Word 2007 documents rejected by leading science journals

When I first read a blog pointed to by nerd news aggregator Slashdot that two of the world's leading science journals are rejecting document submissions in Word 2007, I was mildly intrigued. When I discovered that not even Word 2007 documents saved in earlier version Microsoft Word formats would accepted, my interest level shot through the roof.

Apparently, as the blog from Harvard science
graduate Rob Weir and statements from the two journals, Science and
Nature, point out, the main problem is the way Word 2007 processes the
characters used in mathematical equations.

For reasons known only to itself, Microsoft has changed the default
equations editor of Word 2007 so that, unlike previous versions of
Word, it is no longer compatible with the globally accepted standard
for writing equations in documents, Mathematical Markup Language
(MathML).

The website of Science, the journal of the America Association for the
Advancement of Science, does not hold back criticism of Microsoft in
its explanation of why it will not accept Word 2007 submissions:

"Because of changes Microsoft has made in its recent Word release that
are incompatible with our internal workflow, which was built around
previous versions of the software, Science cannot at present accept any
files in the new .docx format produced through Microsoft Word 2007,
either for initial submission or for revision. Users of this release of
Word should convert these files to a format compatible with Word 2003
or Word for Macintosh 2004 (or, for initial submission, to a PDF file)
before submitting to Science.

"Users of Word 2007 should also be aware that equations created with
the default equation editor included in Microsoft Word 2007 will be
unacceptable in revision, even if the file is converted to a format
compatible with earlier versions of Word; this is because conversion
will render equations as graphics and prevent electronic printing of
equations, and because the default equation editor packaged with Word
2007 -- for reasons that, quite frankly, utterly baffle us -- was not
designed to be compatible with MathML. Regrettably, we will be forced
to return any revised manuscript created with the Word 2007 default
equation editor to authors for re-editing. To get around this, please
use the MathType equation editor or the equation editor included in
previous versions of Microsoft Word."

Nature was more succinct but no less emphatic in its explanation:

"We currently cannot accept files saved in Microsoft Office 2007
formats. Equations and special characters (for example, Greek letters)
cannot be edited and are incompatible with Nature's own editing and
typesetting programs."

It is hard to believe that even Microsoft would be so arrogant as to
expect scientists and scientific publishers around the world to switch
from the globally accepted MathML standard just so they can use Word
2007. It almost seems as if Microsoft is trying to drive the scientific
community into the arms of OpenOffice.org.

In any case, as has just been demonstrated by at least two important
publishers, the power to dictate standards in the documents space may
be starting to shift away from the world's largest software vendor and
toward the user community.

FREE WHITEPAPER - REMOTE SUPPORT TRENDS FOR 2015

Does your remote support strategy keep you and your CEO awake at night?

Today’s remote support solutions offer much more than just remote control for PCs. Their functional footprint is expanding to include support for more devices and richer analytics for trend analysis and supervisor dashboards.

It is imperative that service executives acquaint themselves with the new features and capabilities being introduced by leading remote support platforms and find ways to leverage the capabilities beyond technical support.

Field services, education services, professional services, and managed services are all increasing adoption of these tools to boost productivity and avoid on-site visits.

Which product is easiest to deploy, has the best maintenance mode capabilities, the best mobile access and custom reporting, dynamic thresholds setting, and enhanced discovery capabilities?

To find out all you need to know about using remote support to improve your bottom line, download this FREE Whitepaper.

Stan Beer co-founded iTWire in 2005. With 30 plus years of experience working in IT and Australian technology media, Beer has published articles in most of the IT publications that have mattered, including the AFR, The Australian, SMH, The Age, as well as a multitude of trade publications.