Trace Elements in West Virginia Coals

THULIUM (Tm)

Thulium is one of the very low abundance rare earth elements and has
no detrimental environmental impact.

Geologic Distribution: Of 546 samples analyzed, only 11 had detectable
levels of thulium with a mean whole coal Tm of 0.28 ppm (±0.14 ppm).
These samples were confined to mainly Kanawha Formation coals with 4 from
the No. 2 Gas coal, 3 from the Powellton, and others were from the Sewell,
Winifrede and Coalburg coals. Thulium is present in trace quantities (0.007%)
in the mineral monazite1. Monazite
was found in trace amounts in 22 of 24 coal samples examined using scanning
electron microscopy (SEM) in an unpublished
study by the WVGES and probably is present in most coals.

Economic Impact: Thulium in coal is of no economic importance,
and because of its high price Tm has few applications 1.

Environmental Impact: Thulium has low toxicity and emissions
during coal combustion and mining are not considered an environmental hazard
1.