Connect With Us

Share Your Review

Please leave this field empty.

We spent three months looking at over 20 wedding venues in NYC, Hudson Valley and the Hamptons before deciding on Peconic Bay Yacht Club. It was the last place we saw and easily the most beautiful. The venue itself is pristine and the views are stunning. Even on a cloudy day it’s a gorgeous spot. Many of our picky guests commented on how phenomenal the food was (best wedding food we’ve ever had) as well as how great the staff was. As the bride, I felt more than taken care of before and during our wedding day. All I had to do was think about needing a sip of water, and a glass would appear. It was a completely magical day that more than exceeded our expectations. If you want a wedding venue that has stunning water views and is extremely high touch, look no further. We couldn’t possibly recommend Peconic Bay Yacht Club more!

Brigid and Matthew’s Weddings

My husband and I got married at Peconic Bay Yacht Club in June and I cannot recommend our experience enough. Looking back at other venues we considered (and meeting with other event managers) I can say with great confidence that getting married at Peconic Bay Yacht Club and working with John and his staff was 100% the best choice we could have made. The PBYC team went above and beyond, not only during the planning process, but also night-of. Our bridal attendant, the servers, bartenders and other waitstaff were beyond impressive. Many of our friends and family told us that they were blown away by the superior level of service they received, including servers approaching guests throughout the night, just to ask if there is anything they could provide, was something I’ve never heard of at a wedding before. We cannot recommend Peconic Bay Yacht Club enough.

Bernadette and Sean’s Wedding

Our wedding at Peconic Bay Yacht Club and it was by far was the most magical day of our lives!!! The entire PBYC and Robbins Wolfe staff went above and beyond what we imagined. From the service, coordination, organization, set-up, menu, cuisine, drinks, and everything else, we were impressed by the planning leading up to and execution on our wedding day. Any problems that arose were solved by the PBYC team and they made our bridal party and family feel so welcomed and comfortable. You don’t have to worry or think about anything except for having a great time. Rain or shine, the venue is beautiful and warm. The food is delicious and there’s so much of it! From cocktail hour and the amazing raw bar to the butler-passed dessert parade, everything was flavorful and well-executed. Our guests keep mentioning that it is the best food they’ve ever had at a wedding. The service was impeccable and we always had someone attending to us and our guests. Overall, we could not have had a better experience. The whole PBYC team made our dream wedding come true.

Wedding May 27th, 2018

We just returned from our honeymoon last night and the first thing we wanted to do today was write a review for John and the rest of the staff at Peconic Bay Yacht Club for giving us the wedding of our dreams. There is truly nothing we would change about our experience from the first tour we took with John to when we boarded the bus home at the end of the night. John thought of every detail, responded to every question quickly, and made us feel like we were truly part of the family. The space itself is beautifully designed, the views are surreal, and the food was out of this world. We could not recommend this venue and everything/everyone that comes with it enough. Thank you so much John for everything you did to make our big day as special as it was!!!

Wedding July 14th, 2018

Peconic Bay Yacht Club provided us with the most amazing day of our lives! Within the first few minutes of arriving and PBYC, immediately we knew this was THE spot. My husband and I were married on the lawn overlooking the water on a sunny 65 degree day in April. While we seriously lucked out with the weather, it really was the only thing we had to worry about because the PBYC team took care of everything and were TOP NOTCH. Robbins Wolfe provided the most delicious and unique food options which our guests are still raving about months later.

The building itself is so beautiful and such an amazing space, we really wanted to use the upstairs area for more than just cocktail hour. John and his staff made it possible for us to use the entire building. The dessert parade came out while the band played away and guests raved about being able to enjoy dessert without interrupting their dancing. We ended up doing 1.5 hour cocktail hour and an after-party downstairs, both of which I would highly recommend!

From the venue itself, the gorgeous grounds, the entire staff, to the amazing and seemingly endless amount of food and drinks, you truly get the whole package. Your guests will say it’s the best wedding they have ever been to and actually mean it. Book your wedding here. Now.

Caitlin Collins

I’ve had the most amazing comments from family and friends on the venue, the staff and the amazing food. You are our rock star! No family could expect or receive the level of support you gave us. Please use us as a reference anytime. Just can’t say enough.

Thank you, Kim

Dean Wedding

Not only is PBYC a beautiful venue, but their partnership with Robbins Wolfe catering elevates the experience. The food was unique and absolutely delicious. We are still receiving messages from our guests that they are craving the burrata! The quality of the wine and spirits is above and beyond any other venue (and trust me, we have been to a lot of weddings!) We strongly recommend booking your big day at Peconic Bay Yacht Club. After touring the venue you will know you ended up in the right place!

Getz/Tamimi Wedding

I cannot thank you enough for the incredible job you did to make Lauren & Tommy’s wedding day a day they will cherish forever. From the first moment they met you, you made them feel as if their wedding was the only one you had. Your staff was phenomenal with every last detail. Thank you from the bottom of my heart for the greatest day ever.

Petersen/Wondel Wedding

Top to bottom, this venue is pristine and stunning in every way, and the outstanding service made our wedding day go off without a hitch! If you are looking for a gorgeous venue, with amazing service, beautiful views, and delicious food…look no further than Peconic Bay Yacht Club!

Shohet Wedding

Words cannot describe how perfect it was. The level of service the whole staff was so professional, attentive and straight up amazing. The property is absolutely beautiful, and the food was great, but it’s the staff that makes it perfect.

Reposted from Facebook

We’ve gotten so many phone calls and texts about the food, the service and the beauty of the venue. If I had to do it over again, I wouldn’t change a single thing. Thank you for a wedding that will live on in our memories as one of the most beautiful days of our lives.

Cagnazzi Wedding

The staff, food (which is not your typical wedding catering- important to me as a personal chef), grounds and building were some of the best I’ve ever experienced and many of our guests would agree. Our ceremony was on the beautiful lawn overlooking Shelter Island and our cocktail hour was indoor/outdoor on the upper deck. I would strongly recommend PBYC to anyone looking for an elegant, beach/nautical, romantic, delicious wedding venue.

Israel/Denhoff Wedding

My husband Kevin and I just had our wedding here and it was beyond amazing!!!! The Peconic Bay Yacht Club is unlike any other wedding on Long Island. I 110% recommend having a wedding at the PBYC, other than choosing to marry your significant other it will be one of the best decision you ever make!

Hymowitz Wedding

My husband Kevin and I just had our wedding there and it was beyond amazing!!!! The Peconic Bay Yacht Club is unlike any other wedding on Long Island. I 110% recommend having a wedding at the PBYC, other than choosing to marry you significant other it will be one of the best decision you ever make!

Dana & Kevin

I recently attended a wedding at the Peconic Bay Yacht Club and I do not know how any other wedding will top it! While words cannot do this venue justice, it was truly the most beautiful wedding I have ever been to. From the craftsmanship of the building to the stunning view of Shelter Island, the hardest decision to make would be whether to have the wedding indoors or outdoors. The food was outstanding and the service was impeccable going above and beyond for all the guests and making sure everyone was having a great time. I would highly recommend this setting for your special day!

Allison M

John and his crew are a class act. Our wedding went off flawlessly with 200+ guests in the rain under a tent on the lawn. Delicious food, impeccable service from planning through the day of, and unbelievable scenery for a day I will literally remember my entire life.

Ian & Kathryn

Should a guest at Peconic Bay Yacht Club forget that the affair they are attending is located on the North Fork, a parking lot covered in crushed clam shells with hydrangea-lined walkways and a large anchor leaning against the dock house will remind them. The cedar-shingled siding and gables give the building the feel of a New England seaside estate and an arbor near the shore offers an ideal spot for a couple to say ‘I do.’

TheNorthforker.com

We had our wedding at the Peconic Bay Yacht Club in August 2015, and the venue allowed our day to exceed every expectation. The views from both the upper deck, and the reception tent adjacent to the bay were stunning, and unparalleled to other venues on Long Island. We also sincerely appreciated the flexibility of establishing our ‘wedding look’ while planning; it allowed us to make the already intimate venue have our personal touch for family and friends. It was clear on the faces of our guests that they were enjoying the privilege of taking in the beauty of the spot for just a few short hours. In short, the PBYC was tremendous and we highly encourage newly engaged couples to get a date secured before this hidden gem becomes a wedding hot spot!