There were a lot of tasteless quips at the Emmys on Sunday, including host Jimmy Kimmel speculating that “Transparent” was born as a drama but “identified” as a comedy; however, one had less taste than a sugar-free Jell-O pudding pop. That’s when alleged rapist Bill Cosby was announced to come out onstage.

And that’s how you kill the mood, people.

The smiles immediately died, and the shocked look on Tina Fey’s face says it all.