If this is your first visit, be sure to
check out the FAQ by clicking the
link above. You may have to register
before you can post: click the register link above to proceed. To start viewing messages,
select the forum that you want to visit from the selection below.

That's the whole point. If he's selected in the 2006 Rule 5 draft, he has to be placed and left on the 2007 roster.

I wasn't sure about whether or not they were considering the 2006 Rule 5 draft to be the one that went into effect for 2006 or 2007. I thought they might have said 2006 Rule 5 draft meaning the draft before the 2006 season, as that would also make sense.

a soriano fan

saY WHAT U WANT ABOUT HIS CONTRACT AND I WILL AGREE YES HE MAKES TOO MUCH MONEY YES HE STILL IS SHAKY DEFENSIVELY .HOWEVER OVER THE PAST 5 YEARS CAN U NAME A CUB THAT HAS PRODUCED MORE HOMERUNS?RBIS? NO U CANT WE CANT REPLACE HIS BAT AT THIS MOMENT ,WHY TRADE A POWER HITTER WHEN WE DONT HAVE ONE TO REPLACE HIM.NO THIS TO ME IS A BAD MOVE NOT JUST CAUSE I LIKE SORIANO BUT BECAUSE HE IS THE PERFECT ORGANIZATIONAL PLAYER .HE DOESNT COMPLAIN GETS BOED HE DOESNT REACT NEGATIVELY AT FANS HE GETS BOED HE IS A AUTOMATIC 30 TO 38 HOMER PLAYER NOW. WE CANT REPLACE HIS BAT

saY WHAT U WANT ABOUT HIS CONTRACT AND I WILL AGREE YES HE MAKES TOO MUCH MONEY YES HE STILL IS SHAKY DEFENSIVELY .HOWEVER OVER THE PAST 5 YEARS CAN U NAME A CUB THAT HAS PRODUCED MORE HOMERUNS?RBIS? NO U CANT WE CANT REPLACE HIS BAT AT THIS MOMENT ,WHY TRADE A POWER HITTER WHEN WE DONT HAVE ONE TO REPLACE HIM.NO THIS TO ME IS A BAD MOVE NOT JUST CAUSE I LIKE SORIANO BUT BECAUSE HE IS THE PERFECT ORGANIZATIONAL PLAYER .HE DOESNT COMPLAIN GETS BOED HE DOESNT REACT NEGATIVELY AT FANS HE GETS BOED HE IS A AUTOMATIC 30 TO 38 HOMER PLAYER NOW. WE CANT REPLACE HIS BAT

saY WHAT U WANT ABOUT HIS CONTRACT AND I WILL AGREE YES HE MAKES TOO MUCH MONEY YES HE STILL IS SHAKY DEFENSIVELY .HOWEVER OVER THE PAST 5 YEARS CAN U NAME A CUB THAT HAS PRODUCED MORE HOMERUNS?RBIS? NO U CANT WE CANT REPLACE HIS BAT AT THIS MOMENT ,WHY TRADE A POWER HITTER WHEN WE DONT HAVE ONE TO REPLACE HIM.NO THIS TO ME IS A BAD MOVE NOT JUST CAUSE I LIKE SORIANO BUT BECAUSE HE IS THE PERFECT ORGANIZATIONAL PLAYER .HE DOESNT COMPLAIN GETS BOED HE DOESNT REACT NEGATIVELY AT FANS HE GETS BOED HE IS A AUTOMATIC 30 TO 38 HOMER PLAYER NOW. WE CANT REPLACE HIS BAT

He had a great year last year. Almost living up to his contract for the first time. Plus he's really matured with the partying and womanizing so I feel he is a good club house present for the younger generation like Castro whom we know already has a bit of a sexual assault problem.

saY WHAT U WANT ABOUT HIS CONTRACT AND I WILL AGREE YES HE MAKES TOO MUCH MONEY YES HE STILL IS SHAKY DEFENSIVELY .HOWEVER OVER THE PAST 5 YEARS CAN U NAME A CUB THAT HAS PRODUCED MORE HOMERUNS?RBIS? NO U CANT WE CANT REPLACE HIS BAT AT THIS MOMENT ,WHY TRADE A POWER HITTER WHEN WE DONT HAVE ONE TO REPLACE HIM.NO THIS TO ME IS A BAD MOVE NOT JUST CAUSE I LIKE SORIANO BUT BECAUSE HE IS THE PERFECT ORGANIZATIONAL PLAYER .HE DOESNT COMPLAIN GETS BOED HE DOESNT REACT NEGATIVELY AT FANS HE GETS BOED HE IS A AUTOMATIC 30 TO 38 HOMER PLAYER NOW. WE CANT REPLACE HIS BAT

Why do they need his bat when this team is gonna stink again next year anyways? Makes no sense not to trade him if they can get anything of nice value from somebody. At this point Id consider eating his entire salary too, to allow him to bring back the best talent possible.