Bieber—a member of the evangelical Hillsong Church—and Baldwin—an evangelical Christian—reportedly got hitched in a New York City courthouse on September 13, but TMZ reports that the young lovebirds are still going to have a proper religious ceremony "early next year" in 2019, giving them plenty of time to devise the perfect nuptial celebration.

The tabloid claims the big event will most likely take place in Ontario, Canada or upstate New York.

Recently (and shockingly), it was revealed that the two did not sign a prenup before getting married. It's believed no protective documents were signed because there was no time: The couple reached out to the courthouse the very same day they decided to become legally wed.