Related Links

WHAT IT IS: A two-sided pencil with a black eyeliner on one end and a highlighter on the other

HOW IT FEELS/LOOKS: The creamy liner is dark, not-a-star-in-the-sky black, and the eye brightener is off-white. Both glide on smoothly and blend easily.

WHY WE LIKE IT: The jet-black pencil can define the eyes or be diffused into a sooty look—either way, it adds dramatic intensity and stays put for hours. Drawing the highlighter pencil along the lower lash lines makes eyes look big, bright, and awake.