CAN VOLUNTARY PRICE DISCLOSURES FIX THE PAYDAY LENDING MARKET?

Transcription

1 CAN VOLUNTARY PRICE DISCLOSURES FIX THE PAYDAY LENDING MARKET? Jim Hawkins I. Introduction Eric J. Chang s provocative article, A Solution for Restoring Price-Competition to Short-Term Credit Loans, offers a simple, market-based solution to the fundamental problem in payday lending markets high prices. 1 Chang s core contribution in the article is to propose creating a federally operated online exchange (Exchange) for payday lenders to post their rates and for borrowers to apply and receive payday loans. 2 There is a lot to commend in his approach: it is low-cost, does not infringe on borrowers or lenders liberties, probably will not constrict small-dollar credit markets, and, perhaps most importantly, tackles the perennial problem of price competition in payday lending markets. Texas provides evidence that Chang s approach could be effective. Texas law requires lenders to post pricing information on their websites. 3 Unlike other states, where payday loan prices aggregate near the highest legally permissible rate, 4 Texas appears to Associate Professor of Law, University of Houston Law Center. I m thankful to David Kwok, Megan Neel, and Teddy Rave for comments on this Response. 1 Eric J. Chang, A Solution for Restoring Price-Competition to Short-Term Credit Loans, HARV. BUS. L. REV. ONLINE, see Jim Hawkins, Credit on Wheels: The Law and Business of Auto-Title Lending, 69 WASH. & LEE L. REV. 535, 592 (2012) (arguing that price is a powerful justification for banning title lending ). 2 Chang, supra note 1, at Tex. Fin. Code (a)(1) (3) (2015). 4 SHEILA BAIR, UNIV. OF MASS. AT AMHERST, ISENBERG SCH. OF MGMT., LOW-COST PAYDAY LOANS: OPPORTUNITIES AND OBSTACLES 29 (2005), https://folio.iupui.edu/bitstream/handle/10244/101/fes3622h334.pdf ( The vendors we studied charged the maximum allowed in states where the product is permitted. ). 64

2 CAN VOLUNTARY PRICE DISCLOSURES FIX PAYDAY LENDING? VOLUME 6 have significant price differentiation. 5 If the federal government could establish a successful Exchange, Texas offers hope that disclosures could generate price competition. This Response, however, offers some evidence from recent empirical research to suggest that an Exchange is unlikely to succeed in facilitating price competition. It also argues that lenders are unlikely to voluntarily participate in the Exchange and, even if they did, many borrowers are unlikely to use the Exchange. II. It is Unlikely Payday Lenders Will Voluntarily Participate in a Website Focused on Price Disclosure. Chang suggests that the law should not coerce lenders into participating in the Exchange. 6 Indeed, a primary selling point of his suggestion to lenders and taxpayers is that the Exchange imposes neither new laws nor legal regulations on any party... and taxpayers will be minimally burdened. 7 Instead of being forced into disclosing prices on the Exchange, Chang predicts that payday lenders will voluntarily register with the Exchange in order to reach these potential customers. 8 This prediction seems implausible for several reasons. First, payday lenders historically have not voluntarily produced price information for borrowers in other contexts. In the case of payday and title lending storefronts in Houston, Texas, for example, a recent study demonstrated that outdoor advertising contained information about a variety of things: the speed of getting the loan, the loan amounts, and the simplicity of the application process. 9 Even 15.24% of storefronts claimed to have low loan prices. 10 However, not a single storefront portrayed price information in its advertisements that complied with federal law After several hours looking for prices in Houston one day, I found rates ranging from a 271% annual percentage rate (APR) to a 1,151% APR. Jim Hawkins, Are Bigger Companies Better for Low-Income Borrowers?: Evidence from Payday and Title Loan Advertisements, 11 J.L. ECON. & POL'Y 303, 315 (2015). 6 Chang, supra note 1, at Id. 8 Chang, supra note 1, at In the fall of 2014, I gathered information about the advertising outside 189 payday and title lending storefronts in Houston, Texas. Jim Hawkins, Using Advertisements to Diagnose Behavioral Market Failure in the Payday Lending Market, 51 WAKE FOREST L. REV. (forthcoming 2016) (manuscript at 20) (on file with author). Six research assistants took pictures of all the signs on or around the storefronts between September 14 and October 30, 2014, and we categorized the content of the advertisements. Id. at Id. at See id. at 34 ( 6.71% (n=11) of the storefronts we visited stated the price of the loan, and this

3 HARVARD BUSINESS LAW REVIEW ONLINE 2016 Payday lenders have also failed to comply with laws requiring posting price information on the Internet. 12 Texas law mandates that lenders post certain information on their website, including fees, contact information for the state agency that regulates payday loans, and a notice that the loans are intended to be short-term. 13 Out of a sampling of 30 payday lending websites as of the fall of 2014, only 70% contained information about the regulator, 73.3% provided notice that the loans were short-term, and 80% had the required price information. 14 The regulations implementing the law also require that the pricing information be displayed immediately upon the consumer s arrival at the credit access business s website that includes information about a payday or auto title loan. 15 Shockingly, only 30% of the payday lending websites followed this rule. 16 Thus, even when compelled by law to disclose price information, many payday lenders failed to do so, making the prospects of voluntary disclosure bleak. Second, it seems unlikely payday lenders will voluntarily post pricing information because, as Chang recognizes, 17 lenders do not think the Truth in Lending Act s (TILA) APR disclosures fairly communicate price information for payday loans. 18 Borrowers do not borrow money using payday loans for an entire year, even considering rollovers, so lenders understandably dislike using APRs as the baseline to measure the price of these loans. 19 Because a federal website would require disclosures that comply with TILA, payday lenders would have to consciously choose to use what they consider to be a misleading measurement of price. 20 Given their failure to embrace this approach in other areas of business acquisition, it is hard to see them coming to the Exchange to do so. That said, this problem seems easy enough to solve. The Consumer Financial Pronumber includes 2 storefronts of a company that advertised 0% interest loans on select products, although this advertisement most likely is just a teaser rate. The remaining 9 storefronts were all with the same company, and the advertisement of the price stated an inaccurate price in large font with the correct price in extremely small font. ). Under the Truth in Lending Act, if a lender states the price of a loan in an advertisement, the lender must state the price in terms of an annual percentage rate. 15 U.S.C. 1664(d) (2012) (requiring that, in any advertisement stating the dollar amount of any finance charge, the rate of the charge be expressed as an annual percentage rate ). 12 Hawkins, supra note 5, at Tex. Fin. Code (a)(1) (3) (2015). 14 Hawkins, supra note 5, at Tex. Admin. Code (f) (2016). 16 Hawkins, supra note 5, at Chang, supra note 1, at 5 n Ronald J. Mann & Jim Hawkins, Just Until Payday, 54 UCLA L. Rev. 855, (2007). 19 Id. 20 Because consumers think of these loans in terms of fees and not interest rates, laws should require lenders to advertise using dollar amounts, not APRs. Id. 66

4 CAN VOLUNTARY PRICE DISCLOSURES FIX PAYDAY LENDING? VOLUME 6 tection Bureau (CFPB) could implement rules that make posting prices on the Exchange obligatory in order to obtain the price comparison benefits that Chang seeks. While some lenders likely would violate the law as they do in Texas, more would comply with a mandated disclosure regime than a voluntary one, especially if the consequences of noncompliance were substantial. Implementing the Exchange by force does undermine some of the benefits of Chang s proposal, but given lenders aversion to coughing up price information voluntarily, it seems essential. III. Many Borrowers Will Not Use a Web-Based Exchange. In order to have any substantial positive effect, the Exchange would have to attract a significant portion of the overall payday lending market. A web-based platform, however, would be useless for all the consumers who access payday loans at storefronts. Only around one-third of payday loans are conducted purely online; the rest involve physical trips to storefronts. 21 Thus, at best, Chang s proposal would enhance price competition for only this third of the market. Chang anticipates this objection and argues that lenders will have to lower their rates to attract an informed minority of borrowers, so all payday lending customers will benefit. 22 The problem, however, is that lenders could adapt by offering one price online and another price in the storefront. If a substantial number of borrowers are still obtaining loans in person, lenders will still have to incur all the costs of maintaining storefronts, despite the existence of the Exchange. These continued costs will limit the downward pressure on prices that Chang anticipates. 23 Slightly tweaking Chang s proposal might solve this problem. The CFPB could require lenders to post their prices prominently on the outside of their storefronts, much like how gas stations post pricing information in large numbers visible from the road. 24 This complementary solution could reinforce the Exchange s price competition goals, although lenders operating costs would remain relatively high. 21 Pew Charitable Trusts, Fraud and Abuse Online: Harmful Practices in Internet Payday Lending 3 (2014), Report/Fraud_and_Abuse_Online_Harmful_Practices_in_Internet_Payday_Lending.pdf. 22 Chang, supra note 1, at See Chang, supra note 1, at 16 ( As borrowers begin to use the Exchange as the one-stop destination for payday loans, lenders will face less incentive to continue spending money on advertisements or expensive leases at busy locations. ). 24 Mann & Hawkins, supra note 18.

5 HARVARD BUSINESS LAW REVIEW ONLINE 2016 IV. Conclusion The idea of using the payday lending market to fix the payday lending market is extremely attractive. The problem, however, is that lenders have demonstrated a reluctance to disclose accurate price information even when compelled by law. While skepticism of the efficacy of the CFPB s proposed regulations in this market should be maintained, 25 more is needed than a purely voluntary regime. If the CFPB mandated disclosures on an Exchange like the one Chang envisions and required lenders to display the same pricing information prominently on storefront signs, Chang s market-based solution could potentially improve price competition in the payday lending market. As it stands, however, it seems clear that fixing payday lending markets will take more than relying on voluntary price disclosures. 25 See generally, Jim Hawkins, Regulating on the Fringe: Reexamining the Link Between Fringe Banking and Financial Distress, 86 IND. L.J. 1361, 1368 (2011). 68

Commonly Known as Payday Lending These examination procedures apply to the short-term, small-dollar credit market, commonly known as payday lending. The procedures are comprised of modules covering a payday

A LOW-COST ALTERNATIVE TO PAYDAY & AUTO TITLE LOANS FOR DALLAS COUNTY Raquel Valdez, COO Community Loan Center of Dallas, a program of Business & Community Lenders (BCL) of Texas About Small Dollar Loans

PAYDAY LENDING MARKET INVESTIGATION Summary of a response hearing with money.co.uk held on Wednesday 23 July 2014 Background to money.co.uk 1. money.co.uk was established in 2008. It offers a comparison

Payday, Mayday! Payday and Title Lender Compliance to Signage and Brochure Regulations Series on Predatory Lending: Report 1 March 2002 By Ray Prushnok Consumer Fellow New Mexico Public Interest Research

Excerpts from LWV-TX Facts & Issues Payday & Auto Title Loans in Texas This document provides information in the document provided by LWVTX Facts & Issues for the Study of this issue with the intent of

May 20, 2014 Family Budget Busters: Payday and Auto Title Loans Are Getting More Expensive for Texans A study of 2012-2013 trends in payday and auto title lending in Texas Don Baylor baylor@cppp.org Texans

TRUSTED INTELLIGENCE 1 POINT OF VIEW CFPB Know Before You Owe 2 Background The Consumer Financial Protection Bureau (CFPB) established new disclosure rules that become effective on mortgage applications

The Florida Senate BILL ANALYSIS AND FISCAL IMPACT STATEMENT (This document is based on the provisions contained in the legislation as of the latest date listed below.) BILL: CS/SB 626 Prepared By: The

Report 2 Does State Regulation of Small-Dollar Lending Displace Demand to Internet Lenders? Does State Regulation of Small-Dollar Lending Displace Demand to Internet Lenders? By: Small-Dollar Markets Research

WORKING TO END POVERTY Predatory Lending 101: How You Can Take Action Mission: To move 250,000 people permanently out of poverty by 2020 Vision: Unite all sectors of the community around identifying and

All in Good Faith How Know Before You Owe Changes Everything. Jorge Sauri jorges@mortgagedashboard.com mortgagedashboard August 1, 2015, marks the end of a long road for federal regulations that promise

8/12/14 ORDINANCE NO. AN ORDINANCE OF THE CITY OF AMARILLO, TEXAS: AMENDING THE AMARILLO MUNICIPAL CODE OF ORDINANCES TO ADDCHAPTER 14-10, CREDIT ACCESS BUSINESS, PROVIDING FOR DEFINITIONS, REGISTRATION

The extension of high-cost credit to servicemembers and their families December 2014 1. Introduction In 2006, Congress enacted the Military Lending Act (10 U.S.C. 987) as part of the John Warner National

CUNA s COMPLIANCE HIGHLIGHTS TILA/RESPA INTEGRATED MORTGAGE DISCLOSURES For more than 30 years, Federal law has required lenders to provide two different disclosure forms to consumers applying for a mortgage.

BEST PRACTICES REPORT FORM OLA takes compliance seriously and we expect all of our Members to as well. In keeping with this, we have created the OLA Best Practices, which all OLA members are required by

Personal Loans 101: Understanding APR Everyone needs access to affordable credit, whether it is to make a small purchase, pay for an unexpected emergency, repair their car or obtain a mortgage on their

Payday and Auto Title Lending LBJ SCHOOL OF PUBLIC AFFAIRS Center for Politics & Governance Executive Summary Payday and auto title lending is a fast growing industry in Texas. 1 In 2004, there were approximately

Comments submitted to the National Credit Union Administration By the RE: Payday-Alternative Loans Advance notice of proposed rulemaking (ANPR) The (the Federation) submits these comments in response to

Chapter 24 Title Lending Registration Act Part 1 General Provisions 7-24-101 Title. This chapter is known as the "Title Lending Registration Act." 7-24-102 Definitions. As used in this chapter: (1) "Nationwide

The Florida Senate BILL ANALYSIS AND FISCAL IMPACT STATEMENT (This document is based on the provisions contained in the legislation as of the latest date listed below.) Prepared By: The Professional Staff

Payday Lending and the Demand for Alternative Financial Services by Andrew Weaver and Roman V. Galperin * 1 Community Development Issue Brief 4, 2014 ** October 2014 Summary In this Issue Brief we discuss

2013-2014 DEVELOPMENTS IN BANKING LAW 453 IV. First Actions of the Consumer Financial Protection Bureau A. Introduction The Consumer Financial Protection Bureau ( CFPB ) was formed in 2011, pursuant to

To support your preparation efforts when implementing the TILA-RESPA Integrated Disclosure (TRID) rule effective for applications dated on or after October 3, 2015, we have created this Helpful Tips for

HOME OWNERSHIP EQUITY PROTECTION ACT OF 1994 Raymond Natter 1 Recent Congressional attention to the problems of predatory mortgage lending has led for calls for the Federal Reserve Board to use its authority

ORDINANCE NO. AN ORDINANCE AMENDING TITLE 5 (BUSINESS LICENSE AND PERMIT REGULATIONS) OF THE EL PASO CITY CODE BY ADDING CHAPTER 5.17(CREDIT ACCESS BUSINESSES) IN ORDER TO SET FORTH REGISTRATION REQUIRMENTS

January 2011 Final Program Integrity Regulations Title IV Federal Student Aid Program Integrity Final Regulations On October 29, 2010, the U.S. Department of Education published final regulations for improving

Case 1:15-cv-00299 Document 1 Filed 04/14/15 Page 1 of 24 IN THE UNITED STATES DISTRICT COURT DISTRICT OF NEW MEXICO Consumer Financial Protection Bureau and Navajo Nation, Plaintiffs, Civil Action No.

An overview from Report 3 in the Payday Lending in America series Payday Lending in America: Policy Solutions Oct 2013 Overview About 20 years ago, a new retail financial product, the payday loan, began

January 2016 Military Lending Act It s time to get prepared The final rule has expanded the scope of covered products how does this impact your business? Overview A joint point of view by PwC s Consumer

CFPB and Lenders A presentation on the Consumer Financial Protection Bureau and its impact on the lending industry What is the Consumer Financial Protection Bureau (CFPB)? Independent agency of the United

SMALL BUSINESS ADVISORY REVIEW PANEL FOR POTENTIAL RULEMAKINGS FOR PAYDAY, VEHICLE TITLE, AND SIMILAR LOANS DISCUSSION ISSUES FOR SMALL ENTITY REPRESENTATIVES To help frame the small entity representatives

APPENDIX G Bryant & Stratton College Preferred Lender Arrangement Policy Any Preferred Lender Arrangement to which Bryant & Stratton College enters will comply with the terms of this policy. Definition.

Financial Aid Code of Conduct Original Implementation: April 21, 2009 Last Revision: April 14, 2015 This code of conduct is promulgated under the Higher Education Act 487(a)(25), as reauthorized and amended

IN THE UNITED STATES DISTRICT COURT FOR THE EASTERN DISTRICT OF PENNSYLVANIA UNITED STATES OF AMERICA v. DAVID C. PAUL DIANE F. FLANNERY : : : : CRIMINAL NO. DATE FILED: VIOLATIONS: 18 U.S.C. 1341 (mail

6. Business Plans, Policies and Procedures With a product design and pricing structure in place you can begin to develop a business plan, policies and procedures for your new loan product. Sound lending

Board of Governors of the Federal Reserve System Federal Deposit Insurance Corporation Unfair or Deceptive Acts or Practices by State-Chartered Banks March 11, 2004 Purpose The Board of Governors of the

DELIVERING NEW CONSUMER PROTECTIONS On 24 May 2012, the Consumer Finance Association, the Consumer Credit Trade Association, the BCCA and the Finance & Leasing Association agreed to a series of new consumer

Independence Title Are you buying or selling a home after October 3, 2015? Nationwide the mortgage lending industry (creditors) will face a big change beginning October 3rd of this year. Here are the 3

PAYDAY LENDING MARKET INVESTIGATION ORDER 2015 EXPLANATORY NOTE [This note is not a part of the Order] Introduction 1. The Competition and Markets Authority (CMA) published its findings in a report under

A brief from July 2015 Understanding the CFPB Proposal for Payday and Other Small Loans Overview Research shows that in the payday and vehicle title loan markets, lenders and borrowers interests are not

Testimony of David Sohn Senior Policy Counsel Center for Democracy and Technology Before The House Committee on Small Business June 12, 2008 Hearing on Electronic Payments Tax Reporting: Another Tax Burden

Note: This notice has been submitted to the Office of the Federal Register (OFR) for publication and is currently scheduled for placement on public display at the OFR on Friday, July 17, 2015 and publication

Statement for the Record On behalf of the American Bankers Association before the Committee on Small Business of the United States House of Representatives Statement for the Record On behalf of the American

Advertising Credit And Lease Arrangements: How To Comply With The Truth In Lending Act The federal Truth in Lending Act ("TILA") governs most consumer credit transactions. Its companion law the Consumer

TRID Frequently Asked Questions Q: What is TRID? A: TRID is an acronym for the TILA-RESPA Integrated Disclosure rule. It is a rule mandated by the Consumer Financial Protection Bureau as part of the Dodd-Frank

STATE RESTRICTIONS ON SMALL-DOLLAR LOANS AND FINANCIAL SERVICES, 2005 2009: SUMMARY, DOCUMENTATION, AND APPENDIX Prepared for the US Department of the Treasury by the Urban Institute, 2010 Authors of this