The Starlite Drive-In was opened prior to 1953. It was operated by Robert & Richard Hayman, who by 1955 also operated the Falls Autovue Drive-In in Niagara Falls. It was later operated by the Cataract Theatre Corporation who had taken over the Boulevard Drive-In and the Falls Auto View Drive-In, along with the Strand Theatre, Cataract Theatre and Rapids Theatre which were all in Niagara County.

The Site of the Starlite Drive-In is now the parking lot for Wegmans grocery store.