Emmitt asked me this question after the game, and I was wary of going there. I think Ryan is getting closer to that point, but I wouldn't call him elite yet.

But I figured I'd broach the question to the rest of the forum. Do you think Ryan is elite right now? Is the play we've seen from Ryan so far this year that of what you expect or believe an Elite QB plays at?

If he wasn't a quarterback, he would be. Quarterback is such a demanding position and everything rides on you. When your team loses in the playoffs, it's on you even if your team allows 48 points (Packers 2011). I consider Roddy White elite even if he hasn't won a playoff game. I still consider Tony Gonzalez elite based on how well he's played over the past two years. Abraham and Samuel not playing great enough to be elite but they are very good. Until Ryan wins a playoff game, he won't be considered elite. Same thing happened with Aaron Rodgers and Phillip Rivers.

I'd say he is somewhere in the 5-7 range. He's playing great be he has two of the top ten receivers in the league out there, and the best tight end ever. That needs to be taken into consideration. Give any other of the top 5-7 qb's our weapons and they will look great too.

_________________When life gives you lemons, find some salt and tequila then invite me!

I'd say he is somewhere in the 5-7 range. He's playing great be he has two of the top ten receivers in the league out there, and the best tight end ever. That needs to be taken into consideration. Give any other of the top 5-7 qb's our weapons and they will look great too.

I can guarantee you that most of the QB's in the NFL could not do what Ryan did today with the kind of pressure that Ryan had to deal with. It doesn't matter who he's throwing to when he has someone in his face after 2 steps.

I can guarantee you that most of the QB's in the NFL could not do what Ryan did today with the kind of pressure that Ryan had to deal with.

True, but most QBs in the NFL aren't elite QBs. Aaron Rodgers and Ben Roethlisberger get sacked a ton and still play at a very high level.

You just named two of the NFL elite. Matt Ryan is doing what they do. Ryan is #2 in completion %, #1 in Passer Rating, #2 in TD's, and he's in the top 5 or 10 in every other significant statistic. I doubt that Ryan's, 'elite status,' will be in question by year's end. I'm not saying that he's going to break any records, but people will consider him to be one of the best in the game.

I think he's finally in an offense (and with a mindset) where he can show he's elite by the end of the year.

Still need better OL play, and depth at receiver to truly utilize MRs talent, but I think he's showing that the people who thought he 'could' be elite were probably right.

I'd say he's looked top 5 this season. A few more deep passes, a few more targets involved...seems like he can be really really good. I need to see a whole season before I say elite, but he's on that trajectory. And I'm ecstatic to see him throwing some balls up for his receivers to make plays.

Gotta give some props to Birdbrain here as he said not long after we drafted him that in five years he would be a top five QB. I don't know that he is there yet but he is knocking at the door. He needs to beat some of the best teams consistently to be top five. That was a truly gutty performance from Matt yesterday. So much semantics with all of this stuff but I think elite comes with sustained success. In truth, he has had that as the Falcs have more wins than any team since his arrival if memory serves. That's remarkable. Of course, the same BB said during the Vick Wars that team wins were not admissable evidence to greatness. I disagreed then and I disagree now. I guess th elast two playoff games, unfortunately, are about the most lopsided losses of his career. For the most part, he keeps us in every game. What more can you ask? I must say those who said his evolution would not be fulfilled without a different O philosophy were correct.

Who is online

You cannot post new topics in this forumYou cannot reply to topics in this forumYou cannot edit your posts in this forumYou cannot delete your posts in this forumYou cannot post attachments in this forum