Each of the category scores in this review are calculated using a weighted average of several questions that we rate on a scale of 1 to 10.

The following breakdown explains what these scores typically mean. All of our Teams use this as a reference for providing accurate ratings:

10: “Peak Performance”This score is treated as if it has a chastity belt on it. “10’s” are reserved for the best of the best; those that we feel could not possibly improve on what they’re doing.

9: “Innovative and Groundbreaking”It rocked! Nearly everything seemed to go as planned and it was one of the best we’ve ever seen! These guys are leaders in the industry, and attractions like this are truly hard to come by.

8: “Solid”A high score on our scale. They had a good handle on it and, overall, they knew how to use it well. Most attractions can learn from what these guys are doing.

6 to 7: “Good”We could tell that a good effort was made. However, we’ve seen this done much better at other places, or can detect areas where significant improvements can be made. This is about the top end of what we’d call “Family Friendly.”

5: “Average / Fair”Compared to the competition, they weren’t the best, but definitely not the worst. Scares and Special Effects in this range are usually considered “Family Friendly.”

3 to 4: “Below Average”We could see that a clear attempt was made, but most other professional attractions are doing a much better job at this.

1 to 2: “Poor”It appeared that very little time, thought or effort was contributed to this aspect.

0 (Zero): “Non-Existent”No apparent effort was made to make this a significant contributor to the attraction.

Afterword:This rating system is standardized across all of The Scare Factor’s official haunt review teams. However, keep in mind there will always be minor differences between Teams, as we all have varying levels of experience. Regardless, we do our best to remain true to our core values, which is to promote all haunted attractions!Perhaps the biggest thing to remember is: sometimes the score – in and of itself – doesn’t tell the whole story about an attraction’s merits. This is why we provide detailed explanations for each category… to help you better understand how and why we chose the score/s that we did.We do our best to not let feelings or emotions rule our judgement, while also viewing the attraction through the lens of the typical haunt-goer. But, because all reviews with ratings are inherently subjective, this is nearly impossible to completely prevent. Though, when in doubt, we tend to give slightly lower scores than our original “gut feelings” to account for this, and also give the attraction more room to improve over time.We also do our best to be fair and consistent across all of the haunts that we review. We know that you’ll be looking at these scores and comparing them to other attractions, so we hope this review helps you out in that aspect.Do you have some feedback about our review system? Contact Us Here to let us know what you think!

Hide This

Final Score: 8.14

How Did We Get This Score?

Final Scores:

(15% of Final Score) Cast: 7.77

(15% of Final Score) Costuming: 6.9

(10% of Final Score) Customer Service: 9.23

(10% of Final Score) Atmosphere: 8.69

(15% of Final Score) Special Effects: 8.18

(5% of Final Score) Theme: 8.83

(15% of Final Score) Scare Factor: 8.39

(5% of Final Score) Entertainment & Value: 8.15

Hide This

Summary:

Go to Hell!

Don’t worry; at Dungeon of Horrors at least, it’s a wild ride down.

Back again for another season, Dungeon of Horrors in Moundsville, West Virginia features an exciting blend of a realistic death row prison experience and a horrific glimpse of what may come after. It’s a long journey, with some thrilling experiences along the way, and plenty of wicked Hellians to keep you company.

The Fiery Lake awaits in Moundsville. Eternal Damnation has never been so much fun.

Cast: 7.77

How Did We Get This Score?

Cast Scores (15% of Final Score):

(20% of Cast Score) Did it seem like there were enough actors?: 7.75

(30% of Cast Score) How believable / convincing were the actors?: 7.25

(20% of Cast Score) How interactive were the actors?: 8.5

(15% of Cast Score) How creatively & appropriately did they use dialogue?: 7.85

(15% of Cast Score) Was there a good variety of characters?: 7.75

Hide This

Dungeon of Horrors features a very young cast. It seemed that beyond a handful of adults, most of the actors that we encountered were school-aged. In some roles, this worked perfectly well, but for others, well… it does break the suspension of disbelief a bit being strapped down in Old Sparky by a 14 or 15 year old prison guard.

Still, the first two guards maintained appropriate intensity without shifting into needlessly-uncomfortable territory. The atmosphere generated by the actors in the prison portion were a nice middle ground between the “probably leave the kids at home” intensity of the first season we reviewed and the light-hearted version from last season.

Of course the curiously-horned Last Rites priest excelled as the most intense actor (he REALLY hated us), while the congenial Ringmaster and his lovely assistant were about as close to “friendly” as Hell’s horde was to us.

In fairness, though, several of the young haunters did provide a few of the best performances that we encountered. The pushy cemetery plot salesman got top nods for his comical, interactive delivery, even if his fees were more than we could ultimately afford. A word of caution, however, be sure not to ask him about Bill. He hates that.

The Wheel of Torment-room governess must have been told a unshakably hilarious joke before we arrived. To eschew the awkwardness, we chose to laugh right along with her while performing our menial slog.

The two gals who shepherded us into our afterlife carriages were intense and clever (“GO TO HELL” as one’s parting remark was worth a chuckle), as were the mortuary attacker and victim.

The actor load was a bit light overall, with a few extended dead spots. Though the haunt is, by its nature, very interactive, only a handful of actors offered off-script responses to our inquiries, and there were quite a few rough performances that we encountered.

Costuming: 6.9

How Did We Get This Score?

Costuming Scores (15% of Final Score):

(15% of Costuming Score) How complete / finished did the costumes appear to be?: 6

(25% of Costuming Score) How creative / detailed were the costumes?: 6.75

(15% of Costuming Score) How effectively did they use masks (if used)?: 6.5

(25% of Costuming Score) How appropriate were the costumes for their scene/s & theme/s?: 7.75

Hide This

To get it out of the way, the antagonists featured in the first, semi-realistic portion of the attraction were prison guards. They wore prison guard outfits – no problem there; the horned clergyman is a bit of an oddity, but I can see what they were going for.

The real costuming issue commences post-mortem. While prison guards wearing “normal” clothes is as logical a costuming choice a haunt can have, the vast majority of actors that we encountered during the fantastical section of the attraction were ALSO wearing “normal” clothes. Sometimes this could be rationalized away to varying degrees (depending on the context of the underworld scene we were viewing), but it was just far too common and conspicuous throughout most scenes. I realize that a characterization can occasionally get by with a set of dark, otherwise-ordinary clothing, but it’s difficult to envision the great hellions of Hades’s legions showing up for battle in jeans and t-shirts without chuckling.

There were a few interesting costumes on display, for sure. The obvious stand-out was a monstrous bat who lead us past the underground pool. It was a unique outfit with definite menace locked into its scowling exterior. The last actor, sporting a snazzy, webby ensemble made up for an earlier, woeful web-based costume (literally some Spirit webbing tossed over a normal outfit haphazardly). The Ringmaster wore appropriately gaudy and colorful apparel, and the hypocritical friar (we can SEE the devil horns, bro) who well-wished us into infinity, appeared authentically pious from the neck down. The purveyor of the very first scare wore a cute clown costume… as he sought to murder us.

Makeup was largely basic — often adequate, sometimes rough. In general, there was just enough for most characterizations as to get the general “point” across.

There were a handful of masks in use. One mask that was otherwise interesting (a two-headed oddity from the circus area) was unfortunately undermined by its own sloppy usage. Generally, when actors utilized masks, it is highly recommended that the bottom of the mask be covered by clothing. It helps to sell the illusion of being genuine and not an obvious mask. Because this character was only in street clothes, the mask was not tucked-in and, well, looked pretty silly.

Customer Service: 9.23

How Did We Get This Score?

Customer Service Scores (10% of Final Score):

(25% of CS Score) How easy was it to locate the attraction, park, and navigate the premises?: 9.5

(30% of CS Score) How safe was the attraction?: 9

(25% of CS Score) How professional, helpful and friendly were the staff members?: 10

(20% of CS Score) How easy was it to find their information before you arrived?: 8.25

Hide This

Though there weren’t any sort of parking spotters, we saw multiple parking lots open and available near the entrance to the attraction, and plenty of room along the road for additional parking. Given the ticketing style in use this year, this is more than enough space.

The Dungeon seems to switch its starting position every year or two, with this year maintaining that trend. Last season’s thriving hub area is now present only at the end of the attraction. Instead, customers enter the Dungeon from the side of the building (near the parking lots).

Because of this change, the area surrounding the entrance was largely threadbare. Excluding a few portable toilets and an unattended strongman game, there was a single food truck (with some haunt-unique items available). There is a well-stocked merchandise area available inside the prison which I’d imagine is only accessible to customers who have been accepted into the attraction but not yet actually begun their tour. We didn’t notice any pre-haunt entertainment or line scarers, though there also wasn’t a line…

…Because this season Dungeon of Horrors has reverted to a timed-ticketing system. Customers purchase tickets in advance for a specific time slot (at 15 minute intervals), so obnoxious line-waiting has been removed. This is always a very welcome design that helps both sides of the business.

AFTER the attraction has completed, we emerged into last season’s courtyard. It has retained its zombie paintball play area.

All of the staff we encountered were friendly and helpful.

Atmosphere: 8.69

How Did We Get This Score?

Atmosphere Scores (10% of Final Score):

(60% of Atmosphere Score) How obvious was it that you were at a haunted house before entering?: 8.25

(40% of Atmosphere Score) How well did the atmosphere prepare you for what you experienced inside?: 9.35

Hide This

Due in no small part, I’d imagine, to the reintroduction of timed-ticketing, both the beginning and end hub areas were surprisingly quiet. Don’t get me wrong, it’s still a haunted attraction inside a massive, Gothic prison, but it was certainly noticeable how calm everything felt. Excluding a few lights strobing the side of the prison, the facade was kept fairly natural. Again, that “natural” is still a mega-creepy prison.

Also, the in-theme bus ride portion that traditionally ferries haunt-goer’s to the beginning of the attraction was discontinued this season. We had mixed-feelings about this. In terms of atmosphere, though, its lack erased a degree of immersion within the attraction. Previously, the bus ride served as the transition betwixt reality and the fantastic. Without it, we were thrust directly into the custody of a guard we had seen smiling jovially a few minutes prior. This change was a bit jarring without the bus ride.

The location still has a great feel overall, with the prison’s oppressive mass providing ample palm-sweat as we awaited our turn.

Special Effects: 8.18

How Did We Get This Score?

Special Effects Scores (15% of Final Score):

(20% of SFX Score) How effective were the sound effects?: 9

(20% of SFX Score) How creative / original were the scenes & props?: 8.75

(20% of SFX Score) How well were the scenes detailed?: 6.5

(25% of SFX Score) How well did they achieve & maintain the suspension of disbelief?: 7.75

(15% of SFX Score) How effective were the SFX at providing scares / entertainment?: 9.25

Hide This

Fortunately, the Dungeon has retained all its best set pieces from last season. Their River Styx effect/experience remains the apex of laser swampdom. Claustrophobic digestion through the internal organs of a monstrous insect is always a fun journey as well, and the best-framed version of that classic effect (I noticed this year that insectoid body parts are affixed to the end of the tunnel as well… does that mean that we passed through the organism’s entire digestive process? A butt; I’m asking if we just came out of its butt).

Speaking of cramped journeys, the pair of miniature, haunted thrill rides remain as well. Because they are such a welcome surprise to any first time visitors, I prefer to keep these excellent side-expeditions enigmatic. They’re still gleefully fun, though, like abbreviated entries in a macabre theme park.

One Special Effect staple that has lost some of its potency, though, is the concluding dark maze. It seemed much lighter this year which made traversing it significantly less grandiose. Perhaps safety concerns are the culprit here, but it was disappointing nonetheless.

The Dungeon includes two massive animatronic monstrosities, including Ol’ Red who provides a summary of the second half’s story line. His first few years he seemed to suffer from some form of diabolical speech impediment, but this time around he was as coherent and sober as we could have asked for. Also, it occurred to me this year that my boy sounds eerily John Goodmany. Do you have a confession to make, Mr. Conner?

Despite adding a few new sets (an evil church, circus, mortuary), the cemetery stretch is probably still the Dungeon’s best aesthetic segment. With rows of realistic tombstones jutting out of real dirt plots, it’s a great immersive environment. The underground pool/fountain area and it’s introductory drawbridge are also a definite treat.

Set design on the whole, though, felt especially barren. In addition to multiple portions of mostly uninteresting black walls with occasional lighting effects, we passed through one orange room or hallway that seemed to have received no “haunt attention” at all.

One thing that did improve this season was the use of ambient sounds. Many of the areas featured interesting, varied soundtracks. The “wooden maze” “Styx”, “Evil Chapel” and the “sheet maze” were among the best examples, not overpowering the scenes they overlaid, but enhancing them. The chapel’s background chanting was especially effective.

I suppose it should be mentioned here as a form of FX – the haunt rules are presented before the attraction begins via a long, satirical video. It’s an interesting method to provide that information, but… yeah, let’s leave it at that.

Combining decent FX and set design, a post-catastrophe bus lines the outdoor tract that connects the main attraction to the last, self-contained sliver at its end. Hazy and dreadful, it was a nice chunk of eye candy to close out the experience, but it would have been nice to have actually been able to walk through it instead of beside it. Next year perhaps.

Theme: 8.83

How Did We Get This Score?

Theme Scores (5% of Final Score):

(30% of Theme Score) Could you tell what the theme was?: 8.75

(50% of Theme Score) How well was the theme carried throughout the attraction/s?: 8.45

(20% of Theme Score) How well does their location authenticate the theme?: 9.9

Hide This

Since their large remodel a few years ago, the theme at Dungeon Horrors has, broadly, remained this same : the customer is taken to prison after having been sentenced of a significant crime, is executed, and then descends into Hades. Sunshine and rainbows – you know. The initial version made a play at Dante’ing up the Pit with a stronger narrative, but that element has been abandoned.

With the abrupt introduction to the attraction, things aren’t spelled out as fully this year and progress too quickly, and one could be forgiven for not really understanding what is happening before the execution scene. After that, the literal and metaphorical descent is pretty tough to miss. The Infernal Big Cheese spells things out as well.

At first, I was confused as to why a circus, morgue, etc, would be in Hell, but after listening to Big Red’s monologue again, I realized that we were being subjected to our deepest fears. I suppose just about anything could qualify within that framework, so no further issues, Your Honor.

Though, there weren’t any people-sized army ants clicking their disgusting little pincered-faces in my direction, so El Diablo may have been a bit off in his calculations. He’s not perfect, after all. That’s the other Guy (I’m told).

As I mentioned in Cast, the teen prison guard was a bit of a stretch. Also, the random, untouched room that we passed through tugged at the fabric of illusion pretty strongly. Does Hell have a maintenance closet?

It’s still a great transition between the realistic death row experience and the underworld. That aspect of the theme continues to hold up well.

Scare Factor: 8.39

How Did We Get This Score?

Scare Factor Scores (15% of Final Score):

(30% of Scare Factor Score) How scary was it?: 7.25

(15% of Scare Factor Score) How well did they provide scares to the entire group?: 9.55

(25% of Scare Factor Score) How predictable were the scares?: 8.75

(15% of Scare Factor Score) How well did they provide a wide variety of scares?: 8.65

(15% of Scare Factor Score) How strong was the ending / finale?: 8.65

Hide This

Again, let me begin with the pseudo-realistic prison segment. As I mentioned before, its moderate intensity worked as a good build-up. Obviously being placed in a prison cell with an overbearing prison guard harassing you as you listen to the unsimulated cries of previous customers is an excellent realistic fright. The execution scene with its UNBELIEVABLY loud effects will also amp up the heart-rate of any patrons who are first time visitors.

For any haunt fans who hate glare-scares and boo-startles, the Dungeon was pretty light on both. Most of the actors were involved in the vignettes that played out in each room to some degree, on one side or other of the unfolding sadism. Therefore, most of the fright attempts (and efforts to establish an overall spooky atmosphere) were derived from our interactions with those characters. A few of these were efficient, but too often the “scary” culmination of a scene or interaction simply evolved into the actor screaming as loud as he or she could at us until we left. Obviously this can be a worthwhile tactic but it was definitely overused. On the plus side, these scares generally applied to every member of our group.

Of the few startle scares, the best seemed to involve non-human contributors, at least in part. The giant, chained demon that suddenly appeared beside us was surprisingly startling. The long-standing vibrating hallway still hasn’t gotten old.

There were a few other distraction-infused pop-ups but those must be left to the imagination until you visit.

The dark maze’s potency has been reduced this year as a (kind-of) send-off, but is still a pretty effective way to inflict a final bit of psychological torment on oneself before escaping.

Entertainment & Value: 8.15

How Did We Get This Score?

Entertainment & Value Factor Scores (15% of Final Score):

(30% of E&V Score) How satisfied are you with the entertainment received during the main attraction/s?: 8.25

(25% of E&V Score) How satisfied are you with the entertainment that’s available with the ticket price, excluding the main attraction/s?: 8

(30% of E&V Score) How appropriate is/are the ticket price/s?: 8.25

(15% of E&V Score) Have they effectively used their available space?: 8

Hide This

At 39 minutes long, Dungeons of Horrors still runs pretty long for a haunted attraction – longer if one were to include the rules video. A general admission ticket is $25. Therefore the MPD is a healthy 1.56. The duration does fluctuate due to the nature of (actual) mazes, and the Dungeon’s (sort of) ultimate antagonist is certainly the real deal, even if it’s a bit brighter now.

As I mentioned earlier, zombie paintball is still available for an up-charge. More importantly, though, the scary-in-a-different-way North Walk tour is also still going on for $20. Booking a slot for each attraction is a great way to spend the haunted evening.

There’s no denying that we feel that this season’s Dungeon is a step backwards. Since their big redesign a few years ago, we’ve only noticed minor additions each season, but this year was probably the most underwhelming evolution. Fortunately, the best elements of the attraction remain (if surrounded by largely hit-or-miss actor performances), so it was still a very fun attraction, and could even be considered more of a family haunt this year – minus a simulated beheading or two. And who doesn’t love the inherently-creepy architecture of the greatest set piece from the attraction, the prison itself?

The Dungeon of Horrors is still an exciting way to spend a haunted weekend… as long as you remember to pay the ferryman!

How Did We Get These Scores

Our Rating System

Each of the category scores in this review are calculated using a weighted average of several questions that we rate on a scale of 1 to 10.

The following breakdown explains what these scores typically mean. All of our Teams use this as a reference for providing accurate ratings:

10: “Peak Performance”This score is treated as if it has a chastity belt on it. “10’s” are reserved for the best of the best; those that we feel could not possibly improve on what they’re doing.

9: “Innovative and Groundbreaking”It rocked! Nearly everything seemed to go as planned and it was one of the best we’ve ever seen! These guys are leaders in the industry, and attractions like this are truly hard to come by.

8: “Solid”A high score on our scale. They had a good handle on it and, overall, they knew how to use it well. Most attractions can learn from what these guys are doing.

6 to 7: “Good”We could tell that a good effort was made. However, we’ve seen this done much better at other places, or can detect areas where significant improvements can be made. This is about the top end of what we’d call “Family Friendly.”

5: “Average / Fair”Compared to the competition, they weren’t the best, but definitely not the worst. Scares and Special Effects in this range are usually considered “Family Friendly.”

3 to 4: “Below Average”We could see that a clear attempt was made, but most other professional attractions are doing a much better job at this.

1 to 2: “Poor”It appeared that very little time, thought or effort was contributed to this aspect.

0 (Zero): “Non-Existent”No apparent effort was made to make this a significant contributor to the attraction.

Afterword:This rating system is standardized across all of The Scare Factor’s official haunt review teams. However, keep in mind there will always be minor differences between Teams, as we all have varying levels of experience. Regardless, we do our best to remain true to our core values, which is to promote all haunted attractions!Perhaps the biggest thing to remember is: sometimes the score – in and of itself – doesn’t tell the whole story about an attraction’s merits. This is why we provide detailed explanations for each category… to help you better understand how and why we chose the score/s that we did.We do our best to not let feelings or emotions rule our judgement, while also viewing the attraction through the lens of the typical haunt-goer. But, because all reviews with ratings are inherently subjective, this is nearly impossible to completely prevent. Though, when in doubt, we tend to give slightly lower scores than our original “gut feelings” to account for this, and also give the attraction more room to improve over time.We also do our best to be fair and consistent across all of the haunts that we review. We know that you’ll be looking at these scores and comparing them to other attractions, so we hope this review helps you out in that aspect.Do you have some feedback about our review system? Contact Us Here to let us know what you think!

Promo Images:

Click to Enlarge

Guest ReviewsGuest Average: 9.75 out of 10

DC Books – 9.5/10Amazing haunt. One of the best we’ve been. Custom sets, and a themed plot that follows you all the …show more way through a real prison. More focus on creepy storytelling than screamy jump scares, but there’s a bit of that too. Totally worth the trip, and the highlight of this year’s Season of the Witch road trip. Also very reasonably priced for such a detailed haunt.

Mike Adams – 10.0/10I have been to several Haunted Attractions and this is by far the best in the Ohio Valley. …show more Constantly improving.