In the following excerpt, Maskell evaluates Howards End for Forster's beliefs found in Forster's "What I Believe" and finds that Forster fails to embody his beliefs in the novel.

Mr Forster's place in the canon is an unusual one. He enjoys, securely, a reputation of the most insecure kindthat of a major figuredefinitely thatwho falls just shortbut clearly shortof true greatness. A reputation which might be expected to stimulate objections from all quarters stimulates them from virtually none. No one, apparently, wants to see him promoted into the ranks of the acknowledged masters and hardly anyone wants to see him pushed out of the canon altogether. He is the occasion of no very serious or very interesting debate When he is praised, he is praised extravagantly but harmlessly ... Mr Forster's peculiar reputation rests, it might be guessed, not so much on what he's...