However, they are equals in Win Shares this year, with Andre playing fewer games. Andre’s best career post-season stats are better than Joe’s – Andre averaged (in 6 games) 21.5-6.3-6.7 while Johnson’s best is probably last year’s 20.0-3.9-4.0 line a few years ago.

So what do we have here? A small breakdown:

Better Scorer: Johnson (scores, less efficient, difference too great)

Better Shooter: Johnson (giving it to him for his history – 37% career 3FG)

Better Rebounder: Andre (pretty clearly)

Better Passer: Andre (close, more assists and fewer turnovers)

Better Defender: Andre (no-brainer)

Better Player: I’ll let you decide. But here is some influencing on my part:

Iguodala vs. Johnson, head-to-head this year

Andre: 38 pts, 13 reb, 18 ast, 14-27 FG, 2-6 3FG, 8-10 FT, 4 TOs

Johnson: 27 pts, 5 reb, 3 ast, 9-18 FG, 1-4 3FG, 9-12 FT, 11 TOs

So now, who would you rather have?

*Have to give credit to Rob Neyer, the king of anonymous player comparisons.

Really enjoy reading your Sixers stuff. You’ve got some great in-depth analysis and provide Sixer fans an alternative from game preview/recaps. I’m curious if you’d be interested in doing some Sixers writing for the FanSided network? If you’d like some more details, you can email me or send me a DM on Twitter (I’m following you now). Thanks and have a great day!

Hi, my name is Sean. I like the 76ers. I used to write here, then I got randomly found and wrote in more popular places, namely The Sixer Sense.
But now, I'm back writing for myself here, because I enjoy doing it. And I hope you enjoy it too.