Search This Blog

These posts come from visits to reservations and urban-Indian communities. Look for my book, "American Apartheid: The Native American Struggle for Self-Determination and Inclusion," coming In spring 2018.

Conflict Flares Over Sioux Voting Rights

Not good enough, said Crow Creek Sioux Tribe Chairman Brandon Sazue, when the state of South Dakota and Buffalo County revealed that Crow Creek reservation voters would have minimal ballot-box access in 2018. The county’s auditor, who is tasked with conducting the election—renting space, training pollworkers and the like—had asked the state for federal Help America Vote Act funding to cover just 11 days across both the primary and general elections. That is far cry from the 94 days available in other parts of the state, Sazue pointed out.

Native voters have long struggled to get to the polls in Buffalo County. In 2004, a federal court ordered the county to redistrict after an ACLU lawsuit showed that its three commission districts were grossly gerrymandered. Almost 1,500 Natives were packed into one district, while a few hundred additional county residents, Native and white, were split between two more. This allowed whites to control the local government and its resources.

Crow Creek Sioux tribal member Donita Loudner, shown above, is one of three Buffalo County commissioners. She said that the commission, which is the county’s governing body, had not been fully consulted in crafting the election plan. “I learned from the newspaper what Crow Creek would have during the 2018 elections,” Loudner said.

Buffalo County auditor Elaine Wulff disagreed. She said she had “followed the commission’s lead” and “discussed it with the commissioners ahead of time” before requesting Help America Vote Act (HAVA) money for the Crow Creek polling place. When Wulff was asked whether the three county commissioners had in fact met, decided on a number of days for the Crow Creek satellite office, and conveyed that information to her for the HAVA request, she responded, “They approved what I did.”

The voting plan for Crow Creek is currently being reviewed, according to commission chair Lloyd Lutter, who, like Wulff, is not a tribal member: “It’s under discussion. No decision has been made. We are now waiting for a letter from the tribal chairman to tell us what they want.” Loudner confirmed that a letter was on the way.

South Dakota’s rules for disbursing federal HAVA funds allow such plans to be revisited in “extraordinary circumstances,” according to Jason Williams, spokesperson for the secretary of state, or chief elections official.

Providing equal voting rights in Buffalo County should be simple, said South Dakota state senator and Senate minority leader Troy Heinert, a Rosebud Sioux Tribe member. “Buffalo County is one of three counties in the state that are pre-approved for HAVA funding, so this should not be a problem. The money is there.”

Access to early voting and late registration at the county’s satellite office on Crow Creek—not just in the distant white-inhabited county seat—is a significant factor in ensuring equal rights, Heinert added: “We are a large rural state, and some people have limited ability to travel long distances to vote. Everyone should have an equal chance to participate in our democracy.”

Involvement in the political system is critical, Loudner added: “The county can’t say to our people, ‘This is what you get; take it or leave it.’ We have a voice.” She went on to observe, “After the lawsuit, our commission district boundaries were redrawn, and we were under federal monitoring for 10 years. Monitoring was limited, though—just on election day, and it was over in 2014—so all these behind-the-scenes problems have continued.”

Two Buffalo County commissioners and the auditor are up for re-election in 2018. Whether candidates will emerge to challenge any of them is not yet known.

Popular Posts

This article appeared on In These Times' magazine's Rural America website in September 2015 and was updated in November.
This isn’t the “new” world for the Western Shoshone. And their West was never “wild.” It is a place of deep cultural connections to a homeland that at one time extended across portions of Idaho, Nevada, Utah and California. For more than 10,000 years, they have met to gather a type of white flint and to practice their ceremonies in what is today called the Tosawihi Quarries, or alternately the Tosawihi Complex, a stretch of northern Nevada.

“That stone is very sacred to us,” says Joe Holley, seen below in Tosawihi. He is a tribal council member and former chairman of the Battle Mountain Band of the Te-Moak Western Shoshone, one of several federally recognized tribes with links to the area. “We use it every day and have done so for millennia, for tools, ceremonies and healing. The stone, the water, the entire place is sacred.”
The word Tosawihi means White Kn…

This article first appeared on Indian Country Today Media Network in September 2016. Chairmen Bobby Sanchez and Vinton Hawley,
of the Walker River and Pyramid Lake Paiute tribes, respectively, are
plaintiffs in a major new voting-rights lawsuit, filed in federal court
in Nevada. They are joined by three military veterans from their communities:
Ralph Burns, Robert James and Johnny Williams, Jr. “We know that these veterans have already paid for the
equality we seek for all our people,” the two chairmen announced in a joint
public statement. The lawsuit follows the rejection of tribal requests to
Nevada’s chief elections official, Secretary of State Barbara Cegavske and two
counties for full access to national elections, including reservation satellite
offices for registration and early and Election Day voting. According to the
plaintiffs, Walker River
Paiute Tribe voters must currently travel 70-some miles round trip to register
and early vote in the Mineral County seat, while Pyramid L…

This story first appeared on Indian Country Today Media Network in May 2015. For an August 2015 update, go here.

A federal judge has shredded claim after claim by a South Dakota county that overlaps the Pine Ridge Indian Reservation but will not guarantee tribal members on-reservation voter registration and in-person absentee voting (sometimes dubbed “early voting”). In future, Jackson County wants all residents to continue traveling to the courthouse in the county seat, Kadoka, to access the full range of voting services. Tribal members, including Oglala Sioux Nation vice president and lead plaintiff Tom Poor Bear, sued. They say the county’s stance violates the Voting Rights Act and the Fourteenth Amendment, guaranteeing equal rights. The county defendants came back with a motion that the suit, Poor Bear v. The County of Jackson,be dismissed. Judge Karen Schreier turned the county down, repeatedly opining that the plaintiffs had offered sufficient grounds to move the suit forward, whil…

I am a long-time writer on human rights and culture, with a focus on Native American issues. Recognition for my articles includes the Richard LaCourse Award for Investigative Reporting from the Native American Journalists Association, of which I am an associate (non-Native) member, and numerous other grants and awards from major journalism organizations. I am a contributing writer for publications covering politics and the arts. During two decades in magazines, I was an editor at national consumer magazines.