Nadal has played (and won) more matches than Serena and has more titles

And all this despite being 5 years younger and turning pro 6 years later. I guess it shows the massive gulf in the quality of the mens and women's tours that such a great player like Serena is inferior in many metrics to only the 2nd best player of this era.

Nadal is closer to the male goat(Federer) than Serena is to the female goat(Graf). Nadal has a lot of work to do and people believe eventually he'll reach tier 1 great, but Serena is too far behind to reach tier 1.

All in all, a pretty weird comparison: being injury prone, having to deal with a half sister's murder, and simply having interests outside of tennis are all reasons for that. IMO people regard Serena's career more highly as a woman player than BP's as a male player.

Nadal is closer to the male goat(Federer) than Serena is to the female goat(Graf). Nadal has a lot of work to do and people believe eventually he'll reach tier 1 great, but Serena is too far behind to reach tier 1.

How is Nadal not a tier 1 great?!?!? I mean yeah he is weak on no.1 weeks, no YEC, and a disproportionate amount of his majors are at the French, but the man still has 11 majors and the career slam.

Only an idiot like yourself thinks Serena is not a tier 1 GOAT. Navratilova, Evert, and Graf ALL have said Serena is a top 5 player all time and amongst them. Even if she isnt the GOAT she is one of them. What a clown like you says means nothing when the best female players of all time regard Serena as one of them as well.

Nadal meanwhile is already a tier 1 great as well. Tier 1 men are Laver, Federer, Gonzales, Rosewall, Sampras, Nadal, and possibly Tilden and Borg.

You're such a fanatic. 22 > 15. She has a long way to go and I don't think she'll ever reach tier 1 great or in the level of Graf/Martina. As I've mentioned above, Nadal is 1 tier behind(for now), period.

Quote:

Originally Posted by NadalAgassi

The biggest reason many are now starting to see Serena as the GOAT

In your dream. Most people have Graf and Martina as #1 and #2, just like most people have Fed as #1 and Laver #2. Serena is ranked around #6.

Only an idiot like yourself thinks Serena is not a tier 1 GOAT. Navratilova, Evert, and Graf ALL have said Serena is a top 5 player all time and amongst them. Even if she isnt the GOAT she is one of them. What a clown like you says means nothing when the best female players of all time regard Serena as one of them as well.

Nadal meanwhile is already a tier 1 great as well. Tier 1 men are Laver, Federer, Gonzales, Rosewall, Sampras, Nadal, and possibly Tilden and Borg.

QFT ...........TMF doesn't have a clue what he is talking about. A Fedlard like him thinks that if he writes it frequently enough, it will become true. Pathetic indeed......

Agreed. Yes, Martina, Chris and most importantly Graf have all said Serena is one of the greatest of all time on their level, and unlike the case of Federer, where retired players have flip flopped on his status, this has never happened with Serena.

Speaks volumes about who is the true tennis legend of the 2000s.

But we know certain TW members essentally wear a kind of pointed hood over their faces while finding any reason to attack the Williams family.

Wait, you actually think Serena is a greater and more famous player than Federer? LOL you are really insane