Clippings

Progress Report: Do Los Angeles' public schools work? L.A.
Weekly investigates in a collection of stories featured in its
December 1-7 issue. First, a group of the newspaper's editors and
writers talk to Roy Romer, the former Colorado governor who became
superintendent of the troubled Los Angeles Unified School District
about six months ago. "We're in such shape, we've got to think of every
idea," Romer says. He reveals his top priorities: "to increase the
ability of teachers to teach and to increase the ability of principals
to manage instruction." One of Romer's ideas is to team up beginning
teachers with experienced, "master teachers" for on-the-job training.
Romer also wants to give LAUSD principals back some of the authority
that has been taken away from them—particularly the power to
assign teachers as they see fit, and not necessarily based on
seniority—and then hold them accountable for what goes on in
their schools. "You can't put principals in charge of schools and hold
them responsible for performance without giving them authority," he
says. The section on education also includes a conversation with a
panel of L.A. teachers and excerpts from Samantha Trumbo Campbell's
1997 journal, in which she chronicles her frustrations as an
uncredentialed first-year teacher in the city's tough South Central
area. On her first day at school, she confesses, "I am terrified." In
November, she writes, "I don't belong here," as she describes her
school's system of playground punishment, in which troublemakers are
forced to walk around the schoolyard perimeter with their hands behind
their backs until recess ends. "I can't shake the prison image." To
Campbell, the district's weekly training program for uncredentialed
teachers is a joke. "I come faithfully," she writes, "but rarely learn
anything I can practically apply in the classroom." As time goes on,
Campbell alternates between "bouts of elation and despair." By the end
of the year, Campbell feels as if she's finally getting somewhere. "To
actually see the children's accomplishments, whether on their papers or
their faces, is enough to keep my hope alive that someday I'll know
what I'm doing, someday I'll live up to those impossible expectations
of what a teacher should be." Burned out after three years of teaching,
Campbell is currently on a one-year leave of absence from the
profession but plans to return.

Schools They Like: In its January/February issue, the
American Enterprise profiles 14 schools "where kids really
learn." The conservative magazine "emphatically did not seek
institutions that turn out all Harvard students," Editor in Chief Karl
Zinsmeister explains in his introduction, but picked schools that "push
kids and demand effort." The public, private, and charter schools on
the list are culturally very different but share common traits: strict
discipline, high standards, a rigorous curriculum, a dress code, an
insistence on patriotism, a sense of purpose, and an emphasis on old-
fashioned virtues and morals. And, lumped together, Zinsmeister
contends, they make an argument for school vouchers: The schools, he
says, offer "a glimpse of how rich and multi-faceted childhood
education could be in a freer world of de-monopolized education."

Notice: We recently upgraded our comments. (Learn more here.) If you are logged in as a subscriber or registered user and already have a Display Name on edweek.org, you can post comments. If you do not already have a Display Name, please create one here.

Ground Rules for Posting
We encourage lively debate, but please be respectful of others. Profanity and personal attacks are prohibited. By commenting, you are agreeing to abide by our user agreement.
All comments are public.