E Collar For Dogs | Best Rated E Collars For Dog Training

It’s crucial to find the right E collar for dogs. After all, the human-dog bond is one of the most special and fulfilling connections we are lucky enough to experience. Nothing can quite compare to the bond we get to share with our furry best friends. However, for our best friends to live their most fulfilling lives, it is both in our best interest and theirs that they receive some form of training.

Dog training can be one of the most challenging periods for many dog owners. There are different methodologies and practices that owners and handlers believe can be the most useful in terms of effectiveness. In many instances, one of the most successful tools has been the implementation of the e collar, or the electronic collar. These e collars can be a remarkable tool for communicating behavioral training messages to your dog both quickly and effectively.

Why Do I Need an E-Collar for My Dog?

At times, we as pet owners need to keep our dogs out of harm’s way or reinforce and communicate some behavioral patterns. For instance, we’ve all heard of horror stories where a neighbor’s beloved dog escaped from the yard or perhaps they were somehow inexplicably lost. It would be a lifesaver to have a device in which you could remotely and safely communicate to your dog to return home.

Another scenario in which an e collar could serve as a useful tool would be in a case where your dog dislikes the visiting friendly neighborhood cat and causes it distress. In this kind of situation, an e collar could prevent the stressful and heated interaction between the two parties.

What Is the Best E Collar for Dogs?

There are many variations of e collars, and they should certainly not be approached as one-size-fits all. Several considerations should be noted when investing in this piece of technology such as intended usage (intensive training vs. household behavioral issues), dog size and weight, the general temperament of your dog, and the lifelong durability of the tool itself.

Variations of E Collars

Some of the more popular types of e collars for dogs are remote training collars and containment collars or invisible fence collars. In the correct circumstances, both can yield great results. A remote training collar is generally a two-part apparatus, consisting of both the collar itself and the remote-control transmitting device. The handler can then make individualized decisions on output stimulus for their dog’s particular training needs. The containment collars are relatively self-explanatory – they serve as means to keep your dog from leaving a designated area, most commonly a front or backyard.

Stimulus

Just as there are variations of e collars, there are also variations of the output stimulus which the devices can send out. The stimulus will vary from in situation to situation and dog to dog. For instance, a very large breed dog in the midst of high intensity police or military training will generally require a more substantial degree of output. Contrastingly, a smaller breed dog would generally respond to a lighter degree of output.

Fear Mongering and Misinformation

E collars for dogs have been proven time after time to be some of the most useful training tools that exist. Despite their safe and effective nature, there is quite a bit of fear mongering used to discredit their usefulness. Oftentimes, naysayers will state that such collars are either harmful or dangerous due to the stimulus. In reality, when properly used they can be a great asset for both you and your dog.

E collars are highly adjustable, offering a variety of stimulus levels; it is easy to find your dog’s ideal level without fear of over-stimulation. Long-standing negative connotations can be difficult to avoid. This false information only perpetuates misbeliefs and further misleads people from making the best decisions for their dogs. However, with proper education it is clear to see the long list of benefits that e collars can provide.

E Collar for Dogs: Buying Guide

Intro

This is one of the most comprehensive and highly customizable e collars for dogs on the market. It is also highly intuitive and easy-to-use.

Durability

If you’re looking for an extremely durable product that will last for years to come, this is a definite consideration. It is made of heavy-weight, solid material and is highly durable. It is widely used by those with large-breed dogs completing intensive IPO training (tracking, obedience, and protection). However, it can be used for dogs as little as 35 pounds.

Features

This e collar for dogs has some very useful features. Not only are the collar and receiver fully waterproof, but its transmission can reach up to three to four miles in distance. The handheld transmitter has an LCD screen which gives you peace of mind by showing you both battery life of the e collar and the current level of stimulation. The collar’s contact points are about 5/8 inches and work very well for short and medium-haired dogs. Those with dogs whose hair is very long may want to invest in the manufacturer’s one-inch contact points (sold separately).

Customization

Each dog is unique, and a stimulus that is effective for one may be ineffective for another. This e collar has a stimulus level that is guaranteed to work in some capacity no matter what level they require. The Dogtra 1900S offers an unparalleled amount of customization with levels ranging from zero to 127. It offers a variety of outputs such as a mere nick to constant stimulation and non-stimulation vibration modes.

Charging

While some e collars can take what seems like an excessive amount of time to charge, this one comes with two-hour lithium polymer rapid charge batteries. With almost no downtime, you and your best friend will be in training mode in no time at all.

Aesthetic Qualities

This product is featured in a black colored e collar, while the handheld remote device is a combination of both a muted green and black.

Dimensions

This e collar is made of 95% polyester and 5% nylon. Additionally, it weights 8.6 ounces and its dimensions are as follows: 3.8 x 1.8 x 1.4 inches.

Intro

This e collar for dogs aims to be a professional level model and offers quite a number of useful training features.

Durability

This product is built for dogs that are highly active and spend a great deal of time outdoors. That being said, it is made to last for years to come both outdoors and in direct contact with water. Those with hunting dogs often find that this product works best for their specific needs because it can withstand unpredictable conditions.

Features

This e collar is designed as a three-in-one training system, allowing you the ability to train up to three dogs. However, the product initially only comes with one e collar strap, but two additional ones can be purchased separately and connected to your device. The handheld controller features a color-coded dog selection switch, thus inhibiting any possible confusion when implementing stimulation. In addition, its range works up to one mile in distance and features beacon lights on the collar for easy spotting in dark. This system also features the Vibration Pro 550 for vibration control, as well as the ability to add on a remote Upland Beeper feature (sold separately). All in all, this packaged set appears to be a great value.

Customization

The Garmin Pro 550 offers a substantial amount of customization with up to 21 varying levels of stimulation. These can range from momentary stimulation and continuous stimulation to varying degrees of vibration and tone settings. It is also allows for customization of the built-in BarkLimiter which can be turned on or off. If switched on, the advanced technology automatically senses the ideal level of output needed to offset barking.

Charging

The charging time on this e collar takes no more than two hours and has excellent battery life. It runs on a long-lasting and rechargeable lithium-ion battery which is included in the set itself. The handheld device indicates when it’s running low on battery and needs a charge.

Aesthetic Qualities

Overall, this training system is timeless and classic in design. Other than the color-coded dog selection buttons on the handheld device, the components are all black in appearance. In addition, the handheld device’s tube-shape design makes it effortless to hold and operate with one hand.

Dimensions

This e collar training system is made of 95% polyester and 5% nylon. Additionally, it weighs 7.7 ounces and its dimensions are as follows: 2.1 x 1.8 x 8.2 inches.

Intro

This compact e collar for dogs, as with the previous products, is a remote operating device. It’s a great option to consider specifically for dogs taking part in waterfowl hunting climates. Generally speaking, this could be a great option for someone looking for a mid-grade e collar.

Durability

This e collar certainly appears to be a highly durable piece of equipment. Its intended use is for rugged outdoor climates but would also work ideally for indoor situations.

Features

Don’t let this e collar’s small size fool you. It boasts an impressive list of features that can certainly compete with some of its larger and more bulky competitors. It offers various levels of output – vibrational buzz, an auditory beep, or seven levels medium/high of momentary or continuous stimulation. Its waterproof technology allows submersion up to 25 feet deep. It’s ideal for dogs as little as eight pounds or larger and will fit neck sizes 5” – 22”. It can also be used on up to three dogs with the purchase of additional e collars. As an additional bonus, it comes with an instructional DVD to get you started.

Charging

A factor that should definitely be given some time is its ability to charge quickly. In a mere two hours, your dog could be wearing this fully charged e collar. Its battery life also performs between 50-70 hours per charge.

Aesthetic Qualities

A distinctive point of interest for some to keep in mind is the physical appearance of both the handheld device and the e collar itself. Not only is the design sleek and compact, it is offered in a Realtree camouflage print. This could be incredibly useful to help both you and your dog remain hidden on hunting outings. A black option is also available for those who prefer a more classic look.

Dimensions

The dimensions of the e collar itself (without the strap) are as follows – 2.60 x 1.30 x 1.23 inches.

This is another great option to consider if you’re in the market for a compact e collar for dogs to use as a training device. It is a small, but definitely powerful device.

Durability

Although it is compact and lightweight in design, the Garmin Sport PRO is built to last. Both the collar and remote have a substantial feel, and the buttons are made of solid rubber.

Features

The handheld remote offers a quick turn dial, so you can easily switch between the 10 varying degrees of stimulation. They include levels of continuous, momentary, vibration, and tone. It also features a built-in Bark Limiter which you can adjust as needed to suit your dog. Its range will work up to ¾ mile in distance. The collar itself is fully waterproof while the handheld remote is only water resistant. Its LED beacon lights will make for easy spotting at night.

In addition, it has the ability to train up to three dogs (the collars are sold separately). One possible downside is that Garmin no longer manufacturers this model, and you may find it difficult to secure a warranty or request replacement parts.

Charging

With a rechargeable battery lasting up to 60 hours, your dog will be wearing their e collar for extended periods of time between each charge.

Aesthetic Qualities

Both the handheld device and collar are sleek and compact. Some may appreciate the fact that the remote is two-toned, coming in a black and green combination. The collar itself is fully black.

Dimensions

The Garmin Sport PRO comes in at 4.3 ounces with the following dimensions – 1.4 x 2.1 x 5.4 inches.

Intro

If you’re looking for a mid-tier e collar for your dog’s simple behavioral issues around the house, this may be your product of choice.

Durability

This is a great introductory e collar to use if your dog has simple household behavioral issues you’re hoping to correct. It is not necessarily meant for excessive rugged use, although the collar itself is waterproof. The remote is water resistant.

Features

With a working range of up to 100 yards, this e collar is great for smaller distances and household training (although a 300-yard range model is also available). This is a great option even for smaller dogs as little as eight pounds, as well as for larger dogs with neck sizes ranging from 5 – 27.5 inches. There are eight levels of stimulation which you can manually customize from the handheld remote or a simple tone/beep option. A user guide designed by a skilled professional trainer is also included to assist with the learning curve.

Charging

Unlike all the previous models mentioned, this particular e collar trainer does not come with a rechargeable station. Instead, you must routinely replace the three-volt lithium batteries when they expire, about every six months. This may be something to consider before you purchase this particular model.

Aesthetic Qualities

The simple all black design is a classic that should suit many tastes.

Dimensions

This e collar comes in at 9.6 ounces and dimensions are as follows – 0.5 x 7.6 x 2.3 inches.

Intro

Don’t let the word “micro” in the product’s name fool you. In the right circumstances, this training device could be the ideal e collar for you and your dog.

Durability

Though small in size, it is built to withstand a decent amount of outdoor terrain. However, those looking for an extremely heavy-duty training collar may want to look into other options. The e collar itself is completely waterproof while the remote is weather resistant.

Features

The micro e collar is able to reach up to 900 yards in range. Its internal antenna system is built into the collar and makes for a seamless signal transmission. Additional add-on collars can be purchased to use with up to three dogs. It offers various outputs including positive vibration and 16 levels of stimulation, varying from momentary to continuous.

For those with particularly sensitive dogs, you may want to give this model some consideration as it also boasts a gentle touch system and extra mild stimulation. In case of emergency, there is also a built-in safety shut-off feature.

Charging

A rechargeable NiMH battery system makes it easy to get the device up and running.

Aesthetic Qualities

This all-black compact system has a classic, sleek look that most will have no problem with.

Dimensions

Small and lightweight, it will fit into the palm of your hand and weighs only four ounces. Its dimensions are as follows - 8.6 x 2.6 x 12 inches.

Intro

This system offers several unique features that could sway potential customers in their decision-making process.

Durability

Both the e collar and the remote transmitter are 100% waterproof. In fact, the transmitter will float if dropped into a body of water. This appears to be a great candidate for light and medium intensity usage.

Features

One of the primary draws this system offers is the transmitter’s hands-free option. Its curved handle straps onto the back of your hand while your fingers are free to engage otherwise. The collar is adjustable for small to large dogs and fits between seven to 22 inches. The signal is fully functional up to 1,400 yards. The system is capable of alerting you when battery power is running low. Additionally, it can be used with up to three dogs.

The stimulation output ranges from levels 1-16 and varies between light vibration, nick, and continuous functions (up to eight seconds). For those concerned with how much stimulation their dog is receiving, the multiple light setting offerings could be very useful.

Charging

The system comes with rechargeable NiMH batteries that last between one to two weeks before they need to recharge.

Aesthetic Qualities

A ruggedly classic design will suit many taste preferences.

Dimensions

Small and compact in nature with dimensions as follows - 11.3 x 8.5 x 3 inches.

Intro

Here is another option from Garmin which some may want to consider for its general simplicity. Those overwhelmed by option overload may find this to be a great option.

Durability

Although not fully waterproof, it is somewhat water resistant with a rating of IPX7. Buyers looking to purchase a more heavy-duty e collar system might be better off with another model.

Features

An impressive draw this training system offers is its inclusion of both long and short contact points. Depending on your dog’s coat length, one length may be better suited for your needs than the other. There are 18 levels of stimulation ranging from momentary and continuous, to lower levels of tone and vibration. Additionally, it works in range of up to ½ mile and can be used for up to three dogs.

Charging

A rechargeable lithium-ion battery will last up to 80 hours per charge.

Dimensions

Intro

For the most basic obedience and household behavioral issues, this e collar for dogs could easily and effectively get the job done

Durability

Its intended use is primarily for indoor and household behavioral issues. It is not meant to withstand incredibly harsh conditions. That being said, the e collar is indeed waterproof, and the handheld remote is water-resistant.

Features

Despite its simplicity, it still is able to perform quite a number of tasks. It allows you to gently address behavioral issues with a light to medium stimulus of nick, constant, and vibration. The stimulus levels range from 1-100 and can be adjusted gradually with a dial function. Its transmission range works up to 400 yards in distance. Owners with smaller dogs may be interested as it fits dogs as little as 10 pounds. It can also be used for up to two dogs at once.

Charging

Batteries are included and take a mere two hours to charge. However, at times there may be some longevity issues.

Aesthetic Qualities

The sleek black and red design is classic yet eye-catching compared to some other all-black training systems.

Dimensions

This device is incredibly compact and smaller than many other models on the market. Its dimensions are as follows - 2.4 x 1.5 x 1.2 inches.

Summary

All of the e collars for dogs listed above are top-notch choices. A variety of factors may go into the decision of which to purchase, including the size of your dog, their general nature, your climate, and your intended usage. With the proper guidelines outlined above, you now have the proper information available to make the best choice for both you and your dog’s needs.

The idea for Alpha Dog Nutrition started when our founder, Joe Scott, noticed that there were no straightforward nutritional options for his bird dog. After consulting with pet nutritionists and veterinarians from all over the United States, Alpha Dog Nutrition finally made it's debut. Our highly specialized formulas are now available to hunting dogs throughout the world.