Knowledge from scientific expert testimony without epistemic trust

Abstract

In this paper we address the question of how it can be possible for a non-expert to acquire justified true belief from expert testimony. We discuss reductionism and epistemic trust as theoretical approaches to answer this question and present a novel solution that avoids major problems of both theoretical options: Performative Expert Testimony (PET). PET draws on a functional account of expertise insofar as it takes the expert’s visibility as a good informant capable to satisfy informational needs as equally important as her specific skills and knowledge. We explain how PET generates justification for testimonial belief, which is at once assessable for non-experts and maintains the division of epistemic labor between them and the experts. Thereafter we defend PET against two objections. First, we point out that the non-expert’s interest in acquiring widely assertable true beliefs and the expert’s interest in maintaining her status as a good informant counterbalances the relativist account of justification at work in PET. Second, we show that with regard to the interests at work in testimonial exchanges between experts and non-experts, PET yields a better explanation of knowledge-acquisition from expert testimony than externalist accounts of justification such as reliabilism. As our arguments ground in a conception of knowledge, which conceives of belief-justification as a declarative speech act, throughout the rearmost sections of this paper we also indicate to how such a conception is operationalized in PET.

Notes

Acknowledgements

We thank audiences in Dublin (UCD) and Erlangen (FAU) for discussion of earlier drafts of this paper. We especially want to thank Isaac Choi (Yale) and two anonymous reviewers for Synthese for doubts and comments that greatly helped to improve the manuscript.

Funding

Funded by Deutsche Forschungsgemeinschaft (DFG, German Research Foundation) - 396775817.

Guerrero, A. A. (2017). Living with ignorance in a world of experts. In R. Peels (Ed.), Perspectives on ignorance from moral and social philosophy. New York: Routledge Taylor & Francis Group (Routledge studies in contemporary philosophy (Vol. 85, pp. 156–183).Google Scholar