Cutting the Longline to Extinction

By Dr. Robert Ovetz

Chanting "Get on the right track stop killing the
leatherback!," a festive protest by people of many ages dressed in
colorful turtle costumes wound its way along the busy streets of San
Francisco's Fishermen's Wharf. The October 2003 demonstration marked
the debut of the Sea Turtle Restoration Project's "Save the
Leatherback" campaign for a moratorium on longline fishing in the
Pacific Ocean. Longline fishing in the Pacific kills tens of
thousands of sea turtles annually to serve up swordfish, shark and
tuna for lucrative seafood markets in Japan, the US and Europe.

Longlines, composed of invisible monofilament lines up to 60
miles long and annually float billions of hooks in the Pacific alone,
are the greatest threat to sea turtles, maiming and killing as many
as 40,000 nesting females each year. Having once swum with the
dinosaurs, the more than 100 million [years] old leatherback
now hangs by a thread at the threshold of extinction. Because
leatherbacks feed on jellyfish near the ocean surface, they are
extremely vulnerable to swordfish and tuna longlining. The rapid
growth of longlining during the past 20 years has coincided with a
95% drop in estimated nestings by leatherback females. Longline
fishing in the Pacific annually maims and kills an additional 4
million sharks, whales, dolphins, seals, sea birds and porpoises and
is wiping out some of our swordfish and tuna fisheries.

The campaign to save the leatherback is at the heart of a
concerted international effort to end the lawless pillaging of the
oceans and needless slaughter of millions of marine species such as
the Pacific leatherback by industrial fishing, while also sounding
the alarm about the threat of methyl mercury poisoning to people who
eat swordfish, shark, tuna and other predatory fish.

The Sea Turtle Restoration Project is undertaking a broad array
of initiatives to try to arrest the decline of leatherbacks,
including direct action, strategic legal action, advocating for a
United Nations moratorium on Pacific longlining, a national media
campaign, and educating seafood consumers about the risk of mercury
poisoning.

STRP achieved its first significant victory when the Red Lobster
chain dropped swordfish from the menus of its approximately 500
restaurants in response to a year-long petition drive. We are using
this momentum to pressure other high-profile swordfish sellers
through the threat of a lawsuit against the Safeway, Kroger's,
Albertson's and Whole Foods supermarket conglomerates.

In November 2002, STRP teamed up with the San Francisco-based As
You Sow Foundation to conduct laboratory tests of swordfish sold by
the five chains. When the results showed mercury levels at up to
twice the exposure threshold recommend by the US Food and Drug
Administration, we filed a notice of intent to sue the supermarkets
and Red Lobster under a 1986 California "right to know" law which
requires the posting of public warnings about toxic materials in
food.

With this evidence in hand, the California Attorney's General
office filed the lawsuit itself in February 2003. An interim legal
agreement among the parties stipulates that stores must post signs
warning of the dangers of consuming seafood containing methyl
mercury, especially swordfish, shark, tuna, king mackerel and
tilefish.

During the October 2003 National Fisheries Institute's conference
and International West Coast Seafood Show in Long Beach, California,
Sea Turtle Restoration Project activists confronted swordfish dealers
who had refused requests to drop the fish from their inventories,
hung door hangers reading "Do Not Disturb the Oceans" throughout the
five largest hotels where conference and seafood show guests were
staying, and unfurled a massive banner reading "Swordfishing Kills
Sea Turtles" at both the start of the Long Beach Marathon and the
exclusive sea food show opening night gala on the Queen Mary cruise
ship.

The longliners have a lot to fear from a campaign for a
moratorium. A 1999 lawsuit filed by the Sea Turtle Restoration
Project and Earthjustice closed two million square miles of
territorial waters around Hawaii to swordfish longliners. When about
three dozen Hawaiian longliners relocated to California waters to
exploit a loophole in the ruling by US District Judge David Ezra, we
responded with another lawsuit seeking an injunction to stop
longlining once and for all. When Rep. Duncan Hunter (R-Calif.) a few
weeks later introduced a bill to ban longlines in California waters,
the issue suddenly no longer seemed to be a strictly partisan contest
of "industry vs. environment."

In fall 2003, the Pacific Fishery Management Council, responsible
for managing west coast fisheries, submitted a Fishery Management
Plan guided by the precautionary principle. At the heart of the plan
is a ban on swordfish and tuna fishing in Pacific territorial waters
stretching 200 miles.

The international character of the ocean crisis caused by
industrial fishing requires international action. The United Nations
is expected to increasingly discuss ocean conservation in 2004,
starting with a resolution condemning shark finning and the reduction
of bycatch which passed in November 2003. We'll need more than talk
if we are to save our oceans. It is critical that the UN implement a
moratorium on longlining in the Pacific modeled after the 1992
driftnet moratorium if we are to stop the slaughter and save the
ancient leatherback sea turtle.

Dr. Robert Ovetz is a Marine Species Campaigner with the Sea
Turtle Restoration Project and is on the graduate faculty of the New
College of California in San Francisco. Email robert@seaturtles.org.
The STRP petition calling for a UN moratorium on longlining, signed
by 24 international ocean groups, is posted at www.seaturtles.org.
Visit STRP's "Save the Leatherback" campaign at
www.savetheleatherback.com.