I don't know about "without question" - Collins had a pretty good comeback year too. Though if I had to vote myself, I'd vote for Chad.

yeah, i'd still vote for Chad too because there isnt too many big comeback guys, but Chad had a rating of 86 last year and played half the year before getting injured. With the whole Favre saga and all that, people obviously know about him more and that, but in terms of "comeback" Delhomme overcoming Tommy John surgery was very impressive..

Again, fine with Chad and if i had a vote it'd still go to him, but it's definitely not "without question" if you think about it.

I didn't think adding just this one piece would radically change a 1-15 team to a playoff team but it did. Now, a lot of other players also improved their play but Chad was the man that made the car run so he does deserve it

Im pulling hard for the Dolphins right now, seeing as my team is out of it. It seems like they have no legit shot, but they hang around EVERY game and they always play up to their competition it seems.