EFF Urges FTC to Take Action Against Patent Trolls

EFF filed comments today urging the Federal Trade Commission to take action against patent trolls. We have written often about the rise of the patent troll—entities that don't create products themselves, but instead buy patents and make money from lawsuits—and the serious harm they are causing true innovators.

In our comments, we urge the FTC to produce a detailed report about patent trolls (or, as the FTC more delicately calls them, ‘patent assertion entities’) and the cost they impose on the economy. We explain that trolls are costing billions of dollars every year with the burden falling especially hard on startups. Patent trolls target startups because they know smaller businesses lack the resources to fight back.

We also urge the FTC to use its investigatory and enforcement powers against the most abusive trolls—especially those that use baseless lawsuits to extort settlements. Because shell company patent trolls don’t make anything themselves, they generally have nothing to lose. This gives them a unique incentive to abuse the litigation system. Until now, this abuse has gone largely unchecked.

We welcome the FTC’s interest in patent trolls and hope the agency will follow up with action. A strong response to abusive patent trolls is long overdue.

Related Updates

On September 8, 2017, the multi-billion dollar pharmaceutical company Allerganannounced that it “sold” its patents relating to its eye drops “Restasis” to the Saint Regis Mohawk Tribe. But this was not a usual “sale.” The Tribe doesn't appear to have paid anything in exchange for becoming the...

In a closely watched case, the Court of Appeals for the Federal Circuit has issued an order that should see many more patent cases leaving the Eastern District of Texas. The order in In re Cray, together with the Supreme Court’s recent decision in TC Heartland v. Kraft...

Since 1992, Fairytale Brownies has sold delicious brownies based on a secret family recipe. It’s a small business founded by two childhood friends who were quick to see the potential of the Internet and registered the domain www.brownies.com in 1995. Fairytale Brownies became an e-commerce website before the first...

We have often criticized the Patent Office for issuing broad software patents that cover obvious processes. Instead of promoting innovation in software, the patent system places landmines for developers who wish to use basic and fundamental tools. This month’s stupid patent, which covers user permissions for mobile applications, is a...

Rick Pepper started his company Elevengear as a one-person shop in 2007, and it’s since grown to a small, successful team. All of that could have changed when his company was sued for allegedly infringing a group of obscure patents on delivery and tracking protocols.

San Francisco, California—The Electronic Frontier Foundation (EFF) won a court ruling today affirming that an infamous podcasting patent used by a patent troll to threaten podcasters big and small was properly held invalid by the U.S. Patent and Trademark Office (USPTO). A unanimous decision by a three-judge panel...

Did one Stupid Patent of the Month winner enforce its patent in an exceptional manner, so much so that it has to pay defendants’ attorneys’ fees? That is a question a court in the Eastern District of Texas is being asked to decide, with a public hearing on the...

On July 25, 2017, the Patent Office issued a patent to HP on reminder messages. Someone needs to remind the Patent Office to look at the real world before issuing patents. United States Patent No. 9,715,680 (the ’680 patent) is titled “Reminder messages.” While the patent application does...

EFF has asked a federal court to rule in its favor in a lawsuit we filed against an Australian company that sought to use foreign law to censor us from expressing our opinion about its patent. While the company, Global Equity Management (SA) Pty Ltd (GEMSA,...