Both my brother and a friend we play with have a putting stance that causes them to step about three feet forward on their putts. I called them both on it today and both got real mad and stuff. My brother started taking a few steps back but was still stepping forward. The thing is they are both interested in tournaments and I would assume this is against the rules even if they were taking steps back. You have to throw from 30 centimeters behind your disc so they would be breaking two rules, right?

chronicatm(DGCR FORUMS) wrote:the only person that deserves to be hit with a disc is frank delicious imo

803.04 StanceA. When the disc is released, a player must:(1) Have at least one supporting point that is in contact with the playing surface on the lineof play and within 30 centimeters directly behind the marker disc (except as specified in803.04 E); and, (2) have no supporting point contact with the marker disc or any object closer to the holethan the rear edge of the marker disc; and, (3) have all of his or her supporting points in-bounds.

C. Any throw from within 10 meters or less, as measured from the rear of the marker discto the base of the hole, is considered a putt. A follow-through after a putt that causes thethrower to make any supporting point contact closer to the hole than the rear edge of themarker disc constitutes a falling putt and is considered a stance violation . The player must demonstrate fullcontrol of balance before advancing toward the hole.

There must be a supporting within 30 cm behind the marker when the disc is released. You must maintain balance behind your marker (I don't believe you have to be directly behind your marker).

As long as those two things are satisfied, you can do whatever else you want. If you're friend is planting at 29cm, releasing the disc, walking through, and maintaining balance while still being behind the marker, then it is a legal putt.

If you take a look at Climo's putt, or Rob McIntyre's (sp?), you can see that for most putts they start behind their lie and take a step to the 30-cm line as they release the putter. Is this what you are talking about?

We are not like those other golfers. We throw our clubs and keep our balls where they belong. -Ol' Bob

Also, keep in mind that walking in front of the marker is only a no-no if you're inside the 10m circle. You might know that already, but didn't see in your post where they were putting from, so figured I'd throw that out there.

some call me...tim? wrote:Also, keep in mind that walking in front of the marker is only a no-no if you're inside the 10m circle. You might know that already, but didn't see in your post where they were putting from, so figured I'd throw that out there.

And then only if you haven't demonstrated balance first. It's possible for someone to throw a putt, pick up their mini, and start running to the basket before it comes to rest so long as they've demonstrated balance behind the marker first. (However unlikely.)

Behind the 10m point, Tony Ellis does this pseudo-cheater putt where his back leg is behind the marker, his front leg is in front, and before he fires he lifts his front foot. It's goofy lookin', and it wouldn't help me, but it's legal.

chiggins wrote:Behind the 10m point, Tony Ellis does this pseudo-cheater putt where his back leg is behind the marker, his front leg is in front, and before he fires he lifts his front foot. It's goofy lookin', and it wouldn't help me, but it's legal.

Creative...but I'd call him a cheapazz for it.

Though...now that I think about it, he's robbing himself of some power on his putts doing that. In order to not break the rules, he has to place his front foot behind the mini when it comes down, and demonstrate balance there before he moves back past the mini...That backwards motion is taking energy off his putts.

SkaBob wrote:In order to not break the rules, he has to place his front foot behind the mini when it comes down, and demonstrate balance there before he moves back past the mini...

Nope, out past 10m, not inside. He ends up sort of falling forward and landing on the front foot. Like I said, it's not a shot that goes with my putting style, but it workks for him really well. (And it's no more cheating than a jump/walking putt.)

ChUcK wrote:If you take a look at Climo's putt, or Rob McIntyre's (sp?), you can see that for most putts they start behind their lie and take a step to the 30-cm line as they release the putter. Is this what you are talking about?

Yeah, assuming he starts taking a few steps back, this is legal? There is no limit to where you start, only finish?

chronicatm(DGCR FORUMS) wrote:the only person that deserves to be hit with a disc is frank delicious imo

Oh this isn't about me. I putt with my front foot stationary and lift my back. It's all perfectly legal. I hate seeing my brother make comments on my putting when I at least use a legal stance. Well that and the fact that he ''float'' putts.

chronicatm(DGCR FORUMS) wrote:the only person that deserves to be hit with a disc is frank delicious imo