Following a breakout campaign in which he slashed .321/.367/.520 in 333 at-bats, Colabello was expected to provide solid value for fantasy owners. However, just 16 games into the 2016 season, the first baseman tested positive for performance enhancing drugs and was suspended 80 games. The organization didn't offer much support, and actually shunned him in some ways. Manager John Gibbons said players "come and go" in July when asked about Colabello's standing with the team. After his suspension was over, the 32-year-old was sent to the minors, never to return (not even when rosters expanded in September). Colabello spent the entire second half playing for Triple-A Buffalo and slashed a disappointing .185/.254/.293 in 157 at-bats. Now 33, Colabello will get a look with the Indians in spring training, competing for a backup role at first base and in the outfield corners.

2016

Colabello's story of finally making the major leagues after nearly a decade spent independent ball was nice when he broke through with the Twins in 2013. But in 2015, at age 31, Colabello proved he not only could make the majors, he could also be a productive hitter. With the Blue Jays, who have made magic with so many right-handed power hitters in the past, Colabello found his stride and clubbed 15 home runs in just 360 plate appearances. He hit .300 against both lefties and righties and was a staple in Toronto's playoff lineup. Colabello has a penchant for strikeouts and will almost certainly never hit .300 again -– of the 10 qualified players to strike out more than 27 percent of the time in 2015, only three hit even above .260. Still, Colabello's home run stroke makes him a worthwhile 1B/DH target, and he can feast in Toronto's loaded lineup even as a semi-regular member of the lineup.

2015

Colabello, a late bloomer who was undrafted and played independent ball until he was signed in 2012 by the Twins, was the International League Player of the Year in 2013 after hitting .352 with 24 home runs and a 1.066 OPS. While he struggled in his first taste of the majors in 2013, he won a starting DH role at the start of the 2014 season and began the season red hot by hitting .295 with 27 RBI. Colabello suffered a thumb injury on April 23, and he was never quite the same, proceeding to go on an 8-for-73 slump that led to his demotion to Triple-A. He then posted a lackluster .805 OPS at Triple-A. Colabello has shown great raw power and a decent walk rate at times the past two years and his thumb injury may have been the cause for his disappointing season. He could still find a productive bench role in the majors, but his mediocre defensive ability and age (31) limit his upside.

2014

Colabello is the definition of a late bloomer as he went undrafted and played independent ball until he was signed in 2012 by the Twins. He parlayed a strong showing last year for Italy in the World Baseball Classic, where he hit .333 (6-for-18) with two home runs, into an outstanding season at Triple-A. He was named the International League Player of the Year after hitting .352 with 24 home runs and a 1.066 OPS. He struggled when called up the majors, however, hitting just .194 with a .631 OPS. He hit seven home runs and the rebuilding Twins questionably only gave him 181 plate appearances in the majors. Colabello has shown great raw power and a decent walk rate, so he could emerge with a role in the majors at some point, but the fact that he is already 30 years old limits his upside.