This is one of the better written articles we have read on the multilayered issues surrounding shark fin bans, conservation efforts, and of course New York, currently in the middle of debates about shark fin bans.

The article is filled with facts, good quality interview subjects, and of course the actual moment that the reporter orders up a bowl of shark fin soup as part of a grander social experiment.

What got us was the extreme level of Asian hate on the comments section of this article. A level of acidic racism directed towards the NY Asian community that went unchecked and unchallenged until we stepped up today to say a few words.

Is this really the shark conservation movement and where the hell is the leadership?

Peter Puck

Unfortunately, there is no practical way to
inject a highly lethal poison into the fins of a sufficient number of
sharks to kill a sufficient number of soup slurping scum. It's equally
unfortunate that there's no direct connection between eating shark fin
and contracting cancer.

rufusmcbufus

I swear by god i'd rather see every single east
asian dead before they kill the last shark. Mark my words, if it comes
to this, I'll be on the sharks' side.
-rufus

"This 4 metre plus female great white had just bitten Mark's cage and was
circling when he turned on his camera .... at 1.09 he see's it
approaching from behind his cage. He's been down at 26 metres for over
half an hour and is forced to make a decision. Stay on the bottom and
run into decompression time or confront it .... Starvation Bay, South
Coast Western Australia, October 2011."