Koosey

i dont think that the winners of other survivors should be brought back, i dont think its fair to others who didnt get a very good chance to get very far, maybe because they were judged too soon, like debb, or people who got voted out because they were too nice, like elizabeth. please reply on your opinions.

I agree with you Koosey. I believe the non-winners should have a shot at the prize. I don't think that any of the top winners should be there but this is the "all stars" . I think that the Survivors who brought the most to the show were chosen. Oh, and welcome to the board! Most people here just call me Mama.

Logged

We may rise and fall, but in the endWe meet our fate together.....Creed

I agree, give the others chances to win. However keep in mind that this is the ALL Stars ~ and like pro athletes ALL STARS are the best players.

Also keep in mind that those that won other seasons or were IC winners will be the ones everyone will be targeting in the beginning. So Rupert is helped here as they did not see how far he went or did not. But they saw how he carried his team in the strength department.

I agree. I dont think the winners should be able to compete in this all stars show. Give the people who didnt win a chance at it. However, I think in a few more seasons down the road, they should have an "Ultimate Sole Survivor" show where it is only the winners from each show competing for a larger cash prize. Maybe $2,000,000. That would be a great show to watch!!!!

A better idea is to have winners of other reality tv shows compete for the ultimate reality show star. Being Survivor put reality tv on the map, is it only right to have the show host. Have the Amazing Race winners race in the challenges, have a mole try to sway votes, put some Bachelors on the island next to an average joe, have the American Idols sing their way out of votes, see if Joe Millionare can really win a million, and maybe Joe Schmo can prevail in a non-set up reality show. Of course what would really get the ratings is to put Paris and Nicole there! ha!

That is soooo funny!Chip, you really make me laugh!I would like to see Andrew Firestone on there! Maybe he can turn some coconuts into wine!Also, I think LeeAnn from the last Bachelor would be a hoot on there!!! ~~~~~ LeeAnn on tribal council~~~~~"No Jeff, I was not talking to you! If I was, I would of said Jeff first!" :

I am glad I make you laugh! they say that men with a sense of humor get dates very easily. So why am I still single? Anyway, there was a reality show called "the next cannonball" shown on USA a few years ago. The show was teams of 3 racing across america, taking part in challenges along the way, and 1 team was eliminated each week. There was a team of Jeff and Susan from Survivor, along with Kaya from Temptation Island. I remember Jeff saying " I am on a team with a man named Susan, and a woman named Kaya". I thought it was the most hysterical thing I have ever hearad. Well, up until Nicole Ritchies impression of the autioneer last week.