Giant Gluten Free Brownie Cookie for Two

[Welcome to recipe #2 of Oat Week – Valentine’s Day Edition! This post is sponsored by my wonderful friends over at Bob’s Red Mill – we’re using their Gluten Free Oat Flour for this Giant Gluten Free Brownie Cookie!]

Valentine’s Day 2015. aka. the day I worked up the nerves to ask the guy I really liked, aka. my best friend, over for dinner.

I’ve always been an all-in kinda gal; what better day is there to ask your crush over than the most romantic day of the year?

So, like the good food blogger I am, I lured him in with food. I was testing a recipe, and I told him I wanted a taste tester. Clever, yes? His friends wanted to go ice skating, but luckily for me, it was like 5 degrees outside and my guy wanted no part of it. So he agreed to come over to his good friend’s apartment for Valentine’s Day.

I’m not gonna lie, I was mildly totally freaking out before he got to my apartment. I took the pictures for my Guacos this day, and after looking at them for like two seconds, you can probably tell that I had something else on my mind. ?

So this guy came over. We ate. We talked. I drew on his arm (What?). It was a super fun, low-key night. No “moves” were made. No romanticness occurred. But I ended up having a really awesome night with my very best friend.

I think that’s the point of Valentine’s Day; to spend the day with the people you really care about. And while I don’t need a day to tell my loved ones that I’m crazy about them, having a day dedicated to that very thing is always something I look forward to.

So I’m actually really stoked about Valentine’s Day this Sunday! And, I mean, it definitely helps that this year, I’ll be spending my time with that same guy. But this year, he’s my boyfran ?. And that we have fiesta, wine, and cookie plans this year. Because what is a holiday without delicious food?

Nay, what is a holiday without a Giant Gluten Free Brownie Cookie…for two?

Guys seriously, this is the best kind of sweet treat to share with your honey as you’re clinkin’ the wine and snuggling real close on the couch. Perfectly portioned for two, crazy rich and dreamy, and super-duper chocolatey. The perfect ending to your romantic evening. ?

So, while this cookie definitely gets some of its awe-factor from its size (seriously guys, we’re talking giant), but from its ingredient list, too!

What you won’t find here:

gluten

refined sugar

eggs

dairy

animal products

What you will find here:

Bob’s Red Mill Gluten Free Oat Flour: our flour of choice! I’ve used this flour in a few different recipes in the past, and I can honestly say that I’m OBSESSED. And when used in this recipe, magic happens. Out of the oven, this cookie tastes like a cakey brownie. But. If you stick it in the fridge and let it get all cold, it magically turns into a dense and fudgy brownie! Mark and I both preferred this cookie from the fridge, but you do you, chica.

Coconut Oil and Nut Butter: needed to make this cookie all nice and rich! Use your favorite nut butter here! Just not peanut butter. I surely couldn’t post FOUR peanut butter recipes in a row. That would be crazy. So I’m definitely not recommending peanut butter. *wink wink nudge nudge* I totally did use peanut butter and it was amazing. ? But feel free to use your fav!

CHOCOLATE: in two forms – unsweetened cocoa powder and chocolate chips! This recipe can be completely free of refined sugar and dairy if you use the right kind of chocolate chips, so this recipe is a total crowd-pleaser. I used some semi-sweet chocolate chips and loved it, but your favorite chocolate will work just beautifully. If you love your desserts sweet, a milk or even white chocolate chip should be your go to. If you’re into rich and decadent desserts, opt for a semi-sweet or dark chip. Whatever you fancy, you know it’s gonna be delish.

This Giant Gluten Free Brownie Cookie is a necessary addition to your Valentine’s Day plans with your loved one! When you’re all done with dinner, getting sleepy, and ready relax with your bae, imagine digging into this hunka hunka burnin’ love…

Add your wet ingredient to your dry ingredients, and mix with a silicone spatula or wooden spoon until combined. The dough will be wet, but it should come together in a ball. If not, add another Tbsp. oat flour.

Add chocolate chips and mix to combine.

Dump dough into a tall ball on your prepared baking sheet. Stud with additional chocolate chips for looks if desired. Bake 14-15 minutes, or until the edges start to get crispy.

Allow to cool on the baking sheet.

IF you like cakey brownies, enjoy warm/at room temperature (it’s a bit crumbly this way). IF you like fudgy brownies, throw the cooled cookie in the fridge for about an hour, and then enjoy. We liked it much more cold from the fridge.

Notes

*I used peanut butter because I can’t get enough of that PB+C, but any nut butter would do perfectly! Use cashew butter to add a rich butteriness to your cookies, or use almond butter for a more nutty cookie!

Check your email to confirm and to download your free eCookbook!

Reader Interactions

Comments

This is a verrrrry sexy creation like omg need.
And your story about inviting your boyf over for the first time had me giggling. Love reading the personal stories <3 Hope you two have a fabulous VDay together!!

I love how easy this recipe is and it looks super chocolatey! Yum! Great plan luring your boyfriend in with food- works every time haha. A lot of my “first dates” with my fiancé involved me cooking for him :)

This looks absolutely perfect. I love to hear about your love story? But then again, I am a total hopeless romantic. I think the boyf would definitely love this, but can I just have it all to myself instead?

Hi, Ashley! So glad you liked the flavors (and that it made a great ice cream topping – GENIUS!), but I was bummed yours fell apart! I rushed home to remake the recipe – I added an extra Tbsp. nut butter (which is now reflected in the ingredient list), and it helped the cookie stay together much better! I’d also suggest you letting it cool completely and throwing it in the fridge to get all nice and cold. It stays together much better – and we think it tastes much better – straight out of the fridge. I hope these suggestions help!

Hey, Cece! I’m thinking it would be kinda bland because it wouldn’t have any sweetness. I also think the texture would be a little weird, as gluten free baking is finicky to begin with! If you’re interested in using honey instead, that might work!

I just came across this recipe on Pinterest and so wish I had found it last night. I was having a major brownie craving but didn’t want to make a whole batch. I’m storing this away for next time I’m craving something sweet. :)

Hello Alexa. I really like this recipe and I will be trying it soon. It looks really good! If I want to substitute rice-bran oil for coconut oil, do I still have to boil it first? Also, how long can I keep this cookie out in the room temperature? Thanks!

Awesome! I’ve never actually worked with rice-bran oil before. If you want to give it a go, make sure it’s in a liquid form, then proceed with the rest of the recipe. As I mention in the post, I much prefer this cookie straight from the fridge (it’s a little crumbly warm/at room temp.), but you can probably keep it out at room temp. for a day. If you try it, let me know what you think! :)