Ideas I can suggest for icons are:
1. Icons using Zelda charcters
2. Zelda logo used in the icon

Please use your imagination and dont use the stock icon as a reference, its simply horrible ;)

The base awards we need are:

Most dedicated
Most knowledgable about Zelda
Coolies member
Coolest newb
most immature
Best Sig and Avvy
Funniest member
Promising newbie
Most dedicated
Kindness member
Most helpful
Best graphics artist
hottest male
hottest female