News Item

04/22/2014

by Virginia Hughes

My headline may be a bit misleading. Albert Einstein, the Nobel prize-winning physicist who gave the world the theory of relativity, E = mc2, and the law of the photoelectric effect, obviously had a special brain. So special that when he died in Princeton Hospital, on April 17, 1955, the pathologist on call, Thomas Harvey, stole it.

Einstein didn’t want his brain or body to be studied; he didn’t want to be worshipped. “He had left behind specific instructions regarding his remains: cremate them, and scatter the ashes secretly in order to discourage idolaters,” writes Brian Burrell in his 2005 book, Postcards from the Brain Museum.

But Harvey took the brain anyway, without permission from Einstein or his family. “When the fact came to light a few days later, Harvey managed to solicit a reluctant and retroactive blessing from Einstein’s son, Hans Albert, with the now-familiar stipulation that any investigation would be conducted solely in the interest of science,” Burrell writes.

Harvey soon lost his job at the Princeton hospital and took the brain to Philadelphia, where it was carved into 240 pieces and preserved in celloidin, a hard and rubbery form of cellulose. He divvied up the pieces into two jars and stored them in his basement.

Just when you think this story can’t get any weirder, it does. As Burrell explains (emphasis mine):

After [Harvey's] wife threatened to dispose of the brain, he returned to retrieve it and took it with him to the Midwest. For a time he worked as a medical supervisor in a biological testing lab in Wichita, Kansas, keeping the brain in a cider box stashed under a beer cooler. He moved again, to Weston, Missouri, and practiced medicine while trying to study the brain in his spare time, only to lose his medical license in 1988 after failing a three-day competency exam. He then relocated to Lawrence, Kansas, took an assembly-line job in a plastic-extrusion factory, moved into a second-floor apartment next to a gas station, and befriended a neighbor, the beat poet William Burroughs. The two men routinely met for drinks on Burroughs’s front porch. Harvey would tell stories about the brain, about cutting off chunks to send to researchers around the world. Burroughs, in turn, would boast to visitors that he could have a piece of Einstein any time he wanted.

(I know, right?!)

To fast forward a bit: Come 1985, Harvey and collaborators in California published the first study of Einstein’s brain, claiming that it had an abnormal proportion of two types of cells, neurons and glia. That study was followed by five others (the most recent published just this month), reporting additional differences in individual cells or in particular structures in Einstein’s brain. The researchers behind these studies say studying Einstein’s brain could help uncover the neurological underpinnings of intelligence.

But that premise is nonsense and the studies are bunk, at least according to Terence Hines, a professor of psychology at Pace University.

A couple of weeks ago, Hines presented a poster at the Cognitive Neuroscience Society annual meeting outlining all of the ways in which each of the six studies is flawed. Some highlights:

–In the original 1985 report, Harvey and his collaborators found that inBrodmann Area 39 — a region where the temporal, parietal, and occipital lobes meet — Einstein’s neuron-to-glia ratio was significantly smaller than it was in the same area in 11 control brains. But the control group was not all that well controlled: the brains came from people age 47 to 80 years old, whereas Einstein died at age 76. The controls brains were also fresh, whereas Einstein’s had been languishing in basements and beer coolers for three decades. Perhaps most problematic, counting cells is a subjective business, and the researchers performing the cell counts were not blind to which tissue was Einstein’s and which was not.

–In 1996, Harvey partnered with a scientist from Alabama and counted neurons in Einstein’s Brodmann Area 9 — part of the frontal cortex — as well as those of five controls. There were no differences in the number of neurons or the size of neurons, the study found, but Einstein’s tissue was thinner than controls. More densely packed neurons, the authors speculated, means that cell-to-cell messages travel shorter differences, which might mean faster processing speed overall. That’s quite a stretch. As Hines calls out in his poster, the finding was based on just one square millimeter of Einstein’s brain. What’s more, the authors admit to not reporting any of the ways in which Einstein’s brain was similar to controls.

–In 1999, Harvey and Canadian collaborators got Einstein’s brain into one of the world’s most prestigious medical journals, The Lancet. Based on old photographs that had been taken of Einstein’s brain before it was cut up, the researchers claimed that Einstein had an abnormal folding pattern in part of his parietal lobe, a region that has been linked to mathematical ability. They also reported that his parietal lobes were 15 percent wider, and more symmetrical, than those of control brains. Once again, though, the researchers were not blinded to which photographs showed Einstein’s brain. And though the authors were quick to make links between these supposed differences and Einstein’s mathematical prowess, Hines points out that Einstein wasn’t, in fact, a great mathematician.

The underlying problem in all of the studies is that they set out to compare a category made up of one person, an N of 1, with a nebulous category of “not this person” and an N of more than 1. With an N of 1, it’s extremely difficult to calculate the statistical variance — the likelihood that, for example, Einstein’s low neuron-to-glia ratio is real and not just a fluke of that particular region and those particular methods. Even if the statistics were sound, you’d still have the problem of attributing skills and behaviors to anatomy. There’s no way to know if X thing in Einstein’s brain made Einstein smart/dyslexic/good at math/you name it, or was just an X thing in his brain.

It makes me angry to think of all that was wasted in these investigations. There was the monetary cost of the studies — money that could have been spent on work that was not doomed from the outset to fail. There was a personal cost, in that Einstein’s family was essentially strong-armed into agreeing to participate in research that Einstein explicitly did not want to participate in. And there was a public cost, too. In popular-press accounts of these studies over the years, the public was misled about the findings and their supposed scientific value.

I’ve made this error, too, by the way. In 2012 I wrote an uncritical, cringe-worthy report on preliminary data from a neuroscience conferencecomparing brain images of Temple Grandin, one of the most famous people with autism, with those of three controls. The researchers claimed to find several distinctive features in Grandin’s brain that could explain her exceptional nonverbal intelligence and her way of thinking in pictures.

Here’s how smart Einstein was — he understood all too well the public’s obsession with him, our obsession with celebrity and special-ness. He knew that if given the chance, scientists would pore over his brain’s neurons and glia, sulci and gyri, and make grand pronouncements about what makes a genius. And he knew it would be bullshit.

News

Pace Enviro Clinic Fights for the Hudson

News

A Pace Environmental Policy Clinic study found that the Coast Guard blocked public access to information in the Hudson Anchorage controversy and students are petitioning the agency to withdraw their proposal to create 43 anchorages for oil barges on the Hudson.

Explore a Program

Master of Public Administration (MPA)

Explore a Program

Pace's Master of Public Administration (MPA) will prepare you with the in-depth knowledge of policy, analytical skills, and management expertise to succeed in some of the fastest growing fields in the nation: government, health care, and nonprofit management.

Admission

Transfer Tuesdays

Admission

Thinking about transferring to Pace? Bring your application and supporting documents to accelerated admission days on select Tuesdays (January 10 | March 14 and 18) and we will waive your application fee and provide you with a same-day decision.

News

A Peek Inside Pace Magazine

News

From a new era at Pace to a new generation poised to change the world, this issue of Pace Magazine introduces you to the environmental pioneers, documentary filmmakers, alumni mentors, cybersecurity experts, and Generation Z making an impact at Pace and beyond.

Event

An Evening with Tom Rush: December 9

Event

On Friday, December 9, folk legend Tom Rush, who left his stamp on generations of artists including James Taylor and Garth Brooks, takes the Schimmel stage alongside internationally touring singer Matt Nakoa and Grammy-nominated Seth Glier.

Student Success

Making His Marc in Management

Student Success

During his time at Pace, Marc Rinosa ’17 has challenged the conventions of the business world, led the Student Government Association as Executive President, and has strived to establish recruitment channels for diverse and under-represented students on campus.

News

Student and Faculty at the United Nations

News

“Education can help empower the greater participation of youth, women, survivors of violence, and people from the Global South in peace and security policymaking,” said Rachel Salcedo '17 at the UN. Professor Emily Welty, PhD, also delivered a speech on nuclear weapons.

News

Pace Opens First NYC Design Factory

News

Pace opened the first-ever Design Factory Global Network (DFGN) institute in NYC, only the second DFGN hub in the United States and the eleventh in the world. This collaboration connects Pace students with companies all over the world to provide creative solutions to real, design-based problems.

Virtual Tour

A Peek Inside the Pleasantville Campus

Virtual Tour

A close-knit collegiate campus lifestyle with access to all the dynamic professional and cultural opportunities in the New York metro area. Pace's newly revitalized, 200-acre Pleasantville Campus gives students the best of both worlds. Take a virtual tour right now!

News

PIX11 Features Pace Student Veterans

News

As part of a series featuring Pace student veterans, PIX11 interviewed U.S. Army Reservist Jonathan Rosario, who is currently pursuing a degree in IT and cybersecurity with 100% tuition coverage through the Post-9/11 GI Bill and getting help for his PTSD at Pace.

News

Among the Top 25 Drama Schools

News

Both the Pace School of Performing Arts and The Actors Studio Drama School at Pace University made The Hollywood Reporter’s 2016 list of the 25 best undergraduate drama schools and 25 best drama schools for an MFA.

Video

Watch Pace's Documentary on Cuba

Video

Watch the Pace student-produced documentary "Cuba’s Crossroads–Hope, Rock, and [R]Evolution”, which premiered at the Jacob Burns Film Center and was featured on the New York Times "Dot Earth" blog and WABC-TV's Tiempo.

News

The Elisabeth Haub School of Law

News

The Elisabeth Haub School of Law at Pace University celebrated its renaming at a community event on May 13. The Haub family's gift, the largest in Pace history, will establish an endowment, strengthen our premier environmental law program, and fund teaching initiatives.

Award

A Princeton Review "Best in the Northeast"

Award

Pace University has been named a “Best in the Northeast” institution by the Princeton Review. Part of the "2016 Best Colleges: Region by Region," the Princeton Review rankings recognize only 25% of the nation's four-year colleges.

Video

Clinicals at Pace University

Video

"The best and the brightest" is how one Chief Nursing Officer describes Pace's Lienhard School of Nursing students. Hear students, hospital executives, and alumni describe their clinical experiences through Lienhard at hospitals in the New York metro area.

Academics

Pace Undergraduate Majors at a Glance

Academics

undergraduate majors and combined degree programs. From acting to arts and entertainment management, forensic science to health science, explore your interests and talents and choose a degree that's right for you.