change versus more of the same

October 19, 2008

One step closer to knowing

Barack Obama will be the next president of the United States.

And I'm going to vote for him.

My decision to choose Senator Obama could fairly be described as more bandwagon than profile in courage at this point, with the election just two weeks away and Obama's victory almost assured. I remember how strange it was for Al Gore to endorse Obama after the Democratic primary was over. Though some polls show the race tightening as it often does in the last weeks, Obama has a firm lead in the electoral college and more than enough money to keep the pressure on all the way to election day. I expect his get-out-the-vote effort will also dwarf what the Republican Party can deliver, so without a major mistake, revelation, or foreign policy crisis, the presidency is his.

So, why write anything at all? For two reasons, really. First, because I believe I owe it to you. To write as much about politics as I have over the past two years and then take a pass on the ultimate political question would be disingenuous. Second, I owe it to my family, especially Ben. We've shared so many political conversations over the past two years and watched an inordinate amount of Road to the White House episodes featuring obscure candidates in the homes of Iowans, not to mention a truly endless number of debates. It's important for kids to see politics as more than just an entertaining game. Besides, he keeps asking me, "So, have you decided who you're going to vote for yet?"

This has been a difficult decision to make. Though the campaign has been a disappointment, it has featured my two favorite candidates from the primaries. I thought both deserved a full hearing, including the debates. I respect each of them enormously and have been a supporter of John McCain's since he ran in 2000. Perhaps Obama supporters could at least concede that we would be much better off if he had beaten George Bush 8 years ago.

I have always been a conservative, but have generally considered myself an independent since the Reagan years. I have never voted for a Democrat for president (and please don't ask about my vote for Perot in 1992). The current candidates have regularly frustrated and disappointed me during the campaign, but there are no perfect candidates and I don't personally believe in staying home on election day or casting a protest vote for a third party candidate. I've come to this decision like most everyone else, by reading about the candidates, watching them perform, evaluating their decisions and how they make them, and discussing the election with fair-minded people.

Do I have hesitations? More than I can count. There are many
different directions an Obama presidency might take. His inexperience
could cause significant problems, particularly in foreign affairs. I do
not have anything positive to say about the current Democratic
congress, and the possibility that they will push endless bad
legislation past a young president is an uncomfortable prospect. He may
raise taxes, regulate the economy and restrict trade to such a degree
that the economy is made far worse. His judicial appointments may be
aggressively liberal instead of sensible centrists.

Here's what it comes down to though. First, the reality is that John
McCain is far from a principled conservative. On many of these issues,
he's adopted positions (or at least arguments) similar to Obama's. On
many others, it's clear that there is no guiding philosophy behind
where he stands on a particular issue.

Second, you make your choice for president based on the man. We have
no idea what the future will hold or what issues a president will have
to face. We can only choose who we want to sit in the Oval Office and
make decisions on behalf of the country. Who has the necessary
character, temperament, and wisdom? Who can be trusted to listen to
others and respect the opposition?

I think John McCain is a very good man who would make a good president and be a significant improvement over President Bush. However, I believe that Barack Obama is the best candidate at this moment in our history.

Comments

brian
your doubts about the democratic congress steamrolling obama seem well founded. I'm surprised you can support the lurch toward socialism.even if he is a good man how can a conservative stand behind the most liberal senator in congress. good luck with your choice.

A third party candidate vote is not a protest vote if the candidate most accurately reflects your own views and values. I consider it more throwing away your vote to choose one of the 2-party candidates if they do not represent your own beliefs.

Doug: I can't see how "socialism" applies here as anything other than a scare tactic. I certainly see the federal government growing ever larger, especially in what has happened in the last 8 years (prescription drug benefit, homeland security) and the incredible intervention in the economy of the last few weeks. Bush and McCain (cap and trade) are not different enough to call one socialism and the other free market capitalism.

Scott: thanks a lot! I've enjoyed our political conversations. The next post is more specific about the why.

DP: I agree, and was someone who wanted both Mike Bloomberg and Ron Paul to run as independent candidates. I wish there was true competition with the major parties. There is not a third party candidate I could support in this election however.