We take a look at who ended the season in the Penthouse and who wound up in the Doghouse.

Yes, your Maple Leafs missed the playoffs for the eighth time in nine seasons.

Yes, their 2-12-0 run to finish the season might go down as the most disappointing end to a season in club history.

Yes, they gave up more shots than any team in the history of the 82-game season (2,945) and came close to the record of 3,080 set in an 84-game season by the second-year San Jose Sharks.

By some metrics, that makes this year’s Leafs among the worst teams defensively of all-time.

We offer our all-encompassing, season-ending Penthouse-Doghouse:

Penthouse

Phil Kessel

He carried the team offensively, leading it with 37 goals. When he went dry the last month, he took ownership of the team’s collapse, a sign of maturity. He needs to take fitness seriously and learn to play smarter.

Morgan Rielly

At times, the 20 year old was the Leafs’ best defenceman. His game got better as the season went on. He benefited from coach Randy Carlyle’s penchant for putting young players on the ice in situations where they can succeed and not be overwhelmed.

Jonathan Bernier

His steady, no-panic netminding while often facing 40-plus shots a night kept the team in more games than they deserved. It’s no coincidence the team swooned when he got hurt.

James van Riemsdyk

Ultra-confident and a good penalty killer to go along with front-of-net presence. There are flaws, but a 30-goal performance is not to be sniffed at.

Jake Gardiner

Struggled in the first half but found his game as the season went on. His ability to carry the puck is among the best in the NHL. As his confidence grows, so will his presence.

Carl Gunnarsson

Quiet and steady. Again, better in second half until his hip ailment re-surfaced.

Dave Bolland

Wish you didn’t miss all those games. A big part of the Leafs’ 14-4 start. Give him credit for coming back from that ankle injury — though probably too soon — to try to right the ship.

Joffrey Lupul

Carried the second line and was the only one on that who went to the net. Nice dresser.

Troy Bodie

Everyone’s favourite son-in-law. Honest effort every night. More efforts like his by more talented teammates and this team could still be playing.

Doghouse

Dave Nonis

The GM got himself caught in the salary cap crunch, leaving himself no wiggle room. It meant he couldn’t add help down the stretch, either via trade or through call-ups.

Randy Carlyle

The head coach preached defence. Watch team not play it. Repeat.

David Clarkson

In future, bad free agent signings that hurt a team’s cap situation will be called “Clarksonian.”

Nazem Kadri

Let’s call those blueline giveaways “Kadrian.” Sure, 50 points from a 23-year-old second-line centre isn’t bad. But it’s barely a career year, only six points better than what he amassed in a 48-game season. Frequent turnovers mean he can’t play important minutes. He can’t be trusted late in close games and until he smartens up, he won’t reach his potential.

Tyler Bozak

Funny thing, once he started showing offence to back up the dollars on his contract, his defensive game fell apart. He wasn’t good enough on faceoffs. And didn’t do enough defensively down the stretch.

Dion Phaneuf

Simply overused and overpowered when up (too often) against other team’s best.

James Reimer

We love you James, but when it mattered most you fell apart. You didn’t take adversity well.

Cody Franson

Dare you to hold out again.

Jay McClement

Played better when used less. The penalty kill — his forte — was awful.

Nikolai Kulemin

He’s no Leo Komarov.

Paul Ranger

A good comeback story that could have been so much better. He seemed lost on he ice for half the season.

Mason Raymond

Great first impression, then things faded.

Tim Gleason

See Mason Raymond.

Carter Ashton

If this were the AHL, you’d be in the penthouse. But whatever you did right in the minors wasn’t duplicated in the NHL.

Colton Orr

The enforcer’s era is coming to an end.

More on thestar.com

We value respectful and thoughtful discussion. Readers are encouraged to flag comments that fail to meet the standards outlined in our
Community Code of Conduct.
For further information, including our legal guidelines, please see our full website
Terms and Conditions.