I know this has been discussed in various forms here but I have a specific question.

How many of you have had an arc flash where the doors actually blew open or off? It seems this can happen in a lab or maybe in an extreme case but I have not heard of many (any?) "real world" cases. I would be interested to hear your stories (or lack of )

Great question! I have seen the videos of some pretty bad arc flashes but my own experience has been just a couple of small events years ago and in each case the panel cover was off.

I imagine if a switch fails or racking a breaker with doors closed goes terribly wrong and there is enough energy, then blowing the doors off might be possible but I also wonder how common it is? - although even if it is 1 in a billion, I would not want to be that "1".

The 2012 Edition of NFPA 70E has a disturbing Informational Note 2 under 130.7 (A) stating that their collective genius finds 600V or less enclosed systems not likely to expose an employee to an electrical hazard. I have seen the aftermath of 480V gear, variable speed drives, and MLO MCC's where things were less than contained by the enclosure. Of course the standard goes on to talk out of the other side of their mouth in 130.7 (C) (15).

The more impressive pictures are from the MV gear but we also ran into an instance where an arc flash in a 4160V switch ocureed while an electrician was re-energizing. Most of of the energy was contained but the buckling door dislocated his hip. The equipment photos don't look too bad but the effect is very real.

An outdoor vacuum in air 15 kV circuit breaker flashed over. The condensation prevention heater and thermostat in the high voltage compartment was set from the factory to zero so that it never came on in our climate. Condensation built up on the bushings and interrupters until a flashover occurred. The high voltage compartment doors were bolted on and held, but the high voltage compartment vented into the low voltage compartment below and blew those doors open. This occurred when no one was present, so no injuries occurred. Breaker spec now calls for the thermostat to be located in the low voltage compartment where it can be checked more easily.

I went to a company to review repairs needed after they had a 480V, 1600A Westinghouse DB-50 breaker arc flash on them. Not sure if you have ever seen one of these breakers, but the metal frame is about 1/2" thick and half the breaker was GONE! It disintigrated the door to it and the back of the bucket it was in to where I could see straight through to the back main buss. About 5' around it was singed badly. I did not whitness this arc flash, but it must have been very bad! Other than transformer explosions, this was the worst case I've seen.
In general, I figure if it's Category 2 or more, there is a high probability of having enough blast potential to blast the door open.

I went to a company to review repairs needed after they had a 480V, 1600A Westinghouse DB-50 breaker arc flash on them. Not sure if you have ever seen one of these breakers, but the metal frame is about 1/2" thick and half the breaker was GONE! It disintigrated the door to it and the back of the bucket it was in to where I could see straight through to the back main buss. About 5' around it was singed badly. I did not whitness this arc flash, but it must have been very bad! Other than transformer explosions, this was the worst case I've seen.In general, I figure if it's Category 2 or more, there is a high probability of having enough blast potential to blast the door open.

DB's are scary, perhaps the most scary for racking, and besides a "current production insulated case breaker", I have seen more DB failures than anything out there.

I know this has been discussed in various forms here but I have a specific question.

How many of you have had an arc flash where the doors actually blew open or off? It seems this can happen in a lab or maybe in an extreme case but I have not heard of many (any?) "real world" cases. I would be interested to hear your stories (or lack of )

I see multiple instances every year, unfortunately for the same reasons as posted above, I can't post pictures.

Who is online

Users browsing this forum: No registered users and 1 guest

You cannot post new topics in this forumYou cannot reply to topics in this forumYou cannot edit your posts in this forumYou cannot delete your posts in this forumYou cannot post attachments in this forum