Wednesday, October 9, 2013

Blood Wyne (Otherworld #9) by Yasmine Galenorn

Menolly and Nerissa confirm their relationship in this
book, growing closer than ever before despite the changes stalking Nerissa’s
live – and despite the pressures pushing in on Menolly, including her vampire
“daughter” requiring more of her attention.

There’s a vampire serial killer stalking women which in
turn flares up human hatred against vampires. There’s also a vampire election
coming up and the eldest child of the Blood Wyne, the oldest vampire, the
vampire queen, is in the city and is determined to set what the results of that
election will be.

He also has designs on Menolly herself.

I am torn a little here on the story. On the one hand I
have the same problem I’ve had with these books since the very first – there’s
a huge world here, a huge number of characters and all of them seem to have
their own storylines that WILL get space in the main book (rather than spin off
series of their own). Similarly, the main characters aren’t just focused on the
main storyline – other things happen to divide their attention, like Delilah
and the Autumn Lord and Chase or Camille and her father and the Moon Mother.

This book focuses on a main character, Menolly, but the story is a departure
from the focus on Shadow Wing and the impending invasion. Instead we focus on
vampire politics, a serial killer and developing the world building of the
vampires with a side order of relationship issues and the Wayfarer bar. Morio,
Camille, Vanzir, Smoky, Chase and the Demon underground all have their own
storylines developed as well. And pretty much none of it relates to Shadow Wing
or the war.

And this is where the being torn comes in. Part of me wants to complain about
the distraction, and certainly I do question whether it’s necessary for us to
have Chase and his new abilities taking up space or Smoky having his issue with
his father. I’m not sure they add anything to the story except be more clutter
underfoot.

But part of me also acknowledges that the reason why all
the characters of this series are as strong, as fully fleshed and as
identifiable as they are is the effort the author puts in to making sure that
every character has a life of their own – which, by necessity, means they have
stories of their own (but do we have to see them all?) And part of the reason
why the world is so rich and compelling and complete is because it has all of
these elements that do intrude into their lives rather than there just being
one thing happening. It does make the world real – after all, how often can we
focus on one issue in our lives and the rest of the world go away? Why should
Menolly, a vampire, be able to focus on the war with Shadow-wing and completely
ignore the vampire world? Why should Smoky be able to act without dragon
politics ever imposing on his life? This really lets the world building tell
itself – we could have Menolly drily tell us the risks vampires face of losing
themselves – or we can see the a vampire face that very same, tragic fate.
There’s a lot of excellent world
building about politics, about vampires and about basic characterisation that
is expanded through experience rather than info-dump

It also helps that the pacing issues that have plagues
the series have been really cut. The action is much crisper, there’s much less
“preparation time” before each fight, the scenes move more smoothly, there’s
much less need to talk about unnecessary detail like which car people are
driving and why, or spend pages on people’s clothes or food or gardening and
everyone recapping each other is taken as read rather than having to be spelled
out every time. The story moves now, making distractions a whole lot more
tolerable – and making this book one that maintained tension, action and flow
throughout. It’s really encouraging to me that each book is getting better at
this – and that this book had a good, exciting story with multiple elements,
expanded world building and parallel storylines and handled them all with
excellent balance between speed, description and exposition.

Ok, there are still some things that could have moved
faster and there are storylines I think are unnecessary (Chase, Smoky,
Morio/Menolly, even the Demon Underground), but it’s a vast improvement and the
series continues to head upwards.

I keep worrying about Menolly’s depiction as a bisexual
woman - I’m always tense, waiting for the other shoe to drop, waiting for her
to declare it over with Nerissa and then focus on men, waiting for her to find
a man who is her real, really true love to take Nerissa’s place, waiting for
Nerissa to become second, third or even be completely banished from Menolly’s
affections while she focuses on men.

And it’s unfair. I fear these things because this is a pattern of how I’ve seen
bisexuality depicted in so many Urban Fantasy books – (and TV shows) –
bisexuals have inferior, lesser relationships with people of the same gender
(or have none at all – their relationships with the same gender either being
pre-story or being entirely potential rather than actual) before settling down
with a proper, acceptable “real” opposite gender love interest; it’s a pattern
that happens a lot. However, while I recognise the trope, it’s also deeply
unfair to judge Menolly by that standard

Menolly loves Nerissa, this she makes clear over and over
again and we have some explicit sex scenes this book that are on par with the
scenes we have seen with the opposite sex pairings. Yes, Nerissa isn’t as close
to Menolly as Delilah and Camille are to their love interests, and Menolly does
now have a male love interest vying for her affections, but Menolly is
abundantly clear – Nerissa is the woman she loves, Nerissa is the person who
matters most to her, Nerissa is the woman she wishes to marry and spend her
life with.

We have some other lesbian characters as well – and they
are well rounded and nuanced characters in their own right; one thing this
series is very good at is making sure that all the characters are fleshed out
sufficiently, even with such a huge cast, every member of that cast will have a
personality (if anything it can be a problem to the long windedness). There was
an issue of predation and evil about them, but it is strongly ameliorated by
the sheer humanity of the characters. I could have done without Menolly
describing how very hot she found her sister, Camille that was all kinds of icky.

That same humanity applies to the number of excellent
female characters in the series. This continues to be one of the series
strongest points, the sheer number of female characters, the different ways
each are portrayed, the different power and ways of expressing strength each
have, even among the sisters – but when we bring in Iris and Nerissa and Sharah
and even Sassy – the plethora of women in this series is excellent. And they
relate to each other – as siblings as friends as lovers, even as semi-competing
love interests – they relate to each other and do not hate each other. With so
many “there can only be one strong female character!” out there, this is a
blessed relief. We had a series of female prostitutes murdered which is so
often a trope in fiction – but also a tragic reflection of reality – and
Menolly and Chase both respected and grieved for the women, there was no victim
blaming, no shaming of them, no treating their murders as less.

But then we have the Vanzir issue. I despise the trope of
sexual assault and rape being forced by the woo-woo, no matter how contrite the
perpetrator is after the fact. It didn’t add anything necessary to the story or
characterisations and ended up continuing the trope of “he just couldn’t help
it” that I didn’t appreciate

I’m less enthralled with the POC – as I mentioned, there
are an absolutely huge number of characters in this book and Morio is the only
prominent POC (Sassy’s companion is also a WOC, but she is a servant, a minor
character and dead so, yeah not really adding there). He’s also often the least
present of Camille’s husbands – but I will say that that was resolved in this
book, he was more of the focus, was closest to Camille and the main story for
the longest and is developing a storyline in his own right.

I think I want to rate this book 3.75 fangs, which is
annoying because I can’t do that. I think it was an improvement on the last
book which I gave a 3.5 fang rating to. I think it flowed better, I think it
worked better. But I also think it was too distracted, too rife with tangents
and had a couple of dubious issues for me to be comfortable giving it a 4 fang
rating. I am torn – this is a good book, it’s a great book, but it didn’t quite
pull me up to the next notch, but it didn’t miss it by much and by the feel of
the series, the next book is going to clinch it.