Palestinians: The Nightmare of Christians

For the past four decades, Samir Qumsieh, who hails from a large and well-respected Christian family in the town of Bet Sahour, near Bethlehem, has fought for the rights of the region's miniscule Palestinian Christian minority. He has even dared to speak out against the subjugation of Christians living under the rule of Hamas in the Gaza Strip.

He regularly receives death threats, and he has been the target of a petrol bomb attack.

"The solution to extremism starts with the kindergarten, with elementary school. It begins with the churches, with the mosques and the school curricula. Curricula are very important – Jewish, Christian and Muslim ones. They should concentrate on accepting the 'other.' If this idea is adopted, the future generation will be liberal and open-minded." — Samir Qumsieh.

"Every day we hear and see some radical Muslim clerics speaking strongly against Christians. Just recently, one of the sheiks was saying that Christian Copts should be slaughtered like sheep. Where is the Egyptian security? If I were in charge of Egyptian security, I would have this sheikh arrested immediately, and have him rot in a dark underground cell." — Samir Qumsieh.

"To understand the severity of the situation is, let us recall that in the 1950s about 86% of the population of the Bethlehem area was Christian. Today, we are only 12%. In Israel, by contrast, we have 133,000 Christians and the figure is stable. Of course, I am worried about the future of Christians here." — Samir Qumsieh.

"I fear the day will come when our churches will become museums. is my nightmare." — Samir Qumsieh.

Without question, Samir Qumsieh is one of the most courageous Christian leaders in the Middle East. Qumsieh is one of the few willing to risk his life to speak out against Muslim persecution of Christians in the Palestinian territories and the Middle East, generally.

For the past four decades, Samir Qumsieh, who hails from a large and well-respected Christian family in the town of Bet Sahour, near Bethlehem, has fought for the rights of the region's miniscule Palestinian Christian minority. He has even dared to speak out against the subjugation of Christians living under the rule of Hamas in the Gaza Strip.

The plight of the Christians living under the Palestinian Authority and Hamas is a subject truly taboo. Yet Qumsieh perseveres – and pays the price. He regularly receives death threats, and he has been the target of a petrol bomb attack. Muslim extremists have also distributed leaflets in the Bethlehem area condemning him for his outspoken views and activities on behalf of persecuted Christians.

Samir Qumsieh.

However, the campaign of intimidation has not deterred Qumsieh from defending them.

In an exclusive interview with Gatestone Institute, the prominent Christian figure, who founded the private Nativity TV Station in Bet Sahour, accuses the Obama Administration of failing to combat ISIS and radical Islam. Qumsieh says he is convinced that President-elect Trump will "terminate" ISIS.

Qumsieh discloses that a "Muslim mafia" has been stealing Christian-owned lands in the Bethlehem area.

As a prominent Palestinian Christian figure in the living in the Middle East, how would you assess the Obama Administration's role in the war on ISIS?

President Obama is the spiritual father of ISIS. His administration and he were never serious about fighting ISIS. This is what I firmly believe, and many facts confirm my thoughts. When Obama saw that this was about to be exposed, he finally acted, but in a weak manner. He put out a ransom against (ISIS leader) Abu Baker Al-Baghdadi and started telling us that he had bombed ISIS, and so on.

How do you explain Obama's refusal to use the term radical Islam?

If you ask me, I will tell you the truth: I doubt that Obama is a Christian. Really, I doubt it. During his term, ISIS emerged, and the Christians have suffered heavily. Let me ask you a question. What is ISIS? Why is it that this mobilization of the whole world has not been able to eradicate them? Who can convince me? When America toppled Saddam Hussein, who had a very big and strong army, he collapsed. But when it comes to ISIS, how come they still exist?

Do you believe that President-elect Donald Trump will endorse a different stance toward ISIS?

Absolutely. Trump will obliterate ISIS. Had Hilary Clinton won, believe me ISIS would have continued and flourished. In my view, Turkish President Recep Tayyip Erdogan is the 'father' of ISIS, and Clinton is its 'mother.'

I have a friend who is a painter. He paints portraits of presidents. He is a Muslim, by the way. We sent portraits to King Abdullah, to Mahmoud Abbas and the Pope. He painted a portrait of Obama in front of the Church of Nativity. He worked on it for two months and it cost a lot of money. When the portrait was presented to Obama through the US consul-general in Jerusalem, they did not bother to send a thank you letter to the painter, although I personally talked to the consulate about this. I told them, 'Gentlemen, this is shameful, at least send a thank-you letter to this man.' The consul-general at that time came to my office and took the portrait. Doesn't the painter deserve at least a thank-you letter?

Are you saying that Obama has not done anything to help Christians in the Middle East?

Nothing at all. As I said, I think he was not serious about fighting ISIS, which has harmed the Christians very badly.

In your opinion, what is the best way to fight religious extremism?

I have always said that the solution to extremism is not through the military or security. The solution to extremism starts with the kindergarten, with elementary school. It begins with the churches, with the mosques and the school curricula. Curricula are very important – Jewish, Christian and Muslim ones. They should concentrate on accepting the 'other.' If this idea is adopted, the future generation will be liberal and open-minded.

But isn't the turmoil and violence in the Middle East the result of religious extremism?

The current conflict in the entire region is a religious and sectarian war. Turkey, Saudi Arabia and Qatar are Sunni. They are against Iran, Hezbollah in Lebanon and the Alawite regime of Bashar Assad in Syria. So we are witnessing a religious and sectarian war. This is not only a conflict between Sunnis and Shias.

How do you feel as a Christian when you see what is happening to Christians in the Middle East, especially the recent bombing of a church in Egypt?

What is happening is extremely sad, especially the bombing of a church. I think the Egyptian authorities should act decisively. Every day we hear and see some radical Muslim clerics speaking strongly against Christians. Just recently, one of the sheiks was saying that Christian Copts should be slaughtered like sheep. Where is the Egyptian security? If I was in charge of Egyptian security, I would have this sheikh arrested immediately, and have him rot in a dark underground cell.

Are you aware of Palestinian Muslim clerics who also speak out against Christians?

Yes. This past Friday, one of the sheikhs at a mosque was speaking in a threatening way about Christians. He said that Muslim youths should not imitate Christian youths, and should not wish them well at Christmas. He also said that Muslims should not be doing business with Christians. The sheikh said some highly intimidating things about Christians.

Did the Christians protest against this incitement by the sheikh?

My cousin, who is a retired officer with the Palestinian Authority Intelligence Security Department, published something about the Friday sermon on Facebook. The following day he had to delete the post because it seems he received threats or something like that. When I told my cousin that I will talk with the Palestinian Authority attorney-general about it, he asked me not to talk to anyone. My cousin said, 'Please don't talk about this matter because we are 40 Christian families in that area (where the sheikh lives). It is clear to me that my cousin did receive threats, although he would not admit to it.

How would you describe relations between Christians and Muslims in the Bethlehem area?

Objectively speaking, there are millions of Muslims who are good people. I have many close Muslim friends whom I consider as my brothers. The problem is not Muslims. The real problem is radical Islam. In the Quran, there are various kinds of statements, and every Muslim, depending on his belief and attitude, selects what suits him. Some verses call for peace and describe Christians as the 'People of the Book' and good people. There are also verses that describe us as infidels and sinful folks. Everyone chooses what appeals to him. According to my humble knowledge, these verses are undated. I think that if they were dated, the fresh ones would supersede the old ones.

My understanding is that you have personally been the target of threats and violent attacks. Can you elaborate?

Yes, I have faced a great deal of harassment, and in 2006 I was even attacked with Molotov cocktails. Also, fliers that spoke against me have been distributed.

What is the main accusation against you? Why are some Muslims angry with you?

When I saw that there was encroachment on Christian-owned land here, I protested against it.

Is it true that Muslims have been illegally laying their hands on Christian property in Bethlehem?

We have a mafia here that is seizing Christian-owned lands. I protested against this Muslim mafia, and I even called a large gathering. I invited 80 people to my home. They included the elite of society – Muslims and Christians. They all joined my protest. That same night, fliers were distributed in Bethlehem threatening to kill me.

What has the Palestinian Authority done to help against you fight this mafia?

There are still many unresolved cases with regards to land encroachment. These cases are in the courts, but our judicial system is very slow. If you go to court, you have to wait 15-20 years. Recently, we have noticed that the encroachments decreased immensely because we have been talking to the Palestinian Authority and pressing them about the problem. Today, there are only a few cases like this taking place. We want all these cases to be solved.

Is there discrimination against Christians living under the Palestinian Authority?

One cannot say that there is official discrimination. President Abbas attends Christmas midnight mass, his prime minister attends the lighting of the Christmas tree. Still, I can simply say that among our people you will find some who harbor radical extremist thoughts. ISIS is a thought. There are Christians working in the Palestinian Authority, but not many. We have Christian mayors, and that is how it should be. Bethlehem, Bet Sahour and Bet Jala have Christian mayors, although some have been demanding that this be changed because Christians are a minority. Fortunately for us, the Palestinian Authority did not respond to these demands.

Do you believe that Christian leaders are doing enough to defend the interests of their people?

Frankly, I do not want the day to come when the Church of the Holy Sepulcher and the Church of the Nativity are turned into museums. Rather, I wish to seize this opportunity hope that it will encourage our leaders to tackle the problem and find a solution. Any Christian businessman who is interested in the general issue of Christians should come and invest here. We want them to build projects, including housing projects. We are also hoping that these projects will provide jobs for young Christians. The biggest problem we are facing is Christian emigration. Some Christians are helping, but this is being done on a very limited scale. But I cannot say that Christian patriarchates are doing their best. Some of them are far from the congregation and do not even care about us. We want wealthy Christians to come here and create project initiatives. It is not enough to say 'I love the Christians and I care about them.' This love should be demonstrated through deeds.

Are you worried about the growing number of Christians who are leaving the West Bank and Gaza Strip?

Once, 5,000 Christians lived in the Gaza Strip. When Hamas took over the Gaza Strip in 2006, Christians began to be harassed and discriminated against. Today, only 1,100 Christians live there. In the Bethlehem area, there are about 40,000 Christians. Altogether, there are about 42,000 Christians remaining in the West Bank. There are two reasons behind the dwindling figures. The first of these is the ongoing emigration, which is a nightmare for us; the second is the low birth rate among Christian families. To understand the severity of the situation is, let us recall that in the 1950s about 86% of the population of the Bethlehem area was Christian. Today, we are only 12%. In Israel, by contrast, we have 133,000 Christians and the figure is stable. Of course, I am worried about the future of Christians here. Looking at the facts on the ground, you can see that there is no future for the Christians here. We are melting; we are disappearing. I fear the day will come when our churches will become museums. That is my nightmare.

Khaled Abu Toameh, an award-winning journalist, is based in Jerusalem.

Comment on this item

Name:

Email Address:

Comments:

Email me if someone replies to my comment

Note: Gatestone Institute greatly appreciates your comments. The editors reserve the right, however, not to publish comments containing: incitement to violence, profanity, or any broad-brush slurring of any race, ethnic group or religion. Gatestone also reserves the right to edit comments for length, clarity and grammar. All thoughtful suggestions and analyses will be gratefully considered. Commenters' email addresses will not be displayed publicly. Gatestone regrets that, because of the increasingly great volume of traffic, we are not able to publish them all.

7 Reader Comments

Paul Richard Strange, Sr. • Feb 20, 2017 at 22:28

I like this plainspoken gentleman. Thanks for this article.

Reply->

Valerie Fulford • Jan 3, 2017 at 12:07

A while ago the fighting between Israel and Palestine was fierce, nothing was sacred. At the time I blamed Israel for poaching land to build houses for those coming back to their country from abroad. It was a David and Goliath situation with Israel getting all it wanted from America, even to having a Dome built to protect itself. There were several attempts to bring other parties to a negotiating table but the truces only lasted a few days every time. I don't think the problem will ever be resolved.

Reply->

barry • Dec 25, 2016 at 14:28

I'm sure its not easy being a Christian in his situation, or in most of the Arab world. I think he is right that the US (including Presidents Bush and Obama) should be doing more to help Christians in the region, I think we are held back by geopolitical and petroleum related considerations. But he loses me when he says President Obama is the "spiritual father" of ISIS and is not fighting them, that is ludicrous in light of our ongoing campaign that has them on the verge of losing Mosul and even Raqqa. I believe almost every viewpoint has a tendency to overstate which does their cause more harm than good.

Reply->

Harvey A. Epstein • Dec 25, 2016 at 12:10

Mr. Samir Qumsieh sounds like a wonderful man who, like most people, has never read the Koran. I hate to be the one to tell him, But Chapter 9 of the Koran was the second to last chapter revealed. Verse 9:30 was also spoken by Mohammed on his deathbed. I have read over 50 separate translations of this verse. By plurality it says "Destroy (sometime the word "kill" is used) the Christians and the Jews". The "nice" verses long preceded Chapter 9. Nothing came after it on this subject. According to Ayisha, his favorite wife, Mohammed's last words were " Let there not be two religions in the Arabian peninsula". Mr. Qumsieh is correct, the new verses superseded the old; the concept of "abrogation" is specifically spelled out in the Koran, itself.

Reply->

Badger • Dec 24, 2016 at 19:46

'Muslim children should be educated by their parents and imams to recognise the humanity of Jews and Christians.' Or words to that effect. If the author can't see the absurdity of that suggestion then he is wasting his time posting here.

As long as islam exists the world will always be divided into believers and kufrs. Nowhere in the muslim scriptures can you find any kind words for the kufr. Only torture and damnation. Nowhere that hasn't been abrogated by the Medinan koran. Even for muslims kindness is largely absent. Only hell on earth and hell for eternity unless you follow the example of the perfect man, muhammad. And god help us all when they put that into practice.

islam cannot be reformed. It can only reign supreme over the entire world or be exterminated and that means by brutal force. Talking to them, 'educating' them is just a waste of breath. They are out to dominate us or die in the attempt and we must make sure that the latter prevails. If we don't face up to that fact then we are truly lost.

Reply->

Denis MacEoin • Dec 24, 2016 at 13:20

I wish Samir all the best and hope he is not attacked or forced to stay silent. More Christians should speak out, particulary those who live in safety in the West.

But he is sadly misinformed about one thing. He says: "Some verses call for peace and describe Christians as the 'People of the Book' and good people. There are also verses that describe us as infidels and sinful folks. Everyone chooses what appeals to him. According to my humble knowledge, these verses are undated. I think that if they were dated, the fresh ones would supersede the old ones."

There is indeed a method of Qur'an interpretation that claims later verses should abrogate earlier ones. There is a basic dating system, linking many verses to historical information. Many verses are divided into two classes: 'abrogated' (mansukh) and 'abrogating' (nasikh). Uniformly, it is the peaceful and tolerant verses that are abrogated and the later intolerant and violent verses that abrogate. It is impossible to change this unless (as has happened now and then) interpreters agree to reverse the two classes.

The late verses genuinely coincide with Muhammad's own growing hatred for the Jews and Christians, his call for jihad, and his laws about making Jews and Christians subordinate peoples as dhimmis. The later 'Traditions' (ahadith) conform the use of jihad and the subordination of Jews and Christians. This is one of the reasons that encourage Muslim intolerance, because few are able to go against holy scripture and there are few reformers who want to update the whole system.

Those who do go against the grain are very brave individuals, who struggle on an upward path. But they are the only real hope we have.

Reply->

jeb • Dec 24, 2016 at 07:31

In an Islamic State, if you think an Imam should be arrested for hate speech its Islamophobia and then you are arrested.It is the basis of Islam's failed theology which is largely anti faith based, distracting its believers from serious flaws in its beliefs based on quotations from the Bible that can in no way be substantiated and were posited by "The Prophet", and ends in a defense that is an infinite regression.
The position of Imam's is that the Koran is the proper understanding of Christianity and Judaism, and our beliefs must conform to the Koran. That is why they destroy as many artifacts in the Middle East as they can. It operates on the same principle as the Nazis Holocaust, which the neo-Nazis and Islamists deny happened, it is the belief you can change history and erase parts of it by erasing people their culture and artifacts and denying they ever existed. It is the action of people who do not have faith. Perhaps it is too much to believe it is possible for a Muslim to have the kind of faith Christians and Jews do? Without which one can not learn tolerance. It may also explain why socialists so readily identify with Islamists and defend them against western influences and criticism which liberals also approach much the same way as expressions of socialism.