Missing since: 15 Apr 2004Notes left: 11052Last seen at: In the anals of forum history

It would depend on how people, in general, feel about that person's overall behavior.

Besides, goofy and serious are not really opposed to each other in a good/bad way and would not reflect in such a system.

In my experience, it takes some spectacularly bad behavior to be rated negative overall because it requires a lot of people to rate a person negatively (and, negative rep in that system was worth fewer points than positive).