>>124182718>They didn't make the cut for top 5.They're definitely better than Mikoto and Lessar.

>Both wants the D, dumbass.They don't love him. Lessar only wanted to fuck him for the UK, while Birdway manipulated him to her own gains. Anything else is played for comedy and not serious romantic feelings for him.

>Accelerator got her first and it makes more sense she will be in his harem.Except for the fact that she is head over heels for Touma, not Accel.

>They don't love him.How new are you? Hard rRomantic feelings aren't absolutely required to be part of a harem, especially. Birdway is tsundere for Touma. Lessar has her goal for her country, but she likes him too.

>>124183261Ha, no. Birdway has an extreme cute side, shown well before she started to become tsundere for Touma. And the way she acts to Touma is like a sadistic but affectionate loli. You're really just saying that because you don't like her, and Touma's denseness is something no one should even care for.

>>124183747Index isn't even a harem series, and harem jokes aside, the only girls that are confirmed to be in Touma's harem, girls who have romantic/deep feelings for him are Index, Mikoto, Othinus, the Sisters, Misaki and Itsuwa.

Don't confuse "harem" with the Kamijou faction. Girls with ambiguous or undefined feelings for Touma, but will support and help him belong here. Birdway, Kanzaki, Seria, Orsola, Agnese, etc are part of the Kamijou faction, without being part of the harem.

>>124183900>the only girls that are confirmed to be in Touma's harem, girls who have romantic/deep feelings for him are Index, Mikoto, Othinus, the Sisters, Misaki and Itsuwa. Congratulations, that's more than 2 girls. It's a harem, and not by a small margin, either.

>>124183958>>124183970Way to miss the point. I wrote all that to put in perspective how a girl like Birdway is not really part of the harem, a thing that I never denied. Index as a series doesn't fall into the harem category, is all.

>>124183900Index has always been a shounen with harem on the side as comedy and lighthearted contrast. To say there isn't harem is extremely retarded and a case of denial. Liking, affectionate, being interested, deep feelings, and romantic feelings have all been used in harem series. Your narrow-minded thinking that makes you selective about the girls who like Touma prevents you from getting this.

There's nothing ambiguous or undefined about Birdway and Seria's feelings. Girls like Kanzaki and Agnese can be attributed to somewhere in the middle, but they still have some kind of feelings for Touma, made clear in their tsundere-like behavior regard their own feelings for him.

>>124184088Birdway likes Touma a lot and wants him to act in a way she wants. You have girls from Tenchi Muyo and Love Hina who have less feelings than Birdway, but are still a part of the respective harem in their series. Deal with it, anon.

Regarding Will-tan, anon has a point. Will-tan came to Accelerator first. I remember back when she showed up and we were guessing if she was Full Tuning or not, but we know she's different now. Her role will most likely be expanded in Accelerator's story once the Magic God arc is done. I would probably put her above LO for Accelerator if that turned out to be the case.

>>124184206>Her role will most likely be expanded in Accelerator's story once the Magic God arc is doneThat's what I think too. Or perhaps she will have a role in the Magic God clash in the upcoming volumes.

>>124184290We know it isn't the focus of the series. Why do you have to point that out for? I don't think that was your point a few mins ago. Anyhow, you were denying some of the girls in Touma's harem, and that's not true.

>>124184351Index isn't a series you watch/read if you want a harem. Harem is a genre first and foremost, and Index isn't classified as harem by any means.

>>124184359I already told you the difference between the Kamijou faction and the actual harem. Just because a girl is fond of Touma doesn't mean she's part of his harem. Leave that to the girls with confirmed romantic feelings for him. What's next, saying that Uiharu, Kongou and Misaki are part of Mikoto's harem because they are fond of her/have helped her in some capacity?

>>124184706There is a difference, but most of the girls you listed are in the harem. Komoe is a part of Touma's faction, she isn't a part of Touma's harm. There's a clear cut disgusting between aiding/helping and having no feelings to girls like Birdway who do have feelings, even going so far as to act out and spend time with Touma for flag events.

Don't apply slippy slope fallacy here. Mikoto is a girl and girls can be close an intimate without having a harem thing going on. Uiharu and Kongou are just friends. Even Misaki who is tsundere for Mikoto is a friend too despite her admittance and rivalry. Kuroko is the only one with yuri feelings for Mikoto, and she plays up the kohai/sempai yuri trope, not harem.

>>124184876It's the same. Girls are just friends in both cases. Those girls aren't in the harem because they don't have romantic feelings for him, and they aren't in the type of harem you imply because they don't even interact with him constantly after their introduction. They're not part of his everyday life like the girls with no romantic feelings are in true harem series like LH or TM.

>>124185144>One with no feelings and don't raise flags>One with feelings and do raise flags>sameAre you trying at all? And if you're going to nitpick not in his everyday life, then you would have to cut Itsuwa and Misaki out too.

>>124185293Itsuwa and Misaki have romantic feelings for him. Misaki even got a whole novel dedicated for that.

I'm not nitpicking anything. I'm ruling out those girls out of the harem first for not having romantic feelings -the most important aspect, and second, the everyday life aspect which would justify your comparison with the girls in Love Hina and Tenchi Muyo.