Andy Cohen Once Tried to Make a Love Connection with Jonathan Groff

Andy Cohen may soon be helping hapless singles find the one as the host of Love Connection, but it turns out there was one night he was trying to make a romance of his own bloom with a certain Broadway/Glee star. "I made out with Jonathan Groff once," he recently told PEOPLE magazine's Jess Cagle. Oh, do tell...

Luckily for us, the Watch What Happens Live with Andy Cohen host was willing to share a few details about the night in question. "That was in front of my apartment building. We went out for drinks. I don't know if he thought it was a date, but I did," he shared. "I think once I ended it in that way, I think he definitely knew that I thought maybe, yeah. It was sweet."