I know we were discussing this in the Sherlock thread but it starts next month

I just saw a trailer on TV (and it's saying that its coming soon for the UK),but for some reason to 'SKY Living' Channel which the only other show i watch on there is Teen Wolf,new shows like Sinbad,Game Of Thrones,Boardwalk Empire etc are usually on 'SKY 1' or 'SKY Atlantic' and are heavily advertised

I think straight away this show is not going to be that popular here because it being on SKY Living(no bastard watches it,LOL) i am also wondering how well it will be advertised that its on that channel as well,the advertisement for Teen Wolf is pretty much zero here,but i really like that show so perhaps it will be a dark horse..I am pretty surprised that i managed to even see a trailer for a SKY Living show

I take it we will not have to wait as long after you guys see it if its already saying coming soon here as the wiki page shows that it premiers Thursday September 27th in America

Have you guys seen any trailers for it yet?,and is Thursday nights a good time slot for your side of the pond?(I'm interested to know how this will do)

Thursday 10 PM ET is an excellent slot for it, IF folks stay up to watch it. There is not much competition from over-the-air (OTA) TV. Not sure what the cable networks will be running at the same time.

OTA competition is ABC's Scandal and a Brian Williams news thing on NBC. Looks like the cable networks big shows are going to continue to air on Sundays - as they usually do.

Will be interesting to see if it generates any interest in the "late" ET primetime slot.

Thursday is traditionally a good tv night in the states. Elementary is taking the slot that The Mentalist had ( I believe the Mentalist is moving to sundays? ) and should do well there. Ive seen a few promos for Elementary and in spite of the the obvious comparisons to Sherlock ( one of my favorite shows on TV ) it looks like its going to be quite a different take on the Holmes concept. Enough so that I feel that there's definitely room for both series, without either stepping on the others toes.

I found Lucy Liu terrific during her multi-episode arc on Southland on TNT. I have never really previously warmed up to her in anything.

My only disappointment was that I (and I think many fans of the show) grew to really like and respect her character. When they ultimately turned her crooked, it just seemed... well... out of character and more of a "how do we quickly write this character out of the show now that her multi-episode arc is over?" moment. I wasn't really a fan of how they ended her arc, but I enjoyed her being on the show and look forward to her "female Watson" take in this.

It's also nice when they give a strong female role to an actress who's at least in my generation! (she's 43, turning 44 this year apparently).

It amuses me to see how many people are already ripping this show because there's no way it can live up to or compare to the excellent BBC series Sherlock. It hasnt even aired yet and people are calling it crap. I choose not to be so close minded that mere existence of Sherlock means Elementary is garbage. Ill let the show speak for itself, thank you. Elementary doesnt have to be better than Sherlock to be good and if its entertaining, thats good enough for me. Oh and since theres been a gazillion takes on the Sherlock mythos, including other modernizations prior to Sherlock, Elementary shouldnt be considered a "remake" of Sherlock, like many are claiming. Its just another take on the Holmes mythos. Theres plenty of room for both shows to exist.

It amuses me to see how many people are already ripping this show because there's no way it can live up to or compare to the excellent BBC series Sherlock. It hasnt even aired yet and people are calling it crap. I choose not to be so close minded that mere existence of Sherlock means Elementary is garbage. Ill let the show speak for itself, thank you. Elementary doesnt have to be better than Sherlock to be good and if its entertaining, thats good enough for me. Oh and since theres been a gazillion takes on the Sherlock mythos, including other modernizations prior to Sherlock, Elementary shouldnt be considered a "remake" of Sherlock, like many are claiming. Its just another take on the Holmes mythos. Theres plenty of room for both shows to exist.

I understand what you're saying, but sadly the show will be compared cause they are tackling the same mythos. I'll watch, but the previews I've seen isn't inspiring much hope.

I watched it, and enjoyed it OK. I mentioned I loved Lucy Liu's character's story arc on Southland. I've not particularly found her appealing in any other roles before that.

It wouldn't surprise me if they introduce some Moriarty type character as an over-arcing villain (as with Red John on The Mentalist, or a couple of the villains in Bones, among other shows).

I hope they keep the focus on the characters. It could be way too easy for it to become Sherlock Meets The Mentalist, or some sort of British version of Castle. Those don't even sound like terrible ideas -- I just think the show has potential to find its own identity and not lazily become Another Procedural TV Show.

As for BBC's show, of course I love it too, picked up the initial DVD set as soon as I could, and am eager for the next DVD set. My limited cable here doesn't seem to include the BBC channel it's on.

While I think the shows are completely different animals (beyond just Watson being a woman in the U.S. show), if one thinks "Sherlock in the modern day" is a trademarked idea that nobody should ever do more than once as a TV show idea on planet Earth, then this will upset one, no matter what, much like the U.S. version of The Office originally did.

imho, as long as Elementary carves out its own stories and characters and doesn't resort to copycatting the British show's themes, concepts etc., it should do fine.

I'm sure the creator of the British Sherlock will remain ticked. He probably assumed that if a U.S. studio did a "Sherlock in the modern day" show, he'd at least have gotten to be an executive producer and/or consultant on it as Ricky Gervais and Stephen Merchant were on the U.S. version of The Office (though Gervais/Merchant really had no ongoing involvement in the show, they presumably got paid in some way).

Agreed Blackjack. This is nothing like the BBCs Sherlock. As I mentioned before modernizing Holmes is not a new thing. Its been done even with the old Basil Rathbone movies. Moffat needs to get off his high horse and let his show stand on its own merits. I also agree that they will eventually need a "Moriarity" type or the show will devolve quickly into a simple weekly procedural and we have a ton of them already. They do need to be careful that making Watson a woman doesnt end up being a cliche but as long as the scripts stay strong I think Lucy Lui is a good enough actress to make it work. Overall, it was entertaining and has potential. The important thing is how it develops from here.

Caught the tail end of NPR interviewing Lucy Liu, about the show. The creator has stated that there will not be a romance but rather a bromance between the two characters.Having said that this is an American tv show and what the audience wants they usually get. Course maybe they could introduce a love interest for Moriarty whom Holmes is also interested in. Perhaps a tragic death is what causes the two to become enemies.

Caught the tail end of NPR interviewing Lucy Liu, about the show. The creator has stated that there will not be a romance but rather a bromance between the two characters.Having said that this is an American tv show and what the audience wants they usually get. Course maybe they could introduce a love interest for Moriarty whom Holmes is also interested in. Perhaps a tragic death is what causes the two to become enemies.

Regarding Holmes and women...

Spoiler for Hiden:

They stated in the premiere that the thing that drove Holmes to the drug addiction he is recovering from was a woman... Irene Adler, perhaps?

Wasn't terribly impressed. It seemed to just be a poorly written american attempt at getting in on the sherlock holmes popularity train. I'll give it a few more chances, but i'm not holding out any hope.

Logged

Warning: You will see my penis. -Brian

Just remember: once a user figures out gluten noting them they're allowed to make fun of you. - Ceekay speaking in tongues.

Interesting seeing the differences between this, the RDJr movies, and the BBC show. Not real familiar with the Holmes lore but I've enjoyed what I've seen.

We've started watching the Granada show with my daughter, so now that seems to be in the mix, too, for us.

Which is okay, since Holmes has always been of great interest to me. And all of these versions are very, very different. And all good, too, which is surprising (I certainly wasn't expecting much from the CBS show, but it's better than I would have guessed).

On the Granada show, while I love Jeremy Brett's performance, I can't say I feel the same about the whole production. Something about it often feels stodgy to me. And it can lack tension when it should absolutely have it. I've felt this way about most of the British mystery shows (which is a shame, because my wife loves them). Poirot, for example. Love Suchet. Love the 20s style, too, but the show just leaves me meh.

Interesting seeing the differences between this, the RDJr movies, and the BBC show. Not real familiar with the Holmes lore but I've enjoyed what I've seen.

We've started watching the Granada show with my daughter, so now that seems to be in the mix, too, for us.

Which is okay, since Holmes has always been of great interest to me. And all of these versions are very, very different. And all good, too, which is surprising (I certainly wasn't expecting much from the CBS show, but it's better than I would have guessed).

On the Granada show, while I love Jeremy Brett's performance, I can't say I feel the same about the whole production. Something about it often feels stodgy to me. And it can lack tension when it should absolutely have it. I've felt this way about most of the British mystery shows (which is a shame, because my wife loves them). Poirot, for example. Love Suchet. Love the 20s style, too, but the show just leaves me meh.

I like the Granada shows because they were like watching the original books,and of course i loved Brett's performance..everything in the series reminded me of the original Sidney Paget drawings that accompany the books i have

I went to the Granada Studios Tour back in the 80s when the show was at it's strongest(as Granada Studios is based in Manchester),and i walked down 'Baker Street' and rode on the '1800's tram' as well(it's always fun when i tease Myto about that as well,as she is a fan of the show)

Never liked Poirot,Morse or Lewis or Midsomer murders ...but the Sherlock Holmes series i loved

so,which is next to talk about??...I watched Young Sherlock Holmes a couple of weeks back ,damn shame there wasn't a sequel to that it was asking for one

Interesting seeing the differences between this, the RDJr movies, and the BBC show. Not real familiar with the Holmes lore but I've enjoyed what I've seen.

We've started watching the Granada show with my daughter, so now that seems to be in the mix, too, for us.

Which is okay, since Holmes has always been of great interest to me. And all of these versions are very, very different. And all good, too, which is surprising (I certainly wasn't expecting much from the CBS show, but it's better than I would have guessed).

On the Granada show, while I love Jeremy Brett's performance, I can't say I feel the same about the whole production. Something about it often feels stodgy to me. And it can lack tension when it should absolutely have it. I've felt this way about most of the British mystery shows (which is a shame, because my wife loves them). Poirot, for example. Love Suchet. Love the 20s style, too, but the show just leaves me meh.

I like the Granada shows because they were like watching the original books,and of course i loved Brett's performance..everything in the series reminded me of the original Sidney Paget drawings that accompany the books i have

I went to the Granada Studios Tour back in the 80s when the show was at it's strongest(as Granada Studios is based in Manchester),and i walked down 'Baker Street' and rode on the '1800's tram' as well(it's always fun when i tease Myto about that as well,as she is a fan of the show)

Never liked Poirot,Morse or Lewis or Midsomer murders ...but the Sherlock Holmes series i loved

so,which is next to talk about??...I watched Young Sherlock Holmes a couple of weeks back ,damn shame there wasn't a sequel to that it was asking for one

The actor they got to play Young Sherlock Holmes just captured everything great about the character. It's one of my favorites as well.

Edit: as an aside to Sherlock Holmes' fans, there's a reprint of the most excellent Sherlock Holmes Consulting Detective game coming out shortly. Playing that game with a group of friends as a high schooler is one of my fondest memories. Such a great game.

« Last Edit: November 14, 2012, 10:46:15 PM by hepcat »

Logged

Warning: You will see my penis. -Brian

Just remember: once a user figures out gluten noting them they're allowed to make fun of you. - Ceekay speaking in tongues.

glad its been renewed but it was almost a guarantee it would be. It has done quite well, ratings wise. After all of the accusations from across the pond about this show being a rip off of BBC's awesome series Sherlock, it turns out that Elementary is completely different. I had my doubts when the show was announced but its turned out to be quite entertaining. While the two shows share the very basic commonalities from the Holmes mythos, the similarities stop there. Theres good chemistry between the leads and making Watson a woman has worked well without feeling gimmicky.

glad its been renewed but it was almost a guarantee it would be. It has done quite well, ratings wise. After all of the accusations from across the pond about this show being a rip off of BBC's awesome series Sherlock, it turns out that Elementary is completely different. I had my doubts when the show was announced but its turned out to be quite entertaining. While the two shows share the very basic commonalities from the Holmes mythos, the similarities stop there. Theres good chemistry between the leads and making Watson a woman has worked well without feeling gimmicky.

meh,when Moffat first said what he said about Elementary,he quickly changed his mind a few months later when shown the pilot and he saw it was a lot different from Sherlock,he expressed that he was a fan before the Pilot was even shown in the U.S...he was first upset because they wanted Moffat to remake Sherlock for the U.S,and he said no,so CBS made Elementary...giving the circumstances,you could see how he could be upset,but he saw the Pilot and changed his mind

I mean i was in two minds before i saw the show,whether it would be any good,with it being in New York starring Johnny Lee Miller and having Lucy Lui as Watson....would anybody else think it would be a dead cert for excellence?

Benedict Cumberbatch when told about it said if there is room for two Sherlock Holmes then there is room for three Sherlock HolmesActually Cumberbatch went on record to complain about being misquoted when saying Johnny Lee Miller(both who are friends) was doing Elementary for the pay cheque

Spoiler for Hiden:

Quote

"I am both bemused and upset at this misquote. I never said that Johnny took the job for the paycheck nor did I ask him not to do it. What I said is I would have preferred not to be in the situation where we will again be compared because we are friends. I know for a fact his motivations were to do with the quality of the script and the challenges of this exceptional role."It is baffling because I have only been supportive of an incredibly talented actor who I am proud to call a friend taking a job I know he is going to enjoy immensely and be wonderful in."Over 70 actors have played this exceptional character before us. To say that there can be only one Holmes would be ludicrous. We're both thrilled to get the opportunity to play him in a modern context. The world of Sherlock Holmes and the world that we live in now is big enough to take more than one interpretation. As a genuine Sherlock Holmes fan I am greatly looking forward to his series."

One thing i am disappointed in,and this goes with Sherlock as well is that we have not seen Holmes in any disguises,we saw in Sherlock him dressed as a Security guard,but that just meant he put a uniform on

My comments were not meant as an indictment of Moffat, which is why I did not use his name in my comments. I was merely expressing my surprise and happiness that the show is indeed a completely different take on Holmes, when compared to the BBC series. I understood Moffats concerns ( though when he expressed them I thought he was over the top, as well as a bit premature in his statements ) Im just glad that they ended up being unfounded.

My comments were not meant as an indictment of Moffat, which is why I did not use his name in my comments. I was merely expressing my surprise and happiness that the show is indeed a completely different take on Holmes, when compared to the BBC series. I understood Moffats concerns ( though when he expressed them I thought he was over the top, as well as a bit premature in his statements ) Im just glad that they ended up being unfounded.

I can do nothing but agree with you

The biggest surprise for me is actually liking Johnny Lee Miller in something,ex-Mr Angelina Jolie hasn't really been doing it for me until this came along....(Apart from Trainspotting)

Well, tonight is the finale for both this and Person of Interest, so they will be taking more weeks off, unfortunately. I dig both of these shows, which is odd, since I normally hate CBS procedurals. These are actually a bit different, though.

Logged

Patriotism means being loyal to your country all the time and to its government when it deserves it - Mark Twain

Well, tonight is the finale for both this and Person of Interest, so they will be taking more weeks off, unfortunately. I dig both of these shows, which is odd, since I normally hate CBS procedurals. These are actually a bit different, though.

Huh,it says on the wiki episode list that the last episode is a double episode(episode 23 and 24) on May 16th for you guys,although if its on tonight then the dates are wrong anyway because it says you still have May 9th episode as well(episode 22)...have they changed plans?http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/List_of_Elementary_episodes

Well, tonight is the finale for both this and Person of Interest, so they will be taking more weeks off, unfortunately. I dig both of these shows, which is odd, since I normally hate CBS procedurals. These are actually a bit different, though.

Huh,it says on the wiki episode list that the last episode is a double episode(episode 23 and 24) on May 16th for you guys,although if its on tonight then the dates are wrong anyway because it says you still have May 9th episode as well(episode 22)...have they changed plans?http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/List_of_Elementary_episodes

yeah, Thursday's episode is #22, and next week is 23 & 24.

Logged

Because I can,also because I don't care what you want.XBL: OriginalCeeKayWii U: CeeKay

I am going to miss the Thursday night line up. Ive enjoyed both shows a lot. I will say that Person of Interest has really rocked it lately. The addition of Shaw and the ongoing battles with Root have been great fun. Oh and Shaw is amazingly hot! She makes violence seem seductive.