Obamacare credits could trigger surprise tax bills

President Barack Obama spoke in the East Room of the White House in Washington today. Millions of people who take advantage of government subsidies to help buy health insurance next year could get stung by surprise tax bills if they don't accurately project their income.

WASHINGTON » Millions of people who take advantage of government subsidies to help buy health insurance next year could get stung by surprise tax bills if they don't accurately project their income.

President Barack Obama's new health care law will offer subsidies to help people buy private health insurance on state-based exchanges, if they don't already get coverage through their employers. The subsidies are based on income. The lower your income, the bigger the subsidy.

But the government doesn't know how much money you're going to make next year. And when you apply for the subsidy, this fall, it won't even know how much you're making this year. So, unless you tell the government otherwise, it will rely on the best information it has: your 2012 tax return, filed this spring.

What happens if you or your spouse gets a raise and your family income goes up in 2014? You could end up with a bigger subsidy than you are entitled to. If that happens, the law says you have to pay back at least part of the money when you file your tax return in the spring of 2015.

That could result in smaller tax refunds or surprise tax bills for millions of middle-income families.

"That's scary," says Joan Baird of Springfield, Va. "I had no idea, and I work in health care."

Baird, a health care information management worker, is far from alone. Health care providers, advocates and tax experts say the vast majority of Americans know very little about the new health care law, let alone the kind of detailed information many will need to navigate its system of subsidies and penalties.

"They know it's out there," said Mark Cummings, who manages the H&R Block office where Baird was getting her own taxes done. "But in general, they don't know anything about it."

A draft of the application for insurance asks people to project their 2014 income if their current income is not steady or if they expect it to change. The application runs 15 pages for a three-person family, but nowhere does it warn people that they may have to repay part of the subsidy if their income increases.

"I think this will be the hardest thing for members of the public to understand because it is a novel aspect of this tax credit," said Catherine Livingston, who recently served as health care counsel for the Internal Revenue Service. "I can't think of what else they do in the tax system currently that works that way." Livingston is now a partner in the Washington office of the law firm Jones Day.

There's another wrinkle: The vast majority of taxpayers won't actually receive the subsidies. Instead, the money will be paid directly to insurance companies and consumers will get the benefit in reduced premiums.

Health care providers and advocates for people who don't have insurance are planning public awareness campaigns to teach people about the health care law and its benefits.

Enroll America, a coalition of health care providers and advocates, is planning a multimillion-dollar campaign using social media, paid advertising and grass-roots organizing to encourage people who don't have insurance to sign up for it, said Anne Filipic, a former Obama White House official who is now president of the organization.

The Obama administration says it, too, is working to educate consumers.

"On Oct. 1, each state will have a marketplace up and running where consumers can choose a private health insurance plan that fits their health needs and budget," said Treasury spokeswoman Sabrina Siddiqui. "The premium tax credits will give middle-class Americans unprecedented tax benefits to make the purchase of health insurance affordable for everyone, and we will continue to work with consumers, community health organizations and other stakeholders to raise awareness and understanding of these tax benefits."

The subsidies, which are technically tax credits because they are administered through the tax code, will help low- and middle-income families buy health insurance through the state-based exchanges. Under the new law, nearly every American will be required to have health insurance starting in 2014, or face penalties.

The enrollment season starts Oct. 1.

The subsidies are available to families with incomes up to 400 percent of the poverty level. This year, four times the poverty level is about $62,000 for a two-person family. For a family of four, it's $94,200.

About 18 million people will be eligible for subsidies, according to the Congressional Budget Office.

If families get bigger subsidies than they are entitled to under the law, the amount they have to repay is capped, based on income and family size. If they get less than they qualify for under the law, the government will pay them the difference in the form of a tax refund.

There are also special rules that protect people who marry or divorce from being required to pay back subsidies just because their marital status changes.

There are four thresholds for repaying the subsidies:

—A family of four making less than $47,000 would have to repay a maximum of $600.

— If the same family makes between $47,000 and $70,000, the amount they have to repay is capped at $1,500.

— If the same family makes between $70,000 and $94,200, the amount is capped at $2,500.

— Families making more than four times the poverty level have to repay the entire subsidy.

"It's potentially going to come as a shock to individuals who meet that criteria where their income hits a point where they owe money back," said Rep. Charles Boustany, R-La., chairman of the House Ways and Means oversight subcommittee. "The fact is, with variations in income, people could end up owing money back and that will create consternation and problems for them."

The total amount of money that taxpayers will have to repay is unclear, but congressional estimates offer some clues.

Twice since the health care law was passed Congress has increased the caps for how much people will have to repay. Combined, the two measures are expected to raise more than $40 billion over the next decade, according to Congress' Joint Committee on Taxation.

"I think people will get there," said Livingston, the former IRS official. "They will develop instincts about it the way we all do about any process we go through multiple times. But when it's new, in the early years, this will be a real learning curve."

By participating in online discussions you acknowledge that you have agreed to the TERMS OF SERVICE. An insightful discussion of ideas and viewpoints is encouraged, but comments must be civil and in good taste, with no personal attacks. Because only subscribers are allowed to comment, we have your personal information and are able to contact you. If your comments are inappropriate, you may be banned from posting. To report comments that you believe do not follow our guidelines, email commentfeedback@staradvertiser.com.

Leave a comment

Name:

Comment:

Please login to leave a comment.

cojefwrote:

The 15 page questionaire is enough scare anyone. The Government will create this large bureaucracy where a dossier will be kept on all who subscribe to receive subsidy for their health insurance plan. Are you compromising your privacy by signing up? Currently, the Government pays 2/3 of my health insurance premiums as a retiree, and so they possess enough data on me.

on April 2,2013 | 08:31AM

Name:

Comment:

whatwrote:

The typical Obama voter will be thinking "What's with all these questions? Just give me my free stuff!!"

on April 2,2013 | 11:00AM

Name:

Comment:

OldDiverwrote:

Let's examine the Republican plan. Sorry you can't, they don't have a plan.

on April 2,2013 | 12:43PM

Name:

Comment:

whatwrote:

You obviously haven't been paying attention. I'm not saying I agree with Republican plans, but they have been struggling to pass a budget in congress, but have been stonewalled by the Democrats lead by Obama since Republicans want to cut too much spending. I failed plan is still a plan, so get your anti-Republican talking points straight.

on April 2,2013 | 01:05PM

Name:

Comment:

frontmanwrote:

Hope and Change ........................ Don't you love it????

on April 2,2013 | 12:33PM

Name:

Comment:

1localwrote:

many believers will be deceived by the lawmakers in DC...

on April 2,2013 | 08:34AM

Name:

Comment:

seriouswrote:

I think you mean the Democratic lawmakers who passed and never read the bill---they don't care, they are exempt.

on April 2,2013 | 12:07PM

Name:

Comment:

thepartyfirstwrote:

Why is the state run bias media asking this question now? One of the biggest arguments was that this is nothing but a massive tax hike. Why investigate now? Speak up you Obama supporters. I want to know.

on April 2,2013 | 08:35AM

Name:

Comment:

Maiponowrote:

Obamacare is a massive, ominous tax that punishes Americans for doing well. It is another socialist tool to control the voters to be dependent on the government for their well being and to dumb down and punish anyone who wants to better their life. Welcome to the Obama Doctrine people, you support him, so don't complain. As Nancy Pelosi said, "You have to pass it (Obamacare) to see what's in it...."

on April 2,2013 | 08:46AM

Name:

Comment:

lokahiblazewrote:

Priceless is watching all those who supported Obamacare experience the deleterious effects of this unmitigated legislative disaster.

on April 2,2013 | 09:12AM

Name:

Comment:

weswrote:

So let me understand this. Basically, you get a subsidy based on an estimate of your tax returns filed in 2012. In other words, the government is giving you money to help cover the costs of insure which was never there before, and then if you earn more during the year, then was estimated, you have to PAY BACK some of the subsidy.
This is seen as a "surprise" tax increase??

on April 2,2013 | 09:46AM

Name:

Comment:

eoewrote:

All you naysayers - remember that the reason there is an exchange, and all of these tax penalties, is to make conservatives happy. Remember, conservatives wanted private industry insurers involved - they wanted exchanges, and penalties for non-compliance. Us liberals? We wanted an efficient, single-payer, state run health care, you know, like they have in every single other modern post-industrial democracy at roughly half the cost. But "oh nos! socialism" was the cry from the right. So sorry, all this confusing crap is the fault of the right wing.

on April 2,2013 | 10:12AM

Name:

Comment:

phyllum69wrote:

WOW. "My country tis of thee, sweet land of subsidy..." OR you'll pay the price! What a deal.

on April 2,2013 | 10:13AM

Name:

Comment:

mikethenovicewrote:

Thank God America has a leader that is representing us. It is a fact that we can save all our working live only to see it evaporate overnight by one catastrophic medical accident expense. America must work together as a whole in order to survive.

on April 2,2013 | 10:26AM

Name:

Comment:

DiverDavewrote:

Can't wait to hear all the brainless kids(Obama voters) who have to show they have insurance and don't, and end up not only not getting any tax money back at the end of the year, but instead will get a bill (fine) from the I.R.S.. To them I say, too bad fools!

on April 2,2013 | 10:29AM

Name:

Comment:

AniMatsuriwrote:

This is only a surprise to the zombies that voted for Obama. What do you expect of a nearly 3,000 page bill that was literally shoved down America's throat with out anyone actually reading it? Expect more "surprises" as most of the bad stuff was timed to happen after Obama won his 2nd term.

on April 2,2013 | 11:36AM

Name:

Comment:

walrus808wrote:

"We have to pass the bill to find out what's in the bill" -Nancy Pelosi... well, what we keep finding is more and more expense. Great job congress!

on April 2,2013 | 11:47AM

Name:

Comment:

seriouswrote:

Not Congress--Democratics passed it!!! Remember that next time around.

on April 2,2013 | 12:09PM

Name:

Comment:

st1dwrote:

lame stream media had that warm feeling running up its leg. pass the bill, read it later. hope that moist feeling helps the medicine go down.