Wednesday, March 23, 2016

I know people are thinking about Purim, but I am posting my Toronto Torah article this week, in case anyone is looking for a thought for Shabbos...

As lottery winners demonstrate when they choose lump sum payouts
over perpetual annuities, human beings prefer immediate payment of a smaller
sum over long-term payment of a larger sum. Economists explain this behaviour
via the principle of “time value of money”: since money can earn interest,
money is worth more to us when we receive it sooner. The longer we need to
wait, the less the money is worth to us.

Applying “time value of money” to mitzvot, one might argue that
“Energetic people perform mitzvot at the earliest opportunity.” (Pesachim 4a)
If mitzvot lead to additional mitzvot (Avot 4:2), then we should perform
mitzvot as soon as possible, the better to trigger our next mitzvah more
immediately. However, Rabbi Naftali Zvi Yehudah Berlin(a.k.a.Netziv)
noted an opposite example in our parshah. Regarding the burning of thekorban olah(burnt offering), taking more time is
more highly valued. Akorban
olahthat burns perpetually,
throughout the night, is more desirable to G-d than akorban olahburned immediately.

Vayikra 6:2 instructs the kohanim, “This is the law of thekorban olah, which ascends on
the fire on the altar all night, until morning.” As the Talmud (Megilah 21a)
explains, onemayburn the day’s korbanot at any time
during the night. However, Rabbi Berlin wrote, “The instruction to the kohanim
is that theysee to itthat the flesh of thekorban olahshould be placed [on the altar] and
consumed,little by little,
until the morning. It should not be consumed immediately, lest the altar be
empty of the offering.” (Ha’amek Davarto
Vayikra 6:2) Rabbi Berlin explained that this is why G-d told Moshe that he
must not onlyrelatethese laws to the kohanim, but he mustcommandthem – because this process requires
great care and attention. (Ha’amek Davaribid.) Here we see an inverted sense
of “time value”: this mitzvah is of greater value now, because its completion
will take longer.

Why do we value this extended time? And why is this emphasis on
perpetuity unique to the stage of burning, and not to earlier processes? At
this stage, the gift has been given, the vow fulfilled, and any necessary
atonement has been achieved. The sponsors of the korban have gone home, the
instruments of the Levites are silent, and almost all of the kohanim have
removed their splendid uniforms and nodded off to sleep. Even if we are
concerned that a fire should remain on the altar, plenty of wood is present;
why do we care about how long thekorban
olahburns?

Perhaps the value of spending time is actually a result of the
fact that the essential service has concluded. At this stage, it is only the
barefoot kohen in a darkened Temple, standing in lonely worship of his Creator,
with a warm bed waiting somewhere else. G-d beckons to this kohen: stay with Me.

A similar concept is found with the mitzvah oflinah, in which people who
bring certain korbanot remain in Jerusalem overnight, after the ritual is
complete. (Chagigah 17a-b) In another example, Shemini Atzeret is seen as one
last day on which G-d asks us to remain, after the seven days of Succot are
complete. (Rashi to Vayikra 23:36)

This perspective is consistent with Rambam’s relationship-based
explanation of korbanot.Rambam
was troubled by Yirmiyahu’s prophetic declaration (7:22-23), “For on the day I
removed your fathers from Egypt, I did not speak to them and I did not command
them regarding burnt offerings and celebration sacrifices. Only this did I
instruct them, saying: Hear My voice and I will be your G-d, and you will be My
nation.” Yirmiyahu seems to say that Hashem does not desire korbanot - but the
Torah itself testifies to the contrary! Rambam (Moreh Nevuchim 3:32) explained
that Yirmiyahu was teaching the importance of the relationship that
accompanies, and validates, a korban. “The primary object is that you should
know Me and serve no other, and I will be your G-d and you will be My nation.”
As the kohen remains in the Beit haMikdash, long after the ceremonies are over,
that relationship is deepened.

We are currently without korbanot, but the opportunity to
experience perpetuity remains. Sitting in a synagogue to recite Tehillim
privately after davening is over; singing at a Shabbat table after the meal;
holding the hand of a needy person after giving tzedakah; we can be that kohen,
lingering in the dark, positioning thekorban
olahon the altar. To us,
too, Moshe commands: Give this great care and attention, all night, until
morning.