I do not reject peace, but I am afraid of war disguised as peace.
Cicero 43 B.C.

Friday, April 23, 2010

Speech by Erwin Chemerinsky

Gary Fousefousesquawk

Tuesday night this week, UC-Irvine law school dean Erwin Chemerinsky spoke at a local synagogue on the on-going controversy over the Muslim Student Union and the question of free speech. Prior to coming to UCI, Chemerinsky had been quoted a few years ago as saying he saw no anti-Semitism at the school, a claim he repeated in writing in the wake of the February 8th disruption of the Israeli ambassador's speech, an incident which has aroused world-wide attention and a lot of negative publicity for the school. I was in attendance Tuesday and had the chance to ask a question. Actually, it was more of a comment.

After briefing the audience on the activities of his newly-inaugurated law school at UCI, Chemerinsky addressed the issue of the on-going controversy of the activities of the Muslim Student Union at UCI including the February 8th disruption of the Israeli ambassador's speech.

First, Chemerinsky referred to the problem over the years of MSU-sponsored speakers who, in his words, have sometimes said things that were "anti-Semitic and anti-Jewish". He explained that hateful as they were, they were protected by free speech. He referred two or three times to the MSU annual week of events as "hate week" and advised the audience that it was coming again the week of May 10.

Chemerinsky, however, added that he would never have come to UCI had he thought there was an anti-Semitic atmosphere at the campus (I am paraphrasing.) He also referred to the investigation by the Department of Education Office of Civil Rights (OCR) a few years back and stated that the investigation made at the request of the Zionist Organization of America (ZOA) had determined that the complaints had no foundation (Again, I am paraphrasing.)

As for the disruption of the ambassador's speech, he rejected any defense that the MSU disruptors were exercising their own free speech since they were attempting to shut down the speech of the ambassador.

As far as punishment was concerned, he favored suspension for a term and community service, but nothing "so draconian as to ruin the students' lives."

As for suspending the MSU as a campus organization, he didn't think that was practical since it could simply re-form itself as an organization with a different name, and he did not want to see them become "martyrs".

During the Q&A, I introduced myself as a part-time teacher at UCI who had been following the events for a few years. I told the audience that 99% of the student body had no part in any anti-Semitism at UCI, but that the problem was the MSU-sponsored speakers who had made such statements. I used the quotes of Washington-based imam Mohammed al-Asi, who has appeared at UCI several times, and is on video stating that "you can take the Jew out of the ghetto, but you can't take the ghetto out of the Jew." I added that it was my hope that after such statements, the leadership at UCI would come back and condemn such statements.

In response, Chemerinsky defended UCI Chancellor Michael Drake by saying that Drake had spoken out strongly against the disruption of the Israeli ambassador's speech and that Drake cares deeply about the overall issue.

My colleague, Ted Bleiweis of the Orange County Independent Task Force on Anti-Semitism, took issue with Chemerinsky's statement about the ZOA-DOE investigation, saying that the complaint was dismissed not on the facts, rather on the finding that some of the complaints had not been filed in a timely enough manner and the fact that the OCR had changed their definition of the Jews' status as a protected group. Ted also told the dean about incidents at UCI that went beyond speech but more to incidents of intimidation, including reported incidents where a student had a camera shoved in her face, a Christian preacher was shoved, two brothers were accosted by MSU members who objected to their filming and a girl who was filming an MSU speaker being followed back to her car and harassed while campus police did nothing. Some of the alleged victims of these incidents were not even Jewish.

Another colleague brought a copy of the documentation of the George Galloway event of May 21, which he had obtained through the Freedom of Information Act (which allegedly contained false information) and asked why the investigation as to the fundraising nature of that event was still unresolved. Chemerinsky pointed out that due to student privacy laws, the public may never know the outcome unless the students themselves choose to release the information.

This UCI issue continues to be a burning one with the Jewish community. Dean Chemerinsky clarified the free speech issue for many members of the audience. I hope our questions/comments also contributed to their understanding of the situation.

Roger's Fiction

Welcome to Radarsite

Roger Gardner, the owner of Radarsite, lost his battle with leukemia on December 17, 2009. His friends and contributors will endeavor to keep Radarsite fresh and intriguing in his absence, as was his wish. Please feel free to leave your comments, your opinions are valuable to us. Obscenities, personal attacks, anonymous commenters and anti-American rants will of course be deleted. I hope you enjoy your visit and return often -- Roger W. Gardner, owner/editor. [Note: most of the images on this sidebar are hyperlinks. Click the little icon above to read Radarsite's updated mission statement]

Sansom Street

Radarsite is a proud contributor to Wake Up America

Radarsite is also a proud contributor to that great Australian website Crusader Rabbit

As of July 13, 2008 Radarsite will also be a proud contributor to Maggie's Notebook

Bravo Maggie Thornton!

Beginning July 27, 2008 Radarsite will be contributing to the inimitable Miss Beth's Victory Dance

Miss Beth!

Who is a patriot?

Click on Samuel Johnson to find out

Blogging Against the Religion of Peace

Graphic by No Sheeples Here!

Radarsite on Hillary Clinton Forum

"Obama Convention throw US Flags in the Trash" (Radarsite) - September 6, 2008

Opinions

Opinions, in my opinion, unlike principles, are not sacred possessions to be protected, locked away and defended from all intruders. Rather, they are, or should be, living and evolving attitudes, constantly subjected to rigorous revision and adjustment — or, when necessary, quickly abandoned for some more plausible or cogent truth. - rg-- Wrestling With Mohammed - 12/9/07

Bloggers Against Islamofacism

Radarsite supports Lionheart

I Stand For Freedom

From No Sheeples Here

US Air Force

Proud veteran of the United States Air Force

Political Vindication Radio

Those great silent lessons in humility

The Age of Unreason

We are living in an new era, the Age of Unreason. We are being ruled by a ruthless and unyielding dictator who hides under the benign title of Political Correctness. This tyrant requires nothing less of us than our complete and unquestioning obedience to his rules of conduct. His ironclad laws permeate every area of our existence, even penetrating into our innermost thoughts. He vigorously supports and enforces these regulations through a formidable array of propaganda, misinformation and outright lies.

-- New Rules of Engagement 12/9/07

The truth about "Palestine"

For an intelligent and thorough rebuttal to the "Palestinian" Arabs' claims of "dispossession" by the Israeli Jews, Radarsite highly recommends Churchill's Parrot's authoritative essay "The Desert Bloom: An Insult to Human Dignity?"

Friends, patriots and fellow vets

Check out Pastor Ed at "Do the Right Thing"

Radarsite supports the Gathering of Eagles

Radarsite supports boycotting the City of Berkeley

Thanks Snooper.

Radarsite appears in Real Clear politics

A message from Radarsite

"It does not escape me, however, what a significant proportion of my respected fellow warriors in this blogosphere are women -- well-informed, strong-minded and courageous, and certainly not afraid to speak out against this worldwide Muslim oppression of their female population..." -- From "A Big Ms-Take"

Strong women are sexy!

Radarsite supports freedom for women around the world. ESPECIALLY IN ISLAM

Strong, patriotic, gun-toting, pro-military women are even sexier!

Crown Princess Mary of Denmark. With the Home Guard. (Thanks Crusader Rabbit)

Bravo brave Princess!

Crown Princess Mary of Denmark

Bravo Susan Duclos (Spree)!

Radarsite supports Wake Up America

Bravo Deb Hamilton!

Radarsite supports Right Truth.

Bravo Courtney! Great Satan's Girlfriend

The Great Satan loves you!

Bravo Jenn Sierra!

Radarsite supports Fort Hard Knox

Bravo Reut R. Cohen!

Radarsite supports Reut Cohen.com

Bravo brave Naomi!

Radarsite supports author Naomi Ragen

Bravo Wafa Sultan!

The True Voice of Islam

Bravo Loon!

Radarsite support the fine work of "One Loon's Tales"

Bravo Barb!

Radarsite supports Faultline USA

Bravo Kateri E. Jordan!

Radarsite supports Miss Beth's Victory Dance

Bravo Melanie Morgan!

Radarsite proudly supports Move America Forward

Bravo Carol!

Radarsite supports No Sheeples Here

Bravo Amy Proctor!

Radarsite supports Bottom Line Up Front

Bravo Aurora!

Radarsite supports The Midnight Sun

Bravo brave Debbie!

Radarsite supports the important work of Debbie Schlussel

Bravo Ayaan Hirsi Ali!

Radarsite supports the brave Infidel

For a great introduction to the Ayaan Hirsi Ali story, see Shane Borgess" insightful article at PV

Melanie Phillips

Bravo Maggie Thornton !

Bravo Michelle!

Bravo Angel!

Bravo Cassie L.!

Radarsite also honors our own Cassie L. of Patriots For Conservative Values for her tireless work and her innumerable contributions to our righteous cause.

A follow-up announcement from Radarsite:

I'm sure I've inadvertently neglected to include some brave female warriors in this small tribute, and for this I apologize.If you would like to suggest a site to be included on this list please email me (from my bio) or leave a comment and I'll be happy to make the addition.rg

Islam also honors their women

Islamo-feminist Pride Day Parade

Islam also honors their women

A very public display of respect.

Islam: Religion of peace.

8:67 It is not for a Prophet that he should have prisoners of war (and free them with ransom) until he had made a great slaughter (among his enemies) in the land. You desire the good of this world (i.e. the money of ransom for freeing the captives), but Allâh desires (for you) the Hereafter. And Allâh is All-Mighty, All-Wise. Tafsir: 12

By Pam Gecko - Gecko with Cannon

See "My Haunted TV"

James Dean in Times Square - 1955

My first job in the Big Apple. Doorman at the old Astor Theater (above left), during the 1955 season of its world premier of James Dean's East of Eden: "Step right this way folks, immediate seating in the balcony!"

Times Square and the Old Astor Theater

My second job in the Big Apple: Doorman at the MOMA - 1957

Evidently, there was something about me that made me a good doorman...

Check out "La Ultima Paja"

Fishing for Fatwas

Radarsite supports the truthful but deadly Danish cartoons

Radarsite honors Flemming Rose

The courageous Jyllands-Posten Editor who first published these explosive cartoons and has subsequently been targeted for assasination by those ardent followers of that gentle Religion of Peace.