Andy Cohen Tastes Amber Tamblyn’s Breast Milk on ‘WWHL’

On Watch What Happens Live With Andy Cohen, Andy was in luck. His guest and new mother Amber Tamblyn had just pumped, and she felt like bartending. Tamblyn has been quite outspoken about breast pumping and nursing. When Cohen asked about how her husband, David Cross, had tried her milk, she said, “Wait, do you want to taste it?”

Unexpectedly, Tamblyn had her bag nearby, and in it was a freshly pumped bottle of breast milk. She offered to make Cohen’s beverage into a White Russian, but he declined. Tamblyn got the audience worked into a frenzy chanting, “Chug! Chug! Chug!” and with the combination of live television and audience peer pressure, Cohen decided not to spoil the fun. After he took a sip, he said it was very sweet and good with a tequila chaser.

Though Cohen may not have woken up thinking he’d be enjoying Amber Tamblyn’s breast milk, there’s apparently a first time for everything. He said, “That’s the closest to a breast I’ve ever been.”