Comments

Anonymous

February 8, 2008

I don’t think it’s particularly game-changing at all. The Flash environment is touring-complete, so you can make it do anything. I think the real question is, “is this qualitatively, or quantitatively better than the way I currently manipulate images”. For me, the answer is no, not yet. I don’t have to have web connectivity in order to use my editor of choice, and my editor of choice is faster, and has more features. It also builds upon years of “growing up” with the app. Inertia plays a big role in “fat application” use.

Anonymous

February 9, 2008

Depends CM – you are speaking in the singular. Is it better for “me”? Aviary was built to allow collaborative editing – something you cannot do in a “me” focused desktop program.

Sidenote, there is an offline version as well, but as you said – there’s no point in adopting that, if you already have a tool you like for offline use.

Anonymous

February 10, 2008

To me, even without the collaborative features, having a fully featured image editor running off the web built in Flash is actually a pretty important milestone. If not for the design world (although I believe it is) at least from a software industry point of view.

Some might find this move to web-based apps as a rather mundane ‘next step’ but it is truly going to change the software landscape. Just being able to access my files and work from 95% of the connected machines on the planet must be hailed as a pretty important step.

Anonymous

February 10, 2008

Great Photoshop work it little bit amateur it look like examples from Computer Arts magazine. We wish all best to Hillary Clinton.

Anonymous

February 11, 2008

@communication – looking at your site and “case studies”, I am not sure why you are referring to anyone else’s work as amateur.

As far as the app, pretty amazing level of sophistication for online.

Anonymous

February 21, 2008

While I’m not going to switch to a web app version of Photoshop anytime soon – I do agree with Alex that this is a huge milestone for online apps. Its also pretty impressive what these Flash Developers have been able to achieve.

Anonymous

February 8, 2008

While I’m not going to switch to a web app version of Photoshop anytime soon – I do agree with Alex that this is a huge milestone for online apps. Its also pretty impressive what these Flash Developers have been able to achieve.

Anonymous

February 8, 2008

@communication – looking at your site and “case studies”, I am not sure why you are referring to anyone else’s work as amateur.

As far as the app, pretty amazing level of sophistication for online.

Anonymous

February 8, 2008

Great Photoshop work it little bit amateur it look like examples from Computer Arts magazine. We wish all best to Hillary Clinton.

Anonymous

February 8, 2008

To me, even without the collaborative features, having a fully featured image editor running off the web built in Flash is actually a pretty important milestone. If not for the design world (although I believe it is) at least from a software industry point of view.

Some might find this move to web-based apps as a rather mundane ‘next step’ but it is truly going to change the software landscape. Just being able to access my files and work from 95% of the connected machines on the planet must be hailed as a pretty important step.

Anonymous

February 8, 2008

Depends CM – you are speaking in the singular. Is it better for “me”? Aviary was built to allow collaborative editing – something you cannot do in a “me” focused desktop program.

Sidenote, there is an offline version as well, but as you said – there’s no point in adopting that, if you already have a tool you like for offline use.

Anonymous

February 8, 2008

I don’t think it’s particularly game-changing at all. The Flash environment is touring-complete, so you can make it do anything. I think the real question is, “is this qualitatively, or quantitatively better than the way I currently manipulate images”. For me, the answer is no, not yet. I don’t have to have web connectivity in order to use my editor of choice, and my editor of choice is faster, and has more features. It also builds upon years of “growing up” with the app. Inertia plays a big role in “fat application” use.