Talking With Neo-Nazis and Pro-Israel Germans

On Monday, I wrote a bit about the Quds Day events that took place in Berlin this past weekend. To sum up what happened: As in Tehran, Lebanon, London, Paris, Toronto, and elsewhere, Berlin hosts an Quds Day march at the end of Ramadan. Quds Day (which translates to Jerusalem Day) was originally conceived by Iran in 1979 with the aim of expressing solidarity with Palestinians by marching and rallying, yes, but also by saying all kinds of terrible things about Israel, Zionism, and the Jews.

In Berlin, which has hosted a Quds Day since 1996, the participants ranged from a number of Turkish, Iranian, and Lebanese ex-pats to supporters of Hezbollah and Hamas, some Palestinians, a few neo-Nazis, and some Satmar Jews. Not many there were willing to talk to me, but one Iranian named Omid told me that this was the first Quds rally he’d been to, even though he lived in Iran, and that he was proud such a gathering was possible.

I met one neo-Nazi, who called himself Gene and was wearing a homemade T-shirt that read Assad Ist Gut (Assad is Good). I asked him how such a collection of politically disparate people could come together. His new friend, Tuna, who was Turkish, translated:

“Today we put apart our differences for Jerusalem and to stop the Jews. It’s easy.”

I asked Tuna how he felt about this and he just said yes. I tried to paraphrase that Amos Oz quote about how his father used to see graffiti in Europe that read “Jews, go back to Palestine” and later, after Israel was established, he’d see graffiti in Europe that read “Jews, get out of Palestine,” and asked them what they thought about this. Perhaps not understanding or thinking I was telling a joke, they both kind of chuckled.

There were two counter-demonstrations as well, one that took place right across the street and the other that was stationary near the terminus of the Quds Day rally. The counter-rally across the way was populated by some anti-fascists, some far-left activists, some German Social Democrats, a few Israeli members of the socialist Zionist group Hashomer Hatzair, some members of a German gay alliance dressed in drag, and some anti-Islamist and anti-Iran activists.

As I ambled over to the other side, going around a massive police presence with barricades, riot gear, and trucks, I stopped on the median to chat with a German named Uli (“short for Ulrich,” he courteously explained) who was looking on. I asked him which side he would choose between the two. He jerked his head toward the counter-demonstration.

“I’m not Jewish, but I choose the Israel side because democracy is most important. You have to listen to everyone. But you have to listen to the other side too because they say things that are important as well.”

Over at the counter-rally, there were speeches given in Hebrew, English, and German as well as fair bit of interluding bad techno music. Dr. Kazem Moussavi, a member of the Green Party of Iran, denounced the Iranian regime for its brutality and cruelty and spoke of Israel as a friend to the Iranian people. I spoke with Paul, one of the activists for the group Antifaschistische Aktion, who gave a brief speech to the crowd. He had a septum piercing and on the back of his right calf, he had a large tattoo in block script that read Support Israel in Hebrew. He explained to me briefly:

“It’s important for Germans to support Israel because it’s a democracy. Quds Day is fascist and anti-Semitic and that’s why I’ve come to protest it.”

Paul’s sentiments had been echoed earlier in the week by one of the biggest newspaper columnists in the country.

As the Quds Day rally across shoved off, the counter-rally went alongside it shouting pro-Israel slogans and waving Israeli flags. For those who are familiar with rallies that have to do with Israel, you can imagine what a surprise it is to see activists of the far left screaming defiantly in support of Israel. On the route, I struck up a conversation with a German student named Clemens about the disparity between the German left, some quarters of which contains a vibrant pro-Israel voice, and the rest of the European left, which…very much does not.

“Left-wing Germany is much more sensible than other groups,” he said. “We live in a post-fascist society here and so there’s a stronger feeling against anti-Semitism. In other countries, it’s the other way around. This [supporting Israel] is what we should have learned from our history.”

While we walked, a few random Germans jumped out of cafes or passed by screaming “Lang Lebe Israel!” As the march went on and both sides began hurling abuse at each other, the police eventually diverted the counter-rally off the main street. The group, undeterred, took the next block down and went back to the action. I asked Clemens if he felt it was okay to be critical of Israel.

“It’s not about backing all of their actions,” he said. “I’m here to make a definitive general statement. In a world full of anti-Semitism, we have to support it [Israel]. Israel means Jewish life.”

As we reached the protest again, the counter-demonstration joined a larger one, which was situated at a plaza and cordoned off by barricades. There both sides began shouting at the other again and parts of the Quds Day parade started pressing its way across the street. A phalanx of very tense, very alert German police kept both sides back and eventually drove police vans into the gaps between the crowds. The Quds Day crowd continued on its path while the pro-Israel crowd gathered at the plaza.

The larger counter-rally was made up of more Germans–Jewish and other, some Israelis, and a few Europeans and Americans. A few more speeches were given and then the Hatikvah was played while the police began to break down the barricades. Those who didn’t know the words hummed along.

WAIT, WHY DO I HAVE TO PAY TO COMMENT?
Tablet is committed to bringing you the best, smartest, most enlightening and entertaining reporting and writing on Jewish life, all free of charge. We take pride in our community of readers, and are thrilled that you choose to engage with us in a way that is both thoughtful and thought-provoking. But the Internet, for all of its wonders, poses challenges to civilized and constructive discussion, allowing vocal—and, often, anonymous—minorities to drag it down with invective (and worse). Starting today, then, we are asking people who'd like to post comments on the site to pay a nominal fee—less a paywall than a gesture of your own commitment to the cause of great conversation. All proceeds go to helping us bring you the ambitious journalism that brought you here in the first place.

I NEED TO BE HEARD! BUT I DONT WANT TO PAY.
Readers can still interact with us free of charge via Facebook, Twitter, and our other social media channels, or write to us at letters@tabletmag.com. Each week, we’ll select the best letters and publish them in a new letters to the editor feature on the Scroll.

We hope this new largely symbolic measure will help us create a more pleasant and cultivated environment for all of our readers, and, as always, we thank you deeply for your support.

“The chief rabbi of Lyon, Richard Wertenschlag, has received a letter threatening to “punish a Jew for every complaint the Jews make on TV.”
The threat came in a two-page letter delivered to Wertenschlag on Aug. 10. It contained two photos of a concentration camp, according to Dr. Richard Prasquier, president of the Representative Council of Jewish Institutions in France, CRIF.
Wertenschlag, who reported the letter to the authorities, opened the letter on Aug. 12, according to CRIF.
The authors of the “small, dense handwritten text” signed with the words “the righteous network.”
They added, “Every time you go on television to complain, a Jew – man, woman, child or family – will be punished.” Further down, the authors wrote: “See you soon at a synagogue, which has already been chosen.”
Wertenschlag called the letter “the expression of anti-Semitic rage and unimaginable hate.”
He said he had received an earlier hate letter in April, which was both “anti-Semitic and anti-Arab,” but decided not to go to police at the time.
Last month French police arrested two youths in Lyon for allegedly attacking a 17-year-old Jewish boy.
The boy is a student at Ozar Hatorah, a Jewish school in Toulouse where, on March 19, a Muslim extremist murdered three children and a rabbi.”

Well, this serves to show that the human condition is an immensely complicated one. Left and Right are just (in)convenient labels we apply to save ourselves the very real trouble of thinking out each situation and character on their own terms. Sometimes the labels mislead and lead to wrong conclusions.

curiously the best report about the al-quds-march and the counter-actions in berlin. the german newspapers didn’t inform themselves so good. also this one is quite entertaining to read.
but it has to be said, that (unfortunately) only a part of the far-left activists in germany understood that supporting israel is the right thing. since the 90s the whole radical left-wing movement is split up. the two groups which came into being where generally the so-called ‘antideutsche’ (anti-german, supporting israel, pointing out that the usa isn’t worse than any other state, also pointing out that a banker isn’t worse than a worker, because capitalism is a complex system, in which everyone sticks equally) versus the ‘antiimperialisten’ (anti-imperialists, hating israel, the usa, bankers).
sorry for my bad english…

Name (required)Email (required, will not be published)Website (optional)

Message

2000

Your comment may be no longer than 2,000 characters, approximately 400 words. HTML tags are not permitted, nor are more than two URLs per comment. We reserve the right to delete inappropriate comments.