Trouble logging in?We were forced to invalidate all account passwords. You will have to reset your password to login. If you have trouble resetting your password, please send us a message with as much helpful information as possible, such as your username and any email addresses you may have used to register. Whatever you do, please do not create a new account. That is not the right solution, and it is against our forum rules to own multiple accounts.

I agree, I liked Rewrite's style. Admittedly, usual Maeda nakige don't really succeed in making me all that sad, with the exception of some scenes

Spoiler for LB Refrain:

Namely, the three bros saying the last farewell to Riki. For instance, I still don't really know if Kudryavka's route was supposed to make me feel for her, because I don't even know what the hell actually happened after she went back home

and I really enjoyed Rewrite, albeit fairly flawed in its execution.

Maeda Jun didn't write Kud's route. He only worked in common route, Rin route and Refrain.

I guess the answer to that depends on how happy you want the ending to be.

Spoiler for Terra:

Personally I like to think that they're aspects of the same being somehow... anything else is a bit too depressing.

Spoiler for Terra:

Considering "Key" is born from the planet, I'm thinking of Aurora being something like an existence with "Consciousness" itself and both Kagari can share thoughts through Aurora. Otherwise, you will have to feel pity for Terra-Kagari

So here is my next thought, does Moon-Kagari manage to leave Moon during the end ?

I know they are planning to travel to deep space for exploration, but if the theory that each Kagari is stuck on their own origin planet/star then they need to make Moon as home base somehow (I'd really hate to use the term of "Forever Alone" here)

I know they are planning to travel to deep space for exploration, but if the theory that each Kagari is stuck on their own origin planet/star then they need to make Moon as home base somehow (I'd really hate to use the term of "Forever Alone" here)

Spoiler for Terra:

Well, if the Aurora does have a consciousness of some kind then they'll be bringing Kagari with them wherever they go, right?

I wonder if that person who created that "Key Medley" video got it in his/her mind to update it to include Rewrite/Harvest Festa. Unless it already got an update that I'm not aware of...?

For those unaware, it's a nico video showcasing the main themes from every Key game starting from Kanon down to Kud Wafter (barring Planetarian) which also includes the anime versions of Clannad. I felt it was a nice compilation as a fan, and I was kind of hoping it would've been updated for Rewrite when I finished it back in '11.

About Kagari, I believe "it" is exactly how the game wrote it to be.

Spoiler for Rewrite:

I see her as just some all-encompassing phenomenon given human form. So one questions if Kotarou was just fooled by the outer appearances or something. Then again, the "love story" of the Moon Kagari and Kotarou has the latter being somewhat of a bizarre phenomenon himself, so it might fit.

I always assume Moon Kagari receives all info gained from the Key. Or at least Earth Kagari merged with Kotarou.
EDIT: In Oppai ending, Kagari said she can travel to other planet. Though I am not sure how much trustworthy Oppai ending is.

At first I can't consider Earth Kagari same as Moon Kagari since they seems have different personality.
But once I reread Moon, they are actually quite similar. Both are extremely focused on their job, have short patience for interferences, and get noticeably depressed if they are stuck.
The only difference is Moon-Kagari never talks.

I wonder if that person who created that "Key Medley" video got it in his/her mind to update it to include Rewrite/Harvest Festa. Unless it already got an update that I'm not aware of...?

For those unaware, it's a nico video showcasing the main themes from every Key game starting from Kanon down to Kud Wafter (barring Planetarian) which also includes the anime versions of Clannad. I felt it was a nice compilation as a fan, and I was kind of hoping it would've been updated for Rewrite when I finished it back in '11.

So one questions if Kotarou was just fooled by the outer appearances or something.

Spoiler for Moon/Terra:

Well, it's not as though she doesn't have a (rather silly) personality on top of that, you know? She's fairly human, considering what she is.

Quote:

Originally Posted by galdr

Spoiler for Terra:

But once I reread Moon, they are actually quite similar. Both are extremely focused on their job, have short patience for interferences, and get noticeably depressed if they are stuck.
The only difference is Moon-Kagari never talks.

Spoiler for Moon/Terra:

You get that glimpse of her personality when Kotarou is trying to access the, uh, database, as well.

I know some of this information was in the game, but here's my questions.
1. Why does the Key act differently in different routes? In Kotori's route she seems to have the most humanity (and she lets Kotarou get close) but in others she's just a brick.
2. In non-Terra routes, Kotori and Kotarou are "child-hood friends", yet nothing about their interactions in Terra indicated they were friends. Kotarou was quite unfriendly (even if he did save Pero). Are we to assume that Kotori subconsciously overwrote him since he was her familiar? Or did they just quickly make friends after he woke up without memories?
3. What was the whole story with Gil and Pani? Were they just the final results from the Gaia lab with Chihaya's parents (that had a sense of self)?
4. Why can the Earth Dragon talk in Terra but not Akane's route? You'd think if he could talk in Akane's route, he would, if only to laugh at Kotarou desperately trying to attack him. Also, the Terra fight sucked ._.
5. Are we to assume that Kotarou rewrote himself way more in Terra then other routes? In the other routes he hardly had any penalty for rewriting (except for Chihaya's, but that was moreso because he was rewriting his mind, but wasn't dying), but vomited in Terra. Was this because he was part-familiar in other routes?
6. Was Kotarou being controlled at all (non-Terra), since Kotori was able to make him forget about her in both her route and others (Yoshino yells at him in multiple routes about Kotori, but he really doesn't go to any great attempts to find her)
7. What was up with Yoshino? In one route Kotarou sneaks into the club room investigates school files on student, and along with Kotarou, Yoshino was a type "E" or something (what I thought was foreshadowing that he was superhuman). Was that just a red herring? Yoshino hardly did anything in Terra. How did he even end up in the hospital?

I really liked Rewrite, even though the true ending didn't have quite the impact that Refrain did. However, Sakuya makes up for it.

I know some of this information was in the game, but here's my questions.
1. Why does the Key act differently in different routes? In Kotori's route she seems to have the most humanity (and she lets Kotarou get close) but in others she's just a brick.

Spoiler for Rewrite:

Multiple writers who don't communicate, mostly, but it's also because in Kotori's route she's interacting more with multiple humans.

Quote:

Originally Posted by bromanbro

Spoiler for Rewrite Spoilers:

2. In non-Terra routes, Kotori and Kotarou are "child-hood friends", yet nothing about their interactions in Terra indicated they were friends. Kotarou was quite unfriendly (even if he did save Pero). Are we to assume that Kotori subconsciously overwrote him since he was her familiar? Or did they just quickly make friends after he woke up without memories?

Spoiler for Rewrite:

Notice that Kotori herself never once remarks on the actual status of their relationship (outside of denying that they're lovers). Kotarou simply assumed that they were childhood friends, because he only remembered her as an elementary-schooler and because he had been convinced that they were the same age.
If you haven't seen the bad end in Terra I suggest you do, it explains a bit more about that.

Quote:

Originally Posted by bromanbro

Spoiler for Rewrite Spoilers:

3. What was the whole story with Gil and Pani? Were they just the final results from the Gaia lab with Chihaya's parents (that had a sense of self)?

Spoiler for Rewrite:

They're "familiars formed from garbage and the memories of the scientists". Yes, I know it doesn't make much sense, but they're Tonokawa characters, so...

Quote:

Originally Posted by bromanbro

Spoiler for Rewrite Spoilers:

4. Why can the Earth Dragon talk in Terra but not Akane's route? You'd think if he could talk in Akane's route, he would, if only to laugh at Kotarou desperately trying to attack him. Also, the Terra fight sucked ._.

Spoiler for Rewrite:

Yeah, I never got this either. My thoughts are that it was originally intended to be a familiar far more powerful than the Earth Dragon but they ran out of budgeting for CGs or something.
That's probably also why the fight sucked.

Quote:

Originally Posted by bromanbro

Spoiler for Rewrite Spoilers:

5. Are we to assume that Kotarou rewrote himself way more in Terra then other routes? In the other routes he hardly had any penalty for rewriting (except for Chihaya's, but that was moreso because he was rewriting his mind, but wasn't dying), but vomited in Terra. Was this because he was part-familiar in other routes?

Spoiler for Rewrite:

Kotarou is drawing his power from the Aurora embedded in his right arm in all the other routes; only in Terra is he using his own life energy.

Quote:

Originally Posted by bromanbro

Spoiler for Rewrite Spoilers:

6. Was Kotarou being controlled at all (non-Terra), since Kotori was able to make him forget about her in both her route and others (Yoshino yells at him in multiple routes about Kotori, but he really doesn't go to any great attempts to find her)

7. What was up with Yoshino? In one route Kotarou sneaks into the club room investigates school files on student, and along with Kotarou, Yoshino was a type "E" or something (what I thought was foreshadowing that he was superhuman). Was that just a red herring? Yoshino hardly did anything in Terra. How did he even end up in the hospital?

Spoiler for Rewrite:

Yoshino is a perfectly ordinary human. He is, however, probably aware of how old Kotarou actually is.

Multiple writers who don't communicate, mostly, but it's also because in Kotori's route she's interacting more with multiple humans.

Spoiler for Rewrite:

Notice that Kotori herself never once remarks on the actual status of their relationship (outside of denying that they're lovers). Kotarou simply assumed that they were childhood friends, because he only remembered her as an elementary-schooler and because he had been convinced that they were the same age.
If you haven't seen the bad end in Terra I suggest you do, it explains a bit more about that.

Spoiler for Rewrite:

They're "familiars formed from garbage and the memories of the scientists". Yes, I know it doesn't make much sense, but they're Tonokawa characters, so...

Spoiler for Rewrite:

Yeah, I never got this either. My thoughts are that it was originally intended to be a familiar far more powerful than the Earth Dragon but they ran out of budgeting for CGs or something.
That's probably also why the fight sucked.

Spoiler for Rewrite:

Kotarou is drawing his power from the Aurora embedded in his right arm in all the other routes; only in Terra is he using his own life energy.

Yoshino is a perfectly ordinary human. He is, however, probably aware of how old Kotarou actually is.

Thanks
Couple more questions.....

Spoiler for Rewrite Spoilers:

1. What was the deal with Midou? Was he related to those kids that Kotarou saves in Terra? Even if he was, why does he only appear in Chihaya's route? You'd think that if Kotarou was so important that Midou would show up in other Gaia routes as well.
2. In the moon route, none of the girls could see Kagari, even though Kotori and Akane can see her in other routes (Kotori in her own route, Akane in Chihaya's route when she captures Kagari by herself).

1. What was the deal with Midou? Was he related to those kids that Kotarou saves in Terra? Even if he was, why does he only appear in Chihaya's route? You'd think that if Kotarou was so important that Midou would show up in other Gaia routes as well.
2. In the moon route, none of the girls could see Kagari, even though Kotori and Akane can see her in other routes (Kotori in her own route, Akane in Chihaya's route when she captures Kagari by herself).

Spoiler for Rewrite:

1. I really don't think that the other writers liked Midou very much. 2. Kotori's connection to Moon-Kagari is probably a lot less than to Earth-Kagari, and Akane being able to see Kagari in the first place is probably yet another plot hole created by multiple writers.

2. In the moon route, none of the girls could see Kagari, even though Kotori and Akane can see her in other routes (Kotori in her own route, Akane in Chihaya's route when she captures Kagari by herself).

Spoiler for Answer:

One can say that in order to see Moon-Kagari in Moon route, you need to establish a strong connection with her first.

This also lead to another question though. Does the girls able to see Moon-Kagari after the ending ?