Milwaukee Journal-Sentinel - July 2, 2005

Old pro gives a show with a glint in his eyesTom Petty didn't back down.

Petty and the Heartbreakers kept a promise to deliver a "genuine American rock 'n' roll show" to a sold-out crowd Friday night at the Marcus Amphitheater.

Petty's hour-plus set was short on innovation; even new songs from an upcoming CD, such as "Turn This Car Around," felt like comfortable old favorites. But who would want Petty to change his signature style of Southern-flavored rock, full of buttery guitars, sturdy beats and giant singalong choruses?

Decked out in a green velvet smoking jacket, Petty owned the stage with a beguiling mix of mischief and the effortless grace of a professional who's been rocking crowds longer than many in the Marcus audience have been alive.

"Y'all are gettin' a little rowdy out there," he teased when the crowd outshouted him during "Mary Jane's Last Dance."

The audience's enthusiasm was understandable. In addition to hits from throughout his career -- including set opener "Listen to Her Heart," "You Don't Know How It Feels" and "I Won't Back Down" -- Petty offered up some unexpected gems.

With multi-instrumentalist and singer Scott Thurston filling in for the late Roy Orbison, Petty romped through "Handle with Care," from his stint with the Travelin' Wilburys.

The set also included a cover of The Animals' "I'm Crying" and the new song, "Melinda," with the brooding feel of a lost Johnny Cash track.

Keeping the music fresh for fan and band alike, Petty played with the melody of "Free Fallin'," arguably improving on the studio version, and brought out a few tracks from the underrated "Wildflowers" album, including the title song. While Petty's music isn't complicated, the band's cohesion, and his own ability to deliver even a spare tune such as "Crawlin' Back to You" in an amphitheater without losing its intimacy, make the Summerfest veteran a welcome returning guest.

Deadlines precluded a review of Petty's entire set.

Despite second billing, the Black Crowes hit the stage with all the swagger of a headlining act -- and were welcomed as such by an enthusiastic crowd. Brothers Chris and Rich Robinson led the recently reunited Crowes through an hourlong opening set of boogie-drenched roots rock that recalled that moment in the '70s when a song wasn't done right live unless it stretched into a 10-minute jam.

While most of the crowd appreciated what Chris Robinson dubbed "freak 'n' roll for the true believers," a few fans grumbled that the Crowes ended their set with "Remedy" and skipped an encore.

The Petty Archives is not in any way knowingly affiliated, associated, or endorsed by the Tom Petty estate, any of the Heartbreakers, and/or any of their current or previous management. This site is nonprofit, but is not a registered nonprofit organization or entity.