Various Artists: Black America Sings Sam Cooke (Ace/Border)

Graham Reid | Mar 9, 2015 | 1 min read

Mel Carter: When a Boy Falls in Love

It was perhaps obvious that the on-going series Black America Sings -- which has seen compilations of black artists singing the songbooks of Bob Dylan, Lennon and McCartney, Bacharach and David, and Otis Redding: see here -- would come around to compiling covers of the smoothest and, some might say, the most popular soul singer of them all.

Cooke had an effortless style -- songs like You Send Me, Cupid, Wonderful World and A Change is Gonna Come are pop/soul cornerstones and timeless -- and across the 24 songs here we get mostly respectful treatments of hits and obscurities from Cooke's short but productive career.

Here are Percy Sledge (You Send Me), Otis Redding (Shake), Bobby Womack (I'm Gonna Forget About You), Eddie Floyd (Bring It On Home To Me), the Soul Stirrers in which he was a member and who who were signed to his SAR label (That's Heaven To Me), RB Greaves (Cupid) . . .

All artists you'd be happy to hear anyway, but more so here on this great soul-pop material.

Even so, there are real surprises . . . like Mel Carter whose version of When a Boy Falls in Love (a lyrically dense song that few would dare attempt) and -- because I'd never heard the name before -- I presumed the singer was woman, a soft and smoky style that was redolent of a polite Nina Simone with an orchestrated arrangement by Burt Bacharach.

It's a beautiful song . . . and Mel Carter was a 20-year old guy from Cincinnati, the song with an arrangement Joe Hooven.

Sometimes these days it seems that more music is coming out of the Pacific Northwest than ever did at the height of grunge: the difference being it is quieter, more folksy and singer-songwriterly,... > Read more

These two guitarists are among the best in the wide country/alt.country/roots music arena. The evidence, should you doubt it, is all over this intimate and intelligent collection which opens with a... > Read more

Elsewhere at Elsewhere

The new bio for David Kilgour starts with an arresting claim, "David Kilgour is a guitar god for guitar atheists". The evidence for this is of course his work in the Clean, with his band... > Read more