It all came out when the Riverdale cast stopped by the WWHL clubhouse on October 9. The gang quickly began reminiscing about that time Andy made a cameo on the show, where he appeared as himself. While reminiscing about Andy's appearance, New Zealand native KJ Apa, who plays Archie Andrews on the show, shared, "The first time I met you was at craft [services]. In New Zealand, they don't play [WWHL] so I wasn't familiar with who you were. And I just remember, you were just sticking around at crafty, just eating for a long time."

Andy was quick to admit that in fact, he had taken advantage of the snacks on set — and didn't regret it one bit!

"It was some decent crafty, too," Andy said. "I had a blast — and I ate very well." Watch the clip above to hear the whole story.