For those who watch the show and read the comics, what did you think about this episode.

I really think it needs to win an award, the scene with Lori and Carl...omg and Andrew Lincoln's reaction performance at the end, as well as T-Dog's heroism...I haven't cried this bad for a show in a long long time. Literally my heart jerked and i couldn't hold the tears. I was trying to be all brave watching it next to Aergis...but couldn't help myself.

I saw this in another forum..and this member trully captured how I felt after and what I was doing!

Maybe I'm just a heartless bastard. But I hated Lori, and I hate rick. So I was like "Cool, now focus less on those shit-bags and focus on The cool people, like Glen and Maggie, and Hershel's Recovery"

Although T-Dogs Heroism got me a little...

But seriously though, So glad I don't have to hear Lori bitch anymore.

EDIT: I used to hate Carl. I used to yell at the T.V. And tell him to stay in the house. No Longer will I participate in this. He earned his man-card yesterday, and he earned it well.

Aubade wrote:EDIT: I used to hate Carl. I used to yell at the T.V. And tell him to stay in the house. No Longer will I participate in this. He earned his man-card yesterday, and he earned it well.

I was mad at Carl ever since he indirectly caused the death of Dale, who I really really cared for (well his character).

As a mother and wife, perhaps that's why Lori's performance got me so hard. Ya she did a lot of stupid things, but in the end she made amends with her son and gave him the words I think he needed to hear to continue in that world. She also spoke "goodnight my love" right before Maggie cut her open, so I think she always loved Rick, and he was her last thought.

The fact that the little boy had to step it up...ugh heart wrenching what he had to do.

Rick in the end, what gets me about this performance was that I felt the regret in his pain.

I figured since the title of the thread had the episode name in it, spoilers were guaranteed Haha. My bad =[

Yeah, he did a lot in those last moments. I'm sure Lori did, but the shit she put Rick and Shane through for no reason at all just makes me mad. The Man that Rick has turned into makes me mad too. I liked the original Rick from Season 1, haven't liked him since.

Also; I had forgotten about the dale thing... =[ Bringing back Old Wounds.

Ah, and Maggie = 2nd best character in the show. Glen being first.

She's a pro, and I will stop watching the show if she gets killed off.

and from someone who hasn't read the comic: I predict:

The Kid will be Shane's kid, and Glen/Maggie will Adopt him/her and Darryl will be the godfather since he's the 3rd most bad-ass guy in the show.

I love the Walking Dead. I have also shied away from the comics because I want to be "content" with watching the show. I have friends who have read them all, so I'm "sort of" up on the comics.

This episode should win serious awards. I think that it was fantastic, and I'm not going to lie, I cried a little. To think about having to be the one to put a bullet in your mom's head to make sure that she doesn't come back?! T Dog's heroism was cool, but he knew that his time was coming to an end. He had been bit. It was only a matter of time. It was cool to see him go out in a "blaze of glory" though.

I don't hate Rick. I think that he has been put in an awful situation. Left for dead, woke up to a nightmare made real. Comes back to find his wife who thought he was dead screwing his partner, who oh by the way, has tried to kill him several times. To top it off, he has become the de facto leader of a group after it was formed, and it sort of just "came to him" I don't think that he tried to "be" the leader. The problem is, he has had everyone chirping at him about what they think, and how they think, and what they want. It's sort of a reflection of politics in the US right now, on a "micro scale".

I too have had a serious dislike for Lori, but the ending was... wow. I didn't expect it to end that way. I didn't expect her son to have to do it. She readily admitted that she had been awful towards Rick. That doesn't make life easy.

I hope Carol doesn't die. There are some interesting things to be had with her character, and I hope that they explore them before they kill her, but I'm not so sure that will happen.

While it is a great adaptation and the show is one of the best things currently on it really isn't award winning standard and hasn't been since the first episode with possibly the exception of 'Sofia' in the second season mid season break episode. [Why the hell do they do that? It isn't novel, it is just sodding annoying]

The Thick Of It, Peep Show, Deadwood, Invasion and Sherlock had to wait quite a while for recognition and all of those shows are superior in every way to this while on a much lower budget.

I am hoping The Walking Dead runs for 4 or possibly 5 seasons only before coming to a conclusion, I don't want to watch another drawn out series that goes past its sell by date and then has an appalling ending./looks at 'Lost' which ironically I wish I had never 'Found'.

Make it like Deadwood please but actually finish it. IE have good characters like Daryl, Shane, Dale, Maggie and Glenn as Allbad says. I do feel sorry for Andrew Lincoln, at least his character in This Life had a natural progression rather than the dross he is having to go through now which I don't think is well written at all.

Don't get me wrong, I love The Walking Dead but it isn't 'Band of Brothers'.

Sabindeus wrote:I feel like I should get a t-shirt made for me that says "Not Socially Awkward, Just Fat".

I disagree, I love the writing on The Walking Dead. It might not be Band of Brothers, but It certainly isn't as bad as the writing got on another of my favorite shows as it wound down (Rescue Me) the Last season and a half or so really just didn't sit well with me, and F/X telling them that they couldn't kill Tommy REALLY pissed me off. Part of me wishes the show would have ended in the bar with Teddy offing Tommy.

Personally, I do think that scene deserves one, it moved me like no other in a long time. I usually run away from scenes like those, I really don't like watching them, but this one kept me on the couch, I couldn't look away and I couldn't contain myself. The power of that scene was well felt in our household, the build up and writing up to it culminated into a bunch of cry babies throughout the Walking Dead fan base; must mean something lol.

And part of me is just also being mad that sci-fi shows get ignored and pushed to the side. I often thought that BSG needed to win an award, the social drama was amazing. But hey, though I am a fan, they keep giving awards to shows like Mad Men (which totally sucked this season IMO) and ignore the perceived "nerd" shows.

Guess I feel like a lot of the sci-fi/fantasy shows get glazed over because maybe there is a prejudice against their perceived "geekdom" fan base, as if we don't matter.

But then again, I am sure there are lots of sci-fi shows that might have gotten awards that I am not aware of.

But on its own, I still feel this was one of more powerful episodes I have scene in my life, on the pure raw human emotion and sacrifice.

Personally, I do think that scene deserves one, it moved me like no other in a long time. I usually run away from scenes like those, I really don't like watching them, but this one kept me on the couch, I couldn't look away and I couldn't contain myself. The power of that scene was well felt in our household, the build up and writing up to it culminated into a bunch of cry babies throughout the Walking Dead fan base; must mean something lol.

And part of me is just also being mad that sci-fi shows get ignored and pushed to the side. I often thought that BSG needed to win an award, the social drama was amazing. But hey, though I am a fan, they keep giving awards to shows like Mad Men (which totally sucked this season IMO) and ignore the perceived "nerd" shows.

Guess I feel like a lot of the sci-fi/fantasy shows get glazed over because maybe there is a prejudice against their perceived "geekdom" fan base, as if we don't matter.

But then again, I am sure there are lots of sci-fi shows that might have gotten awards that I am not aware of.

But on its own, I still feel this was one of more powerful episodes I have scene in my life, on the pure raw human emotion and sacrifice.

Personally, I do think that scene deserves one, it moved me like no other in a long time. I usually run away from scenes like those, I really don't like watching them, but this one kept me on the couch, I couldn't look away and I couldn't contain myself. The power of that scene was well felt in our household, the build up and writing up to it culminated into a bunch of cry babies throughout the Walking Dead fan base; must mean something lol.

And part of me is just also being mad that sci-fi shows get ignored and pushed to the side. I often thought that BSG needed to win an award, the social drama was amazing. But hey, though I am a fan, they keep giving awards to shows like Mad Men (which totally sucked this season IMO) and ignore the perceived "nerd" shows.

Guess I feel like a lot of the sci-fi/fantasy shows get glazed over because maybe there is a prejudice against their perceived "geekdom" fan base, as if we don't matter.

But then again, I am sure there are lots of sci-fi shows that might have gotten awards that I am not aware of.

But on its own, I still feel this was one of more powerful episodes I have scene in my life, on the pure raw human emotion and sacrifice.

Flex wrote:The women can't be strong without a man. The minorities are either useless background characters (RIP T-Dogg) or simply yes men to the white people.

Crazy samurai sword lady says hi.

Guardian Angel to a white lady and has shown no character development beyond a stink eye of doom, hell they don't even let her really communicate in fully formed thoughts and sentences. If they expanded upon her "pets" with a flashback history it would do wonders for her story, but nope, can't have that. I bet she'll open up when she comes in contact with a man.

Not to mention that Andrea who morphed to a Stepford Wife to the Governor after becoming a pretty decent asskicker in season 2, then again she gravitates towards men in power and basically becomes what they want.

Now take a look at two characters created for the series. T-Dog and Daryl. Daryl has been a great character from pretty much the start. He is determined, caring, and shows actual character evolution and is a more natural leader than Shane or Rick have shown. T-Dog's character arc can pretty much be summed up with "bald black guy." A body for when you need to fight zombies.

We live in a society where people born on third base constantly try to steal second, yet we expect people born with two strikes against them to hit a homerun on the first pitch.

I do have a distaste for the way they are handling michonne, but I haven't read the comics to see if it is much different. I just know that at this point, she is the "crazy sane person" that woodbury doesn't like.

Speaking of Woodbury, I'm completely baffled by that "community". I'm curious to see where it goes, but at this point, I'm just unsure of what to think about this community that has this illusion of freedom under marshal law. The scientist / dr guy seems to be absolutely crazy.

Oh, if you meant Michonne is not a strong character in the literary sense, being well developed and interesting etc., then yes, I would agree with you. I thought you meant strong as in physically and/or emotionally strong. Not having read the comic books, I was appalled when Michonne appeared at the end of season 2, as the character just seemed so ridiculously, well, comic book in concept. What I've liked about the TV series is that it managed to immerse me in a post-apocalyptic world, which - while essentially absurd if you think about it (zombie apocalypse) - nonetheless got me to suspend disbelief. A katana wielding character with two zombie pets... ugh. Seeing Rick put on a cape and wear his underpants over his trousers would have been less immersion breaking. More generally, Season 3 seems to be making the zombies less of a threat and introducing more comic book violence, with the group one-shotting them with ease and generally tearing through them like a hot axe through butter. Still, Woodbury seems a formidable new threat for Rick's tiny group.

On an unrelated matter - for anyone interested in the Walking Dead world, I'd recommend the Walking Dead adventure game by Telltale games. They just released the final episode this week. If you think of it as an interactive movie or graphic novel, rather than a game, then you might get a lot of enjoyment from it. I've never been so affected emotionally by a computer game - thanks to wonderful voice acting and story telling, it sets up an incredibly strong surrogate father-daughter relationship. There are parts in it that make "The Killer Within" TV episode feel like light entertainment. The game is 50% off on Steam at the moment. It's only 12 hours of game time, but it's a very moving and memorable - reviews talking about it as the game of the year are not over-hyping it. It's better than the TV series and I am addicted to the TV series.

Well Season 3 is months after the end of season 2 so assume everyone took a level in badass during those months on the road and zombies are rather easily killed with coordination, just when they're surprised and go stupid do humans fail against them.

I also picked up the game on the Steam sale. I'll admit that the first half of Episode 3, starting episode 4 tonight, was emotionally draining. Episode 2 was a bit meh, 3 months time seemed way too short for that storyline to be used.

We live in a society where people born on third base constantly try to steal second, yet we expect people born with two strikes against them to hit a homerun on the first pitch.

Flex wrote:Kill a black guy, replace him with the prisoner. Kill the prisoner replace him with the black guy from the comics. There can be only one.

I'm glad I'm not the only one who thought of this. Man... What the heck is their problem with minority men on the show?

is Glen not a minority? he's my fave too, if something happens to Glen I don't want to watch anymore!

Glen is also a developed character. Something T-Dogg and Oscar never got to be, I think we learned more about Oscar in his few episodes than we ever learned about T-Dogg. Tyrese, since he is a comic book import, should actually get development and stick around for once.

We live in a society where people born on third base constantly try to steal second, yet we expect people born with two strikes against them to hit a homerun on the first pitch.