Kindle 2

Wired rating

Wired

The best e-reading system on the market. Welcome improvements to aesthetics, more functional industrial design, better graphics and longer battery life. Sleeker than the original at less than a centimetre thick and 280g.

Tired

Quite expensive. Book content shackled with DRM. Interface is improved, sure, but it could be even better.

Price

$360 (not available in the UK)

The most notable feature of the Kindle 2 (Amazon.com's long-awaited update to its groundbreaking but somewhat flawed electronic reading device) is that it's possible to pick it up and not turn the page. This sounds like faint praise, but anyone using the original Kindle quickly found the oversized buttons covering both sides of the device made grasping it a delicate, stressful task – kind of like picking up a sea urchin. Anything less than perfect finger placement would lose your place.

Not so with the Kindle 2, which fixes that problem and a host of others through thoughtful, business-like improvements and innovations.

Are the improvements big enough for the Kindle 2 to spark an iPod effect, causing bookstores to shut, forests to grow unchecked and the tomes on our shelves to disappear, replaced by plants and bobble-head dolls? Not any time soon, and certainly not in the UK, where the device will not be available in the foreseeable future.

In any case, the evolution towards e-reading devices as the dominant means of reading books will be a drawn-out and complicated affair. It will require screen technology with inexpensive, high-resolution colour, multi-touch and flexible displays. These are all features that the Kindle, as well as competitors like the Sony eReader, are still waiting for. A mass-market solution will also involve pricing that acknowledges how much cheaper it is to distribute books digitally; currently Amazon sells e-books for about half the price of their hardcover equivalents. For now, though, the Kindle 2 is the closest thing to this magic formula.

The Kindle 2's page-turning buttons are smaller and more smartly situated than the first version's. It's harder to press them by mistake. In fact, by requiring you to depress them with authority, they're a little too hard to press – it would be nice if the reader could adjust the action a little. Still, overall, it's a problem solved.

The strengths of the device are the same. The dense, readable display and paperback size allow readers to sink into an author's world just as they do with a physical tome. But this "book" is augmented by digital technology, allowing you to store hundreds of manuscripts, search through them, and look up words in an onboard dictionary, on the web or through Wikipedia. It also has a free wireless connection to the Amazon Kindle store, now hawking 230,000 books (as well as magazines and newspapers).

The day after I got the new Kindle I boarded a plane and before the doors closed, browsed the store and purchased Thomas Perry's thriller Runner. The book uploaded within 30 seconds and I was absorbed in it for the entire five-hour plus flight. When I finished, the 280g device had a shelf-full of books and magazines – as well as a manuscript of an article in progress – waiting for me.

I could have done that with the original. But while Kindle 1.0 won a substantial following, it had many of the problems you'd expect from a novice player in consumer electronics. Amazon has clearly been hard at work addressing the difficulties, and has succeeded to the point where some early buyers will be kicking themselves for premature adoption.

The most dramatic changes are in the physical design. Abandoning the quirky shape of the original, which was meant to evoke the form of a real book, the designers boiled down the shape to a pencil-thin (91mm) slab, which feels completely natural in hand. Though you can buy an "official" $30 leather cover (it has special hooks that keep the device in place, something that was missing in the original), I found it most comfortable to read bareback. But if you're into playing it safe, I'd recommend one of the third-party neoprene cases available on Amazon.com.

The screen is the same size as Kindle 1.0 - a legible 6-inch monochrome e-ink display that requires an external light source to view - just like a paperback. But version 2.0 displays images in 16 grayscale shades, far better than the previous version's pathetic four. Though the Kindle is definitely not the ideal device to show off pictures of the family vacations, this quality bump makes the difference between getting the impact of a chart or photo in a book, rather than having pictures look like fifth-generation Xerox copies, as they did in the original.

Another giant step is the replacement of the original's awkward cursor-control wheel with a simple five-way button that you tilt in the direction you want to cursor to move, or press to select an item. It works so well you wonder why the Amazonians didn't think of it first. Those of us spoiled by multi-touch still wish that the Kindle had a hands-on display so we could turn virtual pages with the swiping gesture that the gadget gods intended.

One of the weakest aspects of the original Kindle was an abysmal interface for reading newspapers: it required painstaking back-and-forthing to get a grasp of contents. This new software still isn't perfect (again, a touchscreen would help) but it now provides a logical path for navigating The New York Times and other publications.

The Kindle 2 is zippier, with pages turning 20 per cent faster (yes, you can tell the difference). It has more memory (2GB, enough for storing more than 1,500 books onboard). And it flaunts a more powerful built-in battery: Amazon claims that the Kindle lasts four to five days with the wireless on (I got 4.5 days in my first test) and up to two weeks with it off. After a week of limited wireless, my meter is around 50 per cent. Amazon also says that after 500 charges, it will hold 80 per cent of its original juice. That means that most users won't have to replace the battery (a $60 procedure) for about a decade or so.

One feature in the new Kindle I couldn't test, because Amazon furnished me with a single test unit, is a new feature that allows you to synch your reading among other Kindles and other mobile devices that Amazon may support. This means you could read 50 pages of Revolutionary Road, turn the device off, and when you open the Kindle application on your phone later, it will start you on page 50. Read ten pages between appointments, and when you revisit your Kindle, you'll start on page 60. The logical partner for this scheme, of course, is the iPhone, and it would be a disappointment if a match weren't made in the app store.

This Kindle 2 has generated some controversy with its experimental "read to me" function that transforms any book into an audio book. I found the text-to-speech implementation perfectly listenable, with only a slight electronic accent (the computer-generated reader apparently is a distant cousin of the Lost in Space robot). The feature would be even better if the built-in speakers weren't on the back of the device, muffling the sound if you place it screen up on a flat surface. Not so enthusiastic is the Author's Guild, which claims that the feature might lessen the value of members' audio rights. Text-to-speech works just as well with your own content - you can upload Word files into your Kindle for a dime apiece.

The new Kindle is currently priced like the old one, at $360. Considering that it's an engine for buying books directly from one supplier, Amazon.com, that seems too high. On the other hand, it's hard to fault Amazon for what it charges when it can't fulfill demand at the current price. Also, consider that the books you buy from Amazon are limited by digital rights management rules imposed by the publishers. You may invest thousands of dollars over the years in a library that your friends can't access and your heirs can't sell to second-hand dealers.

Looking over the horizon, it's clear that Amazon's biggest competitor in selling digital books will be Google, whose recent agreement with publishers and authors will make it a virtually exclusive seller for millions of books in copyright but not in print. But right now at least, the Google and Amazon formats aren't compatible: I was unsuccessful in getting a PDF of a public domain book downloaded from Google to appear in readable form on my Kindle.

Overall, the Kindle 2 addresses the key problems with the original, boosts performance and points to some interesting directions. Now we're a little bit further down the road toward e-book Nirvana.