Garrett himself, Yani Gellman, tells HollywoodLife.com about the Melissa twist & why he was ‘satisfied’ when he found out who ‘A’ is.

Rosewood’s shadiest cop has been laying low for the past few weeks, but Officer Garrett Reynolds (Yani Gellman) returned in a big way on the March 19 episode of Pretty Little Liarswhen it was revealed he’s been carrying on a secret romance with Melissa (Torrey DeVitto) — and Yani tells HollywoodLife.com the secrets have only begun to spill out.

“You definitely find out more about the nature of their relationship in the finale,” Yani says of ‘Garrissa.’

Of course, Melissa isn’t the only girl in Garrett’s life. Before Jenna (Tammin Sursok) skipped town for her eye surgery, she and Garrett were carrying on a dark little romance of their own.

Yani also says that, while he was “shocked and surprised” when he found out who “A” is, the word “satisfied” might be the most appropriate emotion.

“The finale really delivers,” he assures me. “As [creator Marlene King] has been saying, in some ways it’s an ending to the mystery, but it’s also the beginning of a new mystery.”

And what kind of journalist would I be if I didn’t ask Yani how much candy he’s consumed during those classic Garrett stalking-from-a-distance scenes?

“They’re kind of like M&M’s — they’re little chocolate balls,” he says. “They’re quite tasty at first — until you’ve eaten four bags when you’re shooting a scene all day. I don’t know if him eating those is going to be a clue about something going forward, or what’s going on there. Usually, though, if you see something happening a couple times on the show, it becomes a thing in the future.”

What do you make of Yani’s little clue, Pretty Little Liars fans? Could Garrett be “A”? (Let’s not forget the badge we saw in the burning building a few weeks ago!) Cast your vote below, then share your best theories in the comments section.