Prior art searching

We will now take you step by step through two prior art search
processes: a product search and a patent search.

You must do both
to be confident that you have done a thorough prior art search. You must also
do them before spending significant amounts of time and money on
your idea.

Warnings!

It may take only minutes on the internet to find prior art.
If you do not look for it, companies and investors almost certainly will. You
are unlikely to get help or funding if they find crucial prior art that you have
missed.

Do not
ignore evidence you do not like. The purpose of a prior art search is to go looking for evidence you may not
like.

An
absence of prior art at the time of your searches may not be a permanent
absence. You should update your prior art searches periodically as you develop
your idea.

No prior
art search - not even an official Patent Office examination - is regarded in
law as conclusive proof of novelty.

Step
1: Finding
the right keywords

To
maximise your chances of finding relevant information, spend some time thinking
of key words or search terms which best describe your idea.

When using search engines, the most obvious key words may
be unhelpful. For example, let us say your idea is a mousetrap. A search for
‘mousetrap' produces over two million hits - many of them irrelevant, and an
impossible number to search.

But a search for ‘rodent trap' (what else it is) and
‘trapping mice' (what it does) produces 20,000 and 700 hits respectively. These
are still not small numbers but they are
likely to be more relevant, so we can usefully start searching here.

Another problem: the most productive search terms may be
specialist technical terms that you do not know. For example, a search for
external devices that pump blood round the human body required the crucial medical
term ‘extra corporeal'. A searcher with no medical knowledge would be unlikely
to know this term, but might find it while examining the results of other key
word searches. It may therefore take a few preliminary searches to find better
keywords to use for more accurate searches.

Look out too for new terms for new technologies: for
example, ‘virtual fit' for software systems to replace trying on clothes in
shops, and ‘telemedicine' for remote monitoring of patients in their own homes.

Step
2: Product searching

You
need to find out what is already on the market:

That is similar to your idea
(prior art).

That tackles the same problem
(competing art).

Obsolete technologies or products may be prior art, so
check historical as well as current sources of information.

Products in development but not yet on the market may be
prior art, so search news sites, industry journals, trade show and exhibition
websites. Perhaps especially search academic research activity, as this is where
many new products start out, often years before a commercial product appears.

You should also of course search offline - in shops,
books, periodicals, printed catalogues etc.

And talk to people with relevant experience - for example,
retailers and suppliers - who will have seen products come and go over the
years and may have seen your idea among them. (People who have retired from
relevant careers can be valuable sources of information, as their experience
may go back much further than current practitioners!)

Step
3: Patent searching

For many ideas, patent searching will be far more important than
product searching. Although many products on the market do not have a patent,
they are probably heavily outnumbered by the many ideas that are successfully
patented but never reach the market.

Patent searching involves two skills:

Finding
every patent document that is relevant to your invention.

Interpreting
the significance of your patent search findings. We will deal with this in Part 3 .

We are going to show you how to use the European Patent
Office's free Espacenet
database, which
is easy for beginners to use.

However, you are unlikely to be as good as a professional
searcher, so in some cases it may be advisable to ask a professional to search
for you. (See Professional patent searching.) An exception
is if there is so much prior art that your search ends quickly!

How
long will your search take?

It could range from a few minutes, if your first keywords
are accurate and there is a great deal of prior art, to many hours.

The best advice is that you must be prepared to spend all
the time it takes to be confident that you have done a proper job. Your mission
is to find evidence that disproves
the novelty of your invention. Your hope is that you will fail, but in the
interests of a thorough search you must put that to the back of your mind.

For the same reason, assume that if you are not finding
prior art, you are looking in the wrong places.

Keep searching until you are confident that there is
nowhere else left to look. And keep
records of everywhere you look and everything relevant that you find.

A
thorough and well-recorded search is essential - because how else do you prove
an absence of prior art?