Apparently, Ben Arfa says it is muscle and he’s bulked up in a good way. We shall see.

What cannot be disputed in Le Parisien’s story is that arguably the most naturally gifted footballer at the club is being forced out.

Actually, scrub that. It’s not arguable.

He is the most naturally gifted player at the club and yet he is going to be let go if a deal can be done.

Ben Arfa was carrying a few extra pounds a year ago, and looked less then 100% throughout pre-season.

If he is guilty of the same 12 months on, then that’s really bad form.

He won’t be going to New Zealand this week with the squad, having been told to train with the reserves, and with a year to go on his current contract, if these claims are true, it seems that it would be best for all if Newcastle could sell the player.

So even if the player is fighting fit, something is wrong.

And while there are some who blame Alan Pardew for this sad state, it’s interesting to note that more fans are getting to the end of their tether with this flawed and yet at times wonderful footballer.

As one correspondent on our website said: “There are certain things we can blame Pardew for but not HBA putting on weight.

“That’s definitely down to the player, and in my opinion he’s looked overweight for the last season or two.

“(And) he’s lost his touch, his flair and now his waistline to boot. Time to get rid.”

One time, not so long ago, this comment would have been shouted down. Not any more.

“He’s had his moments, but lets the rare good performances go to his head. Turned into a petulant prima donna who thinks he is bigger than the club. Let him go,” said another.

There are some, of course, who still back the man. The memories of him skipping past four Bolton Wanderers players on the way to scoring one of the best goals St James’ Park has ever witnessed remain fresh in the memory.

That was two years ago, right enough.

As one said: “I can’t say I believe this. I saw him on Saturday and he looked fit as a fiddle. If anything judging by his arms he’s gained muscle.”

Three years ago, Liverpool were on the trail of the mercurial star and a fee of £20m was quoted. Now they want to sell him before he leaves on a free next summer. No matter who is to blame, it’s a terrible waste of talent.