Taste Test: Salt and Straw's Thanksgiving Ice Cream Flavors

What happened when our editors dipped their spoons into turkey-flavored ice cream.

Most Read

Thanksgiving came early in the CL offices today when popular Portland, Oregon, ice cream shop Salt and Straw sent us their new flavors, primed for a holiday feast. Naturally, our editors were more than happy to dig in and give these festive flavors a whirl. Here's what they had to say:

"The sweet potato is really rich; the pecans are sweet. But there's something else. Oh! There's caramel in it! And marshmallow. I like the marshmallow with the sweet potato." - Jy Murphy, research editor

"This really tastes like pie with whipped cream on top. This is the most delicious ice cream. It even reminds me of marshmallow fluff." - Jessica Leigh Hester, associate editor

"This tastes exactly like a creamy pumpkin pie, with a little whipped cream on top. Instead of making a pumpkin pie, I would totally buy a pie crust, fill it with this ice cream, and top with whipped cream. I think I'd like it better than a normal pumpkin pie. " - Danielle Lipp, copy chief

Has our taste test piqued your interest? Salt and Straw's Thanksgiving variety packs check in at $65, and the flavors will be available in stores or online from November 1 through November 29.