I got a good question for you guys. Who are the 3 active players who have more Points and more PIMS recorded with a single team than they have played games with that team.

I was going with Malkin and Crosby and Thornton with Boston. But with the hint that two of them are not with another team, one or both of Malkin or Crosby is wrong. I'll go with Malkin since Sid isn't know for PIMs.

Ah, i didn't read that closely enough to see it was only 2 of the 3 who are with new teams.

I just looked up Malkin and he's one of them. He has 437GP's, 539PTS and barely squeezes by with 444PIMS. Ironically, and the OP can clarify, if not for the 18PIMS in 10 games this season so far, he'd fall just shy by 1 single PIM!!! So, if the OP was using a list not including this year, Malkin may not be one he was including?

I just looked up Thornton (as well as Hossa and Kovalchuk after i posted them earlier) and none qualify.

Guest2486 ( )

Posted - 02/07/2013 : 13:28:12

Malkin is correct Hossa and Kovulchuk are wrong all tho Kovalchuk came close with ATL Thornton also came close with BOS but not quite. However one of these guys did do it with ATL

Malkin is correct Hossa and Kovulchuk are wrong all tho Kovalchuk came close with ATL Thornton also came close with BOS but not quite. However one of these guys did do it with ATL

OK, so i came up with the only short term ATL guy who put up points that i could think of and that's Marc Savard. So, thinking he's prob NO WHERE NEAR the necessary PIMS, i go check. BAM! Never knew he was such a goon! Lol. Marc Savard GP-184 PTS-196 PIM-262

Without the clue, i'd never have guessed him! We're still short one, correct? And if he's as obscure as Savard, we may need another clue. lol.

Guest9848 ( )

Posted - 02/07/2013 : 13:53:45

Marc Savard is indeed correct. The trivia book im getting this out of was published after the 2011 season at the time Malkin had GP 352 P 418 and PIMs 356. The final guy ill give you a clue did it with a Canadian team.

quote:Originally posted by Alex116OK, so i came up with the only short term ATL guy who put up points that i could think of and that's Marc Savard. So, thinking he's prob NO WHERE NEAR the necessary PIMS, i go check. BAM! Never knew he was such a goon! Lol. Marc Savard GP-184 PTS-196 PIM-262

Without the clue, i'd never have guessed him! We're still short one, correct? And if he's as obscure as Savard, we may need another clue. lol.

Marc Savard is indeed correct. The trivia book im getting this out of was published after the 2011 season at the time Malkin had GP 352 P 418 and PIMs 356. The final guy ill give you a clue did it with a Canadian team.

Savard, like guys like Pronger (inj) and Arnott (FA), are technically still active but let's face it, Savard is DONE, Pronger is in doubt and Arnott may catch on somewhere eventually!

Guest9848 ( )

Posted - 02/07/2013 : 14:15:27

Malkin, Heatley, Savard good work guys.

Guest9848 ( )

Posted - 02/07/2013 : 14:18:22

also the book i got this out of was from 2011 and savard played 25 games in the 2010-2011 season so he may not be technically active but the NHL website still shows his stats when you search ACTIVE players although he hasnt been playing.

Try this one on for size, and unless you've heard of this incident before, i don't expect you to get it! Therefore, feel free to have a good laugh and click on the link below for an explanation!!!

In 1974, Buffalo Sabres GM Punch Imlach drafted Taro Tsujimoto, a star centre for the Tokyo Kanatas of the JIHL. Tsujimoto, chosen 183rd overall, did not play in the NHL for a very specific reason. What was it?

That was awesome! Had a good laugh. Who knew management in Buffalo had good humor. Looking a Linday Ruff on the bench doesnt remind me of crack me up jokes.

quote:Originally posted by Alex116

Try this one on for size, and unless you've heard of this incident before, i don't expect you to get it! Therefore, feel free to have a good laugh and click on the link below for an explanation!!!

In 1974, Buffalo Sabres GM Punch Imlach drafted Taro Tsujimoto, a star centre for the Tokyo Kanatas of the JIHL. Tsujimoto, chosen 183rd overall, did not play in the NHL for a very specific reason. What was it?

I wanna say Reggie Leech (Leach?) the year he won the Conn Smythe ...or that might be too far back...

Guest4587 ( )

Posted - 02/09/2013 : 09:32:49

How about Bryan Trottier of the Islanders ?

Guest4218 ( )

Posted - 02/09/2013 : 09:43:35

Eric Staal?

I believe he had a 20+ game point streak the year Carolina won the cup.Then the year they went to the conference finals I believe they had a near perfect record whenever he got a point. Man does he love playoffs.

Brian Trottier had an amazing 27game streak over three consecutive playoff years! He scored in 7 straight games in 1980, 18 straight in 1981 and 2 games in 1982! He totalled 42 points during this streak. His 18 game streak is the longest in one playoff year as well!

For non Canadians, i'll go with the obvious one inTim Thomas. As a Canucks fan, i recall, with heartbreak, that Brian Leetch ripped it outta Kirk Maclean's hands in '94. Aside from those, i'm assuming, but just more of a guess, that Lidstrom, Zetterberg and Forsberg may have all won at least one as well???

As for more than one, i'd say Gretzky, Roy and Lemieux as educated guesses? As all out guesses at the other multiple winners, i'd go with Lafleur and Bossy?

As for number of times? Yeesh, no idea? Let's go with Gretzky 4, Roy 2 and Lemieux 3? If Bossy and/or Lafleur are correct, then 2 each?