Buy it... if you are accustomed to John Williams' elegantly simple
and undemanding writing for intimate character stories.

Avoid it... if you'd rather bounce off the walls with the pomp and
bravado of the maestro's fanfares.

EDITORIAL REVIEW

FILMTRACKS TRAFFIC RANK: #220

WRITTEN
11/18/05

BUY IT

Williams

Memoirs of a Geisha: (John Williams) It's taken
four years for this long-anticipated project to finally debut on the big
screen. The internationally acclaimed novel of the same name by Arthur
Golden tells the story of Nitta Sayuri, sold to a geisha house at the
age of nine and eventually trained to be among the best in the trade.
Not only does the film follow her young progression, but also culminates
in her love for a kind, but unreachable patron. As much a historical
documentary as it is a close character story, Memoirs of a Geisha
is a project that immediately attracted the very public attention of
director Steven Spielberg, and a film adaptation was to be one of his
triumphs sometime between 2001 and 2003. Scheduling conflicts and studio
bickering over the rights to the next film of final director Rob
Marshall delayed the film's production until 2005, but no less was the
anticipation for such a promising adaptation. One person who made sure
to work Memoirs of a Geisha into his schedule was composer John
Williams, whose relationship with Spielberg is so strong that he
composed music for both this film and Munich (the 1972 Olympics
docudrama) in 2005 rather than continue his relationship with the
Harry Potter franchise. Williams, like Spielberg, has had
Memoirs of a Geisha on his radar for many years, having fallen in
love with Golden's novel, and has long planned to use it as an
opportunity to collaborate with two of his favorite performers: Yo-Yo Ma
and Itzhak Perlman. Having worked first with violinist Perlman on
Schindler's List in 1993, a score that has achieved legendary
status in the modern history of film music, Williams then collaborated
with cellist Ma on the far less successful Seven Years in Tibet
in 1997. Williams would conduct both artists in separate concerns
thereafter, producing albums of those performances with Perlman and Ma
individually. There is no doubt that Williams' writing suits those two
string soloists well, and it is no surprise that both eagerly signed on
to be part of the recording for Memoirs of a Geisha. Their roles
in the score are appropriately front and center, and an easy selling
point.

As a character story, Williams' work for Memoirs of
a Geisha is restrained and intimate, refraining from any semblance
of the pounding, robust scores for Revenge of the Sith and War
of the Worlds earlier in the year. The pace of Memoirs of a
Geisha is relatively slow as well, being a light, rhythmically
driven score for much of its length. It requires patience and attention
to the details of the plucking and tapping rhythms beneath in order to
be fully satisfied by the similarly drawn-out solo performances on cello
and violin. Interestingly, it is Yo-Yo Ma's cello that makes a far more
important contribution in the score, performing the elegantly beautiful
theme for Sayuri herself. Williams then gives Perlman his primary role
as the performer of the secondary theme served in concert form in "The
Chairman's Waltz." While Perlman's performances are perhaps more
intoxicating than Ma's in general, the cello really stands above and
beyond the violin. Williams is very loyal to his primary theme,
introduced in the opening cue, and it is Ma's solemn performances that
provide the lasting beauty ("Becoming a Geisha" is the highlight cue).
The evolution of this theme throughout the score is remarkable,
remaining stark and barely accompanied until its climax in "Confluence,"
in which the full ensemble (including brass) provide one last noble
statement. The concert suite piece appears over the end titles, and
inserts Perlman's violin and the ensemble into the Sayuri theme for
balance. The light rhythms that carry the minimally-constructed
underscore cues are remarkable in their ease; only in "Brush on Silk"
does dissonance interrupt the perpetually quiet and pleasant listening
experience. The score is saturated with Williams' harmonic and technical
styles, including a slurring of string notes that will remind of
Rosewood. One interesting note is that Williams uses the
shakuhachi flute in "The Journey to the Hanamachi" in much of the same
wailing fashion as James Horner has done in his entire career (but
whereas Horner does it everywhere, including his Zorro music,
Williams restrains it to its proper ethnic setting), with the ambient
sound design actually resembling Horner's Vibes for a few
moments. Overall, Williams very masterfully illuminates Japanese styles
and instrumentation in the environment of a Western orchestra to make
the score enjoyable for the mainstream. But it is a very restrained
piece until its final moments, so don't expect any level of pomp or
bravado. Elegantly simple and undemanding. ****@Amazon.com: CD or
Download

Bias Check:

For John Williams reviews at Filmtracks, the average editorial rating is 3.78
(in 74 reviews)and the average viewer rating is 3.65
(in 346,747 votes). The maximum rating is 5 stars.