It came down to a decision between lesbian firefighter Dani and spiky-haired hetero-guy Billy — and Tila Tequila chose Billy Banhart. But true love wasn’t in the cards for the reality TV sensation and Internet star, and the couple split up soon after.

But while Tequila cites scheduling and work conflicts as the reason for the couple’s split, Banhart says that his relationship with Tila never got off the ground. "She never called me after the last show and no one would give me her number," he said.

Shot at Love, which had 16 women and 16 men competing for Tequila’s affections, was one of MTV’s most successful reality TV shows in history.

The bisexual bombshell will begin filming a second season soon, and the show will air this spring.

"This time I wanna find love for real," said Tequila. Of course she does!