I sometimes wonder if the writers decided to change the story because they saw the chemistry after the Phillip recast. I sorta watched the first version of Phelle with the other Phillip and while he was nice looking I thought they were a dud as a couple. I understood while she was pining for Shawn I guess. Even though I don't think there is much chemistry there with the new Shelle like the old Shelle. But if I think of the Phelle marriage with JKJ in the role, I just don't think I would buy into Belle pining away for Shawn. It would take some creative writing for me to buy it.