"Cara and Ashley were enjoying each other’s company, sitting closely together at a front row table by the dance floor. When the two weren’t sitting, they were intimately dancing with each other and laughing throughout the night. Cake and ice cream with candles were brought out for Cara as everyone in the lounge sang her 'Happy Birthday,'" a source told Entertainment Tonightof the rumored couple, who each shared photos and videos of their night together on Instagram.

But this isn't the only time Delevingne—who, just earlier this year, was linked to Paris Jackson—and Benson were spotted getting cozy: the two were first linked together back in May when Benson shared a selfie of the pair on social media.

That same month, an attendee at Saturday Night Live claimed on Twitter that they saw Delevingne and Benson "making out" during the NBC show's taping.