Percent of Released Prisoners Returning to Incarceration

We have a reader request; she asks about recidivism of people released from prison (arrests, convictions, returns to prison). The report below summarizes the four principle studies:

April, 2014 study from the Bureau of Justice Statistics Following Prison Releases for Three and Five Years:

An estimated two-thirds (68 percent) of 405,000 prisoners released in 30 states in 2005 were arrested for a new crime within three years of release from prison, and three-quarters (77 percent) were arrested within five years, per the Bureau of Justice Statistics (BJS).

More than a third (37 percent) of prisoners who were arrested within five years of release were arrested within the first six months after release, with more than half (57 percent) arrested by the end of the first year.

These findings are based on a BJS data collection, Recidivism of State Prisoners Released in 2005, which tracked a sample of former prison inmates from 30 states for five years following release in 2005.

During the five years after release, prisoners in the study were arrested about 1.2 million times across the country. A sixth (16 percent) of released prisoners were responsible for nearly half (48 percent) of the arrests. About two in five (42 percent) released prisoners were either not arrested or were arrested no more than once in the five years after release.

The longer released prisoners went without being arrested, the less likely they were to be arrested at all during the follow-up period. For example, 43 percent of released prisoners were arrested within one year of release, compared to 13 percent of those not arrested by the end of year four who were arrested in the fifth year after release.

Among prisoners released in 2005 in 23 states with available data on inmates returned to prison, about half (50 percent) had either a parole or probation violation or an arrest for a new crime within three years that led to imprisonment, and more than half (55 percent) had a parole or probation violation or an arrest within five years that led to imprisonment.

Recidivism rates varied with the attributes of the inmate. Prisoners released after serving time for a property offense were the most likely to recidivate. Within five years of release, 82 percent of property offenders were arrested for a new crime, compared to 77 percent of drug offenders, 74 percent of public order offenders and 71 percent of violent offenders.

Released prisoners who were incarcerated for a violent, property or drug crime were more likely than other released inmates to be arrested for a similar type of crime. Regardless of the incarceration offense, the majority (58 percent) of released prisoners were arrested for a public order offense within five years of release. An estimated 39 percent of released prisoners were arrested within five years for a drug offense, 38 percent for a property offense and 29 percent for a violent offense.

Recidivism was highest among males, blacks and young adults. By the end of the fifth year after release, more than three-quarters (78 percent) of males and two-thirds (68 percent) of females were arrested, a 10 percentage point difference that remained relatively stable during the entire 5-year follow-up period.

Five years after release from prison, black offenders had the highest recidivism rate (81 percent), compared to Hispanic (75 percent) and white (73 percent) offenders.

Recidivism rates declined with age. Within five years of release, 84 percent of inmates who were age 24 or younger at release were arrested for a new offense, compared to 79 percent of inmates ages 25 to 39 and 69 percent of those age 40 or older.

The arrest of former prisoners after release increased with the extent of their criminal history. Within five years of release, 61 percent of released inmates with four or fewer arrests in their prior criminal history were arrested, compared to 86 percent of those who had 10 or more prior arrests.

Many inmates had multi-state criminal history records. About a tenth (11 percent) of prisoners had an arrest within five years of release in a state other than the one that released them, and nearly a quarter (25 percent) of the released prisoners had a prior out-of-state arrest.

These findings from the recidivism study on prisoners released in 2005 in 30 states and tracked to 2010 cannot be directly compared to the previous BJS study on prisoners released in 1994 in 15 states due to changes in the demographic characteristics and criminal histories of the U.S. prison population, an increase in the number of states in the study and improvements made to the quality and completeness of the nation’s criminal history records since the mid-1990s.

The report, Recidivism of Prisoners Released in 30 States in 2005: Patterns from 2005 to 2010 (NCJ 244205), was written by Matthew R. Durose, Alexia D. Cooper and Howard N. Snyder. can be found on the BJS website at http://www.bjs.gov/.

April, 2011 study from Pew:

Another study on recidivism (defined for this report as a return to prison) was offered by the Pew Center on the States, Pew Safety Performance Project and released in April, 2011.

The study analyzed returns to prison for 33 states for those released in 1999 and 41 states for those released in 2004 making the study the most comprehensive analysis of returns to prison ever done.

The report compared earlier studies on recidivism conducted by the US Department of Justice for 15 states for releases in 1983 and 1994 and concluded that recidivism rates “have consistently remained around 40 percent.” California was excluded from this finding due to that state’s large percentage of the nation’s prison population and the fact that California’s rate of return to prison is traditionally high.

The report singles out three states, Oregon, Michigan and Missouri for lowering rates of return to prison.

June 2002 study from the Bureau of Justice Statistics Following Prison Releases for Three Years:

Before the Pew report there was nothing of a national and substantive nature except for a US Department of Justice study from the Bureau of Justice Statistics that was released in June of 2002 based on inmates released from prison in 1994.

Note that there are a variety of older studies from the Bureau of Justice Statistics that remains definitive for many years. This study involved a very large set of data from 15 states and the methodology (quality of the research) was very good. This is the most quoted recidivism study in the country.

It followed offenders for three years and tracked results.

Principle Findings:

The study (see summary below) found that:

Two-thirds (sixty-seven percent) of offenders were arrested for “serious” crimes.

Fifty-two percent of the offenders were returned to prison for “serious” crimes and technical violations (they didn’t follow the rules of their release after prison).

Summary of 2002 Study:

Sixty-seven percent of former inmates released from state prisons in 1994 committed at least one serious new crime within the following three years.

This was a rearrest rate 5 percent higher than that among prisoners released during 1983.

State prisoners with the highest rearrest rates were those who had been incarcerated for stealing motor vehicles (79 percent), possessing or selling stolen property (77 percent), larceny (75 percent), burglary (74 percent), robbery (70 percent) or those using, possessing or trafficking in illegal weapons (70 percent).

Those with the lowest rearrest rates were former inmates who had been in prison for homicide (41 percent), sexual assault (41 percent), rape (46 percent) or driving under the influence of drugs or alcohol (51 percent).

About 1 percent of the released prisoners who had served time for murder were arrested for another homicide within three years, and about 2 percent of the rapists were arrested for another rape within that period.

Within three years, 52 percent of the 272,111 released prisoners were back in prison either because of a new crime or because they had violated their parole conditions (e.g., failed a drug test, missed a parole office appointment).

Men were more likely to be rearrested than were women (68 percent, compared to 58 percent), blacks more likely than whites (73 percent vs. 63 percent) and non-Hispanics more than Hispanics (71 percent vs. 65 percent).

Younger prisoners and those with longer records were also more likely to be rearrested.

Post-prison recidivism was strongly related to arrest history.

Among prisoners with one arrest prior to their release, 41 percent were rearrested. Of those with two prior arrests, 47 percent were rearrested. Of those with three earlier arrests, 55 percent were rearrested. Among those with more than 15 prior arrests, that is about 18 percent of all released prisoners, 82 percent were rearrested within the three-year period.

The 272,111 inmates had accumulated more than 4.1 million arrest charges prior to their current imprisonment and acquired an additional 744,000 arrest charges in the 3 years following their discharge in 1994 – an average of about 18 criminal arrest charges per offender during their criminal careers.

These charges included almost 21,000 homicides, 200,000 robberies, 50,000 rapes and sexual assaults and almost 300,000 assaults.

Almost 8 percent of all released prisoners were rearrested for a new crime in a state other than the one that released them. These alleged offenders were charged with committing 55,760 new crimes in states other than the imprisoning state within the three-year period. New York, Arizona and California had the most arrests of out-of-state offenders in this study.

The data were from the largest recidivism study ever conducted in the United States, which tracked prisoners discharged in 15 states representing two-thirds of all state prisoners released in 1994.

Most of them had been in prison for felonies: 22 percent for a violent offense (such as murder, rape, sexual assault or robbery), 33 percent for a serious property offense (mostly burglary, motor vehicle theft or fraud), 33 percent for a drug offense (primarily drug trafficking or possession) and 10 percent for public order offenses (mainly drunk driving or weapons crimes).

Most former convicts were rearrested shortly after getting out of prison: 30 percent within six months, 44 percent within a year, 59 percent within two years and 67 percent by the end of three years.

The study findings are based upon the prison and criminal records of an estimated 272,111 discharged prisoners in 15 states who were tracked through fingerprints records made at various points of contact with the justice system, both within the state in which they had served time and other states to which they traveled.

A previous study titled “Recidivism of Prisoners Released in 1983” was released in April of 1989. It was an analysis of the criminal records of more than 16,000 men and women, representing the almost 109,000 offenders who were released from prisons in 11 States during 1983.

The study links correctional data with federal and state criminal history records to provide a complete portrait of criminal careers for more than a half of the State prisoners released.

About 47% of the former prisoners were convicted of a new crime and 41 percent were sent back to prison or jail.

Comments

I am a bit confused by the data presented: first it states that 67% of released prisoners in 1994 committed at least one new serious crime within 3 years but then it says only 52% were back in jail for either a new crime or for not complying with conditions of parole. That means that a lot of those that committed another serious crime never saw more jail time. I don’t know what qualifies as a “Serious crime” but does not result in jail time especially when it is not a first time offence.

Michigan released thousands of inmates back into society, only to fail to arrest them and return them to prison after they violated their parole or committed new crimes. Currently there is a study to show how many murders have been committed by early released prisoners. Many parolees are not being supervised and therefore no one knows the actual status of these parolees. 11,000 rape kits went untested for years in Michigan, resulting in 21 serial rapist still remaining on the streets after only 600 kits being tested. Michigan needs to be excluded from this study as they have done little to protect the public. As I recall “protecting the public” is a part of

Trackbacks

[…] in and out of prison because he simply refuses to admit there is a problem and turn his life around? 52% of offenders return to prison because they don’t follow the rules after prison. Admittedly, intervention programs can reduce this risk – but here must be something […]

[…] have to pay for his stay is discouraging, especially when he’ll have nearly a 50% chance of ending up back in prison. The type of control they are looking for is to prevent these types of people from being able to […]

[…] reforming after prison sentences is not great. A study by the Pew Center on the States found that half of inmates are back in prison within three years of being released from jail. It is a little better in sports […]

[…] of those people put themselves at risk of being incarcerated, in which case, they would have had a 52% chance of returning to prison with in 3 years, and a strong possibility of not finding a steady […]

DALLAS (AP) -- A mother has been charged with leaving her 7-year-old daughter to sleep overnight in a dumpster outside a spa in Dallas, police said. Alicia Carroll of Garland was being held in the Dallas County jail Tuesday on charges of abandoning and endangering a child. Bond for the 28-year-old woman was set at […]

At 5 o'clock in the morning, I lay awake on the floor of my friend's living room, huddled in a thin blanket. A rerun of "Shark Boy and Lava Girl" was playing on TV. I stared at the screen, not really watching the movie. All I could see was the night's events playing on endless […]

The cross-dressing men who accused of trying to crash through the gates at NSA headquarters in Fort Meade, Maryland on Monday may have taken a wrong turn after stealing a companion's car, according to police. One man died and another was hospitalized Monday morning following a confrontation with NSA police at the security gate. The […]

Six weeks after learning that investigators had focused on his role in the years-old disappearance of his wife, Robert Durst married Debrah Lee Charatan, a driven New York real estate executive who has been a bulwark in his life for nearly three decades. Eight days later, on Dec. 19, 2000, Mr. Durst, the eccentric and […]

Since the birth of rap music, artists have written songs about pretty much everything: progress, struggle, success, failure, societal ills and the responsibility of hip-hop, even an “extraterrestrial time-traveling gynecologist and surgeon from the planet Jupiter.” Sometimes, their lyrics are an unvarnished reflection of the realities they live. Other times their words are less grounded […]

BOSTON, March 31 (Reuters) - Defense of accused Boston Marathon bomber Dzhokhar Tsarnaev is expected to intensify on Tuesday with his lawyers' first full day of calling witnesses. Tsarnaev, 21, could be sentenced to the death penalty or life in prison if found guilty of killing three and injuring 264 people in the April 15, […]

A hospital in Falls Church, Virginia, was was the site of a prisoner escape early Tuesday, The Washington Post reported. Police in Fairfax County confirmed to NBC News that the Inova Fairfax Hospital was in lockdown, and that a manhunt was underway. Inmate Wossen Assaye was being held by Alexandria City on federal charges for […]

A Fresno, California, firefighter is in critical condition after falling through the roof of a burning garage in a frightening scene that was caught on video Sunday. The footage shows a wall of flames shooting up from the garage, engulfing Capt. Pete Dern after the roof gives way under his feet. CAUTION: The video above […]

By Harriet McLeod CHARLESTON, S.C., March 31 (Reuters) - The parents of a 19-year-old Clemson University student who died last year after falling from a highway bridge during a pre-dawn fraternity run sued the university, the Sigma Phi Epsilon fraternity and three of its members for $50 million on Monday. Tucker Hipps' body was found […]

SALT LAKE CITY (AP) — Authorities say the driver of a pickup truck that crashed into the side of a house in Salt Lake City acknowledged drinking 36 beers and doing cocaine. A probable cause statement says Bernabe Urcino-Saldago told police what he had consumed after he failed a field sobriety test early Monday. The […]

KOMO NewsEverett Station overrun with crime: 'I don't feel safe here'KOMO NewsEVERETT, Wash. -- Lesley Bapties was waiting at the Everett Station to catch a bus when she says someone approached her about drugs. "Stay away from over there," she warned. "I don't feel safe here," said Grace Henry, who takes a GED class weekdays ...

KMOV.comWas the attack on a MetroLink passenger a hate crime? - KMOV.comKMOV.comSaint Louis University Law School professor Justin Hansford said Missouri's hate crime law calls for enhanced penalties if someone commits a crime because of hatred or racial bias. However, Hansford told News 4 there must be clear evidence of what's ...

KOIN.comAP CEO: Killing journalists should be war crimeKOIN.comHONG KONG (AP) — The president and CEO of The Associated Press called on Monday for changes to international laws that would make it a war crime to kill journalists or take them hostage. Gary Pruitt said a new framework is needed to protect ...AP chief: Killing of […]

FAIR (blog)Leading Papers Incite 'Supreme International Crime'FAIR (blog)Kellogg-Briand was the basis for the “crimes against peace” indictment at the Nuremberg Trials for Nazi leaders, several of whom were hanged for “planning, preparation, initiation, or waging a war of aggression.” At Nuremberg, chief US prosecutor Robert H.

Fear Of The Black Man: How Racial Bias Could Affect Crime, Labor RatesNPRNPR's Michel Martin speaks with professors Phillip Atiba Goff of UCLA and Harry Holzer of Georgetown University about how fears of African-American men are manifested in the criminal justice system and the labor market, and what that means for the ...

Memphis Flyer (blog)New Database Reveals Alarming Clearance Rates for Memphis CrimeMemphis Flyer (blog)Compiled using statistics submitted to the FBI's "Uniform Crime Report," the tool allows a person to enter a city, county, agency, or state into a search bar and see both the violent crime and property crime that occurred in the requested area. By […]

SFPD Crime Lab Might Have Put 'Hundreds' Of Cases In Jeopardy Over Faulty ...SFistAccording to the letter, the lab generated two incomplete DNA samples in 2013 that pointed to numerous suspects, including Hernandrez, but testified that they had definitively matched Hernandez. He confessed to "some elements of the crime" and was ...and more »

WRAL.comPolice: Durham teen's death not random crimeWRAL.comDurham, N.C. — A Durham teen whose body was found in a backyard a couple of miles from her home on Saturday likely knew her killer, Police Chief Jose Lopez said Monday. Police haven't disclosed when or how Tierra Hall, 17, was killed, but Lopez said ...and more »

Syracuse.comSyracuse has 8th highest violent crime rate in New York (database)Syracuse.comSyracuse has a lower violent crime rate than many neighboring Upstate cities, according to a syracuse.com analysis of FBI crime statistics for the state. Overall, Syracuse had the 8th highest rate for violent crime per 1,000 residents. In this file ...

How Many Crimes Do Your Police 'Clear'? Now You Can Find OutNPRViolent crime in America has been falling for two decades. That's the good news. The bad news is, when crimes occur, they mostly go unpunished. In fact, for most major crimes, police don't even make an arrest or identify a suspect. That's what police […]

As the toy’s inventor challenges patent law in the supreme court he has found unlikely allies in scientists, who rely on delayed payouts to fund critical researchA Spider-Man toy could help fuel the creation of life-saving drugs, if the US supreme court reverses a ruling from 1964 that prevents inventors from receiving royalties after their […]

The FBI—in conjunction with the Department of Justice’s Fraud Section—recently announced the establishment of three dedicated international corruption squads to aid in the battle against foreign bribery and kleptocracy-related criminal activity.

No time this morning to adumbrate the issues in individual posts, but Grits readers may be interested in these items:Just three months into her tenure, Dallas DA Susan Hawk fired two top lieutenants, one of whom called her "unstable," and tearfully admitted she sought treatment a year and a half ago for addiction to prescription […]

What your face shape says about your personalityGettyYour face could indicate if you have leadership potential, a study says.Feature that leaders typically haveMore to seeVitamin D's connection to cancerAir pollution can led to anxiety

Arizona Gov. Doug Ducey vetoed legislation Monday requiring law enforcement agencies to keep the names of officers involved in shootings secret for two months, nixing a bill that was inspired by last year's events Ferguson, Missouri, and similar incidents around the country. Ducey said in a lengthy veto letter that he sympathized with backers who […]

Portland, Me., has paid $72,000 to settle a lawsuit brought by a Bar Harbor couple who were arrested and jailed after they filmed police, reports the Portland Press Herald. Jill Walker and Sabatino Scattoloni spent three hours in jail last May after Scattoloni briefly used a cellphone to film five police officers who were questioning […]

The connection between imprisonment and crime rates in the United States is complex, and conventional wisdom often is at odds with the facts. Take our quiz to test your knowledge about key trends and developments across the nation and in the states.

Governor Dennis Daugaard signed into law on March 13, 2015 comprehensive juvenile justice legislation that will protect public safety, focus state-funded facilities on serious offenders, increase accountability, and contain costs.

From 1980 to 2013, the number of offenders incarcerated in federal prisons increased from approximately 24,000 to more than 215,000, making the federal system the largest in the nation. Policy choices contributed significantly to this expansion as lawmakers added criminal laws to the books, lengthened sentences, and abolished parole.

Starting with Texas in 2007, more than half the states have taken steps to rein in the size and cost of their corrections systems. After nearly 40 years of unabated growth, the state prison population has leveled off and the imprisonment rate is down 6 percent from its peak in 2008. Falling incarceration has coincided […]

Between 1980 and 2013, the federal imprisonment rate increased 518 percent, from 11 inmates per 100,000 U.S. residents to 68. Costs followed a similar trend, rising 605 percent, from $900 million to $6.4 billion, in the same period.

A former FBI agent in the Washington field office charged with stealing heroin that had been collected as evidence is to make his first appearance in federal court later Tuesday.Matthew Lowry, who was fired shortly before he was charged March 20 with 64 criminal counts — including possession of heroin, obstruction of justice and falsification […]

The Los Angeles City Council on Tuesday will consider adding a section to its general plan that focuses on bridging the city's health disparities, representing what experts hail as a shift in how public officials think about health policy.

Through the smoke and flames, Kyle Christiansen found the man he was looking for at the bottom of the basement stairs. Ammunition was heating up and going off, but the Roy officer pulled the man out of the basement and — with the help of a second officer — out of the burning house. And […]

Since launching in 2010, Homicide Watch DC has tracked the cases of 320 people arrested for murder in the District. We track how those cases end in our database, whether in conviction or acquittal. At the end of 2014, 96 suspects are still making their way through the court system. They are awaiting preliminary hearings, […]