So as you can see, Madson is my weak link. He's not full time closer and I'm trying to lure either Nunez or Wilson from the other team.

Who should I offer up? Keeping in mind that Wilson or Nunez can finish the season as high, or higher than the likes of CJ Wilson and Chachin. I don't mind to give up one of my pitchers but can't decide who to offer.

If this league values closers higher than usual, you may have to give up something good. in my league closers are cheap. nobody really puts too much into them. i think Neftali Feliz went for 11 bucks because he was looking like a possible SP before the season, but thats the highest the closer price went.

If he needs hitting, start with offering Rollins possibly? its hard to think up a deal not knowing this guys team needs.

If he needs a SP, offer Garcia or CJ Wilson?

although im unfamiliar with how to value an elite closer in a league that puts extra value on them.