The Giants will pick second or third in the 2018 NFL Draft. Our experts’ take on whom they might pick:

BOB GLAUBER

JOSH ROSEN, QB, UCLA

If Sam Darnold is available, fine. But if he goes before the Giants pick, Rosen is a terrific choice. He has the “wow” factor, and with Eli Manning turning 37 on Wednesday, it’s time to find his heir apparent.

Nick Klopsis

JOSH ROSEN, QB, UCLA

The Giants must find their heir apparent to Eli Manning regardless of whether Manning returns. Rosen has an excellent arm, can make any throw and has a knack for comebacks, which might remind Giants fans of Manning. But while Eli is a quiet leader, Rosen’s outspoken personality could come across as brash.

Tom Rock

Subscribe to Sports Now newsletter

The Giants have not had a game-changing every-down running back since Tiki Barber, and they have a chance to grab one in Barkley. Are there other needs? Sure. But if Eli Manning is back for 2018 and new GM Dave Gettleman is able to rebuild the offensive line through free agency, adding Barkley could change the entire dynamic of the offense. Fans want to grab a potential franchise quarterback with a high pick, but each year has a crop of one or two hot prospects who fit that mold . . . and most don’t work out. A generational running back is a rarity and should not be skipped over.