The site’s interactive map presents more than 375 case studies from around the world that address issues of food diversity, its threats and potential solutions.

But some experts say that, while on the right track, the site is biased towards smallholder innovations and against those from big industry.

Seedmap.org is a collaboration between USC Canada, an international development organisation focused on improving food security in the developing world, and ETC Group, a technology watchdog with interests in ecological diversity.

The site highlights threats to biodiversity such as climate change and the corporate control of seeds, and proposes solutions focusing on the conservation of local seed varieties.

“There’s been increasing pressure on farmers to switch from their local seeds to either hybrid seeds in the Green Revolution and now to genetically modified seeds,” Genevieve Grossenbacher, a programme manager with USC Canada tells SciDev.Net.

“Although in some contexts there are benefits, in the long-term those seeds are often not well adapted to the local climate, and we’ve seen a drop in biodiversity. Having a diverse base of local and well-adapted seeds is a great and transparent policy against disaster, and is something we need to invest more energy into.”

The team behind the website says that small-scale farmers are coming up with innovative ways to protect seed diversity.

Seedmap.org case studies include, for example, on-farm conservation and community seed banks in Ethiopia for saving durum wheat varieties from extinction, participatory rice breeding in the Philippines and developing hurricane-resistant corn and bean varieties in Honduras.

Faris Ahmed, who is in charge of policy and campaigning at USC Canada, explains that the website addresses an information gap by focusing on farmer knowledge systems, which industrial agriculture often does not value.

“The map is full of techniques developed by farmers that are cheap, easily shared and very suited to particular ecosystems because they originate from there,” he tells SciDev.Net. “If we could take the amount of investment in new technologies, and put it into supporting existing technology and farmer knowledge, then I think we would go much further.”

But Kent Bradford, director of the Seed Biotechnology Center at the University of California, Davis, United States, describes the site as “essentially propaganda” and “a very one-sided representation of the challenges of feeding the world”.

He says: “Nobody disagrees with the importance of supporting seed banks and maintaining diversity. But, in this case, it distorts the situation with respect to crop improvement, biodiversity and the impacts of using low-productivity varieties.”

He says the support for seed banks and biodiversity should not require farmers to continue growing low yielding seeds.

“If we want small farmers to operate crop ‘museums’ and living seed banks, let’s subsidize them to do it, rather than expect them to do it just because we need them as a source of diversity,” he says.

The Seedmap.org team at USC Canada says the aim is for the site to be a collaborative platform. It accepts contributions for the news and map sections and is especially keen to hear from scientists.

Paul Jepson, director of the Integrated Plant Protection Center, Oregon State University, United States, says: “The concept behind the seed biodiversity map is an interesting one — it should allow assessments of threats and opportunities to be made at multiple scales, and it should facilitate connections to be made between projects.”

But he shares some of Bradford’s concerns, saying the site is “marred by a campaigning style which renders many of the links unhelpful and uninformative”.

“We should be encouraging a culture of innovation that respects all forms of agriculture and methods of plant breeding, and I would welcome a more open, inclusive and complete approach to mapping that helps us to recognise where progress is being made so that we can all support this and help it to grow.”

Related news

NDVI and Your Farm: Understanding NDVI for Plant Health
Understanding your crops’ health status isn’t the easiest thing to do. Sure, you can use the “eye test”, and a number of foliar contact and direct measurement techniques. But, what if there was an easy, fast and efficient way to see the health of plants and their status and progress over time? That’s where Normalized Difference Vegetation Index (NDVI) data comes in.
NDVI is often discussed without much explanation. Even at...

In an effort to enhance the functionality, ease-of-use and overall value of John Deere Operations Center to producers, John Deere announces a new software release for its cloud-based platform. These user-focused changes include more tools and features that enable producers to easily collect and access more farm information and collaborate with partners to gain insights, increase profits and direct their plans with more precision in the field.
The latest software release for Operations Center, along with new...

We have a superb finance deal on this machine.
Assuming you have a trade in of £50,000 this demo combine can be purchased for 1+3 annuals at £27,500 + VAT.Simply contact us now for more details and this can be delivered to your farm in just days! Embodying DEUTZ-FAHR`s many years of experience in harvesting and its ongoing commitment to developing new technologies, processes and machinery, the C9206TSB is an exceptional machine. It combines outstanding productivity with extraordinary versatility (for...

Fields used by growers contain a treasure trove of data. These data are registered and recorded for use by various (trade) partners, but rarely used actively by growers themselves. This was the idea behind the launch of Farm Maps on 12 February: to establish an independent and open platform on which companies can share data and applications that allow growers to obtain added value from their data and the innovations provided by knowledge institutes and supply companies.
Farm Maps is an initiative of Wageningen...

The EIP-AGRI Focus Group on `Mainstreaming Precision Farming` brought together 19 experts, including scientists, farmers, advisers, and agribusiness to address current opportunities, limitations and transferable innovative solutions on the topic of Precision Farming. In particular, the Focus Group addressed the main question of how to organise data capture and processing to mainstream the application of Precision Farming for input and yield optimisation, while trying to identify the main reasons behind the...

Customer comments

No comments were found for Global map of seeds, food and biodiversity launched. Be the first to comment!