Brightness & Contrast

Uncalibrated – Maximum Backlight Level

The EW3270U is the fifth HDR-capable monitor we’ve tested to date. In our comparison group today, we have Dell’s UP2718Q, LG’s 32UD99, Acer’s PE320QK, and another BenQ, the EW277HDR. To round things out, we’ve added a DCI-P3 screen from NEC, the PA243W. The latter is super-accurate, but does not include HDR support.

01 maxwhite

02 maxblack

03 maxcontrast

01 maxwhite

02 maxblack

03 maxcontrast

The BenQ EW3270U doesn’t put out a ton of light, but makes up for that with excellent black levels and contrast. It manages to beat out its stablemate BenQ EW277HDR by almost 12%, a small but noticeable difference which makes its potential for good HDR quality just a bit higher. VA is certainly the way to go when a full-array zone-dimming backlight isn’t in the budget.

Uncalibrated – Minimum Backlight Level

The minimum backlight level is quite low at just over 35 nits, which is darker than practical, even in a pitch-black room. To hit 50 nits, we turned the brightness up to 6. Contrast drops a little at the darkest level too, down 14% and just outside our preferred consistency level. But if you make 50 nits the bottom limit, contrast stays closer to the 3000:1 mark.

After Calibration to 200cd/m2

07 calblack

08 calcontrast

07 calblack

08 calcontrast

Calibrating the BenQ EW3270U cost us a little dynamic range, because we lowered one RGB slider (green) and dropped contrast by two clicks. That puts the BenQ EW277HDR back on top, but the BenQ 3270U still almost doubles the IPS screens here. For SDR material, VA is by far the best choice for image depth and overall fidelity. Its black levels are significantly superior to other LCD technologies.

HDR Brightness & Contrast

09 hdrwhite

10 hdrblack

11 hdrcontrast

09 hdrwhite

10 hdrblack

11 hdrcontrast

Now that we have five HDR-capable monitors in the database, we need to start comparing HDR brightness, which will be a deciding factor in many purchases. As we’ve said, it isn’t realistic to expect fantastic HDR performance from any LCD with an edge backlight. There just isn’t enough native contrast to really do the standard justice. The Dell UP2718Q clearly shows that divide. With its 384-zone backlight, it can easily top 1000 nits in a 10% window pattern, more than enough to display high HDR quality. The BenQ EW3270U however, equips itself well with an excellent dynamic contrast algorithm that affords it a solid 6232.9:1 result. It’s easily the best edge-lit HDR monitor we’ve reviewed yet.

ANSI Contrast Ratio

We’ve stopped measuring ANSI checkerboard patterns in HDR mode, because the results are no different than the SDR numbers. Even the full-array backlit Dell can only muster 1288.9:1 in HDR mode. Obviously, we’ll need a different way to measure intra-image contrast for HDR monitors. Our SDR numbers tell the expected tale. The VA panels are superior and all the monitors here come close to their sequential values, delivering excellent quality and performance.

4K, high refresh rate HDR displays with G-Sync are coming soon, and they're going to be very expensive. Keep in mind, that's only a 27" screen for $2000. And at 27", you'll probably have a hard time even distinguishing the difference between 1440p and 2160p while gaming, so it would probably make a lot more sense to get a screen with the more moderate resolution and get much higher frame rates instead, at a fraction of the cost. After all, what good are high refresh rates at 4K when even today's best graphics cards will struggle to hit 60fps at max settings in many games.

hannibal

In this size, trible this price!

Ninjawithagun

368223 said:

I'd be happy to pay $1000 for the same thing with Gsync instead, 120Hz refresh rate and if it was properly calibrated from factory. It that so much to ask? What do yo guys think?

I completely agree with you. Unfortunately, reality won't be so kind. Acer plans to sell their 27-inch 4K HDR 120Hz panel for no less than $2000 I'm usually an early adopter of tech, but that price tag is just to steep for me. I had the patience to wait for the formerly very expensive Dell AW3418DW 3440 x 1440 IPS 120Hz G-Sync monitors to drop in price and bought two fo them for only $900/each through Best Buy (with 3-year warranties). I guess I can wait for these to come down in price once there is competition in the market place.