Peyton Manning is every bit the postseason QB Tom Brady is...and I can prove it.

and give me a ****ing break...

that Chiefs/Colts game was over from the first snap...the Chiefs didn't have a first down for 2.75 quarters...

Sure, the Colts defense was the MVP of that game.

Peyton Manning was also down 3-21 against the Patriots in the 1st half of the NFC Championship Game and he didn't come back to beat the almighty Tom Brady in that game? He gets NO credit for that? None?

And the Colts didn't have a 39 to 21 minute T.O.P win over the Bears in the Super Bowl? Peyton Manning gets no credit for 40 minutes of offensive possession against the 2nd best defense in the past 20 years?

BurtGummer44Magnum... oh my, Burt... have you been thrown out of rehab, again?

We love you but we cant go on this way, Burt.

In 9 years Eli has 2 SB Rings, both over Tom Brady's Pats, he's 8-3 in the playoffs with 5 road playoff wins. Hands down the better Prime Time QB. He suffers from bad streaks in the regular season, but once in the playoffs he's lights out compared to big brother. If you are satisfied with a 12-4 team every year that will fizzle in the playoffs, take Peyton. But if it's championships that you want, Eli is the better choice.

Peyton Manning is every bit the postseason QB Tom Brady is...and I can prove it.

and give me a ****ing break...

that Chiefs/Colts game was over from the first snap...the Chiefs didn't have a first down for 2.75 quarters...

Sure, the Colts defense was the MVP of that game.

Peyton Manning was also down 3-21 against the Patriots in the 1st half of the NFC Championship Game and he didn't come back to beat the almighty Tom Brady in that game? He gets NO credit for that? None?

And the Colts didn't have a 39 to 21 minute T.O.P win over the Bears in the Super Bowl? Peyton Manning gets no credit for 40 minutes of offensive possession against the 2nd best defense in the past 20 years?

Peyton Manning is every bit the postseason QB Tom Brady is...and I can prove it.

and give me a ****ing break...

that Chiefs/Colts game was over from the first snap...the Chiefs didn't have a first down for 2.75 quarters...

Sure, the Colts defense was the MVP of that game.

Peyton Manning was also down 3-21 against the Patriots in the 1st half of the NFC Championship Game and he didn't come back to beat the almighty Tom Brady in that game? He gets NO credit for that? None?

And the Colts didn't have a 39 to 21 minute T.O.P win over the Bears in the Super Bowl? Peyton Manning gets no credit for 40 minutes of offensive possession against the 2nd best defense in the past 20 years?

so if Peyton Manning is a choker, and he very well may be...what does that make Tom Terrific?

Dude you need to take Peytons' cock out of your mouth again.
Remember the Donko playoff loss a little over a couple months ago?
If you don't you need to go back and revisit that thread.
Peyton Manning is the biggest choke artist the game has ever seen.

Isnt Tom a good example of how it takes a team to win a SB though?
He won all his rings in the early 2000s, yet no one could argue that Tom Brady 2003 > Tom Brady 2012.

He has improved as a player and despite the fact he has played his best ball of his career the past 5 years, he does not have any rings over that span.

He had defensive help in the early 2000s, now we see that even the great Tom Brady cannot carry a team by himself
This does not make him overrated, nor does it show how his individual accomplishments should always translate into playoff and SB success

Isnt Tom a good example of how it takes a team to win a SB though?
He won all his rings in the early 2000s, yet no one could argue that Tom Brady 2003 > Tom Brady 2012.

He has improved as a player and despite the fact he has played his best ball of his career the past 5 years, he does not have any rings over that span.

He had defensive help in the early 2000s, now we see that even the great Tom Brady cannot carry a team by himself
This does not make him overrated, nor does it show how his individual accomplishments should always translate into playoff and SB success

Football is a team sport, and Peyton Manning is a victim of overall piss poor team building by Bill Polian as much as he is a victim of his own chokes.

The fact that he had inferior teams may well be the cause of his choking.

It has to be far more difficult knowing full well that you have to be the guy in ecery game.

I love peyton as a qb. But of his 9 playoff wins including superbowl. 4 of those have come against kc and denver. Whom happen to be more consistent chokers. He will retire as one of the top 3 all time qbs. But he for some reason loves the 1 and done. That might be a single record also.