From Benjamin Rush

[dateline] Hospital at Limerick 26 miles from Philada: on the Reading road. Octobr 13. 1777

[salute] Dear Sir

I have little to add to the long letter I wrote to you a few days ago, but that the
event of the battle at Germantown on the 4th instant was full of proofs of the truths
I formerly communicated to you. We lost a city—a Victory—a campaign by that want of
discipline and System which pervades every part of the army. General Conway wept for
joy when he saw the Ardor with which our troops pushed the enemy from hill to hill,
and pronounced our country free from that auspicious Sight. But when he saw an Officer
low in command give counter orders to the commander in chief, and the commander in
chief passive under that circumstance, his distress and resentment exceeded all bounds.
For Gods sake do not suffer him to resign. He seems to possess Lee's knowledge and
experience without any of his Oddities or vices. He is moreover the idol of the whole
Army. Make him a Major General if Nothing else will detain him in your Service. He
is entitled to <all> most of the glory our Arms acquired in the late battle.1 But his bravery and Skill in war are not his only military Qualifications. He is
exact in his discipline, and understands every part of the detail of an Army. Besides
this, he is an Enthusiast in our cause. Some people blame him for calling some of
our Generals fools—cowards—and drunkards in public company. But these things are proofs of his
integrity, and should raise him in the opinion of every friend to America. Be not
deceived my dear friend. Our army is no better than it was two years ago. The Spirit
of our men is good. Our Officers are equal nay superior to Howes. A few able major
generals would make them a terror to the whole power of Britain. Adieu. Yours sincerely,

P.S. I am afraid we Shall soon loose a most gallant Officer in Col. Stone.2 Congress must take notice of him living or dead.

An Anecdote

An Officer in Howe's army told me they had executed only two men in the last year. Their discipline prevents crimes. Our want of it creates them. We have had 20 executions in the last year, and our Army is not a bit the better for
them. If Howe Should lie still, desertions, sickness, accidental deaths, and executions
would waste our whole army in one year.

1. Rush's extravagant assessment of Conway's contribution to the Battle of Germantown
on 4 Oct. reflected his own critical attitude toward Washington. Later, Conway's criticism
of Washington in a letter to Gates roused Washington's anger and led to the supposition
of a conspiracy against the commander in chief, the so-called Conway Cabal, for which
modern historians have found no basis in fact. Modern accounts of Germantown stress
the hard-driving attacks of units under Sullivan, of which Conway's was only one,
and under Greene, particularly Peter Muhlenberg's brigade. The failure at Germantown
at the moment of apparent victory was owing to confusion in a heavy ground fog and
perhaps to a too ambitious military plan requiring more precise timing than the Americans
could achieve (Ward, War of the Revolution, 1:362–371).