Mumbai Blasts

13 July, 2006

Indian government has blamed Lashkar-e-Tayyeba and outlawed Indian group Students of Islamic Movement (SIM) for the Mumbai train attacks that killed at least 200 people on Tuesday last. At least 350 people, mostly Muslims have been arrested on the suspicion of
having links to the attacks.

But other Indian officials, speaking on the condition of anonymity because the investigation was just getting under way, cautioned it was too early to accuse a specific group.

On the other hand, Lashkar-e-Tayyeba has denied its involvement in the terrorist attacks saying that "Indian security forces blame Lashkar in an attempt to defame Kashmir freedom struggle."

A spokesman of powerful Hizb-ull-Mujahidin, the largest group fighting Indian rule in held Kashmir, has also termed the attacks an "act of terrorism" saying Islam does not allow any group or individual to hurt the innocent civilians.

Indian Foreign Ministry spokesman Navtej Sarna on Wednesday repeated Indian demands that Pakistan crack down on the militants, who New Delhi says operate from Azad Kashmir.

"We would urge Pakistan to take urgent steps to dismantle the infrastructure of terrorism on the territory under its control and act resolutely against individuals and groups who are responsible for terrorists violence," he said.

Here are some questions

1) Is that too early to blame any specific group for the attacks?

2) Who will be the major gainer vis-a-vis such attacks. Mujahidin or India?

3) Could it be a calculated conspiracy to tarnish the image of freedom fighters?

4) If yes, then who could be behind that?

Reader Comments:

attack againest humanity.

This attack is againest humanity.this is well planed attack.this attack is agianest himanity. I strongly conemn it.

mehboob, Pakistan - 13 July, 2006

Its act of cowardice

THis dastardly inhuman act canot be termed anything but COWARDICE. Killing innocent unarmed people from behind exhibits lack of value system of the individuals. These people's religious teachings has also come under cloud. The desparate , frsutrated people whose religion teaches violence is responsible ofr this cowardice act. Indians have faced such cowardice acts for centuries .but the cowards have never succeeded anytime, same is case now. These terrorists who planted bomb or hurled grenade in India;s Srinagar ...can never be pardoned for act of cowardice. They are creating difficult situations for themselves by aleniating the Muslims from real Indians. In the end , Majority of Indians wud win..! Jai HInd

Sanjay, Hungary - 13 July, 2006

It takes a village to raise a jewess( H.Clinton) what does it take to raise a village?

Q (1) is killing of civilians justified in response to capture of soldiers? Ans:No
Q (2) Have Hamas and Hezbollah the same right to defence in case of Israeli bombardment, and killing of civilians? Ans: No
Q (3) is the demand of Hamas and Hezbollah justified that hundreds of Arab prisoners held by Israel be released first? Ans: No
Q (4) Will Israel is ready to swap detainees with Hams and Hezbollah as it was previously done? Ans: may be yes may be not

This is meaningless question with The Israeli bombardment has left around 50 civilians dead, including women and children in Gaza and Lebanon wiped out a nation called Philistine millions of phislistinian who is in war with Muslims since Israel state idea
Developed. Above All few million Jews have started challenging to wipe out Islam quran
Umma Islamic religion Islamic countries and Islamic population (worldwide)

Israelis alone could not have come to this stage. The other none Muslims do exist who have participated with Jews. They have one thing in common.

In Islam you have to be victim yourself with direct interest to make comment .how you can take part in analysis to establish for potential cause potential solution potential
Guesstimation potential conclusion to the cause of problem potential routes of atrocities
Potential murderers killers potential master minds (with history of prisoners abduction
Annihilation invasion looting wealth making technique via mass extermination via individual Extermination.

benz m Isphahani, India - 14 July, 2006

Mumbai Blast to Generate Anti Muslim Slogan (everywhere)

Mumbai Blast to Generate Anti Muslim Slogan (everywhere)...

There is no evidence of Muslim involvement in Mumbai
Real State development related bombings..

Q (1) what prompted Specific group for the attacks in Mosques Muslim properties around Jews Gujarat's Following Mumbai explosion?

Ans(1) It created slogans by world oil looter none Muslim car oil user( recent middle class None Muslims) public everywhere who with their democracy leaders (with evil plan of their own )with day dreaming of Jewish settlers seem to be getting bolder and bolder with their hostility towards Islam. They have designed their own get rich scheme .They like shedding blood of Muslim citizens .They propose for eliminating Palestinian .They have started following utterance of incompetent democracy leaders (anti Muslim) elements .They have started screaming “it is Muslim terrorist who did it (at point blank range for all mafia or looting
Related incident for stealing related incident) they scream “go and invade Iran oil” amid day dreaming of owning world Muslim resources with out 1500 million Muslim in the world.
This is due to failed democracy this is due to failed economic system of Jewish settlers due to sudden wealth of financiers who got rich due to turmoil by Bush Blair Allied and Jewish group. Their democracy system of Israel's India's USA's EU's have no future .They continue to propose Israel's growth from 22000 to 5 m free via democracy route via junk bond route via car oil plane oil route via theft aggression route. This is
A principle which prompts bombings and killing of Muslim umma
Everywhere.

benz m Ispahani, India - 14 July, 2006

Subject: A Letter from Mumbai

Dear Terrorist,

Even if you are not reading this we don't care. Time and again you tried
to disturb us and disrupt our life - killing innocent civilians by
planting bombs in trains, buses and cars. You have tried hard to bring
death and destruction, cause panic and fear and create communal
disharmony but everytime you were disgustingly unsuccessful. Do you know
how we pass our life in Mumbai? How much it takes for us to earn that
single rupee? If you wanted to give us a shock then we are sorry to say
that you failed miserably in your ulterior motives. Better look
elsewere, not here.

We are not Hindus and Muslims or Gujaratis and Marathis or Punjabis and
Bengaliies. Nor do we distinguish ourselves as owners or workers, govt.

employees or private employees. WE ARE MUMBAIKERS (Bombay-ites, if you
like). We will not allow you to disrupt our life like this. On the last
few occassions when you struck (including the 7 deadly blasts in a
single day killing over 250 people and injuring 500+ in 1993), we went
to work next day in full strength. This time we cleared everything
within a few hours and were back to normal - the vendors placing their
next order, businessmen finalizing the next deals and the office workers
rushing to catch the next train. (Yes the same train you targetted)

Fathom this: Within 3 hours of the blasts, long queues of blood donating
volunteers were seen outside various hospital, where most of the injured
were admitted. By 12 midnight, the hospital had to issue a notification
that blood banks were full and they didn't require any more blood. The
next day, attendance at schools and office was close to 100%, trains &
buses were packed to the brim, the crowds were back.

The city has simply dusted itself off and moved one - perhaps with
greater vigour.

We are Mumbaikers and we live like brothers in times like this. So, do
not dare to threaten us with your crackers. The spirit of Mumbai is very
strong and can not be harmed.

Please forward this to others. U never know, by chance it may come to
hands of a terrorist and they can then read this message which is
specially meant for them!!!

With Love,

From the people of Mumbai (Bombay)

Hindustani!, Hungary - 14 July, 2006

mumbai blast

i seriously believe that pakistan should not be blamed for this attack, it is surely a barbic actand cowardly done to kill innocent people.it is for sure terrorist who are trying to derail this peace process between india and pakistan.

sanjeev roy, Canada - 14 July, 2006

Game

After 9/11, Madrid bombings, after london attacks something were still missing. What was that? yes, why would india be step behind. They have always tried to fake up things so their poor country can stand at least in some cases in same line as "the allies." So, who is the black sheep in india? Oh yes, muslims. Indian intelligence RAW have done such stunts in past and they have done it again. RAW and hindu extremists dont want any work on peace in the region. Indian agencies have done it by thereself for making arrest of hundreds of muslims possible. They can arrest any muslim they want now in india, for "dark-paint" the freedom fight going on against indian occupation of kashmir and to get sympathi and support from europe and israel. To show the world that "poor us, we have also problems with muslims as europe and united states have". We are in same sitution,,,please dont forget us. It`s also very importent to remember that this fabricated attack happened the day or two after failure test of agni3 misilie, which fell down after few minutes, and another missed test of a misile.

zeeshan, Norway - 14 July, 2006

why

Benz, Zeeshan and other hateful brothers

Why do you wish ill on those innocent people who died in Mumbai? Did they ever take a single rupee from you, did they ever cheat you or steal from you? Did they ever insult you or mistreat you? If no, then why??

You may confuse yourself and other frustrated youths with you uninformed vitriol but please don't claim to do this in the name of Islam. You think the whole world is against Islam. But 99.99% of the humanity cares about their private lives; food, shelter, love, parenthood, education, work etc. No one cares to insult YOU. Out of the 6 billion people that live on this planet, only you think yourself significant enough for others to care.

Love yourself and others, educate yourself and god willing, succeed and prosper. But at least have the decency to afford others the same opportunity. Don't kill or justify the killing of innocent civilians while you live a sheltered life in Norway. If you really have the courage and love Allah, why don't you try to improve the life of on poor Muslim child who lives on the streets of my city.

After the partition, my family moved to Mumbai from Karachi. India is my country and I love it as much as anyone. I am happy they did not choose to live in Pakistan, which is on the brink of becoming a failed state under the leadership of the stupid mullahs. I wonder what my life and future would look like if they had stayed back in Karachi.

I urge you, if you want to choose the path of hatred, go ahead follow you mullahs. Because, although you don't realize today, the abyss you are staring at is as deep as Baghdad. Shias killing Sunnis, Sunnis killing Shias, both of them killing some innocent children in churches, pizza parlors and schools. Bravo, what a wonderful world you have created, Allah will be very proud. But remember, by the time you wake up, Karachi will be Kabul and Islamabad, Baghdad.

Khorshid, Hungary - 14 July, 2006

Mumbai Blasts Delhi Pahargunj Tourism Development Blasts

Mumbai Train Compartment Chemical Blast ...

There is no Muslim reason to kill fellow muslim
on the train.For years we see the plight of commutors and Mumbai Apartment Building developers (foreign based).Based upon Landlord Tenant Act with difficulties in evicting slum residents, the crooked Property Hotel Developers simply transferred India's chemical export for demolishing dynamites from freight train to first Class Compartment givng Terrorist attack flavour with few look alike minor blast in kashmir using Kasuri's speech.
This is replica of Pahargunj hotel tourism -cheaper hotels area explosion too using similar
dynamites.India is only one in possession with
such dynamites with mfg plants with construction Sites everywhere ordering such explosives.Your guess is as good as mine.

benz m Ispahani, India - 14 July, 2006

Game ofcourse.. by Pak

This is in response to one of the earlier posts by zzeshan who believes that this bombing was done by hindus. pls remember my friend its never hindus agenda to establish hindu religion across our borders.. unlike ur country's extremists whose very agenda is to establish islamic laws across india..hindus dont believe in jihad and getting 70 virgins on attacking innocents unlike ur extremists who repeatedly quote same everywhere and hijack islam.. and by the way the muslims in our kashmir are much better off than muslims in ur so called azad kashmir..and i feel sorry for ur intelligence on ur comments on the attacks happening after the failure of our missile tests... pls wake up and do some self reality checks before passing such absurd and meaningless statments..pls note that i dont have anything against islam or muslims and i personally have many muslim friends .. may ishwar and allah give u some brains..

Krrish, Hungary - 15 July, 2006

Beware !!

General Musharaff can go upto any limit to retain office for another terms. Even he may think of use of Nuke against India. You no the consequences. So Beware Pakistani frends ! The on going peace process with India is nothing but just an eyewash !!

P.Alam, Pakistan - 15 July, 2006

INDIAN ALLEGATION

When ever there is a security lapse, bad guys will always create problems for the state. Now-a-days it has become a routine matter for the terrorists' to implement on nefarious designed activities. It is the responsibility of law enforcing agencies of every state in the world to unearth and arrest the bad guys before they implement on their agenda.

India is also one of the countries where terrorists' find their way to conduct subversive activities. Instead of arresting bad guys before hand, India always put blame on Pakistan for its security lapse, whatever and wherever it happened in India.

Why Pakistan should get involved in such activities when it is already fighting a war on terror? What Pakistan is going to get out of it, if India becomes a weak neighbour? A weak neighbour will be a high security risk for Pakistan, rather than a stable India.

Prior to the demise of USSR, India was the closest ally of USSR which was one of the super powers at that time. But when USA broke USSR into pieces, India immediately tilt towards USA. After a long pursuance now USA has rewarded India by signing the energy deal. Now India has become a close ally of USA. In 2001, USA had 9/11 and after five years India had 7/11.

Now there is a similarity of terrorist activities in 9/11 and 7/11 events. USA blame Al-Qaeda for 9/11 incidents and now India has put blame of 7/11 incident on Pakistan. What readers of these columns would comment, if I say that behind the incident of 7/11, it was not Pakistan, but it was Indian own intelligence agencies who conducted these terrorist attacks to divert world attention towards India. By putting blame on Pakistan, India cannot wash away the efforts which Pakistan has made during the last five years in fighting war against terror.

Syed A. Mateen, Pakistan - 16 July, 2006

To Khorshid - "Benz you hate oriented"- Not True.Know Fact Instead ..

To Khorshid who said - "Benz you are hatemonger"- Not True.Khorshid
Know Fact amount me about my missing family about God's miracle Instead...
Khorshid I am the only professional in the world without any right to work
Without other normal rights .But I have some kind normal life for decades.
(Exclusively designed by heaven)But I have miracle and escape by the tyranny
Of rich democracy or tyranny of Mullahs, tyranny of Govt of Jews Christian
Muslim alike. One of the richest maulvi businessmen in metal trade is my
US $ millionaire tenant in Kolkatta who paid me barely $50 rent in 47 yrs owing
Monthly rent of Rs4-5000/month (x50 years) due to failed India Landlord Tenant act absent Law Order.
My employer Govt of richest G8 oil rich resource rich owe me $35,000x 15 yrs
Due to injury .They have stolen most of my ID insurance properties without
Giving right to work. Probably I am best trained professional and was well off
Due to my past work with ICI Dupont Base Hoechst Chem. and pot explosive
Mfg skill wire cable mfg skill Pipeline mfg design skill. My family and
I have no right to Emigrate visit mosque or relatives. My relatives have been
Separated or disposed. My Properties had been taken away. Past few weeks
They collected from me $12000 utility bill worth $760 without restoring
Utility in rich democracy. For family of 4 what would you
Do if locks had been placed into your shops factory business taken (by excuse)
And all bank accounts frozen or misappropriated in richest country richest
Democracy again and again (shamelessly on going for decades)
There is no one in the world with this magnitude denial with
This magnitude abuse with this magnitude atrocities ever in the
History of mankind but this magnitude miracle escapes too.

benz m Ispahani, India - 16 July, 2006

Who is behind these attacks?

The sililarity of actions in Afghanistan,Iraq,Pakistan,India,Indonesis,Algeria,Sudan and so on indicates there is only once source doing these terrorist acts and that is Mossad of Israel. The Mossad so far has succeeded to put the Shiites and Sunnies against one another in Afghanistan, Pakistan and recently in Iraq. They are alos bringing about the hatered between the Muslims and Hindus in India. And working very hard to see the Pakistani and India go to nuclear war, so Pakistan get rid of it's nuclear weapons on Idian. Who kills those who are against the Israeli aggression in Palestine and Lebanon ? Thin about it. Nobody is immune from the Zionist Mossad. Today, even United States can't help a friend (Lebanon) newly established democracy from Israeli aggression. Israel is not happy for Muslim countries adopting democracy. If the oil rich Arab countries had adopted democracy 50 years ago, today they could be a strong or maybe stronger military power in the region. Simply to keep these Arab oil rich countries away from democracy the Zionists had to keep the Kings, Emires and Arab Dictators in power, in order to halt their progress. Think about it. Islamic trrorism was created based on the Zionim aggressions. If Palestine was created long ago, terrorism could have been voided today. I don't think the Zionists are serving the Jews and I don't think the Islamic fundamentalists are serving the Muslims. But they are there; one is not spoken about (Zionism) and one is spoken about and condemned (Islamic fundamentalism) think about it.

Jamal Khan, Pakistan - 16 July, 2006

WHY ARE FOOLS ATTACKING

This attacks on mumbai had proved only one that a terrorist can do cowardiness.this terrorist groups are doing nothing but giving a bad reputation of islam oin the world. i ma not against the muslims nor islam i myself have lots of muslims friends. but the thing the terrorists are doing is just proving themselves being coward and their supporting famous country. for god sake pealease remember there was a time when we fought for the independence togather and try to live in peace and harmony. attacks like this dont shock us because we are use to this stupid acts. may god give everybody a good and proporous life and make reliaze the terrorist that they are doing the wrong thing.

gujarat, Hungary - 16 July, 2006

The Heedless Leadership!

As long as the heedless One is at power in WashingtonDC!We should not expect any kind
of peace across the globe.It benefits him to create havoc in this region under pretext of fighting terrorism and the
promotion of democracy.With his inept policies mankind is
divided far worse,than was in
the cold war period.I wonder who after Islam will become US scapegoat to frighten the commonfolk as the bogeyman of
elm street.

Khalid Rahim, Pakistan - 16 July, 2006

Its done by some third party

Before making any pre-judgments, it is very important to see that who will benefit from these blasts.
Pakistan is trying to have good relationship with India now-a-days. It is not done by Pakistan since she is not interested to go back to point zero and start again the process.

It is strange that the damaged party 'India' is not thinking of any other option. There are so many internal insurgencies all over India such as Asam, Tamil, etc. Why didn't India think of these options, Why don't they consider who killed Indra Gandhi and Rajiv Gandhi.

The way India is blaming Pakistan, it seems they were just ready to impugn Pakistan for these cowardly acts.

Other than internal rebellions, India should also consider external factors such as Israel. India should see who will benefit from these attacks other than Pakistan itself.

Expatriate, San Marino - 16 July, 2006

Bombay Blast

Attack against Humanity
"Mehboob, Pakistan"
Now, that is human approach. Need more people like Mehboob on both sides; India and Pakistan. Terrorists or planners whoever are behind such cowardly act ought to be common responsibility to catch and eliminated from this world.

jia, United Kingdom - 16 July, 2006

Look ...

Look, Terrorist acts are underway in many countries around the world, including India and Pakistan. I don't think Pakistan is behind these bombing and bloodshed in India, Pakistan, Afghanistan, Indonesia, Iraq, Spain, England, United States, Saudi Arabia, Kuwait and others. Why Pakistan would be doing this ? What is the benifets for Pakistan? I think It might be done by Mossad of Israel for discrediting Muslims around the world and blaming them for terrorism.

I think the Zionists are not for Muslim countries progress, democracy and respect for human rights. Since the general Muslim population is under educated it's easy for the ememies of the Muslims to use Muslims for terrorism and devide them between Sunnis and Shiites and popularize secterism.

The Answer to fight the outside manipulation for Muslims are to open up, get education for both man and worman, get rid of fundamentalism and adopt democracy. Democracy which brings hope, prosperity and technology is kept out the hands of the oil rich Arabs and Muslim countries, for the reason of not having a military match for Israel.

If the Arab oil rich countries had adopted democray let's say 50 years ago, today they would not suffer in hands of Israel as much.

Ajmal Khan, Pakistan - 17 July, 2006

Act of Cowardice

When India blames Pakistan for sch terror, it should not be mistaken as Pakistani people.Finger is pointed towards few people in establishment who are behind such cowardice act. Even poor local Muslims becomes prey in the name of god and they start colluding with masters. These Masters are to be eliminated once and for all..to bring peace in sub-continent. Pakistani people will have to put pressure on establishment to help in elimination of such sick minded masters.

What do you think about the story ? Leave your comments!

Heading (Optional)

Your Comments: *

Your Name:*

E-mail (Optional):

City (Optional):

Country (Optional):

Field marked(*) are mandatory.
Note. The PakTribune will publish as many comments as possible but cannot guarantee publication of all. PakTribune keeps its rights reserved to edit the comments for reasons of clarity, brevity and morality.
The external links like http:// https:// etc... are not allowed for the time being to be posted inside comments to discourage spammers.