Wednesday, February 10, 2010

Kids, schools and superbugs

What do the three have in common, you might wonder? Well, more than we used to think.

This story in today's UK's Telegraph reports on a school child who developed diarrhea and tested positive for C difficile. The alarming thing is that there did not seem to be any explicit risk factors for this. The appalling thing is the mis-information by the story that

Children rarely become ill with C-diff, which normally strikes elderly people in hospital.

This is how things used to be, before the BI/NAP1/027 bug evolved in the early first decade of the millenium. We and others have shown that kids are not immune from it, and neither are other people previously thought not to possess any risk factors for it. In fact, we have a paper coming out shortly in the CDC's journal Emerging Infectious Diseases showing that in the US the rate of pediatric hospitalizations with C diff rose from 7.2 cases per 10,000 hospitalizations in 1997 to 12.8 cases/10,000 in 2006.

So why is this happening? Well, there are a couple of ways to answer this question. The proximal answer is that the new bug is better equipped to propagate. Its spore possesses greater stickiness than the old pathogenic version which we all knew and loved in the '90s, and thus is more difficult to eradicate from fomites and anatomic surfaces. It also produces on the order of 20-times more of the toxins responsible for wreaking havoc in the colon. So, clearly, this is a bug for the new millenium.

But here is the real reason for this, albeit a little more removed: antibiotic overuse. All physicians are aware of this, and we all get the connection. The way this works is that C diff is impervious to many of the antibiotics employed to treat other infections, while its neighbors in the gut are decimated. Thus, C diff proliferates to fill the void and takes a firm hold under the right circumstances. The new superbug is, of course, very likely the result of the all-too-familiar saga of resistance evolution.

Here is the frightening part: we are still overusing antibiotics! I frequently hear from my friends that their MDs offered antibiotics for something that to me is clearly a non-bacterial issue. The most frustrating situation is when I am convinced that the friend has a post-viral reactive airways cough and needs an inhaler, but instead comes home with a handful of antibacterial pills. And no one wants to take the chance. We are so risk averse that even when we are well educated about the perils of antibiotic overuse, we are still likely to take them if our doctor prescribes them. And for a doctor, with the shrinking appointment times, what is the most expedient course, particularly with a patient with an entitled attitude? You guessed it, antibiotics!

So, what do we do? My feeling is that the action has to be multi-pronged. Yes, physicians need to be held accountable for their treatment choices, but so do patients. We need to do a much better job educating the public about the dark underbelly of antibiotics, so that they can be partners in these decision. In my opinion, this may be the most critical healthcare issue of our time, given the concerns raised by both the WHO and the FDA that, if resistance emergence continues at this pace, we will be back to the dark ages of pre-antibiotic era.

To this end, The Surgeon General should pick up the banner of antibiotic education. In fact, I recently sent her a letter outlining why she might want to make this a part of her Public Health agenda. If anyone is interested in making it a more public effort, I am happy to share it and resend with more signatures than just my own. She after all puts the "Public" into Public Health.

We have got to start talking to the people about this. The resistance train needs to reverse direction. And now!

Welcome and a disclaimer

Welcome to my blog, "Healthcare, etc."! In this blog I take the perspective of a researcher/policy wonk rather than an individual healthcare practitioner. Therefore, all opinions that I express and generalizations that I make about any issues will in no way be construed as medical advice for individual visitors / readers. All views expressed here are solely my own, and do not represent opinions of any organizations with which I am affiliated. I welcome all comments, but reserve the right not to publish paranoid or abusive rants or overt marketing pitches.

About Me

I am an independent physician health services researcher with a specific interest in healthcare-associated complications and a broad interest in the state of our healthcare system. I am also a professor of Epidemiology at the University of Massachusetts, Amherst.
I am frequently invited to speak about evidence-based medicine, methods and healthcare-associated complications.
My posts have been syndicated on The Health Care Blog, KevinMD,The Healthcare Collective and other sites. They have also been cited in the New York Times. Occasionally you can also find me blogging on the British Medical Journal blog site http://www.doc2doc.bmj.com
If you would like to contact me about my research, blog posts or speaking, please e-mail me at Healthcareetcblog@gmail.com