GCSEs Live to See Another Day in Wales and NI: News

GCSEs Live to See Another Day in Wales and NI: News

Article excerpt

Devolved nations say they may keep 'fit for purpose' exams.

The GCSE may soon be consigned to the history books in England, replaced by Michael Gove's English Baccalaureate Certificates, but in Wales and Northern Ireland there are signs that the exam could live on.

The education ministers of the two devolved nations have each signalled that they are willing to keep the GCSE as the academic qualification of choice for 14- to 16-year-olds.

Last week, both Leighton Andrews in Wales and John O'Dowd in Northern Ireland said they considered the exams currently being sat by their pupils to be "fit for purpose".

Mr O'Dowd also said that past GCSE pupils should be "proud" of their achievements. However, the two education ministers have pledged to review both GCSEs and A levels to make sure that they remain relevant for pupils.

The Welsh government's probe is part of a wide-ranging review of 14-19 qualifications. A report is due next month, but no changes will be made until at least 2014.

Mr O'Dowd last week announced that he was commissioning Northern Ireland's Council for Curriculum, Examinations and Assessment to conduct a "root and branch" review of GCSEs and A levels. A final report is due in June next year.

Both ministers claim they have pitched their approaches to reform in direct contrast to that taken by Michael Gove: research and consultation against political philosophy and unilateralism. They had already vowed not to follow England's lead in phasing out the modular element of GCSEs in favour of a purely linear approach, with Wales consulting on the matter in the qualifications review and Northern Ireland allowing its schools to decide what is best for pupils.

Last week, Mr O'Dowd said it was "regrettable" that Mr Gove had chosen to break away from the "three jurisdiction" ownership of GCSEs. It is clear that both ministers are growing increasingly frustrated with the approach of the Westminster education secretary. Earlier this summer, they wrote to Mr Gove to say they were concerned at a lack of prior notice on decisions regarding jointly owned qualifications, and requested a meeting to discuss future communication arrangements. Last week, Mr O'Dowd said that request had been refused.

He told fellow members of the Northern Ireland Assembly: "We may not be on the same page on many things, but he has refused to meet me, and I understand that he has also refused to meet the Welsh education minister on the subject of exams. …

A primary source is a work that is being studied, or that provides first-hand or direct evidence on a topic. Common types of primary sources include works of literature, historical documents, original philosophical writings, and religious texts.