“We wanted to give our fans a chance to expand their love of our cookie dough flavors and offer both classic and entirely new combinations,” said flavor guru Craig Koskiniemi. “In trials, our fans clamored for the new Cookie Dough Core flavors.”

According to Delish, Ben and Jerry’s are the originators of Chocolate Chip Cookie Dough ice cream. In the late 1980s, the ice cream company followed a fan’s suggestion to add raw cookie dough to their ice cream, and in 1991, the flavor hit store shelves nationwide.