This is how you kill a division. Not a steroid scandal, not pedophile, not beating your wife, or some horrible street fight induce fatality or some other horrible crime. You make it monotonous. You award someone for losing fair and square and you undermine the judge's decisions.For all the crap judges get for making bad calls. This act of giving an immediate rematch undermines actual good judging. The 155lb title is now a joke because it takes a series of 2-3 fights for a champion. On top of that it clogs an already clutter and confusing division with more then a top 10 waiting.Honestly people call me a hater but Frankie Edgar is the worse thing to happen to the 155lb division and MMA itself. Its more then just his point fighting. He's to weak and small for the division. He's killing the division off, not with impressive wins with bodies at his feet but rather a slow strangle killing the interest in the 155lb championship. The way he is right now, he's not meant for this sport. He goes down to 145lb he just another generic fighter. He has no where to really go except retire. And I hope for the sake of the 155lb division and MMA itself he calls it quits sooner rather then later.

The only other outcome is to call it a draw, but Aldo won his rounds by wider margins so it isn't quite the best call. The champion stays champion.

The judges got the decision right. I'm very impressed by Aldo tonight. Edgar should fight somebody at the top of 145 and earn his way back to another title shot. There is no argument for an immediate rematch. I mean nothing against Frankie in saying this, but he shouldn't have gotten an immediate rematch against Henderson.

Scramble City - This is how you kill a division. Not a steroid scandal, not pedophile, not beating your wife, or some horrible street fight induce fatality or some other horrible crime. You make it monotonous. You award someone for losing fair and square and you undermine the judge's decisions.For all the crap judges get for making bad calls. This act of giving an immediate rematch undermines actual good judging. The 155lb title is now a joke because it takes a series of 2-3 fights for a champion. On top of that it clogs an already clutter and confusing division with more then a top 10 waiting.Honestly people call me a hater but Frankie Edgar is the worse thing to happen to the 155lb division and MMA itself. Its more then just his point fighting. He's to weak and small for the division. He's killing the division off, not with impressive wins with bodies at his feet but rather a slow strangle killing the interest in the 155lb championship. The way he is right now, he's not meant for this sport. He goes down to 145lb he just another generic fighter. He has no where to really go except retire. And I hope for the sake of the 155lb division and MMA itself he calls it quits sooner rather then later.

Did you even watch the fights tonight? Is this a copy and paste from a post you made 6 months ago?

Scramble City - This is how you kill a division. Not a steroid scandal, not pedophile, not beating your wife, or some horrible street fight induce fatality or some other horrible crime. You make it monotonous. You award someone for losing fair and square and you undermine the judge's decisions.For all the crap judges get for making bad calls. This act of giving an immediate rematch undermines actual good judging. The 155lb title is now a joke because it takes a series of 2-3 fights for a champion. On top of that it clogs an already clutter and confusing division with more then a top 10 waiting.Honestly people call me a hater but Frankie Edgar is the worse thing to happen to the 155lb division and MMA itself. Its more then just his point fighting. He's to weak and small for the division. He's killing the division off, not with impressive wins with bodies at his feet but rather a slow strangle killing the interest in the 155lb championship. The way he is right now, he's not meant for this sport. He goes down to 145lb he just another generic fighter. He has no where to really go except retire. And I hope for the sake of the 155lb division and MMA itself he calls it quits sooner rather then later.

Did you even watch the fights tonight? Is this a copy and paste from a post you made 6 months ago?

Frankie won 3, 4, and 5 hands down and was also WAY more active throughout the entire fight. And rounds 1 & 2 were not decisive at all. Cosmetic damage and a couple of leg kicks does not negate getting out struck and out worked the entire fight. Frankie was the true winner and the judges were complete retards.

FullyLoadedFists -
Frankie won 3, 4, and 5 hands down and was also WAY more active throughout the entire fight. And rounds 1 & 2 were not decisive at all. Cosmetic damage and a couple of leg kicks does not negate getting out struck and out worked the entire fight. Frankie was the true winner and the judges were complete retards.

Scramble City - This is how you kill a division. Not a steroid scandal, not pedophile, not beating your wife, or some horrible street fight induce fatality or some other horrible crime. You make it monotonous. You award someone for losing fair and square and you undermine the judge's decisions.For all the crap judges get for making bad calls. This act of giving an immediate rematch undermines actual good judging. The 155lb title is now a joke because it takes a series of 2-3 fights for a champion. On top of that it clogs an already clutter and confusing division with more then a top 10 waiting.Honestly people call me a hater but Frankie Edgar is the worse thing to happen to the 155lb division and MMA itself. Its more then just his point fighting. He's to weak and small for the division. He's killing the division off, not with impressive wins with bodies at his feet but rather a slow strangle killing the interest in the 155lb championship. The way he is right now, he's not meant for this sport. He goes down to 145lb he just another generic fighter. He has no where to really go except retire. And I hope for the sake of the 155lb division and MMA itself he calls it quits sooner rather then later.

Absolutely agreed. He did nothing to deserve a rematch here. If the UFC wastes Aldo on one because "Frankie took all those rematches as Champ for us" again, they'll be wasting Aldo's talent.

He took rematches for you, Dana? And? Isn't it his JOB to take the fights you tell him are next???

Frankie only took one rematch as champion, verses BJ Penn (and it was the most warranted of the rematches he was involved with, in my opinion). The rematch with Maynard (or the rubber match) was necessary as their first title fight was ruled a draw. The rematch with Henderson was rather unwarranted in my opinion.

Reply Post

“This is the official website of the Mixed Martial Arts llc. Commercial
reproduction, distribution or transmission of any part or parts of this website
or any information contained therein by any means whatsoever without the prior
written permission is not permitted.”