E-cigarettes should be far safer than smoking

Tobacco is the world’s leading cause of preventable death, accounting for around 6 million deaths each year. That’s thanks to the cocktail of over 5,000 chemicals in cigarette smoke, of which at least 70 may cause cancer.

E-cigarettes, on the other hand, do not contain tobacco. Instead, they carry a nicotine-containing liquid which is heated into a vapour and breathed in. The nicotine satisfies the cravings associated with a smoking addiction, but doesn’t cause cancer.

The fact that e-cigarettes don’t produce tobacco smoke and the countless chemicals found within it has always suggested that these devices should be safer than smoking. But when they first came to the market, there wasn’t enough research to be sure of this. This is why scientists around the world have sought to understand what’s in e-cigarettes and what the impact of these products might be.

But, until now, nobody had looked at what everyday users are actually exposed to in the real-world.

So the study out today, led by Dr Lion Shahab, is the first to look at the effects of e-cigarettes in what they define as ‘long-term users’.

Just how safe are they?

The study included a group of e-cigarette users, who had been using them for an average of around 17 months, and measured the levels of nicotine and 26 potentially harmful chemicals in their body, by looking at samples of their urine and saliva.

The team compared the results to cigarette smokers, and people who both smoked and used e-cigarettes. They also looked at people who used nicotine replacement therapy (NRT), which is commonly used to help people stop smoking or as a long-term alternative.

“We looked at NRT users because we know these products are safe to use,” says Shahab. “We thought they would be a good comparison,” he adds, because long-term users get their nicotine hit from a smoke-free source, much like e-cigarette users.

Interestingly, the nicotine levels found in the samples from e-cigarette users were very similar to those who used NRT and to smokers. This suggests that people are able to satisfy their nicotine cravings through using either of these products.

The full benefit of using e-cigarettes is from completely stopping smoking

– Dr Lion Shahab, UCL

“Part of the reason why people use e-cigarettes is to stop smoking, and we have shown that they provide effective delivery of nicotine,” says Shahab.

But the key finding came when the team looked in the samples at the levels of potentially toxic chemicals. They found that there was a remarkable difference in the levels of these substances between the different groups. In fact one chemical, called NNAL (known to cause lung cancer), was 97% lower in e-cigarette users compared to smokers.

Not only did e-cigarette users have lower levels of these substances compared to smokers, but they were also found to have very similar levels to people using NRT – something that Shahab is quick to point out is known to be relatively safe.

“We have 3 decades of research into the safety of NRT, and we’ve not picked up any significant long-term health issues,” he says.

So if e-cigarettes have the same effect on the body as an established stop smoking treatment, then surely we can assume that these products are relatively ‘safe’ too? While nothing can ever be considered completely safe, we can compare it to the other things we experience in our day to day lives.

We still need to be cautious about e-cigarettes

Unfortunately, we’re not 100% convinced yet. There are a number of points left to uncover that this study hasn’t yet answered.

The first is that people who used e-cigarettes while still smoking didn’t reduce the levels of toxic chemicals they were exposed to. And a large number of e-cigarette users do still smoke.

“The full benefit of using e-cigarettes is from completely stopping smoking,” says Shahab. “Any health benefits come from dramatic reductions in these chemicals, and we’re not seeing this in people that use both e-cigarettes and combustible cigarettes.”

Dr Lion Shahab, a Cancer Research UK-funded scientists at UCL

And although this study found significantly lower levels of these substances in vapers than smokers, the chemicals are still there.

The study didn’t compare the levels of chemicals in people who don’t smoke or use e-cigarettes with those who do, so it’s not known what the differences are likely to be. If these chemicals are found to be at higher levels in people who use the devices there’s still a chance that some harm is being done.

According to Shahab the next step is to look for signs of damage in these different groups of people, instead of looking at levels of chemicals that cause harm. But it can take decades to see these differences.

We also know that different users use different devices and liquids. So it could be that some are safer or more harmful than others. And people also use the devices in different ways. So further work needs to be done to understand these differences, so that each vaper is using their device as safely as possible.

We intend on playing a key part in finding these answers. And that’s why we set up the UK E-Cigarette Research Forum, made up of the country’s top tobacco and e-cigarette researchers, to do exactly that.

What does this mean right now?

This study confirms that e-cigarettes are far safer than smoking. If you’re a smoker, the best thing you can do for your health is to stop. And the most effective way to do so is through free Stop Smoking Services.

But this doesn’t mean that e-cigarettes are entirely without harm. If you’re a non-smoker, it’s not advisable to start vaping. We can’t yet be certain of all the long-term effects across all devices and liquids, so it’s best not to pick up the habit.

So although it’s unlikely e-cigarettes will be shown to be completely harmless (nothing ever is), today’s results are a landmark moment in showing just how much safer they are than smoking.

More on this topic

Tags

Comments

This I agree, is all about the risk of Cancer in the case of studies, however there are studies that show that the flavoring could be responsible for serious lung problems.
Another point to raise is that a smoker puts down or out a cigarette when smoked usually, but those that use e – cigs seem to increase their usage and I have watched the non stop e-cig to mouth progress.
I am certain that most smoke these at least 3-4 times more often than they used to cigarettes,
Until all the research is in, I for one will not be trying them again, the vapour causes me to be short of breath and leaves me with an irritated throat.

Iam 66yr old female.been smoking tobacco since I was 16yr old.although not considered a heavy heavy smoker 30gm lasted me nearly 7days.(7th day was butt day).april 2017 l purchased my 30gm.as usual next day I purchased $100dollar e cigarette machine and low tar oil.cit a long story short I allowed myself 1tobacco cig a day and that 30gm lastrd 4week.I have not purchased tobacco since and smoke e permanately.everyone around me has tried e machine with no luck.I dont know how I did it but I did.neverwill I go back to nasty tobacco(plus I save 50.00 a week)I cracked it.and proud of myself.

I’m a Non smoker and my doctor told me that I suffer an allergic reaction to the smoke that comes off these devices my throat becomes sore the back of ,my nose stings and my tongue becomes number … that tells me they are not safe

this article focusing solely on cancer risk – for obvious reasons – but pays not attention to studies that are now 2 years old relating to other respiratory conditions linked to the chemicals in e-cigarettes – https://ehp.niehs.nih.gov/15-10185/ – it’s about over all health caused by these things not just the risk of cancer.

I have been smoking and e-cig vapor for 5 years now and I feel so much healthier. I used to smoke up to 30 cigarettes a day and had a chesty cough. Now my chest is dry and no longer have a cough. Don’t forget I save a lot of money, I don’t smoke my e-cig like a cigarette, I take the maybe up to 4 puffs every now and again. They are the best things to be invented.

Great article Carl and thank you.
Additionally, we should not ignore the fact that tobacco also contains radioactive materials. A by product of fertilization and tobacco yields Lead-210 and polonium-210 alpha and gamma radiation. The radioactive particles settle in smokers lungs, where they build up as long as the person smokes.
Source: epa.gov

Quick links

Follow us

Cancer Research UK is a registered charity in England and Wales (1089464), Scotland (SC041666) and the Isle of Man (1103). A company limited by guarantee. Registered company in England and Wales (4325234) and the Isle of Man (5713F). Registered address: Angel Building, 407 St John Street, London EC1V 4AD.