Strawberry Santas

"I saw these in a magazine years ago, and I finally made them this Christmas. They get a 10 on the cuteness scale! Make sure to use extra-long toothpicks — or you'll have trouble securing them all the way through to the cookie."

Sugar Plums

(Don't Eat The) Yellow Snowmen Cookies

"Everyone knows you shouldn't eat yellow snow, but kids and grownups alike will get a kick out of making an exception in this case. The lemon cake mix guarantees a shortcut to tangy cookies that look as sweet as they taste."