Jose Theodore, hands down. One lights out season and then a whole lot of mediocrity to follow.

(Of single seasons, the least deserved Hart Trophy if you will, my pick would be Henrik Sedin. He practically got it on the Art Ross alone; Sid would have been a far superior choice for chipping in all of a sudden 51 goals for the injury-riddled Penguins and winning the team scoring race by 32 points.)