The pundits collectively whiffed on the NFL South, with only one pundit (Adam Schein) picking the Eagles in the NFC East and only eight picking the Colts in the AFC South.

Now here are the results on an individual basis, sorted by Yield (the average return had you bet $1 on each of the picks at Moneyline Odds).

Pundit

AFC East

AFC North

AFC South

AFC West

NFC East

NFC North

NFC South

NFC West

Hit Rate

Yield

Overall

57/57

39/57

8/57

56/57

1/57

48/57

0/57

29/57

4/8

$0.97

Ben Goessling

NE

CIN

IND

DEN

WAS

GB

ATL

SF

5/8

$1.35

Bill Williamson

NE

CIN

IND

DEN

NYG

GB

ATL

SF

5/8

$1.35

Peter King

NE

CIN

IND

DEN

NYG

GB

ATL

SF

5/8

$1.35

Albert Breer

NE

CIN

IND

DEN

NYG

GB

ATL

SF

5/8

$1.35

Kimberly Jones

NE

CIN

IND

DEN

NYG

GB

ATL

SF

5/8

$1.35

Colin Cowherd

NE

PIT

IND

DEN

DAL

GB

NO

SEA

5/8

$1.26

Adam Schein

NE

BAL

HOU

DEN

PHI

GB

ATL

SF

4/8

$1.22

John Clayton

NE

CIN

HOU

DEN

WAS

GB

ATL

SEA

5/8

$1.19

David Fleming

NE

CIN

HOU

DEN

WAS

GB

ATL

SEA

5/8

$1.19

KC Joyner

NE

CIN

HOU

DEN

DAL

GB

ATL

SEA

5/8

$1.19

Adam Schefter

NE

CIN

HOU

DEN

DAL

GB

ATL

SEA

5/8

$1.19

Rich Cimini

NE

CIN

HOU

DEN

DAL

GB

ATL

SEA

5/8

$1.19

Terry Blount

NE

CIN

HOU

DEN

WAS

GB

NO

SEA

5/8

$1.19

John Keim

NE

CIN

HOU

DEN

WAS

GB

NO

SEA

5/8

$1.19

Phil Sheridan

NE

CIN

HOU

DEN

WAS

GB

ATL

SEA

5/8

$1.19

Nick Wagoner

NE

CIN

HOU

DEN

NYG

GB

ATL

SEA

5/8

$1.19

Don Banks

NE

CIN

HOU

DEN

DAL

GB

ATL

SEA

5/8

$1.19

Ben Eagle

NE

CIN

HOU

DEN

DAL

GB

ATL

SEA

5/8

$1.19

Doug Farrar

NE

CIN

HOU

DEN

WAS

GB

NO

SEA

5/8

$1.19

Tom Mantzouranis

NE

CIN

HOU

DEN

DAL

GB

ATL

SEA

5/8

$1.19

Jim Trotter

NE

CIN

HOU

DEN

WAS

GB

TB

SEA

5/8

$1.19

Elliot Harrison

NE

CIN

HOU

DEN

WAS

GB

ATL

SEA

5/8

$1.19

Gil Brandt

NE

CIN

IND

DEN

DAL

DET

ATL

SF

4/8

$1.14

Austin Murphy

NE

CIN

HOU

DEN

DAL

CHI

ATL

SEA

4/8

$0.98

Bucky Brooks

NE

CIN

HOU

DEN

DAL

CHI

ATL

SEA

4/8

$0.98

Mike Silver

NE

CIN

HOU

DEN

DAL

CHI

ATL

SEA

4/8

$0.98

Bill Simmons

NE

CIN

HOU

DEN

NYG

CHI

ATL

SEA

4/8

$0.98

Mike Reiss

NE

BAL

IND

DEN

NYG

GB

NO

SF

4/8

$0.97

Jeffri Chadiha

NE

CIN

HOU

DEN

WAS

GB

ATL

SF

4/8

$0.90

Rick Reilly

NE

CIN

HOU

DEN

NYG

GB

ATL

SF

4/8

$0.90

Scott Brown

NE

CIN

HOU

DEN

WAS

GB

NO

SF

4/8

$0.90

Tania Ganguli

NE

CIN

HOU

DEN

NYG

GB

ATL

SF

4/8

$0.90

Mike Rodak

NE

CIN

HOU

DEN

NYG

GB

NO

SF

4/8

$0.90

Mike Wells

NE

CIN

HOU

DEN

NYG

GB

ATL

SF

4/8

$0.90

Dan Graziano

NE

CIN

HOU

DEN

DAL

GB

ATL

SF

4/8

$0.90

Michael C. Wright

NE

CIN

HOU

DEN

DAL

GB

ATL

SF

4/8

$0.90

Pat Yasinskas

NE

CIN

HOU

DEN

NYG

GB

ATL

SF

4/8

$0.90

Jeff Darlington

NE

CIN

HOU

DEN

WAS

GB

ATL

SF

4/8

$0.90

Judy Battista

NE

CIN

HOU

DEN

NYG

GB

ATL

SF

4/8

$0.90

Ashley Fox

NE

BAL

HOU

DEN

WAS

GB

ATL

SEA

4/8

$0.82

Mike Sando

NE

BAL

HOU

DEN

NYG

GB

ATL

SEA

4/8

$0.82

Matt Williamson

NE

BAL

HOU

DEN

WAS

GB

NO

SEA

4/8

$0.82

Jamison Hensley

NE

BAL

HOU

DEN

NYG

GB

ATL

SEA

4/8

$0.82

James Walker

NE

BAL

HOU

DEN

NYG

GB

ATL

SEA

4/8

$0.82

Rob Demovsky

NE

BAL

HOU

DEN

NYG

GB

ATL

SEA

4/8

$0.82

Chris Burke

NE

BAL

HOU

DEN

NYG

GB

ATL

SEA

4/8

$0.82

Daniel Jeremiah

NE

BAL

HOU

DEN

DAL

GB

ATL

SEA

4/8

$0.82

Adam Teicher

NE

CIN

HOU

DEN

DAL

CHI

ATL

SF

3/8

$0.69

David Newton

NE

CIN

HOU

DEN

NYG

MIN

NO

SF

3/8

$0.69

Ian Rapoport

NE

CIN

HOU

DEN

DAL

CHI

ATL

SF

3/8

$0.69

Bill Barnwell

NE

PIT

HOU

KC

NYG

GB

TB

SEA

3/8

$0.66

Kevin Seifert

NE

BAL

HOU

DEN

NYG

GB

ATL

SF

3/8

$0.52

Seth Wickersham

NE

BAL

HOU

DEN

NYG

GB

ATL

SF

3/8

$0.52

Michael DiRocco

NE

BAL

HOU

DEN

WAS

GB

ATL

SF

3/8

$0.52

Paul Kuharsky

NE

BAL

HOU

DEN

NYG

GB

ATL

SF

3/8

$0.52

Jeff Legwold

NE

BAL

HOU

DEN

NYG

GB

ATL

SF

3/8

$0.52

Todd Archer

NE

PIT

HOU

DEN

WAS

MIN

ATL

SF

2/8

$0.31

No pundit got more than 5 of the 8 divisions correct. Those with the best yields generally picked the Colts, as Vegas pegged their odds to win the AFC South at just 28% (Texans were the overwhelming favorite). The Eagles were given an 18% probability by Vegas, which makes it surprising that only Schein made that pick, while the Panthers were 15%.

To see what these pundits collectively picked for the conference winners and player awards, see our preseason recap post.

There is still time to make your own picks for this week's Wild Card games and see if you can move up our User Leaderboard. Head over to our Sports Section to do so.

PunditTracker's mission is to bring accountability to the prediction industry by cataloging and scoring the predictions of pundits.