What sets do you now regret selling?

I have bought and sold over the last four years to help offset my collection costs.

I was thinking today about the sets I once owned and have since sold.

Here's my list of regrets that I sold.

6243 Brick Beards Bounty. This is by far the best Pirate ship IMHO to this day. I only had one copy and was really poor at the time of my newly discovered hobby. Sold for 10$ more than I payed and was not retired at the time.

10210 Imperial Flagship. This was a good build but lacked a lot of details for the price. Sold at the same time with Brick Bounty. Sold for 20$ more than I paid and was not retired at the time. Massive size was a great display.

10194 Emerald Night. Bought three copies on sale. Sold two for 250$ a year after retirement. Still have one copy but one passenger car is so plain! Wish I had those other cars and just sold the loco's.

10219 Maesrk Train. Bought two copies on sale. Built one keep other sealed. Sold used for 200$ and Sealed for 220$ Bought one copy back for 240$ Sealed a year after selling the two originals. This is such a great looking train. Wish I had just keep the two originals. Silly me thinking MMV was going to be the winner.

The positive for the sales is that they helped buy many others sets that are now retired. They are all in my MOC collection and many at discounted prices. So I was able to stretch my money very far.

Also I regret missing out on the purchase of a 10224 Town Hall. I really drop the ball in October with double points. I missed when Target and Walmart had the online Lego discount battle. I just could never pull the trigger at full price for this set. Now I will probably sell my other three modular buildings FB (Built), GE (Sealed), PS (Sealed)

To date, I've only sold duplicates, save for some 'yard sale finds.' Though I have a few MISB Spider-Man sets (from the 2004-ish era) that I've thought of selling... I am fearful of regret, hence still having them. ;)

Towards the end of my childhood obsession of with LEGO I started getting into Star Wars and bought as many sets as I could get my hands on. This was around 2005-2006 ish, or around the time Revenge of the Sith was released. Can't remember exactly what I had, but I know I had the Hoth version of the Millenium Falcon, Wookie Catamaran, and some TIE Fighters. Anyway, I got bored of the stuff and sold it on eBay as a lot, think I got around $140. Granted, I did keep a few minifigs I liked (Princess Leia, Han Solo, Emperor Palpatine and his guards from the Imperial Shuttle set). I wish I'd kept them because I could probably have gotten more now, though I haven't done the research.

^Market Street retired before the end of my dark age, same with CC and GG

GG was a set that I had looked at in the catalog I had sorted when I worked at the post office. I'm glad that the catalog was delivered to an old address with no forwarding or I probably would have never looked at it. I honestly think that summer catalog got me out of me dark age. I remember CC being on clearance on the Lego shop at home website before I toke the plunge and actually had bought some sets.

I'm mainly interested in castle and fantasy sets. I started on collecting Castle. Now I have a good selection of Trains and Technic, with a few Modulars.

Nice thread, thinking of selling #4842 Hogwarts and #10199 WV Toy Shop, as both were not an intended purchase but came as part of a bundle. But seeing how our likes and dislikes change with time, I'm afraid to because of future regrets! But then you can't keep everything, money is one thing but space is another very real constraint......

I sold all my Lego collection earlier this year but have now started again from scratch.My biggest regrets were selling 2 x MISB #10221 Super Star Destroyers, the entire Monster Fighters range including #10228 Haunted House , I have managed to get a replacement NISB HH for a good price since it is now retired.I have told myself that if the "Dark Ages " are looming in the future, my Lego collection will be boxed up and get stored in the attic and not sold off.

I have only sold off a few original Star Wars sets - Land Speeder, Snowspeeder, X-Wing Fighter and Speeder Bikes - which I guess it would be quite cool to still have. These were bought during a brief spell out of the Dark Ages when I was around 20.

The sets I regret selling the most are the two Pirates of the Caribbean Ships #4195 Queen Anne's Revenge and #4184 Black Pearl. Since selling them the price of both has skyrocketed to the extent where I simply couldn't justify the £250 odd quid needed to buy them new. They are now permanently absent from my Lego Pirate ship collection. Unfortunately it was done at at a time when I needed the money.

I sold my Imperial Flagship. I really liked that ship, but I don't regret it too much. As others have said, you only have so much space and Pirates is not a theme that I collect. I sold my Futuron Monorail which I regretted very much and because of that re-purchased it a year later. Still don't have a good place to display it, but I like knowing that it's there when I "need" it.

The best thing to do before you sell your prized set is consider how much you'll miss it vs. the cost of replacing it long term. Also don't sell it just so you can have a brand new Lego set to open and build. I've done that and it's a mistake.

Hands down, the Emerald Night. I owned two of them, one opened and one unopened. It was a perfect display... sadly, real-world needs caused me to sell both at the same time.

I am now piecing one back together, but I won't ever have one in a perfect (absolute mint) box again. Also, this set contains my favorite Lego piece of all time, that dark green slope with two gold striped from the front of the train.

The sets I regret selling the most are the two Pirates of the Caribbean Ships #4195 Queen Anne's Revenge and #4184 Black Pearl. Since selling them the price of both has skyrocketed to the extent where I simply couldn't justify the £250 odd quid needed to buy them new. They are now permanently absent from my Lego Pirate ship collection. Unfortunately it was done at at a time when I needed the money.

I also did this as well, I had both ships... Got the Black Pearl on clearance for like $60.00... Sold them both for a nice chunk of change, but definitely regret it! Also regret selling my LotR sets as well...

Well, speaking of the Black Pearl... my son had a babysitter one day, and they opened up this set but they never built it. And somehow all of the bags have disappeared and all I have left is an empty box. I have no idea where the set went. I know it wasn't the babysitter because the set was still there in bags at least initially. So, someday I am hoping to come across this set. I think it's lost in my house somewhere.

I sold quite a few sets, and used the money as down payment to buy a house. Do I regret selling them...I miss having them of course, but having a new house is better, and I still have quite a few Lego to build with. Here's some of what I sold:

I regret selling the half finished sets thinking I would never get hold of the parts to finish them off. But of course you do...I sold #7740, #7738 and #7739. The last two I saved for a long time, and it annoys me not to have built them proper as they are good sets. I have the 7740 on my to-do list, bur been putting off building it as I fear it will be complete...

^Natro220, When a set triples, quadruples, or goes even higher in value its hard not to send it to the next happy owner. Grand carousel is one I had eyed for a long time before full out of the dark age. It was a short lived set that was so drastically different from all the rest. I remember seeing these on clearance at shop at home and before my hobby became an addiction I could never dream of spending $200+ on one set alone.

My thought exactly VaderX. While they were hard to part with...I guess I don't truly regret selling them as they brought in quite a bit of cash. My parents still don't believe that I made enough money for a down payment for a house by selling Lego sets.

I try to only sell the dregs...the sets I bought for a minifig or two or else pieced together from a craigslist lot. (Yes I am a hoarder and rapidly running out of space to display everything!)

I did sell the 7662 MTT to a friend, immediately regretted it, then upon seeing what the new one looked like bought another one as part of a lot on eBay. Haven't even put the thing together, but knowing that I COULD makes me content.

I was always an avid Lego buyer, but never thought Lego could possibly have any resale value (I had never purchased anything used or followed any aftermarket values). I had fallen on some hard times and a friend offered me $300 for my entire original Ninja (castle series) and Fright Knights sets - I had every set, used but put back in the boxes (these were the only sets I thought I could live without). This seemed like a good deal for some used toys, so I sold them. I went to replace them once I was back on my feet only to discover Lego values INCREASE. It made me feel sick, realizing what I had done. I offered to buy them back, but he had already sold them on Ebay, for a huge profit.

Not counting the dozens of 7191's I sold for 199 USD back in 03 (at peace because I was paying less than 60 USD to buy them) probably the dozen or so 10039's sold in the last quarter of 03 for 32USD ( purchased at 19 USD). The BIG killer? The seven INDIVIDUALLY NUMBERED 10020's sold in Q2 '04 for between 20-35 USD each (and bought new and shiny for under 18 USD EACH) I miss the good old days when LEGO was so damn cheap in Australia - the interesting thing is at the time, was more than happy to sell these because I was generally making 70% + profit.....I'm just going to sit in the corner and rock quietly for a while...

Immediately upon my descent into my Dark Ages (around 14/15) I sold almost my entire collection to a mother for her son for litterally pennies on the dollar. I kept maybe a crate worth of bricks, plus my Pirate and Western sets and a few random bits and pieces. But boy oh boy, every once in a while I think back to that very encounter and my selling off of so much....the immediate shiver that follows said thought is truly mind blowing.