Enlarge ImageRequest to buy this photoJohn Minchillo | Associated PressOn June 1, protesters of the Boycott, Divestment and Sanctions movement against Israel’s treatment of Palestinians stood behind a barricade during the Celebrate Israel Parade in New York.

NEW YORK — Once a unifying cause for generations of American Jews, Israel is now bitterly
dividing Jewish communities.

Jewish organizations are withdrawing invitations to Jewish speakers or performers considered too
critical of Israel, in what opponents have denounced as an ideological litmus test meant to squelch
debate.

Some Jewish activists have formed watchdog groups, such as Citizens Opposed to Propaganda
Masquerading as Art, or COPMA, and JCC Watch, to monitor programming for perceived anti-Israel
bias. They argue Jewish groups that take donations for strengthening the community shouldn’t be
giving a platform to Israel’s critics.

American campuses have become ideological battle zones over Israeli policy in the Palestinian
territories, with national Jewish groups sometimes caught up on opposing sides of the internal
debate among Jewish students.

The “Open Hillel” movement of Jewish students is challenging speaker guidelines developed by
Hillel, the major Jewish campus group, which bars speakers who “delegitimize” or “demonize” Israel.
Open Hillel is planning its first national conference in October.

And in a vote testing the parameters of Jewish debate over Israel, the Conference of Presidents
of Major Jewish Organizations, a national coalition that for decades has represented the American
Jewish community, denied membership in April to J Street, the 6-year-old lobby group that describes
itself as pro-Israel and pro-peace but that has sometimes criticized the Israeli government.

Opponents of J Street have been showing a documentary called
The J Street Challenge in synagogues and at Jewish gatherings across the country,
characterizing the group as a threat from within.

“I believe this has reached a level of absurdity now,” said Rabbi Sharon Brous, founder of the
IKAR-LA Jewish community in California, which is considered a national model for reinvigorating
religious life.

“Even where people are acting from a place of love and deep commitment that Israel remains a
vital and vibrant state, they are considered outside the realm. It’s seen as incredibly threatening
and not aligned with the script the American Jewish community expects.”

In 2012, when Israel carried out an offensive in Gaza after an upsurge in rocket fire, Brous
wrote an email to IKAR members that was published in
The Jewish Journal of Greater Los Angeles. She supported Israel’s right to defend itself,
while also urging recognition of Palestinian suffering.

The result? She was overwhelmed with hate mail and inspired op-eds and letters in the
Journal from Jewish clergy members and others until a prominent rabbi called for an end to
the recriminations.