Youi have the blurred lines on the ring going toward the black hole, but its not focused to the middle of the blackhole. It looks more like its going to the top of the hole. The color clashing is pretty good, but you could have used a different (more warm colors) would have been a better look in my opinion. The black hole would have stretched the planets ends, instesad of just breaking it all. The blur effects were very well done and the rotation and background looks amazing! the rings are starting to stretch there at a few inches up from 3/4 from right to left. the ring coloration is well done as well

From my perspective, being interested in astrology, physics, and the science-fiction fan that I am, I have to say this is stunning, incredible work.

The colors are surreal, but are very fitting if you consider that you are trying to express space-time distortion, intense gravity and energy at work. Based on what we know about singularities, this is a very accurate depiction. You have the distortion of the event horizon, that warping of literally space, time, matter, light, everything, with the dark center of the black hole itself from which nothing escapes. You managed to make the center almost look a little like a globe, a reminder of the remnant that was a star once.

The entire piece gives the feeling that you are pulled in, that there is no escape, and I really love the overall distorted feeling of the picture, I couldn't have come up with a better picture in my mind of what the proximity to a black hole would be like.

I am impressed and in awe and I cannot really find anything to fault this, as much as I like to give constructive advice or suggestions. This should be at the very least a cover for an astrophysics book, or maybe even for a new edition of Hawking's "A Brief History of Time". Nice work!