If this is your first visit, be sure to
check out the FAQ by clicking the
link above. You may have to register
before you can post: click the register link above to proceed. To start viewing messages,
select the forum that you want to visit from the selection below.

I don't know. It seems to me that they could combine the two just fine. So long as all of the armor was removable, which seems totally possible. Both Gygor and Man-at-Arms have removable arm and leg armor,, so why couldn't Rattlor? And they could come up with a middle ground for the head design.

I don't know. It seems to me that they could combine the two just fine. So long as all of the armor was removable, which seems totally possible. Both Gygor and Man-at-Arms have removable arm and leg armor,, so why couldn't Rattlor? And they could come up with a middle ground for the head design.

My sentiments exactly!

I want more snakemen, but I like Rattlor as The General. Bring on the army-builders!

I'm just fine with a "classic" inspired MOTUC Rattlor, If they use some of that vintage art as inspiration he's going to turn out awesome. I'm no more interested in a 2k General variant than I am a 2k Sorceress, or King Hiss. I understand introducing 2k characters that aren't already appearing in MOTUC like Marzo or Evilseed, but I have no interest in collecting a bunch of 2k variants of every figure, that would essentially look like the 2k figure collection I already own?

What status does the General diminish? Vintage Rattlor was only a thug.

I was referring more to Rattlor's standing in the motu community. For example, would vintage fans be happy that Rattlor has a superior to take orders from in the form of the General?
Maybe I'm wrong though...

Personally I'm perfectly fine with two seperate characters...the more figures the better, and there is a justification for it, imo, two have two characters.
But the fans, oh, the fans.

I think that works very well. While I'm not strictly opposed to the idea of them being 2 separate characters (and by extension released as 2 separate figures), it does seem rather unneccesary to me when one figure can do the job of both representations just fine.

It also depends on which representation of 200X Rattlor we are using as a reference point.

The differences between the 80s figure and the 200X incarnation seem more drastic when using images from the MYP cartoon (like the ones that MegaGear Max posted). This is largely because the MYP cartoon incarnation is completely missing the blue and yellow stripes from his arms and legs.

However, those stripes were very much present on the 200X figure, as seen here in the He-Man.org action figure archives:

The stripes probably weren't included in the cartoon because they would have likely just been a pain to animate. They otherwise likely would have been included.

So really, the biggest difference is pretty much his head and the armor. And I'm really not expecting him to be a figure that comes with 2 heads after the issues that Mattel had with Whiplash's 200X head. Any other differences between them are really more minor details, which I'm sure in the case of the 200X version will fall under the category of "hyper anime detail" and wouldn't be used anyway.

It also depends on which representation of 200X Rattlor we are using as a reference point.

The differences between the 80s figure and the 200X incarnation seem more drastic when using images from the MYP cartoon (like the ones that MegaGear Max posted). This is largely because the MYP cartoon incarnation is completely missing the blue and yellow stripes from his arms and legs.

I know! That's why I used MYP's General as a visual reference point to show that this could be somebody else entirely. He's orange, big and is wearing armor--things that the vintage Rattlor lacks.

Could Rattlor and the General be two different characters like Zodac/Zodak?

If Classic Rattlor is staying true to the original look and isn't wearing any armor, could he be an altogether different character from the (orange scaled in the MYP cartoon) armor wearing character "The General" from 200X, but in the Classic style?

Does this guy...

(Click on link to see pictures)

...translate into this guy?

(Click on link to see pictures)

Would this be another Zodac/Zodak case?

Keep reading the bio and you'll get your answer!

I find this answer to be pretty interesting...surely TG wouldn't have said that if there wasn't going to be a difference?
I don't have much interest in the vintage snake men. MYP Rattlor, on the other hand, would interest me. They could have made a hybrid version with the armor and two heads, but with no more 200x heads it gives an opportunity to sell two different looking figures. Maybe vintage Rattlor could be the General's son?

I find this answer to be pretty interesting...surely TG wouldn't have said that if there wasn't going to be a difference?

I know...he would have just shot it down if General Rattlor would have been the Vintage version with removable armor or questioned it like he did with 200X King Hsss and MYP Roboto.

This is an opportunity to make a new Snake Man character.

I don't have much interest in the vintage snake men. MYP Rattlor, on the other hand, would interest me. They could have made a hybrid version with the armor and two heads, but with no more 200x heads it gives an opportunity to sell two different looking figures. Maybe vintage Rattlor could be the General's son?

I was thinking that! Sorta like how Vintage Rattlor is the general's son, but he's nowhere near the Snake Man that his father is.

Why do you like MYP Rattlor? You like how the Snake Men were handled in MYP?

I know! That's why I used MYP's General as a visual reference point to show that this could be somebody else entirely. He's orange, big and is wearing armor--things that the vintage Rattlor lacks.

The 200X figure is normal Rattlor with armor and hyper anime detail.

But you are making it sound like the 200X figure and the 200X cartoon are drastically different from each other when they really aren't

The cartoon version simply lacks the stripes of the toy, and he has more of an orang-ish color than red-ish color. To say that the 200X figure is just the old toy with armor and "hyper anime detail" (basically marginalizing the differences between the old and new figures), but to then say that the additional minor differences between the 200X toy and 200X cartoon (which for the most part were likely due to keeping the animiation a bit more simple) make the 200X cartoon version a completely different character from the old toy is a bit of a stretch. I do see where you are coming from to a certain extent, but it is a stretch.

It also just seems kind of funny and ironic to me for any 200X fans to be championing for the stripless Rattlor ala the 200X cartoon. I mean, while it varies from fan to fan and most fans (yourself included), have come to terms with the fact that anything 200X-based that is included in the line will be toned-down in terms of detail, the basic goal has seemed to be to keep things as true to their 200X roots as possible (including keeping as much detail as is reasonably possible). To basically be champoining for a stripe-less Rattlor (i.e. a less detailed version in that respect) as the basis for a MOTUC 200X incarnation of him (despite there being a more detailed, striped version included in 200X, which wouldn't constitute "hyper anime detail" since the original figure had the same stripes) just seems ironic to me.

I mean no offense by that. Personal preference is just that.. personal preference. If you happen to want an orangish stripeless Rattlor, that's your perogative. Like I said earlier, I am not necessarily opposed to the 2 versions becoming 2 separate characters... I just don't consider it necessary.

If they make one figure with removable armor, I'm fine with that. If they make 2 separate figures, that's fine as well (I am actually partial to the 200X face/head, so in all honesty the one saving grace to having him become 2 separate characters would be if that version would bare a greater resemblence to his 200X face), but I can live without it.

I was thinking that! Sorta like how Vintage Rattlor is the general's son, but he's nowhere near the Snake Man that his father is.

Yeah, they could do anything if they went down this road. Another scenario could be that Rattlor is a good warrior, but can't live up to his father's expectations (like how he always disses Kobra Khan no matter how efficient he is, lol)

Originally Posted by MegaGearMax

Why do you like MYP Rattlor? You like how the Snake Men were handled in MYP?

hmm, well I never really knew of the snake men before I saw the MYP show. They were released long after I had stopped playing with the toys, so that cartoon was really my first exposure to them. I thought Rattlor was a pretty decent villain, somehow regal and dastardly at the same time.
There's nothing wrong with the vintage Rattlor, but I have no nostalgic connection so visually he looks like a bit of a downgrade to me in comparison.

But you are making it sound like the 200X figure and the 200X cartoon are drastically different from each other when they really aren't

Shhh!!!! I know that, and you know that, but Mattel doesn't know that!:hmlol:

The cartoon version simply lacks the stripes of the toy, and he has more of an orang-ish color than red-ish color. To say that the 200X figure is just the old toy with armor and "hyper anime detail" (basically marginalizing the differences between the old and new figures), but to then say that the additional minor differences between the 200X toy and 200X cartoon (which for the most part were likely due to keeping the animiation a bit more simple) make the 200X cartoon version a completely different character from the old toy is a bit of a stretch. I do see where you are coming from to a certain extent, but it is a stretch.

I know...but keeping the General red with the Rattlor stripes just makes that character Rattlor with hyper anime detail. Taking those elements away gives us a new Snake Man, while the vintage Rattlor keeps those elements. We also have personalities backing up the two separate designs. In the minicomics and She-Ra TV series, Rattlor is portrayed mostly as Tung Lashor's sidekick, whereas his 2002 portrayal, he is King Hiss' direct second-in-command. I think that vintage Rattlor wearing the General armor would look as awkward as vintage Grizzlor wearing his 200X loincloth and weapons.

It also just seems kind of funny and ironic to me for any 200X fans to be championing for the stripless Rattlor ala the 200X cartoon. I mean, while it varies from fan to fan and most fans (yourself included), have come to terms with the fact that anything 200X-based that is included in the line will be toned-down in terms of detail, the basic goal has seemed to be to keep things as true to their 200X roots as possible (including keeping as much detail as is reasonably possible). To basically be champoining for a stripe-less Rattlor (i.e. a less detailed version in that respect) as the basis for a MOTUC 200X incarnation of him (despite there being a more detailed, striped version included in 200X, which wouldn't constitute "hyper anime detail" since the original figure had the same stripes) just seems ironic to me.

It's not lost on me either. Making sacrificing detail to get a particular representation of a character into Classic is a pretty regular thing in Classicizing 200X characters.

Really? Two versions of Rattlor? I think that's completely unnecessary.

I also think "The General" was a pretty dumb name that they were forced to use because of the copyright lapse. That name should be left for 200X. Removable armor is fine for MOTUC if they even do that. He doesn't really even need to be called "General" Rattlor either. That qualification could be just bio information. Knowing the trends in MOTUC, he'll just be Rattlor.

So I wouldn't get your hopes up for the "General" version. Then again, they did do Zodak so what do I know ...

I really hope his head doesn't look as goofy as the original, I would much prefer a style guide type one, and some removable 200x armour and/or loin-cloth would be really sweet. If they have to call him The General on the card I hope they can use Rattlor has his real name on the back, I don't want two separate figures.