PearlJam (on 31 March 2011)To me this game felt like a true sequel to Fallout 2. It has many throw-back references to F2 and they got many elements right like the Brotherhood of Steel, Enclave, NCR, Super Mutants, Raider gangs and they brought back traits and weapon mods. It just felt right, Fallout 3 on the other hand is Fallout in name only.

snuffsaid (on 30 March 2011)Followed Fallout from the beginning(97/98) and this just didnt feel like the Fallout Universe. Graphics are really strugging and the bugs make it unplayable at times.

yog-sothot (on 15 November 2010)Actually, I think THIS is the real Fallout 3. If you have played the original Fallout, I think you can feel it too. Hopefully the bugs will be sorted out soon so the game will be even more awesome

armchair_cynic (on 06 November 2010)Absolutely superb game. It carries over some of Fallout 3s flaws, but takes over so many important cues for improvement. Also, it feels like a genuine Fallout game, rather than an excellent Bethesda tribute. Well done Obsidian, saved my gaming year. Best game released all year by a country mile.

chaos20xx (on 30 October 2010)good game, but not nearly as good as Fallout 3 imo

yahoocom1984 (on 29 October 2010)pots555 , I heard that Bethesda have already released bug-fixed patch for Xbox360 version

yahoocom1984 (on 29 October 2010)The game is amazing, I played it on PC and didn't encounter any bug issues. I'm 19 hours in and only scratch a surface of this game. This game is so large, so many factions, quests and dynamic world. Much better than Fallout 3 for sure

pots555 (on 22 October 2010)If the get around to fixing the bugs, definite buy.

usrevenge (on 22 October 2010)other then a few graphic bugs, some slow downs the game is great, 2 friends said they're files were currupt and lost hours of gameplay but thier fault for not saving often. story is much better then fallout 3, and there are dozens more quests, i havent even scratched the surface and i'm 24 hours in already. wanna spend weeks on a game this is it.

zgamer5 (on 06 May 2010)what this game is not out, how is it in the top 10?

Barozi (on 06 March 2010)Obsidian is a great developer, but they never come close to AAA levels.
Kotor 2, NWN2 were all very good, but not awesome.
Alpha Protocol will fit in there as well I guess.
I still hope New Vegas will be their first AAA game.

Mr Puggsly (on 14 February 2010)Well I never played any of Obsidian's games. But they said it will be like Fallout 3. So it can't be bad.

Reconite (on 10 February 2010)Strategyking, shut it. Obsidian = Black Isle, the guys who made Fallout. It's very unlikely that they can ever screw up anything Fallout related. Bethesda screwed it up for me.

Strategyking92 (on 08 February 2010)please don't screw us like you did with KOTOR2, obsidian...