No, this isn't an American Pie movie plot. Actor Eddie Kay Thomas called police Wednesday, April 17 after a woman allegedly threatened him with a knife and barricaded herself in his L.A. home after an alleged one-night stand.

According to TMZ, Thomas, who starred as Finch in the American Pie franchise, had only just met the woman the night before at Mel's Diner. After trying to convince the woman to surrender, SWAT reportedly had to force her out with tear gas.