I use cookies on Organized 31 to personalize content and ads, to provide social media features and to analyze traffic. I also share information about your use of our site with our social media, advertising, and analytics partners who may combine it with other information that you’ve provided to them or that they’ve collected from your use of their services. You can Read the Full Policy for more information on how to turn off these cookies.
Read Full Policy.

Mini Finger Pies with Butterfinger Candy

This shop has been compensated by Collective Bias, Inc. and its advertiser. All opinions are mine alone. #ReinventSweet #CollectiveBias

It’s candy season. Yea! I’m a big kid when it comes to the excitement of Halloween and Halloween candy. There’s something magical about staring into a big bowl of candy as the doorbell rings with the first trick-or-treater and something equally magical about watching my children dump out the contents of their candy bags when they return home from trick-or-treating. To add to the magic for the trick-or-treaters that come to our house, I purchase my favorite candy to hand out, but my ulterior motive is that they’re the main ingredient in these amazing Mini Finger Pies.

One of my earliest (and favorite) memories is eating my Great-Aunt Mimi’s BUTTERFINGER® Pie. I was very young and could only say “Finger Pie” but that was enough to get my message across. This family favorite is now known throughout our extended family as Finger Pie. It’s always a big crowd-pleaser with my family and with guests. I’ve added a bit of twist by making Mini Finger pies that are the perfect treat for your Halloween party or celebration. This recipe is easy enough that you can make it the afternoon before your party.

Spoon the filling into the pie crusts and garnish with whipped topping and BUTTERFINGER® Peanut Butter Cup Minis.

Warning – these Mini Finger Pies are addictive. You may not be able to eat just one. While I’m partial to these Mini Finger Pies, you’ve got to check out the Butterfinger Pinterest page for more amazing recipes.

Individual mini pies are perfect for parties because they’re so easy to serve, oh, and they look charming, too.

While I was out running errands this week, I popped over to Walmart to pick up Halloween candy and the ingredients to make my family’s favorite Finger Pie. I found the BUTTERFINGER® Fun-Size Candy Bars and the BUTTERFINGER® Peanut Butter Cup Minis on the candy aisle. Lucky for you and me there’s an Earn $1 with Ibotta offer right now when you purchase Nestle® Fun Size Candy. Saving money this time of year is always appreciated.

My family has already eaten the batch of Mini Finger Pies that I made for our neighborhood Halloween party. Guess I’ll just have to make another batch. Luckily, these pies are easy enough to make that it’s no problem (maybe it’s even an opportunity for me to sample a few candy bars, lucky me!).

I always plan ahead and purchase “extra” of my favorite Butterfinger candy (don’t tell my family my secret strategy) so that I can pass it out to trick-or-treaters, indulge in a couple pieces myself and use the “extra” candy make my favorite Mini Finger Pies (happily they’re also my family’s favorite, too).