To date, we’re 13 seasons into the CW’s hit series Supernatural – a show that started out as a monster-of-the-week romp, but has since woven a rich tapestry of mythology. Kripke and the gang never could have predicted such longevity.

All things considered, they’ve done a good job keeping track of things, but with well over 200 episodes in the can, the writers are bound to slip up once in a while and they’re especially liable to start pulling narratives out of nowhere. It’s hard to blame them considering they thought they were going to be done after season 5. Had they known the legs that their little show would have, they might not have brought out the apocalypse until much later.

With all that in mind, we’re willing to throw them a bone every once in a while (like ret-conning Loki into the angel Gabriel, and introducing a parallel dimension wherein Bobby is alive, the Winchesters were never born, and the angels rule a post-apocalyptic wasteland). But some of the plot holes, inconsistencies, conveniently discovered powers, and dropped plots are so glaring that they simply must be addressed.

That’s just what we plan to do with Supernatural’s 15 Unforgiveable Plot Holes We Can’t Unsee.

For a long time, superheroes were universally revered in their respective universes. Evil was afoot, and most folks were just glad someone was there to help them out of their jams. Sure, you’d get the occasional detractor, like J. Jonah Jameson, the newspaper editor who had it in for Spider-Man. But, for the most part, heroes could do no wrong. In fact, they were so good at their jobs that civilian casualties were virtually non-existent. Sure, destruction of property was rampant, but everyone seemed to understand that was all just collateral damage. When a civilian did die, it would be a major plot point and our heroes would be wracked with guilt over it. But in recent years, superheroes have gotten pretty sloppy, and the people are not pleased.

Here are 16 times that our careless crusaders had lapses in judgment, or were just plain oblivious to the safety of the powerless people unfortunate enough to be caught up in their bad guy beefs.