I'm able to display the two WYSIWYG editors on my theme options page, but the values I enter into the editors aren't saved. I've read a ton of stuff about the Settings API and wp_editor() in hopes of making this work in the most WordPress-friendly way. I feel like I have yet to find a good explanation for how to make wp_editor() work in theme settings while still saving properly according to the Settings API.

I'm getting the feeling that, despite the wp_editor() calls being in the relevant settings field callbacks, the Save process isn't realizing that the editors are associated with valid options.