Bob’ insight – and reference to the start-up ethos – is worth considering on two fronts:
First, many technologies are being used in Jewish outreach in ways that offer unimaginable efficacy. BBYO’s find-a-college roommate app is a good example along the same lines as Open Table.
Second, Younger Jews are less willing to define themselves -or friends – as Jewish/Not or Affiliated/not, which makes any outreach effort overly dependent on targeting a well-defined group obsolete. Bob is right in that a disproportionate amount of Jewish resources have gone toward the 80/20. We’d all be better served to empower those with the most interest and ability to build and leverage networks.

Bob- you are creating a false dichotomy. We do not need to focus on the 80% the same way we do not need to focus on the 20%. The Organized Jewish Community must engage BOTH. I would encourage all my fellow Jewish Educators and Professionals not to forego the inclusion of any member of our community as less important to target than another- our diversity is our strength, not our weakness.

Your analogy of the brewery is not in alignment with the goals of most professional Jewish Organizations. Whereas the brewery does not care who purchases the beer, only the total number of sales. Jewish Organizations actively and intentionally seek to engage a diverse demographic of “customers”. While focusing on the 20% might engage more people per event/program on average -as per the brewery analogy- it will be the same people each time. By ALSO focusing on the 80% the participant base is diversified. I would argue that ultimately, this diversification of Jewish programming and engagement is a core means of strengthening our community.

Judaism may be “cool” at the moment, but it is not a “brand.” Branding is something a business does to get people to recognize and/or differentiate their product or service with the intention of getting people to buy or use their product or service.

To “brand” something is to make it recognizable due to its uniformity and/or consistency. When people find a brand they like, they tend to stick with it because they know what they will get. Starbucks and McDonald’s, for example, are global brands that look pretty much the same and serve pretty much the same coffee and food everywhere in the world. That is definitely not what Judaism is or should be.

Judaism is not one size fits all or uniform in nature. It is diverse with many different interpretations. Judaism is, however, distinct. The way Judaism approaches food and eating, for instance, is distinct from the way most non-Jewish cultures approach food and eating. (Even so different rabbis or Jewish communities will interpret the laws of Kashrut differently.)

That said, what is the point of having Jewish activities if the content is not Jewish? If a group of Jews comes together (with or without their non-Jewish partners) to play sports or eat a meal or see the latest blockbuster how is it any different than activities put on by any non-Jewish group? The point of Jewish products/activities/groups should be to do or create something from a Jewish perspective so it is distinct from anything the non-Jewish world has to offer.

I think that Jews and non-Jews alike who join Jewish activities or groups should have an interest in deepening their knowledge about Judaism and the Jewish people and/or a desire to experience Jewish culture and life. They should be inspired to learn more about Judaism and how Judaism can be meaningful to their lives. There are so many wonderful things to discover!

Primary Sidebar

Join The Conversation

What's the best way to follow important issues affecting the Jewish philanthropic world?
Our Daily Update keeps you on top of the latest news, trends and opinions shaping the landscape, providing an invaluable source for inspiration and learning.