For 2 weeks in a row, we've had fans coming on here telling us how good their QBs passing stats are. Alex Smith was the top rated QBR QB, RG3 completes 70% of his passes, whoopdee doo! If our QB just threw 5-7 yd screens & dumpoffs the vast majority of the game, he'd complete 80% of his passes. Problem is , Eli can make any type of throw that only the elite QBs can make. Smith has proven he can't, RG3 is still 6 games into his NFL career, so I can't make that judgement on him yet.

All week, the only player these Skins fans have been harping is about RG3, not any other single player on their team. That alone tells me they have no one else on their team they feel is worth talking about. Hope all the smack talkers come back after the game to eat their crow. But like most 9er fans, I doubt it.

It's defintely unfortunate that we have a few Skins fans that find a way to make the rest of us look bad. Do I think the Skins beat themselves today? Absolutely, but I also think the Giants showed why they may be the best team in the league. With that said, it's hard to ignore that the Redskins are quickly becoming dangerous on offense.

I realize a lot of people don't like RG3 (Though has he actually done anything to warrant anyone not liking him?), but the argument about him only throwing short passes all day is getting old pretty fast. News flash, he leads the league with 8.5 yard per completion. He threw 2 perfectly thrown 30+ yard passes today, one for a TD and the other dropped by Hankerson. I'm not sure what he would have to do for even opposing fans to admit he is incredibly talented.

Not to mention, what's wrong with Skins fans bragging about him and only him (though you must be missing the hype about Morris and Kerrigan)? Colts fans bragged about Peyton for how long? He was taken away from them for one season and they dropped to the bottom of the league. Just the same, if you take away Eli, what are the Giants? It's not uncommon for one player to be the difference on a team these days, specifically from the QB position.

Bottom line is the Giants are the better team right now overall, and I have no problem admitting that as a Skins fan...but to think RG3 is overrated, over-hyped or just not that talented is absurd.

10-21-2012, 10:08 PM

Sarcasman

Quote:

Originally Posted by enforcer_upu

It's defintely unfortunate that we have a few Skins fans that find a way to make the rest of us look bad. Do I think the Skins beat themselves today? Absolutely, but I also think the Giants showed why they may be the best team in the league. With that said, it's hard to ignore that the Redskins are quickly becoming dangerous on offense.

I realize a lot of people don't like RG3 (Though has he actually done anything to warrant anyone not liking him?), but the argument about him only throwing short passes all day is getting old pretty fast. News flash, he leads the league with 8.5 yard per completion. He threw 2 perfectly thrown 30+ yard passes today, one for a TD and the other dropped by Hankerson. I'm not sure what he would have to do for even opposing fans to admit he is incredibly talented.

Not to mention, what's wrong with Skins fans bragging about him and only him (though you must be missing the hype about Morris and Kerrigan)? Colts fans bragged about Peyton for how long? He was taken away from them for one season and they dropped to the bottom of the league. Just the same, if you take away Eli, what are the Giants? It's not uncommon for one player to be the difference on a team these days, specifically from the QB position.

Bottom line is the Giants are the better team right now overall, and I have no problem admitting that as a Skins fan...but to think RG3 is overrated, over-hyped or just not that talented is absurd.

I got no argument with any of that.

10-21-2012, 11:21 PM

BParcells777

Nothing wrong with RG3.....I wont call him Bob anymore.......he is sensational......we just forced a lot of turnovers today but our Oline took two giant steps backwards

10-22-2012, 06:52 AM

GCGiant

RGIII runs too much. He is young and will get away with it for a while, but eventually all the hits will catch-up with him. I don't care what anyone says, either, because in my mind he is still MVII and will end-up having the same type of injury problems. Actually, I think MV has a better arm.

10-22-2012, 07:47 AM

GMan-67

Quote:

Originally Posted by enforcer_upu

It's defintely unfortunate that we have a few Skins fans that find a way to make the rest of us look bad. Do I think the Skins beat themselves today? Absolutely, but I also think the Giants showed why they may be the best team in the league. With that said, it's hard to ignore that the Redskins are quickly becoming dangerous on offense.

I realize a lot of people don't like RG3 (Though has he actually done anything to warrant anyone not liking him?), but the argument about him only throwing short passes all day is getting old pretty fast. News flash, he leads the league with 8.5 yard per completion. He threw 2 perfectly thrown 30+ yard passes today, one for a TD and the other dropped by Hankerson. I'm not sure what he would have to do for even opposing fans to admit he is incredibly talented.

Not to mention, what's wrong with Skins fans bragging about him and only him (though you must be missing the hype about Morris and Kerrigan)? Colts fans bragged about Peyton for how long? He was taken away from them for one season and they dropped to the bottom of the league. Just the same, if you take away Eli, what are the Giants? It's not uncommon for one player to be the difference on a team these days, specifically from the QB position.

Bottom line is the Giants are the better team right now overall, and I have no problem admitting that as a Skins fan...but to think RG3 is overrated, over-hyped or just not that talented is absurd.

he did throw 2 absolutely perfect deep touch passes ... Vick can fling it a country mile, but he does not have great touch ... RG3s future appears bright

if our defenders did not bring their ball stripping skills today, it could have been a different outcome

10-22-2012, 08:50 AM

BillTheGreek

Quote:

Originally Posted by Tj.Tomahawk

Skins fan here too. I will been the board after the redskins win. See you fellas

Tj ........How did that Loss feel ? It's called the Agony of Defeat ! I must say, you had us on the ropes......but Superman, saved us again ,You gotta Love that Cruz too !
See you Dec. 3.........and make sure to bring Santana Moss with you !!! I Love his Ball Handling !..