Essay about Criminal procedure

Criminal procedure is composed of two models designed by a law professor in
Stanford University named Herbert Packer, intending to embody the sets of different values running the system of criminal justice in the United States of America. These are the crime control model, and the due process model which are known to be of contrast with each other. Both procedures will be discussed within this paper, showing the similarities as well as the differences of the same. This will also be a mode in figuring out the effects of the policies in criminal procedure by taking a look at the amendments made in the
Constitution of the United States, from the Fourth, Fifth and Sixth Amendment as well as the Fourteenth Amendment. The Bill of Rights of the Fourteenth Amendment will also be of a vital role in achieving the goal of this paper,
The most widely used procedure in criminal proceedings is the due process model.
According to Zalman, as an individual will try with utmost certainty to preserve the standard of upholding his right to life, liberty and property, he will not let go of it without undergoing the rightful due process promised to him as embodied in the Bill of Rights. A police officer, even upon arresting, shall not treat off a person arrested as if he was already convicted as guilty (N.A., 2008). Whether or not a person is indeed guilty should not be the defining factor that would qualify if he is entitled to such process, as everyone is entitled to it evidenced by the Bill of Rights incorporated in the Constitution. On the other hand, this varies depending on the enforcement level that has taken place. The crime control model is then used by law enforcers who have the very responsibility to uphold justice and peace all throughout the State, making sure that those who are guilty of crimes committed will be prosecuted and those victimized be served justice.
Another difference is that in due process, it is known of being of high importance most especially with attaining justice needed by the society as well as the culture. It strengthens the need to prove that a person is guilty beyond reasonable doubt before convicting him. There is, however, a negative impression over the crime control model, as it is known to slow down or even stops the improvement of the system of criminal justice upon arrest of an accused. Such arrest is deemed needed so as to ensure that the victim will be given justice, having a sense of responsibility towards the latter.
Despite their relevant contrasts, it is to be noted that they also possess similarities as shown in the Constitution. Both are based on the Constitution which embodies the correct process to be taken in order to validly exercise the same without prejudicing the rights of a citizen. As stated in the Fourth Amendment of the Constitution that the right of the people to be secure in his house, papers and effects shall not be violated, as well as the right of the people against unreasonable searches and seizure. A warrant of arrest shall be issued upon probable cause personally examined by the judge supported by the oath of affirmation of the complainant and the witnesses, and it must be for a single violation. The search warrant shall particularly describe the place to be searched and the specific person or things to be seized (U.S. Const. Amendment IV) (Zalman, 2008). Such provision must be followed by both models so as not to transgress the Constitutional right guaranteed.
Once this is not followed, those seized will not be admissible as evidence against the accused. The Fifth Amendment, on the other hand, states that every citizen are protected against self-discrimination in which an accused may choose who shall represent them in the case or even opt not to be represented by anyone at all. It is inevitable that questions will be asked. However, because of such right, he has the liberty not to answer until given a counsel in his representation. The case will prosper of there will be a

Related Documents: Essay about Criminal procedure

Abstract
The United States and Australian laws of criminal procedure show many common features which originate from their common English origin. These include the presumption of innocence, the neutral role of the trial judge, and the use of the jury trial. However, between the jurisdictions there are also significant different approaches especially in relation to the treatment of illegally obtained evidence, improperly obtained confessions and entrapment. The transparency of the jury is also an…

Individual Work 1 – Week 2
Shannon Long
Everest University Online
Criminal Procedure and the Constitution – 2
Instructor Lisa Story
Brief Fact Summary - Federal agents attached a device used for eavesdropping to a public phone, when they acted on a tip that Charles Katz was transmitting gambling information through the phone to his clients in other states. When the recordings were reviewed, Katz was convicted of eight counts of illegal transmission of wagering information from Los Angeles…

Criminal Procedure Policy
Kristen Torres
CJA/353
June 14, 2010
Kathleen H. Mooneyhan
“Criminal procedure is the branch of American constitutional law concerned with the state’s power to maintain an orderly society and the rights of citizens and residents to live in freedom from undue government interference with their liberty” (Zalman, 2008, p. 4). The Fourth, Fifth, Sixth, Eighth, and Fourteenth amendments are significant in studying criminal procedure. In criminal justice, the criminal procedure…

Criminal Procedure Policy
In the United States criminal justice system the criminal procedure policy is begins when a crime is committed and person is arrested for that crime. This person is now known as the defendant and is protected throughout the criminal procedure policy under the United States Constitution. The United States Constitution ensures fairness and justice to all through the Bill of Rights and other Amendments. Additionally, two procedural models help shape the criminal justice…

Criminal Policy
Amy Pandiscio
CJA/364
Tuesday, May 26th. 2015
Jason Huskey
Criminal Policy
The Fourth, Fifth, and Sixth amendment guarantee many rights to the people of the United States. This paper will explain the key elements that are secured by these amendments. It will also discussed how these policies have impacted criminal procedures are excercised by courts and police officers. Critical elements needed to meet the end state of this paper are the fourteenth amendment and the Bill of…

Name: Maggie leever
Hour: 4th
PRE-TRIAL PROCEDURE
1. What are two possible events that could occur during preliminary proceedings of a criminal case which would not result in a trial?
2. What are the two ways a police officer can legally arrest someone?
3. What is booking? Describe this process in full detail.
4. What happens in a lineup?
5. Generally how long after an arrest will the defendant make their initial court appearance? In…

Nancy Provines
Constitutional Law and Criminal Procedure
Assignment 1
3/5/15
(resubmission)
As discussed in the assignment description and facts, Congress authorized President George H.W. Bush’s war against Iraq (after a major troop build-up in the region already happened) and President George W. Bush’s invasion of Iraq over a decade later. While the White House maintained it was a formality or “rubber stamp”, it was nonetheless sought after by the President. As Commander in Chief of the Armed…

“No conduct constitutes a criminal offense unless it is made a criminal offense by this Criminal Code or by another law” www. http://delcode.delaware.gov/title11/c002/index.shtml.com, The State of Deleware, Title 11, Crimes and Criminal Procedure, 7/12/2013. In order for something to be a crime it must be made a statutory offense by a law or a code that states a certain act is illegal. If you look at the term crime simplistically then you are saying that a crime is something that is wrong. These…

behind-the-scenes actions of criminal investigations, even if its portrayals are not always scientifically accurate. This has caused an interest in the forensic sciences that has led most people to a skewed view of how a criminal investigation actually works. The reality of a criminal investigation is that it is generally more tedious and difficult than the theory of criminal investigation would have you believe. By examining the forensic and investigative procedures of the case of Pamela Foddrill…

Words 1875 - Pages 8

* Test names and other trademarks are the property of the respective trademark holders. None of the trademark holders are affiliated with this website.