So finished my first season as Everton and managed to get 3rd in the League - very happy, and so were the board, giving me 21 million to spend in the Summer window.

I didn't think too much when I saw Salvatore Bocchetti on a Free, so I signed him. Now I have four quality centre backs in Jagielka (average rating last season 7.88), Fallou Diagne (8.08), Heitinga (7.65) and now Bocchetti!

I am either going to sell Jagielka or Heitinga, but don't know which. Who is the better player do you think? Obviously Jagielka is a bit older, but Heitinga is slower, etc.

Keep all 4. You need 4 quality center backs at any top club. Even more so when you are competing in Europe. Heitinga and Bocchetti can both play in other positions so their versatility is good to have around.

Everton's (and in particular Jagielka's) history with injuries is not good. I wouldn't sell any of them.

I always sell heitinga second season, hes on a lot of money and is getting old, and can always pick up 12mil+ after a good 1st season. Sell and buy a younger replacement. Caulker is normally interested as he doesnt get much game time.

Sell Heitinga, Jagielka is one of the eight home grown players you need in the champs league and if I remember correctly you have already got rid of some of the others to fill that quota. Have a look to see if Munoz is available, I got him for 7m at the start of the second season. If not Smalling might be.