Louisiana District ‘Color Codes’ Teacher Job Openings

The St. John the Baptist Parish public school district in Louisiana
has instituted a system to "color code" teaching positions to track the
transfer of teachers from one school to another.

The coding program is part of the district’s new effort to
comply with a federal court order to desegregate its faculty. It comes
at a time when the nation is commemorating the 50th anniversary of the
decision in Brown v. Board of Education of Topeka, which
overturned laws enacting racial segregation in public schools.
("Equality Goals Remain
Unmet, NAACP Argues," this issue.)

Located in southeastern Louisiana, on the Mississippi River, the St.
John the Baptist district has been under a federal court order to
desegregate its schools—including its teaching force—since
the early 1960s.

But like many other districts in Louisiana and elsewhere around the
country, the 6,200- student school system is still trying to meet the
mandates set forth in the court order.

"We are not working to get out of the desegregation order at this
time," Ann LaBorde, the director of personnel for the district, said
last week. "We are just trying to comply."

For the district to do so, the racial mix of the faculty in each of
the district’s 12 schools must come within 10 percentage points
of the makeup of the district’s entire teaching pool. Forty-one
percent of the district’s teachers are minority members, mostly
black, which means that 31 percent to 51 percent of each school’s
faculty must be from a minority group.

Seventy-five percent of the students are African-American, 22
percent are white, and 3 percent are Hispanic, Native American, or
Asian, according to the National Center for Education Statistics.

Color-coding open positions means that some jobs will be available
to white teachers only, and some to teachers from minority groups only,
Ms. LaBorde said.

Other districts, under orders to desegregate, have followed similar
practices over the years.

The voluntary transfers will start this coming fall.

The district attempted to desegregate its teaching corps once before
by forcing some teachers to transfer schools.

"In 1991, all these teachers were moved," said Ms. LaBorde. "And the
next year, they all moved back" to their original schools. The
mandatory placements lasted only a year. "This new order prevents that
from happening," she added.

This time around, the transfers, besides being voluntary, must last
for three years, she said. Those changes have made the process much
more palatable for the teachers, she added.

"The reaction has been OK," she said. "I have had few
complaints."

Before the new system was devised, teacher transfers were based on
seniority. Now, a teacher’s race will play a major role in
determining transfers, Ms. LaBorde said.

Seeking Unitary Status

St. John the Baptist is one of about 60 school districts in
Louisiana, out of 68, still working to comply with a desegregation
order, according to James Hrdlicka, the general counsel for the
Louisiana education department.

Elsewhere, school systems have attained "unitary" status, meaning
they’re free of the vestiges of segregation and so have been
released from desegregation orders and the subsequent federal oversight
of some district policies.

Still, the process has been slow, despite a 1990 U.S. Supreme Court
decision, in Board of Education of Oklahoma v. Dowell,
that made it easier for a school district to attain unitary status.

Since then, fewer than 200 districts, out of 700 with desegregation
orders, have done so.

The advantage to a district in being declared unitary is that the
local school board has complete control over such issues as
transportation, students’ access to extracurricular activities,
and the racial makeup of schools and faculty. "The court no longer
supervises the district," Mr. Hrdlicka said.

When districts are declared so, however, students tend to return to
neighborhood schools. According to Chungmei Lee, a research associate
at the Harvard Civil Rights Project, that "usually results in
resegregation."

Notice: We recently upgraded our comments. (Learn more here.) If you are logged in as a subscriber or registered user and already have a Display Name on edweek.org, you can post comments. If you do not already have a Display Name, please create one here.

Ground Rules for Posting
We encourage lively debate, but please be respectful of others. Profanity and personal attacks are prohibited. By commenting, you are agreeing to abide by our user agreement.
All comments are public.