What was the purpose of keeping James and Lily in a coma for seventeen years rather than killing them? Why would Dumbledore bring them out of it every year to tell them his plans? How could they just accept in a matter of hours/days that the person they considered the most evil Dark Lord in history was now their son's adoptive father? How would they have any muscle tone after being in a coma for that many years?

It's fine to think out of the box, but you need credible reasons for things to happen.

Guest chapter 8 . 10/10/2016

The Gryffindors and Dumbledore left Harry alone all semester? Really? Nothing about his classes, nothing else about Slytherin's ghost?

Guest chapter 6 . 10/10/2016

Harry harvested a 60 foot basilisk in a matter of minutes? You couldn't come up with something credible?

Guest chapter 5 . 10/10/2016

That was Slytherin cunning? Tell us something that wasn't in the news? From people that were hostile to him in prior years? Salazar would be embarrassed by how low his House has sunk.

Snape must have been even more broken. To fond out that Lily is still alive and to see her with Potter. Well, loads of memories must have rushed back up. But beside that, it is a great story. Potter Sr is the character I hate the most so I will not say anything about him

Oh my god, I know about that story, I just can't think of it...was I something like The Dragon Prince?

Guest chapter 1 . 7/24/2015

I know exactly what story you are talking about! Its called something like "Dark Roses" is this it?
s/9281148/1/The-Dark-Roses
Um maybe not, but I'm not sure, I didn't read this one. But it includes a tattoo..and a gang of dark heirs. I'm on a mission to find this story now