Records don't lie and you are as good as your record says you are. I'm looking for intelligent replies here. In NY (where I live) there is tremendous hype surrounding Geno. Don't take my post at just face value.

With all of the dumb mistakes that Ryan keeps making (Don't get me wrong, I love the kid) is Geno Smith farther along at this point than our very own RT?????? What do you all think?:hclap:

Click to expand...

I'll just give you the short answer......NO.......T-Hill is clearly a better QB than Geno. Re-watch the 1st 3 Jets games and you will never think crazy things again. Here's a abit of PFF info, T-Hill is current ranked #8 (with an 8.3 overall rating) Gino is rated #21 (with a -1.6 rating overall) that's -1.6 (as in negative overall rating) so IMHO I have no idea why you think that Gino is better T-Hill.

A lot of Tannehill's picks are on receivers this year. Tannehill has made a few bad throws but ones that go off his receiver's hands or their thigh and bounces into defenders hand I can't really get mad at him

no, but I think Geno is already better than snatchez. He's more accurate than sanchez already. They both make mistakes, but I think I've ever seen a game where mark completed 86% of his passes, actually most of marks games, he only made like 55% of his passes. Franchise qb there ha.

With all of the dumb mistakes that Ryan keeps making (Don't get me wrong, I love the kid) is Geno Smith farther along at this point than our very own RT?????? What do you all think?:hclap:

Click to expand...

Geno, you played a good game but instead of posting on football forums shouldn't you be getting ready for the Steelers? I know they're not as good as they used to be but I think that still may be a tough game for you guys with them having an extra week to prepare.

Geno, you played a good game but instead of posting on football forums shouldn't you be getting ready for the Steelers? I know they're not as good as they used to be but I think that still may be a tough game for you guys with them having an extra week to prepare.

With all of the dumb mistakes that Ryan keeps making (Don't get me wrong, I love the kid) is Geno Smith farther along at this point than our very own RT?????? What do you all think?:hclap:

Click to expand...

:not sure if serious:

Geno had complete meltdowns vs the Titans and Patriots... Tannehill hasn't had a clunker that bad since his first ever game against Houston... (Although he did struggle vs the Titans last year too.)

The thing with Geno is that he reminds me a bit like Sanchez. When things are going good, its all great, but the second there is any adversity, he disintegrates like slug on salt. I am actually happy that he is experiencing some early success because that means the Jets wont address the QB position in next year's draft, and they will be stuck with another QB that will follow the "Sanchez trajectory"...

There is also something about his attitude that is Vince Young-ish. Not something I want from my QB.

It's not even close right now. Tannehill is establishing himself as a very capable starting QB. Geno has a long way to go still.

Tannehill is definitely better but its not even a fair argument because Geno has only played 5 games.

Click to expand...

Agreed, I'll be interested in watching Geno's progression if for no other reason to see if he is going to become a long term threat....that won't be determined this year, but so far to me he's looked like he's progressing in a positive fashion which is bad news, it's too early to tell for sure but the same goes for our guy as well.

I should also say I've been very impressed with what EJ Manuel has done so far, so this division might very well shape up to be one of the toughest in the next year or two.

Look. Geno had a terrific game Monday night no doubt and even though I HATE The Jets, I am happy for the good Jets fans here because after the Suckchez debacle they may have finally found their guy. With that being said, at this point it's not even close. Geno has 8 interceptions to Ryan's 5 and Ryan has a much better qb rating right now. Also, at this point in his career Geno still has a tendency to make that critical rookie mistake like the behind the back, Globetrotter fiasco a couple of weeks ago. Ryan Tannehill is keeping his team in games right now despite having a terrible offensive line, Geno Smith is capitalizing on having maximum protection and doing a better job of finding the open man- which isn't a knock on him, it's what he is supposed to do. Right now Ryan Tannehill is much closer to a franchise qb IMO. I'm not saying he's perfect, but better than Geno at this point in their careers.

It's not even close right now. Tannehill is establishing himself as a very capable starting QB. Geno has a long way to go still.

Tannehill is definitely better but its not even a fair argument because Geno has only played 5 games.

Click to expand...

Another valid point. Geno still has a long way to go. It would be more fair to compare where he is when he's played as many games as Tannehill has. I am making a mental note to revisit this thread after week 5 of the 2014 season.

It's still way too early for either, I don't think Ryan has had as good of a game that geno had the other night but I don't think Ryan has had as bad of a game that geno had the week before. Long way to go for both.

And your boy Sanchez has never had a game as good as Geno's the other night...but he sure had worse that the week before :3w:

Click to expand...

That's not true, that's guy who had comebacks on the road in postseason so he's had better games and at his worst he was never worse than Geno the week before. That was a terrible performance by Geno at Tennessee.