Well, this is a pleasant change, discussing modeling 'the norm'. It seems that modeling too often leans toward the gimmicky exaggerated worn out look. Weathered but maintained as in ordinary everyday use is (for me) more appealing.

Any railroad with the sort of broken down and downright dangerous equipment often seen on some model railroads would soon be out of business. Logging is a classic example where the true condition of equipment is overlooked (or ignored) in favour of the 'cute' caricture of the shoe-string operation. Companies then, as now, realised you can't turn a profit if your equipment keeps breaking all the time.

On the Shorpy.com site there is a pic, search "Homeward bound 1938" . I don't know if you would call it over the top weathering or just flat used up. If you look at the details in the photo, like the guys shoes (toe exposed) , socks(pinned to his pants), the truck bed wired together or the parking block behind the tire, the whole scene is just flat used up and worn out. It good be a good shot for Woodies layout. From the look on his face all looks bad but that's all he has got. Makes me glad I'm where I'm at.
Clif K

____________________Clif Korlaske

OWNER,OPERATOR,CHIEF COOK,& BOTTLE WASHER
W.C.L.M.RY
Favorite Quote
"How old will you be before your as stupid as you think I am?"