Since the end of my innocence, when I became a teenager, I have been fascinated by the character traits that make me up. Some come from my father – my discipline, my fierce determination, and, of course, my hardheadedness – while my free-spirited and high-flying idealism come from my mother.

While that is all well and good, why do I obsess over purses and having perfect skin? Why am I unabashedly addicted to pop culture and music that makes me cry? Why is my voice high, why are my features delicate, and why is my sense of style so bodycon? How did I get so many feminine traits?

I am not a doctor, but I have a theory I don’t mind sharing. I heard once upon a time that when a baby begins to grow in a mother’s womb, the child starts out as a young lady and over time could become a young gentleman. For what other reason could guys have nipples?

I ate this theory up like I was at a half-priced ice cream buffet on binge Friday. Perhaps if I’d started out as a girl, I didn’t cook completely into being a boy and that’s why I like “girly” stuff. There had to be a reason for all this, and I had to wrap my head around it.

I don’t know how well versed you are in gay men’s behavioral patterns, but I am, so let me teach you. There are gay men more masculine than your husband, and more feminine than your favorite aunt. We represent a huge range. We don’t all fit under the terms flamboyant, Jack from “Will and Grace,” or previously worked as an actor/singer/dancer. There are gay men serving our nation proudly in armed combat, there are gay men running police precincts, and there are gay men burping and watching football. There is a curve of gayness.

Sexually, for the most part, gay men all have a preference to act in a certain way. Most fall into the category of either a passive or a dominant role, but I should say not everyone chooses to be labeled. However, most people have a specific role they fit into naturally. I know thinking of your favorite, sparkly, fabulous gay icon can be a bit odd as many people accept gays minus the sex, but I am going somewhere with this. If you have a preference for playing the passive role usually relegated to women, could it have something to do with how long you cooked in your mom’s belly?

I don’t mean to offend anyone by my idea, but it is a theory I’ve created and bashfully tell when I’ve had a glass of wine too many.

Here it is, on full display, the reason I think I am the way I am:

If I started out as a girl in Patti Weir’s belly, and slowly cooked my way into being a boy, but due to all the country air my mom took in or the fall harvest of 1983 when I was conceived, I didn’t quite make it over to being a straight man. Instead of finishing the cycle, I got stuck in a net in the middle of where the sexes overlap and happily floated out the remainder of my time in limbo. While I was being created, perhaps I even stayed a girl until the last possible minute until God stepped in a changed my body to that of a boy with personality traits and some features like a girl. You’d think it would make me some weird, powerful, spirit animal having been caught in the middle, but it has made me more confused throughout my life to not understand why certain things simply are.

When I look at my very masculine husband, is it possible to think that perhaps he was also undercooked on the male side of the limbo net and that’s how he is a masculine gay? If my theory is true, I could be an overcooked girl, while my husband is an undercooked man.

My theory is simply a theory, and there are many theories as to why people are the way they are. Still, I ask, why doesn’t science have an answer yet?

And why do I have nipples?

Share this:

Everytime you post , I think it’s my favorite one. THIS one might be THE MOST favorite as I too have thought this out like you and have a very similar notion and ideas on the theory. Is it possible for me to love you even more? Turns out, yes, yes I do. You make me laugh and think and wonder, Johnny Weir-Voronov! Coincidentally enough, this post is perfect for a gift that I will bestow on you, hopefully on May 19th should I have the fortune of meeting you in person. When I read the header title, I couldn’t believe it and thought ‘omg.. he’s in my head!’.
You’re amazeballs and beyond my dear man! xoxoxo And that goes for your handsome hunka man husband too!

Lady Lisa

I like how Gaga puts it “Baby, you were BORN this way”! Is there a genetic link? Seems to be with enough $ spent on “research” they can pretty much find or prove anything these days.
I really believe some things are simply not meant to be understood. When I look at my gay male friends I see this so much, seeing how happy they are just being themselves – I just would never question it, the “why” they are the way they are. Even if there is a reason, I don’t care, because I love them. Perhaps there is a genetic distinction to this, and, if so, it would be fasinating to know, but until then, what’s most important, to me, is acknowledging and embracing the person who you are – which I think you do quite well Johnny!

http://twitter.com/ac_bitter AB

Interesting theory. I don’t know the scientific reason why people are the way they are. I believe in the saying “it takes all kinds to make the world go around.” And to paraphrase your mom, how boring would life be if we were all the same? On the other hand, that doesn’t answer the “why do men have nipples” question!

http://www.facebook.com/barbara.breuer Barbara Erickson Breuer

This is too funny! Love it! It’s my new favorite.

http://www.facebook.com/jcatrosa Jennifer Cataldo Rosa

Going purely on the research found when I needed to come up with something fast to sooth over the family reaction when my sister informed us all that she was now on the road to becoming our brother… There have been many fascinating brain pattern studies done here in Boston that do prove that the male/female brain are in very many ways different. They also showed ( to a lesser degree ) that those same similar different patterns were found in a study of alpha male/effeminate male thinking patterns. Which does goes to show , That baby we are ALL born this way :)

http://www.facebook.com/jcatrosa Jennifer Cataldo Rosa

Oh PS : You & Your husband are wonderful , Loving these articles you do !

http://www.facebook.com/schismatic.beam Schismatic Beam

I’ve known of two pairs of identical twins where one of the pair is heterosexual and one is homosexual. Therefore, I think some of the mechanism for creating LGBT has to do with when certain gene switches turn certain male- hormones on or off, or don’t turn them on or off or at a different time from the usual. Your cooking theory meshes with that. I think that feminine nest-building and preening put on steroids explain some of a love of cleaning and fashion in your make-up. The chemical and electromagnetic (as in rays) environment plays a big role.

Susen

Here’s a thinker; if you are a girl with girly outer features but strong masculine inner traits, are you over- or undercooked then?
I just want to say that I think gender is overrated. I go nuts if I think about it too much. It’s like thinking about how big the universe is.
Gooooo inbetweeners!

Susen

Or oh oh! Maybe I was supposed to become a male, but God forgot all about me and that’s why I didn’t wanna come out of the womb and they had to shove a lot of drugs into my mother to force me out after 2 weeks overdue. Bastards!
That must be it. Thanks Johnny! ;)

Subscribe to daily updates, breaking news and more from the News-Press: