In the song, Angelica has returned to the United States following the events of The Reynolds Pamphlet and Alexander's confession to the affair. And she really lets him have it.

In Hamilton: The Revolution (p. 235), Lin wrote of this song: "It came between The Reynolds Pamphlet and Burn, But we realized that the audience desperately wanted to see Eliza's reaction, so I folded the best parts of it into The Reynolds Pamphlet.