Rants and musings about things political, philosophical, and religious.

Morality Means Money

In an industry that is renowned for pushing the envelope, morality is almost taboo. Sex sells, so why sell anything but?

But conservatives have been bucking the trend. The New American carried a story last year showing the growing support base for clean movies with morals.

In fact, a close look at Hollywood’s bottom line shows that producing wholesome films is not only morally sound but financially rewarding. The outstanding success of blockbusters like the J.R.R. Tolkien Lord of the Rings fantasy trilogy and Mel Gibson’s The Passion of The Christ is not a fluke. A recent study of the box office statistics of the top 250 movies released by Hollywood shows that moviegoers not only are flocking to G- and PG-rated movies, they also want movies with strong moral messages.

The study, sponsored by the Christian Film & Television Commission ministry (CFTVC), analyzed the content and box office averages of more than 750 movies in 2004, 2003, and 2002. “Movies with strong moral messages, whether they were rated G, PG, PG-13, or R, consistently earn four to seven times as much money on average as movies with immoral messages, according to our biblical standards,” said Dr. Ted Baehr, chairman and founder of the commission.

According to the study, movies released in 2004 like The Incredibles, Spider-Man 2, The Polar Express, Shark Tale, The Passion of The Christ, Miracle, and A Cinderella Story, which contained very strong moral content, “earned nearly $106.7 million on average, more than six times as much money as movies with very strong immoral, negative content or very strong pagan, secular humanist, socialist, homosexual, occult, or anti-religious content, which averaged only $16.4 million per movie in 2004.”

Indeed, many of the most successful movies in recent years have been absent of filthy, offensive content and hence have had more sales appeal:

Furthermore, CFTVC’s annual study of the Top 10 Movies at the domestic box office in 2004, 2003, and 2002 also shows that moviegoers are seeking out family-oriented movies with traditional moral values.

For example, 96 percent of the Top 10 Movies during those years had at least some moral content in them. Also, 80 percent of the Top 10 Movies had no sexual immorality in them or only light sexual references. Finally, only one of the Top 10 Movies in 2004, 2003, or 2002 had any excessive substance abuse in them.

So sorry Hollywood, but sex doesn’t sell. Stop adding that nudity scene, stop tossing in a few gratuitous F-bombs, and stop pushing the envelope. In the end, you’re going to be the one to suffer.

5 Responses to “Morality Means Money”

Adults can enjoy adult movies, but kids and adults can enjoy kid-friendly movies. So kid-friendly movies make more money. Makes sense.

To say that people want moral messages in film is a bit of a stretch, though. Check this quote:

“The numbers don’t lie,” Baehr said. “Not only are families beginning to attend movies again, but they are leaving the theaters with a wonderful moral experience. For Hollywood, biblical morals in movies mean more money at the box office.”

How do they define ‘biblical morals’? Or ‘strong moral content’? When people use sloppy definitions like this, it’s hard to take their results seriously.

more than six times as much money as movies with very strong immoral, negative content or very strong pagan, secular humanist, socialist, homosexual, occult, or anti-religious content

Wow, we secular humanists are sure keeping some interesting company these days! Can anyone tell me where I can find even one movie with secular humanist content?

I liked this one: “96 percent of the Top 10 Movies” Uh, hmm, so 9.6 out of 10 movies had at least some moral content in them. If that .6 is part of the 10th movie, then it must needs be that the statistic should read 100%, as that represents “at least some.” They need to be more careful in their presentation.

Their point is valid, no doubt. I hope other voices are taking the time to make it, as well. It’s gotta be loud to get through to these guys.

I mean, Fox has tentatively taken the plunge, launching “Fox Faith” distribution, which recently released the 4th os the ‘Love Comes Softly’ movies nationally. Granted, they only ran for 2 weekends, and so I (and I’m sure a lot of other people who assumed that a national release would carry a regular –longer– run than that.) I feel, though, that it’s almost like their sabotaging their own efforts. Maybe they are, maybe it’s an experiment in manufacturing evidence against producing films for a faith-based/values-based audience. Ugh.

“Granted, they only ran for 2 weekends, and so I (and I’m sure a lot of other people who assumed that a national release would carry a regular –longer– run than that.)” missed them, and never had a chance to ‘vote with my dollars’.

In reality the producers don’t put in the inappropriate content to sell film. They do it because those are the values of Hollywood. Seriously.
Film studios are not stupid. They know what makes money. But they are artists and want to keep the world “free” by pushing the envelope.

About the Author

Connor Boyack is president of Libertas Institute, a public policy think tank in Utah. He is the author of several books along with hundreds of columns and articles championing individual liberty. Connor's work has been publicly praised by national figures such as Ron Paul, Judge Andrew Napolitano, Tom Woods, and many others.

What do history's most notorious despots have in common with many of the flag-waving, patriotic politicians of our day? Both groups rise to power through the exploitation of fear, which has become a societal plague. There have been widespread casualties. We need an antidote. Feardom offers its readers a much-needed immunization.

The oldest economic battle in history repeats itself in the fourth Tuttle Twins book. Ethan and Emily witness this battle firsthand as they help their food truck friends win public support to overturn the protectionist laws that shut them down.

The third installment in the Tuttle Twins series finds Ethan and Emily confronting a scary creature that somehow controls money and markets. Your children will learn about money, inflation, banking, and other important monetary concepts in an exciting story, beautifully illustrated.

In their second adventure, Ethan and Emily Tuttle go on a field trip to a fun factory where they learn how something as simple as a pencil is in fact a miracle—and one that nobody knows how to make! Your children will learn about the free market, why division of labor makes our lives better, and how spontaneous order is the key to human progress and happiness!

Help your children learn about the proper role of government with this engaging book full of detailed, colorful illustrations! Ethan and Emily Tuttle learn from their wise neighbor Fred about the law, what our rights are and why we have them, and how we should voluntarily help those in need!

A fundamental aspect of the good news of the gospel is the message of liberty. As President Joseph F. Smith said, “The Kingdom of God is a Kingdom of freedom; the gospel of the Son of God is the gospel of liberty.” Men of God, both ancient and modern, have spoken on this issue repeatedly. This book analyzes what liberty is and how it applies to government.

Liberty is a fundamental and eternal principle, but it cannot exist without its counterpart—personal responsibility. From self-defense and self-reliance, to faith, family, and financial freedom, this book pinpoints precise actions needed from each of us if liberty is to successfully be preserved.

This book is a compilation of essays written over the years, organized topically. At 610 pages, it's great for reference material if you're debating something with a friend and want to look up some arguments that you can use to support your pro-liberty positions.

Reviews

"An amazing book"—Ron Paul on Latter-day Liberty

"Clear, compelling, full of faith"—Judge Andrew Napolitano on Latter-day Responsibility

"Sophisticated and compelling"—Tom Woods on Feardom

Significant discounts available for bulk orders of 20 or more. Contact me for information.