Subban > Gardiner (both NHL defenseman, but Subban is one year older. Still he has an extra year of experience, a great playoff run and I would argue better defensively at this stage in development)

Reilly > Beaulieu (Both great defenseman but both scouts and myself agree that Reilly has higher upside going forward)

Finn =/> Tinordi (Finn is putting up an impressive OHL season while Tinordi is having an underwhelming first AHL season. They are very different types of defenseman though and hard to compare. I'd call it a draw)

Therefore, the comparison is a essentially a wash. Really based on preference if you ask me.

Subban > Gardiner (both NHL defenseman, but Subban is one year older. Still he has an extra year of experience, a great playoff run and I would argue better defensively at this stage in development)

Reilly > Beaulieu (Both great defenseman but both scouts and myself agree that Reilly has higher upside going forward)

Finn =/> Tinordi (Finn is putting up an impressive OHL season while Tinordi is having an underwhelming first AHL season. They are very different types of defenseman though and hard to compare. I'd call it a draw)

Therefore, the comparison is a essentially a wash. Really based on preference if you ask me.