Say this for “The Hunt for the Trump Tapes,” Tom Arnold’s new half-hour series in which the actor undertakes a largely farcical hunt for incriminating material about the president — it’s a show of its moment. The series sits at the intersection of two trends: The outlandishness of the ongoing political scene allowing just about anything to seem believable, and the tendency of this era to resurrect just about any pop-cultural figure who’d seemed better left in a previous era.

But being well-positioned to document and to succeed in an era of crass, noisy perniciousness — an era in which vastly more heat than light is generated by whatever’s left of a national discourse — is hardly a compliment, unless it’s bolstered by the sort of vision and artfulness this show lacks. Arnold’s show is an unpleasant wade through widely-known and speculated-about Trump ephemera, adding little in its first two episodes but the re-emergence of a personality whose frantic need to be in front of the camera makes for painful viewing.

For this series, Arnold has taken on a persona that will be familiar to viewers of cable news or heavy users of social media: He’s a conspiracist who’s nebulously half-informed, speaking with brazen directness about anecdotes he hazily, sort of remembers. “There’s supposedly salacious outtakes on ‘The Apprentice’ and ‘Miss Universe’ contest,” he says in an opening bit of voice-over that carries over to episode 2. “There’s this Russian pee-pee tape.”

More Reviews

The series never deals in a serious way with the fact that rumors of these tapes — including “this Russian pee-pee tape” — have hardly dented Trump’s popularity among his base. Neither, ultimately, did a very real and widely circulated tape on which Trump boasted about sexually assaulting women. This show indulges in a common delusion, that restating known facts about Trump’s personality more loudly will somehow cause them to sink in, as though he weren’t elected with the public having a full understanding of who he was. Its focus is also pointedly turned away from policy; Trump’s badness is something beyond ideology, here, which means there’s little for the viewer to grab onto beyond admittedly disgusting quotes.

But does Arnold really even want to bring down the president, or just to use his omnipresence as grist for a TV show? Much of the series is dedicated to resurfacing stories that, while certainly outrageous, are, sadly, no longer remarkable — and performing outrage about them while relishing their entertainment value. An anti-Trump researcher who’s documented his many interviews in the press raises uncouth statements Trump has made about Kim Kardashian and Charlize Theron. How much of this is about bringing the public to greater awareness of Trump’s already widely-known attitudes, and how much is about getting to laugh together at the things the president has said?

The greatest dirt that’s dished in the series’s early going is former “Celebrity Apprentice” contestant Penn Jillette saying that, on set, he got “that hot feeling you get of your face flushing when someone has done something tremendously inappropriate.” Jillette cites “homophobic, racist, misogynist things,” without giving specifics; but instead of asking a follow-up question, Arnold grins and says, “Oh my gosh.” Actually finding out what’s inside the notional Trump tapes, or even if they exist, is less important for the show than taking nourishment from an atmosphere of scandal. Other insiders whom Arnold reached for comment ended up backing out before they could be interviewed on tape, something that could mean everything, or nothing. Does it really matter? What any real revelation of years-old prejudiced language would mean for the president who survived the “Access Hollywood” scandal is never dealt with; for Arnold, the mere broaching of potential scandal is enough for a half-hour’s entertainment. The show is fueled, parasitically, by the times in which we live, even as it has little to say about them beyond that they are unbelievable and crazy.

In an odd way, Arnold is once again linked to his ex-wife Roseanne Barr, this time as her polar opposite in fame-seeking. Roseanne’s short-lived return to TV was characterized by a somewhat opportunistic embrace of Trumpism, an inarticulately explained attempt to surf the wave of history towards renewed fame. If Barr strove to make headlines as the president’s friend, Arnold’s doing so as his nemesis, guided by no coherent ideology or insight. But Barr rose to the president’s attention in part because of her stratospheric ratings success and her blue-moon quality. For all the incoherence of her philosophy and for all the real-world prejudices that cost her her starring role, she was for a time doing something meaningfully different from just about every sitcom star out there, and was rewarded with attention.

Arnold brags that he’s a “professional Trump annoyer,” but will a show in which old stories get rehashed even rise to the president’s attention? This show is indistinguishable from frenzied social-media conversation, and bolstered by about as much successful reporting and meaningful understanding as exists online, too. Which makes it so of its time that it becomes yet more background noise: We’ve seen Arnold’s act, a plate-spinning bit of seizing on minor controversy in order to amuse and entertain while avoiding the tough questions, before. Its more skillful practitioners, after all, include the president.

Sign Up for Daily Insider Newsletter

Welcome back to Tune In: our weekly newsletter offering a guide to the best of the week’s TV. Each week, Variety’s TV team combs through the week’s schedule, selecting our picks of what to watch and when/how to watch them. This week, “Rent: Live” airs on Fox and “Celebrity Big Brother” returns for a second [...]

Cocaine’s a hell of a drug, but you’re not seeing things: That, indeed is Showtime’s old 1980s-era logo pasted all over marketing materials and promos for “Black Monday,” a tongue-in-cheek tale of the excesses exhibited by Wall Street traders in the lead-up to the stock market crash of 1987. The logo, which hasn’t been in [...]

This is a particularly tricky review to write, but not because the merits of “Russian Doll” are at all ambiguous. On the contrary, the show is so striking and smart that I made a note to include it on my favorite TV shows of 2019 immediately after blowing through the season — which is saying [...]

Bringing to bear a talented cast on a story of real geopolitical significance, “Black Earth Rising,” Netflix’s drama about the long-tail aftermath of the Rwandan genocide, would seem to have had the potential to be one of 2019’s early television successes. Which makes its falling short all the more painful and pronounced. The show, previously [...]

The Season 1 finale of “Dirty John” on Bravo continued the scripted show’s ratings hot streak in Live+3. The finale, which aired on Jan. 13, grew to 3.3 million viewers in delayed viewing with 1.3 million of those falling in the key adults 18-49 demographic. That is up 10% in total viewers and 15% in [...]

Qatari powerhouse beIN Media Group is calling on Hollywood to join in fighting a pirate broadcaster that it alleges has stolen billions of dollars’ worth of rights to sports events, films and TV content, and that it says has the backing of Saudi Arabia. Doha-based beIN has compiled what it calls a “dossier of evidence” [...]

Former Sky One and Sky Living programming chief Adam MacDonald has joined Possessed, and will be the ITV-owned production banner’s first chair. The U.K.-based unscripted producer has also hired Lesley Davies, former head of international production at Warner Bros. She will head up production. The double hires follow a recommission of gameshow “5 Gold Rings,” [...]