I needed a mascara for when I have DEP and was interested in this one for the longest time. I liked that it gave me volume and stayed on but I really hate that it clumps my lashes and almost impossible to remove.

I bought this about two weeks ago and just tried to use it. It was like it was old. I used to use the old version all the time and loved it but it seems they have changed the formula. I had to keep going over and over my lashes to get some mascara on them. Wasn't a nice effect so had to wash my eye makeup off and start all over with a different product. Tried to return it but had already thrown out receipt.