“What’s up Doc?” – The UK’s Allergic Reaction to Brexit

I thought, at first, that in endorsing the UK parliament’s right to vote for the triggering of Article 50, the High Court ruling was a good thing. Having heard Theresa May’s views that it wouldn’t change her timetable or attitude, and other politicians saying that they were going to vote for Brexit anyway, has made me doubt over the usefulness of this decision. It seems to me that the UK’s entire democratic system has been twisted and turned to suit the result of the EU referendum.

Gina Miller was only doing what others should have done

The referendum result must be respected, notwithstanding the fact that it was entirely flawed and that a large proportion of the electorate answered the wrong question, i.e. “what do you think of the British establishment?”. I was under the impression, maybe naively, that in a parliamentary democracy, the election candidates proposed policies to the electorate, and not the other way around. In the present situation, it seems that the electorate has decided that the government should lead the UK out of Europe and the government has responded by saying “OK we’ll do it, but we don’t exactly know how, nor do we really agree with you. And, furthermore, let’s not use parliament to discuss it.”

One referendum never took place, and for the other I was disenfranchised

In asking the High Court to decide whether Article 50 could be triggered without the consent of parliament, Gina Miller was only doing what others should have done. She has, baring a reversal of the ruling by the Supreme Court, defended the true values of a parliamentary democracy. People vote for policies, members of parliament represent the voters and, policies are discussed and carried through by the national parliament. This democratic process should not, under any circumstances, be tampered with. That an advisory referendum was held for such an important decision as membership of the EU does not alter the fact that the UK is a parliamentary democracy. Being no ordinary election, all British citizens and EU citizens living in the UK should have been allowed to take part. I felt bad about not being able to vote in a referendum on the Lisbon Treaty in 2005 that never took place, as well as the 2016 UK referendum where I was disenfranchised by an archaic 15 year rule.

Brexit Hangover: Mixing Politics with Ethics

If a patient asked me to place a gold crown on his healthy front tooth, I would refuse

Enough has been written on the meaning and consequences of the High Court’s decision. Theresa May has launched an appeal that will be examined by the Supreme Court in December. What interests me here is the philosophical and ethical dilemmas some of the more “seriously minded” MP’s will be facing. None of the MPs (apart from UKip) were elected on the basis of their desire to leave the EU. And, what is more important, no-one actually proposed policies based on leaving the EU during the 2015 election campaign. The then conservative leader, David Cameron, only pledged to hold a referendum and respect the result. This puts present day MP’s who support the UK remaining in the EU in, what seems to me, an impossible situation. As a health professional, I’m confronted almost every day with ethical decision making. I have to decide whether to comply with the wishes of my patients. I regularly see young people who would rather let me extract a tooth than treat it. In these cases, who decides what is in the best interest of the patient? And as his practitioner must I abide by all his wishes? Of course, most of the time, after discussing the various treatment options, we come to a common approach, which, 9 times out of 10 saves the tooth. But what about the young girl who, for aesthetic motives, wishes to have a gold crown placed on a front tooth that has absolutely nothing wrong with it? What do I do then? I’ve made a point of refusing to carry out such treatment that, for me at least, is unethical.

MP’s who are serious about their mandate should seriously think about resigning

So, where does the result of the EU referendum leave the MP’s? And in what state of mind will they be in? We can broadly classify the MP’s into 3 distinct groups.

MPs who want a “hard” Brexit

These MP’s (if we can call them that) were perfectly happy with the government bypassing parliament. Annoyed and disappointed by the decision of the High Court, they now have to face the prospect of battling it out with others who want a soft approach to Brexit. They still do have hope that the Supreme Court will reverse the decision, but are getting ready for the worst. The real hard liners, of course, are in or close to government circles, kept under scrutiny and control by Theresa May. How many of them will last the full Brexit remains to be seen. Cracks are appearing already.

The “softies”

This group of MP’s, as I see it, is what I would call the “softies”. These are the MP’s who, whilst not really enthusiastic about the EU, would have liked the UK to stay in. In various ways, these MPs will try and soften Brexit, whilst at the same time respecting the will of the majority. But what about the MP’s whose constituents voted to remain in the EU? They are, in theory, in trouble with their constituents whom they would not represent by allowing Brexit to happen. How would you feel if you voted to stay in and your MP did nothing about it? This is the whole problem associated with having a referendum in a parliamentary democracy. MP’s take much pride in saying that they “represent their constituents”. In a referendum, however, the constituencies that have voted against the national majority will be abandoned by their MP’s. It’s difficult to estimate the number of MP’s who are in this position because the referendum results were announced by local authority area and not constituencies. It is estimated that around 150 MP’s could be in this situation.

The “hard” remainers

Some MP’s will have felt deeply disappointed by the referendum outcome. These are the hard line europhiles, who love the EU no matter what. They also have the determination and courage to stick by their opinions. They will fight until the end and have no fear to vote against the will of the people, even if it means losing their parliamentary seat. It remains to be seen how many there are and if they will remain silent.

Referendum Allergy

Allergy result from the body reacting against a substance that normally doesn’t cause a immune response. Peanuts, for example, innocuous to most people, can cause severe reactions in someone who is allergic to them. The danger is that you won’t know that you’re allergic to a substance until it actually happens, and the consequences can be devastating.

Does a referendum fit in with a parliamentary democracy?

For the Swiss-born philosopher Jean-Jacques Rousseau, the best form of democracy was one in which every citizen would regularly participate in the elaboration of laws. A nice thought, but not very applicable to large societies. I cannot imagine 40 million people having to attend assemblies to decide how to run the country. First of all, we would not have the time to do so, and, secondly, I very much doubt that we have the competencies to decide important issues on a part-time basis. Delegating political and constitutional responsibilities on others, as in a parliamentary democracy, whilst not being perfect, allows our views to be represented by governing bodies.

The EU referendum was nothing more than a glorified opinion poll

All you and I can do is offer opinions, and what we base our opinions on, is entirely up to us. The result of the EU referendum, which was advisory and not mandatory, is nothing more than a “glorified” opinion poll. For the former socialist French prime minister Michel Rocard, a referendum is “a national excitement where we put everything into one pot. A question is asked, people ask themselves others, and come to vote based on reasons that have nothing to do with the original question.” Furthermore, for such an important decision as leaving the EU, it was necessary to fix the required majority to a minimum of 60% in order for the referendum decision to have any chance of being valid.

“The more grave and important the questions discussed, the nearer should the opinion that is to prevail approach unanimity.” Jean-Jacques Rousseau – On the Social Contract

The Remedy?

The present parliament was not elected to implement Brexit

The present confusion boils down to the fact that the referendum is advisory and not mandatory. The fact that triggering Article 50 has to be carried out by parliament poses an interesting philosophical and ethical problem for all MP’s, except those who were firmly in the leave camp, and made it known that they were for Brexit. In the same way that a health provider must, from an ethical point of view, not always do what is asked of him, so too must the MP’s who believe that the UK is better off in the EU, and are on record as having said so. Even if it means bringing down the government and acting against the will of the electorate. In accepting Brexit a priori, parliament would resemble a mobile phone that has been switched from plane mode to mute, present but not fully functional. The present parliament was not elected on policies and desire to take the UK out of the EU. A general election is necessary to clear things up and put in place an elected government that is given the mandate to leave the EU. Referendums and parliamentary democracy is a “ménage à deux” that is destined to cause trouble.

Share this:

Related

gskaye

Post navigation

One Expat And His Blog

Welcome to CRYSTAL HORIZONS. The blog after the blog before. The "shares" have disappeared, but the posts haven't.
If you think that 2018 was eventful, you ain’t seen nothing yet.
This blog was originally about the EU and Brexit. Understandable because I’m half a British expat living in continental Europe (my other half is French). In my intro page I did mention that this blog is like cheese and will mature, and so it has... It has now acquired a new name - CRYSTAL HORIZONS.
So many things are happening in the world that it’s obvious that not everything revolves around Brexit. My opinions haven’t changed though, and I still think that smashing the EU door is certainly not the political answer to the UK's philosophical dream.
As for the blog, it still revolves around philosophy, politics and has a tinge of satire. Can philosophers and other learned individuals help me understand what the hell is going on?

Take Your Pick

One of the most important philosophical challenges we are facing today is that of intolerance, particularly religious intolerance. Repeated terrorist attacks in France, Belgium and elsewhere, remind us all of how far these intolerant religious believers are prepared to go. A possible explanation of why religious believers react violently when challenged is a phenomenon known as...
Read more

Having left the UK in 1984, I am beginning to wonder if my motherland is not the outward looking and relaxed land that I thought it was. I love the UK, don’t get me wrong. I can assure you that, on the 24th June, I was one of the most upset persons in the EU,...
Read more

Divorce can be a messy and expensive business. In the same way that people don’t get married with the intention of filing a divorce, I’m convinced that the UK didn’t initially join the EU (or European Economic Community, as it then was), in order to cause chaos and leave it. However, at least one notable...
Read more

I thought, at first, that in endorsing the UK parliament’s right to vote for the triggering of Article 50, the High Court ruling was a good thing. Having heard Theresa May’s views that it wouldn’t change her timetable or attitude, and other politicians saying that they were going to vote for Brexit anyway, has made...
Read more

It’s ironic that former prime minister David Cameron put forward a referendum on Europe that now threatens the very nature of the parliamentary democracy that let him propose it in the first place. Of course, whether Cameron had any choice in the matter remains subject for debate. But the fact of the matter is that...
Read more

Have you ever wondered about the origins of the expression “pardon my French”? Some say that it originated in the 19th century and was used as an apology by people who used French words in conversations. Nowadays it’s used apologetically after swearing. How wonderful language can be. I’m sure that Marine Le Pen, leader of...
Read more

It’s that time of year again, where everyone reminisces over what has happened over the year gone by and you get bombarded with reviews of this, that, and the other. Well, I’ve decided to tell you what I think the most important event of 2016 is. And…you’ve guessed it? It’s Leicester City wining the English...
Read more

On December 24th 1951, a group of Catholic clergymen hanged and set on fire a Father Christmas effigy in front of at least 250 children in Dijon, France. Following the incident, the late French anthropologist Claude Lévi-Strauss wrote an article entitled “Le Père Noël supplicié” (“The tortured Father Christmas”) in the literary journal...
Read more

All of us remember the horrifying picture of a 3 year old Syrian boy found lying on a beach. The scene epitomised the situation for ordinary people in Syria. But he and others are no ordinary people. We are. We, including myself, all live in our protected personal bubbles and are only temporarily affected by...
Read more

Shortly after the EU referendum, Theresa May decided to spend a few days in Switzerland. What a coincidence that this country is part of the European Free Trade Area (EFTA), but not the European Economic Area (EEA). EEA/EFTA: RUOK? Complicated? Yes, it sure is. Luckily Google can help me out. Let’s start with the EFTA:...
Read more

“Only one thing: this thickness and this strangeness of the world, that’s the absurd.” Albert Camus On June 16th 2016, the Labour member of Parliament, Jo Cox, was brutally murdered by Thomas Mair, an unemployed gardener. Although the perpetrator had a history of mental illness, he also had ties with extreme right-wing parties,...
Read more

Now that she knows where the bathrooms are in number 10 (I’m assuming that there is more than one), it’s down to business for Theresa May. She really got us going with her stirring speech and, with only a few weeks to go until the dreaded day when she sends THE LETTER to Brussels,...
Read more

On 23rd January, 2017,the Dutch centre-right prime minister Mark Rutte wrote an open letter which was widely published in the national press. As a non-Dutch national, I would like to respond to comments he made in that letter. The present post is based on my previous post written in Dutch. It wasn’t easy for me...
Read more

This week, the UK parliament approved a bill giving Theresa May the authority to trigger Article 50 of the Lisbon Treaty, in accordance with the EU referendum result on June 23rd last year. Seven months on, and the fate of EU nationals living and working in the UK, as well as British nationals in other...
Read more

2016 was marked by a sharp rise in populist politics and has culminated in the UK vote to leave the EU and the election of Donald Trump in the US. In 2017, the French presidential election race has already been marred by a political scandal involving the right-wing candidate and presidential front-runner, François Fillon. He is...
Read more

In October 2016 the former UK premier Tony Blair wrote an opinion article in The New European newspaper. He appealed to the UK not to rush into Brexit without seriously taking into account the consequences of such a decision. Tony Blair compared Brexit with a house move. For the former prime minister, it is only...
Read more

An international arrest warrant has been ordered for the former Peruvian president Alejandro Toledo amidst allegations that he received up to $20m in bribes from the Brazilian construction giant Odebrecht. The former president would, in return, have granted a lucrative contract to build a transoceanic highway between Brazil and the Peruvian coast. Toledo would not...
Read more

The fact that Theresa May, the UK prime minister, made an unprecedented appearance in the House of Lords speaks volumes over her respect for parliamentary democracy. It is now patently clear that the EU referendum that took place on June 23rd 2016 was flawed ever since the former prime minister, David Cameron, promised the vote...
Read more

Ladies and gentlemen, it’s time once again for “Call My Bluff”. And here’s your host, Theresa May. Hello everybody, and welcome to this edition of “Call My Bluff”, a panel game in which three contestants give me a definition of a political word that I have never heard of. I must guess the true...
Read more

The title of this post paraphrases something Margaret Thatcher said during the 1980 Conservative Party Conference. Having been asked on several occasions by the media whether she would perform a U-turn concerning her economic and social policies, she had always replied that she wasn’t one to change her mind. At the conference she spoke a...
Read more

Books will soon be obsolete in schools. Scholars will soon be instructed through the eye. It is possible to teach every branch of human knowledge with the motion picture. Our school system will be completely changed in ten years. – Thomas Edison – 1913 You’ve got to give Thomas Edison credit for his vision. Of...
Read more

Sometimes by pure accident you read about an act of violence in the news, that fills you with such disgust and hate for the perpetrators that you just feel like shouting your anger to the world. Today, quite by chance, I came across this news story from the Dutch television news website. The act of...
Read more

In prohibiting entry to two senior Turkish politicians, the Netherlands has sparked a serious dispute with Turkey. The decision not to allow Turkish politics to be officially expressed on Dutch soil can only be justified if the decision to do so is based on moral principles that can be as universally applied as possible, and...
Read more

The result of the Dutch parliamentary elections, that took place on Wednesday 15th March, is a victory for the current prime minister, Mark Rutte. Although his party, the VVD, remain the largest political party in the Netherlands despite losing 8 parliamentary seats, Mark Rutte may face difficulties in forming a working coalition. It is probable...
Read more

March 29th 2017 will be remembered as the day the UK officially triggered Article 50 of the European Constitution, signifying a two year slog to disentangle itself from the European Union. I have no intention of browsing the glorifying headlines on the front pages of the UK tabloids. I’ll let the Brexiteers rejoice in their...
Read more

Together we stand, and together we wait And there was I, thinking that we were utterly alone in our battle as UK expats, to avoid being cast into oblivion by the forces of evil from both sides of the channel. It now appears that an entire dependency is about to suffer the same fate as...
Read more

It rains on the roof, like it rains on the stairs My grandmother’s house was no ordinary house. It was a mountain chalet on the outskirts of Nice, in the South of France. The colour of its turquoise entrance to the garden, and ochre yellow walls, had nothing to do with turquoise, and even less...
Read more

The British Press: Responsible but not guilty? When the offices of the French satirical journal Charlie Hebdo were gruesomely attacked in January 2015, the world was shocked, and rightly so. The attack focused on the press, one of the most sacred institutions of our democracies. The terrorists also challenged something that most of us...
Read more

I’ll be honest with you. Before writing this post, I had no idea what a “LGBT person” actually was. “In what sort of world is this guy living?”, I hear you ask. Well, I live in the same world as you, but the meaning of this dreadful label that has been tagged on the shoulders...
Read more

Mes enfants, it’s fast approaching squeaky bum time in France, with the first round of the 2017 presidential election due on the 23rd April. The political situation in France is, as I see it, similar to that of 2002, when far-right candidate Jean-Marie Le Pen, father of present-day Marine, reached the second round to everybody’s...
Read more

If I talked to you about a country that just had a dubiously run referendum, the result of which was so close, as to be invalid for such a huge constitutional change, you would probably be thinking of Turkey. If I then told you that the leader of this country will organise elections with the...
Read more

A series of short posts highlighting interesting points arising during the final countdown to the French presidential election. (I) – Storm in a “Whirlpool” It’s what we call “l’entre deux tours” (between the two rounds) of the French presidential election. And I can just sit back behind my computer and relax. All I...
Read more

Plato And Jeremy Corbyn: “Whose Idea Was This Anyway?” With the June election rapidly approaching, I’m going to dedicate a post to the current leader of the Labour Party, Jeremy Corbyn. I know that my views don’t matter one iota, and, what’s more, I cannot even vote. Well, that should make you listen...
Read more

(II) Marine Le Pen’s Splitting Headache Over Europe The situation at the Whirlpool plant, situated in the northern town of Amiens, underscores the nature of the combat between Marine Le Pen and Emmanuel Macron. The fact that the American owners want to relocate the plant in Poland, is, for Le Pen, the epitome of...
Read more

(III) Evolution And Decomposition Of French Politics The fact that there is no Republican candidate in the second round of the French presidential elections, coupled with the disintegration of the French socialists, underscores the fact that the French political landscape has undergone a seismic shift, for the first time in the long history of...
Read more

(IV) Emmanuel Macron’s Late Night Out Up to now, compared to Marine Le Pen, I’ve been quite nice to Emmanuel Macron. Well, one thing’s for sure: nobody’s perfect I was fortunate enough to attend the Euro 2000 football championship final between Italy and France, that took place in Rotterdam. I was standing in the midst...
Read more

Joan of Arc, having liberated France from English occupation in the 15th century, has become a symbol of ultra-nationalism expressed by the French National Front Party. The Little Prince, written by Antoine de Saint-Exupéry, is a poetic tale, in which a pilot stranded in the desert meets a young prince fallen to Earth from a...
Read more

From time to time, there is such a build-up to a mid-week football match, that you cannot wait for the Wednesday night. The build-up to this week’s French presidential debate promised a night of high drama, philosophical insights and antipodal ideologies. Instead, I was forced to watch the debate on my iPad, my son having...
Read more