It's very pretty, but it doesn't fit the task of a "Brand" much, while IMO G2 is more of a logo.

tbh nether look like a logo to me at all, but both give kind of a theme for AO. For example the they let us in on the feeling how the advertisments, the website and also the courts or sth like that would look

tbh nether look like a logo to me at all, but both give kind of a theme for AO. For example the they let us in on the feeling how the advertisments, the website and also the courts or sth like that would look

Well, I can see where you're coming from but the Roger silhouette on the background + the balls behind the text seem very AO to me. Much like the current logo. G1 is very pretty and has a more overall theme to it, though.

Not arguing that they don't fit the task, they both do, but G2 is more of a "logo"

Well, I can see where you're coming from but the Roger silhouette on the background + the balls behind the text seem very AO to me. Much like the current logo. G1 is very pretty and has a more overall theme to it, though.

Not arguing that they don't fit the task, they both do, but G2 is more of a "logo"

I agree, but the task was to create a new AO theme, so IMO it doesn't and probably even shouldn't look anything like the old one And the task was not logo, but brand

I suppose we should stop this discussion in order not to influence the voters though.