Who wore this Carolina Herrera dress better?

Brooke Andersen is a writer and blogger currently located in New York, NY. She is a lover of all things beauty and fashion with an addiction to nail polish. While writing for SheKnows she also keeps up her own blog Just B. Follow her on ...

Fashion showdown

Showing up at an event wearing the same dress as another guest is a pretty major fashion disaster. Celebrities try madly to avoid this, but sometimes it happens and we can't help but compare. Tell us... Who wore this gown better?

Diana Argon vs. Amanda Hearst

Carolina Herrera designed this dress for her 2011 resort collection. Diana Argon was the first celebrity to wear it out to the 2010 Emmy Awards. Reviews were mixed; some felt the gown was overpowering.

But, apparently, American model Amanda Hearst loved it, too. She wore it recently to the American Museum of Natural History and Apollo Circle Galas. She also sported a similar updo to Diana Argon's, although she let some hair fall around the face.

Which celebrity do you think wore it better? Leave a comment and let us know!