Cons: “Here in the Rockies, solid wood tops tend to warp or even separate,” Landeros warns. “Butcher blocks require constant high humidity and must be oiled or treated with a moisturizing cream.” Nicks and scratches are inevitable, and you’ll need a trivet for hot pans.

Style Match: “Any area where you want to get away from a more sterile, clean look,” Landeros says—think seating areas, buffets, benches, and desks.

Installed PPSF: $85 to $130

Tip: Look for a warranty that covers warping and splitting. “I’ve found Spekva material to be very stable,” Landeros says.

3. Stainless Steel

Pros: Heat, stains, and bacteria are no match for this ultra-durable material.

Cons: “Clients are occasionally put off by the scratching that occurs, though after a few months, the scratches even out to a nice patina,” says Mike Smith, technical designer for Studio Como.

Style Match: Its modern-industrial look is a natural complement to streamlined cabinets, but it also looks cool with rustic reclaimed wood.

Installed PPSF: $85 to $150

Tip: Rather than waiting for scratches to appear, take a cue from some of Smith’s clients and scrub your new countertop with steel wool on day one.

4. Glass

Pros: It’s almost as hygienic and stain-resistant as stainless steel but has many more design and color options. With some basic care, it’ll look like new for years.

Cons: This pricey choice shows fingerprints, and cracks and scratches are a possibility.

Style Match: Ideal for modern kitchens. Pair with glossy lacquered cabinetry for a super-streamlined look.

Installed PPSF: $65 to $300

Tip: “It’s worth getting a sample of any glass you’re considering and using it as a trivet to see how it withstands heat—as not all glass is created equal,” Smith says.

5. Quartzite

Pros: The beauty of marble without the worry: Harder than granite, quartzite shrugs off moisture, heat, scratches, and stains.

Cons: “It’s the most unique choice, but also the most expensive,” says Mikal Otten, owner of Exquisite Kitchen Design (EKD). Its density makes decorative edges a challenge.