Peeps Play Dough Recipe

When your littlest learners are still sometimes putting things in their mouths you might be worried about giving them sensory recipes to explore. That was certainly the cause in our house when we created our Nutella play dough. Excited to experiment with other edible dough recipes, we headed to the kitchen cabinets again and voila! We created a recipe for edible marshmallow Peeps play dough.

This post contains affiliate links.

Update: We're so thankful that this post has drawn such attention! We welcome shares of this recipe, but please do not simply copy/paste the directions. We appreciate when you link to direct readers back to us! Thank you!

Oh, Peeps. The sugary seasonal treat that people seem to either love or loathe. How about you? We always end up with extras leftover so trying to make up a play dough recipe was the perfect way to use them up!

Our kids love play dough and it's great for working little fingers to start to practice fine motor skills that will be used later when writing. We always have a stash of the store bought Play Doh because I can't always create a Pinterest worthy recipe. This Peeps one just happened to take off over there.

No matter what dough you use sensory play is so beneficial for kids! Be sure to follow our 12 Months of Sensory Dough series for plenty of recipes and ideas.

We began by melting the Peeps with a teaspoon of water in the microwave for 45 seconds. Who doesn't love microwaving Peeps? It's a childhood rite of passage.

Some Peeps lost their eyes in the melting process. It's tragic, really, but for a good cause. You can also find the eyes in the dough later as you play with it. (I never thought I'd type that sentence.)

After the marshmallow Peeps were melted we added a teaspoon of oil. This helps the melted marshmallow come out of the microwave safe bowl. Stir to loosen them but leave the melted Peeps in the bowl to cool.

While the Peeps are cooling, add 1/3 to 1/2 corn starch to a different bowl. Press the corn starch down to coat the bottom of the bowl as much as possible.

Add the melted marshmallow Peep mixture to the bowl of corn starch. Gently use a spatula to fold the corn starch over and into the Peeps.

You and your kids will want to get your hands in at this point (which is great fine motor exercise) but make sure the hands are well coated in corn starch first! The dough will remain sticky until it's complete.

It is also quite stretchy like chewed bubble gum. Add a bit more corn starch if you need to but keep mixing and folding until the dough no longer sticks to your hands!

Coat your work surface with more corn starch and dump out the dough. Continue to knead the mixture until it reaches a play dough consistency.

We'd love to hear and see if you try our Peeps play dough recipe so please connect with us on Instagram and Facebook!

FUN!! MB would love this! I love all the literacy elements you did with it too! What a great time!

How weird is it that I've never microwaved peeps? I must also try doing (and tasting) that too!

(PS.. I'm not sure what's up with my deleted comment above... I don't remember deleting but I did walk away to get more coffee with a toddler near the keyboard, when I came back it was on a weird screen and when I clicked back it said my content was deleted)

Please do not use any of our images or writing without contacting for permission. We would love for you to share, write, and link to and about things that you have seen on this blog, but reproducing without permission or credit is not allowed.Read our Privacy Policy.