Wonderful comforter!
I did much research before purchasing this comforter and it was definitely worth every penny! Warm enough for me, not too hot for my husband. Lightweight and fluffy. I trust Garnet Hill products and have never been disappointed.
December 4, 2014

Soft, comfortable, breathable
Bought this duvet on sale and used it for the first time last night. Pros: soft, comfortable, breathable, pretty. Cons: stitching was already coming out in places after one use.
October 29, 2014

Nice lightweight comforter
I purchased this comforter for my daughter's room and it's perfect. Other comforters I considered did not have 100% cotton covers (this one does) and were bulky and/or heavy. This one is lightweight, yet provides warmth, and fits into our comforter cover just right. Think we'll enjoy it for years to come.
August 26, 2014

Goldilocks Approved
"Just right" amount of cozy and comfy. Light weight by itself and easy to cover with a duvet for added warmth. I like the poly-fiber-fill.
June 2, 2014

Warm and Cozy!
I love this comforter! It is warm and squishy. Its great to sleep under and nice to lounge on top of too. It has corner ties to hold your cover in place. (A few ties along the edges of the comforter and cover too would be a great thing to have too.) There are no stray feathers to deal with and no sneezing either!
March 12, 2014

Soft, light and warm - great value!
Purchased this comforter after dealing for years with an older comforter constantly shedding feathers. This one is almost as light weight as the down and just as warm - a winner.
February 11, 2014

Product Q&A

Ask your questions. Share your answers.

I recently bought a down-alternative comforter from a different company & it is noisy/crinkly, even after washing. I am hoping to find a quiet comforter for my daughter. Would you consider this comforter quiet or noisy?

Interesting question! I have also bought a down-alternative comforter elsewhere, and found the cover material accumulated, and retained, an unacceptable level of wrinkling; and I remember that I could hear it making a sort of scratchy sound when the material was moved around-- weird. We returned that comforter without ever sleeping under it.We've been sleeping under our Garnet Hill down-alternative comforter for a month or two now. Its fabric cover is made of pretty heavy cloth, and there's some sound when we turn over or throw the covers aside to get up. The sound isn't at all 'crinkly;' it's more like the sound from a clean, heavy cotton sheet, such as you might find in a good hotel. To me, it's a very luxurious, comforting sound, part of the comfortable sounds of snuggling down into the bed clothes before going to sleep.I hope this is helpful to you.

Answers

Answer:

They are very similar. The biggest differences are the shell which 18283 is Combed Cotton & 24408 is Cotton Cambric (they will feel a little different). The fill which 18283 is Primaloft and 24408 is Polyester, the sizes have a slight difference, and the ounces of fill which 24408 has a little more. Both comforters will be great for year round use.