Which convertibles do Tom and Ray recommend?

Click and Clack

Published: June 29, 2013

Dear Tom and Ray:
I turn 70 in a couple of years and want to do two things to celebrate: Enter a triathlon and drive across the country on back roads in a new convertible.
Assuming I survive the first, I need advice on convertibles. Since I don't have a garage, a hard-top is a necessary option. There are several nice ones, and I love the Volvo. The trouble is, the mileage is so poor. While this car would not be my only wheels, I just can't bring myself to support the car industry's poor efforts at better mileage. Do you think they will wake up in time for me?
I have three years to make a decision - and to find someone fun to travel with. - Ann

RAY: If it were my brother, Ann, he'd combine these two events, and attempt to do the triathlon in the convertible. He'd get less winded that way.
TOM: Yeah. The bad news on the car front is that there's no premium, midsize, four-seat convertible that's head and shoulders above the others in terms of gas mileage. Aside from suffering from the industry's lack of commitment to increasing fuel economy, convertibles also suffer from excess weight. They require extra structural reinforcement to make up for the rigidity that steel roofs usually provide, so they tend to be heavier than their "roofed" sedan counterparts, which further decreases their mileage.
RAY: The good news is that the auto industry is in the process of waking up to the issue of fuel economy after a deep, 30-year slumber. So it's entirely possible that you'll have better choices in three years than you do now. Someone even might come out with a hybrid convertible in that class, which would really raise the bar.
TOM: But at the moment, you're right. The Volvo C70 convertible that interests you is rated at 19 mpg city, 28 highway, which means you'll average about 22. That's OK but not great.
RAY: The best of the bunch probably is the Audi A5, which does a little better, at 24/31. The Volkswagen Eos, which is a size smaller than those two, comes in at 22/30. The other Volvo-size convertibles, like the BMW 328i, the Lexus IS 250, the Ford Mustang and the Infiniti G37, are in the same mpg ballpark as the Volvo, or worse.
TOM: So I'd wait to see if one of those companies - or some other company - takes some bolder steps and separates itself from the pack. And if one does, you should reward it with your business in a few years. And take the trip before doing the triathlon, just in case!
What is the most cost-effective way to buy a car? Tom and Ray hash it all out in their pamphlet "Should I Buy, Lease or Steal My Next Car?" Send $4.75 (check or money order) to Next Car, P.O. Box 536475, Orlando, FL 32853-6475.
You can listen to Tom and Ray Magliozzi's "Car Talk" program at 10 a.m. Saturdays on National Public Radio station WUSF, 89.7 FM.
Got a question about cars? E-mail Click and Clack by visiting the Car Talk website at www.cartalk.com. They can't answer your letter personally but will run the best letters in the column.