Fans of The Mindy Project know that despite Mindy’s best efforts, her life is far from a perfect romantic comedy. So it’s no surprise that a moment that should be steamy – in this case, a shower with new boyfriend Pastor Casey (Workaholics’ Anders Holm) – takes a turn for the awkward and clumsy. Sandra Bullock would never have to deal with freezing temperatures, water-spouting boyfriends, or bath products that may be trying to kill her.

Check out an exclusive clip from next week’s episode, “Frat Party,” below: