I have searched the forums and didn't find anything like this, so i want to get people's opinion on this, "Do you comment on manga on this site and when?"

As for me, i really like this feature so that i can tell everyone what i think about a particular manga that i'm reading or what i have read. As for when, i pretty much do this when i completed the manga and not when the manga is in progress, it's too irresponsible to comment when it's in progress because your comment can depend on if someone decides to read a manga or not, it's my opinion anyway .

I do, and the situation varies, I read the comments first and if there is a comment that pretty much tells everything I wanted to say I don't. Usually I do comment after reading just the first or first couple chapters if the manga left a strong impresion on me, or I consider it interesting enough. I don't comment on completed series, because there are a lot of comments already and I'm kind of lazy

I do sometimes, if I feel strongly enough about a manga *and* feel that I have something more significant than "me too" to add.

________________"[English] not only borrows words from other languages; it has on occasion chased other languages down dark alley-ways, clubbed them unconscious and rifled their pockets for new vocabulary."-James Nicoll, can.general, March 21, 1992

Aside from on Hentai and oneshots, I'll always leave a comment upon completion of a series, but never before that. I don't like stating my opinion until I'm sure of it. I don't even rate series until I'm at at least the third volume.

i do sometimes...but first i read comments on mangas tht i think are interesting and see wat others think bout it...and if its good ill read it or i might jus read it if i jus like it but its always good to hav second opinion i think. i do on series i like and hav read but not all of them cuz i get bored lol

Oh, definitely! Yeah most my comments are under yaoi genre but i try. I haven't had much time to catch up my completed list comments but my goal is to at least say a little something on all of them. In general it has really been helpful for me when others have commented on obscure manga that I see as potentials, really tips the scale for me on whether to waste my time or not.

I only comment on the manga I find horrible because I want to warn all the users who haven't read them to not waste their time with them. (Read my Rosario + Vampire comment whenever you're bored one day )

________________

Quote from Klapzi

The cool part is that I never get tired of being deceived

Quote from tactics

Just because someone's head was chopped off doesn't mean they're dead. That's just silly.

Yeah, I comment. It can help others, so I comment. It's also pleasing to show appreciation to a good manga. Or sometimes if it's horrible, to warn others from it.Some manga are just plain smut/no art/no story so I usually don't bother with those. I only rate them.

________________Hrodulf and Bjornolfr, you will not be forgotten.And if the world were black and white, you would be my rainbow in shades of grey.

I vote on the "maybe ..."Actually it doesn't depends on the manga, it more depends on my mood If I'm in the right mood and not busy, I'll definitely leave a comment whether the manga is good or bad..but lately I haven't commented on a manga *sniff* ah, it's been such a long time..and if the manga I really like and have people saying bad things about it, I'll definitely write a comment, never mind my mood