Is Mary-Kate Olsen Married? Let's Weigh the Evidence

Did they or didn't they? Rumors are swirling that Mary-Kate Olsen secretly married her much older boyfriend Olivier Sarkozy.

The 28-year-old actress has been sporting a Cartier engagement ring since spring, but earlier this week Olsen was seen in the Hamptons with Sarkozy, 45, wearing gold bands on their left ring fingers while going to town on a sandwich. Judging by the photographs, Olsen had moved her vintage engagement ring over to her right hand. We also learned she really likes sandwiches.

The Olsens are notoriously private — possibly a result of literally growing up on television — so it would be very in character for Olsen and Sarkozy to keep their wedding under wraps. And since Olsen designs wedding dresses, she wouldn't even have to trust the secret of her big day with a team of outside designers.

While we might never know for sure if Olsen and Sarkozy tied the knot, at least we know this: we really, really want sandwiches right now.

On the set of Outlander: Why Jamie and Claire are TV's greatest love story