Thursday, November 09, 2006

Florida's Pregnant Pig Amendment

This was NOT on the ballot this election session - it's from 2002. But since I heard references to it recently, and since Cindi was good enough to ask what it was, I thought I'd reproduce it here.

See, we have a Citizen's Initiative process for amending the state constitution. The citizens are all for it...well, mostly. Actually, Floridians polled feel pretty strongly about keeping it.

However, it irritates the legislature and the governor to no end. It often addresses issues that a significant majority of Floridians would like to see addressed by the government, but which the government doesn't address, usually for political (read: lobbying and/or deniability) reasons.

Those who seek to limit citizen's initiatives in this and other states often bring this one up as an example of citizen silliness. The Pregnant Pig Amendment to the Florida Constitution passed by a simple majority of over 50% - but less than 60%. We elect our politicians by a simple majority, not 60%; so the *simple majority* supporters argue that's fair for amendments, too.

That's significant because one of the constitutional amendments this session - called Amendment #3 - was to limit the citizen's initiative by requiring 60% of the vote to pass, rather than a simple majority of over 50%.

To the surprise of many, it actually passed.

But it passed by less than 60%.

So the amendment requiring a 60% margin to pass an amendment would NOT have passed if it, itself, were already in force.

Ain't politics FUN?

~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~Florida Animal Cruelty Amendment: Limiting Cruel and Inhumane Confinement of Pigs During PregnancyCitation: Florida Amendment Article X Section 19Summary: This ballot proposal addresses the inhumane treatment of animals, specifically, pregnant pigs. To prevent cruelty to animals and as recommended by The Humane Society of the United States, no person shall confine a pig during pregnancy in a cage, crate or other enclosure, or tether a pregnant pig, on a farm so that the pig is prevented from turning around freely, except for veterinary purposes and during the prebirthing period; provides definitions, penalties, and an effective date. Note: this measure appears to have passed in the November 2002 election with 54% of the vote.

Ballot Summary:Inhumane treatment of animals is a concern of Florida citizens; to prevent cruelty to animals and as recommended by The Humane Society of the United States, no person shall confine a pig during pregnancy in a cage, crate or other enclosure, or tether a pregnant pig, on a farm so that the pig is prevented from turning around freely, except for veterinary purposes and during the prebirthing period; provides definitions, penalties, and an effective date.

Correction, Desert Cat, I believe ours was a pig item, too. That's why all the signs saying "Prop. 207 Hogwash." I gather that this law (not constitutional amendment) was aimed at a single factory farm up near Snowflake AZ.

There's nothing funny about this amendment. Animal cruelty is all about treating living things like inanimate objects. Pigs have an IQ higher than your dog. They are routinely abused for fun by sociopathic factory farm workers during the painful slaughtering process. Next time you want to laugh at torturing a pig, go get an electric prod, shove it in your dog's eye so you can laugh at it's cries then shove it up it's nose for real fun. That's how pigs are treated for "fun" before the actual killing. Go google downer cows, too. eyeroll.

Paypal Tip Jar

About Me

I'm a nice quiet middle-aged former bankbuster, disabled since age 32 with a myriad of weird health issues. I love heat and humidity and odd hobbies like fossil hunting, tromping around in the Everglades, backyard bricklaying, and rescuing plants damaged by our spate of hurricanes. Oh - I like to live-blog hurricanes, too.*****
I have a wonderful life. I'm one of the happiest people I know. Why? I don't know.*****
I also have nightmare memories in my head that would send some folks around the bend. But that's another story, one I don't tell much, and I seem to have made it past the horror parts pretty well.*****
I have nothing to prove so it's hard to insult me. I know who I am. I own the space I live in - and I don't mean just my house. My life is way far from perfect, but I'm content.*****
For some readers, that would make this a boring blog. For others, my fun adventures, absurd health episodes, and particular way of looking at things keep 'em entertained enough, in the end.