Cashman comes off as a general manager that thinks big picture, so it’s hard to believe a playoff run changed thinking here. Does that mean Girardi’s fate was sealed at some point during the season?

YouTube

Why isn't Girardi the best person for the job now?

In 2008, Girardi emerged from a mix that included Tony Pena and franchise legend Don Mattingly to become the next Yankees manager. In 10 seasons, 910 victories, six postseason trips, four ALCS trips and a World Series commenced.

Yet after all that—including a MLB-best 200 games over .500 during the stretch—Girardi is now no longer the best man for the job? Why? What changed? Was it Girardi or the position itself?