She isn’t (or they aren’t) in their normal state of many years past, though. To quote BGG1 in #718, ‘you think one of us should just cease to exist?’ If anyone has earned a right to exist, it’s GG. God agrees with me, so nyah.

Another character flaw an actual Mary-Sue wouldn’t have; A Mary-Sue would automatically know, and act on, the Right course of action, from the very start, and convince everyone else of the right course of action, and succeed at it instantly.

I’m not really complaining :P it’d be pretty dumb to complain about writing a character with MORE depth than their archetype is supposed to have. I just think it’s funny.

Of course the real question is once recharged (if it can be recharged) will it forcibly merge the two BGG into a single being again, settle on one of them to make into a single GG and leave one BGG, or split again so that we go back to two NGG (Neutral Good Girls)..

I think the “real” good girl is long, long gone, and died the day the exorcism happened.

Both states are, in a sense, a form of her being mind controlled. One by compulsion to do purely good deeds, and one by a compulsion to do purely bad ones(Luckily for them, she has no powers and is motivated by selfishness!).

She has no compulsions to do bad ones. She just does it because she is unable to do it under its influence.
Once she gets it out of her system, she should become an Ordinary Girl, unless someone charges the Halo again.

I have to agree with that. Once the original girl was subjected to having ‘Smiles Painted On Her Soul’ by that exorcism that subjected her to that halo she ceased to exist. She’s lived her life magically forced to do good, when the halo’s drained what’s left is a mind damaged by that compulsion and as a result lashes out trying to counter the good it was forced to do rather than chose to do.

(stepping out of the gutter of what “Pretty please” could get LP)
I’m thinking that there is a time limit on Hexagons splitting GG up, and a charged halo may shorten the time before she remerges.
(Though I’m good with two Meh girls,… they are interesting.)