Friday, 3 December 2010

Grameen founder Muhammad Yunus in Bangladesh aid probe

Norway says it is examining reports that Nobel Peace Laureate Muhammad Yunus allegedly diverted millions of dollars of aid money from a bank.

International Development Minister Erik Solheim said that it was "totally unacceptable that aid is used for other purposes than intended".

A documentary maker has alleged that cash was diverted from Professor Yunus' Grameen Bank to other parts of Grameen.

In a statement, the bank said that the allegations were false.

It said that a full explanation with more details would be provided at the "earliest convenient time".

The bank was set up by Professor Yunus to provide micro-credit - or small loans - to the poor.

The move by the Norwegians - who insist that no criminal activity has taken place - comes at a time when the reputation of the micro-credit industry has been under attack.

The original aim of the micro-credit concept was poverty reduction, but in recent years some micro-financial institutions have been criticised over exorbitant interest rates and alleged coercive debt collection.

In the south-eastern Indian state of Andhra Pradesh, for example, micro-loans have been blamed for a series of suicides among struggling farmers.

It is estimated some 250 organisations in the state have handed out loans totalling more than £1.65bn (£883m), only a small proportion of which have been paid back.

Objections

The Grameen Bank's denial followed the release of a documentary by Danish filmmaker, Tom Heinemann, who claimed Professor Yunus and his associates diverted nearly $100m of grant money to another company - Grameen Kalyan - which was not involved in micro-credit operations.

Mr Heinemann said he stumbled upon the documents and letters relating to the alleged transfer while doing research for his documentary on micro-credit.

"I got most of the documents from the archives of Norad, the Norwegian aid agency in Oslo," he said.

The Grameen group of more than 30 companies headed by Professor Yunus is divided between those not operating for profit and those which do.

Mr Heinemann's report alleged that after the Norwegian authorities raised objections to the alleged transfer of funds, the Grameen bank returned about $30m. The aid money was from Norway, Sweden and Germany.

Professor Yunus, known as the Banker to the Poor, and the Grameen Bank were awarded the Nobel Peace Prize in 2006 "for their efforts to create economic and social development from below".

Replicated model

The economist founded the bank, which is one of numerous organisations now providing loans to the poor - especially women - in Bangladesh.

The micro-credit lending model has been replicated in other parts of the world.

Reacting to the latest report, the Norwegian authorities say they have no suspicions of tax fraud or corruption committed by Grameen Bank.

"Having said that, the Government of Norway finds it totally unacceptable that aid is used for other purposes than intended no matter how praiseworthy the causes might be," Norwegian International Development Minister Erik Solheim said in a statement e-mailed to the BBC.

Mr Solheim said that he had asked the Norwegian Agency for Development Co-operation for a full report on the matter.

"At the same time it is important to stress that we are firm believers in micro-finance as a tool in the fight against poverty," he said.

The documentary "Caught in Micro Debt" was shown on Norwegian National Television earlier this week.

"I travelled to Bangladesh, India and Mexico to find out whether micro-credit loans have really helped the poor. But I found out that poor people are getting into more and more debt because of micro-credit loans," Mr Heinemann told the BBC.

He said that he was not accusing Professor Yunus of misusing the money or personally benefiting from the transfer.

First the national broadcasting company, then NORAD and finally the concerned minister: all acted either mindlessly or with a purpose yet to be known.

How could the Norwegian tell the world that they were not aware of a matter settled years ago?

We can accept that the documentary maker might have missed some point somewhere or he is a part of conspiracy. But how to narrate the silence of the Germans, Swede and the Dutch who were part of the fund?

DESA VIDEOS

Loading...

Robert Orr not welcome in DESA's DC2 bldg

Robert Orr needs a Chinese Visa to enter UN's DC2 building

Rio+20: GreenPeace Statement

​ Greenpeace International Executive Director has released a statement on his views of Rio+20. "The future we want has gotten a little further away today. Rio+20 has turned into an epic failure, It has failed on equity, failed on ecology and failed on economy" were Kumi Naidoo frank comments after the text for the outcome document was adopted. Please click here for the full statement.

UN Policy Coordination on the Road

DESA's Telecommuting Assistant Secretary General

Sha Zukang's behavior not appropriate...

Sha's behavior was not appropriate as a senior advisor. And he also knows that his behavior has embarrassed most of the [other] senior advisors at that time.

Mr. Chance (buy this book now)

Click on the picture and purchase this book now. It's already a best seller. It shows the coward Ban Ki Moon and his Korean team in action.

Chinese Social Affairs Department

"UN needs complete leadership overhaul"

International Development Secretary Andrew Mitchell, who asked Ashdown to carry out the report, said the government would give its response in about six weeks.

Czech President Klaus

"...this is the time for international organizations, including the United Nations, to reduce their expenditures, make their administrations thinner, and leave the solutions to the governments of member states"

Sha Zukang Disrespectful of UN Rules

UN staff rules require employees to uphold and respect the principles set out in the Charter, including faith in fundamental human rights. They prohibit U.N. employees from accepting instructions from any government or from any other source external to the organization. UN staff should avoid any action and, in particular, any kind of public pronouncement that may adversely reflect on their status, or on the integrity, independence and impartiality that are required by that status.

Barack Obama on UN Reform

Obtain Refund of Funds Owed to the U.S. by the U.N.

CLICK ON VOTE - to save approximate $180 million in one time savings

Get ready U.N. !!

Let's raise our voices

The following months are critical. Changing DESA is in your hand. Speak up now and share our message with all colleagues.

NyTimes disavows Ban Ki Moon

"The United States, meanwhile, should think hard about whether it wants to support Mr. Ban’s re-election" NyTimes Editorial - Nov 03, 2010

Feel like saying smth ?

You are free to respond to any of our critics. Send an email at - change.undesa@gmail.com - your reply will be published as is

UN at 65

State Department Spokesperson P.J. Crowley

"Sha Zukang seems to be cranky at lots of folks. It will not affect our relations with China."

UN STAFF RESOLUTION ON BAN KI MOON

If SG Ban Ki-moon fails to take immediate steps towards real reform to address these urgent systemic issues, Staff Union will consider a vote of NO-CONFIDENCE

U.N.D.E.S.A CORRUPTION

Backstabbing for Beginners

Backstabbing for Beginners is at once the darkly comic tale of one man's political coming of age and a stinging indictment of the hypocrisy that prevailed at the heart of the world's most idealistic institution.

Hacked Emails Show Blatant Climate Change Fraud

Loading...

U-Report

anyone who wants to report facts in our Blog is welcomed. You can send us anonymous messages thru leaving comments into our past blogging or you can send us an email at: change.undesa@gmail.com. We ensure full confidentiality of your reporting.