Keeping The Faith

In this age of standards and accountability and testing and cultural
literacy, Jessie Singer is an unabashed progressive. The Portland,
Oregon, high school teacher promotes multiculturalism. She eschews (as
much as possible) the "canon" of dead white male authors. She uses an
interdisciplinary approach to literature. She prefers to teach books
that raise questions of justice, fairness, and equality. She opposes
tracking and standardized testing. She believes classrooms should be
more democratic. And she doesn't lecture.

But as Singer, 27, discovered early in her career, it isn't easy to
go against the grain. After receiving her master's degree from Lewis
and Clark College, which has a well-regarded teaching program steeped
in progressivism, she spent a year at a Eugene high school where her
youthful zeal was not always appreciated. "I felt isolated there," she
says. "I was surrounded by some wonderful teachers, but they were very
stuck in what they were doing. They were threatened by any new way of
doing things." Singer says she was popular with many of her students,
and that caused friction with some of the other faculty members. "One
teacher made a rule that her students couldn't mention my name in her
classroom," she says, still incredulous.

To keep sane, Singer would drive to Portland—a two-hour
journey—to attend meetings with a group of progressive teachers
who are informally affiliated with the Milwaukee-based quarterly
education journal Rethinking Schools. Last year, she left Eugene
and took a job at Portland's Grover Cleveland High School. At
Cleveland, Singer is in good company. The school's English department
is well-known for its embrace of progressive teaching methods. "My
colleagues here are very supportive," she says.

Favorite
Education Books:In the Middle, by Nancy Atwell;
A Workshop of the Possible, by Ruth Hubbard.

Today, Singer is helping other young
progressives stick to their guns. As a leader of the Rethinking Schools
bunch, she heads a support group for beginning teachers. Every other
month, they meet at Singer's house to compare notes about teaching
strategies, behavior management, job satisfaction, and other topics.
"New teachers, especially young progressive teachers, feel really
isolated because they often don't have a lot of like-minded
colleagues," she says. These days, she concedes, it's harder than ever
to keep the faith. "But that's all the more reason why we need good
progressive teachers, teachers who are willing to stand firm, who know
that there's more to good teaching than testing and assessment, who
know that we have to have high standards, but that it comes with a
strong curriculum and creativity and multicultural literature."

Bill Bigelow, a Portland high school teacher and a fellow Rethinking
Schools leader, praises Singer for "her willingness to stand up and
take a leadership role. I wish we had a lot more young teachers like
her." He adds: "She's got a great heart and loads of energy."

Linda Christensen, language arts coordinator for the Portland
district, thinks so highly of Singer that she recently asked the
teacher to lead a workshop for English instructors districtwide. Never
mind that Singer hasn't even completed her first year at Cleveland.

"She's an incredible teacher, with a sense of justice and equality
and a vision that all students can succeed," says Christensen, who
helped found Portland's Rethinking Schools group. "I wanted her to
share her teaching skills with other teachers."

At 8:30 on a drizzly Tuesday morning, Singer introduces herself to
10 teachers who have turned out for training she's conducting at
Cleveland High. The teachers, many of them older than Singer, are
sitting where the students usually sit, in combination desk/chairs.
Singer, who has short, jet-black hair and dark brown eyes, is full of
enthusiasm and energy. Dressed in gray pants and a black long-sleeve
T-shirt, she's relaxed and self-confident. Her workshop: "The Landscape
of Literature."

"I want to show you one way that I get students to connect with
literature," she says as she passes out copies of various short
stories. Singer favors African and Latin American texts in her classes,
and she has chosen examples of the former for the workshop. She asks
each teacher to read the story and copy a short passage from the text
that describes the landscape. Then, she asks them to illustrate the
scene using crayons and pastels. "Sometimes I play African music in the
background while they do this," she says. One teacher complains, "I
have no artistic ability!" but Singer insists that "the art is not
important."

A young woman wearing a long blue-and-white polka dot dress writes
down the title and author of her book—Kaffir Boy: The True
Story of a Black Youth's Coming of Age in Apartheid South AfricaM,
by Mark Mathabane—and this simple passage: "The place was
mountainous, rugged and bone-dry, like a wasteland." Underneath, she
draws brownish, dirt-covered hills with a blazing hot sun.

"This part is pretty easy for the students," Singer says. "But the
next part takes it much deeper." She asks the other teachers to write a
short interior monologue, putting themselves inside the story. As the
teachers begin scribbling, Singer reiterates the lesson's objective
with students: "The goal is to get them to connect as readers to the
texts."

It's a far cry from asking kids to read The Catcher in the
Rye and write a five-page report examining Holden Caulfield's
relationship with his little sister, Phoebe. That approach, Singer
says, can turn kids off to reading. "With my students," she says,
"especially my sophomores, who are the most reluctant readers, if I
give them a book and say, 'There's some really important imagery here
that I want you to know about,' they will literally walk out the door."
But if they are allowed to choose their own books to read—Singer
is a firm believer in this—then chances are good they will
develop a lifelong love of literature.

Later, Singer sits at a table in her empty classroom and expands on
her teaching style: "To me, progressive teaching is coming from a place
of wonder, instead of, 'This is what I know, and I'm going to pass it
on to you.'" But she insists it's not the "airy-fairy" approach that
critics make it out to be. "I do believe that teachers need to teach
skills. In order to be a reader and a writer, there are skills you need
to have. But they go in one ear and out the other unless they have a
purpose and a context and a connection."

Singer leads a visitor through her classroom, which is lined with
students' work, including posters and writings. She points proudly to a
poem by sophomore Kyle Payne, a Native American. "He's never really
read books," says Singer, who gave him The Lone Ranger and Tonto
Fistfight in Heaven, by Sherman Alexie, a Spokane/Coeur d'Alene
Indian writer. "He loved it," she says. The poem, based on Alexie's
novel, is titled "Reservation Style." It ends with this provocative
line: "This life isn't any sensation/This life is the native nation."
Singer smiles. Thanks to her, a student has made a strong connection
with a book. It's a small victory, but a victory nonetheless.

—David Hill

Vol. 11, Issue 7, Pages 51-52

Notice: We recently upgraded our comments. (Learn more here.) If you are logged in as a subscriber or registered user and already have a Display Name on edweek.org, you can post comments. If you do not already have a Display Name, please create one here.

Ground Rules for Posting
We encourage lively debate, but please be respectful of others. Profanity and personal attacks are prohibited. By commenting, you are agreeing to abide by our user agreement.
All comments are public.