‘Shame on you’: Pa. congressional candidates clash at debate

It is the only televised debate for Pa.'s 12th congressional district.

Ed Mahon is a reporter for PA Post.
Previously, he was an investigative and political reporter at the York Daily Record/Sunday News, where his work revealed holes in Pennsylvania’s system for protecting victims of domestic violence.
He grew up in Delaware County, graduated from La Salle University in Philadelphia and has lived in Pennsylvania most of his life.

(Pittston) — The candidates seeking to replace former GOP Congressman Tom Marino clashed multiple times during a debate Thursday evening.

“Shame on you, Fred Keller,” Democrat Marc Friedenberg said at one point in the debate while talking about Russian interference in the 2016 election. At another point, Friedenberg called one of Keller’s criticism of him “pathetic.”

Friedenberg, an instructor of cybersecurity and cyberlaw at Penn State, is facing off against Keller in a special election for the 12th Congressional District. Keller is a state representative from Snyder County and former plant manager for Conestoga Wood Specialties.

Keller, meanwhile, said his criticisms of Friedenberg focused on issues where they differed.

“My performance is about results, not about just trying to degrade somebody,” Keller replied,

The district includes a large section of central and northern Pennsylvania. Here are some highlights from the televised debate, which was held at WVIA Public Media Studios in Luzerne County.

Ed Mahon / PA Post

Republican Fred Keller, left, shakes hands with Democrat Marc Friedenberg ahead of a debate for Pennsylvania’s 12th congressional district on May 2, 2019.

Russian interference

Keller suggested Democrats were trying to use the issue of Russian interference in the 2016 election as a way of delegitimizing President Donald Trump’s victory.

“I’m here to say that nothing would irritate the Russians more than if we could all get together and figure out how what happened under the Obama administration doesn’t happen again,” Keller said.

Friedenberg accused Keller of not taking the issue seriously enough.

“Shame on you, Fred Keller, to say that it’s unimportant that we go back and look what happened in the 2016 election,” Friedenberg said. “We know the Russians tried to interfere in the 2018 election. We know they’re going to do it in 2019. They’re certainly going to do it in 2020.”

Allegations of “collusion” were not “proven false” in the Mueller investigation, nor was the issue of “collusion” addressed in the report.

Social Security

Social Security was a big issue in the debate. Friedenberg said he supports removing a cap on payroll taxes — so that people who earn about $130,000 a year or higher would pay more.

He said Keller would support cutting Social Security.

“The Club for Growth, which is supporting my opponent, this extremist group is dedicated to destroying Social Security as we know it, turning your retirement savings into a slush fund,” Friedenberg said.

Keller insisted that he wants to protect Social Security. Keller said Social Security is something people earned.

“And I will do everything I can to make sure that that is safe,” Keller said.

He said spending increases supported by some Democrats would put funding for Social Security in jeopardy.

Ed Mahon / PA Post

Democrat Marc Friedenberg, seen ahead of a debate on May 2, 2019, is running for Pennsylvania’s 12th congressional district.

Taxes

Keller repeatedly criticized Friedenberg over a 2017 video in which, Friedenberg said, “We should be raising taxes on the middle class so that they’re paying their fair share.”

In the rest of the video, Friedenberg criticizes Republican-backed federal tax cut legislation, saying it “will contribute massively to the already huge income inequality in the United States” and that “it gives massive corporations and the richest 1 percent of Americans a massive tax cut that they absolutely don’t need, while taking away tax deductions that the middle class has already come to rely on.”

Keller said that if Friedenberg didn’t mean to call for raising taxes on the middle class, then he should have reviewed the video and not posted it.

“He said it, he recorded it, he posted it,” Keller said.

Friedenberg called that criticism “pathetic.” He said the context is clear from the video.

“I support permanent, large tax cuts for the middle class,” Friedenberg said.

The primary is May 21.

Ed Mahon / PA Post

Republican Fred Keller, seen on May 2, 2019, is running for Pennsylvania’s 12th congressional district.