@vv: Just like The paperboy reviews were focused in Nicole… This is a never ending discussion, what EVERYONE (and I mean Zac’s AND Vanessa’s fans) should get by now is that none of them is in the a-list yet, so everbody should just shut it.

tina

VV read quite enough thank you, you can’t get any better than the only good thing was his boxer briefs, lol. Read the critics, you know the ones who actually know acting. We didn’t bring him to this thread his fans did. We would be happy for you to taje him with you and leave.

tina

Sb take him with you

tina

@vv you must be fourteen or not understand english well. What I said went over your head, have one of you little friends explain it to you. Why would I care about Zac following her? She’s happy, I’ m happy for her.

tina

Vv bye

Haters Suck!

Vv
Goodbye and good riddance

YOHO

Personally,I don’t think reviews matter at all.I don’t understand why you guys make such a fuss about this.What’s the point of good reviews if the film becomes a big flop.Personally I measure an actor’s success with how many box office hits he has and how much attention he is paid in the film( I mean it’s no use being a part of a large cast like zac did in NYE or being shadowed by other actors like v did in j2) and whether or not he is paid big for the film.To me reviews mean nothing.

Haters Suck!

I never want to hear zac fans complain about haters again when they are the worst of the worst.

tina

@D First it’s a movie about Spring Break, they are at the BEACH, what should they wear? You sent me to rotten tomatoes, thank you never laugh harder. Loved what critics had to say. Is he on some other old guy’s boat this week? We know who using what to get ahead. You and your buddy have pointed out she’s with Austin not gay or old men.

tina

I didn’ t say he was gay READ what I said. The truth hurts, he is auditioning for roles on this guy boat. I’ m sure he’ll get them.

man

@tina: you didn’t use that word.but that’s what you mean,even in your second comment.Why can’t zac go on a trip with some of his friends?is it that wrong?Zac works hard to land roles as much as vanessa does.This Al turki guy or any other guy isn’t gonna get some loser of an actor for his films just because he likes him or has a crush on him.They invest millions on films.They are not gonna waste millions on a silly crush.Zac is being continuosly used inf films because he has talent and that he is so appealing to the audiences,both young and mature unllike most actors out there .He can bare his undies and can be so apealing to mature the female and male audiences as sex symbol and can voice ted and be apealing to kids and play a rebellious son and be apealing to teens etc.

Challenge for Maria

@maria:
-
I propose a challenge to you Maria, go to Rotten Tomatoes, choose 2 movies of Vanessa and get the first 10 reviews about Vanessa’s acting abilities, just her acting as a single element from the movie, no reviews about the movie in general, let’s compare with what people say about Zac, just prove to everyone there’s a consensus about Zac being “bad” and Vanessa being “good” actress, and this is not JUST an narrow-minded fan theory, like it sounds
.
I was impartial, I just get the first comments that is showed on the site, you’ll see positive, condescending and even NEGATIVE reviews
.
What critics say about Zac in “17 Again”:
.
1- “The good news is Efron can carry a movie on his own”
2- “he’s a charismatic actor with solid comedic chops and ability to play the range of this character.”
3- “Efron’s adequate but completely anonymous work keep this from achieving true liftoff.”
4- “…with Zac Efron’s tremendously appealing lead performance playing an instrumental role in the movie’s undeniable success.”
5- “The role of the cool kid recapturing his game is well-suited for Mr. Efron; he’s not asked to stretch his acting skills too far and responds with a charming performance. 6- “Efron is up to such demands. He has an easy way with the comedy and doesn’t seem to be taking himself seriously.”
7- “And with 17 Again, tweenager poster boy Zac Efron proves that he really can act”
8- “the kid has a charming screen presence and more than enough talent to carry this lightweight comedy.”
9- “Efron plays the role well, and certainly had the teenage girls in the audience squealing in delight.”
10 – “’17 Again’ demonstrates that Effron has rightfully earned some of the rampant adulation that has come his way.”
.
What critics say about Zac in “Charlie St. Cloud”.
.
1- “Zac Efron tries something a touch more serious with this synthetic weepie. And for those who thought the star could do no wrong, here’s very solid proof to the contrary.”
2- “He is an actor able to feel emotions as well as portray them, and he’s always likeable.”
3- “Efron excels, proving he’s leading-man material”
4- “Zac Efron conspicuously fails to outgrow his teen roots”
5- “Another solid performance by Zac Efron is flattened by bombastic filmmaking”
6- “If you liked Happy Zac in High School Musical, why not try Sad Zac? All the chiselled sex appeal of the original, but now with a gloomy face on top! ”
7- “Zac Efron hasn’t yet arrived as a big-time movie star, although Hollywood is doing its best to make that happen.”
8- “it’s a decent enough vehicle to flaunt Efron’s acting chops.”
9- “is a tribute to the acting skills of the ever-improving Efron, who strikes just the right balance between grief and introspective miserabilism.”
10- “Efron is an extremely likeable screen presence “

tina

@man for the last time I DON’T THINK ZAC IS GAY. I think he’s a pretentious user, which allows him to suddenly be ‘friends’ with a guy old enough to be his grandfather. Soon they will be making movies together. He ll, Zac name will even be on it as producer.

man

@Challenge for Maria: You should have chosen TLO or Paperboy.These are old reviews when he was still playing the character of a silly teenager.The reviews from TLO and Paperboy may not be good as these,but they show that he is doing a great job moving in to adult roles.

http://Justjare.buzznet.comy BOJI

There is no need to challenge Maria. She has her opinions on the matter. I re iterate, this is Vanessa thread period, plain and simple. And we get Efron Fans doing the dirty here, so why the hell can’t we defend Vanessa on HER Threads.

@ Maria, you don’t need to explain your self or take up poster171′s challenge. Just not worth the E F word(.effort, haha my pun)
@ 171 please take this to his thread

Celestine

@maria: So if a person gets a good review from a critic he/she must have had sex with them?? LOL!! So ridiculous!

tina

@Challenge We didn’t start this ‘go to rotten tomatoes’ thing Zac’s fans did. Of course, while he was filming HSM they thought he was the second coming , nice, polite little boy who showed promise. Now he has become a one trick pony. You went to his FIRST reviews I went to his last.

Haters Suck!

@celestine
I dont believe that is our regular Maria. I believe it is yet another what we like to call doppleganger. Someone posing as Maria by stealing her screen name.

KissThis

Please… If Vanessa’s fans knew her personality… And I know what I’m talking about. She’s completely stuck up with herself. She treats others horribly. But whatever. Her fans can keep thinking she’s amazing. Just know that she doesn’t give a crap about you. She’s in the business purely for fame and money. TRUTH.

Haters Suck!

@kissthis
Right you know what you’re talking about and I’m just supposed to believe you just like that because you say so. That’s not gonna happen. I’ve yet to hear from anyone from people whove worked with Vanessa to fans who take pics and post them on twitter and tweet about meeting her never in all these years have I ever heard one bad thing about her. I’ll take their word over yours any day of the week.

@man: If you want, there it is, from The Paperboy there’s no much about Zac only, have to get some references about the entire cast

The Lucky One
1- Efron puts in his best movie performance yet
2- While impossible to prove with this effort, Efron can act (see “Hairspray” and “17 Again”)
3- The acting isn’t dreadful. Zac Efron is fine as Logan
4- His Logan is stoic, but perhaps too much so, as his acting at times comes off as expressionless and one-dimensional.
5- Scott Hicks’s film is the first where Zac Efron is fairly convincing as a full-fledged adult
6- Former teen idol Zac Efron is all grown up but keeps the boyish charm
7- After this performance no further evidence is needed of Efron’s ability to do vulnerability and puppy love — we’re ready now to see whether he can show any bite.
8- Efron and Schilling are appealing but get little chance to come alive
9 – I never really bought the notion of Zac Efron as a traumatised marine veteran trying to overcome his demons after three tours of duty. He isn’t a man who’s been through hell; he’s a nice-looking boy who’s been through a makeover. I’ve admired his work in the past, but when he attempts to show inner conflict here he looks like a male model who’s a martyr to haemorrhoids.
10- And Efron the actor is Tom Cruise-lite. Beyond the blue eyes and man-scaped stubble, you are left with an actor who simply pauses on screen when he is not speaking
-
The Paperboy
1- Zac Efron himself, who accepts his rather inflexible role as Vexed Ken Doll with markedly good grace.
2- The young actor delivers a far more measured and layered performance than in the Nicholas Sparks’ luckless The Lucky One.
3- The 24-year-old Efron, as the young man who loves her, finally gets the chance to prove that he is more than a pair of pretty blue eyes and a set of rock-hard abs; he rises to the occasion, digging up a note-perfect performance
4- Zac Efron does his part too, but he is rather hamstrung by the fact that he isn’t the biggest presence in his own story, undermined by the pressing, and not altogether welcome omnipotent presence of Macy Gray’s narrator.
5- despite its plot holes The Paperboy is a surprisingly involving film with solid performances from its cast
6- Zac Efron, who arguably is the only cast member credibly cast.
7- Efron – whose hard body is extensively lingered on by Daniels’ camera – does a nice job as the lovestruck youngster
8- it’s the first big-screen part Efron has handled with skill and conviction; he’s quite good in it.
9- Zac Efron is very good as the sad, motherless boy, whose only friend is the family’s stoical maid Anita
10- It feels like clips from around 20 other films, none of them good, sandwiched back to back, and the talented cast can only grit their teeth.

Haters Suck!

@boji
Wow boji, never heard you go at someone like that. Damn I’m proud of you.

http://Justjare.buzznet.comy BOJI

I know, right? Sometimes, I just get wicked a wicked sense of humour.

@ 177, oh can you just stuff it and take your challenge to your Efron thread. Enough of the golden boy. Not interested even if he won an Oscar just as I’m not interested in Tom Cruise. Btw,nthanks for adding to the count. Let’s see if we can make it 200

tina

Sorry but until his fans brought him up nobody really gave Zac a thought. Really your going to go to all this trouble ‘picking out’ reviews. The ones I read were on the first page. I really , really feel sorry for you. I only went there because one of his fans said something about it. I just felt it was funny they sent us there and ON THE FIRST PAGE, there were bad reviews. Sorry your so anal, I just don’t can say more. Just sorry for you.

Kissylissy i realy think there is still something bitween them. i think they are just taking a break and experienceing outher people. i have a feeling that they will get back together in a year or two. just a guess

Tera

I think zac and vanesas agency pushed them to breakup so zac will be availble. i think they still meet eachouther. and will get backtogether

Jm

Zac said in a interview few months ago that he still havent met the one. so i am sure vanessa isnt the one. he has already met her so

KissyLissy

@Tim: I quite agree with you.Most people say that them wearing the cartier bracelet is just a coincidence,bui I don’t believe that.They are both wearing it at the same time.It’s too much of a coincidence.@Jm: I hardly ever think that zac would ever accept in an interview that he has already met the right person and has already lost her.I don’t know whether Vanessa is the right person or not,but even if she was the one ,I would hardly ever think that he is gonna accept that in public after they’ve broken up.

Jm

@kissylissy He said he thinks she is still out there. anyways its not like what he says is the truth. you got a point there. who knows whats bitween them.

KissyLissy

@Jm: I just like to have hope.Did you watch the second video?It mentions the tattoos too.I am curious why he got the tattoo there,when he could have got it ANYWHERE.What is going on between them ,only they know.

Ow wow, looks like tina in a full power to fight haters, awesome, love it

yets

wow its a blockbuster here.

Challenge for Maria

@tina:
-
Will I have to explain the whole situation?
-
Imagine that we’re in a discussion about the competence of Industrial Light & Magic as a special effects creator, you say IL&M is “bad”, I say IL&M is “good”, I collect all the reviews and what they say about “Special Effects” in Transformers and show here, and you question because the reviews of the Transformers movie is bad
-
But Its not about what reviews say about the MOVIE, is about what they say about the SPECIAL EFFECTS of the movie, because movies are a set of technical and artistic elements, some things work, some don’t..
-
There are a lot of bad reviews about the movie, not bad reviews about ZAC, is so hard to understand it?
-
I get the first 10 reviews that are showed on the site, and for The Paperboy, as an example, I get all of them
-
And I said I am impartial because there the bad reviews about Zac in my collection, some of them are cruel with him (you read what I post about “Charlie st Cloud” and “The Lucky One”? I hardly doubt you’re reading now. but ok), and most of this good reviews about Zac are from bad reviews about the movies
-
And I don’t understand the problem of get the “first reviews”, they are in order of publication, not in order of “praise for Zac”, so I am not unfair. =)

Bo

Those videos are great.

Am I missing something?

@Challenge for Maria: You just proved that Zac Efron fans virtually have too much time on their hands and have no life. Isn’t this thread supposed to be about Hudgens?

Am I missing something?

That said…I’ve seen some of the morons i.e. fans that post on Efron’s threads. Most couldn’t spell or form a single, articulate sentence if their lives depended on it and they were handed a Webster’s dictionary. You lose IQ points simply by scrolling through that mess.