A weblog dedicated to reports, commentary, and debate on current developments and scholarship in the fields of international law and politics.

Saturday, December 10, 2005

El-Baradei Nobel Lecture: Imagine a World

The text of Mohamed El-Baradei's Nobel Peace Prize Lecture is here. It is quite good. It is perhaps too utopian for my taste, but if any group deserves utopian license it is that category of individuals known as Nobel Peace laureates. We may have in El-Baradei a prophet of peace from (and for) the Arab world.

The speech is hopeful, cosmopolitan, poetic, tolerant, demanding, and imaginative. It does not target any one nation (i.e., the United States) for specific criticism. It does not attempt to address current events (i.e., the war in Iraq). Rather, it focuses on the broad sweep: globalization, intolerance, world poverty, and nuclear proliferation. It is far more expansive than you might expect from someone who has spent the last twenty years focused on a single theme. The essence of the speech is a call for the world to address root causes that create human strife. Best of all it uses simple language to convey profound ideas.

Here is the hopeful and eloquent conclusion:

Imagine what would happen if the nations of the world spent as much on development as on building the machines of war. Imagine a world where every human being would live in freedom and dignity. Imagine a world in which we would shed the same tears when a child dies in Darfur or Vancouver. Imagine a world where we would settle our differences through diplomacy and dialogue and not through bombs or bullets. Imagine if the only nuclear weapons remaining were the relics in our museums. Imagine the legacy we could leave to our children. Imagine that such a world is within our grasp.

5 Comments:

I think El Baredei's speech is incredibly bad, and perhaps indicative of why the otherwise highly competent IAEA is so ineffecitve. The argument that poverty breeds conflict is without foundation. India is populous and very poor, but largely peaceful, because it has free institutions and a socio-economic system that allows people to work thinks out without killing each other. Where there is conflict, be it in Israel/Palestine, Chechnya, the Sudan or Congo, it is because of a specific political, tribal or religious system, or in the latter two cases, the lack of any functioning social and political system. In no case is it merely because of poverty.

His argument that we should move toward a world in which no country has nuclear weapons is even worse, because it posits an equivalency between the Free World and authoritarian, terrorist states like Iran. That India has nuclear weapons is by itself a non-issue, except as related to the fact that Pakistan has them, and that is a great danger, should Islamists ever take over. But if the U.S. were to relinquish its nuclear weapons, then the entire world could be held hostage by a single nuclear rogue.

A WOLF who had a bone stuck in his throat hired dragonnest gold a Crane, for a large sum, to put her head into his mouth and draw out the bone. When the Crane had dragon nest gold extracted the bone and demanded the promised payment, the Wolf, grinning and grinding his teeth, exclaimed: "Why, you have surely already had a sufficient dragonnest gold recompense, in having been permitted to draw out your head in safety from the mouth and jaws of a wolf." In serving the wicked, expect no reward, and be thankful if you escape injury for your pains.

EVERY object in the next day's journey was new and eq2 plat interesting to Elizabeth; and her spirits were in a state for enjoyment; for she had seen her sister looking so well as to banish all fear for her health, and the prospect of her northern tour was a constant source of delight. When they eq2 gold left the high-road for the lane to Hunsford, every eye was in search of the Parsonage, and every turning expected to bring it in view. The palings of Rosings Park was their boundary on one side. Elizabeth smiled at the eve isk recollection of all that she had heard of its inhabitants.