If this is your first visit, be sure to
check out the FAQ by clicking the
link above. You may have to register
before you can post: click the register link above to proceed. To start viewing messages,
select the forum that you want to visit from the selection below.

Hi Unregistered,
We'll be undergoing major forum changes in the very near future. Be sure to check out the details here

If he was going to be in the N arc you'd think he'd be on the poster like Dawn was, I don't think thats going to happen.
If they do a party type episode that has all of Ash's friends including Brock at the end of the series, I could see it maybe.

A close family member of mine died today, I put this in my sign as respect for him

I've hung around kids, mostly at my old job, during that time and they tended to like Ash more than Dawn and Brock. It seems that amongst the older fanbase, people like Dawn and Ash (and side characters). I've very rarely seen people being huge fans of Brock, though.

I've hung around kids, mostly at my old job, during that time and they tended to like Ash more than Dawn and Brock. It seems that amongst the older fanbase, people like Dawn and Ash (and side characters). I've very rarely seen people being huge fans of Brock, though.

Really? I would think kids would have liked Dawn the best of the DP trio. Interesting.

I'd love Brock to make an appearance and I agree that when Ash returns to Kanto, that would be a good time.

Dawn had a reason to come to Unova. World Tournament due to Cynthia who seems to travel regions quite lot. Brock has his doctor goals so he had no reason to go to the PWT. If anything he might be studying at Ash's house for some reason to be close to Oak who might help him and they meet for a bit.

You are the sun
The moon in the night
You are my everything
Everything so right

I don’t need another Summer
Another Spring, Another Fall
If I have you, don’t need anything at all

Dawn had a reason to come to Unova. World Tournament due to Cynthia who seems to travel regions quite lot. Brock has his doctor goals so he had no reason to go to the PWT. If anything he might be studying at Ash's house for some reason to be close to Oak who might help him and they meet for a bit.

Like Haunter said no she didn't, Haruka was well done since it was a Coordinator coming to a special contest, now Hikari comes from Hoenn out of nowhere to do a battling tournament that just by coincidence Satoshi will also take part in, thats as convinient as her whole "I get Togekiss!" episode.

There has been no evidence for or against Brock getting a cameo, hence this thread is speculation without evidence. Besides, the answer is simple; why do just a cameo instead of fixing up the character so even more people would want an official return?

I support Save Our Voice Actors, a Pokemon fan group in favor of returning the voice actors in the anime dubbed by 4Kids (seasons 1-8). facebook.com/saveourvoiceactors

Not enough to make the writers think "HARK! WE MUST BRING BROCK BACK FOR A CAMEO! HIS INSANE FANBASE IS DEMANDING SO!" ...Yeah.

That's not what you initially questioned though, you questioned whether people care and quite frankly yes enough people do which is evidently seen in the anime spoilers if you actually knew what you was talking about.

p.s There are hundreds of things in the anime that fans love but the writers don't always bring them back, Brock probably won't be any different.

Like Haunter said no she didn't, Haruka was well done since it was a Coordinator coming to a special contest, now Hikari comes from Hoenn out of nowhere to do a battling tournament that just by coincidence Satoshi will also take part in, thats as convinient as her whole "I get Togekiss!" episode.

Still better done than Brock coming for the PWT when he is working on his doctor thing. Plus tbh you can also say they messed up with her besides that due to not mentioned her Hoenn adventure or at least adding a new capture or evo like May which for me bugged me more. however her coming back for liking showing Unova what contests were would of been better than the PWT

You are the sun
The moon in the night
You are my everything
Everything so right

I don’t need another Summer
Another Spring, Another Fall
If I have you, don’t need anything at all

The better question is: Do people even care enough about Brock to warrant him a cameo?

Originally Posted by Super-Staff

Oh, I know there are, and most of them (like 98%) are Gen1 fans who are clearly not the target audience of the show anymore.

Hahahaha, you are 100% and absolutely right

But ... on topic ... not having Brock in a talking role is one of the things that BW has done VERY well, the guy got stale since Clefairy and the Moon Stone (¬_¬).
I don´t think he is missed actually so, even with Dawn´s mentions, I didn´t saw any chances for him to appearing ... luckily.

Still better done than Brock coming for the PWT when he is working on his doctor thing. Plus tbh you can also say they messed up with her besides that due to not mentioned her Hoenn adventure or at least adding a new capture or evo like May which for me bugged me more. however her coming back for liking showing Unova what contests were would of been better than the PWT

Wouldn't be well done either, thats why if he appears it should be in Kanto, Satoshi can come back home and his mom tells Takeshi he is coming home so he comes to visit, easy reasonable way to make him appear.