A federal judge today ruled that the White House must restore the press pass it stripped last week from CNN’s chief White House correspondent, Jim Acosta.

Judge Timothy Kelly ruled that Jim Acosta’s free-press rights under the First Amendment to the U.S. Constitution outweigh “the government’s interest in orderly, respectful press conferences”. He went on to add that the White House failed to give Acosta “due process,” something guaranteed in government proceedings under the Fifth Amendment. And he suggested that the White House exaggerated when it claimed that Acosta “placed his hands” on a female intern last week as she tried to reclaim a press conference microphone.

While Kelly ordered the White House to let Acosta back in the building, he said Trump and his spokespeople aren’t obligated to call on him during press conferences or let him ask questions.

Kelly, a Trump appointee, emphasized that his ruling was temporary, saying: