After basking in the magic that is Signed, Sealed, Delivered: Higher Ground, it wasn't long before I began to consider all the pieces woven together to create the story. One element---the score---has always been one to tell a story all its own, but when a noticeable classic reappeared in a context I had no vocabulary for, it immediately began to stand out, and sent me on a journey beyond my wildest imagination.

You might remember a beautiful piano piece included in From Paris With Love called "Clair de lune," which played as Oliver waited in the lobby for Holly the night they had drinks. Pay close attention during Higher Ground, and it can be heard underneath two particular scenes---as Shane and Oliver walk down Yellow Bird Way toward her home, and when they kiss in the DLO at the end of the film.

Wait a second...what about Holly?

I'm sure it's not hard to see why I was confused---why would a piece of music used during a scene with Holly re-occur later with Shane? What I wasn't prepared for was the depth and weight of the answer, which requires an exploration of the piece itself.

Debussy & "Promenade Sentimentale"

The first thing you should know is that "Clair de lune" was composed in 1890 by French composer Claude Debussy. It's the third and most famous movement from his four movement Suite bergamasque. The piece itself was written during the French impressionistic movement in music, which is important because the pieces produced during this movement were meant to evoke moods and emotions, creating a unique personal connection for each listener based on their own interpretation of the piece. Take a listen for yourself:

Were you walking the streets of Paris? Falling in love for the first time? Remembering a montage of moments from your childhood? Perhaps you imagined a moonlit night? This would be appropriate given that "Clair de lune" translated from the French means "moonlight." But perhaps most important is the fact that Debussy originally entitled the piece "Promenade Sentimentale" which means "sentimental walk." Like a "walk" through one's personal emotions, a listener makes their own sentimental connections to the piece.

Interestingly, this connection is not unlike that which Shane and Oliver share during their actual walk as the pair discusses the instances in which Shane tried to quit the DLO, almost a sentimental connection they share with each other, as its Oliver who, in each instance, manages to convince her to stay. On a larger scale, however, their "walk" will stand in for their evening together as a whole for several reasons I'll expand upon more thoroughly tomorrow, making the piece an even more perfect fit.

But first, there's one more interesting and even deeper connection between the origins of this piece and Higher Ground that must be made.

"I really enjoyed our walk." "So did I."

The Poetry Of Verlaine

As for most things, inspiration has to come from somewhere, "Promenade Sentimentale," or "Claire de lune" as it eventually came to be known, was, indeed, inspired by something---the poetry of Paul Verlaine. In particular, a poem entitled "Clair de lune." It's a very interesting poem that, translated from the French says everything and nothing at the same time. You can read several translations online (including the original French) but here it is in English:

Your soul is a chosen landscape
Where charming masqueraders and bergamaskers go
Playing the lute and dancing and almost
Sad beneath their fanciful disguises.

All sing in a minor key
Of victorious love and the opportune life,
They do not seem to believe in their happiness
And their song mingles with the moonlight,

With the still moonlight, sad and beautiful,
That sets the birds dreaming in the trees
And the fountains sobbing in ecstasy,
The tall slender fountains among marble statues.

Paul Verlaine, 1869

Because this poetry inspired the score "Clair de lune," which underlies our story in Higher Ground, it will require a little interpretation of the poem itself in order to understand how everything ties together.

Overall, there's a general consensus that this particular poem carries with it an almost surreal, melancholic mood as it attempts to reflectively describe "a person's soul or innermost being." It starts off by describing the soul as a "landscape"---like a garden, another theme in Higher Ground---which seems to attract interesting distractions that, for all their fanfare (lutes and dancing), seem empty somehow, singing of love and happiness, yet knowing not of it, in a sense. On the other hand, it could be that they believe the "victorious love and the opportune life" for others and not themselves. All of these conditions are overseen by a moon which, in the final stanza, seems to absorb all of the emptiness, doubt and unbelief of the first two stanzas, reflecting back something full, detailed, and quietly beautiful when taken together (birds dreaming, fountains sobbing). It's perspective achieved only when viewed from "higher ground" perhaps?

Two souls, the same.

Based on this interpretation, which also finds me equating Shane to the "tall, slender fountain" and Oliver to the "marble statue" it shouldn't be a surprise that the soul described above is collectively each of theirs. Which, despite their melancholic existence on the landscape of life, marked by moments of emptiness, doubt and unbelief in "victorious love and the opportune life," are, in fact, each uniquely beautiful and capable of that which they once perceived out of reach. And, not surprisingly, will find "victorious love and the opportune life" with each other, tied together at the deepest level---their souls.

Now, as I said before, the French impressionistic movement was all about creating one's own interpretation of the poem, or piece of music. Since "Clair de lune" the poem, underpins the piece of the score of the same name featured in Higher Ground, the interpretation of the poem explicated above and its application to Shane and Oliver, therefore, pulls through to the score.

But what about Holly? Like I mentioned earlier, "Clair de lune" was used in scenes with her, too. I think we'll get a better sense of that if we take a look at the definition of "sentimental." Sentimental is defined as, "of, or prompted by feelings of tenderness, sadness or nostalgia." Holly and Oliver's entire encounter over drinks was characterized by at the very least sadness and nostalgia, recounting how they met and how things fell apart, making it painfully clear how ill-suited they were for each other. At the same time, there was a touch of tenderness in how Holly complimented Oliver on "being [a] hero [when] she needed one." But one thing is inescapable---they are essentially preparing to say goodbye.

When we hear the piece in Higher Ground, we don't know it yet, but after their brief walk down Yellow Bird Way, we're preparing for Shane and Oliver to do the same.

To best understand what it all means and why it matters is only possible by taking a closer look at the scenes in which "Clair de lune" can be heard. Over the next two days we'll be looking specifically at the their walk, and Shane and Oliver's kiss at the end of the film.

Wow...this is amazing! Once again, Chandel, you have touched on an element of this story that we could easily have missed! Although I immediately recognized the song from FPWL, I didn't think of the connection in HIgher Ground! Thank you for your insight and thank you, Ms Martha, for your brilliant writing!

This is amazing analysis! Thank you for digging deep to bring it to POstables. I played the music as I read your analysis, letting the interpretation of the poetry- inspired music sink in. I will never listen again without this deeper knowledge. It is exciting to think of the detailed thinking that goes into creating each episode/film of Signed,Sealed, Delivered. This kind of depth which we find in so many aspects of SSD is clearly what sets it above the average TV movie! Martha Williamson and her creative crew are brilliant! Can't wait for the rest of this analysis to continue this week.

Reply

Amy

3/15/2017 11:46:18 am

Love it! My piano professor shared some insight on this piece years ago. both the chords and the intervals between the melody line are full of minor thirds in the first half of the song. There is a phenomenon in German that when German mothers call for their children they do so in this minor third. In America we do it as well. A child almost instinctively calls out for his "mom-my" in that same minor third interval. It is a calling, a longing for home and love that comes out in the first passage. I feel like this relates directly to Oliver and holly (and his mother who never came back) how he had waited for her return and all the grief and pain that wait caused him, and soon to Shane that he would wait for her return from d.c. Also there was a study done and they recorded actors saying lines in certain emotions. Then they took the words out and had others identify the mood by just the pitch. Everyone always identified the sad ones with the minor third interval. So even in our speaking voice we use it.

Reply

An Appreciative Fan

3/15/2017 02:51:14 pm

Hats off to Chandel and to your professor!

Reply

Chandel

3/15/2017 03:02:11 pm

It was actually Amy's professor, I wish I had had someone walk me through those elements. Seems it would prompt a whole other blog post!

Amy

3/15/2017 03:34:41 pm

Sorry chandel.I had actually planned on sending my thoughts to you right after it aired but I wanted to look up my score and notes again and never got around to it until I saw your post this morning. I have a few more that might apply more to your second post. I'll send them on Facebook.

Christine

3/15/2017 02:19:41 pm

Wow! Thank you for this analysis. The use of this piece of music had me puzzled, but I love it and thought that it worked so well where it was used in HG.

Reply

Leora M. Kemp

3/16/2017 06:04:26 pm

Chandel, your abilities for analysis continue to amaze me. SSD is lucky to have someone like you create this blog that brings all the POstables together for further understanding of each beautiful movie. Thank you for all you do for us.

Reply

Denise

3/19/2017 07:09:05 pm

I am watching From Paris with Love right now and realized there is another scene in this movie where Clair de Lune is heard in the background. It is the scene where Shane and Rita are sitting in the Mailbox Grille covertly reading Oliver's letter to Holly. Also, there is a full moon during the porch scene at the end. The moon is seen above the Denver skyline before the scene shifts to Shane walking up the steps to her house. Your analysis of the song and poem as they relate to Higher Ground is amazing, so how do these two scenes fit into it all?