Historical documentary data are valuable sources of information about past
climate (e.g., Brown and Issar, 1998; Bradley, 1999). However, their use requires
great care, as such documents may be biased towards describing only the more
extreme events, and are, in certain cases, prone to the use of inconsistent
language between different writers and different epochs, and to errors in dating.
As for all proxy information, historical documents require careful calibration
and verification against modern instrumental data. Two areas particularly strong
in historical documents describing climate are Europe and China. In Europe,
attempts have been made to extend long climate series back in time using a combination
of documentary evidence and fragmentary instrumental records (e.g., Pfister,
1995; Pfister et al., 1998). Additional information about past climate change
has also been obtained purely from documentary records in Europe (e.g., Martin-Vide
and Barriendos, 1995; Brázdil, 1996; Pfister et al., 1996, 1998, 1999;
Pfister and Brázdil, 1999; Rodrigo et al., 1999). In China, regional
instrumental temperature series have been extended back over much of the past
millennium using documentary data combined with inferences from ice cores and
tree rings (Wang et al., 1998a, 1998b; Wang and Gong, 2000).

Figure 2.21: Comparison of warm-season (Jones et al., 1998) and annual
mean (Mann et al., 1998, 1999) multi-proxy-based and warm season tree-ring-based
(Briffa, 2000) millennial Northern Hemisphere temperature reconstructions.
The recent instrumental annual mean Northern Hemisphere temperature record
to 1999 is shown for comparison. Also shown is an extra-tropical sampling
of the Mann et al. (1999) temperature pattern reconstructions more directly
comparable in its latitudinal sampling to the Jones et al. series. The self-consistently
estimated two standard error limits (shaded region) for the smoothed Mann
et al. (1999) series are shown. The horizontal zero line denotes the 1961
to 1990 reference period mean temperature. All series were smoothed with
a 40-year Hamming-weights lowpass filter, with boundary constraints imposed
by padding the series with its mean values during the first and last 25
years.

Mountain glacier moraines
The position of moraines or till left behind by receding glaciers can provide
information on the advances (and, less accurately, the retreats) of mountain
glaciers. Owing to the complex balance between local changes in melting and
ice accumulation, and the effects of topography which influence mountain glaciers
(see Section 2.2.5.4), it is difficult to reconstruct
regional (as opposed to global) climate changes from the extent of mountain
glaciers alone (Oerlemans, 1989). For example, both increased winter precipitation
(through greater accumulation) and lower summer temperatures (through decreased
melting or “ablation”) can lead to more positive glacial mass balances. The
inertia of large glaciers dictates that they respond to climate change relatively
slowly, with delays of decades or occasionally centuries. For smaller, fast
moving glaciers in regions where precipitation and accumulation are moderate,
temperature changes are usually the dominant factor influencing mountain glacier
masses and lengths. Here glacier moraine evidence in combination with other
lines of evidence can provide reliable information on past regional temperature
changes (Salinger, 1995; Holzhauser and Zumbühl, 1996; Raper et al., 1996;
Salinger et al., 1996).

2.3.2.2 Multi-proxy synthesis of recent temperature change

Since the SAR there have been several attempts to combine various types of
high-resolution proxy climate indicators to create large-scale palaeoclimate
reconstructions that build on earlier work by e.g., Bradley and Jones (1993);
Hughes and Diaz (1994) and Mann et al. (1995). Overpeck et al. (1997) and Fisher
(1997) have sought to combine information from ice cores, varved lake sediment
cores, and tree rings to reconstruct high latitude climate trends for past centuries.
Jones et al. (1998) estimated extra-tropical Northern and Southern Hemisphere
warm-season temperature changes during the past millennium using a sparse set
of extra-tropical warm-season temperature proxy indicators (10 and 8 respectively).
Mann et al. (1998) reconstructed global patterns of annual surface temperature
several centuries back in time. They calibrated a combined terrestrial (tree
ring, ice core and historical documentary indicator) and marine (coral) multi-proxy
climate network against dominant patterns of 20th century global surface temperature.
Averaging the reconstructed temperature patterns over the far more data-rich
Northern Hemisphere half of the global domain, they estimated the Northern Hemisphere
mean temperature back to AD 1400, a reconstruction which had significant skill
in independent cross-validation tests. Self-consistent estimates were also made
of the uncertainties. This work has now been extended back to AD 1000 (Figure
2.20, based on Mann et al., 1999). The uncertainties (the shaded region
in Figure 2.20) expand considerably in earlier
centuries because of the sparse network of proxy data. Taking into account these
substantial uncertainties, Mann et al. (1999) concluded that the 1990s were
likely to have been the warmest decade, and 1998 the warmest year, of the past
millennium for at least the Northern Hemisphere. Jones et al. (1998) came to
a similar conclusion from largely independent data and an entirely independent
methodology. Crowley and Lowery (2000) reached the similar conclusion that medieval
temperatures were no warmer than mid-20th century temperatures. Borehole data
(Pollack et al., 1998) independently support this conclusion for the past 500
years although, as discussed earlier (Section 2.3.2.1),
detailed interpretations comparison with long-term trends from such of such
data are perilous owing to loss of temporal resolution back in time.

The largely independent multi-proxy Northern Hemisphere temperature reconstructions
of Jones et al. (1998) and Mann et al. (1999) are compared in Figure
2.21, together with an independent (extra-tropical, warm-season) Northern
Hemisphere temperature estimate by Briffa (2000) based on tree-ring density
data. The estimated uncertainties shown are those for the smoothed Mann et al.
series. Significant differences between the three reconstructions are evident
during the 17th and early 19th centuries where either the Briffa et al. or Jones
et al. series lie outside the estimated uncertainties in the Mann et al. series.
Much of these differences appear to result from the different latitudinal and
seasonal emphases of the temperature estimates. This conclusion is supported
by the observation that the Mann et al. hemispheric temperature average, when
restricted to just the extra-tropical (30 to 70°N band) region of the Northern
Hemisphere, shows greater similarity in its trend over the past few centuries
to the Jones et al. reconstruction. The differences between these reconstructions
emphasise the importance of regional and seasonal variations in climate change.
These are discussed in the next section.