There is a strong bias towards newer models since the majority of owners on the forum are owners of such newer models... I for example have driven the e46, e90, and e92 (and obviously not all transmission types), but nothing else... Clearly some bias towards my own baby...

Too tough to answer in a poll. E46 M3 with 6-speed is the second car I fell in love after the E36 M3 Evo (316bhp, europe only). The E46 did everything the E36 could do but that bit better while looking immense. But then it's undeniable that the E92 moved the game on even further.

So, I guess I'll say E30 simply because it began a run of cars which are all very special.