Re: durability of iPhone 5 without case or screen/back protector

Check this video out the guy is on some cobblestone walkway in Shanghai I believe and compares the GS3 and iPhone 5 against drops it's pretty amazing. If this is any indication on how well the iPhone 5 holds up it's leaps and bounds ahead of the 4/4S!

Re: durability of iPhone 5 without case or screen/back protector

My sister bought an iPhone 5 a couple weeks ago, and after she was done setting it up, while it was still plugged into her laptop, she knocked it off her desk. Because of the cord, it did not hit the floor but instead hit the side of the desk. The screen was completely shattered. If the iPhone 5 hits flush on the screen it will shatter.

durability of iPhone 5 without case or screen/back protector

I have a white one, so this may not count, but I have a few minor nicks. They aren't really noticeable though. I dropped it once on a tile floor when I first got it and it just got the smallest of scratches on the edge. Overall I think it has held up well so far.

durability of iPhone 5 without case or screen/back protector

I have the black/slate I have one tiny scratch on the bezel and that was my otter box commuter case! It was brand new and flawless when I put it in there and when it came out to be put in another case I noticed the scratch if you like it naked do that, I'd suggest AppleCare or a zagg invisible shield

Re: durability of iPhone 5 without case or screen/back protector

Wife dropped hers in a case. The bezel dented with a case. This is aluminum bezel instead of steel like the 4 or 4S. I'm rolling naked with mine right now but I have the peace and mind with Apple Care+. I have the black iPhone and no scratches yet with or without a case and mine is a launch day delivery.

Re: durability of iPhone 5 without case or screen/back protector

so with apple care+, you can get a replacement even with a ding? I thought apple care only replaces a defective phone or maybe shattered screen, but not a ding... how many replacement can you get per year?

Re: durability of iPhone 5 without case or screen/back protector

Originally Posted by gameson

so with apple care+, you can get a replacement even with a ding? I thought apple care only replaces a defective phone or maybe shattered screen, but not a ding... how many replacement can you get per year?

You get 2 replacements total. If you ding your phone, you can get it replaced but then you used 1 of your 2. It has $50 deductible per physical damage incident. Not worth it over a ding.

durability of iPhone 5 without case or screen/back protector

The phone doesn't seem to shatter as readily but it sure chips and scratches around the edges a whole lot. I work at AT&T and out store display black iPhone 5 has no finish on the edge. It's all scuffed up and silver.

durability of iPhone 5 without case or screen/back protector

Originally Posted by trtmazda3

The phone doesn't seem to starter as readily but it sure chips and scratches around the edges a whole lot. I work at AT&T and out store display black iPhone 5 has no finish on the edge. It's all scuffed up and silver.

durability of iPhone 5 without case or screen/back protector

Here's the thing, the phone is going to get scratches. I had a case on it from the day I bought it and somehow it still got a ding and I never dropped it. The case made the phone twice the thickness. I think that I will be able to live with a few scratches. My wife has the 4S and it has scratches and doesn't took that bad.

durability of iPhone 5 without case or screen/back protector

I have neither a case or screen protectors on my black iPhone 5. It does get a few spots where the anodizing has been scratched off, not on the back but on the beveled edges of the sides. No scratches on the screen but I'm careful and put it in a small sleeve before dumping it in my purse.

To me the small dings on the beveled edges don't detract from its looks at all.

durability of iPhone 5 without case or screen/back protector

durability of iPhone 5 without case or screen/back protector

I'm caseless also. It's a phone not a priceless diamond. If I want to put a case on it then its mostly for a different look or feel. I buy insurance like apple care. If I drop it and it breaks I replace it.

Re: durability of iPhone 5 without case or screen/back protector

I have had mine for a month and I think the screen is weaker. I keep the phone in my pocket and the only thing that will go in my pocket with it is the headphones. I wont even do that now because i see little scratches on the screen i am about to put a protecter on the screen. My 4s screen still looks new. Do you think they could not make it as strong because of the size? I am very good with my phones my 3gs 4 and 4s all looked new before I handed them down. I am just bummed the screen is not as tough but i do run a case cause im not about to find out the back is just as weak plus it is a little slippery.

durability of iPhone 5 without case or screen/back protector

durability of iPhone 5 without case or screen/back protector

I have a ding on mine that is the size of a pin head but I don't know if it was there when I bought the phone or not. I immediately put a case on it when I bought it. But when I took it off is when I noticed the ding. Since taking the phone out if the case, I haven't seen another scratch on it. I did drop it on a hardwood floor from about two feet. No damage.