How Surround Sound Works

In the first part of his series on surround sound, Michael Miller explored the history of the technology. Good background info, but how exactly does sound from a surround sound system "surround" you? He explains in this article that it's actually less complicated than you might think.

From the author of

From the author of

By definition, surround sound is sound that surrounds youin
particular, music or movie soundtracks that come at you from all sides, thanks
to multiple audio channels fed through speakers positioned in all corners of the
room. In a home theater system, the surround sound is initially encoded onto a
programming sourcea DVD, a cable or satellite broadcast, and so on. When
the programming is played, the surround sound tracks are extracted from the
source by a piece of electronics called a surround decoder. The
individual surround channels are then amplified and fed to the appropriate
speakers. The result is sound that envelops you as you watch your movie or
listen to your CD.

How do all those channels of audio get from their source to your ears?
It's all a matter of technology. Two primary technologies are used for
surround sound today: the older matrix surround, typified by Dolby Pro
Logic, and the newer discrete surround, as used in the Dolby Digital
system. We'll look at both, starting with the oldest first.

Matrix Surround

The original home surround technology tried to pull off the
impossibleturning two things into four. That's because, at the time
(we're talking the early 1990s herea virtual lifetime ago), the
videotapes and laserdiscs we were watching barely had space to carry two
stereophonic channels, let alone the four channels necessary for a complete
surround experience. Engineers could fit right and left channels onto the tape
or the disc, but no more than that. So where to put the extra channels?

To stuff four channels of information into the space normally used by two,
the engineers at Dolby Laboratories used a matrixing technology. This
enabled them to combine four streams of information into two tracks, and then
retrieve the original four channels on playbacksometimes referred to as a
4-2-4 processing system. (They took four channels, crammed them into two
channels, and then separated them into two channels again: 4-2-4.)

Does that sound a little tricky? It was. Imagine mixing streams of red,
green, blue, and purple sand together in a bucket, carrying the bucket across a
room, and then trying to extract the individual colors at the other end. Messy
at best, and perhaps even impossible to separate into the original colors.

The Dolby engineers figured out how to do it, however. By analyzing the audio
information contained within the left and right channels, they could identify
the information that was the same in both channels. They realized that they
could mix information from a third channel into both the left and right
channels, compare the two channels, and then extract that information (the third
channel) that was identical in the two channels. They could even get a fourth
channel into the mix, by recording it out of phase with the third channel and
then also feeding it to the left and right channels.

Using this approach, the Dolby engineers devised the following data
streams:

Stream A (left channel)

Stream B (right channel)

Stream C (the data that's identical in streams A and B)

Stream D (the difference between the data in streams A and B)

Obviously, streams A and B carried the normal left and right channel
information. The engineers used stream C to carry center channel information,
and stream D to carry information for the surround channel. (This technology
only allowed for a single surround channel, even though this single channel was
often fed to two rear speakers.)

Here's how the whole thing works. Left channel information is fed into
data stream A, and right channel information into stream B. Center channel
information is placed into both the A and B streamsthus resulting in the
"identical" stream C. The surround channel information is also
recorded on streams A and B, but placed out of phase to the second stream. This
creates stream D, the "difference" stream.

Thus, the videotape, videodisc, or television programanything that can
carry a stereo signalis encoded with these four data streams. If you
listen to the program through a normal stereo audio system, it sounds like
normal stereothe center channel information comes out (in equal portions)
through both the left and right channels, as does the surround channel
information. No one knows the difference; the positioning of the new streams is
effectively "hidden."

But when you run the program through a surround decoder, everything changes.
The decoder passes the data in streams A and B directly to the left and right
amplifiers. It identifies the identical data between these two streams and
extracts it into the decoded stream C, which is sent to the center channel
amplifier. The decoder then identifies the differential data in streams A and B
(the out-of-phase information), shifts them relative to each other so
they're back in phase, and sends the stream to the surround channel
amplifier.

The only bad thing about this processcalled Dolby Pro
Logicis that it's not terribly precise. That's because when
everything gets all mixed together, it doesn't always separate out
completely, resulting in some degree of leakage from one channel to another. But
the results are surprisingly effectiveparticularly when the surround
channel contains primarily ambient effects. However, if you want to clearly
position a sound source in the surround channel, the effect is less than
impressive; no matter how effective the decoder, there will always be some
duplication of the sound in the front channels, which spoils the effect. How,
then, to better separate the surround channel sound?