RELIGION IN THE PUBLIC SCHOOLS

Transcription

1 RELIGION IN THE PUBLIC SCHOOLS BACKGROUND RELIGIOUS LIBERTY IN AMERICA & OUR PUBLIC SCHOOLS Since its founding in 1913, the Anti-Defamation League (ADL) has been guided by its mandate of combating bigotry, bias and discrimination, and securing the rights and liberties of all citizens of the United States. ADL deeply believes deeply in the importance of preserving and safeguarding freedom of religion in our increasingly pluralistic nation. Consequently, we believe that government should neither promote nor be hostile to religion.: Therefore, state sponsored or organized religious activity must be kept out of the public schools. Although this belief may be distasteful to some, this position is not one of hostility towards religion; rather, it reflects a profound respect for religious freedom and recognition of the extraordinary diversity of religions represented by the students in our public schools. Families entrust public schools with the education of their children, but condition their trust on the understanding that the classroom will not purposely be used to advance religious views that may conflict with the private beliefs of the student and his or her family. Students in such institutions are impressionable and their attendance is involuntary. The State exerts great authority and coercive power through mandatory attendance requirements, and because of the students' emulation of teachers as role models and the children's susceptibility to peer pressure. In no activity of the State is it more vital to keep out divisive forces than in its schools. Edwards v. Aguillard, 482 U.S. 578, 584 (1987). AMERICA S FOUNDING PRINCIPLE: RELIGIOUS FREEDOM THROUGH SEPARATION OF CHURCH AND STATE The right to freedom of religion is so central to American democracy that it was enshrined in the First Amendment to the U.S. Constitution. Recognizing the unique and intimate nature of religion, the Founding Fathers wisely put religion on a different footing from other forms of speech and observance mandating strict separation of church and state to ensure religious freedom for all individuals and faiths. Largely because of the First Amendment s prohibition against government regulation or endorsement of religion, diverse faiths have flourished and thrived in America since the founding of the republic. The Founding Fathers in drafting the First Amendment wisely treated religion and religious 1

2 beliefs differently from other forms of expression to ensure protection of religious freedom. To do so, they placed special restrictions on religion, but importantly, they also provided religion with special constitutional protections. These special restrictions and protections are expressed in the first sixteen words of the First Amendment, and they are called the Establishment Clause and the Free Exercise Clause: Congress shall make no law respecting an establishment of religion, or prohibiting the free exercise thereof. (First Amendment, U.S. Constitution December 15, 1791). Taken together, these clauses are often referred to as the Constitution s Religion Clauses. Each of these clauses separates religion and government in ways that protect individual religious freedom, and ensure the integrity of both religion and government. Establishment Clause - "Congress shall make no law respecting an establishment of religion...." This clause prohibits a joining between government and religion. As such, there can be no official state religion, no preference by government of one faith over another or religion generally, no taxes to support religion, and no government support for religious worship or practice. Free Exercise Clause - "Congress shall make no law... prohibiting the free exercise thereof." This clause provides each individual with the right to freely practice the religion of his or her choosing. It ensures the autonomy houses of worship and other religious institutions from government in matters of internal governance and religious law. It prohibits government from enacting laws that specifically target religion. Importantly, it empowers the government to provide houses of worship with special accommodations and exemptions from civil law that might otherwise interfere with religious worship or practice. The Establishment and Free Exercise Clauses complement each other to guard against [a] union of government and religion, which, in the words of distinguished U.S. Supreme Court Justice Hugo Black, tends to destroy government and to degrade religion. Engel v. Vitale, 370 U. S. 421, 431 (1962). Not merely burdensome legal technicalities, these two clauses enshrine the belief that all Americans should be free to practice their religion without state interference. Compliance with the separation of church and state must be vigorously enforced in the nation's public schools. Not endorsing or not appearing to endorse religion is especially important in the 2

3 public school setting. This is due to a number of considerations unique to the public schools: the specific sensitivities of school-age children; the fact that public schools are public institutions; and the profound influence of school officials and teachers over students. This last point bears special examination. Most children view their teachers and other school officials as important authority figures. Moreover, children are highly susceptible to coercion, and particularly cogent is the pressure to conform both from adults and from their peers. These factors create a significant danger when religion is introduced into the public schools in circumstances evincing the apparent endorsement of teachers. Furthermore, the student body in America's public schools is growing increasingly diverse. Schools must give special consideration to the fact that many school children belong to minority religions or are raised in non-religious environments. The nation's public schools must be hospitable to students from a variety of backgrounds -- students of all faiths as well as no faith. Public schools should inculcate students with understanding and respect for diversity, as well as a spirit of tolerance, acceptance and inclusion. Moreover, all of this can be achieved without a religious message. In Santa Fe Independent School Dist. v. Doe, the U.S. Supreme Court concisely summed up the difficulty with school sponsored religion: School sponsorship of a religious message is impermissible because it sends the ancillary message to members of the audience who are nonadherents that they are outsiders, not full members of the political community, and an accompanying message to adherents that they are insiders, favored members of the political community. 1 Some have said that this viewpoint "bristles with hostility to religion." 2 ADL does not agree. To the contrary, this statement brilliantly expresses the difficulties that arise when government makes religion its aim. RELIGION IN THE PUBLIC SCHOOLS GENERAL LEGAL PRINCIPLES A. The Establishment Clause As a legal matter, any school practice or policy must not violate the Establishment Clause. For more than three decades, compliance with the Establishment Clause has been examined under the test the U. S. Supreme Court enunciated in Lemon v. Kurtzman, 403 U. S. 602 (1971). When a court looks at whether a program involving religion is permissible, it first asks: does it meet the criteria set forth in Lemon? Indeed, the "Lemon test" has proven largely successful in protecting the religious rights and liberties of all Americans, including religious minorities. Thus, in order for a state practice or policy, including a public school practice or policy, to pass constitutional muster 1 Santa Fe Independent School Dist. v. Doe, 530 U. S. 290, 390 (2000) (internal marks omitted). 2 Id. at 318 (C. J. Rehnquist, dissenting). 3

4 under the Lemon test, a school official must answer "yes" to the following three questions: Does the policy in question have a secular purpose? Will the policy in question have a primary effect which neither advances nor inhibits religion? Does the policy in question avoid entangling government and religion? If a school official cannot answer an unequivocal yes to all three of these questions, then the policy must be abandoned. This is necessary as a matter of constitutional law and is good policy. It respects the rights and sensitivities of all students, some of whom may have religious practices that differ from the one being advanced by the policy in question. In practice, this means that the public schools must never endorse -- or appear to endorse -- any religion or religious practice. Indeed, not only may they not appear to endorse religion, but they may never appear to disapprove of religion either. Moreover, schools may not give the impression that they endorse religious belief over non-belief or any particular belief over others. The principle that public schools must never endorse or disapprove of religion has been established in a long line of U. S. Supreme Court decisions. Students must never be given the impression that their school officially prefers or sanctions a particular religion or religion generally. Further, students must never feel coerced by pressure from their peers or from the public to adhere to any religion. The U. S. Supreme Court reemphasized the importance of church-state separation in the public schools in Lee v. Weisman, 112 S. Ct (1992) and more recently in Santa Fe Independent School Dist. v. Doe, 530 U. S. 290 (2000). In both cases, the Court was particularly concerned with the danger of student religious coercion in public schools resulting from peer and public pressure. The decisions are a ringing reaffirmation of the importance of government not endorsing one religion over another or religion over non-religion, particularly when public schools are involved. Notably, the Supreme Court has held that the state (school) is constitutionally obligated to see that state-supported activity is not used for religious indoctrination. 3 B. The Free Exercise Clause The second question a school must ask about a proposed policy or practice is whether it violates the "free exercise clause" of the First Amendment. "The free exercise of religion means, first and foremost, the right to believe and profess whatever religious doctrine one desires. Thus, the First Amendment obviously excludes all governmental regulation of religious beliefs as such. The government may not compel affirmation of religious belief, punish the expression of religious doctrines it believes to be false, impose special disabilities on the basis of religious views or 3 See Levitt v. Committee for Public Education & Religious Liberty, 413 U. S. 472 (1973). 4

5 religious status, or lend its power to one or the other side in controversies over religious authority or dogma." 4 While this protection seems very broad, the Court has held that the right of free exercise does not relieve an individual of the obligation to comply with a "valid and neutral law of general applicability on the ground that the law proscribes (or prescribes) conduct that his religion prescribes (or proscribes)." 5 That is, if a law or policy is passed that applies to everyone but happens to impinge on your ability to practice your religion, you may not be able to challenge the law or policy on free exercise grounds. These challenges are difficult because the government must only show a minimal justification for such laws. So, for example, criminal drug laws preventing the use of peyote are applicable even to those whose worship requires the use of peyote because the laws were not passed with religion in mind and are applicable to everyone. 6 It should be noted, however, that in certain states there are laws requiring stronger justification for neutral laws or policies of general applicability that impinge on religious practice. The relationship between the Establishment Clause and the Free Exercise Clause can be a bit hard to tease out. At the end of the day, however, so long as the school district is neither endorsing nor disapproving of religion, it should not run afoul of the Constitution. PROVIDED BY: Civil Rights Division 4 Employment Div., Dept. of Human Resources of Oregon v. Smith, 494 U. S. 872, 877 (1990) (internal marks and citations omitted). 5 Id. at Id

When Lemons Are Not Enough: An Analysis of the Lemon Test In Establishment Clause Cases Mariam Rahman Education Law and Policy: Dean Kaufman The Lemon Test, established by Chief Justice Warren Burger in

Touro Law Review Volume 17 Number 1 Supreme Court and Local Government Law: 1999-2000 Term & New York State Constitutional Decisions: 2001 Compilation Article 4 March 2016 United States Court of Appeals

AP UNITED STATES GOVERNMENT AND POLITICS 2007 SCORING GUIDELINES Question 2 6 points Part (a): 1 point One point is earned for correctly identifying the establishment clause as the First Amendment clause

RELIGION IN THE PUBLIC SCHOOLS RELIGION IN THE CURRICULUM Public schools may not teach religion, although teaching about religion in a secular context is permitted. 1 The Bible may be taught in a school,

Student Policies BP 03-08 Board Policy: RELIGION IN SCHOOL Introduction The First Amendment of the Constitution states that Congress shall make no law respecting the establishment of religion, or prohibiting

VOLUME 4, NUMBER 1, 2010 State Aid to Private Schools: A Question of Separation of Church and State Fred C. Lunenburg Sam Houston State University ABSTRACT Historically, the Supreme Court generally has

BIBLE YOUTH GROUP EXCLUDED FROM SCHOOL OPEN FOR COMMUNITY USE James C. Kozlowski, J.D., Ph.D. 2001 James C. Kozlowski In the Good News opinion described herein, the Supreme Court of the United States considered

I PLEDGE ALLEGIANCE TO RELIGION? Alexa Vouros* I. INTRODUCTION Courts have not been consistent in deciding whether students Establishment Clause and Free Exercise rights are violated with the enactment

11 Top Ten Rules That Govern School Authority Over Student Cyber Expressions Although conflicting court decisions have surfaced and jurisdictional variations exist, the following general principles guiding

RELIGION IN THE PUBLIC SCHOOLS 1 RELIGION IN THE PUBLIC SCHOOLS OVERVIEW A COMPLEX ISSUE The issue of the proper role of religion in the public schools continues to be the subject of great controversy.

Congress shall make no law respecting an establishment of religion or prohibiting the free exercise thereof; or abridging the freedom of speech, or of the press; or the right of the people peaceably to

GENERIC OPT OUT LETTER GUIDELINES (provided by United Opt Out) A great deal of rules, regulations, and policies regarding opting a student out of high stakes standardized tests are STATE SPECIFIC. We recommend

FIRST AMENDMENT TO THE UNITED STATES CONSTITUTION 8C H A P T E R 8 the Public Schools the Public Schools: Questions and Answers is sponsored jointly by: American Academy of Religion American Association

The First Amendment Congress shall make no law respecting an establishment of religion, or prohibiting the free exercise thereof; or abridging the freedom of speech, or of the press, or the right of the

The Pledge of Allegiance: Under God is Under Scrutiny Arsineh Arakel * I. INTRODUCTION: THE "UNDER GOD" PHRASE This article examines whether the phrase under God in the Pledge of Allegiance violates the

The Rights of Parents to Home-school Their Children in Europe Written by Mr J. Sperling, LL.M and Drs. P.J. van Zuidam Spoken by Drs. P.J. van Zuidam at the World Congress of Families V, Forum 2 10 August,

STATE OF INDIANA HOUSE OF REPRESENTATIVES THIRD FLOOR STATE HOUSE INDIANAPOLIS, INDIANA 46204 Bruce Borders 7935 N State Road 59 Jasonville, IN 47438 Email: H45@in.gov Statehouse: 1-800-382-9841 Website:

Education Administrator Department of Education Mike Maher 465-3603 Deputy Commissioner Department of Education Enrollment of private and home school students in public schools Janice Gregg Levy Assistant

A Parent s Guide to Religion in the Public Schools National PTA Congress shall make no law respecting an establishment of religion, or prohibiting the free exercise thereof; or abridging the freedom of

MEMORANDUM RE: Religion in the Workplace A Guide for Private Christian Business Owners Questions Presented What are the rights of employers with regard to religion in the workplace, and what best practices

Committee A: Net Neutrality and Internet Access Draft Resolution Submitted for revision by the delegations to the Model United Nation, College of Charleston, Spring 2011 The General Assembly Reaffirming

EXCERPTS OF POLICIES AND REGULATIONS APPLYING TO COLLEGE ACTIVITIES, ORGANIZATIONS AND STUDENTS* ADOPTED BY THE BOARD OF DIRECTORS 6/22/1990 TABLE OF CONTENTS Section 10.00 Introduction 11.00 General Provisions:

1 Chair Education and Science Select Committee RELIGIOUS INSTRUCTION AND OBSERVANCES IN STATE SCHOOLS Purpose 1. The purpose of this paper is to respond to the Committee's request for a briefing on 'issues

IN RE MARRIAGE CASES (California): 2008 These cases present the issue of the legality of gay marriage bans, in the context of previous State domestic partnership (CA) or civil union (CT) Statutes, under

michael e. hersher Home Schooling in California The recent decision of the California Court of Appeal in the Rachel L. case set off a storm of protest from the California home school community and drew

Legal Exemptions for Religious Based Medical Neglect Ariel Alvarez Montclair State University April 19, 2013 Center for Child Advocacy Overview *About the research and goals. *Methods *Results *Discussion

Unofficial translation The Law of Georgia On the Elimination of All Forms of Discrimination Article 1. The Objective of the Law The present law aims to eliminate any form of discrimination and to ensure

RELIGION IN THE PUBLIC SCHOOLS TEACHING ABOUT RELIGIOUS HOLIDAYS THE DECEMBER DILEMMA Teachers must be careful not to cross the line between teaching about religious holidays (which is permitted) and celebrating

I have rights, you have rights, he/she has rights... An introduction to children s rights Everyone has rights. Moreover, as a boy or girl aged under 18 you have certain specific rights. A list of these

BOARD OF EDUCATION GUIDELINES RECITATION OF THE PLEDGE OF ALLEGIANCE (Adopted July 26, 2001) Introduction A primary function of public schools is providing fundamental knowledge to elementary and secondary

Background on the First Amendment Congress shall make no law respecting an establishment of religion, or prohibiting the free exercise thereof; or abridging the freedom of speech, or of the press, or the

Universal Declaration of Human Rights Preamble Whereas recognition of the inherent dignity and of the equal and inalienable rights of all members of the human family is the foundation of freedom, justice

Charter Schools Program Title V, Part B Non-Regulatory Guidance July, 2004 Non-Regulatory Guidance Title V, Part B Charter Schools Program The Charter Schools Program CSP) was authorized in October 1994,

CCBE POSITION WITH RESPECT TO THE FREE CHOICE OF A LAWYER IN RELATION TO LEGAL EXPENSES INSURANCE CCBE position with respect to the free choice of a lawyer in relation to legal expenses insurance The Council

Fresno USD 6000 AR 6141.2 Instruction Religious Expression In The Schools Student Prayer and Religious Discussions Students have the same right to engage in individual or group prayer and religious discussion

SCHOOL LAW STUDY GUIDE CALIFORNIA STATE UNIVERSITY, NORTHRIDGE MICHAEL D. EISNER COLLEGE OF EDUCATION EDUCATIONAL LEADERSHIP & POLICY STUDIES US CONSTITUTION General Welfare Clause is found in the preamble

SCHOOL LAW STUDY GUIDE CALIFORNIA STATE UNIVERSITY, NORTHRIDGE MICHAEL D. EISNER COLLEGE OF EDUCATION EDUCATIONAL LEADERSHIP & POLICY STUDIES US CONSTITUTION General Welfare Clause is found in the preamble

Hinsdale Public Library Internet Access and Computer Use Policy Policy Purpose The Hinsdale Public Library Board of Trustees has established the following policy to guide the provision of access to the

Written Statement of Maggie Garrett Legislative Director on Behalf of Americans United for Separation of Church and State Submitted to the Military Personnel Subcommittee of the United States House Committee

Marriage (Same Sex Couples) Act: A factsheet Marriage is a hugely important institution in this country. The principles of long-term commitment and responsibility which underpin it bind society together

PHILIPPINE LONG DISTANCE TELEPHONE COMPANY CODE OF BUSINESS CONDUCT AND ETHICS Philippine Long Distance Telephone Company ( PLDT or the Company ) is dedicated to doing business in accordance with the highest

firstamendmentcenter.org Your First Freedoms A Basic Guide to the First Amendment Q: What is the First Amendment and where does it come from? A: The First Amendment consists of 45 words added to the Constitution

Chapter 6 The Constitution and Business Laws that govern business have their origin in the lawmaking authority granted by the federal constitution. The Constitutional Powers of Government The Constitution

The appropriate use of sacred music in the public school curriculum is an issue that music educators continually encounter. While the artistic and curricular value of teaching with sacred music may seem

C H A R T E R O F V A L U E S OF C I T I Z E N S H I P AND I N T E G R A T I O N SCIENTIFIC COUNCIL - MINISTRY OF INTERIOR OFFICIAL TRANSLATION ITALY AS A COMMUNITY OF PERSONS AND VALUES Italy is one of

KEY OSCE COMMITMENTS ON FREEDOM OF PEACEFUL ASSEMBLY Vienna 1989 (Questions Relating to Security in Europe: Principles) [ ] In order to ensure the freedom of the individual to profess and practice religion

Sponsored by Senator BATES (Presession filed.) th OREGON LEGISLATIVE ASSEMBLY-- Regular Session Senate Bill SUMMARY The following summary is not prepared by the sponsors of the measure and is not a part

THE SPECIAL NEEDS SCHOLARSHIP PROGRAM ACT AS PASSED BY THE EDUCATION TASK FORCE Summary: The Special Needs Scholarship Program provides special needs students with the option to attend the public or non-public

CURRENT FEDERAL LAWS PROTECTING CONSCIENCE RIGHTS Over the past forty-one years, numerous federal laws and regulations have been enacted to protect rights of conscientious objection. Many of these laws

Index: ASA 16/1107/2015 3 March 2015 Myanmar: Parliament must reject discriminatory race and religion laws Joint statement by Amnesty International and the International Commission of Jurists Myanmar s

THE ADMINISTRATION OF JUSTICE IN CYPRUS A. GENERAL (i) Historical background The island of Cyprus in the northeastern part of the Mediterranean lies forty miles away from Asia Minor, sixty miles away from

IN THE UNITED STATES DISTRICT COURT FOR THE EASTERN DISTRICT OF PENNSYLVANIA MIRANDA L. MAHER : CIVIL ACTION : v. : : MOORE COLLEGE OF ART AND DESIGN : NO. 98-2978 MEMORANDUM AND ORDER BECHTLE, J. FEBRUARY,

Franklin Technology Center s Code of Conduct Franklin Technology Center is comprised of students, faculty, staff and administrators. This community recognizes the need to establish a code of conduct that

RELIGION IN THE PUBLIC SCHOOLS PRAYER IN PUBLIC SCHOOLS Organized prayer in the public school setting, whether in the classroom or at a schoolsponsored event, is unconstitutional. The only type of prayer

Code No. 603.1 BASIC INSTRUCTION PROGRAM The basic instruction program will include the courses required for each grade level by the State Department of Education. The instructional approach will be gender

FIRST AMENDMENT TO THE UNITED STATES CONSTITUTION 6C H A P T E R 6 Public Schools A Teacher's Guide to Religion and Public Schools has been endorsed by the following organizations: American Association

CODE OF PRACTICE ON FREEDOM OF SPEECH AND LAWFUL ASSEMBLY IN THE UNIVERSITY Name of Code of Practice: Purpose of Code of Practice: Approval for this Code of Practice given by: Responsibility for its update:

Obama Executive Order on Sexual Orientation and Gender Identity What did President Obama do? Peter Sprigg and Travis Weber On July 21, 2014, President Obama signed an Executive Order to prohibit discrimination

CASE STUDY JAMES TUTTLE VS. LAKELAND COMMUNITY COLLEGE Patrick Horn, Claremont Graduate University Ryan Robinson, Utah Valley State College In the case of James Tuttle and Lakeland Community College in

Council of Europe: European Court of Human Rights and the Parot Doctrine March 2014 The Law Library of Congress, Global Legal Research Center (202) 707-6462 (phone) (866) 550-0442 (fax) law@loc.gov http://www.law.gov

Annex 1 Primary sources for international standards 1. The United Nations The 1948 Universal Declaration of Human Rights Article 20 1. Everyone has the right to freedom of peaceful assembly and association.

CODE OF CONDUCT FOR PROBATION OFFICERS Probation officers are an extension of the Indiana Judiciary and as such, shall be held to the highest standards of conduct that promote an independent, fair, and

THE FIRST AMENDMENT TO THE U.S. CONSTITUTION 1 Congress shall make no law respecting an establishment of religion, or prohibiting the free exercise thereof; or abridging the freedom of speech, or of the