A ranking of supermodel-boybander PDA (or lack thereof) on Instagram.

It was like a battle of boybander boyfriends among a certain set of supermodels this holiday season. Buddies Gigi Hadid, Kendall Jenner and Hailey Baldwin each appeared in some way over the New Year weekend with the most lusted-after young male heartthrobs. While they made it clear who was with whom, their levels of PDA varied drastically.

The most blatant case of supermodel PDA came from Justin Bieber’s Instagram. The tatted-up singer posted no fewer than seven shots of paramour Hailey Baldwin in the last week. His barrage of Instas included a video showing him giving her a wet willie while she thought they were posing for a photo, and a particularly graphic one of them making out with their hands in the air. For her part, Baldwin shared just two shots of her with the Biebs, though she’s scantily clad and draped all over him in both.

Gigi Hadid was a little more subtle with showing her affections, though just barely. Over the weekend the supermodel shared a close-up black-and-white shot of a tattooed male torso holding a cat. She didn’t ID the shirtless dude, but thanks to fans’ overzealous One Direction obsessions, they quickly recognized him as Zayn Malik. She’s also posted a selfie of herself in a jersey of his favorite soccer team.

Kendall Jenner totally strayed away from social media PDA, however, on her vacation with Harry Styles. Although she didn’t share any snaps, there were plenty of bikini-clad paparazzi photographs to confirm the two’s purported rekindled romance in St. Bart’s, like those of her laying on top of him on a chaise lounge chair, and him playfully yanking her foot as they climb on a yacht.