Auto Suggestions are available once you type at least 3 letters. Use up arrow (for mozilla firefox browser alt+up arrow) and down arrow (for mozilla firefox browser alt+down arrow) to review and enter to select.

Overview

Sherlock Holmes has retired. After a cruel accident during a fruitless chase for Moriarty, Holmes is maimed badly enough that he declares he will no longer solve the crimes of the London streets. But then a letter comes. A letter imploring him to investigate the Opera Populaire's ghost. The spectre everyone has heard rumours of, but only one has seen.

Customer Reviews

Most Helpful Customer Reviews

Rendezvous at the Populaire - A Novel of Sherlock Holmes 4 out of 5based on
0 ratings.
3 reviews.

Philip_K_Jones

More than 1 year ago

This is the first book in a projected series of Sherlockian tales by Ms. Workman. This tale has a small number of editing errors, mostly misused words or terminology. In any case, editing is not a major concern, as it has been for so many new authors lately. Another characteristic is that the book 'reads' as if it had been translated from the French. This is odd, but it has the 'feel' of a number of Sherlockian tales I have read that were so translated. Also, a few of the terms used were 'out of context.'
The author credits Sam Siciliano's "The Angel of the Opera" which involves Sherlock with 'The Phantom of the Opera' as an inspiration, but I found this book to be more interesting. On the other hand, I never really enjoyed Mr. Siciliano's effort in the first place. For Sherlockians, the Holmes they meet in this book is a new person. The utter self-confidence and disdain for others that pervades the Canonical Holmes is absent here. This Holmes is chastened and unsure of himself.
I have never read the original "Phantom of the Opera," by Gaston Leroux nor have I ever seen any of the Plays built on the character. From that viewpoint, this is a relatively new story for me, so I have no preconceptions or emotional ties to the tale. This book has an original approach to the classic tale and draws serious lines between the characters of Erik and Sherlock. I am unsure of the degree of culpability that Erik's original had, but this book presents him as a sympathetic character whose violence is only used to protect others or to prevent his own destruction.
The plot moves right along and the characters are mostly well drawn. One almost feels that the heroine is really more than a pretty face attached to a pretty voice and the hero actually attains a sort of stature at the end. I must admit that it took a while to see him as a serious person and I'm not sure that the impression will last. Mostly, this book concerns Holmes and Erik so that their confrontations, both with their own inner demons and with each other are the actual tale told here. The other supporting cast members are mostly interesting and even attractive, in a perverse way. I especially liked the managers, for whom the phrase "dumb as a box of rocks" may have been invented.
As a first effort, this book is good. As a Sherlockian pastiche, it is readable and inventive. The author's vision of Holmes in the grip of misfortunes is compelling. Although it contradicts the Canonical presentation, it presents a number of intriguing points and it seems to have a good amount of legitimacy if one accepts the author's premises. It has become common practice for authors to submit their manuscripts to a group of knowledgeable fans for discussion and error checking before publication. This author would benefit from wider early exposure and discussion. She has talent and good ideas but could use more active discussion in advance of publication.
Reviewed by: Philip K. Jones, June, 2011

Anonymous

More than 1 year ago

I liked the part where Watson was taking care of Holmes after he got shot, and I also liked the part where Erik let Watson lie down and get warm after he had neary frozen.

rickstilwell

More than 1 year ago

I enjoyed this book more than I thought I would, mainly picking it up with the Sherlock side of the stories being at the top of my list lately (ELEMENTARY, BBC's SHERLOCK, R Downey Jr's SHERLOCK HOLMES). I really appreciated the character interplay as Holmes seeks out the &quot;real person&quot; behind the &quot;phantom&quot; - how he interacts with regular folks and then is enamored with Erik. Great take on two great characters. Finding them near equals in a lot of ways brings a whole new vibe to both.

America's first African American heavyweight boxing champion, Jack Johnson, has a chance encounter with a
mysterious Irishman, named Altamont, when they meet at the boxer's restaurant, Café de Champion, in August 1912. Johnson's new relationship with the unusual man, with ...

Erik has returned and has brought an interesting character to Holmes's attention: Dr. Henry Jekyll.
It appears Jekyll is experimenting on an unsanctioned patient in an effort to prove his theories concerning human nature correct. But who is the patient ...

A sequel to Shadowfall, this novel continues the adventures of Holmes as a man of
two worlds, gifted with both deductive and magical powers.The convalescing Watson's country holiday is brought to an abrupt end when an eccentric recluse named Edgar ...

When the sacred relics and mystical objects of London begin disappearing, Sherlock Holmes must call
on more than his powers of deduction to solve a mystery that threatens the safety of the British Empire and Doctor Watsons mortal soul.

In a new novel of supernatural adventure, Sherlock Holmes faces his greatest challenge, to locate
and defeat the wraith of a powerful wizard. With the assistance of an incorruptible saint, an immortal librarian, a troupe of ghosts, a Scotland Yard ...

Sherlock Holmes and Doctor John Watson are returning to London from Bucharest after the great
detective has interceded in a delicate matter relating to the Rumanian Royal House. As they depart from Bucharest they receive their mail forwarded from London. ...

Emotion-filled memories come cascading from the mind of Britain’s foremost investigator as a troubled Glastonbury
sends its emissaries to beg help in solving a series of poisonings besetting a region Holmes had experienced and explored as a young lad.Somerset, battleground ...

A call from an old comrade has Holmes chasing a reported agent of Satan between
the towering tors and bottomless bogs of Dartmoor only to find the limits of his own confidence and his Public's esteem. Only Watson stands his ...