I’m having trouble wrapping my head around Andy Rubin’s dismissal of Siri, the virtual assistant built into Apple’s iPhone 4S. Here’s what Rubin, Google’s senior vice president of mobile, told Ina Fried during the Asia D conference in Hong Kong:

“I don’t believe that your phone should be an assistant,” he said. “Your phone is a tool for communicating. You shouldn’t be communicating with the phone; you should be communicating with somebody on the other side of the phone.”

A few thoughts:

The smartphone is a descendant of the PDA, which stands for Personal Digital Assistant. So there’s that.

Android already has voice commands in it (“listen to,” “navigate to” and so on). The essential difference is that Android’s voice commands are harder to access because you have to memorize the syntax.

Siri’s main purpose is to make certain tasks easier by letting people talk and listen instead of look and type. That’s it. By thinking of Siri in terms of who is communicating with whom, Rubin is missing the point of why the technology is important.

I understand that tech companies aren’t supposed to praise the competition. No one expects Rubin to go ga-ga over Siri. But when the guy who oversees Android, the world’s biggest smartphone platform, blows off the idea of natural voice interaction with a computer, it’s flabbergasting. And disappointing.

I mean, seriously, Andy. Please grasp the importance of an almost-AI in your pocket. Tell me you’re doing that thing Steve Jobs did where he would pretend to dismiss something, but was actually subtly suggesting how Apple’s implementation would be even better. Because I’d hate to think that the higher-ups at Google took one look at Siri and decided that they weren’t interested in the concept.

I find the drama levels to be delightfully low here at technologizer. I do, however, find the 'connect with facebook' options to be disgustingly non-working. (mac, latest firefox) am I missing something?

I'll only agree if you can tell me the difference between bias and opinion. But in the meantime, allow me to rewrite the story in a way that's more suitable to you.

—–

Andy Rubin said the following about Siri:

“I don’t believe that your phone should be an assistant,” he said. “Your phone is a tool for communicating. You shouldn’t be communicating with the phone; you should be communicating with somebody on the other side of the phone.”

"Siri’s main purpose is to make certain tasks easier by letting people talk and listen instead of look and type"

Is this your original thought? This is the best sound bite yet as to what Siri is. Siri lets people talk and listen rather than look and type. Forget natural language processing, AI, context, semantics, and the like. Siri lets people talk and listen rather than look and type. How simple. How Apple like.

Siri lets people talk and listen rather than look and type. I want partial credit because I reduced the number of words. But Jared deserves credit for getting to the essence of Siri.

So we all get bent out of shape because of smoke and mirror statements? Jobs and everyone else uses misdirection when talking about their competitors. I think we can all agree that ANY edge is important in business and in sales the more edges you have the more lasting the cuts to your competition. Siri is major and Apple has done their homework on this one. Even if you think it's not something you would use millions of others will and that makes it big by anyone’s standards.

I love my iOS devices and my Android devices. Android had speach recognition 1st maybe (not sure) but Apple with SIRI on the iPhone 4s just leapfrogged Android in this area. If it makes anyone want to speak naturally to their device and have it work well people will use it. Keep it simple, make it function well, make it look good and the prize goes to the folks that remember that we are all influenced by Star Trek communicators and having the ability to talk to our computers and they talk back.

Both iOS and Android are large enough to attract loads of attention from malware writers, it's just that (at the moment) that Android market is making it the easy target. bed bath and beyond printable coupons