There are a lot of things Squeenix likes to call a lot of their crap by pretentious names rather the things they should be calling it.

Capcom called RE6 "dramatic horror" and some fans after knowing this got annoyed at Capcom because they weren't getting the same game they played back in 1998. The Tales series has classy names for some of their Mothership titles too and I don't think anybody gets crazy about that.

Point is that these classy titles are there mainly to give an idea to the public of the direction they are going with the game more than anything else.

The problem with horror is that many people confuse horror for "it has to be scary", which is ridiculous. By all means, even the latest Resident Evil is a horror game. It has taken a turn for action, but it's still horror.

Personally, I don't see what the fuzz is about Resident Evil turning into an action series. As long as they're continuing the plotline that they have established over the past games, it makes perfect sense. The monsters were designed to be bio-organic weapons to be employed in warfare to begin with.

Thanks - believe me, not all of us were 100% in agreement with the list either. But it was a list we were all willing to accept. :) You might actually be surprised at how much work one of these lists takes. (Which partially explains why we don't do many of them here.) We've got our "best of DS" list coming, and I talk a little more about the process in the intro to it.

When you're arguing between a large group of people, I understand that it could be difficult to assemble a list like that. It makes me feel 130% more justified in blaming Derek for forcing Ys Chronicles up there. Don't try to deny it, Embryon-senpai.

Quote

Valkyria Chronicles II, Disgaea 1, and Breath of Fire III all came close to making the list. :)

It's unfortunate that so many of the games on the list are remakes... but depending on whether you had played them before (I hadn't), it may be unfortunate that those were simply the best games on the system. :(

Yeah, like I said: I wasn't complaining, but it's true. And a little unfortunate.

Quote

The Monster Hunter series is one that we've decided doesn't fit our coverage - I actually reviewed Monster Hunter Freedom (the one before Unite), and it spurred much debate, resulting in that decision. But how about if I offer the beginning of what my review would have said as a consolation prize?

Quote

Dear Reader,

I didn't want to be the one to have to tell you this, but our friendship means a lot to me, so I'm going to do it anyway. I know Monster Hunter Freedom looks cool, and does fun stuff, but it really doesn't like you "that way." It's cool if you come along with your friends, but when it's just you and Monster Hunter alone, it's just not the same. No hard feelings, OK?

-John T.

Monster Hunter Freedom is two games before Unite. The PSP games go Freedom, Freedom 2, Freedom Unite. In Japan that lineage of PSP MH games is Portable / Portable 2nd / Portable 2nd G / Portable 3rd. For the past year and a half I've been hoping for a Vita G version of Portable 3rd, but alas it hasn't happened.

And re: imported stuff. Well, OF COURSE. Here, I'll make a top 5 important Japanese RPGs right now, without even leaving this tab. Let's see....

I think Popolocrois could have been on there in place of something that's a handheld version of an existing game.

Oh no it couldn't. At least four staffers have played it, and only one liked it. One thought it was OK, and the other two hated it. Sorry. :)

I've seen a number of people (not just here) say that they're disappointed that there were so many remakes... but it's not the list's fault. It's the system's. (If anyone wonders, there were 11 remakes and 9 originals on the list.)

So I've taken the list and redone things to see what would have happened if we took out remakes. It would have been ugly. We would have had to dig so deep that in order to have a top 20 list, we'd have three games that we rated "below average" in the ratings we made for the purposes of this list. So we probably would have just cut it to a "top 10" list and added Unchained Blades as #10.

When you're arguing between a large group of people, I understand that it could be difficult to assemble a list like that. It makes me feel 130% more justified in blaming Derek for forcing Ys Chronicles up there. Don't try to deny it, Embryon-senpai.

Surprisingly, four of us picked that one to make it somewhere on the list, and Derek was the lowest! He voted for it to be somewhere between 16 and 20. :)

Oh - and sorry about the goof on Monster Hunter game order. Actually, a friend just showed me one of the DS games a few days ago, and it really made me want to pick it up...

I think Popolocrois could have been on there in place of something that's a handheld version of an existing game.

Oh no it couldn't. At least four staffers have played it, and only one liked it.

That would be me! :D

I giggled xD

Dammit, Fan. You shoulda made a Top 30 for the weird delinquent titles that have trouble finding a loving home!

Though, I think the list does encapsulate a good "general" scope. God...really makes me question my taste in PSP games given the amount of remake/ports. It's not a bad thing of course....not necessarily a good thing either though...

I was with the list until #1. I think P3P is a pale imitation of the original, since it removes so much of what made the original a classic.

Anyway, I like it besides that. I think Growlanser IV certainly deserves a mention, and possibly Crimson Gem Saga.

Are you talking about the difficulty or the lack of animated cut scenes and walking around in P3P? I didn't mind the lack of cut scenes but the difficulty bugged me a bit. Being able to control the other party members was awesome but I felt it destroyed the difficulty. It seemed like the enemy AI still acted as if you only controlled the main character.

Thought the option to play as a girl was great and they even added in new social links. Only thing I felt was missing from it was The Answer and that kind of felt like filler in P3 FES anyway.

I was surprised that Growlanser IV didn't make the cut as I loved it. I was also disappointed but not that surprised that Brave Story: New Traveller didn't. Loved the game to bits but it is about as traditional as you get.

Oh, I just had a thought: Hexyz Force. Totally okay game. The only Sting game I've ever bothered to finish, in fact. I would have been okay with Hexyz Force in the 17-20 range, but L-O-L higher than that would be silly.