DP's Office

Mich. Governor Signs ‘Anti-Tesla’ Bill

LANSING, Mich. — Michigan Governor Rick Snyder signed into law on Tuesday legislation that adds tighter restrictions on direct-to-consumer vehicle sales. The move effectively bans Tesla Motors from selling vehicles in the state.

Introduced in May, House Bill 5606 originally focused on prohibiting auto manufacturers from dictating what fees a franchised dealer can charge customers. But thanks to a procedural loophole, state lawmakers were able to toss in a last-minute amendment without public comment or debate. And that amendment reinforces a ban on selling vehicles directly to consumers.

The “Tesla Motors Team” reacted the day after the state legislature approved the legislation on Oct. 15. The electric-car maker called the bill a “raw deal,” writing that the last-minute change created an “effective prohibition against Tesla operating in Michigan. The company added that the move was a continuation of the “anti-competitive behavior” the company faced in New Jersey and Missouri.

“By striking a single, but critical word from … the law governing franchise relations in Michigan, the dealers seek to force Tesla into a body of law solely intended to govern the relationship between a manufacturer and its associated dealers,” Tesla stated in its blog post.

Gov. Snyder, however, said Tesla misunderstood what the new law does.

“The bill does not, as some have claimed, prevent auto manufacturers from selling automobiles directly to consumers at retail in Michigan,” Snyder said in a press release. “This is already prohibited under Michigan law.”

The last-minute amendment deleted the word “its” from a sentence in the existing law. A press release from the Governor’s office said that the change was made to allow manufacturers who don’t have their own franchised dealers to sell through another manufacturer’s dealer network.

Snyder added that lawmakers should discuss the current business model to determine if it was good for the state’s consumers.

“We should always be willing to re-examine our business and regulatory practices with an eye toward improving the customer experience for our citizens and doing things in a more efficient and less costly fashion,” said Snyder.

General Motors issued a statement yesterday in support of the legislation, saying the new law would "provide stability and support for our dealers.”

"Further, it will ensure we compete under the same rules in the marketplace as other automobile manufacturers," GM stated.

Comments

1.Sheldon Wolff[ October 22, 2014 @ 01:06PM ]

WOW! ok I'm kidding, like Michigan would let a manufacturer sell directly to consumers.... If this is a surprise to you then, let me tell you there is NO santa either! HIs cars aren't cheap, Yet!, they're selling, consumers want them. Detroit and the oil companies just have a huge hold on American economy. Just like when back in the early 19th century standard oil, ford, Edison, all the big industrialists strangled private enterprise. This will change, as his cars get more affordable, consumers will want one. Just like the right to repair bill is legal in Massachusetts as it should be!

Your Comment

The 1.1% third-quarter decrease in the Manheim Used Vehicle Value Index didn’t set off alarms despite it being the fifth straight decline in used-vehicle prices. The firm’s chief economist noted that the drop helped dealers increase vehicle turns as the market continues to inch toward more normal levels.