Before modern civilisation came it was impossible for humans to eat fruit year round. I bet there wasn't any fruit around by the time winter came. So exactly how important is fruit deemed to be in a primal diet? Can you eat too much fruit? (is, say, 4 pieces of fruit too much sugar intake?)

Thanks!

11-18-2012, 04:42 AM

Damiana

Arguably, you don't need any fruit. Your intake should be dependent upon your goals, if you are trying to keep your carbs down, eat less fruit, for instance. You can get your vitamins and minerals and antioxidants from meats and vegetables just as well.

11-18-2012, 06:17 AM

Knifegill

It's true. Have some spinach/kale/dandelion, some oysters, some liver and a few eggs, nuts and berries and a sweet potato (or not!) with a little bacon/heart/fish/beef/fowl and that hits most of your micronutrient ratios for the day.

I, for one, just tried adding fruit back to my eating and got bloated, gassy, and *runny*. Not worth it, for me.

11-18-2012, 08:09 AM

AlanC

I tend to have just one fruit per day (or a handful of berries) usually in the morning with yogurt.

If nothing else it's peace of mind :)

AC

11-18-2012, 08:16 AM

GreenGranted

So, if I understand correctly: fruit is not needed, but it certainly does have a lot vitamins / anti-oxidants that vegetables also have. So it can substitute part of your vegetable intake?

11-18-2012, 08:22 AM

Neckhammer

[QUOTE=GreenGranted;1008962]So, if I understand correctly: fruit is not needed, but it certainly does have a lot vitamins / anti-oxidants that vegetables also have. So it can substitute part of your vegetable intake?[/QUOTE]

It's not necessary, but it is Primal. 4 pieces a day is about a 120g carb load (give or take). For an average sized human with a healthy metabolism that should not present any problems. For someone with liver disease or metabolic syndrome....may not be optimal.

11-18-2012, 08:31 AM

Lynna

I like fruit and I don't see anything wrong with eating it. It adds variety and I mostly eat what's in season. Berries in spring and summer, peaches in summer, apples and pears in fall and winter. Occasional oranges and clementines in fall and early winter. I generally only eat one serving/piece a day, but not everyday. The only fruit I eat year round is bananas when I have a hankering.

11-18-2012, 08:48 AM

Gilleh

Today I ate an orange, 2 avocados, 3 apples (threw those with some meat on the pen) and a pomegranate (spat the seeds which don't agree with my belly). no adverse effects so far. Ate them with lots of meat to slow the digestion so I won't have a sugar rush.
So far so good.
I do notice acne if I eat more than one banana or binge on potatoes, I wonder if that means I don't react well to starch overload.

11-18-2012, 11:49 AM

tarek

If humans did, in fact, originate from the tropics (where vegetation, including fruit, is available year-round), then this argument does not hold ground. It's a matter of gauging your body's response to fruit. Personally, I can eat 10+ servings of fruit a day and feel fine. If you become bloated and gassy as Knifegill did, you might want to limit it.

11-18-2012, 11:58 AM

Neckhammer

[QUOTE=tarek;1009211]I can eat 10+ servings of fruit a day and feel fine. If you become bloated and gassy as Knifegill did, you might want to limit it.[/QUOTE]

Do you eat a lot of smoothies? Or are some of your entire meals simply made of only fruit?