And for me, KP is a must sign. Our team defense is just so much better with him. He doesn't get all the hype and glamour of safeties who get turn overs but most QB's don't throw near him because they know how good he is playing deep safety.

Plus, with his injury history and not being a headline name I feel we could get him for a very reasonable deal.

I wish I could find that quote about Kenny from Jason Witten. It sums it up pretty well.

You can't invest money a guy who can't stay healthy. Its not just him. Rivers is injury prone, Beckum is injury prone, and how JW is hurt with a knee since the 9ers game. But usually he has a hamstring. Justin Tuck is another one. Nicks is one, but I think we almost do have to re-sign but not break the bank for. He is basically Justin Tuck of offense.

We have injury prone players on this team who fans like but realistically you can't keep throwing money at guys who are not even playing.

That's silly, of course you can invest money into injury prone guys, it's just important that it's not too much money, that you have some decent cover for the games he'll miss and that your team doesn't have too many injury prone guys.

__________________
BK

Quote:

Originally Posted by AcheTen

JPP is a better and more productive player than Brandon Graham

Quote:

Originally Posted by abaddon41_80

Is Shaun Hill a top 10 QB? Definitely not. Is he a top 20 one? Almost certainly.

That's silly, of course you can invest money into injury prone guys, it's just important that it's not too much money, that you have some decent cover for the games he'll miss and that your team doesn't have too many injury prone guys.

Of course not, You don't dump money into guys who don't see the field. Tuck will be a big one. We will be at a cross roads soon where guys we like as fans will either need to re-signed or not. Reese has to make some big time decisions soon.

*shrug* you do if they're elite players and you don't have elite replacements. I.e. I'd rather have Nicks and Phillips for just 12 games a year plus playoffs than have average replacement that play all 16 games plus playoffs. Tuck's a little different cause he's not just injury prone but also old and I think getting ready to retire soon, so him I'd be much more skeptical about paying, but Nicks and Phillips IMO are still guys we should keep provided we get a little injury discount.

__________________
BK

Quote:

Originally Posted by AcheTen

JPP is a better and more productive player than Brandon Graham

Quote:

Originally Posted by abaddon41_80

Is Shaun Hill a top 10 QB? Definitely not. Is he a top 20 one? Almost certainly.

*shrug* you do if they're elite players and you don't have elite replacements. I.e. I'd rather have Nicks and Phillips for just 12 games a year plus playoffs than have average replacement that play all 16 games plus playoffs. Tuck's a little different cause he's not just injury prone but also old and I think getting ready to retire soon, so him I'd be much more skeptical about paying, but Nicks and Phillips IMO are still guys we should keep provided we get a little injury discount.

How many of those guys are elite players currently? KP is elite? Tuck is elite? Nicks is elite? I can buy Nicks. He is a great player, WHEN HEALTHY.. And I wouldn't break the bank for him.

Now if we get an injury discount fine. I will play ball for that. I don't think KP can stay healthy as he gets older. The knee right now is a mess. I think it will be a re-occuring issue.

How many games did KP miss this season? Has it been more than 4? And it's not just missing games, it's being hurt and affecting your play. If someone can miss a game and come back 100% cool, but these types of things affect a player and linger which is an issue.

River is always hurt, Beckum is always hurt, and JW seems to be like Rivers. This time it's a knee since the SF game. Last season I believe it was a hamstring. They are not elite players but just more injury prone players.

Nicks and KP are elite at their respective positions. Again, it's when healthy. But I'll take them for 12 games and a few at 75% over full seasons of Barden, Sash, Brown etc. Gotta think the talent levels of them and their replacements versus the pay.

__________________We ALL bleed scarlet New York Giants Super Bowl 46 Champs
UNITED: I actually attend the college I root for

Quote:

Originally Posted by PalmerToCJ

BTW, if it's 3rd and 97... I'm throwing a screen pass to Brian Leonard and he will convert.

Nicks and KP need to stay. I don't think we'd have to break the bank for them either.

What would you consider breaking the bank? If I had to guess, he'd command more then VJ on the open market pretty easily. I always felt his deal would be the trickiest because on talent and production alone he's worth top dollar, but injury concerns may make Reese hesitant to do it.

__________________

Quote:

Originally Posted by Scott Wright

I guarantee that if someone picks Cam Newton in the Top 5 they will regret it.

I'm in the Re-sign Nicks and KP camp. We have to keep those two. And of course Cruz. I would also really like to keep Joseph, but everyone else nearing the end of their contract I can live with leaving. But those four are our core players who are still pretty young. Yes, some of them are injury prone. But they are very good, young players.

Not sure if it's realistic to manage to re-sign everyone of them, but I hope so.

What would you consider breaking the bank? If I had to guess, he'd command more then VJ on the open market pretty easily. I always felt his deal would be the trickiest because on talent and production alone he's worth top dollar, but injury concerns may make Reese hesitant to do it.

It's very tough with Nicks but you have to bring him back. We saw how bad the offense played when Nicks didn't play. If the cap goes up a lot in the next few years I wouldn't mind giving him a VJ type of deal.

Yeah Nicks has to come back. I don't think you let that talent go UNLESS he wants insane money. The issue is our system too. It's not like any Tom, Richard, or harry, can step in and start for us due to the WR sight adjustment rules. That's why losing people on offense especially TEs is annoying.

Our system is just to tough to get guys to learn perfectly and even then they may not know it 100%. So high turnover on offense is not good for us.

The media is probably going to blame this on Tynes for missing that 43-yarder, but I refuse to do so. It is only to be expected that he misses every now and then when he's required to try FGs 500 million times every game because our offense sputters once they can see the endzone.

******* lame loss, and totally avoidable if we hadn't bitten ourselves in the ass with penalties and ****** third down completion percentage both ways.

And on defense, my God, how many times are you going to bite on the same ******* play. That play action post pass to Garcon? They did that one at least five times successfully, including in obvious passing situations like before halftime in the two minute drill, and on the decisive first down so they could run out the clock. That is horrible ******* discipline and awareness, making it to easy for Bob (who is, by the way a ******* ******** stupid dickhead). I hate him with a passion.

And of course to round out the perfect evening, Locklear gets what looks to be a serious injury, so now we have to watch Diehl allow pressures on Eli all throughout December and in the playoffs if we even get there. ****!!!

And I don't even know why I'm so pissed off at this game, because it was to be expected from the Giants. But this loss really rubbed me the wrong way. Anyways, it's 6 AM in Norway, so i'm off to bed to get my two hours of sleep.

The penalties killed us tonight. Can't win committing dumb penalties, we win a close game if we don't have all those false starts/holding calls. Also, that 3rd & 20 screen when we were losing with 4 minutes left was the dumbest play call I have ever seen.....like ever

I didn't watch the game, still in Berlin, but I'm glad we lost, means there'll be some sort of pressure on the guys down the stretch, so that we have to win those games and can go into the playoffs with momentum.

__________________
BK

Quote:

Originally Posted by AcheTen

JPP is a better and more productive player than Brandon Graham

Quote:

Originally Posted by abaddon41_80

Is Shaun Hill a top 10 QB? Definitely not. Is he a top 20 one? Almost certainly.