Mary Fitzgibbons,

Public Employee Retirement Administration Commission,

Mary D. Fitzgibbons, Pro Se

106 Pleasant View Street Methuen, MA 01844

Appearance for Respondent:

None

Administrative Magistrate:

Richard C. Heidlage, Esq.

ORDER OF DISMISSAL

Pursuant to G.L.c.32, §16(4), the Petitioner, on December 3, 2008, filed a notice of appeal of the Respondent-assigned medical panel finding in 2002 that she is not disabled for purposes of either section 6 or 7 of Chapter 32. M.G.L. c. 32, § 16(4) provides that any person who is aggrieved by any action or decision taken by a retirement board or PERAC "may appeal to the contributory retirement appeal board by filing therewith a claim in writing within fifteen days of notification of such action or decision of the retirement board or the commission . . . ." Ms. Fitzgibbons, in her letter of appeal, acknowledges that the appeal is filed more than fifteen days after the action appealed from, but notes that she "had to wait all these years for a trial" in which a jury had found that she is disabled for purposes of a handicap discrimination claim.

The Contributory Retirement Appeal Board, and therefore this Division, does not have the authority to waive the appeal period set out in §16(4). The fifteen-day appeal period is jurisdictional in nature, and if an appeal is not timely filed, neither CRAB nor DALA has jurisdiction to hear the appeal. See Flynn v. Contributory Retirement Appeal Bd., 17 Mass.App.Ct. 668, 669, 461 N.E.2d 1225 (1984)("the thirty-day limitation upon the filing of actions seeking review of administrative agency action is jurisdictional in nature and, hence, not susceptible to extension except in the limited fashion provided for in § 14[1]"); Herrick v. Essex Regional Retirement Bd., 68 Mass.App.Ct. 187, 189-190, 861 N.E.2d 32, 35 (Mass.App.Ct. 2007). When there is a lack of jurisdiction, "waiver or consent cannot confer it." Second Bank-State St. Trust Co. v. Linsley, 341 Mass. 113, 116, 167 N.E.2d 624 (1960); Flynn v. Contributory Retirement Appeal Bd., 17 Mass.App.Ct. at 670, 461 N.E.2d at 1227.

Even if this were not true, this matter would be barred for another independent reason. This same matter was before this Division and the Contributory Retirement Appeal Board in the case of Mary Fitzgibbons v. Teachers' Retirement Board, CR-03-812 (DALA 2005), aff'd (CRAB 2006). In that decision, after a full evidentiary hearing, we affirmed the decision of the Teachers' Retirement Board denying Ms. Fitzgibbons' application for Section 7 accidental disability retirement benefits on the basis that Ms. Fitzgibbons had not established that the medical panel's negative certification was the result of the application of an improper standard. That decision and conclusion are final and binding on Ms. Fitzgibbons and she is not permitted to raise the matter again in a separate appeal, this time naming PERAC as the respondent. See Kobrin v. Board of Registration in Med., 444 Mass. 837, 843-844, 832 N.E.2d 628 (2005)(doctrine of issue preclusion or collateral estoppel applies where (1) there has been a final judgment on the merits; (2) the party against whom preclusion is asserted was a party (or in privity with a party) to the prior adjudication; and (3) the issue in the prior adjudication was identical to the issue in the current adjudication, and essential to the earlier judgment).

Because there can be no dispute that this matter was not timely filed and because the petitioner would be precluded from raising the issues that underlie her appeal again in any event, the appeal is hereby DISMISSED.

Tool Name: Baynote, Inc. Recommendations

The information below summarizes privacy policy terms related to content recommendations on Mass.Gov and is excerpted from the full Mass.gov privacy policy.

Purpose: Displays relevant content recommendation based on the site usage pattern of all users of Mass.Gov. If Personalization is enabled (the default setting), your personal site usage pattern today and on prior visits to Mass.gov will be displayed to you and will also be a factor in determining personalized relevant recommendations for you.

Data Collected: A random anonymous unique identifier is assigned and tracked for each user of the website. This identifier is sent to our vendor, Baynote, when you view a page, open a document or click a link on Mass.Gov. Our vendor then analyzes the specific content that was viewed and provides content recommendations to similar content that you may find useful. A full description of what data Baynote collects and how it uses this data is available at http://www.baynote.com/baynote-services-privacy-policy/. Please note that the tool uses persistent cookies. These cookies will be Mass.gov domain cookies and not Baynote domain cookies. The cookies will store information related to a user’s Mass.gov Web site usage, including the URL and title of sites recently visited and the random anonymous unique identifier assigned to the user. In general, and as described in more detail in Baynote’s service privacy policy linked to above, Baynote only uses the personalized information it gathers to provide recommendation services and display past usage for Mass.Gov users and will not share this information with any third parties, including advertisers. The information collected will not affect content you may see on sites unaffiliated with Mass.Gov.

Express Opt Out: If personalization of recommendations based on the content you view is not desired, or you do not wish to display a list of recently viewed Mass.gov pages, you may turn personalization off. You can do this by using either the switch located below in this privacy policy or an identical switch located directly above the content recommendations and recently viewed content boxes displayed on the Mass.gov site. Once you turn off personalization, your content recommendations will be based on the overall traffic patterns of all users of Mass.Gov and they will not specifically take into account your own personal usage patterns. If you turn off personalization, information collected by this Tool that is associated with your content usage will be deleted from your cookies, and no further information about your content usage will be sent to our vendor.

Disabling personalization will affect both content recommendations and recently viewed page links. If you turn off personalization, this “off” setting will persist as you browse Mass.Gov and during any future sessions. The opt-out setting is stored in a persistent cookie on your computer. The setting will remain in effect so long as you use the same computer with the same Internet browser. If you delete the cookie that contains the opt-out setting or use a different browser or computer, personalization will be enabled and you will need to disable it again on your next visit, if desired.

For our full privacy policy, please close this window and see the Site Policies or Privacy Policy link in the footer of the page.