CD Reviews

Great recording

Sean M. Kelly | Portland, Oregon United States | 04/22/2001

(4 out of 5 stars)

"John Antill, (1904-1986) the Australian born composer, is the main reason to pick up this interesting mid-priced cd from the Everest label. His most well known work, the balled-score for "Corroboree," graces this recording done by the LSO under Sir Eugene Goossens. The piece is based on a dance ceremony done by one of Australia's aboriginal communities, and allows for wonderful interpretations of its primitivism. The LSO does a credible job, coaxing the listener into Antill's web with a colorfully scored reading of his work. As a culrural anthropologist, I can almost see and feel the action around me, with was likely one of Antill's goals. "Dance to the Evening Star" is a wonderful opening movement, enticing the listener to become part of the ceremony; "Rain Dance," complete with a strong sense of rhythm, draws you closer to the action that is to occur; "Procession of the Totems" invokes a sense of mystery and Antill's gradual building up of suspense- like a good novel, the climax is slow in building; "Closing Fire Ceremony" explodes with frantic energy, as any good fire ceremony would- a fitting climax to the piece.The LSO's performance fits the bill nicely, filled with the energy needed to both build and release the suspense created by Antill. The recording quality of the performance is decent, as well, though a tad over-resonant at moments. Still, the overall performance is well worth the mid-range price of the cd.While the performances of Villa-Lobos and Ginestera are both excellent, it is the Antill piece that will likely grab and keep your attention longer. It is a wonderful collection overall and well worth searching out."

Off the waterfront.

Lee Hartsfeld | Central Ohio, United States | 01/28/2002

(5 out of 5 stars)

"Argentina's Alberto Ginastera's music for the 1936 ballet "Panambi" is the main reason to buy this CD, along with Heitor Villa-Lobos' wonderful "The Little Train of the Caipira," kind of the termperamental counterpart to Arthur Honegger's "Pacific 231." Both pieces were recorded circa 1958 and, in this reissue, they reveal near-digital sound quality. These do not, in any way, sound like 44-year-old recordings.Alberto Ginastera's masterful "Panambi," the notes reveal, concerns a South American Indian legend, and the music must have been one of the primary sources for all those "Exotic Voodoo Island Rapture" type of instrumental albums in the 1950s (for which Les Baxter gets most of the blame, though he was hardly alone). And two of movements sound amazingly like Leonard Bernstein's noisy, syncopated, and brassy score for "On the Waterfront," which arrived many years later and which contained none of Ginastera's subtlety, rhythmic or otherwise. Listen to "Invocation of the Powerful Spirits" and, especially, "Lament of the Maidens and Rondo of the Maidens" and try not to think of Bernstein's famous score. While there are no direct borrowings, as near as my ear can tell, the mood and spirit are remarkably similar, though such music makes a great deal more sense in a South American Indian context than that of Marlon Brando on the docks. It's nice, certainly, to be reminded that loud percussion can be artful and MUSICAL, a lesson the makers of car ads could stand to learn sometime.No mass-market "exotica" here. Just fabulous music. Sir Eugene Goossens and the London Symphony Orchestra are superb. Get this one."

Highly colorful and enjoyable compositions in stupendous sou

Discophage | France | 08/06/2007

(5 out of 5 stars)

"Woof! This is the first "Ultra analog" Everest reissue to come my way, and the sound is simply stupendous! Vivid presence, great stereo definition, and despite some moderate tape hiss, it is hard to believe. They simply don't do recordings like that anymore. The recordings of the Antill piece and Ginastera's Panambi-suite were made in 1958 and released as Everest SDBR 3003 (the product information given on the booklet's back cover is not entirely accurate about this), Estancia was made apparently in the same year and published as 3014 with George Antheil's 4th symphony (see my review of the Bay Cities reissue, George Antheil ~ Symphony 4 / Morton Gould ~ Spirituals for Orchestra) and the Villa Lobos got its outing in 1960, paired with these same two Ginastera ballet-suites as 3041.

Primitivism in music is actually very sophisticated. You want it to be very loud, so it requires a complete symphony orchestra (and don't be stingy on drums and brass!). You want syncopations, so that requires using the resources of Broadway jazz rather than of the Western symphonic tradition. You want it to produce eerie, "primeval" sounds, and that requires lots of imagination in the use of your orchestral resources. All these faculties the three composers here represented have to spare.

Villa Lobos' Litle Train of the Caipira is actually the Toccata from his 2nd Bachianas Brasileiras (1933). It is a superb and brief (4:30) symphonic poem, graphically describing what its title designates. The composer got his inspiration from a train ride he took in 1931 on such a "puffing and chugging" country train transporting rural workers (the "Caipira" are the "yokels" or rustics) around Sao Paolo. It uses a wide array of percussion instruments, traditional (bass drum, snare drum, cymbals and the likes) and exotic. It belongs with Honegger's Pacific 231 to the great evocations of machines in music. And it's immensely fun ! One wonders why Walt Disney and Stokowsky passed that one for Fantasia.

I wasn't prepared for Antill's Corroboree. Somehow I had passed that one in the LP era, probably because I already had Everest 3041 with Villa Lobos and the two Ginastera ballets, and purchasing the Antill entailed duplicating Panambi. Having never heard of Antill, I guess I also assumed that he wasn't a very interesting composer, and that Corroboree was not a very interesting piece. Was I wrong! It is an extraordinary piece of musical noise, eerily starting with percussion beats and bassoon ominously playing in its lowest registers (remember the beginning of Ravel's left-hand Concerto?); then comes a jarring whiplash of strings, bass pizzicato and strucked bows, and soon it bursts out into discharges of violence. What it brings to mind (and the name's proximity is sheer coincidence) is George Antheil's famous and infamous Ballet Mécanique, as well as Mossolov's Iron Foundries - two pieces that until then I had thought to be unique in their kind. Funny how nothing sounds more like the musical evocation of machines than the musical evocation of primitive rituals. It is the same musical resources that are put at play: percussive power, obsessive pulse and eerie sonorities. But Antill is also capable of great sonic refinement, as in the "Dance to the Evening Star" and "Rain Dance", where the percussions (and string harmonics as well) are used not for sheer decibels but for their coloristic contribution. John Antill (1904-1986) was an Australian composer, more or less discovered through this very piece by Eugene Goossens when the conductor took over the Sydney Symphony Orchestra in 1946. Corroboree was inspired by an actual Australian aboriginal dance ceremony, and apparently, Antill is remembered only for that piece: there is hardly anything else from him available on the net. I wonder why.

In his two early ballet-suites the Argentinian Alberto Ginastera (1916-1983) hasn't yet found his own personal voice. He later shed his folk inspiration in favor of a modernist, neo-expressionist style of great power and drama, and became one of the most important Latin-American composers of the last fifty years of the last century. I discovered his music years ago through his magnificent Concerto per corde performed by Ormandy on CBS, sadly not reissued on CD (for another example of his later style, see my review of Symphony No.4/Milena). Yet, in the suites from Panambi (his Opus 1, composed in 1937) and Estancia Op. 8 (1941), he shows that he is already a master in the craft of orchestration. Panambi opens with a beautifully atmostpheric impressionism reminiscent of Ibert's Ports of Call, but other than this introductory movement, both Panambi and Estancia alternate between a subdued lyrical atmostphere almost verging on the effusive ("Lament of the Maidens" from Panambi, "Wheat Dance" from Estancia) and a brutal primitivism ("Invocation of the Powerful Spirits" and "Dance of the Warriors" from Panambi, "Land Workers" from Estancia) whose syncopations sound like a strange cross-breeding of Le Sacre and Bernstein's West-Side Story Jets and Sharks Dance. Again, funny how nothing sounds (musically) more like a primitive ritual than an urban street fight. Obviously the primitive never lurks far under the surface of the urban hoodlum.

These are all highly colorful and enjoyable compositions, in stupendous sound."