Tough Turkey: People Have A Harder Time Getting Pardons Under Obama

President Obama, with daughters Sasha and Malia, at last year's turkey pardoning ceremony.

Pablo Martinez Monsivais
/ AP

Listen

Listening...

/

Originally published on November 20, 2012 6:14 pm

Presidential pardons usually take the world by surprise. There's no advance notice — the White House just sends out an announcement with the names of those receiving clemency. Thanksgiving is one lighthearted exception.

On Wednesday, President Obama will once again take part in the traditional turkey pardoning at the White House. But while the business of pardoning humans is more serious, it's also increasingly rare.

People don't usually think of the president as a part of the justice system. Typically that world includes judges, prosecutors and defense lawyers — not the chief executive. But George Lardner, a former investigative reporter who's now writing a book on the history of presidential pardons, says the Constitution actually makes the president a key part of this web.

In the past, "there was no such thing as probation or parole," Lardner says. "If you wanted to get out of prison before your time was up, you had to get a pardon."

Many people did. But that was long ago. Recent presidents have barely used their clemency power. And Obama is more frugal than any of them, says P.S. Ruckman Jr., a political scientist at Rock Valley College who studies pardons.

White House spokesman Matt Lehrich responded to an inquiry with this statement: "President Obama takes his constitutional power to grant clemency very seriously, and each recommendation received from the Department of Justice is carefully reviewed and evaluated on the merits."

But Obama's record is even more striking if you compare the number of pardons he's granted with those he's rejected. Ruckman crunched the numbers for the past five presidents:

Ronald Reagan: 1 in 8

George H.W. Bush: 1 in 19

Bill Clinton: 1 in 16

George W. Bush: 1 in 55

Barack Obama: 1 in 290

Sam Morison spent 13 years working in the Justice Department's Office of the Pardon Attorney. He left in 2010.

"They really don't give a sort of fair and neutral review of every case," he says. "They tend to view any grant of clemency not as a good thing, as a criminal justice success story, but almost as a defeat — that you're taking away something from what some good prosecutor achieved."

A Justice Department spokesman rejects that description. Wyn Hornbuckle says the department "is committed to providing a fair, careful and merit-based evaluation of every clemency application."

In a statement, he also noted that the department has begun an independent study of the pardon data.

Margaret Love, Clinton's pardon attorney, says the president doesn't see much to gain by exercising clemency.

"It's all sort of all risk and very little reward," she says, "although I think that is a shortsighted view."

The risk was apparent to anyone who watched Clinton pardon the international fugitive Marc Rich, whose wife was a big campaign donor, in 2001. The backlash was huge.

But Love says the president could use clemency power to highlight flaws in the justice system. There are more penalties than ever for people with a conviction on their record. And many of those penalties never go away.

"I have a client, for example, who has a minor white-collar tax offense from a number of years ago who has a business in the Los Angeles airport," she says. "He cannot visit his business because he can't go into the secure area of the airport because of his conviction."

That man and others seeking pardons can take solace in one trend: Half of all recent pardons have come in the month of December. So next month, they may be that lucky 1 out of 290.

Copyright 2017 NPR. To see more, visit http://www.npr.org/.

ROBERT SIEGEL, HOST:

Presidential pardons usually take the world by surprise. There's no advanced notice; the White House just sends out an announcement with the names of those receiving clemency.

AUDIE CORNISH, HOST:

Thanksgiving is one, lighthearted exception.

PRESIDENT BARACK OBAMA: Recently, I've been taking a series of executive actions that don't require congressional approval.

(LAUGHTER)

OBAMA: Well, here's another one. We can't wait to pardon these turkeys.

(LAUGHTER)

CORNISH: That was last year's turkey pardoning ceremony at the White House, and President Obama will do it again tomorrow.

SIEGEL: We're going to get serious, though, and focus now on the president's record of pardoning humans. As NPR's Ari Shapiro reports, he doesn't do it often.

ARI SHAPIRO, BYLINE: People don't usually think of the president as a part of the justice system. Typically, that world includes judges, prosecutors and defense lawyers - not the chief executive. But George Lardner says the Constitution actually makes the president a key part of this web. Lardner is a former investigative reporter who's now writing a book on the history of presidential pardons.

GEORGE LARDNER: There was no such thing as probation or parole. If you wanted to get out of prison before your term's up, you had to get a pardon.

SHAPIRO: And lots of people did - but that was long ago. Recent presidents have barely used their clemency power. And President Obama is more frugal than any of them, says P.S. Ruckman Jr., a political scientist at Rock Valley College who studies pardons.

SHAPIRO: Ruckman says no president since John Adams, has shown so little leniency. White House spokesman Matt Lehrich responded to my inquiry with this statement. Quote, "President Obama takes his constitutional power to grant clemency very seriously; and each recommendation received from the Department of Justice is carefully reviewed, and evaluated on the merits."

But President Obama's record is even more striking, if you compare the number of pardons he's granted with those he's rejected. Professor Ruckman crunched the numbers for the last five presidents.

RUCKMAN: Clinton, one in every 16; H. Walker Bush, one in every 19; Reagan, one in every eight...

SHAPIRO: George W. Bush granted one pardon for every 55 he rejected. And President Obama? He's granted one pardon for every 290 applications.

SAM MORISON: They really don't give a sort of fair and neutral review of every case.

SHAPIRO: This is Sam Morison, who spent 13 years working in the Justice Department's Office of the Pardon Attorney. He left in 2010.

MORISON: They tend to view any grant of clemency not as a good thing, as a criminal justice success story, but almost as a defeat - you know, that you're taking away something from what some good prosecutor achieved.

SHAPIRO: A Justice Department spokesman rejects that description. Wyn Hornbuckle says the department, quote, "is committed to providing a fair, careful and merit-based evaluation of every clemency application." In a statement, he also noted that the department has begun an independent study of the pardon data. Margaret Love was President Clinton's pardon attorney. She says the president doesn't see much to gain, by exercising clemency.

MARGARET LOVE: It's all - sort of all risk and very little reward, although I think that is a shortsighted view.

SHAPIRO: The risk was apparent to anyone who watched President Clinton, in 2001, pardon the international fugitive Marc Rich, whose wife was a big campaign donor. The backlash was huge. But Love says the president could use clemency power to highlight flaws in the justice system. There are more penalties than ever, for people with a conviction on their record. And many of those penalties never go away.

LOVE: I have a client, for example, who has a minor, white-collar tax offense from a number of years ago; who has a business in the Los Angeles airport. He cannot visit his business because he can't go into the secure area of the airport, because of his conviction.

SHAPIRO: That man, and others seeking pardons, can take solace in one trend. Half of all recent pardons have come in the month of December. So next month, they may be that lucky one out of 290.