You would have been better off private messaging a headmin or pinging them on discord then recreating the thread twice. To sum up what happened; the appeal thread went stale and I had already denied the appeal. After leaving it a couple days I pinged a headmin to see if they wanted to add anything or overrule. From the looks of it they abstained and closed the thread like they normally would in that situation. What we both should have done is discussed the note beforehand.

Original Note wrote:Executed an assistant for pushing him over while securing some evidence from a traitor. You have the tools and the authority to arrest people who cause you trouble, executions are usually reserved for people who are highly dangerous or confirmed traitors. Take a break from Captain for a while and be more rational next time.

From what you've said previously you don't like how this reduces the situation you were in when you made that call. So I'll offer you the following.

Proposed Change wrote:Executed an assistant for disarming him and stealing/disposing of a piece of evidence of a traitor during a high pressure man hunt. You have the tools and the authority to arrest people who cause you trouble, if you choose to arrest them you should give the detainee appropriate sentencing with executions reserved for people who are highly dangerous or confirmed antagonists.

I'm open to discussing the wording a bit more if you're still unhappy, but keep in mind this is more because I understand notes need to be accurate. I have no obligation to continue this appeal any further but I want to at least close it cleanly.