Paul first appeared on the CBS game show back in 2000, where he lost his Showcase Showdown with an overbid of a mere $132. This week, the actor “broke onto the set” with James Corden, whose Late Late Show films just a few floors down.

After attempting to recreate the Price Is Right contestant experience, Corden and Paul were caught by Drew Carey, who agreed to preside over a showcase redo. Unfortunately for The Path actor, the odds still weren’t in his favor.