Dry Dog Food Comparison Chart

A Which Dog Food Guide for Loving Pet Owners

Two of the most common questions we get here at Hello Sausage are, “what is in dog food?” and, “is dog food good for dogs?” And the truth is that far too many people just don’t know the answer to either question!

So today we thought we’d dedicate some time (and some serious research) to a bit of dog food analysis. After all, your pet’s diet and nutrition are just as important as your own, right? Eating unhealthy food every day takes it’s toll on a dog in exactly the same way as it does your own body.

Recently, a growing awareness of the poor quality of many dog food brands has caused many loving pet owners to consider making homemade dog food. But is this a healthier path than buying ready made dog food?

The truth is that, as long as you choose an ethical company which uses healthy dog food recipes, your dog is much more likely to get the nutritional value it needs from store-bought dog food than from make your own dog food.

Here at YourPetHatesYou, we want the very best for your dogs as well as our own, so we’ve spent hours researching dog nutrition, essential dog food ingredients, dog food brands, expert opinions and customers’ dog food reviews and put together this helpful chart so that you can compare dry dog food brands and make a well informed decision that’s best for you and for your dog.

We’ve carefully selected twenty products which we would be happy to feed our own dogs and rejected dog food companies with unethical practices or food with poor nutritional value.

While we are recommending these dog food brands, it is important to be aware that your dog may have dietary requirements or allergies which you are not aware of. For example, a dog food type that is recommended by veterinarians and has received thousands of positive independent dog food reviews from buyers may produce stomach upsets or other effects in some dogs. Be prepared to try out more than one food until you get the right fit for your dog.

Okay, that’s enough barking and howling on for now, let’s take a closer look at the quality of dog food brands:

Dogs and puppies with ordinary dietary requirements, all breeds and sizes.
After more than 1300 reviews, this food has an average consumer rating of 4.5 out of 5 stars and 75{55e4f5004a693d68d8dbd5c4b75b248afff95f4e84df91a30e078444959f10b5} of buyers rate it the full 5 stars.

$50 – $60 per 44 pound bag. Smaller sizes also available.

Taste of the Wild Dry Dog Food

Formulated to be as close to a dog’s natural ‘wild’ diet as possible: real roasted meats supplemented with vegetables.
Free of filler ingredients.
Natural antioxidants and digestible proteins.

Dogs and puppies with ordinary dietary requirements, all breeds and sizes.
This dog food has had well over 8000 reviews and maintains a consumer rating of 4.6 out of 5 stars. It is the Number One Best Seller in Dry Dog Food on Amazon.com.

Adult dogs of all breeds and sizes.
This up and coming product is new to the market, and, after nearly 100 reviews, has an overall consumer rating of 4.6 out of 5 stars.

$30 – $40 per 5 pound bag.

ULTRA Weight Management Dog Food

Helps to manage your dog’s weight naturally without hunger.
Made with 100{55e4f5004a693d68d8dbd5c4b75b248afff95f4e84df91a30e078444959f10b5} natural ingredients.
Complete nutrition system for less active dogs.
Made in the USA.

Overweight adult dogs requiring a weight management program.

After more than 100 reviews, this product maintains a 4.6 out of 5 star consumer rating and more than 80{55e4f5004a693d68d8dbd5c4b75b248afff95f4e84df91a30e078444959f10b5} of users rate it the full 5 stars.

$45 – $55 per 30 pound bag. Smaller sizes available.

Purina Pro Plan Savor Dry Dog Food

Adult dogs of all breeds and sizes.
After nearly 1500 reviews, this product has an average consumer rating of 4.6 out of 5 stars and more than 75{55e4f5004a693d68d8dbd5c4b75b248afff95f4e84df91a30e078444959f10b5} of customers rate it the full 5 stars.

$35 – $45 per 35 pound bag. Smaller sizes available.

Blue Buffalo Life Protection Dry Adult Dog Food

Contains high quality lamb, garden veggies and digestion friendly whole grain fiber from corn and rice.
ENhanced with vitamins, minerals and antioxidants.
Made ethically in the USA.

Adult dogs of all breeds and sizes.
After close to 2500 customer reviews, this product maintains an average consumer rating of 4.6 out of 5 stars and more than 75{55e4f5004a693d68d8dbd5c4b75b248afff95f4e84df91a30e078444959f10b5} of buyers rate it the full 5 stars.

Adult dogs of all breeds and sizes.
After more than 300 reviews, Organix dog food has an overall consumer rating of 4.4 out of 5 stars and more than 75{55e4f5004a693d68d8dbd5c4b75b248afff95f4e84df91a30e078444959f10b5} of customers rate it the full 5 stars.

Rachael Ray Nutrish Natural Dry Dog Food

Dogs and puppies with ordinary dietary requirements, all breeds and sizes.
After close to 1500 consumer reviews, this product has an average rating of 4.5 out of 5 stars.

$25 – $35 per 28 pound bag. Smaller and larger sizes available.

IAMS PROACTIVE HEALTH Adult Dry Dog Food

Made with high grade proteins from chickens and eggs.
Supports healthy joints, soft skin and a shiny coat.
Rich in Omega 6 fatty acids.

Adult dogs of all breeds and sizes.
After more than 700 consumer reviews, this product has been overwhelmingly popular and maintains an overall rating of 4.7 out of 5 stars.

$15 – $25 per 25 pound bag. Larger sizes available.

Hill’s Science Diet Large Breed Dry Dog Food

All natural ingredients which include vitamins, minerals and antioxidants.
Free of artificial flavors and colors.
Supports joint mobility.

Suitable for larger dog breeds such as labradors, alsatians,
dobermans, mastiffs and similar.

After close to 1000 reviews, Science diet retains an overall consumer rating of 4.6 out of 5 stars and more than 75{55e4f5004a693d68d8dbd5c4b75b248afff95f4e84df91a30e078444959f10b5} of buyers rate it the full 5 stars.

$35 – $45 per 38.5 pound bag. Smaller sizes available.

Wellness CORE Natural Grain Free Dry Dog Food

Rich in protein from chicken and turkey.
100{55e4f5004a693d68d8dbd5c4b75b248afff95f4e84df91a30e078444959f10b5} free of grains, artificial flavors and fillers.
All natural, made in the USA.
Fish and flaxseed omega promotes skin and coat health.

Adult dogs of all breeds and sizes.
After well over 2500 consumer reviews, this product has an overall rating of 4.6 out of 5 stars and 80{55e4f5004a693d68d8dbd5c4b75b248afff95f4e84df91a30e078444959f10b5} of users rate it the full 5 stars.

Dogs and puppies with ordinary dietary requirements, all breeds and sizes.
After close to 400 reviews, this dog food has an average rating of 4.6 out of 5 stars and nearly 75{55e4f5004a693d68d8dbd5c4b75b248afff95f4e84df91a30e078444959f10b5} of buyers rated it the full 5 stars.

Suitable for larger dog breeds such as labradors, alsatians,
dobermans, mastiffs and similar.
After more than 100 reviews, this dog food has an average consumer rating of 4.6 out of 5 stars and more than 80{55e4f5004a693d68d8dbd5c4b75b248afff95f4e84df91a30e078444959f10b5} of users rate it the full 5 stars.

$35 to $45 per 30 pound bag. Smaller sizes available.

Whole Earth Farms Grain Free Chicken and Turkey Recipe Dry Dog Food

Made in the USA from organic pork, beef and lamb.
Free of grain, poultry by-products and ingredients from china.
Added vitamins and minerals for healthy joints, bones and coats.

Dogs and puppies with ordinary dietary requirements, all breeds and sizes.
After 450 reviews, this organic dog food maintains an overall customer rating of 4.5 out of 5 stars and 75{55e4f5004a693d68d8dbd5c4b75b248afff95f4e84df91a30e078444959f10b5} of consumers rate it the full 5 stars.

$35 – $45 per 25 pound bag. Smaller sizes available.

Holistic Select Natural Dry Dog Food

Balanced levels of fat and protein for a healthy diet.
Small sized kibble for smaller dogs.
Anchovy and Sardine for rich Omega oils.

Small and miniature dog breeds such as chihuahuas, shih tzus, small terriers and teacup breeds.
After close to 800 customer reviews, this natural dog food maintains an impressive overall consumer rating of 4.7 out of 5 stars. More than 80{55e4f5004a693d68d8dbd5c4b75b248afff95f4e84df91a30e078444959f10b5} of buyers rated it the full 5 stars.

$8 – $15 per 3 pound bag. Larger sizes available.

Summary: Making Dog Food vs. Buying Dog Food

While there are some very good healthy homemade dog food recipes available, it can be hard to know whether you are giving your dog a complete and nutritious diet when you make home made dog food. It can also work out to be incredibly expensive and time consuming!

You’re far better off to buy food from trusted dog food manufacturers who have scientifically developed recipes, high quality nutritious ingredients and ethical practices. And, of course, a quality dog food brand should show that they understand dogs and have dogs’ best interests at heart! (Not just lining their own pockets!).

We hope that this dog food ingredients comparison has been useful for you and that you find the very best food for your “best friend”.