The Reminiscing Thread

This post has
68
Replies |
7
Followers

According to my profile, i've been posting here for 3 years (mostly lurking). So I can't remember all the high lights. :P

In terms of recent threads I've enjoyed, I really liked Neodoxy's thread about Stimulus and the Broken Window Fallacy. Even though the thread was perpetually derailed, I think a lot of good points were raised. The discussion wound up being timely too, considering Hurricane Sandy happened not long afterward.

I also want to reminisce about a lot of good posters that I don't see post any more. Esuric, Lagrange Multiplier, Stranger, Strange Loop, hayekianxyz, laminustacitus, others. Hopefully they'll find their way over to the new forums.

Either way, this forum has been a lot of fun. I actually learned a lot from many of the people here. I will be sad to see it go. C'est la vie.

Because it was essentially a circle jerk motion, given to the 'favourites'.. mostly of a certain forum faction? (Saying that as a recipient).

Re: "the KnightofBAWAA if anyone remembers him."

Legend. Great mod before he was ousted/banned when Danny took over and wanted to change the forum dynamic. Would not relent if you were on the wrong side of the argument and continued to try get by the laws of logic.

Reminiscing Thread...

When posts were longer, more considered and less 'chatty'.

When it seemed like everyone had something considerable to add.

When the conversation/discussion was something new... not something that you could simply refer to a past discussion thread (or 100) about.

When these guys were all around; KnightofBawaa, Jon Irenicus, NirgrahamUK, Inquisitor.. the verifiable A-team.

As for AJ, Danny and the rest of the 'consequentialist' crowd... my arguments are far more advanced because of those discussions/criticisms leveled at Rothbard, Hoppe etc. Cheers.

As for thread discussions of amusement/worth, I'll offer two; when mr1001nights came to the forums is one, along with the occasional revleft appearance... and the temp Mises forum excursion over to revleft hahah.

Ron Paul is for self-government when compared to the Constitution. He's an anarcho-capitalist. Proof.

One of my fondest memories is of Liberty Student offering a Mises Store gift voucher to the first two posters who wrote a decent critique of a post by Clayton. I won one, and no one else wrote a critique, so Clayton got the other one!

My favorite time on the forum was back when the deontologists and consequentialists were going at it. I was learning so much back then just from lurking and chipping in now and again.

I'll just say that before I began actively posting here, I was a lurker. Not to take away anything from a lot of people here (because there are many intelligent people who post here) but I found myself really paying attention to a lot of the things that Liberty Student would post. This guy clearly had a set of principles that he would not budge on and I respect him for that, especially since those principles are things that I try to live by myself. I'll take the time now, since it's a golden opportunity, to thank him for his contributions to this forum, whether he still reads the posts here or not. Thanks dude. :)

Not to take away anything from a lot of people here (because there are many intelligent people who post here) but I found myself really paying attention to a lot of the things that Liberty Student would post. This guy clearly had a set of principles that he would not budge on and I respect him for that, especially since those principles are things that I try to live by myself.

Funny you should say that because LStudent went from being a self-proclaimed Rockwellian (which I thought was very clever) to something far more squishy and ill-defined. IIRC by the end he wasn't even a natural rights guy anymore. So clearly there were some principles he moved away from.

I don't remember too much about him, but the basic narrative that I remember was that he came here around the same time I did and he went down the whole beginner's track to learning about AE and Libertarianism and he mostly seemed to agree with the views generally held around here even though he was a n00b.

Then I remember him changing his username to Novus Zarathustra and a lot of his material just got odd and rather intelligent. I always thought that was weird, but I might not be recounting the series of events quite properly.

I also enjoyed Sieben's/Snowflake's contributions, even if he was recently banned. He showed up about the time that I did as well.

At last those coming came and they never looked back
With blinding stars in their eyes but all they saw was black...

I don't remember that Neodoxy, but I do remember you recently claiming that you started here with a noob account and then later opened your Neodoxy account becuase you didn't like some of the things your noob account had posted. This is all adding up now.

Funny you should say that because LStudent went from being a self-proclaimed Rockwellian (which I thought was very clever) to something far more squishy and ill-defined. IIRC by the end he wasn't even a natural rights guy anymore. So clearly there were some principles he moved away from.

This may or may not be true; but from what I can remember, he was pretty strong on his principles and I don't remember seeing any contradiction.

Lol Wheylous. I appreciate your contributions too. Sadly all lists must come to an end! To me you are (or were) like Robin to JJ's Batman (thanks Jargon!). I sense your best posts are still to come - and they won't be on this forum.

By the way, I nominate that What do you look like? thread as the funniest on the forum (shame some of the pics have disappeared though). Anyone got any other nominations?

I had always been impressed by the fact that there are a surprising number of individuals who never use their minds if they can avoid it, and an equal number who do use their minds, but in an amazingly stupid way. - Carl Jung, Man and His Symbols

It's the era when the "Member Issues" group was created. I think Sanchez might have still been posting as Lilburne then. I know one of his bans had to do with him posting a gif file of the Star of David turning into a Swastika. I think everyone else got the irony in that except Sanchez.

I had always been impressed by the fact that there are a surprising number of individuals who never use their minds if they can avoid it, and an equal number who do use their minds, but in an amazingly stupid way. - Carl Jung, Man and His Symbols

I don't get on here much anymore, very rarely, but I do remember Liberty Student. Once I asked him if the world was indeed round, and he said "No." Very little grey with that guy, and although he was neurotic, I don't know many on this forum that haven't appeared to be at one time or another lol.

Liberty Student was entertaining, and I even followed his blog for about a day once upon a time. BTW What is the new forum? I might join it and become more engaged? When does it go live?