Dredging can make flooding worse, say activists

Liz Truss at the Somerset Levels earlier this year The Environment Agency

Dredging is “pointless” and largely ineffective, according to a coalition of environmental groups who are calling on the Government to scale down its preferred method of flood prevention.

The Blueprint for Water coalition, which represents groups such as the RSPB, the Angling Trust and Friends of the Earth, is urging the Government to spend money earmarked for dredging on “more effective” alternative flood-control methods such as improved drainage systems.

In a new report, Dredging Up Trouble, the coalition warns that scooping the mud and weeds from the river bed can, in some cases, make downstream flooding worse by moving water too quickly down the river.

In pictures: 'Faces of the Flood' - Incredible effort and solidarity among people in Somerset

12/18
'Faces of the Flood'

13/18
'Faces of the Flood'

14/18
'Faces of the Flood'

Dave widens a waterway with his digger to move floodwaters towards the pumps

15/18
'Faces of the Flood'

Ritchie, Dean and Daniel from South Yorkshire Fire and Rescue help pump water from a drainage ditch into the River Parrett

16/18
'Faces of the Flood'

Members of the Avon and Somerset Police visit people still living in their flooded homes

17/18
'Faces of the Flood'

A pump engineer lays a new pipeline to drain floodwater threatening dry homes

18/18
'Faces of the Flood'

Local volunteer Clare shovels wood-chip to help strengthen the riverbanks

“In its eagerness to be seen to be ‘doing something’, the Government will increase investment in dredging. This could exacerbate, rather than reduce, flood risk and cause environmental damage,” said Janina Gray, head of Science for the Salmon & Trout Association and chair of the coalition. Mark Lloyd, chief executive of the Angling Trust, added: “The government has been trying to find ways to stop farmers’ fields flooding, but ignoring the fact that bad management of farmer’s fields is causing the flooding of people’s homes.

“Instead of wasting money on dredging, which is largely pointless, the Government should use the existing £2bn subsidies from taxpayers to drive real change in farming practices to improve water management throughout river catchments.”

The coalition is urging to the Government to divert much of the money to be spent on dredging to investment in other areas. It says flood defences that protect hospitals, care homes and bungalows – where people cannot escape upstairs – should be “top of the list”. It also wants to see more spent on natural flood defences that absorb and rainfall and slow its passage downhill, such as woodland and wetlands.

After taking over from Owen Paterson in July, the Environment Secretary, Liz Truss, visited the Somerset Levels which were hit by floods at the start of the year to see how the dredging of the Rivers Parrett and Tone was progressing.

At the time, she said the dredging work was on schedule and that action was being taken where it was needed to prevent future disasters. “I see it as a real priority to make sure the area is properly protected against flooding,” she said.