I consider myself an extreme whodunnit watcher although sometimes I find myself paranoid at the end of each episode. Let me start by saying that this show does not get nearly enough credit! Critics hate this show but really it's not terrible. Like one review said, we know that a body is not actually a dead one and we know that the killer is not actually killing people but we are stillI consider myself an extreme whodunnit watcher although sometimes I find myself paranoid at the end of each episode. Let me start by saying that this show does not get nearly enough credit! Critics hate this show but really it's not terrible. Like one review said, we know that a body is not actually a dead one and we know that the killer is not actually killing people but we are still sucked in and scared. Sure, the contestants are actors but why is that so terrible? It's reality TV! Take, DanceMom for example. That show doesn't get crap about those girls being actresses! Anyways, the mysteries are fun to solve with the contestants and whats even better is the fact that the viewers know the whole story. The only reason it does not get a 10 from me is because I admit to being slightly paranoid after watching.…Expand

Yes there are mixed feelings about this tv series. I think people want to like it because it is a unique twist on normal reality TV. However, there are parts of the show that if tweaked could make this show a hit. Personally I like this show already, can it be improved, yes. I have my fingers crossed for a second season with some improvements.

I love this show! I hope they make another season cause I'm so depressed that it's almost over, because this is the only show that me and everyone else in my family all can agree on and really have fun watching together!

when I saw the coming attractions for this show, I thought it looked like it was going to be corny, but it is now actually one of my favorite tv shows! I hope they make a 2nd season. I really enjoy watching and trying to figure out each case.

I normally hate mystery shows but this one got me all hooked up! My friend told me about this and I must say he sure did make the right choice. The suspense on this one will deliver chills right through your spine. I'm loving it so far and look forward for future seasons and episodes!

This review contains spoilers, click expand to view.
I have no idea why the critics think that this show is bad. I think that this is the best show on tv this summer. For someone to make one of these shows is amazing. I can't wait to see who wins!…Expand

This review contains spoilers, click expand to view.
While the show is silly and campy there is an element of charm the show has that will suck you in. Yes the death scenes are clearly fake but the deaths don't matter its how they solve them. That's why I give the show an eight.…Expand

Whodunnit? is an amazing show that I look forward to every single week. The suspense never gets old, and the intensity of the show remains. It is not only entertaining, but it makes me think and makes me want to solve the crimes along with the contestants. Although some scenes of the show may seem staged, the show itself is very suspenseful and really entertaining. I hope this show gets aWhodunnit? is an amazing show that I look forward to every single week. The suspense never gets old, and the intensity of the show remains. It is not only entertaining, but it makes me think and makes me want to solve the crimes along with the contestants. Although some scenes of the show may seem staged, the show itself is very suspenseful and really entertaining. I hope this show gets a season 2, because there has been nothing on American TV like this in a long time, if not ever.…Expand

I was devastated when ABC canceled Pan Am, I didn't watch an ABC show for 3 years until I heard about Whodunnit. I was very excited about it. It is a very great show and I love it. I don't want whodunnit to get canceled like Pan Am. I really want it to have second or more seasons.

This review contains spoilers, click expand to view.
I personally loved this show because it got you thinking and the suspense was great! The show gave me something to do in the summer and every episode I was jus writing down whodunnit and it has actually helped my brain see that out there is a scary world and you need to find your way through it. I knew that the killer was Cris because she has some popularity on media by being a miss Nevada and she was finding out very quickly how the clues work. She was also giving out hints that she was the killer and has never ever been scared once. Now isn't that a little suspicious but alas we now have solid information and have put an end to the suspense. I really do hope that they come out with another season and when I saw that they might not because of the reviews I was scarred so that is why I am writing this for all fans out there please make another season of whodunnit on behalf of the fans of whodunnit.…Expand

This is my favorite show on Sunday Night. My family is all hooked on this show hope it lasts for few more seasons at least. Its very different concept than most reality shows. Just a fun show to watch.

If you usually read my reviews, I basically give a show up to a rating of 9. but this show.. NO IT DESERVES A 10 ********BASED ON THE FIRST EPISODE ONLY**************** this show is full of intense and mystery. it kept me gut wrenching and it kept my heart racing for a whole hour. just mind blowing!!

This review contains spoilers, click expand to view.
The show tries to mix acting with challenges- The "contestants" are clearly actors- at points they are so unbelievable that I laughed when I really wasn't supposed to. The redeeming qualities on the show came from he enjoyment I got watching my least favorite character get kicked off and the hot guy being the smartest character- but seriously- Drowning... really?)…Expand

Such a numbing an truly terrible show. It takes what could be a good idea and totally ruins it; if it were tongue-in-cheek or just funny in any way it could be good. Instead everyone acts serious like they're actually going to die and the acting is just painfully atrocious. Everything that happens is unintentionally hilarious: plot points, acting, writing, the reveals of how people die,Such a numbing an truly terrible show. It takes what could be a good idea and totally ruins it; if it were tongue-in-cheek or just funny in any way it could be good. Instead everyone acts serious like they're actually going to die and the acting is just painfully atrocious. Everything that happens is unintentionally hilarious: plot points, acting, writing, the reveals of how people die, and more. I watched it for about the first six episodes but then I just gave up because it was basically like watching paint dry, if the paint were somehow drying in a way that made you angry. I did, however, find out the end episode and it's just beyond stupid. I'm at a loss for words.…Collapse

Really cool show. For the reviewer who said it was like clue as if that's a bad thing, they don't really know what they're talking about. While the show is sort of like clue at times, it's pretty much like CSI in game show form without finding out who the killer is. It's a fun watch without a doubt and for a summer game show, it's not bad at all.

I think this is a cool show. although it is extremely cheesy, it didnt bother me because it is very entertaining to see who lives, who dies, and who solves the mystery most thouroly. it is one of my favorite shows right now and recommend to anyone who likes mystery, suspense, and cheesy acting

It is proabably the most stupid fun you can have with a TV show. Yes it's stupid, but in a good way. It's kinda of cathartic to watch people kill each other for 13 episodes. It's not a must watch, but it isn't bad.

This review contains spoilers, click expand to view.
Whodunnit? is an interesting spinoff of Clue that keeps you interested with minor problems. Sherri getting killed and losing her chance of the cash prize was unfair, if they really are normal people, not actors. The other bad thing is the obviousness of the murder cause after watching 40 minutes of the episode is disappointing, like the cause of Dontae's death. But don't judge the show based on the players' fake emotions of "dying", judge it on its unique mystery aspect. Read the book to understand it more! Whodunnit! That is why I give this show an 8.…Expand

Rated a 10 because I've never seen another show like it. The mysteries are great, and it's fun to watch how each day pans out. Even if the hypothetical situation that some or even all the contestants are actors were true, it still wouldn't detract from the show's entertainment value. I find it unfortunate to see critics rate it so low, and hope that this show will live to see another season!

I gave the show a 7 because although I love the show for it's originality and suspenseful drama of running around trying to search for murder clues, the contestants DO feel a little fake at times, the only time I've ever seen a hint of a real moment is after they're dead. At least 2 of the 13 are professional killers are professional actors (Sherri, who was killed in the first episode andI gave the show a 7 because although I love the show for it's originality and suspenseful drama of running around trying to search for murder clues, the contestants DO feel a little fake at times, the only time I've ever seen a hint of a real moment is after they're dead. At least 2 of the 13 are professional killers are professional actors (Sherri, who was killed in the first episode and whoever the "killer" is). Things feel a little too controlled and obvious with regards to "evidence", which makes for a good crime procedural drama but not so much for reality TV. But, despite it's minor flaws it's nice to see a reality show that relies on intelligence rather than who's the most popular/conniving/unlikely to pose a threat or whose got the best Jersey Shore tan (I didn't even bother to watch past 1 episode of that show but since they all looked like oompaloompas who were exposed to heavy amounts of gamma radiation I assume that's what it was all about)…Expand

so amazing i love this show this show should go on forever i am totally one hundred percent loving this show so fun and i will never stop loving this show! Its so good if it gets cancelled i would cry i LOVE it so much and my family does too!!!!1

I love this show!! Very interesting and cool!! It would be better if it was a little less scripted but other than that it's AMAZING!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!

Ironically the critics thought that the viewers wouldn't like this show, yet almost all metacritic user reviews came back positive. Great show and I highly enjoyed watching every bit of it and I really hope they bring this show back.

Surprizingly enjoyable murder-mystery reality series. I didn't know what to make of it at first, especially as it slides into a new layer of reality TV where everyone was oddly convincing as they pretended their teammates died and/or were scared to die themselves. There was something special about it, and enjoyed watching it throughout the summer.

I love this show! I live in the UK and managed to check it out online. It's so entertaining and has a great concept. I do enjoy how creative the murders and riddles get. I also really love the character 'Giles'. I hope to see more in the future!

We know the body convulsing on the floor of the grand foyer isn't really being electrocuted. And yet we get sucked into the suspense and the gore as the players express fear, anxiety and tearful protests against being the next to die. ABC's amalgam of drama, murder mystery, parlor game and elimination competition for money is a curious mishmash.

The cast seems no better, or worse, than any reality TV assemblage, but the clues are delivered to the group in such a way that much of the pilot is spent watching them troop, mostly en masse, from one room to the other. It's not terribly exciting.