Julia struggles to balance learning magic with maintaining her previous life. Pearl investigates the incident at Brakebills and Quentin, Alice, Penny, and Kady face disciplinary action for their role in the Beast's attack, but Eliza, who is called in as specialist, lets them go on probation. Julia meets Marina when she has to pass a test to join the Hedge Witches. Kady is secretly working for Marina.Alice and Quentin find out that her brother, Charlie,The Magicians Season 1 DVD was consumed by magic and turned into a niffin five years previously. When they find him, he acts maliciously and they bind him. Eliot searches for the book that Kady stole for Marina,The Magicians Season 1 which leads Quentin and him to the hedge witches, where Quentin confronts Julia. Penny, after being incorrectly assigned a psychic discipline, discovers he is a "traveller," and could have the ability to travel between worlds.