After Worldwide Underground's PJ Black defeated Sexy Star in the first round of the Cueto Cup with a little help from Taya and Prince Puma defeated another Worldwide member and Lucha Underground Champion Johnny Mundo's fanboy Ricky Mandel, the two were set to take the main event this week in the second round of the tournament that could see them facing off with the winner of Mundo and Rey Mysterio.

Puma is shown having visions on the roof to start the show, when Vampiro comes up and tells him that the only way to silence it all is to win back the Lucha Underground Championship. PJ Black sees Puma on the roof and gives him the one-finger salute, which makes Puma says he will not lose to Black no matter what. Black would later get introduced to his and Worldwide Underground's new agent, Benjamin Cooke, by champion Johnny Mundo and crew. While Cooke couldn't get Mundo's name right and seemed inept, he promised Worldwide Underground would own Lucha Underground with him as their agent.

In the main event, Black and Puma went all out with Puma laying into Black early, but both men rallying with exchanges of moves. Black landed a spike hurricanrana into the corner to take control, but Puma fought back and punctuated with a standing shooting star press. Puma laned a suplex and cutter combination, but Black came back with a front suplex. Both men fought up top and Puma landed both a reverse hurricanrana and Frankensteiner, but Black survived. Puma decided to put Black away with running boots that knocked him down for the 630 splash. Puma advanced, but Lucha Underground owner Dario Cueto informed Black that his agent Benjamin Cooke scored him a match with Rey Mysterio next week.

Cage and Pindar opened the night in a quick one as referee Justin Borden tried to get Cage's gauntlet off before the match. Cage laid him out and tried to finish Pindar, but Borden disqualified him and it earned Borden another beating after the match. Pindar advances, but Cage continues to look unstoppable with the gauntlet quite literally at his hand.

In the other match of the night, Dante Fox was set to take on Son of Havoc. Son of Havoc was attacked on the way to the ring by Son of Madness and hit with a chain. Dario Cueto came out of his office and said he cannot postpone a match in the Cueto Cup and challenged Son of Havoc to get to the ring and gave him an option to quit. Havoc didn't quit and took a beating for it for the majority of the match, but he fought back towards the end. A Death Valley Driver landed off the apron to the floor for Havoc and he went up top for the finish, but Fox avoided it to land a Fox Catcher and secure his spot in the second round.

Lucha Underground next week features the end of the second round of the Cueto Cup, with Drago vs. Pentagon Dark and The Mack vs. Texano as well as PJ Black looking to soften up Lucha Underground Championship number one contender Rey Mysterio for his Worldwide Underground stablemate Johnny Mundo.