A voice for the Tzibbur by the Tzibbur- overcoming challenges. We take no responsibility for comments posted you are solely responsible for any comments you make and their accuracy. We take no responsibility and assume no liability for any comments posted by you or any third-party.

He's a Gaon Adir he is not a Talmid of the Brisker Rav and he also disagreed very strongly with Rav Shach please show us where he said anything against the asifa. Boruch Hashem we don't have to rely on hearsay there is a letter from the Gedolim in America to the Gedolim in Eretz Yisrael if the Gedolim in Eretz Yisroel disagree I'm sure they will respond.

R' Dov is a Gaon Adir and although he was in his 20's when the Chason Ish was nifter he is still considered from his biggest talmidim he is not a talmid of the Brisker Rav at all. R' Dov also disagreed very strongly on the way Rav Shach was Manhig klal yisroel like every machlokes between Gedolei Hador even though he was around 40 years younger than him. Where is the letter that he is against it ? All we saw see so far is a letter from the gedolim in america I'm sure if the gedolei Eretz Yisroel disagree they will respond to as such to the letter written to them.

I wish I could believe such misinformation to be accurate... Rav Shteinman - may he be well - was NEVER kept properly informed over all the different aspects of the deteriorated state of affairs; and when he was - too little, too late - he could only respond based on the beleaguered outcome of others' negligence. It must be remembered that Rav Shteinman has not been physically well for years; and similar to Rav Shach at his age - unable to thoroughly involve himself in the political state of affairs.

Before indulging in an hour of speeches please see this clip of Rav Elya Zt'l https://youtu.be/oDs5iodF3s . You can see the speech in it`s entirety https://youtu.be/I_V3P7BFHno .Then you can decide on your own if this asifa is the derech bnei yeshivos or just derech Satmar

Before bloging and sitting online all day I would trust the Judgment of 2 biggest Talmidei Chahomim in Lakewood Rav Chaim Ginsburg shlita and Rav Chatzkel Rotkin shlita who gave up learning to go to the asifa. Nebach that your daas torah coes from the internet and not from living sifrei Torah.

Where was Reb Moshe Shimon? Didn't they promise us that he would be there? Where were the other Talmidei Chachomim in town? Reb Moshe Friedman, Reb Yehuda Levenberg, Reb Eliyahu Levin, his children, Reb Meir Eiseman, Reb Avremal Bromberg, Reb Eli Yagid and more?

Rav Dov sent his letter first to the Pshevorsker rebbe who is a talmid if his, and after with Maran Rav Gershon sent another to the novominsker rebbe.........and btw the Novominsker Rebbe wrote at the end of his letter that whatever the case is he is machnia himself to Maran rav ahron leib

There are recordings from the entire Moetzes of Degel and Reb Dov Landau after the draft law was passed that they are not familiar with the details and were not involved. So these letters from Reb Dov Landau seem very strange. He also just says every thing is okay. Basically he is not addressing the hard facts including names, documents, videos...that clearly contradict what he writes. Not a very convincing letter from a logical point of view. Reb Dov is a great Gaon but he was clearly out of the mainstream consensus hashkafa wise for many years. Reb Shach distanced him from the tzibur for many years. I heard they are flying in Reb Moshe Hillel to the rescue to try to convince the American Gedolem. Lets see if his argument will more convincing then Reb Dov or todays Israeli Yated.