My question is since they had time to redesign the iPhone and create the iPad Mini, why couldn't they redesign the iPad 4?

Yeah, I'm sure they'll redesign it in 2013, making it lighter, thinner etc. but they could have done it with the iPad 4. It sucks thinking my $100 Logitech Ultrathin Keyboard Cover will become obsolete as well as my iSkin $100 folio case.

I'm pretty sure they have designs laid out for the next 10 years but each year they slowly implement something "new" to justify the "new" in the "new iPad" and brainwash the masses with how great the "new" device is and mention nothing good about the old one except praising how good the new is compared to the old model.

macrumors 6502a

macrumors 6502a

It seems obvious that the iPad 4 was merely a necessary spec bump to stay uniform with the Lightning switch and to offer a more compelling product for the holiday season. Several people I spoke to were hesitant to ever buy the 3rd Gen because of the fact that it wasn't a substantial performance increase over the iPad 2. In hindsight, there's no denying that the A5X was only meant as a stopgap.

Yes it does suck that your accessories designed for the 2/3/4th Gen will likely be physically incompatible with the 5th generation. However, there will likely be newer more impressive peripheals available by that time.

P.S. I just picked up the same Logitech keyboard. Do you use any iPad back case along with the Logitech?

thread startermacrumors regular

It seems obvious that the iPad 4 was merely a necessary spec bump to stay uniform with the Lightning switch and to offer a more compelling product for the holiday season. Several people I spoke to were hesitant to ever buy the 3rd Gen because of the fact that it wasn't a substantial performance increase over the iPad 2. In hindsight, there's no denying that the A5X was only meant as a stopgap.

Yes it does suck that your accessories designed for the 2/3/4th Gen will likely be physically incompatible with the 5th generation. However, there will likely be newer more impressive peripheals available by that time.

P.S. I just picked up the same Logitech keyboard. Do you use any iPad back case along with the Logitech?

Click to expand...

I use a "Just Mobile" stand http://www.just-mobile.com/ipad/encore.html for the iPad and the keyboard is in front of the iPad since I use a silicone case on the iPad to protect the back. I guess since the ketboard is bluetooth it will be compatible with the 5th gen. I've placed rubber feet/bumpers on the back of the logitech keyboard to protect the aluminum finish.

macrumors 68000

The question you ask suggests you think that Apple has it in them to build things as thin as they want at any time, regardless of battery size and other internals, like they've done it for one device and therefore they neglected these other devices that didn't get the same treatment.

I think there are reasons Apple devices are the sizes they are (physical constraints of the hardware), but those are all irrelevant when talking about the iPad 4, because that was an anomalous update to the device, only designed to reset the refresh cycle so that it seems "fresh" for a year, until Autumn 2013, at which time it will get a full upgrade, incorporating a feature set (and perhaps redesign) warrants a product refresh/update.

Guest

You do realise that all these products are designed by one soft spoken British guy that's trapped in the basement of their Cupertino headquarters?

Between designing new products like the ipad mini, iphone 5, retina macbook pro's and new imacs, he also spends several hours a day working on an escape tunnel he's digging out behind a shelf of discarded Thunderbolt Display prototypes in the rear quadrant of building 3.

macrumors 6502a

macrumors 601

You do realise that all these products are designed by one bald guy with a British accent that's trapped in the basement of their Cupertino headquarters?

Between designing new products like the ipad mini, iphone 5, retina macbook pro's and new imacs, he also spends several hours a day working on an escape tunnel he's digging out behind a shelf of discarded Thunderbolt Display prototypes in the rear quadrant of building 3.

macrumors P6

I'm pretty sure they have designs laid out for the next 10 years but each year they slowly implement something "new" to justify the "new" in the "new iPad" and brainwash the masses with how great the "new" device is and mention nothing good about the old one except praising how good the new is compared to the old model.

Click to expand...

You should be good to go then... since you are aware of their tactics, just avoid the brainwash of the next product and keep what you have with all of your accessories
Problem solved

thread startermacrumors regular

You do realise that all these products are designed by one soft spoken British guy that's trapped in the basement of their Cupertino headquarters?

Between designing new products like the ipad mini, iphone 5, retina macbook pro's and new imacs, he also spends several hours a day working on an escape tunnel he's digging out behind a shelf of discarded Thunderbolt Display prototypes in the rear quadrant of building 3.

macrumors 6502

My question is since they had time to redesign the iPhone and create the iPad Mini, why couldn't they redesign the iPad 4?

Click to expand...

Not enough design resources? Limitations with the current technology (i.e., the battery needs to be a certain size to adequately power the Retina display)?

Quote

Yeah, I'm sure they'll redesign it in 2013, making it lighter, thinner etc. but they could have done it with the iPad 4.

Click to expand...

How do you know that? Do you have the necessary engineering background and insight into Apple's design processes?

Quote

It sucks thinking my $100 Logitech Ultrathin Keyboard Cover will become obsolete as well as my iSkin $100 folio case.

Click to expand...

That's why I keep my iDevice accessory purchases to a minimum. But how would the situation be different if they'd redesigned the iPad 4? You'd buy accessories for it. Then Apple would redesign either the iPad 5 or 6, and your iPad 4 accessories would be obsolete if you chose to upgrade.

Quote

I'm pretty sure they have designs laid out for the next 10 years

Click to expand...

You really believe that? I don't think any high-tech roadmaps go out that far, because of the rate at which technology changes.

Quote

but each year they slowly implement something "new" to justify the "new" in the "new iPad" and brainwash the masses with how great the "new" device is and mention nothing good about the old one except praising how good the new is compared to the old model.

Click to expand...

You're saying you're brainwashed, then? Because you said your iPad accessories will become obsolete when the next iPad comes out. If it's just brainwashing, then hang onto your iPad 4 for as long as it's useful. That's what I plan to do with mine. I love it, having recently upgraded from my iPad 1.

macrumors 6502a

If you upgrade from the iPad 3 to the iPad 4...you have no reason to complain about the iPad 5 coming in March.

If you kept your iPad 3 because you were smart, a redesigned iPad 5 is your reward for your patience.

If you got the iPad 4 for a gift, your going to enjoy it a lot and it won't be outdated for a long time.

Click to expand...

This is good sense. It's safe to say that iPad 3-5 will enjoy most if not all of the new iOS 7 features. Typically those excluded are related to hardware, and I haven't seen any major hardware predictions (aside from display improvements and design/weight changes which obviously don't impact the OS).

My question is since they had time to redesign the iPhone and create the iPad Mini, why couldn't they redesign the iPad 4?

Yeah, I'm sure they'll redesign it in 2013, making it lighter, thinner etc. but they could have done it with the iPad 4. It sucks thinking my $100 Logitech Ultrathin Keyboard Cover will become obsolete as well as my iSkin $100 folio case.

I'm pretty sure they have designs laid out for the next 10 years but each year they slowly implement something "new" to justify the "new" in the "new iPad" and brainwash the masses with how great the "new" device is and mention nothing good about the old one except praising how good the new is compared to the old model.

MacRumors attracts a broad audience
of both consumers and professionals interested in
the latest technologies and products. We also boast an active community focused on
purchasing decisions and technical aspects of the iPhone, iPod, iPad, and Mac platforms.