This “smooth operator” is a dynamo that I can barely keep in stock. In fact I’ve got tons of customers who order nothing but this cigar. It’s easy to see why. MISTAKES give you premium flavor and terrific construction at a bargain price. They’re super-smooth, nice and mellow, made in a top-notch factory, and darn cheap. A beauty that’s simply a great everyday cigar. Have I mentioned how inexpensive they are? Made in Nicaragua for CI exclusively, MISTAKES are gorgeous cigars rolled with Connecticut-shade wrappers and Dominican mixed fillers. Trust me, if you like pleasant, smooth, well-constructed cigars with a perfect draw....not to mention a cheap every day price, then this one’s for you. Overall it’s an extraordinarily compelling cigar for the money.

I wasn't expecting much from a cigar called a "mistake", but I was very happy to find a mild, smooth, easily drawn cigar-especially at that price. I hope whoever makes these continues to make the same mistakes for a long time.

If you smoke a lot of cigars -- I order 11 bundles of 20 every 5 weeks for my son and myself -- this is a great cigar. They are cheap and they smoke as good or better than some of the premiums that I often buy. I would rate them higher except sometimes I get an order that has dried out and the wrapper starts coming off and the tobacco cracks when you cut it. If one cigar is bad usually the whole batch is. I have been buying these for years and I'll continue to buy them as long as the price doesn't go up.

Really have enjoyed these smokes. If these are the mistakes I need to order the real thing. These are perfect for yard work, quick smoke while using the BBQ or if your not so sure you have enough time to get a full smoke in, so you don't want to break out one of your pricier sticks. Smooth, good flavor and smokes all the way down. I had 1 that was somewhat of a tough draw so I gave this a 4 out of 5 but you cannot go wrong here for the price point. Will buy again.

This is my go-to everyday cigar. I will buy the premium brands when they go on special, but I normally will order a 20-pack of Mistakes, too. Great mild, tasty smoke (lots of smoke) with a very even burn. In fact, these cigars burn better than a lot of the premium brands.

I would have given this cigar 5 stars if you had the torpedoes in stock. You have been out of stock for that cigar for quite some time now. I had to settle for the Churchill's which to me are way too big.
With that being said these cigars are very mild and burn great.

CI's 'Original Cubans' Coronas are my go-to smokes, these looked similar so I thought I'd give them a try. Yep, I think that's what they were going for: Same size, same shape, same taste - only the mistakes don't burn as evenly. I guess that's the mistake (new guy rolling?). They canoe, at least the 3 that I've tried did. Yet the cost was the same as the 'Original Cubans', so I guess I paid for the new guy's mistakes.

I have usually buy the "49 Throwouts". Tried these, No comparison! Although they are we'll constructed and burn evenly with good draw, they lack the flavor. They're actually on the bitter side improving only slightly when 1/2 way through.

CI has really taken care of us with these “mistakes.” In 3 for 3 with well rolled mild cigars that are perfect for the back deck! Good burn, easy to smoke, and great aroma. All in a really affordable deal. Look I know once in a while the mistakes will be off somehow. I’m enjoying the dice roll though because I’m on a winning streak!

I am not a cigar expert but I know what I like, and I like this cigar. It is a mild cigar but not bland and without character, and it has an easy draw. I smoke good cigars, not names, and in my humble opinion this is good inexpensive cigar.

Super mild, good cigar for someone just starting cigar smoking. I like a mild to medium cigar and these were way to mild for me. Construction and burn were good. For the price I would highly recommend trying these.

All-around excellent smoke! Fairly smooth and slow-burning with consistent flavor -- I plan on buying these again (wish they would go "on sale" sometime soon)! I've also ordered C.I. Knockoffs of a few different varieties -- I like the "MISTAKES" better.

Macanudo knockoffs have been my "go to" cigar for years. When it came time to refill my humidor they were out of stock... (and I see 2 weeks later they are still out of stock). So after checking the reviews, I tried these Mistakes. The name is probably not well chosen, because one does not pay money for 'Mistakes". Though the cost was a little more, I have found a new favorite. Quality control on the Macanudo knockoffs was less than desireable on my last order: while many were good, too many had an uneven burn...and an inconsistent, sometimes bitter taste. I have encountered far fewer inconsistencies with these "Mistakes". The vast majority are smooth, mild and very enjoyable to the very end.

have been a Vegas Gold smoker for years, tried Mistakes Robusto, WOW !! what a great cigar. Taste, even burn, great draw, how can you not like them. They are my new every day cigar at a great price. I have compared them to other top named cigars and keep coming back and will stay with Mistakes. Only one wish! would like to see a bigger cigar maybe 52 or bigger Thank You

I'm shocked at how good this cigar is! I'd pretty much given up on bundle and "budget" cigars. My philosophy is quality over quantity. For some reason (can't remember why) I decided to give these sticks a shot. And am I glad I did! Outstanding construction and performance. I've burned through quite a few and they have all performed like a high end premium. I love the flavor profile (light toast and coffee with cream). I like them so much I just bought another bundle. And just between you and me, I have been choosing these over my stash of Montecristos!

the only mistake I see here is that I didn't order more. I don't know much about cigars and have tried quite a few in this price range. I must tell you if you like mild cigars for a good price these are the ones to buy. I'm sure there are others and everyones taste is different but these are on the top of my list

I just finished one of these knock offs and have to say it was a smooth smoke all the way with nice ash. I wouldn’t call it a go to cigar but then thats just not what its purported to be so thumbs up for what its worth.

I'm disappointed in these cigars.
I have only tried five of them and every one was terrible.
The wrappers split and peel off, the cigar burns crooked and will die out in a few seconds if not puffed on constantly.
Very poorly made cigar.

this is my go to smoke, as a man of less distinct taste. It's a nice, mild cigar with maybe a bit of bite, burns true and is is, well cheap like me. And hey nothing wrong with a cheap cigar; it lets the other ones rest for something special. Seriously these are consistently good and well worth checking out.

Love this smooth , creamy corona. The easy draw provides a lot of smoke with minimal effort. The Ecuadorian Connecticut wrapper allows for fairly pleasant taste. I have another brand corona which is very similar to the Mistake both in price and enjoyment. Did order two bundles of Mistakes Robusto and very pleased with this cigar, though I prefer a smaller ring size. For the money, it's tough to find other cigars any better than these Mistakes. JR Alternatives match the Mistakes for price and performance for me. Both great cigars for the cost

A very aptly named cigar. My mistake was buying it. I have always gotten great value and great cigars from CI; this was definitely not one of them. I am going to give them away anonymously. I think I'll stick with brand names going forward.

Just got my first shipment of Mistakes robusto and tried a couple over the weekend. A good mild smoke for early in the day or just hanging out with a cold one. They have a fairly good burn and for the price you can't go wrong here. So far so good! I will definitely be purchasing again when I run out.

I found these cigars too tightly rolled, a blocked draw and uneven burn on several of the ones I smoked. I had to toss one that burned up on entire side of the body. They do have a nice aroma and taste, however, but I don't think I will order these again.

These have been good firm cigars with an easy draw; good for work and cheap enough to share with co workers. They have gotten me free lunch more than once.

RM of Jasper, AL

I'm more a fan of medium cigars, but these weren't bad for a mild cigar. I do have to agree with another review that they are soft and burn quickly. For the price, there are better options available.

KM of MIDLAND, PA

A good buy for the buck. Medium strength, snug wrap, a nice smoke. Will buy more.

JP of west milford, NJ

Excellent cigar for the price!

KF of Bluffs, IL

I have a humidor (the secret to all cigars as far as better flavor) and everything humidifies for 20 days and I just gotta tell you...I have a bunch of expensive cigars,
(I used to smoke Cohibas), but I keep going back to 'Mistakes' and I cannot believe how good they are! I don't know why, I don't know how to describe it, but they are just really nice if you like a very mild, nice tasting, cigar!

FJ of Christiansted, VI

I ordered a bundle of the churchills. All I can say is that these things are everything they're advertised to be and more! Nice mild-medium smoke, good flavor, VERY solid construction on every single stick in my first bundle. Considering the price, I put these in my top five and would definitely choose them over much, much more expensive sticks. I love 'em, simple as that. Second bundle is on it's way!

SR of Waverly, IL

Great cigar that's all I order.

MB of granite city, IL

These are surprisingly good cigars! I don't have the gift for words that many of the writers on this website possess, so I'll just stop by saying I'd definitely buy these again.

JP of ST. PETERS, MO

These cigars are a great value. They are one of my everyday go to's and you can't beat the price for a torpedo.

MR of Rancho Santa Marg, CA

A very tasty cigar at a very good price. You won't go wrong with these.

RS of KEIZER, OR

I must be losing my taste for these cigars. I am a confirmed mild smoker, but this latest batch has left me un-interested. Taste is a little spicy, aroma is good, but this batch has had an uneven smoke and seems a little soft. For the price, it's still a good smoke, but I'm just not liking them like I used to.

WK of Alexandria, VA

Amazing cigar for the price! Very smooth, medium flavorful smoke, even burn. Great buy will buy again.

SW of Granger, IN

Not as good as used to be, but still a good cigar.

RM of Las Vegas, NV

These are a very tasty smoke ... very mild ... BUT, NOT well constructed. I have smoked only 1 of the 20 I bought, but it was very soft and loose and several others feel to be the same. Maybe some time in the humi will help. Good starter smoke.

SC of LACEY, WA

I'm kind of new to the cigar thing. I like the mild-med. cigars, and a friend told me to try your MISTAKES, and since my first draw on one I have to say I am very pleased, ok happy!! Nice stick and will be ordering more for my rotation.
Thanx CI

RM of Manchester, NJ

Purchased the Robustos. Nice and smooth smokes. Found them to be more on the mild side but still very enjoyable everyday smoke.

DP of Northford, CT

....All I want in a cigar is a nice mild taste, good draw, and good burn. MISTAKES fit the bill quite nicely. I like the Churchills a little better than the Torpedos, but I've finally found a great go-to cigar at a great price. I've read that description a hundred times on other cigars, but this is the first time I've found one that delivers every time so far.

DA of Dracut, MA

A good smoke....me likey....!!!

JM of Lindenwold, NJ

The Mistake Corona is my every day, go-to cigar. Its got a great burn, great taste, fits well in the hand, just perfect for Sunday afternoon grilling! Just make sure you let these fine babies settle in the humidor for a week or two before you smoke 'em--you won't be disappointed. One of the best cigars for the money in my book.

PC of NAUGATUCK, CT

how are these mistakes when they are so meant to be? Smooth, full of flavor, bursting with plumes of sweet mellow smoke... these are hands down the best day to day yard gars on CI. Thanks again CI! This is such an amazing deal!

JL of Middle Village, NY

I've smoked close to 200 of these cigars and have had only 2 duds ! They have a great draw, a nice even burn, and pack a decent flavor. I like to slip on a band from one of the 'super premiums', hand them out to some friends, then listen to them pontificate on the virtues of 'such' brand. Never ceases to make me grin ! This is probably the most consistent of any brand I've smoked. I keep at least 20 in my box at all times.

SC of Tiverton, RI

For the price a very nice smoke. Good taste even burn. My only complaint would be inconsistent draw, either to loose or too tight. Only every other one draws just right, but for the price, I can't really complain.

MP of Ocean Shores, WA

I've been a customer of CI's for over a year now & tried a variety of different brands over that time.Came across the MISTAKES & let me tell you that these cigars have a nice taste & a perfect burn,& basically that is what I have in my humidor.Awsome cigar for very little price.
Awsome job CI.........

RB of Marlborough, MA

Okay, so I admit to bad-mouthing these initially. I got a bundle of the robustos 8 months ago, and found them to be a bit on the sour side; not my cup of tea. So, I let them sit (neglected and forgotten) in a baggy at the bottom of my cooler, until they caught my eye this morning. I had one on the drive in to work this morning, and nubbed it. I'm not saying this is an excellent cigar, but for what it is, it performed extremely well: draw was perfect, burn was perfect, flavor was actually good with no longer any sourness that I could detect, volume of smoke was ridiculously good. If you purchase these, let them sit. I most likely will not buy these again, but I promise I will bad-mouth them no longer.

TT of Vancouver, WA

Ordered my first bundle of these a week ago and smoked one while loading the humidor. Great draw and flavor. A good and tasty smoke that will be a regular in the rotation, particularly for golf outings at a price that you can surely stand to pass a few around.

AG of Americus, GA

Ordered a bundle a couple of months ago, thought they were pretty good. Order the second bundle, and was very suprised! They were as good as the first bunch! Now, this is all I order. Very good smoke, burns evenly, and does not get "hot" as it burns down. All I have received are moist when I receive them. I am impressed!

RB of Knoxville, TN

Bought a bundle of these and quite frankly I am disappointed. Burn evenly but quickly and smell rather good, but taste is very mediocre and these puppies get soft really fast. I shoulda spent a little more and bought some decent smokes. I am sure my cigar-ignorant golf buddies will appreciate these soon-to-be "freebies" handed to them even if I do not.

CJ of Averill Park, NY

I help run a cigar club at Fire HQ were I'm assigned and we try to stick to a 2 to 3 dollar price point.Thanks to CI I'm able to get some great cigars and keep the troops happy. I tried these "MISTAKES" a couple years ago and recalled they were pretty good so I ordered a bundle for the club.those schmucks loved them!!!now I have to keep the humi stocked with em, makes sense cuz one look at my shift and you'll see we look like GODS MISTAKE!! but we get the job done just like these cigars.thanks CI !!!

RL of Bridgeport, CT

A smooth and flavorful smoke with a nice, even burn. Really rich, creamy smoke. I nurtured these babies in the box for a good two months before smoking and they were outstanding...and you just can't beat the price.

MJ of Chicago, IL

Just got the Mistake robustos. Man they are good. Really glad I pulled the trigger and made the purchase. Really well constructed and generates tons of smoke. Best of all they taste and smell awesome.

KM of San Diego, CA

Well I tried giving these several tries, but each time it seemed like I had taken a big lick off the desert plains...

CA of Capistrano Beach, CA

Based on the reviews I decided to try these. I mostly smoke RP, Padron, Don Pepin, etc. I was looking for something decent to hand out to friends when they stop by. I got tired of giving out premium cigars to people who can't appreciate them. Well, I tried one of these last night and I was pretty much blown away. Mellow and silky smooth the whole way through. Nice draw and ash the entire distance. I highly recommend these any day.

D of LBoston, MA

Very nice smoke! MISTAKES are no mistake!

LD of Rockwood, TN

There is no B.S. here. I have smoked very expensive cigars over the years and for the past year i have been smoking the CI Mistakes.
I will put this cigar up against any of those expensive cigars.
Perfect draw,smooth taste,and you can put that cigar down and come back to it several minits later and it is still burning.
Please dont raise the price C.I.

JC of irvine, CA

Wow. Great price, Great cigar.(CI Mistakes) I was surprised. This will be one that refills the humidor. Can't go wrong here. Enjoy Boys.

PM of Surprise, AZ

I just received my latest shipment and have smoked about ten of them. Damn good everyday smokes, which has always been my experience with this brand. In fact, I'm heading outside to my patio to toast one right now. I'd recommend "Mistakes" to any cigar guy who just wants a plain yet satsifying smoke to soothe his soul at the end of a long and hectic day.

RO of Alvarado, TX

I tried a bundle of the "Mistakes" line of cigars after reading all of the other reviews. I have to say overall this cigar is my all time favorite for the money. I've tried most of the premium mild Dominican cigars out there and I keep coming back to my go to "mistake". Well done CI!

RC of Temecula, CA

Mistakes ? Why do you call these Cigars mistakes.
Well, I have smoked better, but I can't remember any cigar I have ever injoyed smoking, better for such a resonal price. Thats why I look forward to receiving your monthly Catalog,there is always something interesting to read about Cigars from around the Planet.
Your writing Staff is great. I love sitting on my terrace, smoking a great Cigar and reading your Catalog. They are informant, and humorous. Great job guys, your why I love C I International.
I Thank You.....

JG of Wilton, NY

Mistakes?? The only mistake here is the one I made not ordering these sooner. A great cigar at a great price!!

JM of Cumbola, PA

I was shocked when I fired the first one up (MISTAKES). From the review you tend to get the idea that this is a lightweight cigar. But these are more like welterweights with some spice.
Very smooth and nice.

BV of Columbia, TN

Don't buy this cigar (MISTAKES). I do not want it to be "Found". This cigar has great consistency, both taste and smoking pleasure. It leaves a pleasant aftertaste, unlike many I have smoked. It's a keeper but just for us guys that know about it. Okay?
CM

CM of Ukiah, CA

Don't try these cigars (MISTAKES) because they are cheap try them because they are great cigars! They are as smooth as they come and very similar in flavor to Monti Cristo or Buterra. Don't let the name put you off!

TW of Richmond, VA

I love a good cigar while I'm relaxing and usually spend $4 to $8 per stick to find something satisfying. It was your "As smooth as they come!" remark about MISTAKES that caught my eye,(I like a smooth cigar), so I tried them. WOW! Was I surprised. This cigar is as good as any $5 cigar I've smoked. Keep'em coming friends!
EB of Berwick, Pa.

EB of Berwick, PA

Wow! Definitely change the name (MISTAKES)! By no means a MISTAKE. Very pleasant taste, VERY smooth, even burn all the way down. A definite every day cigar.

DF of Swartz Creek, MI

Can I just say----I love them (MISTAKES)!! Haven't been this excited since I smoked a macanudo. Taste, draw, ash...all perfect. Will be ordering these as a standard shipment. Well done!!!

DK of Mt. Holly Springs, PA

After only two cigars from my first order,a recent second order of torpedoes (MISTAKES) is making it's case for becoming my every-other day cigar!

JD of Elgin, IL

These cigars (Mistakes) are certainly not a "mistake"! I like every thing about the torpedos. The construction, the color, the draw, the smooth and consistant taste, and last but certainly not least, the price. Excellent cigar for the money!

RH of Springfield, IL

Just received an order of Henrik Kelner "Mistakes", the torpedo size . This is the second time that I've ordered and I just love 'em ! I just think for the money that they're the best cigar. Don't tell anybody how good they are because I don't want the price to go up. Thank you!

JC of South Bend, IN

I've enjoyed these cigars (MISTAKES) Churchills so much so have re-ordered several times. Had my brother-in-law try and hooked him. He now buys them himself. Taste like a more expensive Dominican (LaGloria). Sometimes they have "soft" spots but that doesn't affect the way they burn or taste.

RB of Ellington, CT

I normally don't smoke much, but these cigars (MISTAKES) were so good, I went through them in no time. They all burned perfectly, and I enjoyed the taste of almost all of them. I think maybe there were one or two that didn't taste great in four bundles. They taste better than many 4 buck a piece sticks out there.

AM of Buffalo Grove, IL

A great value cigar in the robusto (Mistakes). It has all the qualities, easy draw, even burn, good consistent flavor and decent construction. The after taste will sometimes linger but that's the tradeoff for all the good in it.

MISTAKES Cigar Staff Reviews

Gonz

Preference:

Words To Live By…"I've never met someone with a lit cigar in-hand and two in-pocket that I would not call friend." - Gonz

"MISTAKES"

Gonz

Do I look like a guineau-pig? Well, I sure feel like one. This month, I've been given the "pleasure" to try a brand that got messed up. Yes, this thing was destined for the dumpster and it gets put on my desk. Gee thanks!

You can read the story of how we got these by clicking the link above. In short, it's designed to be a Knock-off of the Dominican Montecristo in flavor and appearance. Unfortunately, they goofed (b/c we could really use an alternative to the high-priced Montecristo.) It's a a mixed-filler cigar with a slightly burned CT-shade leaf (that looks like a Sumatra instead), loosely filled, but pretty. Yes, I said pretty. It's not offensive in appearance, the name is offensive - Montecristo "Mistakes". I can't smoke a friggin mistake. With great hesitation, and a mean-ass look from the higher-ups, I look forward to this like I look forward to preparing my tax returns.

I'm trying the torpedo "Mistake" at 6" and about 50 ring. It resembles the Montecristo No. 2 in shape-only. The wrapper is somewhat silky like the Montecristo, but it's too damn dark. It lights up like a torch - keep your arms and legs inside the moving tram, this is going to be quite a ride. The cigar is lit in 2 seconds MAX. Whoah!!! The smoke that bellows from this baby just smoked out my office mate. Sorry Larry - mucho smoko! I wasn't expecting it, my office cube now looks likes a head shop. I could really use a lava lamp to add to the ambience. Anyway, I digress.

The smoke is fulfilling (and a little overwhelming), but quite easy going in flavor. The burn is perfect - dark grey ash that holds surprisingly well for a mixed-filler cigar. The flavor holds its own, but won't knock your socks off. It burns fast and smooth. With the ridiculously low temperatures we've had up here in the Northeast, you can get in and out without freezing your butt off. I warn you, don't light this inside, your wife will flip - I'm not kidding about the smoke. The taste leaves a slight tingle in the back of the tongue. I can't identify it and it's not offensive - it actually adds a bit to the flavor.

I can't emphasize enough how well this thing burns. I only have 1/4 left and it has held very well. Other than the loose-fill, you would never know this is a mixed-filler cigar. It's a shame this was a mistake. We could sell these for $60 or $70 a bundle if it wasn't a "mistake." I need to talk to management, we need to change the name.

I just found out they're selling these for about $30 a bundle. That's a good deal. Since I lost my shirt last week at poker, I'm going to bring a bundle of these, take off the bands, and tell them their Cuban Montecristos. They'll never know the difference. Don't think of this brand as a "Mistake" and you'll be pleasantly surprised.

Oh, how do I summarize thee:- mucho smoko! Don't smoke this in the house- silky, Sumatra-looking Connecticut-shade wrapper- quick smoke- good theory, bad execution- well worth a $1.50 per stick

CI hasn’t become the world’s leading cigar retailer by accident. We’re committed to industry-leading prices, exceptional service, the biggest selection, and overwhelming charm. No nonsense, just great cigars delivered fast, fresh, and discounted….beware of imitators.