Do you think that is a good price? Does the M Sport package really hold the value of the car? What is the difference between Sport Package veras M Sport Package? I don't think the M Sport Aerodynamic kit is same as the M3 kit right? I have no experience on M-series, so please forgive me if I am asking here.

I think m sport package is the same only difference is the m bumper upgrade... As for price that a decent price but private sales you should get it check out and see if there any existing warranty that that private seller can transfer...I would give 28 flat

Thanks so much for your reply. Do you guys think $28K flat is reasonable? I completely agree that without CPO, the car is really not worth for $28K. But he is asking for $33500 initially. Guess like i need to keep looking...

Here's the wholesale value of the car. If it was mine I'd want at least $26,000 for it in a private party sale in order to cover my time and aggravation. An owner asking or expecting anything above $28,000 is pipe dreaming IMO:

It is very hard to find a Manual transmission. The other bad news is that the seller is not willing to sell less than $31,500. =(

Keep looking because this particular seller is completely unreasonable about the car's price. He's probably hoping to get what he owes on the car rather than what it's worth. I doubt a BMW dealer would try asking much more than $30,000 for that car as a CPO.