Can you compare Incarnation to Force of Nature? My gut tells me that Incarnation will almost always be more beneficial, unless the treants have other abilities beyond dps/healing.

Aka, both are burst talents, but Incarnation seems like it would scale better with gear and raid buffs, particularly bloodlust. And for PvP, treants would need a lot more buffing in order to be more than the mere nuisances they currently are.

I would much rather be able to target them, so I can place them away from me to gather adds or pull something off a party member. That sounds much more useful than something limited to starting where I can already take care of business.

Ok here is what they should totally allow in beta most definitely not live. But I would totally make it happen if i worked at blizz just for funsies. A Boomkin symbiosis’s a mage which gets them mirror image.Boomkin casts mirror image then he casts force of nature which the images also cast. So you see 4 moonkins and 12 treants all casting wrath at the same time UBER AWESOMENESS!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!