The five-man Fantasy Source staff agrees on many things, like … OK, we don't really agree on anything. And, as such, we like to argue about fantasy baseball.

So, when we cast our ballots for several preseason fantasy awards, it's not surprising that we had some wildly different takes on the various categories. Here's a breakdown of our Breakout Hitter choices:

Lutovsky's pick: Jedd Gyorko. Did you know Gyorko finished second among all 2Bs with 23 homers last year? I didn't either until I looked it up, but he did. The 25-year-old second baseman had an up-and-down rookie campaign, but he flashed power and potential at a relatively thin position. Even at PETCO, he has a chance to be a Dan Uggla-type in the power department, only with a better average. Plus, he has a funny name.

Bender's pick: Yasiel Puig. This is where we see the differing interpretations of this category. To me, Puig broke out last year, but Bill thinks the Cuban phenom can do bigger and better things over a full season. It's easy to see why after last year's .319/.391/.534 campaign, but Puig also runs the risk of disappointing. After all, isn't that what Bryce Harper did last year? Speaking of ...

Pinkerton's pick: Bryce Harper. Harper seemingly took a step back after his stellar rookie season, but fantasy owners' sky-high expectations (and an injury) are more to blame than his play. Harper had a better OBP and SLG than in 2012, and his BB- and K-rates both moved in the right directions. Brad clearly thinks the 21-year-old will stay healthy and put it all together this year. If he does, we could be talking about him as a top-three pick next season (he went top 10 in our first mock draft). If he doesn't, impatient fantasy owners will be labeling Harper a "bust" well before he's legally allowed to rent a car in most states.

Williams' pick: Xander Bogaerts. Craig is known as a wild card around the office, and he definitely went out on a limb with this pick. Bogaerts had just 50 regular-season plate appearances last year, showing very little offensively. But in 12 postseason games, he hit .296/.412/.481, proving his worth. His minor league track record suggests success is on the horizon, but it might be a little too soon for the 21-year-old shortstop. But, just like Charlie Kelly, Craig embraces being a wild card. The rest of the staff isn't quite as sold, as Bogaerts sits just 22nd in our initial SS rankings.

Valentine's pick: Manny Machado. This was the easiest pick to predict, mainly because Ben fervently believes that doubles always turn into homers for young players -- and Machado led the AL with 51 two-baggers last year. Will the homers start flying out of Camden Yards already? Maybe, but Machado is still just 21 and coming off a serious knee injury. For him to truly "break out" after last year's solid season, he'll either have to start stealing more bases or he'll have to prove Ben right and turn those doubles into homers.