No, the emoluments clause does not apply to the Trump organization.

Even if Donald Trump still owns it, in part or in whole, the emoluments clause does not apply to it. I quote the emoluments clause of the
constitution.

“No Title of Nobility shall be granted by the United States: And no Person holding any Office of Profit or Trust under them, shall, without the
Consent of the Congress, accept of any present, Emolument, Office, or Title, of any kind whatever, from any King, Prince, or foreign State.”

First, it has to be a direct transfer from a foreign state to the president himself.

Second, even if a foreign corporation controlled by a foreign state in terms of shares does business with the Trump organization, this does not
violate because the foreign corporation does not represent the foreign state. A case in point, in 2009 when General Motors was controlled by the US
government which owned 40% of GM's shares, GM did not represent the US government. GM was a corporation separate from the US government and did not
represent the US government.

First, it has to be a direct transfer from a foreign state to the president himself.

It doesn't say that. I think that's for a judge to decide.

Second, even if a foreign corporation controlled by a foreign state in terms of shares does business with the Trump organization, this does not
violate because the foreign corporation does not represent the foreign state.

Correct, foreign Corporation are not governments. But, plenty of government officials use Trump's hotels and golf courses. Governments approve his
companies plans and permits, and some of them pay rent to his businesses.

A foreign government official may or may not represent the foreign state. Nigel Farage is a member of the British government, but when he uses a room
in a Trump hotel and pays the fees, he is not paying as a representative of the British state.

A Chinese bank owned by the Chinese government rents a premise in the Trump Tower. But that bank does not represent the Chinese state.

The clause prevents the president from being influence by a foreign state. He has to know about such a gift from a foreign state to be influenced.

Donald Trump will be in the White House and surrounded by people all the time. Even if a foreign diplomat goes to his hotel and pays a fee that far
exceeds what every other customer pays for that room as a gift, Donald Trump will never know about it unless the media reports it. If the president
does not know about a gift from a foreign state, then he cannot be influenced by the foreign state.

Emolument comes from a Latin word and means gain or advantage. Let's say the price for staying at a Trump hotel costs 1000 dollars, and a foreign
diplomat comes and stays and pays 10000 dollars. That's a 9000 dollars emolument. If Donald Trump does not know about it, then he cannot be influenced
by it. If the media picks it up, then Donald Trump knows about it, then he subtracts 1000 dollars from 10000 dollars and donates the 9000 dollars
emolument to the Treasury. So either way, no problem.

The media will surely pick it up and tell him. If the foreign diplomat pays MORE than the stated price which is the price paid by everyone else, then
the media will report that to the president and the president can take the amount paid by the foreign diplomat and subtract the stated price and
donate the resulting emolument to the Treasury. That's not a problem.

The stated price at a Trump hotel is the fair price, because that's the price everyone else pays. Any amount paid more than that is a gain or
emolument. It's easy. The hotel knows how much a foreign diplomat paid. If the stated price is 1000 bucks and the foreign diplomat paid 10000 dollars.
Then that's a gain or emolument of 9000 dollars. That 9000 dollars goes into the Treasury so it does not influence the president.

Well, we'll just have to wait and see how the legal term work out in this case.

The moment Donald Trump became the 45th President, some legal experts say he triggered a violation of the foreign emoluments clause in the
Constitution, flouted the plain terms of the lease for his Washington hotel, and opened himself up to a dizzying array of ethical questions on
financial conflicts of interests. www.cnn.com...

The constitution does not forbid the president from owning a family business. Let's say I cut your lawn. I might charge you 40 bucks which is roughly
the fair price. If I charge you 4000 bucks for it, would you take my service? No. 4000 bucks for cutting your lawn would give me a gain or emolument
of 4000 - 40 = 3960 bucks. That's what emolument means. Emolument means gain. It means something above the fair price.

This content community relies on user-generated content from our member contributors. The opinions of our members are not those of site ownership who maintains strict editorial agnosticism and simply provides a collaborative venue for free expression.