Israelis divided over military drafting of ultra-Orthodox Jews

Mar 13, 2018

March 13, 2018

By Elana Ringler

JERUSALEM (Reuters) – A decades-old exemption of ultra-Orthodox Jews from compulsory military service is a deeply divisive issue in Israel at the heart of a cabinet crisis that could lead to an early election.

A preliminary vote in parliament on a new bill that would maintain the exemption is expected on Tuesday. One faction in Prime Minister Benjamin Netanyahu’s six-party coalition government has vowed to defy him and oppose the legislation.

That could cause Netanyahu’s government to unravel, setting the stage for the possible dissolution of parliament and a snap election in which he would seek a new mandate to help survive corruption allegations threatening his political survival.

The exemption enjoyed by ultra-Orthodox seminary students has long caused friction in Israel, where Jewish women and men are called up for military service at the age of 18.

Army service for most lasts for two to three years and many who do not enlist perform alternative national service in the community, at schools, hospitals, and different organizations.

The ultra-Orthodox, or Haredim, say their study of the Torah is vital for the continued survival of the Jewish people and also fear that young men serving in the army would stray from the religious path.

Outside a military recruitment office in Jerusalem, 16-year-old Hananel Twito, a Haredi Jew, said his community has suggested he opt out of army service.

“I received a draft notice. For now, I still want to check. At the age of 18 I’ll choose if I want to be recruited or not. For now, I’ve postponed because I still want to check if it’s worth going or not,” Twito said.

Last September, Israel’s Supreme Court gave parliament a year to pass a new conscription bill after declaring parts of the existing exemption unconstitutional.

Many Israelis feel the exemption is simply unfair. Many Haredi men who devote themselves to religious studies do not have jobs and rely on state stipends and benefits.

“You are a part of this nation, you will take part of this burden,” said David Cohen, a 26-year-old technician.

Haredim make up about 10 percent of Israel’s population of 9 million.

Smadar Goldstein, who runs an education company in Jerusalem, said all Israelis should enlist to defend their country. “They should go into the army, why shouldn’t they? There’s no reason any more. I’m a religious Jew as well; my son is going into the army next year,” she said.