Hans van der Maarel

Posted 16 September 2012 - 12:01 AM

Hans van der Maarel

CartoTalk Editor-in-Chief

Admin

4,166 posts

Gender:Male

Location:The Netherlands

Interests:Cartography, GIS, history, popular science, music.

Netherlands

Awesome! It seems to be more topographic (OS-inspired) than tourist to me, but from what I gather you didn't intend to make a tourist map. The only thing I can think of so far is maybe add the place names in Greek as well (I assume that's how they signposted, so that would make navigation a bit easier).

Steve Crow

Posted 16 September 2012 - 05:41 AM

Steve Crow

Newbie

Validated Member

9 posts

Location:North London

United Kingdom

Thank you Hans, you are right - it is OS inspired.

Regarding the place names, there are very few signposts on the island - all bilingual. Only 9 or 10 place names on the map actually appear on signposts. Most of the rest are only known to locals. I have considered a Greek version though.

I have also attempted a manual shaded relief of the island if you are interested.

DaveB

Posted 17 September 2012 - 08:33 AM

DaveB

Hall of Fame

Validated Member

1,129 posts

Gender:Not Telling

Location:Oregon

United States

Excellent work on your labor of love! I don't really have anything to add to the previous comments, except to say the points and some of the text looks really small and tricky to read (but my eyes are not getting any younger, as they say).

Dennis McClendon

Posted 17 September 2012 - 12:49 PM

Very handsome work, and I guess my questions are rather high-level ones.

Unless the intended users are military, I wonder about the use of UTM north rather than geographic north. These days, it seems like there'd be far more people trying to match up with GPS/satnav phones and the like, and they'd be making use of a decimal lat-long grid rather than the UTM grid. But the lat-long grid is confusingly skewed.

In the legend, the notes for the typography representing church and "feature" seem rather odd to me. Church has a symbol, which is already labeled, and there's something rather meta about having "feature" as a feature.

Perhaps "trig. point" is familiar to others, but I'd be inclined to call it a spot elevation or (if marked) a benchmark.

Finally, if you're looking for more work I've recently become intrigued by this combination of contours and shading that makes a map like this much more readable for civilians:

rudy

Posted 17 September 2012 - 02:12 PM

rudy

Ultimate Contributor

Validated Member

777 posts

Gender:Male

Location:Canada

Canada

I like it! with the hhillshade you're working on, it should come out as a nice finished product.

One comments - in the legend you list a number of trail types, the last one being "No definable path." but it appears defined on the map - at least it is location. What is your definition of this category? If it is not a definable path, it could go anywhere, couldn't it?

Agnar Renolen

Posted 17 September 2012 - 02:40 PM

The white background gives good contrast to whatever information displayed on top. But it can be a bit hars to look at in sunlight.

Depending on your intended audience (and if you have the tools to do it) you might experiment with replacing the contours with a shaded relief alltogehter. You will notice that information on the map, particularly linear information such as trails and road will stand out better as they don't have to 'compete' with the contours.

Steve Crow

Posted 18 September 2012 - 11:35 AM

Steve Crow

Newbie

Validated Member

9 posts

Location:North London

United Kingdom

One comments - in the legend you list a number of trail types, the last one being "No definable path." but it appears defined on the map - at least it is location. What is your definition of this category? If it is not a definable path, it could go anywhere, couldn't it?

Yes, the "No definable path". I've struggled over this.

What I'm refering to is a route with no markings on the ground that is dictated by local geography, trees etc. In other words, it is the obvious way to go, but is not marked - it's the natural route.

To be honest I had no idea what else to call it and I would welcome any suggestions.

The other option is if there is a particular destination at the end of the trail, perhaps the legend can be "trail" and the line very ephemeral (dotted line, very lightly coloured line, etc). The implication that hey, there's this neat destination and the faintness of the line implies there's some kind of obvious path to follow.

Nice work and very worthwhile project. I'll echo others and suggest replacing the contour lines with hillshade relief. I'm used to mentally pushing the contours to the back of my mind, but tourists are likely to give the same weight to contour lines as roads and be confused.

-Tony

Yes, the "No definable path". I've struggled over this.

What I'm refering to is a route with no markings on the ground that is dictated by local geography, trees etc. In other words, it is the obvious way to go, but is not marked - it's the natural route.

MapMedia

Posted 27 September 2012 - 07:45 AM

MapMedia

Hall of Fame

Validated Member

1,029 posts

Gender:Male

Location:Davis, California

United States

Steve - Impressive map, especially the contours and the GPS excursions and interviews. The true map making process. Now if you said that you had surveyed the island to achieve the contours, that would be something
I was wondering how bathymetric lines would look on your map, but that opens the map use to other uses such as yachts and possibly fishing.

Also want to congratulate you on the hillshading effort - Is there a version of the map with hillshade and contour together?