Deffo NOT 9"! MUFC bedwetter. Grass. Folically-challenged, God-piece-wearing, monkey-rubber. Jizz aroma expert. Operating at the lower end of the distribution curve...has the hots for Alan. Bastard. Fearless in transfer windows with lack of convicti

"Liverpool are magic, Everton are tragic.""It was like playing in a foreign country." Ian Rush on his time with Juventus in Italy"Don't worry Alan. At least you'll be able to play close to a great team!" Bill Shankly to A

Hoever didn't quite look ready to me. Sure he did well for a 17-year old but I dont think he can really be considered a proper option just yet. His development is coming along nicely and if he can just kick on a bit more than maybe in a season or a couple of seasons he'd be there.

Saw a headline on SSN that says Saints, Brighton and Newcastle interested in £25m rated Harry Wilson.Really hope we keep this lad, looks a real talent, we can't just sell our best young players, even for good money.

Saw a headline on SSN that says Saints, Brighton and Newcastle interested in £25m rated Harry Wilson.Really hope we keep this lad, looks a real talent, we can't just sell our best young players, even for good money.

It’s great when academy players come through and make it, and Harry is a cracking talent, but realistically you have to back the manager on these decisions. Look where we’re at, and how many of the young players we’ve sold in the last 5 years would we now be clamouring to get back because they’d make the match day squad? Probably none.

Logged

If you can’t understand it without an explanation, you can’t understand it with an explanation.

It’s great when academy players come through and make it, and Harry is a cracking talent, but realistically you have to back the manager on these decisions. Look where we’re at, and how many of the young players we’ve sold in the last 5 years would we now be clamouring to get back because they’d make the match day squad? Probably none.

Only one I can think of that would be worth it would be Gulacsi and he not good enough to start over Alisson. He also at the age where u want to start as a Goalie.

Think.at this point he's better off not signing and making a permanent move somewhere to try and kick start his career

Possibly but at the same time Football is not always full of stability. Any manner of things can go wrong and knowing you have a five year contract to fall back on at a club like ours is a huge incentive.

If he does well he will have clubs after and if not we are always there plus being at Liverpool will always attract attention of other clubs.

It’s great when academy players come through and make it, and Harry is a cracking talent, but realistically you have to back the manager on these decisions. Look where we’re at, and how many of the young players we’ve sold in the last 5 years would we now be clamouring to get back because they’d make the match day squad? Probably none.

I do trust the manager, however whilst you can argue how much game time he will get I do feel Wilson is a cut above the likes of Brad Smith and Ibe.He has an eye for goal, and is very good at set pieces, anyway I hope we keep him.

Saw a headline on SSN that says Saints, Brighton and Newcastle interested in £25m rated Harry Wilson.Really hope we keep this lad, looks a real talent, we can't just sell our best young players, even for good money.

Klopp rates Harry and Harry said Klopp is always on the phone to him.

A lot of senior players will miss most of the pre season and Harry plus others will have a major part in this years pre season.

I doubt we would sell such talent at this early stage. I can see him on our bench next season or loaned out to a PL club.

Possibly but at the same time Football is not always full of stability. Any manner of things can go wrong and knowing you have a five year contract to fall back on at a club like ours is a huge incentive.

If he does well he will have clubs after and if not we are always there plus being at Liverpool will always attract attention of other clubs.

True, but the loan market makes it harder to get that chance to shine. A slow start and that's you pretty much done as the club look to their other loans or players they can actually profit off.

He signed a long term deal last summer so surprised we're already looking to extend it after an unsuccessful loan.

It’s great when academy players come through and make it, and Harry is a cracking talent, but realistically you have to back the manager on these decisions. Look where we’re at, and how many of the young players we’ve sold in the last 5 years would we now be clamouring to get back because they’d make the match day squad? Probably none.

Conor Coady has probably kicked on more than what most expected.

Logged

And all the world is football shaped, It's just for me to kick in space. And I can see, hear, smell, touch, taste.

After the article in the NYT, I feel as if any decision made by the club on players is grounded on valid inferential stats that accurately predict future success. Whoever is let go and signed, I am cool with it for now.

It’s great when academy players come through and make it, and Harry is a cracking talent, but realistically you have to back the manager on these decisions. Look where we’re at, and how many of the young players we’ve sold in the last 5 years would we now be clamouring to get back because they’d make the match day squad? Probably none.

Suso and Coady might make our squad now.

We don't need to spend loads in the summer and I think it would be also pointless selling top talent that want to be at the club.

Think.at this point he's better off not signing and making a permanent move somewhere to try and kick start his career

Have to agree with that. He isn't getting a sniff here for the foreseeable not in midfield or as a forward at least. The only way I can see him working here is if he converts to full-back. He has the physical qualities, but does he have the tactical nous?

Have to agree with that. He isn't getting a sniff here for the foreseeable not in midfield or as a forward at least. The only way I can see him working here is if he converts to full-back. He has the physical qualities, but does he have the tactical nous?

Makes total sense to sign the lad up and then hope he does enough on loan to bring in some money.

If he does amazingly well elsewhere and starts living up to the hint of potential he was showing a few years ago, then maybe there's even a route back for him. After all, we thought Origi's Liverpool career was dead and buried.

If he does quite well elsewhere, then we can sell him for a profit on what we sold him for.

If he bombs to shit, then we haven't really lost anything as long as the contract we've given him isn't too silly. He can just keep going out on loan until a permanent move materialises, or his deal runs out, whichever happens soonest.