It seems that part of the "art of the deal" is to place people in a position where not making a deal bears unacceptable consequences. As one of us wrote, the Borg (foreign policy establishment) and Lindsey Graham must be tearing their hair out and rending their garments.

Comments

You can follow this conversation by subscribing to the comment feed for this post.

This is the first time I have seen Putin say that all Syrian territory must be restored.

"I can only agree with you that all the forces deployed illegitimately inside any sovereign state – in this case Syria – must leave. This is true for everyone. If Syria’s new legitimate government chooses to say that they have no more need for Russia’s military presence, this will be just as true for Russia. Right now, we are discussing this openly with all our partners, including Iran and Turkey. We spoke about it with our American partners many times. And I will be as open with you as I have been with my counterparts: Syria must be free from other states’ military presence. And the territorial integrity of the Syrian Arab Republic must be completely restored."

Will an asymmetry ensue in which SAA troops are bombed by NATO state Turkey with impunity and Turkish troops cannot be bombed by either SAA or Russia?

Will, in fact, the Turkish air force install a no-fly zone over Northern Syria? I'm positive that's what is wanted in Washington and Ankara, but will it come to pass?

If Russia challenges Turkey in the air, is that an act of war against NATO? Graham and Cheney would love that.

This all certainly contains the elements necessary to take impeachment off the front page... except that I do not believe most Americans give a damn about Syria or Turkey or, in fact, anywhere in the world outside our borders. If $600 billion a year can't solve the world's problems, they ain't going to be solved.

Turkey lacks the strength to impose a NFZ in Northen Syria against the Russians. A NFZ, like a blockade, must be enforced to be effective. This is not a board game. An Article 5 action is not applicable outside the sovereign territory of the NATO member.

Why is Retd. Marine Corp General John Allen being so critical of POTUS leaving Syria? IMHO I would rather see POTUS save GI lives by pulling all U.S. troops out of Syria, than squander them, which would happen if we remained in Syria like what Allen wants. Allen is now part of the Israeli connected Brookings Institute as its president.

If the Borg is this upset and continues to drag into public view the very real, and the imagined, atrocities being committed by Turkey, that is going to give Trump the perfect opportunity to suggest we expel Turkey from NATO. We shouldn't be allies of a country that violates the Geneva Convention.

It's a good thing the SAA and RuAF stopped their advance into southern Idlib because now their best troops are well rested, re-equipped and ready to exploit the opportunities offered by the political front in Russian Deep Battle practice.
On the other hand Erdogan could be in on this and was offered the chance to get rid of a problem (more an opportunity really) and kick the takfiris across the border to be killed by the SAA and RuAF alongside the ISIS escapees.

I am hopeful. An agreement to let SAA in by the Kurds to stabilize the front with Turkey and America standing down is the only way to get the thousand American troops and contractors out of Syria safely. Literally the USA does not have any allies left there. It also is the only way to halt an ISIS resurgence. It will be worth it to see Lindsey Graham and the neo-cons' dreams of endless wars smashed. But I am very much afraid the troop withdrawal will feed into the Impeachment frenzy. Too many rice bowls smashed. The end of the Iraq occupation is next.

The Turkish economy is being propped up by Russia and China. They can squeeze Eroguan's nuts any time they like. They are both adamant that Syria stay whole.

I suspect Russia will still let Turkey create the buffer zone but will tell then to stay on the right side of the line. Putin is currently trying to de-escalate now that he has some thing more to work with.

Well I guess there are a few ways to look at what just happened. Brett McGurk sums up one major school of thought well in one of his twittery lamentations; "..it’s shameful to leave partners to their fate and the mercies of hostile actors with no thought, plan or process in place". This school would have us believe that a clueless Trump was 'rolled' by Erdogan into an impulsive act with no care for what followed. In this reading the return of the prodigal Kurds under the protective wing of Damascus is a sad but inevitable consequence.

But the fact is that it is this reconciliation (and the coming return of SAG control over NE Syria) that forces US troops out, helping to make good on a campaign promise. Without it the Borg would doubtless apply huge pressure on Trump to keep them there indefinitely. An alternative thesis then presents itself; that this is in fact the result of plenty of thought, plan and process. If so, the art of this deal was artful indeed - both diabolically clever and bold. The work of Trump alone, or was a ghost writer involved?

The deal as I understood it was that Assad agreed to deploy to Manbij, Ayn al-Arab (AKA Kobane), and Qamishli. There is no Turkish cross border ground in Kobane and Qamishli, only cross border artillery and airstrikes.

I believe that elements of the SAA and some Russians are already in Manbij, and so far the only threat there is TFSA intermittent shelling and boasting by the Erdogan's Syrian Turkmen Jihadis that they will enter Manbij. Maybe a diversion?

Turkish ground forces attack is about 50km SE of Kobane at Tel Abyad, and stretches from there to about 100km WSW of Qamishli at Ras al-Ayn. That is where the civilians are being killed by Erdogan's jihadi SNA, many of which are former ISIS and Nusra Front. The only other ground fighting going on seems to be a so far very minor incursion at Diwar about 90km east of Qamishli near the Turkish city of Silopi.

So the question is when will the SAA confront Erdogan's proxy army at Tel Abyad and Ras al-Ayn. Or has a deal been made with Erdogan to let his liver-eaters have some fun there for awhile so he can resettle three million refugees on land belonging to Arabs, Kurds, Assyrians, & Armenians who had stayed in Syria to fight AQ & ISIS?

which didn't stop NATO member countries and wannabes from joining in the festivities in Afghanistan using the 9/11 attack on a member as their pretext. In this case however I am sure Turkey is on its own; no other NATO member will want to be involved. Optics too bad.

The SAA have already taken over the whole Al-Taqba area including the dam and airfield. As an indication of how welcome the SAA are it seems that most of the soldiers are being transported in buses. This is the tweet.

Danny Makki
‏ @Dannymakkisyria
2h2 hours ago

These are the main points in the agreement between the #SDF and the Syrian government.

1/ The abolishment of the #SDF (Syrian Democratic Forces), with all the current Kurdish forces and military groups joining the 5th Corps (Assault Legion) under Russian control
3:12 AM - 14 Oct 2019

2/ A solid guarantee of full Kurdish rights in the new Syrian constitution with autonomy which will be agreed upon by Kurdish leadership & Syrian state.

4/ #Manbej & #Kobani were agreed upon for #SAA to enter quickly, whilst #Hasakeh has seen a wide scale deployment of Syrian troops, this will continue in #Qamishly and other joint areas

5/ With Syrian forces now on the border area with #Turkey it's clear that this starts a new phase in the 8-year-long war where some sort of endgame is now taking shape - all border areas and administrational centres will be taken over by the Syrian government

6/ Within one month Kurdish leadership with start to take up some official roles within the current Syrian government to ease the transition period of N. #Syria until an new constitution/government is formed in the future

7/ #Tabqa in #Raqqa was also on the agreement, Syrian forces entered the city and took control of the military airbase earlier today

8/ #Russia had brokered a similar deal a few days ago, yet it was rejected by #Damascus who wanted more concessions from the #SDF.

9/ As per-agreement Syrian forces entered Ein Issa in N. #Raqqa today

10/ The agreement between #SDF and Syrian gov is yet to be fully completed, the finer details will be fleshed out over the next four days.

11/ For now all #ISIS prisoners remain under the control of the #Kurds

12/ The agreement thus far is effectively a military one, based on self-defense and mutual interest with a number of set aims. The governance/land delegation/isis prisoners part will follow later

The reports I read said the Turkish artillery bracketed some American troops after Kurdish troops fired on Turkish positions from positions close to the American troops. This is sop for the Kurds, lets you and him fight.

The deals were always Trump's; the after the fact books had ghost writers because they were less valuable per unit of Trump's time than the next deal.
I don't think that anything has changed now that he is President of a country.

Elaine, Rudaw is an Iraqi-Kurdistan network, specifically the Barzani's KRG which is known to have a bit of bad blood with they YPG. For better coverage of Syrian Kurdish perspective see Kurdistan24.net or ANF News (although the Turks claim ANF is a PKK mouthpiece)