For 36 Hours, N.Y.U. Student Was Trapped Between 2 Buildings

In a crowded city, Asher Vongtau was completely alone, trapped in a space barely wider than a shoe box after plummeting perhaps 100 feet into the tiny crevice between two buildings in TriBeCa.

His skull was fractured, one arm was broken and he had a collapsed lung. But he was alive. Still, as day turned to night and back to day again, there was one urgent question: Would help arrive in time?

People in New York City have fallen from great heights and lived to tell the tale. There was the window washer who fell 47 stories and survived. And it is common enough for New Yorkers to become trapped in tight spaces that there are Fire Department units specializing in unconventional extractions.

But Richard J. Blatus, the battalion chief of rescue operations and a 33-year veteran of the Fire Department, could not recall a situation quite like the one he encountered on Sunday night at the dormitory at 80 Lafayette Street and the garage in the adjacent building.

“It is a testament to the kid’s will that he is alive,” he said. “I don’t know how he lasted.”

There was much that remained unexplained on Monday about how Mr. Vongtau became trapped, including exactly where he was when he fell.

Photo

Landings of two buildings in TriBeCa between which Asher Vongtau was rescued after being trapped for 36 hours in a narrow space.Credit
Michael Appleton for The New York Times

Fire officials said that given how tightly he was wedged into the space — positioned on his left side just above the ground, unable to twist in any direction in a space about 12 inches wide — and the layout of the buildings, it was possible he fell from the roof of the 18-story dormitory.

The gap between the two buildings is wider on the higher floors, but the last 20 feet or so of space is quite narrow because of a setback. That lack of space might have helped slow his fall, officials said.

There is also an old fire escape on the building next to the dorm as well as an unused fire escape attached to the dorm, and officials said it was possible he could have fallen from one of those as well, in which case he might have fallen a shorter distance.

Mr. Vongtau was awake on Monday and talking to friends and family members, but it was unclear whether he was able to recall the details of what happened.

The weekend started like a typical one for a college student, with a night of partying on Friday. After going out, Mr. Vongtau went to the 10th-floor dorm room that another student, Michael Yablon, shared with three roommates at 80 Lafayette Street.

Mr. Yablon, Mr. Vongtau and another friend were still awake when the sun came up.

At around 7 a.m., Mr. Vongtau left the room “to get some fresh air,” Mr. Yablon said.

Soon after Mr. Vongtau walked out the door, someone pulled a fire alarm, waking up residents and causing a brief period of chaos.

Photo

Mr. Vongtau, 19, survived a fall.

By the time it was clear that it was a false alarm, Mr. Vongtau had disappeared.

At first, his friends thought he must have gone to his dorm room in nearby Alumni Hall to get some sleep. But on Saturday afternoon, they started to worry.

Mr. Yablon said that Mr. Vongtau, who was born in Nigeria and moved to the United States when he was 12, always responded to messages. When his friends were unable to contact him, they were convinced that something was terribly wrong.

On Saturday night they alerted campus security and, later, called the New York Police Department.

Mr. Yablon said on Monday that he did not think the university had treated his concerns with enough urgency. But university officials said they did all they could with the information available.

By Sunday morning, the university’s security officers had contacted nearby hospital emergency rooms and checked to see whether Mr. Vongtau’s student identification card had been used to enter any university buildings. His friends began a frantic search, on foot and online. They even reached out to his 13-year-old sister on Facebook, hoping his family might have heard from him.

It was all to no avail.

Then, on Sunday evening, Mr. Yablon said, someone got in touch with the friends about a stray pair of gray high-top sneakers discovered in a hallway on the seventh floor of the dorm.

Mr. Yablon said they quickly realized the shoes belonged to Mr. Vongtau and once again contacted campus security.

John Beckman, a spokesman for the university, said the initial reports indicated that Mr. Vongtau left the dorm on Saturday, but with the discovery of the shoes, attention was focused on the building itself.

A security officer checked areas usually off limits to students, including the roof, Mr. Beckman said. Students are warned that going on the roof can result in their being kicked out of the dorm. Nothing was found on the roof, Mr. Beckman said.

About 5 p.m., a security officer checked the area around the bottom of the fire escapes and found Mr. Vongtau’s phone. He also heard what sounded like a soft moan, Mr. Beckman said.

At 5:11 p.m., Chief Blatus arrived on the scene.

From the fire escape of the adjacent building, firefighters could see where Mr. Vongtau was located, and they quickly determined that the safest way to get to him was through the wall of the garage.

“It was a painstaking process,” Chief Blatus said. They cut through two layers of cinder blocks, being careful not to cause structural damage to the building or further harm to Mr. Vongtau.

It was also critical to get him medical treatment.

Doug Isaacs, the medical director for the Fire Department, said one of the biggest risks in such a rescue was “smiling death,” when a victim initially seems fine when he is removed but soon dies because of internal wounds.

Even as firefighters were opening up the wall, Dr. Isaacs was working to give Mr. Vongtau medication and assess his condition. Though Mr. Vongtau was conscious, he was not coherent. Still, Dr. Isaacs said that he came to understand that he had fallen at least 10 stories.

After 36 hours of being trapped, Mr. Vongtau was saved by the decisions that emergency responders made in minutes, something he seemed aware of when Dr. Isaacs visited him in the hospital on Monday.

“We bring good medicine to bad places,” Dr. Isaacs said. “He told his mother that he compared us to the Navy SEALs, very efficient in what we did.”

Vivian Yee contributed reporting.

A version of this article appears in print on November 5, 2013, on page A18 of the New York edition with the headline: Caught Between Two Buildings For 36 Hours, And Surviving. Order Reprints|Today's Paper|Subscribe