IJNlliEl\$.lTY OF ICl:`LAND - Nordic Volcanological Center

--
~
j
I
-
- .._
-IJNlliEl\$.lTY OF ICl:'LAND
=-~
-
~
___, ______
NORDIC VOLCANOLOGICAL INSTITUTE
80 05
UNIVERSITY OF ICELAND
OBSERVED GROUND DEFORMATION
DURING THE KRAFLA ERUPTION OF MARCH 16, 1980
by
Eysteinn Tryggvason
1980
- 1 -
Abstract
The Krafla volcano h as been monitored with continuously
recording tiltmeters and seismometers and frequent geodetic
measurements since the beginning of the present episode of
activity in 1975. The inflation-deflation sequence of the
volcano sh owed striking regularity in 1977 and 1978 but it
became more erratic in late 1979 with slow inflation interrupted
by small deflations.
Th e eruption of March 16, 1980 was preceeded by rapid
deflation wh ich started at 15:15 (GMT) and intense volcanic
tremor started simultaneously. Th e subsidence became very
rapid at about 16:00, about th ree times more rapid than had
been seen in any previous subsidence event. The eruption
was first seen at about 16:20, but it may h ave started 10 to
20 minutes earlier. It lasted until about 22 h th at same
night. The deflation of th e volcano ceased at about 03h next
morning, March 17, and a new inflation started within a few
hours. Tilt observations indicate th at roughly 30 x 106 m 3
of magma left th e Krafla magma ch amber, but only some 10% of
this came to t h e surface as very fluid basaltic lava. New
fissures extended through the Krafla volcano over a distance
of about 21 km and th e widening of the fissure zone was
about 1.5 m.
- 2 -
Introduction
A period of volcanic and tectonic activity started in
1975 in North Iceland, and the center of activity is
located in the Krafla Central Volcano and the associated
fissure swarm (Bjornsson et al. 1977). This activity has
been characterized by alternating inflations and deflations
of the volcano, and episodic widenings of the fissure swarm
(Fig. 1). The inflation of the volcano progresses at a
rate of 0.5 to 1.0 cm per day for one to seven months
between deflations, which last from a few hours to 20 days.
The rate of deflation varies greatly from one deflation
event to another (Bjornsson et al. 1979, Tryggvason 1980).
Widening of the fissure swarm associated with opening of
new and old fissures, vertical fault displacements,
earthquake swarms in the fissure swarm, and sometimes
outpouring of basaltic lava, occurs only during deflations
of the Krafla volcano. Only a fraction of the fissure
swarm widens during each deflation event, often about
20 km· section, but the part of the fissure swarm which has
widened during the sequence of events since 1975 extends
from Axarfjordur in the north to the southern part of the
Myvatn area in the south, or over a 80 km distance. The
southernmost part of the fissure swarm has not been affected
by the present activity as yet (Bjornsson et al. 1979).
After the deflation event of May 13 to 18, 1979
(Tryggvason 1980) inflation proceeded at the usual rate,
and in mid October 1979 the Krafla volcano had reached the
same stage of inflation as immediately before the May
deflation. The inflation rate in October and November 1979
was rather slow or only 1.0 to 1.5 mm per day, and in early
December 1979 a small deflation of about 4.5 cm occurred
and another small deflation of 10 to 12 cm occurred in
early February 1980. The rate of inflation remained rather
slow between these mini-deflations and also after the
February 1980 deflation, and in mid March the ground surface
in the central part of the Krafla volcano was about 12 cm
higher than immediately before the May 1979 deflation.
- 3 -
t,11
t,wpl••"•
t,•tod
•
•
•
•
0
tN,-lAHC)N
f
100
200
0[FC.4ll0"'
300
400
I
500
600
700
\/
Fig. 1.
19 7 6
1 9 11
I 9 7 8
I 9 7 9
I 9 8 0
North component of tilt at the Krafla power station.
Before August 20, 1976 (dotted curve), no tiltmeter
was operated, but several levelings give the
approximate tilt values. Filled circles give the
times of volcanic eruptions.
- 4- -
On March 16, at about 15h 15m rapid deflation of th e
Krafla volcano started. Th e maxi mum rate of deflation of
about 50 cm per h our occurred at 16h30m . Th is was faster
Th e
deflation rate than in any previous deflation event.
deflation stopped at about 03h on March 17. The total
deflation amounted to about 61 cm according to tiltmeters in
the Krafla power house, using th e average relation between
tilt stage and land elevation. As fissures opened near
th e power station during th is deflation, th e relation
between .tilt and land elevation may h ave deviated so mewhat
from th e average relation, making both total deflation and
maximum rate of deflation somew h at in doubt.
At about 16h 20m, one h our after the deflation started,
a volcanic fissure opened about one k m north of t he
center of th e Krafla volcano and basaltic lava poured out.
Th is rift propagated north wards during th e next 30 minutes
and th e volcanic fissure reach ed about 4 km in length .
Th e eruption lasted only som e 6 hours during wh ich time an
estimated amount of 3 million cubic meters of lava was
formed.
Inflation of th e Krafla volcano started in th e morning
of March 17, and th e rate of inflation was very h igh during
the following days, or about 2 cm per day.
The subsidence event of March 16-17, 1980 differs from
all previous subsidence events in th e Krafla volcano as th e
maximum rate of subsidence was about th ree times h igh er
th an h ad been observed before. T he h ig h est rate of deflation
previously observed was on September 8, 1977, about 16.5 cm
per h our and about 15.5 cm per h our on April 27, 1977. In
all ot her subsidence events th e maximum rate of deflation
was observed as 5 cm per h our or less (Tryggvason 1980).
Two subsidence events h ave occurred since March 1980
until th e writing of th is paper in December 1980. Both
events were accompanied by outpouring of basaltic lava in
in previous eruptions during th e
much greater quantity th an
present sequence of events in th e Krafla area.
- 5 -
Observed tilt
There were 4 recording tiltmeters in the Krafla area
during the deflation event of March 16-17, 1980, in addition
to one water tube tiltmeter where daily readings were made.
Furthermore, 11 "dry tilt" stations were occupied about
three months before the event and about two months after
the event. These stations can rarely be occupied during
winters because of snow cover. All these stations, with
possibly one exception, showed clear indication of tilt
di...r.i.ng the deflation event.
At five of the "dry tilt ll stations, which are located
within 7 km from the center of deflation, good correlation
is found between their tilt, and that of the water tube
tiltmeter in the Krafla power house. This correlation is
used to estimate the tilt stage immediately before and
after the event. At the remaining six ''dry tilt" stations
no or very poor correlation is found with the water tube
tiltmeter, and the observed tilt between the last
observation before the event and the first observation
after the event is taken as the tilt during the event.
Errors in the event tilt due to this assumption are consider­
able or roughly 10 µ-rad as judged from other observations
at the same stations.
Fig. 2 shows the location and the
observed tilt at all the tilt stations in the Krafla area
during the deflation event of March 16-17, 1980. Tilt at
stations less than 5 km away from the center of subsidence
is primarily caused by the nearly circular subsidence bowl,
while .stations farther away are affected by deformation
along the fissure swarm to the south of the center of
subsidence.
Ground subsidence and volume of the subsidence bowl
Two methods are available to estimate the ground
subsidence from observed tilt at the tilt stations. One
method uses the relation between observed north component
of tilt at the Krafla power station and land elevation
determined by precise leveling, and the relation between
- 6 -
I • ..,
.- .... .....",.
Ctfller ot fftloh•l'I
-"
O
-
••""' " •,ot\O ut101•
,et.ti"""; 1•11 .,.,�
o,,, 1111 stouo,.
£uni ol Mo•ch II 1'•0
(,.,, ,,.
Lue
l•tt• elf r,U"'9
.............. W,0,ti,1A9 • 1,uw,• tw'Offfl
a"""
Fig. 2.
f.11 "'l(fOfOd>OI\I
Map of the Krafla area showing tilt stations with
observed tilt during the subsidence event of
March 16-17, 1980. Bars show displacements of one
side of the rift zone relative to the other during
this event. The center of deflation is shown with
an open circle and the size of this circle indicates
the uncertainity of location of this center. All
geodimeter lines which crossed the rift zone
(stippled) or extended into it in E-W direction
increased in length by more than 20 cm during the
event.
- 7 -
tilt at different tilt stations. The other method uses a
deformation model and seeks the best fit between obscrvl�d
tilt and theoretical tilt.
The four tilt stations, Krafla power station,
Hlidardalur (5 3 on Fig. 2), Bjargholl (102 on Fig. 2), and
Hvannstod (178 on Fig. 2), which always show considerable
tilt during inflation and deflation of Krafla, and are
located at considerable distance from fissures formed during
the March 16-17, 1980 deflation event, are used to estimate
the maximum subsidence by the first method. The north
component of tilt at the Krafla power station has been
correlated with precise leveling, and one microradion of
tilt corresponds to 3.4 mm vertical movement in the center
of inflation/deflation (Bjornsson et al. 1979). The tilt
of 180 µ-rad thus corresponds to 61 cm subsidence. The
tilt at the other stations indicate maximum subsidence of
43 to 62 cm, and the average value of maximum subsidence
thus calculated is 55 cm, with a standard error of about
S cm.
A model of spherical body of increasing or decreasing
pressure inside a homogeneous elastic halfspace (Mogi 1958)
has been compared with the tilt observations and a
reasonable conformance is found. The best correlation
between observed tilt and the model is obtained if the
depth to the center of the spherical body is 2.9�0.1 km,
the volume of the subsidence bowl 3 5!2 million m 3 , and the
maximum subsidence 65�5 cm.
The discrepancy between the empirical value for
maximum subsidence of 55±5 cm, and the theoretical value
of 65±5 cm is not significant and the theoretical model
seems not to deviate greatly from the actual condition.
However, one obvious error in the model is the assumption
0£ homogeneous elastic halfspace, while the geology of the
Krafla area is rather chaotic, and increasing temperature
and pressure with depth causes vertical gradient in the
elastic properties. It is also very unlikely that the
inflating and deflating body is spherical, and its diameter
is probably large compared with its depth, but the theory
accounts for a small body relative to its depth below the
surface of the halfspace.
- ti -
The conclusion of this discussion is that the subsidence
bowl formed during the March 16-17 deflation of the Krafla
volcano had a maximum depth of 60!10 cm , and its volume was
probably between 30 and 40 million m 3 . The shape of the
bowl can be roughly approximated by a theoretical model of
decreasing pressure in a spherical body centered at 2.9 km
depth. This is taken as indication of removal of material
(magma) at approximately this depth. The volume of material
removed is probably somewhat greater than the volume of the
subsidence bowl as the decreased stress causes increase in
volume. However, the stress change is not known, and the
volume of material removed from below the area of subsidence
can best be estimated as 30 to 40 million m3.
7 to 13 km south
Tilt in the Myvatn area,
of the center of deflation (Fig. 1) is mostly
20 to 40
towards the Krafla fissure swarm ,
microradians. This shows that the fissure swarm subsided
to the south of the region where surface rifting was observed.
One station,off the north coast of the lake Myvatn,shows
tilt away from the fissure swarm. This may indicate uplift
of the flanks of the fissure swarm in the region where
surface rifting occurred, similar as observed during the
subsidence events of April 1977 and January 1978 (Bjornsson
et al. 1979 , Sigurdsson 1980).
Horizontal deformation
Distance measurements in the Krafla area have been
made many times since early 1977 , and an effort has been
made to cover the area with measurements during every
inflation period. These measurements have shown that inside
the Krafla caldera the distances between bench marks vary
regularily with the stage of inflation , and each distance
varies linearily with the observed tilt at the Krafla power
station. This linear relation is broken only during
deflation events with rifting across the caldera. This
allows us to estimate the length of each measured line
immediately before and after the March 16 to 17, 1980
- 9 deflation event, and to estimate further how much of the
obs8rvcd lcng th di ffcrence is due lo l 11<' Jt•J L.ttion .111t.J
how much is due to permanent deformation in form of rifting.
A total of 79 lines were measured with a geodimeter at
times before and after the March event which allowed
estimate of the length change during the event. Of these,
41 had increased in length by more than 2 0 cm. All these
41 lines cross the rift zone shown on Fig. 2, or extend
into this zone. No line which lies wholly outside the rift
zone had increased in length by more than 10 cm.
Where two or more lines crossed the rift zone at
different angles, the total displacement of one side of the
zone relative to the other can be determined. Six such
determinations of displacements across the rift zone are
shown on Fig. 2. One line, about one km south of the
southernmost such determination, gave increase in length
of 142 cm, but the exact direction of displacement was not
obtained.
· The direction of displacement is found to be nearly
perpendicular to the rift zone. In the northern part of
the area, this direction is 99!3 degrees and in the southern
part is is about 104 degrees. Thus a slight change in the
direction of the rift zone is reflected in the direction
of displacements.
The north and south ends of the zone were rifting
occurred during the March 1980 event were not determined
with the geodimeter measurements, but open fissures were
observed in the snow as far north and south as shown on
Fig. 2.
Fig. 2 shows that the observed widening of the rift
zone during the March 16-17 deflation event ranged between
123 and 165 cm.
The average widening of the
rift zone over the 13 km of lenth, where it was measured
is about 140 cm. The length of the zone where surface
rifting was seen is about 2 1 km, and it may be assumed that
the widening was less towards the end of the rifted zone,
than in the central part. If it is assumed that the 8 km
length of the fissured zone, which lays outside the region
of distance measurements was widened 70 cm on the average,
the increase in area of the rift z one was
2 3800
m2 .
The
- 10 -
increase in area of the Krafla fissure swarm during all
rifting events since December 1975, is probably more than
300000 m 2 (Bjornsson et al. 1979).
The volume of the subsidence bowl formed during the
March 16-17 defl�tion event is estimated as 30-40 x 10 6 m '
and less than 10 per cent of that volume was erupted.
Therefore, it is estimated that some 30 million cubic
meters of magma were deposited in a dike of horizontal cross
section similar to the areal increase of the rift zone of
2
2 3800 m .
This gives the average vertical extension of the
dike about 1.3 km.
Conclusion
The subsidence event in the Krafla area, North Iceland,
on March 16-17, 1980, is one of 13 similar events since
December 1975 (Fig. 1) (Bjornsson et al. 1959, Einarsson &
Brandsdottir 1980). Common features of all these subsidence
events are
1.
Rapid subsidence of the Krafla area, with center of
subsidence about 1.5 km north or northwest of the
Krafla geothermal power station.
2.
Rifting and widening of a section of the Krafla
fissure swarm.
3.
Swarm of earthquakes with epicenters in the area of
�ifting.
4.
Continuous tremor on local seismometers.
In six of the subsidence events, basaltic lava has reached
the surface, but in only small amounts as compared with the
volume of the subsidence bowl, until in July and October
1980, when the volume of lava was similar to the volume of
the subsidence bowl.
It is assumed that the subsidence in the Krafla area
is caused by removal of magma from beneath that area, and
depositing it in fissure or fissures in the elastic crust
below the zone which developed surface rifting (Bjornsson
- 11 -
et al. 1977). The areal increase of this zone is considered
to reflect the horizontal cross sectional area of the dike
or dikes formed and the average height of the dike is
calculated as 1.3 km by equating the volume of the subsidence
bowl and the volume of the dike. The depth to the top of the
dike is zero along the eruption fissure, but elsewhere the
depth of the dike can be roughly estimated as equal the width
of the fissured zone (Tryggvason 1980), or about one km.
Thus the bottom of the dike should be at somewhat less than
3 km depth.
Acknowledgements
The National Energy Authority operates the water tube
tiltmeter at the Kr.afla power station, which is the most
important single measurements made to monitor the tectonic
events in the Krafla area.
- 12 References
Bjornsson, A., Saemundsson, K., Einarsson, P., Tryggvason, E.,
and Granvold, K., 1977, Current rifting episode in
north Iceland, Nature, 266, 318-323.
Bjornsson, A., Johnsen, G., Sigurdsson, S., Thorbergsson, G.,
and Tryggvason, E., 1979, Rifting of the plate boundary
in north Iceland, 1975-1978, J. Geophys. Res., 84,
3029-3038.
Einarsson, P., and Brandsdottir, B., 1980, Seismological
evidence for lateral magma intrusion during the July
1978 deflation of the Krafla volcano in NE-Iceland,
J. Geophys., 47, 160-165.
Mogi, K., 1958, Relations between the eruptions of various
volcanoes and the deformations of the ground surfaces
around·thern, Bulletin of the Earthquake Research
Institute (Tokyo), 36, 99-134.
Sigurdsson, 0., 1980, Surface deformation of the Krafla
fissure swarm in two rifting events, 1980, J. Geophys.,
47, 154-159.
Tryggvason, E., 1980, Subsidence events in the Krafla area,
north Iceland, 1975-1979, J. Geophys., 47, 141-153.