Reasonably priced in West Village or Hell's Kitchen

I am looking for a reasonably priced dinner place (entrees $10-15 range) for five people in either the West Village (preferred) or Hell's Kitchen. It would also be great if this place took reservations.

It is a little bit harder to find good options in that price range, if you cut out Asian and Mexican cuisines. (For instance, Galanga is good for Americanized Thai and Asean for southeast Asian. In my opinion, these are two of the area's better restaurants in your price range.) But you have a few decent options:

Of these, Otto and Panca have the most pleasant decor, but Otto is very loud. Westville is cozy and very small / tight, so less ideal for a group of five, though they will seat you when they have room. Meskerem is dark and underground, with a slight sense of dinginess. I happen to like the food, but I haven't eaten much Ethiopian, except in DC and NYC.