New York Yankees third baseman Alex Rodriguez can’t hide from criticism of his poor offensive output or the trade speculation swirling around him. Even when he seemingly has the protection and isolation of the team’s bench, trouble finds him.

Treacy and friend Kate Quinn reportedly received a baseball from Rodriguez during the ninth inning of the Yankees’ Game 1 loss to the Detroit Tigers. There was a note on the baseball for the two women to write their phone numbers on the ball and return it to the Yankees’ bench.

The episode has led to renewed criticism of A-Rod—both on and off the field—as the Yankees try to battle back from a 3-0 ALCS deficit. Not only has A-Rod been benched during the series, there now are rumors that the Yankees will try to deal him this offseason.