Ok, Jules... you just said it.... "objective stats don't support your thesis, you've got some 'splainin' to do."

Stats make the QB better than other if they have superior stats? Isn't it more about W's and L's? A QB can have a perfect rating in a game and still the team loses because the D s*cks! There are just as many arguments made that stats are simply stats and what counts are rings. Look at Marino, great stats but the Dolphins of his era couldn't get over the SB winning hump. Marino's fault or the team? Manning, on the other hand, has had some of his worst perfomances in crunch time while Brady has had his best. Many point to that in comparisons of these two QBs. Remember, Brady did not lose SB42, the D and the most miraculous play in SB history created that loss. Either way, the cows can come home and there will always be the arguments about QB 1A and 1B!

Becasue Manning had a dome and better weapons! That's why, you inbred. Was Warren Moon better than Joe Montana too, you idiot? When Brady got his toys, be blasted Manning's 2004 season. CASE CLOSED. He has Manning in the postseason and regular season. Turn yourself into the nearest psych ward. Good lord.Posted by russgriswold

Blasted? Really?

Lets see - Brady eclipsed Manning's completion % by 1%. TD's by 1 (and he played the 16th game whereas Manning only plaid one series - going into the final game Manning had 49. Brady had 48). Manning's YPA was higher. His YPC was higher and his QB rating was higher?

There is no sensible reasoning when non-subjective bloggers cannot or attempt to fabricate stats and want to remain argumentatively combative. The need to be right is first and foremost. Some don't have a keen sense for the obvious. Their delusional belief that their insight trumps anyone else's is an indication of underlying issues. The prolonged need to explain a revolutionary thought whether you care or not. May have inherent hate or anger traits. Justifying solely to provoke. Hubris attitude and a feeling a superiority to verbal adversaries. I've alluded to the term before as oppositional defiance disorder. Can't win until they realize how annoying they are. Hit ignore.....

In Response to Re: UNBELIEVABLE COLTS THREAD!!!!! WOW : Brady had 2 brand new weapons he never played with before and broke the records. Manning had Harrison, Wayne, Stokely, etc for years.Posted by russgriswold