Dynasty league: Would you trade RG3 for Luck straight up? Or should I ask for more if I have RG3? Just think Luck is going to be a lot more durable.. don't trust RG3 to stay healthy.

__________________
"Compadres, it is imperative that we crush the freedom fighters before the start of the rainy season. And remember, a shiny new donkey for whomever brings me the head of Colonel Montoya."

__________________
"Compadres, it is imperative that we crush the freedom fighters before the start of the rainy season. And remember, a shiny new donkey for whomever brings me the head of Colonel Montoya."

Dynasty league: Would you trade RG3 for Luck straight up? Or should I ask for more if I have RG3? Just think Luck is going to be a lot more durable.. don't trust RG3 to stay healthy.

I'm an owner of Luck in a keeper league and I wouldn't trade him straight up for the reasons you just mentioned. Also, in the coming years if the Colts shore up the O-Line Luck will erase a lot of those interceptions. So yeah if you wanted him I would tack on a receiver to the trade. Just my thoughts.

__________________

Sig by BoneKrusher

Quote:

Originally Posted by killxswitch

Bill Polian is cancer wrapped in AIDS delivered in an XXL enema so please don't expect me to disagree with you.

Need 7.6 from Morris in a .5 PPR league and 33 points from RGIII, Nicks, and Morris in a standard league to win, which would secure byes in both money leagues I'm in that have playoffs starting next week. Think I can squeak into a bye in the second league with 27 points from that trio but I'd rather just win and lock it up.

with that scoring system I would personally lean towards rg3. if you told me 6 pts/td pass and 20 yards/1 point passing then Id lean Luck. You have reasonable enough backups for a dynasty imo to stick with rg3.

How sad is it that Arizona's QB situation is so bad that I'm going to bench the 3rd best wide receiver in the league in a 3WR PPR league with a flex spot? All I want for Christmas is for Arizona to get a QB, so my dynasty league receiver core can be Green, Thomas, and good Fitzgerald.

I think Brown is better than McCoy though. Not many do but make him the primary back and he's better.

I guess I assume McCoy gets touches until proven otherwise, and that being the case Brown's value is just as a really good handcuff. Brown's fumbling issues don't help his case either (in terms of being the primary back).

I guess I assume McCoy gets touches until proven otherwise, and that being the case Brown's value is just as a really good handcuff. Brown's fumbling issues don't help his case either (in terms of being the primary back).

**** he can get me 35 points and fumble twice I still end up with 31 lol.

Nothing is worse than playing a lessor player and losing b/c you benched a stud.

Er, Gates as a stud? Half of his games this year have featured <25 yards and no touchdowns. Hasn't had many huge games to counteract that, either. I'm not saying anything was a slam dunk in his situation, but at this point Gates owners really do have only themselves to blame if he's giving them poor performances.

Finished 2nd in both my leagues to get 1st round byes and I also won 80 bucks in one for finishing second in the reg. season. Now if I could just get Gronk back in time for the 2nd round I would be in great shape.

**** he can get me 35 points and fumble twice I still end up with 31 lol.

From a fantasy perspective he's awesome, I just don't think the coaches are going to feel the same way about the fumbling.

Quote:

Originally Posted by themaninblack

Finished 2nd in both my leagues to get 1st round byes and I also won 80 bucks in one for finishing second in the reg. season. Now if I could just get Gronk back in time for the 2nd round I would be in great shape.

Also looking to get Gronk back in time for week 15. Picked him up for BJGE since I had a playoff spot locked up and figured he offered some nice upside.

Er, Gates as a stud? Half of his games this year have featured <25 yards and no touchdowns. Hasn't had many huge games to counteract that, either. I'm not saying anything was a slam dunk in his situation, but at this point Gates owners really do have only themselves to blame if he's giving them poor performances.

lol. Can't argue that. Stud really applies more to Nelson there than Gates, but the point remains.

Quote:

Originally Posted by themaninblack

Finished 2nd in both my leagues to get 1st round byes and I also won 80 bucks in one for finishing second in the reg. season. Now if I could just get Gronk back in time for the 2nd round I would be in great shape.

I'm holding out hope. It may hinge entirely on the playoff seeding race. Gronk is clearly an animal - let's hope it applies to healing, too.