A critical look at nutritional science and anything else that strikes my fancy

Post navigation

Dr. Andrew Weil

Dr. Andrew Weil, who graces the cover of Time this week, has a new book out about aging that includes, of course, a wellness diet. According to the accompanying article it looks to me to be pretty much the same diet he has always advocated. I thought it would be worthwhile to consider a couple of the basics.

On a 2,000-calorie-a-day diet, adult women should eat about 160 g to 200 g of carbohydrates daily.

So, according to Dr. Weil, women should add somewhere from Ã‚Â¾ to a full cup of sugar per day to the one teaspoon they have circulating in their blood.

Adult men should eat about 240 g to 300 g of carbohydrates a day.

I guess this means that men should add between a cup and a quarter to a cup and a half of sugar to their blood.

Dr. Weil goes on to point out that

Most of this [carbohydrate] should be in the form of less refined, less processed foods.

He falls into the trap of thinking that somehow all this carbohydrate won’t be converted to sugar because it is “complex.” Complex carbohydrates are not absorbed. Enzymes in the GI tract break them down into simple sugars that are absorbed, so any carbohydrate that makes its way to the small intestine is going to be absorbed as a sugar. One cup of complex carbohydrate goes into the blood as one cup of sugar, and since the body likes to keep about a teaspoon of sugar in the blood, this extra cup (or more) has to be dealt with metabolically by an enormous outpouring of insulin. All this insulin doesn’t just lower the sugar level of the blood; it does a lot of other things such as driving fat into the fat cells, causing the kidney to retain sodium, stimulating the production of VLDL in the liver, and a host of other things one would rather not have happen.

Dr. Weil is a big, cuddly bear of a guy who has somehow gained preeminence as America’s physician who can be trusted to tell it like it is. I’m sure he will now be making the talk-show circuit dispensing his particular brand of idiocy to the American public, who will, no doubt, go out and go face down in the carbs. And the obesity epidemic will continue on.

The media’s unquestioning acceptance of Dr. Weil’s dietary philosophy is an example of if-you-tell-people-something-they-already-believe-they-will-never-question-it. I can guarantee you that if I went on all the same talk shows, I would get challenged in a way he never will. Many of the shows would have “experts” present to disagree with everything I might say; Dr. Weil will have no such “experts” to confront him.

It’s not like Dr. Weil is an expert on anything, much less nutrition. In a 1997 interview in Playboy he made some statements that were absolutely breathtaking in their stupidity.

The love of beef is dangerous. Of all the animal foods, beef is probably the least healthy. It’s the essence of the worst of the American diet. The fat in meat is the worst fat for hearts and arteries.

The main fat in beef is stearic acid, which has been shown in multiple studies to be a saturated fat that actually lowers cholesterol, and, therefore, if one believes in the lipid hypothesis, as Dr. Weil certainly does, would be a fat that is good for hearts and arteries. Stearic acid is the one saturated fat that even the zealous anti-saturated fat people don’t have a problem with.

Here is my favorite:

In addition, cows are big animals at the top of the food chain, so they are likely to concentrate all the environmental toxins”ï¿½

Cows are at the top of the food chain because they’re big? What does it mean to be at the top of the food chain? Animals at the top of the food chain are those that eat other animals lower on the food chain that themselves eat animals still lower. What do cows eat? They eat grass. Cows, irrespective of their size, are on the bottom of the food chain, not the top.

Since Dr. Weil avoids animals at the top of the food chain, what does he eat?

I began eating fish about ten years ago, but that’s all. I don’t eat red meat or chicken or eggs.

Hmmm, fish, eh? Large fish, the kind one usually eats when one eats fish, are at the top of the food chain. Remember all the pictures of a big fish eating a smaller fish eating a smaller fish? Fish indeed do concentrate toxins, and do so to the point that even the government warns pregnant women not to eat too much tuna so as not to take in too much mercury and other contaminants. So, Dr. Weil avoids beef in an effort not to eat anything at the top of the food chain and eats fish instead.

And, finally, Dr. Weil in a burst of sanctimonious holier than thou-ness says

I have never eaten a McDonald’s hamburger. I think I am one of the few Americans who can say that.

He then goes on to add

However, I have, when on the road, gone into a McDonald’s to get a Coca Cola.

Yessiree Bob, let’s avoid that hamburger, but get us a quarter of a cup of good ol’ high-fructose corn syrup and brag about it.

All I can say is that if you eat like Dr. Weil, you’ll look like the portly Dr. Weil. Take a look at his pictures in Time.

Monthly Book Reviews

I have been writing a series of book reviews each month that I email to subscribers. If you're interested and want to get on the list, sign up here (or above where it says Get free email alerts in the upper right). I'll send you an email notice of all new blog posts plus all my monthly book reviews. Also, you will get a link to all the previous month's book reviews I've sent. Hope to see you aboard.

Success! Now check your email to confirm your subscription.

There was an error submitting your subscription. Please try again.

First Name

Email Address

We use this field to detect spam bots. If you fill this in, you will be marked as a spammer.

2 thoughts on “Dr. Andrew Weil”

Do you have any idea just how big he is? Most pictures of him only show him from the shoulder up, but there are a few, like this one http://www.blinkbits.com/blinks/andrew_weil, that show more of him. He appears to have a rather large abdomen, although his arms do appear thin….Insulin resistance me thinks?