Their pricing seems a little weird. They have a Roamio Plus with a 4TB drive for $720 and a Romaio Pro with a 4TB drive for $750. The only difference between the two is the initial hard drive size. And you don't get the original drive with it when you have them put in one 4TB drive.

Their pricing seems a little weird. They have a Roamio Plus with a 4TB drive for $720 and a Romaio Pro with a 4TB drive for $750. The only difference between the two is the initial hard drive size. And you don't get the original drive with it when you have them put in one 4TB drive.

That's in line with their pricing on the Plus upgrades though. The difference with the Pro is that the "Pro" wording on the front costs $30, per Weaknees that is.

Have to admit that even though by all accounts the Plus and Pro are exactly the same but for inbuilt storage, I'm a touch worried that at some point down the road I will regret that I didn't stretch and get the Pro as TiVo in the future may choose to unlock via software some feature(s) in the Pro that leave the Plus out in the cold, as a way to further differentiate the two models.

Have to admit that even though by all accounts the Plus and Pro are exactly the same but for inbuilt storage, I'm a touch worried that at some point down the road I will regret that I didn't stretch and get the Pro as TiVo in the future may choose to unlock via software some feature(s) in the Pro that leave the Plus out in the cold, as a way to further differentiate the two models.

While that may be possible, I would hope that they would not do such a thing, it would really piss some people off, right now the only reason you would chose a pro is addl storage, not future proofing additional enhancements.

While that may be possible, I would hope that they would not do such a thing, it would really piss some people off, right now the only reason you would chose a pro is addl storage, not future proofing additional enhancements.

Have to admit that even though by all accounts the Plus and Pro are exactly the same but for inbuilt storage, I'm a touch worried that at some point down the road I will regret that I didn't stretch and get the Pro as TiVo in the future may choose to unlock via software some feature(s) in the Pro that leave the Plus out in the cold, as a way to further differentiate the two models.

"Unlocking" different features was never done on the TiVo HD/TiVo HDXL, Premiere/Premiere XL, & Premiere 4/Premiere XL4 twins so we have a pretty good track record. So while doing so is technically possible, it certainly is not what we have seen in the past and would cause TiVo all sorts of problems.

Just for the fun of it I check weakness pricing. I looked at the Roamio Pro 4TB at $750 which is $150 more than the stock 3TB version and they extend the warranty to 180 days from 90. Seems reasonable when I factor in labor and the warranty.

But they do get to keep the 3TB drive and they get $170 for it as an upgrade in a Roamio Plus or $250 for it in a basic Roamio.

So for their cost of one 4TB drive, labor to change 2 drives, & providing the warranties on 2 units they are getting $320- $400 (plus normal markup) and still have either a 1TB or 500GB drive left.

Guess that still sounds reasonable to me overall but I don't think the basic Roamio buyer is getting a very good deal given how easy doing your own upgrade is.

"Unlocking" different features was never done on the TiVo HD/TiVo HDXL, Premiere/Premiere XL, & Premiere 4/Premiere XL4 twins so we have a pretty good track record. So while doing so is technically possible, it certainly is not what we have seen in the past and would cause TiVo all sorts of problems.

Hell, getting promised features like a HD interface was hard enough, I cant imagine add ons,

Both can be upgraded to 2TB (1 hard drive). There were/are 2 drive options that went further perhaps there was a difference there I don't know.

The sticky "Drive Expansion and Drive Upgrade FAQ" in the Series 3 forum, paragraph 16 under the Introduction clearly states that the maximum usable space on the THD would be 1.26 TB for one internal drive.

When I upgraded my THD and my HDXL I found that was the case. So unless newer software removed that limitation there was a difference on how much more space could be added with an internal drive upgrade.

The sticky "Drive Expansion and Drive Upgrade FAQ" in the Series 3 forum, paragraph 16 under the Introduction clearly states that the maximum usable space on the THD would be 1.26 TB for one internal drive.

Look at when that post was last updated. I have a 2TB drive in my Tivo HD (non-XL) at home, and have had one for 3 years now.

The sticky "Drive Expansion and Drive Upgrade FAQ" in the Series 3 forum, paragraph 16 under the Introduction clearly states that the maximum usable space on the THD would be 1.26 TB for one internal drive.

When I upgraded my THD and my HDXL I found that was the case. So unless newer software removed that limitation there was a difference on how much more space could be added with an internal drive upgrade.

That info is out of date. I have personally upgrade my TiVo HD to 2TB, simple process. Same for Premiere and my understanding is the original Series 3 can now also be user upgraded to 2TB.

I wonder if it's a trick? On the old units didn't they get past the 2TB limit by basically making the extra 1TB appear as if it were an external eSATA drive? And by doing so make it impossible to actually expand further by adding an eSATA drive? They're probably doing the same thing here. Except now the internal limit is 3TB.

I wonder if it's a trick? On the old units didn't they get past the 2TB limit by basically making the extra 1TB appear as if it were an external eSATA drive? And by doing so make it impossible to actually expand further by adding an eSATA drive? They're probably doing the same thing here. Except now the internal limit is 3TB.

Weaknees sells 4TB 2 disk solutions for the Premieres and for some of the S3 units. I wonder if they will be able to sell 6 or 8 TB 2 disk solutions for the Roamios?

Read through the links in my last post. Both my Premiere and TiVO HD have 318 HD hrs. My Series 3 with it's original 250 GB and 1TB external drive only has 179 HD hrs.

My HD only has 237 hours. Your HD is using all of a 2TB drive. That just means that between time in 2006 or 2007 when I upgraded my HD and the time when you upgraded yours that either Tivo made a change or new upgrade tools became available that allowed the use of the full 2TB.

This doesn't change my original comment that there could be differences in the Roamio Plus and Pro that we don't know about yet, just like there were differences in the HD and XL.

Some people are willing to pay the extra $30 to be safe.

Never got a Premiere so I can't comment on that, but I'm looking forward to my 4TB Roamio.

Yeah but unlike that situation we're talking about pretty static file sizes. In fact, if anything, video files are going to get smaller in the future as we transition to H.264. So that 8GB of storage is going to always hold 1200+ hours of HD video, and could get up to 1700+ with H.264. That's enough to hold the entire season of 50+ TV shows. At a certain point you're accumulating stuff you'll never even have time to watch.

Yeah but unlike that situation we're talking about pretty static file sizes. In fact, if anything, video files are going to get smaller in the future as we transition to H.264. So that 8GB of storage is going to always hold 1200+ hours of HD video, and could get up to 1700+ with H.264. That's enough to hold the entire season of 50+ TV shows. At a certain point you're accumulating stuff you'll never even have time to watch.

For most people your correct but some people like to have everything even though they will never watch all of it, I have to admit my family was like that when we changed to TiVos from VCRs I dumped (after a year) 4 or 5 big bags of VCR tapes and all (but one) VCR that is now not connected. So with TiVo they have to be more efficient as they can't just purchase another VCR tape for more storage.

My HD only has 237 hours. Your HD is using all of a 2TB drive. That just means that between time in 2006 or 2007 when I upgraded my HD and the time when you upgraded yours that either Tivo made a change or new upgrade tools became available that allowed the use of the full 2TB.

This doesn't change my original comment that there could be differences in the Roamio Plus and Pro that we don't know about yet, just like there were differences in the HD and XL.

It entirely undermines your original comment:

Quote:

Originally Posted by bobfrank

I do remember that although the HD and the HDXL seemed the same, except for the disk size that the XL was able to be upgraded to a larger disk than the HD could.

That difference was purely due to people not reverse engineering ways to expand non-XL drives as large as they could make XL drives. An entirely 3rd-party software limitation (as opposed to a hardware one) that was eventually overcome. The HD and the HDXL were identical. It just took longer to figure out how to expand the stock filesystem of an HD.

At the moment, it looks like the Roamio is the same situation, except weaknees (and the hackers here, it seems like) are figuring out the filesystem faster, and so there's zero difference between the expansion potentials of all 3 Roamio models.

But hey, you keep handwaving that there's some merit to your original comment, just like you have done for all of this discussion.