Wednesday, March 03, 2010

I am not a legal scholar nor am I a SCOTUS groupie. I am a gun owner and have given a large portion of my life to a service I believe was to defend this country and our constitutional rights. In my simple layman's mind, I always believed and can not see how it is otherwise than that the Bill of Rights applies to ALL citizens of the United States of America. Apparently this idea that I had has a term to describe it and that is "incorporation".

It seems that the U.S. Constitution wasn't accepted to have applied to all citizens but only those in Federal enclaves such as the capital, Washington, D.C. How then did the SCOTUS manage to come up with the decision they made in Rowe v. Wade? Why do states all read a suspect his/her "Miranda rights"? Seems to me that it was spin...

Well, Chicago and Illinois have long had rather draconian "gun" laws (really people control laws) and on behalf of one Mr. Otis McDonald suit was filed for relief. Yesterday, oral arguments were made before the Supreme Court of the United States. David Hardy and others seem to think that incorporation will win. We'll have to wait and see and also see just what the result of the ruling will be.

Just about 2 years ago, in District of Columbia v. Heller, gun owners and gun owners' rights advocates thought they'd had affirmation of the 2nd Amendment to the Constitution. The result in D.C. has been a series of obstructionist moves by the local government without enforcement of the ruling by the Executive Branch (i.e. the President, Barack Obama). Further, some cities and states, such as Massachusetts, Illinois, New York City, and Chicago have refused to accept that U.S. Constitution applies to the people within their borders. Thus we have this lawsuit.

Given the current Congress's inability to comprehend the Constitution, precedent, or even common sense, I doubt that they or their kin at the local level will move to comply with any ruling that eases access to firearms for the law abiding. Such a concept is the antitheses of their belief that the common person is capable of reasoned self-determination.

If you want a really educated explanation of the case or simply to read further I suggest that you check out David Hardy's blog, Of Arms and the Law and the links he provides.

Food for Thought

"Necessity is the plea for every infringement of human freedom. It is the argument of tyrants; it is the creed of slaves."(William Pitt,Nov. 18, 1783)

"Stand your ground. Don't fire unless fired upon, but if they mean to have a war, let it begin here."Captain John Parker, Apr. 19, 1775The Four Rules

1. All guns are always loaded.2. Never let the muzzle cover anything you are not willing to destroy.3. Keep your finger off the trigger until your sights are on the target.4. Be sure of your target and what is behind it.

NRA Newsfeed

FTC Advertising Notice

The FTC seeks to regulate blogs which advertise product or advocate for certain political views. The author of this blog is not compensated by any company for use, review, remark, link to, or mention of of any product on this or any other blog at any time or in any amount. Products shown, mentioned, reported, demonstrated, or linked to from this blog are those which the author has found to be of high quality, useful, interesting or otherwise needed by himself, family, or friends because of personal experience and the mentions, reports, demonstrations and links are meant to benefit readers but are not to be construed as an endorsement of the product, service or information provided.

Political comments, whether they be the views of the author or opinions on the views, policies or actions of political figures, parties or organizations, formal or informal, are solely those of the author and protected under the 1st Amendment to the Constitution of the United States of America.

This blog is therefore not covered by the FTC restrictions in any way, shape or form.

Legal Disclaimer

This blog is a journal intended to inform and entertain my grandchildren. The reader is solely responsible for the correct use and/or application of any and all load data or other information provided herein. Neither the author, sources, nor my heirs or assigns are in any way responsible for the misuse or misapplication of the contents of this blog. It is the reader's responsibility to comply with law and regulation in effect at the place where application of the included information is attempted.