Here's what others have to say...

View

For freezing rides.

Familiarity:
I've used it several times

Fit:
True to size

Since I live in Arizona, it's not often I have to tough out rides in temperatures around freezing, or lower. But a few weeks ago, I raced in freezing temperatures and ended up using these gloves. While I wasn't out in the cold for long, I was pretty surprised that my hands didn't go numb in the time I was outside. The downside is that you lose some dexterity with all the bulk. But I think that's a reasonable compromise for comfortable hands. I also noticed that my thumb was restricted in these gloves . But this didn't seem to affect their comfort or fit while riding a flat bar or hoods.

Comment on Chloe Woodruff's review:

Restrictive thumb

Familiarity:
I've used it several times

Fit:
Runs small

Tried a women's large and couldn't extend my thumb fully in all directions, so I ended up buying this glove in a men's medium. In terms of warmth, I was out for a three hour ride in 42F weather, and I was fine for the first two hours but suffered with really cold fingertips for the last hour. I'm still looking for a five fingered glove for 25-40 degree weather.

Comment on swmp637156's review:

WARM

These guys are amazingly warm and look great (really sleek). The fingers on them are short though. I actually considered keeping them since they are so comfy, but the safety risk of too short fingers wasn't worth it for me. I didn't test the waterproofing, but it IS Gore...