You know, I can see the argument as to her not being needed but, then again, Max kind of is not needed either. I feel she is needed more then him because the show needs a vixen and a young one at that. They had one with Cassie but they screwed that up.

Melanie over Max? HAHAHHAHA! That's funny.

I disagree 100%. Max has a place on this show. He has history on this show. Real history. Max has a lot of potential if they would just stick with a direction for him and go with it and stay true to it.

Melanie on the other hand, no. She's not needed. Chelsea's the perfect vixen part. Yes, she's matured, but she's still a bitch and they've toned her down too much if you ask me.