Due to Limited Rapid Transit the Far South Side is Dependent on Bus Service

[Last fall the Chicago Reader launched a new weekly transportation column written by Streetsblog Chicago editor John Greenfield. This partnership allows Streetsblog to extend the reach of our livable streets advocacy. We syndicate a portion of the column on the day it comes out online; you can read the remainder on the Reader’s website or in print. The paper hits the streets on Thursdays.]

Chicago’s ‘L’ system, with its iconic train cars, relatively fast speeds, and occasionally breathtaking views, is the sexier side of the CTA. But the city’s grid of 130 bus routes is really the meat and potatoes of our transit network, with 274.3 million boardings in 2015 compared to the train system’s 241.7 million trips.

Bus service is especially important on the far south side, where access to other forms of public transportation is limited; although the city extends as far south as 138th Street, the Red Line terminates at 95th, and the Divvy bike-share coverage area currently stops at 79th.

To get a sense of what it’s like riding buses on the far south side—and whether residents are satisfied with the level of service or feel that improvements are needed—last week I rode the entire route of the 87th Street bus, the southernmost bus line to cover a continuous east-west path across the entire width of the city.

The #87 runs ten miles, from Cicero Avenue in the quaintly named southwest suburb Hometown (near Oak Lawn) east to Buffalo Avenue in the hardscrabble South Chicago neighborhood. On the return trip the route dips south on Buffalo to 91st Street, heads west to Commercial Avenue, then back up to 87th. The route connects with the Red Line as well as Metra’s Rock Island and Electric District lines, which contributes to the route’s popularity—an average of nearly 13,000 people ride the 87th Street bus each weekday, according to the CTA. Except for Hometown, which is 97 percent white according to the U.S. Census, and South Chicago, which is about one-fifth Latino, just about all of the communities served by the bus line are solidly African-American.

A panel from the “Time Traveler, Part 1 and Part 2” installation by Thomas Lucas at the 87th Street ‘L’ stop. Photo: John Greenfield

I started my bus excursion around 5:30 PM on a Tuesday at the 87th Street Red Line stop, which was renovated in 2013 as part of the Red Line South reconstruction. Eighty-seventh Street’s narrow sidewalks were crowded with CTA customers waiting for buses.

I buttonholed one westbound young woman to ask about her commute. She declined to give her name, but explained that she commutes from her home near 87th and Ashland in Auburn-Gresham to her job as a downtown security guard. She takes the #87 to the Red Line, then rides north to her job near State and Lake. The journey takes about an hour, she said, and overall she’s satisfied with the bus.

“During rush hour it’s pretty frequent—although when I get off late the buses only run every 15 or 20 minutes,” she said.

When the next westbound bus appeared, I piled on with about a dozen other people, including a young man with dreads listening to headphones, an older woman with two young children, and a smiling middle-aged guy in a blue suit who clasped palms with the driver in a soul handshake. Soon we were rolling down the broad lanes of 87th Street, passing big-box stores, bungalows, and apartment buildings.

Over the next two miles the bus emptied out. I chatted with 41-year-old passenger Carol Smith, who told me she was on her way home to 87th and Damen from her job as a receptionist at Northwestern Memorial Hospital. Smith usually drives to work, she said, despite the fact that garage parking in Streeterville costs about $20 a day. But her car was in the shop at the time, so that morning she’d taken the #87 to the Red Line to Chicago Avenue and walked the rest of the way. The total commute took about an hour and 15 minutes, she said.

As we talked, we realized that the bus had been stopped at Wood Street for an inordinately long time for no apparent reason. Almost ten minutes went by before we finally started moving again. When I asked about the delay, the driver explained that he’d stopped because he was running ahead of schedule and didn’t want to cause “bus bunching,” the annoying phenomenon in which customers wait an eternity for a ride only to have two or more buses show up at the same time.

Minor correction – the intersection of 87th & Cicero is also the intersection of 4 municipalities: Chicago, Hometown, Oak Lawn and Burbank. The shopping center at the SW corner is in Oak Lawn.

Courtney

I have a friend who has lost plenty of jobs due to the poor bus service on the South side. Some might argue, “Wake up earlier” but who can seriously plan for buses being 20-30 minutes late? Due to their low wages they couldn’t afford to call a Lyft or Uber to get to work.
I am fortunate enough to have been able to move from the South side to a north side neighborhood that has excellent CTA options. It’s a shame every neighborhood doesn’t have great CTA service. I absolutely hate riding the bus but I’d much rather take the bus on the North side vs the South side. =/

Anne A

For a few years, I needed to visit the area around 87th & Cicero regularly and experimented with every transit combination I could find.

The worst: orange line and Cicero bus. The orange line was usually fast, but traffic on Cicero was usually slow and very unpredictable.

Metra SouthWest Service: not many runs, frequent delays.

Metra Rock Island: good in combination with a bike to ride from 91st St. station. Okay in combination with 87th bus, connecting with a little walk from 91st St. station or a longer bus ride from Gresham station.

Best all-weather option: red line to 87th, then 87th St. bus, though waiting for the bus in bad weather was not so pleasant, as there was no bus shelter at either end of my trip at the time.

Having to make this trip, with the unpredictably of overall trip time and challenges making connections, made me REALLY appreciate living within walking distance of the train.

ALSO ON STREETSBLOG

The announcement that, starting Labor Day weekend, six bus lines on the South Sides will offer more frequent and/or extended service, appears to be good news for transit riders in underserved neighborhoods. The service improvements will be paid for out of the CTAs operating budget. Mayor Rahm Emauel and CTA president Dorval Carter, Jr. heralded […]

Today the CTA released some generally good news about ridership, heralding 2015 as the highest-ever recorded year for rail use. Meanwhile there was only a minor dip in bus ridership compared to last year, which means a three-year decline in bus use is leveling off. The total number of rail and bus rides in 2015 […]

Editor’s note: Last November the J14 Jeffery Jump bus launched as the CTA’s first attempt at creating an express bus service with some of the elements of bus rapid transit. While the 15 Jeffery Local makes 37 stops between 103rd Street and Lake Shore Drive, the Jump only makes 19 stops. Between 83rd and 67th streets, inbound buses […]