Transcription

1 The Law and Business of Bitcoin and Other Cryptocurrencies Geoffrey Miller Law School David Yermack Stern School of Business We propose a class on Bitcoin and other alternative payment mechanisms. Interest in this topic has exploded over the past five years, as Bitcoin and an increasing pool of competitors have risen in value and gained increasing acceptance as payment devices. Advocates for Bitcoin praise it as a superior payment mechanism one that operates outside the control of governments, is international in scope, is more secure than prior electronic payments vehicles, and carries within it a locked-in protocol for increase in supply which is impervious to inflationary temptations. At the same time, the growth of these innovations has led to heightened concerns about their use. Governments worry that Bitcoin facilitates illegal transactions (as in the case of the Silk Road site which allegedly was for transactions in illegal drugs). Investors and governments worry that these currencies have a highly speculative value and trade in markets which themselves are vulnerable to fraud and theft (the failure of the Mt. Gox exchange illustrates the dangers). Some governments are concerned that private payments systems will undermine efforts to control the value of their currencies. Governments also worry, more fundamentally, that they could lose hundreds of billions of dollars of seigniorage if virtual currencies become the norm. These concerns have triggered actual or threatened regulatory actions: Bitcoin is banned in Russia, strictly regulated in China, and subject to increasing scrutiny in Switzerland and other countries. So far, however, the United States regulators have allowed the experiment to continue without significant regulation. It appears that the dynamic forces behind virtual currencies will be difficult for governments to halt, even if they wish to do so. Although innovations such as Bitcoin may stumble or disappear, others are likely to take its place. Accordingly, although the future of virtual currencies is uncertain, we believe that this course is likely to have continuing relevance. Our proposal is for a combined offering of the Law School and the Stern School and would be open to registration for both law and business students. The class would be a 2-credit class for law student and a 1.5-credit class for business students. To adjust for the difference in credit, there would be four extra law classes for law students, not required for business school students, taught at the beginning of the semester. Guest speakers from the Bitcoin community or from government will be invited to participate in two or three class sessions. Assessment will be based on student papers. 1

3 - Who is threatened by Bitcoin? - Competitors to Bitcoin Class Six: Bitcoin and monetary economics - Bitcoin as a stateless currency with no monetary policy - The weaknesses of fiat currency; Gresham s law - Bitcoin s appeal to classical monetarists: separating politics from money - Bitcoin s impact on siegniorage - Can Bitcoin be debased? - Bitcoin s long-run problem: deflation after 2140 Class Seven: Is Bitcoin a currency, or something else? - Classical criteria of money: medium of exchange, unit of account, store of value - Bitcoin s problems: volatility, arbitrage, market incompleteness - Measures of Bitcoin s adoption in the mainstream economy - Other views of Bitcoin: an investment security, a transfer service. a commodity - Which regulators should be watching over Bitcoin? - Proposed extensions of the Bitcoin algorithm to other financial and legal services Class Eight: Using Bitcoin as a consumer - How does a consumer acquire Bitcoins? - What are digital wallets? Are they as secure and liquid as bank deposits? - What are Bitcoin ATMs? - Does Bitcoin provide confidentiality, or does it undermine it? - Which businesses accept Bitcoin, and why? - Hidden charges and commissions charged by vendors when you pay in Bitcoin - Bitcoin and sales taxes - Refunds, returns, and other aspects of routine consumer protection - Does Bitcoin preclude the use of ordinary consumer credit? Class Nine: Using Bitcoin as a business - Accepting Bitcoin as a market strategy to attract a certain clientele - How Bitcoin s payment and verification systems work for ordinary transactions 3

4 - Risk management, hedging, and transaction costs for a business - How do auditors and tax collectors treat Bitcoin transactions? - Dealing with consumer fraud strategies such as malleability and double spending - How should businesses think about credit, refunds, deposits, and other transactions if the customer pays in Bitcoin? - Impact of the Silk Road case on Bitcoin commerce Class Ten: Legal treatment of Bitcoin - Potential regulation under the securities laws - Potential regulation under the commodities laws - Pledging Bitcoin as collateral - Seizing Bitcoin in court to satisfy fines, judgments, or back taxes - The emerging regulatory structure and case law in the U.S. - Class Eleven: International remittances and Bitcoin - Introduction to international money transfers - Costs built into the worldwide payments system, compared to Bitcoin transfer costs - Shadow banks and other alternative payment methods - Repatriation of overseas profits by a corporation using Bitcoin - Remittance of overseas earnings by an immigrant using Bitcoin - Money laundering for narcotics, terrorism, tax evasion, and other purposes Class Twelve: Bitcoin and the capital markets - The custody, settlement and verification process Bitcoin vs. standard investments - Overview of the varied Bitcoin markets around the world - Benchmarking the trading of Bitcoin: volume, spreads, liquidity, arbitrage - Bitcoin derivatives and their role in hedging - Why is there no credit denominated in Bitcoin? Will there be? Class Thirteen: Regulating Bitcoin trading - Legal regulation of money transfer agents - Who, if anyone, has authority to regulate Bitcoin trading? - Capital and margin requirements for traders - Capitalization requirements for market makers - Disclosure and transparency requirements 4

5 - Vulnerabilities of Bitcoin: hacking, custodianship, default of market makers - The rise and fall of the Mt. Gox exchange Class Fourteen: Bitcoin as a speculative investment - The world market for currencies does Bitcoin fit in at all? - What intrinsic value would justify investing in Bitcoin? - Is Bitcoin similar to gold as an asset? - Bitcoin investment vehicles, such as the Winklevoss Bitcoin Trust - Risks related to liquidity and market incompleteness - How does Bitcoin measure up on a risk/return basis? - Does Bitcoin s trajectory resemble fads and bubbles from financial history? Class Fifteen (optional and open to the broader community): Bitcoin s conflict with the political system - Why was Bitcoin popular in China? Why is it popular in the U.S.? - Can the U.S. government ban Bitcoin? - Can Bitcoin be a focal point for economic disobedience? - Why do libertarians like Bitcoin? - Does Bitcoin have potential advantages for a government? - Will the existing regulatory structure try to co-opt Bitcoin, or push it away? 5

6 Reading list Source documents and websites bitcoin.org bitcoinfoundation.org coindesk.com, especially A Beginner s Guide to Bitcoin, available at coindesk.com/information, and State of Bitcoin 2014, available at coindesk.com/bitcoin-2014-report. Nakamoto, Satoshi, 2008, Bitcoin: A Peer-to-Peer Electronic Cash System, unpublished manuscript, available at bitcoin.org/bitcoin.pdf. Government materials European Central Bank, 2012, Virtual Currency Schemes, available at ecb.europa.eu/pub/pdf/other/virtualcurrencyschemes201210en.pdf U.S. Department of the Treasury Financial Crimes Enforcement Network, 2013, Guidance: Application of FinCEN s Regulations to Persons Administering, Exchanging, or Using Virtual Currencies, release FIN-2013-G001, March 18, 2013, available at fincen.gov/statutes_regs/guidance/pdf/fin-2013-g001.pdf U.S. Law Library of Congress Global Legal Research Center, 2014, Regulation of Bitcoin in Selected Jurisdictions, L.L. File No , available at cdn1.sbnation.com/assets/ / _Law_Library_of_Congress_Bitcoin_jurisdictional_survey.pdf U.S. Senate Committee on Homeland Security and Governmental Affairs, Beyond Silk Road: Potential Risks, Threats, and Promises of Virtual Currencies, Hearings held November 18-19, 2013, available at hsgac.senate.gov/hearings/beyond-silk-road-potential-risks-threats-and-promisesof-virtual-currencies Letter of Sen. Joe Manchin (D-WV) on regulating Bitcoin, February 26, 2014, available at manchin.senate.gov/public/index.cfm/2014/2/manchin-demands-federalregulators-ban-bitcoin and response of Patrick Murck, Bitcoin Foundation General Counsel, February 27, 2014, available at bitcoinfoundation.org/blog/wp-content/uploads/2014/02/ letter-to- Senator-Manchin.pdf 6

The Law and Business of Bitcoin and Other Cryptocurrencies Geoffrey Miller NYU School of Law David Yermack NYU Stern School of Business This new course, to be offered jointly by NYU s Law School and Stern

STATEMENT OF MYTHILI RAMAN ACTING ASSISTANT ATTORNEY GENERAL CRIMINAL DIVISION U.S. DEPARTMENT OF JUSTICE BEFORE THE COMMITTEE ON HOMELAND SECURITY AND GOVERNMENTAL AFFAIRS UNITED STATES SENATE FOR A HEARING

Virtual Currency Schemes BitCoin A matter of swim or sink? CPSS Worldbank Conference 3-4 December 2013 Cape Town, South Africa The views expressed in this presentation are those of and do not necessarily

STATEMENT BY SENATOR CARL LEVIN (D-MICH) BEFORE PERMANENT SUBCOMMITTEE ON INVESTIGATIONS ON FAILURE TO IDENTIFY COMPANY OWNERS IMPEDES LAW ENFORCEMENT November 14, 2006 In 2004, the United States was home

B.Sc. Essay in Business Cryptocurrency and Bitcoin: A possible foundation of future currency why it has value, what is its history and its future outlook. Sindri Leó Árnason Leiðbeinandi: Guðrún Johnsen

What is Money? This lecture examines the functions of money, the evolution of the payments system, and how money is measured. Functions of Money A. Medium of Exchange 1. Money is any item that is generally

Office of the State Bank Commissioner Guidance Document MT 2014-01 Date: June 6, 2014 Regulatory Treatment of Virtual Currencies Under the Kansas Money Transmitter Act Purpose The purpose of this guidance

ECON 4110: Sample Exam Name MULTIPLE CHOICE. Choose the one alternative that best completes the statement or answers the question. 1) Economists define risk as A) the difference between the return on common

Chapter 13 Money and Banking Multiple Choice Questions Choose the one alternative that best completes the statement or answers the question. 1. The most important function of money is (a) as a store of

Edward Lowery III Special Agent in Charge Criminal Investigative Division, U.S. Secret Service Prepared Testimony Before the United States Senate Committee on Homeland Security and Governmental Affairs

STATEMENT OF BITS PRESIDENT PAUL SMOCER ON BEHALF OF THE FINANCIAL SERVICES ROUNDTABLE BEFORE THE THE UNITED STATES SENATE COMMITTEE ON BANKING, HOUSING, AND URBAN AFFAIRS SUBCOMMITTEE ON NATIONAL SECURITY

12 Ben Fung and Hanna Halaburda, Currency Department With advances in technology and the rapid spread of the Internet, various digital currencies have emerged. While digital currencies could increase the

Research Review CAIAMember MemberContribution Contribution Perspectives CAIA What a CAIA Member Should Know What Is Money? From Commodities to Virtual Currencies/ Bitcoin Benton E. Gup Professor Emeritus,

1 0 1 TITLE VIII PAYMENT, CLEARING AND SETTLEMENT SUPERVISION SEC. 01. SHORT TITLE. This title may be cited as the Payment, Clearing, and Settlement Supervision Act of 00. SEC. 0. FINDINGS AND PURPOSES.

United States Government Accountability Office Report to the Committee on Homeland Security and Governmental Affairs, U.S. Senate May 2014 VIRTUAL CURRENCIES Emerging Regulatory, Law Enforcement, and Consumer

MARCH 2015 bitcointrust.co The Bitcoin Investment Trust (BIT) is a private, open-ended trust that is invested exclusively in bitcoinand derives its value solely from the price of bitcoin. It enables investors

Senate inquiry into digital currency Submission by the Australian Securities and Investments Commission December 2014 Contents A Executive summary... 3 B Overview of ASIC s role and responsibilities...

The Australian Digital Currency Commerce Association Submission to the Financial System Inquiry Digital currencies and Bitcoin A proposed self-regulatory model for Australia 29 August 2014 www.gtlaw.com.au

Luc Laeven Director-General DG Research Virtual currency schemes Chief Economists Workshop Bank of England, London, 20 May 2015 Disclaimer: The views expressed in this presentation are those of the speaker

Bank Secrecy Act for Directors Barb Boyd Content Manager CU Solutions Group Agenda What is the Bank Secrecy Act? How to have a successful BSA Compliance Program OFAC responsibilities. Penalties for non-compliance.

Session Eight Building a Business Plan Part B: Getting Money to Start Your Business It is not necessary to do extraordinary things to get extraordinary results. Warren Buffett Overview: One of the great

Erik R. Barnett 1 Virtual Currencies: Safe for Business and Consumers or just for Criminals? 13 th European Security Conference & Exhibition The Hague April 2, 2014 There is a significant risk of large-scale

Buyers Guide to RMB Bonds Main author: Bryan Collins RMB bond investors need to do their homework first The RMB bond market is a relatively new and exciting investment opportunity, with RMB bond having

FINANCIAL SERVICES Australia has a sophisticated and stable banking and financial services system Australia has a sophisticated and stable banking and financial services system. The banking system is prudentially

metals products Gold Futures vs. Gold ETFs: Understanding the Differences and Opportunities. Noble DraKoln Founder of Speculator Academy and author of Winning the Trading Game and Trade Like a Pro cmegroup.com/metals

ELECTRONIC FUND TRANSFERS AGREEMENT AND DISCLOSURE This Electronic Fund Transfers Agreement and Disclosure is the contract which covers your and our rights and responsibilities concerning the electronic

Nevada Registered Agents Association Best Practices Recommendations to Prevent the Exploitation of Nevada Business Entities for Criminal Activities, and for the Protection of the Nevada Registered Agent

Bitcoin Digital Currency: A Portend for India s National Security Tarandeep Bains The bitcoin has been much in the news lately but there is a general lack of understanding of its concept, usage and the

ACCOUNTANTS AND TAX ADVISORS Sector Specific AML/CFT Guidance Notes May 2015 Whilst this publication has been prepared by the Financial Supervision Commission, it is not a legal document and should not

Virtually Unregulated Countering Virtual Currency Money Laundering in the 21st Century kpmg.co.uk c Section or Brochure name The issue The virtual currency industry has been under increased scrutiny to

CB(1)870/14-15(04) For discussion on 1 June 2015 Legislative Council Panel on Financial Affairs Proposal to Attract Enterprises to Establish Corporate Treasury Centres in Hong Kong PURPOSE In his 2015-16

PROFITEERING IN THE GLOBAL FOREX MARKET -Presentation by R.K.Gurumurthy -Treasurer, Bank One Ltd The story of a successful trader 2 The story of a successful trader trader 3 The story of a successful trader

LAW ON FOREIGN CURRENCY TRANSACTIONS ( Official Herald of the Republic of Serbia, Nos. 62/2006 and 31/2011) The present Law shall govern: I GENERAL PROVISIONS Article 1 1) payments, collections and transfers

How a thoughtful FX strategy can give Fund Managers a competitive edge Executive summary Each alternative investment fund takes a different approach to its investment strategy, but the ultimate goals are

The Commodity Price Roller Coaster Jayati Ghosh For most of the past year, as global prices in oil and other commodity markets zoomed to stratospheric levels, we were told that it had nothing to do with

Mitch Kosev and Thomas Williams* The exchange-traded fund (ETF) industry has grown strongly in a relatively short period of time, with the industry attracting greater attention as it grows in size. The

RISK DISCLOSURE STATEMENT You should note that there are significant risks inherent in investing in certain financial instruments and in certain markets. Investment in derivatives, futures, options and

Remarks by Director John Morton U.S. Immigration and Customs Enforcement Department of Homeland Security State of the Net Conference Washington, D.C. January 18, 2011 Good morning, I am indeed John Morton,

Testimony of David Sohn Senior Policy Counsel Center for Democracy and Technology Before The House Committee on Small Business June 12, 2008 Hearing on Electronic Payments Tax Reporting: Another Tax Burden

Study Questions 5 (Money) MULTIPLE CHOICE. Choose the one alternative that best completes the statement or answers the question. 1) The functions of money are 1) A) medium of exchange, unit of account,

Lecture 10: Money and the Federal Reserve System March 1, 2016 Prof. Wyatt Brooks THE BASIC TOOLS OF FINANCE 0 Question: What Backs US Money? Answer: Nothing. This is true of essentially every currency

VIRTUAL CURRENCY: RISKS AND REGULATION JUNE 23, 2014 EXECUTIVE SUMMARY Only a few years ago, virtual currencies were little-known outside of the online video gaming community. Today, the total market value

Merchant Account Terms of Use This Merchant Account Terms of Use ("MATOU") governs your use of the Services. Capitalised terms and expressions used in this MATOU shall, unless the context otherwise requires,

Seminar Global Foreign Exchange Markets Chapter 9 9- Learning Objectives To learn the fundamentals of foreign exchange To identify the major characteristics of the foreign-exchange market and how governments

Chapter 7 The Asset Market, Money, and Prices Multiple Choice Questions 1. A disadvantage of the barter system is that (a) no trade occurs. (b) people must produce all their own food, clothing, and shelter.

RISK MANAGEMENT AND COMPLIANCE: LOOKING AT THE BIG PICTURE HOW TO IDENTIFY AND MANAGE MONEY-LAUNDERING RISK This presentation exposes money laundering from every perspective and will empower you to identify

Appendix D Fundamentals of the Funds Transfer Process Essentially, an electronic funds transfer is a transaction by which funds move from one institution to another or one account to another at the direction

Trusts Explained Trusts Explained 2 Many people, often without realising it, will come into contact at some point of their lives with a trust in one form or another. Yet trusts are widely misunderstood

Short Selling Tutorial http://www.investopedia.com/university/shortselling/ Thanks very much for downloading the printable version of this tutorial. As always, we welcome any feedback or suggestions. http://www.investopedia.com/investopedia/contact.asp

ARE BITCOINS MONEY? An Undergraduate Research Scholars Thesis by BENJAMIN NADEAU Submitted to Honors and Undergraduate Research Texas A&M University in partial fulfillment of the requirements for the designation

The Monetary System Chapter CHAPTER CHECKLIST Define money and describe its functions. Money is any commodity or token that is generally accepted as a means of payment. Money serves as a medium of exchange,

ELECTRONIC FUND TRANSFERS AGREEMENT AND DISCLOSURE This Electronic Fund Transfers Agreement and Disclosure is the contract which covers your and our rights and responsibilities concerning the electronic

ELECTRONIC FUND TRANSFERS AGREEMENT AND DISCLOSURE This Electronic Fund Transfers Agreement and Disclosure is the contract which covers your and our rights and responsibilities concerning the electronic

STATEMENT OF ALYSA D. ERICHS SPECIAL AGENT IN CHARGE HOMELAND SECURITY INVESTIGATIONS MIAMI U.S. IMMIGRATION AND CUSTOMS ENFORCEMENT REGARDING A HEARING ON CATCH ME IF YOU CAN: THE IRS IMPERSONATION SCAM

Banking - Austria The brave new world of Bitcoin Austria Contributed by Graf & Pitkowitz June 26 2015 Despite recent fluctuations in value, the Bitcoin phenomenon shows no sign of slowing. The meteoric

7 May 2014 Notice on Potential Regulations Applicable to, and Risks of, Crowd-funding Activities The purpose of this notice is to remind parties engaging in crowd-funding activities of the potential application

RISK DISCLOSURE STATEMENT FOR FOREX TRADING AND IB MULTI- CURRENCY ACCOUNTS Rules of the U.S. National Futures Association ("NFA") require Interactive Brokers ("IB") to provide you with the following Risk

Remarks by Thomas J. Curry Comptroller of the Currency Before the Federal Home Loan Bank of Chicago Chicago, Illinois August 7, 2015 Good morning. It s a pleasure to be here with you today, and to have

Macroeconomics, 10e, Global Edition (Parkin) Chapter 25 Money, the Price Level, and Inflation 1 What is Money? 1) The functions of money are A) medium of exchange and the ability to buy goods and services.

ELECTRONIC FUND TRANSFERS AGREEMENT AND DISCLOSURE This Electronic Fund Transfers Agreement and Disclosure is the contract which covers your and our rights and responsibilities concerning the electronic