Tom Ford noir de noir vs GIT vs Tonka imperiale

Hello guys I'm going to Vegas soon and ill be purchasing 1 cologne that will last very long and project very good . Which of these 3 should I buy ? I haven't smelled any of it yet . But I know I'll end up with creed or tom ford or guerlain . Thanks

Re: Tom Ford noir de noir vs GIT vs Tonka imperiale

They are vastly different fragrances, I agree with Bonoanimoes breakdown though. GIT would be the safe bet but if you're looking for something interesting which people seem to be drawn too I would say Noir de Noir.

Re: Tom Ford noir de noir vs GIT vs Tonka imperiale

3 totally different fragrances...

GIT...a violet heavy aquatic. Safe as everyone said...and somewhat decent. I wouldnt pay retail for it since you can get it for much cheaper.
Noir de Noir...Maybe cause I am middle eastern I dont find it that big of a deal? I mean it's nice, but quite typical where I come from. Still lovely though, also can be bought discounted from ebay.
Tonka Imperiale...Very risky, very thick...I love it myself, but it only smells good in winter, sometimes.

You got a fresh aquatic, a middle eastern floral, and a heavy oriental...all of them are excellent, it's hard to make a choice, it depends on what your collection could use I guess.

Re: Tom Ford noir de noir vs GIT vs Tonka imperiale

Depends on what's lacking in your wardrobe: I would pick GIT if you need a daytime fragrance, NdN if it's a nighttime one you need, and TI as a feelgood comfort scent.

I pretty much agree with this and Bonoanimoes. My personal pick would be Noir de Noir.

You mention that you want something that will last a very long time - neither GIT nor NdN last that long on my skin (~5-7 hours). I've only sampled TI once, and I showered around the 5 hour mark. If strong longevity is an absolute must, I highly recommend you try on skin first or consider alternatives.

Re: Tom Ford noir de noir vs GIT vs Tonka imperiale

Tonka Imperiale by Guerlain - One is initially treated to a dulcet, marzipan-like accord, fashioned from the bittersweet bergamot, the nutty almond, and sweetish honey. Mint-like rosemary, with its faint terpenic aspect, wonderfully tempers the sweet accord. Transitioning to the middle, a billowing tonka bean imparts its spicy vanillic facet to the opening brew. A plume of fruitiness and dimmed smokiness from tabacco as well as a shadow of tutti-frutti jasmine swirl about. A drizzle of delectable heliotrope, with its delicate, caramel sweetness, presents. Segueing to the perfecting base, the tonka bean takes on an amber-like creaminess, and commingles with the balsamic menthol of pine. A fresh and somewhat sweet woodiness from cedar permeates the blend, while resiny, smoky, and slightly sweet incense sparkles here and there. A drydown of epicurean delight ensues. Possessing average projection and longevity, this entrancing, gourmand composition is well-crafted and unisex.

Re: Tom Ford noir de noir vs GIT vs Tonka imperiale

Wow, what a different assortment of choices. I think I'm going to have to go with Noir de Noir followed by Tonka Imperial. GIT is obviously good, but make it special for Vegas! Also, longevity is spotty on me at least. Noir de Noir has a really fantastic boozy rose and almost chocolaty feel to me, soooo soo nice. Tonka Imperial is nice, but doesn't live up to what's been said about it for me, although every time I wear it I absolutely love it.

Re: Tom Ford noir de noir vs GIT vs Tonka imperiale

GIT and TF can be found on stores all over the country, but TI is only sold at a few stores. So whichever you buy, sample TI in Vegas if you haven't smelled it yet. Otherwise it's hard to find outside of NY and Vegas stores.