When it comes to New Jersey, the same Reddit user says "On the Waterfront" was the top-rated film on IMDB.com set in the state.

We disagreed (again) and offered five other choices: "Clerks," "American Gangster," "Friday the 13th," "A Beautiful Mind" and "Harold and Kumar Go to White Castle." Readers picked "Clerks," a clear favorite over the next top vote-getter, "A Beautiful Mind."

Did our voters get it right? Tell us what you think in the comments below.