'Prisoner X' plot thickens: Israel 'implicates' Australia in scandal

Australian newspapers lead their front pages in Australia on February 14, 2013, with the story of Ben Zygier as Israel confirms it jailed a foreigner in solitary confinement on security grounds who later committed suicide, with Australia admitting it knew one of its citizens had been detained (AFP Photo/William West) / AFP

Australia had detailed intelligence of a national thought to be a Mossad spy who committed suicide in an Israeli prison, media report. The man's death has given rise to a myriad of theories, some suggesting his interrogation drove him to suicide.

An Israeli official speaking on condition of anonymity to the
Australian Broadcasting Corporation said it was clear the
Australian government was “in the know long before ['Prisoner
X'] died” in June 2010.

The government source stressed that the Australian authorities
were well aware that 34-year-old Ben Zygier was not “some
backpacker who got lost trekking when his coffin was returned to
Australia.”

Zygier, an Australian-Israeli national, was being held in a
high-security Tel Aviv prison for “grave charges” until he
committed suicide in 2010. The Australian broke the story last
week, identifying Zygier, who had previously been known as
'Prisoner X.' The report sparked outrage in Israel over government
censorship of the case.

The news of Zygier’s suicide gave rise to speculation, namely
over how the Australian-Israeli managed to commit suicide in a
maximum-security prison where he was reportedly under constant
surveillance. Zygier’s lawyer, Avigdor Feldman, told Israel’s
Channel 10 that his client had been under intense emotional
pressure in interrogations that could have ultimately contributed
to suicide.
"His interrogators told him he could expect lengthy jail time and
be ostracized from his family and the Jewish community. There was
no heartstring they did not pull, and I suppose that ultimately
brought about the tragic end," he said. Feldman added that in
his conversations with Zygier prior to his suicide, his client was
stable and did not seem like someone about to take their own
life.

A justice ministry official told Israeli press that the
mysterious circumstances of Zygier’s death demanded further
investigation to “examine issues of negligence.”

"If [the judge] had not found anything suspicious, she would not
have transferred the case," the official said, adding that charges
would be filed if any evidence of negligence was unearthed in the
case.

Israeli officials have claimed that Zygier had been treated
fairly while he was in custody, and denied allegations of
negligence.

­

Compensation

Zygier’s wife and family have so far refrained from commenting
on the case publicly. His Israeli wife reportedly fled her home in
order to escape the media hype surrounding the affair.

However, reports have emerged that an agreement between Zygier’s
family and Israeli authorities – promising sizable compensation –
was reached six weeks ago. An anonymous source told Israeli
publication Haaretz that the government had offered hundreds of
thousands of dollars to the family in compensation.

The case of Prisoner X has taken Israeli society by storm,
giving rise to sharp criticism of government censorship.

"A prisoner, who is being hidden, kills himself and no one
knows about it. How is that compatible with the rule of law?"
Zehava Galon, head of opposition liberal party Meretz, said while
addressing Israel's national assembly.

Israeli authorities had managed to keep the case under wraps for
two years. Reports have surfaced that Prime Minister Netanyahu
contacted the country’s top editors and asked them to refrain from
publishing any stories on the case: Even when the case was covered
in international press, Israeli outlets were still not reporting on
it.