I actually enjoyed this episode a lot. It was good topically and the humor was bright.
It is included in my all-time favorites list actually, and I haven't had one of those in quite a while.
Can't wait to see what else is on the way.

I don't remember Columbus Day being a school holiday. It was in the same category as Presidents Day; you still had to go to school, but like the post office was closed.
Is that a California thing to not have school on Columbus Day?

The beauty of this episode was Randy's alternate version of the universe where Columbus used to be super cool, but now he's like Hitler. He feels like he has to overcompensate for how into Columbus he used to be. But in reality, no one gave a shit then and no one gives a shit now. And everyone thinks Randy is acting really strange the entire time. It was so absurd and kept building on itself.

Because of how detached from reality Randy was the entire episode, it was really more of a Cartman story with Randy playing the role of a delusional Fatass. The way he tries to set it up so he looks like a victim, the denial about his own past, not learning the "right" lesson at the end, even the runner where a word is misused/mispronounced. That's the outline of a Cartman story.

Something felt off about Randy in this episode and I think that was it. Randy can't be Fatass. Randy is about being stupid while remaining sincere and passionate. Fatass is about being stupid to feed his ego and selfishness.

true, but maybe this is exactly what matt & trey meant to show, that he has become a little bit like cartman. mostly because of insecurity i guess.

I think Randy is becoming more like Mr. Garrison rather than Cartman. Besides, someone needs to fit in Garrison's shoes for the next four year while Mr. Garrison is impersonating our real-life president.

South Park is way funnier than Family Guy.
Also Mr. Garrison and Donald Trump are two SEPARATE people with completely different career backgrounds.

Anyways. This episode. Out of the three aired by far this one was clearly the WORST!
Barely laughed. Just....stupid all around

It showed promise but ripped on pieces already patched, like the Charleston reaction from episode 1. So Randy took a statute down. Whoopie. It ripped on a holiday that litterally NOBODY cares about (I guess that's partially the point) Look. I live in New Hampshire. When I was in school they cancelled giving us Columbus Day off. Now even most federal buildings don't give off Columbus Day! Pretty much it should be "Ingedious Day" because nobody gives a f*ck about it!

The DNA stuff was stupid. I expected more laughs. I have used those sites. Kinda cool but by god. That sh*tty commercial on TV of a woman that says "I'm Everything!" I wanted a bit more to be played on that. Slightly was...but I needed more! And the native American thing was slightly funny but more dumb sh*t than anything.

Yea this episode was clearly one of the worst ones in the past 2-3 years. I didn't think they could get so low. But apparently, some weeks I do wonder if they just have......run out of ideas

Animation error. If someone isn't supposed to be there, he or she is removed or replaced with someone else after the original airing.

I surprised that they didn't made changes like that in Season 20's Skank Hunt because Kenny should of been with the other boys in destroying Cartman's stuff and seen with Stan instead of Clyde when telling Kyle about Heidi quitting Twitter and Cartman not being Skankhunt42.

South Park is way funnier than Family Guy.
Also Mr. Garrison and Donald Trump are two SEPARATE people with completely different career backgrounds.

General

Welcome to the all new southpark.cc.com!

We've Updated Our Terms

By clicking outside of this box or X, you agree to the Site's updated Terms of Use and consent to the collection, use, disclosure and transfer of information as described in this Site's updated Privacy Policy and to third parties receiving information about the videos you watch as described in this Site’s Video Privacy Terms. Before you do, please read them and check out some of these changes (such as arbitration for disputes - see our FAQs). Please also note that you are accessing a site which is designed for and targeted to U.S. audiences and is governed by and operated in accordance with U.S. laws.