The format is basically "experts take potshots at 10 popular diets" -- so inherently a little unflattering.

Given that, I think we did alright! The author clearly liked it:
("charming techie patois," lots of direct quotes from the book, gave us the last word vs. the critics).

The "just another attempt to organize unorganized emotional eaters" criticism is absurd. What SHOULD we do with disorganized emotional eaters? Lock them in a cage? Shoot them?

If that's the best the experts could do, I'm really not worried (plus it doesn't seem like they made it past the cover. Being an expert that no one listens to is wearying work, no time to actually read the books they're reviewing!).

Certainly great to be mentioned in such company sales-wise... (though perhaps not efficacy-wise )

Reinhard

Last edited by reinhard on Tue Mar 11, 2008 3:32 am; edited 1 time in total

Ooh I will have to read this review soon!
Never mind the barking dogs as the caravan rides by!
hahah
That sounds better in French!

Honestly Reinhard, that's great!!!!!!!!!!!
Peetie is right.
The real people who can be helped by NoS and who know better (been through *ALL* the crap and fad diets already) will come and enjoy and benefit!!!

Have a great day and congrats on getting great exposure!!!
Can't wait to see you on TV soon with Oprah!!
Love
Debs_________________There is no Wisdom greater than Kindness

I am in LA and read the article about the 10 diets. I am glad I did because I found about the No S Diet. I had never heard about it before. After spending the past hour going through the information on the web, I can tell that it looks like home to me. I am ready to start. So, regardless of what the review said, it has brought one new recruit into the fold.

Welcome, lilfrenchbee! Great to see the article translate into new no-essers so quickly.

Relatively speaking -- no s came off pretty darn well. None of the 10 diets escaped unscathed and "charming techie patois" is certainly better than what the author had to say about bestselling "skinny bitch:"

Quote:

You might like this book if you like: PETA; being ordered around by the loud rich girls at your junior high school.

I've heard that the No S Diet book hasn't actually made it into West coast stores yet. Have you had a chance to take a look?

Welcome, lilfrenchbee! Great to see the article translate into new no-essers so quickly.

Relatively speaking -- no s came off pretty darn well. None of the 10 diets escaped unscathed and "charming techie patois" is certainly better than what the author had to say about bestselling "skinny bitch:"

Quote:

You might like this book if you like: PETA; being ordered around by the loud rich girls at your junior high school.

I've heard that the No S Diet book hasn't actually made it into West coast stores yet. Have you had a chance to take a look?

Reinhard

Have you noticed, though, that these so-called "experts" never like ANY diets? No matter how sensible it might be, there's always someone that says "well, this idea is terrible." I guess they're just mad they weren't hired to act as a dietician or something, but what they might not like about eating regular meals and avoiding snacking is beyond me.

... None of the 10 diets escaped unscathed and "charming techie patois" is certainly better than what the author had to say about bestselling "skinny bitch:"

Quote:

You might like this book if you like: PETA; being ordered around by the loud rich girls at your junior high school.

I've heard that the No S Diet book hasn't actually made it into West coast stores yet. Have you had a chance to take a look?

Reinhard

I just finished Skinny Bitch and that about sums is up perfectly! haha.

I'm in Ca so I just called my local Borders bookstore to see if the No S Diet was on the shelf. It's not and I was told that your name wasn't in their computer system so I looks like a book they wouldn't carry. I might go in and request they order a few copies. Maybe between a call and an in store request they will consider stocking it. It's been on my mind to buy a few and offer them to my doctor as waiting room copies...

It's only a matter of time before they start telling us to just eat one big meal all day, never stopping. "If you stop eating at any point, your metabolism will slow down!"

You have to get a constant stream of nutrients into the muscles. Otherwise, you're totally going to go catabolic, bro.

Fact check:

Your body has some elasticity in terms of how it uses calories. If you eat less, the metabolism slows. If you eat more, it speeds up to burn off some of the excess. This is how most people maintain weight over months, days, and years, despite varying energy intake.

But trying to take advantage of this by eating more often is sheer lunacy. "I saved 100 calories today by eating 1000 more than I need!"

It's like getting sucked into a 20% off sale and buying something you had no intention of getting in the first place... you're saving 20%, but you would have been better off by keeping the money in your pocket.

It's only a matter of time before they start telling us to just eat one big meal all day, never stopping. "If you stop eating at any point, your metabolism will slow down!"

You have to get a constant stream of nutrients into the muscles. Otherwise, you're totally going to go catabolic, bro.

Fact check:

Your body has some elasticity in terms of how it uses calories. If you eat less, the metabolism slows. If you eat more, it speeds up to burn off some of the excess. This is how most people maintain weight over months, days, and years, despite varying energy intake.

But trying to take advantage of this by eating more often is sheer lunacy. "I saved 100 calories today by eating 1000 more than I need!"

It's like getting sucked into a 20% off sale and buying something you had no intention of getting in the first place... you're saving 20%, but you would have been better off by keeping the money in your pocket.

Oh, I know. I was being sarcastic about the diet "advice" we all get, where they tell us we should be constantly snacking lest our metabolism slow down (which apparently doesn't really happen except for after days of constant starvation.)

It's so weird, all the contradictory things various diets tell us to do. Usually, they advocate an eating plan that in no way resembles anything ever practiced by any people on earth. The big thing now on the low-carb board I belong to is telling people that "whole grains are terrible for you, have no vitamins, and poison the body!" Yes, they are actually saying this, despite the fact that whole grains have been shown to reduce cardiac risk factors and have a favourable effect on weight. Another diet book I read a while back said we should limit our diet daily to "one pound of cooked vegetables, and one pounds of raw vegetables" with no oil, dairy, salt, nuts, meats, or fat. Sounds like a great way to live.