Kiernan Shipka & Rumored BF Celebrated He Birthday

It's not a magic trick: Kiernan Shipka conjured everyone from Jon Hamm to B.J. Novak to (rumored boyfriend) Christian Coppola to (rumored ex-boyfriend) Charlie Oldman for her 20th birthday party over the weekend. The Chilling Adventures of Sabrina star posted a series of black-and-white photos on her Instagram on Sunday that featured several famous faces — and may have just confirmed a romance that fans have been speculating over.

While Shipka has never spoken publicly about her love life, telling Seventeen last November that "work is [her] number one priority right now," she is active on social media. Her friendships with 20-year-old Charlie Oldman and 26-year-old Christian Coppola have gotten fans arguing in comment sections about the possible romances. It was believed that Shipka was dating Oldman earlier this year, but a post from her birthday party all-but-confirms that her heart really lies with Coppola. A rep for Shipka did not immediately respond to Refinery29's request for comment.