Its not corruption that needs examination, but skate order. COP was supposed to be free from being influenced by skate order. However, as we've een with many champions phips, skate order stillplays a role.

I don't think skate order will ever not play a role in the scoring. Even if someone is judging as fairly and unbiasedly as they possibly can, it's a matter of how the mind works.

Oh, goodness, I find the headline of this thread ridiculous and off-putting. You can have a debate about the results, but shouldn't it be something along the lines of, "Who do you think deserved to win the ladies competition at Skate Canada?" Instead, the headline assumes that something so egregiously wrong happened that the debate it wants to start is not whether the result that happened was wrong or right, but whether it was so wrong that there needs to be an inquiry. Pfftt.