I am afraid we have been too harsh with him.... Bottom line is, when you send your paper to the JOE special issue edited by your advisor, whoever takes care of the submission does not matter that much...

Agree with you. It seems that Liang is a hard-working driver. However, Zhang is more like a free rider.

I am afraid we have been too harsh with him.... Bottom line is, when you send your paper to the JOE special issue edited by your advisor, whoever takes care of the submission does not matter that much...

Agree with you. It seems that Liang is a hard-working driver. However, Zhang is more like a free rider.

I am afraid we have been too harsh with him.... Bottom line is, when you send your paper to the JOE special issue edited by your advisor, whoever takes care of the submission does not matter that much...

Count how many JOE papers Qi Li published with his Chinese students. Count how many JOE papers Lung-Fei Lee published with his Chinese students.
All sort of mindless extensions, tweaking here and there.
Corrupt JOE goes to toilet.

Be careful guys, threads with personal attacks can be deleted by Kirk. But as an econometrician, I am quite disappointed by some of the unethical behavior in our community.

I would also add Yanqing Fan to the list along with Qi Li and Lung-Fei Lee.

The saddest part about all these corrupt practices is that LRM places like Albany willingly and knowingly fall for these fabrications.

Count how many JOE papers Qi Li published with his Chinese students. Count how many JOE papers Lung-Fei Lee published with his Chinese students.
All sort of mindless extensions, tweaking here and there.
Corrupt JOE goes to toilet.

I would also add Yanqing Fan to the list along with Qi Li and Lung-Fei Lee.
The saddest part about all these corrupt practices is that LRM places like Albany willingly and knowingly fall for these fabrications.

Count how many JOE papers Qi Li published with his Chinese students. Count how many JOE papers Lung-Fei Lee published with his Chinese students.
All sort of mindless extensions, tweaking here and there.
Corrupt JOE goes to toilet.

It seems that LRM metrics positions are heavily discussed this season (last one was LSU).