U.S. ammonium nitrate oversight lax, GAO says

1/1

Tony Gutierrez/The Associated Press

Flags wave on a cross for one victim of the 2013 fertilizer plant blast in West.

FROM WIRE REPORTS

Published: 21 May 2014 11:39 PM

Updated: 21 May 2014 11:39 PM

WASHINGTON — The government has no way of fully knowing which U.S. chemical facilities stock ammonium nitrate, the substance that exploded last year at a fertilizer plant in West and killed 14 people, congressional investigators say. Outdated federal policies, poor information sharing with states and a raft of industry exemptions point to scant federal oversight, says a new report obtained by The Associated Press.

The report found regulatory gaps in environmental and worker protections and urged broad changes to U.S. safety rules. President Barack Obama pledged to improve enforcement after the explosion April 17, 2013.

Without improved monitoring, federal regulators “will not know the extent to which dangerous conditions at some facilities may continue to exist,” concluded the report by the Government Accountability Office.

The GAO found that the Homeland Security Department’s database contained only a fraction of the ammonium nitrate storage facilities in the U.S. The federal database shows that 1,345 facilities in 47 states store ammonium nitrate. But spot checks of similar state records found that the federal list missed as many as two-thirds of the storage sites, said the report, which faulted companies’ noncompliance, legal loopholes or poor federal coordination with states.

About half of the facilities that are in the federal database were in six states: Texas, Alabama, Georgia, Kentucky, Missouri and Tennessee. They include chemical plants or any location that stores ammonium nitrate, a widely used fertilizer, such as farm supply retailers or fertilizer distribution warehouses.

Within blast zones

The government audit tracked a monthlong reporting effort last year by the AP that drew upon public records in 28 states. The AP investigation found that schools, nursing homes and hospitals were within the potentially devastating blast zones of more than 120 facilities storing ammonium nitrate. In addition, the investigation concluded that the existence of other facilities nationwide remained a mystery due to poor information sharing.

The GAO faulted the Occupational Safety and Health Administration and the Environmental Protection Agency for decades-old chemical safety regulations that have failed in large part to cover ammonium nitrate.

Facilities that store ammonium nitrate, including the one that blew up in West, are rarely inspected by OSHA, in part because the agency relies on EPA regulations that do not list ammonium nitrate as a hazardous material. OSHA had put in place some requirements for storing the fertilizer back in the 1970s, but prior to the West explosion the agency did not widely publicize them to the fertilizer industry. GAO found the industry often viewed the rules as applying only if the material were used to make explosives.

The audit said the agency may be unwisely granting exemptions to retailers that store and blend fertilizer for direct sale.

As a result, prior to last year’s explosion, OSHA had cited just one facility for violations of its ammonium nitrate storage requirements in its more than 40-year history, the report said. That was in 1997 in Florida, following an employee complaint.

The findings come as a federal working group established by Obama prepares to submit its report later this month that outlines ways to improve oversight.

What’s next

The EPA, OSHA and the Homeland Security Department generally agreed with the findings. They emphasized that states are not required to report their data to federal agencies and that new efforts to improve coordination will be spelled out in the coming task force report. OSHA officials also said they were re-evaluating ways to target high-risk facilities for inspection, even with limited resources.

“We believe that we have already made significant improvements to reduce the likelihood of ammonium nitrate incidents,” wrote David Michaels, an assistant Labor Department secretary for occupational safety and health.

The GAO report noted that U.S. safety standards typically fell short compared with those in Canada, France, Germany and Britain, which in many cases bar the use of wood or other combustible material in ammonium storage facilities. GAO also urged Congress to eliminate an annual budget provision that exempts from safety inspections facilities with 10 or fewer employees, which make up about 4 percent of the 1,345 locations.

A group of Democratic lawmakers on Tuesday called the U.S. safety lapses “unacceptable” and in a letter urged Obama to take action to address GAO’s findings.

Hope Yen,

The Associated Press

Update: West ISD lawsuit

The West school district is suing its insurer, saying the two sides are $23 million apart on the costs of building a new high school and middle school to replace campuses affected by last year’s devastating plant explosion.

West ISD’s lawsuit, which the Waco Tribune-Herald reports was filed Tuesday in Waco district court, names the Texas Association of Public Educators and two insurance companies. Superintendent Marty Crawford said the district claimed $53 million in losses, but the insurers are only offering $30 million.

To post a comment, log into your chosen social network and then add your comment below. Your comments are subject to our Terms of Service and the privacy policy and terms of service of your social network. If you do not want to comment with a social network, please consider writing a letter to the editor.