Epilogue

Epilogue

Epilogue

Epilogue

Epilogue

Epilogue

Summary

Some time later, the Thibaults meet Coss and Watanabe
in Lucca, a small city in Italy where opera composer Giacomo Puccini
was born. The Thibaults have come to attend the wedding of Coss
and Watanabe. The narrator tells us that Edith Thibault, in contrast
to the other three, “still believed she was lucky.” Coss says twice
that she is happy, and she kisses Watanabe.

The two men go off to see if they can find a bar. Leaving
his wife, Thibault feels a moment of panic. Watanabe tells Thibault
that these days he mainly translates books so that he has plenty
of time to attend Coss’s rehearsals. Watanabe and Coss will live
in Milan. Watanabe stops and tells Thibault that not one of the
newspapers he has read mentioned the two female terrorists. He wonders
if the same was true in the French papers. Thibault says it was.
Watanabe has written to the newspapers asking them to correct the
mistake, but none of them have. Watanabe says it is almost as if
Carmen and Beatriz “never existed.”

Watanabe says that when he called Iglesias and told him
about his marriage to Coss, Iglesias advised him not rush into anything. But
Watanabe says he didn’t want to wait. Thibault tells Watanabe he
was right to marry, but privately he begins to suspect that Watanabe
and Carmen were lovers. Thibault remembers how Carmen’s face would
brighten whenever she saw Watanabe. Thibault can’t get Carmen’s
face out of his mind. Watanabe says that when he hears Coss sing,
he thinks well of the world. Thibault says out loud, “She is a beautiful
girl.” It is not clear whether he means Carmen or Coss.

The narrator says that Thibault feels sure that Watanabe
and Coss had married for “the love of each other and the love of
all the people they remembered.” As Coss and Mrs. Thibault come
into view and extend their arms, Thibault is overcome with joy.

Analysis

Most epilogues tie up loose ends, but this one raises
more questions than it answers. Coss and Watanabe, who have both
lost their lovers, marry each other. It is unclear whether they
are happy, or whether they truly love each other. Coss says twice
that she loves Watanabe, as if she is trying to convince herself.
And something about the way Watanabe protests that he didn’t want
to wait to marry Coss makes Thibault suddenly suspect that Watanabe
and Carmen were lovers.

Still, it is possible that Watanabe and Coss have found
happiness together; the novel is ambiguous on this point. Certainly,
throughout the novel Patchett has suggested that true love is often
a product of chance and circumstance. Watanabe only fell in love
with Carmen, and Hosokawa with Coss, because of the bizarre situation
that threw them together. Now that Watanabe and Coss have been brought
together by tragedy; perhaps they have truly fallen in love.