General comments

Is having Place of residence as a defined element valuable enough that we would rather add Other place associated with the person as an additional element, rather than replacing Place of residence with it as proposed here? Maybe not, but the idea came to mind. --Robert J. Rendall 07:29, 28 August 2012 (PDT)

I like the idea of keeping Place of Residence, but including Other Place Associated as an additional element. I would think that Place of Residence would most likely be the primary way a place name would be associated with a person. -- Steve Kelley, CC:DA, Aug. 28, 2012

I don't understand why, in an RDA context, the term "other" is used throughout this proposal. If 9.11.1 is completely replaced as proposed, there is no "other" to contrast this with. I would support adding "other place" in addition to "place of residence" as both Robert & Steve have suggested above. - Glennan (PCC) 8/28/12

In this proposal 9.11 Other Place Associated with the Person is a place "other" than Place of Birth (9.8), Place of Death (9.9) and Country Associated with the Person (9.10). --Robert J. Rendall 11:48, 29 August 2012 (PDT)

We would like to retain the "Place of Residence" as an element, and add "Other Place Associated" as a separate element.
Min Zhang, MAGIRT Liaison, Aug. 29, 2012

With the wording provided, the instructions no longer seem to include Place of residence as a place that can be recorded.