Call of Cthulhu has featured in these reviewers' retrospectives for 2018 which we liked:

"A game made for fans of H.P. Lovecraft’s works, players familiar with his writings will see subtle references to other stories by the writer."—Horrorfuel, Top Five Horror Games of 2018.

"Actually largely
based on the pen-and-paper RPG more than the original story itself, but it does
an overwhelmingly good job at making you feel like you’re actually in an early
1900s New England and right in the middle of Lovecraft’s world. The gameplay is
mostly puzzle and story oriented, with very little combat of any kind
throughout, but really makes you feel like a detective who got sucked into this
strange and macabre world. Many grotesque and disturbing scenes and situations
are scattered throughout, and kept me very intrigued to the end. Definitely
worth playing for any fans of Lovecraft, the tabletop RPG game, or just horror
games in general."—Selective
Hearing, Steve’s 2018 Video Games
Year in Review.

"We didn’t play a
lot of games with "lead/main characters" this year so our vote goes
to [Edward Pierce - the protagonist in Call of Cthulhu]. He had a great development throughout the game about over coming issues
and helping others."—MKAU
Gaming, Games of the Year (2018).

Nominee for Gameitall.com’s
“Best Adapted Game of the Year” – Game it All.

"For fans of horror
and all things scary, Call of Cthulhu
is the game for you. For anyone wanting to experience a psychological horror
fix, then this is for you too. To get the best out of this title, play this
game in the dark and alone with headphones as it will immerse you in its cosmic
horrors from start to finish. There are a few gameplay mechanics that need
work, but those issues can be forgiven as the whole experience was a joy to
play. 8/10."—Gaming
Respawn.

[Cyanide Studios has] "released several real gems and Call of Cthulhu is absolutely one of them. Respecting its source material while keeping the pace up to gaming standards is a masochistic endeavour, as is balancing modern gameplay elements with the works on which it’s based, but Cyanide pulled it off at every turn, bringing great American literature to life in a game. The entire experience is a love letter to one of the best American writers of the last two centuries and the weird, frightening worlds he created… I’m giving Call of Cthulhu an 8.5 out of 10."—airentertainment.biz.

"One of the things
I love most about the game play? Fighting is rarely the best course of action.
You have to use your wits, investigative abilities, and growing knowledge of
the occult. I’m way too busy to have started this f*cking game right now, but
there’s no turning back now."—Biff
Bam Pop!.

"my favourite indie game probably has to go to Call of Cthulhu – which captured the Lovecraftian themes brilliantly."—Dark World Gaming, Our Games of 2018.