Centerplan Construction Co., the fired developer of Dunkin’ Donuts Park, must pay $39 million to Arch Insurance, the company that guaranteed the stadium’s completion after Centerplan was dismissed, under a decision issued by a federal court judge Wednesday.

U.S. District Judge Vanessa L. Bryant ordered the payment as part of a lawsuit filed against Centerplan by Arch, which brokered a takeover agreement and hired contracting firm Whiting-Turner to finish the ballpark after Centerplan was ousted. The $71 million, publicly funded stadium opened a year late.

Advertisement

Arch’s suit alleged that Centerplan failed to reimburse the company for tens of millions of dollars in claims it has paid out. According to court records, Bryant awarded Arch about $33 million related to the construction and completion of Dunkin’ Donuts Park. She also awarded $5.2 million to the insurer for other developments Centerplan was involved in, including the Storrs Center Phase 2 project, a redevelopment project near UConn; a technology center project at Asnuntuck Community College; and a utility replacement project at Hammonassett Beach State Park in Madison.

The judge ordered Centerplan to pay another $2.3 million in legal fees and other expenses.

Bryant also found that Centerplan refused to make certain books, records and other financial documents available for review. The defendant failed to post cash collateral totaling more than $38 million that Arch was entitled to as part of its agreement with Centerplan, she wrote in her decision.

Officials with Arch declined to comment Thursday.

Centerplan was fired by the city in 2016 after missing two key deadlines to complete the ballpark. Hartford also ended an agreement with Centerplan that would have allowed them to build housing, retail and office space on properties surrounding the stadium.

The company sued the city for wrongful termination. It is seeking $90 million in damages.

Centerplan’s attorney, Raymond Garcia, downplayed the decision in the Arch case Thursday, saying he had expected the ruling.

Centerplan’s suit against the city has slowly wound its way through the court system. Superior Court Judge Thomas Moukawsher is weighing a motion for injunctive relief, which would permit the city to build apartments, retail and parking on the parcels near the stadium while the lawsuit is pending. Hartford officials have chosen a new developer, Stamford-based RMS Companies, to lead the new project.

Centerplan had placed liens on the properties, and the lawsuit has prevented Hartford from moving ahead with development.

Advertisement

“We are still reviewing how this ruling affects our ongoing litigation,” said Howard Rifkin, the city’s corporation counsel. “However, the court recognized that Arch’s investigation into the project was extensive and that there was no evidence whatsoever that Arch did anything in bad faith. Instead, the court recognized that the city made all of its required payments to Centerplan, but Centerplan improperly diverted some of those payments to other jobs, and characterized Mr. Landino’s statements as ‘conclusory’ without supporting evidence.”

In 2016, Centerplan also sued the Hartford Yard Goats and owner Josh Solomon, claiming that they had interfered in the company’s relationship with the city. Moukawsher dismissed the case in 2017.