These reader picks for best waterproof mascara will help you beat smudging, smearing and running for good. Plus, see which two waterproof mascara picks were voted the worst

Why it's not great: Even though clumping isn't the worst part about this mascara, readers say it doesn't have a truly waterproof formula.
"This mascara claims to be water resistant but once I go to wash my face, I have raccoon eyes," says one unhappy reviewer. "This mascara definitely does not thicken the lashes.... Waste of money."

I absolutely LOVE the Revlon HD waterproof mascara!!! That other one (Revlon Flashpoint I think) didn't do well in the survey but the new HD one is really good. I don't have to retouch it all day and I'm a musician and I have really long days (and nights!) I don't wear false lashes so I don't know how it works for those but it makes mine look dark and full without excessive clumping. Love it!!