Woolf’s waning momentum is thanks to America putting him in their bottom three last Thursday during “Songs from the Cinema” week. He crooned “Come Together” by the Beatles and the judges gave him mixed reviews, with Harry Connick Jr. concluding, “I think it was an average performance, but I think you’re on the way.”

Even though it was Ben Brileywho was sent home, Woolf should be worried going forward having received such a low vote count despite his frontrunner status.

Conversely, Johnson was universally praised last week for his haunting yet powerful rendition of Adele‘s “Skyfall.” Connick said, “You’re going to be very hard to beat,” while Jennifer Lopez was left momentarily speechless. (Watch Caleb’s performance below.)