"Thugs Surround Innocent Man and Family in SUV. One Thug Run Over as Man Attempts to Escape."

^^Fixed it for ya.^^

You added quite a bit of spin, so for you, "misleading" means that it left out your personal judgement of what happened. My title is simple and without value judgement. The simple fact is that the SUV driver ran over a biker. Right or wrong, he did so and I chose my wording on purpose so as not to cast innocence or blame in either direction. I wanted to prove a point which you are helping me make.