On December 8th, the Florida Supreme Court reviewed a case that could have repercussions for victims of medical malpractice who choose to bring malpractice lawsuits here in Florida. The case centers around a 2013 state medical malpractice law that allows what are known as “ex parte communications,” or communications between attorneys and doctors who have treated the patients involved in the lawsuits, but concerning issues that are completely unrelated to the malpractice allegations. Many have argued that the law deters people from bringing medical malpractice lawsuits in general due to privacy and disclosure concerns, as one justice described it, leading to a “chilling effect.”

What’s frightened many—including the Supreme Court justices—about the law is just how private medical information is, and how important maintaining that guarantee of privacy is in order for doctors to be able to properly and effectively treat their patients.

Constitutional Right to Privacy

The Florida Constitution guarantees privacy rights to citizens. Specifically, it declares that every natural person has the right to be let alone and free from intrusion into their private life. In addition, the court, not the state legislature, is the typically the branch authorized to make decisions concerning ex parte communications. In this sense, the Florida state legislature arguably overstepped its boundaries when it passed this law in 2013.

Federal Judge Previously Strikes Part of Law

In 2013—soon after the law was passed—a federal judge threw out that portion of the law that allowed defendant health care providers and their representatives to have these ex parte communications with the plaintiff’s doctors, indicating that it violated the federal Health Insurance Portability and Accountability Act (Act). Specifically, the judge found that the state law’s requirement that the defendant have ex parte access to the plaintiff’s medical providers did not constitute “voluntary permission,” as required under the Act, and that this statute was an attempt to circumvent federal requirements.

The Health Insurance Portability and Accountability Act (HIPAA)

HIPAA not only protects health insurance coverage for workers and their families in the event of losing or changing jobs, but it also requires that national standards be established when it comes to electronic healthcare transactions. Perhaps most importantly, its privacy rule requires covered entities to take all reasonable steps to ensure the confidentiality of communication. For example, hospitals can’t even reveal information over the phone to relatives of admitted patients.

Medical Malpractice & Civil Litigation Attorneys Serving Florida

When you have the victim of medical malpractice—or your civil rights have been violated—the law offices of Lavalle Brown & Ronan can help. Our Boca Raton attorneys have years of experience representing clients in and around Boca Raton with personal injury claims and civil litigation. Contact us today for a free consultation.

"Finding people you can trust is always a necessity when it comes to legal issues, its critical. Lavalle Brown & Ronan have never failed to deliver superb legal representation without fail. I have and would recommend their services to my family members and closest friends always in good conscience."

– James M.

"Law firm was very professional and effective. Nicole and MV always looked out for me. They would call back or email me even on weekends. They never took advantage of taking money, instead were compassionate and understanding my needs and resolved in the most cost effective way. Truly they cared! Love ‘em 2 thumbs up!"

– Anonymous

"Having an experienced law firm, like Lavalle Brown & Ronan on your side is essential in today’s day and age. I continue to rely on their representation for all of my business. I am very happy with my experience and I recommend them to all of my friends & family!"

– Ulysses M.

"We had a very serious situation occur with one of our operating companies. Within 24 hours Ken Ronan and his team were on the case. It was very time sensitive and required quick action. It was also a very complex case that needed strong and decisive action. In less than 10 days the entire issue was resolved."

By submitting this form I acknowledge that contacting Lavalle, Brown & Ronan, P.A., through this website does not create an attorney-client relationship, and any information I send is not protected by attorney-client privilege.