Unfortunately, with the dawn comes regrets. As he tells Cochran, maybe sabotaging their tribe isn't the best idea. And when Phillip comes over, Brandon tries to make peace. Can they figure out a way to pull the whole tribe together? But Phillip rambles on about how he's the CEO and Brandon's middle management and how he can't trust Brandon, etc.

Brandon is not pleased. "Phillip is a bully," he tells Erik and Corinne. "He's Boston Robbing us."

Over at the fans' camp, two sides are starting to form as well: the couples vs. everyone else. Sherri wants to solidify her six -- herself, Laura, Julia, Michael, Matt, and Shamar.

But Shamar is starting to annoy everyone with his laziness around camp. Still, Sherri wants to keep him around because, "Shamar is my Phillip." Aha, so she's trying to Boston Rob them, too!

Immunity challenge

The challenge is another multi-step obstacle course ending in a ring toss. The fans are so divided, they can't figure out who should do what, and it ends up costing them. The faves win immunity and fishing gear. The Phillip/Brandon showdown will be delayed at least another week.

Go behind the scenes of the challenge:

Meanwhile, the fans go back to camp and start scrambling. Reynold calls out Shamar for their loss, as well as being lazy in camp. Shamar shrugs, asking what Reynold plans to do about it. "Vote for you," Reynold responds.

Laura wants her alliance to target Allie because "she's the only one of the pretty people who's thinking."

Michael and Matt, the floaters, aren't quite sure which way to go. Maybe they should vote Shamar out -- they'll still have a five-to-four advantage anyway. And at least they'll be rid of a troublemaker. Sherri is adamant that they keep him. Which side will they choose?

Hidden agendas

Finally, one of the fans uses their expertise to do something smart! Allie's partner, Reynold goes hunting for the hidden immunity idol ... and finds it! He then hides it in his pocket. "I don't want to go back to camp with a big bulge in my pants," he jokes.

Unfortunately, his pants are too tight and Laura spots the bulge. She instantly knows he's got the hidden idol, and now she's worried he might give it to Allie.

At Tribal, she reveals that information to everybody's shock. He defends himself and makes a case: Don't force him to use it now, so they can all use it after the merge.

Everyone votes, and the floaters choose: Allie is voted out. The pretty people alliance is in major trouble.

Check out Twitter reactions to the episode, then sound off in the comments below!

Is that an immunity idol in your pocket or are you just happy to go to tribal counsel? #Survivor.