What was being said was that GDT was side-stepping or "not answering" the question - implying that 3D was being secretly planned all along - that was what was being claimed by these sources - that the Hobbit WAS going to be in 3D. GDT's first statement (that was being debated earlier) was definitive in that no 3D was being secretly planned. That's how I took it and others took it, and anyone claiming otherwise I felt were looking for a conspiracy. Turns out I and others understood it correctly - there is no conspiracy. So, the people who took the answer as a definitive "the Hobbit is not planned to be in 3D" took it the right way. THAT was what was in question and of COURSE things can always change in the future. Good... Bad..... I'm the guy with the gun.