Last month, the Hunger Games star had a bone to pick with Jimmy when she came by for the show, filling the audience in on a story about how he bailed on her when they were supposed to ask J.Lo to dance with them at the 2014 Met Gala. In the 23-year-old’s version, the invitation was turned down, but the “I Luh Ya Papi” singer has a different story to tell.

“I’m standing up there and I remember seeing you guys come over and I remember Jennifer saying, ‘Let’s go out to the dance floor and dance!’ like out there where everyone was dancing,” she explained. “And I was like, ‘Oh, no…I’m good right here.’ And I kind of felt like she was sad! I didn’t mean it like that! I just meant like, ‘It’s crazy out there, it’s like a mosh pit. We can’t go out there!'”

The 44-year-old made sure she let Jimmy know, too, that she wasn’t happy with him for not following through. “You bailed on the bit!” she laughed. “That is not okay!”

In the end, Jennifer shared a dance with Jimmy, during which he gave J.Law a shout-out. Check it out above!