CBSSports.com's Super Bowl XLVI predictions

Super Bowl XLVI Preview: Will the Patriots get revenge this time around or will the Giants continue their run to another title?

Gregg Doyel

I've never felt so good about a pick in my life, because I've never seen anything as rock-solid as the New York Giants in Super Bowl XLVI. The Giants have already beaten the Patriots this season, at New England, and they did it despite the unavailability of leading rusher Ahmad Bradshaw and 1,000-yard receiver Hakeem Nicks. Plus, the Patriots weren't playing that game with receivers Julian Edelman and Matthew Slater forced to play key roles at defensive back, as will be the case Sunday.

Forget what Vegas is saying. Everyone else is saying the Patriots will lose ... which is why I feel 100 percent certain that the Patriots will win. When everybody's convinced they're right, I'm convinced they're wrong. History shows people just aren't that smart.

Final score: It'll be a slugfest, but the Patriots will win 42-38.

Mike Freeman

Initially, I thought the Giants would actually beat the Patriots handily. Eli Manning would look at the Patriots defense, lick his chops, and light that defense on fire. Tom Brady would get harassed, an injured Gronk would be controlled, and Wes Welker would have a solid though not dominating day. It was all shaping up to a healthy Giants victory.

Then at the beginning of this week the Giants started chirping. And chirping. And chirping some more. It was a jab-fest for them with the team’s main message being they could get to Tom Brady both physically and mentally.

Normally, as Tom Coughlin would say, talk is cheap but this is Brady who thrives on talk and doubters. I’ve seen it happen with Brady on more than a few occasions. Not to mention the Patriots are on a revenge tour. I think the Giants would have been better served shutting the hell up. I know they are talkers. I know the Giants thrive on emotion and yapping but don’t pull on SuperBrady’s cape.

The Giants will still win but their mouths just turned this game from a comfortable win for them into one of the tightest Super Bowls ever.

Final score: Giants, 28-27

Clark Judge

I’ll take the New York Giants in Super Bowl XLVI, and here’s why: Because they’re more balanced than New England, they’re hot, they’re confident and they have the pass rush to flummox the usually unflappable Tom Brady.

Oh, yeah, they also won their last two vs. the Patriots – including a 24-20 defeat this season.

But it’s that pass rush that convinces me. The Giants can bring pressure with their defensive line, allowing everyone else to drop into coverage, and if you don’t think that will affect Brady you weren’t watching the Giants shred Green Bay and Aaron Rodgers in the divisional round of the playoffs.

Brady struggled in his last two starts vs. New York. He was sacked seven times, hit on countless other occasions and had more turnovers (4) than touchdown passes (3). He also lost both games. That counts for something, and I say it counts for a Giants’ victory.

Final score: Giants, 24-17

Pete Prisco

Quarterback and pass rush.

That's the key to winning in the NFL these days. Get a great thrower and have a lot of guys to knock down the other team's thrower. The New England Patriots have the great passer in Tom Brady, but they lack the great pass rushers. The New York Giants have a very good passer in Eli Manning, but they have a lot of pass rushers.

That's why the New York Giants will win Super Bowl XLVI. This time, unlike the last time they played in a Super Bowl, the Giants aren't huge underdogs. What I can't figure out is this: Why they aren't they favored.

The Giants are the better team.

It's a tribute to Brady that the Patriots are here, but in watching him play the Giants in the past, he isn't the same Brady when he faces that the New York defense. Like I wrote this week, the Giants seem to be in his head. In the Giants' victory this season in Foxboro, Mass., Brady looked ordinary.

That's the big edge for the Giants. They have the pass rushers. They don't fear Brady. They rattle him. That's why the Giants will beat the Patriots again in a Super Bowl.

The NFL is all about quarterback and pass rushers -- and the Giants will show on Sunday.

Final score: Giants, 31-24

Paul Dehner

Forget Gronkowski's ankle. Forget Aaron Hernandez. The defining story line of Super Bowl XLVI will be how the Patriots offensive line handles the intense Giants pass rush. Recent history of all New York's opponents on their postseason run insists that's more of a fleeting wish than a likelihood. The Giants have pounded every quarterback in their way into submission and eventual defeat. Tony Romo was sacked six times, Matt Ryan twice, Aaron Rodgers four times and Alex Smith three. The opponent didn't matter.

Tom Brady's only the next in line. When Brady can't throw, the Pats don't go. The Giants front four is coming and there isn't too much Brady can do about it. Jason Pierre-Paul and the rest of the Giants own the rare ability to disrupt timing -- the ultimate equalizer in the new, pass-happy NFL. They'll do it again on Sunday. That's the reason they'll loft the trophy.

Final score: Giants, 21-17

Alex Raskin

Another scoreless first half — like the one the New England Patriots and New York Giants had back in Week 9 — is improbable, but another defensive battle isn’t. Everyone is rightfully talking about each team’s respective high-powered offense. However, this game will be won on the defensive side of the ball and the Giants are up to the challenge.

New York has forced and recovered five fumbles in the postseason and the secondary has played significantly better since the Week 15 loss to the Washington Redskins. Throw in the Giants’ reliable linebackers and fearsome pass rush, and the advantage swings heavily in favor of the NFC Champions.

The Patriots’ defense intercepts passes and buckles down in the red zone, but the Giants’ big-play offense has a way around that. Victor Cruz, Hakeem Nicks and Mario Manningham allow quarterback Eli Manning to throw touchdown passes from anywhere on the field by going over or underneath opposing coverages.

Final score: Giants, 24-16

Will Brinson

It absolutely terrifies me that everyone -- and I mean everyone -- is on the Giants bandwagon. Eighty-five percent of the public money is on the Giants. Almost everyone at CBS is picking the Giants. Everyone outside of Boston is picking the Giants. It makes sense, because New York's front four is going to get pressure on Brady.

The Patriots best offensive weapon, Rob Gronkowski, is going to be limited. And how are the Patriots going to defend Victor Cruz, Hakeem Nicks and Mario Manningham? Not with Julian Edelman playing defensive back. Of course, the problem with all this is that the entire world's betting against the combination of Tom Brady and Bill Belichick. That's somewhat illogical. Two things are going to make this a very close game: Gronk's ankle forcing him to stay in and block and Vince Wilfork turning into an animal for the second straight game. (Wilfork's my darkhorse for MVP.) In the end, though, it's going to come down to who has the ball last and I think it ends up being Eli.

Josh Katzowitz

Seems to me like the buzz this week in Indianapolis is how the Giants will beat the Patriots for the second time this season. And for reasons I’m having a hard time explaining, I don’t think that will happen. Give New England coach Bill Belichick two weeks to figure out how to beat the Giants, and I think he does it.

Obviously, New York has some solid advantages. The Giants front four will provide plenty of issues for the Patriots as they try to keep Tom Brady untouched. Eli Manning shouldn’t have a problem picking on New England’s secondary. And assuming Patriots tight end Rob Gronkowski isn’t 100 percent effective, New England’s offense will be a little less versatile.

So, really, the Giants should win.

But I can’t pull the trigger on predicting them to do so. And I don’t know why. Which, I guess, isn’t much of answer why I’m picking the Patriots to win. I just kinda think they will.

Final score: Patriots, 24-22

Ryan Wilson

It's hard to believe that Vegas has had New England as the favorites for nearly two weeks now because almost everybody likes New York. Never mind that Giants have issues in the secondary and Tom Brady is a future Hall of Famer and three-time Super Bowl winner, New York's front four somehow makes up for all that.

Four years ago, the Pats came into this game undefeated and unstoppable. The Giants' pass rush changed all that. And that's what happened this season, in Week 9, when the two teams met. We get the feeling that New England won't be able to protect Brady on Sunday either.

Meanwhile, Eli Manning is playing the best football of his career even without much of a running game behind him. The Patriots' defense has been better in recent weeks but they still struggle in both phases. And that's bad news if Brady isn't his usual self.

Post Deleted by Administrator

CBSSports.com's Super Bowl XLVI predictions

Much better, thank you. Yac stats for 2011/2012, Nicks #3 in the NFL, Hernandez #4, Gronkowski #5, Bradshaw #8, Branch #11, Cruz #12, Welker #17, Manningham doesn't crack the top 90. Patriots have 4 in top 20, Giants have 3. Should be a good game, enjoy.

beer is great
Since: Mar 18, 2011

Posted on: February 4, 2012 8:59 pm

This comment has been removed.

Post Deleted by Administrator

Since: Aug 13, 2009

Posted on: February 4, 2012 8:59 pm

CBSSports.com's Super Bowl XLVI predictions

Giants went 9-7 during the regular season and beat your Pats in a game your discounting...see how silly you're sounding?

Nope, dont see it and there was no contradiction, there is a difference between 1 game in the regular season and the season as a whole. I guess since the Pats only played 2 games in the Post season because they secured the #1 seed makes them not as consistent.

The Pats defense and the GB defense were going opposite ways the last few weeks of the season, did you see the last regular season games by the Packers defense. Did you see the Packers lose to a terrible KC team.

The the conference championship the Pats beat the better team and the higher ranked and better defense than the Giants, it took overtime for the giants win.

You can say I am making the Patriots sound worse but not actually backing up the statement with how I am doind so Is funny.

THE GIANTS GOT OUTSCORED BY THERE OPPONENTS THIS YEAR, THERE 2 TEAMS IN THERE DIVISION AS GOOD OR BETTER THAN THE GIANTS.

QUESTION STILL NOT ANSWERED - what happened to the Giants when they came out and said before the skins game that they had to win out to have a chance at the playoffs and they puked all over themselves, none of there big guns wer out injured, they had CRUZ, NICKS, MANNINGHAM, JACOBS & BRADSHAW, what happened there. If it was not for the cowboys idiotic mistakes handing teams games the giants would not even be in the playoffs, and everyone would still be laughing at ELI for his elite comment, its funny how something out of his control like the cowboys crapping there pants can bring him from avg to one of the best in 5 games.

9-7, 13-3 , &nbsp; &nbsp; 1 game means nothing in the regular season just like if the Packers were playing the chiefs, that one game the chiefs won would mean nothing but the season as a whole does. How conident would you feel if you were playing the Redskins this week even though you lost to them twice, earlier matchups from back on November 6th mean very very little. Pats killed the Broncos and beat very good Baltimore team but since the Pats were so good during the regular season and did not have to play wildcard week there not as hot. 10 in a row, 5 in a row hmmmm, whos hot.

Since: Mar 28, 2008

Posted on: February 4, 2012 8:55 pm

CBSSports.com's Super Bowl XLVI predictions

Beer is great, please school me on another matchup in the game that will play a larger part of the outcome that the Gaints front four. While it's obvious and widely talked about should we compare kickers, punters, again you are spouting useless nonsense. It's clear you have diarrhea of the mouth. Your talking shit and it's starting to stink.

beer is great
Since: Mar 18, 2011

Posted on: February 4, 2012 8:49 pm

This comment has been removed.

Post Deleted by Administrator

Since: Mar 28, 2008

Posted on: February 4, 2012 8:39 pm

CBSSports.com's Super Bowl XLVI predictions

Beer is great, I agree. However, your Giants are not. Your drinking the NY Post kool aid and getting drunk off it. Reality check, both teams are good, both teams have a chance to win. If the Giants front four get to Brady they should win, if not they should lose. At least the Patriots have a reason their secondary sucks, reciver playing D Back, pratice squad D Backs starting, what's the Giants excuse? Green Bay receivers dropped more than half a dozen passes when they were wide open. If that hadn't happened your Giants would be watching the Super Bowl from the couch. Yes, I know the Patriots would also be doing the same if Evans held on to the ball. Luck is part of winning, when the Giants beat the Patriots in 2008 luck played a part, when the Patriots won their Super Bowls luck played a part. While you talk about fat wives and reach arounds I talk facts. What are you going to do if your Giants lose? Spout off more useless information and derogitory comments?

beer is great
Since: Mar 18, 2011

Posted on: February 4, 2012 8:35 pm

This comment has been removed.

Post Deleted by Administrator

beer is great
Since: Mar 18, 2011

Posted on: February 4, 2012 8:32 pm

This comment has been removed.

Post Deleted by Administrator

Since: Aug 13, 2009

Posted on: February 4, 2012 8:31 pm

CBSSports.com's Super Bowl XLVI predictions

NE DOMINANCE, get ready for another Giants win over your over rated Patriots. Unlike your fat wife, New England has beaten nobody. One question for you...when Brady mounts you, is he nice enough to give you a reacharound?

Another brilliant one, when you move out of your mother basement and grow up just a little come back and try not to make a fool of yourself. You cannot even make any sense when you insult someone first you say I have a fat wife who who unlke the Pats has beaten nobody, then you say I am gay which is it moron/homophob/40yr old living in moms basement, BEER IS GREAT as a name, you are SOOOOO coool. I want to be the cool one with the name I LOVE BEER.