Sanny takes five excellent waterproof jackets from Rab, Berghause, Keela, Haglofs & Dakine out in the rain to find the one that stands out.

Brand:

Hagloffs, Berghaus, Keela, Rab, Dakine

Product:

L.I.M 3, Vapor Storm Active, Saxon, Flashpoint, Calibre

From:

Hagloffs, Berghaus, Keela, Rab, Dakine

Price:

£85 - £270

Tested:

by Sanny for 2 months

By Sanny

Trying to find the right super lightweight waterproof jacket for mountain biking is no easy task. Aside from the almost overwhelming choice of jackets available, finding a waterproof and breathable jacket that can cope with a sweaty body working at full intensity in filthy conditions, is no small challenge. What works for walking, climbing and road biking doesn’t necessarily translate over to being a good jacket for mountain biking.

However, with the advent of adventure racing and multi activity disciplines, big name manufacturers in the outdoor industry have cottoned on to the fact that it’s possible to design and bring to market jackets that work well for a variety of disciplines and which just happen to meet the needs of mountain bikers.

The best waterproof is always the one you have with you, unless its bulk and weight mean you left it at home

So what makes a good, lightweight mountain biking jacket? First and foremost, being waterproof without giving you that horrible boil in the bag feeling that you can get while climbing in the rain is a given. Stopping the water getting in is of limited value if you are soaked in sweat. A hood (ideally one which fits over a helmet) is another key feature, although they tend to be a love ’em or hate ’em thing with most riders. Lightweight and packability are important – the best waterproof is always the one you have with you unless its bulk and weight mean you left it at home. Able to withstand the odd off and not costing the earth are key considerations also. With this in mind, we gathered five lightweight jackets together and put them through their paces.

Haglofs L.I.M. 3

Constructed from Gore Paclite®, the L.I.M 3 comes backed with Haglofs considerable experience in designing lightweight hard-shell jackets. The jacket comprises a full length, waterproof style zip with a concealed rain flap behind it. The chest features a single Napoleon pocket which will take a phone while the waist has a draw cord for adjustment while the tail is dropped for a bit of extra butt coverage. On the sleeves, there is a neat thumb loop feature which is an improvement on the previous version which tended to leave me with damp wrists, while the cuffs are elasticated but not so much as to make rolling up sleeves a chore. The hood design is excellent. It easily accommodates a helmet but can be cinched down to move easily with your head when helmetless. It features a stiffening peak which stops the hood flopping above your brow although I would have preferred to have a wire peak for when shoving it into my pack. Breathability is pretty good although not being a three layer shell, it did suffer a little more condensation than some of the other jackets in the test.

Overall: The L.I.M 3 is a good looking and well-fitting jacket that works both on and off the bike.

Berghaus Vapor Storm Active

Designed by their MtnHaus™ Design Team, the Vapor Storm Active Jacket is an interesting take on how to cope with condensation in a waterproof jacket. Constructed from three layer Gore Active® which is designed for fast and light activity, the jacket feature waterproof storm vents on the chest, side and back which result in this being the most breathable jacket on test without letting any water in. When the weather goes tits up, the slightly thicker material gives a real sense of protection. The waist is easily adjusted while the cuffs are elasticated with thumb loops. Personally, I would have preferred these to have Velcro adjusters as they were a little too loose for my liking, letting some water in when used in driving rain. The hood is adjustable with a stiffened peak although it doesn’t fit over a helmet. The back length was the shortest of the jackets tested while there is a single Napoleon pocket for valuables. Reflective highlights help the jacket stand out in headlights when used on the road.

Keela Saxon

Hailing from the North East of Scotland, the Keela Saxon is the cheapest jacket on test but it’s certainly not lacking in features. Constructed from 2.5 layer Flylight Aqua fabric, the breathability felt on a par with the Haglofs L.I.M. 3.The hood is helmet compatible and features a wired peak (whoop!). The full length zip is waterproof with a concealed rain flap behind it. The back is scooped which gives good additional coverage for your lower back. The cuffs feature both Velcro adjusters and thumb loops while there are two zipped hand pockets. Sensibly, Keela have avoided mesh pockets and used waterproof material for the inner pocket which helps eliminate water ingress while giving you somewhere to put your hands in cold and wet weather when off the bike. At the back, there is a horizontal storage pocket. I never used it but it can be flipped inside out and used to pack down the jacket. There’s even a Velcro flap to cinch down the hood when not in use. While having a slightly more generous cut than the other jackets on test, it never felt flappy in use.

Rab Flashpoint

Weighing in at a mere 186 grams, Rab’s Flashpoint is unbelievably light. Despite its wafer thin feel, the three layer Flashpoint ™ fabric proved completely waterproof throughout the duration of the test. Rab have a well-earned reputation for manufacturing jackets for the worst of conditions and the Flashpoint is no exception. It’s a full featured mountain jacket. The hood is helmet compatible while all seams are taped with the narrowest taping I have ever used. I suspect that the combination of this and the ultralight fabric contribute to the jacket’s excellent moisture management meaning that I would also happily use it instead of a windproof. As is the current fashion, the jacket features one Napoleon pocket while the waist can be adjusted via a single handed draw cord. Pack size using the supplied stuff sack is tiny. I have used lightweight windproof jackets that don’t pack down so small! The full length zip features and double flap internal rain flap. The cuffs feature Velcro adjusters while there is enough material to roll the sleeves up, if required. The grey and orange looks a little bit future world but the jacket also comes in orange.

Overall: Rab haven’t just raised the bar for lightweight jackets but smashed it. For the level of protection it offers in such a small pack size, there’s no excuse not to take it on every ride.

Dakine Caliber

Price: £129.99

Weight as tested: 433 grams

From: Dakine, dakine.com

Dakine have a well-earned reputation for well thought out riding kit. The Caliber is their take on what a mountain biking jacket should be. Constructed from a 2.5 layer unbranded waterproof fabric, the jacket was the heaviest on test. However, the heavier duty stretch fabric lent the jacket a real feeling of crash proof durability. The Caliber did a good job of keeping torrential rain out while the pit zips helped to stop things from getting too steamy. However, when worn against bare arms, the jacket had a bit of a tacky feel to it. The cut is slightly on the boxy side but the dropped hem at the back kept the rain off my lower back. The hood is helmet compatible although felt a little basic compared to the other jackets on test, opting for a Velcro volume adjuster. Having hand pockets, albeit mesh lined ones, was a welcome feature. However, for my six foot one frame, the arms were cut a bit on the short side leaving me with partially exposed wrists and ultimately damp cuffs. If your arms are less orangutan than mine, this shouldn’t be a problem though.

Overall: A good effort from Dakine at a reasonable price. Just make sure you try for fit before parting with your hard earned queenie vouchers.

Verdict

Of the five jackets we tested, none struck a bum note. All have their strengths and we would happily commend all of them for your consideration. It’s great to see that manufacturers have really upped their game and are now making jackets that meet the exacting demands of mountain bikers. Drawing on hood designs pioneered and perfected in the alpine climbing sector, cutting fabric so as to reduce wind flap and employing dropped tail designs mean that we mountain bikers now have a real embarrassment of choice when it comes to keeping the rain out.

If you want the ultimate in durability and don’t mind the extra weight, the Dakine Caliber is an excellent choice. For breathability, the combination of Gore Active™ and clever venting design means that the Berghaus Vapor Storm should be on your list. The Haglofs L.I.M 3 is proof that the Swedes really know their onions when it comes to designing a jacket for biking. Were it to come in Gore Active™ , it would be the clear winner of the test.

Which leaves us with two to choose from. At a mere £84.95, the level of performance on offer from the Keela Saxon is astounding. To have so many useful features crammed into such a well performing jacket had me double checking the price. The Rab Flashlight is breathable, completely waterproof , incredibly light and packs down to a tiny size. It edges the Keela in terms of overall performance although the Keela feels that bit more durable. As such, I’m going to break with tradition and award the Singletrack recommended award to both the Keela Saxon and the Rab Flashlight.

Thanks for the comments. I have to say I disgree about the jackets making you look like snowboarder though. All of the jackets on test worked well at keeping the wind and rain off. While the styling may not be to everyone’s taste, they all work effectively which for me is the most important consideration.

As for Paramo, I didn’t consider them due to their generally higher weight and bulk but will look to try one in the future.

PFC is definitely a concern. While there are alternative reproofing products out there, firms like haglofs are working on alternatives that are just as effective in their eyes. Personally, I now use non PFC based proofers with real success. Look out for an upcoming test.

Flashlight? Yup, guilty. Brain fart on my part!

No Endura MTR as it doesn’t feature a hood unless you mean the MT 500 perhaps? If that is the one with the holes in the hood, I tried one previously and was somewhat underwhelmed by the hood design and general cut of the garment.

Perhaps you could include a Vulpine jacket in your next test…..I’m summoning up the bottle to wear one of mine off road riding as I have been resorting to my Paramo Fuera windproof even in the rain as I just can’t stand any even eVent boil in the bag jackets any more…..I’m soaked with sweat so may as well dry faster in the windproof and not get as sweaty. Worn the Vulpine in some soak you to the skin drizzle road rides and was a hell of a lot more comfortable just know I’m going to have an off wearing it for MTB

I think when it comes to cost, how often you fall off is a consideration. I guess the logic is that it is better to rear a cheap jacket than a dear one. Mind you, one of the recommended jackets is only £85. Can you get anything cheaper that is anywhere near as good? If you can, I’d love to know what it is. With waterproofs, paying more does make a difference in terms of performance and comfort. There are plenty of ways to fix Gore or eVent jackets from Gorilla Tape to dedicated patch kits so a rip isn’t the end of the world.

It’s funny how we worry about tearing a jacket but personally I’m more concerned about scratching a stanchion on my forks!