I've been trying for a little bit, and as far as I can tell it MAY BE possible if you get the Icecrown brain room so you only have 1 portal phase. It is very difficult to get the perfect RNG so you aren't getting stunned constantly from black plague.

Also have to hope sara doesn't blast you to 4 sanity, or even make you insane as soon as you get to phase 2.

Then if you manage to get the phase 3, you have to have your pet tank everything and hopefully you can aoe the adds down when 3 become empowered. Which I think is 90k healing per second to all the adds. All while not going insane.

Don't have a hunter but I have a concept in mind for doing this as Warlock. It seems fairly RNG that sometimes you get MCed before portals and sometimes it stops at 4 sanity and you get to actually have an attempt. I'm pretty sure with *amazing* RNG that it will be doable by the end of this tier as people hit into the 540 or higher ilvls with heroics and 5.3 upgrades.

Note that the amazing RNG I refer to regards you'd have to get the sanity to stop at 4 and then when you enter the portal room you'd have to get all of the skulls in places where you can avoid them without taking a single tick, often one of them will be right in front of you as you portal in and you'll be instantly MCed (but not always). Following all of that you'll have to port out and clean any tentacles still alive while dpsing down immortals, and do an additional 12mil damage to yogg for the kill.

I think it'll be easiest to tank the immortal guardians yourself and have your pet pull the marked ones off of you as they get marked, a guardian at 1hp does very minimal damage.

Off topic: This thread has the most incredibly misleading title I've seen in my history with mmo-champion.

Don't have a hunter but I have a concept in mind for doing this as Warlock. It seems fairly RNG that sometimes you get MCed before portals and sometimes it stops at 4 sanity and you get to actually have an attempt. I'm pretty sure with *amazing* RNG that it will be doable by the end of this tier as people hit into the 540 or higher ilvls with heroics and 5.3 upgrades.

Note that the amazing RNG I refer to regards you'd have to get the sanity to stop at 4 and then when you enter the portal room you'd have to get all of the skulls in places where you can avoid them without taking a single tick, often one of them will be right in front of you as you portal in and you'll be instantly MCed (but not always). Following all of that you'll have to port out and clean any tentacles still alive while dpsing down immortals, and do an additional 12mil damage to yogg for the kill.

I think it'll be easiest to tank the immortal guardians yourself and have your pet pull the marked ones off of you as they get marked, a guardian at 1hp does very minimal damage.

Off topic: This thread has the most incredibly misleading title I've seen in my history with mmo-champion.

Oh really? Hunter forums... Not in Raid and Dungeon nor in World first section.

Definitely doable. I pushed phase 3 after 3 attempts of trying last tier. When you get to 40-28 sanity pop deterrence, shouldn't go any lower than that. The brain room typically took me 2 rounds to get through, and that was one of the challenging parts since I'm godawful at avoiding sanity loss in the portals. Once you push it to phase 3, dealing with the remaining tentacles and the new adds is pretty overwhelming to start. If you get that part down though, you should be able to beat the fight provided you are able to avoid sanity loss from lunatic gaze. T15 gear will make this last part easier.