So I usually use raidbots and AMR combined with each other. I was simming a 915 Engine of Eradication v. a 935 Astral Alchemist Stone. Raidbots told me the alchemist stone was about an 8k upgrade. AMR, however, simmed it as a 60k dps loss. I thought this was weird, asked around, then noticed that AMR isn’t including the alchemist stone’s buff.

It looks like there should be an “infernal alchemist stone” buff with an upkeep of about 25-ish%. Without that buff it’s probably why there’s such a huge disparity. not sure this is something y’all are already looking into, but figured I should report it anyway just in case someone else is confused.

You don’t see the buff because the trinket hasn’t be implemented yet. Yellow (the developer) started downloading the data right before he went on vacation so he wasn’t able to finish all the 7.3 stuff.