Thursday, November 4, 2010

Alimony Must be Based on Sufficient Findings and Alimony Cannot Exceed Needs

Wife was awarded $800 per month in alimony. Husband appealed. He argued that the trial court had insufficient evidence to make findings as to the parties’ ability to earn and their needs. The Court of Appeals found that testimony alone is sufficient evidence for imputation of income, and that Husband’s enrollment in a Technical College did not preclude imputation of income. If a party already has basic job skills, he cannot rely on the schooling to avoid the imputation of income. However, the findings of the trial court did not support the level of income imputed to husband as required by U.C.A. 78B-12-203(7)(b) (2008). Without such findings, the trial court cannot impute income. Additionally, the trial court made no findings as to Husband’s ability to pay and therefore the alimony award was an abuse of discretion and reversed. The Court also found ability to earn cannot be based on monthly income alone, but must be based on the U.C.A. 78B-12-203(7)(b) factors, reversing the trial court’s finding that wife’s ability to earn directly correlates with her current income.

Lastly, simply because the parties combined needs exceed their combined incomes does not prove that the parties’ standard of living is not commensurate with the standard of living at the time of the marriage, it simply proves that the cost to sustain two households is greater than the cost to sustain one.

Disclaimer

:: By using this blog site you understand that this information is not provided in the course of an attorney-client relationship and is not intended to constitute legal advice. This blog site should not be used as a substitute for competent legal advice from a licensed attorney in your state.::

COPYRIGHT

Keep this Blawg Going. Click here to Donate

Search This Blog

Sign up to receive updates by email

If you would like to receive notice of new summaries by email, simply email utahfamilyblawg@gmail.com, and put “add me” in the subject line.I will send you the summaries before they are posted to the blawg and long before the advanced reports summaries are released