Jimbob the question is important. As the name of the first kill is exactly the sort of flavour information I would expect madge to put in a scum role PM. I agree with somitomi on this one, it seems like a really unlikely slip for an experienced player. D) This is a rather aggressive response to a q...

Calling out three people in your first post? You are feeling very spirited this game. I like it :) Have you ever played with wam before? I know he's old guard but that's about it. Games on this forum used to have much longer days (1 -2 weeks, extensions common). It’s only recently that we’ve shifte...

Werewolf of Wall Street So I knew the game started, not because I glanced at the forum on my phone, but because the forum email is working for the first time since July. If only davean had waited another 12 hours to fix it I might have seen the game started a few hours before I got home and had time...

Now i re read it it makes sense, I didn't explain myself properly. What I was saying was that spotting the day chat only thing was suspicious as it is what someone with chat would spot, not missing the night length. Yes, I FoS’d somitomi for knowing about daychat even though it appears he did not r...

@ Bessie as people with chat are more likely to notice that restriction! Thank you for pointing out a second time that you didn’t know all chats are day chat! This seems extremely detailed for the lack of information we have. Some of those roles are common enough, but why are you assuming the bulle...

Halloween Mafia Early Signups Madge and Sabrar are going to make a halloween game??? Me and Sabrar are still coming up with the setup but based on Sabrar's general excellence I already think we're going to have something fun; once we have more nailed down I'll update this signup flavour. In the mea...

First and most important, thank you Overswarm for the extraordinary game! I feel quite honored that xkcd was chosen to host this, and that so many players participated in this special cross site game. Next, thanks to YOLOSWAG/marshy for modding. I appreciate your dedication in ensuring this game hap...

Hi I’m lurking! JudeMorrigan, where the heck have you been? Get back in here and sign up for a game. 2. I called my roommates dog, Rosie, bessie by accident on at least more than one occasion because their names are similar and I had this game on the brain sometimes. Aw, you were thinking about me ...

Crossover Mafia Town looks like it's going to self destruct. Shame. I'm really surprised everyone dropped the "two mafia faction" idea Day 2, I feel like day1lynch (sorry forgot his name) accepting it without question should have kept the idea in the spotlight Yep, I was pu...

Crossover Mafia If it gets down to possessed!bessie and one other townie, what's the endstate of the game? The town win condition, because, you know, I just happen to have a copy: Win Condition You are Town, and you win when your faction is the only remaining faction or nothing can prevent this....

Crossover Mafia Pre spoiler speculation. BoomFrog is so totally scum I should have refused to move my vote from him on D4. I really hate this majority lynch mechanic because you don’t necessarily get to vote for who you think is scum, you need to vote to ensure a lynch. Or maybe BoomFrog is town, an...

Crossover Mafia So why is Gojoe so quiet? Everyone else must be in chat by now. Sorry about that FrozenFlame. It should have been BoomFrog, but no one was voting him except for me. Red Ryu was being stubborn about Madge, and plytho let EGW move him back on to FF. plytho is non town, or he was being ...

Bessie (really not sure where to put her so here she is: decision maker could be useful for scum but it's testable and I think we should test it: just remembered the Peaceful Whale result so she's moved from "good claims" to "likely town") Why do you think we should test bessie’...

FrozenFlame and Red Ryu, please pick a better target than Madge. She's in jail and can't perform the night kill. Lynch her buddies first. plytho, it’s probably buried somewhere in the last 20 pages of content, but who do you think are Madge’s buddies? And lynching Madge’s buddies is what I’m trying...

Interesting interaction with Bessie here. Honestly not sure if scum!Bessie sticks her neck out for a partner this early on simply to basically say "don't answer for H_A." I'm having trouble gleaning if this is Bessie legitimately interested in what H_A's explanation would have been and is...

I'm rereading now and trying to reply to today's content. I'll be here until deadline if my vote is needed to hammer but my strongest scum read this morning was BoomFrog and I would rather lynch him than FrozenFlame (pending today's content).

The reason why I like Madge's vote is because she made her own decision based on claims when she could have joined on Boom. Yes but you’re overlooking the possibility that she didn't want to vote for BoomFrog because she is scum with BoomFrog. Why is Sabrar targeting Madge with the watcher power if...

Today I don't have a lot of classes, but a lot of "distractions" -- I have to get in to the Doctor, some students won an art contest and I have to go to the prize ceremony, another student has to be picked up from the doctor… I can guarantee getting on 2 hours to 1 1/2 hours before deadli...

Bessie, can you go more into your read on Frozen? Frozen Flame- I liked his D1 content, reviewing now I think it’s interesting that he was so sure about the setup, and now it seems he had many things wrong. At the time I agreed with most of the content in this post and this post , especially the co...

Bessie, why do you disagree with my Laser read? He is too confident with PW, Zen, and Boom. Is this referring specifically to LaserGuy's D2 reads? I think it’s a null because he’s confident in his reads as scum and town (as I’ve said previously here ). Tries to use the Zen kill as reason to find Bo...

I’m not a huge fan of night action planning (Sabrar can confirm). Reasons include: 1. Scum probably lied about their powers so the plan is already flawed. 2. Scum could be the planner (especially dangerous with day chat, since scum can coordinate to revise the plan if someone objects). 3. The plan s...

Crossover Mafia Hi Gojoe, I already dumped all my thoughts including my setup spec in the game thread. How am I doing moody? I’m still totally pissed at being possessed and don’t think I can win, since I will need to get rid of the other mafia and make it to the end with one townie (I think…I do...

@LaserGuy: I agree Sabrar doesn't like to bus early, but I suspect that Moody asked to be bussed. He decided that the game was overwhelming and he'd surly be lynched by late game so he decided to save himself the trouble and get bussed early. Sabrar, EGW and plytho seeing together and get mad towni...

bessie’s setup spec, refer to this post from D3. I’m still pondering the setup. I’ve been leaning toward more than one anti-town faction. Based on the flips, my current guess is one main mafia group with a kill, one anti-town group with a goal based wincon, and 2-3 independents. Some things influenc...

Fyi, I have considered Madges later content. I am surprised you don't have more sympathy for her RL schedule. She's perfectly portrayed busy townie who only skims the thread but does want to help. That’s an interesting observation: that she’s portrayed her role perfectly. However, if you were not s...

There's no clear pattern but it does confirm that FF and Red are way too attacked to be scum. I don’t understand this comment, do you mean tunneled on by a few players too much to be scum, or attacked by too many different people to be scum? @Bessie: I'm not saying it's an amazing use of the power,...

I'm confused about this kerfuffle about my initial post and a link with boomfrog and apparently something about me being clever (you know how to stroke my ego...)? I missed something, but what? TBH, I’m not sure what Sabrar’s and BoomFrog’s magic meta read was in your initial post, but I don’t do t...

Also, show me someone else who is being called "it" or "that slot". It's a horrible way to speak about somebody who is trying her best. Madge, I understand you’re upset at the “slot” references, but I think it’s just convention on their site, and the DGamers have used this term ...

There is still the balance issue Is a single-shot Jailer enough protection in a 20 player game? There was the possibility that town!Megaman would inherit the jailer, the wraith, and EGW’s commuter power (if it is the one that is listed first). And the jailer lasts until it is removed. Why did you n...

and if you want to lynch me let me know because i'll quit rather than waste an opportunity for town to lynch scum, because maybe that way I can do one fucking tiny shred of a helpful thing. I feel that would be against the spirit of the rules. I know I'm not the one harassing you but I hope you can...

:shock: my role PM is ambiguous about this! I am asking for clarification.\ :shock: Why am I again not surprised that you claim to have misunderstood your role pm? And I am even more suspicious because of the power itself that you claim should have prompted you that you possibly misunderstood how t...

Madge, please confirm that you need N/2 votes to activate each power separately (three times), and not N/2 votes once to activate all three powers. I am Joel from Last of Us, town decision maker. I have a one shot power that if used, the following day no player can change their vote once they vote f...

On the other hand scum have had really weak fake claims so far so I think we should go for it. This is an odd thing to say. What makes you think scum has weak fake claims? And do you think all town powers are strong? While we get this organized I'd like to play another fun little game. I like every...

@bessie: I have your post tucked away and will answer it later but this all seemed more urgent and I need to get back to work. If you could divide your posts (once they are done) by player you are focusing on, then post those sections as separate posts it would make quote replying easier for phone ...

My bessie interactions at that point were unpleasant and unfruitful. I didn't want a copy of that in chat. I figured I could at least talk with LaserGuy. If you are for some unfathomable reason nightkilled I can keep my evil useless chat to uselessly chat with bessie. Good thing you prevented that....