Shoaib Malik made an unbeaten 124 to lead the Pakistan charge as they ended on 286-4, although it could have been a different story had he been dismissed for 40 when Broad had him caught in the slips - but off a no-ball.

It was one of a number of missed opportunities for the tourists, with Ian Bell also dropping Mohammad Hafeez's regulation edge to second slip off James Anderson, the opener surviving on seven en route to 98.

Broad told BBC Sport: "I blame myself for the no-ball. We pride ourselves on our catching and not bowling no-balls. I can't think of many times I've had one chalked off, if at all. It's a feeling of (being) distraught.

"I'm not a regular no-ball bowler so it took me a bit by surprise, but it's not really acceptable at this level. After lunch it was a gusty wind and as a bowler it can affect your stride pattern. It's about millimeters really.