The Watchmen sub sold well because it was a THEMED sub, and therefore people had a pretty good idea what characters they were getting when they committed to it. The same can't be said for the Club IE sub when two-thirds of the figures are unknown to us going into it. That's why people are so reluctant to sign up, and Mattel can't seem to understand that.

So I agree that doing smaller themed subs would be the better way to go. I have no doubt a LOSH sub would reach its sign-up goal much faster than the Club IE one did. Or several other specifically-themed subs, like a Flash allies and rogues sub (which I'd sign up for in an instant!)

I would certainly like to see more of the Legion in the IE line regardless of how it comes about. My top wants would be:

Sun BoyElement LadDawnstar (and come on, Mattel, how about Zauriel -- get some more use out of Hawkman's wings!)Mon-ElFerro LadInvisible Kid (NOT an imaginary one this time, thank you!)Polar BoyShadow LassPhantom GirlBlok (theoretically, he could use some of the Darkseid molds)

I really think we have a shot at a 2nd box set or sub if we are vocal and adamant with Matty on this. There's no logical reason it can't be done if we let them know there is a demand & we're serious about this. MOTU fans got a Castle Greyskull made from scratch. That was risky, but Mattel took the shot cause they had confidence in MOTU fans. With the LOSH they already have evidence of the viability of a LOSH 12 pack as seen in the 2x sell through. This and the fact that no new tooling really will be necessary. Mattel has the teen buck & can use it to make all the characters at no additional cost. Last, if they were able to go back & do a new run if DCUC wave 5 for DCUC fans (which was a store) how much more so with an in demand item like a LOSH? We just need to be persistent in letting them know that we are here & we're not going anywhere til we get our LOSH sub or multipack. So if your with me on this please go over to the Matty forum and sign the petition I started & vote for how you want your LOSH figures.

The problem as I see it is this "If you don't own the first box set would you be intrested in a Legion sub or a second box set?" It going to be a hard sell to people who don't own the first box set, since it had quite a few of the most popular members in it.

Dawnstar would be my absolute #1 pick, followed by some combination of Shadow Lass, Blok, and Phantom Girl. But the truth is that I'd get any and every member of the team and any villains that they elected to make.