He was also named to the All-Pac-12 first team and Pac-12 All-Academic second team. He started the season on the Bronko Nagurski and Jim Thorpe watch lists. ESPN.com called him the Pac-12’s 11th-best player in the Pac-12 in preseason top-25 player rankings.

Reynolds registered 12 tackles at Utah and 10 tackles (seven solo) against Michigan State in the 2013 Rose Bowl.

As a junior, Reynolds played in 14 games, posting 47 tackles (28 solo) and 11 pass breakups. He also recorded a team-high six interceptions - the most by a Stanford player since Jim Kaffen’s seven in 1973. He set a school record returning three interceptions for touchdowns and ranked first nationally with 301 interception return yards, falling one yard short of the NCAA single-season record for interception return yards.