Welcome to the Piano World Piano ForumsOver 2 million posts about pianos, digital pianos, and all types of keyboard instruments
Join the World's Largest Community of Piano Lovers
(it's free)
It's Fun to Play the Piano ... Please Pass It On!

I have always loved organ music over piano and it seems the organkeeps,...and holds,...my interest more so than the piano. Havingsaid that,my question would be this,...is it possible to start right out on organ even if a person has never had experience onpiano first? I have been told yes and it would take a bit longerdue to the fact you would have to learn the bass pedals. That is okay with me. I have always wanted to learn to play organ,but inthe past,...money was always an issue it seemed,...and space! IfI were to find a nice used Hammond A-100,for example,...would that be a good organ to learn on?

It all depends on what sort of organ music that holds your interest - i.e., pop-rock, gospel, jazz or classical? Regardless, a good knowledge of music theory is essential.

In regards to classical organ specifically, Harold Gleason's Method of Organ Playing states that an organists should have a good basis in Bach's Preludes, 2 & 3 Part Inventions, and French Suites played on the piano before progressing to the organ, (the same can be said for playing fugues on the piano as well).

Jazz/gospel pedaling is a totally different beast than classical organ with completely different techniques corresponding to the different purposes of the pedal in those sorts of music. Using a truncated pedal board (or even a lack of pedals) may be sufficient in rock/pop organ, as the music of ELP, The Doors & Led Zeppelin will attest.

The A-100 is a sweet organ, more suited to jazz/gospel with its flat rather than AGO pedal board, although classical can certainly be played on it.

I am after more of a pipe organ sound than I am the gospel sound of a Hammomd. I only used the A-100 as an example,soI would apologize for any confusion I may have caused. Iwould like to find an older,but well cared for,Allen organthat has the speakers inside the console. On a youtube videoclip I seen an Allen MDS-5 organ that was being demonstrated.The organ was made in the early 1990's. This is pretty much what I have in mind. A newer version of that organ would be an Allen R230 Renaissance organ also with self contained speakers since space would be at a premium. I am drawn to Allen organs for their quality of sound and dependability,as well as parts availability should a part fail for whateverreason. Kinda hard to get parts for an old Hammond tone wheel organ anymore from what I hear. I just want to learn to play hymns is all ,but I want pipe organ sound

Actually, I have an easier time getting parts for those old tonewheel organs than anything else I've ever worked on.

I've seen many organs from the 80's on up that use specialized chips that are no longer made and you can't get anywhere. That really scares me about the newer stuff. The tonewheel vintage stuff used generic parts that you can get in any electronics supply house. But what's going to happen with an organ someone buys today brand new? I honestly wonder if the specialized parts (chips) will be out there, because there are a lot used that are proprietary.

I think it is possible, however a lot more challenging than beginning on Piano; with the Organ there is a lot more to learn, not just with regards to pedalling but also stop combinations, the flat hand technique, geography of 2+ manuals etc... I would recommend going for at least Grade 4 Piano before seriously starting on the Organ, however if you are really determined perhaps it would be best to start on the instrument of your choice so you are more eager to practice?Speaking of practice, another small niggle of being an Organist is finding a decent instrument to practice on, I prefer to go straight in on the full blown church Pipe Organ than to use an electric, for the simple reason that, although electric keys are 'realistic', as an organist you will often find yourself playing non-electrified Pipe Organs, which have a unique touch and can be daunting for a first-time recital if you haven't used them before (trust me, my first proper organ recital was on one of these, it's a completely different kettle of fish - the keys are somewhere between those of a Harpsichord and a Piano in that they're stiff but generally don't have the 'ping' of a Harpsi. - in contrast, the keys of an electrified Pipe Organ are incredibly similar to those of a fully electric arranger keyboard).Finding a church with a suitable Organ can often be difficult, and you can't just walk in and play... The best way to go about it is to visit churches in your local area and talk to the choir masters/Organists, they will usually be happy for you to practice on the instrument so long as you show a degree of respect and at least some knowledge of the keyboard. Once you have a church to practice in, be vigilant that people may well come in and out whilst you are playing, and therefore you will have to get used to having company whilst you practice... When I play the church organ people often stop and watch/listen, something which, when I was a beginner (and therefore adept at making mistakes), found incredibly disconcerting. In the end it will boil down to your determination to play the Organ versus the practicality of playing the Piano, but ultimately it's your choice - the last thing I want to do is discourage you from learning what is, after all, the King of Instruments!