Centres of excellence: inside Rolls-Royce’s UTCs

A network of university research centres helps Rolls-Royce to stay at the frontier of science. Michael Kenward reports

When Rolls-Royce’s next generation jet engine, the UltraFan, enters service, a global network of university researchers will share the credit.

UTC research feeds directly into projects such as the UltraFan next generation jet engine

To pick just one component, the steel shaft on the UltraFan owes much to materials research done in Cambridge University. Indeed, such is the academics’ contribution that Mark Jefferies, the company’s Chief of University Research Liaison, says that it would be hard to pin down areas in the new engine where academics didn’t play a role. “A lot of our tools, our analysis codes, most of CFD [computational fluid dynamics], were initially created and continue to be developed in collaboration between our own engineers and the academics.”

The academics behind the technology work in a series of University Technology Centres (UTC) that Rolls-Royce has assembled to research key technologies. The centres have made important contributions across a number of areas. For instance, they contributed greatly to the materials used in today’s products with researchers at Swansea University, for example, working on the exotic hot-end titanium and nickel alloys throughout the firm’s Trent engines.

The company’s relationships with the materials UTCs have also evolved. In 2009, for example, it brought Swansea and Birmingham together, along with Cambridge’s materials group, to create the Rolls-Royce University Technology Partnership (UTP) in materials research.

The members of the UTP have complementary expertise, with Cambridge focussing on what Jefferies terms the “hot-end alloys”. Birmingham concentrating on “titanium alloys at the front of the engine” and Swansea conducting research into material properties.

Rolls-Royce family of Trent engines has benefitted heavily from the UTCs’ materials expertise (pictured: The Trent XWB)

But materials are just one of many domains for the UTCs. Other centres cover topics including aerodynamics, mechanical aspects, electronics and controls. Cambridge, one of a handful of universities with two UTCs, also houses the University Gas Turbine Partnership, one of the first such centres.

Rolls-Royce created the first UTCs in the early 1990s when Philip Ruffles, then Director of Engineering at the company, found that it was sponsoring many small projects in many universities. He concluded that it made sense to concentrate on bigger contracts with a small number of groups.

The programme began with a handful of centres, but the roster has since grown to 31, with nearly two thirds in the UK and others in Europe, the USA and Asia. One of the newest, set up in 2014, has Virginia Tech and the University of Virginia working on advanced systems diagnostics, flow modelling and power electronics.

One of the keys to the success of the program is the way in which it is structured to encourage long-term relationships, and gives academics and Rolls-Royce’s technical staff time to become comfortable working together. “For these things to be effective there has to be a true partnership,” said Dr Howard Stone, deputy director of the Cambridge materials UTC. “Partnerships based on experience and trust. This puts both parties in a unique position. The technical staff in Rolls-Royce are able to look at the university network and know who can assist with any particular problem, issue or opportunity.”

The UTCs also play an important role in training and recruitment

Size is also important. Each centre is big enough to cover an area in depth. Cambridge’s material UTC alone, has around eight academics along with six post docs and about 20 PhDs students, whilst the materials department in which it sits has a total of around 150 PhD students.

The Department of Engineering at Cambridge also houses the University Gas Turbine Partnership, which, with over 85 staff and graduate students, is even bigger than the materials UTC.

Additionally, the UTCs play an important role in training and recruitment. Since it was formed, the UTP alone has trained about 170 new PhDs, and Jefferies said that around half of all the PhD graduates from the UTCs maintain links with Rolls-Royce. About a quarter of the people who earn PhDs at a UTC join the company. A further third remain on the academic side. Even PhD graduates who go elsewhere may end up working in the company’s supply chain or with a customer. “It is an effective way of training people in the challenges that are relevant to our industry,” he said.

The UTCs help ensure a future pipeline of skilled engineers

The centres also give Rolls-Royce access to expensive scientific tools. Jefferies lists such equipment as X-ray diffraction machines as well as high-performance computing. “We need access only occasionally. So it makes sense for academics to use that equipment. They are using it all the time.”

The UTCs may be important to Rolls-Royce, but they consume a small part of the company’s £1.2 billion a year R&D budget. After all this is frontiers research rather than the very expensive development programmes that take most of the budget. Jefferies won’t say how much the company invests in UTCs, although he doesn’t demur when asked if it is “tens of millions”.

You put 10 people in and you get 100 people’s worth of activity out.

But it isn’t just money that Rolls-Royce puts into the UTCs. There is also considerable input from the company’s engineers. This is an important part of the success of the UTCs, said the firm’s CEO Warren East: “You put 10 people in and you get 100 people’s worth of activity out. The danger where perhaps people fail is that they think they are going to get a hundred people out for putting two people in.”

Jefferies agreed that “the more effort you put into relationships the more you get out. That is obviously a cost to our business,” he added. “I prefer to consider it as an investment.” After all, he points out, if you include support staff and PhD students, “there are probably about 1000 people within our UTC network”. A good number of engineers inside the company are also involved in the UTCs. As Neil Glover, head of materials at Rolls-Royce puts it “We have a team of internal specialists who own and direct the technology programs within their domain.”

One role for the company’s specialists is to ensure that the academics know where engineering is going within Rolls-Royce. In January, senior engineers from within the company and the UTCs met for their annual get together. These events, along with specialist meetings, are a chance to update the UTCs on the major challenges ahead so that the academics can come up with ideas as to how research could help to solve them.

The relationship is structured so that academics are aware of the firm’s long-term ambitions

“We can set the challenges and the goals that we are trying to deal with over the five, 10, 20-year horizon and leave clever people to think about how we might address those challenges,” said Jefferies.

“We expect our senior academic colleagues to challenge us back and say have you thought about, or have you considered these types of technology that are coming over the horizon?”

Planning for the future in this way can mean casting the net wider to bring in new disciplines. “We need computational scientists for example,” said Jefferies. “It is not just engineering. We are entering a much more digital world. There is much more virtual design, much more analysis and understanding of data. You can generate a lot of data but you need to be able to understand and interpret that data.”

So the company has to adapt the UTC network to bring in new skills. “We need to find those who are excellent and who are able to work in this collaborative environment.”

The use of the acronym UTC could cause confusion. The Baker Dearing Trust is overseeing the opening of University Technical Colleges (UTCs) around the country. There are 48 of these open in England.

University Technical Colleges (UTCs) are schools for 14–19 year olds. They deliver an innovative, high-quality education that combines technical, practical and academic learning. In doing so, they offer students more than the traditional GCSE and A Level curriculum.

Second, Rolls-Royce’s use of the term predates the other UTCs by quite some time. The first RR UTC opened in the early 1990s, while the first University Technical Colleges opened two decades later, in 2012.

Oh, and if you go to Twitter you will find that UTC Aerospace Systems snaffled for @UTC address.

I wanted to call the piece “R&D centres take off”, but The Engineer quite rightly decided that it was probably a bit naff.

Graham – you’re quite right. UTCs are the tech colleges. My interview with Phil Ruffles 15+ years ago on this and other matters included talk of ‘URCs’, University Research Centres, which was the description then..

As a regular reader of The Engineer I am continually amazed and heartened by stories like this. It seems like companies like RR just get on with it, they find solutions to getting research done without reference to governments or all the other endless bureaucracies. It is engineering like this that made our country what it is today and given half a chance and some longterm investment will keep our country at the forefront of engineering. There was a time when financial services were there to support our industries and it worked well, making money for everyone, but since they have decoupled themselves from the “sordid” business of making things and innovating, we as a country have suffered mightily

UTC ? That might confuse a lot more than you think. One of the major players in aerospace is UTC Inc (United Technology Corporation) which also owns what used to be part of Goodrich and Lucas Aerospace.

and also UTC (Goodrich) were the joint venturist with R-R owning what was once Lucas gas turbines (following several owners became AEC (Aero Engine controls) rebadged as CDS (controls and Data services) and now is totally under the R-R wing making fuel control systems and electronic engine controls. Now known as Rolls -Royce Control Systems which perversely still supplies units to UTC.