In one of the worst officiated games you’re likely to see this side of replacement officials, the New England Patriots saw off a strong fight from the Buffalo Bills to claim the result everybody predicted all along.

The Bills, in truth, may have played the better football for the majority of this game, but a ludicrous penalty count coupled with a pair of killer fumbles from Fred Jackson and a final last-gasp interception from Ryan Fitzpatrick ensured they would come up one score short in the game as the final seconds ticked off.

The Bills were badly hurt by the officials who called a pair of horrible defensive pass interference penalties on balls that were completely uncatchable (the second of which landed past the first row of photographers out of the back of the end zone), but the ‘zebras’ also helped them out on a couple of occasions by missing a clear false start and a defensive offside penalty later in the game. The pass interference calls were bigger in terms of yardage and setting the Patriots up at the goal line, but the Bills had bigger problems than the officials in the game.

Let’s see what performances stood out.

Buffalo – Three Performances of Note

D-line Sighting

Much has been made this year about how underwhelming the Bills have been up front given the talent on that line, but the three big names in this game all graded positively, with the defensive tackle pairing in particular having a major impact. Kyle Williams was again at his destructive best, notching a sack, a pair of hits and two more hurries as he devastated the New England interior, while Marcel Dareus batted down a pair of passes and got in on a sack along with Williams. That sack showed perfectly the kind of dominance the pair can have. With 11:18 to go in the third quarter, both players lined up in a two-point rushing stance in the middle and destroyed the Patriots assigned to block them. Dareus ran right over center Ryan Wendell, while Williams span off the block of left guard Logan Mankins and the pair met at the quarterback for a sack. This is what we expected to see every week from the Bills this year, but it has been all too rare.

Picking on the MLB

If there was one player that had a really tough time of it for the Bills, it was Nick Barnett (-5.5) in the middle. He found himself matched up in man coverage with the stable of Patriots shifty slot receivers and running backs, and was just exposed again and again. Overall he was in primary coverage for nine passes and allowed eight catches for 102 yards and a touchdown. He was beaten multiple times by Wes Welker and Danny Woodhead, both players who are matchup nightmares for a linebacker, and once by Rob Gronkowski for a 24-yard gain. It’s fair to say that Barnett won’t see a tougher test in terms of his coverage skills this season, and he’ll be glad to put this game behind him.

The Rollercoaster Day of Fitzpatrick and Fred Jackson

This is where things get very tricky, because both players actually played very well for the majority of the game but they were responsible for the Bills’ four biggest negative plays. Fred Jackson rushed for 80 yards and two touchdowns, at five yards per carry, adding four catches for 35 yards, but he coughed the ball up twice, once inside the Patriots’ 5-yard line ending a potential scoring drive, and once on the final drive of the game when he was stunned by a hit from Brandon Spikes. Ryan Fitzpatrick threw for two scores, 337 yards and had a passer rating of 99.7, but he fumbled the ball in the course of a sack he could see coming, and threw an unforgiveable interception at the death to finally end the game. It may be harsh, but this game typifies Fitzpatrick’s play, in that even when he is on song, he conspires to find a way to screw it up and come up short.

New England – Three Performances of Note

Not a Vintage Day on D

As you might imagine given the points Buffalo put on the board, this was not a banner day for the New England defense — but nobody came out of it looking quite as bad as Rob Ninkovich (-7.0) who graded negatively in every facet of the game we track. He was beaten in the run game consistently by the Bills’ offensive line, notched just three total pressures (albeit one sack) from his 43 pass rushes, gave up three receptions in just six snaps in coverage, missed two tackles and was penalized for jumping the snap. The only solace for the veteran defender is that he was not alone in showing poorly. The Patriots missed a massive 15 tackles, with nine of those coming in the secondary and the rest coming at the second level from linebackers. Buffalo has running backs that can make you miss, but the Patriots need to tackle better than that to contain them.

The CB Carousel Continues

New England at times seem like they rotate players on defense just for fun, or to somehow strike on the right combination by luck as if pulling the plunger on a slot machine … sooner or later it will come up jackpot. Well so far it hasn’t, and all they have succeeded in doing is running through a staggering number of young defensive backs, each of whom seem to struggle as badly as the last after flashes of talent. This time it was Alfonzo Dennard who was taken to task, being targeted 10 times and allowing seven receptions for 85 yards and a touchdown. Dennard found himself in the slot a lot and seemed totally lost without a boundary to protect him, allowing massive cushions on quick-breaking routes and 31 yards after the catch. Devin McCourty, the Patriots’ best defensive back, continued his solid play at safety, allowing only one catch and picking off Fitzpatrick to seal the win. But is he better used at corner? I think so.

Woodhead Reminder

Just when you think the Patriots have forgotten about Danny Woodhead, he pops up with a game like this that makes you remember what a problem he is for defenses. His size, speed and quickness make him a Wes Welker in the backfield, and he was a real factor over the middle working against the Bills’ linebackers. He was thrown at six times, catching four of them for 46 yards and a touchdown, and in truth should have had a second on the last Patriots drive (discounting the kneel) when Tom Brady got clear of pressure only to bury the ball in the turf at Woodhead’s feet rather than hit him for a touchdown at the front corner of the end zone. He got only the lone carry, but he made the most of it, breaking back and scampering 15 yards for a score.

Game Notes

– New England had all three running backs on the field for 15 or more snaps, and four TEs saw playing time.

– Tom Brady was 0-2 on passes 20+ yards in the air, and only 38 of his yards came from passes thrown more than 10 yards downfield, on only three completions.

– Under pressure, Ryan Fitzpatrick had a passer rating of 110.1.

PFF Game Ball

It would be harsh to give the ball to anybody other than Danny Woodhead, given his contribution to the scoring, but Kyle Williams ran him very close in a losing effort.

Comments (7)

Tackling was very bad. The Patriots defense’ missed tackles were just horrifying. Plays that should have been dead turn into first downs and 15 yard gains. Very uncommon for a team with solid tacklers. That’s the reason why the Bills drives were kept alive and they capitalized on it. Wrapping the ball carier is a simple thing on paper, but you see so many of these around the league.

According to premium membership PFF numbers Buffalo out-pointed NE by 31.5 points in skill based score (person by person whole team). Guys who are scoring, I have been a believer and have steered people towards this site. How can you say this? That is a massively unbalanced score and you’d expect Buffalo would have win by 20 points if you go by that. Please tell me why I should believe these rankings of scores again!? NE did win this game and played well in many aspects despite the porous defense at times. Thank you.

Testimonials

I've been a fan of Pro Football Focus since 2008. The snap count data and signature stats are indispensable daily resources for me and the Monson-Stockwell Analysis Notebook series is high on my list of must reads. If you're a thinking fan, you'll love the mix of hard data, smart metrics and analysis in context produced at PFF.— Jene Bramel - Footballguys.com staff writer, contributor to NY Times 5th Down blog

I've got so much respect for the time and effort the guys at Pro Football Focus put into their work. The man hours it takes to gather all of their objective data must be astronomical!— Ross Tucker - Former player, Analyst for ESPN.com, SiriusXM, NFL Radio

It's one thing to watch games and notice a player is doing his job. It's a whole other thing to take a step back, do the homework and understand what it means in the big picture. That's where Pro Football Focus is so great. If I ever have a question on a player, if I ever want to know more than simply what I see on TV, that's the site I click on. It takes the game of football to the next level with stats, snap breakdowns, and really anything else I need to know. It's a fantastic resource.— Ian Rapoport - NFL Network

I enjoy reading the PFF articles because they go into more detail than just the numbers. In our day and age numbers get you the accolades, but don't always tell the whole story.— Brian Robison - DE, Minnesota Vikings

Pro Football Focus is an invaluable resource in preparing to broadcast NFL games each week. It's given me the ability to better inform my audience about the strengths and weaknesses of the Bengals and their opponents, as well as providing insight into the strategies used by the league's offensive and defense coaches. But you don't have to cover the NFL to enjoy the content provided by PFF. Any avid football fan will enjoy the premium stats that only PFF provides as well as the interesting…— Dan Hoard - Cincinnati Bengals Radio Broadcaster

Each year, my respect for Pro Football Focus and it’s analysis grows. Now, it’s off the charts. Within 24 hours of every game, PFF puts into perspective how every player on every team ranks and breaks down in depth what they accomplish and how they fail on the field. Where this is valuable is identifying the young players who are becoming stars or the others who may be struggling. It’s a great tool for any football fan wanting to get inside the game.— John Clayton - ESPN

I feel like PFF has given the most accurate evaluations of player performance of any site out there.— Alterraun Verner - Tampa Bay Buccaneers

The ONLY outside source that has ever directly benefited our contract negotiations with NFL teams.
Pro Football Focus has literally helped us put dollars directly into our clients' pockets.
Knowledge is power, and the power of tracking every single player on every single snap of every NFL game is absolutely immeasurable.— Dave Butz (SportsStars Inc.) NFL Agent

Numbers can lie. But PFF breaks the numbers down to paint the truth without bias. When I'm looking to enhance my game I go to PFF. It's the raw truth that numbers won't show you.— Lawrence Jackson - Former Seattle and Detroit DE

I don't have a lot of daily go-to NFL websites, but ProFootballFocus is one of them. It's got vital information about the NFL that you can't find anywhere else. In a short time, it's become an essential niche site we need in the football-reporting business.— Peter King - SI.com

PRO FOOTBALL FOCUS TWITTER FEED

Since we began recording it in 2007, Tom Brady has never had an accuracy percentage below 72.0%. http://t.co/sIPpqDlmN4