Forbidding Wrong in Islam An Introduction

Transcription

1 Forbidding Wrong in Islam An Introduction s massive study in Islamic ethics, Commanding Right and Forbidding Wrong in Islamic Thought, was published to much acclaim in It was described by one reviewer as a masterpiece. In that book, the author reflected on the Islamic injunction, incumbent on every Muslim, to forbid wrongdoing. The present book is a short, accessible survey of the same material. Using anecdotes and stories from Islamic sources to illustrate the argument, Cook unravels the complexities of the subject. Moving backwards and forwards through time, he demonstrates how the past informs the present. By the end of the book, the reader will be familiar with a colourful array of characters from Islamic history ranging from the celebrated scholar Ghazzapplelı, to the caliph Happlerün al-rashıd, to the yatullappleh Khumaynı. The book educates and entertains. At its heart, however, is an important message about the Islamic tradition, its values, and the relevance of those values today. is Cleveland E. Dodge Professor of Near Eastern Studies, Department of Near Eastern Studies, Princeton University. His publications include Early Muslim Dogma (1981), The Koran: A Very Short Introduction (2000), and Commanding Right and Forbidding Wrong in Islamic Thought (2001).

2 THEMES IN ISLAMIC HISTORY comprises a range of titles exploring different aspects of Islamic history, society and culture by leading scholars in the field. Books are thematic in approach, offering a comprehensive and accessible overview of the subject. Generally, surveys treat Islamic history from its origins to the demise of the Ottoman empire, although some offer a more developed analysis of a particular period, or project into the present, depending on the subject-matter. All the books are written to interpret and illuminate the past, as gateways to a deeper understanding of Islamic civilization and its peoples. Editorial adviser: Patricia Crone, Institute for Advanced Study, Princeton Already published: Chase F. Robinson, Islamic Historiography hardback paperback Jonathan P. Berkey, The Formation of Islam: Religion and Society in the Near East, hardback paperback

4 PUBLISHED BY THE PRESS SYNDICATE OF THE UNIVERSITY OF CAMBRIDGE The Pitt Building, Trumpington Street, Cambridge, United Kingdom CAMBRIDGE UNIVERSITY PRESS The Edinburgh Building, Cambridge CB2 2RU, UK 40 West 20th Street, New York, NY , USA 477 Williamstown Road, Port Melbourne, VIC 3207, Australia Ruiz de Alarcón 13, Madrid, Spain Dock House, The Waterfront, Cape Town 8001, South Africa This book is in copyright. Subject to statutory exception and to the provisions of relevant collective licensing agreements, no reproduction of any part may take place without the written permission of Cambridge University Press. First published 2003 Printed in China by Everbest Typeface Jaghbub (Adobe) 10/12 pt. System QuarkXPress [PC] A catalogue record for this book is available from the British Library National Library of Australia Cataloguing in Publication data Cook, M. A. (Michael Allan), Forbidding wrong in Islam: an introduction. Bibliography Includes index. ISBN ISBN (pbk.). 1. Islamic ethics. 2. Religious life Shıfiah. 3. Religious life Islam. 4. Islam Doctrines. I. Title ISBN hardback ISBN paperback

6 viii Contents 6 The state as an agent of forbidding wrong 65 1 The claims of the state to forbid wrong 65 2 The scholars on the role of the state: positive views 68 3 The scholars on the role of the state: negative views 70 7 The state as an agent of wrongdoing 73 1 The misdeeds of rulers 73 2 Rebuking rulers as forbidding wrong 74 3 Rebellion as forbidding wrong 79 8 Is anyone against forbidding wrong? 83 1 Does anyone deny the duty outright? 84 2 Has the future already arrived? 86 3 What do the üfıs have to say? 88 4 fiabd al-ghanı al-napplebulusı 91 5 Minding one s own business 93 6 Concluding remarks 95 9 What was forbidding wrong like in practice? 97 1 What wrongs do people commit? 98 2 Who actually forbids wrong? Forbidding the wrongs of rulers Forbidding wrong and rebellion Concluding remarks What has changed for the Sunnıs in modern times? Religious allegiances in the modern Islamic world The interaction with the West: attraction and repulsion Living with the modern state: activism and quietism Towards forbidding wrong in an Islamic state Religious policing in Saudi Arabia Forbidding wrong and privacy What has changed for the Imapplemıs in modern times? Comparing Imapplemıs and Sunnıs The interaction with the West: attraction and repulsion Living with the modern state: from quietism to activism Towards forbidding wrong in an Islamic state Forbidding wrong and privacy Concluding remarks 144

7 Contents ix 12 Do non-islamic cultures have similar values? What are we looking for? Pre-Islamic Arabia Rabbinic Judaism Medieval Catholicism Non-monotheist parallels? Forbidding wrong and monotheism The distinctiveness of the Islamic case Do we have a similar value? Common ground Rescue and forbidding wrong Right and wrong Concluding remarks 170 Index 173

8 Preface In May 2000 the British police were searching the home of a suspected member of al-qapplefiida in Manchester, and chanced on a terrorist manual written in Arabic. After the events of 11 September 2001, extracts from this manual were made available in an English translation. These extracts included instructions to be followed by undercover members of the organisation in order not to blow their cover; such a member should avoid manifesting his religiosity through his appearance or conduct. One point underlined in this connection was, in the wording of the translation, that he should not get involved in advocating good and denouncing evil in order not to attract attention to himself. In the same way, a brother travelling on a special mission should not get involved in religious issues (advocating good and denouncing evil). 1 The duty which the terrorist manual thereby set aside is a central, and in some ways distinctive, feature of Islamic ethics. As the celebrated Sunnı scholar Ghazzapplelı (d. 1111) put it, every Muslim has the duty of first setting himself to rights, and then, successively, his household, his neighbours, his quarter, his town, the surrounding countryside, the wilderness with its Beduin, Kurds, or whatever, and so on to the uttermost ends of the earth. 2 Of these demanding activities, all bar the first fall under the rubric of commanding right and forbidding wrong (al-amr bi l-mafirüf wa l-nahy fian al-munkar) roughly speaking, the duty of one Muslim to intervene when another is acting wrongly. This book is an epitome of a research monograph I recently published on this duty under the title Commanding right and forbidding wrong in Islamic thought (Cambridge 2001). Note on footnotes: Unless otherwise indicated, all references are to my monograph Commanding right and forbidding wrong in Islamic thought, Cambridge Apart from cross-references and a few references to new sources, the purpose of these notes is to help any reader who wishes to do so to locate the relevant passage or passages in the monograph. 1 The New York Times, 28 October 2001, B8. The passages are taken from pages 54 (item 11) and 40 (item 6) of the manual respectively xi

9 xii Preface The original monograph was a detailed presentation of the results of some fifteen years of research. Its seven hundred pages were weighed down with several thousand footnotes and over fifty pages of bibliography. Moreover, the large-scale organisation of the material was according to the various sects and schools that make up the Muslim community, not by topic. In short, the monograph was written primarily for specialists. The text (as opposed to the footnotes) was not in principle inaccessible to non-specialists, but it would have taken considerable courage and persistence for anyone other than a specialist to read it from cover to cover. The present epitome is designed specifically for the non-specialist. As can be seen from the table of contents, the material has been drastically rearranged to make the organisation thematic; only the last four chapters replicate the organisation of the monograph. No one who has read the monograph need read this epitome. Except in a small number of cases readily identifiable from the notes, there is no new material here. I have often rearranged the data, and occasionally this leads to new and perhaps better ways of looking at things. But there is nothing here that would count as a novel theory. At the same time, no non-specialist who reads this epitome has any need to go to the monograph. Everything that really matters about the subject is covered here. Perhaps the only exception would be someone with an interest in one particular sect or school; for such a purpose, the organisation of the monograph is more helpful. 3 This epitome is subject to all the numerous debts set out in the Acknowledgements and footnotes of the monograph. Some further information used here was kindly given to me by Sµkrµ Hanioÿlu, Barbara von Schlegell, Matti Steinberg and Nenad Filipović. I have benefited considerably from the comments of Patricia Crone and Bob Moore on the typescript, and I regret that at the time I was working on this epitome, few reviews of the monograph had yet appeared. Finally, I would like to thank Janet Klein for preparing the index. 3 I have written an even more succinct account of forbidding wrong that is to appear as the entry al- Nahy fian al-munkar in the Supplement to the second edition of the Encyclopaedia of Islam. There is also an informative article by W. Madelung in the Encyclopaedia Iranica (London 1982, art. Amr be mafirüf ).

10 This map shows the location of places mentioned in the text, and contains information related to more than one period.

ANCIENT ROME A MILITARY AND POLITICAL HISTORY - CHRISTOPHER S. MACKAY University of Alberta PUBLISHED BY THE PRESS SYNDICATE OF THE UNIVERSITY OF CAMBRIDGE The Pitt Building, Trumpington Street, Cambridge,

THE DIVINITY OF JESUS CHRIST THE DIVINITY OF JESUS CHRIST A study in the history of Christian doctrine since Kant Hulsean Lectures, igj6 by JOHN MARTIN CREED, D.D. Ely Professor of Divinity in the University

REAL ETHICS John Rist surveys the history of ethics from Plato to the present and offers a vigorous defence of an ethical theory based on a revised version of Platonic realism. In a wide-ranging discussion

Early Muslim Polemic against Christianity Abu Isa al-warraq s Against the The Muslim thinker Abu Isa al-warraq lived in ninth-century Baghdad. He is remembered for his extensive knowledge of non-muslim

WARGAMES Where did wargames come from? Who participated in them, and why? How is their development related to changes in real-life warfare? Which aspects of war did they capture, which ones did they leave

THE KING JAMES BIBLE The King James Bible (KJB) was the result of an extraordinary effort over nearly a century to take many good English translations and turn them into what the translators called one

saudi arabia in transition Insights on Social, Political, Economic Making sense of Saudi Arabia is today crucially important. The kingdom s western provinces contain the heart of Islam, its two holiest

AN INTRODUCTION TO THE PHILOSOPHY OF MIND E. J. LOWE University of Durham PUBLISHED BY THE PRESS SYNDICATE OF THE UNIVERSITY OF CAMBRIDGE The Pitt Building, Trumpington Street, Cambridge, United Kingdom

PLATO AND THE DIVIDED SELF Plato s account of the tripartite soul is a memorable feature of dialogues like the Republic, Phaedrus, andtimaeus:it is one of his most famous and influential yet least understood

POLLUTION AND RELIGION IN ANCIENT ROME Pollution could come from any number of sources in the Roman world. Bodily functions, sexual activity, bloodshed, death any of these could cause disaster if brought

THE SPIRIT OF HINDU LAW Law is too often perceived solely as state-based rules and institutions that provide a rational alternative to religious rites and ancestral customs. The Spirit of Hindu Law uses

HUMAN EVOLUTION AND CHRISTIAN ETHICS Can the origins of morality be explained entirely in evolutionary terms? If so, what are the implications for Christian moral theology and ethics? Is the latter redundant,

THE RIGHTS OF WOMEN IN ISLAM Also by Haifaa A. Jawad EURO-ARAB RELATIONS: A Study in Collective Diplomacy THE MIDDLE EAST IN THE NEW WORLD ORDER (editor) The Rights of Women in Islam An Authentic Approach

KARL MARX AND RELIGION Also by Trevor Ling The Significance of Satan (SPCK) Buddhism and the Mythology of Evil (Allen and Unwin) Buddha, Marx and God (Macmillan) Prophetic Religion (Macmillan) A History

University of Delaware From the SelectedWorks of Muqtedar Khan December, 2014 What is Islamic Democracy? The Three Cs of Islamic Governance Muqtedar Khan, University of Delaware Available at: https://works.bepress.com/muqtedar_khan/36/

Islamic Religion What is Islam? Second largest religion in the world 1.2 Billion Muslims (20% of earth population) Began in modern day Saudi Arabia Based on beliefs on Jews & Christians Abraham is first

The French Enlightenment and the Emergence of Modern Cynicism analyzes cynicism from a political-theoretical perspective, arguing that cynicism is not unique to our time. Instead, she posits that cynicism

The Languages of the Jews Historical sociolinguistics is a comparatively new area of research, investigating difficult questions about language varieties and choices in speech and writing. Jewish historical

American Society of Missiology Series, No. 50 Christian Mission among the Peoples of Asia Jonathan Y. Tan ORBIS BOOKS Maryknoll, New York 10545 ORBIS BOOKS Maryknoll, New York 10545 Founded in 1970, Orbis

Understanding Islamic Law A Justice Sector Training, Research and Coordination Training Course Convened by the Rule of Law Collaborative at the University of South Carolina September 20-21, 2017 PROGRAM

Introduction i Warfare and Politics in Medieval Germany, ca. 1000 The De diversitate temporum, written in the early eleventh century by Alpert of Metz, is one of the indispensable contemporary accounts

Greg Sinclair November 20, 2013 Love the Lord your God with all your heart and with all your soul and with all your mind. Love your neighbor as yourself Make disciples of all nations Majority Religions

CREATION AND THE GOD OF ABRAHAM Creatio ex nihilo is a foundational doctrine in the Abrahamic faiths. It states that God created the world freely out of nothing from no pre-existent matter, space or time.

Muslims And Crusaders: Christianity's Wars In The Middle East, 1095-1382, From The Islamic Sources (Seminar Studies) By Niall Christie If searching for a book Muslims and Crusaders: Christianity's Wars

Friendship with Non-Muslims According to the Qur an Afroz Ali The al-ghazzali Centre Awareness Papers Friendship with Non-Muslims According to the Qur an Afroz Ali al- Ghazzali Centre For Islamic Sciences

Medieval Times in the Modern Middle East July 5, 2017 As nations fail, nationalism becomes obsolete. Originally produced on June 26, 2017 for Mauldin Economics, LLC By George Friedman and Kamran Bokhari

D. B.I.L.T.: Beliefs 1. What people believe influence what they do, say, wear, eat, etc. Does this have to be associated with an organized religion? What would be an example of your beliefs influencing

Unit 8: Islamic Civilization Standard(s) of Learning: WHI.8 The student will demonstrate knowledge of the Islamic civilization from about 600 to 1000 AD by a) Describing the origin, beliefs, traditions,

Islamic World Standard: Trace the origins and expansion of the Islamic World between 600 CE and 1300 CE. Essential Question: What were the origins and expansion of the Islamic World? Islam Element: Explain

Syria: A Recent History By John McHugo If looking for the ebook by John McHugo Syria: A Recent History in pdf form, then you have come on to the correct website. We presented the full version of this book

Judaism, Islam, & Christianity Standards SS6G11 The student will describe the cultural characteristics of Europe. b. Describe the major religions in Europe; include Judaism, Christianity, and Islam. Teachers

Reading and Writing Scripture in New Religious Movements Palgrave Studies in New Religions and Alternative Spiritualities Series editors: James R. Lewis and Henrik Bogdan Palgrave Studies in New Religions

A Critical Study of Hans Küng s Ecclesiology Other works by Corneliu C. Simuţ Richard Hooker and His Early Doctrine of Justification. A Study of His Discourse of Justification (2005). The Doctrine of Salvation

Islam SLMS/09 Islam is the third of the three major monotheistic religions. It is descended from both Judaism and Christianity. People who practice the religion of Islam are known as Muslims, not Islams.

Spinoza and German Idealism There can be little doubt that without Spinoza, German Idealism would have been just as impossible as it would have been without Kant. Yet the precise nature of Spinoza s influence

THE REDISCOVERY OF JEWISH CHRISTIANITY FROM TOLAND TO BAUR Edited by F. Stanley Jones Society of Biblical Literature Atlanta THE REDISCOVERY OF JEWISH CHRISTIANITY From Toland to Baur Copyright 2012 by

NOBILITY AND KINGSHIP IN MEDIEVAL ENGLAND Nobility and Kingship in Medieval England is a major new account of the relationship between Edward I and his earls, and of the role of the English nobility in

A History of the Application of Islamic Law in Nigeria Yushau Sodiq A History of the Application of Islamic Law in Nigeria Yushau Sodiq Texas Christian University Fort Worth, Texas, USA ISBN 978-3-319-50599-2

As I Enter Think about: Holy Quotes! You decide- is it from the bible, the Torah, or the Quran? Agenda: Notes on Islam Notes on Judaism Jerusalem Timeline Quotations from Holy Books Determine whether the

RELIGION AND POLITICS UNDER THE EARLY 'ABBASIDS ISLAMIC HISTORY AND CIVILIZATION STUDIES AND TEXTS RELIGION AND POLITICS UNDER THE EARLY 'ABBASIDS 7he Emergence qf the Proto-Sunni Elite EDITED BY ULRICH

The Bible In Translation: Ancient And English Versions By Bruce M. Metzger The Bible in Translation: Ancient and English Versions - Amazon.com - [PDF]Book review of The Bible in translation: ancient and

Muslim and Christian Understanding Theory and Application of A Common Word Muslim and Christian Understanding Theory and Application of A Common Word Edited by Waleed El-Ansary and David K. Linnan MUSLIM

Muhammad & The Rise of Islam Overview of Islam Around 600 AD, a new monotheistic religion began called Islam: The faith was founded by the prophet Muhammad His followers, called Muslims, spread Islam throughout

PPT Accompaniment for the Lesson Immigration During the 19 th & 20 th Century To view the lesson, visit https://k12database.unc.edu/files/2017/11/immigration-during-the- 19th-20th-Century_Harris.pdf To

Name: Date: Block: Comparing Christianity, Judaism, and Islam Standard: SSWH5 The student will trace the origins and expansion of the Islamic World between 600 CE to 1300 CE. f. Analyze the relationship

FREE SAMPLE TABLE OF CONTENTS 3. Introduction to the Standard Lesson Study Bible 4. What You ll Find in the Standard Lesson Study Bible 5. For Teachers & Students 6. Features of the Standard Lesson Study

Fishing for Jonah (anew) Various approaches to Biblical interpretation Edited by Louis Jonker & Douglas Lawrie Study Guides in Religion and Theology 7 Publications of the University of the Western Cape

UNITIES AND DIVERSITIES IN CHINESE RELIGION Also by Robert P. Weller POWER AND PROTEST IN THE COUNTRYSIDE: Studies of Rural Unrest in Asia, Europe, and Latin America (edited with Scott Guggenheim) Unities

Introduction The religion of Islam, revealed to Muhammad in 610, has shaped the cultural, religious, ethical, and scientific heritage of many nations. Some contemporary historians argue that there is substantial

4 The beliefs and practices of Islam are a way of life for Muslims. CHAPTER The Teachings of Islam 9.1 Introduction In Chapter 8, you learned about the prophet Muhammad and the early spread of Islam. Now

Page 1 Arab lands role play Understanding Arab hopes for an Arab nation You could use this activity with pages 4 5 of the booklet What caused 9/11? The role play does not involve any students needing to

MORALITY AND SOVEREIGNTY IN THE PHILOSOPHY OF HOBBES Also by George Shelton DEAN TUCKER: Eighteenth-Century Economic and Political Thought Morality and Sovereignty in the Philosophy of Hobbes GEORGE SHELTON

The Global Religious Landscape A Report on the Size and Distribution of the World s Major Religious Groups as of 2010 ANALYSIS December 18, 2012 Executive Summary Navigate this page: Geographic Distribution

[ 6.5 ] History of Arabia and Iraq [ 6.5 ] History of Arabia and Iraq Learning Objectives Describe the civilizations of ancient Mesopotamia. Explain the origins and beliefs of Islam, including the significance

Holy Bible: King James Version By Unknown If searching for a ebook by Unknown Holy Bible: King James Version in pdf format, in that case you come on to correct website. We present the complete option of

Current Issues in Islami Banking and Finance Resilience and Stability in the Present System This page intentionally left blank Current Issues in Islami Banking and Finance Resilience and Stability in the

An Introduction to Islam by Sayyid Muhammad Rizvi In the name of Allãh, the Kind, Merciful. All Praise is due to Allãh, the Lord of the Universe. May God shower His blessings upon Prophet Muhammad & his

History and Causality Also by Mark Hewitson EUROPE IN CRISIS: Intellectuals and the European Idea, 1917 1957 (eds, with Matthew D Auria, 2012) NATIONALISM IN GERMANY, 1848 1866: Revolutionary Nation (Palgrave

Presented at Khazanah Megatrends Forum (KMF) 2013, Kuala Lumpur on September 30, 2013, by Prof. M. Kamal Hassan ISTAC, IIUM The philosophic approach that I am presenting is based on a particular worldview

Alexis de Tocqueville and the New Science of Politics An Interpretation of Democracy in America Second Edition John C. Koritansky Carolina Academic Press Durham, North Carolina Copyright 2010 John C. Koritansky

Islamic terror: Our Creed and Methodology April 13, 2005 [Please note: Images may have been removed from this document. Page numbers have been added.] Al-Zarqawi's Group 'Creed and Methodology' Reiterates

The Oxford History Of Islam By John L. Esposito If searching for a book by John L. Esposito The Oxford History of Islam in pdf form, then you've come to loyal site. We presented full version of this book