'Breaking Amish' cast member refuses to name father of her baby - as friends say she was living with on-screen boyfriend years before show (but she DOES tell the truth about her dentures and bikini photo)

Cast members given chance to respond to their critics in show's finale

Abe and Rebecca refuse to name father of her child despite photograph showing them together before they appeared on the show

Sabrina insists her wedding was a Mennonite ceremony

Jeremiah denies attacking his ex-wife and says he now pays child support

Jeremiah was given the chance to respond
to revelations he is divorced from a woman who claims he repeatedly beat her
- and with whom he has three children, aged seven, five and three.

The children live with their mother, Naomi Stutzman,
in Ohio. The couple married in 2005 and she filed for divorce in 2011,
citing gross neglect of duty, extreme cruelty and incompatibility.

Speaking to CBS21,
Stutzman, who has also left the Amish community, called the show 'a
fake' and claimed: 'The kids and I suffered for years at the hands of this man.'

On one occasion, he punched her in
the stomach while she was pregnant, a police report notes, while other records reveal he did not pay child support.

'Do your frickin' homework,' Jeremiah said. 'I did spend three days in jail for
supposedly [abusing her]. The court threw it out. I regret
that I didn't pay child support in the past, but I'm paying it now.'

Wild: Pictures also show Jeremiah, left, surrounded by friends swigging from beer cans

Trust: Abe and Sabrina had earlier revealed they had sex during the show's filming and it was 'stupid'

And Sabrina, the only Mennonite in the
group, was given the chance to comment on photographs showing her
getting married while wearing a decidedly non-Mennonite dress.

She
was married in 2009 and has not been a practicing Mennonite
for years, friends claim. Other photographs on Facebook show her in skimpy clothing.

But Sabrina said that the ceremony adhered to the community's traditions, there was no dancing or alcohol and she had a panel fitted into her dress to conceal her chest.

'I'm not ashamed I was married,' she said, confirming that her divorce is still pending. I still love him - he's a good man and
he's honorable. I have nothing but good things to say about him.'

In the first part of the finale,
which aired last week, Jeremiah and Sabrina had admitted they had sex
during the filming - throwing yet more doubts on their devotion to their
faiths.

Insistence: But she maintained her wedding in 2009 was traditionally Mennonite, despite how it appeared

While a cast member claimed the couple had sex in a hotel lobby's bathroom, Sabrina denied it.

Jeremiah added: 'If the world wants to know, we did it and enjoyed it.'

'And I made him stop,' Sabrina said. 'I was drunk both times. We were both trashed and started messing around. He sticks it in, and I
was like, No! I made him take it out. I don't consider that
actually doing it.'

Jeremiah was also reportedlyaway from his Amish community for up to 14 years and is pictured on social networking sites surrounded by beer cans.

TLC has also previously admitted that the fifth and final cast member,
Kate, who is billed as an Amish bishop's daughter and aspiring model,
has been arrested for a DUI.

Dark pasts: TLC had previously admitted that Kate, pictured left on the show, was arrested for DUI, right

New life: On the show, Kate finds modelling work and wears a variety of skimpy outfits

But blogs revealed she also previously submitted images to modeling agencies - which is at odds
with the Amish stance against photographs, believing they represent
'vanity' which they deem a sin.

Online
records show that Kate posted a photograph on exploretalent.com to
enter a Best Smile contest in 2010 - years before she claimed she gave
up her Amish life to move to the city.

She is pictured on her wedding day in a ceremony that is not traditionally Mennonite.

The apparent betrayal by the creators of Breaking Amish is documented on a Facebook page, Breaking Amish the Truth, on which people who claim to know the cast have vented their anger.

Scores of people have also uploaded photographs showing the cast in their 'real' lives.

In
response to the outrage, TLC said it would address the revelations
in time, which it has now attempted to do with the two-part finale.

'There is a lot of information
floating around about the group featured on Breaking Amish. Much of it
is not true, but some of it is - and is addressed in upcoming episodes,'
TLC told Variety.

'Reality' TV? TLC's show Breaking Amish has come under fire for its false claims about its characters' pasts