What Is Best Fish Scaler? (Or Is A Knife Enough?)

Fly Fisher Pro is reader-supported. When you buy through links on our site, we may earn an affiliate commission. Learn more.

A fish scaler is an essential tool if you like to take home some of the fish you catch. Preparing a fish is a messy job, and removing the scales can be time-consuming. It’s possible to use a knife, but it’s fiddly and potentially dangerous. That’s why we recommend buying a fish scaler, an affordable and practical tool that every angler needs! The right scale remover will make the process much quicker and easier for you, saving you time and even reducing the mess.

Read on to get our recommendations for the top scalers on the market right now. We’ll also guide you through the essential factors every scale remover should have, so you know you’re getting a great product.

Buyer’s Guide to the Best Fish Scaler

The best fish scalers will be effective, lightweight, and easy to clean themselves. There are a few things to look for when shopping for a fish scaler, so keep these factors in mind:

Durability

A scaler needs to be sturdy enough for frequent use without breaking or rusting. Look for a model that is made from high-quality materials that won’t bend or break. As scalers are often in contact with water, stainless steel is an ideal material due to its anti-rust properties.

Lightweight Fish Scaler

You want a scaler that is lightweight and comfortable to hold, especially if you’ve got a big batch of fish to clean. It’s even better if it has an ergonomic, non-slip handle so that you can work even with wet hands.

Removes Scales Easily

This is a critical factor for any scaler – how easily does it remove the scales? You want a tool that can remove the scales with one sweep of the brush, but also get into those difficult areas on the fish around the fins and tail. Also, does it fling scales all over the place or keep them contained in one area? The less mess the scaler makes, the quicker cleanup will be!

Easy to Clean

The best scale removers are straightforward to clean with a quick rinse under the tap. Streamlined designs are best, as they don’t leave any tricky spots where scales can get stuck. Bonus points if it’s dishwasher-safe!

Manual or Electric Fish Scaler?

While many people don’t mind using a manual tool, there are also some great electric scalers out there that can save you time and energy. You won’t have to put so much force into your scrubbing, but unless you buy a cordless model, you’ll need to plug it into a power source. This feature means that electric scalers can be less portable than a simple manual scaler.

Best Fish Scaler: The Reviews

GiniHome Fish Scaler Brush

This stainless steel fish scaler from GiniHome is an absolute bargain, and won’t fail to impress. Although it’s a low cost, it’s constructed entirely from high-quality, food-safe stainless steel that is easy to clean. There’s no plastic here! It’s sturdy and rust-resistant, so it should last a long time.

The clever handle design makes it comfortable to hold with a firm grip, allowing you to remove the scales quickly and easily. It’s suitable for all types of fish and gets the job done thoroughly in record time. When you’re finished, you can hang it up with your other kitchen utensils until you next need it. Plus, it comes with a 30-day money-back guarantee, so if you’re not happy with the product for any reason, you can get a full refund.

You’ll struggle to find such a great fish scaler brush for such a low price. Whether or not you’re on a budget, this is definitely one of the best fish scalers around!

Pros:

Ergonomic non-slip handle

Durable stainless steel construction

Easy to remove fish skin with this brush

Cons:

It’s quite sharp, so you need to take care with it

Scales go everywhere when you use this fish scaler

Kwizing Fish Scaler Brush

The Kwizing fish scaler is inspired by traditional tools used in Japan to remove scales from fish. It’s handcrafted by Japanese artisans using timeless traditions and sturdy materials, and it works well.

Constructed from brass with a wooden handle, careful thought has gone into the design. There are more than 30 serrated brash teeth that can get into every part of the fish, even the tricky areas around the fins. You’ll have no trouble removing scales all over with this effective brush.

The handle is comfortable to hold, even if you’re working your way through a big batch of fish. You won’t get wrist pain from this scaler, nor should you slip thanks to the non-slip handle. What’s even better is that when you’re removing scales, they go down into the specially designed grooves to stop them flying all over the place. This feature makes clean up a doddle!

Pros:

Handmade to a high standard

Scaling is quick and easy

Less mess in the kitchen thanks to the useful grooves in the brush, which capture the scales

Reasonable price

You won’t damage the fish when you use this scaler

Cons:

Heavier than other scalers

The handle is made from unfinished wood and difficult to clean

Big Norm-Feets 88111 Magic Fish Scaler

This Magic Fish Scaler lives up to its name. It works wonders for fish scaling – it can remove scales in seconds, without making a big mess! Some fish scalers seem to send fish scales flying everywhere, while this one manages to keep all the fish scales contained in the sink or tub where you’re working.

Not to mention that this fish scaler is a steal! It comes in at just over $10 and will save you hours when you use this gadget to remove scales. Even if you have a lot of fish to get through, you’ll be amazed at how quick it is.

The circular design of this scale remover makes it simple to remove the scales all over the fish’s body. It’s suitable for small or large fish and can handle tough fish scales easily. You’ll be impressed by how well it works! The Magic Fish Scaler is so much safer than a knife, too – don’t risk injuring yourself and grab this bargain instead!

Pros:

One of the best budget fish scalers

Compact size

Easy to use

Very lightweight fish scaler

Cons:

You might need to go over the fish a couple of times to remove every fish scale

Viiwuu Electric Fish Scaler

The Viiwuu fish scaler is a little bit different from the other scalers on this list because it is an electric fish scaler, rather than a manual one. If you liked the idea of saving time by using a fish scaler, you’d like this product even more! It’s super fast and does all the work for you, so you don’t have to put any effort in.

This electric fish scaler by Viiwuu is waterproof and submersible, making it entirely safe. It’s powered by a lithium-ion battery, allowing you to charge it up and even take it on the go with you. Once you’ve charged the scaler, it’s fully portable, so you can even pack it in your fishing pack or boat to remove fish scales down at the river (and save on mess at home.) The battery only takes an hour to reach full charge, and then you can use it for 3 hours. So, you’ll be all set and won’t have to worry about it running out when you need it!

As for operating this fish scaler, it’s very straightforward. There’s just one button to press and two speeds to choose between – toggle it one way or the other to select your desired speed.

Cons:

Winco FSP-9 Scale Peeler

Winco products are designed for use in busy restaurants as well as for home cooks, so you know you’ve got a fish scaler you can rely on. It’s suitable for large volumes of fish and very easy to use.

The main drawback of this fish scaler is that it doesn’t catch the fish scales at all. You’ll need to make sure to use it in your sink to try to contain the mess. Otherwise, the fish scales will end up everywhere. And while it’s made from corrosion-resistant stainless steel that won’t rust, it feels fragile and could potentially bend or break.

Pros:

Very low price

Effective and lightweight

Suitable for all types of fish

Simple, streamlined design

Cons:

It is very sharp and can tear the fish when removing scales if you’re not careful

This fish scaler makes a mess

The handle is tricky to clean

Highmoor Fish Scale Scraper

In this fish scaler set, you get two different scalers to use in your kitchen. They both have a sturdy handle and a head of serrated teeth for fish scaling. The advantage of having two scalers of different sizes is that they allow you to get into all the tricky parts of the fish. You can use the larger scale remover for the sides of the fish. Then, swap to use the smaller scaler for the finicky areas around the fins and tail, where it’s harder to get to every single fish scale.

Both scalers are made from food-safe 304 stainless steel that is lightweight and easy to clean. As a result, you can make sure that your fish scaler will last. The stainless steel won’t rust, and overall this fish scaler is very robust, so it shouldn’t bend or dent, either. It’s very easy to clean the scaler, as it’s dishwasher safe. If you’re looking for an affordable option and two scalers to get the job done, this set from Highmoor is your best bet.

Pros:

Great value for money

Two scalers with differently-sized teeth to remove all scales

Easy and quick to clean in the dishwasher or by hand

Cons:

The handles don’t have a non-slip grip

Doesn’t catch the scales

Fish Scaler FAQ

What is the best fish scaler?

The best fish scaler is fast, efficient, anti-rust, and easy to clean. A good fish scaler will also have a comfortable, non-slip handle for ease of use. Some of the most popular brands of fish scaler include Winco, Viiwuu, and GiniHome – check out our recommendations above for more info!

What is a fish scaler?

A fish scaler is a tool you can use to remove the scales from a fish before you cook it. It’s safer, quicker, and more effective than using a knife, and it makes less mess. Most fish scalers have sawteeth that you scrape along the side of the fish to descale the fish. It’s a handy tool to have if you catch and prepare your own fish.

What is the easiest way to remove fish scales?

The easiest way to remove fish scales is with a fish scaler. It’s much more straightforward than using a knife, and you have less chance of injuring yourself. Just take the fish scaler and rub it along the side of the fish and around the fins, and the scales should come up easily. Rinse the fish to remove any stuck scales, and you’re ready to cook it. If you need more directions, check out this tutorial with pictures on how to scale a fish.

Do you need to scale fish?

You don’t have to scale fish, but it’s not pleasant to eat fish scales. Bacteria can also get trapped under the scales. So, it’s a good idea to clean and scale your fish thoroughly before you cook them. Scales don’t add any nutritional value and are not tasty. Scaling your fish is simple – just grab a fish scaler like the products recommended above. It takes only a few seconds to scrape off the scales.

The Wrap Up

So there you have our complete buyer’s guide to the best scalers for fish! You won’t regret investing in this convenient little tool for your kitchen, as it makes scaling your fish a quick and simple process. Any of the products we recommended above should do the job well! Check out more articles and buying guides for fishing tools and gear at Fly Fisher Pro!

Ben Kepka

Hey, I'm Ben, a fly fisherman for over 20 years and also an aspiring blogger. I've been into fly fishing since my graduation from spin fishing when I was 12 years old. I started flyfisherpro.com to help introduce as many people into this amazing sport. Tight lines everyone! You can read more on our about page here.

Our Top Picks

Fly Fisher Pro is a participant in the Amazon Services LLC Associates Program, an affiliate advertising program designed to provide a means for sites to earn advertising fees by advertising and linking to Amazon.com. As an Amazon Associate I earn from qualifying purchases.