transition to 401(k) PLAnS

Transcription

1 transition to 401(k) PLAnS A TRAIN WRECK IN THE MAKING PArt i LoSS of retirement SEcuritY California Retired County Employees Association Retirement Security Committee March 2012 CRCEA; P.O. Box 706; Merced, CA

2 i. introduction The California Retired County Employees Association (CRCEA), a statewide organization representing approximate 160,000 retirees from 20 California counties, is dedicated to furthering the interests of county retirees. Its Retirement Security Committee was formed in June 2011 to counter misinformation that was being disseminated in the media by advocates of public pension reform. Sound public policy development has taken a back seat to ideology and sound bites with a dearth of information provided to the voting public on what pension reform proposals really mean to the individual, the economy, or the future of this country. A dominant solution to the retirement questions touted regularly in the media is to follow the lead of the private sector and transition public workers from traditional pension plans to 401(k) plans. While there are similarities in public and private sectors that allow for each to benefit from the other s experience, there are also dramatic differences that need to be addressed when examining pension issues. The so often claimed fact that business was saved by transitioning their employees to 401(k) plans says absolutely nothing about the ultimate effect of that transition on the individual or the economy. It does not address the rationales applicable to business but not to government, nor does it mention that the level of benefit and structural deficiencies of a 401(k) plan are poor substitutes for a properly run defined benefit plan. This paper deals with the destruction of retirement security in the private sector resulting from a transition to 401(k) plans. ii. LOSS OF RETIREMENT SECURITY IN THE PRIVATE SECTOR Most employers in the private sector have closed defined benefit pension plans ( DB plans ) and now offer primarily, if not exclusively, 401(k) plans. The move to 401(k) plans in the private sector has allowed employers to cut their pension costs from the 6-8% of payroll range for DB plans to the 2-3% range for 401(k) plans while at the same time shifting the burden for pension fund management and other responsibilities to their employees. 1 The shift from DB plans to 401(k) plans has destroyed retirement security for today s workers in the private sector: Review of polling shows that 84% of Americans are in a state of panic about their retirement security. 2 2

3 The median household headed by a person average with a 401(k) account has saved less than one forth (1/4) of what is needed to maintain its standard of living. 3 Over 60% of all U.S. workers now rely on 401(k) plans as their primary retirement fund, and this percentage continues to increase each year. Unfortunately, these plans are woefully underfunded. The average 401(k) account balance of workers with 30 years of private sector experience is only $149,000 to support decades of retirement. 4 In 1991, 50% of workers expected to retire by age 65. Today, only 23% of workers expect to retire by that age. 5 Experience in the private sector demonstrates that 401(k) plans have utterly failed in providing an adequate retirement fund. As this negatively impacts both individuals and the economy, it would be the worst of public policy to repeat that failure in the public sector. The transition to 401(k) plans is, without a doubt, a train wreck in the making. iii. 401(k) PLANS FAIL TO MEET THE REQUIREMENTS FOR A SUCCESSFUL PRIMARY RETIREMENT PLAN A retirement plan, to be successful as the primary source of retirement security, should meet the following three requirements: Sufficient contributions during the entire work career regardless of the number of jobs Sufficient returns on investments during the entire 30+ work career as well as during post retirement years Inability to invade the assets of the retirement fund for nonretirement purposes A. Failure To Provide For Sufficient Contributions While employers can contribute to a worker s 401(k) plan, they are not required to. During the recent economic downturn many employers reduced or eliminated their 401(k) contributions. Many workers contribute only as much as they can afford in order to pay monthly bills. And two out of three workers under age 30 fail to contribute anything, even if their employer matches their contribution. 6 And the later 3

4 one begins to fully contribute to the plan, the higher the annual contribution needs to be. Determining the amount one should contribute to the 401(k) requires a crystal ball and considerable expertise to predict earnings, inflation rates, rates of return on investments, anticipated employer contributions, retirement age, Social Security interface, life expectancy, and on and on. Most of us can t predict what the stock market will do tomorrow, nor do we have ready access to the kind of regular periodic professional actuarial assistance needed to help solve the individual complex equation. Why is this factor so important? Let s compare two employees who retired at age 65 after 35 years of service and with an ending salary of $48,000. Employee A has a DB plan with a 2% at 55 formula that generates and annual pension of $35,000. Employee B, with a 401(k) plan, would need a balance of over $850,000 in the account to achieve the same retirement benefit as employee A. To achieve that balance, employee B would have to contribute to the 401(k) account far more than was paid in by employee A specifically, 25% of his or her annual income, less any employer contribution. But federal law restricts contributions on a tax-favored basis to $16,500 for 2011 for the employee and 6% for the employer. The result that can be expected is upward pressure on salaries for the 401(k) employee, while still suffering inadequate retirement security. B. Failure To Provide For Sufficient Investment Returns From 1999 to 2009 there was effectively no return on the stock market. 7 From October 2007 until January 2009, 401(k) s lost a collective $1 trillion in value; that is fully a third of the value of all 401(k) plan balances. 8 So where can one invest to get a sufficient return? The entire Social Security fund is invested in special issues of the U.S. Treasuries that paid an average of 2.76% for 2010 and 2.82% for Even if made available to 401(k) investors, this is clearly not the kind of return on investment that will meet the individual needs of a 401(k) account holder to build retirement security. As a major contrast, government defined benefit pension plans have historically achieved long-term investment returns in the range of 8.1% over 20 years, and 9.3% over 25 years. 10 This drastically reduces the amount of employee and employer contributions needed to fund a pension (annuity) dollar. Several factors explain the lower investment returns achieved by 401(k) plans. As a 401(k) participant gets closer to retirement, investments must become more conservative. DB plans, however, can invest more aggressively in a balanced, diversified portfolio for a very long period due to the ability to pool longevity risks. And DB plans achieve higher returns due to professional asset management, the 4

5 ability to hedge risks through alternative investment opportunities, and lower asset management fees. Further impairing 401(k) investment returns is Wall Street s propensity to pounce on unsophisticated investors by deducting up to a dozen undisclosed fees on mutual funds including legal fees, trustee fees, transactional fees, bookkeeping fees, stewardship fees, and finder s fees, just to name a few. The financial lobby in Washington has been successful in preventing any bills from being introduced that would require disclosure of these fees. Congressional testimony shows that these fees can eat up one half (1/2) of 401(k) investment income over a 30 year span. 11 C. Failure To Prevent Invading Funds For Non-retirement Purposes Many 401(k) participants cash out their accounts when they change jobs. By doing so they incur a 10% tax penalty, with the employer required to withhold taxes equal to 20%. And in 2009, 21% of participants had loan balances on their accounts. 12 IV. THE LOSS OF RETIREMENT SECURITY HAS DIRE CONSEQUENCES FOR THE NATION The majority of the American workforce has no retirement plan (and savings under $2,000) and will be dependent on Social Security when they retire (if it still exists as it does today). 13 And six (6) out of ten (10) working Americans believe they will get no Social Security when they retire. 14 No one wants to be a burden to family, friends or society in their old age. But the U.S. workforce is clearly headed for a bleak future if we continue on this projected course. The current move to 401(k) systems is not a win/win situation and is far from optimal pension policy for both the private and public sectors. While it may initially appear to be financially beneficial for the employer (and Wall Street), this is short-term thinking. These underfunded 401(k) plans will have a very detrimental impact on business and the economy. Unlike the positive impact (multiplier effect) that has traditionally been associated with defined benefit plans that return $2.36 for every $1.00 of pension expenditure, (k) plans promise to be a future drag on the economy. Consumer spending today accounts for a very significant portion (40-70%, depending on the factors used) of our nation s economic activity. With a huge population of elderly retirees struggling to barely get by financially, our consumer driven economy will be in a disastrous state. 5

6 conclusion The transition in the private sector from defined benefit plans to 401(k) plans has resulted in a disastrous loss of retirement security. Continuation of this trend in the private sector, and expansion of the transition to the public sector is an individual and economy wide train wreck in the making. 1 (Frontline, 5/6/06, Crisis in the Making ) 2 (National Institute of Retirement Security, Letter to Investors Business Daily, May 11, 2011) 3 (Wall Street Journal, February 22, 2011, 401(k) Plans Come Up Short, according to data compiled by the Federal Reserve and analyzed by the Center for Retirement Research at Boston College for the Wall Street Journal.) 4 (The Wall Street Journal, February 19, 2011, Median Boomers 401(k) Balance is a Mere $149,000, according to data compiled by the Federal Reserve and analyzed by the Center for Retirement Research at Boston College for the Wall Street Journal) 5 (Employee Benefit Research Institute, March 15, 2011, 2011 Retirement Confidence Survey-2011 Results ) 6 (Congressional Budget Office, Utilization of Tax Incentives for Retirement Saving in 2006, updated October 2011) 7 (www.adamkoowealth.com Learning From the Lost Decade , January 3, 2010) 8 (The Wall Street Journal, 1/8/09, Big Slide in 401(k) s Spur Calls for Change, based on research at Boston College) 9 (www.socialsecurity.gov, Social Security Trust Fund Data-Trust Fund FAQ ) 10 (National Association of State Retirement Administrators NASRA Issue Brief: Public Pension Plan Investment Return Assumptions, March 2010) 11 (60 Minutes on CNBC, March 23, 2010, The Collapse-The Shortcomings on Relying on a 401(k) for Retirement ) 12 (Employee Benefit Research Institute, November 2010, 401(k) Plan Asset Allocation, Account Balances, and Loan Activity in 2009 ) 13 theeconomiccollapseblog.com 22 Statistics about America s Coming Pension Crisis That Will Make You Lose Sleep at Night 14 (Gallop.com 7/20/10, Six in 10 Workers Hold NO Hope of Receiving Social Security ) 15 (National Institute on Retirement Security 2011, Pensionomics-Measuring the Economic Impact of State and Local Pension Plans) 6

Canada s Retirement Security Crisis National Union of Public and General Employees (NUPGE) Ottawa, Canada: January 2012 MYTH1 Most public sector employees have a gold-plated pension. No, in fact the far

POLICY BRIEF Visit us at: www.tiaa-crefinstitute.org. September 2004 The 2004 Report of the Social Security Trustees: Social Security Shortfalls, Social Security Reform and Higher Education The 2004 Social

The American Council of Life Insurers Written Statement for the Record for Tax Reform and Tax-Favored Retirement Accounts Committee on Ways and Means United States House of Representatives April 17, 2012

NCPERS Testimony for Briefing On Private Sector Pension/Retirement Plans by Hank Kim, Esq. Executive Director and Counsel National Conference on Public Employee Retirement Systems (NCPERS) Before the Pensions

It s not about how much money you earn. It s about how much you save and invest. November 12, 2015 A TIAA-CREF Financial Essentials Workshop Bill Thorne TIAA-CREF Money At Work 1: Foundations of investing

INDIANA PUBLIC RETIREMENT SYSTEM Understanding Indiana s Largest Pension System March 27, 2015 Funds Overview The Indiana Public Retirement System (INPRS) includes the two largest public retirement plans

Planning for the Stages of _ Retirement _ Retirement is being reinvented. It s no longer our parent s retirement. Social Security alone w o n t see us through retirement, especially for higher income earners.

Welcome! Thanks for investing your time today. Please sign in Fill out your name tag Address your mail card It s not about how much money you earn. It s about how much you save and invest. October 2015

Notes - Gruber, Public Finance Chapter 13 - Social Security Social Security started in 1935 in Great Depression. Asset values had fallen drastically, many elderly lost their lifetime savings. Workers pay

Public Pension Issues and Trends Texas Municipal Retirement System Keith Brainard Research Director National Association of State Retirement Administrators May 22, 2015 Comparison of retirement benefits

Your 401(k) Rollover Guide The best approach to rollovers is often the simplest. A simple decision may make a big difference to your future. Whether you re changing jobs or retiring, leaving your employer

Second Quarter 2009 Special for Plan Sponsors Regarding Target Date Funds Bud Green, AIF Target date mutual funds have become increasingly popular as 401(k) plan investment options. Three years ago, about

Retirement today requires more planning than for previous generations. Americans are living longer many will live 20 to 30 years or more in retirement. Finding a way to make savings last over such a long

Chair Pomeroy and Members, Social Security has met the social insurance promise to ensure workers will not have to live in old age poverty. This promise needs to be guaranteed for current and future workers.

November 14 Target-date funds: the to versus through dilemma Leo M. Zerilli, CIMA Head of Investments John Hancock Investments Recent U.S. Department of Labor guidance on target-date funds provides helpful

A guide to: Retirement Account Rollovers Making wise decisions for your future Insight + Process = Results SM Retiring? Changing jobs? In transition? If any of these situations apply to you and you participate

Retirement on the Brain Your Retirement Plan: Don t pass up the perks Retirement on the Brain Your Retirement Plan Understanding the advantages of your retirement plan is crucial in making wise savings

The Truth About Fixed Indexed Annuities Index annuities were first introduced in the United States nearly two decades ago. They were initially created as an alternative to mutual funds and variable annuities,

Why is Life Insurance a Popular Funding Vehicle for Nonqualified Retirement Plans? By Peter N. Katz, JD, CLU ChFC This article is a sophisticated analysis about the funding of nonqualified retirement plans.

PENSION INNOVATION FOR CANADIANS: THE TARGET BENEFIT PENSION PLAN SUBMISSION TO THE DEPARTMENT OF FINANCE, CANADA, FROM THE CONGRESS OF UNION RETIREES OF CANADA, JUNE 23, 2014. The Congress of Union Retirees

October 2009 Document 209097 Retooling Canada s Ailing Pension System Now, For The Future Canada s Actuaries Advocate Change About the Canadian Institute of Actuaries The Canadian Institute of Actuaries

NOVEMBER 2012 ARIZONA Arizona s Pension Challenges: The Need for an Affordable, Secure, and Sustainable Retirement Plan The funding level of Arizona s public employee retirement systems has declined every

April 15, 2015 Senate Finance Committee Public Hearing Hearing Room 1, North Office Building, Capitol Complex, Harrisburg, PA Dear Members of the Committee, Thank you for the opportunity to provide testimony

Intermediate Savings Goals Prior to Retirement White Paper on Retirement, November 2014 Richard C Marston, Wharton School Saving for retirement is tough for young and old alike. Most of us know how important

SAN FRANCISCO RETIREMENT FAQS In early March 2011, hundreds of Local 21 San Francisco members attended retirement and healthcare security meetings at worksites across the city. The meetings were designed

Retirement Security June 2006 Public Policy Issue Statement Background Retirement plans represent an important aspect of the total compensation package used by employers to recruit and retain employees.

IAPF Presentation Retirement Income Industry Association Steve Mitchell US Retirement Scheme Coverage 40% of households are not covered by an employer sponsored retirement scheme Percent of US Households

Tax Policy and Middle-Income Boomers The Importance of Tax Deferral in Attaining Retirement Security March 2012 About the Insured Retirement Institute: The Insured Retirement Institute (IRI) is a not-for-profit

The Case For Employer-Sponsored Retirement Plans Benefits and Accomplishments April 2009 www.sparkinstitute.org www.sparkinstitute.org 1 About The SPARK Institute The SPARK Institute represents the interests

Vanguard Financial Education Series investing How to invest your retirement savings During your working life, you ve saved and invested for retirement. Now that you re finally reaching retirement, consider

PRESENT LAW AND BACKGROUND RELATING TO MULTIEMPLOYER DEFINED BENEFIT PENSION PLANS AND RELATED PROVISIONS OF H.R. 2830, THE PENSION PROTECTION ACT OF 2005 Scheduled for a Public Hearing Before the SUBCOMMITTEE

August 19, 2015 U.S. Department of Labor Advisory Council on Employee Welfare and Pension Plan Benefits Comments from Jeff Stein, VP of Operations at Nationwide on the topic of Model notices and education

Nearing Retirement: How to Use Your 401k/457 to Prepare for Retirement 5/9/14 Disclaimers The content of this presentation is for informational purposes only. This information does not constitute investment

Understanding Actuarial Information By Richard H. Harris Annual required contributions for state and local government pension plans are based on plan data, plan provisions, and actuarial assumptions of

Annexure 1- Detailed Guide CAPE PENINSULA UNIVERSITY OF TECHNOLOGY RETIREMENT FUND COMMISSION FREE PENSION QUOTATIONS When you reach retirement, you will face a difficult decision as to what pension to

The Truth about the State Employees Retirement System of Illinois The State Employees Retirement System (SERS) began in 1944 as a core benefit for state and local employers to use in attracting and retaining

An Insider s Guide to Annuities Whatever your picture of retirement, the best way to get there and enjoy it once you ve arrived is with a focused, thoughtful plan. Introduction 2 What is an Annuity?...

The underrated impact of taxes on retirement Research study Nearly one out of every three dollars spent by high-income retirees goes to taxes, according to a study by Lincoln Financial Group. Most future

TASK FORCE ON SUSTAINABLE FUNDING OF BALTIMORE CITY S FIRE AND POLICE PENSION SYSTEM By THE GREATER BALTIMORE COMMITTEE The City of Baltimore is facing a serious fiscal challenge. Current contributions

Stock Market Fluctuations and Retiree Incomes: An Update by Gary Burtless THE BROOKINGS INSTITUTION SOCIAL SECURITY WAS CREATED in the middle of the Great Depression. The recent dive in stock prices and

Dollars and Sense Introduction Your dream is to operate a profitable business and make a good living. Before you open, however, you want some indication that your business will be profitable, if not immediately

LABORPARTY Financing Just Health Care Labor Party Briefing Paper Revised February 2002 The Labor Party proposes a national health insurance program for the United States that would provide universal coverage

Callan InvesTmenTs InsTITuTe ReseaRCH June 2010 Investment Return Assumptions for Public Funds The Historical Record The return assumptions that public defined benefit plans use to calculate both future

National Association of Government Defined Contribution Administrators, Inc. FACTORING HEALTH CARE COSTS INTO YOUR RETIREMENT PLAN The unfortunate state of Americans financial preparedness for retirement

The Basics of Annuities: PLANNING FOR INCOME NEEDS TABLE OF CONTENTS Income Beyond the Paycheck...1 The Facts of Retirement...2 What Is an Annuity?...2 What Type of Annuity Is Right for Me?...2 Payment

March 2013 The Basics of Annuities: Planning for Income Needs summary the facts of retirement Earning income once your paychecks stop that is, after your retirement requires preparing for what s to come

The purchase of any financial product involves a trade off. For example when saving for retirement, you are often faced with making a trade off between how much you want to protect your investments from

Company Pension Plans in Canada This article provides an introduction to company pension plans as well as a discussion of several issues currently facing company pension plans in Canada. Company pension

The path to retirement success How important are your investment and spending strategies? In this VIEW, Towers Watson Australia managing director ANDREW BOAL reports on investing for retirement success

STUDENT MODULE 5.3 SAVING AND INVESTING PAGE 1 Standard 5: The student will analyze the costs and benefits of saving and investing. Saving and Investing Tools Miley and Hanna are both turning 16 this year

GAO United States Government Accountability Office Report to the Committee on Finance, U.S. Senate January 2008 STATE AND LOCAL GOVERNMENT RETIREE BENEFITS Current Funded Status of Pension and Health Benefits

MAP-21 SUPPLEMENT TO ANNUAL FUNDING NOTICE OF THE ACADEMY OF NATURAL SCIENCES OF PHILADELPHIA PENSION PLAN FOR PLAN YEAR BEGINNING JANUARY 1, 2013 AND ENDING DECEMBER 31, 2013 ( Plan Year ) This is a temporary

Retirement Income Planning With Annuities Your Relationship With Your Finances There are some pretty amazing things that happen around the time of retirement. For many, it is a time of incredible change,

January 2016 COLA Set at 2% Well-Managed Public Pensions What You Don t Hear About in the News Don t Jeopardize Your Benefits! Know and Follow the Limits on Post-Retirement Employment Contact Us PO Box

Background Connecticut State Employee Collective Bargaining and Retirement Benefits State employees through their bargaining units have had the authority under state law to collectively bargain on wages,

2 The Facts of Life and Annuities Introduction... 4 7 Key Facts... 5 Life Insurance Ownership Is Widespread, but Inadequate... 6 Most Individual Life Insurance Policies Are Permanent... 8 Why Life Insurance

RETIREMENT INCOME CRISIS: INEVITABLE OR AVOIDABLE? THE ECONOMIC REALITY A MESSAGE FROM HOOPP PRESIDENT & CEO, JIM KEOHANE March 17, 2014 The following White Paper, entitled Retirement Income Crisis: Inevitable

Benefit Accumulation Account Saving to Make Your Dreams Possible. 1 Get to your dreams faster. Dream #1 Daily walks on the beach. 2 Pension Fund: A Name You Can Trust Pension Fund serves its members as

The Benefits of a Fully Funded Social Security System By Nathan Taulbee I. INTRODUCTION The Social Security system, formally known as Old-Age and Survivors Insurance Disability Insurance (OASDI), began

Social Security Frequently Asked Questions I m too young to care about Social Security, aren t I? We must protect Social Security for our parents and grandparents Many young people have grandparents or

Statement for the Record on Mutual Fund Industry Practices And Their Effect On Investors before the United States House of Representatives Committee on Financial Services Subcommittee on Capital Markets,

Variable Annuity Pension Plans an Emerging Retirement Plan Design Variable annuity pension plans (VAPPs) are not new but may deserve a second look by plan sponsors seeking a more secure retirement plan

The Individual Annuity a re s o u rc e i n yo u r r e t i r e m e n t an age of Decision Retirement today requires more planning than for previous generations. Americans are living longer many will live

Challenges in the Life Insurance Industry Remarks by Superintendent Julie Dickson Office of the Superintendent of Financial Institutions Canada (OSFI) to the 2010 Life Insurance Invitational Forum Cambridge,

Utah State Retirement Systems Overview September 9, 2009 Prepared by the Office of Legislative Research and General Counsel Utah State Retirement Systems Six Participant Systems Judges Public Employees