Doing game by game rankings is better imo, because having all the AA characters together would lead to a lot of conflict and be more boring, as you wonder whether Buddy Faith is better than Dustin Prince or something. Anyway, here we are:

^I'm inclined to agree, some of the characters are really hard to compare to each other and all in all it can get really overwhelming. I've wanted to do a new ranking but gave up because of that, so I'm borrowing the concept. I ranked the characters based on how much I like them in the games in question, hence why some main characters may shift spots at times.

Haha, right? There he had some goofy charm and was a damn hero in the fourth case. In the investigation games he was very flat as a character and mostly annoying. And in SoJ he was downright creepy :/

Yeah, right :/ And then in 3-2 he just acted like a jerk to Phoenix and hit on a married woman. Which in all honesty should have been a hint to his creepiness in SoJ.

Quote:

Haha yeah, I thought deKiller at least added to the plot.

Well, technically Hotti…kinda did? He gave you Ini's driver's license. Though that is a pretty weak justification XD

Quote:

It was a low point for most main characters xD

It was bad for characters in general, honestly XD Even the guy who made this forgot to add Constance Courte to the DD characters, which says a lot. But yeah, with main characters it was really bad. You have the weirdness of Aploplo (and even he's in the top three, which is saying something) Trucy reduced to a gag character, Athena who's mostly there while bogging up the cast. And somehow Pearl is below Klavier here, which is really saying a lot.

To be fair though, I think he's better at art than people give him credit for. He made two of the Thinker, and his sketches are realistic looking- except that of the bridge sketch, but he drew the thing in a hurry while in a sleeping position.

Quote:

Oh that's right, poor Constance. She seemed nice.

She seemed nice, yeah. Among other errors I noticed was Bellboy being a JFA character; Pearl being an AAI character; Betty not being an SoJ character; and dual identities getting separated (like Callisto and Shih-na & Nayna and Amara). Also did all the victims show up? I don't recall ranking Cindy, Jack or Goodman among a few others :(

To be fair though, I think he's better at art than people give him credit for. He made two of the Thinker, and his sketches are realistic looking- except that of the bridge sketch, but he drew the thing in a hurry while in a sleeping position.

^That, and also I think some of the victims are a bit more fleshed out than just being a name and a face even though we never got to meet them (excluding the ones that we do get to meet and are realized characters).

You cannot post new topics in this forumYou cannot reply to topics in this forumYou cannot edit your posts in this forumYou cannot delete your posts in this forumYou cannot post attachments in this forum