The game originated from concepts several individuals made during a Sonic-themed Valentine's Day event on the game-sharing website Glitch City. It was released as freeware on August 10, 2015, accompanied by a satirical press release claiming the contents were discovered in a Dreamcast software development kit Arcane Kids purchased on eBay in 2013. Sonic Dreams Collection quickly caught the attention of many video game journalists, who were intrigued by its absurd nature and content. They characterized the game as scary and bizarre, but considered it a work people should be interested in playing and noted its commentary on the series' fandom. Geek.com went on to name Sonic Dreams Collection the best game of 2015.

Make My Sonic is a character creator in which the player alters the appearance of a Sonic the Hedgehog model. The player can change his coloration and alter the size and positioning of his limbs. After this, they select a randomly generated name.[3]Screenshots of the player's character can be uploaded to Twitter.[6] The game states Make My Sonic was MJSTUDIO's first Sonic game and was created in 1996.[4] The studio apparently wanted it to be compatible with the defunct internet service SegaNet so users could import their character into supported games, believing Sonic would work in any genre.[6]

Eggman Origin is a vestigial massively multiplayer online role-playing game[3] alleged to have been created in 1997.[7] It is initially displayed as unplayable beyond the title screen, as it requests a connection to SegaNet.[3] However, by opening a separate file in the game's directory folders (Seganet.exe) and using Make My Sonic to create an avatar and "upload it to SegaNet", the player will be able to access an untextured map populated by several bipedal, egg-shaped creatures and Doctor Eggman. By feeding Eggman with worms dug up from around him on the map, he grows. After this, the player completes the game and ascends into the sky, with the number of ascensions posted on the online leaderboardchao.garden.[7]

Sonic Movie Maker is an adventure game in which the player is tasked with finding a camera and filming a six-second film to proceed to the following scene. The areas in which the player films are populated by ragdoll models of Sonic and other characters such as Tails, Shadow, Rouge, or Blaze, as well as objects such as pull cords, speech bubble sprites, and rings. Levels in Sonic Movie Maker include a garage, a prom dance floor, and a hospital room.[3] The game states Sonic Movie Maker would have been a technological achievement but was canceled in 1998 when Sega management discovered its dark and sexual content. Similar to Make My Sonic, videos the player makes can be uploaded to Twitter.[8]

My Roommate Sonic is a virtual reality (VR) game presented from a first-person view. The player sits on a couch next to Sonic, with Eggman encouraging the player by text message to pursue a romantic interest in him. The minigame is also compatible with the Oculus Rift VR headset.[3][9] The game suggests My Roommate Sonic was canceled in 1999 because it was supposed to be used with the unreleased Sega VR headset.[10] Completing it unlocks an extra level in Sonic Movie Maker.[9]

Sonic Dreams Collection is a fan’s game. We’re not making fun of the fans necessarily, just celebrating the weirdness of it. Sonic fans kind of hated it for that. I hate any kind of brand that uses anti-corporate language to promote a corporation.

Ben Esposito on how Sonic Dreams Collection was targeted at the Sonicfandom.[11]

The minigames in Sonic Dreams Collection were developed separately during the game-sharing website Glitch City's "Sonic is My Boyfriend" Valentine's Day event;[15]Sonic Movie Maker, for example, was created by former Electronic Arts employee Arjun Prakash.[16] Afterward, Prakash and two Arcane Kids members decided to merge the games they made (Sonic Movie Maker, Make My Sonic, and My Roommate Sonic) to form Sonic Dreams Collection. Development lasted for another three months, progressing through weekly sessions on Glitch City with the help of other contributors.[15] Despite his significant contributions, Prakash did not receive much credit for his involvement.[16] Arcane Kids later issued an apology.[17]

Sonic Dreams Collection was released on August 10, 2015[3] as freeware for OS X and Windows computers on the website hedgehog.exposed.[12] The site contained a press release in which Arcane Kids claimed to have discovered the game's contents in a Dreamcast software development kit they purchased on eBay in 2013 and posted them online as a protest against Sega's apparent attempts to keep their existence a secret.[3] The press release does disclaim that Sonic Dreams Collection is a work of parody, discounting any affiliation with Sega.[18] To download the game, visitors have to type in the password "grandpa".[12]

Sonic Dreams Collection quickly caught the attention of video game journalists for its absurd content and intention to lampoon the series' fandom.[13][19][20] A day after release, VG247 called it a "piece of gaming history."[20]Kill Screen declared it 2015's 13th best game[21] and Geek.com named it the year's top game.[14]Kill Screen wrote that although inappropriate, Sonic Dreams Collection provided a thoughtful homage to the series' fandom;[21]Geek.com found it took what was good about Bubsy 3D: Bubsy Visits the James Turrell Retrospective and "expands on it in glorious ways."[14] Esposito has said some Sonic fans were offended by the game because they felt it was ridiculing them.[11]

Summarizations of the game ranged from a "horror show" (VG247)[20] to "surprisingly polished" (Destructoid).[4]The Daily Dot questioned why the game even existed and wrote it took the Sonic fandom's weirdness to a new level,[19] and Polygon's authors expressed concern they were not allowed to write about its contents.[22] Upon learning about it, Eurogamer's writer said he thought it was "an innocent enough NeoGAF post" that turned into "something much more sinister."[23]Eurogamer and Kotaku were lost for words in describing Sonic Dreams Collection's content, with Kotaku describing the whole experience as haunting.[3][23]VG247 did not describe the game in detail, believing readers needed to play it themselves to understand. They also disagreed with The Daily Dot's comment about the peculiarities of the fandom, saying Sonic Dreams Collection "isn’t even scraping the surface of the places those people go."[20] In addition to mocking the fandom, Engadget found the game served as a comment of the state of the Sonic franchise and its sullied reputation.[2]

Journalists characterized Sonic Dreams Collection's minigames as unsettling and bizarre;[3][22][21]Destructoid wrote they ranged from "creepy sexual fan service and Sonic community parody to something truly nightmare inducing."[4] Of its games, writers were most intrigued by Sonic Movie Maker.[13][19]PC Gamer called it the highlight of the game,[13] while Kotaku, Polygon, and Destructoid were left in shock from playing it.[4][22][3]Polygon—which produced walkthroughs of all four minigames—described Make My Sonic as random,[24]Eggman Origin as scary,[7]Sonic Movie Maker as horrifying,[22] and My Roommate Sonic as "tak[ing] things to the next level".[9]Engadget wrote players would finish Sonic Dreams Collection within minutes but that they would likely come back, finding it "uncanny at recreating both the vibe of crude fan art and Sega's turn-of-the-century zeitgeist, that sense that the Dreamcast would usher in a brave new era for the blue hedgehog and his friends."[2]

^ abArcane Kids (August 10, 2015). Sonic Dreams Collection. Level/area: Make My Sonic. [MJSTUDIO] believed that Sonic was versatile enough for every genre, even sci-fi. Make My Sonic was meant to create and upload avatars for use with every Dreamcast through SEGANET. Sadly, no future games supported this level of creativity. [Version 3.2] Added Twitter support