Well it is song for John. Lyrics should be most important (atleast for this one, even if you are not lyrics person.). I dont like George's , Elton John's is great also. But of course it is your opinion and i am ok with that.

I've never really liked this song. It just doesn't hit the spot. I always think of this song as a strong that's straining to be good and not making it. It also feels a bit flat and well it just doesn't really have any inspiration in it or not enough to make it a truly good song never mind great. it's alright and moves me but yeah it'st just a bit flat. I don't listen to Tug and didn't even install E&I on my itunes. I've got a playlist of the Tug songs which I love. It's one of my fav. playlists.This song isn't on it.

It's one of the weaker tracks on Tug Of War as far as I'm concerned but hey - that's not too bad when you consider how high the bar was generally set by that superb album (Paul's best in my opinion).

I like the song more now than I used to, I think hearing the live version(s) where Paul chokes up slightly before regaining his composure is very moving. Tracks that could be sickly or sentimental in the hands of a lesser artist were often saved by Paul because he's so genuine. And there's no doubt that this one comes straight from the heart.