This blog runs parallel to a new poetry blog 'Poetry Pinfold' (poetrypinfold.blogspot.com), and a new blog with poems in Dutch (bartnooteboomgedichten.blogspot.com)

Monday, May 12, 2014

145. Responses to nihilism: relativism

A radical
response to nihilism is to reject the claim that absolute values are needed or
even desirable, and to seek life without them. Two forms are Richard Rorty’s
indifference and Nietzsche’s passionate ‘revaluation of all values’.

One can
become indifferent, shrugging at nihilism. What is the point of regretting
values that cannot be achieved? Let us rejoice in being freed from them. This
is the stance of (some) postmodernists, notably Richard Rorty.

This yields
a pragmatist view: ideas and actions are good if they are useful, contribute to
a good life.

This
entails perspectivism: what one considers valid or true, in some sense,
or good, depends on one’s perspective, which depends on history, circumstances,
culture and personal perspective.

If the
criterion for adequacy or validity is contribution to the good life, the
question then is, of course, what the good life is and who determines that.

For Rorty
that is a matter of consensus in some community, with different communities
making different choices, without any perspective- and interest-free argument
to adjudicate between them.

For
Nietzsche the old absolutes were not just impossible to achieve but were
inimical to the good life. Life entails variety and ongoing change of
perspectives, and this is blocked by absolutes, any absolutes. For Nietzsche
the good life is contribution to the flourishing of life, the furthering of
human life and excellence, in an ongoing movement of self-transcendence and ‘Dionysian’
creative destruction, driven by the ‘will to power’. I will discuss that in a
later item.

Concerning
knowledge, one can take refuge in epistemological scepticism, like Pyrrho, and
later philosophers, such as Montaigne and David Hume. This skepticism can, but
does not necessarily, lead to radical relativism: no claim to knowledge or
truth is inherently better than any other.

An
alternative to radical relativism is to accept that values can be legitimate
and reasons can be sufficient without being absolute, while they are not
arbitrary and are subject to debate and to improvement.

In
pragmatism, absolute, objective truth is replaced by warranted assertability
(which goes back to John Dewey). Something is to be accepted is there are
good arguments for it, to be settled in debate. In pragmatism the central
warrant for assertability is that it ‘works’, stands up in practice and
furthers practical conduct.

As
indicated, for Rorty the warrant lies in consensus in some community (in
‘ethnocentrism’). Karen Carr argued[1],
correctly in my view, that this entails a surrender to conservatism, the status
quo. And if there is no basis for adjudication between different perspectives,
ultimately it is a matter of force, the right of the strong.

I would add
that it entails a surrender to what Nietzsche called the ‘herd’ and Heidegger
called ‘Das Man’. It entails surrender to suppression by the anonymous power of
institutions, illustrated by Foucault. It entails surrender to the prisoners’
dilemmas in which society has increasingly been caught (as in the case of
banking, discussed elsewhere in this blog), where individual morality is
strangled in collective interest.

Nietzsche
acknowledged that man seeks meaning and value, but rather than accepting them
from some outside authority, man produces them. Is his ultimate value as
contribution to the flourishing of life not a new absolute, a new metaphysics?
Does it yield an escape from relativism? That is the subject for the next item.

[1]Karen Carr, 1992, The
banalization of nihilism, Twentieth century responses to meaninglessness, State
University of New York Press.

No comments:

Post a Comment

Poetry blog

Poems posted on Poetrypinfold.blogspot.comComing down (a memory of Genevaa) NightYin and YangPoetry pinfoldSiëstaDown and out in the mindThe stream bears light (the Nasrid palace at the Alhambra)From one to many Sunday in GoudaOn the canalStanzas of stone (San Gimignano, torre grosso)The words have a ballNo rocket scienceMontreuxNew roomGenerationsSister (Paris)MotherMother 2Blessed solitudeCivil servantAdolescent lamentThe streamTender rip-offNight 2BirdsAtlas unmovedSeminar on KrakmaroDiplomacyDepositionWinter train in ThuringenSarajevoFar aheadHat trick on the canalFlowers of deathOn a camping one night

top 100 blog award

awarded October 2016

Bundles of blog

On my website (www.bartnooteboom.nl) I offer selected items from the blog, bundled according to theme, such as:basic incomea way out for socialism? identity, cultureevolution multiple causalityGod and religionrobots

powerknowledge, truth and inventionethics and moralitythe human conditionself and othertrustmeaning

Eastern and Western philosophypuzzles in philosophydemocracy, autocracy, and fascismvoice and exitNietzsche, nihilism and beyondTime, duration, and discontinuity: Bergson, Derrida, and Bachelardsystem tragedy

power, Foucaultsix more pieces on FoucaultLevinasMontaigneHeideggerBaudrillardWittgensteinZizek and Hegel