c. Preparation of the next DH meeting (928th meeting, 6-7 June 2005) 7

d. New working methods of the Deputies’ Human Rights meetings 7

e. Judgments of the European Court of Human Rights raising issues linked to international conflicts of jurisdiction in child custody matters 7

Section 1

Final Resolutions 8

Section 2

New cases 9

Section 3.a

Supervision of the payment of the capital sum of the just satisfaction as well as, where due,

of default interest, in cases where the deadline for payment expired less than 6 months ago 19

Section 3.b

Supervision of payment of the capital sum of the just satisfaction in cases where the deadline for

payment expired more than 6 months ago 28

Section 3.c

Examination of special payment problems 31

Section 4.1

Supervision of individual measures only 32

Section 4.2

Individual measures and/or general problems 38

Section 4.3

Special problems 47

Section 5.1

Legislative and/or regulatory changes 49

Page

Section 5.2

Changes of courts’ case-law or of administrative practice 50

Section 5.3

Publication/dissemination 51

Section 5.4

Other measures 52

Section 6.1

Cases in which the new information available since the last examination appears to allow the

preparation of a draft final resolution 53

Section 6.2

Cases waiting for the presentation of a draft final resolution 54

The 922nd (DH) meeting of the Ministers’ Deputies opened on 5 April 2005 at 10.00 a.m. under the chairmanship of Mr G.Magheru, Deputy for the Minister for Foreign Affairs of Romania and continued on 7 April 2005 under the chairmanship of Mr J. Duarte, Deputy for the Minister for Foreign Affairs of Portugal (only in the afternoon and for the examination of items H46-432, H46- 434, H46-950, H46-952).

PRESENT

ALBANIA

Ms I Varfi

ANDORRA

Ms G. Cano

ARMENIA

Mr L. Amirdjanian

AUSTRIA

Mr M. Botta

AZERBAIJAN

Mr S. Sharifov

BELGIUM

Mr M. Peetermans

BOSNIA AND HERZEGOVINA

Ms M. Sidran-Beslagic

BULGARIA

Ms E. Tomova

CROATIA

Ms V. Batistić-Kos

Mr D. Maričić

CYPRUS

Mr P. Kombos

Mr C. Petinos

Mr G. Ioannides

Ms S.M. Joannides

CZECH REPUBLIC

Ms V. Stromšìkovà

DENMARK

Mr J. D. Thomsen

ESTONIA

Mr E. Harremoes

FINLAND

Ms A.E. Viljanen

FRANCE

Mr P. Merlin

GEORGIA

Mr A. Meladze

Mr H-J. Bartsch

GERMANY

Ms E. Müller

GREECE

Ms V. Pelekou

HUNGARY

Ms E. Petőházi

ICELAND

Ms E. Magnus

IRELAND

Mr R. Gargan

Ms C. Sharkey

ITALY

Mr P. Lonardo

Mr N. Tassoni Estense di Castelvecchio

Mr F. Crisafulli

Mr N. Lettieri

LATVIA

Mr J. Mažeiks

LIECHTENSTEIN

-

LITHUANIA

Mr J. Rakitskis

LUXEMBOURG

Ms A. Kayser

MALTA

-

MOLDOVA

Mr A. Tulbure

Mr I. Pohila

MONACO

-

NETHERLANDS

Mr M. van den Bosch

NORWAY

Mr H. Andreassen

POLAND

Mr J. Wolasiewicz

PORTUGAL

Mr J. Duarte Chairman (on 7 April part of the afternoon)

Mr A. Figueira

Mr F. Brito

ROMANIA

Mr G. Magheru, Chairman

Mr R. Rotundu

Ms I. Pāunescu

Ms M. Pascaru

RUSSIAN FEDERATION

Ms M. Molodtsova

SAN MARINO

-

SERBIA AND MONTENEGRO

Mr I. Vucinic

SLOVAK REPUBLIC

Ms M. Slováková

Ms M. Pirošîková

Ms. K. Čahojová

SLOVENIA

-

SPAIN

Mr M. Alonso

SWEDEN

Ms P. Berlin

SWITZERLAND

Mr J.C. Joseph

Ms C. Trautweiler

“THE FORMER

YUGOSLAV REPUBLIC

OF MACEDONIA”

Ms O. Graovska

Ms O. Vasilevska

TURKEY

Mr K. Ecener

Mr U. Umar

Ms D. Akçay

Ms G. Erönen

Mr R. Tatar

UKRAINE

Mr A. Kuzmenko

UNITED KINGDOM

Ms P. Mitchison

*

* *

EUROPEAN COMMISSION

-

*

* *

Item a.

Adoption of the Annotated Agenda and Order of Business

The Deputies

1. agreed to add the following items to the agenda of their 922nd (DH) meeting:

The Deputies agreed to resume consideration of these items at their 928th meeting (6-7 June 2005) (DH), on the basis of further information to be provided by the authorities of the respondent state concerning payment of the sums awarded or agreed in these cases:

- 2 cases against Austria

H46-3 69756/01+ Woditschka and Wilfling, judgment of 21/10/2004, final on 21/01/2005

1. having noted the information provided by the delegation of the respondent state, instructed the Secretariat to consider the advisability of preparing a draft final resolution in these cases;

2. agreed to resume consideration of these items at their 928th meeting (6-7 June 2005) (DH):

- 1 case against Austria

H46-5 16174/02 Malek Bettina, judgment of 21/10/2004, final on 21/01/2005

- 1 case against France

H46-32 69680/01 Coulaud, judgment of 02/11/2004, final on 02/02/2005

- 1 case against Poland

H46-68 38668/97 Ciszewski, judgment of 13/07/2004, final on 13/10/2004

The Deputies agreed to resume consideration of these items at their 928th meeting (6-7 June 2005) (DH), on the basis of further information to be provided by the authorities of the respondent state concerning payment of the sums awarded in these cases as well as the individual measures to be taken in order to put an end to the violations and erase, as far as possible, their consequences for the applicants:

- 1 case against Bulgaria

H46-7 50222/99 Krastanov, judgment of 30/09/2004, final on 30/12/2004

- 1 case against Greece

H46-45 67629/01 Assymomitis, judgment of 14/10/2004, final on 14/01/2005

- 1 case against the Netherlands

H46-64 44760/98 Del Latte, judgment of 09/11/2004, final on 09/02/2005

- 2 cases against Spain

H46-109 58438/00 Martínez Sala and others, judgment of 02/11/2004, final on 02/02/2005

H46-110 77837/01 Saez Maeso, judgment of 09/11/2004, final on 09/02/2005

* * *

The Deputies agreed to resume consideration of these items at their 928th meeting (6-7 June 2005) (DH), on the basis of further information to be provided by the authorities of the respondent state concerning payment of the sums awarded in these cases, the general measures proposed to prevent new, similar violations as well as the individual measures to be taken in order to put an end to the violations and erase, as far as possible, their consequences for the applicants:

Cases of length of proceedings concerning civil rights and obligations before labour courts

H46-93 57467/00 Lipowicz, judgment of 19/10/2004, final on 19/01/2005

H46-91 63391/00 Marszał, judgment of 14/09/2004, final on 14/12/2004

H46-94 62109/00. Mejer and Jałoszyńska, judgment of 19/10/04, final on 19/01/2005

H46-95 52074/99 Wiatrzyk, judgment of 26/10/2004, final on 26/01/2005

* * *

The Deputies agreed to resume consideration of this item at their 928th meeting (6-7 June 2005) (DH), on the basis of further information to be provided by the authorities of the respondent state concerning payment of the sums awarded in this case and to join it, subsequently, with the Kitov group, to supervise the general measures proposed to prevent new, similar violations:

- 1 case against Bulgaria

H46-14 54178/00+ Osmanov and Yuseinov, judgment of 23/09/2004, final on 23/12/2004

* * *

The Deputies agreed to resume consideration of this item at their 928th meeting (6-7 June 2005) (DH), on the basis of further information to be provided by the authorities of the respondent state concerning payment of the sums awarded in this case and to join it, subsequently, with the Yankov case, to supervise the general measures proposed to prevent new, similar violations:

- 1 case against Bulgaria

H46-8 47799/99 Bojinov, judgment of 28/10/2004, final on 28/01/2005

* * *

The Deputies agreed to resume consideration of these items at their 928th meeting (6-7 June 2005) (DH), on the basis of further information to be provided by the authorities of the respondent state concerning payment of the sums awarded in these cases and to join them, subsequently, with the case of Djangozov, to supervise the general measures proposed to prevent new, similar violations:

- 2 cases against Bulgaria

Cases of length of civil proceedings

H46-15 47829/99 Dimitrov, judgment of 23/09/2004, final on 23/12/2004

H46-16 47877/99 Rachevi, judgment of 23/09/2004, final on 23/12/2004

* * *

The Deputies agreed to resume consideration of these items at their 928th meeting (6-7 June 2005) (DH), on the basis of further information to be provided by the authorities of the respondent state concerning payment of the sums awarded in these cases and to join them, at the same meeting, with the Manios group, to supervise the general measures proposed to prevent new, similar violations:

- 2 cases against Greece

H46-46 70314/01 Gialamas, judgment of 21/10/2004, final on 21/01/2005

*H46-50 19841/02 Agathos and 49 others, judgment of 23/09/2004, final on 02/02/2005

* * *

The Deputies agreed to resume consideration of this item at their 928th meeting (6-7 June 2005) (DH), on the basis of further information to be provided by the authorities of the respondent state concerning payment of the sums awarded in this case and to join it, at the same meeting, with the case of S.B.F. S.p.a., to supervise the general measures proposed to prevent new, similar violations:

The Deputies agreed to resume consideration of this item at their 928th meeting (6-7 June 2005) (DH), on the basis of further information to be provided by the authorities of the respondent state concerning payment of the sums awarded in this case and to join it, subsequently, with the Calogero Diana group, to supervise the general measures proposed to prevent new, similar violations:

- 1 case against Italy

H46-62 40750/98 Ospina Vargas, judgment of 14/10/2004, final on 14/01/2005

* * *

The Deputies agreed to resume consideration of this item at their 928th meeting (6-7 June 2005) (DH), on the basis of further information to be provided by the authorities of the respondent state concerning payment of the sums awarded in this case and to join it, subsequently, with the Trzaska group, to supervise the general measures proposed to prevent new, similar violations:

- 1 case against Poland

H46-92 42643/98 Paszkowski, judgment of 28/10/2004, final on 28/01/2005

* * *

The Deputies agreed to resume consideration of this item at their 928th meeting (6-7 June 2005) (DH), on the basis of further information to be provided by the authorities of the respondent state concerning payment of the sums awarded in this case and to join it, subsequently, with the Kormacheva case, to supervise the general measures proposed to prevent new, similar violations:

- 1 case against the Russian Federation

*H46-108 60408/00 Yemanakova, judgment of 23/09/2004, final on 02/02/2005

* * *

The Deputies agreed to resume consideration of these items at their 928th meeting (6-7 June 2005) (DH), on the basis of further information to be provided by the authorities of the respondent state concerning payment of the sums awarded in these cases and to join them, at the same meeting, with the cases concerning Action of the Turkish security forces, to supervise the general measures proposed to prevent new, similar violations:

- 3 cases against Turkey

H46-111 30494/96 Tuncer and Durmuş, judgment of 02/11/2004, final on 02/02/2005

H46-113 46928/99 Zengin Güli, judgment of 28/10/2004, final on 28/01/2005

H46-114 44093/98 Çelik and İmret, judgment of 26/10/2004, final on 26/01/2005

* * *

The Deputies agreed to resume consideration of this item at their 928th meeting (6-7 June 2005) (DH), on the basis of further information to be provided by the authorities of the respondent state concerning payment of the sums awarded in this case and to join it, at the same meeting, with the Zhovner case, to supervise the general measures proposed to prevent new, similar violations:

- 1 case against Ukraine

H46-147 67647/01 Bakay and others, judgment of 09/11/2004, final on 09/02/2005

* * *

The Deputies agreed to resume consideration of these items at their 928th meeting (6-7 June 2005) (DH), on the basis of further information to be provided by the authorities of the respondent states concerning payment of the sums awarded in these cases and to join them, subsequently, with the Kutić group, to supervise the general measures proposed to prevent new, similar violations as well as the individual measures to put an end to the violations and erase, as far as possible, their consequences for the applicants:

- 3 cases against Croatia

H46-17 5705/02 Dragović, judgment of 28/10/2004, final on 28/01/2005

H46-18 9138/02 Marinković, judgment of 21/10/2004, final on 21/01/2005

H46-19 78008/01 Varićak, judgment of 21/10/2004, final on 21/01/2005

* * *

The Deputies agreed to resume consideration of these items at their 928th meeting (6-7 June 2005) (DH), on the basis of further information to be provided by the authorities of the respondent state concerning payment of the sums awarded in these cases and to join them, subsequently, with the cases of Bořánková and Hartman, to supervise the general measures proposed to prevent new, similar violations as well as the individual measures to put an end to the violations and erase, as far as possible, their consequences for the applicants:

*H46-24 76802/01 Hradecký, judgment of 05/10/2004, final on 02/02/2005

H46-22 66448/01 Jahnová, judgment of 19/10/2004, final on 19/01/2005

H46-25 65195/01 Jírů, judgment of 26/10/2004, final on 26/01/2005

H46-23 73578/01 Pištorová, judgment of 26/10/2004, final on 26/01/2005

* * *

The Deputies agreed to resume consideration of these items at their 928th meeting (6-7 June 2005) (DH), on the basis of further information to be provided by the authorities of the respondent state concerning payment of the sums awarded in these cases and to joint them, subsequently, with the Papageorgiou group, to supervise the general measures proposed to prevent new, similar violations as well as the individual measures to put an end to the violations and erase, as far as possible, their consequences for the applicants:

- 2 cases against Greece

H46-47 71498/01 Kotsaridis, judgment of 23/09/2004, final on 23/12/2004

H46-49 11800/02 Rodopoulos, judgment of 14/10/2004, final on 14/01/2005

The Deputies agreed to resume consideration of these items at their 928th meeting (6-7 June 2005) (DH), on the basis of further information to be provided by the authorities of the respondent state concerning payment of the sums awarded in these cases and to joint them, subsequently, with the cases of the Tímár group, to supervise the general measures proposed to prevent new, similar violations as well as the individual measures to put an end to the violations and erase, as far as possible, their consequences for the applicants:

- 10 cases against Hungary

Cases of length of proceedings concerning civil rights and obligations including before the labour courts

H46-52 71096/01 Dala, judgment of 05/10/04, final on 05/01/05

H46-53 73413/01 Kellner, judgment of 28/09/04, final on 28/12/04

H46-59 67660/01 Kovács Tamás, judgment of 28/09/04, final on 28/12/04

H46-60 4853/02 Kútfalvy, judgment of 05/10/04, final on 05/01/05

H46-54 66020/01 Mátyás, judgment of 28/09/04, final on 28/12/04

H46-55 4395/02 Móder, judgment of 05/10/04, final on 05/01/05

H46-56 4395/02 Molnár, judgment of 05/10/04, final on 05/01/05

H46-57 61530/00 Nagy and others, judgment of 14/09/04, final on 02/02/05

The Deputies agreed to resume consideration of these items at their 928th meeting (6-7 June 2005) (DH), on the basis of further information to be provided by the authorities of the respondent state concerning payment of the sums awarded in these cases and to join them, subsequently, with the Podbielski group, to supervise the general measures proposed to prevent new, similar violations, and the individual measures to put an end to the violation and erase, as far as possible, its consequences for the applicants:

- 22 cases against Poland

Cases of length of civil proceedings

H46-69 2560/02 Dudek, judgment of 05/10/04, final on 05/01/05.

H46-70 6735/03 Durasik, judgment of 28/09/04, final on 28/12/04.

H46-71 52524/99 Falęcka, judgment of 05/10/04, final on 05/01/05.

H46-72 57670/00 Fojcik, judgment of 21/09/04, final on 21/12/04.

H46-73 7530/02 Iżykowska, judgment of 28/09/04, final on 28/12/04.

H46-74 61454/00 Janas, judgment of 21/09/04, final on 21/12/04.

H46-75 72048/01 Jastrzębska, judgment of 28/09/04, final on 28/12/04.

H46-76 59445/00 Koblański, judgment of 28/09/04, final on 28/12/04.

H46-77 57672/00 Korbel, judgment of 21/09/04, final on 21/12/04.

H46-78 65017/01 Król, judgment of 28/09/04, final on 28/12/04.

*H46-79 67690/01 Kruk, judgment of 05/10/04, final on 02/02/05

H46-80 50424/99 Kusiak, judgment of 21/09/04, final on 21/12/04.

H46-81 10675/02 Kuśmierek, judgment of 21/09/04, final on 21/12/04.

H46-82 63442/00 Kuśmierkowski, , judgment of 05/10/04, final on 05/01/05

H46-83 71625/01 Lizut-Skwarek, judgment of 05/10/04, final on 05/01/05.

H46-84 63390/00 Malinowska-Biedrzycka, judgment of 05/10/04, final on 05/01/05.

H46-85 62179/00 Pieniążek Irena, judgment of 28/09/04, final on 28/12/04.

H46-86 65719/01 Przygodzki, judgment of 05/10/04, final on 05/01/05.

H46-87 77681/01 R.P.D., judgment of 19/10/04, final on 19/01/05.

H46-88 45299/99 Romanow (Barańska), judgment of 21/09/04, final on 21/12/04.

H46-89 64764/01 Sikora, judgment of 05/10/04, final on 05/01/05.

H46-90 70213/01 Zys-Kowalski, judgment of 28/09/04, final on 28/12/04.

* * *

The Deputies agreed to resume consideration of these items at their 928th meeting (6-7 June 2005) (DH), on the basis of further information to be provided by the authorities of the respondent state concerning payment of the sums awarded in these cases, and to join them, at the same meeting, with the other cases concerning freedom of expression, to supervise the general measures proposed to prevent new, similar violations, and the individual measures to put an end to the violation and erase, as far as possible, its consequences for the applicants:

- 3 cases against Turkey

Cases of freedom of expression

H46-115 49283/99 Doğaner, judgment of 21/10/2004, final on 21/01/2005

H46-116 38586/97 Varli and others, judgment of 19/10/2004, final on 19/01/2005

H46-117 42713/98 Yazar Feridun and others, judgment of 23/09/2004, final on 23/12/2004, rectified on 01/02/2005

* * *

The Deputies agreed to resume consideration of this item at their 928th meeting (6-7 June 2005) (DH), on the basis of further information to be provided by the authorities of the respondent state concerning payment of the sums agreed in this case and to join it, at the same meeting, with the other friendly settlements concerning freedom of expression, to supervise the measures to be taken:

The Deputies agreed to resume consideration of these items at their 928th meeting (6-7 June 2005) (DH), on the basis of further information to be provided by the authorities of the respondent state concerning payment of the sums awarded in these cases, and to join them, at the same meeting, with the other cases concerning independence and impartiality of State security courts, to supervise the individual measures to put an end to the violation and erase, as far as possible, its consequences for the applicants:

- 10 cases against Turkey

Cases concerning independence and impartiality of State security courts

*H46-119 42437/98 Dinç Riza, judgment of 28/10/2004, final on 02/02/2005

H46-120 34498/97 Döner, judgment of 26/10/2004, final on 26/01/2005

H46-121 46506/99+ Durmaz and others, judgment of 14/10/2004, final on 14/01/2005

H46-122 43926/98 Epözdemir, judgment of 28/10/2004, final on 28/01/2005

H46-123 57758/00 Kaymaz and others, judgment of 28/10/2004, final on 28/01/2005

H46-124 40498/98 Kılıç Murat, judgment of 30/09/2004, final on 30/12/2004

H46-125 59244/00 Öztürk Ayşe, judgment of 04/11/2004, final on 04/02/2005

H46-128 46284/99 Yanıkoğlu, judgment of 14/10/2004, final on 14/01/2005

H46-127 48173/99+ Y.B. and others, judgment of 28/10/2004, final on 28/01/2005

* * *

The Deputies agreed to resume consideration of this item at their 948th meeting (29-30 November 2005) (DH), and to join it, at the same meeting, with the Immobiliare Saffi group, to supervise the general measures proposed to prevent new, similar violations:

- 1 case against Italy

H46-63 52081/99 Caracciolo, judgment of 14/10/2004, final on 14/01/2005

* * *

The Deputies, having examined progress made in ensuring execution, decided to resume consideration of this case at a forthcoming meeting not later than six months hence, on the basis of further information to be provided by the authorities of the respondent state concerning the publication of the Court’s judgment and its dissemination to the authorities concerned to draw their attention to obligations under the Convention:

- 1 case against the United Kingdom

H46-152 515/02 Henworth, judgment of 02/11/2004, final on 02/02/2005

* * *

The Deputies agreed to resume consideration of these items at a forthcoming meeting, at their 940th meeting (11-12 October 2005) (DH), on the basis of further information to be provided by the authorities of the respondent state concerning the general measures proposed to prevent new, similar violations:

H46-107 60776/00 Poleshchuk, judgment of 07/10/2004, final on 07/01/2005

- 1 case against the United Kingdom

H46-148 45508/99 H.L., judgment of 05/10/2004, final on 05/01/2005

* * *

The Deputies agreed to resume consideration of these items at one of their forthcoming meeting, as soon as the judgment of the European Court on just satisfaction (Article 41) is delivered or not later than six months hence:

- 1 case against Finland

H46-30 41673/98 Bruncrona, judgment of 16/11/2004, final on 16/02/2005

- 1 case against Romania

H46-105 38608/97 Ionescu, judgment of 02/11/2004, final on 02/02/2005

Section 3.a

The Deputies decided to resume consideration of the following cases at their 928th meeting (6-7June 2005) (DH) for supervision of payment of the justsatisfactionor, at the latest, within six months providing that the just satisfaction is paid before the deadline for transmission of new information for the preparation of the meeting:

H46-504 36256/97 Thompson, judgment of 15/06/2004, final on 15/09/2004

H46-507 19365/02 Hill, judgment of 27/04/2004, final on 27/07/2004

* * *

The Deputies, having examined progress made in ensuring execution, decided to resume consideration of these cases at their 928th meeting (6-7 June 2005) (DH), on the basis of further information to be provided by the authorities of the respondent state concerning the general measures proposed to prevent new, similar violations and the individual measures to put an end to the violations and erase, as far as possible, their consequences for the applicants:

- 1 case against Lithuania

H46-395 55480/00+ Sidabras and Džiautas, judgment of 27/07/2004, final on 27/10/2004

- 3 cases against Turkey

- Cases concerning the freedom of expression

H46-475 43995/98 Okutan, judgment of 29/07/2004, final on 29/10/2004

H46-476 42920/98 Yıldırım Haydar and others, judgment of 15/07/2004, final on 15/10/2004

H46-506 35574/97 Le Petit, judgment of 15/06/2004, final on 15/09/2004

* * *

The Deputies, having examined progress made in ensuring execution, decided to resume consideration of this case at their 933rd meeting (5-6 July 2005) (DH), on the basis of further information to be provided by the authorities of the respondent state concerning the general measures proposed to prevent new, similar violations, and the individual measures to put an end to the violations and erase, as far as possible, their consequences for the applicant:

- 1 case against Romania

H46-431 48995/99 Surugiu, judgment of 20/04/2004, final on 10/11/2004

* * *

The Deputies

1. having noted the information provided by the delegation of the respondent state, instructed the Secretariat to consider the advisability of preparing a draft final resolution in each of these cases;

2. agreed to resume consideration of these items at their 928th meeting (6-7 June 2005) (DH):

- 1 case against the Netherlands

H46-401 56698/00 Hutten, judgment of 26/10/2004 - Friendly settlement

- 4 cases against Turkey

-Delays by the administration in paying additional compensation for expropriation and the applicable rate of default interest

H46-478 40261/98 Aydın Asuman, judgment of 15/07/2004, final on 10/11/2004

H46-480 42432/98 Koçak and others, judgment of 19/05/2004, final on 10/11/2004

H46-481 42559/98 Öner and Çavuşoğu, judgment of 24/06/2004, final on 10/11/2004

H46-482 36973/97 Yaşar Muhey and others, judgment of 22/07/2004, final on 22/10/2004

Section 3.b

The Deputies decided to resume consideration of the following cases at their 928th meeting (6-7June 2005) (DH) for supervision of payment of the just satisfaction or, at the latest, within six months providing that the just satisfaction is paid before the deadline for transmission of new information for the preparation of the meeting:

- 1 case against Finland

H46-508 48339/99 Kangasluoma, judgment of 20/01/2004, final on 14/06/2004 14/09/2004

- 18 cases against France

H46-509 38396/97 Karatas and Sari, judgment of 16/05/02, final on 16/08/02 16/11/2002

H46-510 48161/99 Motais de Narbonne, judgment of 02/07/02, final on 02/10/02 and 02/01/2003

judgment of 27/05/03, final on 24/09/03 24/12/2003

H46-511 44081/98 Perhirin and 29 others, judgment of 14/05/02, final on 04/09/02,

revised on 08/04/03, final on 08/07/03 08/10/2003

H46-512 44962/98 Yvon, judgment of 24/04/03, final on 24/07/03 24/10/2004

H46-513 61173/00 Lechoisne and others, judgment of 17/06/03, final on 17/09/03 17/12/2003

The Deputies, having examined progress made in ensuring execution, decided to resume consideration of these cases at their 928th meeting (6-7June 2005) (DH) on the basis of further information to be provided by the authorities of the respondent state concerning individual measures to put an end to the violation and erase, as far as possible, its consequences for the applicants:

H46-757 30054/96 Kelly and others, judgment of 04/05/01, final on 04/08/01

H46-758 43290/98 McShane, judgment of 28/05/02, final on 28/08/02

H46-759 29178/95 Finucane, judgment of 01/07/03, final on 01/10/03

* * *

The Deputies, having examined progress made in ensuring execution, decided to resume consideration of these cases at one of their forthcoming meetings not later than six months hence on the basis of further information to be provided by the authorities of the respondent state concerning individual measures to put an end to the violation and erase, as far as possible, its consequences for the applicants:

- 2 cases against France

Cases of length of civil proceedings

H46-661 42405/98 C.D., judgment of 07/01/03, final on 21/05/03

H46-809 42407/98 C.R., judgment of 23/09/2003, final on 23/12/2003

- 2 cases against the Slovak Republic

Cases of length of civil proceedings

H46-697 53376/99 Beňačková, judgment of 17/06/03, final on 17/09/03

H46-698 65567/01 Piskura, judgment of 27/05/03, final on 24/09/03

* * *

The Deputies, having examined progress made in ensuring execution, agreed to resume consideration of these cases at a forthcoming meeting not later than six months hence, on the basis of further information to be provided by the authorities of the respondent state concerning the general measures proposed to prevent new, similar violations and the individual measures to put an end to the violations and erase, as far as possible, their consequences for the applicants:

- 4 cases against Belgium

H46-653 26103/95 Van Geyseghem, judgment of 21/01/99 – Grand Chamber

H46-654 34989/97 Goedhart, judgment of 20/03/01, final on 20/06/01

H46-655 36449/97+ Stroek L. and C., judgment of 20/03/01, final on 20/06/01

H46-656 51338/99 Pronk, judgment of 08/07/2004, final on 08/10/2004

- 6 cases against Croatia

H46-776 61237/00 Aćimović, judgment of 09/10/03, final on 09/01/04

H46-783 58115/00 Čuljak and others, judgment of 19/12/02, final on 19/03/03

H46-778 60533/00 Kastelic, judgment of 15/07/03, final on 15/10/03

H46-779 48778/99 Kutić, judgment of 01/03/02, final on 01/06/02

H46-780 58112/00 Multiplex, judgment of 10/07/03, final on 10/10/03

*H46-777 5266/02 Freimann, judgment of 24/06/2004, final on 24/09/2004

- 1 case against France

H46-660 46621/99 Mutimura, judgment of 08/06/2004, final on 08/09/2004

- 16 cases against Hungary

Cases of length of proceedings concerning civil rights and obligations in particular before the labour courts

H46-666 36186/97 Tímár, judgment of 25/02/03, final on 09/07/03

H46-667 59562/00 Earl, judgment of 20/01/04, final on 20/04/04

H46-668 58887/00 Károly, judgment of 02/12/03, final on 24/03/04

H46-669 61568/00 Kastner, judgment of 29/06/2004, final on 29/09/2004

H46-670 47355/99 Kerékgyártó, judgment of 16/12/03, final on 24/03/04

H46-671 54457/00 Kovács, judgment of 16/12/03, final on 07/07/04

H46-672 43657/98 Lévai and Nagy, judgment of 08/04/03, final on 24/09/03

H46-673 62730/00 Lovász, judgment of 20/01/04, final on 20/04/04

H46-674 55539/00 Militaru, judgment of 12/11/03, final on 12/02/04

H46-675 52724/99+ Nyírő and Takács, judgment of 21/10/2003, final on 11/11/2003

H46-676 59094/00 Sesztakov, judgment of 16/12/03, final on 16/03/04

H46-677 53844/00 Sikó, judgment of 04/11/03, final on 04/02/04

H46-678 42961/98 Simkó, judgment of 08/04/03, final on 08/07/03

H46-679 59056/00 Szakály, judgment of 25/05/2004, final on 25/08/2004

H46-680 60297/00 Tóth, judgment of 30/03/2004, final on 07/07/2004

H46-681 57966/00 Vass, judgment of 25/11/03, final on 24/03/04

- 1 case against Romania

H46-951 33343/96 Pantea, judgment of 03/06/03, final on 03/09/03

* * *

The Deputies, having examined progress made in ensuring execution, agreed to resume consideration of this case at their 928th meeting (DH) (6-7 June 2005) on the basis of further information to be provided by the authorities of the respondent state concerning the general measures proposed to prevent new, similar violations and the individual measures to put an end to the violations and erase, as far as possible, their consequences for the applicants:

- 1 case against Bulgaria

H46-658 50963/99 Al-Nashif and others, judgment of 20/06/02, final on 20/09/02

* * *

The Deputies

1. having noted the information provided by the delegation of the respondent state, instructed the Secretariat to consider the advisability of preparing a draft final resolution in this case;

2. agreed to resume consideration of this item at their 928th meeting (6-7 June 2005) (DH):

- 1 case against Germany

H46-663 11057/02 Haase, judgment of 08/04/2004, final on 08/07/2004

* * *

The Deputies, having examined progress made in ensuring execution, decided to resume consideration of this case at a forthcoming meeting not later than six months hence, on the basis of further information to be provided by the authorities of the respondent state concerning the general measures proposed to prevent new, similar violations:

- 1 case against Italy

H46-685 41879/98 Saggio, judgment of 25/10/01, final on 25/01/02

* * *

The Deputies, having examined progress made in ensuring execution, agreed to resume consideration of these cases at their 928th meeting (DH) (6-7 June 2005) on the basis of further information to be provided by the authorities of the respondent state concerning the just satisfaction payment, if necessary, as well as the individual measures to put an end to the violations and erase, as far as possible, their consequences for the applicants:

- 2 cases against Italy

H46-214 67972/01 Somogyi, judgment of 18/05/2004, final on 10/11/2004

H46-216 7503/02 Neroni, judgment of 20/04/2004, final on 10/11/2004

- 2 cases against Romania

H46-432 78028/01 Pini and Bertani and Manera and Atripaldi, judgment of 22/06/2004, final on 22/09/2004

H46-434 34647/97 Ruianu, judgment of 17/06/03, final on 17/09/03

- 1 case against Spain

H46-610 55524/00 Stone Court Shipping Company S.A., judgment of 28/10/03,
final on 28/01/04

- 67 cases against Turkey

H46-453 34592/97 Ağdaş, judgment of 27/07/2004, final on 27/10/2004

Cases concerning independence and impartiality of the state security courts

H46-704 39678/98 Acar Leşker, judgment of 22/06/2004, final on 22/09/2004

H46-705 59759/00 Akçakale, judgment of 25/05/2004, final on 25/08/2004

H46-626 52665/99 Akkaş Çağlar, judgment of 23/10/03, final on 24/03/04

H46-706 41956/98 Aksaç, judgment of 15/07/2004, final on 15/10/2004

H46-627 59234/00 Al and others, judgment of 13/11/03, final on 24/03/04

H46-707 57562/00 Becerikli and Altekin, judgment of 08/01/2004, final on 14/06/2004

H46-628 46388/99 Bozkurt Bilal and others, judgment of 04/12/03, final on 24/03/04

H46-467 55812/00 Çaloğlu Vahit and Hilan, judgment of 29/07/2004, final on 29/10/2004

H46-708 38389/97 Can Mahmut, judgment of 27/11/03, final on 27/02/03

H46-709 41580/98+ Çavuş and Bulut, judgment of 23/10/2003, final on 24/03/2004

H46-710 47757/99 Çavuşoğlu and others, judgment of 04/12/03, final on 04/03/04

H46-711 57944/00 Çetinkaya and others, judgment of 18/12/2003, final on 14/06/2004

H46-753 48992/99 Yılmaz Murat, judgment of 24/06/2004, final on 24/09/2004

* * *

The Deputies, having examined progress made in ensuring execution, agreed to resume consideration of these cases at their 928th meeting (DH) (6-7 June 2005) on the basis of further information to be provided by the authorities of the respondent state concerning the just satisfaction payment as well as the general measures proposed to prevent new, similar violations and the individual measures to put an end to the violations and erase, as far as possible, their consequences for the applicants:

- 1 case against Ukraine

H46-633 66561/01 Merit, judgment of 30/03/2004, final on 30/06/2004

* * *

The Deputies, having examined progress made in ensuring execution, and having noted that the judicial review proceedings brought by Mr Quinn have ended with his conviction being quashed, decided to resume consideration of these cases, as far as individual measures are concerned, at their 928th meeting (6-7 June 2005):

The Deputies, having examined progress made in ensuring execution, decided to resume consideration of this case at their 928th meeting (6-7 June 2005) on the basis of further information on the applicant’s position as regards the advisability to adopt individual measures:

- 1 case against Hungary

H46-665 57967/00 Kmetty, judgment of 16/12/03, final on 16/03/04

* * *

The Deputies agreed to resume consideration of this case at their 928th meeting (6-7 June 2005) (DH):

- 1 case against Poland

H46-597 34049/96 Zwierzyński, judgment of 19/06/2001, final on 19/09/2001 and of 02/07/2002, final on 06/11/2002 (Article 41)

Section 4.2

The Deputies, having examined progress made in ensuring execution, decided to resume consideration of these cases at a forthcoming meeting not later than six months hence, on the basis of further information to be provided by the authorities of the respondent state concerning the general measures proposed to prevent new, similar violations:

- 1 case against Belgium

H46-762 32576/96 Wynen, judgment of 05/11/02, final on 05/02/03

- 2 cases against Bulgaria

H46-766 41488/98 Velikova, judgment of 18/05/00, final on 04/10/00

H46-767 38361/97 Anguelova, judgment of 13/06/02, final on 13/09/02

- 1 case against France

H46-817 56243/00 Chaineux, judgment of 14/10/03, final on 14/01/04

- 1 case against Greece

H46-819 62503/00 Karahalios, judgment of 11/12/2003, final on 14/06/2004

The Deputies, having examined progress made in ensuring execution, decided to resume consideration of these cases at a forthcoming meeting not later than six months hence, on the basis of further information to be provided by the authorities of the respondent state concerning the general measures proposed to prevent new, similar violations and the individual measures to put an end to the violations and erase, as far as possible, their consequences for the applicants:

- 8 cases against Bulgaria

Cases of length of criminal proceedings

H46-768 37104/97 Kitov, judgment of 03/04/03, final on 03/07/03

H46-769 35825/97 Al Akidi, judgment of 31/07/2003, final on 31/10/2003 rectified on 16/10/2003

H46-770 39270/98 Belchev, judgment of 08/04/2004, final on 08/07/2004

H46-771 44062/98 Hamanov, judgment of 08/04/2004, final on 08/07/2004

H46-772 35436/97 Hristov, judgment of 31/07/2003, final on 31/10/2003

H46-773 37335/97 S.H.K, judgment of 23/10/03, final on 23/01/04

H46-774 45563/99 Zhbanov, judgment of 22/07/2004, final on 22/10/2004

H46-765 42987/98 Vachev, judgment of 08/07/2004, final on 08/10/2004

- 7 cases against the Czech Republic

- Cases of length of judicial proceedings concerning civil rights

H46-795 41486/98 Bořánková, judgment of 07/01/03, final on 21/05/03

H46-796 53341/99 Hartman J. and J., judgment of 10/07/03, final on 03/12/03

H46-797 50262/99 Bartl, judgment of 22/06/2004, final on 22/09/2004

H46-798 45107/98 Koktavá, judgment of 02/12/2003, final on 14/06/2004

H46-799 50248/99 Králíček, judgment of 29/06/2004, final on 29/09/2004

H46-800 48446/99 Libánský, judgment of 22/06/2004, final on 22/09/2004

H46-947 51806/99 Figueiredo Simoes, judgment of 30/01/03, final on 30/04/03

H46-948 53795/00 Farinha Martins, judgment of 10/07/03, final on 10/10/03

- 2 cases against the Russian Federation

H46-955 53084/99 Kormacheva, judgment of 29/01/2004, final on 14/06/2004, rectified on 29/04/2004

H46-441 14949/02 Plaksin, judgment of 29/04/2004, final on 10/11/2004

- 2 cases against the United Kingdom

H46-1068 39482/98 Dowsett, judgment of 24/06/03, final on 24/09/03

H46-1071 46295/99 Stafford, judgment of 28/05/02 - Grand Chamber

* * *

The Deputies, having examined progress made in ensuring execution, decided to resume consideration of these cases at a forthcoming meeting not later than six months hence, on the basis of a draft interim resolution being prepared by the Secretariat:

H46-862 29687/96 Wesołowski, judgment of 22/06/2004, final on 22/09/2004

Cases of length of civil proceedings

H54-863 27916/95 Podbielski, judgment of 30/10/98

H46-864 38328/97 Bejer, judgment of 04/10/01, final on 04/01/02

H46-865 39597/98 Biskupska, judgment of 22/07/03, final on 03/12/03, rectified on 11/09/03

H46-866 38665/97 Bukowski, judgment of 11/02/03, final on 11/05/03, rectified on 10/07/03

H46-867 27918/95 C., judgment of 03/05/01

H46-868 71893/01 Cegielski, judgment of 21/10/03, final on 21/01/04

H46-869 52037/99 Ciborek, judgment of 04/11/03, final on 04/02/04

H46-870 13557/02 D.M., judgment of 14/10/03, final on 14/01/04

H46-871 74073/01 Domańska, judgment of 25/05/04, final on 25/08/2004

H46-872 71894/01 Dybo, judgment of 14/10/03, final on 14/01/04

H32-873 24559/94 Gibas, Interim Resolution DH(97)242

H46-874 75872/01 Gidel, judgment of 14/10/03, final on 24/03/04

H46-875 48001/99 Goc, judgment of 16/04/02, final on 16/07/02

H46-876 53698/00 Górska, judgment of 03/06/03, final on 03/09/03

H46-877 73003/01 Grela, judgment of 13/01/04, final on 13/04/04

H46-878 29695/96 Gronuś, judgment of 28/05/02, final on 28/08/02

H46-879 46034/99 Gryziecka and Gryziecki, judgment of 06/05/03, final on 06/08/03

H46-880 35656/97 Hulewicz, judgment of 30/03/04, final on 30/06/04

H46-881 77831/01 I.P., judgment of 14/10/03, final on 14/01/04

H46-882 60225/00 Jablonská, judgment of 09/03/04, final on 09/06/04

H46-883 29691/96 Jedamski, judgment of 26/07/01, final on 26/10/01

H46-884 35577/97 Kaszubski, judgment of 24/02/04, final on 07/07/04

H46-885 52518/99 Koral, judgment of 05/11/02, final on 21/05/03

H46-886 6214/02 Kranz, judgment of 17/02/04, final on 17/05/04

H46-887 77746/01 Kroenitz, judgment of 25/02/03, final on 24/09/03

H46-888 51515/99 Krzak, judgment of 06/04/04, final on 07/07/04

H46-415 37770/97 Krzewicki, judgment of 27/04/04, final on 27/07/2004

H46-889 37437/97 Kubiszyn, judgment of 30/01/03, final on 30/04/03

H46-890 47551/99 Leszczyńska, judgment of 22/06/04, final on 22/09/2004

H46-891 77757/01 Łobarzewski, judgment of 25/11/03, final on 25/02/04

H46-892 43779/98 Mączyński, judgment of 15/01/02, final on 15/04/02

H46-893 52168/99 Majkrzyk, judgment of 06/05/03, final on 06/08/03

H46-894 22072/02 Małasiewicz, judgment of 14/10/03, final on 14/01/04

H46-895 76446/01 Malinowska Henryka, judgment of 14/10/03, final on 14/01/04

H46-896 35843/97 Malinowska, judgment of 14/12/00, final on 14/03/01

H46-897 40887/98 Maliszewski, judgment of 06/05/03, final on 06/08/03

H46-898 74816/01 Orzeł, judgment of 25/03/03, final on 25/06/03

H46-899 53029/99 Pachnik, judgment of 30/03/04, final on 30/06/04

H46-900 36250/97 Parciński, judgment of 18/03/01, final on 18/03/02

H46-901 51429/99 Paśnicki, judgment of 06/05/03, final on 06/08/03

H46-902 42042/98 Peryt, judgment of 02/12/03, final on 24/03/04

H46-903 40330/98 Piechota, judgment of 05/11/02, final on 05/02/03

H46-904 39619/98 Piłka Andrzej and Barbara, judgment of 06/05/03, final on 06/08/03

H46-905 29455/95 Pogorzelec, judgment of 17/07/01, final on 12/12/01

H46-418 68930/01 Politikin, judgment of 27/04/04, final on 27/07/2004

H46-906 77759/01 Porembska, judgment of 14/10/03, final on 14/01/04

H46-907 77597/01 R.O., judgment of 25/03/03, final on 25/06/03

H46-908 41033/98 R.W., judgment of 15/07/03, final on 15/10/03, rectified on 11/09/03

H46-909 38804/97 Rawa, judgment of 14/01/03, final on 14/04/03

H46-910 51599/99 Rychliccy, judgment of 18/05/04, final on 18/08/2004

H46-911 37645/97 Sawicka, judgment of 01/10/02, final on 01/01/03

H46-912 52468/99 Sienkiewicz, judgment of 30/09/03, final on 30/12/03

H46-913 42078/98 Sitarek, judgment of 15/07/03, final on 15/10/03, rectified on 11/09/03

H46-914 40694/98 Sobański, judgment of 21/01/03, revised on 23/01/03, final on 09/07/03, rectified on 17/09/03

H46-915 25693/94+ Sobczyk, judgment of 26/10/00, final on 26/01/01

H46-916 49349/99 Sobierajska-Nierzwicka, judgment of 27/05/03, final on 27/08/03

H54-917 28616/95 Styranowski, judgment of 30/10/98

H46-918 40835/98 Szarapo, judgment of 23/05/02, final on 23/08/02

H46-919 48684/99 Uthke, judgment of 18/06/02, final on 18/09/02

H46-920 39505/98 W.M., judgment of 14/01/03, final on 14/04/03

H46-921 65660/01 W.Z., judgment of 24/10/02, final on 24/01/03

H46-922 32734/96 Wasilewski, judgment of 21/12/00, final on 06/09/01

H46-923 41431/98 Wierciszewska, judgment of 25/11/03, final on 25/02/04

H46-924 33082/96 Wojnowicz, judgment of 21/09/00, final on 22/01/01

H46-925 33334/96 Wylęgły J. and J., judgment of 03/06/03, final on 03/09/03,
rectified on 04/06/03

H46-926 34158/96 Zawadzki, judgment of 20/12/01, final on 27/03/02

* * *

The Deputies, having examined progress made in ensuring execution,

1. decided to resume consideration of the individual measures to put an end to the violation and erase, as far as possible, its consequences for the applicants at their 928th meeting (6-7 June 2005) (DH) in the light of further information to be provided by the authorities of the respondent state;

2. decided to resume consideration of the general measures proposed to prevent new, similar violations at a forthcoming meeting not later than six months hence:

- 1 case against Bulgaria

H46-764 39084/97 Yankov, judgment of 11/12/03, final on 11/03/04

- 1 case against Hungary

H46-823 75116/01 Karalyos and Huber, judgment of 06/04/2004, final on 06/07/2004

* * *

The Deputies, having examined progress made in ensuring execution, decided to resume consideration of these cases at their 928th meeting (6-7 June 2005) (DH), on the basis of further information to be provided by the authorities of the respondent state concerning payment of the sums awarded in these cases if need be, the general measures proposed to prevent new, similar violations and the individual measures to put an end to the violations and erase, as far as possible, their consequences for the applicants:

- 1 case against Bulgaria

H46-763 39272/98 M.C., judgment of 04/12/03, final on 04/03/04

- 1 case against Croatia

H46-775 66485/01 Napijalo, judgment of 13/11/03, final on 13/02/04

- 2 cases against the Czech Republic

H46-792 49478/99 Kadlec and others, judgment of 25/05/2004, final on 25/08/2004

H46-793 57567/00 Bulena, judgment of 20/04/2004, final on 20/07/2004

- 1 case against Greece

H46-204 50385/99 Makaratzis, judgment of 20/12/2004 - Grand Chamber

- 1 case against Italy

H46-531 35227/97 Frascino, judgment of 11/12/03, final on 11/03/04

- 1 case against Poland

H46-846 25196/94 Iwánczuk, judgment of 15/11/01, final on 15/02/02

- 5 cases against Ukraine

H46-498 56848/00 Zhovner, judgment of 29/06/2004, final on 29/09/2004

H46-497 56849/00 Piven, judgment of 29/06/2004, final on 29/09/2004

H46-499 18966/02 Voytenko, judgment of 29/06/2004, final on 29/09/2004

H46-495 60750/00 Shmalko, judgment of 20/07/2004, final on 20/10/2004

H46-496 67534/01 Romashov, judgment of 27/07/2004, final on 15/12/2004

- 1 case against the United Kingdom

H46-1069 30668/96 Wilson and the National Union of Journalists, Palmer, Wyeth and the National Union of Rail, Maritime and Transport workers, Doolan and others, judgment of 02/07/02, final on 02/10/02

* * *

The Deputies, having examined progress made in ensuring execution, decided to resume consideration of these cases at their 928th meeting (6-7 June 2005) (DH) on the basis of further information to be provided by the authorities of the respondent state concerning individual measures to put an end to the violation(s) and erase, as far as possible, their consequences for the applicants:

- 1 case against France

H46-815 46096/99 Mocie, judgment of 08/04/03, final on 08/07/03

- 3 cases against the United Kingdom

H46-1070 28212/95 Benjamin and Wilson, judgment of 26/09/02, final on 26/12/02

- Cases concerning the lack of proper review of the lawfulness of the applicants’ continued detention

The Deputies, having examined progress made in ensuring execution, decided to resume consideration of these cases at their 928th meeting (6-7 June 2005) (DH), on the basis of a draft interim resolution to be prepared by the Secretariat:

- 1 case against Poland

H46-847 31443/96 Broniowski, judgment of 22/06/2004 - Grand Chamber

- 1 case against Romania

H46-950 28341/95 Rotaru, judgment of 04/05/00 - Grand Chamber

- 1 case against the Russian Federation

*H46-1692 52854/99 Ryabykh, judgment of 24/07/03, final on 03/12/03

The Deputies, having examined progress made in ensuring execution, decided to resume consideration of this case at their 928th meeting (6-7 June 2005) (DH), on the basis of further information to be provided by the respondent government on the reform of the code of criminal proceedings:

- 1 case against Romania

H46-952 28871/95 Constantinescu, judgment of 27/06/00

* * *

The Deputies, having examined progress made in ensuring execution, decided to resume consideration of these cases at their 928th meeting (6-7 June 2005) (DH), on the basis of further information to be provided by the authorities of the respondent state concerning payment of the just satisfaction if need be and of a draft interim resolution being prepared by the Secretariat:

The Deputies, having examined progress made in ensuring execution, decided to resume consideration of this case this case at their 928th meeting (6-7 June 2005) (DH)] on the basis of further information to be provided by the authorities of the respondent state concerning the general measures proposed to prevent new, similar violations, and the individual measures to put an end to the violations and erase, as far as possible, its consequences for the applicant company:

- 1 case against Ukraine

H46-1079 48553/99 Sovtransavto Holding, judgment of 25/07/02, final on 06/11/02 and judgment of 02/10/03, final on 24/03/04 (Article 41), Interim Resolution ResDH(2004)14

* * *

922nd meeting- 7 April 2005

The Deputies agreed to resume consideration of this case when their 923rd meeting is resumed on 12 April 2005.

2. decided to resume consideration of the present case at their 928th meeting (DH) (6-7 June 2005) with a view to considering the general measures proposed to prevent new, similar violations.

- 2181 cases against Italy

H46-1076 2181 cases concerning the length of judicial proceedings

Press Release

To remedy the delays in Italian justice:

The Committee of the Ministers will draw up a new assessment of the execution of judgments of the European Court by Italy

The Committee of the Ministers, meeting yesterday at the level of Deputies, decided to defer to 6-7 June 2005 the thorough examination of measures required of the Italian authorities in order to remedy the structural problems at the origin of many violations of the European Convention on Human Rights due to the excessive length of judicial proceedings. A new assessment of the execution in these cases will be established, if necessary in a new Resolution by the Committee, once all the necessary information has been provided and examined.

This examination, initially planned for the present meeting of Ministers’ Deputies, could not take place due to the fact that the fourth annual report and the action plan, requested from the Italian authorities in September 2004 in accordance with the interim Resolution (2000)135, were not available. The Deputies however took note of the efforts made by the Italian Delegation in order to submit, although after the deadline, certain information necessary and of its commitment to supplement them, if necessary, before the end of April.

The evaluation of the Committee will focus on the results obtained in the reduction of the length of proceedings through in particular the modernisation of the Italian legal system, the increase in its resources, the elimination of the backlog of pending cases and the effectivity of the internal recourse against the delays set up by the law Pinto (see the press release no. 466 of 30 September 2004 and the document CM/Inf(2004)23rev.).

Under the European Convention on Human Rights, the judgments of the European Court require that the defendant states adopt - under the supervision of the Committee of the Ministers - the necessary measures in order to erase the consequences of the violations for the applicants and to prevent new similar violations in the future (http://www.coe.int/T/E/Human_Rights/execution/).

* * *

Section 5.1

The Deputies, having examined progress made in ensuring execution, decided to resume consideration of this case at a forthcoming meeting not later than six months hence, on the basis of further information to be provided by the authorities of the respondent state concerning the general measures under adoption to prevent new, similar violations:

- 1 case against Austria

H46-1080 32636/96 A.T., judgment of 21/03/02, final on 21/06/02

- 1 case against Belgium

H46-761 51564/99 Čonka, judgment of 05/02/02, final on 05/05/02

- 1 case against Cyprus

H46-1081 25316/94 Denizci and others, judgment of 23/05/01, final on 23/08/01

- 2 cases against Greece

H46-1082 46372/99 Papastavrou, judgments of 10/04/03, final on 10/07/03 and of 18/11/2004, final on 18/02/2005

H46-1083 66742/01 Katsoulis and others, judgment of 08/07/2004, final on 08/10/2004

The Deputies, having examined progress made in ensuring execution, decided to resume consideration of these cases at a forthcoming meeting not later than six months hence, on the basis of further information to be provided by the authorities of the respondent state concerning changes of courts’ case-law or of administrative practice:

- 1 case against France

H46-1089 33592/96 Baumann, judgment of 22/05/01, final on 22/08/01

- 1 case against Iceland

H46-1090 44671/98 Arnarsson SigurÞór, judgment of 15/07/03, final on 15/10/03

Section 5.3

The Deputies, having examined progress made in ensuring execution, decided to resume consideration of theses cases at a forthcoming meeting not later than six months hence, on the basis of further information to be provided by the authorities of the respondent state concerning the publication of the Court’s judgment and its dissemination to the authorities concerned to draw their attention to obligations under the Convention:

- 1 case against Spain

H46-1092 59072/00 González Doria Durán de Quiroga, judgment of 28/10/03, final on 28/01/04

- 4 cases against France

H46-804 36378/97 Bertuzzi, judgment of 13/02/03, final on 21/05/03

H46-1094 42400/98 Seguin, judgment of 16/04/2002, final on 06/11/2002

H46-1093 43722/98 Wiot, judgment of 07/01/03, final on 07/04/03

H46-816 50331/99 Julien Ferdinand, judgment of 08/04/03, final on 08/07/03

- 1 case against Poland

H46-1095 30218/96 Nowicka, judgment of 03/12/02, final on 03/03/03

Section 5.4

The Deputies

1. having noted the information provided by the delegation of the respondent state, instructed the Secretariat to consider the advisability of preparing a draft final resolution in this case;

2. agreed to resume consideration of this item at their 928th meeting (6-7 June 2005) (DH):

- 1 case against Austria

H46-760 39394/98 Scharsach and News Verlagsgesellschaft, judgment of 13/11/03,
final on 13/02/04

* * *

The Deputies, having examined progress made in ensuring execution, decided to resume consideration of this case at a forthcoming meeting not later than six months hence, on the basis of further information to be provided by the authorities of the respondent state concerning the general measures proposed to prevent new, similar violations:

- 1 case against the United Kingdom

H46-1088 50390/99 McGlinchey and others, judgment of 29/04/03, final on 29/07/03

* * *

922nd meeting- 7 April 2005

The Deputies

1. adopted Interim Resolution ResDH(2005)21 as it appears in the present volume of Resolutions ;

2. agreed to resume consideration of these cases in October 2006 at the latest:

- 2 cases against Greece

H46-1096 40907/98 Dougoz, judgment of 06/03/01, final on 06/06/01

H46-1097 28524/95 Peers, judgment of 29/09/99, final on 19/04/01

Section 6.1

The Deputies decided to resume consideration of the following cases at their 928th meeting (DH)

(6-7 June 2005) on the basis of a draft final resolution to be prepared by the Secretariat:

- 10 cases against Croatia

- Cases of length of civil proceedings

H46-781 51585/99 Horvat, judgment of 26/07/01, final on 26/10/01

H46-782 54727/00 Cerin, judgment of 15/11/01, final on 15/02/02

H46-784 48771/99 Delić, judgment of 27/06/02, final on 27/09/02

H46-785 52634/99 Futterer, judgment of 20/12/01, final on 20/03/02

H46-786 73564/01 Muženjak, judgment of 04/03/04, final on 04/06/04

H46-787 45435/99 Radoš and 4 others, judgment of 07/11/02, final on 07/02/03

H46-788 49706/99 Rajak, judgment of 28/06/01, final on 12/12/01

H46-789 56773/00 Rajčević, judgment of 23/07/02, final on 06/11/02

H46-790 63412/00 Sahini, judgment of 19/06/03, final on 19/09/03

H46-791 47863/99 Šoć, judgment of 09/05/03, final on 09/08/03

- 1 case against the Czech Republic

- Cases of length of judicial proceedings concerning civil rights

H46-802 29010/95 Credit and Industrial Bank, judgment of 21/10/03

- 1 case against Finland

H46-1098 45027/98 Narinen, judgment of 01/06/2004, final on 01/09/2004

- 6 cases against France

H46-662 55926/00 Loyen and others, judgment of 29/04/03, final on 29/07/03

- Cases of length of civil proceedings

H46-814 42268/98 J.-M. F., judgment of 01/07/2004, final on 10/11/2004

H46-812 49531/99 Lutz No.2, judgment of 17/06/03, revised on 25/11/03, final on 25/02/04

H46-813 51887/99 Nicolle, judgment of 25/11/03, final on 25/02/04

H46-811 55829/00 Huart, judgment of 25/11/03, final on 25/02/04

H46-810 55875/00 Signe, judgment of 14/10/2003, final on 14/01/2004

- 1 case against Hungary

- Cases of length of criminal proceedings

H46-824 60037/00 Németh, judgment of 13/01/04, final on 09/02/04

- 1 case against Italy

H46-223 36534/97 Osu, judgment of 11/07/02, final on 11/10/02

- 1 case against Lithuania

H46-694 53161/99 Meilus, judgment of 06/11/03, final on 06/02/04

- 1 case against the Slovak Republic

H46-1091 32106/96 Komanický, judgment of 04/06/02, final on 04/09/02

- 1 case against Turkey

H46-1099 27692/95+ Karakoç and others, judgment of 15/10/02, final on 15/01/03

- 2 cases against the United Kingdom

- Cases of length of proceedings concerning civil rights and obligations before the labour courts

H46-1074 42116/98 Somjee, judgment of 15/10/02, final on 15/01/03

H46-1075 50034/99 Obasa, judgment of 16/01/03, final on 16/04/03

Section 6.2

The Deputies decided to resume consideration of the following cases at their 928th meeting (DH)

(6-7 June 2005) on the basis of a draft final resolution to be prepared by the Secretariat:

- 28 cases against Austria

H46-1100 37295/97 Yildiz M., G. and Y., judgment of 31/10/02, final on 31/01/03

H46-1101 57080/00 Pokorny, judgment of 16/12/03 - Friendly settlement

H46-1102 35021/97+ Kolb and others, judgment of 17/04/03, final on 17/07/03