"In honor of your engagement, I got you a cake," DeGeneres said, though Vergara thought it was going to be something else. "You always get me strippers," she said, just before one popped out of a giant cake and others came out of the curtains. DeGeneres then gave Vergara a stack of one-dollar bills, making it just like a true raunchy girl's night out.

The Modern Family star's appearance wasn't all about strippers, though — she took time to gush about her fiancé of five months, too. "I'm so lucky I couldn't believe it. At the beginning I didn't want to go out with him," she said. "I had just finished a relationship...he seemed like a lot of work because [he's] so handsome and younger than me and like so sexy and whatever, best bachelor or whatever he was. And I'm like, 'Ugh.' Just too much!"

Luckily, Manganiello persisted despite his love's initial hesitance. "He flew to New Orleans and forced me on a date. And then I couldn't [you] know — I'm like, 'He's a great guy, super fun, super normal and...we click.' It's super easy to hang out with him."