I have recently done some experimental work in order to render mass amounts of cubes. I was moved by this video from Smash, i wanted to know how far i would be able to go on my NVidia GT240M (rendering side). My first choice was Geometry Shaders.
I quickly wrote an app that sent a list of points in space to the GPU and a geometry shader would generate a cube mesh for each one of the points. Tested it on 100.000 cubes and the framerate was bad(10fps or so). The time was now for optimization.

Next step was to optimize the cube generation by lowering from a 24 vertex cube to 14 vertex triangle strip. Things got better, but nothing close to my expectations. I was not satisfied, i mean, i had alot of cubes on screen (100K which was not that much) and that was it, nothing else. We’re talking about 20fps or so, for 100.000 cubes (around 1.2 million triangles per frame). Later on i added vertex normals to the geometry shader and started to work on some lighting/shadowing, but i ended up going back on the rendering side of the job. Meanwhile, i was speaking with a friend of mine about this idea and we were discussing ways to compute lighting but i couldn’t stop thinking about my real problem. So it came to me.

Previously, i have done some experiments with opengl hardware instancing, but never got to do much about it . What better time than now, so i grabbed the project and took it for a spin. After a few hours i had the same amount of cubes on screen with a much much better framerate. Quickly implemented some eye-candy (coloring, texturing, vertex lighting), some tweaking here and there and as i was listening to Mr. Peter Broderick (hi, i love you man) added some audio analysis to the feature list.
Last but not least, a kind of “Brownian Motion” was used to generate points in space, increased the cube count to 512*512 and watched it flow ( at 20fps ).

In conclusion, Hardware instancing was much easier to implement and performance seems much better at first sight. Above is a video of 262.144 audio-reactive cubes with GPU animation and basic lighting at around 20fps. For my video card i think that is very good. On a sidenote, i have not given up on the geometry shaders. I am not sure what will be my next step regarding the subject (back to geometry shaders?) but for now this is it. Hardware Instancing kicked Geometry Shaders in the ass.