Post by JetRepulsion1 on Mar 18, 2018 17:50:12 GMT -5

He may be gone. I can see the Giants taking him. Jewish kid. Giants owner is Jewish. NY has a big Jewish pop. I’d love Rosen but think he may be gone. Although, if he’s there at 3, then I think the jets will take him. But I will honestly be happy with any of the top 4. Mayfield will bring excitement and swagger, Darnold is the quintessential QB prototype, Rosen reminds me of Aaron Rodgers (yes, I want him as our QB too) and Allen has tons of upside (ala wentz). I actually think we can’t go wrong. We’ve set it up so even Macc can’t fuck this up. The perfect storm.

Post by jetitbe on Mar 18, 2018 18:57:47 GMT -5

He may be gone. I can see the Giants taking him. Jewish kid. Giants owner is Jewish. NY has a big Jewish pop. I’d love Rosen but think he may be gone. Although, if he’s there at 3, then I think the jets will take him. But I will honestly be happy with any of the top 4. Mayfield will bring excitement and swagger, Darnold is the quintessential QB prototype, Rosen reminds me of Aaron Rodgers (yes, I want him as our QB too) and Allen has tons of upside (ala wentz). I actually think we can’t go wrong. We’ve set it up so even Macc can’t fuck this up. The perfect storm.

For what it's worth, Josh Rosen doesn't consider himself to be Jewish. He's an atheist.

Post by Peebag on Mar 19, 2018 10:22:08 GMT -5

He may be gone. I can see the Giants taking him. Jewish kid. Giants owner is Jewish. NY has a big Jewish pop. I’d love Rosen but think he may be gone. Although, if he’s there at 3, then I think the jets will take him. But I will honestly be happy with any of the top 4. Mayfield will bring excitement and swagger, Darnold is the quintessential QB prototype, Rosen reminds me of Aaron Rodgers (yes, I want him as our QB too) and Allen has tons of upside (ala wentz). I actually think we can’t go wrong. We’ve set it up so even Macc can’t fuck this up. The perfect storm.

For what it's worth, Josh Rosen doesn't consider himself to be Jewish. He's an atheist.

Post by crossfire on Mar 19, 2018 10:47:49 GMT -5

I see that most guys want Rosen so will likely get killed for this but I want nothing to do with him. So of the big 4, I rank him fourth. Too many red flags for me. Yes, I do see ability and yes, he may be a good pro. But too many red flags for me. The 2 concussions last year scare the crap out of me. Guys who have concussion issues tend to keep getting them. And he had two last year. He has a history of other injuries too. Then their are the red flag rumors regarding his leadership ability, coachability and a lack of love for the game. Those may or may not be true but the inury history is definitely a big concern.

But I'm sure if we picked Rosen and the injury history turned out to be just a precursor of things to come, everybody who wanted him would still back Mac & the Jets for the pick... right?

Oh... full disclosure.... I wanted nothing to do with Watson last year. So you could bash me for that but since all of you suck at player evaluation too. But with all due (dis)respect, I'm not all that worried about getting bashed.

Here is my list. Rosen is as low as he is because of my concerns about his health and other red flags. Just my opinion.