John B. Monk: Has critic ever met Bishop Tobin?

Leon Andrews's comments on Bishop Thomas Tobin ("Calling on Bishop Tobin," letter, Aug. 17) make it obvious that he is a Chris Matthews-style Democrat -- one who would shout down all who disagree with him and characterize those who hold opposing view

Comment

Posted Aug. 19, 2013 @ 3:51 pm

Leon Andrews's comments on Bishop Thomas Tobin ("Calling on Bishop Tobin," letter, Aug. 17) make it obvious that he is a Chris Matthews-style Democrat -- one who would shout down all who disagree with him and characterize those who hold opposing views and beliefs as ignorant, or worse.

Andrews, upset with Bishop Tobin's position on gay marriage, goes on to question Bishop Tobin's sincerity, professionalism, and ministerial priorities.

Has Mr. Andrews ever met Bishop Tobin? Attended one of his Masses? Heard one of his sermons? Read one of his books? Is he aware of Catholic Charities, Keep the Heat On, or Emmanuel House?

I wonder if he has any personal knowledge of the man or if If he is just casting aspersions on the quality of Bishop Tobin's ministry and his character based their different beliefs?

As far as the bishop changing his political affiliation, I am disappointed in him, too. I am disappointed that it took him so long to jump ship. His decision, like my own, was based on the Democratic Party's pro-abortion platform.

Serious, practicing Catholics should not have a problem with his decision -- even in a blue state like Rhode Island.