Thank you very much for each providing detailed information about this issue. It appears as if this may be related to known issue that our Engineering team is currently working on.

In order to determine if what you're experiencing is, in fact, the same issue, I will be opening tickets on each of your behalf with our Support team. Our Support team will be reaching out soon requesting any other needed information. Please look for a message from them soon.

In the meantime, the best workaround I can suggest would be to Duplicate the layer first, and then apply the data from Craft Data plugin - here's a recorded a screencast for your reference.

Thank you very much for providing those details. I will also open a ticket on your behalf with our Support team so that they can gather all of the information you have provided. They will be reaching out soon with some follow up questions, so please keep an eye out in your inbox.