Rogan always gets a hard on for Frankie. HE is one of the only fighters that i wish Rogan wasn't there to commentate for their fights. Aldo could literally land a 10 piece combo and Frankie lands a leg kick and Rogan will act like Frankie didn't just get hit by 10 punches and that the leg kick was a knockout punch

Can you provide a breakdown of how the overall tally is misleading based on analysis of round by round statistics?

Personally, I look at the round by round statistics and still come up with Aldo winning, the same result I come up with looking at the overall tally and the same result I came up with watching the fight.

Can you provide a breakdown of how the overall tally is misleading based on analysis of round by round statistics?

Personally, I look at the round by round statistics and still come up with Aldo winning, the same result I come up with looking at the overall tally and the same result I came up with watching the fight.

The statistics for round 3, 4, and 5 show Frankie outlanding Aldo in each round and getting a takedown in one of them, so presumably just looking at the statistics you would have Frankie 3 rounds to 2.. How do the round by round statistics make you come up with Aldo winning?

I have Aldo winning 123 with Edgar winning 45. 5 could have gone either way. I think the superman punch at the end could have sealed the deal for the judges but idk. Great fight and hope to see Edgar back again. I think 135-145 are good classes for him to float around in. WAR EDGAR and WAR ALDO!

Chris27 - Yeah I always defend Rogan on commentary but he was riding Frankies nuts so hard in that 5th round, ignoring everything Aldo did.

True, but he's human. Sometimes our emotions get the best of us, not the end of the world. There's a chance he was trying to make it more suspenseful for the casual viewer.

It's pretending the fight was that close that's really ridiculous, even to the point of essentially pulling from Frankie's mouth that he thought he won the fight. Really ridiculous but I guess they feel the need to do something after two potential big money fights went down the toilet tonight.

Can you provide a breakdown of how the overall tally is misleading based on analysis of round by round statistics?

Personally, I look at the round by round statistics and still come up with Aldo winning, the same result I come up with looking at the overall tally and the same result I came up with watching the fight.

The statistics for round 3, 4, and 5 show Frankie outlanding Aldo in each round and getting a takedown in one of them, so presumably just looking at the statistics you would have Frankie 3 rounds to 2.. How do the round by round statistics make you come up with Aldo winning?

The statistics (FightMetric) show Aldo out-landing strikes to the head in all five rounds. In rounds 3 through 4, Edgar out-landed Aldo with strikes to the legs 21 to 2 (10 of which were not ruled power strikes), yet in watching the fight, Aldo's attack on Edgar's legs was clearly more effective than was Edgar's on Aldo's. The same can be said with strikes to the head. Aldo out-landed Edgar in power strikes to the head in 3 of 5 rounds, but was only edged out by 1 and 2 strikes (4 to 5 in rd 3, and 1 to 3 in rd 4) respectively. The rounds in which he out-landed Edgar with power strikes to the head he did so by a wider margin (6 to 2 in rd 1, 8 to 3 in rd 2, and 6 to 3 in rd 5). With non-power strikes (called jabs on FightMetric), Aldo out-landed Edgar in every single round (12 to 0 in rd 1, 7 to 0 in rd 2, 10 to 3 in rd 3, 3 to 0 in rd 4, and 8 to 5 in rd 5). As for body strikes, there was significantly less volume and few significant strikes. Edgar out-landed Aldo with 1 non-power in rd 1 (to 0), 2 non-power in rd 2 (to 0), 3 power and 1 non in rd 3 (to 0), was out-landed 2 power to 1 (and no non) in rd 4, and 5 power and 1 non in rd 5 (to 0). Edgar succeeded in 2 takedowns out of 11 attempts, and each of those were immediately reversed, Aldo managing to get back to his feet without consequence.

Aldo out-landed Edgar rather significantly and out-grappled him, keeping the fight on the feet where he was winning despite Edgar's efforts. Edgar turned the tide later into the fight as Aldo slowed, but Aldo out-performed him. That's my analysis of the data. At first, I had my tally sheet with Aldo winning rounds 1, 2, and 3, and Edgar winning rounds 4 and 5, but after reevaluating the data, I now have come to the conclusion that Aldo won rounds 1, 2, 3, and 5, and Edgar won round 4. The data also suggests Aldo may have taken a 10-8 round, but I think that's not quite accurate.

Can you provide a breakdown of how the overall tally is misleading based on analysis of round by round statistics?

Personally, I look at the round by round statistics and still come up with Aldo winning, the same result I come up with looking at the overall tally and the same result I came up with watching the fight.

The statistics for round 3, 4, and 5 show Frankie outlanding Aldo in each round and getting a takedown in one of them, so presumably just looking at the statistics you would have Frankie 3 rounds to 2.. How do the round by round statistics make you come up with Aldo winning?

The statistics (FightMetric) show Aldo out-landing strikes to the head in all five rounds. In rounds 3 through 4, Edgar out-landed Aldo with strikes to the legs 21 to 2 (10 of which were not ruled power strikes), yet in watching the fight, Aldo's attack on Edgar's legs was clearly more effective than was Edgar's on Aldo's. The same can be said with strikes to the head. Aldo out-landed Edgar in power strikes to the head in 3 of 5 rounds, but was only edged out by 1 and 2 strikes (4 to 5 in rd 3, and 1 to 3 in rd 4) respectively. The rounds in which he out-landed Edgar with power strikes to the head he did so by a wider margin (6 to 2 in rd 1, 8 to 3 in rd 2, and 6 to 3 in rd 5). With non-power strikes (called jabs on FightMetric), Aldo out-landed Edgar in every single round (12 to 0 in rd 1, 7 to 0 in rd 2, 10 to 3 in rd 3, 3 to 0 in rd 4, and 8 to 5 in rd 5). As for body strikes, there was significantly less volume and few significant strikes. Edgar out-landed Aldo with 1 non-power in rd 1 (to 0), 2 non-power in rd 2 (to 0), 3 power and 1 non in rd 3 (to 0), was out-landed 2 power to 1 (and no non) in rd 4, and 5 power and 1 non in rd 5 (to 0). Edgar succeeded in 2 takedowns out of 11 attempts, and each of those were immediately reversed, Aldo managing to get back to his feet without consequence.

Aldo out-landed Edgar rather significantly and out-grappled him, keeping the fight on the feet where he was winning despite Edgar's efforts. Edgar turned the tide later into the fight as Aldo slowed, but Aldo out-performed him. That's my analysis of the data. At first, I had my tally sheet with Aldo winning rounds 1, 2, and 3, and Edgar winning rounds 4 and 5, but after reevaluating the data, I now have come to the conclusion that Aldo won rounds 1, 2, 3, and 5, and Edgar won round 4. The data also suggests Aldo may have taken a 10-8 round, but I think that's not quite accurate.

Reply Post

“This is the official website of the Mixed Martial Arts llc. Commercial
reproduction, distribution or transmission of any part or parts of this website
or any information contained therein by any means whatsoever without the prior
written permission is not permitted.”