Global Golf Post, May 8, 2017

globalgolfpost com MAY 8 2017 Red Light For Greens Books Justified WILMINGTON N C When the USGA and the R A surprised most people last week by announcing they were looking into the seemingly epidemic use of detailed greens books by players it was an encouraging sign for a couple of reasons Like the relatively swift reaction after the Lexi Thompson debacle the action on the greens books suggests the two ruling bodies are gaining a needed sense of immediacy It also offers hope that greens books will soon go the way of anchored putting strokes The statement read in part The R A and the USGA believe that a players ability to read greens is an essential part of the skill of putting We are concerned about the rapid development of increasingly detailed materials that players are using to help with reading greens during a round If youve watched a professional event recently youve become accustomed to seeing a player and his caddie stand behind their ball and study a book for which they paid 150 Youd pay 1000 if you had to one caddie said The book diagrams each green in intricate detail Arrows which look like a school of minnows in a confined space detail the various slopes on each green Another page details the degree of those slopes with the arrows included For example the book at Eagle Point last week had 181 slope readings on the ninth green There were too many arrows to count No matter where a player may be on any green the books tell them how a putt will break Golf balls as we all know have minds of their own and dont always do as theyre told but the books take much of the guesswork out of putting Ian Poulter is a man of many strong opinions and he was right when he recently tweeted this The tour books should be banned No one ever got their tour card because of those books The art of putting has been lost If you cant read a green thats your fault Its a point of discussion for a couple of reasons There is the obvious issue of how much information is too much information There is an art to putting Just watch Ben Crenshaw in his prime Tiger didnt use greens books and he made almost everything for a decade or more Jack Nicklaus Brad Faxon Steve Stricker Artists all Jordan Spieth would be a great putter blindfolded He uses the book So does Phil Mickelson So do plenty of players They are entitled to use whats allowed At the Open Championship last year at Royal Troon both Mickelson and Henrik Stenson had individual sheets of paper detailing the movement on each green I think probably we should ban the book Adam Scott said I have no scientific justification for that other than the ruling bodies make their decisions on what they feel a lot of the time just like maybe the anchored stroke If they feel that reading a green needs to be more of an art and its an advantage to a player whos creative great green reader then I wouldnt have a problem with that The books are also valuable for approach shots giving players an idea of how the ball will react when it lands at various places on a green There is also the pace of play question Its one more ingredient in the study stew that precedes virtually every putt now If you want to address slow play then you can take away one little part of it there Scott said You can make that argument to me that green reading is definitely a skill or an art that some people have an advantage if theyre really good at it and you may be levelling the field by giving everyone a book At the Ryder Cup last fall a handful of players on each side had access to Hazeltine National greens books mapped by a European Some players without the books felt at a disadvantage Davis Love III said As U S captain he raised the issue and European captain Darren Clarke arranged for every player to have the same book Im indifferent because I dont understand them Love said I use the old tricks to figure out which way its sloping Dr Bob Rotella would tell you that youre overthinking it overreading it Zach Johnson carries a book with him in tournaments but uses it primarily for long putts and for approach shots To me its like getting a yardage Johnson said Why cant I make my own Would it have the exact precise things I doubt it Im not suggesting theyre going to ban it I just dont understand the rationale The other big thing is were less than 1 percent of the golfing population The common amateur isnt going to use it so why touch it Thats why we should bifurcate our rules Ive been saying that for 20 years Ernie Els tried using the books but didnt care for them He said players can get books custom made for the way they putt Its too much he said Els too believes the use of such books should be banned I think reading the green is part of the game he said Weve got everything Weve got Trackman you practice and train the way you want you have coaches and equipment Weve got to do something ourselves l Read more from The Posts writers globalgolfpost com now No one ever got their tour card because of those books The art of putting has been lost If you cant read a green thats your fault Ian Poulter via Twitter THE TAKE RON GREEN JR E MAIL RON

View the Covers and the Table of Contents pages from every issue of this publication, all gathered together for easy browsing. Just flip pages and zoom as you normally do to see each issue's Cover and Table of Contents, then follow links directly to interesting content.