You will come across the Drowned Sailor in Chapter 2. The Drowned Sailor has many of the same attacks as the Lost Souls you encounter earlier in the chapter.

Surprise Attack: The Drowned Sailor will disappear undergound and will eventually rush at you, slicing up with his weapon. When he does so, tap RB to dodge the attack. After the initial attack, he will drop back and release a second downward slicing attack. Again tap RB to dodge. After missing with the downward attack the Sailor will become stunned and he will be sitting on the ground. At this time you're free to use any weapon you please to attack him.

Bombs Away: The Sailor will appear with two bombs in his hands. Shoot at him with the pepper grinder, and the bomb will eventually blow up on him, stunning him and knocking him to the ground. Once on the ground, feel free to use any weapon you please to attack him.

Rinse and repeat. Dodge the attacks and before too long, you will down him easily, without taking any damage.

*If you don't succeed, hit the Start button and then choose Restart. It will take you to your last checkpoint, which is just before you encounter the Drowned Sailor.*

Lastly, you will know when you are encountering the Drowned Sailor instead of a Lost Soul. How? It tells you. Subtitles come up and say "Drowned Sailor."

If you're going to vote negative, please say why! Thanks!

*UPDATE* 7/18/11

Thanks to Sandwich Lady for the exact chapter reload to go to in case you miss the cheeve on your first playthrough."Just to add if you're reloading checkpoints then it is "Lost Souls Locker" on chapter 2 (one from last)"

There are 8 comments relating to this Solution | Please log in to comment on this solution.