Pages

April 9, 2015

Dealing With Bad Ideas: Introduction

As we moved into 2015, I indicated that I planned to focus more on free speech. I am happy to report that this is exactly what I have been doing. While it has not eclipsed the other topics I address here, I have been giving it more attention so far this year than I had previously.

Now I'd like to start what I expect to be a slow and lengthy process of taking a look at how we deal with bad ideas and whether attempting to suppress their expression is one of the strategies we should be pursuing.

Here is what I wrote previously on this subject:

I believe that the answer to bad ideas (e.g., sexism, racism, creationism, faith) is not to suppress them through the use of legislation and/or social coercion against those who hold them; the way to answer bad ideas is to reveal their shortcomings in the public forum and provide reasonable alternatives.

At the outset of this discussion, I want to stress two important points that should be kept in mind. First, while my thoughts on the subject of free speech have been influenced by many sources and are continuing to evolve, I anticipate that I will be drawing heavily on one source in particular: On Liberty by John Stuart Mill. I've been re-reading this book lately, and it has prompted me to ask some difficult questions of myself and to critically examine many of my preconceived notions about the free expression of ideas and the role of free speech in society. It has provided some of the ideas I plan to explore here.

The second point I want to make here at the beginning is that many of the views I will be sharing here are somewhat new for me. A big part of why I am doing this is that I want to try on some aspects of this philosophy (starting with but not limited to Mill's) to see if it is tenable and where it might lead. My mind is far from made up, and I expect that my perspective will continue to develop as a result of writing about it and attempting to apply it in my daily life.

What Do I Mean By Bad Ideas?

I'd like to keep this as simple as we possibly can and say that a "bad idea" in the context of this discussion is nothing more than an idea you or I consider to be a bad one. I'm okay with this being completely subjective, at least for now. This means that I'm not generally thinking of claims about reality that can easily be shown to be true or false or about one's personal preferences. When I refer to bad ideas, I'm thinking mostly about the sort of attitudes we are often motivated to try to change, worldviews to which we are likely to object, and theories we oppose.

Yes, some ideas are bad because they are inconsistent with facts or are based on claims that have been shown to be false (e.g., climate change denial, creationism). But there are many others that take us into areas where factual information is either difficult to come by or only marginally relevant. The set of ideas most of us would refer to as racism are bad for a variety of reasons, only some of which involve factual claims of the sort that can be demonstrably true or false. Many political ideas are loosely associated with factual claims and instead involve suggestions for shaping society in various ways that reflect values. The idea that causing offense to Muslims can justify murder is a bad idea that does not readily lend itself to the sort of factual analysis we might like. So while an idea can sometimes be revealed to be bad because its basis can be shown to be false, this is not true for all (perhaps even most) of the ideas we consider to be bad ones.

I'm excluding personal preferences from consideration as bad ideas because these are statements about the person making them with no relevance outside a particular individual. They cannot be good or bad; they just are. My love of metal music would fit here, as would my strong dislike of Brussels sprouts. As long as I'm not trying to make general claims about the nature of reality or attempting to impose my preferences on others, these are statements about me can't be good or bad (or right or wrong) in any meaningful sense.