Walsh's momentum carried over to the second set as they took an early 6-2 lead but the Storm rallied and tied the set at eight. After alternating points, the Cavaliers pulled ahead, 14-11. Following a timeout, the Storm went on a 6-3 run to tie the set at 17. After a Walsh timeout, the Storm built their biggest lead of the set at 23-20. After their second timeout, the Cavaliers went on a 3-0 run to tie the game. The Storm won the next point but failed on the ensuing set-point as Walsh won the next two points to close out the set.

Richardson and Walter had four kills apiece in the set while Sara Aultz (Wooster, Ohio/Orrville) added three. Jamie Hoppe (Green Springs, Ohio/Clyde) had three digs.

Trailing by two sets, the Storm took control early in the third set, taking a 7-3 lead but the Cavaliers went on a 4-0 run to tie the set at seven. The teams exchanged points until the Storm pulled ahead 14-11. The Cavaliers were able to recover and tie the set back up at 17. The Storm took a slight 23-22 advantage but Walsh won the following three points to close out the match.

Walter led the Storm with 10 kills for the match while Richardson ended with nine. Hoppe had a team-high nine digs while Andrea Harris (Beavercreek, Ohio/Beavercreek) had eight. Kristin Swann (Rochester Hills, Mich./Rochester) had a pair of kills and digs.