Jimmy Carter: Reagan only won in 1980 because of the third-party candidate

posted at 8:02 pm on October 25, 2010 by Allahpundit

He’s making a two-step argument here, I think, part of it based on pure conjecture. Step one: If not for Teddy Kennedy’s bitter primary challenge (which of course wasn’t a third-party candidacy), the Democratic Party would have been united for the general election. Instead, untold numbers stayed home, crippling Carter. Step two: If not for John Anderson running as an independent, Carter would have cleaned up among the Anderson base and swept to victory. There’s no way to flatly disprove him on step one since we can’t know how many Teddy fans boycotted the general, but on step two, have a look-see at this recap of the 1980 election. Reagan crushed Carter in the electoral college, 489/49; even if you cede every last Anderson vote to Carter, Reagan still would have won a clear majority of the popular vote with a margin close to three million. Among the individual states, a quickie glance at the numbers reveals that, in states taken by Reagan, Anderson won enough votes to have possibly influenced the outcome in Arkansas, Delaware, Illinois, Kentucky, Maine, Massachusetts, Michigan, New York, North Carolina, South Carolina, Tennessee, Vermont, and Wisconsin. That is to say, if all of Anderson’s voters in those states had broken for Carter, Carter would have won the states. (Anderson was, in fact, a liberal Republican who’d competed in the GOP primary, so no doubt plenty of his supporters would have broken for Reagan over Carter if forced to choose. But let’s keep this hypothetical.) It looks to me like all of those states combined would have given Carter another 170 or so electoral votes — meaning Reagan still would have crushed him by 100 EVs and been elected president comfortably. In which case … what is this guy talking about?

One thing he is right about, though: Why, per today’s New York magazine extravaganza on Palin’s path to the White House, would Mike Bloomberg ever consider running for president? He’d spend a billion dollars or more and would need a clear majority of 270 electoral votes to win, an utter impossibility with the left- and right-wing bases energized for Obama and Sarahcuda. If no candidate won 270 outright, the House of Representatives — which will almost certainly be controlled by the GOP, wink — would decide things, meaning Palin would win. Why on earth would a Democrat in independent’s clothing like Bloomy want to spend a 10-digit sum from his personal fortune to elect the major party candidate with whom he has the least in common politically? Does not compute. Click the image to watch.

Breaking on Hot Air

Blowback

Note from Hot Air management: This section is for comments from Hot Air's community of registered readers. Please don't assume that Hot Air management agrees with or otherwise endorses any particular comment just because we let it stand. A reminder: Anyone who fails to comply with our terms of use may lose their posting privilege.

Man, I can’t believe weyou all elected this idiot all over again in 2008.

Caiwyn on October 25, 2010 at 10:39 PM

I didn’t vote for him.
I suspect many who did were: not legal residents of their district, were illegal aliens, were dead,never existed as human beings.
And then there are the real voters who voted for BO-the insane, delusionary, down right stupid, dependent, retarded, and there may be some who were actually forced at gun point for all I know.

A very simple analysis based on converting electoral college votes with the popular vote (by state) and assuming that Jimmy Carter got ALL of the Indpendent votes only gives him an additional 156 EC votes. Not enough to win.

You lost badly, Mr. Carter. Man up, and own your defeat. Whining makes you look less presidential.

Thaaat’s Right, Jimbo. It Wasn’t Tingles Matthews, ‘Would ya’ like some Malaise on Your Crap Sammich America’ – Speech?
And it Wasn’t Your, Turn Down Your Thermostat!, Fireside Sweater Chat w/America Speech.
And it Wasn’t our 20% mortgage interest rates, or our Gas Lines, or The Misery Index.
And it Wasn’t 444 Days of an Iranian Hostage Crisis, or 4/24/80 and the Failed Operation Eagle Claw Rescue Mission either, which just so happened to Correspond w/my 15th Birthday, that broke Camel’s Back for Me Or My Parents!

No. It was John Anderson, who I had to be Reminded Of in the last couple of days (Hey! That’s Right! That Anderson dude Also Ran for President in 80′!).
Yes, He’s the one who has had Me voting Republican since 84! So you’re correct Again, Jimmy. It’s been John Anderson all Along! John Anderson, That Country singer or Politican guy. Whatever. Yeah, That’s him. It hasn’t been You, You Killer Rabbit-Fearing MORON! Nope. As You, were The Greatest! yeah, We Really “hearted” You!

It’s pretty obvious that Carter is suffering from some form of senility or age-related dementia. What we should be doing is protecting the public from the effects of this by screening all public officials and disallowing any of those affected from influencing public policy.

Actually, if only Carter wasn’t such a poor president people won’t have come out of the wood-work to run against him. The truth is that when you have a weak president people will start to figure it’s now or never as far as their chance at the presidency. It’s all his own fault. Sorry Jimmie.