Where do you draw the line on this, at what point would dying be a better option? Tell you what if we met and you spoke to me you may change your mind at what point would you would want to do this!
So many people live with problems that others feel would invoke a suicide descision, its not right, life is precious and its not right, I feel it gives manner to the folks that beleive that we live in a brave new world or failing that logans run!

OK, this is tricky and I guess we are going to see more posts like this after tonights film and Terry sure isn't going to answer them as he is highly unlikely to post here even if he reads what has been written.

This is a difficult subject and I can see both sides, I'm expecting to die of cancer before what I would like to think is my natural lifeterm. My family is part of the human genome project because of our unusual cancer history where each generation all fall to a particular cancer but it is a different one in each generation. My fathers generation have all had brain tumors as they hit their 50's, just two of them, including my father I'm glad to say, are still alive. The generation below me have all (and I mean ALL) had kidney cancer as young children and whilst so far they are all alive the eldest is 18 and she has now been diagnosed that her remaining kidney is showing signs of the cancer.

I don't know what I would do if/when I find out what my generation will hit. I'm the eldest so expect to be the one that finds out. What I will however defend to the very last is the right of somebody to make their own choice.

Well new members are new members.... if one in ten stays then thats ONE new member for the forum huh?

Mad: What a sad post. Not just for what you must feel is like a Sword Of Damocles for yourself.... but for the other members of your family. I am so sorry to hear that.

Chin up mate. It may never happen. My brothers daughter has been living all her life with a terminal illness. She wasn't supposed to live til she was past her teens... and as meds get better she gets a longer term. As my brother says, "We are all dying! We are dead when we are dead!" and her illness isn't discussed in their family past the immediate health concerns.

None of us know for absolute certain what is in our future short or long term.... so you better wear clean underwear... JUST IN CASE!

The Collective Brain: The synoptic serendipity that comes when interesting thoughts from interesting and interested people get together. And the whole is always more than the sum of its parts.

I'm going to be a paragon of virtue and refrain from commenting at all, unless some religious loony starts spouting off.

For the record (I've mentioned this once before - I believe), my parents were both very religious and my mum died of cancer when I was 21, and when I was 26, my father had a breakdown, said everything he ever believed in was bollux, then killed himself as an assisted suicide with the aid of a train.

This probably explains why I am like I am.

Look on the bright side Mad, as Del says, you aten't dead yet.

"Disliking Carrot would be like kicking a puppy.""You kicked a puppy," Lobsang said accusingly.

Some interesting posts. Good points Mad. Its a battlefield of a debate to get into and i agree with Tony that its as good as banging a head against a brick wall to debate with new posters throwing in one comment. But still a topic worth talking about.
Personally i agree with Mad and pooh amongst others that the right to choose is important.
And I'm sorry for the situation Mad. Not good at all.

'There is no future for e-books, because they are not books. E-books smell like burned fuel.'Ray Bradbury (RIP)

Terry you may (or may not) remember me as a voice from our childhood in Forty Green - And you may not get to see this - but I watched your programme with interest. My wife died six years ago after battling terminal cancer for two years. She would not have opted for an easier way out but even if she had the choice that fee of £10000 I heard quoted would have beyond us and many more in the lower income bracket.

Congratulations for gettine the debate opened up on TV - I'm on your side by the way.

(I know you've been Knighted and already had an OBE but I thought I ought to tell you that I've got an MBE - which isn't bad from the kids that played in Roundhead Wood all those years ago. We've got the set between us.)

Hi to all the new guys and deep empathy for people's takes on this, even if they're anti-choice for themselves - just don't expect other people to be effected by that in the same way that Terry won't be effected by what you'd say to him on the subject.

I think it was very clear in the programme last night (I actually forgot it was on and so I've only just watched it on iPlayer ) that Terry hasn't actually made his mind up on whether he will do this himself - but he wants to have the unequivocal right to make that choice for himself in time. I'm going to comment fully in the thread we've had running in advance of this programme, but to all the new guys, whether you stay here or not, and whether or not you think Terry's a hero or a wimp for wanting this right to die do you really think it's right for rational, responsible people like Andrew and Peter to be forced to go to another country and die on a noisy industrial estate in a glorified portakabin (albeit a very nicely fitted out one with very kind 'escorts') just so there's little risk of their loved ones being prosecuted for helping them into death?

(((((hugs to MAD and to pooh)))))Life should be lived well and make us strong enough to die, however we leave it, because that is something we ultimately have very little choice in, except, perhaps, for the time.

"Some men see things as they are and ask why. Others dream things that never were and ask why not.” George Bernard Shaw