We are a house divided when it comes to soup. One of us (me) likes their soup served piping hot, and the other likes his merely warm. (My daughter is not part of this equation since I always make sure to serve her soup cool enough not to burn her tongue). I often get accused of serving boiling hot food for dinner, however my husband usually manages to get around the problem by eating his salad first while his soup cools.

So I knew there would be trouble when Dorie recommends that this soup be served “brûlante”, or “burning hot”. Indeed, the main feedback I got about this recipe is that it was too hot.

“Cheese-Topped Onion Soup” is the quintessential French Onion Soup. A large amount of onions are slowly caramelized, then the addition of white wine and chicken broth turns it into soup. The crowning touch is a piece of toasted bread and melted Gruyère cheese sitting atop the soup.

I had a problem getting my onions to turn a “deep caramel color”. After 3 hours(!) of cooking and giving into the temptation to try to speed things up by turning the heat up, they were only a light tan color. My husband and I ended up eating dinner after my daughter went to bed because it was running so late. I’m curious to see if others had the same problem.

Light Tan Onions After 3 Hours of Cooking

I found this soup to be very satisfying to eat, but not to make. I enjoyed the flavors and especially the cheesy bread on top, but it wasn’t quite worth the nearly 4 hours it took to make.

I didn’t begin my soup until 6 – by 9:30 we were starving. My onions did not brown as much as I would have liked,(would have cooked them longer is we could have waited) but the soup was still very good.

Wow, it sounds like a lot of people had very long browning times. Mine took a little over an hour using a 9 Qt dutch oven over medium-ish heat.
Your soup looks great – it would go perfect on this cold, snowy morning…

Your soup looks lovely! Sounds like so many people had problems with the caramelizing. I haven’t made this one yet but love french onion soup so I’ll be looking forward to it. Yours looks delicious! Nice post!

Your soup looks wonderful, Karen! The elevation must have helped cook your onions faster. 🙂 I got so tired making this that I forgot to take photos while the onions were cooking, but the end result was so worth the time.