Trouble logging in?If you can't remember your password or are having trouble logging in, you will have to reset your password. If you have trouble resetting your password (for example, if you lost access to the original email address), please do not start posting with a new account, as this is against the forum rules. If you create a temporary account, please contact us right away via Forum Support, and send us any information you can about your original account, such as the account name and any email address that may have been associated with it.

Leaning towards logia. Couple reasons. She doesn't seem cold when Usopp originally spots her and is shown without a coat. Caeser tells Law he knows about his plans because Monet was able to "transform and follow" him.. turn into snow and spy?

I actually really like the idea of a snow-snow fruit (I think that would be yuki yuki no mi in Japanese, right?). In a way, it makes a good alternative to an actual water logia, like the ice fruit did. And hey, even cooler is that means we'd finally be introduced to our first female logia user in the series!

And as for snow being similar to ice..... I don't really see a problem with it, seeing as we already have different powers based off the same base element like ground (sand/diamond/magma). But then again, I actually recall James making an argument about that very element in a previous thread, as well.

Quote:

Originally Posted by janipani

Monet could be real harpy not real human being and thus she can be logia type.

Don't think so. We saw her in a clearly human body during a brief flashback some chapters back. And the fact that she seems to have a DF power unrelated to her harpy body means that she most likely got modified by Law (like Brownbeard's crew did).

I would prefer this as well.
In case of a snow fruit, we would have to ask, where exactly there is the difference to the ice-fruit.

Though there is still another possibility: Since Cesar knows about how to get back a DF: What if Monet actually has the ice fruit, which originally belonged to Aokiji? She may just be using it differently.

What if Monet actually has the ice fruit, which originally belonged to Aokiji? She may just be using it differently.

I don't think this will be the case, either. Oda made it pretty clear in a past SBS that 2 of the same DF power couldn't exist at the same time (though artificial copies should be an exception). If that were really Aokiji's power, then that would mean that he'd have been killed by Akainu 2 years ago. However, we already know he's very much alive....

Snow-fruit could differ from ice-fruit in various ways. We have seen fire-fruit and lava-fruit too. Devil fruits seem not have any rule that prevents similar abilities existing, only thing matter is that theme changes, and these themes can be from nature as well as from technology.

Snow fruit could be about snow storms, snow walls and all type of snow as long it's under snow theme.

Ice theme is different, it can freeze things even though hardened snow could be seen as the same.

Oh, and Monet being a mystical zoan could definitely work. After all, there's a well-known spirit in Japanese mythology known as the "Yuki-Onna" (Snow Woman) that's obviously associated with winter. It could easily be a classified as a human-type fruit (like Sengoku's Buddha power).

^Fire is not Lava and Lava is not Fire. Lave can start fires but fires cannot create Lava. Snow, though, is nothing more than percipitated ice particles. They are not different themes, they are essentially the same (and considering the blizzards Aokiji has created, I am unclear why anyone is arguing that ice and snow is different).

At least as Logias. If Oda wanted to make Harpy a Snowwoman
Paramecia, then there might be some wiggle room. It would still be a little silly, bit it would make more sense than having an ice and snow logia.

^Fire is not Lava and Lava is not Fire. Lave can start fires but fires cannot create Lava. Snow, though, is nothing more than percipitated ice particles. They are not different themes, they are essentially the same (and considering the blizzards Aokiji has created, I am unclear why anyone is arguing that ice and snow is different).

At least as Logias. If Oda wanted to make Harpy a Snowwoman
Paramecia, then there might be some wiggle room. It would still be a little silly, bit it would make more sense than having an ice and snow logia.

I don't think this will be the case, either. Oda made it pretty clear in a past SBS that 2 of the same DF power couldn't exist at the same time (though artificial copies should be an exception). If that were really Aokiji's power, then that would mean that he'd have been killed by Akainu 2 years ago. However, we already know he's very much alive....

I was thinking more along the line that Aokiji stayed on this island and was killed by Caesar later.
We know that he survived Akainu, but we can't say for sure that he is still alive.

What if monet is snow harpy. Mind blown *booom*.
I noticed that you lads all argued if she has some kind of fruit and is a real harpy, but I think she is like mythical zoan snow harpy. Aka the harpy who lives in snowy areas.

It's reasonable to say he's just using tekkai/haki combo, prolly more so then an Iron DF user but his strength, toughness and stuff sticking to him could be explained via him being an iron type by having stuff gravitate towards him (rather then just as a result of his forgetfulness) due to him being a large mass of iron but tbh im not sure i got my concept right wen talking about gravitational pull etc but it would be cooler then hakki/tekkai imo.

I'm also rly interested in Law's plan now as well as Momosuke and what happened to him as at this point, those two things are still unclear and could be linked.

I'm not sure whether Oda will hav Law betray the SH yet or not, on one hand this would be the arc to do it in to set the tone for the NW but on the other hand it would make the SH seem too naive considering their 2 years of training and all that happened in the past.

Also the match ups seem like they're going to change again though I hope Zoro and co move on from the steel dragon, yes it would put Zoro above the samurai but it still doesn't show how he would cope vs NW adversaries since the dragon is some random fodder.

I'm also actually a little dissapointed that Sanji's leg broke, while I expect Vergo to be stronger then him I didn't expect Sanji to get injured like that so soon since he is part of the monster trio.