RYAN & TRISTA

Inaugural Bachelorette Rehn gave her heart to Sutter on the show's season finale in 2003, and the couple tied the knot on Dec. 6 that same year. Almost a decade later, the pair is proud parents to 5-year-old son Maxwell and 4-year-old daughter Blakesley. "There is no secret formula," Trista told PEOPLE in 2004 of making their reality romance work. "Ryan and I were obviously ready … It was in the cards for us."