I actually thought the new Black Canary was fun even if it didn't remotely come close to being a traditional take on the character. Felt like a bit of Scott Pilgrim influence here based on the weird adventures of a rock band. I could see it appealing to a somewhat younger and female audience but I'm sure their going to alienate some more traditional readers at the same time.

I liked it. It follows up on BC having lost everything (thanks Batgirl!) from the Batgirl book and trying to get some money by taking a temporary contract fronting a band but having difficulty adjusting to that. The character still feels to me like I can see the connection with the New 52 Canary from BoP.

Thankfully there's some weird stuff going on which will lead to further intrigue. I think the biggest concern is whether the book can sustain the concept (which they've established in book as a temporary arrangement for BC) over a longer period (but then, maybe that's never been the plan?)

After 2 issues I'm really digging it. It's Black Canary meets Scott Pilgrim sure. I can see how that wouldn't work for everyone but it's hella fun as far as I'm concerned. I think I like it better than Batgirl.

I thought this last issue was awesome. I like the band angle but it had gotten to be a bit too much for awhile. The new issue which still had plenty of the band but also a new martial arts angle and villain that wasn't music really hit the spot for me.

The book it would seem continues to be polarizing. I read two blog reviews of the issue both scoring out of ten one gave it a ten one gave it a three and half. I don't know if I'd quite go ten but that's definitely closer to where I'm at then three and half.