12 Best Makeup Finds for $5 or Less

The high-quality makeup steals our readers say you need to try

No. 11: Rimmel London Scandal Eyes Waterproof Kohl Eyeliner, $3.97TotalBeauty.com average member rating: 8.6*Why it's great: Reviewers describe this drugstore buy as "creamy" and "emollient." "It has great pigmentation, so I don't have to go over my lines with multiple swipes," raves one reviewer. Another reader says this liner is "perfect for lining your water line ... It goes on smoothly without tugging at the lids."