DVDActive uses cookies to remember your actions, such as your answer in the poll. Cookies are
also used by third-parties for statistics, social media and advertising. By using this website, it is
assumed that you agree to this.

Fantastic Four Regional Differences

Chris Gould takes a look at the variation between the UK and Hong Kong discs

With the recent DVD release of the Fantastic Four came the prospect of yet more confusing variations between the differing regions. I thought it might be useful to take a look at some of these differences, which are a great advertisement for the freedom afforded to owners of multi-regional DVD players. To be honest there aren't as many changes as there would be in, say, a director's cut, but there are enough to potentially upset those expecting certain scenes.

The most widely-recognised difference between the two versions of the film is the scene in which Reed and Sue first begin to rekindle their romance. In the UK theatrical cut and DVD release this takes place during a walk with a view of the Statue of Liberty, as evidenced by this screen capture.

The original version of this moment is known as the 'Planetarium with a Kiss' scene, which was included in the theatrical cut in territories such as Hong Kong, France and Germany, as evidenced by this screen capture.

However, this scene is actually truncated from the original version, ending in a rather abrupt close-up of Reed before the actual kiss takes place. The full scene is included in the deleted scenes section of the bonus disc and plays a little better, as evidenced by this screen capture.

A curious change, if ever I saw one. However, there is yet more to come. As well as the visual differences, the Hong Kong DVD release also omits one or two lines of dialogue during the climactic battle towards the end of the film. In the UK theatrical and DVD versions Dr. Doom says the line 'Goodbye, Ben' as he walks towards the Thing with a steel girder, but this line is missing from the Hong Kong DVD release. Click here for a clip from the UK disc, or here for the same scene Hong Kong style.

Next up we have another visual difference between the UK and Hong Kong DVD releases. During the scene in which Dr. Doom is caught in the nova flame, he turns to camera and lets out a yell. In the UK release the yell is just that, as evidenced by the screen capture below.

However, the Hong Kong release adds a small visual effect to the scene. When Doom turns and yells, a fiery breath is emitted, as you can see from the screen capture.

This is a neat little touch, but another curious difference. The next variation is once again of the aural variety. After Doom emerges from the nova flame in the UK version he says the lines ‘Is that the best you can do? A little heat?’ before he is doused in water. However, the Hong Kong release omits the ‘A little heat?’ portion of the dialogue Click here for a clip from the UK disc, or here for the same scene from the Hong Kong release.

The final change during the confrontation relates to the way in which our heroes defeat Doom. In the UK release the Thing breaks open a fire hydrant and Mr. Fantastic uses his body to direct the jet towards the molten villain. This can be seen in this screen capture.

However, in the Hong Kong release the Thing doesn’t appear to need Mr. Fantastic’s help, as he is solely responsible for directing the jet with his foot, as evidenced by this screen capture. Oddly, Mr. Fantastic still has wet hair in the following shot, indicating that the effect was always supposed to appear!

The final change occurs during Reed's proposal to sue on the boat at the end of the film. In the UK theatrical and DVD versions Reed can be seen bending down on one knee while using his stretching powers to maintain eye level with Sue. Here's the screen capture for proof.

However, the Hong Kong release completely omits this shot, instead showing Reed kneeling down to propose without the aid of his powers. Here's the screen capture.

One last thing I'd like to mention is the difference between Dr. Doom's voice in the region two and region three releases. In the UK version his voice sounds almost natural, while the Hong Kong version has him sounding more like he's talking through a mask. It's particularly evident during the scene in which he tortures Mr. Fantastic.

Click here for a clip from the UK release, and here for a clip from the Hong Kong disc. Remind anyone of the aliens from the mini-series V?

Well there you go. There are enough changes in this one to upset those who are familiar with the film, but overall none of the alterations really have an effect on the plot. In fact, a couple of them actually improve the film (I never liked the way Reed looked during his 'stretch' proposal for one thing). If pushed I'd have to say that the UK version just edges out the Hong Kong release because it's more 'polished', but the differences are negligible. I do like the more 'mechanical' voice used for Doom in the Hong Kong release, and those of you unfamiliar with the film might want to plump for that disc simply because it's cheaper and comes packaged in an extremely nice Digipak, as opposed to the boring old Amaray used in other territories. It also appears to have a slightly better transfer than the region two release. Choice is the best thing about owning a multi-regional player and in this case the choice, as they say, is yours.

Advertisements

Comments

Reply

Message

Enter the message here then press submit. The username, password and message are required. Please make the message constructive, you are fully responsible for the legality of anything you contribute. Terms & conditions apply.

(as from the other article) Great stuff Chris! As mentioned before, dvdcompare is a great site for this type of thing, also, for cuts down under (region 4 that is) try Michael DVD's references or Rod Williams site. Quite simply, if you want a movie in it's entirity then do your research for the best version!

Yeah, I do respect other people's opinions, but you will find that I am very opinionated. I hope to be a movie journalist, a.k.a. movie critic someday. Anyway, this film did have its moments, and I loved the cast. Overall, the story wasn't very enjoyable. I'll take Spider-Man 1 and 2, X-Men 1,2, (3 looks awesome) and Batman Begins any day. Perhaps I'll check out the Dircetor's Cut of this when it's released.

Speaking of which, is there much of anything added to the Elektra Director's Cut? I only noticed there's three minutes added. Director Rob Bowman made such a big deal in an interview before its release saying this cut changes the overall tone of the film. How can that be accomplished in three additional minutes?

As I said in the article, it's not in the German or French release. The version shown in the US, Canada, UK, Australia, New Zealand, Japan, Korea and the Philippines has the Reed and Sue Walk scene. All other territories got the planetarium scene (although the Canadian DVD reportedly has the Hong Kong alterations).

Yeah why the change for the DVD release. It is so weird. I am almost positive the scene at the end with the stretching is not included on the German release. In the German version it is a normal proposing

Actually, what I heard is that there was changes having to be done in the Fantastic Four, but not as many as you uncovered... and Kyle, the film wasn't that bad. Granted, it had some moments especially Chris Evan's character, but I don't think it was that bad. Really, I liked the movie. But... it's your opinion and I'll respect that.

And Chris, anyword on the S.E of the film yet? I know it's a bit early, but I'm looking forward to it. I heard that there were many scenes deleted in the final cut.