Britain is at fault going back long term not Israel or the Arab minority. Britain didn't sort out the mess and just pulled out without settling things
down, just as it did in India. You can't blame Israel.

Let me tell you, for what I know Britain was also persecuted and expelled from Palestine by the Jews, in terror attacks, because they started to see
Israel real agenda. Israel also understood, in 2WW, the power to control was the US. So there for Brittan got kicked out.

Yeah that's sort of true from one perspective, but Britain played with a double edged sword. Sure it attempted to keep the peace but it did allow mass
immigration of Jews into the eastern Mediterranean from Europe (and Asia/Africa) plus set up this in the first place by doing a deal with the Zionists
with the balfour Declaration. However you look at it, Britain was behind the establishment of the state of Israel.

I was talking about the dogma issue: hate speech accusation... later on. it will be... anti semetic... etc, etc

Get a grip and don't patronize me...

Says the person who unprompted and totally non related to the OP , Posted a picture about Israel that was clearly trying to be provocative and
negative

No one else even eluded to anything like that about Palestine, they were talking solely about the History of the land in the area and you came out
with that.

Palestine and Israel are both horrible with their Human Rights violations and attacking one another, so to sit here and try and claim some sort of
superiority on that issue is moot.

So was this OP to talk about the Interesting history of Palestine and the area, or was this just another forum , like your multitudes of other
threads, to attack Israel?

Because thats exactly what youve made it, you lured people into your thread on the basis of discussing one thing and then you totally flipped the
script around to use it as yet another soap box for you.

Not only that youve initiated an attack campaign against any posters that post anything you perceive as a different version of history on the land,
launching into completely off topic rhetoric that has NOTHING to do with the lands and everything to do with foreign policy. Yet AGAIN off topic

Again bad form and leads no credence to your integrity regarding the subject

originally posted by: AlienSupernova
So was this OP to talk about the Interesting history of Palestine and the area, or was this just another forum , like your multitudes of other
threads, to attack Israel?

It seems you already know what this op was for (amazing...). About my multitude threads, it was taking to long to come up with that... and here i'm
being so naive believing your only interest was discussion about the topic...

originally posted by: AlienSupernova
Because thats exactly what youve made it, you lured people into your thread on the basis of discussing one thing and then you totally flipped the
script around to use it as yet another soap box for you.

Again accusations and more accusations... all subjective assumptions from you.. for everyone to believe... it's curious that i'm perceiving your only
interest it's to attack me..

originally posted by: AlienSupernova
Not only that youve initiated an attack campaign against any posters that post anything you perceive as a different version of history on the land,

False. I only replied to the ones who are attacking me. like you are.

originally posted by: AlienSupernova
Again bad form and leads no credence to your integrity regarding the subject

Again I believe you are looking at a mirror.

Please don't forget to reply directly to 2 simple questions of this post.
try to be short, to not derail further more the thread. You have only to provide simple evidence for your other accusations.

So asking questions to you , in which you return with hostility towards me, is me attacking you? The first thing you did was accuse me of hate speech
with no reason for it what so ever. And you have yet to answer HOW and WHAT I said that was hate speech

Not true, you were the one (first one) accusing me of hate speech. so please copy and past.

Umm a cursory look at the previous page will prove this is absolutely false.

Again I believe you are looking at a mirror. Please don't forget to reply directly to 2 simple questions of this post. try to be short, to not derail
further more the thread. You have only to provide simple evidence for your other accusations.

This back and forth banter is futile as you seem to not see any issues in your approach and continue to attack posters on a thread, and derailing your
OWN thread with things that are off topic, and then continuing the off topic dierction with your attacks.

I wont contribute to that any longer, I was honestly lokoing forward to a discussion on the history of the area and little known facts about
Palestine.

And instead all I have gotten is hostility , accusations, and "Israel is bad" which has nothing to do with the OP

Yea, really no point in arguing or contributing to this persons threads, s/he is a propagandist and has a relatively large following, you did well to
expose this person,but wether or not they are exposed, enough people buy into the hate Israel first(which strangely fall into the hate America first)
crowd. What I wonder,and of course I have answered this call before so I feel I can ask this question, what I wonder is, why these people don't go out
and put on a uniform and fight the imperialists?if they are truly dedicated that would seem to be the most prudent choice. Instead they will come here
for affirmation of their views, that may sway the less informed, while most everyone holds firm, but truly it does become nothing more than a soapbox.
If anyone who reads this, is apart of these crowds, put on a uniform and fight for what you believe in or be quiet.

originally posted by: AlienSupernova
Pardon me if I am wrong, but isnt it true there never was a "Palestine"

Werent Israel and "Palestine" one land mass before the dividing line?

Werent they both occupied by the same groups of people over the ages?

So that kind of makes the other points moot, thats like saying "Indians have been in Texas for 2000 years" well, yes but Indians were in all of North
America, sooooo

Love Love,

AlienSupernova

You are correct . There has never been an officially recognized Palestine anything. The land was ceded to them by the United Nations and the Israelis
as the Palestinian people were basically "kicked out" of every country they tried to inhabit . Why ? For being exactly as they are today.

For the OP;

2nd. «Palestinian community lives there for the last 2000 years.»

Incorrect . Please do a history of that area check.
Maybe in the not so close vicinity of where they are...

Im a new member here and although I think myself bold sometimes, honestly this thread has really made me rethink contributing and being anything more
than a lurker.

Im not a "soft" person, but it seems futile when people are allowed to start threads in order to trap people and then berate anyone that comes on the
thread to discuss the actual OP , which seemed innocent enough.

I was honestly looking forward to learning more, but within the first half of the page I was already accosted and I hadnt even said anything
inflammatory. And immediately the OP derails his own thread to jump on a soap box.

if this sort of thing is tolerated its going to discourage new contributions.

This content community relies on user-generated content from our member contributors. The opinions of our members are not those of site ownership who maintains strict editorial agnosticism and simply provides a collaborative venue for free expression.