On Tue, 2006-07-18 at 12:27 +0100, Malcolm Wallace wrote:
> Christian Maeder <maeder at tzi.de> wrote:
>> > After all our discussions, I simply want to keep up my old proposal.
> > It drops a final delimiter and is named using "With" instead of "By"
> > and therefore would not imply any changes to Data.PackedString.
>> I think the general objection to the "With" suffix is that it is
> non-standard naming. All the Haskell'98 libraries use "By" for this
> kind of meaning. Data.PackedString is non-standard, and should not
> be relied upon as an accurate stylistic guide.
Indeed, the Data.PackedString API aspires to follow existing practise
from Data.List and elsewhere in the standard libs. So if there is a
discrepancy then it is Data.PackedString that should change. We'd be
happy to do that, especially as the API is not yet set in stone.
Duncan