Smudge Stick Waterproof Eye Liner

Our bestselling Smudge Sticks are available in an array of matte and shimmer formulas that stay—not stray—for reliable color payoff that’s second to none. With a range of gorgeous shades to choose from, they feature a cocktail of moisturizing ingredients that ensures color glides on smooth (no tugging or pulling) and the waterproof formula won’t budge or fade.

What’s more, our Smudge Sticks can be used as a classic pencil liner or a smudgy eye shadow - simply smudge with your fingers or a brush. The color sets after you’ve had time to get your desired effect, and then stays put all day.

Size: 0.01 oz.

Details

Smudge that won’t budge!

Our bestselling Smudge Sticks are available in an array of matte and shimmer formulas that stay—not stray—for reliable color payoff that’s second to none. With a range of gorgeous shades to choose from, they feature a cocktail of moisturizing ingredients that ensures color glides on smooth (no tugging or pulling) and the waterproof formula won’t budge or fade.

What’s more, our Smudge Sticks can be used as a classic pencil liner or a smudgy eye shadow - simply smudge with your fingers or a brush. The color sets after you’ve had time to get your desired effect, and then stays put all day.

Videos

Reviews

Great liner, faulty cap!

2.0
out of
5
stars

I love this liner, I have it in about 10 different colors, but the cap cracks just from normal use (taking the top on and off) and causes the liner to dry out to the point that I can't even draw it on without scraping across my eyelid and even then it doesn't draw on. I end up having to throw them away long before they are used up. I really want to continue using, but not good value at this point ☹️ PLEASE CHANGE CAPS!!

SN from Southold

May 7, 2017 1:52 AM

Amazing

5.0
out of
5
stars

I got the shade Damsel over a year ago, and I still haven't run out (I use it every time I wear eyeliner, about 5-6 days a week). It is the perfect dark brown shade for me, since I am very pale with green eyes and black eyeliner looks too harsh. It lasts all day and I honestly have not had one problem with it.

AS

Mar 25, 2017 5:23 PM

Water proof but too smudgy for a natural look

3.0
out of
5
stars

The color (stingrey) is beautiful, but only lasts for one or two hours. The color easily expands to the lower eyelid, making the look messy. Except that you want a smoky look, this pencil is not for one who wants a natural look with long-lasting color.

LK from Los Angeles

Feb 23, 2017 10:00 PM

Best. Liner. Ever.

4.0
out of
5
stars

My mom bought this for me when she found it on sale at Ulta and I was a little skeptical because the only color they had left was purple tang, but it was super easy and convenient to apply and looked great on all day. I also really appreciate that this is one of the few decent make-up brands that doesn't test on animals. I swear by this liner and haven't used another since. Only downside is that the plastic pencil the liner is contained in is cheaply made and I had a few problems occasionally when twisting to get more out and the cap cracked. But the make-up itself is on point!

EH

Feb 22, 2017 2:59 PM

Won't Turn

3.0
out of
5
stars

The eyeliner itself is actually really nice and stays on really well for a non liquid liner.
But the only problem is when i go to turn it to get more out when its gone dull, it wont budge. Sometimes i get lucky and a little comes out but not much. :c

HW

Nov 2, 2016 8:35 PM

Love the product but cap keeps cracking

5.0
out of
5
stars

Im totally in love with this eyeliner. I wear the purple tang colour which makes my green eyes pop. I love the fact that it stays perfectly put all day and will never run. I've been wearing this product for a minimum of 2 years. It's my favorite!!!! My only issue is the fact that i can never finish one without having the cap cracking and making it dry up. Im talking about for sure a minimum of 5 that is has happened too. I always need to have 1 new as a backup. I do not think that i'm excessive with it??? I've never had this issue with any other makeup product. I will keep buying it but i'm hoping that you will take my comments in consideration and fix this problem. Thank you!

BeepBeepmanian

Jul 9, 2015 4:00 AM

Great product even better usage tip

4.0
out of
5
stars

I really like how easy it is to use this liner and how easy it is to use even AFTER mascara. I thought mine was broken as it wouldn't dispense any more product after the first use. I was really upset, I had such high expectations. Then I realized the big game changer. IF YOU PUT IT UPSIDE DOWN AND TWIST IN THE DIRECTION THAT DOESNT MAKE ANY CLICKING NOISE MORE WILL COME OUT!!! It's not broken, just finicky!!! Now I can finally use the rest and get my money's worth. Hope this helps any other frustrated liner lovers.

Elisabeth

Apr 14, 2015 4:00 AM

my new favorite!

5.0
out of
5
stars

I just bought my first one and I love love love it. It glides very smoothly, stays all day long and it's easy to remove with eye makeup remover. At first I freaked out because when I twisted it to get more product nothing came up. I thought I got a faulty one or something but it came up after twisting it for a while so if you have the same problem, just try to keep twisting it...but not to much since it doesn't retract.

mkculver

Apr 6, 2015 4:00 AM

Super Long Lasting & Great Color

5.0
out of
5
stars

Please pay no heed to the comments regarding that the pencil does not twist up, or that there isn't any more eyeliner than what is exposed when purchased new. The instructions on the website clearly say that it takes 10-15 rotations for the first increase in product for the liner to actually twist up. This is true, do NOT freak out after you twist quite a few times and you don't see any new stuff yet - just keep twisting, it's there, I promise. The pencil does not click when it is being rotated, so maybe that is why some people are confused. Just be sure to twist slowly - after the first time you twist up, it doesn't take much to get new product out of the tip and this eyeliner is very soft (and pricey and you don't want to waste it), and it does not retract.
The actual eyeliner is of very high quality - it does not go on super smoothly because of the softness of the liner, and therefore you cannot push as hard while applying as you would do with a typical pencil. However, it's TOTALLY worth it because this stuff goes on and it does not come off. No more eyeliner in the creases under the eye by early afternoon! You could probably swim in this stuff and still look fab. I'd rather take an extra minute putting my eyeliner on in the morning and not have to worry about reapplying throughout the day. Seriously cannot say how much I love this stuff. Will be getting in other colors, for sure!

Emma B

Mar 14, 2015 4:00 AM

Horrible product

1.0
out of
5
stars

This is the cheapest company ever!! They only give you what is in the tip of the "retractable pencil" when you twist it nothing comes out! They are over priced for such a small amount of eyeliner! Do not buy not worth $20 unless you dont mind only being able to use it twice!

Monica

Nov 29, 2014 5:00 AM

Not so smooth and gone!

1.0
out of
5
stars

It is long lasting. I did the smudge test at the store. Does not go on the eyelids smoothly a bit rough.I do like the way I was able to smudge it and it was long wearing. I was only able to use the product twice then it was gone, it wouldn't roll out anymore. Sadly I paid $20 plus tax.

Deb Bake

Nov 3, 2014 5:00 AM

Tiny amount in cap is all you get!

1.0
out of
5
stars

I took off the cap, so excited to use, and then no product twisted out of the tip?! There's only enough there for two uses...where's the rest of the eyeliner, I paid 20 dollars! This pencil should last longer. Even the note in the product description is fishy, it says *Note: The pencil does not twist down**

Dr. Carlson

Aug 11, 2014 4:00 AM

Excellent Product, Bad Design

2.0
out of
5
stars

Looking for a great waterproof eyeliner for my wedding, I did the "back of the hand smudge & durability test" at the store. This was by FAR the longest lasting and most waterproof, and I still agree that the product itself is great. My low rating is because the first one I purchase dried out after ONE use. I realized the cap was ill-fitting but thought it was probably just a fluke, so I bought another one to use for my wedding day. It was great for wedding day but during the honeymoon when I reached for it before the beach, the second one was dried out too! I had already recommended it to my mother who bought one for the wedding too, and when I asked if she still liked it she said she had to throw it out because it had dried out. (!!!!!) I wish they could make a cap that LOCKS on, and this would be a 5 star product for me, but I can't recommend a $20 eyeliner for single use.

fashonistella

Aug 1, 2014 4:00 AM

unusable eyeliner

1.0
out of
5
stars

I returned your eyeliner because I couldn't use it!! It would not twist out of the pencil. A lady who saw me returning it said she returned 3 because the pencil wouldn't twist out!! The salesman said a couple were returned this morning also!!!
You have an inferior product design, so you'd better figure it out. susan cox

susan

Jun 28, 2014 4:00 AM

It's nice, but..

3.0
out of
5
stars

I use this product when I need a pop of color, but the color runs so fast. I was really disappointed. It's hard finding a product for oily eyes, and thought this would deliver well, however, this was not that great to me. I wish this was better.

Oily Eyelids

May 20, 2014 4:00 AM

Great staying power

3.0
out of
5
stars

This product glides on so smooth and has AWESOME colors! It also stays on so well. I was really impressed with the staying power. The colors stay nice also after they have set. I have NEVER had an allergy to any eye products and when I wear these my eyes burn so bad and I can barely keep my eyelids open and my eyes just can't stop running. :( I haven't had any problems with any of the other liners in the past just these ones. I don't know what is in them that does this. But hopefully most people don't experience this and just get all the wonderful effects. I gave it 3 stars because of the issue

Kat9

Feb 6, 2014 5:00 AM

good with a primer, not so much without

3.0
out of
5
stars

I was very enthusiastic when I tested the liner on the back of my hand at Sephora and it stayed put until I washed it off with soap. However, after having purchased and applied on eyelids, it transferred from my upper lids within two hours. When I used an eyeshadow primer first, though, the liner stayed on without smudging all day, so it's still worth purchasing as a lot of liners don't. Just be aware it's not as smudgeproof as one would like.

Irina

Oct 15, 2013 4:00 AM

Damsel Smudge Stick - why not available??

1.0
out of
5
stars

I purchased an eye color pallet which contained a damsel smudge stick. It's the first eye liner that I totally loved - the perfect color too! Unfortunately, the eye liner doesn't last anywhere near as long as the eye shadow. When I tried to purchase the smudge stick individually, I was informed that it's only available as part of the pallet set. How crazy is that? I'm not going to spend the $$ for the full pallet, just to get the smudge stick. In fact, I'm so disappointed, I'm not going to buy any more Stila products - just on principle. You might think it's a wise marketing tactic - I think it's poor customer experience. Sorry Stila - you had me for as long as my Damsel Smudge Stick lasted ... about 3 weeks.

tag422

Apr 20, 2012 4:00 AM

Versatile and long-lasting.

5.0
out of
5
stars

I received my first smudge stick from the In the Light Palette-- With my fair to medium skin and hair varying from Joan Harris red to shades of dark brown I figured it would be at the very least good to have a shade of brown liner as a backup. And of course, as they have with every other purchase, Stila surprised me.
I love Damsel. Personally, I wear black liners so often I don't generally see the need to purchase other colors but the wearability of this prompted me to branch out.
I work in a hospital, so my shifts are 12 hours overnight and on some days I stay awake after for school, not to mention my eyes water often so I generally have to keep my eyeliner and some makeup remover in my purse to prevent the smudges in the corners. When I'm using the smudge stick the problem dissipates. I can apply this at 6P.M. and still look fabulously lined when I finish with class at 1p.m. the next day.
The shade I'm using allows me to substitute as a brow liner in dire circumstances and is versatile to many different eye looks. On my top lid it's creamy and doesn't pull or transfer to my crease. It even withholds against my waterline which is nearly impossible. And it really makes my amber eyes look golden during bright days when paired with bronze shadows.

whitley

Mar 14, 2012 4:00 AM

THE VERY BEST LINER PENCIL EVER!

5.0
out of
5
stars

THIS LINE OF EYELINER IS FANTASTIC! I HAVE PEACOCK (VERY VIVID BLUE), BLUEFIN (GREAT DARKER BLUE), AND LIONFISH (FANTASTIC COLOR FOR ANY EYE SHADE) THIS IS MY FAVORITE. THEY ARE VERY EASY TO APPLY. GLIDE ON NICELY. IT IS SO HARD TO FIND EYELINER THAT WILL GO ON THE WATERLINE. THESE ARE GREAT FOR THAT. ALSO, THEY ARE VERY LONG LASTING. I WILL BE BUYING TRIGGERFISH AND MORAY VERY SOON. I WANT TO HIGHLY RECOMMEND THIS PRODUCT!

JEANNIE

Mar 1, 2012 5:00 AM

excellent eyeliner

5.0
out of
5
stars

i've never been comfortable wearing dry eyeliner. either you have to press harder than i'd like to get it to stay on the lid, or it is difficult to be precise and get a thin liner, or it smudges like crazy (or some combination), so i've always worn liquid liner. i haven't always been happy with that, but it was the best solution. the smudge stick is a great balance between dry and liquid liner. it can be used for formal and casual days, comes in several great colors, and is super easy to apply. and, even if it does smudge a little, that's fine because you can use it as part of your eyeshadow also. i have triggerfish and bluefin, and i love both. they add a little sparkle without making me feel like i'm wearing too much makeup.

anathema

Feb 21, 2012 5:00 AM

Best eyeliner I have ever found

5.0
out of
5
stars

I have used the UD 24/7 liner that is so popular and I hate it, But this liner is PERFECTION! Smooth application on lash line, lid or waterline. It lasts and lasts and the color is true and bold. Can't really afford it but I pick one up when I can and truly enjoy it. I Love Stila's products and wish I could have one of everything!

blueyedshark

Jan 25, 2012 5:00 AM

Beautiful Color

5.0
out of
5
stars

I received the peacock shade as a gift and I ABSOLUTELY love the color!!! It stays much longer than my other eyeliners and I can't wait to get all of them!!

DominoS90

Jan 17, 2012 5:00 AM

Good Stuff but..

3.0
out of
5
stars

The content is really good, glides on really nice, but ;asdjkf;jf;ajf;aljdf;fa drives me nuts when i screw the pencil's twisty thing to the right for more product to come out.. and nothing happens!

Mary

Dec 20, 2011 5:00 AM

Great eyeliner for waterline!

5.0
out of
5
stars

I love the pigmentation and formula of this eyeliner! My only complaint would be that there is no way to get a sharp point back on the tip- oh well! I guess I can't have it all!

Felix

Nov 5, 2011 4:00 AM

Great Eye Liner

5.0
out of
5
stars

I was attracted to this eye liner because it said "waterproof‰Û�. Having oily eyelids, nothing lasts, or stays on my eyes, for more than 3 hours. Stila‰Ûªs Smudge Stick Waterproof Eye Liners actually stay on all day for me, with little need for touch-ups. The consistency of this eye liner is creamy and soft, and it goes on smoothly, with no dragging, pulling, or skipping. You can apply a definitive line with it, and it is soft and smooth enough so you can smudge it, if you need to. It does have a touch of shimmer to it, which will give the eye more definition. I purchased ‰ÛÏMoray‰Û�, which is a beautiful shade of olive green. It‰Ûªs a great shade for all eye colors, but if you have green eyes, your eye color will definitely be enhanced with this olive green shade. My eye color is both blue and green and my eye color looks so green with this shade on. I love it!

LuLu24

Nov 2, 2011 4:00 AM

The best eyeliner I have ever used!

4.0
out of
5
stars

This eyeliner is fantastic! It is very waterproof, stays on all day and goes on extremely smooth and creamy. The colors are beautiful and very pigmented. This product is my new go to eyeliner everyday, I have ditched all my other eyeliners for the Stila smudgestick waterproof eyeliner!

ky22

Nov 2, 2011 4:00 AM

Perfect Eyes Every Time

5.0
out of
5
stars

Whether you are headed for the office of a night out on the town, the smudge stick can give you the look you want! Create a classic sophisticated eye with a straight line, or a dramatic eye by blending and mixing colors. The color pops and stays on for hours and hours! I can't live without them.

Ria81

Oct 28, 2011 4:00 AM

Great color, super creamy, sticks around.

5.0
out of
5
stars

I have two of these pencils in stingray and triggerfish and they are super high quality. They go on smoothly and easily and have a super strong color payoff. They stay for hours and hours, always looking vibrant. Best eyepencils i've used so far.

Turboweevel

Oct 27, 2011 4:00 AM

You WON'T regret this purchase!

5.0
out of
5
stars

I have every smudge stick waterproof eyeliner and it is seriously amazing. Every color matches with ANY outfit and no matter WHERE I go, I constantly get compliments on a daily basis. My eyes pop with this eyeliner and it stays on ALL day, which is perfect for a busy girl.

Lizzie

Oct 19, 2011 4:00 AM

This liner is AMAZING!

5.0
out of
5
stars

I wish i could have this liner in every color, but i have it in blue ribbon. I have never tried a liner like this one. IT is well worth the money you pay for it. The color is vibrant and gorgeous. IT stays on all day long, wont smear at all! LOVE LOVE LOVE!!!!

alaynapearl

Oct 16, 2011 4:00 AM

AWESOME

5.0
out of
5
stars

I have Purple Tang, the new Bluefin and StinRay and I LOVE THEM ALL...stay on wonderful and look great...Purple Tang is my favorite it's the best purple eye liner I have ever owned

musicmomma

Oct 7, 2011 4:00 AM

LOVE THIS LINER!!!

5.0
out of
5
stars

LOVE IT!!!! I have the Moray and Purple Tang. Moray is possibly the most beautiful eye liner color I've ever used. I got this b/c I have a greenish/goldish eyeliner from Bare Minerals and wanted to get another, but it's only available in a kit. So, the woman at Sephora showed me Moray and it is even better than Bare Minerals. Goes on so smooth with tons of color and lasts all day. The purple tang is gorgeous too.
I will def try the other colors.

kristina

Oct 7, 2011 4:00 AM

amazing

5.0
out of
5
stars

I have been looking for that really black liner and now i found it.I feel like i need to get a few of them in case they stop making them.I have both in brown and black,they go in so smooth and rich in pigment that you feel no pressure on your skin whatsoever.Stays put all day.

anjeza4577

Sep 28, 2011 4:00 AM

Must be in your Makeup Collection!

5.0
out of
5
stars

I remember the first time I saw the waterproof smudge stick I kind of sarcastically giggled because so many companies offer water proof eyeliner that comes off rather quickly even when water is not involved. I thought well it is Stila so I will give it a shot, I purchased it in stingray because a girl could never have enough black eyeliner. I realized it was one of the best decisions I ever made because it did work not just against water, but also with sweat and longevity. I could throw this on when I get ready for work at 5am and be 100% sure I will have it until I leave the office at 5:30pm I now have 4 additional colors that I love to play with.

bcsavesfaces

Sep 12, 2011 4:00 AM

I own every color but one.

5.0
out of
5
stars

These eye liners go on smooth, stay on all day and are easy to remove at night. Stila has always had the best eyeliners. These are just the next improvement on a great product.

lvpurpl

Sep 12, 2011 4:00 AM

Easy application and long lasting

5.0
out of
5
stars

Usually with eye pencils I find that there is a trade-off. Those that apply easily are so soft that they get everywhere and fade quickly. Those that last longer are usually stiff and I have I have to press hard to get any color to transfer. The smudge sticks are that perfect balance of easy application and long wear. I was definitely impressed.

couture

Sep 12, 2011 4:00 AM

Best eyeliner for everyday use

5.0
out of
5
stars

I love this eyeliner. It is easy to put on and the color is vibrant, like all stila products.

Kat05

Sep 11, 2011 4:00 AM

Moray is pretty.

5.0
out of
5
stars

Oh man, I can't say more good things about any liner I've used before. The smudge stick is awesome. I bought the "moray" color and I use it primarily for that spot right under your eye where tears come out to give it a little sparkle. And I love how it has that gold-ish tone to it. All in all, it goes on nicely and it stays there throughout the day.

Candypie

Sep 11, 2011 4:00 AM

Great colors, staying power

5.0
out of
5
stars

I've been using the green one every day for the past week. It stays all day and it has just enough sparkle to make my eyes pop, without looking too disco-y. It doesnt move, A lot of my eyeliners end up on my lid throughout the day because i have oily eye lids. It doesn't happen with this eyeliner. all in all its one of my favorites.

jlf85

Sep 11, 2011 4:00 AM

Great staying power, not for waterline

4.0
out of
5
stars

I bought this product originally because I had read so many reviews about how it stayed well on the waterline. I was so excited when I got it and I used it right away. The problem I had was unexpected, the product did not stay on my waterline but rather found its way all over my contacts and it blurred my vision. I was so upset, I wanted to return it but I decided to see what other people had to say and I found that some other people had the same problem.
After further research I found that this problem was not meant for the water line but rather for the skin around the eye. So I decided to try it there and I loved it! I got other colors and I have been using them on my bottom lid as well as to line my top lid. They are amazingly pigmented and have incredible all day staying power.
The only gripe I have had about them is the price. Smudge pots are $20 and Smudge sticks are also $20 but smudge pots have 1 oz of product and smudge sticks have .01 ounce. the difference between the amount of product is huge so I guess you're paying for the ease of the packaging but it's still a little crazy to think about it. I have not tried smudge pots but I want to soon, if they have the staying power of smudge sticks they are sure to be amazing.

cherryRose1

Aug 17, 2011 4:00 AM

waterproof , ,long power

5.0
out of
5
stars

it do like it to put it on my water line.you can smudge it when you just put it,its very vivid color.

mahli2010

Aug 17, 2011 4:00 AM

This product is just what I've been looking for!

5.0
out of
5
stars

I heard about the smudge stick liners from a youtube makeup tutorial channel, and I tried the peacock color because it is so beautiful. It glides on so smooth and the color payoff is amazing! I love this product. It reminds me of a khol liner, but it's also waterproof, which is perfect for summer days out!

makeupjunkie

Aug 14, 2011 4:00 AM

Awsome liner but little product!

5.0
out of
5
stars

I tried these out when it was released earlier this year i think and the liner was very creamy. It didn't smudge or anything throughout the day; it looked the same after about 7-8 hours since i first put it on in the morning. It;s ridiculously pigmented so just one layer of liner is perfect.

karmen345

Aug 11, 2011 4:00 AM

I Gave Up My MAC Product For THIS! There Are No Regrets! :)

5.0
out of
5
stars

A few weeks ago, I stopped at the Sephora in the JCPenny near my house while my family was shopping for Curtains. I was on the hunt for a good eyeliner. I wanted something waterproof and something that just glides on really smoothly for my lid since I'm not the greatest at applying it. So I found the Stila Smudge Stick in Koi and I fell in love. It was great just on my hand as a swatch and when I took it home it was even greater on my eye. The price was a little expensive for an eyeliner because I usually get a Loreal one in Target for 3 dollars or so. I ran out of money on my debit card so I asked my mom if she could buy it for me. She said that she would but I'd have to pay her back. That's when I decided I'd return my MAC Eyeshadow I got a few weeks prior (that was still unopened) to keep this instead!
Now, it doesn't smudge as easily as the name implies it will, but that's okay because if I wanted to smudge something around, I'd buy a smudge pot.
All in all, this product ended up being worth the money AND the MAC eyeshadow. Since my skin is more tanner than others, this wonderful eyeliner really brightens by eyes up and gives them a wonderful shimmer. I recommend this to anyone and everyone!

thepetrovafirex

Aug 10, 2011 4:00 AM

waterproof!!

5.0
out of
5
stars

I bought the shadow palette that had lionfish included. I wore it recently when it was very hot and humid. It stayed on all day, and I wasn't in air conditioning. It was a great buy with the palette. I'd love to see more palettes with liners included.

jpscraps

Aug 7, 2011 4:00 AM

love this, smooth like butta!

5.0
out of
5
stars

I have the color peacock and it is the most gorgeous color that I haven't seen anywhere else. The color payoff is amazing and it lasts all day without smudging. I would highly recommend these liners to everyone.

suj1234

Aug 6, 2011 4:00 AM

Favorite eyeliner!

5.0
out of
5
stars

I swear by Stila smudge sticks! I used to use the smudge pots, but once the smudge sticks came out, I was sold on their ease of use. I love that I don't have to use a brush to apply and they stay on all day. I use lionfish and purple tang for my "everyday look" and have the black for an evening look.

Jules22

Aug 6, 2011 4:00 AM

This eyeliner is great!!

5.0
out of
5
stars

This is the best eyeliner, it is so easy to put on. The creamy texture is wonderful. The eyeliner stays on all day and doesnt run!

kshill8385

Aug 6, 2011 4:00 AM

Totally smudgeproof!

5.0
out of
5
stars

I love the smudge syicks that i have each and every color , including the the 2 new colors. The colors are stunning, and i live eyeliner but and makeup challenged with the gel pot eyeliner and this is easy to use for everybody and it looks gorgeous on everyone. Soo glad they came up with the smudgesticks!

natasha12

Aug 4, 2011 4:00 AM

Smooth application

4.0
out of
5
stars

I love Stila's smudge stick eyeliner. I currently have it in the Peacock and the golden brown color. They go on so smooth and last pretty long. I will never go back to any other brand for eyeliners.

tamz

Aug 3, 2011 4:00 AM

Love this product, own several!

5.0
out of
5
stars

I used to use Quickliner for Eyes by Clinique and then the same sort of twist up by Lancome. Both waterproof and long-lasting. That was several years/pencils ago. Now I own in order of purchase; Peacock (I love teal), Blue Ribbon, Koi (freebie with purchase), Lionfish and Purple Tang.
I don‰Ûªt line my waterline, never was good at that. I dot between my lashes on the bottom and smudge if necessaryåü bringing the line up towards my outer eyebrow for a little wing. Then I line the tops of my lashes on my other lid. Usually I do not smudge, I leave as is. Works for me!!

violet61

Aug 2, 2011 4:00 AM

My go-to liner

5.0
out of
5
stars

I love this liner...it stays on during the 90 degree days and looks great...I was so tired of black liner...so, I switched to lionfish...love it

sallie15

Aug 1, 2011 4:00 AM

Amazing quality, decent value

5.0
out of
5
stars

These are beautiful, soft, richly pigmented eyeliners, and I really really enjoy using them. I first heard about and picked up Stringray. It is so rich and dark and creamy; it applies so opaquely and does not budge at all. I especially love using this on my waterline; it quickly became my holy grail waterline eyeliner.
However, this wonderful product does have a few drawbacks. For one, I've found I'm not the only person that experiences problems with the packaging. It takes forever and lots of twisting to get the product out of the tube - and sometimes, it's not possible to twist the product back into the tube if too much was dispensed. Another is the value alone. The not having to sharpen an automatic eyeliner is fantastic, but that also means much much less product. .01 oz, to be exact. And for that small amount of wonderful product, you are paying $20. Having paid for the ones I own already, I personally find that outrageous for a single eyeliner pencil. As much as I love the ones I have, this sadly may be a one-time purchase for this reason. But if this is within your price range, it is definitely worth your time and money.
Lastly, I'm sad to see some of their prettiest colours have been discontinued. I also own Koi, the gorgeous rich gold; though I don't see that one or Silver Dollar, which I had been eyeing as a potential gorgeous silver to try. I do hope they bring them back, as they were really wonderful for their versatility.
Quality - 10.
Value - 6.

Sarah

Aug 1, 2011 4:00 AM

smudge stick waterproof eye liner

5.0
out of
5
stars

I got the smudge stick waterproof eye liner in the color Stingray and It is awesome! I love it! I wear it to the beach and in the pool and it still looks great ! I highly recommend it to everyone.I am going to get some of the other colors too :D

Loribear

Aug 1, 2011 4:00 AM

Definitely Waterproof

4.0
out of
5
stars

These stay on the waterline all day. My only complaint is that it would be nice to get a little more for your money.

rachel82

Aug 1, 2011 4:00 AM

Great product

4.0
out of
5
stars

This really is a WATER PROOF eyeliner, not like the rest of them that are anything but.
The only thing i will like is to get more product in the package, i love it, but $20.00 is a lot of money for the pen, add some more product in, and it will be perfect.

makeupholic

Aug 1, 2011 4:00 AM

The name is spot-on

5.0
out of
5
stars

When the call this a "smudge stick", they aren't kidding. The black is my favorite, and goes on easily. It really makes your eyes pop!

Kayy

Aug 1, 2011 4:00 AM

worth the money

5.0
out of
5
stars

will stay all day! it's very pigmented and the colors are amazing

Beee

Aug 1, 2011 4:00 AM

nice product

5.0
out of
5
stars

I think this is a very good eyeliner. I still prefer stila's liquid waterproof eyeliner, but for people who prefer pencils, this is a great choice. I have it in a shimmery brown shade and the color is rich and beautiful. It also stayed on quite nicely.

mlw59

Aug 1, 2011 4:00 AM

This Liner Won't Budge!

5.0
out of
5
stars

I love this collection of liners! I use "Lionfish" (upper lash line) and "Koi" (water line) on a regular basis. Both work very well with my hazel eyes. If you want extra staying power for your upper lash line, follow the liner application with an eyeliner powder of the same color.

jgb29

Aug 1, 2011 4:00 AM

long lasting rich color

5.0
out of
5
stars

I love this liner in the color lionfish! Its great for summer and stays on for so long. the value is great and the rectractable factor is awesome

maggs

Aug 1, 2011 4:00 AM

Easy to apply

5.0
out of
5
stars

These eye liners are really great! I just started using eye liners and these have been so easy to apply. I love that I can also smudge these liners and you can create a very sultry look. They stay on the entire day even after the beach or being sweaty.

Rose83

Aug 1, 2011 4:00 AM

Great but not for sensitive eyes/contact lens wearers

3.0
out of
5
stars

Okay, so I was so excited when these came out. I was looking for something to use on my waterline. I do have allergies. I do wear contacts. Regardless of how carefully I applied this product to my waterline, it irritated my eyes and also smeared onto my contact lens - I ruined about 3 pairs of them.
Anway, I still rate this 3 stars because it is a good value, the colors are great, AND I can still use them, I just only use them underneath my lower lashline. The liner stays all day, does not run, does not smear.
I do recommend this product for lower lashline for contact lens wearers or those with sensitive eyes.
I do recommend this product for waterline if you do not fit in the above category :-).
Thanks!

DeDe

Aug 1, 2011 4:00 AM

This is one of my favorite eyeliners

5.0
out of
5
stars

I bought this a couple of months ago and I haven't been disappointed. Application is very smooth. I will buy this again when i run out.

carynrose

Aug 1, 2011 4:00 AM

Great Eye Liner!

5.0
out of
5
stars

I got this eye liner in lionfish and love it! It‰Ûªs true to the name waterproof and I know this because it was part of my makeup I used on my cousins wedding where I did cry and did not suffer any type of makeup run. Also I love the color and plan on ordering it in other colors.

sarah067

Aug 1, 2011 4:00 AM

Super easy to apply

5.0
out of
5
stars

Rolls on super smooth, stays exactly where I put it. My fav eyeliner.

kako

Aug 1, 2011 4:00 AM

Super eyeliner!

5.0
out of
5
stars

Stila smudge sticks are my go-to eyeliner, especially for the waterline. They are exceptionally creamy and pigmented, and they don't wear off once applied, even on the waterline. Plus the colors are amazing! You really can't go wrong :)

springdancer

Jul 31, 2011 4:00 AM

Amazing color, great staying power

5.0
out of
5
stars

I have this in Peacock, a bright teal blue. It's a great and easy way to play up your eyes, especially in the summer when you're going to be sweating up a storm as it barely budges over the course of the day. I only have to touch up the inner corners by the end of the workday to go into the evening. I definitely recommend it!

meredithmo

Jul 31, 2011 4:00 AM

Great product

4.0
out of
5
stars

I love this eyeliner. It goes on so smooth and makes a really nice line, it's smudgeable at first but then sets really well and lasts forever. My only pet peeve is that I wish it came in more colors!!