New York magazine writes, "The shop has an amazing selection of plants...and features one of the most extensive selections of bulbs and seeds in the city." The Garden Shop carries garden supplies and books, gifts for children and adults, and an extensive selection of indoor plants and seasonal outdoor plants, as well as bulbs and seeds.

Throughout the shop, visitors will also find artisanal gifts, jewelry, and housewares from around the world. Exclusive to the Garden Shop are signature items with the Garden's distinctive logo and products featuring the artwork of Brooklyn Botanic Garden's Florilegium Society, including prints and stationery. To complement the many children's activities at BBG, the shop offers a huge selection of nature and gardening toys, books, and crafts for kids.

All profits benefit the Garden. Visa, MasterCard, Discover, and American Express are accepted.