Transcription

1 Faculty Perspectives: A Comparison of Distance Education and Face-to-Face Courses Shanan G. Gibson, Department of Management, East Carolina University Greenville, North Carolina, Michael L. Harris, Department of Management, East Carolina University Greenville, North Carolina, ABSTRACT With the increasing demand for distance education and the need for faculty to embrace this as a viable teaching tool, faculty perceptions and expectations for distance education as compared with traditional face-to-face courses is an important issue. The current study asked faculty to make comparisons of the two teaching mediums across numerous dimensions. Introduction Distance learning is a broad term that encompasses both distance education (a term commonly used in academia) and distance training (a term commonly used in industry). The current paper examines faculty perceptions of distance education as defined by Bordeau and Bates (1997); education that is computer based, remote, or asynchronous and supported by some instructional system. The pros and cons of distance education are frequently debated at all levels of academia (Celsi and Wolfinbarger, 2001; Bryant, Kahle and Schafer, 2005). As educators we are greatly concerned with the degree to which our current educational practices prepare students to thrive in our ever-changing technological society. While there appears to be little consensus of judgment, most faculty agree that distance education is becoming more important as it provides an opportunity to service more students beyond a geographical location and to make improvements in operational efficiency and student service (Perreault, Waldman, Alexander and Zhao, 2002; Martins and Kellermans, 2004). This influx of students is typically seen as encouraging, because although additional demands are placed on the technological systems of the organization (computing networks, new hardware and software, etc.), there is not a corresponding demand for increased physical space associated with onsite students. Despite the positives, distance education is not without its skeptics. With the explosion of distance education programs in business schools, issues related to maintaining accreditation standards now permeate curriculum discussions. In fact, current American Association of Collegiate Schools of Business accreditation standards state that An institution that uses a variety of educational delivery systems at various locations must demonstrate comparable quality of its educational programs for all students. An institution must meet accreditation standards at all the various locations at which the included degree programs are delivered, or in the case of distance learning, standards must be met in all delivery modes (AACSB, 2005). Faculty has also expressed concerns related to distance education, particularly the technological problems associated with course delivery (Perreault et al., 2002; Crow, Cheek and Hartman, 2003). While challenges still exist, colleges and universities are facing increasing pressure from both internal

2 and external stakeholders including accrediting agencies, public agencies, and private organizations, to incorporate more technology into their curriculum (Driver, 2002). Distance education is not only challenging for many students; it also presents challenges for instructors to create a well-designed virtual learning environment (Kearsley, 2002). Shea, Motiwalla and Lewis (2001) found that most professors sampled from 68 higher education institutions relied primarily on asynchronous tools for their distance education courses; only 63% used live chat, 32% used streaming audio, and 28% used streaming video. The lack of personalized communication has been previously documented as an obstacle in the distance education learning environment (Perreault et al., 2002). Various recommendations in course design and administration have been offered to overcome potential obstacles, including the perceived lack of personalized communication. Berger (1999) suggests that distance education professors set up online office hours and incorporate live chat sessions into their virtual classes. Similarly, Perreault et al. (2002) recommend that professors strive to create distance education courses that promote interaction and collaboration via providing multiple means for communicating, including , discussion boards, online office hours and flexible telephone access. Further supporting these findings, Arbaugh and Benbunan- Fich (2006) report that separate from epistemological considerations, collaborative approaches to online course work result in better outcomes and higher levels of medium satisfaction. Riley and Gallo (2000) stressed the importance of incorporating all aspects of course design into a distance education environment. This includes providing the appropriate curriculum and teaching tools, as well as support, interaction, and selection of the best mix of technology tools. Daily (2000) equates the move to teaching a distance education course to the professor moving from an expert lecturer to more of a coach and mentor. The Current Study With the increasing demand for distance education and the need for faculty to embrace this as a viable teaching tool, faculty perceptions and expectations for distance education as compared with traditional face-to-face courses is an important issue. The current study reports faculty comparisons of the two teaching mediums across numerous dimensions. METHODS Research Setting, Participants, and Procedures As part of an on-going, multi-phase research endeavor examining distance learning, faculty associated with both a College of Business and a College of Education from a large regional university were asked to complete an anonymous survey regarding their perceptions of distance education. The response rate for the survey was 47%; 109 completed surveys (52% male, 45% female, and 3% undisclosed) were received from the 235 faculty that were invited to participate. The average age of faculty participants was 48 years old, with an average of 12.3 years teaching at the university level and an average of 2.1 years teaching online. Seventy-seven percent of respondents held a PhD/EdD/MD or other terminal degree and 23% had a MA/MS/MBA or other Masters level degree. With regard to academic rank, 22% of respondents were lecturers,

3 33% were assistant professors, 19% were associate professors, 19% were full professors, and 6% reported some other status or rank. Approximately 71% of participants teach undergraduate courses face-to-face, 28% of participants reported teaching undergraduate courses online, 49% teach graduate courses face-to-face, and 40% teach graduate courses online. Survey Instrument The survey instrument used for the current study was comprised of questions used in previous research on technology acceptance (Davis, 1989), distance education (Christensen, Anakwe and Kessler, 2001; Martins & Kellermanns, 2004), and other questions specific to the researchers' interests. RESULTS & DISCUSSION Table1 and Table 2 both depict the responses of faculty with regard to comparisons between traditional face-to-face courses and distance education courses. An examination of reported faculty perceptions indicates that faculty believes there are numerous differences between distance education and traditional face-to-face courses; although some things are thought to be quite comparable. For example, distance education courses were perceived to provide more flexibility for students, better cost efficiency, and even improved student-centered learning than do face-to-face courses. Likewise, faculty reported that at least comparable resources training, technological, and clerical, were available for distance education courses as for face to face teaching. Additionally, faculty felt that distance education provided greater opportunity to try new, innovative teaching techniques. However, faculty still felt that online courses provided less structure and likely included less professor-to-student interaction than does the traditional classroom setting. In addition to this, faculty reported than distance education courses are more time consuming in several ways time spent grading, responding to student , talking to students on the phone, and in overall course administration. Encouragingly, student motivation, performance, and learning were all perceived as being comparable across the two teaching media. Christensen et al. (2001) argue that online education is becoming more suitable for traditional learners as professors integrate more technological features into their virtual classrooms. As distance education courses become more sophisticated, they have greater success at mimicking the traditional classroom (Christensen et al., p. 276). The current study, while obviously a preliminary examination of faculty perceptions, indicates that distance education courses are also beginning to be seen by faculty as more and more like traditional face-to-face courses on several dimensions. As we continue to increase our understanding of faculty perceptions we will be better equipped to provide the support and resources necessary to allow faculty to best serve their diverse student populations by delivering the best possible courses.

SIMILAR MEDIA ATTRIBUTES LEAD TO SIMILAR LEARNING OUTCOMES Denise Potosky The Pennsylvania State University dxp16@psu.edu ABSTRACT In this paper, a theoretical framework developed for comparing personnel

Asynchronous Learning Networks in Higher Education: A Review of the Literature on Community, Collaboration & Learning Jennifer Scagnelli CREV 580 Techniques for Research in Curriculum and Instruction Fall

Classrooms Without Walls: A Comparison of Instructor Performance in online Courses Differing in Class Size Chris Sorensen, Ph.D. Assistant Professor College of Education Ashford University San Diego, CA,

STUDENT ATTITUDES TOWARDS SOCIAL NETWORKS AND LEARNING MODALITIES Alison M. Wolfe, Elmira College ABSTRACT Social networks such as Facebook, MySpace and others have become an integral part of student life.

Strategies for Orientation. 1 Running head: STRATEGIES FOR ORIENTATION Strategies for Designing An Orientation for Online Students Norma Scagnoli University of Illinois at Urbana Champaign Strategies for

COURSE COORDINATION: A MAINSTAY IN ACCOUNTING EDUCATION Holly R. Rudolph, DBA, CPA Professor of Accounting Department of Accounting College of Business and Public Affairs Murray State University Murray,

Asynchronous Learning Networks and Student Outcomes: The Utility of Online Learning Components in Hyhrid Courses Daniel L. DeNeui and Tiffany L. Dodge The current research focuses on the impact that learning

ENGAGING STUDENTS IN ONLINE CLASSES WITH WIMBA: A PRELIMINARY STUDY Camille F. Rogers Georgia Southern University cfrogers@georgiasouthern.edu ABSTRACT This paper discusses the issue of keeping students

THE THEORY OF PLANNED BEHAVIOR AND ITS ROLE IN TECHNOLOGY ACCEPTANCE OF ELECTRONIC MEDICAL RECORDS IMPLEMENTATION Elaine Seeman, Department of Management Information Systems College of Business, East Carolina

& Asynchronous Synchronous E-Learning A study of asynchronous and synchronous e-learning methods discovered that each supports different purposes By Stefan Hrastinski Today s workforce is expected to be

Instructional Strategies: What Do Online Students Prefer? Kristen Cuthrell Assistant Professor East Carolina University College of Education Curriculum and Instruction Greenville, NC USA cuthrellma@ecu.edu

GRADUATE FACULTY PERCEPTIONS OF ONLINE TEACHING Sharon Santilli and Vesna Beck Nova Southeastern University The participants for this study were 47 doctoral faculty from Nova Southeastern University Fischler

VIEWS OF STUDENTS IN THE DEPARTMENT OF RECREATION AND SPORT MANAGEMENT ON DISTANCE EDUCATION Asst.Prof.Dr.Gülten Hergüner Sakarya University Physical Education and Sports Teaching Department herguner@sakarya.edu.tr

The Effect of Software Facilitated Communication on Student Outcomes in Online Classes Stuart S. Gold, DeVry University Online Abstract This research project examined the question of the relationship between

Offering On Line Courses: Policy Issues For The Small College Pete Gomori, St. Francis College Introduction Some critics of the U.S. post secondary education system often express concern about declining

Comparing the Distance Learning-Related Course Development Approach and Faculty Support and Rewards Structure at AACSB Accredited Institutions between 2001 and 2006 Heidi Perreault, Missouri State University

THE ROLE OF OCCUPATIONAL VALUES IN ELECTRONIC MEDICAL RECORDS IMPLEMENTATION Shanan G. Gibson, Department of Management College of Business, East Carolina University (252) 328-6354, gibsons@ecu.edu Elaine

158 THE DESIGN AND DELIVERY OF EFFECTIVE WEB-BASED INSTRUCTION: AN ANALYSIS OF FACULTY CONCERNS R. Nicholas Gerlich, West Texas A&M University LaVelle Mills, West Texas A&M University ABSTRACT This paper

ANIMATING DISTANCE LEARNING: THE DEVELOPMENT OF AN ONLINE LEARNING COMMUNITY Mary Quinn, DBA, Assistant Professor Malone College Canton, Ohio Abstract The number of students enrolled in distance learning

DESIGNING A HYBRID CLASS IN ACCOUNTING: HOW TO GET MAXIMUM MILEAGE? Gaurav Kumar Assistant Professor Department of Accounting, College of Business University of Arkansas at Little Rock 2801 S University

The Management of the International Online Distance Learning Program in Thailand Krisda Tanchaisak Assumption University krisda2009@yahoo.com Abstract Online learning is popular throughout the world however

Session No. 1648 Distance Learning: Facts, Failures, Foibles, and the Future Robert Easton and John Stratton College of Applied Science and Technology Rochester Institute of Technology Abstract: Within

and Mentoring of Adjunct Business Faculty Kathleen Vinlove, PhD Park University Department of Accounting, Economics, and Finance ABSTRACT As colleges and universities face increasing pressure to increase

Where has the Time Gone? Faculty Activities and Time Commitments in the Online Classroom B. Jean Mandernach, Swinton Hudson, & Shanna Wise, Grand Canyon University USA Abstract While research has examined

A Study of Student Attitudes and Performance in an Online Introductory Business Statistics Class Sue B. Schou Idaho State University ABSTRACT Due to economic constraints, more and more distance education

A COMPARISON OF COLLEGE AND HIGH SCHOOL STUDENTS IN AN ONLINE IT FOUNDATIONS COURSE Amy B. Woszczynski Kennesaw State University awoszczy@kennesaw.edu Debra Bass Geist Kennesaw State University dgeist1@students.kennesaw.edu

EFFECTIVE ONLINE INSTRUCTION IN HIGHER EDUCATION Heather Glynn Crawford-Ferre and Lynda R. Wiest University of Nevada, Reno Online education has emerged as an effective and increasingly common alternative

GLOBAL CHALLENGES FOR ENGINEERING EDUCATORS: LESSONS FROM AN ONLINE MASTERS DEGREE FOR PRACTICING ENGINEERS Don Schramm Program Director, Engineering Professional Development Director, University of Wisconsin-Disaster

Review of Research on Online High School Recovery Programs Titinesha Llewellyn Mastery learning is an approach used by many online programs designed to support students in gaining the content knowledge

AC 2007-481: COMMUNITY COLLEGE TEACHER PROFESSIONAL DEVELOPMENT Theodore Branoff, North Carolina State University Ted Branoff is an associate professor of Graphic Communications in the Department of Mathematics,

MANAGING DISTANCE EDUCATION CLASSES BY CERTIFYING INSTRUCTORS Scott Mensch, Indiana University of Pennsylvania ABSTRACT When developing online classrooms it is necessary to ensure that all learners will

Journal of Research and Reflections in Education December 2011, Vol.5, No.2, pp 128-145 http://www.ue.edu.pk/jrre Impact of Technology on Business Schools: Perceptions of Faculty & Management Ashi Zeeshan,

1 E-learning: Students perceptions of online learning in hospitality programs Sungmi Song Hospitality Management Iowa State University Robert Bosselman Hospitality Management Iowa State University ABSTRACT

1 of 10 Distance Learning Programs for Non-Traditional and Traditional Students in the Business Disciplines Dana V. Tesone Rosen School of Hospitality Management University of Central Florida dtesone@mail.ucf.edu

An exploratory study of student motivations for taking online courses and learning outcomes ABSTRACT Sarath A. Nonis Arkansas State University Grant H. Fenner Arkansas State University An investigation