Trust me 2nd, I've been in this business long enough to know the reaction I was going to get. If there was any surprise it was that he actually replied. I messaged orci too, but I doubt I'd get a reply. Well unless it was about the new world order or the World Trade Center bombing, that is.

Indeed. We don't have to take the chaff with the wheat. And calling STID "chaff" is an insult to chaff. I started to watch it last night because I figure I would've done so out of cheer curiosity anyways, even after reading the "spoilers" and stupid things that happen throughout. But I guess seeing is believing, and the sheer idiocy that goes on in the first 10 or so minutes of this movie is simply perplexing, to put it mildly. I don't know if I could sit through the whole thing without throwing something at my TV.

I'll have to disagree. Parts of Star Wars - even parts of godsforsaken PT - are passable, even entertaining. I can't say the same of NuTrek. Star Wars is fantasy wrapped around SF trappings. NuTrek doesn't even attempt at being competent SF.

I'll have to disagree. Parts of Star Wars - even parts of godsforsaken PT - are passable, even entertaining. I can't say the same of NuTrek. Star Wars is fantasy wrapped around SF trappings. NuTrek doesn't even attempt at being competent SF.

PT is demonstrably worse than NuTrek. STID is better than any of the PT.

I'll have to disagree. Parts of Star Wars - even parts of godsforsaken PT - are passable, even entertaining. I can't say the same of NuTrek. Star Wars is fantasy wrapped around SF trappings. NuTrek doesn't even attempt at being competent SF.

PT is demonstrably worse than NuTrek. STID is better than any of the PT.

I said parts of the PT because, on the whole, ultimately they are wretched abominations. However, you'll forgive me if I don't sit through STID to confirm that; what little I've seen requires turning off higher brain functions in order to enjoy the rest of it.