Iron Man 3 – Takes a big Dump. Michelle’s Review

Many argue that without the staggering critical and box office success of the first Iron Man movie, there would be no Marvel Universe, as we know it. However, when last I checked Spider-Man and the X-Men movies gave Marvel the confidence and financial resources to go off and build this franchise. Now Iron Man returns to kick off the aptly named Wave II of Marvel movies that eventually concludes with another Avengers movie.

Tony Stark’s (Robert Downey Jr.) two biggest villains have always been the Mandarin (Ben Kingsley), a terrorist that wield 10 powerful magical rings and himself. Fans have been clamoring to see a big screen version of the Mandarin and a serious take on the famous Demon and the Bottle story where Tony goes completely off the rails. We got a little bit of that in the awful IM 2 but it was played for laughs.

Based on Marvel Executives current fascination with taking a big dump on fans (yes, I’m bitter about what they did to Spider-Man, no I won’t let it go), I should have known better than to get my hopes up about the Mandarin finally making it to the screen. Director Shane Black didn’t use magical rings because it would not have been “natural” or “realistic.”

Iron Man occupies a world where there are Gods of Thunder, 90-year old Super Soldiers, Aliens, Hulks, invisible flying fortresses, but somehow having a character with magical rings stretches the imagination? I’m sick to death of dark, grim, and “realistic. You are making a Super Hero movie. Get with the fun already!

The Mandarin is just as smart, but by being magic based, is the polar opposite of Tony. While there was no magical Mandarin, the way he was used was brilliant. Kingsley gave the Mandarin the gravitas and menace he deserved. The character design and costuming was awesome. He was the perfect foil for Stark. They didn’t need to completely bastardize his character and pee all over fans with the ridiculous 3rd act twist. I’m not saying The Mandarin is a comic character that I particularly like, what I’m saying is don’t use such an “iconic” character if you are just going to destroy him out of spite, create your own original villains.

Using Guy Pearce to play major bad guy Aldrich Killian the head of AIM (Advanced Idea Mechanics) was solid casting, until it got completely mishandled. AIM in the comic book world is a dark, shadowy organization that always manipulates events in the background. IM 3 should have had Aim operate in the background and then they could have used AIM for a couple of the upcoming movies – the evil version of Shield.

Shane Black has had an interesting, spotty career, he wrote two of the best action movies of all time – the criminally underrated The Long Kiss Goodnight and Lethal Weapon, but he has very little directing experience and hasn’t done much of anything in the last several years so why Marvel selected him is beyond me. But ok.

Having just watched The Long Kiss Goodnight last week, there are some nice subtle touches that fans will recognize. The opening shot of the suits exploding and the voiceover had the same feel and there’s a funny moment in the middle of the movie where he uses the same Christmas song.

This time out Tony is suffering PTSD from the events of the Avengers and hyperventilates every time someone mentions the wormhole. The cool thing about IM3 is the fact that while his PTSD and nervous reactions stem from that movie, you don’t need to have seen any of the previous films to get this. As they say in comics – this is the perfect “jumping on point.” He covers his fears and stress up with his trademark humor.

Black’s dialogue in the hands of Downey, Jr. is a match made in heaven. The quips come fast, furious and usually hysterically funny. While the tone is black, Downey’s presence never allows the movie to sink under it’s own weight. Usually kids in these kinds of movies are annoying but the way Stark handles his little helper Harley Keener (Ty Simpkins) as a miniature adult that is to be mocked is pure gold. The first 2 thirds of this movie are really strong.

The movie finds a million illogical reasons for Tony not to use the Armor and I’ve lost count of the amount of times the armor gets destroyed. For one of the most powerful weapons in the world IM 3 completely belittles the suit. It is kind of criminal how poorly the suit is treated throughout most of this movie. Don’t get me wrong I can watch Downey, Jr. be Tony Stark all day and I love the chemistry between he and Paltow, however, don’t do it by making the suit a worthless hunk of junk.

Brian Tyler’s score was amazing. It was really hard to keep track of capabilities of the bad guys, one moment they can regenerate from after being blown into bits, other times a simple gun shot can kill them, there is zero consistency in this movie. Even with the major logic gaps and flaws the movie was viscerally enjoyable for a bit, until all involved just took a gigantic dump into my face.

I wish I could talk about the 3rd act to really explain how awful this is, but I don’t want to spoil the movie. There is no way they can justify what they did. The 3rd act has to be one of the worst ones in movie history, on so many different levels. Everything about the last 30 or 40 minutes is just god awful and not just because it’s all action – because I love mindless action. What I hate is when unnecessary plot “twists” destroy a movie, or action that is designed to completely mock your audience for liking something. The audience is too sophisticated to have magic rings, but the rest of this crap, yeah, we’ll just lap this up?

Iron Man 3 suffers from the “too many cooks in the kitchen syndrome,” you can literally see the studio interference and an inexperienced Director’s unwillingness to say no up on the screen. Either that or Shane Black hasn’t worked that much in the last 13 or 15 years for a reason.

“Bitch?” Because you dont like the review? What the hell is the matter with you?

For the record, she’s referring to Marvel’s rather sadistic killing off of Peter Parker in the comics – multiple times, technically speaking. So she clearly knows more about this stuff than you do – what the hell does that make you, then?

You need to a pretty big comic book nerd to know what the comment was referring. I had to do a double take because I was still thinking of the movies since I was reading an article about movies.
Full disclosure: I love Superios Spider-man, so suck it! 🙂

well, if I was referring to films, I think SM 3 and ASM 1 last year would still prove my point. Just saying….. 😉 don’t get me started on Superior, so mad about that…..pretty much stopped reading comics…. grrrrr….

what ticks me off is the response from Marvel and others that fans are soooo unreasonable for hating this bastardization and the “oh, Pete will be back, just enjoy the ride…” Why enjoy a train wreck that is designed to just anger you? As Marvel solicits say “this issue will make you Angrier, than before!” I read comics for enjoyment, not to be angered for no reason.

“Yes, I’m bitter about what they did to Spider-Man, no I won’t let it go”

What they did to Spider-man was a spit in the face to everything Marvel used to stand for. Not to mention the fact that the editor in charge of the book loves to insult the long time fans who dare criticize their decision making. But hey, that’s what happens when you have Disney backing you.

As for the film, decent, not great and the twist ruins it. It seems that Marvel is even getting lazy with their films now.

While we’re in complete disagreement about the third act of IM3, I completely understand why you didn’t like it. I thought it worked because it allowed the film to take a character that was based on the very racist ‘Ming the Merciless/Yellow Peril’ model and completely undermine it. To be fair, the undermining began with the quickly established Osama bin Laden-looking/Middle American accent sounding video terrorist persona, but the twist totally exploded every aspect of the original stereotype in what I thought was a very emphatic and fun way.

That being said, I fully agree with the comments on the last third. A good friend of mine was mentioning how the studio most assuredly backed out of any negative connotations regarding a badguy of another race so as to maintain political correctness–as it ends up we have just a couple of white guys goin’ mano-a-mano. Why not just create your own villain, execs?

IM3 felt like an awful let-down just like the recent Batman movie that stood up an iconic villain just to tear that down to insert a different backstory. It’s a classic bait-and-switch manuever, getting the diehard fans into the theater with the understanding their iconic character will get some screentime, then changing the backstory for whatever purpose (I won’t go as far as saying it’s to spite the fans, but the studios obviously had too much influence on the end product).