they are 2 different aminals IMO.... for target use and plinking i would choose the buckmark out of the 2, your going to get better accuracy and in my experience be able to use cheap ammo if you choose.....that said i would also look at rugers offerings the MKI ,, MKII,, MKIII, and 22/45 models are all great and are some of my personal favorites... i personally reccomend the MKII