The United Grand Lodge of England will this year celebrate
the bicentenary of the Union between the Ancients and the Moderns Grand Lodges
in 1813. The Union was formally celebrated on 27 December, in accordance with
Article I of the Articles of Union, which states:

I. There shall be, from and
after the day of the festival of Saint John the Evangelist next ensuing (i.e.
27 December 1813) a full, perfect and perpetual union of and between the two
Fraternities of Free and Accepted Masons of England . . . represented in one
Grand Lodge, to be solemnly formed, constituted and held, on the said day . . .
''

The word ‘celebrated’ needs emphasising. The Union had in
fact been ‘consummated’, so to speak, on 25 November and ‘ratified’ and
confirmed on 1 December 1813. These three key dates have caused some confusion
among historians, made worse by the loss of two documents, one of which has
since been retrieved and which are the subject of this article.

On 25 November 1813, the Grand Masters of both Grand
Lodge, the two Royal brothers, the Duke of Sussex and the Duke of Kent,
representing the Moderns and the Antients respectively and their commissioners,
six in total, met at Kensington Palace for the sole purpose of signing the two
identical manuscript original Articles of Union, one for each Grand Lodge. The
original document belonging to the Antients is extant in the Library and Museum
of Freemasonry in London. It is 205mm wide and 324mm in height, consisting of a
total of 10 pages with text on both sides of each page and the last three sides
left blank. They are signed on page 7, each signatory’s wax seal added, under
the legend: 'Done at the Palace of Kensington, this 25th Day of November, in the
year of our Lord 1813, and of Masonry, 5813', as follows: on the left hand side
for the Antients -

Edward G.M. (H R H Edward, Duke
of Kent & Strathearn)

Thos Harper D G M (Thomas
Harper Deputy Grand Master)

Ja Perry P.D.G.M. (James Perry
Past Deputy Grand Master) and

Jas Agar P D G M (James Agar
Past Deputy Grand Master)

and on the right side, for the Moderns (or Premier) Grand
Lodge, additional four signatures:

Although the Duke of Kent was only Grand Master Elect at
this time, it would have been felt that he was qualified to sign the document as
‘Edward G.M.’. Each Grand Lodge retained their copy of the original signed and
sealed Articles of Union.

Two particularly significant alterations,
among a few minor ones, were made to Article II on these documents. They are
revealed in Companion Douglas Burford’s 1993 Royal Arch Batham Lecture ‘The
Anomalies of the Royal Arch - Craft Connection’: the words ‘four degrees’ were
altered to read ‘three degrees’ and the words ‘Supreme Degree’ in the next line
were altered to read ‘Supreme Order’. The indirect consequence of these changes
is that these same original documents had to be ‘ratified’ by each Grand Lodge
and this was done separately at the ‘Especial Grand Lodge’ meetings, which
followed the Duke of Kent’s installation and sumptuous dinner on 1 December.

The requirement for such ratification was
also incorporated in the first paragraph of Clause IX of the Articles of Union
which read:

IX. The United Grand Lodge
being now constituted, the first proceeding

after solemn prayer shall be to
read and proclaim the act of Union, as

previously executed and sealed with the
great seals of the two Grand Lodges;

after which the same shall solemnly
accepted by the members present.

(The second paragraph of Article IX does not appear to have been complied with
and is outside the scope of this brief article). Thus the 1st December meeting
was to fulfil a pre-determined requirement of the Articles of Union. As
incredulous as it may sound, late at night after a long day’s ceremonies and
lots of food and drink, the Moderns retired to reassemble at Freemasons’ Hall
and the Antients remained at the Crown and Anchor Tavern and they each opened
their respective 'Especial Grand Lodges'. Here the Articles of Union were
ratified and also confirmed with a second signature of each Grand Master
applying his Grand Lodge’s seal. The almost identical ceremonies took place in
totally separate locations more or less simultaneously, when each Grand Master
acted on behalf of his own Grand Lodge. The added text under which each of the
Grand Masters signed, reads: 'In Grand Lodge this first day of December A.D.
1813, Ratified and Confirmed, and the seal of the Grand Lodge affixed'.

Thus at this stage of events, on 1 December 1813, the two
copies of the Articles of Union are signed and sealed, ratified and confirmed
and seals of the two Grand Lodges applied, legally binding the parties to the
Union. Fait accompli. As mentioned, this original document of the
Articles of Union belonging to the Antients is extant. The Moderns’ (or Premier)
Grand Lodge’s version is missing.

It was now time to prepare for the Grand
Assembly of Freemasons celebrations on 27 December, as required by Article I of
the Articles of Union. Among these preparations a decision was taken to produce
two larger and engrossed manuscript facsimile copies of the original Articles of
Union, one for each Grand Lodge, with a view of their being ceremonially carried
into Grand Lodge and signed during the proceedings of 27 December. Both copies
of these facsimiles survive and are housed in the archives of the Library and
Museum of Freemasonry in London. They are larger than the originals, measuring
300mm x 420mm and elaborate and attractive, with part of the title on the first
page highlighted in gold. The corrections to Article II have been incorporated,
although clearly these facsimile copies have no legal value or standing. They
are not original documents and cannot change the status of the Union already
achieved on 1 December nor can they add anything to the agreement of the Union.
As facsimile copies of the Articles, they include both date-legends that appear
on the original, namely: 'Done at the Palace of Kensington, this 25th Day of
November, in the year of our Lord 1813, and of Masonry, 5813' and : 'In Grand
Lodge this first day of December A.D. 1813, Ratified and Confirmed, and the seal
of the Grand Lodge affixed'.

The facsimiles, when presented to the
two Grand Masters preceding the 27 December ceremonies, were blank without
signatures or seals. As recorded in the proceedings describing the procession
into the Grand Hall, each of the two Grand Masters was laden 'with the Act of
Union, in duplicate' i.e. one for each Grand Master. They are now signed by the
two Grand Masters and their respective Grand Secretaries below the legend
reading: 'In Grand Lodge this first day of December A.D. 1813, Ratified and
Confirmed, and the seal of the Grand Lodge affixed'. They are witnessed and
countersigned: 'In the presence of Count Jacob Pontusson De la Gardie 1st Grand
Master of the North'. They were then solemnly and ceremonially placed inside the
Ark of the Covenant. It must be borne in mind and emphasised that these two
manuscript facsimile copies of the original Articles of Union were
representative only, cosmetic copies, so to speak, for show purposes alone. They
were, of course, accurate and identical to the signed and sealed originals but
the legal aspects of the Union had by now already taken place.

Both documents, now available for
inspection, show that they are signed by the Grand Masters and by the Grand
Secretaries (the moderns have an added signature) and witnessed by De la Gardie,
on the inside back cover of each document, below the legend that reads: 'In
Grand Lodge this first day of December AD1813 Rectified and Confirmed and the
seal of the Grand Lodge affixed’. As expected, there are no seals or signs that
any seals were ever applied. There was no need for seals. Furthermore although
the event was taking place on 27 December 1813, the document being signed was
dated, quite correctly, 1 December 1813. The events of 27 December 1813 were a
symbolic show and celebration of unity, the Union already having been achieved
on 1 December.

The facsimile copy of the Articles of
Union belonging to the Antients was subsequently selected for use as the
'Master' or official document of the Union and was accordingly handsomely bound
in a decorated and embossed velvet cover. The copy was signed by the four
signatories of the Antients (it is presumed the Moderns never bothered to sign
this document or may never have been asked) and, until recently, it was carried
into Grand Lodge at each Quarterly Communication in the special satchel still in
use today and on display at the Museum of Freemasonry.

The facsimile belonging to the Moderns (or
Premier) Grand Lodge has an interesting pedigree, as reported to the author in
private correspondence by Susan Snell, Archivist and Records Manager at the
Library and Museum of Freemasonry and a former British Records Association (BRA)
archivist. She writes that the document concerned, accessioned as ‘BRA 1607’
together with a large quantity of other unrelated documents, was deposited with
the BRA on 12 August 1968 from the College of Arms via the Historical
Manuscripts Commission (HMC) as a gift. The British Records Association acts as
an archives clearing house for London solicitors’ papers and other records of
potential historical interest. On 16 January 1976, Janet Foster, then the BRA
archivist, wrote to Grand Lodge and the document was subsequently delivered to
James Stubbs, Grand Secretary at the time, at Charterhouse where he was
residing. The receipt of the document ‘despatch number 1662’ is acknowledged
with thanks in a letter from the United Grand Lodge of England addressed to the
BRA dated 5 February 1976. The relatively late discovery of the document may
explain why it has not been referred to by several authors who have written on
the subject, and who may have reached different conclusions had the existence of
a Moderns’ version of the facsimile copy been known to exist.

Illustration:
The Articles of Union dated 25 November 1813 signed and with the seals of the two Grand Masters and their commissioners . The last three lines below the signatures and seals are the ratification and confirmation 'in Grand Lodge' (namely of the Antients) dated 1 December 1813 and signed by 'Edward' Grand Master of the Antients. The large seal to the left centre of the document is also that of the Antients Grand Lodge. This document is preserved in the archives of the Library and Museum of Freemasonry in London. An identical document with the signature of the Duke of Sussex at its base and the large seal of the Moderns (or Premier) Grand Lodge of England is currently missing.
Photograph by David Peabody.

ACKNOWLEDGMNENTS

My thanks are extended to the very patient Martin Cherry,
knowledgeable Librarian of the Library and Museum of Freemasonry for his
unhesitant assistance and Bro John Hamill for sharing with me his views on the
subject. John Belton, whose excellent book 'The English Masonic Union of 1813'
has recently seen the light of day, has proven to be a friend and gentleman of
the greatest value. Finally, I have mentioned Bro Douglas Burford and Susan
Snell in the text.