Once again, Elephantmen left nothing to be desired. This was another
amazing issue in what is truly one of the greatest continuing stories to
date. The way Richard Starkings draws on past issues and makes it
relevant to the present issues is one of the many reasons why I love
this series so much. There is an established timeline he draws from that
makes the Elephantmen history important. THAT is something that I
desire in other books. Once again we are graced with a dream sequence by the talented Dave Sim.
The sequences he draws are so different that, as I am sure was
intended, you can tell the dreams feel real to the dreamers at the time
in which they take place. As always, Axel Medellin brings the
Elephantmen world to life with vibrant colors and amazing art. This is
one book I have come to enjoy over the years and I hope to for many
more.

UNLEASH THE FANBOY:
(from a review at Unleash The Fanboy, 13 November 2012)
After some rather complicated issues, Elephantmen #44 begins to
put the pieces together, whilst still being vague and mysterious.
Still, there’s a sense of things moving in this issue, even if it
dialogue heavy... This issue carries on from a lot of the previous arcs, uniting many of the Elephantmen. Its only when you see them together that you realize some of them don’t interact that much; Elephantmen can be a difficult series to get to grips with plot wise, and new comers might not feel at ease. This mainly focuses around on Trench (the Zebra). More of a fringe
character recently, the series does its best to bring him into the fold.
This is done via the third dream sequence shown so far. These, like
previous issues, demonstrate a fantastic level of art, even if the
images are very ‘static’, showing the same scene over and over. Still, with some reasonably written dialogue, its a very atmospheric couple of pages. Trench always has a
certain ‘noir’ feel about him, and the writing and art captures that
well, especially through its use of a moody New York at night time. Of course, if there’s one thing Elephantmen can do, its
bring characters together only to leave more questions and potential
plots. The dialogue is good, but its obvious suggestions towards a
certain path might be too obvious for some. The dream sequences are
referenced a lot, but it sometimes feels too obvious; although its hard
to criticize a world full of talking anthropomorphic animals for not
being realistic.