Just kidding, you have two ways:
1) Pray the Top Eleven's God: not 100% reliable technics but it can work... sometimes
2) use 4-5-1 V style
-----ST-----
AML-----AMR
---MC--MC--
-----DMC----
DL-DC-DC-DR

The narrow diamond is always a tough nut to crack. I used it exclusively in Levels 2 & 3 & won the League easily. Came a cropper in Level 4 when a couple of flank attacks found me out.

The two formations which I have found give it the most difficulty are 4-5-1V & 4-1-3W-2. I used the 451V last night in an away game & won 2-0 against the narrow diamond. Orders were normal mentality, down both flanks (most important), normal tackling, short passing, zonal, no counter or off side.

Just kidding, you have two ways:
1) Pray the Top Eleven's God: not 100% reliable technics but it can work... sometimes
2) use 4-5-1 V style
-----ST-----
AML-----AMR
---MC--MC--
-----DMC----
DL-DC-DC-DR