Join the Shanghai Expat Community!

Terms of Service

Purpose: This is set of guidelines we use to manage this forum and the Shanghai Expat website. This site encourages debate, discussion, and the free flow of ideas. We do all we can to allow a range of opinions and viewpoints. However, we do not confuse the free flow of debates with the unrestricted right to say anything about anybody. This site does not support expressions that encourage racism, hate, violence, illegal activity, or harassment.

Sections 2 and 3, below, contain a non-exclusive list of activities that are against the guidelines of this forum.

Section 1: Definitions

The following are definitions of specific language of Shanghai Expat's Terms of Service (hereafter the "TOS").

Banning. The deletion of a user's account and termination of that user's right of access to the site as a result of serious or repeated violations of the TOS.

Flaming/Flame wars.

The act of calling into question someone's thoughts and beliefs, simply because you don't agree with them;

the act of posting confrontational, abusive, insulting, derogatory, abusive or inflammatory representations about another person, site member or poster; or

the act of sending a confrontational or abusive message containing angry, and possibly insulting or vulgar, content. See also "Harassment."

Harassment.

Unsolicited words or conduct that tend to annoy, alarm or abuse another person;

a course of conduct directed at a specific person that causes substantial emotional distress in such person and serves no legitimate purpose;

a course of vexatious comment or conduct that is known or ought reasonably to be known to be unwelcome; or

the act of tormenting by continued persistent attacks and criticism.

Non-Public Person. Defined as any member, guest or participant in any activity attended by Shanghai Expat members or any other person, who is not a public figure and has a reasonable expectation of privacy or where a poster knows or should have known that the subject person would object to his/her depiction on a public domain. By contrast, a "public figure" is a person who, by employment (tv personality, professional entertainer, professional athlete, politician, etc.) or by other prior action or reputation has become known to the general public and his/her likeness already exists in the public domain.

Spamming.

Multiple, unauthorized advertising posts within one or more forum or classified sections or the posting of multiple off-topic messages within the forum sections; or

the practice of sending copies of the same or materially similar post to more than one section of the forum or via the site's private messaging system.

Section 2: Restricted Conduct

The following activities, whether by forum post or via the site's private message system (hereafter "PM"), violate the TOS and will require action by site Moderators. This is a non-exclusive list that may be amended from time to time at the sole discretion of Shanghai Expat:

Flaming or inciting or participating in a flame war.

Posts that promote or encourage sexism, racism or racist stereotyping; or that attack an individual or group based on things such as religious belief or sexual orientation.

Posts that encourage illegal activity.

Posts that are blatantly offensive, violent or pornographic.

Posts that include links to racist or pornographic websites or sites that promote any illegal activity.

Spamming.

Posting personal information (e.g., home or business address, phone number, mobile number, E-mail address, etc.) of any other Non-Public Person without such person's express written consent to do so.

Posting identifiable photos or other likenesses of any Non-Public Person without the subject's express written consent to do so (see Section 4A for details).

Improperly-placed commercial posts (see Section 3, below).

Repeated improper placement of postings into the wrong section with what is deemed by the moderator as solely an intent to attract more readers .

Harassment.

Interference with site operations or the actions of a Moderator or other site staff including, but limited to, harassing site Moderators or other site staff for actions taken in the line of duty or inciting others to violate the TOS.

Posting attachments or graphics files that significantly impede the operation of the site or slow down page loads unreasonably.

The use of a screen-name that would generally be considered vulgar or offensive or is otherwise deemed inappropriate by Shanghai Expat.

Use of similar screen names, avatars or file attachments within the body of a post to parody the identity of real people in a derogatory or defamatory manner.

Any other conduct that, in the sole discretion of Shanghai Expat staff:

Reflects negatively on the community impression of the site;

creates a negative reaction among a significant number of other site members;

tends to harm, damage or in any way adversely affect the reputation of Shanghai Expat;

exposes or tends to expose Shanghai Expat to potential liability for violation of any governmental or official agency law, regulation, ruling, instruction, or known or reasonable ascertainable expectation of conduct; or

does not conform with the norms of community behavior

Section 3: Rules Regarding Commercial Postings

We limit commercial posting on this board. If you want to promote your business, please refer to the advertising page: www.shanghaiexpat.com/advertising
Commercial posts are subject to the following rules:

Commercial posts, generally: Posts of commercial nature (where you are selling a product or a service) must only go in the Buy-Sell Forum or the Doing Business Forum. Paid advertisers are allowed to contribute to the community by providing usable content within the forum or providing exclusive benefits to Shanghai Expat members, in order to promote their product or services, but excessive posting or blatant advertising is still subject to standard rules (see SPAMMING)

Language/cultural instruction posts: Posts promoting a language or cultural instruction program or course must include an actual lesson in the Learning Language forum, not just an announcement of the program or course. A limited exception applies to posts made by advertisers with a current paid advertising contract in effect with Shanghai Expat.

Real estate offers: Real estate offers are not permitted within the forum section buta re welcomed in the classified section as well as any specialized real estate listing section on the site (except as paid advertisements pursuant to a contract with Ringier China.

Event postings: If you have an announcement about a specific event with a definite date and time, you can post it in the Events Announcements classified. General-purpose "We are open for business" announcements are not permitted in the forum.

Spamming: Spamming the board with advertisements (posting the same or materially similar advertisements over in different forums or several times within one or more forum sections in a short period of time) will result in the deletion of all posts. General-purpose announcement posts about a business that are not part of a paid advertising agreement with Shanghai Expat will be deleted.

Section 4: Privacy and Intellectual Property

The world wide web ("www") allows information to be viewed, with few restrictions, to a worldwide audience that is not subject to the control or regulations of this site. Because of this characteristic of the internet, although Shanghai Expat will take reasonable measures to protect the privacy and intellectual property of its members, the site can assume no liability for third-party reproduction, misuse, or commercial use of any information posted by members on this site.

Photos or Other Likenesses of Real Persons: It is a violation of the TOS for members to post a photo, video clip or any other likeness of a real person affiliated with Shanghai Expat as a member, guest or participant in an activity attended by Shanghai Expat members or any other Non-Public Person without the subject's express written consent. The burden of evidence of receiving such consent will be on the poster.

Photos generally: Photos submitted to Shanghai Expat or posted on any of its forums become the property of the site unless otherwise specified by agreement made prior to such submission or posting.

Member information: Screen-names of members are the property of Shanghai Expat and can be modified, deleted or used by the site without permission of the member and without notice should it become necessary. Member information collected at time of registration may be used only for the administration of this site and its activities, but will not be sold or otherwise distributed to third parties without the member’s prior written consent, except where required by law.

Other site content: Members' forum posts, articles, blogs or any other text submissions to the site become the property of Shanghai Expat for the purposes of re-use, modification or disposal on the site or in connection with site community activities.

Section 5: Actions Taken in Response to TOS Violations

Shanghai Expat uses a team of moderators and other staff to monitor all activity on the forums. In response to a violation of the TOS, moderators may take, at the moderator's or site's discretion, one or more of the following actions:

Delete the thread in question.

Delete the post in question.

Edit the post in question to remove content that violates the TOS.

Move a thread to the appropriate section of the forum, if incorrectly placed, or, in the case of any other violation of the TOS, move the thread to the PIT section of the forum.

Post a request, comment or warning on the thread in question to indicate that a violation of the TOS has occurred or that the trend of the thread is leading to a violation of the TOS.

Send a PM to the poster of a post that violates the TOS.

Ban a member.

Section 6: Procedures

If a Moderator takes action to remedy a violation of the TOS, the Moderator may, at his/her discretion:

Post the reason for the action within the post or thread itself (this action is required where the Moderator has acted under Section 5C). An example of this is: "<Content deleted for violation of Section 2B>"

Send a PM to the poster advising of the reason that poster's post was deleted or moved.

Post no explanation to the forum or via PM where the nature of the violation of the TOS is obvious.

A member may always request a brief explanation for a Moderator's action via PM to the "moderator" in instances where no explanation has yet been given. Banned members have no recourse.

Posters who are habitual or frequent violators of the TOS (under one or more usernames) and who have not ceased violations of the TOS after warnings from Moderators can and will be subject to banning without further notice.

Posters of multiple offending posts may not be given any warning prior to banning should the violations be committed and/ or discovered at the same time.
E. Moderators' actions with respect to violations of the TOS are FINAL and not subject to further review.

When i first arrived, i remember searching this site and others for info about shanghai water. i sought answers to

a) how safe was tap water.

b) what was the best solution to drinking water and using water in food preparation and

c) what were the best solutions for home filtration for safe healthy drinking water.

i wound up with more questions than answers and adopted a few practices and products i abide by. this such an important topic i finding it difficult to believe i left it at that. many months have gone by and i hoped readers might be able to enlighten me further.briefly, i read that

a study (cant recall details) had shown high incidence of stomach cancer in shanghai and some suspect the water.

that the tap water is more a risk for the by products of purification than the contaminants it originally contained.

pure distilled water is actually harmful over time as it is devoid of needed minerals / elements.

bottled water (large bottles) varies in quality eg some are actually sourced from lakes/springs as apart from being purified.

some of the older parts of town use piping that are likely to still contain contaminants from before 'purification' of water started.

more recently i heard that the mouth ulcers sometimes come from using tap water for cleaning teeth, i know people who actually drink the tap water.

1. The study you are referring to showed that not stomach cancer, but colon cancer rates had increased in Shanghai by 100% over the last 10 years. Of course this could be for any number of reasons, water, pesticides, an increase in reporting, etc.

2. Distilled water is not harmful because the human body can not absorb minerals from water. Dr. Andrew Weil (google him if you don't know who he is) says drinking distilled water is fine, and there are no studies to show that you can get minerals from water. He says distilled water is all he drinks.

3. Yes, some bottled water is not that pure (this is true in the USA too) and some vendors even sell "counterfiet" bottled water.

I was really worried about this when I first got here, but all you can really do is use common sense and take precautions. I never drink tap water, but I cook with it (like boiling noodles) and I brush with my teeth with it, etc. I don't think you can obsess too much or you will go crazy.

Andy

p.s. Joe Jackson has a song called "Everything Gives You Cancer." Listen to it and then go sit in a dark room for a while...

Look at the bright side. At least there is no way to get stomach bugs (ie the local equivalent of Delhi Belly or Montezuma's Revenge) from the local tap water....there are too many chemicals in it for any bugs to survive.

I'm not being entirely facetious. One of the biggest problems in many third world countries is that you have to be careful of how you wash the dishes, brush your teeth, and etc. or you do risk getting intestinal parasites. That risk is much lower here.

Totally agree with the previous two posts.. While admittedly SH is not the most environmentally clean place, it is definitely not the worst. If you worry about the quality of water beyond what is common sense, you have to also think about what they put in your food, how the cattle and vegetables were grown, how much and which chemicals were used, etc. Life will become too miserable if you start looking for bugs and chemicals in every bite and sip you take.

As for the water itself, I use tap water for cooking (except for tea and coffee) and brushing the teeth. I don't drink it. For plain drinking I use bottled Chinese water, or better yet, imported water.

hmmm just thinking outloud . . .
so i don't drink cups of water straight from the tap, but i know i swallow a lot of it taking showers (i sing and like to gargle in the shower), brushing and rinsing my teeth, boiling pasta/noodles and not straining it well (about the extent of my cooking abilities). no problems so far in 5 years.

i do notice that there is no noticeable chlorine taste/smell in the water here. i always recall when i go back to the states that i definitely taste something in the water that is chlorine-ish after being used to the water here. i also notice my teeth are not as white here - i heard that there is less flouride in the water here and so its harder for me to keep my teeth whiter (i bring the same toothpaste i use back home over - arm n hammer baking soda toothpaste)- fact? fiction? not sure. any dentists out there reading this?

b) what was the best solution to drinking water and using water in food preparation and

c) what were the best solutions for home filtration for safe healthy drinking water.

a) Fill the sink (preferably white) with tap water and judge whether you would like to swallow what you see there
b) water purifying systems will remove most of the visible partickles and chemicals they have in the water (what you see at a).
Alternatively, use botled water, either purified or mineral water for cooking and drinking
c) bottled water from reputable company

c) what were the best solutions for home filtration for safe healthy drinking water.

This is something I am dealing wiht now as we are having a system installed in our new apartment. Actaully some of the systems here are quite good, even can have them installed in your bathroom for the shower. Am getting the pricing ASAP so can PM you with that later.

If you're out on a moonlit night be careful of them neighbourhood strays/Of a lady with long black hair trying to win you with her feminine ways

The water i get out of my tap is defintiely mroe chlorinated than back at home in the states. The white sink defintiely shows the yellowness of the chlorinated water.

As for Flouride in the water, it seems China has been smart enough not to inject toxins in to the water just for the alleged benefit of good teeth. Do a google search on the topic if youa re curious why. Anyhow, no flouride but lots of other tooxins I am sure... but seriously a reverse osmosis purifier will probably go a long way here as I have been uning on in our offfice and its been working fine. never thought I'd drin purified tap but hey...better than boiled tap for sure.

Hmmm, interestingly, I attended a talk about drinking water this week hosted by Dr. Xuan, an MD with years of clinical and research experience, with recent research into healthy lifestyles which led him to research the water situation here in Shanghai. A few notes about what he said about the water...

China has been trying to attain a standard for tap water for years but so far, because of the limits with the older infrastructure, no drinkable water standard has been attained yet. Current water in Shanghai, for example is very "hard' in that there are many minerals, particulates and heavy metals that have not been filtered in the processing at the water treatment plants. What DOES come out of the pipes is disinfected water with chlorine content and a few other contaminants. "Ironically", he stated, "there is nothing that can be boiled out of the water ther than Chlorine these days."

He continued to talk about what he considers "healthy" water. 1) Non toxic and no toxins; 2) Mildly Basic 7.2-7.4pH, which incidentally is the blood pH of newborns, 3) contains necessary minerals (not like many DI and distilled water which are left devoid of any minerals)

What I learned from the talk is that while drinking "pure water' without minerals is not necessarily bad for you, it does tend to leech minerals away from what it comes in contact with as osmosis kicks in, though it should NOT take any thing away from cells already utlizing these minerals. Along the same lines, Reverse Osmosis is also the only way to truly filter out heavy metals to a suitable level for drinking (96% heavymetal free for drinking / 99% free for medicinal use per US FDA standards) Given this, its my goal to find a proper filter that utilised Reverse Osmosis AND can still provide a mildly basic (pH level 7.2-7.4) water with some essential minerals.

As for rinsing and showering, he mentioned that technically, we are showering and rinsing with chorinated water (chlorine being the main active disinfecting ingredient used in public and private water systems ) Heating it up in a hot shower actually make it easier to absorb... so we are actually absorbing much mroe Chlorine than is healthy with all those hot showers. Sorry to make things seem worse... Sigh.

Reg- you mentioned beer...so did the dear Doctor. He mentioned that the best beers and alcohols, come for areas with the best source for clean water. Fresh water is clear, and soft, with a minimum of minerals and the water molecules tend to be clustered in smaller bunches. this water is a better solvent and blends better to make better beer and drinks...as well as a better cleaning solution. Guess a good beer will clean you right out!

Anyhow, i am going to look inot this more and follow up as i find more info.

1) Tap water is highly chlorinated to essentially eliminate bacteria at the water treatment plant and in the private building systems.
2) Tap water containes high levels of heavy metals that boiling and carbon filtration will not remove.
3) Tap water here is mildly acidic as it is hard with large cluster molecules of H2O and many minerals and particulate matter picked up along the way in the older water system.

yu888, thanks for the great post. Apart from absorbing chlorine, it seems the biggest bogey is heavy metals which i recall works its way into the food chain?. if i also remember correctly heavy metals are accumulative (hard to get rid of once you have acquired them...so you slowly get 'poisoned' over time) If you can identify a suitable filter i would appreciate you dropping me a line. i gave up looking but suspected something more than micron filters and active carbon was needed. ....thanks for your informative post. ...so hot beer baths from now on!

yeah, the heavy metals have ALWAYS been my only concern about the water here and thus i have been cooking with bottled water at home all the time, even for pasta and dumplings and soups since boiling, whicl good to eliminate any hydro-carbon chemicals, deos not affect the heavy metal content. i am going to get a pH kit to test the bottled water I get, but it seems pretty good in taste and is a branded source. but having seen some of the new in-house filters in action recently, i am on the hunt for the right filter. I don;t want to take the info i get for granted until i get a chance to learn more. Active carbon is needed as it removes taste, but essentially, to remove heavy metals means to remove all minerals as a good filter cant tell the bad from the good. Reverse Osmosis filters made by Dow Chemical and GE are the only two specified approved filters that meet US FDA requirements so whatever filter we find on the market MUST utilise one of these filters.

Oh, I think i figured out the translation of the "larger clusters of H2O molecules" I mentioned above. Essentially its a measure of softness/hardness of water and its surface tension. The softer the water, the less surface tension. I guess there is an ideal point of softness that makes the water most healthy in terms of consumption and usage (for cleaning etc...). Seems the softer water with less surface tension has smaller clumps of molecules which allows for better solvency...it cleans better and I guess is absorbed better by the body's cells. (Please any experts correct what I may be wrong in translating and learning)

So far in looking at filters most of the multi stage filters are in couple to few hundred USD range but are set up for constant household use. Will see what comes up. I have my doubts that we will find the "perfect" filter but lets see what we can get.

Yes. great post, Yu... please do tell us when you have decided on what to buy and where ! I guess finding the perfect one would be difficult.. but we are lucky, we have you to do all the hard work of research and we only have to follow you.

Yu has made some very good points. I normally comment on water issues as I am involved with this but I have been away for a few days.

I've also been banging on that boiling water does pretty much no good for people in Shanghai. Due to the levels of chlorine there are unlikely to be any bacteria in the water to kill. And there are heavy metals in varying levels and boiling will not help this at all. In particular heavy metals are really bad for kids.

Reverse Osmosis, if you can get a decent kit, is one of the best ways to treat water. With all these things though you need to be careful when using as it is impossible to tell when looking whether your water has been properly treated.

I wouldn't be so concerned about particles or colour in water here though. Generally this comes from old pipes and is usually just iron. May make your clothes dirty and looks bad but by itself is not so harmful.

I don't know much about the bottled water companies here though. Does anyone know whether they have any websites, preferably in English?

Geez, took you long enough... I felt like I have been treading water here

Hammerforlife, in case others did not know, is somewhat of an expert in terms of water quality issues as i beleive he works in a related industry. He has commented to no end about heavy metals and chlorine and such and pretty much helped me build the basis of my knowledge prior to sitting in on the talk I did earlier this week (that and a little basic chemistry and physics did not hurt ).

I have set my short term goal here to finding a few things...

1) a drinking water filter with Revers osmosis that will meet US FDA and NSA requirements of 96% polutant free, including heavy metals
2) a shower filter that will allow removal of chlorine from my bathing/shower water
3) a simple tester to check water quality at least in a ver basic sense to make sure the filters do what they are supposed to.

The other goal is to continue finding new info aboutthe water so we can be as informed as possible.

yu888 wrote:1) a drinking water filter with Revers osmosis that will meet US FDA and NSA requirements of 96% polutant free, including heavy metals2) a shower filter that will allow removal of chlorine from my bathing/shower water3) a simple tester to check water quality at least in a ver basic sense to make sure the filters do what they are supposed to.

1) Would be a very good idea. But these filters do need maintenance. They can clog up quite easily especially if there are other particules in the water. The RO cartidges would either need cleaning or replacing on a regular basis if they are to keep working well.

Ironically many filters in China and other places just end up as breeding grounds for all sorts of stuff and make the water quality worse as the cartridges never get changed.

For 2) I doubt you will find anything. In fact I'm sure you won't. But is it necessary anyway? Swimming pools all over the World often have higher levels of chlorine than in tap water, apart from those that use ozone of course.

For 3) there is no simple test unfortunately. I've been trying to develop some myself over the years, as much of my work has taken me to remote parts of the World where there are no labs. Easy to test for chlorine, ph and bacteria but that's about it.

Hi Portsmouth. Yep reverse osmosis is known as the best system to remove pretty much all contamination and that does include heavy metals (it is the only system that is capable of turning sea water into drinking water too). I don't know about that particular company but as they are RO they should be fine.

Just make sure that you chose the correct model and also maintain it properly. The problem with these things is that you cannot tell when the membrane is damaged and are therefore getting no treatment at all.

Thanks, Hammerforlife! Another question - the company also sells a TDS meter, "TDS meter- High quality pocket digital water meter to test your water quality before and after the ro system. So you know the system is working." Do you think that is sufficient for me to tell the membrane is in good shape?

To me a TDS (total disolved solids) meter seems to be the best practical way of checking whether things are working properly. If you go for 6 months and the meter is showing that 90% of disolved solids are being removed and then suddenly it goes down to 10% then you know you have a problem.