Friday, June 22, 2012

LE CORBUSIER: CHAPEL OF NOTRE-DAME-DU HAUT, RONCHAMP (I)

The chapel of Notre Dame du Haut, located in the small village of
Ronchamp, near the French border with Switzerland, is the best-known
work of Le Corbusier's, and one of the most emblematic masterpieces in modern
architecture.

Frank O. Gehry argues that the problem with the chapel at Ronchamp is that it is impossible to hold back tears while visiting it.
I can not say I reached that point, but certainly the pilgrimage to
this small chapel was an overwhelming experience for me, both by the building and its powerful presence in the landscape, the composition of the volumes and the sublime
use of light, all of which Le Corbusier amalgamated brilliantly, as well
as by the memories of numerous architectural conversations about the chapel held with teachers, colleagues and students through the years.

After spending several hours in the place and having a lot of material
to share with you, it is impossible for me to summarize this experience
in just one post, so the discussion about this work will be divided into three
entries: the first deals with the chapel's historical background, location on the
site and landscape as well as the "urban" elements that constitute the complex in Ronchamp.
The second post will be devoted to the chapel's architectural, formal and spatial features, as well as some of its remarkable details. These two entries will be accompanied by Geoffrey Baker's analysis from his brilliant book "Le Corbusier. Analysis of Form." (I apologize that the citations will not be literal, by my translation from a Spanish version of the book).

Ronchamp is a small village nestled in a gentle valley, connected by
train to Belfort, near the French border with Switzerland and Germany. Its occupation dates back to millennia, in fact the name "Ronchamp" comes from "Roman Camp".

Then occupied by the Celts and a small population during the Middle
Ages, the town prospered due to a coal mine that operated from the mid
eighteenth century (remains of this industry can be seen from the road
leading to the chapel).

Opposite the village lies a wooded hill. From its summit, one enjoys an important visual domain of the surrounding landscape,
flanked by the Jura Mountains and from whichnearby towns can be glimpsed, such as Mouriere to the north and La Selle to northeast, as well as the cemetery
and the village of Ronchamp to the southeast.

"The idea was born in the brain, then wandered and grew indefinitely. I
carefully drew the four cardinal points from the hill. As there are only
four: to the east, Ballons d'Alsace; to the south, the cliffs; to the west, the plain of the Saône and to the north, a small valley and a
village ... Day 4 June 1950. "

Le Corbusier

"The
hill is crowned with a plain, which is accessed by a road that rises
from the southeast; a group of trees enclose the site to the west and partially delimits the plain on the east side.

The open space extends in a southeasterly direction, downhill, up to the eastern boundary coinciding with the trees.Within
this context, in the middle of a wooded and hilly terrain, the small
plain is significantly closer to the western margin of the field with a
view of the surroundings, but especially towards the south. "

Geoffrey Baker

LOCATION.A."The access road comes from the southeast flanking the open space; the topography determined a slope to the southeast.B.The site has an manifested obliquity . "

ZONING.C."There is a state of confrontation circulation-building in the context of the obliquity of the site."D."Le Corbusier uses this obliquity to separate the entrance area of the assembly area."

Text and graphics: G.Baker.

HISTORY

Because of its visual properties, the hill have enjoyed a symbolic role for centuries. After the Roman occupation, a Celtic shrine to worship the sun was built at the top of the mountain.

View of the chapel at the top of the hill and the cemetery on its side.This mountain has had a symbolic significance since ancient times.

Later, in the fifteenth century a chapel was erected,dedicated to the Virgin Mary, Our Lady of the Heights, or Notre Dame du Haut.
In the mid nineteenth century a tower was added, anticipating a series
of renovations to the chapel, which became an important regional center
of pilgrimage.

Left: chapel before the mid-nineteenth century.Right: enlargement in 1857.

In 1913 a fire left only the walls standing. The chapel was rebuilt in 1923 and completely remodeled in 1930 in NeoGothic style. During World War II the church was bombed and completely destroyed.

Remodeling of 1930, before the bombing in the Second World War

Then the religious authorities opted to rebuild it in a contemporary
architectural style, that would seek to convey an abstract sense of sacredness. It was so decided to give the commission to Le Corbusier in 1950 (not without opposition, as the Swiss architect was an agnostic). Le Corbusier himself was reluctant to accept the commission, but he was convinced after visiting the site.

THE COMPLEX

The complex is composed of several elements, leaded by the chapel, the esplanade, the residence of the monks, a memorial pyramid and bell
tower.

The chapel is located eccentrically on top of the hill and is oriented east-west, nearly perpendicular to the access path.

To the west is located a bell tower, a very simple composition, comprising a metal frame holding 3 bells.

A view of the chapel from bell tower.

To the east is a large esplanade, facing an outdoor chapel, that allows celebrations in front of a large number of pilgrims.

Le Corbusier had originally proposed an artificial slope arc in order to contain the space, but this was never implemented.

At the northern end a stepped pyramid is located, built with the
remnants of the original church, which serves as a monument to peace.

Towards the southern end, and a in a lower area of the topography, stands a
rectangular volume made of concrete,that contrasts in both form and color
with chapel.
This volume, perpendicular and closer to the access path, contains the
residence of the monks and was designed by Le Corbusier in 1953 and
completed in 1959. The building, austere and sober, has classrooms, library, refectory, kitchen and cells for monks.

1 comment:

Thank you very much for your two posts on Notre Dame du Haut. Fascinating and packed with information. Fabulous pictures too - takes me back to when I first saw her in the 1960s, when she and I were both a lot younger than we are now. I think maybe she's aged better than I have! ;)

MY ARCHITECTURAL MOLESKINE

MY ARCHITECTURAL MOLESKINE

Notes on the fly throughout an exciting journey, a logboof of emotions and senses while walking between architectural spaces bathed in light, surrounded by landscape, or being part of it.

Just like in a moleskine - that notebook where travelers compiled writings and drawings of their visits- this blog offers you, dear reader, my own collection based on my personal experience about interesting sites visited in recent years.

Welcome to My Architectural Moleskine

"What I hear, I forget; what I read, I remember; what I do, I learn; what I teach, I know."

Old Chinese proverb.

About me

Architect and urban designer, professor in universities in Peru and Russia. Post PhD. researcher on urban design and landscape in Japan. Earned his PhD in Urban Environmental Planning at Kyoto University, Japan and Master degrees in Sustainability in Argentina and Environmental Management in Peru.

The texts, graphics and photos, unless otherwise stated, belong to the author of this blog.They may be used for personal and academic purposes, as long as the respective authors and source are acknowledged.Its use is not allowed for commercial purposes.