Let's take a look at the back of the package for a description and ingredient list:

This balm is indeed moisturizing. Oddly enough, it feels a bit waxier than regular Vaseline, which I love the consistency of. This surprises me, as it doesn't contain any emollients besides the petrolatum. Vaseline's Cocoa Butter and Creme Brulee formulas both contain cocoa seed butter as well, and I've tried one of those, and it was very sticky and waxy--I had assumed the consistency was due to the additional emollient, but oh well.

Though it's supposed to smell like roses, I think the fragrance is like a cheap perfume with a chemical edge--horrible; roses don't even figure in here. Out of curiosity, I asked my mom what she thought it smelled like (she didn't know it was supposed to smell rose-y), and after some deliberation, she said, "I think I've smelled it before...is it gardenia?"

This balm is tinted and colors your lips ever-so-slightly. The shade is a bit too peach for my liking.

Needless to say, this is not a product I would buy again, though it certainly looks cute at the drugstore counter, especially during Valentine season. I plan to stick with plain old Vaseline, which is my go-to when my lips are actually chapped--red, burning, and dry--no other lip moisturizer helps more and more readily than Vaseline, I've found.

This balm is all-natural, as are all of the company's products, and to make matters even better, the fragrances that are used in them are natural as well (it's important to note that some beauty products which are marketed as being all-natural do indeed contain synthetic fragrance).

You'll find the ingredient list here--lots of lovely butters and oils with Vitamin E to boot.

I love For Goodness Grape lip balms with one exception--the formula isn't as soft and glossy as I would like. I always rub these balms on my pulse points (wrists and the front of my neck) to soften them up before applying them to my lips. I think some people probably prefer a denser formula because it helps to prevent them from melting when they're in your pocket or car. That being said, I prefer balms that glide on more easily. It's possible the owner would make a glossier formula if requested, though she might have to charge a bit extra in order to do so--I just might ask about that the next time I place an order.

As for the scent of this balm, it's perfect--it smells exactly like fresh roses, which isn't surprising since the fragrance ingredient in it is real rose absolute. The scent isn't too strong, which is also nice.

For a softer, creamier formula that glides on more easily try Seville Rosa, which I also own. Its combo of rose absolute, cocoa butter, and orange essential oil is lovely. This balm is from her Lip Balm Queen line, as is the Rose Buttercream Cupcake balm.

As you can see in the ingredient list here, this balm is petrolatum-based and also contains cottonseed oil. It's very moisturizing, and I really like the consistency of it--it's glossy but not waxy or sticky. The fragrance is all-natural (derived from essential oils and botanicals), which is ideal. Here's the rub (pardon the pun): this balm smells more like baby powder than roses to me, and baby powder isn't really my thing--it doesn't smell bad, but it's not what I would prefer.

This salve is a very well-loved product that has gotten a ton of press, and the packaging is great with its vintage charm. I bought my generous-sized tin of it quite a few years ago, and though I use it off and on, it's probably not something I would buy again.

So, there you have it. I guess I could always try buying some real roses and rubbing them across my lips, but instead I think I'll stick to lovely rosalicious lip balms that are easier to use.

That concludes my reviews. Have a lip-happy day, and please remember to stop and smell the...rose lip balms! ☺