It would be that anonymous Brit at the Manchester Free Trade Hall during Dylan’s 1966 world tour who famously called the singer-songwriter “Judas” right before the newly electric Dylan played a definitely-not-unplugged rendition of “Ballad of a Thin Man.”

Everyone else, perhaps including Judas Iscariot himself, has a preference.

The Salt Lake Tribune asked musicians from all different genres to name their favorite Dylan song or two: