Yes, I know - but that is why I haven't seen the movie yet! I finally just broke down and rented whatever they have at Blockbuster, but it certainly doesn't say 'Director's Cut' on it, so I have to assume it's the theatrical version.

GANDALF with 49
Legolas with 17
Maedhros with 10
Rosie with 7
Beren with 6
Arwen with 6
The Moth with 6
Luthien with 5
Sauron with 5
Sam with 4
Lorien with 3
Ulmo with 3
Faramir with 3
The Balrog with 3
Frodo with 3
Eowyn with 2
Finrod with 2
Boromir with 2
Aragorn with 2
Maglor with 2
Feanor with 2
Eru with 2
and the following with one vote apiece:
Orome
Finduilas
Pippin
Eomer
The witch-king
Galadriel
Morgoth
Elrond
The Black Squirrels
The Fox
Manwe
Hama
The Ward
Denethor
Cirdan
Bilbo
Morwen
A Midgewater Mosquito
Nerdanel
Nimloth
Elbereth
Gimli
Beleg
Earendil