Dislikes: They fit HORRIBLY. I own four other pairs of RS full seat breeches in the same size, all of which fit me very well. I couldn't even pull these all the way up, and I suspect that if I had been able to get them all the way up, the waist would have been about at my boobs, and about 10 inches too big. If you have a long rise and narrow hips/thighs/not much of a waist, they may fit you okay, but if you have a figure, look elsewhere for your winter breeches.

Quality: If they're anything like my other RS breeches, they should last a LONG time.

Summary: Great fabric and construction, terrible fit. I don't know why they didn't use the same fit model as the other RS breeches.