James Gordon is the Police Commissioner of Gotham City. Over time, he became a close ally of Batman. While both out at sea on a fishing trip, Gordon and Batman didn't notice Silkie drift pass their boat. They were later hanging out in a squad car in Jump City when Starfire, Raven, and Jinx drove past with police in hot pursuit. Gordon and Batman fell in love with Wacka Doodles Amusement Park's bumper cars ride. Because the wait time was so long, they became the Two Headed Ghoul to scare guests away at night. They had the bumper cars all to themselves. The Teen Titans eventually captured them and uncovered their scheme. Batman and Gordon hung out in the Batcave and watched the Teen Titans on the former's HD TV. They later held a slumber party again. Once Alfred Pennyworth left, they continued to party and watch the Titans on TV, throwing food at each other, and getting into a pillow fight. The Joker and Penguin joined the party later into the night. They played a shaving cream prank on Gordon. He pretended to be Two-Face but Pennyworth caught them at 11:15 pm. He called Mrs. Gordon to take him home. He snuck off to police headquarters and turned on the Batsignal. Batman arrived and they continued with the party. It started to rain but Penguin and Joker arrived with a giant umbrella and coffee.

Gordon attended the first annual Teen Titan Awards. He also competed in a Halloween costume contest with Batman as Gilligan and the Skipper from "Gilligan's Island". They won second place. For Batman's surprise birthday party, Gordon hid in a present. Batman's spirits finally rose when Gordon was revealed and they hugged. Gordon gave him a golden TV remote then Superman presented Batman with a gigantic TV with many screens.