Making the Connection: Trauma and Substance Abuse

Transcription

1 Making the Connection: Trauma and Substance Abuse When Mary was 11, her mother left this man, Dave to babysit. Dave gave her a joint. It made me happy. It made me feel like nothing could touch me and everything was OK. So I started stealing my mum s drugs. Of course, she was caught and locked in a closet. I was in there for almost two days. After that happened, I guess a part of me changed. I didn t care for anybody. I hated the world after that. 1 Data from the most recent National Survey of Adolescents and other studies indicate that one in four children and adolescents in the United States experiences at least one potentially traumatic event before the age of 16 2, and more than 13% of 17-year-olds one in eight have experienced posttraumatic stress disorder (PTSD) at some point in their lives. 3 Most, if not all, of these young people also have access to a wide range of psychoactive substances that can both dull the effects of stress and place teens at increased risk of experiencing trauma. It is estimated that 29% of adolescents nearly one in three have experimented with illegal drugs by the time they complete 8th grade, and 41% have consumed alcohol. 4 For many adolescents, such early experimentation eventually progresses to abuse of or dependence on illicit drugs or alcohol. Every year, approximately one in five American adolescents between the ages of 12 and 17 engages in abusive/dependent or problematic use of illicit drugs or alcohol. 5,6 Although it is unclear exactly how many adolescents who abuse drugs or alcohol also have experienced trauma, numerous studies have documented a correlation between trauma exposure and substance abuse in adolescents: n In the National Survey of Adolescents, teens who had experienced physical or sexual abuse/assault were three times more likely to report past or current substance abuse than those without a history of trauma 3 n In surveys of adolescents receiving treatment for substance abuse, more than 70% of patients had a history of trauma exposure 7,8 This correlation is particularly strong for adolescents with PTSD. Studies indicate that up to 59% of young people with PTSD subsequently develop substance abuse problems The National Child Traumatic Stress Network

2 Traumatic Stress and Substance Use: A Complex Relationship Multiple pathways have been proposed to explain the temporal link between trauma and substance abuse in adolescents. 12 A review of these theories demonstrates that the road connecting these disorders runs both ways: trauma increases the risk of developing substance abuse, and substance abuse increases the likelihood that adolescents will experience trauma. Trauma as a risk factor for substance abuse According to the self-medication hypothesis of substance abuse, people develop substance abuse problems in an attempt to manage distress associated with the effects of trauma exposure and traumatic stress symptoms. This theory suggests that youth turn to alcohol and other drugs to manage the intense flood of emotions and traumatic reminders associated with traumatic stress or PTSD, or to numb themselves from the experience of any intense emotion, whether positive or negative. Several studies have found that substance use developed following trauma exposure (25% 76%) or the onset of PTSD (14% 59%) in a high proportion of teens with substance abuse disorders Recent research in this area also suggests that traumatic stress or PTSD may make it more difficult for adolescents to stop using, as exposure to reminders of the traumatic event have been shown to increase drug cravings in people with cooccurring trauma and substance abuse. 13,14 (For more information on trauma reminders, see Understanding Traumatic Stress in Adolescents: A Primer for Substance Abuse Professionals.) Substance abuse as a risk factor for trauma Numerous epidemiological studies have found that, for many adolescents (45% 66%), substance use disorders precede the onset of trauma exposure Studies have shown a direct link between alcohol use and engagement in risky behaviors in which adolescents may get hurt 10, such as hitchhiking, walking in unsafe neighborhoods, and driving after using alcohol or drugs. 15 According to the most recent National Survey on Drug Use and Health, more than 25% of underage drinkers are binge or heavy drinkers, and approximately 20% one in five report driving while under the influence during the past year. 5 Not surprisingly, adolescents with substance abuse disorders are also significantly more likely than their nonsubstance abusing peers to experience traumas that result from risky behaviors, including harm to themselves or witnessing harm to others There is also evidence that youth who are already abusing substances may be less able to cope with a traumatic event as a result of the functional impairments associated with problematic use. In one study, investigators found that even after controlling for exposure to trauma, adolescents with substance abuse disorders were two times more likely to develop PTSD following trauma than were their non-abusing peers. The researchers suggested that the extensive psychosocial impairments found in adolescents with substance abuse 2 Understanding the Links Between Adolescent Trauma and Substance Abuse June 2008

3 disorders occurred in part because they lacked the skills necessary to cope with trauma exposure. 10 Regardless of the pathway describing the onset of trauma exposure or PTSD and the development of substance abuse problems, youth with this co-occurrence experience difficulties with emotional and behavioral regulation that make it all the more difficult for them to stop using. A successful treatment approach must therefore be flexible enough to accommodate the multiple ways in which trauma and substance abuse may be related. Addressing the Needs of Adolescents with Co-occurring Trauma and Substance Abuse For adolescents dealing with the effects of traumatic stress or PTSD, alcohol and/ or drugs initially may seem to alleviate distress, either through the increased pleasurable sensations or through the avoidance of intense emotions that may follow stressful experiences. In the long run, however, substance use perpetuates a cycle of problem behaviors that can make it more difficult to recover after a traumatic event. For teenagers struggling with substance abuse and traumatic stress, the negative effects and consequences of one disorder compound the problems of the other. Raphael s* Story Raphael was a 15-year-old boy with a history of truancy and drug involvement (marijuana use and drug dealing). He had been placed in a group home after Child Protective Services became involved with the family and his mother and stepfather asserted that they couldn t control Raphael. In the group home, Raphael was angry, threatening, and unwilling to cooperate with group activities. He was disruptive during group therapy sessions and initially refused to say much during individual treatment sessions. Through patience, openness, and a willingness to explore Raphael s interests including his flair for developing spontaneous rhymes and rap-style lyrics Raphael s therapist was gradually able to engage Raphael in the treatment process. Over time, Raphael opened up about his difficult relationship with his mother, being frequently hit and locked in a dark closet by his stepfather, and his conflicted relationship with his younger sister. He also talked about his frequent, almost daily, use of marijuana and alcohol and how they made him feel better and on top of things. It became clear that, for Raphael, alcohol and marijuana served as tools that enabled him to numb overwhelming feelings and to feel dominant in uncomfortable or threatening social situations. As Raphael and his therapist began to address his trauma and substance abuse histories, Raphael started to develop better tools for coping with the intense feelings and impulses that contributed to his most pressing problems. * Raphael is a composite representation based on real teenage clients struggling with traumatic stress and substance abuse. Although such teenagers need help, often desperately, they frequently have difficulty entering or staying involved in treatment services. Usually teenagers attend such facilities against their will because they are either mandated to attend treatment (i.e., by the courts), referred by teachers, or brought in by their parents. The National Child Traumatic Stress Network

4 Because the service systems targeting substance abuse and mental health problems have traditionally been fragmented, few teenagers with both traumatic stress and substance abuse problems receive integrated treatment services. Compounding the problem is that there are few facilities offering integrated services, primarily because few professional training programs in substance abuse or mental health provide clinicians with the education necessary to develop expertise in both trauma and substance abuse treatment, and few professionals have training and experience across both fields. Given the strong link between trauma and substance abuse among adolescents, however, the majority of both substance abuse and mental health professionals have encountered this population. Providing adequate and effective care to adolescents who are grappling with substance abuse and trauma will require adjustments on the part of both groups. For mental health providers, it is critical to become familiar with the patterns of addiction associated with substances of abuse, and to recognize that similar patterns are at work in traumatic stress and addiction. Both are characterized by emotional and behavioral dysregulation, and are expressed in a range of symptoms and behaviors that can include classic posttraumatic stress symptoms, substance abuse, and other risky behaviors. For substance abuse professionals, it is important to look beyond the immediate circumstances of the youth s substance use and pay attention to his or her trauma history and its relationship to his or her current emotional difficulties and coping patterns (including substance use). There are many commonalities between the ways in which youth respond to substance abuse triggers and the ways in which they respond to reminders of loss and trauma. Compiling a list of triggers that may lead to emotional dysregulation and substance use, and incorporating possible reminders of previous trauma and loss can be helpful. Overcoming Common Challenges to Care Clinicians, administrators, and other healthcare providers in the substance abuse and mental health fields often face major challenges in providing care to youth with traumatic stress and substance abuse problems. For example, the fragmentation that has traditionally existed between mental health and substance abuse systems often limits the types of services that youth are eligible to receive. Additionally, service centers may lack the resources or support necessary to provide comprehensive services. Although it may not be possible to find solutions to many of these challenges, below are some solutions to common treatment problems. 4 Understanding the Links Between Adolescent Trauma and Substance Abuse June 2008

5 CHALLENGE Lack of institutional awareness and prioritization of adolescent trauma and substance use assessment and treatment Clinician lack of familiarity with the common presentations of posttraumatic stress symptoms in adolescents Time and costs associated with conducting standardized assessments and training staff to use evidence-based interventions Adolescents with severe co-occurring disorders often require assistance with other practical aspects of life such as transportation, schooling, court advocacy, health insurance that not all institutions are equipped to provide Difficulty engaging adolescents with trauma and substance abuse histories who often employ avoidant coping mechanisms in treatment Lack of local substance abuse and trauma training resources SUGGESTED SOLUTION The materials in this toolkit can serve as resources to aid in raising institutional awareness of the need for sound substance abuse and trauma assessment and treatment. Presenting case material that highlights the relationships between trauma and substance abuse can also help raise institutional awareness Use the materials in this toolkit to help become familiar with the common presentations of posttraumatic stress symptoms in adolescents. Access more information via the National Child Traumatic Stress Network website: To convince institutional administrators to invest the time and money required for the initial stages of such program development, present them with research on improved treatment adherence and treatment outcomes when standardized assessments and evidence-based interventions are employed. Once the program has been established and youth outcomes are improved, working with youth will be more rewarding, which may encourage administrators to seek additional funding opportunities Partnerships with local agencies can often go a long way towards meeting the practical needs of clients when they cannot be met by a single organization Use the tips in this toolkit to help engage adolescents in treatment. For clinicians struggling to engage difficult clients: access institutional support, including additional supervision Search the Internet for substance abuse and trauma training resources. To reduce the cost of face-toface training sessions, agencies can send a single representative to be trained, who can subsequently train his/her colleagues Conclusion Adequate care begins with the recognition and accurate identification of the problems these adolescents experience, whether they present to a mental health professional or to a substance abuse specialist. Rather than referring a multi-problem teenager to another provider, clinicians willing to address co-occurring disorders can develop the skills necessary to provide such adolescents with hope of recovery. The National Child Traumatic Stress Network 5

6 Therapists and counselors can develop skills to provide a comprehensive and integrated treatment approach. In order to maximize an adolescent s chances of success, this approach should broadly address the adolescent s concerns and take into account the functional relationship between traumatic stress and substance abuse problems. When developing an individualized treatment plan, special attention should be given to the signs and symptoms of posttraumatic stress, substance abuse, and the relationship between the two. This toolkit has been developed to assist mental health and substance abuse professionals in providing comprehensive assessment and treatment to adolescents suffering from traumatic stress and substance abuse. It explores the complex connections between traumatic stress and substance abuse and provides guidelines for identifying, engaging, and treating adolescents suffering from these co-occurring problems. Trauma and Substance Abuse: Myths and Facts MYTH: Since most adolescents who use drugs and/or alcohol have experienced some kind of trauma, there is no need to treat trauma as a unique clinical entity. FACT: Although not all youth who experience traumatic events develop PTSD, it is important to be prepared to address the multiple ways youth respond to trauma. Traumatic stress and PTSD are associated with unique (and challenging) symptoms that require targeted, trauma-informed treatment to optimize recovery. (For more information, see Understanding Traumatic Stress in Adolescents: A Primer for Substance Abuse Professionals.) Effective treatment approaches and interventions have already been developed for patients suffering from traumatic stress and PTSD. Making use of these techniques as part of a comprehensive treatment plan offers the greatest hope of treatment success for adolescents dealing with the effects of substance abuse and traumatic stress. MYTH: When dealing with an adolescent who has a history of trauma and substance abuse, you need to treat one set of problems at a time. FACT: Because the symptoms associated with traumatic stress and substance abuse are so strongly linked, the ideal treatment approach is to address both conditions. Unfortunately it is not uncommon for substance abuse programs to deny admission to patients with PTSD, and for trauma treatment programs to deny admission to patients who have not achieved sobriety. The decision about which symptoms and behaviors to address first therefore requires a careful assessment of the relative threat that each condition poses to a youth s safety, health, and immediate well-being. 6 Understanding the Links Between Adolescent Trauma and Substance Abuse June 2008

TEEN MARIJUANA USE WORSENS DEPRESSION An Analysis of Recent Data Shows Self-Medicating Could Actually Make Things Worse Millions of American teens* report experiencing weeks of hopelessness and loss of

Written statement of the American Psychological Association Hearing before the United States Senate Committee on the Judiciary Breaking the Cycle: Mental Health and the Justice System February 10, 2016

Alcohol Abuse Among our Nation s Youth What to do as educators The devastating rate of drug and alcohol abuse by American youth is cause for alarm and its prevention and treatment remains one of our nation

4 4 5 5 6 7 8 10 11 12 3 DRUG REHAB FOR TEENAGERS Discovering that a teen is taking drugs or alcohol is worrisome. Parents not only worry about the impact on a child s health, but also the possible impact

Traumatic Stress and Substance Use Problems The relation between substance use and trauma Research demonstrates a strong link between exposure to traumatic events and substance use problems. Many people

How HOLiSTIC REHAB Benefits You Table of Content Holistic Rehab Centers are More Popular than Ever The Need for Drug & Alcohol Rehabilitation Programs Alcohol Abuse and Addiction These Issues Need Treatment

Statistical Snapshot of Underage Drinking Alcohol consumption and dangerous patterns of drinking are widespread among adolescents and lead to many adverse consequences for underage drinkers and others.

Women in Drug Treatment Courts: Sexual Assault as the Underlying Trauma National Judicial Education Program* *A Project of Legal Momentum in cooperation with the National Association of Women Judges Women,

Substance Abuse Treatment Services Struggling with drugs or alcohol? We can help. 303 730 8858 admhn.org Sarah s Story I was born into chaos, says Sarah a recovering addict. Raised by parents who abused

Underage Drinking Underage drinking is a serious public health problem in the United States. Alcohol is the most widely used substance of abuse among America s youth, and drinking by young people poses

Trauma Informed Services Part 1 The Hidden Aspect of Addiction Many individuals struggling with addiction have personal and family histories of trauma including sexual, emotional, and/or physical abuse

Common Drug Rehab Concerns Does drug rehab work? How do I find the right treatment program for my loved one s needs? Does my loved one need to detox prior to entering rehab? Can my loved one leave rehab

National Clearinghouse on Child Abuse and Neglect Information National Adoption Information Clearinghouse Gateways to Information: Protecting Children and Strengthening Families Substance Abuse and Child

Testifying in Court about Trauma: How to Prepare It is critical that therapists willingly go to court to try to impart their knowledge to the judge. The judge will only make a good decision if he or she

Bulletin for professionals December 2003 Substance Abuse and Child Maltreatment Substance abuse has a major impact on the child welfare system. It is estimated that 9 percent of children in this country

Co Occurring Disorders and the on Children: Effectively Working with Families Affected by Substance Abuse and Mental Illness Definition (Co-Occurring also called Dual Dx) A professional diagnosis of addictive/substance

Identifying and Treating Dual-Diagnosed Substance Use and Mental Health Disorders Presented by: Carrie Terrill, LCDC Overview What is Dual Diagnosis? How Common is Dual Diagnosis? What are Substance Use

1 Statistical facts associated with addiction and substance abuse are concerning, but many men and women choose to ignore the dangers. By understanding the main causes of addiction to drugs, it is possible

Taking Care: Child and Youth Mental Health ANXIETY WHAT IS IT? Open Learning Agency 2004 WHAT IS IT? Anxiety is a normal human feeling characterized by worry, nervousness and fear. Not only does anxiety

Co-Occurring Disorders: A Basic Overview What is meant by Co-Occurring Disorders (COD)? Co-Occurring Disorders (COD) refers to two diagnosable problems that are inter-related and occur simultaneously in

Summary Report On Participant Characteristics at Entry Into the Missouri Drug Court Programs Included in the Multi-jurisdictional Enhancement for Evaluation of Drug Courts School of Social Work University

Trauma and the Family: Listening and learning from families impacted by psychological trauma Focus Group Report A summary of reflections and remarks made by Baltimore City families impacted by trauma and

Open Residential Firesetting and Sexual Behavior Treatment Program ABRAXAS Open Residential Firesetting and Sexual Behavior Treatment Program Since 2006, the Abraxas Open Residential Firesetting and Sexual

Spotlight 4 Nine Elements of Effective Alcohol Treatment for Adolescents An Example from Wisconsin David Poehlmann has been counseling people recovering from alcohol addiction for more than two decades.

Post-Traumatic Stress Disorder - PTSD Introduction Post-Traumatic Stress Disorder, or PTSD, is a common disorder in which a person experiences disabling anxiety after a traumatic event. People with PTSD

Substance Abuse and Sexual Violence: The Need for Integration When Treating Survivors Kelli Hood, M.A. Objective To understand the necessity for therapeutic strategies in clients with cooccurring Substance

YOUNG PEOPLE & ALCOHOL Essential Information for Social Workers A BASW Pocket Guide Supported by: Bedford and Luton Purpose of the guide This guide seeks to support Social Workers in their practice with

Adolescent Substance Use: America s #1 Public Health Problem June 29, 2011 A Report by The National Center on Addiction and Substance Abuse at Columbia University 9 in 10 People Who Are Addicted* Begin

Prescription drugs are the 3 rd most commonly abused drugs amongst teens in Nebraska, and the same statistic holds true on a national level. The rise in prescription drug abuse is becoming increasingly

Workforce Development Online Workshop Descriptions Behavioral Health Service Delivery Workshops: The Effects of Violence Exposure on Children (1.5 hours) Regretfully, violence against children and youth

Do you help people recover from trauma? 2015 training programs Do you or your staff help people who have experienced trauma? Phoenix Australia s training programs teach the skills required by a range of

Minnesota Co-occurring Mental Health & Substance Disorders Competencies: This document was developed by the Minnesota Department of Human Services over the course of a series of public input meetings held

SUBSTANCE ABUSE & DEPRESSION: WHAT YOU SHOULD KNOW TABLE OF CONTENTS What is Depression? 4 Symptoms of Depression 6 Substance Abuse as a Coping Mechanism 8 Which Occurs First? 10 Substance Abuse and the

Questions and Answers about Child Sexual Abuse Treatment An Interview with Judith Cohen, MD Dr. Judith Cohen is a member of the and Medical Director of the Center for Traumatic Stress in Children, Department

TRAUMA & ADDICTION written for American Academy of Health Care Providers in the Addictive Disorders by Sandra H. Colen, LCSW, Dip-CFC, CAS December 22, 2014 Purpose The purpose of this paper is to present

YOUNG PEOPLE & ALCOHOL Essential Information for Social Workers A BASW Pocket Guide Supported by: Bedford and Luton C_YoungPeopleAlco.indd 1 19/10/2012 10:29 Purpose of the guide This guide seeks to support

Questions to Ask Treatment Programs Are you looking for a drug and alcohol treatment program for your teen or young adult? This list of questions can help guide your conversation with treatment program

The Role of High School Teachers in Preventing Suicide Understand Why Suicide Prevention Fits with Your Role as a High School Teacher Ms. Gomez, a high school social studies teacher, was concerned about

The Role of High School Mental Health Providers in Preventing Suicide Ellen s English teacher told the school counselor, Ms. Thompson, that several of Ellen s class writing assignments indicated that she

Eating Disorders Eating disorders are serious conditions that can have life threatening effects on youth. A person with an eating disorder tends to have extreme emotions toward food and behaviors surrounding

REVISED SUBSTANCE ABUSE GRANTMAKING STRATEGY The New York Community Trust April 2003 1 I. INTRODUCTION Substance Abuse is defined as the excessive use of addictive substances, especially narcotic drugs,

The Many Facets of Social Work The scope of social work practice is remarkably wide. Social workers practice not only in the traditional social service agency, but also in elementary schools; in the military;

Substance Abuse and Mental Health Services Administration Reauthorization 111 th Congress Introduction The American Psychological Association (APA) is the largest scientific and professional organization

Expanding Services to Children and Families in Family Drug Courts: Lessons Learned from the Children Affected by Methamphetamine Grant Program Acknowledgement Introductions This presentation is supported

information for families Schizophrenia & Substance Use Schizophrenia and Substance Use Index 2 3 5 6 7 8 9 10 Why do people with schizophrenia use drugs and alcohol? What is the impact of using substances

AGENCY OVERVIEW MFT & MSW* Intern-Trainee Program 2015-2016 Training Year Non-profit mental health agency established in 1945 Recipient of the CAMFT School and Agency Award for 2009 Clients from diverse

Substance Abuse, Violence, Mental Health, and Academic Success July 2009 The mission of the American school has expanded considerably over the last thirty years. We expect our schools to teach the traditional

Using Evidence for Public Health Decision Making: Violence Prevention Focused on Children and Youth Community Guide Slide Modules These slides are designed to be used with overview slides also available

I. Introduction Division of Child and Family Services Treatment Plan Goal Status Review Aggregate Report The more efficient and effective the delivery of our services, the greater our opportunity for realizing

TABLE OF CONTENT 3 The Need for Inpatient Rehab 3 Success with Inpatient Treatment 4 Numbers Rarely Lie 4 An Overview of Inpatient Substance Abuse Treatment 7 Participating in the Program 9 Get the Most

1 About drugs Drugs are substances that change a person s physical or mental state. The vast majority of drugs are used to treat medical conditions, both physical and mental. Some, however, are used outside

The truth about alcohol abuse among college students is hard to swallow. George Comiskey, the associate director in the Center for the Study of Addiction and Recovery at Texas Tech, works with students

Development of Chemical Dependency in Adolescents & Young Adults How to recognize the symptoms, the impact on families, and early recovery Tim Portinga, PsyD, LP, Mental Health Clinic Supervisor Tim Portinga

FACT SHEET TRAUMA-INFORMED CARE FOR WORKING WITH HOMELESS VETERANS According to SAMHSA 1, trauma-informed care includes having a basic understanding of how trauma affects the life of individuals seeking

Statistics on Women in the Justice System January, 2014 All material is available though the web site of the Bureau of Justice Statistics (BJS): http://www.bjs.gov/ unless otherwise cited. Note that correctional