Which Celeb Was Dustin Hoffman’s Waiter in 1969?

Gusmano Cesaretti/HBO(NEW YORK) — Dustin Hoffman joined George Stephanopoulos on Good Morning America Wednesday to talk about Quartet, the new movie he directed, which hits theaters Friday.

Aside from sharing his thoughts on his new role behind the camera, Hoffman also told a funny, and rather shocking, story about his first encounter with Robert De Niro in 1969. And no, it wasn’t on a movie set.

“He says, ‘So you remember in 1969?’ I said, ‘Well, what do you mean, Bob? He says, ‘Well, there was some benefit dinner. Maybe [Eugene] McCarthy was running for president, and you were there.’ And I said, ‘Oh yeah, vaguely, a Second Avenue restaurant? Why are you telling me this?’ He says, ‘I was your waiter.’”

De Niro’s revelation clearly took Hoffman by surprise at the time, and got a good laugh from the GMA crew.

Hoffman said he asked De Niro if they actually met that night. De Niro’s reply was simple, said Hoffman. “‘Yeah,'” Hoffman recounted De Niro saying. “‘The first thing you said to me is ‘How is the flounder?’”

On Dec. 2, De Niro introduced Hoffman at the Kennedy Center Honors, which recognize lifetime contributions to American culture through the performing arts. Hoffman was one of the recipients.

Although the two men have known each other for years and are “very good friends,” said Hoffman, “when De Niro came out, I was wondering if he was doing it for one of the other honorees.”