Once upon a time, in the year 2014, a mysterious cookie-fairy appeared—she’d reveal her to-be location on social media, and park her powder-blue cookie-themed car in a corner of Mumbai and share with the world delectable, comforting cookies. Three years later, we know Sweetish House Mafia is the brain child of Mumbai resident’s Neha Arya Sethi and her brother-in-law Aakash Sethi. With six successful outlets under their belt, and a seventh at Kemps Corner open this July, cookie monsters like us can’t wait to get their hands on SHM’s range of cookie shakes and sundaes. But since we at Vogue are also something of wish-granters, bakers everywhere (and out-of-Mumbai people), we’ve got the OG chocolate chip cookie recipe for you. Get, set, cook(ie)-off!