Book Review: Gifts Not Yet Given by Kergan Edwards-Stout

Gifts Not Yet Given and Other Tales of the Holidays by Kergan Edwards-Stout

Rating:

Star3

Star

Star

Star

Star

Reviewer: Alan ChinPublisher: Circumspect PressPages: 186

Kergan Edwards-Stout has complied a collection of fourteen short stories all centered around different holidays. Yet, these stories are not about holidays, but about turning points in character’s lives, where the emotions and magic of the holidays push these characters past those turning points. These are tales of personal awakenings, where dreams are achieved, hope is found, life is cherished. Many are touching, others sad.

Like all short-story anthologies, I found this work a bit of a mixed bag, connecting with some stories, some characters, and not others. I felt the author’s talent shown brightest with Glenbourne, Il, where a woman, Sarah, struggles to gain acceptance from her in-laws. And in The Old Rugged Cross where a mother leaves her home in Alabama to be near her son in L.A. I found these characters genuine, and their stories thought provoking.

The author’s prose is well-paced and beautifully written, yet I often felt there was simply too much telling, as apposed to showing, and I also found the author’s habit of head-hopping a bit distracting.

As much as I enjoyed each of these stories, I feel that this collection does not live up to the promise that this talented author exhibited so eloquently in his first novel, Songs For The New Depression. Still, this anthology is a worthwhile read.

Share this article

Alan Chin writes gay-themed novels, novellas, and screenplays. He earned a Masters Degree in Writing from the University of San Francisco and has authored two novels: Island Song (Sept, 2008) and Changi (Sept., 2009). Visit Alan's blog here.