Paul Wesley and Torrey DeVitto to Divorce

Paul Wesley and Torrey DeVitto are calling it quits after two years of marriage.

The couple "have decided to amicably split. They will continue to remain good friends," his rep confirms to PEOPLE exclusively.

The Vampire Diaries star, 31, and Pretty Little Liars actress, 29, met in 2007 on the set of their film Killer Movie. They were married in a private ceremony in New York City in April 2011.

DeVitto also appears on Vampire Diaries; in 2012, Wesley spoke of the benefits of working on the same set. "It's fantastic because otherwise we'd be 2000 miles away, Los Angeles and Georgia, so it's very nice to be in the same geographical location," he said at the time.