the person writing the review was likely doing potty training with like a 3 year old. it wouldn't be my potty of choice for a child over the age of two if you were just buying one at that age (though my 4.5 year old still uses ours in emergencies in the car).

but they're a great size for babies and toddlers, and like i said, we still use ours in the car when we can't find a clean potty nearby for both my huge 2.5 yo and my average sized 4.5 yo. so i think you'll be fine with it.

i do actually prefer the Once Upon a Potty potties, though. we have two BBLP's and a OUaP and the OUaP has always worked better for us - seems to have a bit more support, a higher splash guard bit up front for the boys, and less likely to tip over. i'm planning on buying another one of those for this next baby. and larger toddlers/pre-schoolers fit more comfortably IME, though it's still a great size for smaller ones too.