According to the New York Post, Yankees shortstop stud Derek Jeter makes sure to give his lady friends a small piece of his MLB pride the morning after. After splitting with starlet Minka Kelly, Jeter has reportedly begun sending his one-night stands off with autographed baseball memorabilia. A so-called “friend” of Jeter’s dished out the gossip to the Post, saying that Jeter had an encounter with the same woman twice without realizing it.

“This summer, he ended up hooking up with a girl who he had hooked up with once before, but Jeter seemed to have forgotten about the first time and gave her the same identical parting gift, a gift basket with a signed Derek Jeter baseball,” said his acquaintance. “He basically gave her the same gift twice because he’d forgotten hooking up with her the first time!”

Some would say autographed swag from one of baseball’s biggest stars isn’t such a bad deal. Here’s what people are posting.