Claim Review and TV/Media -- Discussion NotesStatus of this document: This is a public document recording notes made during/after Dan Brickley visits to (and calls with) the Archive.org team working on TV-related fact checking, September 2017. It is shared as input into Schema.org and related discussions around improvements to ClaimReview.Followup discussion in https://github.com/schemaorg/schemaorg/issues/1686 please.
Dan BrickleyDB_4627dfdc-6095-11e8-a329-b937fe613715Contact: <danbri@google.com>Archive.orgSchema.org_4627e126-6095-11e8-a329-b937fe613715_4627e1da-6095-11e8-a329-b937fe613715ClaimReview SchemaAdjust the ClaimReview schema documentation on Schema.org to provide examples of a wider variety of sources_4627e27a-6095-11e8-a329-b937fe613715ASchema.orgThe ClaimReview schema already supports a wide variety of use cases which non-experts may not know how to implement given the current documentation. We would like to adjust the documentation on Schema.org to provide examples of a wider variety of sources, especially VideoObjects and Clips._4627e34c-6095-11e8-a329-b937fe613715Video ClipsSupport use cases and implementations of online video clips_4627e3e2-6095-11e8-a329-b937fe613715BThe Clip schema definition should be reviewed to ensure that it supports use cases and implementations of online video clips.
See also:
* schema.org issue tracker #1686
* Tracey's notes in Github from Sept meeting.
* Added #1 rough cut to Schema.org github (staged on webschemas.org)TV News Claims/Written ResponsesConduct written fact checks of TV news video claims_4627e478-6095-11e8-a329-b937fe613715Use Case 1Written fact check of a TV news video moment --
PolitiFact reviews a claim made a half hour into a presidential debate; the debate was aired on three news networks. The clips also appeared in other news segments the next day. All of these broadcasts exist in the TV News Archive.
Candidate design: see link in #1686, Individual Claims/Written ResponsesReview claims made multiple times at various rallies and public speeches_4627e54a-6095-11e8-a329-b937fe613715Use Case 2Written fact check of recurring individual talking point --
PolitiFact reviews a claim that has been made multiple times at various rallies and public speeches. Several of these speeches have been captured by the TV News Archive as part of larger programs. Some of the speeches have not been captured by the TV News Archive, but were recorded by event attendees and posted to YouTube or Facebook LiveMulti-Party Claims/Written ResponsesReview claims made by multiple sources in multiple locations_4627e5ea-6095-11e8-a329-b937fe613715Use Case 3Written fact check of widespread talking point --
PolitiFact reviews a claim that has been made by multiple different sources in multiple locations (e.g. as pundits or surrogates on news networks, in public speeches, in Tweets).Tweet Claims/Written ResponsesReview claims made in tweets aired on TV news_4627e694-6095-11e8-a329-b937fe613715Use Case 4TwittterTV News ReportersWritten fact check of a broadcast tweet --
PolitiFact reviews a claim made in a tweet that was aired on TV news.Written Claims/Video ResponsesTelevise reviews of claims made in writing._4627e748-6095-11e8-a329-b937fe613715Use Case 5Video fact check of a non-video claim --
CNN reviews a claim made in a written format. The review itself is broadcast on television.Video Claims & ResponsesTelevise reviews of claims made in video broadcast events_4627e888-6095-11e8-a329-b937fe613715Use Case 6Video fact check of a video claim --
CNN reviews a claim made in a broadcast event (e.g. a claim made in a debate). The review itself is broadcast and contains a re-airing of the claim in question.Written Claims/Multi-Media ResponsesTelevise and also publish written reviews of claims made in writing._4627e946-6095-11e8-a329-b937fe613715Use Case 7Multimedia fact check of a non-video claim --
CNN reviews a claim made in a written format. The review itself is broadcast on television, and is also written on cnn.com. The written version may or may not contain the aired version.2017-09-302018-05-25https://docs.google.com/document/d/1_YxG42aEbhu33ZoZDPX0oTkKN7tr1B_5gYH33LJYIZk/edit#heading=h.4elx2n6h9gmtOwenAmburOwen.Ambur@verizon.net