Facebook under pressure over Soros smear tactics

Facebook is facing calls to conduct an external investigation into its own lobbying and PR activities by an aide to billionaire George Soros.

BuzzFeed reports that Michael Vachon, an advisor to the chairman at Soros Fund Management, made the call in a letter to friends and colleagues.

The call follows an explosive investigation, published yesterday by the New York Times based on interviews with more than 50 sources on the company, which paints an ugly picture of how Facebook’s leadership team responded to growing pressure over election interference, in the wake of the Kremlin ads scandal of 2016, including by engaging an external firm to lobby aggressively on its behalf.

The firm used smear tactics targeted at Soros, according to the NYT report, with the paper writing that: “A research document circulated by Definers [the PR firm engaged by Facebook] to reporters this summer, just a month after the House hearing, cast Mr. Soros as the unacknowledged force behind what appeared to be a broad anti-Facebook movement.”

Wikipedia describes Definers as “an American right leaning opposition research firm… [that] performs media monitoring services, conducts research using the Freedom of Information Act and also creates strategic communication to negatively influence the public image about individuals, firms, candidates and organizations who oppose their clients”.

Facebook has since responded to the NYT article, rejecting some of the report as inaccurate — and denying outright that it ever asked Definers to smear anyone on its behalf.

“The New York Times is wrong to suggest that we ever asked Definers to pay for or write articles on Facebook’s behalf – or to spread misinformation,” the company writes. “Our relationship with Definers was well known by the media – not least because they have on several occasions sent out invitations to hundreds of journalists about important press calls on our behalf.

“Definers did encourage members of the press to look into the funding of ‘Freedom from Facebook,’ an anti-Facebook organization. The intention was to demonstrate that it was not simply a spontaneous grassroots campaign, as it claimed, but supported by a well-known critic of our company. To suggest that this was an anti-Semitic attack is reprehensible and untrue.”

In a follow up report today the NYT says Facebook cut ties with the PR firm on Wednesday, after the publication of its article.

In his letter, Vachon describes it as “alarming that Facebook would engage in these unsavory tactics, apparently in response to George’s public criticism in Davos earlier this year of the company’s handling of hate speech and propaganda on its platform”.

“What else is Facebook up to? The company should hire an outside expert to do a thorough investigation of its lobbying and PR work and make the results public,” he adds.

We contacted Facebook for a response to Vachon’s call for an external investigation of its internal conduct. A company spokesman just directed us to its earlier response to the NYT article.

The title of the NYT article — “delay, deny and deflect” — hints at the meaty reportage within, with the newspaper presenting a well-sourced view of Facebook’s management team grappling ineptly and then cynically and aggressively with an existential reputation crisis by reaching for smear tactics associated with the worst kind of politics.

It also alleges that Facebook knew about Russian activity on its platform as early as the spring of 2016 but was slow to investigate.

Again, in its rebuttal, Facebook rejects that characterization — claiming a less inept early handling of the political disinformation threat. “Leading up to Election Day in November 2016, we detected and dealt with several threats with ties to Russia … [including] a group called APT28 … we also saw some new behavior when APT28-related accounts, under the banner of DC Leaks, created fake personas that were used to seed stolen information to journalists. We shut these accounts down for violating our policies,” it writes.

It also denies its then CSO, Alex Stamos, was discouraged by senior management from looking into Russian activity.

Although Stamos clashing with Sandberg over the Russian disinformation threat has previously been causally linked to his departure from Facebook this summer. (And in an internal memo that BuzzFeed obtained earlier this year Stamos does admit to having had “passionate discussions with other execs”.)

“After the election, no one ever discouraged Alex Stamos from looking into Russian activity — as he himself acknowledged on Twitter,” Facebook writes now, rejecting that portion of the NYT report. “Indeed as The New York Times says, “Mark and Sheryl [Sandberg] expanded Alex’s work.”

Facebook has also denied treating Donald Trump’s comments about Muslims — when in December 2015 the US president posted a statement on Facebook calling for a “total and complete shutdown” on Muslims entering the United States — any differently to “other important free speech issues”.

On this the newspaper’s sources told it that Facebook’s management team had delegated key decisions on whether or not Trump’s post constituted hate speech to policy staffers who “construed their task narrowly” yet were also motivated by worries about stoking a conservative backlash.

The post was not deleted. And the NYT writes that it was shared more than 15,000 times on Facebook — “an illustration of the site’s power to spread racist sentiment”.

TigerPress Previous Volumes Second Chance 4Premium one of a kind wordpress themes that do all the onpage seo for you including image seo, with TigerPress themes you can also generate an unlimited amount of geo targeted landing pages in any language.

SpeakEz PRO VersionEngage more users by adding voice to your web pages. Allow visitors to seamlessly transition from reading your content, into enjoying a captivating narrated audio version they can have read to them at their leisure.

Live Vid Ranker - Lead Gen AppLiveVidRanker is a Revolutionary SaaS system using Never Before Seen Technologies... all helping you to do ONE THING very well.
Thatand#39;s getting Page 1 Rankings on YouTube and Google practically Instantly. =)

SQZin Pro PlatinumGenerate Qualified Leads From Popular Content
with Your Call-To-Action Overlay
Without Having To Write A Single Word!|
Squeeze – Share – Profit!
You know that content is king and that high-quality content leads to the best conversions.

LetVidimaze TrainingLetVidimaze - Walk Your Visitors Through Your Page Using Videos That Play On Each Section Of Your Webpage!

Viper Cache Personal License10x your page load speed with viper cache engine...built from the ground up to give you total ease of use and minimum user input and maximum security unlike its competitors.

Viral Reach Agency 25 YearlyOnce you get the the Viral Reach Agency version you can sell Viral Reach access to others and charge your for it.
This is an entire business wrapped and readied for you. Make use of this opportunity and create an all new passive income stream for yourse

Live Vid Ranker - Lead Gen AppLiveVidRanker is a Revolutionary SaaS system using Never Before Seen Technologies... all helping you to do ONE THING very well.
Thatand#39;s getting Page 1 Rankings on YouTube and Google practically Instantly. =)

VidRepurposer EnterpriseThe enterprise, elite addition of VidRepurposer to users who want to outsource their content creation and resell the product.

TopStorySites ProA Cloud Based App That Builds INSTANT 1-Click AUTHORITY Affiliate Sites Like StumbleUpon, Scoop.it, Digg etc. with TOP Quality Content and Gets You Better Ranking, Viral Traffic from Top 7 Social Media Platforms, Sales and Commissions on Autopilot.

DropGecko ProPro level access for incredible traffic solutions and 7 extra bonuses with this groundbreaking software giving you the complete solution for the easiest access to profitable Dropship stores, complete with 1-click shipping and customer fulfilment.

Video Course - Cash Kit PROFinally! A GUARANTEED Way To Make Money Online, that Anyone Can Do! Literally ANYONE can do this... the only way to fail is not to try!! So let's go to Make Some Money Today!!!

Livecaster 3 Pro MonthlyGet on top of rankings and traffic with Livecaster3 Pro Version. It comes with several compelling capabilities and has absolutely no caps. Livecast on unlimited pages, profiles and YouTube channels
This upgrade lets you Livecast multiple videos simultane

Cloud Defender v2 Developer EditionComplete Cloud Site Security for you and your clients Inc Dev Rights - Tested and proven system for setting up the ultimate in server security, creating a virtual 'cloud' based fence that will protect your site from Bad Bots, Site Scrapers, DDOS attacks e

Twitworkz Agency 2.0 (one-pay)Twitworkz Following Builder is an amazing tool for auto-building your Twitter following. Twitworkz Agency One-Pay allows up to 50 Twitter accounts and full use of the Content Module.

TweetPush Pro One TimeTake a look at the powerful professional features of Tweetpush Pro Version. With this version you can automate and publish content for 25 Twitter accounts. Create multiple IDs for your business, and generate traffic through all of them targeting different

Credi Response EliteCredi Response is a web based SAAS product that is 100% compatible with Facebook terms if service. It replies to each and every comment with a notification graphic and sound on your Facebook fan page automatically..
Reach out to followers in their inbox,

ProfitFox EnterpriseThe world's most powerful notification technology that shows your lead forms and promo offers to right audience according to their behavior and boost leads, sales and profits on autopilot.

Tappit ProGet this Breakthrough Automated Software Builds Self-Generating and Buyer-Driven Funnels Using AI Analysed Links and Generates Leads and Profits On The Way Without Lifting A Finger

Pinflux Agency YearlyCharge your clients a monthly fee to promote their business on Pinterest. All you need to do today is call 10 local businesses a day explain to them what a terrific traffic source Pinterest can be. Even if just one signs up daily, that’s already a profit

Stock Audio Downsell Pack - PLRIt is time to give your wallet a break for good with this Massive Upsell offer of premium Stock Images, Video background Footages, Clip-Arts, Animated Icons and more With PLR (This offer is without 5 Awesome Bonuses)

VideoMax -[Reseller- 200 Packs]How Would You Like to Earn Huge Extra Income Each Year, Selling VideoMax Licenses To Anyone You Want, While Keeping 100% Of The Profits? Get 200 VideoMax Reseller Licenses..Resell and keep the profits..

Pixelmodo - BasicPixelModo is a cloud-based tool that lets you create Stunning Graphics, banners, ads, social media covers, capture and load any image or text from webpages directly into the editor, create Print on Demand Tshirt Graphics, access 2.5 million high quality i

1-Click Drophip PLATINUM1-Click Dropship PLATINUM will add an unlimited number of products from Etsy, Deal Extreme and Banggood.com!

Rank Hijack (yearly)Rank Hijack locates powerful "Parasite SEO" properties with high Auhority in Google that can be leveraged to rank quickly for buyer keywords, effectively leveling the playing field with the dominant high authority sites.

SpyCom - ClipsReel ACEClipsReel is a modern, A.I. based automatic storyboarding and video creation web based software. Using ClipsReel you can turn any article, blogpost or webpage into a stunning video.

LeadFunnelCloud EliteGet this Cloud Based App That Creates INSTANT Done-For-You UNLIMITED Profitable Lead Funnels To Build A HUGE List,Drive Targeted Social Traffic and Affiliate Commissions In Just 60 Seconds