Search This Blog

Without the right to communicate and democratisation of communication, the right to life, liberty, freedom of speech and expression is meaningless.It attempts to keep track of traditional media, offline media and digital media that faces the onslaught of monopolistic tendencies and is wary of localisation of media. It is part of Citizens Forum for Civil Liberties (CFCL) For Details: https://groups.yahoo.com/neo/groups/mediavigil/info

Long live Marx, Netaji zindabad!

A memorandum opposing Aadhaar and other anti-people policies was submitted to the Indian National Congress-led government along with a big truck load of signatures numbering 3.57 crore to mark the 129th death anniversary of Karl Marx, one of most influential socialist thinkers post industrial revolution amidst a huge People's March to Parliament comprising about one lakh citizens on Mach 14 in the national capital.

The meeting concluding the People's March underlined the need for internationalism and remembered Netaji Subhash Chandra Bose, one of foremost anti-imperialist heroes of the world in glowing terms. His death remains unconfirmed since August 18, 1945.

Marx died in London [ Images ] at the age of 64, two years prior to the formation of India [ Images ]n National Congress and Communist parties in India, but they claimed that his ideas influenced them. Under the Indian Constitution every political party in the country is registered as a socialist party. If they will profess any other ideology, they will not even be registered. All the national and regional parties take oath to be a socialist party but in a classic case of double speak and hypocrisy they practice against the principles of socialism.

The meeting of the People's March remembered that during the freedom movement, the leaders of the Indian National Congress backstabbed the revolutionary trend in the interest of capitalism-imperialism by forcing Netaji to resign from the post of the president of the Congress and finally expelling him.

In his presidential address at the Haripura Congress in 1938 he asserted: If after the capture of political power, national reconstruction takes place on socialistic lines -- as I have no doubt it will -- it is the "have-nots" who will benefit at the expense of the "haves" and the Indian masses have to be classified among the "have-nots".

Bose was of the view that 'the struggle for Independence has as its aim the removal of the triple bondage of political, economic and social oppression' resonates with views of Marx.

When world financial crisis struck in 2008, which is still far from over, mainstream media reported 'Booklovers turn to Karl Marx as financial crisis bites in Germany' (15 October 2008, The Guardian) and 'Marx popular amid credit crunch' (20 October 2008, BBC). The question is will the popular perception be accepted that "the history of all hitherto existing society is the history of class struggles"?

In the post World War II era, it is not evident that economical laws determine the course of history, as Marx contended.

Marx along with Friedrich Engels his co-author viewed this law of 'economic determinism' as the creative force in human progress. Engels stated, "The final causes of all social changes and political revolution are to be sought, not in men's brains, not in man's insight into internal truth and justice... but in the economies of each epoch."

Hasn't the time come to admit, "Religious suffering is, at one and the same time, the expression of real suffering and a protest against real suffering. Religion is the sigh of the oppressed creature, the heart of a heartless world, and the soul of soulless conditions. It is the opium of the people. The abolition of religion as the illusory happiness of the people is the demand for their real happiness. To call on them to give up their illusions about their condition is to call on them to give up a condition that requires illusions," as Marx argued?

Both free trade barbarism and wars take birth in the mental landscape. In fact they are conceptual constructs. When war begins in mind, peace must be built there reads motto of UNESCO created in the aftermath of application of nuclear weapons on Japanese cities of Hiroshima, Nagasaki by USA government to kill people and contaminate ecosystem in August 1945.

In a pithy article titled 'Occupy the Mind: Red Ink For Our Walls!' Slavoj Zizek, a political philosopher and a senior researcher at the University of Ljubljana, Slovenia aptly calls for occupation of mind perhaps as a next step to the Occupy Wall Street Movement. Bitter with the experience of how the ideology of Marx has been applied in practice, Zizek, in his book First as Tragedy, Then as Farce argues that "critical leftists have hitherto only succeeded in soiling those in power, whereas the real point is to castrate them . . ."

One European poet of English origin had long back committed an epistemic sin of having equated war with love by saying "all is fair in love and war". Had he been alive today and taken note of trade wars of last 400 years, he would surely have inferred that 'all is fair in trade' as well. When war is trade-in information, food, water, medicines, natural resources-ecological catastrophe and extinction of plant and animal species is deemed merely collateral damage or 'natural' like market forces. There is something deeply cannibalistic in the protestant ethics of capitalism that creates an illusion that there is anything ethical about unlimited profit at any cost fundamentalism. Following the same an emerging technology regime is attempting to create a convergence economy, People's March alone can give a befitting reply to such sinister efforts underway.

It is now for the fellow citizens and comrades among movements to devise the next plan of radical action to arrest further collapse in the face of companies with militarised mind that believe in acting might fully rather than rightfully irrespective human suffering. Destruction of ecological space during war and during peace time development both merit urgent attention, the impact appears to be the same. Is development, a war machine in conceptual cloak?

Emergence of a surveillance state using identification technologies is an expression of a militarised mind of the state, which still carries the residues of imperial propensities, which were opposed by Marx and Bose. It has been opposed even by a parliamentary committee and rejected by the electorate in Uttar Pradesh.

People's March on the death anniversary of Marx reveals the truthfulness of British writer John Berger's contention "the multitudes have answers to questions which have not yet been posed. The questions are not yet asked because to do so requires words and concepts which ring true, and those currently being used to name events have been rendered meaningless: Democracy, Liberty, Productivity, etc. With new concepts the questions will soon be posed, for history involves precisely such a process of questioning."

"In applying any theory to practice, you can never rule out geography or history. If you attempt it, you are bound to fail," said Bose. In the aftermath of the demise of socialist governments in USSR and China and in the imminent post capitalist world order, People's March alone holds the key to sane world economy instead of blind Europeanisation or Americanisation. Marx and Bose would not have disagreed.

Comments

Popular posts from this blog

Note: Procedural Establishments Under The Code Of Criminal Procedure, 1973: Section 197 of the Code of Criminal Procedure, 1973 gives protection to a person who is still a Public Servant at the time the prosecution is launched, and also when he is no longer a public servant. This is to protect the Public Servant from a case being filed against him after his retirement. When the government servant or the employee is not removable from his office without the sanction of the Central Government, then the same is necessary. Sanction under this section is not necessary before a Public Servant could be prosecuted for an offence of bribery under Section 161 of the Indian Penal Code, 1860. There are three facets in the consideration of the protection given by Section 197 of the Cr.P.C. to the acts done by public officers. (i) The act complained attaches to it the official character of the person doing it; (ii) The official character or status of the accused gave him an opportunity of doing the…

Press ReleaseQuestionable and illegal UIDAI completes four yearsMaj Gen S.G.Vombatkere, VSM tell President that UID is extra-legal,
unethical, coercive
New Delhi, 28 Jan, 2013: Prime
Minister headed Cabinet Committee on UID related matters (CCUIDRM) which also
deal with National Population Register (NPR) has ensured that Unique
Identification Authority of India (UIDAI) continues to complete its four years
of existence without any legal basis and without disclosing that UID database
and NPR database is being merged with the electoral database. UIDAI was created
by a notification of Planning Commission dated January28, 2009.The notification is attached. As of as on
January 2, 2013, Cabinet Committee on
Unique Identification Authority of India related issues includes Prime
Minister, Sharad Pawar, Minister of Agriculture and Minister of Food Processing
Industries, P. Chidambaram, Minister of Finance, Sushilkumar Shinde, Minister
of Home Affairs, Mallikarjun Kharge, Minister of Labour and …

At a program to mark the 76th birth anniversary of late Prabhash Joshi, well known columnist and former editor of Nayi Duniya, Jansatta and Indian Express, speaker after speaker demanded the formation of Third Press Commission. The program was organised on July 15 at Satyagrah Mandap, Raj Ghat by Prabhash Parampra Nyas and Gandhi Smriti awam Darshan Samiti.

It has come to light that the efforts of senior journalists like Ram Bahadur Rai, Ram Sharan Joshi and Kuldeep Nayar have been demanding setting up of the Third Press Commission from the Manmohan Singh Govt but due to resistance from the de facto head of the state, it has not been constituted so far.

Press Council of India in its report of 2001 had also recommended setting up of a Third Press Commission during Justice PB Swant's tenure. Justice G.N. Ray, the Press Council chairman also recommended it in his speech in 2009 in Kolkata.

In July 2011, at a function in Indore too, journalists marched in the streets demanding…