Turks in Transoxiana. Richard N. Frye

Transkript

1 Turks in Transoxiana Richard N. Frye It is over half a century since my roommate, the late Professor Aydin Sayili, and myself jointly investigated the disputed question of Turks in the Near East in the pre Islamic period. Since that time more information has been gathered about the presence of Altaic speaking nomads in the eastern Iranian cultural area. I use the word Altaic advisedly, and we should examine several propositions before employing the designation Turk. Here I do not wish to enter into controversies about the etymology of one or another word, name or title, but simply to present the most plausible general reconstruction of the presence of peoples in Central Asia in the pre Islamic period. If we rely solely on outside written sources, as indeed we must, to identify the earliest usage of the name Turk then it is not earlier than the sixth century, when the Tu cheh are first mentioned in Chinese sources. They were said to have been living in the Altai mountains, as vassals or subjects of a people called Jouan jouan in Chinese. The latter is obviously an appellative rather than a name, which we do not know. Inasmuch as steppe empires were really confederacies of tribes, we may suppose that a number of tribes comprised the empire of the Jouan jouan, one of which had the name Turk. It is important to review what had happened on the steppes of Inner Asia in the fourth and fifth centuries, to which subject we now turn. At the end of the fourth century on the western steppes, a tribe or horde of nomads appeared, who a few years later were to strike fear into the peoples of western Europe. They were called Huns in the West. Regardless of the controversy, whether or not these people were descendants of those whom the Chinese called Hiung nu, there seems agreement on the fact that the steppes were no longer dominated by the Scythian Sakas, presumably Iranian speakers, but by Huns, who were Altaic speakers. In the political history of the time, the Huns, as usual with the creation of a steppe empire, united various tribes in their confederation, among whom were the Alans or As, presumably those whom the Chinese called Wu sun, and who were living originally in the Ili valley. These Iranian speakers may be the ancestors of the modern Ossetes in the Caucasus. The name Hun, in various forms, came to be used by settled folk for all of the nomads of Inner Asia, as previously they had been called Scythians by the Greeks or Sakas by the

2 Persians. In an account of the siege of the city of Amida by the Sasanian Shapur II in 356 A.C., we are told that Grumbates, king of the Chionites, took part. Since the Byzantine chronicler, Ammianus Marcellinus was on the spot in Amida, he surely was using a contemporary designation for the nomads who were allies of Shapur, and that can only be a form of the general term Hun. Inasmuch as this period ( middle of fourth to sixth centuries) in the history of Central Asia can be called a dark age, with little information about the peoples of Central Asia, we must speculate about the usage chionite in the context of Amida. It has been suggested that Grumbates is an Iranian name, and the Chionites then were Iranian speaking nomads. Few, however, would assert that the word chionite designates Sakas, or other Iranian speaking nomads. Then, it is further claimed, Grumbates assumed the name Chionite for his people, to frighten the enemy with the dreaded name of the Huns. But in the middle of the fourth century in Amida, would Ammianus have known previously of the Huns and the fear they inspired? Hardly; so we may conclude that this was the first time Ammianus heard of that people, and he did not refer to Huns in the same way as his countryman, Priskos did when he wrote about the court of Attila in Central Europe. Therefore we confidently may conclude that there were Hunnic elements in the people, tribe or horde, who were called Chionites, but how many? Was the proportion, 10%, 50% or more? The percentage really does not matter, for obviously the ruling class, or tribe, would be Huns, otherwise why use that name? Can we refer to a formula Huns=Turks? Obviously not, given the nature of steppe tribal organizations. But it would not be amiss to conclude that among the Altaic speakers in the people called Chionite, there were those who later appear with the name Turks, as well, of course, as other tribes. Some linguists might say that we should call these Altaic speakers, proto Turks and/or proto Mongols, and this need not be rejected. But we could ask, in a parallel situation at this time, were the Poles and Czechs differentiated, or should we speak of proto Poles and proto Czechs or just Slavs? In my opinion, if the term altaic speakers is used, we may be closer to the actuality of the past. After the Chionites, in the middle of the fifth century, we hear of another people who came from the east into Transoxiana. According to Chinese and Byzantine sources, they were called Hephthalites, after the name of one of their chiefs. Since their homeland was said to be eastern Turkestan, or present Xinjiang, it is possible that they had fewer Altaic speakers in their confederation than the previous Chionites. This has given rise to controversies, whether they basically were mountaineers from Badakhshan, or nomads from the steppes of Inner Asia. Again one might play a game of numbers or percentages, which is really irrelevant, since obviously both elements, and more, were present in the large state of the Hephthalites, which at first, extended from Xinjiang to the Hindukush Mts., and then later into India. The fact that Latin was used as the lingua franca of western Europe in the Middle Ages, did not mean

3 that all the inhabitants were Romans or Italians. Likewise the use of an Iranian tongue, such as Sogdian and later Persian in Transoxiana, as the written language, does not mean that everyone was a Sogdian who used it. The poet laureate of the republic of Azerbaijan was Nizami, who composed his poetry in Persian. When the Ottoman Sultan Selim wrote to Shah Ismail, he wrote in Persian. In Central Asia always many languages have been used, and any disputes over an exclusive language need to be relegated to the dustbin of ethnic fanaticism. Now we have only spoken of language, for that is the main determinant of identification of a person in the present. In the past, however, especially after the third century of our era, a person came to be identified primarily as the follower of a religion, and this persisted down to the Ottoman Empire and its millet system. But what of the actual background of a person and his locale? Is it important? I believe it has relevance to the question we are discussing. Rather than discussing theoretical questions about identity as race, language, locale, or whatever, in conclusion I simply would like to repeat a story which I have told many times. It has relevance to the above brief discussion and was told to me by a long departed friend, Hans. H. von der Osten, a German excavator of the Hittite capital at Bogaz Kuy. At a reception in the German Embassy he was presented to the guest of honor, Mustafa Kemal Ataturk. The latter congratulated him on excavating the remains of the ancestors of the Turks. Von der Osten was about to protest, when a kick from the ambassador caused him to reply simply, Yes, your Excellency. Afterwards many smirked at what they regarded as a foolish remark of Ataturk, but in my opinion, he was quite correct, for the ancestors of the people of the Turkish republic are both those who always lived in Anatolia, plus the nomads who came from Central Asia and gave their language to everyone. The heritage of the past of Anatolia and of Central Asia both today belong to all of the people of Turkey. This same concept could be applied to other lands and peoples, and not just in the Near East. For sources and references, see Frye, R. and Sayili, A., Turks in the Middle East before the Saljuqs, Journal of the American Oriental Society, Vol. 63 (1943), , and Selklardan Evvel Ortasarkta Turkler, Belleten, 10 (1946),

3 Important Pillars of a website : Sunita Network Pvt Ltd There are numerous advantages of having a website and for business entities, it is must to own a website dedicated to their organization. In such

About QDenetim and QDestek (Sistem Danışmanlık) Sistem Danışmanlık began its operations in 2001 and continues to improve its products and services to enhance its customers' performances and productivity.

Possessive Endings In English, the possession of an object is described by adding an s at the end of the possessor word separated by an apostrophe. If we are talking about a pen belonging to Hakan we would

Chingiz Garasharly The Turkic Civilization lost in the Mediterranean basin Baku 2011 Leading adviser: Academic editor: Kamran Imanov Professor, Chairman of Copyright Agency of the Republic of Azerbaijan

Just Enough ENGLISH GRAMMAR Illustrated Gabriele Stobbe New York Chicago San Francisco Lisbon London Madrid Mexico City Milan New Delhi San Juan Seoul Singapore Sydney Toronto Copyright 2008 by Gabriele

The Economy and the Power of Money Dr. Hasan ALPAGU 1 Abstract This paper is an attempt to bring light into relations between economic developments and the developments in the society. The key and fundamental

International Science Index, Humanities and Social Sciences Vol:6, No:10, 2012 waset.org/publication/6169 Abstract In this article, the authors reviewed and analyzed the survey materials similarities ornament

A Missionary Society at the Crossroads: American Missionaries on the eve of the Turkish Republic 1 İdris YÜCEL Hacettepe University YÜCEL, İdris, A Missionary Society at the Crossroads: American Missionaries

VIRTUAL MUSEUM and REVIEW OF VIRTUAL MUSEUMS IN TURKEY Research Assistant Arzu Cilasun, Yasar University, Department of Architecture arzu.cilasun@yasar.edu.tr Museums can be defined in many different ways.

İDRİS YÜCEL AN OVERVIEW OF RELIGIOUS MEDICINE IN THE NEAR EAST: MISSION HOSPITALS OF THE AMERICAN BOARD IN ASIA MINOR (1880-1923) İdris Yücel Hacettepe University, The Ataturk Institute for Modern Turkish

"IF CLAUSE KALIPLARI" am / is / are doing have / has done can / have to / must / should be to do was / were did, was / were to do was / were doing had to do should do had done had been doing had had to

This page intentionally left blank English Grammar Understanding the Basics Looking for an easy-to-use guide to English grammar? This handy introduction covers all the basics of the subject, using a simple

ZfWTVol. 8 No. 1 (2016) 221-238 THE MILITARY COUP ON 28 MARCH 1962 IN SYRIA AND PROPAGANDA BROADCASTS ON DAMASCUS RADIO ABOUT THE COUP Savaş SERTEL Sabri MENGİRKAON Abstract: Located in the Middle East,

Design and Implementation of a Microcontroller Based LCD Screen Digital Stop Watch Mr. Khalid I. Saad, Ms. Nusrat Afrin and Mr. Rajib Mikail Abstract The stop watch is used to measure the time required

Concentrating Solar Power Gerry Wolff, Coordinator of DESERTEC-UK, explains how concentrating solar power could become a major source of clean energy for most of the world. Introduction Sunset at Kramer

The Economy of Conflicts Hasan ALPAGU Any behavior of individuals and the change in the society have consequences and these consequences lead to tangible effects and costs. The migration and refugees also

The Conflict s Economy Dr. Hasan ALPAGU Any behavior of individuals and the change in the society have consequences and these consequences lead to tangible effects and costs. The migration and refugees

Menopause: The Journal of The North American Menopause Society Vol. 21, No. 2, pp. 000/000 DOI: 10.1097/gme.0b013e3182937966 * 2013 by The North American Menopause Society Frequency and determinants of

Going Home 02: At a Duty-free Shop Hi! How are you today? Today s lesson is about At a Duty-free Shop. Let s make learning English fun! Eve Dönüş 02: Duty-free Satış Mağazasında Exercise 1 Vocabulary and

EVALUATION OF TURKEY'S FOREIGN TRADE COMPOSITION AFTER 1980 ACCORDING TO THE COUNTRIES ABSTRACT In this study, It was tried to analyse effects of growth rate of Turkey, EU and the World country economies,

Lesson 12 One Crazy Story Turkish Tea Time turkishteatime.com Made with love. Ever have one of those nights? You know, the kind you can't wait to tell all your Turkish friends about the next day? Before

European International Journal of Science and Technology Vol. 4 No. 1 January, 2015 Science and the Importance of the Scientific Approach Dr. Hasan ALPAGU 1 Abstract The objective of this article is to

WOULD FUTURE in PAST [1] (geçmişteki gelecek) [past of WILL] He said he would be She hoped (that) we would com I thought that he would ref WILLINGNESS (gönüllülük) She would not The car would not POLITE

İNGİLİZCE SORU CÜMLELERİ What are you cooking, Fatma Hanım? What is it, Mrs. Miller? What do you want? What is his name? What have you in your basket? What can I do for you? What is the meaning of Topkapı

1. Planned future actions (Planlanmış gelecek zaman etkinlikleri) We use it to express a future decision, intention, or plan made before the moment of speaking (Konuşma anından daha önce düşünülmüş kararlar,

The Supporting People Logo Insanlari ve bagimsiz yasami destekleme The Supporting People Door in Watermark The Supporting People Introduction Helping you to live more independently Daha bagimsiz yasamak

BackPage Press Copyright Andrea Pirlo and Alessandro Alciato, 2013 English translation copyright Mark Palmer, 2014 All rights reserved The moral right of the author has been asserted First published in

International Journal of Health Sciences and Research www.ijhsr.org ISSN: 2249-9571 Original Research Article The Effects of Simulation Training on Identifying Cardiopulmonary Health Problems Eylem TOPBAŞ

Who is this book for? Introduction This book has been written for students who are planning to take the Cambridge First Certificate in English (the FCE) and who want to develop their vocabulary for the

1 4 The price of a book is first raised by 20 TL, and then by another 30 TL. In both cases, the rate of increment is the same. What is the final price of the book? 60 80 90 110 120 2 3 5 Tim ate four more

An introduction to Turkish Who speaks Turkish? Approximately 70 million inhabitants of Turkey. A few million people in Northern Cyprus, Bulgaria, Romania and other parts of the Balkans. A few million members

Lesson 31: Interrogative form of Will Ders 31: Will kalıbının soru biçimi Reading (Okuma) Will it be sunny tomorrow? (Yarın güneşli mi olacak?) Will you lend her the car? (Arabayı ödünç verecek misin?)

Originally appeared in: Language in time and space. A Festschrift for Werner Winter on the occasion of his 80th birthday, edd. Brigitte L.M. Bauer, Georges-Jean Pinault, Berlin - New York 2003, 257-269

Lesson 29: "It" in Various Usages Ders 29: "It" Zamirinin Farklı Kullanımları Reading (Okuma) What time is it now? It s eight thirty. (Şu an saat kaç? Sekiz buçuk.) What day of the week is it today? It