A REPORT found there has been “weaknesses in engagement and effective listening” with residents over the future of a care home – resulting in a further consultation.

Gwynedd Council will extend talks over their plans to demolish Hafod y Gest in Porthmadog and replace it with 42 extra care flats.

The care home for the elderly was given a reprieve from closure in December, pending further consultation after councillors voted against the plans.

The six month process was intended to finish this month, however, a report from an independent officer showed there had been “weaknesses in the engagement arrangements, communication and effective listening” and a “lack of identifying additional options”.

Cllr Wyn Williams, cabinet member for care services, said there needed to be a more complete picture over people’s views and older people’s care needs.

“We have listened closely to the concerns, comments and suggestions presented to us by local councillors, the residents and Friends of Hafod y Gest and staff about the previous process.

“From this work it has become apparent that a much more complete picture of the needs and aspirations of local people is required.

“As a result, we are recommending that the council starts anew by first of all inviting local residents to give us their views on the best way forward.”

It’s hoped that further meetings could be arranged with residents over the plans.

Councillors have been urged to fully plan the consultation process from the start by giving everyone a chance to air their views while adequately researching the needs of the area’s residents and identify clear options.

The announcement has been welcomed by campaigners Friends of Hafod y Gest who led a 300 person protest march last March over the proposals.

Martha Hughes, chairman of the group, said: “I’m very glad they’ve listened to the people of Porthmadog. We need residential care. We don’t need these units. Perhaps allow a few there but not as many as units as they wanted originally.”

Cllr Alwyn Gruffydd said: “ We want a transparent and open consultation and don’t want it to be rushed.”

The recommendations will be discussed at a full council meeting today.