James Peaslee, 37, of Easton (center), who is accused of killing 79-year-old Paul Hilenski of Bridgewater, made his initial court appearance via video from the Aroostook County Jail in Houlton on Friday morning. The hearing was held before Justice Harold Stewart, who was presiding from the Superior Court in Caribou. Flanking Peaslee are attorneys for the day Robert Ward, left, and Jeff Pickering. (File photo | Chris Bouchard)

James Peaslee, 37, of Easton (center), who is accused of killing 79-year-old Paul Hilenski of Bridgewater, made his initial court appearance via video from the Aroostook County Jail in Houlton on Friday morning. The hearing was held before Justice Harold Stewart, who was presiding from the Superior Court in Caribou. Flanking Peaslee are attorneys for the day Robert Ward, left, and Jeff Pickering. (File photo | Chris Bouchard)

The 38-year-old is accused of killing Hilenski Sr. in January 2018, at Hilenski’s Boundary Line Road home.

The state contended that multiple security videos taken from the home of 79-year-old Hilenski Sr. depict Peaslee committing the killing.

Peaslee was indicted on charges of murder and using a firearm to intentionally or knowingly cause the death of Hilenski. He pleaded not guilty and is being represented in Aroostook County Superior Court in Houlton by attorneys Stephen Smith and John Tebbets. Testimony began on Thursday afternoon after a jury was seated before Superior Court Justice Harold Stewart II.

Assistant Attorneys General Leanne Robbin and Robert “Bud” Ellis contend that Peaslee was furious over a probate decision involving the estate of his mother, Janet Hilenski.

On Monday morning, the court heard testimony from Matthew Clark, who is currently incarcerated at the Aroostook County Jail on charges of theft, burglary and receiving stolen property. He told the court that he had known Peaslee for approximately 20 years after they met in a Houlton High School shop class.

When both were incarcerated, he said, Peaslee told him that he had gone to the Mars Hill One Stop in the hours before the killing to “establish an alibi,” change into different clothes, and then go to the victim’s house. Peaslee was pictured on the store’s security cameras in the hours before the killing.

“He said he went up to the door in ‘military mode,’ knocked on the door and shot him,” he said of the killing. “He told me, ‘you should have seen that old bastard run.’”

At that point, Peaslee launched to his feet and angrily pounded on the defense table.

“Stop lying!” he shouted at Clark. “It’s ignorant!”

Stewart cleared the courtroom and met with the attorneys. Smith asked for a mistrial, but the motion was denied.

Clark later said that Peaslee told him he headed to Limestone after the killing, tossed the gun into a forest, and put the clothes back on he was wearing at the Mars Hill One Stop.

“He wiped down his right hand with bleach in case they did a gunshot residue test,” he added.

Smith sought to paint Clark as a man who was only testifying in court in the hopes of receiving a lesser sentence in his upcoming court case. Clark denied this, saying he was looking to “do the right thing.”

The defense has questioned several witnesses about Peaslee’s resemblance to his brother, George Peaslee, since the start of the trial. George Peaslee did not testify, nor was any picture of him shown in court.

State Police Detective Lawrence Anderson said that George Peaslee was questioned at the State Police barracks the day after the killing. He said that George Peaslee had a mustache and “noticeably longer facial hair” than the man he identified as James Peaslee in Hilenski Sr.’s security video of the shooting. He said that James Peaslee had a “strong five o’ clock shadow” in the video, but did not have long facial hair.

An interior video showed the victim going to answer the door and being fired at. He is then shown reaching for a landline phone in the kitchen, sitting down in a chair, and quickly thereafter falling to the floor and dying.

Gloria Dewitt, Peaslee’s stepmother, also testified. She said that she felt the individual pictured in the shooting video looked “a lot thinner than my son [James] ever did.”

Taking the stand again, State Police Detective Lawrence Anderson testified that Dewitt had been shown the shooting video 14 months after the killing. He said that she “became teary eyed and said that she thought the person in the video was who we thought it was, which was James Peaslee.”

The defense called two witnesses to the stand Monday, including Walter Dewitt, Peaslee’s father. In contentious testimony, he told Ellis that he felt that law enforcement was “out to get” his son and that he didn’t think it was him in the shooting video. Ellis got him to acknowledge, however, that when first shown the video by police, all he would say was that he had “no comment” on it. He acknowledged during testimony that he didn’t deny that his son was pictured on the video.

Jurors will be handed the case tomorrow after closing arguments.

Get the Rest of the Story

Thank you for reading your 4 free articles this month. To continue
reading, and support local, rural journalism, please subscribe.