I know i am not that popular based on that answer, many on this site wouldn't shoot past 20 yards. I practice and i am very accurate to 80 yards. I feel a relaxed animal at 50 is about the max if you don't want something to go wrong more times than not.

I practice almost daily out to 80yd. Given the situation you discribed (that being perfect) I would take a shot out to 65 or 70 yards. It would have to be the perfect situation though I.E. Flat ground, open lane , and a deer that is totally oblivious to the fact that there is a hunter with in 100 miles of him.

Sunday afternoon I was up in a tree. 3:45 I had a buck come by at 29-30 yards broadside. I use a Cobra pendulum site. Put the pin on him and hit the release. At the sound of the string, he turned which then the arrow entered in front of the back leg and exited behind the front leg. When doing the field dressing, the back 1/2 of the arrow was in him.
Have I practiced at that range, no. Always 20 yards was my practice distance but someone said with that site, if your on at 20, you're good to 35.

I know i am not that popular based on that answer, many on this site wouldn't shoot past 20 yards. I practice and i am very accurate to 80 yards. I feel a relaxed animal at 50 is about the max if you don't want something to go wrong more times than not.

How about you JPH, since I stuck my neck out to be lopped off.

You dont need to feel guilty for being a good archer! If your confident and consitant at that distance, then I dont see anything wrong with taking a 50 yrd shot! Myself, 30 yrd's is as far as I'll shoot at an animal. With my new setup(bought in july 08), I'll shoot targets out to 60 yrd's, but passed 30 my groups get kinda ugly!