The YouTubers got together for a game of “Spill or Refill,” during which they had to answer super juicy questions or else put a mystery ingredient in their tea – which turned out to be mayonnaise – and drink it!

They got asked questions like, “How did you really feel when your sister got a boyfriend?,” “Have you flirted with a guy or pretended you liked him to make another girl mad?,” and “Have you ever swooped in and stolen someone’s man?”