A fatal error occurred during profiling: Maximum execution time of 90 seconds exceeded in file /home4/mygator/public_html/myduffybear.com/wp-content/plugins/p3-profiler/classes/class.p3-profiler.php on line 285

P3 is set to time out at 90 seconds for safety. If you want to raise the timeout, you need to edit the plugin. It's in your wp-content/plugins/p3-profiler/classes/class.p3-profiler.php file on line 183:

@set_time_limit( 90 );

You may find that a value higher than that (say 120) might cause other timeouts (apache/nginx or upstream proxies like varnish). I don't know the particular configuration of your WordPress set up.