Yes, but it was your fault. I'm to trying to be nasty, but YOU broke it, so it was *your* job to fix it - not AT&T's. If you couldn't fix it yourself, you should have found someone who could, and paid them to do it. Why burden AT&T with your mistake? The phone they gave you worked fine out of the box, didn't it?

Yes, but it was your fault. I'm to trying to be nasty, but YOU broke it, so it was *your* job to fix it - not AT&T's. If you couldn't fix it yourself, you should have found someone who could, and paid them to do it. Why burden AT&T with your mistake? The phone they gave you worked fine out of the box, didn't it?

-Mike

Click to expand...

oh, so it was a moral thing. i don't care about that. at&t makes enough money off of me.

If AT&T decided to give him a new phone after checking it out, then thats their call. At that point he probably had no other choice but to take it to them and see what would happen. He was LUCKY to get a new phone.

I am going to stop this before it goes any further. In any situation, returning your phone to AT&T (or any carrier) after you bricked it or messed it up and having them replace it "under warranty" is not a moral issue, it is considered defrauding AT&T period. And we here at Androidforums.com will not allow discussion on this point in any way as we do not support these actions.

So thread closed. If you disagree PM me and I will be happy to discuss it.