Sister Cathey DeSantis heads the Detroit Catholic Pastoral Alliance, a coalition of 14 churches in the city. She said the Archdiocese and its advisors aren’t taking into account “what the people in the pews are capable of.”

“It is, according to canon law, very permissible to have lay administration in a parish. But our Archbishop doesn’t want that to happen,” DeSantis said.

DeSantis said the recommendations process was a “flawed” one that looked solely at staffing and financing issues.

"There’s a lot of talk about outreach," she said. "But that outreach doesn’t happen without a worshipping community that comes together, that feels a commitment to each other and to the place where they are. And those outreach programs grow from that.”

Archbishop Allen Vigneron is expected to announce final closure decisions early next year.