Case Number 18862

Stoic

Every purchase you make through these Amazon links supports DVD Verdict's reviewing efforts. Thank you!

All Rise...

Judge David Johnson is stoic. Or is that stucco?

The Charge

It all started with a game of cards…

Opening Statement

Uwe Boll strikes again, this time trading the video game adaptations for
something just as awful.

Facts of the Case

Stoic follows four men who are locked up in prison. They're typically
mundane existence is highlighted by a regular game of cards, where cigarettes
and bragging rights are the spoils for victory. One such card game has a
particularly disgusting wager hanging over it, and when the low inmate on the
totem pole loses and refuses to accept his penalty, his three cell-mates go
bonkers. One thing leads to another and the guy is found hanging and dead the
next morning. Was it suicide? Or murder? What follows is the telling of the
tale.

The Evidence

I'm not an Uwe Boll hater. I don't really hate anyone, except for maybe
Khalid Sheikh Mohammed and that kid who wrote on my face with permanent marker
in eighth grade. Granted, more than a couple of his movies have hurt my brain,
but I won't deny the guy his success. If he can find investors and make them
money with his directorial efforts, then good for him. Which is to say I didn't
go into Stoic harboring any preconceived desires to dump on it just
because Boll was the creative force behind it.

But…dump on it I will, because Stoic is pretty much pointless.
What exactly is Boll trying to tell me with this movie? That being in prison
sucks? That having psycho roommates sucks? I knew that already.

The story is told by a mixture of interviews with the cellmates and a
gradual unveiling of what really led up to the hanging. There is a smidgen of
tension in the beginning because the cause of the kid's death is unknown, but
that suspense doesn't hold. Of course there's more to the story than a
simple suicide, and watching Boll weave his yarn becomes an exercise in bored
inevitability.

However, what isn't inevitable is the lengths Boll goes to shock the
audience. I won't get too detailed so to avoid spoilers; I'll just say the
culmination of the jailhouse shenanigans involves a mop handle and is quite
disturbing. (This begs the question why there are such dangerous weapons just
sitting around a cell room full of wackos.)

Again, though, what's the point? I don't understand the lesson I'm supposed
to take away from this. These guys are crazy douchebags and with each passing
frame one-up their douchebaggery until the end. In the interview segments, Boll
attempts to lend some weight to the story with the guys trying to defend their
actions and blame the system and blah blah blah. Hey, I'll be honest, after
watching Stoic I came away even more grateful for institutionalized
incarceration.

The disc is a gun-metal gray-tinted 1.78:1 anamorphic widescreen; 5.1 Dolby
Digital; with commentary from Boll, deleted scenes and a making-of
featurette.

Closing Statement

It wants to be something more, but Stoic is just empty-headed
brutality for brutality's sake.