So, as you can see there can be little doubt that Lewis witnessed the same people and events described by Hutchinson.

There is indeed little doubt that the stories are essentially the same, as it is that Sarah gave her story to the police shortly after the murder was discovered and the details were out in the general publics knowledge for 3 days..at which time she appeared at the Inquest into the crime, and long before George gave his story, behind closed doors, to one person, with what can only be described as "fantastic detail" about a man supposedly accompanying Mary Kelly to her room. After an Inquest statement from someone who had to pass by Mary Kellys door anytime she went in or out that night, and who stated that she saw the woman arrive home before midnight.. apparently very drunk, with someone who doesn't match Astrakans description at all.