With Kyle heartbroken over being dumped by Amanda, everyone attempts to cheer him up, including Declan and Josh, who take him on an adventure to a local bar that doesn't check IDs. Having too many drinks, Kyle decides to show off his abilities to impress girls and everyone else in the bar. Once the boys are able to get him out of the bar, they discover Josh's car has been towed and, in an attempt to avoid calling the parents, they steal the car back from the impound. The dreadful night doesn't end there: Upon returning to the Trager home, Foss shows up to tell Kyle some sad news.

Meanwhile, Lori is fuming over Stephen banning her from seeing Mark and uses Jessi's apartment as a getaway. Jessi confesses to Lori that she believes she and Kyle are soul-mates, much to Lori's chagrin. However, after bumping into Jessi's good looking neighbor, Cassidy, Lori pushes Jessi to have a change of heart, which surprisingly leads to Lori being reunited with Mark.