When the death of Moore's Law was greatly exaggerated in the mid-90s and 2000s

Summary : Crashing into Moore's Wall is like a conspiracy theory: it can never be disproved to the true believers that our industry is about to run into a wall that has never appeared. Back in the mid-nineties, Scientific American asked me and my Dad to layo

Chip History 1996 & 2004:When the death of Moore’s Law was greatly exaggerated. Crashing into Moore’s Wall is like a conspiracy theory: it can never be disproved to the true believers that our industry is about to run into a wall that has never appeared. Back in the mid-nineties, Scientific American asked me and my Dad to layout the case for the continuation of Moore’s Law. Clearly we got it right. Here’s some of the things we wrote that are still true today:

The ability to store and process information in new ways has been essential to humankind’s progress. From early Sumerian clay tokens through …

Scientific advances have enabled the storage, retrieval, and processing of ever more information, which in turn, has helped generate the insights needed for further advances.

In essence the demand for more Moore is unlimited.

… here we go again. With the cost of building a new semiconductor facility now into 10 figures, and with the densities of transistors close to the theoretical limits … an unsettling question is once more being asked in some quarters.

Moore and More Transistors

In stark contrast to what would seem to be implied by the dependable doubling of transistor densities, the route that led to today’s chips was anything but smooth.

… a harrowing obstacle course that repeatedly required chipmakers to overcome significant limitations in their equipment and production processes.

None of those problems turned out to be the dreaded showstopper …

Note this title predates More Moore, as offers the definition that it’s about More Transistor. The yet-to-be invented More Than Moore, would then be More Than Transistors.

Must the Show Go On?

One of the impediments to i-line operation was … Innovative solutions overcame these limitations.

… as new manufacturing technology takes hold, the costs of fabricating chips begin to decline.

Billion-Dollar Factories

Intel is spending $1.1B on its new factory in Hillsboro, Ore., and $1.3B on another one in Chandler Ariz …

That factories now cost so much is one piece of widely cited evidence that formidable technical barriers are close.

Today we spend 10X these amounts and still, there’s no economic barrier!

When the cost-per-bit begins to rise permanently, the most likely result will be a phase change that significantly alters business models.

Still hasn’t happened after 21 years. Note the use of cost-per-bit, as DRAMs were still considered the node clock and the term node did not exist yet.

Eight years later, in a 2004 Scientific American article, addressing another challenge, I would write:

These immensely sophisticated microchips – or rather, nanochips – are now manufactured by the millions, yet the scientists and engineers responsible for their development receive little recognition. You might say these people are the Rodney Dangerfields of nanotechnology.

That it has advanced as far as it has is a testament to the ingenious ability of the countless scientists and engineers to continually refine the basic method of chip manufacture …

At the end of the day, it is the brilliance of the people in our industry that bring evermore innovation each year. Physics may pose barriers. But it is people that overcome them.

You may like this also:

VLSI's Customer Satisfaction Survey Celebrates 30 Years of award winning semiconductor equipment companies.
A Look Back... 2018 marked the 30th year VLSIresearch has released its annual Customer Satisfaction ... See more

The replacement of optical lithography with e-beam direct write for semiconducto ...

The replacement of optical lithography with e-beam direct write for semiconductor manufacturing has been predicted since Gordon Moore penned his 1965 paper, writing "It is worth noting that this density of comp ... See more

Tencor (later evolved to be KLA - Tencor) is in the bedrock of the semiconducto ...

Tencor (later evolved to be KLA - Tencor) is in the bedrock of the semiconductor equipment industry. It developed many products that were essential to chip manufacturing. Some are still made today. ... See more

The emergence of crystalline silicon and silicon-based material such as silicon- ...

The emergence of crystalline silicon and silicon-based material such as silicon-germanium as the premier material and the personnel driving the integrated circuit (IC) microelectronics revolution will be review ... See more