The single-camera comedy follows the relationship of a young couple, Andrew and Zelda, from meet-cute to breakup. Milioti will play Zelda, a lawyer at a small, public advocacy firm who is the "realist" in the relationship. Hilarious yet serious, Zelda loves being an adult and doesn't understand why anyone over the age of 20 would want to see an animated movie or eat ice cream sundaes. She doesn't believe in fate, instead Zelda believes she holds the keys to her own destiny.