Piff was one of my favorites of the audition rounds, and this time, he’s back with another humorous magic act. Piff has even brought along Mr. Piffles, the world’s first magic performing Chihuahua. It says a lot about Piff’s natural charisma that the judges are already loving him before he even begins. Heidi is the volunteer, getting to hold Mr. Piffles for this act. Watch the magic below:

So Piff starts making a sandwich onstage, prompting Howie to ask if this couldn’t wait. But Piff insists he’s hungry from looking at all this dog food onstage. Neil praises Piff for the uniqueness of his act, saying he loved the humor, the showmanship and the magic. In fact, he loved it so much…

This was totally the right decision. On the one hand, I’m sure Piff would have gotten through anyway, but I like that he’s guaranteed a spot at Radio City Music Hall, since I imagine he’s going to be a bit of a divisive act, moving forward.

But what did you think of Piff the Magic Dragon? Was Neil Patrick Harris right to give him the Golden Buzzer? Sound off in the comments!