Jay Mathews Yields to Persuasion

You have to admire Washington Post columnist Jay Mathews for his openness to persuasion. Unlike so many education commentators, he is willing to budge an inch or two in the face of compelling arguments.

With its all-or-nothing focus on passing state tests, No Child Left Behind turns a blind eye to much excellent work in schools.

Current accountability policies encourage schools to focus on "bubble kids"--students just under the passing bar. Meanwhile, those schools leave other children behind.

Mathews' instinctive reaction to the "bubble kids" phenomenon is fairly common: "A good principal...would put an end to such nonsense." This response certainly carries genuine emotional weight. Still, it puzzles me that so many DC policy wonks invoke it in defense of No Child Left Behind in its current form.

What, after all, is the point of a policy that creates poor incentives and encourages perverse behavior? If we can rely on everyone to do the right thing regardless of consequences, then we hardly need accountability systems in the first place.

As Mathews realizes, even good principals succumb to pressures to focus on "bubble kids" when the stakes are so high. When he learns that the founder of DC's much-admired Cesar Chavez charter school does it, he concludes that it is "a bigger problem than I thought."

Sure, many schools offer all children rich instruction in the liberal arts and still manage to reach their performance targets on state assessments. This website celebrates many such schools. But is such courage always or even often rewarded? Are impressive achievement gains always recognized in AYP determinations?

Mathews recommends broader, fairer and more accurate measures of school and student success. Like many, he calls for measures that gauge students' academic improvement over time. He also seconds his young teacher's call for a more comprehensive vision of success:

It would be better to credit the school for important successes outside of testing, Fine wrote, such as "when a teacher energizes a reluctant reader to tackle a novel, when a struggling math student starts coming after school for tutoring, when an administrator finally gets a troublemaker to reflect on her actions."

...

There should also be a way to honor Fine's request for an extra dimension, such as reporting a rise in students doing scientific experiments or writing analytical papers. Some monitoring systems, such as those used by International Baccalaureate programs, do that. It is part of good teaching and should be available to everybody.

Using richer and more accurate measures for accountability purposes won't be easy. But many more people now agree that it's important.

Update: A kind reader discreetly informed me that I had misspelled "persuasion" in the title of this blog posting. How embarrassing. At least I got it right in the text of the posting. Apologies for the lapse.

I'm glad someone recognized the image included in this posting! She's one of my favorites--a photographer who turned photography into an art form in the 1860's, a time when many others feared it heraleded the end of all art and beauty.

Claus - as you know, I hang out in a virtual community with outstanding teachers from across the USA. In our daily discussions over the past six years, many many members of the Teacher Leaders Network have shared stories about the bubble-kid focus in their schools and districts. Why in the world do we think (or expect) that principals will take heroic stands against such practices, in the face of pressure from central office leaders, local media, state regulators, and political forces in the community to raise test scores.

School leaders who perceive the rules of the game as unfair will soon engage in strategies to get around the rules. We need a new game and we need to involve principals and teachers in creating fair rules.

Featured Story

Every Student an Individual

Strong teacher commitment to rigorous, personalized instruction has lead to a higher graduation rate and greater participation in postsecondary learning opportunities for a racially and economically diverse New York high school. Learn more...