Oh Earth One is awesome. Out of those three, Earth One really stands out to me and may be my favorite.

I guess I had a bunch of expectation for Birthright, which is a bad thing to go in with.

Birthright for me will always remain special because to me I see it as the way Smallville should've ended instead of the way it did end. Please much like Earth One Birthright was suppose to be ongoing as the start of DC Ultimate line.