Could Lindsay really be innocent after all? Read on and give us your new verdict!

We already know Lindsay Lohan, 24, is facing jail time for violating her probation and allegedly stealing a $2,500 necklace — but TMZ now claims the surveillance tape from Kamofie & Company proves Lindsay may not have intended to take it after all!

Here’s what the surveillance tape reveals, according to the new report:

She first took off her own necklace in order to try on the new one.

She wore it for 45 minutes in “plain view.”

She and the owner chatted for several minutes, necklace in plain sight, before she walked out.

She put her own necklace back on before leaving, but the report says the store’s necklace was still visible.