Peer Review Guidelines

Boffin Access Limited - Peer Review Guidelines for Authors

Boffin Access follows widely accepted and well established guidelines of double-blind peer review process. This method requires that both the authors' and reviewers' identities are hidden from each other, thus reducing any likelihood of bias from reviewers while it also prevents the authors from contacting the reviewers to affect the review outcome. In a double-blind review, authors and reviewers are equally responsible for preserving the integrity of the review process. Both parties are expected to behave responsibly and ethically throughout the process.

Authors submitting articles to our journals need to ensure that their identities are not disclosed to the reviewers either directly or indirectly, any information that could indicate otherwise must be stripped from the manuscript. Authors need to submit a cover letter containing the article title, author(s) details, affiliations, contact information and acknowledgements in the separate file from the blinded manuscript. Here are some additional steps to ensure compliance with the double-blind review.

Tables or figures cited in the manuscript must not bear any affiliation related identifier

Remove any references to your funding sources

Use third person to refer to any previously published work

Limit self references

Essential reference to previous work should be anonymised and cited as, '[Anonymous, 2010] Details hidden for double-blind review'

Do not include acknowledgements, this section must be submitted separately with the cover letter

Remove any identifying information from the files, including any metadata/properties such as 'Document author...'