Essay by Daniel Pipes: Counting Palestinian refugees

Only about 1% are real refugees who fit the agency’s definition of “people whose normal place of residence was Palestine between June 1946 – May 1948, who lost both their homes & means of livelihood as a result of the 1948 Arab-Israeli conflict.” The other 99% are descendants of those refugees, or what I call fake refugees.

The fetid, dark heart of the Arab war on Israel, I have long argued, lies not in disputes over Jerusalem, checkpoints, or “settlements.” Rather, it concerns the so-called Palestinian refugees.

So-called, because of the nearly 5 million official refugees served by the U.N. Relief and Works Agency for Palestine Refugees in the Near East, only about 1 percent are real refugees who fit the agency’s definition of “people whose normal place of residence was Palestine between June 1946 and May 1948, who lost both their homes and means of livelihood as a result of the 1948 Arab-Israeli conflict.” The other 99 percent are descendants of those refugees, or what I call fake refugees.

Daniel Pipes (Illustration)

Worse: Those who were alive in 1948 are dying off, and in about 50 years not a single real refugee will remain alive, whereas (extrapolating from an authoritative estimate in Refugee Survey Quarterly by Mike Dumper) their fake refugee descendants will number about 20 million. Unchecked, that population will grow like Topsy until the end of time.

This matters because this refugee status has harmful effects: It blights the lives of these millions of non-refugees by disenfranchising them, while imposing an ugly, unrealistic irredentist dream on them. Even worse, refugee status preserves them as a permanent dagger aimed at Israel’s heart, threatening the Jewish state and disrupting the Middle East.

Solving the Arab-Israeli conflict, in short, requires ending the absurd and damaging farce of proliferating fake Palestinian refugees and settling them permanently. 1948 happened; it’s time to get real.

Senator Mark Kirk (R-Ill.) is the force behind making long-needed changes to UNRWA.

Kirk’s proposed amendment requires the State Department to inform Congress about the use of the annual $240 million of direct American taxpayer funds donated to Palestinian refugees via UNRWA. How many recipients, Kirk asks, meet the UNRWA definition cited above, making them real refugees? And how many do not, but are descendants of those refugees?

The Kirk amendment does not call for eliminating or even reducing benefits to fake refugees. Despite its limited nature, Kirk calls the reporting requirement a “watershed.” Indeed, it inspired what a senior Senate GOP aide called “enormous opposition” from the Jordanian government and UNRWA itself, bringing on what Foreign Policy magazine’s Josh Rogin called a raging battle.

Why the rage? Because, were the State Department compelled to differentiate real Palestine refugees from fake ones, the U.S. and other Western governments (who, together, cover over 80 percent of UNRWA’s budget) could eventually decide to cut out the fakes and thereby undermine their claim to a “right of return” to Israel.

Sadly, the Obama administration has badly botched this issue. A letter from Nides opposing an earlier version of the Kirk amendment demonstrates complete incoherence. On the one hand, Nides states that Kirk would, by forcing the U.S. government “to make a public judgment on the number and status of Palestinian refugees … prejudge and determine the outcome of this sensitive issue.” On the other, Nides himself refers to “approximately 5 million refugees,” thereby lumping together real and fake refugees, and prejudging exactly the issue he insists on leaving open. That 5 million refugee statement was no fluke; when asked about it, State Department spokesman Patrick Ventrell confirmed that “the U.S. government supports” the guiding principle to “recognize descendants of refugees as refugees.”

Also, by predicting a “very strong negative reaction [to the amendment] from the Palestinians and our allies in the region, particularly Jordan,” Nides invited Arabs to pressure the U.S. Senate, a shoddy maneuver unworthy of the State Department.

Through all of Israel’s 64-year existence, one American president after another has vowed to resolve the Arab-Israeli conflict, yet every one of them ignored the ugliest aspect of this confrontation — the purposeful exploitation of a refugee issue to challenge the very existence of the Jewish state. Bravo to Kirk and his staff for the wisdom and courage to begin the effort to address unpleasant realities, initiating a change that finally goes to the heart of the conflict.

It too comes to the same “about 1% are real refugees” conclusion. I, personally, think it’s less. Everyone uses a base-line of who were “residence of Palestine between June 1946 and May 1948″ I DO NOT.

Most of those people were already refugees who fled west after the Hashemite Hejaz – Saudi Nejd war. They WERE NOT indigenous to ‘Israel’ and should not be redefined as ‘Palestinians’.

The current number of 5,000,000 refugees should actually be no more than 30,000. If there are responsible people willing to publicly declare their resistance (to the world) to perpetuate a lie that only fattens parasites (at the expense of working class peoples of the West) and contributes to the suffering of 2nd & 3rd generations born all over the Arab world, why not be truthful (realistic) to the end?

MAGEN DAVID ADOM – Israel

Israel travel Info

Live-cam from Israel

Israel and Stuff shall not be held liable for any delays, inaccuracies, errors or omissions in any content, or for any actions taken in consequence. Israel and Stuff does not obtain release from the subjects, individuals, groups or entities contained in its photographs, graphics or quoted in its text. Further, no clearance is obtained from the owners of any trademarks or copyrighted material where the marks and material are included in photos or content. You shall be solely responsible for obtaining any and all the necessary releases from whatever individual or entity is necessary for any of your uses of Israel and Stuff material. You agree to indemnify Israel and Stuff from any losses, damages and expenses (including attorney fees) it incurs as a result of any claim based on your use of its materials in violation of these terms.
Visitors here (You) are hereby notified that you are strictly prohibited from disclosing, copying, distributing, disseminating, or taking any other action against me with regard to this website and the contents herein. The foregoing prohibitions also apply to your employee(s), agent(s), student(s) or any personnel under your direction or control.
Copyright Disclaimer Under Section 107 of the Copyright Act 1976, allowance is made for "fair use" for purposes such as criticism, comment, news reporting, teaching, scholarship, and research. Fair use is a use permitted by copyright statute that might otherwise be infringing. Non-profit, educational or personal use tips the balance in favor of fair use.