Appeals court suspends DOE collection of nuke fees

WASHINGTON (AP) -- A federal appeals court on Tuesday ordered the Energy Department to suspend collection of about $750 million in fees annually for the permanent disposal of nuclear waste because the agency had no plans to use the money.

In a sharply worded opinion, the U.S. Court of Appeals for the District of Columbia said the Obama administration failed to provide a good reason why money for the federal Nuclear Waste Fund should continue to be collected.

The appeals court called a DOE analysis of the fee collection 'absolutely useless' and compared the agency's arguments to 'the old razzle dazzle' offered by a disreputable lawyer in the musical 'Chicago.'

Nuclear operators have paid more than $27 billion over the years to help cover the costs of long-term storage and disposal of nuclear waste from the nation's 100 commercial nuclear reactors. With interest, the fund is approaching an estimated $30 billion.

The money has sat idle for decades amid disputes about how to dispose of the waste. The Obama administration has moved to close a nuclear dump planned at Nevada's Yucca Mountain.

A DOE spokeswoman said the department was reviewing the court's opinion.

The Nuclear Energy Institute, an industry group, hailed the ruling.

'Today's decision confirms that the federal government cannot continue to defy Congress' explicit direction to implement a viable program to manage reactor fuel from America's nuclear power plants,' said Ellen Ginsberg, the institute's general counsel.

The court ruling 'reinforces the fundamental principle that the federal government's obligation is to carry out the law, whether or not the responsible agency or even the president agrees with the underlying policy,' Ginsberg said.

The ruling marked the second time in three months the D.C. Appeals Court has rebuked the administration over a continued stalemate on how to store and dispose of nuclear waste. The court ruled in August that the Nuclear Regulatory Commission was 'simply flouting the law' when it allowed the Energy Department to abandon the proposed Yucca Mountain waste site in Nevada. The action goes against a federal law designating Yucca Mountain as the nation's nuclear waste repository.

The appeals court at the time ordered the NRC to complete the review of Yucca Mountain and approve or reject the Energy Department's application for the never-completed project 90 miles from Las Vegas. The NRC said this week it has directed its staff to complete work on a key safety report related to Yucca Mountain.

In the opinion issued Tuesday, Senior Judge Laurence H. Silberman said the administration was contradicting itself in arguing that money for the Nuclear Waste Fund should continue to be collected even as the government no longer is pursuing Yucca Mountain as a long-term solution for nuclear waste storage.

The government 'cannot have it both ways,' Silberman wrote on behalf of a three-judge panel. 'It cannot renounce Yucca Mountain and then reasonably use its costs as a proxy' for determining how much money should be paid into the Nuclear Waste Fund.

'The government was hoist on its own petard,' Silberman wrote.

A group representing state utility regulators called the ruling great news for nuclear power consumers, who have spent billions to support nuclear waste storage. 'Unfortunately all they have to show for their investment is a hole in the Nevada desert,' said Charles Gray, executive director of the National Association of Regulatory Utility Commissioners.

Putting aside the political dispute about Yucca Mountain, 'nuclear-power ratepayers should not be charged for a program the federal government has closed down,' Gray said. 'Thankfully, because of today's actions, nuclear-power consumers will no longer have to pay for the government's mishandling of this program.'

Related news

SKB is currently undergoing authorising according to the Act on Nuclear Activities and Swedish Environmental Code for KBS-3, the Swedish system for disposal of nuclear waste. A part of the application concerns the construction of Clink, an integrated facility for interim storage and encapsulation of spent nuclear fuel in Oskarshamn, consisting of the current facility Clab and a new facility for encapsulation of spent nuclear fuel.
“Sweco will contribute with expertise and commitment in a broad range of...

There are not many jobs you could take on at the beginning of your working life and know they would still be nowhere near completed by the time you retired. But decommissioning the world’s nuclear power plants is one of them.
The estimates of the amounts of money involved in keeping old nuclear plants safe and dismantling them are so large that they are almost beyond comprehension − and unlikely to be accurate anyway.
The fact is that the problems are so difficult and so liable to complications that...

Researchers in the U.K. say they have found a way to turn radioactive waste into miniature diamond batteries to produce small electric currents that can last thousands of years.
A team of physicists and chemists from the University of Bristol unveiled the technology at a lecture in Europe late last month. The technique involves scraping away carbon-14, a radioactive isotope of carbon, from graphite blocks used to facilitate energy production in nuclear reactors. The scientists use the extracted carbon-14, in...

The prospect of using nuclear energy appears to deter European countries from adopting renewable technologies such as wind and solar, and from introducing energy efficiency measures.
Researchers say they found that countries in Europe intending to build new nuclear power stations have a poorer record of reducing their carbon emissions than those that have rejected the technology.
Europe has a higher concentration of nuclear power plants for its population than anywhere else in the world, although many of the...

The world’s leading nuclear research organisation National Nuclear Laboratory (NNL) has strengthened its waste reduction programme with investment in a heavy duty waste baler.
NNL is globally renowned for its nuclear research, technical development, reactor operations support, and the provision of decommissioning expertise for facilities throughout the UK.
But keen to advance its environmental stance and improve the efficiency of NNL’s hazardous waste management, the organisation has procured new...

Customer comments

No comments were found for Appeals court suspends DOE collection of nuke fees. Be the first to comment!