Comments

Comment by Psyphen

Killed Nefarian today with the guild, and was extremely depressed to find out we didn't receive our achievement. D:Any word on when this will be fixed? Will we be given credit for the kill?

Comment by HolyShield

Maybe it needs at least a fixed amount of guild member in the raid, 35 maybe?

Comment by Schubi

As posted in the molten core guild run comments, it seems as if you needed a fixed amount of 10 players for the classic raid achievements.

Comment by kamaha87

You need to be a minimum of 10 people from the same guild in order to be eligible for this achievement.

Comment by Pyronomikon

Correct, you need at least 10 guild members zoned in to get credit for the old 40 man raids. You will know your in a guild group because a symbol pops up next to your mini map when enough guild members have zoned in.

Comment by noodwow

My guild did this last week with all 10 members in the raid being guilded and we couldn't get it either. Very strange.

Comment by rabbitboi

For some reason I was under the impression you only needed 8 people for this. I can confirm that it's not enough - we just did a guild run with 9 and didn't get the achievement.

Comment by Spondyl

Rule 1: in pre-wotlk 25 and 40 player raids it is considered a Guild run if at least 10 Guild members in the group. However, i believe the rule of 80% also applies.

You can get the Guild achievement when at least 80% of the group members are in the same Guild. And minimum number of guildies is 10. Not confirmed this, but i strongly believe this is the case here.

So, if you have a group of 15 players and 10 of them are guild mates = no guild achievement.

Comment by Mightylorddk

Originally Posted by Blizzard EntertainmentIn general we require 80% of the group to be comprised of guild members. There are exceptions to this case though like 40 man raids and arenas. All the gritty details below are below.