Editorial: Minimum imbalance

The reference was buried deep in a closing communiqué after the Council of Atlantic Premiers met last month in Halifax.

It was in the third-last paragraph of the two-page news release detailing joint efforts to expand the regional economy, create jobs and streamline regulatory co-operation.

It has premiers finally acknowledging the elephant in the room — major increases to minimum wages in Ontario, Alberta, British Columbia and other provinces. Many of them will reach $15 an hour in early 2019.

The four Atlantic premiers agreed “to explore opportunities to align minimum wage rates in the region” and to attain predictability and consistency throughout Atlantic Canada.

Will a $15 minimum wage attract even more Atlantic Canadian workers to Ontario or Alberta? To keep workers here, will businesses be forced to pay substantially higher wages?

Last year, there was considerable angst in the Atlantic business community over minimal increases.

P.E.I. now has the highest minimum wage rate at $11.25 an hour, followed by New Brunswick and Newfoundland and Labrador at $11. Nova Scotia has the lowest wage — $10.35 for inexperienced workers and $10.85 for experienced workers.

A valid complaint of businesses has been unexpected increases to the minimum wage. They must budget for it, and that’s a lesson Atlantic premiers seem finally to have learned. There is a commitment in the Maritimes to adjust minimum wages once a year on April 1, generally tied to the consumer price index; and the four Atlantic provinces are exploring opportunities to align rates.

Ontario’s minimum wage leapt to $14 this month, creating turmoil in the fast-food industry, with some employers reducing employees’ benefits and eliminating break times to cover the cost of the increases.

The reaction to that was swift. Ontario Premier Kathleen Wynne called those employers bullies, and consumer boycotts in support of workers forced some employers to back down.

Polls indicate a majority of Ontario residents support the minimum wage increases, and a surprising number of businesses have embraced the higher wage levels as well. They feel if they can retain an experienced workforce, then paying a higher wage is an acceptable cost of doing business.

The premiers have found a key ally in the Atlantic Provinces Economic Council (APEC), which has endorsed the concept of predictability and consistency in setting minimum wages.

Last week APEC released a report card that echoed the council of premiers’ views.

Atlantic alignment would require that P.E.I. hold or slow its rate increases, while other provinces, especially Nova Scotia, catch up. That prospect has already drawn the ire of a P.E.I. anti-poverty group, which says Island workers would suffer from such an agreement. P.E.I. has always felt it must pay a higher minimum wage rate to retain workers, especially in fisheries and agricultural industries.

Atlantic premiers had better fast-track a regional strategy to assist both workers and employers amid this growing minimum wage imbalance threat from other regions of the country.