Josephine Chez Dumonet

We are renting an apartment in Paris in October. We love to shop the markets and cook so we usually only eat out 2 times during the week. I was looking at JCD to book on our last night but can't seem to get a consensus of opinion. Any recent thoughts?Thanks!

And it's doubtful if you will get a clear and convincing argument for or against any resto in Paris. In any case, even if there is overwhelming approval, that's no guarantee that your experience will be memorable... every resto has a day when everything goes wrong.