I have never had a problem with any of the lip liners in American Beauty. I have 4-5 colors and they all glide on just the same as the last. Maybe she ogt a bad one out of the bunch. You know Kohl's backs up their products (which are all done by the Estee Lauder Companies).....so, return it and get an even exchange.
— 9 years, 10 months ago

The product name Ultra-Easy doesn't describe my experience. This lipliner just doesn't transfer color and protection to your lips. It has a dry texture that doesn't seem to work on either dry or pre-conditioned lips. I ended up pressing harder and dragging the pencil along my lipline to try to get color and resulted in my lips just feeling damaged.
— 10 years ago