BLOG

Authentication and phishing

Yahoo announced today that they are releasing the Yahoo! Mail Anti-Phishing Platform (YMAP) that will help protect their users from phishing. They have a similar project in place for eBay and PayPal mail, but this will extend to a broader range of companies.

[W]e’re beefing up Yahoo! Mail’s SpamGuard by adding more security measures that make it much harder for phishers to get to your mailbox. We’ve teamed up with email authentication partners—namely, Authentication Metrics, eCert, Return Path, and Truedomain—to gain significant coverage to protect the prime targets of phishing attacks.

Phishing is a huge problem. I have an unprotected mailbox and get tens of dozens of phishing emails a day. But until there was a way to validate the sender of an email, rather than just the source IP, there wasn’t a good way to say that a particular email didn’t count.

SPF was one of the first attempts to solve this problem, but it didn’t do it very well. There were a number of very common uses of email that SPF didn’t accommodate.

Despite what the SPF crowd desperately wants to belive, there’s no simple way to tell what mail can legitimately be sent from what IPs. In some cases you can get pretty close, e.g., ESP spam cannon stuff, but even there plenty of people forward other accounts to gmail, which SPF doesn’t handle. — John Levine

Then there came Domain Keys and Identified Mail. Those two specs were close enough to one another that they merged into a single spec, DKIM. For the last few years significant numbers of people have been working to get DKIM stabilized and deployed. That adoption and deployment lets companies build out products like YAMP and protect users from phishing.

You can't technical your way out of the bulk folder. I wrote that a year and a half ago, and it's even more true today. Filters at the big webmail providers continue to evolve to meet new threats and new spamming techniques. Sending technically perfect mail won't get your mail into the inbox. Recipients have to want the mail and interact with the mail for good delivery.
No Comments