An Open Letter to Mark Shapiro and Ross Atkins

Look, you both know it, I know it, and even the bandwagon fans on Facebook know it. This season had considerable promise and started well, but with the starting rotation in shambles and the bullpen already showing the signs of overuse and this season about to become as disappointing as grocery store sushi, it’s time.

Time to make plans to break up the American League’s oldest roster, a group you knew last year was getting past the point of being able to realistically compete for a post-season berth. But the higher-ups at Rogers wouldn’t let you take a wrecking ball to it, because they liked the sounds of the cash register ringing.

Even though you both have been on the job for only a couple of years, you’ve built an organization that is poised to become a leader in analytics, scouting, sport science, and minor league instruction. You quickly understood that the key to long-term competitiveness for this franchise lay in its ability to unearth diamonds in the rough in the form of amateur players both through the draft and IFA markets, and use your system to give them the polish they need.

Mark, you spoke in the off-season about developing waves of prospects to come in an compete for MLB jobs. The first of them is almost ready. The best prospect in baseball, Vladimir Guerrero Jr, is part of that group, which includes Danny Jansen, Ryan Borucki, and Anthony Alford. You certainly could make the argument that more development time is warranted for all four, but you could counter that by suggesting that if the roster is torn down to make room for them, that development could continue at the MLB level. We know all about the risk of failure that can come with accelerating players too quickly, but the Nationals decided to move top prospect Juan Soto (who is all of six months older than Vladdy) to AAA after (check that – he’s been promoted to the bigs) only 32 AA At Bats. Granted, Jr has some more defensive development to complete before he graduates, and top pitching prospects still give him a bit of trouble, but move him up to Buffalo already. If he succeeds there an and opening on the big league roster becomes available by, say, July 31st, bring him on up. Who knows where any of us will be in six years – and it’s hard to see you sticking around that long if you have to keep banging heads with the suits upstairs.

After the first wave has established itself in a year or so, the next wave, with talent like Bo Bichette (who’s struggling for the first time in his pro career this year, but that’s ok – better to learn to deal with it in AA), Sean Reid-Foley, and Cavan Biggio might be ready, and you could throw in Jordan Romano, too. Behind them, you’ve got a collection that includes Nate Pearson, Logan Warmoth, Yennsy Diaz, and Kevin Smith, and farther down the road, Eric Pardinho, Miguel Hiraldo, and this year’s top draft choice -hopefully, another arm – (and a possibly even better one next year) and IFAs. Players dealt to make room on the MLB roster should be exchanged for more prospect depth.

It’s time to put a bow on this season and write it off, rather than continuing to apply duct tape to your broken roster. The execs at Rogers are no doubt worried that time in baseball’s wilderness will plunge the team back into the bottom third of AL attendance figures, and that is a concern. It’s bad enough that they seem to keep putting off badly needed renos to the Rogers Centre, but they should give you both a broad brush to undertake the makeover of the 25-man roster. Yes, attendance will dip, but if/when Vlad is added to the 40 (part of a bigger set of roster decisions) and promoted, that should help stem the slide at the gates. Yes, this team spent almost two decades wandering through the baseball wilderness before 2015, but you guys are putting together an organization that is becoming one of the top ones in baseball in terms of development. Your time in the basement shouldn’t be long.

You have some decisions to make (although some of them are pretty obvious), but space needs to be made. It won’t be easy, but it’s time. And has they proved three years ago, the fans will come back.

7 thoughts on “An Open Letter to Mark Shapiro and Ross Atkins”

I get your argument, its what i want to see myself in many ways, but really, what is the point? You can call up whoever you want but this Jays team is not competing for a playoff spot no matter who they bring up or who the demote or release, the competition level is just way too high at this point in time. With that in mind, there is no reason to rush the guys down below, let them develop naturally in the minors as they should. The Nationals and other contenders have good reason to push their prospects as these additions, if they pan out like Devers did last season, can make the difference between post season or not. The Jays are just not in this category, way to many areas of need, particularly now that most, if not all, the starters are struggling. Their only hope was that their starting staff all stayed healthy and they all pitched at their peak potential and that is not happening with this group. Bring up Vladdy a month into the season next year like the Cubs did a few years ago to maximize Bryant’s service time, then the following season many of the others could follow suit. This year is about getting veterans as much playing time as they can, pray that some of them get hot soon and then trade as many of them as you can at the deadline and then use those that you didn’t trade, such as Morales, Pearce, etc, for the rest of the season as you have paid for them anyway. They aren’t blocking anyone as there really isn’t anyone that needs their spot that couldn’t benefit from AA or AAA anyway.

First off, you need an editor for your vlog. Honestly reading your write up, I can tell you’re another “AA fanboy”; which doesn’t bode well for your opinions on any matter. If you don’t like Shapiro and Atkins then watch another team.