I like it.. but what is "our new feature process"? Is it "Our new feature process" or "our new feature process"?
–
ɥʇǝSJun 27 '13 at 17:15

1

Love it.... but it is just so disappointing to see how close to the top I am (in terms of number of privileges left to earn), but yet I am no where close to getting there. The old way was so much less ... disappointing :-)
–
psubsee2003Jun 27 '13 at 17:15

3

A+, would surprisingly find nothing to complain about again
–
Tim StoneJun 27 '13 at 17:16

I liked the simultaneous percentage counters. Maybe you could add them to the checkmark column for unachieved things.
–
ToomaiJun 27 '13 at 17:23

1

@Toomai I just didn't think it made sense for something that happens as a progression. And we found from user testing that newer users couldn't understand what the percentages meant or why they were all different
–
Jeremy TJun 27 '13 at 17:25

7

Where's the diamond privilege!?!?! For everyone but mods it should say "U CAN NOT HAS CHEEZBURGER".
–
casperOneJun 27 '13 at 17:34

The page looks great overall, but I'm with you. I have no idea what that bar is supposed to represent. My filled-in bit is about twice as long: i.stack.imgur.com/RPkdc.png, and I have a little less than twice as much rep, so that seems to be absolute reputation, but what determined the length of the bar as a whole? Jeff Atwood's rep? Is his bar full?
–
Josh CaswellJun 27 '13 at 19:32

@JoshCaswell The start of the bar is the last privilege you gained, and the end point is the next privilege. (wait never mind, after examining your comment more I have no idea what the bar is supposed to be :P)
–
DoorknobJun 27 '13 at 22:59

2

The zero of the bar was the rep required for your last gained privilege (5k). Anyways, the zero is now... zero (pending deploy).
–
Sklivvz♦Jun 28 '13 at 9:23

I linked the wrong picture in my comment above. This is it: i.stack.imgur.com/pusRM.png So Doorknob's green bar is the 494 rep e has out of the 5000 between 5000 and 10k. I see where that came from now. It's mostly confusing when combined with the text below. I assumed that they were redundant, @Sklivvz; I don't find it at all intuitive that they represent two different measurements.
–
Josh CaswellJun 28 '13 at 19:49

Please also mention the reputation requirement for the privilege in its page, and not just in the summary pages.

I often link directly to the privilege page (mostly to the "comment everywhere" one) in comments, and in the new design there's no way of knowing how much reputation is necessary to earn the privilege (if you land directly on the privilege page).

Well, technically they aren't any links in there. They're all just divisions with hover effects and a hand cursor, and JavaScript detects the click and redirects you. But it does seem odd they chose that path for them...
–
animuson♦Jun 28 '13 at 1:23

Feature Request

I would like to be able to see how much rep I have to gain before I gain each individual privilege. The main page shows how close you are to achieving the next privilege, and each privilege's page shows how close you are to that privilege. However, I miss not being able to see how far I am from each privilege without having to go to one of the individual privilege pages. In the past, this has been implicated as a tooltip.

Feature Request

I posted a feature request relating to privileges, so I will link it here for consistency