Overall them menus are really disappointing.
However, with tip included, as well as appetizer, and considering these would all be 2 credit restaurants if they were Disney O&O, as well as breakfast also being included, I’d say pricewise, it’s a little better than the deluxe dining plan. I just don’t like the menu limitations though.

The Swan, which opened January 13, 1990 on Disney property, is an official Disney Hotel but not owned by the Walt Disney Company. Rather, it is owned by Tishman Hotel Corporation and operated by Starwood Hotels & Resorts Worldwide under the Westin Hotels brand.

Tishman owns the buildings, but has a 99-year lease on the land from Disney. Disney also receives a share of the hotel’s revenues, and has a say in any design or architecture changes to the interior or exterior of the buildings.