WHO starred and who stunk for our Nissan SuperCoach teams in Round 12?

See who made our Hall of Fame and Hall of Shame across the weekend.

GEELONG 107 d CARLTON 102

Cats Studs: Mathew Stokes (134) continues to fly under the SuperCoach radar, after booting 3.1 from 22 touches and five clearances. Tom Hawkins (127) imposed himself on the game early, booting four goals from 17 touches and 10 marks. Joel Selwood’s (122) match-winning goal boosted his score, while George Horlin-Smith (107) and Cam Guthrie (103) produced their best games for the Cats.

Cats Duds: Corey Enright (63) is one of the most popular SuperCoach picks this season, but many owners would have been disappointed with his output. Young Jed Bews (19) was subbed out of the game and might be subbed out of the Cats’ line-up soon.

Blues Studs: If you want a unique midfielder, Bryce Gibbs (153) might be your man. Gibbs produced arguably his best ever game, booting 4.2 from 29 touches and six tackles, while also restricting Selwood to 18 disposals. Andrew Walker (106) and Chris Yarran (106) were the only other Blues to crack the ton.

Blues Duds: Simon White (12) started as the sub, while Lachie Henderson (42), Zac Tuohy (43) and Jarrad Waite (50) barely had any influence on the game.

Hawks Studs: If you dropped Jarryd Roughead (180) from your side, your face would be as red as Rough’s beard. The big Hawk slammed through a whopping eight goals from 24 disposals to leave the Eagles red-faced. Fellow left-footers Luke Hodge (120), Isaac Smith (112) and Jordan Lewis (103) all reached three figures.

Hawks Duds: Billy Hartung (five) was only substituted into the game deep in the fourth quarter and was unable to have an impact on the game. Ryan Schoenmakers (57) started well, but only managed a little over 30 points from the final three quarters.

Eagles Studs: Andrew Gaff (116) registered his highest score of 2014 to date, while Nic Naitanui (116) continued his recent good form, notching his second consecutive SuperCoach century. Luke Shuey (104) cracked the ton for the first time since Round 6.

Eagles Duds: A stinker of a day for Jamie Cripps (13), accumulating a miserly three touches from a full game. Sharrod Wellingham (18) was only injected into the game during the final term.

Power studs: Hamish Hartlett (152) was in a league of his own with 36 disposals including a brilliant goal from nigh on 60m. Matthew Lobbe (150) dominated the stoppages while Robbie Gray and Ollie Wines scored 140 and 120 respectively.

Power duds: Jack Hombsch (41) didn’t have a lot to do in defence while Aaron Young (28) was in the wars throughout the contest.

Saints studs: Lenny Hayes (110) refused to give up while Jack Steven was the only other Saint in triple figures.

Saints duds: Take your pick. Farren Ray (27), substitute Jack Billings (29) were among the lowest scorers while veteran Leigh Montagna (58) had his colours well and truly lowered by Kane Cornes. Cam Shenton could only must 63 points.

Essendon's David Zaharakis walks off with team mates after their win. Picture: Toby ZernaSource:News Corp Australia

ESSENDON 81 def GWS GIANTS 66

Bombers studs: David Zaharakis (142) raised the bat for 100 before three-quarter time and looks back to his best and fairest winning form, while big Joe Daniher (103) was the only other Don to crack the ton in an even performance.

Bombers duds: Jake Melksham (39) was spared the subs vest this week but didn’t set the world on fire and BJ Goddard (76) and Michael Hibberd (83) had relatively quiet nights.

Giants duds: Kristian Jaksch (21) and Aidan Corr (40) should feature in the SuperCoach teams of friends and family ONLY.

Brisbane’s Jack Redden notched his eight SuperCoach century of 2014 against the Western Bulldogs.Source:Getty Images

BRISBANE LIONS 95 def WESTERN BULLDOGS 87

Lions studs: Jack Redden (128) returned to his ferocious best, laying nine tackles and booting two goals from 26 disposals. Pearce Hanley (119) never stopped running and Rohan Bewick (113) played arguably his best game for the club.

Lions duds: Zac O’Brien (16) against started as the sub, but couldn’t replicate his century on debut in Round 11. Jed Adcock (43) and Darcy Gardiner (25) stayed deep in defence, while Dan Merrett (34) also had little impact.

Bulldogs studs: Jack Macrae (126) didn’t receive as much attention this week and thrived, cracking three figures for the first time since Round 5. Fellow midfielder Tom Liberatore (112), Adam Cooney (107) and Liam Picken (106) all reached the ton.

Giants duds: After a miserly four touches, Christian Howard (nine) was subbed out just after half-time to inject Daniel Giansiracusa into the game.

David Swallow was subdued game against the Swans ... and let tens of thousands of SuperCoaches across the country down. Picture: Getty ImagesSource:Getty Images

SYDNEY SWANS 109 def GOLD COAST SUNS 74

Swans studs: Seven Swannies went past three figures in an even spread for John Longmire’s SuperCoach side. Dan Hannebery (137) was the best of them, while fellow mids Josh Kennedy (126) and Kieren jack 114) were also superb. Running defender Nick Malceski (116) continued his steallar output.

Swans duds: Few bad players for the red and white, although Adam Goodes (37) isn’t yet having his usual impact. Kurt Tippett (41) was also well held before being subbed out with a knee niggle.

Suns studs: Nothing left to say about the Little Master when it comes to SuperCoach. Just 149 for Gaz in a losing side. Fair effort. Big man Zac Smith (115) has returned from his knee like it was a cut toenail, while Harley Bennell (100) is going to be sppppeeeccciiial.

Sun duds: Karmichael Hunt (25) found the Swans outing a step up from the NEAFL, Sam Day (27) battled against the Sydney backline but David Swallow (59) had thousands of SuperCoaches relying on him and let us down. C’mon David, we want more next week. Please.

Dockers Studs: Big man Aaron Sandilands returned a big score of 148 in a dominant display. Lesser lights Paul Duffield and Lee Spurr also turned it on with 126 and 121 respectively. Matthew Pavlich and Stephen Hill finished all square on 113.

Dockers Duds: Hayden Ballantyne managed just 51 in a quiet performance while his fellow forward Chris Mayne finished on 67. As Sandilands dominated, it meant back-up Zac Clarke was left with little to do and a score of 58.

Crows Studs: Despite Sandilands dominating, Sam Jacobs (109) was disgraced and top-scored for the Crows. Rory Sloane was the only other Adelaide player to crack a ton with 105. Scott Thompson (98) and Brodie Smith (95) were the only Crows to score 90s.

Crows Duds: In total, 12 Crows finished with scores of less than 50. Matthew Jaensch is a hugely popular defender but could only score 36. Taylor Walker couldn’t back up last week’s performance with just 48 points.

Kangaroos Studs: Todd Goldstein was immense for the Kangaroos and top-scored with 166. Brent Harvey was at his usual inspirational best with 145 while Jack Ziebell (119) and Drew Petrie (114) played their best game for the year.

Kangaroos Duds: Scott Thompson is a shadow of himself in defence. The All Australian managed just 39 points. Shaun Atley and Ryan Bastinac finished on 52 apiece and Majak Daw was subbed out at half-time with just 19 points.

Tigers Studs: Dustin Martin in the first half scored 92 points but finished with 108. Bachar Houli tried all day and collected 108 as well. Matt Thomas (103) and Brandon Ellis (102) were the only other century-makers.

Tigers Duds: Dustin Martin in the second half scored just 16 points. Trent Cotchin owners breath a sigh of relief after he got a few cheap touches late to rise to 81. Ben Lennon copped the green vest and managed only 13. Brett Deledio (68) had a shocker.

Collingwood’s Scott Pendlebury flexed his muscled against the Demons.Source:Getty Images

COLLINGWOOD 61 def MELBOURNE 28

Magpies Studs: Scott Pendlebury (112) was heading for a big game after notching 50 points at quarter-time, but was well held after that. Lachie Keeffe (110) was excellent down back, while Dayne Beams (106) and Jarryd Blair (105) also cracked the ton.

Magpies Duds: Alex Fasolo (23) was a massive let down for many SuperCoach owners, accumulating five kicks and finishing the game subbed on the bench. His replacement, Luke Ball (29), didn’t have a lot of time to make an impact, although he did finish with 11 touches.

Demons Studs: Post match, some pundits believed Lynden Dunn (145) was the best player on the ground, after racking up 24 touches, 10 marks and 10 rebound 50s down back,

Demons Duds: Christian Salem (six) had a day he’d rather forget, while Jay Kennedy-Harris (six) only gathered three touches as the sub. Dom Tyson (37) would have cost many SuperCoach owners victory in their respective leagues.

News.com.au's Privacy Policy includes important information about our collection, use and disclosure of your personal information (including to provide you with targeted content and advertising based on your online activities). It explains that if you do not provide us with information we have requested from you, we may not be able to provide you with the goods and services you require. It also explains how you can access or seek correction of your personal information, how you can complain about a breach of the Australian Privacy Principles and how we will deal with a complaint of that nature.