And here she does it again! Sara Shepard captures fear, suspense, mystery, and murder in such an intricately woven web that one can't help diving in headfirst. From the beginning to the end, it just doesn't cut a break. The main characters are all so different, yet tied together closely by the weird knowledge that they may all have something to do with murders happening around them. It just doesn't seem to go away, even as they go on with their lives. I never would have guessed the ending; it was so well planned. However, it did confuse me a lot because I couldn't differ between what "the character" imagined and what was reality. 4/5 stars
- @Siri of the Teen Review Board of the Hamilton Public Library

This book is amazing!! The plot twist at the end is incredibly written and you would never suspect it to be what happened, but when you read it back it totally makes sense!!! Shepard is such a good writer.

Halfway through this book, I formed a theory. In the end the theory was correct (about Julie and Parker). But ugh that last chapter really messed with my mind! A third book would be interesting, I heard there would only be two though. Anyways, I love Shepard's writing because there are so many twists and it's so fun to read!