Wartime melodrama with William Wyler's deft
directorial touch of realism interspersed with sympathetic and lovable
characters. Winner of multiple awards this film may feel quite dated to modern
viewers, but regardless, it is a very worthwhile viewing experience with
everlasting themes of respect, community and familial bonding. Characters are
shown with subtle flaws enhancing their realism and the story is one of
consequence and drama probably touching on memories of many individuals who
lived through similar tribulations of World War II. Being aware of the period
this film was made it showed a prevalent 'shot-in-the-arm' feel for the Allies
and although, not treating the topic politically even-handedly, it did not
overindulge to allow generalizations. I say immerse yourself in the cinematic
power of William Wyler and sip from the fountain of a divisive moment in
humanity that we can hope has vanished forever. out
of.

Blu-ray (January 2013): What a great flic - Warner's HD-upgrade improves in the
predictable areas with a smoother, artifact-free presentation. It is
brighter and there is a hint of grain-texture. Contrast levels of the
2004 Warner DVD were quite adept and there isn't a dramatic superiority
on the new 1080P transfer. In fact, I like the SD except the visuals
could appear slightly dirty by comparison. The older DVD may be slightly
vertically stretched beside both the Taiwanese digital attempt and the BD. Those
with more discerning systems will notice the video benefits of the Blu-ray
more. I thoroughly enjoyed my presentation.

Extras lose the photo gallery from the DVD but gain another short
animated feature - entitled 'Blitz Wolf' essentially mocking
Nazi-ism with a warning about racial and ethnic prejudices of the day.

I love Wyler's storytelling ability and while propaganda-leaning, this
is a story of courage and communal spirit fighting an injustice.
Definitely, a film I want in my
Blu-ray collection.

***

ON THE DVD:

Again, not so much a comparison
as praising the stunning Warner DVD. It shows some damage but this is
very film-like presentation. Beautiful contrast with prevalent film
grain. This DVD is sharp, perfect black levels, solid sound and a host
of timely Extras. I won't defend my purchase of the Taiwan import 2
years ago excepting that it allowed me to see this Wyler masterpiece -
and for $9 it was not a bad purchase at the time. However this Warner
ranks up with their best. A wholehearted recommendation.