Q & A: Timothy Lytton, Author of the Book 'Kosher'

Timothy D. Lytton is the Albert and Angela Farone Distinguished Professor of Law at Albany Law School, where he teaches courses on regulatory theory and administrative law. His book, “Kosher: Private Regulation in the Age of Industrial Food,” has just been published by Harvard University Press. In his book, Lytton argues that the $12 billion a year kosher industry is something of an unheralded story of success of private-sector regulation in an era of growing public concern over the government’s ability to ensure food safety. Kosher uncovers how independent certification agencies rescued American kosher supervision from fraud and corruption and turned it into a model of nongovernmental administration.

Recently Professor Lytton answered a few questions from the What Is Your Food Worth? Project.

WIYFW: What got you interested in kosher food and the business of kosher?

Timothy Lytton: I am interested in private alternatives to government regulation, especially in the areas of food safety and nutrition labeling. As a general matter, private food safety audits and industry-sponsored nutrition labeling schemes have been a great disappointment. Behind most major food-poisoning outbreaks is some private auditing firm that gave the food producer a phony five-star rating. And when nutritional rating schemes give high marks to sugary cereals and full-fat ice cream, you have to wonder.

As a kosher-observant Orthodox Jew, I realized that kosher certification offers a 2000 year old example of private food certification. My initial suspicion was that kosher certification was full of price gouging and unnecessary, super-stringent standards. As I began to get into my research, however, I found that, although fraud and corruption were rampant a century ago in kosher meat production, today’s kosher system is highly reliable. My book tells the story of how, within the span of a century, kosher certification became the one of the most reliable systems of private certification in the food industry, indeed, perhaps in any industry.

WIYFW: Given the recent horsemeat scandal, do you have any thoughts about why some food regulations fail and others succeed? In our industrialized and globalized food system, is it really possible to monitor what goes into the food we eat?

The food business is one of the largest and most complex industries on the planet. Global retail food sales alone are a $4 trillion operation, and supply chains from farm to table reach around the globe. No regulatory system can provide 100% protection from foodborne illness or adequately police nutrition labeling. The real question is how to achieve marginal improvements in food safety and labeling. Government regulation of these problems has come a long way in the past century since the Pure Food and Drug Act and the Federal Meat Inspection Act were passed in 1906. Governments in other countries have made similar advances.

Unfortunately, government regulation still falls short of public expectations. That’s where private regulation comes in. Reliable private certification can help to achieve marginal improvements in these areas. Private regulation need not be instead of government regulation; it can complement it.

WIYFW: You write that the kosher industry has succeeded as a non-governmental regulatory body. In other words, if something is labeled kosher, it will not include treif [non-kosher] ingredients. Do you think there is a larger lesson here? Has government failed? Do we seek other ways and other forms of regulation?

TL: As I mentioned, private certification offers a potential complement to government regulation in reducing food contamination, adulteration, and mislabeling. The larger lesson of kosher certification is that, under certain conditions, private regulation can be highly effective in making sure that whatever companies claim about their products is true—whether that be the kosher status of the product or some other feature, such as purity, fair labor standards, or environmental sustainability.

WIYFW: Back to the kosher industry: Do you think the kosher industry could expand its regulatory power to deal with how labor, animals, and the environment are treated? Do you believe the kosher industry should feel responsible to adhere to regulations beyond those specifically mandated by Jewish law?

TL: Kosher certification agencies are staffed by professionals with specialized training in Jewish dietary laws, food chemistry, and food technology. Although there may be some overlap between these specialties and other regulatory specialties, one should be careful to entrust kosher inspectors with tasks for which they are not trained and to which they may not be as committed as they are to kosher observance. Of course, an ethical person should not be complicit in any production operation involving unfair labor practices, animal cruelty, or environmental degradation. But I’m not sure I would entrust the job of assuring consumers about those things to a person not professionally trained in these areas or committed to these regulatory goals. Moreover, on a practical basis, companies grant kosher inspectors extraordinary access to their operations for the purpose of kosher certification. It is not clear that they would grant these same inspectors this level of access to police other aspects of their operations that might expose them to criminal or civil sanctions.

That said, as a consumer, I seek products that are certified as fair trade, free of animal cruelty, and environmentally sustainable. Private certification offers a potentially effective tool to protect consumers and promote these policies. My book argues that the history of the kosher certification system holds important lessons about how to make such systems of private certification reliable. Kosher certification is not the vehicle, but it is the model.

Top Stories

The Jewish Daily Forward welcomes reader comments in order to promote thoughtful discussion on issues of importance to the Jewish community. In the interest of maintaining a civil forum, The Jewish Daily Forwardrequires that all commenters be appropriately respectful toward our writers, other commenters and the subjects of the articles. Vigorous debate and reasoned critique are welcome; name-calling and personal invective are not. While we generally do not seek to edit or actively moderate comments, our spam filter prevents most links and certain key words from being posted and The Jewish Daily Forward reserves the right to remove comments for any reason.

AIPAC is kicking off its conference under a cloud of controversy over Benjamin Netanyahu's planned speech.
As the meeting starts this morning, a fresh dispute raged over Shmuley Boteach's nasty attack ad aimed at White House security chief Susan Rice.

Of Rosanne Barr, King David Kalakaua and 9 other things about Jewish Hawaii

Yum. Deli Man is a mouthwatering journey to Jewish delis across the country, from New York to Houston - our review.

The #Missouri politician who committed suicide amid rumors that he was Jewish received at least $200,000 in political contributions in the past two years from a leading Jewish Republican donor.

Irving Kahn, the Jewish money manager who has died at the age of 109, exemplified a work ethic which stressed ever-fresh intellectual interests as a way to remain young in spirit.
We recall his legacy.

Chocolate-nutella halvah hamantaschen? This fudge and rich #Purim cookie is as delicious as it sounds.

The Forward occasionally sends promotional e-mails to our subscribers on behalf of selected sponsors, whose advertising supports our independent journalism. We hope you will look at their messages and find their offers interesting to you, but if you would like to opt out of receiving them, please uncheck this box.