Gamebook store

Friday, 29 May 2015

Designer genes

The author Conn Iggulden (who incidentally has written about the creative benefits of role-playing, but that’s a detail) was talking recently about the effects being able to buy genetic upgrades for your children.

I'd be happy allowing parents to buy mutations: say, height, to pass on forever. All would benefit in the end.
http://t.co/aAmoieeweV

Let’s not oversimplify. (I’ll get this out of the way first.) Genes don’t code for attributes directly, they code for structure. And the genome is a big mess of software patches going back millions of years, so typically it’s not easy to point to one gene and say it does X and X only. Even so, my family has some genetic kinks I’d like ironed out. Migraines. Sinus trouble. Short sight. Wonky knees. If it doesn’t mean turning into the Brundlefly, I’d pay for some changes there.

Some people have reacted by saying, “Oh great. So the rich will buy genes that give them a competitive advantage.” And my first thought was, sure, all genes that are worth keeping must give you a competitive advantage. Actually getting in there and tweaking them could get us out of a saddle point on Mount Improbable. So – other than the qubit-melting complexity of the entire interdependent H. sap genetic program – where’s the harm?

But on second thoughts, consider the Klingons. They’ll fight at the drop of a pin, and prehistoric Klingons must have been even worse. In the course of ordinary evolution, presumably a mutation arose that made early Klingons slightly less aggressive. Thus a family of brothers and sisters with that trait cooperated and thrived. And so the gene spread to other families within the village, then the tribe, then the entire Klingon race.

The point is that the cooperative trait I’m describing is an advantage in situations which allow a win-win solution – that is, where everybody does better by cooperating than by competing. Reverting to the real world and guessing now: maybe conditions in the Ice Age were so perilous that the human race had to become less selfish in order to survive. Thus we modern humans are able to understand a concept like pooling our resources via taxation in order to create a more comfortable society than we could enjoy if we were all living like backwoods survivalists.

But what if you were a Klingon buying a trait rather than having it sprung on your bloodline by mutation? Now there isn’t much point in buying the cooperation gene. (Yeah, yeah – see oversimplification disclaimer above). Little Worf is going to do much better in life if you make him more grasping and combative. Screw those jerks who’d share a fish they caught, right?

A common misunderstanding of Richard Dawkins’s selfish gene concept is that it must imply a selfish organism. How can we have altruism? Simple. If the world doesn’t consist solely of zero-sum games, the problems the genes are trying to solve will sometimes throw up cooperative solutions and hence social animals. Sadly, in the case of humanity, we could add: just social enough for the circumstances of a hunter-gather community of a few hundred individuals. Yet we are a species so in thrall to amour-propre that most of us would opt for being higher status than our neighbour even if that meant dragging everybody’s living standards down including our own.

And that’s the best we’ve got from evolution, which can chug on trying to find a joined-up solution. Biohacking is a whole other environment, one that doesn’t have to see problems in aggregate. There, you start by wanting your son to be a couple of inches taller than the other fellow, and next thing you know it’s the towers of San Gimignano all over again.

Long-time readers of this blog will know that I’m an evangelist for the post-human future. We’re not going to inherit the cosmos with monkey brains, and once Man 2.0 is out there among the stars, the old primates can grow their hair long again – and spiny, and blue, and luminous, or whatever they like. But in the meantime, let’s try not to allow rivalrous gene wars to pull us off into a future of futile hardwired fashion accessories.

2 comments:

Ah, but it was a misguided attempt at genetic manipulation that flattened out the Klingons' foreheads, back when Scott Bakula was captain of the Enterprise. Even the first Klingons Kirk met had those. It took until Star Trek: The Motion Picture (and its unprecedented budget, in Star Trek terms) for the Klingons to regain the Cornish pasty foreheads we all know and love. When it comes to genetic meddling, let that be a lesson to all of us.

What? You haven't seen season 4 of Star Trek: Enterprise? You really should watch more television.

Excuse me, this is a trite response to a very profound post. I just can't resist a bit of Star Trek trivia...

Search This Blog

This month's pageviews

Featured post

I intended to put this up to commemorate the start of the Interregnum (and also the anniversary of the Beatles’ last public performance , o...

Followers

Dragon Warriors

New revised & expanded edition of the classic British RPG. Available in hardcover, paperback and as a free PDF version.

The Empire of the Petal Throne

Tekumel is a world in the distant future, isolated from the rest of the galaxy by a spacetime catastrophe. Civilizations have risen and fallen over the millennia. Ancient technology is regarded as magic. Engineered species and automata are seen as demons.

You have come upon the fabled lands

Dave Morris and Jamie Thomson have created an exotic gaming world with hundreds of quests, locations and choices. This is your gateway to the Fabled Lands.

As well as our classic gamebooks and role-playing games such as Dragon Warriors, we talk about our current projects: the epic fantasy comic book Mirabilis, the Roald Dahl Prize winning Dark Lord: The Early Years, an interactive literary take on Frankenstein, and new novels, apps and games that you'll hear about here first.

Follow us on Twitter

HEART OF ICE

Are you ruthless enough to seize the ultimate power? The classic SF adventure of greed, alliance and betrayal in a new revised edition. Just click on the picture.

The Frankenstein Wars

What does war become, when death is not the end?

DOWN AMONG THE DEAD MEN

A prophecy of your own death at the hands of a pirate as black-hearted as the devil himself. A crew of bloodthirsty dogs who would cut your throat for a doubloon. And high seas adventure with magic, mystery and the undead. NOW AN INKLE APP!

The Keep of the Lich Lord

A classic Fighting Fantasy Gamebook now fully rebooted as an adventure in the Fabled Lands

The Serpent King's Domain

Demo by Paul Gresty of the long-awaited Fabled Lands book 7

BLOOD SWORD IS BACK!

The True Magi are planning to return from exile among the stars to enslave mankind. It's a time in need of heroes. The gamebook saga for solo or multiplay, back in a brand-new large format edition.

ONCE UPON A TIME IN ARABIA

Enter a magical world of lost palaces, uncharted islands and haunted deserts. Do battle with bandits, fire wizards, ghouls and djinn. For this is the land of the Thousand and One Nights, where even a beggar might rise to save a kingdom.

Fabled Lands Publishing UK

Our UK bookstore. Click/tap on the masthead banner if you're looking for US links.

FRANKENSTEIN

A new kind of interactive novel. Be the voice of Victor's conscience - or goad him to ever greater heights of hubris. Available in the App Store now.

Sparta Sourcebook

A guide to Sparta in the year 485 BC, as the threat of attack by the Persian Empire grows daily. Includes city map with key features.

Enter the Mayan underworld!

Mayan myth comes to life in interactive revenge saga. App by Cubus Games for iOS and Android.

Critical IF Gamebooks

Classic interactive stories in a new collectible edition. Click on the picture for more info.

Peter Andrew Jones Art Studio

Books, cards, calendars and posters by the legendary fantasy artist.

80 Days

Multi-episode open-world next-gen gamebook from the creator of Samsara and the coders of Frankenstein.

Avenger returns!

The classic '80s gamebook series in a brand-new revised paperback edition.

NECKLACE OF SKULLS

Through trackless forest thick as night, across burning plains, even into the depths of the underworld, your quest for vengeance takes you to the gates of death in a mythic struggle against the demon who slew your twin.

JAMIETHOMSON.COM

The horror... The horror...

Starship Captain

The hilarious new sci-fi series by the author of the Dirk Lloyd books. Now on sale.

Fabled Lands Book 5 now on Amazon

Assassination, adventure and intrigue in the Court of Hidden Faces - on sale now!

Fabled Lands Book 6 now on Amazon

Tension between Sovereign and Shogun threatens Akatsurai with civil war

Roald Dahl Prize 2012

The lord of all evil is trapped on Earth in the body of a 13-year-old kid. Brilliant comedy adventure by Jamie Thomson.