IPM: from Integrated Pest Management to Intelligent Pest Management

Transcription

1 IPM: from Integrated Pest Management to Intelligent Pest Management About the author: Joe Boggs Assistant Professor The Ohio State University Extension and OSU Department of Entomology Joe Boggs Boggs draws upon years of practical experience in providing technical support and educational outreach on tree pest diagnostics and management to reexamine well-known Integrated Pest Management principles through the lens of modern arboriculture. The result is a simple 4-Step approach to pest management. From determining which pests matter to deciding when to pull the pesticide trigger, this presentation uses real-life case studies to educate participants on how to apply intelligent pest management concepts to meet client needs and expectations. Extended abstract: Arboriculture has always included a customer service component. However, at no other time have tree service customers had access to so much information. Unfortunately, information that shapes societal attitudes towards pest management is often inaccurate, inconsistent, and subject to the vagaries of 1-minute media sound bites and 140-character text messages. Social networking means the impact of a single misapplication of an insecticide can quickly reverberate around the world to immediately influence the attitudes of tree care customers. While it may seem that trying to meet client needs and expectations in the age of social media is like trying to hit a moving target, there is one expectation that remains unchanging: clients want perfect landscapes at minimal costs. Of course, there is no avoiding the fact that trees will have pests. Indeed, all landscape plants including trees are living organisms and there are other living organisms that will make a living on them. The only way to have perfect landscapes is to use silk flowers and artificial turf! It is important to keep things in perspective; to educate our tree care clients on some simple facts about insect and mite tree pests. This is not an easy task given the common misconception that most insects and mites are pests. In fact, of the 90,000+ described species of insects in North America north of Mexico, only 6,700 are pests (7.4%) and only 700 are serious pests (0.7%). The remaining 6,000 (6.6%) insect species rarely cause significant damage. Mites and microorganisms probably conform to a similar if not more dramatic ratio. This reality flies in the face of the public's perception that first and foremost, insects cause damage and they are scary! In fact, insects are so beneficial they are considered "key organisms" in all terrestrial ecosystems. This designation means that if insects are removed, the ecosystems would collapse! As the famed Harvard biologist, E.O. Wilson said, "If all mankind were to disappear, the world would regenerate back to the rich state of equilibrium

2 that existed ten thousand years ago. If insects were to vanish, the environment would collapse into chaos." Very few insects are pests and all pests are not equal. A few hickory tussock moth caterpillars feeding on the leaves of a mature oak tree causes no harm to the overall health of the tree; it's not about looks, it's about tree health. The Integrated Pest Management (IPM) concept first appeared in print in 1967 (1). The approach evolved out of pest managers and entomologists recognizing that the continual reliance on a single pest management tactic - insecticides - had produced a number of unintended consequences including pest resistance and negative environmental impacts. The IPM approach combined the judicious use of insecticides with other pest management tools including the use of cultural (e.g. plant selection) and biological (e.g. insect predators) pest suppression methods. IPM was widely adopted by both agricultural crop managers as well as entomologists. In fact, it was so widely accepted by the scientific community that by 2000, there were 67 published definitions for IPM (2). Although different, some shared common ideas and language. For example, 54% included the word economics; 48% had the word "environment;" 25% included "ecology" or "ecological;" and 17% referenced "economic threshold" or "economic injury level." Many "how to" conceptual guides to IPM decision-making have also evolved over time. Some are lists; others are graphic depictions of the components of an IPM program. An example of an IPM list appears on the Cornel University Biological Control website (3). There are four components: 1. Set Action Thresholds 2. Monitor and Identify Pests 3. Prevention 4. Control. A graphic depiction of the components of an IPM program appears in Figure 1 (4). "Cultural" tactics serve as the base signifying a greater importance compared to "Chemical" tactics at the top. The point is further emphasized by the arrows on the left showing tactics towards the base are "preventative" whereas tactics at the top are "intervention."

3 A simple 3-component graphic representation of IPM tactics has been used by the speaker for a number of years (Figure 2). The value of this elementary visual perspective is that the tactics are easy to remember and tied together by the need to "Monitor;" from keeping an eye on the overall health of trees, to monitoring for developing pest problems, to gauging the need to react, to assessing the efficacy of applied pest management tactics. Another way to visualize the importance of integrating all three components is to view this graphic as a threelegged stool with the seat being "Monitor." Remove any piece of the stool, and it collapses! The IPM concept was first introduced to manage pest of field crops such as corn, soybeans, cotton, etc. Figure 3 illustrates that the objective is use the three basic IPM tactics to keep pest populations below a recognized "Economic Threshold" that has been established through scientific research. Unfortunately, there are no economic thresholds for urban trees based on direct values such as those used for field crops. For example, just because a blue spruce was purchased for $500 does not justify spending $500 to protect the spruce; the tree would then be worth $1,000, but it's never going to be sold. Replacement cost values for urban trees are not connected to the economics of pest management decisions except for documenting loss; using them to justify expenditures falls under the "value added" economic column rather than return on investment. Of course, the National Tree Benefits Calculator (5) does allow us to determine tree benefits values, such as impacts on property value, heating/cooling costs, etc., for urban trees. These values have been justifiably used to validate preventative insecticide applications to protect ash trees from emerald ash borer (EAB); however, they are not the same as the "Economic Thresholds" used in IPM programs which are like on - off switches over time. As pest populations approach Economic Thresholds (a.k.a. Action Thresholds), IPM tactics are brought to bear (switches are turned on) to suppress the pest population. The justification for action is that costs will be covered through increased crop yields, such as an increase in bushels of corn per acre. If the "switch" is an insecticide application, it's turned on to suppress, and turned off once the pest population drops below the economic threshold; applications are not continual. The switch is turned on and stays on with protecting ash trees from EAB and the expected return on investment is measured through indirect economic benefits such as reduced heating/cooling costs; the trees themselves are not being sold.

4 With no real economic thresholds for urban trees, pest management decisions are often based solely on "Aesthetic Thresholds." This is highly subjective; pest impacts are in the eyes of the beholder. One of the 67 definitions for IPM published prior to the year 2000 read: "Integrated Pest Management means 'Intelligent Pest Management'" (6). Applying this prescient message to urban tree pest management means all aspects of modern arboricultural knowledge should be brought to bear in dealing with tree pests. Following is a simple 4-Step pest management program that meets that standard: 4 Steps in an Effective Pest Management Program for Urban Trees: 1. Support good tree health! 2. Identify the pest(s): the Diagnosis. 3. Separate the serious pests from the not-so-serious pests. 4. Devise a multi-tactic management strategy targeting the serious pests. Supporting good tree health is the first step because by fully exploiting this step, steps 2, 3, and 4 may never need to be considered! Step 1 includes three simple actions: proper tree selection (right tree, right place); proper installation (plant it right!); and appropriate aftercare (proper watering, pruning, etc.). Tree selection includes considering trees that are resistant to a prevailing pest problem. Planting non-native birch trees where the North American native bronze birch borer is endemic is not a good idea; planting native birch trees is a good idea. Proper pest identification has historically been viewed as the first step in a pest management program. However, as noted above, if step 1 is fully followed, there may be no need to identify a pest; there may be no pest! Of course, even the best managed trees may attract unwanted pests. The key is to make certain that you are making an accurate identification and you are certain the problem is indeed a tree pest and not some other problem such as a disease or physiological issue; the value of employing accurate tree problem diagnostics should never be ignored. Separating the serious from the not-so-serious pests can be a challenge; however, the full evaluation should be based on pest impacts on tree health rather than on tree aesthetics. Fortunately, much has been learned over the years regarding the intricate relationships between native pests and their native tree hosts. Native pests are not killers of their native hosts; if they were, both would have gone extinct. However, it is common for native pests to select stressed or dying native hosts which takes us back to Step 1! It is important to keep things in perspective; to educate our tree care clients on the true facts about tree pests and their hosts. Finally, devise a multi-tactic management strategy (IPM) targeting the serious pests. This final-step positioning of integrated pest management illustrates the proper perspective relative to tree pests: it's not all about pests, it's all about trees! This is why the simple 3- component IPM visual graphic presented in Figure 2 is so helpful; it's really a simple "treatment" selection triangle. Dealing with redheaded pine sawfly? Your hands and feet provide the most effective "Cultural" treatment of the problem: knock the sawfly colonies to the ground and step on them! Dealing with aphids? Perhaps the best "treatment" is to do

5 nothing a let the "Biological" component do the job; aphids are the meat items of the insect world. Have a North American tree that is heavily infested with the calico scale? This sucking insect is non-native to North America, so populations can build rapidly requiring the selection of a "Chemical" IPM component. However, using a systemic rather than a topical insecticide will reduce exposure to beneficial insects; it will preserve the "Biological" component on the IPM triangle. The bottom line is that IPM should mean "Intelligent Pest Management." After all, the original IPM concept took us away from an identify-and-kill approach to pest management and focused our attention on more holistic perspectives. It's not just about tree pests, it's about trees; and it's also about arborists making intelligent pest management decisions. References: 1. Smith, R. F., & van den Bosch, R. (1967). Integrated control. In: W.W. Kilglore & R.L. Doutt (Eds.), Pest control: biological, physical and selected chemical methods (pp ). New York: Academic Press. 2. Waheed I. Bajwa and Marcos Kogan Compendium of IPM Definitions (CID), What is IPM and how is it defined in the Worldwide Literature? Integrated Plant Protection Center (IPPC), Oregon State University, Publication 998, May Cornel University Biological Control Website: 4. Penn State Extension; PA Integrated Pest Management website: 5. National Tree Benefits Calculator 6. Zweig, G. and A. Aspelin The role of pesticides in developing countries. In: Formulation of pesticides in developing countries. United Nations Industrial Developing Organization. United Nations Publication E B P: pp 1-12

Technology Fact Sheet for Adaptation Upscaling of locally proven IPM technologies for control of pest of economic importance i Technology: Upscaling of locally proven IPM technologies for control of pest

What is a pest? How Insects Become Pests How do insects become pests? Introduction outside of native range Becomes disease vector Plant or animal (inclu. human) disease vector Host shift in native insect

DEPARTMENT OF PRIMARY INDUSTRY AND FISHERIES Principles of Integrated Pest Management Deanna Chin and Brian Thistleton, Entomology, Diagnostic Services What is a pest? Principles of IPM Introduction to

Chapter 1: Integrated Pest Management (IPM) Introduction Pests are an inevitable problem faced by nursery growers. For the purposes of this document, the term pest refers to insects, diseases, weeds, slugs,

Pest Management - Holistic Pest Control? 2. Modern control tactics and the birth of IPM The action of parasites, predators, and pathogens in maintaining another organism s density at a lower average than

Chapter 2 Integrated Pest Management In This Chapter Keywords After learning the information in this chapter, you will be able to: 1. Define Integrated Pest Management (IPM). 2. List and describe the 5

SLIDE 1: This is Steve Johnson, University of Maine Cooperative Extension, bringing you information on Integrated Pest Management. It is possible to receive a Maine Board of Pesticides Control recertification

Economics of Pesticide Use 1 What are the Benefits of Pesticides?! Despite well-deserved demonization, pesticides have many benefits! e.g. Americans pay less of their income on food (7-8%), than any other

GS-21F-0037W Leaders in a domestic and global arena F rancis A. Bartlett founded the F. A. Bartlett Tree Expert Company in 1907. His mission was to provide scientifically based care to improve the safety,

Module #4 What is a Threshold? p. 1 www.nysaes.cornell.edu/ipmnet/ne.ipm.region What is a Threshold? By James VanKirk Overview Concept Activity Handouts The Economic Injury Level and the Action Threshold

Integrated Pest Management Ecology and Human Impact R. Bruce Chapman Insect Science Ltd Pest organisms When do organisms become pests? When an organism s population exceeds a threshold level, and control

A DISCOVERY REGARDING THE DEATH OF ASH TREES IN THE PLYMOUTH AREA As you are probably aware, we have seen a significant amount of dying ash trees in the Plymouth, Canton, Northville area. This prompted

6 Ways to Kill a Cockroach: How to Rid Your Home of Roaches, Ants, and Other Unhealthy Pests Florida's warm and humid climate is a magnet for many insect pests that often threaten your home. It would be

INSECT MANAGEMENT (Roberts & McPherson) A number of insect pests are capable of severely damaging soybeans. However, it is important to realize that soybeans can withstand considerable insect damage at

Unit D: Controlling Pests and Diseases in the Orchard Lesson 1: Managing and Controlling Pests of Fruit and Nut Crops Student Learning Objectives: Instruction in this lesson should result in students achieving

INTEGRATED PEST MANAGEMENT SYSTEM FOR KENNESAW STATE UNIVERSITY KENNESAW, GEORGIA PREPARED JANUARY 1997 REVISED NOVEMBER 2006 TABLE OF CONTENTS Introduction and Principles of Integrated Pest Management

In the previous presentation on Human Health and Pesticides, we discussed some of the negative consequences associated with pesticide use. In this presentation we will focus on environmental degradation

Attachment I Santa Barbara County Integrated Pest Management Strategy Mission Statement It is the mission of the County of Santa Barbara to promote environmentally sensitive pest management while preserving

A Ros-E-IQ By Robert B. Martin Jr. The Rose is the most beautiful flower in the environment and rose bushes have diverse uses in the green landscape. But the public's interest in rose gardening is changing.

Afion ynop i Students make food webs of their study site, then trace how a change in one population could affect other populations within the web. Session 1 1. Show a food web made by a team of ecologists.

Introduction to the Biotechnology Supplement What is Biotechnology? Any technological application that uses biological systems, living organisms or derivatives thereof, to make or modify products or processes

Lesson A8 1 Determining the Use of Technology in World Food and Fiber Production Unit A. Mechanical Systems and Technology Problem Area 8. Technology Systems Lesson 1. Determining the Use of Technology

2016 Approved On-line / CD/ Correspondence Courses [Updated Thursday, May 18, 2016] On-line Courses Note: The CEU s indicated with the special category specific indication can be used for the expansion

Insect Pests of Pecan Will Hudson Extension Entomologist How important is nut drop to production? Pecan trees typically lose 75% of the pecans between nut set and shell hardening even when protected from

General Knowledge: Integrated Pest Management (IPM) Integrated Pest Management (IPM) Learning Objectives After studying this section, you should be able to: Define the concept of Integrated Pest Management

Compendium of IPM Definitions (CID) What is IPM and how is it defined in the Worldwide Literature? Waheed I. Bajwa and Marcos Kogan Integrated Plant Protection Center (IPPC) Oregon State University, Corvallis

Farm Energy IQ Conserving Energy in Nutrient Use and Pest Control INTRODUCTION Fertilizers and pesticides are the most widely used sources of nutrients and pest control, respectively. Fertilizer and pesticides

Athens-Clarke County Community Tree Program Black Dotted Brown Moth Athens is experiencing its fourth year of significant infestation by the black dotted brown moth (Cissusa spadix). The caterpillar of

Integrated Pest Management At Boise State University Purpose The purpose of this document is to provide an overview of Boise State University Landscape Service department s philosophy regarding plant health

1. Recent evidence indicates that lakes in large areas of New York State are being affected by acid rain. The major effect of acid rain in the lakes is (1) an increase in game fish population levels (3)

Integrated Pest Management Science and Language Arts Brief Description: This lesson will focus all of the information the students have learned about pests in the other insect lessons in a decision-making

Chemical versus Biological Control of Sugarcane By Abid Hussain Matiari Sugar Mills Ltd. Sugarcane It is an important cash crop, Pakistan is the fifth largest cane producing country. However, its yield

Note: Not all tree care and maintenance practices are addressed in this sample. A licensed arborist should be consulted for recommendations regarding pruning, hazard management, cabling, bracing and treatment

Using IPM In The Landscape Washington State University Urban IPM and Pesticide Safety Education Program Integrated pest management (IPM) is an environmentally sensitive approach to controlling pests that

INTEGRATED PEST MANAGEMENT IN SCHOOLS OVERVIEW OF STATE LAWS Part of the ELI Series Environmental Law Institute Topics in School Environmental Health: Overview of State Laws www.eli.org/buildings/tseh.cfm

Improving Control Systems in Thailand for Plant and Plants Products Intended for Export to the European Union co-funded by the European Union and Thai Department of Agriculture Preharvest Use of Pesticides

Host a Learning Bee Hive! Frequently Asked Questions Honeybees are incredibly important for two main reasons: pollination and honey creation! Pollination: According to the USDA Agricultural Research Service,

Introduction Best Management Practices for Tarnished Plant Bug in Cotton Jeff Gore, Angus Catchot, Don Cook, and Fred Musser Mississippi State University Agricultural and Forestry Experiment Station and

They are beautiful in their peace, They are wise in their silence. They will stand after we are dust. They teach us, and we tend them. G.A. MacDunelmor BASIC GROWING REQUIREMENTS FOR YOUR Oak Trees The

Why hire an arborist? Spring is fast approaching and that means gardens to attend and flowers to plant, but what about your trees? Now is the best time to hire an arborist to maintain your trees before

19 TOPIC 3 INTEGRATED PEST CONTROL Scope Chemical pesticides are now the traditional solution to pest problems, and they have saved lives and crops. Their use, however, has created significant problems,

VII. Appendix G. Entomology Department Strategic Plan Entomology Department: Helping you to Become your Best The ISU Entomology Department has a long history of responsiveness, excellence, training students

The Connecticut Tree Protective Association s Position Statement on Exceptions to the Arborist Law It is the position of the Connecticut Tree Protective Association that, whenever an individual or firm

Edward J. Bechinski and William H. Bohl Potato growers who use IPM consider all available pest control tools. Alternatives to conventional pesticides are the foundation of every IPM plan. Pesticides play

1Code: EBB(2) SOUTH COAST EDUCATION Adopted: 6/12/12 SERVICE DISTRICT Readopted: 1/15/15 Integrated Pest Management To ensure the health and safety concerns of student, staff and community members, the

What you need to know about the management of the Emerald Ash Borer (EAB) Guidelines for hiring tree care services to manage urban trees What is an Emerald Ash Borer? This booklet has been designed for

Natural Enemies in IPM Systems 145 THE IMPORTANCE OF NATURAL ENEMIES IN IPM SYSTEMS I. Problems Resulting From Total Reliance on Pesticides A. Development of insecticide resistance in pest species 1. As

FAQs: Gene drives - - What is a gene drive? During normal sexual reproduction, each of the two versions of a given gene has a 50 percent chance of being inherited by a particular offspring (Fig 1A). Gene

Forest Insect Pests and Diseases Forest insect pests The forest is home to an abundant diversity of organisms, including insects. The study of forest insects is called forest entomology. Many insects play

a white paper from Pete Trotman The effects of biocides legislation on pest management A white paper on the effects of biocides regulation (EU) 528/2012 (BPR) on controlling rodent population This paper