Questions like this get asked all the time and the answer is that's its different for every person. Is 4g important to you? How about a physical keyboard? You need to decide what's important to you and compare the phones. I had a charge for a day and paid the $35 to return it in favor of the DROID 3. Familiarity with the moto DROID was more important than 4G but some people really want 4G.