I'll saw one wrong thing. It's actually physics related so you can say that laws of physics are different in the star wars world. anyway, here it is. I noticed when the droid ship was tilting at the beggining of the movie, everything was sliding. i think that they shouldn't be since they were all in space and the gravity of the ship is supposedly towards the floor. the only explanation i can think of is that they were pulled somehow by coruscant. anyway, what do you guys think?

Yeah, I caught that too. That implies when Han Solo is spinning the Millennium Falcon in pinwheels to escape the Tie-fighters in ESB, everyone not strapped down is bouncing off the walls inside of the Falcon.

It's a continuity error, notice that R2 and C3PO do slide in ESB as well as it tilts.

The OT has no excuse, the only one I can think of in ROTS, is since the Invisible Hand is going down because of terrible damage I imagine the power grid is fluctuating so maybe the artificial gravity is fluctuating as well.

Padme's death is what was bothering me too. I didn't know if I was just remembering RTJ wrong or what? I don't know why Lucas made such a change. Well I mean obviously it's more dramatic if Padme dies but seems like a big mistake.

Kashyyyk. Everything(which is mostly EU info) that I've seen/read/heard about Kashyyyk says that it is covered in trees that stand miles and miles high. And the surface of the planet is a place that only Wookiees go, and is highly dangerous for even them. Its supposed to be filled with huge, vicious creatures. And the Wookiee's cities are built in the tops of the trees.

Now, in the movie, all we could see of Kashyyyk was a little bit of jungle, what seemed to be mountainous regions, and a beach. Nothing like what I'd expected.

On the other hand, I can accept that there might be a large body of water somewhere on the planet. And that the trees would thin around this area and the surface wouldn't be as dangerous. But the trees just didn't seem tall enough. And the fact that trees don't grow well around mountains...

Anyway, just something I'd noticed.

On the topic of the EU...I like the EU. Not all of it, but there have been quite a few stories that I've really liked. Many of them are pretty fun and interesting. While I don't agree that Maul would have been able to come back to life, I suppose it could be possible. Palp was able to keep Anakin alive...its likely that he could keep Maul alive too. And Maul was an interesting character that didn't get much A)Screen time or B) Backstory.

Anyway, I think the EU can be fun and isn't something that HAS to fit in with what the movies say. Most of them, however, do go along with the movies, for the most part. Though, quite a few will become huuuuuge stretches now that the prequels have ended.

Anakin drops his lightsaber after slicing off Mace's hand. Its still on the floor when he gets up and heads for the temple. So how did it wind up in his hand when he was at the temple? And where did Palpatine get the new lightsaber for his fight with Yoda?

Regarding gravity on the Invisible Hand, it is explained in the novelization that the artificial gravity is messed up from the attack and that gravity is changing directions throughout.

To make it easier to understand for the non-technical they show the ship moving in relation to Coruscant, but there is still dialog as Grievous and Neimoidian captain attempt to bring the "stabilizers" back online.

This is absolutely not a technical gaffe, it's simply another occassion where Lucas doesn't go into the dirty technical details. This isn't Star Trek, so who cares?

Yeah Yoda losing his robe with his fight with Sidious, he jumps in the speeder with bail without it and then on Tantiv IV he is wearing it again. how did he get his robe back or did he have a spare one somewhere.

There's a significant amount of time between Yoda and Obi-Wan's return to the temple and the two final duels. Obi-Wan needs enough time to get to Mustafar on the Outer Rim. Meanwhile, Yoda might have had time to pack up both his and Obi-Wan's stuff and put it on the Tantive IV.