The Good:
I sometimes forget that Ryan Reynolds is a pretty darn good actor when given the opportunity to stretch. And stretch he does as he downplays his natural matinee idol-ness to play the unintentionally psychopathic Jerry. Reynolds transforms himself very subtly so that he embodies this awkward, damaged man from his facial tics to his haphazard gait. He also was impressive providing the myriad number of voices for the the animals who all speak to Jerry. I especially liked his voice work as Jerry’s loyal lovable dog Bosco and the manipulatively abusive Scottish accent he put on for Mr. Whiskers, the most disagreeable cat ever put on film.
I was also impressed with just how dark this film went in the violent scenes. This is a “black comedy” but got downright brutal with some of Jerry’s kill scenes. And the scenes that would alternate between Jerry’s shiny idea of what his life looks like and the real world were really cool as they gave you a glimpse into just how messed up Jerry was.
Gemma Arterton was a delight in her role as the brassy office “hot chick” and unfortunate object of Jerry’s affections.

The Bad:
I really would have liked to have seen Anna Kendricks character of Lisa given more time to explore what made her tick. She seemed like a perfectly normal woman so her having a crush on someone as bizarre as Jerry didn’t make much sense.

Look at those moves

The Ugly:
Reynolds and Arterton’s dance moves were just….words cannot express the utter soulessness of their dance floor gyrating.

Final Verdict: A wonderful dark comedy that gives Ryan Reynolds an opportunity to show some serious acting chops while telling a story that kept me captivated all the way through. Plus who can hate a movie that has a pretty sizable body count but still can end with a big musical number? Not this guy.