A thorough look at the personal effects laid out on the yellow blanket supplies a bevy of evidence. Rummage through the handbag to find movie lot job and upper half of torn letter. Examine the body, specifically the head and the victim's right hand for the vagrancy and missing ring clues. The blood spatter on the train indicates the point of trauma from a standing position. The matchbook points to a new location of interest.

New Objective: Investigate Railyard Crime Scene

↓

Speak to the coroner.

↓

Peruse the evidence in the area.

↓

There are two witnesses to speak to, but speak to the African trainyard worker first to note a quick detail.

↓

Speak to Ferdinand for the lipstick clue.

↓

Witness: John Ferdinand Jamison

↓

Interference with evidence: Truth

↓

Discovery of victim's body: Doubt

↓

Make a phone call for address on Levine's Liquor.

↓

Clues To Find:Book
Liquor purchase

The bowling pin introduces a new location to investigate: Rawling's Bowling. Open the cover of the book for the true owner of the book.

New Objective: Investigate Levine's Liquor Store

↓

Follow the shopkeeper to the back.

↓

Go through Evelyn's belongings.

↓

Person of Interest: Robbins

↓

Contact with victim: Truth

↓

Relationship with victim: Truth

↓

Knowledge of McCaffrey: Doubt

↓

New Objective: Investigate Mensch's Bar

↓

Ask the patrons about Evelyn.

↓

It's possible to trace a connection from Grosvenor to Evelyn by visiting Levine's first. Don't provoke Grosvenor's snobby attitude anymore than you need to get info on victim last seen.

Person of Interest: Grosvenor McCaffrey

↓

Criminal history: Doubt

↓

Relationship with victim: Lie

↓

Present evidence: Book

↓

Around this time you'll be asked to return to Central Station for an impromptu meeting with the captain and the coroner.

The jovial elderly lady introduces you to James Tiernan if you don't already have a profile on him.

New Objective: Investigate Rawling's Bowling Alley

↓

Another runner.

↓

Chase down Tiernan and turn him in for questioning.

↓

At this point, there are some fingers pointing at McCaffrey, so the order is put out to snoop around his place. Pick up any phone and get his full address.

There's going to be a lot of going back and forth between the two suspects. Interview Tiernan first to gain an additional question with McCaffrey and new ammo in the form of Tiernan's accusation. In return, McCaffrey fires back with McCaffrey's accusation. After the interview with McCaffrey, the telephone icon appears. Making the call brings to light a crucial piece of evidence against McCaffrey: McCaffrey's criminal record.

Suspect: James Tiernan

↓

Relationship with victim: Lie

↓

Grosvenor's testimony of "victim last seen" exposes Tiernan's lie.

↓

Victim's book found: Doubt

↓

Alibi for James Tiernan: Lie

↓

Show James the liquor purchase clue.

New line of questioning that appears only after speaking to McCaffrey after speaking to Tiernan first.

↓

Access to murder weapon: Doubt

↓

Events prior to murder: Lie

↓

Present: McCaffrey's accusation.

↓

Suspect: Grosvenor McCaffrey

↓

Alibi for McCaffrey: Lie

↓

Present evidence: Torn letter

↓

Access to tire iron: Lie

↓

Tiernan's accusation is strong enough evidence of that.

↓

The Military Service question appears after going back and forth between Tiernan and McCaffrey and acquiring McCaffrey's criminal record. This then solidifies the case against McCaffrey.