If this is your first visit, be sure to
check out the FAQ by clicking the
link above. You may have to register
before you can post: click the register link above to proceed. To start viewing messages,
select the forum that you want to visit from the selection below.

Re: MAFIA GAME 18 POWAH PUFF GRRRLS EDITION

Ok, I'll make my vote!
I vote for kdowns.
My reasons: ToC has 3 votes on him and I don't think he's mafia. I just don't feel he's and I think he's being the same. I strongly doubt he's mafia and I hope I'm right.
And kdowns seems to be a bomb or a serial killer. He doesn't post much, just troll and play the jerk, it's annoying and I don't like inactive players. So I prefer to try to save ToC, who I think is a good townie. Plus googlez said he would help me to do it, so my vote won't be in vain.

Re: MAFIA GAME 18 POWAH PUFF GRRRLS EDITION

Originally Posted by Googlez_kun

Moreover, he doesn't seem to care all that much for the game, so eliminating him should be alright.
Also, if he was the bomb, wouldn't he try to drag a mafia member down with him? I mean, he's a townie right? Let me think. He voted for xi0 who was accused of being a mafia all the time. So did he want to attract his attention in order to provoke xi0 into killing him? But then he would have to come back later to check who the voted last and he would've needed to collect some votes beforehand. So maybe he's just trolling and doesn't care, which would make him an aweful townie or a serial killer.

Well, whatever, let's do this.

Make sense, but maybe he really doesn't care about the game and wouldn't care about killing a townie or a mafia.
And not only xi0, he provoked others like law. He was just saying things like: if you don't like it just vote for me.
Idk, he can be both.

Don't know if I'll be able to come online tonight, so I'd rather voice my opinion now.

Evil listed some good arguments. According to those I think xi0 or Thorn might be mafia. (Well, could be because I'm a noob, but his points were convincing.)
Anyhow, looking at how Evil was banned from voting in this round, xi0 could also just be a townie who was afraid of Evil because he was threatened all the time. Then again, Thorn was as well, so maybe it was him, which would mean xi0 could still be mafia.
And, why did Niichan vote for Thorn? He's very suspicious himself, so maybe it's like a fake vote to show that 'a mafia wants to kill an innocent townie', while in reality both are mafia trying to confuse us. Or Niichan is aware of his current image and toys with us. No idea. Still Thorn remains highly suspicious.Hmmm.
(This game is fun)

Well, before I don't vote at all I'll go for.....erm Thorn.

Originally Posted by naruto-niichan

I was pretty much away for the whole day and I'm sorry to say that I probably will be busy again today :/ this is why I'm cautious, don't want to create an argument when I'm gone for a long time.

So I will try to express my thoughts now. I don't see anything particularly wrong with your list evil, what you said had it's reason and can very well be interpreted that way. I can't really judge toc or imp, haven't seen much from them. Same goes for the rest. Who I deem really suspicious is xi0 though, he accused me out of the blue for a silly reason. Because I said the same thing as he did? I don't even recall that but even if that's true, I can't see why that makes me suspicious. Sounds more like he was trying to shift the attention to someone else.

the rest of his actions seemed kinda suspicious too, reminds me of last time

He's the most suspicious one for now so I will vote kill xi0. If I make it back in time I will reconsider my vote according to what people posted here.

Originally Posted by sakura-aneki

I'm gonna cast my vote since my opinion did not change since yesterday.

Vote kill Thorn

Also , tata , Gary is extremely suspicious exactly for the fact that he's not stupid so acting like he is now makes no sense unless he is mafia. That being said he's next on my list of suspects.

I don't remember if bannana was in the last game and if he was innocent but I know two ppl so far who got the same roles as last time. So I'm thinking that maybe we all got the same ones?

That means thorn and Gary are on my list more than ever.

Originally Posted by thornofcarrion

Its obvious Sakura is still mad at me for voting against her in the last game. And googlez...

Its night phase here, in real life and I am going to sleep. I am still maintaining my position:

Vote Kill lawlett

Originally Posted by lawlett-kun

so pretty much xio vs evil3ye discussion all over haha.Its interesting I hope evil is sincere and not a lying scumbag.... on the other note it would be funny if xio and evil are both mafias and its just their tactic.I remember doing the same with evil when we were mafias haha.Well Ill go ahead and vote i am gonna go for the most in my opinion useless troll memeber, that is on the verge of gettin host killed but wont be ... vote kill kdowns

Originally Posted by wizzard

Lynch Googz
Reason: He did it for two reason both of which I don't recognize
1-st save himself from lynching, but If I were in his place I'd sacrifice myself for the common good,
2-nd instead of voting for some one more suspicious (or one with lower vote counts) he gave the deciding vote to someone who apparently voted random thus being a revenge vote.

Originally Posted by lawlett-kun

hmmmmm alright evil ill trust you 1 last time... wantt to see whether toc is mafia rlly.... change vot for toc nothing really comes out of me single voting kd

Looking at the votes currently, I can only find two votes with valid reasoning. The xi0 for niichan and the niichan for xi0. The rest...the rest. What in the name of fucks has this game descended too.

Lets begin with the toc votes. The vote by googlez boils down too "I am convinced by evils arguments, so its either xi0 or toc..so urm i got toc". How has this slipped under the radar? I understand noob townie behaviour but this is classic noob mafia behaviour. He is votekilling someone without any serious thoughts of his own. Please provide something more than jumping on evils bandwagon. Edit: This was written before googlez post above, which has changed my mind on this paragraph.

Then we get to Sakura. Ah lovely Sakura. If I didnt like her outside the thread I would probably resort to strangling vodoo dolls of her likeliness in the faint hope magic actually works. She has stuck to toc like a bad flea. From Farfalla to me, and others as well have said countlessly again and again, toc played the same way in every game he has
been in. He hasnt changed. Not once. But nonetheless dear Sakura has taken upon herself to vote for him again because her suspicions have not changed. What were her suspicions?

Yea, im off to begin making that doll.

She also seemed to have said she thought Evils analysis was spot on, and then after said she found him really suspicious. Inconsistent.

I am not going to even go into wizzards vote in detail. Just a cursory glance from anyone should be enough.

...Noob exuberance I hope. We use to have a stamp on our reports in school called the CDB, it meant you were being horrible in class. It stood for "Could do better", classic understatement but apt here.

Then is toc

This is superb deductive skills toc. Why did no one else think of this? It was all there in black in white. I for one am pretty convinced, you have everything right there. There is reason, logic and a sound rationale. I think you are being severely underestimated in your critical thinking. Its obviously showing up here. As I said, superb stuff.

lawlett seems to have voted out of annoyance at kdowns behaviour. Which is not helpful but understandable I think.

Reading through this I cant help but wonder if there is a single player Evil hasnt accused of something or other. You are like an overexcited dog barking at everything and everyone. Not that I mind, it brings everything out to the fore but you are still in my opinion simply to brazen to be mafia. This can easily backfire and cause a people to suspect you in turn, so you must either be brave and canny or have complete confidence in your innocence. To be perfectly honest you I still dont know what to fully make of you...My suspicions are a trio, xi0, naruto-niichan and lawlett. However it is not conclusive and its not based on anything more solid than my feelings on how they are playing. If I had more I would try and make a case but I dont. So I am going to do something else entirely.

I am going to vote for kdowns. My reasoning is that I believe he is a serial killer. Its been discussed above. Now I know this brings about the question of why try to kill the serial killer. The reasoning is simple, I am more sure of him being a serial killer than I am of someone being suspicious enough as a mafia member.

The likelihood we kill a townie is higher than a mafia member, this means by the beginning of the next phase we can conceivably be down by 3 townies (including the serial killer kill). This will make our chances of winning this game closer and closer to nil. Killing the serial killer in this lynching would mean that the likelihood two townies dying in the night becomes 0 this extends the game and makes it more likely to find the mafia members in future phases because we have more posts to build evidence on. We also kill a disruptive influence on our game, his posts help the mafia more than they hinder it and he is annoying.

Originally Posted by Tatasugoi

Ok, I'll make my vote!
I vote for kdowns.
My reasons: ToC has 3 votes on him and I don't think he's mafia. I just don't feel he's and I think he's being the same. I strongly doubt he's mafia and I hope I'm right.
And kdowns seems to be a bomb or a serial killer. He doesn't post much, just troll and play the jerk, it's annoying and I don't like inactive players. So I prefer to try to save ToC, who I think is a good townie. Plus googlez said he would help me to do it, so my vote on be in vain.

Kdowns signed up, got busy with work or school and now is being incredibly trollish. I don't know if he's Mafia, but if he just wants out of the game without being hostkilled he can just kill whoever he wants as the ultimate troll.

Kdowns signed up, got busy with work or school and now is being incredibly trollish. I don't know if he's Mafia, but if he just wants out of the game without being hostkilled he can just kill whoever he wants as the ultimate troll.

I don't think DD would use a role never used before, it's his first time.
But you know him better, so maybe you're right.
And it's similar to the bomb, the only difference its because he can choose who he wants to kill so I think if you doesn't believe my theory why you would believe it?
And why you want to save him?

Re: MAFIA GAME 18 POWAH PUFF GRRRLS EDITION

I could vote for thorn, but it''s impossible for me to know if he's Mafia or not. He rarely posts, and when he does he doesn't offer up much.

A troll like KD, who clearly doesn't have time for the game but insists on having a "plan". Who posts just enough to not be hostkilled... He's either a Bomb or Vengeful Townie. If he's the latter, well then I'm fucked.

Re: MAFIA GAME 18 POWAH PUFF GRRRLS EDITION

Originally Posted by xi0

I could vote for thorn, but it''s impossible for me to know if he's Mafia or not. He rarely posts, and when he does he doesn't offer up much.

A troll like KD, who clearly doesn't have time for the game but insists on having a "plan". Who posts just enough to not be hostkilled... He's either a Bomb or Vengeful Townie. If he's the latter, well then I'm fucked.

You said toc always played like this and you don't think he's mafia. And still he post more than KD.
Both doesn't contributes when they post, but KD is annoying and he voted for you (only because DD pmed him to vote) so maybe he suspects of you, so why you would try to save him? Are you crazy?

Re: MAFIA GAME 18 POWAH PUFF GRRRLS EDITION

Because I have a feeling by his trollish behavior that he wants out of the game, but doesn't want to be hostkilled without using his ability....IF he's the Bomb. I don't think Googz is Mafia personally, and if he's a Daytime Vigilante... Then who knows what.

Re: MAFIA GAME 18 POWAH PUFF GRRRLS EDITION

Not save him, more like prevent him from being able to kill whoever he wants. Because I don't think he should even be in the game in the first place and I would bet on him just wanting to screw someone over. Why else do this so early on the second day? He doesn't post, he wants out and doesn't want to be banned from further games so he'll "hostkill" himself. What other "strategy" that he mentioned could he have? If he's Mafia, he's just fucking over his teammates. If he's anything other than a Bomb or Vengeful Townie then he's just a stupid player.