Hair care giant Pantene was all over the list, but did it nab the no. 1 spot?

Why it's great: Readers love that this product "never strips color" and "helps it to last between coloring treatments." In addition to that, readers say their "hair is so shiny and touchable" and they love they way it smells "like orange-cream candy." One reader sums it up saying, "I color my hair every two and a half months and I need a conditioner that keeps my hair looking vibrant. This conditioner does that. Not only does it prolong my hair color, but it also keeps my hair super shiny and smooth. It's a life saver!"