Whitewashed pine floors

I am trying to convince DH that we should get rid of the carpet in the bedrooms and refurbish the original Victorian floorboards. Since we are not keen on bright yellow knotty wood we are likely to uncover, I am thinking of having the floors whitewashed.

If you have whitewashed pine floors, I'd be grateful if you could share your experience both in terms of having this job done, as well as living with such floor:- Did you have to move out when the floors were being sanded/ stained / varnished or you can stay at home? How long does it take per room?- What's the advantage of oil-based vs water-based whitewashing? The chap who will be doing our floors will use oil stain and then a two-pack varnish. From what I've read, oil may give a yellow tint and is generally more toxic and it takes longer to finish the job. Your experience?- How durable is whitewash? Does it wear out in higher traffic parts of the room?- Is wooden floor a good idea for a nursery? DD is 10 months old and seems to find carpet lint an irresistible snack... On the other hand, carpet absorbs the shock when she plops. - Will it look weird if some rooms have wooden floors and others, as well as the hallway, are carpeted?

We are moving into the house in ten days time (yay!) and I really want to have the bedroom floors done before putting in the furniture. At the same time I am concerned that trying to unpack and settle in with a baby in a house being sanded and stinking of varnish may not be wise and we should postpone it until we go on holiday and the house if empty. I need to decide NOW!

Sorry I don't understand this. Actual whitewash will flake and wear away in dust when you walk on it. Ther might be a white treatment I don't know about, of course.

A few points, hth.

Sanding the floor is a very dusty and dirty job and the dust will spread through the house.

Pine will intrinsically go yellow over time, although you can dye it with a darker colour to hide it. If you put a light-coloured dye on a dark-coloured wood, the dark colour will show through. You can use paint which will cover though. If the floor has been taken up for plumbing or electrical work, you may have damaged or mis-matched boards which you will want to correct if on show. It is preferable to use countersunk screws rather than nails to fix any boards above an electrical or plumbing item (including ceiling roses) so that they can in future easily be taken up without damage.

Floorboards are much noisier than carpets, especially for anyone underneath and your neighbours unless you have a detached house. Fluids will go through the cracks between the boards and drip into the void below or stain the ceiling. This may be unhygenic.

Floorboards do have splinters; even if you sand the tops well, bare feet can get splinters off the edges at the joints, or when there is any damage.

Satin or matt PU varnish is hard-wearing and will cure within a day. Avoid gloss varnishes which are known in the trade as "toffee-apple" due to their unnatural appearance.

We've just done ours. It took DP 4 days to do 4 rooms, we did have the ghastly, sticky bitumen stuff all around the edges which was what took so long to get off. We did them before moving in to our new house. Sanding is a VERY dusty job, so far far better to do it before moving furniture in if possible. We used osmo polyx White tint on the floors upstairs, no odour and made if natural stuff, so much so that apparently you can eat it.

They do seem very noisy and echoy compared to our old house that had carpet, but sure one everything is unpacked and a few rugs are down it'll seen better.

Don't know v much about this but I think one alternative to painting the floorboards is to bleach them. Won't wear in high traffic areas in the same way.

You could consider putting soundproofing under the boards to counteract the noise factor (however, the most effective soundproofing involves detaching all the boards from the joists and putting padding between, so it's not a small job).

Minipie - bleaching or liming is what I initially had in mind but I think it is used mostly for oak whilst white washing is for pine. The effect is similar, ie it does not look painted, you can see the grain of wood but the wood looks, well, bleached, tinted.

Soundproofing underneath is a good idea but at this stage it's way too much, I am after a low-hanging fruit (minimum effort for maximum impact plus something that's easier to do before all the furniture is in)...