Criss, Colfer and Shum at the “Struck By Lightning” After Party this week.

Well, at least when posed with a “Bang, Marry, Kill” proposition that pits his Glee costars Chris Colfer, Darren Criss and Cory Montieth against each other (sorry, Montieth).

Shum recently appeared on Lance Bass’ XM radio show and was posed the question — Criss would be his husband because they’re such good friends, he’d have to kill Montieth because he said “knew he’d come back alive,” leaving Bang for Colfer.

We have to agree with the choices, but how would it share out for you? Let us know in the comments!