sorry but i still find it pooreven if it was before...in heroes 3 there wasn't any of that crap (sorry but i really feel its awkward just my opinion)

It's not aliens, it's the necromancers of Deyja using high tech equipment. The world of Might and Magic has had plenty of sci-fi elements and the Forge town was an attempt to integrate the evil ending of Might and Magic VII with Heroes III.

Of course, people like you complained, NWC caved in, and instead we got the Conflux, everyone's favorite overpowered generic elemental town. But, as I said before, don't worry: The chances of the WoG team ever getting that far are extremely slim, after all, it's only taken them 5 years to get this far without completing WoG 3.59.

In fact, assuming that any of these new town projects ever get finished (none of them have so far), I will consider it an achievement in and of itself.

Midas wrote:The "Sci-fi" began even in the first one, doesn't it?About the "Alien Crash Land" Kind of thing,

Yeap, it was in Might and Magic I and those elements are in every single MM game after it as well. I guess that HoMM1 being a King's Bounty clone didn't include those elements since they're not in KB, but why HoMM2 didn't have them is a mystery.

Well said Corlagon And yes, sci-fi is the background of MM. Everything takes place in the future, just that all the civilisations have fallen to barbarianism once again. In fact, I tried to explain some of that in my MM History video: http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=1EtyslKxvY4

Yeap, that should be done, like the Lincoln/Oracle places.
And yes, I found the idea pretty odd at fist as well, but if the graphics implementation is good (hint: MM6's autobots) it could come very nicely. Also, a less aggressive approach would be to create other things like new objects and artifacts that would be from the Time of Wonders.

I may not be very familiar with MM history, not having played MM I through V, but I know some of where the sci-fi comes in. And I still say it has no place in the game. After all, just think - the moment you get your hands on blasters, nothing can stand up to you. It's just too damn unbalanced. And making it balanced in gameplay terms means that the so-called hi-tech things are lame. After all, a blaster of any kind should be capable of taking pretty much anything out with one shot, which, I remind again, would be extremely unbalanced in gameplay terms.
I'm no Ubisoft supporter, I can tell you that much, but I still think that sci-fi and fantasy are two things best not mixed together...

obelisk v2.0 wrote:I may not be very familiar with MM history, not having played MM I through V

That's your problem If you played MM2, you would see that hi-tech weapons there are barely better than normal weapons, and often even worse than those are. That's because while hi-tech objects have the technology, the old objects have magic, so it all balances out. If you create a magical shield against arrows, it works against bullets just as well. So the balance would and should be kept, anything hi-tech would never be overpowering in strategy games. Sure, they can be of the stronger variety (for example, all sci-fi artifacts could be of the Relic kind), but they won't be stronger than your normal, magical items.

And if you think the genres don't mix, go play Unreal I. Or even Unreal Tournament I for that matter. The elements balance out very neatly.

Not to mention that the entire Forge faction, its troops and heroes were meant to be strictly campaign only (like the Conflux practically is now when you look at ToH). It wasn't being forced into the game - you could add it to your maps or pretend it never existed at will.

To go on a tangent - logically, based on their strength in MM6 and 7, the Kreegans should kick the collective behind of every single faction in the game. Yet the Inferno is repeatedly a contender for most useless town. So blasters needn't necessarily serve as the be-all and end-all of combat.

Corlagon wrote:I'm not sure you fully understand. The Forge isn't some fan-invented abomination which doesn't belong in the game. It was created by the people who made the series in the first place.

I remember when the Forge debate was all in fashion. I think I was one of the few people that had an opion that both sides of the argument didn't like One side said it was great, the other said it was awful. Me: it was appropriate, but not quite in line with the MM games. There were several units with guns / advanced projectile weapons. I argued that the MM games didn't have these, but did have "blasters" and other energy-based based weapons. Thus, the units should have had those. The anti-forge people saw me as pro-forge, and said I was making things worse. The pro-forge people though I was bashing on it. MAde for some interesting debate at the time.

I just go by the old political adage- in both sides hate you, you must be doing something right

obelisk v2.0 wrote:After all, a blaster of any kind should be capable of taking pretty much anything out with one shot, which, I remind again, would be extremely unbalanced in gameplay terms.

Not really. Even if you discount the way blasters worked in the MM games, not every shot will hit, and as with any other weapon, a hit doesn't mean something vital was hurt. Also, there have been creatures with instant-kill / deathblow attacks in HoMM games from the start (H1 and H2 genies, H3 dread knights, H4 sea monsters, H5 wraiths), so this is just another way to explain that ability.

For that matter, in sci-fi, only the "phaser set to kill" on star trek was an instant kill. Every other time I have seen hand-held energy weapons, that wasn't the case. Yes, you COULD get a kill on one shot, but you can get that with a slingshot also.

Qurqirish Dragon wrote:it was appropriate, but not quite in line with the MM games. There were several units with guns / advanced projectile weapons. I argued that the MM games didn't have these, but did have "blasters" and other energy-based based weapons. Thus, the units should have had those.

Yes, I agree. And I have to watch Star Trek sometime :\

Qurqirish Dragon wrote:I just go by the old political adage- in both sides hate you, you must be doing something right