While we can't make your gems larger, we think we know what may have went wrong. It is a lesson that many have yet to learn - when it comes to buying gemstones, carat weight is often times not as important as size. Different gemstone materials have a different density (specific gravity), so some gems will appear larger than others of the same weight. For example, a 1 carat sapphire is smaller than a 1 carat diamond because sapphire is a denser material. We have a weight comparison chart that will allow you to compare the weight of different gemstones in calibrated sizes. We always give the exact dimensions of our gemstones in millimeters on our website, so don't forget to check the size of your gemstones, in addition to the carat weight.