The SitePoint Forums have moved.

You can now find them here.
This forum is now closed to new posts, but you can browse existing content.
You can find out more information about the move and how to open a new account (if necessary) here.
If you get stuck you can get support by emailing forums@sitepoint.com

If this is your first visit, be sure to
check out the FAQ by clicking the
link above. You may have to register
before you can post: click the register link above to proceed. To start viewing messages,
select the forum that you want to visit from the selection below.

Consciousness independent of life?

How about this for an article:http://www.boston.com/news/daily/28/brain.htm
Thought some of the religiously-minded would like to see it, I could argue some of the points in it, but best if you guys have a look first.
The mind is a truly mysterious thing.

Originally posted by z7 What is their to start - the body dies, the soul lives on - tell me something I didn't already know.

Does the soul live on? Jesus talks about the soul being destroyed in Matthew. Just thinking that NDE's could be described as 'in the spirit' experiences instead? But that starts off the soul and/or spirit discussion which gets away from the original thread.

As to NDE's. I believe they happen. I believe that man has a spiritual dimension that is ignored in this material world.

z7, send me an email telling me what you know and I'll send you back something you didn't know?

Well, personally I'd need more than this to think there's a case - but I haven't got the faintest idea how the brain is affected by this stuff. Could it be an illusory experience? I really don't know. I mean, what is consciousness anyway, could consciousness be an illusion, and there is no free will? Or does consciousness occur 'on a higher level'? Even though I don't know what that I mean by that.
All I can really do is repeat myself - the mind is a truly mysterious thing.

the soul can be destroyed... Depends on which word is used to translate to soul...

"He speculated that human consciousness may work independently of the brain, using the gray matter as a mechanism to manifest the thoughts, just as a television set translates waves in the air into picture and sound."

Yes... we are all one consciousness, we just happen to each be tuned to our own frequency </sarcasm> (not to offend you marina).

This scientist is speculating on stuff that has nothing to do with the data from the study.

"The Tibetans considered Cannabis sacred. A Mahayana Buddhist tradition maintains that during the six steps of asceticism leading to his enlightenment, Buddha lived on one Hemp seed a day.
He is often depicted with Soma leaves in his begging bowl and the mysterious god-narcotic Soma has occasionally been identified with Hemp.
In Tantric Buddhism of the Himalayas of Tibet, Cannabis plays a very significant role in the meditative ritual used to facilitate deep meditation and heighten awareness."
From:http://www.a1b2c3.com/drugs/mj001.htm

Well, either way, one man's weed is another man's soul-destroyer, that's true enough.
What we need is for someone with an NDE to say they saw Buddha, and he offered them a toke on some sacred Tibetan 'herbs'. Proof enough for me.

Originally posted by studiococo the soul can be destroyed... Depends on which word is used to translate to soul...

"He speculated that human consciousness may work independently of the brain, using the gray matter as a mechanism to manifest the thoughts, just as a television set translates waves in the air into picture and sound."

Yes... we are all one consciousness, we just happen to each be tuned to our own frequency </sarcasm> (not to offend you marina).

This scientist is speculating on stuff that has nothing to do with the data from the study.

It may have nothing to do with data from the study, but there is a LOT more reasoning behind it than is given in the article.

About 60 years ago physicists observed something that was unexplainable. They were watching two photons flying around and found that each one seemed to know what the other was doing instantaneously. Their movements co-varied exactly. This observation caused a real problem for physicists because in order for them to communicate instantaneously, the information passing "between" them would have to be moving faster than the speed of light. According to Einstein's Special Theory of Relativity this was impossible. Taking this into account, they concluded and then proved that there had to be a deeper level of existence, outside of our three dimensional universe where everything is connected. The reason why the "two" particles knew where the other was going was because at a deeper level they were of the same holograph. It was only the scientists' observations that made them appear separate. We are made of the same stuff as these particles. There is a deeper level of reality on which we are all connected. Mind (consciousness) is not rooted in any one place. It is omnipresent. This means we have access to all the information there is. It means that distance healing is possible and that the concept itself (distance) is a misnomer. It means we have a lot more to do with how the world is than what Newtonian physics led us to believe.

Holograph: from laser technology. Bounce a stream of coherent light off some object onto a photographic plate; that plate retains a three-dimensional image of that object and will project that image in 3 dimensions when that laser light shines through the plate. What makes this phenomenon holographic is that if you break the plate, every fragment of that plate will prove to have that entire 3-dimensional image! Every particle of that plate carries the complete record of information. The more profound aspect of this phenomenon is that:

You are correct, the scientist is speculating, but there's more... a LOT more thought behind his statement than most people realize. Whether people want to turn that into some spiritual thing, or not, is rather irrelevant.

NDE - the tunnel and the light

On NDE: some studies have brought the hypothesis that the NDEs where the subjects describe a tunnel with a light at the end of it, are illusions inducted by the release of an abnormal amount of a molecule in our brain. My memories are unclear, so I can't elaborate more on this, I'll try to find at least one or two articles on this on the web...

Edit: I should read the articles entirely before I post, since what I call "the release of a molecule" seems just to be the lack of one, oxygen.

z7, I never doubted the existence of the soul. Still, I have a hard time taking conclusions based on the testimonies of 7 people out of 63.
To me, the brain looks like it's not functioning anymore but that may be because we cannot detect some kinds of brain activity. Maybe it's still functionning, neurons communicating only through chemical reactions rather than electric signals. After all, most of the basic cell functions are still acting when we're dead, until the cells themselves die.