Both premiered new singles on April 25 -- DeWyze's "Silver Lining," from his forthcoming album on Vanguard Records, and Langone's "Yes to Love," from his debut for Hollywood Records -- and got to take a quick, if stressful, stroll down memory lane.

Fortunately, THR's own Idol correspondent Casey Abrams, himself a graduate of season 10, was there to trade barbs with his fellow finalists after the show -- and not just of the Nicki Minaj kind. He also got their thoughts on this year's final four and the new judges.