Two Sides to Every Story is a collection of ten songs, written in pairs, collected in five chapters, with interludes and an epilogue. Peter and Annie share vocals and instrumentation, and are joined by Jerry Marotta (Peter Gabriel, Indigo Girls, Elvis Costello), on drums and percussion.

"Their music has a lo-fi, dark Americana feel. Both artists are very literate, almost studious with their craft. Though their is very much their own, you can hear influences from the likes of Eric Taylor, Leonard Cohen and Lou Reed weaving through." -Maverick

“Gallway is the man with the tall-cool voice and elegantly understated touch on the electric guitar and keyboard, Gallup the siren poet with the breezy voice and sure touch on guitar, banjo and lap steel... This abundantly talented duo seems to have a genuine and gentle regard for each other that makes this a sophisticated and warm listening experience.” - Music Matters Review