Search This Blog

Watandost in Urdu, Turkish and Farsi means "friend of the nation or country". The blog contains news and views about Pakistan and broader South West Asia that are insightful but are often not part of the headlines. It also covers major debates in Muslim societies across the world.

Asif Ali Zardari as the President of Pakistan

Can anyone name a Pakistani soul who has more votes in our presidential electoral college than does Mr Asif Ali Zardari? To be certain, presidential-hopeful Zardari is a product of a process – a process called elections. He is also a product of a system of governance – a system called democracy. We have had generals Ayub Khan, Yahya Khan, Zia-ul-Haq and Pervez Musharraf as our presidents and none of them were products of a legitimate electoral process (didn't they broke into the presidency led by the Triple-One Brigade?). Ayub, Zia and Pervez all descended as guardian angels but faded away as Lucifers-in-uniform.

Our most recent messiah-in-uniform, General Pervez Musharraf, managed to attract $12.277 billion in overt aid from the US. Then there was a 5-year-long Saudi Oil Facility (under which the Kingdom gave us up to 100,000 barrels of oil every day). Additionally, during Musharraf's 8-year rule Pakistanis working abroad sent in a wholesome $33.277 billion. That's a colossal $45.554 billion, but look at where we stand now: we are begging the US for flour; we are begging the Saudis for oil; we are begging everyone else for dollars. We have no atta, no electricity and no dollars.

Mr Asif Ali Zardari, no messiah he is. He surely has his share of flaws, perhaps more than his share of stains. More recently, he has added another hefty log – breaking another written promise – to the already backbreaking baggage he has been carrying around. But, let him who is without any flaw throw the first stone.

President-to-be Zardari is certainly no angel – remember, angels don't breathe. So far, Co-chairman Zardari has taken us all on a rough, bumpy, treacherous, a rather deceptive ride. Not too long ago, I had asked my readers if they had ever experienced a desert safari in Dubai. When the desert ranger comes to pick you up from your hotel he isn't really the type you would normally trust. You discover he is a rash driver. You soon discover he goes back on his words. Then he, unexpectedly, jumps the red light. Is he a lawbreaker too! As the sun descends into the horizon, you find yourself in the middle of a dune field; crescentic sand dunes, linear and parabolic, moving dunes, reversing dunes and dunes interacting with the wind (that's present-day Pakistan). The ranger, unexpectedly, speeds the 4X4 to the top of a dune and you feel elated (that's the Bhurban Declaration). The ranger then lets the vehicle into a freefall and you feel you are in the middle of Death Valley National Park (Zardari goes back on his written commitment). When would this roller coaster end? Where would this crafty charade take us? Seems like eternity but your ranger finally stops the vehicle. You realise that you are still in one piece and that there's barbecue, henna painting and belly dancing. You stare back at your ranger but this time in a different light.

Mr Zardari has the political right as well as the legal right to occupy the presidency. Does he have the moral right? Again, let him who hasn't sinned throw the first stone…

We can talk about individuals, along with their flaws, and what they have delivered. We can talk about presidents Iskander Mirza, Ayub Khan, Yahya Khan, Fazal Elahi Chaudhry, Zia-ul-Haq, Ghulam Ishaq Khan, Farooq Ahmad Leghari, Rafiq Tarar and Pervez Musharraf. On the other hand, we can talk of due electoral processes and how these processes have delivered in countries around the world.

We have had our share of messiahs – uniformed and otherwise – perhaps more than our share. We need no more messiahs. Processes is what we need because processes deliver, individual don't. Systems deliver, individuals don't. Let us, for once, put processes in place, a system of governance in place. Once we have a strong system it shall on its own throw all the bad apples out.

Postscript: A month ago, US Carrier Strike Group (CSG) led by USS Abraham Lincoln was ordered to move from the Persian Gulf to the Gulf of Oman. If that wasn't enough, another U.S. Carrier Strike Group led by USS Ronald Reagan has now moved in the 5th Fleet Area of Responsibility (AOR).

The writer is an Islamabad-based freelance columnist. Email: farrukh15@hotmail.com

Popular posts from this blog

Inside Story about Musharraf-Mahmood TussleHassan Abbas: September 24, 2006

General Pervez Musharraf’s memoir In the Line of Fire is expected to generate a lot of debate and discussion in the days to come. Except some western journalists and Musharraf’s close friends (three ghost writers) hardly anyone has had a chance yet to read the book from cover to cover. The excerpts of the book leaked through Indian media and General Musharraf’s statements to some American media outlets however have already created some controversies. In the United States, controversy is considered a positive thing, so the book is bound to become a bestseller here, but in Pakistan probably the opposite is true.

This article is not a review of the book (as I haven’t got hold of a copy yet), but it endeavors to throw some light on the widely reported Musharraf comment about the Armitage threat conveyed through Lieutenant General Mahmood Ahmed, the then Director General of the ISI. I had done research on this speci…

From Stalemate to Settlement: Lessons for Afghanistan from Historical Insurgencies That Have Been Resolved Through Negotiations
by Colin P. Clarke, Christopher Paul, RAND, 2014

In June 2013, the Afghan Taliban opened a political office in Qatar to facilitate peace talks with the U.S. and Afghan governments. Negotiations between the United States and the group that sheltered al-Qaeda would have been unthinkable 12 years ago, but the reality is that a negotiated settlement in Afghanistan is one of several possible end games under the current U.S. withdrawal plan. Negotiating an end to an insurgency can be a long and arduous process beset by false starts and continued violence, but a comprehensive review of historical cases that ended in settlement shows that these negotiations followed a similar path that can be generalized into a "master narrative." This research examines 13 historical cases of insurgencies that were resolved through negotiated settlement in which neither sid…

‘Get your facts first, and then you can distort them as much as you please’. Mark Twain

Pakistan is in the throes of a judicial crisis since March 2007. On March 09, 2007, general Pervez Mussharraf summoned chief justice Muhammad Iftikhar Chaudry to army house. He was asked some tough questions and then asked to resign. Chief justice held his ground and refused. He was kept at army house for several hours so that an acting chief justice could be sworn in. Justice Javed Iqbal was sworn in as the senior most judge justice Rana Baghwan Das was out of country. Chaudry was given the title of ‘suspended’ chief justice and his case referred to Supreme Judicial Council (SJC) for action. This started a crisis where majority of the people denounced the cavalier manner in which general Mussharraf dealt with the chief justice. Legal community fully supported chief justice by boycotting courts and b…