A lot of uneducated flailing in this thread. Brady is the GOAT. Rodgers is way up there too. Prime Vs Prime if I needed a QB to win the biggest game I’d go with Brady because I’ve seen him do it so many times. System or not the dude can execute at an insanely consistent level and make you pay if your defense isn’t on point. That said, you can’t go wrong with Rodgers there either.

Lol & people arguing about Brady vs. Rodgers when experts agree that both of them are brutally inferior to GOAT Breesus

Click to expand...

His numbers are much different outside of a dome if I’m not mistaken. He’s great too tho. But.. getting to play 8 or more games a year in a controlled climate is a great benefit to statistical prowess.

His numbers are much different outside of a dome if I’m not mistaken. He’s great too tho. But.. getting to play 8 or more games a year in a controlled climate is a great benefit to statistical prowess.

Click to expand...

I mean you have a point, his career #s are clearly better in a dome vs outside

But you have to take into account that all those outdoor games are also road games, and so it's to be expected that a QB (or any player really) would perform better at home. Regardless, a career 91.4 QB rating outdoors (on the road) is pretty elite

I'm more interested in how he performs in the yoffs, and as expected it turns out he's a ridiculously elite yoff QB with an absurd yoff QB rating (and Comp% and TD/INT ratio and YPG)
[If you extrapolate this^^ 13 game performance to a full season (16 games) yoff Breesus is putting up 5181 yards and 37 TDs (11 INTs) on 66% completion vs opposing yoff defenses]

I mean you have a point, his career #s are clearly better in a dome vs outside

But you have to take into account that all those outdoor games are also road games, and so it's to be expected that a QB (or any player really) would perform better at home. Regardless, a career 91.4 QB rating outdoors (on the road) is pretty elite

I'm more interested in how he performs in the yoffs, and as expected it turns out he's a ridiculously elite yoff QB with an absurd yoff QB rating (and Comp% and TD/INT ratio and YPG)
[If you extrapolate this^^ 13 game performance to a full season (16 games) yoff Breesus is putting up 5181 yards and 37 TDs (11 INTs) on 66% completion vs opposing yoff defenses]

Breesus also outshines Rodgers in the yoffs (though to a lesser degree)

Breesus is objectively the most dominant yoff QB of this era

Click to expand...

Get back to me on Brees’s ‘yoff’ numbers compared to Brady’s when he’s got 37 games and not 13 bud. 37 games is alot of games to drop stats off pct% and average wise. If anything, having so few playoff appearances on his resume given all his playing time is a knock on him in comparison to guys like Manning and Brady.

For what it’s worth, I definitely like Brees and ageee he’s up there too. But he is a stat whore playing in an era where the NFL has altered rules to facilitate that part of the game (passing). Obviously Brady, Manning and Rodgers have benefits there too. That’s why you need to look at more than stats imo.

I’ll also point out to all those in favor of Brees over Brady because of Billy B and the ‘system’.. Brees has been running a system under Sean Peyton -an elite offensive minded coach- during most of his success in the NFL too.

So, if it’s a knock on Brady for whatever reason, well, it’s a knock on Brees too..

I think one of Rodgers' issues is that he doesn't take enough chances unless it's at the very end of the game and they need that Hail Mary. He throws very few interceptions in no small part due to not taking some big chances, but that comes at a cost.