Best Remake

OK, let's try the flip side of these "worst" threads. What remake completely owned the original?

I think John Carpenter's The Thing was so much better than the original it's ridiculous. I was terrified when I saw the remake, but when I was shown the original with Marshall Matt Dillon as the freakish carrot from outer space, I laughed.

Best Remake would have to be ... The Shining.
The first one with Jack Nicholson was a travesty.
The second one was more along the lines of the book.
C'mon, it's supposed to be scary. The first one was more funny than scary. Any producer that would make a movie that would kill off Scatman Carruthers ought to be .... something bad done to them. hahhah Can't even think of anything bad enough to do to the producers of the original Shining.

I actually preferred the original "Imitation of Life." Also, I didn't really like the fact that in the remake they had a white person play the daughter, whereas they used a light-skinned "Black" person in the original...

I see what you mean. What I liked about the second was that I got to see more of the conflict and turmoil the daughter went through and her pain at the end. I like that actress. The only other movie I remember her from was from "Dino" (nothing to do with the Flinstones); it starred Sal Mineo as the conflicted youth-as usual.

Originally posted by miamomma Best Remake would have to be ... The Shining.
The first one with Jack Nicholson was a travesty.
The second one was more along the lines of the book.
C'mon, it's supposed to be scary. The first one was more funny than scary. Any producer that would make a movie that would kill off Scatman Carruthers ought to be .... something bad done to them. hahhah Can't even think of anything bad enough to do to the producers of the original Shining.