Located on N. 5th Avenue, Cibo Urban Pizzeria Cafe was the winner for Arizona. Cibo set up shop in a restored 1913 bungalow and specializes in artisanal pizzas and housemade pastas.

Not every restaurant on the list flaunted an expensive price tag or even a mid-range one but was instead selected based on “that perfect balance of cuisine, atmosphere, and service that makes them stand out among the rest.”