Research-Teaching Linkages:

Fostering Student Engagement Through
Research-Teaching Linkages
Ray Land, University of Strathclyde, Glasgow
University of York Annual Learning and Teaching Conference 25thth May 2011
graduates for the 21st century
3 questions
• What are likely to be defining characteristics of
“21st century society” in the next two decades?
• What (higher order) attributes will our graduates
need to thrive (or at least survive) in the 21st
century world we have envisaged?
• What kind of learning environments or teaching
approach are most appropriate to foster the
kinds of graduate attributes we identify?
‘A radically
unknowable world’
'our ignorance expands in
all kinds of directions' (p.250)
Need for creative 'knowing-insitu' and imagination. Mode 3
knowledge where all our
knowledge - of the world, of our
situations, of ourselves is contested.
Pedagogy must be founded on
openness, mutual disclosure,
personal risk and disturbance'
(p.258).
(Barnett 2004: 247-260)
Question 1
• What would we envisage as likely to be defining
characteristics of 21st century society in the next
two decades?
•
•
•
•
•
•
•
•
•
•
•
•
•
•
Uncertainty
Speed and acceleration
Complexity
Multiculturalism
Mobility of the population
Conflict (social, military)
Inter-generational tension
Need for ethical citizenship
Information saturation
Proliferation of knowledge
Globalisation
Internationalisation
Private /public sector tension
Increasing panic
Characteristics of
the 21st century
•
•
•
•
•
•
•
•
•
•
•
•
•
•
Unpredictability
Risk
Need for flexibility and agility
Entitlement v responsibility
Scarcity of resources
Austerity
Sustainability
Need for prudence
Transparency & accountability
Discontinuity and rupture
Shifting paradigms
Poverty v affluence
Outsourcing of jobs
Youthfulness
Supercomplexity
Unlike complexity, ‘interactions
between the elements are
unclear, uncertain and
unpredictable’ (p.249) This is
symptomatic of professional life
with its competing demands,
overload and stress. Challenges
are never resolved because ‘it
produces a multiplication of
incompatible differences of
interpretation’ (Barnett 2004 p.249)
Intellectual uncertainty
‘Intellectual uncertainty is not
necessarily or simply a negative
experience, a dead-end sense of not
knowing, or of indeterminacy. It is just as
well an experience of something open,
generative, exhilarating, (the trembling
of what remains undecidable). I wish to
suggest that ‘intellectual uncertainty’ is
..a crucial dimension of any teaching
worthy of the name.’
(Royle 2003 : 52)
Venturing into
strange places
The student is perforce
required to venture into
new places, strange
places, anxiety-provoking
places . This is part of the
point of higher education.
If there was no anxiety, it
is difficult to believe that
we could be in the
presence of a higher
education.
(Barnett 2007: 147)
Pedagogies of uncertainty
it's ... insufficient to claim that a combination of
theory, practice, and ethics defines a professional's
work; it is also characterized by conditions of
inherent and unavoidable uncertainty.
(Shulman 2005:1)
Uncertainty in the classroom
... learning to deal with uncertainty in the
classroom models one of the most crucial
aspects of professionalism, namely, the
ability to make judgments under
uncertainty.
Lee Shulman, Signature pedagogies in the professions, 2005 p.57
Atmospheres of risk
... uncertainty, visibility, and accountability
inevitably raise the emotional stakes of the
pedagogical encounters.
Uncertainty produces both excitement and
anxiety. These pedagogies create atmospheres of
risk taking and foreboding, as well as occasions for
exhilaration and excitement.
Lee Shulman, Signature pedagogies in the professions, 2005 p.57
Pedagogies of uncertainty
I would say that without a certain amount of
anxiety and risk, there's a limit to how much learning
occurs. One must have something at stake. No
emotional investment, no intellectual or formational
yield.
(Shulman Pedagogies of Uncertainty, 2005:1)
Speed
Virilio 2000, Eriksen 2001
supercomplexity
death of geography
issues of democratic space
advent of universal real time
tyranny of the moment
slow and fast time
‘presentified’ history
single gaze of the cyclops
process
fragmentation
exploration
visual
volatility
fast time
consensus
openness
artefact
cohesion
exposition
textual
stability
slow time
authority
containment
What forms of ‘technoliteracy’ do
we need to work in these
spaces?
How can assessment regimes be
re-crafted for these volatile
spaces?
What digital pedagogies work in
these environments?
How do these texts and
technologies change the way
academic knowledge is produced
and distributed?
Plutarch’s fire
‘the mind is not a vessel to
be filled, but a fire to be
lit’.
(Plutarch c46 -127AD).
Plutarch’s Fire
‘Never has the educational philosophy behind
this belief been more important: the changing
world to be faced by today’s students will
demand unprecedented skills of intellectual
flexibility, analysis and enquiry.
Teaching students to be enquiring or researchbased in their approach is not just a throwback
to quaint notions of enlightenment or liberal
education but central to the hard-nosed skills
required of the future graduate workforce.’
(Hammond 2007:1)
Troublesome knowledge
Perkins 1999
Characteristics of a
threshold concept
•
•
•
•
•
•
•
integrative
transformative
irreversible
bounded
re-constitutive
discursive
troublesome
Meyer & Land 2003
Liminality
• a transformative state that
engages existing certainties
and renders them
problematic, and fluid
• a suspended state in which
understanding can
approximate to a kind of
mimicry or lack of authenticity
• liminality as unsettling –
sense of loss
East of Eden
through the threshold
Troublesome knowledge
• ritual knowledge
• inert knowledge
• conceptually difficult
knowledge
• the defended learner
• alien knowledge
• tacit knowledge
• loaded knowledge
• troublesome language
Question 2
• What are the higher order attributes that our
graduates will need to thrive (or at least survive)
in the 21st century world we have envisaged?
Higher order graduate attributes
• critical understanding
• disciplinary currency
• provisionality (knowledge,
situations)
• contingency (knowledge,
situations)
• problem formulation
• problem analysis and
resolution
• evaluation
• evidence-based solutions
• argumentation
• deriving meaning from
complexity
• modes of enquiry
•
•
•
•
•
•
informed judgement
advanced techniques
independence
learner responsibility
creativity
critical values
– ethical
– social
– cultural
– environmental
• wider professional conduct
– contextual ‘savviness’
– political astuteness
And at Master’s level
• constructing conceptual frameworks
• critical evaluation of current research and advanced
scholarship
• originality in the application of knowledge
• reconciling complex issues
• forming sound judgments
• coping with incomplete data
CIHE international /
intercultural GAs
Knowledge
• world geography, conditions, issues and events
• complexity and interdependence of world events &
issues
• understanding of historical forces that have shaped
the current world system
• knowledge of a foreign language, intercultural
communication concepts, international business
etiquette
CIHE international / intercultural GAs
Attitudes
• openness to learning & positive orientation to
new opportunities, ideas and ways of thinking.
• tolerance for ambiguity and unfamiliarity.
• sensitivity & respect for cultural differences.
• empathy or the ability to take multiple
perspectives.
• self-awareness and self esteem about one’s own
identity & culture.
CIHE international / intercultural GAs
Skills
•
•
•
•
research skills to learn about the world
critical and comparative thinking skills
ability to think creatively and integrate knowledge
ability to use another language effectively and
interact with people from other cultures
• coping and resiliency skills in unfamiliar and
challenging situations
Question 3
• What kind of learning environments or teaching
approaches might be most appropriate to foster
the kinds of graduate attributes that have been
identified?
Research could be a strong
condition that is aimed at
bringing about supercomplexity
in the minds of students.
(Barnett 1992 p.623)
Linking research and teaching
“We are all researchers now … Teaching and research
are becoming ever more intimately related … In a
‘knowledge society’ all students – certainly all graduates –
have to be researchers. Not only are they engaged in the
production of knowledge; they must also be educated to
cope with the risks and uncertainties generated by the
advance of science”
(Scott 2002, 13)
Supercomplexity (Barnett)
Risk (Beck)
Uncertainty (Shulman),
Speed (Virilio)
What is distinctive about ‘higher’ learning?
“It is furthermore a peculiarity of
the universities that they treat
higher learning always in terms
of not yet completely solved
problems, remaining at all times
in a research mode …
Schools, in contrast, treat only
closed and settled bodies of
knowledge. The relationship
between teacher and learner is
therefore completely different in
higher learning from what it is in
schools. ..”
Wilhelm von Humboldt 1810
What is distinctive about ‘higher’ learning?
“…At the higher level, the
teacher is not there for the sake
of the student, both have their
justification in the service of
scholarship.”
Wilhelm von Humboldt 1810
Idealistic (Humboldtian) approach. (Simons & Elen 2007)
• Research a kind of general education.
• Academic enquiry, morality (edification) and
citizenship are linked.
• University different from schools (social needs) as
well as from research institutions (govt needs,
commercial interests)
• Education at the university solely guided by academic
enquiry (one submits to the tribunal of reason, the
spirit of truth, the force of the better argument.)
• Not influenced by pedagogic expertise or didactics, or
managerial or moral or economic imperatives.
• State and society cannot ask for immediate returns.
successful graduate
responsible citizen
effective employee
potential research-teaching linkages
• Learning about the research of others
• Learning in research mode – enquiry based
• Learning to do research – research methods
• Pedagogic research – enquiring and reflecting
about learning
Curriculum design and the research-teaching nexus
STUDENT-FOCUSED
STUDENTS AS PARTICIPANTS
EMPHASIS ON
RESEARCH
CONTENT
Research-tutored
Research-based
Curriculum emphasises
learning focused on
students writing and
discussing papers or
essays
Curriculum emphasises
students undertaking
inquiry-based learning or
low key research
Research-led
Research-oriented
Curriculum is structured
around teaching subject
content
Curriculum emphasises
teaching processes of
knowledge construction
in the subject
EMPHASIS ON
RESEARCH
PROCESSES
AND
PROBLEMS
TEACHER-FOCUSED
STUDENTS AS AUDIENCE
(Healey 2005)
Curriculum design and the research-teaching nexus
STUDENT-FOCUSED
STUDENTS AS PARTICIPANTS
EMPHASIS ON
RESEARCH
CONTENT
Research-tutored
Research-based
Curriculum emphasises
learning focused on
students writing and
discussing papers or
essays
Curriculum emphasises
students undertaking
inquiry-based learning or
low key research
Research-led
Research-oriented
Curriculum is structured
around teaching subject
content
Curriculum emphasises
teaching processes of
knowledge construction
in the subject
EMPHASIS ON
RESEARCH
PROCESSES
AND
PROBLEMS
TEACHER-FOCUSED
STUDENTS AS AUDIENCE
(Healey 2005)
Curriculum design and the research-teaching nexus
STUDENT-FOCUSED
STUDENTS AS PARTICIPANTS
EMPHASIS ON
RESEARCH
CONTENT
Research-tutored
Research-based
Curriculum emphasises
learning focused on
students writing and
discussing papers or
essays
Curriculum emphasises
students undertaking
inquiry-based learning or
low key research
Research-led
Research-oriented
Curriculum is structured
around teaching subject
content
Curriculum emphasises
teaching processes of
knowledge construction
in the subject
EMPHASIS ON
RESEARCH
PROCESSES
AND
PROBLEMS
TEACHER-FOCUSED
STUDENTS AS AUDIENCE
(Healey 2005)
High Impact Activities
 First-Year Seminars and Experiences
 Common Intellectual Experiences
 Learning Communities
 Writing-Intensive Courses
 Collaborative Assignments and Projects
 “Science as Science Is Done”;
Undergraduate Research
 Diversity/Global Learning
 Service Learning, Community-Based
Learning
 Internships
 Capstone Courses and Projects
George Kuh (2008)
Illustrations of practice
• Induction week Materials Science – ‘a product in
ten years time’
• 2nd yr Literary Studies – ‘Toni Morrison’s Jazz’
• 1st yr Mech Eng – ‘dissection of a car’
• 1st yr Basic Psychology – ‘online peer groups’
• 2nd yr Chemistry ‘forensic investigation of a
(fictitious) death’
• ‘Exhibitions’ as a research-teaching linkage in a
School of Art
‘Beyond Understanding’
 Possessive Knowledge
 Performative Knowledge
 Proactive Knowledge
David Perkins – ‘Beyond Understanding’ in Land. Meyer & Smith Eds) (2008)
Threshold Concepts within the Disciplines
From demand culture to opportunity culture
 From very other-directed to significantly self-directed
 From extrinsic motivation to intrinsic motivation
 From cool to hot cognition
 From prototypical examples to include diverse and
marginal examples and close counterexamples
 From ‘learning about’ to ‘learning to do’
• From learning the pieces to ‘whole game
learning’
• From ‘designing to specifications’ to ‘designing
the specifications’
• From problem solving to problem finding,
problem defining
• From learning here and there to learning here,
there and elsewhere
David Perkins – ‘Beyond Understanding’ (2008) pp 14-15.
Academics for the 21st Century?
Thank you
[email protected]
Project information at:
http://www.enhancementthemes.ac.uk/themes/
ResearchTeaching/outcomes.asp