Keep getting all your baseball news form Baseball Tonight and John Kruk buddy. It seems to be working out really well for you.

I'm sorry your team has been playing like S*** this year. Its not our fault man. Dickey is having a good season and is impressing a lot of people. However no matter how you put it he just doesnt deserve the award.

Cueto is pitching in one of the best (if not the best) hitters parks in the entire league. Dickey is pitching in a pitchers park. Yet his ERA is still almost half a run lower. Dickey has had a great year,and things could change, but Cueto has to be the leader right now.

How can you be considered a valuable player when you can't help your team to the playoffs. That is a very strong argument and is used by most voters unless the play has an unbelievable season. (Which Dickey is having a very good season but not unbelievable.)

Only 3 of the last 10 cy young winners have made the playoffs the year they won.

The only thing run support affects are wins. Wins are not a good metric of how good a season a pitcher is having. This is pretty widely accepted, even upon "non-stats" folks.

Nobody said that wins are, however when players' more meaningful stats like era, whip and baa are so similar run support is a big factor. We're not talking Jamie Moyer winning 15 games with a 5+ era while getting 7.5 runs a game in support here.

Nobody said that wins are, however when players' more meaningful stats like era, whip and baa are so similar run support is a big factor. We're not talking Jamie Moyer winning 15 games with a 5+ era while getting 7.5 runs a game in support here.

There are plenty of other meaningful stats to long at, that don't rely on things like run support, how good your teammates are, etc.

Again, WAR is park neutral. If you don't know what that means, please go read about it. It shows Cueto has the slight edge in value right now, which is what I've been saying. Another reason to use advanced sabrmetrics instead of stats like wins, and even worse your team's record.

Nobody said that wins are, however when players' more meaningful stats like era, whip and baa are so similar run support is a big factor. We're not talking Jamie Moyer winning 15 games with a 5+ era while getting 7.5 runs a game in support here.

Again, WAR is park neutral. If you don't know what that means, please go read about it. It shows Cueto has the slight edge in value right now, which is what I've been saying. Another reason to use advanced sabrmetrics instead of stats like wins, and even worse your team's record.

I know what WAR is buddy. And yes its 3.9 to 4.3 Cueto leading. So by that you are agreeing with everyone you've been arguing against. Wow smh