Best Fresh Peanut Butter

Boone Hall Farms Market

Staff Pick

If you’ve never dipped a tiny spoon into a sample of just-pressed peanut butter, then drop what you’re doing and hop a horse to Boone Hall Farms Market. Located just across the street from Boone Hall Farms, this market has a little bit of everything — a restaurant (get the shrimp salad, trust us), large wine selection, and decently stocked array of fresh produce and ready-made products. But it’s the peanut butter that keeps us coming back. It’s warm when you first turn the peanut-pressin’ knob, and comes out in a dollop so sweet you’d think you’d stepped into another world entirely. Nope, just your taste buds traveling to Never, Neverland. Best part — you can get that PB in a variety of to-go sizes. It’s the gift that keeps on giving. —Connelly Hardaway