Literary:
Pemberley- The name of Mr. Darcy's home in Debryshire, sounds similar to Kimberly but prettier if you ask meDarcy- speaking of Darcy, a very popular and cute girls nameCora- A charaters name in the book, Last of the Mohicans, and its a very common name nowSydney- Tale of Two cities CharacterLucie- unique spelling from a character of A Tale of Two CitiesMayella- Character in To Kill a Mockingbird, written by southern author HarperLeeHarper- Look above

You already have such beautiful childrens names, I really hope these help!

Names that feel classic and vintage-y but also have literary & faith connections and are well-known imo:Lucy -means "light" which would be a great name for a December baby, since the Light of the World was born at Christmas (although, I'm assuming that when you said your faith was central, that you're Christian... but if you're Jewish, it also works for Chanukka )Jane -means "God is gracious"Phoebe -Biblical name that also means "light"
hope that helps (sorry list is so short -baby's nap is finished now )

You guys, these are great! Thank you so much. You would not believe how many of these names have been on my lists between last time and this time. Southernbeauty's list looked like a list of my husbands aunts and cousins!!

Ok, so here are some of my favorites that are usable (ie not already in the family, etc), but still nothing husband approved: