When comparing InMind VR vs Doom 3 BFG VR, the Slant community recommends InMind VR for most people. In the question“What are the best Oculus Rift games?”InMind VR is ranked 41st while Doom 3 BFG VR is ranked 43rd. The most important reason people chose InMind VR is:

Unlike many other games, this one was built ground up for a head mounted display instead of adapted for it. As such the user interface and control scheme are well optimised for the Oculus Rift.

Pros

Pro

Built specifically with a VR headset in mind

Unlike many other games, this one was built ground up for a head mounted display instead of adapted for it. As such the user interface and control scheme are well optimised for the Oculus Rift.

Pro

Does not require any additional controllers

All interaction in the game are done using the headset. Head gestures are used to interact with the user interface and aiming is done by looking at the target.

Pro

No VR sickness

The game creates a frame of reference for the player by having his avatar be stationary. That helps avoid motion sickness commonly induced by the dissociative feeling created when the avatar is moving and the player himself is stationary.

Pro

Runs smooth

No lag, excellent, non-jittery head tracking.

Pro

Free

The game is available completely for free.

Pro

Tense atmosphere

The game features many claustrophobic corridors, unnerving sound design, moody lighting and creepy enemies that seemingly appear from nowhere. Put together these elements create a lots of tension and a sense of unease.

Cons

Con

Short

The experience is less than 10 minutes long.

Con

Gameplay is a little barebones

It's a shooter on rails where the only action is looking at brightly coloured neurones.

Con

VR development was dropped by ZeniMax midway through

Due to disagreements between ZeniMax and Oculus, development of Doom 3 BFG VR was dropped. There are a few community attempts to finish VR support including one by an Oculus developer Samson and another by reddit user mscoder610.