Good song choice, fits his vibe perfectly; he's performing it really well, strutting around the stage. Not crazy about the song melodically, but he's really relaxed up there, big smile. Fun to listen to; and a sick last note.

"Different flavor than everyone else, and I love that," says Steven Tyler. "You have grit and you have soul," says Jennifer Lopez, who "liked it a lot."

"Perfect rhythm, you were performing it, we were feeling it," says Randy Jackson. "Job well done."

Agree? Disagree? Tell us in the comments below, or on Twitter using #ndidol.