Two talk-show titans came together Monday night: Oprah Winfrey and The Tonight Show.

It wasn't the first time Winfrey had been on the show – that was in 1986 during Johnny Carson's tenure – but it was her first time visiting Jimmy Fallon, and the pair put together quite the skit for the occasion.

"Back in the '80s, we starred in a TV show together," Fallon explains to Winfrey, before showing a clip of the pair starring in a wonderfully cheesy soap opera called Midnight Memories – with Auto-Tuned voices. They run through the gamut of soap-style histrionics, their their voices pitched up, down and all over with the effect.

After Oprah Winfrey told PEOPLE she thought the protests in Ferguson and New York City over police treatment of African-Americans lacked leadership, some of the movement's organizers took to social media to criticize her take.