Division of Consolidated Laboratory Services

Richmond, Virginia

The Benefits of MeeFog Technology:

Nearly $200,000 annual energy savings

Greater than $50,000 saved on annual maintenance

The Challenge

The Commonwealth of Virginia’s state laboratory uses nearly 100% outside air, resulting in a high demand for humidification in the winter months. The gas-fired steam humidifiers were not only expensive to operate, but were continually breaking down.

The Solution

The Division of Consolidated Laboratory Services installed MeeFog humidification fogging arrays in each of the three air handlers, which were not only more reliable and less expensive than the steam generators, but can also provide summertime cooling.

In the old detective movies, it was common for the criminals to suddenly appear out of the fog and then disappear back into it after completing their dastardly deeds. For the Commonwealth of Virginia’s Division of Consolidated Laboratory Services (DCLS), however, fog played the hero’s role, cutting maintenance and energy costs, while providing a more comfortable working environment for the employees.

As its name implies, the DCLS provides testing services for around 50 state and federal agencies including the FBI, the state police, state health department and the Environmental Protection Agency. In 2004, the DCLS moved into a new 140,000 square foot building. The HVAC there included dual 400-ton Buffalo Air air handling units (AHUs) to provide more than 200,000 CFM of mostly outside air, allowing eight to ten complete air changes per hour.

Given the large amount of outside air, gas-fired steam humidifiers were installed to offset the effects of the dry winter air. But within a few years of installation, they were already proving problematic. Scale buildup on the steam generators greatly reduced their capacity and they had failed multiple times.

“They just kept breaking down,” says DCLS building manager Steve Crouch. “The burners would quit; the boxes would get cracks in them; they just weren’t working out. We needed to replace the units and hated the idea of just putting back in the same type of system.”

The Installation

Since these types of problems are common with steam humidification, Crouch went looking for a better technology that was simpler to maintain. He spoke with Al Torquato of Prime Air Products about switching to a fog humidification system. Torquato ran the numbers and found that DCLS could cut its maintenance and energy costs by $250,000 a year. Crouch decided to make the switch.

“I liked the simple design of the system and we have been very satisfied with the way it has performed,” says Crouch.

Torquato proposed that DCLS use a Mee fog humidification system consisting of three 7.5 hp CAT Pumps model FM-1050-B1051 high pressure ceramic plunger pumps, each delivering 10.5 gpm of water at 1000 psi. The pumps are controlled via individual manual-off-auto (MOA) selector switches mounted on the PLC panel. The lead pump can be selected manually, or if all three pumps are in Auto, then the pump with the lowest run hours will start first. The total load of the air handlers can be served by just two of the pumps, with the third pump acting as a backup. Initially just one pump comes on line, but if the flow rate exceeds a set point, the second one will come on line and the speed of the two pumps is equalized.

The Building Automation System provides the fogging system with a 0-10 vdc signal which the staging processor uses to determine which staging solenoids to energize for each air handler to increase or decrease the amount of fogging. As the humidity demand changes, the processor re-calculates the valve configurations needed to maintain humidity set points.

Installation of both the fogging system and a reverse osmosis (RO) water softener system took less than a month.

“It is not a big, complicated system,” says Crouch. “They were even able to install the spray racks in the air handlers while the air handlers were running, so there was no interruption in the operations.”

Slashing Energy and Maintenance Costs

Prior to installation, Torquato had conducted an analysis comparing the purchase, installation, maintenance and operations costs of the gas-fired and fog systems. To purchase and install the MeeFog and RO system was about 9% more expensive than simply replacing the gas-fired steam generators and there was also a $139,725 cost for demolition, retrofit of AHU sections, and electrical and piping changes. However, these were more than offset by a $192,426 annual energy savings and $58,400 less in annual maintenance costs. Based on those figures, the fogging system would pay for itself in 8 months, and the DCLS would save $250,000 a year from there on out.

While the DCLS won’t give financial details, Crouch does say that “we are saving a tremendous amount of money because we are not burning gas through the gas fired humidifiers. Our gas bills came way down when we got rid of them.”

The gas savings are primarily in the dry winter months, but the MeeFog system also saves money in the summer when Crouch manually runs the units on hot days to take advantage of the cooling effect of the evaporating water.

“You get the evaporative cooling across the air handlers and that takes some of the load off the chillers,” he says. “That works out very well for us.”

He also reports that the Mee system has eliminated the high maintenance load associated with the steam humidifiers.

“With the steam units we were always washing them out, changing the elements, doing this, doing that,” says Crouch. “There was a great deal of maintenance with the old ones. “

With the MeeFog system, maintenance has been reduced to changing the oil in the pumps, swapping out the water filters and making sure there is softening salt in the RO system. Other than that, it just does its job without a lot of extra care and attention.

“There is nothing complicated about the MeeFog system,” says Crouch. “It just works great.”