Swastikas in New York

Jewish students face ongoing anti-Semitism and no one is doing anything about it.

My great grandparents were born in New York. At the end of a high school Holocaust memorial assembly, students were asked to file out quietly in the following order: those who had parents who were Holocaust survivors, those who had grandparents who were survivors, and finally those who had great grandparents who were survivors. I remained sitting with three other students in the empty auditorium. We looked at each other across rows of empty seats, and I felt shock ripple through me. I didn’t know that most of my classmates' grandparents were survivors.

On the stage the American flag rippled in the dim spotlights alongside the Israeli flag, and I thought about the refuge that this country has been for so many Jews. My grandmother used to tell the Santa Claus who offered us candy canes at the mall: "No thank you. We're Jewish so we celebrate Hanukkah. But happy holidays!" I'll never forget the way her green eyes lit up with her fiery pride for Judaism. As her granddaughter, I grew up believing that being Jewish was a gift, and that anti-Semitism was an archaic form of ignorance that lay far away in mid-century Europe.

Unfortunately last week’s headline in the New York Times, "Swastikas, Slurs and Torment in Town's Schools" shows that virulent hatred still simmers right here. In the Pine Bush Central School District in New York State, located 90 minutes north of New York City, going to school has been a nightmare for Jewish students. Swastikas have been found on walls, desks, lockers, textbooks, computer screens, a playground slide and, in an especially horrifying incident, scrawled onto a Jewish student's face. Three Jewish families are suing the district and its administrators in federal court for flagrant anti-Semitism and the apathy of school officials.

In 2011, when a parent complained about the harassment of her daughter, the school superintendent, Philip G. Steinberg, wrote in an email: "I have said I will meet with your daughter and I will, but your expectations for changing inbred prejudice may be a bit unrealistic." The affected students’ grades have been dropping, and many of them have felt depressed and socially isolated. The swastikas that were carved onto school property were often accompanied by messages such as: "Die Jew." One of the students said that he stopped reporting swastikas to teachers because no one was doing anything about them.

The school superintendent said that he found the situation especially challenging because there were so many students accused of anti-Semitic behavior. When a NYT reporter visited the town and asked its citizens if they were aware of the swastikas and incidents, one man said: "We don't want them (Jews) in our town. They can't drive, for number one, and they already have Sullivan County. Who really wants them here? They don't belong here."

The families say that their discussions with school officials were fruitless, and that they were not informed that other families had raised similar issues. A father once asked an assistant principal why his son was disciplined for defending himself against a student who had grabbed him after teasing him about the Holocaust. The school official answered: "We have a zero-tolerance policy for fighting." The Jewish students have had coins thrown at them, been told to retrieve money from garbage cans and have been shoved and beaten.

The parents who have lodged complaints have been asked by the superintendent why they are still living in a community with such a level of hatred for Jews. One frustrated mother answered: "In a better economy that might be nice (to leave), but I can't sell my house and move from here right now. Something needs to be taken care of at the school level."

Years ago, I heard Rav Noah Weinberg ztz"l repeat a powerful statement made by Rav Elazar Shach ztz"l: "If one man can kill six million Jews, then one man can save six million Jews." If one or two or even 30 ignorant people can shove and put down our fellow Jews right here in New York, then one or two or even 30 of us can uplift and support them. At the gates of Auschwitz, Rav Noah stood with a group of Jewish educators and said: "We're not serious. The Nazis were serious. They didn't stop improving their methods until they were operating at full efficiency. Just as the Nazis were motivated to destroy the Jewish people, we have to be motivated to build the Jewish people."

The worst thing that we can do when we hear about a horrific story like this is nothing. The Jewish families in this rural town should not feel like they are on their own. They're not. I think of the light in my grandmother's eyes. I think of the empty seats at that Holocaust assembly so long ago. And I know, now more than ever, what a gift it is not only to be Jewish but to be proud of who we are. The courage and strength of these families in Pine Bush is an example for all of us. Let's stand by their side.

Please write a comment of support below. They will be forwarded to the Jewish families in the Pine Bush case.

Featured at Aish.com:

About the Author

Sara Debbie Gutfreund received her BA in English from the University of Pennsylvania and her MA in Family Therapy from the University of North Texas. She has taught parenting classes and self-development seminars and provided adolescent counseling. She writes extensively for many online publications and in published anthologies of Jewish women's writing. She and her husband spent 14 wonderful years raising their five children in Israel, and now live in Blue Ridge Estates in Waterbury, Connecticut, where Sara Debbie enjoys skiing and running in her free time.

The opinions expressed in the comment section are the personal views of the commenters. Comments are moderated, so please keep it civil.

Visitor Comments: 265

(233)
Gitel,
July 25, 2017 4:16 PM

Contact The Major News Media

Dear Brothers and Sisters of Pine Bush, We all need to contact NBC,CBS,,ABC ask if this is ''news worthy''. If some random whale is washed up from the ocean that's ALWAYS news worthy.It appears that Jews in this day and age are an entity that doesn't exist and therefore are not valued by the major media. Silence is NOT ALWAYS GOLDEN.The State of Israel regained our dignity!.Now it is time for your fellow brothers and sisters here in The USA to help restore The Pine Bush Jewish communities dignity ! Everyone of us needs to contact ::NBC,CBS and ABC !!!

(232)
Anonymous,
June 19, 2017 5:11 AM

Stay strong!

Stay strong. Our prayers are with you.

(231)
Liz Weishaar,
June 16, 2017 2:47 PM

I stand with you

You are fighting for what's right and you are setting an excellent example for your children, for your community, and for everyone who hears your story. I wish I were there to help you and your families work against this abuse. I'm far away, but my prayers are with you as you struggle through this painful time.

(230)
Lauren Rivka Goldman,
January 2, 2017 10:22 AM

Speaking out against anti-Semitism.

I am 71 and grew up in Los Angeles, where there was a whispered anti-Semitism (nothing overt) in the town of my youth.
When I moved to the Fairfax neighborhood, in my mid-20s, I came in contact with a number of Holocaust survivors, some with tattoos on their arms. Those who lived in Germany, during the rise of Nazism, told how they adapted to the growing anti-Semitism until the Nuremberg Laws made their future in Germany very clear. Shortly thereafter, escape became impossible.
Thanks to the Internet, the world's shifting back to anti-Semitism is becoming clear much sooner than it did in the 1930s. I currently live in San Francisco, and the level of anti-Semitic speech is increasing, so I try to call it out when I hear it. People say things with impunity, against Jews, that would get them challenged if spoken against other groups.
As I have heard some of those who survived WWII say, "We have seen this before."
Sadly, this is true.

(229)
Julius,
December 12, 2013 12:50 PM

Come to Des Moines, Iowa

Go ahead, leave that city. Step out on faith, and come to Des Moines (Dee Moin) Iowa. The economy is great and housing is cheap. Let that city suffer the fate of Detroit.

(228)
Yehoshua Eshaghian,
December 12, 2013 12:26 AM

Big Kiddush Hashem

I greatly admire the strength and courage of these families to stand up for themselves. I also admire their pride in being Jewish despite the hatred and contempt being displayed toward them. I strongly support them in their efforts to rectify the situation and put an end to the anti-Semitism occurring in their schools. This is a great Kiddush Hashem they are doing by showing the world that they are proud of being Jewish in all situations.

(227)
Anonymous,
December 3, 2013 3:39 PM

Unacceptable?

U can not tolerate this, I understand. Do you ever think how the palestinians feel when u occupy their lands and torture them, kill them and deny their rights at their own land?

Marsha Coleman,
December 17, 2013 1:55 AM

Get real! No cure for stupidity!

You should get your facts straight. Israel is not torturing and killing anyone. There is a major problem with Palestinian leaders, however, who steal from their own people. What has happened to all the aid these people receive from all over the world? They don't believe in human rights with all the stoning and beheading. The people should take responsibility and not blame Israeli for everything that goes wrong!

Barbara,
January 3, 2017 4:03 PM

Spewing propaganda and outright lies is unacceptable!

To "Anonymous" and his / her cohorts: Can you put your poisoned bias aside long enough to find out the facts instead of acting as the stooges of Palestinian propaganda? (You know, of course, that the very idea of a Palestinian entity is a historical falsehood.)

If you have no patience for that, visit Israel and see for yourself what's really going on! (In direct opposition to the historic mistreatment of the Jewish minority in Arab countries, Israeli Arabs enjoy the highest standard of living compared to their counterparts in any part of the Middle East -- including in health care, educational opportunities, earning potential, etc.

So get past your prejudice (which is the reason you can so easily turn a blind eye to the truth and swallow blatant lies), and wake up to reality!

BTW, I know it's a waste of time to reason with die-hard anti-Semites -- after all, our Torah tells us about Jew hatred (as well as assuring us that Israel's enemies will get their just deserts) -- but this doesn't negate our need to speak our minds!

(226)
LLOYD OESTREICHER,
December 2, 2013 7:34 PM

PINEBUSH

WHAT CAN I DI TO HELP?

(225)
Murray Goodman,
November 22, 2013 9:03 PM

Horrific

Did I read the name of the Superintendent correctly? Steinberg? What is wrong with this guy? We must not allow this to happen in any corner of the world, let alone in the US. We must prosecute this egregious affront aggressively. Has the SPLC been contacted?

(224)
Shamayah,
November 22, 2013 3:59 PM

I suggest that the parents who's children are victim to antisemitism in their school be home-schooled. Not to say that doing this would stop antisemitism, but it will surely take their children out of harms way. Whenever there is danger, especially when it involves the well-being of our children, we must take them out of it. However, if some parents cannot, for whatever reason, home-school their child they should either consider in suing the school [if that's possible], or transferring them. Although I encourage all parents to take the step to home-school their children. Even if you do not have any degree in teaching, as my mom had not, it is still a great choice to make.

(223)
Kenan Moss,
November 20, 2013 2:05 PM

action

May I suggest, that all those minorities that have been persecuted, merely for being who they are and have come to the United States in order to live in peace and freedom, join forces in a national manifestation against hatred. We have the model of Martin Luther King to look to: he brought together all people of good will and they brought down the horror that was segregation. And less than fifty years later America has an Afro-American President, Democracy is an active idea and must be practiced in all that we do and defended everyday. Ask the German people where passivity in the face violence leads: let us not forget that the Germans themselves were among the first victims of their inaction. Not to act in the face of evil is to share the guilt.

(222)
Anonymous,
November 19, 2013 7:58 PM

Raise a unified voice against prejudice and racism

Living in Europe I am shocked to think that the country Jews ran to after the atrocities of the War over here, that provided freedom to all, is now ignoring the return of suffering to the very group of people they claim to support and save. As a European I await the US lead and example in this important area - seeing as inspite of the past Germany cannot currently stem the growing trend of racial hatred. My soul stands with the Jews of the New York boroughs who are suffering. Let us write to mayors and councillors and raise a unified voice against this prejudice. May HaShem give grace and wisdom to bring change for the better.

(221)
Anonymous,
November 19, 2013 12:23 AM

They were God's CHOSEN people & HE still cares for them. anti-semitism should NEVER be tolerated - Look what it brought on in Europe, Germany specifically....Do unto others as you would have them do unto you!!

(220)
Rebecca,
November 18, 2013 1:58 AM

All that is necessary for the triumph of evil is that good men do nothing

This is terribly disturbing to me. And I'm not even Jewish. Too many places in our modern world, even (and sometimes especially) the places which are supposedly bastions of freedom, are becoming bastions of hatred and oppression.

Evil against anyone is a threat to everyone. But the first triumph of evil is when otherwise good people turn a blind eye to the oppression of others. That is how evil destroys people from within. But unlike oppression, this kind of destruction is freely allowed by the 'good'. It's a choice they make.

We need to make the other choice - to change our culture from within, not to let ourselves be changed by the worst parts of that culture. And this starts with those of us who aren't being oppressed.

In one sense, the school official had a valid point in saying "your expectations for changing inbred prejudice may be a bit unrealistic," after all, the atmosphere in schools reflects cultural forces beyond the control of schools. However, everyone has to do their part, and there is certainly a big role that schools can play in educating students and encouraging them to change their culture for the better.

I find it hypocritical for our public schools to be pushing radical culture-changing types of sex education, to influence students' perception of sexual morality, but yet to be unwilling to even try to combat blatant antisemitism.

Actually, though perhaps I shouldn't be surprised. Because behind both there is a common thread. Evil always rebels against all that is good and all that is from God. Sexual morality threatens the desire of evil to replace God's will with human desires. And Judaism (and other religion) threatens the desire of evil to replace God's people with a godless world.

(219)
Anonymous,
November 18, 2013 12:56 AM

You have more support than you know.

I cannot believe there are still people who think this way. I live in Texas with a small Jewish community but we are respected by our neighbors. I hope that the few haters in the community will turn their hearts.

(218)
Rachel Silverman,
November 18, 2013 12:54 AM

I stand with you

I'm appalled by the virulent anti-Semitism that my Jewish brothers and sisters in Pine Bush, New York, are suffering. I'm greatly concerned for the Jewish children who are forced to endure such hatred. I'm sickened by the superintendent's lack of response to your concerns. I'm on your side, and I care about you.

Jerry Meents,
November 19, 2013 7:20 PM

Silence

Before WWII our Jewish comunity were silent and walkt around with pins on there caots with a broken rifle. And see what that got us, between 104 and 115.000 deaths.

Speak up against Anti-Semitis.

(217)
Anonymous,
November 18, 2013 12:10 AM

How Can We Help?

Ms. Gutfreund, can you write about what we might be able to do to help this community?

My dear fellow Jews in this tormented community, please let us know how we can help you.

(216)
Anonymous,
November 17, 2013 7:45 PM

Anti-semitism is always shocking and defies reason. I experienced that kind of anti-semitism as a child when neighbors would though coins at us during the high holy days....that was 40 years ago....it's so sad that with all the technological advances we've made, ignorance and hate still exist. We are with you and this kind of hatred should never be tolerated or allowed to continue. As decent human beings one would think the administration would find this behavior unconscionable.

(215)
GG,
November 17, 2013 6:12 AM

horrifying

This is a horrifying story--We are standing with you, supporting you. If there's a number we can call up, to speak up to (bombard) the school principal, please update this article with that info.Looking forward to the time when 'gar ze'ev im keves...' -- 'the wolf can live with the lamb...'

(214)
Allan Foster,
November 16, 2013 8:32 PM

Memories of Pine Bush

I grew up in Scotchtown, about twelve miles away from Pine Bush, NY. When I was growing up, seventy years ago, most of the people were colonial descendants who simply wanted to be left alone. Anti-Semitism was found only among more recent immigrants. I know the population has changed greatly in the last fifty years, but I suspect, there are still a lot of the old families who would find Jews a lot more acceptable than Catholics.

(213)
Rosalie H. Kaye,
November 16, 2013 8:30 PM

Stay Strong, DON'T GIVE UP THE FIGHT!!!! MANY ARE WITH YOU!!

There are many people, who I believe, that are with you in your fight to combat this disgusting environment in the the Pine Bush school system! Hopefully with outside intervention, this hateful situation can be neutralized and an environment of positive learning can be instituted.

(212)
Anonymous,
November 16, 2013 2:36 PM

You are not alone. Stay strong!

(211)
Mrs Shapiro,
November 16, 2013 9:11 AM

Davening for you!

I'd like to extend my love and support to my fellow Jews in Pine Bush. Honestly, I cannot understand how you must be suffering, especially worrying so much about your precious children. I've encountered antisemitism and Ignorance, of course, but never as you have. Not even close. I would be so filled with rage and hurt that I know I'd have trouble letting it go. To people like us, it makes no sense. I do not know one Jew who hates others, though certainly they're out there (those leftist Jews who excoriate Israel!) But, having suffered, surely we know the horrific power of hate, and how bringing out the divine light in others improves our world. HKBH. I am praying for you and I've shared this on my facebook page, asking other friends to comment and pray as well.

(210)
Brian Thompson,
November 16, 2013 12:30 AM

So sorry

The prejudice & bullying you suffer is wrong & destructive. As a christian I owe so much to the Israeli people - as does the world. Please understand we are for you, not against you. May there be peace in Jerusalem!

bt

(209)
Lensman,
November 15, 2013 7:29 PM

history repeats

When I was in high school back in the 70's, I had the same problem, but the JDL under R. Kahane (zt'l) was making an impact. I recommend that the students travel in groups and attend the same classes if possible. Next, arrange for Krav Maga or other training, and consider home schooling. You only need one parent for supervision, and can force the school system to provide tutors, but may require months of wrangling with attorneys and fees before the school caves in to you

(208)
Suri Katx,
November 15, 2013 7:14 PM

Priorities

Is there any way to get these poor kinderlach out of this situation? Perhaps bus them to a Jewish school?
my experience in raising my six children has taught me that who your children are surrounded with in school is even more important than the education they're getting.
On top of that a true Torah education outweighs all the benefits of a secular one. Not that Jewish schools don't offer a top quality secular education. They just make Torah learning the number one priority.

(207)
Marti,
November 15, 2013 4:08 PM

It might be helpful for readers to know that the US Attorney's Office for the Southern District of NY has gotten involved thanks to three families who have filed lawsuits against the school district. Here is a link to an article in the NY Time about that: http://www.nytimes.com/2013/11/14/nyregion/us-investigates-anti-semitism-claims-at-pine-bush-schools.html?hpw&rref=nyregion&_r=0 One can only hope that, now that the federal authorities have taken note, their action will put things right. Having said that, the most disturbing issue...and the issue that never seems to go away once and for all...is the continual, non-sensical prevalence of anti-semitism. It has never gone away...and it only waits for a time and a place when no one will stand against it. That time and place and people have now appeared in the Pine Bush School system. Shame upon the children, their parents, and the local school officials who did nothing.

(206)
Jill,
November 15, 2013 3:01 PM

Take State Action

This is New York State, right? Where is the State head of police to have a chat with local officers? Where is the State Supervisor of schools to have a chat with school administrators? Where are the State leaders for the various churches to speak to the congregants? You have to get them all present & involved NOW. The press has to blow this up with a big stink. I would make sure every state official is aware of this and get them there thru pressure exerted by the media.

(205)
annie,
November 15, 2013 11:26 AM

do something

what is happening in those schools isdisheartening yet should be a wakeup call for jewish communities in those areas. the problem as quoted by school official seems inbred from parents to children to teachers and community ignoring the sitn. well sees to me anti semitism is not yet dead. it wasnt born with hitler and definately didnt go to the grave with him. it seems to change its face with every generation but it is there. the problem is more spiritual than geneologicall. i pray that the parents do not give inor give up.the jewish community should join hands and do something to protect themsselves, thier children and precious heritge even if t means moving away back to Israel.pray for guidance from Hashem and do what is within yor means to do, Hashem will "top up".

(204)
Anonymous,
November 15, 2013 7:28 AM

I am sorry your children are being mistreated. We once said never again, but we are letting it happen again. Daven and the rest of us will daven with you. You are not alone, Hashm is with you, and so are the Jewish people

(203)
Linda,
November 15, 2013 6:43 AM

Most Jews are in NY?

Respectfully, I think statistics show that most Jews live in Israel. Which is where I live, and have never had to endure anti-Semitism. Not once.

Terrorists, yes- The IDF recently extricated some from a neighboring Arab village- but they did their job magnificently, and I feel completely safe.

The difference is that the Israeli government recognizes our enemies, while the US does not, will not. Even here in the West Bank, my children are safer than yours, apparently.

As a child of Holocaust survivors whose parents were murdered in Auchwitz, who didn't heed the warnings from their own family members who fled in time, I do not plan to repeat their grievous errors.

I truly apologize if this comes out as a tough pill to swallow with no sugar-coating, but you have made the choice to live among enemies- people who have outright admitted that they don't want you around...

...But we DO want you! There is an ever growing population of American olim here in Israel, but it's not enough. Here, you may not be wealthy, but you will be among your own people who love you. And there are so many options for Jews wishing to make a home here, especially those who can continue to commute to NY for work. Really, Israel has something for everybody.

Listen to the signs that Hashem is sending you everyday. With emuna, it can be so easy.

Again, I apologize if this came out as a Zionist rant, but it pains me to see Jews mistreated in the Diaspora while we are breaking our backs to maintain a home for you here, in our homeland, eretz ha'kadosh.

Shabbat shalom.

david,
November 15, 2013 12:29 PM

Israel MUST NOT be the 'only' place for Jews

I am a great lover of Israel ,but the fellow who implies that we should all move to Israel ( it "pains him" that they "break their backs to provide a HOME for US " ) is not recognizing the complexity of the problem . 1 ) As one of the victims points out ,it's not so easy to give up your home and job and just move someplace else . - A far better response is to encourage Jew and non-Jew alike to fight the bigotry . 2) It is desperately important for ISRAEL that there be a large Jewish presence in the Diaspora offering financial assistance , and support for Israel from within the outer world community . Israel would soon be isolated if ( and overcrowded) if we all moved there

Beverly Kurtin,
November 15, 2013 7:45 PM

Heh, heh, heh

Oh yeah, we Jews can't drive and we all live in New York. So what am I doing in TEXAS? We have a thriving Jewish community here. Living as I do in the Fort Worth/Dallas area, we have to drive rather large distances to get from one country to the other. Our two counties, Tarrant and Dallas, if put up in Connecticut, there would be very little space left on either side of the Nutmeg State.My Torah partner heard that there were horrendous rains in Austin. She asked me if we were involved. "Nope, but thanks for calling, Austin is 200 miles south of here." That's about the distance from Brooklyn to Washington D.C.Let's face it, Texas is humongous. If you are in Texarkana, Texas, you are 100 miles closer to Chicago than El Paso!A few months ago I drove to a shul in Dallas to see members of the Southern Poverty Law Center. Round trip was about 75 miles and that was just from one county to another.I used to be a text book representative. I had to drive 300 to 500 miles every Monday to get to my starting point for the week. I estimate that I have driven, in my lifetime, over a million miles...and never had a chargeable accident. Jews can't DRIVE?When I was a school girl, I was picked on as I was THE Jew in my elementary school. An uncle of mine taught me JEWdo. That ended any problems I had. All it took was putting two of the bullies down.

(202)
KingsKnight1,
November 15, 2013 5:30 AM

Of days gone by

I remember a time maybe 35 or 40 years ago when if a report like this got published, with a week Pine Bush would have become host to a couple of dozen Brooklyn and Queens Jews where kippot, leather jackets maybe with tiztite hanging out. These guys would have literature helping to organize Jewish defense practice for the vulnerable kids. They also might be carrying baseball bats and bike chains available if needed. Also literature on how to purchase a legal gun in Sullivan county. Jews, if you're going to make a stand on your home ground, make sure you're prepared and practiced for any eventuality. Don't to ask for God's help also. You we'll need it. Best of luck

PrairieBoy,
November 16, 2013 5:42 PM

Makes sense to me.

Are you talking about the JDL? Nobody's heard anything about them for decades, but they were extremely effective in reducing or even eliminating antisemitic incidents. If all Jews believed--as you apparently do--in defending ourselves physically, as all other ethnic groups do, the antisemitism described in this article would be short-lived.

(201)
Johanna,
November 15, 2013 3:57 AM

Stand strong unified

We need to speak up and stand strong about any kind of antisémitisme act.

(200)
Yehudit,
November 15, 2013 2:11 AM

We Jews are all TOGETHER!

Oy vey! I feel for you so much ! I want to give you my assurance that you are NOT alone. Your Jewish brothers and sisters care deeply, and we are all with you. May HaShem bless and protect you and give you strength. Meanwhile, I'm going to find out what I can do to see that this garbage stops ! ! !

(199)
Anonymous,
November 14, 2013 10:55 PM

NY anti-semitism

The folks up there need help. Is there still a JDL? ADL might help with school administrators but I expect the former would be more effective.

(198)
Miriam,
November 14, 2013 10:16 PM

All students should take special sensitivity classes

The school district needs to institute special ongoing sensitivity classes for all students and for their parents as well. We live in a nation that is built on diversity. If these students are ignorant than they must be taught how to behave correctly.

(197)
Andrew Dimond,
November 14, 2013 10:07 PM

How

How can we help you?
We are with you.

(196)
Leah Bleiberg,
November 14, 2013 10:01 PM

contacting Senator Schumer

I add my support to these families and hope they would contact persons in positions of power who may be able to help them, perhaps Senator Chuck Schumer. May HaShem protect them..

(195)
Kenan Moss,
November 14, 2013 9:14 PM

hatred and the constitution

I cannot believe that the framers of so admirable a document as the United States Constitution could have wished the propagation of hatred to be to be included in "Freedom of Speech". The non-establishment of religion and its consequent, religious toleration, would logically be extended to the toleration of all minorities and their opinions. Let us let the people of Pine Bush know that they by no means represent the majority of the nations population: let all who oppose such behaviour think of ways of letting them know how far out of sync they are with society. And those inert school authorities should be informed that Psychiatry has a long and honoured history in the United States and that they should draw on its knowledge and wisdom.

(194)
Beverly,
November 14, 2013 8:36 PM

Bring in all the appropriate officials

The school officials are totally out of line. If they don't act, the district school administration should be brought in, along with the state's appropriate dept. as well as the local state representatives and the governor if necessary. This is worse than just bullying, but it has the same threatening affect. It's a community problem, but of course it's the community that is the problem.

(193)
Anonymous,
November 14, 2013 6:13 PM

In my prayers

We should not delude ourselves into thinking that it is not our problem since we don't live there-- for it most surely is.

I wish you courage and to those who are investigating integrity. I will keep you in my prayers and know that you are not alone.

(192)
Anonymous,
November 14, 2013 5:24 PM

Anti-Semitism Today

I do not find it shocking that Anti-Semitism still exists today what shocks me is that it occurred in NY where most Jews live and no one is advocating on their behalf "Wake Up Jews and Help Your Brothers" the more of a cry from Jews will create a bigger stir and eventually 'hush up' the perpetratorslets not stand aside this time

(191)
karen,
November 14, 2013 5:19 PM

Be strong!

Jews have been persecuted for centuries. Now is the time to stand up, be a Kiddish Hashem and make a change for the good. Who knows what good things may come from this? One of the Jewish teens may stand up and become a tremendous leader. Our thoughts are with you during this difficult time!

(190)
neil,
November 14, 2013 4:34 PM

this must be dealt with on governmental level. the senatore and congressmen should be brought in, the schools that do not act to reverse the anti -semitism should be penalized . those that try to correct the situation should be rewarded publicly. the media should be brought in , glen beck should be brought in. plenty can be done and it should be done. there should be civilion patrols too.

(189)
Beverly Kurtin,
November 14, 2013 3:55 PM

It COULD happen again: Here

The people in that town are deliberately ignoring the real situation. They've gotten together and rather admit that there is something horribly wrong in that school district, they're pointing to a totally different problem. They say that this stems from a land buy gone wrong because a Jewish developer "illegally" bought land on which he is going to build town homes and a private school.It is reminiscent of the "Oh, we didn't know..." that the Germans and others pleaded. This is a case of 2 2 = nein.

If that community was as open as they claim, why have they let their kids continue to taunt Jewish students and why are hate symbols all around their school?

(188)
Anonymous,
November 14, 2013 3:51 PM

Be Strong!

As a fellow Jew who lives in the U.S I am so sorry that you and especially your children have to go through this- Be Strong! We are all one family and when one of us is hurt we all feel it. Have a Happy Chanukah and I hope that the issue will be resolved quickly.

dina simhony,
November 14, 2013 4:32 PM

hebrew/frech teacher.

never give up your pride to be a jew. i was born in egypt where jews were hated by many ignorant ones and appreciated by the ones we,hews, always helped by giving them jobs,food clothings. my father always told me not to ear my magen david necklace out but i always displayed it so everyone can see i was jewish and very proud of being one. the jealousy is eating the ones who hate us. noone has ever given us anything. we worked hard to get where we want to be and we are proud of who we are. so continue to lift your heads up and be proud. they need us more than we need the. good luck to all of us.

(187)
Miriam,
November 14, 2013 3:19 PM

Be Proud!

It is a terrible thing to live under such blatant anti-semitism, and have everyone turn a blind eye. May G-d give all the families in Pine Bush the strength to make it through this time, and may no one be hurt physically or emotionally or spiritually.This week's Torah Portion explains "eisav soneh liyaakov", the basis for anti-semitism. Eisav will always hate Yaakov, out of jealousy. throughout history, we have fought against this hate again and again and again. In 2 weeks is Chanukah- a holiday in middle of the cold and dark winter, reminding us that our little lights light up the world, that G-d loves us and that at the end of time we will remain. Let us teach our children the profound thoughts and ideas behind all this, and let everyone come out of this experience with greater pride in their heritage and identity. Am Yisroel Chai!

(186)
Sylvia Band,
November 14, 2013 2:33 PM

Antisemitism

My husband was born in Lodz Poland and survived several concentration camps . Antisemitism starts in the home. Parents and children.must be educated and taught to tolerate different religions and to respect others and to apply the golden rule--Do unto others as you would have them do unto you. Our leaders and our schools must educate and do something right now. Everyone has a G-d given right to live in peace and to follow their beliefs. We must stamp out antisemitism now !

Jerry Meents,
November 14, 2013 7:46 PM

Dear Sylvia you are so right.!!!!!!!

(185)
Mike Levy,
November 14, 2013 1:14 PM

Only for the thinkers..................

The victims and the parents of the victims should pose a question to the perpetrators of anti-semitism by asking them whether, if Jesus were alive today, they would do and say the same thing to him. I think not! It may turn them into thinkers!!

(184)
Sivana Sharon,
November 14, 2013 11:53 AM

That such venomous hatred could be 'overlooked' and even categorically endorsed in the U.S. in the 21st century is appalling and utterly unacceptable! These students and their families deserve our total support. DON'T MOVE: Stand your ground! You have fellow Jews who love you, and we will help you in your fight. STAY STRONG!!!

(183)
John Hayworth,
November 14, 2013 10:12 AM

Stand firm

As a Gentile I feel appalled that such behaviour is going on. It seems to me that the school authorities are either supportive of this or are exhibiting sheer cowardice! This could so easily be stamped out.

(182)
Rina Haller,
November 14, 2013 10:09 AM

We need to act.

As a student who still remembers all I saw in Poland months ago, the daunting Auschwitz gates call me to speak up. While our world seems so tolerant and Jews might always be hated, our brethren in a "free" country should not be persecuted at all. The real action we should do is take this Jewish children and place them in Jewish schools. The PEW report's most shocking conclusion is that we are acting worse than a Holocaust, more assimilation is occurring than Nazi genocide. This stems from our own inaction, sitting in our frum communities and just building ourselves up. WE NEED TO REACH OUT! Everyone knows someone who could be closer, who should be closer. GO, send that email, make that phone call. History has shown that Jews are terrorized most when they mingle into society, these tormented kids need to know where they belong, with their Jewish brothers. So stand up by standing out, don't become what hates you.

(181)
ray,
November 14, 2013 8:52 AM

the antisemites are right

Jews belong in Israel.

Dianna,
November 14, 2013 3:32 PM

Hatred Running Wild

It saddens me to think that this type of behavior occurs in this day and age. ANY form of racism is wrong. We are suppose to look at each persons behavior and not the entire group in which they belong. If I am upset with my brother, my entire family should not suffer for it so I deal with my brother. Unfortunate as it is hatred of others exist..

IDM,
November 14, 2013 4:39 PM

Double standards?

Similar,or worst, situation is occurring to the Palestinians: both Muslims and Christians. But Jews ignore it or majority even support by all means. Let us face the fact: Jews encourages antisemitism by their isolationist ideologies such as the concept of "chosen race", being Jewish only by "blood", Israel is right in all situations, - - - -. I don't hate Jews, but at the same time do not accept the habit of double standards from ANYONE!!!

Mati,
November 28, 2013 1:50 PM

IDM is obviously speaking with forked tongue

For while he claims that he does not hate Jews, what he writes contradicts his claims. DOUBLE STANDARDS? Why are there Chinese Jews, Arab Jews, black Jews, white Jews, Jewish Jews (descendants from Jacob), etc., if they have a concept of "chosen race?" They have never claimed to be a chosen RACE...the bible claims them to be a chosen PEOPLE (of all races). Why are they a chosen People, because G-d chose them to give the Torah to...THAT'S ALL!!! "Being Jewish only by "blood" is figment of your antisemitic hatred of Jews and not from Jews. There is no such thing as "blood" when it come to Jews because they don't claim to be a race and they have had a history filled with converts. There is no "isolationist ideologies" held by Jews since they accept all people as being PEOPLE of G-d. As for the "Palestinians:" The first Palestinians were Jews not Arab squatters claiming the title. When and where has there EVER been a country called Palestine? I would guess that you are one of those "Palestinian" people who are being taught by schools who want to rewrite history and who teach hatred of Jews to their young. Would you kill a sleeping soldier on a bus like the 15 year old "palestinian" coward did two weeks ago when he entered the country illegally?

Mati,
November 27, 2013 5:47 PM

I disagree

ONLY Jews who have the desire to do Torah should be in Israel. All others should go to the galut where they fit right in with the other antisemites.

(180)
susan,
November 14, 2013 5:48 AM

stay strong

Stay strong brothers and sisters of pine bush! Draw from the message
Of hHanukkah. Be fearless like the Maccabees!

(179)
David,
November 14, 2013 3:43 AM

Stay Strong

Remember you are apart of Kol Yisrael. You are not alone. We are not alone. Hashem does not forget his people.

(178)
Marian,
November 14, 2013 12:59 AM

We support you in your fight for justice

You are not alone. We commend you for taking the District to court and are certain that justice will prevail. Thank you for this article and allowing us to send our message of love and support to the Jewish families of the Pine Bush Central School District. Shame on this country if we allow such bigotry hatred and ugliness to go unanswered. Can you imagine anywhere in the country allowing African Americans or Hispanics to be treated so in the public school system? Sure in the 30's but in today's day and age? Stand strong. We support you.

(177)
Bill Rosenson,
November 14, 2013 12:55 AM

It never goes away. Not until messiach comes.

Sue the anti semites but don't ask the democrats for any help. They are in league with them.

(176)
zev,
November 14, 2013 12:51 AM

DO SOMETHING

Meet the baseball bat, It's not an illegal weapon. Meet Krav Maga, It's OURS! and it works. Meet strength in numbers. These bullies will cower when they see that Jews will come together to fight these SCUM!

(175)
Frumma,
November 14, 2013 12:09 AM

It says in the Hagaddsh that they will rise up against us in every generation . We tried to convince ourselves that it wouldn't happen now. We. Must learn from history and make changes early on. The biggest one is to eliminate our self hatred and intolerance of each other and then hopefully Moshiach will come.

(174)
Ilann Maazel,
November 14, 2013 12:08 AM

Are you a witness to or victim of anti-Semitic harassment or bullying?

We are the lawyers at Emery Celli Brinckerhoff & Abady who represent the victims of anti-Semitic harassment and bullying in Pine Bush schools. If you have been a victim of anti-Semitism or bullying in these schools, or in other schools, please contact us at 212-763-5000 or imaazel@ecbalaw.com. Now is the time to come forward so that we can finally bring much needed reform to this school district.

(173)
Sara Debbie Gutfreund,
November 13, 2013 11:44 PM

Update from Author

Governor Cuomo has directed the NY State Police and the State Division of Human Rights to investigate these incidents. The AJC has called for a statewide probe into the problem. The outpouring of comments is a crucial source of support for the families involved. Thank you all for speaking up

(172)
PHYLLIS LEVY,
November 13, 2013 11:41 PM

WE HAVE THE SAYING NEVER AGAIN I HOPE THAT WE WONT BE SAYING HERE WE GO AGAIN

ANTI-SEMITISIM IS ON THE RISE AND WHERE ARE THE PEOPLE THAT KEEP SAYING NEVER AGAIN

(171)
Roberta Burnett,
November 13, 2013 10:55 PM

Outreach

The Working Press (locally and regionally) your state's congresspeople, the NY Times, Time Magazine, and film directors of conscience should all have your article above in their hands, fully supported with facts. You can use a pseudonym as a writer and give permission for reprinting only if that pseudonym is used. You do need protection. The situation is alarming, but you must not be passive. Jews have been the target to be ravaged from at the very least the Holy Roman Empire. As a numerically small population in a mass of other believers, passivity can lead directly to more massacres. The crazies are out there, but it is equally crazy to be passive to a larger audience than your own.

(170)
Richard Robbins,
November 13, 2013 10:16 PM

Appeasement never works. Sue them in Federal court

Appeasement never works. Sue them in Federal court

(169)
Jonathan Keefe,
November 13, 2013 9:35 PM

I'm sorry for your suffering

I hope this very difficult situation is a springboard for your community to come closer to HaKadosh Baruch Hu. In the period before Moshiach it becomes apparent that we can only rely on HaShem.

(168)
Chana Jenny Weisberg,
November 13, 2013 9:12 PM

you are heroes!

you are heroes for standing up to antisemitism! May G-d give you strength and support you:)

(167)
j. Frohwein,
November 13, 2013 8:58 PM

COME TO ISRAEL WE WANT YOU HERE

Maybe Hashem is dropping hints to us. It is time FOR ALL JEWS TO COME TO ISRAEL. This is where OUR FUTURE IS

(166)
Anonymous,
November 13, 2013 8:54 PM

Sue the school district

Parents complain but don't go further? I'd try enlist a national organization to proceed with an anti-discrimination legal action.And where are the synagogues with this problem?? How about some Rabinical leadership.

(165)
Shoshana - Jerusalem,
November 13, 2013 8:32 PM

We are praying for you

To our dear fellow Jews in Pine Bush:

I am shocked and saddened to read this article and hear what you are going through. Our hearts and prayers are with you. May H-shem, G-d, help you and protect you through this difficult time,

May I suggest that as a community, or as individuals you accept upon yourselves to strengthen your Jewish observance in whatever way possible, something small that it will be possible for you to keep. A type of resolution concerning Shabbos or kashrus or family purity or modesty in dress, and in the merit of this resolution , may Hshem help you. This is what our communities in Eretz Yisrael do in times of trouble.

(164)
Anonymous,
November 13, 2013 8:28 PM

I would like to know the names of the students who are harrassing the Jewish students. Their names s hould be posted in the newspapers and given to the mayor,

the govenor and the President.

By the way, where are the parents of these students?

Don't think antisemitism will end there. Anti Christian

will also come to fore. Hatred breeds hatred but understanding what it means to be Jewish and a human being is paramount in our lives.

Also, if not for Haym Salomon supplying money for George Washington's troops he would not have been successful.

How about a little history lesson for these children and adults.

Also their Savior was Jewish. Would he be proud of their actions?

If they are bored with their lives maybe they can volunteer in old age homes or hospitals or tutor where they will learn to appreciate what they have.

Unfortunately, I don't think they are busy with anything positive in their lives.

Shame on the adults who condone this nonsense.

(163)
Lea,
November 13, 2013 8:00 PM

Come home

Dear families of Pine Bush, Life in Israel is not always easy. Things can be expensive and since I've been here my material comfort has dropped. Still, I have made my home nice and I have a different kind of comfort. My neighbors are Jews and they do not draw swastikas. COME HOME. Come now while you can still bring your "stuff" with you. The hardships are different here but they are not hate filled. Come home to the Land that *wants* you, to a government that will pay you, teach you the language, give you health care. Come home to the people who call you family. Even with all the "mishagas" this is your true home. Come on! Love,Lea

(162)
Judy Marker,
November 13, 2013 7:41 PM

Hate Crimes are not just directed at blacks

Hateful behavior and rhetoric is despicable, and this is punishable when directed at blacks. It should not matter who is victimized, we are a melting pot of a nation, and no group should be singled out for hate. And it should not be that certain groups are protected and others are left to fend for themselves. Why doesn't this school district undertake educating the students?? Isn't that supposed to be their mission?

(161)
Anonymous,
November 13, 2013 6:53 PM

stay strong

Please stay strong- I'm sure with all this publicity, conditions will change.Trust in G-d. As Jews we have made it through the very worst.We are behind you! We love u! Jews all over, unite!

(160)
sottsavd@otenet.gr,
November 13, 2013 4:29 PM

Be strong!

It's times like this that I want to quote Deuteronomy/Devarim 7:6

"For you are a holy people to HASHEM, your God, has chosen you to be for Him a treasured people above all the peoples that are on the face of the earth."

Take heart, He hears and sees what is happening in the world today. Remember that He is a Righteous Judge and He will judge the world one day.

(159)
Anonymous,
November 13, 2013 4:26 PM

B"H, I live in a Jewish community which doesn't experience a lot of Anti-Jewish activity. But we're all Jews, we're all mishpacha, and we feel what's going on. Just make sure that you assert your Judaism and your pride in it. Don't let the haters take that away from you. The best revenge is when we Jews survive, continue to practice Torah and mitzvot, and come out stronger.

(158)
myra,
November 13, 2013 4:00 PM

That school district needs EDUCATION! The students and teachers really need to learn about the Holocaust and Jews and prejudice. This should not be swept under the carpet.

(157)
Tovah,
November 13, 2013 4:00 PM

Stand strong

May HaShem give you the strength you need and the wisdom you need to figure out what to do. May your children identify strongly as Jews and find strength in it. May we all join together to educate people about what hatred does and how it isn't the way to go.

(156)
Anonymous,
November 13, 2013 3:24 PM

You are NOT alone

Not to be depressing but it is here, too, in Colorado Springs, CO. Much more insidious and definitely not so blatant but it is definitely here. The oddity is that much comes from minorities who have experienced prejudice in the past and now they feel entitled to share it. B"H we have Israel today. Maybe we all should go home.

Ben Zalman,
November 13, 2013 7:34 PM

The Jewish diaspora is necessary for a strong Israel.

It's amazing we Jews are still here with so many enemies for 4000 yrs. Hating Jews must be fun to those sickos who belong to the "blame the Jews for everything" club!

Jerry Meents,
November 13, 2013 8:09 PM

Home

Your so right,. We should all go home.

(155)
Melanie,
November 13, 2013 2:11 PM

I live in South Africa and we have very little anti-semetism and a strong ,but quite small Jewish community. I hope that this rural community in the USA can do something about their prejudiced citizens. It is very sad to hear about the suffering of thestudents.

(154)
Anonymous,
November 13, 2013 2:02 PM

Support in Israel

From all the way in Israel, you should know that we are praying for your safety, success and happiness. Reading about the strength of the families in Pine Bush has inspired me to be even more proud of my status of a Jew.

(153)
Sondra Wallace,
November 13, 2013 1:49 PM

UNACCEPTABLE BIGOTRY

This needs to be made nationally exposed and addressed by President Obama. We can be angry at many things - illegals taking advantage, gays demanding marriage and perks - on and on. However, a wise friend once told me - you can't talk in generalities. And it's true. Please expose this dangerous bigotry at the highest level.

(152)
Aaron,
November 13, 2013 12:31 PM

We're all in this together

Don't think this is happening only in New York (And don't forget that you're not far from the birthplace of the KKK.. Our shul in Texas is fighting a similar issue (albeit not as serious- yet) Anti semitism has been a rising issue throughout this country (as has happened historically in times of social/ economic turmoil) and we've been blind to it. As R. Weinberg Zt'"l mentioned, we have to wake up to it and word as hard if not harder than the haters to organize and grow our identity and pride- to grow the Jewish people AS Jewish people-regardless of denomination.

Anonymous,
November 13, 2013 8:18 PM

Stop turning the other cheak

Be fore WWII we had a large group of people who did walk around with pins on there cloting with a broken rifle, and no more war. look wat it got us by not more aggressive demonstrating.

We lost 110 thousand of our people in the exturmination camps and millions in othere country's.

(151)
Hal,
November 13, 2013 12:06 PM

stand strong

Stand up[ for yourself and others will also stand. Makingt this public and fighting against it will expose these people, once exposed the pressure will be brought to bear on them.

(150)
Lisa,
November 13, 2013 12:02 PM

Yes....I will stand with my fellow Jews

How can we REALLY help.....pls print a follow up!!

And yes, it took courage to even say something....Yasher Koach to them!!

(149)
Anonymous,
November 13, 2013 11:25 AM

"Spiritual Wastelands"

Shalom my name is Haydee with an accent on the last e. I want to do everything I am able to do to stand with the faimlies of Pine Bush. I myself have been challenge twice at a work place and I am sueing the Hotel where I workd. They hired me as a Jewish woman than after 4yrs, the new GM schedules me to work on the "SABBATH". I told her that she was breaking the law and she just shook her shoulder like saying ;"I don't care"! Well, they have been found accountable for breaking the "Religious Discrimination Laws" and I will stand again and fight the BULLYS out there! Haydee is my name and I am out of work for now and fighting the Anti-Semitism... I pray to HaShem to give us strength to stand up and fight these "Spiritual Wastelands". That is my Title of a poem for story I am writing. We must Stand together as ECHAD (ONE) as HaShem is ONE! Thank you!

(148)
Gila,
November 13, 2013 11:07 AM

Make Alyia

I can believe this. It is even better that it is blatant and transparent. In the time before Mashiach we are taught that we will not be able to trust anyone. This is an example. I think we should all be living in Israel. This might not be possible for some, but everyone who can should make Alyia. For those who can't the war against antisemitism should be waged! Keep it up! Keep fighting and fighting in as many ways as possible. This must be stopped and addressed.

(147)
Jp.,
November 13, 2013 8:51 AM

enough.....

The school and it's administrators and teachers need to be sued for harrassment....if this was against Blacks or Gays, none of this would be tolerated.

(146)
Bruce A. Lorence,
November 13, 2013 7:40 AM

Ugly truth exposed re. upstate New York antisemitism.

Antisemitism has long been a cancer in upstate New

York. Just look at New York State's capital city Albany--

Judenrein city and county government. The same goes

for the Albany Police & Fire Depts. as well as the

Albany Public Library system. Jewish teachers in

the Albany city school district have a very hard time

taking off for Jewish holidays (as do their Jewish

students). Swastikas have been daubed on the doors

of Jewish homes and on graves in local Jewish

cemeteries. Hitler truly would be very proud of Albany!!!

MURRAY SCHWARTZ,
November 13, 2013 12:25 PM

fight back

publily put pressure on the various non-jewish religious community leaders and clergy to take public positions on the danger of remaining silent. Who will the bigots attack next?

(145)
alan ziegler, Jerusalem,
November 13, 2013 6:53 AM

light years from NYC and around the corner to reality

Suggestion...Call Attorney Alan Dershowitz. A great Jewish advocate. He can create a two state solution. When will our brethren wake up to the historical paradigm that Jews are loved only when they nullify themselves and even then it is doubtful whether the endgame will be comfortable. Why would the America historical experience be any more sacred?

(144)
Anonymous,
November 13, 2013 6:26 AM

Hate must never be allowed to prosper

Cannot believe that this is happening in New York which has such a large Jewish population. We in Sydney, Australia, stand shoulder to shoulder with you and vow to fight this scourge wherever it may be.

Lisa,
November 13, 2013 12:05 PM

NY is not immune

.....& it happened in Poland....which had such a large Jewish population!!

(143)
Lovely,
November 13, 2013 5:53 AM

Be strong and courageous the almighty GOD will fight for you ?I understand the pain even after all these yrs y is that they try to harm the Jews coz these hooligans are plain jealous .in this whole wide world is there any country as strong ,courageous independent economically technically financially ? Well you have the answer .No country has the courage to stand you to Israel .it is the TRUTH . The GOD who made the world is with you ? TO hell with the others .

(142)
Fay,
November 13, 2013 5:35 AM

Bullys are cowards. All Jewish children from kindergarden up should be taught self defense. I would suggest the Israeli system.From the article it appears that the Jewish population is not a cohesive community.

Organize!

(141)
Yael,
November 13, 2013 5:28 AM

So sorry

I'm so sorry to hear. It's heart breaking. Even as we are regularly reminded of the repetition through history of this- it doesn't make it easier. And most of us pray it's not us in the dejavu. Please feel us loving you, even if you don't know who we are. It's irrelevant. Stay strong. Homeschool. I know it's not a possibility for most. Start your own school. We are there in spirit.

(140)
Kelly Rebekah ben Maimon,
November 13, 2013 5:09 AM

Families in Pine Bush

What a depressing state of affairs, that in my opinion needs to be highlighted widely, across the world!
To the families in Pine Bush, my message would be that you are inspirational, courageous and as the author Debbie said "You are not alone." Far from it. Just pray, recite Psalm 23 and know that Michael, Gabriel, Raphael & Uriel walk with you always. Hold on tightly to the Torah with both hands.
Why on earth the authorities are not stepping in to deal with this escalating situation is beyond belief. What exactly are they afraid of? A friend in the background has just shouted out "Their own shadows." Maybe so, but surely some one with power has the balls to deal with this and expose the perpetrators? Over here in England, it would fall in the category of hate crime and would be dealt with quickly. This kind of behaviour is not tolerated here. An utter disgrace that discriminatory action has not been dealt with!
London, England

(139)
Simcha,
November 13, 2013 5:07 AM

My Experience in the 1970's!!!

When I was in junior high school in one of the cities in the USA (not NY) from 1972-75, I was verbally harassed by many of the students in a school that I was the only Jew out of 2,000 students. Two students befriended me, one of whom was a big black boy; the blacks were also a minority in the school. The black student always defended me against those who harassed me. The teachers were on my side as well especially due to the fact that I was an excellent student. My parents (may they rest in peace) met with the vice-principal about the harassment but to no avail. When my parents met with the principal about the situation, not only did the harassment stop but the students apologized to me as well. The principal who was not Jewish fought against the Nazis (may their names be blotted out forever from the face of the Earth) in the war and when he heard about the harassment, he was furious. He was a very, very tough principal who the students except for myself despised and were very much afraid of him. He ran the school like a military man due to the fact that he was in the war and thanks to that path, the harassment stopped.

(138)
Florence,
November 13, 2013 4:47 AM

We are all equal

I am so sorry. I am not Jewish by birth but in a way I am. For we are all created equal - ALL. Just wanted you to know I am praying and care for you.

Anonymous,
November 13, 2013 8:23 PM

Thanks

Thank you very much.

(137)
Sarah,
November 13, 2013 4:46 AM

Our hearts and prayers are with you

May HasHem grant you strength, wisdom and clarity to deal with this unfortunate situation. Stay strong, keep your head high and know that you're in our hearts and prayers. Please teach your children the beauty of Judaism and connecting to Gd so it does not become something that they are just tormented about but rather something they are proud of and something worth standing up for. Kol Hakavod!

(136)
Ruth Broch,
November 13, 2013 4:39 AM

The only true solution

The USA has, indeed, become an anti-Jewish country under Obama, who has tried to marginalize, manipulate and destroy Israel. Jews of Pine Bush, do what I did over 42 years ago, a former New Yorker - come home to Israel. This is where all Jews belong. It is your Land, waiting for you. I still wake up every day thanking G-d I left the USA for our homeland.

(135)
Elana,
November 13, 2013 4:26 AM

Chazak,Chazak

This outrage brings grief,but also reminds us niot to tolerate this. You are not alone, there will be many to rise us and stand beside you. The entire ignorant town needs to be sued before,not after any further atrocities occur. This is Nazi Germany all over again. This time we can stop it before it goes any further. I am so sorry for your pain.

(134)
Tzofia,
November 13, 2013 4:13 AM

Chazak! Chazak! Chazak!

We must all stand as ONE against this monster that has never died...Pine Bush today...where tomorrow?

(133)
C. Hollander,
November 13, 2013 3:32 AM

Be Strong, Be Proud

Dear Victims of Pine Bush, may the Almighty give you the strength that you need to defend yourselves against the wicked anti-Semites in your midst. Stay strong and be proud of your heritage. Pray to G-d for the strength and wisdom to deal with these despicable acts of hatred. May G-d bless you and protect you always.

(132)
Yechiel,
November 13, 2013 3:11 AM

Standing up to evil takes courage

It takes a lot of courage to be able to stand up to evil and wrong doing. We can learn from Yacov Avinu in his dealings with esav in this weeks parsha. He prayed for success, made his efforts to appease, and was also prepared to fight if necessary. May your efforts be sucessful.

(131)
Elaine,
November 13, 2013 2:59 AM

As I read the above report and the comments, my first thought was how similar it sounded to Europe in the 1930's. "The only thing needed for evil to succeed is for good men to do nothing." Shame on you, Pine Bush citizens and school officials.

(130)
Karen calloway,
November 13, 2013 2:48 AM

wishing you strength and courage

I'm grateful to you for having the courage to stand up to these bigots. I wish you courage and strength as you fight to protect ourright to celebrate our faith and traditions.

(129)
Iris Adler,
November 13, 2013 2:47 AM

I am mortified to hear of this. Please tell the parents to go up to the Board of Education; bullying and hazing out of hatred has to be stopped. Go up!

(128)
Michele S.,
November 13, 2013 2:32 AM

We are with you!

Dear Jewish community of Pine Bush,We the Jewish people will rally around you! March, gather, and publicize what happened and we will be there with you. If it can happen to you it can happen to all our children, mine included. My great grandparents did not die in the camps for others to do this to our fellow Jews.It is unacceptable. We need to do something.

(127)
Mark J.,
November 13, 2013 2:22 AM

Publish the superintendents name and we can all

call and email and write letters.

(126)
AK,
November 13, 2013 2:19 AM

What exactly you suggest we do?

We as Jews are disorganized. Our intellectual elites are happy defending anybody but other Jews, they demonize Israel, on one hand, and visibly support causes, like open borders, that many Americans consider treasonous

Despite the antisemitic claims on the Right and on the Left, Jews have absolutely no power and no influence.

Perhaps the article in the NYT wakes few liberal Jews up to the importance of Israel as a shelter.

Anonymous,
November 13, 2013 8:32 PM

Most of use are scared of anti-semitism

I lost my grand parents, uncles, aunt's, cousins and any body I should have grown up with in the gas chambers. I was to young to do anything or save somebody, so after WWII I never turned the other cheek any more. Speak up and defend our self's. I do at 83 years old.

(125)
Anonymous,
November 13, 2013 2:19 AM

If there isa man who is your enemy, if you kill the man, no more enemy. We do not tke serious action against hatred. We must bemore proactive.

(124)
Donald James,
November 13, 2013 2:04 AM

I am with you

I am sorry to hear of this persecution and the listless response of the school authorities. As a Christian, I make it a point to stand with the Jewish people here in my Winnipeg community. I pray that many people will stand with you there in New York.

(123)
MICHAEL - Chicago,
November 13, 2013 1:41 AM

Horrible !!!!

I had to read this article twice to see I was reading of something that is now occurring. Is it 2013 or 1940 ?The entire community, all Jews and Gentiles of this area, should be standing with these tormented Jewish people. As a retired member of law enforcement, I am appalled that local and federal agencies have not taken up an active investigation of these hate crimes. I really wished I was living near this town to stand with these poor people that have done nothing to be subjected to this hate. The parents of these students that are abusing the Jewish Children should be ashamed of the way they are raising their children. But it appears they are feeding off the antics of these hateful children. Telling the Jews to relocate is totally unbelievable to say the least. Let us all pass this article on to everyone in our address book, Jews and Gentiles alike. The vast majority of Gentiles have no issues with Jewish people and support Jews whenever they can. The Jewish community of NYC, which is nearby should be livid and support these people. Be brave my dear brothers and sisters of Pine Bush. To say that this makes me sad is an understatement. May G-d be with you all. Thank you to AISH.com to bring this to light because we would of never heard of this being outside of NY state.

(122)
Tzippy,
November 13, 2013 1:35 AM

Hashem is always with us, always reminding us...

Hashem is always with us. We are in exile, true, but Hashem is always with us. Furthuremore, this should be a reminder to ALL Jews in exile - learn from history!!!! Every time that the Jewish people have gotten too comfortable and started assimilating in an a country of exile, anti-Semitism followed. The Jews of pre-war Germany said, "Berlin is our Jerusalem" and "Germany is a civilized country, it (anti-Semitism) could never happen here." Jews of America - LEARN FROM HISTORY. Yes - it CAN happen here - in our democratic Amercia. UNLESS we wake up an realize that we are in exile and pray for messiah. Anti-Semitism is G-d's way of reminding us that we are in exile, and that we are different - the Chosen People. REMEMBER!!

(121)
Kelly Ueber,
November 13, 2013 1:35 AM

Standing with you in prayer

I am deeply saddened to hear about the attacks on your children and your families. I am praying for you and that those in your community will come to their senses and do the right thing!

(120)
frayda,
November 13, 2013 1:31 AM

kidush Hashem

Your courage and strength are so admirable to us.know that G-d sees your pain and you are making a kidush Hashem -- sanctification. In your merit may we all be redeemed from this long bitter exile. We will keep up in mind in our prayers.

(119)
Adina,
November 13, 2013 1:29 AM

We stand with you!

The bullies feel threatened by you. You scare them because the light of G-d shines off of your faces. Don't stop fighting back! Know that you have the entire Jewish world behind you and supporting you! You are part of our family!

(118)
Jordy gold,
November 13, 2013 1:17 AM

Anti Semites.

When we were kids if confronted by Jew batters,we beat the living hell out of them....that is the only way....these rats see anything else as cowardice and it gets worse...if we were to small our older brothers and cousins took care of them...even our fathers took part if needed..one needs to fight..not talk

(117)
Samuel Weiss,
November 13, 2013 1:10 AM

Our heart does out to you but please don't give up...

Our heart does out to you but please don't give up...track this bigots down, put cameras on The Shules; expose these racist 'mamzers' in the papers and media, hire Israeli ex Sayaret Matkel security guards..,. expose them and pray and don't give up.

Fight them and win decent people are on your side. Don't dance with the bear slay it!

If yopu guys take flight in NY where's the rest of the USA going!

(116)
Aaron Shafter,
November 13, 2013 1:04 AM

NYers, Call Your Elected Officials

Call Senators Schumer and Gillibrand. Call your Representative in the House. Call your state legislators. Call the Governor. Call NY Attorney General Schneiderman. Do more than just sympathize. Call the US Attorney for NY.Do something usefull. Demand these officials intervene.

(115)
Michelle,
November 13, 2013 12:58 AM

Don't feel alone

You are not alone. And be cause you are not alone, don't let anyone bully you! These are people who feed on hatred and who feel powerful when others are intimidated. Use every, every legal tool at your disposal to show the haters you are not going anywhere, that you have just as much right to live there, and in no way, shape or form are you ashamed of being Jewish. They don't like it, they can move.

(114)
Howard,
November 13, 2013 12:57 AM

Time to go on offense- in a good way

All the lessons regarding Holocaust education are for naught if Jews don't protest and organize- The police and courts need to be involved to deal with these hooligans. Parents need to join together with teach-ins: Sullivan and Ulster are the heartland of Jewish agriculture, by the way. Little Sholem, New York housed the earliest Jewish farming community there in 1832. So who was there first? The gentiles are badly in need of an education. Am Yisrael Chai!

(113)
p.herring,
November 13, 2013 12:31 AM

Has the JDL been made aware of these incidents

Sadly there are times when local authorities, be they police or in this case school officials, do not act for whatever reason - if these kids had been Afro American rest assured the instigators would have been identified with steps taken to ensure there were no further such incidents.Ideally JDL representatives would request permission to address the school students simply stating that all are proudly Americans irregardless of color,religion and ethnic backgrounds. The short talk would be completed by telling students the JDL would be monitoring the situation and no further anti-semitic behavior would be acceptable - media would be asked to attend and publicise the meeting especially as it is probable the school(s) in question would not readily comply.Such action might serve to push the local Police into monitoring behavior of known offenders.

(112)
Anonymous,
November 13, 2013 12:23 AM

We understand what the Bush pine Jewish families are going through

We had to leave France 11 years ago when 2nd intifada started in Israel and was sort of imported there. We did not have the courage to handle the terrorism threats in Israel at that time as it was so unbearable in France. So we decided to go in US. When we arrived in Florida, we were so surprised by the nice atmosphere which prevailed. Dancing in the streets with the sefarim on simchat Torah? Wow (unthinkable in France). No palpable anti-Semitism. However, we were fearing that this was probably just delayed because the extremists would do their job and propaganda here in US too. And this is happening, it started about 10 years ago on the campuses.The problem is the same: people around don't move when Jews are attacked. The world did not change and did not learn nothing. Instead, school authorities ask the question: "why don't you move from here if there is too much anti-Semitism?" Instead of doing all possible to stop it. So they send very bad signals of impunity to anti-Semitics. What to do to stop when it is STILL time? The students should be trained to know what to answer, how to counteract propaganda relentless and organize groups to explain and explain again, if anti-Semitism takes the face of anti-Sionism, why Israel is in his rights and remind historic facts. The high level authorities have to be reached and aware folks that they want tolerance 0 (that's what they say in France....)Thank to G.od and Israelis courage, we have Israel that we have to cherish and support as much as we can. In Israel, if somebody is in danger, everyone will be there to help him. This is the difference. If nothing is done NOW, a day will come where we may have to move from US as we moved from Europe where the atmosphere became unbreathable.Dear brothers from Pine Bush and elsewhere, try to act together in your city, don't stay isolated. Call the Jewish federations of Nth America to be guided toward the right one who can help: Phone: 212-284-6500.

(111)
Katie,
November 13, 2013 12:09 AM

The school Administrators need to be educated. They probably don't know how to stand up for something they don't know much about. Ignorance is not bliss.

(110)
Jim Wright,
November 13, 2013 12:06 AM

No tolerance for these school officials

There should be a zero tolerance policy against school officials and educators who take such matters so lightly. Sounds like this school district could use some education in holocaust studies. Perhaps these folks should visit the national holocaust museum.

(109)
Margarita,
November 12, 2013 11:55 PM

the bystanders are the most guilty once

Do not fear your enemies. The worst they can do is kill you. Do not fear friends. At worst, they may betray you. Fear those who do not care; they neither kill nor betray, but betrayal and murder exists because of their silent consent.”— Bruno Jasienski (Yasensky)

(108)
Yahoshua,
November 12, 2013 11:37 PM

we must never forget

Anti-Semitism is on the rise. We must never forget that what happened in Europe between 1939 and 1945 can happen again. The only thing preventing that is our own willingness to stand proudly for who we are and to combat anti-Jewish hatred and violence wherever and whenever it occurs. I am proud of the parents and students for filing suit against the school district and its ignorant officials. May you go from strength to strength.

(107)
Jack Altabef,
November 12, 2013 11:25 PM

Jews have been fighting prejudice and persecution for a very long time. I know that the only way to put an end to this is to take action every time we hear it, To ignore it is to tacitly accept it.

Anonymous,
November 13, 2013 8:33 PM

Yes, Yes, Yes

Dear Jack, you are so right.!!!!!

(106)
Frederica,
November 12, 2013 11:24 PM

Make anti-semitism illegal

In some European countries anti-semitic acts were made illegal.I think our legislators should do the same here. Hate speech is not free speech and should not be allowed. Any institution that receives government funding and allows any anti-semitic words or actions should have the funding rescinded.

(105)
Anonymous,
November 12, 2013 11:10 PM

This is so sad. I think they should do something to lower the anti Semitism in this school. I thought the statement by Elazar Shach ztz"l was very interesting and inspiring.

(104)
Samsmom,
November 12, 2013 11:08 PM

I feel their pain

I experienced similar abuse when I attended school in the 1970's. I was a black child in an almost all white school. I was singled out for abuse, sidelined and neglected. No one did anything. One teacher even told my parents it was so sad that I was a bright child because I was destined to do domestic work and being smart would make me unsatisfied with my fate.

I had hoped that things like this were history. But no, it is sadly the same. My son, who is converting to Judaism, has experienced it. I pray that the children who experience this discrimination and harassment can rise above it to speak out about it to the next generation. They have so much to be proud of.

(103)
Susan Robb,
November 12, 2013 10:50 PM

Support for all of my Jewish family

I am not Jewish by birth, but my dear mother instilled a love for the Jewish people since I was a young child. I have my own passion and love for the Jewish people and the land of Israel because I am a Christian. Please let me know where to write ( Congressman) for I will not be silent in this matter! I have written my Congressman (SC) with regards to Iran's nuclear enrichment and the stand we should take which affects our nation and Israel!! My prayers are with you and the Living God answers prayers !!!I I will pray for protection for you and the evil behind this to be stopped!!!

(102)
Jo,
November 12, 2013 10:45 PM

what can we do? so sad.

This is so hard to believe. In the U.S & N.Y no less. How did it get to this point. So sad! Are any other minorities bullied ? What can we do to help in some way?

(101)
Anonymous,
November 12, 2013 10:41 PM

The US Jewish community must support them

if the haters are more united than the defenders than all Jews will have failed, "Hitler was serious" should be remembered and if the Jews were united and more against him who knows. All Jews an decent people should make it their business to show their support.

(100)
rochelle,
November 12, 2013 10:41 PM

Unbelievable that this is happening in America

Unbelievable that this is happening in America-hey, wait! Isn't that what they said about Germany?

(99)
Michael Dorf,
November 12, 2013 10:39 PM

I live in Pinebush

I live 10 minutes out of Pinebush with a weekend house and have been up there for 25 years. I've never seen or heard of any of this before the recent articles. I am upset deeply and want to help in any way I can. I perhaps think a large Menorah for Chanukah should be placed on Main Street and lit with a peaceful message and engagement for the community. I am game to help organize.

(98)
Anonymous,
November 12, 2013 10:36 PM

Don't give in! A message from Australia

Although I am sitting in far off Australia I feel I must copy. A few years ago some antisemitism comments were daubed on a sign outside our Melbourne Shule.

Everyone was shocked. One of the Shule's committee members got up and clearly and defiantly said " we're not going to stand for this we're going to put up another sign and these thugs aren't going to isn't intimidate us we're proud we're Jews"

Accordingly if we in sleepy Australia can do it surely you blokes in the USA the leaders of the free World aren't going to be intimidated by these thugs! Be proud that we're Jewish the children of the prophets Abraham YITZCHOK and Yaacov Sara rivka Rachel and Leah!USA get up and show the GAON Yaacov pride to be Jewish don't be intimidated by these antisemitism thugs expose these racists in your media let people know we're not going to be pushed around when it comes to our sacred religion. These bigots will be punished for their antisemitism.The end of the story at our Shule was an even bigger sign went out in front of our Shule and the event was a huge success!

Anonymous,
November 13, 2013 8:36 PM

None

Great, never give up.

(97)
Anonymous,
November 12, 2013 10:26 PM

Strength in numbers

It sounds to me like Pine Bush NY would be a great winter break destination. These people need us to stand with them both in spirit and in reality.

(96)
Conrad Nadell,
November 12, 2013 10:15 PM

Get help from Jewish organizations

Anti-Semitism unfortunately remains a fact of life. In small communities with few Jews, victims of anti-Semitism can be particularly exposed to hatred and even violence. This is against Civil Rights legislation which makes the experiences described in the Pine Bush case. I suggest the Jewish families that are experiencing blatant anti-Semitism and physical attacks contact the Anti-Defamation League and ask for legal assistance to punish the guilty and hold the school systems accountable.

(95)
Dora,
November 12, 2013 10:13 PM

Ignorance and

It's frightening to know that there are people out there who have deep hatred in their hearts. The children accused of bullying and harassing Jews were likely taught to hate Jews at home. It's incredibly sad that parents/caregivers pass on ignorance, venomous hate and intolerance onto their impressionable children. It's even sadder that the school district doesn't take action. They can create a program that promotes tolerance of Jews and other groups/faiths so that children can have the chance to live a life free of baseless hatred. I commend the victims in this scary and difficult situation-continue to walk in strength with Jewish pride. No one can bring us down except ourselves. My heart and prayers go out to the Pine Bush!

(94)
Savtamama,
November 12, 2013 10:11 PM

You are all in my prayers! This article brought me to tears, thinking of these Jewish children suffering. I hope you can find a quick remedy. Meanwhile, may these trials be an opportunity to learn more of Yiddishkeit.

(93)
Dolores Wine,
November 12, 2013 10:02 PM

the NY Times article upset me terribly---90 miles from my home!

It is unbelievable that there is still so much hate for us. Thesekids need to be reeducated and worked with so they expendtheir energy on better things. Actually it is probably what theyhave heard in their homes---it is the adults who also have to be held accountable. We are a multi ethnic society and and need to have tolerance for each other. My thoughts a prayers are with the Jewish Families of Pine Bush School District.

(92)
Sandi,
November 12, 2013 9:49 PM

God give you strength

I wish I ahd answers, but I do not.

(91)
Aaron,
November 12, 2013 9:46 PM

Recognize that there are many in the NY and National community who will be ready to demonstrate their support in ways that you might feel would be helpful. The school officials may have become aware of this through the publication of the MY Times article but should a more forceful demonstration be appropriate, I am certain that this support can be made to be more evident.You are not alone.

(90)
Don Krausz,
November 12, 2013 9:37 PM

You must fight, if only for your own self esteem.

You must fight!! You don't have to win. Those who insult or attack you must know that starting with a Jew means that they will have a fight on their hands. Just as they can hit or insult you, so you can retaliate. Join a boxing, karate or krav maga club.At first you will be scared but after the first blows have been struck you will be coming back with a vengeance! If they use weapons then so must you. Organise the other Jewish kids to stand by you and you stand by them.

Concentration camp survivor.

(89)
maxine k winston,
November 12, 2013 9:22 PM

disgusting & reprehensible

Reading this right after Krystal Nacht, just shows how anti-Semitism continues to grow. My heart & prayers go out to the victims, but they need more-HELP. What are the local police doing about this mess? Has anyone contacted the governor of New York & New York's congressional delegation? We need to stop this, before it catches on in other places.

(88)
Ed G,
November 12, 2013 9:05 PM

Disgusting

I have written to my local civic newspaper and the NY Times regarding this matter. Any official investigation by Gov. Cuomo or Attorney General Eric Schneiderman must be extremely thorough. Let's find out how many Jewish teachers and other Jewish personnel have left this district. Obviously, there are federal and state civil rights violations here. A judge must not just slap the wrist of the guilty. I don't want to hear that they're to write a term paper on the holocaust or see "Schindler's List." Something is terribly amiss here. Those guilty should face expulsion and the parents be fined. Those parents on welfare should have their benefits reduced. The school hallways, from pictures, look like 1933 Berlin. Where is the AFT in this matter? We have heard NOTHING from Randi Weingarten about this disgrace. The National Guard needs to be called in as it is obvious that school authorities can't control the situation. I also read that the District Superintendent is involved in a suit trying to keep a Yeshiva out of the neighborhood. This place is nothing more than a hotbed anti-Semitism. Let's make sure that all of this is not merely swept under the rug.

(87)
sophia rubinstein,
November 12, 2013 8:57 PM

how to help that community

Would someone tell me how it is possible to visibly support this upstate community and make an educated and civilized stand against this and change the community schools policy to zero tolerance and bring in jewish educators to lecture in thta community

(86)
Bracha,
November 12, 2013 8:50 PM

To all of the families being targeted and affected:
I am so sorry that you are going through this. Please stay strong and stick together. We are praying for you and thinking of you here on the west coast.
I hope things only get better from now, and that they are dealt with properly soon. Hashem is with you!!

(85)
Debra Hebb,
November 12, 2013 8:47 PM

Anti-Semitism in New York

Stand together and do not allow your children or community to be bullied by this vile hatred. Has anyone contacted the Fox News with Hannity or O'Reilly to report this? Because of the huge ratings and balance in reporting stories like this, it is sure to get coverage and positive actions. Standing with you in prayer for a peaceful resolution. Show no fear and remember G-d is your shield....Peace

(84)
Harriette R. Ellis,
November 12, 2013 8:41 PM

Shocked

IAs a former editor of a Jewish newspaper in California, I know that anti-Semitism, neo nazis, and their ilk abide in most states of the union, but to hear of such hate bias and virulence in New York State is indeed a shocker! I only hope that the authorities will take steps to change this situation immediately. This story needs to be spread across the country and shame brought to this town.They need classroom Holocaust education available through the ADL, the National Holocaust Museum in D.C. and Southern Poverty Law Center. What are they waiting for?

(83)
Francine Goldman,
November 12, 2013 8:22 PM

Pine Bush Schools Anti Semitic Hazing

THE WAY HATE GROWS IS FOR GOOD PEOPLE TO DO NOTHING! THERE ARE LAWS IN PLACE IN MOST AREAS NOW AGAINST ANY FORM OF HATE AND HAZING. THERE ARE ALSO LAWS AGAINST DEFACING PUBLIC PROPERTY. ALL OF THESE LAWS HAVE BEEN VIOLATED. IF THE SCHOOL DISTRICT OF PINE BUSH WILL NOT DO THE RIGHT THING, THEN CARRY IT TO HIGHER. IF PEOPLE ARE HATED BECAUSE OF RACE, SEX, SEXUAL ORIENTATION, RELIGIOUS BELIEFS, IT IS AGAINST THE CONSTITUTION. THE AMERICAN CIVIL LIBERTIES UNION SHOULD BE ALERTED AS WELL AND LAW ENFORCEMENT. HAZING HAS BEEN BANNED IN COLLEGE FRATERNITY AND CLUB INITIATIONS AND IT ANGERS ME TO SEE IT GO UNCHALLENGED IN A RURAL SCHOOL DISTRICT. THOSE VIOLATORS ARE NOT ONLY PHYSICALLY ASSAULTING STUDENTS, THEY ARE DAMAGING TAX PAYERS ITEMS LIKE THE COMPUTERS, PLAYGROUND EQUIPMENT, WALLS OF BUILDINGS, AND THERE IS NOTHING BEING DONE ABOUT IT. IT IS BECAUSE THE LEADERSHIP IN THIS TOWN ARE THEMSELVES ANTI SEMITIC. THIS IS WHY THIS SHOULD BE TAKEN TO HIGHER AUTHORITY IN A CLASS ACTION LAW SUIT, ALL VICTIMS AND PARENTS OF THEM AND PEOPLE WHO WISH TO STAND WITH THEM, INCLUDING LOCAL SYNAGOGUES AND CHURCHES. THE ACLU HAS ATTORNEYS THAT WILL TAKE THIS SORT OF CASE. THE PROBLEM IS APATHETIC PEOPLE THAT DO NOT CARE OR "IT DID NOT HAPPEN TO ME SO WHY SHOULD I GET INVOLVED"? TYPE OF PEOPLE. WHEN INNOCENT PEOPLE, ESPECIALLY SCHOOL CHILDREN'S CIVIL LIBERTIES AND THE BASIC CONSTITUTIONAL RIGHTS OF ALL PEOPLE ARE VIOLATED, IT BECOMES EVERYONE'S PROBLEM AND CONCERN. IF IT CAN HAPPEN TO ONE GROUP OR SECT OF PEOPLE, IT CAN HAPPEN TO ANYONE. TODAY IT IS THE JEWISH CHILDREN, TOMORROW GAYS, NON WHITE, ETC., CAN BE VIOLATED. HATE IS HATE THAT GROWS LIKE WEEDS IN AN UNATTENDED GARDEN THAT CHOKES THE LIFE OUT OF THE THRIVING PLANTS. IT IS TIME TO PULL UP THE WEEDS AND TEND THE GOOD PLANTS. REMEMBER THE NAZIS ALSO PUT OTHERS IN CAMPS THAT STOOD WITH THE JEWISH PEOPLE OR ANYONE THAT HITLER DIDN'T LIKE. GAYS, HANDICAPPED, NON GERMAN, POLITICAL PRISONERS. HALT ALL HATE NOW

(82)
A. Eller,
November 12, 2013 8:11 PM

NYT's "Swastikas, Slurs and Torment in Town's Schools"

I just read the New York Times article referred to in Ms. Gutfreund's piece; I also read the comments. One of the things that struck me about the comments was the unrestrained resentment of the Pine Brook community for Kiryat Yoel, the nearby Chassidishe community, the Jews of which are slyly referred to as "certain populations' or "certain groups." Another striking point is the recollections of former Jewish students at Pine Brook Central, confirming a long-standing hatred for Jews there, going as far back as the 1970s. (This alongside claims of non-Jewish students that no such hatred existed.) The oddest point, however, is the quote of Philip Steinberg, Pine Brook’s school superintendent. While it appears clear that he has shirked his duties, and in my opinion even turned on those who have most needed the protection he could have provided, he hits upon a truth. He challenges the parents of harassed Jewish students, asking, "If being Jewish is so important to you, why would you move into a community that does not have a synagogue?" Now, I believe that the parents are right in their attempt to seek justice through the court system, and am sickened by suggestions that the suit is anything but such an attempt. Nevertheless, Steinberg’s question is a good one. It seems to me that these Jewish children should have been, and should be, thoroughly educated as to the Truths of Judaism that continue, after millennia, to rile others. The strength of the Jewish People, a strength which would help sustain these victimized Jewish children, lives in the knowledge of what is unique and precious in Judaism. That’s something hardly discoverable in a shul-free town.

(81)
Herbert Kohn,
November 12, 2013 8:01 PM

Lesson of the Holocaust: We must learn not tobe Bystanders

I am a child Holocaust survivor and speak 40 times a year to schools, churches, civic clubs, etc. concerning "The Lessons Holocaust". As long as these crimes against Humanitycontinue, we must stand UP not stand BY to learn how to stopthese crimes through education and awareness of what really happened during the Holocaust..

(80)
susan,
November 12, 2013 8:00 PM

antisemitism is alive and well and living the the usa

it is ludicrous that zero tolerance policies expel a 5 year old for pointing a finger as though it were a gun, yet does nothing to stem the viscous tide of antisemitism that is rising int his country.

remember - all it takes for evil history to repeat itself is for good people to do nothing. as long as we stand by and do nothing about situations like this it will be tolerated. these people are breaking the law in many instances. if law enforcement will do nothing find lawyers who will.

it is time for all of us to stand up and say "NEVER AGAIN"......make them pay!!!!!!!

(79)
Anonymous,
November 12, 2013 7:48 PM

Be proud of who you are

Just before Rav Hutner died he was asked what is the most important message to convey to our children as we eductae them? He answered,"Asher bachar banu," - G-d chose us. Lift your head up high and know that as a Jew, you are on a different plane of existence (see Kuzari). It is our mission, as Jews, to transfrom this world from physical to spiritual. My father-in-law became a baal teshuvah when he saw swastikas on his locker in school. He wondered why his Jewish identity mattered so much more to them than it did to him. So he studied Torah to find out. Please don't place money above your safety or above the education of your children. G-d is the One who supports us all. Do what is right and what must be done, and G-d will figure out your finances for you.

(78)
Carol,
November 12, 2013 7:35 PM

Be encouraged! You are greatly valued

May G_d bless you with His safety and protection. And may you be girded up in His strength and shalom every day.I stand with you against such ignorance and hatred.

(77)
Meir,
November 12, 2013 7:33 PM

Who are you, Mr. STEINBERG!

If you are a Jew, Mr. Steinberg, then you are derelict in your responsibility as a Jew! By not finding a way to stand by and vigorously defend the civil rights of your school, you are also derelict in your duty as an American citizen to uphold the constitution of the USA.
As for my brothers and sisters of Pine Bush, I suggest it's time, this month of Kislev, the month of Hanukah, to begin to uphold the Torah by observing Shabbos, learning Torah, doing acts of loving kindness to one another, and thereby sanctify G-d's Holy Name.
Abe Foxman, where are you? Is this not a situation that needs the power and the resources of the ADL?

(76)
Norma,
November 12, 2013 7:30 PM

Horrified that such anti-semitism is rife!

My real sympathies to the children and parents in this dreadful situation.I think that they have to act together and take out an injunction on the head teacher and the school boards who are permitting this sort of thing to go on.Then I think there has to be a public demontrationof the values of Judaism- start witha public menorah, a chanukah lighting and doughnuts, and a speech about our religion.What rabbonim or Chabad or Aish have you got to help?Have strength and do not give in.Write to President Obama and ask him if he thinks this is ok in the USA>

(75)
Anonymous,
November 12, 2013 7:30 PM

Apathy

An Apathic Spirit causes the good to say nuthin. That happened in the 30's and 40's in Germany as they progressively took away rights until there were no rights for anyone.

(74)
Paul Price,
November 12, 2013 7:28 PM

saddening

It deeply saddens me that antisemitism still rears its ugly head wherever and it is a cancer on the face of the earth. The Jewish people are as precious to God now as they always have been, that's why whatever field be it science, medicine, arts, inventions, its always a Jew at the top of that field, because God says to the Jew first and then the gentile. I am a gentile but have a deep love and respect for the Jewish people.

(73)
Brian M,
November 12, 2013 7:27 PM

Christians That Support You

Prayer group has you in support. We support Israel.

(72)
sharon tessler,
November 12, 2013 7:27 PM

Where can we write directly to the superintendent and have u tried to have a holocaust surviver come and talk to them I know the name of2 survivors.

(71)
ROSENBERG,
November 12, 2013 7:26 PM

ANTI-SEMITISM

I AM WILLING TO LEAD A MASS PROTEST. RABBI DR. BERNHARD ROSENBERG CALL ME 732 572 2766. I WILL HELP YOU WITH PUBLICITY ALSO. I AM A SON OF HOLOCAUST SURVIVORS. AND AN ACTIVIST.

(70)
Anonymous,
November 12, 2013 7:24 PM

Anti-Jewish violence: It happened to me and now it's happening to Jews in Pine Bush

What happened in Pine Bush must be condemned by Jews and non-Jews. That such a thing can happen in 2013 after so many years of "Holocaust education" only shows how deep rooted the anti-Jewish sentiment is in many American communities. Also, that such cowardice can be exhibited by school officials - some even Jewish themselves - is a complete disgrace. There have always been such syncopate Jews who try to ingratiate themselves with bigots - but that they should show no shame - is disgusting.

I urge the parents of these children to speak out loudly and pursue justice for their children and accountability from school officials.

I can't conclude without mentioning my own experience with anti-Jewish violence. More than 56 years ago at the age of 7, I had a friend in the second grade. When I went to his home to play, his mother asked me my name. When I told her - she said "Is that a Jewish name?" I said yes. About a week later, just before Easter, I was walking near school in East New York, Brooklyn. My friend's older brother - about 14 years old - walked up to me and used his arms to put a vice-grip around my neck. As he choked me, he looked down at me and said "You dirty Jew. You killed my god. Stay away from my brother!" I don't know how close he was to breaking my neck, but it hurt for two weeks. Needless to say my friendship ended, but I was too young to know enough how to report the incident.

I am requesting that Aish inform us how to support the children and parents of Pine Bush.

(69)
Hampton S. Tonk,
November 12, 2013 7:22 PM

To Defend the Jews Is to Defend Humanity

One of the measures of civilization is how it treats its minorities, whether those minorities be unborn children, Jews, blacks, or any other minority group.

If that is the measure of how civilized we are, we are getting an "F."

To defend the Jews is to defend all of humanity. If we allow one Jew, or one member of any minority to be devalued or regarded as subhuman such that he can be attacked and even killed, then we have opened the door to ourselves being attacked and killed.

If it is God's precious gift that the Jews be His Chosen People to manifest His glory in all the world, than an attack on the Jews is an attack on God Himself.

Historically I must mention that every regime and nation which has ever messed with the Jews has been utterly destroyed.

Wickedness and evil will, in the end, always be subject to the Judgment of God. The Law of Consequences has not been repealed.

(68)
Roberta McLoughlin,
November 12, 2013 7:17 PM

Hatred starts at home.

Children are taught this hatred at home. There is so much hate in this world and why on earth do they want the children to be bottled up with anger and hate? It's hard to understand.

(67)
Anonymous,
November 12, 2013 7:16 PM

JDL

Where is the JDL when you need them?

(66)
abe zelcer,
November 12, 2013 7:09 PM

there is no room for hate in the USA.

As a child of survivors, this particular story is appalling. In todays America there is no room for any kind of hate. The superintendents comments were defeatist and the situation should not be accepted. Jail the perpertrators. Educate the parents because there where prejudice begins

(65)
Anonymous,
November 12, 2013 7:05 PM

New York anti-semitism

I encourage the parents of these students to contact the ADL, an attorney and the local newspapers with all the disgusting speech and actions directed toward their students. This is an outright travesty of justice, as well.

Let sing!!!!! and lets remember the Holocaust composers."Songs Of My People" is my cultural musical project, aimed at preserving Jewish cultural heritage. I have gathered songs in Russian and Yiddish, a language which was put on the Red List of Threatened Languages by the UNESCO. Before World War II, the number of native Yiddish speakers amounted to 11 million people. During the Holocaust, over 6 million Jews were killed, and the number of Yiddish speakers was halved. The language is still prevalent in modern literature, speech, and songs. Music has an ability to reflect and portray various events, religion, work, folklore, life, death, family etc. in a way that no other art form can. Each song of my people tells a story and opens a window onto our traditions, beliefs, sufferings, hopes and dreams.

(63)
Mary Spaulding,
November 12, 2013 7:01 PM

Feeling Ashamed

Since my fellow countrymen feel no shame in tormenting children, Jewish or otherwise, I feel shame for them. I regret that this can happen in my country. I do not understand how anyone can feel they can treat others in this way.

(62)
Deb shmidman,
November 12, 2013 7:01 PM

We are thinking of you and if you are being scapegoated it's as if we are all. We are all one people. Be strong and I pray you see justice soon.

(61)
Alan Zoldan,
November 12, 2013 6:58 PM

What happened to tolerance and mutual respect?

Having grown up in NYC and still living in the NYC area (and notall that far from Pine Bush, I am so sad disappointed to read this. Are there no students, parents, or administrators willing to step up and confront this evil? I won't even call it ignorance, because I'm sure, in their hearts, these people know that what they are doing is wrong. Like they say, all that is necessary for evil to triumph is for good people to ignore it, minimize it, or look the other way. I hope and pray that now that this has become a more public matter, there will be more pressure to flush this hatred out. Governor Cuomo has said that there will be an official inquiry. And why hasn't the ADL weighed in on this -- aren't hate crimes like this their whole reason for being?

(60)
Carroll Peterson,
November 12, 2013 6:57 PM

The shadow of HItler is alive and well in Pine Bush

Experts need to come in and educate the whole community about anti-semitism and the Holocaust. A lot of the bullies probably don't even know about it. I hope the courts give a large settlement against the school district.

A. Eller,
November 14, 2013 1:00 AM

RESOLVING ANTISEMITISM

Antisemitism will not be mitigated by educating non-Jews. It is irrational - and I'd say even supernatural in the extent of its irrationality.

Lloyd George in 1928 said:

“Of all the extreme fanaticism which plays havoc in man’s nature, there is not one as irrational as anti-Semitism. … If the Jews are rich [these fanatics] are victims of theft. If they are poor, they are victims of ridicule. If they take sides in a war, it is because they wish to take advantage from the spilling of non-Jewish blood. If they espouse peace, it is because they are scared by their natures or traitors. If the Jew dwells in a foreign land he is persecuted and expelled. If he wishes to return to his own land, he is prevented from doing so.”

Professor Michael Curtis, of Rutgers University, pointed out in 1987:

"The uniqueness of anti-Semitism lies in the fact that no other people in the world have ever been charged simultaneously with alienation from society and with cosmopolitanism, with being capitalistic exploiters and also revolutionary communist advocators.

"The Jews were accused of having an imperious mentality, at the same time they're a people of the Book. They're accused of being militant aggressors, at the same time as being cowardly pacifists. With being a Chosen people, and also having an inferior human nature. With both arrogance and timidity. With both extreme individualism and community adherence. With being guilty of the crucifixion of Jesus and at the same time held to account for the invention of Christianity."

This strange blight called antisemitism will not disappear by way of normal solutions; it is not non-Jews who must be educated in who Jews really are. It is we who must be educated in who we really are.

prayers are going up night & day until Hashem cuts off the right hand of Y'sraEl's enemies everywhere! B"H

(57)
Heidi T.,
November 12, 2013 6:55 PM

Horrified.

I'm horrified that this type of thing is still going on in 2013. I wish there was something I could do other than pray, but know that my thoughts and prayers will indeed be with you all.

(56)
Rivka,
November 12, 2013 6:51 PM

I understand

I too experienced some antisemitism in public school but not to this extent. It is time for this to be widely publicized in order to bring general, not just Jewish, condemnation. What is the name of the local newspaper? Which television stations are received in the area? We should all contact the school district as well.

(55)
MIriam,
November 12, 2013 6:50 PM

Support from Israel

My thoughts and prayers are with you!!!

(54)
CK,
November 12, 2013 6:49 PM

We mustn't forget . . .

The one ultimatum in this tragedy of persecution and all Jewish suffering is that Hashem has allowed it to happen for our benefit . . . and only one response that we have can guarantee Hashem's help to overcome it. The event happened to the people in Pine Bush so we should all be affected by it. THE ONLY WAY TO EFFECTIVELY HELP THEM AND OURSELVES is by following in the ways of our Avos, our M'forshim and chazal's teaching by CRYING OUT with a full sensitized heart to Hashem to intercede on our behalf. Hashem is a living God and is only sitting back because we think we can make sufficient changes BY OURSELVES. If we will only truly cry for our persecuted children in true tear ridden tefillo, Hashem will respond IMMEDIATELY and we will then know what we have to do to stop their persecution. America and the Nazi's would like to teach us the God is dead (hasv'shalom and ridiculous!) and that are prayers are a cop out and not doing anything. BUT THEY ARE WRONG!

Allow this event to affect you as I have and raise the heaven's with your protests. (Precede your outcry with praises of Hashem's malchus and endless strength to intercede on our behalf). If you truly believe Hashem loves us and wants to help us (which he promised in the Torah which can never be changed or taken from us) than HE WILL! Our despair is OUTRAGIOUS! Hashem is so much stronger than them and is only waiting for our outcry . . . SO GET BUSY! Fulfill the words of our sages and tell your friends to join you to - - - IT'S OUR OWN FAULT THAT WE'RE STILL IN GOLUS! AS SOON AS WE WANT TO GO OUT, HASHEM WILL HELP US COME HOME! (read page 19 of Rabbi Shimshon Pinkus' book on Shabbos "Nefesh Shimshon: Shabbos Kodesh"

CK

(53)
Michael Schwartz,
November 12, 2013 6:41 PM

We are here to help

I work with groups nationwide, and we are willing to come help combat the ignorance, bullying and indifference through the arts, please find me on FB or the web. You are NOT alone, millions are with you - Speak OUT, Contact the Media, Protest, Reach Out, NEVER BE SILENT, we can help you build coalition, establish dialogue and much more. There are many other groups, Jewish and non, that can help out as well - we will not tolerate and kids being bullied or targeted.

(52)
matis,
November 12, 2013 6:39 PM

Be More Jewish

I feel for the children and adults going through this terrible situation. If moving is not an option - being more Jewish may be. Hashem sends messengers to remind us that we are jews - the more jewish we are the less need for any reminders. Stand Up! Be Strong! Continue to speak out. Send your story to the media.

(51)
Laura Goldmeier,
November 12, 2013 6:39 PM

thinking of you

Praying for everyone in Pine Bush. Let us know if there is anything else we can do to help.

(50)
Yochanan,
November 12, 2013 6:38 PM

Build up in spite of the tearing down.

This is unbelievable that such anti-semitism goes on today unchecked. Of course, anger and sadness are right emotions to feel, but there needs to be a desire to educate, build up, comfort, and live. This especially needs to be done among the Jewish community for it's these things that have the potential to knit us together.

(49)
Anonymous,
November 12, 2013 6:37 PM

Sad to see this has persisted and gotten more overt

I grew up in Pine Bush (graduated in 1980). I experienced many instances of ignorant/not intended to be offensive anti-Semitism then, and it was a hard place to be a Jewish kid. It's amazing and sad to me to see the attitude has persisted to this day, and risen to the level of swastikas and purposeful harrassment.

(48)
Hadassa,
November 12, 2013 6:36 PM

Stay Strong!

It pains me so much to hear about the hate and torment my Jewish brothers and sisters are experiencing in Pine Bush. I hope and pray that this appalling display of antisemitism and apathy will come to end. And I hope that the Jewish families there can build a strong community and support system, to keep themselves strong. Thinking of, and praying for you all!!

(47)
William Leonard Lambert,
November 12, 2013 6:31 PM

Support Jews where I live

My Father always said that our family will defend and support the Jewish people right here where we live and then through our example of behavior perhaps others will see the loving acceptanced of the chosen people of God and hopefully drop thier hatred and stupid unwise attitude. Dad was a wise man, loving and we so enjoyed being friends of the Jewish neighbors. I want you here and know as I bless and support you God will bless me. The Holy Book says..."If you bless my people I will bless you. So see my family has been and continues to be blessed along with your blessing.

(46)
Richard Lindner,
November 12, 2013 6:30 PM

Where are the Jewish Lawyers?

We need the lawyers to step forward & force the School District to do whatever is necessary to fix the problem.

(45)
myriam le van,
November 12, 2013 6:29 PM

what kind of generation is this country building?

Shame on the parents of the haters, shame of a school system that does not teach nor enforce basic morality any longer... My heart goes out to the victims. Please circulate a petition! This is unacceptable!

(44)
Anonymous,
November 12, 2013 6:28 PM

Be proud

My heart goes out to you all. I hope eventually you will be able to relocate to friendlier territory but for now be happy and proud you are who you are and not one of these animals tormenting your families. Although the kiddush HaShem you're making in the world is painful for you, you will in the long run be richly rewarded.

(43)
Tehila,
November 12, 2013 6:28 PM

History repeats itself...

I was born in NYC and raised "upstate NY" too. When the economy is good and the general populace is happy, they often ignore us. Historically when the opposite is true - as is the case now - Jews are always the first to be blamed and attacked.

IMHO, suing and raising awareness and attempting to combat ignorance are a waste of time. The man was right when he said "they [Jews] don't belong here". The USA did fulfill it's purpose in providing a TEMPORARY refuge for Jews fleeing persecution in other lands. But the time has come to go home to Israel, the only land where we really have a right to expect to live freely and openly as Jews. Every other country belongs to other peoples.

May the light of Chanukah enlighten the Jews of America before intermarriage and antisemitism cause a holocaust of a different type.

(42)
Ann,
November 12, 2013 6:27 PM

School and town officials bear responsibility for halting this

The Pine Bush town adminiatrators and the Pine Bush school officials bear full responsibility for ensuring that Jewish children can attend the Pine Bush school without any harressment or prejudice-based tormenting, bullying or anti-semitic taunts. The ability to attend school in a harrassment free environment is part of the civil rights of these students. I suggest that fedetal law enforcement officials be contacted to enforce the civil rights of these students.

(41)
Devorah,
November 12, 2013 6:26 PM

Never Give Up

Tell us what we can do - can we petition government officials? Can we put this despicable community on the 6 o'clock news to shame them before the world? It must NOT be tolerated and these lovely children of Abraham must not be treated this way. I am doing the most powerful thing I know to do which is to pray but if someone in the area organizes things outside the spiritual realm, I will be happy to participate!

(40)
Dvirah,
November 12, 2013 6:25 PM

Illogic

One of the most amazing statements made in this article is the complaint that Jews "don't drive" - did he mean on Saturday (Shabbat)? We shouldn't need to point out that a decision to drive or not on a particular day is a personal one and no-one else's business; but the very illogic and inconsequence of such a complaint is quintessial anti-semitism. Would it be possible to show these people to themselves, show them the pettiness and irrationability of their thinking and behavior and thus shame them out of their hatred?

(39)
Barbara Goldin,
November 12, 2013 6:24 PM

Anti-Semitism in our Schools

1. The current and new Govenor of NY need to get involved.2. Rabbis and congregations need to protest at school3. News reporters of the NY times need to report about this4, Go on Fox, CNN and local TV channels to report this5. Where is the UN when we need them? Same place, no where.6. Circulate this article on other web sites, world wide7. Continue with the law suit. Need to donations for this?

(38)
Dennis R. Green,
November 12, 2013 6:23 PM

The Hits Keep Coming!

To hear about Jewish kids gettin beaten in New York reminds me of when I went to High School in Berkley, Mi in the late 50's and early 60's. Berkley was a largely gentile community. The High School had about 1,100 students at the time- with about 100 Jews included. I personally endured taunts and insults, although I was only attacked physically once at the neighboring Jr. High, where a kid threw a basketball at my crotch as hard as he could in gym class. I saw stars, and not the six-pointed variety! The teacher, of course, did nothing.
My point is that discrimination against us is nothing new. It has been going on for 5,000 years or so, and it just appears in similar forms everywhere. I often ask people what Israel ever did to Iran to merit such hatred. Nobody seems to know. Any theories out there?

(37)
Dave,
November 12, 2013 6:22 PM

So What other Action Items are planned to combat this

BH*Hello Fellow Table 43 Attendee!,'So, I wonder out loud- Who in the School District is pushing back and does it serve Aish well, to provide a link to the email addresses of every School Committee member and faculty? This way we could easily take the next step, in "Push Back"Knowing it is the first step, but without a push back plan we are actually helping our enemy by taking no further action and demanding a policy adjustment. The student who got expelled for having a pop tart shaped like a pistol was expelled! Where is the policy that says this is inappropriate and who is tasked with enforcing it???

(36)
Fr, Joseph Mirowski,
November 12, 2013 6:22 PM

responsibility as a Christian

I am a Priest in the Greek Orthodox Church, my question is for those so called Christians who stand by and do nothing, what part of love and defend your neighbor don't you understand!!!!!!!

(35)
S. Metro,
November 12, 2013 6:22 PM

Jewish in rural America

-must be difficult, and apparently NOT only in the South, a target, I think, of a different prejudice! This article made me think of my own Jewish husband, now in blessed memory, and his mother, also remembered as a very proud Jewish woman who instilled this in her son. NO ONE in this wonderful country should feel endangered or anything less than the person they are. Hope that the kids and fheir families turn this around, and the bullies who are doing this become ashamed of their actions enough to quit!

(34)
Anonymous,
November 12, 2013 6:21 PM

Be strong

I am shocked and astounded : this is worse than what occurs in France and parallels Hungary. Let it be an eyeopener to US Jewry that things are not so very different in the USA. Take courage, our thoughts are with you! Try approaching individual non Jewish studens and use publicity to help. Hold together and remember, the law is on your side. Be strong!

(33)
Anonymous,
November 12, 2013 6:20 PM

Tell the WORLD!! Lets do something to help!

My thoughts and prayers for those children and their families. there is no excuse for this...it needs to stop NOW. Is there an address we can send support and/or letters to stand up for these kids?

This is the first I've heard of this, it should ne covered in the news. These children and their families need support! I'm confident Jews and Non Jews from around the world not just in NY would help and show support. This is blatantly wrong and against their civil rights.

(32)
srtdc,
November 12, 2013 6:18 PM

we must stand united with our fellow Jews in Pine Bush

Rivka...This is a time for action... as well thoughts and prayers. As the torah states..."Thou Shall Not Stand Idly By". Leviticus.

Is it possible to use this forum to organize a rally/demonstration of support? Any thoughts or suggestions...?

(31)
ajones,
November 12, 2013 6:13 PM

you have some who care

although I live far away I offer the support of my family and I.Be assured that those who sow hatred will not go unpunished as 'the One who watches over Israel niether slumbers or sleeps'Ps 121:4

(30)
Lewis,
November 12, 2013 6:11 PM

Nothing New Here!!!

Nothing new at Pine Bush; I will never forget almost sixty years ago when I was ten years old; and leaving my Hebrew school in the Bronx; I was attacked by five gentile boys; I fought back both that lasted less than a minute; what I remember most was the adults just walking by as I was beaten to a pulp and doing nothing; I survived and made a promise to myself that if I ever saw another Jew attacked I would fight the attackers; I kept my word; I lost some fights and others I won; but the damn Jew Haters knew Jews take care of one another; it is time to take care of the Jews in Pine Bush, and bust a few new nazi dogs!!!! Chazak, Chazak,Chazak!!!!!!

(29)
Stuart,
November 12, 2013 6:09 PM

This is disgusting and outrageous.

Has the ADL been made aware of this? Some parts of NYS, in particular, and the country, in general, have a long history of anti-Semitism. In many cases, the local politicians are part of the problem, not willing to stand up for what is right.

(28)
Marilyn Nathan,
November 12, 2013 6:09 PM

Where is the antidefimation league? They should be involved

I wish I knew the answer that would make Anti-Semitism go away. I think people will always need to blame someone else for their short comings. Jews have been the target for thousands of years. It is because we are a smart group and have found ways to survive even the worst of the worst since the time of Abraham

(27)
Yochanon,
November 12, 2013 6:09 PM

My prayers are with you. May Hashem bring peace to your town and to all of us soon.

(26)
Annette,
November 12, 2013 6:07 PM

They did the same thing in Skokie, IL

There was a similar incident years back in Skokie, and the police merely told the harassers to stay across the street! Interesting that in Detroit the police made Americans to leave the Muslim area for nothing more than handing out pamphlets. Gosh, I wonder which is worse - hope everyone enjoys what this country is coming to when we have to set aside our religions preferences for the Muslims! Oh, excuse me, that is already happening, isn't it? As for the abuse, get used to it. They enjoy inflicting the worst kind imaginable. I am personally sick to death of the garbage this country allows to happen to innocent people.

(25)
Anonymous,
November 12, 2013 6:04 PM

What to do?

Request Governor Cuomo, local politicians, school administrators, teachers and parents to come to someplace neutral or if necessary a synagogue to condemn and set up a program to address the situation on an ongoing basis. Where both sides can talk and resolve individual and other issues. request the Southern Poverty Law Center to bring in teachers and materials to "Teach Tolerance." If need be, engage counsel...

(24)
Roberta Hess,
November 12, 2013 6:02 PM

Pray,stick together,and stay informed!

(23)
Burt,
November 12, 2013 6:02 PM

Stay Strong

It is a shame what has happened in Pine Bush!! This should not happen in the united States of America...especially in New York State. Where are the politicians??? when they are needed??STAY STRONG and keep us informed. They need help...NOW!!

(22)
pnina baim,
November 12, 2013 6:01 PM

the school must do better or be penalized

Never stop fighting for justice. These students should be compensated for their misery, and the offenders expelled. Don't give up; history is on your side.

(21)
josiah english,
November 12, 2013 6:00 PM

Be encouraged!

Though I worship the same God, led by a different Jewish Rabbi, we are told to count it all (persecution) for joy ... work for change now, but rejoice; the difference in destination of those scrawling hate, warrants it.

(20)
jgarbuz,
November 12, 2013 5:53 PM

What's so new about swastikas in New York?

I was born in a DP camp in Germany after WWII, but grew up in Brooklyn. Once, when I was 14 i was invited down some kid's basement to jam on the guitar with them, and I was startled by a HUGE swastika on the wall. I pretended not to notice, and they pretended I wasn't Jewish.

(19)
Paul K,
November 12, 2013 5:49 PM

Antisemitism

This is not an isolated case. As much as we and our politicians would like you cannot legislate away hate. I heard it said that antisemitism is in peoples DNA. This is another example why Israel is important, the one place we can feel truly free.

Do not give up, keep speaking out. Where is the Anti-defamation league, ACLU?

(18)
Alfredo,
November 12, 2013 5:46 PM

Support by 100%

I'm not Jewish, but I support you 100% This should not be happening and should never happen in any part of the world.

(17)
Reva,
November 12, 2013 5:46 PM

Support for Pine Bush Jews from CA

It is shocking & disturbing to read this report of whst is happening in Pine Bush. It is obvious that the ignorance goes beyond the school & the students but also to the adults there as well. My heart breaks for the students - children who have to live in daily fear just to get an edjucation in public schools - it is even mor insidious to read the comments of the Superintendent w/ a Jewish name who basically sits by & lets this continue - this town needs an education about the Holocaust - someone newds to contact the Museum of Tolerance here in L.A. & have them get involved - get them to speak to the Superintendent - get a program going in all the schools wducating students & parents - have survivors & ex-white supremicists come speak @ the schools - contact Steven Speilberg & his Shoah Foundation - get this on Mational news -the best thing that can happen is lots of publicity - get some big names w/ power & $$$ involved - where are the local synagogues & chabad in the area? Why arent they helping these families? My heart breaks over this story - know that you are in my prayers here in Hollywood!

(16)
Robin Rosenblatt, M.Sc.,
November 12, 2013 5:44 PM

Poor Education

Leads to coward like behavior.

(15)
April Sharrock,
November 12, 2013 5:43 PM

We are so sorry for your pain and pray for your strength and wisdom in handling this. There must be something else that we can offer from this distance though. Public outcry, protest of some sort, a petition...Please inform us of the practical help that we may be able to offer.

(14)
Lou,
November 12, 2013 5:40 PM

Write to the school board as well

Show the school board that there is national, and international, condemnation of their lack of action to resolve this problem.

(13)
Nancy,
November 12, 2013 5:40 PM

The school administrators are shirking their responsibilities BIG TIME! Zero tolerance policy for fighting? What type of policy does this district have for hatred and anti Semitism? These horrific actions of harassment need to be stopped yesterday and the harassers need to be criminally charged for their actions.

(12)
Donneal,
November 12, 2013 5:38 PM

Keep your chin up

i am deeply saddened to hear what the families have been going through. Everyone in NYC who heard the stroy was quite sickened. Remember why the nazis hated us - because we have conscious and morals. you are in good company.

(11)
Josephine Bacon,
November 12, 2013 5:36 PM

Incredible!

I met a Russian-Jewish woman in California who said that she had encountered more antisemitism in the USA than in Russia. Now I believe her.

(10)
Bill Morgenstein,
November 12, 2013 5:33 PM

Anti Jewish is fine but disrepect Islan is a NO NO!

The school district says we must ignore Swastika's and Jew hatred but try putting a picture of Mohammed up and then hear the roar and outcry. (Including from Jews).

Or let a 5 years old point their finger like a gun and they are castigated and thrown out of school!

(9)
Mary,
November 12, 2013 5:30 PM

I pray for strength for everyone. This breaks my heart.

(8)
EstherAsna,
November 12, 2013 5:28 PM

H-shem should be with you

and all of us in Galut and we have to do what we can to bring the Geulah soon!

(7)
Anonymous,
November 12, 2013 5:28 PM

The Individual Right to Keep and Bear Arms. . .

Tu., 11/12/13 common era /// While not a panacea for all forms of anti-Semitism, the 2nd Amendment to the U.S. Constitution confers an individual, G-d-given right. to keep and bear arms. American Jews should seriously considermaking Aliyah now, before the situation worsens. The overall tone for this old hatred is set by the Oval Office, and the A.D.L. is as useless now as it was 70 years ago.

(6)
Carol Otero-Oquin,
November 12, 2013 5:26 PM

Support in Travisty and Injustice

I am amazed this barbarism continues. Our Father surely loves us to cause us to endure so much. I keep you in my heart and prayers.

(5)
seymour,
November 12, 2013 5:19 PM

Terrible situation. But unfortunately not surprising. Anti semitism has proven to be anywhere and everywhere. Even in the "safe" haven of America.

(4)
Linda,
November 12, 2013 5:13 PM

Please dont forget that the Swastika is also a Hindu symbol of good. So terrible that the Nazis used it for evil.

Diina - Jerusalem,
November 13, 2013 8:52 PM

are you normal?

What a sick, stupid comment.

(3)
Chana Block,
November 12, 2013 4:35 PM

It's so disgusting to see Jewish children abused like this! I hope the superintendent allowing this to happen is fired.

(2)
Rivka,
November 12, 2013 2:31 PM

Feeling sad

My heart goes out to all the victims in pine bush! I wish you a lot of strength in this difficult time! I hope this problem will be resolved quickly! Be strong! Our thoughts and prayers are with you!

sruli,
November 12, 2013 8:34 PM

enough

Where are our leaders, where is Abe Foxman, where is the OU, why are we not having marches and demonstrations in this horrible town. Prayers and feeling bad is nice but enough my fellow Jews, if we would have marched and demonstrated in 1933 perhaps things would have been different. There are many Christians who find this behavior disgusting as well and they would join us in the protests. Boycott this disgusting town and show them we are not going to take it again, we are tired of being sheep, WAKE UP JEWS this is just the beginning we have to stop it now.

ms Bo Salsberg,
November 12, 2013 9:20 PM

While we are free to choose, why stay when we're not wanted

The threat of another Holocaust can only be achieved by standing still and doing nothing. At all cost, both financial and mind setting, my parents refused to live in neighborhoods that were not Jewish oriented. As a post war family in the US, we always had Jewish neighbors, shuls and opportunities that would offer the children hope, respect, knowledge and friendship in a world that will never be equal. Why then are we moving backwards. How can we stay in areas that are potentially harmful to our children. This has nothing to do with money. How much will it cost you in the end to stay put amongst hate and discrimination. Cut your losses and get out while there are choices to be made.

(1)
G. Berry,
November 12, 2013 1:22 PM

You left out a very important part of the original article in your summary. The Jewish children who were physically and verbally attacked and bullied said the worst and most hurtful part of their experience was to see the many, many kids who watched the abuse as bystanders, but did not speak up against it nor do anything to stop it.

Anonymous,
November 12, 2013 7:12 PM

Important to know, but ...

At least three key facts were omitted from this otherwise important article. First, to provide context, the writer should have given the size of the Jewish population relative to the general population. Second, the article failed to mention a large rally in which Pine Bush residents denied being racist and blamed the problem on a dispute involving a Jewish developer in a nearby town. Third, despite the claim in the subheadline that "nobody is doing anything about it," Gov, Andrew Cuomo ordered last week that the New York State Police and state Division of Human Rights investigate the situation. All of these facts were widely reported in the New York area last weekend.

Anonymous,
November 12, 2013 7:48 PM

There is a message in the madness

When Jews try to assimilate, G-d sends anti-semitism to remind us who we are and where we are supposed to be. I highly recommend "A Divine Madness" by R' Avigdor Miller; it's a provocative and politically incorrect book about why the Holocaust and why anti-semitism has and is happening.

Herbert Kohn,
November 12, 2013 8:01 PM

We must learn and teach not to be Bystanders

I am a child Holocaust survivor and speak 40 times a year for the last 35 years about "the Lessons of the Holocaust". My main message is to prevent the ongoing crimes against humanity, we must learn and teach how NOT to be Bystanders in an appropriate non confrontational way. It is our common obligation to make this a better world for the privilege of living in this world.

Anonymous,
November 12, 2013 8:17 PM

Do not lay down and die

We Jews know you cannot turn the cheek on Jew haters. I believe we must train our youths in self preservation as the historical survival of us depends on our strength . This shouldbe a international cry for all Jews in our present world.The haters wont go away , so we fighy!

Marv,
November 14, 2013 12:05 AM

same old hate

As I previously said, being nice in spite of the nonsensical hate and turning the cheek wont work. We have to adopt a manner of toughnest to deal with ignorant people and the best example is the Israeli people

G.C.,
November 13, 2013 6:11 AM

My greatest respect and admiration to parents who complained!!!

It takes great courage to stand up when most of others don't. Some people think it is pointless and those voices will not be heard. It is cowardly thought. This article reminder to all of us. What seemed just a little trifle end up being Holocaust. My greatest respect and admiration to parents who complained!! Bravo!!!

ricky,
November 13, 2013 6:57 AM

The above article is absolutely disgusting to us Jews.Im from South Africa so we don't really have a huge Jewish community for the hatred to get out of hand but I somehow think to myself,its never gonna end.If its been going on since the dawn of time,its not going to get any better now even with the world becoming more civilized or tolerant.We should never take it lying down but I guess its our fate.We will always be the minority and the persecuted.

We have a canistel (or eggfruit) tree our backyard which we’d like to get rid of. We do not eat its fruit, and the fruit and leaves make a constant mess. I haven’t found anyone who is interested in its fruit – even to take it from us for free. I would like to replace it with an orange tree (we live in Miami). Is there any problem doing so?

The Aish Rabbi Replies:

The Torah actually writes specifically that we may not cut down fruit trees (Deuteronomy 20:19-20). From this the Sages learn a more general principle that one may not purposelessly waste or destroy anything of value – food, good utensils, clothes, etc. (see e.g. Talmud Baba Kama 91b, Shabbat 140b).

The Talmud (Baba Kama 91-92) distinguishes that whenever there is a legitimate reason, one may cut down a fruit tree – if it damages other trees or plants, if it’s not productive and not worth its upkeep, if it’s more valuable for the wood, etc. The commentators include in this dispensation when ones needs the space the tree is growing on (Rosh Baba Kama 8:15).

There is, however, a frightening line in the Talmud there which makes people much more hesitant to rely on the above leniency. Rabbi Chanina stated that his son died young as a punishment for his cutting a fig tree before its time. Thus apart from the legal issue of destroying a productive tree, this law appears to carry with it severe Divine retribution.

Most authorities explain that this punishment is incurred only if a person cuts down a fruit tree without legitimate reason, but there is a minority opinion that it is incurred even if the tree is cut with good reason.

As a result, even in cases where a legitimate reason applies, people generally take an extra precaution of first selling the tree to a non-Jew, and having a non-Jew do the actual cutting. (The entire prohibition does not apply to non-Jews.) Your case is also better in that you are cutting one fruit tree to plant another, more productive one. Even with all of this, it’s preferable, if possible, to leave a part of the original tree intact.

In 1942, Hitler devised a plan for a Museum of Judaism, to remember the dead Jewish religion, culture and people. Millions of Jewish treasures -- Torah scrolls, ritual objects, books and art -- were looted by the Nazis and taken to warehouses. In Czechoslovakia, the objects were taken to the Jewish Museum in Prague, where the Jews themselves were forced to sort, label, and pack the items for use in the Nazi's future museum. After the war, many of these items were recovered, including thousands of Torah scrolls and nearly one million books. These were distributed to Jewish communities worldwide, as a living testimony to the indestructibility of the Jewish people.

One who humiliates another person in public ... even though he may be a scholar and may have done many good deeds, nevertheless loses his portion in the eternal world (Ethics of the Fathers 3:15).

Imagine a situation: you have a fine home, a well-paying job, a comfortable car, and a substantial retirement annuity. If you do a single thoughtless act, you will lose everything you have worked to achieve: home, job, car, and savings. What kind of precautions would you take to avoid even the remotest possibility of incurring such a disaster? Without doubt, you would develop an elaborate system of defenses to assure that this event would never occur.

The Talmud tells us that everything we have worked for during our entire lives can be forfeited in one brief moment of inconsideration: we embarrass another person in public. Perhaps we may say something insulting or make a demeaning gesture. Regardless of how it occurs, the Talmud states that if we cause another person to turn pale because of being humiliated in public, we have committed the equivalent of bloodshed.

Still, we allow our tongues to wag so easily. If we give serious thought to the words of the Talmud, we would exercise the utmost caution in public and be extremely sensitive to other people's feelings, lest an unkind word or degrading gesture deprive us of all our spiritual merits.

Today I shall...

try to be alert and sensitive to other people's feelings and take utmost caution not to cause anyone to feel humiliated.

With stories and insights,
Rabbi Twerski's new book Twerski on Machzor makes Rosh Hashanah prayers more meaningful. Click here to order...