Matt Cosby of Bronson was named first runner-up and “Blesst” Ellen Burke, Sturgis was second runner-up.

Mettler said the win sincerely took her by surprise. But her children had plans for the prize money, in case she won.

“The kids have been wanting to donate it so, we are going to look into giving it away during the holidays,” she said.

Mettler faced seven other contestants in the final round, Burke, Cosby, Chelsea Fink of Nappanee, Ind., Larry Forest of Elkhart, Ind., Daniel Jackson of Sturgis, Michael Reed of Three Rivers and Samantha Saltsman of Angola, Ind.

Mettler excelled at selecting songs to best showcase her vocal ability.

The theme from “Titanic” was her first song. Belting it out with powerful volume then pulling back so her notes would hit then hover melodically, Mettler’s voice rivaled that of Celine Dion throughout this song.

In the second round, Mettler took a walk on the country side and smoothly sang the ballad, “There You Are” by Martina Mcbride before finishing the competition with a perfect-pitched, self-styled version of Elvis’ “I cant Help Falling In Love.”

“I just started working with the Elvis song this morning,” Mettler said. “So it was nice to do something a little different.”

Mettler’s plans are to continue doing what she has been doing — being a mom — but she does have plans to sing in the future.

“I am going to sing in Detroit at a Tigers game, so I am really excited about that. That’s a wonderful opportunity for me and, I can’t wait.”

Mettler does not advertise her vocal abilities and performs only through personal referrals.

“‘Michiana Idol 5’ had unbelievable talent,” said “Idol” producer and Swick Broadcasting president, Steve Swick. “The contestants were all great and Missy did an amazing job, which is why she is now $993 richer. It was also nice to see a full house enjoy this event. It’s great to be a part of bringing the community together for a positive, family-friendly, entertaining event in Sturgis.”