Los Angeles vote could spell end for plastic grocery bags in the city

Two women wait for a bus after their grocery shopping in Los Angeles, Thursday, May 24, 2012. Now that the city of Los Angeles has taken the first step toward banning plastic bags, it appears the little utilitarian bags themselves may be headed for the trash heap of history. (AP Photo/Jae C. Hong)

Although it seems as if the single-use grocery bag, as it’s formally known, has been around forever, it wasn’t until 1977 that it was introduced to U.S. supermarkets, a move that prompted perhaps the most asked question of the following decade: “Paper or plastic?”

As the years went by and plastic won, people began to find myriad other makeshift uses for the little bags with the briefcase-like handles. You could line small trash cans with them, use one to scoop up dog doo and another to carry wet towels home from the beach. You could even use them to take pictures in the rain and not destroy your camera.

The discarded bags, though, had a nasty habit of washing up on beaches by the thousands, clogging storm drains and getting tangled in all sorts of stuff. That raised the ire of environmentalists, who have been on a ban-the-bag quest for years.

Now, with the city of Los Angeles taking the first step toward joining nearly four dozen other California municipalities in outlawing them, the humble little polyethylene bag may be headed for the trash heap of history.

San Francisco already bans the bag. So do San Jose, Long Beach, Berkeley and Malibu.

But LA, with nearly 4 million residents, goes through an estimated 2.7 billion plastic grocery bags a year, according to city officials, and environmentalists believe a ban here will have a huge impact and could even influence the rest of the country to follow suit.

“This is a gateway for sustainability,” said Leslie Tamminen of the Clean Seas Coalition, which pushed for the LA ban. “This is meant to change consumer behavior and expand consumer consciousness.”

So, using those handy little bags with the tie-shut handles for cleaning up after your dog or cat? Forget about it.

In Santa Monica, many people say they already have.

“I’ve had to buy a lot more of these,” laughed Dana Artress, pulling a little green pet-store doggie bag from her pocket as she walked her longhaired Chihuahua through Pacific Palisades Park.

Santa Monica banned the use of plastic grocery bags more than a year ago, as did Los Angeles County for its unincorporated areas, which is where Artress lives. And although she misses her free bags, she figures it’s a small sacrifice to make for the environment.

“Plastic has done a lot of good things,” she said. “But I don’t think we absolutely need it just to pick up our dog poop.”

Indeed, every dog walker, jogger or bicyclist who stopped to talk about plastic bags on a recent sunny afternoon in the park that overlooks the Pacific Ocean agreed wholeheartedly with her.

Oh sure, most of them admitted, they’ve forgotten their reusable bag. They’ve had to fumble with paper ones, which cost them a dime apiece. Some even precariously juggled their purchases free hand on the way back to the car.

But the tradeoff, they say, was worth it.

“We used to see just so much plastic bags and trash on the beach,” said David Schwartz of Santa Monica as he sat on a blanket overlooking the ocean with his wife, Jennifer, and their baby.

Schwartz’s best use for his grocery bags was collecting the discarded food that winds up in your kitchen sink.

The bags have also been known to be handy for carrying baby bottles and for stashing dirty diapers until you find a trash can. But Schwartz says he’s found freezer bags serve the same purpose and don’t seem to blow away in the wind, get tangled in trees or power lines or stuck in storm drains like grocery bags do.

The biggest thing now is remembering to bring those reusable cloth bags to the grocery store that he and his wife have collected since the plastic ban began.

“I’m still not used to it, I always forget,” Jennifer Schwartz acknowledged.

Under the proposal the City Council approved last week, Los Angeles will conduct an environmental impact study to see just what effect banning plastic grocery bags might have.

Then it will look at adopting a ban similar to Santa Monica’s, which would allow people who forget to bring their reusable bags to the store to buy paper ones for 10 cents apiece.

No time frame for all that was given, prompting industry officials who oppose the ban to note it’s still a long way from happening, and that they will argue that it would be a job killer for California while not significantly cleaning the environment.

Meanwhile, bans have begun to be adopted elsewhere. Every county in Hawaii has now banned plastic grocery bags, although all the bans won’t fully take effect across the state until 2015. The bags have also been banned in Portland, Ore, and in the Outer Banks region of North Carolina, although there is an effort under way in that state to repeal the ban.

In LA, the proposed ban wouldn’t completely eliminate plastic bags.

People who feel they just can’t survive without having a plastic grocery bag to entertain a cat with or slide over a broken parking meter could still obtain one by going to a takeout restaurant.

ADVISORY: Users are solely responsible for opinions they post here and for
following agreed-upon rules of civility. Posts and
comments do not reflect the views of this site. Posts and comments are
automatically checked for inappropriate language, but readers might find some
comments offensive or inaccurate. If you believe a comment violates our rules,
click the "Flag as offensive" link below the comment.

"Satire is a sort of glass, wherein beholders do generally discover everybody's face but their own." Jonathan Swift "I don't care to belong to a club that accepts people like me as members." Groucho Marx

They help in studying dust devil behavior, and help determine which way the wind is blowing, kind of like a wind sock at an airport.

I doubt that Texas will ban them, and I'm not sure with all the furniture, appliances, and full trash bags folks dump out in the country, that it would make a lot of difference as far as trashy vistas are concerned.

Some counties have garbage transfer stations to encourage citizens to dispose of their trash appropriately. That way it's less likely to end up in bar ditches and spread across the countryside.

Why do we have plastic bags? As I recall, it was the environmentalists who wanted us to quit cutting down trees to save the trees. So, some smart engineer came up with plastic bags.

Now, in California, the special interest groups are pointing out that the reusable bags contaminate the food and carry disease.

Back in the 1960's I was impressed when I saw European shoppers carry their push carts and mesh bags to the store when they went shopping. Several years ago, I was in France and everybody had plastic bags. We did not follow their example, they followed ours.

The article does not mention that if you want a paper bag, you will have to pay 10 cents per bag (To pay for a new tree perhaps).