http://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/articles/PMC2367227/ gives the actual details. First note that the study had only 10 subjects, was unblinded to the therapist as well as the subject as to the content of the procedures, and thus there was no blinded control group. This is a significant problem when the psychological mechanisms are hard to operationally define much less tie them into a specific effect or efficacy of psychoanalysis.

The article proposes 2 conditions that has theoretical basis but no validation in any double-blind placebo controlled clinical research:

1. transference, defined as an unconscious aspect of social cognition, is an emerging core concept that can be used to unite theoretical and empirical investigations into normal mental functioning, psychopathology, and psychotherapeutic change.

2. a normal person’s perceptions and affective responses vis-à-vis the self and others are heavily influenced by the activation of significant relationship representations from the past.

Even if we are to assume these conditions are true, translating the operational definition of these concepts into brain changes, and then to some effect of psychoanalysis in this uncontrolled study of 10 subjects, is stretching the limits of valid clinical research.

It is extremely difficult to say with much certainty what is the exact cause of any brain changes found, their specificity, nor their connection to efficacy of psychoanalysis for a specific indication, and both the NY Times article and Dr. Tasman are taking any results of this unblinded and uncontrolled study IN ONLY 10 SUBJECTS far too far. Even if the emotions of transference are correlated to a brain change, that still does not translate to efficacy of psychoanalysis for any specific indication.

The NY Times article at least had the term “Preliminary research” under the image, and the research article itself noted the translation limitation, “It is crucial that the paradigm be designed for optimal reliability and clinical relevance at this stage, before it is applied broadly to questions of development, psychopathology, and psychotherapeutic change.”

Dr. Tasman’s statement that “…positive clinical improvement can be correlated with identifiable changes in brain functioning” is not yet near any kind of confirmation by the data in this preliminary and uncontrolled study.

It should be noted that brain changes can be found in various activities. For example, this study,

Nature Neuroscience 12, 1370 – 1371 (2009); 11 October 2009 | doi:10.1038/nn.2412 found and increase in white matter underlying the intraparietal sulcus following training of a complex visuo-motor skill. Note however, this study was unblinded (a training study can not be blinded), and there was no placebo control group.

Mindfulness meditation has also been found to alter regions of the brain associated with memory, awareness of self, and compassion, according to a brain imaging study:

Mindfulness meditation is the practice of paying attention to moment to moment experience without drifting into thoughts about the past or concerns about the future and without analyzing what is going on around you. It is thus very different from psychoanalysis. The subjects in this study were also unblinded (a meditation study can not be blinded), and there was no placebo control group.

Other studies have found brain changes from running, yoga, etc, This is indicative that the brain is a plastic organ responding to stimuli in some fashion, it would be a jump of wishful-thinking logic at this point to conclude that each type of therapy will provide a differential type of efficacy.

The conclusions here should be:

1. Various actions the brain may undertake may make adjustments to the structure and/or function of the brain.

2. Brain changes as a surrogate end-point are not necessarily indicative of a therapeutic effect of a specific psychotherapy; visual-motor training or meditation may also make brain changes (if we assume the unblinded and uncontrolled studies are valid).

3. To conclude that brain changes seen on imaging is strongly suggestive of an efficacy of a psychotherapy is a jump of logic not born out by a large double-blind or blinded-placebo controlled study.

4. These uncontrolled studies, and especially the study noted by the NY times article with only 10 subjects, do not tie-in a specific psychiatric indication of efficacy of a specific psychotherapy in a confirmatory way.

While different psychotherapies may help persons function better in certain ways, our zeal to validate a specific psychotherapy as a proven method for a specific indication because of brain changes is still based on research with poor methods so that conclusions needs to be tempered or else seem to be deceptive to the intended audience.

Comments

Wonderful site and I wanted to post a note to let you know, "Good job"! I’m glad I found this blog. Your blog site has presented me most of the strategies which I like. Thanks for sharing this.
http://www.gta5-wiki.com/cheats

The capital posseses an estimated population of 2.2m within the city limits and 9.9m within the more downtown area. As one of the prime four leader towns in the world along with London, New York and Tokyo, it has become the most popular location in the world, having an projected 30 million international readers every year. Dubbed the Town of Light, it features a popularity to be the most lovely and romantic city on the planet, full of record, and is extremely significant in the realms of culture...

In That the area of gym center, the greens would be your supervisor. 1 green element to both help keep you healthy and strong would be your barley grass juice. Bearing in your mind 'well being is success', barley grass juice would be your best place to become absorbed. Today you may be wondering if barley bud is like wheat bud.
Very Well, It's correct that wheat grass and wheat marijuana both seem alike and possess a few similarities. However you can find a number of variances. The distinction ...

Osaka, JP – MANGA.TOKYO is pleased to announce the launch of Otsukai, a new service that allows members of the site to get hold of anime, manga, and video games merchandise that can be found only in Japan.
The Japanese word ‘otsukai’ means ‘errand’ and MANGA.TOKYO has created the service with that definition in mind. Otsukai doesn’t have a warehouse or a standard product list. Instead, it has created a platform that allows fans from all around the world and f...

Osaka, JP – MANGA.TOKYO, the online anime and otaku portal operated by DONIKA Co, Ltd (location: Osaka, Japan), has released its first light novel, Shikigami Girl.
The novel is written by a group of Japanese anime and manga creators who have been involved in many famous works and who have come together under the name Honda-Na, especially for this project. They have created a dream-like story for fans of anime and manga all around the world. Each chapter contains homages to beloved anime a...

FILE - In this file photo dated Monday nike air vapormax grises , Dec. 4, 1989, a Trident II missile launched by the U.S. Navy during a performance evaluation from the submerged submarine USS Tennessee in the Atlantic Ocean off the coast of Cape Canaveral in Titusville nike air vapormax negras baratas , Fla., USA. According to Britain's Sunday Times newspaper published Sunday Jan. 22, 2017 nike air vapormax negras , an unarmed nuclear test missile fired by a British submarine off the coast of Fl...

Alees International
Major Mir Ali has spent 20 years cultivating export and business relationships in India and other countries. His association with manufacturers, marketers and importers has given him rich experience
Our team is capable of handling the following:
Alees International
Export Import Consultant
Iron Dealers, Corporate Agency
Product Export Promotion
Consultants
Direct seller-buyer contracts review Corporate export agency Sourcing the suppliers of Wheat, Rice, Fertilizers &...

And now, MapleStory M will go live in 140 nations at 7 pm Pacific time.The game is available on both iOS along with the Google Play Store. Tokyo-based Nexon said players who log Maplestory M Mesos into and play MapleStory M over the next 14 days will get special in-game items daily until August 21. Those who preregistered will also be able to claim their preregistration rewards until August 21.
By July 24 through July 31, 2018, MapleStory M streamers will have the chance to win extra rewar...