Here is the latest in a series of examinations into urban legends about football and whether they are true or false. Click here to view an archive of the football urban legends featured so far.

FOOTBALL URBAN LEGEND: NBC sent an employee running on to the field to delay the 1958 National Football League Championship because they had lost the TV signal.

The 1958 Championship pitted the Baltimore Colts against the New York Giants in Yankee Stadium for a game that has since been dubbed “the Greatest Game Ever Played.” It was the first, and remains the ONLY, NFL title game (including all Super Bowls) to ever end in overtime. In fact, it was the first NFL game period to ever end in overtime. It came about at a time when the American public were primed to become invested in professional football, and the game served as a sign that they were now “all in.” Gone were the years of poorly attended games – the league would never average less than 40,000 a game again and within three years public demand caused the league to expand from 12-game seasons to 14-game seasons.

Perhaps even more important was how pro football was adopted by the media. Sports Illustrated had barely given any coverage to the league, but soon began covering them regularly. Soon, incoming commissioner Pete Rozelle would began to control the media angle of the sport and help to build a multi-media sporting empire. He founded NFL Films and began to work out national television contracts to replace smaller, local TV deals. Eventually, these plans would lead to shows like Monday Night Football and today an entire network devoted to the NFL. It all started that night, when a record 45 million people watched the Colts defeat the Giants.

So as important as the game was to the future success of the NFL, it was also very important to the network, NBC (National Broadcasting Company), who was televising the game. As stated, the NFL was clearly poised to become a ratings bonanza and NBC wanted to capitalize on that themselves. They were so invested in the coverage of the game that, when they lost their TV signal late in the game, NBC took very drastic measures to make sure that their viewers would not miss the ending of the game. Drastic measures that included actually causing an on the field delay in the middle of what turned out to be the game-winning drive!
Tied at 17-17 that cold December 28th day, the Colts took over at their own 20 yard line following the Giants’ offense stalling after getting the ball to start the overtime period. Through a bold mix of passing and rushing (passing on a cold day when any interception could lead to a dramatic loss), Colts quarterback Johnny Unitas slowly creeped his team all the way to the Giants’ eight-yard line, where he called timeout.

The problem was, the crowd of over 68,000 was SO raucous that the cable providing NBC’s TV signal, which was located in the end zone, was DISCONNECTED! It actually happened RIGHT before Unitas called timeout. So now 45 million Americans saw just snow. The folks at NBC were likely seeing stars. They were on the Giants’ eight-yard line! The game could be over on the very next play!! They frantically tried to locate the problem. Earlier that year, in an article about televised sports, the New York Times had asked a CBS producer what they would do in just such an occasion. The producer joked that they would likely send someone out on to the field acting like a drunk to delay the game.

Well, sure enough, that’s exactly what NBC did. NBC employee Stan Rotkiewicz, standing on the sidelines doing some statistician work (a former college football player, Rotkiewicz worked as a business manager for NBC News, but did stat work on game days), was the sacrificial lamb. After Unitas returned from the sidelines and the timeout, Rotkiewicz ran on to the field, running up and down the length of the field chased by a few police officers. Some more officers joined in from the other side of the field and soon Rotkiewicz was taken down and hauled off of the field (even at the time, when everyone considered him a drunk, most fans and commentators noted how well dressed the young man was).

The delay worked well, but NBC still missed the first play out of timeout. Luckily for them, it was just a short rush that gained only a yard. The signal returned in plenty of time to capture Unitas’ final two glorious plays – a six-yard pass to Jim Mutscheller (who, had he not slipped on some ice, might have won the game right there). Finally, he handed off to Alan Ameche for the game-winning one-yard rush for the touchdown, finishing the scoring at 23-17.

Leave a Reply

Buy My Books!

If you enjoy this site, there's a good chance you'll enjoy my books from Plume Publishing (a division of Penguin Books) Was Superman a Spy? and other Comic Book Legends Revealed! and my newest book Why Does Batman Carry Shark Repellent?

Here are links to some fine online bookstores where you can order copies of the books!