integrated graphics and UI speed

Do Macs with dedicated graphics memory and discrete circuity (ie not integrated on board) have snappier general OS user interface? Or does the difference in graphics speed only come to bear in particularly graphics intensive applications like games?

In order to answer your question we need to have a "relative to" added.

Is the UI faster on a MacPro because of it's dedicated card? Yes, possibly - would it be faster if the macBook had dedicated ram? Who really knows.

I have a Powermac G5 1.8 and the user interface is just as snappy as on my Macbook which has integrated graphics. The power of the graphics isn't actually as bad as I thought when people were moaning on these boards. I can play all my games that I couldn't actually play on the iBook I had before it. The GMA is a pretty good chip!

It used to be the case that no matter what, integrated graphics were always very slow. However, these days system RAM is a lot faster than it was in those days. So I do not know how fast or slow modern integrated graphics are. Is the graphics hardware the same between MiniMac and MacBook? Do these machines use dual-channel ram that doubles the bandwidth or anything?

The slowest thing for integrated graphics is vertex processing (it doesn't do it; it just hands it to the cpu), but a 2D interface shouldn't have much of that; I'd expect it to basically depend on resolution vs. available memory.

Am I going to be A-ok safe for a while from amount-of-ram UI slow-downs with 1GB of RAM or does Tiger like to have more than that somewhat commonly? And if so, do u think 1GB will still be plenty when 10.5 and 10.6 come around?

Am I going to be A-ok safe for a while from amount-of-ram UI slow-downs with 1GB of RAM or does Tiger like to have more than that somewhat commonly? And if so, do u think 1GB will still be plenty when 10.5 and 10.6 come around?

Click to expand...

Depends entirely on what programs and data you open, and how many at one time. Not possible to guarantee you AOK. 1 Gb is fine for Tiger and 1 or 2 apps, 2 Gb is best for graphic programs, digital audio, digital video and for running a bunch of programs at once.

MacRumors attracts a broad audience
of both consumers and professionals interested in
the latest technologies and products. We also boast an active community focused on
purchasing decisions and technical aspects of the iPhone, iPod, iPad, and Mac platforms.