Am looking at the Nigel Cabourn Eddie Bauer Geddes US Clip Coat- Tan. I am a 40" normally so should I go for the 48, 50 or 52 in this? Anyone have experience with this jacket as to how it fits? I won't be wearing anything too chunky underneath and want it to fit well but not too snug.

Managed to grab a Mallory Harris Tweed jacket in size 50, though was totally torn on which size to get (I have a Cameraman in 50 and a Tweed waistcoat in 52, both fit perfectly), and also there is a mismatch between photos and description between the two Mallory jackets. I want the one with the patches and ordered the right one going by the photos. I did email Marrkt earlier informing them of the error, but haven't heard anything. Fingers crossed!

Am trying to get the Geddes in 50 (didni't want to risk waiting for an answer to my question above) but have been on the checkout page for about 15 min. I guess there a couple of others trying to buy at the moment. If the sale comes off and the 50 doesn't fit, it'll be on the B&S forum in a couple of days.

Hmm I went for a Geddes in Moss colour version, I really couldn't make up my mind- all 3 colour versions are nice. Any thoughts on that guys? Which one would you pick if you were to settle for just one?

Hmm I went for size 48 of Geddes - I think it is oversized, 23" chest is quite roomy even for layering if you are 40". Oh and Eddie Bauer line is inconsistent with sizing- I have a Skyliner size 52 and the chest area is far from roomy..