Kentucky girl receives Christmas gift she wanted most, a family of her own

By Roger Alford

Published December 11, 2018

LOUISVILLE—Sure, six-year-old Lilly has the typical wish list for Christmas, including Barbie dolls and a dollhouse. But it was something much more meaningful that she longed for most: a family of her own.

For the past three years, Lilly had been in foster care through Sunrise Children's Services, a Kentucky Baptist organization that ministers to abused and neglected kids. Her story is one that has become all too familiar to Kentucky authorities in a culture where drug addiction is rampant.

As a toddler, Lilly faced tough times and was well acquainted with hunger while she was in the care of a drug-addicted birthmother who focused more on getting a fix than on food.

Those days are long passed now, because she got what she was hoping for in a Louisville courtroom Thursday morning. Judge Derwin Webb decreed that she is now the adopted daughter of a Mount Washington couple, Paul and Michelle Chitwood.

Actually, Webb handed Lilly the gavel, which she pounded it on the judge's bench and declared: "This adoption is final."

Robin Cornetet

Lily Chitwood's face lit up when a family court judge declared her the daughter of Paul and Michelle Chitwood on Dec. 6 in Louisville. The Chitwoods had fostered Lily through Sunrise Children's Services for three years.

The finalized adoption was the culmination of a long journey for the Chitwoods, who, as foster parents, fell in love with Lilly as soon as she arrived in their home three years ago.

"When we first got Lilly, we could tell that this three-year-old had been in a very difficult situation," Paul said. "She had headlice and bedbug bites. The first night she was with us, when Michelle tucked her into bed, she asked a question: 'Will we have food tomorrow?' She continued to ask that question for several nights until she realized that she would never go hungry in our home."

Michelle, a public school teacher for the past 20 years, said the food issue weighed heavily on the little girl's mind.

"After about a week of trying to reassure her she would have food the next day, I placed a bowl of Cheerios beside her bed, and that was the fix," Michelle said. "She never worried about food after that."

Living with the Chitwoods was supposed to be temporary, perhaps a few months until her birthmother was able to get off drugs and get her life back on track. That never happened, and little Lilly was put up for adoption. The Chitwoods didn't hesitate.

"As soon as we found out that we could adopt Lilly, I knew we would move mountains to make her adoption happen," Michelle said.

Lilly arrived at the Chitwoods' home in early February 2015. They had been serving as foster parents through Sunrise Children's Services for about a year. They had felt a compulsion to open their home to foster children after learning of the thousands of abused and neglected kids who had become wards of the state.

The Chitwoods already had three other children, Daniel, Anna and Cai. Daniel and Anna are biological children. Cai had been adopted from China, where she, like Lilly, had known her share of hardship.

Cai had actually been placed in a box and abandoned in a marketplace by her birth family because of China's one-child policy. She ended up warehoused in an orphanage with hundreds of other newborns.

"She had been found not long after her birth," Paul explained. "Though she had a very difficult beginning to her life, when she came into our family, those difficulties quickly faded away."

The Chitwood children were thrilled to have a little sister, especially one so hungry for the family's affection.

"She bonded with us very quickly, as we did with her," Paul said. "I knew that we would be giving her up very soon to be reunited with her mother, at least that was the state's initial plan, but also knew that it would break our hearts."

The Chitwoods said they recalled the words of a foster care trainer from Sunrise Children's Services who challenged them by asking: "Who will, instead of refusing to foster parent because they 'love them too much to let them go,' be willing to say to a hurting child carrying all her pain by herself, 'I'll take some of your pain?' Who will let their hearts be broken to carry a child's burden and, as Scripture says, 'so fulfill the law of Christ?'"

That challenge cemented the Chitwoods' decision to open their home and hearts, knowing the risk of being hurt.

"As it turned out, the state had to terminate the parental rights of Lilly's birth parents," Paul said. "When we learned she would not be able to go back to her mother, the decision to adopt her was one of the easiest decisions we've ever made."

The Chitwoods have been involved in Christian ministry throughout their adult lives. Paul served as a pastor for 18 years, followed by seven years as executive director of the Kentucky Baptist Convention, the state's largest religious organization. Since November, he has been president of the Southern Baptist Convention's International Missions Board, the world's largest missionary-sending organization.

Those roles have given them platforms to promote foster care and adoption, urging Baptist families to open their homes to hurting children. They've especially championed the cause of Sunrise Children's Services, which is caring for more than 1,300 children as of this week.

"Paul and Michelle Chitwood have meant the world to Sunrise," said the agency's director, Dale Suttles. "They are huge advocates for orphan care across our state, inspiring Baptists to be part of the solution.

"If every church in Kentucky got involved with foster care, the very landscape of our state would change," Michelle said. "I'm not just talking about giving money or buying a Christmas present; I'm talking boots on the ground, making relationships with kids in residential care or even giving a child a place in your home. We all have tons of excuses not get involved but we live in a state where kids are in crisis. This crisis has an easy fix."

The greatest need for Kentucky's child welfare system is families to open their homes to hurting kids.

"Most of the kids in the state system are orphans of the living," Paul said. "One or both of their parents may be alive but the state has declared that their children's lives are in danger should they remain in their care. The plight of an orphan of the living is, I believe, a worse plight than that of a child whose parents have passed away."

Suttles said the Chitwood family has exhibited the true meaning of sacrificial love.

"Adults frequently tell me they could not imagine becoming a foster parent," Suttles said. "They express worry over caring for children over a period of time, then watching them move on. It's true children sometimes return to their families and foster parents play a critical role in reunification. Fostering can feel like an emotional roller coaster.

"Paul and Michelle knew this, yet agreed to lay down the uncertainties because a little girl needed stability, guidance and love. They simply chose to put a child above their own needs, providing love and stability for the time needed, choosing to risk a broken heart in exchange for living the Gospel." (KT)