Make water bottle filled of water fill 1/2 of a shank

If I'm using the word correctly it is the hunger bar but Minecraft is a fantasy game so it follows some laws of real life like it would be in real life the Satarition effect wouldn't be that strong but it would make a quick infinite food sorce

Your right. It would make a quick infinite food source and would completely invalidate the need for growing food, breeding pigs, or any other method of food production. An entire section of gameplay can be replaced with 3 blocks of glass.

I get offtopic a lot, be warned. I also often mention a Minecraft clone called Minetest. The clone is nowhere near playable with it's default game in my opinion, but it's at least the start of a good open-source voxel rendering engine, and maybe one day it might be decently playable.

quote=CreeperKingXIIf I'm using the word correctly it is the hunger bar but Minecraft is a fantasy game so it follows some laws of real life like it would be in real life the Satarition effect wouldn't be that strong but it would make a quick infinite food sorce

If water is unnecessary for thirst (a whole 'nother debate), I don't see why it should satisfy hunger.

With carrots (& beets and potatoes) edible straight out of the ground and able to grow on dry, tiilled land whenever the light level is 9+, an easier food source doesn't seem like a crying need.

Given that filled water bottles don't stack, there would still be occasional circumstances where lack of access to water sources would make food necessary [eg. the Nether, most obviouly] ... but C1ff's observation about the tendency to supplant farming / ranching would be true at least much of the time.

Rollback Post to RevisionRollBack

WARNING: I have an extemely "grindy" playstyle; YMMV — if this doesn't seem fun to you, mine what you can from it & bin the rest.