Al-Fatihah wrote:You do not have observable evidence of a dinosaur or a fossil forming. Therefore, you have no logical evidence that dinosaurs or dinosaur fossils exist as you have no firsthand evidence. Your argument of assimilation proves my point, as you assimilate through direct observations. Yet you have no direct observable evidence of a dinosaur or a fossil forming.

Al-Fatihah wrote:You do not have observable evidence of a dinosaur or a fossil forming. Therefore, you have no logical evidence that dinosaurs or dinosaur fossils exist as you have no firsthand evidence. Your argument of assimilation proves my point, as you assimilate through direct observations. Yet you have no direct observable evidence of a dinosaur or a fossil forming.

Al-Fatihah wrote:Response: There is no logical evidence that they have existed.

Ahhh Al-Fatihah. What next.

I am Dutch woman, and my father was a fisherman. As you can imagine he was after fish. That was what he wanted to find in his nets. But what he also often found in his nets were bones. Mammoths bones. Not one, but many. Like this one.

Al-Fatihah wrote:Response: There is no logical evidence that they have existed.

Ahhh Al-Fatihah. What next.

I am Dutch woman, and my father was a fisherman. As you can imagine he was after fish. That was what he wanted to find in his nets. But what he also often found in his nets were bones. Mammoths bones. Not one, but many. Like this one.

manfred wrote:just as any Christian who learns it in school will not suddenly decide he must be an atheist. People are more complex than that.

That is a fact.Well, I learned about Darwin's theory for the first time in my 8th standard and I still was a believer 15 years later.The reason is I never learnt about any Hindu creation myth.Now thinklogic,a supposedly Hindu forum member of the old forum said that Hindus have not one but many creation myths.In the old old forum,they mentioned about creation arising out of egg from Brahma/egg of Brahma called Brahmaanda.Now later on I learnt from some other sources that creation was due to the joint efforts of Brahma,Prajapatis,Manus etc.Still that did not make me an atheist.May be because Hindu pundits will come up with new reasoning that evolution happened in one yuga or manvantaram and different modes of creation in other yugas or manvantaras.It is only the truth in Edison's words that had a profound effect on my thinking.

Last edited by Nosuperstition on Wed Jan 27, 2016 4:01 pm, edited 1 time in total.

Prime Minister Narendra Modi waived loans to the tune of hundreds of thousands of rupees for corporate firms.Yet he is not prepared to give even a few thousand crores to debt ridden remnant Andhra Pradesh(debts due to unjust division in 2014) for constructing the national project of Polavaram.

Al-Fatihah wrote:Response: Exactly. Repeating the same thing will not improve it, which is why your repetition of the same flawed argument continues to fail.

You do not have observable evidence of a dinosaur or a fossil forming. Therefore, you have no logical evidence that dinosaurs or dinosaur fossils exist as you have no firsthand evidence. Your argument of assimilation proves my point, as you assimilate through direct observations. Yet you have no direct observable evidence of a dinosaur or a fossil forming.

So according to your own assimilation argument, both are false.

Of course!!!. I see where you come from. Since the entire knowledge of Islam was conceived by one man, and only over 23 year span - it is easy to understand your repeated dismissal of any knowledge accumulated over longer periods.

Al-Fatihah wrote:Response: There is no logical evidence that they have existed.

Ahhh Al-Fatihah. What next.

I am Dutch woman, and my father was a fisherman. As you can imagine he was after fish. That was what he wanted to find in his nets. But what he also often found in his nets were bones. Mammoths bones. Not one, but many. Like this one.

So many bones and molars that the university was not interested in them any more . So I still have some mammoth molars in my possession.

You still think "There is no logical evidence that they have existed." ?

Response: If I show you a picture of Santa Clause, does that mean Santa Claus exist?

Ariel. Please, we need to get better understanding from where our friend al-Fatihah comes from. He is right, since dinosaurs are not mentioned in Qur'an - nor there is any evidence that they lived between 610-632 ACE - a period of Islamic knowledge was handed from Allah to Big Muhmmmad. Then yes "There is no logical evidence that they have existed."

Al-Fatihah wrote:Response: If I show you a picture of Santa Clause, does that mean Santa Claus exist?

I feel pity for you Al-Fatihah.

Indeed, pity is still a compliment. It would have been very funny, had it not be so sad.

You guys need to understand al-fitnah believes only in what he can see himself. Am I right al-fitnah ? I am sure you don't believe in HIV virus, or bacteria , or atom or electron , planets , galaxies , earth is round ...... all these things that you have not seen from your own eyes you can not believe them, right ??

I have seen many but he is one of a kind muslim brother

al-fitnah this skeleton in the museum is all fake?? they are just making fool of people ?

Last edited by iffo on Sun Jan 03, 2016 8:09 am, edited 4 times in total.

My biology teacher from 8th to 10th , Mrs Padma had shown all of my classmates ,various specimens of micro-organisms under the microscope.So I believe they exist.

Prime Minister Narendra Modi waived loans to the tune of hundreds of thousands of rupees for corporate firms.Yet he is not prepared to give even a few thousand crores to debt ridden remnant Andhra Pradesh(debts due to unjust division in 2014) for constructing the national project of Polavaram.