Hotels are one of the oldest and most common forms of business enterprise in rural Saskatchewan. The fact that Saskatchewan’s tenacious old hotels still stand on the corners of Railway and Main is a testament to the determination of the people who have owned and operated them over the past 100 years - and to the fact that they haven't burned down!

Saturday, 17 August 2013

In 1907, Albert E. Playfair from Whitewood, Saskatchewan, and John Berglund built the three-storey
Windthorst Hotel. It opened in 1908. By 1911, William Williamson was
the hotel keeper. He lived in the hotel with his son Finlay, and his
daughters Iva and Elda. According to the 1911 Canada census, nine other
people lived at the hotel as well, including the bartender, the cook
and her three young daughters, two waitresses, a housekeeper, and a
chambermaid. Williamson sold the hotel to Tom Henry after Saskatchewan
introduced Prohibition in July 1915.

Windthorst Hotel, c. 1910. Source: Windthorst Memories, 1980.

The 1916 Canada Census shows that owner Thomas Henry, age 58, was living at the Windthorst Hotel along with his 13-year-old daughter, Vivian. There is no mention of his wife, although he is listed as married. Other residents include hotel employees: the Chinese cook Duck Lee, a 21-year-old Polish kitchen girl, a 20-year-old waitress from Russia, a 64-year-old porter, a stableman, a chauffeur, and a Danish engineer, age 33.

Tom Henry got into some trouble of a personal nature. Census records for 1916 show that 21-year-old Alice Ellen Playfair, daughter of Albert Playfair, the builder of the Windhorst Hotel, was working as the housekeeper at the hotel that year. Alice was living with two of her brothers in a private home in the village. Alice and Tom must have had an affair, because genealogical records show that Alice eventually became his second wife. Source Tom's first wife, Ellen or Nell (Robinson), is listed in the 1916 census as a residing, unemployed, in a separate residence from the hotel with her seven-year-old daughter, Ethel.

Tom Henry also got into some trouble with the law while operating the Windthorst Hotel. In the spring of 1919, he was convicted of perjury and sentenced to a year of hard labour in the Regina jail. This resulted from his appeal of his previous conviction for hiding liquor in with his stock of soft drinks at the hotel in Windthorst - a no-no during Prohibition. Source

In 1918, Jack Johnson and his wife Olga bought the Windthorst Hotel and ran it until 1945. According to the Windthorst history book, Jack had started
out building and driving race cars in the early 1900s in Iowa. He came to
Canada in 1903 and settled first in Findlater, and later in Riceton
where he operated a café. "Mr. and Mrs. Johnston made their hotel business an
asset to the community in many ways, opening their doors freely for public
functions and making the hotel a gathering place of the district. It was a
‘home away from home’ for the young people who were employed in the village," the town history records.
"Social functions which included weekly card parties, bridal showers, and
wedding receptions were held at the hotel." (Source: WIndthorst Memories; A History of WIndthorst and District, 1980)

The Johnstons, who had no children of their own, opened their hearts
to three children of the Lenius family, following the death of their mother in 1920. Annie, Frank and Joe Lenius were foster children of the Johnstons, who gave them a
happy home while they continued their schooling.

Jack Johnston had many
interests. "His main hobby was taxidermy and he mounted birds and animals with an artist’s touch," states the Windthorst history book.
"So much so that some of his specimens are in the Smithsonian Institute… and
some are in the Provincial Museum in Regina." Johnston served on the Windthorst Village Council for eighteen years. After he
retired from the hotel business in the mid-forties, he sold it to Joe
Lenius, He then opened a movie theatre in town called the Johnston Theatre which he operated from 1947 to 1954 when ill health
necessitated his retirement. Jack
Johnson died in 1957 at age 78. Source

Removing the third floor, 1966. Source: Windthorst history book

Jack's foster son, Joe Lenius and his wife Emmie ran the Windthorst Hotel from 1945 until 1950, when they sold it to Ron and Marg Morrison. The Morrisons renovated the hotel extensively between 1950 and 1976. The biggest change they made was to remove the third storey of the building in 1966. A lunch counter, and later a cafe, replaced the hotel's dining room.

The Windjacks became the owners of the Windthorst Hotel in 1979. Once again, renovations were undertaken, and a steak pit was added. A variety of entertainment was featured in the hotel bar.

Norm and Karen Jones bought the hotel in 1993 and changed its name to Norm's Place Hotel. The hotel was put up for sale by the Jones in 2009 - asking price: $235,000. The price went up to $350,000 in 2013. The real estate listing for the hotel in Windthorst stated that it had a 100-seat beverage room and steak pit; a commercial kitchen on the main floor; eight non-modern guest rooms; and an office and guest lounge on the second floor. The bar featured four VLTs, a lottery kiosk, and offered special promo nights -- wings, steaks, golf, poker, and pizza. The hotel had two full-time and six part-time employees.

Monday, 5 August 2013

In 1906, Robert and Annie Florence Bannatyne
sold their hotel in Oak Lake, Manitoba, and with their one-year-old son Herman,
headed for Saskatoon.They planned to
buy the Flanagan Hotel, but on the train they met Charles Volkes, a real estate
dealer who persuaded them that Quill Lake was the place with a future.They bought a boarding house and enlarged it
into the three-storey Leland Hotel. This was the beginning of the Bannatyne
hotel “dynasty” that lasted until the 1950s.

Robert Bannatyne was the son of a prominent Winnipeg
family.His mother was Metis woman Anne “Annie”
McDermot Bannatyne; his father was Andrew Graham Ballenden Bannatyne, a fur
trader, politician and “possibly the wealthiest, probably the most influential,
certainly the most highly esteemed man in the Red River community.” Born in 1867, Robert grew up in one of the best
homes in Winnipeg – a “noble mansion” on the banks of the Assiniboine River called
Ravenscourt.The two hotels Robert Bannatyne built in
Quill Lake were much humbler structures. Source

The Leland Hotel on the
corner of Main Street was built in 1906 by Robert Bannatyne.
A number of Quill Lake residents initially opposed Bannatyne’s license for a hotel. The hotel license
commissioners of the day, however, felt the community needed a place of public
accommodation, and the thirty-room, three-storey Leland Hotel, complete with
sample rooms and steam heat, opened in the fall of 1906.One of the first functions held at the hotel was
a banquet given by the Board of Trade on December 10, 1906 to celebrate the
incorporation of Quill Lake as a village. The hotel did a roaring business
until 1916 when the bar was closed due to Prohibition.

Mrs.
Bannatyne is reported to have been a jolly woman who loved having company despite
the busy life she led. She often had her sister Ellen helping her with the
chores of running the hotel and looking after the Bannatyne’s ten children. Source and With Quill in Hand; Quill Lake and District, 1903 to 1983, Quill Lake Historical Society, 1984.

Robert and Annie Bannatyne with their ten children, c. 1925. Source: With Quill in Hand (1984)

Bannatyne sold the Leland
hotel in 1920, due, no doubt, to poor business during Prohibition. The

Source: With Quill in Hand (1984)

new
owner was Edward A. Cunningham, an Irishman from Liverpool, England. Edward and
his wife Jessie came to Saskatchewan in 1907 with their three children. In
1915, they sold their homestead and bought the Invermay Hotel which they
operated for a short time. In 1922, the Cunninghams and their four children
moved to Quill Lake where they bought the Leland Hotel. The the onslaught of
the Depression spelled doom for many a country hotel, and in 1929 the
Cunninghams retired to Saskatoon.

Two Chinese men, including “Der
Louie” took over the Leland Hotel in the late 1930s, but after Archie McLean
was murdered in November of 1939, they left. The police may have given them a
hard time. McLean, an elderly bachelor, had participated in a late-night poker
game held in a room at the hotel. The following morning, he was found dead in
his shack by the village watchman.The
old-age pensioner had been beaten to death with a piece of wood. Fred Zazula, a
31-year-old farm labourer, was charged with the murder, the motive being
robbery. When McLean left the poker game at the Leland Hotel, he had money in
his pockets, but when his body was found, his pockets had been turned
inside-out, and only a few coins were found on his body. Source

Leland Hotel in the 1920s. Source: With Quill in Hand (1984)

Major changes were made to the
Leland Hotel after Edward W. Walker bought the business in 1941. Walker, a
barber originally from Winnipeg, removed the second and third floors of the
building, which included 20 guest rooms. Walker then operated his barber shop
and poolroom on the main floor.

Apparently, the hotel still had eight rooms and
plenty of living space for Walker, his wife Irene, and their four children. The balconies were also removed, the windows
changed, and some partitions removed and a stucco job done on the front.“Our old building, known as Ed’s Barber and Billiards,
has quite a history,” Walker wrote in the Quill Lake history book. “It was the
largest hotel in the district in the early days, an old-time bar, a liquor
outlet, and later a restaurant before I took over in 1941. … Heating was always
a problem. There was a leaky hot water system which I changed to steam to heat
the front part of the building and I had a big barrel wood stove in the
poolroom part in the back. Steam was later piped back there, too. A big
threshing boiler – hand fed, supplied the steam for heat; later a stoker, then
an oil-burning furnace, which was at last converted to natural gas. Gasoline
lamps were used over my pool tables for the first two years. Water kept coming
up in the basement and had to be pumped out twice a day at least.Finally sewer and water and inside plumbing
was a wonderful change when it came to town. ….” (Source: With Quill in Hand; Quill Lake and District, 1903 to 1983, Quill Lake Historical Society, 1984, p. 843)

Photo by Ruth Bitner

Walker sold the Leland hotel
to Mac Wilson and Thomas Scarfe in 1982.It was used as a game arcade, with pinball machines and a pool table.
The building was torn down sometime after that, replaced by a park and the Quill
Lake roadside attraction – a large Canada goose.

The Quill Lake Hotel

After Robert Bannatyne sold
the Leland Hotel in 1920, he turned to farming.He kept his hand in with business in Quill Lake, however.He owned a store across Main Street from his
old hotel.In 1929, the original O.C.
King Hardware store was remodeled and opened as the Quill Lake Hotel by Bannatyne.He operated the hotel until he died in 1934
at age 70.The business was taken over
by Bannatyne’s daughter, Mrs. Flo Piett, who ran it until 1940. Other
members of the Bannatyne family operated the Quill Lake Hotel throughout the
1940s.Herman, also known as “Toots”
because he played saxophone in the town orchestra for local dances, ran the
hotel with his wife Jean until his brothers, Garnet and Jim, returned from overseas
after the Second World War.Garnet
brought with him a bride from Holland and their four-month-old daughter.(Source: With Quill in Hand; Quill Lake and District, 1903 to 1983, Quill Lake Historical Society, 1984)

Annie Bannatyne passed away
on June 3, 1945. She was survived by all ten of her children.The Bannatyne’s Quill Lake Hotel was still
standing in 2013.

Quill Lake Hotel across the street from the former Leland Hotel site, August 2013. Joan Champ photo

About Me

One of my favorite activities was traveling around the southern half of Saskatchewan with my digital camera. My favorite photo subjects were old small-town hotels. I am the former the Executive Director of the Saskatchewan Western Development Museum.

Acknowledgements

I could not write this blog without the local history books from all the little villages and towns throughout the province. I am indebted to the web site, Our Roots, for digitizing many Saskatchewan local history books, and to the libraries that preserve these rich resources on their book shelves.

I am sorry that Google News Archives is no longer searchable. It still provides free access to scanned newspapers, including full issues of the major Saskatchewan papers, going back to the 1800s, but it no longer has a search engine. You have to browse, which is not really practical for my research purposes.

“I stayed in a really old hotel last night. They sent me a wake-up letter.”