UN: Australia is not meeting human rights obligations to First People with Disability

Sara IrvineRamp Up
14 Oct 2013

Marlon Noble was jailed for a decade despite never being tried or convicted of any crime. He is a participant in UNFINISHED BUSINESS - a photographic essay about Australia's First Peoples with disability.
Credit: Belinda Mason

The Committee identified significant shortcomings relating to all Australians with disability. Many are outlined in the fact sheets prepared by the non-Government delegation that presented to the UN Committee.

In its concluding observations released last week, the Committee outlined its recommendations for progressing Australia's compliance with the Convention. The Committee is "concerned that not all the organisations of persons with disabilities, including those of people with psychosocial disabilities and Aboriginal and Torres Strait Islander people, are provided with adequate resources for their operations."

Damian Griffis, Executive Officer of the First Peoples Disability Network (FPDN) said, "The recommendations provided to the Australian Government are critical reflections of the way Australia is viewed on its human rights record by the rest of the world. When it comes to Aboriginal Australians with disability, there are some steps that must be taken immediately."

The Committee's report recommends that the government "as a matter of urgency, ends the unwarranted use of prisons for the management of un-convicted persons with disabilities, with a focus on Aboriginal and Torres Strait Islander persons with disabilities, by establishing legislative, administrative and support frameworks that comply with the Convention."

The indefinite detention of people with disability, most of whom are Aboriginal, is a persistent issue that has been prioritised by the Australian Human Rights Commission. According to the UN Committee it is a breach of these individuals' human rights.

The ABC's Lateline program reported the stories of Aboriginal men with mental illness who are detained indefinitely in prison and without conviction last year and again last month during the UN sessions.

Aunty Gayle Rankine, Chairperson of FPDN, said, "We are proud and honoured to have travelled to Geneva to participate in the Committee on the Rights of Persons with Disability process. A range of issues and injustices impact on the daily lives of people with disability, particularly Australia's First Peoples with disability, who are often subjected to 'double disadvantage'."

Belinda Mason said, "Each participant's story is complex and intertwined with Australia's shameful political and social history, which has resulted in the unacceptably high rates of disability in Aboriginal and Torres Strait communities. Through their involvement in the project, each participant is revealing their story and drawing much needed attention to these critical issues."

Marlon Noble, one of the participants in Mason's project, was incarcerated for ten years without conviction. He also featured in the Australian Human Rights Commission's Twenty Years: Twenty Stories film series which celebrates the twentieth anniversary of the Disability Discrimination Act. He is no longer in prison but he is still not free. There are strict conditions placed on him and he is constantly supervised. He tells his story in the short video Presumed Guilty.

Speaking on ABC Radio National's PM program last week, Rosemary Kayess, Chairperson of the Australian Centre for Disability Law, said, "I think [the Committee's concluding observations] gives the Australian Government something really strong to work with in identifying areas of reform, and working within reform processes that have already started.

"They provide guidance to the Government in the reform process, but they also become a mechanism for local disability organisations and advocacy organisations to work with the Government for change and to ensure that there's reform occurring in these areas."

Sara Irvine works in the disability and health sectors as a communications adviser.

Lacking :

People with a mental disability are just not a consideration by governments so far. Too hard basket.

Victoria Eastern Suburbs has recently opened a Headspace for under 25's and is doing much good in our community. Needs to be for those over 25 as well.

These Headspaces are no doubt expensive to set up/run however on a cost benefit analysis to the whole community (sufferer and community) it is a winner. They have psych nurses, Psychiatrists bulk billing, group sessions for sufferers. Even in Melbourne psychiatrists usually have a gap fee which most unemployed/sick cannot afford and the bulk billing psychiatrists are often 20 or more kilometres away thus sufferer unable to afford to get there. Australia can afford Headspaces we just do not have any politician good enough to go there.

I heard on radio new NT Chief Minister Adam Giles has some encouraging ideas.

Booze is a disgrace to the Aboriginal + Torres Straight peoples as well as the rest of Australia. We must address the problem of booze(+ drugs). Stop the culture of drop dead boozing. Less booze available, more expensive, whatever it takes.

Stay Connected

What's this Website About?

How Does this Site Work?

This site is where you will find ABC stories, interviews and videos on the subject of disability. As you browse through the site, the links you follow will take you to stories as they appeared in their original context, whether from ABC News, a TV program or a radio interview. Please enjoy.