If god creates us all, and has plans for us all, why does he make some of them gay if he calls it a sin?

maybe god is just a bored, spoiled mofo?

Queen of the PointyShiney

"Too much ink is drawn to describe and define love. Why describe it and define it? Take my hand and let's just take a ride through it. Love is... Love is... Let's just go for awhile, leaving ourselves for each other." --Mike Smith

If god creates us all, and has plans for us all, why does he make some of them gay if he calls it a sin?

Well obviously, as another religious stand point, by free will i'm saying he is letting you do whatever you want to do and he isn't makinganyone gay

Its all the persons choice

And if you think about it the ppl that are or turn out to be gay or lesbian are the ppl that dont have a serious-or if any-realationship with the opposite sex so they find other ppl like them and in my opinion try to make a point

but i could correct my-self in a point because not all gay ppl were social outcasts
for example some movie stars male and female are adored by their opposite sex but for some odd reason they turn gay-perhaps they are bored....but like I said its all the persons choice

The passages that supposedly say he has something against gays(ive read them and would advise u to read them to)Im just saying this cause im presbitarien but i also believe in gay marriage as do most of the other presbutariens i know.

Well obviously, as another religious stand point, by free will i'm saying he is letting you do whatever you want to do and he isn't making anyone gay

Its all the persons choice

well, only in-so-much as anything is anyone's choice. i mean, just because our fate may not be set in stone, i'm not entirely sure it's up to us, either. indeed, i think the more likely scenario is that we are slaves to the atoms inside us, but those atoms are, as suggested by this page have randomness sorta built into 'em.

however, that said, i do believe i understand the point you're trying to make. it's somewhat similar to the points people make to explain away the problem of evil.

of course, i think a better way to explain away the problem of evil is assume that the power to defy logic is included within god's status as being omnipotent.=

Well obviously, as another religious stand point, by free will i'm saying he is letting you do whatever you want to do and he isn't making anyone gay

Except that if god is all knowing, he must therefore know the outcome of any action he undertakes. As such, there is no such things as 'free will'... or, put another way, god knows exactly what we will decide, and has known since Adam and Eve

And if you think about it the ppl that are or turn out to be gay or lesbian are the ppl that dont have a serious-or if any-realationship with the opposite sex so they find other ppl like them and in my opinion try to make a point

Odd... I get along really well with the opposite sex. There's also a few of them I care deeply for. I am simply not attracted to them in the same way, however.

Its all the persons choice

No choice here. I can't say it isn't some combination of nature/nurture and thus a subconcious choice, but there was no concious choice on my point. I'm a rather logical person, and there's no way I would choose a path which would make my life more difficult in this manner.

but i could correct my-self in a point because not all gay ppl were social outcastsfor example some movie stars male and female are adored by their opposite sex but for some odd woah.gif reason they turn gay-perhaps they are bored....but like I said its all the persons choice

Again, why do you say it is a choice? Are you saying that you, yourself, could CHOOSE to, starting tommorow, be sexually attracted to and want to be in a relationship with the same sex. Not just go through the motions, but actually be *attracted* to them?

The passages that supposedly say he has something against gays

Well, it's also in the OT along with a bunch of other stuff that is all but ignored.

Vive le titre de deux.
In an ironic twist, the only trait I find completely appaling is intolerance.

And if you think about it the ppl that are or turn out to be gay or lesbian are the ppl that dont have a serious-or if any-realationship with the opposite sex so they find other ppl like them and in my opinion try to make a point

can't say ive had any problem with the opposite sex. i love girls, in a non-boyfriend/girlfriend way. if i were attracted to them in an intimate/sexual way, id have no problem having a girl friend. until recently, my best friends have been girls.

and i can guarentee u that i didn't chose to be attracted to guys (although i do love it. guys are so hot!) . id like to be attracted to girls so i could share that interest with my straight guy friends, brother, etc.

i believe that it is mostly nature(that is if nurture plays any part at all). studies have shown physiological differences between straight woman and lesbians. lesbians tend to have thicker eardrums (more like a man's) than straight woman.

now, this is not to say ill never have sex with a girl. the opportunity presents itself directly on my doorstep, and im in a very sexual mood, ill do her. but i am about 99.8% sure that i won't be marrying a girl, or even haveing a girlfriend girlfriend.