Functional Communication for Soft or Inaudible Voices: A New Paradigm

Transcription

1 The following technical paper has been accepted for presentation at the 2005 annual conference of the Rehabilitation Engineering and Assistive Technology Society of North America. RESNA is an interdisciplinary association of people with a common interest in technology and disability. The organization s purpose is to improve the potential of people with disabilities to achieve their goals through the use of technology. RESNA promotes research, development, education, advocacy and provision of technology; and supports people engaged in these activities. Functional Communication for Soft or Inaudible Voices: A New Paradigm James Rothwell, DMA *, Dennis Fuller, PhD ** * Voicewave Technology Inc., Bridgeton, MO ** Saint Louis University, Saint Louis, MO ABSTRACT This paper introduces a proprietary electronic technology for improving the communication of soft or inaudible voices, contrasts it with prior technologies, and demonstrates its real-world functionality in extracting a fully intelligible whisper from an 85dB SPL noise-environment. KEYWORDS Soft voice; inaudible voice; speech; microphone; amplifier; aphonia; speech recognition; augmentative communication; BACKGROUND For more than fifty years electronic amplification has been tried as a means to boost soft or inaudible voices (SIV). Its unsatisfactory performance is due to the inability of microphones to pick up these voices and reject unwanted background noise: the softer the voice, the greater the difficulty. Noise is always in our lives; so much so, we re usually unaware of it-- until it affects communication. Hearing our voice (auditory feedback) is a crucial component of the verbal output product: talkers monitor their output and adjust it accordingly. These adjustments may be subtle changes in pulmonary support, laryngeal tension, articulatory rate, etc., that the listener perceives as changes in voice projection, intelligibility of the message, or general vocal quality. The act of speaking is both a verbal and an auditory task in which persons with SIV find themselves at a disadvantage. Improved auditory monitoring could contribute to better production, but microphones aren t effective with SIV. Further, few microphone manufacturers provide specifications from which the outcome can be predicted. There are many causes of SIV, including developmental disability, vocal abuse, and traumas such as highlevel Spinal Cord Injury (SCI). SCI, for example, may impair the vocal mechanism or respiratory system, leaving a person unable to communicate in a work place or social setting, or direct his or her own medical care. Ordinary activities, like talking on the telephone, can become daunting challenges. If a person s SIV cannot somehow be separated from background noise, other empowering technologies such as computer speech recognition or voice-driven environmental controls are inaccessible to them. Inaudible usually means sound imperceptible by the ear. Noise isn t part of the definition, nor is the listener s hearing; yet, both influence the outcome. For this paper, soft or inaudible voice means a voice at less than normal output level -- without regard for its specific sound pressure level (SPL) -- that cannot be understood due to its softness, the listener s hearing ability, or because it is obscured by noise. All 1.

2 three factors must be considered; a truly functional communication paradigm must include as a minimum, a talker, a listener, and the transmission medium or acoustic environment in which the communication occurs. DEVELOPMENT Improving the outcome for SIVs begins with prior technologies and their inadequacies. The basic principles of microphone design have been known for more than fifty years.(1) Unfortunately, little difference exists between the soft-voice and noise-rejection capabilities of today s microphones and those of a half-century ago. Microphones employ one of two operating principles: directional discrimination or distance discrimination. Microphones with directional discrimination are most common, the prevalent types being omni-directional and cardioid (heart-shaped). Microphones with distance discrimination are called noise-canceling microphones and marketed at a premium. Omni-directional microphones offer no noise rejection, picking up sound equally from all directions. Though ineffective in noise, they re inexpensive and frequently used in low-cost systems. Cardioid microphones offer a slight improvement, favoring sounds arriving at the front over sounds from the sides and rear. This matters little unless the environment is non-reverberant. Reverberant (acoustically reflective) environments distribute noise rather equally around a microphone, making directionality unimportant. Cardioids provide typically 6dB of noise rejection, often less. Noise-canceling (NC) microphones discriminate against sounds on the basis of distance, rejecting sound originating at a distance (far field) while accepting sound originating near the microphone (near field). Their principal drawback is that rejection is undesirably frequency dependent: they reject best at low frequencies (100Hz) unimportant to intelligibility, but reject least in the critical region of 800Hz to 4KHz that is vital to intelligibility. Consequently, their success depends on the type and severity of noise in which they are used. Specifications, while seldom given, reveal worst-case noise rejection is typically 4dB to 6dB in the critical region, increasing by 6dB per octave as frequency decreases -- a most severe limitation if there is competing noise in the critical region. 2.

3 To have functional, real-world communication, as used here, requires that a person able to converse in any situation encountered in daily life. Although quiet residential levels may range from 50dB to 60dB SPL, an active household can top 80dB SPL. Workplaces and offices seldom have noise levels under 65dB to 75dB SPL, and industrial, school, and workshop environments can exceed 95dB SPL. Most surprisingly for those who would direct their own medical care, one hospital noise study documented jackhammer-like noise levels of 113dB SPL inside patient rooms during the morning shift change.(2) To understand the requirements for accommodating SIVs we examine the speech signals themselves. In normal adult speech, low frequency components have the highest amplitude, being the chief contributors to the average speaking level of 55dB to 65dB SPL. These components, though, contribute little to intelligibility. Conversely, the speech components in the critical 800Hz to 4KHz region are lowest in amplitude -- typically 20dB to 30dB less than low frequency components but are essential to intelligibility. Since a normal voice emits these critical components at 25dB to 35dB SPL, they are obviously far lower in SIVs, making them easily obscured as noise rises or voice declines. The talker s diminished auditory feedback usually causes them to overdrive pulmonary, articulation and voicing characteristics to the point of hyper-function. Hyper-functional characteristics result in distorted verbal output, requiring significant energy consumption -- often to the point of premature speaker fatigue. This in turn leads to diminished intelligibility and/or loss of voicing capability. Auditory feedback is vital. Traditional microphones are designed for positive signal-to-noise environments: more voice than noise is required for satisfactory performance. Real-world conditions, though, dictate that often more noise is present than voice. Functional SIV communication, then, requires accommodating voices far weaker than noise -- by perhaps as much as 70dB to 80dB -- while rejecting noise across the entire audio spectrum. 3.

4 The Voicewave Technology Inc. (Voicewave) proprietary speech technology was designed to these requirements. It s a three-fold approach, comprising uniquely effective microphone architecture, an electronic signal processor, and an auditory feedback mechanism to the talker. Together, they provide over 99% broadband rejection of noise, aid speech production through improved self-monitoring, and have the sensitivity to pick up signals at or below the threshold of hearing. This dramatic increase in performance enables persons with SIVs to communicate virtually without regard for their noise environment, using motor articulation and pulmonary support levels that produce the most efficient performance levels. The resulting verbal output can extend communication time, while improving the verbal output quality and reducing talker fatigue. Further, the technology opens up other opportunities to enhance communication, such as speech clarification and speech recognition --subjects for future papers. Figure 3 illustrates the superior performance of Voicewave technology over a standard cardioid microphone in picking up a whisper in a reverberant environment of 85dB SPL noise. While noise totally obscures the whisper with the cardioid, Voicewave s technology extracts a fully intelligible whisper. The benefits of this technology are significant for SIV. The nearly total rejection of background noise enables boosting SIVs to a far greater extent than allowed by other technologies. A side benefit is reduction of stress, since less effort is expended to produce speech, and improved self-monitoring -- essential for coordinating speech processes. The Voicewave processor incorporates spectrally enhanced auditory feedback that improves hearability in noise, increasing the auditory feedback s effectiveness by 10dB to 15dB without increasing its volume level. 4.

Lecture 1-8: Audio Recording Systems Overview 1. Why do we need to record speech? We need audio recordings of speech for a number of reasons: for off-line analysis, so that we can listen to and transcribe

Conference Phone Buyer s Guide Conference Phones are essential in most organizations. Almost every business, large or small, uses their conference phone regularly. Such regular use means choosing one is

Introduction When purchasing powered loudspeakers, most customers compare three key specifications: price, power and maximum SPL. Unfortunately, this can be like comparing apples and oranges. For the Maximum

Selecting the Right Conference Phone for Different Room Environments 1 Introduction When was the last time you used a conference phone? Today? Yesterday? It probably hasn t been more than a day or two.

Application Note AN-1112 MICROPHONE SPECIFICATIONS EXPLAINED INTRODUCTION A MEMS microphone IC is unique among InvenSense, Inc., products in that its input is an acoustic pressure wave. For this reason,

Audiology as a School Based Service 2008 Medicaid in the Schools (MITS) Summit January 24, 2008 Donna Fisher Smiley, Ph.D., CCC-A Audiologist Arkansas Children s Hospital and Conway Public Schools Purpose

Psychological and Social Aspects of Hearing Loss 404.591.1884 www.childrensent.com Adjusting to your Child s Diagnosis of Hearing Loss When you learn your child has a hearing loss you may feel grief, shock,

Module 9 AUDIO CODING Lesson 28 Basic of Audio Coding Instructional Objectives At the end of this lesson, the students should be able to : 1. Name at least three different audio signal classes. 2. Calculate

SYSTEM DESIGN AND THE IMPORTANCE OF ACOUSTICS n Will your communication or emergency notification system broadcast intelligible speech messages in addition to alarm tones? n Will your system include multiple

SO YOUR PARENT NEEDS HEARING AIDS (The Adult Child s Guide to Hearing Loss and Hearing Aids) By Patty Earl, Ph.D., CCC-A Welcome to world of hearing loss and hearing aids. Your mother or father may have

A Microphone Array for Hearing Aids by Bernard Widrow 1531-636X/06/$10.00 2001IEEE 0.00 26 Abstract A directional acoustic receiving system is constructed in the form of a necklace including an array of

hearing products and acoustic regulations in school 1+1 could equal 3, if a classroom is acoustically regulated when using hearing systems By Anna K Lejon, November 2014 Anna Karlsson Lejon has a master's

2011-06-13 Acoustic design with wall acoustic solutions Introduction A suspended ceiling is by far the most common acoustical treatment in a room. In most cases this is also a sufficient solution to create

Welcome to the United States Patent and TradeMark Office an Agency of the United States Department of Commerce United States Patent 5,159,703 Lowery October 27, 1992 Silent subliminal presentation system

Workshop Perceptual Effects of Filtering and Masking Introduction to Filtering and Masking The perception and correct identification of speech sounds as phonemes depends on the listener extracting various

How can Lightspeed s sound panel solutions possibly break down acoustic barriers in the classroom? There is no audio solution that throws sound. There is no solution that overcomes the laws of physics.

Audio processing and ALC in the FT-897D I recently bought an FT-897D, and after a period of operation noticed problems with what I perceived to be a low average level of output power and reports of muffled

Microphone Basics 1 Table of Contents Introduction 3 So Many Options, So Little Time 4 How Does a Mic Fit into an Audio System? 10 Considerations for Choosing a Mic 12 Words of Wisdom 14 Wrap-up 15 2 Introduction

On the Job Off the Job Hearing Health Facts for Sound Professionals & Musicians Your Ears - Your Most Valuable Sound Equipment Your auditory system is one of the most complex systems in your body. Working

A Hearing Aid Primer Includes: Definitions Photographs Hearing Aid Styles, Types, and Arrangements WROCC Outreach Site at Western Oregon University This hearing aid primer is designed to define the differences

Microphones Microphone types There are a number of different design principles on which a particular microphone may be based, each with its own range of application. Condenser Sensitive, capable of capturing

Tom Scheller and Kelly Fitz Introduction Starkey Hearing Technologies Synergy platform introduces a suite of features designed to enhance the enjoyment of music for patients. Maybe the most significant

The loudness war is fought with (and over) compression Susan E. Rogers, PhD Berklee College of Music Dept. of Music Production & Engineering 131st AES Convention New York, 2011 A summary of the loudness

USING ASSISTIVE LISTENING DEVICES Getting Connected 1 Bringing Sound Even Closer to You Cochlear implant (CI) technology has opened up a whole new world of sound and improved quality of life for many people.

OFFER YOUR PATIENTS THE CUSTOMIZED SETTINGS THEY RE LOOKING FOR IN THEIR NEW HEARING AIDS Calibra PRO A complete line of premier digital instruments offered with professional, user-friendly features for

WHITE PAPER MEETING THE DEMAND FOR CEILING MICS IN THE ENTERPRISE 5 BEST PRACTICES This white paper will help you overcome potential issues with ceiling mics and give you tips for delivering high-performance

Dolby Volume: An Innovative Solution to Inconsistent Volume Issues As home entertainment options have increased more channels, more media, more content so have inconsistencies in perceived volume levels.

A new era in classroom amplification Life is on We are sensitive to the needs of everyone who depends on our knowledge, ideas and care. And by creatively challenging the limits of technology, we develop

The Conference is Calling A guide to getting the most out of your conference calls The Conference is Calling Why use a conference phone? Most phones today have a speakerphone button but there are in fact

WHITE PAPER Navigating a New Generation of Conference Phone Solutions A guide to selecting the right conferencing solution for different room environments Jeffrey Rodman CTO/Co-Founder Polycom Table of

Improving the Acoustics in a Historic Building Using Axiomatic Design and TRIZ Andrew Kankey atk127@psu.edu Department of Acoustics Pennsylvania State University University Park, PA 16801 Abstract Madara

COMPARISON OF LARGE AREA ASSISTIVE LISTENING SYSTEMS Why Use an Assistive Listening System? Distance from the sound source, background noise, and reverberation combine to degrade signal intelligibility,

Hearing and listening in a typical classroom By Catherine V. Palmer, PhD, University of Pittsburgh From Language, Speech & Hearing Services in Schools, July 1997 ABSTRACT: In the past, many educational

The Effects of Ultrasonic Sound Generated by Ultrasonic Cleaning Systems on Human Hearing and Physiology Questions about the effects of ultrasonic energy on hearing and other human physiology arise from

Early vs. Late Onset Hearing Loss: How Children Differ from Adults Andrea Pittman, PhD Arizona State University Heterogeneity of Children with Hearing Loss Chronological age Age at onset Age at identification

Cheat Sheet for Local Church Audio Training Sound Essentials Thank you for attending this session and supporting your church s ministry. I believe that, as a sound technician, you are a vital part of the

1 SPEECH AUDIOMETRY Pure tone Audiometry provides only a partial picture of the patient s auditory sensitivity. Because it doesn t give any information about it s ability to hear and understand speech.