If this is your first visit, be sure to
check out the FAQ by clicking the
link above. You may have to register
before you can post: click the register link above to proceed. To start viewing messages,
select the forum that you want to visit from the selection below.

I know the odds of it happening are little or none, but would it satisfy you to see the original line-up on stage again in the future?

Or would you consider that selling out without a new album?

I think you all know that for me a reunion tour with absolutely no new music would be just fine with me. The chance to see Eddie and Dave sharing a stage again with MA on backing vocals sends shivers down my spine.

Originally posted by dj88:I know the odds of it happening are little or none, but would it satisfy you to see the original line-up on stage again in the future?

Or would you consider that selling out without a new album?

I think you all know that for me a reunion tour with absolutely no new music would be just fine with me. The chance to see Eddie and Dave sharing a stage again with MA on backing vocals sends shivers up my spine.

Yeah I bet it sends shivers...ANYWAY...

No..no one here wants van halen to reunite with david lee roth. We never talk about that, ever.

Ah, my good buddy bk is here from the Army to spread a little Army cheer.

This is a Van Halen discussion; not an opinion. Some people don't want a reunion if it's just going to be nostalgia. Some others may not feel that Dave is capable of pulling it off (concerns about his voice).

That's what I would like to discuss here. Would nostaglia satisfy you or is that a waste of time/money in your book?

Dude we've all talked the reunion to death. This topic is inane and involves someone drawing a personal conclusion based on their belief structure - therefore in my opinion this is a topic best meant for opinions. Of course, the final judgement is up to the mods.

And yes, I post at the Army too. I actually like it there because Sarge is a good guy and lets his users basically say whatever they want. Does it make your opinions different if you post somewhere besides here? I don't think so.

I think it can be said quite certainly that most here would enjoy Roth returning to the band. The word inane doesn't even begin to describe your question.

Not a lot of people are worried about Roth or Van Halen's artistic integrity at this point in the game.

Originally posted by badkaraoke:Dude we've all talked the reunion to death. This topic is inane and involves someone drawing a personal conclusion based on their belief structure - therefore in my opinion this is a topic best meant for opinions. Of course, the final judgement is up to the mods.

And yes, I post at the Army too. I actually like it there because Sarge is a good guy and lets his users basically say whatever they want. Does it make your opinions different if you post somewhere besides here? I don't think so.

I think it can be said quite certainly that most here would enjoy Roth returning to the band. The word inane doesn't even begin to describe your question.

Not a lot of people are worried about Roth or Van Halen's artistic integrity at this point in the game.

I try to se some relevance in your post..but I can't.

Add to the discussion or piss off. Not every thread needs to have shit stired in it.

I don't think anyone is that concerned about "selling out" they just want it to happen at this point, anyhow anyway. Soon VH will make a record with singer #4 or Ed will go on tour with Britney Spears or whatever..truth is that Ed and Dave can't make it work.

And you guys who are quoting an entire 3 paragraph post just to say "add to the discussion or piss off" aren't doing much better.

A tour would be nice, but it's the sizzle. An album... now that's the steak!

Really, a tour provides a few hours of memories. That's all well and good, but I get far more enjoyment out of any VH album I own than I've ever gotten out of a live show. To put it in some perspective, would you trade Fair Warning and all the songs on it (meaning they don't exist) for a chance to see a show in 1981? I know I wouldn't.

What I want most of all is an album. If they can only stomach each other for 3 months, I hope they pass on the cash and try to make something that lasts. Neither of those is going to happen, however.

Our little dedication to CRPS awareness. If you don't know what this horrible disease is, please click this link to learn more. My (Brett) wife suffers from this extremely painful and debilitating nerve disorder that doctors are just now learning more about and realizing the severity. Please consider donating to help doctors find a cure for what many call the "suicide disease." Thank you!

Like Us On Facebook!

Newest Posts

For me, ADKOT was the first album to finally approach the incendiary intensity of the six pack. A big reason for this is The creative friction and competition between Ed and Dave. That push/pull...