If this is your first visit, be sure to
check out the FAQ by clicking the
link above. You may have to register
before you can post: click the register link above to proceed. To start viewing messages,
select the forum that you want to visit from the selection below.

Re: The Changing Landscape of Baseball and (maybe) a new Roster Approach

Originally Posted by kaldaniels

I can't wait to see Billy in a real MLB game. Cause until then, I won't be convinced he can just magically make his way to third base. I really hope he can do so, of course.

And I swear I'm not knocking you at all, it's just that we won't know for sure how his speed will play until he is actually in the bigs.

I am 100% in agreement with this.....BH very well might be the fastest man ever to step foot on a diamond.....but Ricky Henderson once said that 90% of his steals were based off the fact that the pitcher and catcher were defeated before he even lead off the base.....he stated that the pitcher was always thinking about him and the catcher never took his eyes off him, Ricky was trying to prove that when all the emphasis is put on you as the base burgular then small mistakes made by the pitcher and catcher will favor you that much more than if you were standing there leading off as just a regular base runner......

anyone that has ever heard Ricky speak understands that nothing he says is understood very well but when he started speaking about stealing bases being a lead off hitter, he almost spoke in a different tongue, you could actually understand him......

Billy Hamilton might get out there and do the exact opposite that Ricky did....he might get thrown out on his first attempt and therefore start making those little small mistakes that lead to him getting thrown out.....sometimes just being fast does not get you a stolen base.....it all comes down to how his speed translates to the 90 feet between each base....its gonna be fun to watch because if it all works out we could be watching something that has not been seen before, not even with Ricky.

Re: The Changing Landscape of Baseball and (maybe) a new Roster Approach

Originally Posted by kaldaniels

I don't know which way it will tip the scales, but it should also be considered that Hanny will be walked/pitched around often with a man on 2nd.

Which is why Hamilton should not hit that low in the order. If we agree that the best part of Hamilton's game is the stolen base then you have to put him in a lineup position where he can steal 80-100 bases and #7 isn't it. I want him hitting #1 or #2 and not only stealing bases but distracting the pitcher while pitching to dangerous hitters. Now if Hamilton has an OBP of less than .300, we'll have to re-evaluate

Re: The Changing Landscape of Baseball and (maybe) a new Roster Approach

Hamilton at leadoff. Let's assume the .350+ OBP.

His value at the top of the order goes beyond who is batting behind him. Yes Votto can drive him home from first, but Say Hamilton walks to leadoff the game.

Instantly, the pitcher is in the stretch, and while some baserunners warrant fastballs being thrown, a pitcher cannot risk a slider away or a curve with him on. one curve and Hamilton is on 2B.

Now Hamilton is making a nuisance of himself at 2B with nobody out. Pitcher is still in the stretch because he knows Hamilton can and will steal 3B, a steady stream of FB's to BP results in a 2 run HR. to start the game.

This is what the Reds lacked last year, the quick start. They were the team that came back, scored late and held on with superior pitching.

But with Hamilton, and to a somewhat lesser extent Choo, the Reds now have OBP at the top of the order plus a SB threat.

Likes:

Re: The Changing Landscape of Baseball and (maybe) a new Roster Approach

Originally Posted by Sea Ray

Which is why Hamilton should not hit that low in the order. If we agree that the best part of Hamilton's game is the stolen base then you have to put him in a lineup position where he can steal 80-100 bases and #7 isn't it. I want him hitting #1 or #2 and not only stealing bases but distracting the pitcher while pitching to dangerous hitters. Now if Hamilton has an OBP of less than .300, we'll have to re-evaluate

Wait, why can't he steal 80-100 bases batting seventh?

Originally Posted by jojo

and buckeye fans only a week and a half away from another embarrassing loss they'll be forever unable to reconcile though one would think they should be well used to the modern buckeye brand.

Re: The Changing Landscape of Baseball and (maybe) a new Roster Approach

Originally Posted by Plus Plus

Furthermore, the landscape of MLB has changed to the point where league leaders in SB are around the 50 steal mark, whereas in 1979 Moreno's 97 steals put him second in MLB. ~100 steals is more valuable in 2013 simply by scarcity principles alone.

Are the stolen bases really more valuable today? They would be in a fantasy league but in reality it wouldn't seem to actually create any more runs than it would have in 1978.

Re: The Changing Landscape of Baseball and (maybe) a new Roster Approach

Originally Posted by Steve4192

Hopefully, because there are too many 'base cloggers' in front of him.

That and it's not worth the risk at that spot in the lineup. I doubt they'd let him attempt that many stolen bases down there. Has anyone ever stolen that many from the #7 hole? Not one that I can recall

Re: The Changing Landscape of Baseball and (maybe) a new Roster Approach

Originally Posted by Sea Ray

That and it's not worth the risk at that spot in the lineup. I doubt they'd let him attempt that many stolen bases down there. Has anyone ever stolen that many from the #7 hole? Not one that I can recall

What do you mean not worth the risk? That's when a stolen base is most valuable!

Originally Posted by jojo

and buckeye fans only a week and a half away from another embarrassing loss they'll be forever unable to reconcile though one would think they should be well used to the modern buckeye brand.

Re: The Changing Landscape of Baseball and (maybe) a new Roster Approach

When you get to the 8th spot in your lineup all you care about is flipping the lineup to get to the top.....if there is 1 out and BH is on first then you'd hate to have him get thrown out stealing and make the 2nd out then Hannigan make the 3rd out then your pitcher leads off the next inning....you can use the same theory but different scenario if there were 2 outs......bottom line is, at least IMO, is that managers don't allow guys that low in the lineup to openly steal bases for fear of not flipping the lineup over....Its just a theory

Re: The Changing Landscape of Baseball and (maybe) a new Roster Approach

Originally Posted by klw

Are the stolen bases really more valuable today? They would be in a fantasy league but in reality it wouldn't seem to actually create any more runs than it would have in 1978.

I meant that simply in that a guy who steals 100 bases per year would be more scarce and therefore more valuable in that aspect in today's landscape where 50 steals puts you near or atop the leaderboard. Steals are still a valuable asset for a player's offensive repertoire, and appear to be increasing in value.

Re: The Changing Landscape of Baseball and (maybe) a new Roster Approach

This is what the Reds lacked last year, the quick start. They were the team that came back, scored late and held on with superior pitching.

Right and wrong. Their first inning was actually their most productive inning. They really fell off in inning number two and then muddled through innings three, four, five and six. They did finish strongly. In innings 7-9 they scored 222 runs while allowing only 159.

Board Moderators may, at their discretion and judgment, delete and/or edit any messages that violate any of the following guidelines: 1. Explicit references to alleged illegal or unlawful acts. 2. Graphic sexual descriptions. 3. Racial or ethnic slurs. 4. Use of edgy language (including masked profanity). 5. Direct personal attacks, flames, fights, trolling, baiting, name-calling, general nuisance, excessive player criticism or anything along those lines. 6. Posting spam. 7. Each person may have only one user account. It is fine to be critical here - that's what this board is for. But let's not beat a subject or a player to death, please.

Thank you, and most
importantly, enjoy yourselves!

RedsZone.com is a privately owned website and is not affiliated with the Cincinnati Reds or Major League Baseball