They’re classes, i.e. reference types. This means they must be allocated on the heap, and garbage collected when they’re no longer used. For applications where performance is critical, it can be an issue. Also, the fact that they can be null is often not desirable.

The elements in the tuple don’t have names, or rather, they always have the same names (Item1,Item2, etc), which are not meaningful at all. The Tuple<T1, T2> type conveys no information about what the tuple actually represents, which makes it a poor choice in public APIs.

In C# 7, a new feature will be introduced to improve support for tuples: you will be able to declare tuples types “inline”, a little like anonymous types, except that they’re not limited to the current method. Using this new feature, the code above becomes much cleaner:

Note how the return type of the Tally method is declared, and how the result is used. This is much better! The tuple elements now have significant names, and the syntax is nicer too. The feature relies on a new ValueTuple<T1, T2> structure, which means it doesn’t involve a heap allocation.

You can try this feature right now in Visual Studio 15 Preview 3. However, the ValueTuple<T1, T2> type is not (yet) part of the .NET Framework; to get this example to work, you’ll need to reference the System.ValueTuple NuGet package.

Finally, one last remark about the names of tuple members: like many other language features, they’re just syntactic sugar. In the compiled code, the tuple members are only referred to as Item1 and Item2, not count and sum. The Tally method above actually returns a ValueTuple<int, double>, not a specially generated type. Note that the compiler that ships with VS 15 Preview 3 emits no metadata about the names of the tuple members. This part of the feature is not yet implemented, but should be included in the final version. This means that in the meantime, you can’t use tuples across assemblies (well, you can, but you will lose the member names and will have to use Item1 and Item2 to refer to the tuple members).