Ask Stacy: How Do I Find a Good Investment Adviser?

Before beginning my career in personal finance news, back in 1991, I worked for about 10 years as a stockbroker, also known as a “financial adviser.” So this week’s question is right up my alley. Here it is:

How do you choose a good, reliable stockbroker? — Anonymous

Here’s your answer, Anonymous:

How to pick a stockbroker? Carefully

Stockbrokers serve two functions. Technically a stockbroker acts as a registered agent to buy or sell securities on behalf of a client. (Hence the term “broker.”)

But the type of stockbroker Anonymous is asking about is probably the one offering a second service: investment advice. And the question is a good one, because the quality of advice you receive can mean the difference between creating a fortune and destroying one.

What’s in a name?

While I called myself a stockbroker back in my day, those in the advice business these days rarely do. Instead, they use titles they presumably hope will convey trust, like financial analyst, financial adviser, financial consultant, financial planner, investment consultant and wealth manager, among others.

When it comes to quality advice, these are all interchangeable labels. None requires any specific education, skill or certification. In fact, your barber probably has more strict licensure requirements than is required to call yourself almost any kind of financial adviser or consultant.

More important than titles? Compensation

While I left the financial advisory business decades ago, the problem for consumers today is the same as it was then. Namely, most advisers make money from commissions. And anyone who does that can never be completely trusted.

Overly harsh? Maybe. There are undoubtedly many commission-based advisers who are both sharp as a tack and honest as the day is long. But they’re working within a rotten system — one that requires them to move your money around to get paid, when often that’s not in your best interests.

Furthermore, the typical stockbroker isn’t required to act as a fiduciary, which would require that they place your financial interests ahead of their own. Instead, they adhere to a lesser standard of conduct, known as suitability. Suitability requires only that they suggest investments that are suitable for an investor with your goals, risk tolerance and financial means.

An example to illustrate the distinction: Suppose your goals and risk tolerance suggest that a stock mutual fund is right for you. There are two similar funds available. One charges a 5 percent commission and the other 2 percent. A fiduciary would be honor-bound to suggest the fund with the lower cost, because that’s obviously in your best interests. The suitability standard, on the other hand, allows the adviser to suggest the fund that pays them the higher commission, because either fund is suitable.

The bottom line is this: A system built on commissions and without fiduciary standards invites abuse. That was true when I started as a stockbroker 35 years ago, and it’s true today.

Who can you trust?

To receive objective advice, you’ve got to take commissions out of the equation. There are two ways to do this. The first is to replace commissions with a simple, annual fee based on the amount being managed. I explained the pluses and minuses of that setup in the post, “Ask Stacy: Why Is My Investment Adviser Charging a Fee on Idle Cash?”

The other way to take commissions off the table — and the better option, in my opinion — is to pay for your financial advice by the hour, the same way you do with an accountant or lawyer. The problem with this approach: Depending on whom you pick, the fees could be high. The adviser I was talking to in the video above, for example, has a minimum fee of $1,500. There are cheaper alternatives, however.

A third option, of course, is to learn the ropes yourself, then make your own decisions. Unlike taxes or law, investing doesn’t require massive training or an advanced degree. Check out “Ask Stacy: How Do I Invest in the Stock Market?”

How to pick an adviser

Here’s how to go about picking the right adviser, however they get paid. These rules also apply to picking an accountant, lawyer, doctor or plumber.

Ask your friends or co-workers for referrals. The most useful will be from people who are in situations somewhat similar to yours.

Check out credentials. You don’t have to be a genius to pass the exams required to obtain securities licenses. Look beyond that and check out educational background and other professional credentials. The Certified Financial Planner (CFP) designation is a good one.

Ask about experience. Credentials and education are nice, but as with most things in life, experience is often the best teacher. If two professionals charge the same price, you’d certainly rather have one with 20 years of experience versus 20 months.

Ask them for references. Any professional in any field should be happy to provide them. Of course, only an idiot would provide the name of someone who would bad-mouth them, so don’t put too much weight on this one.

Talk to several before you decide. This is easily the single most important thing before hiring any service professional. Only after you talk with several possible candidates for the position will the positive attributes you’re seeking surface in one of them.

Ask how they get paid. If you read what I wrote above, this one should be obvious.

Got a question you’d like answered?

A great way to get answers to just about any money-related question is to head to our Forums. It’s the place where you can speak your mind, explore topics in-depth and, most important, post questions and get answers. It’s also where I often look for questions to answer in this weekly column. You can also ask questions by replying to our daily emails. If you’re not getting them, fix that right now by subscribing here.

About me

I founded Money Talks News in 1991. I’ve earned a CPA (currently inactive), and have also earned licenses in stocks, commodities, options principal, mutual funds, life insurance, securities supervisor and real estate. Got some time to kill? You can learn more about me here.

Financial solutions for seniors:

SanDisk Outlet Store takes an extra 17% off its selection of items, already reduced by up to 75% off, via coupon code "LABORDAY17". Shipping starts at $6, but orders of $75 or more qualify for free shipping. Items on offer include flash drives, memory cards, and cables.

Jet.com takes an extra 20% off a selection of patio furniture, grills and smokers, storage, outdoor decor, and more via ... Read
more.

Updated: 4 days 4 hr ago

For in-store pickup only, Lowe's offers the Kobalt Garage Storage System for $7.49. That's $22 off and the lowest price we could find. It fits on on Kobalt garage tool bases and measures 27" x 18". Deal ends October 18.

For in-store pickup only, Lowe's offers the Kobalt Garage Storage System for $7.49. That's $22 off and the lowest price ... Read
more.

Updated: 1 week 2 days ago

Today, Apple announced its new iPhone X, which includes an all-new 5.8" Super Retina OLED display that stretches nearly edge to edge without a bezel. You can now tap the display to wake up the phone, and unlock it using Face ID. It has an A11 Bionic chip neural engine, 12-megapixel dual rear camera with dual OIS, wireless charging, Bluetooth 5.0, and water and dust resistance. It comes in 64GB and 256GB models from $999.

Today, Apple announced its new iPhone X, which includes an all-new 5.8" Super Retina OLED display that stretches nearly edge ... Read
more.

Updated: 2 weeks ago

Backcountry cuts up to 55% off a selection of The North Face men's, women's, and kids' apparel, shoes, and accessories. (Prices are as marked.) Plus, take an extra 20% off when you add to cart. That beats August's mention of just an extra 15% off and is the best sale we've seen on these items all year. Shipping starts at $5.95, but orders of $50 or more qualify for free 2-day shipping. After discount, accessories start as low as $10.38, men's T-shirts at $11.17, men's jackets at $41.58, and women's jackets at $55.41. Size availability for many items is limited.

Backcountry cuts up to 55% off a selection of The North Face men's, women's, and kids' apparel, shoes, and accessories. ... Read
more.

Updated: 4 days 10 hr ago

As part of a class action lawsuit, those who received pre-recorded telemarketing calls from Resort Marketing Group (RMG) between July 2009 and March 2014 may be entitled to monetary compensation. The suit alleges that RMG violated the Telephone Consumer Protection Act by making pre-recorded calls without express consent. Click here to read more about how to make a claim. Claims must be filed by November 3.

As part of a class action lawsuit, those who received pre-recorded telemarketing calls from Resort Marketing Group (RMG) between July ... Read
more.

Updated: August 14, 2017

As part of a class action lawsuit, customers who purchased certain Honest Diapering, Cleaning, or Personal care products between January 17, 2012 and July 10, 2017 may be entitled to cash compensation. The suit alleges that Honest engaged in deceptive practices in their advertising and labeling of products. Eligible customers can receive $2.50 for each item with proof of purchase, and up to ten items without proof of purchase. Click here to find out more information. Claims must be submitted by October 23.

Walmart continues to discount thousands of items as part of its End of Summer Clearance Sale. Opt for in-store pickup ... Read
more.

Updated: 5 days 5 hr ago

At P.F. Chang's, buy one entrée and get a second entrée of equal or lesser value for free when you fill out this short form. (You'll receive this offer via email.) That's tied with our mention from a month ago as the best entrée freebie we've seen from P.F. Chang's. (We've seen BOGO entrées several times before, but it's usually restricted to specific entrées.) It's valid for dine-in only for 14 days from offer sign-up date. Click here to find a location near you.

If you'd rather dine solo (or maybe just make your lunch buddy buy their own darn meal for once), you can also get an entrée salad paired with a cup of soup for $10. It's also only valid for dine-in; just mention the offer to your server to redeem. (Offer only applies to the Asian Caesar, Mandarin Crunch, and Vietnamese Noodle salads.) This deal ends September 26.

At P.F. Chang's, buy one entrée and get a second entrée of equal or lesser value for free when you ... Read
more.

Updated: 23 hr 29 min ago

Abercrombie & Fitch cuts up to 50% off sale items and up to 70% off clearance. (Prices are as marked.) Shipping adds $7, but orders of $75 or more net free shipping. Women's swimwear starts at $4.40, men's fragrance at $3.50, women's jeans at $18 $29, and men's jeans at $35.99.

Beginning September 12, T-Mobile will offer its customers a Netflix Standard 2-Screen Monthly Subscription for free when they sign up ... Read
more.

Updated: 2 weeks 6 days ago

Fall is on the horizon and we're restocking our closets with all things warm and wintry in preparation for the cooler weather. That's made all the easier this month thanks to the wide selection of end-of-season sales coming your way. Steep & Cheap is leading the pack too, not only with The North Face sale we listed yesterday, but again with big discounts on last season's Patagonia apparel.

The store is knocking up to 65% off a wide selection of Patagonia outerwear, pants, backpacks, and more in last season's colors, with prices starting at $11.60. Shipping starts at $6.31. A couple of best bets from the sale (you will see these prices in the drop-down menu when you select your color on the product page):

Fall is on the horizon and we're restocking our closets with all things warm and wintry in preparation for the ... Read
more.

Updated: 1 day 6 hr ago

Retail chain Toys"R"Us has filed for bankruptcy in the United States and Canada. Per reports from several news outlets, the 60-year-old company has racked up nearly $5 billion in debt. There are currently 1,600 Toys"R"Us and Babies"R"Us retail locations worldwide, which are expected to operate as usual for now.

Lids takes up to 75% off a selection of NCAA, NFL, NBA, MLB, NHL, and other clearance caps, with prices starting at $5. (Select styles may have an even larger discount.) Plus, all orders bag free shipping. (It usually adds $5 for orders under $50.) That beats yesterday's mention (which lacked the free shipping offer) and is the best sale we've seen on these items at Lids this year. Deal ends September 27. A couple of best bets:

Joe's New Balance Outlet takes up to 70% off a selection of men's, women's, and kids' shoes as part of ... Read
more.

Updated: 3 days 1 hr ago

At Best Buy, buy one select Blu-ray or 4K Blu-ray movie and get a second movie of equal or lesser value for free. Plus, get an additional $1 off, dropping prices to as low as $6.99, when you order via in-store pickup using the instructions below. Eligible titles include The Secret Life of Pets, Jason Bourne, Jurassic World, Baseketball, and several multi-movie sets. To get all discounts:

At Best Buy, buy one select Blu-ray or 4K Blu-ray movie and get a second movie of equal or lesser ... Read
more.

Updated: 1 week ago

StackSocial offers the HBQ i7 Twins True Wireless Earphones in White or Black for $29.99 with free shipping. That's $20 off and the lowest price we could find. They feature 4-5 hours of play time, hands-free calling, and lag-free connections. Deal ends October 6.

Today, Apple unveiled its new iPhone 8 and iPhone 8 Plus models. Available in Silver, Space Grey, and Gold, it now has both a glass front and back, with an overall steel-reinforced design. They have a 4.7" and 5.5" Retina HD display, respectively, as well as a new A11 Bionic 6-core CPU. Also included is a 12-megapixel rear camera with optical image stabilization on both models (dual camera on the Plus model), Bluetooth 5.0, wireless charging, and water and dust resistance. It'll come in 64GB and 256GB options, from $699 for the iPhone 8, and from $799 for the 8 Plus.

It can be ordered starting September 15, for delivery on September 22.

Today, Apple unveiled its new iPhone 8 and iPhone 8 Plus models. Available in Silver, Space Grey, and Gold, it ... Read
more.

Updated: 2 weeks ago

Pop Chart Lab cuts a selection of 18" x 24" posters to $10 via coupon code "5PRINTS410", as listed below. (Choose "Print Only" under finishes to see this deal.) With $6.95 for shipping, that's $19 off list and the lowest price we could find. Each poster is printed on 100-lb. archival stock. The deals:

ThinkGeek takes up to 80% off a wide selection of items as part of its Fall Blowout Clearance. Shipping starts at $5.95, or spend $75 or more for free shipping. Shop for home goods, apparel, and accessories from popular franchises such as Harry Potter, Doctor Who, Star Wars, Star Trek, and many more.

ThinkGeek takes up to 80% off a wide selection of items as part of its Fall Blowout Clearance. Shipping starts ... Read
more.

Updated: 1 week ago

Today, Apple introduced the Apple Watch Series 3. The newest version of Apple's smartwatch features built-in cellular, to allow for phone calls without the need to pair with your phone, as well as a new W2 dual-core processor that enables Siri to talk on your watch. It also has an altimeter and remains the same size as the Series 2. With cellular, the new Apple Watch starts at $399, and it can be had without cellular for $329.

Today, Apple introduced the Apple Watch Series 3. The newest version of Apple's smartwatch features built-in cellular, to allow for ... Read
more.

Updated: 2 weeks ago

Spring offers the Kenneth Cole New York Men's Tag Em Leather Sneakers in Cognac for $39.97. Coupon code "STOCKUP20" cuts that to $31.98. With free shipping, that's $24 under last month's mention and the lowest price we could find by $17. They're available in select sizes from 7 to 8 10. Deal ends September 27.

United Airlines via ShermansTravel offers United Airlines Roundtrip Flights to select West Coast U.S. Cities, with prices starting from $82.40. (On the ShermansTravel landing page, click on "United.com" in the main paragraph to see this sale.) That's the lowest price we could find for select routes today by at least $10. Book this travel deal by September 30.

All prices, dates, and booking details were valid at the time of publication.

United Airlines via ShermansTravel offers United Airlines Roundtrip Flights to select West Coast U.S. Cities, with prices starting from $82.40. ... Read
more.

Updated: 4 days 4 hr ago

Walmart discounts a selection of garage and storage rollbacks, with prices starting from $12.70. Choose in-store pickup to avoid the $5.99 shipping fee, or get free shipping on orders of $35 or more. (Oversized items may have additional fees.) A couple of best bets: