Do you have a topic that is an immediate deal breaker if a manga series you were already reading suddenly featured that topic, such that you would stop reading the series (even if it was "tastefully" done)? For example: religion, rape, etc.

Sakura had lived with her grandma ever since her parents died in a car accident when she was three. When she turned fourteen, her grandma also passed away, leaving her alone. Just when she was about to give up hope having a family, out of nowhere, four guys claim to be her older half-brothers.

---

- Himitsu no Tobira no Kugurikata (Vol. 4)Terasima Tika has always wished to meet her prince charming. When she accidentally enters the 'Spirit Door' and is placed in the body of her brother, she is forced to be him for the day and go to an all boy's school where she hopes to finally meet her prince.

It's Hari Tokeino, man. I love this guy's works. The art may be simple but they are so cute (esp when children/babies are involved. So damn cute. Unf). So far, all of his/her works are really enjoyable reads and this one is not all bad. There's drama but it's fairly subtle. For the most part, I was worried about the protagonist's eldest brother going for his youngest sister (LOL) when she had a decent school boy falling for her too. And, you might get tired of the brother-sister complex as well (LMAO) because in this manga, nearly everyone has it. Anyway, what kept me reading was the subtle comedy as well. I'm a sucker for funny side characters. This manga has that sort of thing and it's good overall. Check the mangakas other works if you liked this one (or you liked it but couldn't finish it due to the brother-sister stuff).

At the beginning it was all about family and fun. I thought it was cute and adorable. Then a timeskip happened and our main character grew. She's now into relationships, and it her brother. That's the point I barley made it past chapter 7 (I think I went farther than that, but I can't think). It just left me uneasy with the characters.

It started out alright, the characters were cute and the brothers all very sweet. The comedy was not bad...at first, then it gets repetitive and boring.

The heroine started off being the cutsy weak shoujo type of girl. It would be fine if she was not pathetic. One would expect improvement in characters with the development, but no, she gets more and more infuriating. But alas, once she is in love with the eldest brother, her life simply revolved around the question of 'does he/will he love me?', consisting of her acting like a mouse in front of her brother 24/7. Of course being the pathetic girl she is, she does not do anything herself to help their relationship progress.

Another problem is with her love interest that is a man who should really be born a woman. While I do not have a problem with incest, I have a huge problem with his personality. Do not take me wrong, I accept men acting girly, but apart from his occasional spouts of manliness, he is beyond the point of girliness to the extent that it feels like this should really be a yuri about the love life of two shoujo girls.

To sum it up. Yes the first few books are interesting and sweet. After around volume 7 or 8 (it has been a while since I read this) everything goes down hill.

Yeah i know... Ewww incest/older guys/lolicon/ or whatever u thinkIs disgusting bout this manga... But phew! This thing is hilarious!!! Its not gonna give u the creeps of older men younger girl nor sibling as lover "relationship" this is jist simply funny, heart warming, and you'll never get bored of the characters xD i love this manga!!

When I first read the preview for this series in one of the Fruits Basket volumes, I thought it was a good read, I almost went ahead and bought the books, I'm glad I didn't...they have up to volume 6 in my local library and I decided to check them out....Sakura and her brothers started off like really fun characters, but then Sakura and the brother's developed a very strong brother-sister complex that I just found annoying....then Sakura falls for

Spoiler (highlight to view)

the oldest brother

, and things just go downhill from there.....There are a lot of cuter manga out there that do not have such a needy character....It started out promising, but it soon went down the drain...

At first, like many others, I didn't like the manga. Now, though, I've fallen in love with it. It's not just Tokeino's main story that endeared this series to me, but her one-shots that are included many of the volumes, as well. Definitely check it out!

A couple years ago I read the first chapter or so of this series and found it boring, cliché, annoying, and not worth continuing. Then the other day I was at my local library and they had volumes 4-5. I was bored, and figured they were worth a read if I didn't have to pay anything for them, so I checked them out and read them. And I loved them!! Then I went back and read the first chapter scanlated, again. And I could see why my first impression was so bad—the first chapter really was boring, cliché and annoying (there seemed to be some mistakes in the fan-translation which only added to my un-impressed-ness).

So my point is, the beginning of the story (at least the first chapter, possibly more) is dull, but the later volumes are pretty fun and definitely worth reading (I'm considering buying the rest of the series now as it comes out because I don't want to wait for my library to get them). Also, amusingly, I wasn't confused at all jumping into the middle of the series, even though my memory of the beginning of the series was quite foggy. The family-aspect is really sweet and the characters are all lovable and fun. The art is adorable. Don't give up on it like I almost did!

I also wanted to say I love all the random dudes with mustaches that Tokeino-sensei draws in the backgrounds and sidebar panels. They remind me of the Pink Panther cartoons or something... they're hilarious!!

haha, it's nice and funny. it makes me laugh. the art, is sometimes a little wacky, but is still pretty good. at first i didn't like the idea of the girl loving her not-blood brother. One reason was that she was too young. (when we found out that she loves him that way, she was only a 8th grader!!! and he's like, 20 something!?) So i didn't like that very much. but i just finish with vol. 5 and she's in 10th grade! yay! at least now, it doesn't feel so wrong. XDand since they aren't real siblings by blood....this manga is pretty good.