It looks like you're enjoying The BBQ Brethren's Forums but haven't created an account yet. Why not take a minute to register for your own free account now? As a member you get free access to all of our forums and posts plus the ability to post your own messages, communicate directly with other members, and much more. Register now!

Already a member? Login at the top of this page to stop seeing this message.

I've not been one to use foil a lot when cooking but over the past couple years I've heard a lot of other folks talking about foiling meat when smoking after a while and letting it cook in the foil for the rest of the smoking/cooking time. I've seen quite a few posts on here with guys using foil as well.

I am curious about how you guys that foil do it. Do you wrap it tightly and double the foil or do you loosely put the foil on it? Do you make like a foil pan with the top opened a bit or do you close it off completely? I've mostly used foil to cook blooming/smoked onions with butter and have finished off a couple of chuckies using a foil pan but I've always poured a little beer in the pan for the chuckies. When you do ribs, for example, and foil how do you keep the ribs from adhering to the foil? Same question for brisket.

I don't mind experimenting a little with the foil if I have some base knowledge of the techniques used what I don't want is to end up with a piece of meat that you have to scrap foil off when you plate it OR worse yet, having to pick chunks of foil out of my teeth.

Thanks in advance for the info guys. Ya'll have always been a huge library of information and I know there will be a whole plethora of ideas shared.

Brethren have truly helped me kick my cooking skills up a notch since I've been a member and for that, I'm TRULY thankful.

The primary purpose of the foil is to push through the stall by braising, which means a fairly tight seal and maybe a little added liquid (or letting the meats own juices perform that magic.

Covering a pan with foil is purely convenience, and it works basically the same as above (but not quite as effectively from the braising perspective). It is a lot easier to manage a pan than meat wrapped in foil, especially if you wish to reserve the juices.

When I foil meat, if I get a good seal with one layer of foil (and it is HD foil) then I am happy with that. OTherwise you need more layers to make sure it holds together and doesn't tear or puncture as you move it to the cooker.

I get a realy long strip of foil, and place the meat centered on one half of the foil, then take the other half to fold over, bring the sheets together as cleanly as possible, then crimp up and seal tightly.

Because you are pushing through the stall, if you don't check your meat, you may find yourself overcooking it before you know it on your first few attempts.

(wait a minute....what the FARK am I doing posting over here in Q-Talk???)

I pan up and foil the pan w/ pork butts that I do Hot and Fast as that is the way I learned to do them HnF that way. However I need try to do a HnF (~325 degrees) without foil method to see how it turns out. I also need to try ~275ish without panning up/foiling as well to determine which way I like the most.

Butts no foil cook through to probe tender like Buttah
Ribs depends on what I'm after. Sometimes 3-2-1 sometimes cook through no foil
Chuckie always foil in a pan of veggies and broth at 160* until probe tender like Buttah
Brisket foil the flat at 160* until probe tender like Buttah
Chicken no foil
Lamb no foil
Rib Roast no foil
Beef ribs no foil

I've done butts both ways. If you don't want much of a bark use foil. If you're after the old Southern way for Mr. Brown don't even think about foil. Foil does make handling easier. I really don't see the need for foil but I will use it occasionally if the situation warrants. Enough science for today.

The great advantage of foil is that it makes it a little more predictable how long the meat will take to cook. With practice is also makes a more predictable product easier to achieve. It is a valid tool if you are cooking just a few chunks of meat.

I use Heavy Duty foil, as wide as I can get. I generally will put a pan under it to move it around, as the bone easily punctures the foil. I vent the foil a little, a couple of holes, but, that is not necessary.

__________________the meat thermometer was so far past the top reading, it read Taylor

Give it a try. It may just fit your style. I use it to keep on time...when I really don't care how long a cook session takes I'll sometimes leave it uncovered. I usually inject and foil or a foil covered pan keep all this juice from winding up in the bottom of the cooker.
YMMV!