We've been buzzing all week about the rumor that some or all of our beloved American Idol judges weren't coming back next season, and even asked you who should replace Steven Tyler, Jennifer Lopez, and/or Randy Jackson in the judges' seats. But it looks like Lauren was right, the rumor mill can be eerily accurate! Us Weekly reports that Steven Tyler will NOT be returning next season to the hit reality show. But that's not all...

He's not the only one who might be out the door! Jennifer hinted this morning on Today that she's still debating.

"Little by little I'm making up my mind," she told Natalie Morales. "I love everybody, I love the guys, but I am thinking it's time for me to go and do other things I love to do like films."

As for Randy, well, we're not sure, but he hasn't officially confirmed a return yet either.

Just a reminder--some of the names being suggested for replacement judges are Adam Lambert, Katy Perry, Miley Cyrus, and Fergie. Who would you pick to replace Steven? If the producers listened to our lovely readers (which, um, they totally should), then Katy would be the top pick, according to our poll earlier this week!

Who would you pick to replace Steven? Are you shocked that he's leaving? (And what do you think Jennifer will do?)