Which of these guys would you be more likely to want to date at college?

Which guy would you be more attacted too/more likely to date at college if these where the only two there?

1: Above average looking guy, sporty, confident, always with other girls, enjoys social gatherings and partying , is decent and not a douchebag, but smokes often, average intelligence.

2. Pretty much the cutest guy you know, tall and slim but shy. Doesn't talk much but can hold a conversation. Relatively introverted overall but sweet and open with you. Is more intelligent although comes across as timid in social situations and somewhat unassertive.