IN FOCUS: Tibetan opinion divided on self-immolation spate

For Tashi Choezom, a Tibetan studying for a nursing degree in New Delhi, the string of suicides by Tibetan monks who have set themselves on fire to protest Chinese religious repression are a sin.

“I express my solidarity with those who have committed self-immolation, but it is terribly wrong to take one’s own life,” Choezom said at a recent demonstration by exiled Tibetans.

Yesterday, a Tibetan nun burnt herself to death in southwest China, Xinhua reported, becoming the 11th Tibetan this year known to have set themselves on fire.

Qiu Xiang, 35, set herself on fire at a road crossing in Sichuan Province, Xinhua said, citing the local government.

The nine Buddhist monks and two nuns who have set themselves ablaze this year — chanting for religious freedom and the return of the Dalai Lama to his homeland — have brought international attention once more to the Tibetan campaign.

“We are getting support from various countries through this, but these acts of self-immolation must stop. Buddhism does not allow this,” said Choezom, who has never been to Tibet.

The protests began in March when a 21-year-old monk called Phuntsog set himself on fire at the influential Kirti monastery in Si-chuan, which borders Tibet and has a large Tibetan population. At least another six have died since then, and their actions mark a new phase in resistance to Chinese rule.

However, they have also divided opinion in the exile community: Some feel the ends justify the means, others are staunchly opposed to suicide or attempted suicide on religious grounds.

A culture of self-censorship because of heavy Chinese security and restrictions placed on reporters in the remote Himalayan province make measuring opinion inside Tibet extremely difficult.

Geshey Lobsang, a monk at the monastery of the Dalai Lama in Dharamsala, the Tibetan spiritual leader’s home-in-exile in India, said when it comes to suicide the teachings of Buddhism are ambiguous.

“It is sin to destroy one’s body, but Buddhist philosophy also states that every action should be driven by good motivation and reason,” he said. “So, if the Tibetans self-immolated with a good motivation and to fulfill a higher cause, it cannot be counted as sin.”

The spate of self-immolations has also posed a dilemma to the government-in-exile, which cannot be seen to encourage a protest movement that costs lives.

The prime minister of the Tibetan government--in-exile, Lobsang Sangay, has paid tribute to the “courage” of the protesters and held a day of prayers in solidarity.

“The real question is why are these young Tibetans doing this?” said Samphel Thubten, a spokesman for the government-in-exile.

“Their actions grow out of really repressive measures put in place and the fact that the victims of that repression have nowhere to turn,” he said.

While views on whether suicide is a legitimate form of protest vary among exiles, the diagnosis of why monks are taking their own lives is unanimous.

“I’m personally against this way of protest. In Buddhism, it’s a big sin. But they don’t have a choice because they are not allowed to practice their faith,” said Tsewang Dolma, a 28-year-old Tibetan refugee in Kathmandu, Nepal.

Others echo the widely held belief that the self-immolations are a cry of desperation from a people who fear that their religious identity and culture are losing a battle for a survival.