Love It or Hate It? Severe Smoky Eyes

How's this for a bold makeup look? French actress Marion Cotillard, who plays Edith Piaf in the upcoming biopic La Vie en Rose, took smoky eyes to a new level at the movie's New York premiere. This certainly isn't everyday eye makeup, but there's something oh-so French about the severe shadow paired with pale lips. What do you think?

As much as I love the smoky eye look, this overpowers her fine features. She looks like she has black eyes. If her makeup artist had simply created the smoky effect from layers of eyeliner and not smoked out her entire eyelid, this look would rock, but alas.

I don't like how they applied the eyeshadow. All they did was smeared it all over the lid and put some under her eyes.
I think this looks so much better: http://fileserver.glam.com/20/24097352-21245440e0f3ebaa43.gif

I don't like how they applied the eyeshadow. All they did was smeared it all over the lid and put some under her eyes.I think this looks so much better: http://fileserver.glam.com/20/24097352-21245440e0f3ebaa43.gif