Brief Synopsis – An outlaw captured in Australia is given a deal by the law; he must kill his notorious older brother otherwise, they will hang his younger brother.

My Take on it – This is a film that I had never even heard of before it was recommended to me and just by seeing the premise, I had high hopes that it would be quite good.

Unfortunately, it’s paced way too slowly and although that is sometimes good with a Western, it wasn’t in this case.

Things feel too drawn out and I believe that had the pace been quickened a bit, it would have been even more enjoyable.

The cast is quite competent here, but I constantly had the feeling that Guy Pierce was terribly cast in the lead role in this film.

He was great in L.A. Confidential (1997) and in Memento (2000) as a sort of anti-hero who we can sympathize with, but here, he plays an extremely ruthless character and IMHO. it just doesn’t fit him well.

I also found it quite strange that this is perceived as a Western , yet takes place in the Outback of Australia. I’m sure that there were Cowboys there, but it just seemed a bit strange to me.

This is quite a violent film, so it isn’t for those without a strong stomach.

All in all, some parts work better than others, but I thought this was a pretty average kinda Western.

Bottom Line – Interesting premise that just doesn’t work as well as I would have hoped. Cast is quite competent, but Pierce isn’t as good playing a ruthless character as he is as an anti-hero. The pace is too slow and I think had it moved a bit quicker, it would have been even more enjoyable. Personally, found it strange having a Western that takes place in the Australian Outback.

MovieRob’s Favorite Trivia – One of the gunmen in the Burns’ fort at the beginning is named “Jack Bradshaw”. Although the movie’s plot was fictitious, there had been a real 19th century Australian “bushranger” (outlaw) by that name. (From IMDB)

Like this:

Related

Search MovieRob

Thanks for watching this Rob! Appreciated. You know, having watched it again last night…as much as I enjoy all the sets, music etc, I do actually think the pace is a tad too slow. While I was watching I was thinking…gosh, did I recommend this to Rob…he may think it booring! 😉

it’s not the worst Ive seen for this series, just struggled thru 2 really bad films this morning… one was horrendous!!!! Cant believe it was recommended to me. I think I’m gonna unfriend the recommender 🙂

This series is all about trial and error. I don’t expect to love or even like all of the suggestions, I just want to try and watch what others perceive as great films that I haven’t yet been exposed to.

And, I really enjoy how “recommender” and “recomendee” don’t always have the same opinion. That’s what makes it so interesting. I also enjoy being “challenged” i.e. hearing your opinion makes me think a bit.
Now you’ve got me all curious about the horrendous film. In a weird way, looking forward to your review…
But, if it makes you feel any better – I watched a horrid one on the weekend – I should have known, IMDB gave it a 3 or so rating but people commented that it wasn’t really that bad….well, trust me, it was worse than bad…so, avoid “Without Men”