Isn't the point of thumbing down you thumb down junk?
If you think he played amazingly, then why did he not score the chance he had? The one that probably could have won them the World Cup? All he did was pop up and occasionally score a goal, you can score goals and still be anonymous. That's what he did.
And they don't need to carry them, they need to inspire them. He played poorly, and he captained his team poorly.