Medtronic wins pain pump case on preemption | Legal News

Medtronic (NYSE:MDT) won another personal injury lawsuit based on the preemption doctrine it helped create in the U.S. Supreme Court’s Riegel v Medtronic decision in 2008.

Preemption holds that patients can’t sue medical device makers in state courts over products that went through the FDA’s most stringent review process, called pre-market approval. But the justices left open a loophole to allow state suits that allege a "parallel claim" that the company in question broke FDA regulations.

In 2000, plaintiff Richard Stengel began using Medtronic’s SynchroMed EL pain pump, an implanted device that delivers medication directly to the spine via an intrathecal catheter. In 2005, Stengel began developing symptoms of paralysis from an inflammation in his spine around the catheter tip. The device and most of the inflammation were removed, "but not in time to prevent the granuloma from rendering Stengel permanently paraplegic," according to court documents.

The FDA approved the first SynchroMed pump in 1998 and later granted approval for the iteration used to treat Stengel. Medtronic recalled that device in 2008.

The U.S. Court of Appeals for the 9th Circuit upheld a lower court’s ruling dismissing Stengel’s case on preemption grounds, but the 3-judge panel’s decision earned a sharp rebuke from a lone dissenter.

"Has Congress or the Supreme Court created such freedom from liability for the manufacturers of such sensitive devices that only in nonexistent cases are the manufacturers subject to suit for damages?" wrote Judge John Noonan, according to court documents. "Are individuals injured by the malfunction of such devices without remedy against the manufacturers of them? That appears to be the conclusion of this court today with its holding that the [Medical Device Act] explicitly preempts and implicitly preempts any state remedy of damages for violation of a state requirement paralleling the MDA."

Judge J. Clifford Wallace, writing for the majority, said the law is clear on the issue of pre-emption.

"We recognize that it may seem harsh to deny compensation to a person who alleges serious injury from a medical device," Wallace wrote. "But such is the direction from the Supreme Court for cases like the one before us. We are required to follow the Court."

Noonan argued that the Stengel’s lawsuit ought to stand because it presents a parallel claim.

"Nothing in the statute prevents provision by a state of ‘a traditional damages remedy’ for violation of ‘state duties’ that parallel the federal requirements," Noonan wrote. "The Stengels have alleged a valid parallel state law cause of action. Arizona law imposes requirements that parallel the requirements under federal law, and Arizona law provides a remedy in damages for the violation of the state requirement."

Medtronic Donna Marquard spokeswoman said the company is pleased that the appeals court’s decision was "consistent with other federal circuit court and Supreme Court rulings that have upheld the doctrine of federal pre-emption for devices which have gone through the rigorous pre-market approval process for medical devices," according to Cronkite News.

The first cases of the roughly 3,500 personal injury lawsuits filed over Johnson & Johnson‘s (NYSE:JNJ) recalled DePuy ASR hip implant are close to going to trial, with lawyers discussing which suits should serve as "bellwether" trials that are representative of the plaintiffs’ claims.

Six plaintiffs in Nevada, Wisconsin, Florida and Utah have successfully petitioned to be excluded from the multi-district litigation. More than 5,000 patients worldwide have sued over the implants, which were recalled in 2010. Read more

A C.R. Bard (NYSE:BCR) insurer won’t have to cover Bard’s costs in a case it lost to Rochester Medical (NSDQ:ROCM) after the U.S. Court of Appeals for the 3rd Circuit upheld a lower court’s ruling for Rochester.Read more

The medical market for cosmetic devices is booming. However, quickly launching new products to meet demand is becoming more challenging because device manufactures face increased regulatory scrutiny. To help meet regulatory requirements, aesthetic and other medical-device OEMs are partnering with electronics manufacturing services (EMS) companies that also offer expertise with the FDA filings necessary to […]

Power Partners releases a new 310 Watt medical grade desktop power supply from their PEAMD Series of AC and DC adapters. The 310 Watt unit is packed for ideal performance inside a compact case measuring 7.8 x 4 x 2 in. with a weight of only 3 lbs. The PEAMD310 Series is approved to the latest […]

Saelig Company has introduced the ABI Electronics’ Multiple Instrument Station MIS4, an all-in-one testing tool that provides all commonly required test instruments in one compact programmable hardware module, mounted in a compact case or installed in a PC-drive bay. Controlled by ABI’s sophisticated SYSTEM 8 Ultimate PC software with a simple yet programmable operator interface, […]

AssurX, an enterprise quality management, risk and regulatory compliance solution provider, announces the release of the latest update to their AssurX document management software. The document management solution provides a cost-effective solution for small to medium sized companies faced with streamlined operations and is fully compliant for FDA regulated industries. Ideal solution for small to […]

Saelig Company announces the Amplicon Impact-R 1100F series, a fanless system powered by the Intel ATOM D2550 processor. Configured with a high performance 2.5 in. MLC Solid State Drive (SSD), the Impact-R 1100F series is a silent controller system. With options for multiple serial communication ports, the Impact-R 1100F can offer up seven DB9 connections […]

Gerresheimer AG, a partner to the global pharmacy and healthcare industry, will further extend its pharmaceutical packaging business with the acquisition of Centor. Gerresheimer has reached an agreement with Nemera Development S.A. to acquire 100% of the share capital of Centor US Holding. “Centor is the highly profitable market leader for plastic vials and closures in […]

Editor’s Note: This article is written by Ashley Boam and Mary Malarkey from the “FDA Voice” blog. Boam is an FDA’s acting Director of the Office of Policy for Pharmaceutical Quality, the Office of Pharmaceutical Quality and the Center for Drug Evaluation and Research. Malarkey is an FDA’s Director if the Office of Compliance and Biologics Quality […]