Sunday, August 02, 2009

Purported heroization of Judas

Scholars have long recognized that the four “canonical” gospels ascribed to Matthew, Mark, Luke, John are not the only ones we have. This hallowed quartet represents a mere selection from a much larger body of available gospels and memoirs of the life of Jesus. No one knows--or can ever know given the losses of fragile papyrus--how many members of this special company once existed. Yet today at least sixteen noncanonicals are extant. The texts of most of these can be read in translation, as for example in the book edited by J. K. Elliott, “The Apocryphal New Testament” (Oxford University Press, 1993). In fact scholars have been pouring over these texts for the better part of two centuries.

During the 1970s a leather-bound Coptic papyrus was discovered near Beni Masah in Egypt. The codex has four parts: the Letter of Peter to Philip, already known from the Nag Hammadi Library; the First Apocalypse of James, also known from the Nag Hammadi Library; the first few pages of a work related to, but not the same as, the Nag Hammadi work Allogenes; and the Gospel of Judas. About a third of the codex is currently illegible. Since the other three texts were previously known, interest has focused on the last, the Gospel of Judas. This document is not claimed to have been written by Judas himself, but rather by Gnostic followers of Jesus.

After many vicissitudes, this intriguing manuscript came into the possession of the National Geographic Society, which sponsored a 2006 translation of the text (a translation that has proved defective in some respects). The Gospel is an esoteric account of an arrangement between Jesus and Judas, who in this telling are Gnostic enlightened beings, with Jesus asking Judas to turn him in to the Romans in order to allow Jesus finish his appointed task from God.

As has been noted, currently the text is extant in only one manuscript, a late-third or fourth-century Coptic compilation known as the Codex Tchacos, which surfaced in the 1970s, after languishing some sixteen centuries in the desert of Egypt. (Rumors that another version resides in the Vatican Library are unsubstantiated.) The existing manuscript has been dated "between the third and fourth century," according to Timothy Jull, a radiocarbon-dating expert at the University of Arizona's physics centre. That means, of course, that the present text was written some 250 years after the death of Jesus. It is generally assumed that it is the Coptic rendering of a Greek original, but there is no way of determining the date of that.

Some scholars detect a possible clue to the origin of the Greek original in a reference to a “Gospel of Judas” by the early Christian writer Irenaeus of Lyons, who, in arguing against Gnosticism about 180 CE, called the text a "fictitious history" (Refutation of Gnosticism, 1:31). Still, it is not certain that the text Irenaeus mentioned is in fact the same text as the Coptic “Gospel of Judas,” which in its present form must be at least a century later. Thus there remains no solid evidence for an early Greek prototype.

Unlike the four canonical gospels, which employ narrative accounts of the last year of life of Jesus (in the case of John, three years) and of his birth (in the case of Luke and Matthew), the Gospel of Judas takes the form of dialogues between Jesus and Judas, and Jesus and the twelve disciples, without embedding these in any narrative framework or working them into any overt philosophical or rhetorical context. Such "dialogue gospels" were popular during the early decades of Christianity, and indeed the four canonical gospels are the only surviving gospels in narrative form. The New Testament apocrypha contain several examples of the dialogue form, an example being the Gospel of Mary Magdalene.

Owing to poor treatment after its exhumation, today the manuscript is in over a thousand pieces, with many sections missing. For some passages, there are only scattered words; for others, many lines. According to Rodolphe Kasser, the codex originally contained 31 pages, with writing on front and back; when it came to the market in 1999, only 13 pages, with writing on front and back, remained. It is thought that individual pages had been removed and sold.

According to the canonical Gospels of the New Testament, Judas betrayed Jesus to Jerusalem's Temple authorities, who handed Jesus over to the Roman prefect Pontius Pilate for crucifixion. The Gospel of Judas, on the other hand, portrays Judas in a very different light, for the newly recovered text seems to present Judas's act not as betrayal, but rather as an act of obedience to the instructions of Jesus. It seems that Jesus required a second agent to set in motion a course of events which he had planned. In that way Judas acted as a catalyst. The action of Judas, then, constituted a critical juncture, triggering a series of pre-orchestrated events.

This depiction seems to accord with a notion current in some forms of Gnosticism, that the human body is a kind of prison of the spirit. In this view Judas served Christ by helping to release Christ's spirit from its corporeal bondage. The action of Judas allowed him to do that which he could not do directly. The Gospel of Judas does not claim that the other disciples knew Gnostic teachings. In fact, the Gospel implies that Judas was the only one of Jesus’ followers to fully understand the Gnostic teachings: "Knowing that Judas was reflecting upon something that was exalted, Jesus said to him: Step away from the others and I shall tell you the mysteries of the Kingdom. It is possible for you to reach it, but you will grieve a great deal. For someone else will replace you, in order that the twelve disciples may again come to completion with their God."

Moreover, the Gospel of Judas shows Jesus in various instances criticizing the other disciples for their ignorance and their followers of immorality.

When they tell Jesus about a vision, he points out its true meaning as follows: "Those you have seen receiving the offerings at the altar — that is who you are. That is the God you serve, and you are those twelve men you have seen. The cattle you saw brought for sacrifice are the many people you lead astray before that altar. (. . .) will stand and make use of my name in this way, and generations of the pious will remain loyal to Him."

The early conclusions stemming from the find have not gone unchallenged. April D. DeConick, a professor of Biblical studies at Rice University, has emerged as a major critic of the translation sponsored by the National Geographic. She maintains that this version is faulty in many substantial respects. Based on a corrected translation, Judas was actually a demon, truly betraying Jesus, rather than following his orders.

Having retranslating the text, DeConick published “The Thirteenth Apostle: What the Gospel of Judas Really Says” to assert that Judas was not a daimon in the Greek sense, but that "the universally accepted word for “spirit” is “pneuma ” — in Gnostic literature “daimon” is always taken to mean “demon”, as she wrote in The New York Times, 1 December 2007. "Judas is not set apart 'for' the holy generation, as the National Geographic translation says." Instead, DeConick asserted, "he is separated 'from' it." A negative that was dropped from a crucial sentence, an error National Geographic admits, changes the import.. "Were they genuine errors or was something more deliberate going on?" DeConick asked in the Op-Ed page of the Times.

DeConick has stated her views more fully in her monograph, "The Thirteenth Apostle: What the Gospel of Judas Really Says" (London: Continuum, 2007 [1st ed.]; 2009 [rev. ed.]).

In the first edition of this book, DeConick challenged the idea that the Gospel of Judas presented the traditionally infamous disciple in a favorable light, as the scholars who published the edition sponsored by the National Geographic maintained. DeConick has concluded that the recently recovered gospel was, in fact, “an ancient Gnostic parody.” The publisher’s website quotes her as saying:

“I didn’t find the sublime Judas, at least not in Coptic. What I found were a series of English translation choices made by the National Geographic team, choices that permitted a different Judas to emerge in the English translation than in the Coptic original. Judas was not only not sublime, he was far more demonic than any Judas I know in any other piece of early Christian literature, Gnostic or otherwise.”

For the second edition, DeConick reports in a personal post:

“I revised this book substantially, including two new chapters - one on Judas and astrology (my paper from the Codex Judas Congress) and another on Judas and ancient magic (I cover the magic gem that I think is related to the ideology put forth in the Gospel of Judas). I also have a new preface, covering what has been happening with the Gospel of Judas since its initial release, and I added a section on Thomasine church in the chapter on early Christianity.”

In short, DeConick has clearly established herself as one of the leading proponents of the “Judas as villain” position. The matter is still disputed, but it is no longer possible simply to maintain the hero view--especially since it seems to be based in part on mistranslation and wishful thinking. Thus the purported heroization of Judas seems to have ground to a halt.

Another issue concerns salvation. The first commentators held that the Gospel of Judas teaches that access to the Kingdom will be widely available. Later consideration, however, shows that this boon will be accorded only to a select few.

Stung by these criticisms the National Geographic editors have seen fit to issue a second edition of their version. This text corrects some, but not all the errors.

In an insightful piece, “Betrayal,” just published in The New Yorker (August 3, 2007), Joan Acocella asks why this battered papyrus book should have generated so much excitement. She sees the interest as reflecting a concern about the persistence of evangelical and fundamentalist views. I would go somewhat further. For some time now a group of dissident Christian intellectuals, with Elaine Pagels at their head, has been seeking to construct a kind of Christianity II from the surviving body of material that did not make it into the New Testament. This new (or they would say old) version of Christianity would be tolerant, pluralistic, proerotic, and feminist (perhaps even progay).

A good example of this selectivity is the purported feminism of the Gnostic Gospel of Thomas. At the end of this text, however, it says that a woman must become a man in order to enter the Kingdom of Heaven. Another instance comes from the Gospel of Judas itself, where Jesus denounces the priests of the Temple for the sins of murder and homosexuality (“lying with males").

In a nutshell, the problem with this hopeful project is that it is a modern fabrication, not a convincing reconstruction of a lost ancient faith. Granted that the orthodox view embodied in the now-canonical Christian scriptures is the result of a process of selection, why would a different selection enjoy any authority? There could be many such creations. The fact that the current amalgam is modern-friendly would seem to count against it, since one of the enduring characteristics of ancient documents is that they are, in many respects, profoundly alien from our own way of thinking.

My sense is that the Gospel of Judas has proved something of a dead end. Still, the figure of Judas continues to fascinate. As Acocella points out, one reason is that he became a focus for Christian anti-Semitism. Acocella also notes a new book by the feminist scholar Susan Gubar, which attempts to trace the evolution of the Judas figure in Western culture. Apparently, “Judas: A Biography” offers some interesting observations about works of art.

Not having read Gubar's book, I cannot say whether her survey includes the following scabrous episode from a late medieval Jewish work, the Toledot Jusu. According to this account, the miracle-working powers of Jesus derive from his having stolen the Name of God from the Temple in Jerusalem. Jesus goes to Galilee, where he brings clay birds to life and makes a millstone float. Jesus is thus a sorcerer. Nefariously, Judas Iscariot learns the Divine Name as well, and so Jesus and Judas fly through the sky engaged in aerial combat. As the winner, Judas sodomizes Jesus, whereupon both fall to the ground. The now powerless Jesus is arrested and put to death by being hung upon a carob tree, and buried.

The past yields many curious relics. A passage from Gubar’s book reveals the far shores onto which this kind of speculation can lead, even in these latter days:

“A male Eve, Judas—rejecting or accepting, promoting or curtailing Jesus’ potency—inhabits a decidedly queer place in the Western imaginary. To the extent that Judas stands for the poser or passer—a person who is not what he seems to be—he reflects anxieties about all sorts of banned or ostracized groups, not just Jews. An apostle in an all-male circle, associated with anality and with the disclosure of secrets, Judas retains his masculinity. . . . At other times and in diverse contexts, though, Judas represents a range of quite various and variously stigmatized populations—criminals, heretics, foreigners, Africans, dissidents, the disabled, the suicidal, the insane, the incurably ill, the agnostic. Members of these groups, too, have been faulted for posing or passing as (alien) insiders. Potentially convertible, all such outcasts might be thought to be using camouflaging techniques to infiltrate, hide out, assimilate, and thereby turn a treacherous trick.”

Welcome to this young and newest Escorts Agency. We start this escorts agency in the last month of 2014 it develops the centre of visitors from all over India. All gentlemen who belong to other cities join this models escorts agency here and get entertainment only entertainment.

Hyderabad beautiful girls spread happiness in your life their elegant killer looks make men crazy. You can easily avail the services of appealing and beautiful Independent Escorts Hyderabad as and when you like.High society Escorts in Hyderabad are well aware about the significance of the desires of their clients. Intimate services of high class Hyderabad Escorts are simply superb by all means. You can experience majestic intimate services wrapped in the layers of cupidity every single time.Along with agency escorts you can also find the services of high class Hyderabad escorts services as well.http://allgirlhotties6.in/

Welcome dear, I am kanchan sengar, and Hyderabad Escorts girl to make you feel lit up with a perfect sexual and mental satisfaction. I am such a great Independent Female escort, in whose association you will feel peaceful, relaxed and energetic immediately.I am the ideal Hyderabad escort for the men who have flawless taste in all viewpoints. I am shockingly lovable and appealing, and in addition have an energizing persona and a considerable measure of fascination and understanding of Hyderabad escort services. A heart-to-heart meeting with me is an amazing feel from the very initial minutes.http://kanchansengar.in/

We are a high class escort service that represents some Nashik's most beautiful companions.We Nashik Escorts Services have an inmate understanding of what makes our clients happy and are flexible enough to accommodate many different requirements.Our main focus is providing the best Independent Escorts in Nashik, we keep our clients satisfied and update very often.Our call girls, hot woman and beautiful Nashik Escorts in gallery where you can select the best of best.

The gorgeous the sexiest the stunning it all about the Independent Thane Escorts, who is soo sexy escorts girls in our Thane Escorts Service we are so liberal and dedicated to our service and also for our client the is so memorable for you and your service.Most of the clients looking for the intimate session with the sexy and hot Escorts in thane because of lack of romance in their life.

My Dear, pleasant welcome to the hot spot of Independent Jaipur Escorts. I am the manager of Escorts in Jaipur ankita here. You were did an outstanding search to discover the real Independent Escorts in Jaipur city. I welcome you for that and you are very blessed to make me without deceptive by any other shameful class service provider. Have you ever enjoyed the GF based loving Jaipur Escorts. If not it is the perfect time to have it. I am ankita, a very popular female fashion model for luxurious Jaipur Escorts Services and secret fun making activities.

Guys! Here your navya khan is back with her new forms. A well known and highly reputed Independent Jaipur Escorts.Being an escort is quite easy, but being a popular one is not so easy task.Jaipur Escorts is an elite agency that offers a wide range of adult entertainment to almost every corner of the Jaipur city. With an occupied designation in own running Independent Escorts in Jaipur When most of Jaipur sleeps under the moon, me and my Jaipur Escorts Services turn your wildest fantasies of the bed into reality. With navyakhan’s outcall Escorts in Jaipur that turns your running desires for that night of playfulness.

grows up rapidly day by day. So more and more such agencies start their activities. They are mostly concentrated in Lucknow, which is quite naturally,and one of the most attractive cities in touristic and business aspects. Jaipur Escorts are rather outstanding owing to their amazing beauty, female charm and refined manners. Jaipur Escorts Services in the capital run thorough selection when employing this or that woman. The reason is each Escorts in Jaipur knows the value for clients. ArtiChopra ( A+ ), Independent Jaipur Escorts is about sexual energy and will fun with you in a completely different Independent Escorts in Jaipur way of dealing with this energy within you.

Welcome to our Jaipur Escorts Services home page where you can get all the possible details and answers to each and every query of yours.These Jaipur Escorts including Jaipur model escorts and Russian model Escorts in Jaipur are always game for anything.If you visit this website, then you shall be quite stunned to have discovered a vivid range of Independent Jaipur Escorts They are simply mesmerizing in whatever they do and shall smartly execute their job of seduction in order to make their client’s desires run wild.They undertake each and every client calls with equal sincerity and precision so that our Independent Escorts in Jaipur agency never loses its charm and reputation which has always been a sign of excellence and achievement for us.

kanchan batra is a sweet caring young lady that is happy to be your sweet India By Night is an honest Jaipur Escorts Services offering female escorts in Jaipur with wide range of portfolio. Our Independent Escorts in Jaipur include budget models escort in Jaipur, upcoming models Escorts in Jaipur. People seeking beautiful and educated escorts in India are requested to go through the profiles and photos of our Jaipur Escorts and choose according to their choice.While individuals look for an Independent Jaipur Escorts they repeatedly recover themselves dissatisfied with not simply the female they expend moment with them but the services they obtain also.

We have earned the credibility with our honest approach and sheer dedication.People prefer Jaipur Escorts Services for the satisfaction of their intimate desires and Jaipur Escorts fully satisfy them always. We always deliver what we promise. Quality of our Independent Jaipur Escorts becomes predominant always because we are committed to serve our clients with the best options available with us.Our Escorts in Jaipur can take you along to an unforgettable ride where you can enjoy the never before explored treasures of physical fun.Though, several other agencies are also offering Independent Escorts in Jaipur, but they can’t give you the needed joy and satisfaction. High profile people love to enjoy with our escorts always because they know the class and elegance of our escorts.

The best part of it all is that the highly trained Jaipur Escorts Services help the client to relax their mind. This applies especially when you had a long day at work. They provide for high professional Jaipur Escorts who will ensure unlimited fun for you.You’ll definitely get satisfied by my company as I also have the body of a model. You want to share your time with some Independent Jaipur Escorts, once to go through the journey of my love.let me explain, my services have all the twists and turns you expect from a Independent Escorts in Jaipur. Because I am a model, my body is toned, curvaceous and has a great sex appeal. So what is the meaning to search any other Escorts in Jaipur!

Shashi bhargav is a Luxury Jaipur Escorts Services providing a high class Escorts in Jaipur the areas of Jaipur and many of the top cities around the globe. We’re able to provide you a wide variety of Jaipur Escorts, and our VIP Service ensures you receive the high-quality service and professionalism that you require.We have hand-picked and selected roster of beautiful Escorts From Jaipur ready to accompany you.the most famous our VIP Travel Independent Jaipur Escorts. I and my teammates very well know how to deal with customers. Independent Escorts in Jaipur service 24/7 for you all around year.

My Self kamya agnihotri and I am an Independent Jaipur Escorts girl providing my Escorts in Jaipur. I was created in Jaipur and I have done my education from here as well.Jaipur Escorts brings you the best colours from the city.You can also recommend your buddies about me if they are top level guys and like to fulfill an Independent Escorts in Jaipur for fun and entertainment.The most attractive thing of our agency is that you would find yourself in the middle of most attractive Jaipur Escorts Services brings you the best.So hiring High Profile Independent Jaipur Escorts like me is the dream come true for you. Isn’t It boys ???

Welcome to the romantic gateway of love and amour. If you have the itch to meet busty, beautiful,curvy, and vivacious Hyderabad Escorts Services, you are at the right destination.Before getting started with the independent, you should know her well. You should spend some happy moments by chatting with her.Nowadays, “Independent Hyderabad Escorts” has been a popular term to end up with the most desired escorts in India.If you are searching for the High Profile Independent Escorts in Hyderabad that is convenient for your special demand and essential.The Hyderabad Escorts are yet another group of escort girls in Hyderabad who takes their profession sportingly and simply love to serve their clients in a unique and desirable way.Escorts in Hyderabad Divas are not new in the escort market so that amazing features in them easily you can find, it means from many years we are serving elegant escort to client to keep them happy and satisfied.

Your welcome to all friends Hyderabad Escorts Services. Friends have you ever our escort service in your city, if yes then do not need to tell you something. You might have hired escorts earlier also in various parts of the country but being with the Glamorous Hyderabad Escorts is really something different you will secure for your lifetime.Escorts in Hyderabad are a shocking consortium of tempting female sidekicks driven by devotion and responsibility, never ready to bargain on the nature of administrations they give to their regarded customers.In the event that you are searching for a sensual accomplice, burrow through the talented and expert Independent Escorts in Hyderabad commended for giving quality administrations the considerable thoughtfulness regarding customer's needs and prerequisites.Who will not like to be with a hot,Independent Hyderabad Escorts who behaves like his girlfriend during the romance sessions?

This is one of the strong reasons why the professional Hyderabad Escorts Services of the city are highly demanded. They are engaged in offering nonstop fun and entertainment to their esteemed customers. To please every customer, they have trained themselves in the modern art of erotica. Today, Independent Hyderabad Escorts are offering popular erotic services at the most competitive prices.Hyderabad Escorts are including precious diamond in identity of people who loves to live royal life. You will have sure assistance of fun making ladies for improving your lives and sure the environment will be like a dream with presence of gorgeous Escorts in Hyderabad.We curate one of the most exquisite and classy High Profile Independent Escorts in Hyderabad for our elite class exclusive clients who want to enjoy the best variety, choices and class in the town.

This is the purpose for which their customer platform includes entrepreneurs and expert guys centered in Chandigarh. They anticipate and necessity to possess an exceptional escort support. Choice may be done by the interesting and increasing profile of wonderful female escort service in Chandigarh to select from. If you are in the town of Chandigarh and want escorts company, go for the town's most popular escorts ladies. You can get provided by models by divas and time by evening.

Anyone requiring Zirakpur escorts agency with immense quality in conditions of appealing physical appearance, sexy body, beautiful encounters and hot stuffed, sexual pleasures, young girl friendly encounter may come across our company quite helpful. Our females are highly informed and one can opt out the best one and there will end up being no single boring instant.

About Me

I like to consider myself a citizen of Cosmopolis, ranging widely across the humanities. I have traveled to 45 countries, and speak five languages. Out of self-interest, I am concerned with current affairs in my own country. Writing is important to me: I have published seventeen books (including edited volumes).
My beginning the blog coincided with my retirement. No longer muzzled, I felt, by the demands of being a salaried professor, I gave vent to my untrammeled opinions. Sometimes, perhaps, too much so--but it is my right, all the same. Here is an appropriate motto from La Fontaine: Est bien fou du cerveau qui prétend contenter tout le monde et son père. ("The Miller, His Son, and the Donkey"). For my work in linguistics see the revised (electronic) version of Homolexis at www.williamapercy.com/homolexis/index.php?title=Main_Page; for the Encyclopedia of Homosexuality, see:
http://www2.hu-berlin.de/sexology/BIB/EOH/index.htm. See also the electronic version of my 1987 book, Homosexuality: A Research Guide (/www2.hu-berlin.de/sexology/BIB/ResGde/main.htm).