Besides that, there is nobody Sanchez cant be better than in the future. (Only because they will be right in the middle of their primes when Sanchez starts to hit his)

Seriously no disrespect to the guy because I'm notorious for being down on Sanchez and I'm not trying to add insult to injury here, literally, because he cut down on mistakes and I feel looked more like an NFL QB today than Jay Cutler...he really isn't in this class. His stats are bloated by working the middle of the field..roll-outs, swing passes, quick hitches, and his receivers doing a good job of making YAC. And that's the reality of his numbers. He went downfield twice today...a nice td to Holmes after the DB slipped and left him wide open...and incomplete to Edwards. If you wanna say he had a pretty good game and is headed in the right direction now to start year 3, ok. But this stuff here...this is why I'm not a Sanchez guy and its not a bias whatsoever...if Eli Manning was receiving un-due hype for w yard dump-offs or his receivers doing most of the work, Id call him on it. Edwards will probably be gone next year too...and the young excuse no longer is valid. Year 3 is time to step up...and even he knows he's got to get better. Sloooow down on him.

Seriously no disrespect to the guy because I'm notorious for being down on Sanchez and I'm not trying to add insult to injury here, literally, because he cut down on mistakes and I feel looked more like an NFL QB today than Jay Cutler...he really isn't in this class. His stats are bloated by working the middle of the field..roll-outs, swing passes, quick hitches, and his receivers doing a good job of making YAC. And that's the reality of his numbers. He went downfield twice today...a nice td to Holmes after the DB slipped and left him wide open...and incomplete to Edwards. If you wanna say he had a pretty good game and is headed in the right direction now to start year 3, ok. But this stuff here...this is why I'm not a Sanchez guy and its not a bias whatsoever...if Eli Manning was receiving un-due hype for w yard dump-offs or his receivers doing most of the work, Id call him on it. Edwards will probably be gone next year too...and the young excuse no longer is valid. Year 3 is time to step up...and even he knows he's got to get better. Sloooow down on him.

Read the post....he has a loooong way to go. Top 5 guys can beat you with one arm tied behind thwir back and a leaky defense allowing 50+ points. Sanchez is a looooong ways away from that status. And even Rex Ryan and Mark Sanchez knows that. They'd both laugh at that post. Mark Sanchez knows he's not even close to Philip Rivers, let alone Manning or Brady.

Read the post....he has a loooong way to go. Top 5 guys can beat you with one arm tied behind thwir back and a leaky defense allowing 50+ points. Sanchez is a looooong ways away from that status. And even Rex Ryan and Mark Sanchez knows that. They'd both laugh at that post. Mark Sanchez knows he's not even close to Philip Rivers, let alone Manning or Brady.

So because he doesnt go down field as much as you would like and "lets" his recievers make plays after the catch, he will not be elite?

So because he doesnt go down field as much as you would like and "lets" his recievers make plays after the catch, he will not be elite?

Yeah I would say that's a big limitation. He throws quuck screens so much that teams have it scouted and you often see defenders trying to jump them. Its the most simplistic offensive play-calling that everything has to go their way for them to be able to win. They relied on crazy come from behind miracles that you'd only see on a Buffalo Wild Wings commercial all year long to compensate for playing like crap 3 3/3 of a game. Great QBs don't just lean on the defense most of the game and make a throw or 2 that counts during an entire game. There is never a game you could come away from saying "man he played great"...if you aren't a Jets fan to begin with. Start there. Make him win you games..throw 3-4 tds a game without a few to the other team dropped or otherwise. Some website tallied his dropped ints this season at 12. If you want I can dig the link up from the other Sanchez thread but that means he threw 27 to the other team in total. Improve that number drastically, be more of a guy that teams need to fear who can beat you deep without a DB slipping, or dink and dunk. He could be that guy but it isn't anytime soon.

I'll give credit to Sanchez in the 2nd half, but when you're up 24-3, you tend to play a little 'loose' and Sanchez took advantage right off the bat. He played very good, but just because this is a common opponent, doesn't make him better than Flacco. If I remember correctly early in the year, Flacco was making plays and completing passes for big gains against the same Steeler defense.

You can argue all you want Jets fans, but fact is, Sanchez and the entire offense didn't have a pulse in the 1st half. I don't know what the heck the Steelers were doing in the 2nd half but in my opinion, being from PA, and see the Steelers a lot on TV, Troy Polumolu didn't look at his best.

All these QBs are young and some haven't tasted post season success or haven't even seen the post season. But to tell me Sanchez is going to be a top 5 QB because he's 4-2 in the postseason? Dilfer won a super bowl. Is he better than Marino? Sanchez, for the majority of his career so far, hasn't been asked to do much. He's had a top 3 OL, running game, and defense carry him most of the way and he is by far in THE best situation out of all the other young QBs.

I'll give credit to Sanchez in the 2nd half, but when you're up 24-3, you tend to play a little 'loose' and Sanchez took advantage right off the bat. He played very good, but just because this is a common opponent, doesn't make him better than Flacco. If I remember correctly early in the year, Flacco was making plays and completing passes for big gains against the same Steeler defense.

You can argue all you want Jets fans, but fact is, Sanchez and the entire offense didn't have a pulse in the 1st half. I don't know what the heck the Steelers were doing in the 2nd half but in my opinion, being from PA, and see the Steelers a lot on TV, Troy Polumolu didn't look at his best.

All these QBs are young and some haven't tasted post season success or haven't even seen the post season. But to tell me Sanchez is going to be a top 5 QB because he's 4-2 in the postseason? Dilfer won a super bowl. Is he better than Marino? Sanchez, for the majority of his career so far, hasn't been asked to do much. He's had a top 3 OL, running game, and defense carry him most of the way and he is by far in THE best situation out of all the other young QBs.

I'll give Sanchez where credit is due and almost pulled off an incredible upset. However, most have even said in the month of December, no QB was better than Freeman, not even a guy named Brady.

Josh Freeman with all the offensive weapons the Jets have would be deadly. He could put a motivated Braylon Edwards back in the Pro Bowl with his cannon arm. No one wants to admit it but they should have waited and taken Freeman.

It's hard to do these rankings because these are all damn good QBs. Interchangeable in a lot of different areas. I have Stafford listed as my worst, but he was to stay healthy he could be right at the top. I can honestly see all of these guys in the top 10 QBs within the next 3-4 years.

Yeah I would say that's a big limitation. He throws quuck screens so much that teams have it scouted and you often see defenders trying to jump them. Its the most simplistic offensive play-calling that everything has to go their way for them to be able to win.

Sounds like you have a much bigger problem with Schotty than you do with Sanchez to be honest

Quote:

Originally Posted by JPP90

They relied on crazy come from behind miracles that you'd only see on a Buffalo Wild Wings commercial all year long to compensate for playing like crap 3 3/3 of a game. Great QBs don't just lean on the defense most of the game and make a throw or 2 that counts during an entire game. There is never a game you could come away from saying "man he played great"...if you aren't a Jets fan to begin with.

Really? How about when he played Houston, Cleveland, Detroit, Chicago, NE (both games besides 45-3) or Pitt today

Quote:

Originally Posted by JPP90

Start there. Make him win you games..throw 3-4 tds a game without a few to the other team dropped or otherwise. Some website tallied his dropped ints this season at 12. If you want I can dig the link up from the other Sanchez thread but that means he threw 27 to the other team in total. Improve that number drastically, be more of a guy that teams need to fear who can beat you deep without a DB slipping, or dink and dunk. He could be that guy but it isn't anytime soon.

Ummmm....... He has shown both the ability to win his team games and throw 3 TD's. Dropped INT's are a meaningless stat IMO, defenses always drop picks. Ben had 2 picks dropped today, yet everyone will (rightfully) praise him for "making plays when it mattered."

Bottom line is this, hear me out. Last year Sanchez's biggest problem was taking care of the football. He fixed that this year (from 23 to 14). This year his biggest problem was inconsistent accuracy. If (seems pretty plausible to me) he fixes that this off-season, what weaknesses will he have as a QB? He has the arm, legs, and mind of an elite QB, it just takes a little time to put it all together. Year 3 is when we will start to see it all clicking

Sounds like you have a much bigger problem with Schotty than you do with Sanchez to be honest

Really? How about when he played Houston, Cleveland, Detroit, Chicago, NE (both games besides 45-3) or Pitt today

Bottom line is this, hear me out. Last year Sanchez's biggest problem was taking care of the football. He fixed that this year (from 23 to 14). This year his biggest problem was inconsistent accuracy. If (seems pretty plausible to me) he fixes that this off-season, what weaknesses will he have as a QB? He has the arm, legs, and mind of an elite QB, it just takes a little time to put it all together. Year 3 is when we will start to see it all clicking

If that's the truth, then Freeman and the young Bucs might be dangerous.

Sounds like you have a much bigger problem with Schotty than you do with Sanchez to be honest

Really? How about when he played Houston, Cleveland, Detroit, Chicago, NE (both games besides 45-3) or Pitt today

Ummmm....... He has shown both the ability to win his team games and throw 3 TD's. Dropped INT's are a meaningless stat IMO, defenses always drop picks. Ben had 2 picks dropped today, yet everyone will (rightfully) praise him for "making plays when it mattered."

Bottom line is this, hear me out. Last year Sanchez's biggest problem was taking care of the football. He fixed that this year (from 23 to 14). This year his biggest problem was inconsistent accuracy. If (seems pretty plausible to me) he fixes that this off-season, what weaknesses will he have as a QB? He has the arm, legs, and mind of an elite QB, it just takes a little time to put it all together. Year 3 is when we will start to see it all clicking

Funy you reference all the games where he made a bunch of mistakes and had to compensate for it by making a throw or 2 at the end. I see the whole complete picture here. In Miami, you threw the game away twice on the final drive..whether you want to count them or not. In Detroit, you lose the game if Drew Stanton falls on the ball and runs the clock. Cleveland..another loss if Stuckey isn't stripped at the end of the game OR if Elam holds onto your interception. Houston was Buffalo Wild Wings. Only the Houston secoondary gives that up. Worst secondary in the league. You see the trends...they had to compensate for him to win...he had to compensate for himself. Even in Indy, he didn't win that game. He was lucky his team was in the game in spite of him. He has his moments and he gets in grooves but he is still extremely streaky, unreliable and still mistake-prone. I count dropped ints...they are there, undeniable, bad decisions dropped or not and I saw Bens tonight..and I saw that Sanchez had 0 too. I won't defend Ben...he had a bad game and the defense bailed him out. I'm not as high on Ben as some people. Very talented QB with a great defense that you never know what you're gonna get from. If Sanchez throws 14 or 15 true interceptions in a season, ill be impressed. Its alarming he made so many mistakes this year though with the offense dumbed down to prevent them. Its nice that he can win a game if his team is put at the 40 and he needs 2 completions for a FG but that's a baby step. John Skelton could do that for you with a 6'5 WR. I'm looking for 4 good quarters of football from Sanchez next year on a consistent basis. Until then, I'm more impressed with the progress of Sam Bradford and Josh Freeman hand-cuffed with less talent.

Funny you reference all the games where he made a bunch of mistakes and had to compensate for it by making a throw or 2 at the end. I see the whole complete picture here. In Miami, you threw the game away twice on the final drive..whether you want to count them or not. In Detroit, you lose the game if Drew Stanton falls on the ball and runs the clock. Cleveland..another loss if Stuckey isn't stripped at the end of the game OR if Elam holds onto your interception. Houston was Buffalo Wild Wings. Only the Houston secoondary gives that up. Worst secondary in the league. You see the trends...they had to compensate for him to win...he had to compensate for himself. Even in Indy, he didn't win that game. He was lucky his team was in the game in spite of him.

Are you ******* kidding me man? So what your saying is that we should discredit all the good things he does and emphasize the mistakes he makes. Sounds like a pretty fool-proof strategy to win an argument. The bolded sentence is where you almost got it right, except that Sanchez has been compensating for the other members of this team

Quote:

Originally Posted by JPP90

He has his moments and he gets in grooves but he is still extremely streaky, unreliable and still mistake-prone.

Yes he is streaky, but that is assumed with a young, inexperienced QB. The few times in his career he has been relied on to win the game, he has come through. Mainly however, Schotty has tailored this offense to not rely on Sanchez to win games, and basically force him into managing the game. Mistake Prone? He had 11 less turnovers this year than he did last year, clearly he is learning to take care of the ball

Quote:

Originally Posted by JPP90

I count dropped ints...they are there, undeniable, bad decisions dropped or not and I saw Bens tonight..and I saw that Sanchez had 0 too. I won't defend Ben...he had a bad game and the defense bailed him out. I'm not as high on Ben as some people. Very talented QB with a great defense that you never know what you're gonna get from. If Sanchez throws 14 or 15 true interceptions in a season, ill be impressed. Its alarming he made so many mistakes this year though with the offense dumbed down to prevent them. Its nice that he can win a game if his team is put at the 40 and he needs 2 completions for a FG but that's a baby step. John Skelton could do that for you with a 6'5 WR. I'm looking for 4 good quarters of football from Sanchez next year on a consistent basis. Until then, I'm more impressed with the progress of Sam Bradford and Josh Freeman hand-cuffed with less talent.

That is nice. You know what else is nice? Throwing for 200+ yards and 2 TD's against the best D in the NFL in the biggest game of your career. Or having 9 TD's vs. 3 INT's in your post-season career. Just because Sanchez has considerable room for improvement doesn't mean he isnt already on his way to becoming a damn good QB