Constitutional limits

BBJ

Thursday, April 21, 2011, 15:20

On the occasion of ratifying the new constitution, the Hungarian government received a great amount of criticism. The BBJ, being a paper that values the liberty of free thought, agrees with parts of the critique, mainly the ones that challenge the document for disregarding human rights.

But, being also a business paper, the BBJ must admit that certain parts of the constitution, such as the introduction of a debt ceiling, even at the price of reducing the government’s jurisdiction, are not necessarily the work of the devil. Far from it.

The fact that there is a debt ceiling enshrined in the constitution might be an unorthodox measure, but in a country that has suffered from ever-increasing public debt and irresponsible spending, we see it as a good thing, maybe. It could be argued that it should not be 50%, as it is, but it is probably superfluous to do so: there are several “exceptions” to this rule, including periods of economic difficulty. It could also be argued that linking tax legislation to a two-thirds majority vote will make the tax system inflexible. However, another word for inflexible is predictable. It could turn out to be predictably bad, which would be a bad thing, but we are sure that the minor tax laws, which will probably set the rates if not the tax types, will allow the government some room for adaptation to circumstances.

We can only hope that basing so many important regulations on a two-thirds majority will eventually force Hungarian politics to become more consensual. At the moment, it does not seem likely that there will be another government with a two-thirds majority in the near future, which means that with the new constitutional checks on government power could force governing parties to make deals with the opposition. However, the often arrogant way the current government is exercising its power does not form a good precedent for the future.

Related articles

The Department of Constitutional Law of the University of Debrecen has issued a statement strongly opposing the proposed granting by the universityʼs senate of honorary citizenship to Russian President Vladimir Putin, according to various domestic news reports.

Despite widespread criticism, Hungary’s President János Áder signed the NGO law approved by the Hungarian Parliament’s Fidesz-KDNP majority into effect today, saying he sees no constitutional concerns about it, according to online news portal index.hu.

Former President László Sólyom and former constitutional judge Miklós Lévay, together with two doctors of the Hungarian Academy of Sciences (MTA), have submitted an amicus curiae brief to the Constitutional Court of Hungary, arguing that the “lex CEU” amendment is “seriously anti-constitutional,” according to online news daily index.hu.

Although Hungary’s opposition party Jobbik has been referred to in news coverage as “far-right” or “extreme right,” a decision of the Hungarian Constitutional Court states that the party can no longer be described as such, according to reports.

The Hungarian Parliament will not vote on far-right Jobbikʼs modified draft amendment to the Fundamental Law (constitution), originally submitted by Prime Minister Viktor Orbán and rejected by Parliament, which would have set in stone the governmentʼs rejection of the European Union’s refugee settlement quotas, according to reports.

In the face of a labor shortage, Hungary should consider bringing in qualified workers from countries outside of the European Union, according to a sensible proposal offered by the Confederation of Hungarian Employers (MGYOSZ) and endorsed by National Economy Minister Mihály Varga on July 6. But it seems this plan faces a lot of opposition, and not only from the current anti-migrant government.

Hungary’s Constitutional Court (AB) rejected all initiations in opposition to the referendum on the European Commission’s refugee quota plan, as such the referendum initiated by the Hungarian government on the matter can be held this year, according to reports.