Comment: Sir the main motive of RTI act is being defeated under garb of section 2(f). Today PIOs are denying information that question cannot be answered which is not justified. No doubt Bombay high court has rightly stated that “why” cannot be replied but other question like “whether”, “how”, etc. should have been replied and we should make efforts in this regard. As per my information, the SIC of Kerala had ordered the PIO to provide information asked in questionnaire format, copy of which I can provide. Please take the matter with ministry and CIC of India to achieve the ultimate goal and there should have no problem in replying the questions like whether this has been done or not supply copy of the same, because this question falls within the ambit of information available on record.