Who holds the most cloud computing patents now? A preliminary analysis

Transcription

1 Who holds the most cloud computing patents now? A preliminary analysis Prior to becoming an IBMer, I was very fortunate to work at a company called Transpacific IP (a well-known intellectual property acquisition, management and consulting firm headquartered in Asia). This unique experience gave me first-hand knowledge of how patents can serve as a vital strategic value to a corporation. Up until now, I ve noticed there has been little discussion regarding cloud-computing patents in our Thoughts on Cloud blog. Thus, I believe it would be interesting to shed some light on who are the primary cloud computing patent holders now. But before we delve into the topic, what is a patent exactly? According to the USPTO (United States Patent and Trade Office): A patent is a property right granted by the Government of the United States of America to an inventor to exclude others from making, using, offering for sale, or selling the invention throughout the United States or importing the invention into the United States for a limited time in exchange for public disclosure of the invention when the patent is granted. Please pay attention to the verb exclude. In essence, unless the patent owner is willing to license the rights, the patent owner is the only entity that can use the invention for commercial usage. Please also note that a granted US patent is only valid in the US. In order to exercise the rights of the patent in other countries, the invention must go through the patent application process of that particular country. Consequently, for any strategically important patent, there will always be a patent family, where the same patent has been granted by multiple countries. As competition rapidly intensifies in the cloud computing market, IT companies are racing to increase their cloud computing patent portfolio. Sooner or later, like the raging smartphone patent war we have seen between Apple, Samsung, HTC and so forth, a similar war will be waged in the cloud computing industry. Please understand with no professional patent analysis tool on hand and limited free time, I needed to narrow down my search scope and concentrate on patents that included the phrase cloud computing in either the patent title, abstract or claims (claims define the scope of the patent protection). Although this only covers part of the overall cloud computing patents that have been issued (some may not have the phrase cloud computing in it), it provides a glimpse as to who are the major players now. The results of my analysis are presented in the following graphs and tables. Figure 1 shows the number of issued US patents. The reason behind the special attention on US patents is because they are considered more valuable than those granted by other

2 countries. This is because many of the patent infringement cases are filed in the US. Meanwhile, Figure 2 portrays the number of patent families. The family consists of patents based on the same invention filed in different countries. Noteworthy, the family may not necessarily include a US patent. The purpose of this figure is to depict the cloud computing application trend. Separately, Tables 1 and 2 respectively show the Top 6 and Top 10 IPC (International Patent Classification) codes that were assigned to the patent families and US patents. As defined by WIPO (World Intellectual Property Organization), The International Patent Classification (IPC), established by the Strasbourg Agreement 1971, provides for a hierarchical system of language independent symbols for the classification of patents and utility models according to the different areas of technology to which they pertain. The IPC code for Table 1 ends at the 3 rd hierarchal level, while Table 2 ends at the 5 th (the technology classification for the latter is more detailed than the former). The reason for stopping at the 3 rd level for Table 1 is because the IPC code type increases sharply when at the 4 th or 5 th level. Thus, a significant amount of time would be needed to compile the statistics. Essentially, based on the Top 10 IPC codes, we can infer which codes are primarily used for cloud computing. For everyone s easy reference, I have summarized my findings in bullet points. The data was compiled with the help from a good friend using the Thompson Innovation patent analysis tool during November of Figure 1. Number of US patents with phrase "Cloud Computing" in title, abstract or claims (as of November, 2013) Number of Patents IBM Microsoft Sharp Lab of America Google Novell SAP AG Amazon Tech Company Name Honeywell Verizon patent & licensing EM C As of November of 2013, there were a total of 167 issued US patents with the phrase cloud computing in either the patent title, abstract or claims. IBM currently tops the list with 42 patents. IBM appears serious in securing its leadership in the cloud computing industry.

3 Many well-known technology companies are seen in the graph. It is interesting to note that companies such as HP, AT&T, SalesForce and so forth are not found. Possible reasons include: Most of their cloud computing patents don t have the phrase cloud computing in either the patent title, abstract or claims. Their inventions are still in the patent application phase. Number of patents they have are relatively lower. Excluding Sharp (Japan) and SAP AG (Germany), all of the companies listed in the graph are headquartered in the US. Cloud computing will likely be an important growth industry to the US economy. 957 Figure 2. Number of patent families with phrase "Cloud Computing" in title, abstract or claims (as of November, 2013) Number of Patent Families Li ZongCheng IBM Microsoft Langchao Electronic ZTE Inspur Beijing Company Name Kore a Ele ctronics Telecomm KT corp Univ Nanjing Posts & Telecom Verizon Patent & Licensing As of November of 2013, there were a total of 1,616 patent families with the phrase cloud computing in either the patent title, abstract or claims. Mr. Zong Cheng Li, who is a professor from Su Zhou University (information obtained from Baidu) tops the list with a whopping 957 patent families. This is astonishing, where a single inventor instead of a company is the owner for so many patent families. Most of the families probably consist of China patents. Compared to the other technology companies in Figure 1, IBM and Microsoft are the most aggressive in building a comprehensive cloud computing patent family. Most of the companies in Figure 2 are China and Korea based. The two countries appear to be aggressively seeking a firm foothold in the cloud computing industry.

4 The huge gap between the total number of patent families (1,616 in total) and US patents (167 in total) show most of the patents in the patent families are being filed with non-us patent offices. Based on the data from Table 1 and 2, it appears the majority of the cloud computing patents are centered around the following three IPC codes: H04L (Transmission of digital information) G06Q (Data processing systems or methods) G06F (Electric digital data processing)

5 Conclusion Needless to say, cloud computing will be a technology that will revolutionize our world. But to fully tap the cloud computing market potential, players will need a strong patent portfolio to both protect oneself and to attack any patent infringers. IBM seems to have established a good start in this respect (way to go IBM!). It is interesting to point out that although there has been a lot of talk regarding IBM vs Amazon in the offering of cloud services, patent-wise, the challenge from Microsoft should not be overlooked. Separately, a very surprising discovery from this research is the hundreds of patent families owned by Mr. Zong Cheng Li. It will be worth seeing how he intends to utilize these patent families. Will a wave of patent infringement cases be filed? Or will it bring forth the next wave of innovation? Let s wait and see. All in all, I hope this article will help readers have a better understanding regarding the cloud computing industry from a patent standpoint. Before I wrap up this article, I would like to extend my special thanks to Neo, Alston and Blanche for their help and input!

LTE Standard Essential Patents Now and in the Future Marshall Phelps and Cheryl Milone Driving Next Generation LTE A portfolio of high quality and comprehensive essential LTE patents that rapidly evolves

INTRODUCTION At first, the Internet of Things (IoT) may seem like an idea straight out of science fiction. However, on closer consideration, we realize that the process of connecting everyday electronic

Private Cloud Expected to Grow at Twice the Rate of Public Cloud In This Paper Security, privacy concerns about the cloud remain SaaS is the most popular cloud service model in use today Microsoft, Google

Protecting Your Ideas: An Introduction to Intellectual Property Rights By Sasha G. Rao and Andrew J. Koning You have an idea. Something that s going to revolutionize the industry. You re excited, but before

Patent data mining and effective patent portfolio management There are many tools that help put patent mining theory into practice. Knowing how to use them can be a key element in developing a commercially

- 1 - Terms and Conditions LEGAL NOTICE The Publisher has strived to be as accurate and complete as possible in the creation of this report, notwithstanding the fact that he does not warrant or represent

Powerpoint Presentation http://libguides.nus.edu.sg/patents Section on Guides, Tutorials, etc. NUS Libraries 2012-2016 No part of this publication may be reproduced or transmitted in any form or by any

Google's Patent Counsel on the Ongoing Tech-Patent Wars Brian Glaser Corporate Counsel November 08, 2011 The big tech companies want the end-of-year gadget story to be about the nifty smartphones, e-readers,

Is the Beats Electronics Acquisition Overpriced? Intellectual Property Analysis of Beats Electronics LLC May 12, 2014 On May 8, 2014, multiple news sources reported that Apple, Inc. was close to acquiring

How to Effectively Analyze a Patent Portfolio By Ron Simmer Patscan University of British Columbia Established in 1986 to assist Tech Transfer Process by providing access to patents Serves all university

Healthcare CLOUD-BASED TECHNOLOGY MARKET IN HEALTHCARE APPLICATIONS The cloud market that reached about 130 billion at the end of 2013, is promising significant platform for data storage and application

Many people think that Ideas constitute an Invention. In this module, we make the distinction between an idea and an invention more clear. 1 2 The invention process for the successful inventor should start

Patent and Trademark Searching Provisional v. Non-provisional Applications Provisional Patent Application only serves as a place-holder and a patent will not issue from a Provisional Patent Application.

BOISE STATE UNIVERSITY THE INVENTOR'S GUIDE The purpose of the Inventors Guide is to answer the most common questions regarding inventions, patents and technology commercialization. The guide is designed

Brochure More information from http://www.researchandmarkets.com/reports/2123828/ Internet of Things Market in China 2012 Description: The Internet of Things Market in China is part of Netscribes Information

IAB Email Marketing Series 2014 Ryan Hickling, Head of Email, TMW Landscape Over the past two to three years we ve seen a massive change in the way consumers interact with brands digitally. As technology

IP protection and patent filing strategies: an overview Alberto Di Consiglio, EPFL -TTO Cluj, 21.03.2015 A real life example You have a technology and you want to find a industrial partner Partners usually

Inventions & Patents: Marketing a New Idea About Intellectual Property Intellectual Property (IP) refers to the rights assigned to individuals who have created an original work. This can include inventions,

Forward Looking Statement This presentation contains forward-looking statements which are statements that refer to expectations and plans for the future and include, without limitation, statements regarding

Technology Insight Report Billing Technologies in Cloud Computing Cloud computing is a paradigm shift in the way computing resources such as processing power, memory, data storage and bandwidth are utilized

Eight Great Technologies Big Data A patent overview Intellectual Property Office is an operating name of the Patent Office #8Great This report was prepared by the UK Intellectual Property Office Informatics

INTERNET USAGE AND THE POTENTIAL EFFECT IN YOUR MANAGEMENT OF YOUR PATENT PROGRAM Steven D. Hemminger Lyon & Lyon, LLP {1} Much has been written and said about the Internet and the benefits for a company

2015/7/11 Advanced Technical English English / Japanese 0M100100 Advanced Technical English School Graduate School of Engineering and Science(Master's Program) Course Common subjects Grade Semester Spring/Fall

The State Of Mobile Apps Created for the AppNation Conference with Insights from The Nielsen Company s Mobile Apps Playbook by The Nielsen Company Introduction Most Americans can t imagine leaving home

The following is an extraction from Marketing Ingenuity and Invention: an Innovation Guidebook, a publication from the Wisconsin Innovation Service Center. Marketing Ingenuity and Invention an Innovation

Patents Where do I start and how to I find what I need? Today s How-tos: 1.How to read a patent 2.Practical considerations mindy.thuna@utoronto.ca 3.How to search for patents Components of a Patent Cover

Intellectual Property Protection for Computer Software in the United States How can you protect what you or your client considers novel aspects of your computer software in the United States? What options

You ve Got a Million-Dollar Idea, But Can You Protect It? Patent Pending You ve got a brand-new product or service idea, one that you can build a successful business around. But there s still the milliondollar,

Changes in US Patent Law: How it Affects Researchers/Inventors ATIA Orlando, Florida February 2013 James A. Leahy Center on Knowledge Translation for Technology Transfer (KT4TT) University at Buffalo http://kt4tt.buffalo.edu/

INTELLECTUAL PROPERTY LAW FOR THE ENTREPRENEUR Peter R. Leal INTELLECTUAL PROPERTY FROM THE BEGINNING OF THE BUSINESS Next to its management team, intellectual property is a startup s most important asset.

Effective Use of Intellectual Property Data for Competitive Business Intelligence By Ron Simmer Patscan University of British Columbia Established in 1986 to assist Tech Transfer Process by providing access

PREPARE YOUR INCIDENT RESPONSE TEAM JUNE 2015 Michael Harrington, Fidelis Cybersecurity It s a big problem... The ongoing cyber-thefts from The scale of international theft the In networks 2013, the of

The Internet of Things in Smart Buildings 2014 to 2020 THIS REPORT IS A NEW 2014 STUDY WHICH MAKES AN OBJECTIVE ASSESSMENT OF THE MARKET FOR INTERNET OF THINGS TECHNOLOGIES, NETWORKS AND SERVICES IN BUILDINGS

Open Source Why it s a big deal for your business software Sponsored by Webanywhere Ltd. partnered with Copyright Webanywhere Ltd 2011. All Rights Reserved. 1 What do we mean by Open Source? For readers

LexisNexis TotalPatent Search the largest online collection of enhanced first-level patent data When it comes to innovation and protection of intellectual property, you need a resource that provides you

We will begin momentarily at 2pm ET Slides available now! Recordings will be available to ACS members after one week. www.acs.org/acswebinars Contact ACS Webinars at acswebinars@acs.org 1 Have Questions?

1 Mobile Internet in Asia is the Next Big Thing The China & India Story The mobile internet industry has been growing at an exponential rate in countries across Asia in the past 3 or 4 years, it has reached

CHAPTER 4.2 How to Read a Biotech Patent Carol Nottenburg, Principal/Patent Lawyer, Cougar Patent Law, U.S.A. ABSTRACT This chapter provides an annotated description of a sample U.S. patent. The U.S. patent

Intellectual Property Protection for Websites By Donika Ilieva, IP and ICT lawyer Nowadays companies cannot afford to ignore the internet, which provides a global market where they can place their products

WRITTEN TESTIMONY OF KEVIN MANDIA CHIEF EXECUTIVE OFFICER MANDIANT CORPORATION BEFORE THE SUBCOMMITTEE ON CRIME AND TERRORISM JUDICIARY COMMITTEE UNITED STATES SENATE May 8, 2013 Introduction Thank you

Using Patent Analysis to Supercharge Patent Licensing Programs Prepared for: About AcclaimIP and FPO 10 years experience bringing patent data to millions of users. The AcclaimIP project started in 2010

Inspiring Insight The real impact of mobile on the corporate travel program A global research paper from Travelport and ACTE The real impact of mobile on the corporate travel program Executive introduction