Trouble logging in?If you can't remember your password or are having trouble logging in, you will have to reset your password. If you have trouble resetting your password (for example, if you lost access to the original email address), please do not start posting with a new account, as this is against the forum rules. If you create a temporary account, please contact us right away via Forum Support, and send us any information you can about your original account, such as the account name and any email address that may have been associated with it.

I thought the Hall of thunder would be something. Seeing Erza so healthy like that disappointed me... Her toughness is 200 times more than normal?

It might have something to do with her armor, it was called the "lightning emperor armor" or something like that. If it weren't for that she probably wouldn't be able to handle most of it. Although even with that im kind of disappointed as well.

She's the one who took a direct hit from Phantom's Cannon and still battled one-on-one with Jose for a good while to keep him from attacking the other guild members.

And even if the lightning power was halved, that's 100 - her being one of the Top 4, she could withstand that...either that or a certain MystGun helped from behind the scenes.

What bugs me the most is she can still talk just fine, when just one hit took Visca out cold, and before that were all those talk about life and death... Either it's incredibly bullshit for me, or those ball are just super duper weak that a light touch can break them, and 200 weak attacks are of course no trouble. But that also means the others are all idiot.

Oh well, it's shounen.

Could have been better if the page having those ball collapsed replace by Erza with hundred swords. We have that already, but I won't complain if it's Erza

IMO, it doesn't matters whether you destroy 1 or 100, if you do it at the same time. It will just generate the same amount of voltage so Erza actually took the same damage as the others (she was wearing the knight armor instead of the thunder emperor).

Why don't you try using your hand to touch an electric plug, then 2 at the same time to see if it's the same...

Really, the only explanation i can think of is that this is "magic link," the reflecting thunder is created using the magic power of the attack. So no matter if it's 1 or 200 balls, Erza can only receive so much attack power as high as her own.

Which means those balls are not tough at all. And others are idiots, using full force to crush them..

In fact, Erza alone can crush 200 at once. No matter how strong she is, if those balls were THAT hard to break...

Well, this is also the reason why Ezra's S-class and they're not. lol They most likely didn't know how much force to use but hey, in that situation, better to crush with more force than nessacary than to not use enough and have to do it again.

Why don't you try using your hand to touch an electric plug, then 2 at the same time to see if it's the same...

Really, the only explanation i can think of is that this is "magic link," the reflecting thunder is created using the magic power of the attack. So no matter if it's 1 or 200 balls, Erza can only receive so much attack power as high as her own.

Your trying to compare real world logic to "magic" logic... That's the funny thing about magic, it follows its own rules and doesn't have to subscribe to any kind of real world logic... ergo hitting 200 at once deals the same damage as just hitting one, and is thus less painful than hitting 200 one at a time

Grant it though, the lack of a clear explanation, is a bit of a mark of poor writing as assuming that hitting all of them at the same time deals the same damage as hitting one, is too big of an assumption... frankly, had Ezra kept wearing the lightning armor, then THAT would have done fairly well to explain as it would significantly reduce the amount of damage

Then what's the talk with life and death about? That's what ticked me the most.

What is its own rule? I've stated why it sounds dumb. And nowhere in the manga states anything to prove other wise. Until it does (which may never happen) the "own rule" you speak of is just the rule your brain thinks of, isn't it? We are just trying to justify the manga we like. That's it, we still like it nevertheless.

Much as I'd love to spend all of my money on fairy tail manga, there's only one shop in town and it's seriously out of date.
About Erza: her power is not just her insane hax armours, remember that when she was introduced she was effortlessly carrying a huge demon horn and 1HKO'd Natsu in the train later on.

About Luxus: I doubt his magic is dragon slayer-type, apparently that kind of magic is known only by dragons and possibly takes many years to learn (somehow Natsu and Gazille count as being older than 80 o_0) but Luxus had lived with Makarov his entire life, so he's probably just really proficient with lightning magic.

Then what's the talk with life and death about? That's what ticked me the most.

What is its own rule? I've stated why it sounds dumb. And nowhere in the manga states anything to prove other wise. Until it does (which may never happen) the "own rule" you speak of is just the rule your brain thinks of, isn't it? We are just trying to justify the manga we like. That's it, we still like it nevertheless.

Well, we are all trying to decipher what the mangaka is drawing with our own thinking. It's speculation of a magical world, where nothing was ever explained in logical details, especially one by Hiro Mashima. Like how you were suggesting that "the reflecting thunder is created using the magic power of the attack", is what you stated in bold above. And to justify fantasy shounen manga with real world logic is kinda dumb... no?

Talk about a series of massively anti-climactic moments these last few chapters...

Spoken for truth...

When Luxus was introduced, he seemed like this hax character with insane power, but so far he hasn't been able to accomplish anything. He only rages in futility as each of his plans gets completely demolished - the petrification was undone, his underlings were defeated and now the hall of thunder. Seriously, if he doesn't do some serious damage the next couple of chapters, he will be the biggest joke so far.