“SJ, you’ve gone on some talk shows recently, said the role of Samantha could be recast, and you’ve offered the part to two other talks show hosts — Ellen DeGeneres and Stephen Colbert,” Cohen said. “What? I don’t see it.”

So naturally, Cohen threw on a wig and “auditioned” for the part with Parker by acting out a scene from Season 5 of Sex and the City.

After the audition, Cohen brought up the possibility of Sharon Stone playing Samantha. Parker said he wasn’t the first to suggest that and said it was a really interesting idea. But in the end, she said, the part belongs to Cohen.

“I think you’re more suited than Stephen Colbert, and I don’t think Ellen’s really interested. In fact, I think she passed. So the part, by default, is yours,” Parker said.

Watch What Happens Live with Andy Cohen airs Sun. to Thurs. at 11 p.m. on Bravo.

Check out what Andy Cohen said about Omarosa’s move from the White House to the Celebrity Big Brother house: