Supernatural Recap: The Many Unexpected Faces of Sam Winchester

Forget Game of Thrones‘ Hall of Faces. Our gallery of the best moments from Thursday night’s Supernaturalis a parade of visages, from a sexed-up Sam to a surprised Sam to a shocked Sam. We also threw in a grotesque Lucifer, for good measure.

“Mamma Mia” — which felt like it should have been the season premiere, yes? — brought us several long-awaited scenes, including Sam’s reunion with his brother and his alive-again mother, who started to make an impression. (Perhaps like mom, we just needed some time to adjust to her resurrection?)