Analysis: If blind human rights activist Chen Guangcheng is holed up in U.S. embassy, it could cause rift with China

Chen Guangcheng being in U.S. embassy could cause rift with China

BEIJING —The secret flight by blind Chinese activist Chen Guangcheng from smothering home detention to what appears to be U.S. protection conjures images of the last Chinese dissident to seek shelter with the U.S. mission in China — astrophysicist Fang Lizhi.

China and the United States have kept silent on Chen’s whereabouts, but a U.S.-based rights group has told Reuters he is under U.S. protection and high-level talks regarding his status are under way.

If Chen is holed up with the United States — possibly at its Beijing embassy — it could open a wound in U.S.-China relations not unlike the rift more than two decades ago caused by Fang who, along with his wife, took refuge with the United States following the 1989 Tiananmen crackdown.

Related

Like Chen, an activist who helped women who were victims of forced abortions, Fang was an outspoken critic of a different era of Beijing’s human rights policies.

Fang emerged as an eloquent advocate of radical political change in China in 1986. He was quoted as saying in 1987 that the Chinese Communist Party could not boast of a single success in nearly 40 years of rule. “Marxism … is like a worn dress that must be put aside,” he said.

His constant challenge to the Communist Party apparently led China’s former paramount leader, Deng Xiaoping, to single him out in a secret speech in 1987 for expulsion from the party.

In the wake of the June 4, 1989, crackdown on pro-democracy activists centered on Beijing’s Tiananmen Square, Fang and his wife took refuge in the U.S. ambassador’s residence after being accused of counter-revolutionary crimes, a charge tantamount to treason — which could have meant the death penalty.

Fang had no public role in the student-led protests, but sought shelter after government supporters burned effigies of him. His more than yearlong ordeal under U.S. protection enraged China and became a sore spot in bilateral relations.

It was June 1990 before Beijing, in a concession to Washington, allowed Fang to leave China with his wife to seek medical treatment abroad, saying the couple had shown “signs of repentance.”

EMBASSY SUBTERFUGE

James Lilley, the U.S. ambassador to China who sheltered Fang and his wife, published colorful details of embassy subterfuge and high-stakes negotiations with the Chinese in an acclaimed 2004 memoir titled “China Hand.”

Lilley described Fang as an “affable type,” whose sense of humor helped get him through tense times. Lilley detailed absurd moments with Chinese authorities, who in October 1989 warned him “not to use Halloween as a ruse to sneak (Fang) out.”

“The truth was Fang was a living symbol of our conflict with China over human rights,” wrote Lilley, who died in 2009.

“The longer he and his wife remained under protective U.S. custody, the more difficult it would be to repair the considerable damage that had already been done,” he wrote.

Fang, who died earlier this month at the age of 76, never returned to China. But he remained one of the country’s most famous dissidents from the 1989 crackdown, campaigning for countries to maintain pressure on the Chinese government to respect human rights and permit dissent.

When Fang sought protection with the United States 23 years ago, Chinese leaders were isolated internationally after Tiananmen.

Beijing now enjoys international clout that comes with being the world’s second-largest economy, as well as the momentum of years of strong growth while Western economies founder.

Chen’s case, hearkening back to bitter post-Tiananmen memories, now threatens to overshadow a visit by U.S. Secretary of State Hillary Clinton and Treasury Secretary Timothy Geithner, due in Beijing next week for annual bilateral talks.

There is a much more recent case of a Chinese person entering an American mission with possible asylum claims. Chongqing police chief Wang Lijun fled to the U.S. Consulate in Chengdu on Feb. 6, triggering a crisis that wound up toppling the city’s party chief, Bo Xilai.

Similarities end quickly. Wang had led Bo’s campaign to clean up crime in the city, hailed by state media as successful but decried by critics for human rights violations. Asylum is more typically offered to victims of persecution.

Wang left the U.S. Consulate after a 30-hour stay and was taken into custody by officials from Beijing, avoiding capture by Chongqing officials sent to the Chengdu mission by Bo. Wang has not been heard from since.

“People are also mindful of what happened with the Wang Lijun incident and we want to remind the U.S. not to handle Chen’s case that way,” said Bob Fu, president of ChinaAid, the Texas-based religious and political rights advocacy group that has long campaigned for Chen’s freedom.