I bought deepest black but strangely if you try to sharpen it, good luck with that. It does not sharpen well. Lead inside the pencil is extremely soft to sharpen. I tried to freeze it before I sharpen it....no luck. So if you don't mind spending $ 6 for using it only twice. It is not for me.

I have tried so many black eyeliners . Pencil and cream. This is the best . Super creamy, glides on very smoothly without tugging your eyelids. Lasts even on my waterline (the only eyeliner to ever last ) This is pure black. It's the darkest one one I have found. Get the total intensity pencil sharpener , as other sharpeners eat this pencil up . I have repurchased many times. I won't use any other liner except this. $5.95 is the price.

My favorite black eyeliner. Super creamy and pigmented. It does smudge on my waterline after a few hours, but not as much as every other liner I have tried. The only issue is since it's so soft , sharpening it is a little difficult, since it tends to break off in the sharpener .

I used to only use Urban Decay 24/7 Glide-On eye liner pencils. However, once I tried Prestige Total Intensity gel eye liner, I ditched UD. They feel the same and glide on just as smooth and stays on. And best part, they are a fraction of the price yet quality is equally good. I can no longer justify spending $20 on a gel eyeliner when there are plenty of other less expensive ones that are just as great quality with a different brand name stamped on.

I had bought the purple previously and when this brand went on sale (half off where I've seen it) I stocked up on the brand and got this line in brown and black. This whole line (and brand in general to be honest) is extremely pigmented. I like all the colors I have.

Like most gel liners, it does smudge a bit in the waterline. But, I do notice it being better than some other gel liners in that it actually deposits nicely and I have no issues with it on the top of the lid. Another thing I like about gel liners (as long as they are pigmented enough) is that you can rub them onto a liner brush and get a more winged lok with them, which you really can't do with a standard pencil (too dry in my opinion or even sharpened well they aren't usually as pigmented). It's not perfect like a liquid or the gel liners in a pot but at least you can play up the variety of looks that way, especially for the colors.

I actually prefer their velvety smokey liner to this one, and probably the L'oreal Extra Intense carbon black one second as they smudge less. So it's not my top favorite black pencil liner, but it's pretty good for it's pigmentation. I say stock up on this brand now while it's still around and half off, since they're pretty amazing in general.

Absolutely adore this eyeliner. The formula is so creamy, pigmented and goes on the eyelid very smoothly, no tugging whatsoever. Unfortunately, as with every pencil/crayon liner I've tried, I do notice a bit of smudging under my eyes after a few hours. Still, this is a fabulous eyeliner and the price is hard to beat!

Prestige is definitely an under rated brand.. They recently rebranded and repackaged their total intensity line. I had to try the pencil liner- gel formula, similar to March Jacobs gel liner (ck the ingredients). The pencil delivers a richest deepest black and is very smooth to apply,.

I have super oily upper lids, that hooded, that makes any pencil, or gel liner travel...I mean any and all, some more so than others. Given this, I didn't intend to use this for my upper lids, only the bottom lids.

For this, I found it stayed on very well, with very slight smudging, on my bottom/lower lid and I tested this in the summer's humidity, with no powder to set. For those who don't have the oily/hooded problem like mine, I can see this used for the upper waterline ,for tight lining, and any part of upper lids....Just..give it time to set and don't draw over too many times or the build-up layers will smudge with any liners. For those looking for a great bottom liner eyeliner, I say try this. .. I say it stays better than the Milani's liquefy-eye pencil.

Just discovered this liner from MA reviews and I'm so happy I did. First of all, it's really cheap. The packaging is nice and simple and easy to hold. I have pretty oily eyelids, so liquid liner doesn't work well (it skips spaces) and I'm not skilled enough to use those gel pots. It just glides on so easily and has amazing staying power. I love this stuff.

This eyeliner is amazing. Very deep, pigmented black and it stays really well, including on the waterline. I actually like it better than UD 24/7 in Perversion -- it's equally black but doesn't irritate my eyes like Perversion does on the waterline. Current fave!