Boston Red Sox first baseman Mike Napoli is known for his incredible beard, but it certainly wasn’t always that way.

A Reddit user, who says his girlfriend went to high school in Pembroke Pines, Fla., with Napoli, posted the slugger’s yearbook photo, and it’s truly awesome. The serious, baby-faced Napoli is dressed to the nines, wearing a tuxedo and sporting a diamond earring.

Napoli obviously has been working on his game face for quite some time.