Poor Miss Finch, by Wilkie Collins

Chapter the Twenty-Ninth

Parliamentary Summary

OH, the welcome interruption! After the agitation that we had suffered, we all stood equally in need
of some such relief as this. It was absolutely a luxury to fall back again into the common-place daily routine of life.
I asked to whom the letter was addressed? Nugent answered, “The letter is addressed to me; and the writer is Mr.
Finch.”

Having read the letter, he turned to Lucilla.

“I sent a message to your father, asking him to join us here,” he said. “Mr. Finch writes back to say that his
duties keep him at home, and to suggest that the rectory is the fitter place for the discussion of family matters. Have
you any objection to return to the house? And do you mind going on first with Madame Pratolungo?”

Lucilla’s quick suspicion was instantly aroused.

“Why not with Oscar?” she asked.

“Your father’s note suggests to me,” replied Nugent, “that he is a little hurt at the short notice I gave him of our
discussion here. I thought — if you and Madame Pratolungo went on first — that you might make our peace with the
rector, and assure him that we meant no disrespect, before Oscar and I appeared. Don’t you think yourself you would
make it easier for us, if you did that?”

Having contrived in this dexterous way to separate Oscar and Lucilla, and to gain time for composing and fortifying
his brother before they met again, Nugent opened the door for us to go out. Lucilla and I left the twins together, in
the modest little room which had witnessed a scene alike memorable to all of us for its interest at the time, and for
the results which were to come of it in the future.

Half an hour later, we were all assembled at the rectory.

Our adjourned debate — excepting one small suggestion emanating from myself — was a debate which led to nothing. It
may be truly described as resolving itself into the delivery of an Oration by Mr. Finch. Subject, the assertion of Mr.
Finch’s dignity.

On this occasion (having matters of more importance on hand) I take the liberty of cutting the reverend gentleman’s
speech by the pattern of the reverend gentleman’s stature. Short in figure, the rector shall be here, for the first
time in his life, short in language too.

Reverend Finch rose, and said — he objected to everything. To receiving a message on a card instead of a proper
note. To being expected to present himself at Browndown at a moment’s notice. To being the last person informed
(instead of the first) of Mr. Nugent Dubourg’s exaggerated and absurd view of the case of his afflicted child. To the
German surgeon, as being certainly a foreigner and a stranger, and possibly a quack. To the slur implied on British
Surgery by bringing the foreigner to Dimchurch. To the expense involved in the same proceeding. Finally to the whole
scope and object of Mr. Nugent Dubourg’s proposal, which had for its origin rebellion against the decrees of an
all-wise Providence, and for its result the disturbance of his daughter’s mind —“under My influence, sir, a mind in a
state of Christian resignation: under Your influence, a mind in a state of infidel revolt.” With those concluding
remarks, the reverend gentleman sat down — and paused for a reply.

A remarkable result followed, which might be profitably permitted to take place in some other Parliaments. Nobody
replied.

Mr. Nugent Dubourg rose — no! sat — and said, he declined to take any part in the proceedings. He was quite ready to
wait, until the end justified the means which he proposed to employ. For the rest, his conscience was at ease; and he
was entirely at Miss Finch’s service.

Mr. Oscar Dubourg, sitting hidden from notice behind his brother, followed his brother’s example. The decision in
the matter under discussion rested with Miss Finch alone. He had no opinion of his own to offer on it.

Miss Finch herself, appealed to next:— Had but one reply to give. With all possible respect for her father, she
ventured to think that neither he nor any one, possessing the sense of vision, could quite enter into her feelings as
the circumstances then were. If there really was any chance of her recovering her sight, the least she could do would
be to give that chance a fair trial. She entreated Mr. Nugent Dubourg not to lose one unnecessary moment in bringing
the German surgeon to Dimchurch.

Mrs. Finch, called upon next. Spoke after some little delay, caused by the loss of her pocket-handkerchief. Would
not presume to differ in opinion with her husband, whom she had never yet known to be otherwise than perfectly right
about everything. But, if the German surgeon did come, and if Mr. Finch saw no objection to it, she would much
like to consult him (gratis, if possible) on the subject of “baby’s eyes.” Mrs. Finch was proceeding to explain that
there was happily nothing the matter, that she could see, with the infant’s eyes at that particular moment, and that
she merely wished to take a skilled medical opinion, in the event of something happening on some future occasion — when
she was called to order by Mr. Finch. The reverend gentleman, at the same time, appealed to Madame Pratolungo to close
the debate by giving frank expression to her own opinion.

Madame Pratolungo, speaking in conclusion, remarked:—

That the question of consulting the German surgeon appeared (after what had fallen from Miss Finch) to be a question
which had passed beyond the range of any expression of feeling on the part of other persons. That she proposed,
accordingly, to look, beyond the consultation, at the results which might follow it. That, contemplating these possible
results, she held very strong views of her own, and would proceed to give frank expression to them as follows. That in
her opinion, the proposed investigation of the chances which might exist of restoring Miss Finch’s sight, involved
consequences far too serious to be trusted to the decision of any one man, no matter how skillful or how famous he
might be. That, in pursuance of this view, she begged to suggest (1) the association of an eminent English oculist with
the eminent German oculist; (2) an examination of Miss Finch’s case by both the professional gentlemen, consulting on
it together; and (3) a full statement of the opinions at which they might respectively arrive, to be laid before the
meeting now assembled, and to become the subject of a renewed discussion before any decisive measures were taken.

Lastly, that this proposal be now submitted, in the form of a resolution, and forthwith (if necessary) put to the
vote.

Resolution carried by a majority of two. Debate adjourned to a day to be hereafter decided on.

By the first train the next morning, Nugent Dubourg started for London.

At luncheon, the same day, a telegram arrived, reporting his proceedings in the following terms:—

“I have seen my friend. He is at our service. He is also quite willing to consult with any English oculist whom we
may choose. I am just off to find the man. Expect a second telegram later in the day.”

The second telegram reached us in the evening, and ran thus:—

“Everything is settled. The German oculist and the English oculist leave London with me, by the twelve-forty train
to-morrow afternoon.”

After reading this telegram to Lucilla, I sent it to Oscar at Browndown. Judge for yourself how he slept, and how we
slept, that night!