Step 6: Begin spraying the mixture with witch hazel and begin using your hands to form cookies. You want to pack them tightly so that the do not crumble.

Step 7: Finally, add the edible eyeballs and allow to set up.

Your Monster Cookies are now ready to use!

Natures Garden is not responsible for the performance of any of the recipes provided on our website. Testing is your responsibility. If you plan to resell any recipes we provide, it is your responsibility to adhere to all FDA regulations. If there are ingredients listed in a recipe that Natures Garden does not sell, we cannot offer any advice on where to purchase those ingredients.