Reminder: The post-Super Bowl ratings bump usually doesn’t last

Share this:

The show that airs after the Super Bowl each year gets a big audience — in many cases the biggest one that particular show will ever see. That’s a big deal.

It’s also true, however, that shows usually return to their typical ratings within a week or two of the post-Super Bowl episode. By and large over the last decade or so, the hope of a Super Bowl halo extending beyond the post-game episode didn’t meet with the facts.

Only three of the past 11 post-game shows have seen any meaningful long-term ratings gain. The Super Bowl audience may be huge, but it’s also fleeting — what network programmers refer to as a “rented audience.” TV pretty much returns to normal the next day.

TV by the Numbers crunched the pre- and post-Super Bowl ratings for each of the last 11 Super Bowl lead-outs. We’ll soon know how “24: Legacy” performs after Super Bowl LI. In the meantime, here’s a look at the ratings halos (or lack thereof) for shows that followed the Super Bowl since 2006, starting with the biggest beneficiary of them all.

Halo: Massive. “Grey’s” is the gold standard of Super Bowl boosts in recent memory. The show was already a hit in its second season, but it moved into the stratosphere following “It’s the End of the World,” the bomb-in-a-body-cavity episode that aired after Super Bowl XL.

The three episodes immediately after the Super Bowl episode averaged a 10.9* in adults 18-49. That’s a 29 percent gain over the show’s prior Season 2 average. Here’s the really remarkable stat, however: 35 of the next 37 episodes — a run stretching all the way to the Season 4 premiere — came in above the show’s pre-Super Bowl average. Of the two that didn’t, one virtually tied it (an 8.4 on May 10, 2007), and one aired on Thanksgiving 2006 (7.6).

(*Side note: Man, things sure have changed in the past decade.)

2007: ‘Criminal Minds’ (CBS)

Pre-Super Bowl season average: 4.5Super Bowl episode: 9.9

Halo: Short-lived. The CBS crime drama’s next episode tied a season high with a 5.1, but the next three airings all came in at 4.0 opposite “American Idol’s” juggernaut. To be fair, the lone pre-Super Bowl episode of “Criminal Minds” that faced “Idol” managed just a 3.3, so the exposure of the game probably did help a little.

2008: ‘House’ (FOX)

Pre-Super Bowl season average: 7.4Super Bowl episode: 12.9

Halo: Lost to outside forces. The next episode drew a 9.0 in adults 18-49, a season high for a regular episode. It was the last one made before the 2008 writers’ strike shut production down. “House” didn’t return until April 28 of that year.

2009: ‘The Office’ (NBC)

Pre-Super Bowl season average: 4.5Super Bowl episode: 11.0

Halo: Non-existent. The next two episodes of the show averaged a 4.45 rating, in line with the pre-Super Bowl average. The show stayed in the high 3s and low 4s for most of the rest of the season.

2010: ‘Undercover Boss’ series premiere (CBS)

Pre-Super Bowl season average: N/ASuper Bowl episode: 16.2

Halo: Sizable. “Undercover Boss” had the best 18-49 rating of a Super Bowl lead-out since “Grey’s” (and a slightly bigger total audience), and it sustained solid ratings into its second season. The eight Season 1 episodes after the premiere averaged a 4.5, and it didn’t dip below 3.0 until the sixth episode of Season 2.

2011: ‘Glee’ (FOX)

Pre-Super Bowl season average: 4.8Super Bowl episode: 11.1

Halo: Non-existent. The next three episodes of the show averaged 4.4 in the demo, and the back end of “Glee’s” second season tailed off some more.

2012: ‘The Voice’ Season 2 premiere (NBC)

Season 1 average (April-June 2011): 4.5Super Bowl episode: 16.3

Halo: Pretty big. “The Voice” didn’t record a rating below the Season 1 average until early April, when the ninth episode scored a 4.1. It probably helped that NBC only aired a single weekly episode until that time.

2013: ‘Elementary’ (CBS)

Pre-Super Bowl season average: 2.4Super Bowl episode: 7.8

Halo: Non-existent. Airing after the 49ers-Ravens blackout Super Bowl, “Elementary” didn’t start until after 11 p.m. ET and subsequently recorded the lowest Super Bowl lead-out numbers in a decade.Subsequent episodes had same-day ratings on par with the season average. “Elementary” was a big DVR show from the outset of its inaugural season, but the Super Bowl episode didn’t persuade any new viewers to start watching live.

Halo: Nope. The weeks immediately after the game saw both shows come in below their prior season average.

2015: ‘The Blacklist’ (NBC)

Pre-Super Bowl season average: 2.7Super Bowl episode: 8.4

Halo: Not really. The Super Bowl episode also teed up “The Blacklist’s” move to Thursday nights after a season-plus on Mondays after “The Voice.” The first Thursday episode earned a 2.4, with subsequent airings all falling below 2.0. It can’t really be quantified, but you could argue that without the promotion of a Super Bowl episode, ratings on Thursdays would have been lower.

2016: ‘The Late Show with Stephen Colbert’ (CBS)

Pre-Super Bowl season average: 0.7Super Bowl episode: 7.7

Halo: None. The following day’s “Late Show” experienced a small uptick in ratings, but the show’s average for the week (0.55) was only a few hundredths of a point higher than the previous week. It remained in that range for the rest of the season.

Share this:

Posted by:Rick Porter

Rick Porter has been covering TV since the days when networks sent screeners on VHS, one of which was a teaser for the first season of "American Idol." He's left-handed, makes a very solid grilled cheese and has been editor of TV by the Numbers since October 2015. He lives in Austin.

[…] shows have aired episodes after the Superbowl, and drawn huge crowds. However, as TV By The Numbers reports, most of those shows lost the majority of their Superbowl viewership, when the yearly viewership […]

[…] of extra viewers won’t necessarily stick around beyond the next few weeks. According to TV by the Numbers, Super Bowl lead-out shows in seven years out of the past 10 saw a major initial spike in their […]