Monster Eye Cookies

These creepy cookies are looking right at ya! I love this Monster Eye Cookie recipe because of its simplicity yet the cookies till melt in your mouth. The combination of butter and cream cheese makes these a super soft cookie that you will want to eat more of, even though the cookie is totally staring at you!

I was lucky enough to find the candy eyeballs at our ALDI store. If you can’t find them in stores, you can order Wilton Candy Eyeballs here.