After I dug deep into the recesses of Facebook I found a post featuring...

Top 5 Albums in May 2009:

Underoath - Define The Great Line

August Burns Red - Messengers

Blindside - A Thought Crushed My Mind

He Is Legend - I Am Hollywood

Poison the Well - Versions

It's good to see a lot of overlap between the lists with a 3-year split between them. I identified a lot of powerful, genre-defining albums and they have been no less amazing as time goes on which speaks volumes about the bands' abilities.