CONGRESS OF THE UNITED STATES CONGRESSIONAL BUDGET OFFICE

Transcription

1 CONGRESS OF THE UNITED STATES CONGRESSIONAL BUDGET OFFICE A CBO PAPER MAY 2005 The Effects of Reserve Call- Ups on Civilian Employers Royalty-free/Corbis

2

3 A CBO PAPER The Effects of Reserve Call-Ups on Civilian Employers May 2005 The Congress of the United States O Congressional Budget Office

4 Note Unless otherwise specified, all years are fiscal years.

5 Preface The ability of reservists to contribute to national defense depends in part on the support of their civilian employers. The current trend toward longer and more frequent reserve deployments, however, raises questions about the ability of civilian employers, particularly small businesses, to absorb the costs they experience when their reservist employees are called up. This Congressional Budget Office (CBO) paper, which was requested by the Chair of the Senate Committee on Small Business and Entrepreneurship, examines the implications of reserve call-ups for civilian employers and considers measures that might alleviate problems that businesses face. In keeping with CBO s mandate to provide objective analysis, the paper makes no recommendations. The report was prepared by Heidi L. W. Golding of CBO s National Security Division under the supervision of J. Michael Gilmore and Matthew S. Goldberg. David Brauer, Arlene Holen, Carla Tighe Murray, Jennifer Smith, Ralph Smith, Jo Ann Vines, and Tom Woodward provided helpful comments on a draft of the analysis, as did external reviewer Glenn Gotz. (The assistance of external reviewers implies no responsibility for the final product, which rests solely with CBO.) Leah Mazade edited the paper, and Janey Cohen proofread it. Maureen Costantino prepared the report for publication and designed the cover. Lenny Skutnik printed the initial copies, and Annette Kalicki and Simone Thomas prepared the electronic version for CBO s Web site (www.cbo.gov). May 2005 Douglas Holtz-Eakin Director

8 vi THE EFFECTS OF RESERVE CALL-UPS ON CIVILIAN EMPLOYERS Figures 1. Organization of the Military Reserves 4 2. Selected Reservists by State, Selected Reservists as a Proportion of a State s Population 7 4. Civilian Employers of Selected Reservists, Civilian Occupations of Selected Reservists, Annual Active-Duty Days per Ready Reserve Member 10 Boxes 1. Selected Legal Authorities for Mobilizing the Reserves 5 2. The Continuum of Service State Initiatives 21

9 The Effects of Reserve Call-Ups on Civilian Employers Summary and Introduction The military reserves provide trained service members and units that are available for active military duty during peacetime and war. 1 Over the past decade, the Department of Defense (DoD) has dramatically increased its reliance on the reserve forces, particularly since the terrorist attacks of September 11, The reserves are integral to current operations of service members deployed in November 2004 in Iraq and Afghanistan, about 33 percent were reservists and DoD foresees continued reliance on them. (Throughout this paper, reserves refers to the individual services National Guard and reserve components: the Air Force Reserve, the Air National Guard, the Army Reserve, the Army National Guard, the Coast Guard Reserve, the Marine Corps Reserve, and the Navy Reserve.) Yet many reservists, when they joined the military, probably did not anticipate the increased frequency and duration of the activations that have occurred during the past several years and may be finding those mobilizations more disruptive than they might have expected. 2 To alleviate difficulties with call-ups, the Congress has enacted legislation to provide civil and employment protections and financial relief. The Uniformed Services Employment and Reemployment Rights Act of 1994 (USERRA), the primary legislation governing service members employment rights, guarantees the right of reservists to be reemployed by their civilian employer after 1. See 10 U.S.C , added by Pub. L , Div. A, Title XVI, Subtitle C, 1661(a)(1), 108 Stat. 2970, and most recently amended by the Ronald W. Reagan National Defense Authorization Act for Fiscal Year 2005, Pub. L , 118 Stat Although in some contexts the terms mobilization, activation, and call-up may have different meanings, in this report they are used interchangeably. serving on active duty, prohibits employers from discriminating against individuals in any aspect of employment because of their service in the reserves, and mandates some continuation of benefits to reservists who have been activated. 3 By ensuring that people who are interested in military service can retain their jobs and participate in the reserve forces without fear of reprisal by their civilian employers, those provisions may also aid DoD in its recruiting and retention efforts. The increased pace of reservist activations has focused attention on how call-ups affect the civilian employers of reservists, including reservists who are self-employed. Yet there is little information about the type and magnitude of the disruption that firms experience when their reservist employees or reservist owners are activated. As a result, the impact of call-ups on businesses has not been systematically examined. This Congressional Budget Office (CBO) report examines the combined effects of reservists activations and federal job protections on civilian employers. It also addresses the question of financial losses among selfemployed reservists, a group that some people maintain deserve special assistance because they may have experienced particularly negative effects from the recent rise in activations. 4 In its analysis, CBO used survey informa- 3. Codified at 38 U.S.C (2000), as most recently amended by the Veterans Benefits Improvement Act of 2004, Pub. L , , 118 Stat The protections of USERRA do not apply to self-employed reservists or reservist business owners, terms that are used synonymously in this paper to refer to both incorporated and unincorporated businesses owned by reservists. 4. At many points in the discussion, the experience of reservist business owners is combined with that of other employers. At other times, the unique issues confronting self-employed reservists are treated separately.

10 2 THE EFFECTS OF RESERVE CALL-UPS ON CIVILIAN EMPLOYERS tion collected by the Departments of Defense and Labor and by other organizations; it also interviewed reservists, manpower experts, business and reserve associations, and others. Although such data are limited and any conclusions drawn from them cannot be generalized to all employers, they provide insight into the problems that some employers are confronting. CBO s Findings CBO s analysis revealed that most employers are unaffected by the activation of reservists. Only about 6 percent of business establishments employ reservists, and fewer than half a percent of self-employed people are in the reserves. Among firms with reservist employees and owners, substantial variation is seen in their ability to adjust to a reservist s call-up. Activations create vacancies that firms would not otherwise have had. Some businesses may absorb the loss of personnel at little cost, but others may experience slowdowns in production, lost sales, or additional expenses as they attempt to compensate for a reservist s absence. A smaller number yet may find that they are unable to operate for lengthy periods or at all without their reservist and may experience financial losses or insolvency. Such problems are likely to be more severe for: B Small businesses that lose essential (key) employees; B Businesses that require workers with highly specialized skills; and B Self-employed reservists. Small businesses (generally those with fewer than 100 employees) employ about 18 percent of all reservists who hold civilian jobs; businesses with fewer than 500 employees and self-employed reservists employ about 35 percent. But there are no precise data on the number of reservists who are key employees or who have highly specialized skills. On the basis of survey information about reservists civilian occupations, CBO estimates that out of the 860,000 reservists in the Selected Reserves (the primary source of reserve personnel), between 8,000 and 30,000 of them probably hold key positions in small businesses. In addition, about 55,000 reservists are selfemployed. Considering that snapshot of reservists employment, CBO expects that as many as 30,000 small businesses (0.6 percent of all such firms) and 55,000 selfemployed individuals (less than 0.5 percent of the selfemployed) may be more severely affected than other reservist employers if their reservist employee or owner is activated. In addition, CBO found that although USERRA provided employment protections to reservist employees, it might be exacerbating the difficulties that call-ups present for those individuals employers. The legislation limits firms flexibility in avoiding vacancies and imposes additional costs on some employers. Options for Mitigating the Effects of Reservists Activations To help lessen the adverse effects of call-ups, two broad approaches are available: policymakers could enact legislation, or DoD could change its policies. Either approach, however, would require balancing a number of goals that sometimes conflict, such as providing reservists with a wide range of protected civilian employment, assisting DoD s efforts to recruit and retain the military personnel it requires, minimizing the value of the labor resources being diverted from the civilian economy and improving DoD s allocation of personnel, and avoiding harm to small businesses. In its analysis, CBO considered several potential measures to mitigate the undesirable effects of call-ups, evaluating the measures in terms of those goals and their effects on DoD, reservists, and their employers. Options might include: B Compensating businesses through tax credits or direct payments; B Subsidizing loans to employers; B Providing or subsidizing call-up insurance for businesses; or B Exempting certain reservists from call-ups. The first three options, depending on how they were structured, could advance the goals listed above, including that of maintaining the legislated employment protections that reservists enjoy. The options would at least partially offset financial losses for firms that had reservist employees or owners who had been activated. In addition, the measures might increase employers support for reservists military service, which could in turn encourage

11 THE EFFECTS OF RESERVE CALL-UPS ON CIVILIAN EMPLOYERS 3 more individuals to either join or remain in the reserves. Moreover, if mechanisms could be developed so that DoD faced more of the costs associated with call-ups, it would then be better able to evaluate the most costefficient mix of reserve and active-duty personnel. In particular, it might have an incentive to recruit civilians whose absence from their positions would pose less cost to employers and thus decrease any amounts DoD might pay in compensation. The final option features a different mechanism from that of the others: it would reduce the number or frequency of call-ups rather than compensate employers for activations that had occurred. For example, DoD could exempt certain reservists or particular civilian positions from call-ups. Employers might benefit from that option, but if it was formulated too broadly, it might interfere with DoD s efforts to provide sufficient forces for war and other military contingencies. In addition, if call-ups were limited, reservists who were eager to serve and who wanted to be activated might be less satisfied with reserve service. By the same token, reservists who found the current levels of activation too high might be more satisfied. All of the options would assist at least some of the businesses affected by call-ups. But none of the measures are likely to completely eliminate the problems that firms face. The rules that established which businesses were eligible for assistance and the extent of that aid would determine the degree to which a particular measure reduced the losses that some reservist employers and owners incurred from a call-up. Another consideration is that the options entail either direct or indirect costs for the federal government and, consequently, for taxpayers. Even the fourth option, which calls for limiting certain reservists call-ups, would entail indirect costs. Declaring some individuals ineligible for activation might impede DoD s ability to mobilize sufficient personnel and might discourage participation in the reserves. DoD would then need to use pecuniary or other incentives to attract additional people to reserve service. The direct costs of compensating businesses through tax credits or direct payments, or by offering loans or insurance the first three options could be substantial, depending on how a measure was structured. The more targeted a remedy is, the more cost-effective the solution will be. That notion implies that any remuneration should be based on the actual loss that a firm experiences. However, calculating the decrease in profitability associated with call-ups may be virtually impossible. As CBO s interviews revealed, some business owners, even when they could quantify a change in profits, could not isolate how much of the decline was due to a reservist s activation and how much was due to other causes, such as a downturn in the economy, shifts in demand for the firm s products, or increased competition. Instead, the basis for compensating an employer s loss might be approximated. For example, the reservist s civilian salary or the costs of replacing the reservist could be used as measures of the firm s financial loss. Another approach would be to base compensation more broadly on the type or size of the business. An Overview of the Reserves The military s increased use of the reserves over the past several years has highlighted that component of the armed forces. The section that follows sketches some demographic features of this group as well as the positions they fill and the firms that employ them in the civilian sector of the economy. Organization The nation s military reserves, totaling 1.8 million members, are organized by service. Each service, including the Coast Guard, has a reserve component. In addition, the Air Force and Army each have a National Guard component. In general, National Guard units are organized and controlled at the state level. All states (including the District of Columbia) and all U.S. territories have both Army and Air National Guard units. The personnel in each of those components are assigned to one of three categories: the Standby Reserve, the Retired Reserve, or the Ready Reserve (see Figure 1). Standby Reservists, who are not required to train, are generally reservists who have a temporary hardship or disability or who have been exempted for other reasons. Retired Reservists are primarily former members of the armed forces who are receiving military retired pay. The Ready Reserve, with more than a million members, is the largest component, comprising the Selected Reserve, the Individual Ready Reserve, and the Inactive National

12 4 THE EFFECTS OF RESERVE CALL-UPS ON CIVILIAN EMPLOYERS Figure 1. Organization of the Military Reserves Total Reserves and National Guard Air National Guard, Air Force Reserve, Army National Guard, Army Reserve, Coast Guard Reserve, Marine Corps Reserve, and Navy Reserve (1.8 million) Standby Reserve (22,000) Ready Reserve (1.15 million) Retired Reserve (622,000) Individual Ready Reserve (284,000) Inactive National Guard (1,400) Selected Reserve (859,000) Source: Congressional Budget Office based on data from the Office of the Assistant Secretary of Defense for Reserve Affairs. Note: The figures in parentheses indicate numbers of reservists. Guard. All reservists may be mobilized for national security reasons under certain circumstances (see Box 1). Members of the Selected Reserve, which is considered essential to the initial missions that the military undertakes when the country goes to war, must be available to mobilize within 24 hours. This component of the reserves is primarily organized into units that drill (train) one weekend a month; in addition, members of the Selected Reserve participate in extended training for two weeks each year. Some Selected Reservists, however, support the military in other ways. For example, Individual Mobilization Augmentees do not train with a unit except when they prepare for mobilization. By contrast, the Active Guard/Reserve comprises military personnel on full-time active duty who support the reserves in such areas as personnel administration. All active members of the National Guard are part of the Selected Reserve. By comparison with the Selected Reserve, the other two components of the Ready Reserve participate less intensively. Many members of the Individual Ready Reserve

13 THE EFFECTS OF RESERVE CALL-UPS ON CIVILIAN EMPLOYERS 5 Box 1. Selected Legal Authorities for Mobilizing the Reserves Under a Presidential declaration of national emergency (partial mobilization), an authority designated by the Secretary of Defense, as specified in 10 U.S.C , may order to active duty as many as a million Ready Reservists at one time for no more than 24 consecutive months. As specified by 10 U.S.C (a), the entire reserves, including Standby and Retired Reservists, may be ordered to active duty under a Congressional declaration of war or national emergency (full mobilization) for the duration of the war or national emergency and for six months thereafter. (However, Standby and Retired Reservists may not be ordered to active duty under a Congressional declaration unless there are not enough qualified reserves in an active status or in the inactive National Guard in the required category who are readily available. ) The Presidential Selected Reserve Call-Up Authority, as specified at 10 U.S.C , allows the federal government to mobilize as many as 200,000 members of the Selected Reserve and the Individual Ready Reserve for no more than 270 days even without the stipulation of a national emergency. Other authorities exist for the mobilization of reserves but are more restrictive for example, regarding the duration of the call-up or the consent required. As an illustration, 10 U.S.C (b) allows an authority designated by the Secretary of Defense at any time to order any reserve member to active duty for no more than 15 days per year. The authority may be exercised without the consent of the reservist. However, the appropriate governors must consent to any such order for their state s National Guard members. In addition, 10 U.S.C (d) allows an authority designated by the Secretary of Defense to order a reserve member to active duty with the consent of that member (in other words, it provides for calling up reservists who volunteer for active duty). Again, governors, or other appropriate authorities, must consent to any such order for their state s National Guard members. In addition to those federal authorities, the states governors may call up their National Guard units to help respond to domestic emergencies typically, to participate in disaster relief efforts. have separated from the active-duty military before their contract has expired (for example, for medical reasons) and are fulfilling the remainder of their total service obligation in the reserves. Such reservists do not perform regularly scheduled training. Members of the Inactive National Guard must meet with their unit once a year but do not participate in training. 5. Based on data on reservists states of origin from DoD s Defense Manpower Data Center (for 2004) and from the Population Division of the Bureau of the Census (for 2003). Selected Demographic Data Reservists volunteer from all parts of the United States and its territories. 5 However, more than 40 percent of the reserve population comes from 10 populous states: in descending order by number of reservists, they are California, Texas, Pennsylvania, Florida, New York, Ohio, Georgia, Virginia, Illinois, and Alabama (see Figure 2). The greatest concentrations of reservists as a proportion of population are in the District of Columbia, Hawaii, North Dakota, Vermont, Alaska, and South Dakota (see Figure 3). In those states, about 1 of every 100 residents over the age of 17 is a reservist. Reservists also represent a wide variety of races and ethnicities. 6 Although the bulk of the force (72 percent) describes itself as white, about 16 percent of reservists are black, and 9 percent are Hispanic, with other races and ethnicities making up the remainder. Seventeen percent of reservists are female. 6. Based on data from DoD s Defense Manpower Data Center as of September 2004.

14 6 THE EFFECTS OF RESERVE CALL-UPS ON CIVILIAN EMPLOYERS Figure 2. Selected Reservists by State, 2004 Hawaii Wash. Oreg. Nev. Calif. Idaho Utah Mont. Wyo. Colo. N. Dak. S. Dak. Nebr. Kans. Minn. Wisc. Iowa Ill. Mo. Ind. Mich. Ky. Ohio W. Va. Pa. Va. N. Y. Vt. N. J. Del. Md. Maine D C. N.H. Mass. R. I. Conn. Ariz. N. Mex. Okla. Ark. Tenn. S.C. N. C. Alaska Miss. Ala. Ga. Tex. La. Fla. Top 10 States Middle 31 States Bottom 10 States Source: Congressional Budget Office based on data from the Department of Defense s Defense Manpower Data Center. Note: Data include the District of Columbia as well as the Coast Guard Reserve. Employment Profile Among Selected Reservists in 2004, most (about 75 percent) worked for pay in the civilian labor force. 7 Of that group, private-sector firms employed 52 percent (or about 335,000 individuals). Eighteen percent of paid reservists worked in firms with fewer than 100 employees (see Figure 4 on page 8); 8 percent worked in firms that 7. The data on reservists employment derive from CBO s analysis of Department of Defense, Defense Manpower Data Center, May 2004 Status of Forces Survey of Reserves (CD-ROM release of data, February 2005). CBO s estimates include almost 70,000 military technicians who support the reserve units full time as government employees and are members of the Selected Reserve as a condition of employment. Estimates of reservists who work for pay in the civilian sector do not include Active Guard/Reservists, who make up about 9 percent of the Selected Reserve and are employed by the military. had between 100 and 499 employees; and another 26 percent worked in firms that employed 500 or more people. In addition, 9 percent (or 55,000) of Selected Reservists who worked in the civilian sector were self-employed or worked without pay in a family business as their primary source of employment. Four percent were employed by nonprofit organizations. Federal, state, or local governments employed 36 percent of Selected Reservists who worked in the civilian sector in Among those who worked for the federal government, DoD was the largest employer. The proportion of reservists employed in the public sector is larger than the proportion of nonreservists who work in that sector a statement that holds true even after excluding the fairly sizable group of reservists who are full-time military technicians.

15 THE EFFECTS OF RESERVE CALL-UPS ON CIVILIAN EMPLOYERS 7 Figure 3. Selected Reservists as a Proportion of a State s Population Hawaii Wash. Oreg. Nev. Calif. Idaho Utah Mont. Wyo. Colo. N. Dak. S. Dak. Nebr. Kans. Minn. Wisc. Iowa Ill. Mo. Ind. Mich. Ky. Ohio W. Va. Pa. Va. N. Y. Vt. N. J. Del. Md. Maine D C. N.H. Mass. R. I. Conn. Ariz. N. Mex. Okla. Ark. Tenn. S.C. N. C. Alaska Miss. Ala. Ga. Tex. La. Fla. Top 10 States Middle 31 States Bottom 10 States Source: Congressional Budget Office based on data from the Department of Defense for 2004 and data covering 2000 to 2003 from the Population Division of the Bureau of the Census. Note: Data include the District of Columbia as well as the Coast Guard Reserve. Reservists differ from active-duty forces along several dimensions. With an average age of 33, reservists bring about five more years of experience to the military than active-duty service members do. 8 In addition, reservists tend to be more highly educated. In 2000, about 17 percent of enlisted reservists had a bachelor s or higher degree compared with 9 percent of active-duty enlisted service members. 9 Also differing somewhat from the active-duty force is the mix of occupations that the reserves represent. Some military capabilities, such as civil affairs and air traffic control, reside primarily in the reserve force. Generally, however, reservists are drawn from a variety of civilian occupations (see Figure 5). About 33 percent of reservists report that they are executives, managers, or professionals; of that group, managers or executives account for 24 percent, and health care practitioners and technicians make up 18 percent. The occupational category of executives, managers, and professionals is the largest among reservists (and is similar percentagewise to that category in the overall U.S. workforce). 10 In general, the balance of the reserves (67 percent) is drawn roughly equally from service, sales, construction, and production occupations Data on reserve forces as of September 2004 come from DoD s Defense Manpower Data Center; data on active-duty forces are from Department of Defense, 2003 Demographics of the Military Community, available at 9. For data on active-duty forces, see Congressional Budget Office, Educational Attainment and Compensation of Enlisted Personnel (February 2004). For data on reserve forces, see Paul Hogan, 2000 Survey of Reserve Component Personnel Overview (Falls Church, Va.: Lewin Group, 2002). 10. Estimates of reserve forces are based on information as of 2000 obtained by CBO from DoD s Defense Manpower Data Center. Information on the U.S. workforce was drawn from Bureau of the Census, Occupations: 2000, Census 2000 Brief C2KBR-25 (August 2003), available at cen2000/briefs.html. 11. Sales or office occupations have a much smaller representation among reservists than among the U.S. workforce 18 percent for reservists versus 26.7 percent of employed civilians.

16 8 THE EFFECTS OF RESERVE CALL-UPS ON CIVILIAN EMPLOYERS Figure 4. Civilian Employers of Selected Reservists, 2004 Private Firm with Fewer than 100 Employees (18%) Federal Government (20%) Private Firm with 100 to 499 Employees (8%) State Government (7%) Local Government (9%) (26%) Private Firm with More than 500 Employees Nonprofit Institutions (4%) Self-Employed or Family Business (9%) Source: Congressional Budget Office based on data from the Department of Defense s Defense Manpower Data Center. Notes: The data include the military technician category, personnel who support reserve units full time as government employees and are members of the Selected Reserve as a condition of their employment. The data do not include the Coast Guard Reserve. Percentages may not add to 100 because of rounding. The occupational profile of both self-employed reservists and reservists who are employed in small businesses tends to differ from that of the overall reserve force. Self-employed reservists are concentrated in fewer occupations than is characteristic of the reserves in total. They are most likely to consider themselves to be in construction and sales occupations; however, they are also more likely than reservists who are not self-employed to be health care or legal professionals or to work in occupations related to building and grounds maintenance. Reservists who work for small businesses are less likely than other reservists to be managers or professionals and more likely to be in occupations related to food service, construction, or sales. DoD s Use of the Reserves In the early 1990s, while engaged in Operations Desert Storm and Desert Shield, DoD began mobilizing reservists more extensively than it had in earlier years, when reserve call-ups were rare. Since then, reservists have provided critical manpower for missions ranging from peacekeeping and humanitarian efforts to counterdrug operations and small-scale contingencies. After the terrorist attacks of September 11, 2001, however, the pace and extent of reserve call-ups increased, raising questions about the degree of the disruptions that both reservists and their employers are experiencing and the impact of those upheavals on the recruiting and retention of reservists. DoD plans to continue its reliance on reserve personnel for the foreseeable future, but at the same time it is considering several approaches for mitigating the potentially adverse effects of such a strategy. Recent Mobilizations Between September 2001 and November 2004, the Department of Defense called up more than 410,000 reservists. At the end of calendar year 2004, the number of reservists supporting DoD s current operations numbered 187,000.

17 THE EFFECTS OF RESERVE CALL-UPS ON CIVILIAN EMPLOYERS 9 Figure 5. Civilian Occupations of Selected Reservists, 2000 Production, Transporation, and Material Moving (16%) Management, Professional, and Related (33%) Construction, Extraction, and Maintenance (15%) Farming, Forestry, and Fishing (1%) Sales and Office (18%) Service (17%) Source: Congressional Budget Office based on data from the Department of Defense s Defense Manpower Data Center. Note: The data include the Coast Guard Reserve as well as the military technician category, personnel who support reserve units full time as government employees and are members of the Selected Reserve as a condition of their employment. Increasing in tandem with those activations has been the time that reservists spend on active duty. Before Desert Storm/Desert Shield, the average number of days a reservist spent on active duty in exercises and operations each year was about one; that measure had risen to an average of more than 75 days in 2004 (see Figure 6). For reservists called to active duty since September 11, 2001, tours have averaged more than 300 days. 12 DoD s activations of the reserves for its current operations have not been evenly distributed among the reserve components. 13 The Army has supplied the bulk of the manpower: at the end of calendar year 2004, about 160,000 members (30 percent) of the Army National Guard and Reserve were on active duty in support of the 12. Estimates are based on information as of November 2004 obtained by CBO from DoD s Office of the Assistant Secretary of Defense for Reserve Affairs. 13. Mobilization data are from the Department of Defense, available at military s current operations. By comparison, the Navy had about 3,400 (4 percent) of its reservists mobilized. In addition to differences in the mobilization rates of reserve components, the activation of reservists in particular occupations has varied, with some specialties being used much more intensively than others. 14 For example, from September 11, 2001, through November 2004, callup rates among some officer career fields (such as military police, intelligence, and fixed-wing aviation) had reached more than 45 percent. Mobilization rates for some enlisted specialties (such as installation security, law enforcement, and motor vehicle operators) were even higher, exceeding 55 percent. Some individuals about 64,000 members (7.5 percent) of the Selected Reserve had been mobilized multiple times. Yet reservists in other career fields (for example, medical and legal) experienced relatively low rates of mobilization. 14. Estimates are based on information as of November 2004 obtained by CBO from DoD s Office of the Assistant Secretary of Defense for Reserve Affairs.

18 10 THE EFFECTS OF RESERVE CALL-UPS ON CIVILIAN EMPLOYERS Figure 6. Annual Active-Duty Days per Ready Reserve Member Source: Congressional Budget Office based on data from the Office of the Assistant Secretary of Defense for Reserve Affairs. Notes: Annual active-duty days include time spent mobilized to support the military services or combatant commands under voluntary and involuntary orders as well as to assist in domestic emergencies, counterdrug operations, and exercises. They exclude most training. The number of days for 2004 is estimated. Since the 2001 terrorist attacks, DoD has relied on involuntary mobilization, although some individuals have chosen to volunteer. Even before the attacks, some reservists volunteered for active duty, and some volunteered for longer-than-usual tours. In 2001, for instance, DoD activated more than 120,000 reservists for periods longer than 30 days; about 15 percent of those individuals served tours that exceeded 180 days. 15 On the basis of interviews with reservists and manpower experts, CBO has concluded that those activations were largely voluntary. Some people signed up during slowdowns in their civilian jobs; others, because of their desire to serve. Those individuals, like reservists who are mobilized involuntarily, are also protected by the employment provisions of the Uniformed Services Employment and Reemployment Rights Act of DoD s Plans for the Future Military analysts anticipate that deployments of reserve personnel will remain an important component of fighting the global war on terrorism over the next few years. The Department of Defense expects that reservists active-duty tours will continue at the current pace, lasting about one year, on average. However, to minimize the disruption to reservists civilian lives, Secretary of Defense Donald Rumsfeld has directed the services to limit involuntary mobilization to reasonable and sustainable rates, using not more than one year in every six as the planning metric. 16 In addition, as directed by law, DoD conducts annual and contingency-specific screening of reservists to ensure their immediate availability for active duty. 17 As part of 16. Office of the Deputy Assistant Secretary of Defense for Reserve Affairs (Readiness, Training, and Mobilization), Rebalancing Forces: Easing the Stress on the Guard and Reserve (January 2004). 15. Estimates are based on information obtained by CBO from DoD s Defense Manpower Data Center. 17. See 10 U.S.C , 10 U.S.C , 32 C.F.R , and Department of Defense Directive

19 THE EFFECTS OF RESERVE CALL-UPS ON CIVILIAN EMPLOYERS 11 Box 2. The Continuum of Service The Department of Defense (DoD) has begun to implement a new management system that is designed to offer reservists more flexibility in fulfilling their reserve commitment. DoD officials envision a reserve force in which reservists can participate at varying levels of intensity at different points in their career sometimes, for perhaps only a few days a year; at other times, for extended periods of as much as a year. To encourage alternatives to the traditional reserve commitment, the continuum would enable service members to move more easily between reserve status and active duty. DoD officials are currently studying how best to structure compensation to encourage such movement and are working to ease institutional policies that impede it. In addition, as part of the change, the Defense Department is seeking to develop new forms of affiliation among employers, potential reservists, and the military. The result, some senior DoD officials believe, will be a more attractive form of military service that offers new ways to serve. They are hopeful that with those changes, DoD can enlist people who were unable or unwilling to join previously particularly individuals whom the military has had trouble recruiting and retaining in the past, such as people who have advanced technical skills. DoD officials believe that ultimately, the continuum will create a more flexible, capable reserve force For further discussion of the continuum of service, see Department of Defense, Office of the Assistant Secretary of Defense for Reserve Affairs, Review of Reserve Component Contributions to National Defense (December 2002); John D. Winkler and others, A Continuum of Service for the All- Volunteer Force, in Barbara A. Bicksler, Curtis L. Gilroy, and John T. Warner, All-Volunteer Force: Thirty Years of Service (Dulles, Va.: Brassey s, Inc. [now Potomac Books], December 2004); and Glenn Gotz, Restructuring Reserve Compensation, in Cindy Williams, ed., Filling the Ranks: Transforming the U.S. Military Personnel System (Cambridge, Mass.: MIT Press, 2004). that screening, it assesses the hardship that individuals might face if they were mobilized. The annual program, which is suspended under partial or full mobilization, allows some Ready Reservists to transfer to the Standby or Retired Reserve or to be discharged. Those who may be eligible for transfer or discharge are reservists whose mobilization would: B Result in extreme personal hardship or hardship for their community; or B Seriously harm their employer s ability to perform functions essential to the nation s defense, health, or safety. Currently, the annual screening program is suspended. However, since September 11, 2001, DoD has granted waivers or delays to about 225 reservists under a special exemption program. 18 To help meet the military s future needs for personnel, the Defense Department has begun to implement a new management system for the reserves. Called the continuum of service, it aims to provide a mechanism to allow individuals to serve in the reserves at varying levels of participation throughout their military careers (see Box 2). 19 The continuum may encourage reservists to volunteer for active duty and may provide a greater range of opportunities for serving in the reserves. However, the military s increased reliance on voluntary commitments may strain the operations of reservists civilian employers. Some 18. The annual screening program may be suspended at the discretion of the Secretary of Defense when an involuntary activation occurs under 10 U.S.C (or a Presidential Selected Reserve Call- Up Authority). In September 2001, the program was suspended upon the authorization of partial mobilization, although DoD created a special exemption process in October In calendar year 2000, DoD removed 246 reservists from the Ready Reserve. 19. Because DoD is still refining and implementing the continuum concept, how the reserves will eventually be configured is uncertain, and the full implications for employers are unknown.

20 12 THE EFFECTS OF RESERVE CALL-UPS ON CIVILIAN EMPLOYERS firms may find that their reservist employees are absent more often or for longer periods. How Reservists Call-Ups and Federal Protections Affect Employers DoD s greater reliance on the reserves in recent years and its expectation of continuing that policy mean that private-sector employers of reservists and self-employed reservists may experience longer and more costly absences from the workplace. Legislated job protections in particular, those contained in the Uniformed Services Employment and Reemployment Rights Act of 1994 hinder employers ability to adjust to the mobilization of reservists and require that employers incur the cost of continuing some of those reservists benefits while they are away. Thus, instead of DoD s bearing the full costs of a reserve mobilization, employers also bear some of the costs of call-ups. 20 Effects of Job Vacancies The mobilization of reserve personnel can create involuntary and unexpected absences for employers. Businesses face decisions about replacing a reservist whether to hire a substitute, have other employees fulfill the reservist s job duties, keep the position open and allow work to go undone, or, in the most extreme case, close the business. No matter how a firm chooses to deal with the vacancy, the reservist s mobilization may disrupt the business s normal flow of work and entail costs. For example, hiring a new employee may require significant expenditures for recruiting, administration, and training. Although some recruiting and hiring techniques, such as direct application, can be inexpensive, others can be costly. Hiring through a temporary agency may increase employers costs, even if the wages and productivity of the reservist and the temporary hire are comparable, because such agencies fees generally exceed 50 percent of the temporary worker s wages. Also, fees charged by recruiting firms may range between 10 percent and 30 percent of a new 20. For additional discussions on employers costs and ways to remunerate employers, see Glenn Gotz, Strengthening Employer Support of the Guard and Reserve, Document D-2755 (Alexandria, Va.: Institute for Defense Analyses, January 2003); and Colin M. Doyle and others, Analysis of Employer Costs from Reserve Component Mobilization, IDA Paper P (Alexandria, Va.: Institute for Defense Analyses, December 2004). hire s salary in the first year. For a position paying the median national salary in the private sector (about $40,000 in current dollars), firms could face direct recruiting expenditures of more than $4, The time that staff members spend to screen and interview candidates adds to the costs of hiring. Shifting personnel or allowing work to remain undone may also be costly. Shifting duties among a firm s remaining employees may require the business to pay overtime or suffer problems with employee morale and retention. Some firms, regardless of how they deal with their reservist s absence, may find that they cannot continue business as usual. Work slowdowns or stoppages, an inability to deliver products, or a permanent loss in sales may be unavoidable. Some firms may even shut down when a reservist is activated or when they find later that they cannot operate for lengthy periods without their reservist employee. Effects of Uncertainty About the Timing and Duration of Call-Ups Employers often receive little warning of a reservist s mobilization. A survey published by DoD in 2003, which questioned reservists who had been mobilized over the previous 24 months, indicated that reservists notified their civilian employers an average of 13 days before their mobilization began. 22 The survey also showed that almost 60 percent of reservists gave their employers advance notice of one week or less. A further problem for employers is that DoD sometimes changes reservists mobilization or demobilization dates. In addition, for recent operations, DoD has extended many reservists tours of duty during the time in which they were activated. Lack of advance warning and uncertainty about reservists activation or deactivation can exacerbate the problems that call-ups pose for employers. With little time to plan 21. See Bureau of Labor Statistics, National Compensation Survey: Occupational Wages in the United States, July 2003 Supplementary Tables (August 2004), Table 4.2. Annual earnings in 2003 dollars for white-collar workers in the private sector were $45,962; for blue-collar workers, $31,566; for service workers, $19,239; and for professional specialty and technical occupations, $56, Department of Defense, Defense Manpower Data Center, May 2003 Status of Forces Survey of Reserve Component Members: Tabulations of Responses, DMDC Report No (November 2003).

MILITARY LEAVE PEOPLE CENTER SECTION I PURPOSE OF THE POLICY To establish procedure for administering a request for Military Leave. The policy also outlines certain rights, responsibilities and benefits

PUBLIC HEALTH AGENCY OPERATIONS 50-State Survey State Laws Addressing Extension of Workers Compensation Coverage to Public Health As of May 31, 2014 Please note that this document describes the content

National Conference of State Legislatures Discrimination Laws Regarding Off-Duty Conduct Updated October 18, 2010 The issue of employees' rights to engage in certain off-duty activities and in the competing

Alabama any other person called upon to render aid to any child ALA. CODE 26-14-10 Alaska ALA. CODE 26-14-3(a) paid employees of domestic violence and sexual assault programs, and crisis intervention and

Model Regulation Service April 2005 Corporate Owned Life Insurance (COLI) is life insurance a corporate employer buys covering one or more employees. With COLI, the employer is generally the applicant,

Title 27: Part 210: Chapter 49 Personnel PERS, Regulations for Retirement Plans Administered by the Board of Trustees Military Service 100 Purpose This regulation provides information to the member regarding

EMPLOYMENT BENEFITS AND REEMPLOYMENT RIGHTS FOR MINISTERS SERVING AS CHAPLAINS I. Policy Statement It is the policy of San José Presbytery to ensure that Ministers serving within the Presbytery who are

Summary of statutory or regulatory provision by entity. Alabama As long as may be necessary to treat the patient and for medical legal purposes. Ala. Admin. Code r. 545-X-4-.08 (2007). (1) 5 years. Ala.

ARTICLE 17 MILITARY LEAVE A. Temporary Military Leave for Active-Duty Training 1. Temporary military leave for active-duty training shall be granted to any employee who as a member of a reserve component

MILITARY LEAVE OF ABSENCE Military and Veterans Code, Sections 389, 395, 395.01, 395.02, 305.03, 395.04, 395.05, 395.1, 395.2, and 395.3 389. Definitions. (a) As used in this chapter, "temporary Military

THE EFFECT OF MILITARY LEAVE ON HEALTH INSURANCE COVERAGE AND FLEXIBLE BENEFIT PLANS The Uniformed Services Employment and Reemployment Rights Act of 1994 (USERRA) (P.L. 103-353) was signed into law on

Model Regulation Service - January 1993 These Guidelines have been prepared for use by state insurance department personnel who may be presented with questions or concerns regarding charitable gifts of

October 19, 2005 The Honorable John Warner Chairman The Honorable Carl Levin Ranking Minority Member Committee on Armed Services United States Senate The Honorable Duncan L. Hunter Chairman The Honorable

San Diego Military Advisory Council (SDMAC) Positon Paper on the Report of the Military Compensation and Retirement Modernization Commission Background: The National Defense Authorization Act of FY2013

Postsecondary Tuition and Fees Introduction Tuition-Setting Authority for Public Colleges and Universities By Kyle Zinth and Matthew Smith October 2012 Who sets tuition? Regardless of the state in question,

ADULT PROTECTIVE SERVICES, INSTITUTIONAL ABUSE AND LONG TERM CARE OMBUDSMAN PROGRAM LAWS: CITATIONS, BY STATE (Laws current as of 12/31/06) Prepared by Lori Stiegel and Ellen Klem of the American Bar Association

Uniformed Services Employment and Reemployment Rights Act of 1994, as amended The Uniformed Services Employment and Reemployment Rights Act (USERRA) was enacted by Congress and signed into law by President

Of CITGO Petroleum Corporation And Participating Subsidiary Companies Summary Plan Description As in effect January 1, 2012 01/2012 In the event of any conflict between this Summary Plan Description and

Re-Employment Rights and the Soldiers' and Sailors' Civil Relief Act (SSCRA) RE-EMPLOYMENT Members of the National Guard and Reserves activated for Federal Duty -- their civilian careers and activities

CB03-FF.04SE April 10, 2003 Quotes and Radio Sound Bites i Special Edition i U.S. Armed Forces and Veterans Active Duty and Reserves 1.4 million The number of active duty men and women in the U.S. armed

This chart accompanies Protection From Creditors for Retirement Plan Assets, in the January 2014 issue of The Tax Adviser. State-by-state analysis of IRAs as exempt property State State Statute IRA Alabama

Things New Yorkers Should Know About Public Retirement Benefits in New York State October 2010 INTRODUCTION Citizens Budget Commission One Penn Plaza, Suite 640 New York, NY 10119 411 State Street Albany,

Page 1 of 5 Subject: Military Leave Applies to: Regular Full-time and Regular Part-time Staff and Faculty called to active military duty, active or inactive military duty training, or full-time National

Journal of Agribusiness 20,1(Spring 2002):41S50 2002 Agricultural Economics Association of Georgia How Much Do Farmers Pay in Taxes? Gregory M. Perry and Clair J. Nixon A variety of federal, state, and

Military Related Leaves & Benefits Presented by: Human Resources November 4, 2014 Why is Military Leave important? Employers are seeing more and more employees undergo military training, leave for active

NON-LICENSEE INTERNET ADVERTISING AND REFERRALS Marc M. Tract, Esq. 212.940.8760 It has been five years since the New York Insurance Department ( New York Department ) issued Circular Letter No. 5 (2001)(the

Military Leave at Indiana University A Summary for Staff and Temporary Employees and Their Families Introduction The Uniformed Services Employment and Reemployment Rights Act (USERRA) and the Code of Federal

APPENDIX D CONTINUATION OF COVERAGE SAMPLE DESCRIPTIONS This Appendix contains important information about continuation coverage which may be available to Covered Individuals under federal and/or Illinois

Military Compensation: Balancing Cash and Noncash Benefits To attract and retain the military personnel that it needs, the Department of Defense (DoD) must offer a compensation package that is competitive

SUMMARY OF MAJOR CHANGES TO CHAPTER 12 DOD 7000.14-R, VOLUME 7B MILITARY PAY POLICY AND PROCEDURES FOR RETIRED PAY New and revised instructions are indicated by a star placed immediately before the new

September 2010 No. 347 Sources of Health Insurance and Characteristics of the Uninsured: Analysis of the March 2010 Current Population Survey By Paul Fronstin, Employee Benefit Research Institute LATEST

DEPARTMENT OF DEFENSE MILITARY PROGRAMS MILITARY PERSONNEL ACTIVE AND RESERVE FORCES These appropriations finance the personnel costs of the Active, Reserve, and Guard forces of the Army, Navy, Air Force,

REPORT TO THE CONGRESS Cost and Impact on Recruiting and Retention of Providing Thrift Savings Plan Matching Contributions OFFICE OF THE SECRETARY OF DEFENSE February 2010 Table of Contents I. Introduction...

2010 DEM OGR PROF ILE O F TH APH E MIL ITARY ICS COM MUN ITY Acknowledgements ACKNOWLEDGEMENTS This report is published by the Office of the Deputy Under Secretary of Defense (Military Community and Family

Demographics PROFILE OF THE MILITARY COMMUNITY ACKNOWLEDGEMENTS This report is published by the Office of the Deputy Assistant Secretary of Defense (Military Community and Family Policy), under contract

1/09 FREQUENTLY ASKED QUESTIONS 1. Which employees are eligible for an FMLA qualifying leave? An "eligible employee" is a State employee who: a) Has been employed by the State for at least 12 months, and

Order Code RL30631 CRS Report for Congress Received through the CRS Web Retirement Benefits for Members of Congress Updated January 21, 2005 Patrick J. Purcell Specialist in Social Legislation Domestic

U.S. ARMY NAF EMPLOYEE RETIREMENT PLAN March 2014 INTRODUCTION This booklet is published by the U.S. Army NAF Employee Benefits Office. It is intended to provide you with useful information about the U.S.

Compensation Flexibilities INTRODUCTION The Federal Government uses its competitive advantage to attract and keep candidates who will contribute to the success of the organization. The compensation flexibilities

NONJUDICIAL TRANSFER OF TRUST SITUS CHART 1 This chart provides a survey of the State statutory provisions for all States and the District of Columbia relating to the nonjudicial transfer of the principal

Health Insurance Continuation Coverage Under COBRA Janet Kinzer Information Research Specialist July 11, 2013 CRS Report for Congress Prepared for Members and Committees of Congress Congressional Research

FEDERAL LAWS AND GROUP BENEFITS Military service and group insurance How does this apply to you? Each situation is different. The information we share here is simply a general overview of a topic. To find

Purchasing Service Credit For members enrolled in the Defined Benefit Plan 2015 2016 Purchasing Service Credit Table of Contents Purchasing Service Credit...1 How to certify purchasable credit...2 Methods

COMPARATIVE NEGLIGENCE RULES & BI/PD STATUTES OF LIMITATIONS This survey of state laws is a quick reference guide that should only be used as a starting point in researching the applicable law to a given

SECTION 22. MILITARY LEAVE (As amended December 11, 2007, and October 21, 2008) 22-1. Definitions. Military leave: Paid or unpaid leave granted to an employee who temporarily leaves County employment for

United States General Accounting Office Washington, DC 20548 March 20, 2002 The Honorable John McHugh Chairman The Honorable Vic Snyder Ranking Member Military Personnel Subcommittee Committee on Armed

The Florida Senate BILL ANALYSIS AND FISCAL IMPACT STATEMENT (This document is based on the provisions contained in the legislation as of the latest date listed below.) Prepared By: The Professional Staff

MILITARY SERVICE AND RETIREMENT Persons First Employed Under the Civil Service Retirement System BEFORE 10-1-82 If You Will Be: Your Choices: Effect on Your Annuity: Eligible for Social Security benefits

Release 11.0.2 YOUR GROUP TERM LIFE BENEFITS FOR EMPLOYEES OF: The School Board of Broward County, Florida CLASS(ES): All Eligible Active Paraprofessionals All Other Eligible Active Employees EFFECTIVE

GAO United States Government Accountability Office Report to Congressional Committees September 2009 MILITARY AIRLIFT DOD Should Take Steps to Strengthen Management of the Civil Reserve Air Fleet Program

September 2013 No. 390 Sources of Health Insurance and Characteristics of the Uninsured: Analysis of the March 2013 Current Population Survey By Paul Fronstin, Ph.D., Employee Benefit Research Institute

FAMILY AND MEDICAL LEAVE ACT (FMLA) POLICY Purpose To define policy pursuant to the federal Family and Medical Leave Act for employees of Olympus Corporation of the Americas ( OCA ), Olympus America Inc.

Page 705 TITLE 38 VETERANS BENEFITS 4301 ices to a covered person before a non-covered person or, if resources are limited, giving access to such services to a covered person instead of a non-covered person.

OFFICE OF HUMAN CAPITAL TSA MANAGEMENT DIRECTIVE No. 1100.55-6 To enhance mission performance, TSA is committed to promoting a culture founded on its values of Integrity, Innovation and Team Spirit. Note:

Benefits for Your Life Paid Time Off Taking time off allows you to rest and recharge, and helps you maintain a proper balance between your personal and work life which is key to your overall health and