Facts: The defendant operated “Café Indiana” at 18 Montmartre Boulevard, Paris. The terrace of the cafe was found to be closed on its three main sides and to be only partly ventilated beneath its roof.

Held: Allowing the appeal and remitting the matter to the Versailles Court of Appeal, that the cafe’s provision of only partial ventilation under its roof while being closed on its three main sides was inadequate to respond to the law’s requirements.