Here are 6 movies and shows for you and your squad to get scared by, together.

1. Stranger Things, Season 2

The kids of Hawkins, Indiana, are back! If you’ve spent every waking moment—since devouring the first season in one sitting—hoping and waiting for the follow-up, it’s finally here. Revisit the old episodes or jump into the new ones, now that Will Byers is back home.

2. TheAddams Family

3. Penny Dreadful

The name of this show is a term that was used to refer to kitschy, thin, paperback books that were popular in the 1800s. This show takes these witchy characters (Frankenstein, American werewolf in London, Dorian Gray) and weaves three seasons into an interconnected spook-a-thon.

4. Donnie Darko

A cult classic, Donnie Darko stars IRL siblings Jake and Maggie Gyllenhaal as a brother and sister dealing with some bizarre, parallel-universe shenanigans. This movie isn’t all creepy—it also has some of the best one-liners in movie history. Namely: “Sometimes I doubt your commitment to Sparkle Motion.”

5. The Nightmare Before Christmas

This movie prompted a mini-debate in the office over whether it’s actually a movie for Christmas movie or Halloween. The verdict: It’s at least a little bit of both, so why not watch it twice a year? The Tim Burton classic is one of those age-old crowd-pleasers.