I am incredibly happy my team isn't taking a first round QB this year.

Underwhelming as a #1 overall, maybe, but he'd have definitely been in contention for the Dolphin's 8th overall pick last year ahead of Tannehill, IMO. It could just be the rose-colored goggles I'm wearing, but as of now, I think Geno is a solid top-10 or top-15 pick in any post-payscale change draft.

Underwhelming as a #1 overall, maybe, but he'd have definitely been in contention for the Dolphin's 8th overall pick last year ahead of Tannehill, IMO. It could just be the rose-colored goggles I'm wearing, but as of now, I think Geno is a solid top-10 or top-15 pick in any post-payscale change draft.

Yea I should have worded it different. I meant a first round Chiefs/Jaguars pick. Easily a top 10 pick .

Underwhelming as a #1 overall, maybe, but he'd have definitely been in contention for the Dolphin's 8th overall pick last year ahead of Tannehill, IMO. It could just be the rose-colored goggles I'm wearing, but as of now, I think Geno is a solid top-10 or top-15 pick in any post-payscale change draft.

I think a lot of folks would agree with you on his rating with regards to Tannehill.

Yea I should have worded it different. I meant a first round Chiefs/Jaguars pick. Easily a top 10 pick .

I just don't see how it would be a "bad idea" to take him at 1 if he's worth some other top-10 pick. He's a strong prospect at what is by far our team's largest position of need. Had we won one or two more games by sheer luck, our team would have the exact same needs as it does now, and all of a sudden he would be a good pick?