Jesse revels his power to Cassidy, who soon makes a deal with Fiore and DeBlanc. Meanwhile, the town starts to talk about Tracy opening her eyes, and whisper behind Donnie's back about what Jesse did to him.

Cassidy tries to keep Fiore and DeBlanc off of Jesse after they express their willingness to cut open the preacher with a chainsaw. Meanwhile, Jesse approaches Odin with an offer: the church land if Odin doesn't accept God.

Jesse sets out to use the Voice to solve the troubles of the people of Annville. Meanwhile, Odin agrees to a meeting with the Green Acres people, Donnie realizes what he's up against, and Tulip and Cassidy begin a relationship.

Jesse escapes police custody and steals the angels' line to Heaven so that he can summon God to Texas. Meanwhile, Tulip tells Emily what Cassidy really is, Miles pays Emily a visit, and the true nature of the Cowboy's fate is revealed.

Tulip has nightmares of the Cowboy's touch, and finds a unique way to deal with them. Meanwhile, Jesse seeks out a doomsday preacher for advice on selling 1% of his soul, and the origin of Herr Starr's entry into the Grail is revealed.

While Cassidy considers what to do with Denis, Tulip spackles the bulletholes that the Cowboy left in the walls. Meanwhile, Jesse goes to a video store to try and determine whose gun was used to kill Mark Harelik.