The band has retained the same lineup since its formation, with the only exception being bassist Ryan Neff, who left the band in 2007 and rejoined in 2009. Miss May I released their second studio album, Monument, on August 16, 2010; their third album, At Heart, on June 12, 2012; their fourth, Rise of the Lion, on April 29, 2014; and their fifth, Deathless, on August 7, 2015. On June 24, 2016, the band left Rise Records and signed with SharpTone Records.[5]

Miss May I was formed in 2007, in Troy, Ohio with the original members being Levi Benton, Justin Aufdemkampe, BJ Stead, Jerod Boyd, and Ryan Neff.[2] Neff left in late 2007 to join Cincinnati band, Rose Funeral and was then replaced by Josh Gillespie.[citation needed]

In late 2007, the band released a 5-track EP titled Vows for a Massacre followed by their 2008 demo the next year, both of which were self-released. This demo contained 6 tracks, including "Architect" and "Tides", which would later on be featured in their first full-length album, Apologies Are for the Weak in 2009. It was after this release, that the band was signed onto Rise Records.[2]

According to the website of producer Joey Sturgis' Foundation Studios, Miss May I had booked studio time in May 2010 to ostensibly record the follow-up to their debut album.[2] According to Ryan Neff's Twitter, the new album would be released sometime in August along with a new music video.

On June 11, 2010, Levi Benton announced that there would be a track on the new album called "Colossal" and that the album would be called Monument and confirmed its release to be on August 17th of that year. The artwork for it was also later revealed, featuring the iconic MMI Lion from the cover of the band's debut. On September 2nd, 2010, Miss May I released their music video for "Relentless Chaos" Directed by Thunder Down Country. In December 2010, Miss May I then confirmed plans to appear at Warped Tour 2011.[2] The album peaked at 10 on the Top Hard Rock Albums chart, 15 on the Top Independent Albums chart, and 31 on the Top Rock Albums chart.[6] The band toured with Abandon All Ships, Sleeping with Sirens and Bury Tomorrow to support the album.

After finishing up touring for 2011, Miss May I entered the studio throughout the beginning of 2012 to work on a new album set for release sometime during the summer. On March 8th, 2012, the band announced that they had completed work on their new album titled At Heart and were set to release the album on May 29th 2012.[10]

To make last minute changes (as said in an interview by Levi Benton), the band bumped back the release, to June 12th, 2012.[11]

The band soon set out on tour with Whitechapel, After the Burial, The Plot in You, Rescued By A Sinking Ship, and Structures throughout March 2012, followed by a European tour with Parkway Drive, The Ghost Inside and Confession through April. The band also set out to tour with Whitechapel, The Ghost Inside, Within the Ruins and The Plot in You in the US during May 2012.[12] Miss May I released (Hey Mister) on May 3rd on Rise Record's YouTube page. The band played on Warped Tour in the summer of 2012,[13] and headlined the AP Tour in the fall. The band supported Bullet for My Valentine on their March 2013 UK tour alongside Halestorm. While also supporting Killswitch Engage for the United States Disarm the Descent tour in the Summer of 2013 with other supporting acts like Affiance, The Word Alive and Darkest Hour.

It was recently announced that they are back in the studio, working on new material for their fourth studio album, for a late 2013/early 2014 release with producer Terry Date. Levi Benton released a press statement regarding their plans for the new album,

"We don’t know a release date. We’re hoping for this year. We’re shooting really hard for this year but it might be early next year. We’re going to a really big producer this time, which we’re really excited about, and changing up the team again. We’re trying to change it every record just to see what we can do. I guess since we got a lot of acceptance on our last record, we have a more open door to doing crazier stuff. We were like dumbing it down a little bit before and now we can go full out. We’re working with Terry Date, he did Pantera, Slipknot, Limp Bizkit, the new Bring Me The Horizon record. We’re going to go 100 percent new Miss May I. We’re bringing the lion back as the art cover and we have some really cool new ideas."[14][15]

As of September 14, 2013 Miss May I have finished the initial recording sessions for their coming new album with producer Terry Date at Studio X in Seattle, WA. The group expect to return to the studio in November to wrap up tracking the effort.[16]

On November 20, 2013 the band described the sound of their forthcoming album via Metal Hammer with vocalist Levi Benton stating that "no two songs sound the same" and "...After a couple of years touring and growing, we’ve come back to writing and have been adding different influences. There’s some slower, heavier stuff, thrashier parts and no two songs sound the same. We’re doing something to challenge ourselves and our listeners but please both, too.".[18]

On December 14, 2013 the band announced that they are looking for a fan to get a tattoo of their infamous lion design for the cover of their forthcoming album.[19]

The band has posted three studio updates on their new album-dedicated website, www.mmiriseofthelion.com, which briefly detail the drums, guitars, and vocals for the new album. On February 25, 2014 Rise of the Lion was announced as the title of the new album. The album was released on April 29, 2014.

The band recorded their fifth studio album with Joey Sturgis, who recorded the band's first two records.[20] The album, titled Deathless, was released on August 7, 2015. The first single from Deathless, "I.H.E.", was released on June 17, 2015. Miss May I also played the entire 2015 Warped Tour, marking their third time on the tour. On July 29, 2015, the title track from Deathless was released as the second single for the album.

Miss May I supported Parkway Drive on their October 2015 Ire North American tour with Thy Art Is Murder and In Hearts Wake. They will then go on another tour with Blessthefall in February 2016 on their Drop the Gloves tour with The Plot in You, Sirens & Sailors and A War Within. The band also announced they would be returning to the UK for the first time in 2 years in May 2016, co-headlining a tour with We Came As Romans. They also announced a London date in which both bands are support for Memphis May Fire. They will also support Memphis May Fire & We Came as Romans on their Bands vs Food tour with For Today joining them as support.

In an interview with Guitar World, the band discussed how their influences have changed over the years. Guitarist Justin Aufdemkampe said he started by covering basic blues, then moved to pop punk by covering Blink-182, and Green Day, then eventually learned lead guitar by listening to and copying his dad’s Stevie Ray Vaughan records.[28] In the 10th grade, Justin started learning Taking Back Sunday, Underoath and Avenged Sevenfold songs. However, once he saw Atreyu at Warped Tour, his taste in music abruptly shifted. He then discovered As I Lay Dying, All That Remains and Darkest Hour, and began writing fast, aggressive originals.[28]

Guitarist B.J. Stead stated "I had been playing guitar for years, but not much metal. I mostly listen to Pink Floyd and straight rock."[28] In an interview with Alternative Press, it was said that B.J.'s favorite band is Iron Maiden.[38]

The band has stated on their influences:

“

Basically, any metal-core band that doesn’t have keyboards and who aren’t fake guys who just play instruments. We’re trying to be as old school as possible, as it’s been working out. So I’m happy with that.[31]

”

In an interview with WIDB, Levi stated on behalf of his biggest musical influences: "As I Lay Dying is definitely the biggest one that really sets Miss May I where we are. We like a lot of All That Remains, Unearth, Darkest Hour and, recently, In Flames. This is weird, because it’s not really the thing that everyone would say, but we're really interested in Five Finger Death Punch. We’ve been researching how they do everything because their story’s really cool. But As I Lay Dying and All That Remains are probably the biggest ones, along with Killswitch Engage"[29] Levi has stated his "dream tour" would be Lamb of God, As I Lay Dying, It Dies Today, and Atreyu.[34]

In an interview with Dayton Daily News writer Madeline Bush,[44] when asked what they thought their music conveyed, Benton replied:

“

"We have been asked a lot if we are a Christian band due to our lyrics. And the answer to that is no, but some of us are Christians and others are not. But myself as a Christian, I try and not put the wrong negative message out in our lyrics. Most of what we stand for is just a band that plays for the crowd to be happy, and to love what we are doing as much as we do."

The Corruption Tour- Whitechapel, Impending Doom, Miss May I, Oceano, I Declare War

No Guts, No Glory Tour- Miss May I, Pierce the Veil, Woe is Me, The Amity Affliction, letlive

Warped Tour 2011- A Day to Remember, Asking Alexandria, Black Veil Brides, The Devil Wears Prada, August Burns Red, The Acacia Strain, Attack Attack, I Set my Friends on Fire, Eyes set to Kill, Miss May I