is he glad she smokes tobacco? that she buys cigarettes? that she carries means of lighting cigarettes? if she carried cigarettes but never smoked them would he still be glad? if she held a cigarette to her mouth but did not light it would he still be glad? if she lit it but did not inhale? if she took one puff then put it out? if she carried them and offered them to other people?

is the type of cigarette relevant? the colour? the size? is it relevant whether she uses matches? a lighter?

would he still be glad if she only smoked cigs that someone gave her? is it relevant how many she smokes? is he glad on many occasions? just one?

does her smoking give him a benefit? cause him not to lose a benefit?

is he glad for his own sake? for hers? for someone else's?

is their relationship relevant? are they romantically involved? married? friends? colleagues? is he glad that she has to go outside to take smoking breaks? is a smoking ban in public places relevant? in workplaces?

Posted on Wednesday, October 04, 2006 - 10:20 pm: is he glad she smokes tobacco? yes that she buys cigarettes?irrel that she carries means of lighting cigarettes? irrelif she carried cigarettes but never smoked them would he still be glad? no if she held a cigarette to her mouth but did not light it would he still be glad? no if she lit it but did not inhale?no if she took one puff then put it out? possible but unlikely if she carried them and offered them to other people?irrel

is the type of cigarette relevant? no the colour? no the size? nois it relevant whether she uses matches? no a lighter? no

would he still be glad if she only smoked cigs that someone gave her? yesis it relevant how many she smokes? yesishis he glad on many occasions? no just one? yope

does her smoking give him a benefit? yes cause him not to lose a benefit? yesish

is he glad for his own sake? yesfor hers? no for someone else's? no

is their relationship relevant? yes are they romantically involved? no married? no friends? no colleagues? nois he glad that she has to go outside to take smoking breaks? yesis a smoking ban in public places relevant?yope in workplaces?yope

Would it work if she smoked a pipe? If she suffered from some medical condition which meant she had to go outside for 10 minutes every few hours? Does he smoke? Does he get to see her more often because she smokes? Does he enjoy seeing her? Does he get some benefit from seeing her? Is it relevant where this takes place? Is her profession relevant? Is she at work when she takes smoking breaks? Does she work in a hospital? Hotel?

Posted on Friday, October 06, 2006 - 10:21 am: Does her taking smoking breaks allow him time alone to check out the latest LTPF? Nice idea, but no Bentarm (Bentarm) New member Username: Bentarm

Post Number: 949 Registered: 6-2001

Posted on Saturday, October 07, 2006 - 1:13 pm: Would it work if she smoked a pipe? yes If she suffered from some medical condition which meant she had to go outside for 10 minutes every few hours?much less likely to work Does he smoke? irrelDoes he get to see her more often because she smokes? no Does he enjoy seeing her? unlikely Does he get some benefit from seeing her? Is it relevant where this takes place? yesIs her profession relevant? no Is she at work when she takes smoking breaks? yope Does she work in a hospital? no Hotel? no

Does she do voluntary work? Does she have a job at all? Does she have any relevant medical conditions? Is her religion relevant? politics? ethnicity? gender? Would this puzzle work just as well if she were a man?

Posted on Sunday, October 08, 2006 - 4:06 pm: Does she do voluntary work? no Does she have a job at all? yope & yopeishly relevant Does she have any relevant medical conditions? yope Is her religion relevant? no politics? no ethnicity?\ b{ no} gender? no Would this puzzle work just as well if she were a man? yes

Is she inside some building when she takes smoking breaks? Is he inside the same building? Does their relationship result in them seeing each other every day? Every week? Every month? regularly? Or on a fairly random basis? Does she have a similar relationship with any other people? Lots of other people? Does he? Is her relationship with him related to her "yopeish" work? Does she get paid for doing some service for some other people?

Posted on Sunday, October 08, 2006 - 8:32 pm: Is she inside some building when she takes smoking breaks? irrel Is he inside the same building? dittoDoes their relationship result in them seeing each other every day? yesish Every week? no Every month? no regularly? yes Or on a fairly random basis? noDoes she have a similar relationship with any other people?noish Lots of other people? no Does he?noishIs her relationship with him related to her "yopeish" work? Does she get paid for doing some service for some other people? yes--find out what it is!!!!!!!

Posted on Monday, October 09, 2006 - 8:32 am: Thinking about their relationship; Is it professional?no (ish?)Personal trainer and trainee? noCoach and some sort of team member? noDriver and passenger? noDoes Kent employ Chrystal? noDoes Chrystal employ Kent? no

is it a necessary service to do with food? drink? cigarettes? does she sell something? buy something? does she touch her clients? do they touch her? does she make her clients feel better? happier? safer? after an interaction with her do they posses something they didn't before? have they lost something they had before? do they pay her? does she get paid by the state? by an employer? by her clients?

does she work in retail? in law enforcement? in medicine? healthcare related? in entertainment? in the armed forces? in an office? in finance? in a factory? in education? academia?

is it a necessary service to do with food?no drink? no cigarettes? no does she sell something? no buy something? no does she touch her clients? no do they touch her? no does she make her clients feel better? yope happier? yope safer? yope after an interaction with her do they posses something they didn't before? yope have they lost something they had before? yope do they pay her? no does she get paid by the state? yes by an employer? see [previous answer by her clients? no

does she work in retail? no in law enforcement? noish in medicine? no healthcare related? no in entertainment? no in the armed forces? no in an office? no in finance? no in a factory? no in education? no academia? no

is she concerned with the way people look? noish a hairdresser? no beautician? no

So she has a yopeish job, but is paid by the state to do some service for people...? Does she do the service for lots of people at once (eg, gives a lecture)? for one person at once? (eg, counselling?) Does she go to people's houses to perform this service? Does she do a service for people accused of crimes? For people who have been victims of crimes? Does she encounter police officers during the course of her work? lawyers? other court officials? Does she help to prevent crimes in any way?

Posted on Sunday, October 15, 2006 - 5:41 pm: So she has a yopeish job, but is paid by the state to do some service for people...? yesDoes she do the service for lots of people at once yes (eg, gives a lecture not that)? for one person at once? no (eg, counselling?) Does she go to people's houses to perform this service? noDoes she do a service for people accused of crimes? yope For people who have been victims of crimes? yes Does she encounter police officers during the course of her work? possibly lawyers? yes other court officials? yesDoes she help to prevent crimes in any way? yope or yesiahKdoc (Kdoc) New member Username: Kdoc

Post Number: 688 Registered: 7-2001

Posted on Sunday, October 15, 2006 - 9:39 pm: is she a traffic warden? no

Does she perform this service in a court? Does she talk to people who have been the victims of crimes? Give them some sort of counselling? Is she present in the courtroom at any point? Does she ever talk to the people who've committed crimes?

Posted on Thursday, October 19, 2006 - 4:57 pm: Does she perform this service in a court? yes Does she talk to people who have been the victims of crimes? no Give them some sort of counselling? noIs she present in the courtroom at any point? yes Does she ever talk to the people who've committed crimes? no

Posted on Monday, October 23, 2006 - 10:10 pm: does she record the court proceedingsno (not sure what you call that person - the one you see typing in the corner in courtroom films) In the US, it's a court reporter

Posted on Monday, October 23, 2006 - 11:54 pm: Did she provide this service during office hours? yesDid she provide this service when a trial was in progress?yesishIs she involved in a trial?yesIs he involved in a trial? yes

is 'she' the plaintiff? seeking damages from someone/company, but because she smokes, whatever claim she had against the person/company is negated or casts doubt as to the person/company being the cause of her 'sickness? 'loss'?

Posted on Monday, October 30, 2006 - 9:29 pm: Is she a witness to something? noSenorina_illuminata (Senorina_illuminata) New member Username: Senorina_illuminata

Post Number: 92 Registered: 9-2006

Posted on Tuesday, October 31, 2006 - 4:05 am: is 'she' the plaintiff? noseeking damages from someone/company, but because she smokes, whatever claim she had against the person/company is negated or casts doubt as to the person/company being the cause of her 'sickness? no'loss'? no

Posted on Thursday, November 02, 2006 - 6:20 pm: Since she is the court reporter, any "smoke" breaks she would take would necessitate a court recess no, I said she's NOT the court reported--see above!!... is this relevant? But smoke breaks are relevant

Senorina_illuminata (Senorina_illuminata) New member Username: Senorina_illuminata

Post Number: 96 Registered: 9-2006

Posted on Wednesday, November 08, 2006 - 3:13 am: are they both physically in the same place? yopei mean, for example, one person is in the actual courtroom, the other appears in the court room via videolink? both have been in court at the same time

Ok, I know some of these have been asked, but to figure out her role in the courtroom, is she: An attorney? Defense attorney? Prosecuting attorney? Judge? Juror? Witness? Victim? Plaintiff? Defendant? Baliff? Legal secretary? Audience member (if thats what you'd call it)?

Same questions for him.

Is it relevant what case is being held in court when they are there? Is it relevant whether it is a civil or criminal case? If so, is it civil? Criminal?

Posted on Thursday, November 09, 2006 - 9:10 pm: Ok, I know some of these have been asked, but to figure out her role in the courtroom, is she: An attorney? Defense attorney? Prosecuting attorney? Judge? Juror? Witness? Victim? Plaintiff? Defendant? Baliff? Legal secretary? Audience member (if thats what you'd call it)? She is a juror & he is a defendantSame questions for him.

Is it relevant what case is being held in court when they are there? see previous & subsequent answers, which are relevantIs it relevant whether it is a civil or criminal case?I'm sure this would work for a criminal trial. I don't know much about civil trials, since they don't occur on "Law & Order" If so, is it civil? see previous answer Criminal?see previous answer but one

Is he happy about one particular smoke break she takes? Does she discover/realize something about the defendant when she goes outside? Does she discover/realize something about the case when she goes outside? If so, could she realize it if she was outside, but not smoking?

Posted on Thursday, November 09, 2006 - 9:10 pm: Ok, I know some of these have been asked, but to figure out her role in the courtroom, is she: An attorney? Defense attorney? Prosecuting attorney? Judge? Juror? Witness? Victim? Plaintiff? Defendant? Baliff? Legal secretary? Audience member (if thats what you'd call it)? She is a juror & he is a defendant Same questions for him.

Is it relevant what case is being held in court when they are there? see previous & subsequent answers, which are relevant Is it relevant whether it is a civil or criminal case?I'm sure this would work for a criminal trial. I don't know much about civil trials, since they don't occur on "Law & Order" If so, is it civil? see previous answer Criminal?see previous answer but one Puzzlicious (Puzzlicious) New member Username: Puzzlicious

Post Number: 11 Registered: 11-2006

Posted on Thursday, November 09, 2006 - 11:36 pm: Is he happy about one particular smoke break she takes? noDoes she discover/realize something about the defendant when she goes outside? noDoes she discover/realize something about the case when she goes outside? noIf so, could she realize it if she was outside, but not smoking?N/A

Does he gain some benefit from her smoking? From her taking smoke breaks? Does he percieve some benefit that doesn't necessarily exist from her smoking? From the smoke breaks?

Does her smoking lead to recesses being called for that wouldn't otherwise be called? Relevant?

Relevant how often the smoke breaks occur? How long they last?

quote:

is he glad that she smokes then just because this means she has to take smoking breaks? yesish

Is there another aspect of her smoking that is relevant? Another aspect about the smoke breaks? Or is the ish because the smoke breaks allow for something else to happen (which perhaps is what ultimately makes him glad)?

Is there another aspect of her smoking that is relevant? see next answer Another aspect about the smoke breaks? yesish Or is the ish because the smoke breaks allow for something else to happen (which perhaps is what ultimately makes him glad)? no

Does anyone else take smoke breaks with her? no Relevant? yesish--there's still a false assumption, I think

Posted on Monday, November 13, 2006 - 9:08 pm: Does she get to take smoke breaks? no Or is she forced to stay in court causing her to become agitated and not pay attention to the case? yesish or yope--you're ORT (on the right track)

Were the jury undecided on a verdict the outcome of the trialwhich could have been unfavourable for the man, and due to the nature of the crime it required a unanimous decision? Did the woman make her decision based on the fact that she needed a smoke, rather than whether she thought him guilty or ot? Was the oucome of her decision favouable to the man?

Posted on Monday, November 13, 2006 - 11:14 pm: Were the jury undecided on a verdict the outcome of the trialwhich could have been unfavourable for the man, and due to the nature of the crime it required a unanimous decision? yesDid the woman make her decision based on the fact that she needed a smoke, rather than whether she thought him guilty or ot? yesWas the oucome of her decision favouable to the man? no

BLOOOPRERRRRRRRALERTTTT!Did the woman make her decision based on the fact that she needed a smoke, rather than whether she thought him guilty or ot? yes Was the oucome of her decision favouable to the man? no The last answer should be yopeMartinfg (Martinfg) New member Username: Martinfg

Post Number: 286 Registered: 8-2005

Posted on Monday, November 13, 2006 - 11:42 pm: So although he is glad she smokes yes, her decision to smoke did not produce a favourable result for him?yope--see above BLOOOOOPERALERTTTTTTTTTTTT!!! is this correct?see above

Posted on Wednesday, November 15, 2006 - 9:42 am: This could get a bit confusing now but; Did the jury on the whole before her input find him guilty? Not Guilty? the jury found him guiltyDid her decision cause an early end to the trial? or the trial to be continued? her desire for a smoke break caused an early end to the jury deliberation

Did she vote not guilty resulting in a hung jury? Which could be good or bad for him depending on the retrial, hence the yope? Is he glad that she smokes because had she not wanted a smoke break she might have stayed longer debating the verdict and they might have convinced her to vote guilty?

Posted on Wednesday, November 15, 2006 - 4:54 pm: Did she vote not guilty resulting in a hung jury? no. see above. The jury found him guilty Which could be good or bad for him depending on the retrial, hence the yope? a retrail is relevant--that's a BIG HINT!!!!!Is he glad that she smokes because had she not wanted a smoke break she might have stayed longer debating the verdict and they might have convinced her to vote guilty? no

Posted on Wednesday, November 15, 2006 - 6:03 pm: Is he able to use her rushing the verdict for a smoke break as grounds for appeal? YES!!!!! **** SPOILER ************Alfred is glad Crystelle is a smoker because, after he was found guilkty, she said she wasn't able to take a smoke break during jury deliberations & so agreed to a guilty verduct because she was so desperate to get out of the jury room & have a smoke. Thanks for sdticking with it, everyone, & for solving it, Beccann, & please check out my new puzzle at the bottom of the page

Add Your Message Here

Post:

Username:

Posting Information:
This is a private posting area. Only registered users and moderators may post messages here.