It will take some time to know if Nelsen is the right hire but I am encouraged. No coaching experience is a concern but there's no doubt his playing resume and knowledge of how MLS works is a plus. For his sake (and for TFC's) I hope he has a seasoned assistant next to him. The league has grown leaps and bounds since Nelsen left and it will be a huge challenge. But if there's anyone that can rise to the challenge it's Nelsen. He defied many odds as a New Zealander not only making it to the Premier League but being a very good player.

Off subject (kind of) -- but I think it's a telling sign of where QPR is headed that he was willing to turn in his boots so quickly for a manager role. He started 18 games this season for QPR.

Putting aside my DC United supporter grumbling (damn! I wanted him back with us!), I will say this in defense of Nelsen's coaching "experience". You often hear about players who coach from the field. Nelsen was definitely a player who coached from the field. That was especially true when he played with the NZ national team. He wasn't the manager, but with that team Nelsen was no mere player. Granted, it's not the same as being the real coach. But it counts for something -- maybe even a lot. And I also recall the other MLS coach who had a very strong "coaching from the field" reputation during his playing days: Jason Kreis.

Certainly some inherent risk with a first-time coach, but can anyone name a "sure thing" coach who was available and willing go to coach TFC? The closest thing would seem to be luring another MLS coach like Sigi Schmid away from their current team or spending gobs of money on a foreign high profile coach, who still might struggle to adapt to the league.
Peraonally I love this move, and as a close follower of the league I've been watching TFC step on its own feet since day one while hoping they could get it sorted out, because it seems like a great atmosphere and could be a big boost to the league if they could have success. He's got international pedigree, knowledge of MLS, leadership, is young enough to relate to players, and seems to have a good reputation (and has an accent for added credibility!).

Putting aside my DC United supporter grumbling (damn! I wanted him back with us!), I will say this in defense of Nelsen's coaching "experience". You often hear about players who coach from the field. Nelsen was definitely a player who coached from the field. That was especially true when he played with the NZ national team. He wasn't the manager, but with that team Nelsen was no mere player. Granted, it's not the same as being the real coach. But it counts for something -- maybe even a lot. And I also recall the other MLS coach who had a very strong "coaching from the field" reputation during his playing days: Jason Kreis.

Click to expand...

100% correct and I knew that of Nelsen. His "coaching" on the field is a compliment and speaks volumes of Nelsen. I bet he has little trouble grasping the X's and O's. But there's more to coaching. It's the management side --- handling players, training, scouting, etc. that often proves to the hurdle for new coaches. Respect as a player is easier earned than respect as a manager especially for an inexperienced one. With that said, these are obstacles and merely that. Nelsen can certainly overcome them and I suspect he will. He'll have some bumps in the road a la Olsen and Kries but they are perfect examples of patience equals success. Patience is wearing thin in Toronto so hopefully their brass (fans) understand this. Like I said, on paper, I love this hire but time will tell if it's the right one.

Not a DC fan, but Nelsen was one of the most inspirational players the league has ever seen. He had a quote once that I can't find anymore, but something along the line of Herm's 'you play to win the game' - basically saying that MLS players were pros and how seriously they took their jobs at a time when MLS was still trying to gain credibility. Also having made the professional jump he made, you would think he will command immense respect from young players. I'm sure they'll hire a tactically-minded assistant and he should work out at least reasonably well, if TFC gives him a little time.

As a Spurs fan in the few matches he was at the club I really grew to like him, great professional. If he still wants to play for TFC he has a lot to give. He along with a few other players always got praise for how well they trained.

Saying that it's clearly a risk. I think he'd make a good manager but this situation isn't ideal imo. I liked the idea of him being a player-coach, i.e. not head coach, then he can take a managers job some time down the road. He's being thrown directly into the fire with the MLS worst club, big task.

Good hire for TFC. He really does have the right experience for an MLS club. Having played College soccer in the US, along with his Pro experience in MLS and the BPL, it really is a unique resume. Consummate professional by all accounts. MLS Cup winner. World Cup. Team Captain on every club He's played on. I would roll the dice on him.

As for possible assistant coaches.....Jesse Marsch has ties to Kevin Payne from his 2 years at DC United.....

Good hire for TFC. He really does have the right experience for an MLS club. Having played College soccer in the US, along with his Pro experience in MLS and the BPL, it really is a unique resume. Consummate professional by all accounts. MLS Cup winner. World Cup. Team Captain on every club He's played on. I would roll the dice on him.

As for possible assistant coaches.....Jesse Marsch has ties to Kevin Payne from his 2 years at DC United.....

If I were a Toronto fan I would looooove this move more than anything the organization has done since they put in grass...maybe since they got the team.

1. Nelsen has incredible leadership ability. When he went to Rovers he became vice captain within months, and was one of the keys to them staving off relegation that year. He is always the captain.
2. He was a very successful defender despite a lack of speed, which means he had to be a smart, tough player. When he and Samba were at their peak, they were the best central pairing outside of the big 4, in large part due to his ability to organize the defense.
3. There are two models for successful MLS coaches. One is the Bruce/Sigi model of coming from college. The other is the Kinnear/Yallop model of having international playing experience and experience in MLS. Nelsen is a terrific example of the latter.

As always when a coach is hired, you have to think back to the Bill Parcels line. Nelsen is the cook, but you don't know if he's gonna buy the ingredients. You can't make steak out of horsemeat.