Комментарий от Glanco

Комментарий от Huennin

Not true, for the Alliance quest you get a stack of Shoveltusk Soup but no recipe.

Комментарий от Shadoweric

Alright, talked to a GM. He says it's working as intended now.

Now GMs can't tell you where to find an item, but he did confirm that the recipe is still in the game. He also confirmed that there are NO cooking recipes as quest rewards in Northrend at the moment.

So there are 2 possibilities here: 1 - They're now drops or rare daily cooking quest reward and we'll find them sooner or later. 2 - They are supposed to be quest rewards, something broke and they got removed from the quest rewards, but the recipes are still in the database, which is why he told me they are still in the game. Which would be a bug.

I hope it's #1 and that someone will find them eventually.

A heads-up from the profession/quest guys would have been nice if the change is intended.

Комментарий от Amante

That GM doesn't know what he's talking about - the Northern Stew recipe is a quest reward.

Комментарий от jdaymet

Just to make sure you understand.

GMs know absolutely nothing, many of them know less than the regular player.

So a GM saying that something is "working as intended" doesn't mean a thing.

I have had GMs tell me that something is "working as intended" when the previous patch notes had specifically said it had already been fixed. (It just hadn't actually been fixed.)

One particular case was the unlocked outdoor chests in Outlands dropping level 22 mana potions and food. After the next patch in which the developers had claimed to fix it so that the chests in outlands wouldn't do that anymore, I got more level 22 food and potions. When I petitioned a GM they claimed it was "working as intended" and stopped replying after I pointed out that the notes for the previous patch claimed to have fixed this problem, so it was NOT working as intended.

"Working as intended" is just the new "Reset your UI" for GM's.

Комментарий от Rhili

The recipe is NOT available from this quest. I ticketed this thinking I had a bug which made me not receive the recipe. The GM said that this quest is working as intended, and that I had not been deprived of the appropriate quest rewards. GMs can't give you game advice or spoilers so that is all he would say, but I assume the recipe must be available elsewhere.

Комментарий от Vlad

I talked about the "missing" recipie (why the quest didn't reward it, if its a bug or just not given by that quest) with a game master:

: Greetings Zuo, I am Game Master Nydanlar. Might I have a moment of your time to discuss your ticket? : Yes please. : The quest only gives food not the recipe at the moment. : Our developers are still reviewing the recipe and how it shall be obtained. : I see. I got a bit confused since most of the other quests involving fetching meat also rewarded recipie and a batch of the ready food from the npc. I wondered since I also didnt see it on the daily cooking in dalaran as a reward, hehe. : thanks for clearing it up, I shall expect it added in future patch and save my meat meanwhile, I just hope it doesnt go bad until then... : So do I >.<. Is there anything else I can offer assistance with while I am here? : Nope actually, that would be all for today -hehe :P : Then I bid you farewell, Zuo, and should you need our help again we are always just a ticket away. Goodbye! :) : byebye! less than three

So we can hope for it to be added in a future patch! :)

Комментарий от Mordal

15 recipes is only the first of three achievements. After that one follows "30 of the recipes listed below" and then "45 of the recipes slisted below". The last being one of the requirements for Hail to the Chef achievement.

Комментарий от Grimleiv

You can get this recipe at Dalaran. You have to do cooking quest, gain Dalaran Cooking Award, then buy the recipe with that.

Комментарий от FieldLoner

Recipe: Shoveltusk Soup can not be bought with Dalaran Cooking Award tokens on the ally side.

Комментарий от rurr

You can vendor the meat for 25 silver a pop in the meantime.

Комментарий от Nicomy

There are only 46 recipes available for The Northrend Gourmet, so you certainly need at least 3 of the 4 missing recipes.

Комментарий от Nasus

I've been playing this game for two years, there are so many bugs in the game that they never do fix. I get tired of reporting stuff and they only give me the same crap responce " We are aware of the problem and are looking to correct it"

WELL FIX THE STUPID THING THEN!

Комментарий от Toggol

The Shoveltusk Meat is useless after you finish the quest and can be deleted.

According to the 3.0.8 patch notes:

Shoveltusk Meat obtained during the quest, "Shoveltusk Soup Again?" is now correctly flagged as a quest item with no sell price.

Комментарий от DoctorHat

"The final tier of The Northrend Gourmet achievement is lowered to 44 from 45."

Yet you claim they remove two recipes...?

Комментарий от Arzion

well if they remove 2 recipes, they have to get 2 more in the game or change the Chef de Cuisine achievement....

Комментарий от Senra

... and with Worg Tartare, it makes 45. See MMO Champion for more details.

Комментарий от Necrolite

Confirmed, this has indeed been removed from both the game and the achievement req.

Комментарий от Uhrmacher

Shoveltusk Soup has appeared in the list of recipes given by The Northrend Gourmet achievement in 3.1.

Is it obtainable again, or is this just there to /lol at us?

I count 46 recipes in the achievement list, counting the Shoveltusk Soup recipe, so it doesn't look like it's required.

Комментарий от Maliah

yeah i just found that I hadn't cooked it yet either. do I have to cook it for chef? I only need to do 4 more recipes total but I don't want them to keep adding more :/

Комментарий от Hyos

The Shoveltusk Soup recipe is no longer obtainable. You have to cook all other 45 foods to get the achievement.

Комментарий от SIMSteven

Since this recipe is BOP it is VERY possible it's a random world drop much like the other white cooking recipes (Haunted Herring, Last Week's Mammoth, etc).

Комментарий от reverendvader

And as of Patch 3.1, the Shoveltusk Soup recipe has reappeared in the Northrend Gourmet achievement list.

Fortunately, it's just one of the 46 recipes listed and only 45 of them are required for the achievement.

So, whether or not the recipe itself will actually show up in-game anytime soon is still anybody's guess.

Комментарий от Halryn

I guess I have Kungaloosh :P

Комментарий от Difdi

I definitely agree, GMs often don't know what they're talking about. I tend to take "Working as Intended" as "I don't know but don't want to admit it." More than once, I've put in a bug report, gotten an answer back stating it's not a bug and is working as intended...and the very next patch fixes the exact bug that was "working as intended" a few days prior to the patch!

Комментарий от Methlie

So u mean it is not possible to make it?I am horde and the quest "Shoveltusk Soup Again?" it's only for Ally's says wowhead

Комментарий от Teufelgott

I think it's far more likely that it was re-added to the achievement in error, especially since the recipe is still removed

Комментарий от Felet

The recipe is gone from the game, so unless you already have it, you can never cook this dish.

Комментарий от foxbuster

reverendvader

And as of Patch 3.1, the Shoveltusk Soup recipe has reappeared in the Northrend Gourmet achievement list.

And as of patch 3.3.3, there's no mentioning to it anymore.

Datamining the recipe, we can at least see it's OK, not like Succulent Orca Stew, which shows the Big Bear Steak recipe...