South Street Steakhouse
A Freehold, NJ Restaurant Review

A New Jersey restaurant review of a two and a half star restaurant with a steak and beef menu. This is a New Jersey dining experience best enjoyed by discerning diners.

The New Jersey restaurant reviews and ratings have been established on the basis of personal visits by the restaurant editor of New Jersey Leisure Guide and/or other reliable sources who have made a visit to the restaurant and/or feed back from our viewers.

Price

Very Expensive

Fare

American Steakhouse

Restaurant Rating

CLOSED

Restaurant Review

This Freehold BYOB steakhouse serves up very good steak and beef selections, but be prepared to pay New York prices at a Central New Jersey restaurant.

The restaurant is located in a storefront setting with an attractive decor made up with a soft earth toned canopied ceiling, Roman columns, and walls adorned with large paintings and shelved glass art works. The tables, without linens, are spaced nicely apart over ceramic tile flooring. On busy weekend evenings, it tends to be noisy.

The service is friendly, very attentive, although their demeanor is a little rough around the edges, Brooklyn style. Don't be surprised to find as many as three waiters at a time hovering over your table.

The quality of the beef served varies from good to excellent, and repeated visits to this eatery have demonstrated an inconsistency in the preparation.

The recommended appetizers are; The Fried Calamari Steaks served with chipotle aioli; and the very pricey Shrimp Cocktail served with cocktail sauce and natural lemon.