I also didn't send in three stars. Since we said that they were useless from the beginning because of the difficulty counting them, this seems like a particularly terrible way of doing it.

I honestly didn't think 3 stars were still being used as a tiebreak after (I think it was arrbez in ATD2011) specifically asked that we stop using them in a draft where a few GMs traded out of the first round, but then I honestly didn't think we'd ever need to go past the # of games, so I didn't really think about it