Postmodern Jukebox has already transformed Taylor Swift's "Blank Space" into a cabaret steamer, added a big-band swing to Bell Biv Devoe's ubiquitous romp "Poison," interpreted an Ariana Grande ballad as a James Bond theme and made a sad clown with a booming voice a viral sensation.

For its latest YouTube cover, the New York ensemble – led by musician Scott Bradlee – has dusted off Radiohead's seminal '90s hit "Creep."

Advertisement

With "American Idol" finalist Haley Reinhart tackling the vocal, Bradlee and co. traded the alt-rock tune's raging self-pity for a more delicate tone.

Reinhart's meaty, throaty growl that made her a favorite on "Idol" years ago paired with a piano and horn section makes for a stunning listen -- you'll forget the lyrics are about a weirdo's obsessive crush.

The cover is also a reminder that Reinhart got a really raw deal with pop stardom.

During her appearance on "Idol," she became a fan favorite as a bluesy ingenue on a season full of country and rock singer-songwriters.

Though her stage presence was often criticized by the judges, the singer's gritty vocals showcased with bold versions of songs from Adele, Alanis Morissette and Elton John made her a dark horse in the competition.

After placing third – country crooner Scotty McCreery won the title – Reinhart was one of the few finalists from that season to quickly score a record deal through the show.

On the album, Reinhart traded in carefully crafted pop hits for depth. It featured tunes that reached across vintage jazz, blues, R&B and bright Motown-inspired dance-pop (so it's no surprise that she's able to fit seamlessly into Postmodern's throwback aesthetic).

Now, Reinhart has spent the better part of this year as a member of Postmodern's rotating stable of musicians. She's performed with them during their recent European tour and contributed other YouTube covers.