Is there sufficient evidence in Sources D to J to explain why the Troubles broke out in Northern Ireland in 1969?

Extracts from this document...

Introduction

Is there sufficient evidence in Sources D to J to explain why the Troubles broke out in Northern Ireland in 1969? Problems began in Ireland long before 1969's troubles and continue today. The dilemmas are a consequence of an ongoing reason, which is the opinion of some people in Northern Ireland that those of the opposite religion are attempting to overpower and enforce a certain way of life upon the rest of Northern Ireland's civilisation. This problem stems back along way to similar events when King Henry VIII changed the religion of England from Roman Catholic to Protestant, he tried to enforce this in Ireland too but met strong opposition, as most of the Irish remained loyal to the Catholic Church so there was danger of an Irish rebellion. Continuing into the reign of Queen Elizabeth I (1558-1603) the worry was that Ireland would become allies with England's catholic enemies because many Irish Catholic lords rebelled against English rule and Protestantism. They received harsh treatment and the Elizabethan attempt to conquer Ireland ended in 1601,when, to reward her Protestant supporters, Elizabeth gave them lands taken from the Catholic Irish rebel leaders. ...read more.

Middle

Houses, jobs, and votes being unmistakably unfairly allocated, lead to the setting up of the CRA. Protestants were kept in employment in times of depression in preference to fellow Catholic workers. For instance in 1961, 68/75 bus drivers in the city of Fermanagh were Protestant. The unfair election system called "The Gerrymander" supplied the majority of votes to Protestants. 25'000 adults were therefore disenfranchised for local elections, nearly all of them being Catholics. Source F is an example of the issue of unfair voting within Northern Ireland. The map shows that in one ward the Catholic voters had 10'047 of the 11'185 votes, which is evidently unfair. On the other hand, the other two wards shown on the map have a Protestant domination of votes. Overall, the source shows that there was unfair distribution of votes, which is another significant reason in the build-up to Ireland's troubles of 1969. Still, although this appears to suggest that Protestants were being unnecessarily harsh to Catholics, another factor not portrayed in the sources is the Protestants reasons for fearing a United Ireland. Since they regarded Catholics as their enemies, they did not want to give them higher positions because they felt the Catholics would destroy them. ...read more.

Conclusion

Though not entirely happy, the Unionists, who wanted Ireland to remain closely linked with Britain, accepted Home Rule (Britain's control) in just the six counties of Ulster. However, the Nationalists continued to fight for a United Independent Ireland. Catholics and Protestants live in both the two divided countries. Therefore partition has been ineffective in bringing peace to Ireland. Instead friction continued to cause major issues between the two religions but this is not mentioned in any of the supplied sources and so fails to contribute to a listing of foundations on which Ireland's troubles have developed. This is yet another example of further causes that built up to 1969's trouble. However without these mentioned in Sources D to I, there is not sufficient information to generate a fairly decided conclusion to why troubles broke out in Northern Ireland in 1969. The Sources are well selected and show a diverse collection of important aspects that contributed to the troubles of 1969.They give a reasonable idea of some causes of Irelands problems. On the other hand many events of greater importance are not mentioned. Therefore I do not think there is sufficient evidence in them to fully and fairly explain why the troubles broke out in Northern Ireland in 1969. LAUREN BAKER 11B4 -History Coursework on Ireland ...read more.

Related GCSE Northern Ireland 1965-85 essays

so they sent in the 'Black and tans' and the Auxiliaries, ex-soldiers and ex-army officers. However, despite the attempts to control the situation the Catholics and Protestants continued to fight and cause destruction. This left the British government in a state of hopelessness.

In the face of what could have been a political victory for the British, they made the error of executing the surviving Irish rebels, martyring them and instilling anger and determination in the minds of many Irish Nationalists. The dilemma of Home Rule as the British saw it was how

And a war needs an army, and the only army which Catholics believe that they could call on was the IRA. The Protestant Perspective When we look at how Protestants use violence against Catholics, we have to remember we're talking about a minority of Protestants.

"If there is to be any hope of prosperity for this country it is by reversing that policy which made us simply the kitchen garden for supplying the British with cheap food." The statement above is from De Valero and he talks about how England has used Ireland for its own purposes.

The party was formed out the split in the IRA in January 1970 when the original SF split into the Official SF and the Provisional SF. The party began to take part in elections following the success in Westminster by - elections by Republican prisoners who took part in the 'Hunger Strike' of 1981.

According to source L 'much religious bitterness in the growing industrial town where the population was being swollen by rural Catholic immigration.' Catholic funerals were by way of Sandy Row to Friar's Bush. Source L states that proceedings were frequently 'boohed at, insulted and attacked' during it route to Friar's Bush.

This emphasises the long-term disagreements between the Protestants and the Catholics, which finally led to the Troubles. Source D certainly gives evidence that Catholics and Protestants didn't get along. It suggests that they Catholics felt that the Protestants weren't really Irish.

In 1922, tension still increased in Ireland with the Partiton in Ireland occurring. Unionists and Nationalists movements emerged with both movements arming themselves to achieve their aims. Following a bitter war, the British MP Government partitioned Ireland and created Northern Ireland.