I didnt choose P3ST (or any other silent tyres) because I drive on all types of roads very frequently. So soft tyres wasn't a choice for me at all. Based on reviews for all-weather tyre tests, I have purchased Continental ContiMaxContact MC5. Its been driven for 14K KMs so far on really very bad patches, harsh summer (45+ degrees in Nagpur) and heavy monsoon (last week). I am satisfied with its dry/wet grip and lesser noise.