SAAB 9-5 Review from Singapore

2007 SAAB 9-5 Aero Sedan 2.3 turbo petrol

Summary:

Faults:

Nothing really alarmingly that has to be highlighted as failures, however it’s good to share the following incident encountered, which involved replacing the Direct Injection Coil Pack.

After an ECU remap, done DIY with a tuning kit from a well recognized SAAB tuning specialist, the Check Engine Light came on. Diagnosis pointed to the failure of Direct Injection Coil Pack. It is believed that the increased performance after being tuned, places higher demands on the hardware being in good condition. The coil pack is a consumable, it will break sooner or later, even on a standard car. With the car tuned, this weakness on the coil pack was shown much earlier.

There’s more. The SAAB specified spark plugs were not used by the previous mechanic during servicing (this was discovered when the car was fixed at SAAB dealership here), and that might have shortened the lifespan of the coil pack. It’s very important that the right plugs are being used, as the engine management system uses them as sensors to diagnose every single combustion cycle. If the wrong plugs were used, the numbers coming to the ECU will be all wrong.

Lesson well learned - it is essential to attend to SAAB cars at SAAB specialists.

Otherwise, the usual weakness for car interiors in the tropical environment; both front door handles had the upholstery layer starting to peel off, and the previous owner deliberately peeled them completely off, exposing the plastic underneath. The right rear speaker grill came off slightly, but was easily fitted back into position. Certain panels becoming slightly loosened, but as said, not alarming given the current mileage; a little DIY effort will get them fixed.

Ironically, hard nasty plastics assembled together with ugly bolts and nuts of lesser cars, would survive this weather better. This is a common problem here for higher end cars. Leather stitching at the steering wheel however has come off slightly at 2 o’clock position, which is disappointing, as I expect better workmanship or design to be able to withstand wear better for an executive saloon, especially the performance Aero version.

I have previously owned Japanese cars known for their quality and reliability, and this is indeed true for my experience. For my SAAB 9-5 Aero, I couldn’t differentiate it from all the Japanese cars I had in this aspect.

General Comments:

I love this car.

It is clear that the basic SAAB 9-5 design goes way back 1997 (now known as OG9-5 by SAAB enthusiasts with the new generation out - NG9-5), but the gradual evolution and continuous improvement have honed the car to its optimum. While it may lack the bells, whistles and gizmos of the current executive cars, dollar for dollar, especially bought used, it offered far more on value that matters most, an all-round performance - generous power/torque, safe and entertaining handling for the driver, yet comfortable ride for the passengers, generous interior and boot space for the family, proven real world safety records.

And to top that, a SAAB 9-5 driver, especially in Aero guise, will often be well regarded on taste, and respected on the road on performance. It is unique and special, but not loud. It is not understood, yet not misunderstood. One steps out of the car into curious and probing eyes, and generally impressed when one shows them around the car, and explains to them about the logic of what is a SAAB 9-5.

Even the centrally mounted ignition was often misunderstood as an idiosyncrasy in design, but in truth, this is a repositioning of one of the hardest hardware systems in a vehicle from injuring the driver during a frontal crash situation. The night panel is another; switches off most lights in the vehicle, other than the most essential, so the driver has a much better vision of the road in a pitch dark environment. In essence, what one needs, a SAAB 9-5 provides; intelligent and wise engineering, what one doesn’t, a SAAB 9-5 does not even provide.

Being an Aero performance version, real world performance - the SAAB 9-5 Aero has plenty. With its rich mid range 350Nm, now tuned to 420Nm torque coming on song as early as 2200RPM, and with now tuned 270bhp, powering a relatively light body compared to the current generation of executive saloons, it is seriously quick in the real world, able to keep up easily with the GTIs, Audi Turbos and the Volvo Rs, not to mention easily outpacing all the BMW and Mercedes engine size to engine size. By the time BMW and Mercedes get serious with the bigger engine sizes and the AMGs, the prices are of another dimension.

The Sport button, once activated, brings immediately the Mr Hyde out of the clinical Doctor Jekyll, and everything turns manic. It is extremely safe and entertaining, overtaking slower traffic with the Sport mode, and after deactivating the Sport mode, everything is back to Doctor Jekyll, cool and calm cruising mode. But for most daily commutes, it can be an effortless and comfortable expressway muncher for the family, with respectable fuel consumption – 10km/l for 40% expressway 60% urban.

Interior wise, the leather seats are very comfortable, one of the best in the business. The infotainment system has very good sound, as it is a Harman Kardon system I believe, able to play MP3 discs or connected by aux inputs to portable music devices. However, the head unit user interface has some software bugs in my experience with MP3 discs – it always restarts the play list, playing the first song of the folder when the engine is restarted. Maybe it’s about the settings, and I have yet to figure this out.

Yes, the car is not perfect in its design, the only one cup holder at the front is small in size, and I lamented the lack of manual shifts at the gear lever for the 9-5 (SAAB 9-3 has it at the gear lever). Paddle shift is not very practical for tight turns; a combination of paddle and gear level manual shifting is needed for optimal use of the manual mode. It is better off leaving the gear in drive mode and let the car shift for the driver, which is smooth and therefore sufficient.

The SAAB dealer here is very friendly and helpful, so it adds to the joy of ownership. There is a big cult following of SAAB owners, so much to read and exchange on the Internet, one feels like part of a big harmonious family. No longer just a means of transport, no longer just expressions of personality and freedom, but a vehicle to be part of the family of SAAB, the maker and its dealership, service providers and owners.

Yet, it is hard to understand the emotional attachment to the car. A SAAB 9-5 Aero never tried to be a perfect car in truth, it’s a 15 year old design by now, despite many design improvements and 2 face lifts. The fact that it doesn’t feel obsolete today on the road speaks highly of the original engineering, ahead of its time when it was first conceived. Even the 2006 face lift, dubbed ‘Dame Edna’ by the old school SAAB enthusiasts, has worn down well, else it would have been dated in looks. Mine in silver, looks great and different, and does not have the ‘Dame Edna glasses’ look most prominently in darker body colors. But it has to say it is not the latest design, and does not have some of the creature comforts of its competition.

It has to be said, SAAB 9-5 was the last car design before a 100% GM ownership back then, and holds true to the DNA bloodline of the true blue SAAB design, in and out, with some component sharing, but crucially not all, with GM platforms, to realistically bring product cost down to a more competitive level.

So, to appreciate a SAAB 9-5, one tends to be wise and understated, and not tempted by the superficial and gimmicks, which bring no true value to the owning and driving. And buying it used with the value highly depreciated was one of the best decisions I have made. Still, a SAAB 9-5 Aero is a car one will either take great notice of and love it, or not at all.

In my case, I love my SAAB 9-5 Aero, and lived with its personality (flaws is another way to put it), and it is one of the most satisfying car ownership experiences, if not the most, I have had so far.

23rd Mar 2015, 03:23

8th Jul 2015, 06:19

Thanks for the kind words. Yes, I'm still with the Aero. Had a few skirmishes, hit at the back by a motorbike (rider fell asleep!), side swiped and ran by a bus and had to chase it down to sort the damages out. Also hit at the port side front by a colleague's Mitsubishi as he didn't see me when he moved out from his parking lot (I think that's a camouflage effect of silver vehicles). Drove to Thailand and back. I must say there's been a temptation to part with it on more than a few occasions, but nothing is better in value in the market for me. It's the best car I've ever owned.