Shakespearian Scholars on his Authorship

With Peter Holland

In this section

What is the attitude of mainstream Shakespeare scholars towards the authorship discussion?

Transcript

Holland: For a long time, Shakespeare scholars ignored the authorship controversy, treating it as a bizarre, marginal
phenomenon. After all, the proponents of other candidates don’t develop their arguments according to the standards of scholarship developed in so many fields of academic study (history, biography, textual analysis and
so on).

Discussing the details of their case with anti-Stratfordians was and continues to be frustrating, because
the kinds of evidence they adduce—hypothesis piled on speculation, built on conspiracy theories and secret
codes—can’t be met with logical argument.

But those of us intrigued by the ways in which popular beliefs develop (Elvis lives, Barack Obama wasn’t born
in the USA, and so on) are fascinated by why it should be that some people might think that Shakespeare
couldn’t have written Shakespeare. The strange passion that drives these theories is a powerful fact about our
society’s need to believe.

Peter Holland

Peter Holland is McMeel Family Chair in Shakespeare Studies in the Department of Film, Television and Theatre and Associate Dean for the Arts, at the University of Notre Dame.

Get involved

Useful

Follow us

Sharing Shakespeare with the World

We rely on the support of visitors, donors, Friends and volunteers to help inspire future generations through Shakespeare's works, life and times.

The independent charity that cares for the world’s greatest Shakespeare heritage sites in Stratford-upon-Avon, and promotes the enjoyment and understanding of his works, life and times all over the world. Celebrating Shakespeare is at the heart of everything we do.