Exclusive: Bizarre ice cream fight derails Billy and Susie

Billy and Susie had finally reached an uneasy truce after a heated argument during their homestay and were working on establishing a “sorta, kinda” friendship.

Until it all fell apart when the two had an enormous fight about ice cream.

Using their exclusive Diary Cams, Billy and Susie revealed exactly what went down during their dessert debate. Watch the video above for a full explanation.

They admitted their tiff on the Commitment Ceremony couch. And while the group laughed at the seemingly insignificant issue, Billy and Susie were both staunch in their opinion that they were right.

Despite the argument Susie elected to stay and have Billy get a taste of her home life.

However, Billy wanted out. Watch the video below to find out why.

It's just the latest in a series of small arguments that have derailed the couple's progress.

“The small things that you sweat about – that you get upset about – are ridiculous,” Billy said, frustrated. “You can just smash me – it hurts. I walked away from there and I was in tears.”

One of their major arguments was about sweetener. Susie asked Billy if he had some in the cupboard, he assured her he did. When checking, he did not.

Susie was baffled as to why Billy would say he had sweetener when he didn’t. Billy shrugged it off as, he thought he did, but turns out he didn’t. For Susie, who appreciates facts only, the suggestion there might be sweetener when Billy knew there wouldn’t be, was the equivalent of a blatant lie. And Susie does not like liars.

Billy at first protested that his roommate generally uses sweetener and he presumed there would be some in the house… but eventually conceded that was a mistruth. A little white lie, if you will. Susie doesn’t believe in little white lies – they’re black in her book. A big black mark.

Next on the scoreboard was surfing. The pair went first went surfing on their honeymoon, as shown in this exclusive clip. To make up for his rusty efforts, Billy faffed a little on the exact dates of when he last paddled out.

The next time they went in the water for a wave, Billy forgot about that furphy and mentioned the specific time he last went surfing. Susie, who deals with facts, was furious. She called him out on the lie and was extremely frustrated with what she saw as repetitive behaviour – constant massaging of the truth.

Susie couldn’t understand why Billy couldn’t just say it how it is. Billy couldn’t see the drama with looking at life through rose coloured glasses and occasionally being loose with the truth – especially when it wasn’t hurting anyone. Well, anyone who didn’t love sweetener, that is.

In Pictures

Susie and Billy's Wedding Album

Our groom is 'smitten', but time will tell whether he'll be able to capture the heart of his independent bride.