Mary Alice's Laughing Jack: Bakery manager Mary Alice Yeskey grabbed a box of toothpicks (always on hand in bakeries, for testing a cake's doneness) and snapped dozens of them in half to make jagged teeth.

Anna's Bat Girl: Anna Ellison, the bakery's artistic director, gave her pumpkin a bat-shaped mouth. She chose the flat back side of the pumpkin for the face and used an orange marker to hide the sketch lines.