Papa Don't Preach by Madonna is featured in Hairography, the eleventh episode of Season One. It is sung by Quinn with Puck backing her up on guitar, only to feature the line "I've made up my mind, I'm keeping my baby".

While babysitting Kendra's triplets with Puck, Quinn decides to perform this song as a way to calm the triplets down after their unruly behavior goes as far as tying up Puck and Quinn. Quinn also performed many of the dance moves Madonna did in the original video.