Two Cups Too Many for All the Presidents Men

By

The question is whether a world-class collection of players at Royal Montreal have enough left to fill the Presidents Cup with the kind of golf that has made these matches so compelling over the last few years.

Tiger Woods, who plays fewer golf tournaments than any other star, will be competing for the sixth time in nine weeks. Ditto for Phil Mickelson, who usually shuts it down this time of year. Even an ironman like Vijay Singh has spent an awful lot of time inside the ropes, skipping only two weeks since August.

Mike Weir practices Tuesday before the home country crowd. (WireImage)

Blame that on the FedExCup, a four-week bonanza that ended only nine days ago for 16 players in the Presidents Cup. It only figures to get tougher next year, with the Ryder Cup scheduled for the week after the TOUR Championship.

As much as players are cursing the schedule, it could turn out to be a blessing.

'You would think that you're pretty prepared to be here, maybe more so than years past, because of playing so much golf recently,' David Toms said Tuesday. 'I think that's something they need to take a look in the future, how much golf is being played at this particular time. For us this year, I know we have a lot of guys who are coming in and playing well, and it should be an advantage for us.'

Indeed, the FedExCup could be a good barometer for these matches when they get under way Thursday.

Woods is playing a lot of golf, but playing well. He has won four of the five tournaments he has played dating to the Bridgestone Invitational, including his last two to easily win the FedExCup. The other two playoff events were won by Phil Mickelson (Deutsche Bank) and Steve Stricker (Barclays).

Since all 24 players from the United States and International teams are PGA TOUR members, an even better barometer might be the 30-man field at the TOUR Championship.

Ten Americans were at East Lake, the exception being Toms (No. 32) and Lucas Glover (No. 35). The International team had only six players in the Tour Championship, and two of the players -- Mike Weir and Retief Goosen -- didn't even qualify for the 70-man field the previous week at the BMW Championship.

'Our team has been really playing well,' U.S. captain Jack Nicklaus said. 'I think they are well prepared.'

Nicklaus tried to make the case the International team is stronger on paper, which is usually the norm. Comprised of players from all but European countries, the team has an average world ranking of 18.5, with Weir the lowest at No. 46. The United States has an average ranking of 21.9, with Glover the lowest at No. 61.

International captain Gary Player, however, was quick to point out the United States was top-heavy in the world ranking with Woods, Mickelson, Jim Furyk and Stricker the new 'Big Four.' It is believed to be the first time in the 21-year history of the world ranking Americans have occupied the top four spots.

While the International team looks good on paper, it hasn't looked good in competition lately. The most recent winner is K.J. Choi at the AT&T National in July. Angel Cabrera hasn't done much since his U.S. Open victory in June, and Singh played five consecutive tournaments over par until finishing 10 under at easy East Lake.

Even so, Player had reason to believe 'the stage is set for another great match.'

The last two have been so close they essentially were decided by one shot -- Chris DiMarco's 15-foot birdie putt on the final hole of the final match in 2005 at the Robert Trent Jones Golf Club in Virginia. The matches ended in a tie in South Africa in 2003.

'I think that the whole 'on paper' is kind of a farce,' Furyk said. 'If we have a tour that's deep enough where 100 guys can go out on any week and win a tournament, then 12 of the best players from any side can go out and win that week. A lot of it is momentum. Obviously, you don't want to get behind early.'

Closing out matches is equally important, as the International team learned last time.

Of the 12 matches that went to the 18th hole in 2005, the Americans won five and halved seven. That included DiMarco's match against Stuart Appleby that set off a rare but wild celebration with Nicklaus at the center.

'To be on the losing end, it was pretty gutting,' Appleby said. 'The entire team felt like I did.'

Appleby is one of only three players on the International team who have known the feeling of winning the Presidents Cup. The others are Ernie Els and Singh, the three of them on the 1998 that whipped the United States in Australia.

Appleby looks at that '98 team and wonders how it did so well. It featured Frank Nobilo, who was nearing the end of his career, and Carlos Franco, who was making his way through Q-school.

'We've come a long way as an International team, and we need to start winning,' he said. 'We have the desire. We all want to be here. But we have to taste victory. It's been a while.'