Columbia in most years are probably ranked between 20-40 in the state of Florida, if Madison had to play a team of that level once during season I would think they will have a average to above average chance of competing and/or beating them when healthy
But I don't think Madison could handle facing that level of schedule for the majority of their season without being wore down
That's what separates them from being mentioned alongside the powerhouses in the larger classifications

Here's the thing you have to keep in mind
Madison does deserve credit for being as good as they are and they can every now and then knock off a "true" top FL 25 team
However most national powers can compete with and defeat a top 25 FL team, every week of the season
Madison is capable of beating top 25 teams from time to time but at no point would I believe they could run a full schedule of top 25 teams and hang for the majority of that schedule
Madison lacks the overall depth to rise to the level of a national powerhouse, only a few programs in Florida can be seen as believable national powerhouses on a consistent basis

Hello again my friend
It will be interesting to see how TCA does this season. They are always one of the toughest teams in the state regardless of class. However, we at OTC have a senior laden team this season and have our old most winning HC Brantley back at the helm. Went to the 2nd round last year with mostly a Sophomore and Junior team and that team did defeat TCA in the 1st round. So if both teams do well in the regular season you guys will probably be coming through us in the 1st round again. I'll advise not looking past us.