This is the only eyeliner you could ever need. It glides on extremely well, It doesn’t budge all day, and the colors are extremely pigmented. I love it so much. I found it when I was in college and haven’t stopped using it because it’s an old faithful for sure

I love MaC products so this didn’t disappoint. I have blue eyes and it looks nice with my eye color. I have bought this multiple times. It is long lasting on my eyes. I do not have oily lids so not sure if that matters. Definitely recommend.

i find the formula too dry or dries out within a short time. i don’t like pencils that need to be sharpened because i feel like it wastes more product. good staying power. i’ve had a few of these but never have been my go to item.

Okay so used teddy when I was In middle school and I just feel like that’s where it should stay. The eyeliner did not stay very well and application was always difficult. I started using a liquid liner and prefer it much more

This is one of my favorite M.A.C eyeliners after finding Smolder many years ago. It’s versatile and lasts a long time on the waterline. It’s also a great smoky-eye base. I’m thinking of getting other colors as well.

This is my go to especially when it comes to a white pencil. The formula is so creamy that is slides on like butter! Yass ma’am! I’d recommend this 100%. They last a long time and I will be buying more.

Total junk, don't buy! I was so disappointed. I'm on the hunt for an actual long lasting, waterproof eye liner and this is not the one. Since moving to sweaty, humid Florida (which I love) my eyeliner has smudged, run and faded without fail every time I wear it and am outside for any length of time. This product is not longwear. Would not recommend. :(