We noticed that you're using an unsupported browser. The TripAdvisor website may not display properly. We support the following browsers:
Windows:Internet Explorer,
Mozilla Firefox,
Google Chrome.
Mac:Safari.

Not ready to book?

No rush. We've saved this trip in your cart
so you can come back any time, compare prices, and complete your booking.

TripAdvisor Reviewer Highlights

Read all 18 reviews

Visitor rating

5

Excellent

11

Very good

0

Average

1

Poor

1

Terrible

Rating summary

Food

Service

Value

Atmosphere

“Best in this little town”

For years, as a kid, Sierra Buttes Inn was the place for dinner. Many years later, Doc & Eddie are gone, and that Inn is a shambles. Herrington's is modern for Sierra City, rustic cabinesque. It is busy especially on weekends, and for good reason. The food is good. The service is friendly and...read more

For years, as a kid, Sierra Buttes Inn was the place for dinner. Many years later, Doc & Eddie are gone, and that Inn is a shambles. Herrington's is modern for Sierra City, rustic cabinesque. It is busy especially on weekends, and for good reason. The food is good. The service is friendly and fast. And to work off your...
More

I kept hearing how great this restaurant was. I was good. The seafood chowder was wonderful, however I did not order it, I had a bland watery salad. My husband order the filet wrapped in bacon and the bacon was close to raw and could not be eaten, however the rest was good. I ordered the halibut, a bit dry...
More

We thoroughly enjoyed our dinner at Herrington's Sierra Pines Resort Restaurant. My husband had the salmon cakes special and I had the Filet of Sole Amandine. Fortunately, we both chose to have baked potatoes, which were unusually good. The salad itself wasn't anything special, but I liked the sun-dried tomato vinaigrette. We had noticed the blackberry bushes growing down near...
More

We parked by the trout pond next to the restaurant and saw some fish that looked to be close to two feet in length. Once inside, we were seated near the front window from which there was a lovely pastoral view. We ordered a couple of cocktails from the full bar. For dinner, I ordered the Rib Eye steak which...
More

My husband and I spent a wonderful quiet week in June in the Lakes Basin area, staying at a house on the Yuba River in Sierra City. We cooked in most of the nights, but for our night "out" we went to one of our local favorites, Herrington's. I ordered the pork chops which were tasty but the baked potatoe...
More

Early cold weather set in; Many restaurants closed in the area. Was expecting just an average meal. Was delighted with the excellent fare chef Steven cooked for us.
Warm lodge atmosphere added to the experience. Will deffinately return when back in the area.

* TripAdvisor LLC is not a booking agent and does not charge any service fees to users of our site... (more)

We noticed that you're using an unsupported browser. The TripAdvisor website may not display properly. We support the following browsers:
Windows:Internet Explorer,
Mozilla Firefox,
Google Chrome.
Mac:Safari.

TripAdvisor LLC is not responsible for content on external web sites. Taxes, fees not included for deals content.