On this week’s episode, the critics discuss Penny Dreadful, a lush Showtime drama set in 1890s London. A mash-up of gothic tropes—from Frankenstein to Dorian Gray—the show may be too gloomy. Next the gabbers turn to Chipotle’s new marketing campaign, which features original stories by acclaimed authors like Jonathan Safran Foer and Toni Morrison on their cups and bags. But do we really need our burritos with a side of erudition? And finally, the critics welcome David Auerbach, Slate’s Bitwise columnist, to discuss the FCC’s latest proposals, which may jeopardize net neutrality. David explains what the future of the web could look like under the proposed rulings and how we’ve been taking the Internet for granted.