A Real Solution to Polarization

As I mentioned briefly, I met Krist Novoselic on Friday, and though I’m a big Nirvana fan the actual subject was his work as chairman of Fair Vote, an excellent organization pushing a variety of worthy reforms to the American electoral system.
One of the things we talked about was the remarkable fact that for all the bellyaching in Washington about the related topics of gerrymandering and polarization, elites seem totally blind to the ways in which shifting to a more proportional system could ameliorate these problems. When Americans hear “proportional” they often immediately leap to imagining something like a nationwide closed party list system, but a much more realistic and practical solution would be to have multiple member congressional districts with single transferrable vote.
What does that mean and what does it have to do with polarization?
Well, take New York City. Instead of carving the city up into 13 or 14 different districts with members elected by plurality, all of them won by Democrats, the whole city could vote proportionally for a slate of 13-14 members of congress, and several of them would wind up being Republicans with the exact number depending on political fortunes. This would reduce what I think bothers people about polarization in congress in at least two ways. One is that though on many issues the NYC Republicans and NYC Democrats would fiercely disagree, on a bunch of other issues that have substantial regional or urban/non-urban elements to them the NYC bloc would be collaborating along with other bipartisan congressional blocks against other bipartisan congressional blocks. The other is that the balance of power in congress wouldn’t be determined by a relatively small number of “swing districts.” In any given election, Democrats and Republicans alike would have plausible pickup opportunities all across the country—even in New York City—meaning that it would make sense for the GOP to always at least think about trying to answer the concerns of American cities.
Then on the flipside, if Nebraska elected its three-member congressional delegation in a proportional manner you wouldn’t have the scenario where 41 percent of Nebraskans vote for Barack Obama but 100 percent of them are represented in the House by conservative Republicans. All regions of the country would have a measure of bipartisan representation, and both parties would have substantial blocs of members to advocate for the interests of different kinds of places.

Related

GATINEAU, Que. — It has been said the best argument against democracy is talking to the average voter for five minutes.
Mark Holland has probably had some sympathy with that sentiment during his time as co-host of the electoral reform town hall, currently going nationwide.
The Liberal parliamentary secretary was reprimanded at one point in the evening by a gentleman who said he didn’t like the way things were being run.

OTTAWA — NDP MPs have been holding town halls in ridings held by other parties this summer in an attempt to rile up the public on options for new voting systems — and to compensate for what they perceive as a lack of action in some Conservative ridings.
Maryam Monsef, the Liberal democratic institutions minister, conducted her own town halls this summer regarding electoral reform, while Tories were still gunning for a referendum on the issue, seeing events as ineffective and conducting their own public engagement differently.

Associated Press/J. Scott ApplewhiteThe Supreme Court on Tuesday heard oral arguments for a long-awaited case on partisan gerrymandering, the outcome of which could essentially overhaul the American election process.

Here is how some opponents of proportional representation think it works. After the votes are cast, each party receives a number of seats in strict accordance with its share of the total vote. Rather than running in constituencies, MPs are simply pulled off lists drafted by party leaders.

Tom Friedman becomes the latest in a very long string of pundits to blame congressional polarization on partisan gerrymandering of House districts. As Joshua Tucker points out no matter how many times people say this, there’s still no evidence that it’s true.

The wind power industry may have just won another year of taxpayer support, as the fiscal cliff deal being negotiated between congressional Republicans and President Obama includes a one-year extension of the wind Production Tax Credit.