Huh? That's not a very good argument. So two problems start on the same starting hold. They go in totally opposite directions using different holds. Once you reach the lip you can traverse inbetween the two different topouts. So they are considered the same problem?

Okay Nic. I have to defend this problem because it is actually really cool. You only used the starting hold. That is it. There are 7 other holds on the problem as well. It is a different line. The cross move is bad ass too! Super fun and much easier for me than Alpine Club. You are correct when saying it is the same boulder, I will give you that much.