Feedback is an essential part of the map making process. It allows the mapmaker to get different perspectives and find out what people like and don't like about their map. It also sheds light on any flaws in gameplay or graphics which the mapmaker did not see. For someone that wants to be involved but doesn't have the artistic knack, giving good feedback is a great way to become a vital part of the foundry. If you regularly give good feedback, you will become well liked by the mapmakers, Foundry Assistants and Moderators (members who are in charge of stamping maps). Not only that, but you will make a noticeable impact on the quality of the maps the foundry produces.

The best feedback comes from people who have put a little bit of thought into their post(s), and

a. Adds something to the development of a map.b. Identifies specific elements/issues which do or don't work in their eyes.c. Offers some kind of alternative or solution to any problems/issues.

So, how do you give good feedback? There's no one way to do it, but here are a few general guidelines to think about: