Help

No account yet?
Registering is free, easy, and private.
Discuss in the forum, contribute to the Encyclopedia, build your own MyAnime lists, and more.

Shelf Life

Space Runaway Ideon

by Paul Jensen, James Beckett, Feb 18th 2019

I'm sure I'm just adding to an already loud chorus here, but y'all really should be watching Mob Psycho 100 (or catching up on the first season if you missed it). I can already tell I'm going to go back through this show a second or third time just to appreciate the animation, because holy crap it's impressive. The story's also smarter than the average action series, which never hurts. Welcome to Shelf Life.

Shelf Life Reviews

The last time I binged a non-GundamYoshiyuki Tomino series was when I covered Aura Battler Dunbine, and while I appreciated and enjoyed its infusion of fantasy tropes with mecha action fare, it never quite got its hooks into me enough to make a lasting impression. Ever since then I've hoped to have another chance to have an old-school mecha anime really impress me. Enter the new Space Runaway Ideon Blu-Ray set from Maiden Japan, which collects all 39 episodes from the original 1980 television series as well as its two theatrical releases from 1982. Ideon was the first series that Tomino got to direct after launching the Mobile Suit Gundamfranchise, and like its predecessor, Ideon was famously cancelled and given a rushed conclusion that made nobody happy. This disappointed fans enough that they demanded (and received) a proper theatrical conclusion two years later; naturally, the comparisons to Evangelion's eventual fate just a decade-and-a-half later are pretty obvious, and they become even more so when you consider just how ambitious and emotionally intense Space Runaway Ideon's finale ended up being.

Ideon's plot starts off very simply at first, almost to a fault: The colonists of Planet Solo have recently unearthed the advanced technology of the lost Sixth Civilization of aliens, and before they can make heads or tails of it the planet is attacked by a race of aliens known as the Buff Clan. Preposterous name aside, the Buff Clan is hunting for the mythical power of Ide, and it just so happens that the machines uncovered by the Solo Colonists form an unstoppable war machine called the Ideon. This sparks an immediate conflict that destroys the colony on Solo and sends the colonists fleeing on a massive Sixth Civilization vessel they've dubbed the Solo Ship. The Buff Clan pursues the colonists into deep space.

For most of the series, the thrust of the plot in every episode is nearly identical: the Solo Ship is running away from the Buff Clan, the Buff Clan finds the colonists anyways, and a fight ensues that is inevitably ended by the Ideon's ever-increasing power. Every now and then we get a Star Trek-esque alien planet that mixes things up on the battlefield, but the formula rarely deviates too much. The show's cast is similarly simple: Cosmo is a headstrong leading man whose most unique characteristic is his giant fire-red afro, Kasha is the perpetually disrespected pilot who just wants Cosmo to take her seriously, Bes is the captain, Sheryl is the dispassionate scientist, and Karala is the beautiful Buff Clan woman who ends up switching sides to defend humanity. There are many other cast members, but all of them tend to possess only one or two character traits, and they tend to only show up when it serves the plot, at least at first.

Initially, I was put off by how safe and straightforward Space Runaway Ideon felt, and it took getting past the sluggish first ten or so episodes for me to tune into the show's particular rhythms and tone. Once I did, though, I found myself surprisingly engaged with the Solo Ship's endless quest to be free from the Buff Clan's destructive warpath. The characters became more well-rounded and likable, the battle grew more perilous, and the colonist's desperation for peace and safety grew ever more palpable and complicated. The multi-episode arc that sees Karala trying to prove her loyalty and good intentions to the human crew of the Solo Ship was in particular the exact kind of classic sci-fi melodrama that I like to dig in to, and I also appreciated Cosmo's gradual maturation into a less selfish and more empathetic hero. Even the show's style improves – while Ideon's visuals are never what I would call “impressive”, the show's storyboarding and direction becomes noticeably more ambitious as the Solo Ship makes its way further and further into space.

The show isn't perfect by any means. The repetitive and broad scripts are very much a foible of serialized 80s-anime, and the show really suffers in how it characterizes the Buff Clan. While the antagonist force has a small handful of interesting villains to toss our heroes' way, we barely get any real sense of their culture or motivations outside of their one myth of Ide, and their constant referring to themselves as “samurai”. The Buff Clan are bad because the show needs them to be, and by the time Space Runaway Ideon ends it feels like we haven't learned much more about them than we did in the series' first episodes.

Then there's the ending, which truly is a letdown, because it barely even exists. The final episode gives us a limited climax of sorts, and then two minutes before the credits roll the narrator comes in and explains in an incredibly vague manner how things would have ended if the show had the extra four episodes that were originally planned. It finishes Space Runaway Ideon on such a sour note that it threatens to devalue all of the goodwill the show managed to accumulate in spite of its many roadblocks. Thankfully, that ending isn't the one we have to live with, because this Blu-Ray set also gives us the two Ideon movies: A Contact and Be Invoked. To my knowledge, this is the first time the movies have been legally available to own in the U.S.

A Contact is just a recap film, and while it does its best to rearrange and reanimate the most important scenes from the show, it's still trying to cram thirteen hours of story into a ninety-minute run-time. The movie is nice to have for the sake of completion, and it might be useful if you ever need a quick refresher before watching Be Invoked, but that's about it.

Be Invoked is a different beast entirely. While it never quite escapes the aesthetic limitations of its television origins (and budget), this movie is still gorgeous to behold, a radical reshaping of Space Runaway Ideon's original ending that is so good it retroactively makes the entire series better. Be Invoked takes the humanist and anti-war themes that Space Runaway Ideon had always been working with and pushes them to their most confrontational extremes. The series had its moments of shocking violence before, but the movie is grimly devoted to depicting the graphic and cruel apathy of war in all of its senseless death and destruction. It's bit messy in its construction, and the Buff Clan never quite attains the depth of character I think they need for the story to truly sing, but the payoffs to our heroes' relationships and character arcs are equal parts inspiring and heartbreaking. And lest you think that the nihilism might be too much to bear, there's enough joyful optimism on display in the movie's final moments to justify all of the anger and despair that fills the preceding ninety minutes.

Maiden Japan's Blu-Ray set is predictably bare bones – these kinds of collections are historical artifacts meant for a very specific audience, and that they exist at all is enough of a bonus for some fans. Given that the series is nearly forty years old, the sound and picture were bound to be rough no matter the format, but the show's color grading is noticeably improved over what's available on streaming via HIDIVE (at least it looks that way on my devices).

Rating a show like Space Runaway Ideon is always tricky, because the audience for an older series with such a niche appeal will always be relatively limited. While it is far from perfect, I ended up really loving Space Runaway Ideon, warts and all. The quality of Be Invoked was in and of itself enough to cement Ideon as a flawed but earnest passion project in my mind, which I can't help but admire. For a lot of 21st century anime fans, I suspect Space Runaway Ideon might be too janky and repetitive to capture their imaginations. For fans of Tomino's work, or for anyone who enjoys the classic giant robot anime of yore, the Rental I'm giving Space Runaway Ideon comes with my highest recommendation. If you have any interest the anime that have built a small but deserved legacy in the fandom's cultural consciousness, Space Runaway Ideon belongs on your shelf.
-James[TOP]

That wraps up the review section for this week. Thanks for reading!

This week's shelves are from Crisha:

"The-user-formerly-known-as-willag-now-Crisha reporting in to share her collection. And it's probably not going to take you long to notice a few obvious influences and think to yourself that this fan might have a teensy-weensy bit of a small OBSESSIVE PROBLEM. And I really only have two things to say to that.

1. If Princess Tutu actually had a decent selection of fan merchandise, I'd have the other half of my sloped ceiling space dedicated to it alongside my Yuri!!! on Ice merch. As it is, I had to get those two framed artworks commissioned, I bought the DVD box from Paul Champagne, and the book in the background is a fan book of a fanfic released by the author and artist themselves.

2. I conferred with a panel of psychologists, and 9 out of 10 psychologists agree that I fall just shy of the clinical definition of an OBSESSIVE PROBLEM. (Just give it half a year, I'm sure I'll be there by then).

So, yeah, I love Yuri!!! on Ice, particularly Yuuri and Victor. What else is new? Regardless, I take pride in my collection of anime, manga, figures, fanzines, and wall art, and always try my best to display them in an aesthetically pleasing way.

Also, have a picture of a kitty in a box, my darling Willow."

Yuri!!! on Ice is such a good show that having a ton of merch from it qualifies as the exact opposite of a problem. I love the display-style setup of those shelves, thanks for sharing!

This isekai fantasy captured fans' hearts in its first half, but did its first season go out with more of a whimper than a bang? Nick and Andy dissect the disappointment of this series' concluding arc.― That Time I Got Reincarnated as a Slime captured fans' hearts in its first half, but did its first season go out with more of a whimper than a bang? This week, Nick and Andy dissect the disappointme...

This hit series continues its exhilarating run of battles in a volume that demonstrates the stunning impact of shonen manga at its best. Nick Creamer has the details.― Although the Hassaikai assault isn't necessarily My Hero Academia's best arc yet, it's fair to say that it's undoubtedly the manga's most complicated. We're following a half-dozen separate teams representing at least three separate in...

Todd hosts this week and gets to talk about the latest Valkyrie Profile game! Plus a new Zelda, some old Konami classics, Sega memories, and the surprise return of Blaster Master!― Hello, and welcome to another edition of Todd Guest Hosts His Old Column. This week's edition comes on the heels of Sega halting sales of Judgment, a spin-off of the popular Yakuza series, due to Japan's bizarrely draconi...

Why can't we get Netflix anime like Devilman Crybaby or Aggretsuko on bluray in the West? Justin breaks down some of the reasons why.― DarkShadow asked: So, several folks in anime circles are complaining that whenever Netflix gets an anime exclusive (i.e. Little Witch Academia TV series), that anime title is effectively condemned to not be released on home video, like it will never be released on h...

Kim Morrissy explores the legacy of the massively influential cult hit Boogiepop and Others, a supernatural story about adolescent anxieties with an unprecedented impact on the light novel industry.― In 1997, Kouhei Kadono's Boogiepop and Others won the 4th Dengeki Novel Prize (then the Dengeki Game Novel Prize). Despite the publisher's obvious faith in the novel's quality, when the manuscript was p...

This compilation film for the first half of this beloved fantasy anime compresses Made in Abyss' story without losing any of its wonder and charm. Theron Martin has the full story on what was changed in the move to the big screen.― Journey's Dawn is a compilation movie that condenses the first eight episodes of 2017's Made in Abyss TV series into a roughly two-hour story. Its four-minute prologue is...

This experimental comedy anime adapts a 4-panel manga about a free-spirited woman in her twenties into something truly avant-garde. Micchy and Steve explore what makes this collaborative anthology series so special.― Rinshi!! Ekoda-chan adapts a 4-panel manga about a free-spirited woman in her twenties into something truly avant-garde. This week, Micchy and Steve explore what makes this collaborati...

This series of vignettes might not make for a satisfying film when smushed together, but Take Your Marks still offers an enjoyable set of old-fashioned Free! adventures. Nick Creamer has the details.― It's been interesting to watch the Free! franchise grow and transform, the show itself oddly echoing the journeys of its characters. The show's first season focused largely on slice of life and comedy,...

Paul plumbs the psychedelic depths of this alternate-history superhero thriller, along with a breakdown of all this week's new blu-ray releases!― There's apparently a new game in the Fate franchise coming out this week, and I hope it's good. Not because I don't already have a huge gaming backlog to deal with, but because I need an excuse to finally take a break from the Fate smartphone game. A pers...

Mike Toole takes all 8 episodes of Rooster Teeth's ambitious, 3DCG sci-fi mecha action series - starring Creed's Michael B. Jordan - out for a spin.― Many fans of animation and nerd culture around the world revere Rooster Teeth, the Austin-based production studio that began a slow climb to fame back in 2003 with Red vs. Blue, a series of online animated shorts created with the Halo engine about two ...