Room For Debate: Open Shelving

There are few design decisions that draw as much controversy as open shelving. The critics are up in arms about the extra work needed to keep it clean—the enthusiasts love the incentive to stay tidy. One side hates having their pieces out for the world to see, the other appreciates a great display. One thing's certain: It inspires a great debate. We asked our Facebook community to share their opinions.

Advertisement - Continue Reading Below

PRO

"I like it. Easier to keep clean because you can actually see in and around. I also think it gives one a sense of pride showing off nice dishware." -Constance Lahr Koopman

"I'm on the open shelving team. I don't like the completely-organized look where everything is tucked behind doors. Plus, I don't live for having everything clean. It's not the main priority in my life, thus, it's not a criterium in my choice of kitchen. I go for character and warmth; I put my stuff on display." -Merel van Haastert

"I'm a proponent... It forces you to stay organized because there's nowhere to hide anything." -Helene Adélé

"I like the idea of showing off beautiful kitchenware; whether it be China, crystal, pottery, or cool pots and pans. It is an informal and relaxed look, and great for the cook to access tools." -Sharran Parkinson

"Love it... If you are not a slob" -Maureen Bradbury

AGAINST

"No open shelves wanted in my kitchen—too much cleaning (dust and grease.) And the dogs would break stuff at reachable heights." -Shino Okumura

"No on this. Keeping stuff inside cabinets keeps it cleaner; my hutch has open shelving and the stuff needs cleaning all the time. Also, open shelving holding a lot of stuff makes the kitchen feel jumbled rather than sleek and clean. It's trendy, but has lots of downsides." -Suzanne Caston Topham

"I personally don't care for open shelves, but then I do my own cleaning." -Diane Courtney Bush