PROS: Bought all three scents for X-Mas (BOGO sale). They all have slightly different scents, but they do smell like a fresh, clean men's cologne... really nice.

CONS: Price... (I will only buy if it's Buy One, Get One.) The lather is rich at first, but you have to keep reapplying (constantly) to maintain that lather. It could use a little more suds, in my opinion. (Hence, the 4-star rating).