Good but not great.

The Witcher 2 is a solid & unique RPG but I can't give the 360 version a great rating many for technical reasons. The game play is solid, navigating the world & fighting feel smooth & responsive. I really like the way they setup the combat system so you can fluidly use your melee & magic attacks without much interruption in the action. But I feel the poor graphics, constant loading, & somewhat confusing inventory system stop it from being a top tier game on the 360. If the 360 is your only option to play this game I wouldn't let these issues turn you away from this game. But some people might find these issues detract from the game enough to make playing it on the 360 a very frustrating experience.