A Phi Delta Theta pledge and double computer science and mathematics major at Duke, Bagley recognized Belle after watching one of her videos on the website Facial Abuse a few months ago. When Belle asked Bagley not to reveal her secret, Bagley told his fraternity brothers, who then outed her to the rest of the Duke campus.

Now, in a Shakespearean-level (OK, maybe M. Night Shyamalan–level) twist, an adult industry representative is giving Bagley a taste of his own medicine by penning an open letter to him, in which he exposes Bagley’s porn tastes and makes him an offer to appear in an XXX scene.

Bagley’s porn offer is by way of Mike Kulich, the CEO of XXX distribution company Monarchy Pictures (which has no affiliation to Facial Abuse, the website where Bagley first spotted Belle). If that name sounds familiar, Kulich has a habit of making porn offers to other notorious news figures, such as accused murderer Amanda Knox and disgraced former PR exec Justine Sacco.

Kulich says he doesn’t know for sure if Bagley subscribes to Facial Abuse. But given the timing of Belle’s shoot for the website, and the fact that Belle had only shot one or two scenes when Bagley outed her, “for [Bagley] to find out what he was doing, he had to have seen that scene.” The rationale behind the offer? “[If] he can shame girls for doing porn,” he recently told porn journalist Gram Ponante (NSFW), “I can shame him for watching it.”

Here’s Kulich’s offer letter, in full:

Dear Mr. Begley,

First off, I would like to thank you for being such a fan of our business. For someone who subscribes to a site like Facial Abuse I want to commend you for spending the $200 a week your parents send you every week for living expenses wisely. Facial Abuse is a great site! There is nothing like watching a new girl getting a huge cock viciously rammed down her throat. I like your taste!

I want to also commend you on getting accepted into Duke. Great school! I am sure your parents are proud. I bet you pull straight A's when you're not whacking it to Facial Abuse and Casting Couch movies. I love our fans and I love you! You are the type of guy that makes our business move.

With that I would like to make you an offer. As I sit here in my office at 6:30 on a Wednesday night I am writing a check for $10,000 to pay to the order of Thomas Bagley. I want to give you the opportunity to live out all your fantasies. In addition to that 10K, there is a plane ticket and hotel room with your name on it out here in sunny Los Angeles. Screw the polar vortex. Get your ass out and come shoot for us! I will give you the opportunity to bang ANY porn star you want. We will make you a celebrity because it is apparent how much you love porn and attention.

10 Grand is a lot of money for a kid like you. Do you know how many porn memberships you could buy with that? That is more than a lifetime membership to Facial Abuse!

I ask that you seriously consider our offer. Any girl you want! Come out to LA and become a star. ALSO, for every inch you are packing over 4, I will throw in an EXTRA $1,000. Get your tiny pecker out here and become the next Ron Jeremy kiddo!