Nay. The guy has 14 strands of hair and insists on keeping it long. Not much charisma, too scrawny to be a "typical big man," too big and not seasoned enough to be a "good worker".... If he were to be released, I would not miss him slightly....

Nay. The guy has 14 strands of hair and insists on keeping it long. Not much charisma, too scrawny to be a "typical big man," too big and not seasoned enough to be a "good worker".... If he were to be released, I would not miss him slightly....

You have valid argument's however aside from his receding hairline, his charisma I disagree with. It's true heel charisma, you can't cheer this guy, he's a fucking dick and that bleeds through the screen to me. We need real heels and I feel that he's perfect for that role. Plus he has started to physically have real dynamic intensity about his work that I find believable for a WWE main eventer. He's only improving I think.

Not would I claim he's directly responsible for all the WWEs recent success, but he has to get some credit for carrying the company while Cena has been hurt and doing outside projects. If the fans were really against him in a top spot, they would likely reject the product. So even if you don't want to say he's solely responsible for the upward trends, he's at least part of the equation of success, for which he deserves credit. And if you're looking for a new star, you would want them to contribute to success in a similar manner to what Roman has.

Nay. The guy has 14 strands of hair and insists on keeping it long. Not much charisma, too scrawny to be a "typical big man," too big and not seasoned enough to be a "good worker".... If he were to be released, I would not miss him slightly....

Fives also brought up a good point about the rest of his look. He's tall, but nothing else about him is intimidating or even decent.

People always complain about a lot of the cruiserweights and others looking like "average Joes" but I never hear them complaining about Corbin on that front.

I can honestly say that I see guys like him on a regular basis around the local college campus. Tall guys who were good at sports in high school but that's about it. That's not the look of a world class wrestler.

Now, look isn't everything of course, but Corbin is lacking too much in other areas to make up for it.

Meh. The hair/chin strap beard is a big factor in his look. I thought for a second he'd dyed the front until I realised it has just his scalp showing through. The normal go to would be shave his head but with that awful beard I think he'd look worse.

Dean Ambrose has a way worse look, including balding, weird longish hair and street clothes that don't even have the added personality of Corbin's, and I don't see too much complaining about that.

He didn't put a foot wrong on Smackdown this week either. He is developing all the time and I think he will win a lot of people round in the end.

Dean Ambrose's look is probably the second biggest complaint against him, right after that forced rebound clothesline spot he does every single match. If Ambrose actually got some ring gear he would look much less out of place at the top of the card.

Dean Ambrose has a way worse look, including balding, weird longish hair and street clothes that don't even have the added personality of Corbin's, and I don't see too much complaining about that.

He didn't put a foot wrong on Smackdown this week either. He is developing all the time and I think he will win a lot of people round in the end.

I'm not really a fan on Ambrose's look either, If I'm honest.

He his balding too, but it's nowhere near as much as Corbin's balding but also, it kinda adds to Ambrose's character, whereas Corbin's balding really takes away from his character.

Corbin is supposed to be this intimidating lone wolf, but a man who's emotionless and heavily balding with long stringy hair and weak facial hair isn't really intimidating. If anything, it's slightly creepy. It's a "I don't want him near my kids" kind of creepy.

He his balding too, but it's nowhere near as much as Corbin's balding but also, it kinda adds to Ambrose's character, whereas Corbin's balding really takes away from his character.

Corbin is supposed to be this intimidating lone wolf, but a man who's emotionless and heavily balding with long stringy hair and weak facial hair isn't really intimidating. If anything, it's slightly creepy. It's a "I don't want him near my kids" kind of creepy.

Similar looks can work for one character and not another. Corbin is presented as a biker bad ass. When you here those words what kind of person comes to mind? If you said Corbin you're either a liar or you've never seen a real biker in your life.

Dean on the other hand is portrayed literally as "the dude." He's supposed to look out of place. He's that wacky and crazy uncle who everyone loves but are also slightly afraid of. Now is that the best presentation for him? Well, no, in my opinion it's not, but for what it is it works.