The Jan. 24th episode (9/8c, The CW) will find Catherine recovering from the car accident that landed her in the hospital on the midseason finale. When Vincent sneaks in a visit, he's caught by Alex, who works at the hospital — and who thought Vincent was dead! Awkward

In our exclusive first look at the episode below, it seems Vincent has a lot of explaining to do with both women. "This is a big juicy obstacle in Vincent and Cat's way," executive producer Sherri Cooper previously told us.