rick, i understand where your coming from but he does have ability, still scoring for Keighley now and got 3 tries for sheffield against wigan in a cup tie not so long ago.I think the problem with wingers is they dont get any quality passes on that pitch.

Barnett was given 4 out of 10 recently for Keighley, the lowest of all the team!

It is far better to remain silent and be thought a fool
than to open your mouth and prove that you are.

For me , our best winger was Ronnie Sulipa, the tall,strong and fast new Zealander who played at the dogtrack.
He scored two great tries at Headingly against Leeds in a game, which was played on a Boxing Day. Think it was a league game.

Also remember he played in a game opposite Des Drummond the Leigh/Great Britain winger, and knocked him all over the place,we beat Leigh that day Sulipa scoring again. Des Drummond was known as a hard man in Rugby League, but met his match in Sulipa.

The other winger for me has to be Richard Baker , not as big and powerfull as Sulipa , but fast, heart like a lion , tackle anyone far above his weight, never stopped working. he got a few tries off Manson's perfect chip over the top kicks.

I remember Suilipa. I think he was a New Zealand international and it was a real shame he only stayed with us for one season. I'd say the best wing combination would be him and Muscroft but Kingston, who like those two is from the Greyhound stadium days would run them pretty close.