On the peninsula Snug Harbor Cafe, the one in Discovery Bay, not the one in Port Ludlow, has a mighty fine burger. Difference is that the Ludlow one nas a flat top grill where the Discovery Bay one has a nice broiler. All the other food is quite good there but the building echos like mad (once made the mistake of taking a woman, one known for her loud voice there, YIKES!)

I've been to Pilchuck. It was good. Didn't know it was so revered, might have to go for something a little more impressive other than the double cheese next time. That's the only one I've tried of all these though.