The Rage: Carrie 2 (harpoon to the dick, 'nuff said)
The Blair Witch Project (THE film of the 90s?)
Idle Hands (probably has aged terribly, but was a fun ride at the time)
End of Days (Liked the understated performance by Arnie in this, and some dark imagery by Hyams)
House on Haunted Hill (fun Hollywood fluff, beat The Haunting at its own game)

Audition
Stir of Echoes
Ravenous (one of my favorite horror movies of the 90s)
The Blair Witch Project
Lake Placid (I did enjoy this, but immediately after voting I realized I'd missed The House on Haunted Hill, which I definitely would have voted for first.)