A Heated Debate Between Two Charismatic Geniuses: A Cardinal Fan (Jeff Lung) and a Tiger Fan (Allen Krause)

A Call for a Ban on Crappy Nicknames

Oh jeez.

In 2005, the St. Louis Cardinals called up a 27 year-old lifetime minor leauger to get his first hacks at the big league level. That man’s name was John Rodriguez.

Don’t remember him? No worries. Most people don’t.

Mr. Rodriguez came on pretty strong during his brief glimpse of the Majors, hitting .295 with 5 HRs and 24 RBI in 149 at-bats. The folks in St. Louis liked him and his cinderella story so much that someone decided to grace Mr. Rodriguez with the nickname: J-Rod (a la A-Rod, K-Rod, YourMom-Rod, et al).

J-Rod *ahem* wasn’t a fan of the name. Why? Maybe because he wasn’t A-Rod! To be honest, he wasn’t anywhere close to being an A-Rod type player. His greatest downfall was was being born with the same easily nicknameable name as poster boy Alex while also having a first initial that contained just one syllable (you see, W-Rod would never work).

Flash forward to December 7th, 2009 and my trusty misanthrope of a colleague, Mr. Allen Krause, deigns us with the phonetically challenged nickname “Pla-Po” for his beloved (and now long gone from Detroit) Placido Polanco.

Pla-Po? Are you kidding me? How is that even pronounced? PLAY-Poh? Plah-POH? Ah, forget it; all I know is that it sucks.

So, please know, Mr. Krause, that from now on we are calling for a complete ban on poorly constructed nicknames, specifically on those you created. For those of you dear readers unaware, the following Krausian nicknames shall no longer be used, under any circumstances, lest you wish the worst on the baseball-politico community:

14 Comments

K.Y. Kill-Us…Hmmm…I like the “Kill Us” idea, if the “us” is the opponent, but K.Y.? Not so much. We’ll stick with “Youk”, “Youk Dog”, etc.! (How will KY Jelly kill us, after all?)😉
Harry Nancy, eh? Sounds like a caveman version of the illustrious Speaker…

Jeff,
I know I call that balkd-headed member of the Red Sox Nation Kevin U-Kill-us because we get to see that mug 17 times a year.
But there are some good nicknames still present in the MLB.
I still love “Zorilla” for Ben Zobrist for the way he burst on the MLB scene to the rest of you in 2009. We always knew he had the right stuff. That is why he was “Benzo” before Rays Manager Joe Maddon popped the “Zorilla” on him.
Even if a true zorilla is a little striped polecat found in west and south Africa.
Ahhh, research can make these names better (lol).

Greg — Actually, for many people, KY makes it a more pleasurable experience🙂 And I’m all for “Your Hirsuteness”… if I can figure out what it means🙂
RR — Zorilla beat Benzo any day, man! And thanks for the research. I had no idea it was a real animal!
Julia — Hehe… it makes me chuckle, I cannot lie.
–Jeff

Jeff, “hirsute” means “hairy”–nothing more. Hence “Harry Nancy”…also, ergo, the caveman reference (perhaps Victor, Renegade’s interview topic).😉
But the funny thing to me, as one who (like you) likes to turn words around, is that it sounds like a word that would be in a Monty Python royal proclamation (“Hear ye, hear ye, forsooth hirsute…ah, whatever…)
As for KY Kill You, perhaps that experience would be the “death” of you?😉 Hmmm!…

Meta

The following are trademarks or service marks of Major League Baseball entities and may be used only with permission of Major League Baseball Properties, Inc. or the relevant Major League Baseball entity: Major League, Major League Baseball, MLB, the silhouetted batter logo, World Series, National League, American League, Division Series, League Championship Series, All-Star Game, and the names, nicknames, logos, uniform designs, color combinations, and slogans designating the Major League Baseball clubs and entities, and their respective mascots, events and exhibitions.