The rantings of a Public Defender constantly fighting against society's pervasive Police Industrial Complex. Enjoy the unique perspective of one whose life's work is to fight the system through the system.

About me

Saturday, July 17, 2010

Connect the Dots

I haven't posted in a long time, so let me make a short post to observe a few "connect the dots" observations - I want to connect two pieces of news and sort of juxtapose them, so that people can draw their own conclusions.

In both Gastello and Low the defendants were charged with a statute that California has called Penal Code section 4573. In essence, it is illegal to bring drugs into a jail. But what if a person is arrested, and has drugs on them, and THEY are brought to a jail? Well, in the intake area of pretty much all jail facilities in Californi, there is a sign that advises the defendant of PC 4573, and essentially tells the defendant that he has to fess up that he has drugs, or else he faces a straight felony when the deputies find them.

In California, possession of marijuana is a misdemeanor, unless it's for sale. Possession of methamphetamine can be a misdemeanor, at the DA's discretion. Possession of cacaine is a stright felony. But a defendant facing a charge of simple possession of any drug, even cocaine, can often get into PC 1000 diversion, or Prop. 36, or even drug court, depending on his/her record. Most simple possession cases do not result in prison time, not even for 3rd strikers. Remember, I said most simple possession cases - some still get prison based on their prior strikes, their records, other charges, etc. It all depends on the facts, the DDA, the court, the temperature outside, the relative humidity, the defendant correctly guessing the number of angels that can dance on the head of a pin, etc. But not so with a PC 4573 charge. That is a straight felony for which there is no diversion, or Prop. 36. Maybe drug court. But certainly a felony that cannot be reduced to a misdemeanor at some point. Thus, having a simple possession charge amped up to a stright felony PC 4573 charge can be a serious issue. In Low, the defendant lied to the cop, claiming that he had no drugs on him. A search found the drugs. In Gastello the defendant said nothing, after having been Mirandized at some point, and the drugs were found in a search. In both cases the defendants were convicted on straight felonies. Low was the longer opinion, dealing with the various Constitutional and statutory issues. Gastello is much shorter and pretty applies Low.

In both the Low and Gastello cases the California Supreme Court, the George court, discussed the Fifth Amendment right to remain silent, and the idea that neither of the defendants "voluntarily" went to jail. Both defendants would much rather have been somewhere else. Thus, they didn't "bring drugs into a jail" - they were brought to jail while possessing drugs. The George court ruled against both Gastello and Low, and pretty much gave short shrift to the Fifth Amendment argument. In Gastello, in fact, the better of the two cases (he remained silent, after all), the George court simply could not understand how the Fifth Amendment was implicated at all. They acted as if they had never heard of the "cruel trilemma" - the basis of Miranda. The "cruel trilemma" is as follows: A defendant has three choices when questioned by the police. 1) He can remain silent, and be thought guilty, because if he wasn't guilty he would have said something, 2) He can confess, thereby proving his guilt, or 3) He can lie, which will likely convict him as well, because his lies will be found out. This is one of the bases for the 5th Amendment and for Miranda. Like it or hate it, it is blackletter law. Instead, the Goerge court said that the defendant was correctly prosecuted for PC 4573 BECAUSE he remained silent - a "nontestimonial act." Beg pardon? His REFUSAL to confess his guilt was a "nontestimonial act" for which he could be prosecuted? Wow - that really turns the law on its head, huh?

The George court simply couldn't understand how the Fifth Amendment was implicated at all. I mean, if the defendant has drugs on him, and reads that sign, all he has to do at that point, to prevent a charge of PC 4573, is to confess to the cops that he has drugs. And, wallah, there can be no PC 4573 charge. Wow, I never thought of that. What a great idea. Next time, I will advise my client who faces a potential crime and who is afraid of the police charging him with a more serious crime to confess his crime to the police and waive his Miranda rights. That way, he won't have to worry about new charges. And I guess then I can wait to be disbarred or something.

Is the George court really this dumb? The only way to prevent a PC 4573 charge is to confess, and that doesn't implicate the Fifth Amendment? At least one unanimous appellate court thought it did. Oh, and of seven members on the Goerge court, guess how many dissented. None. Yeah, I guess that happens when everyone uses the same law clerks. Note that both Gastello and Low were written by the court's most conservative member, J. Baxter. But George gets to assign the opinion to whomever he wants, since the opinion was unanimous. And I am sure that George also had some influence on the opinion, again because it was unanimous.

Chief Justice George announced his retirement now so that Governor Arnold Schwarzenegger, a guy with the lowest approval ratings ever (even lower than Gray Davis before his recall), can name his replacement. I suppose that this is just in case Jerry Brown, the Democrat who put Rose Bird onto the court, wins over Meg Whitman in November (that race is a tossup at this point). It is no wonder that California's judiciary, especially it Supreme Court, has become the laughingstock of the free world. The trial judges in California hand out horribly punitive sentences, then the appellate court and the California Supreme Court simply affirms them, all the while the prison system is in tatters due to massive growth. Meanwhile, the Legislature dithers and passes tougher and tougher laws with longer and longer sentences, with the electorate every once in awhile one-upping them. It is no wonder that our criminal justice system has become the shame of the free world.

So, connect the dots. Chief Justice George is retiring, and the newspapers say he is a really great guy because he helped convict the Hillside Strangler. But many of his court's opinions, especially many of his court's recent opinions, really suck and are pretty much devoid of honest reasoning. Yeah, I suppose that many in California will really miss Chief Justice George. I won't.

26 comments:

I am Independent Escort Girl offer independent Escort Service in Luck now. I am a stunning Luck now Escort girl introduced with all the desire and differentiation demand of gentlemen or executive the very well and always dress, complementary completing and spoiling myself so that I can provide you the best time of your vitality. I am well-educated, cultured and well- trained, have good manners and approach, being a Model, I always dress elegantly and discerning to handle any function. I have a big collection of beautiful attractive intimate apparel, stockings and erotic dress for secret moments.

Samika Das is most alive Independent Delhi escorts. Samika is just a dream come true for those of you who would like an unutterably hot blonde for the evening, she is so hot and spicy that all are sure to melt in her bearing. She has an perfectly beautiful body with long blonde hair and a very slim and bronzed figure but it is her looks that steal the show as she is just so knock-out lovely that she will never fail to be noticed. Independent Goa escorts. Samika is just a dream come true for those of you who would like an indescribably hot blonde for the evening, she is so hot and spicy that all are sure to melt in her bearing. She has an absolutely gorgeous body with long blonde hair and a very slim and tanned figure but it is her looks that steal the show as she is just so knock-out lovely that she will never fail to be detected.See other Website of my partners:Delhi EscortsDelhi Escort ServiceDelhi Escort AgencyDelhi Escorts ServiceIndependent Delhi EscortEscorts In Delhi

My name is Adhisa, High Class Independent Goa Escort for the Classy and discreet men. I live in Goa. I also travel between Goa, and Daman. I am cute and lovely with face and my charming body. My beautiful personality attract every man, they want to be with me for some fun and personal instants. If you are a businessman or tourist, staying in any hotel and want some for for companionship as you are alone while travelling, which I understand well and i think of you with full of my humor.See other Website of my partners:Goa EscortsGoa Escort ServiceGoa EscortGoa Escorts AgencyIndependent Goa EscortsEscort In Goa

I am Tripti Mahate one of the expert and real Mumbai escorts doing people who wish to meet Beautiful and glamorous friend. I am a complete share for everything you need from a lovable and reasonable partner. My professional and excited company is for those who are going through a tough phase of life and want to get rid of it. My services are over delight for high-profile and reasonable gentlemen. I am young and independent. I understand your impressions and respect your opinions. My life is committed to cater you in the most enchanting way. I am here just to heal you and keep you intelligent and sound.See My Partners website for future bookings:Mumbai EscortsIndependent Mumbai Escorts Mumbai Escorts AgencyEscorts In MumbaiMumbai EscortMumbai Escorts Service

Akshra Shah is independent escort in Delhi. A tremendous experience that can entice every man toward her. A popular Delhi escort lady among those guys who likes you organic charm. Let me present you about a fantastic organic charm king Akshra. I am Akshra and I am a top quality Escorts in Delhi. I am currently living in Delhi itself and offering my high-class Service to top quality guys. I am a wishful model and came to Delhi for my model Service does. I have been offering my Escort Services in Delhi since last 6 several weeks and now I am a very expert Delhi model Escorts lady and know what the customer’s considerations are and what customer may want to meet a outstanding Escort strategy.Kindly Visit My Friends Websites:Delhi EscortsDelhi Escort serviceDelhi Escorts AgencyEscorts In DelhiDelhi EscortIndependent Delhi Escort

I am a independent escorts in jaipur and want to live it on sharpness. As from my puerility i would love to take take a chance and specially with another woman. So in that case this is the only way for me to get new adventure and make love in my life. yeah and believe me I am very much warm from these life and making it much better and the best thing of remaining in such professing is that you are able to get love from different people and the best thing is they are concerned in you. In such case being an independent escort in jaipur is not that bad.Please check out my partner’s website for more entertainment: Jaipur EscortsJaipur Escort ServiceJaipur Escorts AgencyEscorts In JaipurJaipur EscortIndependent Jaipur Escort

My name is Gitika and i am a independent escorts in Mumbai and I am here who would be happy to convince all your contacts and change things as per your demand. So what are you thinking just come to me and have lots of fun in your life. There are many people who would be happy and would able to do things as per require and for that you just have to come to me and being an independent call girls in Mumbai I would love to close to you and change your life.See My Partners website for future bookings:Mumbai EscortsEscorts In MumbaiMumbai EscortMumbai Escorts serviceIndependent Mumbai EscortsMumbai Escort Agency

Hi my name is Neeru. I am a 21 years hot and beautiful girl from Mumbai. I want to spend a excellent life so I want to make a lot of money and complete all my wishes. My naughty and bold behavior always behave to everyone and all the classmates want to friendship with me and they are always walk of life around me so I proud on my beauty. Every Guy must want to talk with me and they always touch me for no reason and I know that they want to enjoy with me but I always only give them eyes pleasure.See My Partners website for future bookings:Mumbai EscortsMumbai Escort AgencyEscorts In MumbaiMumbai Escorts ServiceEscorts In MumbaiIndependent Mumbai Escorts

Hi my name is Neeru. I am a 21 years hot and beautiful girl from Mumbai. I want to spend a excellent life so I want to make a lot of money and complete all my wishes. My naughty and bold behavior always behave to everyone and all the classmates want to friendship with me and they are always walk of life around me so I proud on my beauty. Every Guy must want to talk with me and they always touch me for no reason and I know that they want to enjoy with me but I always only give them eyes pleasure.See My Partners website for future bookings:Mumbai EscortsMumbai Escort AgencyEscorts In MumbaiMumbai Escorts ServiceEscorts In MumbaiIndependent Mumbai Escorts

One of the best and altering way by which you are going to have some of the best fun and make your life restful. So choose high profile escorts in Delhi and make your life prosperous. There are bands of trouble in everyone’s life and people often take all those stresses so much that they don’t have any idea that what ought they do. So that they are able to unbend. Thus an escort in Delhi is always there for you. Anyplace in the world when anyone is trouble or tension, he wants to some special that make his life full of joy and sunshine. If she is hot and young girls that want to make your life full of joyful and pleasure.Please See my Other Friends Website:Delhi EscortsDelhi Escort serviceIndependent Delhi EscortsEscorts In DelhiDelhi Escorts AgencyIndependent Escorts In Delhi

One of the best and altering way by which you are going to have some of the best fun and make your life restful. So choose high profile escorts in Delhi and make your life prosperous. There are bands of trouble in everyone’s life and people often take all those stresses so much that they don’t have any idea that what ought they do. So that they are able to unbend. Thus an escort in Delhi is always there for you. Anyplace in the world when anyone is trouble or tension, he wants to some special that make his life full of joy and sunshine. If she is hot and young girls that want to make your life full of joyful and pleasure.Please See my Other Friends Website:Delhi EscortsDelhi Escort serviceIndependent Delhi EscortsEscorts In DelhiDelhi Escorts AgencyIndependent Escorts In Delhi

I am one of the best Girls in Delhi escorts in the city Delhi. I have been working as a Delhi Escort since last few years and the reaction I have got from Delhi people is awesome which obviously shines the energy and exuberance in them. I have an experience of working this industry for long time and I carry a track record of giving my clients a kind of experience which they never forget in life. I believe in satisfying whatever the client wants as I know customer is the king and I am his queen.Kindly Visit My Friends Websites:Delhi EscortsDelhi Escort serviceDelhi Escorts AgencyEscorts In DelhiDelhi EscortIndependent Delhi Escort

I am one of the best Girls in Delhi escorts in the city Delhi. I have been working as a Delhi Escort since last few years and the reaction I have got from Delhi people is awesome which obviously shines the energy and exuberance in them. I have an experience of working this industry for long time and I carry a track record of giving my clients a kind of experience which they never forget in life. I believe in satisfying whatever the client wants as I know customer is the king and I am his queen.Kindly Visit My Friends Websites:Delhi EscortsDelhi Escort serviceDelhi Escorts AgencyEscorts In DelhiDelhi EscortIndependent Delhi Escort

Hiii I am Safia an High Profile Escorts In Goa.Our first intention is full satisfaction of our customer, so when any one reach we want to take our serves first we ask him, the type of the Independent escort In Goa you want to apply. We have many type of girl that is hot and sexy girl and they are to the full trained to give full enjoyment to our customer and contributed him to full satisfy. The girl who work with us, are very sexy and hot.See other Website of my partners:Goa EscortsGoa Escorts ServiceGoa EscortEscorts In GoaGoa Escort AgencyIndependent Escorts In Goa

Hiii I am Safia an High Profile Escorts In Goa.Our first intention is full satisfaction of our customer, so when any one reach we want to take our serves first we ask him, the type of the Independent escort In Goa you want to apply. We have many type of girl that is hot and sexy girl and they are to the full trained to give full enjoyment to our customer and contributed him to full satisfy. The girl who work with us, are very sexy and hot.See other Website of my partners:Goa EscortsGoa Escorts ServiceGoa EscortEscorts In GoaGoa Escort AgencyIndependent Escorts In Goa

My name is Hasrat and I am a Mumbai independent escort and also I am the heart beat of thousand of hearts. This is the reason there are many boys who are ready to do anything for me but i don't like them much as they need long some also want to marry with me. I love to be in small and sweet relationship which is totally fill with some of badness and love and i known you are the same person I am looking for. So what are you waiting for you can also get the same love which i need from you. So just call me and being independent escorts in Mumbai.See other Website of my partners:Mumbai EscortsMumbai Escort AgencyEscorts In MumbaiMumbai Escorts ServiceIndependent Mumbai EscortsEscorts In Mumbai

My name is Hasrat and I am a Mumbai independent escort and also I am the heart beat of thousand of hearts. This is the reason there are many boys who are ready to do anything for me but i don't like them much as they need long some also want to marry with me. I love to be in small and sweet relationship which is totally fill with some of badness and love and i known you are the same person I am looking for. So what are you waiting for you can also get the same love which i need from you. So just call me and being independent escorts in Mumbai.See other Website of my partners:Mumbai EscortsMumbai Escort AgencyEscorts In MumbaiMumbai Escorts ServiceIndependent Mumbai EscortsEscorts In Mumbai

My name is Anisa and you can treat me an independent escorts in Delhi. But to be frank I am also like another girl who would love to be satisfying up with different boys. You know what their many boys out there are but I am looking for something particular and once when I found it. I know it’s hurt me lot and I can still think those days when there is just me a empty room. That time I recognize that I would be happy to become escorts in Delhi. So it would be better for me that I should give all that felicity to the guys who are in need of. If I am not happy from my life than it would be better for me, Please check out my partner’s website for more entertainment: Delhi EscortsDelhi EscortDelhi Escorts ServiceIndependent Escorts In DelhiDelhi Escort AgencyEscort in Delhi

My name is Anisa and you can treat me an independent escorts in Delhi. But to be frank I am also like another girl who would love to be satisfying up with different boys. You know what their many boys out there are but I am looking for something particular and once when I found it. I know it’s hurt me lot and I can still think those days when there is just me a empty room. That time I recognize that I would be happy to become escorts in Delhi. So it would be better for me that I should give all that felicity to the guys who are in need of. If I am not happy from my life than it would be better for me, Please check out my partner’s website for more entertainment: Delhi EscortsDelhi EscortDelhi Escorts ServiceIndependent Escorts In DelhiDelhi Escort AgencyEscort in Delhi