A UCLA study seems to imply that insulin interferes with cognitive function.

The DHA-deprived rats also developed signs of resistance to insulin, a
hormone that controls blood sugar and regulates synaptic function in
the brain. A closer look at the rats' brain tissue suggested that
insulin had lost much of its power to influence the brain cells.

He suspects that fructose is the culprit behind the DHA-deficient
rats' brain dysfunction. Eating too much fructose could block
insulin's ability to regulate how cells use and store sugar for the
energy required for processing thoughts and emotions.

"Insulin is important in the body for controlling blood sugar, but it
may play a different role in the brain, where insulin appears to
disturb memory and learning," he said. "Our study shows that a
high-fructose diet harms the brain as well as the body. This is
something new."

Don't take it personally, but this is a ridiculous question. You have in hand a study that "seems to imply" it has an effect, but you ask anonymous users of an internet website to tell you whether the authors are right or not - something which only further experiments can clarify. The only answer to such a question is "Do your own study, and then draw your own conclusions".
–
CHMMay 18 '12 at 0:31

1 Answer
1

Diabetes

I've not read about any conclusive evidence for a link between insulin and differential cognitive function, but I have read studies that link type-2 diabetes and impaired cognition (1). I will point out now that this is cross-sectional, so the study only reports associations (i.e. diabetes may not necessarily cause the cognitive impairment).

The study I have mentioned does not conclude that this is caused by raised insulin, but rather the effects on the vascular system (specifically microvascular). They also find a significant interaction between diabetes and smoking status, in the context of cognitive impairment. Again, this seems likely to be the vascular system, rather than insulin levels.

A recent review paper also refers to the links between diabetes and executive function (2), but again makes no reference to insulin as the cause, but rather microvascular changes, hypertension, and other associated traits (again, the causes are not known, these are speculative based on the evidence).

Diabetes may not be the best model for studying this though, as it can be characterized by either high insulin (tolerance), or low insulin (impairment) - therefore the association may not be found this way.

Insulin

In a separate review (this may be the best one for you if you only read one of the papers I've referenced) the author posits that whilst insulin may have a neuroprotective role, it also increases amyloid-Beta metabolism and tau phosphorylation, possibly contributing to Alzheimer's-like pathologies (3). Studies have found that insulin directly improves cognitive performance (4) after infusion of insulin, but the long term effects are less certain - it is unlikely to improve overall health having constantly raised insulin serum levels!

However the link between IGF-1 and improved cognition is less disputed, so you may well be right in thinking that the 'overall' effect of insulin on cognition may be protective, but this may just be a marker of good health overall, which is certainly protective!