If this is your first visit, be sure to
check out the FAQ by clicking the
link above. You may have to register
before you can post: click the register link above to proceed. To start viewing messages,
select the forum that you want to visit from the selection below.

I never tried 4th or 5th gen pokémon games (don't have the right consoles for them), but I think that 1st 3 gens were fairly similar in terms of difficulty. I remember the 1st gen team rocket building in Saffron City with all the rocket guys, which was a total maze with all the teleporting panels. I got stuck in there so long. Or the cave with Articuno in it (forgot the name), which was also a true maze where you needed strength to push all the rocks and change the water flow. In terms of being mazes 1st gen was brutal. 2nd gen was a bit better, although the caves with Lugia in it where still a maze (though you didn't need to go there to reach E40. And 2nd gen also had those dreaded puzzles for the unown. 3rd gen didn't really have any mazes as far as I recall, everything was quite straigthforward. Finding the Regi's without looking up a help site took some clever observing though, and the Feebas mechanic is still the most sadistic thing ever put in a pokémon game. The E4 was quite easy for me because you have Kyogre there and Kyogre just blasts them away without any training. It's Ice beam obliterates Drake whilst its Hydro Pump obliterated Steven. I guess if you have Ruby that could be slightly harder, although I think that Groudon can also destroy Stevens steel types with ease. Just EQ and Fire Blast spam. In Emerald Wallace can be a pain, his Milotic keeps on recovering and his Double Team Ludicolo can be really annoying. My Sceptile had some trouble against Wallace due to the good Sp.Def stats of his pokémon. Gyarados, Milotic, Ludicolo, Tentacruel, a lot of good Sp.Def stats there to take Leaf Blade, and loads of them know Ice Beam.

Last edited by Sceptile Leaf Blade; 16th September 2012 at 4:00 PM.

Master balls are the cheapest thing ever invented. It's more fun catching everything with balls that can fail. 'caught Latios in the wild without master ball ftw'

I think it actually depends which gen. you play first which determines this.. for example, if you play gen. 4 before 3, when you do play 3, there are less items, less moves, attacks and special attacks are based on type, etc.
On the other hand, if you played 1 and 2 first, you have more moves, items, pokemon, and natures.
Depends how you look on it, really.

Precisely which is why you have people saying they were harder than the 4/5th gen but easier then the 1/2nd gen. (then again is wasn't until the 4th gen came in which you see decent bug/fighting moves which was a pain for heracross).

I think 2nd gen was the hardest, since it extended a long way and if you wanted to switch pokes after the e4, it would take a loooooooong time to grind your way up their.

The hardest pokemon game is Yellow, no contest. The interface was so much clunkier than the GBA games, you couldn't see how much damage your moves did, Mt Moon is a ***** the first time through and so are the Rocket HQs, the battles were alot harder, and there is soooo much grinding. Beating Brock with a pikachu definitely isn't easy. And I'll never forget that empty feeling I would get after I had been playing for hours without saving and dropped my Gameboy Color and the game would freeze or the batteries would fall out. :'( Still one of the best games ever though.

Gen 3 was much harder than Gen 5 and Gen 4, but waaaaaaaaaaay easier than Gen 1 and Gen 2. Mystery Dungeon was the hardest though.

All the other kids with the pumped up kicks you better run, better run...
If you want to see my Event Pokemon, PM me

If you believe in Jesus Christ put this in your profile and don't just ignore this, because in the Bible it says,
If you deny me, I will deny you in front of my Father at the gates of Heaven.
† I am a Christian and proud of it! Copy and paste this if you are too.†

I would have to say that I thought sapphire was harder than blue (says the man who is stuck in mewtwo's cave on blue, but has completed sapphire) I found the battles and training a lot more of a challenge than in the previous games, I also found gen 4 pretty easy, although it could just be I had gotten better at the games, and I'm currently doing quite well in black (only marginally harder than platinum imo)

Spoiler:- games I want:

PM me if you know the where abouts or cost of any of these items, or if you are selling them on ebay
[] pokemon green (Japanese one or if in english, a rom dumped on a fake cart)
[] any fake pokemon game (PM me the name first)
[] any fake snes pokemon game (pal region)
[] lsd (the ps1 game not the drug)
[] mother3 (japanese)
[] mother3 (english) (didn't have a pal release, it will be a patched rom on a fake cart)

This. The main reason I beleive games are easier for me now is I understand the mechanics. Before in the old GBA games I would use tackle on everything because I thought it was good. I didn't understand STAB boosts and I would just use my most powerful move on every pokemon I faced even if it resisted it. I thought every move that didn't do damage was a waste so most of my mon's had 3 moves of the same type and one garbage one xD. This is why I htink the GBA games were harder at least for me personally.

Exactly, I remember my Dragonite having Surf. I taught everything Surf back then...

I definitely found Generations 4 and 5 to be the hardest. My reasoning is that those were the first gens that enemy movesets seemed genuinely thought out. Gens 1-3 were easy in that when you fight a dark gym leader/E4 member you use your fighter and it's cake. In gens 4 and 5 there was a better chance the enemy would have a psychic move or two on their dark Pokemon so that you'd have to think and plan a little bit more. The gen 4 and 5 E4 was awesome because every member was like this. You could no longer slap ice beam on your water starter and expect to sweep the dragon guy.