A follow-up to the book "Unnatural Acts: Critical Thinking, Skepticism and Science Exposed!" by Robert Todd Carroll, creator of The Skeptic's Dictionary. The blog will offer irregular postings about cognitive biases, logical fallacies, and illusions.

Site Map

Monday, February 4, 2013

the wisdom of not thinking too much

This will be last blog post for Unnatural Acts that can improve your thinking. Instead of introducing another cognitive bias or logical fallacy, this final post will be devoted to considering when wisdom requires that we stop thinking altogether or that we stop gathering data to reflect on.

We know that we have evolved to make quick decisions and that following our instincts has served the species pretty well, at least in terms of survival. The other entries in this blog have focused on the cognitive short cuts and logical fallacies that often accompany thinking that comes naturally. The focus has been on the importance of reflective thinking for making good judgments and coming to decisions that we won't regret. But there are times when a person will do better to stop thinking, stop reflecting, and to simply act. Not everyone arrives at this stage where the wise thing to do is to put critical thinking aside. Those who do have spent many years gaining knowledge, expertise, or performing ability. Their training, practice, and the skillful development of their talents have eliminated the need for reflection in order to do the right thing or make the right call. When it comes time to sing that aria before an adoring audience or swing at a 98 mph fastball in front of 50,000 baseball fanatics, thinking about what you are doing will hinder rather than help you succeed. When you have analyzed a problem to death in chemistry or physics, sometimes the best thing to do is to stop thinking about the problem and divert your attention to something else. There is no guarantee, but sometimes unconscious processes will provide you with the solution out of the blue. When an unexpected situation arises for which none of your years of training or experience has prepared you, following your instincts may be your best policy. All of these situations presuppose that you are extremely knowledgeable, have many years of experience, or have reached a performance level recognized as the highest level in your field. Herbert Simon, Nobel Prize winner in economics, put it this way: for the true expert, "intuition is nothing more than recognition." For the true expert, the situation provides cues and the cues give "the expert access to information stored in memory, and the information provides the answer" (quoted in Daniel Kahneman, Thinking, Fast and Slow, p. 11).

Experts in fields where reliable predictions occur with some regularity--such as physics, math, and chemistry--should be looked at differently than experts who make predictions in low-validity fields where long-term predictions are just guesswork because of the complexity of the system they are trying to master. Political and economic experts, for example, actually do worse than dart-throwing monkeys when it comes to making long-term predictions. (See Philip Tetlock, Expert Political Judgment: How Good Is It? How Can We Know? [2005]. Tetlock is a psychologist at the University of Pennsylvania who studied expert predictions over a twenty-year period.) The intuition of such experts is about as reliable as the intuition of the "average citizen" when asked to make long-term predictions about politics or the economy. It should go without saying that having high subjective confidence in one's knowledge or intuition is not a good sign of being accurate or wise.

People who are ignorant and have no experience and little talent but who follow their instincts are as likely to make bad decisions as stumble upon a good decision. But people who have vast amounts of knowledge, experience, or performing history should do little or no thinking while acting and should trust their instincts when working in their field of expertise. Outside their fields of expertise, of course, experts and talented artists are as vulnerable to the snares and lures of uncritical thinking as the rest of us.

There are also times when each of us should stop gathering more information to help us make a decision or judgment. Information overload can hinder our ability to make good judgments at times. Often we are better off making a decision by considering only a few obviously
important factors rather than by introducing as many pertinent items as we can come up with. The more variables we bring into play, the greater our chances of giving more weight to minor items and less weight to important items. This point was made clear by Daniel Kahneman and Amos Tversky in experiments that showed giving people more information about a subject led them to poorer decisions. One example has become a classic. Subjects are told that Linda is "thirty-one years old, single, outspoken, and very bright. She majored in philosophy. As a student, she was deeply concerned with issues of discrimination and social justice, and also participated in antinuclear demonstrations." Then they are asked which of several statements they thought would be true of Linda. In test after test, subjects thought it more likely that Linda was a feminist bank teller than that she was a bank teller. There is a fundamental logical error here, which Kahneman and Tversy called the conjunction fallacy. (A conjunction is the joining of two statements with words like 'and' or 'but'.) It should be obvious that there is a greater probability of a single conjunct being true than there is of both conjuncts being true (Daniel Kahneman, Thinking, Fast and Slow, p. 156). These conjunction error studies have been replicated by Christopher Hsee and John List with different scenarios presented to test subjects but with identical results to Kahneman and Tversky.

Gathering more and more information can give one the illusion of understanding. American psychologist and philosopher Paul Meehl compared the predictions of trained counselors versus a simple algorithm that used just two or three variables and found that the simple programs were significantly more accurate in their predictions than the more complex programs of the experts. A typical test might involve trying to predict the grade point average for various freshmen at the end of the school year. A simple formula that looked only at high school GPA and the results of one standardized college entrance test were compared with the predictions of counselors who had interviewed each student for 45 minutes and also had access to the results of several standardized tests and a four-page personal statement from each student. In that study, the simple algorithm outperformed 79 percent of the experts. American economist Orley Ashenfelter did a similar experiment involving predicting prices for fine Bordeaux wines. He pitted the experts against a simple formula that considered only weather, average temperature over the summer growing season, the amount of rain at harvest-time, and the total rainfall during the previous winter. Ashenfelter's formula outperformed the world-renowned experts. (Ashenfelter's work is discussed in Daniel Kahneman, Thinking, Fast and Slow, p. 224ff.)

In matters of personal taste, the less information the better. Just drink the wine, taste the jam, let your feelings tell you which print you prefer. Don't be influenced by how much the wine costs. Don't get hung up on the various qualities one might list to distinguish different jams. Don't get too many details about the various prints you have to choose from. If the one you like is affordable to you, buy it no matter what your friends or the critics say.

In decisions that are more or less trivial in the big picture--this would include everything from buying a new pen to deciding where to go on vacation or what new couch to buy--the less information the better. We've all heard the expression "paralysis by analysis." When a decision is a minor one, the wisest path is often to focus on two or three important points, rather than drum up a list of every pro and con you can think of and then apply your list to dozens of possible choices.

In decisions that are monumental, such as the decision to send troops to fight in a foreign country or to take a loved one off life support, one should get as much information as possible from trustworthy sources who aren't likely to be biased. In such cases, we should consult with both those who are likely to think in ways we are likely to agree with and with those who are likely to disagree with us. Important decisions require diversity of input. In the end, the evidence may seem to weigh equally for going to war and not going to war or for taking a loved off life support and keeping a loved one on life support. You may have no choice but to rely on your gut feeling at that point. (Cf. William James's "The Will to Believe"). The only other alternative I can see is to take a vote among one's advisers or family members (or whatever group is relevant to the decision-making process) and go with whatever the majority thinks.

So, while wisdom requires devotion to critical thinking, it also requires knowing when to turn off critical thinking and rely on intuition, gut feeling, instinct, or whatever you choose to call that non-reflective preference percolating in our ever-fascinating brains.

Oh no! The end, so soon? I hope all is well. I found my way here a few months ago, for the first time.

This was a wonderful post. It is completely consistent with my personal world view. I am invulnerable to confirmation bias, of course. On a more serious note, thank you so much. Your approach isn't dogmatic. You are never condescending. I'll echo Mike D's comment, that your blog was, and will continue to be a valuable resource.

Very interesting. What do you make of Malcom Gladwell's "Blink?"I read it some time ago, but seem to recall that he makes generally the same thesis as you in your article, although Gladwell leans a bit more toward snap decisions in just about all situations.I know from experience that turning off the thinking about a stumping crossword solution works. Returning after a period of thinking about other things often results in surprising insight and solution. Works in other areas as well. Let it go for awhile, and an correct answer often appears as if by magic.

I dont believe is magic when the correct answer appears. We are all conected by the devine matrix and as reiki shows us, there is a natural flow of wellnes. Just read here: http://tarot-el-paso-reiki.com/

Truly a great work is here. This is the article to whom I was searching for a long time and now I found it here, I enjoy after finding this precious post and also would like to say thanks to you for such a informative post. You have done a very impressive work.PassbeeMedia

It is our objective to generate the first Power Van for 90 periods and find out all of the technicalities that might come with an EV or if there are any style changes we would like to have involved with upcoming vehicles,”plano dentist

I recently took a Media Bistro class and although I did learn a lot, I'm not sure it justified the high cost of the class. If they were cheaper, I would take them much more frequently.100CouponCode.com

I recently came across your article and have been reading along. I want to express my admiration of your writing skill and ability to make readers read from the beginning to the end. I would like to read newer posts and to share my thoughts with you.ha long bay

Hi, I think now I have a strong hold over the topic after going through the post. The subject that you have discussed in the post is really amazing; I will surely come back for more information.Swarovski 2014 Crystal Snowflake Ornament

Nice article. Really nice. I have a hunch that this is going to be a really top class article in the future. This has earned my 100% respect. I am sure after some time it will earn other's respect as well.West Palm Beach attorneys

There is so much in this article that I would never have thought of on my own. Your content gives readers things to think about in an interesting way. Thank you for your clear information.gospeltracts bible tracks

Thank you for some other informative website. The place else may just I get that kind of information written in such a perfect method? I have a venture that I am simply now running on, and I’ve been at the glance out for such info.Me Before You Official Movie Review Complete

I blog frequently and I really thank you for your information. The article has truly peaked my interest. I will book mark your blog and keep checking for new information about once per week. I opted in for your RSS feed too.perfume oil

I simply want to tell you that I am new to weblog and definitely liked this blog site. I have been meaning to write something like this on my website and you have given me an idea.Patent Attorney Naples

Regular practise and careful playing is required to be able to convey and evolve the different themes, rewarding you with that intimate instrument connection that we musicians lust for.personal injury lawyer West Palm Beach

Regular practise and careful playing is required to be able to convey and evolve the different themes, rewarding you with that intimate instrument connection that we musicians lust for.personal injury lawyer West Palm Beach

Banks are understanding with regards to loaning to understudies, and incorporate a scope of motivators, from premium just installments to times of beauty, to make credits reasonable. Be that as it may, once they graduate, the truth sets in.custom shirts canada

Your Chandigarh escorts like to fulfill with fresh men and invest some time together. At Fanni, we've enjoyable and pleasant escorts to give a great time to you. So that they may place the work that is very best to cause you to pleased each time you fulfill with them. They'll additionally ensure that your very first time visit in Chandigarh may be worth visit, in the event that you visit the area again and you'll absolutely request them.

I'm Fanni, a standout between the many wanted female escorts in Chandigarh and appeared. I've gained an unparalleled prestige and verification being a specialist grown up artist within the town of Chandigarh and provide my effective services towards the people who've nothing to rejoice within their existence as a result on most severe erotic frustration directed at them by their interpersonal existence attractive accomplices.

Our admittance into Chandigarh escorts area wasn't chancy at everything except instead it had been a transfer that is very significantly calculated from my part. Examining erotica has easily been my infatuation right since from my college times, and today after I am grown crazy up, I have to depart no open-door for my yearning's fulfillment.

If you should be looking for the best quality feminine adult artists commonly named the Jalandhar escorts you've looked the best location. We're the absolute most far famed qualified escort agency in D helping our much talked about customers across groups offering the busty school girls alluring air-hostesses and also leading models with numerous options of skilled enjoyment providers.

By strolling through the library I figured out that the number of pages of my master's thesis is five standard deviations lower than the average number of pages my friends have written to graduate from the Vienna University of Economics and Business.regular money transfer payments

Numerous individuals possess a dream to invest moment having a Housewife Companion in Chandigarh simply because they need an older Companions having an excellent encounter therefore below for you personally begin to see the Housewife escorts to find out more about these we're.An Air Hostess Chandigarh escorts is a superb option regarding hello-account males who would like an ideal friend of the female using elegance views the class for information.

Welcome towards Chandigarh escorts' greatest site!! You're in the really correct location if you like to savor the trip of paradise. If you should be a grownup and 18 +, we shall welcome you having a large grin. We're not for that which you do within our site responsible. If you're buying attractive attractive and stunning chandigarh escorts or if you imagine a sexy queen who'll treat you subsequently we are able to assist you to.

Your girls will be attracted to recognition, appeal and the money of the company. That is one of the primary reasons why every one of these supreme quality call girls in Chandigarh chose this profession. We are exceptionally pleased to display the account of call girls that are appealing in Chandigarh who're in a position to aid you to truly have a good time in Chandigarh for you. Should you be trying to find appealing chandigarh escorts Here’s a perfect area to suit your needs.

I would like to thank you for the efforts you have made in writing this article. I am hoping the same best work from you in the future as well. In fact your creative writing abilities has inspired me to start my own BlogEngine blog now. Really the blogging is spreading its wings rapidly. Your write up is a fine example of it.vintage shops near me

They hear directly from the market about pain points and needs, and they often have the relationships necessary to get buy twitter followers your message through when an impersonal public post or email would get lost in a sea of online activity.Termite Inspection West Chester

We possibly may would rather guarantee you of discretion and discernment at all occasions, we often are a specialist agency that preserves discretion and discernment and you will unwind and luxuriate using some of our impartial escorts service in Chandigarh in your own time. Something, our women may swing be useful using, is the fact that the indisputable fact that anyone’ll be represented by them everywhere you-go. Be perhaps a unique meeting, or it a noisy celebration using buddies with acquaintances, you will be prepared to permanently consider the proven fact that is particular that the female escort that is truly amazing are likely to have the ability to keep consistently the vocabulary heading and everybody the people there fascinated. That certainly will provide a satisfying atmosphere and method you will increase every your self-confidence. This is often that we are able to verify to search out the best independent call girls for the ideal evening and why it is permanently wise cause to get hold of people nowadays.

The fingers and thumbs are used to open up the ongoing energy lines on the legs and foot between.Chandigarh female escorts The therapeutic massage stay stimulates that activity of inner organs to enhance bloodstream and lymph blood circulation in the body to give ongoing ejaculation to the body correct w hen required.

Please give some period to move through with about me personally page and also my pictures account web page rather, because my site is certainly a something exclusive from other Chandigarh Escorts sites, I experience it is needed accordingly, to ongoing explore in specify my services. Numerous gentlemen that search my-site comment me that they hardly ongoing ever experienced the satisfaction from the business of any Chandigarh independent escort before or make use of any type of high class companionship.

When s he is met by you, you feel like you're here in heaven w here a great deal of therefore hot and gorgeous children play with you and you ongoing enjoy with her because w e also provide regards leader and independent escorts in chandigarh take which may be the first selection of the people so to meet her you experience therefore agreeable and wish to spend so very much stage with her. Therefore if you would like to observe white beauty with you get in touch with two female assistance in right here and full all you hunger desire which you comprehensive simply by take altered type of like ongoing enjoyments.

Are you seeking an indie take in Chandigarh? Meet me personally once and we shall make you content by my mind-blowing Chandigarh escort services. I was a popular American Indian companion young lady from New Chandigarh and a young, sexy and beautiful Chandigarh escort girl. I am a well educated female passed out from Chandigarh University simply. I have always been a high class and presentable lady and you could hire me for every event. I am available anytime, anywhere in escorts in Chandigarh for both in Outcalls and phone calls escort services in Chandigarh.

We provide both type of take solutions in female escorts in Chandigarh. I can go to you if a hotel is had by you room. On the additional method if you do not really possess any resort then you can come to my hotel space anytime 24x7. My assistance charges are inexpensive and greatest as per marketplace and you may get in touch with me straight on my phone number provided on my contact web page. You can also get in touch with me via email and I also prefer this technique because it's secure.

This is the purpose for which their customer platform includes entrepreneurs and expert guys centered in Chandigarh. They anticipate and necessity to possess an exceptional escort support. Choice may be done by the interesting and increasing profile of wonderful female escort service Chandigarh to select from. If you are in the town of Chandigarh and want escorts company, go for the town's most popular escorts ladies. You can get provided by models by divas and time by evening.

Our female escorts in Panchkula is open 24 × 7 and therefore our client bolster personnel are in like way promptly accessible 24 × 7. They'll hardly ever at any point end up being stupefied or sick carefully bred, irrespective of the known fact that you call at the little hours of the early morning hours or night. We choose them with most intense analysis and speaking with and subsequently we can guarantee you a soft procedure with us.

I am Ramita Shetty Acertainly will usually display my appreciation and do adore the better issues in existence although. Actually thought using TWO spectacular sex unique girls of a heavenly TWO girl treat. Nicely several dreams may come accurate whenever personally is joined by you, and my partner in you or a heavenly TWO girl treat may be really bold having a bi-sexual that is complete rendezvous around, most dreams could be reality.

When she is in your room normally, you simply observe her you will be shocked simply by their beauty in fact simply get in touch with her any asset is enough to seduce you. They have curvy and Panchkula independent escorts that can make crazy really.

If you were looking for someone to embody the essence of a boss lady, Jenna Lyons would be it. She's not only the president and executive creative a fashion label for prime quality Italian leather items.golf short game