To shoot, or not to shoot, at Rocky Mountain NP

The elk of Rocky Mountain National Park are wildlife’s couch
potatoes. Rather than roam widely throughout the 415-square-mile park
and the land outside it, they are content to laze around in meadows,
eating, sleeping and mating.

With no predators, they can afford to be slackers. Many of them saunter
into the tourist town of Estes Park outside the eastern entrance. There,
they mosey along city streets and loiter on golf courses.

Their inertia has created problems in the park, however. Aspen and
willow stands are denuded where the elk do much of their grazing. That
habitat is vital to a variety of birds and butterflies, park officials
say. The damage has also driven out most of the beavers that once
populated the area, which in turn has caused a nearly 70-percent decline
in surface water that helps nourish the very habitat being damaged.

After years of debate, Rocky Mountain National Park decided on a
solution: Kill a portion of the voracious ungulates. It’s not an image
coveted by the National Park Service – sharpshooters picking off the
park’s most iconic creatures. The killing is done at dawn in winter with
rifles equipped with sound suppressors.

There is, however, a nonlethal method that can potentially keep the elk
in check and lessen the need to kill them: Birth control. In January, a
team of researchers wrapped up a three-year field study in which dozens
of cow elk were injected with a vaccine called GonaCon designed to
prevent pregnancies. The vaccine worked well for up to two years. But is
wildlife contraception a viable tool in controlling proliferating
wildlife herds? If it is, it might also be one means of managing the
size of rapidly-breeding wild horses in the West and nettlesome bison at
Yellowstone National Park.

“I’m always very wary when we try to do Mother Nature’s job better than
she does,” says Jenny Powers, a National Park Service wildlife
veterinarian and one of three lead scientists who participated in the
elk research.

But Stephanie Boyles, a wildlife scientist with the Humane Society of
the United States, welcomes the prospect of family planning for elk. “As
stewards, we are called on to do something to keep (wildlife) in
balance with nature,” she says. “It’s a politically contentious area.”

***

Elk are native to the Rocky Mountain National Park area, but unregulated
hunting wiped them out by the 1870s. Their only significant predators
were wolves, and they were eradicated by 1900. Elk were reintroduced in
1913 and 1914, and the national park was established in 1915. Congress
banned hunting within the park in 1929. The elk population quickly grew –
so much that the animals decimated parts of the park’s vegetation.
Between 1944 and 1969 park rangers culled some of the elk to keep their
numbers more manageable. (Culling differs from hunting in that it’s not
recreational and there’s no element of a fair chase.)

In 1969 the park began a “natural regulation policy” in the belief that
hunting of elk outside the park would control their numbers inside it.
That didn’t happen, in part because the park’s herd is less migratory
and more concentrated than under natural conditions. Many of the elk
spend winters in the eastern part of the park, where their munching has
damaged some aspens to the point where they don’t grow back.

Park officials say the optimum population within the park is between 600
and 800. Between 1997 and 2001, the park estimates there were between
2,800 and 3,500 elk within the boundaries. There also are another 1,000
to 1,300 elk that winter outside the park.

The park began a $6-million, 20-year plan in 2008 to reduce the elk
population and restore the plant life it damaged and destroyed. The plan
calls for “gradual lethal reduction” and fencing around some of the
most badly-damaged aspens and willows, while leaving open the options of
fertility control and wolves.

Four alternatives were considered, including one that would have culled
far greater numbers of elk in the park, and another that would have
phased in a maximum of 14 gray wolves. The thinking was that the wolves
would kill some of the elk and scare others into dispersing elsewhere in
the park. Their grazing would then be over a wider area and be less
destructive. Yet another alternative would have been the use of
“fertility control agents,” but even doing this would have still
required some culling to keep the elk’s numbers at an acceptable level.

Elk have now been culled inside the park three years in a row. Park
service personnel and others, including 23 trained volunteers who get $7
a day to cull the elk, do the job. Some 122 females and one male that
had the bad luck to be mistaken for a female have been killed in the
past three years. (Seventy-nine of them of them were euthanized during
the contraception research, while the remaining 44 were culled,
according to Kyle Patterson, the park’s spokeswoman.)

That’s far less than the maximum of 200 animals a year that park
officials had said might have to be culled. Patterson cites a couple of
reasons. A historic snowstorm in 2003 caused many of the elk to migrate
out of the park toward the city of Loveland 30 miles to the east. And
there was a record hunting harvest outside the park in 2006. All of that
can be reversed with a series of mild winters or if the Loveland
vagabonds return.

***

GonaCon was developed in the early 1990s by Lowell Miller and other
scientists at the National Wildlife Research Center, the research arm of
the United States Department of Agriculture’s Animal and Plant Health
Inspection Service in Fort Collins, Colo. Sitting on 43 acres in the
foothills, the center’s mission is to mitigate human-wildlife conflicts,
whether by nonlethal or lethal means. Its work includes conducting
research into reducing bird and aircraft collisions, developing
nonlethal ways of lessening wildlife damage to forests and analyzing
toxic concoctions aimed at killing tiny, nonnative coqui frogs in
Hawaii.

GonaCon is registered by the U.S. Environmental Protection Agency for
use on female white-tailed deer. The vaccine has also been tested on
other animals, including Yellowstone bison, feral cats and dogs and
California ground squirrels. Federal scientists also partnered with a
private company on an oral contraception for use on urban Canada goose
and feral pigeon populations, and are working on an oral contraceptive
for feral hogs.

GonaCon works by stimulating the production of antibodies that reduce
the ability of a hormone called GnRH to trigger the release of sex
hormones. Females don’t go into heat and males aren’t amorous as long as
there are sufficient levels of antibodies in the female’s body.

The Rocky Mountain National Park elk were vaccinated in the daunting
cold of January 2008. First, the animals had to be shot with a
tranquilizer dart – not easy on mornings when the drug froze inside the
dart. The dart guns are accurate up to 45 meters, says Powers, the park
service veterinarian. “The habituation of these animals and their
fearlessness of humans made this possible,” Powers says. “There are very
few (elk) populations close enough to dart them with a tranquilizer.”

Once sedated, the elk were rolled on to their chests so they could
breathe easier, blindfolded, injected with the vaccine and fitted with a
radio telemetry collar to locate them later. Samples of blood, feces
and hair were extracted. Then they were injected with another drug to
reverse the effects of the tranquilizer. The entire process took about
40 minutes, Powers says.

None of the critters died while being treated or examined, but one did
give researchers a surprise when she got to her feet. Normally, elk bolt
in the direction away from the scientists when they come to. “But this
animal seemed disoriented and chased my colleague around and around the
willow,” Powers says.

***

Elk that were subsequently recaptured were checked not only for
pregnancy but chronic wasting disease, a transmissible, untreatable and
fatal neurological disorder also found in deer. Hunters outside the park
were asked not to shoot at elk wearing collars, and animals treated
with GonaCon wore tags advising hunters not to consume their meat since
the vaccine may not have cleared their bodies.

One year after injecting 60 Rocky Mountain National Park elk with
GonaCon, 10 of the animals were recaptured. None was pregnant. Yet 90
percent of the control group recaptured – also composed of 60 females
given a saline solution—were pregnant.

Powers declined to provide data for the animals recaptured after the
second and third years until she and her colleagues publish the results
in a scientific journal. But she says the vaccine, while still effective
after the second year, was less so than after year one. And after three
years, the percentage of pregnancies was greater than after two years.
(In a small study of captive elk between 2004 and 2007, females injected
with GonaCon actually were more infertile with each passing year. The
percentages were 86, 90 and 100 percent in one group, and 90, 100 and
100 percent in a second group given a stronger dose of vaccine).

Powers thinks GonaCon might be effective in free-roaming elk for a year
or two, but she’s equivocal about its potential. Some animals that have
been treated may leave the park and never return, while others living
outside the park – like the Loveland emigrants—may return, she says.
Those sorts of variables dilute GonaCon’s effectiveness. She also points
out that determining how much impact a contraceptive has on reducing a
herd’s numbers is imprecise because severe weather and deaths from
chronic wasting disease kill an undetermined number every year.

She’s not alone in her guardedness. “It’s just a bit too early to tell
where we’re going to go next,” says John Mack, the park’s branch chief
of natural resources. “We need to wait and be patient.”

Every one of the elk in the GonaCon study had an abscess at the
injection site, Powers says. The researchers found nothing to suggest
that the sore spots became infected, hindered them in foraging or made
them lame. Nor were they aware of behavioral changes caused by the
vaccine. Since they didn’t monitor the elk year-round, they just don’t
know. “Free-ranging wild behavior with GonaCon has not been answered,”
Powers says.

Still, there is reason to believe that wildlife contraception may become
a more common method for controlling wildlife populations. Another
contraceptive, Porcine Zona Pellucida or PZP, has been field-tested for
nearly 30 years. The Bureau of Land Management, in cooperation with the
Humane Society of the United States, is treating nearly 900 mares from
wild horse herds in Idaho, Nevada and Utah this year in an effort to
control that species.

Unlike GonaCon, PZP doesn’t have to be injected manually, says Stephanie
Boyles, the Humane Society wildlife scientist. Wild horses are drawn to
temporary corrals baited with food or water, injected by a dart
containing the PZP and released. That’s a big improvement over the BLM’s
current program of rounding up frightened horses by helicopter and
confining them in holding pens, Boyles says. “The technology continues
to get better and better all the time,” she adds.

Even Congress has taken notice. In February, Rep. James Moran,
D-Virginia, called the BLM’s use of holding pens for wild horses
“enormously wasteful and misguided” and said contraception would be
cheaper and more humane.

Skeptics, however, question whether contraception should be used on
wildlife at all. When public input was solicited on various proposals
for dealing with the elk and the damage to their habitat, some people
were “strongly in favor of fertility control, and some were strongly
opposed who felt it was unnatural,” Patterson says.

“Some things are meant to be wild,” Powers says. “At some point, do we
not want to treat them like domestic animals and be handling them? I
think it’s important to point out that this is no silver bullet so that
we don’t have to kill wild animals. Any time we’re manipulative with
wild animals, we’re messing with natural selection.”

Boyles counters, “Any intervention could be construed as tampering with
the natural process”—including culling. “If that’s not animal husbandry
as well, I don’t know what is.” The reason there are wildlife
imbalances, she notes, is because humans eradicated predators, such as
at Rocky Mountain National Park.

Powers agrees. “We’ve changed the ecosystem,” she says. “We’ve created an artificial situation.”

Few argue that free-ranging wildlife populations can be reduced by
contraception alone. Its best use may be with animals that are confined
to some extent by either geography or fences, Powers says.

“It probably is more valuable in a confined setting than an open
setting,” Lowell Miller, the lead researcher in the development of
GonaCon, says of that vaccine. “It’s a lot more work (in an open
setting), but it can be effective. I think as time goes on, we’ll
determine how practical a tool it is.”

TROUT UNLIMITED NORTH IDAHO FIELD COORDINATOR
The field coordinator will work with TU members, other fishing organizations, community leaders, businesses and elected officials to build support for actions necessary to recover...

RECRUITMENT & HIRING MANAGER WITH WRA
Western Resource Advocates (WRA) is seeking a dynamic, organized, and creative person with great people skills to be our Recruitment & Hiring Manager to recruit...

DONOR RELATIONS MANAGER
This position is responsible for the identification and qualification of major and planned gift prospects and assists in cultivating and soliciting donors through meetings, trips,...

EXECUTIVE DIRECTOR
Do you enjoy rural living, wild places, family farms, challenging politics, and big conservation opportunities? Do you have leadership abilities, experience with rural land protection,...

MONTANA LAND STEWARD
The Montana Land Steward develops, manages, and advances conservation programs, plans, and methods related to TNC's property interest portfolio in Montana. For more information and...

DIRECTOR OF DEVELOPMENT
We are hiring a Director of Development Full time, competitive pay and benefits. Location: Bozeman,MT Visit www.greateryellowstone.org/careers for details GYC is an equal opportunity employer

EXECUTIVE DIRECTOR, KANIKSU LAND TRUST
Kaniksu Land Trust, a community-supported non-profit land trust serving north Idaho and northwest Montana, is in search of a new executive director. The ideal candidate...

MARKETING AND COMMUNICATIONS DIRECTOR
The Arizona Wildlife Federation seeks an energetic Marketing and Communications Director. Please see the full job description at https://azwildlife.org/jobs

CHIEF OPERATING OFFICER/DEPUTY DIRECTOR
Friends of Cedar Mesa seeks a skilled non-profit leader to play a crucial role in protecting the greater Bears Ears landscape. Experience working with government...