What would you do if you were in Barbossa's place?

We all know the story. Barbossa mortally wounded Blackbeard, took his sword, his crew, and his ship. And the first thing he does as the new captain of the Queen Anne's Revenge is ordering the crew to sail for Tortuga. But what would you do if you were in his place? I known what would I do. I would go back to the Santiago to take the treasure of Juan Ponce de León.