Though "The Terms of My Surrender" was not a top show at the box office, Playbill.com reported, Moore's show did complete it's full scheduled run. Still, it mostly grossed less than half of its potential and drew in a capacity around the 70th percentile.

Moore went on to chastise Trump for focusing on his broadway show instead of fallen service members in Afghanistan, the first charges filed in the Russia investigation and the ongoing crisis in Puerto Rico after Hurricane Maria. He claimed that "The Terms of My Surrender" was the highest grossing non-musical of the summer. While it was the highest grossing of those that opened in the summer, Playbill.com reported, "The Play That Goes Wrong" grossed more in the 12 weeks Moore's play was open.

This is not the first time Trump has taken on a Broadway show. In Nov. 2016, then-President-Elect Trump criticized Lin-Manuel Miranda's "Hamilton" after castmembers took time onstage to address then-Vice-President-Elect Mike Pence, who was sitting in the audience of the Pulitzer Prize-winning musical. Trump said Pence was "harassed" and that the cast was "very rude"