Pages

Saint Thomas Aquinas

Thursday, December 8, 2011

Archbishop Dolan Redefining Human Dignity

The modernist crisis is alive and well within the Church hierarchy. In reading a recent article concerning Archbishop Dolan's teaching regarding human dignity and the death penalty, we can see what happens when the seminaries quit teaching Thomistic principles in moral theology. The archbishop nonsensically stated ,"“If even a man on death row has a soul, is a human person, an ‘is’ that
cannot be erased even by beastly crimes he may have committed, then we
ought not to strap him to a gurney and inject him with poison.” The Archbishop obviously does not understand that the death penalty cannot be against the dignity of the human person if carried out by a lawful authority. In fact it upholds it by sustaining the common good of society. If we read past documents by Saints and past Popes we all know that the death penalty does not in any way violate a person's "human dignity." Does the archbishop think himself wiser than St Thomas Aquinas, Pope Pius XII, or the entire Church of the year 1210 when it formally mandated that the Waldensians accept the use of the death penalty as a legitimate form of punishment? Did they think it contrary to human dignity? No.

St. Thomas Aquinas addressed this issue in depth long before Archbishop Dolan, and the Church has firmly stood by his point of view concerning this matter throughout the centuries. St. Thomas clearly views capital punishment as being in keeping with
the fundamental principles of human dignity. If we read the ST 1-2.85
we can see how St. Thomas understands the effects of sin. He understands
that even a criminal does not lose their fundamental dignity, which is
that they are made in the image and likeness of God. This however never compelled St. Thomas to advocate abolishing capital punishment. What is true then is true now. Cultural variation does not change truth and Pope Pius XII told us this specifically in regard to capital punishment. (cf. Acta Apostolicae Sedis 47 (1955): 81-82.) The Archbishop here is clearly railing against 2000 years of the Church's voice repeatedly telling us that the death penalty does not in any manner violate human dignity. If it did, it would be malum in se, that is it would be evil in itself and it would never be justified as a licit moral act upheld by the Church in past centuries.When are the few Thomists that are left in the hierarchy going to challenge this kind of modernist theological rubbish? Is it not time that the seminaries and bishops honored Pope Leo XIII's wishes to restore Thomism to the Church?

"Among the Scholastic Doctors, the chief
and master of all towers Thomas Aquinas, who, as Cajetan observes, because
"he most venerated the ancient doctors of the Church, in a certain way
seems to have inherited the intellect of all. The doctrines of those
illustrious men, like the scattered members of a body, Thomas collected
together and cemented, distributed in wonderful order, and so increased with
important additions that he is rightly and deservedly esteemed the special
bulwark and glory of the Catholic faith... But, furthermore, Our predecessors in
the Roman pontificate have celebrated the wisdom of Thomas Aquinas by
exceptional tributes of praise and the most ample testimonials. Clement VI in
the bull In Ordine; Nicholas V in his brief to the friars of the Order
of Preachers, 1451; Benedict XIII in the bull Pretiosus, and others
bear witness that the universal Church borrows lustre from his admirable
teaching; while St. Pius V declares in the bull Mirabilis that
heresies, confounded and convicted by the same teaching, were dissipated, and
the whole world daily freed from fatal errors;...the words of Blessed Urban V to the University of Toulouse are worthy of
recall: "It is our will, which We hereby enjoin upon you, that ye follow
the teaching of Blessed Thomas as the true and Catholic doctrine and that ye
labor with all your force to profit by the same."...We
think it hazardous that its special honor should not always and everywhere
remain, especially when it is established that daily experience, and the
judgment of the greatest men, and, to crown all, the voice of the Church, have
favored the Scholastic philosophy.

Moreover, to the old teaching a novel
system of philosophy has succeeded here and there, in which We fail to
perceive those desirable and wholesome fruits which the Church and civil
society itself would prefer. For it pleased the struggling innovators of the
sixteenth century to philosophize without any respect for faith, the power of
inventing in accordance with his own pleasure and bent being asked and given
in turn by each one. Hence, it was natural that systems of philosophy
multiplied beyond measure, and conclusions differing and clashing one with
another arose about those matters even which are the most important in human
knowledge. From a mass of conclusions men often come to wavering and doubt;
and who knows not how easily the mind slips from doubt to error? But, as men
are apt to follow the lead given them, this new pursuit seems to have caught
the souls of certain Catholic philosophers, who, throwing aside the patrimony
of ancient wisdom, chose rather to build up a new edifice than to strengthen
and complete the old by aid of the new-ill-advisedly, in sooth, and not
without detriment to the sciences. For, a multiform system of this kind, which
depends on the authority and choice of any professor, has a foundation open to
change, and consequently gives us a philosophy not firm, and stable, and
robust like that of old, but tottering and feeble.Taken from Pope Leo III, Aeterni Patris

2 comments:

This nonsence about the death penalty being against the dignity of the human person by our so-called Catholic bishops sickens me big time. Has any of these bishops ever seen the body of a murder victim, especially one that was murdered in a very savage way? Perhaps they would gain a new perspective on "human dignity" if they would start visiting the morgues when they see some of the corpses of the members of their dioceses lying on an aotopsy table with all their wounds and bruises in plain sight!

Live Mass!

Click Image to Watch the Extraordinary Form Everyday!

Catholic Champion Podcast on ITunes

Be sure to visit ITunes and subscribe to the Catholic Champion podcast. New sermons by the FSSP are now available. Go to the Itunes store and search in the top right text box for Catholic Champion. Subscriptions are free.

“When I get a little money I buy books; and if any is left I buy food and clothes.”

Visit the Cardinal Manning Society

Cool Non-Catholic Sites

FSSP DVD

Get the instructional video on the Tridentine Liturgy.

Welcome to Catholic Champion blogspot.

It is important for people to have access to solid Thomistic Catholic reading material as well as solid spiritual sources. This is what I have now focused this blog towards. It is always a work in progress of course.