文化 Culture

The myth of dog-eating in China

Eating dog meat is not a Chinese tradition and the Yulin “dog-meat” festival is just a money-making scheme carried out under the banner of culture, argues Hu Yifu

There is a misconception among some that China has always been a dog-eating nation. The growing popularity of eating dog in China is due mainly to prominent depictions of the practice in the film Shaolin Temple and a popular historical TV show about a monk, helped by over-promotion by some restaurant-owners and local governments.

The recent controversy over the “dog-meat” festival in Yulin, a city in south-west China’s Guangxi province, is awkward for the local government. Officials first stirred up the debate to promote the importance of the festival, claiming it supported local culture while boosting the local economy. But the local government never expected that its commercial activities would come under pressure from dog lovers around the country. It was forced to quietly claim that the whole affair was run by local businesspeople in an attempt to avoid responsibility.

China’s history of dog-eating

Dogs have been a part of Chinese households for at least 7,000 years, archaeologists say. The mythological ruler Fu Xi was said to have domesticated six wild animals: the pig, ox, goat, horse, fowl and dog, indicating that dogs were often kept even in ancient times.

Records show that back then dogs were kept mainly to assist with hunting. As the Chinese people became more engaged with agriculture, the dog’s role as hunter became less important – but it was not cast aside. Its loyalty to its owner made it valued for its role as a guard.

Those who advocate the eating of dog maintain it is a Chinese tradition, claiming that historical documents tell of “dog butchers” who specialised in preparing the meat. Others quote from works by founder of the Han dynasty Liu Bang and Qing dynasty painter Zheng Banqiao as proof that the Chinese have always enjoyed dog meat – but this is not enough to prove it is a tradition or custom.

The San Zi Jing, a text used to teach children since the 13th century, describes dog as one of the six animals raised by people. This is generally taken to mean that these animals were a source of meat. But as agriculture developed and eating habits changed cows, sheep, chickens and pigs became the main sources of meat for Chinese people. Dogs gradually stopped being used as food – and the reasons behind this are complex.

Prior to the Qin and Han dynasties the combination of primitive agricultural techniques and the chaos of constant war meant that living standards were low and meat a rare luxury, offered primarily to the elderly as a sign of respect. Beasts of burden and guard dogs which died of illness or old age could not be wasted, so our thrifty ancestors would cook the meat and eat their fill.

Dog meat was not an essential food for people, as can be seen from a study of sacrificial offerings. These offerings to the gods and their ancestors were important and great attention was paid to the goods to be offered. For the grandest of imperial ceremonies a cow or horse would be sacrificed, for less important occasions a pig or sheep, and the ordinary people would offer pork, chicken or fish. But dog was almost never used, and it was regarded as disrespectful to the spirits to do so. That taboo is still common today, showing that dog meat is not suitable for refined tastes, and certainly not for serving to guests.

Dog fell increasingly out of favour after the Han dynasty. Philosophical Taoism, which rose in the late Han, saw dogs as unclean and consumption of dog was believed to harm efforts to live a simple life. During the Tang and Song dynasties dog consumption decreased further as the range of available meats increased and stories of faithful dogs and Buddhist ideas of reincarnation spread.

China has many ethnic minorities, each with its own traditions and culinary customs. But none of them can be described as dog-eating. In Islam dogs are regarded as unclean and so there is a religious prohibition on eating dog meat. Mongols are traditionally nomads and see dogs as guards and staunch companions. For Manchus eating dog is taboo, due to a legend that a dog saved the life of their forefather Nurhaci. The Tibetans are Buddhist and will not kill animals unnecessarily, and see dogs as loyal companions, so rarely eat them. And even the Zhuang people of Guangxi – where the Yulin “dog-meat festival” takes place - are not recorded in historical documents as being keen dog eaters.

All about the money

Local government officials are evaluated by their superiors on GDP growth. But remote and poor regions struggle to meet these growth targets, and the officials responsible are under considerable pressure. This gives rise to various odd money-making schemes, with cultural events designed to boost the local economy a popular choice.

Yulin, situated in China’s south-west border province of Guangxi, has never been a part of mainstream Chinese culture and has no famous historical figures or events to make use of. So people scratched their heads and came up with a ”dog-meat and lychees” tradition to attract tourists and investment.

Dog-eaters have, naturally enough, any number of reasons to explain the legitimacy of the practice, going as far to defend its legality by pointing out that anything not banned by law, is permitted. But have they thought that there are moral standards as well, higher than legal ones? Or our own standards as human beings, higher again?

Legal standards are designed to protect our basic security. Moral standards maintain our civilisation and ensure we do not tend towards the degenerate. And our own standards push us forward to achieve more.

While the dog-eating advocates argue the reasons for their case, have they considered the shock and horror of the ordinary people seeing dogs slaughtered in the streets of Yulin?

Now more than ever…

chinadialogue is at the heart of the battle for truth on climate change and its challenges at this critical time.

Our readers are valued by us and now, for the first time, we are asking for your support to help maintain the rigorous, honest reporting and analysis on climate change that you value in a 'post-truth' era.

我不认为吃狗肉就不正常，请问护狗者凭什么代表我们正常人去剥夺我们吃狗肉的权利？

I don’t think eating dog meat is not normal. May I ask why we, as normal people, have our right to eat dog meat taken by dog protectors?

I don’t think eating dog meat is not normal. May I ask why we, as normal people, have our right to eat dog meat taken by dog protectors? You must know that diet is one’s personal freedom, it is the most important of human rights, morality cannot oppose to a man’s natural instincts. To go against nature’s laws is to go against humanity.

即使不是主流文化，他们亦有权利维护传统

Even it's not mainstream, they have the right to maintain their tradition.

Humane slaughtering is a big problem now in China. It is not ethic to slaughter any animal on the street, including chicken, fish, quail and etc. But it only means we need to improve in the regulation of slaughtering. It dose not prove that consuming dog meat is unethical. This article mentioned that eating dog meat is not mainstream, but according to an interview I watched, people in Yulin has a tradition of eating dog meat. Even it's not mainstream, they have the right to maintain their tradition.

匿名 | Anonymous
15:1801.06.2015

Mr David

Disgusting practice to treat dogs this way (see cages) and to eat dog also..

匿名 | Anonymous
10:0411.08.2015

吃肉扯道德

獻祭的獻指的就是狗肉，然後的然指的是烤狗肉，吃個肉能扯文明道德？文藝復興工業革命時期所謂的文明國家一樣吃狗肉，文明倒退了？

匿名 | Anonymous
06:2830.10.2015

#StopTheTaboo

Some people can argue that eating dogs and cats is just like the consumption of cows, pigs and chickens. Technically this is true. But things get really different when you consider the moral side of the culture you are living in.

Please be considerate of what you eat, because what you are eating is not just an animal. It could be someone’s companion in life.

https://stopthetaboo.wordpress.com

匿名 | Anonymous
15:3925.04.2016

omg

this is cruel and no animal should ever be treated like this

匿名 | Anonymous
05:4821.11.2016

dog meat trade

Millions are denouncing the dog meat trade and China for allowing this to happen. China should be ashamed and its standing in the world is lessening. Business, travel and respect will be lost if China does not stop this. President Xi please stop the dog meat trade. You have the power to do this so we hope you make the right decision. Thank you.

匿名 | Anonymous
00:2517.03.2017

Disgusting chinese custom

This is a disgusting and sickening Chinese custom. It is estimated that 10,000 dogs died at the Yulin festival last year. These dogs are tortured and forced to endure the worst pain any living creature can endure for prolonged amount of time. That behavior is beneath human. Animals have souls and have the capacity to feel pain, joy, love, and fear. I would never want to extend the pain of any living creature. Except for the people who torture and eat dogs. I would torture the life right out of those sick people. The world is better off without them.

匿名 | Anonymous
13:2019.03.2017

Religion

Do the people of Yulin have a particular religion? If so, what is it?

What other ways can the people of Yulin make money without this "festival"?

If Americans were to stop purchasing all goods from China and eating at Chinese restaurants, would this have an impact on their government ending this barbaric practice?