Punishment: All Murr has to do is take a five mile walk (estimated to be an hour and a half) from the Staten Island mall to his parents' house while wearing his old centaur costume, and the costume now comes with an added touch: deer antlers! Simple, right? Wrong! Beginning his long walk of shame, Murray thinks it's all he has to do, being mocked by passing drivers and pedestrians in the process, but the real reason behind it is the other jokers are going hunting, and he's their quarry! After being honked at by passing vehicles, the humiliated Murr takes the bus for three miles. He's two miles away from his destination, not knowing the other jokers are on the hunt, chasing him in a pickup truck, armed with eggs, paintball guns and squirt guns loaded with deer urine. After walking 3 blocks and dodging the ammo, Murr finally makes it to his parents' house, only to be surprised by the other jokers waiting for him: Sal at the front door and Q and Joe in the backyard. Murr's father exits the house to witness the excitement happening and Murr finally "dies", leading up to the end of the episode.