i swear people at like whedon is aaron sorkin on SHH and goyer apparently is uwe boll

2 hyperbole's

It's not hyperbole to suggest that one is vastly superior to the other in proven talent. No one said Whedon is the greatest writer ever (neither is Aaron Sorkin, for the record), and no one said Goyer is the worst. But to many, the difference between them and their body of work is pretty big and hard to ignore. To put it plainly, one is what I'd consider to be a bad-to-mediocre writer, and one is what I'd consider to be a very good-to-great one. No hyperbole or exaggeration there, just an honest opinion.