If this is your first visit, be sure to
check out the FAQ by clicking the
link above. You may have to register
before you can post: click the register link above to proceed. To start viewing messages,
select the forum that you want to visit from the selection below.

Re: Playoffs: WC vs Chiefs

Really? Not just one game buddy, RG3 has been WAY outshined by Luck ALL SEASON, this is just the icing on the cake.

Really, buddy? RG3 was coming off an injury and had nothing on offense to help him out (see Cousins getting blown up by the terrible O-line). RG3 was out-shined by everyone this season, but one playoff one hardly seals the deal.

Re: Playoffs: WC vs Chiefs

You can't compare the two (and yes I know this is the last place to ask such a question) but when Manning started on the Colts they were the laughing stock of the NFL. Stuff like regular postseason trips and winning divisions were a foreign concept around here.

When Luck was drafted we only had one bad season but its not as if we forgot how to win we had Mathis and Wayne(well not today obviously). So really to say this playoff win is career defining is rather premature.

Manning had his first playoff win vs Denver(oh the irony) fortunately with Luck we didn't have to wait as long but it was less than 10 season.

Re: Playoffs: WC vs Chiefs

Really, buddy? RG3 was coming off an injury and had nothing on offense to help him out (see Cousins getting blown up by the terrible O-line). RG3 was out-shined by everyone this season, but one playoff one hardly seals the deal.

Regardless, congrats to Luck and the Colts.

Luck lost his top WR, TE, and top two RBs this season not to mention a bad o-line and STILL led his team to the playoffs and a playoff win.

Re: Playoffs: WC vs Chiefs

Really, buddy? RG3 was coming off an injury and had nothing on offense to help him out (see Cousins getting blown up by the terrible O-line). RG3 was out-shined by everyone this season, but one playoff one hardly seals the deal.

Regardless, congrats to Luck and the Colts.

Sorry, until PROVEN otherwise, RGIII is not even in the same tier, probably 2 tiers down actually.

Re: Playoffs: WC vs Chiefs

Peyton manning in the AFC Championship game against the Patriots just called...he begs to differ

Not buying it. At that point in his career, Peyton SHOULD win that game. And anyway, I never once thought the Colts were out of that game. It might have been slaying a bigger demon, but that's it. This comeback was bigger in terms of score and adding to the comeback legacy Luck has already established. It's crazy to even think about. This is historic like the Bills comin from 38 down to beat the Oilers in the playoffs.

Re: Playoffs: WC vs Chiefs

Luck lost his top WR, TE, and top two RBs this season and STILL led his team to the playoffs and a playoff win.

RGIII couldn't sniff Luck's jockstrap.

Your high.

BTW, when Luck leads a team that loses 36 million in cap money and comes off a torn knee ligament come talk to me.

Dude has been Lucky (pun intended) with great talent and depth and a lot of talent. But lets GTFO this whole notion that Luck is leaps and bounds above RG3. Both guys were in the playoffs last year.....

Re: Playoffs: WC vs Chiefs

Not buying it. At that point in his career, Peyton SHOULD win that game. And anyway, I never once thought the Colts were out of that game. It might have been slaying a bigger demon, but that's it. This comeback was bigger in terms of score and adding to the comeback legacy Luck has already established. It's crazy to even think about. This is historic like the Bills comin from 38 down to beat the Oilers in the playoffs.

now that I agree with definitely numerically but you can also argue winning your first game in the playoffs in that fashion is pretty huge itself like other people were saying look how long it took peyton to get his

Re: Playoffs: WC vs Chiefs

BTW, when Luck leads a team that loses 36 million in cap money and comes off a torn knee ligament come talk to me.

Dude has been Lucky (pun intended) with great talent and depth and a lot of talent. But lets GTFO this whole notion that Luck is leaps and bounds above RG3. Both guys were in the playoffs last year.....

Re: Playoffs: WC vs Chiefs

BTW, when Luck leads a team that loses 36 million in cap money and comes off a torn knee ligament come talk to me.

Dude has been Lucky (pun intended) with great talent and depth and a lot of talent. But lets GTFO this whole notion that Luck is leaps and bounds above RG3. Both guys were in the playoffs last year.....

Luck didn't have a great team his first year or even this year and most of the better players on the colts were on IR. How many Colts are going to pro Bowl? One

Re: Playoffs: WC vs Chiefs

BTW, when Luck leads a team that loses 36 million in cap money and comes off a torn knee ligament come talk to me.

Dude has been Lucky (pun intended) with great talent and depth and a lot of talent. But lets GTFO this whole notion that Luck is leaps and bounds above RG3. Both guys were in the playoffs last year.....

Indy had $36mill in dead money last year. And Andrew lost a ton of his weapons this year.

Sent from my KFTHWI using Tapatalk

There are two types of quarterbacks in the league: Those whom over time, the league figures out ... and those who figure out the league.

Re: Playoffs: WC vs Chiefs

BTW, when Luck leads a team that loses 36 million in cap money and comes off a torn knee ligament come talk to me.

Dude has been Lucky (pun intended) with great talent and depth and a lot of talent. But lets GTFO this whole notion that Luck is leaps and bounds above RG3. Both guys were in the playoffs last year.....

holy crap people still think Luck and RG3 are close competitively speaking? arguing that after this game is going to be pretty hard....