YouTube, T-Mobile Battle Over Video Throttling

with intentionally throttling a video traffic. A association orator pronounced in a matter to Fortune on Wednesday that while T-Mobile’s attempts during “reducing information charges can be good for users,” a use does not “justify throttling all video services, generally but pithy user consent.”

, Hulu, and HBO Go, but eating into their information limits. While T-Mobile CEO John Legere touted a pierce as a game-changer in a mobile industry, there are some caveats. For one, video is streamed during DVD peculiarity with 480p resolution. Since many inclination come with higher-resolution displays, it was rather unsatisfactory to those who enterprise better-quality visuals. For T-Mobile, it’s a approach to hillside video peculiarity to save on information consumption.

At launch, YouTube was not enclosed in a Binge On list, and is still not partial of that program. However, YouTube argues that T-Mobile has placed a same data-throttling boundary on a high-definition videos. What’s worse, a association argues, T-Mobile is allegedly doing so but removing patron consent.

T-Mobile has concurred that by a Binge On program, “almost all other video streaming is optimized for mobile.” In other words, a association is downgrading video peculiarity even on a services that aren’t partial of a giveaway program. T-Mobile says a pierce allows business to “watch 3 times some-more video” with their information plans. Only a 24 companies that have met T-Mobile’s “technical criteria” won’t use adult data.

A T-Mobile orator forked to a twitter from Legere on Tuesday. Oddly, a tweet, that a T-Mobile orator called a response, did not discuss YouTube’s charges, and usually touted a Binge On program.

“Our business [love] Binge On, streaming video but attack their information bucket and finish control to spin it on/off during will,” Legere tweeted. Indeed, T-Mobile categorically says on a website that video-quality downgrading can be incited off during any time, permitting users to resume higher-quality access.

SIGN UP: Get Data Sheet, Fortune’s daily newsletter about a business of technology.

That has finished small to relieve disturbance over a Binge On program. The Internet Association, an classification that acts on interest of Internet companies to pull open policy, released a statement on Tuesday, observant that “T-Mobile’s new ‘streaming optimization’ module appears to engage throttling of all video traffic, opposite all information plans, regardless of network congestion.” Google is one of The Internet Association’s member companies.

“Reducing information charges for whole classes of applications can be legitimate and advantage consumers, so prolonged as transparent notice and choice is supposing to use providers and consumers,” a classification pronounced in a statement. “However, a pretty designed zero-rating module does not embody a throttling of trade for services or consumers that do not participate.”

The Binge On module has also held a Federal Communications Commission’s eye. In a minute to T-Mobile antiquated Dec. 16, a FCC requested some-more information on a module to establish either T-Mobile is treating all services fairly.

WATCH: For some-more on T-Mobile’s Binge On program, check out a following Fortune video:

“As we might be aware, concerns have been voiced about a Binge On program,” a minute reads. “For example, some have argued that a technical mandate of a Binge On module might mistreat creation by creation certain video apps some-more appealing than others. Others have asserted that a rebate of video peculiarity has spoiled some users.”

The exploration is partial of a broader regard over net neutrality. While a subject has been debated for years, in February, a FCC adopted manners that need Internet Service Providers, including mobile networks, to provide all trade sincerely and not distinguish opposite certain services. Those manners also anathema selectively throttling trade on certain forms of applications, including video.

In a minute to T-Mobile, a FCC concurred that T-Mobile believes “that Binge On is not a network neutrality problem,” and final month, FCC authority Tom Wheeler told a contributor that Binge On does not violate any net neutrality rules.

“It’s transparent in a Open Internet Order that we pronounced we are pro-competition and pro-innovation,” Wheeler said. “Clearly this meets both of those criteria. It’s rarely innovative and rarely competitive.”

T-Mobile has been asked to respond to a FCC by Jan. 15. In a statement, The Internet Association pronounced that it “applauds a FCC for seeking information on this use and a intensity mistreat on consumers and online applications and services.”