The views published here are of an ecosocialist nature and from the broad red, green and black political spectrum. The opinions expressed are the personal opinions of the writers and are not necessarily the view of any political parties or groupings that they belong to. Please feel free to comment on the posts here. If you would like to contact us directly, you can email us at mike.shaughnessy@btinternet.com. Follow the blog on Twitter @MikeShaugh

Friday, 12 August 2016

The Myth of New Labour’s Electoral appeal to Labour Voters

After eighteen miserable years of Tory rule, Tony Blair’s
New Labour was swept into office in 1997, with a landslide victory. I was as
pleased as anyone to see the back of the Tories, and watching the results come
in the early hours of Friday morning, it did just keep getting better. One
after another, top Tories were felled, culminating in the defeat of arch
Thatcherite, Michael Portillo.

I knew Labour had tacked considerably to right under Blair,
and so was not expecting much from the incoming Labour government, but it was
good to see the Tories, long our arrogant rulers, completely thrashed. As it
turned out, even my low expectations of Labour were confounded. New Labour was
actually even worse than I had expected.

The turn out for the 1997 general election was 71.3%, which
by today’s standards is good, indeed it has not been bettered since. But by
historical standards it is on the low side. The previous general election in
1992 had a turn out of 77.7% and every general election since the second World
War had a higher turn out than in 1997 up until that point.

Turn out at the next general election in 2001, was a dismal
59.4% which recovered a little in 2005 to 61.4% and again in 2010 to 65.1%
(under Gordon Brown’s premiership). Hardly popular endorsements, even though
Labour won easily until 2010.

What happened is that voters in 1992 gave John Major’s
Tories the benefit of the doubt, after Margaret Thatcher was ousted eighteen
months previously. That benefit of the doubt evaporated after only four months,
when Black Monday sent sterling hurtling out of the Exchange Rate Mechanism
with the subsequent loss of billions of pounds to currency speculators, George
Soros chief amongst them.

It was a national humiliation, and the voters never
forgave the Tories for it.

On top of this, Major’s government was wracked with
division, over Europe, and mired in sleaze, of the sexual and financial kind,
and the voters just bided their time until kicking them out in 1997, in
spectacular fashion.

So the myth of New Labour’s electoral prowess was born, but
in reality it was the Tories profound unpopularity with British voters that led
to Blair’s victories. The Tories also lost seats to the Lib Dems and the idea
of ‘tactical voting’ took hold like never before. Basically, whoever was best
placed to keep the Tories out in any particular constituency, usually Labour or
the Lib Dems, got the votes.

The low voting turn outs over the Blair years were most
pronounced in Labour’s traditional heartlands, Manchester, Liverpool, South
Wales, Leeds etc. New Labour stalwart, Hilary Benn was elected to Parliament
for the first time at a by-election in 1999, on a turn out of just 19.6%. A
record for low turn out at the time, but since beaten by Lucy Powell, another
anti-Corbyn rebel MP in 2012, in Manchester Central with a paltry 18.2% turn
out.

This trend continued under Ed Miliband’s leadership with the 20
lowest turn out seats in the 2015 general election, all safe Labour ones. These
seats are under threat from UKIP now, and the idea that a return to Blairism by
Labour would halt this trend is for the birds.

Incidentally, one of the strains of the ‘Corbyn is
unelectable’ mantra put about by the New Labour tendency MPs at the moment, is
that Corbyn lacks leadership qualities, but the same could have been said about
Ed Miliband, but wasn’t. No rebellions from MPs when Miliband was leader,
although there was some muttering, no tantrums, no leadership challenge.

This is because what the New Labour faction don’t like about Corbyn
is his policies, it has nothing to do with his ‘leadership qualities,’ it is
purely ideological.

New Labour Tory-light policies have been rejected by the
electorate twice now, so how this can be held up as a winning formula is beyond
rationality, but that is because it is all bollocks.