Appearing on Jimmy Kimmel Live on Tuesday night, the rapper-turned-mogul revealed his favorite New York slice: Lucali, a pizzeria in Brooklyn’s Carroll Gardens neighborhood that specializes in thin-crust pizza.

We know that’s not true, but still — the idea of a city without pizza sends shivers down our spines.

Jay Z and Beyoncé dine out all over the city — and the world. While touring Italy this summer with their daughter, Blue Ivy, the power couple scarfed down quite a bit of pizza (though no jalapeños in sight.)