Crowded airplanes and screaming children

By USA TodayFebruary 20, 2013 12:10 pm

Text Size:AAA

A 60-year-old man accused of slapping a crying toddler on a Delta flight earlier this month has put a spotlight on one of the most tension-filled aspects of flying -- how irritable passengers on a packed plane co-exist with crying children.

The incident, which has led to an assault charge being filed against the older flier, has also rekindled a debate about whether airlines should carve out sections that are adults only, an idea that some passengers support, but some industry observers say won't fly.

The tension between adults and pint-size seatmates is "pretty significant," says Brandon Macsata, executive director of the Association for Airline Passenger Rights, particularly at a time when cabins are packed as airlines pare the number of seats they make available.

"The larger issue is if you're a passenger without a kid, you have to expect there will be times when you're flying with a screaming child," Macsata says. "If you're a passenger with a child, it's incumbent upon you to do everything you can to make sure the kid doesn't get out of control."

The Feb. 8 incident on a Delta flight from Minneapolis/St. Paul to Atlanta was perhaps the most serious of a handful that have been reported in recent years. Joe Rickey Hundley allegedly hurled a racist slur at the 2-year-old son of a fellow passenger, Jessica Bennett, before slapping the infant who was making noise as the jet prepared to land.

Hundley was charged in federal court last week with assault. His attorney, Marcia Shein, told the Associated Press that Hundley would plead not guilty to the charge, which could result in a maximum penalty of a year in jail. In the meantime, Hundley's employer, AGC Composites, said that he no longer works for that business.

There have been other incidents. Qantas settled a lawsuit filed in 2009 by a woman who said a screaming child on her flight led her to lose some of her hearing. In 2007, AirTran kicked a family off a flight headed to Boston from Fort Myers, Fla., after the family's 3-year-old daughter refused to sit down and was disruptive.

Such flare-ups, while seemingly rare, raise the question about whether rows set aside solely for families flying with children, or adults who don't have kids, might be a way to tamp down tensions.

Several surveys taken in recent years indicate there are some fliers who would like to see spaces that are kid-free zones.

A TripAdvisor poll to be released next week found that 23% of 2,001 respondents were willing to pay $25 or less to sit in a "quiet" section of a jet. A 2010 poll by fare-comparison website Skyscanner found that 59% of more than 2,000 travelers surveyed wanted airlines to have a section exclusively for families. Almost 20% of those polled said they'd like to see child-free flights.

Some overseas carriers have taken such steps. AirAsiaX, a carrier in Malaysia, has said that starting this month, it would reserve the first seven rows of coach for passengers age 13 and up, dubbing the section the "Quiet Zone." Malaysia Airlines banned babies in the first-class cabins of its Boeing 747 jumbo planes, and has said it will have a section where children aren't allowed in its Airbus A380s, according to the Australian Business Traveller.

But in the U.S., some airline industry analysts say, such separate sections would be unacceptable and could spark a backlash.

"To have a child-only or infant-only section, we get into that debate (about) whether there should be a section for folks traveling with pets, or folks who drink," says Macsata. "When you look at how poorly the airlines do in general in terms of accommodating passengers, imagine how difficult it would be if we had all those different sections for different people."

Delta Air Lines, which says it's "reviewing" the incident allegedly involving Hundley "and cooperating with the FBI," has no plans to create separate sections for families, says spokesman Morgan Durrant.

Jay Sorensen, an airline industry consultant who is an expert on the extra fees carriers charge for everything from checked bags to more legroom, says it's possible a U.S. carrier might one day impose a rule on infants flying in a premium cabin.

But a families-only section in coach, he says, would be unacceptable to many members of the public.

"It would touch on two flash points," Sorensen says. "One is fees, and one is discriminatory practices against children, and I think those things combined would force an airline to not go down that path."

Besides, Sorensen says, there's another way to deal with the discomfort between a cranky adult and an equally tired, noisy toddler. "If there's a kid crying," he says, there's a solution: "It's called earplugs."

---

(c) Copyright 2013 USA TODAY, a division of Gannett Co. Inc.

A service of YellowBrix, Inc.

VN:F [1.9.6_1107]

Rate this post:

please wait...

Rating: 7.8/10 (12 votes cast)

Crowded airplanes and screaming children, 7.8 out of 10 based on 12 ratings

5 Comments

Comment by lokiswife February 20, 2013 @ 1:48 pm

Traveling is hard for small children, a pediatrician can prescribe a mild sedative for the kids to keep them calmed down for the duration of the trip and something to help with the ear problems caused by the changing air pressure in the cabin. Childrens’ ears are much more sensitive to this pressure change, it hurts them and they scream.

Very true. On top of that, they don’t know to, or how to, clear their ears, making the pain worse and longer in duration than an older child or an adult.

A tip; give the little traveler something they will chew. That will cause him to swallow and that tends to help with ear clearing. That and some comforting is about all you can do.

Someone who slaps a crying child aboard an aircraft or anywhere else deserves a good deal more than an assault charge.

VN:F [1.9.6_1107]

Rate this comment:

please wait...

Rating: 3.5/5 (13 votes cast)

Comment by sumitch February 20, 2013 @ 5:07 pm

In years past there were seperate rooms for parents with children in order to promote a peaceful movie for others. I’m sure that would be deemed as discrimination now.

Try flying 3-5 times/week and then setting close to a screaming kid. It’s a real treat. And watching the parents sit there with a “isn’t he/she cute” smirk on their face and do nothing to quiet the kid just adds to the pleasure.

Since when does a parent with a screaming kid have rights over an adult who would like just a little peace and quiet? I certainly do not think that smacking a kid by a stranger is appropriate, but I can sympathize with the sentiment.

Why shouldn’t there be a parents with kids only section? Is it more important for a parent with a kid have the right to disturbe those without?

VN:F [1.9.6_1107]

Rate this comment:

please wait...

Rating: 4.8/5 (19 votes cast)

Comment by summergoat February 20, 2013 @ 2:25 pm

I don’t have any problem with the crying or screaming kids — like the article said, a pair of earplugs works great. However, I do have a great problem with the kids that kick the back of the seat, reach up and pull your hair, throw food, or, worse yet, mess with your own personal items. If the parents cannot control their children where they are not disruptive to other passengers, then they do not need to travel with them on planes, trains, or buses.

I travelled extensively with my oldest child from the time she was about 6 months old, including overseas trips. As a parent I did everything I could to make sure she would not disturb those around us. I brought new and special toys, had extra changes of clothes and plastic bags for dirty stuff, extra food and drink, and I ALWAYS took her shoes off so if she inadvertently kicked the seat ahead of us (which I would stop immediately) it was less awful.

However, I also hoped for, and rarely got, some help from those around me. For example, the people who saw a child in arms or in a car seat behind them yet laid the seat back all the way and then shot dirty looks when the seat got bumped. The people who wouldn’t change seats so I could sit near my husband and have two people helping with the baby. The seating by the airline that had me hauling a baby, car seat (and yes, we paid for the seat to put it in) and all our bags to the very back of the plane and then the flight crew shooting me daggers that I was holding up boarding.

It is a two way street. Parents need to do everything they can to make sure their children don’t disrupt others and those flying without kids could show a little patience and understanding and maybe even help a little. I still remember the time my child just was at the end of her rope and the lady across the aisle started to talk to her which got her attention and stopped the crying immediately. Much better than a slap or dirty looks.