Tuesday, July 15, 2014

On July 15, we had another PGIS orientation session. I had
the privilege to be a part of the first participatory data extraction and
digitisation process which occurred in Barangay Sua. The huge amount of
information displayed on the model and therefore the amount of data to be
digitised required the REBUILD Project management to allocate additional staff
to oversee the digitising work. At least three local government officials from
the Municipality of San Dionisio and two leading staff of the REBUILD Project
attended the session. The training conducted by Green Forum-Western Visayas
focused on the use of QGIS for digitising the data extracted from the 3D model
of Barangay Sua. In the course of the digitising process, I realized that most
data depicted on the 3D model represent infrastructure and habitats that were destroyed
by super typhoon Yolanda. Although no longer present, these were located by the
villagers in order to conduct a proper vulnerability assessment. They considered
that visualising a complete data-set of the pre-typhoon situation and comparing
it with the present conditions would enable them to gain a better understanding
of possible courses of action. As an example, they cited the introduction of
storm resistant infrastructures and the design of evacuation plans which would
reduce risks related to natural calamities.

A total of six P3DM exerciseswere conducted by the REBUILD Project. It is worth mentioning that in addition
to facilitating PGIS processes, the REBUILD Project staff implements livelihood
projects.Related posts by Wilfred Don Dorovoqa:

Monday, July 14, 2014

On July
14, I was introduced to the free and open source software (FOSS), QGIS (QuantumGIS) to be used in the PGIS process. The
REBUILD Project deploys two
facilitators stationed at the San Dionosio office to implement the disaster
rehabilitation program and livelihood strategy. Given these circumstances, I had
the opportunity to work with the QGIS
software for one day. Yet, Melvin was really helpful in teaching me the QGIS essentials and introducing me to a range of FOSS GIS software
applications which are available on the web. In the end, my learning
process of QGIS was much easier than expected.

Later in the day, we went to a local fishing village to work
with a non-indigenous community in Sua, a Barangay (administrative unit within
a municipality) located along the San Dionisio coastline. Here, we conducted a
community consultation meeting. While discussing the project with the
community, the importance of collaboration and participation was evident. Last June
2014, the community worked together to construct a 3D map of their location.
The 3D map was overlaid with a transparent plastic sheet, where information layers
were depicted by locals. From the conversations I had, the map clearly
indicates an effective medium for participatory discussions. It was nice to see
a couple of local Barangay councillors and their secretary, partake in the
consultation process with the REBUILD Project and
Green Forum-Western Visayas staff. The active participation of the Barangay officials
clearly demonstrated that the local government is aware and committed to
address the damages caused by the super typhoon Yolanda. The facilitating team,
however, pushed for a more direct cross-disciplinary and multi-sectoral
participation from those higher up in the government. Furthermore, it was
recalled that while constructing the 3D model, the residents of Barangay Sua
managed to outline their administrative boundary and to come to an agreement
about it with the neighbouring Barangay Tiabas.

Photo credit: Melvin Purzuelo

I was struck by the ease and dynamic use of the 3D model. It
did not become redundant or obsolete, even if it had been completed a month earlier.
On the contrary, it gained even more relevance as a reliable repository of
geo-referenced data generated by and for the community. The enthusiastic reaction
demonstrated by the local women to the consultation process was really
inspiring. They shared their views and opinions with respect to the need to
formulate a Disaster Risk Reduction Plan which could fit well with the
Community Climate Change Adaptation Plan. Both plans will be appraised by the
Barangay community. The villagers themselves attest that the model will be
revisited at regular intervals based on their information needs or at the
request of external agencies. From my perspective, the 3D model is a true
representation of the communities’ spatial knowledge concerning the entire
locality and the livelihoods of the residents. The 3D model enables residents
to effectively respond to emerging / changing situations.

In observing the consultation process, I was reminded that
strategic decisions must offer some degree of flexibility to avoid becoming
irreversible when implemented. Therefore the decision making process should be
based on quality data, adequate resources and sufficient time allocation. In my
opinion, the P3DM process undertaken by this community met these requirements.
During the consultation I noted that the model was constantly referred to when
analysing and identifying the risks inherent to their current and future livelihoods
and security. The model encourages the planning and distribution of future
activities in collaboration with the facilitators.

Photo credit: Melvin Purzuelo

The instances of the consultation process that are so vivid in
my memory are those linked to residents showing grief and despair when sharing
their stories. They explicitly used the model to describe the impact of super typhoon
Yolanda and recall the life-threatening ordeal they experienced. The typhoon caused
devastation, loss of property and lives and internal displacement. It severely
affected to the habitats essential to the community subsistence, and in general,
the existence of a once prideful fishing community. In response to such
terrible consequences, the facilitating team from the REBUILD Project used the
model to revive some hope in the midst of community’s despair. By autonomously
analysing their situation, its strengths, weaknesses, opportunities and
threats, residents were able to plan a concrete way forward leading to regain
to a 'normal' way of life.Related posts by Wilfred Don Dorovoqa:

I was welcomed at the Iloilo Airport by Melvin Purzuelo coordinator of the Green Forum-Western
Visayas (my local mentor) and driven to my accommodation. I was briefed on the
following day about the upcoming activities. On July 13, we went to the REBUILD Project Implementation Centre in San Dionisio. However we had to adjust our travel plans
due to ensure travellers safety in an area which has been affected by super typhoon
Yolanda. Recent past has witnessed a couple of incidents along the San Dionisio
and Estancia Highway, involving armed robberies that included loss of
lives. The locals believe that displaced people affected by the super typhoon
Yolanda who are dispossessed and resort to illegal activities to sustain
their living. We therefore were advised to be vigilant at all times and take the necessary precautions while travelling within the devastated area. Yet, the
PGIS activities were maintained as planned.

While working
with Melvin, I took the opportunity for preparing the base map for organising a
similar 3D modelling exercise to the one back home in Solomon Islands. We
discovered that the topographic maps of Solomon Islands are the work of the US
air force, the same as in the Philippines. Considering that these maps were made
decades ago, we realised that we had to improve them to be suitable for use in
a P3DM process. I am exploring possibilities for establishing a long term
partnership between our organisation in Solomon Islands and Melvin’s NGO in
terms of PGIS activities.Related posts by Wilfred Don Dorovoqa:

Friday, July 11, 2014

My overall expectations for attending the Philippines PGIS are vast. However, I shall limit the list to the following:

Gain practical knowledge and skills on how to facilitate and organise stakeholders into a participatory process and to know when and how to hand over the spatial information generating process to the concerned groups.

Acquire practical skills on how to select and procure appropriate inputs for the manufacture of a physical 3D map.

Gain hands on experience in the process of capturing and digitizing data displayed on the model and their processing for desired outcomes.

Discover appropriate approaches to assess, manage spatial data and strategise on how to use them to help concerned communities achieve their objectives

Align, impact and measure the outcome of a P3DM on the intended scenario.

Improve and advance my capacity on the use of Web 2.0 and Social Media.

During my participation, I believe that my theoretical knowledge on the subject will be enriched by practical experience and best serve an eventual replication of the P3DM process in Solomon Islands.

Follow the learning journey of Wilfred Don Dorovoqa, a member of the Padezaka tribe in Solomon Islands.
Supported by CTA, Wilfred Don has embarked in a journey which will bring him from Sasamuqa Village to Estancia in the Philippines where he will participate in a participatory mapping exercise. Green Forum – Western Visayas, Inc. (GF-WV) in partnership with Aksyon Klima Pilipinas and the Rebuild Project is facilitating the implementation of a Participatory 3-Dimensional Modelling (P3DM) process in an area which was severely affected by Supertyphoon Haiyan in November 2013. GF-WV is using the P3DM as an ICT tool for allowing communities to analyse their vulnerabilities and assist them in planning for reconstruction.Related posts by Wilfred Don Dorovoqa:

My name is Wilfred Don Dorovoqa. I am a member of the Padezaka tribe in Solomon Islands. I am about to embark on a challenging learning journey and I thought it would be interesting to document and share it with people having similar interests and aspirations.

This is my first blogpost. More will follow.

I left Sasamuqa Village (S 7°02’18.49” E 156°45’54.33”) in the early hours of June 16, 2014 by OBM boat and arrived at Gizo (S 8°06’12.99” E 156°50’27.80”) that same day, a three to four hour journey by boat. From there, I took a passenger boat for a two day journey to Honiara (S 9°25’52.13” E 159°57’33.57”), where I am today waiting for the trip to the Philippines.

How it all started: Embarking on the P3DM / PGIS learning journey

In 2009 I came across the concept of P3DM on the Internet, while I was searching customizable mapping resources for local spatial data entry that derived from non-technical / non-machine readable formats. I was captivated by the distinct nature and approach of the P3DM process, taking into account that at that time I was already familiar with the Participatory Rural Appraisal (PRA) concept. I assisted in a contracted PRA activity that aimed to identify and further develop livelihood measures for a localized World Wildlife Fund (WWF) conservation project based on four indigenous land owning groups of Choiseul Island, Solomon Islands, where I was holding a position as secretary for one of the groups. The conservation efforts were funded by the European Union , and led by the Ministry of Forestry in Solomon Islands.

Simultaneously, the Padezaka tribe, pursued its land based conservation initiative under a separate NGO in Solomon Islands called ‘Live and Learn’. The Padezaka tribe was eventually very fortunate to become a selected recipient of the Global Environment Facility (GEF) – Small Grants Programme funds coordinated by the United Nations Development Programme (UNDP) office based in Honiara, the capital city of Solomon Islands. As a member of the Padezaka tribe, I have very strong land and blood ties with the local community, and have been heavily involved in most of their conservation activities. The network of local protected areas attempts to conserve 17 percent of the highest priority terrestrial ecosystem of the Choiseul Island in adherence to the convention on biodiversity to which Solomon Islands is a signatory.

My search for mapping resources on the web was motivated by the fact that three conservation land units were under WWF conservation initiatives, including the Padezaka tribal land. Here, the conservation land units were all situated in the same segment of a significant freshwater system, locally known as the Kolobangara River. Major logging activities authorised by government, occurred further upstream while government-endorsed WWF conservation initiatives were concentrated downstream. Indeed, upstream deforestation posed a significant threat to the livelihoods of local communities. It was a counteractive measure to monitor and moderate critical changes to the natural environment. Currently, all stakeholders involved need to come to an agreement to implement an alternative measure. One possible alternative is to produce a collaborative map with detailed land use that covers the entire watershed of the Kolobangara River.

Given this, my research eventually landed me on the front steps of the local provincial planning advisor’s house, an expatriate from New Zealand working for The Nature Conservancy (TNC) Solomon Islands Office. The planning advisor assisted the Choiseul government in provincial-wide planning, project implementation and monitoring. He was very helpful and promised to update me on any available opportunities that need expert assistance for a future P3DM exercise comprising the concerned land area. In anticipation, the Padezaka Tribe submitted a budget under the GEF-Small Grants Programme fund for a P3DM project in the Padezaka bio-diversity protected sites; to generate a well defined land use plan, consult, invite and include the contiguous land owning tribes for broad holistic land-based planning activities. This of course, will work if there is an environment conducive to collaborative planning that can systematically and coherently tackle the issue of the endangered watershed areas by creating a sectoral land and resource management plan in advance. We estimated that the availability of the P3DM opportunity would coincide with the disbursement and implementation of the external fund.

Our desire for P3DM does not materialise the Padezaka Conservation Project funds. These included GEF-Small Grants Programme funds that were mismanaged by the implementing NGO, which ceased to be operational whilst subjected to that same timeframe. WWF also closed its doors to the other four local land groups, perhaps due to the lapse of the funding contract. However, the Choiseul provincial advisor was true to his word and invited me to attend a P3DM introductory workshop in May 2012. It was jointly organized by the Technical Centre for Agricultural and Rural Cooperation (CTA), TNC and UNDP held in the Capital of the Solomon Islands. During this organised workshop, I repeatedly called on our provincial leaders in attendance to convene an extensive P3DM of the whole Island of Choiseul but was adhered not to.

Fundamentally, this is the dominant culture in PGIS practices found in some areas of the Southern hemisphere. In the Northern hemisphere, I believe the public is more proactive in using PGIS to enhance, empower and improve their way of life. At the very structure of our society there is a lack of proactive dimensions needed to engender a collaborative planning process that measures collective growth. This weakness is inherent to those tribes whose land comprises the noted watershed area. Furthermore, the National River Act was very ineffective in dealing with large scale natural resource extractions, because it had no clear provisions for specific social and natural environment safeguards. However, I am also fully aware of the fact that some methodologies and techniques incorporated into the PRA approach have limitations for discovering effective solutions in the midst of the large scale emergence of this environmental threat.

Thursday, July 10, 2014

The Caribbean Natural Resources Institute (CANARI), the University of the West Indies (UWI), the Tobago House of Assembly, Division of Agriculture, Marine Affairs, Marketing and the Environment (DAME) and the Partners with Melanesians (PwM) facilitated the building of a Participatory 3D Model (P3DM) of Tobago Island from 28th September to 12th October 2012.

The model was used as a tool to incorporate and recognize local and traditional knowledge and values into decision making about climate change adaptation.

A training of trainers in facilitating participatory approaches, with participants drawn from the Caribbean Region, was executed concurrently with the building of the P3D model of Tobago. Participants in the Training of Trainers used participatory video to evaluate the effectiveness of the use of P3DM.

The project was funded by the Technical Centre for Agricultural and Rural Cooperation (CTA) and the United Nations Development Programme and the Global Environment Facility Small Grants Programme (UNDP GEF SGP).