Tuesday, July 3, 2012

Women, War and Political Empowerment: Notes from Rwanda

Kigali, Rwanda. It was recently named the cleanest capital city in the world by the UN. Photo by author

I arrived in Rwanda for the fourth time in early May to
conduct the final phase of my dissertation research on women’s political empowerment.
Kigali has changed dramatically since my last trip here in 2009—more streets
are paved, high-rise buildings dot the horizon, and the country’s impressive
economic growth is visibly apparent. Led by President Paul Kagame, Rwanda has
made significant progress since the 1994
genocide that devastated the country. Just
last week the controversial Gacaca court system—designed to quickly and
efficiently prosecute the estimated one million suspected genocide
perpetrators—was declared finished. Perhaps most famously, Rwanda has been
heralded for its successful promotion of gender equality and currently has the
world’s highest percentage of women in Parliament (56%). While these achievements
have garnered international praise, the Rwandan government is increasingly
coming under scrutiny for its human rights practices, its rumored support of
the bloody war in Congo, and its heavy-handed control over the daily lives of
its citizens.

2012 meeting of the Rwandan National Women's Council attended by members of the NWC, parliamentarians, and civil society representatives.Photo courtesy of Ministry of Gender and Family Promotion 2012, Rwanda

My fieldwork here has thus been caught in an interesting trap. On one hand, I’m looking at the tremendous progress women in Rwanda have made since the genocide. Women’s mobilization after violence in community organizations, local women’s councils, and eventually in national politics represented a dramatic shift away from the male-dominated political realm before the violence. Before the genocide, as one parliamentarian told me, “Politics…was a male domain. It was like their personal bedroom where no one else could go in.” After the genocide, however, women began to take on key roles in their households and communities by caring for orphans; rebuilding houses; and finding food, shelter, and healthcare. Thousands of informal associations of women formed after the violence to address these immediate needs, and these groups became the locus for sustained collective action. Many women who joined these grassroots associations eventually ended up in national politics, and the Government of Rwanda played a key role in their advancement

National Parliament, Kigali, Rwanda. The political progress in Rwanda is often juxtaposed with the memory of recent violence — here the Parliament of Rwanda, home to the highest percentage of female legislators in the world, is deliberately left damaged from artillery and grenades during the genocide 18 years ago.

On the other hand, I’m constantly running into the appendages of a strong, authoritarian state, and finding evidence that “women’s empowerment” in Rwanda is full of contradictions and far from complete. A recent debate centered on a bill passed by Parliament that absolves criminal liability for women who get abortions under certain circumstances (such as when the pregnancy originated in rape, incest, or a forced marriage, or when the life of the mother is at risk). This highly controversial bill comes at a time when hundreds of girls in Rwanda are in jail for seeking abortions, and, according to the Ministry of Health, an estimated 60,000 abortions are conducted illegally every year—40% of which lead to medical complications that require treatment.

At the root of the abortion debate is the inconsistent
development between the core and the periphery of the country, and the tension
between implacable government regulations and the ability of ordinary citizens
to accommodate them. Millions of Rwandans have been left out of the country’s
impressive economic development. They are “stuck”—as Marc Sommers has described
them—between deeply engrained cultural expectations about marriage, sexuality,
and gender roles, and a country that is rapidly advancing and actively
promoting women’s rights. Last week a woman in her mid-twenties told me that
she couldn’t possibly go to the health center to get birth control because she is
“still a girl”—in Rwanda, you are a girl (umukobwa)
until you are married. Yet, there are 9 men for every 10 women in this country,
and housing and land shortages mean that traditional marriage expectations are increasingly
hard to fulfill. This country also has with a national health care plan that
provides free or low cost family planning resources to anyone who wants them.

My research here thus faces the challenge of balancing the various
ways in which women’s progress is understood. As I interview women in politics
and civil society organizations, I remain optimistic that the gains at the
national political level will eventually translate to progress for the masses but
I also remain unconvinced.

— Marie Berry

Marie Berry, a Ph.D. candidate in the Department of Sociology at UCLA, recently received A CSW Jean Stone Dissertation Research Fellowship. She holds an B.A. with honors from the Jackson School of International Studies at the University of Washington and an M.A. from the Department of Sociology at UCLA. Her dissertation, “From Violence to Mobilization: War, Women, and Political Empowerment in Rwanda, Bosnia, and Beyond,” explores the effects of mass violence on women’s participation in politics and community organizations in Rwanda and Bosnia-Herzegovina. In 2010 she joined the Board of Directors of Global Youth Connect, an organization that empowers youth to advance human rights through cross-cultural training programs in post-conflict countries.

Photos: Top: Kigali, Rwanda. It was recently named the cleanest capital city in the world by the UN. Photo by author Middle:2012 meeting of the Rwandan National Women's Council attended by members of the NWC, parliamentarians, and civil society representatives.Photo courtesy of Ministry of Gender and Family Promotion 2012, Rwanda. Bottom: National Parliament, Kigali, Rwanda. The political progress in Rwanda is often juxtaposed with the memory of recent violence — here the Parliament of Rwanda, home to the highest percentage of female legislators in the world, is deliberately left damaged from artillery and grenades during the genocide 18 years ago.