I don't think anyone knows. So you won't get an answer. But I'm willing to put money on it being a sort of lapsed Christian-thing. Like most people past 50, he believes in God but he doesn't need to make a song and dance about it!

Do you think Dylan is a Jew who is a True Believer when it comes to Christmas or a Christian who is happy to observe his Jewish roots?

Aren't these essentially the same thing? Having recently read the Scott Marshall book, if I had to choose I'd say Dylan is a Christian who believes in Jesus Christ and both testaments of Bible, while still observing and maintaining his Jewish roots. But as he said in that Rolling Stone interview, music is his true religion.

[and I assume that nothing on "Trouble No More" was released against his will, if that counts for anything]

Oh, and also, ...

On February 6th 2015, in Los Angeles, after being presented by President Jimmy Carter with the MusiCares Person of the Year 2015 award, Bob Dylan delivered a long acceptance speech (published online by Rolling Stone three days later). Here is a small part of that speech which included a reading of the first three of five verses of the beautiful gospel song "Stand By Me" from 1905, written by Charles Albert Tindley.

"... The Blackwood Brothers were talking to me about making a record together. That might confound expectations, but it shouldn't. Of course it would be a gospel album. I don't think it would be anything out of the ordinary for me. Not a bit. One of the songs I'm thinking of singing is "Stand By Me" with the Blackwood Brothers. Not "Stand By Me" the pop song. No. The real "Stand By Me." The real one goes like this:

When the storms of life are raging stand by me

When the storms of life are raging stand by me

When the world is tossing me like a ship upon the sea

Thou who rules the wind and water stand by me

In the midst of tribulation stand by me

In the midst of tribulation stand by me

When the hosts of hell assail and my strength begins to fail

Thou who's never lost a battle stand by me

In the midst of fault and failure stand by me

In the midst of fault and failure stand by me

When I do the best I can and my friends don't understand

Thou who knowest all about me stand by me

That's the song. I like it better than the pop song. If I record one by that name, that's going to be the one. ..."

Well as an atheist, I have no time for any of it, but as an historian I can see that Judaism and Christianity (and Islam, come to that) are simply reboots of the same religion. And I think Dylan, quite sensibly (given the nonsense of it all), has merged the two. As someone says upthread, he believes in the Bible, both parts. He's learned to talk about it as little as possible, so as to avoid poking the hornets' nests of all the squabbling factions, each of which insists it is The True Faith, and wants him in their camp.

A question worthy of pondering is when Dylan, circa mid-1980s, was asked by an interviewer about exactly this: his current religious beliefs. Dylan responded, asking why no one asked Billy Joel these kinds of questions. Perhaps on offhand comment in an interview but, to me, it summed up Dylan in some significant ways: his wit...his artful deflection...responding to a question with a question (predictable question, followed by an unpredictable response)...and the blues in regard to fame/celebrity. Can't recall if Dylan did cover any religious or spiritual ground in this interview, but sure do remember that one exchange.

Well as an atheist, I have no time for any of it, but as an historian I can see that Judaism and Christianity (and Islam, come to that) are simply reboots of the same religion. And I think Dylan, quite sensibly (given the nonsense of it all), has merged the two. As someone says upthread, he believes in the Bible, both parts. He's learned to talk about it as little as possible, so as to avoid poking the hornets' nests of all the squabbling factions, each of which insists it is The True Faith, and wants him in their camp.

I forget where this was published, but a close source said that there was in Dylan's mind no contradiction or incompatibility between Judaism and Christianity, contrary to the opinion of adherents of both faiths. I thought that was telling, and explains a few things. Dylan's mother also said that Jesus was something between toler-ated and celebrated in the Jewish community in Hibbing. Anyone who remembers the sources of these statements, please share.

I think now is good time for Dylan to give up the Sinatra nonsense and release his 'Muslim' album. He could call it Slow Jihad Coming.

But seriously, I am *guessing* Dylan's "religious" (not necessarily the same as "spiritual") life has gone something like this:

1941 to 1955: Jewish by default; memorizing Torah; Bar Mitzvah, etc.

1956-ish to 1966-ish: "angry young man" rejects organized religion

1967-ish to 1977: death of Woody Guthrie and his father (close together), combined with birth of young children, prompts prolonged period of reflective reconsideration and re-reading of Torah and the New Testament, with an open-mindedness to both (resulting in songs from 'Sign on the Cross' to 'Oh Sister', etc.)

1978 to 1980/1981: Vineyard Fellowship cult-ish Christianity, after Dylan is confronted by Jesus in a Tucson, Arizona hotel room and signs up for Bible school

1982-ish to early (?) 1990s: "Messianic Jew" -- he's both a Jew by extended family and a Christian by choice and association (on stage in 1987, he was still describing Jesus as his "hero"). Was in with the Lubavitch-ers but still singing Christian hymns, etc.

Since early/mid(?)-1990s: Combination of everything from the past with less dogma needed; a comfortable post-middle aged resignation that American song and musical traditions will ultimately define his spiritual experience of the material world.

So to understand his religious beliefs requires insight from the Transfigured perspective. That means Jesus and Elijah as mentioned above. He also said he went to the Vatican to read up on the theology books housed there on the subject.

From that angle, I can’t imagine anything but a pure, transformed integration and regeneration of his Judaism and Christianity it all their glorious authenticity

Great thing for us is he spills it out all over his art and even tries to tell us about it by invoking a Hell’s Angel

A question was asked by an interviewer about exactly this: his current religious beliefs. Dylan responded, asking why no one asked Billy Joel these kinds of question.

This reminds me of a certain witty president, but I think that was quite a relevant question to ask a man who just had sentenced billions of people to hell in the name of his religion. Had Billy Joel done something like that?

Bob just released the most curated and comprehensive collection of his career, spanning 10 audio CDs and a full length movie on DVD for the first time in the Bootleg Series.

This music is a celebration of his dramatic conversion experience to Christianity.

It’s a full throated embrace of this aspect of his career, thumbing the nose at any naysayers.

Obviously, he’s an atheist.

I am not going to comment on his belief as I have no idea about it. But judging on his current moves with his Nobel lecture, I think that deducing what he wants to celebrate based on what he releases is not a very reliable tactic.

Joined: Wed December 5th, 2012, 18:52 GMTPosts: 5163Location: In a hole in the ground there lived a....

I think that Bob’s fans tend to project themselves onto him.

Agnostics and atheists, including the aggressive anti-theist types, seem generally unwilling to admit their hero could believe in fairy tales. Therefore every effort is expended to prove somehow that Bob has rejected his former beliefs.

Judeo-Christian types look and listen to Bob and both see and feel that he is a fellow believer. Since they feel it in their heart, sometimes it is hard to explain to those with a different worldview.

Can these two groups reconcile? My history on ER indicates the answer is no.

Only Bob and God know the truth, all we can do is bicker and fight - which I don’t have the taste for anymore.

Agnostics and atheists, including the aggressive anti-theist types, seem generally unwilling to admit their hero could believe in fairy tales. Therefore every effort is expended to prove somehow that Bob has rejected his former beliefs.

Judeo-Christian types look and listen to Bob and both see and feel that he is a fellow believer. Since they feel it in their heart, sometimes it is hard to explain to those with a different worldview.

Can these two groups reconcile? My history on ER indicates the answer is no.

Only Bob and God know the truth, all we can do is bicker and fight - which I don’t have the taste for anymore.

As the years roll by I have less and less of a clue what I think Bob Dylan actually believes in. He's done such a good job of obfuscating everything. I don't know who he would have voted for, what God he prays to or anything really. Quite a achievement from the voice of a generation..

Who is online

You cannot post new topics in this forumYou cannot reply to topics in this forumYou cannot edit your posts in this forumYou cannot delete your posts in this forumYou cannot post attachments in this forum