Andy Cohen's Quest to Lose His 'Gold Star Gay' Status Almost Ended with a Threesome

Andy Cohen prides himself on being a “gold star gay,” which means he’s never hooked up with a woman. However, that almost changed during a stop on his book tour — and he tells most of the story in his new book, Superficial: More Adventures from the Andy Cohen Diaries.

“It’s one of my favorite parts of the book because I think it’s fascinating to hear about what it’s like to do that,” the Watch What Happens Live host tells PEOPLE and Entertainment Weekly Editorial Director Jess Cagle during an EW SiriusXM Town Hall taped for the latest installment of The Jess Cagle Interview.

While he was in Boston, Cohen met a heterosexual couple from New Hampshire who were very eager to hangout with him and gave off “a really interesting vibe” that told him “this was maybe more than a hang out.”

“I was like, ‘This shocking to me,’ because I’m strictly d—ly,” he says in the interview.

Watch the full episode of The Jess Cagle Interview, available now on the new People/Entertainment Weekly Network (PEN). Go to PEOPLE.com/PEN, or download the PEN app on Apple TV, Roku Players, Amazon Fire TV, Xumo, Chromecast, iOS, and Android devices.

“SJP via from email from Italy, she said, ‘Please remember every detail.’ Mark Consuelos [said], ‘Dude!’ Kelly: ‘Jake is very handsome and Angela is beautiful. I am very happy for you,'” says Cohen, reading from his book, which hits stands Tuesday.