Is Kagan a Lesbian?

I hate to seem trolling here but I really beg to differ.
1. I didn't even imply it would be negative, only that it would 'kind of' affect every American. Dont say I said something when I didn't.
2. It's a hot online rumor and I was simply interested in exploring the hypothetical. I don't know or care if she is anything.
3. Dont quote "one of those chicks" out of context as I directly referred to someone else's use of "chicks"- someone on your side of the
'argument'.
4. Again I was simply exploring the hypothetical and look at how heated you gay-defenders get. Who's to say I'm not a lesbian and therein lies my
interest? Yet YOU passed judgment.

I think you guys are so vehement to defend one lesbian you would persecute another.

If we're to judge by appearance, obviously her hairdresser isn't gay.
By the way those pearls highlight that neck, apparently her stylist isn't either.
Any gay "liberal" that appreciates her firm stance on allowing them the opportunity to die in the service of their country while denying them
"marriage" equality deserves this "pig in a poke" as much as the last one.

I think you'll find it's more about the absolutely ridiculousness of this thread and suggesting that her being a lesbian would make any difference;
absolutely nothing to do with defending being a lesbian - a lesbian would surely get that

Lesbians don't need defending

Also, we can be fairly sure you aren't a lesbian, or gay, by that stupid crap "you gay-defenders". Being a
decent human being doesn't make you some kind of gay extremist; most people get that, too.

Well that depends my friend. Does what you do in bed with your partner have anything to do with your job? If so then i want to know if your deviant or
not before i would hire you so i need to know everything your into you naughty boy!!!

get real. A persons sexuality has no bearing on their job. bring it into the new century here and leave the 1950's conservatism behind.

I didnt say others werent idiots also. I was just pointing out that whose genitals you decide to rub against has nothing to do with anything when your
out of the bedroom. If your a doctor then i am assuming your not a better or worse doctor because your gay or hetero.

I didnt say others werent idiots also. I was just pointing out that whose genitals you decide to rub against has nothing to do with anything when your
out of the bedroom. If your a doctor then i am assuming your not a better or worse doctor because your gay or hetero.

Its just stupid.

[edit on 12-5-2010 by fizzy1]

Couldn't agree more.
But, being conspiracy minded, I think the choice of a candidate who's likely to be perceived as gay is intentional.
The appearance of tossing a bone to all those recently disillusioned gays and their supporters shortly before an election is a ruse that's worked
before.
Sexual preference matters to both American political parties.

I'm just really surprised you gay-defenders feel its that much of a non-issue. When has the GBLT had more rights in society and when has the GBLT
community asked for so much? Have you seen the ENDA bill? Are you familiar with these issues?

I support people's freedom regardless of sexuality(not including pedophilia,rapists,etc) but Kagan is only 50 years old. Her tenure will be very long
and the court will likely see more cases on sexuality on her watch than during the rest of its history. And there are only 9 of these positions that
are at the top of one of only three branches of our government making the chair one of the most powerful in America.

Yet you gay-defenders are so militant that this consideration isn't needed. I find that an amazing testament to our society.

I don't believe we should worry about her sexuality. What we should be concerned on is what her views on what the issues will be, to include that of
gay rights, and other issues that are affecting our society. If it does come out that she is a lesbian, and she is not truthful about it, she may be
encouraged to retire from the bench if she is confirmed, due to the embarassment that it would cause. However, what I think we should all be
concerned about is her views on the freedome of speech.

I am not sure who she sleeps with or whether that would even help me determine her sexual preferences, if I cared.
Why do you want to know?
Unless you are planning to ask her out, it is a rather moot point, I think.

The question is "why should we care?". Homosexuality has been around for as long as mankind has been around... I've never really understood why
I'm supposed to care who has sex, or loves, who... I flat don't care. If you are happy with whomever you're happy with, I'm jealous, not
angry... I should be so lucky.

She's gay. So? She's straight? So?

Can she interpret the Constitution in accordance with precedence, or be brave enough to buck it, or set it? That's the important question.

The Above Top Secret Web site is a wholly owned social content community of The Above Network, LLC.

This content community relies on user-generated content from our member contributors. The opinions of our members are not those of site ownership who maintains strict editorial agnosticism and simply provides a collaborative venue for free expression.