What do you have against it? I'm not increasing the innings pitched limit, so it simply allows you to have another pitcher occupying an active slot. I also did not increase the roster size (still 30).

I didn't have any real opinion on it. Just was wondering cause you normally ask the group like you did when you asked if we should add another OF position.

Pros:
- We have another active P spot for a reliever. I say reliever cause I don't see anyone really needing to start more than 5 SPs on any given day.
- Makes hunting for long relievers more fun. If you like that sorta thing.
- Increases the value of closers. If you have 'em great!
- Increases the value of having better batters. One more P spot means one less Hitter, so it's more imperative to have better batters on your roster.

Cons:
- We reach our IP max faster.
- We have another active spot for a reliever. Would be boring to store long relievers on your roster.
- Increases the value of closers. If you don't have 'em, just punt the category. lol
- Increases the value of having better batters. If you don't have 'em, good luck loser.

Innings limit will not change. It would be advantageous to teams with the best collection of pitchers to choose to keep and that's not a fair change without advance notice.

The extra 'P' slot has no effect on the value of hitters. Hitters play every day, pitchers don't. Roughly half your active pitching slots go unused each day of the season. You still have a finite number of innings to use as you so desire. And saves are still only 10% of the scoring formula.

I don't feel like over-analyzing this. It's insignificant. If 3 people object to this, I will change it back.

Innings limit will not change. It would be advantageous to teams with the best collection of pitchers to choose to keep and that's not a fair change without advance notice.

The extra 'P' slot has no effect on the value of hitters. Hitters play every day, pitchers don't. Roughly half your active pitching slots go unused each day of the season. You still have a finite number of innings to use as you so desire. And saves are still only 10% of the scoring formula.

I don't feel like over-analyzing this. It's insignificant. If 3 people object to this, I will change it back.

I like to consider this a pretty serious league. So I like the discussion of changes. 4 P spots is different from 3 P spots. But if everyone else is fine with it, I'll adapt like GF said. I just hope people think about it.

I usually like to keep my P spots used everyday in addition to my RP spots. So already I'm trying to have a mixture of closers and non-closing RPs that at least have some sort of value on my roster. Another P spot means having to have another RP and one less hitter. If I have one less hitter, that means less depth at a hitting position. Yes, they play mostly everyday, but you still need depth when your starters aren't playing. So less hitting depth means making sure the hitters I have are valuable. That's what I meant about hitters being more important.