I agree with Ohyoupokedme. I think it's likely that he's The Boy Who Cried Wolf, and the fact that he's everywhere makes him suspicious. But we have no established motive and there is no proof that he carried out any murders. Suspicious doesn't equal guilty. I'm hoping that we get to actually talk to this character soon. Only one episode out of 5 so far, I'm sure that there will be plenty more twists and turns. Maybe we've figured out his identity, but I think the case is still wide open.

Maybe his motive is to fuck with Bigby, after eating him and all. He seems to make Crane fucking despise him, as the title card for episode three shows, where Beauty is trailing Bigby while she holds a gun and wears a badge that reads: "Fabletown Police."

Well, I'm pretty sure that the girl is not Beauty. She's wearing an NYPD badge. But, my thought is, why would he mess with Bigby now? Fabletown has existed since the days when New York was New Amsterdam. Bigby and the other fables have been in the mundane world for around 400 years. Why, after so many centuries, would he choose now to try to mess up his life?

Maybe his motive is to fuck with Bigby, after eating him and all. He seems to make Crane fucking despise him, as the title card for … moreepisode three shows, where Beauty is trailing Bigby while she holds a gun and wears a badge that reads: "Fabletown Police."

Well, I'm pretty sure that the girl is not Beauty. She's wearing an NYPD badge. But, my thought is, why would he mess with Bigby now… more? Fabletown has existed since the days when New York was New Amsterdam. Bigby and the other fables have been in the mundane world for around 400 years. Why, after so many centuries, would he choose now to try to mess up his life?

Hell, for all we know, he could actually be helping Bigby in some way. If Telltale knew their audience, then they would know better than to reveal the killer in the first episode. He may be involved, but the killer? I doubt that.

I agree with Ohyoupokedme. I think it's likely that he's The Boy Who Cried Wolf, and the fact that he's everywhere makes him suspici… moreous. But we have no established motive and there is no proof that he carried out any murders. Suspicious doesn't equal guilty. I'm hoping that we get to actually talk to this character soon. Only one episode out of 5 so far, I'm sure that there will be plenty more twists and turns. Maybe we've figured out his identity, but I think the case is still wide open.

This guy is definitely implicated in the plot in some way I think we can all agree on that.However it is still way too early to confirm the identity of the killer, we haven't even played the second episode yet.This is a noir thriller, I expect at least a few red herrings before we find the real culprit.

She's not wearing an NYPD badge, unless the whole city started going by Fabletown, which, given the historical roots of the name, is not likely. Anyways, to answer your question, why not? Maybe he was too poor before to even get food on his table. Maybe he didn't hate Bigby quite as much yet. All the business with Snow White might have been what set him off. And he decided to go after someone that he hated more than the rest of them, Bigby.

Well, I'm pretty sure that the girl is not Beauty. She's wearing an NYPD badge. But, my thought is, why would he mess with Bigby now… more? Fabletown has existed since the days when New York was New Amsterdam. Bigby and the other fables have been in the mundane world for around 400 years. Why, after so many centuries, would he choose now to try to mess up his life?

Anyway, interesting thoughts as far as why he'd mess with Bigby now. We do know that since Fables are near immortals they have very long memories and tend to hold grudges (Colin said as much in the game). But, why would he kill Faith then? It's not like she meant very much to Bigby. Not that we know of, anyway. And if he did do all of this because he was poor and disenfranchised, why not go after the rich fables? Why a fable who had fallen on hard times like Faith? Anyway, I don't really know what to think. Just throwing some ideas around, playing Devil's Advocate.

She's not wearing an NYPD badge, unless the whole city started going by Fabletown, which, given the historical roots of the name, is… more not likely. Anyways, to answer your question, why not? Maybe he was too poor before to even get food on his table. Maybe he didn't hate Bigby quite as much yet. All the business with Snow White might have been what set him off. And he decided to go after someone that he hated more than the rest of them, Bigby.

The badge prop says NYPD police:
http://tf3dm.com/3d-model/female-cop-76917.html
Anyway, interesting thoughts as far as why he'd… more mess with Bigby now. We do know that since Fables are near immortals they have very long memories and tend to hold grudges (Colin said as much in the game). But, why would he kill Faith then? It's not like she meant very much to Bigby. Not that we know of, anyway. And if he did do all of this because he was poor and disenfranchised, why not go after the rich fables? Why a fable who had fallen on hard times like Faith? Anyway, I don't really know what to think. Just throwing some ideas around, playing Devil's Advocate.

The badge prop says NYPD police:
http://tf3dm.com/3d-model/female-cop-76917.html
Anyway, interesting thoughts as far as why he'd… more mess with Bigby now. We do know that since Fables are near immortals they have very long memories and tend to hold grudges (Colin said as much in the game). But, why would he kill Faith then? It's not like she meant very much to Bigby. Not that we know of, anyway. And if he did do all of this because he was poor and disenfranchised, why not go after the rich fables? Why a fable who had fallen on hard times like Faith? Anyway, I don't really know what to think. Just throwing some ideas around, playing Devil's Advocate.

No, it's possible. The badge could just be for the game to tell us what is going on. Tell us that Beauty is trailing Bigby (and yeah, the character model is different, too), and Crane doesn't trust Bigby at all.

No, it's possible. The badge could just be for the game to tell us what is going on. Tell us that Beauty is trailing Bigby (and yeah, the character model is different, too), and Crane doesn't trust Bigby at all.

This character I think appears in two ..maybe because bigby is getting framed for the murders and someone wants him out of the picture "Bluebeard" ...who else to do that but the cryer? But then a Mundy (the cop) starts looking into it as well..

Again these are my theories on this I'm sure once it's released minds will be blown and we'll be left questioning characters motives .

Only Fables call him Sheriff. Humans don't know it. It's secret, Humans don't know that "Woodlands" is "Fabletown" and they are real fables. And fables calls him sheriff because he solves problems or cases, with his own and he tries to be very careful about humans.

Only Fables call him Sheriff. Humans don't know it. It's secret, Humans don't know that "Woodlands" is "Fabletown" and they are real… more fables. And fables calls him sheriff because he solves problems or cases, with his own and he tries to be very careful about humans.