On Beijing’s Anti-Japan Protests

Today saw huge demonstrations in front of Japan’s Embassy in Beijing to protest Japanese claims over the Diaoyu Islands. Two years ago when tensions last flared over this issue, I checked out the Japanese embassy in Beijing, where there were no more than about 50 people. This time, turnout was exponentially bigger and more serious.

I got to the embassy at about 1:00 this afternoon. The roads around it were all closed off to traffic with a few hundred riot police, regular police, public security volunteers and lord knows how many plain clothes officers. I estimate there were at least 2,000 people while I was there, although it’s unclear how many actively came to protest and how many were just curious onlookers.

In the middle of the street there was a partition with police directing people to parade around it in long circles. People had huge Chinese flags and banners saying things like “Fuck little Japan.” What I was most surprised by were the number of Chairman Mao posters floating around. I asked a few people about this and the consensus was “Mao would never let Japan get away with this.”

This mass outpouring obviously had official sanction. The police’s presence was to direct the protests rather than try to hamper them in any way.

Later things started to get a bit more intense. While the crowds circled around they were allowed to stop briefly in front of the Japanese embassy itself. It was guarded by hundreds of riot police with helmets and shields. At first protestors threw water bottles and eggs at the embassy, which police made no attempt to stop. But gradually rocks and (I assume Japanese) cell phones started to be thrown. Many of them hit the Chinese police, who were covering themselves with shields.

One man brought a bucket full of rocks, which police came and confiscated somewhat violently. After a man chucked a rock, an officer wrestled him away and said, “Enough, they’re Chinese.” He then let him go. I caught up with the man and asked him what had happened. He said, “I just wanted to fuck Japan.”

Finally I went to interview a man on the side of the road holding a sign. As I was speaking with him a police officer grabbed my shoulder and turned me around. “What are you doing,” he asked forcefully in English.

I said I was just talking with people and taking pictures. He pulled me toward a small police post on the side of the road and demanded my passport. He looked at the visa page, handed it back and then seemed to get distracted with something else. I slowly but steadily walked away.

It was very strange. It seemed like coverage was being encouraged. I didn’t notice any of the other foreigners who were taking video/pictures being hassled. I’m not sure why I was singled out.

That was about the time I headed home. If you didn’t understand what the people were chanting, the whole atmosphere of the protests seemed very festive. People chanted things, others laughed. Families with little kids were out, young people, old people. It kind of felt like a 4th of July parade…until things began to be thrown at the embassy.

This whole uproar is a godsend for the Communist Party. I never imagined I’d see people marching down the street with pictures of Mao Zedong chanting “Long live Mao, Long live the Communist Party.” It was a bit surreal. (Though several people were chastising the government for sitting by too idly)

It’s interesting to speculate on how much of this was deliberately egged on by the CCP. The whole thing erupted when the Japanese government bought some of the islands from a private owner. The move was intended to put the islands under national control so Japanese activists could be prevented from planting flags on the island and stirring up tensions. But it seems that was a huge miscalculation by Japan on the eve of China’s 18th Party Congress.

The Chinese media could have lauded the move as an attempt to ease tensions and work toward a peaceful solution, but it went hard in the opposite direction, portraying it as an illegitimate slap in China’s face. It’s no wonder so many are riled up.

It is important to note that when you see Mao posters being paraded, it’s probably a pretty poor representation of Chinese people. And it’s hard to say how many people present at the protest were active nationalists, how many came because they thought it’d be cool or interesting, and how many just happened to walk by and stuck around.

But there was a lot of intensity. Whenever someone started a chant, most joined in. This is clearly the most serious clash between China and Japan in a long time, and it could be far from over. A few days from now will be September 18th, the anniversary of Japan’s invasion of Manchuria. Unless there’s a police clampdown, the protests are likely to continue through at least that day.

With Xi Jinping back and all this intense anger directed toward Japan, I predict China’s leadership transfer can now go off without a hitch.

[Update: Below is a video I threw together of the protests with subtitles. See the rock chucker and hear a “Fuck the USA” chant]

Pictures

“Angry eggs, free to take (everyone take 2)”

Notice the egg stains on the embassy

[If you want to use any of these pictures for anything, please either leave the watermark on or contact me to send you the original]

[…] by protests across China with Toyota dealerships are set on fire, Uniqlo stores being shut down, protesters throwing Japanese phones at embassy guards, and Audi dealership staff posing with signs calling for death to all Japanese. […]

From a international stand point, I think ppl must look at Island dispute objectively. The Chinese claiming that island simply belongs to them is not correct. No Chinese person have even lived on the island. There are some old maps that show that they were part of Ming Dynasty. There are also other maps from same era in China that shows it was unclaimed.

1) How do you explain about maps that clearly showed it was a neutral territory?
2) How do you claim a property if you have never even lived there?
3) How legit is Ming Dynasty map? Roman empire map shows most of Europe belong to them… Does that mean Italians get to re-claim some of the territory from that era? Same goes for Mongolians and Ottoman(Turkey).
So that’s something that Chinese government should answer.

Now, on the other side, Japanese claim that they did a 10 year research from 1885 to prove that the Island didn’t belong to anyone before acquiring it in 1895…

1) How legit is that 10 year research?
2) What protocol was taken to ensure it didn’t belong to anyone?
3) If it belong to you, why have you not developed the island?
That’s something Japanese government should answer.

Now, there are few facts that are clear.
1) Japan acquired the Island in 1895 and made it part of Okinawa prefecture.
2) There were population of about 200 Japanese who lived in the island from early 1900s to 1940s.
3) When Japan lost a war, they were forced to return all lands occupied during the war. In a 1951 SF treaty, that did not include the Senkaku(Japan) Daioyu (China)Island.
4) When the US returned the control of Okinawa to Japan in the 70s, the Senkaku Island was part of the Island that was returned to the Japanese.
5) During the same era, the researched showed there could be a potential oil resource around the region. Now, for the first time ever, China and Taiwan started claiming it was their island.

Just looking at this dispute objectively. IMO, Chinese report of simply saying it belongs to them is way too one sided. There is a legit reasons for the dispute and it should be handled using modern common sense and law.

[…] despite a concerted effort by the CCP and state media (like Xinhua) to paint Japan (and the US) as foreign devils, there probably will not be any military confrontation between China and Japan. In part because […]