Since the theme of the night is punk—the gala serves as the official kickoff to the Metropolitan Museum of Art’s exhibit “Punk: From Chaos to Couture“—we expected a pretty jaw-dropping red carpet, but the night’s fashion left a bit to be desired. That’s not to say there weren’t any bright moments. Miley Cyrus killed it in a glittering fishnet body-contouring gown by Marc Jacobs, complete with spiky platinum blonde hair, Sarah Jessica Parker wore a very Carrie Bradshaw-esque Philip Treacy headdress that recalled the iconic punk mohawk, and Ashley Olsen radiated in orange vintage Dior Couture.

Click through the gallery above to see all the looks from the night’s red carpet! And tell us in your unfiltered comments below: whose outfit do you love? Whose do you, well, not love?