Brothers Judd Top 100 of the 20th Century: Novels (80)

These people had a kind of courage that may be the
finest gift of man: the courage of those who
simply keep on, and on, doing the next thing ...
-Alan Le May (on the Texicans)

It's muy chic in these days of political correctness to bemoan our ancestors'
horrible misguided behavior in regards to the American Indians. In
Leftist hindsight, the Indians have been converted into pastoral New Age
environmentalists, facing off against a militaristic, technological behemoth.
The novel The Searchers, basis for the great John Ford/John Wayne movie
(The
Searchers--1956), offers a necessary antidote to such fuzzy headed
platitudinous twaddle.

The story begins in 1868 Texas; neglected by the military during the
Civil War and now subject to the naive Quaker administration of Indian
affairs, white settlements are being rolled back by persistent murderous
Comanche raids. Living at the very edge of civilization are Henry
and Martha Edwards and their children, Lucy, Debbie, Ben and Hunter.
The couple are assisted by the young man , Martin Pauley, who they virtually
adopted when Comanches slaughtered his family, and by Henry's brother Amos,
a quiet, taciturn man who seems to be irresistibly drawn back to the ranch
time and again. But then one day Marty and Amos are lured away from
the ranch when a Comanche party steals a herd of cattle. They pursue them
for quite a distance before realizing that they have been tricked.
By the time they arrive back at the Edwards ranch, it is in ruins, the
parents and the boys are dead and scalped and the girls are missing.
As every movie viewer knows, what ensues is a years long quest by Martin
and Amos (Ethan in the movie) as they search for the girls.

Martin is driven by a memory of how he ignored Debbie on her last day
of life, Amos appears to be driven by darker demons. Eventually,
Martin has an epiphany:

Amos, Mart realized, no longer believed they would
recover Lucy alive--and wasn't thinking of
Debbie at all. Seeing Amos' face as it was
tonight, Mart remembered it as it was that worst time of
the world, when Martha lay in the box they had made
for her. Her face looked young and serene,
and her crossed hands were at rest. They were
worn hands, betraying Martha's age as her face did
not, with little random scars on them. Martha
was always hurting her hands. Mart thought, "She
wore them out, she hurt them, working for us."

As he thought that, the key to Amos' life suddenly
became plain. All his uncertainties, his deadlocks
with himself, his labors without pay, his perpetual
gravitation back to his brother's ranch--they all
fell into line. As he saw what had shaped
and twisted Amos' life, Mart felt shaken up; he had lived
with Amos most of his life without ever suspecting
the truth. But neither had Henry suspected
it--and Martha least of all.

Amos was--had always been--in love with his brother's
wife.

At first they are accompanied by Lucy's fiancé, but when he thinks
that he has spied Lucy dancing around a fire in the Comanche camp, Amos
brutally explains that what he's actually seen is a young buck wearing
her scalp. The young man, driven mad, attacks the camp and is killed.
From there on, Amos and Martin have only each other and Martin increasingly
realizes that they do not share the same obsessions:

Mart had noticed that Amos always spoke of catching
up to "them"--never of finding "her." And
the cold, banked fires behind Amos' eyes were manifestly
the lights of hatred, not of concern for a
lost girl. He wondered uneasily if there might
not be a peculiar danger in this. He believed now that
Amos, in certain moods, would ride past the child
and let her be lost to them if he saw a chance to
kill Comanches.

In the coming years they survive Indian attacks, blizzards, comic misadventures,
robbery attempts and the like as their search narrows in on Scar, a chief
of the Wolf Clan. Along the way, Amos develops a grudging respect
for Martin (even making him his heir) and the two become the stuff of legend,
known to the Indians as "Bull Shoulders" (Amos) and "The Other" (Marty).

This is historical fiction in the grand manor, combining an exciting
story and extensive historical background to create the kind of mythos
that is central to a nation's understanding of itself. What emerges
is a more balanced sense of how precarious a situation these early white
homesteaders faced as they pushed into Indian territory and, while not
justifying racial hatred, it makes the animus between the races more understandable.
This is a great American story, with an obvious debt to Moby Dick (Amos/Ahab,
Marty/Ishmael, Scar/Moby); the movie will always preserve our memory of
the tale, but it deserves to be read too.