Why does Labour find sado-masochism so appealing?

It is astonishing that sado-masochism, so beloved of the English upper classes in their sexual antics, is so infectious in the Labour Party, albeit in a very different context. There seems to be an obsession in some sections of the party that once the Tories go down the route of self-destructive austerity, we must at least match them or even preferably out-austerity them – self-flagellation in true Lutheran style – in order to prove our ‘credibility’ or to display ‘realism’.

The Guardian, or at least the Blairite wing of its political journalists, is intent on pursuing this line for all they’re worth, whilst giving no coverage whatever to the alternative view which makes much more sense. Now we’re told that Gavin Kelly, chief exec of the reputable Resolution Foundation, is saying Labour must face the facts on future spending. To that I say, bring it on. Let’s start by looking at the true picture.

The whole debate is conducted, unquestioningly, on the basis that there’s no money available – it’s all just a matter of how much spending is cut and where. Now nobody is suggesting that all public spending should be automatically protected and no cuts be made at all: of course it’s sensible continually to review public expenditure regularly to make sure it’s all providing the best value for money, and if not, either cut it or spend it differently. But that’s completely different from making slashing cuts when there are far better economic alternatives available.

It’s really bizarre that such a consensus about huge blanket cuts has been rigged up as though three crucial facts didn’t exist. One is that the government is spending £8-10bn keeping every million persons on the dole – that’s about £23.75bn a year keeping the present 2.64 million persons unemployed. That is not a sensible way of spending public money. The same amount of money, no borrowing, should be used to fund their employment building houses which are desperately needed, improving transport and energy infrastructure, and starting to build the green economy.

Second, the government is about to print another £75bn in so-called credit easing and giving it to the banks or big corporations. That is also not a good way of spending money when much of it, or even most of it, will end up in offshore speculation or tax havens. Far better for the government itself directly to use £20bn of that (or more) creating a million jobs in the priority sectors above.

Third, the 1,000 wealthiest super-rich (just 1,000 persons, only 0.003% of the population!) according to the Rich List have increased their wealth since 1997 by £296bn, enough to pay off the entire budget deficit twice over. How about a wealth tax on these lucky persons who’ve made such colossal gains at the expense of the rest of us, which could well raise £50bn over the next 5 years? A rather better way of conducting the public accounts than slashing the budgets for the NHS, schools and universities, housing, social welfare, and benefits for the disabled.

One Comment

My initial concern about the sado-masochism references was relieved when I read Larry Elliott’s view that “the language of S&M is also now part of the eurozone discourse” – see “Angela Merkel has the whip hand in an orgy of austerity“. Good piece – worth a read. And so at least we know what flavour alternative strategy we’re seeking. Vanilla.

Are there any patterns in the CLP nominations so far? | LabourListLuke Akehurst's analysis concludes "Corbyn’s lead may be stronger than the raw nomination figures suggest, that the gap between Burnham and Cooper may be a bit smaller, and that Kendall whilst still in a weak fourth place is doing a bit better and her transfers may have a critical impact on the outcome – they could easily put Cooper ahead of Burnham"

Subscribe!

On Facebook

By Sergio Cesaratto The victory of ‘no’ opens two scenarios. The most likely is the further effort by the Syriza-led government to reach a new agreement with the Troika, but it is not clear why it should be given something that had not been given before. The financial upheaval of recent days may be such as […]

Italy’s Five Star Movement, which has campaigned for a referendum on the Euro, is in Athens today to support the Syriza government. Interview with Italian MP Alessandro Di Battista of the Five Star movement, who is participating in the delegation led by party leader Beppe Grillo. By Giacomo Russo Spena Top Quotes: Today’s referendum: “It is […]

What image will remain in the European Union in the wake of the Greek crisis? Indeed, whatever the outcome of this crisis, whether it results in a Greek default and a possible exit from the euro zone, or a capitulation of the Greek government, the consequences of this crisis on the EU and its image […]

Barcelona’s new radical mayor-elect has signalled her determination to secure a fair deal for exploited Telefonica-Movistar workers by threatening to curtail the company’s contract with the City to put pressure the company in its labour dispute. Outgoing mayor Xavier Triasa aimed to prolong the contract between the operator and the City Council for another year until July 2016, but that is now […]

In the past seven days we have been given a glimpse into what could lie ahead in our true blue Tory future. This is a government not content with simply demolishing the welfare state but seemingly hell bent on eradicating meaningful democracy itself.

Yesterday in Prime Minister’s Question Time, David Cameron proudly claimed that the Tories are the Party who are “standing up for working people”. Under normal circumstances, this would be enough to make us on the Labour benches in the House of Commons and working people across the country despair, but yesterday it just served […]

A technicality it may be, but today has seen the first unfettered Conservative budget of the twenty first century, the first for almost two decades. All illusions the True Blue Tory party have changed, that they are compassionate, have been shattered. The mask has not slipped it has been torn off and thrown into the […]

This week I didn't behave well. Really bad in fact. I mean I slow clapped the home secretary as she headed for her lobby. I then followed it with, what I will call a robust exchange, with the minister for women and equalities Nicky Morgan across the chamber.

On Saturday, I was proud to march alongside friends, family and hundreds of thousands of other people - trade unionists, campaigners, celebrities and activists - all united in their determination to voice their anger at the Tory Government’s austerity agenda.

About Left Futures

Meta

Left Futures

Left Futures is a new Labour Left network. If you want to get involved as a contributor, please contact Jon Lansman using the form on this page.
Header images: Wind farm [credit]. Balloons [credit] and crowd scene [credit]. Labour Conference pics [credit].