Post by bonzai on Dec 3, 2011 21:30:24 GMT -5

Soooooooooooooo I guess its safe to assume that anyone who hasnt voted for bonzai after my earlier post is mafia.

Ummm really?! I didn't even know that we got a final player and I join in to see this?

What I learned from my second game (last game) everyone lies. It didn't occur to me that Bek was lying about being inspector. Now I feel that I am ready for anything (I say this now.. I am sure I will be fooled in any second.) All I know is that I am a townie. If someone in round one decides to point a finger at me.. they are obviously a mafia under a really odd agenda. I haven't experienced this yet, but my vote is obvious

Post by EAP on Dec 3, 2011 22:05:33 GMT -5

ok ntellier, i'm just going to come out and say it....if you really are inspector, then you have made a terrible move coming out so early. the only two things that will happen now is you will be whacked tonight or they will keep you alive and make you look guilty. the inspector needs to try and go undetected until at least day two or three so that they can make more guesses.

sorry if that is blunt.

on the other hand, if you are mafia, then you are smart b/c it could look like you are making a rookie mistake and people will then trust you.

Post by ntellier85 on Dec 3, 2011 22:08:11 GMT -5

ok ntellier, i'm just going to come out and say it....if you really are inspector, then you have made a terrible move coming out so early. the only two things that will happen now is you will be whacked tonight or they will keep you alive and make you look guilty. the inspector needs to try and go undetected until at least day two or three so that they can make more guesses.

sorry if that is blunt.

on the other hand, if you are mafia, then you are smart b/c it could look like you are making a rookie mistake and people will then trust you.

so if you trust me and arent mafia, why not change your vote to bonzai?

Post by jhammett on Dec 3, 2011 22:49:46 GMT -5

JHammett >>> Flanzomar

My logic, Omar stacked a vote on scrog early, I want to see how the votes split between them.

Also, I would like to see someone change their vote and throw Bonzai into this runoff, since she has been suggested by a potentially credible source. Personally, I find 3 way runoffs to be the most telling, especially in the first round.

------------

I know we have a lot of new players this game. A few things:

First, you can change you vote as much as you like. Do it like this:

YOU >>> WHO YOU WERE VOTING FOR >>> WHO YOU ARE VOTING FOR NOW

Second, do not edit your posts, it will only make people suspicious.Third, posting pictures doesn't always work, so make sure you get your point across with words too.

Post by ntellier85 on Dec 3, 2011 22:56:48 GMT -5

1. Only the mafia know for a fact whether I am the inspector or not, since bonzai is one of them, and I obv picked her.

2. I will get whacked tonight, making this even more damming evidence towards bonzai. So Mafia, if you whack me, you are giving up one of your own. Or dont whack me, whatever.

3. If we can get bonzai into a runoff, we can narrow down the other two mafia. If you are a townie, you dont have to trust me, but just trusting me this one time wont hurt you that bad, you will still be at a 7-3 advantage if you are wrong.

4. However, if you are right, and we take out bonzai, not only have we gotten the mafia down to 2, but we can then take everyone who doesnt vote for bonzai and assume mafia status. Or, the mafia can be forced to vote for their own as to not let on suspicion, but in the end taking out one of their own.

Post by Guest on Dec 3, 2011 22:59:27 GMT -5

For the record, I only voted Scrog because people on the sign-up thread were voting for him (I realize they were jokes, I just didn't know about the "voting partner" and I'm new to the game).

I don't think Ntell is the real inspector, so I'm simply not voting with him and trying to last more than one round in my first game. If someone can give me a convincing argument to change my vote I would, but not without Scrog or jham changing their vote as well (obviously).

My vote stands, but it's not set in stone. The floor is open for someone other than Ntell to sway me...

Post by ntellier85 on Dec 3, 2011 23:02:35 GMT -5

For the record, I only voted Scrog because people on the sign-up thread were voting for him (I realize they were jokes, I just didn't know about the "voting partner" and I'm new to the game).

I don't think Ntell is the real inspector, so I'm simply not voting with him and trying to last more than one round in my first game. If someone can give me a convincing argument to change my vote I would, but not without Scrog or jham changing their vote as well (obviously).

My vote stands, but it's not set in stone. The floor is open for someone other than Ntell to sway me...

Just read my above post, you have little to lose, and everything to gain out of it.

Post by El-D on Dec 3, 2011 23:53:13 GMT -5

I really have no intention of seriously voting for Scrog, but we need to put someone in a runoff around here.

And Tellier is either the worst noob at this game ever, or a quacking genius. I'm gonna go with worst noob at the moment, but I wanna keep Bonnie around for the hell of it. Assuming she's Mafia: she's blonde, she'll have to slip up sometime.

Post by Scrog on Dec 4, 2011 2:52:36 GMT -5

I like this, a 3-way with the vote stacker and the accused. I think flanzO made a noob vote stacking mistake. I also think Ntell did as well by posting the Inspector Gadget pic, Since you are calling Bonzai out as Mafia, I think you the accuser, should be in the run-off, more so than a noob who stacked a vote, does anybody else agree? I will change from FlanzO to Ntell, if nobody else wants to change. If someone else changes their vote, that would give us a four-way run off, which I know you guys like the 3 way. I have no problem being in the run-off, I know I am a townie. Should it stay Bonzai, FlanzO, and I orChange to Bonzai, Ntell, and IorFlanzO, if you want to change to RDK or LD, they seem to be pro-Bonzai, I will switch to Ntell and we would have a Bonzai, Ntell, and RDK or LD run-off.