In this game the panelists answers are the only real evidence we have (so far) to use. IMO that leaves me, Troy Loney, and Crankshaft as the 3 most probable reds based on that information alone. We each gave the least probable answers as panelists therefore reducing the possible points fellow contestants earn.

I'm not red and between TL and Crank, TL gave the least probably answer as panelist (John Glenn for "what the canadians left on the moon).