Objectives

To assess the effects of ventilation with lower tidal volume (Vt) on morbidity and mortality in adults patients affected by ALI/ARDS. A secondary objective was to determine whether the comparison between low and conventional Vt is different if a plateau airway pressure of greater than 30 to 35 cmH20 was used.

Data collection and analysis

Main results

Five trials, involving 1202 patients, were eligible. The test for heterogeneity gave a P-value of 0.12. Ventilation with lower Vt was associated with a decreased mortality at the end of the follow up period for each trial: 216/605 (35.7%) versus 249/597 (41.7%), relative risk (RR) 0.85 (CI 0.74 to 0.98). The effect of the intervention was not statistically significant when a random effects model was used: RR 0.91 (CI 0.72 to 1.14). Mortality at day 28 was significantly reduced by lung-protective ventilation: RR 0.74 (CI 0.61 to 0.88). The comparison between low and conventional Vt was not significantly different if a plateau pressure less than or equal to 31 cm H2O in control group was used: RR 1.13 (CI 0.88 to 1.45). There was insufficient evidence about morbidity and long term outcomes.

Reviewer's conclusions

Clinical heterogeneity, such as different lengths of follow up and higher plateau pressure in control arms in two trials make the interpretation of the combined results difficult. Mortality is significantly reduced at day 28 and the effects on long term mortality are uncertain, although the possibility of a clinically relevant benefit cannot be excluded. There is no evidence that low Vt ventilation is beneficial in patients where hypercapnia is potentially harmful.

Plain language summary

Synopsis

Patients affected by severe lung failure need a gentler form of mechanical breathing

Critically ill patients affected by severe acute respiratory failure syndrome need air to be pumped into their lungs (mechanical ventilation) to survive. Mechanical support buys time for the lungs to heal. Nevertheless, 40 to 50% still die. Several studies suggested that mechanical breathing can also cause lung damage and bleeding. A new lung-protective way of mechanical ventilation was tested in large trials. This systematic review shows that protective ventilation can decrease death in the short term, but the effects in the long term are unknown.