National Trust abandons ground rent rises of up to £8,000 a year for its rural leaseholders

The National Trust has abandoned today its attempt to rack up ground rents for leaseholders who faced massive hikes owing to what the Trust’s property managers termed “modern ground rents”.

Around 300 National Trust leaseholders – who bought long-term tenancies to often dilapidated estate houses, many of no particular historic worth – faced the increased charges.

LKP spoke to an 86-year-old former headteacher living in a cottage with his disabled, middle-aged son in Devon where the National Trust is the freeholder: this year his ground rent was set to rise from £50pa to £8,000 a year.

Many of the leasehold properties were sold in the 1970s and 1980s in states of dilapidation.

They were sold on long leases of 49 years, with the National Trust at the time and for long afterwards indicating to putative buyers that the leases could be extended “free of charge” by another 50 years, a statutory extension under the 1967 Act.

Buyers were told that this arrangement, as opposed to issuing a 99-year lease at outset, was to discourage short-term ownership and speculation in National Trust residential property.

But the Trust’s property managers saw the opportunity to play the leasehold game and dreamed up what they termed “modern ground rents”. But whether modern or plain old-fashioned ground rents the unarguable truth is that they are for no defined benefit at all.

The issue was taken up by LKP and the Times newspaper ran a report as its lead story on its front page.

We understand that Communities Secretary Sajid Javid personally intervened, representing National Trust leaseholders at the Cadbury estate in his Bromsgrove constituency.

In December, Geoffrey Brewis-Levie, a National Trust leaseholder in Alnwick, Northumberland, told the Trust, contacted LKP to express his outrage at the Trust’s conduct.

He was the fourth owner of the lease, from 2001, since National Trust was bequeathed the freehold.

“The National Trust had therefore four opportunities to amend the lease in accordance with the Lease Reform Act 1967. This has not been carried out by the NT in any of the instances of sale with the title changes.

“As far as we were concerned we would be offered at least a 50 yr extension without charge of a premium for the extension component.

“We were aware at that point how the NT had treated other tenants in other parts of the country with huge rent increase demands.

“It appears the NT only started to make significant changes to their policies in the recent past to long leasehold renewals.

“It is for this reason we feel we have been misled by the National Trust concerning the statutory extension to our lease.”

In a face-facing statement, the National Trust says it has made the change after the Charity Commission said it could forgo these lucrative “modern ground rents” – implying that they were a legitimate revenue stream now voluntarily abandoned.

The press release even welcomes the government plans to reform leasehold law.

Modern ground rents will now simply be the existing ground rents adjusted for inflation on the “current nominal rent”.

In a statement today, the National Trust said:

“The National Trust has agreed to remove modern ground rent (MGR) for most of its long leaseholders.“The charity hopes that this significant change will help to resolve the situation for those long leaseholders who were not aware of the financial impact of MGR when they acquired their properties.

“Modern ground rent arises when, under the terms of the Leasehold Reform Act 1967, long leaseholders may have the right to statutorily extend their leases by up to 50 years. This is in return for payment of a higher rent known as ‘modern ground rent’. This is likely to be significantly more than the nominal annual amount payable before the extension begins.

“The Trust has been looking at this issue for the past four years when it first became aware of how little MGR was understood among many of its long leaseholders. Since 2016, the Trust has been reaching agreements with a number of long leaseholders to lessen the impact of MGR.

“However the Trust has continued to listen to its leaseholders and look for a resolution to this complex issue.

Mark Harold, Director of Land and Nature said:

“We have been listening to the concerns of our long leaseholders and looking to find ways to ease the impact of MGR where we could. However, we have increasingly seen that in many cases, finding out about the rises in modern ground rent has caused serious concerns for them.

“We also welcome the Government and Law Commission’s plans to review leasehold law. It may some take time for Ministers to implement any subsequent changes in the law and we have decided to act now.

“We are pleased that The Charity Commission has agreed to our request for an Order enabling us to remove the effect of modern ground rent altogether for most long leaseholders. In these situations we will replace modern ground rent with an index-linked rent based on the current nominal rent.

“We appreciate that it has been a difficult time for many of our long leaseholders and we hope that this significant change will help resolve the situation. We shall now be working with the individual leaseholders to put this into effect.”

Contact LKP

The leasehold game is weighted against ordinary home-owning leaseholders, who aren’t professional players. LKP was set up to redress the balance, to help you win your disputes or at least avoid disasters.

If you have a leasehold problem, you can email sok@leaseholdknowledge or take a chance on calling 07808 328 230.

Comments

Modern Ground Rent applies to any lease on a house extended under the 1967 Leasehold Reform Act. It was not made up by the National Trust. It’s great that the NT have made this concession and agreed not to apply the law but we need to be campaigning to have this law scrapped. Private landords who are freeholders or head lessors can all charge modern ground rent on extended leases. It is worse for National Trust tenants as we can’t buy the freehold. But if there are private intermediary landlords in the chain this NT concession does not help us. And house owners only have the right to ONE lease extension of 50 years. We need the legal right to multiple lease extensions on houses with peppercorn ground rent for all Leasehold house owners including those with National Trust properties.

As a paid up member of the National trust I hope that they don’t apply this in a simplistic way

For example if someone bought the house with 15 yrs remaining for a drastically reduced price then I think they should pay a reasonable premium/ ground rent..because on the one hand they would be shafting the vendor citing the problems of the short leases then having acquired the property at a discount supporting the LKP in trying to get ground rents abolished – j fortunate it is human nature

A different set of rules clearly to apply to someone who bought it nearly 50 years

News archive

Commonhold is slowly working its way into the national consciousness – 16 years after being introduced to the statute book. Last Friday, Sam Barker in the Daily Telegraph reported the Law Commission’s study of the tenure. Commonhold exists almost all jurisdictions apart from England and Wales, where flats and over a million houses are held […]

A last minute attempt to stop LKP from publishing three legal opinions extremely critical of the government’s bungled reform to Recognised Tenants’ Associations failed last week. The government introduced a statutory instrument in October that has actually made the position of leaseholders worse. The failing was referenced in the Commons by Sir Peter Bottomley with […]

This is the first of 3 articles looking at the history of the RTA project and the findings of the most recent consultation. The stated objective of Ministers since 2014 is to make it easier to form a formal residents group known as a Recognised Tenants Association (RTA). LKP has argued from the outset that […]

The APPG on leasehold and commonhold reform has asked two specialist barristers to provide formal opinions on the RTA SI which came into force on 1st November 2018. “The Tenants’ Associations (Provisions Relating to Recognition and Provision of Information) (England) Regulations 2018” The first opinion was provided by barrister Rebecca Cattermole of Tanfield Chambers. Miss […]

In this section, we look at the results of an experimental test of the RTA SI to see how it might work in practice. We then go on to draw conclusions from all three papers. A test of the RTA SI We have been able to use the leaseholders at the Charter Quay (CQ) site […]

The Leasehold Advisory Service, the government funded Leasehold Advisory Service, has been under review by the government for much of the last ten years. This seems to suggest that something is wrong, yet the government’s long-standing support for the Leasehold Advisory Service continues. LKP has, after many requests, obtained the two most recent reviews of […]

– Select Committee deluged with complaints about taxpayer funded organisation – It failed to alert government to scandals over ground rents and proliferation of leasehold houses – Why did it hold seminars advising freeholders how to exploit leaseholders? – ‘Huge credibility problem’ for LEASE among leaseholders, says MP: it is working against them – Why […]

Push for alternative to leasehold system Expansion of the commonhold system of home ownership as an alternative to leasehold tenancies has been urged by the government’s law reform adviser. Commonhold – where people own their homes without an expiring lease – was introduced 14 years ago, but has been little-used. Meanwhile, there have […]

The Help To Buy scheme that has hugely boosted plc house builders share prices – and turned the likes of Persimmon’s Jeff Fairburn and David Jenkinson into multimillionaires – is not available for commonhold properties. This astonishing revelation comes from small house builder (and former leaseholder) Stewart Moxon, of Hopton Build. He trying to selling […]

Two years after the leaseholders at Canary Riverside thought that they had escaped from the clutches of freeholder John Christodoulou after they secured a court-appointed managing agent, the legal wrangling continues. This week saw the 19th day in tribunal since Monaco-based freeholder John Christodoulou lost control of the site’s management in October 2016, when his […]

Cherry Jones has managed to drastically reduce service charges using local contractors … The epic right to manage victory at Rectory Court – where Stonewater was given the boot and the new manager is LKP-accredited Cherry Jones of Swindon-based Home from Home – has made it to the national press. The leaseholders at the 44-flat […]

LKP chair Martin Boyd and Sir Peter Bottomley attended a meeting at Number 10 yesterday to urge government to overturn its flawed statutory instrument to reform recognised tenants’ associations. The MHCLG announced changes in October and made the existing arrangements even worse for leaseholders. The key hurdle faced by leaseholders is to contact their leasehold-owning […]

The FT today reports that government hopes that speculators in residential freeholds – especially anonymous ones hidden offshore – are unlikely to pay up to remove Grenfell cladding. The article coincided with reports of Places for People, freeholder of Leeds Saxton, issuing a non-repayable loan to leaseholders and pursuing a claim against warranty provider NHBC. […]

Slough Council – which made the unaccountable decision to buy the freehold of Grenfell cladding site Nova House for £1 – was in tribunal earlier last week against a formidable opponent, Benjamin Pell, better know to journalists as Benji the Binman. Mr Pell, who came to national attention after raiding the dustbins of London’s leading […]

The government is persisting with its argument that “building owners” must pay up to remove Grenfell cladding from their sites – even though the law has said that they don’t pay, leaseholders do. The statement today from Communities Secretary James Brokenshire says: “Local authorities will get the government’s full backing, including financial support if necessary, […]

By Harry Scoffin Last month, as part of its Britain section, The Economist explored the leasehold system and recognised the work of the Leasehold Knowledge Partnership. The article starts by referencing Anis Kasmani, an unhappy Persimmon customer who bought a leasehold house at Harrow View West before house builders were shamed into abandoning the tenure […]

The Law Commissioner Professor Nicholas Hopkins has dashed hopes of early leasehold reform, telling the Law Gazette that legislative change won’t come before 2020. Speaking at a consultation exercise at the Ministry of Justice on Monday, Professor Hopkins said that his team is working to an “accelerated time-table”, but that new legislation on leasehold would […]

leasehold.reform@communities.gov.uk It is vital that as many leaseholders as possible respond to the government consultation to reform leasehold, ban leasehold houses and address ground rents. The government is pushing £10pa ground rents, which will keep the WHOLE leasehold racket going. If there is a legitimate income in residential freeholds, they will be traded and used […]

Using a flat for “immoral purposes” can be grounds for forfeiture The Sunday Times today exposes a prime London site belonging to freeholder, insurance tycoon and Conservative Party donor Christopher Moran as being full prostitutes. Many have to sell their bodies 30 times a month before they can afford the rents of £3,000 a month […]

And sector offers up yet another ‘code of practice’, this time for freeholders (whoever they may be when hidden offshore) One of the greatest fictions of the leasehold sector is that freeholders – even anonymous offshore ones – are the only reliable long-term stewards of a block of flats. The leasehold owners would be incapable, […]