i like this best out them all, but the red is very jarring and i'm noticing the color instead of the design and pattern (which are beautiful). If you really want color what about a black bkgrd with a the 3 berries you have being red? It would give it a pop without taking away from anything.

i think i like the handwritten joy better. It feels like it fits in the space better. And I LOVE the charcol version. Very chalkboard drawing-ish. I'm not sure the color palette in this version is reading holiday. Maybe if the blue 5-petal flowers were red? they would read as pointsetta's i like the layout in versions 1 and 2. I think this could be a winner with a litle tweeking. I lvoe it!