"Derek, I knew "bad faith", I worked with "bad faith", "bad faith"
was a friend of mine. Here, this is not "bad faith"..."

If you want to see what "bad faith" looks like, take a look
at an old analysis of the censorware wars and
Mike Godwin's tactics back then ("Sometimes they deliberately and
calculatedly lie. Period. ... there may be tactical advantages in
smearing your opponents so." - I didn't write that, and though it's from
someone who is mentioned unfavorably in my blog these days, it's still
a good essay). But I'm posting this to point out, that's what
"bad faith" looks like - a
lying,
bullying,
campaign. To echo a bit, I'm writing this to make clear - there have been
bad-faith dealings on issues in the past, but these difficulties now aren't anywhere close.

Note all the above was from the old, more corporate-oriented, EFF,
under Esther Dyson and Lori Fena. EFF's under new management as of a few
years ago, under the far more civil-libertarian focused Shari Steele,
and even gave me a treasured
apology for the bad-faith dealings above.

Now, with that as background, the problem here is as follows: There's an
elephant in the room, in that preserving copyright in anything close to
its current form, seems to require draconian measures. I don't say it
can or can't be done - but to do it, we're getting laws such as the DMCA,
"spampoenas", lawsuits to strike fear into the hearts of
file-shares everywhere, and so on.

There's no way out of this that fits in a press release. It's not clear
if there even is a way out of this, which leads to a pundit-party
of prodigious proportions. It's all about
what do we do with the
elephant? There's a path which starts out saying, "Don't put the
elephant in with the tech-types (broadcast flag, etc.) - it should be
wrangled by lawyers". Then "But wait, the lawyers are letting the elephant
stampede, they shouldn't do that". And "Hey, it's not so gentle when
one is dealing with an enraged bull elephant".

There are also a few blatherers talking about what a wonderful opportunity
we have now in the evolution of Loxodonta<->Sapiens networking.
A circus generally has some spectacle which is good filler-fodder, after all.

But all we're seeing here, is that EFF is not able to make that elephant
go away, and is struggling like everyone else over where best to put it.