Keith Hackett's verdict

1) It's simple enough: the goalkeeper has failed to save a ball which has hit the post and gone in. He's trying it on. The flight of the ball was not altered by the puncture it sustained on hitting the frame of the goal, so the kick counts and the result stands. The laws are explicit on this sort of scenario: only if the ball had clearly burst after being kicked, but before it hit the post, would you award a retake. Jonny Davidson wins the shirt. 2) No. It's a competitive tournament, and competition rules have to be adhered to. This may not be the World Cup, but it's still important in any competition to make sure everything is fair. If the rules state extra time must be played, then it must be played, but you can, of course, allow water breaks. Thanks to Matt Hunt. 3) Play on. You would stop the game only if the defender had been guilty of violent conduct, which is a deliberate act. Fouls are penalised only if committed on opponents, and dangerous play as such is no longer defined in the laws. Thanks to Euan Hill.