'Truth spoken without moderation reverses itself'
This blog is a source for intellectual exploration. It includes a list of alternative resources and a source of free books. The placement of an article does not imply that I agree with it, merely that I found it thought-provoking. There are also poems and book reviews. Texts written by me are labelled. Readers are free to re-post anything they like.

Saturday, February 18, 2017

Jodhpur University Goes on ‘Anti-National’ Witch-Hunt, Here’s the Backstory. By Nivedita Menon

In the light of Jodhpur University’s
February 16 decision to
suspend Rajshree Ranawat, an assistant professor in the English department,
for inviting Prof Nivedita Menon to deliver a lecture on nationalism on campus
earlier this month, The Wire is republishing an article Menon wrote about the
‘controversy’ earlier this month.

On the 3rd of
February, ABVP called a bandh in Jai Narain Vyas
University (JNVU), Jodhpur, forcibly stopping classes and demanding suspension
of the organizers of a conference and police action against them, as well as
against myself. Police complaints have now been lodged, and perhaps FIRs, we
hear. The charge? The
conference, and my lecture in particular, was anti-national. Not one of these
ABVP students attended the event, nor is there yet a video recording available
to my knowledge, largely because the ABVP also gathered in intimidatingly large
numbers outside the shop that had conducted the recording, and the owner shut
up the shop and fled. The entire drama and some sensationalist and outright
false stories in the local Hindi press, is based entirely on the testimony of
one person, NK Chaturvedi, retired professor from the History department at
JNVU, who attended just one session, mine.

At the end of my
lecture, he informed me that he had seen me on YouTube and had come to see for
himself how anti-national I am. But more on that exchange later. The point is
that the blatantly false media coverage and the frenzy whipped up in JNVU is
based entirely on the testimony of this one person who on his own admission,
had come to measure me against the standards of his own deshbhakti.
He did not attend a single other session.

On February 1 and 2,
2017, The English Department organized a conference titled “History Reconstrued
through Literature: Nation, Identity, Culture”. Among the speakers were the
Chairperson of ICHR, Sudarshan Rao, Sandip Dikshit of the Congress and scholar
Himanshu Roy who replaced the original invitee, Seshadri Chari of the RSS when
he declined due to ill health. Apart from these there were several academics
and practitioners from universities and institutions in Delhi, Gujarat and
Rajasthan; among them, Ameena Kazi Ansari and Rizwan Kaiser from Jamia Milia
Delhi, Avdhesh Kumar Singh from IGNOU, Ashutosh Mohan from GGS University,
Balaji Raghunathan from Central University of Gujarat, Gauhar Raza, scientist
and film-maker, Aishwarya Bhati, Supreme Court advocate.

Evidently, the key
organizer, Rajshree Ranawat, faculty member in the department, had ensured that
the widest possible range of political and scholarly views were represented.
There were also presentations by young research scholars and younger faculty on
their areas of research, ranging from George Orwell in the era of Trump, to
Palestinian poet Mahmud Darwesh and the writing of Shashi Deshpande. A scholarly,
stimulating academic event, to a room of about a hundred students, male and
female, undergraduate and research scholars, an event marked by debate and
sometimes sharp disagreements among panelists, and challenging questions from
students to speakers. It was a wildly successful conference, and on any other
planet but the RSS griha, the Conference Director Rajshree
Ranawat and her colleague Vinu George would have been congratulated and
felicitated by their university, the local press would have reported the
conference in glowing terms.

Now here are the two
“news” stories that were published yesterday, the only reportage on the event.