Couldn't find it quickly looking at their site, but MacUser in their print magazine have an Apple hardware roundup at the back of each issue with tweaked review ratings based on how the product compares here and now, rather than when it was initially reviewed.
–
pauldunlopSep 10 '10 at 11:06

As far as software goes, MacUpdate is pretty good. They have lots of user reviews, and the ability for users to suggest similar software is awesome. I've found many a free alternative to a poorly reviewed commercial app that way.

As a side note, alternativeTo is another great way to find alternates.

There's always ArsTechnica. Yes, they do review other stuff besides just Apple stuff, but I fail to see how that should disqualify them, especially given the quality and depth of the reviews. And with a couple of clicks, you can specify Apple reviews: