Sustainability's virtuous feedback loop

November 30, 2018

More public companies are stepping forward to address global climate risks, instituting policy changes in the service of social equity, and embedding better and bolder governance practices in their businesses. This laudable shift toward corporate responsibility provides a tailwind for environmental, social, and governance (ESG) investing and reflects the impact of shareholder advocacy efforts to date.

As of the beginning of 2018, about 25% of U.S. assets under management—nearly $12 trillion—was in sustainable-investing strategies, marking a 38% increase in two years.¹ It should come as no surprise that ESG-focused investing is attracting more assets, and we expect 2018 to be a year of redoubled interest. The rapid-fire frequency of destructive climate-related events, the growth of social justice movements like #MeToo, and the explosion of governance issues around cybersecurity, data privacy, and rogue political interventions on social media platforms are leading investors to demand more of the companies in which they invest.

Companies want to provide real answers

Investors want to know: What climate risks are their portfolio companies exposed to and how are they preparing for the future? Do companies actually care about their employees, think about gender equality in the workplace, and believe in the power of diversity at all levels of their organization? Are they thinking for the long term in how they regulate themselves? This kind of interrogation by everyday investors is a good thing. But it’s not the only force driving positive change in corporate practices: Company managements themselves are recognizing the existential threat posed by certain ESG risks—and they’re beginning to embrace change.

Catastrophes command attention—and may provoke positive change

Consider the climatological predicament of the United States in 2018. Climate-related events have profoundly affected the lives of tens of millions of people this year—through incredibly destructive hurricanes across the South and mid-Atlantic; as a result of protracted droughts in the Southwest and in farm country across Missouri and Kansas; and because of the calamitous fires in California, which, as of this writing, still linger as an acrid haze across huge swaths of the state.

Add to this the recent dire warnings from the world’s scientific community, widespread media coverage of rapidly shrinking biodiversity, and the perplexingly dismissive stance taken by the White House in response to its own federal government’s ominous climate report. With all of this, we find nothing more nor less than a politically charged recipe for more urgent action by states, local communities, corporations, and individuals whose lives and businesses may never be the same again because of climate change.

As ESG investors, we notice that clients care—more and more—about whether the companies in which they invest are addressing ESG-related costs, risks, and opportunities. And companies know that these investors care, both due to shareholder advocacy efforts like those engaged in by our firm, and because companies hear it directly from their customers and employees. Tellingly, many companies are purchasing renewable energy because they recognize that it’s a smart business decision and because they can use it to promote themselves on the basis of their environmental citizenship.

Social responsibility is good for business

Similarly, companies that care about their human capital—that think it’s important to treat employees like valued contributors rather than as, merely, a means to end—understand that a socially responsible business is also a more risk-aware business.

At Trillium, we think the #MeToo movement, for example, underscores a variety of critical issues in workplace safety, sexual harassment, and gender pay equity that corporations are becoming more prepared to consider and work through. The movement itself has helped us frame questions to ask of company managements concerning their preparedness for dealing with discrimination and violence in the workplace—and, more importantly, it’s helped us focus our approach to asking about the steps companies are taking to foster a corporate culture that can reduce these risks.

Shareholder advocacy supports better corporate governance

Over the last few years, we’ve seen an increasing number of company boards adopt better corporate governance practices. Indeed, it’s becoming the norm for companies to recognize—as academic and industry studies have borne out—that better corporate governance translates into stronger financial results. Behind this interest is both a self-motivated will to improve and the force of shareholder advocacy. For our part, Trillium regularly engages with company managements to encourage better corporate governance.

An example of our recent advocacy efforts involves Alphabet, parent company of Google, with which we’ve been working on the issue of board diversity. Alphabet’s lack of gender and racial diversity—and the lack of such diversity among tech companies more generally—is a fairly well-known topic. But we’ve asked Alphabet to change for the better. Specifically, we asked the company to adopt what’s known as the Rooney Rule—a race-conscious recruitment principle developed in the National Football League—to help ensure that when the board picks new members, it must look at a diverse pool of candidates. In particular, we asked Alphabet to adopt the rule so that any time it has an open board position, it must ensure that at least one member of an underrepresented community of color and at least one woman will be among the pool of candidates. Over time, we believe the adoption of this type of guideline will lead to increasingly diverse boards and, consequently, to better decisions and risk controls.

The virtuous circle of corporate engagement

As companies adopt sustainable business practices, investors take note. And naturally, investors want to know what those companies they haven’t heard from are doing to promote sustainability. If one company is reducing greenhouse gas emissions, are its peers doing the same? Who’s building a more inclusive corporate culture, and who’s just “green-washing” with token recruitment efforts? What does more sustainable corporate governance look like, and what standards can we use to measure it? These types of questions reinforce the efforts of activist investors andof every corporation under scrutiny to aspire to higher benchmarks for sustainability.

A deep understanding of ESG issues has become indispensable for investors in emerging markets. Members of Boston Common Asset Management discuss the proliferation of investment opportunities linked to ESG criteria.
Read more

Cheryl I. Smith, Ph.D., CFA

Trillium Asset Management

Portfolio Manager

Cheryl is a portfolio manager and economist at Trillium Asset Management, where she began her invest…

A deep understanding of ESG issues has become indispensable for investors in emerging markets. Members of Boston Common Asset Management discuss the proliferation of investment opportunities linked to ESG criteria.
Read more

Explore the latest thinking from our network

Sign up to get market insight and analysis delivered straight to your inbox.

Click here to view a prospectus or summary prospectus. You may also request one from your financial advisor or by calling us at 800-225-5291. The prospectus includes investment objectives, risks, fees, expenses, and other information that you should consider carefully before investing.

Some information may not be approved by certain organizations. Please check with your organization before using this information.

ETFs

John Hancock ETFs are distributed by Foreside Fund Services, LLC, and are subadvised by Dimensional Fund Advisors LP. Foreside is not affiliated with John Hancock Funds, LLC or Dimensional Fund Advisors LP.

ETF shares are bought and sold through exchange trading at market price (not NAV), and are not individually redeemed from the fund. Shares may trade at a premium or discount to their NAV in the secondary market. Brokerage commissions will reduce returns.

Click here to view a prospectus or summary prospectus. You may also request one from your financial advisor or by calling us at 800-225-5291. The prospectus includes investment objectives, risks, fees, expenses, and other information that you should consider carefully before investing.

529

If your state or your designated beneficiary’s state offers a 529 plan, you may want to consider what, if any, potential state income-tax or other state benefits it offers, such as financial aid, scholarship funds, and protection from creditors, before investing. State tax or other benefits should be one of many factors to be considered prior to making an investment decision. Please consult with your financial, tax, or other advisor about how these state benefits, if any, may apply to your specific circumstances. You may also contact your state 529 plan or any other 529 education savings plan to learn more about their features. Please contact your financial advisor or call 866-222-7498 to obtain a Plan Disclosure Document or prospectus for any of the underlying funds. The Plan Disclosure Document contains complete details on investment objectives, risks, fees, charges, and expenses, as well as more information about municipal fund securities and the underlying investment companies that should be considered before investing.Please read the Plan Disclosure Document carefully prior to investing.