The better PS3 game... inFAMOUS or Uncharted?

I mean, they're both pretty amazing but which one do you personally like the most? I'd give the edge to inFAMOUS just because I tend to sink more hours into open world games (the Dead Drops were a nice touch).

Thanks to Kwes for the signature!
"As long as there are dreamers who have the courage to pursue their dreams, the world will have heroes. And as long as there is a thirst to discover the unknown, there will be new stories to tell...and new adventures to be had."

Either way, Uncharted for me. Number's 2 my favourite game of the last generation; perfectly blended animation, fun, quirkiness, a competent script and story - plus played well and looked astonishing. It gets my vote!

Either way, Uncharted for me. Number's 2 my favourite game of the last generation; perfectly blended animation, fun, quirkiness, a competent script and story - plus played well and looked astonishing. It gets my vote!

The first of each, since they'd be fresh experiences. I love Uncharted 2 myself.

Thanks to Kwes for the signature!
"As long as there are dreamers who have the courage to pursue their dreams, the world will have heroes. And as long as there is a thirst to discover the unknown, there will be new stories to tell...and new adventures to be had."

uncharted. Orchestral score, story, prettiness. it might not be open world. but it's chapters make for enjoyable playback. Uncharted games are fantastically paced, and beautiful to witness, first one included.

Not sure if I can vote! Each exceeded and the other unimpressed on too many aspects from a personal standpoint.
For example I found the inFAMOUS story to be below par, and the whole script and voice acting quite bland.
Whereas Uncharted, virtually everything Drake said over the 3 titles had me sniggering to myself or bursting out laughing.

Downside for me in the first Uncharted was playing a fairly realistic, and compelling game 3/4 of the way through, and then finding that El Dorado had turned that whole fleet into monsters who still roamed the ruins. At the time I thought the story had taken quite a cheesey exit route. Though it does seem to work well.

inFAMOUS was expected to be unrealistic though, so I had no qualms to hovering around a city with electric powered hands.

I think Uncharted edged it for me for the narrative.
Number two was a brilliant, no nonsense game.

Depends on what you are looking for. Uncharted in a very linear experience, and you can probably finish it in less than 10hrs. inFamous is a sandbox game with much more flexibility that takes a lot longer to finish. Both are fun, Uncharted is certainly the prettier of the two, and is certainly the most focused. Uncharted has limited replayability, you can looking for hidden artifacts and work towards trophies but the game doesn't change. inFamous has two main story paths, which admittedly aren't that different but they change what powers you have which changes how you play.

inFamous however did one of the coolest things I've ever seen a game do. I typically start a game on easy till I learn it, then if I'm hooked play it again on a harder level. When I went back to play the evil path for inFamous I was feeling lazy and set it to easy again. But the first major mission, getting to safety under the bridge after the attack, tests your skills and the game literally told me that I was too good for easy and should up the difficulty level. Then a few minutes later it told me I was too good for the middle difficulty and should up the challenge to hard. So I ended up playing the evil path of hard difficulty to the end.

An open world game wins 99% of the time in my book, prefer super long games with a high replay value over a linear game that gives you no freedom. Only exception to this is Arkham Asylum over Arkham City, played better linear IMO.

Tough call as both are awesome games but inFamous comes to my mind more. I'm not sure if that's because it's 'better' and may be more the fact that I love games that give me any form of agency in direction be it geographically or story. The less on rails I am, the better a game is for me. Of course, Uncharted is one of the industry's biggest franchises so...bah it's too apples and oranges for me to choose.

Uncharted, I liked everything about uncharted better. Better characters, better dialogue, the way the characters talked with each other the indiana jones type storylines. With infamous I didn't really care for any of that. In infamous I also hated the way the enemies would shoot u from a long distance away. Also how when I jumped off a building they were able to shoot with amazing accuracy like they're $#@!ing deadshot or something

Uncharted is/was a great game, but Infamous all the way. Guess I'm in the minority there.

I've never really even been a fan of those types of games, but there's just something about it. The only other games I've played to 100% more times have been Super Mario 64 and the some of the Hitman/Splinter Cell games.

My only plat trophy is Infamous 2. One of the best games on PS3 imo. I loved uncharted 3 as well but Infamous 2 is better. Loved the setting of a flooded city and the whole game drips atmosphere. The evil ending was great fun too!