Both were parties in a formal discipline hearing Jan. 18-24 in Atlanta. Warren filed charges in 2006 after Schmeling told him he was in a committed relationship with another man, a violation of the ELCA’s clergy standards.

In addition, the committee’s written opinion made recommendations for changes in ELCA clergy standards and suggested that synod assemblies ask the 2007 Churchwide Assembly to consider proposals for change.

For the appeal, written responses and rebuttals may be filed by both parties. Once the final statement is submitted, the 12-member committee has 60 days to render a decision in writing. The decision of the appeals committee is final.