I. Fragmentary Notes for “A Dissertation on the Canon and the Feudal Law”

[dateline] [May–August 1765]

Liberty, that has been compelled to skulk about in Corners of the Earth, and been
everlastingly persecuted by the great, the rich, the noble, the Reverend, the proud,
the Lasey, the Ambitious, avaricious, and Revengeful, who have from the beginning
constituted almost all the sons of Adam. Liberty, that complication of real Honour,
Piety, Virtue Dignity, and Glory, which has never been enjoyd, in its full Perfection,
by more than ten or twelve Millions of Men at any Time, since the Creation, will reign
in America, over hundreds and Thousands of Millions at a Time.

In future ages, when the Bones and sinews that now direct this Pen, shall become indistinguishable
from the rest of Mother Earth, and perhaps incorporate into some Plant or other Animal,
Man shall make his true Figure, upon this Continent, He shall make that great and
happy Figure among Intellectual and sensible reigns that his great Creator intended
he should in other Countries before his Ruin was effected by the Lust of Tyrants.

When science, Literature, Civility, Politeness, Humanity, [every?] Christian grace and Virtue shall be well understood by all Men, when <a few> one shall not be able to deceive a Thousand and two because 10,000 of their Souls
and Bodies then will be the Aera of human Happiness.

Knowledge monopolized, or in the Possession of a few, is a Curse to Mankind. We should
dispense it among all Ranks. We should educate our children. Equality should be preserved
in knowledge.

Property monopolized or in the Possession of a few is a Curse to Mankind. We should
preserve not an Absolute Equality.—this is unnecessary, but preserve all from extreme
Poverty, and all others from extravagant Riches.1

The Happiness of a Milion is in the sight of God, and in the Estimation of every honest
and humane Mind, of more Importance, than that of 20 or an Hundred. Even tho the former
may be called the Mob, the Vulgar, or the Herd, and tho the former may be called the
reverd or right reverend, the honourable, or excellent, or noble, or puissant, or
royal—for Happiness is Happiness to every human Creature, and they all feel nearly
the Like Sensations from Hunger, Frost, from broken Bones, and bruised Flesh, notwithstand[ing] all such Accidental Titles of Dignity or Reproach.

Let us reverence, with hearty Gratitude, the Memory of the late Chief Justice Dudley,2 for his noble Foundation of a Lecture on the Validity of Presbyterian ordinations,
an Institution, that will redound more to his Honor and that of his family, than all
the offices, that could have been bestowd upon him by the Crown or the People, an
Institution that has given every Friend to unsullied Liberty, a great Idea both of
his foresight and Public Spirit.

MS (Adams Papers). These notes are located amidst a group of draft newspaper letters which JA wrote in 1763 and which CFA docketed: “Original Draughts of Newspaper Articles, signed U. 1763” (Adams Papers, Microfilms, Reel No. 343). However, internal evidence, particularly that of a thematic nature,
indicates that they were actually written by JA in 1765 in conjunction with the composition of “A Dissertation on the Canon and the
Feudal Law.” Like the published “Dissertation,” although in much more summary style,
the notes deal with the themes of the natural dichotomy between power and liberty
and the role of popular education in the preservation of freedom. Also like the published
“Dissertation,” they pay tribute to the institution of the Dudleian Lecture at Harvard
College. Because JA was heavily influenced by the Dudleian Lecture delivered by Jonathan Mayhew on 8
May 1765 (see below, No. IV, note 3, and No. V, note 2), there are good grounds for assuming that JA jotted down these notes no earlier than that date.

1. Although JA expounded at some length in his draft and in the finished version on the dangers
of monopolized knowledge, he did not develop the theme of the dangers of monopolized
property and of the extremes of wealth and poverty. His concentration on the monopolization
of knowledge probably grew out of concern over the Stamp Act with its taxes on newspapers,
college diplomas, and the like.

2. Paul Dudley (1675–1751) graduated from Harvard in 1690. He served as attorney general of Massachusetts from
1702 to 1718, Superior Court justice from 1718 to 1745, and chief justice of the same
court from 1745 until his death. In his will he endowed Harvard with the funds for
an annual lecture, soon known as the Dudleian Lecture, every fourth one of which was
to be devoted to “the detecting and convicting and exposing the Idolatry of the Romish
Church, Their Tyranny, Usurpations, damnable Heresies, fatal Errors, abominable Superstitions,
and other crying Wickednesses in their high Places; And Finally that the Church of
Rome is that mystical Babylon, that Man of Sin, That Apostate Church spoken of, in
the New-Testament” (Sibley-Shipton, Harvard Graduates, 4:42–53).