It's just obsessiveness--I don't really need to have so many backups--but when we're dealing with this kind of orphaned hardware it makes me feel better to know that I'm covered if a unit suddenly fails.

More likely is that there will be some other HD recording solution long before I need to use any of these receivers.

No, but I found a source on the web that apparently has the 5000 Mods in stock for $360. I just purchased one of them as well. So for a bit over $500, I will be able to start recording HBO!!!! (using my existing HiPix).

Alright, I have a Dish 6000 and a Dish 5000, no modulator yet. My question is, What are the costs I'm looking at here. From what I gather there is a Panasonic HD1000 method, and a HiPix method. What are my costs, and what are the pros and cons? Also if someone has a lead on the modulator, send me a mail.

Originally posted by jlin:I was able to buy one 5000 plus a 4700 for the same plus with 'multiple discount of $20'

It wasn't necessary to talk to "Tom"

Anyway.. the reason I didn't buy more was my fear that eventually DISH will disable the HDTV modulator system due to pressure from Hollywood by swapping the 5000's with the 6000's.

How likely will that happen?

They have already refused to support these products. That's as far as it will go. As long as they still work, I think they'll ignore us.

Really, how many people have this setup and can record HDTV. It's simply not worth the effort or the potential legal backlash, however small, to disable them. Besides we are still customers paying their bill and $6 for a PPV movie that's recorded and never bought again is still better than nothing. And they kill my box, that's just what they'll get - nothing. I know I speak for many other users in saying that as well.

What are you referring to, when you say "They have already refused to support these products"?

After hearing similar rumors, I called Dish the other night. A Dish technical supervisor confirmed that Dish will repair the 5000 and HD Modulator, in warranty, or out of warranty for a standard charge.

This is precisely in line with Federal Law, which requires consumer electronics manufacturers to offer repair service for their equipment for 7 years after it's taken off the market.

As far as I can see, the only thing Dish did was to discontinue the 5000, which was always a stop gap measure anyway, and introduce the 6000.

Paying $70 for a 5000 is not a bad deal. However, I predict that soon we will have several HDTV recording alternatives available. This is why I have decided not to jump into spending a fancy price for a second PVHD1000 even though it would be nice to have two. Soon better recording VCRs will be out and the PVHD1000 will drop significantly in price because it won't be the only game in town. Likewise, as much as 16X9 is having startup problems right now we will see options to record off the DTC100 to the DVHS and off the 6000. It's only a matter of time before I believe Andy will have his act together AND will have competition.