Whoa, Candice! Tell us how you really feel. “It’s so interesting how their relationship built over the past couple of seasons. it’s almost like she hated him so much that she didn’t know whether she wanted to grab him by the throat and throw him through a door, or just kiss him. I think that was the awesome tension the fans really loved about their chemistry.”

We couldn’t agree more! Klaus and Caroline’s will they/won’t they chemistry was one of the most compelling parts of Season 4. And while the TVD Powers That Be seemed to entertain the idea of the two of them possibly being together — Klaus did tell Caroline he intended to be her “last” love — Candice seems to think Caroline is so over the big bad hybrid.

“But I think she just hates him, and if he never comes back to Mystic Falls, it will be too soon. All she ever wanted, and all she still really wants, it to be with Tyler.”

Perhaps it’s Candice who is so tired of talking about Klaroline. After all, Klaus and Caroline ended things on relatively friendly terms. Not only did he save her at graduation, but he also allowed Tyler to come back to Mystic Falls. It didn’t look like Caroline was too upset at Klaus in the Season 4 finale, so why is Candice so adamant that Klaroline will never happen?

Sure, in Caroline’s mind, she’s still in love with Tyler, but when Klaus returns to Mystic Falls in Season 5, there’s no telling what could happen between him and Caroline. Sparks fly when they’re on screen, so we’re still holding out hope for a Klaroline reunion. (Sorry, Candice!)

What do you think, TVD fans? Why will Klaus return to Mystic Falls? Sound off with your theories below!

Crystal Bell is an editor at Wetpaint Entertainment and our resident fangirl for all things The Vampire Diaries. Follow her on Twitter and Google+!