Mackinnon and Dworkin's Views on the Harmful Effects of Pornography

Suppose one accepts MacKinnon and Dworkin's suggested statutory definition of pornography. How does one who generally accepts MacKinnon and Dworkin's views on the pervasively harmful effect of pornography, and who accepts a need for legal redress of the harms perpetrated by pornography, deal with pornographic material? The ordinance proposed by MacKinnon and Dworkin would deal with such material by enacting legislation which gives people adversely affected by the works, which clearly fit their definition of pornography, a cause of action against the producers, vendors, exhibitors or distributors for "trafficking", or for an assault "directly caused by the specific work. I do not think liberals, or others for that matter, should have much problem with the clause dealing with assault, since a causal connection to specific works is demanded by it. However, s. 3.2(iii) which deals with trafficking would be very problematic for liberals and legal conservatives because it creates a cause of action for a person contrary to the traditional conception of a rights holder's cause of action. This subsection reads: Any woman has a claim hereunder as a woman acting against the subordination of women. Any man, child or transsexual who alleges injury by pornography in the way women are injured by it also has a claim. [emphasis added] My goal in this paper is to suggest that a slight modification to this subsection of the ordinance would make it very difficult for liberals and legal conservatives to object to it. This modification would restrict the cause of action to the same persons as the other sections of the ordinance, namely, the particular victim of the specified injury. I shall argue that such a modification would largely cohere with the conception of harm already at work in Ontario law, would afford only a minor reduction in the potential efficacy of such legislation in curbing the harm of pornography, and would offer to empower the feminist camp which is behind such an ordinance with a mechanism for social and political change if a sufficiently organized feminist "vanguard" took hold of the opportunity to empower women. Adrian Howe argues that the concept of social injury which may be suggested by the ordinance recognizes the differential harm felt by women from pornography. Howe suggests this social notion of harm may be a necessary feature of any successful law reform which is to address the huge social problem of male domination and female oppression. The liberal notion of an individuated human right fails to capture, for MacKinnon and Howe, "the specificity of the harm to women." Thus, an ordinance which did not create a cause of action "for women as women" would fail to address the root of the social problem of which pornography is a manifestation. This conception of social harm, and thus subsection 3.2(iii), may offend liberals or legal conservatives in two ways. First, the notion of non-individuated harm is antithetical to the liberal conception of a rights holder claiming a cause of action. Fundamental to a liberal conception of harm is the notion of the individual who is autonomous, separate and fundamentally worthy of respect. Rawls and Kant exemplify this view in their analyses when they posit the undifferentiated self, free of any particular qualities save that of being an agent worthy of a fundamental, inviolable respect. This notion of the individual worthy of equal concern and respect in the eyes of the state permeates liberal conceptions of rights. It is also a fundamental, if not exclusive, tenet of the common law of torts: In tort litigation, the courts must decide whether to shift the loss suffered by one person, the plaintiff, to the shoulders of another person [emphasis added]. Clearly, on its face this conception of harm precludes the notion of a harm suffered collectively which cannot be delineated individually. While class actions are possible, and claims may be made on behalf of groups such as company...

You May Also Find These Documents Helpful

...The Effects of Pornography in Our Culture Today
Pornography is a constant debate. Everyone has an opinion on the subject. Many people say pornography is bad for society as a whole. There are many negative effects of pornography, such as an increased likelihood of sexually aggression, the objectification of women, and the imbalanced relationship in pornography may be integrated into real life relationships. Pornography has extensive, destructive effects that are too great to defend.
Pornography, especially violent pornography, may amplify the probability of sexual aggression. Violent pornography may provide one with the impression that sexual aggression is acceptable. In a study conducted by Kelly Davis, men were more likely to be sexually aroused by a portrayal of pornographic rape when the victim “was portrayed as experiencing sexual arousal during the rape (as is typical of rape portrayals in pornography) rather than disgusted” (Davis 3). The violent behavior caused the men to become aroused instead of disgusted, as they should have been. The behavior depicted in the film was acceptable to the men. Violent pornography enforce the idea “that women like to be treated like objects, treated with contempt, and enjoy eroticized violence” (Kasper). The woman enjoying...

...Remember when your parents told you that you could not watch certain channels, or went to the extent of blocking channels and shows that came on after dark. Although it may have been frustrating, thinking it was just another way for our parents to control us. In actuality our parents were just trying to protect us. They were shielding us from material that may be harmful to us. This is similar to what the government attempts to do with pornography and obscenity laws. Pornography is the portrayal of sexually explicit material with the intent to cause sexual arousal. Pornography is the display of women as sexual objects, enjoying pain, humiliation, rape or being physically harmed. It is also obscene material in the form of audio, video, pictures, paintings, and even in written words. Pornography is many things and can not be defined it to one single definition because over time the meaning changes. What is classified as pornography varies from culture to culture and with time. For example In Iraq the display of a woman’s cleavage or legs is categorized as obscene and explicit material. to a African Zulu tribe that wears just enough clothing to cover their genitals,would see that as normal. It all depends oon the context of that culture. Through history porongraphy ancient history that has been hundreds maybe thousands of years; in the form of sculptures, cave drawings and venus...

...THE EFFECTS OF PORNOGRAPHY
ON INDIVIDUALS, MARRIAGE,
FAMILY AND COMMUNITY
Pat Fagan
Pornography is a major threat to marriages, the family, and the society at
large. It is not a private choice without public consequence. Pornography
alters both sexual attitudes and behavior, undermining marriage, which in
turn, undermines the stability of the entire community.
THE FAMILY AND PORNOGRAPHY
• Married men who are involved in pornography feel less satisfied with
their conjugal relations and less emotionally attached to their wives.
• Pornography use is a pathway to infidelity and divorce, and is
frequently a major factor in these family disasters.
• Couples affected by one spouse’s addiction usually experience a loss of
interest in sexual intercourse and good family relations.
• Both spouses perceive pornography viewing as tantamount to infidelity.
• Pornography viewing leads to a loss of interest in good family relations.
Pornography affects all members of the family. Not only does it eliminate
an affectionate family life, children can experience traumas related to
encounters with their parents’ pornographic material. A study of
adolescents revealed that viewing sexually explicit internet materials
significantly increased their uncertainties about sexuality, and it can lower
their self-esteem and bring about feelings...

...1- “PORNOGRAFHY IS HARMFUL TO WOMEN”
I oppose pornography because women are presented dehumanized as sexual objects, things in scenarios of degradation, injury, and torture. The harm from pornography is not easily traced to a single source. Hymowitz and Cleveland go to great lengths to point out the complexity of the problem of pornography, that harm ensues not just because of what the content of pornography is, but also because of how the messages of pornography contribute to the social fabric of male hegemony. "Pornography hurt women, including me. As a woman." If, as has been argued, pornography's harm is intimately connected to social practices, then perhaps blame for this harm cannot be pinpointed to pornography alone, or any particular source of pornography.
Pornography creates a world where sexual brutality is legitimized and even celebrated. In this world, no matter how cruelly you treat a woman. She is always available for any man and will do whatever he wants. Pornography gives women a distorted image of sex. They think something is wrong with them not responding to women in the movies. Of course the porn stars are getting paid to look excited, but many people think that pornography is a reflection of reality rather than a carefully constructed image.
Some wonder why part of the political...

...﻿
Porno or No?
The Ethical Egoist’s View on Pornography
Shauntel Branch
SOC120: Introduction to Ethics & Social Responsibility
Instructor: Michael Kellam
April 28, 2014
“Everyone, no matter how refined, had a stash of Pornography.”-Tinnean, No One Should Be Alone
Pornography is prevailing everywhere you look. Most people put up with it or deal with it with blind eyes. However, several eyes are wide open. In fact seventy-seven percent of Americans viewPornography at least once a month. On a weekly basis 68 percent of adult men and 18 percent of women use Pornography at least once every week. (Ackman, 2011) Another shocking truth is the pornography industry generate $13 billion each year in the United States alone.
Although, most are morally opposed to pornography the numbers are constantly growing faster over a thirty year trend. Does it have an effect on individuals who engage in pornographic activities? What exactly is pornography, and what are the moral conflicts that are so controversial in our society? This paper will discuss pornography topics from an ethical egoist point of view. An ethical egoist is an individual who finds it in their own self-interest to act regardless of the case. Secondly, ethical egoist may practice behaviors in which society would rule as...

...The Cause and Effect of Pornography
Nessa Perez
COMM 105
March. 16, 2010
Rebecca Coleman
The Cause and Effect of Pornography
“Pornography is a multi-billion industry so powerful it drives the direction of much media technology.” (Jensen, 2007) The annual revenue in pornography business is $12 billion here in America and $57 billion worldwide. According to the reports every second more than 28 thousand-Internet users are viewing pornography and typically do it during working days. Although it is impossible to deny pornography in economic force, Jensen stated that the effect of pornography in the industry is often over look. In addition he said that people need to start asking some important questions like how does pornography affects people and what it means to be a man and how does it affect young man.
Pornography addiction is a health hazard that western culture is only just starting to recognized. Pornography today describe as a material that means intended to excite or explicitly intended for sexual arousal. Through the Internet, virtual reality, image delivery system, and interactive TV pornography has become an epidemic addiction invading hearts, homes, and intimate relationship. Statistic showed in 1996, here in America over $ 8 billion on hard-core...

...Frye 1
Effects of Pornography on Society
Pornography is a virus that has far-reaching detrimental effects that threatens to rip the moral fabric of society. It has become a growing part of the American economy, family life, and is easily accessible.
What Is Pornography?
Wikipedia define pornography as being "the explicit representation of human body or sexual activity with the goal of sexual arousal." (Wikipedia 2007) The Attorney General Commission defines it as "sexually explicit and intended primarily for the purpose of sexual arousal. It has taken on many forms. Pornography may be in the form of printed literature, photos, sculptures, drawings, paintings, animations, sound of recordings, films, videos, or video games. It is a growing part of the American economy and is readily available at many locations.
The Economy of Pornography
In the year of 1970, only $ 10 million dollars was spent a year on pornography. By the year of 1998, Forrester Research published an online report stating that anywhere
Frye 2
between $ 750 million to $ billion annually is spent on pornography. (Wikipedia 2007) Now pornography grosses $ 8 billion dollars a year. Every year, about 100 pornographic films are shown at "adult" theaters, profiting an annual box office sale of $ 50 million. The...

...Cyberbullying and Its HarmfulEffects on Teens
Teens have nowhere to hide. Cyberbullying is increasing alongside of advances in technology. Most teens now have access to electronic communications and the Internet, making them easy targets for cyberbullying. Cyberbullies are using e-mail, cell phones and the Internet to cause emotional harm, harass, threaten, ridicule, and exert control over their victims. Additionally, cyberbullied teens are committing suicide at an alarming rate. Cyberbullying must be stopped; it poses psychological trauma and health risks, affects social interpersonal skills, and can ultimately cause suicide. A Cyberbully is able to breach every part of its victim’s life, and keeping teens safe in cyberspace will be a challenge that parents, educators, and law enforcement officers must face and defeat.
To begin to understand why cyberbullying poses a risk for psychological trauma, as well as other health risks to teens, one must understand a teens’ brain, which is a work in progress. Teens lack fully developed judgment and impulse controls until they transition from childhood to adulthood. The brain’s frontal lobe (involved in making judgments and plans) is slower developing than the brain’s limbic system (associated with emotions and drives), which causes increased emotional stress, and emotional storms. Teens lack fully developed judgment and impulse controls until they transition from childhood to adulthood. “During the...