Search

eBook TCH

This powerful e-book will inform you, shock you, amaze you and give you wonderful encouragement in these days.

These events are about to unfold on the world stage, the Middle East and in Israel. This is like a giant play, enough to put a thousand Shakespeare's to shame...except this is no play! In fact it's already starting to unfold.

This book is full of incredible revelation.

The book reveals many amazing repeating patterns and shows just why the coming holocaust is inevitable.

Dear Joel, A really huge thank you for your book! I have read through it – its real and gripping!! I have found myself re-reading chapter after chapter. I follow your belief and Holy Spirit inspired words. Wow what a wake-up call to the world and the church in general.

B. Currie:

Shalom Joel. Your book blew me away. I loved the way you dovetailed everything. There is no reason for anyone to be offended by the book because it’s straight truth. As you kept on saying the Jews did nothing to deserve this favour of God and yet people despise them even though it’s not their choice. I am saying that they are God's people and we had better love them! I enjoyed the history and the meaning of words. Highly recommended was the way you supported your statements with Scripture. A sterling work!

J. Pasma:

I have read your book and have learned a few things that I did not know before. This book should be read by every truly born-again saint of God, if for no other reason than to strengthen belief in Israel's right to their God-given land and God-given promises. Please keep on writing the Prophetic Scroll. After I read the "the interviews” section, I was shocked by comments from people who claimed to be believers, even more so by those who said they were pastors.

Joanne Smith (Ringwood, NJ, USA) 9/11/12

The Coming Holocaust is much like reading the book of Isaiah; it is a mind-boggling compilation of every book of the Bible purposefully pointing toward the Messianic age. That said, you can read this book and read your newspaper headlines almost side by side with the incomparable benefits of Mr. Joseph’s scholarly expository skill and his exhaustive investigation of the historical roots of just about any major player on the world stage.

Ever mindful of the title of this book, Mr. Joseph zooms in and out of the patterns and parallels throughout history that foreshadow the final battle for human souls that will result in a holocaust of unprecedented proportion and climax in a real-time Valley of Decision. He emphasizes that every single person alive is brought to reveal his/her decision if by nothing more than one’s opinion. As he explains,

“In this day, you must know and understand these things, otherwise you’re

in infinitely more danger than you can imagine. If you don’t understand what

is about to unfold, you’re in danger of being swept away in a tidal wave of

Satanic influence, opinion and intent. These very issues will lead a great

many people into hell.”

The most important changes I made after reading The Coming Holocaust are two unwavering decisions which I now can explain clearly. My first is to recognize that God’s roadmap to peace is not up to man nor can it be. It has always been up to God. It is the cross of Christ. And it is none other than this same Yeshua who will fully answer the cries of His Jewish people and similarly enable their recognition of Him. The true Messiah says “My peace I give to you; not as the world gives”. My other decision honors the eternal covenant with Israel as divine and not open to human revision. Again, here is the clearest explanation ever given to me:

“The very essence of all sin, is the doubting or denial of God’s word,

will and ways. God has made an eternal covenant with Israel. So what

does the modern world do? It says, ‘Has God said?’

This will be the very issue of separation and division between the

eternal purposes of the living God and the short-term doomed purposes of

Satan himself. You will go with one or the other, believe it or like it or not!”

(Joel Joseph, p5)

The best description I can give this body of work is that of a compass needle that will reliably point true North no matter who you are, where you stand, what clouds your visibility and above all how lost you‘ve become.

eBook NEWAIP

It covers much that is truly wonderful, some material that is frightening and much that is little or completely unknown in modern times.

This book will inform you, amaze you, shock you and give you great comfort.

In this book I’ve covered many exciting issues from stewardship of nature, to environment and health, to terrible man-made tragedies.

I’ve covered the interesting subject: “Do pets go to heaven?” and some indictments on hunters and Christian hunters in particular

I’ve covered the full circle of the perfect pre-Adamic creation, through the fall of man and curse on nature, to the liberation of nature and its complete return to perfection.

I’ve looked into “Glimpses of the future” and the terrible regret of the unsaved.

The book ends off with a collection of my own photographs and art works.

This ministry has a distinct kingdom vision, identifying with God’s call and plan for Israel and the church. My position is pre-trib! I was saved in 1976 while working as a war correspondent, journalist, photographer, artist and environmentalist. My calling is to share with you the great end-time dramas, to stand as a watchman and above all, to glorify my God.

►We have now reached 46 million regular visitors.

►Next Edition, Lord willing: "Rapture Reverberations"

Next on the prophetic agenda will be Israel, again thrust into the limelight and crosshairs! Annexation of Judea and Samaria on July 1st is a “hard deadline” – Netanyahu.

Riots / insurrections worldwide are being seen and believed to be orchestrated by a central force and financier. (Soros) But it is the force of pure evil that is at work. It’s the devil’s coup attempt! (Psalm 2:1-4)

US jobs report smashes expectations positively. US markets close to all time record highs, with more to come. (Markets are forward looking.)

►Regular readers of The Prophetic Scroll are hereby informed that this Covid19 virus will not come near you. I and my prayer team are praying this as a specific prayer of protection over you.

These will change on Sundays or as the Lord leads.

This verse, below was given to me by our Lord in December last year to give to you as the crowning verse for 2020. This was just before the corona-virus became a world pandemic:

The heading is, “Babylon humiliated.” End-time Babylon is the modern world system:

Isaiah 47:10-11 “You have trusted in your wickedness. You have said, ‘No one sees me.’ Your wisdom and your knowledge have warped you; You have said in your heart, ‘I am, and there is no one besides me.’ Therefore evil shall come upon you and you shall not know from where it arises, and trouble shall fall upon you. You will not be able to put it off, and desolation shall come upon you suddenly.”

__________________________

Proverbs 24:21 (Amp) “My son, reverently fear the Lord and king, and do not associate with those given to changing allegiances and revolution.”

Proverbs 28:28 (Amp) “When the wicked arise, men hide themselves; but when they perish, the constantly righteous increase and become many.”

Proverbs 28:2 (Amp) “When a land transgresses, it has many rulers; but when the ruler is a man of discernment, understanding and knowledge, its stability will last long.”

Psalm 9:17 (Amp) “The wicked shall be turned back into premature death, into Sheol (hell), even all the nations that forget God.”

Psalm 120:7 “I am for peace, but when I speak, they are for war.”

Shabbat (Sabbath) begins on Fridays at 6pm and ends on Saturdays at 6pm. The purpose of this report is to help the church and Israel become reconciled in Messiah.

5th June 2020

Shabbat Shalom to all!

Why and when God judges:

But first: What’s happening now is the attempted overthrow of God, His authority structures and the creation of the new world order system of false gods, idols, icons and release of hosts of demons.

The world is redefining God and His word to their standards and values, but it is the standards and values of Satan, their unseen god.

Here is a profound verse which I am applying to the current riots and upheavals:

Isaiah 59:6-8 (Separated from God) “...Their works are works of iniquity, and violence is in their hands. Their feet run to evil, and they make haste to shed innocent blood. Their thoughts are thoughts of iniquity; wasting and destruction are in their paths. The way of peace they have not known, and there is no justice in their ways. They have made themselves crooked paths; whoever takes that way shall not know peace.”

I have spoken a lot lately about where we are on the prophetic clock and what is happening now and why. I’ve used the analogy of the forerunners of the four runners of the apocalypse. We are not in the tribulation period yet, but in the time of birth-pangs and forerunners.

The big judgements upon the world of the tribulation period are seen in the events brought onto the stage by the four riders of the apocalypse.

But now I would like to look into the reasons for the big judgements of the tribulation, which are obviously the same reasons for the troubles being brought on now in the form of forerunners.

Big historic judgements of God:

The big judgements from God in the Old Covenant were for these reasons:

●Molech the evil god of child sacrifice: This god was worshipped by the offering of infants, including those from abortions as a sacrifice in fires under his outstretched bronze hands. This occurred in the Valley of the son of Hinnom, (Gehenna). The place became known as cursed for these murders. Today it is still believed to be cursed. (Jeremiah 32:34-35, 2 Kings 23:10) Gehenna is identified with Armageddon.

●Noah: The world then was destroyed by flood for rampant sin, including homosexuality, complacency in the face of predicted judgement, and mocking of judgement to come.

●Sodom & Gomorra: These cities were destroyed by fire for persistent, aggressive homosexuality and refusal to repent.

●Babylon & Babel: Babylon and the tower of Babel were destroyed by God for rampant sin, humanistic unity, false religion, and trying to reach God and be like Him, – man’s way. “Babylon was never to rise again.” (Jeremiah 51:64, Isaiah 13:20) But end-time Babylon is here again, as revealed in many verses. It is NOT the original city. It is now the end-time world system. End-time Babylon has its religion Catholicism and similar orthodox beliefs. The true church is commanded to “flee from Babylon.” (Jeremiah 51: 6-9, and Revelation 17&18)

●Jericho: Was destroyed for rampant sin, and for obstructing the children of Israel on their journey to the Promised Land.

Here are the reasons collectively: ●Rampant unrepentant sin and wickedness. ● Homosexuality which today includes the redefining of God’s institution of marriage and family. ●Abortion. ●Complacency in the face of coming judgement. ●Mocking God’s ways and coming judgement. ●Humanism which includes the philosophy of “I am,” and there is no other. ●False religion of all sorts. ●Coming against Israel.

Here’s the big question: Do you see these sins in the world today? Do you see the world repenting of these things?

Let’s be clear on one thing. The world will not repent, because that’s what the Bible shows. But many individuals in the world will and are repenting even now.

Do you see how difficult it is for the world to repent? These sins have become so normalised and entrenched in modern society that they have become a human right! And even some deceived churches are supporting these judgment-bringing sins!

The gradual normalisation of sin has been done mainly by the mass-media.

So, the four riders of the apocalypse are ready to ride, for the above reasons. When they do, they will race swiftly onto the stage – suddenly!

Because of unrepentant, continuing and worsening sin, God has blinded the minds of the unbeliever and Satan has blinded their minds to the salvation of God.

Matthew 11:25 “I thank You Father Lord of heaven and earth because you have hidden these things from the wise (in self) and prudent, and have revealed them to babes.”

The sin of obstructing Israel:

►But first: Interestingly the organisation “Black Lives Matter (BLM) contains a foundational document rejecting the right of the Jews to their homeland and other anti-Semitic statements.

●Why did God destroy nations and kingdoms that came against the children of Israel, and those that attacked Jerusalem in the Old Covenant?

●Why did God not destroy the nations that divided Israel and Jerusalem in the days since the cross? (For example Jordan, Turks, Britain).

●Why did God not destroy Germany after the Holocaust?

●Why has God not destroyed the many churches including the Catholic church that formed, promoted and practise replacement theology, which is simply the theology of dividing Israel and Jerusalem?

It is because we are in the church age of grace and the longsuffering of God. (2Peter 3:9, Acts 17:30) This is the era of God overlooking these things. (Read those two verses).

But woe to them all when the age of grace ends and the world returns to the Old Covenant ways of doing things. God’s severe, immediate, demonstrative judgement is the main characteristic of the tribulation.

The main verse used by many against dividing Jerusalem is Joel 3:2. But this occurs in the tribulation period if you read the surrounding context. That is not in the church age, but the next dispensation, the seven year tribulation or closing of the Old Covenant.

If this is the case, which I challenge anyone to dispute, then, the current virus troubles and riots are not because the US divided Israel or Jerusalem, which it did not do anyway.

If you recall, I applied the key of David, which no one can remove, to President Trump for his biblical moves on Jerusalem. (Revelation 3:7, Isaiah 22:22) He still holds that key! The world is trying its damndest to get the key out of his hands!

I have mentioned this many times but it bears repeating. The next big thing on the prophetic agenda is war. It will be war against Israel and in the Middle East, as the war-rider rides out of the starting gates.

►►►Jeremiah 4:19 “O my soul, my soul! I am pained in my very heart. My heart makes a noise in me; I cannot hold my peace, because you, O my soul, have heard the sound of the trumpet, the alarm of war.”

Peace? Hah!

Once the four riders race out of the starting gates, the world will cry for peace, but this is what they will get:

Revelation 6:4 “Another horse, fiery red went out. And it was granted to the one who sat on it to take peace from the earth and that people should kill one another, and there was given to him a great sword.”

Do you see why it’s not a good idea to go to the races?

It is of utmost importance to know what is going on behind the scenes in all these things.

My friends, true deep, glorious peace and rest is only for the true believer, going deep with the things of God!

Edition 198

►In this edition, apart from the main subject, I will also share with you some interesting new developments and factors about the coming peace treaty, (Daniel 9:27)

Due to the current situation in the Ukraine, I feel it’s necessary to have another look at the war of Gog and Magog, also referred to as World War Three (WW111), which is found primarily in Ezekiel 38 & 39. It is also inferred in a few other places in the Bible.

I have shared on this war in numerous editions, but right now things are heating up and the stage is being set. Yes the current situation may fizzle out, that’s okay...the lessons still stand as I haven’t shared much of this material before.

The current Ukraine /Russia situation has nothing to do with Israel, and WW111 has everything to do with Israel, so are we barking up the wrong tree?

No not at all!

If the current situation does develop into WW111, Israel is in the wings awaiting her entrance onto the stage.

How the Ukraine situation may play out.

Can Russia cripple the US without firing a shot? Russia could easily crash the US financial system by dumping the billions of dollars worth of treasury bonds which they hold. Nations outside of the US hold some $16 trillion in liquid assets, which could be turned into a weapon against the dollar very quickly.

The US economy is only as strong as international confidence is. When your economy is built on such enormous debt, it is like a house of cards and can come down on a simple shift in sentiment.

The US and some European nations are talking of sanctions against Russia. This would infuriate the “bear.”

The dollar is already out of favour with China, Russia and others. It would take a light squeeze on the trigger to create dollar- selling and an economic collapse in the US. So Russia in fact does have a powerful weapon in this regard.

In 2008 the US saw the biggest financial crisis in a long time. The Fed came in to save the system, but the hang-over is a slow fragile recovery. Any new or similar financial catastrophe now would again bring the Fed in, but the results would end up being hyperinflation and a crashing economy.

One thing we must be aware of is that these things can happen very quickly.

Few people are aware that there is a large Jewish population in Ukraine. They are under threat right now as neo-Nazi groups gain strength. This may be one of the issues that brings Israel into the picture.

The name Ukraine means, “The edge”.

Right now Russia’s state owned Gazprom, an enormous oil and gas company, is close to bankruptcy. European nations are amongst Gazprom’s biggest customers. Russia gets 40% of its gas-revenue from Europe. Gazprom charges Europe a premium two and a half times more than US gas.

Some of the gas pipelines run through Ukraine. Ukraine is also a strategic nation in that it offers Russia an entrance to the Black Sea and through a small channel into the Mediterranean and Israel.

Many people in Ukraine want to become part of Europe and many want to return to the fold of Russia. If Russia cuts off gas to Europe, as she has threatened to do, it would put extra economic pressure on Gazprom and “ignite” the situation further. Russia has used oil-supply as blackmail before. In 2009 Gazprom shut off oil supply to Ukraine. Coming trade sanctions against Russia will corner Putin.

Russia desperately wants to keep these lines of commerce open especially now that a big, new threat to its dominance of oil and gas supply in the region has emerged from Israel. Europe is a huge consumer of natural gas and Israel is now making inroads into this.

Enter Israel and its Leviathan! 100 trillion cubic feet of gas and some oil fields were recently discovered off the Israeli coast. The two main fields are called Leviathan and Tamar. A few months ago production and sales began.

Israel is a small consumer of gas leaving the majority of its production available for export. Numerous new contracts have already been signed between Israel and Europe, severely cutting into Russia’s dominance of the market.

Gas and oil prices will go higher in the face of trade sanctions against Russia from the West. The Russian stock market crashed by 12% the day the Ukraine crisis began, and their currency, the rouble, has fallen dramatically.

Analysts are now calling Russia’s GDP down from 2.6% to 1%. That’s a very big fall for GDP in one move and all due to the Ukraine crisis.

These factors combined are going to put enormous pressure on Putin. But he is notorious for not handling pressure well. In fact he has many characteristics of a psychopath!

There are rumours floating around that Russia is bankrolling the environmental lobby to slow down the oil-fraking process in the US and other nations, so that Russia can keep its oil and gas dominance.

The culmination of conflict could see the US become a more significant ally of Europe. If Russia swallows up Ukraine we would end up with the players perfectly aligned for the great war of Gog and Magog in Ezekiel 38 &39. This would identify more clearly the “young lions” and the allies of Israel in WW111 on the one hand and the great bear (Russia) on the other.

All of this could speed up the formation of the final Roman Empire of the book of Daniel.

The timing of this crisis is not coincidental. If we are heading for a tribulation start later this year or even next year, the Gog and Magog war must occur first. We are also awaiting the Isaiah 17 war in which Syria is completely destroyed, which also needs to occur before the tribulation begins.

Bear in mind that Russia has interests in keeping Assad in power in Syria.

Today as I write, I am hearing I am being given news of a US / Israeli offensive soon to be launched against Assad’s Syria. This would bring in Iran and Saudi Arabia!

China is in the wings very much on the side of Russia, Syria, Iran and others of similar persuasion.

Key factors of WW111:

Please read Ezekiel 38& 39 yourselves and familiarise yourself with these two dramatic chapters, which are very soon to unfold before us. What follows are the main points from those two chapters:

●The main players will have “hooks” in their jaws drawing them into the conflict. ●Horsemen, with spears, shields and bucklers, is all the prophet was familiar with. In our day this would be all the modern weapons of warfare. ●The war will occur in the “latter days”. ●It will occur in “Israel which had long been desolate.” ●They (Israel) were brought out of the nations and now dwell safely. ●The enemies attacking will “ascend coming like a storm, covering the land like a cloud.” This could be air forces. ●They will go up against a land of “unwalled villages.” They will attack a peaceful people, dwelling safely without walls”. ●They will attack and come to “take great plunder, spoil, livestock, goods, silver and gold”. ●The attackers will come from the “far north”, with Muslim allies. ●It will occur so that the nations may “know Me when I am hallowed in you (Israel).” ●The “fury, wrath and fire of God will show in His face” against Israel’s attackers. ●There shall be a “great earthquake” in the land of Israel at that time. God will bring the attackers to judgment with “bloodshed, great hailstones, flooding rain, fire and brimstone.” ●Those who live in Israel will “burn the weapons for seven years”. “Seven months” will be required to cleanse the contaminated land. They will set up a “marker” next to the dead bodies after the seven months land-cleansing, so that the buriers can do their job. ●This will be done in a place to be called “The valley of Hamon Gog.” ●All the nations shall see the judgement of God. God will have mercy on the whole house of Israel after they have borne their guilt. He will “pour out His Spirit on Israel.” (Jews).

Interestingly the “Valley of Hamon Gog” mentioned in Ezekiel 39:11 means the “hordes” of Gog and refers to a valley which will be the burial place for the hordes killed in the war.

Hooks

Ezekiel 38:4 “I will turn you around, put hooks in your jaws and lead you out, with all your army, horses and horsemen, all splendidly clothed, a great company with bucklers and shields, all of them handling swords.”

The original Hebrew word translated “hooks” is the word “chach” meaning: “hook as in nose ring.” A great big bull can have a rope tied to its nose-ring and be drawn around easily because it’s too sore to pull away. This is also a common method used to tame and subdue big beasts. It implies being dominated or controlled by an outside force without much option.

This entire prophetic war looks like it should be part of the tribulation period. It does fit in with many descriptions in the Revelation. But there are also some key factors placing the war before the tribulation.

The breakdown:

Let’s break this war down and see what we come up with.

It will be an end-time war, which has not yet occurred. The chief attackers will be Russia and a number of Muslim states in southern Russia. The nations of the West (young lions) will come to Israel’s defence. It will involve land- based and air- based military forces. Israel will be in some sort of peaceful state at the time. (Israel is in a much more peaceful state now than in previous history.) The cause of the war will be to take “plunder and spoil” which would perhaps be oil, gas and agricultural riches of which Israel is well stocked.

The war will coincide with salvation flowing to the Jews in large numbers. (Ezekiel 39:7) This actually begins in chapter 37 of Ezekiel, the well known “dry bones” prophecy.

It may be a nuclear war. The description of the aftermath implies that something horrific has happened to the dead bodies, making them untouchable for seven months.

The war does not last seven years as many say. The cleaning up events last seven months for the initial decontamination process (Ezekiel 39:12), and then seven years for the complete cleaning process. But the war itself may be very short in time.

It is unlikely that it will occur in the tribulation period, because then the seven year cleaning up would run into the Millennium.

It is quite possible that the war occurs during or close to the war of Isaiah 17, in which Damascus, Syria is destroyed.

The victors:

Ezekiel 39:2-3 “I will knock the bow out of your left hand and cause the arrows to fall out of your right hand. You shall fall upon the mountains of Israel, you and all your troops and the peoples who are with you.”

One of the reasons why this great war is not Armageddon is because the participants are different and the outcome is different. Armageddon involves all the nations of the world and is ended by the Second Coming of our Lord.

The Ezekiel war ends with Israel being the victor after huge losses. It appears that the “young lions” which are the commonwealth nations also survive as victors, but also with great losses. (For more on the identity of the nations involved see edition 74).

The US may be greatly weakened, but will not be destroyed in this war.

Why is this important now?

I have decided to do this edition now, because the current situation may develop quickly into the war of Gog and Magog and other wars in prophecy.

There are so many other prophetic events all dovetailing together at the same time.

It is possible that this all fizzles out and we have to wait. That’s highly unlikely because a lot of things have to fizzle together.

We can’t be sure of dates and the sequence of events, but I sense a freight train rumbling down the tracks.

The peace treaty:

Deuteronomy 27:17 “Cursed is the one who moves his neighbour’s landmark. And all the people shall say, amen!”

The current peace talks and process are essentially all about land for peace. It is about dividing the land of Israel. Joel 3:2,Zechariah 12:3 and other verses bring out the fact that dividing the land brings war and not peace.

The nations of the world have the audacity to think that they can change God’s word on this issue! Israel itself will be brought into the land for peace delusion and fall for it to her own regret.

►If the great war of Gog and Magog takes place very soon; it just may be an extra reason for the cry for peace, and be a catalyst to the dreadful day the peace covenant is confirmed, starting the tribulation period.

Daniel 9:27 “Then he shall confirm a covenant with many for one week (of years)...”

Some believe that the current peace negotiations are not part of the Daniel 9:27 peace treaty, because they say that the Daniel peace covenant could easily be one of the previous peace agreements / talks, which were never completed.

That may be so, but let’s see what the Bible has to say.

The original word used for “confirm” a covenant, is insightful:

“Confirm”: Strongs, H1396 = ‘gabar.’ This word means to make strong and mighty, to give strength to, to bind up that which is broken, to act proudly towards God.

“Confirm the covenant” does not mean a pre-existing one, eg Oslo. The word “confirm” means to secure it. That simply means to sign it, or ratify it. That does not mean it must be a pre-existing treaty. When all the negotiations are said and done, they sign or ratify the work. We could accurately say this: “He shall sign the covenant with many for one week of years. In the midst of it he shall cause the sacrifice and oblation to cease...” (Daniel 9:27)

The news on this developing peace treaty or covenant is changing fast. It has broken down, and been put back together again. I would not put too much emphasis on the public utterances of the Palestinians.

Right now the news is that the Palestinians will not recognise Israel as a Jewish state. There’s nothing new about this, but then just a while back they also said that they will. So, confusion reigns.

The Palestinians have now just said that they will not recognise a Jewish state ever. Actually, recognition of the Jewish state may not be a prerequisite for the peace deal anyway, but we wait and watch.

I keep coming back to one big thing and that is the timing of these peace talks. I have said numerous times before that the tribulation period begins and is kicked off by the signing of a peace covenant. Is it all a coincidence? It may be, but I doubt it because of all the other things lining up.

What you must do:

●Know how these things will play out! Know what is knowable from the scriptures. The most valuable thing you can ever do is know your Bible through the leading of its Author in your heart.

●Shake off the trappings that hinder your growth in our Lord and your love for Him.

●Watch, pray and be ready, but do not jump the gun!

Finally:

The world is staring down the barrel of a nuclear gun! We don’t know the exact timing of these events and we don’t know the exact sequence, but be very sure they will occur - and very soon! Right now we are in the calm before the storm.

If this lot does develop into the Ezekiel war very soon, are you right with God? You had better be, because time will be very short!

Deuteronomy 31:6 “Be strong and of good courage, do not fear nor be afraid, for the Lord your God is the one who goes with you. He will never leave you nor forsake you.”

Ezekiel 37:12 “Behold O My people, I will open your graves and cause you to come up from your graves and bring you into the land of Israel.”

Psalm 46:10 “Be still and know that I am God; I will be exalted among the nation, I will be exalted in all the earth.”

I took this picture in a beautiful tropical forest. It speaks of calm and quiet – which is what we all have in our hearts even if we don’t see it now.