I don't think Reyes really has 20HR potential which puts him well below MCab in my book

Doesnt have 20 HR potential? Forget potential, he pretty much did it last year. Not to mention his HR's have been steadily increasing each year and hes only 23!!! The sky is the limit for this kid, I coud see 25 HR's this year easily.

Um you do know that before this year Reyes highest home run total was 7 right? Year before his AVG was .273, outside of stolen bases his numbers jumped across the board.

MCabs OBP SLG and AVG have gone up year by year. While his home run total was a bit less this year he also had around 60 less ab's.

MCCab is the better hitter for now and for the future,

“Never argue with a idiot, because first they will bring you down to their level. Then beat you with experience.”