Pages

4/16/14

What I learned from a 400 year old book on how to kill a man.

You
follow the rules of war for you -- not your enemy. You fight by rules to keep
your humanity.

Franz Stigler

For
many years I have studied Martial Arts and traditional weapons, from the
practical self-defense and combat oriented aspect to the historical and
theoretical point of view. Man has turned killing into an art form and a
science as important to their development as literature or architecture. In
some cultures it was actually fashionable to carry weapons while others limited
their access to only a select few as a status symbol.

Every
time I hear about the debated over right
to bear arms, open- carry, and
how this dissuades violence, I am reminded of the Renaissance, were all
gentlemen would have a dress sword as part of their attire. Can you guess how
men would solve most conflicts at that time? Duels, lots of them. Dueling
became so popular that it actually became a problem for the Church and State of
the time, forcing them to make such act illegal. Basically, if you lost the
Duel, you’re probably dead. If you won, you go to jail. And even then, dueling
didn’t stop.

It
was during this time, where Dueling was at its most popular, that killing
science of “La Verdadera Destreza” was developed by Jerónimo Sánchez de
Carranza. Liberally translated into English as “The True Skill” but most commonly
known as “The Spanish Circle”, Destreza is a universal method of fighting, based
on reason, geometry, and incorporate various other aspects from your typical
Renaissance humanist education. Defined as “the art of
killing an opponent when he wants to die”, Destreza focused on positioning yourself for a killing blow while
avoiding placing yourself in harm’s way. It is the reason why so many people
feared the Conquistadors, why Inigo Montoya was written as a Spaniard, and why
the Gun
Kata is plausible.

The
treatise was divided into four Dialogues. The first three are the technical
breakdowns of the Art, focusing on the basic concepts, understanding how traditional
fencing works, and the applications of these advanced technics. These have been
the source of intense study and analysis by the fencing community, specially
the first and the third Dialogue. But it was the fourth book that caught my attention,
the ethics of the Diestro, the skilled man.

It
talks about the moral responsibility of the skilled swordsman, focusing on how
the Diestro can avoid committing aggressions, treachery, and, most importantly,
getting killed. It elaborates on the He has the obligation to help himself, his
friends, and his enemies. Yes, you read that right, his enemies. These are some
of the moral and ethical lessons taught within the same manual that details the
Spanish Kiss, attack aimed at serving a person’s spinal cord by thrusting your
sword into an opponent’s mouth.

All life is valuable. The Diestro sees life
as a gift that must not be squandered on petty vanity or on simple arguments.
He understands that from every fight and every conflict, someone will die. He
must ask himself if he is willing to die at that moment? Is he willing to kill?
He becomes aware of the reality that every time he draws his sword, he has the
full intention to kill someone and is giving the other person permission to
kill him. This attitude, instead of making life cheap, turns life into a valuable
gift that must be appreciated. You never know when you will draw your last
breath, or go to jail for taking a life.

Risk yourself foolishly
is the same as suicide. You only have one life to enjoy. Risking it foolishly or
brandishing your weapon at any challenge is the same as asking to be killed.
And dying because of stupidity is little more than suicide.

Defending yourself is
right. Attacking isn't. There is a very thin line between defense and attack, especially
when we are always force-fed the phrase “the best defense is a good offense.” You
have the right to defend your life when it is in genuine danger. Actively
looking to attack a possible aggressor is the same as becoming an aggressor
yourself. You have the right to defend yourself with force similar to scale to
the attack. A full blown assault for a minor offense is no longer defense; it
was looking for an excuse to attack.

No material possession
is worth killing over or dying over. So they stole you watch or your wallet. Is it
more valuable than your life? Is it as irreplaceable as a life, any life? Killing
someone just to keep them from stealing something is still murder. Material
possessions can be replaced or recovered, a life cannot.

Vengeance is not
justice.
If you openly seek to “get even” because someone caused you wrong, you are
openly planning murder. The problem is that you become what you hate. What
keeps them from continuing the chain going? You got even. You might think it is
justified. But now it’s their turn to get even with you. Killing someone for
any reason other than self-defense is always murder.

Let the law handle the
unjust.
The authorities are the ones in charge of administering justice. Vigilantism is
little more than Vengeance in disguise. If you chose to handle it yourself, it’s
then YOU who the authorities will be after. We live in a society ruled by laws
and order. We can’t complain about chaos and disorder if we are part of the
problem.

Think and control
yourself. You are not a beast who lives out of reaction. We are rational beings
with full control of our emotions. We are the result of thousands of years of
evolution as a society and as a species. ACT LIKE IT. Attacking as a reaction
to something is the acts of a savage animal.

Club Men

--Copyright Notice--

Unauthorized use and/or duplication of this material without express and written permission from this blog’s author and/or owner is strictly prohibited. Excerpts and links may be used, provided that full and clear credit is given to Being Caballero with appropriate and specific direction to the original content.

Logo and quotes are the exclusive property of Being Caballero and are protected under the United States and International Copyright laws. The logo may not be reproduced, copied, transmitted or manipulated without the written permission of Eduardo García, Being Caballero.