The look on the two men’sfaces said it all, and after getting over the initial horror, Steve had a tip for Sherri. “Sherri, listen to me,” Steve said. “This thing we’re doing, this is a game show. This isn’t therapy. You know, you’re not supposed to be up here to get out your innermost thoughts.”

But Sherri wasn’t going to shrink from her answer. “I just thought most of America would feel that way if they’ve been through something,” Sherri said.

Unfortunately, Sherri’s answer didn’t cut it, but she got another crack at it when it came back around to her, and she revealed even more about herself. “OK, this is something both me and my ex-husbands did all the time when we [were] in the bedroom. We did role play.” Steve replied: “You know one of them role plays got out of hand — that’s when he got his penis cut off.”