Favorite Teams

Umpires Greg Gibson (53) and Bill Miller wear headsets during a play review at the request of Tampa Bay Rays manager Joe Maddon during a baseball game between the Rays and the Baltimore Orioles, Monday, April 14, 2014, in Baltimore. (AP Photo/Patrick Semansky)

Major League Baseball's expanded replay system is just a few weeks old, but many have already made up their minds about whether it's good for the game or not.

Here's a look at some early reaction to replay -- the good and the bad -- from around the league, as well as a rundown of the biggest midweek headlines from around the league:

Expanded replay: the good and the bad

Through Monday, 30 calls made by umpires had been overturned out of 89 total challenges under MLB's new replay system this season. Thirty-three calls had been confirmed and the remaining 25 plays stood as called because of a lack of "clear and convincing" evidence.

"We've had really very little controversy overall," Selig said Tuesday at the MLB Diversity Business Summit. "Everything in life will have a little glitch here and there where you do something new. And are our guys on top of it? You bet. But I'm saying to you again, you'll hear about the one or two controversies, but look at all the calls that have been overturned."

The biggest controversy to arise with the advent of expanded replay challenges one of the most basic tenets of baseball -- the definition of a catch.

Confusion about the league's new interpretation of a catch has come up a number of times on "transfer" plays, when a fielder initially controls the ball before losing control while transferring the ball from his glove to his throwing hand.

Selig wouldn't say whether the league will make any mid-season changes to the new replay rules, but continued controversy surrounding the transfer rule might force the league's hand.

Here's Exhibit A:

In season's past, there might have been little to no drama after this play. This season, however, the play was reviewed and overturned. Rangers manager Ron Washington argued the play and was promptly ejected: (via Yahoo! Sports)

"We've got to do something about it," Washington told reporters. "I understand the rule and I understand their interpretation of it. I just don't agree with it."

Exhibit B:

The Athletics' Yoenis Cespedes believed his liner to be caught (it technically wasn't), so he headed to the dugout and was called out for leaving the base path. And in another play from the same game, a fly ball dropped on the transfer resulted in Brandon Moss and Josh Donaldson passing each other on the base paths.

Moss granted the new enforcement of transfer - from glove to hand - rules are intended to eliminate the gray areas of possession and exchange (particularly during double plays turned at second base), just like the new replay system is designed to offer more clarity. But after living through several iffy transfer calls and seeing replays of others in other games, Moss isn't so sure.

Seemingly an outfielder could secure a ball in his glove and run all the way into the infield before dropping the ball when he goes to take it out of his glove with his bare hand and the batter would be ruled safe. Let's think about how insane that sounds and then realize that is how it's being called right now.

To compound matters, the baserunners are left in no man's land while waiting to see when the outfielder is going to try and make the transfer.

It wouldn't be too difficult to make the rule discretionary. Just say the player attempting to make a catch has to have secured the baseball within his glove in order for it to be a catch. Reasonable people can see a catch and realize if the ball has been secured. Some can argue the discretionary calls at times but they already do that with the strike zone.

Red Sox manager John Farrell has likely been the most vocal in his disdain for the replay system, publicly criticizing the system after being ejected Sunday in a game against the Yankees for arguing a replay ruling.

Torre told the Daily News: "I'm not going to suspend him. It will be a fine. I'm sorry about what he said. What I try to do in whatever I do in this job that the commissioner has imported me to do, is basically never forget what it's like to be a player or a manager.

"Part of that never forgetting are the feelings, especially when you're dealing with Red Sox-Yankees games," Torre said. "There is nothing that is insignificant about anything that happens in those games."

Baseball honors Jackie Robinson

In this 1952 file photo, Brooklyn Dodgers baseball player Jackie Robinson poses. Baseball holds tributes across the country on Jackie Robinson Day, Tuesday, April 15, 2014, the 67th anniversary marking the end of the game's racial barrier. (AP Photo/File)

Each year, on the anniversary of Jackie Robinson's first major league game, every player around the league wears Robinson's No. 42 to honor the breaking of baseball's color barrier. Tuesday marked 67 years since Robinson took the first major step toward ending segregation in sports.

Selig frequently points out that Robinson's first game occurred more than a year before President Harry Truman desegregated the U.S. military and seven years before the Supreme Court's Brown v. Board of Education decision that ruled state laws requiring segregated public schools were unconstitutional.

"Baseball must continue to be more than just a game on the field," Selig said. "The game's remarkable ability to serve as a common bond should be used to create opportunities for all people regardless of race, religion, sexual orientation or gender."

In 10 seasons, Robinson was a six-time All-Star, won Rookie of the Year in 1947, won a World Series and finished with a career .311 batting average.

While Robinson is deservedly the face of the movement that desegregated baseball, there were 15 other players who broke the color line on each of the other teams of that era. Arguably the most important of which was Larry Doby, who broke the American League's color line just 81 days after Robinson first played in the National League, at a time when there was hardly any interaction between the two leagues: (via Sports Illustrated)

Doby's importance to the success of integration has been unfairly overshadowed by the deserving celebration of Robinson. However, it is fair to say that Doby's impact on the field wasn't truly felt until the following season. Whereas Robinson took the field as part of the Dodgers' starting lineup on Opening Day and in all but three games thereafter that season for the NL champions, Doby debuted as a seventh-inning pinch-hitter in a midseason game, striking out in place of Cleveland pitcher Bryan Stephens, and drew just one start on the season, that coming on July 6. Primarily a pinch-hitter, Doby hit a mere .156 in 29 games, appearing in the field in just six of them.

In 1948, however, he was Cleveland's Opening Day rightfielder and hit .301/.384/.490 in 121 games for a pennant-winning Indians team. He would make the All-Star team in each of the next seven seasons and ultimately join Robinson in the Hall of Fame.

Injury news and notes: Another elbow bites the dust

Tampa Bay Rays starting pitcher Matt Moore, left, walks off the field with a trainer following an injury during the sixth inning of the MLB American League baseball game against the Kansas City Royals at Kauffman Stadium in Kansas City, Mo., Monday, April 7, 2014. (AP Photo/Orlin Wagner)

Tampa Bay Rays left-hander Matt Moore will sit out the rest of this season after opting for elbow-ligament replacement surgery. Moore experienced soreness in his elbow April 7 and knew surgery was inevitable Monday after attempting to throw one pitch.

Rays manager Joe Maddon sees the positives and negatives of Moore choosing surgery, hoping that after a successful operation Moore can get back to his winning ways: (via ESPN)

"It's awful, but it's great," Maddon said. "It's awful that we're going to miss this guy for a bit. It's good for him to be able to get past this moment and look forward to a really long and prosperous career. Almost all of the time, percentage-wise, it's a very successful operation."

"Major League Baseball gets the blame for pitchers getting injured," said Glenn Fleisig, research director at the prestigious American Sports Medicine Institute in Birmingham, Ala. "But the fact is these pitchers definitely have some damage in their arm when they get them."

• Padres pitcher Josh Johnson, who hasn't pitched this season after straining his elbow in spring training, will give Dr. James Andrews a visit about his balky elbow. Johnson underwent Tommy John surgery in 2007 and suffered from shoulder inflammation in 2011. (via CBS Sports)

"You miss it when you're gone," Bourn said. "You don't know it, but you miss being in the big leagues and being able to come in here with the fellas and go about your everyday business and have an opportunity to play at the top level every day. I'm ecstatic to be back and ready to join the team and try to help every way I can."

Mark Teixeira, the brittle first baseman, sidelined again, has no real backup, except for Kelly Johnson, the third baseman who by trade is actually a second baseman. The second baseman, Brian Roberts -- can barely straighten his barking back, which means the backup third baseman, Yangervis Solarte, is needed there.

Follow Us

cleveland.com is powered by Plain Dealer Publishing Co. and Northeast Ohio Media Group. All rights reserved (About Us).The material on this site may not be reproduced, distributed, transmitted, cached or otherwise used, except with the prior written permission of Northeast Ohio Media Group LLC.