California Bill on Police Militarization Reaches Governor’s Desk

California Bill on Police Militarization Reaches Governor’s Desk

Among the many bills awaiting the signature—or veto—of Governor Jerry Brown is AB 3131, a measure that would ensure transparency about police militarization across the State of California. While we are disappointed in recent legislative amendments that weakened the original bill, we remain eager to see it signed into law. Today’s pervasive secrecy about police acquisition of military hardware—including high tech spying devices—impedes a long overdue public debate.

EFF is troubled by the transfer of powerful spying technologies from our armed forces to state and local police.

Police militarization has prompted concerns from across the political spectrum. For instance, progressives and racial justice advocates decry the frequency with which police use force, which all too often has lethal consequences partly driven by the use of military training and equipment. Meanwhile, libertarians and many conservatives with fiscal concerns bemoan spending public tax dollars on expensive weapons (often built by powerful corporations).

EFF is especially troubled by the transfer of powerful spying technologies, built for combat on foreign battlefields, from our armed forces to our state and local police. This phenomenon has proceeded aggressively across California, where law enforcement agencies have gained access to thermal imaging equipment, drones, and sonic crowd control devices worth over $130 million. Currently, police acquisition and use of this equipment is not subject to civilian oversight by any legislative body.

In the face of these concerns, A.B. 3131 would at last ensure transparency in law enforcement acquisition of military equipment. And it would apply to law enforcement agencies generally, including sheriff’s departments that sometimes escape civilian oversight by county boards.

We ultimately hope to establish robust opportunities for community control over whether police agencies may acquire high tech military spying equipment, and not just (as in this bill) transparency when police agencies decide to acquire such equipment. Such community control would have been provided by earlier versions of A.B. 3131. We are disappointed that recent amendments removed this provision, watering down the influence of communities over law enforcement militarization. However, the transparency provided by A.B. 3131—into both the acquisition of military equipment and policies governing its use—pierces the wall of secrecy that has prevented public discussion for entirely too long in far too many places.

Concerns about the role of militarization in undermining our rights were articulated by none other than President Eisenhower, the last President who commanded a wartime army. It may have taken the state legislature over 55 years to respond to his historic speech, but—even though today’s response does not go far enough—late is better than never.

We encourage Governor Brown to sign A.B. 3131 into law, so that Californians across the state can finally learn about how police are acquiring and using military equipment, including powerful spying technologies, in our communities.

Related Updates

It has taken more than a year, but the California Attorney General’s Office has implemented steps to protect immigrants from U.S. Immigration and Customs Enforcement (ICE) and other agencies that abuse the state’s public safety network, the California Law Enforcement Telecommunications System (CLETS). Following calls for reform from EFF and...

The San Francisco Board of Supervisors voted today by 8-to-1 to make San Francisco the first major city in the United States to ban government use of face surveillance technology. This historic measure applies to all city departments. The Stop Secret Surveillance Ordinance also takes an important step toward...

Government use of many surveillance technologies, and especially face surveillance, can invade privacy and chill free speech. It also disproportionately harms already marginalized communities: it increases the likelihood that they will be entangled with police, ICE, and other agencies with a history of abuse, bias, and unlawful violence. San Francisco’s...

To make it easier for everyone to recognize surveillance “in the wild,” EFF is fighting back with Spot the Surveillance, a virtual reality (VR) experience that teaches people how to identify the various spying technologies that police may deploy in communities. And with a major update to the software released...

Thanks to a recent ruling by Fairfax County Circuit Court Judge Robert J. Smith, drivers in Fairfax County, Virginia need not worry that local police are maintaining ALPR records of their travels for work, prayer, protest or play. Earlier this month, Judge Smith ordered an injunction against the use...

Despite Facebook’s repeated warnings that law enforcement is required to use “authentic identities” on the social media platform, cops continue to create fake and impersonator accounts to secretly spy on users. By pretending to be someone else, cops are able to sneak past the privacy walls users put up...

Earlier this week, EFF filed a brief in one of the first cases to consider whether the use of automated license plate reader (ALPR) technology implicates the Fourth Amendment. Our amicus brief, filed in the Ninth Circuit Court of Appeals in United States v. Yang, argues that when...

Emails Prove ICE Could Access Data from Orange County Shopping Malls, Despite the Companies' Denials In response to an ACLU report on how law enforcement agencies share information collected by automated license plate readers (ALPRs) with Immigration and Customs Enforcement, officials have been quick to denyand...

It’s time for governments to confront the harmful consequences of using facial recognition technology as an instrument of surveillance. Yet law enforcement agencies across the country are purchasing face surveillance technology with insufficient oversight—despite the many ways it harms privacy and free speech and exacerbates racial injustice. EFF...