In case you didn’t get enough of Andi Dorfman’s men proving they shouldn’t quit their day jobs when they serenaded a crowd with Boys II Men during Episode 3, a few of her cast-offs are at it again. This time they’re putting their pipes out into the ether known as the Internet for all the world to cringe at enjoy.

Andi’s bromantic group of suitors reunited in L.A. for the taping of the Men Tell All special, and apparently some of them didn’t feel like they’d gotten their voices heard enough, because they went out afterward and expressed their feelings through song. Chris Soules, Brian Osborne, and Nick Viall were among Andi’s exes who took part in the karaoke magic, and it was this trio that got up on stage and blessed all our ear holes with a rendition of “Baby Got Back.”