Traditional 5x5, 10 team keeper league and each team keeps 5 players. I have the first overall pick. Theoretically, the top 50 players are off the board. Considering my keepers (Beltran, Thome, B Boone, Pierre, J Santana) I have narrowed my pick down to the following, how do you rank them?

I would say Either Wells or Beckett. In 5X5 I like Beckett over Mulder.

You need pitching, but I would lean towards Wells since he has significantly more Value than any others on the board. Santana is solid, but not a staff Ace as of yet IMO. If you take Wells, at some point you will probably need to deal for a quality SP and if you do, you can probably pretty much have your pick if you need to deal Wells, provided he contiues to build on last season

Traditional 5x5, 10 team keeper league and each team keeps 5 players. I have the first overall pick. Theoretically, the top 50 players are off the board. Considering my keepers (Beltran, Thome, B Boone, Pierre, J Santana) I have narrowed my pick down to the following, how do you rank them?