Towards an Environmental Architecture

Apichapong Weerasethakul, Uncle Bonmee Who Can Recall His Past Lives, film still, 2010.

Global environmental change poses two immediate challenges to architecture: the first is how to respond to its myriad consequences, from rapid transformations in land-use to food scarcity or population displacements; the second is how to re-assess the legal, ethical and political limits of architecture’s responsibilities, as—from an environmental perspective—these cannot be confined to the limits of the building. All around the world several inroads are being made to address these issues, from adopting sustainable building practices to incorporating concerns with materials’ embodied energy and CO2 emissions. And yet, the multi-scalar complexity and intricate chains of causality that characterize environmental issues, not to mention the different ways in which these affect architecture, requires moving beyond piecemeal responses to a more systematic approach. It implies the development of a new field, concerned with re-imagining architecture as a practice that has the environment as its object of concern.

Architecture has always been an environmental agent

At stake in environmental architecture should not be how to design a sustainable building but the ways in which design participates in processes of environmental transformation. The 1960 design of the British Petroleum headquarters in Lagos by international development architects Maxwell Fry & Jane Drew is a perfect example of “tropical architecture” with its use of brise-soleils and its bioclimatic concern with local conditions, including humidity levels, wind direction, and solar orientation. But this building also gave form to the administration of wide ranging environmental destruction. At that particular time and in the decades that followed, Shell British Petroleum was one of the key players in the oil contamination of the Niger Delta. Between 1958 and 2010, oil industries spilled between nine and thirteen million barrels of oil into the Delta ecosystem. The BP headquarters were not a distant relation but a central part of oil’s extractive architecture. They were necessary in managing the circulation of commodities from Nigeria to the US and Europe and housed what was mostly a white labor force. To say that architecture is an environmental agent doesn’t simply apply to its direct material consequences (the disruption of water tables or deforestation that are typically associated with exploitative forms of urbanization, for instance). It concerns its participation in broader environmental assemblages as well. To the frequently wavered claim that architects are responsible to the building only, such willful refusal to answer for architectures’ broader consequences is at best a cynical position, and at worst a contribution to ecocide. If to this we add the common practice of playing along in providing “sustainable” and “ecological” images for greedy corporations, we start to realize the extent to which environmental neglect has characterized architectural practices.

Environmental violence is molecular

We are not all in this together. Some environments are changing faster than others: in the US for instance, African American, Latino, and Native American communities have been disproportionately affected by the decision to locate polluting industries or toxic waste treatment stations in their vicinity.1 What distinguishes environmental violence is how it is often invisible, slow, remote and indirect—in other words, molecular. Contaminants such as mercury and arsenic left behind by mining, or pesticides used in the maintenance of plantation monocultures, slowly transform environments, and in doing so, often reinforce racial or colonial forms of violence (of course, colonialism was always an environmental project).2 Globally, areas of resource extraction tend to map out according to racial lines, whereby it is the minorities, the wretched, which suffer most from the molecular effects of capitalism: be it directly from oil spills, water contaminations or air pollutants, or indirectly via the transformations these impose to modes of coexistence.3 It is in great part because environmental violence is often imperceptible that such forms of violence can continue to take place. But when resistance emerges, environmental violence can become direct and visible. Indigenous peoples are particularly at risk: according to Global Witness in 2016 alone 201 environmental activists were killed across the world, most of whom from indigenous groups.4 Women are at the forefront of environmental struggles: initiatives like Womin, Not1More, or COPINH (founded by Berta Cáceres) have been key to highlight gender discrimination and violence in environmental disputes.5 In the context of today’s environmental transformations, more urgent than designing sustainable futures for a future climate change is recognizing how, for most people, the current situation is already unsustainable.

Environments are relations of coexistence

But what are environments? Often confused with habitats, ecosystems, or ecologies, an environment is a medium or milieu. Medium here should be understood not as an entity per se but as a consistency formed by relations of coexistence. A lake is an environment, but not as a geographical entity. For an environment to exist the formation of a stable space or consistency is required: in this case a stable (but not static) relation between water, geological strata, climate, fish, algae, etc. Environments are the consistency generated by modes of coexistence between living and non-living bodies. They are consistent relations between bodies, but their demarcation is not necessarily a line, a border, or a date. Instead, they are existentially demarcated. The limit of one environment is the end of a mode of coexistence. A forest, for instance, is a very peculiar mode of coexistence that, as Eduardo Kohn has shown, is maintained by a broad range of communicational processes (biosemiotics) without which it could not persist.6 Environments are always collective, always in composition with other environments, always dynamically affecting and being affected by the bodies that produce them. In other words, environments are the product of relations of coexistence, among living and non-living entities.7 Coexistence is not only molecular but also semiotic: by this I am referring not only to the signifying semiotics of language and symbols, or more broadly to the semiotics of icons and indexes, but to all other forms of a-signifying semiotics that, like molecular relations, are at stake in environmental relationships, such as those between bacteria, trees, and stones. It is molecular and semiotic relations that should be the object of environmental architecture, with the caveat, of course, being that humans are not the only environmentalists around. Animals and plants, fungus and bacteria, all these participate in the production and transformation of environments.

Environments represent themselves

While so much contemporary work about climate change and the Anthropocene focuses on how to represent or visualize changing Earth systems, it is often left to the side that the world is already a sensorium of environmental transformations; a sensorium of changes in modes of coexistence. This is evident in how black snow expresses pollution in the Artic, and how the increase of mental health disorders in urban contexts expresses the precarization of labor relations. We require a different attention to the world’s capacity to represent itself.8 This is where techno-science enters: the molecular nature of environmental change has been pushing a different sensibility to material properties, acoustics, and chemicals, as much as it has to the technologies that allow us to capture them, from climatic simulations to remote-sensing technologies, reflection seismology tools, big data analysis, and material and archival sampling practices. All this has been key to feed the discussion of new problems and the constitution of new politics. However, an engagement with techno-sciences can only be emancipatory if these are seen as practices, as modes of existing in the world, and not as expert representations detached from a world out-there; if they are seen as part of concrete environmental assemblages, instead of devices to eliminate the legitimacy of other modes of expression or existence.9 A renewed environmental aesthetics should be a project in polyphony insofar as representing is always an intervention into environments, a practice that takes place within pre-existing semiotic relations of coexistence. This was the case of Ken Saro-Wiwa’s writing of poetry as his way to intervene (in a non-pacific way) in the destruction of Ogonilands’ environments by Shell Oil. The fact that environments represent themselves indicates that the challenge for environmental architecture is not so much the aesthetics of how to best represent or visualize, but how to practice environmental transformation as an aesthetics.

Thinking the future otherwise

The polyphonic dimension of an environmental aesthetics requires the opening of ways to practice the future otherwise. The key point is to not see futures as predictions; the future is not a bet, but the dismantling of power-relations that are presented as certain or eternal. In this sense, the future is something that is practiced, in the way that Afrofuturism practiced in writing and in music a future where whiteness and patriarchy did not own the exclusive rights to science and fiction. What follows is that it is not only the future that has to be disputed, but our relation with time. For the Atacamenos indigenous to Chile, for instance, it is the past that lies in front of us, as that which we can see, while the future is invisible and as such behind us. How, then, does one accelerate towards the future while walking backwards? This promethean premise becomes unraveled by one of those other futures that have been around for a long time, and that despite colonial or racial projects’ best wishes, is not a thing of the past. Three key aspects are worth highlighting in contemporary conversations about the future: discovering how sites of technological mutation can become sites of environmental and subjective re-invention; considering the rights of those that cannot bear responsibilities such as “nature” and future generations; and expanding the structures of thought upon which the idea itself of a future is built upon.10 To re-imagine what might be architectures of coexistence, we should strive to practice futures that are based on dignity and justice. For this we could start by learning from Ursula Le Guin’s eco-feminism and her imaginations of care as a guiding principle of inhabiting the Earth, or from the environmental speculations of Afrofuturism, from Sun-Ra to Octavia Butler.11

Environmental monocultures are a project in subjectivity

Monoculture is commonly associated with imperial expansion and its conversion of biodiverse areas of land into singe-species plantation—as a matter of soils, waters and chemicals; of patents, Monsanto herbicides, and industrial farming techniques; a matter of losing plant, animal, and insect species; of exploiting, drying, erasing, and plundering the Earth. But monocultures are first and foremost a problem of subjectivity, that manifests in two key ways: in the erasure of alternative modes of living and production—for instance, in the dismissal of subsistence agriculture by industrialized agriculture and agribusinesses as reactionary or primitive—and in capitalism’s endless production of commoditized lifestyles—each with its own app, dress code, specialized shop or film and music culture. As Guattari said, “Capitalism launches (subjective) models the way the automobile industry launches a new line of cars.”12 Which is also to say that capitalism requires the bringing together of the material/energetic economy and the subjective one. This is evident in the coupling of new forms of precarious labor with the promotion of “socially liberated” and flexible work/life relations, or in the global promotion of real estate developments with lush tropical imagery as an index of “green” and “sustainable” living. Despite their diversity, capitalist models of subjectivity are all anchored in the same principle of valorization (profit), and in the same mode of relating to and conceiving of nature (extraction). Monocultures are as much a matter of soya as they are of desire. Be it in hinterlands or urban centers, monoculture is a project with both material and subjective dimensions.

Militancy can only be from the middle

To think the future otherwise is not to refuse architecture’s long tradition of vanguard thinking, but to acknowledge that its ability to recognize and engage concrete struggles has been very limited. It is also to recognize that architecture has historically been privileged, colonial, and male, existing comfortably within structures of domination and control. The consequences of climate and environmental change are surely an incentive for the transformation of the practice. But before attempting to yet again conquer the space of the vanguard, environmental architecture can only emerge from engaging the multiplicity of projects of future that are already being practiced around the world: from Chiapas and Rojava to Marinaleda, or Alto Comedero;13 from Barcelona en Comu’s experiment in radical democracy, to ECSA’s development of post-blockchain technologies or the Yasuní ITT initiative in Ecuador.14 The list could go on. These are not ideal models, but often-precarious projects of emancipation that could do with being supported and expanded upon. Architecture can have an important role in these processes, from the design of collective equipment or infrastructure to spatial research in the form of reports and the deployment of analytical and representational tools to support environmental claims in legal forums. This leads to a form of practice that can only be characterized as militant: intervening from within social movements and popular organizations, NGOs, or governmental institutions. It is a matter of moving from the position of providing services to that of critically supporting ongoing processes of social transformation, be it at the scale of small communities of international alliances. Expanding epistemic, economic, legal, or democratic cannons has to take center stage: if environmental architecture is to engage with the future, it should start from the middle of the futures that already exist.

From modes of living to modes of coexistence

If the way architecture conceives of the environment remains limited to its current form—something out there that surrounds us—architects and designers will remain unable (or unwilling) to address environmental relations that are in cities as much as in forests. Recognizing how environments consist of semiotic and molecular processes of coexistence between all kinds of bodies aims to address this issue. It implies, for instance, that architecture affects and is affected by the world in far more complex ways than usually assumed. In fact, architectural history is immensely rich in environmental concepts, from the quanat to the roman aqueduct, the nineteenth century greenhouse, or the air-conditioned interiors of post-war US. By organizing customs, habits, rituals, and protocols of being in the world, all these architectures gave form to very different socio-environmental ecologies. This is, after all, what architecture has always done best: to provide consistency to modes of living through the design of infrastructure and collective equipment.15 And yet, the radical challenge for environmental architecture is not simply that of providing consistency to human modes of living, but to modes of coexisting. By coexistence I mean the possibility of an architecture that has care instead of domestication as the driver for being with and among others. Who or what these “others” are will vary from case to case. Perhaps the spirits of the dead, perhaps soil, perhaps future generations.

×

Positions is an initiative of e-flux Architecture.

Godofredo Enes Pereira is the course leader for the MA in Environmental Architecture at the Royal College of Art, where he also teaches ADS7 Ecologies of Existence design studio and leads the Architecture and Social Movements Research Group.

Jencks was right when he predicted that “the iconic building is here to stay.” 1 Its generalization and expansion in the form of so-called “image architecture” has become central to the way cities are being shaped across the world. Since the early 2010s, the phenomenon of image architecture has been joined by another one essentially based around similar tenets, if often adjusted to a rhetoric of economic modesty and smaller scales: a version of postmodernism currently present in biennales,...

Nick Axel Architecture is always a product of its time. It registers the social, economic, and political conditions within which a project has come into being, not to mention the cultural, ideological, and aesthetic agendas fueling its realization. The architect, then, is like a meteorologist, with projects as their barometers. Your practice started in Spain in the early 2000s, in a period of euphoric construction. Then, the financial system underpinning it collapsed. Can you describe what...

“ El Caballo ” ( The Horse ), a seven-ton bronze equestrian statue of general Francisco Franco, was removed from Ferrol’s Plaza de España in 2002. Originally erected as a gift from the Spanish city to the dictator in 1967, the monument presided over its main public space for nearly forty-five years. It had endured demonstrations and soft vandalism, yet after being attacked with explosives, the municipal government of Xaime Bello decided to loan the statute to the army, placing it in...

Nick Axel You have done a lot of work after the 2011 Tōhoku earthquake and tsunami dealing with reconstruction. Can you speak to the type of effect this event has had on the practice of architecture in Japan?
Toyo Ito After the earthquake and the tsunami, architects were not called on by anyone in Japan. Those who were called were the engineers. So after the tsunami, we had to proactively go to the municipalities to propose something. We went and had conversations with the people who...

Nikolaus Hirsch Architecture is a schizophrenic profession. There is, on the one hand a form of practice that believes in design and building as a problem-solving practice, and on the other, there is a form of practice that finds and somehow constructs problems through research, analysis, critique. The field of architecture seems to split between those who build and those who research and question its relevance in a broader social-political sphere. You are one of the few who seem to bridge...

Nikolaus Hirsch Part of the architect´s profession seems to be the permanent reinvention of what it means to be an architect. A constant process of self-legitimation that keeps on changing the foundations of the practice. Some of the exhibitions you curated over the past few years have been quite instrumental in proposing an expansive idea of architectural practice. For instance, the exhibition The Other Architect , or, on questions of medicine, the exhibition Imperfect Health , or...

Nikolaus Hirsch We are interested in the contradictions and potentials of today’s architectural practice, and in speculating on what this practice might be in the future. How has your own practice and your way of thinking and working changed as an effect of the deep societal, technological, and economic changes that have taken place over the past decades?
Juan Herreros The question of what kind of architect was and is possible has been crucial in the different forms of offices I...

Nick Axel How do you see your role as an architect today?
Sou Fujimoto My role as an architect is to create space for people, space that does not control but that allows for different things to happen. Space that inspires people to behave as they like, or beyond. Architecture belongs to society, no matter how small or large. So architects have a responsibility to give shape or form to society, which will hopefully make society better and people happier.
Nikolaus Hirsch...

Nikolaus Hirsch You have a very expansive practice, ranging from design to curating, art directing, and editing. How do you understand the role of architecture and architects in this expanded field?
Ippolito Pestellini Laparelli I feel like there has been a general shift from construction to media, but I don’t have a theory for it, and I believe my case is specific to my background. I'm a product of Italian schools, which until some years ago provided a very broad education. I'm...

Nikolaus Hirsch What is design?
Paola Antonelli I am not able to answer that question. It's a little bit like asking what art is or what food is. A definition is not possible, or at least I am not able to give one. I have my own ways to distinguish design from art, for instance, but not really from engineering.
NH And from architecture?
PA Architecture is part of design. I studied architecture at the Polytechnic of Milan, and because of that I have a sort of panic...

Nikolaus Hirsch Recent projects of yours have put you in a very political role, or at least one with a certain exposure in the political field. Has your professional trajectory, from building studios, homes, and installations, very often in collaboration with artists, to much more public projects, changed how you see your role as an architect?
David Adjaye My career started under the agency or patronage of artists, at a particular moment when the group of artists that I was working...

The City is a Res Publica.
The Right to Access to most of the City will be universal.
Everyone will be able to go everywhere in the City that’s Public.
Everyone will be able to go everywhere in the City that’s private that’s open to the General Public.
Private accommodation, hospitality, commerce, and other services, prospects, events, and possibilities offered to the General Public shall be subject to a Determination of Access by the City Department of Public Access....

Imagine you are looking through a sequence of photographs. One image after another, all of empty rooms. On superficial inspection, they all look the same. And they seem to show the same thing: nothing. No furniture, no people. Just empty rooms inside empty apartments. The rooms are clean and white. They look new. The light is diffuse, northern. Even the shadows it throws are soft. In one room is a floor of polished concrete, in another, wooden parquet. Sometimes there is a window visible, a...

Thanos Zartaloudis The urban protocols started as a collection of images, designs, photographs, and sketches, which later took a new form in Archipelago of Protocols . 1 No direct explanation is, however, given in the book concerning their character, form, or manner. How could a dialogue be initiated about this peculiar textual, literary, architectural exercise, or what appears to be, at first sight, an essential difference between architectural writing and legal writing or law-making?...

Global environmental change poses two immediate challenges to architecture: the first is how to respond to its myriad consequences, from rapid transformations in land-use to food scarcity or population displacements; the second is how to re-assess the legal, ethical and political limits of architecture’s responsibilities, as—from an environmental perspective—these cannot be confined to the limits of the building. All around the world several inroads are being made to address these issues,...

Everybody knows that our cities
Were built to be destroyed
—Caetano Veloso
As the architecture profession continues to struggle in a contemporary landscape where economic and technological forces erode its agency, every Venice Biennale begins by answering a single question before making any other statement: What is architecture? This obstruction makes it difficult to find the common ground necessary to make a cohesive large-scale exhibition like the International Architecture...

Expanding the Self
On a February evening of 1969, Coop Himmelblau’s Astroballon was presented at Galerie nächst St. Stephan, an avant-garde gallery in the heart of Vienna. 1 Documentation from the opening night performance shows a spherical shell of pliable, transparent PVC plastic strung from the ceiling, wires and tubes cascading. Inside the bubble is a woman, her face calm, her arms outstretched. Small light bulbs speckled across the semi-plump skin of the sphere flicker and...

We’re Solarpunk because the only other options are denial or despair.
—Adam Flynn 1
By now, dystopia may have become a luxury genre. Indulging in miserable future scenarios is not something everyone has time for. William Gibson recently repurposed his own adage, “the future is here, it’s just not evenly distributed” to say that “dystopia is not very evenly distributed” either. 2 For most, the dystopias the privileged entertain themselves with are old news. In the current...

One or two years ago, describing Junya Ishigami’s architecture would likely conjure imagery of delicate and immaculately conceived structures tending towards invisibility. Often veiled in and populated with plant life, it was as if he sought to demarcate space with the tiniest fraction, a whisper, of manmade matter.
Yet, his new work and writing suggests that the last decade of practice and research has culminated in a new project of a different weight entirely. Ishigami’s “freeness”...

We’ll build houses like we used to, without roofs and without walls
—Vincenzo Agnetti 1
After World War II, the view of Milan from Monte Stella—the artificial hill made out of rubble from the allied bombing designed by and dedicated to the wife of Piero Bottoni—was quite sad. These were the years of the ricostruzione , the material and metaphorical reconstruction of Italy after fascism; the opportunity to hurry Italy into the future, into industrialization, into the modernity...

Computers are machines: so we tend to think they work like all the other machines we know. They don't. Computers are a new kind of machine. They do not work like any other machine we have ever seen during the modern age and the industrial revolution. Computers are post-industrial, post-modern, post-scientific machines. If we use computers to make physical stuff, computers follow a technical logic that is the opposite of that of the industrial age. And if we use computers to process...

In Ansbach, Germany, sporting goods company Adidas is opening the first fully operational version of its so-called Speedfactory concept, in which trainers and other sport shoes will be produced using the latest technology in computerized knitting, additive manufacturing, and robotics. A “digital twin” of the production chain, developed by Siemens, allows for testing and optimization in a virtual shop floor before actual implementation of new processes. Faster production, shorter supply...

For much of their history European cities have been unhealthy places. Until the end of the nineteenth century, they were traversed by waves of infection that would thrive in the close assemblage of people and livestock. Urban mortality rates were so great that sustained migration from the countryside was the only way cities could maintain their population levels stable. 1
This may seem a distant past now that “health” is understood in opposition either to aging or to diseases, such as...

In 1930, the French colonial regime celebrated the hundredth anniversary of France’s colonization of Algeria, known as Le Centenaire de l’Algérie française (Centenary of French Algeria). These colonial celebrations were held in Algiers and in other cities in Algeria under French rule (1830–1962) during the first six months of 1930, and included a number of commemorative, artistic, theatrical, and sport festivals and events. According to Gustave Mercier, French lawyer and general curator of...

“Mere decorating,” we say without thought. The former modifies the latter with such frequency that the words appear natural together. In fact, the Cambridge Dictionary gives, as an example of the usage of the adverb “merely,” the sentence: “These columns have no function and are merely decorative.” 1 A Google search for the twinned words “mere” and “decorating” turns up 1,420 results. Meanwhile, “merely decorative” has 166,000 results and “mere decoration” gets us another 155,000.
In...

Michael Bloomberg, once referred to as “America’s greenest mayor,” launched One Million Trees for New York (MTNYC) in 2007. 1 This project, initiated as the subprime mortgage crisis started to be noticed, ventured to protect citizens from the effects of air pollution and climate change. Working to add the eponymous number of trees to the city, MTNYC was considered the largest urban afforestation effort in the world. Highlighting the benefits of improved air quality, increased shading, and...

Karl Marx once observed that revolutionaries, seemingly engaged in “creating something that did not exist before,” will “anxiously conjure up the spirits of the past to their service, borrowing from them names, battle slogans, and costumes in order to present this new scene in world history in time-honored disguise and borrowed language.” 1 Written in the aftermath of France’s failed revolution of 1848, Marx goes on to note in The Eighteenth Brumaire of Louis Bonaparte that “the tradition...

In 2012, Facebook signed on its one billionth user. To celebrate the occasion, the company commissioned filmmaker Alejandro G. Iñárritu—of Amores Perros and Babel fame—to make their first-ever brand video, “to express what [their] place is on this earth.” 1 Born eight years earlier as a Harvard “hobby,” Facebook had established itself as global socio-technical infrastructure, one that was transforming the way people “get together, open up,” and “feel human,” in the words of the...

In short, when the muck comes back up onto the sidewalks, it is memory flooding back —a certain long-buried historic past that re-emerges suddenly into the present in the form of a rag, a scrap, a remnant.
—Georges Didi-Huberman 1
[W]hat do we do when questions are too big for everybody, and especially when they are much too grand for the writer, that is, for myself?
—Bruno Latour 2
This article is not about the damage of the 2017 Central Mexico earthquake, but about...

It is hard to imagine how the many ruptures that have occurred in the composition of whatever may be called "normality" today do not render canonical architectural knowledge a distant constellation, receding from our present. Nor is it difficult to see how such ruptures are themselves a stern reminder of our need for new forms of knowledge altogether—forms that reject the assurances of a professionalized architectural discourse, and that call instead for a new horizon of common,...

In the comedy of errors that is US car culture, contradictions and cross-purposes seem to thrive. The mid-twentieth century monovalent highway network replaced a finely grained rail network to conform with default modernist scripts that claim newer is better. In perennial cycles of obsolescence and replacement, new infrastructure technologies have overwritten existing networks, however intelligent or efficient they may be. Adhering to false logics of traffic engineering that linked roadway...

Athens used to be small town. In 1922, following the war the Greeks lost against Turkey, she was asked to take in a large part of the 1.2 million refugees from Asia Minor. The refugees were placed in camps outside the city, which in time grew into suburbs, all named after the places the displaced Greeks left behind: Ionia, Smyrna, and Philadelphia all used to be towns on the coast of Turkey, and in Athens, they were all New. Athens became a city of refugees, and as she struggled to deal with...

Consider the following exchange from the infamous press conference conducted by the President of the United States in the lobby of his fading, brassy New York tower on 15 August 2017, three days after the death of Heather Heyer, a peaceful counterprotestor at a “Unite the Right” rally in Charlottesville, Virginia, who was murdered, allegedly, by a Nazi sympathizer:
Reporter: Do you think that what you call the alt-left is the same as neo-Nazis?
President: All of those...

e-flux conversations is a discussion platform for e-flux readers. Click to start a discussion of the article above.

Start the Conversation

Notes - Towards an Environmental Architecture

1

See as well a recent study by Yale University with evidence of racial and economic gaps in affects from air pollution, ➝. Recently, similar motives have led Black Lives Matter UK to close down London City airport in protest.

Go to Text

2

Arturo Escobar, Encountering Development (Princeton: Princeton University Press, 1995); Eduardo Galeano, Open Veins of Latin America: Five Centuries of the Pillage of a Continent (New York: Monthly Review Press, 1997); Eyal Weizman and Fazal Sheikh. The Conflict Shoreline: Colonization As Climate Change in the Negev Desert (Steidl, 2015); Jason W. Moore, Capitalism In The Web Of Life: Ecology And The Accumulation Of Capital (London: Verso, 2015).

According to Global Witness figures of killings of environmental activists in 2016, thirty-three deaths resulted from conflicts against mining and extractivism, twenty-three against logging, twenty-three against agribusiness, eighteen against poaching, and eight related to water conflicts. ➝.

Every technology redistributes a set of affective coordinates and opens up possibilities for political re-imagination, whether this is a conflict over the resolution of remote sensors, the classification of hydrocarbons, or estimates of financial credit rating. See Godofredo Pereira, “Dead Commodities,” Cabinet 43, August 2011.

Go to Text

11

See Ursula le Guin’s short story “Sur,” first published in The New Yorker, February 1, 1982, 38. See also Octavia E. Butler, Parable of the Sower, 1993.

I'm referring to the Zapatista experiment in Chiapas, México; to the feminist self-managed Kurdish communities of Rojava in Syria; and to the self-managed Tupacamaru indigenous community of Alto Comedero, in Argentina. These are only a few, among a wide list of examples from all around the world.

Importantly, to give consistency in this sense is not simply reinforcing what exists, but also providing support in such a way that collectives can empower and transform themselves.

Go to Text

See as well a recent study by Yale University with evidence of racial and economic gaps in affects from air pollution, ➝. Recently, similar motives have led Black Lives Matter UK to close down London City airport in protest.

Arturo Escobar, Encountering Development (Princeton: Princeton University Press, 1995); Eduardo Galeano, Open Veins of Latin America: Five Centuries of the Pillage of a Continent (New York: Monthly Review Press, 1997); Eyal Weizman and Fazal Sheikh. The Conflict Shoreline: Colonization As Climate Change in the Negev Desert (Steidl, 2015); Jason W. Moore, Capitalism In The Web Of Life: Ecology And The Accumulation Of Capital (London: Verso, 2015).

According to Global Witness figures of killings of environmental activists in 2016, thirty-three deaths resulted from conflicts against mining and extractivism, twenty-three against logging, twenty-three against agribusiness, eighteen against poaching, and eight related to water conflicts. ➝.

Every technology redistributes a set of affective coordinates and opens up possibilities for political re-imagination, whether this is a conflict over the resolution of remote sensors, the classification of hydrocarbons, or estimates of financial credit rating. See Godofredo Pereira, “Dead Commodities,” Cabinet 43, August 2011.

See Ursula le Guin’s short story “Sur,” first published in The New Yorker, February 1, 1982, 38. See also Octavia E. Butler, Parable of the Sower, 1993.

I'm referring to the Zapatista experiment in Chiapas, México; to the feminist self-managed Kurdish communities of Rojava in Syria; and to the self-managed Tupacamaru indigenous community of Alto Comedero, in Argentina. These are only a few, among a wide list of examples from all around the world.

I have read e-flux’s privacy policy and agree that e-flux may send me announcements to the email address entered above and that my data will be processed for this purpose in accordance with e-flux’s privacy policy*

Next

e-flux

e-flux Architecture

art-agenda

Exhibitions at commercial galleries

Art & Education

Exhibitions, symposia and teaching positions at art schools world wide

Thank You!

Subscription pending. Your email subscription is almost complete. An email has been sent to the email address you entered. In this email is a confirmation link. Please click on this link to confirm your subscription.

Close

* This consent can be revoked at any time with effect for the future. For more information, please see our privacy policyIf you have any questions regarding data protection, please contact dataprivacy [​at​] e-flux.com