NOTICE: ON APRIL 30th 2014 THE CBR FORUMS WERE RESET AND ALL USER ACCOUNTS WERE CLOSED. TO JOIN THE NEW CBR FORUMS ALL PREVIOUS USERS NEED TO RE-REGISTER. All users, both new and returning, are expected to follow the CBR COMMUNITY STANDARDS & RULES.

If this is your first visit, be sure to
check out the FAQ by clicking the
link above. You may have to register
before you can post: click the register link above to proceed. To start viewing messages,
select the forum that you want to visit from the selection below.

It sure is lonely being a person who actually likes the way Marvel is going right now simply because the few books that they do read (books that have been roasted as "bad" on places like D&C) are actually enjoyable.

I could go into a deep debate about all this but instead all I will say is that for the most part, I am enjoy Marvel and will continue buying their books because of that. Is it perfect? No, there are issue that need to be dealt with (Events, how characters are treated, lack of development with older characters etc) but I doubt there will ever be an age of books where everyone agrees its perfect.

For the record, even if the quality at Marvel sunk then I would simply cut down to my 'must have' books. I would not jump over to DC because, outside of a few characters, I just much prefer the Marvel world and cast, even when they are not at their best.

Originally Posted by The Negative Zone

Avoid these channels like the plague, nothing to offer but bias opinions.

Yeah, I stay far away from any comics-related YubTub channels. Its one thing to listen to constructive criticisms of those you disagree with, its another to endure 10 mins of hateful shouting. If people find them useful then, fair enough. I just hope they also try some of the discredited books themselves rather then just blindly follow the loudest voice.

I have more than a few issues with Marvel myself, but they still release quite a bit of good stuff. No publisher is 100% terrible. Jane as Thor? It was promoted in a gimmicky, pandering way but was actually really good. Ms. Marvel was a breath of fresh air when she was released. The Soule Inhumans stuff was great, though clearly Marvel was trying to make them a success at the expense of the X-Men because of movie rights.

But there is a lot of crap being published. And Marvel creators are free to have their opinions, but more than a few of them have turned me off buying their products due to their behaviour on social media. NOT the opinions they hold, but the way in which they treat people. And Marvel editorial just seems so disingenuous. They treat diversity like a marketing gimmick and hire minority writers for headlines then don't support them or help them improve. And it *is* tokenism to only hire black people to write black characters, gay people to write gay characters, etc. Let a straight black woman write a Iceman. Let a Hispanic man write Captain Marvel. Actually be progressive. Marvel is talking the talk but not walking the walk.

But, again, in regards to quality? Marvel editorial is clearly acting like DC during the lowest points of the New 52 and interfering in storytelling. And the event fatigue is real. And they're not letting up on any of it.

I have more than a few issues with Marvel myself, but they still release quite a bit of good stuff. No publisher is 100% terrible. Jane as Thor? It was promoted in a gimmicky, pandering way but was actually really good. Ms. Marvel was a breath of fresh air when she was released. The Soule Inhumans stuff was great, though clearly Marvel was trying to make them a success at the expense of the X-Men because of movie rights.

But there is a lot of crap being published. And Marvel creators are free to have their opinions, but more than a few of them have turned me off buying their products due to their behaviour on social media. NOT the opinions they hold, but the way in which they treat people. And Marvel editorial just seems so disingenuous. They treat diversity like a marketing gimmick and hire minority writers for headlines then don't support them or help them improve. And it *is* tokenism to only hire black people to write black characters, gay people to write gay characters, etc. Let a straight black woman write a Iceman. Let a Hispanic man write Captain Marvel. Actually be progressive. Marvel is talking the talk but not walking the walk.

But, again, in regards to quality? Marvel editorial is clearly acting like DC during the lowest points of the New 52 and interfering in storytelling. And the event fatigue is real. And they're not letting up on any of it.

I can totally agree with you on most of these and I do think Marvel has a long way to go to honor the characters they've created. Some of the creators have an attitude that is very off-putting and it makes supporting their work challenging, if not impossible. As far as the diversity hires and such, yes to a degree they should let a someone of a differing race/gender/orientation/religion write the characters, but it is important that representation matters (a good story trumps that for sure), but it makes a difference for younger audiences to see a black man writing Black Panther, or a Muslim woman writing Ms. Marvel. Just as important as having the titles on the stands. I certainly agree with you that Marvel does not provide enough support for their creatives, pulling books left and right without letting them have the actual chance to find their footing and audience. That is a huge mark against Marvel editorial. Event fatigue is certainly real, and the corporate push for synergy and stilted storylines is really killing the fun the comics used to have for me.

It sure is lonely being a person who actually likes the way Marvel is going right now simply because the few books that they do read (books that have been roasted as "bad" on places like D&C) are actually enjoyable.

It is indeed strange why so many people seem to have such strong opinions on books that are both popular and they are not reading. But look on the bright side. Threads like this help you flesh out your ignore list.

It is indeed strange why so many people seem to have such strong opinions on books that are both popular and they are not reading. But look on the bright side. Threads like this help you flesh out your ignore list.

There is a huge amount of toxicity in comic fandom now particularly regarding Marvel. I've been on these forums for a long, long time and it hasn't been this bad.

ISome people don't like certain characters and titles and that's fine. But the negativity is so thick right now that people that actually enjoy the books struggle to even discuss them on the Marvel forums.

Not read through the whole thread but has anyone brought up Marvel using it's characters to try and promote real life War profiteers and only cancelling the release of the comic at the very last minute when peopl protested against it even though they'd already made it (and it was Part 1 too...)

Marvel's deal is that they are sell out hacks who's owner and owner's owner are in love with people who worship the dollar at all costs

Not read through the whole thread but has anyone brought up Marvel using it's characters to try and promote real life War profiteers and only cancelling the release of the comic at the very last minute when peopl protested against it even though they'd already made it (and it was Part 1 too...)

Not sure I've ever heard of this situation . . . can you say what project this was?

Business is pretty good, the content may have flip-flopped around a bit but the money is still coming in. Critics are largely in favour, social media (at least the loudest parts of it) seem to be somewhat irked.

Personally I've tried a lot of books but found most of them not to my taste so I haven't added them to my pull list. A couple have made the cut and I'm enjoying them.

Whatever Marvel's problems, I think things will get better. If not, well they'll always be comics I enjoy, no use worrying about what their problems are.

I respect that people enjoy their books, and I wish I could, too; hell, I even also hope that Marvel does better. I don't want to misrepresent myself, because I grew up with Marvel, but I'm not enjoying their books.

I have more than a few issues with Marvel myself, but they still release quite a bit of good stuff. No publisher is 100% terrible. Jane as Thor? It was promoted in a gimmicky, pandering way but was actually really good. Ms. Marvel was a breath of fresh air when she was released. The Soule Inhumans stuff was great, though clearly Marvel was trying to make them a success at the expense of the X-Men because of movie rights.

But there is a lot of crap being published. And Marvel creators are free to have their opinions, but more than a few of them have turned me off buying their products due to their behaviour on social media. NOT the opinions they hold, but the way in which they treat people. And Marvel editorial just seems so disingenuous. They treat diversity like a marketing gimmick and hire minority writers for headlines then don't support them or help them improve. And it *is* tokenism to only hire black people to write black characters, gay people to write gay characters, etc. Let a straight black woman write a Iceman. Let a Hispanic man write Captain Marvel. Actually be progressive. Marvel is talking the talk but not walking the walk.

But, again, in regards to quality? Marvel editorial is clearly acting like DC during the lowest points of the New 52 and interfering in storytelling. And the event fatigue is real. And they're not letting up on any of it.