Why does Dave produce Caramel and not chocolate like Dade? This is the reason:

There are different subspecies of what are known as the Confectionary Men. These are humans whose livers produce a confectionery substance. The two known ones ones are chocolate and caramel. There also is sugar, though Sugar Men only produce powdered sugar. Other possible subspecies are butterscotch and cream, among others.

It is possibly for one to be able to produce more than one confectionary, though this is not common.

Some of these can be classified as Bald. Otherwise that part of the name is dropped. Confectionary Men can also be Lycra, like Black Friend, who is both Lycra and a Chocolate Man. He would thus be called a Chocolate Lycra.

Also, Confectionary Men can be women. It is more common for them to be men, so in general they are called “Confectionary Men”. If one is a woman, they specifically would be “Confectionary Women”.

All Confectionary Men are human. What sets them apart is their different function of the liver. The reason why there liver acts this way is because they possess a certain number more chromosomes than the normal human, though the specific number is not known yet. The differences in these extra chromosomes account for the different confectionaries they produce.

On the "WORST FILM EVER" video, where we discover that Dade's liver failed, there is a part that says that there are only 2 "Bald Chocolate Man" in the whole universe. Dave spits caramel in the teasers, but eats FRUT SNEKS. So we have the similarity of the FRUT SNEKS, but the difference in the liquid they spit. Bald Chocolate Men in FF lore, we have Dade and Bade, obviously, so if Dave ever becomes a Bald Chocolate Man, he must become either Dade, or Bade. Or maybe, if Bald Internet Man is after the FF lore, he would be the third Bald Chocolate Man. Now I will try to discover if Bald Internet Man is before FF, or after FF, if it is even related to FF.

I was the leader and creator of the religion based around Filthy Frank. I spent almost the entirety of 2016-2017 formulating lore. I was also featured in the Vox video about Filthy Frank. Here is a brief summary of My version of the lore of Dade:

Dade was first found by Frank alongside Black Friend and Hurshees Kisses, all of which have the unique blessing of throwing up chocolate. Dade became a favorite friend of Frank.

Dade traveled to a far off realm to find butter, because butter helps his chocolate secretion. This is where Safari Man found him. But Dade ended up ingesting too much butter, causing his liver to fail. He began to puke blood. Safari Man took Dade to Franks apartment and laid him in the bathtub. Frank proceeded to search everywhere for a way to help Dade. But Dade ended up dying in the bathtub with Pink Guy by his side.

When Dade died in the bathtub, he ascended to the Spirit Realm where the Shaman lived. He went there because the Shaman had placed his hand on Dades head when he tried to heal him. So Dade was in realm 3, having a glorious afterlife of fruit snacks. But Frank went to get him to help, because Bade, his evil brother, was taking over. Dade had to choose between his fruit snacks or saving his friend. He ended up choosing his friend and killed Bade. But he slipped and fell. I don’t know whether he died again or not, but I do know that he returned to Realm 3.

That is Dade’s story from the FF lore. Parts of this aren’t canon but have been my theories and my own personal lore after much study. Perhaps this could be useful in determining what’s going on with Dave and this new channel.