Maui vs Kauai: A Hawaii Guide From Someone Who’s Been to Both

Traveling to Hawaii has been my all-time favorite vacation destination. I have been to Oahu, Kauai, and Maui (twice), and plan to visit the Big Island this next year. One of the questions I get asked very most is “Which Island is better? Maui or Kauai?” I’m going to focus today’s post on Maui vs Kauai because although I love both islands very much, they are very different from each other. Before you dive into this article, read our main Hawaii Tips article where I share everything I wish I knew before planning my trip to Hawaii.

Our very first trip to Hawaii, we spent 3 days on Maui, and then 4 days on Kauai, which in my opinion is the very best way to do it! It’s not that much more to add an inter-island flight to your trip. I would only advise this if your trip is going to be more than 7 days long though. Otherwise you just won’t have enough time to see both islands like you should!

Maui vs Kauai: What’s the Same?

Oneloa Beach Pathway at sunset, Maui Hawaii

Maui vs Kauai is a difficult comparison, because you really can’t go wrong going to either island! I deeply love them both. Both have wonderful hiking opportunities and equal amounts of outdoor adventure, as well as unlimited ways to relax and rejuvenate. Both have good snorkeling, although Maui’s is better in my opinion due to calmer waters.

MY LATEST VIDEOS

Maui vs Kauai: What’s Different?

Na Pali Coast

Maui is more about fancy restaurants, has more beachfront accommodations and lovely scenery. Kauai is the only island of its kind and is lush and rural: you won’t find high-rise resorts here (I believe the law is nothing higher than a coconut tree). Here’s some more noticeable differences between Maui and Kauai:

Haleakala – Haleakala is the large dormant volcano taking up 40% of the island. You can drive, bike, or hike parts of the volcano, and it’s really popular for the sunrise at the top (although I recommend sunset for less of a crowd).

Road to Hana – Arguably one of the most beautiful, scenic drives in the world with waterfalls and beaches at every hairpin turn. Most of the amazing beauties that you find pinned on Pinterest, are sites from the Road to Hana, including white, black and red sand beaches, the bamboo forest, all kinds of waterfalls, and the famous rainbow eucalyptus trees.

Maui is more accessible: Maui has a lot more going on close together (especially if you are staying in Lahaina). Your main drives that will be longer are going to be Road to Hana or Haleakala. Everything else is pretty close by.

Better snorkeling and more beachfront properties. Maui is going to be more touristy, and as such you have a lot more options for beachfront properties and resorts.

Whales. If you are traveling during winter, Maui is going to be your choice for whale sightings. Whales have been spotted off of Kauai, but not nearly as easily as Maui due to more protected waters. In fact, many have spotted humpback whales from their hotel room (bring some binoculars).

Turtles! Although you can find turtles on both islands, they are pretty much a guarantee on Maui. There are a few spots that you can always found them, and I saw and swam with many turtles on Maui. Here’s a picture my husband took of one of our first turtle sightings under water:

Swimmable beaches. once again, because the water is more calm in Maui, you have many more options for swimmable beaches. You can find some swimmable beaches in kauai, but you will be driving more.

Relaxing boat tours. One of my all-time favorite memories of Hawaii, is taking a catamaran snorkeling trip in Maui. It’s the reason I had to go back a second time. This is the first time I swam with a turtle, and the entire experience was so relaxing and majestic. I still dream of that boat tour. We also did a boat tour in Kauai, but it was hard to relax as I felt I was going to be swallowed by the ocean. ROUGH seas on our Kauai boat tour and it was considered a “good day.”

cons: Maui isn’t quiet as lush and quiet as Kauai since there is more touristy appeal here.

Kauai: Adventurous and Rugged (Stay in the North Shore)

Pros

As with Maui, there are two main sights that set Kauai apart:

Napali Coast – The mammoth coastline is featured in countless movies (Like Jurassic Park). Although the coastline is majestic and beautiful, it’s hard to see unless you boat, kayak, or hike this coastline. Helicopter tours are also offered. We did a top-rated boat tour, and although the site was spectacular, I probably wouldn’t do it again due to how choppy the water was. We had people barfing off the side of the boat, and we went during the calmer season when it was calm enough to go in the caves (I can’t imagine doing this in winter).

Rivers to Kayak: Unlike other islands, Kauai has a few rivers that you can kayak! We almost booked a vacation rental that was walking distance to Hanalei river. It sounded so fun!

Quiet: Kauai is going to have less families and honeymooners, so if you want to go somewhere quiet with fewer people, Kauai is your island!

Monk Seals. The total population of Hawaiian monk seals is 1,100, so seeing one is a pretty big deal. The chance that you will see one while in Maui is extremely rare, but we saw TWO while in Kauai! In fact, our resort had a special protected spot where they like to rest. This picture below is a quiet beach we found near Hanalai Bay, and also where we saw a monk seal.

Cons: I would say Kauai’s biggest con is that the water isn’t as calm here, and it’s the reason I chose Maui over Kauai for our second visit. However, I have been longing to go back and will probably choose Kauai next time. You really can’t go wrong choosing either island. My preferred way to go is to visit them both in one trip.

I'm six-foot tall mother of three and I'm enjoying the view! I'm currently fighting a battle with Lyme disease and am determined to come out victorious. I enjoy warm summer rain, peanut butter everything, having dance parties with my husband and kids, natural remedies and healthy living. Most days I'm just looking for another excuse to avoid the piles of laundry.

Like this:

About Tina M

I'm six-foot tall mother of three and I'm enjoying the view! I'm currently fighting a battle with Lyme disease and am determined to come out victorious. I enjoy warm summer rain, peanut butter everything, having dance parties with my husband and kids, natural remedies and healthy living. Most days I'm just looking for another excuse to avoid the piles of laundry.

Comments

I prefer Kauai but I live here on the north shore! Anini is the beach with the calm water since it’s reef protected. I’ve watched humpbacks breaching frequently while sitting in my beach chair at Anini. It’s a great place to SUP and kayak. I’ve seen many, many turtles, some coming on shore to rest, manta rays, and all kinds of fish. It’s a 2 mile beach so it’s rarely crowded, especially the west end.

Hi Joy
We visited Kauai, Oahu, Maui and Big Island for at month in 2015. We are going back in 2019 and chose Kauai and Oahu to visit since we just love Kauai. We have kids of 14 and 18 and they also chose the two islands. The other islands are really nice and maybe we will go back sometime. We stayed at Poipu beach on Kauai south side and didn´t have time enough to go to the north og the island. But reading your reply will definitely bring ud to Anini the next time. Are there a speciel area where you have seen the turtles. Coming from Denmark almost on the other side of the planet, it is a speciel experience foro us. And my wife simply fell in love with turtles.

Visit Brennecke’s Beach from about 7:30-9:00pm and you will see several turtles swim to shore for the night. It is an awesome experience especially when people are respectful and keep their distance and do not shine their lights in their faces. Such a great treat.

We have been to Hawaii twice. The first time was 1 week (January 2015)……4 days to Oahu & 3 days to Kauai. We feel in LOVE with Kauai and decided that 1 week was not near enough time. So we went back 12 months later (January 2016) for 2 weeks. This time 4 days on Maui in Kihei, 3 days on the Big Island in Kona and the whole second week back on Kauai in Poipu. I left my heart in Kauai. We personally found it far more relaxing, more intimate becasue of it’s MUCH smaller size and extremely less commercialized. TONES to do, great beaches and in January when we have gone both times, AWESOME whale shows. We did the Captain Andy’s Sunset Cateraman dinner cruise both times. The first time lucky enough to get to the Napoli Coast and the second year, MUCH too rough so they went instead south coast around to the east coast. Equally as beautiful to see. We are boaters here at home, however we did both times take gravol “just in case”. Yes there was others sick, but we were very comfortable with our little “gravol insurance policy”. We LOVED it both times. Dolphins playing with us within a couple of feet of the boat. Whales breaching very close to us. Turtles, flying fish, and monk seals. An incredible meal on board too. The first time, We did a helicopter tour (doors off) over the whole Kauai island……..seeing the Napoli coast from air and sea were truly amazing! Hiking and driving through the Waimea Canyon was another amazing time. Nothing like sitting on the edge (literally) of the canyon and contemplating life. An experience and moment I will never forget. We rented a car both times and drove the island many times. We did the same on Maui, travelling the road to Hana, going to Lahaina, incredible beaches as well. It was all alright but like I said, my heart is in Kauai. Very honestly, my favorites in order from 1st to last….. Kauai 1st, then the Big Island, then Maui and the Oahu. All islands are very very different for many reasons. No matter where you go……..it’s Hawaii…….the greatest place imaginable!! ENJOY!! And we’ll see you again soon Kauai. <3