This seems to be an identical item from the same seller. Both of these were gifts, really? This looks like intentional fraud.

Tykeanaut

Some unfortunate person was duped for $201.

Steve Zarelli

Looking through this seller's offerings, of all the signatures I was familiar with, they were all obvious, amateurish fakes. Cooper, Glenn, Leonov, Obama, Schwarzenegger, etc.

Hart Sastrowardoyo

But hey! Proceeds are going to disabled vets! That means they must be good!

riolag

Amazing how many names this guy has if he got them signed himself... Not to mention if he was donating to a charity eBay has a way to do it direct with lovely little flashy symbol to highlight your (and their) good deed. lol