"It’s a large scope story told in a small way with some of the best writing I could ever imagine... an explanation of the Universe’s tendency to make life fall apart. The Diary of Preston Plummer is nearing perfection." - Napierslogs' Movie Expositions

"The crowning achievement of the film is the cinematography and direction. It is evident Sean Ackerman loves the setting of the Florida coast. He lingers on the sunsets and beach landscapes in a way that makes the film’s setting the sixth actor. He makes the film beautiful in a way that not every director with the same script would or could." - Sarah Ksiazek, Lost in Reviews