User Reviews

Pick A Bagel On Third

Posted by Q. Cicero on 12/26/2013

Nice Food, Gruff Staff

I have placed orders for delivery for some time now and find the food good & delivery prompt. However, staff sometimes interrupt me on the phone, or make it sound like they are doing me a big favor to serve me. I doubt this will change--just putting my 2 denarii in.

Pick A Bagel On Third

Posted by NYCgirl on 09/23/2012

Not Recommended

I order from this place because they're good enough and local but I always walk away annoyed. The service is fine, the bagels are just fine but the prices are as if they are the only food store in NYC. For example a pound of sliced turkey is $15, $5 more than every other place. And they have annoying rules, like they wont put cream cheese on a mini-bagel? Why? They give you a soda with a sandwich, unless the sandwich is on a bagel and you're out of luck if you don't drink soda. I'm out. No more.

Pick A Bagel On Third

Posted by Anonymous on 06/15/2012

Unfriendly Staff

I find the staff very unfriendly. I browsed other reviews and realized I'm not the only one who found this to be the case. The bagels aren't bad; the prices are a bit high. It's nice and clean. But there's too many other bagel stores that have better bagels and friendlier staff for me to return to this one.

Pick A Bagel On Third

Posted by SBarrick on 05/22/2012

Consistent good service

Always on time, never any issues. The bagels are good. When I'm ordering for a meeting, they make my job easier.

Pick A Bagel On Third

Posted by Elisabeth on 02/26/2012

Pick Another Place

Extremely poor service for such low quality bagels. The staff is unnecessarily rude. I would rather stay at home and make my own bagels instead of going back to this place.

Pick A Bagel On Third

Posted by pickmebagel on 11/20/2011

Pickabagel Regular

I live on the corner of this pickabagel and it's become a weekend tradition in our house to crawl out of bed and stroll down there. On weekends its usually crowded (but in a fun way). You have to be ready to order when it's your turn, and do so quickly. They're only rude if you're a slug. The girl at the cashier grinds my gears a little sometimes but she has her good days too. I just finished ordering over the phone for the first time and the person on the other line was friendly. A toasted bagel, coffee and juice $7. I love this place. You should too.