It was my big idea to turn our next neighborhood wine tasting into a spaghetti dinner, and now I've got to come up with the goods. How does one actually deal with that kind of quantity and not serve gummy, stupid pasta? I'm thinking that preparing the noodles to extreme al denti, then refreshing in boiling water, will do the trick, but I've never done it. I'm going to test the efficacy to get it right (using mostaccioli instead of string/long noodles, for sturdiness), but I'm still wondering if anyone else has done it and has any tips to offer. We obviously can't plan on cooking 15 pounds of pasta the conventional way.....

My wine shopping and I have never had a problem. Just a perpetual race between the bankruptcy court and Hell.--Rogov

Jenise wrote:It was my big idea to turn our next neighborhood wine tasting into a spaghetti dinner, and now I've got to come up with the goods. How does one actually deal with that kind of quantity and not serve gummy, stupid pasta? I'm thinking that preparing the noodles to extreme al denti, then refreshing in boiling water, will do the trick, but I've never done it. I'm going to test the efficacy to get it right (using mostaccioli instead of string/long noodles, for sturdiness), but I'm still wondering if anyone else has done it and has any tips to offer. We obviously can't plan on cooking 15 pounds of pasta the conventional way.....

You have two choices. Holding it in cold water will work for a short period. If you have to hold the pasta for a few hours, toss it in olive oil. Yeah, I know the sauce won't stick as well, but on the other hand, the pasta won't stick to itself either.

15 lbs. of pasta seems like a lot for 50 people, unless you mean 15 lbs. cooked, or about 5 lbs. dry. An alternative to Chef Carey's suggestion of tossing with olive oil is to cook it al denti, toss it with a small quantity of the tomato pasta sauce, put it in one of those aluminum foil pans, cover with foil and keep warm in a 175 deg oven while you cook the rest.

It's doable - not ideal, but doable, and your instincts are taking you in the right direction.

Par cook your pasta in manageable batches - say 2lb increments.

Pull it before it reaches al dente - cool it as quickly as possible. Perhaps spreading it out on sheet pans will speed the process.

I agree that tossing with olive oil will keep the pasta edible.

For service - just have a very large pot of simmering water - dunk the pasta in the water to bring it to temp - and serve. While you're serving up one increment of the pasta, another can go into the hot water.

One thing I learned when feeding crowds - if your sauce is hot, it covers up the fact that your pasta might not be as hot as it should be.

I really don't like serving pasta this way, but if your back is against the wall, what are you going to do?

Of the hundreds of things I learned from my Mom about feeding large numbers of people - one was that baked pasta is always a less stressful alternative. I guess that's why we always had lasanga on holidays.
I would strongly suggest doing five or six hotel pans of baked ziti and calling it a day. You can get all the work done ahead of time and enjoy the party - unless you're lacking oven space.
Then, you're screwed.

I'm not sure I'd agree with that, Howie, unless a lot of Jenise's guests are picky eaters. As we've discussed here before, my standard pasta ration is 2 to 4 ounces of <i>dry</i> pasta per person - the former as a side dish or if counting calories/carbs, the latter for a generous portion. Fifty people times 4 ounces is 200 ounces or 12.5 pounds, so Jenise's plan for 15 pounds isn't that far off - and if the pasta dish is to be the main course, a lot of people will eat more than 4 ounces.

I like the idea of the baked spaghetti. I've done this several times for large groups, or to take to an event. This is not your elegant al dente dish, rather savory and comforting, and darn tasty. My recipe is a rather simple one, created by the wife of my dentist while they were raising their nine children. Some of the ingredients are 1 lb. each of spaghetti, bacon, and cheddar cheese. It also has tomato soup and a few other things I cannot recall now. But you could bake the typical red sauce and meatball type too. I'm sure there are others on sites like EPI, Chowhound, etc.
Saves lots of work. I use my 22 lb. roaster and fill it up.

One more suggestion...first, I like the spreading on sheet pans to cool so you don't have to olive oil it AND you keep the starch on it. Did that at one restaurant in Philadelphia and the flavor...yum

And skip the reheat in water step...Instead, reheat it in the sauce. If it's a cream sauce, think with cream; tomato? thin with more sauce or some broth...the cook it until it's hot and the pasta soft. That was Union Square's method. Works great and eliminates one step.

Barb, I appreciate that idea and it's easy to do one batch or so at a time, but the gentleman who is making the sauce prefers plain noodles with sauce over. I found that out when I lobbed John/Karen's idea. And that's okay, I get my way often enough. Going to have to do the water bath. BUT YOU'VE GIVEN ME ANOTHER GOOD IDEA: I'll save some of the cooking water and use that for the refreshing stage instead of starting with clean--it will be much tastier. Thank you!

My wine shopping and I have never had a problem. Just a perpetual race between the bankruptcy court and Hell.--Rogov