it's going to be a backdoor pilot about a young Adama during the first Cylon War. looks like we're in for some more cool space battles, and it'll be interesting to see if they keep Caprica around to pair it with.

Logged

Because I can,also because I don't care what you want.XBL: OriginalCeeKayWii U: CeeKay

that's not really something i would brag about considering that it's turned out to be a pretty interesting show...not quite up to the level of BSG, but i'm enjoying it.

personally I'm glad they canceled Atlantis and freed up money for Caprica; we ended up with a better quality show. they kept showing sneak peeks of a lot more centurions running around, can't wait to see that in the show even though I'm guessing it'll be the season finale where it happens.

Logged

Because I can,also because I don't care what you want.XBL: OriginalCeeKayWii U: CeeKay

Now we're getting into "bad prequel" territory. It would be like the Star Wars prequels; where's the tension, since you know how things turn out? "Great battle, guys, but the Cylons are still gonna blow your worlds to shit". We know who lives and who dies, who's a Cylon, and all of that. I'd rather they just kept on doing Caprica, which is at least back far enough in the timeline and a different genre.

Logged

Patriotism means being loyal to your country all the time and to its government when it deserves it - Mark Twain

Now we're getting into "bad prequel" territory. It would be like the Star Wars prequels; where's the tension, since you know how things turn out? "Great battle, guys, but the Cylons are still gonna blow your worlds to shit". We know who lives and who dies, who's a Cylon, and all of that. I'd rather they just kept on doing Caprica, which is at least back far enough in the timeline and a different genre.

Have you watched any of The Clone Wars? There's tension aplenty, and we definitely know how things turned out.

Yeah, but this is even more extreme of a situation for me. I haven't seen the Clone Wars, but it is feasible that some of the characters on there can survive the events of the OT and beyond, but 99.99% of humanity is annihilated by the cylons, so unless they happened to be on Galactica/Pegasus/the civilian fleet, they're gone. Any other characters who evade danger in B&C are only postponing their inevitable doom and what they're fighting for is fruitless.

Logged

Patriotism means being loyal to your country all the time and to its government when it deserves it - Mark Twain

Yeah, but this is even more extreme of a situation for me. I haven't seen the Clone Wars, but it is feasible that some of the characters on there can survive the events of the OT and beyond, but 99.99% of humanity is annihilated by the cylons, so unless they happened to be on Galactica/Pegasus/the civilian fleet, they're gone. Any other characters who evade danger in B&C are only postponing their inevitable doom and what they're fighting for is fruitless.

ETA: I understand what you are saying, just so you don't respond trying to explain your point. Seeing as how my life, at least, is led differently than a sci-fi action series (though perhaps I should try to change that), they really aren't analogous. To me, most of the tension from a series like this comes from:

A) Who will live? Whether it's a big mission, potential sabotage, or some other potentially lethal situation, I need to be invested in a character's survival.

B) Wil the "good guys" win? Regardless of who survives, will the protagonists' struggle find victory?

Both are meaningless as even if the colonials make it out alive, their entire way of life will be obliterated within 50 years. Plus, it's not as if we don't know how the war "ends": big, sexy armistice action.

Fr all of that, I'll give it a shot. I loved the reboot series, so who knows, but it'll be a challenge to get me invested in the new characters.

« Last Edit: March 21, 2012, 10:32:03 PM by Suitably Ironic Moniker »

Logged

Patriotism means being loyal to your country all the time and to its government when it deserves it - Mark Twain

Yeah, but this is even more extreme of a situation for me. I haven't seen the Clone Wars, but it is feasible that some of the characters on there can survive the events of the OT and beyond, but 99.99% of humanity is annihilated by the cylons, so unless they happened to be on Galactica/Pegasus/the civilian fleet, they're gone. Any other characters who evade danger in B&C are only postponing their inevitable doom and what they're fighting for is fruitless.

I'm more interested in the big 'splosions than worrying about who lives or dies. I figure it'll be cool to see the big battles and the old Cylons on the screen, even without the suspense of knowing if they'll live or die.

Logged

Because I can,also because I don't care what you want.XBL: OriginalCeeKayWii U: CeeKay

It's been really good so far. The only criticism I have is that Adama and his co-pilot aren't paticularly deep characters. They're corny stereotypes up to now. Also, dialog is often over the top cheesy, with an over abundance of "frak" this and "frak" that. However, the battle sequences are really well done and the overall look is great. The old school Vipers vs. the original Cylon raiders is really cool to see for those of us who grew up watching the original series.

Caprica was actually a good show with some really strong acting. I honestly think if it hadn't been burdened with Galactica's backstory, and as a prequel it would have done well on its own. Something along the lines of "I, Robot" but in long form tv series.

That said, this is definitely what they should have made.

Also, anyone notice an actor being reused for this series? Kirby is also a pilot from Pegasus named Allison.

Watched the first four episodes via the PS3 YouTube app. Surprised me how good the video quality was. Problem was the YouTube app on the PS3 sucks and locked up 3 separate times causing the system to have to reboot twice. Will have to try it on the 360 next time.

I was pretty damn impressed with what I've seen so far. It moved fast, got you interested quick and felt like Battlestar when it was at its best. The space scenes are pretty fantastic looking. And I loved seeing the Galatica, both inside and out, during its glory days.

Only quip I have so far is the actor playing Adama. He doesn't seem to have much acting chops. I don't see the older Adama in him at all. He's a pretty one dimensional at this point with none of the charisma that Adama should have.

Really hope they change their minds about making this in to a series or some other network picks it up.

The final epsiodes were put up a few weeks ago so sat down and watched the entire thing. Really loved it. The second half of it takes place outside of the cockpit and liked that just as much. Really hope they turn this in to a series as it has potential - and there were several loose ends near the end of it. Even if they had the same actor playing Adama I would still watch it - although hope for someone who can act a bit more like Adama other than in their unconvential ways to win a fight.

So if you're on the fence weather to watch this or not I'd say watch it. It's basically like Battlestar Galatica when it was at its best and tells a complete story.