Abstract

Background

Artemisinin-based combination therapy (ACT) introduced in the mid-1990s has been recommended since 2005 by the World Health Organization as first-line treatment against Plasmodium falciparum in all endemic countries. In 2010, the combination dihydroartemisinin–piperaquine (DP) was recommended for the treatment of uncomplicated P. falciparum malaria. DP is one of the first-line treatments used by the French army since 2013.

Case presentation

A case of P. falciparum clinical failure with DP at day 20 was described in a 104 kg French soldier deployed in Djibouti. He was admitted to hospital for supervision of oral treatment with DP [40 mg dihydroartemisinin (DHA) plus 320 mg piperaquine tetraphosphate (PPQ)]. This corresponded to a cumulative dose of 4.6 mg/kg DHA and 37 mg/kg PPQ in the present patient, which is far below the WHO recommended ranges. No mutation was found in the propeller domain of the Kelch 13 (k13) gene, which is associated with artemisinin resistance in Southeast Asia. Pfmdr1 N86, 184F, S1034 and N1042 polymorphisms and haplotype 72–76 CVIET for the pfcrt gene were found in the present case. There was no evidence of resistance to DP.

Conclusion

This case confirms the risk of therapeutic failure with dihydroartemisinin–piperaquine by under-dosing in patients weighing more than 100 kg. This therapeutic failure with DP by under-dosing highlighted the importance of appropriate dosing guidelines and the need of research data (efficacy, pharmacokinetics and pharmacodynamics) in over-weight patient group.

Keywords

Background

Artemisinin-based combination therapy (ACT) introduced in the mid-1990s has been recommended since 2005 by the World Health Organization (WHO) as first-line treatment against Plasmodium falciparum in all endemic countries. Combined with wide-spread use of insecticide-treated bed nets, ACT has led to a significant reduction in malaria incidence and mortality, especially in sub-Saharan Africa [1]. However, with 214 million cases globally leading to an estimated 438,000 deaths worldwide in 2015, malaria remains a public health concern [2]; moreover, ACT therapeutic failures are increasing in Cambodia, where resistance to previous first-line anti-malarial drugs also first emerged [3]. Today, artemisinin resistance has been documented in Southeast Asia and must be closely monitored [4].

Clinical resistance, defined by a slow parasite clearance [3], is in vitro correlated with an increase in the ring-stage survival rate after contact with artemisinin [5]. Recently, mutations in the propeller domain of the Kelch 13 (k13) gene (PF3D71343700), especially the Y493H, R539T, I543T, and C580Y mutations, have been associated with in vivo and in vitro resistance to artemisinin in Southeast Asia P. falciparum strains [6–8]. Currently, these mutations have not been identified in African P. falciparum isolates [9–15]. K13 mutations as well as patients with slow clearing parasites were found in and some African countries (Kenya, Democratic Republic of Congo and Nigeria) [4]. However, there was no confirmation about spreading artemisinin resistance to Africa.

Nevertheless, addressing ACT-failure requires a systematic approach, and the conclusion of drug resistance is based on a body of clinical and scientific arguments. Poor compliance (insufficient oversight or intolerance) and under-dosing (insufficient dosage, poor absorption, drug interactions or defects in drug metabolism) may also contribute.

In this report, a failure of dihydroartemisinin–piperaquine (DP) anti-malarial treatment was identified in a patient weighing 104 kg.

Though ACT failure is infrequent in Africa, the genome of the recurrent P. falciparum isolate was sequenced and searched for polymorphisms involved in antimalarial drug resistance. The k13 gene was amplified by polymerase chain reaction (PCR) with the nested PCR method previously described [13]. The following primers were used for PCR: 3′ GGG AAT CTG GTG GTA ACA GC 5′ and 3′ CGG AGT GAC CAA ATC TGG GA 5′; 3′ GCC TTG TTG AAA GAA GCA GA 5′ and 3′ GCC AAG CTG CCA TTC ATT TG 5′. The K13 propeller gene was successfully sequenced, and the result was compared to the reference 3D7 strain. No mutation was identified in the propeller domain of the k13 gene. Two fragments of the pfmdr1 gene (P. falciparum multidrug resistance 1) were also amplified according to the description by Wurtz et al., revealing N86, 184F, S1034 and N1042 alleles [16]. The pfcrt gene (P. falciparum chloroquine resistance transporter) was also sequenced, as previously described [17], and the 72–76 haplotype found was CVIET. Finally, the copy number of the two genes pfmdt and pftetQ, which in vitro reduced susceptibility to doxycycline in Africa, was determined by finding one copy of pfmdt and two copies of pftetQ [18–20].

Discussion

Artemisinin derivatives clear parasitaemia more rapidly than all other currently available anti-malarial agents, including atovaquone–proguanil [21]. In 2010, DP was recommended by WHO [22] for the treatment of uncomplicated P. falciparum malaria, providing a promising alternative to other artemisinin-based combinations on the basis of its high efficacy, excellent safety profile, once-daily dosing scheme, and prolonged post-treatment prophylactic protection [23]. In the French army, DP is the available first-line treatment.

In this case, P. falciparum reinfection cannot be excluded because of the lack of comparative genome sequencing between the two isolates. However, the low P. falciparum transmission in Djibouti [24–26] and the 19-day delay both indicated that malaria relapse had occurred; this was further supported by the fact that this occurred despite prophylaxis, and only late trophozoite forms of the parasites without gametocytes appeared on the thin blood smear.

DP was well tolerated, and the whole course of treatment was well completed. Failure more likely resulted from inadequate dosage, because there are no data on which to base a dose recommendation in patients weighing above 100 kg according to the European Medicines Agency (EMA) [27]. In the absence of toxicity data in patients weighing above 100 kg, the DP maximal dosage (i.e., 1280 mg/day PPQ and 160 mg/day DHA indicated for body weight 75 to 100 kg) was administered. This corresponded to a cumulative dose of 4.6 mg/kg DHA and 37 mg/kg PPQ in the present patient, which is far below the WHO recommended ranges (6–20 mg/kg DHA and 48–78 mg/kg PPQ) [22]. Indeed, WHO recommended the use of a PPQ dose of 1600 mg/day for body weigh above 80 kg [22]. In the literature, concerns have been raised over potential DP under-dosing in young children [28], and the 2013 Worldwide Antimalarial Resistance Network (WWARN) has explored the relationship between weight-adjusted DP dosage (mg/kg) and therapeutic efficacy in a meta-analysis [23]. Data of 7072 patients from prospective studies investigating DP efficiency were pooled. Those without molecular evidence for failure or with follow-up less than 28 days were excluded. The primary endpoint was the PCR-adjusted risk of P. falciparum recrudescence at the end of the study follow-up. Secondary endpoints included new P. falciparum infections, parasitological clearance rates, and gametocyte carriage. No patient was heavier than 100 kg. Twenty-eight patients weighed from 75 to 100 kg, and the median cumulative dose in this group was 37.4 mg/kg (32.8–48.3) for PPQ and 4.7 mg/kg (4.1–6.4) for DHA; these were close to the rates in the present patient and corresponded to 71.4 % (20/28) of patients below the WHO recommended dose [22]. The WWARN DP Study Group clearly showed that a total PPQ dose below 40 mg/kg predicted risk of recrudescence failure [23]. Additionally, in this previous study, six factors were reported to be associated with the risk of malaria recrudescence with PPQ [23]. In the present case, two of these six factors were found: the PPQ total dose and the body weight.

Thus, there is much evidence that DP treatment outcome depends on the PPQ plasma concentration. In DP, the artemisinin derivative DHA is responsible for a rapid initial reduction in parasitemia by targeting the parasitized erythrocytes, while PPQ is the partner drug that has a much longer elimination half-life to complete long-term parasite clearance [29]. Moreover, PPQ is of a lipophilic nature with a large volume of distribution [27]. For all of these reasons, it can assume that DP treatment failure in the present case was more related to PPQ under-dosing.

Interestingly, similar overweight-related failures have been documented with atovaquone–proguanil [30, 31]. In a series of 347 P. falciparum—infected travellers, atovaquone–proguanil therapeutic failures were overrepresented among patients weighing more than 100 kg [3/12 in the group (100–115 kg) receiving a standard atovaquone–proguanil regimen versus 2/335 in patients <100 kg] [32]. These data emphasize the lack of an alternative validated malaria treatment in overweight patients.

However, clinical failure by resistance cannot be excluded. Multidrug resistance to DP is currently emerging in Cambodia, where recrudescent infections have increased from 15.4 % in 2011–2013 to 39 % in 2012–2014; 84 % of treated patients presented with parasite clearance half-lives longer than 5 h in 2012–2104, and 57 % were still parasitaemic at 72 h [33, 34]. All the C580Y k13 mutant parasites collected from recrudescent patients after a 3-day DP treatment were resistant in vitro by PPQ survival assay [35]. DHA resistance is a real threat in African countries [4]. However, no mutation in the k13 gene was found in the present patient’s isolate. However, clinical failure by resistance cannot be excluded even if no mutations were identified in k13. Artemisinin failures seem not to be associated with k13 polymorphisms in Africa [15, 36]. However, in the absence of in vitro phenotyping (ring-stage survival assay) as well as data on parasite clearance rate, there was no evidence of resistance to artemisinin.

Decreased susceptibility or parasite resistance to artemisinin partner drugs has been observed in Africa, where single nucleotide polymorphisms in pfcrt and pfmdr1 have been identified in recurrent infections with ACT partners like lumefantrine, mefloquine or amodiaquine [37–41]. However, there is no data currently supporting the involvement of the pfcrt or pfmdr1 genes in PPQ or DHA resistance [17, 42]. The isolate contained two copies of the pftetQ gene, suggesting that the parasites were resistant to doxycycline [18–20]. This result may explain why, even as he took doxycycline as prophylaxis after his treatment by dihydroartemisinin–piperaquine, the patient had recurrent malaria.

Conclusion

Sub-optimal dosing of either component of ACT can result in incomplete elimination of the parasite biomass and subsequent recrudescence, both of which are important driving forces for the selection of parasites with reduced drug susceptibility. ACT regimens should absolutely be deployed using optimal dosing strategies to maximize the likelihood of rapid clinical and parasitological cure, minimize transmission, and retard the onset and spread of resistances. Overweight patients are at particular risk of under-dosing. In some military units, the soldiers often weigh more than 90–100 kg. Should physicians automatically exclude the use of dihydroartemisinin–piperaquine as an anti-malarial treatment in these patients in the absence of data in patients weighing above 100 kg? Until studies assessing how to adapt treatment are performed (increase the duration or the daily dose or repeat a course later), patients weighing more than 100 kg should be aware of the higher risk of therapeutic failure and should be closely monitored at least until day 28, and beyond if possible. This therapeutic failure with DP by under-dosing highlighted the importance of appropriate dosing guidelines and the need of research data (efficacy, pharmacokinetics and pharmacodynamics) in over-weight patient group.

Abbreviations

ACT:

artemisinin-based combination therapy

DHA:

dihydroartemisinin

DP:

dihydroartemisinin–piperaquine

PCR:

polymerase chain reaction

Pfcrt
:

Plasmodium falciparum chloroquine resistance transporter

Pfmdt
:

Plasmodium falciparum metabolite drug transporter

Pfmdr1
:

Plasmodium falciparum multidrug resistance

PPQ:

piperaquine

QBC:

quantitative buffy coat

RDT:

rapid diagnostic test

WWARN:

Worldwide Antimalarial Resistance Network

WHO:

World Health Organization

Declarations

Authors’ contributions

JBR, SV and NP carried out the diagnostic tests, monitored the patient, collected clinical and epidemiological data. BP and MM carried out the molecular genetic study. JBR, BP, SV, FS and EJ wrote the first manuscript. All authors have read and approved the final manuscript.

Acknowledgements

Competing interests

The authors have declared that they have no competing interests.

Ethics approval and consent to participate

According to the French legislation, bio-banking and secondary use for scientific purposes of human clinical samples used for malaria diagnostics are possible as long as the corresponding patients are informed and have not indicated any objections. This requirement was fulfilled here because oral information was given to the patient, and no immediate or delayed patient opposition was reported by the hospital clinicians. Moreover, samples received at the French Malaria Reference Center were registered and declared for research purposes as a bio-bank for the French National Institute of Health Survey. No institutional review board approval is required according to French legislation (article L. 1111–7 du Code de la Santé Publique, article L. 1211–2 du Code de Santé Publique, articles 39 et suivants de la loi 78–17 du 6 janvier 1978 modifiée en 2004 relative à l’informatique, aux fichiers, et aux libertés).

Funding

This study was supported by the Institut national de veille sanitaire (grant CNR Paludisme).

Open AccessThis article is distributed under the terms of the Creative Commons Attribution 4.0 International License (http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/), which permits unrestricted use, distribution, and reproduction in any medium, provided you give appropriate credit to the original author(s) and the source, provide a link to the Creative Commons license, and indicate if changes were made. The Creative Commons Public Domain Dedication waiver (http://creativecommons.org/publicdomain/zero/1.0/) applies to the data made available in this article, unless otherwise stated.

Faulde MK, Rueda LM, Khaireh BA. First record of the Asian malaria vector Anopheles stephensi and its possible role in the resurgence of malaria in Djibouti, Horn of Africa. Acta Trop. 2014;139:39–43.View ArticlePubMedGoogle Scholar