*Rookie of the Year, NL MVP in 2007 (also finished 2 ,3, 5 in this time frame), 2x All Star, Silver Slugger

Jim Thome (2003-2005) = 5.9, 3.7, 0.0 = 9.6

*Finished 4th in MVP for the 2003 season, named an All Star in 2004

Personally, I’ll go with Jimmy Rollins. He played in red pinstripes for the entire decade, through the ups & downs, thick & thin, etc. We know how bad the Phillies were when Rollins first came up to the majors, but when I think of the rebound of Phillies baseball, I picture Jimmy Rollins.