Why doesn’t the Bank of Canada just print money to pay off our National Debt?

July 17, 2012

We at the CTF are often emailed questions about the Bank of Canada. Most commonly we are sent links to little girls on youtube talking about the Bank of Canada, to the Michael Journal or videos of retired teachers explaining why the Bank of Canada should simply print money to pay off the National Debt, rather than the government borrowing money from commercial banks...

Should they? Should the federal and provincial government order the Bank of Canada to print money to pay off our debt?

We asked an expert to help answer a couple of questions.

Why doesn’t the Bank of Canada just print money to pay off our National Debt?

Dr. Ron Kneebone, Professor of Economics at the University of Calgary answers:

The Bank of Canada is owned by the Government of Canada so that any income earned by the Bank is handed over to the Government. This sets up a really cool idea that some people are advocating.

It works like this: the government regularly prints Government of Canada bonds and sells them to people like you and me. Canada Savings Bonds are one type of bond the government sells but there are others. Selling bonds is one way the government raises revenue. The other way, of course, is to tax us. But when taxes are insufficient, the government can sell us Government of Canada bonds and get revenue that way.

Although this sounds like an attractive alternative to raising taxes on cranky taxpayers, the government still faces a problem; it is on the hook to pay us interest on those bonds. The more bonds the government sells – that is, the bigger is its debt – the more it must pay in interest. The amount of interest that the federal government pays in interest is quite large. In 2011, they spent $31 billion. Provincial governments also sell bonds and so they also pay a lot in interest; about $23 billion in 2011 in total. In 1995, when interest rates and the pile of government debt were both higher, all governments in Canada were paying about $78 billion in interest payments annually. To put that into perspective, in that same year governments spent about $53 billion on health care.

The Bank of Canada can also buy these bonds. When it does, it pays for them by printing money. (The Bank does not literally print currency, but by purchasing bonds they put in motion things that cause the money supply to grow. Don’t ask or I will tell you how.) Like you and me, the Bank of Canada receives interest on the bonds it buys. BUT THE BANK IS OWNED BY THE GOVERNMENT AND SO RETURNS THE INTEREST TO THE GOVERNMENT. Sorry for shouting but that is the exciting bit. It means that if the government sells its bonds to the Bank of Canada, it is as though the government pays no interest on that debt. This is better than raising taxes on cranky taxpayers. If only we can get the Bank of Canada to buy these bonds we could save ourselves the $54 billion in interest payments. It is free money!

This is not a new idea. Governments have been using this method to raise revenue for a long time. During the 1920s, the governments of Germany, Austria, Poland and Hungary all required their central banks purchase government bonds. In each case the central bank paid for these bonds by printing money. In each case the result was what is known as “hyperinflation;” rates of inflation exceeding 50% per month. If you wonder why in 2012 the German government was so hesitant to allow the European Central Bank to buy up Greek debt, you need only remember Germany’s history with hyperinflation.

Lest you think this is ancient history, this method for raising revenue has been tried more recently. But the results have been the same. During the period 1971 to 1973 inflation reached levels of 500% per year in Chile. Just over a decade later, in 1985, the rate of inflation exceeded 11,000% per year in Bolivia. Since 2000 the government of Zimbabwe has printed trillions of Zimbabwe dollars resulting in rates of inflation hitting 98% per day; the equivalent of over 35,000% per year.

Oh. Maybe this is not such a good idea after all. These experiences are the reason that good central banks, like the Bank of Canada, refuse to play this game of buying inappropriate amounts of government debt. The Bank of Canada understands that its mandate is to maintain a low rate of inflation and this requires that it keep tight reins on the amount of money in the economy.

Those who advocate the “no interest loans solution” emphasize that the Bank of Canada has, in the past, purchased government debt without serious consequences. Are they right?

They are correct that the Bank of Canada does buy government debt. It does so as part of its mandate to regulate the supply of money in the economy. Buying federal government bonds – paid for by printing money – is one tool the Bank uses to fulfill its inflation mandate. The Bank, however, is very careful to ensure it does not buy so much as to threaten its low inflation target and it has never purchased debt simply to relieve the federal government with the need to pay interest. Those advocating the “no interest loans solution” are less correct about the suggestion that the purchase of government debt has never had unfavourable consequences. During the 1970s the Bank of Canada relied much more heavily than it does now on purchasing federal bonds as a way of regulating the money supply. This turned out to be a less successful policy than hoped. Those of a certain age will recall inflation rates exceeding 10% per year and the implementation of wage and price controls in an effort to slow inflation. That earlier policy has been replaced with one that relies much less on purchase of government debt.

Maybe that has not convinced you. If not, let me try another tack. No one likes to pay taxes. So when we pay taxes we demand government prove to us that we are getting good value for our money. We vote them out if they propose low-return public projects and vote them in if they convince us their spending proposals provide us with good value for our tax dollars. This disciplines governments to think hard before coming hat in hand to cranky taxpayers. This is how it should be. The idea of forcing the Bank of Canada to purchase government debt to give the government access to interest free borrowing is an invitation to fiscal profligacy. Why would taxpayers ever want to do such a thing?

So, bottom line, responsible central banks do not purchase government debt in order to relieve governments of the need to pay interest on their debt. Canada is not Zimbabwe and that, at least when it comes to inflation, is a very good thing.

Ron Kneebone is a Professor of Economics and Director of Economic & Social Policy in The School of Public Policy, both at the University of Calgary. His research interests are mainly in the areas of the macroeconomic aspects of public finances and fiscal federalism. His published research has dealt with issues pertaining to government budget financing in a federal state, the political economy of government deficit and debt reduction, the history of government fiscal and monetary relations in Canada and the characteristics of Canadian federal, provincial and municipal fiscal policy choices. Professor Kneebone is a co-author of two undergraduate textbooks in economics; a best-selling economics principles text with co-authors Gregory Mankiw and Ken McKenzie and an intermediate level text with co-authors Andrew Abel, Ben Bernanke, and Dean Croushore. For joint work with Ken McKenzie he was awarded the Doug Purvis Memorial Prize for the best published work in Canadian public policy in 1999. From 2002-2006, Professor Kneebone was an associate editor of Canadian Public Policy, Canada's foremost journal examining economic and social policy. An eight-time winner of a Superior Teaching Award in the Department of Economics he was also awarded the Faculty of Social Sciences Distinguished Teacher Award in 1997 and again in 2003.

By

on July 23, 2012

....this is completley misleading,
Anyone looking for some truth - find these on YouTube, do your own research and decide for yourself,
VICTORIA GRANT
THE CRIME OF THE CANADIAN BANKING SYSTEM
BANK OF CANADA LAWSUIT

You have successfully posted your comment. Please allow 24 hours for your comment to be reviewed before being published to the site.

By

on October 12, 2012

Interesting that he co-authored a book with Ben Bernanke.
As a side note, the words "wintity" and "quife" were the "re-CAPTHCA" words. I could not have come up with two better words to describe my feelings and attitude towards CTF's so called "expert" Ron Kneebone. It's funny 'cause it's true!

You have successfully posted your comment. Please allow 24 hours for your comment to be reviewed before being published to the site.

By

on October 16, 2012

A lower Canadian dollar? Higher interest rates? Inflation? Wow...what a disaster for our country. Oh wait...
Sounds like a miracle cure for a crippled manufacturing industry, a BOC created housing bubble and deflation...not to mention government debt.

You have successfully posted your comment. Please allow 24 hours for your comment to be reviewed before being published to the site.

By

on November 29, 2012

I saw Victoria, she tells it better than this profesor.
He is just following general economics understanding.
National debt is fraud period. Read some writings by Ron Paul.
Taxes is power to destroy.
When govern borrows the money they are asking private banks to actually issue the money, create the money from thin air ( whic profesor fails to note) which is of course what government itself can do without interest.
Canada has been sliding this way from around 1918 when they implemented income tax( a interest paid straight to private interests)
Today we have something like communistic/ fascinating government at its core.
Government and private corporations have joined together in conquering the populatio in submitition, dependency and slave conditions trough taxation. And eventually they will render as so poor that we want be able to live where we live because property taxes will be so hight they will force u out.

You have successfully posted your comment. Please allow 24 hours for your comment to be reviewed before being published to the site.

By

on August 04, 2014

Can't just create thin air money for debt. If you do, money is worth "thin air" and has no value.
Since no legitimate savvy investors buy all this debt, govmint electronically counterfeit the money to buy debts so the provinces and Ottawa, and some cities don't go instantly bankrupt.
Its really an illusion of solvency. Be like you or I printing money to pay the bills. The reality is Ottawa, US Fed and others went bankrupt in 2005/6 and caused the credit crisis and it snow balled into 2008 crash.
Be damned if I would lend BoC, Ottawa, or some idiot provinces, banks or mutual bond/mortgage funds at todays negative value money rate. Negative vlue money is where you lend money, but the money you have at the end of the term, while larger buys less goods and services.
Its really a currency inflation tax on pensions, incomes, savings, bonds, lending instruments and money. If you or I did it, we would be in jail.
But its immoral, tax greedy, myopic stupid politicians and union greeds that drive this and f$#@ Canadians with illusions.
Its why I know recovery, real recovery isn't even possible unless politicians whack 40-60% of governemtn waste and corruption...and keep the few things we actually need.
I only wished I moved more offshore than I did. 1/2 my cash is in USD, HK and elsewhere, I should have moved it all. This way I wouldn't get devalued Canadian govmint screwing. We all get screwed in this depreciating tax inflated economy of govmint fraud.

You have successfully posted your comment. Please allow 24 hours for your comment to be reviewed before being published to the site.

By digger

on December 09, 2015

Please excuse my ignorance, but doesn't the Bank of Canada effectively print money to pay off ALL government bonds, regardless of whether there is interest on them or not? If so, I don't see the impact difference to the monetary supply other than it seeming to add MORE money to the supply for them to pay interest. I would love to understand this better...if anyone knows whether the gov prints money for interest bearing bonds, please reply.

You have successfully posted your comment. Please allow 24 hours for your comment to be reviewed before being published to the site.

You have the power to change who influences politics in our country: big unions, big corporations and government-funded special interest groups can be challenged by the contributions of thousands of individual taxpayers who care to make a difference.

“This donation is help the Onion Lake reserve lady continue her fight against the chief and council members. I can’t understand how JT allows this to take place. ”

Reg Coderre| Donated $ 100.00

“Charmaine Stick is a true heroine. Thanks to CTF she can afford to stand up the tribe's bullies. ”

Gary Mauser| Donated $ 105.00

“Our Government should support its own laws, not pay only lip service!”

Thomas Duyck| Donated $ 100.00

“I continue to support Charmaine in her pursuit of fairness and transparency. Keep up the battle Ms Stick! You are an inspiration.”

Donn Watt| Donated $ 25.00

“Thank you for pushing back on these taxes that keep creeping up and for demanding that our money is properly spent.”

Andrei Valachi| Donated $

“Keep up your good work on our behalf.”

Pete MacEwen| Donated $

“This is ridiculous!!! The Federal government must enforce The First Nations Financial Transparency Act.”

Garry MacLennan| Donated $ 105.00

“Keep fighting, Charmaine. We need more people like you. And oh yes, we need a change of government in Ottawa that will enforce the Accountable Act. ”

Magda Keith| Donated $ 250.00

“Embarass the Band Administration and incompetent Trudeau Government.............symbols of personal Greed and Waste respectively.”

Larry Hallatt| Donated $ 105.00

“In view of the federal government's failure to enforce the First Nations Financial Transparency Act, perhaps Charmaine should sue the federal government because her stated rights are being denied.”

Rev. Charles Gingerich| Donated $

“Keep up the good work you do for already over taxed Canadians!”

Edward J Chorney| Donated $ 105.00

“Keep fighting! I'm very happy to help! Thank-you CTF.
”

Conway Yury| Donated $ 105.00

“Keep up the good work. Thank you for being the voice of common sense. ”

George Chalk| Donated $ 55.00

“Keep up the good fight, Charmaine”

Jim McIntosh| Donated $ 105.00

“Good project. Go get them.”

Larry Olney| Donated $ 105.00

“Need Chief`s email address to tell him he`s a `jerk`.
This is the fault of the silly woman who has not enforced
transparency.”

Andrew Lewington| Donated $ 55.00

“Keep working hard ! Keep Canada Great!”

Randy McCall| Donated $ 35.00

“You guys are awesome!”

Chris Matthews| Donated $ 20.00

“All the best Charmaine Stick!”

Dale Odberg| Donated $ 25.00

“Keep up the excellent work.
At this point, you are the sole group speaking for the hard-working taxpayers in Canada.
Keep the pressure on the so-called carbon tax, one of the greatest scams.”

Dale Mullen| Donated $ 105.00

“Get a standing or continuing order from the court to cover future years so Charmaine and the Canadian Taxpayers don't have to keep doing this every year or two.”

Timothy Roark| Donated $ 55.00

“Keep up the great work, we need to hold these people accountable to the Canadian public!”

Steven Morris| Donated $ 250.00

“Keep up the struggle!”

christopher atkinson| Donated $ 55.00

“The Liberals and Justin Trudeau should be ashamed of themselves for not keeping the first nations transparency act in force. ”

Jack and Sylvia Churchward| Donated $

“Keep up the good work. The government has to stop using taxation to balance a budget that provides for governor general graft and so much unnecessary spending. ”

Sandra Taylor| Donated $ 55.00

“Incredible waste of federal funds on those who are retired with massive pensions! How can this be justified?”

Alex Geddes| Donated $ 55.00

“I take home 40% of my income. Then I pay my bills. Enough is enough.”

Daniel Stewart| Donated $ 105.00

“This daylight robbery by past governor generals from Canadian taxpayers must be stopped as soon as possible.”

Dilip Joshi| Donated $ 55.00

“The Olympics have become a heinous waste of taxpayers hard earned money and just another example of politicians blatant disregard for the use of that money.”

Ronald Froescul| Donated $ 55.00

“Adrienne Clarkson always portrayed herself as being better than the rest of us. As John Iverson stated in the 2018 11 01 London Free Press "TIME TO STOP THIS GRAVY TRAIN".
”

Arnold Hull| Donated $ 20.00

“If the answer is "yes" Calgarians get the privilege of paying for the Olympics all 3 times, Federally, Provincially, Municipally. A "Hat Trick" way to go!!! ”

andy pawson| Donated $ 50.00

“Stop this insanity. We can't afford it. How can anyone trust the three levels of government involved to be fiscally responsible when all they know how to do is to spend, spend spend...”

Dean Starke| Donated $ 20.00

“No experience at managing this project”

bill Svrcek| Donated $ 105.00

“Time to tell the TRUTH. Short term gain for a long term pain.”

Terry Yuck| Donated $ 55.00

“NoCalgary2026 helping as I can. Thanks for standing up for Canadians CTF!”

Lawrence Kozy| Donated $

“Retired and do not live in CGY but wish I had more to donate to stop this waste of taxpayer money !!!
John Douglas Handford - $20.00”

John| Donated $ 20.00

“Hey folks, I must say I am done. It appears through all our efforts, that the corruption within all levels of governments, can not be fixed. I am moving to Costa Rica. ”

Reg L Coderre| Donated $ 55.00

“Thank you for standing up for taxpayers. As a rural Albertan, I am being taxed from two of the three levels of so called government and there will be a raised cost for everything in Calgary”

Archie MACDONALD| Donated $

“#KILLtheBID
whose money is the yes side spending - 1 million$$ ??”

Brian Rushfeldt| Donated $

“As a senior living on a pension, I say Good on the CTF for taking this initiative. All Canadians should have a right to vote on this ill thought out, fiscally irresponsible folly.”

Darrell Clarkson| Donated $ 20.00

“The vote should never have happened. How does the insurance co. make money if the overrun is assured. How many years do we pay $20 million? Security cost reduced???? ”

Don Ballance| Donated $

“STOP!!! SPENDING OUR TAX MONEY ON FRIVOLOUS CRAP THAT DOES NOTHING TO GIVE CITIZENS A BETTER QUALITY OF LIFE WITH DECENT MEDICAL CARE AND A SAFE AND HAPPY PLACE TO LIVE AND GROW”

ken miles| Donated $ 105.00

“Stop the 2026 Olympics bid boondoggle in its dirty tracks!”

Joanne Morcom| Donated $

“I am living in a Senior Retirement place and put you excellent Taxpayer in our Library to share with all the other Residents.
Keep up you good work!”

Berta Schwerdt| Donated $ 150.00

“The bid budgeting process was a sham. Worked on it for months changed it on the last day to make it fit. Typical "buy the work" mistake that has to lead to cost over runs.”

Lawrence Brus| Donated $

“Keep up the great work!”

Edward Kulicki| Donated $ 105.00

“The Trudeau Carbon Tax is absolutely the worst thing he can do to Canada. It will make absolutely no difference to global emissions. What am I supposed to do when it's -30C, freeze!”

Bruce Benson| Donated $ 25.00

“Thanks for all you are doing on No YYC Olympics.”

Judy Johnson| Donated $ 25.00

“I detest how this liberal government is wasting our hard earned wages and ignoring Canadians.I want them to get their hands out of our pockets. Thank you for all your hard work .”

Jim Goodwin | Donated $ 20.00

“I don't support your NO Olympics campaign but I do agree with most of your other initiatives.”

Scott Bratt| Donated $

“Keep up the good work!”

Al vanMourik| Donated $ 55.00

“Thank you for enforcing Band accountability laws written by our federal Government that they never intended to enforce. Keep up the good work!”

Richard St Laurent| Donated $ 55.00

Prev

Next

FEATURED PETITIONS

Federal: No Carbon Tax

Federal

Your government’s plan to impose a “pan-Canadian carbon framework” – a carbon tax - on any province that refuses to do so itself will be an unfair hit to Canadian families, businesses and rural communities.
Sign Petition

AB: Scale Back Calgary’s Golden Benefits

Alberta

The pension benefits provided to city council are way too rich. Sign Petition

BC: Stop the "School" Property Tax Hike

British Columbia

British Columbians should not be punished for owning a home in this province.Sign Petition

AB: No Calgary Olympic bid

Alberta

Calgary households and businesses can’t afford a large property tax increase to pay for hosting the Olympics.Sign Petition