Ann Rothstein’s reviews

Very knowledgable

4.0 stars

Posted by Ryan from Wauwatosa October 5, 2016

I filed myself in MKE cty. Things turned ugly. The sherriff's office couldn't get papers served. I found Ann on our Ulliance link from work. After 1 phone call, she arranged me with her process server and had papers served in less than 24 hrs! Had minimal meetings with Ann, due to her discussing issues with the other lawyer and setting things straight on short term marriages in WI.
After court she pleaded to me to NOT get married again, or hire her for a pre-nup. Will do! Thank you, Ann.

Ann is a phenomenal lawyer and great person

5.0 stars

Posted by Mary June 19, 2016

Not being from the area, I interviewed multiple lawyers trying to find the right lawyer to take on my daughters divorce and child custody case. My first conversation with her set her apart from all others as she talked to me herself for quite sometime to get details this is before she was ever hired. She gave me great specific and honest facts about Wisconsin laws, what we were facing and how we would need to approach the case. We hired her and she jumped right in, was available anytime. This is something very rare in a lawyer. She is one of a kind. I found her to be great in and out of the courtroom. She guided us to a relatively quick divorce with equal shared custody and placement. This was not an easy case, but she made it happen. Also, as for her as a person, she is just like family. She is so caring and truly has been there for us and with us. We just love her as a lawyer and a friend.

Passionate, strong, works with you, not for you!

5.0 stars

Anonymous review posted onJuly 16, 2015

let's just say that my divorce was one of the most difficult Ann can recall in recent years. Throughout the entire process, Ann consistently kept me informed, and gave great legal advice. Through the many hurtles and hoops we have to jump through, and was persistent in making sure that my needs were met. She was available for me 24 seven no matter what time and what the case was. I am so blessed that attorney Rothstein was by my side through my trial, and there is no doubt that my positive outcome was because of her. In Wisconsin, there is no doubt that mothers normally come out with a judges decision favorable, but in our case she fought for the right decision. We met multiple times working on briefs and other documents for the court and I appreciated that. She wanted my input and value my input to make sure all the facts were represented properly. She looked out for me and I will forever be grateful. And isn't just a lawyer, she is an extension of my family and cares about all of her family members. From the bottom of my heart and for my children, words can't explain how indebtedI am to you. You are amazing and thank you so much!

Hiring Ann was the best legal descision I ever made!

5.0 stars

Posted by Jason November 2, 2014

Ann truly was Heaven sent. My original divorce was in another state pro se, and I basically tied both my hands behind my back and didn’t even realize it. It was a hard fight, but there was absolutely no slacking on Ann’s part. I honestly believe the outcome of my custody issue was important to Ann, and legitimately cared. Ann provides a very reasonable rate based on your situation, and she won’t seek to nickel and dime you every chance she gets. She also won’t drag the case as long as possible in order to get more money. Understand, as most things in life, you can’t just throw money at her and then retire to the couch and expect a judgment in your favor. Simply put, your results will be reflective of the effort you put in. Ann will ALWAYS do the best possible with what you provide her. You will have to provide accurate information to her, and you will have to take ownership of your situation and do some work. (Constantly keeping your case in the ear of the guardian ad litem by writing him or her, keeping records of events, and providing Ann all the ammunition you can for her to make your case. But she will not abandon you and will tell you exactly how and what you need to do. She will still write anything that needs to be official and provide you with an opportunity to review before submitted.) She is the type of attorney that works for big boys and girls with a sense of personal responsibility, and this is a huge tool she uses to keep her costs so reasonable. Make no mistake, Ann will make good on her end of the bargain! She is at home in the courtroom/ mediation room and will ensure your side is heard loud and clear. She has an uncanny way of arguing a case and maintaining the momentum; the whole time maintaining the upmost in professionalism. Before your trial, Ann will give you advice of things you should or should not do. You may not always fully understand why initially, but FOLLOW IT. She knows what she is doing. She never led me down a bad road and I know she won’t to you either. Ann was NOT a ghost when I needed to talk to her. There were some times I had to talk to her as late as 11 oclock at night, and at some points during my ordeal talked to her every day of the week. I never paid 1 extra cent for those communications. She really cared, period. Ann always gave me an accurate assessment of the situation. She didn’t lie or build up false hope. Then she fights like hell anyway making my argument. If you are a dad with gumption that just wants what is fair, or a hard working single mom who is being bullied in the courtroom by some high dollar legal eagle, Ann is right for you. Because of her, my daughter is now out or a really bad situation and now has chance at a bright, successful future. Ann was able to secure primary placement for one of my children and get enforceable, fair visitation and rights for the other children. I am honored to not only call Ann my counsel, but my friend. Thank you Ann

Absolutely the best!

5.0 stars

Posted by James July 16, 2014

I normally don’t write reviews for anything but I felt like I needed to after I read the review that says she makes her clients do all the work. I’m a little in awe as to where this person is coming from. No one knows your case better then you and no one should care more about it then you. Ann genuinely cares about helping you but you need to care as well. She might ask you to type something up or make a phone call. Big deal. She keeps her operating costs down so she can pass the savings on to her clients. It sounds like this person didn't care enough to get off their lazy ass. It’s your battle with your ex, if you don’t want to fight it then no one will be able to help you. If you actually care, Ann will help make the best out of a bad situation. She’s the best guide/ally one could hope for.

Works for you, not for your wallet

5.0 stars

Anonymous review posted onJune 11, 2014

I foolishly allowed my ex to have primary physical placement of our children in an attempt to speed up or divorce process. I paid her child support for over 5 years and only got to see my kids every other weekend. With Ann's help, I built a successful case against my ex and won primary physical placement 5 years ago.

The review before mine complained about having to do work themselves and that you should hire a lawyer that will be "in your corner." Ann tells it like it is without sugar coating; she will not waste your time and money filing motions that will be a dead end. So what if you have to correct a typo? So what if you have to make a phone call on your own? I've got kids to raise and they come first; I'll gladly make a call on my own time rather than paying another lawyer $300.00/hr to do it just to pretend they're "in my corner."

Ann has been a blessing to be and my family since Day 1. She meets us at odd hours, calls and emails on the weekend, and genuinely wants to help her clients instead of being out to get every penny she can. She knows the law and abides by it, an asset that my ex's attorneys could benefit from.

Makes her clients do all of the work, Waste of time & money

1.0 star

Anonymous review posted onMay 14, 2014

Ann Rothstein appeared to have good reviews; so I hired her. I recommend that you do your homework first, on the lawyer that you are hiring. She never did anything to help us. She wanted me to do all of the work. Working with her was so absurd. It is a total waste time and money, find yourself another attorney, pay the extra cost and hire an assiduous lawyer, that will be in your corner. It will be in your best interest in the end.

Awesome Attorney

5.0 stars

Posted by Scott November 13, 2013

Ann handled my case for additional placement when my daughter was five, 8 years later, based on the agreement she helped me win, I have a healthy relationship with my daughter, and I'm a big part of her life.

She was clear, concise, and handled the case with a ton of respect and patience, and ultimately was a major reason reasonable I have a great relationship with my daughter today.

Ann Rothstein Gave Me My Life Back!

5.0 stars

Posted by Bruce August 6, 2013

Over the past 8 years, I have seen the inside of a court room many times. Each time seemed like the last.....a decision was made and my case was closed without fairness, justice, and my voice was never heard. My hopes were gone because it was the same thing each time; I was sure I would never see fairness but, I always did what the court documents said I was suppose to do. I honestly forgot who I was talking to but, I was told about Ann, given her number, and wasn't sure if I could go through this again. Then I figured I had nothing else to lose so I called her, received counsel, and finally had a lawyer who saw that I was doing the right thing all along. She worked around the clock on my case, was by my side every step of the long way, made sure I knew what to expect.......good or bad, and made sure my voice was heard. Ann stood up for me, she knew I did the right thing and clarified that! I can honestly tell you.....................Ann Rothstein gave me my life back!