@LBalazi: Never thought about this. Never thought about having a keepsake garter either. My friend is making a nice little DIY garter which, thanks to this post, I realized that I would like to keep. Luckily my dress comes with a free garter so I guess I’m using that for the garter game (we’re going a game instead of the usual toss). I will have to see though how it would feel wearing two garters since I’m not very sold on the idea on having something on my leg through the entire event.