But this way the others won't learn. We really speak here not in order to mock people but to learn from them. If you see a mistake in my review you can name me here, everyone will be able to instantly check that review, have a voice and possibly take a lesson. This all isn't possible in PMs.

Btw I'm dealing with Egyptian Valley by Osvaldo, and I'm trying hard NOT to insult the builder - exceptionally difficult to handle in this case, but the review is still in beta stage and will yet change...

I received a very nice review from Manarch2 (about Scaramucce), I thank him for mentioning the final dedication, something I care about very much, but... I want to understand why 4 in gameplay.

"A nice and always appreciated addition to the Easter Calendar that has a nice Venetian atmosphere and a few good usages of objects, especially at the cat scene. The architecture is a bit simple, the texturing in the water not very clean (but quite decent elsewhere); the gameplay honestly doesn't offer much more than exploring the canals up and down, but the boat ride is always fun, there's a hint of a puzzle in the mansion and overall there's no feeling of tedium in the 25 minutes I spent here, maybe except of the need of having to cross the tight rope at least one time too often. The two secrets are nicely hidden and the final scene is a nice hommage to the builder's dad which thus ended emotionally. Recommended as a sweet little break"

Remember that this is a tribute to twenty years of TR2, created to celebrate the event.

However, as the discussion preceding your post shows, it is expected in such cases that the builder (you) contact the reviewer in question (manarch) via PM first, so that the two of you resolve the (perceived) problem in private before going public.

However, as the discussion preceding your post shows, it is expected in such cases that the builder (you) contact the reviewer in question (manarch) via PM first, so that the two of you resolve the (perceived) problem in private before going public.

Thank you. This is the first time that I discussed for a review, so I don't know no practice in these matters.
Tomorrow I will send a pm, then. Thank you

Hello everyone. Is it possible to contact Gorty? Because I wanted to inform about the English links of the cutscenes of my level on the download page were inserted. He in the review wrote that it did not understood anything because the dialogues are in Italian (my native language)... has no email and I do not find it among users. How do I contact?

not all know that they shall press the little white box beside options
to show subtitles
and it could also have being added to the pdf file

No, the subtitles are in the videos. I took weeks to create them with Movie Maker for users who do not speak Italian... Michael has entered the link of the playlist. I also wrote to activate the volumetric fx, but I do not think he did. And I put in the folder the right setting...

My thoughts exactly. I mean, being critical and showing that in reviews is one thing, but being plain nasty and destroying other people's work is another thing. Then again, I suppose us players can't do anything about it. It's up to Michael.

I assume we're not talking in the abstract here, but about a specific review. If I'm correct in my guess of which level is now under discussion, then in my case I suppose that ignorance is bliss. I know nothing about the finer (or the broader, for that matter) points of level construction, so the phrase "worst texturing I've ever seen" means nothing to me. As far as I'm concerned, if the texturing is pleasing to the eye, I'll reward it with a high score in my review without regard for whether my verdict is rationally based or not. Those of us who are more familiar with level construction are certainly entitled to voice that higher level of experience in their reviews, but in this case I plan to disregard the negative comments when I get around to downloading and playing the level.

I've not played the level in question either;but I wonder if the reviewer simply didn't properly 'get' the characteristically idiosyncratic and somewhat freeform style of the builder?
Knowing the builder,I'm sure he'll be able to take the review comments in good grace.