I am in love with this Benefit
BadGal waterproof eyeliner. I bought my first one around 2 years ago
and I am still using the same one! It has lasted me ages and I went
through a phase of using it every single day but since finding my
Inexpensive product I am picking at both of them to see which I prefer.
The benefit one comes with a little smudger at one end, which to be
honest I am not that keen on.

Pros* true black colour* long lasting* staying power is amazing* glides on smoothlyCons* goes blunt easilyAs you can see from my Pros/Cons, it
appears to be an amazing eyeliner which it is and I would definitely
recommend if you are looking for a higher end product.

Avon Supershock Gel EyeLiner in Black

I
came across this eyeliner and having a glance through my Avon
catalogue. To be honest, I'm not a fan of the Avon cosmetics as I often
feel some of their stuff is just cheap but I am definitely glad I
purchased this item. Gel eyeliner is apparently the new trend when
applying eyeliner as it has better staying power and a darker colour
which I do agree with. I find this is similar to the badgal due to the
texture, althought Avon supershock is a tiny bit darker which I prefer.

*
to be honest I have no cons at all for this, although I would not
recommend using this for daily use, as the staying power is that good it
will not move and it can look a bit strong - personally that is what I
like and its an amazing eyeliner for a night out as you can really rely
on it.

As you can see in the above picture, the Avon one is slightly darker in colour.