This eyeliner looks GREAT when you first apply it. And for about an hour after that point. Then, it starts to blend and smear onto your eyelids, leaving a mess. I am DEFINITELY finding a new liner
— 3 years, 9 months ago

It's satisfying, but not as wowing to me. Maybe because I already tried the Urban Decay 24/7 eyeliners, that this one is less appealing to me. These aren't as creamy, and they smudge waaay too easily. Sorry, but there are better products out there.
— 4 years ago

A make-up artist recommended the navy color to me, stating that navy is better than black as it is not as harsh and makes the whites of your eyes sparkle more. So, I bought this one and she was right. It lasts all day especially if I layer it with a navy eye shadow over top of the line. Good product for the money.
— 5 years, 11 months ago

I've been wearing eyeliner for 40 years. Yes, 40. I've tried almost every line out there. These are great, esp the waterproof ones that I bought while living in Sweaty Florida. Had to use wp there.
I STILL have some of these pencils 15-18 yrs. later and they have not crumbled. I STILL go for them when I have to make a quick call while getting ready-I know they won't fail and they go on just right-not too hard and not too soft.
— 6 years, 5 months ago