REVISED BROAD-BASED BLACK ECONOMIC EMPOWERMENT CODES OF GOOD PRACTICE – A FEW MORE DAYS TO SUBMIT COMMENTS TO THE DTI

Interested parties have until 4 December 2012 to submit comments to the Department of Trade and Industry (DTI) on the Revised Codes of Good Practice (COGP), which were published in the Government Gazette at the beginning of October.

According to Verushca Pillay, a director in the Corporate and Commercial practice at Cliffe Dekker Hofmeyr, every individual in South Africa should take the opportunity to comment on and thus contribute to improving the revised COGP.

“Failure to do so will result in a missed opportunity to ensure the COGP fulfill their mandate of transformation of individuals and development of the economy,” said Pillay.

Pillay noted that comments submitted to the DTI should highlight general errors in the Codes, impracticalities, impossibilities, ambiguities and unintended consequences of the Codes. Comments can be summited via email to xzondo@thedti.gov.za.

‘It is important that the submissions are constructive,” noted Pillay.

Lisa Tait, Chairperson of Transcend Corporate Advisors, said that the codes were broadly revised to address obvious errors in the existing COGP. However, there is also the need to make sure that the BEE is aligned to all of Government’s other strategy documents, such as the new growth path, which focuses on national priorities such as job creation, localisation and industrialisation.

“However, although Government has expressed its commitment to these broad developmental objectives little or no mention is made of these in the revised COGP.

“There is no recognition in the COGP for entities that create jobs, or procurement from other companies that create jobs. There is no mention of localisation, except in the Enterprise and Social Development Pillar, where importers are now included in the target, but there is no further incentive for companies in South Africa to produce or procure local content.

“With regards to Local Content, the DTI has attempted to incentivise this through the exclusion of all entities that are not Value-Added Suppliers (VAS) from participating in or being recognised by the COGP. However, the formula used is not appropriate and effectively keeps entire sectors out of the BEE Framework, which is of no benefit to anyone,” Tait said.

Pillay noted that one of the important changes to the Codes is that there are now three priority pillars: Ownership; Skills Development; and Enterprise and Supplier Development. A minimum 40% threshold applies to certain indicators in respect of these pillars, and failure to comply will result in companies being penalised. Companies not meeting the threshold of these elements will drop two levels if they are a large companies and one if they are a Qualifying Small Enterprises (QSE).

“The total BEE points for ownership has increased from 23 to 25, meaning that ownership continues to be a dominant feature on the generic scorecard. The minimum threshold applicable to ownership means that companies are required to do ownership deals or face the penalty. Existing ownership deals will have to be examined to understand the impact of the new Codes for the measured entity.

“There could also be a potential contractual consequence if the measured entity had contractually undertaken to maintain its BEE status level, because the level might now drop based on the increased points allocation for BEE status levels. The DTI will need to clarify if companies will be given time and the ability to remedy this,” explained Pillay.

“It is worth noting that the pillar that relates to people, namely management control, and the only pillar relating to broad socio-economic inclusion, namely socio-economic development, are not priority pillars,” she said.

“We feel these pillars should more adequately reflect government priorities with regards to social development, job creation and the transformation of disadvantaged individuals,” said Pillay.

Pillay explained that the revised codes propose merging the elements of Management Control and Employment Equity into a single element referred to only as Management Control, and the elements of Preferential Procurement and Enterprise Development into a single element referred to as Enterprise and Supplier Development.

“The weightings under these five pillars have changed substantially and so under the revised codes, enterprises are likely to find it much more difficult to achieve and, possibly, retain their current (and perhaps, favourable) BEE status levels,” said Pillay.

“This effectively means companies that did nothing to become BEE compliant since the codes were adopted in 2007 are being rewarded, and companies that spent time and effort on BEE compliance and transformation are being punished because everyone will have to start again moving up the compliance ladder. We are not sure that this is positive for transformation in the future,” said Tait.

Pillay explained that proposed changes include a requirement that, for Management Control and Skills Development scoring purposes, account must be taken of the different racial sub groups (i.e. Africans, Coloureds and Indians) in an attempt to manage compliance according to national demographic indicators.

Pillay noted that formulae have also been introduced for calculating demographic representation in Management Control and Skills Development scoring.

“Besides the fact that the formulae seem to contain a number of errors, they also seems to be premised on the fact that there are or will be weighting targets for each of the racial sub groups. It is not clear precisely what how, and on what basis, such weighting should be determined, since no such weighting targets have been proposed. The application of the formulae could thus lead to anomalous results,” Pillay said.

“The concern with regards to racial sub groups is that is adds an additional layer of BEE compliance, creates complexity, and adds further pressure on companies to achieve BEE compliance. This could in turn stifle economic development,” explained Pillay.

“Enterprise Development and Supplier Development are now two separate concepts,” explained Tait.

“The Enterprise and Supplier Development Pillar is aimed at local supplier development and attracts the lion’s share of the points on offer for BEE compliance. This pillar offers bonus points for the annual value of all supplier development contributions made by the measured entities as a percentage of the target,” Tait said.

“We feel this point should include not only suppliers, which are upstream in the supply chain, but also customers and distributors, and is too narrow in its current form. Beneficiation, for example, sits downstream and it cannot be argued that companies should prioritise their suppliers over their customers and other businesses related to them. The codes need to be revised to reflect the reality that all businesses related to your company are equally important,” said Tait.

“There should also be more recognition for new business creation. Only one bonus point is given for job creation. The public should demand more recognition in the codes for companies that create jobs and support new business opportunities,” said Tait.

The new Socio Economic Development scorecard details that 100% of contributions must now benefit black people, whereas currently the Codes provide that in order to be fully recognised, at least 75% of the value of these contributions must benefit black people.

Tait said, “We feel it is inappropriate for government to ask that beneficiaries must be 100% black. They should rather measure the quality of output and value of these programmes. It also effectively excludes black people who benefit from non-racial programmes.”

“We suggest a greater weighting for the Socio Economic Development Pillar – companies should be rewarded for the investments they make that benefit 100% of the population. There should be bonus points for companies who contribute to poverty alleviation, education at primary and secondary level and the strengthening of the health care system,” said Tait.

“The revised codes should be aligned with other pieces of legislation as well as the Government’s economic strategies such as the Commission for Employment Equity Report, the Industrial Policy Action Plan, the Competitive Supplier Development Programme and the New Growth Path. There is a disproportionate emphasis on ownership and senior management issues in the revised codes and inadequate incentives for employment creation and support for small enterprises and local procurement,” added Pillay.

About Angela Graham

Featured Press Releases

Johannesburg, South Africa --February 2018
4% of employees agree blocking out noise increases their productivity.(1)
Today, work happens everywhere — in busy open-plan offices and contact centers, at home, even coffee shops. This flexibility is great for business and people, but with it comes a new challenge: noise. Distraction caused by noise reduces productivity and well-being and, in contact centers, detracts from a positive customer experience.
Studies show that it takes 23 minutes to recover from distraction(3) and over 58% of employees are distracted multiple times each day.(2) That represents a significant impact on your . . .

Art by Santiago Ribeiro on display at Times Square in New York heads to Coimbra, Portugal
By FIN Staff / 5 February 2018
NEW YORK – Following the multimedia exhibition of Santiago Ribeiro’s art in Times Square, it will now head to the ‘International Surrealism Now’ exhibition in Coimbra, Portugal, having also been featured in Paris at the “Osmosis-Kiraméki Transfigured!” event along with cultural icons and renowned artists.
Portuguese surrealist painter Santiago Ribeiro has been featured since July 2017 at the Thomson Reuters and Nasdaq OMX Group at Times Square in New York City, and will remain highlighted throughout . . .

The Matt Brown Show, in association with CNBC Africa and social trading platform, Etoro, flew the wildly successful cryptocurrency trader, Luke Martin, AKA Venture Coinist, from the United States to take part in the show’s sixth live (and sold-out) cryptocurrency podcast.
The Matt Brown Show has built a listenership and captive audience in over 100 countries around the world. #CryptoJHB was the first podcast event to trend in the #1 hashtag position on Twitter in the history of South African media.
CNBC Africa broadcasted a section of The Matt Brown Show, through their programme #CryptoTrader, Hosted by Ran Neu-Ner. The Matt Brown Show . . .

GAUTENG, MIDRAND- Attracting close to three thousand athletes, and a couple thousand onlookers, the 2018 season opener of the hugely popular obstacle course racing (OCR) series, the Toyota WARRIOR Series, powered by Reebok, was off to the perfect start this past weekend at Riversands Country Farm in Johannesburg.
The OCR Toyota WARRIOR series is designed for adventure seekers from all walks of life, and, with no barrier to entry, makes obstacle course racing (OCR) accessible to anyone with a pair of trainers, t-shirt and shorts.
Course designer, Jono Hart, says Toyota WARRIOR 2018 will be the best year yet for OCR. “I build these . . .

Excitement as Global Startup Grind Chapter is established in Port Elizabeth
Startup and entrepreneurial businesses are characterised by high energy, high hopes and high expectations.
Port Elizabeth offers many advantages to these businesses - central location, institutional and private support, easy and quick accessibility within the city, a can-do mindset and friendly people willing to freely share insider knowledge and advice.
Start up businesses in Port Elizabeth have access to many different flavours of entrepreneurial support to assist them to go from Startup to global player.
What is lacking however is a forum in which these . . .