Peyton Manning is simply the greatest QB ever to play in the NFL at this point in time. If the guy had a couple more SB wins, this would be indisputable. If he gets 3 to 5 more years out of his career, and maybe another SB win or two, there can be no argument. And for you, Samola, Brees is pretty good also. Just not in the same league as Peyton.

UPDATE: After yesterday's NFL contests, the sportswriters and assembled experts have revised their earlier rankings.

It has now been universally agreed upon that Michael Vick is both the greatest humanitarian and quarterback of all time. Peyton Manning, by contrast, is now ranked just below Bobby Hebert and one slot above Jon Fourcade.

peyton manning is simply the greatest qb ever to play in the nfl at this point in time. If the guy had a couple more sb wins, this would be indisputable. If he gets 3 to 5 more years out of his career, and maybe another sb win or two, there can be no argument. And for you, samola, brees is pretty good also. Just not in the same league as peyton.

Speaking of LOL, I really don't see how Charlie Joiner and Steve Largent get left off a list like this. And the same could be said for Art Monk.

As for Peyton Manning, I can certainly see the statistical argument for his inclusion in the Top 10 ... although I imagine Tom Brady would like the opportunity to be heard on the issue of Manning being placed on a higher pedestal in this list. Further, Terry Bradshaw might take exception to being behind Brett "Penis Pics" Favre and a couple other people listed above him, who played the same position.

Charlie Joiner and Steve Largent get left off a list like this. And the same could be said for Art Monk.

Good points on all three. They all had very strong numbers, except that Joiner and Largent never made it to the Super Bowl.

Quote:

Originally Posted by DerailAmnesty.com

As for Peyton Manning, I can certainly see the statistical argument for his inclusion in the Top 10 ... although I imagine Tom Brady would like the opportunity to be heard on the issue of Manning being placed on a higher pedestal in this list.

To me, Brady has done more with less, and should get a nod over Manning.

Quote:

Originally Posted by DerailAmnesty.com

Further, Terry Bradshaw might take exception to being behind Brett "Penis Pics" Favre and a couple other people listed above him, who played the same position.

They all had very strong numbers, except that Joiner and Largent never made it to the Super Bowl.

Joiner played for 17 (count them!) seasons as a wide receiver in the NFL. Further, he had some very clutch and meaningful play in the postseason. As for Largent, at the time he retired, and for some time thereafter, he was the all-time NFL receptions leader.