ADJ. describing someones finger abilities. One whom has "Magic Fingers" can supposedly make girls moan for hours(this is not yet proven). They usually tend to think they are good at basketball, have a lot of dandruff, that they're stronger than you, are better than you, and will make it farther in life than you. They usually are said to have "A Magic Tongue" also, which is less talked about.

Person1: Hey, did you use ur magic fingers last night on that girl?
Person2: Shut up, come see me on the basketball court or in the gym. I'll still make it farther in life than you.

The event ,during a attempted action of fingering a girl, when the fingerer is not able to locate the "hole" of the recipient. Sometimes, in addition to this, the term may also include the fact that the favour was not returned.

Although the night was initially fun, The magic fingers kicked in and the action was spoiled.