A strange medley

Any thoughts about this medley I’d like to put together of two tunes posted today? The first is a D Dorian jig version of The Broken Pledge, that Will transcribed from The Kane Sisters. Then it goes into a 4/4 march in G Major, The North Wind, that Kenny got from a Teada album. (Maybe I should run this by John Blake!) I’d call the set The Broken Wind. I had fun coming up with that and just thought I’d give you all a whiff of the craic.

To each his own. I’ve know the reel for years as well, but happen to like the jig just fine. And I doubt that Liz and Yvonne should get credit for the jig version—"changing the nature of the tune" by reframing reels as jigs and vice versa is a long-standing and well-supported custom in this tradition and it’s likely they learned it from someone else (I don’t have the liner notes so can’t say for sure).