Both Caroline and Lucy took some serious flack from One Directioners when it was revealed that each of the women had apparently been in a relationship with Styles.

Caroline met her attackers head on over Twitter, posting a precise message to Harry’s crazed fans saying: ‘Hi one direction fans! To clarify. I’m close friends with harry.. He’s one of the nicest people I know… I don’t deserve death threats :) x.’

Too cool for school: Caroline was afraid of 1D fans who tweeted nasty comments on Twitter

Lucy had a bit of a rough ride, with fans tweeting her in their droves telling the DJ to back off their man.

In the end the 32-year-old deleted her Twitter account after she fell victim to a tirade of abuse from One Directioners – the collective name given to fans of the boyband – who condemned her over the alleged tryst.

One user even went as far as to say: ‘Haha you stupid f***ing wh**e. god you must have some issues to f*** a 17 year old boy hahahahaha.’

Winner – Round Two:Caroline wins for facing the haters head on

Cougar credentials

Caroline is the ultimate cougar in this face off, as she is often seen in towering heels and flattering, figure-hugging outfits.

Her unapologetic comments about seeing Harry are also admirable, showing she is a lass who likes to have fun. Being ridiculously attractive doesn’t hurt either…

Cougar next door: Lucy Horobin (Picture: Twitter)

DJ Lucy seems more like the girl – or woman – next door type, but if the rumours about her having an ‘affair’ with Harry are to be believed, then Lucy is as cougar as they come!

Winner – Round Three:Caroline wins this round for looking the part, as well as acting it.