Long Term Incentive Plans and Deferred Bonus Plans

Transcription

1 Long Term Incentive Plans and Deferred Bonus Plans Introduction Long Term Incentive Plans (LTIPs) (also sometimes referred to as "Performance Share Plans") are the most popular form of long term share award for senior executives of listed companies having progressively out-stripped the alternative of "market value" options over the previous 10 years or so. It has also become increasingly common over the same period for companies to make at least part of annual bonus awards to senior executives in the form of deferred share awards. Long term incentive plans and deferred bonus plans are similar in some respects as both involve free shares so we have dealt with both here. They are often of equal interest to investors when assessing the overall effectiveness of remuneration packages. In devising these arrangements, companies on the full list of the London Stock Exchange are required to comply with the rules of the Listing Authority and the Combined Code on Corporate Governance and will usually wish to comply with the guidelines of representatives of institutional investors such as the Association of British Insurers ("ABI"). These constraints do not apply to companies traded on AIM but such companies may choose to adopt similar principles for good governance reasons or they may wish to honour previous commitments to shareholders on governance issues. LTIPs key features The key features of LTIPs are: awards entitle participants to free shares after a performance period (of at least three years) provided service and performance conditions are met; participation is at the discretion of the remuneration committee and is usually confined to senior executives but may be extended to other employees; awards are typically made annually, based on a multiple of base salary; awards are invariably subject to comparative and graduated performance targets which are designed to be stretching in order to align the interests of participants and shareholders; participants benefit from the full value of shares subject to the award in contrast to "market value" options which are more geared in that they reward only increases in value from the grant date; share awards are usually sourced using shares held in an employee share ownership plan trust ("ESOP") which can purchase or subscribe for shares. Awards can also be sourced using treasury shares but it makes no sense to do this as shares purchased in the market and held in treasury count towards the ABI dilution limits whereas shares purchased in the market by an ESOP do not. LTIPs v Market Value Options LTIPs have become more popular than market value options because: fewer shares are required (participants receive the full value of shares so awards are generally made over lower multiples of salary); accounting charges are generally lower (particularly for companies with volatile share prices which tend to have an exponential effect on the value of market value options); options can be no incentive when "out of the money" whereas free share awards still have some value if the share price declines;

2 performance targets tend to be more demanding so (arguably) aligning better the interests of participants and shareholders. Market value options should not be dismissed out of hand, however, as the tax treatment can be better; in addition they can result in the use of fewer shares if structured so as to be "share settled". A separate fact sheet is available on discretionary share options which deals with these issues in more detail. Different LTIP Structures LTIPs can generally be structured in one of three ways: Nil cost options Participants are granted an option at the outset which becomes exercisable at the end of a performance period of at least three years to the extent service and performance targets are met. Options typically have a 10 year life. No tax is due until exercise so participants can retain the option after vesting and benefit from the upside on the gross number of shares subject to the award. This gives nil cost options an advantage over the other two ways of structuring LTIPs so we prefer to use nil cost options in the UK and other jurisdictions where possible. Restricted stock units Participants receive a promise or contractually binding right to receive free shares at the end of a performance period of at least three years to the extent service and performance targets are met. Participants are typically taxed on the receipt of the shares. LTIPs usually have to be structured as RSUs in the US, for example, as there is an up front tax charge on the grant of discounted options but not on the award of RSUs. Restricted stock Participants receive beneficial ownership of shares at the outset but the shares are subject to forfeiture on cessation of employment or on failure to meet performance targets at the end of a performance period of at least three years. UK participants can elect to pay income tax on the value of the shares at the outset thereby benefiting from capital treatment on future gains. Restricted stock is rare in the UK, however, as the up front tax cost represents a cash-flow disadvantage and the tax cannot be recouped if the shares are later forfeited. Deferred Bonus Plans Deferred bonus plans are typically structured in one of two ways: Compulsory arrangements Participants are given no choice. Part of their annual bonus is paid in deferred shares which are forfeited on cessation of employment during a performance period of up to three years. These awards are not typically subject to performance targets. Voluntary arrangements with a matching element Participants may opt to take part of their annual bonus as a deferred award of shares with companies offering a matching award of free shares to encourage take-up. The matching element of the award is typically subject to service requirements and to performance conditions measured over a performance period of up to three years.

3 Other key features Other key features of deferred bonus arrangements are: plans can be structured as nil cost options, restricted stock units or even as restricted stock in the same way as LTIPs; participation is at the discretion of the remuneration committee and is often extended beyond senior executives; participants opt in to voluntary plans before their bonus has been determined to avoid a tax charge at that point; awards are usually sourced using shares purchased in the market and held in an ESOP. Shareholder Approval The Listing Rules of the Financial Services Authority (broadly) require companies listed on the full list to seek shareholder approval for plans sourced using new issue shares or in which main board directors are eligible to participate and which measure performance over more than one financial year. LTIPs typically require shareholder approval whereas deferred bonus plans do not if structured correctly. No such rules apply to AIM traded companies but they may be obliged to seek shareholder approval due to prior commitments to shareholders. Tax treatment The tax treatment of LTIPs and Deferred Bonus Plans depends on how they are structured: Nil cost options No income tax arises until the option is exercised, pay as you earn ("PAYE") and National Insurance contributions ("NIC") will arise at that point if the shares are readily convertible assets. Participants will typically sell all their shares on the date of exercise and part of the sale proceeds will be paid to the employer to enable it to operate withholding. Restricted stock units No income tax arises until participants become unconditionally entitled to the shares, PAYE and NIC will arise at that point if the shares are readily convertible assets. Participants will typically be required to sell sufficient shares on vesting to fund the tax withholding liability. Restricted stock No income tax arises on acquisition (assuming the forfeiture conditions lift within 5 years of acquisition). Income tax arises instead when the forfeiture conditions lift on the full value of the shares at that point. PAYE and NIC apply if the shares are readily convertible assets on each tax point. Alternatively, participants can make an election pursuant to section 431(1) ITEPA 2003 to pay income tax on the "unrestricted market value" of the shares within 14 days of acquisition with the result that subsequent gains are taxed as capital. Participants do not usually make such elections, however, as they have to fund the tax from their own resources and it cannot be reclaimed if the shares are later forfeited.

4 Disguised Remuneration Care needs to be taken when structuring LTIPs and Deferred Bonus Plans to avoid unwelcome tax charges arising under the so called "disguised remuneration" rules. These impose PAYE and NIC charges on the provision of benefits by a "relevant third person" by reason of employment. An ESOP is a relevant their person for these purposes so care needs to be taken to avoid the rules triggering early PAYE and NIC charges. As a general rule the usual solution is to keep the trustee blind as to the identity of participants until the shares are required to be transferred. Corporation tax deduction A statutory corporation tax deduction is available on the exercise of options, vesting of restricted stock units or on the receipt or vesting of restricted stock (whichever event is taxable) provided certain conditions are met. The relief is generally given to the employer for the accounting period in which the tax charges arise in the hands of participants on the amount assessed to income tax in their hands. Structuring LTIPs and Deferred Bonus Plans Tax Efficiently The top rates of income tax and NIC are as follows: The top rate of income tax for individuals is 45% and applies to income in excess of 150,000; The top rate of employees NIC is 2% and applies to income above 34,370 for 2014/15; The rate of employers NIC is 13.8% The employers NIC can be passed on to participants by agreement or election and if it is passed on it can be deducted from the amount assessed to income tax. The effective tax rate for an additional rate taxpayer who is not required to pay employers NIC is 47% whereas this increases to 54.59% if the employers NIC is passed on. On 100 of gain an additional rate taxpayer who is require to pay employers NIC would pay calculated as follows: ( x 45%) + ( 100 x 2%). These tax rates make it important for employers to structure LTIPs and Deferred Bonus Plans tax efficiently. There are several alternatives of which we have considered three here: Joint share-ownership plans ( JSOPs ); Enterprise Management Incentive Plans ("EMI"); and Shares for rights. JSOPs are arrangements designed to replicate option plans commercially and can be used by any listed company. HMRC has confirmed JSOPs are effective for tax purposes and need not be disclosed as a tax avoidance scheme. EMI is a form of tax-advantaged option plan which qualifies for favourable tax treatment by statute but is only suitable to smaller companies. Shares for rights is a tax advantaged statutory arrangement whereby employees can sacrifice certain employment rights in exchange for the issue of free shares but is only likely to be suitable for AIM companies rather than companies on the full list. Separate fact sheets are available on each of these arrangements.

5 JSOPs JSOPs are available to practically all listed companies without any limit on the size of individual awards and it is common for listed companies to use them. In contrast to EMIs, no corporation tax deduction is available for the employer. The high income tax and NIC rates in the UK, however, make JSOPs attractive despite the absence of corporation tax relief. Listed companies with LTIPs and Deferred Bonus Plans should consider structuring awards so gains are delivered through linked JSOP arrangements. Under JSOPs: the participant and the trustee of the company's ESOP jointly subscribe for shares; the shares are held jointly in undivided shares as tenants in common on terms set out in a JSOP agreement; the participant's interest entitles him to gains made on the sale of the shares in excess of a threshold; participants elect to pay income tax on the value of the interest on acquisition, subsequent gains are taxed as capital; performance targets apply so that participants forfeit the interest to the extent targets are not met after a performance period (usually of three years); once the shares vest the participant is entitled to require the shares to be sold. These arrangements allow participants to benefit from capital gains tax treatment on gains made in excess of the threshold. The full value of the shares is delivered through a linked nil cost option which is exercised at the same time as the jointly owned shares are sold and the extent to which it can be exercised is capped at such number of shares as deliver a value equal to the value below the threshold. The arrangement replicates LTIPs and Deferred Bonus Plans commercially and so can be introduced without seeking shareholder approval (if the LTIP they are replicating contains the usual wording which permits amendments to secure more favourable tax treatment). EMI EMI plans are the most generous form of discretionary option plan in the UK. Tax relief is available whenever options are exercised with no minimum holding period for the shares. Options may be granted up to a limit of 250,000 per employee. EMI is only available to smaller companies, however, with gross assets of less than 30 million and fewer than 250 full-time (or full-time equivalent) employees that meet certain "trading activities" tests. Companies that qualify should structure their LTIPs as nil cost EMI options to qualify for tax relief. If so structured, only the value of the shares on grant is subject to income tax on exercise. Gains in excess of market value on grant are generally taxed as capital on the sale of the shares. The conditions for entrepreneurs' relief have been relaxed as they apply to shares acquired pursuant to the exercise of EMI options after 5 April 2013 with the result that it will usually be possible for participants to claim ER on gains made on the sale of their EMI option shares. Broadly, ER can be claimed if the EMI option was granted more than a year prior to the disposal of the option shares and in the 12 months prior to disposal the option-holder must be an officer or employee within the group and the company must be a trading company or holding company of a trading group. Shares for Rights The so called "shares for rights" legislation came into force on 3 September 2013, it allows employees to sacrifice certain employment rights in exchange for at least 2,000 worth of shares. Participants are required to pay income tax on the value of the shares in excess of 2,000. The first 50,000 worth of shares (measured on issue) can be sold tax free. It is possible for AIM companies to create a new class of growth shares in an intermediate holding company the economic value of which is pegged to the listed share price above a threshold. Once vested, the growth shares can

6 be exchanged for listed shares of the same value tax free. These proposals only deliver gains above the threshold so a linked nil cost option to acquire listed shares is required to deliver the value up to the threshold. It is not generally feasible for companies on the full list to use this sort of arrangement as it requires shareholder approval and the use of subsidiary shares is not recommended by the Guidelines of the Association of British Insurers. These restrictions do not generally apply to AIM companies. This paper is based on the law at 15 April About Bird & Bird Bird & Bird is an international commercial law firm with more than 1,100 lawyers in 26 offices worldwide. Bird & Bird's UK employee incentives and benefits team is ranked in the UK's editions of Chambers and the Legal 500. The Team: "is known for is capacity in handling complex international mandates, particularly on behalf of technology sector clients" "is adept at implementing new share scheme plans and at advising upon the share plan aspects of corporate transactions" "contains a number of quality individuals and is doing some impressive international work" "are pragmatic in their advice [and] recognise what we need to do in order to get to a favourable outcome" "are very knowledgeable about the different alternatives open to us and provide us with very appropriate advice" Chambers and Partners 2014 For more information please contact: Colin Kendon Partner and Head of UK Employee Incentives & Benefits D: +44 (0) T: +44 (0) Fleur Benns Legal Director D: +44 (0) T: +44 (0)

7 Dan Sharman Associate D: +44 (0) T: +44 (0) This document gives general information only as at the date of first publication and is not intended to give a comprehensive analysis. It should not be used as a substitute for legal or other professional advice, which should be obtained in specific circumstances. twobirds.com Bird & Bird LLP is a limited liability partnership, registered in England and Wales with registered number 0C and is authorised and regulated by the Solicitors Regulation Authority. Its registered office and principal place of business is at 15 Fetter Lane, London EC4A 1JP. Bird & Bird is an international legal practice comprising Bird & Bird LLP and its affiliated and associated businesses and has offices in the locations listed on our web site: twobirds.com. The word partner is used to refer to a member of Bird & Bird LLP or an employee or consultant, or to a partner, member, director, employee or consultant in any of its affiliated and associated businesses, who is a lawyer with equivalent standing and qualifications. A list of members of Bird & Bird LLP, and of any non-members who are designated as partners and of their respective professional qualifications, is open to inspection at the above address.

Enterprise Management Incentives ("EMI") Introduction The EMI is a tax qualified discretionary share option arrangement aimed at small growing companies to help them recruit and retain employees. The exercise

Shares for Rights (UK) Introduction The so called "shares for rights" legislation came into force in the UK in September 2013. The tax breaks are very generous as they allow employees to achieve tax free

UK Employee Incentives and Benefits About our UK Employee Incentives and Benefits Team The UK Employee Incentives and Benefits team at Bird & Bird design, draft and implement employee share plans and other

Employee and Business Angel Shareholdings Avoiding Income Tax Issues Employee and Business Angel Shareholdings Introduction Private companies, particularly those in a start-up or early stage development

DISPLAY VERSION ST IVES PLC ST IVES LONG TERM INCENTIVE PLAN 2010 Approved by shareholders of the Company on Adopted by the board of the Company on The Plan is a discretionary benefit offered by St Ives

A Guide to Equity Plans For international companies with UK operations Introduction This paper is designed to provide an insight into the main types of share plans available in the UK and practical guidance

C Taxation C.1 Taxation of equity-based payments Australian taxation arrangements Equity-based payments are remuneration for employment services provided in the form of equity or rights (this could constitute

Briefing A review of the Government s June 2012 proposals for a binding shareholder vote on directors pay and new pay disclosures Summary This briefing looks at the detailed proposals for the new regime

October 2011 Registered pension schemes: Changes relating to age 75 and flexible drawdown This year s Finance Act makes a number of changes from 6 April 2011, concerning the impact that reaching age 75

RELEVANT TECHNICAL LIFE GUIDE PLAN TO THE RELEVANT LIFE PLAN 1 RELEVANT LIFE PLAN TECHNICAL GUIDE. 2 TECHNICAL GUIDE TO THE RELEVANT LIFE PLAN ABOUT THIS GUIDE This guide has been designed for financial

New board pay rules are they working? Key statistics Linklaters Incentives Practice New board pay rules are they working? Many of the world s largest companies rely on our global incentives practice to

1. INTRODUCTION CORPORATE MEMBERS OF LIMITED LIABILITY PARTNERSHIPS 1.1 This note, prepared on behalf of the Company Law Committee of the City of London Law Society ( CLLS ), relates to BIS request for

Employee Share Schemes What you Need to Know about the New Tax Rules 1. Introduction As we all know, the Government announced some significant unexpected changes to the taxation of employee share plans

DESCRIPTION OF THE PLAN PURPOSE 1. What is the purpose of the Plan? The purpose of the Plan is to provide eligible record owners of common stock of the Company with a simple and convenient means of investing

Important tax changes a summary March 2010 1 Important tax changes - a summary Why should I read this briefing? This briefing summarises fundamental changes to the taxation of both offshore funds and investors

KEY GUIDE Drawing profits from a company Constantly changing tax rules When you draw profits from an owner-managed company it is important that you do it in ways that minimise the tax and national insurance

National Instrument 55-104 Insider Reporting Requirements and Exemptions PART 1 DEFINITIONS AND INTERPRETATION 1.1 Definitions and interpretation (1) In this Instrument acceptable summary form means, in

A guide for employees Salary sacrifice and pensions MPEN15/D 03.15 Did you know that salary sacrifice (also known as salary exchange, SMART Pensions and Smart Pay) can provide you with an opportunity to

WOODSIDE PETROLEUM LTD. EMPLOYEE SHARE PLAN OFFER Guidance Notes Offer period 1 July 2008 to 30 June 2009 These guidance notes are for information only and in the event of any conflict between this document

Employee Benefit Trust (EBT), Settlement Opportunity Frequently asked questions (FAQs) August 2012 Introduction These FAQs are designed to help our customers consider how the terms of the EBT Settlement

1(1) PROPOSAL BY THE BOARD OF DIRECTORS TO GRANT STOCK OPTIONS TO SELECTED PERSONNEL OF NOKIA The Board proposes to the Annual General Meeting that a maximum of 35 000 000 stock options be granted to selected

Introduction This section of the report sets out the details of the Remuneration Policy for Executive and Non-Executive Directors of the Company and will be proposed for approval by shareholders at the

Equity-Based Compensation for Canadian Employees By Leonard Glass May 2, 2002 This is a general overview of the subject matter and should not be relied upon as legal advice or opinion. For specific legal

Introduction The capital gains tax (CGT) legislation favours business assets by providing a number of tax reliefs. The one with the widest scope is entrepreneurs relief, which results in certain disposals

KEY GUIDE Drawing profits from a company Constantly changing tax rules When you draw profits from an owner-managed company most people are keen to ensure that they do it in a way that minimises the tax

AIG Life AIG Relevant Life Insurance Adviser guide Contents The basics 4 What is relevant life insurance? 4 Who is it suitable for? 4 What are the conditions that have to be met for relevant life insurance?

EMPLOYEE SHARE PUBLIC RULING NO. 11/2012 Translation from the original Bahasa Malaysia text. DATE OF ISSUE: 13 DECEMBER 2012 Published by Inland Revenue Board Malaysia Published on 13 December 2012 First

Restructuring and insolvency briefing October 2009 Debt for equity swaps: an introduction Summary and implications Companies are often looking for ways to strengthen their balance sheet and reduce their

Brief guide to Administration Administration is a rescue procedure for companies that are, or are likely to become, insolvent. It is similar in concept to Chapter 11 proceedings in the United States but

The Trust Deed is a complex document and the following is a summary only. Recipients of this prospectus and all prospective investors should refer to the Trust Deed itself to confirm specific information

INDIVIDUAL SAVINGS ACCOUNTS 2014/2015 An Individual Savings Account (ISA) is not an investment in its own right rather it is a type of account that can be used to undertake tax-advantageous investment.

GSK Policy Title: Code for Dealing in Securities Official Short Title: Code for Dealing in Securities Key Points No employee may deal in GlaxoSmithKline plc securities ( GSK securities ) if he or she is

View the online version at http://us.practicallaw.com/3-589-7685 Choosing the Right Type of Equity Compensation for Start-up Company Employees SHAWN E. LAMPRON, FENWICK & WEST LLP, WITH PRACTICAL LAW EMPLOYEE

For financial advisers only Relevant life technical guide Please note this communication is for financial advisers only. It mustn t be distributed to, or relied on by, customers. About this guide We ve

EMPLOYER-SUPPORTED CHILDCARE GUIDANCE AND FAQs FOR EMPLOYEES WHO ARE PARENTS, STEP-PARENTS OR WHO HAVE PARENTAL RESPONSIBILITY This guidance outlines HM Revenue & Customs interpretation of the legislation

TD Direct Investing A Guide to SIPPs Introduction If you are considering investing for retirement, there are a number of ways to approach it. One way is to embark on the do it yourself (DIY) self investment

1. GENERAL The Company was incorporated in the Cayman Islands on 16 April 2003 as an exempted company with limited liability under the Companies Law (2002 Revision) of the Cayman Islands and its shares

GUIDE Entrepreneurs A guide to investment jargon What does this guide cover? Angel investors, venture capital funds, accountants, lawyers and fundraisers use jargon. To anyone raising funds for the first

DIRECTORS REMUNERATION POLICY Directors Remuneration Policy PageGroup is a global business that operates in a cyclical industry in which the retention of key executives and management continuity is critical

The United Kingdom (UK) continues to be one of the world s leading locations for global investment, being rated again as the most attractive place in Europe for foreign investment. i Also, the World Bank

METLIFE Group Life (INCLUDING FLEXIBLE BENEFITS) Technical Guide 1 MetLife Group Life Policies Technical Guide MetLife has a range of policies aimed to meet your life cover needs in respect of your employees

A guide for employees Salary sacrifice and pensions MPEN15/D 07.16 Did you know that salary sacrifice (also known as salary exchange, SMART Pensions and Smart Pay) can provide you with an opportunity to

International Financial Reporting Standard 2 Share-based Payment OBJECTIVE 1 The objective of this IFRS is to specify the financial reporting by an entity when it undertakes a share-based payment transaction.

ey.com/ifrs Negotiation series Earn-out arrangements in a business combination impact of the revised IFRS 3 January 2010 When negotiating a business acquisition, the potential consequences of the accounting

ITEM 4: BOARD OF DIRECTORS STATEMENT REGARDING SALARY AND OTHER REMUNERATION OF EXECUTIVE PERSONNEL Statement regarding stipulation of salaries and other remuneration of executive personnel in Lerøy Seafood

TAX LIMITS FINAL SALARY AND CAREER REVALUED BENEFITS SECTIONS Limits to tax relief and tax-free benefits Introduction Pension benefits accrued by individuals in the UK which qualify to receive tax relief

COMPENSATION UPON TERMINATION OF APPOINTMENTS OF DIRECTORS AND SENIOR EXECUTIVES DIRECTORS ADVISORY SERVICE FACTSHEET These Guidance Notes provide an outline of the relevant provisions, but they are not

Effective remuneration in an unfriendly tax world are you ready for the 50% tax rate? November 2009 Agenda Welcome Introduction to an unfriendly tax world Are pensions losing their tax appeal? Effective

Switzerland Switzerland Ueli Sommer and Rosemarie Knecht, Walder Wyss & Partners www.practicallaw.com/4-373-5954 GENERAL 1. Is it common for employees to be offered participation in an employee share plan?

LUNDIN MINING CORPORATION INCENTIVE STOCK OPTION PLAN ARTICLE I INTRODUCTION 1.1 Purpose of Plan The purpose of the Plan is to secure for the Company and its shareholders the benefits of incentive inherent

Key Features of the Suffolk Life SIPP (Deed Poll Scheme) This document is part of a set, all of which should be read together. Key Features Your Personal Illustration Schedule of Fees Schedule of Allowable