Case Number 10870: Small Claims Court

PENN AND TELLER: BULLSHIT!: THE COMPLETE FOURTH SEASON

The Charge

Grab your shovels.

The Case

Penn and Teller started the Showtime series Penn & Teller:
Bullshit! in 2003, and skeptics and cynics have been celebrating the
cerebral show ever since. The mission is to reveal cons and crimes that sucker
America, and this is the fourth season of the show packaged for DVD called
Penn & Teller: Bullshit!: The Complete Fourth Season. Why would two
Vegas magicians take it on themselves to reveal frauds and scams? They are
carrying on the tradition of master magician Harry Houdini who made it his
mission late in his career to reveal common cons. The magicians say the
difference between liars and the act they perform on the stage is "We tell
you we're lying!."

Each show opens with a skit from Penn and Teller that introduces the subject
to be debunked, and obviously Penn Jillette does all the talking while Teller
mugs silently like a magical mime. Penn keeps a constant profanity laden
diatribe over documentary footage while talking heads debate the arguments. Penn
always takes the dark cynical side, but his arguments are as well thought as
they are bombastic. In between segments we get more skits from Penn and Teller
as comedic punctuation to the rants. Jillette says the name of the series and
all the profanity are used to defend the show legally. Apparently calling people
"liars" or "frauds" is considered slander, but calling
"bullshit" or hurling "mother fucker" at someone is just
good clean fun. Don't you love speech laws? They're bullshit.

During season four here's the bullshit the guys took on:

* Episode One, "The Boy Scouts" Penn and Teller challenge
the Boy Scouts of America for the restrictive membership clauses -- mainly
"no gays, no atheists, no women." It's not that the guys have a
problem with private organizations restricting members, but they call out the
Scouts for accepting Federal, State, and local government handouts. That makes
them a public organization funded in part by tax dollars, so the denying of
membership is BULLSHIT!

* Episode Two, "Prostitution" Penn and Teller look at areas
where prostitution is legal, and are surprised to find a thriving business
monitored by the state health departments without pimps and with health
insurance. They decide trying to prevent two consenting adults from having sex
for money is BULLSHIT!

* Episode Three, "The Death Penalty" Penn and Teller
consider the idea the death penalty only satisfies a primitive emotion. The
investigators find evidence to debunk the idea the death penalty is anything
other than BULLSHIT!

* Episode Five, "Ground Zero" Four years have gone by since
9/11, and yet only a disturbing hole remains of the site. Penn and Teller look
at the BULLSHIT of trying to decide what to do with what should be a beautiful,
moving tribute to heroes and victims of the tragedy.

* Episode Six, "Pet Love" Sure we all love our pets, but cat
shows and treating dogs like humans? Penn and Teller call BULLSHIT on a thriving
industry that asks us to humanize our animals.

* Episode Seven, "Reparations" Who does the Federal
Government owe money to for its past wrongs? Penn and Teller call BULLSHIT on a
proposed program that could inspire institutionalized racism rather than
absolving any sins.

* Episode Eight, "Manners" Are we less civilized now than
the Victorians? Do we live in a rude world with no manners? Penn and Teller call
BULLSHIT on the idea that people were more socially adept when they had no
indoor plumbing and peed in the streets.

* Episode Ten "Abstinence" The idea of teaching abstinence
only is BULLSHIT.

The fourth season of Penn & Teller: Bullshit! as a whole is a
strong one. Taking on the Boy Scouts, Ground Zero, and the death penalty
resulted in moving and compelling television. The guys showed the appropriate
amount of respect for the hot button topics, and still got the arguments across
eloquently even if they dropped the "f bomb" on more than one
occasion. The series is a prime example of how cable television trumps network
shows, because Penn & Teller: Bullshit! dares to take a stand where
other shows waffle in a politically correct mess of cowardice. Penn and Teller
have balls: other news shows are neutered. Now the guys do stumble now and then.
I can't say the "Pet Love" episode revealed much other than people are
sorta nuts when it comes to the dogs and cats in their home. But is this news?
Still, it's fun to see Penn curse while kitties prance through a cat show
obstacle course and fashion show.

As much as I love Penn and Teller, I'm going to call bullshit on this set's
extras. Penn & Teller: Bullshit! -The Complete Fourth Season consists
of ten episodes spread over three discs without anything but a photo gallery and
filmographies as extras. These shows are simple fullscreen transfers of half
hour episodes that don't take up that much disc space. Surely we could get some
deleted scenes, bloopers, interviews or commentaries. The picture and sound is
fine throughout, and each episode is delivered uncut and in the order they
aired. And that folks is all we get.

Penn & Teller: Bullshit!: The Complete Fourth Season is a fresh
load of ten episodes that continue the muckraking magician movement. This is an
outstanding set of episodes, and it certainly makes sense as a purchase or
rental if you didn't get to catch the show on cable. But be warned, you don't
get much more than the episodes. If you recorded the series as it aired you
don't have much reason to check this one out, unless you want to have an
official copy to thrust on your more gullible friends. The biggest problem
facing America is how much bullshit we fall for, again and again. Thank goodness
Penn and Teller are here to save us.