Today's Deals

This restaurant's overall star value is determined by comparing its ratings against
those of other restaurants in the same city.

A teacher might call this grading on a curve. At Seamless, this means that regardless
of their actual tally, restaurants with the highest ratings will have five stars,
those with average ratings will have three, and the not-so-favorite restaurants
will have the least number of stars.

So pay it forward to the Seamless community. Rate and review places you've tried
so we can all find food happiness!

We automatically select the best deal for you!

Johnny's pizzeria was first established in 1968 by owner John Miniaci Sr. John opened his pizzeria with nothing but high hopes for the community of Sunset Park. He didn't want to own just an ordinary business, but he wanted to have a relationship with every customer that walked through his door. As the community welcomed John and his pizzeria to the neighborhood that is exactly what happened. Johnny's pizzeria became a household name. When the customers came to Johnny's they knew they would find their Johnny's family right behind the counter which were of course John himself, his two sons John Miniaci Jr. & Louie Miniaci, his son- in law Rocco Coluccio and his loyal and caring staff . John's motto was always about the value of family and creating an environment around Sunset Park that simply says "WELCOME". Johnny Had passed the pizzeria over to his son John Miniaci Jr. and son in law Rocco Coluccio due to heart problems, but that never stopped him from checking in on his second home : Johnny's Pizzeria & his second family which were his loyal customers he knew by a first name basis. John Sr. had always instilled in John & Rocco's heads the power of family and he taught them that the respect they gave their customers over the years is the reason. Johnny's Pizzeria will mark its 40th anniversary in May 2008.

In 40 years of business there is only one thing that has changed which is that on July 5th 2007 John Miniaci Sr. had passed away due to complications of a stroke. Due to the love and respect he had for his customers and his family is the reason his beloved pizzeria is a household name today. The guidance and leadership that John Miniaci Sr. has given to John and Rocco over the years is the reason they are still able to provide Sunset Park a place that they can always call home.

As Johnny would always say:
THERE IS ALWAYS ROOM AT OUR TABLE FOR YOU.

Reviews for Johnny's Pizzeria

Best pizza in Brooklyn! They'll make it the way you want it... Just ask

Written by
Jenn O.
on
10/14/2014
|
Member since
2014
Jenn
ordered from here
within the last month

Service from here has ranged from very good to very bad. With the delivery fee, it makes it so I would not recommend this establishment.

Written by
Steven C.
on
8/23/2014
|
3 other reviews |
Member since
2013
Steven
ordered from here
within the last year

The food is good but it is very cold at times.

Written by
Rajeev M.
on
4/14/2014
|
1 other review |
Member since
2014
Rajeev
ordered from here
within the last month

hot, tasty and greasy in a good way. takes a bit longer than expected for how close i live.

Written by
Lynne A.
on
4/8/2014
|
11 other reviews |
Member since
2012
Lynne
ordered from here
over a year ago

I have been ordering from this spot since the moment I have moved into the neighborhood summer of 2012. I can honestly say the best pizza in Brooklyn.

Written by
Luis T.
on
2/25/2014
|
4 other reviews |
Member since
2013
Luis
ordered from here
within the last month

The food was fine but the delivery man made a point of complaining that I only spent $9.92... "You really should spend more than ten dollars next time even though you put a tip". Extremely rude. Wish I didn't even give them a tip. I'll order from somewhere else next time, and Johnny's should increase their minimum and slash the discount if they're going to be jerks about it.

Written by
Cristina G.
on
2/22/2014
|
4 other reviews |
Member since
2013
Cristina
ordered from here
over a year ago

Best Grandma pizza ever

Written by
Steven M.
on
12/15/2013
|
3 other reviews |
Member since
2013
Steven
ordered from here
within the last year

Decent

Written by
Jenn L.
on
12/6/2013
|
5 other reviews |
Member since
2012
Jenn
ordered from here
over a year ago

Fast Delivery, Amazing Food.. You get so much pasta and meat on your order. Its like family style!

Written by
Antonio R.
on
10/25/2013
|
Member since
2013
Antonio
ordered from here
over a year ago

After four years in Sunset Park I am prepared to award Johnny's the title of best pizza in the neighborhood, at least from my vantage point on 51st St and 5th Ave. Strong combo of quality/price/speed. Always nice to support a business that has been owned by the same family for a long time. Grandma Pie is my pick here.

Written by
Peter B.
on
10/12/2013
|
Member since
2013
Peter
ordered from here
within the last year

Food is good but the delivery guy is really bad " next time i dont come, it's an asshole to come" he said, Thank you for the food .. I regret my $2 tip

Written by
Ronan P.
on
4/30/2013
|
6 other reviews |
Member since
2013
Ronan
ordered from here
over a year ago

Thick crust pizza was horrible - never ordering from here again!

Written by
Melissa G.
on
11/27/2012
|
6 other reviews |
Member since
2012
Melissa
ordered from here
over a year ago

Ordered 2 sicilian slices and I think that was the worst pizza I have ever ate. Couldn't even finish one slice.

Written by
Jackie O.
on
12/12/2011
|
2 other reviews |
Member since
2008
Jackie
ordered from here
over a year ago

Best pizza in Brooklyn, in my opinion. Try out their Sicilian pie

Written by
Chad L.
on
10/31/2011
|
30 other reviews |
Member since
2011
Chad
ordered from here
over a year ago

We have only ordered the pizza here and it has been pretty good. They do not skimp on the toppings, the cheese had that perfect melt and the crust was not too thick. Why only 3 stars? First off, charging a delivery fee is outrageous. There are OTHER FREE places that are better to choose from. Next, they were late... like it took them over an hour to reach us and we don't live too far away! I'll be sticking with my usual pizzeria...

Written by
Michelle G.
on
9/15/2011
|
24 other reviews |
Member since
2010
Michelle
ordered from here
within the last month