oh, come on, guys… Scarlett Johanson? I think not. "One of most fashionable [you] had seen in this blog"? Please… Scott's blog is brimming with the sartorial equivalent of natural diamonds, sapphires and rubies. What I see here is a cubic zirconia from K-Mart.

Not feelin it at all. The individual pieces are great, but I detest the summer/fall mix of shorts, bare legs and boots. If the shirt was paired with a cute mini skirt, I could have tolerated it, but in general I think it's best to pick a season and go with it. The time for boots will come soon enough. Enjoy the warm weather while we still have it.

P'Boy may be from BKK, but her ensemble is utterly NY. As for the comment about 'picking a season and sticking with it': clearly that person is not from NY. Boy's look is incredibly put together, with an effortlessness achieved only by intuition. Makes sense given that her bags (www.boyybag.com) are equally remarkable.

The boots make the outfit. I absolutely love the combination with shorts. Funny, if she wore a skirt no one would think it was summer/winter or whatever nonsense the weather police are thinking up. But a skirt is no warmer then shorts, even tho it would have shushed them.