Monday, 7 August 2017

The
ABC Four Corners program “Pumped” which was screened on 24th July
has illustrated how important scrutiny of the establishment is to the rule of
law in our democracy. It also illustrates why the ABC is under threat from many
politicians and other powerful players who see any effective scrutiny of their
operations as an intolerable threat to their way of doing business, a way that
is against both the general community interest as well as the national
interest.

The
outrage from the revelations of water theft and other illegality by big
irrigators in the northern NSW area of the Murray-Darling Basin (MDB) has
increased over the days since the program was screened. Politicians have
been left scrambling and forced to change tack following the strength of the
reaction and the condemnation of the inadequacy of their initial responses.

In
NSW the Nationals Minister for Primary Industry, Niall Blair, was forced to
change from an internal inquiry conducted by his department to an independent
inquiry. Blair was excessively optimistic in thinking that such an
internal inquiry would be acceptable given that Four Corners had revealed a
questionable relationship between Gavin Hanlon[1],
his department’s Deputy Director General (Water), and big irrigators in the upper
MDB. In addition there was the important question of why the department
had failed to act on departmental compliance officers’ reports of licence
breaches and meter tampering. And there were questions about the role of the
former water minister Kevin Humphries in dealing with the large irrigators.

The
NSW Opposition has also taken action referring both the former Nationals water
minister Kevin Humphries (Member for Barwon) and a senior bureaucrat
(presumably Gavin Hanlon) to ICAC.

The
Federal Government reaction was initially almost dismissive. The Minister
for Water Resources, Nationals Leader Barnaby Joyce[2],
as well as attempting to downplay the water theft by comparing it to cattle
rustling, claimed that it was a matter for NSW and that there was no need for
Federal Government involvement. Billions of dollars of taxpayer funds have been
used to buy back water for environmental flows and instead of being used for
this purpose this water has gone to the big irrigators in the upper
Barwon-Darling. Presumably the taxpayer funds had come from the Federal
Government. This would surely make it a matter of very great interest to this
government which, seeing it is so concerned about budget repair, would surely
be appalled at the waste of billions of taxpayer dollars.

Joyce’s
totally inadequate initial response was compounded shortly afterwards with what
he said in a speech to irrigators in a hotel at Shepparton, a speech which was
recorded by one of those attending.

Joyce said,
"We have taken water, put it back into agriculture, so we could look after
you and make sure we don't have the greenies running the show basically sending
you out the back door, and that was a hard ask.”

"A
couple of nights ago on Four Corners, you know what that's all about? It's about
them trying to take more water off you, trying to create a calamity. A calamity
for which the solution is to take more water off you, shut more of your towns
down."

Even
a dinosaur like Barnaby Joyce should have been aware that anyone carrying a
smartphone has the capacity to secretly record what others are saying. In
the political sphere we have seen how damaging this can be in the cases of
Christopher Pyne and One Nation’s James Ashby. The Shepparton recording has
certainly damaged Joyce and has added volume to the calls for him to be sacked
from the Water portfolio. Unfortunately, this is unlikely to happen as
the Prime Minister has enough problems in his own party without alienating
Joyce and the Nationals.

By
Sunday 30th the scandal became a matter that the Federal Government
had to act upon despite Joyce’s earlier labelling it a state matter. The
Federal solution was for the Murray Darling Basin Authority to carry out an
independent basin-wide review into compliance with state-based regulations governing
water use. The Authority is to report by 15th December 2017.
The Government saw this review as complementing the other investigations of the
Four Corners allegations.

However,
this is a case of far too little too late. The MDB Authority is scarcely
a body able to conduct an independent review of what has obviously been
happening under its watch. Furthermore a cynic would see the reporting
date of 15th December, just before the Christmas holiday season, as
a typical government move to ensure that the review report would receive
minimal attention and be forgotten about over the holiday break.

The
Federal Opposition, like its NSW state counterpart, has also taken action on
the scandal. It requested that the Auditor-General expand his current
audit of the Federal Department of Agriculture and Water Resources. The
Auditor-General will now include how the federal department is monitoring the
performance of NSW under the National Partnership Agreement on Implementing
Water Reform in the MDB relevant to the protection and use of environmental
water.

Unsurprisingly,
the South Australian Government, which has long been concerned about the lack
of water reaching the end of the Murray-Darling system, was outraged by the
allegations. It is calling for a judicial inquiry, a much stronger
investigation than those arranged by NSW and the Federal Government. SA
senators from Labor, the Greens, the Nick Xenophon Party and the Conservatives
have joined their state government in calling for a judicial inquiry.

This
scandal has a long way to run yet. There are major questions to be
answered about the National Party – both state and federally - and its
relationship with the big irrigators and its apparent indifference to the needs
of other irrigators further down the system. There is also the question
of its influence on the workings of the NSW Department of
Agriculture. And just what role has it had in limiting the
effectiveness of – perhaps even of sabotaging - the Murray Darling Basin Plan?

For
both Federal and NSW state Liberal leaders there is the question about the
advisability of having resource management portfolios in the hands of Nationals
and of putting both Agriculture and Water in the same portfolio. Each of
these governments has a very poor environmental record. What has been
happening on the Barwon-Darling reinforces the view that keeping “in good” with
the Nationals is far more important for the Liberals than ensuring that
environmental policies are in the best long-term interests of the state and nation.

[1] Gavin Hanlon joined
the NSW Department of Primary Industries in December 2014. Prior to this
he had been Managing Director of Goulburn Murray Water since 2011.

[2] The water portfolio
was removed from the Environment Department and allocated to Joyce as a result
of the agreement with the Liberals in 2015 following Malcolm
Turnbull becoming Prime Minister.

No comments:

Everyone has the right to freedom of opinion and expression; this right includes freedom to hold opinions without interference and to seek, receive and impart information and ideas through any media and regardless of frontiers.
[Adopted and proclaimed by United Nations General Assembly resolution 217 A (III) of 10 December 1948]

NSW North Coast

Australian Bureau of Meteorology

Moggy Musings

Hi! My name is Boy. I'm a male bi-coloured tabby cat. Ever since I discovered that Malcolm Turnbull's dogs were allowed to blog, I have been pestering Clarencegirl to allow me a small space on North Coast Voices.

A religion & local government musing: On 11 October 2017Clarence Valley Councilhas theChurch of Jesus Christ Development Fund Incin Sutherland Local Court No. 6 for a small claims hearing. It would appear that there may be a little issue in rendering unto Caesar. On 19 September 2017 an ordained minister of a religion (which was named by the Royal Commission into Institutional Responses to Child Sexual Abuse in relation to 40 instances of historical child sexual abuse on the NSW North Coast) read the Opening Prayer at Council’s ordinary monthly meeting. Earlier in the year an ordained minister (from a church network alleged to have supported an overseas orphanage closed because of child abuse claims in 2013) read the Opening Prayer and an ordained minister (belonging to yet another church network accused of ignoring child sexual abuse in the US and racism in South Africa) read the Opening Prayer at yet another ordinary monthly meeting. Nice one councillors - you are covering yourselves with glory!

An investigative musing: Newcastle Herald, 12 August 2017: The state’s corruption watchdog has been asked to investigate the finances of the Awabakal Aboriginal Local Land Council, less than 12 months after the troubled organisation was placed into administration by the state government. The Newcastle Herald understands accounting firm PKF Lawler made the decision to refer the land council to the Independent Commission Against Corruption after discovering a number of irregularities during an audit of its financial statements.The results of the audit were recently presented to a meeting of Awabakal members. Administrator Terry Lawler did not respond when contacted by the Herald and a PKF Lawler spokesperson said it was unable to comment on the matter. Given the intricate web of company relationships that existed with at least one former board member it is not outside the realms of possibility that, if ICAC accepts this referral, then United Land Councils Limited (registered New Zealand) and United First Peoples Syndications Pty Ltd(registered Australia) might be interviewed. North Coast Voicesreaders will remember that on 15 August 2015 representatives of these two companied gave evidence before NSW Legislative Council General Purpose Standing Committee No. 6 INQUIRY INTO CROWN LAND. This evidence included advocating for a Yamba mega port.

A Nationals musing: Word around the traps is that NSW Nats MP for Clarence Chris Gulaptis has been talking up the notion of cruise ships visiting the Clarence River estuary. Fair dinkum! That man can be guaranteed to run with any bad idea put to him. I'm sure one or more cruise ships moored in the main navigation channel on a regular basis for one, two or three days is something other regular river users will really welcome. *pause for appreciation of irony* The draft of the smallest of the smaller criuse vessels is 3 metres and it would only stay safely afloat in that channel. Even the Yamba-Iluka ferry has been known to get momentarily stuck in silt/sand from time to time in Yamba Bay and even a very small cruise ship wouldn't be able to safely enter and exit Iluka Bay. You can bet your bottom dollar operators of cruise lines would soon be calling for dredging at the approach to the river mouth - and you know how well that goes down with the local residents.

A local councils musing: Which Northern Rivers council is on a low-key NSW Office of Local Government watch list courtesy of feet dragging by a past general manager?

A serial pest musing: I'm sure the Clarence Valley was thrilled to find that a well-known fantasist is active once again in the wee small hours of the morning treading a well-worn path of accusations involving police, local business owners and others.

An investigative musing: Which NSW North Coast council is batting to have the longest running code of conduct complaint investigation on record?

A which bank? musing: Despite a net profit last year of $9,227 million the Commonwealth Bank still insists on paying below Centrelink deeming rates interest on money held in Pensioner Security Accounts. One local wag says he’s waiting for the first bill from the bank charging him for the privilege of keeping his pension dollars at that bank.

A Daily Examiner musing: Just when you thought this newspaper could sink no lower under News Corp management, it continues to give column space to Andrew Bolt.

A thought to ponder musing: In case of bushfire or flood - do you have an emergency evacuation plan for the family pet?

An adoption musing: Every week on the NSW North Coast a number of cats and dogs find themselves without a home. If you want to do your bit and give one bundle of joy a new family, contact Happy Paws on 0419 404 766 or your local council pound.