Maybe it's time for Charlie to just literally roll dice to see who ought to be the closer on any given night. Lidge, Madson, Myers, Eyre, and Park. Those are the choices, and really, he can't do any worse than how the games have been going lately. Lidge has about a 70-75% success rate, and Madson is probably just above 50% at this point. I think that this particular Phillies team doesn't get out of the first round of the playoffs *if* they make it that far.