Reflections, thoughts and shenanigans of a professional pole dancer. www.michelleshimmy.com

Friday, 26 July 2013

The Proliferation, Professionalisation and Sanitisation of Pole Competitions: Part 1 The Cleaning Up of Pole Competitions

The Cleaning Up of Pole Dance Competitions – Professionalism or Sterilisation??

I’ve been competing in pole competitions for about six years now. I have been a competitor in all kinds of pole competitions, from dodgy pub competitions, to national championships, and all the way to the international stage. Some competitions are well-oiled machines that run without a hitch, and others are so terribly organised that in the end, I've regretted entering them. Some competition organisers treat their competitors with respect and consideration, and some... well, some don’t.

The Proliferation of Competitions

During the 6 years that I’ve been competing, a lot has happened in the pole industry. The competition circuit has exploded, with dozens of new competitions appearing every year. As the pole industry grows larger, competition amongst competitions also increases. New competitions make big promises, and try to differentiate themselves from the others on the scene. Dissatisfaction with the way some competitions are run is often the reason why new comps appear, as the organisers try to do a better job than their predecessors. These days, competitions are becoming more professional and streamlined. Gone are the days when it was a common occurrence that the pole would fall down, a competitor would arrive drunk, that the judging panel would be the comp organiser's boyfriend/hairdresser/spraytanner, or that an audience member would try to climb on stage and gyrate against the competitor. These days, many competitions are so professional and efficiently run that they are almost corporate-like.I've noticed two changes in the competition scene over the past couple of years. The first is that the judging criteria are becoming more refined, and demanding. Competitors are expected to be all-rounders, and to satisfy all elements of the criteria in their routines. Generally speaking, competitors must demonstrate strength, flexibility, dynamism, athleticism, grace, dance skill, acrobatic skill, and of course, pole skill. This topic will be the subject of a future blog post.The second change I've noticed (and the topic of today’s blog post) is that in an effort to make pole dance competitions seem more serious, and more legitimate, the rules and regulations governing participation in the various competitions have multiplied to the point where a competitor really needs to sit down with a glass of wine and dinner to be able to make it through reading everything they need to know about the competition. (**Unless of course it's one of those competitions that bans wine-drinking and food-eating during the perusal of the rules and regulations.)

The sanitisation of pole competitions

I’ve noticed a common theme as I’ve been travelling around Europe visiting studios and teaching workshops. At the end of my Signature Tricks & Combos workshop, I usually finish by teaching a small piece of choreography, using one of the combos taught in the workshop, and in my style of dance. On this tour, the choreography I taught was slow, sensual and sexy.Often, after having finished the choreography and the workshops, students chat to me about pole dance in their country, and how it differs from what they've just learnt with me. On numerous occasions, I heard the same complaints and frustrations voiced. Students complained about the strictness (even puritanism) of their national championships, particularly with respect to costuming, and the outright banning of any sensual or sexual style of performance. The rules I most often hear pole dancers complain about are:

Being disqualified for an accidental costume malfunction;

Being required to cover the “gluteal crease” (?);

Being required to cover cleavage;

Being strictly forbidden from touching their own bodies in any way that hints at sensuality;

Banning of shoes; and

Banning of music containing swear words.

To me, the above rules seem to go beyond what is necessary for a respectable competition. I would just like to point out that the following video of a small child dancing is exactly the kind of performance that would not be permitted in many national/international pole dance championships. Note the boots, the costume, the hair flicks, the booty popping... Banned by many pole competitions. Yet there is nothing offensive about this child's awesomeness. If she is a child, and we are adults, why are we forbidden to dance this way in so many competitions, if we should decide we want to?

Is sexy pole dance a legitimate and artistic style of dance?

Those of you that know me, and my style of dance, will probably assume they know what my stance on this issue is. However, I want to make it clear that I see both sides of the debate. I understand that there are some very active individuals in the pole community who are trying to promote pole dance as a fitness activity or as an art form – one that has no links whatsoever to the sex industry or to strip clubs. They seek public and mainstream acceptance of the legitimacy of pole dance, which they believe will come from severing all ties with its origins. I understand that a lot of pole dancers want to see their favourite activity recognised for what it is: a complex and challenging form of physical exertion, which more often than not has absolutely zero to do with strip clubs and stripping.On the other hand… We are all adults, and we have all chosen to participate in pole dance for different reasons. Many pole dancers took their first class because they were attracted to the “sexy” side. I know I did. As a fully grown (if not 100% mature at all times) consenting adult, I resent being told how to dress and how to perform. Especially when the unspoken message is that there is something wrong or dirty with the way I like to dance.Sexy means different things to different people, but whether it be slow and sensual, fast and aggressive, badass and full of swagger, or however you choose to interpret "sexy" - it's almost always banned by the big, important competitions. In my opinion, the crux of the issue is this: the problem with the “sanitisation” of pole competitions is that it creates a tiered level of what world-class or elite pole dancing should look like, and excludes performers who prefer the “sexy” style of pole dance (for want of a better term). I’m not saying that this is done intentionally by competition organisers. I believe that pole competition organisers are genuinely doing their best to have pole taken more "seriously". However, by implication at least, the rules of many international and national competitions seem to suggest that if you are not the kind of pole performer that shuns sensual dancing, high heels, bikinis and black eyeliner, then you are not an artistic/serious/legitimate performer, and therefore you can’t compete for the chance to call yourself a world class, champion pole dancer. I love to watch pretty much all styles of pole dance. I have been an Alethea Austin fan since the first time I saw her freestyle YouTube videos years ago, but at the same time I love watching Natalia Tatarintseva’s rhythmic gymnast flexibility and grace. I think Alessandra Marchetti is a stunning performer and athlete, and her wining performance at the World Pole Sports this year thrilled me. Anne-Marie Davies is a dynamite and electrifying performer, and Lolo Hilsum is mesmorising to watch on the ground and in the air. Michelle Stanek is fierce and commanding on stage, and Natasha Wang is pure elegance and poetry on the pole. As for Felix Cane – well, I love Felix Cane bare foot, in high heels, heck – I even love her in ugg boots!Similarly, when performing, sometimes I dance in heels, and sometimes I dance barefoot. Last year, I competed in Miss Pole Dance Australia with a booty-shaking, shoe-banging, body-rolling, drop-splitting routine, telling the story of a prima ballerina turned wild. MPDA is one of the few national competitions that permit booty-shaking, shoe-banging, body-rolling and drop-splitting. In fact, at MPDA, it is compulsory to wear heels, which is unusual these days.Ironically, coming second in MPDA earned me an invitation to compete at the 2013 World Pole Sports, a competition that bans booty-shaking, shoe-banging, body-rolling and drop-splitting (unfortunately, I wasn’t able to take part in the World Pole Sports this year, as it conflicted with my tour schedule, but I loved watching the live stream online). Recently, I also competed in the Australian Pole Fitness Championships earlier this year (which bans shoes, sensuality, swear words, skimpy costumes, etc). I abided by the competition rules, and danced barefoot and demure. I was happy and honoured to place third. I’ve competed at the Australian Pole Championships, where you can choose to dance barefoot or in heels, and in that competition, I chose to dance barefoot. When I free dance, alone, in my own studio, it's usually in heels, in the semi-darkness, to a slow and sensual song - just me, my music and my dance. That's when I really feel like I'm dancing for myself - true to my own style, without having to please anyone. And sometimes late at night, I'll lock the studio, make sure no one's around, crank up some crazy music and run wild in the studio dancing barefoot like a crazy monkey on too much sugar (but I do not record these sessions!). So you see, I’m not a die-hard stripper heel addict, and I genuinely love pretty much all styles of pole dance. However, I freely admit that the main reason I started pole dance is because I loved the freedom and the sensuality of it, and that’s what keeps me coming back for more. To me, the sexy style of pole dance is as much an art form as any other, and a legitimate form of expression. But sometimes I wonder if those of us who remain faithful to the origins of pole dance, and want see them celebrated onstage, are a dying breed…

Conclusion?

I think that the fact that pole dancers now have dozens of competitions to choose from is a good thing. Pole dance means many things to many people. As the industry grows, no doubt particular dance styles will develop and move in different directions. In the same way that hip-hop as a genre encompasses the sub-categories of breaking, popping, locking, turfing, jerkin’ and krumping (at least, that’s what Wikipedia tells me – I have no idea about hip hop!), pole dance may well be on its way to becoming the banner term for a variety of sub-categories. Pole dancers who wish to dance barefoot against other barefoot competitors can do so. Pole dancers who wish to go full glitz and compete in heels and sequins can. Pole dancers who consider it a sport can compete against other like-minded individuals. In my eyes, all these styles are valid and legitimate. The only issue that concerns me is that with the way most competitions are headed, pole dancers who wish to be taken seriously in the industry, and have their achievements recognised at an international competition level, may end up feeling pressured to dance a particular way. One of the most beautiful characteristics of the pole community is that it is so diverse, and so accepting. I’ve shared poles with mums, uni students, strippers, men (gay and straight), transgender pole dancers, dancers with disabilities, big dancers, tiny dancers – in short – all walks of humanity. I would hate to see our industry lose its acceptance and appreciation of the artistry and beauty of sensual, sexy pole dance. To put it plainly, I want to see more sexy pole dance at an elite level. I want to see more elite level competitions support the sexy side of pole dance. I want the particular brand of artistic expression that is sexy/sensual pole dance to be recognised as such, at an elite level. So what can we do about it, when the overwhelming trend seems to be the removal of any and all elements of sensuality or sexuality from international/national pole dance competitions?

Take your sexy dancing to the stage!

At the Pole Dance Academy, we are doing our bit to support and provide opportunities for sexy pole dancers to compete. This year we launched Dance Filthy, which is an Amateur and Professional competition that celebrates the sexy side of pole dance. On 15 September 2013, we will hold the first ever Pole Theatre, a competition requiring competitors to enter one of four categories: Pole Art, Pole Drama, Pole Comedy, and Pole Classique. In contrast to many other competitions, Pole Theatre seeks to impose a bare minimum of rules and restrictions on competitors. Competitors are encouraged to express themselves and their creativity onstage, with a focus on performance. However, we do insist on two slightly unusual rules in one of the categories. In the category of Pole Classique, competitors are required to wear heels for part of their performance, and they also are required to remove at least one item of clothing (and they are permitted to strip all the way down to a g-string and pasties, if they wish). In Pole Classique, we want to showcase sexy pole dance as an art form, and we want to create a platform for dancers who prefer this style of dance to perform and compete, at an elite level. United Pole Artists just finished another successful Bringing Sexy Back, for the second year. This is a two-week celebration of sexy pole dance, UPA encourages pole dancers to post and tag their sexy pole videos. This event is sponsored and massively promoted by Bad Kitty. As a Bad Kitty Brand Ambassador, I absolutely love that Bad Kitty embraces both the fitness AND the sexy side of pole. In addition to all the fun and sexy pole related gear on their website, they are the makers of PoleFit, a brand of pole wear that is sporty, fun, with a touch of sexy. After all, as Jack Gaffney himself says (one of the Head Cats at Bad Kitty), "We are Bad Kitty, not good kitty, after all =^.^=".

I love the time of year that is Bringing Sexy Back - it's amazing to see all the sexy pole dancers emerging from the shadows to proudly post their sexy style pole videos! But at the same time, I don’t want to see sexy pole dance relegated to studio freestyles and nightclub performances. It deserves a place on the big stage. As a member of the pole community, I do my bit to support good competitions and their competitors – no matter what the style. I support clear judging criteria and professionally-run competitions, but I feel like some competitions are imposing unnecessary restrictions on competitors’ creativity, and are letting down some would-be competitors by failing to create space for their style of dance. Why do we care so much about stripping the sexuality away from pole (if you’ll pardon the pun)? Is acceptance of pole dance by the general public really so important? I don’t know. I kind of think that it’s time that we stopped trying to seek acceptance by the mainstream, and started making more room for pole dancers to dance how they want to dance. Dance your way! Shimmy xxxPS "X-Pole My Way" is part of X-Pole Australia's campaign - and one of the many reasons I'm so proud to be an X-Pole Ambassador. I love the words on the poster below - "Create your own pole style. X-Pole. Your pole, your way." Words to live by :-)

27 comments:

I've always thought we have enough pole fitness competitions and it would be great to have a pole competition devoted to being sensual and smooth. Or maybe a prize at competitions the way we have prizes for best entertainer or best costume - a prize for Miss Sex Appeal lol ;)

What I love about pole is that you can bring anything to it and make it your own. It can be about fitness, but it can also be about feeling sexy. You can incorporate ballet or gymnastics or burlesque or martial arts or any form of movement - it's a very creative form of dance that is personal to you.

Shimmy, you were right about hip-hop culture, its growing more and more every day so as pole-dancing, but the first one has more freely form, there are no rules almost, you just have to feel the beat, and wins the one who better can transform it into moves. As pole-dance requires good physical shape and a lot of sport skills it goes to the technical part of dance not just as expression of your personality. Nice article, thank you!!!

Shimmy, I love it! This reminds me a little of a post I wrote last month for UPA ... "In Defense of Exotic Dancers." I'm super proud of that piece, and if it changes not one single mind, it's still important to me that I wrote it. http://unitedpoleartists.blogspot.com/2013/06/in-defense-of-exotic-dancers.html

Thank you so much for saying this. I was having this exact conversation with Aimee (StarrGrrl)a few weeks ago. Seems our "breed" is dying out and more of a novelty, which makes me sad because it's the reason many of us veterans got into in the first place.

This is an excellent article. While I am not a fan of the 'stripper' style of pole, I also agree that some competitions have too many rules. I had to modify a Beauty and the Beast routine for the Canadian Nationals because I wanted to take off a piece of clothing. There have also been times where I would like to use pointe or ballet shoes, but shoes are banned.

Some sexy can be awesome, for example I loved your ballet girl gone bad MPDA routine. Sexy can be creative.

However, I do understand some of the rules. We are still working at making the general population understand that just because we pole does not mean we strip. This takes example-setting (like classy or gymnastic style pole routines and competition), time and alot of patience.

But so what if we *do* strip? How does that take away from the skill and artistry of a good competition performance? Why does it have to be one or the other? Why is sexy not classy? Why is being sexy a "bad" example? And again, the reality is that modern pole dancing originated in the strip clubs and made its way into the mainstream from there. Not the Chinese pole, not gymnastics, so why are we so determined to deny the roots of this awesome art form?

I wish everyone in the world could read this. You've said everything I wanted to say ever since I had entered the pole community in my country. It's good - and also bad - to know that Brazil's problem with sexuality, gender and expression are not unique in some way. I would love to have people to talk about these questions, the many sanitarian rules are also applied here. In other hand we also have a competition for the sexy side of pole dancing (miss pole dance glamour).I tend to think that this dichotomization of styles is a very common social phenomenon that reflects the barrier between dance/sports, art/science and many others. As close as "pole dancing" gets to the mainstream media and institutions, it gets more sanitazed.I really admire you as a dancer and writer and I love reading your blog (you owned my views when I read your post on being pole dancer and feminist)! :)anxious for the second part!

THANK YOU for writing this! I have literally been less and less interested in pole, less motivated to blog about it and generally disenchanted with it in the past yer or two. I never started pole dancing to become a Cirque artist or a gymnast. And I think the sexuality of pole is exactly what makes it so riveting and unique. Like I have been saying since 2010 we have an opportunity as pole dancers to use pole dancing as a vehicle for changing the way a culture views female sexuality and beginning to heal the Madonna-Whore split that is so pervasive in so many cultures today. It saddens me to see this split begin to be repeated in the pole community.

I too have dropped out of the competition scene. When I first started pole it was never to compete it just kind of happened. I did a few competitions and did well! I also teach competitive dance for kids (pole has way more rules than dance) and it got to the point where one of my studios completely stopped doing competitions. Sometimes competitions take the fun out of what you are doing. Instead of competitions the kids perform 6-7 per year and they love it! The benefits of pole to me are the friends you make and that feeling of accomplishment when you finally get that trick and your friends are all happy for you! So I'm happy just performing and practicing pole for myself and for exercise. And if I get to perform a couple of times a year I see it as GREAT bonus for my hard work!

I haven't competed myself. I have been self taught most of my time as a "poler" and I admit, I take my husband to the local strip joint to watch the dancers, (they have good burgers too!) I told my husband, I would make a terrible dancer, because I don't want to shake my booty for a dollar, I would be on the pole the whole night. He understands and I think is very happy about that! Well, I did ONE amateur competition with a local radio station. I saw the other girls I was up against and most of them were really good. (they were not allowed to be real strippers.) Anywho, it was between me and other girl who did do other competitions and knew a lot of holds and moves that I did not. I kept it sexy, wore my thigh high boots (really for better hold) and flung my hair a bit and shook my booty, well I tied her for 2nd place! I couldn't believe it! I'm gonna keep it sexy for sure.

I have spent weeks trying to put in to words why I do not wish to compete and you have come along and put it so beautifully in to words. We need more of a variety of competitions, all I see are the same competitions with a different name every few weeks and don't get me wrong, like you, I do enjoy them. I just want variety. I want freedom and I want sensuality and sexuality.

If anyone wants sexy back, it's me, those are my roots. I thought I would share an excellent example of why we have to do what we do. We had planned to have our Canadian Nationals at the Scotia Bank Theatre in Niagra Falls this year. We booked it in November but they had not sent the contract yet. One week ago we asked for the contract and they gave us some excuse that someone else had booked and they were very sorry. We asked for any other weekend in November and they told us it was fully booked and confirmed. I had my suspicions so I had someone else call to enquire and guess what.....they have lots of availability in November.....they just don't want our kind there. This is what we deal with every year. Last year, a manager at the Novotel caught wind of what we were doing and tried to pull the plug one week before the competition. So before everyone comes down on competitions, know that the "sterilization" of competitions is what has helped educate people and open minds to pave the way for even the possibility of bringing sexy back. I have been fighting this fight for 10 years now. If competitions had been sexy from the beginning, Pole Dancing would not be anywhere near where it is today, it would still be consider something that should stay in a strip bar. Tammy Morris - co-organizer of the Canadian National Competition

Thank you! I was having serious second thoughts about the pole convention in Las Vegas when I read several (not naming anyone) blogs about how they were "vertical athletes" and are offended when they get called "strippers". If anything I do is appropriate for a 7 year old to do or see, I must have really messed up. I don't understand how people can try to "take over" something and then judge it for being what it has always been.

While checking out each instructor and deciding on classes, I took a look at their work and I am really excited to take your class. I really appreciate that you went out on a limb to embrace the stripper aspect, sanitizing pole dancing and making it appropriate for children is not an evolution, it's a tragedy.

About Me

My name is Michelle, or Shimmy, which is my nickname (comes from Shimelle - get it?). I'm a pole dancer and co-owner of the Pole Dance Academy (www.poledanceacademy.com.au) in Sydney, Australia, with my sister Maddie. She is also a crazy pole dancer like me. I have no problems admitting that I'm completely obsessed with pole dance. I train, teach, compete, eat, sleep and breathe pole. It's my inspiration, my release, my motivation and my passion. I'm so lucky to be able to share it with my sister Maddie, who is also my best friend.