Originally I had bought this to shade in my eyebrows when I had dark hair which it works fine for that. Not so good for eyeliner. Let me start by saying I have oily eye lids, but as part of my routine I put on an oil mattifier and UD primer in Eden. Well within 2 hours of putting it on I can see it smudging to my bottom eyelid. Not a good look.

This eyeliner did not glide on smoothly and the color is not intense. It was actually quite painful by the time there was enough eyeliner around my lids to actually see and by that time it didn't look smooth at all. It went on like a crayon.

I was very disappointed with this product. Even my first ever $1 eyeliner stayed on longer. It is especially difficult to apply it on your waterline; instead of adding black, it seemed to be rubbing it off. On my upper eyelid, it does not glide smoothly at all.

The only pros are that the smudger is good and I guess it can blend decently. The color is also pretty dark.

Overall, I would NOT recommend this and won't be purchasing this again.