Post navigation

Police in the US state of New Mexico are crediting a voice assistant with saving the life of a woman by calling the sheriff at her command during an alleged assault.

According to ABC News, a crisis team – including a SWAT team – were sent to the house and managed to take the man into custody after an hours-long standoff.

That man was Eduardo Barros. He was house-sitting with his girlfriend and her daughter on July 2. The couple reportedly got into an argument that turned violent, according to the Bernalillo County Sheriff Department.

As ABC News tells it, Barros allegedly held up a firearm and threatened to kill the woman, asking her: “Did you call the sheriffs?”

The utterance triggered a smart speaker – we don’t know what type; the police had initially and erroneously said it was a Google Home device, but a press release subsequently said that the emergency call recording indicated that the alleged victim was telling Amazon’s Alexa to dial 999. The question was interpreted as a voice command and a call was placed to the emergency services, presumably by an always-listening device such as an iPhone with Siri.

Bernalillo County Sheriff Manuel Gonzales III said in a statement to ABC News that the device’s mistake possibly saved the woman and her child:

The unexpected use of this new technology to contact emergency services has possibly helped save a life. This amazing technology definitely helped save a mother and her child from a very violent situation.

Barros is facing charges of possession of a firearm or destructive device by a felon, aggravated battery against a household member, aggravated assault against a household member and false imprisonment. He’s being held without bond.

This isn’t the first time that voice assistants have been credited with life-saving calls.

In March, Apple’s Siri voice assistant was credited with saving a London woman’s life. When she fell to the floor, unconscious, her four-year-old son unlocked his mother’s mobile phone by pressing her thumb to it. Then, he asked Siri for help. Siri dialed 999: the British emergency number. With life-saving first aid, she survived and was taken to the hospital.

Also, in June 2016, an Australian mother, rushing to the nursery when a baby monitor showed her one-year-old had stopped breathing, dropped her phone while she was turning on the light. She still managed to tell Siri to call for help while she performed CPR. Both she and her husband credited the few precious seconds that Siri gave them for potentially making all the difference.

The outcome of that particular story is one of the upsides of the fact that recent iPhones can be set to always be listening for commands. That new feature came about in iOS 9, when Apple enabled activation of the built-in personal assistant at the sound of your voice, rather than waiting for you to hold down the Home button.

If that’s turned on, Siri can not only open music and send text messages, it can also make hands-free phone calls on its own while you drive, or, while you’re in critical situations. Note that Siri in hands-free mode only works on newer models when not plugged in to a power source. Older models – at least back to 5s – need to be plugged in to a power source to enable Siri to work in hands-free mode.

Other phone brands can also be set up for hands-free voice assistance, of course. These stories illustrate one good reason why people might want to activate the feature. Police have urged parents to teach children their home address, as well as how to unlock a phone and how to summon help, whether it’s through a voice assistant or by pressing an emergency services number like 999 in the UK or 911 in the US.

It’s worth noting that you can make an emergency call on a locked phone. The feature is available on the Lock screen of every iPhone: press the Home button to trigger the passcode screen, after which you can bypass the lock to either make an emergency call or access someone’s Medical ID information.

Ditto for Androids: Tap Phone (if your phone is locked, tap Emergency Call). If that doesn’t work, swipe to get to the login screen, which will offer an option of placing the emergency call. Android allows you to set up four emergency contacts, and it presents a number pad to call for emergency services and an icon for emergency medical information.

It’s a welcome departure from our always-on-listening-devices norm, which has otherwise been taken up with things like all the internet-connected, artificially intelligent and very scary toys that listen to your kids!

We’ve double-checked this and the sheriff’s department has clarified what seems to have happened to Lisa, and we’ve updated the story. Briefly, police say that the recording indicated that she was shouting at an Alexa device to call 911, and it seems that the smart assistant on her phone picked up the command too and placed the call.

I talked with the sheriff’s department. It posted a press release about the incident to Facebook a few hours after I had started working on the story, so I missed the updated details. There’s a press release on the sheriff’s Facebook page which we’ve linked to in the story.

As you’ll see from reading the release, this is a confusing story. The victim was telling Amazon Alexa to call 911, but Amazon has said that no, you can’t place an emergency call with its voice assistant. The police say that all they know is what the victim told them (that she’d told Alexa to call 911) and what the recording of the 911 call said (Alexa, call 911).

What I assume, and this is just an assumption, is that the “Alexa” part of the voice command did nothing, but the “call 911” might have triggered a mobile phone voice assistant, such as Apple’s Siri.

At any rate, no smart speaker seems to be involved, so we’ve updated the story to reflect that. Thanks for giving us a heads-up!

While new gadgets receive media hype, they all too often can underserve the end-user. Hence the name ‘gadget’ is rather appropriate here. Refinements to new technology are a constant and in the case above, I’m glad Alexa or Siri seemed to effectively transmit a call for help. In an emergency, time is of the essence and the simpler the means to communicating the need for help, the greater the chances are to receiving a timely response and emergency medical treatment, if needed.

Sidebar regarding cell phones (smart devices) in general- I have interviewed dozens of First Responders in the States who confirm that upon arrival at the scene of an accident they do NOT go searching for cell phones. (A cell phone is the first thing lost in an accident, often flying out of the car or flung to the back of the vehicle upon impact.) Emergency personnel go immediately to assessing their patient and only briefly scan the body for ID jewelry or anything that is literally right in front of their face that might alert them to their patient’s unique health condition, if any.

Given the above, I believe inputing medical info into ones smart phone can provide the consumer with a false sense of adequate emergency preparedness. I can not imagine relying only upon my good “friend” Alexa or Siri to relay my urgent need for possible life-saving assistance. Fortunately for this woman, it worked.