Once the enemies are defeated, Mickey can talk to Starkey to complete the quest. Starkey will exit with him. Once Mickey goes back to Tortooga, the area will be enemy-free. Mickey can talk to Starkey to obtain the Pirate Hero Pin.

If Mickey doesn't complete this Quest, Starkey will stay trapped in the Jungle and Tortooga will be overrun by 2 Bashers and some Spatters.