Customer Reviews

I wear a size 8 in most shoes but I had heard that these Dexter 1957 shoes run a little bigger - similar to Allen Edmonds. I bought a 7.5 and it fits perfectly! This is a beautifully well made shoe that looks like it's made at the Highland factory in Maine (not sure about this) and is on par with Alden, Allen Edmonds, Rancourt and Co. penny loafers. The leather is soft and looks high quality - doesn't have a that plastic-y look at all. I got the brown one and the color is basically exactly like the photo - not any darker or lighter. It came with a pair of nice shoe bags. Top notch!

I felt this product's fit was
Fits half size larger

I felt this product's width was
Fits true to width

Kathie

starstarstarstarstar

Spencet

8/7/2012

This is the second pair of this shoe that I
have purchased for my husband. The style
and comfort make them one of his favorite.

I felt this product's fit was
true to size

I felt this product's width was
true to width

Jean

starstarstarstarstar

Poughkeepsie NY

9/14/2011

GREAT SERVICE

I felt this product's fit was
true to size

I felt this product's width was
true to width

Barry

starstarstarstarstar

Virginia

4/27/2011

Another excellent made in the USA product from Dexter

I felt this product's fit was
true to size

I felt this product's width was
true to width

Richard

starstarstarstarstar

Winston Salem/NC

4/10/2011

I bought two pair and this is a great shoe I did not however receive shoe bags with one pair. Would it be possible to send them. Thanks very much for good service.

I felt this product's fit was
true to size

I felt this product's width was
true to width

James

starstarstarstarstar

Cedar Rapids Iowa

10/26/2009

I have worn Dexter Shoes in the past. We haven’’t had a local dealer selling Dexter shoes for several years. I found the shoes available on-line and though I would try a pair again. I have always worn 13d so I tried the 13m. The shoes I received seem to be a little tight in the width.

I felt this product's fit was
true to size

I felt this product's width was
fits narrow

Robert

starstarstarstarstar

Detroit Michigan

5/6/2009

Excellent customer service

I felt this product's fit was
true to size

I felt this product's width was
fits narrow

Walter

starstarstarstarstar

Columbus

2/16/2009

This pair of loafers from Dexter fit perfectly. My size is 11 and these were perfect. Couldn’’t be happier about them. I did go for the more expensive quicker option on delivery and it didn’’t arrive as quick as hoped but it was less than a week. Great shoes great fit.

I felt this product's fit was
true to size

I felt this product's width was
true to width

Levend

starstarstarstarstar

New York/NY

6/24/2008

Great shopping

I felt this product's fit was
true to size

I felt this product's width was
true to width

Frederick

starstarstarstarstar

New Milford

1/3/2008

Its rare to locate shoes made in the good old USA. Trust me the Chinese and the Brazillians are not able to match he quality of material and construction.I found the size 8/2 that I reieeved to fit perfectly with heavy scks.

I wear a size 8 in most shoes but I had heard that these Dexter 1957 shoes run a little bigger - similar to Allen Edmonds. I bought a 7.5 and it fits perfectly! This is a beautifully well made shoe that looks like it's made at the Highland factory in Maine (not sure about this) and is on par with Alden, Allen Edmonds, Rancourt and Co. penny loafers. The leather is soft and looks high quality - doesn't have a that plastic-y look at all. I got the brown one and the color is basically exactly like the photo - not any darker or lighter. It came with a pair of nice shoe bags. Top notch!

Kathie

starstarstarstarstar

Spencet

8/7/2012

I felt this product
true to size

I felt this product
true to width

This is the second pair of this shoe that I
have purchased for my husband. The style
and comfort make them one of his favorite.

Jean

starstarstarstarstar

Poughkeepsie NY

9/14/2011

I felt this product
true to size

I felt this product
true to width

GREAT SERVICE

Barry

starstarstarstarstar

Virginia

4/27/2011

I felt this product
true to size

I felt this product
true to width

Another excellent made in the USA product from Dexter

Richard

starstarstarstarstar

Winston Salem/NC

4/10/2011

I felt this product
true to size

I felt this product
true to width

I bought two pair and this is a great shoe I did not however receive shoe bags with one pair. Would it be possible to send them. Thanks very much for good service.

James

starstarstarstarstar

Cedar Rapids Iowa

10/26/2009

I felt this product
true to size

I felt this product
fits narrow

I have worn Dexter Shoes in the past. We haven’’t had a local dealer selling Dexter shoes for several years. I found the shoes available on-line and though I would try a pair again. I have always worn 13d so I tried the 13m. The shoes I received seem to be a little tight in the width.

Robert

starstarstarstarstar

Detroit Michigan

5/6/2009

I felt this product
true to size

I felt this product
fits narrow

Excellent customer service

Walter

starstarstarstarstar

Columbus

2/16/2009

I felt this product
true to size

I felt this product
true to width

This pair of loafers from Dexter fit perfectly. My size is 11 and these were perfect. Couldn’’t be happier about them. I did go for the more expensive quicker option on delivery and it didn’’t arrive as quick as hoped but it was less than a week. Great shoes great fit.

Levend

starstarstarstarstar

New York/NY

6/24/2008

I felt this product
true to size

I felt this product
true to width

Great shopping

Frederick

starstarstarstarstar

New Milford

1/3/2008

I felt this product
true to size

I felt this product
true to width

Its rare to locate shoes made in the good old USA. Trust me the Chinese and the Brazillians are not able to match he quality of material and construction.I found the size 8/2 that I reieeved to fit perfectly with heavy scks.

Ben

starstarstarstarstar

Boston Massachusett

8/13/2007

I felt this product
true to size

I felt this product
true to width

I returned the first pair of Pembrokes I received from Shoeline for exchange because the stitching was loose on the sole of one shoe. I suspect the supposed replacement that was then sent to me may have been the same pair with the stitching trimmed since there was still a loose end albeit shorter in exactly the same place. Otherwise I’’m delighted with what seem excellent shoes at a competitive price.

David

starstarstarstarstar

Sandy/Utah

7/20/2006

I felt this product
true to size

I felt this product
true to width

Great shoes. Comfortable from first wearing.

Jeffrey

starstarstarstarstar

Brooklyn NY

11/21/2005

I felt this product
true to size

I felt this product
true to width

I loved these shoes so much the first time that I bought them that I decided I needed another pair. I forgot the model number but I called and was helped by the great customer service who not only helped me identify the model but helped get it to me on time. Shoeline.com is not staffed by robots. While the computer said it wouldn’’t get to me before my trip the customer service representative did some magic and made it show up.