Commentary Critical and Explanatory on John 6: 35-50

From the Commentary on the Whole Bible (Jamieson, Fausset and Brown, 1871).

35. I am the bread of life—Henceforth the discourse is all in the first person,
"I," "Me," which occur in one form or other, as Stier reckons, thirty-five
times.

he that cometh to me—to obtain what the soul craves, and as the only
all-sufficient and ordained source of supply.

hunger … thirst—shall have conscious and abiding satisfaction.

36. But … ye have seen me, and believe not—seen Him not in His mere bodily
presence, but in all the majesty of His life, His teaching, His works.

37-40. All that, &c.—This comprehensive and very grand passage is expressed with
a peculiar artistic precision. The opening general statement (Joh 6:37) consists
of two members:

(1) "All that the Father Giveth me shall come to me"—that is, "Though ye, as I
told you, have no faith in Me, My errand into the world shall in no wise be
defeated; for all that the Father giveth Me shall infallibly come to Me."
Observe, what is given Him by the Father is expressed in the singular number and
neuter gender—literally, "everything"; while those who come to Him are put in
the masculine gender and singular number—"every one." The whole mass, so to
speak, is gifted by the Father to the Son as a unity, which the Son evolves, one
by one, in the execution of His trust. So Joh 17:2, "that He should give eternal
life to all that which Thou hast given Him" [Bengel]. This "shall" expresses the
glorious certainty of it, the Father being pledged to see to it that the gift be
no empty mockery.

(2) "And him that cometh to me I WILL IN NO WISE CAST OUT." As the former was
the divine, this is just the human side of the same thing. True, the "coming"
ones of the second clause are just the "given" ones of the first. But had our
Lord merely said, "When those that have been given Me of My Father shall come to
Me, I will receive them"—besides being very flat, the impression conveyed would
have been quite different, sounding as if there were no other laws in operation,
in the movement of sinners to Christ, but such as are wholly divine and
inscrutable to us; whereas, though He does speak of it as a sublime certainty
which men's refusals cannot frustrate, He speaks of that certainty as taking
effect only by men's voluntary advances to Him and acceptance of Him—"Him that
cometh to Me," "whosoever will," throwing the door wide open. Only it is not the
simply willing, but the actually coming, whom He will not cast out; for the word
here employed usually denotes arrival, as distinguished from the ordinary word,
which rather expresses the act of coming (see Joh 8:42, Greek), [Webster and
Wilkinson]. "In no wise" is an emphatic negative, to meet the fears of the timid
(as in Re 21:27, to meet the presumption of the hardened). These, then, being
the two members of the general opening statement, what follows is meant to take
in both,

38. For I came down from heaven not to do Mine own will—to play an independent
part.

but—in respect to both the foregoing things, the divine and the human side of
salvation.

the will of Him that sent Me—What this twofold will of Him that sent Him is, we
are next sublimely told (Joh 6:39, 40):

39. And this—in the first place.

is the will of Him that sent me, that of all—everything.

which He hath given Me—(taking up the identical words of Joh 6:37).

I should lose nothing, but should raise it up at the last day—The meaning is
not, of course, that He is charged to keep the objects entrusted to Him as He
received them, so as they should merely suffer nothing in His hands. For as they
were just "perishing" sinners of Adam's family, to let "nothing" of such "be
lost," but "raise them up at the last day," must involve, first, giving His
flesh for them (Joh 6:51), that they "might not perish, but have everlasting
life"; and then, after "keeping them from falling," raising their sleeping dust
in incorruption and glory, and presenting them, body and soul, perfect and
entire, wanting nothing, to Him who gave them to Him, saying, "Behold I and the
children which God hath given Me." So much for the first will of Him that sent
Him, the divine side of man's salvation, whose every stage and movement is
inscrutable to us, but infallibly certain.

40. And this—in the second place.

is the will of Him that sent Me, that every one which seeth the Son and
believeth on Him—seeing the Son believeth on Him.

may have everlasting life, and I will raise him up at the last day—This is the
human side of the same thing as in the foregoing verse, and answering to "Him
that cometh unto Me I will in no wise cast out"; that is, I have it expressly in
charge that everyone that so "beholdeth" (so vieweth) the Son as to believe on
Him shall have everlasting life; and, that none of Him be lost, "I will raise
him up at the last day." (See on Joh 6:54).

41-46. Jews murmured—muttered, not in our Lord's hearing, but He knew it (Joh
6:43; Joh 2:25).

he said, I am the bread, &c.—Missing the sense and glory of this, and having no
relish for such sublimities, they harp upon the "Bread from heaven." "What can
this mean? Do we not know all about Him—where, when, and of whom He was born?
And yet He says He came down from heaven!"

43, 44. Murmur not … No man—that is, Be not either startled or stumbled at these
sayings; for it needs divine teaching to understand them, divine drawing to
submit to them.

44. can come to me—in the sense of Joh 6:35.

except the Father which hath sent me—that is, the Father as the Sender of Me and
to carry out the design of My mission.

draw him—by an internal and efficacious operation; though by all the means of
rational conviction, and in a way altogether consonant to their moral nature (So
1:4; Jer 31:3; Ho 11:3, 4).

raise him up, &c.—(See on Joh 6:54).

45. written in the prophets—in Isa 54:13; Jer 31:33, 34; other similar passages
may also have been in view. Our Lord thus falls back upon Scripture authority
for this seemingly hard saying.

all taught of God—not by external revelation merely, but by internal
illumination, corresponding to the "drawing" of Joh 6:44.

Every man therefore, &c.—that is, who hath been thus efficaciously taught of
Him.

cometh unto me—with absolute certainty, yet in the sense above given of
"drawing"; that is, "As none can come to Me but as divinely drawn, so none thus
drawn shall fail to come."

46. Not that any man hath seen, &c.—Lest they should confound that "hearing and
learning of the Father," to which believers are admitted by divine teaching,
with His own immediate access to Him, He here throws in a parenthetical
explanation; stating, as explicitly as words could do it, how totally different
the two cases were, and that only He who is "from God" hath this naked,
immediate access to the Father. (See Joh 1:18).

47-51. He that believeth, &c.—(See on Joh 3:36; Joh 5:24).

48. I am the bread of life—"As he that believeth in Me hath everlasting life, so
I am Myself the everlasting Sustenance of that life." (Repeated from Joh 6:35).

49. Your fathers—of whom ye spake (Joh 6:31); not "ours," by which He would hint
that He had a higher descent, of which they dreamt not [Bengel].

did eat manna … and are dead—recurring to their own point about the manna, as
one of the noblest of the ordained preparatory illustrations of His own office:
"Your fathers, ye say, ate manna in the wilderness; and ye say well, for so they
did, but they are dead—even they whose carcasses fell in the wilderness did eat
of that bread; the Bread whereof I speak cometh down from heaven, which the
manna never did, that men, eating of it, may live for ever."

51. I am, &c.—Understand, it is of Myself I now speak as the Bread from heaven;
of Meif a man eat he shall live for ever; and "THE Bread which i will give is my
Flesh, which i will give for the life of the world." Here, for the first time in
this high discourse, our Lord explicitly introduces His sacrificial death—for
only rationalists can doubt this not only as that which constitutes Him the
Bread of life to men, but as THAT very element IN Him which possesses the
life-giving virtue.—"From this time we hear no more (in this discourse) of
"Bread"; this figure is dropped, and the reality takes its place" [Stier]. The
words "I will give" may be compared with the words of institution at the Supper,
"This is My body which is given for you" (Lu 22:19), or in Paul's report of it,
"broken for you" (1Co 11:24).