Williams Tree Farm

Friendly golden retrievers and Bernese mountain dogs welcome visitors to this Rockton, Illinois, farm (15 miles north of Rockford). Clydesdales pull wagons out to the fields, and families pet reindeer on the children's farm. When you want to warm up, the Cabin Cafe serves lunch and the Candy Corner sells fudge near a crackling fireplace. (815) 624-7579; williamstreefarm.com -- Barb Sanford

Dull's Tree Farm

Homesteaded in the mid-1800s, Dull's 25-acre farm in Thorntown, Indiana, celebrates sights, sounds and scents that have defined the holiday for generations. The farm sells six kinds of pine and fir trees, but a visit here also includes slides in the hayloft, the chance to cut your tree if you'd like, handfuls of peanuts, a cozy Wreath Barn for shopping and visits with the family's animals. (765) 325-2418; dullstreefarm.com -- Danny Lee

Kuipers Family Farm

The fresh cider doughnuts at this Maple Park farm alone are worth the 60-mile trip west of Chicago, but most people come to pick out their Christmas tree. On weekends, kids can get pictures with Santa (call to see if he'll be there!), and parents can design gift baskets at the Orchard Shop. (815) 827-5200; kuipersfamilyfarm.com -- Amy Bizzari

Hann's Christmas Farm

Santa and Mrs. Claus pose for pictures at this Oregon, Wisconsin, farm known for its hot cider, fresh popcorn and Holiday Haystack playground (11 miles south of Madison). Check the website for special events such as woodworkers making home decor items, and stop in the Christmas Store for ornaments, candles, tree stands, toppers and more. (608) 835-5464; hannschristmasfarm.com -- Melanie Radzicki McManus

Miller's Christmas Trees

With 38 acres, this Rio, Wisconsin, spot (30 miles north of Madison) is smaller than its competitors, but promises a similar kind of magic. A diorama shows visitors the locations of the Christmas tree groves, ponds and woodlands. Santa listens to kids' wish lists, and a dachshund lords over the gift shop. (608) 206-6239; treerex.com -- Barb Sanford

Anderson Tree Farm

Just outside Plainfield in the southwest suburbs of Chicago, Anderson's has been toting visitors out to fields on a tractor-drawn wagon for more than 40 years. A tiny log cabin decked in twinkle lights greets families who stop to pet ponies in the petting zoo and shop in the store for jewelry, ornaments, and homemade jams and jellies (815) 436-2140; visitandersontreefarm.com -- Karen Sorensen