Battle Barbecue - Renegade Rosamund's Devil's Apple Sauce

"Oh, I shouldna think so, Ronnie." Jamie took a firm grip on Ronnie's arm, and smiled engagingly at Rosamund. "Ye mean to sell the meat, I suppose, Mrs. Lindsay? It's a poor merchant that would kill her customers, aye?"

"I ain't yet lost a one, Mr. Fraser," Rosamund agreed, turning back another sheet of burlap and leaning over to dribble sauce from a wooden ladle over a steaming haunch. "Ain't never had but good words about the taste, neither," she said, "though a-course that would be in Boston, where I come from."

Where folk have sense, her tone clearly implied.

The Fiery Cross (Chapter 13 - Beans and Barbecue)

I'm baaaack!!!! Did you miss me? Summer finally arrived to the Pacific Northwest, so I decided to take a week off and have a little fun in the sun.

My R&R meant an interruption to our little recreation of The Fiery Cross's Battle Barbecue. But I'm glad for the wee break. I'm feeling rested, refreshed and ready to conclude this epic BBQ tale with my version of Renegade Rosamund's tomato-based sauce!

While I held pretty true to the roots of Eastern North Carolina BBQ with Ronnie Sinclair's Traditional Vinegar Mop, I decided to go out on a bit of a limb with this one. After all, I've got a little Rosie in me -- all cooks/chefs do, really -- that's why they keep making Reality TV shows in kitchens all over the world.

Knives, stress and overwhelming heat lead to drama faster than you can say "Did I just see BJR?"

But I digress.

This recipe started with my intention to make some Lexington barbecue, from Western North Carolina, where they use tomatoes in varying proportions in their sauce...and then I reread the excerpt, where it says that Rosamund is from Boston.

So I figured, since Rosamund got around, so could my sauce.

See how easily I get off track?

I caught a savory whiff as the wind changed. So far as I could tell from smell alone, Rosamund's sauce seemed to include tomatoes, onions, red pepper, and enough sugar to leave a thick blackish crust on the meat and a tantalizing caramel aroma in the air.

The Fiery Cross (Chapter 13 - Beans and Barbecue)

Some of you may be shocked by the cola - it certainly isn't 18th C - but then again, neither is the ketchup in this uncooked sauce. Both up the sugar content, which leads to caramelization, which ends in a blackened crust.

The result is an easy pulled pork that is tangy, sweet and bold.

Just like Rosamund and her barbecue. Only better...'cause it doesn't take 2 days from start to finish.

My Englishman preferred Ronnie's Vinegar Mop, while I thought this one here was the best. Is it a case of gender stubborness? The only way to find out is to try both for yourselves...

Renegade Rosamund's Devil's Apple BBQ Sauce

A shoulder (butt) roast seasoned with a dry rub and mopped using a tomato-vinegar sauce with origins in western North Carolina and some added inspiration from Rosamund’s hometown of Boston. Traditionally served pulled on rolls with coleslaw.

Serves 4-6

Ingredients

Sweet Paprika - 2 Tble

Brown Sugar - 2 Tble

Kosher Salt - 2 tsp

Mustard Powder - 1 tsp

Onion Powder - 1½ tsp, divided

Cayenne - ½ tsp

Dried Thyme - ½ tsp

Ground Black Pepper - ½ tsp

Pork Butt (Shoulder) Roast - 3 to 4 lbs

Ketchup - 1 Cup

Coca Cola - 1 Cup

White Vinegar - ½ Cup

Brown Sugar - ¼ Cup

Kosher Salt - 2 tsp

Ground Black Pepper - 1 tsp

Cayenne - 1 tsp

Onion Powder - 1 tsp

Method

Combine the paprika, brown sugar, salt, mustard powder, 1/2 tsp onion powder, cayenne, thyme and pepper in a small bowl and stir to mix well. Blot the pork roast dry with paper towels. Use your hands to rub generous amount of the dry rub into the roast. Refrigerate, uncovered, for 12 to 24 hours.

Combine the sauce ingredients in a saucepan. Bring to a boil over medium-high, reduce the heat and simmer briskly until reduced to 2 cups, about 10 minutes.

Place the roast in your smoker/grill, set to between 180°F and 225°F. Cook with the wood/charcoal of your choice (I used hickory). Start mopping the surface with sauce at hour 3, and every half hour after that, until the internal temperature measures 190°F on an instant read thermometer inserted in the thickest part of the roast, about 5-7 hours.

Remove from the smoker and tent lightly with foil for 15 minutes. Pull the meat apart with 2 forks, and serve on rolls with coleslaw and additional sauce on the side.

Store leftovers in the fridge for up to 5 days.

Ith gu leòir! (Eat Plenty)

To keep food-borne illness away, pour a small amount of the sauce into a bowl from which you can mop the cooking meat. Replenish as needed, but never dip the brush you use on the meat into the main batch of sauce.

Next time I will remove the elastic netting from the roast. It’s not necessary, and it got in the way.

Theresa

renilyn

I do a similar sauce however beings that us folks that have EVER lived in TX know... you MUST use Dr. Pepper where cola is called for ;) Sounds awesome! Cant wait to try the rub.nn@mary - I have tried mine on chicken (whole chickens, half chickens, breasts, wings etc) and its tremendous! Give it a go, I don't think you'll be disappointed in the least hehe

Kathleen Smith

Looking forward to making this sauce for short ribs or slow cooker pork roast. :-) I live in an apartment, no grilling allowed. The boiled dressing link leads to a notice that it no longer exists. :( Coleslaw sounds delicious with this.