How to improve domain reputation for better email deliverability

Ashley HarppJune 21st2018

The goal of any email is to reach the inbox. But that doesn’t always happen and there are many factors that can affect deliverability. Most issues are a result of problems in at least one of the following areas:

Infrastructure

Sending practices

Content

If you’re sending through Postmark, we take care of the infrastructure for you. We do this by keeping our IPs clean, throttling our sending rate to ISPs, and properly managing bounce and spam complaints. We also encourage customers to setup DKIM and a custom return-path to be complaint with DMARC. But there are things that an ESP doesn’t have control over that can affect deliverability.

In this guide we’ll discuss the following topics:

How domain reputation affects deliverability.

What can influence your domain reputation.

What can be done to maintain or improve your reputation.

Domain reputation webinar

Learn how domain reputation affects deliverability, what factors influence domain reputation, and what can be done to maintain or improve your domain reputation.

Domain reputation is a lot like the reputation we build as people. It’s affected by what you’ve done in the past and who you’re associated with.

Poor-reputation IPs you’ve been associated with or a slip-up sending to the wrong recipient affect how ISPs see you, but there’s always a way to redeem yourself.Unlike IP reputation, your domain reputation is portable. That means you could add new IPs, you could move IPs, you could send mail from different systems, even different ESPs – and you’d still enjoy the benefits of your good reputation. But if your domain reputation is low you’re at a higher risk of having your emails classified as spam.

The good reputation of your domain increases the deliverability of your emails.

That’s why it’s important to check it regularly and fix all issues that may weaken it before you start any proactive outreach. But what all can influence your domain reputation? Let’s first discuss two things can impact your domain reputation — IP reputation and content.

IP reputation and domain reputation are two different concepts but they can affect each other. Let’s imagine you’re sending from an IP that has a low reputation. All emails sent from that server will be at risk of not being delivered because of the low reputation of that IP. But if you start sending from another IP that has a high reputation, then the chances of that email reaching the inbox improves.

To be clear, we aren’t implying that sending from IPs with a high reputation do not impact deliverability. But if your domain reputation is low then having a high IP reputation won’t be of much help. IP reputation and domain reputation are two interdependent concepts that affect each other. We’ll share a few deliverability tools towards to the end of this guide. But for now its important to understand the following points:

IP reputation is tied to the specific server you’re sending from. You can send from a dedicated IP or a shared IP. Read our post on the false promises of dedicated IPs here.

Content not only plays a role in whether or not an email gets delivered to the spam folder, but it also can affect your domain reputation. Transactional emails can be flagged as spam as a result of their content.For example, emails that are flagged as spam may have lots of exclamation marks or attention getting subject lines that make ISPs suspicious. Here are a few helpful resources that can help improve the content on your emails.

If a person wants to know their reputation they ask credible sources around them. Similarly, to understand your domain reputation you have to go to reliable sources. Here are a few tools you can use to find your IP reputation.

Gmail’s reputation scores are broken out by both domain and IP address. It assigns a reputation score of Bad, Low, Medium, or High.

Bad — A history of sending an enormously high volume of spam. Mail coming from this entity will almost always be rejected at SMTP or marked as spam.

Low - Known to send a considerable volume of spam regularly, and mail from this sender will likely be marked as spam.

Medium/Fair — Known to send good mail, but is prone to sending a low volume of spam intermittently. Most of the email from this entity will have a fair deliverability rate, except when there is a notable increase in spam levels.

High — Has a good track record of a very low spam rate, and complies with Gmail's sender guidelines. Mail will rarely be marked by the spam filter.

Senderscore is a service that measures your domain reputation and offers suggestions on how to improve it. It is derived from a proprietary Return Path algorithm, and represents an IP address’s overall performance against metrics important to both ISPs and their customers who receive your email.

Use Senderscore to learn your reputation

You can pull Sender Score metrics for your domain that’ll include details such as:

Another reputation service that provides a score of Good, Neutral, or Poor. Senderbase provides additional data on email volume and volume history.

Use Senderbase to learn your reputation

Senderbase data results for the domain

You can search by IP, domain, or network owner for real time data. In this example, we’re searching for data specific to the example.com. The Reputation Details section includes data about the content your host on your website, which may be of higher or lower reputation in relation to your email.

The best email indicators will be at the bottom under Additional Information.

Additional information shows the top addresses used to send emails for your domain

The Email Reputation column refers to IPs sending on behalf of the domain. This will let you know if there have been any issues. Keep in mind, Talos may not show any data if you don’t send enough volume.

If your domain reputation is low and you’ve had it for some time, you may want to find out if its been blacklisted by any ISPs. MXtoolbox is a great reference for these scenarios. They have a domain health check that executes hundreds of performance tests to make sure all of your systems are online and performing optimally. The report will then return results for your domain and highlight critical problem areas for your domain that need to be resolved.

Domain reputation is something you can only earn over time. It can’t be built overnight and it isn’t derived from a single email going to spam or the inbox. It’s based on the consistency of your messages and all the other contributing factors we discussed earlier. All of these pieces collectively paint a picture of your domain to ISPs. Whether your domain is new and has no reputation or has existed for a while with a low reputation—there are a few things to keep in mind when building your reputation:

Warming up your domain is just as important as warming up your IP. This is because most ISPs are shifting to use domain reputation for most filtering decisions. But how do get ISPs to trust you when you don’t have a history of sending email? No history means no reputation and there’s no reason to trust your emails ISPs don’t know what to expect from you. What can you do?

If you’re working with a new domain start by sending small amounts of messages to your most engaged recipients. This high engagement percentage builds your domain reputation much more quickly, allowing you to later send more messages that are less engaged without much penalty. You want to have a consistent process so that ISPs don’t become suspicious and flag your domain.

When you registered your domain you were likely asked to classify it to a specific industry. It’s important that the types of emails you send are consistent with the industry you selected.

For example, if your business is classified under the dating category but you’re sending emails related to computer software, then that would be inconsistent with the selected domain type. As a result, ISPs may flag your domain.

Email consent is another aspect of domain classification that can’t be overlooked. If someone signs up to hear about events at local bars and restaurants, but later you send them a message selling wines and beer gadgets, you've lost that consent. Your described industry and content is so important and if you need to expand or change what you offer, make sure your domain registration and customer subscriber permission is updated.

When it comes to email deliverability, subdomains carry a lot of weight. Using a subdomain rather than your company’s top-level domain will provide easier reputation tracking because its separate from other domains and subdomains being used within your company.

Let’s suppose that someone in your company sends an email campaign that contains broken links. These messages generate a lot of spam complaints and your ISP flags your top level domain. Now all emails sent from your company domain will be affected. This is a huge problem that could have been controlled by using subdomains.

With that said, using subdomains can affect the main registered domain's reputation. But the advantage is that subdomains can only affect each other indirectly.

For example, let's say that you send messages using the subdomains notify.example.com and newsletter.example.com. If you make a mistake with your newsletter and ruin the reputation of newsletter.example.com, you can expect to see some kind of dip in the reputation for example.com as well.

By sending transactional mail over notify.example.com, however, it won't suffer a reputation hit at the same rate. It's only able to be affected indirectly by the smaller reputation hit to the main registered domain.

Because they affect each other indirectly, this means that in many cases subdomains can have wildly varying reputations, which is often vital for protecting your most important mail streams.

As we discussed earlier, there are many factors that contribute to domain reputation. Our goal is to make sure your most important emails are reaching the inbox and build your domain reputation in the process. We do this by keeping our IPs clean and encouraging domain authentication with DKIM and Return Path.

DMARC weekly digest

We encourage all to setup DMARC to not only improve deliverability but also improve your domain reputation.Our DMARC weekly digest is a free tool you can use to monitor and implement DMARC. We process reports from major ISPs about your domain's DMARC alignment and send these details to you every Monday for free.

Sign up for Postmark DMARC weekly digest to monitor your domains

High reputation IPs

Postmark can also help improve your domain reputation because all of our IPs maintain a high reputation. This can affect your domain reputation in a positive way. Postmark customers generally see much better deliverability on our shared pool than on a dedicated IP.

That’s because a high-quality shared pool means mistakes you might make are padded from affecting deliverability. While a dedicated IP is extremely sensitive to errors in sending or in your list, it can only have a reputation as good as your own sending practices alone.

Monitoring your domain health isn’t just a one time ordeal. It’s an ongoing process that requires consistent nurturing.