The roses flogger is thuddy, not stingy. The roses have a surprising amount of heft to them. (I own this toy.)

The cane and the flogger have different histories and each can have different kinds of fantasies attached to them. What kinds of scenarios do you enjoy best? Do you already have canes or floggers at home? I don't own either of the remaining toys, but my guess would be that the cane would be more likely to raise welts/bring out bruises, but the flogger would be more likely to potentially break the skin. (Obviously these things all depend on the intensity and skill with which they are wielded.)

Flogger will possibly sting more, but you'll get a very different kind of sting from a bamboo cane. For instance, the flogger will hurt over a wider area, while the cane will hurt in very thin, targetted welts. Stingyness of a cane also depends on its width--wider ones are actually quite thuddy.