Pulling the tablecloth out from under essential metabolism

Because plants can't get up and run away, they've had to be clever instead. They are the chemists of the living world, producing hundreds of thousands of small molecules that they use as sunscreens, to poison plant eaters, to scent the air, to color flowers, and for much other secret vegetative business.

Historically these chemicals, called "secondary metabolites," have been distinguished from "primary metabolites," which are the building blocks of proteins, fats, sugars and DNA. Secondary metabolites smooth the way in life but the primary metabolites are essential, and the failure to make them correctly and efficiently is fatal.

Secondary metabolism is thought to have evolved to help plant ancestors deal with living on dry land rather than the more hospitable oceans. The idea is that the genes for enzymes in the molecular assembly lines of primary metabolism were duplicated. The duplicates were more tolerant of mutations that might have destabilized the primary pathways because the originals were still on the job. With evolutionary constraints thus relaxed, synthetic machinery was able to accumulate enough mutations to do new chemistry.

Primary metabolism, however, is widely conserved, meaning that it remains unchanged across many different groups of organisms because it has been fine tuned to operate correctly and efficiently and because its products are necessary for life. Or so the textbooks say.

But now a collaborative team of scientists has caught primary metabolism in the act of evolving. In a comprehensive study of a primary-metabolism assembly line in plants, they discovered a key enzyme evolving from a canonical form possessed by most plants, through noncanonical forms in tomatoes, to a switch-hitting form found in peanuts, and finally committing to the novel form in some strains of soybeans.

This feat, comparable to pulling the tablecloth out from under the dishes without any breaking any of them, is described in the June 26 issue of Nature Chemical Biology. It is the work of a collaboration between the Maeda lab at the University of Wisconsin, which has a longstanding interest in this biochemical pathway, and the Jez lab at Washington University in St. Louis, which crystallized the soybean enzyme to reveal how nature changed how the protein works .

"The work captures plants in the process of building a pathway that links the primary to the secondary metabolism," said Joseph Jez, the Howard Hughes Medical Institute Professor in the Department of Biology in Arts & Sciences. "We're finally seeing how evolution creates the machinery to make new molecules."

It may also have practical importance because the old and the new pathways make the amino acid tyrosine, which is a precursor for many secondary metabolites with biological and pharmaceutical activity-- everything from vitamin E to opioids. But the old pathway makes only tiny amounts of these compounds, in part because they must compete for carbon atoms with the greedy process for making lignin, the tough polymers that let plants stand tall.

The discovery of the new pathway for making tyrosine is much less constrained than the old one. This raises the possibility that carbon flow could be directed away from lignin, increasing the yields of drugs or nutrients to levels that would allow them to be produced in commercial quantities.

A tale of two enzymes

Tyrosine is made on an assembly line called the shikimate pathway, a seven-step metabolic pathway that plants use to make the three amino acids that have aromatic rings. Animals (including people) shed the ability to erect this assembly line deep in the evolutionary past. Because we cannot make these amino acids on our own and they are essential for life, we must instead obtain them by eating plants or fungi.

That aromatic ring is important, said Jez, because it is a distinctive structure that can absorb light or energy. So the aromatic amino acids also are the precursors for many secondary metabolites that capture light, transfer electrons, or color flowers. Moreover, the aromatic amino acids are also precursors for chemicals that poison other plants or plant predators and attract pollinators. Many medicinal drugs include an aromatic ring, Jez commented.

In most plants the shikimate pathway is in the chloroplast, the organelle that does the work of converting the energy of sunlight to energy stored in carbon bonds. Once made, however, tyrosine can be exported out of the cytosol for incorporation or conversion into other compounds.

In the last step of one branch of the pathway an enzyme called arogenate dehydrogenase (ADH), catalyzes a reaction that makes the compound arogenate into tyrosine. The ADH enzyme is considered "regulatory" because it is a bottleneck in tyrosine production. It must compete for the arogenate substrate with the branch of the shikimate pathway that makes a different aromatic amino acid and it is strongly inhibited by the buildup of tyrosine

ADH activity is common in plants, but in the course of studying the shikimate pathway the Maeda lab discovered that the DNA sequences coding for ADH in some flowering plants were significantly different from those in most plants. They called the enzymes produced by these sequences noncanonical ADH. Then, in 2014, they reported that some legumes also make tyrosine with a different enzyme, called prephenate dehydrogenase (PDH).

PDH differs from ADH in many ways. It is active outside the chloroplast, it acts on the substrate prephenate rather than on arogenate, because it is outside the chloroplast it does not have to compete for its substrate with other branches of the shikimate pathway, and it is not inhibited by rising levels of tyrosine.

Why are there two different assembly lines for tyrosine? The scientists believe the PDH enzyme evolved via two gene duplication events and the accumulation of mutations in the "extra" copies of the gene. The first event gave rise to nonstandard ADHs in some flowering plants and the second to PDH in a subset of legumes. But why did this happen?

That's not a question the scientists can answer yet except in general terms, Jez said. What sticks out, however, is that the more recently evolved metabolic pathway is not tightly regulated and could potentially churn out product at a hectic pace. Perhaps the legumes were in dire need of secondary metabolites for some reason. It is certainly suspicious that legumes have an ecology quite different from that of other plants, since they live symbiotically with nitrogen-fixing bacteria.

Fiddling the bits

By this point the scientists knew that the novel enzyme, PDH, bound a different substrate than the original enzyme, ADH. They also knew that PDH, unlike ADH, did not bind tyrosine itself. But what changes in structure led to these differences in chemical activity?

To find out, Craig Schenck, a graduate student in the Maeda lab, compared the gene sequences for the ADH or PDH enzyme in many different plants, carefully chosen to be on the boundaries of the switchover from one enzyme to the other. But they encountered a problem. There were enough differences in the DNA that it was difficult to see what was relevant, Jez said.

Encountering Maeda at a conference, Jez offered to try crystallizing the novel enzymes so that their structure could be reconstructed from X-ray images. His graduate student Cynthia Holland was able to crystallize the soybean PDH and produce detailed images of its three-dimensional shape.

"Once you looked at the structure you could see that there were only two differences from the typical ADH found in most plants and only one of the differences actually changed things," Jez said. Stunningly that difference was a single amino acid in the active site on the enzyme. At that spot the asparagine had replaced aspartic acid.

Schenck double-checked this structural insight by flipping that amino acid in mutant forms of the enzyme. The ADH mutant turned out to have PDH activity, and the PDH mutant had ADH activity, just as the team had suspected.

"That one difference changes the enzyme's preferred substrate and its ability to be inhibited by tyrosine feedback," Jez said. "And if you look at it, it's literally the difference between a nitrogen atom or an oxygen atom. In these proteins, which are made up of nearly three hundred amino acids or forty-two hundred atoms, one atom makes all the difference. That's just kind of cool."

The work is important because it demonstrates that primary metabolism does evolve. And because it shows how nature steals machinery from primary metabolism and cobbles it together for making novel secondary metabolites. They do this with much more finesse than genetic engineers can yet manage.

"When we want a plant to make a new molecule," Jez said, "we drop in a gene and hope it integrates with existing pathways. We still don't know how to readily connect the wiring between what we drop in and what is already there. So it is interesting to see how nature contrived to connect the wiring and change things without breaking them."

-end-

This work was supported by National Science Foundation grants IOS-1354971 and MCB-1614539. Cynthia Holland was supported by the NSF Graduate Research Fellowship Program (DGE-1143954).

Diverse natural fatty acids follow 'Golden Mean'Bioinformatics scientists at Friedrich Schiller University in Jena (Germany) have discovered that the number of theoretically possible fatty acids with the same chain length but different structures can be determined with the aid of the famous Fibonacci sequence.

Amino acid biochemistry and nutrition spans a broad range of fields including biochemistry, metabolism, physiology, immunology, reproduction, pathology, and cell biology. In the last half-century, there have been many conceptual and technical advancements, from analysis of amino acids by high-performance liquid chromatography and mass spectrometry to molecular cloning of transporters for amino acids and small peptides. Amino Acids: Biochemistry and Nutrition presents comprehensive coverage of these scientific developments, providing a useful reference for students and researchers in... View Details

Now available for the first time on Kindle, the world's leading PhD expert on Amino Acid nutrition shares this comprehensive look into exciting new field of Amino Acid Nutrition! Dietary Essential Amino Acids (EAAs) are the fundamental building blocks of life as we know it. EAAs are the “active” components of dietary protein and as such are the only macronutrients required for survival, yet the benefits of optimal EAA nutrition are generally underappreciated. In this groundbreaking new book Dr. Wolfe shares the secrets to losing weight, correcting metabolic imbalances and enhancing... View Details

In recent years, organo-fluorine chemistry has made a marked impact on the design and synthesis of a large variety of biologically active molecules, such as steroids, carbohydrates, amines, amino acids, peptides and other natural products. Naturally occurring amino acids play a pivotal role in living systems, and therefore synthetic fluorine-containing amino acids have been of significant interest to researchers working towards the understanding and modification of physiological processes. Fluorine-containing Amino Acids: * is the first volume devoted to the synthesis and properties of... View Details

Current research is revealing new therapeutic potential in the use of amino acids supplements - with effects ranging from pain relief to appetite modification and mood alteration - and over the next few years such names as ornithine and phenylalanine may be as common as Vitamin C or zinc are to us now. This book explains what amino acids are, what they can do, and how to use them for maximum effect. View Details

Use protein power to detoxify, improve your memory, fight pollution, stress and fatigue, high blood pressure and low sex drive. Plus important new information for athletes. Protein is one of our most basic needs, but research into how its building blocks, the amino acids, can be combined to assist health is only just beginning. One of Britain's most respected nutrition writers brings you a complete update on the amino acids, how the body uses them, and their many effects on health. Read about Military research on aminos as a treatment for stress Which aminos are vital for detoxification... View Details

Have you wondered if you might be deficient in one or more of the amino acids? Are you on a low protein or vegetarian diet? If so, combining different foods is essential for health and energy. Do you have questions about what else the amino acids can do for you? Look no farther than this book, a nutritional guide. 22 amino acids are listed, with fascinating histories, glands affected, plus complementary vitamins and minerals that will enhance the action. SAF practitioners use the amino acids to help their clients to sharpen their mental images; this is essential to self awareness work.... View Details

Best Science Podcasts 2018

We have hand picked the best science podcasts for 2018. Sit back and enjoy new science podcasts updated daily from your favorite science news services and scientists.

Inspire To ActionWhat motivates us to take up a cause, follow a leader, or create change? This hour, TED speakers explore stories of inspirational leadership, and what makes some movements more successful than others. Guests include high school history teacher Diane Wolk-Rogers, writer and behavioral researcher Simon Sinek, 2016 Icelandic presidential candidate Halla TÃ³masdÃ³ttir, professor of leadership Jochen Menges, and writer and activist Naomi Klein.

#474 Appearance MattersThis week we talk about appearance, bodies, and body image. Why does what we look like affect our headspace so much? And how do we even begin to research a topic as personal and subjective as body image? To try and find out, we speak with some of the researchers at the Centre for Appearance Research (CAR) at the University of the West of England in Bristol. Psychology Professor Phillippa Diedrichs walks us through body image research, what we know so far, and how we know what we know. Professor of Appearance and Health Psychology Diana Harcourt talks about visible...