Reynolds also noticed — as we all have, really — that Jackman looks just about as good as he did when he graced People's cover as Sexiest Man Alive in 2008. "Do you ever age?" Reynolds, who was Sexiest Man in 2010, asked Jackman.

Reynolds also took some fan questions, one of which came from "a Blake Lively in New York City, New York. He writes, 'Hugh, I tried calling you on the burner phone and you didn't answer. Are we still meeting at the Gansevoort Hotel this afternoon? I don't have much time because Ryan's having a mani-pedi from 3 to 4."

Jackman confirmed the plans while it dawned on Reynolds that he was also getting a mani-pedi that afternoon: "That's super weird."