Monday, September 12, 2016

Take a Knee

I understand the visceral reaction that many have to the collective
protest of our National Anthem and Flag. When my home team quarterback Colin
Kaepernick set off the firestorm by sitting for the anthem, I felt stung and my
sensibilities were offended. Kaepernick, I thought, is an example of our
meritocracy – a black man growing up in a struggling Central Valley town who by
hard work and skill was able to lead his team to America’s greatest stage. He
is an example of America when it works. My reaction was anger and annoyance,
how dare he insult our vets when he has benefited so much from their sacrifice?
Who the hell is he to complain? He seems to have it pretty good…

First of all, why not Kaepernick? Why not use his position
as a successful (albeit currently challenged) athlete on the national stage to
make a strong statement on behalf of those who are silenced? Until he sat down
for the anthem, no one was paying any attention to him, either. Tweets do not
make a movement. Tweets and Facebook posts did call attention to the number of
black men who are killed in the street by police officers who later face no
trial of their peers. A movement erupted but the comfortable ignored it or made
fun of it, insisting that all lives matter when clearly they do not. If the
lives of these black men mattered, then there would have been indictments and
trials.

He sat and we finally paid attention but we still ignore the
statement. We latch on to the hagiography of what the flag means to us without
truly questioning what it should mean. Kaepernick made me think hard and my
mind was changed. Fundamentally, we a nation of ideals. We a nation based on
the political ideology of equality under the law. We are not a nation defined by our borders
and our cultural identity. We are not a nation defined by nationalism; we are
defined by our Declaration of Independence and our Constitution that codifies
our equality under the law.

By taking a knee for the anthem, Kaepernick asserts those ideals
and makes a strong and painful declaration that we are not living up to them. Our
nation was founded by those who wanted to leave behind the blood and boundary
nationalism of Europe. There is an England, there is a France, there is a Germany
that transcends the political system of the moment. Vichy France was never not
France and the Democratic Republic of Germany continued to be German even under
Soviet control. These were and continue to be nations that are defined by their
cultural identity and nationalism. We are not.

With my initial anger at Mr. Kaepernick I lost sight of
America’s great legacy. We are not a nation founded on boundaries and
ethnicity. We are a nation that is founded on the ideas of equality and
liberty. If the flag is only a symbol of the sacrifice of our soldiers during
war time, then we are nothing more than the physical borders that must be
protected, not our principles and not our ideals. Our nation is much greater
than our boundaries and we should demand respect for those ideals, especially from
sworn officers. Extrajudicial murders in black communities, carried out by the
very officers who are meant to protect us, are a perversion of the ideals our
nation is built on. The integrity of those ideals are more important than the
integrity of our national boundaries, if not more so.

Opening Day of the NFL season fell on the 15th
anniversary of the terrorist attacks of September 11th. Nine Eleven.
Even after defending my quarterback for the last couple of weeks, I felt
ambivalent about the appropriateness of continuing the protest on a day where
our nation mourned the greatest attack on our national integrity since the
Second World War. Our homeland was attacked. We went to war to protect our
ideals and our way of life. Surely sitting down on 9/11 is disrespectful to
that memory, isn’t it? And yet, surely it is disrespectful to our ideals to
accept that entire communities are not afforded the rights enshrined in our
founding documents. To accept that citizens of this country can be killed with
impunity, where there is no accountability for the taking of their life, is to
deny the concept of our right to life, liberty and pursuit of happiness.

If our flag doesn’t stand for those ideals, then what does
it really stand for?