Study Tools

Farewell to Manzanar

Jeanne Wakatsuki Houston

Chapter 5

Chapters 7–8

Summary—Whatever He Did Had Flourish

Papa continues to use his cane even after he recovers.
Sometimes he uses it as a sword to swat at his family, and Jeanne
imagines it as a makeshift version of the samurai sword of his great-great-grandfather
from Hiroshima. Jeanne sees the camp as the place where her father’s
life ends and her own life begins.

Papa is the oldest son of a samurai family that was stripped
of its warrior status when Commodore Matthew Perry arrived in Japan. Papa’s
uncle was a general and persuaded him to enter military school,
but he dropped out at seventeen and sailed for the Hawaiian Islands
with money borrowed from an aunt. In Hawaii, Papa saw an advertisement
for a job. He bought a new suit and went to find out about the job,
but on arriving he found that the ad was for work in the sugar cane
fields. He soon found a job as a houseboy in Idaho for an
American lawyer. After spending five years with the lawyer, he enrolled
at the University of Idaho and began preparing for a law degree.
He changed his plans, however, when he met Jeanne’s mother.

Mama was born in Hawaii to a sugar cane worker from Niigata, Japan.
Her family moved to Spokane, Washington, after her birth. When Mama
was seventeen, she had already been promised to the son of a well-to-do
farmer. She met Papa one morning when he was unloading vegetables
at a market. Her family did not like him because he lived a fast-paced
life, but the two eloped and got married in Salem, Oregon. They
moved frequently over the next eighteen years and had ten children.
Papa did not finish law school and worked many odd jobs. A
few years before Jeanne was born he started farming near Watsonville,
California. During the Great Depression he moved to Inglewood, but
he then turned to fishing in Santa Monica, where he acquired two
boats, a house, and a Studebaker.

Jeanne sees her parents’ golden wedding anniversary as
the climax of her family’s happiness at Ocean Park. She recalls
that her father stood looking elegant in his double-breasted suit
and demonstrated how to carve a pig with a few swift strokes of
a cleaver. Jeanne says that her father was not a great man but that
he held on to his self-respect and dreams, and whatever he did,
he did with flourish. She adds that the other men at the detention
camp at Fort Lincoln remember him because he helped the government
conduct interviews, taught other inmates English, and gave comic
readings of the news every morning.

Analysis

Papa is unique in the memoir both because he is an Issei,
or first-generation Japanese immigrant, and because of the status
that his family’s samurai heritage confers upon him. The U.S. government’s disregard
for the historical importance of the samurai class reflects the
extent to which its actions degrade Papa. For centuries Japan was
a feudal society ruled by samurai warlords, but when Commodore Perry
forced Japan to open its ports to the West in 1853,
the feudal structure crumbled. However, the social significance
of having samurai heritage remained powerful. But Papa’s high social
status in Japan contrasts sharply with the working class status
he must assume in America, where he does not own land or automatically earn
respect from others. Rather, he must move frequently in order to
catch odd jobs, repeatedly starting his life from scratch.

Papa’s identification with his samurai heritage explains
the high value he places on honor and his concern about being disgraced. The
samurai were long important and greatly respected members of Japanese
society. Papa feels shame about his father’s cabaret business, because
the working-class nature of such an enterprise has reduced his father
from a noble individual to an average worker. The extent of Papa’s
shame is manifest in his cutting himself off from his family; he
does not want his father’s disgrace to taint him. His abandonment
of his family constitutes a figurative version of the suicide that
disgraced samurai are expected to commit. Papa’s continued efforts
in America to cultivate himself as a strong figure reflect his pride
in his samurai heritage. His family is so used to this pride that
his withered appearance when he returns from being interrogated
shocks them immeasurably.

“Whatever He Did Had Flourish” establishes Papa’s pride
as the defining trait through which we can trace his downfall. Wakatsuki initially
portrays Papa as a resourceful, adventurous, and dashing young man
whose pride gives him strength of character. His pride manifests
itself not only in his anger at his own father’s degradation but
also in the earnestness with which he lives his daily life, turning out
for jobs in a brand new suit. This loving picture of Papa contrasts
with Wakatsuki’s later, frightening picture of him, after the war
and the internment have warped his pride into misdirected anger
and resentment. Papa’s ultimate failure to fit in to American society
is important to Wakatsuki’s story because it serves as a counterpoint
to Jeanne’s own attempts to reconcile her Japanese ethnicity with
her American identity. Papa and Jeanne’s experiences differ, however,
in that Jeanne’s struggle leads to her eventual growth and self-realization,
whereas Papa’s struggle defeats him and leaves him alienated from
both his family and his identity.