Comments

Comment by Golmadin

This kind of suck for those who have already fished up the Sea Turtle......

Comment by Furydeath

I already did like 8k fish so I'm just gonna let my guild work this out.

Comment by Pathospriest

Will the character achievement 1000 fish count for this as well?

If so, you only need 10 leveled fishermen in your guild.

Comment by DLuniz

so your earlier fishing will count towards this?

Comment by Gadiantan

Catch 10,000 fish from fishing pools

Currently this is not tracked.

Only fish caught and fish and other things caught are tracked.

It doesn't seem to distinguish between caught in a pool or not.So does this mean we need to start over at 0 with Cat when they start tracking fish caught in pools instead of open water?I hope not. But I don't see how they can tell the difference. Unless this is being tracked internally now and just not shown to us.

Currently the 1000 Fish achievement describes it self as really only having to fish up 1000 items, not only fish.So maybe it's really Fish up 10,000 items as well.

I was going to try for the Sea Turtle between now and Dec 7 but I don't want all those fish being caught to possibly not count so I guess I'll wait until then just to be sure.

Comment by Benegesserit

I can't wait to link this in trade.

Comment by evenprimes

This is a Guild achievement, so we all start at 0 when GA's are implemented with Cataclysm on December 7.

Comment by arusiasotto

Comment by Kelth

Possible reference to Nostalgia Critic's review of 'Godzilla 1998' where he parodies the line of dialogue, "That's a lot of fish!"

Comment by Lithuen08

I was all excited about this achieve (being the nerd that i am) because I remembered that in northrend you can usually catch 2 fish per pool, cutting the time taken for this in half. Unfortunately blizz was apparently one step ahead of me in this thought because only the actual fish counts...not the pygmy suckerfish as well. Kinda a bummer, but just thought I'd give a warning to anyone who may have been thinking along the same line as me.

Comment by Lautturi

They forgot you don't need bait for pool fishing ;)

Comment by Malix

I havent seen that movie in FOREVER!

"I'll take a pound of nuts..."

lawl

Comment by fadeaway

"That's A Lot of Bait" - Ironically you don't need any Bait and have a 100% success chance at fishing from pools even with a skill of 001.

Comment by smi53

tried on caelstrasz turning auto loot off and casting and catching the fish and not looting it, to see if the pool would not disappear after the 2-4 casts in it. didnt work for me along the coast of westfall but i thought perhaps someone else could try this on pools of blood or wreckages and see if it works. let me know <--- brielene caelstrasz nelf druid

Comment by coreycubed

Of course, the implication is that catching 100,000 fish with fishing poles would require a lot of bait.

Nice catch =)

I was going to downrank this, but... oh... I see what you did there. :)

Comment by anodynex

If you got this achievement off strictly Sealed Crate you'd probably be sitting on a million gold.

Comment by verokast

I caught 90% of the pool fish needed for this guild achievement. The majority of the pool fishing was done in Deepholm, Twilight Highlands, and Uldum. It took a total of 45 hours to catch 9000 pool fish with two toons.

A single fisherman rate of 1.66 fish per minute can be expected under favorable conditions of low pool competition, minimal travel distance between pools, and seldom fighting mobs.

Two toons fishing at the same time can catch an average of 100 fish every half hour. Optimal conditions of zero competition and close pool clusters can yield 120-130 fish every half hour.

Comment by Praetora

Step 1: Take a bunch of people to Borean Tundra.Step 2: Kill an animal and get the blood debuff.Step 3: Jump in the water and spawn a blood pool.Step 4: Let everyone fish there.

Now, using 25+ people expand upon that, those pools count, even though you aren't catching actual fish. With 25 people this makes it take about 3-4 hours. Just have dedicated pool spawners and dedicated fishers.

I came here to ask if anyone knew if the daily quests that makes it so you catch 2 things at once, cuts the time in half. So go to test that part out for me and use that information for yourself.

Good luck with your fishing parties.

Comment by Nastyiam

Hopefully they reduce the amount, I see all the suggestion, but we all know that in most guilds, maybe 3 people if so many fish..

my guild is up to 1000+ and I caught most of those.

Comment by Fishspam

i do this achieve for guilds get paid tons of money and get to keep and sell the fish i make bank because of this.

Comment by smi53

hmm, so u got a toon on allience caelstrasz lolz

Comment by Fishspam

ive done 1 guild so far and im working on my 2nd i have 3 more lined up.

Comment by Cronieock

"That's a lotta fish!"

I wouldn't get this reference if it wasn't for the Nostalgia Critic.

Comment by pierworker

Out of curiosity, could someone clarify if fish caught from schools in the shorelines count for the achievement?

Comment by llastllama

A bunch of players from a guild on our server just got a 72 hour ban for doing this. It is very effect, but apparently considered exploitation. Try this at your own risk.

Comment by kythos

Can I just say how dumb it is that this requires fish from pools when only agi users and tanks want such fish, and everyone else wants open water fish (or not fish at all). /sigh

Comment by kythos

Do you have to have a certain reputation level with the guild before the fish you catch will count?

Comment by 12dogs

i find it especially amusing that you can't find any of the fish required for the recipe for in pools, so you can't even stock up for when you get the recipe

Comment by venjur

I mean it's Blizz's game and they have the final say, but really, how is that an exploit? It's a properly working game mechanic, used en masse....

Comment by Zeen1

Don't forget about trying to catch Pinchy, that's also a wonderful way to waste time while working on this achievement.

Comment by Newnie

I caught a little over 100 Deviate Fish in about 45 minutes. This included travel time between the three ponds.

100/45= 2.2 fish per minute.

Comment by nutasha936

I think that Blizz should make it so that when you are fishin in Borean Tundra (or wherever else) you are fishing and receive more than one item you get credit for ALL of those items, and not just the cast. I think this would encourage people to fish more within their guilds.

NuTasha

Comment by azzeria

This is by far (in my own opinion) the most hateful of all achievements. I hate it, I abo$%^&ely hate it...why you ask? Because fishing is boring, according to my fellow guildmates, PvP is so much more fun. So guess whom is stuck flitting around grumbling to herself while she fishes? Yep...ME!

It's not just grumbline mind you. But for a small guild, catching 10k fish is a bit excessive, since there are some guilds out there that have only 10-15 members in them, would it not be far to say...maybe 5k fish, 7500 fish? For the love of Azeroth...

Just a little addition: what about combining the fish with meat? Say 5k fish, and 5k meat from animals to make a feast? You would still have to grind, but you can at least help out a skinner/LW with their professions if you thrown in a meat combo. Why on earth does Blizz want to give us Mercury poisoning with all this bloody fish? And who knows what Deathwing has been doing in the water....EWWWWWWW

Comment by Mazzic

You can hire a 'fisherman' for this achievement.

Try putting a shout out in trade like "1g paid for each fish fished from pools when you join guild"

I had like 4 replies and now paying 3k to finish the last 3000 fishes after our small 10 man team got bored of the fishing.

Comment by Henderman

Speckled Tastyfish from Tastyfish pools spawned during the STV fishing Tournament count towards this. After the tournament ends the pools stay up for a few hours.

Comment by TrollanGaems

I've been working for this achievement pretty much on my own for our guild off and on. Since no one else fishes it's come to the point that another cook brings the personal +90 foods and hands them out to the raid. I wouldn't mind it so much if only the fish I really cared about came from pools: deepsea sagefish for my mage and lavascale catfish for my paladin. If those 2 had pools I'd gladly fish up the 7k or so left for the achievement, but as it is I'm slowly raising it as I fish for fathom eels and volatile fires.

Comment by vanchak

You just go round the pond fishing in the pools, by the time you've gone round once they've started respawning. sometimes they hadn't so i just killed a mammoth near the water, jumped in and fished in the pool of blood, then carried on with the musselback sculpin pools as they'd respawned :) hope this helps anyone trying to do this achievment quickly

EDIT: Got 63 "things" in just under 15 mins by doing this

Comment by LadyTeaspoon

The easiest pools I found for this achievement are the pools of Deviate Fish. So far, I haven't come across anyone else fishing from those pools. The most fish I caught from a single pool was 12, not many other pools have that many fish in them.

If you want to make some money from your fish:The drop rate for the recipe has increased a lot, and so it's also a lot cheaper to buy from the AH. But the fish themselves still sell for quite a bit on most servers (100 gold per stack on mine), so fishing these is easy and profitable!

Another easy place is Stranglethorn Vale, just run along the coastline and you'll find plenty of fishing pools. The Oily Blackmouths and Firefin Snappers you'll mostly be catching might sell on the AH since they're needed for leveling alchemy.

Enjoy your fishing :)

Comment by LazyRiver

I'm probably the only one...lol....but just in case ANYBODY else did not automatically equate fishing "pools" with "schools".....

You have to fish from a school to get credit.

Comment by Goldpaw

...which is why this is a Guild Achievement, not a character specific raid achievement...

Comment by Centaurian

My guild held a few fishing contests to work towards the new recipe. First one was how many fish can you catch in one hour from level appropriate pools (to make it fair for low level players) using no fishing buffs and no mounts. And the second contest was all out fish no holds barred. The best place to fish is... my best place to fish. Hunters secret. The prize is 1000 gold and the recipe but we didn't get the achievment the first time. This is a great idea for working towards it but the winnings need to be more practicle if you are far from the 10,000 fish mark. I was able to fish 153 in one hour. I will still have to wait until Winter Veil to get the Iron Chef Achievment.

Comment by Klyvanna

I take it that you cannot fish from anywhere, must be some sort of fish school?

Comment by Mesothorny

The pool you fish The Lurker Below from in Serpentshrine Cavern counts for the achievement. If you have an 85 hunter with fishing you can easily sneak your way to the Lurker pool and fish from it until he is caught. Then when he attacks you, feign death. He resets and the pool respawns in about 15 seconds.

Unlike normal pools this one is impossible to miss so you don't have to "aim". You also don't have to fly around looking for one. So if you don't care about getting a sea turtle or any decent fish (it's all sagefish and junk) this is a decent way to work on the achievement if you have the time. You usually get about 1-8 casts before he's summoned. Not sure if this is more time efficient than flying around fishing from pools but I didn't see it mentioned above.

Comment by Vlad

The name "That's a Lot of Bait" reminds me of the phrase "That's a lot of fish" and therefore makes me think of That Guy with the Glasses, episode 175 - Godzilla (1998). I guess I should have thought about Godzilla at first but it wasn't as funny as the Nostalgia Critic review. ;)

*giggles while thinking about the phrase*

Comment by forestsage

A good way to check for good zones to fish in, check the Volatile Water and Crystallized Water pages and then click the "Fished In" tab. Since pretty much all nodes have a chance of droping them it will show you all those nodes in every zone.

Comment by Eclipsegirl

I am soloing this for my 2 person guild.I think I started at around 4500 fish caught before I started working on it. I had been doing fishing tourneys, and had fished up both Mr. Pinchy (the Magical Crawdad), and the Sea Turtle.

I have been doing the fishing in Mt Hyjal, and cooking the fish to get the cooking achievement.

Set a daily goal for yourself, and cook the fish and continue the grind.

By the time I am done, and I am close, I will have spent 3 to 4 weeks fishing and cooking just to get the achievements and recipes. I have also made a decent amount of gold with volatile water and volatile fire.

Comment by anisadora

We got the guild achievement by holding weekly fishing derbies. Mostly we thought smart and used fish that we knew we would need for the recipe once we unlocked it, but occasionally we would throw people off by having them fish something totally random up, such as Deviate Delights.

Comment by ithme

The quickest way to farm this up is to pick up Blood Is Thicker in Dalaran, create pools of blood in Borean Tundra, and amass a large number of guildmates to alternate between spawning numerous pools and fishing from them.

The smart way is to hire fishermen and pay them 1-2 g a fish. Let them keep the fish. What is 10000 to 20000 g to a guild?