Wow! I like this! You are the second author, who has decided to let Elfling!Harry be attacked by humans. Well, this is the second story in which I have read it anyway, but since I have read so many...-shrug-

I really appreciate you letting humans attack him. After all it DOES make sense. (Giving Harrys track record with luck :D)

Hmm...though I would have enjoyed seeing the reacions of the elves when humans tried to SELL an elfling to them. Oh my, can you imagine their faces? :D

Thank you for not making HARRY all accepting of being yanked to and fro. I like that he's sick of being used.

J. R. Quinnet chapter 4 . 5/18/2012

So, the basic storyline is that Elrond just pulled a Dumbledore and kidnapped an innocent person?

It doesn't matter if they're related or not, he had no right to do that to him. I imagine he is now going to be holding him hostage? Yes, you'll use different terminology something along the lines of how Harry is really a guest and that he has been given such an honor! A guest that can't leave is a prisoner, even if they're kind people who hold you against your will are wardens/prison guards/kidnappers, and a cage no matter how golden is still a cage.

It does make more sense for James to be the elf. Black hair was incredibly common among elves. Red hair, on the other hand, was only ever described in one elvish family. Most of them are dead, and those who aren't never left Valinor. I'll admit, this has definitely caught my interest.