Search America's historic newspaper pages from 1836-1922 or use the U.S. Newspaper Directory to find information about American newspapers published between 1690-present. Chronicling America is sponsored jointly by the National Endowment for the Humanities external link and the Library of Congress. Learn more

Download & Play

Questions

Newspaper Page Text

4
JUST ARRIVKJD
A now lot of tho Finest
Musical lnslrumeots
Autohnrps Guitars Violins Etc
- Also a now invoice of the Celebrated
Westerineyer Pianos
Specially manufactured for tho tropical
climate second to none
MOltH THAN 100 OF T1IBM SOLD
On tho Hawaiian Islnnds during tho last
years
j i ii ii I-
DRY GOODS
AND
General Merchandise
Also tho choicest European and Ameri
can
Beers Ale Wiues Lpors
AT MOST nEASONADLIS NllCES
Kd hoffsohlaegbhco
Cornor King Bethel Streets
PALME BESTAUMT
Corner of Dothol and Hotel Sts
Comfortable Private Rooms or Ladies
to 1 am
and Gentlemen OpenfromCAM
Tickets
150
DAYID K BAKER
IPXjOKEST
Nuuanu Valley above the Mausolonm
ALL Flowers OUDisitB and
Wants will leeolvo
prompt and faithful
atttcnion Freo doli
voryto all parts with
in tho city limits
Lois Evorgrcom
and Carnations a
Speciality
9V TwtWPCTONJi NTn 747
REMOVAL
iv
JOHN PHILLIPS
Hbb removv1 ills Plumbing Business rom
King street to tho preiuisen on
Hotel Street
Formerly occtipted bywvaii
MORIKAWA
Tfce Champion of His Trade
I kona Stables Konia Street above
Hotol
Blacksmith Carriage Builder
Repairer
Horse Shoeing a Specialty
His charges as a Smitli aro tho Lowest in
tho Trade and his wor is uncqmiled
203 3m
Oceanic - Steamship to
TIME TABLE
LOCAL LINE
8 S AUSTRALIA
Arrivo Honolulu Leave Honolulu
from S V for B F
Sept J BeptO
Sept28 Oct3
Oct20 Oct 28
Nov 10 Nov 21
Deo 11 Deo 10
Till DUG II LINE
From Son Francisco
for Bydnoy
Arrive Honolulu
Monowol Aug 27
Alameda 8ept21
Mariposa nt fi
Monowni Nov 10
Alnnili n 7
Froni Bydnoy for
Ban Francisco
Leave Honolulu
Marpo8aSept 17
Mniinnfil Ont Ifi
Atamcd Nov 12
CD
P EL
rt hi
CD go
3
CD
r l
bmm4
If you want to read
the News and the
Facts relating to the
Political Standing of
Hawaii Subscribe to
The Independent
We are there and
we charge only
50 Cents
a Month
m Ujitii
m vlTxl
gWHgWi W
SuUSA
Continued frovi hi Pope
At tho same tlino l was loath to
brtliovo that decent mou could onlor
iuto airy compact with such a so
cioty WIihu I published tho lost i
niouy as it stood in tho records of
tho courts and of tho lodges I du
clarod that I believed your word as
against all tho sworn statomout3 of
mon liko Iludolson Marshall aud
Ross I stand by that declaration
At tho clo3oof your letter you write
If after reading this lottor you do
not feol fully satisund with tho faots
hero givon I shall bo most happy to
respond to any questions or to fur
nish any oral or documentary corro
borative ovidenco which you may
think wiso to requost I tako ad
vantage of this mauly offor not to
ask you to produco ovidouco oral or
documentary as to the truth of your
statemonts Your word is sufficient
I will go over tho chargo3 which
have been tho roasou for siugling
out tho Oall for tho solo purposo
that you may havo an opportunity
to sot your explanation ovor agaiuBt
thorn and that you may bo enabled
to give a categorical answer to ques
tions plainly put
A MISUNDERSTANDING
In tho beginning lot mo doal with
ono point in your letter which
may causo somo misunderstanding
Henry P Marshal a theological
student or tho Presbyterian Semi
nary at San Ansolmo and au occa
sional reporter on tho Call claims
that ho wrote tho letters which ap
peared in your columns last Febru
ary and which were fathorod by tho
Rev Benjamin Hudolson Baptist
minister aud State President of tho
A P A of California Concerning
this statement you write
Marshall served as a reporter on
that journal the Call was dotailod
by my city editor Mr McMullen to
intorview various parties who were
contributing to the controversy on
behalf of ycur antagonists and
sorvod in a capacity similar to that
of Mr Frank McGuiro a formor
oditor of tile Monitor at that timo
employed by the Call who assisted
in galhoriug material for publica
tion on behalf of tho causo you
espoused
Permit mo to remark that thoro
must bo somo mistake concerning
tho duties performod by Mr Frank
McGuire I was tho only person
who contributed to tho Catholic
sido of tho controversy in the Call
and Mr McGuiro gathered no mat
erial for mo nor did I ovor dream
that ho was deputized to do so As
far as T remember his solo duty con
sisted in carrying my manuscript
tho few yards which seporato our
oIHcpp aud if I mistake not that
duty was porformod far oftenor by
somo of ray dorks than it was by
Mr Frank McGuiro
As to tho question whether Mar
shall wroto tho loiters or not I do
not intend to allow more personal
considerations to enter this matter
at all You dony that you employed
Marshall to writo tho letters That
ouds tho matter as far as I am con
cerned
TUE BASIS OF TUB CHARGES
But to return to tho main point
I need not remiud you that tho basis
of all tho charges made in tho Mo
nitor against tho Call was a certain
letter written by tho Rev Benjamin
Hudolson Stato President of tho A
P A of California and given to
Henry F Marshal a roportor em
ployed by you for tho previous year
for tho purposo of introducing him
to you In order to havo tho docu
ment before our eyos I will copy it
out in full
San Francisco Oal January 18
1890
Mr O M Shortridgo San Fran
cisco Dour Sir This introduces
Mr H FMarshall a friend in whom
I havo the utmost confidence ho is
authorized by mo in ray official capa
city to confer with you in mattors
of a political character
Most respectfully
seal B F JIudeiaon
State Pros A P A of Cal
As you aro doubtlocs awaro this
lottor was destroyed but not boforo
tho provident Marshall had a tin-
wewne b -
typo of it takou You also know
that said tintype was made tho
burthon of au affidavit in which II
F Marshall swore that tho letter
was written in pursuance of aRcherao
by which tho Kov Bonjamiu Iludel
801 ho Marshall aud two othors
ahould throw tho solid voto of thu
A P A to Mr John D Spreckols
faction in tho Republican party in
consideration of tho sum of 2500
a month until uoxt Novembor and a
lump sum of 30000 aftorwards
You may recollect too that Mar
shall sworo that a furthor consider
ation was tho initiation of Mr
Sprockols candidate for United
States Senator into the A P A aud
you romember that aftor tho Rev
Benjamin Hudolson had withdrawn
his confidence from Marshall said
Marshall testified that ho was to
tally in tho dark as to what arrange
ments ho tho Rev Bonjamin Hudol
son finally concluded with Mr John
D Sproskcls
Jin snoRTiuoan corroborates Mar
shall
Ono of the chief points in disputo
among tho members of tho American
Protective Association has been tho
oxistonco of this committee aud tho
roasou of its oxistouco Your lottor
sots hat dispute at rest Before
tho 18th of January at a timo whon
the conspirators woro alreadj sniffing
success Marshall told you of its
objects Ho said to quoto from
your lottor among other things
that he and other loaders of tho
American Protective Association
mentioning tho Rev Donald M
Ross ono Wood worth B F Hudol
son and a Mr Owens desired to
make something out of politics
that they did not propose to givo
all their timo and work for nothing
that thoy had concluded to demand
2500 por month from thou until
qho election in November and thou
if thoy were successful thoy woro
to ask for 30000 more
2b be continued
Is this a 1G to 1 city asked our
Sau Francisco visitor It is on
Sunday nuswered tho kamaaina
On Sunday Yo Sixteen go
fishing for drink to ono going to
church Wo havo to got our Sunday
supplies on Saturday from Jim
Dodd
Limited
Win G Irwin President A Manager
Clans Spreckela Vice rresidont
W M Qillord Sccrotary t Trcasuror
fhco 0 Porter Auditot
SUGAR FACTORS
AND
Commission Agents
AGENTS OF THE
Oceanic Steamship Compy
Of Rnn VrannlRpn fnl
W H RICKARD
Generil Business Agent
WILL ATTEND TO
ttHYoyanclug in All Us Branches
Collecting and AU Business
Miittors of Trunt
All hnHincsi ontrustcd to him will rccoivo
prompt and careful attention
Office llunokaa Umnakun Hawaii
Bruce Waring Co
Real Estate Dealers
603 Fort St near King
building lots
uotjbes and lots and
lands Fob balk
4W Parties wishing to dispose of thair
PropertlflB aro Invltnd to oall on us
D
Corner King and Nuuanu Sis
W M Cunningham - - Manager
Headquarters tor Mechanics and Laborers
TUB OELKIIIIATKD
Fredricksbnrg Draught Beer
ALWAYS ON TAf
Solo Agents for the ltonowncd
Oysters for Cocktails
Per Kvory Australia
CttT Oall and ho convinced -S
Corner Nuuanu and Hotel Bis
I W McNiciioL - - Managor
cinWiiKLipruiH
POllTKKB Tic ON DRAUGHT
on Draught
MoBR AYIDRS
Maiulmaie Sour lash
A SrKOIALTy
ire
i Mm
8 I SHAW Proprietor
Corner King and Nnuanu Streets
Choice Mpors
AND-
Fins Besss
OXf TRIKPHONR 401
Metropolitan Meat Go
81 KINO STKEET
Q 1 Wallbh Manaoko
Wholesalo and
Kctsill
J -
BUTCHERS
AND
Navy Oontraotora
Telehionb C07 P 0 Box 321
HONOLULU
Carriage Manufactory
128 130 Fort Street
Carriage Builder
AND ItKPAIItEIl
Blacksmitliiug in ail its Brandies
Orders from tho olhfr Islands In Building
Trimming Painting Ktc Etc
promptly attended to
W W VRIGHT Proprietor
Suceossor to G West
THEBIiNGTOH
A family Hotel
X KBOTJSE - Prop
Per Day 8 200
Per Weok 1200
SPECIAL MONTHLY ItATHS
Tho liest 0 Atteudauco tho Host Situation