Chip and Joanna Gaines might seem like pros when it comes to pregnancy announcements, after sharing with fans they’re expecting their fifth child in an adorable Instagram in January. But as of Wednesday morning, it looks like Chip might have made a rookie mistake (which is funny, considering he’s far from one) and let the new baby’s gender slip.

“We’re just about to have another little baby,” Chip shared with Gage before accidentally giving away too much detail. “So can you help me come up with a D name? A boy. Is that a secret? I don’t know. That might not even be allowed on Twitter — you better keep that to yourself dude. But listen to me, it’s a little boy and I need a D name, and so far, all I could come up with was Dragon. And [Joanna’s] like, you are not calling that baby Dragon.”

Gage, who fractured all of his bones before being born, chuckled with Chip, likely not even realizing the anticipation surrounding the announcement. However, since seeing the video themselves Wednesday morning, fans have been quick to share their joy — as well as some baby name suggestions.

im not crying, you’re crying! ahh! soo excited for you guys, another boy! so exciting! the girls are out numbered! lol! I saw another twitter user say Deacon as a possible name. or how about Demo Day! haha!

The couple are already parents to Drake, 12; Ella, 11; Duke, 9; and Emmie Kay; 7. And although Joanna has yet to comment publicly on the announcement, let’s just hope that Chip’s tweet was mother-approved.