So the Iggles just named Foles the starter for the remainder of the season. Do they cut Vick before the season is done? And if so, we would have the first crack to sign him off waivers. Would we do it?

I actually am starting to warm up to the idea of getting Vick for next year, taking BPA in the draft in round 1, then getting the highest rated developmental qb in the 2nd (Mike Glennon).

I think with a good offensive line, good weapons (hopefully we re sign Bowe) and a good defense + a weaker division he should be able to do A LOT better than what he did this year. Not too mention Andy Reid has been discussed a lot around these parts, so I would like the idea even more with the familiarity between the 2 of them._________________

Love him, as a back-up. He has shown that you just can't put a team on his shoulders for the entire season. The way he plays just leaves him too open to injuries-- he has started all 16 games just once in his career. If you bring him in as depth and a change of pace/back-up QB, then I'm all about it. He has the arm, he has the moves, he can even go out and win a game for you, and that's something we haven't had in a back-up since Rich Gannon._________________

Joined: 31 Aug 2011Posts: 5260Location: Hate for the Donkeys is at a mile high

Posted: Wed Dec 05, 2012 2:24 am Post subject:

But you don't think anyone will project as good as Tannehill or Wilson? Who are both capable of being a playoff QB on the right team....Tannehill had a chance with a bad team and Wilson may very well make it.

How could we possibly sell going with Quinn, when we have all the offensive weapons necessary to be successful if we have a capable QB? Quinn clearly won't be good enough to be a playoff caliber QB even if he continues playing decent, so you might as well play the guy who does have that possibility to get the most out of the offense._________________

49ers Finest wrote:

People just seem to be mad because the chiefs are all of a sudden doing what their fans thought they were capable of

But you don't think anyone will project as good as Tannehill or Wilson? Who are both capable of being a playoff QB on the right team....Tannehill had a chance with a bad team and Wilson may very well make it.

How could we possibly sell going with Quinn, when we have all the offensive weapons necessary to be successful if we have a capable QB? Quinn clearly won't be good enough to be a playoff caliber QB even if he continues playing decent, so you might as well play the guy who does have that possibility to get the most out of the offense.

This is where I have to admit to being a Quinn fan and wanting to see him get a good shot._________________

I would pass. Vick has never developed beyond an athlete with a canon for an arm. We need a young franchise quarterback and I would prefer to add a veteran that would give us a stabilizing presence behind the rookie (ex. Brady Quinn or Jason Campbell). Vick doesn't strike me as the type of veteran quarterback that would take a younger player under his wing - and I don't think he has the understanding of the position that would allow him to be a good teacher either.

If we select a player like Geno Smith for example, I want a heady veteran that understands the position and knows how to share his experience with Smith. Kind of like Mark Brunell in his later years._________________

I would pass. Vick has never developed beyond an athlete with a canon for an arm. We need a young franchise quarterback and I would prefer to add a veteran that would give us a stabilizing presence behind the rookie (ex. Brady Quinn or Jason Campbell). Vick doesn't strike me as the type of veteran quarterback that would take a younger player under his wing - and I don't think he has the understanding of the position that would allow him to be a good teacher either.

If we select a player like Geno Smith for example, I want a heady veteran that understands the position and knows how to share his experience with Smith. Kind of like Mark Brunell in his later years.

Fair point.

What about Vick going to Cleveland....then he will be back in the Dog Pound.....

I would pass. Vick has never developed beyond an athlete with a canon for an arm. We need a young franchise quarterback and I would prefer to add a veteran that would give us a stabilizing presence behind the rookie (ex. Brady Quinn or Jason Campbell). Vick doesn't strike me as the type of veteran quarterback that would take a younger player under his wing - and I don't think he has the understanding of the position that would allow him to be a good teacher either.

If we select a player like Geno Smith for example, I want a heady veteran that understands the position and knows how to share his experience with Smith. Kind of like Mark Brunell in his later years.

Fair point.

What about Vick going to Cleveland....then he will be back in the Dog Pound.....

.....

.....
....

I think bigs' head is gonna explode when he sees all of the "......"! LOL_________________