My fiancé and I picked this out last April and after he proposed on Christmas I'm still as happy as I was in the store when my eyes first saw it. The salesman knew it was the one because my eyes wouldn't stop looking at it in my finger! I actually did try the 1carat set on but with such a small finger, (I'm a size 5) it looked way too big and this one is just perfect! I'm definitely not disappointed with his purchase, in fact I couldn't be happier!