There is this guy in my league that constantly offers me bad trades for my top closers. For example, he has continually offered Shields + Fuentes for my JJ Putz, and there is no way that I am accepting that.

I am very interested in his Gio Gonzales. Do you think that offering Jon Rauch and Jeremly Hellickson is a fair trade for Gio?

Yeah, I'd try that. Rauch is most likely not getting a boatload of saves this year, and Gio is a favorite breakout candidate. Hellickson is pretty stellar but I like him more long-term. I assume this is redraft and in redraft I like this deal.