Today's hours

The Zagat Review

3.6

Food

3.8

Decor

3.8

Service

A “Gramercy Park tradition”, this circa-1864 “landmark” turns out “gently priced” Italian-American pub grub in an “old-time” space where former regular O. Henry “would still be comfortable”; though the food's “passable”, it’s the “history, charm” and “lively” front bar that “brings you back.”