The Sunflower has a massive total efficiency of around 80%, thanks to very clever tech.

Share this story

Behold, the Solar Sunflower! Here they are trying a bunch of different reflector materials, which is why the segments all look slightly different. Some of the reflectors are covered up to protect them from the elements, or to stop them from frying a nearby engineer.

Sebastian Anthony

Solar Sunflower, back

Sebastian Anthony

Solar Sunflower, back

Sebastian Anthony

Sebastian Anthony

If you squint, you can see the "bright spot" on the collector in the middle of the Sunflower; that's somewhere between the power of 1,500 and 5,000 suns.

Sebastian Anthony

Sebastian Anthony

The Solar Sunflower control room.

Sebastian Anthony

The Sunflower is controlled through this tablet. The Sunflower can be set to track the sun, or you can manually move it around (which I did!)

Sebastian Anthony

Sebastian Anthony

Gianluca Ambrosetti, in the Airlight Energy control room.

Sebastian Anthony

Praise the sun!

Sebastian Anthony

Airlight Energy, in Biasca, Switzerland

Sebastian Anthony

The various lightweight concrete pieces that make up a Solar Sunflower. They are preparing to build another Sunflower.

Sebastian Anthony

Sebastian Anthony

This giant machine is for covering the reflector segments in a protective plastic coating.

Sebastian Anthony

This is a small collector, with GaAs photovoltaics in the centre. I think it's from an early Sunflower prototype.

Sebastian Anthony

Various bits and pieces from Airlight projects.

Sebastian Anthony

This is unrelated to the Sunflower; it's the collector for a concentrated solar thermal plant. Reflectors would be used to beam sunlight into this giant contraption.

Sebastian Anthony

The layout of a large concentrated solar thermal plant in Morocco.

Sebastian Anthony

Airlight operates a concentrated solar thermal plant in Morocco; the control room gives them lots of feedback about the plant.

Sebastian Anthony

Sebastian Anthony

Airlight Energy's pool table

Sebastian Anthony

Rubik's Cube seats. Very cute.

Sebastian Anthony

Biasca train station. How picturesque!

Sebastian Anthony

High on a hill was a lonely sunflower. Not a normal sunflower, mind you; that would hardly be very notable. This sunflower is a solar sunflower that combines both photovoltaic solar power and concentrated solar thermal power in one neat, aesthetic package that has a massive total efficiency of around 80 percent.

The Solar Sunflower, a Swiss invention developed by Airlight Energy, Dsolar (a subsidiary of Airlight), and IBM Research in Zurich, uses something called HCPVT to generate electricity and hot water from solar power. HCPVT is a clumsy acronym that stands for "highly efficient concentrated photovoltaic/thermal." In short, it has reflectors that concentrate the sun—"to about 5,000 suns," Gianluca Ambrosetti, Airlight's head of research told me—and then some highly efficient photovoltaic cells that are capable of converting that concentrated solar energy into electricity, without melting in the process. Airlight/Dsolar are behind the Sunflower's reflectors and superstructure, and the photovoltaics are provided by IBM.

The two constituent technologies of the Solar Sunflower—concentrated solar thermal power and photovoltaic solar power—are both very well known and understood at this point, and not at all exciting. What's special about the Sunflower, however, is that it combines both of the technologies together in a novel fashion to attain much higher total efficiency. Bear with me, as this will take a little bit of explaining.

The reflectors are simply slightly curved, mirrored panels. Airlight has tried a variety of different reflector materials, from glass to mylar, but it looks like they have finally settled on aluminium foil, which isn't prohibitively expensive and has very high reflectance. Aluminium foil does need additional material to protect it from the elements, though, as it's very flimsy. The Sunflower has six "petals," each consisting of six reflectors. At the focal point of the 36 reflectors there are six collectors, one for each block of six reflectors.

The collectors are where most of the magic occurs. To begin with, each collector has an array of gallium-arsenide (GaAs) photovoltaic cells. GaAs is much more efficient at converting sunlight into electricity (38 percent in this case, versus about 20 percent for silicon), but it's much, much more expensive. With the Sunflower, though, space is at a premium: the sunlight is only focused on a very small region, so you need to use the absolute best cells available. The GaAs array in each collector only measures a few square centimetres, and yet it can produce about 2 kilowatts of electricity (so, one Sunflower generates about 12kW of electricity in total).

Photovoltaic cells, like most semiconductors, become less efficient as they get hotter. The GaAs cells used by the Sunflower have a max operating temperature of around 105°C. The problem is, when you focus the power of 5,000 suns on a single point, things get a lot hotter than 105°C. During one test, Airlight told me that they used the reflectors to melt a hole in a lump of iron (which has a melting point of 1538°C); during another test, the reflectors were misaligned and "we had molten aluminium dripping everywhere."

How then do you stop your collectors turning into very expensive puddles of molten metal?

A close-up of the IBM GaAs photovoltaic receiver. You sadly can't see the silicon microfluidics, but this is the best photo I could get.

What a complete Solar Sunflower installation would look like, providing heat and electricity to a nearby house/office/factory.

Airlight Energy

Tech specs of a completed Solar Sunflower.

Airlight Energy

Cooling with hot water? Cool.

The answer is a very clever cooling system, borrowed from one of IBM's specialities: supercomputers. In high-performance computing (HPC) installations, heat is one of the limiting factors on how much processing power you can squeeze into a given volume. Computer chips are tiny; you could physically cram hundreds of them into a 1U server chassis, if you so wished. Cooling them, though, is another matter entirely. You can use fancy heat pipes, or perhaps immerse the whole thing in liquid, but it only gets you so far.

Over the last few years, IBM has been working on advanced methods of liquid cooling, primarily to boost compute density, but also to reduce the amount of waste heat (getting rid of it increases efficiency and reduces costs). In a conventional liquid cooling setup, there's a water block (a lump of metal with some channels for liquid to flow through), a pump, and a radiator. The liquid is usually water, but it could be something else, like Fluorinert or mineral oil. Heat is transferred from the computer chip to the liquid, and then carried to the radiator and released into the atmosphere. This is inefficient for two reasons: there's a limit to how much heat can be "picked up" as the fluid passes through the block; and the heat being radiated into the atmosphere is wasted.

IBM solves both of these problems with its hot-water cooling technology. First, instead of the hot water passing through a radiator and venting the thermal energy out into the atmosphere, the hot water is simply used as hot water: to heat homes, or to drive industrial processes, such as desalination, pasteurisation, drying, cooking, etc. IBM already has an example of this in Aquasar, a supercomputer at ETH in Zurich, where the hot water is used to heat university buildings.

Second, to increase heat transfer from the chip to the water, IBM has replaced the dumb ol' water block with a piece of silicon with microfluidic channels. This piece of silicon, which is then stuck to the back of the computer chip like a tiny water block, has thousands of tiny channels that bring the water to within just a few microns of those pesky heat-generating transistors. This massively increases the amount of heat that can be dissipated, plus all of those discrete channels do a lot better job of dealing with chip hot spots (small regions that are more active than others) than the handful of giant channels in a conventional water block.

The Solar Sunflower, at Airlight Energy in Biasca, Switzerland. Video produced by Jennifer Hahn.

Okay, Seb, get back to the sunflowers...

The Solar Sunflower uses this exact same cooling technology—but instead of computer chips, those microfluidic slices of silicon are stuck to the backside of those gallium-arsenide photovoltaic cells. The cooling system ensures that the GaAs efficiently converts photons into electrons, while at the same time whisking away the thermal energy of 5,000 suns. It's pretty cool, to be honest. Or hot. Or something.

The end result is a device that produces about 12kW of electricity, along with 21kW of thermal energy (with water temperatures up to 90°C). Neither Airlight or IBM would reveal the exact pricing of a single Sunflower, but the fully installed cost will likely be in the tens-of-thousands-of-pounds range—and that's just the first caveat of many.

For a start, concentrated solar power only works with direct sunlight: the reflectors need to be pointed directly at the sun, and anything less than totally clear skies will significantly reduce power generation. The Sunflower has some control software that automatically tracks the sun, but IBM gave me a distinct "no comment" when I petulantly probed them about their ability to rid the world of clouds.

Second, there's the lack of energy density: the Sunflower is very efficient, but it still only produces 12kW of electricity. That's enough to power maybe three or four homes—during the few hours of the day that the sun is visible, anyway. You would need a large field of these things to power a town—and again, you'd need some kind of energy storage solution to get through the evenings, winters, and periods of inclementousness.

Perhaps the largest problem, though, is cost. When Airlight and IBM started work on the Solar Sunflower, the cost of bog-standard silicon solar cells was about £1 ($1.60) per watt. Over the last few years, as China has ramped up production, the cost has dropped precipitously to about 25p (40 cents) per watt—plus the efficiency of silicon PVs has improved, too. With its GaAs cells, fancy plumbing, control systems and motors, the giant lump of concrete, and the time it takes to construct the whole thing, the Solar Sunflower simply can't compete with hectares of boring-ass silicon photovoltaics.

What a completed Solar Sunflower installation might look like in the future. Maybe. (This is a computer render.)

Airlight Energy

Another Solar Sunflower render.

Flaming flowers that brightly blaze, swirling clouds in violet haze

While there's very little chance that Switzerland will soon be powered by millions of Solar Sunflowers sprouting from the Alps, not all hope is lost. The Solar Sunflower looks awesome—and in this day and age where companies, governments, real estate developers, and hotel resorts are doing everything they can to appear greener, more engaged with the community, or otherwise differentiate themselves, looks are very important indeed.

In business, these are called soft factors, as opposed to hard factors. It can still make sense to buy something, even if it isn't the most financially prudent acquisition. Putting silicon solar panels on your roof to get cheap and green electricity is one thing—but sticking a huge Solar Sunflower in your front garden so that everyone knows that you're green is another thing entirely.

Perhaps I'm being too cynical, though. Another way of looking at the Solar Sunflower is that it's definitely a niche product—but in a market as large as the energy production and distribution market, which is worth trillions of pounds per year, the niches can be rather roomy. If Airlight and IBM can sell 100,000 Sunflowers per year, that would equate to around 1.2 gigawatts of peak electricity power output—a tiny fraction of the world's energy production. If we assume a single Sunflower costs about £30,000, though, that would equate to £3 billion in total sales—which is definitely not a tiny amount of money.

Airlight Energy is planning to sell some Solar Sunflowers to early adopters in 2016, and then ramp up to full commercial manufacturing capacity in 2017. The Sunflower that we saw in Switzerland was a full-size, fully working prototype, but the final version will look a lot more polished and aesthetically pleasing.

Share this story

Sebastian Anthony
Sebastian is the editor of Ars Technica UK. He usually writes about low-level hardware, software, and transport, but it is emerging science and the future of technology that really get him excited. Emailsebastian@arstechnica.co.uk//Twitter@mrseb