As we head into the final hours of Category Voting, it’s time to turn the spotlight on a contender that’s already starting to generate buzz: Favorite Sci-Fi/Fantasy Star.

From epic dragon filled dramas like Game of Thrones, to supernatural series, like The Vampire Diaries, Grimm, The Walking Dead, True Blood, and well Supernatural, there are a slew of shows starring potential Sci-Fi/Fantasy nominees. In other words, if the category makes the cut, expect the showdown to be intense.

Category Voting ends Thursday night, so if you want to see Favorite Sci-Fi/Fantasy Star (or, for that matter, any one of the other potential categories) make it on to the final ballot, we suggest you go here now.

In the meantime, we want to know, who you think is the BEST sci-fi/fantasy star of all time? Is it Buffy the Vampire Slayer’s Sarah Michelle Gellar or TheX-Files David Duchovny? Or, maybe, it’s someone more recent like Arrow’s Stephen Amell or Once Upon a Time’s Ginnifer Goodwin?The debate starts now.

Jensen Ackles as Dean Winchester (Supernatural), Alec (Dark Angel, and Jason Teague (Smallville). He has always had the ability to make me feel what his character is feeling, with just one look. He can also be the comic relief in the show. It takes a lot for an actor to be able to be super serious and bad ass in one scene and then *snap* have that perfect comedic timing. I will forever feel like he is one of the most underrated actors out there, along with Stephen Amell, Jared Padalecki, Misha Collins, and Josh Dallas.

Misha Collins as Castiel from Supernatural..He’s one of my favourite actor. Smart,amazing, talent and sympathetic person. He’s always willing to help people through activities Charity. To me he is the best sci-fi/fantasy star of all time. Also I like Jensen Ackles and Jared Padalecky. I love J2M !!!!!

Definitely Jay Ryan of Beauty and the Beast. He is such a talented and amazing actor apart from being so darn attractive. His performance in Season1 and so far in Season 2 shows that he can ‘transform’ himself into whatever is written in the script, bringing into life the character being played. The viewer cannot help but ‘feel’ what he seeks to perform be it a beast or human.

Kristin Kreuk!! Look at all the works Sci-fi/Fantasy stuff she’s done: Snow White: The Fairest of them All, Earthsea, Smallville, Space Milkshake (awesome movie!)Beauty and the Beast! She is without at doubt one of the most talented actress to EVER live! I have not seen anyone more brilliant! She is so genuine in her acting! And she’s bloody gorgeous!

I would definitely vote for Jensen Ackles as Dean Winchester from Supernatural here. His amazing abilities as an actor never cease to amaze me. Anyone who has watched an episode like “On the Head of a Pin” would be able to agree. Jensen can say so much with just a look, his comedic timing is flawless, and he has created an extremely beloved character

Where’s the love for Doctor Who, you got a heck of a choice of doctor’s, all the way back in ’63 with William Hartnell up to the present with Matt Smith (Peter Capaldi hasn’t made any yet)? My vote is for DAVID TENNANT

I’ve watched X-Files, Buffy, StarTrek, Roswell, Sliders, Charmed and more during the 90ies.
But yes, it’s Jensen Ackles as Dean Winchester who left the biggest impression. The show seems simply not exposed enough for people to know how great actor and character are.

Of course is Jensen Ackles. He is such an amazing actor! Whether is funny, sad, accion, or whatever, his emotions seem so real. He becomes the character of Dean like he is real. And everyone can see that he gives everything he has in his performance.

Jensen, Jared, and Misha are a package deal. They bring such life to Supernatural. It’s the first and only show to make me cry, and I’m sure it’s all because of their amazing acting. They’re talented and wonderful people. I love them to infinity and beyond.

Jensen ackles for sure!!! And no it’s not only because he is hot. Jensen is the kind of actor that speaks a Thousand words with his eyes. He just gets better and better every episode, every season. This awards HAS to be HIS. Supernatural Family let’s repay Jensen for all his hard work!! If i could i would give this Awards for Jared and Misha too. They are all great, but Jensen Always stand out!!

Jensen Ackles is the best actor ever!!! and don’t you dare saying that it’s just because of his looks that everyone loves him! people who think that need to watch him acting on SPN. he’s an awesome actor <3

For my money, it’s Jared Padalecki. He has only been acting a little more than a decade, but boy, he has impressed in every role! His co-star Jensen Ackles is great, but Jared brings his heart and soul to every episode, every scene, every emotion. It is his performances that mesmerize me and make me smile, laugh and cry.

i love jared padalecki but in all honesty, he’s not the best actor. his character (sam) does have a lot of different sides to him but i feel like jareds portrayal of them is so generic, like they all sort of act the same. i love misha collins, hes a great actor & his charisma on set is great but his character doesn’t really have enough emotion for him to be voted #1. i think jensen ackles is a great actor (not because hes attractive, i mean he is but thats not what im basing it on) and his character on supernatural has two very different sides to him and i find that he portrays them both amazingly. however for all time sci-fi/fantasy, i’d say leonard nimoy, nathan fillion, david tennant.

Jensen Ackles gets my vote for best actor in Sci-Fi/fantasy of all time. I’m nearly 70 years old, and think of both Jenson and Jared as if they were my own sons. Jensen uses comedic actions to relieve the tension, such as his reaction to a kitten during “Yellow Fever”. My two favorite episodes so far are A Very Supernatural Christmas and Swan Song. The scene at the end of both with gift exchanges always touch my heart. Watching the game after an exchange of gifts from a convenience store … Good writing, but great understated acting is what makes it so very believable! But they are pivotal to understanding the deep relationship between the brothers. “Dark side of the Moon” shows how deeply Dean is hurt by Sam’s quite expectable stretches toward independence.

I am so excited for the debut of season 9 on Oct 8! It is guaranteed to be another great season.

I hope Jensen receives the recognition he deserves,. But one way or another, he will ALWAYS BE my ALL-TIME Favorite Sci-Fi/ Fantasy actor.

Jensen Ackles is without question my favorite all time Sci-Fi /Fantasy actor of all time. He blends comedic actions in at unexpected places, like his reaction to a kitten in the episode “Yellow Fever”. It helps to move the story along, as many other of his nonverbal actions during that episode. His acting is sincere at times of sorrow, and he brings it right on during the intense action scenes as well. The French Mistake is another episode in which the brothers play themselves in an alternative universe(ours) where they are actors. The scenes where they are “ACTING!” Are hilarious. They don’t slip into character, but are convincing as non actors!

Dean is often the tension release in really tense scenes. My two favorite episodes are a Supernatural Christmas, and Swan Song. The deep relation ship between the two brothers is shown ell by both actors, but the exchange of presents from the convenience store never fails to touch my heart. The episode ends with them watching a game together. It doesn’t necessarily sound like much, but it is so true to life… I hope Jensen is selected, but whether he is or not, he will ALWAYS be my favorite. I’m old enough to be their mom, he and Jared ha

Jared Padalecki, hands down.
Jensen Ackles is the one we hear about the most, and yes, he’s amazing in his own right and very deserving or recognition. But it takes nothing from Jensen to state that Jared absolutely blew everyone else out of the water with his performances this year, especially in the latter half of season 8. He utterly wrecked himself for some of those scenes, and it showed.
Jared has the ability to make the audience feel anything his character is feeling, which is a unique gift, and he has truly become my favorite sci-fi/fantasy star OF ALL TIME.

Jensen ackles hands down! As Dean He makes me laugh, cry, smile, he makes me mad sometimes, but no other character has ever been more important to me than he is. He is a rock and a hero. And I can’t imagine anyone else pulling it off line he can.

Jensen Ackles. We’re talking about sci/fi and fantasy here, when I think about supernatural atmosphere and fighting unimaginable creatures, Dean Winchester is the first character who comes to my mind, the guy has the ‘style’.

I’ve tried to watch different sci-fi movies/series, but never was able to enjoy any of them, until the first time that I saw Castiel on TV series Supernatural.
So naturally *FOR ME* “the best sci-fi/fantasy star of all time” would be Misha Collins who plays Castiel on Supernatural – the only actor ever who’s been able to make me watch a long sci-fi TV series.

I love Jensen Ackles but I’m seeing way too much of him on the comments. Jared is a part of the show too! I vote Jared Padalecki because his acting is amazing in absolutely anything he acts in. Jared deserves this, especially after his gorgeous performance in “Sacrifice.”

Well in my opinion screw only one winner and there should be a tie between Jared Padalecki and Jensen Ackles.they both are truly amazing actors and the fact that they are like brothers in real life and support each other on camera is the reason that they both are brilliant actors. Trust me there’s no dean without sam and vise versa. Its ‘sam and dean’ and not ‘sam’ & ‘dean’. So if one deserves the PCA its 50% bcoz of the other. And I can NEVER EVER be partial between them.

My favorite actor in this genre is ” Jared Padalecki ” ! His brilliant performances in past 8 seasons of ” Supernatural ” , specially season 8 , made all the fans speechless ! His talent and passion is what make him the best in my eyes !

Jensen Ackles AND Jared Padalecki! Come on, SPN fans, you can’t just vote for one. Did you not see Jared’s performance in Sacrifice? It was OSCAR-WORTHY. Both of them are equally amazing, incredible actors and both deserve a PCA. But only one person can win so I hope it’s neither of them.

As much as I am a big fan of Supernatural, and believe that Jensen and Jarad are top draw actors and deserve more recognition then they get, I have to note that the categories is “Star of All time”. As that is the criteria, I would have to say, the choices have to go back a few more decades then what I see being debated here.

I would pick Leonard Nimoy. Hard to beat out a classically trained actor with the goods.

After him there is Ron Perlman. Sorry for the fans of the current Beast, but Perlmans’ portrayal of Vincent set the bar to a height that a guy with fake fangs and minor prosthetic will never reach.

You can pick, almost anyone that was a regular on Babylon 5, or Deep Space Nine. (I’m not even going to try and list them all, save to say that Avery Brooks’ performance on the show was stellar)

The sad part is, that most of the ppl voting never got a chance to see these shows, save in faded reruns. And the mind is set to pick the most recent stars over ones that would, if they were to be around now, would out shine them all. (Including Jensen and Jared, but it would be close).

Jensen Ackles who plays Dean Winchester on Supernatural! I know a lot of people are probably thinking the fans love him for his looks – but watch ONE episode of the show and you will see just how talented he is. He is able to give such depth to his character that it feels like Dean comes alive on screen. Jensen Ackles also adds so much of his own insight to the character, that I think that half the credit for Dean’s complexity should go to Jensen.

I hate it when certain fans (@Amy) say we’re not voting on merit if we’re voting for Jensen Ackles, we happen to believe he’s not just a pretty face we think he’s a phenomenal actor, he has amazing chemistry with his co-stars, breaks hearts in emotional scenes, has excellent comic timing and completely owns his role as Dean Winchester, what’s more he’s a total pro and stays on set for hours even when not in shot but just to be there for the other actors.

Jared gets the big storylines and he gets credit for it, Jensen’s role is a thankless one a lot of the time, being the glue that holds the show together but some fans recognize the amazing work he does and feels he deserves recognition for it and who are you to say otherwise?

Also for your information Jared Padalecki is a good looking man to so why say we vote one for looks and one talent it’s insulting to both when they’re both talented and gorgeous.

Definitely Jensen Ackles. No actor, or character, has ever pulled me in like he has. Before Supernatural, TV shows were just background noise, but his acting ability sucked me in so much that I feel like I’m a part of the show. He makes the sci/fi aspects seem like reality and gives them true emotion.

Jensen Ackles. He has done consistently awesome work in Supernatural as Dean Winchester, not to mention the other roles he’s had in Sci-Fi/Fantasy shows before that. His ability to say so much without speaking a word never fails to amaze me. He will always be my number one pick for this award. No actor has ever made me love a character more than I love Dean Winchester. Jensen Ackles deserves this award and so much more.

Wow, fangirls. I love Supernatural too but this is supposed to be the best of ALL TIME. How about Leonard Nimoy as Spock. Sarah Michelle Gellar as Buffy. David Duchovny as Mulder. Patrick Stewart as Picard. Scott Bakula as Sam Beckett. John Noble as Walter Bishop. All great characters from great shows with fantastic actors playing those roles.

If I were to go with someone from Supernatural I’d go with Jared Padalecki over Jensen Ackles any day of the week. I just think he’s a better actor. He’s played several different versions of his character on that show and hit it out of the park every single time. We get it, Ackles is good looking. But it doesn’t make him God’s gift to the acting world. Base the award on merit, not who is the prettiest to look at.

Jensen Ackles/Dean Winchester. No contest. The man is brilliant. His incredible acting abilities are phenomenal. His facial expressions alone can make you cry, laugh, sing, cuss etc. The man is beautiful inside and out.

Jared Padalecki; he poured his heart & soul into last season of Supernatural, completely wrecked himself. I have so much respect for his work ethic, undeniable talent, & his love & devotion to his fans.

Jared Padalecki; he poured his heart & soul into last season of Supernatural, completely wrecked himself & I have so much respect for his work ethic, undeniable talent, & his love & appreciation for his fans.

Dean Winchester from Supernatural is my favourite character of all time, and he MADE that character his own. He is able to portray countless emotions without even saying a word. He can do heartbreaking drama, has excellent comedic timing, and will tackle literally any scene you throw at him. He doesn’t act the character, he IS the character on screen.

Add on to the fact that he’s only ever given me the impression of being a classy, humble, kind, all-around great guy makes him my obvious choice for Favourite Sci-Fi Fantasy Star!

Jensen Ackles is the best ever because as the seasons progress in supernatural, he just gets better and better. There is no match for Dean Winchester. Jensen is also an amazingly nice person so I think he really deserves it.

Jensen Ackles aka Dean Windchester gives us his heart and soul to this character. Jensen Ackles reveals layers of Dean Windchester like pealing an apple he gives grit, loyalty, brotherly love, Friendship showing us the audience through all the pain being uncomfortable with some special effects still gave us performance that engaging witty. This is my reasons that Jensen Ackles is best SciFi/Fantasy star of all time.

My favorite sci-fi/fantasy star is absolutely Misha Collins. He’s one of my favorite people and can always make me smile. His zany sense of humor and amazing work with charity are just two of the awesome things about him. And he’s a terrific actor! The many different versions of Castiel (and his portrayal of Jimmy Novak) that we’ve seen from him on Supernatural will amaze you with how great he makes subtle changes between the versions of them. He’s the best and really an angel on the show and in real life too.
Also love, love, love Jensen Ackles and Jared Padalecki from Supernatural too. This show is blessed with three amazing lead actors! And I really hope to see all three of them at the awards show this year (especially Misha since he wasn’t invited last year!)

Jensen Ackles deserves real recognition for all he’s brought to Supernatural and for fans to have to chance to say they appreciate him even though the new showrunner *Carver* finds his character boring and even said as much to his face :/

I would definitely say: Jay Ryan as Vincent Keller in Beauty and the Beast. I only knew him from Neighbours and wow did he surprise me in this role. When he beasts out.. man.. I would be scared sh*tless (excuses my French)and run!
Great actor.. so definitely Jay Ryan!

No doubt.. Jay Ryan as the Beast Vincent Keller. The struggle he portrays of containing the beast inside him with Muirfield hunting him down. Jay can do it all. Outstanding actor. Cannot wait how he will be doing in Season 2 as the new, revised Beast 2.0

I’m torn. Nathan Fillion as Malcolm Reynolds gave an incredibly nuanced performance, from deep rage to befuddled lust to sharp wit to gentle pathos to sheer goofiness, and everything in between. Add to that his chilling turn as Caleb in Buffy the Vampire Slayer, and he should have it sewn up.

On the other hand, Ron Perlman – who played the original Vincent in Beauty and the Beast, also a very convincing caveman in Quest for Fire, also Hellboy and the giant in “City of Lost Children” – he’s brilliant. Literally always worth watching.

Jensen Ackles! He’s just so talented. He can convey 100 emotions in just one look. He can say a thousand things in the way he delivers one sentence. He has more talent than a lot of the actors that win all of the awards.

Jensen Ackles makes you feel what his character is feeling without ever overacting. He emotes. He is also convincing in action scenes and has a presence whenever he’s on camera. He can do comedy, tragedy, and everything in between.

That is a hard question! Obviously Sarah Michelle Gellar and David Duchovny would be on my top list as would Gillian Anderson and James Marsters. Besides them, I would definitely include David Tennant as the Doctor. (Christopher Eccleston and Matt Smith are also great). I’d even include the actors who play the companions such as Billie Piper as Rose. There’s so many other great ones I’d have to think about it. It’s impossible to pick the best!

Kristin Kreuk! Not just for Beauty and the Beast but for Smallville, the work she did on that show alone was just mind blowing. People still can’t get over her role in that show and they never will because she is the BEST!