What do you get the girl that has it all? Just ask Alex Rodriguez, who is planning the most “creative” present to get his A-list girlfriend Jennifer Lopez. Read on for all the details!

Photo credit: Getty

Photo credit: Getty

The former baseball superstar spoke with PEOPLE exclusively about his gifting plans for his longtime beau.

Photo credit: Getty

Photo credit: Getty

“It has to be something creative,” he revealed. “I can’t just go out and buy something expensive.”

Photo credit: Getty

Photo credit: Getty

“For Jennifer, something that’s handwritten, maybe a photo,” Alex said. “I don’t want to give any secrets away for this holiday, but it’s something that is heartfelt, something that resembles a memory that we’ve had together that involves our children, that involves our home because, ultimately, that’s what it’s all about.”

Photo credit: Getty

Photo credit: Getty

J. Lo got her man something super sparkly about a month before Christmas last year, when she gifted him with a bedazzled Starbucks cup!

Photo credit: Getty

Photo credit: Getty

Could that "handwritten" thing that Alex mentioned include a proposal? Rumors of them being engaged have swirled for months now, even though they have both denied them every step of the way.

Photo credit: Getty

Photo credit: Getty

What do you think A. Rod will get J. Lo for Christmas? Sound off in the comments!