Is there a separate Toronto Robby Alomar card (1992, 1993, and 1995) and a Baltimore Robby Alomar (1996 and 1998)? Or just one Alomar for the league, and only the Toronto or Baltimore owners have the option of drafting him?

Any players that show up when you pick that team for the dropdown in the player browser. So in your example, the Jays and O's owner could draft Robby, still making the ranked draft list crucial. Clearly, you'll want to top load it with guys that have cards for more than one team.

"It's like dating a woman who hates you so much she will never break up with you, even if you burn down the house every single autumn." ~ Chuck Klosterman on Browns fans relationship with the Browns

I'm in a theme league right now where for 14 seasons we are rotating through the teams. Generally in the theme you are restricted to the player cards on the team you are assigned. And that's that.

But, in the league I'm in, you have to fill out your autodraft card with players who have cards on your team. After the autodraft runs every player who played for you could be used.

For example: Matt Williams has 4 SF cards and 1 Arizona card. So, either one of those teams could draft him. But, if after the autodraft runs he's still available, the Indians could pick up any one of his cards because he played for them in 1997, even though he doesn't have an Indians card in Strat. You just can't place those players on your draft card...have to wait until waivers.

Not saying we should do that. Just an example of a putting a bit of a twist on a theme.