Schools No Longer as Eager To Accept Used Computers

In Linda Griffin's
computer science classes in Jacksonville, N.C., high school students
learn how to program, repair, and rebuild personal computers—all
thanks to organizations that have donated used computer equipment to
the Onslow County school district's vocational education
department.

The program has worked well on two fronts, Ms. Griffin says. Not
only does it give students a great opportunity to learn a marketable
skill, but in its three- year history, it also has provided the
20,000-student district with about 600 much-needed computers.

"We had an opportunity to get a lot of computers into the classrooms
quickly," the teacher said.

Still, donated computers are not always a boon to districts,
according to some technology experts. Many schools find that they
cannot use the older, outdated equipment that businesses and
individuals want to give them, or that the cost of repairing and
maintaining older technology is too high.

"The cost of free equipment is not free," said Keith R. Krueger, the
executive director of the Consortium for School Networking, or CoSN, an
education technology advocacy organization based in Washington. "There
is no free lunch with donated computers."

Districts need to take into consideration what CoSN calls the "total
cost of ownership," Mr. Krueger said. That term refers to factors such
as the price of replacement parts to maintain and upgrade the machines,
the time it takes to work on the computers, and the salaries of the
technicians who will do that work.

And many times, replacement parts are not available for donated
machines. So schools are left with computers they simply cannot use and
have to put in a warehouse or dispose of, at additional expense, Mr.
Krueger said.

Potential Problems

With so much attention having been paid to educational technology in
recent years—including an influx of funding, such as that
available through the federal E-rate program—many schools have
updated their computers and are using new software that won't run on
older systems, said Mr. Krueger.

Because of that, donated equipment may not be compatible with a
school system's network of computers, he said.

It was just such a combination of problems that led to the downfall
of what once was a successful computer-recycling program in Indiana. In
1992, the Central Indiana Educational Service Center, a branch of the
state department of education, started Buddy Up With Education.

Between 1992 and 1998, the program accepted 3,600 donated computers,
upgraded them, and then sold the machines to schools at a cut rate. But
then schools stopped buying the refurbished machines, said Marlene
Schick, who directed the program. "Schools wanted faster systems," she
said.

Yet, even though the schools don't want the older equipment, and the
program has been out of business for almost four years, donors are
still knocking on her door. "I get three or four phone calls a week"
from businesses or individuals wanting to donate computers, Ms. Schick
said.

Businesses have a financial incentive to donate machines, education
technology experts point out, because they can receive a federal tax
deduction for giving schools computers that are no more than 3 years
old.

It's too bad when schools are put in the situation of having "to run
on donated equipment," said Ann Lee Flynn, the director of education
technology for the National School Boards Association in Alexandria,
Va.

And refusing the gifts of eager donors can put schools in sticky
situations politically, she said.

"If a district tells a generous donor 'no,' you can get a backlash"
when the time comes to ask the community for money for technology, Ms.
Flynn said. Such donors, who may not know of the schools' real needs,
could question the district's need for more technology funding when
school leaders refuse free equipment.

To complicate matters further, schools are sometimes pressured by
their district school boards into accepting the donations, Mr. Krueger
added. "We see too many schools that tell us horror stories about
warehouses full of old, donated equipment they can't use, but
politically they had to accept," he said.

Both Ms. Flynn and Mr. Krueger agree that it is vital for districts
to have clear policies on what types of donated technology the district
will accept.

For instance, Ms. Flynn said that districts need to keep a close eye
on their technology inventories and know how each machine is being
used. "It is critical for a district to proactively develop a plan so
they have a good way of saying 'Thanks, but no thanks' without being
offensive," Ms. Flynn said.

Beyond that, Mr. Krueger suggested that schools outline the minimum
specifications for the equipment they'll accept, and be clear about how
they are going to use the technology.

"Schools are always looking for a good deal," he said. "But we want
to make sure [they] think through strategically what the deal is."

One school district that has found itself in the position of turning
away offers for donated computers is the suburban Henrico County
district outside Richmond, Va.

"For the most part, what we need is pretty modern, state-of-the-art
stuff," said Charles K. Stallard, the director of technology for the
43,000-student district.

After putting in place an $18.6 million technology initiative this
school year that supplied high school students in the district with
iBooks, the Macintosh version of a laptop, the district found that it
had a surplus of older computers.

So district officials decided to give the equipment to low-income
families in the district. According to Mr. Stallard, 3,500 computers
have been given to parents.

Built-In Help Desk

In Portland, Ore., an organization called Students Repairing Used
Technology Alliance, or StRUT, acts as a warehouse for donated
computers. Teachers from across the state drive to Portland, sometimes
in tractor trailers, to stock up on the equipment and take it back to
their schools, where students then refurbish the machines, said Greg
Sampson, the executive director of the program.

Mr. Sampson warned that when teachers use donated computers, one of
their first responsibilities is to make sure that any personal
information stored on the computer hard drives by the previous owners
is deleted. Some of the donated computers come from state agencies,
doctors, and lawyers, said Mr. Sampson, and could contain private
records and documents. That's why StRUT sends out reminders every three
months to all of the teachers who have picked up donated computers to
wipe the hard drives clean.

The cost of upgrading the systems—a concern raised by Mr.
Krueger of CoSN—is also a consideration, said Madeline Tucker,
one of the directors of the Onslow County program in North
Carolina.

But she said it helps that students are able to cannibalize parts
from other computers. For example, one computer may have a fine CD-ROM
drive, but no other working components, she said.

Plus, the students in Onslow County are taking their knowledge of
computers to do more than just repair old machines. This spring, a
group of Ms. Griffin's present and former students are studying for A+
Certification, a national credential for computer technicians that is
highly useful for anyone hoping to enter the information technology
workforce.

The computer sciences curriculum that the Onslow County vocational
education department uses is provided by ExplorNet Computer Recycling,
based in Raleigh, N.C. Currently, 165 schools in North Carolina and 60
schools in Arkansas, Mississippi, North Dakota, and South Dakota are
using the ExplorNet curriculum, said Clayton Henkel, a spokesman for
the nonprofit group.

Using what they've learned through the ExplorNet curriculum,
students are able to put their newly acquired technical knowledge to
use in the schools.

Mr. Henkel said Onslow County teachers will often pop into the
computer technology classes and say, "'My hard drive is
crashing—can I borrow a couple of your students?'"

Coverage of technology is supported in part by the William and
Flora Hewlett Foundation.

Explornet, a nonprofit
dedicated to improving technology-based learning in America’s
schools, runs a Computer Recycling
Project, a "curriculum [that] teaches students how to upgrade these
"junk" computers to modern multimedia machines as well as how to build
new machines." (Use the pull-down menu at top left, and the the
left-hand margin links, to find specific information for participating
states.)

Ground Rules for Posting
We encourage lively debate, but please be respectful of others. Profanity and personal attacks are prohibited. By commenting, you are agreeing to abide by our user agreement.
All comments are public.