Last year (and over his career) he was better than Ortiz with runners on, RISP, RISP w/ 2 outs, almost every "clutch" (IMO) situation except for with the bases loaded. He had several game winning HRs too but since he doesn't play for New York or Boston, no one will care.

And let's not forget how he managed to ruin the career of a very talented and promising pitcher: