I do not have personal experience here as I speak French and am learning Italian, but to learn Swiss German, I think someone would really have to make an effort. From what native German speakers have told me, yes, some of the words are the same, but they don't understand most of Swiss German either!

I do not have personal experience here as I speak French and am learning Italian, but to learn Swiss German, I think someone would really have to make an effort. From what native German speakers have told me, yes, some of the words are the same, but they don't understand most of Swiss German either!

I have rarely (if ever) met a German who speaks or even tries to speak Swiss-German. All other nationalities - it seems to me - take the trouble to at least try and there are many who only having ever heard S-G cannot speak high-G.
If I ever get the chance of being born again and come to life in Switzerland I hope it will be as a member of the Valais community. I love the dialect.

Americans are "open" people and here I feel that the people are closed off.

Here in Europe, "loud" will be the adjective more often used rather than "open", so it's really down to cultural differences.

Quote:

I feel like every time I speak High German ( with my Accent) they want to speak back to me in English.

I've found there's a few reasons for this, most of which have already been cited here, such as English being a far more useful language here, career-wise, so it's in their interests to practice it, whenever they have a chance, with a native speaker. High German is also, ultimately, a foreign language for the Swiss, that they were forced to learn in school, so there's probably a bit of negative association with it (much like your average Irishman will have for Irish Gaelic after 12 years of schooling in it).

And you have to ask yourself; is their English better than my German? If so, it probably makes sense to communicate in the former, even if it doesn't help you learn the language.

Personally I just respond in German in such situations, ignoring the fact they're speaking in English, until they get the message - but yes, it makes learning German (or even knowing what to learn) a much slower process.

I have rarely (if ever) met a German who speaks or even tries to speak Swiss-German.

Germans, unless Swabian, have a problem with Swiss German when they move over here. It comes out of the subconscious assumption that Switzerland should be like Germany because they speak 'German'. The Germans are not alone in this - how many Americans are shocked to find that the UK is culturally very different to the US and vice versa, despite sharing the same language?

However, Germans being Germans, do tend to presume that the German way of doing something must me the only correct way, so they tend to look down on Swiss German as some feeble minded dialect - I've heard it called a Krüppelsprache in the past and have been told that it 'hurts' their ears to hear it.

Given this, if they do stay here long enough, they do seem to get used to it and have known a few who have learned to speak it and even admit to it having grown on them.

The following 3 users would like to thank Aeneas for this useful post:

btw, Italian in Ticino is almost Lombardo dialect which is almost pure Italian.

Don't call their dialect that to a Ticinese - they'll get terribly upset.

As for Lombardo being "pure Italian", it's not. The closest Italian dialect to standard Italian is Tuscan (you can thank Dante for that) and even there, there are some differences.

Quote:

Nowdays. Before Lambardo was much more Lombardo because Italian has massacrated all dialects, we now have only regional accents and dialacts are spoken among elder people which will be no more in some 20 years (God bless them).