SuperCoach Scores is a community chat forum, where members can discuss strategies on SuperCoach to assist each other improve their overall SuperCoach ranking and/or league results. SuperCoach Scores is provided by Impromptu, who was the 2011 SuperCoach Winner and who has been involved with chat forums since the inception of SuperCoach.

Impromptu's Highlights

Our members include 4 previous SuperCoach Winners

SuperCoach - Winner (2011)

2013 SuperCoach Winner - John Bruyn, TheDimmaWits

SuperCoach - 724th (2010)

2012 SuperCoach Winner - Michael Thuen, PowerToThePeople

SuperCoach - 188th (2009)

2011 SuperCoach Winner - Jay To, Impromptu

AFL Dream Team - 26th (2011)

2010 SuperCoach Winner - Joe Scudieri, BlueThunder

Please feel free to browse our website, however to create threads, post comments or use additional features, you will need to
register with SuperCoach Scores. Registration is a quick process and is FREE!

Not sure that you have to many options. Given that you wish to keep your F/D, your only real
options are Viney, O'Meara or Kommer.

If you were desperate to get Crouch in Kommer would probably have to be the one to go. Depends how much you see Crouch as a must have.

Originally Posted by Nk29

Get rid of Kommer next week. He isn't going to score that well I feel.

I think you're both right but Kommer plays before O'Meara and Viney almost every week so i'd love to keep him too because I get a second look at his score before having to lock it in. I'm just going to hope he either gets subbed or Crouch gets subbed or misses the week after...anything that will make my decision.

I have VARCOE and am thinking of going with JJ KENNEDY before his price rise over a downgrade like Neade as I think Josh will be a good stepping stone in future weeks especially with WC draw. I have the DUFF MAN but am tempted to hold another couple weeks. My sneaky play im thinking of may seem a little crazy but i want to bring in Luke Parker 379k for Mundy which is 100k more and likely price decrease. With Parkers price rise again could be a solid future stepping stone. Should i go another mid rookie go with my plan?

Your thoughts would be much appreciated

Very interesting questions.

For me Stepping Stones can be important as I used Jack Riewoldt in 2011 stepping stone. However, it really depends on your intention. If it's solely to make money then Neade will be better. However, if you prefer a mix of generating money and scoring then Kennedy.

If I was in your shoes and ranked in top 1,000 then JJK is a decent decision as less risk. In my shoes, ie ranked over 10,000 then I'd go Neade to generate more cash (and while much riskier possibly higher return as I will be able to trade in genuine premiums. JJK is okay if you intend to upgrade him, but need someone cheap to continue to score.

For me I prefer to keep Mundy then to trade out Parker and then trade back even though you have saved 100K. Parker scoring SC Gold's projected score means he'll generate $40K. FWIW Parker/Swans have played GWS and Giants.

I think if you are confident that JJK and Parker will give you a solid 6 games of 90s then yes.

It's a tough one to be honest as I understand you need to keep scoreboard pressure.

Sooner or later you're going to realize, just as I did, that there's a difference between knowing the path, and walking the path - Morpheus
Let no man forget how menacing we are, we are lions! Do you know what's waiting beyond that beach?Immortality! Take it! It's Yours! - Achilles

For me Stepping Stones can be important as I used Jack Riewoldt in 2011 stepping stone. However, it really depends on your intention. If it's solely to make money then Neade will be better. However, if you prefer a mix of generating money and scoring then Kennedy.

If I was in your shoes and ranked in top 1,000 then JJK is a decent decision as less risk. In my shoes, ie ranked over 10,000 then I'd go Neade to generate more cash (and while much riskier possibly higher return as I will be able to trade in genuine premiums. JJK is okay if you intend to upgrade him, but need someone cheap to continue to score.

For me I prefer to keep Mundy then to trade out Parker and then trade back even though you have saved 100K. Parker scoring SC Gold's projected score means he'll generate $40K. FWIW Parker/Swans have played GWS and Giants.

I think if you are confident that JJK and Parker will give you a solid 6 games of 90s then yes.

It's a tough one to be honest as I understand you need to keep scoreboard pressure.

Hey Inpromptu ,

Do you suggest to offload a fallen premium ( Eg. Newman ) to another rookie. Eg Heath. Even though I already have Pittard, Stevenson, Terlich and Goodes. Would mean I only have Godd, Gibbs and Duffield in the backline plus 5 rookies including bench.

Can't decide whether to get in Heath or Brown for Newman and upgrade Karnesis to Buddy this week. Yes I know I am better off waiting for Buddy's price drop but don't want to really get caught with Newman and Karnesis. Any suggestions appreciated?

Do you suggest to offload a fallen premium ( Eg. Newman ) to another rookie. Eg Heath. Even though I already have Pittard, Stevenson, Terlich and Goodes. Would mean I only have Godd, Gibbs and Duffield in the backline plus 5 rookies including bench.

Can't decide whether to get in Heath or Brown for Newman and upgrade Karnesis to Buddy this week. Yes I know I am better off waiting for Buddy's price drop but don't want to really get caught with Newman and Karnesis. Any suggestions appreciated?

There's nothing wrong with going 3-0-5 in the backline, especially with how the Def Rookies have been going. I'm actually trading Watts to Heath this week (I already have Brown), and will be sitting at 2-0-6 this week AND next week.
Brown is probably preferred over Heath, even though Heath has the lower B/E. Brown's first round score was injury affected, and he has been named in the starting 18, where as Heath is on an extended bench, and would be a vest risk.

i feel i may have missed the boat with my starting team with the rookies in defence.

my defence - is waters,goddard,hanely,heppel,hartett,goodes (brown,stevenson)
mid rookies - in omeara,viney,dywer,jones,kommer,rampe
ruck - bicav sinclair
fwd - neade,mcaffer
my plan was to have a set and forget back 5 and then upgrade goodes but he could be a keeper, this leaves me to play brown and stevenson as back ups as well as cash grabs to help with mids.
this decision could slow down my ability to upgrade guess time will tell