Process:1. Found Natalie in the 1910 Manhattan NY Census - parents Charles and Jennie. Listed as having been married 10 years2. Found Charles & Jennie living with brother-in-law in 1900 Manhattan Census. Showed they'd been married 6 months and the census was taken on 2 June 19003. Started looking for online marriage records. Found an IGI extraction of NY Marriage records with the above data. I haven't found Jennie listed as a daughter of a Samuel and Sophie Schwab Lim, so that data is suspect.

Found archived 1915 NYT article that ties the marriage of Solomon Tim's daughter to the son of Samuel Schafer. (Kids' first names not mentioned.) Charles Schafer is listed as a son of Samuel in 1880, as is sister Mamie, with whom both Charles & Jennie Schafer are living in 1900. Case closed.

1. Found Natalie in the 1910 Manhattan NY NY CensusParents, Charles and Jennie Schafer, had been married 10 years.2. Found Charles and Jennie living with brother-in-law in 1900 Manhattan NY NY Census.Census was taken 2 Jun 1900.Charles and Jennie listed that they'd been married 6 months.3. Started looking for NY marriage records.Found an IGI marriage extract from NY records as shown above.Another UNVERIFIED record shows the parents of Jennie, therefore the maternal grandparents of Nataliewould be the above listed Lim/Schwab folks.