Did clay hydrogels ‘host’ the first life on Earth?

The researchers, working on cheaper hydrogels for protein production, realized that what they had discovered might answer a long-standing question about how biomolecules evolved. (Credit: "clay" via Shutterstock)

Clay might have been the birthplace of life on Earth, or at least of the complex biochemicals that make life possible, report biological engineers.

“We propose that (in early geological history) clay hydrogel provided a confinement function for biomolecules and biochemical reactions,” says Dan Luo, professor of biological and environmental engineering and a member of the Kavli Institute at Cornell for Nanoscale Science.

[related]

In simulated ancient seawater, clay forms a hydrogel—a mass of microscopic spaces capable of soaking up liquids like a sponge. Over billions of years, Luo explains, chemicals confined in those spaces could have carried out the complex reactions that formed proteins, DNA, and eventually all the machinery that makes a living cell work.

Clay hydrogels could have confined and protected those chemical processes until the membrane that surrounds living cells developed, he says.

Why clay?

The Luo group previously has used synthetic hydrogels as a “cell-free” medium for protein production. Fill the spongy material with DNA, amino acids, the right enzymes, and a few bits of cellular machinery and you can make the proteins for which the DNA encodes, just as you might in a vat of cells.

To make the process useful for producing large quantities of proteins, such as for drug manufacturing, you need a lot of hydrogel, so the researchers set out to find a cheaper way to make it. Postdoctoral researcher Dayong Yang noticed that clay formed a hydrogel. Why consider clay? “It’s dirt cheap,” says Luo. Better yet, it turned out unexpectedly that using clay enhanced protein production.

But then it occurred to the researchers that what they had discovered might answer a long-standing question about how biomolecules evolved. Experiments by the late Carl Sagan and others have shown that amino acids and other biomolecules could have been formed in primordial oceans, drawing energy from lightning or volcanic vents.

But in the vast ocean, how could these molecules come together often enough to assemble into more complex structures, and what protected them from the harsh environment?

Matching timelines

Scientists previously suggested that tiny balloons of fat or polymers might have served as precursors of cell membranes. Clay is a promising possibility because biomolecules tend to attach to its surface, and theorists have shown that cytoplasm—the interior environment of a cell—behaves much like a hydrogel. And, Luo says, a clay hydrogel better protects its contents from damaging enzymes (called “nucleases”) that might dismantle DNA and other biomolecules.

As further evidence, geological history shows that clay first appeared (as silicates leached from rocks), just at the time biomolecules began to form into protocells—cell-like structures, but incomplete—and eventually membrane-enclosed cells. The geological events matched nicely with biological events.

How these biological machines evolved remains to be explained, Luo says. For now his research group is working to understand why a clay hydrogel works so well, with an eye to practical applications in cell-free protein production.

Luo collaborated with Max Lu, a professor at the Australian Institute for Bioengineering and Nanotechnology at the University of Queensland in Australia. The work took place at the Cornell Center for Materials Research Shared Facilities, supported by the National Science Foundation.