The couple stopped into SoHo's C. Wonder but "they came in separately and held hands as they perused the store," an onlooker tells PEOPLE. "When they were in the back of the store, they even snuck in a smooch!"

The Mud actress couldn't hide her smile around Toth and purchased two pairs of sunglasses.

"They seemed to have great chemistry together and while they were checking out, they were hugging and cuddling," the source adds. "They clearly aren't afraid of PDA."
– Mary Margaret