@Tim_EagonIf a monster has a combination of immunities & resistances, which column should you use to determine effective hit points? Pick whichever column is likely to cause the most trouble for the characters.

@pukunui81Could really use your input re: lycanthrope damage immunity http://bit.ly/1pGGCTp Immunity to nonmagical weapons intentionally leaves the door open for a monster to take damage from falling, being crushed, etc.

@pukunui81OK. Still seems a bit weird – monster can hit its head on a rock and get hurt but doesn’t if the rock is used as a weapon. That would have to be a mighty bump on the head to deal damage to a character, much less a lycanthrope.

@pukunui81It still doesn’t make a lot of sense to me that one can’t take bludgeoning damage from a club but can take it from a fall. A lycanthrope's immunity is a supernatural resilience against the attacks of regular mortals. It's not about the damage types.

@pukunui81But why would they be resistant to mortals’ attacks but not forces of nature? It feels like it should be all or nothing. The material is modeling folklore. Curses and blessings in legend are often specific, not universal laws.

@pukunui81Fair enough, I suppose. Still, I wonder if it would’ve made more sense to give them regeneration rather than immunity. Regeneration has a different effect in world: many farmers could take out a werewolf with pitchforks. Not what we wanted.

@pukunui81OK. Just trying to get my head around it after a PC in my game became a wererat. I’ll have to just go with “It’s magic”. Yeah, I would emphasize that it's supernatural. It doesn't obey the physical laws of our world.