There are a TON of negative reviews about their tents. If you do some googling, an awful lot of people have had a tent go bad in just a few years. Their website talks the talk, but their tents are lacking.

I've got a Montana Canvas tent. It's great. Over 20 years old and going strong. I'd consider Montana Canvas or Davis Tent the two premier tent makers. If I had to do it again I'd add a window or two. No windows in my 14x16 makes it pretty much unusable in summer months. But come deer season its perfect.