Band of Horses is one of my all time favorite bands, Everything all the time and Cease To Begin is masterpieces. But the new album is so far underwhelming, which makes me so sad. There is no melodies and almost every song is acoustic. where is the rock n roll?...

Band of Horses is one of my all time favorite bands, Everything all the time and Cease To Begin is masterpieces. But the new album is so far underwhelming, which makes me so sad. There is no melodies and almost every song is acoustic. where is the rock n roll?...

Really? I've literally been listening to nothing but for the past week or so.

i just got it 2 days ago and can't stop listening either. don't understand the hate... this definitely caught me quicker than Infinite Arms did.

i guess this is just what happens when you release such a critically acclaimed debut... there will always be those fans who feel underwhelmed, and will never be satisfied with any new direction a band goes.