Full Review

This is an unrepentantly ruthless dungeon crawler aimed squarely at hardcore players. Read on for our Dark Souls 2 review

Dark Souls 2 review

Love

Uncompromising design

Beautiful design

Harsh but fair

Hate

Lowered health bars

Lack of human empathy

Dying and dying and dying

Three years ago Dark Souls caused something of a stir within the ranks of the gaming community. In a time when many games were aimed at empowering and entertaining players, Dark Souls adhered to an old-school aesthetic.

Here was a game that was hard - rock hard - and made absolutely no apologies for it. Its submit-or-die demeanour repelled as many players as it attracted. Those players who were seduced by its brutal delights became torchbearers, while those who weren't dismissed it as a needlessly nasty taskmaster. When it came to Dark Souls, players took sides.

Dark Souls 2: Difficulty

To a degree the series' history - which began with the PS3 exclusive Demon's Souls - makes this review redundant. If you ever played and disliked Dark Souls, close this browser and leave; there is nothing for you here. While the developers have talked a good game about making their dungeon crawler more accessible they've made sure the game's hardcore appeal remains intact. Dark Souls 2 is a beast of a game.

In the opening ten minutes there's no helpful tutorial. No set of guidelines that lay out the mechanics and the game's structure. There's just some dialogue from a group of snaggle-toothed crones who cackle about how hard everything's going to be. We urge you to listen to them. They aren't lying.

Dark Souls 2: Features

In truth, that's exactly the way the target audience for this game wants it. Oh sure, there are features in Dark Souls 2 that look like concessions - such as the ability to fast-travel between levels using bonfires - but they're balanced by hideously harsh new aspects; the player's health bar, for example, drops slightly every time they die until they're respawning with half of their health unless they burn an effigy. Oh, and effigies are in short supply so good luck with that.

Dying also means you're stripped of any souls you've collected, which, as was the case with Dark Souls, means failure carries a very immediate cost. Like its predecessor, Dark Souls 2 isn't a game players can button-bash through. There's a very real need to work out timing, mechanics and enemy attack patterns if you don't want to end up infinitely frustrated. Dark Souls 2 rewards only those who are prepared to put the work in.

Covenants are back, but they're more open ended this time round. Depending on which Covenant players choose to enter into, they can find themselves either working to the detriment of other players or calling on them for help against other human players.