Bad Moves - “Bad Moves is a series by philosopher Julian Baggini detailing the various ways in which arguments or points are made badly, but often persuasively.”

Chat Highlights:

Sunday: Formula 1, almost a fiasco at Indianapolis; monthly statistics of SFN with evil numbers; Skepticality forum; Paradise Lost; West Memphis Three; Dan Brown books; days of the week, and their connection to mythology.

Wednesday: Chat opened with astronomy and puzzles. Then, onto program launchers and internet browsers. It seems as if the SFN QUOTE tags don’t work well in some of them. Kil loses a chili cook-off. He claims that he won two in the past, but I’ll be skeptical ’til he can provide some evidence. After testing our psychic abilities to guess how many fingers someone is holding up, we discover other uses for fingers. Back to more astonomy. Then back to those $%&@ing puzzles. Chat ended with a final dicussion on browsers and java clients.

“On the evening of May 5, 1993, in the small town of West Memphis, Arkansas, three eight-year-old boys disappeared. The next afternoon, the naked bodies of Stevie Branch, Christopher Byers, and Michael Moore were found submerged in a nearby stream. The boys had been bound from ankle to wrist with their own shoelaces and severely beaten. Christopher had been castrated.

The crime scene had yielded few clues, and despite Christopher’s castration, there was a remarkable absence of blood. The police were stymied, and citizens’ alarm mounted as weeks passed without an arrest. Finally, a month after the murders, detectives announced three arrests — and a startling theory of the crime: that the children had been killed by members of a satanic cult.

Detectives attributed their break in the case to a former special education student, seventeen-year-old Jessie Misskelley Jr. Although Jessie insisted he knew nothing of the crime, after eight hours of questioning, police announced that he had implicated himself and accused two other teenagers, eighteen-year-old Damien Echols and sixteen-year-old Jason Baldwin. Damien and Jason both denied Jessie’s account, and Jessie himself recanted it within hours, but by then all three had been charged with the murders.

With no physical evidence connecting anyone to the crime, prosecutors contended that the murders bore signs of ‘the occult’ and that the three accused teenagers possessed a ‘state of mind’ that pointed to them as the killers. As proof of the defendants’ mental states, they introduced items taken from their rooms … such as books by Anne Rice and album posters for the rock group Metallica. Jurors found all three teenagers guilty. Jessie and Jason were sentenced to life in prison. Damien was sentenced to death.

While the verdicts were popular in Arkansas, an HBO documentary raised questions about the lack of evidence in the case, and a Web site was formed to support the inmates, now known as ‘The West Memphis Three.’ When the Arkansas Supreme Court affirmed the verdicts, state officials insisted that anyone who questioned the trials simply did not know ‘the facts.’

Now, for the first time, an award-winning investigative reporter examines that official stand. In riveting narrative, Devil’s Knot draws readers into the drama of a modern-day courtroom dominated by references to Satan. In laying out ‘the facts’ of this still-unfolding case, it offers a frightening look into America’s system of justice.”

The mission of the Skeptic Friends Network is to promote skepticism, critical thinking, science and logic as the best methods for evaluating all claims of fact, and we invite active participation by our members to create a skeptical community with a wide variety of viewpoints and expertise.