A web log on K-12 education policy -- with emphasis on teaching practices, curriculum, testing, accountability, school finance, and the federal, state, and local roles in public education.

Bill Evers is a research fellow at Stanford University's Hoover Institution; a member of the Hoover Institution's Koret Task Force on K-12 Education; a member of the editorial board of Education Next magazine; and a former assistant secretary for policy in the U.S. Department of Education.

Saturday, October 10, 2009

New NCTM HS Math Doc Does A Disservice

This document stands out more for what it omits rather than for what it includes. It is full of paeans to reasoning and sense-making that it--quite properly--hails as the hallmark of mathematics. Yet reasoning and sense-making are not exclusive to mathematics. They are the cornerstones of history, of physical sciences, of economics, and even of political science. The reason mathematics is unique, that it has been called the Queen and Servant of Science, is not because it is focused on reasoning and sense-making, but because it is focused on formal reasoning--on mathematical proofs.

Yet reading the new NCTM document one might well not notice the concept of proof. The word "proof" appears a scant 27 times in the body of this 145 page document, one third of them in the short opening chapter which ties reasoning and sense making to proof. Yet even there, the first appearance of "proof" is immediately followed by "however", as in "However, mathematical reasoning can take many forms, ranging from informal explanation ..." (p.4) Another half of the occurrences of "proof" is found in the single geometrical semi-proof example in the text, with the other five incidences sprinkled elsewhere. Contrast that with almost 500 occurrences of "reasoning" and over 200 occurrences of "sense making" in this document.

In fact, much of the document is spent trying to confound reasoning and sense-making (which are present in every discipline) with formal proofs that are unique to mathematics. This is presumably made in an effort to make mathematics more accessible, yet it amounts to pouring out the baby with the bathwater. Without exception, all of the discussion is centered around so-called "real world" examples, and abstraction is essentially unmentioned. Reasoning and sense making are indeed important, in mathematics as in history, yet they are not the defining characteristics of mathematics, as NCTM pretends they are. The formal aspects of mathematical proof, and its powerful abstractions, are what makes mathematics uniquely effective. Spending almost 150 pages with barely a mention of prerequisite mathematical knowledge and skills, and with nary a paragraph promoting proof or abstraction as the keys to mathematics, and to its enormous utility in all domains of life and science, is NCTM's disservice to all of us.

At this point it is almost pointless to mention the other deficiencies of this document: The exclusive focus on reasoning and sense-making comes with the deprecation of almost anything else in mathematics, and particularly skills and procedural fluency. Readers are warned that students may "capriciously invoke incorrect or baseless rules" without understanding (p.12) yet nowhere is a similar warning of careless or unsubstantiated reasoning given. Little time is spent on mentioning content, with the exception of promoting--without any research support--yet more probability, statistics, and discrete mathematics in the curriculum, topics that NCTM has been promoting for decades as its antidote to the "traditional math." Some things never change.

I am a college math professor. The NCTM types focus on reasoning, etc., but when these kids get to college they can't compute anything and even those who make it to Calculus are extremely weak. Besides emphazing proof (which any such document should) it should make it clear that students need to be strong at compuation. Thanks to the NCTM -like math de-education, we have had over 20 years of students who are lacking basic arithmetic, algebraic/trigometric skills and have absolutely no idea what a mathematical proof is. The Harvard Calculus text was the completion of the demolition of mathematics - make math open to all by taking out all theory and computations. What is left is math-lite, if that.

Thanks to the NCTM -like math de-education, we have had over 20 years of students who are lacking basic arithmetic, algebraic/trigometric skills and have absolutely no idea what a mathematical proof is

g proof (which any such document should) it should make it clear that students need to be strong at compuation. Thanks to the NCTM -like math de-education, we have had over 20 years of students who are lacking basic arithmetic, algebraic/trigometric skills

NCTM works great, they provide so many examples on mathematics, and i also agreed your saying that no body learn mathematics in one day and math contains so many concepts,which we either didnt here.Thanks for posting such great article.

Wow,NCTM take a nice step towards focus in high school mathematics,it's a responsibility of our government to pay attention also on these institution and provide new and fast technology because by these institution mathematics move towards more success.

Very nice written but very hard to understand because written with very hard vocabulary,although i like it becuase there are some thing which i understood and i use those things in my life that's why i like all it.

Hi, this is first time i am visiting your site and happy to see such a great article here, so many things new i came to know by your article. Thanks for all your efforts you made here for us. Will back soon for more updates.

Hi, this is first time i am visiting this site and so happy to see such a great info here, the way you guys described everything here is amazing. Thanks for all of your efforts you made here, will back soon for more updates.

ut his trust in a supplier of five years, who then framed Rubesch for his own crime. Even after the charges were dropped, with the case never making it to trial and the story pulled from the papers, Rubesch lhttp://rjandcogroup.com.au/

In 1952, Ray-Ban created another classic style, the Ray Ban Wayfarer 2140, this time with plastic frames. They soon became popular in Hollywood, and can be seen on James Dean in 1955’s Rebel Without a Cause.

whoah this weblog is terrific i really like reading your posts. carry on the terrific function! You already recognize, many persons ar seeking spherical for this data, youll be able to aid them greatly.

It was extremely beneficial for me. Retain sharing such tips in the future also. This was actually what I was trying to find, and I'm glad to come here! Thanks for sharing the such information with us.

this is very interesting, I will consider and thank you for sharing.Most of my own qustions continues to be awnsered.thanks. on all other issues I will find the answer on our site http://custom-paper-writing.org

Thanks for the article. Once I tried out some professional essay services. I was lucky to receive a well-written research paper on literature...So I would recommend using some external help in cases, your grades are on the line.

Sometimes many students need professional help with essay writing. This happens because nobody can be equally good at all subjects. That's why it is advisable to order custom essays from college essay help.

If you want to surprise your instructor with a well-structured and brilliant custom essay that is based on deep research, best-essays-writers.org is the right place to make an order.Do not hesitate to buy essays at best-essays-writers.org and see how your academic life changes!...I recommend it cause once i trusted them and never regretted http://www.best-essays-writers.org/

Great blog, just looking around some blogs, seems a really nice platform you are using.http://www.katespade-outlets.net/http://www.newjordans11shoes.net/http://www.outletmoncler-jackets.net/http://www.pardaoutlet-onlinestore.com/http://www.coachfactory-outlet.in.net/http://www.moncleroutlet-sale.us/http://www.prada-outlet-online.us/http://www.todsshoesoutlet.us/http://www.guccihandbagsoutletonlines.net/http://www.asicszapatos.es/ http://www.airjordans-retro2014.net/

Great post full of useful tips! My site is fairly good and I am also having a hard time getting my readers to leave comments. Analytics shows they are coming to the site but I have a feeling “nobody wants to be first”

Hello, as for me math it is the best subject in college! As for me, I don’t like writing! It is very hard for me to write essay or something other in writing tasks! That is why, I use only the best and cheked help as http://custom-writing.net ! It is the best way to save my tasks and my time! Thanks them very much)

Very interesting article. Thanks for it. Besides I agree with Jerry Rosen. It is awlful that students which come to colleges and universities are strongly weak in arithmetics. That is why I advise students go to this site http://www.papers-writings.com here you can buy top quality term papers and essays!

Bright career supposes to be on the first place in college students' life time. But, it's not easy to create hundreds the history essays during the studying process. Furthermore, no one man is able to manage with such heavy workload, however advanced-writer.com should do this simply. Thence you ought to rely on the advanced writer.

Hard work is needed to attain win in our life. This could be apply in any level of our life. If we are looking to score good in study or to succeed in our life or anything. Some are hiring help from college paper writing service to get good paper for the assignment task.

I agree great and really interesting article! But at school I hated mathematics, this why I go in university on humanities!But if you student and not understand something subject and not know what write in your assignments, you can address for help to professional writers from site http://essay-professors.com who write you quality essay or article in a short time

Sometimes writing academic papers can be too incomprehensible task for students, because often they cannot understand the topic wholly. I recommend academic-writings.com to order high-quality and original custom papers at not big prices.

Busy life circumstances than the current world history. Must try to earn money to support themselves, their families and pay for living. But not so that you neglect your own health, but more must cherish it.geometry dash , geometry dash game , geometry dash 2.0

Easily, the article is actually the best topic on this registry related issue. I fit in with your conclusions and will eagerly look forward to your next updates. Just saying thanks will not just be sufficient, for the fantasti c lucidity in your writing. I will instantly grab your rss feed to stay informed of any updates. baixar whatsapp, baixar whatsapp gratis, whatsapp baixar,

Just remember your stab at this business, should you decide to end it, is not a failure but a training ground. You will take with you what has worked and learned from what has not in order to make the next business idea a success!subway surfers game , subway surfer , subway surfers ,

Life becomes more interesting and wonderful when you share your memorable moments with friends and family through unique photographs. You can create your own unique style impressed with image editing software. And after hours of work stress you can also

Life becomes more interesting and wonderful when you share your memorable moments with friends and family through unique photographs. You can create your own unique style impressed with image editing software. And after hours of work stress you can also dr driving, dr driving baixar ,download dr driving, dr driving

I was very impressed by this post, this site has always been pleasant news. Thank you very much for such an interesting post. Keep working, great job! In my free time, I like play game: redball4games.com. What about you?