Maybe it's just hype ? .. but I also remember hearing about the founder of Brooklyn Pie Co comming back to Austin.\r
If so , this is great news for serious pizza foodies.\r
I know someone who ran into him in LA .and mentioned the same thing. Everyone keep their fingers crossed , because you havn't tasted real pie until youv'e had it from Mike , mark or something like that .

2

by pie master at Citysearch
September 02, 20105The Original Brooklyn Pie Co.

News Flash !

★★★★★

Maybe it's just hype ? .. but I also remember hearing about the founder of Brooklyn Pie Co comming back to Austin.\r
If so , this is great news for serious pizza foodies.\r
I know someone who ran into him in LA .and mentioned the same thing. Everyone keep their fingers crossed , because you havn't tasted real pie until youv'e had it from Mike , mark or something like that .

My daughter and I truly enjoy going to The Original Brooklyn Pie Co. They have delicious choices, great big slices, and my daughter loves to watch as the chefs toss the dough and arrange the toppings right in front of you!

My daughter and I truly enjoy going to The Original Brooklyn Pie Co. They have delicious choices, great big slices, and my daughter loves to watch as the chefs toss the dough and arrange the toppings right in front of you!

Was this review helpful to you?

by johnsledge at CitysearchAug 14.

This is the best pizza in Austin, the lunch slice is huge and cheap. You have to try this place! Order a large pizza and you will eat it for a week!!!

2

by johnsledge at Citysearch
October 16, 20085The Original Brooklyn Pie Co.

The best pizza in Austin!!!

★★★★★

This is the best pizza in Austin, the lunch slice is huge and cheap. You have to try this place! Order a large pizza and you will eat it for a week!!!

I'm from New Haven, CT. Even the f!@#ing Krauser's, a quick stop type store in New Haven, has better pizza than anywhere in Austin. The Brooklyn Pie Co. on the other hand makes proper pizza with thin but substantial crust the way only us from the east cost seems to know is right. I was especially delighted that they put real good sausage and roasted peppers on my pie instead of microwave breakfast sausage and thin uncooked peppers like everywhere else in Austin has so far. Can't speak to the quality of their delivery service, finding the place was a little hard, I'm not used to this business of access roads, but the people were nice and the price was fair for a great pizza.

2

by BillyMcDermot at Citysearch
September 02, 20085The Original Brooklyn Pie Co.

Only pizza in Texas

★★★★★

I'm from New Haven, CT. Even the f!@#ing Krauser's, a quick stop type store in New Haven, has better pizza than anywhere in Austin. The Brooklyn Pie Co. on the other hand makes proper pizza with thin but substantial crust the way only us from the east cost seems to know is right. I was especially delighted that they put real good sausage and roasted peppers on my pie instead of microwave breakfast sausage and thin uncooked peppers like everywhere else in Austin has so far. Can't speak to the quality of their delivery service, finding the place was a little hard, I'm not used to this business of access roads, but the people were nice and the price was fair for a great pizza.

These guys can make anything you ever craved when it comes to pizza and it tastes wonderful! \r
They have a variety of toppings like no place else I have ever seen. Their gourmet topping selection is unbeliveable!\r
Not in the mood for red sauce? They have white pizzas as well as a great pesto sauce. \r
I have been a customer since they opened and have always found the staff to be curtious and accomidating. They make the time to double check my order before I walk out the door, as a single mom with 2 kids I can tell you there is nothing more annoying than picking up food, getting home and then realizing that the restraunt frogot something. Conversation is kept at a good level for all customers so you feel welcome, yet you are not waiting on some long drawn out conversation to finish between the counter person and the customers infront of you.\r
If you want a great place to just eat and relax with your friends their patio seating is perfect.\r
I definately suggest you go in and try a whole pie or stop in for lunch for a slice of pizza that is so large you could save a bit for a snack later if you wanted to! The only issue you may have here is that everything sounds and looks so good you may not be able to decide what you want!!! Don't fret though, they are great at giving you suggestions!!!!!

2

by pinkdaisycmp at Citysearch
September 01, 20085The Original Brooklyn Pie Co.

Your own personal cravings satisfied!!!

★★★★★

These guys can make anything you ever craved when it comes to pizza and it tastes wonderful! \r
They have a variety of toppings like no place else I have ever seen. Their gourmet topping selection is unbeliveable!\r
Not in the mood for red sauce? They have white pizzas as well as a great pesto sauce. \r
I have been a customer since they opened and have always found the staff to be curtious and accomidating. They make the time to double check my order before I walk out the door, as a single mom with 2 kids I can tell you there is nothing more annoying than picking up food, getting home and then realizing that the restraunt frogot something. Conversation is kept at a good level for all customers so you feel welcome, yet you are not waiting on some long drawn out conversation to finish between the counter person and the customers infront of you.\r
If you want a great place to just eat and relax with your friends their patio seating is perfect.\r
I definately suggest you go in and try a whole pie or stop in for lunch for a slice of pizza that is so large you could save a bit for a snack later if you wanted to! The only issue you may have here is that everything sounds and looks so good you may not be able to decide what you want!!! Don't fret though, they are great at giving you suggestions!!!!!

Pros: Loads of toppings to choose from, they even offer alternative sauces

Very good pizza. Would recommend that anyone try it. But is different compared to the chains. Was just in NYC about 2 weeks ago...very similar to the pizza stands and similar to Grimaldi's crust. Would go again..might not have it delivered because of the past reviews. Only problem is that the building is small..they have 2 tables and window bar seats (about 6) inside and a few picnic tables outside.

2

by jonnilm at Citysearch
June 08, 20085The Original Brooklyn Pie Co.

Yummy!

★★★★★

Very good pizza. Would recommend that anyone try it. But is different compared to the chains. Was just in NYC about 2 weeks ago...very similar to the pizza stands and similar to Grimaldi's crust. Would go again..might not have it delivered because of the past reviews. Only problem is that the building is small..they have 2 tables and window bar seats (about 6) inside and a few picnic tables outside.

After we moved here from the East Coast we were able to find a couple of so-called ""pizza"" places, but we could not find any place that served real NY ""Pies""...until now! OMG, this place is amazing!! mouth-watering, delicious, and the biggest New York Slices you can get your hands on!!! If you drop by for lunch, sit back and get ready for a treat...and I dare you to order 2 slices!\r
\r
They are opening a new location at Spicewood Springs and Mesa, next to Mirabelle which will be much closer to my home and more seating...I can't wait! See you all there :-)

2

by lingaling at Citysearch
January 30, 20085The Original Brooklyn Pie Co.

BEST PIZZA! A real New York experience...brings you back to the East Coast!

★★★★★

After we moved here from the East Coast we were able to find a couple of so-called ""pizza"" places, but we could not find any place that served real NY ""Pies""...until now! OMG, this place is amazing!! mouth-watering, delicious, and the biggest New York Slices you can get your hands on!!! If you drop by for lunch, sit back and get ready for a treat...and I dare you to order 2 slices!\r
\r
They are opening a new location at Spicewood Springs and Mesa, next to Mirabelle which will be much closer to my home and more seating...I can't wait! See you all there :-)

I have bought (picked up) pizza from here (Round Rock location) a couple of times now. Love the crust! But the rest of the pizza was great also. Very generous with the ingredients and tasted very fresh. I like that they offer a white pizza. I was told they don't deliver so I don't have a comment on delivery or times. Would recommend you give it a try. I think it's better than any pizza chain around the area.

2

by texasmedic2004 at Citysearch
July 24, 20074The Original Brooklyn Pie Co.

Great pizza

★★★★☆

I have bought (picked up) pizza from here (Round Rock location) a couple of times now. Love the crust! But the rest of the pizza was great also. Very generous with the ingredients and tasted very fresh. I like that they offer a white pizza. I was told they don't deliver so I don't have a comment on delivery or times. Would recommend you give it a try. I think it's better than any pizza chain around the area.

The pizza is really nummy, but 5 out of 6 times we've called they've been short delivery staff, or they don't deliver after 8PM on a Friday, or it's the wrong phase of the moon or something. Seriously, it's no longer worth the effort. We only live a couple of miles away, but the delivery times when they DID say they could deliver were up to 4 hours. For a $20 pizza, you'd think they could get it out :( If they're going to offer delivery, they need to staff up and make it possible.

0

by andrameada at Citysearch
July 14, 20071The Original Brooklyn Pie Co.

Good when you can get it.

★☆☆☆☆

The pizza is really nummy, but 5 out of 6 times we've called they've been short delivery staff, or they don't deliver after 8PM on a Friday, or it's the wrong phase of the moon or something. Seriously, it's no longer worth the effort. We only live a couple of miles away, but the delivery times when they DID say they could deliver were up to 4 hours. For a $20 pizza, you'd think they could get it out :( If they're going to offer delivery, they need to staff up and make it possible.

This has got to be the best pizza in central TX. Just like the name, their pizza tastes like it's straight from Brookyln. This is true New York style pizza. They have a great menu and great atmosphere. The location is convenient since they are in the La Frontera shopping center which is a great place to shop.

2

by jsimpson23 at Citysearch
June 25, 20075The Original Brooklyn Pie Co.

BEST PIZZA IN CENTRAL TEXAS.

★★★★★

This has got to be the best pizza in central TX. Just like the name, their pizza tastes like it's straight from Brookyln. This is true New York style pizza. They have a great menu and great atmosphere. The location is convenient since they are in the La Frontera shopping center which is a great place to shop.

This was a huge disappointment. Its Fathers Day and my dad wanted to try this place, so we called for delivery and they told us it would be 45 minutes for delivery, then 60 minutes later we call back to find out where the pizza is and they tell us that they don't deliver that far. Thats just bad customer service, I will never be eatting from this place.

0

by pincushionprince at Citysearch
June 17, 20071The Original Brooklyn Pie Co.

Terrible Service

★☆☆☆☆

This was a huge disappointment. Its Fathers Day and my dad wanted to try this place, so we called for delivery and they told us it would be 45 minutes for delivery, then 60 minutes later we call back to find out where the pizza is and they tell us that they don't deliver that far. Thats just bad customer service, I will never be eatting from this place.

Disregard the previous comment. Thank god I gave these guys another chance the cheese is back and\r
the pizza is very good. If you live in N. Austin and you think your eating real pizza at one the many chains\r
available think again.Brooklyn is back in N. Austin!!!!!!!

2

by natx at Citysearch
April 16, 20075The Original Brooklyn Pie Co.

Very good pizza as good as Home Slice

★★★★★

Disregard the previous comment. Thank god I gave these guys another chance the cheese is back and\r
the pizza is very good. If you live in N. Austin and you think your eating real pizza at one the many chains\r
available think again.Brooklyn is back in N. Austin!!!!!!!

I love even thinking about their pizza - whole wheat crusts that aren't terrible (Mangia), real, fresh ingredients, like fresh mozzarella, feta, green olives, pesto sauce, delicious marinara sauce, fresh garlic, marinated tomatoes, and sausage - not your typical, run-of-the-mill, bought-from-sam's club ingredients. They have tons of specialty pizzas that are all wonderful, or you can create your own. Plus, if you go in and order by the slice, it's $5 for a slice the size of your head, but only if you have a huge head! They'll also bake the slice however you want it. Their salads are wonderful, and it's BYOB, if you go in. They're always nice and friendly and accomodating. And when you ask for extra sauce, they actually do it. It kicks Mangia and Lamppost's butts. I have to go get a slice now...

1

by katrina85 at Citysearch
February 06, 20073The Original Brooklyn Pie Co.

BEST PIZZA EVER!

★★★☆☆

I love even thinking about their pizza - whole wheat crusts that aren't terrible (Mangia), real, fresh ingredients, like fresh mozzarella, feta, green olives, pesto sauce, delicious marinara sauce, fresh garlic, marinated tomatoes, and sausage - not your typical, run-of-the-mill, bought-from-sam's club ingredients. They have tons of specialty pizzas that are all wonderful, or you can create your own. Plus, if you go in and order by the slice, it's $5 for a slice the size of your head, but only if you have a huge head! They'll also bake the slice however you want it. Their salads are wonderful, and it's BYOB, if you go in. They're always nice and friendly and accomodating. And when you ask for extra sauce, they actually do it. It kicks Mangia and Lamppost's butts. I have to go get a slice now...

People at work are always asking me... ""what is the name of the pizza that we have delivered"".\r
BROOKLYN PIE... Yummy to the Tummy. Best pizza I have ever had and I am picky.... Great variety as well. LOVE LOVE LOVE

2

by momadisco at Citysearch
January 30, 20075The Original Brooklyn Pie Co.

MY MOUTH WATERS at the thought of Brooklyn Pie

★★★★★

People at work are always asking me... ""what is the name of the pizza that we have delivered"".\r
BROOKLYN PIE... Yummy to the Tummy. Best pizza I have ever had and I am picky.... Great variety as well. LOVE LOVE LOVE

The sauces and cheeses used at this place are nothing short of fantastic, and the crust is the right blend of chewy and crisp. While I don't have any authentic Brooklyn pizza experiences to reference this against, this beats the hell out of any of the large chains. Great stuff, and friendly people, don't let the small size of the shop fool you, it's a hidden treasure!

2

by hummingbird7 at Citysearch
December 06, 20065The Original Brooklyn Pie Co.

Delicious!

★★★★★

The sauces and cheeses used at this place are nothing short of fantastic, and the crust is the right blend of chewy and crisp. While I don't have any authentic Brooklyn pizza experiences to reference this against, this beats the hell out of any of the large chains. Great stuff, and friendly people, don't let the small size of the shop fool you, it's a hidden treasure!

Pros: Quality of ingredients, and overall taste, especially the sauce.

I have lived in Austin for almost 2 years and had struggled to find good pizza until I found Brooklyn Pie. They had the best crust and the best cheese until about a month ago. They have changed the cheese and it now resembles the cheese at CiCi's. I know this sounds harsh but the owner should not change the cheese to save money.

1

by shannon_shsu at Citysearch
November 19, 20062The Original Brooklyn Pie Co.

Was the Best Pizza Until They Changed The Cheese

★★☆☆☆

I have lived in Austin for almost 2 years and had struggled to find good pizza until I found Brooklyn Pie. They had the best crust and the best cheese until about a month ago. They have changed the cheese and it now resembles the cheese at CiCi's. I know this sounds harsh but the owner should not change the cheese to save money.