In this board, I'm putting the chances of the characters from the SSB series to be in Nuke, from what I believe. It ranges from Confirmed, Very Likely, Moderately Likely, Not Likely, and Disconfirmed. If, upon request by Callum, TaroNuke, or Hoeloe, I will delete this topic. Changes are also expected to be made as time goes on.

2/11/10:Changed Falco from Moderately Likely to Confirmed.Changed Meta Knight from Very Likely to Confirmed.Changed Roy from Not Likely to Confirmed.Changed Mewtwo from Very Likely to Confirmed.Changed Lucas from Moderately Likely to Very Likely.

4/12/10:Added "Semi" to the previously added Confirmed. (Except Roy, as his artwork has been shown.) The leak is old, so it may or may not be revelant.

4/15/10:Changed Mr. Game & Watch from Moderately Likely to Confirmed, but with "Semi".

4/21/10:Changed Captain Falcon from Very Likely to Confirmed.Changed Pokemon Trainer from Not Likely to Confirmed.

Last edited by GoldenYuiitusin on Wed Jul 27, 2011 10:30 am; edited 6 times in total

The list is altogether likely to be true, as it seems, although the Young Link thing puzzles me. IIRC, Callum said he liked YL, and I remember that YL is a very famous character. I just thought he might be budged up a notch on the likely scale, but that's just my opinion. Good work on this list though.

The list is altogether likely to be true, as it seems, although the Young Link thing puzzles me. IIRC, Callum said he liked YL, and I remember that YL is a very famous character. I just thought he might be budged up a notch on the likely scale, but that's just my opinion. Good work on this list though.

I may be wrong, but I thought they said that there would be no clones, so I don't think a second Link, Young or Toon, is going to make the cut. Thanks for the praise!

It's awesome to look at this list knowing what I know and have been working on.

Of course you must realize that we can't put all of these characters in, and thatwe have another million universes to choose from. : ) epic list.

I am well aware that not all the characters are going to be in. This list just represents what I feel the chances of certain characters are to be in SNBM. I'm glad you like it!

Flying Dutchman wrote:

Correct me if I'm wrong, but I think Taro deconfirmed Wolf a long time ago.

I'd say Lucas is out too, because you have to admit - Ness and Lucas are way similiar. I think the team will do the wise thing and only have one Mother representative.

I will need proof, but I figured that Wolf had low chances anyway.In fact, it was TaroNuke that made me put Mewtwo for High and Lucario for Low because of his hatred for Lucario.As for Ness and Lucas, to me, and to most other people, they are like Mario and Luigi. They have many similarities, but are different enough to not be clones.Most people would disagree about having only one Mother representative though, and they want more than what Brawl had. (People were complaining about no Kumatora, or Masked Man!) They need to STFU. It should be Ness, Lucas, and Ninten for SSB. The 3 main heroes. As for SNBM, I wouldn't be surprised if Ness was the only one. But Lucas has a Medium chance.

As for Ness and Lucas, to me, and to most other people, they are like Mario and Luigi. They have many similarities, but are different enough to not be clones.Most people would disagree about having only one Mother representative though, and they want more than what Brawl had. (People were complaining about no Kumatora, or Masked Man!) They need to STFU. It should be Ness, Lucas, and Ninten for SSB. The 3 main heroes. As for SNBM, I wouldn't be surprised if Ness was the only one. But Lucas has a Medium chance.

Earthbound hasn't even been released over here in Australia... I wouldn't have heard of the game if it weren't for Smash brothers. America and Japan are the only places Earthbound was released, so frankly, it isn't as famous as you say it is. Heck, if that franchise were to have all three main characters in the game, does that not mean that every other franchise should have the same privilege?

As for Ness and Lucas, to me, and to most other people, they are like Mario and Luigi. They have many similarities, but are different enough to not be clones.Most people would disagree about having only one Mother representative though, and they want more than what Brawl had. (People were complaining about no Kumatora, or Masked Man!) They need to STFU. It should be Ness, Lucas, and Ninten for SSB. The 3 main heroes. As for SNBM, I wouldn't be surprised if Ness was the only one. But Lucas has a Medium chance.

Earthbound hasn't even been released over here in Australia... I wouldn't have heard of the game if it weren't for Smash brothers. America and Japan are the only places Earthbound was released, so frankly, it isn't as famous as you say it is. Heck, if that franchise were to have all three main characters in the game, does that not mean that every other franchise should have the same privilege?

America, Japan, and EUROPE. And people treat it like if it was made by God. I personally don't give a crap about the series, but the main heroes should be playable.As for "every other series", almost all the worthy ones do. Mother is in the worthy list. So is F-Zero, which needs at least another character.

No. Because he is one of the people that are under the illusion that Lucario replaced Mewtwo. Which is not true. Both were supposed to be in. Mewtwo was almost finished when he was cut.

Objection!

The data was present in the game, but could not be salvaged. As far as my knowledge goes, there was no way of telling how advanced the coding actually was. Data for his Victory Theme might have been found, but that could not be salvaged either - so it's unknown whether the file in question was even complete.

Besides, if the data from Brawl would tell you anything, Plusle and Minun would've had just as much of a chance of appearing as Mewtwo did.

F-Zero and Mother are fine with just one character. Number of characters in the series is not as important (or SHOULD not be) as how easily one would recognize the character. For instance, if I have to explain to you who a certain character is, I feel I would have done my job wrong. You should even vaguely be able to tell just who that character is, what world he or she is from and so on. On the internet, we get an abundancy of information thrown towards us, information that we remember and therefore we can recognize a whole series of characters most people should never have heard about. I feel this warps our sense of which characters should or should not be in the game.

For instance, when I told my friend about Samurai Goroh's state in Brawl, he asked me who Samurai Goroh was. It was obvious to me, even though I've only played 1 F-Zero game. Such things may not be obvious to anyone.

And as I would like to state again: amount of characters in the actual series =/= characters in this game, otherwise the amount of Pokémon would be through the roof.

No. Because he is one of the people that are under the illusion that Lucario replaced Mewtwo. Which is not true. Both were supposed to be in. Mewtwo was almost finished when he was cut.

Objection!

The data was present in the game, but could not be salvaged. As far as my knowledge goes, there was no way of telling how advanced the coding actually was. Data for his Victory Theme might have been found, but that could not be salvaged either - so it's unknown whether the file in question was even complete.

Besides, if the data from Brawl would tell you anything, Plusle and Minun would've had just as much of a chance of appearing as Mewtwo did.

Overruled!

The reason why it couldn't be salvaged is that Nintendo had to null the data when he/it couldn't be in the game (as to prevent hacking, which Nintendo hates), but they couldn't delete it completely, as removing data completely would eff up the game in some way. So the data was made into "dummy" files. Seeing as Mewtwo has the most "dummy" files over the others proves that he/it was the most worked on.As for "Pra_Mai", it is unknown if it IS Plusle & Minun or not. (There is no way to prove it at this time) That aside, like I said before, they had less "dummy" files than Mewtwo.

No. Because he is one of the people that are under the illusion that Lucario replaced Mewtwo. Which is not true. Both were supposed to be in. Mewtwo was almost finished when he was cut.

Objection!

The data was present in the game, but could not be salvaged. As far as my knowledge goes, there was no way of telling how advanced the coding actually was. Data for his Victory Theme might have been found, but that could not be salvaged either - so it's unknown whether the file in question was even complete.

Besides, if the data from Brawl would tell you anything, Plusle and Minun would've had just as much of a chance of appearing as Mewtwo did.

Overruled!

The reason why it couldn't be salvaged is that Nintendo had to null the data when he/it couldn't be in the game (as to prevent hacking, which Nintendo hates), but they couldn't delete it completely, as removing data completely would eff up the game in some way. So the data was made into "dummy" files. Seeing as Mewtwo has the most "dummy" files over the others proves that he/it was the most worked on.As for "Pra_Mai", it is unknown if it IS Plusle & Minun or not. (There is no way to prove it at this time) That aside, like I said before, they had less "dummy" files than Mewtwo.

No. Because he is one of the people that are under the illusion that Lucario replaced Mewtwo. Which is not true. Both were supposed to be in. Mewtwo was almost finished when he was cut. :Pokemon:

Objection!

The data was present in the game, but could not be salvaged. As far as my knowledge goes, there was no way of telling how advanced the coding actually was. Data for his Victory Theme might have been found, but that could not be salvaged either - so it's unknown whether the file in question was even complete.

Besides, if the data from Brawl would tell you anything, Plusle and Minun would've had just as much of a chance of appearing as Mewtwo did.

Overruled!

The reason why it couldn't be salvaged is that Nintendo had to null the data when he/it couldn't be in the game (as to prevent hacking, which Nintendo hates), but they couldn't delete it completely, as removing data completely would eff up the game in some way. So the data was made into "dummy" files. Seeing as Mewtwo has the most "dummy" files over the others proves that he/it was the most worked on.As for "Pra_Mai", it is unknown if it IS Plusle & Minun or not. (There is no way to prove it at this time) That aside, like I said before, they had less "dummy" files than Mewtwo.

Hold it!

The name "Pra_Mai" fits Plusle & Minun to a T.. in the original Japanese: "Prasle" & "Mainun". Also, the amount of dummy files doesn't prove that one character was worked on more or less than the other, as work may not have progressed a whole lot after all. There's no way of telling!

(Actually, I think you're right, I just like trying to act like a Phoenix Wright character :D)

Nope, not Europe. According to Earthbound Wiki, it was only released in Japan and America. Of course, Wikipedia isn't always a reliable source, but I think those whom made the Earthbound Wiki would know their stuff in regards to the Mother franchise.. :S

-- Yeah, I know I'm a bit late with this, but hey, better late than never.

Anyways it would be wierd to put them on the same file, as Popo and Nana have separate ones.

You pronounce the word als "Mainun", same with "Purasuru" -> "Plusle". They're the same words as in English, just pronounced that way.

Pronounciation=/=Spelling.Anyways, if Sakurai went by Japanese variations of the same name in Japan (Excluding Jigglypuff, Squirtle, Ivysaur, and Charizard, as their Japanese names are used)Pikachu would be....Pikachu....Lucario would be RukarioMewtwo would be MyuutsuSo why would Plusle and Minun get special treatment?

Anyways it would be wierd to put them on the same file, as Popo and Nana have separate ones.

You pronounce the word als "Mainun", same with "Purasuru" -> "Plusle". They're the same words as in English, just pronounced that way.

Pronounciation=/=Spelling.Anyways, if Sakurai went by Japanese variations of the same name in Japan (Excluding Jigglypuff, Squirtle, Ivysaur, and Charizard, as their Japanese names are used)Pikachu would be....Pikachu....Lucario would be RukarioMewtwo would be MyuutsuSo why would Plusle and Minun get special treatment?

I wondered about that for a while, too. However, you answered it yourself - the Trainer's Pokémon got their japanese names (Zenigame, Fushigisou and Lizardon, I believe) and so did Pikachu. Plusle and Minun didn't get special treatment, the programming team was just really inconsistent. It's not special treatment, just weird programming. Besides, you're better off argumenting Lucario and Mewtwo got special treatment, since most of the Pokémon have their names in Japanese (5 out of 7).