Omelas Literary Argument

March 26, 2012
The Iron Curtain of OmelasThe short story, “The Ones Who Walk Away from Omelas”, written by Ursula Le Guin, is about a so-called perfect society where the sacrifice of a child is what provides harmony, equality, and prosperity to the citizens of this city. As a reader, one is invited to create and visualize their own utopia, so that one is emerged with the reality of a moral dilemma: the happiness of many for the unhappiness of one. The symbol represented in the story reflects current and past society issues such as military sacrifice, slavery, and injustice.

The narrator describes the city of Omelas to have no king (president), political system, technology, weapons, or many of the things that currently permeate our society. The story portrays a utopia where the citizens of Omelas enjoy freedom and pleasures much like Americans do today because of the sacrifice soldiers give everyday for the citizens of the United States. The town sacrifices the child’s existence of a normal life for the sake of peace and freedom, whereas in the real world, soldiers sacrifice their lives for the sake of peace and freedom for their nation. One can tie the sacrifice the child endures for the way of life in Omelas to the sacrifice of the soldiers in the U.S.; however, many of the soldiers in the U.S. make their own decision about enlisting in the Armed Forces, whereas the child’s decision was not if its own. However, one can also compare the child’s predicament to those drafted and required to go to war, which are required to sacrifice their lives for the people of its land as the child sacrificed its freedom for the citizens of Omelas. Conversely, the narrator shows the reader that a perfect society should not celebrate victory in war and blood, but rather celebrate peace and love between humans. The narrator goes further and states, “[b]ut as we did without clergy, let us do without soldiers” (244). Clearly, if there is no conflict between nations, there would...

You May Also Find These Documents Helpful

...Cameron Young
Ms. Newsom
Composition 1302
2 April 2012
Simply a Bad Case
Is the outcome of our lives predetermined before we are born or by the environment in which we are born into or is it determined by our own free will? “These are some of the many questions that plague humanity, the questions that give philosophers, sociologists, scientists, and writers material with which to work” (Hicks). In the short story Paul’s Case: A Study in Temperament, Willa Cather uses these questions to tell of a boy, Paul, whom his peers do all they can to help; yet, their attempts do not work because he simply struggles from a bad case of petty lying and borderline narcissism. Often the traits associated with narcissism are said to be developed from the way parents raise their children (Narcissists). In Paul’s instance his father raised him as well as he could. Paul used his own free will to determine the outcome of his life.
Paul is a strange young man, often leaving his peers confused about his actions and his motives. The strangeness is best depicted by Paul’s physical appearance, “his master had noted with amazement what a white, blue-veined face it was; drawn and wrinkled like an old man's about the eyes, the lips twitching even in his sleep…” (Cather). Also he is described in another instance as displaying the characteristics of being addicted to the drug belladonna. Paul has no care for his physical appearance at school; in fact, he does not even care to be at school,...

...Life in Omelas
Ursula K. Le Guin's short story "The Ones Who Walk Away from Omelas" describes a Utopian village. The beautiful city of Omelas is described as though it were in a fairy tale. The city has no crime, enemies, and most importantly the citizens have no sense of guilt. Unfortunately the beauty of the city is built upon the torture and abuse of a small child whose suffering serves as a scapegoat for the sins of the city's society. Some of the citizens of Omelas choose to leave the city because they do not wish to partake in the social contract that binds the city to its prosperity. Le Guin uses the themes of the scapegoat and the rite of passage to explore the values of Omelasians.
The first appearance of the scapegoat is the Festival of Summer, Le Guin does not directly state why the celebration is taking place, but the festival is of great significance to the city of Omelas. In medieval Europe Mid-Summer Fire Festivals occur to celebrate the sun, but also to expunge the evil. Sir James George Frazer, states that, "The annual expulsion of evil generally coincides with some well marked change of season, such as the beginning or end of winter, the beginning or end of the rainy season, etc" (Frazer 224-225). Frazer also explains that," the three great features of the midsummer celebration were the bonfires, the procession with torches round the fields, and custom of a rolling wheel"...

...
1 May 2012
Deceit of the Utopia:
Analysis of “The Ones Who Walk Away From Omelas” by Ursula K. LeGuin
What is one to make of the city of Omelas? It is a fantastical place so transcendental that the author herself struggles to properly detail its majesty. Omelas has everything— it is beautiful, technologically advanced, and bears no need for organized religion. The atmosphere is rich with music, festivities, and orgies. And even with all this excessive indulgence, the people manage to remain elite: expert craftsman in every art, scholars of the highest caliber, gentle mothers and fathers, and all-around good people. However, all this prosperity comes with a price. The success and happiness of Omelas stems from the immense and intentional suffering of one person: a small child who lives in a dark cellar and is continuously abused and neglected by the citizens. If the child were freed, it would supposedly lead to the destruction of this great city, therefore keeping it there is for the greater good. So who is to be pitied? LeGuinn presents us with a moral crossroads, a true question of ethics that is left open ended. Readers may interpret the text in many ways. They may choose to sympathize with the people of Omelas and agree with the narrator. Or, they may choose to make the revelation that there should be no happiness founded on the misery of others and blindness to truth, and if...

...The story of his life
In the young Chin Peng interest once read print materials and highlights developments in China. At that time a dispute between Chiang Kai Shek and Mao Tse Tung. Japan army seized Manchuria and China dominate the interior. China country is the birthplace of the father and his ancestors in the Kwantung.
During his youth 15 years, Chin Peng have a feeling that is close to the western educated nationalist Chiang Kai Shek who dominate the southern China and Taiwan. But the booklet 'On Protacted War' essay Mao Tse Tung changed his mind on the flow of communism. Clear determination to resist the Japanese invasion of Malaya then 1941.
In 1940 he was accepted into the Communist Party of China Communist Party of the branches abroad. He also joined Force 136, an armed force established by the British spy against the Japanese in Malaya. When the age of 18.
Chin Peng led MPAJA or Malayan People Anti Japanese Army, a guerrilla force against the Japanese. British Army (Force Special Air Services and MI6) that deployed in the jungles of Perak, has a variety of weapons, financing, training and a variety of other equipment to equip Force 136 and MPAJA. MPAJA Army attacked the Japanese army to the banks of the Silver River near Pasir Salak in 1942.
After World War II, some of the radical faiths MPAJA acted out in the forest to kill punish them of collaborating with the Japanese and British stooge and also kill local leaders such as the Chieftain...

...Useful Argumentative
Essay Words and
Phrases
Examples of Argumentative Language
Below are examples of signposts that are used in argumentative essays. Signposts enable the reader to
follow our arguments easily.
When pointing out opposing arguments (Cons):




Opponents of this idea claim/maintain that…
Those who disagree/ are against these ideas may say/ assert that…
Some people may disagree with this idea,
Some people may say that…however…
When stating specifically why they think like that:

They claim that…since…
Reaching the turning point:



However,
But
On the other hand,
When refuting the opposing idea, we may use the following strategies:

compromise but prove their argument is not powerful enough:
- They have a point in thinking like that.
- To a certain extent they are right.

completely disagree:
- After seeing this evidence, there is no way we can agree with this idea.

say that their argument is irrelevant to the topic:
- Their argument is irrelevant to the topic.
Signposting sentences
What are signposting sentences?
Signposting sentences explain the logic of your argument. They tell the reader what you are going to do at key
points in your assignment. They are most useful when used in the following places:






In the introduction
At the beginning of a paragraph which develops a...

...‘At the start of the automotive revolution in the late 1890′s, a defining battle similar to that of VHS versus Betamax or HD-DVD versus Blu-ray took place. Electric cars fought side by side against internal combustion engined vehicles to become the first choice to power the way forward for mankind.
Electric cars enjoyed notable successes including the first vehicle to achieve a speed of over 62mph (100kmh) in the all-electric La Jamaica Content in 1899 by the Belgian Camille Jenatzy. However, overriding factors still familiar today meant that fossil-fuel won the overall battle for adoption, with thanks to their being more convenient to refuel and thanks to the likes of Henry Ford who mass produced the Ford Model T; thus lowering the overall purchase price for petrol engined cars.
Though there have been several attempts over the last 100 years to revive the initial successes enjoyed by electric cars in the 1890′s and early 20th century, they have mostly been one offs, concept cars and individual engineering projects.
In recent years, the ever expanding field of electronics has played an important role in the development of the story. The advent of purely electronic devices, rather than mechanical, has meant we’re more accepting of machines with no moving parts and only powered by electricity. This means we are better conditioned for ownership and an understanding of electric vehicles than we were at the turn of the 20th century. The simplicity and efficiency of...

...﻿The Smarter Measure quiz helped me notice my learning styles. This included my life factors, personal attributes, technical competency, technical knowledge, and reading recall. Between personal attributes, technical competency, technical knowledge, life factors and reading recalls, life factors is my highest one. This puts me at 82% on a 100% scale. Technical competency is at 80%, personal attributes at 69%, reading recall at 60% and technical knowledge at 41%. These are all the things that make up my learning styles.
My primary learning style is social. My learning style is an 8 for social, a 7 for physical and solitary, a 6 for aural, logical and visual and 4 for verbal. Having a social learning style means that I communicate well with other people, both verbally and non-verbally. I prefer learning in groups and I like spending one on one time with the teacher. My lowest learning style is verbal. Verbal style includes both written and spoken words. This one is my lowest one because I don’t find it easy to express myself. I do not like reading but I like writing.
My typing accuracy was measured at 95% and my typing speed was measured at 18 WPM. I have the ability to type but the speed is not fast. Overall I thought the comparison to other smarter measure averages was well rounded because I am smart and I found out that I am really more of a social learner than a visual learner. I believe that the results from my smarter measure quiz will impact my ability to be...

... When writing it is very important to use either logos, pathos, or ethos. Ethos is the appeal to moral character, logos appeals with reason and logic, and pathos appeals to the emotions. It is very important to use all of these when writing but of course, everyone has a favorite. My favorite happens to be Logos. I would prefer to use logos because I like backing myself up with logical ideas that are facts.
When using logos I like to use clear and concise information to help readers see logically why they should agree with me. When you can get someone to agree with your logic then it is really easy to convert them to your way of thinking. Nevertheless, pathos and ethos are also very good ways to change a person’s views on a certain idea.
Ethos, for example, can be used when trying to persuade the audience that a character is a good person. This is because pathos appeals to moral character and it would be very helpful when trying to show the worth of what a certain character is doing.
Pathos is a rhetorical device used to get readers to stop thinking and start feeling. “I have a dream that my four little children will one day live in a nation where they will not be judged by the color of their skin but the content of their character.” –MLK In this quote, King used his little children to emotionally appeal to his audience and get them to see his side of things.
Lastly, logos is the easiest rhetorical device to use out of the three. It is easy to find logical...