This restaurant's overall star value is determined by comparing its ratings against
those of other restaurants in the same city.

A teacher might call this grading on a curve. At Seamless, this means that regardless
of their actual tally, restaurants with the highest ratings will have five stars,
those with average ratings will have three, and the not-so-favorite restaurants
will have the least number of stars.

So pay it forward to the Seamless community. Rate and review places you've tried
so we can all find food happiness!

Please check back for future deals.

Reviews for Carroll Gardens Classic Diner

based on 68 ratings

Avoid at all costs. Order was wrong. Charged extra $2 for a large orange juice and delivered a small. Lied about the OJ being fresh squeezed when it's obviously from a can. Dry pancakes and toast and stale bagel. The "chocolate chip" pancakes had about 25 chips in 3 dry pancakes.
A total ripoff for horrible food.

Written by
Jason M.
on
12/14/2014
|
1 other review |
Member since
2007
Jason
ordered from here
within the last year

overpriced, low quality food. rude customer service. almost always get the order wrong or forget something. five stars all tha way

Written by
drew v.
on
9/8/2014
|
22 other reviews |
Member since
2011
drew
ordered from here
within the last year

They have mixed in the dressing on my salad twice, even tho I expressly indicated for them not to. When I called to complain, the manager eventually helped and sent a new salad over, but the guy who answered the phone gave me lots of attitude, said I entered the wrong thing (I didn't), and then told me that "the dressing is always mixed in" (obviously untrue). The salad is soggy and in edible if dressing mixed in. Food is good, but be careful with your salad directions and check your food before the delivery guy leaves.

Written by
Joanne W.
on
8/20/2014
|
3 other reviews |
Member since
2011
Joanne
ordered from here
within the last year

average food. delivers late night. good delivery times

Written by
Verna S.
on
7/22/2014
|
38 other reviews |
Member since
2010
Verna
ordered from here
within the last week

Quick and friendly delivery service

Written by
Bran M.
on
6/25/2014
|
Member since
2014
Bran
ordered from here
within the last year

A two leaf 'side salad' and a breakfast platter with no syrup for french toast--get real Carroll Gardens Classic Diner.

Written by
matt h.
on
2/9/2014
|
3 other reviews |
Member since
2013
matt
ordered from here
over a year ago

People,reviewing this place negatively are doing so solely on price... I get my orders within 20 minutes, always hot/fresh, & never any mistakes. The food is good diner food, I'm from NJ - diner capital of the world. You see the prices before you order, you don't want to pay, don't order.
I'd highly recommend for breakfast or sandwiches...

Written by
Matt L.
on
1/26/2014
|
5 other reviews |
Member since
2011
Matt
ordered from here
within the last year

Terrible customer service and slow deliver. Unwilling to work with their clients. Food it ok but not worth dealing with the people. Go to another diner.

Written by
Jessica F.
on
1/5/2014
|
Member since
2010
Jessica
ordered from here
within the last month

Food is decent but it WAY Overpriced. Bistro Prices for decent Diner food.

Written by
jason b.
on
10/18/2013
|
8 other reviews |
Member since
2012
jason
ordered from here
within the last month

Order the chicken fingers - they are awesome. No comment on the rest of the menu.

Written by
Meghan K.
on
8/4/2013
|
3 other reviews |
Member since
2009
Meghan
ordered from here
within the last month

I've never written a review on seamless until now - This is the worst restaurant in the neighborhood. Occasionally I will come home drunk and make the mistake of ordering from here...Unbelievably expensive for the crap quality. The only reason why this place is still open is because it's one of the only places open late at night. People who say it's "standard diner food" must have terrible taste in food or be stoned out of their mind. A disgrace.

Written by
Rene G.
on
7/27/2013
|
2 other reviews |
Member since
2011
Rene
ordered from here
over a year ago

I have been ordering from this diner for the past 10 years. NOT ANYMORE. It's not the food, but the horrible customer service and even worse attitude. I ordered the Meatloaf Meal which says it comes with Potatoes, Vegetable AND Soup or Salad. When my meal arrived it was missing the potatoes. So I called to inform the diner. The guy who answered the phone said I didn't ask for the potatoes. I explained that the meal comes with potatoes and there was no where in the ordering process where it asks me. He basically said sorry because you didn't specify you didn't get them. He refused to re-deliver. Very bad customer service in my opinion.

Written by
Anthony P.
on
1/17/2013
|
Member since
2011
Anthony
ordered from here
over a year ago

Yes, they are outrageously overpriced, but they're the best 24-hour diner in my delivery area --- and delivery is always fast with no problems. Food quality is solid and consistent.

Written by
Stephanie B.
on
12/17/2012
|
34 other reviews |
Member since
2006
Stephanie
ordered from here
within the last week

this food is consistently the worst in the neighborhood, and the prices are higher than fine restaurants in Manhattan; all for poorly portioned and poor quality diner food.

Written by
Scott E.
on
12/27/2011
|
1 other review |
Member since
2007
Scott
ordered from here
over a year ago

Standard diner food? Always arrives fast and hot

Written by
salih a.
on
12/16/2011
|
10 other reviews |
Member since
2011
salih
ordered from here
over a year ago