Next is Maxwell's brother Guy. Guy is playing volleyball with a girl, but it's gotten boring with a ball. Hand him a baby turtle to get the "Unconventional Volleyball" shard, as well as unlock Guy's Avatar.

The tv host at the right of the start point needs another contestant for the "Reality Television Challenge" Starite, so sign Maxwell up! Maxwell must compete against other contestants in a number of challenges, beginning with a fire. Light the logs with a flamethrower, and the wrestler will be eliminated. Next up is an armadillo Maxwell must decorate to be appealing, so place a top hat on him to see the nerd get booted off the island. It's down to Maxwell and the wizard in an object combination contest. Maxwell must combine a, er, pickle and wings. Write up a flying cucumber and Maxwell wins the contest!