Why I ignored Clark Howard’s warning about basic economy fares

Team Clark is adamant that we will never write content influenced by or paid for by an advertiser. To support our work, we do make money from some links to companies and deals on our site. Learn more about our guarantee here.

Basic economy vs. low-cost airlines comparison: What you need to know

Delta, American and United have placed so many restrictions on passengers with basic economy tickets. Travelers don’t get to pick a seat, can’t get a refund or make flight changes and may face additional baggage restrictions.

Sounds a lot like Spirit and Frontier, doesn’t it? Clark says basic economy fares were introduced in the first place to compete in search results with those low-cost carriers.

However, once a passenger clicks on the low fare, they see the list of restrictions and are offered a main cabin ticket.

“American, United and Delta have come up with something to try to make flying as miserable as they possibly could — called basic economy. They’ve been bragging to Wall Street that when people get burned by basic economy, the next time they go to book a flight they may click on that airline because they see a low fare and then they sell them up to a higher one.”

An argument for booking basic economy over low-cost airlines

Despite Clark’s warning, I’ve flown as a basic economy passenger on Delta a handful of times. It’s the least restrictive of the three full-fare airlines because the carrier allows a full-sized carry-on bag.

After American recently changed its policy, United is the only one that limits basic economy passengers to just a single personal item.

Since Spirit, Frontier and Allegiant don’t operate as many flights as the full-fare airlines, getting booked on the next available flight could still mean being stranded for a day or two.

On the other hand, the full-fare airlines may offer a dozen flights a day on some popular routes.

The bottom line is that Delta, American and United — along with mid-priced carriers like Southwest — are massive airlines that have enough resources in place to quickly bounce back when things go wrong.

This basic economy strategy can help you avoid travel nightmares

It may seem a bit extreme, but that one canceled Spirit flight changed the way I book travel forever. Let me explain…

When I reserve non-refundable mystery hotel deals through Hotwire or Priceline, I avoid flying Spirit or other low-cost carriers in case the flight is canceled and I can’t be rebooked quickly.

This is about risk. If a flight delay or cancellation will cost me a lot of money, I fly basic economy or on Southwest.

On the other hand, I don’t hesitate to book with low-cost airlines like Spirit when my travel itinerary is more flexible and I’m planning to stay with family or friends instead of paying for a hotel.

So far, my basic economy strategy has allowed me to travel more often on a tight budget. Why not give it a try?

Have you booked a basic economy fare with Delta, American or United? Let us know about your experience and how it compares to the low-cost airlines!