A state that extols outsiders considers an insider for President

TWIN MOUNTAIN, N.H. -- When, 120 years ago, the New Hampshire poet Edna Dean Proctor saluted this state's "cliffs, her meads, her brooks afoam" and spoke elegiacally of the "white-robed heights" of its mountains, she identified perhaps the mostly enduring characteristic of New Hampshire -- its worship of the outside.

And now, as the 2020 presidential campaign cranks to an opening in the state that holds the first primary of the political season, one major question persists:

Will a state that extols the virtues of the outside embrace an insider for the White House?

The question, like the two peaks for which this town nestled between Franconia Notch and Crawford Notch is named, has twin aspects:

Will New Hampshire grant its Democratic National Convention delegates to a neighbor such as Sen. Elizabeth Warren of Massachusetts, whose principal residence is but 30 miles from the New Hampshire border?

Or will the Democrats instead side with a true outsider like the two little-known municipal leaders contemplating presidential campaigns, Mayor Eric Garcetti of Los Angeles and former Mayor Mitch Landrieu of New Orleans?

Past practice, never an entirely reliable guide, answers both questions with a resounding, though thoroughly contradictory, yes.

New Hampshirites customarily regard Massachusetts residents as outsiders, and not welcome ones; the most expensive act on a highway here is driving in a car with red-on-white Bay State plates, magnets for state patrollers looking for speeders or, more precisely, for any excuse to torment a Massachusetts driver.

And yet in politics, New Hampshire voters, recipients of a constant diet of news from Boston television stations, have been remarkably congenial to Massachusetts presidential candidates, virtually considering them one of their own. Bay State candidates John F. Kennedy (1960), Michael Dukakis (1988), Paul Tsongas (1992), John Kerry (2004) and Mitt Romney (2012) all won the New Hampshire primary. The only Massachusetts candidates to fall short have been Edward Kennedy (1980) and Romney, in his first try (2008).

So Warren has an edge in this contest. Now the second question: Can she, elected twice to the Senate and with the advantage/disadvantage of having served on the faculty of the Harvard Law School -- which produced by far the most Supreme Court justices in American history, including a majority of today's high court -- plausibly portray herself as an outsider?

Her best bet: Emphasize her gender and her views, both departures from American political custom. The outsider question has special resonance in this age and for Democrats, who will be opposing an incumbent who, in his 2017 Liberty University commencement address said, "Being an outsider is fine. Embrace the label, because it's the outsiders who change the world and who make a real and lasting difference."

Democratic insider presidential candidates have faired poorly. Nine of the last 11 Democratic insider non-incumbent candidacies lost. The outsiders prevailed: Jimmy Carter (single gubernatorial term), Bill Clinton (veteran governor but an outsider by virtue of being cast by his GOP rivals as a "failed governor of a small state") and Barack Obama (less than a full term as senator).

Indeed, it is possible to argue that since the pre-Civil War years of James Buchanan (member of the House and Senate, twice an ambassador and a secretary of state -- and thus a true insider), the Democrats have elected only two true insiders to the White House, Franklin Delano Roosevelt and Kennedy.

(In an intriguing twist of history, both FDR and JFK, elected president with the nomination of the self-styled "party of the people," were aristocrats.)

Determined to prevent Trump from winning a second term, Democrats here and elsewhere are priding themselves on examining the candidates with sedulous care, looking less to ideology than to electability.

The ideology factor may aid Warren, or Sen. Bernie Sanders of Vermont, or many others such as Sen. Kirsten Gillibrand of New York or Sen. Amy Klobuchar of Minnesota, plus a passel of relative newcomers whose views match the new generation of voters -- vigilant about civil rights, troubled about the wealth gap, concerned about climate change, determined to win single-payer health care. The winnability factor may favor former Vice President Joseph R. Biden Jr., who is not alone in believing he has the best chance of toppling Trump.

The result is a Democratic dilemma unlike any it has encountered before.

And it comes at a time when it is prudent to remember that it is not the Democrats but the Republicans who for the past century have tended to elect insider candidates such as, among others, Herbert Hoover (the longest-serving secretary of commerce), Richard Nixon (victorious in House and Senate races, two terms as vice president, and one presidential nomination before winning the presidency in 1968) and George H.W. Bush (member of the House, director of the CIA, veteran diplomat, two terms as vice president).

The only modern exception until recently was Wendell Willkie (1940). Plus one other: Donald Trump.

Watch this discussion.Stop watching this discussion.

(0) comments

Welcome to the discussion.

Daily Journal Online Comment Policy
The goal of the story comments at dailyjournalonline.com is to have
a community forum for the thoughts of our readers.
We strive to make sure this is an open, thought-provoking yet
polite debate on the issues.Report Abuse
If you feel a comment has violated our guidelines, please use the
"Report Abuse" link under the comment.Comments not edited
We do not edit comments. They are approved or denied.Comments will be screened
All comments will be screened and may take several hours to be
posted.No Personal Attacks
Refrain from personal attacks or degrading comments.Do not feed the trolls
Keep comments clear, concise and focused on the topic.No Emails or Links
No advertising allowed. Do not post e-mails or links except for
pages on dailyjournalonline.com or Government websites.Be Courteous
Do not type with CAP LOCKS ON. Forgive spelling errors. No racism,
sexism or any other sort of -ism that degrades another person.Do not imply guilt
Do not convict a suspect of a crime before he or she has been
proven so in a court of law.Comment Length
Comments are limited to 1000 Characters. Characters remaining are
posted on top left of comment box.
Assertions of questionable or unrelated information will decrease
the likelihood of approval.
However we welcome such information in the form of news tips sent
via our contact us page.