A Changed Man

Thomas Hardy

To the best of our knowledge, the text of this
work is in the “Public Domain” in Australia.
HOWEVER, copyright law varies in other countries, and the work may
still be under copyright in the country from which you are accessing this website.
It is your responsibility to check the applicable copyright laws
in your country before downloading this work.

Prefatory Note

I reprint in this volume, for what they may be worth, a dozen minor novels that have been published in the
periodical press at various dates in the past, in order to render them accessible to readers who desire to have them in
the complete series issued by my publishers. For aid in reclaiming some of the narratives I express my thanks to the
proprietors and editors of the newspapers and magazines in whose pages they first appeared.

T. H. August 1913.

A Changed Man

Chapter I

The person who, next to the actors themselves, chanced to know most of their story, lived just below ‘Top o’ Town’
(as the spot was called) in an old substantially-built house, distinguished among its neighbours by having an oriel
window on the first floor, whence could be obtained a raking view of the High Street, west and east, the former
including Laura’s dwelling, the end of the Town Avenue hard by (in which were played the odd pranks hereafter to be
mentioned), the Port–Bredy road rising westwards, and the turning that led to the cavalry barracks where the Captain
was quartered. Looking eastward down the town from the same favoured gazebo, the long perspective of houses declined
and dwindled till they merged in the highway across the moor. The white riband of road disappeared over Grey’s Bridge a
quarter of a mile off, to plunge into innumerable rustic windings, shy shades, and solitary undulations up hill and
down dale for one hundred and twenty miles till it exhibited itself at Hyde Park Corner as a smooth bland surface in
touch with a busy and fashionable world.

To the barracks aforesaid had recently arrived the —— th Hussars, a regiment new to the locality. Almost before any
acquaintance with its members had been made by the townspeople, a report spread that they were a ‘crack’ body of men,
and had brought a splendid band. For some reason or other the town had not been used as the headquarters of cavalry for
many years, the various troops stationed there having consisted of casual detachments only; so that it was with a sense
of honour that everybody — even the small furniture-broker from whom the married troopers hired tables and chairs —
received the news of their crack quality.

In those days the Hussar regiments still wore over the left shoulder that attractive attachment, or frilled
half-coat, hanging loosely behind like the wounded wing of a bird, which was called the pelisse, though it was known
among the troopers themselves as a ‘sling-jacket.’ It added amazingly to their picturesqueness in women’s eyes, and,
indeed, in the eyes of men also.

The burgher who lived in the house with the oriel window sat during a great many hours of the day in that
projection, for he was an invalid, and time hung heavily on his hands unless he maintained a constant interest in
proceedings without. Not more than a week after the arrival of the Hussars his ears were assailed by the shout of one
schoolboy to another in the street below.

‘Have ‘ee heard this about the Hussars? They are haunted! Yes — a ghost troubles ’em; he has followed ’em about the
world for years.’

A haunted regiment: that was a new idea for either invalid or stalwart. The listener in the oriel came to the
conclusion that there were some lively characters among the —— th Hussars.

He made Captain Maumbry’s acquaintance in an informal manner at an afternoon tea to which he went in a wheeled chair
— one of the very rare outings that the state of his health permitted. Maumbry showed himself to be a handsome man of
twenty-eight or thirty, with an attractive hint of wickedness in his manner that was sure to make him adorable with
good young women. The large dark eyes that lit his pale face expressed this wickedness strongly, though such was the
adaptability of their rays that one could think they might have expressed sadness or seriousness just as readily, if he
had had a mind for such.

An old and deaf lady who was present asked Captain Maumbry bluntly: ‘What’s this we hear about you? They say your
regiment is haunted.’

The Captain’s face assumed an aspect of grave, even sad, concern. ‘Yes,’ he replied, ‘it is too true.’

Some younger ladies smiled till they saw how serious he looked, when they looked serious likewise.

‘Really?’ said the old lady.

‘Yes. We naturally don’t wish to say much about it.’

‘No, no; of course not. But — how haunted?’

‘Well; the — thing, as I’ll call it, follows us. In country quarters or town, abroad or at home, it’s just the
same.’

‘How do you account for it?’

‘H’m.’ Maumbry lowered his voice. ‘Some crime committed by certain of our regiment in past years, we suppose.’

‘Dear me . . . How very horrid, and singular!’

‘But, as I said, we don’t speak of it much.’

‘No . . . no.’

When the Hussar was gone, a young lady, disclosing a long-suppressed interest, asked if the ghost had been seen by
any of the town.

The lawyer’s son, who always had the latest borough news, said that, though it was seldom seen by any one but the
Hussars themselves, more than one townsman and woman had already set eyes on it, to his or her terror. The phantom
mostly appeared very late at night, under the dense trees of the town-avenue nearest the barracks. It was about ten
feet high; its teeth chattered with a dry naked sound, as if they were those of a skeleton; and its hip-bones could be
heard grating in their sockets.

During the darkest weeks of winter several timid persons were seriously frightened by the object answering to this
cheerful description, and the police began to look into the matter. Whereupon the appearances grew less frequent, and
some of the Boys of the regiment thankfully stated that they had not been so free from ghostly visitation for years as
they had become since their arrival in Casterbridge.

This playing at ghosts was the most innocent of the amusements indulged in by the choice young spirits who inhabited
the lichened, red-brick building at the top of the town bearing ‘W.D.’ and a broad arrow on its quoins. Far more
serious escapades — levities relating to love, wine, cards, betting — were talked of, with no doubt more or less of
exaggeration. That the Hussars, Captain Maumbry included, were the cause of bitter tears to several young women of the
town and country is unquestionably true, despite the fact that the gaieties of the young men wore a more staring colour
in this old-fashioned place than they would have done in a large and modern city.

Chapter II

Regularly once a week they rode out in marching order.

Returning up the town on one of these occasions, the romantic pelisse flapping behind each horseman’s shoulder in
the soft south-west wind, Captain Maumbry glanced up at the oriel. A mutual nod was exchanged between him and the
person who sat there reading. The reader and a friend in the room with him followed the troop with their eyes all the
way up the street, till, when the soldiers were opposite the house in which Laura lived, that young lady became
discernible in the balcony.

‘They are engaged to be married, I hear,’ said the friend.

‘Who — Maumbry and Laura? Never — so soon?’

‘Yes.’

‘He’ll never marry. Several girls have been mentioned in connection with his name. I am sorry for Laura.’

‘Oh, but you needn’t be. They are excellently matched.’

‘She’s only one more.’

‘She’s one more, and more still. She has regularly caught him. She is a born player of the game of hearts, and she
knew how to beat him in his own practices. If there is one woman in the town who has any chance of holding her own and
marrying him, she is that woman.’

This was true, as it turned out. By natural proclivity Laura had from the first entered heart and soul into military
romance as exhibited in the plots and characters of those living exponents of it who came under her notice. From her
earliest young womanhood civilians, however promising, had no chance of winning her interest if the meanest warrior
were within the horizon. It may be that the position of her uncle’s house (which was her home) at the corner of West
Street nearest the barracks, the daily passing of the troops, the constant blowing of trumpet-calls a furlong from her
windows, coupled with the fact that she knew nothing of the inner realities of military life, and hence idealized it,
had also helped her mind’s original bias for thinking men-at-arms the only ones worthy of a woman’s heart.

Captain Maumbry was a typical prize; one whom all surrounding maidens had coveted, ached for, angled for, wept for,
had by her judicious management become subdued to her purpose; and in addition to the pleasure of marrying the man she
loved, Laura had the joy of feeling herself hated by the mothers of all the marriageable girls of the
neighbourhood.

The man in the oriel went to the wedding; not as a guest, for at this time he was but slightly acquainted with the
parties; but mainly because the church was close to his house; partly, too, for a reason which moved many others to be
spectators of the ceremony; a subconsciousness that, though the couple might be happy in their experiences, there was
sufficient possibility of their being otherwise to colour the musings of an onlooker with a pleasing pathos of
conjecture. He could on occasion do a pretty stroke of rhyming in those days, and he beguiled the time of waiting by
pencilling on a blank page of his prayer-book a few lines which, though kept private then, may be given here:—

AT A HASTY WEDDING

(Triolet)

If hours be years the twain are blest,
For now they solace swift desire
By lifelong ties that tether zest
If hours be years. The twain are blest
Do eastern suns slope never west,
Nor pallid ashes follow fire.
If hours be years the twain are blest
For now they solace swift desire.

As if, however, to falsify all prophecies, the couple seemed to find in marriage the secret of perpetuating the
intoxication of a courtship which, on Maumbry’s side at least, had opened without serious intent. During the winter
following they were the most popular pair in and about Casterbridge — nay in South Wessex itself. No smart dinner in
the country houses of the younger and gayer families within driving distance of the borough was complete without their
lively presence; Mrs. Maumbry was the blithest of the whirling figures at the county ball; and when followed that
inevitable incident of garrison-town life, an amateur dramatic entertainment, it was just the same. The acting was for
the benefit of such and such an excellent charity — nobody cared what, provided the play were played — and both Captain
Maumbry and his wife were in the piece, having been in fact, by mutual consent, the originators of the performance. And
so with laughter, and thoughtlessness, and movement, all went merrily. There was a little backwardness in the
bill-paying of the couple; but in justice to them it must be added that sooner or later all owings were paid.

Chapter III

At the chapel-of-ease attended by the troops there arose above the edge of the pulpit one Sunday an unknown face.
This was the face of a new curate. He placed upon the desk, not the familiar sermon book, but merely a Bible. The
person who tells these things was not present at that service, but he soon learnt that the young curate was nothing
less than a great surprise to his congregation; a mixed one always, for though the Hussars occupied the body of the
building, its nooks and corners were crammed with civilians, whom, up to the present, even the least uncharitable would
have described as being attracted thither less by the services than by the soldiery.

Now there arose a second reason for squeezing into an already overcrowded church. The persuasive and gentle
eloquence of Mr. Sainway operated like a charm upon those accustomed only to the higher and dryer styles of preaching,
and for a time the other churches of the town were thinned of their sitters.

At this point in the nineteenth century the sermon was the sole reason for churchgoing amongst a vast body of
religious people. The liturgy was a formal preliminary, which, like the Royal proclamation in a court of assize, had to
be got through before the real interest began; and on reaching home the question was simply: Who preached, and how did
he handle his subject? Even had an archbishop officiated in the service proper nobody would have cared much about what
was said or sung. People who had formerly attended in the morning only began to go in the evening, and even to the
special addresses in the afternoon.

One day when Captain Maumbry entered his wife’s drawing-room, filled with hired furniture, she thought he was
somebody else, for he had not come upstairs humming the most catching air afloat in musical circles or in his usual
careless way.

‘What’s the matter, Jack?’ she said without looking up from a note she was writing.

‘Well — not much, that I know.’

‘O, but there is,’ she murmured as she wrote.

‘Why — this cursed new lath in a sheet — I mean the new parson! He wants us to stop the band-playing on Sunday
afternoons.’

Laura looked up aghast.

‘Why, it is the one thing that enables the few rational beings hereabouts to keep alive from Saturday to
Monday!’

‘He says all the town flock to the music and don’t come to the service, and that the pieces played are profane, or
mundane, or inane, or something — not what ought to be played on Sunday. Of course ’tis Lautmann who settles those
things.’

Lautmann was the bandmaster.

The barrack-green on Sunday afternoons had, indeed, become the promenade of a great many townspeople cheerfully
inclined, many even of those who attended in the morning at Mr. Sainway’s service; and little boys who ought to have
been listening to the curate’s afternoon lecture were too often seen rolling upon the grass and making faces behind the
more dignified listeners.

Laura heard no more about the matter, however, for two or three weeks, when suddenly remembering it she asked her
husband if any further objections had been raised.

‘O— Mr. Sainway. I forgot to tell you. I’ve made his acquaintance. He is not a bad sort of man.’

Laura asked if either Maumbry or some others of the officers did not give the presumptuous curate a good setting
down for his interference.

The acquaintance developed apparently, for the Captain said to her a little later on, ‘There’s a good deal in
Sainway’s argument about having no band on Sunday afternoons. After all, it is close to his church. But he doesn’t
press his objections unduly.’

‘I am surprised to hear you defend him!’

‘It was only a passing thought of mine. We naturally don’t wish to offend the inhabitants of the town if they don’t
like it.’

‘But they do.’

The invalid in the oriel never clearly gathered the details of progress in this conflict of lay and clerical
opinion; but so it was that, to the disappointment of musicians, the grief of out-walking lovers, and the regret of the
junior population of the town and country round, the band-playing on Sunday afternoons ceased in Casterbridge
barrack-square.

By this time the Maumbrys had frequently listened to the preaching of the gentle if narrow-minded curate; for these
light-natured, hit-or-miss, rackety people went to church like others for respectability’s sake. None so orthodox as
your unmitigated worldling. A more remarkable event was the sight to the man in the window of Captain Maumbry and Mr.
Sainway walking down the High Street in earnest conversation. On his mentioning this fact to a caller he was assured
that it was a matter of common talk that they were always together.

The observer would soon have learnt this with his own eyes if he had not been told. They began to pass together
nearly every day. Hitherto Mrs. Maumbry, in fashionable walking clothes, had usually been her husband’s companion; but
this was less frequent now. The close and singular friendship between the two men went on for nearly a year, when Mr.
Sainway was presented to a living in a densely-populated town in the midland counties. He bade the parishioners of his
old place a reluctant farewell and departed, the touching sermon he preached on the occasion being published by the
local printer. Everybody was sorry to lose him; and it was with genuine grief that his Casterbridge congregation learnt
later on that soon after his induction to his benefice, during some bitter weather, he had fallen seriously ill of
inflammation of the lungs, of which he eventually died.

We now get below the surface of things. Of all who had known the dead curate, none grieved for him like the man who
on his first arrival had called him a ‘lath in a sheet.’ Mrs. Maumbry had never greatly sympathized with the impressive
parson; indeed, she had been secretly glad that he had gone away to better himself. He had considerably diminished the
pleasures of a woman by whom the joys of earth and good company had been appreciated to the full. Sorry for her husband
in his loss of a friend who had been none of hers, she was yet quite unprepared for the sequel.

‘There is something that I have wanted to tell you lately, dear,’ he said one morning at breakfast with hesitation.
‘Have you guessed what it is?’

She had guessed nothing.

‘That I think of retiring from the army.’

‘What!’

‘I have thought more and more of Sainway since his death, and of what he used to say to me so earnestly. And I feel
certain I shall be right in obeying a call within me to give up this fighting trade and enter the Church.’

‘What — be a parson?’

‘Yes.’

‘But what should I do?’

‘Be a parson’s wife.’

‘Never!’ she affirmed.

‘But how can you help it?’

‘I’ll run away rather!’ she said vehemently;

‘No, you mustn’t,’ Maumbry replied, in the tone he used when his mind was made up. ‘You’ll get accustomed to the
idea, for I am constrained to carry it out, though it is against my worldly interests. I am forced on by a Hand outside
me to tread in the steps of Sainway.’

‘Jack,’ she asked, with calm pallor and round eyes; ‘do you mean to say seriously that you are arranging to be a
curate instead of a soldier?’

‘I might say a curate is a soldier — of the church militant; but I don’t want to offend you with doctrine. I
distinctly say, yes.’

Late one evening, a little time onward, he caught her sitting by the dim firelight in her room. She did not know he
had entered; and he found her weeping. ‘What are you crying about, poor dearest?’ he said.

She started. ‘Because of what you have told me!’ The Captain grew very unhappy; but he was undeterred.

In due time the town learnt, to its intense surprise, that Captain Maumbry had retired from the —— th Hussars and
gone to Fountall Theological College to prepare for the ministry.

Chapter IV

‘O, the pity of it! Such a dashing soldier — so popular — such an acquisition to the town — the soul of social life
here! And now! . . . One should not speak ill of the dead, but that dreadful Mr. Sainway — it was too cruel
of him!’

This is a summary of what was said when Captain, now the Reverend, John Maumbry was enabled by circumstances to
indulge his heart’s desire of returning to the scene of his former exploits in the capacity of a minister of the
Gospel. A low-lying district of the town, which at that date was crowded with impoverished cottagers, was crying for a
curate, and Mr. Maumbry generously offered himself as one willing to undertake labours that were certain to produce
little result, and no thanks, credit, or emolument.

Let the truth be told about him as a clergyman; he proved to be anything but a brilliant success. Painstaking,
single-minded, deeply in earnest as all could see, his delivery was laboured, his sermons were dull to listen to, and
alas, too, too long. Even the dispassionate judges who sat by the hour in the bar-parlour of the White Hart — an inn
standing at the dividing line between the poor quarter aforesaid and the fashionable quarter of Maumbry’s former
triumphs, and hence affording a position of strict impartiality — agreed in substance with the young ladies to the
westward, though their views were somewhat more tersely expressed: ‘Surely, God A’mighty spwiled a good sojer to make a
bad pa’son when He shifted Cap’n Ma’mbry into a sarpless!’

The latter knew that such things were said, but he pursued his daily’ labours in and out of the hovels with serene
unconcern.

It was about this time that the invalid in the oriel became more than a mere bowing acquaintance of Mrs. Maumbry’s.
She had returned to the town with her husband, and was living with him in a little house in the centre of his circle of
ministration, when by some means she became one of the invalid’s visitors. After a general conversation while sitting
in his room with a friend of both, an incident led up to the matter that still rankled deeply in her soul. Her face was
now paler and thinner than it had been; even more attractive, her disappointments having inscribed themselves as meek
thoughtfulness on a look that was once a little frivolous. The two ladies had called to be allowed to use the window
for observing the departure of the Hussars, who were leaving for barracks much nearer to London.

The troopers turned the corner of Barrack Road into the top of High Street, headed by their band playing ‘The girl I
left behind me’ (which was formerly always the tune for such times, though it is now nearly disused). They came and
passed the oriel, where an officer or two, looking up and discovering Mrs. Maumbry, saluted her, whose eyes filled with
tears as the notes of the band waned away. Before the little group had recovered from that sense of the romantic which
such spectacles impart, Mr. Maumbry came along the pavement. He probably had bidden his former brethren-inarms a
farewell at the top of the street, for he walked from that direction in his rather shabby clerical clothes, and with a
basket on his arm which seemed to hold some purchases he had been making for his poorer parishioners. Unlike the
soldiers he went along quite unconscious of his appearance or of the scene around.

The contrast was too much for Laura. With lips that now quivered, she asked the invalid what he thought of the
change that had come to her.

It was difficult to answer, and with a wilfulness that was too strong in her she repeated the question.

‘Do you think,’ she added, ‘that a woman’s husband has a right to do such a thing, even if he does feel a certain
call to it?’

Her listener sympathized too largely with both of them to be anything but unsatisfactory in his reply. Laura gazed
longingly out of the window towards the thin dusty line of Hussars, now smalling towards the Mellstock Ridge. ‘I,’ she
said, ‘who should have been in their van on the way to London, am doomed to fester in a hole in Durnover Lane!’

Many events had passed and many rumours had been current concerning her before the invalid saw her again after her
leave-taking that day.

Chapter V

Casterbridge had known many military and civil episodes; many happy times, and times less happy; and now came the
time of her visitation. The scourge of cholera had been laid on the suffering country, and the low-lying purlieus of
this ancient borough had more than their share of the infliction. Mixen Lane, in the Durnover quarter, and in Maumbry’s
parish, was where the blow fell most heavily. Yet there was a certain mercy in its choice of a date, for Maumbry was
the man for such an hour.

The spread of the epidemic was so rapid that many left the town and took lodgings in the villages and farms. Mr.
Maumbry’s house was close to the most infected street, and he himself was occupied morn, noon, and night in endeavours
to stamp out the plague and in alleviating the sufferings of the victims. So, as a matter of ordinary precaution, he
decided to isolate his wife somewhere away from him for a while.

She suggested a village by the sea, near Budmouth Regis, and lodgings were obtained for her at Creston, a spot
divided from the Casterbridge valley by a high ridge that gave it quite another atmosphere, though it lay no more than
six miles off.

Thither she went. While she was rusticating in this place of safety, and her husband was slaving in the slums, she
struck up an acquaintance with a lieutenant in the —— st Foot, a Mr. Vannicock, who was stationed with his regiment at
the Budmouth infantry barracks. As Laura frequently sat on the shelving beach, watching each thin wave slide up to her,
and hearing, without heeding, its gnaw at the pebbles in its retreat, he often took a walk that way.

The acquaintance grew and ripened. Her situation, her history, her beauty, her age — a year or two above his own —
all tended to make an impression on the young man’s heart, and a reckless flirtation was soon in blithe progress upon
that lonely shore.

It was said by her detractors afterwards that she had chosen her lodging to be near this gentleman, but there is
reason to believe that she had never seen him till her arrival there. Just now Casterbridge was so deeply occupied with
its own sad affairs — a daily burying of the dead and destruction of contaminated clothes and bedding — that it had
little inclination to promulgate such gossip as may have reached its ears on the pair. Nobody long considered Laura in
the tragic cloud which overhung all.

Meanwhile, on the Budmouth side of the hill the very mood of men was in contrast. The visitation there had been
slight and much earlier, and normal occupations and pastimes had been resumed. Mr. Maumbry had arranged to see Laura
twice a week in the open air, that she might run no risk from him; and, having heard nothing of the faint rumour, he
met her as usual one dry and windy afternoon on the summit of the dividing hill, near where the high road from town to
town crosses the old Ridge-way at right angles.

He waved his hand, and smiled as she approached, shouting to her: ‘We will keep this wall between us, dear.’ (Walls
formed the field-fences here.) ‘You mustn’t be endangered. It won’t be for long, with God’s help!’

‘I will do as you tell me, Jack. But you are running too much risk yourself, aren’t you? I get little news of you;
but I fancy you are.’

‘Not more than others.’

Thus somewhat formally they talked, an insulating wind beating the wall between them like a mill-weir.

‘But you wanted to ask me something?’ he added.

‘Yes. You know we are trying in Budmouth to raise some money for your sufferers; and the way we have thought of is
by a dramatic performance. They want me to take a part.’

His face saddened. ‘I have known so much of that sort of thing, and all that accompanies it! I wish you had thought
of some other way.’

She said lightly that she was afraid it was all settled. ‘You object to my taking a part, then? Of course —’

He told her that he did not like to say he positively objected. He wished they had chosen an oratorio, or lecture,
or anything more in keeping with the necessity it was to relieve.

‘But,’ said she impatiently, ‘people won’t come to oratorios or lectures! They will crowd to comedies and
farces.’

‘Well, I cannot dictate to Budmouth how it shall earn the money it is going to give us. Who is getting up this
performance?’

‘The boys of the —— st.’

‘Ah, yes; our old game!’ replied Mr. Maumbry. ‘The grief of Casterbridge is the excuse for their frivolity.
Candidly, dear Laura, I wish you wouldn’t play in it. But I don’t forbid you to. I leave the whole to your
judgment.’

The interview ended, and they went their ways northward and southward. Time disclosed to all concerned that Mrs.
Maumbry played in the comedy as the heroine, the lover’s part being taken by Mr. Vannicock.

Chapter VI

Thus was helped on an event which the conduct of the mutually-attracted ones had been generating for some time.

It is unnecessary to give details. The —— st Foot left for Bristol, and this precipitated their action. After a week
of hesitation she agreed to leave her home at Creston and meet Vannicock on the ridge hard by, and to accompany him to
Bath, where he had secured lodgings for her, so that she would be only about a dozen miles from his quarters.

Accordingly, on the evening chosen, she laid on her dressing-table a note for her husband, running thus:—

DEAR JACK— I am unable to endure this life any longer, and I have resolved to put an end to it. I told you I should
run away if you persisted in being a clergyman, and now I am doing it. One cannot help one’s nature. I have resolved to
throw in my lot with Mr. Vannicock, and I hope rather than expect you will forgive me. — L.

Then, with hardly a scrap of luggage, she went, ascending to the ridge in the dusk of early evening. Almost on the
very spot where her husband had stood at their last tryst she beheld the outline of Vannicock, who had come all the way
from Bristol to fetch her.

‘I don’t like meeting here — it is so unlucky!’ she cried to him. ‘For God’s sake let us have a place of our own. Go
back to the milestone, and I’ll come on.’

He went back to the milestone that stands on the north slope of the ridge, where the old and new roads diverge, and
she joined him there.

She was taciturn and sorrowful when he asked her why she would not meet him on the top. At last she inquired how
they were going to travel.

He explained that he proposed to walk to Mellstock Hill, on the other side of Casterbridge, where a fly was waiting
to take them by a cross-cut into the Ivell Road, and onward to that town. The Bristol railway was open to Ivell.

This plan they followed, and walked briskly through the dull gloom till they neared Casterbridge, which place they
avoided by turning to the right at the Roman Amphitheatre and bearing round to Durnover Cross. Thence the way was
solitary and open across the moor to the hill whereon the Ivell fly awaited them.

‘I have noticed for some time,’ she said, ‘a lurid glare over the Durnover end of the town. It seems to come from
somewhere about Mixen Lane.’

‘The lamps,’ he suggested.

‘There’s not a lamp as big as a rushlight in the whole lane. It is where the cholera is worst.’

By Standfast Corner, a little beyond the Cross, they suddenly obtained an end view of the lane. Large bonfires were
burning in the middle of the way, with a view to purifying the air; and from the wretched tenements with which the lane
was lined in those days persons were bringing out bedding and clothing. Some was thrown into the fires, the rest placed
in wheel-barrows and wheeled into the moor directly in the track of the fugitives.

They followed on, and came up to where a vast copper was set in the open air. Here the linen was boiled and
disinfected. By the light of the lanterns Laura discovered that her husband was standing by the copper, and that it was
he who unloaded the barrow and immersed its contents. The night was so calm and muggy that the conversation by the
copper reached her ears.

‘Are there many more loads to-night?’

‘There’s the clothes o’ they that died this afternoon, sir. But that might bide till tomorrow, for you must be tired
out.’

‘We’ll do it at once, for I can’t ask anybody else to undertake it. Overturn that load on the grass and fetch the
rest.’

The man did so and went off with the barrow. Maumbry paused for a moment to wipe his face, and resumed his homely
drudgery amid this squalid and reeking scene, pressing down and stirring the contents of the copper with what looked
like an old rolling-pin. The steam therefrom, laden with death, travelled in a low trail across the meadow.

Laura spoke suddenly: ‘I won’t go to-night after all. He is so tired, and I must help him. I didn’t know things were
so bad as this!’

Vannicock’s arm dropped from her waist, where it had been resting as they walked. ‘Will you leave?’ she asked.

‘I will if you say I must. But I’d rather help too.’ There was no expostulation in his tone.

Laura had gone forward. ‘Jack,’ she said, ‘I am come to help!’

The weary curate turned and held up the lantern. ‘O— what, is it you, Laura?’ he asked in surprise. ‘Why did you
come into this? You had better go back — the risk is great.’

‘But I want to help you, Jack. Please let me help! I didn’t come by myself — Mr. Vannicock kept me company. He will
make himself useful too, if he’s not gone on. Mr. Vannicock!’

The young lieutenant came forward reluctantly. Mr. Maumbry spoke formally to him, adding as he resumed his labour,
‘I thought the —— st Foot had gone to Bristol.’

‘We have. But I have run down again for a few things.’

The two newcomers began to assist, Vannicock placing on the ground the small bag containing Laura’s toilet articles
that he had been carrying. The barrowman soon returned with another load, and all continued work for nearly a
half-hour, when a coachman came out from the shadows to the north.

‘Beg pardon, sir,’ he whispered to Vannicock, ‘but I’ve waited so long on Mellstock hill that at last I drove down
to the turnpike; and seeing the light here, I ran on to find out what had happened.’

Lieutenant Vannicock told him to wait a few minutes, and the last barrow-load was got through. Mr. Maumbry stretched
himself and breathed heavily, saying, ‘There; we can do no more.’

As if from the relaxation of effort he seemed to be seized with violent pain. He pressed his hands to his sides and
bent forward.

‘Ah! I think it has got hold of me at last,’ he said with difficulty. ‘I must try to get home. Let Mr. Vannicock
take you back, Laura.’

He walked a few steps, they helping him, but was obliged to sink down on the grass.

‘I am — afraid — you’ll have to send for a hurdle, or shutter, or something,’ he went on feebly, ‘or try to get me
into the barrow.’

But Vannicock had called to the driver of the fly, and they waited until it was brought on from the turnpike hard
by. Mr. Maumbry was placed therein. Laura entered with him, and they drove to his humble residence near the Cross,
where he was got upstairs.

Vannicock stood outside by the empty fly awhile, but Laura did not reappear. He thereupon entered the fly and told
the driver to take him back to Ivell.

Chapter VII

Mr. Maumbry had over-exerted himself in the relief of the suffering poor, and fell a victim — one of the last — to
the pestilence which had carried off so many. Two days later he lay in his coffin.

Laura was in the room below. A servant brought in some letters, and she glanced them over. One was the note from
herself to Maumbry, informing him that she was unable to endure life with him any longer and was about to elope with
Vannicock. Having read the letter she took it upstairs to where the dead man was, and slipped it into his coffin. The
next day she buried him.

She was now free.

She shut up his house at Durnover Cross and returned to her lodgings at Creston. Soon she had a letter from
Vannicock, and six weeks after her husband’s death her lover came to see her.

‘I forgot to give you back this — that night,’ he said presently, handing her the little bag she had taken as her
whole luggage when leaving.

Laura received it and absently shook it out. There fell upon the carpet her brush, comb, slippers, nightdress, and
other simple necessaries for a journey. They had an intolerably ghastly look now, and she tried to cover them.

‘I can now,’ he said, ‘ask you to belong to me legally — when a proper interval has gone — instead of as we
meant.’

There was languor in his utterance, hinting at a possibility that it was perfunctorily made. Laura picked up her
articles, answering that he certainly could so ask her — she was free. Yet not her expression either could be called an
ardent response. Then she blinked more and more quickly and put her handkerchief to her face. She was weeping
violently.

He did not move or try to comfort her in any way. What had come between them? No living person. They had been
lovers. There was now no material obstacle whatever to their union. But there was the insistent shadow of that
unconscious one; the thin figure of him, moving to and fro in front of the ghastly furnace in the gloom of Durnover
Moor.

Yet Vannicock called upon Laura when he was in the neighbourhood, which was not often; but in two years, as if on
purpose to further the marriage which everybody was expecting, the —— st Foot returned to Budmouth Regis.

Thereupon the two could not help encountering each other at times. But whether because the obstacle had been the
source of the love, or from a sense of error, and because Mrs. Maumbry bore a less attractive look as a widow than
before, their feelings seemed to decline from their former incandescence to a mere tepid civility. What domestic issues
supervened in Vannicock’s further story the man in the oriel never knew; but Mrs. Maumbry lived and died a widow.

1900.

The Waiting Supper

Chapter I

Whoever had perceived the yeoman standing on Squire Everard’s lawn in the dusk of that October evening fifty years
ago, might have said at first sight that he was loitering there from idle curiosity. For a large five-light window of
the manor-house in front of him was unshuttered and uncurtained, so that the illuminated room within could be scanned
almost to its four corners. Obviously nobody was ever expected to be in this part of the grounds after nightfall.

The apartment thus swept by an eye from without was occupied by two persons; they were sitting over dessert, the
tablecloth having been removed in the old-fashioned way. The fruits were local, consisting of apples, pears, nuts, and
such other products of the summer as might be presumed to grow on the estate. There was strong ale and rum on the
table, and but little wine. Moreover, the appointments of the dining-room were simple and homely even for the date,
betokening a countrified household of the smaller gentry, without much wealth or ambition — formerly a numerous class,
but now in great part ousted by the territorial landlords.

One of the two sitters was a young lady in white muslin, who listened somewhat impatiently to the remarks of her
companion, an elderly, rubicund personage, whom the merest stranger could have pronounced to be her father. The watcher
evinced no signs of moving, and it became evident that affairs were not so simple as they first had seemed. The tall
farmer was in fact no accidental spectator, and he stood by premeditation close to the trunk of a tree, so that had any
traveller passed along the road without the park gate, or even round the lawn to the door, that person would scarce
have noticed the other, notwithstanding that the gate was quite near at hand, and the park little larger than a
paddock. There was still light enough in the western heaven to brighten faintly one side of the man’s face, and to show
against the trunk of the tree behind the admirable cut of his profile; also to reveal that the front of the
manor-house, small though it seemed, was solidly built of stone in that never-to-be-surpassed style for the English
country residence — the mullioned and transomed Elizabethan.

The lawn, although neglected, was still as level as a bowling-green — which indeed it might once have served for;
and the blades of grass before the window were raked by the candle-shine, which stretched over them so far as to touch
the yeoman’s face in front.

Within the dining-room there were also, with one of the twain, the same signs of a hidden purpose that marked the
farmer. The young lady’s mind was straying as clearly into the shadows as that of the loiterer was fixed upon the room
— nay, it could be said that she was quite conscious of his presence outside. Impatience caused her foot to beat
silently on the carpet, and she more than once rose to leave the table. This proceeding was checked by her father, who
would put his hand upon her shoulder and unceremoniously press her down into her chair, till he should have concluded
his observations. Her replies were brief enough, and there was factitiousness in her smiles of assent to his views. A
small iron casement between two of the mullions was open, and some occasional words of the dialogue were audible
without.

‘As for drains — how can I put in drains? The pipes don’t cost much, that’s true; but the labour in sinking the
trenches is ruination. And then the gates — they should be hung to stone posts, otherwise there’s no keeping them up
through harvest.’ The Squire’s voice was strongly toned with the local accent, so that he said ‘drains’ and ‘geats’
like the rustics on his estate.

The landscape without grew darker, and the young man’s figure seemed to be absorbed into the trunk of the tree. The
small stars filled in between the larger, the nebulae between the small stars, the trees quite lost their voice; and if
there was still a sound, it was from the cascade of a stream which stretched along under the trees that bounded the
lawn on its northern side.

At last the young girl did get to her feet and secure her retreat. ‘I have something to do, papa,’ she said. ‘I
shall not be in the drawing-room just yet.’

‘Very well,’ replied he. ‘Then I won’t hurry.’ And closing the door behind her, he drew his decanters together and
settled down in his chair.

Three minutes after that a woman’s shape emerged from the drawing-room window, and passing through a wall-door to
the entrance front, came across the grass. She kept well clear of the dining-room window, but enough of its light fell
on her to show, escaping from the dark-hooded cloak that she wore, stray verges of the same light dress which had
figured but recently at the dinner-table. The hood was contracted tight about her face with a drawing-string, making
her countenance small and baby-like, and lovelier even than before.

Without hesitation she brushed across the grass to the tree under which the young man stood concealed. The moment
she had reached him he enclosed her form with his arm. The meeting and embrace, though by no means formal, were yet not
passionate; the whole proceeding was that of persons who had repeated the act so often as to be unconscious of its
performance. She turned within his arm, and faced in the same direction with himself, which was towards the window; and
thus they stood without speaking, the back of her head leaning against his shoulder. For a while each seemed to be
thinking his and her diverse thoughts.

‘You have kept me waiting a long time, dear Christine,’ he said at last. ‘I wanted to speak to you particularly, or
I should not have stayed. How came you to be dining at this time o’ night?’

‘Father has been out all day, and dinner was put back till six. I know I have kept you; but Nicholas, how can I help
it sometimes, if I am not to run any risk? My poor father insists upon my listening to all he has to say; since my
brother left he has had nobody else to listen to him; and to-night he was particularly tedious on his usual topics —
draining, and tenant-farmers, and the village people. I must take daddy to London; he gets so narrow always staying
here.’

‘And what did you say to it all?’

‘Well, I took the part of the tenant-farmers, of course, as the beloved of one should in duty do.’ There followed a
little break or gasp, implying a strangled sigh.

‘You are sorry you have encouraged that beloving one?’

‘O no, Nicholas . . . What is it you want to see me for particularly?’

‘I know you are sorry, as time goes on, and everything is at a dead-lock, with no prospect of change, and your rural
swain loses his freshness! Only think, this secret understanding between us has lasted near three year, ever since you
was a little over sixteen.’

‘Yes; it has been a long time.’

‘And I an untamed, uncultivated man, who has never seen London, and knows nothing about society at all.’

‘Not uncultivated, dear Nicholas. Untravelled, socially unpractised, if you will,’ she said, smiling. ‘Well, I did
sigh; but not because I regret being your promised one. What I do sometimes regret is that the scheme, which my
meetings with you are but a part of, has not been carried out completely. You said, Nicholas, that if I consented to
swear to keep faith with you, you would go away and travel, and see nations, and peoples, and cities, and take a
professor with you, and study books and art, simultaneously with your study of men and manners; and then come back at
the end of two years, when I should find that my father would by no means be indisposed to accept you as a son-inlaw.
You said your reason for wishing to get my promise before starting was that your mind would then be more at rest when
you were far away, and so could give itself more completely to knowledge than if you went as my unaccepted lover only,
fuming with anxiety as to how I should be when you came back. I saw how reasonable that was; and solemnly swore myself
to you in consequence. But instead of going to see the world you stay on and on here to see me.’

‘And you don’t want me to see you?’

‘Yes — no — it is not that. It is that I have latterly felt frightened at what I am doing when not in your actual
presence. It seems so wicked not to tell my father that I have a lover close at hand, within touch and view of both of
us; whereas if you were absent my conduct would not seem quite so treacherous. The realities would not stare at one so.
You would be a pleasant dream to me, which I should be free to indulge in without reproach of my conscience; I should
live in hopeful expectation of your returning fully qualified to boldly claim me of my father. There, I have been
terribly frank, I know.’

He in his turn had lapsed into gloomy breathings now. ‘I did plan it as you state,’ he answered. ‘I did mean to go
away the moment I had your promise. But, dear Christine, I did not foresee two or three things. I did not know what a
lot of pain it would cost to tear myself from you. And I did not know that my stingy uncle — heaven forgive me calling
him so! — would so flatly refuse to advance me money for my purpose — the scheme of travelling with a first-rate tutor
costing a formidable sum o’ money. You have no idea what it would cost!’

‘But I have said that I’ll find the money.’

‘Ah, there,’ he returned, ‘you have hit a sore place. To speak truly, dear, I would rather stay unpolished a hundred
years than take your money.’

‘But why? Men continually use the money of the women they marry.’

‘Yes; but not till afterwards. No man would like to touch your money at present, and I should feel very mean if I
were to do so in present circumstances. That brings me to what I was going to propose. But no — upon the whole I will
not propose it now.’

‘Ah! I would guarantee expenses, and you won’t let me! The money is my personal possession: it comes to me from my
late grandfather, and not from my father at all.’

He laughed forcedly and pressed her hand. ‘There are more reasons why I cannot tear myself away,’ he added. ‘What
would become of my uncle’s farming? Six hundred acres in this parish, and five hundred in the next — a constant
traipsing from one farm to the other; he can’t be in two places at once. Still, that might be got over if it were not
for the other matters. Besides, dear, I still should be a little uneasy, even though I have your promise, lest somebody
should snap you up away from me.’

‘Ah, you should have thought of that before. Otherwise I have committed myself for nothing.’

‘I should have thought of it,’ he answered gravely. ‘But I did not. There lies my fault, I admit it freely. Ah, if
you would only commit yourself a little more, I might at least get over that difficulty! But I won’t ask you. You have
no idea how much you are to me still; you could not argue so coolly if you had. What property belongs to you I hate the
very sound of; it is you I care for. I wish you hadn’t a farthing in the world but what I could earn for you!’

‘I don’t altogether wish that,’ she murmured.

‘I wish it, because it would have made what I was going to propose much easier to do than it is now. Indeed I will
not propose it, although I came on purpose, after what you have said in your frankness.’

‘Nonsense, Nic. Come, tell me. How can you be so touchy?’

‘Look at this then, Christine dear.’ He drew from his breast-pocket a sheet of paper and unfolded it, when it was
observable that a seal dangled from the bottom.

‘What is it?’ She held the paper sideways, so that what there was of window-light fell on its surface. ‘I can only
read the Old English letters — why — our names! Surely it is not a marriage-licence?’

‘It is.’

She trembled. ‘O Nic! how could you do this — and without telling me!’

‘Why should I have thought I must tell you? You had not spoken “frankly” then as you have now. We have been all to
each other more than these two years, and I thought I would propose that we marry privately, and that I then leave you
on the instant. I would have taken my travelling-bag to church, and you would have gone home alone. I should not have
started on my adventures in the brilliant manner of our original plan, but should have roughed it a little at first; my
great gain would have been that the absolute possession of you would have enabled me to work with spirit and purpose,
such as nothing else could do. But I dare not ask you now — so frank as you have been.’

She did not answer. The document he had produced gave such unexpected substantiality to the venture with which she
had so long toyed as a vague dream merely, that she was, in truth, frightened a little. ‘I— don’t know about it!’ she
said.

‘A mere tiller of the soil, as I should be called,’ he continued, without heeding her. ‘And you — well, a daughter
of one of the — I won’t say oldest families, because that’s absurd, all families are the same age — one of the longest
chronicled families about here, whose name is actually the name of the place.’

‘That’s not much, I am sorry to say! My poor brother — but I won’t speak of that . . . Well,’ she murmured
mischievously, after a pause, ‘you certainly would not need to be uneasy if I were to do this that you want me to do.
You would have me safe enough in your trap then; I couldn’t get away!’

‘That’s just it!’ he said vehemently. ‘It is a trap — you feel it so, and that though you wouldn’t be able to get
away from me you might particularly wish to! Ah, if I had asked you two years ago you would have agreed instantly. But
I thought I was bound to wait for the proposal to come from you as the superior!’

‘Now you are angry, and take seriously what I meant purely in fun. You don’t know me even yet! To show you that you
have not been mistaken in me, I do propose to carry out this licence. I’ll marry you, dear Nicholas, tomorrow
morning.’

‘Ah, Christine! I am afraid I have stung you on to this, so that I cannot —’

‘No, no, no!’ she hastily rejoined; and there was something in her tone which suggested that she had been put upon
her mettle and would not flinch. ‘Take me whilst I am in the humour. What church is the licence for?’

‘That I’ve not looked to see — why our parish church here, of course. Ah, then we cannot use it! We dare not be
married here.’

‘We do dare,’ said she. ‘And we will too, if you’ll be there.’

‘If I’ll be there!’

They speedily came to an agreement that he should be in the church-porch at ten minutes to eight on the following
morning, awaiting her; and that, immediately after the conclusion of the service which would make them one, Nicholas
should set out on his long-deferred educational tour, towards the cost of which she was resolving to bring a
substantial subscription with her to church. Then, slipping from him, she went indoors by the way she had come, and
Nicholas bent his steps homewards.

Chapter II

Instead of leaving the spot by the gate, he flung himself over the fence, and pursued a direction towards the river
under the trees. And it was now, in his lonely progress, that he showed for the first time outwardly that he was not
altogether unworthy of her. He wore long water-boots reaching above his knees, and, instead of making a circuit to find
a bridge by which he might cross the Froom — the river aforesaid — he made straight for the point whence proceeded the
low roar that was at this hour the only evidence of the stream’s existence. He speedily stood on the verge of the
waterfall which caused the noise, and stepping into the water at the top of the fall, waded through with the sure tread
of one who knew every inch of his footing, even though the canopy of trees rendered the darkness almost absolute, and a
false step would have precipitated him into the pool beneath. Soon reaching the boundary of the grounds, he continued
in the same direct line to traverse the alluvial valley, full of brooks and tributaries to the main stream — in former
times quite impassable, and impassable in winter now. Sometimes he would cross a deep gully on a plank not wider than
the hand; at another time he ploughed his way through beds of spear-grass, where at a few feet to the right or left he
might have been sucked down into a morass. At last he reached firm land on the other side of this watery tract, and
came to his house on the rise behind — Elsenford — an ordinary farmstead, from the back of which rose indistinct
breathings, belchings, and snortings, the rattle of halters, and other familiar features of an agriculturist’s
home.

While Nicholas Long was packing his bag in an upper room of this dwelling, Miss Christine Everard sat at a desk in
her own chamber at Froom–Everard manor-house, looking with pale fixed countenance at the candles.

‘I ought — I must now!’ she whispered to herself. ‘I should not have begun it if I had not meant to carry it
through! It runs in the blood of us, I suppose.’ She alluded to a fact unknown to her lover, the clandestine marriage
of an aunt under circumstances somewhat similar to the present. In a few minutes she had penned the following
note:—

October 13, 183-.

DEAR MR. BEALAND— Can you make it convenient to yourself to meet me at the Church tomorrow morning at eight? I name
the early hour because it would suit me better than later on in the day. You will find me in the chancel, if you can
come. An answer yes or no by the bearer of this will be sufficient.

CHRISTINE EVERARD.

She sent the note to the rector immediately, waiting at a small side-door of the house till she heard the servant’s
footsteps returning along the lane, when she went round and met him in the passage. The rector had taken the trouble to
write a line, and answered that he would meet her with pleasure.

A dripping fog which ushered in the next morning was highly favourable to the scheme of the pair. At that time of
the century Froom–Everard House had not been altered and enlarged; the public lane passed close under its walls; and
there was a door opening directly from one of the old parlours — the south parlour, as it was called — into the lane
which led to the village. Christine came out this way, and after following the lane for a short distance entered upon a
path within a belt of plantation, by which the church could be reached privately. She even avoided the churchyard gate,
walking along to a place where the turf without the low wall rose into a mound, enabling her to mount upon the coping
and spring down inside. She crossed the wet graves, and so glided round to the door. He was there, with his bag in his
hand. He kissed her with a sort of surprise, as if he had expected that at the last moment her heart would fail
her.

Though it had not failed her, there was, nevertheless, no great ardour in Christine’s bearing — merely the momentum
of an antecedent impulse. They went up the aisle together, the bottle-green glass of the old lead quarries admitting
but little light at that hour, and under such an atmosphere. They stood by the altar-rail in silence, Christine’s skirt
visibly quivering at each beat of her heart.

Presently a quick step ground upon the gravel, and Mr. Bealand came round by the front. He was a quiet bachelor,
courteous towards Christine, and not at first recognizing in Nicholas a neighbouring yeoman (for he lived aloofly in
the next parish), advanced to her without revealing any surprise at her unusual request. But in truth he was surprised,
the keen interest taken by many country young women at the present day in church decoration and festivals being then
unknown.

‘Good morning,’ he said; and repeated the same words to Nicholas more mechanically.

‘Good morning,’ she replied gravely. ‘Mr. Bealand, I have a serious reason for asking you to meet me — us, I may
say. We wish you to marry us.’

The rector’s gaze hardened to fixity, rather between than upon either of them, and he neither moved nor replied for
some time.

‘Ah!’ he said at last.

‘And we are quite ready.’

‘I had no idea —’

‘It has been kept rather private,’ she said calmly.

‘Where are your witnesses?’

‘They are outside in the meadow, sir. I can call them in a moment,’ said Nicholas.

‘Oh — I see it is — Mr. Nicholas Long,’ said Mr. Bealand, and turning again to Christine, ‘Does your father know of
this?’

‘Is it necessary that I should answer that question, Mr. Bealand?’

‘I am afraid it is — highly necessary.’

Christine began to look concerned.

‘Where is the licence?’ the rector asked; ‘since there have been no banns.’

Nicholas produced it, Mr. Bealand read it, an operation which occupied him several minutes — or at least he made it
appear so; till Christine said impatiently, ‘We are quite ready, Mr. Bealand. Will you proceed? Mr. Long has to take a
journey of a great many miles today.’

‘But have you a right to refuse us?’ interposed Nicholas. ‘I believe we are in a position to demand your fulfilment
of our request.’

‘No, you are not! Is Miss Everard of age? I think not. I think she is months from being so. Eh, Miss Everard?’

‘Am I bound to tell that?’

‘Certainly. At any rate you are bound to write it. Meanwhile I refuse to solemnize the service. And let me entreat
you two young people to do nothing so rash as this, even if by going to some strange church, you may do so without
discovery. The tragedy of marriage —’

‘Tragedy?’

‘Certainly. It is full of crises and catastrophes, and ends with the death of one of the actors. The tragedy of
marriage, as I was saying, is one I shall not be a party to your beginning with such light hearts, and I shall feel
bound to put your father on his guard, Miss Everard. Think better of it, I entreat you! Remember the proverb, “Marry in
haste and repent at leisure.”’

Christine, spurred by opposition, almost stormed at him. Nicholas implored; but nothing would turn that obstinate
rector. She sat down and reflected. By-and-by she confronted Mr. Bealand.

‘Our marriage is not to be this morning, I see,’ she said. ‘Now grant me one favour, and in return I’ll promise you
to do nothing rashly. Do not tell my father a word of what has happened here.’

‘I agree — if you undertake not to elope.’

She looked at Nicholas, and he looked at her. ‘Do you wish me to elope, Nic?’ she asked.

‘No,’ he said.

So the compact was made, and they left the church singly, Nicholas remaining till the last, and closing the door. On
his way home, carrying the well-packed bag which was just now to go no further, the two men who were mending
water-carriers in the meadows approached the hedge, as if they had been on the alert all the time.

‘You said you mid want us for zummat, sir?’

‘All right — never mind,’ he answered through the hedge. ‘I did not require you after all.’

Chapter III

At a manor not far away there lived a queer and primitive couple who had lately been blessed with a son and heir.
The christening took place during the week under notice, and this had been followed by a feast to the parishioners.
Christine’s father, one of the same generation and kind, had been asked to drive over and assist in the entertainment,
and Christine, as a matter of course, accompanied him.

When they reached Athelhall, as the house was called, they found the usually quiet nook a lively spectacle. Tables
had been spread in the apartment which lent its name to the whole building — the hall proper — covered with a fine
open-timbered roof, whose braces, purlins, and rafters made a brown thicket of oak overhead. Here tenantry of all ages
sat with their wives and families, and the servants were assisted in their ministrations by the sons and daughters of
the owner’s friends and neighbours. Christine lent a hand among the rest.

She was holding a plate in each hand towards a huge brown platter of baked rice-pudding, from which a footman was
scooping a large spoonful, when a voice reached her ear over her shoulder: ‘Allow me to hold them for you.’

Christine turned, and recognized in the speaker the nephew of the entertainer, a young man from London, whom she had
already met on two or three occasions.

She accepted the proffered help, and from that moment, whenever he passed her in their marchings to and fro during
the remainder of the serving, he smiled acquaintance. When their work was done, he improved the few words into a
conversation. He plainly had been attracted by her fairness.

Bellston was a self-assured young man, not particularly good-looking, with more colour in his skin than even
Nicholas had. He had flushed a little in attracting her notice, though the flush had nothing of nervousness in it — the
air with which it was accompanied making it curiously suggestive of a flush of anger; and even when he laughed it was
difficult to banish that fancy.

The late autumn sunlight streamed in through the window panes upon the heads and shoulders of the venerable
patriarchs of the hamlet, and upon the middle-aged, and upon the young; upon men and women who had played out, or were
to play, tragedies or tragi-comedies in that nook of civilization not less great, essentially, than those which,
enacted on more central arenas, fix the attention of the world. One of the party was a cousin of Nicholas Long’s, who
sat with her husband and children.

To make himself as locally harmonious as possible, Mr. Bellston remarked to his companion on the scene —‘It does
one’s heart good,’ he said, ‘to see these simple peasants enjoying themselves.’

‘O Mr. Bellston!’ exclaimed Christine; ‘don’t be too sure about that word “simple”! You little think what they see
and meditate! Their reasonings and emotions are as complicated as ours.’

She spoke with a vehemence which would have been hardly present in her words but for her own relation to Nicholas.
The sense of that produced in her a nameless depression thenceforward. The young man, however, still followed her
up.

‘I am glad to hear you say it,’ he returned warmly. ‘I was merely attuning myself to your mood, as I thought. The
real truth is that I know more of the Parthians, and Medes, and dwellers in Mesopotamia — almost of any people, indeed
— than of the English rustics. Travel and exploration are my profession, not the study of the British peasantry.’

Travel. There was sufficient coincidence between his declaration and the course she had urged upon her lover, to
lend Bellston’s account of himself a certain interest in Christine’s ears. He might perhaps be able to tell her
something that would be useful to Nicholas, if their dream were carried out. A door opened from the hall into the
garden, and she somehow found herself outside, chatting with Mr. Bellston on this topic, till she thought that upon the
whole she liked the young man. The garden being his uncle’s, he took her round it with an air of proprietorship; and
they went on amongst the Michaelmas daisies and chrysanthemums, and through a door to the fruit-garden. A green-house
was open, and he went in and cut her a bunch of grapes.

‘How daring of you! They are your uncle’s.’

‘O, he don’t mind — I do anything here. A rough old buffer, isn’t he?’

She was thinking of her Nic, and felt that, by comparison with her present acquaintance, the farmer more than held
his own as a fine and intelligent fellow; but the harmony with her own existence in little things, which she found
here, imparted an alien tinge to Nicholas just now. The latter, idealized by moonlight, or a thousand miles of
distance, was altogether a more romantic object for a woman’s dream than this smart new-lacquered man; but in the sun
of afternoon, and amid a surrounding company, Mr. Bellston was a very tolerable companion.

When they re-entered the hall, Bellston entreated her to come with him up a spiral stair in the thickness of the
wall, leading to a passage and gallery whence they could look down upon the scene below. The people had finished their
feast, the newly-christened baby had been exhibited, and a few words having been spoken to them they began, amid a
racketing of forms, to make for the greensward without, Nicholas’s cousin and cousin’s wife and cousin’s children among
the rest. While they were filing out, a voice was heard calling —‘Hullo! — here, Jim; where are you?’ said Bellston’s
uncle. The young man descended, Christine following at leisure.

‘Now will ye be a good fellow,’ the Squire continued, ‘and set them going outside in some dance or other that they
know? I’m dog-tired, and I want to have a yew words with Mr. Everard before we join ’em — hey, Everard? They are shy
till somebody starts ’em; afterwards they’ll keep gwine brisk enough.’

‘Ay, that they wool,’ said Squire Everard.

They followed to the lawn; and here it proved that James Bellston was as shy, or rather as averse, as any of the
tenantry themselves, to acting the part of fugleman. Only the parish people had been at the feast, but outlying
neighbours had now strolled in for a dance.

‘They want “Speed the Plough,”’ said Bellston, coming up breathless. ‘It must be a country dance, I suppose? Now,
Miss Everard, do have pity upon me. I am supposed to lead off; but really I know no more about speeding the plough than
a child just born! Would you take one of the villagers? — just to start them, my uncle says. Suppose you take that
handsome young farmer over there — I don’t know his name, but I dare say you do — and I’ll come on with one of the
dairyman’s daughters as a second couple.’

Christine turned in the direction signified, and changed colour — though in the shade nobody noticed it, ‘Oh, yes —
I know him,’ she said coolly. ‘He is from near our own place — Mr. Nicholas Long.’

‘That’s capital — then you can easily make him stand as first couple with you. Now I must pick up mine.’

‘I— I think I’ll dance with you, Mr. Bellston,’ she said with some trepidation. ‘Because, you see,’ she explained
eagerly, ‘I know the figure and you don’t — so that I can help you; while Nicholas Long, I know, is familiar with the
figure, and that will make two couples who know it — which is necessary, at least.’

Bellston showed his gratification by one of his angry-pleasant flushes — he had hardly dared to ask for what she
proffered freely; and having requested Nicholas to take the dairyman’s daughter, led Christine to her place, Long
promptly stepping up second with his charge. There were grim silent depths in Nic’s character; a small deedy spark in
his eye, as it caught Christine’s, was all that showed his consciousness of her. Then the fiddlers began — the
celebrated Mellstock fiddlers who, given free stripping, could play from sunset to dawn without turning a hair. The
couples wheeled and swung, Nicholas taking Christine’s hand in the course of business with the figure, when she waited
for him to give it a little squeeze; but he did not.

Christine had the greatest difficulty in steering her partner through the maze, on account of his self-will, and
when at last they reached the bottom of the long line, she was breathless with her hard labour.. Resting here, she
watched Nic and his lady; and, though she had decidedly cooled off in these later months, began to admire him anew.
Nobody knew these dances like him, after all, or could do anything of this sort so well. His performance with the
dairyman’s daughter so won upon her, that when ‘Speed the Plough’ was over she contrived to speak to him.

‘Nic, you are to dance with me next time.’

He said he would, and presently asked her in a formal public manner, lifting his hat gallantly. She showed a little
backwardness, which he quite understood, and allowed him to lead her to the top, a row of enormous length appearing
below them as if by magic as soon as they had taken their places. Truly the Squire was right when he said that they
only wanted starting.

‘What is it to be?’ whispered Nicholas.

She turned to the band. ‘The Honeymoon,’ she said.

And then they trod the delightful last-century measure of that name, which if it had been ever danced better, was
never danced with more zest. The perfect responsiveness which their tender acquaintance threw into the motions of
Nicholas and his partner lent to their gyrations the fine adjustment of two interacting parts of a single machine. The
excitement of the movement carried Christine back to the time — the unreflecting passionate time, about two years
before — when she and Nic had been incipient lovers only; and it made her forget the carking anxieties, the vision of
social breakers ahead, that had begun to take the gilding off her position now. Nicholas, on his part, had never ceased
to be a lover; no personal worries had as yet made him conscious of any staleness, flatness, or unprofitableness in his
admiration of Christine.

‘Not quite so wildly, Nic,’ she whispered. ‘I don’t object personally; but they’ll notice us. How came you
here?’

‘I heard that you had driven over; and I set out — on purpose for this.’

‘What — you have walked?’

‘Yes. If I had waited for one of uncle’s horses I should have been too late.’

‘Five miles here and five back — ten miles on foot — merely to dance!’

‘With you. What made you think of this old “Honeymoon” thing?’

‘O! it came into my head when I saw you, as what would have been a reality with us if you had not been stupid about
that licence, and had got it for a distant church.’

‘Shall we try again?’

‘No — I don’t know. I’ll think it over.’

The villagers admired their grace and skill, as the dancers themselves perceived; but they did not know what
accompanied that admiration in one spot, at least.

‘People who wonder they can foot it so featly together should know what some others think,’ a waterman was saying to
his neighbour. ‘Then their wonder would be less.’

His comrade asked for information.

‘Well — really I hardly believe it — but ’tis said they be man and wife. Yes, sure — went to church and did the job
a’most afore ’twas light one morning. But mind, not a word of this; for ‘twould be the loss of a winter’s work to me if
I had spread such a report and it were not true.’

When the dance had ended she rejoined her own section of the company. Her father and Mr. Bellston the elder had now
come out from the house, and were smoking in the background. Presently she found that her father was at her elbow.

‘Christine, don’t dance too often with young Long — as a mere matter of prudence, I mean, as volk might think it
odd, he being one of our own neighbouring farmers. I should not mention this to ‘ee if he were an ordinary young
fellow; but being superior to the rest it behoves you to be careful.’

‘Exactly, papa,’ said Christine.

But the revived sense that she was deceiving him threw a damp over her spirits. ‘But, after all,’ she said to
herself, ‘he is a young man of Elsenford, handsome, able, and the soul of honour; and I am a young woman of the
adjoining parish, who have been constantly thrown into communication with him. Is it not, by nature’s rule, the most
proper thing in the world that I should marry him, and is it not an absurd conventional regulation which says that such
a union would be wrong?’

It may be concluded that the strength of Christine’s large-minded argument was rather an evidence of weakness than
of strength in the passion it concerned, which had required neither argument nor reasoning of any kind for its
maintenance when full and flush in its early days.

When driving home in the dark with her father she sank into pensive silence. She was thinking of Nicholas having to
trudge on foot all those miles back after his exertions on the sward. Mr. Everard, arousing himself from a nap, said
suddenly, ‘I have something to mention to ‘ee, by George — so I have, Chris! You probably know what it is?’

She expressed ignorance, wondering if her father had discovered anything of her secret.

‘Well, according to him you know it. But I will tell ‘ee. Perhaps you noticed young Jim Bellston walking me off down
the lawn with him? — whether or no, we walked together a good while; and he informed me that he wanted to pay his
addresses to ‘ee. I naturally said that it depended upon yourself; and he replied that you were willing enough; you had
given him particular encouragement — showing your preference for him by specially choosing him for your partner — hey?
“In that case,” says I, “go on and conquer — settle it with her — I have no objection.” The poor fellow was very
grateful, and in short, there we left the matter. He’ll propose tomorrow.’

She saw now to her dismay what James Bellston had read as encouragement. ‘He has mistaken me altogether,’ she said.
‘I had no idea of such a thing.’

‘What, you won’t have him?’

‘Indeed, I cannot!’

‘Chrissy,’ said Mr. Everard with emphasis, ‘there’s noobody whom I should so like you to marry as that young man.
He’s a thoroughly clever fellow, and fairly well provided for. He’s travelled all over the temperate zone; but he says
that directly he marries he’s going to give up all that, and be a regular stay-at-home. You would be nowhere safer than
in his hands.’

‘It is true,’ she answered. ‘He is a highly desirable match, and I should be well provided for, and probably very
safe in his hands.’

‘Then don’t be skittish, and stand-to.’

She had spoken from her conscience and understanding, and not to please her father. As a reflecting woman she
believed that such a marriage would be a wise one. In great things Nicholas was closest to her nature; in little things
Bellston seemed immeasurably nearer than Nic; and life was made up of little things.

Altogether the firmament looked black for Nicholas Long, notwithstanding her half-hour’s ardour for him when she saw
him dancing with the dairyman’s daughter. Most great passions, movements, and beliefs — individual and national — burst
during their decline into a temporary irradiation, which rivals their original splendour; and then they speedily become
extinct. Perhaps the dance had given the last flare-up to Christine’s love. It seemed to have improvidently consumed
for its immediate purpose all her ardour forwards, so that for the future there was nothing left but frigidity.

Nicholas had certainly been very foolish about that licence!

Chapter IV

This laxity of emotional tone was further increased by an incident, when, two days later, she kept an appointment
with Nicholas in the Sallows. The Sallows was an extension of shrubberies and plantations along the banks of the Froom,
accessible from the lawn of Froom–Everard House only, except by wading through the river at the waterfall or elsewhere.
Near the brink was a thicket of box in which a trunk lay prostrate; this had been once or twice their trysting-place,
though it was by no means a safe one; and it was here she sat awaiting him now.

The noise of the stream muffled any sound of footsteps, and it was before she was aware of his approach that she
looked up and saw him wading across at the top of the waterfall.

Noontide lights and dwarfed shadows always banished the romantic aspect of her love for Nicholas. Moreover,
something new had occurred to disturb her; and if ever she had regretted giving way to a tenderness for him — which
perhaps she had not done with any distinctness — she regretted it now. Yet in the bottom of their hearts those two were
excellently paired, the very twin halves of a perfect whole; and their love was pure. But at this hour surfaces showed
garishly, and obscured the depths. Probably her regret appeared in her face.

He walked up to her without speaking, the water running from his boots; and, taking one of her hands in each of his
own, looked narrowly into her eyes.

‘Have you thought it over?’

‘What?’

‘Whether we shall try again; you remember saying you would at the dance?’

‘Oh, I had forgotten that!’

‘You are sorry we tried at all!’ he said accusingly.

‘I am not so sorry for the fact as for the rumours,’ she said.

‘Ah! rumours?’

‘They say we are already married.’

‘Who?’

‘I cannot tell exactly. I heard some whispering to that effect. Somebody in the village told one of the servants, I
believe. This man said that he was crossing the churchyard early on that unfortunate foggy morning, and heard voices in
the chancel, and peeped through the window as well as the dim panes would let him; and there he saw you and me and Mr.
Bealand, and so on; but thinking his surmises would be dangerous knowledge, he hastened on. And so the story got
afloat. Then your aunt, too —’

‘Good Lord! — what has she done?’

The story was, told her, and she said proudly, “O yes, it is true enough. I have seen the licence. But it is not to
be known yet.”’

‘Seen the licence? How the —’

‘Accidentally, I believe, when your coat was hanging somewhere.’

The information, coupled with the infelicitous word ‘proudly,’ caused Nicholas to flush with mortification. He knew
that it was in his aunt’s nature to make a brag of that sort; but worse than the brag was the fact that this was the
first occasion on which Christine had deigned to show her consciousness that such a marriage would be a source of pride
to his relatives — the only two he had in the world.

‘You are sorry, then, even to be thought my wife, much less to be it.’ He dropped her hand, which fell
lifelessly.

‘It is not sorry exactly, dear Nic. But I feel uncomfortable and vexed, that after screwing up my courage, my
fidelity, to the point of going to church, you should have so muddled — managed the matter that it has ended in neither
one thing nor the other. How can I meet acquaintances, when I don’t know what they are thinking of me?’

‘Then, dear Christine, let us mend the muddle. I’ll go away for a few days and get another licence, and you can come
to me.’

She shrank from this perceptibly. ‘I cannot screw myself up to it a second time,’ she said. ‘I am sure I cannot!
Besides, I promised Mr. Bealand. And yet how can I continue to see you after such a rumour? We shall be watched now,
for certain.’

‘Then don’t see me.’

‘I fear I must not for the present. Altogether —’

‘What?’

‘I am very depressed.’

These views were not very inspiriting to Nicholas, as he construed them. It may indeed have been possible that he
construed them wrongly, and should have insisted upon her making the rumour true. Unfortunately, too, he had come to
her in a hurry through brambles and briars, water and weed, and the shaggy wildness which hung about his appearance at
this fine and correct time of day lent an impracticability to the look of him.

‘No, Nicholas, I do not repent that,’ she returned gently, though with firmness. ‘But I think that you ought not to
have got that licence without asking me first; and I also think that you ought to have known how it would be if you
lived on here in your present position, and made no effort to better it. I can bear whatever comes, for social ruin is
not personal ruin or even personal disgrace. But as a sensible, new-risen poet says, whom I have been reading this
morning:—

The world and its ways have a certain worth:
And to press a point while these oppose
Were simple policy. Better wait.

As soon as you had got my promise, Nic, you should have gone away — yes — and made a name, and come back to claim
me. That was my silly girlish dream about my hero.’

‘Perhaps I can do as much yet! And would you have indeed liked better to live away from me for family reasons, than
to run a risk in seeing me for affection’s sake? O what a cold heart it has grown! If I had been a prince, and you a
dairymaid, I’d have stood by you in the face of the world!’

She shook her head. ‘Ah — you don’t know what society is — you don’t know.’

‘Perhaps not. Who was that strange gentleman of about seven-and-twenty I saw at Mr. Bellston’s christening
feast?’

‘Oh — that was his nephew James. Now he is a man who has seen an unusual extent of the world for his age. He is a
great traveller, you know.’

‘Indeed.’

‘In fact an explorer. He is very entertaining.’

‘No doubt.’

Nicholas received no shock of jealousy from her announcement. He knew her so well that he could see she was not in
the least in love with Bellston. But he asked if Bellston were going to continue his explorations.

‘Not if he settles in life. Otherwise he will, I suppose.’

‘Perhaps I could be a great explorer, too, if I tried.’

‘You could, I am sure.’

They sat apart, and not together; each looking afar off at vague objects, and not in each other’s eyes. Thus the sad
autumn afternoon waned, while the waterfall hissed sarcastically of the inevitableness of the unpleasant. Very
different this from the time when they had first met there.

The nook was most picturesque; but it looked horridly common and stupid now. Their sentiment had set a colour hardly
less visible than a material one on surrounding objects, as sentiment must where life is but thought. Nicholas was as
devoted as ever to the fair Christine; but unhappily he too had moods and humours, and the division between them was
not closed.

She had no sooner got indoors and sat down to her work-table than her father entered the drawing-room.

She handed him his newspaper; he took it without a word, went and stood on the hearthrug, and flung the paper on the
floor.

‘Christine, what’s the meaning of this terrible story? I was just on my way to look at the register.’

She looked at him without speech.

‘You have married — Nicholas Long?’

‘No, father.’

‘No? Can you say no in the face of such facts as I have been put in possession of?’

‘Yes.’

‘But — the note you wrote to the rector — and the going to church?’

She briefly explained that their attempt had failed.

‘Ah! Then this is what that dancing meant, was it? By — — it makes me ——. How long has this been going on, may I
ask?’

‘This what?’

‘What, indeed! Why, making him your beau. Now listen to me. All’s well that ends well; from this day, madam, this
moment, he is to be nothing more to you. You are not to see him. Cut him adrift instantly! I only wish his volk were on
my farm — out they should go, or I would know the reason why. However, you are to write him a letter to this effect at
once.’

‘How can I cut him adrift?’

‘Why not? You must, my good maid!’

‘Well, though I have not actually married him, I have solemnly sworn to be his wife when he comes home from abroad
to claim me. It would be gross perjury not to fulfil my promise. Besides, no woman can go to church with a man to
deliberately solemnize matrimony, and refuse him afterwards, if he does nothing wrong meanwhile.’

The uttered sound of her strong conviction seemed to kindle in Christine a livelier perception of all its bearings
than she had known while it had lain unformulated in her mind. For when she had done speaking she fell down on her
knees before her father, covered her face, and said, ‘Please, please forgive me, papa! How could I do it without
letting you know! I don’t know, I don’t know!’

When she looked up she found that, in the turmoil of his mind, her father was moving about the room. ‘You are within
an ace of ruining yourself, ruining me, ruining us all!’ he said. ‘You are nearly as bad as your brother, begad!’

‘Perhaps I am — yes — perhaps I am!’

‘That I should father such a harum-scarum brood!’

‘It is very bad; but Nicholas —’

‘He’s a scoundrel!’

‘He is not a scoundrel!’ cried she, turning quickly. ‘He’s as good and worthy as you or I, or anybody bearing our
name, or any nobleman in the kingdom, if you come to that! Only — only’— she could not continue the argument on those
lines. ‘Now, father, listen!’ she sobbed; ‘if you taunt me I’ll go off and join him at his farm this very day, and
marry him tomorrow, that’s what I’ll do!’

‘I don’t taant ye!’

‘I wish to avoid unseemliness as much as you.’

She went away. When she came back a quarter of an hour later, thinking to find the room empty, he was standing there
as before, never having apparently moved. His manner had quite changed. He seemed to take a resigned and entirely
different view of circumstances.

‘Christine, here’s a paragraph in the paper hinting at a secret wedding, and I’m blazed if it don’t point to you.
Well, since this was to happen, I’ll bear it, and not complain. All volk have crosses, and this is one of mine. Now,
this is what I’ve got to say — I feel that you must carry out this attempt at marrying Nicholas Long. Faith, you must!
The rumour will become a scandal if you don’t — that’s my view. I have tried to look at the brightest side of the case.
Nicholas Long is a young man superior to most of his class, and fairly presentable. And he’s not poor — at least his
uncle is not. I believe the old muddler could buy me up any day. However, a farmer’s wife you must be, as far as I can
see. As you’ve made your bed, so ye must lie. Parents propose, and ungrateful children dispose. You shall marry him,
and immediately.’

Christine hardly knew what to make of this. ‘He is quite willing to wait, and so am I. We can wait for two or three
years, and then he will be as worthy as —’

‘You must marry him. And the sooner the better, if ’tis to be done at all . . . And yet I did wish you
could have been Jim Bellston’s wife. I did wish it! But no.’

‘I, too, wished it and do still, in one sense,’ she returned gently. His moderation had won her out of her defiant
mood, and she was willing to reason with him.

‘You do?’ he said surprised.

‘I see that in a worldly sense my conduct with Mr. Long may be considered a mistake.’

‘H’m — I am glad to hear that — after my death you may see it more clearly still; and you won’t have long to wait,
to my reckoning.’

She fell into bitter repentance, and kissed him in her anguish. ‘Don’t say that!’ she cried. ‘Tell me what to
do?’

‘If you’ll leave me for an hour or two I’ll think. Drive to the market and back — the carriage is at the door — and
I’ll try to collect my senses. Dinner can be put back till you return.’

In a few minutes she was dressed, and the carriage bore her up the hill which divided the village and manor from the
market-town.

Chapter V

A quarter of an hour brought her into the High Street, and for want of a more important errand she called at the
harness-maker’s for a dog-collar that she required.

It happened to be market-day, and Nicholas, having postponed the engagements which called him thither to keep the
appointment with her in the Sallows, rushed off at the end of the afternoon to attend to them as well as he could.
Arriving thus in a great hurry on account of the lateness of the hour, he still retained the wild, amphibious
appearance which had marked him when he came up from the meadows to her side — an exceptional condition of things which
had scarcely ever before occurred. When she crossed the pavement from the shop door, the shopman bowing and escorting
her to the carriage, Nicholas chanced to be standing at the road-waggon office, talking to the master of the waggons.
There were a good many people about, and those near paused and looked at her transit, in the full stroke of the level
October sun, which went under the brims of their hats, and pierced through their button-holes. From the group she heard
murmured the words: ‘Mrs. Nicholas Long.’

The unexpected remark, not without distinct satire in its tone, took her so greatly by surprise that she was
confounded. Nicholas was by this time nearer, though coming against the sun he had not yet perceived her. Influenced by
her father’s lecture, she felt angry with him for being there and causing this awkwardness. Her notice of him was
therefore slight, supercilious perhaps, slurred over; and her vexation at his presence showed distinctly in her face as
she sat down in her seat. Instead of catching his waiting eye, she positively turned her head away.

A moment after she was sorry she had treated him so; but he was gone.

Reaching home she found on her dressing-table a note from her father. The statement was brief:

I have considered and am of the same opinion. You must marry him. He can leave home at once and travel as proposed.
I have written to him to this effect. I don’t want any victuals, so don’t wait dinner for me.

Nicholas was the wrong kind of man to be blind to his Christine’s mortification, though he did not know its entire
cause. He had lately foreseen something of this sort as possible.

‘It serves me right,’ he thought, as he trotted homeward. ‘It was absurd — wicked of me to lead her on so. The
sacrifice would have been too great — too cruel!’ And yet, though he thus took her part, he flushed with indignation
every time he said to himself, ‘She is ashamed of me!’

On the ridge which overlooked Froom–Everard he met a neighbour of his — a stock-dealer — in his gig, and they drew
rein and exchanged a few words. A part of the dealer’s conversation had much meaning for Nicholas.

‘I’ve had occasion to call on Squire Everard,’ the former said; ‘but he couldn’t see me on account of being quite
knocked up at some bad news he has heard.’

Nicholas rode on past Froom–Everard to Elsenford Farm, pondering. He had new and startling matter for thought as
soon as he got there. The Squire’s note had arrived. At first he could not credit its import; then he saw further, took
in the tone of the letter, saw the writer’s contempt behind the words, and understood that the letter was written as by
a man hemmed into a corner. Christine was defiantly — insultingly — hurled at his head. He was accepted because he was
so despised.

And yet with what respect he had treated her and hers! Now he was reminded of what an agricultural friend had said
years ago, seeing the eyes of Nicholas fixed on Christine as on an angel when she passed: ‘Better a little fire to warm
‘ee than a great one to burn ‘ee. No good can come of throwing your heart there.’ He went into the mead, sat down, and
asked himself four questions:

1. How could she live near her acquaintance as his wife, even in his absence, without suffering martyrdom from the
stings of their contempt?

2. Would not this entail total estrangement between Christine and her family also, and her own consequent
misery?

3. Must not such isolation extinguish her affection for him?

4. Supposing that her father rigged them out as colonists and sent them off to America, was not the effect of such
exile upon one of her gentle nurture likely to be as the last?

In short, whatever they should embark in together would be cruelty to her, and his death would be a relief. It
would, indeed, in one aspect be a relief to her now, if she were so ashamed of him as she had appeared to be that day.
Were he dead, this little episode with him would fade away like a dream.

Mr. Everard was a good-hearted man at bottom, but to take his enraged offer seriously was impossible. Obviously it
was hotly made in his first bitterness at what he had heard. The least thing that he could do would be to go away and
never trouble her more. To travel and learn and come back in two years, as mapped out in their first sanguine scheme,
required a staunch heart on her side, if the necessary expenditure of time and money were to be afterwards justified;
and it were folly to calculate on that when he had seen today that her heart was failing her already. To travel and
disappear and not be heard of for many years would be a far more independent stroke, and it would leave her entirely
unfettered. Perhaps he might rival in this kind the accomplished Mr. Bellston, of whose journeyings he had heard so
much.

He sat and sat, and the fog rose out of the river, enveloping him like a fleece; first his feet and knees, then his
arms and body, and finally submerging his head. When he had come to a decision he went up again into the homestead. He
would be independent, if he died for it, and he would free Christine. Exile was the only course. The first step was to
inform his uncle of his determination.

Two days later Nicholas was on the same spot in the mead, at almost the same hour of eve. But there was no fog now;
a blusterous autumn wind had ousted the still, golden days and misty nights; and he was going, full of purpose, in the
opposite direction. When he had last entered the mead he was an inhabitant of the Froom valley; in forty-eight hours he
had severed himself from that spot as completely as if he had never belonged to it. All that appertained to him in the
Froom valley now was circumscribed by the portmanteau in his hand.

In making his preparations for departure he had unconsciously held a faint, foolish hope that she would communicate
with him and make up their estrangement in some soft womanly way. But she had given no signal, and it was too evident
to him that her latest mood had grown to be her fixed one, proving how well founded had been his impulse to set her
free.

He entered the Sallows, found his way in the dark to the garden-door of the house, slipped under it a note to tell
her of his departure, and explaining its true reason to be a consciousness of her growing feeling that he was an
encumbrance and a humiliation. Of the direction of his journey and of the date of his return he said nothing.

His course now took him into the high road, which he pursued for some miles in a north-easterly direction, still
spinning the thread of sad inferences, and asking himself why he should ever return. At daybreak he stood on the hill
above Shottsford–Forum, and awaited a coach which passed about this time along that highway towards Melchester and
London.

Chapter VI

Some fifteen years after the date of the foregoing incidents, a man who had dwelt in far countries, and viewed many
cities, arrived at Roy–Town, a roadside hamlet on the old western turnpike road, not five miles from Froom–Everard, and
put up at the Buck’s Head, an isolated inn at that spot. He was still barely of middle age, but it could be seen that a
haze of grey was settling upon the locks of his hair, and that his face had lost colour and curve, as if by exposure to
bleaching climates and strange atmospheres, or from ailments incidental thereto. He seemed to observe little around
him, by reason of the intrusion of his musings upon the scene. In truth Nicholas Long was just now the creature of old
hopes and fears consequent upon his arrival — this man who once had not cared if his name were blotted out from that
district. The evening light showed wistful lines which he could not smooth away by the worldling’s gloss of nonchalance
that he had learnt to fling over his face.

The Buck’s Head was a somewhat unusual place for a man of this sort to choose as a house of sojourn in preference to
some Casterbridge inn four miles further on. Before he left home it had been a lively old tavern at which High-flyers,
and Heralds, and Tally-hoes had changed horses on their stages up and down the country; but now the house was rather
cavernous and chilly, the stable-roofs were hollow-backed, the landlord was asthmatic, and the traffic gone.

He arrived in the afternoon, and when he had sent back the fly and was having a nondescript meal, he put a question
to the waiting-maid with a mien of indifference.

‘Squire Everard, of Froom–Everard Manor, has been dead some years, I believe?’

She replied in the affirmative.

‘And are any of the family left there still?’

‘O no, bless you, sir! They sold the place years ago — Squire Everard’s son did — and went away. I’ve never heard
where they went to. They came quite to nothing.’

‘Never heard anything of the young lady — the Squire’s daughter?’

‘No. You see ’twas before I came to these parts.’

When the waitress left the room, Nicholas pushed aside his plate and gazed out of the window. He was not going over
into the Froom Valley altogether on Christine’s account, but she had greatly animated his motive in coming that way.
Anyhow he would push on there now that he was so near, and not ask questions here where he was liable to be wrongly
informed. The fundamental inquiry he had not ventured to make — whether Christine had married before the family went
away. He had abstained because of an absurd dread of extinguishing hopeful surmise. That the Everards had left their
old home was bad enough intelligence for one day.

Rising from the table he put on his hat and went out, ascending towards the upland which divided this district from
his native vale. The first familiar feature that met his eye was a little spot on the distant sky — a clump of trees
standing on a barrow which surmounted a yet more remote upland — a point where, in his childhood, he had believed
people could stand and see America. He reached the further verge of the plateau on which he had entered. Ah, there was
the valley — a greenish-grey stretch of colour — still looking placid and serene, as though it had not much missed him.
If Christine was no longer there, why should he pause over it this evening? His uncle and aunt were dead, and tomorrow
would be soon enough to inquire for remoter relatives. Thus, disinclined to go further, he turned to retrace his way to
the inn.

In the backward path he now perceived the figure of a woman, who had been walking at a distance behind him; and as
she drew nearer he began to be startled. Surely, despite the variations introduced into that figure by changing years,
its ground-lines were those of Christine?

Nicholas had been sentimental enough to write to Christine immediately on landing at Southampton a day or two before
this, addressing his letter at a venture to the old house, and merely telling her that he planned to reach the Roy–Town
inn on the present afternoon. The news of the scattering of the Everards had dissipated his hope of hearing of her; but
here she was.

So they met — there, alone, on the open down by a pond, just as if the meeting had been carefully arranged.

She threw up her veil. She was still beautiful, though the years had touched her; a little more matronly — much more
homely. Or was it only that he was much less homely now — a man of the world — the sense of homeliness being relative?
Her face had grown to be pre-eminently of the sort that would be called interesting. Her habiliments were of a demure
and sober cast, though she was one who had used to dress so airily and so gaily. Years had laid on a few shadows too in
this.

‘I received your letter,’ she said, when the momentary embarrassment of their first approach had passed. ‘And I
thought I would walk across the hills today, as it was fine. I have just called at the inn, and they told me you were
out. I was now on my way homeward.’

He hardly listened to this, though he intently gazed at her. ‘Christine,’ he said, ‘one word. Are you free?’

‘I— I am in a certain sense,’ she replied, colouring.

The announcement had a magical effect. The intervening time between past and present closed up for him, and moved by
an impulse which he had combated for fifteen years, he seized her two hands and drew her towards him.

She started back, and became almost a mere acquaintance. ‘I have to tell you,’ she gasped, ‘that I have — been
married.’

Nicholas’s rose-coloured dream was immediately toned down to a greyish tinge.

‘I did not marry till many years after you had left,’ she continued in the humble tones of one confessing to a
crime. ‘Oh Nic,’ she cried reproachfully, ‘how could you stay away so long?’

‘Whom did you marry?’

‘Mr. Bellston.’

‘I— ought to have expected it.’ He was going to add, ‘And is he dead?’ but he checked himself. Her dress
unmistakably suggested widowhood; and she had said she was free.

‘I must now hasten home,’ said she. ‘I felt that, considering my shortcomings at our parting so many years ago, I
owed you the initiative now.’

‘There is some of your old generosity in that. I’ll walk with you, if I may. Where are you living, Christine?’

‘In the same house, but not on the old conditions. I have part of it on lease; the farmer now tenanting the premises
found the whole more than he wanted, and the owner allowed me to keep what rooms I chose. I am poor now, you know,
Nicholas, and almost friendless. My brother sold the Froom–Everard estate when it came to him, and the person who
bought it turned our home into a farmhouse. Till my father’s death my husband and I lived in the manor-house with him,
so that I have never lived away from the spot.’

She was poor. That, and the change of name, sufficiently accounted for the inn-servant’s ignorance of her continued
existence within the walls of her old home.

It was growing dusk, and he still walked with her. A woman’s head arose from the declivity before them, and as she
drew nearer, Christine asked him to go back.

‘This is the wife of the farmer who shares the house,’ she said. ‘She is accustomed to come out and meet me whenever
I walk far and am benighted. I am obliged to walk everywhere now.’

The farmer’s wife, seeing that Christine was not alone, paused in her advance, and Nicholas said, ‘Dear Christine,
if you are obliged to do these things, I am not, and what wealth I can command you may command likewise. They say
rolling stones gather no moss; but they gather dross sometimes. I was one of the pioneers to the gold-fields, you know,
and made a sufficient fortune there for my wants. What is more, I kept it. When I had done this I was coming home, but
hearing of my uncle’s death I changed my plan, travelled, speculated, and increased my fortune. Now, before we part:
you remember you stood with me at the altar once, and therefore I speak with less preparation than I should otherwise
use. Before we part then I ask, shall another again intrude between us? Or shall we complete the union we began?’

She trembled — just as she had done at that very minute of standing with him in the church, to which he had recalled
her mind. ‘I will not enter into that now, dear Nicholas,’ she replied. ‘There will be more to talk of and consider
first — more to explain, which it would have spoiled this meeting to have entered into now.’

‘Yes, yes; but —’

‘Further than the brief answer I first gave, Nic, don’t press me to-night. I still have the old affection for you,
or I should not have sought you. Let that suffice for the moment.’

‘Very well, dear one. And when shall I call to see you?’

‘I will write and fix an hour. I will tell you everything of my history then.’

And thus they parted, Nicholas feeling that he had not come here fruitlessly. When she and her companion were out of
sight he retraced his steps to Roy–Town, where he made himself as comfortable as he could in the deserted old inn of
his boyhood’s days. He missed her companionship this evening more than he had done at any time during the whole fifteen
years; and it was as though instead of separation there had been constant communion with her throughout that period.
The tones of her voice had stirred his heart in a nook which had lain stagnant ever since he last heard them. They
recalled the woman to whom he had once lifted his eyes as to a goddess. Her announcement that she had been another’s
came as a little shock to him, and he did not now lift his eyes to her in precisely the same way as he had lifted them
at first. But he forgave her for marrying Bellston; what could he expect after fifteen years?

He slept at Roy–Town that night, and in the morning there was a short note from her, repeating more emphatically her
statement of the previous evening — that she wished to inform him clearly of her circumstances, and to calmly consider
with him the position in which she was placed. Would he call upon her on Sunday afternoon, when she was sure to be
alone?

‘Nic,’ she wrote on, ‘what a cosmopolite you are! I expected to find my old yeoman still; but I was quite awed in
the presence of such a citizen of the world. Did I seem rusty and unpractised? Ah — you seemed so once to me!’

Tender playful words; the old Christine was in them. She said Sunday afternoon, and it was now only Saturday
morning. He wished she had said today; that short revival of her image had vitalized to sudden heat feelings that had
almost been stilled. Whatever she might have to explain as to her position — and it was awkwardly narrowed, no doubt —
he could not give her up. Miss Everard or Mrs. Bellston, what mattered it? — she was the same Christine.

He did not go outside the inn all Saturday. He had no wish to see or do anything but to await the coming interview.
So he smoked, and read the local newspaper of the previous week, and stowed himself in the chimney-corner. In the
evening he felt that he could remain indoors no longer, and the moon being near the full, he started from the inn on
foot in the same direction as that of yesterday, with the view of contemplating the old village and its precincts, and
hovering round her house under the cloak of night.

With a stout stick in his hand he climbed over the five miles of upland in a comparatively short space of time.
Nicholas had seen many strange lands and trodden many strange ways since he last walked that path, but as he trudged he
seemed wonderfully like his old self, and had not the slightest difficulty in finding the way. In descending to the
meads the streams perplexed him a little, some of the old foot-bridges having been removed; but he ultimately got
across the larger water-courses, and pushed on to the village, avoiding her residence for the moment, lest she should
encounter him, and think he had not respected the time of her appointment.

He found his way to the churchyard, and first ascertained where lay the two relations he had left alive at his
departure; then he observed the gravestones of other inhabitants with whom he had been well acquainted, till by degrees
he seemed to be in the society of all the elder Froom–Everard population, as he had known the place. Side by side as
they had lived in his day here were they now. They had moved house in mass.

But no tomb of Mr. Bellston was visible, though, as he had lived at the manor-house, it would have been natural to
find it here. In truth Nicholas was more anxious to discover that than anything, being curious to know how long he had
been dead. Seeing from the glimmer of a light in the church that somebody was there cleaning for Sunday he entered, and
looked round upon the walls as well as he could. But there was no monument to her husband, though one had been erected
to the Squire.

Nicholas addressed the young man who was sweeping. ‘I don’t see any monument or tomb to the late Mr. Bellston?’

‘O no, sir; you won’t see that,’ said the young man drily.

‘Why, pray?’

‘Because he’s not buried here. He’s not Christian-buried anywhere, as far as we know. In short, perhaps he’s not
buried at all; and between ourselves, perhaps he’s alive.’

Nicholas sank an inch shorter. ‘Ah,’ he answered.

‘Then you don’t know the peculiar circumstances, sir?’

‘I am a stranger here — as to late years.’

‘Mr. Bellston was a traveller — an explorer — it was his calling; you may have heard his name as such?’

‘I remember.’ Nicholas recalled the fact that this very bent of Mr. Bellston’s was the incentive to his own
roaming.

‘Well, when he married he came and lived here with his wife and his wife’s father, and said he would travel no more.
But after a time he got weary of biding quiet here, and weary of her — he was not a good husband to the young lady by
any means — and he betook himself again to his old trick of roving — with her money. Away he went, quite out of the
realm of human foot, into the bowels of Asia, and never was heard of more. He was murdered, it is said, but nobody
knows; though as that was nine years ago he’s dead enough in principle, if not in corporation. His widow lives quite
humble, for between her husband and her brother she’s left in very lean pasturage.’

Nicholas went back to the Buck’s Head without hovering round her dwelling. This then was the explanation which she
had wanted to make. Not dead, but missing. How could he have expected that the first fair promise of happiness held out
to him would remain untarnished? She had said that she was free; and legally she was free, no doubt. Moreover, from her
tone and manner he felt himself justified in concluding that she would be willing to run the risk of a union with him,
in the improbability of her husband’s existence. Even if that husband lived, his return was not a likely event, to
judge from his character. A man who could spend her money on his own personal adventures would not be anxious to
disturb her poverty after such a lapse of time.

Well, the prospect was not so unclouded as it had seemed. But could he, even now, give up Christine?

Chapter VII

Two months more brought the year nearly to a close, and found Nicholas Long tenant of a spacious house in the
market-town nearest to Froom–Everard. A man of means, genial character, and a bachelor, he was an object of great
interest to his neighbours, and to his neighbours’ wives and daughters. But he took little note of this, and had made
it his business to go twice a week, no matter what the weather, to the now farmhouse at Froom–Everard, a wing of which
had been retained as the refuge of Christine. He always walked, to give no trouble in putting up a horse to a
housekeeper whose staff was limited.

The two had put their heads together on the situation, had gone to a solicitor, had balanced possibilities, and had
resolved to make the plunge of matrimony. ‘Nothing venture, nothing have,’ Christine had said, with some of her old
audacity.

With almost gratuitous honesty they had let their intentions be widely known. Christine, it is true, had rather
shrunk from publicity at first; but Nicholas argued that their boldness in this respect would have good results. With
his friends he held that there was not the slightest probability of her being other than a widow, and a challenge to
the missing man now, followed by no response, would stultify any unpleasant remarks which might be thrown at her after
their union. To this end a paragraph was inserted in the Wessex papers, announcing that their marriage was proposed to
be celebrated on such and such a day in December.

His periodic walks along the south side of the valley to visit her were among the happiest experiences of his life.
The yellow leaves falling around him in the foreground, the well-watered meads on the left hand, and the woman he loved
awaiting him at the back of the scene, promised a future of much serenity, as far as human judgment could foresee. On
arriving, he would sit with her in the ‘parlour’ of the wing she retained, her general sitting-room, where the only
relics of her early surroundings were an old clock from the other end of the house, and her own piano. Before it was
quite dark they would stand, hand in hand, looking out of the window across the flat turf to the dark clump of trees
which hid further view from their eyes.

‘Do you wish you were still mistress here, dear?’ he once said.

‘Not at all,’ said she cheerfully. ‘I have a good enough room, and a good enough fire, and a good enough friend.
Besides, my latter days as mistress of the house were not happy ones, and they spoilt the place for me. It was a
punishment for my faithlessness. Nic, you do forgive me? Really you do?’

The twenty-third of December, the eve of the wedding-day, had arrived at last in the train of such uneventful ones
as these. Nicholas had arranged to visit her that day a little later than usual, and see that everything was ready with
her for the morrow’s event and her removal to his house; for he had begun to look after her domestic affairs, and to
lighten as much as possible the duties of her housekeeping.

He was to come to an early supper, which she had arranged to take the place of a wedding-breakfast next day — the
latter not being feasible in her present situation. An hour or so after dark the wife of the farmer who lived in the
other part of the house entered Christine’s parlour to lay the cloth.

‘What with getting the ham skinned, and the black-puddings hotted up,’ she said, ‘it will take me all my time before
he’s here, if I begin this minute.’

‘I’ll lay the table myself,’ said Christine, jumping up. ‘Do you attend to the cooking.’

‘Thank you, ma’am. And perhaps ’tis no matter, seeing that it is the last night you’ll have to do such work. I knew
this sort of life wouldn’t last long for ‘ee, being born to better things.’

‘It has lasted rather long, Mrs. Wake. And if he had not found me out it would have lasted all my days.’

‘But he did find you out.’

‘He did. And I’ll lay the cloth immediately.’

Mrs. Wake went back to the kitchen, and Christine began to bustle about. She greatly enjoyed preparing this table
for Nicholas and herself with her own hands. She took artistic pleasure in adjusting each article to its position, as
if half an inch error were a point of high importance. Finally she placed the two candles where they were to stand, and
sat down by the fire.

Mrs. Wake re-entered and regarded the effect. ‘Why not have another candle or two, ma’am?’ she said. ‘‘Twould make
it livelier. Say four.’

‘Very well,’ said Christine, and four candles were lighted. ‘Really,’ she added, surveying them, ‘I have been now so
long accustomed to little economies that they look quite extravagant.’

‘Ah, you’ll soon think nothing of forty in his grand new house! Shall I bring in supper directly he comes,
ma’am?’

‘No, not for half an hour; and, Mrs. Wake, you and Betsy are busy in the kitchen, I know; so when he knocks don’t
disturb yourselves; I can let him in.’

She was again left alone, and, as it still wanted some time to Nicholas’s appointment, she stood by the fire,
looking at herself in the glass over the mantel. Reflectively raising a lock of her hair just above her temple she
uncovered a small scar. That scar had a history. The terrible temper of her late husband — those sudden moods of
irascibility which had made even his friendly excitements look like anger — had once caused him to set that mark upon
her with the bezel of a ring he wore. He declared that the whole thing was an accident. She was a woman, and kept her
own opinion.

Christine then turned her back to the glass and scanned the table and the candles, shining one at each corner like
types of the four Evangelists, and thought they looked too assuming — too confident. She glanced up at the clock, which
stood also in this room, there not being space enough for it in the passage. It was nearly seven, and she expected
Nicholas at half-past. She liked the company of this venerable article in her lonely life: its tickings and whizzings
were a sort of conversation. It now began to strike the hour. At the end something grated slightly. Then, without any
warning, the clock slowly inclined forward and fell at full length upon the floor.

The crash brought the farmer’s wife rushing into the room. Christine had well-nigh sprung out of her shoes. Mrs.
Wake’s enquiry what had happened was answered by the evidence of her own eyes.

‘How did it occur?’ she said.

‘I cannot say; it was not firmly fixed, I suppose. Dear me, how sorry I am! My dear father’s hall-clock! And now I
suppose it is ruined.’

Assisted by Mrs. Wake, she lifted the clock. Every inch of glass was, of course, shattered, but very little harm
besides appeared to be done. They propped it up temporarily, though it would not go again.

Christine had soon recovered her composure, but she saw that Mrs. Wake was gloomy. ‘What does it mean, Mrs. Wake?’
she said. ‘Is it ominous?’

‘It is a sign of a violent death in the family.’

‘Don’t talk of it. I don’t believe such things; and don’t mention it to Mr. Long when he comes. He’s not in the
family yet, you know.’

‘O no, it cannot refer to him,’ said Mrs. Wake musingly.

‘Some remote cousin, perhaps,’ observed Christine, no less willing to humour her than to get rid of a shapeless
dread which the incident had caused in her own mind. ‘And — supper is almost ready, Mrs. Wake?’

‘In three-quarters of an hour.’

Mrs. Wake left the room, and Christine sat on. Though it still wanted fifteen minutes to the hour at which Nicholas
had promised to be there, she began to grow impatient. After the accustomed ticking the dead silence was oppressive.
But she had not to wait so long as she had expected; steps were heard approaching the door, and there was a knock.

Christine was already there to open it. The entrance had no lamp, but it was not particularly dark out of doors. She
could see the outline of a man, and cried cheerfully, ‘You are early; it is very good of you.’

‘I beg pardon. It is not Mr. Bellston himself — only a messenger with his bag and great-coat. But he will be here
soon.’

The voice was not the voice of Nicholas, and the intelligence was strange. ‘I— I don’t understand. Mr. Bellston?’
she faintly replied.

‘Yes, ma’am. A gentleman — a stranger to me — gave me these things at Casterbridge station to bring on here, and
told me to say that Mr. Bellston had arrived there, and is detained for half-an-hour, but will be here in the course of
the evening.’

She sank into a chair. The porter put a small battered portmanteau on the floor, the coat on a chair, and looking
into the room at the spread table said, ‘If you are disappointed, ma’am, that your husband (as I s’pose he is) is not
come, I can assure you he’ll soon be here. He’s stopped to get a shave, to my thinking, seeing he wanted it. What he
said was that I could tell you he had heard the news in Ireland, and would have come sooner, his hand being forced; but
was hindered crossing by the weather, having took passage in a sailing vessel. What news he meant he didn’t say.’

‘Ah, yes,’ she faltered. It was plain that the man knew nothing of her intended re-marriage.

Mechanically rising and giving him a shilling, she answered to his ‘good-night,’ and he withdrew, the beat of his
footsteps lessening in the distance. She was alone; but in what a solitude.

Christine stood in the middle of the hall, just as the man had left her, in the gloomy silence of the stopped clock
within the adjoining room, till she aroused herself, and turning to the portmanteau and great-coat brought them to the
light of the candles, and examined them. The portmanteau bore painted upon it the initials ‘J. B.’ in white letters —
the well-known initials of her husband.

She examined the great-coat. In the breast-pocket was an empty spirit flask, which she firmly fancied she recognized
as the one she had filled many times for him when he was living at home with her.

She turned desultorily hither and thither, until she heard another tread without, and there came a second knocking
at the door. She did not respond to it; and Nicholas — for it was he — thinking that he was not heard by reason of a
concentration on tomorrow’s proceedings, opened the door softly, and came on to the door of her room, which stood
unclosed, just as it had been left by the Casterbridge porter.

Nicholas uttered a blithe greeting, cast his eye round the parlour, which with its tall candles, blazing fire,
snow-white cloth, and prettily-spread table, formed a cheerful spectacle enough for a man who had been walking in the
dark for an hour.

‘My bride — almost, at last!’ he cried, encircling her with his arms.

Instead of responding, her figure became limp, frigid, heavy; her head fell back, and he found that she had
fainted.

It was natural, he thought. She had had many little worrying matters to attend to, and but slight assistance. He
ought to have seen more effectually to her affairs; the closeness of the event had over-excited her. Nicholas kissed
her unconscious face — more than once, little thinking what news it was that had changed its aspect. Loth to call Mrs.
Wake, he carried Christine to a couch and laid her down. This had the effect of reviving her. Nicholas bent and
whispered in her ear, ‘Lie quiet, dearest, no hurry; and dream, dream, dream of happy days. It is only I. You will soon
be better.’ He held her by the hand.

‘No, no, no!’ she said, with a stare. ‘O, how can this be?’

Nicholas was alarmed and perplexed, but the disclosure was not long delayed. When she had sat up, and by degrees
made the stunning event known to him, he stood as if transfixed.

‘Ah — is it so?’ said he. Then, becoming quite meek, ‘And why was he so cruel as to — delay his return till
now?’

She dutifully recited the explanation her husband had given her through the messenger; but her mechanical manner of
telling it showed how much she doubted its truth. It was too unlikely that his arrival at such a dramatic moment should
not be a contrived surprise, quite of a piece with his previous dealings towards her.

‘But perhaps it may be true — and he may have become kind now — not as he used to be,’ she faltered. ‘Yes, perhaps,
Nicholas, he is an altered man — we’ll hope he is. I suppose I ought not to have listened to my legal advisers, and
assumed his death so surely! Anyhow, I am roughly received back into — the right way!’

Nicholas burst out bitterly: ‘O what too, too honest fools we were! — to so court daylight upon our intention by
putting that announcement in the papers! Why could we not have married privately, and gone away, so that he would never
have known what had become of you, even if he had returned? Christine, he has done it to . . . But I’ll say
no more. Of course we — might fly now.’

‘No, no; we might not,’ said she hastily.

‘Very well. But this is hard to bear! “When I looked for good then evil came unto me, and when I waited for light
there came darkness.” So once said a sorely tried man in the land of Uz, and so say I now! . . . I wonder if
he is almost here at this moment?’

She told him she supposed Bellston was approaching by the path across the fields, having sent on his great-coat,
which he would not want walking.

‘And is this meal laid for him, or for me?’

‘It was laid for you.’

‘And it will be eaten by him?’

‘Yes.’

‘Christine, are you sure that he is come, or have you been sleeping over the fire and dreaming it?’

She pointed anew to the portmanteau with the initials ‘J. B.,’ and to the coat beside it.

‘Well, good-bye — good-bye! Curse that parson for not marrying us fifteen years ago!’

It is unnecessary to dwell further upon that parting. There are scenes wherein the words spoken do not even
approximate to the level of the mental communion between the actors. Suffice it to say that part they did, and quickly;
and Nicholas, more dead than alive, went out of the house homewards.

Why had he ever come back? During his absence he had not cared for Christine as he cared now. If he had been younger
he might have felt tempted to descend into the meads instead of keeping along their edge. The Froom was down there, and
he knew of quiet pools in that stream to which death would come easily. But he was too old to put an end to himself for
such a reason as love; and another thought, too, kept him from seriously contemplating any desperate act. His affection
for her was strongly protective, and in the event of her requiring a friend’s support in future troubles there was none
but himself left in the world to afford it. So he walked on.

Meanwhile Christine had resigned herself to circumstances. A resolve to continue worthy of her history and of her
family lent her heroism and dignity. She called Mrs. Wake, and explained to that worthy woman as much of what had
occurred as she deemed necessary. Mrs. Wake was too amazed to reply; she retreated slowly, her lips parted; till at the
door she said with a dry mouth, ‘And the beautiful supper, ma’am?’

‘Serve it when he comes.’

‘When Mr. Bellston — yes, ma’am, I will.’ She still stood gazing, as if she could hardly take in the order.

‘That will do, Mrs. Wake. I am much obliged to you for all your kindness.’ And Christine was left alone again, and
then she wept.

She sat down and waited. That awful silence of the stopped clock began anew, but she did not mind it now. She was
listening for a footfall in a state of mental tensity which almost took away from her the power of motion. It seemed to
her that the natural interval for her husband’s journey thither must have expired; but she was not sure, and waited
on.

Mrs. Wake again came in. ‘You have not rung for supper —’

‘He is not yet come, Mrs. Wake. If you want to go to bed, bring in the supper and set it on the table. It will be
nearly as good cold. Leave the door unbarred.’

Mrs. Wake did as was suggested, made up the fire, and went away. Shortly afterwards Christine heard her retire to
her chamber. But Christine still sat on, and still her husband postponed his entry.

She aroused herself once or twice to freshen the fire, but was ignorant how the night was going. Her watch was
upstairs and she did not make the effort to go up to consult it. In her seat she continued; and still the supper
waited, and still he did not come.

At length she was so nearly persuaded that the arrival of his things must have been a dream after all, that she
again went over to them, felt them, and examined them. His they unquestionably were; and their forwarding by the porter
had been quite natural. She sighed and sat down again.

Presently she fell into a doze, and when she again became conscious she found that the four candles had burnt into
their sockets and gone out. The fire still emitted a feeble shine. Christine did not take the trouble to get more
candles, but stirred the fire and sat on.

After a long period she heard a creaking of the chamber floor and stairs at the other end of the house, and knew
that the farmer’s family were getting up. By-and-by Mrs. Wake entered the room, candle in hand, bouncing open the door
in her morning manner, obviously without any expectation of finding a person there.

‘Lord-a-mercy! What, sitting here again, ma’am?’

‘Yes, I am sitting here still.’

‘You’ve been there ever since last night?’

‘Yes.’

‘Then —’

‘He’s not come.’

‘Well, he won’t come at this time o’ morning,’ said the farmer’s wife. ‘Do ‘ee get on to bed, ma’am. You must be
shrammed to death!’

It occurred to Christine now that possibly her husband had thought better of obtruding himself upon her company
within an hour of revealing his existence to her, and had decided to pay a more formal visit next day. She therefore
adopted Mrs. Wake’s suggestion and retired.

Chapter VIII

Nicholas had gone straight home, neither speaking to nor seeing a soul. From that hour a change seemed to come over
him. He had ever possessed a full share of self-consciousness; he had been readily piqued, had shown an unusual dread
of being personally obtrusive. But now his sense of self, as an individual provoking opinion, appeared to leave him.
When, therefore, after a day or two of seclusion, he came forth again, and the few acquaintances he had formed in the
town condoled with him on what had happened, and pitied his haggard looks, he did not shrink from their regard as he
would have done formerly, but took their sympathy as it would have been accepted by a child.

It reached his ears that Bellston had not appeared on the evening of his arrival at any hotel in the town or
neighbourhood, or entered his wife’s house at all. ‘That’s a part of his cruelty,’ thought Nicholas. And when two or
three days had passed, and still no account came to him of Bellston having joined her, he ventured to set out for
Froom–Everard.

Christine was so shaken that she was obliged to receive him as she lay on a sofa, beside the square table which was
to have borne their evening feast. She fixed her eyes wistfully upon him, and smiled a sad smile.

‘He has not come?’ said Nicholas under his breath.

‘He has not.’

Then Nicholas sat beside her, and they talked on general topics merely like saddened old friends. But they could not
keep away the subject of Bellston, their voices dropping as it forced its way in. Christine, no less than Nicholas,
knowing her husband’s character, inferred that, having stopped her game, as he would have phrased it, he was taking
things leisurely, and, finding nothing very attractive in her limited mode of living, was meaning to return to her only
when he had nothing better to do.

The bolt which laid low their hopes had struck so recently that they could hardly look each other in the face when
speaking that day. But when a week or two had passed, and all the horizon still remained as vacant of Bellston as
before, Nicholas and she could talk of the event with calm wonderment. Why had he come, to go again like this?

And then there set in a period of resigned surmise, during which

So like, so very like, was day to day,

that to tell of one of them is to tell of all. Nicholas would arrive between three and four in the afternoon, a
faint trepidation influencing his walk as he neared her door. He would knock; she would always reply in person, having
watched for him from the window. Then he would whisper —‘He has not come?’

‘He has not,’ she would say.

Nicholas would enter then, and she being ready bonneted, they would walk into the Sallows together as far as to the
spot which they had frequently made their place of appointment in their youthful days. A plank bridge, which Bellston
had caused to be thrown over the stream during his residence with her in the manor-house, was now again removed, and
all was just the same as in Nicholas’s time, when he had been accustomed to wade across on the edge of the cascade and
come up to her like a merman from the deep. Here on the felled trunk, which still lay rotting in its old place, they
would now sit, gazing at the descending sheet of water, with its never-ending sarcastic hiss at their baffled attempts
to make themselves one flesh. Returning to the house they would sit down together to tea, after which, and the
confidential chat that accompanied it, he walked home by the declining light. This proceeding became as periodic as an
astronomical recurrence. Twice a week he came — all through that winter, all through the spring following, through the
summer, through the autumn, the next winter, the next year, and the next, till an appreciable span of human life had
passed by. Bellston still tarried.

Years and years Nic walked that way, at this interval of three days, from his house in the neighbouring town; and in
every instance the aforesaid order of things was customary; and still on his arrival the form of words went on —‘He has
not come?’

‘He has not.’

So they grew older. The dim shape of that third one stood continually between them; they could not displace it;
neither, on the other hand, could it effectually part them. They were in close communion, yet not indissolubly united;
lovers, yet never growing cured of love. By the time that the fifth year of Nic’s visiting had arrived, on about the
five-hundredth occasion of his presence at her tea-table, he noticed that the bleaching process which had begun upon
his own locks was also spreading to hers. He told her so, and they laughed. Yet she was in good health: a condition of
suspense, which would have half-killed a man, had been endured by her without complaint, and even with composure.

One day, when these years of abeyance had numbered seven, they had strolled as usual as far as the waterfall, whose
faint roar formed a sort of calling voice sufficient in the circumstances to direct their listlessness. Pausing there,
he looked up at her face and said, ‘Why should we not try again, Christine? We are legally at liberty to do so now.
Nothing venture nothing have.’

But she would not. Perhaps a little primness of idea was by this time ousting the native daring of Christine. ‘What
he has done once he can do twice,’ she said. ‘He is not dead, and if we were to marry he would say we had “forced his
hand,” as he said before, and duly reappear.’

Some years after, when Christine was about fifty, and Nicholas fifty-three, a new trouble of a minor kind arrived.
He found an inconvenience in traversing the distance between their two houses, particularly in damp weather, the years
he had spent in trying climates abroad having sown the seeds of rheumatism, which made a journey undesirable on
inclement days, even in a carriage. He told her of this new difficulty, as he did of everything.

‘If you could live nearer,’ suggested she.

Unluckily there was no house near. But Nicholas, though not a millionaire, was a man of means; he obtained a small
piece of ground on lease at the nearest spot to her home that it could be so obtained, which was on the opposite brink
of the Froom, this river forming the boundary of the Froom–Everard manor; and here he built a cottage large enough for
his wants. This took time, and when he got into it he found its situation a great comfort to him. He was not more than
five hundred yards from her now, and gained a new pleasure in feeling that all sounds which greeted his ears, in the
day or in the night, also fell upon hers — the caw of a particular rook, the voice of a neighbouring nightingale, the
whistle of a local breeze, or the purl of the fall in the meadows, whose rush was a material rendering of Time’s
ceaseless scour over themselves, wearing them away without uniting them.

Christine’s missing husband was taking shape as a myth among the surrounding residents; but he was still believed in
as corporeally imminent by Christine herself, and also, in a milder degree, by Nicholas. For a curious unconsciousness
of the long lapse of time since his revelation of himself seemed to affect the pair. There had been no passing events
to serve as chronological milestones, and the evening on which she had kept supper waiting for him still loomed out
with startling nearness in their retrospects.

In the seventeenth pensive year of this their parallel march towards the common bourne, a labourer came in a hurry
one day to Nicholas’s house and brought strange tidings. The present owner of Froom–Everard — a non-resident — had been
improving his property in sundry ways, and one of these was by dredging the stream which, in the course of years, had
become choked with mud and weeds in its passage through the Sallows. The process necessitated a reconstruction of the
waterfall. When the river had been pumped dry for this purpose, the skeleton of a man had been found jammed among the
piles supporting the edge of the fall. Every particle of his flesh and clothing had been eaten by fishes or abraded to
nothing by the water, but the relics of a gold watch remained, and on the inside of the case was engraved the name of
the maker of her husband’s watch, which she well remembered.

Nicholas, deeply agitated, hastened down to the place and examined the remains attentively, afterwards going across
to Christine, and breaking the discovery to her. She would not come to view the skeleton, which lay extended on the
grass, not a finger or toe-bone missing, so neatly had the aquatic operators done their work. Conjecture was directed
to the question how Bellston had got there; and conjecture alone could give an explanation.

It was supposed that, on his way to call upon her, he had taken a short cut through the grounds, with which he was
naturally very familiar, and coming to the fall under the trees had expected to find there the plank which, during his
occupancy of the premises with Christine and her father, he had placed there for crossing into the meads on the other
side instead of wading across as Nicholas had done. Before discovering its removal he had probably overbalanced
himself, and was thus precipitated into the cascade, the piles beneath the descending current wedging him between them
like the prongs of a pitchfork, and effectually preventing the rising of his body, over which the weeds grew. Such was
the reasonable supposition concerning the discovery; but proof was never forthcoming.

‘To think,’ said Nicholas, when the remains had been decently interred, and he was again sitting with Christine —
though not beside the waterfall —‘to think how we visited him! How we sat over him, hours and hours, gazing at him,
bewailing our fate, when all the time he was ironically hissing at us from the spot, in an unknown tongue, that we
could marry if we chose!’

She echoed the sentiment with a sigh.

‘I have strange fancies,’ she said. ‘I suppose it must have been my husband who came back, and not some other
man.’

Nicholas felt that there was little doubt. ‘Besides — the skeleton,’ he said.

‘Yes . . . If it could not have been another person’s — but no, of course it was he.’

‘You might have married me on the day we had fixed, and there would have been no impediment. You would now have been
seventeen years my wife, and we might have had tall sons and daughters.’

‘It might have been so,’ she murmured.

‘Well — is it still better late than never?’

The question was one which had become complicated by the increasing years of each. Their wills were somewhat
enfeebled now, their hearts sickened of tender enterprise by hope too long deferred. Having postponed the consideration
of their course till a year after the interment of Bellston, each seemed less disposed than formerly to take it up
again.

‘Is it worth while, after so many years?’ she said to him. ‘We are fairly happy as we are — perhaps happier than we
should be in any other relation, seeing what old people we have grown. The weight is gone from our lives; the shadow no
longer divides us: then let us be joyful together as we are, dearest Nic, in the days of our vanity; and

With mirth and laughter let old wrinkles come.’

He fell in with these views of hers to some extent. But occasionally he ventured to urge her to reconsider the case,
though he spoke not with the fervour of his earlier years.

Chapter I. — She Misses Her Sister

July 7. — I wander about the house in a mood of unutterable sadness, for my dear sister Caroline has left home today
with my mother, and I shall not see them again for several weeks. They have accepted a long-standing invitation to
visit some old friends of ours, the Marlets, who live at Versailles for cheapness — my mother thinking that it will be
for the good of Caroline to see a little of France and Paris. But I don’t quite like her going. I fear she may lose
some of that childlike simplicity and gentleness which so characterize her, and have been nourished by the seclusion of
our life here. Her solicitude about her pony before starting was quite touching, and she made me promise to visit it
daily, and see that it came to no harm.

Caroline gone abroad, and I left here! It is the reverse of an ordinary situation, for good or ill-luck has mostly
ordained that I should be the absent one. Mother will be quite tired out by the young enthusiasm of Caroline. She will
demand to be taken everywhere — to Paris continually, of course; to all the stock shrines of history’s devotees; to
palaces and prisons; to kings’ tombs and queens’ tombs; to cemeteries and picture-galleries, and royal hunting forests.
My poor mother, having gone over most of this ground many times before, will perhaps not find the perambulation so
exhilarating as will Caroline herself. I wish I could have gone with them. I would not have minded having my legs
walked off to please Caroline. But this regret is absurd: I could not, of course, leave my father with not a soul in
the house to attend to the calls of the parishioners or to pour out his tea.

July 15. — A letter from Caroline today. It is very strange that she tells me nothing which I expected her to tell —
only trivial details. She seems dazzled by the brilliancy of Paris — which no doubt appears still more brilliant to her
from the fact of her only being able to obtain occasional glimpses of it. She would see that Paris, too, has a seamy
side if you live there. I was not aware that the Marlets knew so many people. If, as mother has said, they went to
reside at Versailles for reasons of economy, they will not effect much in that direction while they make a practice of
entertaining all the acquaintances who happen to be in their neighbourhood. They do not confine their hospitalities to
English people, either. I wonder who this M. de la Feste is, in whom Caroline says my mother is so much interested.

July 18. — Another letter from Caroline. I have learnt from this epistle, that M. Charles de la Feste is ‘only one
of the many friends of the Marlets’; that though a Frenchman by birth, and now again temporarily at Versailles, he has
lived in England many many years; that he is a talented landscape and marine painter, and has exhibited at the Salon,
and I think in London. His style and subjects are considered somewhat peculiar in Paris — rather English than
Continental. I have not as yet learnt his age, or his condition, married or single. From the tone and nature of her
remarks about him he sometimes seems to be a middle-aged family man, sometimes quite the reverse. From his nomadic
habits I should say the latter is the most likely. He has travelled and seen a great deal, she tells me, and knows more
about English literature than she knows herself.

July 21. — Letter from Caroline. Query: Is ‘a friend of ours and the Marlets,’ of whom she now anonymously and
mysteriously speaks, the same personage as the ‘M. de la Feste’ of her former letters? He must be the same, I think,
from his pursuits. If so, whence this sudden change of tone? . . . I have been lost in thought for at least a
quarter of an hour since writing the preceding sentence. Suppose my dear sister is falling in love with this young man
— there is no longer any doubt about his age; what a very awkward, risky thing for her! I do hope that my mother has an
eye on these proceedings. But, then, poor mother never sees the drift of anything: she is in truth less of a mother to
Caroline than I am. If I were there, how jealously I would watch him, and ascertain his designs!

I am of a stronger nature than Caroline. How I have supported her in the past through her little troubles and great
griefs! Is she agitated at the presence of this, to her, new and strange feeling? But I am assuming her to be
desperately in love, when I have no proof of anything of the kind. He may be merely a casual friend, of whom I shall
hear no more.

July 24. — Then he is a bachelor, as I suspected. ‘If M. de la Feste ever marries he will,’ etc. So she writes. They
are getting into close quarters, obviously. Also, ‘Something to keep my hair smooth, which M. de la Feste told me he
had found useful for the tips of his moustache.’ Very naively related this; and with how much unconsciousness of the
intimacy between them that the remark reveals! But my mother — what can she be doing? Does she know of this? And if so,
why does she not allude to it in her letters to my father? . . . I have been to look at Caroline’s pony, in
obedience to her reiterated request that I would not miss a day in seeing that she was well cared for. Anxious as
Caroline was about this pony of hers before starting, she now never mentioned the poor animal once in her letters. The
image of her pet suffers from displacement.

August 3. — Caroline’s forgetfulness of her pony has naturally enough extended to me, her sister. It is ten days
since she last wrote, and but for a note from my mother I should not know if she were dead or alive.

Chapter II. — News Interesting and Serious

August 5. — A cloud of letters. A letter from Caroline, another from mother; also one from each to my father.

The probability to which all the intelligence from my sister has pointed of late turns out to be a fact. There is an
engagement, or almost an engagement, announced between my dear Caroline and M. de la Feste — to Caroline’s sublime
happiness, and my mother’s entire satisfaction; as well as to that of the Marlets. They and my mother seem to know all
about the young man — which is more than I do, though a little extended information about him, considering that I am
Caroline’s elder sister, would not have been amiss. I half feel with my father, who is much surprised, and, I am sure,
not altogether satisfied, that he should not have been consulted at all before matters reached such a definite stage,
though he is too amiable to say so openly. I don’t quite say that a good thing should have been hindered for the sake
of our opinion, if it is a good thing; but the announcement comes very suddenly. It must have been foreseen by my
mother for some time that this upshot was probable, and Caroline might have told me more distinctly that M. de la Feste
was her lover, instead of alluding so mysteriously to him as only a friend of the Marlets, and lately dropping his name
altogether. My father, without exactly objecting to him as a Frenchman, ‘wishes he were of English or some other
reasonable nationality for one’s son-inlaw,’ but I tell him that the demarcations of races, kingdoms, and creeds, are
wearing down every day, that patriotism is a sort of vice, and that the character of the individual is all we need
think about in this case. I wonder if, in the event of their marriage, he will continue to live at Versailles, or if he
will come to England.

August 7. — A supplemental letter from Caroline, answering, by anticipation, some of the aforesaid queries. She
tells me that ‘Charles,’ though he makes Versailles his present home, is by no means bound by his profession to
continue there; that he will live just where she wishes, provided it be not too far from some centre of thought, art,
and civilization. My mother and herself both think that the marriage should not take place till next year. He exhibits
landscapes and canal scenery every year, she says; so I suppose he is popular, and that his income is sufficient to
keep them in comfort. If not, I do not see why my father could not settle something more on them than he had intended,
and diminish by a little what he had proposed for me, whilst it was imagined that I should be the first to stand in
need of such.

‘Of engaging manner, attractive appearance, and virtuous character,’ is the reply I receive from her in answer to my
request for a personal description. That is vague enough, and I would rather have had one definite fact of complexion,
voice, deed, or opinion. But of course she has no eye now for material qualities; she cannot see him as he is. She sees
him irradiated with glories such as never appertained and never will appertain to any man, foreign, English, or
Colonial. To think that Caroline, two years my junior, and so childlike as to be five years my junior in nature, should
be engaged to be married before me. But that is what happens in families more often than we are apt to remember.

August 16. — Interesting news today. Charles, she says, has pleaded that their marriage may just as well be this
year as next; and he seems to have nearly converted my mother to the same way of thinking. I do not myself see any
reason for delay, beyond the standing one of my father having as yet had no opportunity of forming an opinion upon the
man, the time, or anything. However, he takes his lot very quietly, and they are coming home to talk the question over
with us; Caroline having decided not to make any positive arrangements for this change of state till she has seen me.
Subject to my own and my father’s approval, she says, they are inclined to settle the date of the wedding for November,
three months from the present time, that it shall take place here in the village, that I, of course, shall be
bridesmaid, and many other particulars. She draws an artless picture of the probable effect upon the minds of the
villagers of this romantic performance in the chancel of our old church, in which she is to be chief actor — the
foreign gentleman dropping down like a god from the skies, picking her up, and triumphantly carrying her off. Her only
grief will be separation from me, but this is to be assuaged by my going and staying with her for long months at a
time. This simple prattle is very sweet to me, my dear sister, but I cannot help feeling sad at the occasion of it. In
the nature of things it is obvious that I shall never be to you again what I hitherto have been: your guide,
counsellor, and most familiar friend.

M. de la Feste does certainly seem to be all that one could desire as protector to a sensitive fragile child like
Caroline, and for that I am thankful. Still, I must remember that I see him as yet only through her eyes. For her sake
I am intensely anxious to meet him, and scrutinise him through and through, and learn what the man is really made of
who is to have such a treasure in his keeping. The engagement has certainly been formed a little precipitately; I quite
agree with my father in that: still, good and happy marriages have been made in a hurry before now, and mother seems
well satisfied.

August 20. — A terrible announcement came this morning; and we are in deep trouble. I have been quite unable to
steady my thoughts on anything today till now — half-past eleven at night — and I only attempt writing these notes
because I am too restless to remain idle, and there is nothing but waiting and waiting left for me to do. Mother has
been taken dangerously ill at Versailles: they were within a day or two of starting; but all thought of leaving must
now be postponed, for she cannot possibly be moved in her present state. I don’t like the sound of haemorrhage at all
in a woman of her full habit, and Caroline and the Marlets have not exaggerated their accounts I am certain. On the
receipt of the letter my father instantly decided to go to her, and I have been occupied all day in getting him off,
for as he calculates on being absent several days, there have been many matters for him to arrange before setting out —
the chief being to find some one who will do duty for him next Sunday — a quest of no small difficulty at such short
notice; but at last poor old feeble Mr. Dugdale has agreed to attempt it, with Mr. Highman, the Scripture reader, to
assist him in the lessons.

I fain would have gone with my father to escape the irksome anxiety of awaiting her; but somebody had to stay, and I
could best be spared. George has driven him to the station to meet the last train by which he will catch the midnight
boat, and reach Havre some time in the morning. He hates the sea, and a night passage in particular. I hope he will get
there without mishap of any kind; but I feel anxious for him, stay-at-home as he is, and unable to cope with any
difficulty. Such an errand, too; the journey will be sad enough at best. I almost think I ought to have been the one to
go to her.

August 21. — I nearly fell asleep of heaviness of spirit last night over my writing. My father must have reached
Paris by this time; and now here comes a letter . . .

Later. — The letter was to express an earnest hope that my father had set out. My poor mother is sinking, they fear.
What will become of Caroline? O, how I wish I could see mother; why could not both have gone?

Later. — I get up from my chair, and walk from window to window, and then come and write a line. I cannot even
divine how poor Caroline’s marriage is to be carried out if mother dies. I pray that father may have got there in time
to talk to her and receive some directions from her about Caroline and M. de la Feste — a man whom neither my father
nor I have seen. I, who might be useful in this emergency, am doomed to stay here, waiting in suspense.

August 23. — A letter from my father containing the sad news that my mother’s spirit has flown. Poor little Caroline
is heart-broken — she was always more my mother’s pet than I was. It is some comfort to know that my father arrived in
time to hear from her own lips her strongly expressed wish that Caroline’s marriage should be solemnized as soon as
possible. M. de la Feste seems to have been a great favourite of my dear mother’s; and I suppose it now becomes almost
a sacred duty of my father to accept him as a son-inlaw without criticism.

Chapter III. — Her Gloom Lightens a Little

September 10. — I have inserted nothing in my diary for more than a fortnight. Events have been altogether too sad
for me to have the spirit to put them on paper. And yet there comes a time when the act of recording one’s trouble is
recognized as a welcome method of dwelling upon it . . .

My dear mother has been brought home and buried here in the parish. It was not so much her own wish that this should
be done as my father’s, who particularly desired that she should lie in the family vault beside his first wife. I saw
them side by side before the vault was closed — two women beloved by one man. As I stood, and Caroline by my side, I
fell into a sort of dream, and had an odd fancy that Caroline and I might be also beloved of one, and lie like these
together — an impossibility, of course, being sisters. When I awoke from my reverie Caroline took my hand and said it
was time to leave.

September 14. — The wedding is indefinitely postponed. Caroline is like a girl awakening in the middle of a
somnambulistic experience, and does not realize where she is, or how she stands. She walks about silently, and I cannot
tell her thoughts, as I used to do. It was her own doing to write to M. de la Feste and tell him that the wedding could
not possibly take place this autumn as originally planned. There is something depressing in this long postponement if
she is to marry him at all; and yet I do not see how it could be avoided.

October 20. — I have had so much to occupy me in consoling Caroline that I have been continually overlooking my
diary. Her life was much nearer to my mother’s than mine was. She has never, as I, lived away from home long enough to
become self-dependent, and hence in her first loss, and all that it involved, she drooped like a rain-beaten lily. But
she is of a nature whose wounds soon heal, even though they may be deep, and the supreme poignancy of her sorrow has
already passed.

My father is of opinion that the wedding should not be delayed too long. While at Versailles he made the
acquaintance of M. de la Feste, and though they had but a short and hurried communion with each other, he was much
impressed by M. de la Feste’s disposition and conduct, and is strongly in favour of his suit. It is odd that Caroline’s
betrothed should influence in his favour all who come near him. His portrait, which dear Caroline has shown me,
exhibits him to be of a physique that partly accounts for this: but there must be something more than mere appearance,
and it is probably some sort of glamour or fascinating power — the quality which prevented Caroline from describing him
to me with any accuracy of detail. At the same time, I see from the photograph that his face and head are remarkably
well formed; and though the contours of his mouth are hidden by his moustache, his arched brows show well the romantic
disposition of a true lover and painter of Nature. I think that the owner of such a face as this must be tender and
sympathetic and true.

October 30. — As my sister’s grief for her mother becomes more and more calmed, her love for M. de la Feste begins
to reassume its former absorbing command of her. She thinks of him incessantly, and writes whole treatises to him by
way of letters. Her blank disappointment at his announcement of his inability to pay us a visit quite so soon as he had
promised, was quite tragic. I, too, am disappointed, for I wanted to see and estimate him. But having arranged to go to
Holland to seize some aerial effects for his pictures, which are only to be obtained at this time of the autumn, he is
obliged to postpone his journey this way, which is now to be made early in the new year. I think myself that he ought
to have come at all sacrifices, considering Caroline’s recent loss, the sad postponement of what she was looking
forward to, and her single-minded affection for him. Still, who knows; his professional success is important. Moreover,
she is cheerful, and hopeful, and the delay will soon be overpast.

Chapter IV. — She Beholds the Attractive Stranger

February 16. — We have had such a dull life here all the winter that I have found nothing important enough to set
down, and broke off my journal accordingly. I resume it now to make an entry on the subject of dear Caroline’s future.
It seems that she was too grieved, immediately after the loss of our mother, to answer definitely the question of M. de
la Feste how long the postponement was to be; then, afterwards, it was agreed that the matter should be discussed on
his autumn visit; but as he did not come, it has remained in abeyance till this week, when Caroline, with the greatest
simplicity and confidence, has written to him without any further pressure on his part, and told him that she is quite
ready to fix the time, and will do so as soon as he arrives to see her. She is a little frightened now, lest it should
seem forward in her to have revived the subject of her own accord; but she may assume that his question has been
waiting on for an answer ever since, and that she has, therefore, acted only within her promise. In truth, the secret
at the bottom of it all is that she is somewhat saddened because he has not latterly reminded her of the pause in their
affairs — that, in short, his original impatience to possess her is not now found to animate him so obviously. I
suppose that he loves her as much as ever; indeed, I am sure he must do so, seeing how lovable she is. It is mostly
thus with all men when women are out of their sight; they grow negligent. Caroline must have patience, and remember
that a man of his genius has many and important calls upon his time. In justice to her I must add that she does
remember it fairly well, and has as much patience as any girl ever had in the circumstances. He hopes to come at the
beginning of April at latest. Well, when he comes we shall see him.

April 5. — I think that what M. de la Feste writes is reasonable enough, though Caroline looks heart-sick about it.
It is hardly worth while for him to cross all the way to England and back just now, while the sea is so turbulent,
seeing that he will be obliged, in any event, to come in May, when he has to be in London for professional purposes, at
which time he can take us easily on his way both coming and going. When Caroline becomes his wife she will be more
practical, no doubt; but she is such a child as yet that there is no contenting her with reasons. However, the time
will pass quickly, there being so much to do in preparing a trousseau for her, which must now be put in hand in order
that we may have plenty of leisure to get it ready. On no account must Caroline be married in half-mourning; I am sure
that mother, could she know, would not wish it, and it is odd that Caroline should be so intractably persistent on this
point, when she is usually so yielding.

April 30. — This month has flown on swallow’s wings. We are in a great state of excitement — I as much as she — I
cannot quite tell why. He is really coming in ten days, he says.

May 9. Four p.m. — I am so agitated I can scarcely write, and yet am particularly impelled to do so before leaving
my room. It is the unexpected shape of an expected event which has caused my absurd excitement, which proves me almost
as much a school-girl as Caroline.

M. de la Feste was not, as we understood, to have come till tomorrow; but he is here — just arrived. All household
directions have devolved upon me, for my father, not thinking M. de la Feste would appear before us for another
four-and-twenty hours, left home before post time to attend a distant consecration; and hence Caroline and I were in no
small excitement when Charles’s letter was opened, and we read that he had been unexpectedly favoured in the dispatch
of his studio work, and would follow his letter in a few hours. We sent the covered carriage to meet the train
indicated, and waited like two newly strung harps for the first sound of the returning wheels. At last we heard them on
the gravel; and the question arose who was to receive him. It was, strictly speaking, my duty; but I felt timid; I
could not help shirking it, and insisted that Caroline should go down. She did not, however, go near the door as she
usually does when anybody is expected, but waited palpitating in the drawing-room. He little thought when he saw the
silent hall, and the apparently deserted house, how that house was at the very same moment alive and throbbing with
interest under the surface. I stood at the back of the upper landing, where nobody could see me from downstairs, and
heard him walk across the hall — a lighter step than my father’s — and heard him then go into the drawing-room, and the
servant shut the door behind him and go away.

What a pretty lover’s meeting they must have had in there all to themselves! Caroline’s sweet face looking up from
her black gown — how it must have touched him. I know she wept very much, for I heard her; and her eyes will be red
afterwards, and no wonder, poor dear, though she is no doubt happy. I can imagine what she is telling him while I write
this — her fears lest anything should have happened to prevent his coming after all — gentle, smiling reproaches for
his long delay; and things of that sort. His two portmanteaus are at this moment crossing the landing on the way to his
room. I wonder if I ought to go down.

A little later. — I have seen him! It was not at all in the way that I intended to encounter him, and I am vexed.
Just after his portmanteaus were brought up I went out from my room to descend, when, at the moment of stepping towards
the first stair, my eyes were caught by an object in the hall below, and I paused for an instant, till I saw that it
was a bundle of canvas and sticks, composing a sketching tent and easel. At the same nick of time the drawing-room door
opened and the affianced pair came out. They were saying they would go into the garden; and he waited a moment while
she put on her hat. My idea was to let them pass on without seeing me, since they seemed not to want my company, but I
had got too far on the landing to retreat; he looked up, and stood staring at me — engrossed to a dream-like fixity.
Thereupon I, too, instead of advancing as I ought to have done, stood moonstruck and awkward, and before I could gather
my weak senses sufficiently to descend, she had called him, and they went out by the garden door together. I then
thought of following them, but have changed my mind, and come here to jot down these few lines. It is all I am fit for
. . .

He is even more handsome than I expected. I was right in feeling he must have an attraction beyond that of form: it
appeared even in that momentary glance. How happy Caroline ought to be. But I must, of course, go down to be ready with
tea in the drawing-room by the time they come indoors.

11 p.m. — I have made the acquaintance of M. de la Feste; and I seem to be another woman from the effect of it. I
cannot describe why this should be so, but conversation with him seems to expand the view, and open the heart, and
raise one as upon stilts to wider prospects. He has a good intellectual forehead, perfect eyebrows, dark hair and eyes,
an animated manner, and a persuasive voice. His voice is soft in quality — too soft for a man, perhaps; and yet on
second thoughts I would not have it less so. We have been talking of his art: I had no notion that art demanded such
sacrifices or such tender devotion; or that there were two roads for choice within its precincts, the road of vulgar
money-making, and the road of high aims and consequent inappreciation for many long years by the public. That he has
adopted the latter need not be said to those who understand him. It is a blessing for Caroline that she has been chosen
by such a man, and she ought not to lament at postponements and delays, since they have arisen unavoidably. Whether he
finds hers a sufficiently rich nature, intellectually and emotionally, for his own, I know not, but he seems
occasionally to be disappointed at her simple views of things. Does he really feel such love for her at this moment as
he no doubt believes himself to be feeling, and as he no doubt hopes to feel for the remainder of his life towards
her?

It was a curious thing he told me when we were left for a few minutes alone; that Caroline had alluded so slightly
to me in her conversation and letters that he had not realized my presence in the house here at all. But, of course, it
was only natural that she should write and talk most about herself. I suppose it was on account of the fact of his
being taken in some measure unawares, that I caught him on two or three occasions regarding me fixedly in a way that
disquieted me somewhat, having been lately in so little society; till my glance aroused him from his reverie, and he
looked elsewhere in some confusion. It was fortunate that he did so, and thus failed to notice my own. It shows that
he, too, is not particularly a society person.

May 10. — Have had another interesting conversation with M. de la Feste on schools of landscape painting in the
drawing-room after dinner this evening — my father having fallen asleep, and left nobody but Caroline and myself for
Charles to talk to. I did not mean to say so much to him, and had taken a volume of Modern Painters from the bookcase
to occupy myself with, while leaving the two lovers to themselves; but he would include me in his audience, and I was
obliged to lay the book aside. However, I insisted on keeping Caroline in the conversation, though her views on
pictorial art were only too charmingly crude and primitive.

To-morrow, if fine, we are all three going to Wherryborne Wood, where Charles will give us practical illustrations
of the principles of coloring that he has enumerated to-night. I am determined not to occupy his attention to the
exclusion of Caroline, and my plan is that when we are in the dense part of the wood I will lag behind, and slip away,
and leave them to return by themselves. I suppose the reason of his attentiveness to me lies in his simply wishing to
win the good opinion of one who is so closely united to Caroline, and so likely to influence her good opinion of
him.

May 11. Late. — I cannot sleep, and in desperation have lit my candle and taken up my pen. My restlessness is
occasioned by what has occurred today, which at first I did not mean to write down, or trust to any heart but my own.
We went to Wherryborne Wood — Caroline, Charles and I, as we had intended — and walked all three along the green track
through the midst, Charles in the middle between Caroline and myself. Presently I found that, as usual, he and I were
the only talkers, Caroline amusing herself by observing birds and squirrels as she walked docilely alongside her
betrothed. Having noticed this I dropped behind at the first opportunity and slipped among the trees, in a direction in
which I knew I should find another path that would take me home. Upon this track I by and by emerged, and walked along
it in silent thought till, at a bend, I suddenly encountered M. de la Feste standing stock still and smiling
thoughtfully at me.

‘Where is Caroline?’ said I.

‘Only a little way off,’ says he. ‘When we missed you from behind us we thought you might have mistaken the
direction we had followed, so she has gone one way to find you and I have come this way.’

We then went back to find Caroline, but could not discover her anywhere, and the upshot was that he and I were
wandering about the woods alone for more than an hour. On reaching home we found she had given us up after searching a
little while, and arrived there some time before. I should not be so disturbed by the incident if I had not perceived
that, during her absence from us, he did not make any earnest effort to rediscover her; and in answer to my repeated
expressions of wonder as to whither she could have wandered he only said, ‘Oh, she’s quite safe; she told me she knew
the way home from any part of this wood. Let us go on with our talk. I assure you I value this privilege of being with
one I so much admire more than you imagine;’ and other things of that kind. I was so foolish as to show a little
perturbation — I cannot tell why I did not control myself; and I think he noticed that I was not cool. Caroline has,
with her simple good faith, thought nothing of the occurrence; yet altogether I am not satisfied.

Chapter V. — Her Situation is a Trying One

May 15. — The more I think of it day after day, the more convinced I am that my suspicions are true. He is too
interested in me — well, in plain words, loves me; or, not to degrade that phrase, has a wild passion for me; and his
affection for Caroline is that towards a sister only. That is the distressing truth; how it has come about I cannot
tell, and it wears upon me.

A hundred little circumstances have revealed this to me, and the longer I dwell upon it the more agitating does the
consideration become. Heaven only can help me out of the terrible difficulty in which this places me. I have done
nothing to encourage him to be faithless to her. I have studiously kept out of his way; have persistently refused to be
a third in their interviews. Yet all to no purpose. Some fatality has seemed to rule, ever since he came to the house,
that this disastrous inversion of things should arise. If I had only foreseen the possibility of it before he arrived,
how gladly would I have departed on some visit or other to the meanest friend to hinder such an apparent treachery. But
I blindly welcomed him — indeed, made myself particularly agreeable to him for her sake.

There is no possibility of my suspicions being wrong; not until they have reached absolute certainty have I dared
even to admit the truth to myself. His conduct today would have proved them true had I entertained no previous
apprehensions. Some photographs of myself came for me by post, and they were handed round at the breakfast table and
criticised. I put them temporarily on a side table, and did not remember them until an hour afterwards when I was in my
own room. On going to fetch them I discovered him standing at the table with his back towards the door bending over the
photographs, one of which he raised to his lips.

The witnessing this act so frightened me that I crept away to escape observation. It was the climax to a series of
slight and significant actions all tending to the same conclusion. The question for me now is, what am I to do? To go
away is what first occurs to me, but what reason can I give Caroline and my father for such a step; besides, it might
precipitate some sort of catastrophe by driving Charles to desperation. For the present, therefore, I have decided that
I can only wait, though his contiguity is strangely disturbing to me now, and I hardly retain strength of mind to
encounter him. How will the distressing complication end?

May 19. — And so it has come! My mere avoidance of him has precipitated the worst issue — a declaration. I had
occasion to go into the kitchen garden to gather some of the double ragged-robins which grew in a corner there. Almost
as soon as I had entered I heard footsteps without. The door opened and shut, and I turned to behold him just inside
it. As the garden is closed by four walls and the gardener was absent, the spot ensured absolute privacy. He came along
the path by the asparagus-bed, and overtook me.

‘You know why I come, Alicia?’ said he, in a tremulous voice.

I said nothing, and hung my head, for by his tone I did know.

‘Yes,’ he went on, ‘it is you I love; my sentiment towards your sister is one of affection too, but protective,
tutelary affection — no more. Say what you will I cannot help it. I mistook my feeling for her, and I know how much I
am to blame for my want of self-knowledge. I have fought against this discovery night and day; but it cannot be
concealed. Why did I ever see you, since I could not see you till I had committed myself? At the moment my eyes beheld
you on that day of my arrival, I said, “This is the woman for whom my manhood has waited.” Ever since an unaccountable
fascination has riveted my heart to you. Answer one word!’

‘O, M. de la Feste!’ I burst out. What I said more I cannot remember, but I suppose that the misery I was in showed
pretty plainly, for he said, ‘Something must be done to let her know; perhaps I have mistaken her affection, too; but
all depends upon what you feel.’

‘I cannot tell what I feel,’ said I, ‘except that this seems terrible treachery; and every moment that I stay with
you here makes it worse! . . . Try to keep faith with her — her young heart is tender; believe me there is no
mistake in the quality of her love for you. Would there were! This would kill her if she knew it!’

He sighed heavily. ‘She ought never to be my wife,’ he said. ‘Leaving my own happiness out of the question, it would
be a cruelty to her to unite her to me.’

I said I could not hear such words from him, and begged him in tears to go away; he obeyed, and I heard the garden
door shut behind him. What is to be the end of the announcement, and the fate of Caroline?

May 20. — I put a good deal on paper yesterday, and yet not all. I was, in truth, hoping against hope, against
conviction, against too conscious self-judgment. I scarcely dare own the truth now, yet it relieves my aching heart to
set it down. Yes, I love him — that is the dreadful fact, and I can no longer parry, evade, or deny it to myself though
to the rest of the world it can never be owned. I love Caroline’s betrothed, and he loves me. It is no yesterday’s
passion, cultivated by our converse; it came at first sight, independently of my will; and my talk with him yesterday
made rather against it than for it, but, alas, did not quench it. God forgive us both for this terrible treachery.

May 25. — All is vague; our courses shapeless. He comes and goes, being occupied, ostensibly at least, with
sketching in his tent in the wood. Whether he and she see each other privately I cannot tell, but I rather think they
do not; that she sadly awaits him, and he does not appear. Not a sign from him that my repulse has done him any good,
or that he will endeavour to keep faith with her. O, if I only had the compulsion of a god, and the self-sacrifice of a
martyr!

May 31. — It has all ended — or rather this act of the sad drama has ended — in nothing. He has left us. No day for
the fulfilment of the engagement with Caroline is named, my father not being the man to press any one on such a matter,
or, indeed, to interfere in any way. We two girls are, in fact, quite defenceless in a case of this kind; lovers may
come when they choose, and desert when they choose; poor father is too urbane to utter a word of remonstrance or
inquiry. Moreover, as the approved of my dead mother, M. de la Feste has a sort of autocratic power with my father, who
holds it unkind to her memory to have an opinion about him. I, feeling it my duty, asked M. de la Feste at the last
moment about the engagement, in a voice I could not keep firm.

‘Since the death of your mother all has been indefinite — all!’ he said gloomily. That was the whole. Possibly,
Wherryborne Rectory may see him no more.

June 7 . — M. de la Feste has written — one letter to her, one to me. Hers could not have been very warm, for she
did not brighten on reading it. Mine was an ordinary note of friendship, filling an ordinary sheet of paper, which I
handed over to Caroline when I had finished looking it through. But there was a scrap of paper in the bottom of the
envelope, which I dared not show any one. This scrap is his real letter: I scanned it alone in my room, trembling, hot
and cold by turns. He tells me he is very wretched; that he deplores what has happened, but was helpless. Why did I let
him see me, if only to make him faithless. Alas, alas!

June 21 . — My dear Caroline has lost appetite, spirits, health. Hope deferred maketh the heart sick. His letters to
her grow colder — if indeed he has written more than one. He has refrained from writing again to me — he knows it is no
use. Altogether the situation that he and she and I are in is melancholy in the extreme. Why are human hearts so
perverse?

Chapter VI. — Her Ingenuity Instigates Her

September 19. — Three months of anxious care — till at length I have taken the extreme step of writing to him. Our
chief distress has been caused by the state of poor Caroline, who, after sinking by degrees into such extreme weakness
as to make it doubtful if she can ever recover full vigour, has today been taken much worse. Her position is very
critical. The doctor says plainly that she is dying of a broken heart — and that even the removal of the cause may not
now restore her. Ought I to have written to Charles sooner? But how could I when she forbade me? It was her pride only
which instigated her, and I should not have obeyed.

Sept. 26. — Charles has arrived and has seen her. He is shocked, conscience-stricken, remorseful. I have told him
that he can do no good beyond cheering her by his presence. I do not know what he thinks of proposing to her if she
gets better, but he says little to her at present: indeed he dares not: his words agitate her dangerously.

Sept. 28. — After a struggle between duty and selfishness, such as I pray to Heaven I may never have to undergo
again, I have asked him for pity’s sake to make her his wife, here and now, as she lies. I said to him that the poor
child would not trouble him long; and such a solemnization would soothe her last hours as nothing else could do. He
said that he would willingly do so, and had thought of it himself; but for one forbidding reason: in the event of her
death as his wife he can never marry me, her sister, according to our laws. I started at his words. He went on: ‘On the
other hand, if I were sure that immediate marriage with me would save her life, I would not refuse, for possibly I
might after a while, and out of sight of you, make myself fairly content with one of so sweet a disposition as hers;
but if, as is probable, neither my marrying her nor any other act can avail to save her life, by so doing I lose both
her and you.’ I could not answer him.

Sept. 29. — He continued firm in his reasons for refusal till this morning, and then I became possessed with an
idea, which I at once propounded to him. It was that he should at least consent to a form of marriage with Caroline, in
consideration of her love; a form which need not be a legal union, but one which would satisfy her sick and enfeebled
soul. Such things have been done, and the sentiment of feeling herself his would inexpressibly comfort her mind, I am
sure. Then, if she is taken from us, I should not have lost the power of becoming his lawful wife at some future day,
if it indeed should be deemed expedient; if, on the other hand, she lives, he can on her recovery inform her of the
incompleteness of their marriage contract, the ceremony can be repeated, and I can, and I am sure willingly would,
avoid troubling them with my presence till grey hairs and wrinkles make his unfortunate passion for me a thing of the
past. I put all this before him; but he demurred.

Sept. 30. — I have urged him again. He says he will consider. It is no time to mince matters, and as a further
inducement I have offered to enter into a solemn engagement to marry him myself a year after her death.

Sept. 30. Later. — An agitating interview. He says he will agree to whatever I propose, the three possibilities and
our contingent acts being recorded as follows: First, in the event of dear Caroline being taken from us, I marry him on
the expiration of a year: Second, in the forlorn chance of her recovery I take upon myself the responsibility of
explaining to Caroline the true nature of the ceremony he has gone through with her, that it was done at my suggestion
to make her happy at once, before a special licence could be obtained, and that a public ceremony at church is awaiting
her: Third, in the unlikely event of her cooling, and refusing to repeat the ceremony with him, I leave England, join
him abroad, and there wed him, agreeing not to live in England again till Caroline has either married another or
regards her attachment to Charles as a bygone matter. I have thought over these conditions, and have agreed to them all
as they stand.

11 p.m. — I do not much like this scheme, after all. For one thing, I have just sounded my father on it before
parting with him for the night, my impression having been that he would see no objection. But he says he could on no
account countenance any such unreal proceeding; however good our intentions, and even though the poor girl were dying,
it would not be right. So I sadly seek my pillow.

October 1. — I am sure my father is wrong in his view. Why is it not right, if it would be balm to Caroline’s
wounded soul, and if a real ceremony is absolutely refused by Charles — moreover is hardly practicable in the
difficulty of getting a special licence, if he were agreed? My father does not know, or will not believe, that
Caroline’s attachment has been the cause of her hopeless condition. But that it is so, and that the form of words would
give her inexpressible happiness, I know well; for I whispered tentatively in her ear on such marriages, and the effect
was great. Henceforth my father cannot be taken into confidence on the subject of Caroline. He does not understand
her.

12 o’clock noon. — I have taken advantage of my father’s absence today to confide my secret notion to a thoughtful
young man, who called here this morning to speak to my father. He is the Mr. Theophilus Higham, of whom I have already
had occasion to speak — a Scripture reader in the next town, and is soon going to be ordained. I told him the pitiable
case, and my remedy. He says ardently that he will assist me — would do anything for me (he is, in truth, an admirer of
mine); he sees no wrong in such an act of charity. He is coming again to the house this afternoon before my father
returns, to carry out the idea. I have spoken to Charles, who promises to be ready. I must now break the news to
Caroline.

11 o’clock p.m. — I have been in too much excitement till now to set down the result. We have accomplished our plan;
and though I feel like a guilty sinner, I am glad. My father, of course, is not to be informed as yet. Caroline has had
a seraphic expression upon her wasted, transparent face ever since. I should hardly be surprised if it really saved her
life even now, and rendered a legitimate union necessary between them. In that case my father can be informed of the
whole proceeding, and in the face of such wonderful success cannot disapprove. Meanwhile poor Charles has not lost the
possibility of taking unworthy me to fill her place should she —. But I cannot contemplate that alternative unmoved,
and will not write it. Charles left for the South of Europe immediately after the ceremony. He was in a high-strung,
throbbing, almost wild state of mind at first, but grew calmer under my exhortations. I had to pay the penalty of
receiving a farewell kiss from him, which I much regret, considering its meaning; but he took me so unexpectedly, and
in a moment was gone.

Oct. 6. — She certainly is better, and even when she found that Charles had been suddenly obliged to leave, she
received the news quite cheerfully. The doctor says that her apparent improvement may be delusive; but I think our
impressing upon her the necessity of keeping what has occurred a secret from papa, and everybody, helps to give her a
zest for life.

Oct. 8. — She is still mending. I am glad to have saved her — my only sister — if I have done so; though I shall now
never become Charles’s wife.

Chapter VII. — A Surprise Awaits Her

Feb. 5. — Writing has been absolutely impossible for a long while; but I now reach a stage at which it seems
possible to jot down a line. Caroline’s recovery, extending over four months, has been very engrossing; at first slow,
latterly rapid. But a fearful complication of affairs attends it!

O what a tangled web we weave
When first we practise to deceive!

Charles has written reproachfully to me from Venice, where he is. He says how can he fulfil in the real what he has
enacted in the counterfeit, while he still loves me? Yet how, on the other hand, can he leave it unfulfilled? All this
time I have not told her, and up to this minute she believes that he has indeed taken her for better, for worse, till
death them do part. It is a harassing position for me, and all three. In the awful approach of death, one’s judgment
loses its balance, and we do anything to meet the exigencies of the moment, with a single eye to the one who excites
our sympathy, and from whom we seem on the brink of being separated for ever.

Had he really married her at that time all would be settled now. But he took too much thought; she might have died,
and then he had his reason. If indeed it had turned out so, I should now be perhaps a sad woman; but not a
tempest-tossed one . . . The possibility of his claiming me after all is what lies at the root of my
agitation. Everything hangs by a thread. Suppose I tell her the marriage was a mockery; suppose she is indignant with
me and with him for the deception — and then? Otherwise, suppose she is not indignant but forgives all; he is bound to
marry her; and honour constrains me to urge him thereto, in spite of what he protests, and to smooth the way to this
issue by my method of informing her. I have meant to tell her the last month — ever since she has been strong enough to
bear such tidings; but I have been without the power — the moral force. Surely I must write, and get him to come and
assist me.

March 14. — She continually wonders why he does not come, the five months of his enforced absence having expired;
and still more she wonders why he does not write oftener. His last letter was cold, she says, and she fears he regrets
his marriage, which he may only have celebrated with her for pity’s sake, thinking she was sure to die. It makes one’s
heart bleed to hear her hovering thus so near the truth, and yet never discerning its actual shape.

A minor trouble besets me, too, in the person of the young Scripture reader, whose conscience pricks him for the
part he played. Surely I am punished, if ever woman were, for a too ingenious perversion of her better judgment!

April 2. — She is practically well. The faint pink revives in her cheek, though it is not quite so full as
heretofore. But she still wonders what she can have done to offend ‘her dear husband,’ and I have been obliged to tell
the smallest part of the truth — an unimportant fragment of the whole, in fact, I said that I feared for the moment he
might regret the precipitancy of the act, which her illness caused, his affairs not having been quite sufficiently
advanced for marriage just then, though he will doubtless come to her as soon as he has a home ready. Meanwhile I have
written to him, peremptorily, to come and relieve me in this awful dilemma. He will find no note of love in that.

April 10. — To my alarm the letter I lately addressed to him at Venice, where he is staying, as well as the last one
she sent him, have received no reply. She thinks he is ill. I do not quite think that, but I wish we could hear from
him. Perhaps the peremptoriness of my words had offended him; it grieves me to think it possible. I offend him! But too
much of this. I must tell her the truth, or she may in her ignorance commit herself to some course or other that may be
ruinously compromising. She said plaintively just now that if he could see her, and know how occupied with him and him
alone is her every waking hour, she is sure he would forgive her the wicked presumption of becoming his wife. Very
sweet all that, and touching. I could not conceal my tears.

April 15. — The house is in confusion; my father is angry and distressed, and I am distracted. Caroline has
disappeared — gone away secretly. I cannot help thinking that I know where she is gone to. How guilty I seem, and how
innocent she! O that I had told her before now!

1 o’clock. — No trace of her as yet. We find also that the little waiting-maid we have here in training has
disappeared with Caroline, and there is not much doubt that Caroline, fearing to travel alone, has induced this girl to
go with her as companion. I am almost sure she has started in desperation to find him, and that Venice is her goal. Why
should she run away, if not to join her husband, as she thinks him? Now that I consider, there have been indications of
this wish in her for days, as in birds of passage there lurk signs of their incipient intention; and yet I did not
think she would have taken such an extreme step, unaided, and without consulting me. I can only jot down the bare facts
— I have no time for reflections. But fancy Caroline travelling across the continent of Europe with a chit of a girl,
who will be more of a charge than an assistance! They will be a mark for every marauder who encounters them.

Evening: 8 o’clock. — Yes, it is as I surmised. She has gone to join him. A note posted by her in Budmouth Regis at
daybreak has reached me this afternoon — thanks to the fortunate chance of one of the servants calling for letters in
town today, or I should not have got it until tomorrow. She merely asserts her determination of going to him, and has
started privately, that nothing may hinder her; stating nothing about her route. That such a gentle thing should
suddenly become so calmly resolute quite surprises me. Alas, he may have left Venice — she may not find him for weeks —
may not at all.

My father, on learning the facts, bade me at once have everything ready by nine this evening, in time to drive to
the train that meets the night steam-boat. This I have done, and there being an hour to spare before we start, I
relieve the suspense of waiting by taking up my pen. He says overtake her we must, and calls Charles the hardest of
names. He believes, of course, that she is merely an infatuated girl rushing off to meet her lover; and how can the
wretched I tell him that she is more, and in a sense better than that — yet not sufficiently more and better to make
this flight to Charles anything but a still greater danger to her than a mere lover’s impulse. We shall go by way of
Paris, and we think we may overtake her there. I hear my father walking restlessly up and down the hall, and can write
no more.

Chapter VIII. — She Travels in Pursuit

April 16. Evening, Paris, Hotel ——. — There is no overtaking her at this place; but she has been here, as I thought,
no other hotel in Paris being known to her. We go on tomorrow morning.

April 18. Venice. — A morning of adventures and emotions which leave me sick and weary, and yet unable to sleep,
though I have lain down on the sofa of my room for more than an hour in the attempt. I therefore make up my diary to
date in a hurried fashion, for the sake of the riddance it affords to ideas which otherwise remain suspended hotly in
the brain.

We arrived here this morning in broad sunlight, which lit up the sea-girt buildings as we approached so that they
seemed like a city of cork floating raft-like on the smooth, blue deep. But I only glanced from the carriage window at
the lovely scene, and we were soon across the intervening water and inside the railway station. When we got to the
front steps the row of black gondolas and the shouts of the gondoliers so bewildered my father that he was understood
to require two gondolas instead of one with two oars, and so I found him in one and myself in another. We got this
righted after a while, and were rowed at once to the hotel on the Riva degli Schiavoni where M. de la Feste had been
staying when we last heard from him, the way being down the Grand Canal for some distance, under the Rialto, and then
by narrow canals which eventually brought us under the Bridge of Sighs — harmonious to our moods! — and out again into
open water. The scene was purity itself as to colour, but it was cruel that I should behold it for the first time under
such circumstances.

As soon as I entered the hotel, which is an old-fashioned place, like most places here, where people are taken en
pension as well as the ordinary way, I rushed to the framed list of visitors hanging in the hall, and in a moment I saw
Charles’s name upon it among the rest. But she was our chief thought. I turned to the hall porter, and — knowing that
she would have travelled as ‘Madame de la Feste’— I asked for her under that name, without my father hearing. (He, poor
soul, was making confused inquiries outside the door about ‘an English lady,’ as if there were not a score of English
ladies at hand.)

‘She has just come,’ said the porter. ‘Madame came by the very early train this morning, when Monsieur was asleep,
and she requested us not to disturb him. She is now in her room.’

Whether Caroline had seen us from the window, or overheard me, I do not know, but at that moment I heard footsteps
on the bare marble stairs, and she appeared in person descending.

‘Caroline!’ I exclaimed, ‘why have you done this?’ and rushed up to her.

She did not answer; but looked down to hide her emotion, which she conquered after the lapse of a few seconds,
putting on a practical tone that belied her.

‘I am just going to my husband,’ she said. ‘I have not yet seen him. I have not been here long.’ She condescended to
give no further reason for her movements, and made as if to move on. I implored her to come into a private room where I
could speak to her in confidence, but she objected. However, the dining-room, close at hand, was quite empty at this
hour, and I got her inside and closed the door. I do not know how I began my explanation, or how I ended it, but I told
her briefly and brokenly enough that the marriage was not real.

‘Not real?’ she said vacantly.

‘It is not,’ said I. ‘You will find that it is all as I say.’

She could not believe my meaning even then. ‘Not his wife?’ she cried. ‘It is impossible. What am I, then?’

I added more details, and reiterated the reason for my conduct as well as I could; but Heaven knows how very
difficult I found it to feel a jot more justification for it in my own mind than she did in hers.

The revulsion of feeling, as soon as she really comprehended all, was most distressing. After her grief had in some
measure spent itself she turned against both him and me.

‘Why should have I been deceived like this?’ she demanded, with a bitter haughtiness of which I had not deemed such
a tractable creature capable. ‘Do you suppose that anything could justify such an imposition? What, O what a snare you
have spread for me!’

I murmured, ‘Your life seemed to require it,’ but she did not hear me. She sank down in a chair, covered her face,
and then my father came in. ‘O, here you are!’ he said. ‘I could not find you. And Caroline!’

‘And were you, papa, a party to this strange deed of kindness?’

‘To what?’ said he.

Then out it all came, and for the first time he was made acquainted with the fact that the scheme for soothing her
illness, which I had sounded him upon, had been really carried out. In a moment he sided with Caroline. My repeated
assurance that my motive was good availed less than nothing. In a minute or two Caroline arose and went abruptly out of
the room, and my father followed her, leaving me alone to my reflections.

I was so bent upon finding Charles immediately that I did not notice whither they went. The servants told me that M.
de la Feste was just outside smoking, and one of them went to look for him, I following; but before we had gone many
steps he came out of the hotel behind me. I expected him to be amazed; but he showed no surprise at seeing me, though
he showed another kind of feeling to an extent which dismayed me. I may have revealed something similar; but I
struggled hard against all emotion, and as soon as I could I told him she had come. He simply said ‘Yes’ in a low
voice.

‘You know it, Charles?’ said I.

‘I have just learnt it,’ he said.

‘O, Charles,’ I went on, ‘having delayed completing your marriage with her till now, I fear — it has become a
serious position for us. Why did you not reply to our letters?’

‘I was purposing to reply in person: I did not know how to address her on the point — how to address you. But what
has become of her?’

‘She has gone off with my father,’ said I; ‘indignant with you, and scorning me.’

He was silent: and I suggested that we should follow them, pointing out the direction which I fancied their gondola
had taken. As the one we got into was doubly manned we soon came in view of their two figures ahead of us, while they
were not likely to observe us, our boat having the ‘felze’ on, while theirs was uncovered. They shot into a narrow
canal just beyond the Giardino Reale, and by the time we were floating up between its slimy walls we saw them getting
out of their gondola at the steps which lead up near the end of the Via 22 Marzo. When we reached the same spot they
were walking up and down the Via in consultation. Getting out he stood on the lower steps watching them. I watched him.
He seemed to fall into a reverie.

‘Will you not go and speak to her?’ said I at length.

He assented, and went forward. Still he did not hasten to join them, but, screened by a projecting window, observed
their musing converse. At last he looked back at me; whereupon I pointed forward, and he in obedience stepped out, and
met them face to face. Caroline flushed hot, bowed haughtily to him, turned away, and taking my father’s arm violently,
led him off before he had had time to use his own judgment. They disappeared into a narrow calle, or alley, leading to
the back of the buildings on the Grand Canal.

M. de la Feste came slowly back; as he stepped in beside me I realized my position so vividly that my heart might
almost have been heard to beat. The third condition had arisen — the least expected by either of us. She had refused
him; he was free to claim me.

We returned in the boat together. He seemed quite absorbed till we had turned the angle into the Grand Canal, when
he broke the silence. ‘She spoke very bitterly to you in the salle-a-manger,’ he said. ‘I do not think she was quite
warranted in speaking so to you, who had nursed her so tenderly.’

‘O, but I think she was,’ I answered. ‘It was there I told her what had been done; she did not know till then.’

‘She was very dignified — very striking,’ he murmured. ‘You were more.’

‘But how do you know what passed between us,’ said I. He then told me that he had seen and heard all. The
dining-room was divided by folding-doors from an inner portion, and he had been sitting in the latter part when we
entered the outer, so that our words were distinctly audible.

‘But, dear Alicia,’ he went on, ‘I was more impressed by the affection of your apology to her than by anything else.
And do you know that now the conditions have arisen which give me liberty to consider you my affianced?’ I had been
expecting this, but yet was not prepared. I stammered out that we would not discuss it then.

‘Why not?’ said he. ‘Do you know that we may marry here and now? She has cast off both you and me.’

‘It cannot be,’ said I, firmly. ‘She has not been fairly asked to be your wife in fact — to repeat the service
lawfully; and until that has been done it would be grievous sin in me to accept you.’

I had not noticed where the gondoliers were rowing us. I suppose he had given them some direction unheard by me, for
as I resigned myself in despairing indolence to the motion of the gondola, I perceived that it was taking us up the
Canal, and, turning into a side opening near the Palazzo Grimani, drew up at some steps near the end of a large
church.

‘Where are we?’ said I.

‘It is the Church of the Frari,’ he replied. ‘We might be married there. At any rate, let us go inside, and grow
calm, and decide what to do.’

When we had entered I found that whether a place to marry in or not, it was one to depress. The word which Venice
speaks most constantly — decay — was in a sense accentuated here. The whole large fabric itself seemed sinking into an
earth which was not solid enough to bear it. Cobwebbed cracks zigzagged the walls, and similar webs clouded the
window-panes. A sickly-sweet smell pervaded the aisles. After walking about with him a little while in embarrassing
silences, divided only by his cursory explanations of the monuments and other objects, and almost fearing he might
produce a marriage licence, I went to a door in the south transept which opened into the sacristy.

I glanced through it, towards the small altar at the upper end. The place was empty save of one figure; and she was
kneeling here in front of the beautiful altarpiece by Bellini. Beautiful though it was she seemed not to see it. She
was weeping and praying as though her heart was broken. She was my sister Caroline. I beckoned to Charles, and he came
to my side, and looked through the door with me.

‘Speak to her,’ said I. ‘She will forgive you.’

I gently pushed him through the doorway, and went back into the transept, down the nave, and onward to the west
door. There I saw my father, to whom I spoke. He answered severely that, having first obtained comfortable quarters in
a pension on the Grand Canal, he had gone back to the hotel on the Riva degli Schiavoni to find me; but that I was not
there. He was now waiting for Caroline, to accompany her back to the pension, at which she had requested to be left to
herself as much as possible till she could regain some composure.

I told him that it was useless to dwell on what was past, that I no doubt had erred, that the remedy lay in the
future and their marriage. In this he quite agreed with me, and on my informing him that M. de la Feste was at that
moment with Caroline in the sacristy, he assented to my proposal that we should leave them to themselves, and return
together to await them at the pension, where he had also engaged a room for me. This we did, and going up to the
chamber he had chosen for me, which overlooked the Canal, I leant from the window to watch for the gondola that should
contain Charles and my sister.

They were not long in coming. I recognized them by the colour of her sunshade as soon as they turned the bend on my
right hand. They were side by side of necessity, but there was no conversation between them, and I thought that she
looked flushed and he pale. When they were rowed in to the steps of our house he handed her up. I fancied she might
have refused his assistance, but she did not. Soon I heard her pass my door, and wishing to know the result of their
interview I went downstairs, seeing that the gondola had not put off with him. He was turning from the door, but not
towards the water, intending apparently to walk home by way of the calle which led into the Via 22 Marzo.

‘Has she forgiven you?’ said I.

‘I have not asked her,’ he said.

‘But you are bound to do so,’ I told him.

He paused, and then said, ‘Alicia, let us understand each other. Do you mean to tell me, once for all, that if your
sister is willing to become my wife you absolutely make way for her, and will not entertain any thought of what I
suggested to you any more?’

‘I do tell you so,’ said I with dry lips. ‘You belong to her — how can I do otherwise?’

‘Yes; it is so; it is purely a question of honour,’ he returned. ‘Very well then, honour shall be my word, and not
my love. I will put the question to her frankly; if she says yes, the marriage shall be. But not here. It shall be at
your own house in England.’

‘When?’ said I.

‘I will accompany her there,’ he replied, ‘and it shall be within a week of her return. I have nothing to gain by
delay. But I will not answer for the consequences.’

‘What do you mean?’ said I. He made no reply, went away, and I came back to my room.

Chapter IX. — She Witnesses the End

April 20. Milan, 10.30 p.m. — We are thus far on our way homeward. I, being decidedly de trop, travel apart from the
rest as much as I can. Having dined at the hotel here, I went out by myself; regardless of the proprieties, for I could
not stay in. I walked at a leisurely pace along the Via Allesandro Manzoni till my eye was caught by the grand Galleria
Vittorio Emanuele, and I entered under the high glass arcades till I reached the central octagon, where I sat down on
one of a group of chairs placed there. Becoming accustomed to the stream of promenaders, I soon observed, seated on the
chairs opposite, Caroline and Charles. This was the first occasion on which I had seen them en tete-a-tete since my
conversation with him. She soon caught sight of me; averted her eyes; then, apparently abandoning herself to an
impulse, she jumped up from her seat and came across to me. We had not spoken to each other since the meeting in
Venice.

‘Alicia,’ she said, sitting down by my side, ‘Charles asks me to forgive you, and I do forgive you.’

I pressed her hand, with tears in my eyes, and said, ‘And do you forgive him?’

‘Yes,’ said she, shyly.

‘And what’s the result?’ said I.

‘We are to be married directly we reach home.’

This was almost the whole of our conversation; she walked home with me, Charles following a little way behind,
though she kept turning her head, as if anxious that he should overtake us. ‘Honour and not love’ seemed to ring in my
ears. So matters stand. Caroline is again happy.

April 25. — We have reached home, Charles with us. Events are now moving in silent speed, almost with velocity,
indeed; and I sometimes feel oppressed by the strange and preternatural ease which seems to accompany their flow.
Charles is staying at the neighbouring town; he is only waiting for the marriage licence; when obtained he is to come
here, be quietly married to her, and carry her off. It is rather resignation than content which sits on his face; but
he has not spoken a word more to me on the burning subject, or deviated one hair’s breadth from the course he laid
down. They may be happy in time to come: I hope so. But I cannot shake off depression.

May 6. — Eve of the wedding. Caroline is serenely happy, though not blithe. But there is nothing to excite anxiety
about her. I wish I could say the same of him. He comes and goes like a ghost, and yet nobody seems to observe this
strangeness in his mien.

I could not help being here for the ceremony; but my absence would have resulted in less disquiet on his part, I
believe. However, I may be wrong in attributing causes: my father simply says that Charles and Caroline have as good a
chance of being happy as other people. Well, tomorrow settles all.

May 7. — They are married: we have just returned from church. Charles looked so pale this morning that my father
asked him if he was ill. He said, ‘No: only a slight headache;’ and we started for the church.

There was no hitch or hindrance; and the thing is done.

4 p.m. — They ought to have set out on their journey by this time; but there is an unaccountable delay. Charles went
out half-an-hour ago, and has not yet returned. Caroline is waiting in the hall; but I am dreadfully afraid they will
miss the train. I suppose the trifling hindrance is of no account; and yet I am full of misgivings . . .

Sept. 14. — Four months have passed; only four months! It seems like years. Can it be that only seventeen weeks ago
I set on this paper the fact of their marriage? I am now an aged woman by comparison!

On that never to be forgotten day we waited and waited, and Charles did not return. At six o’clock, when poor little
Caroline had gone back to her room in a state of suspense impossible to describe, a man who worked in the water-meadows
came to the house and asked for my father. He had an interview with him in the study. My father then rang his bell, and
sent for me. I went down; and I then learnt the fatal news. Charles was no more. The waterman had been going to shut
down the hatches of a weir in the meads when he saw a hat on the edge of the pool below, floating round and round in
the eddy, and looking into the pool saw something strange at the bottom. He knew what it meant, and lowering the
hatches so that the water was still, could distinctly see the body. It is needless to write particulars that were in
the newspapers at the time. Charles was brought to the house, but he was dead.

We all feared for Caroline; and she suffered much; but strange to say, her suffering was purely of the nature of
deep grief which found relief in sobbing and tears. It came out at the inquest that Charles had been accustomed to
cross the meads to give an occasional half-crown to an old man who lived on the opposite hill, who had once been a
landscape painter in an humble way till he lost his eyesight; and it was assumed that he had gone thither for the same
purpose today, and to bid him farewell. On this information the coroner’s jury found that his death had been caused by
misadventure; and everybody believes to this hour that he was drowned while crossing the weir to relieve the old man.
Except one: she believes in no accident. After the stunning effect of the first news, I thought it strange that he
should have chosen to go on such an errand at the last moment, and to go personally, when there was so little time to
spare, since any gift could have been so easily sent by another hand. Further reflection has convinced me that this
step out of life was as much a part of the day’s plan as was the wedding in the church hard by. They were the two
halves of his complete intention when he gave me on the Grand Canal that assurance which I shall never forget: ‘Very
well, then; honour shall be my word, not love. If she says “Yes,” the marriage shall be.’

I do not know why I should have made this entry at this particular time; but it has occurred to me to do it — to
complete, in a measure, that part of my desultory chronicle which relates to the love-story of my sister and Charles.
She lives on meekly in her grief; and will probably outlive it; while I— but never mind me.

Chapter X. — She Adds a Note Long After

Five-years later. — I have lighted upon this old diary, which it has interested me to look over, containing, as it
does, records of the time when life shone more warmly in my eye than it does now. I am impelled to add one sentence to
round off its record of the past. About a year ago my sister Caroline, after a persistent wooing, accepted the hand and
heart of Theophilus Higham, once the blushing young Scripture reader who assisted at the substitute for a marriage I
planned, and now the fully-ordained curate of the next parish. His penitence for the part he played ended in love. We
have all now made atonement for our sins against her: may she be deceived no more.

1887.

The Grave by the Handpost

I never pass through Chalk–Newton without turning to regard the neighbouring upland, at a point where a lane crosses
the lone straight highway dividing this from the next parish; a sight which does not fail to recall the event that once
happened there; and, though it may seem superfluous, at this date, to disinter more memories of village history, the
whispers of that spot may claim to be preserved.

It was on a dark, yet mild and exceptionally dry evening at Christmas-time (according to the testimony of William
Dewy of Mellstock, Michael Mail, and others), that the choir of Chalk–Newton — a large parish situate about half-way
between the towns of Ivel and Casterbridge, and now a railway station — left their homes just before midnight to repeat
their annual harmonies under the windows of the local population. The band of instrumentalists and singers was one of
the largest in the county; and, unlike the smaller and finer Mellstock string-band, which eschewed all but the catgut,
it included brass and reed performers at full Sunday services, and reached all across the west gallery.

On this night there were two or three violins, two ‘cellos, a tenor viol, double bass, hautboy, clarionets, serpent,
and seven singers. It was, however, not the choir’s labours, but what its members chanced to witness, that particularly
marked the occasion.

They had pursued their rounds for many years without meeting with any incident of an unusual kind, but to-night,
according to the assertions of several, there prevailed, to begin with, an exceptionally solemn and thoughtful mood
among two or three of the oldest in the band, as if they were thinking they might be joined by the phantoms of dead
friends who had been of their number in earlier years, and now were mute in the churchyard under flattening mounds —
friends who had shown greater zest for melody in their time than was shown in this; or that some past voice of a
semi-transparent figure might quaver from some bedroom-window its acknowledgment of their nocturnal greeting, instead
of a familiar living neighbour. Whether this were fact or fancy, the younger members of the choir met together with
their customary thoughtlessness and buoyancy. When they had gathered by the stone stump of the cross in the middle of
the village, near the White Horse Inn, which they made their starting point, some one observed that they were full
early, that it was not yet twelve o’clock. The local waits of those days mostly refrained from sounding a note before
Christmas morning had astronomically arrived, and not caring to return to their beer, they decided to begin with some
outlying cottages in Sidlinch Lane, where the people had no clocks, and would not know whether it were night or
morning. In that direction they accordingly went; and as they ascended to higher ground their attention was attracted
by a light beyond the houses, quite at the top of the lane.

The road from Chalk–Newton to Broad Sidlinch is about two miles long and in the middle of its course, where it
passes over the ridge dividing the two villages, it crosses at right angles, as has been stated, the lonely monotonous
old highway known as Long Ash Lane, which runs, straight as a surveyor’s line, many miles north and south of this spot,
on the foundation of a Roman road, and has often been mentioned in these narratives. Though now quite deserted and
grass-grown, at the beginning of the century it was well kept and frequented by traffic. The glimmering light appeared
to come from the precise point where the roads intersected.

‘I think I know what that mid mean!’ one of the group remarked.

They stood a few moments, discussing the probability of the light having origin in an event of which rumours had
reached them, and resolved to go up the hill.

Approaching the high land their conjectures were strengthened. Long Ash Lane cut athwart them, right and left; and
they saw that at the junction of the four ways, under the hand-post, a grave was dug, into which, as the choir drew
nigh, a corpse had just been thrown by the four Sidlinch men employed for the purpose. The cart and horse which had
brought the body thither stood silently by.

The singers and musicians from Chalk–Newton halted, and looked on while the gravediggers shovelled in and trod down
the earth, till, the hole being filled, the latter threw their spades into the cart, and prepared to depart.

The Sidlinch men had been so deeply engrossed in their task that they had not noticed the lanterns of the
Chalk–Newton choir till now.

‘What — be you the Newton carol-singers?’ returned the representatives of Sidlinch.

‘Ay, sure. Can it be that it is old Sergeant Holway you’ve a-buried there?’

‘’Tis so. You’ve heard about it, then?’

The choir knew no particulars — only that he had shot himself in his apple-closet on the previous Sunday. ‘Nobody
seem’th to know what ‘a did it for, ‘a b’lieve? Leastwise, we don’t know at Chalk–Newton,’ continued Lot.

‘O yes. It all came out at the inquest.’

The singers drew close, and the Sidlinch men, pausing to rest after their labours, told the story. ‘It was all owing
to that son of his, poor old man. It broke his heart.’

‘But the son is a soldier, surely; now with his regiment in the East Indies?’

‘Ay. And it have been rough with the army over there lately. ’Twas a pity his father persuaded him to go. But Luke
shouldn’t have twyted the sergeant o’t, since ‘a did it for the best.’

The circumstances, in brief, were these: The sergeant who had come to this lamentable end, father of the young
soldier who had gone with his regiment to the East, had been singularly comfortable in his military experiences, these
having ended long before the outbreak of the great war with France. On his discharge, after duly serving his time, he
had returned to his native village, and married, and taken kindly to domestic life. But the war in which England next
involved herself had cost him many frettings that age and infirmity prevented him from being ever again an active unit
of the army. When his only son grew to young manhood, and the question arose of his going out in life, the lad
expressed his wish to be a mechanic. But his father advised enthusiastically for the army.

‘Trade is coming to nothing in these days,’ he said. ‘And if the war with the French lasts, as it will, trade will
be still worse. The army, Luke — that’s the thing for ‘ee. ’Twas the making of me, and ’twill be the making of you. I
hadn’t half such a chance as you’ll have in these splendid hotter times.’

Luke demurred, for he was a home-keeping, peace-loving youth. But, putting respectful trust in his father’s
judgment, he at length gave way, and enlisted in the —— d Foot. In the course of a few weeks he was sent out to India
to his regiment, which had distinguished itself in the East under General Wellesley.

But Luke was unlucky. News came home indirectly that he lay sick out there; and then on one recent day when his
father was out walking, the old man had received tidings that a letter awaited him at Casterbridge. The sergeant sent a
special messenger the whole nine miles, and the letter was paid for and brought home; but though, as he had guessed, it
came from Luke, its contents were of an unexpected tenor.

The letter had been written during a time of deep depression. Luke said that his life was a burden and a slavery,
and bitterly reproached his father for advising him to embark on a career for which he felt unsuited. He found himself
suffering fatigues and illnesses without gaining glory, and engaged in a cause which he did not understand or
appreciate. If it had not been for his father’s bad advice he, Luke, would now have been working comfortably at a trade
in the village that he had never wished to leave.

After reading the letter the sergeant advanced a few steps till he was quite out of sight of everybody, and then sat
down on the bank by the wayside.

When he arose half-an-hour later he looked withered and broken, and from that day his natural spirits left him.
Wounded to the quick by his son’s sarcastic stings, he indulged in liquor more and more frequently. His wife had died
some years before this date, and the sergeant lived alone in the house which had been hers. One morning in the December
under notice the report of a gun had been heard on his premises, and on entering the neighbours found him in a dying
state. He had shot himself with an old firelock that he used for scaring birds; and from what he had said the day
before, and the arrangements he had made for his decease, there was no doubt that his end had been deliberately
planned, as a consequence of the despondency into which he had been thrown by his son’s letter. The coroner’s jury
returned a verdict of felo de se.

‘Here’s his son’s letter,’ said one of the Sidlinch men. ‘’Twas found in his father’s pocket. You can see by the
state o’t how many times he read it over. Howsomever, the Lord’s will be done, since it must, whether or no.’

The grave was filled up and levelled, no mound being shaped over it. The Sidlinch men then bade the Chalk–Newton
choir good-night, and departed with the cart in which they had brought the sergeant’s body to the hill. When their
tread had died away from the ear, and the wind swept over the isolated grave with its customary siffle of indifference,
Lot Swanhills turned and spoke to old Richard Toller, the hautboy player.

‘’Tis hard upon a man, and he a wold sojer, to serve en so, Richard. Not that the sergeant was ever in a battle
bigger than would go into a half-acre paddock, that’s true. Still, his soul ought to hae as good a chance as another
man’s, all the same, hey?’

Richard replied that he was quite of the same opinion. ‘What d’ye say to lifting up a carrel over his grave, as ’tis
Christmas, and no hurry to begin down in parish, and ‘twouldn’t take up ten minutes, and not a soul up here to say us
nay, or know anything about it?’

Lot nodded assent. ‘The man ought to hae his chances,’ he repeated.

‘Ye may as well spet upon his grave, for all the good we shall do en by what we lift up, now he’s got so far,’ said
Notton, the clarionet man and professed sceptic of the choir. ‘But I’m agreed if the rest be.’

They thereupon placed themselves in a semicircle by the newly stirred earth, and roused the dull air with the
well-known Number Sixteen of their collection, which Lot gave out as being the one he thought best suited to the
occasion and the mood

He comes’ the pri’-soners to’ re-lease’,
In Sa’-tan’s bon’-dage held’.

‘Jown it — we’ve never played to a dead man afore,’ said Ezra Cattstock, when, having concluded the last verse, they
stood reflecting for a breath or two. ‘But it do seem more merciful than to go away and leave en, as they t’other
fellers have done.’

‘Now backalong to Newton, and by the time we get overright the pa’son’s ’twill be half after twelve,’ said the
leader.

They had not, however, done more than gather up their instruments when the wind brought to their notice the noise of
a vehicle rapidly driven up the same lane from Sidlinch which the gravediggers had lately retraced. To avoid being run
over when moving on, they waited till the benighted traveller, whoever he might be, should pass them where they stood
in the wider area of the Cross.

In half a minute the light of the lanterns fell upon a hired fly, drawn by a steaming and jaded horse. It reached
the hand-post, when a voice from the inside cried, ‘Stop here!’ The driver pulled rein. The carriage door was opened
from within, and there leapt out a private soldier in the uniform of some line regiment. He looked around, and was
apparently surprised to see the musicians standing there.

‘Have you buried a man here?’ he asked.

‘No. We bain’t Sidlinch folk, thank God; we be Newton choir. Though a man is just buried here, that’s true; and
we’ve raised a carrel over the poor mortal’s natomy. What — do my eyes see before me young Luke Holway, that went wi’
his regiment to the East Indies, or do I see his spirit straight from the battlefield? Be you the son that wrote the
letter —’

‘Don’t — don’t ask me. The funeral is over, then?’

‘There wer no funeral, in a Christen manner of speaking. But’s buried, sure enough. You must have met the men going
back in the empty cart.’

‘Like a dog in a ditch, and all through me!’

He remained silent, looking at the grave, and they could not help pitying him. ‘My friends,’ he said, ‘I understand
better now. You have, I suppose, in neighbourly charity, sung peace to his soul? I thank you, from my heart, for your
kind pity. Yes; I am Sergeant Holway’s miserable son — I’m the son who has brought about his father’s death, as truly
as if I had done it with my own hand!’

‘No, no. Don’t ye take on so, young man. He’d been naturally low for a good while, off and on, so we hear.’

‘We were out in the East when I wrote to him. Everything had seemed to go wrong with me. Just after my letter had
gone we were ordered home. That’s how it is you see me here. As soon as we got into barracks at Casterbridge I heard o’
this . . . Damn me! I’ll dare to follow my father, and make away with myself, too. It is the only thing left
to do!’

‘Don’t ye be rash, Luke Holway, I say again; but try to make amends by your future life. And maybe your father will
smile a smile down from heaven upon ‘ee for ‘t.’

He shook his head. ‘I don’t know about that!’ he answered bitterly.

‘Try and be worthy of your father at his best. ’Tis not too late.’

‘D’ye think not? I fancy it is! . . . Well, I’ll turn it over. Thank you for your good counsel. I’ll live
for one thing, at any rate. I’ll move father’s body to a decent Christian churchyard, if I do it with my own hands. I
can’t save his life, but I can give him an honourable grave. He shan’t lie in this accursed place!’

‘Ay, as our pa’son says, ’tis a barbarous custom they keep up at Sidlinch, and ought to be done away wi’. The man a’
old soldier, too. You see, our pa’son is not like yours at Sidlinch.’

‘He says it is barbarous, does he? So it is!’ cried the soldier. ‘Now hearken, my friends.’ Then he proceeded to
inquire if they would increase his indebtedness to them by undertaking the removal, privately, of the body of the
suicide to the churchyard, not of Sidlinch, a parish he now hated, but of Chalk–Newton. He would give them all he
possessed to do it.

Lot asked Ezra Cattstock what he thought of it.

Cattstock, the ‘cello player, who was also the sexton, demurred, and advised the young soldier to sound the rector
about it first. ‘Mid be he would object, and yet ‘a mid’nt. The pa’son o’ Sidlinch is a hard man, I own ye, and ‘a said
if folk will kill theirselves in hot blood they must take the consequences. But ours don’t think like that at all, and
might allow it.’

‘What’s his name?’

‘The honourable and reverent Mr. Oldham, brother to Lord Wessex. But you needn’t be afeard o’ en on that account.
He’ll talk to ‘ee like a common man, if so be you haven’t had enough drink to gie ‘ee bad breath.’

‘O, the same as formerly. I’ll ask him. Thank you. And that duty done —’

‘What then?’

‘There’s war in Spain. I hear our next move is there. I’ll try to show myself to be what my father wished me. I
don’t suppose I shall — but I’ll try in my feeble way. That much I swear — here over his body. So help me God.’

Luke smacked his palm against the white hand-post with such force that it shook. ‘Yes, there’s war in Spain; and
another chance for me to be worthy of father.’

So the matter ended that night. That the private acted in one thing as he had vowed to do soon became apparent, for
during the Christmas week the rector came into the churchyard when Cattstock was there, and asked him to find a spot
that would be suitable for the purpose of such an interment, adding that he had slightly known the late sergeant, and
was not aware of any law which forbade him to assent to the removal, the letter of the rule having been observed. But
as he did not wish to seem moved by opposition to his neighbour at Sidlinch, he had stipulated that the act of charity
should be carried out at night, and as privately as possible, and that the grave should be in an obscure part of the
enclosure. ‘You had better see the young man about it at once,’ added the rector.

But before Ezra had done anything Luke came down to his house. His furlough had been cut short, owing to new
developments of the war in the Peninsula, and being obliged to go back to his regiment immediately, he was compelled to
leave the exhumation and reinterment to his friends. Everything was paid for, and he implored them all to see it
carried out forthwith.

With this the soldier left. The next day Ezra, on thinking the matter over, again went across to the rectory, struck
with sudden misgiving. He had remembered that the sergeant had been buried without a coffin, and he was not sure that a
stake had not been driven through him. The business would be more troublesome than they had at first supposed.

‘Yes, indeed!’ murmured the rector. ‘I am afraid it is not feasible after all.’

The next event was the arrival of a headstone by carrier from the nearest town; to be left at Mr. Ezra Cattstock’s;
all expenses paid. The sexton and the carrier deposited the stone in the former’s outhouse; and Ezra, left alone, put
on his spectacles and read the brief and simple inscription:—

HERE LYETH THE BODY OF SAMUEL HOLWAY, LATE SERGEANT IN HIS MAJESTY’S—— D REGIMENT OF FOOT, WHO DEPARTED THIS LIFE
DECEMBER THE 20TH, 180-.
ERECTED BY L. H.
‘I AM NOT WORTHY TO BE CALLED THY SON.’

Ezra again called at the riverside rectory. ‘The stone is come, sir. But I’m afeard we can’t do it nohow.’

‘I should like to oblige him,’ said the gentlemanly old incumbent. ‘And I would forego all fees willingly. Still, if
you and the others don’t think you can carry it out, I am in doubt what to say.’

Well, sir; I’ve made inquiry of a Sidlinch woman as to his burial, and what I thought seems true. They buried en wi’
a new six-foot hurdle-saul drough’s body, from the sheep-pen up in North Ewelease though they won’t own to it now. And
the question is, Is the moving worth while, considering the awkwardness?’

‘Have you heard anything more of the young man?’

Ezra had only heard that he had embarked that week for Spain with the rest of the regiment. ‘And if he’s as
desperate as ‘a seemed, we shall never see him here in England again.’

‘It is an awkward case,’ said the rector.

Ezra talked it over with the choir; one of whom suggested that the stone might be erected at the crossroads. This
was regarded as impracticable. Another said that it might be set up in the churchyard without removing the body; but
this was seen to be dishonest. So nothing was done.

The headstone remained in Ezra’s outhouse till, growing tired of seeing it there, he put it away among the bushes at
the bottom of his garden. The subject was sometimes revived among them, but it always ended with: ‘Considering how ‘a
was buried, we can hardly make a job o’t.’

There was always the consciousness that Luke would never come back, an impression strengthened by the disasters
which were rumoured to have befallen the army in Spain. This tended to make their inertness permanent. The headstone
grew green as it lay on its back under Ezra’s bushes; then a tree by the river was blown down, and, falling across the
stone, cracked it in three pieces. Ultimately the pieces became buried in the leaves and mould.

Luke had not been born a Chalk–Newton man, and he had no relations left in Sidlinch, so that no tidings of him
reached either village throughout the war. But after Waterloo and the fall of Napoleon there arrived at Sidlinch one
day an English sergeant-major covered with stripes and, as it turned out, rich in glory. Foreign service had so totally
changed Luke Holway that it was not until he told his name that the inhabitants recognized him as the sergeant’s only
son.

He had served with unswerving effectiveness through the Peninsular campaigns under Wellington; had fought at Busaco,
Fuentes d’Onore, Ciudad Rodrigo, Badajoz, Salamanca, Vittoria, Quatre Bras, and Waterloo; and had now returned to enjoy
a more than earned pension and repose in his native district.

He hardly stayed in Sidlinch longer than to take a meal on his arrival. The same evening he started on foot over the
hill to Chalk–Newton, passing the hand-post, and saying as he glanced at the spot, ‘Thank God: he’s not there!’
Nightfall was approaching when he reached the latter village; but he made straight for the churchyard. On his entering
it there remained light enough to discern the headstones by, and these he narrowly scanned. But though he searched the
front part by the road, and the back part by the river, what he sought he could not find — the grave of Sergeant
Holway, and a memorial bearing the inscription: ‘I AM NOT WORTHY TO BE CALLED THY SON.’

He left the churchyard and made inquiries. The honourable and reverend old rector was dead, and so were many of the
choir; but by degrees the sergeant-major learnt that his father still lay at the cross-roads in Long Ash Lane.

Luke pursued his way moodily homewards, to do which, in the natural course, he would be compelled to repass the
spot, there being no other road between the two villages. But he could not now go by that place, vociferous with
reproaches in his father’s tones; and he got over the hedge and wandered deviously through the ploughed fields to avoid
the scene. Through many a fight and fatigue Luke had been sustained by the thought that he was restoring the family
honour and making noble amends. Yet his father lay still in degradation. It was rather a sentiment than a fact that his
father’s body had been made to suffer for his own misdeeds; but to his super-sensitiveness it seemed that his efforts
to retrieve his character and to propitiate the shade of the insulted one had ended in failure.

He endeavoured, however, to shake off his lethargy, and, not liking the associations of Sidlinch, hired a small
cottage at Chalk–Newton which had long been empty. Here he lived alone, becoming quite a hermit, and allowing no woman
to enter the house.

The Christmas after taking up his abode herein he was sitting in the chimney corner by himself, when he heard faint
notes in the distance, and soon a melody burst forth immediately outside his own window, it came from the
carol-singers, as usual; and though many of the old hands, Ezra and Lot included, had gone to their rest, the same old
carols were still played out of the same old books. There resounded through the sergeant-major’s window-shutters the
familiar lines that the deceased choir had rendered over his father’s grave:—

He comes’ the pri’-soners to’ re-lease’,
In Sa’-tan’s bon’-dage held’.

When they had finished they went on to another house, leaving him to silence and loneliness as before.

The candle wanted snuffing, but he did not snuff it, and he sat on till it had burnt down into the socket and made
waves of shadow on the ceiling.

The Christmas cheerfulness of next morning was broken at breakfast-time by tragic intelligence which went down the
village like wind. Sergeant–Major Holway had been found shot through the head by his own hand at the cross-roads in
Long Ash Lane where his father lay buried.

On the table in the cottage he had left a piece of paper, on which he had written his wish that he might be buried
at the Cross beside his father. But the paper was accidentally swept to the floor, and overlooked till after his
funeral, which took place in the ordinary way in the churchyard.

Christmas 1897.

Enter A Dragoon

I

I lately had a melancholy experience (said the gentleman who is answerable for the truth of this story). It was that
of going over a doomed house with whose outside aspect I had long been familiar — a house, that is, which by reason of
age and dilapidation was to be pulled down during the following week. Some of the thatch, brown and rotten as the gills
of old mushrooms, had, indeed, been removed before I walked over the building. Seeing that it was only a very small
house — which is usually called a ‘cottage-residence’— situated in a remote hamlet, and that it was not more than a
hundred years old, if so much, I was led to think in my progress through the hollow rooms, with their cracked walls and
sloping floors, what an exceptional number of abrupt family incidents had taken place therein — to reckon only those
which had come to my own knowledge. And no doubt there were many more of which I had never heard.

It stood at the top of a garden stretching down to the lane or street that ran through a hermit-group of dwellings
in Mellstock parish. From a green gate at the lower entrance, over which the thorn hedge had been shaped to an arch by
constant clippings, a gravel path ascended between the box edges of once trim raspberry, strawberry, and vegetable
plots, towards the front door. This was in colour an ancient and bleached green that could be rubbed off with the
finger, and it bore a small long-featured brass knocker covered with verdigris in its crevices. For some years before
this eve of demolition the homestead had degenerated, and been divided into two tenements to serve as cottages for farm
labourers; but in its prime it had indisputable claim to be considered neat, pretty, and genteel.

The variety of incidents above alluded to was mainly owing to the nature of the tenure, whereby the place had been
occupied by families not quite of the kind customary in such spots — people whose circumstances, position, or
antecedents were more or less of a critical happy-go-lucky cast. And of these residents the family whose term comprised
the story I wish to relate was that of Mr. Jacob Paddock the market-gardener, who dwelt there for some years with his
wife and grown-up daughter.

I

An evident commotion was agitating the premises, which jerked busy sounds across the front plot, resembling those of
a disturbed hive. If a member of the household appeared at the door it was with a countenance of abstraction and
concern.

Evening began to bend over the scene; and the other inhabitants of the hamlet came out to draw water, their common
well being in the public road opposite the garden and house of the Paddocks. Having wound up their bucketsfull
respectively they lingered, and spoke significantly together. From their words any casual listener might have gathered
information of what had occurred.

The woodman who lived nearest the site of the story told most of the tale. Selina, the daughter of the Paddocks
opposite, had been surprised that afternoon by receiving a letter from her once intended husband, then a corporal, but
now a sergeant-major of dragoons, whom she had hitherto supposed to be one of the slain in the Battle of the Alma two
or three years before.

‘She picked up wi’en against her father’s wish, as we know, and before he got his stripes,’ their informant
continued. ‘Not but that the man was as hearty a feller as you’d meet this side o’ London. But Jacob, you see, wished
her to do better, and one can understand it. However, she was determined to stick to him at that time; and for what
happened she was not much to blame, so near as they were to matrimony when the war broke out and spoiled all.’

‘Even the very pig had been killed for the wedding,’ said a woman, ‘and the barrel o’ beer ordered in. O, the man
meant honourable enough. But to be off in two days to fight in a foreign country —’twas natural of her father to say
they should wait till he got back.’

‘And he never came,’ murmured one in the shade.

‘The war ended but her man never turned up again. She was not sure he was killed, but was too proud, or too timid,
to go and hunt for him.’

‘One reason why her father forgave her when he found out how matters stood was, as he said plain at the time, that
he liked the man, and could see that he meant to act straight. So the old folks made the best of what they couldn’t
mend, and kept her there with ’em, when some wouldn’t. Time has proved seemingly that he did mean to act straight, now
that he has writ to her that he’s coming. She’d have stuck to him all through the time, ’tis my belief; if t’other
hadn’t come along.’

‘At the time of the courtship,’ resumed the woodman, ‘the regiment was quartered in Casterbridge Barracks, and he
and she got acquainted by his calling to buy a penn’orth of rathe-ripes off that tree yonder in her father’s orchard —
though ’twas said he seed her over hedge as well as the apples. He declared ’twas a kind of apple he much fancied; and
he called for a penn’orth every day till the tree was cleared. It ended in his calling for her.’

‘’Twas a thousand pities they didn’t jine up at once and ha’ done wi’ it.

‘Well; better late than never, if so be he’ll have her now. But, Lord, she’d that faith in ‘en that she’d no more
belief that he was alive, when a’ didn’t come, than that the undermost man in our churchyard was alive. She’d never
have thought of another but for that — O no!’

‘’Tis awkward, altogether, for her now.’

‘Still she hadn’t married wi’ the new man. Though to be sure she would have committed it next week, even the licence
being got, they say, for she’d have no banns this time, the first being so unfortunate.’

‘Perhaps the sergeant-major will think he’s released, and go as he came.’

‘O, not as I reckon. Soldiers bain’t particular, and she’s a tidy piece o’ furniture still. What will happen is that
she’ll have her soldier, and break off with the master-wheelwright, licence or no — daze me if she won’t.’

In the progress of these desultory conjectures the form of another neighbour arose in the gloom. She nodded to the
people at the well, who replied ‘G’d night, Mrs. Stone,’ as she passed through Mr. Paddock’s gate towards his door. She
was an intimate friend of the latter’s household, and the group followed her with their eyes up the path and past the
windows, which were now lighted up by candles inside.

II

Mrs. Stone paused at the door, knocked, and was admitted by Selina’s mother, who took her visitor at once into the
parlour on the left hand, where a table was partly spread for supper. On the ‘beaufet’ against the wall stood probably
the only object which would have attracted the eye of a local stranger in an otherwise ordinarily furnished room, a
great plum-cake guarded as if it were a curiosity by a glass shade of the kind seen in museums — square, with a wooden
back like those enclosing stuffed specimens of rare feather or fur. This was the mummy of the cake intended in earlier
days for the wedding-feast of Selina and the soldier, which had been religiously and lovingly preserved by the former
as a testimony to her intentional respectability in spite of an untoward subsequent circumstance, which will be
mentioned. This relic was now as dry as a brick, and seemed to belong to a pre-existent civilization. Till quite
recently, Selina had been in the habit of pausing before it daily, and recalling the accident whose consequences had
thrown a shadow over her life ever since — that of which the water-drawers had spoken — the sudden news one morning
that the Route had come for the —— th Dragoons, two days only being the interval before departure; the hurried
consultation as to what should be done, the second time of asking being past but not the third; and the decision that
it would be unwise to solemnize matrimony in such haphazard circumstances, even if it were possible, which was
doubtful.

Before the fire the young woman in question was now seated on a low stool, in the stillness of reverie, and a
toddling boy played about the floor around her.

‘Ah, Mrs. Stone!’ said Selina, rising slowly. ‘How kind of you to come in. You’ll bide to supper? Mother has told
you the strange news, of course?’

‘No. But I heard it outside, that is, that you’d had a letter from Mr. Clark — Sergeant–Major Clark, as they say he
is now — and that he’s coming to make it up with ‘ee.’

‘Yes; coming to-night — all the way from the north of England where he’s quartered. I don’t know whether I’m happy
or — frightened at it. Of course I always believed that if he was alive he’d come and keep his solemn vow to me. But
when it is printed that a man is killed — what can you think?’

‘It was printed?’

‘Why, yes. After the Battle of the Alma the book of the names of the killed and wounded was nailed up against
Casterbridge Town Hall door. ’Twas on a Saturday, and I walked there o’ purpose to read and see for myself; for I’d
heard that his name was down. There was a crowd of people round the book, looking for the names of relations; and I can
mind that when they saw me they made way for me — knowing that we’d been just going to be married — and that, as you
may say, I belonged to him. Well, I reached up my arm, and turned over the farrels of the book, and under the “killed”
I read his surname, but instead of “John” they’d printed “James,” and I thought ’twas a mistake, and that it must be
he. Who could have guessed there were two nearly of one name in one regiment.’

‘Well — he’s coming to finish the wedding of ‘ee as may be said; so never mind, my dear. All’s well that ends
well.’

‘That’s what he seems to say. But then he has not heard yet about Mr. Miller; and that’s what rather terrifies me.
Luckily my marriage with him next week was to have been by licence, and not banns, as in John’s case; and it was not so
well known on that account. Still, I don’t know what to think.’

‘Everything seems to come just ‘twixt cup and lip with ‘ee, don’t it now, Miss Paddock. Two weddings broke off —’tis
odd! How came you to accept Mr. Miller, my dear?’

‘He’s been so good and faithful! Not minding about the child at all; for he knew the rights of the story. He’s
dearly fond o’ Johnny, you know — just as if ’twere his own — isn’t he, my duck? Do Mr. Miller love you or don’t
he?’

‘Iss! An’ I love Mr. Miller,’ said the toddler.

‘Well, you see, Mrs. Stone, he said he’d make me a comfortable home; and thinking ‘twould be a good thing for
Johnny, Mr. Miller being so much better off than me, I agreed at last, just as a widow might — which is what I have
always felt myself; ever since I saw what I thought was John’s name printed there. I hope John will forgive me!’

‘So he will forgive ‘ee, since ’twas no manner of wrong to him. He ought to have sent ‘ee a line, saying ’twas
another man.’

Selina’s mother entered. ‘We’ve not known of this an hour, Mrs. Stone,’ she said. ‘The letter was brought up from
Lower Mellstock Post-office by one of the school children, only this afternoon. Mr. Miller was coming here this very
night to settle about the wedding doings. Hark! Is that your father? Or is it Mr. Miller already come?’

The footsteps entered the porch; there was a brushing on the mat, and the door of the room sprung back to disclose a
rubicund man about thirty years of age, of thriving master-mechanic appearance and obviously comfortable temper. On
seeing the child, and before taking any notice whatever of the elders, the comer made a noise like the crowing of a
cock and flapped his arms as if they were wings, a method of entry which had the unqualified admiration of Johnny.

‘Yes — it is he,’ said Selina constrainedly advancing.

‘What — were you all talking about me, my dear?’ said the genial young man when he had finished his crowing and
resumed human manners. ‘Why what’s the matter,’ he went on. ‘You look struck all of a heap.’ Mr. Miller spread an
aspect of concern over his own face, and drew a chair up to the fire.

‘O mother, would you tell Mr. Miller, if he don’t know?’

‘Mister Miller! and going to be married in six days!’ he interposed.

‘Ah — he don’t know it yet!’ murmured Mrs. Paddock.

‘Know what?’

‘Well — John Clark — now Sergeant–Major Clark — wasn’t shot at Alma after all. ’Twas another of almost the same
name.’

‘Now that’s interesting! There were several cases like that.’

‘And he’s home again; and he’s coming here to-night to see her.’

‘Whatever shall I say, that he may not be offended with what I’ve done?’ interposed Selina.

‘But why should it matter if he be?’

‘O! I must agree to be his wife if he forgives me — of course I must.’

‘Must! But why not say nay, Selina, even if he do forgive ‘ee?’

‘O no! How can I without being wicked? You were very very kind, Mr. Miller, to ask me to have you; no other man
would have done it after what had happened; and I agreed, even though I did not feel half so warm as I ought. Yet it
was entirely owing to my believing him in the grave, as I knew that if he were not he would carry out his promise; and
this shows that I was right in trusting him.’

‘Yes . . . He must be a goodish sort of fellow,’ said Mr. Miller, for a moment so impressed with the
excellently faithful conduct of the sergeant-major of dragoons that he disregarded its effect upon his own position. He
sighed slowly and added, ‘Well, Selina, ’tis for you to say. I love you, and I love the boy; and there’s my
chimney-corner and sticks o’ furniture ready for ‘ee both.’

‘Yes, I know! But I mustn’t hear it any more now,’ murmured Selina quickly. ‘John will be here soon. I hope he’ll
see how it all was when I tell him. If so be I could have written it to him it would have been better.’

‘You think he doesn’t know a single word about our having been on the brink o’t. But perhaps it’s the other way —
he’s heard of it and that may have brought him.

‘If not, speak out straight and fair, and tell him exactly how it fell out. If he’s a man he’ll see it.’

‘O he’s a man true enough. But I really do think I shan’t have to tell him at all, since you’ve put it to me that
way!’

As it was now Johnny’s bedtime he was carried upstairs, and when Selina came down again her mother observed with
some anxiety, ‘I fancy Mr. Clark must be here soon if he’s coming; and that being so, perhaps Mr. Miller wouldn’t mind
— wishing us good-night! since you are so determined to stick to your sergeant-major.’ A little bitterness bubbled amid
the closing words. ‘It would be less awkward, Mr. Miller not being here — if he will allow me to say it.’

‘To be sure; to be sure,’ the master-wheelwright exclaimed with instant conviction, rising alertly from his chair.
‘Lord bless my soul,’ he said, taking up his hat and stick, ‘and we to have been married in six days! But Selina —
you’re right. You do belong to the child’s father since he’s alive. I’ll try to make the best of it.’

Before the generous Miller had got further there came a knock to the door accompanied by the noise of wheels.

‘I thought I heard something driving up!’ said Mrs Paddock.

They heard Mr. Paddock, who had been smoking in the room opposite, rise and go to the door, and in a moment a voice
familiar enough to Selina was audibly saying, ‘At last I am here again — not without many interruptions! How is it with
‘ee, Mr. Paddock? And how is she? Thought never to see me again, I suppose?’

A step with a clink of spurs in it struck upon the entry floor.

‘Danged if I bain’t catched!’ murmured Mr. Miller, forgetting company-speech. ‘Never mind — I may as well meet him
here as elsewhere; and I should like to see the chap, and make friends with en, as he seems one o’ the right sort.’ He
returned to the fireplace just as the sergeant-major was ushered in.

III

He was a good specimen of the long-service soldier of those days; a not unhandsome man, with a certain
undemonstrative dignity, which some might have said to be partly owing to the stiffness of his uniform about his neck,
the high stock being still worn. He was much stouter than when Selina had parted from him. Although she had not meant
to be demonstrative she ran across to him directly she saw him, and he held her in his arms and kissed her.

Then in much agitation she whispered something to him, at which he seemed to be much surprised.

‘He’s just put to bed,’ she continued. ‘You can go up and see him. I knew you’d come if you were alive! But I had
quite gi’d you up for dead. You’ve been home in England ever since the war ended?’

‘Yes, dear.’

‘Why didn’t you come sooner?’

‘That’s just what I ask myself! Why was I such a sappy as not to hurry here the first day I set foot on shore! Well,
who’d have thought it — you are as pretty as ever!’

He relinquished her to peep upstairs a little way, where, by looking through the ballusters, he could see Johnny’s
cot just within an open door. On his stepping down again Mr. Miller was preparing to depart.

‘Now, what’s this? I am sorry to see anybody going the moment I’ve come,’ expostulated the sergeant-major. ‘I
thought we might make an evening of it. There’s a nine gallon cask o’ “Phoenix” beer outside in the trap, and a ham,
and half a rawmil’ cheese; for I thought you might be short o’ forage in a lonely place like this; and it struck me we
might like to ask in a neighbour or two. But perhaps it would be taking a liberty?’

‘O no, not at all,’ said Mr. Paddock, who was now in the room, in a judicial measured manner. ‘Very thoughtful of
‘ee, only ’twas not necessary, for we had just laid in an extry stock of eatables and drinkables in preparation for the
coming event.’

‘’Twas very kind, upon my heart,’ said the soldier, ‘to think me worth such a jocund preparation, since you could
only have got my letter this morning.’

Selina gazed at her father to stop him, and exchanged embarrassed glances with Miller. Contrary to her hopes
Sergeant–Major Clark plainly did not know that the preparations referred to were for something quite other than his own
visit.

The movement of the horse outside, and the impatient tapping of a whip-handle upon the vehicle reminded them that
Clark’s driver was still in waiting. The provisions were brought into the house, and the cart dismissed. Miller, with
very little pressure indeed, accepted an invitation to supper, and a few neighbours were induced to come in to make up
a cheerful party.

During the laying of the meal, and throughout its continuance, Selina, who sat beside her first intended husband,
tried frequently to break the news to him of her engagement to the other — now terminated so suddenly, and so happily
for her heart, and her sense of womanly virtue. But the talk ran entirely upon the late war; and though fortified by
half a horn of the strong ale brought by the sergeant-major she decided that she might have a better opportunity when
supper was over of revealing the situation to him in private.

Having supped, Clark leaned back at ease in his chair and looked around. ‘We used sometimes to have a dance in that
other room after supper, Selina dear, I recollect. We used to clear out all the furniture into this room before
beginning. Have you kept up such goings on?’

‘No, not at all!’ said his sweetheart, sadly.

‘We were not unlikely to revive it in a few days,’ said Mr. Paddock. ‘But, howsomever, there’s seemingly many a
slip, as the saying is.’

‘Yes, I’ll tell John all about that by and by!’ interposed Selina; at which, perceiving that the secret which he did
not like keeping was to be kept even yet, her father held his tongue with some show of testiness.

The subject of a dance having been broached, to put the thought in practice was the feeling of all. Soon after the
tables and chairs were borne from the opposite room to this by zealous hands, and two of the villagers sent home for a
fiddle and tambourine, when the majority began to tread a measure well known in that secluded vale. Selina naturally
danced with the sergeant-major, not altogether to her father’s satisfaction, and to the real uneasiness of her mother,
both of whom would have preferred a postponement of festivities till the rashly anticipated relationship between their
daughter and Clark in the past had been made fact by the church’s ordinances. They did not, however, express a positive
objection, Mr. Paddock remembering, with self-reproach, that it was owing to his original strongly expressed
disapproval of Selina’s being a soldier’s wife that the wedding had been delayed, and finally hindered — with worse
consequences than were expected; and ever since the misadventure brought about by his government he had allowed events
to steer their own courses.

‘My tails will surely catch in your spurs, John!’ murmured the daughter of the house, as she whirled around upon his
arm with the rapt soul and look of a somnambulist. ‘I didn’t know we should dance, or I would have put on my other
frock.’

‘I’ll take care, my love. We’ve danced here before. Do you think your father objects to me now? I’ve risen in rank.
I fancy he’s still a little against me.’

‘He has repented, times enough.’

‘And so have I! If I had married you then ‘twould have saved many a misfortune. I have sometimes thought it might
have been possible to rush the ceremony through somehow before I left; though we were only in the second asking, were
we? And even if I had come back straight here when we returned from the Crimea, and married you then, how much happier
I should have been!’

‘Dear John, to say that! Why didn’t you?’

‘O— dilatoriness and want of thought, and a fear of facing your father after so long. I was in hospital a great
while, you know. But how familiar the place seems again! What’s that I saw on the beaufet in the other room? It never
used to be there. A sort of withered corpse of a cake — not an old bride-cake surely?’

‘Yes, John, ours. ’Tis the very one that was made for our wedding three years ago.’

‘Sakes alive! Why, time shuts up together, and all between then and now seems not to have been! What became of that
wedding-gown that they were making in this room, I remember — a bluish, whitish, frothy thing?’

‘I have that too.’

‘Really! . . . Why, Selina —’

‘Yes!’

‘Why not put it on now?’

‘Wouldn’t it seem —. And yet, O how I should like to! It would remind them all, if we told them what it was, how we
really meant to be married on that bygone day!’ Her eyes were again laden with wet.

‘Yes . . . The pity that we didn’t — the pity!’ Moody mournfulness seemed to hold silent awhile one not
naturally taciturn. ‘Well — will you?’ he said.

‘I will — the next dance, if mother don’t mind.’

Accordingly, just before the next figure was formed, Selina disappeared, and speedily came downstairs in a creased
and box-worn, but still airy and pretty, muslin gown, which was indeed the very one that had been meant to grace her as
a bride three years before.

‘It is dreadfully old-fashioned,’ she apologized.

‘Not at all. What a grand thought of mine! Now, let’s to’t again.’

She explained to some of them, as he led her to the second dance, what the frock had been meant for, and that she
had put it on at his request. And again athwart and around the room they went.

‘You seem the bride!’ he said.

‘But I couldn’t wear this gown to be married in now!’ she replied, ecstatically, ‘or I shouldn’t have put it on and
made it dusty. It is really too old-fashioned, and so folded and fretted out, you can’t think. That was with my taking
it out so many times to look at. I have never put it on — never — till now!’

‘Selina, I am thinking of giving up the army. Will you emigrate with me to New Zealand? I’ve an uncle out there
doing well, and he’d soon help me to making a larger income. The English army is glorious, but it ain’t altogether
enriching.’

‘Of course, anywhere that you decide upon. Is it healthy there for Johnny?’

‘A lovely climate. And I shall never be happy in England . . . Aha!’ he concluded again, with a bitterness
of unexpected strength, ‘would to Heaven I had come straight back here!’

As the dance brought round one neighbour after another the re-united pair were thrown into juxtaposition with Bob
Heartall among the rest who had been called in; one whose chronic expression was that he carried inside him a joke on
the point of bursting with its own vastness. He took occasion now to let out a little of its quality, shaking his head
at Selina as he addressed her in an undertone —

‘This is a bit of a topper to the bridegroom, ho ho! ’Twill teach en the liberty you’ll expect when you’ve married
en!’

‘What does he mean by a “topper,”’ the sergeant-major asked, who, not being of local extraction, despised the
venerable local language, and also seemed to suppose ‘bridegroom’ to be an anticipatory name for himself. ‘I only hope
I shall never be worse treated than you’ve treated me to-night!’

Selina looked frightened. ‘He didn’t mean you, dear,’ she said as they moved on. ‘We thought perhaps you knew what
had happened, owing to your coming just at this time. Had you — heard anything about — what I intended?’

‘Not a breath — how should I— away up in Yorkshire? It was by the merest accident that I came just at this date to
make peace with you for my delay.’

‘I was engaged to be married to Mr. Bartholomew Miller. That’s what it is! I would have let ‘ee know by letter, but
there was no time, only hearing from ‘ee this afternoon . . . You won’t desert me for it, will you, John?
Because, as you know, I quite supposed you dead, and — and —’ Her eyes were full of tears of trepidation, and he might
have felt a sob heaving within her.

IV

The soldier was silent during two or three double bars of the tune. ‘When were you to have been married to the said
Mr. Bartholomew Miller?’ he inquired.

‘Quite soon.’

‘How soon?’

‘Next week — O yes — just the same as it was with you and me. There’s a strange fate of interruption hanging over
me, I sometimes think! He had bought the licence, which I preferred so that it mightn’t be like — ours. But it made no
difference to the fate of it.’

‘Had bought the licence! The devil!’

‘Don’t be angry, dear John. I didn’t know!’

‘No, no, I’m not angry.’

‘It was so kind of him, considering!’

‘Yes . . . I see, of course, how natural your action was — never thinking of seeing me any more! Is it the
Mr. Miller who is in this dance?’

‘Yes.’

Clark glanced round upon Bartholomew and was silent again, for some little while, and she stole a look at him, to
find that he seemed changed. ‘John, you look ill!’ she almost sobbed. ‘‘Tisn’t me, is it?’

‘O dear, no. Though I hadn’t, somehow, expected it. I can’t find fault with you for a moment — and I don’t
. . . This is a deuce of a long dance, don’t you think? We’ve been at it twenty minutes if a second, and the
figure doesn’t allow one much rest. I’m quite out of breath.’

‘They like them so dreadfully long here. Shall we drop out? Or I’ll stop the fiddler.’

‘O no, no, I think I can finish. But although I look healthy enough I have never been so strong as I formerly was,
since that long illness I had in the hospital at Scutari.’

‘And I knew nothing about it!’

‘You couldn’t, dear, as I didn’t write. What a fool I have been altogether!’ He gave a twitch, as of one in pain. ‘I
won’t dance again when this one is over. The fact is I have travelled a long way today, and it seems to have knocked me
up a bit.’

There could be no doubt that the sergeant-major was unwell, and Selina made herself miserable by still believing
that her story was the cause of his ailment. Suddenly he said in a changed voice, and she perceived that he was paler
than ever: ‘I must sit down.’

Letting go her waist he went quickly to the other room. She followed, and found him in the nearest chair, his face
bent down upon his hands and arms, which were resting on the table.

‘What’s the matter?’ said her father, who sat there dozing by the fire.

‘John isn’t well . . . We are going to New Zealand when we are married, father. A lovely country! John,
would you like something to drink?’

‘A drop o’ that Schiedam of old Owlett’s, that’s under stairs, perhaps,’ suggested her father. ‘Not that nowadays
’tis much better than licensed liquor.’

‘John,’ she said, putting her face close to his and pressing his arm. ‘Will you have a drop of spirits or
something?’

He did not reply, and Selina observed that his ear and the side of his face were quite white. Convinced that his
illness was serious, a growing dismay seized hold of her. The dance ended; her mother came in, and learning what had
happened, looked narrowly at the sergeant-major.

‘We must not let him lie like that, lift him up,’ she said. ‘Let him rest in the window-bench on some cushions.’

They unfolded his arms and hands as they lay clasped upon the table, and on lifting his head found his features to
bear the very impress of death itself. Bartholomew Miller, who had now come in, assisted Mr. Paddock to make a
comfortable couch in the window-seat, where they stretched out Clark upon his back.

Still he seemed unconscious. ‘We must get a doctor,’ said Selina. ‘O, my dear John, how is it you be taken like
this?’

There were plenty to volunteer to go for a doctor, but as it would be at least an hour before he could get there the
case seemed somewhat hopeless. The dancing-party ended as unceremoniously as it had begun; but the guests lingered
round the premises till the doctor should arrive. When he did come the sergeant-major’s extremities were already cold,
and there was no doubt that death had overtaken him almost at the moment that he had sat down.

The medical practitioner quite refused to accept the unhappy Selina’s theory that her revelation had in any way
induced Clark’s sudden collapse. Both he and the coroner afterwards, who found the immediate cause to be heart-failure,
held that such a supposition was unwarranted by facts. They asserted that a long day’s journey, a hurried drive, and
then an exhausting dance, were sufficient for such a result upon a heart enfeebled by fatty degeneration after the
privations of a Crimean winter and other trying experiences, the coincidence of the sad event with any disclosure of
hers being a pure accident.

This conclusion, however, did not dislodge Selina’s opinion that the shock of her statement had been the immediate
stroke which had felled a constitution so undermined.

V

At this date the Casterbridge Barracks were cavalry quarters, their adaptation to artillery having been effected
some years later. It had been owing to the fact that the —— th Dragoons, in which John Clark had served, happened to be
lying there that Selina made his acquaintance. At the time of his death the barracks were occupied by the Scots Greys,
but when the pathetic circumstances of the sergeant-major’s end became known in the town the officers of the Greys
offered the services of their fine reed and brass band, that he might have a funeral marked by due military honours.
His body was accordingly removed to the barracks, and carried thence to the churchyard in the Durnover quarter on the
following afternoon, one of the Greys’ most ancient and docile chargers being blacked up to represent Clark’s horse on
the occasion.

Everybody pitied Selina, whose story was well known. She followed the corpse as the only mourner, Clark having been
without relations in this part of the country, and a communication with his regiment having brought none from a
distance. She sat in a little shabby brown-black mourning carriage, squeezing herself up in a corner to be as much as
possible out of sight during the slow and dramatic march through the town to the tune from Saul. When the interment had
taken place, the volleys been fired, and the return journey begun, it was with something like a shock that she found
the military escort to be moving at a quick march to the lively strains of ‘Off she goes!’ as if all care for the
sergeant-major was expected to be ended with the late discharge of the carbines. It was, by chance, the very tune to
which they had been footing when he died, and unable to bear its notes, she hastily told her driver to drop behind. The
band and military party diminished up the High Street, and Selina turned over Swan bridge and homeward to
Mellstock.

Then recommenced for her a life whose incidents were precisely of a suit with those which had preceded the soldier’s
return; but how different in her appreciation of them! Her narrow miss of the recovered respectability they had hoped
for from that tardy event worked upon her parents as an irritant, and after the first week or two of her mourning her
life with them grew almost insupportable. She had impulsively taken to herself the weeds of a widow, for such she
seemed to herself to be, and clothed little Johnny in sables likewise. This assumption of a moral relationship to the
deceased, which she asserted to be only not a legal one by two most unexpected accidents, led the old people to indulge
in sarcasm at her expense whenever they beheld her attire, though all the while it cost them more pain to utter than it
gave her to hear it. Having become accustomed by her residence at home to the business carried on by her father, she
surprised them one day by going off with the child to Chalk–Newton, in the direction of the town of Ivell, and opening
a miniature fruit and vegetable shop, attending Ivell market with her produce. Her business grew somewhat larger, and
it was soon sufficient to enable her to support herself and the boy in comfort. She called herself ‘Mrs. John Clark’
from the day of leaving home, and painted the name on her signboard — no man forbidding her.

By degrees the pain of her state was forgotten in her new circumstances, and getting to be generally accepted as the
widow of a sergeant-major of dragoons — an assumption which her modest and mournful demeanour seemed to substantiate —
her life became a placid one, her mind being nourished by the melancholy luxury of dreaming what might have been her
future in New Zealand with John, if he had only lived to take her there. Her only travels now were a journey to Ivell
on market-days, and once a fortnight to the churchyard in which Clark lay, there to tend, with Johnny’s assistance, as
widows are wont to do, the flowers she had planted upon his grave.

On a day about eighteen months after his unexpected decease, Selina was surprised in her lodging over her little
shop by a visit from Bartholomew Miller. He had called on her once or twice before, on which occasions he had used
without a word of comment the name by which she was known.

‘I’ve come this time,’ he said, ‘less because I was in this direction than to ask you, Mrs. Clark, what you mid well
guess. I’ve come o’ purpose, in short.’

She smiled.

‘’Tis to ask me again to marry you?’

‘Yes, of course. You see, his coming back for ‘ee proved what I always believed of ‘ee, though others didn’t.
There’s nobody but would be glad to welcome you to our parish again, now you’ve showed your independence and acted up
to your trust in his promise. Well, my dear, will you come?’

‘I’d rather bide as Mrs. Clark, I think,’ she answered. ‘I am not ashamed of my position at all; for I am John’s
widow in the eyes of Heaven.’

‘I quite agree — that’s why I’ve come. Still, you won’t like to be always straining at this shop-keeping and
market-standing; and ‘twould be better for Johnny if you had nothing to do but tend him.’

He here touched the only weak spot in Selina’s resistance to his proposal — the good of the boy. To promote that
there were other men she might have married offhand without loving them if they had asked her to; but though she had
known the worthy speaker from her youth, she could not for the moment fancy herself happy as Mrs. Miller.

He paused awhile. ‘I ought to tell ‘ee, Mrs. Clark,’ he said by and by, ‘that marrying is getting to be a pressing
question with me. Not on my own account at all. The truth is, that mother is growing old, and I am away from home a
good deal, so that it is almost necessary there should be another person in the house with her besides me. That’s the
practical consideration which forces me to think of taking a wife, apart from my wish to take you; and you know there’s
nobody in the world I care for so much.’

She said something about there being far better women than she, and other natural commonplaces; but assured him she
was most grateful to him for feeling what he felt, as indeed she sincerely was. However, Selina would not consent to be
the useful third person in his comfortable home — at any rate just then. He went away, after taking tea with her,
without discerning much hope for him in her good-bye.

VI

After that evening she saw and heard nothing of him for a great while. Her fortnightly journeys to the
sergeant-major’s grave were continued, whenever weather did not hinder them; and Mr. Miller must have known, she
thought, of this custom of hers. But though the churchyard was not nearly so far from his homestead as was her shop at
Chalk–Newton, he never appeared in the accidental way that lovers use.

An explanation was forthcoming in the shape of a letter from her mother, who casually mentioned that Mr. Bartholomew
Miller had gone away to the other side of Shottsford–Forum to be married to a thriving dairyman’s daughter that he knew
there. His chief motive, it was reported, had been less one of love than a wish to provide a companion for his aged
mother.

Selina was practical enough to know that she had lost a good and possibly the only opportunity of settling in life
after what had happened, and for a moment she regretted her independence. But she became calm on reflection, and to
fortify herself in her course started that afternoon to tend the sergeant-major’s grave, in which she took the same
sober pleasure as at first.

On reaching the churchyard and turning the corner towards the spot as usual, she was surprised to perceive another
woman, also apparently a respectable widow, and with a tiny boy by her side, bending over Clark’s turf, and spudding up
with the point of her umbrella some ivy-roots that Selina had reverently planted there to form an evergreen mantle over
the mound.

‘What are you digging up my ivy for!’ cried Selina, rushing forward so excitedly that Johnny tumbled over a grave
with the force of the tug she gave his hand in her sudden start.

‘Your ivy?’ said the respectable woman.

‘Why yes! I planted it there — on my husband’s grave.’

‘Your husband’s!’

‘Yes. The late Sergeant–Major Clark. Anyhow, as good as my husband, for he was just going to be.’

‘Indeed. But who may be my husband, if not he? I am the only Mrs. John Clark, widow of the late Sergeant–Major of
Dragoons, and this is his only son and heir.’

‘How can that be?’ faltered Selina, her throat seeming to stick together as she just began to perceive its
possibility. ‘He had been — going to marry me twice — and we were going to New Zealand.’

‘Ah! — I remember about you,’ returned the legitimate widow calmly and not unkindly. ‘You must be Selina; he spoke
of you now and then, and said that his relations with you would always be a weight on his conscience. Well; the history
of my life with him is soon told. When he came back from the Crimea he became acquainted with me at my home in the
north, and we were married within a month of first knowing each other. Unfortunately, after living together a few
months, we could not agree; and after a particularly sharp quarrel, in which, perhaps, I was most in the wrong — as I
don’t mind owning here by his graveside — he went away from me, declaring he would buy his discharge and emigrate to
New Zealand, and never come back to me any more. The next thing I heard was that he had died suddenly at Mellstock at
some low carouse; and as he had left me in such anger to live no more with me, I wouldn’t come down to his funeral, or
do anything in relation to him. ’Twas temper, I know, but that was the fact. Even if we had parted friends it would
have been a serious expense to travel three hundred miles to get there, for one who wasn’t left so very well off
. . . I am sorry I pulled up your ivy-roots; but that common sort of ivy is considered a weed in my part of
the country.’

December 1899.

A Tryst at an Ancient Earth Work

At one’s every step forward it rises higher against the south sky, with an obtrusive personality that compels the
senses to regard it and consider. The eyes may bend in another direction, but never without the consciousness of its
heavy, high-shouldered presence at its point of vantage. Across the intervening levels the gale races in a straight
line from the fort, as if breathed out of it hitherward. With the shifting of the clouds the faces of the steeps vary
in colour and in shade, broad lights appearing where mist and vagueness had prevailed, dissolving in their turn into
melancholy gray, which spreads over and eclipses the luminous bluffs. In this so-thought immutable spectacle all is
change.

Out of the invisible marine region on the other side birds soar suddenly into the air, and hang over the summits of
the heights with the indifference of long familiarity. Their forms are white against the tawny concave of cloud, and
the curves they exhibit in their floating signify that they are sea-gulls which have journeyed inland from expected
stress of weather. As the birds rise behind the fort, so do the clouds rise behind the birds, almost as it seems,
stroking with their bagging bosoms the uppermost flyers.

The profile of the whole stupendous ruin, as seen at a distance of a mile eastward, is cleanly cut as that of a
marble inlay. It is varied with protuberances, which from hereabouts have the animal aspect of warts, wens, knuckles,
and hips. It may indeed be likened to an enormous many-limbed organism of an antediluvian time — partaking of the
cephalopod in shape — lying lifeless, and covered with a thin green cloth, which hides its substance, while revealing
its contour. This dull green mantle of herbage stretches down towards the levels, where the ploughs have essayed for
centuries to creep up near and yet nearer to the base of the castle, but have always stopped short before reaching it.
The furrows of these environing attempts show themselves distinctly, bending to the incline as they trench upon it;
mounting in steeper curves, till the steepness baffles them, and their parallel threads show like the striae of waves
pausing on the curl. The peculiar place of which these are some of the features is ‘Mai–Dun,’ ‘The Castle of the Great
Hill,’ said to be the Dunium of Ptolemy, the capital of the Durotriges, which eventually came into Roman occupation,
and was finally deserted on their withdrawal from the island.

* * * *

The evening is followed by a night on which an invisible moon bestows a subdued, yet pervasive light — without
radiance, as without blackness. From the spot whereon I am ensconced in a cottage, a mile away, the fort has now ceased
to be visible; yet, as by day, to anybody whose thoughts have been engaged with it and its barbarous grandeurs of past
time the form asserts its existence behind the night gauzes as persistently as if it had a voice. Moreover, the
south-west wind continues to feed the intervening arable flats with vapours brought directly from its sides.

The midnight hour for which there has been occasion to wait at length arrives, and I journey towards the stronghold
in obedience to a request urged earlier in the day. It concerns an appointment, which I rather regret my decision to
keep now that night is come. The route thither is hedgeless and treeless — I need not add deserted. The moonlight is
sufficient to disclose the pale riband-like surface of the way as it trails along between the expanses of darker
fallow. Though the road passes near the fortress it does not conduct directly to its fronts. As the place is without an
inhabitant, so it is without a trackway. So presently leaving the macadamized road to pursue its course elsewhither, I
step off upon the fallow, and plod stumblingly across it. The castle looms out off the shade by degrees, like a thing
waking up and asking what I want there. It is now so enlarged by nearness that its whole shape cannot be taken in at
one view. The ploughed ground ends as the rise sharpens, the sloping basement of grass begins, and I climb upward to
invade Mai–Dun.

Impressive by day as this largest Ancient–British work in the kingdom undoubtedly is, its impressiveness is
increased now. After standing still and spending a few minutes in adding its age to its size, and its size to its
solitude, it becomes appallingly mournful in its growing closeness. A squally wind blows in the face with an impact
which proclaims that the vapours of the air sail low to-night. The slope that I so laboriously clamber up the wind
skips sportively down. Its track can be discerned even in this light by the undulations of the withered grass-bents —
the only produce of this upland summit except moss. Four minutes of ascent, and a vantage-ground of some sort is
gained. It is only the crest of the outer rampart. Immediately within this a chasm gapes; its bottom is imperceptible,
but the counterscarp slopes not too steeply to admit of a sliding descent if cautiously performed. The shady bottom,
dank and chilly, is thus gained, and reveals itself as a kind of winding lane, wide enough for a waggon to pass along,
floored with rank herbage, and trending away, right and left, into obscurity, between the concentric walls of earth.
The towering closeness of these on each hand, their impenetrability, and their ponderousness, are felt as a physical
pressure. The way is now up the second of them, which stands steeper and higher than the first. To turn aside, as did
Christian’s companion, from such a Hill Difficulty, is the more natural tendency; but the way to the interior is
upward. There is, of course, an entrance to the fortress; but that lies far off on the other side. It might possibly
have been the wiser course to seek for easier ingress there.

However, being here, I ascend the second acclivity. The grass stems — the grey beard of the hill — sway in a mass
close to my stooping face. The dead heads of these various grasses — fescues, fox-tails, and ryes — bob and twitch as
if pulled by a string underground. From a few thistles a whistling proceeds; and even the moss speaks, in its humble
way, under the stress of the blast.

That the summit of the second line of defence has been gained is suddenly made known by a contrasting wind from a
new quarter, coming over with the curve of a cascade. These novel gusts raise a sound from the whole camp or castle,
playing upon it bodily as upon a harp. It is with some difficulty that a foothold can be preserved under their sweep.
Looking aloft for a moment I perceive that the sky is much more overcast than it has been hitherto, and in a few
instants a dead lull in what is now a gale ensues with almost preternatural abruptness. I take advantage of this to
sidle down the second counterscarp, but by the time the ditch is reached the lull reveals itself to be but the
precursor of a storm. It begins with a heave of the whole atmosphere, like the sigh of a weary strong man on turning to
re-commence unusual exertion, just as I stand here in the second fosse. That which now radiates from the sky upon the
scene is not so much light as vaporous phosphorescence.

The wind, quickening, abandons the natural direction it has pursued on the open upland, and takes the course of the
gorge’s length, rushing along therein helter-skelter, and carrying thick rain upon its back. The rain is followed by
hailstones which fly through the defile in battalions — rolling, hopping, ricochetting, snapping, clattering down the
shelving banks in an undefinable haze of confusion. The earthen sides of the fosse seem to quiver under the drenching
onset, though it is practically no more to them than the blows of Thor upon the giant of Jotun-land. It is impossible
to proceed further till the storm somewhat abates, and I draw up behind a spur of the inner scarp, where possibly a
barricade stood two thousand years ago; and thus await events.

* * * *

The roar of the storm can be heard travelling the complete circuit of the castle — a measured mile — coming round at
intervals like a circumambulating column of infantry. Doubtless such a column has passed this way in its time, but the
only columns which enter in these latter days are the columns of sheep and oxen that are sometimes seen here now; while
the only semblance of heroic voices heard are the utterances of such, and of the many winds which make their passage
through the ravines.

The expected lightning radiates round, and a rumbling as from its subterranean vaults — if there are any — fills the
castle. The lightning repeats itself, and, coming after the aforesaid thoughts of martial men, it bears a fanciful
resemblance to swords moving in combat. It has the very brassy hue of the ancient weapons that here were used. The so
sudden entry upon the scene of this metallic flame is as the entry of a presiding exhibitor who unrolls the maps,
uncurtains the pictures, unlocks the cabinets, and effects a transformation by merely exposing the materials of his
science, unintelligibly cloaked till then. The abrupt configuration of the bluffs and mounds is now for the first time
clearly revealed — mounds whereon, doubtless, spears and shields have frequently lain while their owners loosened their
sandals and yawned and stretched their arms in the sun. For the first time, too, a glimpse is obtainable of the true
entrance used by its occupants of old, some way ahead.

There, where all passage has seemed to be inviolably barred by an almost vertical facade, the ramparts are found to
overlap each other like loosely clasped fingers, between which a zigzag path may be followed — a cunning construction
that puzzles the uninformed eye. But its cunning, even where not obscured by dilapidation, is now wasted on the
solitary forms of a few wild badgers, rabbits, and hares. Men must have often gone out by those gates in the morning to
battle with the Roman legions under Vespasian; some to return no more, others to come back at evening, bringing with
them the noise of their heroic deeds. But not a page, not a stone, has preserved their fame.

* * * *

Acoustic perceptions multiply to-night. We can almost hear the stream of years that have borne those deeds away from
us. Strange articulations seem to float on the air from that point, the gateway, where the animation in past times must
frequently have concentrated itself at hours of coming and going, and general excitement. There arises an ineradicable
fancy that they are human voices; if so, they must be the lingering air-borne vibrations of conversations uttered at
least fifteen hundred years ago. The attention is attracted from mere nebulous imaginings about yonder spot by a real
moving of something close at hand.

I recognize by the now moderate flashes of lightning, which are sheet-like and nearly continuous, that it is the
gradual elevation of a small mound of earth. At first no larger than a man’s fist it reaches the dimensions of a hat,
then sinks a little and is still. It is but the heaving of a mole who chooses such weather as this to work in from some
instinct that there will be nobody abroad to molest him. As the fine earth lifts and lifts and falls loosely aside
fragments of burnt clay roll out of it — clay that once formed part of cups or other vessels used by the inhabitants of
the fortress.

The violence of the storm has been counterbalanced by its transitoriness. From being immersed in well-nigh solid
media of cloud and hail shot with lightning, I find myself uncovered of the humid investiture and left bare to the mild
gaze of the moon, which sparkles now on every wet grass-blade and frond of moss.

But I am not yet inside the fort, and the delayed ascent of the third and last escarpment is now made. It is steeper
than either. The first was a surface to walk up, the second to stagger up, the third can only be ascended on the hands
and toes. On the summit obtrudes the first evidence which has been met with in these precincts that the time is really
the nineteenth century; it is in the form of a white notice-board on a post, and the wording can just be discerned by
the rays of the setting moon:

CAUTION. — Any Person found removing Relics, Skeletons, Stones, Pottery, Tiles, or other Material from this
Earthwork, or cutting up the Ground, will be Prosecuted as the Law directs.

Here one observes a difference underfoot from what has gone before: scraps of Roman tile and stone chippings
protrude through the grass in meagre quantity, but sufficient to suggest that masonry stood on the spot. Before the eye
stretches under the moonlight the interior of the fort. So open and so large is it as to be practically an upland
plateau, and yet its area lies wholly within the walls of what may be designated as one building. It is a long-violated
retreat; all its corner-stones, plinths, and architraves were carried away to build neighbouring villages even before
mediaeval or modern history began. Many a block which once may have helped to form a bastion here rests now in broken
and diminished shape as part of the chimney-corner of some shepherd’s cottage within the distant horizon, and the
corner-stones of this heathen altar may form the base-course of some adjoining village church.

Yet the very bareness of these inner courts and wards, their condition of mere pasturage, protects what remains of
them as no defences could do. Nothing is left visible that the hands can seize on or the weather overturn, and a
permanence of general outline at least results, which no other condition could ensure.

The position of the castle on this isolated hill bespeaks deliberate and strategic choice exercised by some remote
mind capable of prospective reasoning to a far extent. The natural configuration of the surrounding country and its
bearing upon such a stronghold were obviously long considered and viewed mentally before its extensive design was
carried into execution. Who was the man that said, ‘Let it be built here!’— not on that hill yonder, or on that ridge
behind, but on this best spot of all? Whether he were some great one of the Belgae, or of the Durotriges, or the
travelling engineer of Britain’s united tribes, must for ever remain time’s secret; his form cannot be realized, nor
his countenance, nor the tongue that he spoke, when he set down his foot with a thud and said, ‘Let it be here!’

Within the innermost enclosure, though it is so wide that at a superficial glance the beholder has only a sense of
standing on a breezy down, the solitude is rendered yet more solitary by the knowledge that between the benighted
sojourner herein and all kindred humanity are those three concentric walls of earth which no being would think of
scaling on such a night as this, even were he to hear the most pathetic cries issuing hence that could be uttered by a
spectre-chased soul. I reach a central mound or platform — the crown and axis of the whole structure. The view from
here by day must be of almost limitless extent. On this raised floor, dais, or rostrum, harps have probably twanged
more or less tuneful notes in celebration of daring, strength, or cruelty; of worship, superstition, love, birth, and
death; of simple loving-kindness perhaps never. Many a time must the king or leader have directed his keen eyes hence
across the open lands towards the ancient road, the Icening Way, still visible in the distance, on the watch for armed
companies approaching either to succour or to attack.

I am startled by a voice pronouncing my name. Past and present have become so confusedly mingled under the
associations of the spot that for a time it has escaped my memory that this mound was the place agreed on for the
aforesaid appointment. I turn and behold my friend. He stands with a dark lantern in his hand and a spade and light
pickaxe over his shoulder. He expresses both delight and surprise that I have come. I tell him I had set out before the
bad weather began.

He, to whom neither weather, darkness, nor difficulty seems to have any relation or significance, so entirely is his
soul wrapped up in his own deep intentions, asks me to take the lantern and accompany him. I take it and walk by his
side. He is a man about sixty, small in figure, with grey old-fashioned whiskers cut to the shape of a pair of
crumb-brushes. He is entirely in black broadcloth — or rather, at present, black and brown, for he is bespattered with
mud from his heels to the crown of his low hat. He has no consciousness of this — no sense of anything but his purpose,
his ardour for which causes his eyes to shine like those of a lynx, and gives his motions, all the elasticity of an
athlete’s.

‘Nobody to interrupt us at this time of night!’ he chuckles with fierce enjoyment.

We retreat a little way and find a sort of angle, an elevation in the sod, a suggested squareness amid the mass of
irregularities around. Here, he tells me, if anywhere, the king’s house stood. Three months of measurement and
calculation have confirmed him in this conclusion.

He requests me now to open the lantern, which I do, and the light streams out upon the wet sod. At last divining his
proceedings I say that I had no idea, in keeping the tryst, that he was going to do more at such an unusual time than
meet me for a meditative ramble through the stronghold. I ask him why, having a practicable object, he should have
minded interruptions and not have chosen the day? He informs me, quietly pointing to his spade, that it was because his
purpose is to dig, then signifying with a grim nod the gaunt notice-post against the sky beyond. I inquire why, as a
professed and well-known antiquary with capital letters at the tail of his name, he did not obtain the necessary
authority, considering the stringent penalties for this sort of thing; and he chuckles fiercely again with suppressed
delight, and says, ‘Because they wouldn’t have given it!’

He at once begins cutting up the sod, and, as he takes the pickaxe to follow on with, assures me that, penalty or no
penalty, honest men or marauders, he is sure of one thing, that we shall not be disturbed at our work till after
dawn.

I remember to have heard of men who, in their enthusiasm for some special science, art, or hobby, have quite lost
the moral sense which would restrain them from indulging it illegitimately; and I conjecture that here, at last, is an
instance of such an one. He probably guesses the way my thoughts travel, for he stands up and solemnly asserts that he
has a distinctly justifiable intention in this matter; namely, to uncover, to search, to verify a theory or displace
it, and to cover up again. He means to take away nothing — not a grain of sand. In this he says he sees no such
monstrous sin. I inquire if this is really a promise to me? He repeats that it is a promise, and resumes digging. My
contribution to the labour is that of directing the light constantly upon the hole. When he has reached something more
than a foot deep he digs more cautiously, saying that, be it much or little there, it will not lie far below the
surface; such things never are deep. A few minutes later the point of the pickaxe clicks upon a stony substance. He
draws the implement out as feelingly as if it had entered a man’s body. Taking up the spade he shovels with care, and a
surface, level as an altar, is presently disclosed. His eyes flash anew; he pulls handfuls of grass and mops the
surface clean, finally rubbing it with his handkerchief. Grasping the lantern from my hand he holds it close to the
ground, when the rays reveal a complete mosaic — a pavement of minute tesserae of many colours, of intricate pattern, a
work of much art, of much time, and of much industry. He exclaims in a shout that he knew it always — that it is not a
Celtic stronghold exclusively, but also a Roman; the former people having probably contributed little more than the
original framework which the latter took and adapted till it became the present imposing structure.

I ask, What if it is Roman?

A great deal, according to him. That it proves all the world to be wrong in this great argument, and himself alone
to be right! Can I wait while he digs further?

I agree — reluctantly; but he does not notice my reluctance. At an adjoining spot he begins flourishing the tools
anew with the skill of a navvy, this venerable scholar with letters after his name. Sometimes he falls on his knees,
burrowing with his hands in the manner of a hare, and where his old-fashioned broadcloth touches the sides of the hole
it gets plastered with the damp earth. He continually murmurs to himself how important, how very important, this
discovery is! He draws out an object; we wash it in the same primitive way by rubbing it with the wet grass, and it
proves to be a semi-transparent bottle of iridescent beauty, the sight of which draws groans of luxurious sensibility
from the digger. Further and further search brings out a piece of a weapon. It is strange indeed that by merely peeling
off a wrapper of modern accumulations we have lowered ourselves into an ancient world. Finally a skeleton is uncovered,
fairly perfect. He lays it out on the grass, bone to its bone.

My friend says the man must have fallen fighting here, as this is no place of burial. He turns again to the trench,
scrapes, feels, till from a corner he draws out a heavy lump — a small image four or five inches high. We clean it as
before. It is a statuette, apparently of gold, or, more probably, of bronze-gilt — a figure of Mercury, obviously, its
head being surmounted with the petasus or winged hat, the usual accessory of that deity. Further inspection reveals the
workmanship to be of good finish and detail, and, preserved by the limy earth, to be as fresh in every line as on the
day it left the hands of its artificer.

We seem to be standing in the Roman Forum and not on a hill in Wessex. Intent upon this truly valuable relic of the
old empire of which even this remote spot was a component part, we do not notice what is going on in the present world
till reminded of it by the sudden renewal of the storm. Looking up I perceive that the wide extinguisher of cloud has
again settled down upon the fortress-town, as if resting upon the edge of the inner rampart, and shutting out the moon.
I turn my back to the tempest, still directing the light across the hole. My companion digs on unconcernedly; he is
living two thousand years ago, and despises things of the moment as dreams. But at last he is fairly beaten, and
standing up beside me looks round on what he has done. The rays of the lantern pass over the trench to the tall
skeleton stretched upon the grass on the other side. The beating rain has washed the bones clean and smooth, and the
forehead, cheek-bones, and two-and-thirty teeth of the skull glisten in the candle-shine as they lie.

This storm, like the first, is of the nature of a squall, and it ends as abruptly as the other. We dig no further.
My friend says that it is enough — he has proved his point. He turns to replace the bones in the trench and covers
them. But they fall to pieces under his touch: the air has disintegrated them, and he can only sweep in the fragments.
The next act of his plan is more than difficult, but is carried out. The treasures are inhumed again in their
respective holes: they are not ours. Each deposition seems to cost him a twinge; and at one moment I fancied I saw him
slip his hand into his coat pocket.

‘We must re-bury them all,’ say I.

‘O yes,’ he answers with integrity. ‘I was wiping my hand.’

The beauties of the tesselated floor of the governor’s house are once again consigned to darkness; the trench is
filled up; the sod laid smoothly down; he wipes the perspiration from his forehead with the same handkerchief he had
used to mop the skeleton and tesserae clean; and we make for the eastern gate of the fortress.

Dawn bursts upon us suddenly as we reach the opening. It comes by the lifting and thinning of the clouds that way
till we are bathed in a pink light. The direction of his homeward journey is not the same as mine, and we part under
the outer slope.

Walking along quickly to restore warmth I muse upon my eccentric friend, and cannot help asking myself this
question: Did he really replace the gilded image of the god Mercurius with the rest of the treasures? He seemed to do
so; and yet I could not testify to the fact. Probably, however, he was as good as his word.

* * * *

It was thus I spoke to myself, and so the adventure ended. But one thing remains to be told, and that is concerned
with seven years after. Among the effects of my friend, at that time just deceased, was found, carefully preserved, a
gilt statuette representing Mercury, labelled ‘Debased Roman.’ No record was attached to explain how it came into his
possession. The figure was bequeathed to the Casterbridge Museum.

Detroit Post,

March 1885.

What the Shepherd Saw: A Tale of Four Moonlight Nights

The genial Justice of the Peace — now, alas, no more — who made himself responsible for the facts of this story,
used to begin in the good old-fashioned way with a bright moonlight night and a mysterious figure, an excellent stroke
for an opening, even to this day, if well followed up.

The Christmas moon (he would say) was showing her cold face to the upland, the upland reflecting the radiance in
frost-sparkles so minute as only to be discernible by an eye near at hand. This eye, he said, was the eye of a shepherd
lad, young for his occupation, who stood within a wheeled hut of the kind commonly in use among sheep-keepers during
the early lambing season, and was abstractedly looking through the loophole at the scene without.

The spot was called Lambing Corner, and it was a sheltered portion of that wide expanse of rough pastureland known
as the Marlbury Downs, which you directly traverse when following the turnpike-road across Mid–Wessex from London,
through Aldbrickham, in the direction of Bath and Bristol. Here, where the hut stood, the land was high and dry, open,
except to the north, and commanding an undulating view for miles. On the north side grew a tall belt of coarse furze,
with enormous stalks, a clump of the same standing detached in front of the general mass. The clump was hollow, and the
interior had been ingeniously taken advantage of as a position for the before-mentioned hut, which was thus completely
screened from winds, and almost invisible, except through the narrow approach. But the furze twigs had been cut away
from the two little windows of the hut, that the occupier might keep his eye on his sheep.

In the rear, the shelter afforded by the belt of furze bushes was artificially improved by an inclosure of upright
stakes, interwoven with boughs of the same prickly vegetation, and within the inclosure lay a renowned Marlbury–Down
breeding flock of eight hundred ewes.

To the south, in the direction of the young shepherd’s idle gaze, there rose one conspicuous object above the
uniform moonlit plateau, and only one. It was a Druidical trilithon, consisting of three oblong stones in the form of a
doorway, two on end, and one across as a lintel. Each stone had been worn, scratched, washed, nibbled, split, and
otherwise attacked by ten thousand different weathers; but now the blocks looked shapely and little the worse for wear,
so beautifully were they silvered over by the light of the moon. The ruin was locally called the Devil’s Door.

An old shepherd presently entered the hut from the direction of the ewes, and looked around in the gloom. ‘Be ye
sleepy?’ he asked in cross accents of the boy.

The lad replied rather timidly in the negative.

‘Then,’ said the shepherd, ‘I’ll get me home-along, and rest for a few hours. There’s nothing to be done here now as
I can see. The ewes can want no more tending till daybreak —’tis beyond the bounds of reason that they can. But as the
order is that one of us must bide, I’ll leave ‘ee, d’ye hear. You can sleep by day, and I can’t. And you can be down to
my house in ten minutes if anything should happen. I can’t afford ‘ee candle; but, as ’tis Christmas week, and the time
that folks have hollerdays, you can enjoy yerself by falling asleep a bit in the chair instead of biding awake all the
time. But mind, not longer at once than while the shade of the Devil’s Door moves a couple of spans, for you must keep
an eye upon the ewes.’

The boy made no definite reply, and the old man, stirring the fire in the stove with his crook-stem, closed the door
upon his companion and vanished.

As this had been more or less the course of events every night since the season’s lambing had set in, the boy was
not at all surprised at the charge, and amused himself for some time by lighting straws at the stove. He then went out
to the ewes and new-born lambs, re-entered, sat down, and finally fell asleep. This was his customary manner of
performing his watch, for though special permission for naps had this week been accorded, he had, as a matter of fact,
done the same thing on every preceding night, sleeping often till awakened by a smack on the shoulder at three or four
in the morning from the crook-stem of the old man.

It might have been about eleven o’clock when he awoke. He was so surprised at awaking without, apparently, being
called or struck, that on second thoughts he assumed that somebody must have called him in spite of appearances, and
looked out of the hut window towards the sheep. They all lay as quiet as when he had visited them, very little bleating
being audible, and no human soul disturbing the scene. He next looked from the opposite window, and here the case was
different. The frost-facets glistened under the moon as before; an occasional furze bush showed as a dark spot on the
same; and in the foreground stood the ghostly form of the trilithon. But in front of the trilithon stood a man.

That he was not the shepherd or any one of the farm labourers was apparent in a moment’s observation — his dress
being a dark suit, and his figure of slender build and graceful carriage. He walked backwards and forwards in front of
the trilithon.

The shepherd lad had hardly done speculating on the strangeness of the unknown’s presence here at such an hour, when
he saw a second figure crossing the open sward towards the locality of the trilithon and furze-clump that screened the
hut. This second personage was a woman; and immediately on sight of her the male stranger hastened forward, meeting her
just in front of the hut window. Before she seemed to be aware of his intention he clasped her in his arms.

The lady released herself and drew back with some dignity.

‘You have come, Harriet — bless you for it!’ he exclaimed, fervently.

‘But not for this,’ she answered, in offended accents. And then, more good-naturedly, ‘I have come, Fred, because
you entreated me so! What can have been the object of your writing such a letter? I feared I might be doing you
grievous ill by staying away. How did you come here?’

‘I walked all the way from my father’s.’

‘Well, what is it? How have you lived since we last met?’

‘But roughly; you might have known that without asking. I have seen many lands and many faces since I last walked
these downs, but I have only thought of you.’

‘Is it only to tell me this that you have summoned me so strangely?’

A passing breeze blew away the murmur of the reply and several succeeding sentences, till the man’s voice again
became audible in the words, ‘Harriet — truth between us two! I have heard that the Duke does not treat you too
well.’

‘He is warm-tempered, but he is a good husband.’

‘He speaks roughly to you, and sometimes even threatens to lock you out of doors.’

‘Only once, Fred! On my honour, only once. The Duke is a fairly good husband, I repeat. But you deserve punishment
for this night’s trick of drawing me out. What does it mean?’

‘Harriet, dearest, is this fair or honest? Is it not notorious that your life with him is a sad one — that, in spite
of the sweetness of your temper, the sourness of his embitters your days. I have come to know if I can help you. You
are a Duchess, and I am Fred Ogbourne; but it is not impossible that I may be able to help you . . . By God!
the sweetness of that tongue ought to keep him civil, especially when there is added to it the sweetness of that
face!’

‘Captain Ogbourne!’ she exclaimed, with an emphasis of playful fear. ‘How can such a comrade of my youth behave to
me as you do? Don’t speak so, and stare at me so! Is this really all you have to say? I see I ought not to have come.
’Twas thoughtlessly done.’

Another breeze broke the thread of discourse for a time.

‘Very well. I perceive you are dead and lost to me,’ he could next be heard to say, ‘“Captain Ogbourne” proves that.
As I once loved you I love you now, Harriet, without one jot of abatement; but you are not the woman you were — you
once were honest towards me; and now you conceal your heart in made-up speeches. Let it be: I can never see you
again.’

‘You need not say that in such a tragedy tone, you silly. You may see me in an ordinary way — why should you not?
But, of course, not in such a way as this. I should not have come now, if it had not happened that the Duke is away
from home, so that there is nobody to check my erratic impulses.’

‘When does he return?’

‘The day after tomorrow, or the day after that.’

‘Then meet me again tomorrow night.’

‘No, Fred, I cannot.’

‘If you cannot tomorrow night, you can the night after; one of the two before he comes please bestow on me. Now,
your hand upon it! To-morrow or next night you will see me to bid me farewell!’ He seized the Duchess’s hand.

‘No, but Fred — let go my hand! What do you mean by holding me so? If it be love to forget all respect to a woman’s
present position in thinking of her past, then yours may be so, Frederick. It is not kind and gentle of you to induce
me to come to this place for pity of you, and then to hold me tight here.’

‘But see me once more! I have come two thousand miles to ask it.’

‘O, I must not! There will be slanders — Heaven knows what! I cannot meet you. For the sake of old times don’t ask
it.’

‘Then own two things to me; that you did love me once, and that your husband is unkind to you often enough now to
make you think of the time when you cared for me.’

‘Yes — I own them both,’ she answered faintly. ‘But owning such as that tells against me; and I swear the inference
is not true.’

‘Don’t say that; for you have come — let me think the reason of your coming what I like to think it. It can do you
no harm. Come once more!’

He still held her hand and waist. ‘Very well, then,’ she said. ‘Thus far you shall persuade me. I will meet you
tomorrow night or the night after. Now, let me go.’

He released her, and they parted. The Duchess ran rapidly down the hill towards the outlying mansion of Shakeforest
Towers, and when he had watched her out of sight, he turned and strode off in the opposite direction. All then was
silent and empty as before.

Yet it was only for a moment. When they had quite departed, another shape appeared upon the scene. He came from
behind the trilithon. He was a man of stouter build than the first, and wore the boots and spurs of a horseman. Two
things were at once obvious from this phenomenon: that he had watched the interview between the Captain and the
Duchess; and that, though he probably had seen every movement of the couple, including the embrace, he had been too
remote to hear the reluctant words of the lady’s conversation — or, indeed, any words at all — so that the meeting must
have exhibited itself to his eye as the assignation of a pair of well-agreed lovers. But it was necessary that several
years should elapse before the shepherd-boy was old enough to reason out this.

The third individual stood still for a moment, as if deep in meditation. He crossed over to where the lady and
gentleman had stood, and looked at the ground; then he too turned and went away in a third direction, as widely
divergent as possible from those taken by the two interlocutors. His course was towards the highway; and a few minutes
afterwards the trot of a horse might have been heard upon its frosty surface, lessening till it died away upon the
ear.

The boy remained in the hut, confronting the trilithon as if he expected yet more actors on the scene, but nobody
else appeared. How long he stood with his little face against the loophole he hardly knew; but he was rudely awakened
from his reverie by a punch in his back, and in the feel of it he familiarly recognized the stem of the old shepherd’s
crook.

‘Blame thy young eyes and limbs, Bill Mills — now you have let the fire out, and you know I want it kept in! I
thought something would go wrong with ‘ee up here, and I couldn’t bide in bed no more than thistledown on the wind,
that I could not! Well, what’s happened, fie upon ‘ee?’

‘Nothing.’

‘Ewes all as I left ’em?’

‘Yes.’

‘Any lambs want bringing in?’

‘No.’

The shepherd relit the fire, and went out among the sheep with a lantern, for the moon was getting low. Soon he came
in again.

‘Blame it all — thou’st say that nothing have happened; when one ewe have twinned and is like to go off, and another
is dying for want of half an eye of looking to! I told ‘ee, Bill Mills, if anything went wrong to come down and call
me; and this is how you have done it.’

‘You said I could go to sleep for a hollerday, and I did.’

‘Don’t you speak to your betters like that, young man, or you’ll come to the gallows-tree! You didn’t sleep all the
time, or you wouldn’t have been peeping out of that there hole! Now you can go home, and be up here again by
breakfast-time. I be an old man, and there’s old men that deserve well of the world; but no I— must rest how I
can!’

The elder shepherd then lay down inside the hut, and the boy went down the hill to the hamlet where he dwelt.

Second Night

When the next night drew on the actions of the boy were almost enough to show that he was thinking of the meeting he
had witnessed, and of the promise wrung from the lady that she would come there again. As far as the sheep-tending
arrangements were concerned, to-night was but a repetition of the foregoing one. Between ten and eleven o’clock the old
shepherd withdrew as usual for what sleep at home he might chance to get without interruption, making up the other
necessary hours of rest at some time during the day; the boy was left alone.

The frost was the same as on the night before, except perhaps that it was a little more severe. The moon shone as
usual, except that it was three-quarters of an hour later in its course; and the boy’s condition was much the same,
except that he felt no sleepiness whatever. He felt, too, rather afraid; but upon the whole he preferred witnessing an
assignation of strangers to running the risk of being discovered absent by the old shepherd.

It was before the distant clock of Shakeforest Towers had struck eleven that he observed the opening of the second
act of this midnight drama. It consisted in the appearance of neither lover nor Duchess, but of the third figure — the
stout man, booted and spurred — who came up from the easterly direction in which he had retreated the night before. He
walked once round the trilithon, and next advanced towards the clump concealing the hut, the moonlight shining full
upon his face and revealing him to be the Duke. Fear seized upon the shepherd-boy: the Duke was Jove himself to the
rural population, whom to offend was starvation, homelessness, and death, and whom to look at was to be mentally
scathed and dumbfoundered. He closed the stove, so that not a spark of light appeared, and hastily buried himself in
the straw that lay in a corner.

The Duke came close to the clump of furze and stood by the spot where his wife and the Captain had held their
dialogue; he examined the furze as if searching for a hiding-place, and in doing so discovered the hut. The latter he
walked round and then looked inside; finding it to all seeming empty, he entered, closing the door behind him and
taking his place at the little circular window against which the boy’s face had been pressed just before.

The Duke had not adopted his measures too rapidly, if his object were concealment. Almost as soon as he had
stationed himself there eleven o’clock struck, and the slender young man who had previously graced the scene promptly
reappeared from the north quarter of the down. The spot of assignation having, by the accident of his running forward
on the foregoing night, removed itself from the Devil’s Door to the clump of furze, he instinctively came thither, and
waited for the Duchess where he had met her before.

But a fearful surprise was in store for him to-night, as well as for the trembling juvenile. At his appearance the
Duke breathed more and more quickly, his breathings being distinctly audible to the crouching boy. The young man had
hardly paused when the alert nobleman softly opened the door of the hut, and, stepping round the furze, came full upon
Captain Fred.

‘You have dishonoured her, and you shall die the death you deserve!’ came to the shepherd’s ears, in a harsh, hollow
whisper through the boarding of the hut.

The apathetic and taciturn boy was excited enough to run the risk of rising and looking from the window, but he
could see nothing for the intervening furze boughs, both the men having gone round to the side. What took place in the
few following moments he never exactly knew. He discerned portion of a shadow in quick muscular movement; then there
was the fall of something on the grass; then there was stillness.

Two or three minutes later the Duke became visible round the corner of the hut, dragging by the collar the now inert
body of the second man. The Duke dragged him across the open space towards the trilithon. Behind this ruin was a
hollow, irregular spot, overgrown with furze and stunted thorns, and riddled by the old holes of badgers, its former
inhabitants, who had now died out or departed. The Duke vanished into this depression with his burden, reappearing
after the lapse of a few seconds. When he came forth he dragged nothing behind him.

He returned to the side of the hut, cleansed something on the grass, and again put himself on the watch, though not
as before, inside the hut, but without, on the shady side. ‘Now for the second!’ he said.

It was plain, even to the unsophisticated boy, that he now awaited the other person of the appointment — his wife,
the Duchess — for what purpose it was terrible to think. He seemed to be a man of such determined temper that he would
scarcely hesitate in carrying out a course of revenge to the bitter end. Moreover — though it was what the shepherd did
not perceive — this was all the more probable, in that the moody Duke was labouring under the exaggerated impression
which the sight of the meeting in dumb show had conveyed.

The jealous watcher waited long, but he waited in vain. From within the hut the boy could hear his occasional
exclamations of surprise, as if he were almost disappointed at the failure of his assumption that his guilty Duchess
would surely keep the tryst. Sometimes he stepped from the shade of the furze into the moonlight, and held up his watch
to learn the time.

About half-past eleven he seemed to give up expecting her. He then went a second time to the hollow behind the
trilithon, remaining there nearly a quarter of an hour. From this place he proceeded quickly over a shoulder of the
declivity, a little to the left, presently returning on horseback, which proved that his horse had been tethered in
some secret place down there. Crossing anew the down between the hut and the trilithon, and scanning the precincts as
if finally to assure himself that she had not come, he rode slowly downwards in the direction of Shakeforest
Towers.

The juvenile shepherd thought of what lay in the hollow yonder; and no fear of the crook-stem of his superior
officer was potent enough to detain him longer on that hill alone. Any live company, even the most terrible, was better
than the company of the dead; so, running with the speed of a hare in the direction pursued by the horseman, he
overtook the revengeful Duke at the second descent (where the great western road crossed before you came to the old
park entrance on that side — now closed up and the lodge cleared away, though at the time it was wondered why, being
considered the most convenient gate of all).

Once within the sound of the horse’s footsteps, Bill Mills felt comparatively comfortable; for, though in awe of the
Duke because of his position, he had no moral repugnance to his companionship on account of the grisly deed he had
committed, considering that powerful nobleman to have a right to do what he chose on his own lands. The Duke rode
steadily on beneath his ancestral trees, the hoofs of his horse sending up a smart sound now that he had reached the
hard road of the drive, and soon drew near the front door of his house, surmounted by parapets with square-cut
battlements that cast a notched shade upon the gravelled terrace. These outlines were quite familiar to little Bill
Mills, though nothing within their boundary had ever been seen by him.

When the rider approached the mansion a small turret door was quickly opened and a woman came out. As soon as she
saw the horseman’s outlines she ran forward into the moonlight to meet him.

‘Ah dear — and are you come?’ she said. ‘I heard Hero’s tread just when you rode over the hill, and I knew it in a
moment. I would have come further if I had been aware —’

‘Glad to see me, eh?’

‘How can you ask that?’

‘Well; it is a lovely night for meetings.’

‘Yes, it is a lovely night.’

The Duke dismounted and stood by her side. ‘Why should you have been listening at this time of night, and yet not
expecting me?’ he asked.

‘Why, indeed! There is a strange story attached to that, which I must tell you at once. But why did you come a night
sooner than you said you would come? I am rather sorry — I really am!’ (shaking her head playfully) ‘for as a surprise
to you I had ordered a bonfire to be built, which was to be lighted on your arrival tomorrow; and now it is wasted. You
can see the outline of it just out there.’

The Duke looked across to a spot of rising glade, and saw the faggots in a heap. He then bent his eyes with a bland
and puzzled air on the ground, ‘What is this strange story you have to tell me that kept you awake?’ he murmured.

‘It is this — and it is really rather serious. My cousin Fred Ogbourne — Captain Ogbourne as he is now — was in his
boyhood a great admirer of mine, as I think I have told you, though I was six years his senior. In strict truth, he was
absurdly fond of me.’

‘You have never told me of that before.’

‘Then it was your sister I told — yes, it was. Well, you know I have not seen him for many years, and naturally I
had quite forgotten his admiration of me in old times. But guess my surprise when the day before yesterday, I received
a mysterious note bearing no address, and found on opening it that it came from him. The contents frightened me out of
my wits. He had returned from Canada to his father’s house, and conjured me by all he could think of to meet him at
once. But I think I can repeat the exact words, though I will show it to you when we get indoors.

“MY DEAR COUSIN HARRIET,” the note said, “After this long absence you will be surprised at my sudden
reappearance, and more by what I am going to ask. But if my life and future are of any concern to you at all, I beg
that you will grant my request. What I require of you, is, dear Harriet, that you meet me about eleven to-night by the
Druid stones on Marlbury Downs, about a mile or more from your house. I cannot say more, except to entreat you to come.
I will explain all when you are there. The one thing is, I want to see you. Come alone. Believe me, I would not ask
this if my happiness did not hang upon it — God knows how entirely! I am too agitated to say more — Yours. FRED.”

‘That was all of it. Now, of course I ought have gone, as it turned out, but that I did not think of then. I
remembered his impetuous temper, and feared that something grievous was impending over his head, while he had not a
friend in the world to help him, or any one except myself to whom he would care to make his trouble known. So I wrapped
myself up and went to Marlbury Downs at the time he had named. Don’t you think I was courageous?’

‘Very.’

‘When I got there — but shall we not walk on; it is getting cold?’ The Duke, however, did not move. ‘When I got
there he came, of course, as a full grown man and officer, and not as the lad that I had known him. When I saw him I
was sorry I had come. I can hardly tell you how he behaved. What he wanted I don’t know even now; it seemed to be no
more than the mere meeting with me. He held me by the hand and waist — O so tight — and would not let me go till I had
promised to meet him again. His manner was so strange and passionate that I was afraid of him in such a lonely place,
and I promised to come. Then I escaped — then I ran home — and that’s all. When the time drew on this evening for the
appointment — which, of course, I never intended to keep, I felt uneasy, lest when he found I meant to disappoint him
he would come on to the house; and that’s why I could not sleep. But you are so silent!’

‘I have had a long journey.’

‘Then let us get into the house. Why did you come alone and unattended like this?’

‘It was my humour.’

After a moment’s silence, during which they moved on, she said, ‘I have thought of something which I hardly like to
suggest to you. He said that if I failed to come to-night he would wait again tomorrow night. Now, shall we tomorrow
night go to the hill together — just to see if he is there; and if he is, read him a lesson on his foolishness in
nourishing this old passion, and sending for me so oddly, instead of coming to the house?’

‘Why should we see if he’s there?’ said her husband moodily.

‘Because I think we ought to do something in it. Poor Fred! He would listen to you if you reasoned with him, and set
our positions in their true light before him. It would be no more than Christian kindness to a man who unquestionably
is very miserable from some cause or other. His head seems quite turned.’

By this time they had reached the door, rung the bell, and waited. All the house seemed to be asleep; but soon a man
came to them, the horse was taken away, and the Duke and Duchess went in.

Third Night

There was no help for it. Bill Mills was obliged to stay on duty, in the old shepherd’s absence, this evening as
before, or give up his post and living. He thought as bravely as he could of what lay behind the Devil’s Door, but with
no great success, and was therefore in a measure relieved, even if awe-stricken, when he saw the forms of the Duke and
Duchess strolling across the frosted greensward. The Duchess was a few yards in front of her husband and tripped on
lightly.

‘I tell you he has not thought it worth while to come again!’ the Duke insisted, as he stood still, reluctant to
walk further.

‘He is more likely to come and wait all night; and it would be harsh treatment to let him do it a second time.’

‘He is not here; so turn and come home.’

‘He seems not to be here, certainly; I wonder if anything has happened to him. If it has, I shall never forgive
myself!’

The Duke, uneasily, ‘O, no. He has some other engagement.’

‘That is very unlikely.’

‘Or perhaps he has found the distance too far.’

‘Nor is that probable.’

‘Then he may have thought better of it.’

‘Yes, he may have thought better of it; if, indeed, he is not here all the time — somewhere in the hollow behind the
Devil’s Door. Let us go and see; it will serve him right to surprise him.’

‘O, he’s not there.’

‘He may be lying very quiet because of you,’ she said archly.

‘O, no — not because of me!’

‘Come, then. I declare, dearest, you lag like an unwilling schoolboy to-night, and there’s no responsiveness in you!
You are jealous of that poor lad, and it is quite absurd of you.’

‘I’ll come! I’ll come! Say no more, Harriet!’ And they crossed over the green.

Wondering what they would do, the young shepherd left the hut, and doubled behind the belt of furze, intending to
stand near the trilithon unperceived. But, in crossing the few yards of open ground he was for a moment exposed to
view.

‘Ah, I see him at last!’ said the Duchess.

‘See him!’ said the Duke. ‘Where?’

‘By the Devil’s Door; don’t you notice a figure there? Ah, my poor lover-cousin, won’t you catch it now?’ And she
laughed half-pityingly. ‘But what’s the matter?’ she asked, turning to her husband.

‘It is not he!’ said the Duke hoarsely. ‘It can’t be he!’

‘No, it is not he. It is too small for him. It is a boy.’

‘Ah, I thought so! Boy, come here.’

The youthful shepherd advanced with apprehension.

‘What are you doing here?’

‘Keeping sheep, your Grace.’

‘Ah, you know me! Do you keep sheep here every night?’

‘Off and on, my Lord Duke.’

‘And what have you seen here to-night or last night?’ inquired the Duchess. ‘Any person waiting or walking
about?’

The boy was silent.

‘He has seen nothing,’ interrupted her husband, his eyes so forbiddingly fixed on the boy that they seemed to shine
like points of fire. ‘Come, let us go. The air is too keen to stand in long.’

When they were gone the boy retreated to the hut and sheep, less fearful now than at first — familiarity with the
situation having gradually overpowered his thoughts of the buried man. But he was not to be left alone long. When an
interval had elapsed of about sufficient length for walking to and from Shakeforest Towers, there appeared from that
direction the heavy form of the Duke. He now came alone.

The nobleman, on his part, seemed to have eyes no less sharp than the boy’s, for he instantly recognized the latter
among the ewes, and came straight towards him.

‘Are you the shepherd lad I spoke to a short time ago?’

‘I be, my Lord Duke.’

‘Now listen to me. Her Grace asked you what you had seen this last night or two up here, and you made no reply. I
now ask the same thing, and you need not be afraid to answer. Have you seen anything strange these nights you have been
watching here?’

‘My Lord Duke, I be a poor heedless boy, and what I see I don’t bear in mind.’

‘I ask you again,’ said the Duke, coming nearer, ‘have you seen anything strange these nights you have been watching
here?’

‘O, my Lord Duke! I be but the under-shepherd boy, and my father he was but your humble Grace’s hedger, and my
mother only the cinder-woman in the back-yard! I fall asleep when left alone, and I see nothing at all!’

The Duke grasped the boy by the shoulder, and, directly impending over him, stared down into his face, ‘Did you see
anything strange done here last night, I say?’

‘O, my Lord Duke, have mercy, and don’t stab me!’ cried the shepherd, falling on his knees. ‘I have never seen you
walking here, or riding here, or lying-inwait for a man, or dragging a heavy load!’

‘H’m!’ said his interrogator, grimly, relaxing his hold. ‘It is well to know that you have never seen those things.
Now, which would you rather — see me do those things now, or keep a secret all your life?’

‘Keep a secret, my Lord Duke!’

‘Sure you are able?’

‘O, your Grace, try me!’

‘Very well. And now, how do you like sheep-keeping?’

‘Not at all. ’Tis lonely work for them that think of spirits, and I’m badly used.’

‘I believe you. You are too young for it. I must do something to make you more comfortable. You shall change this
smock-frock for a real cloth jacket, and your thick boots for polished shoes. And you shall be taught what you have
never yet heard of; and be put to school, and have bats and balls for the holidays, and be made a man of. But you must
never say you have been a shepherd boy, and watched on the hills at night, for shepherd boys are not liked in good
company.

‘Trust me, my Lord Duke.’

‘The very moment you forget yourself, and speak of your shepherd days — this year, next year, in school, out of
school, or riding in your carriage twenty years hence — at that moment my help will be withdrawn, and smash down you
come to shepherding forthwith. You have parents, I think you say?’

‘A widowed mother only, my Lord Duke.’

‘I’ll provide for her, and make a comfortable woman of her, until you speak of — what?’

‘Of my shepherd days, and what I saw here.’

‘Good. If you do speak of it?’

‘Smash down she comes to widowing forthwith!’

‘That’s well — very well. But it’s not enough. Come here.’ He took the boy across to the trilithon, and made him
kneel down.

‘Now, this was once a holy place,’ resumed the Duke. ‘An altar stood here, erected to a venerable family of gods,
who were known and talked of long before the God we know now. So that an oath sworn here is doubly an oath. Say this
after me: “May all the host above — angels and archangels, and principalities and powers — punish me; may I be
tormented wherever I am — in the house or in the garden, in the fields or in the roads, in church or in chapel, at home
or abroad, on land or at sea; may I be afflicted in eating and in drinking, in growing up and in growing old, in living
and dying, inwardly and outwardly, and for always, if I ever speak of my life as a shepherd boy, or of what I have seen
done on this Marlbury Down. So be it, and so let it be. Amen and amen.” Now kiss the stone.’

The trembling boy repeated the words, and kissed the stone, as desired.

The Duke led him off by the hand. That night the junior shepherd slept in Shakeforest Towers, and the next day he
was sent away for tuition to a remote village. Thence he went to a preparatory establishment, and in due course to a
public school.

Fourth Night

On a winter evening many years subsequent to the above-mentioned occurrences, the ci-devant shepherd sat in a
well-furnished office in the north wing of Shakeforest Towers in the guise of an ordinary educated man of business. He
appeared at this time as a person of thirty-eight or forty, though actually he was several years younger. A worn and
restless glance of the eye now and then, when he lifted his head to search for some letter or paper which had been
mislaid, seemed to denote that his was not a mind so thoroughly at ease as his surroundings might have led an observer
to expect.

His pallor, too, was remarkable for a countryman. He was professedly engaged in writing, but he shaped not word. He
had sat there only a few minutes, when, laying down his pen and pushing back his chair, he rested a hand uneasily on
each of the chair-arms and looked on the floor.

Soon he arose and left the room. His course was along a passage which ended in a central octagonal hall; crossing
this he knocked at a door. A faint, though deep, voice told him to come in. The room he entered was the library, and it
was tenanted by a single person only — his patron the Duke.

During this long interval of years the Duke had lost all his heaviness of build. He was, indeed, almost a skeleton;
his white hair was thin, and his hands were nearly transparent. ‘Oh — Mills?’ he murmured. ‘Sit down. What is it?’

‘Nothing new, your Grace. Nobody to speak of has written, and nobody has called.’

‘Ah — what then? You look concerned.’

‘Old times have come to life, owing to something waking them.’

‘Old times be cursed — which old times are they?’

‘That Christmas week twenty-two years ago, when the late Duchess’s cousin Frederick implored her to meet him on
Marlbury Downs. I saw the meeting — it was just such a night as this — and I, as you know, saw more. She met him once,
but not the second time.’

‘Mills, shall I recall some words to you — the words of an oath taken on that hill by a shepherd-boy?’

‘It is unnecessary. He has strenuously kept that oath and promise. Since that night no sound of his shepherd life
has crossed his lips — even to yourself. But do you wish to hear more, or do you not, your Grace?’

‘I wish to hear no more,’ said the Duke sullenly.

‘Very well; let it be so. But a time seems coming — may be quite near at hand — when, in spite of my lips, that
episode will allow itself to go undivulged no longer.’

‘I wish to hear no more!’ repeated the Duke.

‘You need be under no fear of treachery from me,’ said the steward, somewhat bitterly. ‘I am a man to whom you have
been kind — no patron could have been kinder. You have clothed and educated me; have installed me here; and I am not
unmindful. But what of it — has your Grace gained much by my stanchness? I think not. There was great excitement about
Captain Ogbourne’s disappearance, but I spoke not a word. And his body has never been found. For twenty-two years I
have wondered what you did with him. Now I know. A circumstance that occurred this afternoon recalled the time to me
most forcibly. To make it certain to myself that all was not a dream, I went up there with a spade; I searched, and saw
enough to know that something decays there in a closed badger’s hole.’

‘Mills, do you think the Duchess guessed?’

‘She never did, I am sure, to the day of her death.’

‘Did you leave all as you found it on the hill?’

‘I did.’

‘What made you think of going up there this particular afternoon?’

‘What your Grace says you don’t wish to be told.’

The Duke was silent; and the stillness of the evening was so marked that there reached their ears from the outer air
the sound of a tolling bell.

‘What is that bell tolling for?’ asked the nobleman.

‘For what I came to tell you of, your Grace.’

‘You torment me it is your way!’ said the Duke querulously. ‘Who’s dead in the village?’

‘The oldest man — the old shepherd.’

‘Dead at last — how old is he?’

‘Ninety-four.’

‘And I am only seventy. I have four-and-twenty years to the good!’

‘I served under that old man when I kept sheep on Marlbury Downs. And he was on the hill that second night, when I
first exchanged words with your Grace. He was on the hill all the time; but I did not know he was there — nor did
you.’

‘Ah!’ said the Duke, starting up. ‘Go on — I yield the point — you may tell!’

‘I heard this afternoon that he was at the point of death. It was that which set me thinking of that past time — and
induced me to search on the hill for what I have told you. Coming back I heard that he wished to see the Vicar to
confess to him a secret he had kept for more than twenty years —“out of respect to my Lord the Duke”— something that he
had seen committed on Marlbury Downs when returning to the flock on a December night twenty-two years ago. I have
thought it over. He had left me in charge that evening; but he was in the habit of coming back suddenly, lest I should
have fallen asleep. That night I saw nothing of him, though he had promised to return. He must have returned, and —
found reason to keep in hiding. It is all plain. The next thing is that the Vicar went to him two hours ago. Further
than that I have not heard.’

‘It is quite enough. I will see the Vicar at daybreak tomorrow.’

‘What to do?’

‘Stop his tongue for four-and-twenty years — till I am dead at ninety-four, like the shepherd.’

‘Your Grace — while you impose silence on me, I will not speak, even though nay neck should pay the penalty. I
promised to be yours, and I am yours. But is this persistence of any avail?’

‘I’ll stop his tongue, I say!’ cried the Duke with some of his old rugged force. ‘Now, you go home to bed, Mills,
and leave me to manage him.’

The interview ended, and the steward withdrew. The night, as he had said, was just such an one as the night of
twenty-two years before, and the events of the evening destroyed in him all regard for the season as one of
cheerfulness and goodwill. He went off to his own house on the further verge of the park, where he led a lonely life,
scarcely calling any man friend. At eleven he prepared to retire to bed — but did not retire. He sat down and
reflected. Twelve o’clock struck; he looked out at the colourless moon, and, prompted by he knew not what, put on his
hat and emerged into the air. Here William Mills strolled on and on, till he reached the top of Marlbury Downs, a spot
he had not visited at this hour of the night during the whole score-and-odd years.

He placed himself, as nearly as he could guess, on the spot where the shepherd’s hut had stood. No lambing was in
progress there now, and the old shepherd who had used him so roughly had ceased from his labours that very day. But the
trilithon stood up white as ever; and, crossing the intervening sward, the steward fancifully placed his mouth against
the stone. Restless and self-reproachful as he was, he could not resist a smile as he thought of the terrifying oath of
compact, sealed by a kiss upon the stones of a Pagan temple. But he had kept his word, rather as a promise than as a
formal vow, with much worldly advantage to himself, though not much happiness; till increase of years had bred
reactionary feelings which led him to receive the news of to-night with emotions akin to relief.

While leaning against the Devil’s Door and thinking on these things, he became conscious that he was not the only
inhabitant of the down. A figure in white was moving across his front with long, noiseless strides. Mills stood
motionless, and when the form drew quite near he perceived it to be that of the Duke himself in his nightshirt —
apparently walking in his sleep. Not to alarm the old man, Mills clung close to the shadow of the stone. The Duke went
straight on into the hollow. There he knelt down, and began scratching the earth with his hands like a badger. After a
few minutes he arose, sighed heavily, and retraced his steps as he had come.

Fearing that he might harm himself, yet unwilling to arouse him, the steward followed noiselessly. The Duke kept on
his path unerringly, entered the park, and made for the house, where he let himself in by a window that stood open —
the one probably by which he had come out. Mills softly closed the window behind his patron, and then retired homeward
to await the revelations of the morning, deeming it unnecessary to alarm the house.

However, he felt uneasy during the remainder of the night, no less on account of the Duke’s personal condition than
because of that which was imminent next day. Early in the morning he called at Shakeforest Towers. The blinds were
down, and there was something singular upon the porter’s face when he opened the door. The steward inquired for the
Duke.

The man’s voice was subdued as he replied: ‘Sir, I am sorry to say that his Grace is dead! He left his room some
time in the night, and wandered about nobody knows where. On returning to the upper floor he lost his balance and fell
downstairs.’

The steward told the tale of the Down before the Vicar had spoken. Mills had always intended to do so after the
death of the Duke. The consequences to himself he underwent cheerfully; but his life was not prolonged. He died, a
farmer at the Cape, when still somewhat under forty-nine years of age.

The splendid Marlbury breeding flock is as renowned as ever, and, to the eye, seems the same in every particular
that it was in earlier times; but the animals which composed it on the occasion of the events gathered from the Justice
are divided by many ovine generations from its members now. Lambing Corner has long since ceased to be used for lambing
purposes, though the name still lingers on as the appellation of the spot. This abandonment of site may be partly owing
to the removal of the high furze bushes which lent such convenient shelter at that date. Partly, too, it may be due to
another circumstance. For it is said by present shepherds in that district that during the nights of Christmas week
flitting shapes are seen in the open space around the trilithon, together with the gleam of a weapon, and the shadow of
a man dragging a burden into the hollow. But of these things there is no certain testimony.

Christmas 1881.

A Committee-Man of ‘The Terror’

We had been talking of the Georgian glories of our old-fashioned watering-place, which now, with its substantial
russet-red and dun brick buildings in the style of the year eighteen hundred, looks like one side of a Soho or
Bloomsbury Street transported to the shore, and draws a smile from the modern tourist who has no eye for solidity of
build. The writer, quite a youth, was present merely as a listener. The conversation proceeded from general subjects to
particular, until old Mrs. H — whose memory was as perfect at eighty as it had ever been in her life, interested us all
by the obvious fidelity with which she repeated a story many times related to her by her mother when our aged friend
was a girl — a domestic drama much affecting the life of an acquaintance of her said parent, one Mademoiselle V — a
teacher of French. The incidents occurred in the town during the heyday of its fortunes, at the time of our brief peace
with France in 1802–3.

‘I wrote it down in the shape of a story some years ago, just after my mother’s death,’ said Mrs. H—. ‘It is locked
up in my desk there now.’

‘Read it!’ said we.

‘No,’ said she; ‘the light is bad, and I can remember it well enough, word for word, flourishes and all.’ We could
not be choosers in the circumstances, and she began.

* * * *

‘There are two in it, of course, the man and the woman, and it was on an evening in September that she first got to
know him. There had not been such a grand gathering on the Esplanade all the season. His Majesty King George the Third
was present, with all the princesses and royal dukes, while upwards of three hundred of the general nobility and other
persons of distinction were also in the town at the time. Carriages and other conveyances were arriving every minute
from London and elsewhere; and when among the rest a shabby stage-coach came in by a by-route along the coast from
Havenpool, and drew up at a second-rate tavern, it attracted comparatively little notice.

‘From this dusty vehicle a man alighted, left his small quantity of luggage temporarily at the office, and walked
along the street as if to look for lodgings.

‘He was about forty-five — possibly fifty — and wore a long coat of faded superfine cloth, with a heavy collar, and
a hunched-up neckcloth. He seemed to desire obscurity.

‘But the display appeared presently to strike him, and he asked of a rustic he met in the street what was going on;
his accent being that of one to whom English pronunciation was difficult.

‘The countryman looked at him with a slight surprise, and said, “King Jarge is here and his royal Cwort.”

‘The stranger inquired if they were going to stay long.

‘“Don’t know, Sir. Same as they always do, I suppose.”

‘“How long is that?”

‘“Till some time in October. They’ve come here every summer since eighty-nine.”

‘The stranger moved onward down St. Thomas Street, and approached the bridge over the harbour backwater, that then,
as now, connected the old town with the more modern portion. The spot was swept with the rays of a low sun, which lit
up the harbour lengthwise, and shone under the brim of the man’s hat and into his eyes as he looked westward. Against
the radiance figures were crossing in the opposite direction to his own; among them this lady of my mother’s later
acquaintance, Mademoiselle V—. She was the daughter of a good old French family, and at that date a pale woman,
twenty-eight or thirty years of age, tall and elegant in figure, but plainly dressed and wearing that evening (she
said) a small muslin shawl crossed over the bosom in the fashion of the time, and tied behind.

‘At sight of his face, which, as she used to tell us, was unusually distinct in the peering sunlight, she could not
help giving a little shriek of horror, for a terrible reason connected with her history, and after walking a few steps
further, she sank down against the parapet of the bridge in a fainting fit.

‘In his preoccupation the foreign gentleman had hardly noticed her, but her strange collapse immediately attracted
his attention. He quickly crossed the carriageway, picked her up, and carried her into the first shop adjoining the
bridge, explaining that she was a lady who had been taken ill outside.

‘She soon revived; but, clearly much puzzled, her helper perceived that she still had a dread of him which was
sufficient to hinder her complete recovery of self-command. She spoke in a quick and nervous way to the shopkeeper,
asking him to call a coach.

‘This the shopkeeper did, Mademoiselle V—— and the stranger remaining in constrained silence while he was gone. The
coach came up, and giving the man the address, she entered it and drove away.

‘“Who is that lady?” said the newly arrived gentleman.

‘“She’s of your nation, as I should make bold to suppose,” said the shopkeeper. And he told the other that she was
Mademoiselle V — governess at General Newbold’s, in the same town.

‘“You have many foreigners here?” the stranger inquired.

‘“Yes, though mostly Hanoverians. But since the peace they are learning French a good deal in genteel society, and
French instructors are rather in demand.”

‘“Yes, I teach it,” said the visitor. “I am looking for a tutorship in an academy.”

‘The information given by the burgess to the Frenchman seemed to explain to the latter nothing of his countrywoman’s
conduct — which, indeed, was the case — and he left the shop, taking his course again over the bridge and along the
south quay to the Old Rooms Inn, where he engaged a bedchamber.

‘Thoughts of the woman who had betrayed such agitation at sight of him lingered naturally enough with the newcomer.
Though, as I stated, not much less than thirty years of age, Mademoiselle V — one of his own nation, and of highly
refined and delicate appearance, had kindled a singular interest in the middle-aged gentleman’s breast, and her large
dark eyes, as they had opened and shrunk from him, exhibited a pathetic beauty to which hardly any man could have been
insensible.

‘The next day, having written some letters, he went out and made known at the office of the town “Guide” and of the
newspaper, that a teacher of French and calligraphy had arrived, leaving a card at the bookseller’s to the same effect.
He then walked on aimlessly, but at length inquired the way to General Newbold’s. At the door, without giving his name,
he asked to see Mademoiselle V — and was shown into a little back parlour, where she came to him with a gaze of
surprise.

‘“My God! Why do you intrude here, Monsieur?” she gasped in French as soon as she saw his face.

‘“You were taken ill yesterday. I helped you. You might have been run over if I had not picked you up. It was an act
of simple humanity certainly; but I thought I might come to ask if you had recovered?”

‘“I saw you in years gone by, when you did not see me. You were formerly Member of the Committee of Public Safety,
under the Convention.”

“I was.”

‘“You guillotined my father, my brother, my uncle — all my family, nearly, and broke my mother’s heart. They had
done nothing but keep silence. Their sentiments were only guessed. Their headless corpses were thrown indiscriminately
into the ditch of the Mousseaux Cemetery, and destroyed with lime.”

‘He nodded.

‘“You left me without a friend, and here I am now, alone in a foreign land.”

‘“I am sorry for you,” said be. “Sorry for the consequence, not for the intent. What I did was a matter of
conscience, and, from a point of view indiscernible by you, I did right. I profited not a farthing. But I shall not
argue this. You have the satisfaction of seeing me here an exile also, in poverty, betrayed by comrades, as friendless
as yourself.”

‘“It is no satisfaction to me, Monsieur.”

‘“Well, things done cannot be altered. Now the question: are you quite recovered?”

‘“Not from dislike and dread of you — otherwise, yes.”

‘“Good morning, Mademoiselle.”

‘“Good morning.”

‘They did not meet again till one evening at the theatre (which my mother’s friend was with great difficulty induced
to frequent, to perfect herself in English pronunciation, the idea she entertained at that time being to become a
teacher of English in her own country later on). She found him sitting next to her, and it made her pale and
restless.

‘“You are still afraid of me?”

‘“I am. O cannot you understand!”

‘He signified the affirmative.

‘“I follow the play with difficulty,” he said, presently.

‘“So do I— now,” said she.

‘He regarded her long, and she was conscious of his look; and while she kept her eyes on the stage they filled with
tears. Still she would not move, and the tears ran visibly down her cheek, though the play was a merry one, being no
other than Mr. Sheridan’s comedy of “The Rivals,” with Mr. S. Kemble as Captain Absolute. He saw her distress, and that
her mind was elsewhere; and abruptly rising from his seat at candle-snuffing time he left the theatre.

‘Though he lived in the old town, and she in the new, they frequently saw each other at a distance. One of these
occasions was when she was on the north side of the harbour, by the ferry, waiting for the boat to take her across. He
was standing by Cove Row, on the quay opposite. Instead of entering the boat when it arrived she stepped back from the
quay; but looking to see if he remained she beheld him pointing with his finger to the ferry-boat.

‘“Enter!” he said, in a voice loud enough to reach her.

‘Mademoiselle V—— stood still.

‘“Enter!” he said, and, as she did not move, he repeated the word a third time.

‘She had really been going to cross, and now approached and stepped down into the boat. Though she did not raise her
eyes she knew that he was watching her over. At the landing steps she saw from under the brim of her hat a hand
stretched down. The steps were steep and slippery.

‘“No, Monsieur,” she said. “Unless, indeed, you believe in God, and repent of your evil past!”

‘“I am sorry you were made to suffer. But I only believe in the god called Reason, and I do not repent. I was the
instrument of a national principle. Your friends were not sacrificed for any ends of mine.”

‘She thereupon withheld her hand, and clambered up unassisted. He went on, ascending the Look-out Hill, and
disappearing over the brow. Her way was in the same direction, her errand being to bring home the two young girls under
her charge, who had gone to the cliff for an airing. When she joined them at the top she saw his solitary figure at the
further edge, standing motionless against the sea. All the while that she remained with her pupils he stood without
turning, as if looking at the frigates in the roadstead, but more probably in meditation, unconscious where he was. In
leaving the spot one of the children threw away half a sponge-biscuit that she had been eating. Passing near it he
stooped, picked it up carefully, and put it in his pocket.

‘Mademoiselle V—— came homeward, asking herself, “Can he be starving?”

‘From that day he was invisible for so long a time that she thought he had gone away altogether. But one evening a
note came to her, and she opened it trembling.

‘“I am here ill,” it said, “and, as you know, alone. There are one or two little things I want done, in
case my death should occur — and I should prefer not to ask the people here, if it could be avoided. Have you enough of
the gift of charity to come and carry out my wishes before it is too late?”

‘Now so it was that, since seeing him possess himself of the broken cake, she had insensibly begun to feel something
that was more than curiosity, though perhaps less than anxiety, about this fellow-countryman of hers; and it was not in
her nervous and sensitive heart to resist his appeal. She found his lodging (to which he had removed from the Old Rooms
inn for economy) to be a room over a shop, half-way up the steep and narrow street of the old town, to which the
fashionable visitors seldom penetrated. With some misgiving she entered the house, and was admitted to the chamber
where he lay.

‘“You are too good, too good,” he murmured. And presently, “You need not shut the door. You will feel safer, and
they will not understand what we say.”

‘“Are you in want, Monsieur? Can I give you —”

‘“No, no. I merely want you to do a trifling thing or two that I have not strength enough to do myself. Nobody in
the town but you knows who I really am — unless you have told?”

‘“I have not told . . . I thought you might have acted from principle in those sad days, even —”

‘“You are kind to concede that much. However, to the present. I was able to destroy my few papers before I became so
weak . . . But in the drawer there you will find some pieces of linen clothing — only two or three — marked
with initials that may be recognized. Will you rip them out with a penknife?”

‘She searched as bidden, found the garments, cut out the stitches of the lettering, and replaced the linen as
before. A promise to post, in the event of his death, a letter he put in her hand, completed all that he required of
her.

‘He thanked her. “I think you seem sorry for me,” he murmured. “And I am surprised. You are sorry?”

‘She evaded the question. “Do you repent and believe?” she asked.

‘“No.”

‘Contrary to her expectations and his own he recovered, though very slowly; and her manner grew more distant
thenceforward, though his influence upon her was deeper than she knew. Weeks passed away, and the month of May arrived.
One day at this time she met him walking slowly along the beach to the northward.

‘“You know the news?” he said.

‘“You mean of the rupture between France and England again?”

‘“Yes; and the feeling of antagonism is stronger than it was in the last war, owing to Bonaparte’s high-handed
arrest of the innocent English who were travelling in our country for pleasure. I feel that the war will be long and
bitter; and that my wish to live unknown in England will be frustrated. See here.”

‘He took from his pocket a piece of the single newspaper which circulated in the county in those days, and she read
—

“The magistrates acting under the Alien Act have been requested to direct a very scrutinizing eye to the Academies
in our towns and other places, in which French tutors are employed, and to all of that nationality who profess to be
teachers in this country. Many of them are known to be inveterate Enemies and Traitors to the nation among whose people
they have found a livelihood and a home.”

‘He continued: “I have observed since the declaration of war a marked difference in the conduct of the rougher class
of people here towards me. If a great battle were to occur — as it soon will, no doubt — feeling would grow to a pitch
that would make it impossible for me, a disguised man of no known occupation, to stay here. With you, whose duties and
antecedents are known, it may be less difficult, but still unpleasant. Now I propose this. You have probably seen how
my deep sympathy with you has quickened to a warm feeling; and what I say is, will you agree to give me a title to
protect you by honouring me with your hand? I am older than you, it is true, but as husband and wife we can leave
England together, and make the whole world our country. Though I would propose Quebec, in Canada, as the place which
offers the best promise of a home.”

‘“My God! You surprise me!” said she.

‘“But you accept my proposal?”

‘“No, no!”

‘“And yet I think you will, Mademoiselle, some day!”

‘“I think not.”

‘“I won’t distress you further now.”

‘“Much thanks . . . I am glad to see you looking better, Monsieur; I mean you are looking better.”

‘“Ah, yes. I am improving. I walk in the sun every day.”

‘And almost every day she saw him — sometimes nodding stiffly only, sometimes exchanging formal civilities. “You are
not gone yet,” she said on one of these occasions.

‘“No. At present I don’t think of going without you.”

‘“But you find it uncomfortable here?”

‘“Somewhat. So when will you have pity on me?”

‘She shook her head and went on her way. Yet she was a little moved. “He did it on principle,” she would murmur. “He
had no animosity towards them, and profited nothing!”

‘She wondered how he lived. It was evident that he could not be so poor as she had thought; his pretended poverty
might be to escape notice. She could not tell, but she knew that she was dangerously interested in him.

‘And he still mended, till his thin, pale face became more full and firm. As he mended she had to meet that request
of his, advanced with even stronger insistency.

‘The arrival of the King and Court for the season as usual brought matters to a climax for these two lonely exiles
and fellow country-people. The King’s awkward preference for a part of the coast in such dangerous proximity to France
made it necessary that a strict military vigilance should be exercised to guard the royal residents. Half-a-dozen
frigates were every night posted in a line across the bay, and two lines of sentinels, one at the water’s edge and
another behind the Esplanade, occupied the whole sea-front after eight every night. The watering-place was growing an
inconvenient residence even for Mademoiselle V—— herself, her friendship for this strange French tutor and
writing-master who never had any pupils having been observed by many who slightly knew her. The General’s wife, whose
dependent she was, repeatedly warned her against the acquaintance; while the Hanoverian and other soldiers of the
Foreign Legion, who had discovered the nationality of her friend, were more aggressive than the English military
gallants who made it their business to notice her.

‘In this tense state of affairs her answers became more agitated. “O Heaven, how can I marry you!” she would
say.

‘“You will; surely you will!” he answered again. “I don’t leave without you. And I shall soon be interrogated before
the magistrates if I stay here; probably imprisoned. You will come?”

‘She felt her defences breaking down. Contrary to all reason and sense of family honour she was, by some abnormal
craving, inclining to a tenderness for him that was founded on its opposite. Sometimes her warm sentiments burnt lower
than at others, and then the enormity of her conduct showed itself in more staring hues.

‘Shortly after this he came with a resigned look on his face. “It is as I expected,” he said. “I have received a
hint to go. In good sooth, I am no Bonapartist — I am no enemy to England; but the presence of the King made it
impossible for a foreigner with no visible occupation, and who may be a spy, to remain at large in the town. The
authorities are civil, but firm. They are no more than reasonable. Good. I must go. You must come also.”

‘She did not speak. But she nodded assent, her eyes drooping.

‘On her way back to the house on the Esplanade she said to herself, “I am glad, I am glad! I could not do otherwise.
It is rendering good for evil!” But she knew how she mocked herself in this, and that the moral principle had not
operated one jot in her acceptance of him. In truth she had not realized till now the full presence of the emotion
which had unconsciously grown up in her for this lonely and severe man, who, in her tradition, was vengeance and
irreligion personified. He seemed to absorb her whole nature, and, absorbing, to control it.

‘A day or two before the one fixed for the wedding there chanced to come to her a letter from the only acquaintance
of her own sex and country she possessed in England, one to whom she had sent intelligence of her approaching marriage,
without mentioning with whom. This friend’s misfortunes had been somewhat similar to her own, which fact had been one
cause of their intimacy; her friend’s sister, a nun of the Abbey of Montmartre, having perished on the scaffold at the
hands of the same Comite de Salut Public which had numbered Mademoiselle V—‘s affianced among its members. The writer
had felt her position much again of late, since the renewal of the war, she said; and the letter wound up with a fresh
denunciation of the authors of their mutual bereavement and subsequent troubles.

‘Coming just then, its contents produced upon Mademoiselle V—— the effect of a pail of water upon a somnambulist.
What had she been doing in betrothing herself to this man! Was she not making herself a parricide after the event? At
this crisis in her feelings her lover called. He beheld her trembling, and, in reply to his question, she told him of
her scruples with impulsive candour.

‘She had not intended to do this, but his attitude of tender command coerced her into frankness. Thereupon he
exhibited an agitation never before apparent in him. He said, “But all that is past. You are the symbol of Charity, and
we are pledged to let bygones be.”

‘His words soothed her for the moment, but she was sadly silent, and he went away.

‘That night she saw (as she firmly believed to the end of her life) a divinely sent vision. A procession of her lost
relatives — father, brother, uncle, cousin — seemed to cross her chamber between her bed and the window, and when she
endeavoured to trace their features she perceived them to be headless, and that she had recognized them by their
familiar clothes only. In the morning she could not shake off the effects of this appearance on her nerves. All that
day she saw nothing of her wooer, he being occupied in making arrangements for their departure. It grew towards evening
— the marriage eve; but, in spite of his re-assuring visit, her sense of family duty waxed stronger now that she was
left alone. Yet, she asked herself, how could she, alone and unprotected, go at this eleventh hour and reassert to an
affianced husband that she could not and would not marry him while admitting at the same time that she loved him? The
situation dismayed her. She had relinquished her post as governess, and was staying temporarily in a room near the
coach-office, where she expected him to call in the morning to carry out the business of their union and departure.

‘Wisely or foolishly, Mademoiselle V—— came to a resolution: that her only safety lay in flight. His contiguity
influenced her too sensibly; she could not reason. So packing up her few possessions and placing on the table the small
sum she owed, she went out privately, secured a last available seat in the London coach, and, almost before she had
fully weighed her action, she was rolling out of the town in the dusk of the September evening.

‘Having taken this startling step she began to reflect upon her reasons. He had been one of that tragic Committee
the sound of whose name was a horror to the civilized world; yet he had been only one of several members, and, it
seemed, not the most active. He had marked down names on principle, had felt no personal enmity against his victims,
and had enriched himself not a sou out of the office he had held. Nothing could change the past. Meanwhile he loved
her, and her heart inclined to as much of him as she could detach from that past. Why not, as he had suggested, bury
memories, and inaugurate a new era by this union? In other words, why not indulge her tenderness, since its
nullification could do no good.

‘Thus she held self-communion in her seat in the coach, passing through Casterbridge, and Shottsford, and on to the
White Hart at Melchester, at which place the whole fabric of her recent intentions crumbled down. Better be staunch
having got so far; let things take their course, and marry boldly the man who had so impressed her. How great he was;
how small was she! And she had presumed to judge him! Abandoning her place in the coach with the precipitancy that had
characterized her taking it, she waited till the vehicle had driven off, something in the departing shapes of the
outside passengers against the starlit sky giving her a start, as she afterwards remembered. Presently the down coach,
“The Morning Herald,” entered the city, and she hastily obtained a place on the top.

‘“I’ll be firm — I’ll be his — if it cost me my immortal soul!” she said. And with troubled breathings she journeyed
back over the road she had just traced.

‘She reached our royal watering-place by the time the day broke, and her first aim was to get back to the hired room
in which her last few days had been spent. When the landlady appeared at the door in response to Mademoiselle V—‘s
nervous summons, she explained her sudden departure and return as best she could; and no objection being offered to her
re-engagement of the room for one day longer she ascended to the chamber and sat down panting. She was back once more,
and her wild tergiversations were a secret from him whom alone they concerned.

‘A sealed letter was on the mantelpiece. “Yes, it is directed to you, Mademoiselle,” said the woman who had followed
her. “But we were wondering what to do with it. A town messenger brought it after you had gone last night.”

‘When the landlady had left, Mademoiselle V—— opened the letter and read —

“MY DEAR AND HONOURED FRIEND. — You have been throughout our acquaintance absolutely candid concerning your
misgivings. But I have been reserved concerning mine. That is the difference between us. You probably have not guessed
that every qualm you have felt on the subject of our marriage has been paralleled in my heart to the full. Thus it
happened that your involuntary outburst of remorse yesterday, though mechanically deprecated by me in your presence,
was a last item in my own doubts on the wisdom of our union, giving them a force that I could no longer withstand. I
came home; and, on reflection, much as I honour and adore you, I decide to set you free.

“As one whose life has been devoted, and I may say sacrificed, to the cause of Liberty, I cannot allow your judgment
(probably a permanent one) to be fettered beyond release by a feeling which may be transient only.

“It would be no less than excruciating to both that I should announce this decision to you by word of mouth. I have
therefore taken the less painful course of writing. Before you receive this I shall have left the town by the evening
coach for London, on reaching which city my movements will be revealed to none.

‘When she had recovered from her shock of surprise and grief, she remembered that at the starting of the coach out
of Melchester before dawn, the shape of a figure among the outside passengers against the starlit sky had caused her a
momentary start, from its resemblance to that of her friend. Knowing nothing of each other’s intentions, and screened
from each other by the darkness, they had left the town by the same conveyance. “He, the greater, persevered; I, the
smaller, returned!” she said.

‘Recovering from her stupor, Mademoiselle V—— bethought herself again of her employer, Mrs. Newbold, whom recent
events had estranged. To that lady she went with a full heart, and explained everything. Mrs. Newbold kept to herself
her opinion of the episode, and reinstalled the deserted bride in her old position as governess to the family.

‘A governess she remained to the end of her days. After the final peace with France she became acquainted with my
mother, to whom by degrees she imparted these experiences of hers. As her hair grew white, and her features pinched,
Mademoiselle V—— would wonder what nook of the world contained her lover, if he lived, and if by any chance she might
see him again. But when, some time in the ‘twenties, death came to her, at no great age, that outline against the stars
of the morning remained as the last glimpse she ever obtained of her family’s foe and her once affianced husband.’

1895.

Master John Horseleigh, Knight

In the earliest and mustiest volume of the Havenpool marriage registers (said the thin-faced gentleman) this entry
may still be read by any one curious enough to decipher the crabbed handwriting of the date. I took a copy of it when I
was last there; and it runs thus (he had opened his pocket-book, and now read aloud the extract; afterwards handing
round the book to us, wherein we saw transcribed the following)—

Mastr John Horseleigh, Knyght, of the p’ysshe of Clyffton was maryd to Edith the wyffe late off John Stocker,
m’chawnte of Havenpool the xiiij daje of December be p’vylegge gevyn by our sup’me hedd of the chyrche of Ingelonde
Kynge Henry the viii th 1539.

Now, if you turn to the long and elaborate pedigree of the ancient family of the Horseleighs of Clyfton Horseleigh,
you will find no mention whatever of this alliance, notwithstanding the privilege given by the Sovereign and head of
the Church; the said Sir John being therein chronicled as marrying, at a date apparently earlier than the above, the
daughter and heiress of Richard Phelipson, of Montislope, in Nether Wessex, a lady who outlived him, of which marriage
there were issue two daughters and a son, who succeeded him in his estates. How are we to account for these, as it
would seem, contemporaneous wives? A strange local tradition only can help us, and this can be briefly told.

One evening in the autumn of the year 1540 or 1541, a young sailor, whose Christian name was Roger, but whose
surname is not known, landed at his native place of Havenpool, on the South Wessex coast, after a voyage in the
Newfoundland trade, then newly sprung into existence. He returned in the ship Primrose with a cargo of ‘trayne oyle
brought home from the New Founde Lande,’ to quote from the town records of the date. During his absence of two summers
and a winter, which made up the term of a Newfoundland ‘spell,’ many unlooked-for changes had occurred within the quiet
little seaport, some of which closely affected Roger the sailor. At the time of his departure his only sister Edith had
become the bride of one Stocker, a respectable townsman, and part owner of the brig in which Roger had sailed; and it
was to the house of this couple, his only relatives, that the young man directed his steps. On trying the door in Quay
Street he found it locked, and then observed that the windows were boarded up. Inquiring of a bystander, he learnt for
the first time of the death of his brother-inlaw, though that event had taken place nearly eighteen months before.

‘And my sister Edith?’ asked Roger.

‘She’s married again — as they do say, and hath been so these twelve months. I don’t vouch for the truth o’t, though
if she isn’t she ought to be.’

Roger’s face grew dark. He was a man with a considerable reserve of strong passion, and he asked his informant what
he meant by speaking thus.

The man explained that shortly after the young woman’s bereavement a stranger had come to the port. He had seen her
moping on the quay, had been attracted by her youth and loneliness, and in an extraordinarily brief wooing had
completely fascinated her — had carried her off, and, as was reported, had married her. Though he had come by water, he
was supposed to live no very great distance off by land. They were last heard of at Oozewood, in Upper Wessex, at the
house of one Wall, a timber-merchant, where, he believed, she still had a lodging, though her husband, if he were
lawfully that much, was but an occasional visitor to the place.

‘The stranger?’ asked Roger. ‘Did you see him? What manner of man was he?’

‘I liked him not,’ said the other. ‘He seemed of that kind that hath something to conceal, and as he walked with her
he ever and anon turned his head and gazed behind him, as if he much feared an unwelcome pursuer. But, faith,’
continued he, ‘it may have been the man’s anxiety only. Yet did I not like him.’

‘Was he older than my sister?’ Roger asked.

‘Ay — much older; from a dozen to a score of years older. A man of some position, maybe, playing an amorous game for
the pleasure of the hour. Who knoweth but that he have a wife already? Many have done the thing hereabouts of
late.’

Having paid a visit to the graves of his relatives, the sailor next day went along the straight road which, then a
lane, now a highway, conducted to the curious little inland town named by the Havenpool man. It is unnecessary to
describe Oozewood on the South–Avon. It has a railway at the present day; but thirty years of steam traffic past its
precincts have hardly modified its original features. Surrounded by a sort of fresh-water lagoon, dividing it from
meadows and coppice, its ancient thatch and timber houses have barely made way even in the front street for the
ubiquitous modern brick and slate. It neither increases nor diminishes in size; it is difficult to say what the
inhabitants find to do, for, though trades in woodware are still carried on, there cannot be enough of this class of
work nowadays to maintain all the householders, the forests around having been so greatly thinned and curtailed. At the
time of this tradition the forests were dense, artificers in wood abounded, and the timber trade was brisk. Every house
in the town, without exception, was of oak framework, filled in with plaster, and covered with thatch, the chimney
being the only brick portion of the structure. Inquiry soon brought Roger the sailor to the door of Wall, the
timber-dealer referred to, but it was some time before he was able to gain admission to the lodging of his sister, the
people having plainly received directions not to welcome strangers.

She was sitting in an upper room on one of the lath-backed, willow-bottomed ‘shepherd’s’ chairs, made on the spot
then as to this day, and as they were probably made there in the days of the Heptarchy. In her lap was an infant, which
she had been suckling, though now it had fallen asleep; so had the young mother herself for a few minutes, under the
drowsing effects of solitude. Hearing footsteps on the stairs, she awoke, started up with a glad cry, and ran to the
door, opening which she met her brother on the threshold.

‘O, this is merry; I didn’t expect ‘ee!’ she said. ‘Ah, Roger — I thought it was John.’ Her tones fell to
disappointment.

The sailor kissed her, looked at her sternly for a few moments, and pointing to the infant, said, ‘You mean the
father of this?’

‘Yes, my husband,’ said Edith.

‘I hope so,’ he answered.

‘Why, Roger, I’m married — of a truth am I!’ she cried.

‘Shame upon ‘ee, if true! If not true, worse. Master Stocker was an honest man, and ye should have respected his
memory longer. Where is thy husband?’

‘He comes often. I thought it was he now. Our marriage has to be kept secret for a while — it was done privily for
certain reasons; but we was married at church like honest folk — afore God we were, Roger, six months after poor
Stocker’s death.’

‘’Twas too soon,’ said Roger.

‘I was living in a house alone; I had nowhere to go to. You were far over sea in the New Found Land, and John took
me and brought me here.’

‘How often doth he come?’ says Roger again.

‘Once or twice weekly,’ says she.

‘I wish th’ ‘dst waited till I returned, dear Edy,’ he said. ‘It mid be you are a wife — I hope so. But, if so, why
this mystery? Why this mean and cramped lodging in this lonely copse-circled town? Of what standing is your husband,
and of where?’

‘He is of gentle breeding — his name is John. I am not free to tell his family-name. He is said to be of London, for
safety’ sake; but he really lives in the county next adjoining this.’

‘Where in the next county?’

‘I do not know. He has preferred not to tell me, that I may not have the secret forced from me, to his and my hurt,
by bringing the marriage to the ears of his kinsfolk and friends.’

Her brother’s face flushed. ‘Our people have been honest townsmen, well-reputed for long; why should you readily
take such humbling from a sojourner of whom th’ ‘st know nothing?’

They remained in constrained converse till her quick ear caught a sound, for which she might have been waiting — a
horse’s footfall. ‘It is John!’ said she. ‘This is his night — Saturday.’

‘Don’t be frightened lest he should find me here!’ said Roger. ‘I am on the point of leaving. I wish not to be a
third party. Say nothing at all about my visit, if it will incommode you so to do. I will see thee before I go afloat
again.’

Speaking thus he left the room, and descending the staircase let himself out by the front door, thinking he might
obtain a glimpse of the approaching horseman. But that traveller had in the meantime gone stealthily round to the back
of the homestead, and peering along the pinion-end of the house Roger discerned him unbridling and haltering his horse
with his own hands in the shed there.

Roger retired to the neighbouring inn called the Black Lamb, and meditated. This mysterious method of approach
determined him, after all, not to leave the place till he had ascertained more definite facts of his sister’s position
— whether she were the deluded victim of the stranger or the wife she obviously believed herself to be. Having eaten
some supper, he left the inn, it being now about eleven o’clock. He first looked into the shed, and, finding the horse
still standing there, waited irresolutely near the door of his sister’s lodging. Half an hour elapsed, and, while
thinking he would climb into a loft hard by for a night’s rest, there seemed to be a movement within the shutters of
the sitting-room that his sister occupied. Roger hid himself behind a faggot-stack near the back door, rightly divining
that his sister’s visitor would emerge by the way he had entered. The door opened, and the candle she held in her hand
lighted for a moment the stranger’s form, showing it to be that of a tall and handsome personage, about forty years of
age, and apparently of a superior position in life. Edith was assisting him to cloak himself, which being done he took
leave of her with a kiss and left the house. From the door she watched him bridle and saddle his horse, and having
mounted and waved an adieu to her as she stood candle in hand, he turned out of the yard and rode away.

The horse which bore him was, or seemed to be, a little lame, and Roger fancied from this that the rider’s journey
was not likely to be a long one. Being light of foot he followed apace, having no great difficulty on such a still
night in keeping within earshot some few miles, the horseman pausing more than once. In this pursuit Roger discovered
the rider to choose bridle-tracks and open commons in preference to any high road. The distance soon began to prove a
more trying one than he had bargained for; and when out of breath and in some despair of being able to ascertain the
man’s identity, he perceived an ass standing in the starlight under a hayrick, from which the animal was helping itself
to periodic mouthfuls.

The story goes that Roger caught the ass, mounted, and again resumed the trail of the unconscious horseman, which
feat may have been possible to a nautical young fellow, though one can hardly understand how a sailor would ride such
an animal without bridle or saddle, and strange to his hands, unless the creature were extraordinarily docile. This
question, however, is immaterial. Suffice it to say that at dawn the following morning Roger beheld his sister’s lover
or husband entering the gates of a large and well-timbered park on the south-western verge of the White Hart Forest (as
it was then called), now known to everybody as the Vale of Blackmoor. Thereupon the sailor discarded his steed, and
finding for himself an obscurer entrance to the same park a little further on, he crossed the grass to reconnoitre.

He presently perceived amid the trees before him a mansion which, new to himself, was one of the best known in the
county at that time. Of this fine manorial residence hardly a trace now remains; but a manuscript dated some years
later than the events we are regarding describes it in terms from which the imagination may construct a singularly
clear and vivid picture. This record presents it as consisting of ‘a faire yellow freestone building, partly two and
partly three storeys; a faire halle and parlour, both waynscotted; a faire dyning roome and withdrawing roome, and many
good lodgings; a kitchen adjoyninge backwarde to one end of the dwelling-house, with a faire passage from it into the
halle, parlour, and dyninge roome, and sellars adjoyninge.

‘In the front of the house a square greene court, and a curious gatehouse with lodgings in it, standing with the
front of the house to the south; in a large outer court three stables, a coach-house, a large barne, and a stable for
oxen and kyne, and all houses necessary.

‘Without the gatehouse, paled in, a large square greene, in which standeth a faire chappell; of the south-east side
of the greene court, towards the river, a large garden.

‘Of the south-west side of the greene court is a large bowling greene, with fower mounted walks about it, all walled
about with a batteled wall, and sett with all sorts of fruit; and out of it into the feildes there are large walks
under many tall elmes orderly planted.’

Then follows a description of the orchards and gardens; the servants’ offices, brewhouse, bakehouse, dairy,
pigeon-houses, and corn-mill; the river and its abundance of fish; the warren, the coppices, the walks; ending
thus —

‘And all the country north of the house, open champaign, sandy feildes, very dry and pleasant for all kindes of
recreation, huntinge, and hawkinge, and profitble for tillage . . . The house hath a large prospect east,
south, and west, over a very large and pleasant vale . . . is seated from the good markett towns of Sherton
Abbas three miles, and Ivel a mile, that plentifully yield all manner of provision; and within twelve miles of the
south sea.’

It was on the grass before this seductive and picturesque structure that the sailor stood at gaze under the elms in
the dim dawn of Sunday morning, and saw to his surprise his sister’s lover and horse vanish within the court of the
building.

Perplexed and weary, Roger slowly retreated, more than ever convinced that something was wrong in his sister’s
position. He crossed the bowling green to the avenue of elms, and, bent on further research, was about to climb into
one of these, when, looking below, he saw a heap of hay apparently for horses or deer. Into this he crept, and, having
eaten a crust of bread which he had hastily thrust into his pocket at the inn, he curled up and fell asleep, the hay
forming a comfortable bed, and quite covering him over.

He slept soundly and long, and was awakened by the sound of a bell. On peering from the hay he found the time had
advanced to full day; the sun was shining brightly. The bell was that of the ‘faire chappell’ on the green outside the
gatehouse, and it was calling to matins. Presently the priest crossed the green to a little side-door in the chancel,
and then from the gateway of the mansion emerged the household, the tall man whom Roger had seen with his sister on the
previous night, on his arm being a portly dame, and, running beside the pair, two little girls and a boy. These all
entered the chapel, and the bell having ceased and the environs become clear, the sailor crept out from his hiding.

He sauntered towards the chapel, the opening words of the service being audible within. While standing by the porch
he saw a belated servitor approaching from the kitchen-court to attend the service also. Roger carelessly accosted him,
and asked, as an idle wanderer, the name of the family he had just seen cross over from the mansion.

‘Od zounds! if ye modden be a stranger here in very truth, goodman. That wer Sir John and his dame, and his children
Elizabeth, Mary, and John.’

‘I be from foreign parts. Sir John what d’ye call’n?’

‘Master John Horseleigh, Knight, who had a’most as much lond by inheritance of his mother as ‘a had by his father,
and likewise some by his wife. Why, bain’t his arms dree goolden horses’ heads, and idden his lady the daughter of
Master Richard Phelipson, of Montislope, in Nether Wessex, known to us all?’

‘It mid be so, and yet it mid not. However, th’ ‘lt miss thy prayers for such an honest knight’s welfare, and I have
to traipse seaward many miles.’

He went onward, and as he walked continued saying to himself, ‘Now to that poor wronged fool Edy. The fond thing! I
thought it; ’twas too quick — she was ever amorous. What’s to become of her! God wot! How be I going to face her with
the news, and how be I to hold it from her? To bring this disgrace on my father’s honoured name, a double-tongued
knave!’ He turned and shook his fist at the chapel and all in it, and resumed his way.

Perhaps it was owing to the perplexity of his mind that, instead of returning by the direct road towards his
sister’s obscure lodging in the next county, he followed the highway to Casterbridge, some fifteen miles off, where he
remained drinking hard all that afternoon and evening, and where he lay that and two or three succeeding nights,
wandering thence along the Anglebury road to some village that way, and lying the Friday night after at his native
place of Havenpool. The sight of the familiar objects there seems to have stirred him anew to action, and the next
morning he was observed pursuing the way to Oozewood that he had followed on the Saturday previous, reckoning, no
doubt, that Saturday night would, as before, be a time for finding Sir John with his sister again.

He delayed to reach the place till just before sunset. His sister was walking in the meadows at the foot of the
garden, with a nursemaid who carried the baby, and she looked up pensively when he approached. Anxiety as to her
position had already told upon her once rosy cheeks and lucid eyes. But concern for herself and child was displaced for
the moment by her regard of Roger’s worn and haggard face.

‘Why — you are sick, Roger — you are tired! Where have you been these many days? Why not keep me company a bit — my
husband is much away? And we have hardly spoke at all of dear father and of your voyage to the New Land. Why did you go
away so suddenly? There is a spare chamber at my lodging.’

‘Come indoors,’ he said. ‘We’ll talk now — talk a good deal. As for him [nodding to the child], better heave him
into the river; better for him and you!’

She forced a laugh, as if she tried to see a good joke in the remark, and they went silently indoors.

‘A miserable hole!’ said Roger, looking round the room.

‘Nay, but ’tis very pretty!’

‘Not after what I’ve seen. Did he marry ‘ee at church in orderly fashion?’

‘He did sure — at our church at Havenpool.’

‘But in a privy way?’

‘Ay — because of his friends — it was at night-time.’

‘Ede, ye fond one — for all that he’s not thy husband! Th’ ‘rt not his wife; and the child is a bastard. He hath a
wife and children of his own rank, and bearing his name; and that’s Sir John Horseleigh, of Clyfton Horseleigh, and not
plain Jack, as you think him, and your lawful husband. The sacrament of marriage is no safeguard nowadays. The King’s
new-made headship of the Church hath led men to practise these tricks lightly.’

She had turned white. ‘That’s not true, Roger!’ she said. ‘You are in liquor, my brother, and you know not what you
say! Your seafaring years have taught ‘ee bad things!’

‘Edith — I’ve seen them; wife and family — all. How canst —’

They were sitting in the gathered darkness, and at that moment steps were heard without. ‘Go out this way,’ she
said. ‘It is my husband. He must not see thee in this mood. Get away till tomorrow, Roger, as you care for me.’

She pushed her brother through a door leading to the back stairs, and almost as soon as it was closed her visitor
entered. Roger, however, did not retreat down the stairs; he stood and looked through the bobbin-hole. If the visitor
turned out to be Sir John, he had determined to confront him.

It was the knight. She had struck a light on his entry, and he kissed the child, and took Edith tenderly by the
shoulders, looking into her face.

‘O, Jack!’ she cried. ‘I have heard such a fearsome rumour — what doth it mean? He who told me is my best friend. He
must be deceived! But who deceived him, and why? Jack, I was just told that you had a wife living when you married me,
and have her still!’

‘A wife? — H’m.’

‘Yes, and children. Say no, say no!’

‘By God! I have no lawful wife but you; and as for children, many or few, they are all bastards, save this one
alone!’

‘And that you be Sir John Horseleigh of Clyfton?’

‘I mid be. I have never said so to ‘ee.’

‘But Sir John is known to have a lady, and issue of her!’

The knight looked down. ‘How did thy mind get filled with such as this?’ he asked.

‘One of my kindred came.’

‘A traitor! Why should he mar our life? Ah! you said you had a brother at sea — where is he now?’

‘Here!’ came from close behind him. And flinging open the door, Roger faced the intruder. ‘Liar!’ he said, ‘to call
thyself her husband!’

Sir John fired up, and made a rush at the sailor, who seized him by the collar, and in the wrestle they both fell,
Roger under. But in a few seconds he contrived to extricate his right arm, and drawing from his belt a knife which he
wore attached to a cord round his neck he opened it with his teeth, and struck it into the breast of Sir John stretched
above him. Edith had during these moments run into the next room to place the child in safety, and when she came back
the knight was relaxing his hold on Roger’s throat. He rolled over upon his back and groaned.

The only witness of the scene save the three concerned was the nursemaid, who had brought in the child on its
father’s arrival. She stated afterwards that nobody suspected Sir John had received his death wound; yet it was so,
though he did not die for a long while, meaning thereby an hour or two; that Mistress Edith continually endeavoured to
staunch the blood, calling her brother Roger a wretch, and ordering him to get himself gone; on which order he acted,
after a gloomy pause, by opening the window, and letting himself down by the sill to the ground.

It was then that Sir John, in difficult accents, made his dying declaration to the nurse and Edith, and, later, the
apothecary; which was to this purport, that the Dame Horseleigh who passed as his wife at Clyfton, and who had borne
him three children, was in truth and deed, though unconsciously, the wife of another man. Sir John had married her
several years before, in the face of the whole county, as the widow of one Decimus Strong, who had disappeared shortly
after her union with him, having adventured to the North to join the revolt of the Nobles, and on that revolt being
quelled retreated across the sea. Two years ago, having discovered this man to be still living in France, and not
wishing to disturb the mind and happiness of her who believed herself his wife, yet wishing for legitimate issue, Sir
John had informed the King of the facts, who had encouraged him to wed honestly, though secretly, the young merchant’s
widow at Havenpool; she being, therefore, his lawful wife, and she only. That to avoid all scandal and hubbub he had
purposed to let things remain as they were till fair opportunity should arise of making the true case known with least
pain to all parties concerned, but that, having been thus suspected and attacked by his own brother-inlaw, his zest for
such schemes and for all things had died out in him, and he only wished to commend his soul to God.

That night, while the owls were hooting from the forest that encircled the sleeping townlet, and the South–Avon was
gurgling through the wooden piles of the bridge, Sir John died there in the arms of his wife. She concealed nothing of
the cause of her husband’s death save the subject of the quarrel, which she felt it would be premature to announce just
then, and until proof of her status should be forthcoming. But before a month had passed, it happened, to her
inexpressible sorrow, that the child of this clandestine union fell sick and died. From that hour all interest in the
name and fame of the Horseleighs forsook the younger of the twain who called themselves wives of Sir John, and, being
careless about her own fame, she took no steps to assert her claims, her legal position having, indeed, grown hateful
to her in her horror at the tragedy. And Sir William Byrt, the curate who had married her to her husband, being an old
man and feeble, was not disinclined to leave the embers unstirred of such a fiery matter as this, and to assist her in
letting established things stand. Therefore, Edith retired with the nurse, her only companion and friend, to her native
town, where she lived in absolute obscurity till her death in middle age. Her brother was never seen again in
England.

A strangely corroborative sequel to the story remains to be told. Shortly after the death of Sir John Horseleigh, a
soldier of fortune returned from the Continent, called on Dame Horseleigh the fictitious, living in widowed state at
Clyfton Horseleigh, and, after a singularly brief courtship, married her. The tradition at Havenpool and elsewhere has
ever been that this man was already her husband, Decimus Strong, who remarried her for appearance’ sake only.

The illegitimate son of this lady by Sir John succeeded to the estates and honours, and his son after him, there
being nobody on the alert to investigate their pretensions. Little difference would it have made to the present
generation, however, had there been such a one, for the family in all its branches, lawful and unlawful, has been
extinct these many score years, the last representative but one being killed at the siege of Sherton Castle, while
attacking in the service of the Parliament, and the other being outlawed later in the same century for a debt of ten
pounds, and dying in the county jail. The mansion house and its appurtenances were, as I have previously stated,
destroyed, excepting one small wing, which now forms part of a farmhouse, and is visible as you pass along the railway
from Casterbridge to Ivel. The outline of the old bowling-green is also distinctly to be seen.

This, then, is the reason why the only lawful marriage of Sir John, as recorded in the obscure register at
Havenpool, does not appear in the pedigree of the house of Horseleigh.

Spring 1893.

The Duke’s Reappearance — a Family Tradition

According to the kinsman who told me the story, Christopher Swetman’s house, on the outskirts of King’s-Hintock
village, was in those days larger and better kept than when, many years later, it was sold to the lord of the manor
adjoining; after having been in the Swetman family, as one may say, since the Conquest.

Some people would have it to be that the thing happened at the house opposite, belonging to one Childs, with whose
family the Swetmans afterwards intermarried. But that it was at the original homestead of the Swetmans can be shown in
various ways; chiefly by the unbroken traditions of the family, and indirectly by the evidence of the walls themselves,
which are the only ones thereabout with windows mullioned in the Elizabethan manner, and plainly of a date anterior to
the event; while those of the other house might well have been erected fifty or eighty years later, and probably were;
since the choice of Swetman’s house by the fugitive was doubtless dictated by no other circumstance than its then
suitable loneliness.

It was a cloudy July morning just before dawn, the hour of two having been struck by Swetman’s one-handed clock on
the stairs, that is still preserved in the family. Christopher heard the strokes from his chamber, immediately at the
top of the staircase, and overlooking the front of the house. He did not wonder that he was sleepless. The rumours and
excitements which had latterly stirred the neighbourhood, to the effect that the rightful King of England had landed
from Holland, at a port only eighteen miles to the south-west of Swetman’s house, were enough to make wakeful and
anxious even a contented yeoman like him. Some of the villagers, intoxicated by the news, had thrown down their
scythes, and rushed to the ranks of the invader. Christopher Swetman had weighed both sides of the question, and had
remained at home.

Now as he lay thinking of these and other things he fancied that he could hear the footfall of a man on the road
leading up to his house — a byway, which led scarce anywhere else; and therefore a tread was at any time more apt to
startle the inmates of the homestead than if it had stood in a thoroughfare. The footfall came opposite the gate, and
stopped there. One minute, two minutes passed, and the pedestrian did not proceed. Christopher Swetman got out of bed,
and opened the casement. ‘Hoi! who’s there?’ cries he.

‘A friend,’ came from the darkness.

‘And what mid ye want at this time o’ night?’ says Swetman.

‘Shelter. I’ve lost my way.’

‘What’s thy name?’

There came no answer.

‘Be ye one of King Monmouth’s men?’

‘He that asks no questions will hear no lies from me. I am a stranger; and I am spent, and hungered. Can you let me
lie with you to-night?’

Swetman was generous to people in trouble, and his house was roomy. ‘Wait a bit,’ he said, ‘and I’ll come down and
have a look at thee, anyhow.’

He struck a light, put on his clothes, and descended, taking his horn-lantern from a nail in the passage, and
lighting it before opening the door. The rays fell on the form of a tall, dark man in cavalry accoutrements and wearing
a sword. He was pale with fatigue and covered with mud, though the weather was dry.

‘Prithee take no heed of my appearance,’ said the stranger. ‘But let me in.’

That his visitor was in sore distress admitted of no doubt, and the yeoman’s natural humanity assisted the other’s
sad importunity and gentle voice. Swetman took him in, not without a suspicion that this man represented in some way
Monmouth’s cause, to which he was not unfriendly in his secret heart. At his earnest request the new-comer was given a
suit of the yeoman’s old clothes in exchange for his own, which, with his sword, were hidden in a closet in Swetman’s
chamber; food was then put before him and a lodging provided for him in a room at the back.

Here he slept till quite late in the morning, which was Sunday, the sixth of July, and when he came down in the
garments that he had borrowed he met the household with a melancholy smile. Besides Swetman himself, there were only
his two daughters, Grace and Leonard (the latter was, oddly enough, a woman’s name here), and both had been enjoined to
secrecy. They asked no questions and received no information; though the stranger regarded their fair countenances with
an interest almost too deep. Having partaken of their usual breakfast of ham and cider he professed weariness and
retired to the chamber whence he had come.

In a couple of hours or thereabout he came down again, the two young women having now gone off to morning service.
Seeing Christopher bustling about the house without assistance, he asked if he could do anything to aid his host.

As he seemed anxious to hide all differences and appear as one of themselves, Swetman set him to get vegetables from
the garden and fetch water from Buttock’s Spring in the dip near the house (though the spring was not called by that
name till years after, by the way).

‘And what can I do next?’ says the stranger when these services had been performed.

His meekness and docility struck Christopher much, and won upon him. ‘Since you be minded to,’ says the latter, ‘you
can take down the dishes and spread the table for dinner. Take a pewter plate for thyself, but the trenchers will do
for we.’

But the other would not, and took a trencher likewise, in doing which he spoke of the two girls and remarked how
comely they were.

This quietude was put an end to by a stir out of doors, which was sufficient to draw Swetman’s attention to it, and
he went out. Farm hands who had gone off and joined the Duke on his arrival had begun to come in with news that a
midnight battle had been fought on the moors to the north, the Duke’s men, who had attacked, being entirely worsted;
the Duke himself, with one or two lords and other friends, had fled, no one knew whither.

‘There has been a battle,’ says Swetman, on coming indoors after these tidings, and looking earnestly at the
stranger.

‘May the victory be to the rightful in the end, whatever the issue now,’ says the other, with a sorrowful sigh.

‘Dost really know nothing about it?’ said Christopher. ‘I could have sworn you was one from that very battle!’

‘I was here before three o’ the clock this morning; and these men have only arrived now.’

‘True,’ said the yeoman. ‘But still, I think —’

‘Do not press your question,’ the stranger urged. ‘I am in a strait, and can refuse a helper nothing; such inquiry
is, therefore, unfair.’

‘True again,’ said Swetman, and held his tongue.

The daughters of the house returned from church, where the service had been hurried by reason of the excitement. To
their father’s questioning if they had spoken of him who sojourned there they replied that they had said never a word;
which, indeed, was true, as events proved.

He bade them serve the dinner; and, as the visitor had withdrawn since the news of the battle, prepared to take a
platter to him upstairs. But he preferred to come down and dine with the family.

During the afternoon more fugitives passed through the village, but Christopher Swetman, his visitor, and his family
kept indoors. In the evening, however, Swetman came out from his gate, and, harkening in silence to these tidings and
more, wondered what might be in store for him for his last night’s work.

He returned homeward by a path across the mead that skirted his own orchard. Passing here, he heard the voice of his
daughter Leonard expostulating inside the hedge, her words being: ‘Don’t ye, sir; don’t! I prithee let me go!’

‘Why, sweetheart?’

‘Because I’ve a-promised another!’

Peeping through, as he could not help doing, he saw the girl struggling in the arms of the stranger, who was
attempting to kiss her; but finding her resistance to be genuine, and her distress unfeigned, he reluctantly let her
go.

Swetman’s face grew dark, for his girls were more to him than himself. He hastened on, meditating moodily all the
way. He entered the gate, and made straight for the orchard. When he reached it his daughter had disappeared, but the
stranger was still standing there.

‘Sir!’ said the yeoman, his anger having in no wise abated, ‘I’ve seen what has happened! I have taken ‘ee into my
house, at some jeopardy to myself; and, whoever you be, the least I expected of ‘ee was to treat the maidens with a
seemly respect. You have not done it, and I no longer trust you. I am the more watchful over them in that they are
motherless; and I must ask ‘ee to go after dark this night!’

The stranger seemed dazed at discovering what his impulse had brought down upon his head, and his pale face grew
paler. He did not reply for a time. When he did speak his soft voice was thick with feeling.

‘Sir,’ says he, ‘I own that I am in the wrong, if you take the matter gravely. We do not what we would but what we
must. Though I have not injured your daughter as a woman, I have been treacherous to her as a hostess and friend in
need. I’ll go, as you say; I can do no less. I shall doubtless find a refuge elsewhere.’

They walked towards the house in silence, where Swetman insisted that his guest should have supper before departing.
By the time this was eaten it was dusk and the stranger announced that he was ready.

They went upstairs to where the garments and sword lay hidden, till the departing one said that on further thought
he would ask another favour: that he should be allowed to retain the clothes he wore, and that his host would keep the
others and the sword till he, the speaker, should come or send for them.

‘As you will,’ said Swetman. ‘The gain is on my side; for those clouts were but kept to dress a scarecrow next
fall.’

‘They suit my case,’ said the stranger sadly. ‘However much they may misfit me, they do not misfit my sorry fortune
now!’

But the other would not, saying that it was better that things should take their course. Notwithstanding that
Swetman importuned him, he only added, ‘If I never come again, do with my belongings as you list. In the pocket you
will find a gold snuff-box, and in the snuff-box fifty gold pieces.’

‘But keep ’em for thy use, man!’ said the yeoman.

‘No,’ says the parting guest; ‘they are foreign pieces and would harm me if I were taken. Do as I bid thee. Put away
these things again and take especial charge of the sword. It belonged to my father’s father and I value it much. But
something more common becomes me now.’

Saying which, he took, as he went downstairs, one of the ash sticks used by Swetman himself for walking with. The
yeoman lighted him out to the garden hatch, where he disappeared through Clammers Gate by the road that crosses
King’s-Hintock Park to Evershead.

Christopher returned to the upstairs chamber, and sat down on his bed reflecting. Then he examined the things left
behind, and surely enough in one of the pockets the gold snuff-box was revealed, containing the fifty gold pieces as
stated by the fugitive. The yeoman next looked at the sword which its owner had stated to have belonged to his
grandfather. It was two-edged, so that he almost feared to handle it. On the blade was inscribed the words ‘ANDREA
FERARA,’ and among the many fine chasings were a rose and crown, the plume of the Prince of Wales, and two portraits;
portraits of a man and a woman, the man’s having the face of the first King Charles, and the woman’s, apparently, that
of his Queen.

Swetman, much awed and surprised, returned the articles to the closet, and went downstairs pondering. Of his surmise
he said nothing to his daughters, merely declaring to them that the gentleman was gone; and never revealing that he had
been an eye-witness of the unpleasant scene in the orchard that was the immediate cause of the departure.

Nothing occurred in Hintock during the week that followed, beyond the fitful arrival of more decided tidings
concerning the utter defeat of the Duke’s army and his own disappearance at an early stage of the battle. Then it was
told that Monmouth was taken, not in his own clothes but in the disguise of a countryman. He had been sent to London,
and was confined in the Tower.

The possibility that his guest had been no other than the Duke made Swetman unspeakably sorry now; his heart smote
him at the thought that, acting so harshly for such a small breach of good faith, he might have been the means of
forwarding the unhappy fugitive’s capture. On the girls coming up to him he said, ‘Get away with ye, wenches: I fear
you have been the ruin of an unfortunate man!’

On the Tuesday night following, when the yeoman was sleeping as usual in his chamber, he was, he said, conscious of
the entry of some one. Opening his eyes, he beheld by the light of the moon, which shone upon the front of his house,
the figure of a man who seemed to be the stranger moving from the door towards the closet. He was dressed somewhat
differently now, but the face was quite that of his late guest in its tragical pensiveness, as was also the tallness of
his figure. He neared the closet; and, feeling his visitor to be within his rights, Christopher refrained from
stirring. The personage turned his large haggard eyes upon the bed where Swetman lay, and then withdrew from their
hiding the articles that belonged to him, again giving a hard gaze at Christopher as he went noiselessly out of the
chamber with his properties on his arm. His retreat down the stairs was just audible, and also his departure by the
side door, through which entrance or exit was easy to those who knew the place.

Nothing further happened, and towards morning Swetman slept. To avoid all risk he said not a word to the girls of
the visit of the night, and certainly not to any one outside the house; for it was dangerous at that time to avow
anything.

Among the killed in opposing the recent rising had been a younger brother of the lord of the manor, who lived at
King’s-Hintock Court hard by. Seeing the latter ride past in mourning clothes next day, Swetman ventured to condole
with him.

‘He’d no business there!’ answered the other. His words and manner showed the bitterness that was mingled with his
regret. ‘But say no more of him. You know what has happened since, I suppose?’

‘I know that they say Monmouth is taken, Sir Thomas, but I can’t think it true,’ answered Swetman.

‘O zounds! ’tis true enough,’ cried the knight, ‘and that’s not all. The Duke was executed on Tower Hill two days
ago.’

‘D’ye say it verily?’ says Swetman.

‘And a very hard death he had, worse luck for ‘n,’ said Sir Thomas. ‘Well, ’tis over for him and over for my
brother. But not for the rest. There’ll be searchings and siftings down here anon; and happy is the man who has had
nothing to do with this matter!’

Now Swetman had hardly heard the latter words, so much was he confounded by the strangeness of the tidings that the
Duke had come to his death on the previous Tuesday. For it had been only the night before this present day of Friday
that he had seen his former guest, whom he had ceased to doubt could be other than the Duke, come into his chamber and
fetch away his accoutrements as he had promised.

‘It couldn’t have been a vision,’ said Christopher to himself when the knight had ridden on. ‘But I’ll go straight
and see if the things be in the closet still; and thus I shall surely learn if ’twere a vision or no.’

To the closet he went, which he had not looked into since the stranger’s departure. And searching behind the
articles placed to conceal the things hidden, he found that, as he had never doubted, they were gone.

When the rumour spread abroad in the West that the man beheaded in the Tower was not indeed the Duke, but one of his
officers taken after the battle, and that the Duke had been assisted to escape out of the country, Swetman found in it
an explanation of what so deeply mystified him. That his visitor might have been a friend of the Duke’s, whom the Duke
had asked to fetch the things in a last request, Swetman would never admit. His belief in the rumour that Monmouth
lived, like that of thousands of others, continued to the end of his days.

* * * *

Such, briefly, concluded my kinsman, is the tradition which has been handed down in Christopher Swetman’s family for
the last two hundred years.

A Mere Interlude

Chapter I

The traveller in school-books, who vouched in dryest tones for the fidelity to fact of the following narrative, used
to add a ring of truth to it by opening with a nicety of criticism on the heroine’s personality. People were wrong, he
declared, when they surmised that Baptista Trewthen was a young woman with scarcely emotions or character. There was
nothing in her to love, and nothing to hate — so ran the general opinion. That she showed few positive qualities was
true. The colours and tones which changing events paint on the faces of active womankind were looked for in vain upon
hers. But still waters run deep; and no crisis had come in the years of her early maidenhood to demonstrate what lay
hidden within her, like metal in a mine.

She was the daughter of a small farmer in St. Maria’s, one of the Isles of Lyonesse beyond Off–Wessex, who had spent
a large sum, as there understood, on her education, by sending her to the mainland for two years. At nineteen she was
entered at the Training College for Teachers, and at twenty-one nominated to a school in the country, near
Tor-upon-Sea, whither she proceeded after the Christmas examination and holidays.

The months passed by from winter to spring and summer, and Baptista applied herself to her new duties as best she
could, till an uneventful year had elapsed. Then an air of abstraction pervaded her bearing as she walked to and fro,
twice a day, and she showed the traits of a person who had something on her mind. A widow, by name Mrs. Wace, in whose
house Baptista Trewthen had been provided with a sitting-room and bedroom till the school-house should be built,
noticed this change in her youthful tenant’s manner, and at last ventured to press her with a few questions.

‘It has nothing to do with the place, nor with you,’ said Miss Trewthen.

‘Then it is the salary?’

‘No, nor the salary.’

‘Then it is something you have heard from home, my dear.’

Baptista was silent for a few moments. ‘It is Mr. Heddegan,’ she murmured. ‘Him they used to call David Heddegan
before he got his money.’

‘And who is the Mr. Heddegan they used to call David?’

‘An old bachelor at Giant’s Town, St. Maria’s, with no relations whatever, who lives about a stone’s throw from
father’s. When I was a child he used to take me on his knee and say he’d marry me some day. Now I am a woman the jest
has turned earnest, and he is anxious to do it. And father and mother says I can’t do better than have him.’

‘He’s well off?’

‘Yes — he’s the richest man we know — as a friend and neighbour.’

‘How much older did you say he was than yourself?’

‘I didn’t say. Twenty years at least.’

‘And an unpleasant man in the bargain perhaps?’

‘No — he’s not unpleasant.’

‘Well, child, all I can say is that I’d resist any such engagement if it’s not palatable to ‘ee. You are comfortable
here, in my little house, I hope. All the parish like ‘ee: and I’ve never been so cheerful, since my poor husband left
me to wear his wings, as I’ve been with ‘ee as my lodger.’

The schoolmistress assured her landlady that she could return the sentiment. ‘But here comes my perplexity,’ she
said. ‘I don’t like keeping school. Ah, you are surprised — you didn’t suspect it. That’s because I’ve concealed my
feeling. Well, I simply hate school. I don’t care for children — they are unpleasant, troublesome little things, whom
nothing would delight so much as to hear that you had fallen down dead. Yet I would even put up with them if it was not
for the inspector. For three months before his visit I didn’t sleep soundly. And the Committee of Council are always
changing the Code, so that you don’t know what to teach, and what to leave untaught. I think father and mother are
right. They say I shall never excel as a schoolmistress if I dislike the work so, and that therefore I ought to get
settled by marrying Mr. Heddegan. Between us two, I like him better than school; but I don’t like him quite so much as
to wish to marry him.’

These conversations, once begun, were continued from day to day; till at length the young girl’s elderly friend and
landlady threw in her opinion on the side of Miss Trewthen’s parents. All things considered, she declared, the
uncertainty of the school, the labour, Baptista’s natural dislike for teaching, it would be as well to take what fate
offered, and make the best of matters by wedding her father’s old neighbour and prosperous friend.

The Easter holidays came round, and Baptista went to spend them as usual in her native isle, going by train into
Off–Wessex and crossing by packet from Pen-zephyr. When she returned in the middle of April her face wore a more
settled aspect.

‘Well?’ said the expectant Mrs. Wace.

‘I have agreed to have him as my husband,’ said Baptista, in an off-hand way. ‘Heaven knows if it will be for the
best or not. But I have agreed to do it, and so the matter is settled.’

Mrs. Wace commended her; but Baptista did not care to dwell on the subject; so that allusion to it was very
infrequent between them. Nevertheless, among other things, she repeated to the widow from time to time in monosyllabic
remarks that the wedding was really impending; that it was arranged for the summer, and that she had given notice of
leaving the school at the August holidays. Later on she announced more specifically that her marriage was to take place
immediately after her return home at the beginning of the month aforesaid.

She now corresponded regularly with Mr. Heddegan. Her letters from him were seen, at least on the outside, and in
part within, by Mrs. Wace. Had she read more of their interiors than the occasional sentences shown her by Baptista she
would have perceived that the scratchy, rusty handwriting of Miss Trewthen’s betrothed conveyed little more matter than
details of their future housekeeping, and his preparations for the same, with innumerable ‘my dears’ sprinkled in
disconnectedly, to show the depth of his affection without the inconveniences of syntax.

Chapter II

It was the end of July — dry, too dry, even for the season, the delicate green herbs and vegetables that grew in
this favoured end of the kingdom tasting rather of the watering-pot than of the pure fresh moisture from the skies.
Baptista’s boxes were packed, and one Saturday morning she departed by a waggonette to the station, and thence by train
to Pen-zephyr, from which port she was, as usual, to cross the water immediately to her home, and become Mr. Heddegan’s
wife on the Wednesday of the week following.

She might have returned a week sooner. But though the wedding day had loomed so near, and the banns were out, she
delayed her departure till this last moment, saying it was not necessary for her to be at home long beforehand. As Mr.
Heddegan was older than herself, she said, she was to be married in her ordinary summer bonnet and grey silk frock, and
there were no preparations to make that had not been amply made by her parents and intended husband.

In due time, after a hot and tedious journey, she reached Pen-zephyr. She here obtained some refreshment, and then
went towards the pier, where she learnt to her surprise that the little steamboat plying between the town and the
islands had left at eleven o’clock; the usual hour of departure in the afternoon having been forestalled in consequence
of the fogs which had for a few days prevailed towards evening, making twilight navigation dangerous.

This being Saturday, there was now no other boat till Tuesday, and it became obvious that here she would have to
remain for the three days, unless her friends should think fit to rig out one of the island’ sailing-boats and come to
fetch her — a not very likely contingency, the sea distance being nearly forty miles.

Baptista, however, had been detained in Pen-zephyr on more than one occasion before, either on account of bad
weather or some such reason as the present, and she was therefore not in any personal alarm. But, as she was to be
married on the following Wednesday, the delay was certainly inconvenient to a more than ordinary degree, since it would
leave less than a day’s interval between her arrival and the wedding ceremony.

Apart from this awkwardness she did not much mind the accident. It was indeed curious to see how little she minded.
Perhaps it would not be too much to say that, although she was going to do the critical deed of her life quite
willingly, she experienced an indefinable relief at the postponement of her meeting with Heddegan. But her manner after
making discovery of the hindrance was quiet and subdued, even to passivity itself; as was instanced by her having, at
the moment of receiving information that the steamer had sailed, replied ‘Oh,’ so coolly to the porter with her
luggage, that he was almost disappointed at her lack of disappointment.

The question now was, should she return again to Mrs. Wace, in the village of Lower Wessex, or wait in the town at
which she had arrived. She would have preferred to go back, but the distance was too great; moreover, having left the
place for good, and somewhat dramatically, to become a bride, a return, even for so short a space, would have been a
trifle humiliating.

Leaving, then, her boxes at the station, her next anxiety was to secure a respectable, or rather genteel, lodging in
the popular seaside resort confronting her. To this end she looked about the town, in which, though she had passed
through it half-a-dozen times, she was practically a stranger.

Baptista found a room to suit her over a fruiterer’s shop; where she made herself at home, and set herself in order
after her journey. An early cup of tea having revived her spirits she walked out to reconnoitre.

Being a schoolmistress she avoided looking at the schools, and having a sort of trade connection with books, she
avoided looking at the booksellers; but wearying of the other shops she inspected the churches; not that for her own
part she cared much about ecclesiastical edifices; but tourists looked at them, and so would she — a proceeding for
which no one would have credited her with any great originality, such, for instance, as that she subsequently showed
herself to possess. The churches soon oppressed her. She tried the Museum, but came out because it seemed lonely and
tedious.

Yet the town and the walks in this land of strawberries, these headquarters of early English flowers and fruit, were
then, as always, attractive. From the more picturesque streets she went to the town gardens, and the Pier, and the
Harbour, and looked at the men at work there, loading and unloading as in the time of the Phoenicians.

‘Not Baptista? Yes, Baptista it is!’

The words were uttered behind her. Turning round she gave a start, and became confused, even agitated, for a moment.
Then she said in her usual undemonstrative manner, ‘O— is it really you, Charles?’

Without speaking again at once, and with a half-smile, the new-comer glanced her over. There was much criticism, and
some resentment — even temper — in his eye.

‘I am going home,’ continued she. ‘But I have missed the boat.’

He scarcely seemed to take in the meaning of this explanation, in the intensity of his critical survey. ‘Teaching
still? What a fine schoolmistress you make, Baptista, I warrant!’ he said with a slight flavour of sarcasm, which was
not lost upon her.

‘I know I am nothing to brag of,’ she replied. ‘That’s why I have given up.’

‘O— given up? You astonish me.’

‘I hate the profession.’

‘Perhaps that’s because I am in it.’

‘O no, it isn’t. But I am going to enter on another life altogether. I am going to be married next week to Mr. David
Heddegan.’

The young man — fortified as he was by a natural cynical pride and passionateness — winced at this unexpected reply,
notwithstanding.

‘Who is Mr. David Heddegan?’ he asked, as indifferently as lay in his power.

She informed him the bearer of the name was a general merchant of Giant’s Town, St. Maria’s island — her father’s
nearest neighbour and oldest friend.

‘Then we shan’t see anything more of you on the mainland?’ inquired the schoolmaster.

‘O, I don’t know about that,’ said Miss Trewthen.

‘Here endeth the career of the belle of the boarding-school your father was foolish enough to send you to. A
“general merchant’s” wife in the Lyonesse Isles. Will you sell pounds of soap and pennyworths of tin tacks, or whole
bars of saponaceous matter, and great tenpenny nails?’

‘He’s not in such a small way as that!’ she almost pleaded. ‘He owns ships, though they are rather little ones!’

‘O, well, it is much the same. Come, let us walk on; it is tedious to stand still. I thought you would be a failure
in education,’ he continued, when she obeyed him and strolled ahead. ‘You never showed power that way. You remind me
much of some of those women who think they are sure to be great actresses if they go on the stage, because they have a
pretty face, and forget that what we require is acting. But you found your mistake, didn’t you?’

‘Don’t taunt me, Charles.’ It was noticeable that the young schoolmaster’s tone caused her no anger or retaliatory
passion; far otherwise: there was a tear in her eye. ‘How is it you are at Pen-zephyr?’ she inquired.

‘I don’t taunt you. I speak the truth, purely in a friendly way, as I should to any one I wished well. Though for
that matter I might have some excuse even for taunting you. Such a terrible hurry as you’ve been in. I hate a woman who
is in such a hurry.’

‘How do you mean that?’

‘Why — to be somebody’s wife or other — anything’s wife rather than nobody’s. You couldn’t wait for me, O, no. Well,
thank God, I’m cured of all that!’

‘How merciless you are!’ she said bitterly. ‘Wait for you? What does that mean, Charley? You never showed — anything
to wait for — anything special towards me.’

‘O come, Baptista dear; come!’

‘What I mean is, nothing definite,’ she expostulated. ‘I suppose you liked me a little; but it seemed to me to be
only a pastime on your part, and that you never meant to make an honourable engagement of it.’

‘There, that’s just it! You girls expect a man to mean business at the first look. No man when he first becomes
interested in a woman has any definite scheme of engagement to marry her in his mind, unless he is meaning a vulgar
mercenary marriage. However, I did at last mean an honourable engagement, as you call it, come to that.’

‘But you never said so, and an indefinite courtship soon injures a woman’s position and credit, sooner than you
think.’

‘Baptista, I solemnly declare that in six months I should have asked you to marry me.’

She walked along in silence, looking on the ground, and appearing very uncomfortable. Presently he said, ‘Would you
have waited for me if you had known?’ To this she whispered in a sorrowful whisper, ‘Yes!’

They went still farther in silence — passing along one of the beautiful walks on the outskirts of the town, yet not
observant of scene or situation. Her shoulder and his were close together, and he clasped his fingers round the small
of her arm — quite lightly, and without any attempt at impetus; yet the act seemed to say, ‘Now I hold you, and my will
must be yours.’

Recurring to a previous question of hers he said, ‘I have merely run down here for a day or two from school near
Trufal, before going off to the north for the rest of my holiday. I have seen my relations at Redrutin quite lately, so
I am not going there this time. How little I thought of meeting you! How very different the circumstances would have
been if, instead of parting again as we must in half-an-hour or so, possibly for ever, you had been now just going off
with me, as my wife, on our honeymoon trip. Ha — ha — well — so humorous is life!’

She stopped suddenly. ‘I must go back now — this is altogether too painful, Charley! It is not at all a kind mood
you are in today.’

‘I don’t want to pain you — you know I do not,’ he said more gently. ‘Only it just exasperates me — this you are
going to do. I wish you would not.’

‘What?’

‘Marry him. There, now I have showed you my true sentiments.’

‘I must do it now,’ said she.

‘Why?’ he asked, dropping the off-hand masterful tone he had hitherto spoken in, and becoming earnest; still holding
her arm, however, as if she were his chattel to be taken up or put down at will. ‘It is never too late to break off a
marriage that’s distasteful to you. Now I’ll say one thing; and it is truth: I wish you would marry me instead of him,
even now, at the last moment, though you have served me so badly.’

‘O, it is not possible to think of that!’ she answered hastily, shaking her head. ‘When I get home all will be
prepared — it is ready even now — the things for the party, the furniture, Mr. Heddegan’s new suit, and everything. I
should require the courage of a tropical lion to go home there and say I wouldn’t carry out my promise!’

‘Then go, in Heaven’s name! But there would be no necessity for you to go home and face them in that way. If we were
to marry, it would have to be at once, instantly; or not at all. I should think your affection not worth the having
unless you agreed to come back with me to Trufal this evening, where we could be married by licence on Monday morning.
And then no Mr. David Heddegan or anybody else could get you away from me.’

‘I must go home by the Tuesday boat,’ she faltered. ‘What would they think if I did not come?’

‘You could go home by that boat just the same. All the difference would be that I should go with you. You could
leave me on the quay, where I’d have a smoke, while you went and saw your father and mother privately; you could then
tell them what you had done, and that I was waiting not far off; that I was a school-master in a fairly good position,
and a young man you had known when you were at the Training College. Then I would come boldly forward; and they would
see that it could not be altered, and so you wouldn’t suffer a lifelong misery by being the wife of a wretched old
gaffer you don’t like at all. Now, honestly; you do like me best, don’t you, Baptista?’

‘Yes.’

‘Then we will do as I say.’

She did not pronounce a clear affirmative. But that she consented to the novel proposition at some moment or other
of that walk was apparent by what occurred a little later.

Chapter III

An enterprise of such pith required, indeed, less talking than consideration. The first thing they did in carrying
it out was to return to the railway station, where Baptista took from her luggage a small trunk of immediate
necessaries which she would in any case have required after missing the boat. That same afternoon they travelled up the
line to Trufal.

Charles Stow (as his name was), despite his disdainful indifference to things, was very careful of appearances, and
made the journey independently of her though in the same train. He told her where she could get board and lodgings in
the city; and with merely a distant nod to her of a provisional kind, went off to his own quarters, and to see about
the licence.

On Sunday she saw him in the morning across the nave of the pro-cathedral. In the afternoon they walked together in
the fields, where he told her that the licence would be ready next day, and would be available the day after, when the
ceremony could be performed as early after eight o’clock as they should choose.

His courtship, thus renewed after an interval of two years, was as impetuous, violent even, as it was short. The
next day came and passed, and the final arrangements were made. Their agreement was to get the ceremony over as soon as
they possibly could the next morning, so as to go on to Pen-zephyr at once, and reach that place in time for the boat’s
departure the same day. It was in obedience to Baptista’s earnest request that Stow consented thus to make the whole
journey to Lyonesse by land and water at one heat, and not break it at Pen-zephyr; she seemed to be oppressed with a
dread of lingering anywhere, this great first act of disobedience to her parents once accomplished, with the weight on
her mind that her home had to be convulsed by the disclosure of it. To face her difficulties over the water immediately
she had created them was, however, a course more desired by Baptista than by her lover; though for once he gave
way.

The next morning was bright and warm as those which had preceded it. By six o’clock it seemed nearly noon, as is
often the case in that part of England in the summer season. By nine they were husband and wife. They packed up and
departed by the earliest train after the service; and on the way discussed at length what she should say on meeting her
parents, Charley dictating the turn of each phrase. In her anxiety they had travelled so early that when they reached
Pen-zephyr they found there were nearly two hours on their hands before the steamer’s time of sailing.

Baptista was extremely reluctant to be seen promenading the streets of the watering-place with her husband till, as
above stated, the household at Giant’s Town should know the unexpected course of events from her own lips; and it was
just possible, if not likely, that some Lyonessian might be prowling about there, or even have come across the sea to
look for her. To meet any one to whom she was known, and to have to reply to awkward questions about the strange young
man at her side before her well-framed announcement had been delivered at proper time and place, was a thing she could
not contemplate with equanimity. So, instead of looking at the shops and harbour, they went along the coast a little
way.

The heat of the morning was by this time intense. They clambered up on some cliffs, and while sitting there, looking
around at St. Michael’s Mount and other objects, Charles said to her that he thought he would run down to the beach at
their feet, and take just one plunge into the sea.

Baptista did not much like the idea of being left alone; it was gloomy, she said. But he assured her he would not be
gone more than a quarter of an hour at the outside, and she passively assented.

Down he went, disappeared, appeared again, and looked back. Then he again proceeded, and vanished, till, as a small
waxen object, she saw him emerge from the nook that had screened him, cross the white fringe of foam, and walk into the
undulating mass of blue. Once in the water he seemed less inclined to hurry than before; he remained a long time; and,
unable either to appreciate his skill or criticize his want of it at that distance, she withdrew her eyes from the
spot, and gazed at the still outline of St. Michael’s — now beautifully toned in grey.

Her anxiety for the hour of departure, and to cope at once with the approaching incidents that she would have to
manipulate as best she could, sent her into a reverie. It was now Tuesday; she would reach home in the evening — a very
late time they would say; but, as the delay was a pure accident, they would deem her marriage to Mr. Heddegan tomorrow
still practicable. Then Charles would have to be produced from the background. It was a terrible undertaking to think
of, and she almost regretted her temerity in wedding so hastily that morning. The rage of her father would be so
crushing; the reproaches of her mother so bitter; and perhaps Charles would answer hotly, and perhaps cause
estrangement till death. There had obviously been no alarm about her at St. Maria’s, or somebody would have sailed
across to inquire for her. She had, in a letter written at the beginning of the week, spoken of the hour at which she
intended to leave her country schoolhouse; and from this her friends had probably perceived that by such timing she
would run a risk of losing the Saturday boat. She had missed it, and as a consequence sat here on the shore as Mrs.
Charles Stow.

This brought her to the present, and she turned from the outline of St. Michael’s Mount to look about for her
husband’s form. He was, as far as she could discover, no longer in the sea. Then he was dressing. By moving a few steps
she could see where his clothes lay. But Charles was not beside them.

Baptista looked back again at the water in bewilderment, as if her senses were the victim of some sleight of hand.
Not a speck or spot resembling a man’s head or face showed anywhere. By this time she was alarmed, and her alarm
intensified when she perceived a little beyond the scene of her husband’s bathing a small area of water, the quality of
whose surface differed from that of the surrounding expanse as the coarse vegetation of some foul patch in a mead
differs from the fine green of the remainder. Elsewhere it looked flexuous, here it looked vermiculated and lumpy, and
her marine experiences suggested to her in a moment that two currents met and caused a turmoil at this place.

She descended as hastily as her trembling limbs would allow. The way down was terribly long, and before reaching the
heap of clothes it occurred to her that, after all, it would be best to run first for help. Hastening along in a
lateral direction she proceeded inland till she met a man, and soon afterwards two others. To them she exclaimed, ‘I
think a gentleman who was bathing is in some danger. I cannot see him as I could. Will you please run and help him, at
once, if you will be so kind?’

She did not think of turning to show them the exact spot, indicating it vaguely by the direction of her hand, and
still going on her way with the idea of gaining more assistance. When she deemed, in her faintness, that she had
carried the alarm far enough, she faced about and dragged herself back again. Before reaching the now dreaded spot she
met one of the men.

‘We can see nothing at all, Miss,’ he declared.

Having gained the beach, she found the tide in, and no sign of Charley’s clothes. The other men whom she had
besought to come had disappeared, it must have been in some other direction, for she had not met them going away. They,
finding nothing, had probably thought her alarm a mere conjecture, and given up the quest.

Baptista sank down upon the stones near at hand. Where Charley had undressed was now sea. There could not be the
least doubt that he was drowned, and his body sucked under by the current; while his clothes, lying within high-water
mark, had probably been carried away by the rising tide.

She remained in a stupor for some minutes, till a strange sensation succeeded the aforesaid perceptions, mystifying
her intelligence, and leaving her physically almost inert. With his personal disappearance, the last three days of her
life with him seemed to be swallowed up, also his image, in her mind’s eye, waned curiously, receded far away, grew
stranger and stranger, less and less real. Their meeting and marriage had been so sudden, unpremeditated, adventurous,
that she could hardly believe that she had played her part in such a reckless drama. Of all the few hours of her life
with Charles, the portion that most insisted in coming back to memory was their fortuitous encounter on the previous
Saturday, and those bitter reprimands with which he had begun the attack, as it might be called, which had piqued her
to an unexpected consummation.

A sort of cruelty, an imperiousness, even in his warmth, had characterized Charles Stow. As a lover he had ever been
a bit of a tyrant; and it might pretty truly have been said that he had stung her into marriage with him at last. Still
more alien from her life did these reflections operate to make him; and then they would be chased away by an interval
of passionate weeping and mad regret. Finally, there returned upon the confused mind of the young wife the recollection
that she was on her way homeward, and that the packet would sail in three-quarters of an hour.

Except the parasol in her hand, all she possessed was at the station awaiting her onward journey.

She looked in that direction; and, entering one of those undemonstrative phases so common with her, walked quietly
on.

At first she made straight for the railway; but suddenly turning she went to a shop and wrote an anonymous line
announcing his death by drowning to the only person she had ever heard Charles mention as a relative. Posting this
stealthily, and with a fearful look around her, she seemed to acquire a terror of the late events, pursuing her way to
the station as if followed by a spectre.

When she got to the office she asked for the luggage that she had left there on the Saturday as well as the trunk
left on the morning just lapsed. All were put in the boat, and she herself followed. Quickly as these things had been
done, the whole proceeding, nevertheless, had been almost automatic on Baptista’s part, ere she had come to any
definite conclusion on her course.

Just before the bell rang she heard a conversation on the pier, which removed the last shade of doubt from her mind,
if any had existed, that she was Charles Stow’s widow. The sentences were but fragmentary, but she could easily piece
them out.

‘A man drowned — swam out too far — was a stranger to the place — people in boat — saw him go down — couldn’t get
there in time.’

The news was little more definite than this as yet; though it may as well be stated once for all that the statement
was true. Charley, with the over-confidence of his nature, had ventured out too far for his strength, and succumbed in
the absence of assistance, his lifeless body being at that moment suspended in the transparent mid-depths of the bay.
His clothes, however, had merely been gently lifted by the rising tide, and floated into a nook hard by, where they lay
out of sight of the passers-by till a day or two after.

Chapter IV

In ten minutes they were steaming out of the harbour for their voyage of four or five hours, at whose ending she
would have to tell her strange story.

As Pen-zephyr and all its environing scenes disappeared behind Mousehole and St. Clement’s Isle, Baptista’s
ephemeral, meteor-like husband impressed her yet more as a fantasy. She was still in such a trance-like state that she
had been an hour on the little packet-boat before she became aware of the agitating fact that Mr. Heddegan was on board
with her. Involuntarily she slipped from her left hand the symbol of her wifehood.

He was a hale, well-conditioned man of about five and fifty, of the complexion common to those whose lives are
passed on the bluffs and beaches of an ocean isle. He extended the four quarters of his face in a genial smile, and his
hand for a grasp of the same magnitude. She gave her own in surprised docility, and he continued: ‘I couldn’t help
coming across to meet ‘ee. What an unfortunate thing you missing the boat and not coming Saturday! They meant to have
warned ‘ee that the time was changed, but forgot it at the last moment. The truth is that I should have informed ‘ee
myself; but I was that busy finishing up a job last week, so as to have this week free, that I trusted to your father
for attending to these little things. However, so plain and quiet as it is all to be, it really do not matter so much
as it might otherwise have done, and I hope ye haven’t been greatly put out. Now, if you’d sooner that I should not be
seen talking to ‘ee — if ‘ee feel shy at all before strangers — just say. I’ll leave ‘ee to yourself till we get
home.’

‘Thank you much. I am indeed a little tired, Mr. Heddegan.’

He nodded urbane acquiescence, strolled away immediately, and minutely inspected the surface of the funnel, till
some female passengers of Giant’s Town tittered at what they must have thought a rebuff — for the approaching wedding
was known to many on St. Maria’s Island, though to nobody elsewhere. Baptista coloured at their satire, and called him
back, and forced herself to commune with him in at least a mechanically friendly manner.

The opening event had been thus different from her expectation, and she had adumbrated no act to meet it. Taken
aback she passively allowed circumstances to pilot her along; and so the voyage was made.

It was near dusk when they touched the pier of Giant’s Town, where several friends and neighbours stood awaiting
them. Her father had a lantern in his hand. Her mother, too, was there, reproachfully glad that the delay had at last
ended so simply. Mrs. Trewthen and her daughter went together along the Giant’s Walk, or promenade, to the house,
rather in advance of her husband and Mr. Heddegan, who talked in loud tones which reached the women over their
shoulders.

Some would have called Mrs. Trewthen a good mother; but though well meaning she was maladroit, and her intentions
missed their mark. This might have been partly attributable to the slight deafness from which she suffered. Now, as
usual, the chief utterances came from her lips.

‘Ah, yes, I’m so glad, my child, that you’ve got over safe. It is all ready, and everything so well arranged, that
nothing but misfortune could hinder you settling as, with God’s grace, becomes ‘ee. Close to your mother’s door a’most,
’twill be a great blessing, I’m sure; and I was very glad to find from your letters that you’d held your word sacred.
That’s right — make your word your bond always. Mrs. Wace seems to be a sensible woman. I hope the Lord will do for her
as he’s doing for you no long time hence. And how did ‘ee get over the terrible journey from Tor-upon-Sea to
Pen-zephyr? Once you’d done with the railway, of course, you seemed quite at home. Well, Baptista, conduct yourself
seemly, and all will be well.’

Thus admonished, Baptista entered the house, her father and Mr. Heddegan immediately at her back. Her mother had
been so didactic that she had felt herself absolutely unable to broach the subjects in the centre of her mind.

The familiar room, with the dark ceiling, the well-spread table, the old chairs, had never before spoken so
eloquently of the times ere she knew or had heard of Charley Stow. She went upstairs to take off her things, her mother
remaining below to complete the disposition of the supper, and attend to the preparation of tomorrow’s meal, altogether
composing such an array of pies, from pies of fish to pies of turnips, as was never heard of outside the Western Duchy.
Baptista, once alone, sat down and did nothing; and was called before she had taken off her bonnet.

‘I’m coming,’ she cried, jumping up, and speedily disapparelling herself, brushed her hair with a few touches and
went down.

Two or three of Mr. Heddegan’s and her father’s friends had dropped in, and expressed their sympathy for the delay
she had been subjected to. The meal was a most merry one except to Baptista. She had desired privacy, and there was
none; and to break the news was already a greater difficulty than it had been at first. Everything around her, animate
and inanimate, great and small, insisted that she had come home to be married; and she could not get a chance to say
nay.

One or two people sang songs, as overtures to the melody of the morrow, till at length bedtime came, and they all
withdrew, her mother having retired a little earlier. When Baptista found herself again alone in her bedroom the case
stood as before: she had come home with much to say, and she had said nothing.

It was now growing clear even to herself that Charles being dead, she had not determination sufficient within her to
break tidings which, had he been alive, would have imperatively announced themselves. And thus with the stroke of
midnight came the turning of the scale; her story should remain untold. It was not that upon the whole she thought it
best not to attempt to tell it; but that she could not undertake so explosive a matter. To stop the wedding now would
cause a convulsion in Giant’s Town little short of volcanic. Weakened, tired, and terrified as she had been by the
day’s adventures, she could not make herself the author of such a catastrophe. But how refuse Heddegan without telling?
It really seemed to her as if her marriage with Mr. Heddegan were about to take place as if nothing had intervened.

Morning came. The events of the previous days were cut off from her present existence by scene and sentiment more
completely than ever. Charles Stow had grown to be a special being of whom, owing to his character, she entertained
rather fearful than loving memory. Baptista could hear when she awoke that her parents were already moving about
downstairs. But she did not rise till her mother’s rather rough voice resounded up the staircase as it had done on the
preceding evening.

‘Baptista! Come, time to be stirring! The man will be here, by heaven’s blessing, in three-quarters of an hour. He
has looked in already for a minute or two — and says he’s going to the church to see if things be well forward.’

Baptista arose, looked out of the window, and took the easy course. When she emerged from the regions above she was
arrayed in her new silk frock and best stockings, wearing a linen jacket over the former for breakfasting, and her
common slippers over the latter, not to spoil the new ones on the rough precincts of the dwelling.

It is unnecessary to dwell at any great length on this part of the morning’s proceedings. She revealed nothing; and
married Heddegan, as she had given her word to do, on that appointed August day.

Chapter V

Mr. Heddegan forgave the coldness of his bride’s manner during and after the wedding ceremony, full well aware that
there had been considerable reluctance on her part to acquiesce in this neighbourly arrangement, and, as a philosopher
of long standing, holding that whatever Baptista’s attitude now, the conditions would probably be much the same six
months hence as those which ruled among other married couples.

An absolutely unexpected shock was given to Baptista’s listless mind about an hour after the wedding service. They
had nearly finished the mid-day dinner when the now husband said to her father, ‘We think of starting about two. And
the breeze being so fair we shall bring up inside Pen-zephyr new pier about six at least.’

‘What — are we going to Pen-zephyr?’ said Baptista. ‘I don’t know anything of it.’

‘Didn’t you tell her?’ asked her father of Heddegan.

It transpired that, owing to the delay in her arrival, this proposal too, among other things, had in the hurry not
been mentioned to her, except some time ago as a general suggestion that they would go somewhere. Heddegan had imagined
that any trip would be pleasant, and one to the mainland the pleasantest of all.

She looked so distressed at the announcement that her husband willingly offered to give it up, though he had not had
a holiday off the island for a whole year. Then she pondered on the inconvenience of staying at Giant’s Town, where all
the inhabitants were bonded, by the circumstances of their situation, into a sort of family party, which permitted and
encouraged on such occasions as these oral criticism that was apt to disturb the equanimity of newly married girls, and
would especially worry Baptista in her strange situation. Hence, unexpectedly, she agreed not to disorganize her
husband’s plans for the wedding jaunt, and it was settled that, as originally intended, they should proceed in a
neighbour’s sailing boat to the metropolis of the district.

In this way they arrived at Pen-zephyr without difficulty or mishap. Bidding adieu to Jenkin and his man, who had
sailed them over, they strolled arm in arm off the pier, Baptista silent, cold, and obedient. Heddegan had arranged to
take her as far as Plymouth before their return, but to go no further than where they had landed that day. Their first
business was to find an inn; and in this they had unexpected difficulty, since for some reason or other — possibly the
fine weather — many of the nearest at hand were full of tourists and commercial travellers. He led her on till he
reached a tavern which, though comparatively unpretending, stood in as attractive a spot as any in the town; and this,
somewhat to their surprise after their previous experience, they found apparently empty. The considerate old man,
thinking that Baptista was educated to artistic notions, though he himself was deficient in them, had decided that it
was most desirable to have, on such an occasion as the present, an apartment with ‘a good view’ (the expression being
one he had often heard in use among tourists); and he therefore asked for a favourite room on the first floor, from
which a bow-window protruded, for the express purpose of affording such an outlook.

The landlady, after some hesitation, said she was sorry that particular apartment was engaged; the next one,
however, or any other in the house, was unoccupied.

‘The gentleman who has the best one will give it up tomorrow, and then you can change into it,’ she added, as Mr.
Heddegan hesitated about taking the adjoining and less commanding one.

‘We shall be gone tomorrow, and shan’t want it,’ he said.

Wishing not to lose customers, the landlady earnestly continued that since he was bent on having the best room,
perhaps the other gentleman would not object to move at once into the one they despised, since, though nothing could be
seen from the window, the room was equally large.

‘Well, if he doesn’t care for a view,’ said Mr. Heddegan, with the air of a highly artistic man who did.

‘O no — I am sure he doesn’t,’ she said. ‘I can promise that you shall have the room you want. If you would not
object to go for a walk for half an hour, I could have it ready, and your things in it, and a nice tea laid in the
bow-window by the time you come back?’

This proposal was deemed satisfactory by the fussy old tradesman, and they went out. Baptista nervously conducted
him in an opposite direction to her walk of the former day in other company, showing on her wan face, had he observed
it, how much she was beginning to regret her sacrificial step for mending matters that morning.

She took advantage of a moment when her husband’s back was turned to inquire casually in a shop if anything had been
heard of the gentleman who was sucked down in the eddy while bathing.

The shopman said, ‘Yes, his body has been washed ashore,’ and had just handed Baptista a newspaper on which she
discerned the heading, ‘A Schoolmaster drowned while bathing,’ when her husband turned to join her. She might have
pursued the subject without raising suspicion; but it was more than flesh and blood could do, and completing a small
purchase almost ran out of the shop.

‘And we won’t,’ he said. ‘They are suffocating this weather. Let’s go back and have some tay!’

They found the much desired apartment awaiting their entry. It was a sort of combination bed and sitting-room, and
the table was prettily spread with high tea in the bow-window, a bunch of flowers in the midst, and a best-parlour
chair on each side. Here they shared the meal by the ruddy light of the vanishing sun. But though the view had been
engaged, regardless of expense, exclusively for Baptista’s pleasure, she did not direct any keen attention out of the
window. Her gaze as often fell on the floor and walls of the room as elsewhere, and on the table as much as on either,
beholding nothing at all.

But there was a change. Opposite her seat was the door, upon which her eyes presently became riveted like those of a
little bird upon a snake. For, on a peg at the back of the door, there hung a hat; such a hat — surely, from its
peculiar make, the actual hat — that had been worn by Charles. Conviction grew to certainty when she saw a railway
ticket sticking up from the band. Charles had put the ticket there — she had noticed the act.

Her teeth almost chattered; she murmured something incoherent. Her husband jumped up and said, ‘You are not well!
What is it? What shall I get ‘ee?’

‘Smelling salts!’ she said, quickly and desperately; ‘at that chemist’s shop you were in just now.’

He jumped up like the anxious old man that he was, caught up his own hat from a back table, and without observing
the other hastened out and downstairs.

Left alone she gazed and gazed at the back of the door, then spasmodically rang the bell. An honest-looking country
maid-servant appeared in response.

‘A hat!’ murmured Baptista, pointing with her finger. ‘It does not belong to us.’

‘O yes, I’ll take it away,’ said the young woman with some hurry. ‘It belongs to the other gentleman.’

She spoke with a certain awkwardness, and took the hat out of the room. Baptista had recovered her outward
composure. ‘The other gentleman?’ she said. ‘Where is the other gentleman?’

‘He’s in the next room, ma’am. He removed out of this to oblige ‘ee.’

‘How can you say so? I should hear him if he were there,’ said Baptista, sufficiently recovered to argue down an
apparent untruth.

‘He’s there,’ said the girl, hardily.

‘Then it is strange that he makes no noise,’ said Mrs. Heddegan, convicting the girl of falsity by a look.

‘He makes no noise; but it is not strange,’ said the servant.

All at once a dread took possession of the bride’s heart, like a cold hand laid thereon; for it flashed upon her
that there was a possibility of reconciling the girl’s statement with her own knowledge of facts.

‘Why does he make no noise?’ she weakly said.

The waiting-maid was silent, and looked at her questioner. ‘If I tell you, ma’am, you won’t tell missis?’ she
whispered.

Baptista promised.

‘Because he’s a-lying dead!’ said the girl. ‘He’s the schoolmaster that was drownded yesterday.’

‘O!’ said the bride, covering her eyes. ‘Then he was in this room till just now?’

‘Yes,’ said the maid, thinking the young lady’s agitation natural enough. ‘And I told missis that I thought she
oughtn’t to have done it, because I don’t hold it right to keep visitors so much in the dark where death’s concerned;
but she said the gentleman didn’t die of anything infectious; she was a poor, honest, innkeeper’s wife, she says, who
had to get her living by making hay while the sun sheened. And owing to the drownded gentleman being brought here, she
said, it kept so many people away that we were empty, though all the other houses were full. So when your good man set
his mind upon the room, and she would have lost good paying folk if he’d not had it, it wasn’t to be supposed, she
said, that she’d let anything stand in the way. Ye won’t say that I’ve told ye, please, m’m? All the linen has been
changed, and as the inquest won’t be till tomorrow, after you are gone, she thought you wouldn’t know a word of it,
being strangers here.’

The returning footsteps of her husband broke off further narration. Baptista waved her hand, for she could not
speak. The waiting-maid quickly withdrew, and Mr. Heddegan entered with the smelling salts and other nostrums.

‘Any better?’ he questioned.

‘I don’t like the hotel,’ she exclaimed, almost simultaneously. ‘I can’t bear it — it doesn’t suit me!’

‘Is that all that’s the matter?’ he returned pettishly (this being the first time of his showing such a mood). ‘Upon
my heart and life such trifling is trying to any man’s temper, Baptista! Sending me about from here to yond, and then
when I come back saying ‘ee don’t like the place that I have sunk so much money and words to get for ‘ee. ‘Od dang it
all, ’tis enough to — But I won’t say any more at present, mee deer, though it is just too much to expect to turn out
of the house now. We shan’t get another quiet place at this time of the evening — every other inn in the town is
bustling with rackety folk of one sort and t’other, while here ’tis as quiet as the grave — the country, I would say.
So bide still, d’ye hear, and tomorrow we shall be out of the town altogether — as early as you like.’

The obstinacy of age had, in short, overmastered its complaisance, and the young woman said no more. The simple
course of telling him that in the adjoining room lay a corpse which had lately occupied their own might, it would have
seemed, have been an effectual one without further disclosure, but to allude to that subject, however it was disguised,
was more than Heddegan’s young wife had strength for. Horror broke her down. In the contingency one thing only
presented itself to her paralyzed regard — that here she was doomed to abide, in a hideous contiguity to the dead
husband and the living, and her conjecture did, in fact, bear itself out. That night she lay between the two men she
had married — Heddegan on the one hand, and on the other through the partition against which the bed stood, Charles
Stow.

Chapter VI

Kindly time had withdrawn the foregoing event three days from the present of Baptista Heddegan. It was ten o’clock
in the morning; she had been ill, not in an ordinary or definite sense, but in a state of cold stupefaction, from which
it was difficult to arouse her so much as to say a few sentences. When questioned she had replied that she was pretty
well.

Their trip, as such, had been something of a failure. They had gone on as far as Falmouth, but here he had given way
to her entreaties to return home. This they could not very well do without repassing through Pen-zephyr, at which place
they had now again arrived.

In the train she had seen a weekly local paper, and read there a paragraph detailing the inquest on Charles. It was
added that the funeral was to take place at his native town of Redrutin on Friday.

After reading this she had shown no reluctance to enter the fatal neighbourhood of the tragedy, only stipulating
that they should take their rest at a different lodging from the first; and now comparatively braced up and calm —
indeed a cooler creature altogether than when last in the town, she said to David that she wanted to walk out for a
while, as they had plenty of time on their hands.

‘To a shop as usual, I suppose, mee deer?’

‘Partly for shopping,’ she said. ‘And it will be best for you, dear, to stay in after trotting about so much, and
have a good rest while I am gone.’

He assented; and Baptista sallied forth. As she had stated, her first visit was made to a shop, a draper’s. Without
the exercise of much choice she purchased a black bonnet and veil, also a black stuff gown; a black mantle she already
wore. These articles were made up into a parcel which, in spite of the saleswoman’s offers, her customer said she would
take with her. Bearing it on her arm she turned to the railway, and at the station got a ticket for Redrutin.

Thus it appeared that, on her recovery from the paralyzed mood of the former day, while she had resolved not to
blast utterly the happiness of her present husband by revealing the history of the departed one, she had also
determined to indulge a certain odd, inconsequent, feminine sentiment of decency, to the small extent to which it could
do no harm to any person. At Redrutin she emerged from the railway carriage in the black attire purchased at the shop,
having during the transit made the change in the empty compartment she had chosen. The other clothes were now in the
bandbox and parcel. Leaving these at the cloak-room she proceeded onward, and after a wary survey reached the side of a
hill whence a view of the burial ground could be obtained.

It was now a little before two o’clock. While Baptista waited a funeral procession ascended the road. Baptista
hastened across, and by the time the procession entered the cemetery gates she had unobtrusively joined it.

In addition to the schoolmaster’s own relatives (not a few), the paragraph in the newspapers of his death by
drowning had drawn together many neighbours, acquaintances, and onlookers. Among them she passed unnoticed, and with a
quiet step pursued the winding path to the chapel, and afterwards thence to the grave. When all was over, and the
relatives and idlers had withdrawn, she stepped to the edge of the chasm. From beneath her mantle she drew a little
bunch of forget-me-nots, and dropped them in upon the coffin. In a few minutes she also turned and went away from the
cemetery. By five o’clock she was again in Pen-zephyr.

‘You have been a mortal long time!’ said her husband, crossly. ‘I allowed you an hour at most, mee deer.’

‘It occupied me longer,’ said she.

‘Well — I reckon it is wasting words to complain. Hang it, ye look so tired and wisht that I can’t find heart to say
what I would!’

‘I am — weary and wisht, David; I am. We can get home tomorrow for certain, I hope?’

‘We can. And please God we will!’ said Mr. Heddegan heartily, as if he too were weary of his brief honeymoon. ‘I
must be into business again on Monday morning at latest.’

They left by the next morning steamer, and in the afternoon took up their residence in their own house at Giant’s
Town.

The hour that she reached the island it was as if a material weight had been removed from Baptista’s shoulders. Her
husband attributed the change to the influence of the local breezes after the hot-house atmosphere of the mainland.
However that might be, settled here, a few doors from her mother’s dwelling, she recovered in no very long time much of
her customary bearing, which was never very demonstrative. She accepted her position calmly, and faintly smiled when
her neighbours learned to call her Mrs. Heddegan, and said she seemed likely to become the leader of fashion in Giant’s
Town.

Her husband was a man who had made considerably more money by trade than her father had done: and perhaps the
greater profusion of surroundings at her command than she had heretofore been mistress of, was not without an effect
upon her. One week, two weeks, three weeks passed; and, being pre-eminently a young woman who allowed things to drift,
she did nothing whatever either to disclose or conceal traces of her first marriage; or to learn if there existed
possibilities — which there undoubtedly did — by which that hasty contract might become revealed to those about her at
any unexpected moment.

While yet within the first month of her marriage, and on an evening just before sunset, Baptista was standing within
her garden adjoining the house, when she saw passing along the road a personage clad in a greasy black coat and
battered tall hat, which, common enough in the slums of a city, had an odd appearance in St. Maria’s. The tramp, as he
seemed to be, marked her at once — bonnetless and unwrapped as she was her features were plainly recognizable — and
with an air of friendly surprise came and leant over the wall.

‘What! don’t you know me?’ said he.

She had some dim recollection of his face, but said that she was not acquainted with him.

‘Why, your witness to be sure, ma’am. Don’t you mind the man that was mending the church-window when you and your
intended husband walked up to be made one; and the clerk called me down from the ladder, and I came and did my part by
writing my name and occupation?’

Baptista glanced quickly around; her husband was out of earshot. That would have been of less importance but for the
fact that the wedding witnessed by this personage had not been the wedding with Mr. Heddegan, but the one on the day
previous.

‘I’ve had a misfortune since then, that’s pulled me under,’ continued her friend. ‘But don’t let me damp yer wedded
joy by naming the particulars. Yes, I’ve seen changes since; though ’tis but a short time ago — let me see, only a
month next week, I think; for ’twere the first or second day in August.’

‘Yes — that’s when it was,’ said another man, a sailor, who had come up with a pipe in his mouth, and felt it
necessary to join in (Baptista having receded to escape further speech). ‘For that was the first time I set foot in
Giant’s Town; and her husband took her to him the same day.’

A dialogue then proceeded between the two men outside the wall, which Baptista could not help hearing.

‘Ay, I signed the book that made her one flesh,’ repeated the decayed glazier. ‘Where’s her goodman?’

‘About the premises somewhere; but you don’t see ’em together much,’ replied the sailor in an undertone. ‘You see,
he’s older than she.’

‘Older? I should never have thought it from my own observation,’ said the glazier. ‘He was a remarkably handsome
man.’

‘Handsome? Well, there he is — we can see for ourselves.’

David Heddegan had, indeed, just shown himself at the upper end of the garden; and the glazier, looking in
bewilderment from the husband to the wife, saw the latter turn pale.

Now that decayed glazier was a far-seeing and cunning man — too far-seeing and cunning to allow himself to thrive by
simple and straightforward means — and he held his peace, till he could read more plainly the meaning of this riddle,
merely adding carelessly, ‘Well — marriage do alter a man, ’tis true. I should never ha’ knowed him!’

He then stared oddly at the disconcerted Baptista, and moving on to where he could again address her, asked her to
do him a good turn, since he once had done the same for her. Understanding that he meant money, she handed him some, at
which he thanked her, and instantly went away.

Chapter VII

She had escaped exposure on this occasion; but the incident had been an awkward one, and should have suggested to
Baptista that sooner or later the secret must leak out. As it was, she suspected that at any rate she had not heard the
last of the glazier.

In a day or two, when her husband had gone to the old town on the other side of the island, there came a gentle tap
at the door, and the worthy witness of her first marriage made his appearance a second time.

‘It took me hours to get to the bottom of the mystery — hours!’ he said with a gaze of deep confederacy which
offended her pride very deeply. ‘But thanks to a good intellect I’ve done it. Now, ma’am, I’m not a man to tell tales,
even when a tale would be so good as this. But I’m going back to the mainland again, and a little assistance would be
as rain on thirsty ground.’

‘I helped you two days ago,’ began Baptista.

‘Yes — but what was that, my good lady? Not enough to pay my passage to Pen-zephyr. I came over on your account, for
I thought there was a mystery somewhere. Now I must go back on my own. Mind this —‘twould be very awkward for you if
your old man were to know. He’s a queer temper, though he may be fond.’

She knew as well as her visitor how awkward it would be; and the hush-money she paid was heavy that day. She had,
however, the satisfaction of watching the man to the steamer, and seeing him diminish out of sight. But Baptista
perceived that the system into which she had been led of purchasing silence thus was one fatal to her peace of mind,
particularly if it had to be continued.

Hearing no more from the glazier she hoped the difficulty was past. But another week only had gone by, when, as she
was pacing the Giant’s Walk (the name given to the promenade), she met the same personage in the company of a fat woman
carrying a bundle.

‘This is the lady, my dear,’ he said to his companion. ‘This, ma’am, is my wife. We’ve come to settle in the town
for a time, if so be we can find room.’

‘That you won’t do,’ said she. ‘Nobody can live here who is not privileged.’

‘I am privileged,’ said the glazier, ‘by my trade.’

Baptista went on, but in the afternoon she received a visit from the man’s wife. This honest woman began to depict,
in forcible colours, the necessity for keeping up the concealment.

‘I will intercede with my husband, ma’am,’ she said. ‘He’s a true man if rightly managed; and I’ll beg him to
consider your position. ’Tis a very nice house you’ve got here,’ she added, glancing round, ‘and well worth a little
sacrifice to keep it.’

The unlucky Baptista staved off the danger on this third occasion as she had done on the previous two. But she
formed a resolve that, if the attack were once more to be repeated she would face a revelation — worse though that must
now be than before she had attempted to purchase silence by bribes. Her tormentors, never believing her capable of
acting upon such an intention, came again; but she shut the door in their faces. They retreated, muttering something;
but she went to the back of the house, where David Heddegan was.

She looked at him, unconscious of all. The case was serious; she knew that well; and all the more serious in that
she liked him better now than she had done at first. Yet, as she herself began to see, the secret was one that was sure
to disclose itself. Her name and Charles’s stood indelibly written in the registers; and though a month only had passed
as yet it was a wonder that his clandestine union with her had not already been discovered by his friends. Thus
spurring herself to the inevitable, she spoke to Heddegan.

‘David, come indoors. I have something to tell you.’

He hardly regarded her at first. She had discerned that during the last week or two he had seemed preoccupied, as if
some private business harassed him. She repeated her request. He replied with a sigh, ‘Yes, certainly, mee deer.’

When they had reached the sitting-room and shut the door she repeated, faintly, ‘David, I have something to tell you
— a sort of tragedy I have concealed. You will hate me for having so far deceived you; but perhaps my telling you
voluntarily will make you think a little better of me than you would do otherwise.’

‘Tragedy?’ he said, awakening to interest. ‘Much you can know about tragedies, mee deer, that have been in the world
so short a time!’

She saw that he suspected nothing, and it made her task the harder. But on she went steadily. ‘It is about something
that happened before we were married,’ she said.

‘Indeed!’

‘Not a very long time before — a short time. And it is about a lover,’ she faltered.

‘I don’t much mind that,’ he said mildly. ‘In truth, I was in hopes ’twas more.’

‘In hopes!’

‘Well, yes.’

This screwed her up to the necessary effort. ‘I met my old sweetheart. He scorned me, chid me, dared me, and I went
and married him. We were coming straight here to tell you all what we had done; but he was drowned; and I thought I
would say nothing about him: and I married you, David, for the sake of peace and quietness. I’ve tried to keep it from
you, but have found I cannot. There — that’s the substance of it, and you can never, never forgive me, I am sure!’

She spoke desperately. But the old man, instead of turning black or blue, or slaying her in his indignation, jumped
up from his chair, and began to caper around the room in quite an ecstatic emotion.

‘O, happy thing! How well it falls out!’ he exclaimed, snapping his, fingers over his head. ‘Ha-ha — the knot is cut
— I see a way out of my trouble — ha-ha!’ She looked at him without uttering a sound, till, as he still continued
smiling joyfully, she said, ‘O— what do you mean! Is it done to torment me?’

‘No — no! O, mee deer, your story helps me out of the most heart-aching quandary a poor man ever found himself in!
You see, it is this — I’ve got a tragedy, too; and unless you had had one to tell, I could never have seen my way to
tell mine!’

‘What is yours — what is it?’ she asked, with altogether a new view of things.

‘Well — it is a bouncer; mine is a bouncer!’ said he, looking on the ground and wiping his eyes.

‘Not worse than mine?’

‘Well — that depends upon how you look at it. Yours had to do with the past alone; and I don’t mind it. You see,
we’ve been married a month, and it don’t jar upon me as it would if we’d only been married a day or two. Now mine
refers to past, present, and future; so that —’

‘Past, present, and future!’ she murmured. ‘It never occurred to me that you had a tragedy, too.’

‘But I have!’ he said, shaking his head. ‘In fact, four.’

‘Then tell ’em!’ cried the young woman.

‘I will — I will. But be considerate, I beg ‘ee, mee deer. Well — I wasn’t a bachelor when I married ‘ee, any more
than you were a spinster. Just as you was a widow-woman, I was a widow-man.

‘Ah!’ said she, with some surprise. ‘But is that all? — then we are nicely balanced,’ she added, relieved.

‘No — it is not all. There’s the point. I am not only a widower.’

‘O, David!’

‘I am a widower with four tragedies — that is to say, four strapping girls — the eldest taller than you. Don’t ‘ee
look so struck — dumb-like! It fell out in this way. I knew the poor woman, their mother, in Pen-zephyr for some years;
and — to cut a long story short — I privately married her at last, just before she died. I kept the matter secret, but
it is getting known among the people here by degrees. I’ve long felt for the children — that it is my duty to have them
here, and do something for them. I have not had courage to break it to ‘ee, but I’ve seen lately that it would soon
come to your ears, and that hev worried me.’

‘Are they educated?’ said the ex-schoolmistress.

‘No. I am sorry to say they have been much neglected; in truth, they can hardly read. And so I thought that by
marrying a young schoolmistress I should get some one in the house who could teach ’em, and bring ’em into genteel
condition, all for nothing. You see, they are growed up too tall to be sent to school.’

‘O, mercy!’ she almost moaned. ‘Four great girls to teach the rudiments to, and have always in the house with me
spelling over their books; and I hate teaching, it kills me. I am bitterly punished — I am, I am!’

‘You’ll get used to ’em, mee deer, and the balance of secrets — mine against yours — will comfort your heart with a
sense of justice. I could send for ’em this week very well — and I will! In faith, I could send this very day.
Baptista, you have relieved me of all my difficulty!’

Thus the interview ended, so far as this matter was concerned. Baptista was too stupefied to say more, and when she
went away to her room she wept from very mortification at Mr. Heddegan’s duplicity. Education, the one thing she
abhorred; the shame of it to delude a young wife so!

The next meal came round. As they sat, Baptista would not suffer her eyes to turn towards him. He did not attempt to
intrude upon her reserve, but every now and then looked under the table and chuckled with satisfaction at the aspect of
affairs. ‘How very well matched we be!’ he said, comfortably.

Next day, when the steamer came in, Baptista saw her husband rush down to meet it; and soon after there appeared at
her door four tall, hipless, shoulderless girls, dwindling in height and size from the eldest to the youngest, like a
row of Pan pipes; at the head of them standing Heddegan. He smiled pleasantly through the grey fringe of his whiskers
and beard, and turning to the girls said, ‘Now come forrard, and shake hands properly with your stepmother.’

Thus she made their acquaintance, and he went out, leaving them together. On examination the poor girls turned out
to be not only plain-looking, which she could have forgiven, but to have such a lamentably meagre intellectual
equipment as to be hopelessly inadequate as companions. Even the eldest, almost her own age, could only read with
difficulty words of two syllables; and taste in dress was beyond their comprehension. In the long vista of future years
she saw nothing but dreary drudgery at her detested old trade without prospect of reward.

She went about quite despairing during the next few days — an unpromising, unfortunate mood for a woman who had not
been married six weeks. From her parents she concealed everything. They had been amongst the few acquaintances of
Heddegan who knew nothing of his secret, and were indignant enough when they saw such a ready-made household foisted
upon their only child. But she would not support them in their remonstrances.

‘No, you don’t yet know all,’ she said.

Thus Baptista had sense enough to see the retributive fairness of this issue. For some time, whenever conversation
arose between her and Heddegan, which was not often, she always said, ‘I am miserable, and you know it. Yet I don’t
wish things to be otherwise.’

But one day when he asked, ‘How do you like ’em now?’ her answer was unexpected. ‘Much better than I did,’ she said,
quietly. ‘I may like them very much some day.’

This was the beginning of a serener season for the chastened spirit of Baptista Heddegan. She had, in truth,
discovered, underneath the crust of uncouthness and meagre articulation which was due to their Troglodytean existence,
that her unwelcomed daughters had natures that were unselfish almost to sublimity. The harsh discipline accorded to
their young lives before their mother’s wrong had been righted, had operated less to crush them than to lift them above
all personal ambition. They considered the world and its contents in a purely objective way, and their own lot seemed
only to affect them as that of certain human beings among the rest, whose troubles they knew rather than suffered.

This was such an entirely new way of regarding life to a woman of Baptista’s nature, that her attention, from being
first arrested by it, became deeply interested. By imperceptible pulses her heart expanded in sympathy with theirs. The
sentences of her tragi-comedy, her life, confused till now, became clearer daily. That in humanity, as exemplified by
these girls, there was nothing to dislike, but infinitely much to pity, she learnt with the lapse of each week in their
company. She grew to like the girls of unpromising exterior, and from liking she got to love them; till they formed an
unexpected point of junction between her own and her husband’s interests, generating a sterling friendship at least,
between a pair in whose existence there had threatened to be neither friendship nor love.

October, 1885.

This web edition published by:

eBooks@Adelaide
The University of Adelaide Library
University of Adelaide
South Australia 5005