When the favorite female country artist at the AMAs performed "I Knew You Were Trouble," we caught a different glimpse of the star. After beating Miranda Lambert and Carrie Underwood in the category, there was no doubt about it: It was Taylor's night to shine.

Descending the stage from a winding staircase similar to her "Love Story" video, a masquerade party morphed from a fairy tale with masked suitors to a dance party!