astrosfanatic commented 1366 days ago
I would keep Cano in that case. Premium position, contract year, most consistent of those 3.

skyflame21 (Poll Creator) commented 1367 days ago
I meant these are the top 3 that will be in draft. The others are already kept. Our keeper style league allows 3 years of keeper options on players after the year in which they are drafted and the 3 years have been used, the player must return to the draft. Max of 8 players can be kept. You forfeit the round in which the player was drafted to keep the player. Example, I drafted Trout in the 18th round last year. So I can forfeit my 18th round pick and keep Trout, which obviously I did. Kemp, McCutchen and Cano are the best 3 on the board returning to the draft.