December 17, 2010

No matter how much you love your old-fashioned paper books, it’s hard not to own up to a few little covetous twinges when you see people with Kindles or sleek iPads.

Students who download their texts on e-readers must love not having to carry around the extra weight of traditional texts. They must also find being able to highlight, underline, or make notes in their e-books, as the Kindle application permits, incredibly convenient. Those who commute or travel also love their e-readers, for the same reasons.

This information may prove immensely useful to businesses who want to sell more products to consumers, of course. But what might a government inclined to monitor its citizens’ activities closely do with information about people’s thought processes, I wonder? Might the government of, say, China require all university students to use e-readers that report students’ reading habits and notetaking back to it, I wonder?

Of course, data about individuals’ browsing habits is already stored in multiple locations on different computers and servers. When in doubt, you can assume that online publications generally know your IP address, which articles you’ve clicked on, and other information about you. If you buy books online, or in a store using a credit card or frequent buyer program, there’s a record of the books you’ve bought. If you check books out of a library, there’s a record. Bottom line: we trade our privacy for what electronic devices, applications, and the internet offer.

NPR quotes Stephen King on the data collection issue as follows: “Ultimately, this sort of thing scares the hell out of me,” King says. “But it is the way that things are.”

In related news, the Sixth Circuit Court of Appeals held this week that citizens have the same expectation of privacy in their e-mails as in their snail mail letters and phone conversations, so that the government must obtain a search warrant before seizing and searching e-mails held by private e-mail providers. Hat tip for this and the WSJ Law Blog item: Ed Walters of FastCase.

About me

CONTENT AND COPYRIGHT NOTICE

All material on this blog is copyrighted. I’m delighted if you’d like to quote from any of my posts for non-commercial use, but I’m a stickler for giving others credit and would appreciate the same courtesy, including links back here.
All opinions expressed here are solely my own, and I reserve the right to modify them at any time. I am not available to accept or represent clients. Nothing on this blog constitutes legal advice. I welcome thoughtful comments, but please understand that I cannot keep comments or messages confidential, and comments will be approved for public viewing at my sole discretion. Additionally, neither submitting a comment nor sending me a message by any other method will create an attorney-client relationship. If you are seeking legal advice or representation, please visit the American Bar Association's public legal resource portal http://apps.americanbar.org/legalservices/findlegalhelp/home.cfm or contact another bar association of your choice.