Robert Scholes on Video Text's - Comparison

According to Robert Scholes, author of On Reading a Video Text, commercials aired on television hold a dynamic power over human beings on a subconscious level. He believes that through the use of specific tools, commercials can hold the minds of an audience captive, and can control their abilities to think rationally. Visual fascination, one of the tools Scholes believes captures the minds of viewers, can take a simple video, and through the use of editing and special effects, turn it into a powerful scene which one simply cannot take his or her eyes from. Narrativity is yet another way Scholes feels commercials can take control of the thoughts of a person sitting in front of the television. Through the use of specific words, sounds, accompanying statements and or music, a television commercial can hold a viewer's mind within its grasp, just long enough to confuse someone into buying a product for the wrong reason. The most significant power over the population held by television commercials is that of cultural reinforcement, as Scholes calls it. By offering a human relation throughout itself, a commercial can link with the masses as though it's speaking to the individual viewer on an equal level. A commercial In his essay, Scholes analyzes a Budweiser commercial in an effort to prove his statements about the aforementioned tools. The commercial described in Scholes composition is a "well-known Budweiser commercial which tells the life story of a black man pursuing a career as a baseball umpire" (Scholes, p. 620). Scholes feels that this commercial elegantly proves his theory that video texts can hold a viewer captive and control his thought pattern through the use of visual effects, narrativity, and of course, cultural reinforcement. The commercial itself tells the story of a young black man, working as an umpire in the minor baseball leagues, risen from the provinces, having overcome great racial tension throughout his life, who "makes it" as he is accepted by a white manager after making a close call during a game. Scholes analysis of this video text references his tools of "power and pleasure" (Scholes, p. 619) many times. Throughout the commercial visual effects are placed in order to capture the audience as we are offered an "enhancement of our vision" (Scholes, p. 619) by them, according to Scholes. A key feature of the commercial, the slow motion video of the play in question allowing us to see what the right call truly is, is not only important to the story, it's important as it allows us to see something we cannot without the use of special effects. We are simply awestruck by seeing something we cannot on our own. The Budweiser commercial in question uses narrativity throughout itself to not only tell the story of the umpire, but to tell the story of America, to tell the story of our national pastime, to tell the story of the young black man who has worked ever so hard to make it, when he finally does. While watching the young umpire working a game, we hear the narrator's voice, "In the minors you got to make all the calls, and then one day you get the call" (Scholes, p. 620), Budweiser uses this catchy phrase in order to grab our attention, to focus us on the commercial in order to look for the blossoming story. This slight play on words has a great effect on a viewer due to the fact that our minds think about the statement, and by the time we realize what is actually happening, the commercial has shown us that the black umpire has just gotten his "call." Later in the commercial, after the game has obviously ended, we see the umpire sitting in the same bar as the manager who confronted him about his "bad" call during the game. The old white manager with "the history of [baseball] written on [his face]" (Scholes, p. 621) holds up his bottle of Budweiser to the young black umpire, and toasts him with it. All the while a chorus plays in the background, singing "You keep America working. This...

You May Also Find These Documents Helpful

...consideration in business is cost management.
Unlike Mario, Robert seems to be an imaginative person. This explains for his bachelor’s degree in theatre. However, he cares about business and use tools of business administration methodically and logically. Because of the creative ability and logical inference, Robert gradually approaches problem sequence that Falls Video has met. These steps represents Robert’s competency of organizational behavior in dealing with relationship with colleagues, customers resulting in correctly defining problem requiring solving and proposing strategic project to settle those problem.
As we studied, the two primary sources shaping personality differences are heredity and environment. Aspects of environment that influence personality formation include culture, family, group membership, and life experience. In this case study, there is no evidence about heredity, so we mainly analyze environment.
About culture:
The author do not mention about The Valencia or Robert Princeton’s nationality.
About family:
The primary vehicle for socializing an individual into a particular culture is the person’s immediate family. For the Valencia, Poppa Valencia is content to remain in Glens Falls office and keep the books for growing business. This characteristic affects somewhat son Mario Valencia’s personality.
Looking back to decision of Mr. and Mrs. Princeton when giving support for...

...CASE ANALYSIS
“ROBERT PRINCETON AT FALLS VIDEO”
Introduction
Falls Video had been founded by “Momma and Poppa” Valencia in 1983. It started as a small video rental in a corner of their Glens Falls grocery store. After some successful years, Momma decided to separate them into two independent businesses. Then Valencias had 4 grocery stores which were managed by Momma and 8 video stores which were managed by Momma’s son, Mario Valencio. As the expanded video business, problems had begun to arise:
Losses due to stolen or misplaced videotapes were up
Supplies of newly released films were inadequate to satisfy customer demand
Turnover, absenteeism, and tardiness were way up among the 35 full- and part-time employees of the chain
Supposing the reason is personnel, Momma decided to hire Robert Princeton who had just graduated from Middlebury College with major theater as the assistant manager of Falls Video. He did have some effective ways to approach the problems of Falls Video and suggest plans to solve them. But these plans were not applied because Mario Valencio oppose these suggestions and had some confrontations with Robert Princeton.
Problems at Falls Video
Conflict between Robert and Mario
There are four times that were mentioned in this case showed the conflicts between Mario...

...﻿ Vision of the future
For many years, science fiction writers have challenged readers with visions of the future and future society. These authors offered an insight into what they expected man, society, and life to be like at some future time. One could divide their visions of future into two main streams: an apocalyptical one, with the degradation and demoralization of our society, and a utopian world, where our civilization turns into a highly conscious and developed one, and people live in perfect harmony.
Today one can state that we live in a highly developed society, where science can be encountered everywhere. For the past two centuries, our world has drastically changed with the development of nuclear physics and chemistry. Major countries possess weaponry that can completely annihilate Earth multiple times (if that was possible). No wonder that while living on the verge of such technological progress it makes people wonder what is going to happen in the future. Though apocalyptical theories have a certain background, I do not think that they have an actual chance to become truth.
If one would carefully analyze everything what has happened to humanity over the past 30 centuries he would see that so many mistakes were made by our leaders because of power-greed blinded eyes, and so many people were mistreated and suffered because of someone's sick will, that if it did not happen we would probably live in one of those utopian...

...﻿Martin Alejandro Ahumada Padilla
Professor Mathew Copeland
Rhetoric Written Argument 100
September 19, 2014
Essay on Robert Scholes’s On Reading a Video Text
“The American Dream”, the myth America has built upon itself. What are the first images that pop in our minds when we hear this phrase? The big house? The perfect job? Living in a land of equal opportunities? That hard work will inevitably be rewarded with the deserved economical goods? The immigrant working for a better life? These are all heart-warming images that have been implanted into our conscious since we were little. “Implanted” seems like a harsh word though, it by definition is the action of inserting something into someone’s body. Kind of like a predetermined seed of ideas being burrowed deep into our minds. How can something as beloved as “The American Dream” be seen as an intruder to our conscious? Shouldn’t it be welcomed? “The American Dream” essentially promotes hard work and well-being doesn’t it? Unfortunately, everything is bound to have a malicious side to it. “The American Dream” has been victimized by marketers in order to sell products and use it as a tool to take advantage of “the seed” implanted upon us.
The first information we are presented when reading Scholes’s On Reading a Video Text is that of video and its forms of presenting a message. Video effects can enhance our vision of images and information we would...

...Robert Frost
One can only marvel at the grandeur of nature and its influence upon every aspect of the universe. The irony is that nature wears many different masks, for at times nature is kind, gentle, and giving; while, in an instant, it can turn harsh, unforgiving, and unrelenting. One phenomenon that is certain, though, is that nature is continually teaching new and old lessons with regard to life and survival. Robert Frost was an extremely insightful man who recognized the lessons of nature and was able to articulate his thoughts about nature and life through his works. These thoughts were sometimes bittersweet, sometimes ironic, or could be simple reflections regarding his surroundings. One can, also, see autobiographical details in Frost’s works, for he suffered devastating losses during his lifetime. These include the untimely deaths of his sister, two of his children, and his wife (Seidman 465-467). Even though he knew the soul’s depths of psychic despair, he was capable of delighting in birch trees ‘loaded with ice a sunny winter morning’. While memorializing the rural landscape, vernacular, culture, and people of New England in his traditional verse and style, his works have proven to transcend the boundaries of time. Human nature, as with nature itself, is both beautiful and often an exercise of contradictions. Frost’s works reflect the metaphysical significance and modern exploration of this beauty and contradiction. Even though...

...﻿ In the video "A Place at the Table" it showcases eight American teens discussing their ancestors trials and tribulations of what they thought would be the American dream. Their names are Wislene, Peter, Samuel, Reina, Carol, David, Terry, and Deloria.
Wislene is a descendent from Africa, her grandparents were stolen from their native land and forced into slavery in America. They were re-named and separated from each other. They had to endure social justice blatant racism and nightmares upon nightmares of brutal violence and segregation. All they wanted was to start a family, homestead some land and live what they thought was the America dream.
Peters grandparents were Japanese, they were under the impression that there was mountains of gold in America and they could come here and harvest the gold and live wonderful lives better than the current conditions they were in. When they arrived during the war they were placed into "concentration camps" and had everything taken away from them. All they wanted was to escape poverty and have a small piece of the American dream but even though his grandfather even fought in the war his family still endured social injustice.
Deloria's grandparents were Native American. Her grandmother walked from Canada to California with her child on her back and a "white man's bullet in her leg". Self transformation plays a big role in Deloria's past, Native Americans were forced into American schools to reform them into the...

...The American dream is a symbol of hope, empowering the characters to endure the tribulationsof life. In Of Mice and Men, protagonists Lennie and George have created an American dreamthat one day they will "have a bigvegetablepatch and a rabbit hutch and chickens. And when itrains in the winter, we'll just say the hell with goin' to work, and we'll build up a fire in the stoveand set around it and listen to the rain comin' down on the roof [SIC]"(Steinbeck 16). The dreamis a stronghold; it allows them to endure the circumstances on the farm where they work. Bothmen dislike working on the farm because the boss's son, Curley is often very cruel and theconditions on the ranch are deplorable. However, they continue to work on the farm because "if we can get jus' a few dollars in the poke we'll shove off and go up the American River and pangold. We can make maybe a couple of dollars a day there, and we might hit a pocket [SIC]" (33).The dream creates an impetus for Lennie and George to stay within the intolerableconfines of farm to earn the money necessary to attain their dream. To them, "the dream of landrepresents independence and dignity; the American Dream" (Magill 4622). Theranchis asanctuary where Lennie and George can evade society and find acceptance despite Lennie'smental disability. Lennie is the beholder of dream, he constantly asks "George, how long's itgoing to be till we get that little place an' live off the fatta the lan'an' rabbits?" (Steinbeck 55).Although...

...Annie Dillard, the author of “The Death of a Moth” and Virginia Woolf, the author of “The Death of the Moth” have very different outlooks on the subject of life and death. Annie Dillard notices the point of loss and gain involved in the circle of life. Virginia Woolf, however, seems to see life as pointless and meaningless. It is essentially a postponement of the inevitable to her.
Each author writes her essay at a different point in the year. This has a major impact on the personalities each of them. Dillard, the more chipper author, writes her essay in recollection of a past summer. Summer is a time when life is thrilling and nature is at its best, a season of positivity. The offspring of many animals first come out into the world in summer, signifying the beginning of new life. Because summer is a warm and bright season, energy is at its peak, and spirits are high. Then you have less ecstatic Woolf, who wrote her essay in the fall, a time of changing, when the life of summer is slowly depleted so we can go into the cold days of winter. The autumn is a dark time in which the energy of all living things is being drained, even the summer’s green leaves begin to die out to an orange or red. Fall and summer are totally opposite seasons but the dark time of autumn reflects the dark nature of Woolf’s essay and her as a person.
Each author writes in a manner that clearly describes their surroundings. Dillard goes to the woods to relax and enjoy the world. She describes...