Will Lithuania elect its first new generation president?

As Lithuanians are getting ready to vote for their next President on May 12, the race is intensifying between the three leading candidates Ingrida Šimonytė, Gitanas Nausėda, and Saulius Skvernelis. Ms. Šimonytė has taken the lead in the polls and she also edges out her competition when compared for experience and qualifications in public service, foreign policy expertise, and leadership strengths. A lot will be at stake for Lithuania in the coming years and it will need a new generation leader up for the task

Lithuania
navigates a complex international environment with rising populism and
Euroscepticism, weakening transatlantic alliances, a revisionist Russia,
continuing war in Ukraine, and growing tensions between the West and China.
Domestically, the Lithuanian population demands higher living standards and a
reduction of income inequality as society faces divergent interests among its different
segments and suffers from persistent emigration and brain drain.

Public Service

The candidates’ backgrounds highlight their vastly different
levels of experience in politics and public service. Economist Nausėda stands
out for his lack of political experience. He has spent his career in banking
and has had limited public service involvement outside starting his career at
the Lithuanian state bank Lietuvos Bankas. Meanwhile, Mr. Skvernelis has been
serving as Prime Minister since 2016. After a career in law enforcement, he
entered politics in 2014 as Minister of Interior when the newly revived
political party Farmers and Greens won a surprise victory in the Parliament.

A member of parliament member since 2016, Šimonytė
benefits from the longest and most diverse experience serving the country. She
started her career as a civil servant in the Ministry of Finance in the early
2000s as the country was preparing to join the European Union. She served as
the Minister of Finance from 2009 to 2012 during the the global financial
crisis that hard hit Lithuania and the other Baltic States. Her diverse and
extensive public service background in different branches of government gives
Šimonytė a solid foundation for implementing her vision and ideas as well as
navigating the Lithuanian state apparatus. Yet she still remains a fresh face on
the political scene–something that the Lithuanian voters often favor in the
Presidential and Parliamentary elections.

Nonpartisanship

In order to ensure a system of checks and balances in the
government, the Lithuanian constitution stipulates that the President must not
be a party member even though political parties may raise candidates for the
presidency. A nonpartisant President is more likely to serve the whole
population and unify rather divide society rather than work for political party
interests.

All
three leading candidates are not members of any political parties. However, due
to their different level of experience in government (or lack thereof) their ties
to political parties differ. Mr. Nausėda currently has no formal ties any
political party. Ms. Šimonytė is not a member of a party, but is supported in
the elections by the conservative Homeland Union-Cristian Democtrat party.

Here, the candidacy of Mr. Skvernelis becomes somewhat
problematic. Though he is not a member of a political party, as the leader of
the current government and Prime Minister, Skvernelis is supported and financed
by the rulling Farmers and Greens political party. If Skvernelis wins the
Presidency, the government and the presidency would be tied to and dependent on
the same political party. This could create an unfavorable situation for
Lithuania’s politics, weakening the “checks and balances” system at the very
highest level of government and could throw into question the political
impartiality of the presidency.

Foreign Policy

As a parliamentary and semi-presidential republic,
Lithuania has a mixed government system where the President serves as the head
of state and the Prime Minister is the head of government. The President’s most
important responsibilities center on foreign policy. In a difficult
neighborhood and a complex geopolitical environment, foreign policy becomes an
even more critical and challenging task for the next Lithuanian President.

While foreign policy is not the strongest suit of the
leading candidates, here Šimonytė stands out among her competition.

Prime Minister Skvernelis is a player in Lithuania’s
domestic politics and has demonstrated limited interest in foreign policy or
knowledge of foreign languages. His visit to Israel was critiqued by current President
Dalia Grybauskaitė for having “done more damage than good.” More so than his
main competitors he favors improving dialogue with Russia. Nausėda has had a
more international career having studied in Germany and worked as an advisor to
international banks. However, largely due to his lack of political background,
he also lacks foreign policy experience.

Šimonytė benefits from her experience and expertise working
as the Minister of Finance representing Lithuanian interests internationally
during the global financial crisis. From 2015 she has served on the board on
European Central Bank where she gained further experience into the workings of
European Union countries’ financial and political economic relations.

In diplomacy, key personality traits and a healthy dose of
common sense can be instrumental. Šimonytė’s charisma and approachability would
help her build diplomatic relations while her experience and pragmatism would
serve to guard Lithuania’s interests.

While Euroscepticism and populism is on the rise in
Europe, Šimonytė has taken a clear position on the European Union’s importance
to Lithuania. She has advocated that Lithuania “has to be open to those ideas
that strenghten the EU.” As a pro-Europe candidate, Šimonytė recalls other new European
politicians such as France’s President Emmanuel Macron and Slovakia’s new President
Zuzana Caputova. Among the Lithuanian candidates Šimonytė has also most clearly
articulated her principled and pragmatic position regarding foreing policy
towards Russia.

Populism and
Europe

As populist trends shook up Britain, France, Poland,
Italy and others in Europe and across the Atlantic, they have not yet raised a
significant challenge to Lithuania or the other two Baltic States. Yet populism
and Euroscepticism is only likely to grow. Forecasts indicate that during the
next European Parliamentary elections, held on 23-26 May the mainstream EU
political parties such as Christian Democrats or Social Democrats will win less
than 50% of seats loosing some votes to new, Eurosceptic, and populist forces.

In this context of decreasing voter trust in European and
national institutions, Lithuania will need leadership that can withstand such
pressures. At the same time, a new era of politics requires leadership that is approachable
with an ability to forge bonds and dialogue with voters, civil servants, and politicians.
These trying times would be difficult for a political novice or a dusty old-era
politician.

Šimonytė here stands out as someone who has not played to
populism but is also perceived as approachable and communicative. Her ability
to balance these traits with experience without falling into the traps of
populism or elitism will be invaluable.

In contrast, Nausėda’s positions and style are more
difficult to discern because he is new to the political scene and because he
favors cautious moderation in his rhetoric seemingly to appeal to a broad
spectrum of the electorate. Meanwhile, Skvernelis and his government of Farmers
and Greens rhetoric is intended to appeal to the everyday voters rather than
city elites and is marked by a sprinkling of nationalism, Euroscepticism and populism.

New Generation
Politician

Comparing Šimonytė, Nausėda, and Skvernelis is not easy. Though all three are close enough in age they create an impression that they are of different generations or even of different era’s of Lithaunia’s political life. Here some may want to compare Šimonytė to the current President Grybauskaitė, but Šimonytė stands out among other candidates or other Lithuanian political figures.

Šimonytė is the first new generation Lithuanian leading
politician. She is Western, pro-European, and a Transatlanticist. Her youth and
approachable charisma is also characteristic of Europe’s new generation of
politicians. She entered Lithuania’s
political life just a decade ago during one of the most difficult times for the
state. Šimonytė works to demonstrate “that politics can be transparent, clean,
clear, and oriented towards the many segments of society.” Her style is a
reflection of her experience as a public servant, rather than a traditional
politician, and she has sought to serve her country rather than a political
party of a particular government institution.

Who Lithuania will choose come May 12th remains to be
seen with Šimonytė and Nausėda leading neck and neck in the polls and
Skvernelis trailing close behind. Both Šimonytė and Nausėda are likely compete
for many of the same electoral segments: younger, educated, pro-European, urban
voters. What distinguishes them is Šimonytė’s public service and political
experience while Nausėda is a fresh face on the Lithuanian political scene.

Ukraine just elected a political newcomer, actor
Volodymyr Zelenskiy, as its president.
Estonia’s new President Kersti Kaljulaid was an experienced state
official but largely a political unknown. Latvia opted for an experienced
public servant and politician Raimonds Vejonis as its president.

How Lithuania will vote remains to be seen in May. Given
the complex geopolitical context, populist and Eurosceptic tendencies in the
EU, the hopes of the Lithuanian public and the responsibilities of the
presidency, Šimonytė is the best prepared and best suited candidate to the
Lithuanian presidency.

Dr. Agnia Grigas is a geopolitical economist and political risk expert. She is a senior fellow at the Atlantic Council and author of “The New Geopolitics of Natural Gas” and “Beyond Crimea: The New Russian Empire”. Follow her @AgniaGrigas and Grigas.net

Lithuania’s President Dalia Grybauskaitė on Wednesday congratulated her Polish counterpart, Andrzej Duda, on May 3 Constitution Day and wished the people of Poland continued success, prosperity and unity. […]

Lithuania’s President Dalia Grybauskaitė attending the European Union‘s (EU) summit says there should be more specifics in the proposal of the community’s largest members to set up a position of the euro zone finance minister and have a separate budget for the area. […]

Latest

May 24, 2019Comments Off on Others already dividing up Farmers party property

The European Parliament elections and the first round of presidential elections will be held this Sunday. However, we can already notice one of the main, if not the main result of the three election, municipal, […]

Advance voting had started in the country’s municipalities early on Monday morning for the second round of presidential elections and the European Parliament elections, Lrytas.lt wrote in editorial. The advance voting will be held throughout […]

By the initiative of MEP Antanas Guoga, a group of MEPs addressed Amazon Inc. in a collective video message, urging to cease the sale of goods featuring Soviet symbols on the Amazon online shopping platform. […]

The ruling majority and Seimas Budget and Finance Committee (BFK) chairman Stasys Jakeliūnas, who is leading them into battle against the head of the Bank of Lithuania (BL), were unable to pass a no-confidence motion […]

Skvernelis voters‘ votes will be very valuable for the presidential hopeful in the second round of the Lithuanian presidential elections. Left second in the first round of presidential elections, but has the greatest chances to […]

It wasn’t by chance that I spoke about my meeting with the daughter of Jonas Noreika – General Storm, Dalia Noreikaitė Kučėnienė, and the broad conversation that I had with her. I resolved to remember […]