But not everyone agrees. Though he's the overwhelming favorite of users, our editors are split, with two backing Fallon and three favoring the Jack Black/Kyle Gass music duo Tenacious D for their collection "Rize of the Fenix." They're currently in second place with 10/3 odds.

In third place with 11/2 odds is Lewis Black for "In God We Rust." Unlike Fallon and Tenacious D, Black is a previous winner, with Grammys in 2006 for "The Carnegie Hall Performance" and 2010 for "Stark Raving Black."

"Seaman 1st Class" is the fifth consecutive nomination in this category for Kathy Griffin. She has yet to win, and most of our predictors expect that streak to continue. She is ranked fifth with 15/2 odds.