You've confused me with someone else, I check the player production every week during the season. If you're a .300 hitter you're a .300 hitter. If you can only throw .60% completions, 1 1/2 TDs for every INT, your QB rating will say you're average and ordinary.

So you don't take quality of competition into account? Quality of teammates? Scheme-type? Blown assignments?

In short, do you watch games, or do you just look at the boxscores and read what other people say?