Friday, May 25, 2007

"... Even if one thinks that [Joseph] Smith was profoundly mistaken (as I do), one cannot help but marvel at the religious genius of this project [Mormonism]: It has all the advantages of Reformation Protestantism and nineteenth-century Restorationism ("Let's get back to what Jesus and the apostles originally taught") with all the advantages of Catholicism and Orthodoxy - an apostolic magisterium within the confines of a visible church. Smith has both a priesthood of all believers and a priesthood managed by a church hierarchy. He offers a new gospel unconstrained by centuries of theological precedent, yet it he could claim that it is as old as the apostles. He could, without contradiction, reject tradition while claiming to be the true guardian of an ancient message. It may be wrong, but it was brilliant..."