I'm not sure it's a selection issue, whatever player they pick they don't seem able to do the job. We've had one after another top order batsmen and they've been given a reasonable stab at performing when it matters but none seem able to do it.
So I don't think I'd point the finger at the selectors, they can only pick the players that are available, unfortunately there's not many about.

Mind you I wouldn't worry too much about the WI test matches do vary wildly from hammering one side to loosing badly the next, seems to be the way of modern test match cricket.

TMS Pundits seem to be throwing up the idea of Hales and even Roy as possible candidates for the Ashes.

Not opening I hasten to add, but coming in down the order as replacements for Westley, who they have written off, and Malan, who might get another test if he scores some in the 2nd innings of this one.

Thinking seems to be the selectors have got it wrong again and it's too late now for somebody new to be thrown in down under.

Although Hales and Roy wouldn't be perfect they at least have some International experience and wouldn't be intimidated.

I shall certainly attend Monday if there is still a reasonable amount of cricket to be played. I always want England to win but it is hard not to want the West Indies to do well and wouldn't mind witnessing them achieve an historic win, should they manage it.

Paul Farbrace giving a very honest interview on Sky now - what a good man he seems to be. 'Lack of concentration and maybe taking the eye off the ball' in this Test. Bowlers not getting ball in right place consistently.
Adamant that people have to adapt their games to Test cricket but need to 'find the right time to make adjustments'.