After Jennifer Aniston and boyfriend Justin Theroux were spotted leaving Chateau Marmont in LA last Thursday, rumors swelled that the pair are now engaged when a paparazzi shot caught a large ring on Aniston's finger. (As in that finger.)

"The two just seem so happy together! AND JUST LOOK AT THAT ROCK!!!!" Perez Hilton said in posting about the ring, adding that he thought Aniston deserves "every happiness in love after what that beardy Brad Pitt did to you!" But not so fast retorted rumor-hunter Gossip Cop. The site took a closer look at Aniston's supposed engagement ring and concluded the actress was wearing the same gold "Jennifer" ring she's been sporting for months.

We wouldn't rule out the possibility, however, that Aniston and Theroux are taking their relationship more seriously now that they've been dating since last year and have a dog named Sophie. And soon, Aniston hinted, the couple may add a fourth member to the group. "I think people maybe want me to have a kid now," she said in an interview with GQ. "I still kind of go with it. If it happens, it happens. I'm calm and peaceful with whatever the plan is. It's not something where I'm going, 'I gotta have a kid!'"