'Docs vs. Glocks' - the Florida case of First Amendment vs the Second Amendment

'Docs vs. Glocks' - the Florida case of First Amendment vs the Second Amendment

.

Florida officials are appealing a federal judge's ruling striking down a Florida law that restricted doctors from talking with patients about gun ownership.

Gov. Rick Scott announced the appeal Monday. U.S. District Judge Marcia Cooke ruled earlier this month in the case known as "Docs vs. Glocks." Cooke agreed with physicians who contended the law violates free speech rights.

Re: 'Docs vs. Glocks' - the Florida case of First Amendment vs the Second Amendment

its just turning doctors into another arm of the police state.

Quoting: Anonymous Coward 20962219

First off, doctors suck, only use the douche bags to stitch up a massive head wound, other wise most illnesses can be curedwith diet, exercise.. If a doctor asked me about "guns" I would reply,, oh no doc , I'm scared of guns, in fact I'm so scared I need some friggin Valium. Haaa get the Valium, trade it for silver, go out and buy a shit load of guns. Good plan?

Re: 'Docs vs. Glocks' - the Florida case of First Amendment vs the Second Amendment

I am an ER nurse in the UK and I am so happy we don't allow guns in this country and if I was seeing tens of gunshot wounds every night I would call for the banning of guns...not to be a nanny but because I went into my job to help people stay healthy...

Gun related deaths in the USA is over 11,000 a year, higher than the rest of the developed world put together...if you lost that many troops in Iraq the Army would get pulled!

Re: 'Docs vs. Glocks' - the Florida case of First Amendment vs the Second Amendment

I am an ER nurse in the UK and I am so happy we don't allow guns in this country and if I was seeing tens of gunshot wounds every night I would call for the banning of guns...not to be a nanny but because I went into my job to help people stay healthy...

Gun related deaths in the USA is over 11,000 a year, higher than the rest of the developed world put together...if you lost that many troops in Iraq the Army would get pulled!

How can a Doctor do his job when the law is against him?

Quoting: Dr Shroom

Stab wounds easier to stitch up I take it?

"You will not be punished for your anger, you will be punished by your anger"

Re: 'Docs vs. Glocks' - the Florida case of First Amendment vs the Second Amendment

Most male doctors know about FEDERAL medicare and realize what the federal government is up to......that is why pediatrics and ob-gyn are left to the women .....to control young people and children...as most women just don't want to see the truth!!!!!

Re: 'Docs vs. Glocks' - the Florida case of First Amendment vs the Second Amendment

.

Gun related deaths in the USA is over 11,000 a year, higher than the rest of the developed world put together...if you lost that many troops in Iraq the Army would get pulled!

How can a Doctor do his job when the law is against him?

.

Quoting: Dr Shroom

.

Then why doesn't the law address knife ownership or blunt object ownership?If a criminal is involved in a gun-related death, it's not the doctor's responsibility; it's the responsibility of law enforcementto then talk to the gang member or drug seller.

This law is just one more attempt of the government trying to ease their nose under the tent of 2nd Amendment rightsof the US citizen.

Re: 'Docs vs. Glocks' - the Florida case of First Amendment vs the Second Amendment

I am an ER nurse in the UK and I am so happy we don't allow guns in this country and if I was seeing tens of gunshot wounds every night I would call for the banning of guns...not to be a nanny but because I went into my job to help people stay healthy...

Gun related deaths in the USA is over 11,000 a year, higher than the rest of the developed world put together...if you lost that many troops in Iraq the Army would get pulled!

How can a Doctor do his job when the law is against him?

Quoting: Dr Shroom

Stab wounds easier to stitch up I take it?

Quoting: ANHEDONIC

They rarely get trapped in the body and never leave football sized exit wounds...so the answer is yes.

Re: 'Docs vs. Glocks' - the Florida case of First Amendment vs the Second Amendment

I am an ER nurse in the UK and I am so happy we don't allow guns in this country and if I was seeing tens of gunshot wounds every night I would call for the banning of guns...not to be a nanny but because I went into my job to help people stay healthy...

Gun related deaths in the USA is over 11,000 a year, higher than the rest of the developed world put together...if you lost that many troops in Iraq the Army would get pulled!

How can a Doctor do his job when the law is against him?

Quoting: Dr Shroom

Do you have any idea how many would be killed if they tried to ban guns in this country?

Re: 'Docs vs. Glocks' - the Florida case of First Amendment vs the Second Amendment

I am an ER nurse in the UK and I am so happy we don't allow guns in this country and if I was seeing tens of gunshot wounds every night I would call for the banning of guns...not to be a nanny but because I went into my job to help people stay healthy...

Gun related deaths in the USA is over 11,000 a year, higher than the rest of the developed world put together...if you lost that many troops in Iraq the Army would get pulled!

How can a Doctor do his job when the law is against him?

Quoting: Dr Shroom

Stab wounds easier to stitch up I take it?

Quoting: ANHEDONIC

They rarely get trapped in the body and never leave football sized exit wounds...so the answer is yes.

Re: 'Docs vs. Glocks' - the Florida case of First Amendment vs the Second Amendment

.

Gun related deaths in the USA is over 11,000 a year, higher than the rest of the developed world put together...if you lost that many troops in Iraq the Army would get pulled!

How can a Doctor do his job when the law is against him?

.

Quoting: Dr Shroom

.

Then why doesn't the law address knife ownership or blunt object ownership?If a criminal is involved in a gun-related death, it's not the doctor's responsibility; it's the responsibility of law enforcementto then talk to the gang member or drug seller.

This law is just one more attempt of the government trying to ease their nose under the tent of 2nd Amendment rightsof the US citizen.

.

Quoting: Borat Sagdiyev

How many other laws written before the dawn of flight do you still live by? Guns back then where shit...rifling was imported to the states during the Civil war...the Colt repeater was not too effective a way to kill somebody even with their basic levels of healthcare...now a man can kill 15 people with one hand.

Re: 'Docs vs. Glocks' - the Florida case of First Amendment vs the Second Amendment

I am an ER nurse in the UK and I am so happy we don't allow guns in this country and if I was seeing tens of gunshot wounds every night I would call for the banning of guns...not to be a nanny but because I went into my job to help people stay healthy...

Gun related deaths in the USA is over 11,000 a year, higher than the rest of the developed world put together...if you lost that many troops in Iraq the Army would get pulled!

How can a Doctor do his job when the law is against him?

Quoting: Dr Shroom

Stab wounds easier to stitch up I take it?

Quoting: ANHEDONIC

They rarely get trapped in the body and never leave football sized exit wounds...so the answer is yes.

Quoting: Dr Shroom

What about clubs smashing skulls?

Quoting: Anonymous Coward 20972399

Utterly illogical, or shall we bring in car crashes, poison and sharpened pencils?

Re: 'Docs vs. Glocks' - the Florida case of First Amendment vs the Second Amendment

I am an ER nurse in the UK and I am so happy we don't allow guns in this country and if I was seeing tens of gunshot wounds every night I would call for the banning of guns...not to be a nanny but because I went into my job to help people stay healthy...

Gun related deaths in the USA is over 11,000 a year, higher than the rest of the developed world put together...if you lost that many troops in Iraq the Army would get pulled!

How can a Doctor do his job when the law is against him?

Quoting: Dr Shroom

Do you have any idea how many would be killed if they tried to ban guns in this country?

So much for your "theory".

Quoting: Anonymous Coward 20972399

Only parts of Africa and certified war zones have a higher death rate to guns than the US...I would say thats evidence of sound theory on my part.

You want to kill people, I can deal with that...I'm a nurse, I like keeping them alive...how I can get negative karma for that is a truly sad indictment of this board.

Re: 'Docs vs. Glocks' - the Florida case of First Amendment vs the Second Amendment

I am an ER nurse in the UK and I am so happy we don't allow guns in this country and if I was seeing tens of gunshot wounds every night I would call for the banning of guns...not to be a nanny but because I went into my job to help people stay healthy...

Gun related deaths in the USA is over 11,000 a year, higher than the rest of the developed world put together...if you lost that many troops in Iraq the Army would get pulled!

How can a Doctor do his job when the law is against him?

Quoting: Dr Shroom

Do you have any idea how many would be killed if they tried to ban guns in this country?

So much for your "theory".

Quoting: Anonymous Coward 20972399

Only parts of Africa and certified war zones have a higher death rate to guns than the US...I would say thats evidence of sound theory on my part.

You want to kill people, I can deal with that...I'm a nurse, I like keeping them alive...how I can get negative karma for that is a truly sad indictment of this board.

Quoting: Dr Shroom

Because you don't believe in individual liberty to own guns, in case you were wondering.

Re: 'Docs vs. Glocks' - the Florida case of First Amendment vs the Second Amendment

...

They rarely get trapped in the body and never leave football sized exit wounds...so the answer is yes.

Quoting: Dr Shroom

What about clubs smashing skulls?

Quoting: Anonymous Coward 20972399

Utterly illogical, or shall we bring in car crashes, poison and sharpened pencils?

Quoting: Dr Shroom

May as well, everybody wants to be safe, right?

Quoting: Anonymous Coward 20972399

Did you miss the bit where I said I was a nurse? Do you know how sad and frustrating it is patching people hurt by other people is? Have you seen somebody die or a dead body? I have, beyond count and we have little or no gun crime here...it must be heartbreaking for my colleagues in your country...that is all I am saying.

Re: 'Docs vs. Glocks' - the Florida case of First Amendment vs the Second Amendment

...

What about clubs smashing skulls?

Quoting: Anonymous Coward 20972399

Utterly illogical, or shall we bring in car crashes, poison and sharpened pencils?

Quoting: Dr Shroom

May as well, everybody wants to be safe, right?

Quoting: Anonymous Coward 20972399

Did you miss the bit where I said I was a nurse? Do you know how sad and frustrating it is patching people hurt by other people is? Have you seen somebody die or a dead body? I have, beyond count and we have little or no gun crime here...it must be heartbreaking for my colleagues in your country...that is all I am saying.

Re: 'Docs vs. Glocks' - the Florida case of First Amendment vs the Second Amendment

I am an ER nurse in the UK and I am so happy we don't allow guns in this country and if I was seeing tens of gunshot wounds every night I would call for the banning of guns...not to be a nanny but because I went into my job to help people stay healthy...

Gun related deaths in the USA is over 11,000 a year, higher than the rest of the developed world put together...if you lost that many troops in Iraq the Army would get pulled!

How can a Doctor do his job when the law is against him?

Quoting: Dr Shroom

Haaaa. ,, tens of thousands,, where did you get that statistic.. First of all you live In a horrible nation that has done nothing but destroy humanity and our ultimate destiny which is complete freedom following the laws of nature and natures God. Read " the decline and fall of the British empire" by Piers Brendon.Secondly , a good friend of mine spent 3 years in Bath while working for Motorola. His story's of the appalling state of " the queens" health care are evidence that has been submitted to Congress..Lastly,why on earth won't your goverment of German userpers(Saks, Coberg, Gotha), stop harassing the American people. Have you not learned yet that no matter how many viscious clandestine operations that are waged upon us, generation to generation, that WE WILL NEVER BOW TO THE CROWN. I'm sure your a great nurse and these comments are from a heart of love. Peace, William Wallace

Re: 'Docs vs. Glocks' - the Florida case of First Amendment vs the Second Amendment

...

What about clubs smashing skulls?

Quoting: Anonymous Coward 20972399

Utterly illogical, or shall we bring in car crashes, poison and sharpened pencils?

Quoting: Dr Shroom

May as well, everybody wants to be safe, right?

Quoting: Anonymous Coward 20972399

Did you miss the bit where I said I was a nurse? Do you know how sad and frustrating it is patching people hurt by other people is? Have you seen somebody die or a dead body? I have, beyond count and we have little or no gun crime here...it must be heartbreaking for my colleagues in your country...that is all I am saying.

Re: 'Docs vs. Glocks' - the Florida case of First Amendment vs the Second Amendment

I am an ER nurse in the UK and I am so happy we don't allow guns in this country and if I was seeing tens of gunshot wounds every night I would call for the banning of guns...not to be a nanny but because I went into my job to help people stay healthy...

Gun related deaths in the USA is over 11,000 a year, higher than the rest of the developed world put together...if you lost that many troops in Iraq the Army would get pulled!

How can a Doctor do his job when the law is against him?

Quoting: Dr Shroom

"Gun Control: The theory that a woman found dead in an alley, raped and strangled with her own pantyhose, is somehow morally superior to a woman explaining to the police how her attacker got that fatal bullet wound."

Jack of all trades, master of none.We are all the result of our past choices meeting the future."shall not be infringed."

Um, I dont get it? I was saying knife wounds are less complicated than bullet wounds, that was a description of a bullet wound...and whats a cops job? Alive or dead a victim ends up at a doctor...and his nursing staff (me)...I am sorry but I dont get it, really. Sorry.