Fans Want Jennifer Lopez to Return to American Idol

Buzz Blabber: Why J Lo Should Return to American Idol

Jennifer Lopez shook things up this week when she mentioned that she may not be returning to American Idol next year. Buzz readers rallied around the new judge, but whether or not she'll renew her contract is still up in the air. In the meantime, check out fan arguments for why Idol needs J Lo, plus more of this week's most talked-about stories.

"She needs to realize that Idol brought life back to her music career and without it she's just going to fade away again." — awesomepants

"I've not watched this season of American Idol regularly, but she seems to be one of the more entertaining judges on the panel. — stone_soup

"Jennifer was a plus to the last season, and hopefully she'll return next year. She and her husband (even their children being included in a commercial with her) seem like an entertainment empire right now. Strike while the iron is hot." — Peachiz

More of this week's topics, including Moneyball and Goldie Hawn's new project when you

"So excited for this movie to come out! The book was really good and well-written, so I'm eager to see what Aaron Sorkin did with it." — gingirl

"I loved the book and can't wait for this movie to be released! It's written by the same author as The Blind Side. I will be there opening weekend!" — NVMolly

"I am not a big fan of sports films but this looks really good. Pitt of course is amazing! He seems to be able to transform himself endlessly. What is really surprising to me is Jonah Hill. He has come a long way from playing the fat kid that was the butt of jokes in teenage party movies. I am excited to see where his career takes him." —Whitfield517

"I'm not sure about the Viagra Diaries thing. It kind of disturbs me..." — pss

"I think that it fits with HBO though even if you're not loving the concept. I don't know how I feel about it but i'm sure that I'll at least check it out since I love when HBO comes up with new shows and I love the team working on it" — ilanac13

"Not loving the whole sound of the Viagra Diaries either...but it does sound very HBO and will be nice to Goldie working again!" — littlemunchkin