I have both of these, I also bought them for my mother and sister who LOVE them. It is very fine and non invasive, it does not add weight to the phone like most chunky cases. It is clearly more decorative then protective but it looks and feels great.

I was super excited about this phone case when I bought. It fit in my wallet, it's thin, and it looks great! The only problem is that I've had if for roughly two weeks and the rubbery plastic piping on the front of the phone case has already come off. In a few words, the phone that that I bought two weeks ago is quickly falling apart. Really disappointed in the product.