3 accused of Marine's '72 killing

Thursday

Dec 31, 2009 at 12:01 AMDec 31, 2009 at 10:36 AM

JACKSONVILLE, N.C. -- William Miller's final errand was supposed to be a good deed, helping his estranged wife with car trouble. The Marine sergeant left home one night in 1972 and within the hour was found dead on a rural road.

JACKSONVILLE, N.C. -- William Miller's final errand was supposed to be a good deed, helping his estranged wife with car trouble. The Marine sergeant left home one night in 1972 and within the hour was found dead on a rural road.

Thirty-seven years later, three people are facing murder charges for what prosecutors say was an ambush triggered by a love triangle involving Miller's wife and violence between Marines.

The case remained unsolved until Miller's s ister contacted a news-paper reporter looking into cold cases. The resulting investigation elicited new information from a 1970s baby sitter.

Miller's ex-wife, Vickie Babbitt, 58, is scheduled to go to trial in March on charges of first-degree murder and conspiracy to commit murder. Also charged with murder and conspiracy are George Hayden, 57, who married Babbitt after Miller's death and later became a small-town police chief, and Rodger Gill, 56, an ex-Marine who was friends with the others.

"All these years, I've been carrying on this crusade trying to get the cold case reopened," said Miller's sister, Sharron Aguilar, 68, who with her husband owns an automotive air-conditioning and restoration company in Houston. "Everything fell into place. I just know we have divine help."

Attorneys for the three people charged either declined to comment or did not return calls.

Trial dates for Hayden and Gill have not been set yet. All three are free on bond.

Miller, Hayden and Gill were all friends in the Marine Corps.

On Sept. 16, 1972, court records say, Miller got a call from his wife asking for help with car trouble.

A month earlier, he had kicked her out of their Jacksonville house after returning from a year's service in Okinawa, Japan, to find Hayden living with her. He beat up Hayden to get him to leave. When Miller's wife of two years walked out with Hayden, they took the Millers' 1-year-old daughter, Wendy.

Miller borrowed a neighbor's car for the late-night trip to help his estranged wife and took a .22-caliber pistol with him. He had told his sister days before that he felt threatened.

Passing motorists found Miller's body near Camp Lejeune less than an hour after he left home. He'd been shot twice.

Prosecutors say Babbitt faked car trouble to lure Miller to a secluded stretch of rural road in Jacksonville. They say Hayden was waiting in a ditch with an M-16 rifle and shot Miller in the temple and back. He appears to have been surprised: When police found the car, its engine was running, the headlights were on and Miller's pistol remained in the front seat, unfired.

"I spoke with him for the last time when he called, crying, to say he found George living with Vickie," Miller's sister Aguilar said in an e-mail to the Associated Press. "He stated George would not leave, so he beat the living hell out of George. George then threatened Bill, stating, 'I have an M-16.' He told me he was getting a lawyer to divorce Vickie and fight for Wendy."

Aguilar said she always suspected Babbitt. When her brother died, Babbitt called the family and told them he had been killed but didn't offer any details. She attended the funeral at Arlington National Cemetery with Hayden but wouldn't talk with the family.

Babbitt and Hayden married four months after Miller's death, then divorced four years later.

Hayden retired from the Marine Corps in 1989 and worked for the Carteret County Sheriff's Department before becoming chief for the Cape Carteret and Belhaven police departments.

Hayden's son, Joshua Hayden, a Cape Carteret police officer, told WNCT-TV last year that he didn't think his father is a criminal. "My father is a good man, very law-abiding, a strict law-abider," he said. "I don't see him committing a murder now or 36 years ago."

Babbitt remarried and worked as a bookkeeper at Austin Tile Design Studio in Bend, Ore.

Aguilar never quit trying to get the case open. When Lindell Kay, a crime reporter for The Daily News of Jacksonville, N.C., started working on a project about unsolved murders, Aguilar sent him the initial investigation report and Kay wrote two stories about the case.

After Kay's stories appeared in August 2008, a former baby sitter for Miller's daughter named Bonnie Sharpe came forward with key information. Sharpe was engaged at one time to Gill. Sharpe told investigators that Gill had witnessed the shooting, according to news reports.

Aguilar said she plans to be at Babbitt's trial in March.

"I know we're going to get justice," she said. "I don't have any doubts because I know I had divine help with this.

"Every step of the way, a path opened. I don't think I was led this far to be disappointed."

Never miss a story

Choose the plan that's right for you.
Digital access or digital and print delivery.