John proposed on the beach in Punta Mita, Mexico, beneath a white tent filled with white lilies and roses. "The St. Regis Punta Mita Resort is where we fell in love; it was the perfect choice for this wonderful occasion," John told Us. "Taylor was beautiful and never stopped smiling! It was an amazing evening, a 10 all 'round!"

In addition to her new husband-to-be, Taylor also said yes to a gold and diamond engagement ring, which she hasn't shared a picture of. Yet.