A Nashville judge has sided with Tennessee’s Achievement School District in the tussle over whether local school districts must share student contact information with charter networks under a new state law.

Chancellor Bill Young this week ordered Metropolitan Nashville Public Schools to turn over information requested by LEAD Public Schools, which operates two state-run schools in the city. The district has until March 16 to comply or appeal.

The ruling is a blow to local district leaders in both Nashville and Memphis, who have argued that a federal privacy law gives them discretion over who gets that information. They also contend that the intent of Tennessee’s new charter law, which passed last year, was that such information should not be used for marketing purposes.

Looking at the available guidances from the U.S. Department of Education on student privacy and FERPA (the Family Educational Rights and Privacy Act) does not reveal any guidance where disclosure to Charter schools appears to have been specifically addressed. PogoWasRight.org has sent an inquiry to U.S. Department of Education asking if there has ever been a specific guidance on this topic.

If FERPA does require disclosure, then I would think that it should trump any state laws to the contrary under the supremacy clause of the constitution, but I think we need to bring in some FERPA experts if DOE indicates that FERPA does require sharing or disclosure.