The following is a translation of Imam Ahmed al-Hassan’s a.s. words yesterday on Paltalk, and it has been translated from an Arabic document that was gathered by one of the Ansar who were present in the Paltalk room during that time. Since I, your servant, wasn’t there at that time, there are some replies from the Imam a.s. that I do not know the questions for, meaning what were the questions that were asked for him a.s. to give those replies. That is why you may find some answers below without the question related to them. So if any of the pure Ansar who were present in the room, recognizes an answer here that does not have its question next to it, then please comment below clarifying for example: “When the Imam a.s. said such and such he was responding to a person who asked such and such”. And then I will add the question inshaAllah. Thank you very much and may Allah swt bless your efforts pure brothers and sisters and please forgive me for any inconvenience.________________Imam Ahmed al-Hassan (a.s) said:Assalamu alaykum waRahmtullah waBaraktuh (Peace, mercy, and blessings, of Allah be upon you) السلام عليكم ورحمة الله وبركاته

How is everyone, my children, inshaAllah everyone is well and in good health كيف الحال ابنائي إن شاء الله يكون الجميع بخير وعافية

Is the sound cutting off at Aba Muhammad’s or is the problem with my deviceهل الصوت عند ابا احمد يقطع ام من جهازي الخلل

Ansar al-Hujjah, if you understand, then what did you understand from this narrationانصار الحجة اذا كنت تفهم ما فهمت من هذه (الرواية

So the meaning of your words is that everyone who claimed to have seen [the Hujjah a.s] is a slanderous liar...Which means that all of your scholars who have claimed to have seen [the Hujjah a.s] are liars. And this is the best proof for the one who asked before you about what is the proof that the Hawzas are corrupt فمعنى كلامك كل من ادعى المشاهدة فهو كاذب مفتري يعني كل علمائكم الذين ادعوا المشاهدة هم كذابين وهذا خير دليل على السائل الذي قبلك الذي كان يسأل ما دليلكم على ان الحوزات فاسدة

________________Whoever from them knew that Taqlid is false, and still practiced Taqlid, then yes they are to hell fire. And whoever did not know from them, then the scholars whom they were doing Taqlid of are to hell fire, they carry their own sin and the sins of the ones who did Taqlid of them, and to hell fire and the most wretched destinationمن كان يعلم منهم ان التقليد باطل وكان يقلد نعم الى النار ومن كان منهم لا يعلم فالعلماء الذين كانوا يقلدونهم الى النار يحملون وزرهم ووزر من كان يقلدهم والى جهنم وبئس المصير

Whoever says to the people “I am knowledgeable” or “I am the most knowledgeable”, and says to the people “Do Taqlid of me”, or accepts/approves of Taqlid, then he is in hell fireكل من يقول للناس انا عالم او الاعلم و يقول للناس قلدوني او يرضى بتقليد فهو في النار

The curse of Allah is upon all of them without an exception لعنة الله عليهم جميعا دون استثناء

All of them without any flattery or hypocrisy الكل دون اي مداهنة او نفاق

Whoever acknowledges Taqlid is in hell fire كل من يقر بتقليد في النار

All wonder is especially regarding you O Mutashay’a (the ones who claim to be Shia) of Iraq! I ask you by Allah, do you not see their actions and theftالعجب كل العجب عليكم يا متشيعة العراق خصوصآ اسألكم بالله الا ترون افعالهم ولصوصيتهم

________________The Greater Sayha (the Outcry which is mentioned in the narrations of Ahlul Bayt a.s) is soon inshaAllahالصيحة الكبرى قريبا إن شاء الله

If you hear my voice in this time it would be a fitna to the Ansar, but if you hear our voice with our picture then it would not be a fitna to the Ansarصوتي سوف يكون فتنة للأنصار في هذا الوقت لكن اذا سمعت صوتنا مع صورتنا لن يكون فتنة للأنصار

________________Sakr, what is your questionصكر ... ما سؤالك

[A guest by the name Essam Mansour Muhammad asked: “A question to you O Shia, do you admit that Abu Bakr is from the Rashidun (rightly guided) Caliphs?”]

To which Imam Ahmed al-Hassan (a.s) replied: Essam Mansour, yes yes he was an elected caliph, but we do not know that he was from the rightly guided ones, we know that he was from the distorters/corrupters, this is what we know about him, the curse of Allah is upon himضيف أسمه عصام منصور محمد سأل: سوال ياشيعه هل تعترفو بأن أبو بكر من الخلفاء الراشدين. فأجابه الإمام أحمد الحسن ع قائلا: عصام منصور نعم نعم انه كان خليفة منتخب لكن لا نعلم انه كان من الراشدين نعلم انه كان من المحرفين هذا ما نعلمه عنه لعنه الله

________________The solution is the voice with the picture الحل هو الصوت مع الصورة

________________[A guest by the name Bahaa’ al-Ghoraify asked: Master you did not answer, the Sayha is soon, when is soon?!]

________________[The guest Bahaa’ al-Ghoraify said: “You, and I, and the owner of this live stream, do not know when is the Sayha, but the Yamani knows when is the Sayha. I want an answer. Do not say soon soon”.]

[1] Ahlul Bayt a.s. have mentioned several times that they do not determine a time. The following are just two examples of many Hadiths about this: Aba Abdillah al-Sadiq a.s. said: “The ones who determine a time are liars, and the ones who are in a rush are destroyed, and the ones who submit are rescued and to us they turn. We have not determined a time in the past, and we will not determine a time in the future” - Mo’jam Ahadith Imam al-Mahdi (a.s) Volume 3 Page 370

[A guest by the name Karrar al-Sadrawi al-Zerijawy said: “Ahmed alHassan did not answer the question. I am not going to defend the scholars. Who was the Hujjah before the appearance of Ahmed al-Hassan if Taqlid is false and the scholars are false and everyone is in hell fire?!”]

So Imam Ahmed al-Hassan a.s said: Do you want names, O Karrar? If you want names then I will not mention that to you. But if you want the name of the ones who preceded me, then I will give you two names. The first is Eesa Aba Ahmed, and the second is Abbas Aba Muhammad. And I do not believe that you will know any of them. And I do not believe that this will add to you anything nor benefit youضيف إسمه كرار الصدراوي الزريجاوي قال:"لم يجيب احمد الحسن على السؤال انا لست بصدد الدفاع عن العلماء من كان الحجه قبل ظهور احمد الحسن اذا كان التقليد باطل والعلماء باطلين والناس كلها بالنار". فأجابه الإمام أحمد الحسن ع: هل تريد اسماء يا كرار ؟اذا كنت تريد اسماء فلن اذكر لك اسماما اذا تريد اسم الذي قبليسوف اعطيك اسمينالاول عيسى ابا احمدوالثاني عباس ابا محمدولا اعتقد انك سوف تعرف احد منهمولا اعتقد ان هذا سوف يضيف لك شيء او ينفعك

[The guest Karrar al-Sadrawi al-Zerijawy said: The Answer is not enough. I want an answer with a text from Ahlul Bayt a.sSo they are not Hujjahs on the people and the Taqlid is absolving.]

________________[A guest by the name Sakr al-Shimri said: SubhanAllah, an Imam who withholds an answer, is he failing to answer or there is no answer to the question? Those names that you mentioned are Hujjahs upon who then if we do not know them according to your words?]

________________[The guest Sakr al-Shimri said: Brother, is it logical that Allah sends Hujjahs and the people do not know them? Is this the justice of Allah? And now you come and say even if you knew them you would not have believed in them. Isn’t it more of a priority that I know them first?]

So Imam Ahmed al-Hassan a.s. said: And who told you that the people do not know them. Indeed the ones who had light in their hearts knew them. Here I am, I am present in your time, and I have come by that which no one before me has come with, and here you are not believing. It is the same case. What is the difference? Why are you surprised by this condition? Has someone before me come to you by what I have claimed? الضيف صكر الشمري قال: اخي هل من المعقول الله يبحث حجج ولم يعرف الناس بهم هل هذا عدل الله وتاتي وتقول الان حتي لو عرفتهم لم تامن بهم اليس بالاول انا اعرفهم. فأجابه الإمام أحمد الحسن ع: ومن قال لك ان الناس لا تعلم بهم فد عرفهم من كان في قلبه النورها انا موجود في زمانك وجأت لكم بمن لم يأتي به احد من قبلي وها انت لا تؤمنالحال نفسهما الفرق ؟لما تتعجب على هذا الحالهل جائكم احد من قبلي بما ادعيت

Just answer me and I will give you what will calm you downفقط اجبني وانا اريحك

Are you from the Ansar of the people of the office as you call themهل انت من انصار جماعة المكتب كما تسموهم

Take the mic and speakخذ المايك وتحدث

If you do not do as I ask you then this will be the last sentence directed to you اذا لم تفعل ما اطلبه منك سوف تكون هذه اخر جملة توجه اليك

Give him the micاعطيه المايك

If you want voice then go to that other roomاذا كنت تريد الصوت فذهب عند تلك الغرفة

Here there is no voiceهنا لا يوجد صوت

We do not need an Arabic teacherلا نحتاج مدرس لغة عربية

Thank youشكرا لك

Yes my son, it does not matter, how many are theyنعم بني لا يهم ما اكثرهم

Those are pitiful/poor ones هؤلاء مساكين

This one is from the Ansar of the Calfهذا من انصار العجل

________________[A guest said why hasn’t the book the Calf been corrected?]

So Imam Ahmed al-Hassan (a.s) replied: Who told you that there is a correction for the book the Calfضيف قال لماذا لم يتم تصحيح كتاب العجل؟ فأجابه الإمام أحمد الحسن ع: من قال لك ان هناك تصحيح لكتاب العجل________________[A guest by the name Abbas alHijji said: Is Ahmed ibn alHassan from the offspring of the Prophet Muhammad (sawas)]

[The same guest said: So we say to the people that the Imam will appear after a hundred years?]

So Imam Ahmed al-Hassan a.s. said: That is what you want, you do not want him to emergeAnd I have wasted a lot of time with you. Speaking with you has ended.نفس الضيف قال: يعني نقول للناس سيظهر الامام بعد مائة سنة؟ فقال الإمام أحمد الحسن ع: انت تريد ذالك تريده ان لا يخرجوانا اضعت الكثير من الوقت معكانتهى الكلام معك

________________[A guest by the name Abu Mustafa alKhaz’ali said: May Allah grant you success, what is the obligation of the person who awaits the Hujjah Imam may my soul be sacrificed for him, so that the person who is waiting may beautify his eye by looking at him a.s. and become from his Ansar (supporters) and helpers and servants and martyrs between his hand.]

________________Ossama, when the body dies, it does not return. The soul is what returnsاسامة الجسد حين يموت لا يرجع الروح التي ترجع

________________A guest by the name kmalshreef said: I have a question that is confusing me...why are most of the religious people unproductive and not inventors and they are just sitting, while the disbelievers and the atheists are the ones who invent. Does technology conflict with religion?

________________[A guest by the name jasim443 said: Brother, I directed two questions to the Imam: The first is: Can the Imam inform us of the places of distortion/corruption in the holy Qur’an? And the second question is what is the core of the Dawa of Imam [Ahmed] al-Hassan?]

[So the same guest said: This is exactly my question, what is the true religion?]

Imam Ahmed al-Hassan a.s. replied: This religion which you know now is not the religion of Muhammad sawas, it has become as far from the true religion as the sun is from the earth. It is corrupted/distorted by 99 percentفقال نفس الضيف: هذا سؤالي تماما ما هو الدين الحقيقي. أجاب الإمام أحمد الحسن ع: هذا الدين الذي تعرفونه الان هو ليس دين محمد صقد ابتعد بعد الشمس عن الارض%فهو محرف بنسبة 99

________________[The guest Abu Mustafa al-Khaza’li asked: What is the meaning of the star in the Israeli flag? And what does the year 2022 mean to Ahmed al-Hassan? May Allah grant you success to what He loves and what pleases Him].

________________[Imam Ahmed al-Hassan a.s. said to the guest who asked about the distortions in Qur’an:] I believe that the answer to that question about Qur’an will not benefit you. By Allah the answer will surely not benefit you and you will be confused about matters. هذا السؤال الذي يخص القران الجواب عنه لا اعتقد انه سوف ينفعكوالله ان الجواب سوف لن ينفعكوسوف يختلط عليك الأمر

[So the guest replied: Do not fear for me my brother, I want to understand the true religion and it is the core of the Dawa whether the people like it or not].

So Imam Ahmed al-Hassan a.s. said: Brother, did you read the Qur’an as a book? Meaning have you read it as a book while lifting the holy halo off of it, and read it as a researcher? Do that if you haven’t, do it then return to me after you read it more than once. At this time you will find at least more than one place of distortion/corruption in itفرد الضيف: لا تخف علي اخي انا اريد ان افهم الدين الحق وهو جوهر الدعوه سواء اعجب الناس ام لا. فقال الإمام أحمد الحسن ع: هل قرأت القران اخي ككتاب ؟ بمعنى انك ترفع عنه الهالة القدسية وتقرأه كباحثافعل ذالك اذا لم تفعل ففعل ثم ارجع لي بعد ان تقرأه اكثر من مرةحينها سوف تجد على الاقل اكثر من موضع فيه تحريف

[So the guest replied: If the normal researcher can find the places of distortions/corruptions, then what is the reason for the presence of the Hujjah Imam?]

________________[The guest who was asking about the Qur’an said: If the nation, after a thousand years of misguidance, does not find an answer from the Hujjah Imam, then when will that be?! And has Allah appointed him for anything other than for this matter which is to guide to the true religion?]