Quilted Northern Ultra Soft & Strong Toilet Paper

Though it wasn't a top performer in any category, this 2-ply Quilted Northern toilet paper was thick and stronger than many when wet. On the downside, this also meant that it didn't break down in dissolvability tests. When it came to absorbency and softness, it had average scores: it wasn't terrible, but wasn't great.

How We Tested: We evaluated each type of toilet paper in absorbency, dissolvability, softness, thickness, wet strength, dry strength, perforation tear strength and visual quality tests in the lab. We then had consumer testers blindly rate them for softness both in a comparison test and during use.