Erin Cummings, who on Spartacus: War of the Damned played the title character’s ill-fated wife Sura, has been cast as Eve Steele, an elite thief-for-hire that happens to bear a resemblance to NYPD detective Carrie Wells, played by Poppy Montgomery.

When Eve is pulled in for questioning on the eve of a major heist, watch for Carrie’s team to consider a “switcheroo,” by having Detective Super-Memory pose as the elusive, reclusive burglar.

The actress’ other TV credits include CBS’ short-lived Made in Jersey (photo’d above) Pan Am, Detroit 1-8-7 and Mad Men (where she played Candace, a pro that Don has frequented). She next can be seen visiting Comedy Central’s Inside Amy Schumer, on July 2.