Freedom and Responsibility: Censorship at Yeshiva College in the Early History of The Commentator, 1935-1958

View/Open

Date

Author

Metadata

Abstract

The first undergraduate newspaper was established at Dartmouth College in 1799. The
Dartmouth Gazette, to which Daniel Webster contributed in his college days, ran as a
weekly publication until 1820. The Yale Daily News was the first everyday college paper
starting in 1873. The Harvard Crimson traces its origins to that same year but did not
become a daily until 1883. Another storied news journal, Columbia’s Spectator was
established in 1877 but did not establish itself as a daily for nearly 25 years. By the end
of the century, most colleges had a student newspaper.1
By the close of the 1920s, there were at least 37 colleges which published daily
news journals. Midwest college newspapers like University of Wisconsin’s Daily
Cardinal and the Minnesota Daily, with circulations near 10,000, functioned like small
city newspapers covering a wide range of news interests. The East Coast college papers
generally restricted themselves to campus news, and consequently, their circulations were
much smaller. Until the third decade of the twentieth century, covering the campus beat
meant writing on sports, fraternity events and hazings. Perhaps if they were fortunate
enough these collegiate journalists would scoop the local newspapers to reveal the
university president’s new plan to build more study halls and dormitories to
accommodate the influx of student enrollment felt at colleges campuses nationwide.
Hardly any headlines in the college press reflected student discontent or any sort of
affront to college officials.2
By the 1930s, however, the life of a college newsman became something very
different. As a result of increased student radicalism on campuses, student newspapers
waged an editorial war against their administrations. Whereas in the first quarter of the
century when editors would seldom take issue with curricula and tenure appointments,
suddenly hardly a week could go by without some campus newspaper taking issue with
its university’s policies. In the Manhattan college scene alone, City College’s Campus
and The Spectator of Columbia became famous for leading student strikes to pressure
their respective administrations on a variety of campus related issues. In kind, outcry
from student newspapers at this time led to doling out of suspensions and even expulsion
of editors from time to time. This was the college culture into which Yeshiva College’s
student newspaper, The Commentator, was born.