Avoiding Legal Blunders
Board Missteps Can Be Expensive for Associations

You’ve just been elected to your condo board of trustees. On the one hand, you’re honored. A few neighbors have offered a congratulatory handshake, and now you’re in the mood to pop the bubbly. On the other, there’s a sense of hesitation. You’ve placed your trust in your fellow board members, some of whom have served for
a while. They know how to conduct association business procedurally and
understand the legal ramifications when problems arise…right?

More often than not, yes. Nevertheless, it’s easy to make mistakes relative to the law, owing to the fact that seemingly
minor oversights can turn into major problems. Yet with proper attention to
detail and a thorough understanding of potential issues, condo boards can
indeed avoid legal blunders—and the fines and lawsuits that go along with them.

As with many areas in life, it’s wise to glean valuable lessons from the (unfortunate) missteps of others.
Knowing what mistakes boards sometimes make and what those mistakes signify in
terms of consequences is one way to take precautions against faulty
decision-making.

Mistake No. 1

Attorney Frank Lombardi, a partner at the law firm of Goodman, Shapiro & Lombardi, LLC in Rhode Island, identifies three areas in which boards are
commonly prone to error. “First, fining owners for covenant breaches and rules violations without having
hearings. Second would be a failure to follow the condo documents. For
instance,” he says, “a two-thirds majority vote is disregarded sometimes, and boards will go with
just a simple majority on an issue where two thirds is required.” Determining budgetary matters is an example of where there might be a
majority-vote shortcut, he notes. “Third is the method of election. Boards sometimes ignore the correct nomination
process, which puts the validity of elections in question.”

Attorneys Charlie Perkins and Diane Rubin both echo Lombardi’s point on following documentation. Perkins, who is a senior partner at the law
firm of Perkins & Anctil in Westford, Massachusetts, says he has seen many boards that don’t have a sufficient understanding of the condo documents. And here’s where the seemingly minor oversights come in, because condo boards need to
know the rules for “everything from parking, pools, and pets to how they’re administratively required to run a meeting.”

Association rules are the basis for governing the association. (That being said,
it’s worth mentioning that if there’s a conflict between condo rules and state or federal legislation, the latter
two supersede the condo rules.) In most cases, though, condo rules dictate how
things are done, particularly for association-specific matters.

Studying those dense condo docs, as challenging as they may be to read, is
therefore a board member must. Mistakes happen, Rubin contends, when boards don’t read their own documents—particularly when there are votes and changes to the rules. Rubin, a partner at
the law firm of Prince Lobel Tye in Boston, says that boards must be mindful of
following rules “very carefully instead of generally.” Elections are one area in which this is important. “If you’re not really careful and there’s a challenge, especially with elections, you can end up with a big mess.”

Poorly-made property decisions are also a common, but easily avoidable, mistake.
If a board were to sign a one-page proposal from a contractor, Perkins
explains, that wouldn’t be advisable. It may well open them up to possible legal issues down the road.
“That doesn’t make sense if someone is hired to do a $100,000 roof job—you’d need much more detail.”

Act In Good Faith

One key distinction boards need to be aware of is the legal difference between
decisions made in good faith (with honestly and fairness) and those made in bad
faith (involving fraudulence or deception). This is important because even
decisions made in good faith can results in lawsuits or fines.

There are two layers to this, explains Perkins, and it comes down to this: What
is and is not upheld by a court. Lombardi adds that a Rhode Island statute
requires all board members to act in good faith. “Good faith and due diligence may not prevent a lawsuit,” he says, “but the courts may well uphold a board’s decision under these circumstances.”

“Having the decision made in good faith is one of the best shields both for the
decision and for liability,” says Perkins. Needless to say, honesty really is the best (and least expensive)
policy for all those involved. “In cases of bad-faith decisions, the court might not uphold and members may be
exposing themselves to personal liability.” Furthermore, malfeasance doesn’t apply.

Conflicts of interest are the area in which Rubin has seen the greatest number
of bad faith allegations. “In other words, this often happens when a board member has a personal interest
and it’s not disclosed to the whole board,” she says.

Bad-faith decisions can also occur if boards do the exact opposite of what their
attorney says to do, says Lombardi, who has “seen courts impose sanctions that insurance may not cover, and board members may
lose the right to indemnification if it rises to the level of fraud.” By contrast, according to the business judgment rule, boards that act in good
faith and rely on professional advice are granted broad discretion and have the
right of indemnification. This means that board members and trustees do not
incur personal losses as a result of their role on the board.

Cover Your Board

Indemnification is, in fact, the cornerstone of protection for board members.
Perkins, Lombardi, and Rubin all emphasize the importance of obtaining (and
keeping up) directors and officers liability insurance (D&O), which protects members from claims held against the board when decisions are
made in good faith. All board members should be listed on the policy. D&O is not specific to condos; most large corporations have it as well. The
insurance will pay (or reimburse) the costs that the board is obligated to pay
as a result of a breach of duty, neglect, error, misstatement, or omission
committed by the board.

“A board would be well-advised to spend the money for directors and officers
insurance, even for small associations where it’s not required,” says Rubin. “In a small association, if you don’t have the insurance, the indemnification will be borne [by the individuals].
There shouldn’t ever be personal liability.”

Some associations may not have the money to indemnify, Lombardi points out. This
is an unenviable position: Not having D&O poses a tremendous risk to the trustees and the board members from a liability
standpoint. If there’s a lawsuit, board members will be responsible for hiring lawyers—and it will come out of their own pockets.

D&O is clearly the strongest form of protection board members and trustees can
have once mistakes have been made. But getting back to those common mistakes
mentioned earlier: What else can a condo board do to avoid those and other
expensive legal mistakes?

Ask for Help

Get professional help. “It’s inherent that the more professionals you use to make decisions, the more
protection you have,” says Perkins. To illustrate, he elaborates on the roof project cited earlier—the one in which signing off on a single-page proposal from the contractor
wouldn’t be advisable. When undertaking a project of this scope, it’s imperative to get a “good team to help you with the process.” He suggests that in addition to the roofing contractor, boards get input from
an engineer to assess and talk to a clerk of the works. Also, be sure that the
condominium management company is on board with payment schedules. Having a
lawyer review the contract is a good idea, too.

Lombardi also endorses the idea of drawing on the knowledge of professionals—not only for specific projects, but as a general rule of thumb. People comprising condo boards “are often volunteers, but even their combined expertise is not enough to avoid
mistakes.” He recommends consulting with an attorney if an issue arises relative to condo
rules and the interpretation of those rules. (Of course, this depends on the
composition of the board, some of whom do, of course, have attorneys).
Designating one board member to do so streamlines communication between the
lawyer and the board.

There may also be times, Lombardi says, when talking to an insurance agent or
property manager is necessary as well. “The biggest way to avoid legal mistakes is to operate your association
defensively—it’s like driving defensively.” This is a concept with which New Englanders are well acquainted, naturally, and
the comparison is apt: “Try to see around corners. Be mindful of the steps.”

Finally, another means of avoiding expensive legal mistakes—and achieving board success with decision-making—is perhaps the most fundamental approach of all: good communication. “It makes sense to talk things through as a board,” Rubin says. She advises boards to be deliberate and to refrain from making
hasty decisions. This, too, goes hand-in-hand with soliciting professional
advice. “Understand all sides of a problem. That way you can steer clear of decisions
based on assumptions when additional expert opinions might help avoid the
problem.”

When all is said and done, perhaps Lombardi’s succinct advice to condo boards sums it up best: “Don’t run it like a corner lemonade stand.”

Jodie Lynn Boduch is a Massachusetts-based freelance writer and a contributor to
New England Condominium.

2
Comments

Is it legal for a board to put new siding on some of the buildings but not all if there is no vote taken by the owners in the state of NH? And then assess all owners 15,000 now and possibly 15,000 later. I thought Chapter 356-B New Hampshire Condominium Act prevents the board from doing anything like this requires the owner's to vote.

Do allNH condo buildings have to have a condo board? Mine does not and my landlord was one of the people that decided on which property management company to use. As it happens, he is part of that particular company.

Leave a Comment

News

5/29/2020
Behavior of some condo owners is only getting worse—Fosters

5/29/2020
Behavior of some condo owners is only getting worse—Fosters

It’s getting worse, not better. And I don’t mean COVID-19. I mean the interactions with owners. I get it. These are frustrating, scary, even dangerous, COVID-19 times. Either people know someone sick, worry about getting sick, are out of work, know someone who is out of work, or if working, fear being put out of work or catching the virus. It leads to stress, frustration, loneliness, depression, probably a list too long for single column. But nothing excuses bad behavior at a condo meeting. Nothing. Ever. It’s just not that important.
Read full story

5/28/2020
Mass. home sales down almost 14 percent in April—Lowell Sun

5/28/2020
Mass. home sales down almost 14 percent in April—Lowell Sun

Home sales in Massachusetts during April were down nearly 14 percent, although buyers and sellers wrapped up 3,706 sales agreements while the state grappled with a surge in COVID-19 cases and deaths and as residents largely stayed home and away from shuttered workplaces.
Read full story

5/28/2020
Goodspeed: Condo associations have a lot of power—Wicked Local

5/28/2020
Goodspeed: Condo associations have a lot of power—Wicked Local

Often, these types of situations where there is selective rules enforcement are really nothing more than a cover for a personality conflict. You can try to reason with the trustees. You can try to build alliances with other owners and/or sympathetic trustees to promote your case. You can also run for trustee yourself.
Read full story

The Cape Cod & Islands Multiple Listing Service for Barnstable County has reported a 43% decrease in pending single-family home sales in April, but the association notes a continuing high level of interest in homes in the area.
Read full story

5/21/2020
Dakota Partners Closes on Oak Tree Village in Connecticut—Boston Real Estate Times

5/21/2020
Dakota Partners Closes on Oak Tree Village in Connecticut—Boston Real Estate Times

Dakota Partners recently secured all permits and closed on the property at 89 and 92 Preston Road in Griswold, CT. Construction on the new affordable housing community, Oak Tree Village, began in late 2019.
Read full story

5/21/2020
In Boston, a Development’s Approach to a Changing Coastline Is to Embrace It—Metropollis Magazine

5/21/2020
In Boston, a Development’s Approach to a Changing Coastline Is to Embrace It—Metropollis Magazine

Along the formerly gritty, industrial waterfront of East Boston, high-end residential developments have been popping up over the past decade, taking advantage of the stunning views of Boston Harbor and downtown that the district offers. Among the most prominent of these projects, the 478-unit Clippership Wharf was conceived as four buildings, two of which reach out into the harbor to create a tranquil central cove for the property.
Read full story

Officials with Top Shelf Cannaseurs outlined their plans Thursday to prevent noise and odors from emanating from their proposed marijuana cultivation and manufacturing facility on Brent Drive.
Read full story

5/19/2020
Billerica man burned in 2-alarm fire—Lowell Sun

5/19/2020
Billerica man burned in 2-alarm fire—Lowell Sun

A Billerica man in his 30s was taken to a Boston trauma center with serious burns after firefighters pulled him from a 2-alarm fire in a Kenmar Drive condo complex that also left residents of about 20 other units displaced on Friday afternoon.
Read full story

5/8/2020
The rich are sheltering from coronavirus in luxury retreats with guns—New York Post

5/8/2020
The rich are sheltering from coronavirus in luxury retreats with guns—New York Post

It’s easier to cope with coronavirus lockdown when your backyard is thousands of acres of rolling hills, meadows and marshes.
Read full story

5/8/2020
Coronavirus Escape: To the Suburbs—The New York Times

5/8/2020
Coronavirus Escape: To the Suburbs—The New York Times

For some New Yorkers, it’s time to get out of town for good.
Cooped up and concerned about the post-Covid future, renters and owners are making moves to leave the city, not for short-term stays in weekend houses, as was common when the pandemic first arrived, but more permanently in the suburbs.
Read full story

4/30/2020
COVID-19 Safety Rules Take Shape in Boston—Engineering News Record

4/30/2020
COVID-19 Safety Rules Take Shape in Boston—Engineering News Record

Temperature checks at the jobsite gate and portable toilets equipped with hot water are set to become regular features at Boston construction sites going forward as city officials put into action new safety rules in the wake of the deadly coronavirus pandemic.
Read full story

4/28/2020
Real estate Q&A: My condo’s pool and gym are closed. Do I still have to pay the full monthly dues?—Boston Herald

4/28/2020
Real estate Q&A: My condo’s pool and gym are closed. Do I still have to pay the full monthly dues?—Boston Herald

4/27/2020
Large Massachusetts construction union tells members they can return to work—Curbed

4/27/2020
Large Massachusetts construction union tells members they can return to work—Curbed

The North Atlantic States Regional Council of Carpenters, which represents about 10,000 workers in Massachusetts, told members that it was alright to return to construction sites if they thought they were safe. The union had pulled its members from jobs on April 6 amid concern about the spread of the novel coronavirus.
Read full story

4/20/2020
Condo sales in Boston mixed in the immediate wake of coronavirus—Curbed Boston

4/20/2020
Condo sales in Boston mixed in the immediate wake of coronavirus—Curbed Boston

It is the biggest parlor game in Boston real estate right now: How will the novel coronavirus pandemic affect housing sales? A new report from Warren Residential, part of Berkshire Hathaway HomeServices, shows a mixed bag from neighborhood to neighborhood during the first three months of 2020 in terms of condo sales.
Read full story

4/20/2020
Pandemic leaves buyers and sellers with no place to go—Boston.com

4/20/2020
Pandemic leaves buyers and sellers with no place to go—Boston.com

Looking back, the March date that Eliza Peters moved out of her Braintree home did seem a bit ominous.
Read full story

The economic pain caused by the coronavirus is translating to lower rent collections this month.
Just 69% of U.S. apartment renters made payments through April 5. That compares with 81% who paid their rent by March 5, a new tracking tool published by the National Multifamily Housing Council shows.
Read full story

4/9/2020
What Boston-area homebuyers need to know during the coronavirus pandemic—Curbed Boston

4/9/2020
What Boston-area homebuyers need to know during the coronavirus pandemic—Curbed Boston

The Boston area has long been a difficult place to buy a home. Prices are high compared with most of the country, and the competition for condos and houses is fierce. Bidding wars and purchase prices well over asking have been features of the market for years. All-cash offers in the high six figures and beyond are not uncommon.
Read full story

The number of pending condo sales in Massachusetts was down sharply in March compared with the same month in 2019, in what might be the first sign of the effects of the novel coronavirus pandemic on the state’s housing market.
Read full story

Follow Us

About

New England Condominium

Welcome to the new online edition of New England Condominium newspaper. The publication serves the New England Condo, HOA and co-op community with informative free articles on management, finance, maintenance and more...