Handling: The Insight did not achieve “recommended” status for performance with Consumer Reports; it received demerits for poor acceleration, loud noise, a stiff ride and low visibility. The Prius is a “recommended” vehicle from Consumer Reports. It drives smoothly and unremarkably–exactly what you want in a hybrid sedan.

Clear winner?: Yes. In almost every way, but especially in fuel-efficiency and cargo space, Toyota’s Prius betters the Insight. The Prius costs a touch more, but it’s worth it.

Read on for more auto coverage, including lists, rankings and features about iconic cars like the MINI Cooper and Porsche 911.