Instagram tops Facebook on engagement

Brands are seeing nearly four times as much user engagement on Instagram than they do on Facebook, according to an analysis conducted by Socialbakers.

And it's not only brands that fare better — celebrities have four times as much engagement on Instagram as well. Here are a few more observations from the study:

Media companies get more engagement on Facebook. This may not be surprising, as a large share of Newsfeed stories come from news sites. What is unexpected, however, is that media companies saw 10 to 12 times more engagement than brands on Facebook. Meanwhile, media companies saw less engagement than brands on Instagram.

Celebrities get the most engagement on Instagram than other content providers. Engagement rates for celebrities are by far the best versus media, brand and entertainment accounts. For brands, this means getting celebrities to advocate on their behalf is an effective way to attract and engage customers. This also highlights the importance of influencer marketing, and Instagram is better suited for these types of campaigns over Facebook.

Simple interaction feature may drive higher engagement on Instagram. The study also suggested that Instagram's simple method for liking content by double-tapping the photo or video, could contribute to higher ratios of engagement.

Brands shouldn't pull spend from Facebook, but rather increase focus on Instagram. The sheer size and reach of Facebook makes it a must-have for advertisers or brands, and Socialbakers founder Jan Rezab does not advise shifting ad budgets from Facebook to Instagram. Rather, more resources should be dedicated to Instagram, and brands should start viewing the platform as a conversion tool.

Mobile-app makers and content creators are vying for consumer attention in a crowded and noisy market.

Even if an app can stand out enough to prompt a consumer to download it from among a list of millions, it then faces the challenge of enticing him or her to use it enough times to recuperate development, maintenance, and marketing costs. To make matters worse, those marketing costs have hit record-high levels over the past year as discoverability has become more challenging.

And while consumers are spending more time in apps, most of that time is spent in a few favorites. Consumers spend almost three-quarters of their total smartphone app time in just their three favorite apps, according to comScore.

But it's not all doom and gloom: There are numerous tools at a publisher's disposal to engage and re-engage consumers, and there are new products and solutions coming to market that can help alleviate some of the issues around this app engagement crisis.

Jessica Smith, research analyst for BI Intelligence, Business Insider's premium research service, has compiled a detailed report on app engagement that explores the current state of the app market, the issues around engaging consumers, and the tools at a publisher's disposal. It also identifies best practices for the implementation of some app engagement tools, and presents the pitfalls that some publishers fall into in this pursuit.

Here are some key takeaways from the report:

The app market today is challenging and volatile. It's difficult to stand out, and most apps have to be offered for free in order to entice consumers who have too much supply to choose from. This puts greater emphasis on engaging consumers after they've downloaded an app in order to recoup costs.

Consumers are more difficult to engage today, as most have dozens of apps installed on their devices yet spend most of their time in just a select handful of favorites.

There are numerous solutions at hand for mobile app publishers and content creators seeking to engage consumers. Push notifications, in-app messaging, and app message centers with badges are three tools publishers can use to engage consumers.

While many publishers mistakenly rely solely on push notifications for app engagements, this is a poor practice because many consumers don't allow push notifications and those that do can easily be overwhelmed when they receive too many.

The best solution often includes leveraging two or three of these tools to engage consumers with the right message at the right time. The technology in this market has grown increasingly sophisticated, and publishers that don't diversify their approach run the risk of annoying their consumers to the point of abandonment.

There are emerging engagement technologies that will change the current app engagement norms and present new ways for app publishers to communicate with users. The mobile ecosystem is changing quickly as technology improves and consumers become more comfortable conducting more activities on mobile devices.

In full, the report:

Identifies the major challenges in today's app market and explains why employing good app engagement practices is more important than ever before.

Presents the major app engagement tools currently available.

Examines the pros and cons of each app engagement tool while outlining some pitfalls that publishers encounter in implementing them.

Prescribes best practices for adopting various app engagement tools or strategies.

Assesses how the market will likely change over the next five years as emerging technologies change both consumer behavior with mobile devices and introduce new tools with which to engage consumers.

Interested in getting the full report? Here are two ways to access it:

Subscribe to an All-Access pass to BI Intelligence and gain immediate access to this report and over 100 other expertly researched reports. As an added bonus, you'll also gain access to all future reports and daily newsletters to ensure you stay ahead of the curve and benefit personally and professionally. » Learn More Now