With 12 days left until Christmas, don’t just buy them a CD or a band t-shirt this year, get them something personal from their favorite artist like a One Direction body pillow, a Celine Dion watch or a Lady Gaga toothbrush.

Last night at the 64th Annual Emmy Awards, Josh Groban showed off not only his angelic voice but his sense of humor when he turned One Direction’s “What Makes You Beautiful” into a touching ballad, which got us thinking, what other songs could Groban make all his own?