As bleak as the Walking Dead gets, I'm not going to buy that everyone in that room is going to be arbitrarily supportive of slaughtering and plundering innocent communities. Nobody in this story is even close to sentient. Everyone's a cardboard cutout.

My take on it, having played it, is that The Cat Lady is technically ugly, but thematically good. Its design is extremely rough around the edges, but it goes places and, problems aside, it's more or less honest in what it sets out to accomplish.