Is he better than Williams yep is he better than jags yep is better at centre back than holgate yep.

Based on what? Marking the mighty Robson-Kanu out the game last night? Doing well in a backs to the wall display? Or a fairly non descript season so far at Brighton who haven't played many top teams yet?

Yeah, he's now playing in the Prem, for a promoted team, who will be flirting with the relegation places. As I say, he's at his level.

Jags has been finished for three seasons now, hasn't he? Keeps going though and hasn't let us down when he's played.

I know who I'd rather starting for us on Sunday. (It's not Ashley Williams though, that we can agree on).

As much as I liked jags he should be nowhere the first team,but he is because obviously we have no one better,I'm not talking about jags of 6/7years ago I'm talking about now and Duffy is better In my opinion,I'm not saying he is Maldini,I'm saying he would get in next to Keane.