In it, he goes over-the-top and gets emotional delivering a hilariously self-important recounting of how he first got his start on SNL. (In real life, the Portlandia star was a cast member on the show between 2002 and 2013.)

Other highlights from the night included his turn as insufferable girlfriend Regine, with Jason Sudeikis lending a heavy assist as Regine’s smitten boyfriend, as well as a spoof on Robin Williams’ classic role in Dead Poets Society.

The sketch, titled “Farewell Mr. Bunting,” was a near word-for-word re-creation of the famous last scene from the 1989 film, down to the desktop declarations of “O Captain! My Captain!” — with a twist.

Andy Samberg made a surprise cameo on the show with a hilarious Lonely Island digital short about a woman with a sexual fetish involving Osama bin Laden.