Republicans reject Bush's anti-terror law

Thursday 14 September 2006 19.45 EDT
First published on Thursday 14 September 2006 19.45 EDT

George Bush suffered a serious rebuff yesterday to his demand to grant the CIA and the military a freer hand in the war on terror after Senate Republicans moved to block legislation that would allow coercive interrogations of detainees.

The show of defiance came hours after Mr Bush made a rare visit to Capitol Hill to drum up support for White House proposals to limit America's commitment to the Geneva convention on treatment of prisoners. Four Senate Republicans, including John Warner, the chairman of the armed services committee, joined Democrats to vote against the proposals setting the stage for a showdown with the White House.

The struggle within the Republican party deepened further yesterday when it emerged that the former secretary of state and general Colin Powell had also repudiated the White House's plans.

In a letter to Senator John McCain - one of three powerful Republicans opposed to White House proposals for new legislation on detainees - Mr Powell said it would be a mistake to reduce America's commitment to the Geneva convention. "The world is beginning to doubt the moral basis of our fight against terrorism," he wrote. The letter, written on Wednesday, was released by Mr McCain yesterday.

The Senate vote was a setback to White House efforts to bring in legislation before November's midterm congressional elections for which Republicans plan to campaign as tough on national security.

But Mr Powell added his voice to those of military judges who said the US would imperil its own soldiers if it watered down compliance with the Geneva convention.