Episcopal School of Dallas Fights Former Student in Court Over Religious Freedom Case

Real. Passionate. Trial Lawyers.

Episcopal School of Dallas Fights Former Student in Court Over Religious Freedom Case

A student at the Episcopal School of Dallas (ESD), John Doe Jr., sued the school over their decision to expel him after leaving school property at lunch time without first receiving permission.

Someone living nearby the school alerted ESD that they saw Doe Jr. parked on the street smoking marijuana, something Doe Jr. denies doing. He also did not allow for a search of his vehicle, but was caught on school security cameras leaving campus.

While the drug claims cannot be proven, he did break school rules by leaving campus, and was given the choice to either withdraw from the school or to be expelled. Doe Jr. and his father sued the school, based at least partially on the fact that tuition-paying parents were informed that students should be given a chance to redeem themselves after breaking rules rather than being kicked out after a single infraction. Doe Jr. had a clean school record when he was offered the choice to leave willingly or be forced out.

While the case was working its way through state district courts, ESD filed an appeal to the 5th Court stating that the case should be thrown out based on religious grounds.

Doe Jr., kept anonymous in court records because he’s a minor, and his father are now fighting the ESD in court over whether or not the school is a religious institution, therefore protected by the ecclesiastical abstention doctrine. This doctrine essentially states that the First Amendment’s guarantee that Americans are free to practice their religious without interference from the courts.

In this case, ESD is arguing that, as a religious organization, the Does cannot fight the expulsion in court. The school contends that, while it is not owned or financially supported by the Episcopal Diocese in Dallas, neither its board members nor staff are required to be Episcopalian, its students are not trained for seminaries, and only 15 percent of its student body is Episcopalian, it still requires students to attend chapel every day, the school was founded by an Episcopalian minister, and has clearly Christian guiding principles.

The Does state in their appeal that ESD’s religious qualifications are questions of fact, and the law states that these questions need to be decided by juries and trial courts, not by appellate judges. Aldous \ Walker LLP filed a brief supporting John Doe Jr., stating that,

"Application of the Ecclesiastic Abstention Doctrine would have had a devastating impact on Ms. Doe and, if applied in pending and future lawsuits, will certainly encourage private schools to ignore the needs of students who are victims of sexual assault or other abusive emotional and physical conduct.”

Aldous \ Walker LLP represented a different ESD student back in 2011. This student, a minor, was groomed for and led into a sexual relationship with one of her male teachers. He was fired from the school, and the school gave her the same “withdraw or be expelled” choice John Doe received in this case. She sued ESD, and a jury ruled in her favor, awarding her more than $6 million. The case was later settled between Jane Doe and ESD for an undisclosed sum in order to avoid an appeal.

Brent Walker, who was one of the attorneys representing Jane Doe in 2011, stated that the court’s decision on doe Jr.’s case is not in line with prior rulings handed down by the Supreme Court.

"ESD had tried to raise the ecclesiastical abstention doctrine in our case ... and it didn't go anywhere for them," said Walker. "It is simply not a school that is a church school. It's a secular school."

Walker went on to say that broadening the doctrine like this to cover ESD’s disciplinary policy will also have a negative impact on religious freedom. He said that it could lead to other organizations claiming religious affiliation in order to receive the same protections ESD received. In an interview with the Dallas Observer, he asked the reporter, Patrick Williams, a rhetorical question:

“If his firm changed its name to the Episcopal Law Firm of Dallas, could it avoid any responsibility for mistakes?” wrote Williams. “"Sorry, I forget to file your lawsuit," he says, but there's nothing you can do. Too bad.”

Learn About
Our Philosophy

See How
We Can Help

Hear It From
Our Clients

Attorneys Charla Aldous and Brent Walker are members of the Dallas Trial
Lawyers Association, an organization committed to empowering and supporting
trial lawyers in the city.

Best Lawyers in America

Attorney Charla Aldous has been selected to the list of the Best Lawyers
in America every year since 2013, and attorney Brent Walker has been selected
to the list every year since 2018.

Best Lawyers - Lawyer of the Year

Attorney Charla Aldous has been named the Lawyer of the Year by the Best
Lawyers in America seven times, in 2009, twice in 2013, 2016, 2017, 2018, and 2019.

Best Law Firms

Aldous \ Walker LLP has been consistently selected to the list of Best
Law Firms by U.S. News and Best Lawyers® as a Tier 1 law firm, the highest
possible ranking that recognizes the firm’s years of groundbreaking success.

National Top Lawyers Top 100

Attorneys Charla Aldous and Brent Walker have been included in this invitation
only group of the premier trial lawyers in each state.

American Board of Trial Advocates

Attorney Charla Aldous is a member of the American Board of Trial Advocates,
a nationwide organization of lawyers who care passionately about the trial
system in the United States.

Inner Circle of Advocates

Attorney Charla Aldous is a member of the Inner Circle of Advocates, a
prestigious organization whose members consist of the 100 best plaintiff
trial lawyers in the United States.

International Academy of Trial Lawyers

Attorney Charla Aldous is a member of the International Academy of Trial
Lawyers, an invitation-only organization comprised of the most accomplished
trial lawyers from across the globe.

International Society of Barristers

Attorney Charla Aldous is a member of the International Society of Barristers,
an organization committed to bringing together the best members of the
legal community from across the globe.

Texas Trial Lawyers Association

Attorneys Charla Aldous and Brent Walker are members of the Texas Trial
Lawyers Association, an organization that works to give trial lawyers
the tools they need to best represent their clients.

American Association for Justice

Attorneys Charla Aldous and Brent Walker are members of the American Association
of Justice, a nonprofit advocacy organization with the stated mission
to "promote a fair and effective justice system."

National Trial Lawyers Top 40 under 40

Attorney Brent Walker is a member of the National Trial Lawyers: Top 40
under 40, an invitation-only organization comprised of the top young trial
lawyers in every state.

Public Citizen

Aldous \ Walker LLP is a benefactor of Public Justice, a nonprofit consumer
advocacy organization committed to defending democracy, resisting corporate
power, and working to make sure that the governments works for the people,
not corporations.

Super Lawyers

Attorney Charla Aldous has been selected to the list of Super Lawyers every
year since 2003, and attorney Brent Walker has been selected to the list
every year since 2013.

D Magazine Best Lawyers Under 40

Attorney Brent Walker was selected to the list of the best lawyers under
40 years old in Dallas by D Magazine.

The information on this website is for general information purposes only.
Nothing on this site should be taken as legal advice for any individual
case or situation. This information is not intended to create, and receipt
or viewing does not constitute, an attorney-client relationship.