Trouble logging in?If you can't remember your password or are having trouble logging in, you will have to reset your password. If you have trouble resetting your password (for example, if you lost access to the original email address), please do not start posting with a new account, as this is against the forum rules. If you create a temporary account, please contact us right away via Forum Support, and send us any information you can about your original account, such as the account name and any email address that may have been associated with it.

OP still going strong as ever...though last arc was a bit meh worthy at times...

Dunno I myself dropped OP at the "Big wall prison, save the black haired girl arc", frankly I may pick it up in the future, maybe even read it from the start. But as it is now I don't find any initiative to do so. Same for fairy tail, even though those stories are great with a well thought plot, the art just kicks me back each and every time.

Dunno I myself dropped OP at the "Big wall prison, save the black haired girl arc", frankly I may pick it up in the future, maybe even read it from the start. But as it is now I don't find any initiative to do so. Same for fairy tail, even though those stories are great with a well thought plot, the art just kicks me back each and every time.

The what, the arc and the one after the arc proceeding it are some of the best ones and I'll tell you this now fairy tails plot is mediocre.

I still don't quite get why this manga ranks so well, it's a romance slice of life that rarely does well in jump, which is typically dominated by gag and mostly action manga, and the plot like general with these sorts of manga isn't that great. What am I missing.

I think this manga somehow captured the romance niche and also niche that some slice of life mangas of the Jump. Sket Dance used to rank much higher until Nisekoi came on. Maybe it even got some votes of Bakuman niche.

I think this manga somehow captured the romance niche and also niche that some slice of life mangas of the Jump. Sket Dance used to rank much higher until Nisekoi came on. Maybe it even got some votes of Bakuman niche.

Bakuman was boring. At first I was interested in the mangaka world but around the time when they were getting to pcp anime I dropped it. Seriously the drawing main character and his gf were to dumb for me, they behaved like some kind of saint freaks, who couldn't even speak properly over the phone. I don't think I will even finish Bakuman, it probably ended in some stupid way, not to mention the retarded rivalries against other mangakas, where plot just went wtf.

As for Nisekoi, its cliche but it hits the right spots. It gives me the feeling of old romance mangas. So its the old good titles feeling with new age art. Just the right thing.
It isn't some kind of super high plot, but its a good romance with likeable main cast. Which I cannot say about most of the other popular romances lately (GE/KNIM for example)

I didn't think that a romance manga would be doing good in WSJ and though this is the first time, I am checking the rankings, while reading the recent chapters, I had a feeling that the romance or the plot, is going too fast. Feels like, this was not made with the intention to last long, in my opinion.

I didn't think that a romance manga would be doing good in WSJ and though this is the first time, I am checking the rankings, while reading the recent chapters, I had a feeling that the romance or the plot, is going too fast. Feels like, this was not made with the intention to last long, in my opinion.

I rather take 50 chapters short romance story (it can easily get to 50 chapters) than something drawn out like Pastel, knim and so on.