The victims of the fire are buried in the Percival family cemetery on Walton-Nicholson Road, including Amanda Garrison, who is listed as "​coloured"​ on her tombstone. ​ [[African-Americans]] were generally buried in separate cemeteries at that time. It is believed that their badly burned bodies were impossible to distinguish,​ leading to all three victims being buried together.

The victims of the fire are buried in the Percival family cemetery on Walton-Nicholson Road, including Amanda Garrison, who is listed as "​coloured"​ on her tombstone. ​ [[African-Americans]] were generally buried in separate cemeteries at that time. It is believed that their badly burned bodies were impossible to distinguish,​ leading to all three victims being buried together.