We’re not knocking PB&Js, but peanut butter’s versatility extends far beyond it’s ability to adhere to both white and wheat toast. From cookies to salad dressing, ice cream to swordfish, here are 10 sweet and savory recipes that make creative use of our favorite pantry staple. One tip before we dig in: Stock up on the creamy sort—it’s called on much more often in recipes than it’s crunchy counterpart.