Security Alarm Response: The Benefits of Privatization

Transcription

1 Security Alarm Response: The Benefits of Privatization Over the last 20 years, new technology has made it easier, faster and more cost effective to remotely detect security problems in homes and businesses. As a result, an alarming gap has emerged between the ability to detect problems and the ability of the police to respond. This paper examines costs and benefits of outsourcing alarm response to private security firms. By Tim Keller, CPP Even before the Great Recession of , law enforcement budgets were stretched thin. From Cleveland and Milwaukee to Las Vegas and Sacramento, many municipal police departments were obliged to institute hiring freezes or reduce the number of sworn officers. Despite these budget and labor constraints, however, law enforcement is being asked to assume even more responsibility for public safety and security. For example, in the wake of the September 11, 2001 terrorist attacks, some police are now tasked with securing vital infrastructure such as train stations, bridges, power plants, and more. As a consequence of providing more services with fewer resources: Average response times by police have increased. Local governments have levied (or increased) fines on businesses and homeowners whenever police respond to false security alarms. A growing number of towns and cities, including Las Vegas and Milwaukee, have instituted Verified Alarm Response (VAR) policies. Accordingly, the police no longer respond to alarms unless video or eyewitness corroboration is first provided that an actual crime is in progress. Increasingly, businesses and homeowners are employing private security firms to patrol their neighborhoods. In Chicago, Milwaukee, New Orleans and New York, for example, the members of business improvement districts have pooled resources to hire private security officers. These officers patrol the streets, respond to alarms, interact with business owners, and serve as a supplemental deterrent to crime. i Collectively, these and other smaller trends are fueling a larger trend toward the privatization of certain security and policing functions. In 1965 there was one sworn police officer for every 0.9 private security guards in the U.S. By 2007, 2.3 private security officers were employed for every sworn officer, and the number of private security personnel has only grown since then. ii By the mid-1990s, one retailer even employed more security officers than there were police officers in the entire Los Angeles police department. iii Since 9-11, the public and private sectors have sought new and better ways to promote cooperation to improve public safety and control costs. Although the decades-long privatization trend is cause for concern by some observers, most experts believe the great contemporary challenge confronting public safety in the United States is not primarily about whether privatization and civilianization are good things but about how best to serve the public s need for protection against crime. iv Indeed, few policy experts advocate the wholesale substitution of private security for sworn police. Instead, most believe the lion s share of policing, including criminal investigation and 1

2 apprehension, should remain the sole domain of the public sector. At the same time, there is widespread agreement that certain time-consuming (and largely ancillary) functions are more cost-effectively handled by the private sector, and that privatization of these tasks benefits the public by allowing law enforcement to devote more time, manpower and equipment to higherpriority tasks. A Good Fit for Privatization From a public policy perspective, expecting police to respond to unverified security alarms is an unnecessary consumption of taxpayer dollars and law enforcement resources. In the United States in 2002, police responded to approximately 36 million alarm activations at an estimated cost of $1.8 billion. In fact, the vast majority of the calls between 94 and 98 percent (higher in some jurisdictions) were false. Research suggests that the most common causes of false alarms are: User errors e.g., typing incorrect keypad codes, leaving doors or windows open when activating alarms, pets, and inadequate employee training. Faulty or inappropriately selected equipment. Poor installation, including failure to install motion detectors in sensible areas or at appropriate heights. v Conversely, a recent survey of VAR policies across 20 U.S. jurisdictions revealed that the police enjoyed significant time and manpower savings after such policies were implemented. Before Milwaukee instituted a VAR policy in 2004, police responded to 30,000 burglar alarms per year 97 percent of which were false. Annually, false alarms in Milwaukee consumed the time of up to 150 police at a cost of over $1.1 million. In 2012, by contrast, the number of alarms to which Milwaukee police responded dropped to 620 only 38 percent of which were false. vi 2.8 % VALID ALARMS 62,000 Alarm Calls 2004 Dallas, TX 0.3 % ACTUAL CRIMES >1,000 Alarm Calls 1999 Salt Lake City, UT 10 POLICE ARRESTS 5,944 Alarm Calls 2001 Eugene, OR Salt Lake City s VAR policy reduced police response times to high-priority emergency calls by an average of two minutes, and nearly 8,500 officer hours were freed for other priorities. In fact, every municipality surveyed reported significant time savings for police as well as an increased ability to respond promptly to emergency calls. Answering the Alarms Today, it s easier than ever to remotely detect potential security issues. Consumers can walk into a Home Depot or a Best Buy, and walk out with security systems that are less expensive, more user-friendly and more sophisticated than anything available years ago. But if these alarms activate, who will respond to them, and what will the responders do upon arrival, especially if they encounter a crime in progress? While police are authorized and trained to detain and interrogate criminal suspects, most private security officers are not. In short, what are the direct costs and benefits to homeowners and businesses of privatizing alarm response? Until recently, alarm systems were often connected directly to police stations. Today, that s rarely an option. Increasingly, the only personnel willing and able to respond to alarms are the security officers employed by alarm companies or the consumers themselves. At larger businesses, security officers may be hired to patrol properties 24/7 or cover particular shifts, maintaining a physical on-site presence for all or part of each day. The problem with staffing an office building, manufacturing facility or distribution center with security personnel 2

3 for eight, 16 or even 24 hours is, of course, the significant cost of the labor. Staffing a location or multiple locations with private officers is beyond the financial means of many small businesses, and the routine nature of some security patrols tends to diminish their value as a crime deterrent. Mobile Guarding and Alarm Response A newer alternative to stationing security officers throughout a property is Mobile Guarding Alarm Response an option that can dramatically reduce the cost of hiring private security while simultaneously increasing its efficiency and deterrence value. Thirty years ago, a company leasing a 15-story office building might have hired multiple security officers to staff the property in two or even three shifts. In recent years, however, management might have determined that the rising cost of this arrangement outweighed the risks. Thanks to advances in technology, specially-trained officers can now keep this company s facilities under close and constant observation from offsite monitoring stations at a fraction of the cost. The remote stations allow security personnel to position and reposition surveillance cameras, make announcements and summon emergency responders in the event of break-ins, vandalism, fire, flooding, accidents, etc. Meanwhile, security officers in marked cars inspect customer facilities at random intervals throughout the day and night, remaining in the vicinity at all times so they can quickly respond to a variety of issues. (This is known as Proactive Patrolling.) In the case of a legitimate security breach or other perceived threat, officers staffing the off-site monitoring stations contact the appropriate responders, whether mobile security officers, law enforcement or other emergency personnel. 97 % OF FALSE ALARMS IN MILWAUKEE, 2004 Remote surveillance also allows officers at the monitoring centers to identify and deactivate false alarms quickly. This saves customers money on false alarm fees, and helps maintain excellent relationships with local law-enforcement and other emergency responders. Advances in video analytics help security firms to recognize triggers and alert off-site monitoring personnel to the potential for false alarms before they become problems. Other benefits of Mobile Guarding and Alarm Response include: Equipment and materials monitoring: Many manufacturing plants contain machinery or materials that must be kept at specific temperatures. Mobile security officers can check in, as needed, to confirm that these temperature (and other) specifications are met, and can even be trained to make minor adjustments. Real-time reports: Advances in technology mean that mobile officers can create reports on-site, alerting business owners to any security issues within minutes of detection. Instead of arriving at the location to find a problem, customers arrive to a complete review of the night s activity. Shift coverage: Mobile officers can provide a friendly face and peace of mind for employees working solo shifts, especially during overnight hours. They can be posted at a front desk or lobby reception to cover employee breaks and provide parking lot escorts. Power outages: In the event of a local or regional power outage, mobile officers will be alerted, and back-up officers dispatched to provide coverage at customers facilities. Together, remote monitoring, alarm response, and proactive patrolling reduce the overall cost of security, including the cost of false alarms, while enhancing deterrence and helping to ensure rapid response to genuine threats and emergencies. 3

4 A Scalable Solution The mobile guarding approach is also highly scalable. What works for a single location can work for multiple locations even entire neighborhoods. Where officers once had to be physically present at control booths or entrances to gated communities, they can now monitor remotely. This is already standard practice for many larger companies whose manufacturing plants in the Northeast can be monitored by highly-trained personnel in the mid-atlantic, from which security officers can dispatch local responders almost instantly. Although a combination of remote and mobile guarding seems like an obvious solution for lowactivity posts, it s also a viable option for locations experiencing high levels of activity. Working with homeowners associations, security personnel can patrol entire neighborhoods during designated times. In addition to deterrence, they can help to promote neighborhood rules and guidelines, help keep pools, parks and playgrounds secure after hours, and enforce traffic regulations and more. Mobile units are a good value for these associations, since officers are not paid to staff a gatehouse or patrol 24/7, but patrol only at random intervals. Customers pay for only the proactive services they actually receive rather than for general coverage. In business improvement districts, mobile security can serve as an extra set of eyes and ears for the police, helping deter minor nuisances (littering, loud music, loitering) that can erode merchants ability to do business. New Avenues for Security More than ever, both the public and private sectors are challenged by seemingly contradictory goals to increase the security of people and property and maintain (or reduce) the associated expenses. These expenses, which include wages, benefits, taxes, fees and fines, are unlikely to abate and will probably increase over the long term. It s reasonable to expect, therefore, that costs affecting the security industry will continue to rise even as many customers are under intense pressure to contain overhead and operate more cost-effectively. This is where remote monitoring and mobile guarding alarm response can make a difference. The mobile monitoring and alarm response model allows commercial and residential property owners to enhance security while decreasing dependence on labor-intensive practices. Instead of simply employing more officers to provide more services, the best security firms deploy new technologies, tools and strategies to make each officer more productive. IN SUM, private security is pioneering innovative new ways to do more with less. i Verified Response: Lessons Learned. White paper commissioned by Sonitrol, June 20, ii Manning, Peter The United States of America. ; USBLS (United States Bureau of Labor Statistics) Occupational Outlook Handbook, Edition: Police and Detectives. Washington, DC: Bureau of Labor Statistics. iii Brian Forst, The Privatization and Civilianization of Policing. Criminal Justice 2000, National Institute of Justice/NCJRS. iv Ibid. v Rana Sampson, False Burglar Alarms 2nd Edition. vi Verified Response: Lessons Learned. 4

The remote CCTV monitoring specialists CCTV Monitoring Providing security and total peace of mind 24 hours a day, 365 days a year! Welcome to Valleywatch Valleywatch is a specialist CCTV monitoring station

Alarm Management: Determining the Best Approach for Your Community October 2013 Summary Since 2002 the International Association of Chiefs of Police (IACP) and the alarm industry have worked together to

Remote Guarding Remote Guarding The traditional guarding functions that you depend on can now be performed remotely. When you have Remote Guarding managed by Securitas USA, we act on incidents in real-time

Virtual Security Technology Complete Security Solutions for Communities Secure your Entire Community with an Envera Integrated System We were concerned residents would feel they weren t receiving the same

The Business Argument for Integrating Security Systems Over the past decade security managers and others charged with the protection of an organization s assets have faced the dichotomy of defending against

School Security: What are you missing? The need to keep our nation s children safe at school has become more urgent than ever. But this also puts pressure on both the school s administrators and its budget.

The Basics of Home Security Topics Covered: Home Security Basics Home Security Guides Home Security Products and Services The Value of Insurance in Home Protection Top Ten Tips for Your Home Security Essentials

Crime and our first line of defense Presented by: The Lee County Sheriff s Office False Alarm Reduction Unit What will we cover? Why people install alarm systems. What is an alarm system? How alarm systems

Security Master Plan and Standard for Yuba Community College District Submitted by: Christopher S.M. Wilkinson Chief of Police Yuba Community College District Page 1 SECTION 1.0 INTRODUCTION The Yuba Community

Alarm User Awareness Class 1 What We Will Cover What is an alarm system How alarm systems really work What is a False Alarm Causes & impacts of false alarms How to reduce & eliminate false alarms And more.

Keep Watch on Your Projects Through the Cloud, 24/7/365 Unlock the all the potential tools of a modern enterprise video surveillance system with a costeffective and elegantly simple cloud video surveillance

Securitas CCTV Surveillance Vehicle 1 2 3 What is the Service? The Securitas CCTV Van is deployed either proactively to deter crime, or reactively to prevent reccurrence of incidents. It can also be used

2011 Law Enforcement Security Industry Study SPONSORED BY securitysales.com JULY 2011 61 Original Research Law Enforcement Calls Security Industry to Duty istockphoto.com/frances Twitty Thanks to the implementation

Commercial Security Systems Securing Your Business Environment The security of your business and the safety of your employees are of vital importance. When choosing a security provider, you need someone

California Department of Social Services Child Care Advocate Program CHILD CARE CENTERS SELF-ASSESSMENT GUIDE HOW TO MAKE YOUR CHILD CARE CENTER A SAFER PLACE FOR CHILDREN COMMUNITY CARE LICENSING DIVISION

Secure Homes Report 2014 We advance safety and security by finding smarter ways to save lives, improve businesses and protect where people live and work. At ADT Security we have made it our business to

FREQUENTLY ASKED QUESTIONS WASHOE COUNTY ALARM ORDINANCE Is there a value to owning an alarm system? Yes, an alarm system can bring you a sense of security and peace of mind and is effective with proper

City of Dallas Alarm Permit Application For Burglar and/or Holdup/Panic/Duress Alarm Systems Please Print. The application will be returned if not filled out completely. NEW,RENEWAL AND REINSTATEMENT PERMIT

Leveraging the Benefits of IP and the Cloud in the Security Sector The CCTV and alarm industry has relied on analogue or Integrated Services Digital Network (ISDN) communications to provide data connectivity

ReadyGuard Touch Security System Your Connected Home Dynamic, Full Color Touchscreen Security System and Home Controller Your Connected Home First Alert Professional s ReadyGuard Touch is a dynamic, lifestyle-enhancing

Major Risks and Recommended Solutions www.icdsecurity.com OVERVIEW Are you familiar with the main security risks that threaten data centers? This paper provides an overview of the most common and major

The VXM4B Range Digital Video Recorder and Remote Monitoring System Think Remote Monitoring Think Concept Pro Think VXM4B Not much more left to Think about Who watches over your business when you re not

FREQUENTLY ASKED QUESTIONS about the ALARM ORDINANCE, ALARM REGISTRATION AND FALSE ALARM FEES Is there a value to owning an alarm system? Yes, an alarm system can bring you a sense of security and peace

premium asset PROTECTION Services Your partner in security solutions and risk management The success of your company depends on your investments in people, product and facility. How will you protect those

The following presents a detailed outline of goals and objectives of this Department organized by Department function. It is intended to provide a guideline for use in assessing progress in attaining the

A COST ANALYSIS OF OF OUTSOURCING SECURITY OPERATIONS CENTERS Analysis of a global company with 500 employees in fifteen locations SECURITY EXPENDITURES ON THE RISE AND SO ARE LOSSES GREATER THAN $10 MILLION

Reducing the cost of crime through reserve police officers and volunteer citizen patrol ABSTRACT James Larson National University Victor Lewis National University Kenneth D. Kay National University Chandrika

Tool 1: Assessing Robbery Risk Physical Security Checklist and Inventory Any assessment of robbery risk begins with an evaluation and inventory of the measures you are already taking as a financial institution.

WHITE PAPER Video Alarm Verification Comes of Age Technology Advancements Are Driving Down Costs FOREWORD Increasing demands on local law enforcement coupled with shrinking municipal budgets are driving

Melaleuca Home Security Why Melaleuca Security? Get great home protection at 30% savings off the competitors Generate additional income opportunities from your current Melaleuca organization Sterling Barnes

09/18/08 FALSE ALARM REDUCTION REPORT AND RECOMMENDATIONS Intrusion alarms have been extensively used since the 1950 s to protect businesses from being victimized by burglars. In recent decades alarm systems

A Consumer Guide to Purchasing a Burglar Alarm System and Understanding False Alarms Produced by the False Alarm Reduction Association (FARA) May not be reproduced without the expressed, written consent

Partnerships between Public Law Enforcement and Private Security Should Become the Norm By: Terrance W. Gainer, Senior Advisor to Securitas USA WHAT S INSIDE: Partnerships between law enforcement and private

ORDINANCE REGARDING ALARMS IN THE TOWN OF PLAINVILLE SECTION I. PURPOSE AND INTENT. The purpose of this ordinance is to encourage Alarm Users and Alarm Businesses to maintain the operational reliability

Working Relationship with Local Law Enforcement Authorities The working relationship with local police departments is limited to the reporting of crimes and information sharing. The working relationship

Your Home. Your Family. Your Life. powered by Stay in the know, wherever you go. Access Your Guardian Security System through MyGuardianControl Connect to What Matters Most Whether you want to check up

What Should I Expect From My Alarm Monitoring Station? When the alarm goes off... What actions will the operators take? When will they dispatch the authorities? What actions do I need to take? Monitoring

(877) 435-4832 (4-ELITE-2) info@eliteisi.com www.eliteisi.com Introducing the Remote Guarding Vendor Comparison Tool. Now, you can compare Elite ISI with competitors and see how we measure up to the task

EAST WINDSOR POLICE DEPARTMENT ~ Ordinance Regulating Alarm Systems ~ I. PREAMBLE: It has been determined that the number of false alarms being made to the Police and Fire Department hinders the efficiency

United States Environmental Protection Agency Enhanced Security Monitoring Primer For Water Quality Surveillance and Response Systems Office of Water (M 140) EPA 817-B-15-002B May 2015 Introduction A Water

The CHICAGO STORY Use of CCCTV for General Area Surveillance, Crime Hot Spots, Mobile Applications, and Future Developments 3rd Largest U.S. City 2.9 million residents 228 square miles CPD 2 nd largest

about your house CE 66C How to Lock Out Crime: Home Security Alarms If you are like most Canadians, you are concerned about the safety of your home and your community. One particular type of crime that

FREQUENTLY ASKED QUESTIONS about the FALSE ALARM ORDINANCE, ALARM PERMITS AND FALSE ALARM FEES Is there a value to owning an alarm system? Yes, an alarm system can bring you a sense of security and peace