I disagree I think dvds are better im dislexic and I would rather watch a trick than read it and to get a real good book cost a lot more than to get a real good dvd

Both of your points are flawed. First of all, last time I checked, having dyslexia affected your abillity to write--not read. Additionally, there are many great dyslexic magicians. They didn't have access to DVDs when they were learning. Why should that block you?

Also, your second point is completely untrue. Art of Astonishment Volume 3 has more/about the same amount of material as Volumes 1,2,3, and 4 of Bill Malone's On the Loose DVD series. The DVD series, in total costs about 130 dollars, while the Art of Astonishment book costs about 50. These are rough estimates, so don't start correcting, I know these are probably wrong. I'm just giving a general ballpark.

if you know exactly what you want, then I would say DVDs may be a better choice. However if you want a wide range of tricks on one apparatus then of course books are the way to go. For instance there are many books that are solely on cards but I only need to know 5 really good card tricks. In this instance I would go with a DVD in order to view the handling

I am however a big fan of books about performing in general and how to relate to certain audiences (for example kids).

I guess there is no real answer as long as you practice enough to perform the trick flawlessly and add your own flare to truly make it yours.

I'd also have to agree that books excel over DVDs, because the fact is that you get more tricks for your money, and also, many of whom we consider the great magicians weren't around when DVDs were common (or even existent), so the only way we can gain thier knowledge directly is from books.

Ironically, I am the proud owner of one, two, three, mumble, mumble, 25 magic DVDs and 18 books and booklets. The reason for this is because as a child, I found learning from DVDs easier because they were more visual, and watching a screen is much more appealing to today's generation (myself included) than reading a book.

However, I'm in the process of buying more books and selling my one-effect DVDs.

magicdjw wrote:

First of all, last time I checked, having dyslexia affected your abillity to write--not read.

From Wikipedia: Dyslexia refers to any reading difficulty not associated with obvious problems such as bad eyesight. ... Dyslexias include the inability to name letters, to read words or sentences, or to recognize words directly even though they can be sounded out. Dyslexia is not limited to reversing the order of letters in reading or writing, as is often implied in popular culture; it may, for instance, include unexpected spelling mistakes and unusual syntax

dyslexia is reading an writing trust me i know
and i didnt say it was a block for me i said it was easyer for me
to watch a dvd
but yes i think your rite about the price
good point
thinking about it books are better in some ways
because when you watch a dvd you use the same patter as the magician your watching but if you read a book and learn a trick you use your own patter because books only have a out line of patter

Ask any magician who does magic for a living and they will say 99% of the time that they have learned more from books then they have from DVD's.

Maybe so, but ironically enough one of the best authors of one of the best magazines/books to ever be printed (The Magic Menu) states: "DVD is really the best choice for magic instructional media -Jim Sisti." I think saying "99%" is a little far-fetched, and an inaccurate percentage, especially these days. The reason being is, not as many even bother reading books to begin with, as they wish to take every shortcut possible.

Now back about 20 years ago, maybe 99% would be more accurate, as DVDs were not available. Granted I am also from the old school of "book learners," but I see DVDs as a great new learning tool for those who choose to supplement them in with their reading, as opposed to replacing books entirely. After 26 years of magic thus far, I do not have that many DVDs—I only have some of the classic sets. However so far I have thoroughly enjoyed what I have watched, and actually was able to grasp the information a lot quicker by actually seeing it done live by a performer.

With books, some may miss key elements as far as timing and misdirection goes. But like I also said, I was already well grounded in magic long before I even seen a DVD. So my prior knowledge helped me to learn much more quickly. I think DVDs are a great new learning tool as long as they are used for the right reasons. Not simply because one is too lazy to read, or is looking for instant gratification. DVDS should be used to "fill in the gaps" so to speak, not replace books.

They provide a great visual reference, and allow another magician to come into your home for personal instruction. Some older magicians tend to become jaded, and antiquated in their own solidified and outdated ways. They refuse to evolutionize simply because they fear something new, or hold resentment because this was not available for them when they were first learning, so why should everyone else be able to just jump in and freely access all the knowledge that they had to spend years reading?

I felt the same way, and still do to a point. I believe beginners should also go the book route for starters, as books provide far more material for a much better price. I think that if one sticks to only DVDs, they are actually cheating themselves out of a lot of knowledge, a lot more that could ever be found on DVDs. So build your foundation with books, and supplement it with DVDs from time to time.

Just make smart, and wise decisions. Beware of high priced i"ndividual effects" as well, and only buy what gives you the most bang for your buck. This is why I only stick to the "classic sets."

...not as many even bother reading books to begin with, as they wish to take every shortcut possible....I think DVDs are a great new learning tool as long as they are used for the right reasons. Not simply because one is too lazy to read, or is looking for instant gratification. DVDS should be used to "fill in the gaps" so to speak, not replace books.

They provide a great visual reference, and allow another magician to come into your home for personal instruction. ...I believe beginners should also go the book route for starters, as books provide far more material for a much better price. I think that if one sticks to only DVDs, they are actually cheating themselves out of a lot of knowledge, a lot more that could ever be found on DVDs. So build your foundation with books, and supplement it with DVDs from time to time. ...

WELL SAID,
I just hope that those that READ this will follow the advice given. Reading does allow for one to develop one's own performance style because they cannot SEE what they are learning doen by anyone else and just in that respect books are superior. Alas, kids nowadays do not read the same way we all did and do.

I agree with this, but one flaw there is with books. Many of them can't stay open on a surface, and you have to hold it open with one hand. Really annoys me, some books will stay though. I like both Books and DVD's.

Also, DVD's are something where you know exactly what is there and there are no suprises. yet books are packed with all kinds of things. Mark Wilson's book for example:

Both are good. Books are good because they are cheap for lots of information but DVDs may be easier to learn from. You can see exactly how to do the move. I think every magician can't get just books or jsut DVDs but you need a mix. about half and half.

Seeing exactly how to do the move is only half the story. Many moves also demand a discussion of the subtleties involved, exactly where pressure must be put, clear viewpoints with transparent fingers and more... Much of this explanation is clumsy when spoken. If DVDs included menus of line drawings you could refer to, 3d graphical visualisations and a carefully-planned script they could be onto something. I've yet to see a DVD which hasn't dispensed with the best parts of study from a book. These things need documentary production values, not one camera, a couple of studios, and people talking and explaining off the top of their head while performing. While in principle the format could be good, it's hardly being used to its full potential.

Now back about 20 years ago, maybe 99% would be more accurate, as DVDs were not available. Granted I am also from the old school of "book learners," but I see DVDs as a great new learning tool for those who choose to supplement them in with their reading, as opposed to replacing books entirely. After 26 years of magic thus far, I do not have that many DVDs—I only have some of the classic sets. However so far I have thoroughly enjoyed what I have watched, and actually was able to grasp the information a lot quicker by actually seeing it done live by a performer.

With books, some may miss key elements as far as timing and misdirection goes. But like I also said, I was already well grounded in magic long before I even seen a DVD. So my prior knowledge helped me to learn much more quickly. I think DVDs are a great new learning tool as long as they are used for the right reasons. Not simply because one is too lazy to read, or is looking for instant gratification. DVDS should be used to "fill in the gaps" so to speak, not replace books.

The next step here really, is to have an actual magician right next to you and teach you. I still think DVDs > Books. In terms of learning

I generally find learning actual techniques easier from a book than from a person. A demonstration is great for seeing a routine or presentation, but not for actual sleight-of hand. Explanations need to be very carefully planned and thought through, and they rarely are in person, unless the situation is a prepared lecture. The only way I can learn difficult sleights directly from a person is if they are very patient and happy to repeat themself a lot. Book format tends to pace itself

Who is online

Users browsing this forum: No registered users and 1 guest

You cannot post new topics in this forumYou cannot reply to topics in this forumYou cannot edit your posts in this forumYou cannot delete your posts in this forumYou cannot post attachments in this forum