“Dude came up to me yesterday… Head Butts me hard. Outta nowhere,” Amell shared Sunday on Instagram. “Then [he] says ‘I want to fight the Green Arrow.’ Paused, looked at him … shook his hand and said no thank you. Because I’m a father and a husband. Pretty manly if you ask me.”

Though Amell looks to be recovering, as his Instagram mug shows a scrape and a black-and-blue on his nose, it appears he enjoyed most of his time in central New York.

Before the fateful encounter — and the Orange’s 35-20 loss to the Wolfpack– Amell hung out with some pals and mingled with the band.