Sustainability Issues Likely to Restrict Vehicle Biofuels Use in Europe

EC officials will report by July whether land-use changes and associated emissions are sufficiently quantifiable to amend Europe’s renewable-fuels law. If the answer is “yes,” it could be bad news for some auto makers.

Only a few years ago, European policymakers were hailing biofuels, made from plant matter such as corn, rapeseed and grasses, as the practical green alternative to fossil fuels, citing it as so clean that cars, vans and trucks might as well have been running on water.

But with the growing acceptance that producing many of these biofuels creates substantial carbon emissions from crop cultivations, those days are over.

Mathematical calculations being pored over by the European Commission could further cloud the reputation of biofuels as acceptably green, leading to a reduction in subsidies and tax breaks available under the EC’s renewable-energy directive.

The 2009 law came into force in December and imposes compulsory targets for the European Union’s 27-member states. At least 20% of their energy consumption must come from renewable sources by 2020, while 10% of their transport sector’s energy usage must be derived from renewable fuels under the ruling.

The Commission wants to be able to measure which biofuels are sufficiently green to count towards these compulsory targets and, therefore, qualify for lower duty and higher manufacturing subsidies.

EC officials have worked out a mathematical model by considering emissions as the biofuels are manufactured, consumed and released into the atmosphere when feedstock fields replace the natural environment.

That is complex enough, but now officials are embarking on a tougher task of modeling the additional CO2 caused by indirect changes in land-use wrought by biofuels production.

For example, the amount of emissions created when a wheat field is sown with rapeseed for biofuels production, forcing farmers to clear the nearby woodland to create a new field to grow their crops.

“The potential effects of indirect land use need to be properly weighed in our biofuels policy,” says EU Energy Commissioner Günther Oettinger. “It is in our interest to investigate this seriously to ensure we have legislation that avoids negative side effects.”

EC officials will report by July whether such land-use changes and associated emissions are sufficiently quantifiable to amend Europe’s renewable-fuels legislation. If the answer is “yes,” this could be bad news for auto makers that have invested in making flex-fuel vehicles.

Renault spokesman Mike Gale says vehicle manufacturers started to move away from biofuels three years ago, when incentives began to fade. The French auto maker is a case in point, with its aggressive electric-vehicles program.

That said, car companies continue to invest in the development of second-generation biofuels that use waste products as feedstock, although Sigrid de Vries, communications director for the European auto makers’ group, the ACEA, acknowledges second-generation technology has “a long path in research and development.”

Susan M. Cischke, Ford group vice president-sustainability, environment and safety engineering, is quoted as saying: “To unlock the full potential of biofuels, more investment into the development and implementation of second-generation biofuels is needed.

“Second generation biofuels that avoid the transfer of CO2 emissions into other sectors or regions are fully sustainable and should be encouraged.”

Although biofuels still are valued by the transport sector, their use in the EU last year fell below the 5.75% consumption target set in 2003 to an estimated 4.05%.

Nonetheless, in 2009, 12 million tons of oil equivalent (TOE), a unit of energy, was used by the EU transport sector, with Germany and France the largest consumers.

That was up from 10.2 million TOE in 2008, says renewable-energy monitor EurObserv’ER, which measures the annual progress made by renewable energies in each sector of each EU member state.

The European Biodiesel Board says the EU had capacity to produce about 24 million tons (22 million) of biodiesel, alone, last year.

The EC’s math modelers continue to wrestle with all of the complex data. Last summer, they released guidelines for the calculation of land carbon stocks on direct land-use changes.

Accordingly, a biofuels sustainability calculation measuring carbon content of virgin land (pre-biofuels production) must be based on areas roughly uniform before the feedstock growers came along.

It should have similar “biophysical conditions in terms of climate and soil type; management history in terms of tillage; and input history in terms of carbon input to soil,” the guidelines say. In other words, calculations must compare lands that have similar soils and similar plants, whether natural or farmed, before the feedstock growers.

The indirect land-use calculations, if officials can frame a model, likely will be even more complicated.

“The state is worried that with cars getting better and better mileage, it’ll collect less in fuel taxes to take care of the roads and bridges,” Nance tells husband Peter as she explains Oregon’s pay-per-mile road-funding scheme....More

Singling out shareholders for a big payday is not being fair or responsible. The “old GM” spent billions buying back shares and kept doing so almost until it went bankrupt. Look how well that worked....More

A key issue in the aluminum-vs.-steel standoff is strength. Each side is playing the military and, by extension, the patriotism card. The message is that if it’s strong enough to protect soldiers in combat, then it’s strong enough, and safe enough, for you and everybody in your truck....More

Hot Topic

Acquisition of major elements of TRW following its merger with ZF, including design, manufacturing and intellectual property, could offer the buyer “a once-in-a-lifetime opportunity” to expand globally, industry analyst Peter Cooke says....More

“The government must do more to prepare for a transition period where manual, semi-autonomous and driverless vehicles will share U.K. roads,” says Louise Ellman, chairwoman of Parliament’s Transport Committee....More

The announcement follows a 6-month government review that considered the best and safest ways to test automated vehicles that allow an individual to take control of the car if necessary. It also looked further ahead to the legal implications....More

Today’s auto-industry executives must connect Silicon Valley and Detroit, as well as address entirely new dimensions of safety concerns, such as how to protect their customers’ privacy and data....More

The supplier envisions connected vehicles carrying on never-ending digital conversations with IBM’s computer servers in Dallas about more than just the weather. Forgive my inability to process the vast implications....More