Former leading New Zealand publisher and bookseller, and widely experienced judge of both the Commonwealth Writers Prize and the Montana New Zealand Book Awards, talks about what he is currently reading, what impresses him and what doesn't, along with chat about the international English language book scene, and links to sites of interest to booklovers.

Thursday, February 07, 2013

Chick lit 'harms body image', study finds

Depressing stories ... Renee Zellweger in
the film version of Bridget Jones: The Edge of Reason. Photograph:
Allstar/Cinetext / Allstar Colle

Bridget Jones and the army
of weight-obsessed young heroines who followed in her footsteps have a lot to
answer for, according to academics, who have found that women's body image is
negatively affected by chick lit.

New research from Virginia
Tech, published
in the journal Body Image, analysed "the effect of protagonist body weight
and body esteem on female readers' body esteem", and concluded that "scholars
and health officials should be concerned about the effect chick lit novels might
have on women's body image". Co-author Melissa Kaminski, a chick lit fan, said
she was prompted to launch the study after noticing that "body image research
frequently looked at how visual images of thin women negatively affected women's
body esteem, [but] no research had examined how textual representations of body
esteem and body weight affected female readers' body esteem".

Researchers chose two chick
lit novels – Emily
Giffin's Something Borrowed, and Laura
Jensen Walker's Dreaming in Black and White, each of which features heroines
with "healthy body weight" but "low body esteem". They adapted a passage from
each of them to come up with nine versions for each novel, from an underweight
heroine with high body esteem to an overweight one with low body esteem, so
there might be a character who states: "I'm 5'4", 140lb, and a size six", or one
who says: "I'm 5'4", 105lb, and a size zero".

They then distributed the passages amongst 159 female university students,
who after reading them were then asked to rate how they felt about various body
parts and sexual attractiveness. The study found that when the narrative was
about a slim heroine, participants felt "significantly" less sexually
attractive, and that when it featured a protagonist with low body esteem,
readers were "significantly more concerned about their weight" than participants
in the control condition.

"The negative effects produced from the current study underscore the concern
of previous scholars for the potential effect of chick lit protagonists'
obsession with weight and appearance," write Kaminski and co-author Robert Magee
in the study, "Does this book make me look fat?". "Scholars and health officials
should be concerned about the effect novels have on women's body image,
especially since these issues could lead to disordered eating and other health
issues."

The academics suggest that a future study could look at using chick-lit
narratives as an "intervention tool" to fight poor body esteem in teenage
females, with the creation of stories in which characters with low body esteem
seek support from family and friends.