Me and another team are joining into an already established keeper league and we get the first 4 picks between the 2 of us. (don't know the order yet). But the top players I know that will be available (from the vacated teams) are Kucherov, Erik Karlsson, Vasilevsky, Malkin.

If I get the first pick, who should I take first overall? My ranking of order I should take these 4 players is this:
Karlsson
Kucherov
Vasilevski
Malkin