To Me, Shields, Kennedy and Strassburg seem like locks and I lean towards Ellsbury/Hanson (healthy for 2012?) for the other two, but a few others seem to have some value here and I appreciate all thoughts. Thanks!

I think Ellsbury is hands down the most valuable player of all of them. Even if his power slips to 18 homers next year, he is still immensely talented and fills out the stat sheet. Also, if he homers drop his SBs will likely rise, so it's a win win. I'd make him your one expensive keeper and then go with the ones I previously listed. Hanson honestly is a huge risk for me with that shoulder. Moore is intriguing but I still take those other arms above him.