We use cookies to customise content for your subscription and for analytics.If you continue to browse Lexology, we will assume that you are happy to receive all our cookies. For further information please read our Cookie Policy.

TTAB Dismisses Cancellation, Petitioner Failed to Prove Standing

The Board dismissed a petition for cancellation of a registration for the mark BEACH PIZZA for "pizza" [PIZZA disclaimed], because petitioner failed to establish its standing to bring the proceeding. None of the evidence of record concerned the nature of Petitioner NH’s commercial activities and its need to use the BEACH PIZZA mark. NH Beach Pizza, LLC v. Cristy’s Pizza Inc., Cancellation No. 92058955 (November 20, 2015) [not precedential].

Standing is a threshold issue that must be proven in every inter partescase. In order to meet the standing requirement, a plaintiff need only show that it has a real interest, i.e., a personal stake, in the outcome of the proceeding. In short, the bar is not high.

In its petition, NH Beach Pizza alleged that it "will be damaged should it be prevented from using the generic term 'beach pizza' in the advertising of its goods, and has received claims of likelihood of confusion with the mark by Registrant." Respondent’s answer did not contain any admissions regarding Petitioner’s alleged business activities or Petitioner’s interest in the mark BEACH PIZZA.

In its Brief, Petitioner asserted that it is in direct competition with Respondent. Respondent did not acknowledge that Petitioner is a competitor or that it is engaged in its asserted business activities.

Neither party submitted testimony. The Board found that "[t]he record is utterly devoid of any evidence concerning the nature of Petitioner’s commercial activities and its interest in Respondent’s registered BEACH PIZZA mark."

Petitioner could have submitted testimony or competent documentary evidence as to its asserted need to use the term "beach pizza" and nature of its business activities to establish its standing. Petitioner neglected to do so. Thus, on the record before us, Petitioner has failed to establish a "real interest" and "reasonable belief in damage."

Compare jurisdictions: Litigation: Enforcement of Foreign Judgments

"The problem with the information age is that it leaves one drinking from a firehose. The service succeeds in reducing that torrent to manageable gulps of high value analyses addressing topics of immediacy. "