Before The Insane was nerfed, I remember watching my wife farm the single required goblin in Badlands for weeks on end. No movement. No interaction. Just pressing one button to kill this poor, goblin vendor every few minutes. Not long after that she began the arduous process of Shen'dralar and let me tell you, none of that was the hardest part. That came after, she it broke her heart to hear that 4.x was removing the most difficult(and for some, the greatest badge of dedication) aspects of the achievement.

The initial requirements of the title were indeed, insane. Now they're just annoying.

Alliance AB tabard is also the best looking tabard in the game imo
honestly I wouldn't even count arena titles (or maybe even legit hero from rbgs) since some people simply can't achieve them, no matter how hard they try.

More accurate to say most people will never get arena titles. It's kinda unfair since every achievement/title should be obtainable by the average casual player.

Says who? I like that there are some titles, achievements that are just for them hardcore players. And no, I am not one of them

I have to agree with Kerdoz here, if every title would be obtainable by every player in WoW they wouldn't be unique at all. There are lots of titles easily obtainable for
the average casual player already today.

With Battlemaster, Conqueror and the Bloodthirsty Titles on my Main i would say Battlemaster is the one who causes the most Nerdrages of all of them, especially when you did it like me without any help.

Rank 1 titles are mostly hoarded by the same handful of players each season. Most players wont ever see a player wearing a rank 1 title (unless they play on specific realms), let alone actually getting one for themself. Assuming the title is obtainable, a player who is dedicated will surely be able to earn it.

Current heroic mode end boss title? Join a 5 days a week raiding guild and you will eventually, but surely get it while it is current.

Arena master... Some players with interrest in PvP will eventually get it. Gladiator..? Fotm + dedication + a lot of pvp practice. Rank 1? If you don't already have a rank 1 title, chances are that you wont ever get one. Unless you are into DDos, buying titles, or have already been close to getting one several times already of course. DDos part was a joke btw.

Rank 1 titles are mostly hoarded by the same handful of players each season. Most players wont ever see a player wearing a rank 1 title (unless they play on specific realms), let alone actually getting one for themself. Assuming the title is obtainable, a player who is dedicated will surely be able to earn it.

Current heroic mode end boss title? Join a 5 days a week raiding guild and you will eventually, but surely get it while it is current.

Arena master... Some players with interrest in PvP will eventually get it. Gladiator..? Fotm + dedication + a lot of pvp practice. Rank 1? If you don't already have a rank 1 title, chances are that you wont ever get one. Unless you are into DDos, buying titles, or have already been close to getting one several times already of course. DDos part was a joke btw.

Before The Insane was nerfed, I remember watching my wife farm the single required goblin in Badlands for weeks on end. No movement. No interaction. Just pressing one button to kill this poor, goblin vendor every few minutes. Not long after that she began the arduous process of Shen'dralar and let me tell you, none of that was the hardest part. That came after, she it broke her heart to hear that 4.x was removing the most difficult(and for some, the greatest badge of dedication) aspects of the achievement.

The initial requirements of the title were indeed, insane. Now they're just annoying.

Killing the goblin in the Badlands was needed to get your reputation above Revered. You only needed Honored for Insane. It was never, ever a part of Insane. It never did and still doesn't award any achievement or feat at all to get Exalted with Bloodsail.

Of course completionists like me dreamed of one day getting Bloodsail rep to exalted. Which you now can. The whole fact that Bloodsail rep capped at Revered and only one mob in the game exceeded the cap was clearly just an oversight, there is no reason for it whatsoever.

In fact in terms of Bloodsail rep, the Insane became A LOT harder in Cataclysm because they buffed the goblins in Booty Bay so much you needed a group to kill them. Where you could just annihilate the whole town solo in your sleep in Wrath. The only things that got easier where the removal of Shendralar due to the elimination of the faction (but if you were a completionist you still needed it to get the Agent feat of strength so it's kind of irrelevant) and the Darkmoon Faire rep which you can now get through the DMF daily quests and/or turnins I believe.

People vastly overestimate how hard DMF rep was in any case. All I did was buy heaps of Cataclysm decks in the weeks leading up to DMF and hand them all in and AH the resulting trinkets. I actually MADE MONEY from it. Took about three months because I was doing it slowly but if you had enough free capital you could easily do it in what, a few days? Depending on your server's AH. It was nothing compared to Shendralar which cost an arm and a leg (you could farm all the mats but I quickly decided to hell with that, much easier to farm gold and buy them).

Storm's End for the time being, same with The Fearless during T14. Any current heroic raid titles (except maybe Savior of Azeroth - that wasn't hard to get at all with progressive debuff getting higher and higher to a point where T13 HC had lesser DPS/HPS checks than previous tiers)

PvP titles R1 gladiator, even regular gladiator is good and hard to get.