Everyone in the room was hyped to have Bates in the house. The crowd was chanting her name way before the battle even began. So it was beyond satisfying when the 69-year-old actress knocked us back by rapping Naughty by Nature’s “Hip Hop Hooray.”

After her performance, Chrissy Teigen said, “I don’t think I could’ve ever called that for a million dollars.” When host LL Cool J asked Bates, “On your bucket list of things to accomplish in your career, how high was performing ‘Hip Hop Hooray’ on Lip Sync Battle?” Bates responded, “You know it was an unexpected pleasure. I didn’t even know it was in my bucket list, and I’ve been digging through my bucket list, and there it is. It’s like a diamond, and I’m like ‘Oh my god!'”

As for Bates’s opponent, Bell tried to get on Teigen’s good side when he performed John Legend’s “Green Light,” which had Teigen responding, “Very smart! Tone, I am not a voter, but John is in South Africa right now, and you might just do. That was amazing.” And even though Bell really got the party going with his second performance of Eddie Murphy’s “Party All the Time,” Bates’s performance of Bruno Mars’s “That’s What I Like” was pure 24K magic. Even Tiegen shared that it was her new favorite LSB moment, and Bates exclaimed, “Oh my God, I love me some Bruno. I really do. I gotta tell you, I love that guy. I want to go to his concert. Do you think, maybe, he’ll let me come and see his concert?”

In the end, Bates won, but we weren’t the ones surprised. It was Bates, who admitted that she didn’t know she would be receiving a commemorative belt. “I don’t even know what to say. Seriously. Because I didn’t know this was part of it. And this feels really good.”