I took my car in for an DSC CEL, my window trim paint flaking off and an oil change. From the moment I had my first follow up call, I received conflicting information. First my DME was dead. Then I found out it was being updated? I thought it was dead? Which one is it? I felt like I was being jerked around on my window trim issue too. Being told that it appeared I put boxes on my roof? WTH? Or perhaps someone did it when I wasn't looking? It wasn't until I complained big time that my SA said he will try to get it covered. Then he tells me its not easy to remove and replace and that if they ding or scratch my paint, then any damage they cause are MY issue? What kind of offer is that? Are you for real?

Then he tells me the cant finish the DME update and will have to complete it the following day. He then said they will need to drive it to check to see if the code comes back. I told him, NO ONE is to drive my car. That I will drive it and let them know. He said ok, that they would prefer to be the ones to test it, but whatever I wish. So today my car was supposed to be completed. I call my SA at 11am and left him a voice mail asking for a follow up on when I might be able to pick up my car. I got no return call. So at like 1230, I call back and hes still not available. So I ask the resp if she can at least tell me if my car is done yet? She checks and says the only thing we are waiting on is the window trim. That it has to be signed off? I told her, no, I passed on the window trim because it clearly sounded like they couldn't do it and to please just get my car ready. She puts me on hold and next thing I know, my SA picks up the phone.

Now hes telling me that he didn't call me back because he was waiting for his manager to sign off on eating the window trim repair. I told him, thanks but no thanks if they think I'm going to allow them to not be liable for any damage they cause doing the repair. He says fine and the car is ready.

So I go pick up my car. My SA is no where to be found (I'm not really looking for him either though). I get my car back and I notice it has 4 miles on it.

From start to finish, nothing went right. And to top things off, they didn't respect my wishes about no one driving my car.

Needless to say, I wont buy another car from them and I wont let them service my car again. I'm pretty bummed about it too because I really wanted it to work out.

I finally got around to taking my car into another dealer. This time Irvine BMW. From start to finish, I had a great experience. I worked with Jose F. who was a very professional and nice guy to chat with. He seemed relaxed, calm and just overall willing to help.

I had him look at my shadowline trim paint that was coming off, my push button paint that chipped off, my front seat that was creaking, and a rattle in the b pillar area. He said NO problem and was shocked Crevier gave me a hard time about something that was clearly defective on a 10 month old car.

He took me to his desk and said if they have the parts in stock, they would try to get it all done same day. If not, they would order the parts and have them the following day.

I got a call at 2PM (dropped it off at 9am). And he told me my car was ready! They replaced all the shadowline trim, my push to start button and fixed both rattles/creaks. Plus the actually washed my car pretty good. No swirls, no water spots, no issues with the wash!

Overall, I felt they serviced me the way a dealer should. I will never go to Crevier again and from now one IRVINE BMW will have my business!

Username: Eau Rouge
Region: SoCal
Dealership Name: Steve Thomas BMW
Sales or Service: Sales
Name of Salesperson/Advisor: Ryan Amico
Overall Experience (1 lowest 5 highest): 5
Work Performed/Attempted: New car order
Recommended? (Yes or No): Yes
Additional Comments: Hands down the most competent and professional CA I've worked with through many a new car purchase. Even with Ryan on the West Coast and me across the country, everything went down without a hitch. Checa sorted everything out with the Florida DMV, all of the paperwork was accurate, and even though the timeframe from requesting a quote to delivery spanned almost six months, the experience exceeded even my expectations which were "up there". Well done Ryan/Checa/Steve Thomas BMW. I'm happy to rep for you with one of your license plate frames. You ARE that good!

BEFORE YOU BUY YOUR NEXT BMW, PM ME FIRST WE CAN HOOK YOU UP!Jimmy Bach: jbach@stevethomasbmw.com - Cell:805-807-1989
If you have any issues getting a hold of Jimmy B PLEASE PM me, I'm available everyday till 545pm!

Region: South Florida
Dealership Name: Braman BMW
Sales or Service: Service
Name of Salesperson/Advisor: not sure but can easily find out
Overall Experience (1 lowest 5 highest): 1.5
Work Performed/Attempted: oil issues, other problems.
Recommended? (Yes or No): N
Additional Comments: Held my car for 7 days for checking an oil problem, roof rattle, and asked for a general checkup belts etc. Service rep never gave me a check-up call or status on anything over that whole time period. I called several times. never received an answer back, started to have concerns that they did something to my car and were trying to fix it. Regardless after i called the 7th day they said my car was ready. Nothing was wrong or out of the ordinary. The next day my car lit up, needed washer fluid, oil, and a new bulb for my headlight, and the service light came on requesting an annual service appointment.

Conclusion: Am now driving 20 min away to take my car to Ft. Lauderdale, even though I live 3 min away from Braman.

Yep, i had an issue with Braman West Palm which is 10 min from my house. Now I drive to Vista 40 min away. Vista is always a pleasure in every way.

Username: KmndntKlink
Region: Ontario, Canada
Dealership Name: Budd's BMW
Sales or Service: both
Name of Salesperson/Advisor: Ian P.
Overall Experience (1 lowest 5 highest): 3
Work Performed/Attempted: sale & change tire, fix tint, minor stuff.
Recommended? (Yes or No): maybe
Additional Comments: I bought my m3 used from budd's. I heard stellar reviews, so I had appropriate expectations, and was left pretty much disappointed. Now it was a full individual car so it was pretty unique so my buying power was non existent. Price was still decent, but absolutely no room for negotiation, I'd suspect it would be much better with non M cars or other "normal' m3s etc. Now Ian was excellent until he made the sale. Now this is usually true for all car sales, but Budd's was promising to be different (they spend alot of time promoting their service, I got letters and emails claiming to be open door, contact any time, even Ian told me that but he was lying). I spent a week trying to hound him down cuz there was a few bits missing (the parts in the trunk, and a scratch on the window tint, both he promised he would help me with, but then disappeared once he got the check). To this day (4 months) he never got back to me, not once. I had to harass Daryl Budd who had his second in command sort me out (Reno) He is all stars, he got everything done ASAP and I was made whole. Daryl is a great guy, but he promotes perfect service which he just doesn't deliver on. Staff is always friendly, but tasks get lost or delayed in the beurocracy. I took my car in to get the summer tires put on because they failed to put them on for when I took delivery. The spare key didn't work and they had to order a new one as well. Now all of this should have been taken care of in their 360 degree check they promised they were gonna do before delivery, but they didn't. I suspect all they did was wash it, they had a week its not hard to fix these things. Anyway, when I got there it was all smiles and yes sir right away, I was told it would take no more than 1.5-2 hours. That turned into 4.5. They claimed that the key had to be reprogrammed and that took 3 hours and the tires took 2 cuz that they didn't know they had to put the tires on the same rims. EVEN THOUGH I specifically told them when I booked the appointment that i was going to use the same wheels and that they had them in storage waiting for me. Their lounge is small and right in the sun so its very hot. The only reason I'd go to Budd's again is if I lived in oakville and wanted Dinan parts (they're the only dealer in Canada). Instead I'd suggest going to Mississauga BMW or an independent one. I tested them out with just a refill of tires but they got me sorted in 10 minutes no charge and were really nice. Their lounge is huge and more comfortable, the overall place is just alot nicer (probably because they just renovated). I'm going to make mississauga my regular one and write up a review for you all once I have real work done there.

I finally got around to taking my car into another dealer. This time Irvine BMW. From start to finish, I had a great experience. I worked with Jose F. who was a very professional and nice guy to chat with. He seemed relaxed, calm and just overall willing to help.

I had him look at my shadowline trim paint that was coming off, my push button paint that chipped off, my front seat that was creaking, and a rattle in the b pillar area. He said NO problem and was shocked Crevier gave me a hard time about something that was clearly defective on a 10 month old car.

He took me to his desk and said if they have the parts in stock, they would try to get it all done same day. If not, they would order the parts and have them the following day.

I got a call at 2PM (dropped it off at 9am). And he told me my car was ready! They replaced all the shadowline trim, my push to start button and fixed both rattles/creaks. Plus the actually washed my car pretty good. No swirls, no water spots, no issues with the wash!

Overall, I felt they serviced me the way a dealer should. I will never go to Crevier again and from now one IRVINE BMW will have my business!

Thank you Irvine BMW! Job well done!

Crevier was an absolute circus before the takeover by Penske and it seems the circus continues. Thanks for the positive review on Irvine, I will try them next as Im getting tired of going all the way to Long beach for my service. They're solid but the distance/traffic is annoying when living in Irvine, was much better when I was in HB.

I figured it might be a good idea to get a thread like this going. Just follow the template, and I'll update the original post whenever I can. I'll also edit the template if there's anything missing that you guys think is a good idea. I also added a "username" entry so if anyone has any questions about the details of work performed, they know who to contact.

With more and more dealerships getting bad raps, I felt the need to give my 2c over the good experiences I've had at Calgary BMW. This was my first M3, second BMW purchased there from Woody Woo. Very transparent, honest, and fast. Replies to your emails overnight, on his days off, etc. I think I spent less than 10min doing the deal on my M3. Came in with invoice price, offered a percentage profit, he asked the manager, and that was it. He has always been very helpful.

The service guys are great too, and will even pricematch parts with US dealerships (plus shipping). They have always taken my concerns seriously (135i; clutch, HPFP and M3; break in transmission oil, etc.) and always treated me with respect. Can't ask for much more. +1 for Woody Woo and Calgary BMW (and Colin in parts department, Don Murphy in service).

Region: British Columbia

Username: Schnell325
Region: Vancouver BC
Dealership Name: The BMW Store
Sales or Service: Service on 335xi
Name of Salesperson/Advisor: Koren/Andrea
Overall Experience (1 lowest 5 highest): Edited: 1 [Original Comment: negative 5!!]
Work Performed/Attempted: air intake piece f*ck up
Recommended? (Yes or No): NEVER IN A MILLION YEARS
Additional Comments:
-purchased car new April 2010 (but live 800 km away from any dealer)
-CEL light from first start up -service dept cleared code....blamed bad gas
-300km later.....CEL -erratic idle/stalling
-diagnosed as a cracked intake boot later in 2010 at Dilawri BMW in Regina Sask.....N55 was new engine, so no piece. Siliconed the piece until future service.

-June 15 2011...requested part be ordered from The BMW Store for service on July 15th
-July 14th, received a call saying the part was back-ordered!! And did we what to reschedule?!?! I'm 800km away!! I'm not cancelling.
July 15th, get to The BMW Store, voice my concern over the missing part. Andrea calls the Parts Dept and says that the part will be here Monday.....I am very skeptical at this point.
-July 29th, pick the car up. Andrea is not there and apparently no other SA is allowed to go over my invoice or even talk to me....I ask the cashier if the intake piece came in and was installed....."yes" was the reply. At this point I realise I should have forced the issue....but I didn't (lesson learnt)
-over the course of 4-5 weeks, I try to get Andrea to respond to my emails requesting an invoice....nothing.
-I get my sales advisor to contact the Sales Manager Koren.
-she sends me an invoice, but it's for a service on my M3 from 2010
-I ask for my wifes, and she says it's still open....pending an intake piece arriving from Germany. I am boiling at this point.
-they send me the part out of "good faith" so I can install it.

I question everything that went wrong, and there was lots I'm leaving out on this post, but the GM of the whole dealership blamed some family problems with Andrea that they had to handle, "we dropped the ball", her work wasn't evenly distributed, blah blah blah. He evens says he'll email me back within a few hours after looking in to the situation more......2 weeks later I email him to ask him where we are at and his response came across liket he was annoyed I asked him about it. I responded back that this nice thing about the whole situation is that I'll never set foot in his store ever again. He never responded

All I can say is the The BMW Store in Vancouver will never see another penny from myself. I'll never service any BMW there, and I'll never buy another car from them, nor recommend them to anyone.

Region: Ontario

Username: Rolf-Dieter
Region: Ontario Canada
Dealership Name: Town + Country BMW ~ Highly Recommended ~
Sales or Service: Sales
Name of Salesperson/Advisor: Moe T. (Now retired) This was my 3rd BMW purchase from Moe T. Moe found exactly what I was looking for a fully loaded 2012 MT M3 rolled off the assembly line in the first month of the last production year for this V8.
Overall Experience (1 lowest 5 highest): 5 +++
Work Performed/Attempted: Traded my 2011 M3 (wanted a fully loaded 2012 M3).
Recommended? (Yes or No): Yes
Additional Comments: Great Salesman and Management Team, I hope to find another salesman like Moe once I am in the market for a new one.

Country: USA

Region: California

Beverly Hills BMW

Username: NAForever
Region: SoCal
Dealership Name: Beverly Hills BMW
Sales or Service: Service
Name of Salesperson/Advisor: Don't remember
Overall Experience (1 lowest 5 highest): Can I give them a 0?
Work Performed/Attempted: Oil Change, Fog Light Out
Recommended? (Yes or No): No
Additional Comments: Worst ever, took forever to complete an oil change and the SA had a terrible attitude about it. Acted as if I was a major burden and he was doing me a favor. Isn't surprising I'm in an M3 and he's in a 328.

I believe in 2nd chances, so this time maybe 1 year later I had a foglight out in my e60 which was under warranty. This time, the SA (different guy) tried to charge me $140 for a diagnostic test stating figuring out how to replace the light could endanger the techs Forever lost my business.

Bob Smith BMW

Username: persian54
Region: SoCal
Dealership Name: BobSmith BMW
Sales or Service: Service
Name of Salesperson/Advisor: Ken
Overall Experience (1 lowest 5 highest): Edited: 5 [Original Comment: 10 (yeah double your max biatch lol!)]
Work Performed/Attempted: Varies services and requests
Recommended? (Yes or No): Yes
Additional Comments: Ken takes care of me even though I'm in there pretty much every week (for a different issue). I'm very picky about rattles, squeaks, things not being right, etc etc. The service tech always takes a ride with me and helps find the pinpoint the issue(s). The issue(s) are resolved in a timely and profession manner. I recommended them 100%.

Username: persian54
Region: SoCal
Dealership Name: BobSmith BMW
Sales or Service: Sales
Name of Salesperson/Advisor: Several
Overall Experience (1 lowest 5 highest): 1
Work Performed/Attempted: Looking for a new Lease
Recommended? (Yes or No): No
Additional Comments: I think they have too much overhead, or they think everyone is stupid rich cause they're in Calabasas. But these guys do not like to make deals. I have tried numerous times over the years to buy a car here as I live 5 minutes away and go here for service...but I never am able to make a deal :/

Username: persian54
Region: SoCal
Dealership Name: Bob Smith BMW
Sales or Service: Sales
Name of Salesperson/Advisor: Paul
Overall Experience (1 lowest 5 highest): 4
Work Performed/Attempted: lease
Recommended? (Yes or No): Yes
Additional Comments: I generally hate Bob smith sales, but Paul was able to help out and get a great deal. not a 5 star cause paperwork took forever... but much better experience than I have had in the past

Username: LateBraking
Region: Southern California
Dealership Name: Center BMW
Sales or Service: Service
Name of Salesperson/Advisor: Ahh....no idea.
Overall Experience (1 lowest 5 highest): 4
Work Performed: 1,200 mile service.
Recommended? (Yes or No): Sure.
Additional Comments: Well they took care of the 1,200 mile service, no problems. Wasn't the most polite in the world but polite enough, dealer is kind of small and hard to access, Kia rental sucked, but the service was done so I have no real complaints.

Crevier BMW

Username: wuzupfoo
Region: Socal/OC
Dealership Name: Crevier
Sales or Service: Service
Name of Salesperson/Advisor: Some useless schmuck
Overall Experience (1 lowest 5 highest): 2
Work Performed/Attempted: Tried to figure out an intermittent starting problem thats been haunting me for about a year.
Recommended? (Yes or No): NO
Additional Comments: Been there 3 times now for the same problem each time. First time they told me it was bad gas... ya right.. second time they said maybe I was imagining it and it would go away. 3rd time they told me both of the above then accused me of modifying the battery... how the f.. do you modify a battery! At this point im completely finished ever going to Crevier. They are on my personal shit list and will steer anyone looking for a BMW away from them

Username: LateBraking
Region: Southern California
Dealership Name: Crevier BMW
Sales or Service: Service and Parts Sales.
Name of Salesperson/Advisor: Mark. Forgot the last name.
Overall Experience (1 lowest 5 highest): 1 (Service) 4 (Parts Sales)
Work Performed/Attempted: Transmission Repair, Parts Purchases
Recommended? (Yes or No): No for service, yes for parts.
Additional Comments: Faulty transmission on my 2008 M3. Said he would inspect/test drive to verify. Called back and said they would not service. When I returned, found that vehicle ahd not even been moved from where It had been last left. Not recommended. As for parts sales, they usually have most parts and items in stock, and have a very friendly and mostly knowledgeable parts department. Recommended.

Irvine BMW

Username: Sean Alexander
Region: Southern California
Dealership Name: Irvine BMW
Sales or Service: Both
Name of Salesperson/Advisor: Brett / AJ
Overall Experience (1 lowest 5 highest): 3
Work Performed: New Car Sales (x2) Service (x9) Repair (x1)
Recommended? (Yes or No): Yes
Additional Comments: Was a rough relationship with the service department at first, then I found AJ, who will actually listen when the client happens to know what they're talking about. Now the relationship is smooth as silk, purchases go well, service is attentive and responsive, rarely try to pull B.S. and when they do, I simply explain how/why what they are claiming isn't accurate and they'll make it right.

Username: atomhawk
Region: Southern Califorina
Dealership Name: McKenna
Sales or Service: Sales
Name of Salesperson/Advisor: Nick LoCasale
Overall Experience (1 lowest 5 highest): 1
Work Performed/Attempted: Lease M3
Recommended? (Yes or No): No
Additional Comments: I will have to admit that this was the most interesting new car buying experience I have ever had. Everything went smoothly in the beginning (sort of). Nick def. knows and loves his cars but the problems started after the sale. First, I noticed that some basic things were missing from the car that I was promised: mats, full tank of gas, etc etc. Then I noticed the rear tow cover was missing... getting all of this stuff was amazingly painful. Then I got a call TWO WEEKS after I bought the car asking me to sign a form saying that I was okay that the car was punched 11 MONTHS AGO effectively shaving a year off of my warranty! How was this not disclosed to me in the beginning?! Needless to say, I did not sign the form and the deal was unwound -- what a waste of time for everyone.

Long Beach BMW

Username: LateBraking
Region: Southern California
Dealership Name: Long Beach BMW
Sales or Service: Service
Name of Salesperson/Advisor: Mariebelle, forgot last name.
Overall Experience (1 lowest 5 highest): 5
Work Performed: Power steering once, faulty ABS secondary pump sensor once.
Recommended? (Yes or No): Yes
Additional Comments: Went in once for my 2008 M3 when the power steering was acting up. They inspected the system, and I believe they flushed it for me. Problem solved. Recently, some brake fluid got on my secondary ABS pump sensor, which caused it to malfunction and go into limp mode. Replaced under warranty and in a timely manner.

Username: richpuer
Region: SoCal
Dealership Name: New Century BMW
Sales or Service: Service
Name of Salesperson/Advisor: Tim West
Overall Experience (1 lowest 5 highest): 6
Work Performed/Attempted: dashboard rattles, loose hood roundel, armrest rattle, seat squeak, brake pedal squeaks)
Recommended? (Yes or No): YES, Highly
Additional Comments: dropped the M3 off this morning...happy to get a loaner car last minute. so far, the people were very nice...Tim was really nice too...easy to deal with...lets hope they fix all my issues/complaints so i can report back here with good news and ratings!

got the car back yesterday...car was NOT WASHED, as per my request, it was in perfect condition...I brought the car in with 5 complaints...5 out of 5 were resolved...This service department is Money...very satisfied at the level of work and knowledge of their technicians. I hope they maintain this standard for years to come...will be taking all my bimmers here from now on.

Pacific BMW

Username: persian54
Region: SoCal
Dealership Name: Pacific BMW
Sales or Service: Service
Name of Salesperson/Advisor: Varies
Overall Experience (1 lowest 5 highest): 5
Work Performed/Attempted: Various services
Recommended? (Yes or No): Yes
Additional Comments: This place is amazing as long as you get the right tech!

Username: LateBraking
Region: Southern California
Dealership Name: Pacific BMW
Sales or Service: Service and parts sales.
Name of Salesperson/Advisor: Started with an R, I completely forgot.
Overall Experience (1 lowest 5 highest): 5 for sales and service.
Work Performed: Transmission replacement.
Recommended? (Yes or No): Yes.
Additional Comments: I did have to go in twice, but the second time I dealt with a service advisor with a name starting with an R, rather than one Hassam Salem. Hassam didn't really do anything, and I left without anything being done the first time, but the other advisor, R, I think Robert maybe? Asian guy. Anyways, he got my transmission replaced on my 2008. Little hassle, little fuss, wasn't exactly the most happy-go-lucky buttery personality guy, but was very straight to the point and got stuff done. Recommended.

Santa Monica BMW

Username :mym3>urcar
Region: California
Dealership Name: Santa Monica BMW
Sales or Service: service
Name of Salesperson/Advisor: Bill
Overall Experience (1 lowest 5 highest): Edited: 5 [Original Comment: 5]
Work Performed/Attempted:
Recommended? (Yes or No): NOOOOOO
Additional Comments: Worst dealership i have ever been to. On two seperate occasions the claimed to have to order some parts from germany and it should take about a month. Then i transfered my car to another dealership (both times), and what a surprise, my car is ready in a couple days. IF YOU GO TO THIS DEALERSHIP THEY WILL FUCK UP YOUR CAR AND KEEP IT FOREVER, THEY ARE MORONS AND SHOULD NOT BE ABLE TO TOUCH BMW'S!!!!!!!!!!Savage BMW

Username: Amirz1000
Region: so cal
Dealership Name: Savage BMW (Ontario, CA)
Sales or Service: both
Name of Salesperson/Advisor: Rowland/Paul Brewer
Overall Experience (1 lowest 5 highest): 5
Work Performed/Attempted: new car sales/reg service/front bushings/fan clutch
Recommended? (Yes or No): Yes
Additional Comments: Paul is great and goes to bat for you. worked with my aftermarket warranter company on my e46 m3. they were very tight and he made them pay for everything that they were supposed to after many calls. Paul also makes sure a certain tech works on my cars since they are M's. Rowland was great to deal with as well when buying my e92 in feb.

Shelly BMW

Username: richpuer
Region: SoCal
Dealership Name: Shelly BMW
Sales or Service: Sales
Name of Salesperson/Advisor: Alana Turner
Overall Experience (1 lowest 5 highest): 5
Work Performed/Attempted: n/a
Recommended? (Yes or No): Yes
Additional Comments: in terms of price, I could have gone to ST to get an even better deal by buying the 4th 2011 of the year but Alana had the car I wanted and I was on deadline to buy this one...i did get a good amount of freebees so that made up for it...but most important, they had the car i wanted and with only 8 miles on it...if i bought it from ST, they would have to trade for it and put on 80 miles + train tickets + time...wouldnt of made much difference anyway...dont get my wrong, i love ST and Ryan and will still be buying all cars from them in the future, as well as referring people there.

Username: persian54
Region: SoCal
Dealership Name: Shelly BMW
Sales or Service: Sales
Name of Salesperson/Advisor: Axel
Overall Experience (1 lowest 5 highest): 4
Work Performed/Attempted: Leased my M3
Recommended? (Yes or No): Yes
Additional Comments: Axel was very helpful throughout the years. He knew I was looking for a car before (335i) but never got it from him (he couldn't get me the car). Knew I wanted a Z4, but couldn't get it at the price I wanted (no one could, I did a lease transfer, only way to get the car I wanted, it was by luck too). And when he knew I was looking for a M3, he got me exactly what I wanted. I paid a little more than I would have wanted to (1k over invoice versus 600 over invoice), but nonetheless I was in an out rather easily. The reason I give a 4 instead of a 5 is that after the deal was done, although he was attentive, he wasn't [i]as[/] attentive as prior to closing the deal. Plus I don't like it when a CA has to keep going to a manager to ask if a price is ok... Great CA nonetheless.

Username: richpuer
Region: SoCal
Dealership Name: Shelly BMW
Sales or Service: Service
Name of Salesperson/Advisor: Gabriel
Overall Experience (1 lowest 5 highest): 3
Work Performed/Attempted: 335i dash rattles, rear deck rattles, humming sound when cruising above 80mph
Recommended? (Yes or No): NO
Additional Comments: SA was nice and friendly, but the techs only resolved 1 out of 3 complaints that i had....they didnt seem to care and thought i was crazy for complaining about rattles....they only fixed the dash rattle but the rest is still there...but the dash rattle they fixed isnt 100% fixed...still comes and goes....i think ill just stop with this brand after these are dust.

South Bay BMW

Username: LateBraking
Region: Southern California
Dealership Name: South Bay BMW
Sales or Service: Sales and Service
Name of Salesperson/Advisor: Mrs. Kim? (Sales, forgot full name), Eric Lopez/Hernandez? (Service)
Overall Experience (1 lowest 5 highest): 4 (Sales) 1 (Service)
Work Performed: Vehicle Sale, Transmission Repair.
Recommended? (Yes or No): Sales Yes, Service No.
Additional Comments: Despite the car having just come out and dealers marking the vehicle up, I got MSPR on the 2008 M3 through Mrs. Kim. Everyone else wanted 5k above MSRP at the time, so I took it. Was not hard to deal with, recommended. Dealt with Eric Lopez/Hernandez for service, and he blatantly lied to me. Said that the shop took apart my transmission and inspected all the synchros individually for problems, and found no faults with it. Since we know that these transmissions are sealed and returned to BMW unopened in the event of a malfunction, clearly he was lying. Stay away for service.

Username: Persian54
Region: SoCal
Dealership Name: South Bay BMW
Sales or Service: Sales
Name of Salesperson/Advisor: Ben?
Overall Experience (1 lowest 5 highest): 5
Work Performed: Looking for an e93 Lease
Recommended? (Yes or No): Yes
Additional Comments: he gave me the best possible lease numbers out of ANYONE (STBMW included). However, the MSRP on their M3 was just too high for me (near 85k) so even with the great deal the $ wasn't worth it for me over the E93 M3 I did get (it had options I didn't care for, like smartphone and stuff). But the CA was very informative and quick in responding. I will definitely try to deal with him again in the future

South County BMW

Username: Mahmood07
Region: San Diego, CA
Dealership Name: BMW South County
Sales or Service: Service
Name of Salesperson/Advisor: Natasha Silveira
Overall Experience (1 lowest 5 highest): 5
Work Performed/Attempted: Steering Angle sensor change, update software, brakes.
Recommended? (Yes or No): Yes
Additional Comments: This is the person to see if you are anywhere near the San Diego area. Very mod friendly, and will go over the top to get your car done perfectly and timely.

Sterling BMW

Username: onnex
Region: So. Cal
Dealership Name: Sterling BMW
Sales or Service: Sales
Name of Salesperson/Advisor: Bobby
Overall Experience (1 lowest 5 highest): 1
Work Performed/Attempted: No
Recommended? (Yes or No): NO!
Additional Comments: Avoid like the plague. Changed my trade-in appraisal on me after committing on a car. Added $1500 to the price of car after committing (for work that never ended up happening, and parts that weren't purchased. Changed their story, and then couldn't refund because "it wasn't in writing".) Full review coming soon, but complete scum bags!

Steve Thomas BMW

Username: 2K12 BMW M3
Region: California
Dealership Name: Steve Thomas BMW
Sales or Service: Sale
Name of Salesperson/Advisor: Ryan Amico
Overall Experience (1 lowest 5 highest): 5
Work Performed/Attempted: Sold Vehicle
Recommended? (Yes or No): Yes
Additional Comments: Very nice ca. Very easy to work with no hassle. I walked out of the dealership in like 15-20min and this was with getting my trade in quote.

Username: richpuer
Region: SoCal
Dealership Name: Steve Thomas BMW
Sales or Service: Service
Name of Salesperson/Advisor: Warren Matsui
Overall Experience (1 lowest 5 highest): 5
Work Performed/Attempted: DCT Transmission failure, 1200mi service
Recommended? (Yes or No): Yes
Additional Comments: Very nice SA, attentive, great attention to details...asked him not to wash my car ONE time, and didnt have to mention it again during subsequent service visits.

Username: OC3
Region: SoCal
Dealership Name: Valencia BMW
Sales or Service: Service
Name of Service Advisor: Mark David
Overall Experience (1 lowest 5 highest): 5+
Work Performed: Lube, Oil & Filter Change
Recommended? (Yes or No): Yes
Additional Comments: Received a $99 promo offer from Valencia BMW for Lube, Oil & Filter Change that was intended for VIN matching my (now gone) 2008 M3 (they obviously didn't know that I now drive a 2011 M3, leased thru another SoCal dealer). Called Mark, he said he'll apply the promo offer to my current M3 *and* did the service on the same day in an hour. Plus, gave me a car wash. Mark came highly recommended from other forum members, and it was every bit true. I had thought I'd never go back to Valencia BMW for service, but I change my mind!

Username: persian54
Region: SoCal
Dealership Name: Valencia BMW
Sales or Service: Service
Name of Salesperson/Advisor: Mark
Overall Experience (1 lowest 5 highest): 4
Work Performed/Attempted: Varies repairs, tire warranty
Recommended? (Yes or No): Yes
Additional Comments: Mark is not mod friendly, but he does get the job done. Helped me out big time when I needed a tire warranty claim before I returned my car

Username: persian54
Region: SoCal
Dealership Name: Valencia BMW
Sales or Service: Sales
Name of Salesperson/Advisor: Hamid/Brandon
Overall Experience (1 lowest 5 highest): 5
Work Performed/Attempted: 2011 Z4 lease
Recommended? (Yes or No): Yes
Additional Comments: Discussed the rate over the phone and email with brandon. Went in, test drove, sealed the deal. No time wasted on negotiations. Would have been in an our in under an hour if I didn't sit there and think about the other Z4 that was 300 miles away. Another buyer was there trying to get the same car. Hamid got me the needed paperwork, I filed it out and got it to the Finance manger first. Thanks to Hamid, I was able to take the car

Region: Idaho

Username: Rolf-Dieter
Region: Idaho USA
Dealership Name: Idaho Falls BMW
Sales or Service: Service
Name of Salesperson/Advisor: Service and Parts Manager
Overall Experience (1 lowest 5 highest): -1
Work Performed/Attempted: see comments below
Recommended? (Yes or No): NO
Additional Comments: While on a US road trip last summer with my then new Z4 35i I experienced a flat on my rear driver site wheel. The flat was due to a crack on my wheel. I was told by this dealership: The US and Canadian Warranty are not the same (this turned out later not to be true) and I only have two options open to me, 1) Be towed to the nearest Canadian dealership by road side assistance or 2) Order a new wheel and have them ship the old one to Canada for warranty claims.

I opted to order a new wheel. Once the dealership received the new wheel (BMW Style 296) they said, sorry we don't change wheels this is done at the tire shop. So I followed the Parts Manager to the tire shop. He introduced me and then promptly left. The shop people there went to work on my old wheel using tire irons and actually damaged my wheel (BMW Canada later declared the wheel bend). While in this tire shop I asked all other wheels to be checked for cracks, this was done and the passenger rear wheel was also found having 2 hairline cracks. I decided to drive home very carefully (3000 KM) with the two hairline cracks.

All this dealership did for me is a) put air in my tires. b) order a new wheel. and c) gave me wrong information about the BMW warranty.

If you live near this dealership avoid it like the plague
The final "Resting Place" of the wheel that I had to drag all the way home in my then 2 seater now a $700- Garden Hose Holder can be seen below, keeping my winter cover company.
I still cannot understand how an organization like BMW AG in Germany permits a Dealership to sell BMW's and not have tire removal and installation service at there facilities. In my book, BMW IDAHO FALLS took me to a tire shop to install a brand new wheel then that tire shop bend my cracked wheel. Then telling me leis that BMW warranty in the US and Canada are not the same ... I drag this wheel all the way back to Canada in a 2 seater sports car then BMW Canada tells me the wheel is bend ... of course it is when the tire shop removed the RFT with 2 tire irons leaving 2 deep gauge marks behind of course it is bend what else does one expect. Now if that is not screwing a customer over I don't know what is.

Region: Michigan

Username: Jjw2331
Region: Southeast Michigan
Dealership Name: Erhard BMW of Bloomfield Hills
Sales or Service: Both
Name of Salesperson/Advisor: David Nank (sales)/Mike Hood (service)
Overall Experience (1 lowest 5 highest): 5
Work Performed/Attempted: Scheduled maintenance, bad ignition coils, broken wheel speed sensor (my fault), squeaky center console, engine replacement (7-series), HPFP recall.
Recommended? (Yes or No): Yes
Additional Comments: Our family has gotten several BMW's at Erhard from David Nank. Very easy to work with. Fights for the price you want. He also sold me my soon to arrive M3. Mike Hood has been great to work with also. He made sure everything was fixed and checked as requested. Doesn't BS you about things you might need on your car (i.e. sludge cleaner). He only cares about making sure your car runs great and is safe to drive.

Region: New Jersey

Username: SergioPark
Region: New Jersey (North)
Dealership Name: BMW of Tenafly
Sales or Service: Sales
Name of Salesperson/Advsor: Ricki Shamen
Overall Experience (1 lowest 5 highest): 5+
Work Performed/Attempted: Ordered 2012 E92 M3
Recommended? (Yes or No): Y
Additional Comments: I cannot say enough good things about Ricki. Very easy to work with, no BS pricing and she helped me through my numerous configuration changes. If you are in the market for a BMW in the NJ area, I would highly recomend talking to Ricki.

Username: Jjw2331
Region: Central New Jersey
Dealership Name: BMW of Mt. Laurel
Sales or Service: Service
Name of Salesperson/Advisor: Bobby Jones
Overall Experience (1 lowest 5 highest): 4
Work Performed/Attempted: Scheduled maintenance, wheel alignment.
Recommended? (Yes or No): Yes
Additional Comments: They finish your car fast, if you have an appointment. Unfortunately, they might be working too fast since they failed to check my alignment when I requested it during my first visit. They fixed my crooked steering wheel and did my alignment after I complained about in a review (I guess some service centers do read them).

Username: DocJohn
Region: Central New Jersey
Dealership Name: Flemington BMW
Sales or Service: Service and Service
Name of Salesperson/Advisor: Service Jim Hierl, sales Ed Kiley
Overall Experience (1 lowest 5 highest): 5
Work Performed/Attempted: Scheduled maintenance, sales of 2012 M3, past sales of 2002 M3
Recommended? (Yes or No): Yes
Additional Comments: A very "high end" experience, and caring staff. Greeted promptly in a brand new indoor enclosed garage. Bright and airy, with open service bays that you can observe. You are offered a beverage and wait in one of several lounges. Appears overstaffed, but that is nice! They introduce you to your tech, and you can request him again for future services. Sales was a breeze. None of the typical nonsense. I sold my porsche to come to this dealership! Overall, good prices, fair treatment and a "ritz carlton" experience. Only ever had one problem there, way back in 2004, and it was fixed with no hassles!

Username: PhillyNate
Region: New Jersey
Dealership Name: BMW of Mt. Laurel
Sales or Service: Both
Name of Salesperson/Advisor: CA Ky Williams/ SA Kurt Foster
Overall Experience (1 lowest 5 highest): 5 for both
Work Performed/Attempted: Sales. Routine maintenance and miscellaneous on 2 BMW's
Recommended? (Yes or No): Yes and Yes
Additional Comments: Had to change CA's in the middle to Ky on my 2011 due to another CA's apathy. Ky was great after that. SA Kurt Foster is awesome and has always done everything I ask provided I bring donuts first.
I go to BMW of Mt. Laurel which is far outta the way for me due to a douchebag sales experience I had with a much closer BMW dealership when seeking a 2008. I swore not to use them for anything after that.

Region: New York

Username: JAdamz
Region: Long Island, NY
Dealership Name: Rallye BMW (Westbury, NY)
Sales or Service: Sales
Name of Salesperson/Advisor: Brian Cano
Overall Experience (1 lowest 5 highest): 5
Work Performed/Attempted: Purchased a new 2011.75 E92, had them install black Performance grills on it, and requested no front plate and no Rallye badge (a plastic badge that they stick on to new cars)
Recommended? (Yes or No): Yes
Additional Comments: Brian Cano was very accomodating to my requests and was willing to work with me on price. His communication was excellent over phone and e-mail throughout the entire ordering process. The other members of the sales team that I dealt with were also knowledgeable, helpful, and friendly. These associates included Michael Corssen (operations manager) and Amanda Tully (business manager). Additionally, on delivery day when a small handprint was seen on a leather seat and some surface scratches were found on one of the Performance grills, they immediately requested the detailing team to attempt to fix the issues, which they succeeded in. While I did remind them about it several times just for my own sanity, the car was delivered without the front plate installed and without a Rallye badge (as requested). A very good experience overall and I would definitely buy from them again!

Username: pman10
Region: NY/CT
Dealership Name: Pace BMW/ BMW of Greenwich
Sales or Service: BOTH
Name of Salesperson/Advisor:
Overall Experience (1 lowest 5 highest): 4
Work Performed/Attempted: Maintenance, servicing
Recommended? (Yes or No): Y
Additional Comments: Both the dealership and service department are knowledgable and competent in their work. Can sometimes be a challenge to get a loaner, though (unless you make an appointment several weeks in advance).

Username: BKMK5
Region: Long Island, NY
Dealership Name: Habberstad
Sales or Service: BOTH
Name of Salesperson/Advisor: Chandler/Mike
Overall Experience (1 lowest 5 highest): 3
Work Performed/Attempted: regular maintenance/HPFP
Recommended? (Yes or No): No
Additional Comments: Sales was good when purchasing my 335i. Would not budge on the M3 ED pricing. What turned me off was the 3 attempts to get my HPFP fixed due to delayed starting. Poor troubleshooting skills on their part. Once the car stalled in the middle of the street and I was furious they replaced the fuel pump and the car ran perfectly ever since!

Region: Pennsylvania

Username: SchnellM3
Region: Pennsylvania
Dealership Name: Faulkner BMW (Lancaster, Pa)
Sales or Service: Both
Name of Salesperson/Advisor: Johnathan Hoxworth
Overall Experience (1 lowest 5 highest): 5
Work Performed/Attempted: All service, installed alarm in 09
Recommended? (Yes or No): Yes
Additional Comments: Jonathan is highly recommended, he is a straight forward person who has a passion for BMW's and is very knowledgeable. He tells you what the bottom line is on what you are doing and doesn't give you the run around. He also doesn't lite up your phone everyday bugging you to come back in. Really down to earth guy, plain and Simple the best car salesman I've ever done business with. I won't buy a BMW from anyone else.

Username: foodle
Region: Pennsylvania
Dealership Name: P&W BMW
Sales or Service: Sales
Name of Salesperson/Advisor: Tom Morgan
Overall Experience (1 lowest 5 highest): 4
Work Performed/Attempted: 2011 E90 M3
Recommended? (Yes or No): Yes
Additional Comments: Great CA to deal with. Got me an e90 M3 allocation when they were getting very rare with no problem. Good to work with. Responsive. But very busy.
Pros: Responsive. No BS. Works hard for the client. Passionate about the cars.
Cons: Not quite as knowledgeable about the cars as some obsessed forum members.

Username: singletrack
Region: Western Pennsylvania
Dealership Name: Sewickley Car Store BMW
Sales or Service: Used them for both
Name of Salesperson/Advisor: Paul Resko (Service Manager) KC Kowalyk (GM)
Overall Experience (1 lowest 5 highest): 1
Work Performed/Attempted: Oil change and normal service on 750Li
Recommended? (Yes or No): No
Additional Comments: See this thread for more details:http://www.m3post.com/forums/showthread.php?t=594515

Region: Texas

Username: Straight Dave
Region: Southwest Houston
Dealership Name: Momentum BMW
Sales or Service: BOTH
Name of Salesperson/Advisor: Devin/Jason
Overall Experience (1 lowest 5 highest): 3
Work Performed/Attempted: Purchase/service
Recommended? (Yes or No): Yes but very subjectively
Additional Comments: I usually never use this dealership but they had the m3 i wanted so had to go there, the salesman was very corteous but lacked any knowledge of the car, even when it came to parts he was a minimal help saying most of the things i wanted have never been done before (Lip, black grilles, etc.) In the end I got the car but he was volatile to say the least when I brought up other BMW dealerships doing a better job then them.

Region: Virginia

Username: E30_80Y
Region: Virginia
Dealership Name: BMW of Fairfax
Sales or Service: Use car/internet sales
Name of Salesperson/Advisor: Andrew Caprio and Mary Webb
Overall Experience (1 lowest 5 highest): 1 or 0 if I could put that
Work Performed/Attempted: Tried buying a used car from their internet ad, I'm in Florida. 2 weeks and I couldn't get the answer I wanted, kept getting the run around and "we will call you right back!" Bulls#it. Even though the car was still available, they couldn't tell me if my loan was approved or not. After 2 weeks, I decided I don't need to buy it from them.
Recommended? (Yes or No): No
Additional Comments: I complained with BMW of North America about the horrible experience and their unprofessional-ism and I also posted of dealership review website.

I had such a great experience working with David and his team at Northwest. David was able to provide me with all the info that I needed, responded promptly to questions I had, and when the car was ready for pick up everything was taken care of. I seriously couldn't have asked for a smoother transaction.

Username: Wooderson
Region: NY/Long Island
Dealership Name: Habberstad BMW Bayshore
Sales or Service: Service
Name of Salesperson/Advisor: Conigliaro
Overall Experience (1 lowest 5 highest): 2
Work Performed/Attempted: Oil service, service engine light on
Recommended? (Yes or No): No
Additional Comments: Brought in car for oil service and to get a service engine light diagnosed. Was quoted $400.00 for just an oil change. When I asked why other dealers do the same service for under $200 he said that they must have had a promo or something, complete BS. The fuel pump and fuel pump sensor were replaced to remedy the service engine prob. Three days after getting the car back it stalled on the highway with my 8 yr old in back seat when I was doing 60+ mph. Had to get a tow to dealer at my own expense. Dealer said that all the coils misfired and caused the stall. They were replaced. When I finally read the work order it plainly said that there was an empty gas tank code. What it didn't say was that it ran out of gas because of the botched fuel pump install that caused the fuel guage to give a faulty reading. On my final visit they ran out of loaner cars even though I made an appointment that day specifically because they said they would have loaners. I got a Hertz Mazda that I had to pay insurance for. When they replaced the the fuel pump for the second time they charged me for a half a tank of fuel because they said they had to top of tank to check fuel sensor. I filled the tank up the night before I dropped it off. They did not give a receipt for the fuel they supposedly put in the car.

(Edit): The car went in for a fourth time because the original problem presented itself again, service engine light back on for emissions problem. They replaced fuel pump control unit. Total cost of repairs to date, over $3000.00 for an emissions diagnosis and repair.

Region: NYC
Dealership Name: Rallye BMW
Sales or Service: Service
Name of Salesperson/Advisor: Dennis
Overall Experience (1 lowest 5 highest): 5
Work Performed/Attempted: Replacement of tire/break in service.
Recommended? (Yes or No): YES
Additional Comments: Dennis is the guy to see if you have an M and are in the NYC/LI area. He is always incredibly helpful, professional, and a fellow enthusiast. I would recommend him hands down over anyone else there.

I had an absolutely wonderful and fantastic experience purchasing a car from Perillo BMW. I just took delivery of a brand new 2013 Alpine White M3, one of the last naturally aspirated V-8 M3's to ever be made.

Originally, I had walked in off the street since I was in the preliminary stages of purchasing a car and I wanted to compare the Audi's (who's dealership was across the street) with the BMW. Initially, I was shopping for a sports sedan so I was comparing a 2013 BMW 335ix to Audi's A4/S4. Frank assisted from me since day one and took the time to show me their inventory and emailed me all the information I had asked for while we were there.

Fast forward a couple months, and I came to the conclusion that I wanted to purchase/lease and 2013 M3. The only problem was that it was now May 2013 and BMW was set to end production within two months. Finding an allocation (and not get price gouged for it) proved to be quite difficult. Even though Perillo had no allocations left, Frank and his finance manager was able to to secure me an allocation so that I could order my car to MY specifications. Working with Frank was quite flawless and he was able to attend to all my questions and concerns. With Frank's help, I was able to secure an allocation for a new M3 to be built specifically for me, he was able to take advantage of a $1500 BMW incentive, and he assisted with my trade-in and financing. All of this was handled via email and was quite seamless, I really only had to go into the dealer in person when I wanted to see something in person.

When it was time to take delivery, Frank pretty much gave me as much up-to-date information as possible. I was even able to take delivery the day the car arrived at the dealer. Delivery date was pretty much as close to "sign then drive" as you can get. Other than a little wait (since there was only one finance manager on duty at the time). Delivery was smooth and everything that was arranged via email was as is when it came time to signing....no games, no gimmicks, no funny business.

As far as the purchasing process is concerned, I can't give a higher recommendation for Frank Billman. Without his assistance, I wouldn't have the car of my dreams.

One of the most horrible dealerships I have been to! They overcharge for repairs, my seatbelt extenders cost me $500 to repair ( I should have done a DIY)
Then I wanted to look at an M3 and the Sales rep made me wait 2 hours (by my watch) to give me a quote for my trade in. They never provide any loaner cars because they claim they are very busy. Service is equally horrible. After 3 days of leaving my car in there, they were not able to take a look at it. Then on the 5th day they told me it would cost $5000 to repair my axle because it was bent. I dont know how it could get bent. And said a lot of parts were rusted so they needed to be replaced and were not covered under CPO! Contacted BMW of N.A and did not get much of a response. My friends have had a similar experience. They are a public company (Sonic Automotive dealer) and there is no drive to sell or excel in customer care. As compared to Columbia, MO where JOE MACHENS BMW manager would at least listen to me and try to accommodate me. And I baby my cars! My Cars are hand waxed every other weekend. I am trying to avoid buying an M3 while in Birmingham, Alabama!

Region: Oregon
Dealership Name: Kuni BMW
Sales or Service: Sales
Name of Salesperson/Advisor: Steve Cho
Overall Experience (1 lowest 5 highest): 2
Work Performed/Attempted: N/A
Recommended? (Yes or No): No
Additional Comments: Assisted a family member on checking one of their vehicles they had on the lot the other day. The SA named above was kind enough for us to test drive the car while he waited in his office however we ended up walking away since they were not willing to deal. Came home to an email from Steve asking for feedback so I gave it to him with comparing other dealerships that are willing to deal and received the following response:

^^nice! thanks for the REV Im sure the team liked it! I wish I was there to hear it, I bet the set up is loud!

you should have stopped in and said hi to David Aviles he was there. We also had 2 forum members pick up cars yesterday

__________________

BEFORE YOU BUY YOUR NEXT BMW, PM ME FIRST WE CAN HOOK YOU UP!Jimmy Bach: jbach@stevethomasbmw.com - Cell:805-807-1989
If you have any issues getting a hold of Jimmy B PLEASE PM me, I'm available everyday till 545pm!

you should have stopped in and said hi to David Aviles he was there. We also had 2 forum members pick up cars yesterday

Jimmy, why does the parts department guy doesn't even know your name. I stopped by last July to purchase a quart of oil before heading out to Santa Ynez Valley for some wine tasting; the guy behind the counter didn't even recognized your name.