If this is your first visit, be sure to
check out the FAQ by clicking the
link above. You may have to register
before you can post: click the register link above to proceed. To start viewing messages,
select the forum that you want to visit from the selection below.

Responding here so as to not dump info about my podcast into an oM thread,
"Is your Harry Potter podcast better than Mugglecast?"

Depends on who you ask. We've definitely had comments telling us that we're better. But we pretty much only get positive feedback and don't really hear from the people that try our show and decide not to listen. We aren't really trying to be another Mugglecast though, what we do is fairly different. They seemed to be really into fostering community discussion, which is not something we do at all. They also tended towards lengthy and slow paced episodes, whereas our show is typically 15-20 minutes long, and is edited very tightly. If you're looking for a podcast to relax to and fill up your afternoon, that's not us. I try to keep things as tight and punchy as possible and not have an unnecessary second. We're also more comedically oriented than they were. So it depends on what you're into. Let me know what you think if you decide to give us a shot.

Okay man. We could do Lover's Mafia. It's only 5 players (2 maf, 3 town) and it's short, no night phases (mafia don't get to kill, if one mafia is lynched, both die). I modded one of these on mafiascum. Seemed good enough.

Enjoyable but flawed in a lot of ways. The style, presentation, sound, graphics, etc., are great, and the accurate facial expressions are a great mechanic. But the clue hunting can be tedious and the interrogations aren't very intuitive. They came up with a great idea for investigation gameplay, but the execution was poor.