Monday, September 2, 2013

War or Diplomacy

As we celebrate the Labor Day holiday, Americans should
thank our lucky stars that we’re still around. America as we know it nearly ended in
October 1962. That’s when the US
military squared off against Soviet forces in the Cuban Missile Crisis.

Long
before President Obama proclaimed a “red line” in Syria,
President John F. Kennedy drew one around Cuba. In the end, World War III was
narrowly averted by back door diplomacy.

The Soviet Union is no longer around, but Russia inherited
its nuclear weapons. And Russia’s
leaders back Syria’s
government, which Obama is threatening to “punish” with a military attack. Getting
into a proxy war with Russia
in the Middle East could well revive the most
dangerous times of the Cold War nuclear age.

Furthermore, Syria
and its regional allies previously devastated a US military force sent to send them
a message.

“At this time of crisis, it is worth remembering another
time, 30 years ago in October, 1983 when U.S.
warships bombarded Lebanon,
the country located next to Syria,”
retired Col. Ann Wright wrote recently. “Within weeks, the U.S. Marine barracks
in Beirut was
blown up by a massive truck bomb that killed 241 American servicemen: 220
Marines, 18 sailors and three soldiers. The truck driver-suicide bomber was an
Iranian national named Ismail Ascari … Two minutes later a second suicide
bomber drove a truck filled with explosives into the French military compound
in Beirut
killing 58 French paratroopers.”

The explosive blowback against US military posturing aimed
at countering Syria’s influence
in Lebanon also destroyed US diplomatic work
in the region. Wright, a former diplomat as well as Army officer, noted:

“Earlier in the year, on April 18, 1983, the U.S. Embassy in
Beirut had been
blown up by another suicide driver with 900 pounds of explosives that killed 63
people, 17 Americans, mostly embassy and CIA staff members, several soldiers
and one Marine, 34 Lebanese employees of the US Embassy and 12 Embassy
visitors. It was the deadliest attack on a U.S. diplomatic mission up to that
time, and marked the beginning of anti-U.S. attacks by Islamist groups. The U.S. and French military were in Lebanon as a part of a Multi-National force
after the PLO left Lebanon
following the 1982 Israeli invasion of Lebanon. ostensibly to create a 40
km buffer zone between the PLO and Syrian forces in Lebanon
and Israel.”

US military forces withdrew from Lebanon and diplomatic efforts
sputtered out. Three violent decades later, Obama aims to fire cruise missiles
into Syria
to teach them a lesson, a move that could backfire in explosive ways that wreck
peacemaking work in the region for another generation.

If Obama intends to resolve this long-simmering crisis,
rather than inflame it, he should read a perceptive account in The Atlantic of
how Kennedy ultimately used diplomacy in the Cuban Missile Crisis:

“Plainly shaken by the apocalyptic potentialities of the
situation, Kennedy advocated, in the face of the bellicose and near-unanimous
opposition of his pseudo-tough-guy advisers, accepting the missile swap that
Khrushchev had proposed [that the US
remove its nuclear missiles from the Soviet border area in Turkey in exchange for Soviet missiles being
shipped back from Cuba].
…”

Obama should continue reading how Kennedy hid this
diplomatic deal from the American public, so that he would look tough
militarily.

“Although Kennedy in fact agreed to the missile swap and,
with Khrushchev, helped settle the confrontation maturely, the legacy of that
confrontation was nonetheless pernicious. By successfully hiding the deal from
the vice president, from a generation of foreign-policy makers and strategists,
and from the American public, Kennedy and his team reinforced the dangerous
notion that firmness in the face of what the United States construes as
aggression, and the graduated escalation of military threats and action in
countering that aggression, makes for a successful national-security strategy…”

As the author of The Atlantic article, Benjamin Schwarz,
noted:

“This esoteric strategizing—this misplaced obsession with
credibility, this dangerously expansive concept of what constitutes
security—which has afflicted both Democratic and Republican administrations,
and both liberals and conservatives, is the antithesis of statecraft, which
requires discernment based on power, interest, and circumstance.”

The lesson of the Cuban Missile Crisis that Kennedy muddled
is that diplomacy is a far better bet than waging war—and it takes more courage
to do peacemaking than doing puffed chest posturing to look warrior-like.

No comments:

About Me

I'm a poet, journalist, author and editor of several books, including A Citizen's Guide to Grassroots Campaigns, Earth Songs: New and Selected Poems, and Winning Hearts & Minds: War Poems by Vietnam Veterans. I also teach writing workshops and college journalism courses. For more information: www.janbarry.net.