hhmmm so there was a doctor..... The other reason I didn't vote off Teddy the first time is because I really thought there may be a doctor and didn't want my lynching to get wasted.... Wow, so I really managed this game a little better than I thought!

Damnit. I investigated A's and once I found out he was innocent I was fairly certain it was Giants. I should have listened to him and investigated J but I went with my own suspicions. What really killed us was me investigating poker when he got killed.

How come you didn't reveal yourself as the doctor on the final day Giants?

teddy ballgame wrote:Damnit. I investigated A's and once I found out he was innocent I was fairly certain it was Giants. I should have listened to him and investigated J but I went with my own suspicions. What really killed us was me investigating poker when he got killed.

How come you didn't reveal yourself as the doctor on the final day Giants?

what good would that have done? thats why i like that theres no guarentee if there is or isnt a role, because then you can always doubt someone. the doctor's role was pretty pointless this game. giants protected you the first night teddy so if j would have lynched you it would have definitely been a waste. but the other nights j/deeray were on different pages than giants, so his protection didnt really keep anyone alive.

Because then A's might not have voted for him so quickly. On the final day if you have a defined role like doctor/investigator I can't see how it wouldn't help to explain yourself along with what actions you made throughout the game.

wow thats two games in a row that i picked one of the mafia on the first day and just could not get anyone on my side, not really sure what to do differently to get people on my side...i'm pretty much a pro at reading people, maybe i should join the FBI or something and go after the real mafia

GiantsFan14 wrote:wow thats two games in a row that i picked one of the mafia on the first day and just could not get anyone on my side, not really sure what to do differently to get people on my side...i'm pretty much a pro at reading people, maybe i should join the FBI or something and go after the real mafia

No offense, but on Day 1 I really do believe that was more luck than anything...