I'm not a former TreasureHunters LS member and there are many others in the LS that don't like you, so stop trying to defend yourself. They don't post because they feel like they don't have to. Others have already posted that you are questionable so leave it at that.

I'm not in Treasure Hunter either. Besides I never got an apoligy and nobody else on my team at the time did either. You were no where to be found after you bound the pug. you disappeared over the horizon. There were pugs all up and down the beach, we were the only party on whitesands and you just happened to bind a pug in the middle of our small party. nah. I believe you knew what you were doing. Your not a noob.

lol kouarama you are in treasure hunters, and i would like to see these many others you speak of, cuase all i have seen post about me are you, chotaru that ehandlr guy and dagg, whom i only partied with once around level 50 or so, and i have no idea what his problem is. and ehandlir that is not true i did finish of the pug after it aggroed one of your members. so until you can find liable reasons to keep me on that list besides your own personal problems, then take me off.

funny. i had to zone into selbina to keep the pug off of me after it came un-bound. and it attacked 4 of the 6 party memebers not one like you say. again....no apology was offered to anyone like you said. seems to me, the more you press the issue of getting of this list, the more people come out and have something against you. In fact...not 1 person has taken up for you.

Why are you talking shiet Rumplestiltskin? you're the sorry taru nin that cant keep hate. first off i've seen some good taru tanker and RUMP aint one of them.

Beside Rumplestiltskin you pretty much couldnt hold hate when you were in my pt. the fighters in the pt wanted to replace you but because there was no other tankers at the time so we had to settle for you.

Are you still mad at that one time when i ripped you a new one in front of everyone about how much you suck as a tanker? tis tis tis

oh ya watch out for Rumplestiltskin when he is your ninja tanker, if any problem arises he will commit suicide and let you defend for yourself. he did that to my pt and left us to fight at boyadha tree, and the crawler still had 1/2 blood.

Say Cybralisk, why do you care? Reputations are nothing :P Lots of people in this thread seem to think they are, but no matter what you do, your real friends will still be your real friends. It's why I don't care that I'm on the list :P I blew up once and tried to give criticism once and that makes me an evil enough person to be on the Questionable list. Yay for me! It's more joke material between me and my friends :P I'm not taking any sides, I'm just curious why it bothers you so much that you're on the questionable list. Please fill me in.

White Gate has become a second Jeuno over night. White Gate had like 700ish people in it at all times during the first couple of days of ToAU's release. SE even sent system messages telling us to disperse or we will be removed by force lol.

but the fact is some people play the game poorly, and no amount of patronizing from you is going to change that.

Playing the game 'poorly' will hold a different deffinition to each person. Just another reason you should keep your opinion on a more private level. You play the job, you gradually get better. Notice how some posts have been defending Tigereye? Maybe he has improved? You don't know that and now neither will half the server cause people decided to post stories about what happened in your pt with him 3 months ago. I don't exactly see a movement on anyones part here to follow up with those players who got listed? How can someone get off the list?

Quote:

you shouldn't feel so empowered as to say that we are all just "stroking our egos."

It's kind of ironic in a sense that someone trys to tell me that I shouldn't feel "empowered" in a thread about flaming and evaluating. That aside, let's stleast refresh the topic on what I actually said:

"Alot of this sounds more like you're stroking your own ego by berating other players then actually showing concern for other people's party."

Now that we have your misquotes cleared up, I'll continue. Don't get me wrong, I think this thread can be a great idea; if you report people who borrow items and don't return them, purchased an account and can prove it beyond a reason of a doubt, train mobs to zone with the sole purpose of killing as many people as possible, anything that disruptive in that sense.

As for things along the lines of receiving /tells, asking to join LS', poor partying; those should be left private. You can prevent these things with /blacklist or /ptcmd kick, where as you can't prevent the things I listed previously.

Bottom LineIt's bad enough you're listing people for 'poor party playing,' but people are getting listed with one request. All someone has to do is post the name, throw in a story, and they get added to Questionables.

To make matters even worse; in some cases, you don't even have to give a reason. Maybe I'm the only one who realized this, but "Exdeath"/"Exdeth" is on the list... and there wasn't even a reason anywhere on this thread? Not even from the person who put him there. But now you all know the name and that he's questionable. So without thinking twice, you'll treat him the same way you do to all the rest; and you don't even know why...

I would like to add "Istubedmytoe"(elvan thief/ninja) to the notable list. Last night (before titan died) he had his **** together. him and the tank , sorry forgot the name started with "Sig" and was a paladin, kept hate perfectly. i remember the white mage saying something like "there's not much for me to do" because she only had to cast cure II once or twice every few battles. Damage output and skillchaining was incredible between our party thanks to Istubedmytoe. we chained to #5 about a dozen times in a row.

someone to lookout for is Crendol. I swear he was goblins to zone intentionally. I mean every 5 minutes : Crendol: GOBBIE TO ZONE! ^^

Malboja, you're not high enough lv to be bothered by these people so it doesnt really affect you. Exdeath kills many people in Boyahda tree by charming mobs and dropping them in pts. Everyone on the list has done something to RUIN the gameplay for other people, im not telling anyone to hate these people, its their own decision to hate people, this list is just making people aware of the people that might ruin their time playing. Blacknova asked for help from our ls many times and didnt think about other people, and when someone helped him he never said thanks. Everyone has their own reasons to hate tigereye, he tried to take my papyrus that i paid Illustrious for. One day when Exdeath kills you in Boyahda Tree then you'll know why people hate him.

You don't need a reason to add exdeth to this list. Hes one of the most notorious BSTs on the server. Ask ANYONE whose done an XP party in Boyhada tree and you will get at least 2 stories of MPKing.

I've had people ask me about random monster adds and without even looking my reply was Exdeth? After a confused few seconds, he confirmed it was him. He'll drop mobs on anyone. Now since hes 75, he'll bring down Korrigans from the 65+ leveling area and drop them on teh 53-56s.

Bottom Line It's bad enough you're listing people for 'poor party playing,' but people are getting listed with one request. All someone has to do is post the name, throw in a story, and they get added to Questionables.

Unless you're me and you corroborate the story because it's funny and you know it sounds a lot worse than it really is :P

As for your reasoning here, hmm... I can see an upside to it, as well as a fault. I think the questionable list should be people who repeatedly show cause to be on the list. Not people who do something they can't help, or have one thing against them that multiple people say and that's counted as more proof, like that Cybralisk guy.

I guess what my bottom line is if someone's looking for a blm in a party around my level, they could care less if I killed mandies in yuhtunga once and ****** off a random thief. They need a capable blm, and I happen to be just that. The people who they'll watch out are notorious enough that they don't even -need- to be posted on a thread like this. Like tigereye and exdeath, anyone who's been in the appropriate area/level range long enough knows everything they need to know about these people.

PS-If I don't make any sense right now, I'm tired. I just had to go upstate to buy a vehicle. It was a whole day or thereabouts ; ;

I partied with Elgor in Yhoator Jungle with my WAR at around lvl 27-29. The pt was good but he is such an @$$. I was pulling just fine but he insisted that if i didn't disengage and pull before we defeated the mob that we would not get a chain. Well needless to say i told him that xp chains have more to do with how fast you kill them and not how you pull. But he kept ordering me around and i told him he didn't know what he was talking about. He ended up kicking me in the middle of a battle, angering most of the other pt members. He tried to invite me back after trying to tell me that i didn't know what i was talking about but decided to /blist him and not join his pt. If you see this guy try to educate him on pulling i tried but he said me being lvl 53 THF and pulling in 90% of my parties didn't matter because i didn't know what i was talking about.

WOW!, I am crazed over how many replys are on this post, okay, here I go. First, I would like to say my opinion about Gooding is a good one, he was a great BLM in my party, and one of the funniest people I have ever partied with, if I was ever in a party with him, no doubt it was a good one, Also, sure, he may get on your case about armor/whatever, but is that so wrong that he is going out of his way to express his opinion? I think thats great, every party im ever in hes either helping people on what they should do, Setting up skillchains and magic bursts (Good ones at that) Or making the party come alive. Furthermore, in my BD tree party a high level bst creeped up on us with a korrigan charmed and the second the bst released, goodings escape went off, cheers to you gooding, you saved us! ;-) SoOoOoO NOTABLE!Petrov Gooding Renning Hajime Mange Killerme QUESTIONABLE!Tigereye (heck not even questionable) RUN AWAY!

Quote:

Tigereye occasionally gets a pearl to my LS and shows up to swear and berate LS members. We have fun breaking his pearl before he dips back out.

Quote:

Tigereye <---he has his totally rare decent kinda moments

Quote:

Hellllllllllllllllllllooooooooooooooooooo TITAN peeps that love to slap Tigereye =) ... its 5:15 and i'm in jeuno right now .. Saw like 7 different people spam Slaps at Tigereye .. so i was like wut the **** might as well join too ..... then i asked Javelin and Sqvall why they was slapping Tigereye .. Sqvall asnwered HE is EVIL!!!! .. i was like oh .. and went on slapping ...

Conclusion; Tigereye is hated/disliked (I just dislike him with a passion, a big deep dark passion) person of a lot of Titan who has ::coughs:: some rare good moments ;-), he is so disliked he famous in a way, its kind of pathetic, it has even stretched to a point where a Tigereye in another server is hated just because they think its Tigereye on Titan...poor dude. Also, Tigereye has gotten many of my friends partys murdered, especcially papyrus paper partys a while back, and constantly begs people, including a highlevel friend of mine for help, which is probly why he managed to get his hands on his AF somehow. Furthermore, I have been informed from many people he has been kicked from Lionhearted, RCS, GMS, Ravens of shadowmoon, Titan light warriors, and a few others I have forgotten. Not to mention he has probly 3ish million gil, because I saw him the other day in emp pin, leaping boots, heaubergon, double snipers rings, and when he was on his theif he had strider boots, I do not suppose that gil just popped out of nowhere ::coughs:: GILBUYER!. Sorry to all you that may like him, but all I can do is pity him and spread the word of my pity-ness, I apoligize, and for you who think hes just a little kid and we should just let everything go and be nice to him, If hes really a little kid, then he shouldnt care, and it already seems he doesnt. /em busts out his superglue and sticks Tigereyes name on everybody's questionable lists. Once again, sorry if I came off a little to strong, Peace -Sqvall

Woot! Finally have someone on my side! XD /cheer Sqvall! It's been too long since we've partied man. Either we're not on when the other is, or something. I know I'm not on quite as much as I used to be, and when I'm on, I'm falling asleep in parties because I'm trying to stay caught up to Briley :P And I thank the people that put up with me >_< IE Rileydbz (very knowledgeable pld btw), hypnotik (my partner in crime XD), tarcon (oh god this guy should hate me with a passion by now, but he doesn't for some reason x.x), and others that I can't think of right now, but you know who you are. And of course the party from 2 nights ago where we had all sorts of fun with warp 2 and /nin's! The people who know what happened are probably still laughing XD I know I chuckle when I think about it. Anyways, this post was meant less to make sense and more to be a shout to the people that put up with me on a daily basis :P I'll check back later!

I certainly wouldn't put Petrov on the notable list. Last night I was in Pashhow Marshlands when Bloodpool Vorax spawned, and when I claimed the mob (I'm 21 bst) I lost claim when I switched pets. Petrov was there watching me all the time and stood ready to take the claim. Fortunately my pet hit Vorax faster than Petrov could. I know this is just "part of the game" (losing NM claim) but I still find it rude.

First off I was not waiting to steal him from you. I was there farming beastman blood and trust me a 10k drop is not worth being rude over. I know that I hate it when someone steals a claim from me so that is why I don't camp NM's. I was standing there due to the fact that I was interested in whether you got the drop. When I asked you and I got no response I thought you were rather rude. I'll chalk it up to miscommunication and move on.

Where's the love for me!?! :P I don't know Blacknova personally, but he helped me for 4 and a half hours with Genkai 1 and nearly died a few times because of other morons in the area so I feel somewhat obligied to throw that into the pile. I like Treasure Hunter people too. I have partied with plenty of them and never really had a bad experience.

Notable Xenmind - He is teh uber. Deathspawn, Fng, Testo, Kandy - Four of the Titan Light Warriors who I partied with recently and had a blast. Deathspawn also got me into my first BCNM back in the day and I had a lot of fun doing that as well. Mantaka - I accidentally overbid on something by 200k on the AH and he was nice enough to give me a refund for the difference. I'm sure there are a ton of people I'm forgetting too, but my brain is mush

First off I was not waiting to steal him from you. I was there farming beastman blood and trust me a 10k drop is not worth being rude over. I know that I hate it when someone steals a claim from me so that is why I don't camp NM's. I was standing there due to the fact that I was interested in whether you got the drop. When I asked you and I got no response I thought you were rather rude. I'll chalk it up to miscommunication and move on.

I'm glad we cleared it up. I have the worst luck getting them to drop and that is why I only hunt NM's if my fellow LS members are there. Then we can at least have fun while trying to get the claim. Good luck next time getting the selfish leech to give up his loot ^^

. And of course the party from 2 nights ago where we had all sorts of fun with warp 2 and /nin's! The people who know what happened are probably still laughing XD I know I chuckle when I think about it.

Might this be the party I was in?

I was having connection issues and got DCed. I come back and find our 58blm/27nin friend gone and Gooding in his place. I was like wtf!?!?

Turns out the party leader invited Gooding when I disappeared, then he warp2ed the blm/nin and then I came back and we continued about our way.

Still I told my friends and linkshell and they laughed so hard at this story >_<

Furthermore, I have been informed from many people he has been kicked from Lionhearted, RCS, GMS, Ravens of shadowmoon, Titan light warriors, and a few others I have forgotten

He was never in GMS, at least not that I know of. Our linkshell has a policy where 3 officers have to approve to join the shell. I'm pretty sure that even if I approved him, it would be unlikely I could get approval from two other officers, due to his reputation alone.

I don't necessarily think Tigereye is a bad guy really, I have had some conversations with him and he seems like a nice kid. It's just from what I heard he is not the greatest player. Now keep in mind I have never actually partied/quested with him, it's just what I hear from others.

Yes, that was the party XD I was laughing so hard just thinking about it before I did it, I actually had to open the magic menu and choose warp II, I couldn't actually TYPE /ma "Warp II" <t>! After which, I had a thorough discussion with the afforementioned BLM/NIN with an underleveled sub about why BLM/NIN didn't work. Anywho, he refused to listen, so I told him to come to the BLM forums here on Allakhazam. I told him there were probably a throng of people more than willing to argue this with him. Anywho, I better stop thinking about this, I'm at work and people are beginning to wonder why I'm chuckling :P

still havent the good luck of finding ppl like some snake i met on jeuno that charged me with 20k for papirus then dissapeared on eld. necropolis while we were fighting. letting me to die w/o papirus......ring a bell?

hmmmmm so many ppl i like on this server. Rottenmonk, he always sticks up for me Oberin rocks eventho he killed my pet jellysifh Morrisey, hes a know it all but is still a cool guy none the less. Chotaru i was one of the guys he came to raise. Curzor great blm who has his stuff togeather. marten always makes me laugh, blister helped me for a total of about 10 hours trying to get my **** garlage key Loukey too and my 3 best mercs Odessa Euriko and Bladewarrior.

as for the lame ones. well im not one for talking smack behind ones back. ill settle it with fists not words in a game :p

Well you are entitled to your own opinion, but what I don't understand is that if you think this thread is terrible, why post/read it? Its one of the few things I can't understand about people. If you don't like something don't involve yourself in it. Thats like me complaining there's too much rap (just an example) on the radio but listen to the station that plays rap all the time. So, please if you can explain to me the logic that went through your head when you bashed this thread I can understand your reasoning a whole lot better.

As it seemed to be originally intended, as a warning of people who intentionally seek harm on others, it seems like a worthy thread to read. But that isn't the reason I read. I read the threads which seem either interesting to me or popular.

'What has got so many people posting?' Well, what i found basically amounts to a witch hunt of gil sellers and people bitter about bad party experiences. Exdeth is a valid 'watch out for this guy' because he will kill your party if you aren't paying attention. This is what the thread should be.

Your comparison isn't exactly analagous. Its more like flipping on talk radio listening for a little while and saying 'Wow, this guy's views are off-kilter.'

And i don't view these forums often. Every once in a while I read them. I remember reading this thread maybe a month ago. This isn't limited to the allakhazam forums either. I read KI (much more often) and there is pretty much the same thing going on there. There are lots of people named here that I have issues with but publicly decrying them is a whole other beast than having personal issues with them. I just don't think people have the right to judge other players in this manner.

I think this thread should be about what the topic creator intended it to be. Also although you do have a point, this topic has helped some people confront each other on what issues they were having with one another, however, I still don't understand after you read the posts in this thread why you would even post anything if you felt that way you do. It just seems like adding to the gossip, and calling the topic horrible insinuates something about the people who posted in this thread. So, in essence, it seems that you are doing exactly what you dislike about this thread.

i posted something because i felt like it. i don't like people's reputations being sullied for basically petty reasons. Everyone who reads this should consider who is saying what and weigh some evidence before you make some judgement call. Tigereye is an example of someone who everyone hates but probably less than half have a reason to. Decide these things for yourself.

Ok i got someone to add to this never pt with Luckie he he a ???? noob. We are in jueno and everyone is geting alot of lag and we all say to him that someone will probably dc so wait for 5 min after till you get someone else. Guess who dcd.... Well i get back on mabey 2 min and i send a tell and he say he thought i quit. I talk to everyone else and they said the\at he waited 5 sec before geting anyone. They all told him to wait but he didnt! i really hate people like that, and being a drg i had bine waiting for 3 and ahalf hour for a pt. I have never bine so ******* Everyone was screeming at himn for it too. I have also heard that he sucks as a whm.

So if you ever see Luckie dont pt with him please he doent deserve to get any further.

Taubaud shut up, Luckie isnt a noob, hes a lv70 rdm. If anything you're the noob, so nobody pt with Taubaud he's a noob and doesnt deserve to get any further. Learn to spell too. Learn this too, Drg is pretty much a last resort option in pties, be glad he even invited you at all beacuase I bet he didnt even want you in the pt.

Why are you getting all angry because he posted about his bad experience in the thread that you created? Isn't that the purpose of the thread? Maybe you have something personal against him, so I'm not really going to comment on that. It just seems kind of hypocritical that you make a thread to badmouth people on, yet get on somebody's case when they do what the thread asked for.

Also, I find the comment about drgs being last picks to be kind of amusing. Drgs are quite ideal depending on party makeup and where you are fighting. Most people just don't know how to fully utilize them in a party makeup.

I have no idea what you are talking about because Luckie is one of the best people I know. He helps me whenever he can and is great at the jobs he plays. I'm sorry you've been waiting for such a long time for a pt but you've never pt'd with him before so you really wouldn't know how good or bad he would be.

Are you talking about Luckyone? I know him, he's a nice guy, and he tries to help when he can... ^^ I don't know any Luckie though. ^^

BTW, just want to throw a few honorables out there, Mugmug for one, he's been with me while I've been trying to get my davoi coffer key and gone through some pretty bad stuff otherwise and has always tried to help me. Major major kudos points to him, he helps lots of other people too. Daubaut as well, a great guy that knows what's goin on lol. Pawlouski or however his name is spelled, the lvl 70 drg lol, GOOD LUCK ON MAAT! And of course Briley, without whom none of this would have been possible. Also thanks to the ChaoticRemix LS who's helped me on and off lots over this last week, including friends steppers and kawaiikun ^^

Noone to add to questionable right now :) That's a good thing I suppose.

Ok i guess he was just haveing a bad day maybe and i was that day too sorry if i offended anyone and trust me i am not a noob! I only get positive remarks from people. Sorry if i ****** everyone off maybe it was just a bad day.

Oh and drg is not a bad job! anyone that says that doesn't know wtf they are saying. Drg is good as long as you know what you are doing. I always out damage the mnk's and drk's in my pts.

Dude i feel your pain i am a lvl 56 rdm that didnt have any AF done like you i shout in jeuno and ask some higher lvls and didnt get any help. Since i hit 56 i have compleated AF1 and AF2 because a group of ppl that i use to pt with. Just be patiante and just send tells to some of the higher lvls youll be surprise how much help you can get like than than shouting endlessly in jeuno as long as you are polite you shouldnt have any problems.

About Vajra i dont know the deal but he is a good guy not every day you ask a high lvl to help you with Key in eldieme and they accept since they can die fighting the **** mobs there. Well i ask vajra for help to get my key not only he help me but he brought 2 other lvl 60 to help me didnt get key and both lvl 60 dark die but after they got raise they didnt bail on us they went back at it, until they had to go because it was getting late.

What we didnt train anything we had one link and and no one died no one even got into red. I have no idea who trained those. I did see it though when me and my pt were on aware way out to go to garlaige Citadel.