Welcome to Treetop Whispers, a discussion forum for fans of the Warriors/Seekers series. The most complete Warrior Cats forum on the net, with discussion, roleplay, photo gallery, user profiles, and so much more!

Yellowfang's Secret

The book is out now! The newest super edition was released October 9th, and while I personally haven't gotten it yet (I still need to finish The Mark of Athena >.>), have any of you? Remember to use spoilers when talking about the book.

Oh, I can't wait to read it! I don't keep up to date with the series itself, but I've always loved reading the special editions (read each twice so far, Firestar's Quest five times. ). I should probably start catching up to the rest of the books for when they start writing special editions about the newer cats!

Okay I'm bringing this back because I got it the other day and read it all yesterday and I thought it was really good!!

Spoiler:

Okay I don't even know where to start! I loved just getting to live out her whole life, to be able to see that she always had a fiery spirit but that she wasn't always a cranky old cat I was really interested in how she became a medicine cat, like why she decided to give up being a warrior, and while the whole 'I can feel other people's pain' thing was really cool I kinda wish they hadn't given her a 'power' just because they're cats? Like I wanted a more natural thing to happen, like maybe she had killed a cat and had felt so bad that she never could fight again and instead wanted to heal cats. Idk? I just don't like the whole cats have powers thing. I didn't really like Raggedstar simply because I thought he was a jerk most of the time. I also didn't think that he had lost all his lives at once? Like in the original series whenever Yellowfang used to talk about him she always made him seem like an awesome leader and stuff so I figured he had stayed around longer but I guess she was just saying that stuff because she still loved him? Maybe? Who knows. I feel really bad for her having to lose two of her kits, although I really wish it had been Brokenstar that had been the one to die. I hated him before the book and this book just made me hate him even more. I REALLY LOVED RUNNINGNOSE. OMG he was so cute, how he would kinda hang around her den when he was a kit but he never really said anything ahhhh and then he became her apprentice and just. I loved their relationship. AND SPOTTEDPAW OMG when Feathertail was like oh yeah there's this kit, Spottedkit, who I'm thinking about taking on as my apprentice I was like awwwww. I ALSO REALLY LIKED SEEING BLACKSTAR AS AN APPRENTICE. I don't know why I just thought it was really cute to see him as an innocent little apprentice who gets this thorn stuck in a paw and he's so far from this big scary ShadowClan leader. I liked that scene. I was really surprised that the kits Yellowfang was accused of killing were her own siblings. And I was so angry that her mom actually thought she had killed them. Like I get that she was upset and everything, but like she was the one that woke Yellowfang up to help her find them, and that means that Yellowfang would have had to have killed them right there in the forest before anyone got to them, but shouldn't she have had a LOT of blood on her then?? Idk, it just made me mad how everyone jumped to conclusions except for like her dad and Runnningnose. Sighs oh well, she had to get to ThunderClan somehow. Ugh, that little run in with Firepaw at the end made me so nostalgic I was like ahhhh the good old days. So hah yeah I liked it a lot, this is probably one of my favorite super editions.

So, if any of you have read it feel free to add on/disagree with what I said or go wild and start a discussion.

The book is out now! The newest super edition was released October 9th, and while I personally haven't gotten it yet (I still need to finish The Mark of Athena >.>), have any of you? Remember to use spoilers when talking about the book.

OMSC MARK OF ATHENA IS SOOOOOOOOOOO AWESOME (i read it on epubbud) and i CANNOT wait for the house of hades