Thursday, 26 March 2015

NHS campaigners wrote to three East London MPs yesterday urging them to support the call for Barts Trust’s PFI debt to be written off.

Local campaign group Waltham Forest Save Our NHS is calling on Leyton and Wansted Labour MP John Cryer, Walthamstow Labour MP Stella Creasy and Chingford Tory MP Iain Duncan Smith “to work together” to remove the hospital trust’s debt burden.
Barts Trust was recently put under special measures by the government after a damning Care Quality Commission report about care at Whipps Cross hospital, one of the six London hospitals under its management.
The Trust’s PFI debt, standing at £93 million, is the largest in the country and costs £2m a week to service.
“The PFI costs are unmanageable, unreasonable and growing,” says the letter, which points out that £58m of cuts made by Barts Trust last year were due to the need to save money because of PFI.
“In a vain attempt to save money, Barts management enforced mass redundancies and a demoralising down-banding of staff, which led to the disastrous consequences detailed in the CQC report.”
The campaign group warned that instead of a much-needed increase of funding local health services have been told to make an 11 per cent cut over the next five years.
“It is clear that services are being sacrificed on the altar of PFI and that PFI costs must be annulled to safeguard the health of the local community,” the group added.
“As our elected representatives it is incumbent upon each of you to work together to restore NHS services to your constituents, the people who pay not only for the NHS, but for you to properly represent our interests.”

Monday, 23 March 2015

Premium bonds are more secure, lottery tickets more likely to generate a return, so why did 973 investors put their money into Secured Energy Bonds?

Investing in sustainable energy bonds is a highly risky savings strategy, the market is unregulated, the Financial Conduct Authority takes no responsibility for anything that happens there and investors should be fully prepared to lose all their capital.

This is the sort of warning that should have been carried on Secured Energy Bonds when they were launched a couple of years ago.

The energy bonds were advertised in the financial press, offering 6.5% on cash invested for three years.

The investment looked good and secure. The company Secured Energy Bonds plc was a separate UK incorporated body, which would use the £7.5 million raised to buy solar panels to put on schools. The investors would receive their 6.5% return over three years in the main from the feed in tariff payments on energy generated.

All good so far, the investor’s money was safe because even if some problem arose with the company, the assets (ie the panels on the schools) would still be there raising revenue.

Investors, no doubt keen to do their bit for the environment and get some sort of return from their money, quickly provided the £7.5 million required for the bond.

All went well for the first months of the bond, interest was paid on the quarter, there was even an early bird payment for those who got in early.

This all changed in January, when the fourth interest payment was not made. The hazard warning lights came on. There was no response to emails sent to the company, the phone line was dead. A call to Capita, which dealt with the interest payments, confirmed that interest payments had been suspended.

A bit more digging round the internet revealed that the Australian parent company, CBD Energy, had gone into administration. But no worries surely the UK incorporated Secured Energy Bonds was separate – the assets must remain untouched – all £7.5 million of them.

I contacted the Financial Conduct Authority which effectively said nothing to do with us mate, try the trustee Independent Portfolio Managers.

IPM were the “security trustee” charged with overseeing investors interests. Initially, phone and email messages went unanswered before finally IPM confirmed that SEB had been put into administration. Grant Thornton have been appointed administrators. The investors remain in the dark, as to what is happening – other than be prepared to lose your money.

The loss for 973 plus investors has implications going far beyond the Secured Energy Bonds saga. The main concern for other players in the sustainable energy bond sector is that investors will be put off this unregulated market entirely.

Trillion Fund, a crowd financing platform for renewable energy projects, sent out a press release following the initial news about SEB declaring: “Trillion Fund listed Secured Energy Bonds on our web directory in 2013, alongside other opportunities to lend to or invest in renewable energy projects, which referred interested lenders to Capita.

“Investment carries risks that you may lose your capital, and this is incredibly disappointing to those who backed the project. “Not all renewable energy investments are created equal. Some projects are more risky than others and Trillion strongly encourages investors to ensure they have a well diversified portfolio.

“We take great care to make sure potential investors understand all of the risks involved. For example, that projects that are yet to be developed are more risky than those that are operational.”

So there is clearly concern in the sector about the damage that the SEB episode is doing to the confidence of investors.

For the 900 plus investors in Secured Energy Bonds, such warnings are too late. They now need to wait to hear from Grant Thornton in Australia.

In January, finance website This is Money quoted the administrators as saying: “During 2014, CBD utilised funds of Secured Energy Bonds plc, a UK subsidiary, which were segregated and should have only been used for the purposes outlined in the bond-raising prospectus, which precluded working capital funding of CBD.

“However, due to CBD’s cashflow difficulties $8.4m [AUD] was transferred to CBD over time, via various inter-company loans to fund outstanding creditor payments and working capital requirements.”

If this is the case, there will be many questions to answer.

The IPM will in particular have some explaining to do as to what they were actually doing to protect investor’s interests. What were they doing to monitor where the funds were going and whether they were actually being used to buy solar panels on schools in the UK?

The FCA should also be asking questions, as IPM – an FCA-regulated company - was supposed to ensure that investors’ interests were protected. The simple shrug of the shoulders approach really will not suffice.

The comments made that it was always a risky investment and that capital could be lost really does not wash. On paper this was not a risky investment, if the company concerned did what it said it intended to do with the money raised. The investment was not even as risky as buying shares, the investment should not go down – let alone disappear altogether.

There are many questions that need answering. The 900 plus investors want to know when they are going to get their money back. Platforms like Trillion and Abundance Generation should be as concerned for those investors as their own given that the way in which this is resolved will
have serious implications for the whole of the privately backed sustainable energy market.

* A creditors meeting for Secured Energy Bonds has been called by Grant Thornton for 1 April 2015

Friday, 20 March 2015

The recent survey conducted by Leeds Justice and Peace
Commission uncovered the huge scale of food poverty, with the Catholic Church
at the forefront of the fight to feed people.

The survey found that more than 50% of the 88 parishes in
the Leeds diocese were actively involved in feeding people. There is also much
church involvement with a number of foodbanks in the Hallam diocese, covering
South Yorkshire.

The Leeds diocese though would seem to be just a
microcosm of what is going on in terms of the Catholic Church confronting food
poverty across Britain.

Take the
Archdiocese of Birmingham, where there are foodbanks operating out of 60
churches in 223 parishes.

At the Manchester Catholic chaplaincy foodbank, they are
finding that the implementation of benefit sanctions are one reason why more
people are coming to the foodbank. “It seems that a
dislocation from the family unit leads them with nowhere to turn to,” said
Father Tim Byron SJ, chaplain and chair of trustees at the foodbank. “We
also see that many, perhaps not surprisingly, are suffering from mental health
issues (temporarily or more long term it is difficult to assess). This
means that they vulnerable when it comes to engaging with bureaucracy and
perhaps don't have the resilience to follow some of the endless procedures they
are confronted with. They can be penalised for being for a few minutes
late for an interview or for not making enough job applications in a week (this
can be an unreasonable number).”

The Manchester foodbank has also seen an
increase in the numbers of students actually coming for food. The vouchers are
given out by the advice centres in the student unions at the Univerisy of
Manchester and Manchester Metropolitan University. There has been a particular
problem with students on professional courses for things like nursing, which
have placements and so cannot hold down a part time job to help make ends meet.
“They can’t get by without supplementing their income,” said Father Byron.

On the south coast, the Catholic churches support the
local foodbank in Eastbourne. More than 20,000 people have visited the foodbank
since it opened in June 2011.

One of the most startling
findings of the Leeds research was that the Church backed network, the Trussell
Trust, only represent part of the food poverty picture. “Half of those
responding had provided food to the Trussell Trust foodbank but half as many
again give food through the SVP,” says the report. Caritas Social Action
Network confirm that the Trussell Trust only account for around half of all
foodbanks. A research project conducted by the CSAN last year found that 21
CSAN members deliver food programmes, had cooked 153,465 meals in 27 separate
food projects

The Trussell Trust reports that in 2010, there were 54
foodbanks, today the number has increased to 423. Some 41,000 people went to
foodbanks n 2009/10, compared to 913,000 being given three days emergency
food and support last year (330,000 were children). Some 8,318 tonnes of
food was donated by the public in last 12 months. 30,000 people have
volunteered at foodbanks over the past year. 27,000 frontline care
professionals such as doctors or care workers have vouchers to issue for
foodbanks.

The Trussell Trust
statistics show that 45% of food bank referrals are due to benefit delays and
changes, including sanctions and 22% cite low income as the main trigger for
the crisis. “Substantial
numbers are needing help because of problems with the social security system
but what's new is that we're also seeing a marked rise in numbers of people
coming to us with 'low income' as the primary cause of their
crisis," said David McAuley,
chief executive of the Trussell Trust. “Incomes for the poorest have
not been increasing in line with inflation and many, whether in low paid work
or on welfare, are not yet seeing the benefits of economic recovery. Instead,
they are living on a financial knife edge where one small change in
circumstances or a ‘life shock’ can force them into a crisis where they cannot
afford to eat.”

Liz Firth, the development
worker at the church charity Wellsprings Togethr in Bradford, says that there
has been a massive increase in food poverty over the past 18 months. “We
are trying to map existing provision, get a sense of why people are needing
food, ensure the food projects have the means they need to provide their
service. We'd love to move the debate on from food banks and to look more to
seeing food banks as a necessary evil but not as a long-term solution. It's a
tricky balance to appreciate and value the service provided and the efforts of
those involved but there is no dignity in asking for food,” said Ms
Firth. “I worry that in Bradford we're still seeing those in need as people
worthy of help because we're Christians and we want to respond in love but
we're not really questioning why they are in that situation or if we are we're
blaming them rather than the system.”

Niall Cooper, director of
Church Action on Poverty, is concerned that foodbanks and food aid become
institutionalised, as has happened in Canada. They were introduced in
Canada in the early 1980s in what was perceived as a tough economic time. There are now 700 foodbanks,
providing help to 800,000 people. The number has increased by nearly 100,000
over the past six years – as the country has come out of economic recession.
There have been an abundance of low income jobs created as part of the economic
recovery. “Churches have done a fantastic job recently to meet
the need but we want to avoid what happened in the States and Canada, where
foodbanks were introduced as a stop gap and are still going strong today,” said
Mr Cooper. “The question is where we need to go to get to a position where we
don’t need foodbanks.”

A report, Feeding Britain,
compiled by the All Party Parliamentary Group on Hunger and Food Poverty, at
the end of last year, makes recommendations concerning changes to the
benefits system, to stop delays and the implementation of the living wage to
counter low pay. It’s third recommendation was to create a new generation of “super”
food banks. The new foodbanks would combine food aid with welfare advice and
advocacy. This network of foodbanks would bring together the existing players
with supermarkets and the state.

Chris Mould. Chief executive of Trussell
Trust, is disappointed that “the government has not responded in any practical
way” to the 77 recommendations made in Feeding Britain.

Mr Mould is happy to see the function of foodbanks
expand, so that they offer things like debt, benefits and budgets advice. He
does not though want to see local authorities or government taking over
foodbanks as such. “When asked, the churches across the country have stepped up
to help neighbours in trouble,” said Mr Mould, who stresses foodbanks are
support not a substitute for public services. “I do not believe that access to
basic help should be discretionary. A modern wealthy country like the UK should
have public (welfare) services available – we are not a substitute for the
welfare state."

Former
Leeds West MP, John Battle, believes that the real issue is low pay, with the
rich getting richer and the poor poorer. “This cannot be allowed to go on, with
the poor effectively being left to pick up the scraps from the rich man’s
table,” said Mr Battle, who insisted that the implementation of a living wage
and maintaining of the welfare state is the direction in which things should be
heading

Tuesday, 17 March 2015

Barts Trust came under growing pressure at the east London employment tribunal over its failure to produce documents backing up its claims against sacked trade union rep Charlotte Monro.

Twice during proceedings at the Anchorage House based tribunal, Judge Jonathan Ferris asked why the legal team were unable to produce key documents.

The first instance came in relation to a disciplinary charge against Ms Monro over what was claimed to be a breach of confidentiality regarding staff matters. “We didn’t consider the contents of the consultation evidence confidential,” said Ms Monro, under pressured questioning from the Barts Trust barristerNadia Motraghi.

Judge Ferris intervened to state that the tribunal could do with seeing the consultation document which had gone missing.

The judge also pulled up Ms Motraghi over what he considered to be a “bludgeoning” of Ms Monro.

The second missing document concerned a listing of Ms Monro’s convictions back in the 1970s. The convictions had been one of the grounds for Ms Monro’s original dismissal.

Ms Monro had failed to declare the convictions when she first applied and obtained her job at Whipps Cross hospital in 1987.

It was when Ms Monro was asked to complete a CRB check in March 2013 to reveal any convictions that she openly went to her line manager explaining the situation.

She was assured that it was clear she was no risk to patients or public and as the convictions were so long ago it was unlikely to be a problem, but advice would be sought about process.

She heard nothing till four months later after she had spoken to the local council scrutiny committee the convictions were added later to accusations relating to her union activities.

Previously, Judge Jonathan Ferris picked up on the point that it had taken just five days to present the charges relating to the other accusations against Ms Monro but took 80 days (from March) relating to the convictions question

The judge though was less than happy about the failure on this occasion to provide the original document with the convictions listed, presenting instead “an inadequate photocopy.”

Judge Ferris questioned whether the Trust had lost the original document. “The Trust has got no business losing it,” said Judge Ferris. “The basis of what is on the document is central to the dismissal.”*Judge slams Trust for missing documents" - Morning Star - 17/3/2015

Saturday, 14 March 2015

NHS trade union rep Charlotte Monro has claimed she was sacked from her job as a moving and handling co-ordinator in the stroke unit at Whipps Cross hospital due to her trade union activities.

Monro was dismissed by Barts Trust after she addressed the Waltham Forest Health Overview and Scrutiny Committee in June 2013 in her capacity as a Unison rep about bed reduction at the stroke service.

She was also charged with prematurely disclosing information about job losses to her union members and later with failure to disclose criminal convictions that arose out of political activities in her 20s.

Addressing the resumed employment tribunal hearing at Anchorage House in the Docklands Monro declared that “my attendance to speak at the Scrutiny Committee was the trigger for my suspension and the Trust's investigation.”

It was a matter of days after she made this address that Barts Trust acted, suspending Monro and launching its investigation.

“I have been dismissed for activities I undertook in my union capacity and demand the protection I am entitled to under the law. If this (dismissal) is allowed to stand it will give a message not just to the Trust but to other NHS employers that they can at will class union activity as personal conduct of an individual employee and take action against them where they may perceive a challenge to some agenda,” said Monro, stressing that her case was really about the right of trade unions to operate in the NHS.

“It will reinforce an approach to unions that does not respect their independence and right to organise, free from interference by an employer and that union reps are equal partners to reach mutual agreement on how relations are conducted,” said Monro. “In the prevailing conditions within the NHS and public services this has to be a matter of wider concern.”

Monro highlighted how with the exceptions of the non-declaration of convictions allegation, all of the others related to her trade union activities.

On the question of the convictions, she suggested these were included in order that the Trust could justify the decision to dismiss her. “The real reason was my trade union activities,” she said.

Her suspension at the time concerned effectively took Monro out of wider discussions about reorganisation at Whipps Cross hospital. She had previously campaigned vigorously with the union to save the hospital.

Thursday, 12 March 2015

Chilean photo journalist Carlos Reyes Manzo has put together a remarkable set of pictures from around the world representing the stations of the cross.

The stations, on display at Harecourt United Reformed Church in north London, begin with Jesus in condemned to death depicted with the picture of a prisoner bound in South Africa at the funeral of 21 other prisoners who died in a cell fire during a protest for the right to vote in the 1994 elections.

The fourth station: Jesus meets his mother is reflected in a picture of Rosa Elvira Franco Sandoval, mother of María Isabel Velíz Franco 15, who was abducted, raped, tortured and murdered in Guatemala in December 2001.

The scene of Simon of Sirene taking the cross is reflected in a 1996 picture that Carlos took of people migrating Nepal to India in search of work.

Jesus meets the women of Jerusalem is reflected with a picture of mothers marching for justice for their missing and murdered daughters on VDay Ciudad Juarez, Mexico in 2004.

The crucifixion scene is captured with a picture of a man terminally ill in Uganda with HIV/Aids.

Jesus dies on the cross is represented by a picture of eight crosses in the desert in Mexico. These crosses were put up in Lomas de Poleo, Mexico, where the bodies of eight young women were found in 1996.

The Salvation Army hostel for the homeless Mumbai, India 1996 is used to represent Jesus being taken down from the cross.

The final image of Jesus being laid in the tomb is reflected in a picture of the family mourning the death of a teenager killed by the paramilitary police in Brazil.

The pictures are drawn from Carlos work documenting scenes of injustice across the world over the past 40 years, from Latin America, the Middle East and Africa to the streets of London.

Carlos recalled how Jesus became a refugee in Africa. “So why are we treating African refugees as criminals,” said Carlos.

*The station will be open for viewing at Harecourt URC, 12 St Pauls Road, N1 2LR during Holy Week Monday March 30th--Thursday April 2nd 2-6pm Good Friday from 12-6pm (service from 2-3.30pm)13/3/2015 "Dramatic stations of the cross captured in photo exhibition" - see Universe"Injustice stations of the cross" - see Catholic Times

Sunday, 8 March 2015

Climate campaigners came out in their thousands to march and demand action on climate change from corporate centred politicians

John Sauven, executive director of Greenpeace, contrasted the urgency with which politicians and business moved to address the financial crisis with the dithering and inaction displayed when it comes to dealing with climate change.

He highlighted the battle ahead against corporate interests that continue to peddle fossil fuels. Sauven highlighted Shell’s move back to oil exploration in the arctic, a move ironically only made feasible by the thawing of glaciers, caused by global warming. “No company should be able to profit from the impact they are having on the well being of the planet,” said Sauven.

The Greenpeace executive director quoted Denmark as an example of a country acting to counter climate change with its commitment to go fossil fuel free. “We can have clean energy and clean jobs if we stick together, “ said Sauven.

Bert Wander from Avaaz, which helped raise a petition to ensure that the march was able to go ahead, pointed out that renewables are getting cheaper and being rolled out across the world. The growth of the divestment movement in relation to those contributing to climate change was cited as another positive development.

Wander called for campaigners to ensure that the four words “zero emissions by 2050” remained part of the climate change agreement due to be enacted by governments in Paris at the end of the year.

The 15,000 strong march made its way along Holborn onto the Strand past Trafalgar Square to the final rally on St Stephens Green outside Parliament. Led by the cyclists, the march processed along in the spring sunshine.

Each had their own way of bearing witness, one man in a bright green outfit protesting against radioactive waste took a refreshing lager at the Coal hole pub. Another woman carried a banner calling to banprivate carsinlondon.com. Outside Downing Street, ten protesters lined up spelling out “Time to Cycle.”

Groups from across the country were represented on the march from Operation Noah, Christian Ecology Link, Greenpeace and Friends of the Earth to trade unions like Unite, Unison and the Fire Brigade Union (FBU). The Green Party were also well in evidence.

At the rally, Kat Hobbs from Campaign Against the Arms Trade called for government funds to be moved from weapons to addressing climate change. “The government is handing billions to arms companies,” said Hobbs, who said there is something seriously wrong when 25 times more is being spent on developing weapons than renewables.

Gary Shrubsole, a Friends of the Earth campaigner, highlighted the success of the battle to stop fracking, with moratoriums in Scotland and Wales, with life being made increasingly difficult for frackers in England.

“We’ve got the six energy companies on the run – there is a crisis of trust and profit,” said Shrubsole, who paid tribute to the 500,000 households that now have solar panels on their roofs.

Green Pary MP Caroline Lucas declared that people have the power and they are saying no to fossil fuels and climate change.

She claimed the technology to tackle climate change is already there, what is now needed is the political will to make it happen.

Matt Wrack, general secretary of the FBU, called for energy to be taken back into public ownership.

Labour MP John McDonnell called for people to come and help his community in Hayes and Harlington in the latest stage of the fight to stop a third runway being built at Heathrow airport.

Saturday, 7 March 2015

There is growing speculation about the future of the Catholic Association for Racial Justice (CARJ), with suspicions that the organisation might be absorbed into the Bishops Conference for England and Wales's office for migration.

Established in 1984 to promote the voice of black and minority ethnic Catholics in the Church and beyond, CARJ later became an agency of the Bishops Conference of England and Wales. A large proportion of the agencies income comes from the annual Racial Justice Sunday collection, which occurs on the second Sunday in September.

The suspicions about the future of CARJ arise due to a change that has been made in the way in which the funds collected on Racial Justice Sunday are now allocated. Previously, all the funds went to CARJ but as of last September the administration and funding of the collection moved to the office for migration at the Bishops Conference for England and Wales based in Eccleston Square, London.

A letter was sent out to parish priests last July by Archbishop Malcolm McMahon, chair of the Catholic Trust for England and Wales and Marcus Stock, the then general secretary of the Catholic Bishops Conference for England and Wales, declaring that there would be no special materials sent out to priests to promote Racial Justice Sunday, as previously organised by CARJ, but they would be called upon to encourage “the support of the faithful in the Church’s work for racial justice.”

“Recognising the normal channels through which parish priests communicate with the members of their parish, we hope that you will provide assistance by promoting Racial Justice Sunday and the second collection which accompanies it through your parish newsletter, parish website and any notices which you announce at Sunday Mass,” says the letter.

The funds collected seem to be destined for the Bishops Conference Office for Migration. “The Catholic Church in England and Wales is contributing to the efforts to overcome racial justice in our nation through the pioneering work of the Bishops’ Conference Office for Migration. This work has seen a unique partnership forged between the Church and the statutory authorities in combatting human trafficking and modern‐day forms of slavery, and supporting some of the most vulnerable and marginalised people. To support this work and that of the Catholic Association for Racial Justice, a second collection will be taken next/this weekend,” says the letter.

Interestingly, Bishop Pat Lynch is head of the office for migration and President of CARJ, whilst the secretary for the office for migration is Cecilia Taylor-Camra, who was previously the CARJ co-ordinator.

Five months after the collection was taken, the Bishops Conference was unable to give any indicator as to how much had been collected or what the split would be between the office for migration and CARJ. “The Racial Justice Sunday collection is now being administered by the Bishops' Conference of England and Wales finance department. The monies will be distributed amongst Carj and the Office of Migration. It is too early to say how much the collection has fully raised - it takes some time for all the monies to be sent into the Bishops' Conference, most dioceses tend to send in their restricted collections at their financial year end,” said a spokesperson for the Catholic Communications Network.

CARJ relies for more than 75% of its income on the Racial Justice Sunday collection with that reliance growing as income from other traditional sources like religious orders dries up

Thursday, 5 March 2015

A major survey conducted by Leeds Diocesan Justice and Peace Commission has found that the food aid crisis in Britain is far bigger than previously estimated.

The survey of 88 parishes in West Yorkshire found that there is a huge amount of food aid being delivered to people under the radar, as it were, by organisations like the Catholic charity the St Vincent De Paul Society (SVP). “Half of those responding had provided food to the Trussell Trust foodbank but half as many again give food through the SVP,” says the report.

Examples of other forms of food aid, beyond foodbanks, included churches providing hot meal and delivering food parcels to those in need.

The report found more than 50% of parishes in West Yorkshire actively involved in providing food aid via food banks and other support mechanisms.

Chairing a conference titled: Foodbanks: charity or injustice, former Labour MP, John Battle declared that the Trussell Trust figures of 900,000 people nationally going to foodbanks in the last year was under representing the true level of food aid being provided by at least two thirds.

The research also discovered the very high level of involvement by Catholic parishes in helping people survive. Some 40% of those surveyed had been involved for between one and three years, reflecting the massive growth in the need for foodbanks over that period. Another 23% had been involved for less than a year.

“This comprehensive research shows the Catholic Church massively involved in emergency food aid,” said Mr Battle, who pointed out that it was low pay and benefits sanctioning that were the main drivers for the increase in demand. “Foodbanks are being substituted for proper support.”

Underlining the crucial role of low pay in driving the demand for foodbanks, Mr Battle quoted an individual he knows who stacks shelves in a supermarket. “If he gets a week when he has short hours, he will be going from the supermarket to the foodbank to pick up some of the food he has stacked to support his own family,” said Mr Battle.

There was a strong call from many present at the Leeds conference to not merely seek to meet the ever growing demand for food aid but to question why this is happening in 21st century Britain. “It struck me listening to the testimonies how shocking it was that in Britain in 2015 that people have to lose their dignity in order to get enough food to eat,” said Joe Burns, Leeds Diocesan J&P Commission foodbank survey co-ordinator.

The Leeds Diocesan Justice and Peace Commission is making the demand for a right to eat as the central plank of its general election campaign.

There are to be 10 questions drawn up from the survey process and commission day asking prospective candidates what their answer would be to the food aid crisis. “The outcome of the survey and conference show that Catholic parishes are involved at the rock face of this food poverty issue, it is now for us to hold the politicians to account. Our representatives must back the right to eat,” said Mr Battle.