The Not-So-Magic Mirror first appeared in "Mirror, Mirror". Grim Gloom purchased the mirror for Hildy Gloom to be declared the fairest of them all, but the Not-So-Magic Mirror doesn't gave her that recognition. So Grim kidnaps Queen Delightful's Magic Mirror and placed the Not-So-Magic Mirror on the Magic Mirror's wall. After The 7D recovered the Magic Mirror at the Glooms' manor, the Magic Mirror and the Not-So-Magic Mirror fell in love and then soon began dating.