Well, I bought into the hype and what a big disapointment!! It dried up after 2 uses despite having it had standing. I loved the fine tip and the colour but not the fact that it didn't come with a click button or a twist for more liquid. I used it the first time and great and 2 days later, as I was going for the second eye it dried up. Very expensive for what it is, cheap looking presentation and a big no no. The other products I bought from the make have been a big disapointment as well.

I really liked the felt tip on this eye liner because it made it easy to apply and the wand was easy to hold. It also didn't move once in place which is a plus for my oily skin. I didn't really have too much trouble applying it either but I don't think the product came out very easily because the tip just always felt a little dried out even when it was new. All in all I think I will stick with my Lancôme Artliner I like it much better.

I do like this a lot. This is very precise and I didn't have any smearing what-so-ever. It set quickly and didn't move. It's very black and didn't require me to keep going over it. One swipe and I was good.

Very easy to use and very nice eye liner but 4 lippes for the price and what compares. I think Jordana's liquid pens are very similar for $2.99. This is $16.

I was so disappointed when I purchased this product after hearing so many good things. When I swiped it on my hand in the store it went on ok, but when I tried it at home on my eyes it was as if it had already dried out. It goes on patchy and you can't even build it up to a dark black. Waste of money and would not purchase again.

Like many others, I thought my liner was a dud. But, having received it for free with a magazine I couldn't complain (usually free gift are of a much better quality). My problem with it is the way it applies; it's so sporadic and uneven. I found the sharp tip scratches my eye too. Although, once on, it wears well and is easy to remove.

I agree with most of the negative comments on this post. I purchased a magazine that had this as a freebie as I heard many people rave about it. I'm so glad I never actually purchased this by itself as I feel it was a waste to even pay the amount I did for the magazine. This was so patchy and hardly produced any actual product, I've had better eyeliners for a Â£1. I assumed it was just a dodgy one off perhaps because it was in a magazine but from the other comments it seems like it's the product itself.

I am so disappointed by this product. A while a go I saw some makeup tutorials using this eyeliner and the girls raved about how they loved this product and it went on so beautiful! So when I saw Beauty Brands just got it in today I jumped on it and I was so excited. I swatched it and it is a nice black shade and I loved the felt tip since I am still a newbie with liquid eyeliner. I tried it on my eyes when I got home and it was terrible. No product would come out no matter how I held it and if some did come out it would be erased right away if I went over it just a little bit. I cannot wait to return this in a few days when I can get back to Beauty Brands. I paid $20 for this and I do not recommend this at all! It makes me sad though because I was so excited but I have never been so disappointed by a product before.

I bought this product just a few days ago, I was crazily excited to have it. When i opened the box, the tip seemed to be dry. soooooo i thought it was because the hot climate here, i try to put it on, NO INK WAS COMING OUT!!...i tried putting it on with different angle, literally a splurge of black ink appeared on top of my eyelid. i didn't wanted to believe that it had let me down, so i put the tip facing downwards and the bottom upwards overnite. the next day, THE SAME THING HAPPEN, still no ink from the tip, I HATE IT....what a waste of money, there's nothing good i can say about this stuff, better buy from drugstore its even better from this stuff..

Literally the WORST eyeliner i had. Just bougt it couple days ago due to high rave, and sadly i dont have any satisfaction over this. Swatches came out beautifully, but its another story when u run it on your eyelids. Its dry, hard edge makes it difficult to draw a precise line, and its not as intense as when u swatch it in ur hands.

Luckily i dont buy this in full price, or else i'll be pretty upset abt this product.

Alexa prob one great fashionista but shes sure dont understand makeup. Theres a LOT of other much cheaper eyeliner that works waaayyy better than this.