But then when I read the article, I was kinda let down. Basically, he’s releasing a free e-book (which he’s done for a while now), an on-demand paperback, and a de luxe hardcover edition. And one dude gave him 10K as a commission on a story.

Well, let me be fair. There are two things that I think are interesting and kind of new about what Doctorow’s doing:

Doctorow has some nifty-sounding software, contributed by a fan, Vaskin Kissoyan: “a beta of a package called ‘Ange’ that he’s written to single-source my master text files into HTML, PDF and EPub, so that all I need to do is make an edit in the text file and run the script, and it converts the updated file to all the other formats and uploads them for me. There’s a reason this collection is called With a Little Help!” That’s pretty cool.

Doctorow is going to disclose all of his earnings, from every stream, in a blog for PW, to show that giving away e-books can pay off. I think that’s kind of nice, and might even be useful.

I think what bothers me is that Doctorow’s “packages” aren’t really packages. Each book is a separate product at different, individuated price points, without any overlap. And you get to pick one. Compare that to what this whippersnapper is offering:

Pledge $3 or more

DIGITAL PACK. Get a PDF copy of the book and follow along with behind-the-scenes updates.

Pledge $11 or more

PHYSICAL PACK. All of the above, plus get a physical copy of the book. (The more people who choose this level or higher, the better the book is for everybody!)

Pledge $19 or more

SINCERITY PACK. All of the above, plus your book is signed, and it comes with a little surprise.

Pledge $29 or more

PATRON PACK. All of the above, plus your name (or secret code-name) is listed in the acknowledgments.

Pledge $39 or more

SUPER OCCULT VALUE PACK. All of the above, plus get three more copies of the book (for a total of four), so you can give one to a friend, donate one to the library, leave one in a coffee shop with a line of hexadecimal code scribbled across the title page…

Note the refrain: “all of the above.” When you spring for a package, you actually get more than one thing. You don’t choose between a digital book and a paperback — you get both.

This is pro forma true in CD’s model, too, b/c he’s giving away the e-book for free — but what if the e-book, for hard copy purchasers, came without advertising? Might not the collectors’ edition hardcover buyers also want a paperback as a reading copy? How can an upmarket purchase actually give a reader some leverage on a downmarket one – or vice versa?

I’m going to put a marker down on this. In this transitional period, the most valuable and successful experiments will come from people who find new ways to give readers BOTH digital and print books – who in fact create incentives to encourage BOTH kinds of reading – and that in turn value their readers as members of an interlocking community, not (just) isolated buyers at different price points. And that means aligning readers’ interests and offering them MORE than they might think they’d want.

Yeah, I’m with you (and not just because of the nice link) w/r/t to the fancy edition. I want more, not different. (And also, on a personal level, although I feel plenty of book-lust, it’s never been towards those gilt-and-leather editions. I mean, what are those even for? You can’t carry ’em around!)

I do like the commissioned short story, at least insofar as it’s a simple example of a new (old) funding model. Another (so far unrealized) data point is BLDGBLOG‘s playful notion that a big-ticket apartment development might commission someone to write a novel set in and around the new building—sort of a supercharged Significant Objects. The book would operate as marketing and commemoration—and even if they paid the writer a hundred grand (!!!) it would be, like, an asterisk in the total construction budget.

Right. Again, de luxe editions ahould not just be fancy, they should offer MORE — illustrations, illuminations, an expanded introduction, notes, an extra story.

The folks who sell movies right now, dumb as they’ve been, are actually ahead of the curve on this. I remember when I bought my last Harry Potter DVD, I had a choice between the regular and deluxe edition: the deluxe edition came with an extra disc of features, and crucially, a high-quality digital AVI of the movie for the computer. It had DRM, so you needed a little code from the DVD case, but here it was — a major studio actually OFFERING a legal digital copy of their movie to folks who’d sprung (and paid a little more) for the disc.