Search This Blog

Of Low and High Charging Translators, Undercutting, and Local Variables

The global village is an illusion, all
the more so for all the elements of truth it contains. The market is more fragmented than one
may be inclined to think. Due to this illusion of a global village, created by instant (real-time) communication all across the globe, we may neglect the fact that each of us live in a different economy, with a different local balance.

The rivers and hills

In the translation world, markets in whch one can consistently charge more than 0.06 p.s.w. (per source word) are islands
and caves and high hills. If you and a neighbour live on the same
island or hill, or in the same cave, it makes it natural that both of
you share the same experience and roughly the same perspective, as then do your neighbour's neighbours
and so on within a couple of miles radius. This confirmation around you produces reinforcement and in the end it makes your experience appear to you as the most natural, default state of things, one which either really is or should be the same everywhere else in the world. But then there are
the lowlands and the vast plains and fields of corn, and the rivers,
and forests and meadows, and the low hills where the perspective is
similar to but not quite the same as that seen from a real mountain. The landscape is not uniform.

Real-life example

I spent much of my Friday two weeks ago researching the competition for webdesign clues. This is because I like to see at which stage they are, and occasionally they hire a smart designer that comes up
with something new and inspiration. But I still did look at the Pricing tab whenever
one was available. Their rates fell
anywhere from just under €0.03 p.s.w. to just under €0.04 p.s.w. (where EUR 1 = PLN 4.23). I'm not talking about rookie translators or rates charged from agencies. The search string I used was 'Polish sworn translator', a qualification which requires
a master's degree and a notoriously difficult bidirectional exam, and the prices were inteded for direct clients. My own Polish clients pay noticeably above that range, but how far can you really go above what everybody else seems to be
charging? Especially if those who charge so little are also qualified translators?

The high earners

On the other side of our illustrative Polish spectrum
there are certainly some translators who can get away with charging more
than I do. Those are usually — but not always — significantly experienced colleagues with strong portfolios and good connections, meaning a considerable group of stable relationships with direct clients and higher-paying agencies.
Then, there are supposedly some high-paid specialists who score in
the range of €0.14 p.s.w. before any rush fees — this in a country
where the average wage in the business sector is €799 per month and
falling. At a rate of €0.14 p.s.w., an entire gross salary of €799 could buy you 5700 words of
translation, which means that having paid all your taxes and bills, buying food and so on, you'd be lucky to afford 2000 words. The minimum wage — in a month's scale — could buy you 2850 words if you didn't have to pay tax and bills, probably meaning less than a half of the number in real life. At that point needing your CV in a different language is a very painful event in your life.

Local variables are relevant

As I hope you have seen by now, there are local variables at play here. Those local variables are what makes the different
corners of our global village really different. Anybody can register an account on Proz.com — though there
are certainly places in the world where the membership fee is a fortune — or TranslatorsCafé, anybody with some basic computer skills can start a website
and write a blog like this one (or better). Gifted and driven
individuals can do so much more, write inspiring copy and have magnificent search rankings due to SEO (Search Engine Optimisation). But to get inside the fertile enclaves of good rates —
which may be barren wastes to someone else — one
needs to have clients willing to pay those rates. This necessarily requires access to such clients, and the clients must actually exist in the translator's languages and fields of expertise. The existence of such such clients, and their level of affluence, depends on economic factors, while access to them also depends on relevant cultural issues, for example appetite for outsourcing, willingness to trust freelancers rather than large provides, openness
of businesses to solicitation or their energy and ingenuity and diligence in procuring the best services they can, the social perception and standing of translators, and some more.

Translators with lower variables

The working bees and zombie workers
of our so called 'translation industry' — those being, for example, people who charge below
€0.03 in Poland and perhaps €0.06 in the more affluent western countries — not only lack such privileged access to clients
(not considering here whether that's their own fault or not), they may also lack the more glamorous and well-selling
qualifications that their more prosperous colleagues have, or the imagination, or drive, to sell them well. Finally, they
may lack a certain basic level of business skills or awareness of what's going on in the industry (e.g.
due to isolation), or something which we could refer to as being quick on one's feet. Especially the latter
failure perhaps results from some sort of passivity which a downtrodden translator could theoretically break free of, but that is — naturally — easier said then
done. More so among people exhibiting certain particular personality traits, or types, which are
further affected by their native or host culture, education, beliefs and so on. There's a reason
why most people are not entrepreneurs, just like there is a reason why
most people are not managers, even among the most qualified specialists. Not everybody is a leader, innovator or organiser. There is a reason why business coaches are necessary, why agents and middlemen are in demand. Not
all people can handle — mentally, emotionally, intellectually, physically — either some general aspects of business acumen such as
organisation, planning, marketing, or some particular challenges that they face; of those who actually can, still not all eventually find it in themselves to do so.

Bottom line

Translators who, in abstract numbers, charge a fraction of what other translators are paid are not necessarily undercutting anybody. Neither are translators who charge higher rates, in abstract numbers, necessarily better off economically than someone who charges less in a market with smaller prices. Even where there actually is some undercutting, then it's still not necessarily done on purpose but often the result of those lower-charging translators not doing their utmost to improve their business and marketing skills and performance. Are all translators who charge in the region of €0.10 p.s.w. in the most developed countries really doing their utmost in this regard? Comparing rates taken as abstract numbers makes no sense. After the inclusion of factors such as spending power, costs of living, prices, wages and so on, it may turn out that somebody somewhere in the world who charges, let's say, half the rates, is effectively making twice the money. Conversely, those high rates earned in higher paying but more expensive economies don't look as attractive when you look at the cost of living there.

Ending on a twist

I hesitated whether to include this
last paragraph, but after
leaving it out intially I felt I was depriving some of my potential readers of a useful piece of knowledge, a tip which could perhaps change their
professional life for the better, at least for beinners. Without further ado, if you have a nagging suspicion
that your rates may be low due to your not having the business or
marketing skills to take them higher (or to find better-paying clients),
there are books and trainings which can help you address that weakness, as well as counsellorsand coaches and marketers and specialised web designers and graphical designers and other people who can
help. Such assistance usually costs money, but it is a job just as yours, which is why it's professional assistance. If resources are scarce perhaps at least you have some free time to read about things and try them out. There are many free resources out there online, such as
Marta Stelmaszak's presentation from TraduEmprende or the Latitudes Blog, free website
content management systems such as Wordpress, Drupal and Joomla to build a professional-looking website in, with free or low-cost themes
that are customisable and in any case better overall than most of the websites our colleagues are currently sporting. Most
translators could and should put more effort in their online professional image, making it easier for them to convince clients of the value they provide, making it better for us all in the greater scheme of things.
They can't find you if you aren't visible, and it's hard to believe someone who doesn't look credible. If you increase your rates successfully, not only will you earn more, you will make life easier for your colleagues.

Disclaimers and all that jazz

REPOSTING AND RIGHTS: Don't worry about copyrights and stuff when printing or sharing these posts for your own benefit or that of your friends. In fact, the point of them is to be read. You can also repost them whole if you think that will reach the audience better than linking to my blog here, or if you want to host a vigorous discussion on the subject among your commenters; it's all fine as long as you don't make a blog that's simply a copy of my blog. Feel free to translate the posts, too, or adapt them, just please mention the fact you did so on your own. Understand, however, that by reposting my posts in any way or form, including paper, you will not gain any sort of copyright or interest in my own copyright, let alone moral rights, other than limited protection of any significant value you actually add, where any such rights such as you may so acquire shall not restrict my own rights and freedom as the author or in any way impede the free, unpaid circulation of the material I created. Always credit me as the author.

NOT PROOFREAD OR EDITED: The posts are not always edited and proofread before posting. They are intended to represent the typical standard of blogs posts rather than printed works; I apologize for any inconvenience you may experience as a result. I simply prefer to write another post or five rather than either go back and reread old stuff or complete five rounds of editing before hitting the send button; this is more or less the point of having a blog. Still welcome to let me know if you find a typo or if anything's unclear, which may very well occasionally be the case due to the timing, such as late at night or in between urgent projects. Hence, before reposting any of this in a more serious setting than a blog or forum post, please drop me a line to give me the chance to apply some finishing touch or even ask me to write a proper article, which I'll be happy to do subject to time constraints.

NO ADVICE, NO CLIENT RELATIONSHIP: Nothing here consitutes legal, business, marketing, career or any other advice, at least not in the sense of establishing a lawyer-client or consultant-client relationship, not in the least because I didn't get a dime and because any implied contract is (hereby, herewith, etc.) expressly disclaimed. If what you find here is useful and informs your course of action, you still need to get proper legal advice appropriate to your jurisdiction and your unique factual situation, without exception. Likewise, consult such other advisors as are appropriate for proper business, marketing, career or other advice relevant to your situation. Whether or not you consult them, you agree to assume and do assume the responsibility and risk, with the consequence being, without limitation, that you can't sue me (and agree not to try) on the grounds of having relied on anything whatsoever on this blog.

NO RESPONSIBILITY FOR THIRD-PARTY SITES: Any links on this blog that don't expressly lead to other posts here should be presumed to lead to external sites that are outside my control. I am not responsible for the contents of such sites or their availability. Linking does not imply endorsement. By clicking on a link you expressly and enthusiastically declare for the benefit of any pesky government official anywhere that you did so out of the pure, unadulterated, spontaneous desire of your heart miraculously coupled with the informed and deliberate consent of your conscious, sovereign, unbroken will.

NO RESPONSIBILITY FOR COMMENTS YOU READ: If you find something illegal, obscene, hateful, etc., in the comments, let me know and, if I agree with your assessment, I'll axe the comment. You are hereby warned that I don't control the comments otherwise, they are the product of their own authors' expression. If you don't accept the risk that you might see something objectionable, don't read the comments.

YOUR RESPONSIBILITY FOR COMMENTS YOU POST: By posting a comment you agree to assume and do assume full and sole responsibility at law for posting whatever you post, even if I saw it and did not delete it, and even though you also agree that I may delete any comment at ultimately my sole discretion, with no liability to you, though I'll normally do so only if I find it to be spammy or more than just a little offensive. Further, you agree that if you subsequently decide to delete or modify your comment, you will need to do so on your own, and agree to do so on your own without involving me in the process. You agree not to post anything which is illegal, hateful, defamatory, spammy, in breach of a confidentiality obligation (or otherwise contains anything you are not free to disclose, including without limitation personal data) or infringes on anyone's legally protected rights. Advertising is forbidden.