Birchbox Breakdown

How do we feel about this trio of Benefit Cosmetics’ all-star They’re Real! products? Really, really, really excited (see what we did there?). We can now try the dramatic They’re Real! Mascara, the eye-opening They’re Real! Push-Up Liner, and powerful They’re Real! Remover—in one convenient value kit that we can pick up for a steal.

How to Use

The first time you use the liner, twist the base 8 to 10 times until gel emerges from the pen tip. Each later use, click base once to fill tip with gel. Slowly sweep pen tip along lash line. Follow with a coat (or two!) of the mascara: Wiggle the thick brush from the base of lashes to the ends for the full volumizing and lengthening effect. Maneuver the brush’s tip to catch those elusive bottom lashes. At the end of the day, dispense remover onto a cotton pad. Sweep over eye area until makeup is removed, then rinse.

This stuff is great!

I wasn't really a fan of the eye liner (but I'm not great at that in the first place) I absolutely love the mascara! I used both for my wedding, and it really made my eyes stand out! Lasts all day, and I usually layer pretty lightly for a more natural look.

5

Was this review helpful to you? Yes |
NoWas this review helpful to you? Yes |
No

Gift

I bought this as a gift for my sister after she received the sample in her monthly box. She absolutely loves it! She was also very surprised that it came with eyeliner, which she was not expecting. I can tell a big difference how full her eyelashes are and the eye liner is easy to use and doesn't create the mess that normal eye liners do. Needless to say she was very pleased with her gift!

5

Was this review helpful to you? Yes |
NoWas this review helpful to you? Yes |
No

Tricia

Age

25-34

Beauty style

Adventurous, Classic, Trendy, Low-maintenance

Love the mascara, eyeliner is tricky

This is my sister and mine's HG mascara. We both have lashes that to not compare to our brother's lovely full lashes....this mascara helps! :P The eyeliner is tricky and I can't figure it out....my sister can sometimes get it, other times she lays it on too thick and takes it all off.

3

Was this review helpful to you? Yes |
NoWas this review helpful to you? Yes |
No