Huge fan of Fiona... this would be my breakdown:
1. The Idler Wheel...
2. When the Pawn...
3. Tidal
4. Extraordinary Machine
The Idler Wheel just has that extra stroke of fucking go for broke brilliance. But, in my opinion, it and When the Pawn are perfect and absolutely complete albums.
Really glad to see her where she belongs on this list, at #1 :)