Posted by Jtpsops on 11/29/2011 2:17:00 PM (view original):I guess we should also take into account that 98% of Newton's INTs are good throws that are tipped or missed by his WRs. Dalton's are probably all lame ducks.

don't need to, because there's enough support for him in spite of that.

sarcastically exaggerating commentary from me in the past doesn't do anything to change the facts that i just clearly presented. sure you can arrive at a different conclusion than i did, but probably not in a logically coherent way.

Passer rating is sorta like OPS- it gets you in the ballpark but really is quite arbitrary and there are much more accurate super stats to cram a passer's entire performance into one stat. That's why I use ANY/A, it does a body good.

That was sort of my point. Most rational people are going to have Brees, Brady, Rodgers as top 3 and have Gabbert, Painter and Bradford near the bottom(maybe Ponder and Grossman replace one here or there) as "effective QB". Dalton, Tebow, Newton, Sanchez, Vick and the like all fit somewhere in the middle. And below Rapey, Manning, Ryan, Stafford.

But stats can prove anything. Saying ANY/A is "TEH BESTEST" is retarded. It's just the one you like.