(07-12-2012 01:07 PM)kingschosen Wrote: Okay, I'll take that it's not metaphysical and that it's a verbal blank, but in the same vein, why is saying "God did it" physical?

It's a metaphysical claim, so it's theology.

Because it makes a claim about a question that exists in the physical world with some interaction with it. If it interacts with and impacts the physical world, then it can be known. No one has yet to show the evidence that it has any real physical world existence, and as such, it is an unnecessary assertion and a baseless claim.