A forum for civil debate that promotes progressive alternatives to current challenges and a firm voice for the Patriotic Left.

Sunday, March 05, 2006

Grandpa Rosenberg's America

Recently I’ve been thinking of my grandfather. I didn’t know him well because he died when I was 8. As I reflect upon his life, my memories of him and the numerous anecdotes I’ve been told – I can’t help but wonder what he would think of our country today.

Irving Rosenberg’s story resembles that of many immigrants from his generation. At the age of 16 he escaped Poland prior to Hitler’s September 1939 invasion with his six brothers. His father was a man of great foresight and correctly diagnosed the storm that was brewing from Nazi Germany. My great grandmother opposed her children leaving for America and even chased my grandfather with a broomstick prior to his departure. Thankfully she didn’t get her way or I never would’ve been born.

My grandfather was a self-motivated man of discipline, integrity and values. He believed in self-improvement to get ahead, mastered the English language, and worked hard. Fortunately, he came to this country when the great middle class was beginning its ascendancy following the Depression. During his era, a work ethic was sufficient to establish oneself in a trade and earn a decent living. My grandfather never became an entrepreneur nor did he join the professional class as a lawyer or doctor. He remained a working stiff throughout his life in the garment industry where he rose to be a valued manager in a factory. In those days it was possible for such a man to raise two kids as he did, save his earnings, and even buy a summer cottage. My grandmother never had to work. She had plenty of outside activities in the community but primarily focused on her children. And they were able to afford health insurance for themselves. All this was possible then. His job was never outsourced to another country.

My mother once told me that she remembers teasing him as a little girl while he was figuring out his taxes. An otherwise gentle man he sternly rebuked her and said, “I am proud to pay taxes in the United States of America.” Grandpa Rosenberg was a patriot and he truly believed his tax dollars went for a noble cause: preserving the greatest country in the world. From his perspective America was a beacon of prosperity and decency. It was the country that saved him from certain death, liberated the world from fascist totalitarianism and represented the side of freedom in the Cold War. He was a New Deal Democrat devoted to the ideals of his adopted country. America was standing up for right and giving him a good life. He was therefore quite happy to do his part and pay taxes. It would never have occurred to him to “starve the beast.”

I think about that anecdote with my mother whenever I read or listen to some conservative greed monger earning a six-figure salary and whining about taxes. How many people rationalized putting this President in power simply because of pure selfishness? Many of them claim to be “social moderates” yet they’re quite content to redistribute the tax burden from the wealthiest among us to laborers who can’t keep up with the cost of living. My grandfather would no doubt rebuke me for putting it this way, but I can’t help myself: such people who empowered the reign of indecency sweeping America today couldn’t carry my grandfather’s jock. He was a real man.

To be sure America was not an idyllic place in his era. Racism and anti-Semitism were blatant staples of American life. Gender discrimination was the norm. Blacks were not equal under the law and I recall hearing how his co-workers didn’t want to believe that Jesus was Jewish. It also had to be unnerving to escape the Nazis, come to New York and hear the anti-Semitic rants uttered by Father Coughlin from Madison Square Garden on the radio. He lived through periods of hysteria with McCarthyism and misguided military ventures in Korea and Vietnam. Yet even with America’s imperfections there remained a prevailing sentiment of optimism and progress. The little guy had a piece of the American dream in Grandpa Rosenberg’s America. Stability and security were not simply purviews of the mega rich. Our culture valued work over wealth and individuals like him benefited.

One could also feel reasonably confident in the competence and intentions of our leadership. Eisenhower may not have been as progressive as he would’ve liked but at least one could respect the President. Even the devious Richard Nixon at least had something between his ears when an emergency presented itself – it’s doubtful Hurricane Katrina would’ve played out the same way on his watch. Yes there was corruption, abuses of power, and misjudgments in both parties. America’s imperfections and regulation by fear did not solely manifest itself under the current administration. But our civilization was moving forward albeit with setbacks and traumas. Progress is never a straight uninterrupted forward line but it was the trend for much of my grandfather’s life.

It doesn’t feel that way today. The conservative movement finally achieved critical mass when George W. Bush took the oath of office in January 2001 after decades of political agitation from exile. The results are a staggering display of callous incompetence. These people know how to seize power and keep it. They have no idea how to use it for the greater public good. Under their rule wages have declined while personal bankruptcies, health care costs, college tuition, energy costs, and the number of uninsured and poor Americans continue to increase. The government is populated by incompetent chuckleheads who view public service as an entitlement program for cronies to enrich themselves. Public service agencies such as FEMA have simply become another stronghold for corporate welfare and even national security was hijacked by greed. Hence is it any wonder that this group ignored warnings that Osama Bin Laden wanted to attack America and drew up plans to invade Iraq so the monied interests that put them in power could profit?

My grandfather was also a quietly religious man. Decency and treating others with respect was part of his overall being. He was secure enough in his beliefs that he didn’t need to proselytize to anyone about them. The exploitation of religion to drive wedges between people would’ve disgusted him. Furthermore, the debasement of America’s reputation from torture scandals would’ve have profoundly saddened him I think. For him the “culture of life” was more than a mere slogan – it was how he lived.

As I contrast my late grandfather’s value system with our current leadership I can only reach one conclusion: he would not approve.

4 comments:

VtPoet
said...

I have read commentaries speculating that the underfunding of agencies such as FEMA are a two pronged strategy. The first part is straightfoward, reducing funding reduces government and that extra money translates into tax cuts which, conservatives would assert, benefits the economy as a whole.

The second part is far more, to me, sinister and cynical if true. Some commentators have speculated that the underfunding of FEMA and other related agencies is meant to undermine their effectiveness and performance, and so undermine their political popularity, making them easier to eliminate and more difficult for Democrats and Liberals to defend. In essence, this assertion speculates that conservatives *want* the "government" to look bad. Then they can cut these programs and hand them over to the "private sector": read "faith based sector". Indeed, Bush has repeatedly put forth the idea that "faith-based" organizations should be assuming certain roles the government has traditionally overseen. What makes this strategy, if true, so sinister is that it implies a willingness among some conservatives to, in plain terms, sacrifice American lives if their deaths achieves their aims (making the "government" look bad). An underfunded and inept FEMA certainly cost more lives than it otherwise might have.

If this is true, then it would appear that the right wing has severely miscalculated. Rather than disgust with government, the American public seems disgusted only with those who have, in their eyes, mismanaged (through incompetence or criminality) the government that was entrusted to them.

It might well be that Katrina will be seen as the storm that led to the downfall of neo-conservatism. What is troubling is that there is no one to fill the void. The Democrats appear to be a loose conglomeration of inviduals with little to offer. They sit like asses in the barnyard, waiting for the apples to fall.

Something that will stick in my mind forever is seeing a beady-eyed guy on CNN justifying tax privileges for the wealthy as a reward for "working on Saturdays". The sad thing is that these privileges would come at the expense of people who actually do work on Saturdays...for slave wages.

Thanks for sharing this story about your Grandfather with your readers. Yeah, G'pa Rosenberg would not approve.

I am of irish stock and the Rosenberg story is a lot like that of the Sullivans (my people) who imigrated about 1920. My Pop Sullivan was a retired sanitation engineer (read: trash man) who cleaned to streets of NYC for a living. But there was a certain dignity to such an existance. In exchange for hard work, he enjoyed security and was able to raise a family (Mamaw was a stay-at-home mom) and buy a home and retire with pride.

It's not esy paying taxes when our treasure is plundered in the manner it is under President Bush. If i lived in sweden i'd gladly fork over the majority of my income in taxes....

wow, imagine living is sweden, i'd have health insurance, i would have NO student debt.....

Search This Blog

About Me

I'm an information professional with a Bachelor of Arts from Sarah Lawrence College and Masters in Library Science from Queens College Graduate School for Library and Information Studies.
Obviously, I have to earn a living and therefore won't be able to post new entries everyday. However, I will make every effort to regulary unscreen comments from others.
Please be advised that my podcast interviews originally posted here can also be accessed for free on Itunes. Simply search in the Itunes store for Intrepid Liberal Journal or Robert Ellman.

PLEASE CONTRIBUTE TO THIS BLOG

I hope the content of this blog is appreciated and I humbly request readers make a donation by either clicking on the button below or completing a purchase through the Amazon.com advertisements. Another option is to click on the Google text advertisements. It happens that having my podcast interviews stored on a host site costs money and so does some of the research I do. So, even though blogspot is free, the content I provide does add up over time. I appreciate the consideration and understanding.