Water guzzlers in water-stressed areas

This summer, stories of the impacts of drought and water scarcity that mostly highlight the conditions of farmers, cattle, domestic water supplies in villages, towns and cities have been regular. What is often not reported is the situation with industries, particularly the coal based thermal power plants, reports Shripad Dharmadhikary.

Water scarcity and droughts have badly affected industries in the country, particularly coal based thermal power plants (TPPs).

Water Guzzlers

Thermal power plants require huge amounts of water for their operation. Water is required mainly for cooling the steam that is used to generate electricity, and for disposal of the ash that is produced when coal is burnt. Typically, a 1000 MW coal-fired power plant would need 28 million cubic meter of water per year, enough to irrigate 5600 ha of land, or sufficient for the domestic water needs of around 500,000 people. Such water requirement can be a significant stress on local water systems, particularly in years of low rainfall, or in areas where there are clusters of more than one such power plant. This can either lead to power plant shut down due to lack of water, or, if the power plant generation is kept going, can impact other uses and users of water.

This is exactly what we have seen happening this year.

Electricity Generation Lost Due to Water Shortage

This year, coal based thermal power have already lost around 8.7 billion units (billion KWh) of electricity generation because of shut-downs due to shortage of water. This figure is based on data on daily generation of power plants that the Central Electricity Authority (CEA) makes public. The biggest share in this is of the Parli TPP in Beed district of Maharashtra, which has been closed off and on due to water shortages since last several years.

Raichur Coal based Thermal Power Plant. Pic: Tanzeel Ahad

If we leave out Parli, then there has been a loss of 582 Million Units of electricity as plants have had to shut down due to lack of water. These figures for loss of generation relate to the period between 1 Dec 2016 to 24 April 2016 except for Parli TPP, for which the figures are for year starting 1 April 2015. Some of the TPPs affected include Raichur TPP in Karnataka and the EMCO Warora TPP in Maharashtra. The actual loss in generation is likely to be higher as these figures are only upto last week of April, whereas the summer and water scarcity would extend till the beginning of the monsoon, which is expected to be around first or second week of June.

The overall generation in the country in the year 2015-16 was 1107 billion units. This means that the loss is about 0.7% of the total generation in the country. This may seem a small proportion of the total generation, but for individual projects it has serious financial implications.

Moreover, the actual loss due to water shortage is likely to be more than these figures indicate. This is because of two reasons.

One, a number of upcoming, or almost ready-to-commission plants are also likely to be affected by water shortages. The reason is that they are in close vicinity to plants already affected, or their water sources are stressed. For example, NTPC’s 2400 MW Kudgi TPP in Karnataka was expected to commission its first unit by March 2016. But since it is in the water scarcity hit Krishna basin, and is to get water from the Krishna River / Almatti dam – where shortage of water has already affected the Raichur TPP – the commissioning is at the risk of being delayed due to water scarcity.

Similarly, in the case of NTPC’s 1320 MW TPP in Solapur, Maharashtra, the commissioning of the first unit has been deferred to March 2017 as against May 2016 planned earlier. While the official reason is the delay in plant construction, water is also a serious issue. The project, located in a drought prone area, has been promised water from the Ujani dam on Bhima river in the Krishna basin. This year, the storage in the dam has been practically zero.

The state government has now suggested to NTPC that instead of taking fresh water from the dam it should take the treated sewage from Solapur municipal corporation. This suggestion is not only for this year, but as a permanent arrangement. NTPC claims that this arrangement is not viable as it would be costly and the quality of treated water would not be suitable for its needs. Thus, the commissioning – and operation - of this almost ready plant is now at risk of significant delays and uncertainties. There are several other such cases.

The second reason for likely under-estimation of loss of electricity generation due to water shortage is that in many cases, the TPP does not shut down, but generates much less than its capacity. CEA data gives, for each day, the “Programmed Generation” (generation planned for that day) as well as Actual Generation. It is seen that often, the “Programmed Generation” is much lesser than the maximum possible generation. The unit operates at part load/part capacity. The reasons for this are often not given. We suspect that in several cases, the programmed generation may have been cut back as there is not enough water to sustain full (maximum possible) generation.

The loss in generation this year has already been much higher than previous years. According to CEA’s report on Performance Review of Thermal Power Stations 2011-12, there were 17 outages with loss of 3901.03 MU in year 2010-11 and 10 outages with loss of 725.03 MU in year 2011-12 due to water shortage problem.

Long Term Problems

While the problem seems to be related to the deficit rainfall in a particular year, it is a manifestation of a more fundamental issue of locating water guzzling power plants in drought prone areas, and that too in clusters. For example, while the Raichur TPP in Karnataka has suffered from shut down due to water shortage this year, there are at least three other power plants coming up in its close vicinity – the 1600 MW Yermarus TPP, the 800 MW Edlapur TPP and the 420 MW Vadlur (Captive) TPP.

Another example is the Singrauli region on the border of Uttar Pradesh (UP) and Madhya Pradesh(MP). A large number of TPPs are located in this area. Most of them draw their water from the Rihand reservoir. Data from Central Water Commission shows that in the last ten years, the average storage in Rihand at the end of monsoon has been just 47% (of its live storage).

Locating large number of power plants in such areas of water stress creates the risk of conflicts between the other users of water like domestic users and agriculture, and power generation.

Unfortunately, the siting policy for thermal power plants does not even consider the factor of water stress. Indeed, the siting policy is a very limited and out-dated document.

The siting policy for thermal power plants, obtained by this author under the Right to Information Act, is a 1987 document, and consists just one page in a 10 page document published by the Ministry of Environment and Forests (MoEF), titled “Environmental Guidelines for Thermal Power Plants”. Indeed, the MoEF has failed to update this policy in spite of an explicit direction by the National Green Tribunal dated 23 March 2012 in the Sompeta TPP case.

One important development in this regard is that the Union Ministry of Power (MoP) has taken cognisance of this issue, and has increased efforts requiring TPPs to use treated sewage where possible in place of fresh water. This move is welcome, but it should be taken up with caution and only after proper assessment of the risks involved. This is because sewage is not a “waste”.

In most cases, water is allocated to towns and cities with an expectation that the return flows – which can be as high as 80% in case of water for domestic use – shall augment the river flow downstream of the city. The return flows, which should consist of treated sewage, but in most cases is untreated sewage, are important source of water for downstream areas. Moreover, they are also used for irrigation purposes. Thus, diversion of sewage to TPPs should not be undertaken without a proper basin or sub-basin level assessment.

Conclusion

Ultimately, whether TPPs use sewage or any other water, they remain large users of water. Hence, the location of such plants in water scarce areas should be avoided. Planning of such plants should be preceded by a carrying capacity study, particularly in areas where a number of TPPs are planned. However, in the long run, the most optimal solution would be to replace coal fired plants with more benign sources of energy, like solar, which would not only save water but would also be greatly beneficial from the point of other adverse environmental impacts.

Shripad Dharmadhikary06 June 2016

Shripad Dharmadhikary coordinates the Manthan Adhyayan Kendra, a centre set up to research, analyse and monitor water and energy issues.

Kathy Miles
Is there any additional information on TPPs available? I have seen some case study at http://hireessaywriter.org , but I can not find it know. Will be very glad to receive some information.

rainahuang
Running Shoe Fit Tips
Foot size: Shoe lasts (which determine shoe sizes) vary by manufacturer and even from one www.mkpee.com shoes shoe model to another. http://www.lightupshoe.sale. You may need a half-size or even a full size smaller or larger than you think. If you're unsure, have http://www.nikemax.shoes your feet measured. http://www.nikeyeah.com. Try on shoes at the end of the day. Your feet normally swell a bit during the day's activities and http://www.mkpee.com will be at their largest then. This helps you avoid buying that are too small. http://www.nikeshoesales.com. Aim for a thumbnail's length of extra space in the toebox. The width should be snug but allow a bit of room for your foot to move without rubbing. Laces should be snug but not tight. Barefoot shoes are an exception: Heel and toes should “fit like a glove”without any extra http://www.shoesmaxs.com space in the toes.

August 21 2017, 6:45 AM ·
0 ·
0

aliyazou
'Fear' is just a process My ear blowing through the biting wind, the heart could not help but rise a feeling: that is afraid. Dark night, a long field on the road I ride alone [url=http://www.nikedelicacy.com/]Authentic Nike Shoes[/url] crazy walk on the way home, my heart again and again to tell myself not afraid! But when I passed a cemetery, my heart could not help speed up the speed of jumping, eyes from time to time [url=http://www.nikeneo.com/free-run-c-1.html]Free Run Shoes[/url] to look at the cemetery to see two eyes, my mind suddenly emerge all the ghost stories I have seen. I am afraid of 'ghosts possessed', my heart and told myself that is just a superstition. But I could not help but speed up the speed of cycling, really want to immediately home! But the road or need to step by step, and now feel this road is so long, as if not the end of the road. My surface is calm, but the heart is afraid! Finally saw the dawn of victory, my heart relaxed a little. When the light reaches the place, the heart is full of joy. In fact, there are a lot of life we ​​did not dare to try the first time, but you do not try, you can not get the kind of heart from the heart of joy, you can never win another of their own. Some people may say: I failed, how to do? I am afraid of failure, so I do not challenge I can not do things. If you think so wrong, the world is not only a successful life, there is no only a lifetime of failure. People always have setbacks in life, you face you did not do things, you retreat, that you are very weak! If you choose to challenge, to overcome, even if you fail, you will feel confident. Because you did it, failed to sum up experience from scratch! As the lyrics said, 'do not experience the wind and rain, how can we see the rainbow, no one can casually succeed.' In my opinion is afraid of just an excuse in life, overcome the fear of just need a process, the length of the process is [url=http://www.nikeneo.com/nike-dunk-sb-mens-shoes-c-174_175.html]Nike Mens Shoes Cheap Online[/url] the need for your own definition. There are many celebrities in ancient and modern, they are not born is a successful person. Their success is the need to step by step down to earth, they are afraid, but also failed. But they are afraid of the front and did not retreat, but to overcome! People see is always their brilliant life, people will never see the brilliant life behind. We can put [url=http://www.nikedelicacy.com/index.php?main_page=index&cPath=13]Nike Free Run Womens[/url] in the first time in the fear, [url=http://www.nikezoom.shoes/womens-air-max-c-390/]Womens Air Max[/url] as another life in their own. You can not let the cowardly oneself live in the world at the same time, so that you will provoke ridicule and irony, so you are going to destroy that cowardly oneself. This process is a step towards your success. All in all, fear is just a process, the length of the process just need you slowly to consider their own. The process may be full of excitement, failure, etc., but I hope that every friend must go to challenge the process, always remember 'do not experience the rain and rain can see the rainbow.'﻿'Bird's Nest' chief electrician [url=http://www.nikeneo.com/]Cheap Nike Shoes For Women[/url] In March 2009, a film called 'Rainstorms' was shot in the 'Bird's Nest' boot film, the film is the 'Bird's Nest' contact builders - Tan Shuangjian's struggle for the prototype. The play, Tan Shuangjian also starred. In 1980, Tan Shuangjian was born in Hebei, an ordinary farmhouse. In order to reduce the pressure of their parents, so that my brother, sister peace of mind to [url=http://www.nikezoom.shoes/]Cheap Nike Shoes Sale[/url] school, the first did not finish, he will tear down the textbooks, picked up the hoe. 16 years old, Tan Shuangjue regardless of family dissuasion, alone boarded the train to Shanghai. He does not light every day from the bridge hole 'get up', began to find a job. Three days later, Tan Shuangjian trot all the way to an electronics factory. Row for a few hours after the team, and finally turn to his interview, 'education?' 'Over a junior year.' The other side of his white one: 'finished junior high school again!' Tan Shuangjian immediately pushed back by the people The. He also found a number of factory interviews, because the education was blocked in the door. Finally, Tan Shuangjian in the terminal to find a carry a large bag of work. A shoulder is nearly a hundred pounds, less than two days after the neck will be grinding up the blood bubble, rejection of the arm like a dislocated like. Adhere to more than two months, led by more than 200 yuan wages, Tan Shuangqiu resigned back home Unyielding Tan Shuangjian decided to go outside to break into a break, he came to Beijing, and exactly the same in Shanghai, after a series of running for more than ten days did not find a job. Just use the body with only five cents by bus to the suburbs to find a job, Tan Shuangjian through the windows to see the roadside there are several buildings under construction, and quickly get off. Contractors look at the fellow in the fellow, leaving him at the site to do small work Once in the top floor work, Tan Shuangjian noted that several electricians are on the roof to install a thick 'antenna pole', very curious. The workers told him: 'This is called lightning rod, the city every building has.' He secretly try to figure out: If you can master a little technology, at least than when the future work ah! Tan Shuangjian began to consciously pay attention to this door 'technical content' of the work. Sometimes the

August 21 2017, 12:08 PM ·
0 ·
0

LILLIAN
A dream is to a man what wings are to a bird. With a dream in the deep heart's core http://www.mkfact.com, a man is spontaneously driven to hitch his wagon to a star. A dream is an inexhaustible source of energy that keeps our enthusiasm burning, and kindles our desire to enhance our spiritual cultivationhttp://www.mkzho.com, refine our character, and upgrade our quality of life. A life without a dream is like a bird with broken wings, confined to a cage and oblivious of what lies beyond the range of its vision. On the contrary, a man with a dream is like a warrior armed with ambition, foresight and gallantry, daring to step into an unknown domain to make a journey of adventure. It is dream that adds fullness, variety, and spice to our life and makes it worth living.I have a dream. It is a dream that is deeply rooted in human nature. http://www.shoesmaxs.com/ I dream that one day people of all origins can live in harmony and peace without being discriminated against or persecuted. The bounty of the earth can be shared by every single human being http://www.nikeshoesales.com/. Mutual respect will guarantee the existence and continuation of the diversity of customs and cultures. Love, sympathyhttp://www.mkpee.com, and cooperation will alleviate the sufferings and disasters inflicted upon our fellow men.http://www.nikeyeah.com/ Respect for basic human rights will put an end to social injustices and evilshttp://www.lightupshoe.sale/. When my dream comes true, all men will be truly equal and happy.Sun always rises in the place where there has a dream; moon always becomes more beatiful where there has a dream http://www.mkpee.com. Dream is a forever smile, something we should go in for in our lives http://www.nikemax.shoes, something that will make your soul pure.

August 22 2017, 1:26 PM ·
0 ·
0

evaheseo
But they can only have meager pay, and the daily fantasy has become their own upward momentum, but they never forget to change their own. Over time, fantasy has become their greatest comfort, year, two years, to the end, always return to the original, the only change that only the passing of youth. (6) to adapt to all your things that have not been adapted.Along the way, only to find that I have been accepting.hings they do not like. No way, then to adapt to those things you do not adapt it And try to do it like it. In this world, no one is born aristocrat. Even if you are born is the prince, is the daughter, but how is this? It is not yours that is attached to you, and maybe one day they will be [url=http://www.nikeneo.com/nike-air-jordans-mens-shoes-c-44_45.html]Mens Nike Shoes Sale[/url] away from you. A child, parents asked us, send you to school to read and write, okay? You say good You think the school is very fun, the school has so much and your age almost the same person. So happily agreed. After a while, you think there is always a teacher in the binding of your freedom. You ran home, followed by Mom and Dad said, I do not go to school. Did they ask you not to go? You are not fun. In the father without any reason the curse, you still obediently went to school, this stay is more than ten years. Grow up, to adapt to the school's pace of life, lifestyle, you have to go to another adult space, society. When you fantasize into this space, you think it's free to be free. But looking around the people are busy looking for work, make money, you stupid. It was not all that we had fantasy, [url=http://www.nikeneo.com/nike-football-boots-c-186.html]Wholesale Nike Football Boots[/url] and when you were scolded by a leader, you still had a low salary to live an ordinary day. You start the epiphany, the original home is better than the school, the school is [url=http://www.nikeneo.com/]Cheap Nike Shoes For Men[/url] better than the social, childhood better than adult. And why, when we experience, always feel that it is so unremitting. In fact, early to adapt to those of you do not adapt to things, always good. (Seven) feelings, do not need to deliberately When a person boredom, will be from the Hingmen through the Xiangjiang River Bridge, has been walking to the Hexi University City, and then from the University City walk Fairview Xiaoxiang. Maybe others do not understand, good car ride, why do you want to abuse yourself. In fact, sometimes life is a heart with their own constantly [url=http://www.nikezoom.shoes/]Cheap Nike Shoes Sale[/url] competing with the process. Perhaps to a certain age, some do not understand things, naturally understand; some do not want to accept the facts, but also slowly began to accept; some too late to consider things, do not need to consider. In fact, choose to go with the flow, more than anything more reliable. The strength of time is that the earth is running, so your mind is always walking along with time. Love, with the age of the longer, more and more that can not believe, into a semi-doubt state. And become more and more believe that family, the total feeling of love than love to go long.

August 23 2017, 12:05 PM ·
0 ·
0

evaheseo
The world has never ill-treated every effort A few years ago, standing in front of a famous school, his girlfriend denounced Kaoyao's brother: all people mistakenly think that this is the beginning of the dream, I want to tell you, here is the dream [url=http://www.nikerell.com/index.php?main_page=index&cPath=35_59]Air Jordan 8[/url] of broken place. Said that she was too pessimistic, his girlfriend blame him unrealistic. So she turned and left, and did [url=http://www.nikedelicacy.com/]Authentic Nike Shoes[/url] not even say goodbye to him. For a long time, the brother is waking up every day and sleep will hold her photos. The most uncomfortable time, he went to the snow, swallowed a few cold snow, wrote in the snow: I \u0026 rsquo; m coming, coming, coming until the fingers were frozen unconscious. Since then, when the odds of pity, all the time on weekdays properly, and then squeeze out some time to charge. I remember that summer we travel together to train, take the plane, while the brother is reading; see the customer, he went to accompany friends to play; the streets of the night, we are exhausted, he is still happily visiting the bookstore; back to the hotel, we Fell asleep, and only his bedside lamp was still on, and the bite of that string of strange Italian, before that, he had learned Japanese and French. In the end, the brother was admitted to the famous school of the lotus read, in the celebration of the party, is still low-key brother, is still obsessed with the former girlfriend, mistakenly thought she was injured outside will come back. We have this feeling of his already no interest, it touches on the past few years, the brother gradually turned into a charming man, like Superman. In the past few years, he will get up at 4:30 every day to read, adhere to the night run, in the passage of time, suddenly from a two hundred pounds of fat thin to the value of the explosion table, from a lattice between the [url=http://www.nikezoom.shoes/]Cheap Nike Shoes Sale[/url] glasses men read To the male Bo. When he was sad, look at the vast and distant galaxy, imagine that he is just a dust, that sad thing will be instantly naught; the same time, Be afraid of ridden, listen to quantum mechanics, the original body of each cell contains strength, you can listen to the idea of ??the command, did not make things, mostly because there is no continuous force In short, every chaos, he Can quickly straighten out, I have always felt that the rare Superman, standing on our future, thinking rationality, rhetoric, can be directed to anyone, so that the people around the five body cast.

September 08 2017, 6:32 AM ·
0 ·
0

evaheseo
Forever love, Chang Huaihan read. Get rid of loneliness, make ends meet. Contentment and joy. Tolerant lonely, bitter to sweet. Greedy not mind, wide face no change. Cold place [url=http://www.nikerell.com/index.php?main_page=index&cPath=35_58]Air Jordan 7[/url] enthusiastic, timely help. The beauty of adults, the difficulties of people Generous, selfless dedication. Help others, and people are good. Do not read the old evil, to Germany complain. By grace and forget, Shi Hui Mo read. Do not complain, nagging when the reduction. Zhimei encouragement, words about far. Honest and trustworthy, not to mention lies. Prudent doubt, avoid slander. Debate white slander, generous attempts to speak. Get rid of jealousy, do not sing rumors. Do not sulking, bogey gossip. Seek truth from facts and punish the lies. Words must line, Min [url=http://www.nikedelicacy.com/index.php?main_page=index&cPath=121]Nike Air Max 90 Hyperfuse Mens[/url] line words. When you must say, not yet empty talk. Loyal to duty, [url=http://www.nikezoom.shoes/]Cheap Nike Shoes Sale[/url] hard work. Jump out of self, hard working. Hold Park Shouzhuo, diligent study hard practice. Mu body bath Germany, go forward. Attack must be grams, heart to wear stone. Take precautions and think about it. Adhere to the principle of temporary response.

September 13 2017, 2:38 PM ·
0 ·
0

evaheseo
See my dear as her salary is high, he is also very happy, [url=http://www.nikedelicacy.com/]Authentic Nike Shoes[/url] my heart often think, their efforts ah, my dear wife's wages are higher than you friends. Usually do not have to go, as long as the need to consult him on the line, a month to give him a thousand dollars, if any big things encountered, the other money count. In this way, his monthly salary, plus the money to do the legal adviser, there are [url=http://www.nikezoom.shoes/air-max-2014-c-387_412]Air Max 2014[/url] usually published articles of money, almost a month can earn six or seven thousand of the bar. So in front of his wife, it will not be too shame.See my dear as her salary is high, he is also very happy, [url=http://www.nikedelicacy.com/]Authentic Nike Shoes[/url] my heart often think, their efforts ah, my dear wife's wages are higher than you friends. Usually work, she did not have other hobbies, is like shopping, but because of the reasons for the work, too tired, often can not go. So she often on the Internet, and online to buy a lot of very cheap things. Usually he wore clothes, shoes, what is her online Amoy, and her own favorite clothes, jewelry or something, are also bought online. Recently she was playing the idea, want to get something to buy what. Tell her business people, is to do clothing business. In this way, his monthly salary, plus the money to do the legal adviser, there are [url=http://www.nikezoom.shoes/air-max-2014-c-387_412]Air Max 2014[/url] usually published articles of money, almost a month can earn six or seven thousand of the bar. So in front of his wife, it will not be too shame.Yes, life [url=http://www.nikedelicacy.com/]Authentic Nike Shoes Sale[/url] has its own wonderful, when the disadvantage has been unable to change, you have to change a point of view, for a living law.There are countless examples of reality:Seems to be the weak of life, in the hardships of life, college entrance examination fell, employment was rejected, everywhere after a series of failures, and finally another way to become a strong [url=http://www.nikerell.com/]Nike Air Max Shoes Sale[/url] life, access to the success of life, blooming life beautiful.Yes, [url=http://www.nikezoom.shoes/]Air Max Shoes on Sale[/url] the road of life a lot, when the front of the road can not go, you have to understand the fork, for a point of view, for a living law.Years of flies, 'life is not perfect is normal, and the perfect is very state', in the face of setbacks, as long as another point of view to think, to observe, you [url=http://www.nikedelicacy.com/index.php?main_page=index&cPath=120]Nike Air Max 89 Mens[/url] will find that life is not usually feel so romantic

September 19 2017, 11:12 AM ·
0 ·
0

India Together offers an excellent forum for people from diverse fields of expertise to present their views, share their experiences and raise questions about where our country and society are headed in the future.

Amitabha Basu

Retired Scientist

National Physical

Laboratory

India Together reader

India Together offers an excellent forum for people from diverse fields of expertise to present their views, share their experiences and raise questions about where our country and society are headed in the future.

I urge all democratic-minded individuals to road, contribute to and publicise the e-newsletters from India Together. All power and success to India Together staff for their excellent and vital contribution to our society!