Rain Partier

GHERU wrote:if 0 was always an option I take back my objectionbut, 0's from people who refuse to read the book - that can't be considered fair play, can it?

Nah, I think people should read the book to have the right to complain or score lower. Similarly, I think they should review books and be a member to vote in our polls to select books. We don't let non-members select books individually, why should they have a vote in what is merely a collective selection??

Rain Partier

GHERU wrote:if 0 was always an option I take back my objectionbut, 0's from people who refuse to read the book - that can't be considered fair play, can it?

Nah, I think people should read the book to have the right to complain or score lower. Similarly, I think they should review books and be a member to vote in our polls to select books. We don't let non-members select books individually, why should they have a vote in what is merely a collective selection??

"Being offended is not to be confused with a state of grace; it’s the occasional price we all pay for living in an open society." -- Ian McEwan

The Red Stands for Irony

How is it exclusive? If someone wants to join, they submit a review! For the purpose of the poll, I suppose if someone states their intent to review, that would be good enough for me.

And as for the zero, it has not been an option except for special occasions. I deem that this Holiday Season is one. In the rule of fair play, I'll allow the use of elevens too, for this one week only.

How is it exclusive? If someone wants to join, they submit a review! For the purpose of the poll, I suppose if someone states their intent to review, that would be good enough for me.

And as for the zero, it has not been an option except for special occasions. I deem that this Holiday Season is one. In the rule of fair play, I'll allow the use of elevens too, for this one week only.

Outhouse Editor

Victorious Squid wrote:Nah, I think people should read the book to have the right to complain or score lower. Similarly, I think they should review books and be a member to vote in our polls to select books. We don't let non-members select books individually, why should they have a vote in what is merely a collective selection??

Outhouse Editor

Victorious Squid wrote:Nah, I think people should read the book to have the right to complain or score lower. Similarly, I think they should review books and be a member to vote in our polls to select books. We don't let non-members select books individually, why should they have a vote in what is merely a collective selection??

Outhouse Editor

BlueStreak wrote:How is it exclusive? If someone wants to join, they submit a review! For the purpose of the poll, I suppose if someone states their intent to review, that would be good enough for me.

And as for the zero, it has not been an option except for special occasions. I deem that this Holiday Season is one. In the rule of fair play, I'll allow the use of elevens too, for this one week only.

I can't go and change the pick when the masses have spoken. The only way I can think of to rectify this is moving forward to only count votes of Review Groupers.

Outhouse Editor

BlueStreak wrote:How is it exclusive? If someone wants to join, they submit a review! For the purpose of the poll, I suppose if someone states their intent to review, that would be good enough for me.

And as for the zero, it has not been an option except for special occasions. I deem that this Holiday Season is one. In the rule of fair play, I'll allow the use of elevens too, for this one week only.

I can't go and change the pick when the masses have spoken. The only way I can think of to rectify this is moving forward to only count votes of Review Groupers.