The teens, staying at Dabbelt's house, said they called a few times to complain that their pizza was late and were told to ask the deliveryman to call his manager as soon as he arrived.

They told deputies the deliveryman became angry when he arrived at 11:59 p.m. and demanded payment for the pizza within two minutes. When the girls did not pay, the deliveryman walked into the house and through several bedrooms, they told deputies.

Stevenson said she tried to block the deliveryman and he pushed her. The deliveryman spent 15 minutes in the house before throwing the pizza on the floor and leaving, the girls told deputies.