I have no issue with Margarito getting a big fight again, but IMO he has to earn it.

A lot has happened since since his win over Cotto.

He lost a fight, a fight in which he took a severe prolonged beating. A career killer type of beating in which he may never get back to his old level again. Since then he has been forced into a long period of inactivity.

In that time period others have done much more and deserve their spot in the pecking order. Margarito, if he does get his license back, should have to fight his way back into line for another crack at the big time.

He does not deserve to leapfrog others until he proves he still has what it takes.

Since you asked, if he really wanted to prove himself he would have taken the more risky fight with the true champion Tszyu. Gatti had been beaten by Ivan Robinson and Angel Manfredy and was not risky.
Gatti won a vacant title while Tszyu was the unified champ. Very careful move obviously. Who did he fight at 140 that was worthy lb4lb?
His goal was to gain a title with the least risk. Even at 147, fighting Judah for a vacant title, when Judah was coming off a loss. Sure he beat Baldomir eventually, but if you look at the rankings at the time you have to ask about all the better fighters that were not supposedly worthy to fight.

So there you have it. A long list of misfits, journeymen, no hopers and blown up fighters since 2002.

How the hell is this guy even ranked in the top 10 at WW??

What has he done?

You can't even compare him and Margarito.

Margarito fought Cintron, Williams, Cotto, Mosley and Clottey.

He deserves a crack at Packy first on achievements alone.

give the man props for Oscar at 154.....but thats where it stops with me.....cats can kick and scream about this guy was this and that guy was that....but at the end of the day Zab, Baldi and Hatton shouldn't be his biggest wins at WW ....its a disrespect to the throne.