Under current UK legislation, pirates of physical media such as CDs and DVDs can be jailed for up to 10 year s On the other hand, those committing similar offenses online can be jailed for ‘only’ two y ears – @AceFriendsNews

This has led to anti-piracy groups such as the Federation Against Copyright Theft choosing to pursue their own private prosecutions under the Fraud Act, which allows for much tougher sentences.

In an effort to fix this disparity, earlier this year a new draft of the Digital Economy Bill contained plans to extend the current ‘online’ prison term from two to ten years. The relevant section amends the Copyright, Designs and Patents Act 1988, and simply replaces the word two with ten.

On its way to becoming law, the Bill has been progressing through various stages in the House of Commons. This week, however, concerns were raised over the precise wording of the amendments. The image below shows how they currently stand.

Despite assurances from MPs that 10-year sentences are directed at large-scale commercial pirates, the text above does not clearly reflect that goal. In fact, just about any online infringer could be swept up in its net, a point not lost on Jim Killock, executive director of the Open Rights Group (ORG), who this week appeared before MPs.

In an exchange with Nigel Adams MP in the Commons, Killock said that ORG is concerned that ordinary members of the public could be affected by the amendments.

“We are worried about the impact of this on people who should not be criminalized and who we thought the Government were not trying to criminalize in this case,” Killock said.

“Our position is that if the Government are going to extend the sentence and have the same sentence online as offline for criminal copyright infringement — that is to say, 10 years — then they need to be very careful about how the lines are drawn, because the offenses are quite different.”

Killock said that offline criminal copyright infringement is all about criminal gangs duplicating things like DVDs, but online things are harder to define because everything looks like the same act – publication.

“You put something on the internet, it is a publication. So how do you tell who is the criminal and who is the slightly idiotic teenager, or whatever it happens to be? How do you make sure that people who should not be threatened with copyright criminal sentences are not given those threats?” Killock asked the MP.

To illustrate his point, Killock spoke about the current state of copyright trolling in the UK by companies such as Golden Eye International.

“They have no specific knowledge that these people are actually the people doing the downloading, all they know is that somebody appears to have downloaded,” Killock said.

At this point Adams interrupted, stating that there’s no intent for the new legislation to affect regular file-sharers.

“The idea of the Bill is not to go after people who are downloading content, it is purely for those who are uploading content for commercial gain. That is the whole purpose,” Adams said.

“Unfortunately, that is not how the language of the offense reads,” Killock responded.

“The test in the offense is that somebody is ‘causing a loss’, which is defined as not paying a licence fee, or is ‘causing the risk of loss’, about which your guess is as good as mine, but it is essentially the same as making available, because if you have made something available and somebody else can then make a copy, and then infringe copyright further and avoid further licence fees, basically that is a criminal act,” the ORG chief explained.

“So file sharers, whether they are small or large, all appear to be criminal copyright thieves. Similarly, people who are publishing things on websites without a license are also potentially criminalized. Those things can be dealt with much better and more simply through civil courts and civil copyright action.”

So, to solve the problem of the legislation potentially targeting the wrong people, Killock suggested a tightening-up of the wording in the amendments.

“What we are calling for is either to get rid of those things which are attacking individuals and wrongly bringing individuals into scope, or to put thresholds of seriousness around the risk of loss and/or causing loss. Something like, ‘Serious risk of causing significant loss’ would be the way to deal with this. Similarly, ‘Causing serious loss’,” he said.

Even with this explanation, the MP didn’t appear to understand.

“If you are knowingly uploading creative content online for commercial gain, to my mind it does not matter whether it is 50 quid or 50,000 quid, you are knowingly stealing someone’s content,” Nigel Adams said.

“The commercial gain is not part of this offense. That is what I am saying,” said Killock.

“The offense is purely to cause loss — in other words, to not pay a license fee — or to cause risk of loss. There is no ‘commercial’ in it. So you have to put the threshold somewhere. You have an offense for the commercial activities and, separately, individuals who cause risk of loss or fail to pay a license fee.”

The Open Rights Group are to be commended for raising this issue in the House of Commons since as things stand, the wording of the legislation is wide open to abuse from aggressive rightsholders. Whether appropriate amendments will be introduced remains to be seen, but there is clearly a need to be more specific. If not, trouble could lie ahead….

Editors Notes:

I would remind you that this blog is produced free for the public good and you are welcome to republish or re-use this article or any other material freely anywhere without requesting further permission.

News & Views welcome always published as long as NO bad language or is not related to subject matter.

Ace Social & Media News

Like this:

LikeLoading...

Related

Filed under #AceNewsDesk|Comments Off on Under current UK legislation, pirates of physical media such as CDs and DVDs can be jailed for up to 10 year s On the other hand, those committing similar offenses online can be jailed for ‘only’ two y ears – @AceFriendsNews

About Ace Worldwide News Group

After 30 years of providing my services in Warwickshire in the United Kingdom. I am in the process of building a network of news sites in finance,business, property, social and healthcare under the name of "Ace News Group" together with providing goods and services through our sales and marketing news. I also have an organisation and fully fledged management consultancy agency. This provides contracts to enable people to provide their news, goods and services.

#AceNewsReport – Jan.21: Starting in September, Paris is making all public transit free for people under 11, including non-nationals: Preteens aren’t the only ones getting a bonus, either #AceNewsDesk reports All people with disabilities will get free public transit until the age of 20, while high school students between the ages of 14 and 18 […]

#AceNewsReport – Jan.21: Investigators in the southern province of Guangdong determined Dr. He Jiankui organised and handled funding for the experiment without outside assistance in violation of national guidelines, the Xinhua News Agency said: Along with the birth of the twins, Lulu and Nana, another embryo yet to be born reportedly resulted from his experi […]

#AceNewsReport – Jan.21: The Russian military has announced that Syrian air defences had destroyed over 30 cruise missiles and guided bombs, when repelling an Israeli strike: According to the Russian Defence Ministry, the Israeli strike killed four Syrian servicement and injured 6 others. In addition to this, the air raid has “partially damaged the infrastru […]

#AceFinanceReport – Dec.06: OPINION: The decision by the State of Qatar to leave the Organisation of the Petroleum Exporting Countries (OPEC) by January 2019 has raised eyebrows and set off speculation as to the extent of tensions and discord within the 15-member intergovernmental organisation: The dominant analysis centres on Qatar’s spat with Saudi Arabia […]

#AceFinanceReport – Dec.03: U.S. Customs and Border Protection (CBP), in partnership with the U.S. Army Corps of Engineers, awarded a contract to construct border wall gates in the U.S. Border Patrol’s (USBP) Rio Grande Valley (RGV) Sector, which was funded in CBP’s Fiscal Year (FY) 2017 appropriation: The contract for the first phase of gate […]

#AceFinanceReport – Nov.28: Powell’s comments and similar remarks from other Fed officials have raised hopes in financial markets that the central bank may be close to slowing its rate increases, which have gradually raised borrowing costs for consumers and businesses. Any such slowdown — or pause — in its rate hikes would be welcome news […]

Originally posted on Cooking Without Limits: I was born in Bucovina, Romania and today we celebrate 100 years since the union with all its historical provinces. Home is where your heart is and my heart is in Bucovina. More about Bucovina you can find here. Here are some Romanian recipes with the original name. Click…

Originally posted on The Red Box: Christmas is coming….it is time to upgrade your bundt cake accordingly. Here is a variant of the classy bundt cake, which my Palatine Grandma used to bake for us every 2nd weekend to show us her love. Of course, my grandma knew a wide range of “Gugelhupf”? (= ring…

Originally posted on theglocaljournal: The Pepper Mill is a newly opened gem at Bandra. It’s has a lovely colourful decor and loads of seating available. They’re known for playing really good music. We interacted with a Chef Parag who recommended us a variety of dishes prepared by him. We left the choices on him and…

Originally posted on Sunshiny SA Site: Cast thy woven web and let us repair for eternal life. Beloved mine, as my wife. Forever may we be the sleeping duo. Winged Eros, Mother Nature hath ordained it so. The wind hath whispered. This is no time to dither. The Great Spirit hath sacredly spoken. Fine feathers,…

Originally posted on Musings: Clumps of dark clouds blanketed the horizon A foreboding warning of droplets of rain soon to come Without warning, the zephyr swept away the somber bleakness The shining sun resplendent in its luminosity An iridescent of beautiful colors burst into view A fleeting glimpse of a?bee hovering around Exquisite blossoms gladly…

Originally posted on Sunshiny SA Site: A valued blogging family member from India asked me what was so unique about Durban. Without hesitation and doubt, I replied, “Our Rainbow Nation irrespective of the divides of previous.” This is why, THIS is our Ubuntu “humanity towards others”, the belief in a universal bond of sharing that…

(BEIRUT, Syria.) JUST IN: Two American soldiers and four Kurdish Armed units were killed in a car-bomb attac k which hit a convoy south of Hasaka city on Monday after early land and airstrikes conducted by Israel ’s IDF #AceNewsDesk reports https://t.co/ajt7u89zmL — Ace News Services (@AceNewsServices) January 21, 2019 Advertisements

OPINION: If @realDonaldTrump gets wall it would take away justification for his re-election in 2020, professor says https://t.co/C04eg5bkfb pic.twitter.com/CCROn3Ak2p — Sputnik (@SputnikInt) January 21, 2019