Yes, selections are by public vote. They are moving one line at a time. If a player has an All Star in two different positions they can obviously only be picked for one. For example Paídí was picked in the full back line and so was excluded from being picked in the HB line. They are at midfield now in both the football and hurling teams.

In fairness, the hurling team is a similar mess. FB line doesn't include any Kilkenny men - Corcoran, Lohan, O'Sullivan. Tommy Walsh is the only Kilkenny man in back 6.