What was your favorite quote/scene from the episode?Matt: It was short, it was simple and it wasn't snarky. But, man, it got me when Elena told Caroline "We're gonna slumber it." The show doesn't often stop and focus on friendship moments such as this. It was beautiful.

Steve: My favorite of many great Damon quotes was, "I'm steering clear of all women at the moment... trust me, it's in the best interests of women everywhere."

Eric: Can I just cite the entire fight sequence between the vampires and werewolves in the woods? Very dramatic and well-filmed all around. And I didn't see Jonah coming to the rescue!

Do you trust John Gilbert?Matt: On one hand, he tried to burn Damon alive. On the other hand, he has recently-sewn-back-on fingers. So it's hard to say. But I was moved by his speech to Elena and his rejection of the ring he gave Jeremy and am willing to give him the benefit of the doubt. For now.

Steve: Does anyone? This guy was shady even before this mysterious, quasi-unexplained return that smacks of suspiciousness.

Eric: Yes, I trust him... to keep me guessing about his intentions!

Hotter Damon scene: Shower or bathtub?Matt: The bathtub. Call me a sucker for blood and bubbles.

Steve: Best tie ever. The only downside? Every subsequent episode not bookended by Ian Somerhalder in the shower will now feel like a letdown.

Eric: The shower. The tears in my eyes from Damon's touching admissions to Andie made it difficult to see a lot of the bathtub scene.

Are you on Team Caroline or Team Tyler?Matt: Team I Understand Both Sides. I felt worse for Caroline, of course, because she was tortured for hours and all. But put yourself in Tyler's position: he's as confused and lost as one can be. I don't blame the guy for his hesitation in unlocking that cage.

Steve: Going with my girl Caroline on this one. Vampires all the way. I like Tyler, but haven't seen enough of his team to feel any sort of loyalty to his canine kin. Plus, Caroline is very cute.

Eric: Team Tyler has alliteration going for it, but Team Caroline is on the side of the girl who was trying to protect her friends and who was shot full of wooden bullet holes. I'll go with the latter.

When the heck did Jeremy and Bonnie start dating?!?Matt: I have no idea, but I was very troubled by their sudden closeness last night. Fans haven't come together to finalize a nickname yet. Jonnie? Beremy?!? Hurry up and sound off!

Steve: Around the time Alaric went looking for Isobel, happened to find John and decided it'd be cool to bring him back instead because he can help. Both developments were sprung on us out of nowhere.

Eric: Who said they were dating? High school is all about hook ups these days. Just because Jeremy put his arm around Bonnie, and just because they shared a table at the Grill, doesn't mean they are anything more than friends with benefits.

Follow The Vampire Diaries

What was your favorite quote/scene from the episode?"Better watch your back. Because I might need to get a hero hairdo of my own and steal your thunder." That was hilarious! Do you trust John Gilbert?idk, the guy want to get katherine's out of the tumb? that can't be good

caroline did so save stefan and damon from her mother and the other people that was going to kill stefan and damon. I don't trust john. I like both the shower and tub scene. now only if we could see stefan in the shower and in a tub

What was your favorite quote/scene from the episode?"Better watch your back. Because I might need to get a hero hairdo of my own and steal your thunder." i was actually creasing!Do you trust John Gilbert?I think i do! Because in one of the previous episodes him and isobel were like "she's our daughter we have to protect her blah blah blah." so i don't think he would do anything to hurt elena!Hotter Damon scene: Shower or bathtub?BATH! Seriously amazing i've watched the scene like 6 times!!!!Are you on Team Caroline or Team Tyler?I'm team "Tylerine" i want them to be together so bad! But see in that last ep i was heartbroken for car!When the heck did Jeremy and Bonnie start dating?!?I was like WTH when you see them on the date and hugging and stuff! It's good but totally random!

grilledcheese!*•February 04, 2011 21:20

i agree with this , but since when is high school all about hookups? not everyone's a hoe :P the vampire diaries isn;t the best show in the moral category , but i love it all the same :)

Blairfan<3•February 04, 2011 20:56

But you already say it, it was her mom so that is more logical. Tyler didn't know Jules that well. And Caroline was his friend all the time he needed her, even when she could easily be killed by him (by full moon). Caroline only wanted to protect him and her friends. But I still love Tyler and Caroline together!!

drich61•February 04, 2011 20:50

Caroline didn't instantly step in to help her friend Stefan either when her Mom was about to Kill Damon and Stefan. She also needed to process first.