You know how sometimes an actor plays a character so well that you can’t imagine anyone else in that role? Well, Steve Carell as Michael Scott is widely considered one of those scenarios.

But things could’ve been much different. Take a look at this audition sign-in sheet for The Office from 2003.

Yep, you read that correctly. Rainn Wilson was auditioning for both Dwight AND Michael.

Frederick M. Brown / Getty Images

Imagine if Rainn Wilson had been cast as Michael instead, and played the role of an immature, irresponsible, silly Regional Manager.

NBC

Just picture all of the incredible Michael Scott scenes being pulled off by Rainn Wilson. The countless conference room meetings, the negative interactions with Toby, and all of the cringeworthy moments — like Scott’s Tots.

NBC

WIlson auditioning for Michael Scott isn’t the only interesting thing on the sign-in sheet — look who auditioned for the role of Jim Halpert.