Can Tax Cuts Grow the Economy Without Government Spending Cuts?

Share this:

Last week, we asked an important question about Trump’s tax reform plan: Can it deliver?

Despite rampant optimism about tax reform, there are a number of problems. In the first place, it remains uncertain whether or not Congress can even get anything done. Second, as Peter Schiff pointed out, the plan as presented won’t likely create the economic growth it promises.

Peter focused on the fact that the plan isn’t truly reform. It’s tax cuts masquerading as reform. Then there is the issue that it promises to decrease revenue without actually cutting spending and shrinking the size of government. There is strong evidence showing high debt levels retard economic growth.

President Donald Trump proposed last month a tax plan that would lower the top individual tax rate to 35% from 39.6%. It would also lower the corporate income tax rate to 20% from 35%.

The plan, however, says nothing about how spending will be cut to avoid increasing deficits. According to supply-side economics — a relatively new school of economics — a reduction of tax rates and lower revenues for the government does not need to be offset by decreased government spending or increased borrowings.

It is held that the boost in consumer spending and investment in capital goods will set the platform for a stronger economic growth, which in turn will lift government revenues and trim the budget deficit.

Effective tax depends on the size of the government outlays

The problem rests with the fact that the government is not a wealth-generating entity as such — the more it spends, the more resources it has to take from wealth generators. What really counts is the amount of wealth diverted to the government from wealth generators.

Irrespective of the official lowering of tax rates, as long as government spending is not curtailed, there is not going to be an effective lowering of the government tax.

The government will always find ways to divert real wealth to itself. This could be achieved by means of printing money, increasing borrowings, or by imposing various levies. In the presence of a central bank, a lowering of tax rates — sans spending cuts — merely rearranges the way government diverts wealth to itself.

So what then are we to make out of President Trump’s plan of lowering tax rates?

It is quite likely that the initial response of consumers and businesses to the lower tax rates would be to boost their spending.

However, without a real cut in spending, the impression that market participants now have more wealth is illusory. This results in the misallocation of resources.

Without the lowering in effective tax rates — achieved by lowering both spending and taxation — individuals would not lift their spending without the preceding increase in real wealth. What we have here is that more important market-guided priorities are denied the necessary funding in favor of government-spending activities that continue in spite of “tax cuts.”

This, in turn, means that the government’s faux lowering of taxes inflicts damage to the wealth generation process and curtails the potential economic growth.

No doubt — in terms of GDP — the lowering of the tax rates will appear to be a temporary success. This supposed success is likely because the increase in the money supply growth rate — which has a direct link to the so-called GDP growth rate — emerges to help the government to divert wealth to itself from wealth producers.

Note that real GDP is the amount of monetary expenditure on final goods and services — including government outlays — deflated by a dubious price deflator. Obviously, the stronger the monetary growth, the stronger the GDP growth rate.

We can conclude that a meaningful lowering of taxes can only emerge once the government has lowered its outlays in absolute terms. Once outlays are curtailed this will result in less wealth being diverted from wealth generators to the government.

Once more real wealth is made available to wealth producers, this strengthens the process of real wealth generation and sets the platform for stronger economic growth.

Contrary to what the followers of supply-side economics claim, it is not possible to strengthen economic growth by lowering the tax rates whilst keeping the size of government outlays intact.

What the followers of this type of economics suggest is that something can be created out of nothing. These followers confuse the GDP growth rate with the growth rate of the pool of real wealth.

Get Peter Schiff’s latest gold market analysis – click here for a free subscription to his exclusive monthly Gold Videocast.Interested in learning how to buy gold and buy silver?Call 1-888-GOLD-160 and speak with a Precious Metals Specialist today!

Share this:

Related

Related Posts

The Federal Reserve claims to be tightening. According to the conventional wisdom, the Fed will raise interest rates at least three times in 2018 – maybe even four. And last fall, the central bank announced its plan to begin shrinking its balance sheet. But have you actually looked at the Fed’s balance sheet? Dan Kurz […]

Jerome Powell came out pretty hawkish in his public debut yesterday. The new Federal Reserve chairman said he sees little risk of recession and reaffirmed plans to continue tightening the money supply through interest rate increases and quantitative tightening. My personal outlook for the economy has strengthened since December. I don’t see [the recession risks] […]

During a podcast last month, Peter Schiff asked a key question: who is going to buy all of the debt necessary to finance the ballooning US deficit? In his most recent analysis, Dan Kurtz at DK Analytics explores this question more in-depth and comes to generally the same conclusion. The dollar has lost more than […]

Just over a week ago, President Trump delivered the State of the Union speech. The president gave a speech with a decidedly optimistic tone. This was certainly welcome with the increasingly fractured and divided American political landscape. But it’s important to focus beyond the political theater and take a hard look at where the US economy […]

As the GOP tax plan wound its way through Congress, we argued that it is not going to create the kind of economic benefits promised without some reduction in the size and scope of government. We don’t just need tax relief, we need government relief. But there don’t appear to be any serious efforts to […]

Archives

Search

My wife and I have purchased metals from a number of companies and were never comfortable with the way they pushed numismatic coins. After we placed an order for Double Eagles with SchiffGold, you called back and explained how we could get a better p…

John s.

I was impressed by SchiffGold, because you did what you said you were going to do. I have bought silver from two other major sellers of metals and was disappointed both times, one for the quality of the product and the other for taking months to deli…

Scott T.

My order came safe and sound, and I have been telling others that SchiffGold is the best way to buy physical gold. The company we bought from before we changed to SchiffGold asked for social security numbers and sold our name to many aggressive coin …

Becky K.

I was very pleased with my recent purchase. I appreciate the smooth process and very quick shipping with tracking numbers. My next purchase will be one or two bags of junk silver coins. I already have 1/2-ounce rounds, so now I want a smaller denomin…

Paul P.

The metals arrived sooner than I expected. The delivery process was great. I will be contacting you soon for another order, and I will gladly pass your name to anyone I know is interested in investing in precious metals.

Craig D.

SchiffGold is not one of the ‘name brand’ gold sellers one hears about constantly on TV. But I follow Peter’s commentary on the market and his thoughts on gold, and felt I would give his company a try. I’m glad I did, as I received my gold very quick…

Bob M.

I am very happy with my recent shipment. I felt that SchiffGold got me the best deal that I could get—a true ally in this investment! I will be using you guys in the future.

Charles M.

One of the biggest concerns I had when purchasing precious metals for the first time was sending funds overseas to a company that was new to me. However, I was put at ease by the fact that my friend had taken large deliveries from SchiffGold without …

Richard C.

Every senior broker at SchiffGold is a libertarian who is a student of Austrian Economics and not your average salesman. Everybody is extremely knowledgable about the markets, the current state in Washington, and of course precious metals. I ordered …

Daily Paul Reader

I received the latest shipment earlier today. All looks great! Delivery is extremely quick. If I know of someone who is interested in physical metals I will definitely pass them onto you. I was very leery about a service like this (phone, email, wiri…