You are here

Why do media value Israeli children’s lives more than those of Palestinian kids?

A young Palestinian man named Abd al-Rahman al-Shaludi rammed his car into pedestrians exiting the Ammunition Hill light rail station in northern Jerusalem on Wednesday, killing three-month-old Haya Zissel Brown and injuring at least seven others.

Israeli officials instantly labeled the crash a terrorist attack, which US media outlets have parroted without question even though the intent of the driver remains unclear. Given that Israeli police shot and killed al-Shaludi immediately after he exited the vehicle, whether the crash was deliberate may never be certain.

His family insists it was an accident, telling reporters that al-Shaludi, 21 years old, suffered from mental illness as a result of being tortured in Israeli prison.

“We believe that he was shot and killed in cold blood and there was no attempt to question him, and hear his side of the story,” his cousin, Abed al-Shaludi, told the Israeli newspaper Haaretz.

Al-Shaludi had been jailed by Israel three times since September 2012 for allegedly hurling stones and molotov cocktails at Israeli settlers and their property in Silwan, his neighborhood in Israeli-occupied East Jerusalem. The Israeli press is using this to cast al-Shaludi as a career criminal with a history of “anti-Jewish” violence.

According to his mother, al-Shaludi’s mental health began to deteriorate after a three-week-long interrogation at the hands of the Shin Bet (Israel’s secret police) in the Jerusalem Russian Compound jail, a notorious site of abuse and torture of Palestinians.

This context has of course been missing or buried in most US media accounts, of which there are many. Israel and Palestine-related news is currently saturated with headlines about a Palestinian man killing an Israeli baby.

Meanwhile, these same outlets have either whitewashed or completely ignored the ongoing abuse and killings of Palestinian children by the Israeli military and settlers.

Gaza children still dying

The same day that al-Shaludi killed an Israeli infant with his car, an unexploded Israeli bomb took the life of four-year-old Muhammad Sami Abu Jrad in Beit Hanoun, a city in northern Gaza that was decimated by Israel’s merciless summertime bombing campaign, which killed nearly 2,200 Palestinians, most of them civilians, including more than 500 children.

According to the Ma’an News Agency, Jrad is the tenth person killed by unexploded Israeli munitions, most of which have yet to be cleared because the Israeli-imposed, Egypt-enforced blockade hampers access to the robotic and protective equipment needed to neutralize the leftover ordnance.

Unlike the tragic death of three-month-old Haya Zissel Brown, Muhammad Jrad’s killing elicited only silence from the American press corps, as did that of another Palestinian child run over by an Israeli settler earlier this week.

Children run down

On Sunday, a man reportedly from the Jewish-only settlement of Yitzhar ran over Palestinian schoolchildren as they made their way towards their mothers after exiting a school bus in the West Bank town of Sinjil.

Five-year-old Inas Khalil died of her wounds shortly thereafter and another girl, also hit, was left in critical condition.

Instead of stopping to check on the children or calling for help, the man kept driving until he reached a nearby Jewish settlement, at which point he says he called the police.

Raed al-Jabari, a 35-year-old Palestinian father and husband, was not so lucky when he hit Israeli settlers with his car in the Gush Etzion settlement bloc in late July. Al-Jabari insisted it was an accident and turned himself in to the police, reported Ma’an News Agency. But unlike the settler who killed Inas Khalil, al-Jabari was jailed for two months and ultimately died under suspicious circumstances.

Israeli authorities claim al-Jabari hanged himself in the bathroom at Israel’s Eshel prison, but the autopsy suggests the man was tortured to death, according to Palestinian officials. Either way, the disparity in treatment of the settler who killed Khalil versus that of al-Jabari is the essence of Israel’s apartheid regime that affords different, unequal rights to those under its rule.

Palestinian Ambassador to the United Nations Riyad Mansour responded to the latest settler hit-and-run by filing a complaint with the UN Security Council, accusing “extremist terrorist settlers” of launching intentional hit-and-run attacks against Palestinians in recent months.

Indeed, settlers slamming their vehicles into Palestinians in the occupied West Bank is a commonoccurrence that is routinely overlooked by the Israeli authorities as well as western media outlets.

Relatives mourn over the body of Inas Khalil during her funeral in the West Bank village of Sinjil on 20 October.

As far as this writer can tell, none of the perpetrators have been labeled “terrorists” nor have any been held accountable. But such is the nature of apartheid.

Meanwhile, Khalil’s killing received a mention of two sentences in The New York Times, buried near the end of an article about Wednesday’s Jerusalem incident.

The Associated Press, one of the only US media outlets to cover Khalil’s death, devoted just five sentences to the hit-and-run, framing it as nothing more than an unproven accusation by Palestinians against an unnamed Israeli settler.

“The Palestinians are accusing an Israeli settler of running over two schoolgirls, killing one of them, and speeding away,” reads the article’s opening line.

In stark contrast, here is the opening sentence to the Associated Press article on the Jerusalem car crash: “A Palestinian motorist with a history of anti-Israel violence slammed his car into a crowded train station in Jerusalem on Wednesday, killing a three-month-old baby girl and wounding eight people in what police called a terror attack.”

Boy shot dead

On Thursday, 16 October, Israeli soldiers shot Bahaa Samir Badir, 13, in the chest at close range in Beit Laqiya, a village northwest of Ramallah in the occupied West Bank. He was pronounced dead shortly thereafter at the Palestine Medical Complex in Ramallah.

The Israeli army excused the killing, saying its soldiers were simply responding to firebombs directed at their jeeps as they were leaving the village. Live fire, an Israeli army spokesperson said, was an appropriate response to stones and Molotov cocktails, a troubling narrative that went largely unchallenged in the US media outlets which bothered to report on Badir’s death.

The US press showed even less interest in the video that surfaced this week that shows Israeli soldiers blindfolding, handcuffing and abusing an eleven-year-old developmentally disabled Palestinian boy in the occupied West Bank city of Hebron as a crowd of settlers and their children laughed, cheered and shouted racist slurs.

The abuse and wanton killing of Palestinian children by the Israeli war machine is not an exception, but rather a norm that US media outlets are complicit in enabling through omission or obfuscation, and, like Israel, they are guilty of valuing some children’s lives more than others.

Comments

Settlers are responsible for running over dozens of Palestinians each year, killing a good number, injuring even more. No reports of this in the NY Times. See "When Death Makes the Headlines (and When it Doesn't") at www.TimesWarp.orghttp://wp.me/p3zcQt-bE

This is an important piece. Like Ms Khalek, each day since the so-called ceasefire I'm struck by the mainstream media's failure to cover ongoing violence against Palestinians. In fact, I began blogging about this on www.twowords.ca about six weeks ago (What the media don't call news), and so far over eight blogs (plus one in my drafts folder!) I've documented literally dozens of such incidents (including many I learned about on Electronic Intifada). I intend to continue so there is a record for anyone who actually wants to know.

Why aren't Israeli settlers who run down Palestinians with their cars described as being engaged in a pattern of war crimes and violations of humanitarian law? They've earned this status through their very presence on Palestinian land- yet it's the native people whom the media tag with epithets and smears, never failing to cite previous arrests under brutal occupation rule. When will US news reports contain the obligatory reminder that the settlers were carrying out crimes at the time of these "unfortunate accidents", that their colonies are illegal and that their daily activities flout international law and the dictates of conscience?

Great article. I would still say the reason that Israeli lives are valued more than Palestinian lives (bodies) is racism. Put shortly, white supremacy. Israel is a white country, Palestinians are not white, they are part of the global south of those colonised and oppressed by racists, this means their deaths are simply bodies that do not matter.

Let's not forget that it is not only media bias that values children's lives differently, but appallingly, the US Administration as well, as evidenced but the number and of timing of condemnation, issued by either/both the State Department or White House upon such deaths.

Living far from the middle east, the data is taken in the context of our lives. Whatever the media portrays, we in the west feel nothing but horror and sadness for the lost lives of the children, no matter the religious or political affiliations of the parents. There is terrible media bias in all sorts of issues. Intelligent people do a little extra research and effort to learn the truth and get the full context. Believe me, if there was an 'easy button' to end the cycle hatred, most of us in the west would have pressed it a long time ago. At some point, a person needs to look around and make a decision. It is difficult to change core beliefs, but if you love your children and want them to grow up in a positive, productive society, you do what is hard.

It's disappointing that even events that should have helped change the general perception of Israel/Palestine events have been successfully downplayed in the mainstream media. Tariq Abukhdeir's story should have become Palestine's equivalent of the Rodney King beating, but his ordeal and the horrific murder of his cousin failed to have the impact they should have had in the US, despite his family's courage and intelligence in dealing with the media. And I've got to admit that even pro-Palestinian outlets were disappointing in their coverage of the three settler teens' murder earlier this year; by focusing on whether the teens were actually killed by Palestinians, media sites helped the Israeli spin machine gloss over the illegality of the settlers being there to begin with.