Vergara started dating Loeb on and off in 2010, but the two called it quits for good in May. Two months later, it was being reported that the actress was seeing Manganiello. On Christmas Day, the actor reportedly popped the question and put a sizable ring on Vergara's finger. The couple's reps have yet to confirm the news.

Loeb's sweet sentiments about his ex are a bit nicer than when he attempted to explain why it didn't work out with the Columbian actress. "I'm sort of a conservative, so I like a girl to dress a little classier," he said of Vergara's cleavage-baring looks during an interview with The New York Post this past September.