AND STILL GET HIGH QUALITY CARE?

Transcription

1 HOW CAN WE REDUCE OUR HEALTH CARE SPENDING AND STILL GET HIGH QUALITY CARE? A Choicework discussion guide from Public Agenda, developed through a collaborative research project with the Kettering Foundation Copyright 2013 Public Agenda

2 HOW CAN WE REDUCE OUR HEALTH CARE SPENDING AND STILL GET HIGH QUALITY CARE? Introduction Rapidly rising health care spending hurts individuals and families who can t afford insurance; employers who can t afford to provide coverage to employees; and taxpayers who can t afford the cost of Medicare, Medicaid and mending our wounded veterans. This is not just a problem of affordability for individuals but for our nation as a whole. As more and more baby boomers retire, the cost of providing Medicare benefits which most Americans want and support will skyrocket to the point where it will make today s deficits seem like small change. In short, the American health care system has a serious spending problem that is fast approaching crisis proportions. Some kind of change is necessary the current system is simply unsustainable but what kind of changes will best bring costs under control while providing the best possible care and creating the fewest negative consequences? That is the question we want to discuss today. Obviously, this is a complex problem and no single, simple answer will address the entirety of this national challenge. What we do know is that it will require us to make some tough decisions and face some tradeoffs. To help you think and talk about this important issue, this guide offers three strategies for addressing our nation s health care spending problem, each with its own pros and cons. You may also think of additional strategies not covered in this guide. If you do, please add them to the conversation. Which strategy or combination of strategies do you support and why? A Choicework Discussion Guide from Public Agenda

3 Approach A. Make people take more responsibility for their health and health care. If people took more personal responsibility then health care spending would come down and health outcomes would improve. First, people should take more responsibility for the choices that affect their own and their family s health. Chronic diseases like diabetes are more prevalent than ever, and unhealthy choices like smoking and eating junk food mean people need more medical care. People make bad choices that raise costs for themselves and everyone else. Second, people don t realize how much their health care really costs because they only pay for insurance and insurance pays the doctors. Meanwhile, we are boxed into one size fits all insurance plans by our employers and by Medicare. People do not have the ability to make choices and shop for the best plan at the best price. In sum, health spending would go down if people took more responsibility for the choices that affect their health and were given more freedom to choose the insurance they want. From this perspective, our country can best reduce its health care spending if, People are encouraged to live healthier lifestyles through public education campaigns, taxes on cigarettes and junk food and higher insurance premiums for smokers and others whose choices put their health at risk. Rather than a set insurance plan, people receive a lump sum from their employers (or from Medicare and Medicaid), and they can spend that money on whichever plan best fits their needs in an open health insurance marketplace. Insurance companies offer more plans that cost less but have higher deductibles and copayments so that people become more aware of how much their health care actually costs. Doctors and patients talk about the costs of tests, procedures and medicines so that they can choose the best care at the best price. People who like this approach might say: When people take more responsibility for their health and health care spending, they will make better and less wasteful choices. Because patients will be searching for the most cost effective coverage and treatments, insurance companies, drug companies, doctors and hospitals will reduce their prices to attract a more cost conscious public. People who do not like this approach might say: We don t need a nanny state trying to regulate our private lives. We have the right to eat what we want and to smoke if we want. This will work fine for healthy people with high incomes. But for most people, higher out ofpocket costs mean they might avoid going to the doctor when they need it. A Choicework Discussion Guide from Public Agenda

4 Approach B. Make sure doctors and hospitals work in smart, cost effective ways. Doctors and hospitals today get paid for every test and procedure they do, which leads them to conduct too many tests and prescribe too many pills. This doesn t necessarily make us any healthier but it certainly costs us money. Moreover, doctors often don t work together or communicate as well as they should. Dangerous side effects and re hospitalizations are more likely when no one is in charge, especially for people with chronic conditions who see multiple doctors. Health care costs can best be contained if doctors and hospitals are given incentives and tools to work smarter. From this perspective, our country can best reduce its health care spending if, Government and insurance companies pay primary care doctors, specialists, nurses and pharmacists to work in teams and coordinate care, especially for people with chronic conditions. Health care providers use electronic medical records to avoid repeat testing, conflicting medications and medical errors. Insurance companies, Medicare and Medicaid pay doctors a flat fee for each of their patients instead of paying for each procedure, and also They pay bonuses when patients recover quickly, stay healthy and give doctors high satisfaction ratings. People who like this approach might say: More is not necessarily better. I want my doctor to focus on my health and not view me as a source of income for every little test. I feel safer knowing that a well coordinated team of doctors and nurses is taking care of me. When health care providers work together, they make fewer mistakes. People who do not like this approach might say: What if this new payment system means that doctors earn less money? Will we still be able to attract the best and brightest to become doctors? It will be impossible to change the entire structure of the US health care system fast enough to get the savings we need. What we really need is strict limits on the prices of medical services. A Choicework Discussion Guide from Public Agenda

5 Approach C. Contain health care costs by regulating prices. Health care spending is too high because doctors, hospitals, insurance companies and pharmaceutical companies charge too much money. Medical procedures like lab tests and surgeries not only cost a lot, but prices can be radically different depending on which hospital you go to or which insurance you have. Insurance premiums go up every year to cover those high medical costs. And prescription drugs are much cheaper in other countries. We must regulate prices if we want to cut costs. From this perspective, our country can best reduce its health care spending if, Medicare, Medicaid and private insurers set strict price limits on medical procedures so that participating hospitals and doctors can t charge so much. The federal government limits how much insurance companies can raise premiums each year. The FDA allows generic drugs to come to market sooner and bans pharmaceutical and medical device companies from marketing directly to doctors and patients. The federal government gradually phases out private insurance companies by giving all Americans the option of joining Medicare. People who like this approach might say: If hospitals and pharmaceutical companies didn t charge so much, then insurers wouldn t pass those costs along to us. Individuals don t have the power to negotiate with hospitals and insurance companies. We need the government to keep prices under control. People who do not like this approach might say: This is another example of big government meddling in private markets. This will restrict consumer choice and leave pharmaceutical companies with too little money to invest in research. This is not a long term solution we can t tighten our belts forever. We must do more to prevent disease and restructure the medical system to stop waste and overuse. A Choicework Discussion Guide from Public Agenda

6 The Approaches in Brief Approach A. Give people more responsibility for their health and health care. People are encouraged to live healthier lifestyles through public education campaigns, taxes on cigarettes and junk food and higher insurance premiums for smokers and others whose choices put their health at risk. Rather than a set insurance plan, people receive a lump sum from their employers (or from Medicare and Medicaid), and they can spend that money on whichever plan best fits their needs in an open health insurance marketplace. Insurance companies offer more plans that cost less but have higher deductibles and copayments so that people become more aware of how much their health care actually costs. Government and independent organizations provide clear information about the costs and quality of insurance plans and of local doctors and hospitals so that people can shop around for the coverage and care that s the best value for them. Approach B. Make sure doctors and hospitals work in smart, cost effective ways. Government and insurance companies pay primary care doctors, specialists, nurses and pharmacists to work in teams and coordinate care, especially for people with chronic conditions. Health care providers use electronic medical records to avoid repeat testing, conflicting medications and medical errors. Insurance companies, Medicare and Medicaid pay doctors a flat fee for each of their patients instead of paying for each procedure, and also They pay bonuses when patients recover quickly, stay healthy and give doctors high satisfaction ratings. Approach C. Contain health care costs by regulating prices. Medicare, Medicaid and private insurers set strict price limits on medical procedures so that participating hospitals and doctors can t charge so much. The federal government limits how much insurance companies can raise premiums each year. The FDA allows generic drugs to come to market sooner and bans pharmaceutical and medical device companies from marketing directly to doctors and patients. The federal government gradually phases out private insurance companies by giving all Americans the option of joining Medicare. A Choicework Discussion Guide from Public Agenda

Your Health Insurance: Questions and Answers This simple guide will help you understand how to use and keep your health insurance Meet four people with questions about their health insurance: George is

I Have Health Insurance! Now What? A Guide to Using Your Private Health Insurance Plan Brought to you by: Congratulations on Your New Health Plan! This guide is an overview of private insurance plans and

health insurance Why It s Important & What You Need to Know HEALTH INSURANCE: WHY IT S IMPORTANT & WHAT YOU NEED TO KNOW Worry Less: Protect Your Health and Your Wallet No one plans to get sick or hurt,

health insurance Why It s Important & What You Need to Know If you do not have health insurance: Fixing a broken arm can cost up to $7,500 The average cost of a 3-day hospital stay is around Worry Less:

HELPING SOMEONE CHOOSE A MEDICARE PLAN? MVP IS HERE TO HELP YOU! Y0051_2387 Accepted WHAT YOU NEED TO KNOW ABOUT MEDICARE When you re helping a friend or family member choose a Medicare plan, be sure you

I Have Health Insurance! Now What? A Guide to Using Your Private Health Insurance Plan Brought to you by: Congratulations on Your New Health Plan! This guide is an overview of private insurance plans and

2015 SMALL BUSINESS HEALTH Colorado Small Business Enrollment Guide A BETTER WAY to take care of business Choose BETTER. 31 Important deadline Open enrollment begins on November 15, 2014 for coverage beginning

Response to the New Brunswick Government Consultation on a Prescription Drug Plan for Uninsured New Brunswickers Brief submitted by The New Brunswick Nurses Union April 2012 Background The New Brunswick

Health Care Reform Frequently Asked Questions June 2013 Frequently Asked Questions (FAQs) What is a health insurance marketplace or exchange? A marketplace, or exchange, is a website where you can shop

Health Matters A Guide for Medicare-Eligible Retirees Why am I receiving this booklet? We have decided to offer SelectQuote Senior s insurance exchange. We are committed to helping you make smart choices.

Appendix C: Online Health Care Poll Internet Poll through May 14, 2006 (10,512 responses) 1. How much do you agree or disagree with the following statement about health insurance coverage and public policy

THE FIELD POLL THE INDEPENDENT AND NON-PARTISAN SURVEY OF PUBLIC OPINION ESTABLISHED IN 1947 AS THE CALIFORNIA POLL BY MERVIN FIELD Field Research Corporation 222 Sutter Street, Suite 700 San Francisco,

Obama Administration Record on Health Care Today, two years after we passed health care reform, more young adults have insurance, more seniors are saving money on their prescription drugs, and more Americans

Massachusetts Health Connector logo What Does National Health Care Reform Mean for You? 1 National health care reform offers more opportunities for individuals, families, and small businesses to save on

Patient Education Page 18-1 For a kidney/pancreas transplant Kidney and pancreas transplants are expensive. Planning your finances, both your income and insurance, will be a key part of planning for transplant.

Timeline: Key Feature Implementations of the Affordable Care Act The Affordable Care Act, signed on March 23, 2010, puts in place health insurance reforms that will roll out incrementally over the next

Manage Health care choices and expenses The EmblemHealth Consumer Direct Program 1 Employees can manage their health care expenses today and save for their future. There s an alternative for people who

BARACK OBAMA S PLAN FOR A HEALTHY AMERICA: Lowering health care costs and ensuring affordable, high-quality health care for all The U.S. spends $2 trillion on health care every year, and offers the best

A GUIDE TO UNDERSTANDING, GETTING AND USING HEALTH INSURANCE The of Health Insurance wahealthplanfinder.org 1-855-WAFINDER 1-855-923-4633 HL-14-001 Rev. 08/2015 THE ABC S OF HEALTH INSURANCE: WHY IS HEALTH

A NEWSLETTER CONCERNING COVERAGE AND BENEFITS Second Quarter 2014 Understanding health insurance is confusing enough - - - With the onset of the Affordable Care Act (ACA), it has clouded the issue even

Cigna Medicare Services MEDICARE: You ve earned It. Make the most of it. A simple guide filled with useful information on Medicare, health and wellness and more. Section 1 MEDICARE. PLAIN AND SIMPLE. Section

Molina Marketplace We have a plan to keep you healthy. Access. Quality. Commitment. With the new Health Insurance Marketplace, you have a choice. Molina Healthcare is the answer. Here is why you should

FROM COVERAGE TO CARE A Roadmap to Better Care and a Healthier You Step 7 Decide if the provider is right for you Your ROADMAP to health 2 Understand your health coverage Check with your insurance plan

The Health Care Law and You The health care law enacted in 2010 brings a number of benefits to all Americans, including people over 50. Some of these benefits you can get right now. Others phase in over

Paying for Health Care in Retirement One of the complications in retirement planning is the need to make predictions what will our future living expenses be, and what about inflation rates? A big mistake

Page 1 of 10 Key Features of the Affordable Care Act, By Year On March 23, 2010, President Obama signed the Affordable Care Act. The law puts in place comprehensive health insurance reforms that will roll

Generic and Brand Name Drugs: Understanding the Basics We ve been there. We can help. Joe has just been diagnosed with bipolar disorder. After talking to his doctor, he decides to see a therapist and go

how to choose the health plan that s right for you It s easy to feel a little confused about where to start when choosing a health plan. Some people ask their friends, family, or co-workers for advice.

Roadmap for Medicare Navigating Medicare Part D A guide for seniors and caregivers Roadmap for Medicare: Getting Oriented This Guide offers information and advice for choosing a Medicare Part D prescription

The Young Person s Guide to Health Insurance For Graduating Seniors A message from the WHITE HOUSE Dear Friends: Graduation is a time for you and your family to celebrate your accomplishments, and to think

Neuropathy Action Foundation Awareness Education Empowerment Getting the Medications and Treatments You Need Understanding Your Rights in Arizona As you search for a health insurance plan or coverage for

Molina Marketplace We have a plan to keep you healthy. Access. Quality. Commitment. With the new Health Insurance Marketplace, you have a choice. Molina Healthcare is the answer. Here is why you should

1 Good to Know ColoradoCare Colorado Health Care Cooperative Name Change: The proposal has been renamed ColoradoCare because it is shorter. It s also less likely to be confused with CoHealthOp, the Colorado

Health insurance 101 Know the facts. Knowing the facts can make all the difference when it comes to health insurance. To make the most of new choices, protections and financial help, you need good information.

Understanding Group Health Insurance Anthem KeyCare 15+ Plan January 12, 2010 Although it is the intent of the University to continue current benefit plans, the University reserves the right to modify,

CUT THE COST OF HEALTH INSURANCE FINANCIAL HELP AND NO-COST COVERAGE ARE ON THE WAY FOR MORE OREGONIANS CoverOregon.com 1-855-CoverOR (1-855-268-3767) HAVING HEALTH INSURANCE PROTECTS YOU AND YOUR FAMILY

Annual NEWSletter Important information about authorizations and appeals 2013 A publication of for CHIP and STAR members and their parents. Sometimes the care you get from your doctor needs prior approval.

LIFE HAS OPPORTUNITIES Your guide to finding the best health insurance plan. Start saving today with the help of Excellus BlueCross BlueShield. National strength. Local focus. Individual care. SM Contents

Bargain Medicine: Anatomy of a High Quality Healthcare System, Valiantly Operating with Inadequate Funding, or Socialism in Actions: How to over Promise and Under Deliver ; Mr. Kenneth Abramowitz, Managing

Health Insurance Basics: Key Words and Phrases You Need to Know Shopping for insurance can be confusing, but the Affordable Care Act (ACA) makes it easier to understand. This simple guide will help you

Do you have health insurance? We will help you understand how to get, pay for, and use health insurance This presentation will help you understand how to get health insurance, how to pay for health insurance,

Table Recorder Notes 1. What does acceptable access to primary health care services look like to you? Having acceptable access to family doctor care Having acceptable access to allied care professional

Accessing Health Care Curriculum Introduction The three activities in this curriculum are designed to help students learn 1) the basics about health insurance, 2) how to obtain insurance under the Patient

How the New Health Care Law Benefits You Congress enacted a new health care law which brings a number of benefits to all Americans, including people over 50. Some of these changes you will see this year.

Elephant in the Room A,B,C s of Obama Care What do you need to know? How will it affect you and your family? Confused? What will you learn in this webinar? O What is Obamacare? O What has it done so far?

N A T I O N A L PHYSICIANS A L L I A N C E My name is Dr. Valerie Arkoosh. I am an Anesthesiologist at the University of Pennsylvania School of Medicine and the President of the National Physicians Alliance.

Medigap Insurance Overview A summary of the insurance policies to supplement and fill gaps in Medicare coverage. How to be a smart shopper for Medigap insurance Medigap policies Medigap and Medicare prescription

What is the Affordable Health Care Act (ObamaCare)? Whether you need health coverage or have it already, the health care law offers new rights and protections that make coverage fairer and easier to understand.

Using Your Medicare Drug Plan: What to Do if Your Medicine Isn t Covered SPRING 2009 9 www.yourpharmacybenefit.org Table of Contents How does it work?............................................ 1 When

Insurance how to use health insurance taking charge of your health insurance Now that you have health insurance, you are able to get the health care you need, when you need it. You won t have to wait until

CENTERS FOR MEDICARE & MEDICAID SERVICES Things to Think about when You Compare Medicare Drug Coverage You have two options to get Medicare coverage for your prescription drugs. If you have Original Medicare,

Make your health a top priority. Your guide to the Health Insurance Marketplace ChooseHealthDE.com 24/7 helpline: 1.800.318.2596 TTY: 1.855.889.4325 The deductible was $3,000 less than my previous policy.

For over 30 years now, Design Benefits has had the privilege of helping thousand of clients with their insurance needs. We have a full staff of experienced employee's to assist you with any insurance questions,

The American Healthcare System By David M. Cutler Otto Eckstein Professor of Applied Economics at Harvard University and Member of the Institute of Medicine America is the largest, most diverse society

CENTERS FOR MEDICARE & MEDICAID SERVICES Are You a Hospital Inpatient or Outpatient? If You Have Medicare Ask! Did you know that even if you stay in the hospital overnight, you might still be considered

Is a kidney transplant right for me? Your guide to the transplant process www.esrdncc.org Contents Introduction 3 What is a Transplant Center? 4 What is the Waiting List? 5 What Happens After the Surgery?

Summary of Benefits & Coverage All private health plans must use this standard form. The information is laid out the same for every plan, making it easier for you to compare. Worst-case scenario. Add together

Healthy Michigan MEMBER HANDBOOK 2014 The new name for Healthy 1 TABLE OF CONTENTS WELCOME TO HARBOR HEALTH PLAN.... 2 Who Is Harbor Health Plan?...3 How Do I Reach Member Services?...3 Is There A Website?....

Your guide to UnitedHealthcare Face the future with confidence The benefits environment remains challenging. Uncertainty reigns as a wave of new regulation sweeps across the industry. Costs continue to

2016 GROUP MEDICARE supplement plans Create a Healthier Organization Your employees are your organization s most valuable asset. As they retire, you want to show your commitment to them and manage health

The Healthy Michigan Plan Handbook Introduction The Healthy Michigan Plan is a health care program through the Michigan Department of Community Health (MDCH). Eligibility for this program will be determined

THE 2008 PRESIDENTIAL CANDIDATES ON HEALTH CARE REFORM AUGUST 2007 (UPDATED JUNE 4, 2008) Prepared by: Victoria Craig Bunce, Director of Research and Policy, The Council for Affordable Health Insurance

The Future of Medicare: 15 Proposals You Should Know About Strengthening Medicare AARP s You ve Earned a Say is working to make your voice heard on the future of Medicare. For more than a year, Washington