Despite 'Urban Renaissance' Suburbs Continue To Dominate In U.S.

The traditional narrative goes like this: After World War II, upper and middle class white families fled the inner cities for the suburbs. They were chasing the "American Dream" of white picket fences, two car garages and shopping centers you could drive to. The children of those Baby Boomers grew up, fought back and now, are moving back to the cities.

According to a new report from the Urban Land Institute's Terwilliger Center for Housing, the first part of that story is more true than the second part — so far.

While cities may be seeing a comeback, suburbs still have a significant advantage. "Housing in the Evolving American Suburb" looked at the 50 largest metro regions in the country, and found that 79 percent of the population lives in the suburbs. Since 2000, suburbs have accounted for 91 percent of the population growth.

And as for that idea that Millenials are moving into the city? Three-quarters of people age 25 to 34 live in the suburbs.

"There is no single thing that can be called a 'suburb,'" said ULI Terwilliger Center for Housing Executive Director Stockton Williams. "Understanding those differences matters, so we can break down generalizations that too often stop the conversation."

These shades of gray can help explain why suburbs are still holding strong despite recent interest in urban living. Even as some young people move into cities, other groups are just arriving in the suburbs.

In the 50 largest metro regions, 76 percent of the minority population lives in suburbs. Williams says a lot of this is driven by young immigrant families for whom the suburbs are "the preferred destination." Many of them are settling outside cities, attracted to the reasonable cost of home ownership, accessibility of green space and better schools.

But this positive growth for suburbs doesn't mean cities are destined for another five decades of hollowing out.

"There's this idea we have that if cities are winning, suburbs must be losing. Or if suburbs are strong, cities must be weak," said Williams. "In fact, many of the cities that are doing well, we're also seeing their suburban areas doing well."

There was a time when suburbs were gaining at the expense of cities, but Williams thinks that metro regions are much more intertwined now than they were before.

"Think of the sort of cliche story of a young professional moving to the urban core and renting an apartment," said Williams. "Then, they're getting a little older and looking to own a home, they find that it's more affordable further out. Maybe when they're in their middle age, they'll move back closer in. You need a healthy, diverse city and suburban housing market to support that."

Cities risk falling into the trap of isolating themselves from the suburbs that support them, says Williams. The report found that certain types of suburbs are working to become more appealing to young people and city dwellers, just as cities are doing the same for suburbanites. This balancing act could create more varied, diverse regions.

The report looked at 2000 to 2015, so the much-touted "urban revival" may not be reflected in the results yet. Fifteen years down the road, cities may have regained some of that population growth from their suburban neighbors. Williams hopes that it's collaborative growth, rather than competitive.

Related Content

For the past 20 years, Rep. Gene DiGirolamo, R-Bucks, has been a vocal advocate for drug and alcohol rehabilitation in Pennsylvania. And he’s been pushing the public and lawmakers to stop looking at addiction as a crime.

“Addiction has to be looked at like a disease and it is, like other diseases, highly treatable, and treatment works,” he said.

Ninety-six percent of students at Pennsylvania College of Technology entertain job offers in their final semester. It's an enviable statistic, one that the college is very proud of, said Tracy Brundage, vice president of workforce development and continuing education.

“Our tagline is ‘degrees that work,’” she said.

But employer interest isn't limited to graduates of the Penn State affiliate's two- and four-year degree programs.

Theresa Cygrymus looked around the hall at Prince of Peace Parish, a Catholic Church on Pittsburgh’s South Side, and shook her head.

“It’s already nine o’clock, usually we have stuff cooking already," she said.

Cygrymus knows the drill. At 78, she’s been volunteering for the church all her life. On a Saturday in late October, Cygrymus and a church group called The Christian Mothers were preparing to churn out hundreds of dozens of pierogis to sell. All the money they make supports the church and its outreach.

Last week, about 20 people waited anxiously for the walk signal at the busy intersection outside Target in East Liberty. When the light changed, they danced into the crosswalk. As James Brown sang “Get on the Good Foot,” they spun, they shimmied, they high-fived.