Kimmel expressed his own shock that Henderson got the hook. “When you saw Bristol Palin in that gorilla thing, you must’ve said, ‘We got this wrapped up this week,’” he joked. Henderson didn’t understand. “I don’t know. I don’t know exactly how it works,” she wondered.

Kimmel offered his own theory as to why Henderson was voted off – her on-camera kiss with Barry Williams, who played her son on ‘The Brady Bunch.’ “Do you think that when America saw you kissing Greg Brady, they went, ‘What the hell’s going on here? This cannot happen again! Who knows where they’ll go next week if we let this continue!’?”

Henderson just laughed. “Now, Jimmy, I hate to break it to you, but he wasn’t really my son.”