Perrie wore the skirt to lunch in London last week, pairing it with a fuzzy black sweater, ankle-strap heels and round sunglasses. Then this weekend, Ariana shared an Instagram photo of herself in the $76 piece. She went more preppy with the bottom by punctuating it with a collared white top.

Both girls look super-cute in the skirt, but who do you think wore it better: Ariana or Perrie? Vote below and sound off in the comments.