Beverly Shiner said that she assumed Johnson and Lozada had broken up when she visited him at his Foxborough, Massachusetts home in January 2012, which marked the beginning of a five-month affair.

"I Googled him before we met and saw he was engaged, but at the time there were reports that she had broken it off because she thought he was cheating, so I assumed they had split up," Shiner claimed.

"While I was there he called Evelyn and asked if she could order a pizza to be delivered for him, and even had her pay for it on her credit card. I thought it was odd and wondered if she was really his fiancée or just a secretary."

Shiner went on to allege that her relationship with the athlete ended suddenly when he reacted negatively to a comment she made about the way he was treating her.

"He had asked me to come over so I drove there and knocked on his door and he didn't answer even though I could hear his Xbox playing. Then I texted him the next day and he didn't apologize. I got upset and told him, 'You are not the guy I thought you were', to which he replied that he had been sleeping and warned me, 'You're overstepping your boundaries a little bit. I'm not your man, keep your comments to yourself'," she recalled.

"He just stopped talking to me because he didn't like the comments I made. It wasn't just a one night thing, he always said he wanted to move in with me, and said if he had I'd be pregnant by then. He kept asking if I wanted to have more kids."

The 30-year-old also claimed that Johnson did not feel guilty about having a sexual relationship with her behind Lozada's back, adding: "Once, when I was at his house, I asked what would happen if Evelyn walked in right now, and he said she wouldn't care.

"He said, 'I'm not doing anything different than what every other man is doing', he thinks it is fine to cheat. I feel he was completely disrespectful and he led me on."