Transcription

1 Research Re-Examined AACSB s Impact of Research Task Force generates much dialogue and debate as it issues a report that calls for new ways to measure faculty scholarship. by Sharon Shinn Academic research is one of the key functions of business schools, but its importance sometimes goes unappreciated. On the one hand, the general public often is unaware of the advances that have been made possible because of academic research. On the other hand, members of the academic community sometimes voice criticisms about the relevance of business research in the real world. Because research is so essential to the part that business schools play in society, AACSB International has recently re-examined the role of research and management education. Last year, the association released a preliminary report that proposed changes to the way business schools and accreditation committees evaluate research. The report calls for schools to align their research outputs with their missions, while finding ways to increase the value of their research to students, practitioners, and society at large. The report, written by members of the Impact of Research Task Force, was released in draft form last August. AACSB invited comments from members before producing a final version, due to be published in late January. If, as expected, its recommendations are implemented by AACSB s Board of Directors, the report eventually could have a profound influence on the way business school research is conducted, measured, and shared with the world. While many hurdles still lie ahead, they are all surmountable, according to Joseph Alutto, who chaired the task force. Alutto is executive vice president and provost of The Ohio State University in Columbus. Here he offers responses to the concerns of AACSB members who shared their observations about the report. The Impact of Research The report s first and most controversial recommendation is that AACSB change accreditation standards to require schools to demonstrate the impact of faculty intellectual contributions to targeted audiences. In essence, the task force suggests that existing guidelines be amended to focus on outcomes, not inputs. Schools would be required not just to keep track of refereed journal articles published by their faculty, but also to demonstrate the impact of all types of scholarship. It wouldn t matter what forms that scholarship took or whether the impact was on practice, theory development, or teaching and learning. Under this system, schools would tie scholarship more closely to their own missions, a notion that aligns smoothly with AACSB s mission-based accreditation. However, the report acknowledges that it would not be easy to switch to such a model. Schools would need to find ways to gauge the impact of research; they also would have to convince faculty and administrators that various forms of scholarship are equally worthwhile, not only as part of the accreditation process, but as part of the tenure and promotion process. 42

2 illustration by Neil Brennan 43

3 Administrators need to think ahead of time about what information they ll need to demonstrate their faculty s scholarship and to show how that scholarship is appropriate for their schools missions. Joseph Alutto, The Ohio State University While many members applaud the move and are supportive of the recommendation, many also foresee difficulties in implementation. In fact, early readers of the report had a number of questions and concerns, most of which fell into several broad categories: n The burden to schools. Many members felt that supplying the data would be difficult and expensive for schools particularly small schools that focus more on practice and pedagogy. But Alutto believes the burden would not be nearly as onerous as some fear. We re not asking for any more information than the schools should normally be collecting, he says. The reality is, we all have to have mission statements, and those statements all have to include some reference to faculty scholarship. We then have to measure the impact of that scholarship to judge if we re achieving our missions. This is exactly what we tell corporate officials they should do identify objectives, identify metrics, and then translate them to individual contributions. Once deans think it through, most of them will realize What Did the Report Say? The report prepared by AACSB s Impact of Research Task Force summarized the history of the relationship between business schools and research. It noted that accredited business schools spend an estimated $320 million every year to support faculty research. Much of that research is published in scholarly journals: AACSB estimates that more than 15,000 English-language business and management articles appear every year, produced by roughly 25,000 academically qualified faculty members. Clearly, research is a cornerstone in the value proposition of business schools, but there is still dissent about what kind of research should be pursued and how it should be offered to practitioners, students, and society. A business school cannot separate itself from practice to focus only on theory and still serve its function, write the authors of the report. On the other hand, it cannot be so focused on practice that it fails to support development insights into principles and theories that serve to increase understanding of practice. Whether research is conducted with a practical or theoretical aim, the authors note three central problems. First is the transfer of knowledge from the academic community to the business community since the dense and highly theoretical research papers that appear in scholarly journals aren t widely accessible to the general public. Second is the determination of what qualifies as high-quality research, a definition hotly debated in the academic community. The third trouble spot is the fact that the faculty tenure and compensation process tends to give more weight to research that is published in peer-reviewed journals without assigning much importance to work that appears in other media, including trade journals, popular press business books, or software. The same accusation is leveled at accreditation teams, which often judge a school s research output only by the research that appears in those same top journals. Determining that it is critical that business schools find ways to continuously enhance the value and visibility of scholarship and research, the task force has developed seven recommendations for AACSB to pursue: 1. Extend and augment accreditation guidelines to require schools to demonstrate the impact of faculty intellectual contributions to targeted audiences. 2. Encourage and support efforts to create incentives for greater diversity in institutional missions and faculty intellectual contributions. 3. Support studies examining the link between scholarly inquiry and education in degree and nondegree programs. 4. Develop an awards program to recognize and publicize high-impact research by faculty. 5. Develop mechanisms to strengthen interaction between academics and practicing managers in the production of knowledge in the areas of greatest interest. 6. Study the community of business and management journals and make recommendations designed to highlight the impact of faculty research. 7. Identify and disseminate information about best practices for creating links between academic research and practice. To download a copy of the report and find additional information, visit 44

4 that their schools already have much of the information in hand, Alutto believes. And it isn t that difficult to collect the rest. It does mean administrators need to think ahead of time about what information they ll need to demonstrate their faculty s scholarship and to show how that scholarship is appropriate for their schools missions. This recommendation is all about alignment. n Measuring results. Members who read the early draft also worried about how difficult it would be to actually measure the impact of research. They pointed out that it is nearly impossible to quantify the long-term effect of research on teaching and management practice, and it is equally difficult to gauge impact if research leads a practitioner not to follow a certain course. The authors of the report anticipated this worry when they wrote, Clearly, AACSB must take the lead in helping schools develop useful and appropriate measures of impact, as well as systems for collecting and maintaining the data. Alutto adds, If we re serious about schools identifying specific missions and then aligning faculty scholarship with those missions, then we must expect accreditation review teams to make judgments based on that set of objectives as well as on other metrics for measuring institutional and individual performance. This approach gets to the heart of the mission-based accreditation process. n Training requirements. Members pointed out that school administrators weren t the only ones who would have to learn to judge the impact of research accurately. Accreditation review teams would also need to be trained to make those judgments. Alutto concedes that retraining will be required if this recommendation is accepted, but he believes many teams will welcome the chance to weigh diverse forms of scholarship instead of limiting their review to research published in top-tier journals. For instance, he says, accreditation teams might visit an urban school that does an excellent job working with the regional community; there, they ll expect to find faculty research focused on local economic development. It s very frustrating for the accreditation review team when the administrators have to pretend that they have this broader function of developing new theories when that s not really their strength, he says. The new approach would allow those schools to define their comparative advantage and then remain accountable in terms of how well they fulfill that mission. n Institutional acceptance. Some members had questions regarding the buy-in of university officials. Even if business school deans embrace a new approach to measuring impact, will university administrators be as easy to convince? Will they agree that business schools should be allowed to weigh contributions to practice and pedagogy as much as they would weigh other kinds of intellectual contributions? 45

5 A commitment to research will continue to define management education in the years to come. Alutto believes that top administrators at certain universities will be much quicker to accept the proposed recommendations than others. Administrators at large institutions among the top 30 schools already recognize that there s a mix of scholarship, he says. They know that some faculty are committed to top-tier research publications, while others provide research that has an impact on practice. For these institutions, this approach is really nothing more than a verification of what s already happening. At other institutions, acceptance of these recommendations will take some education on what the purpose of a business school really is. That s where AACSB comes in, he adds. We believe that AACSB must be more active in accurately portraying the role of a business school in a university setting. Presidents of universities have to learn to say, What is the mission of my business school? If it s teaching, we ought to be rewarding scholarship that supports that mission. If it s to work closely with regional firms, then the scholarship of the faculty should be consistent with that. That s the point AACSB will need to make as it plays this advocacy role. Diversity of Scholarship The other six recommendations listed in the initial report have not been nearly as controversial as the first one. Nonetheless, the second recommendation, which encourages schools to reward more diverse approaches to scholarship, is regarded by some business school leaders as unrealistic. These respondents consider it virtually impossible to overcome the powerful incentives created by tenure and promotion committees, academic job markets, and journal editors. Again, the authors of the report anticipated this concern, and they admit that changing the incentive structure will be challenging. They note that AACSB will have to support such efforts by helping to develop these new models or advocating for them with university administration. Several of the report s other recommendations address the divide between practical and theoretical research that is, between research with an obvious application in the business world and purer research that is not designed to have an immediate impact on practice. While the authors of the report argue for both rigor and relevance, it s clear they believe there needs to be more communication between academics and practitioners and more ways to publicize the value of research. One of the task force s recommendations encourages schools and executives to work together to identify re search areas of the greatest common interest. Another promotes the idea that AACSB should work with existing journals, or perhaps create new knowledge portals, to more widely disseminate faculty research and translate it for practitioners. And to make sure vibrant new research is getting the attention it deserves, the task force makes two recommendations: that AACSB develop an awards program to recognize high-impact research, and that the association disseminate information on best practices regarding the links between research and practice. It s not yet clear how some of these recommendations might become reality. For instance, Alutto notes that AACSB might consider allying with some of the major research journals to find ways to translate and publish scholarly research in more accessible terms. Nonetheless, the intent of the task force members is plain: They want business school research of all kinds to be more diverse, more visible, and more accessible. And they want business schools to work with AACSB to promote these goals. Facing the Challenges It s clear that there are significant challenges and changes ahead in the way business schools conduct, measure, and share research. Yes, these recommendations mean changes for business schools, says Alutto. Yes, they mean that not all schools would be required to fit one mold. But we gave up the one-mold approach years ago with the mission-based accreditation process. The plan to tie research requirements to a school s mission is a strategy that will be successful for institutions both inside and outside the U.S., Alutto believes. Schools that are embedded in very different sociopolitical settings have clear differences in mission, he says. This approach allows us to focus on the quality of impact that faculty scholarship is having, regardless of where the school is located. Schools and individual faculty alike are known by their research and honored for their contributions to the world s expanded pool of knowledge. There is no question that a commitment to research will continue to define management education in the years to come. But how management educators define research could have a profound effect on the future of business schools and their place in the world. z 46

Contents: UNIVERSITY OF ROCHESTER William E. Simon Graduate School of Business Administration Proposal for a Clinical Faculty Track 1. Rationale and Objectives of the Proposal 2. The Simon School Mission

College of Business and Economics, CSU East Bay Criteria for Scholarly Academics (SA), Practice Academics (PA), Instructional Practitioners (IP), and Scholarly Practitioners (SP) Preamble: We the faculty

The School of Education & Human Services The University of Michigan Flint Standards and Criteria for Promotion and Tenure Introduction The primary mission of the University of Michigan Flint is to be the

COLLEGE OF BUSINESS AND TECHNOLOGY FACULTY QUALIFICATIONS AND ENGAGEMENT AACSB International accreditation Standard 15 requires accredited schools to develop policies, aligned with the CBT s mission, that

B. Scholarly Activity Scholarly Activity is an essential part of University life and development and encompasses the many pursuits that broaden and expand the learning communities in which faculty function

Centers & Institutes Description Centers and institutes are established within the University to strengthen and enrich programs of research, instruction or public service conducted by the faculty and staff.

Standards for Faculty Sufficiency & Faculty Qualifications This document provides the College of Business Administration at The University of Texas Pan American the definitions for and maintenance of the

DOES ONLINE LEARNING HAVE A ROLE IN LIBERAL ARTS COLLEGES? An Interview with Council of Independent Colleges President Richard Ekman Rebecca Griffiths December 2014 Ithaka S+R is a strategic consulting

GUIDELINES FOR TENURE AND PROMOTION Kenan-Flagler Business School The University of North Carolina Adopted April 24, 1985 and amended March 30, 2009, September 12, 2011 All procedures and policies relating

FACULTY INTELLECTUAL CONTRIBUTIONS UNDER THE 2009 AACSB INTERNATIONAL ACCREDITATION STANDARDS Spritzer, Allan D. East Tennessee State University spritzer@etsu.edu Garceau, Linda R. East Tennessee State

Achieving AACSB International s Initial Accreditation: The Montana State University Billings Experience - The College of Business Coordinator of Accreditation and Assessment s Perspective Barbara M. Wheeling

8 www.efmd.org/globalfocus Business schools have been among the most successful higher education institutions of the last 50 years. Yet now they face many serious challenges that, as Michael Osbaldeston

Draft: April 10, 2016 NORTHEASTERN 2025 Distinctively Excellent PhD Education Context We are in a moment of Northeastern s history when our PhD programs have the opportunity to excel by building on the

GUIDELINES FOR THE PROFESSIONAL EVALUATION OF DIGITAL SCHOLARSHIP BY HISTORIANS June 2015 Developed by the Ad Hoc Committee on the Evaluation of Digital Scholarship by Historians Approved by the AHA Council

Final Report of the AACSB International Impact of Research Task Force Final Report of the AACSB International Impact of Research Task Force AACSB International The Association to Advance Collegiate Schools

FISHER: Forward to the future. The Strategic Plan for St. John Fisher College 2012-2017 Vision Statement St. John Fisher College Vision Statement By the end of the decade, we will be a widely recognized

University of Delaware College of Health Sciences Department of Behavioral Health and Nutrition GUIDELINES FOR PROMOTION, TENURE AND REVIEW I. INTRODUCTION The mission of the Department of Behavioral Health

Belk College Policy on Qualified Faculty Status The Belk College of Business is committed to maintaining a high quality faculty that is consistent with its mission of being North Carolina s Urban Research

Creating and Sustaining a Competitive Advantage The Premise Creating and sustaining a competitive advantage might well be considered the Holy Grail of business. Boards, shareholders and business owners

1 Political Science Program Standards Aligned with College Standards 5.00 COLLEGE STANDARDS FOR FACULTY EVALUATION The additional Political Science Program Standards, where relevant, appear in italics.

Rob Davis Everyone wants a good process. Our businesses would be more profitable if we had them. But do we know what a good process is? Would we recognized one if we saw it? And how do we ensure we can

Critical analysis Be more critical! More analysis needed! That s what my tutors say about my essays. I m not really sure what they mean. I thought I had written a really good assignment this time. I did

CALIFORNIA STATE UNIVERSITY, CHICO COLLEGE OF BUSINESS CONTINUING REVIEW TEAM REPORT for Reaffirmation of Business Accreditation by AACSB -The International Association for Management Education I. Introduction

DEPARTMENT of ART Departmental criteria to be applied in personnel actions involving reappointment, promotion, and tenure, in supplement to the minimum standards described in the university's faculty manual,

Program Assessment: School of Criminology and Criminal Justice. Florida Atlantic University David Binninger, Ph.D. Scott H. Decker, Ph.D. Mark R. Pogrebin, Ph.D. On March 9-12, the external review team

Journal of Higher Education Outreach and Engagement, Volume 16, Number 4, p. 3, (2012) Copyright 2012 by the University of Georgia. All rights reserved. ISSN 1534-6104 The History of TRUCEN B Maureen F.

Tutor Response Form (Your marked-up essay is below this form.) HOW THIS WORKS: Your e-structor has written overview comments about your essay in the form below. Your e-structor has also embedded comments

College of Engineering Faculty Appraisal System For 2011/2012 Revised September 2011 1. Introduction We believe in the premise that people are more productive when they agree on what is expected of them

School of Architecture Interior Design Criteria for Reappointment, Promotion, Tenure College of Design, Architecture, Art, Planning School of Architecture Interior Design Criteria for Reappointment, Promotion,

OHIO UNIVERSITY REGIONAL HIGHER EDUCATION FACULTY WORKLOAD POLICY and the Mission of RHE With a focus on serving their respective communities across a service region that extends through most of the southeastern

New Leadership forstudent Learning andaccountability A STATEMENT OF PRINCIPLES, COMMITMENTS TO ACTION ASSOCIATION OF AMERICAN COLLEGES & UNIVERSITIES COUNCIL FOR HIGHER EDUCATION ACCREDITATION With support

SETTING THE PACE FOR THE NEXT GENERATION OF BUSINESS SCHOOLS 1 2 WHO WE ARE Concordia University s John Molson School of Business is a world-class business school that offers an approachable and collegial

This handout will: Discuss how to interpret teaching credential application essay prompts. Provide an example of a prompt. Provide an example of a sample response with critique. Discuss how to establish

1 Doctor of Education - Higher Education The University of Liverpool s Doctor of Education - Higher Education (EdD) is a professional doctoral programme focused on the latest practice, research, and leadership

Introduction: The Clinical Faculty College of Education Clinical Faculty Appointment and Promotion Criteria Provost Approved 11/11/11 In accordance with University guidelines most professional programs

STRATEGIC PLAN: 2010-2015 Journey to Excellence Henry W. Bloch School of Business and Public Administration University of Missouri Kansas City SEPTEMBER 2010 TABLE OF CONTENTS Preface... 3 Where We Are

1 Dean of the College of Pharmacy and Health Sciences Texas Southern University invites nominations and applications for the position of Dean of the College of Pharmacy and Health Sciences (COPHS). Reporting

University of Wisconsin Oshkosh Graduate Education Strategic Plan Introduction The University of Wisconsin Oshkosh has a long tradition of providing students with high-quality, affordable graduate education

Adopted: April 8, 2013 Updated: January 31, 2015 Eligibility Procedures and Accreditation Standards for Business Accreditation Engagement Innovation Impact AACSB International The Association to Advance

The Balanced Scorecard Beyond Reports and Rankings More commonly used in the commercial sector, this approach to strategic assessment can be adapted to higher education. by Alice C. Stewart and Julie Carpenter-Hubin

Faculty Productivity and Costs at The University of Texas at Austin A Preliminary Analysis Richard Vedder Christopher Matgouranis Jonathan Robe Center for College Affordability and Productivity A Policy

1 Criminal Justice Program Standards Aligned with College Standards 5.00 COLLEGE STANDARDS FOR FACULTY EVALUATION The additional Criminal Justice Program Standards, where relevant, appear in italics. This

Achievement, Innovation, Community: The University of Baltimore Strategic Plan 2014-17 Mission The University of Baltimore provides innovative education in business, public affairs, the applied liberal

APSU College of Business Policy for Faculty Retention, Tenure, Promotion & Annual Review of Tenured Faculty For Review by Faculty, August 2013 Teaching Faculty members are expected to engage in a process

J. T. M. Miller, Department of Philosophy, University of Durham 1 Methodological Issues for Interdisciplinary Research Much of the apparent difficulty of interdisciplinary research stems from the nature

OFFICE OF PROVOST S THE AND OFFICE SENIOR VICE PRESIDENT TUFTS UNIVERSITY APRIL 27, 2011 GUIDELINES FOR PROPOSING NEW DEGREE AND CERTIFICATE PROGRAMS These guidelines outline the steps necessary to develop

College of Business Mission Statement Mission: To build and nurture learning partnerships that foster sustainable enterprises and careers. Collaborations with alumni, business, educational and community

Quality Assurance, Accountability, and Accreditation in Collegiate Business Programs Executive Summary This paper argues that when states require business programs offered in the state to achieve specialized

Guidelines on Academic and Professional Qualifications For AACSB Accreditation Purposes College of Business and Public Administration Governors State University (Revision December 19, 2014, Approved by

The NSU Qual-AID Center Concept Notes At its essence, international development is one group of people aiding another group of people. Be the aid science and technology innovation, healthcare improvement,

INDIANA UNIVERSITY SCHOOL OF EDUCATION Long-Range Plan An Evaluative Framework for Pursuing School Goals and Submitted by the School of Education Long-Range Planning Committee 3/4/2013 Approved by Policy

TRANSFORMING YOUR DISSERTATION: TURNING YOUR RESEARCH INTO A BOOK OR SCHOLARLY ARTICLE Congratulations! The months, perhaps years, of hard work and often frustrating experiences have paid off. You have

Procedures for the Promotion of Assistant Professors to Associate Professor with Tenure Department of Chemistry, University of Pittsburgh The timeline for the promotion process is fixed by the Dean s requirement

Civic Engagement in Graduate Education: Preparing the Next Generation of Engaged Scholars Wingspread Conference Report Context of the Meeting: Responding to a rising conversation around civic engagement

Nomination and Selection of External Consultants for Graduate Program Reviews Graduate Programs External Consultants are required for the review of all new programs (with the exception of new collaborative

What So What Now What Stephen Melamed, IDSA Chair/Clinical Professor, Industrial Design School of Design Associate Director, UIC Innovation Center Interdisciplinary Product Development Program University

Advocacy Workshop Presented by: Susie Vallance Vice President, Human Resources, Seneca College 1. One that pleads the cause of another; 2. One that pleads the cause of another before a tribunal or judicial

Q: We re rolling on this. 3, 2, 1. Welcome, everyone. My name is Chris Kenneally, and on behalf of Copyright Clearance Center I want to welcome you to a very special program looking at the latest developments

AACSB Accreditation 101: What AACSB Expects, What We Have Done Faculty Meetings November 2014 Objectives Understanding of KEY AACSB standards and expectations Overview of our own processes and procedures

AACSB Self Evaluation Report Documentation Supporting Materials and Timeline The Self Evaluation Report is a critical document in achieving initial accreditation. Ours is due May 15, 2012. To reach this

Blog Carmen Klann Take the Sting Out of the 360 Degree Feedback Process Everybody agrees with the statement that constructive feedback is very worthwhile and tremendously crucial for every individual and

t INTRODUCTION The National Board for Professional Teaching Standards (NBPTS) was founded in 1987 in order to achieve the following mission: To advance the quality of teaching and learning by maintaining

Medicare Respiratory Therapist Access Act - 2013 These Frequently Asked Questions (FAQs) are designed to provide insight into developing a legislative initiative, to discuss why AARC is taking a different

THE DIVINITY SCHOOL THE UNIVERSITY OF CHICAGO GUIDELINES OF THE COMMITTEE ON DEGREES (effective Autumn Quarter 1979; revised Autumn Quarter 2010) The faculty established the Committee on Degrees to oversee

Financial Freedom: Three Steps to Creating and Enjoying the Wealth You Deserve What does financial freedom mean to you? Does it mean freedom from having to work, yet still being able to enjoy life without

A. Contributions to Teaching Department of Child & Family Development Promotion and Tenure Guidelines November 2004 The Standard Teaching communicates knowledge to students and develops in them the desire

THE STATESMAN Volume 8 Issue 12 December 2005 Happy Holidays! From George Wythe College On Campus Seminars: Dec 16-17 Mar 4-5 Mar 7-8 May 2-27 May 30-31 July 15-16 Roots of America How to Read a Book A

SMU PhD IN BUSINESS Advance knowledge at Asia s leading business and management university Message from Associate Dean (Research) and Programme Director The Lee Kong Chian School of Business at the Singapore