I believe Rossi much more than i do the penguins. the penguins have no obligation to tell reporters or anyone exactly how Malkin is feeling.

Rossi is writing Malkin's book, was chosen by Geno supossedly and went to russia to spend time with him work on it. it would seem they have a somewhat close relationship so i don't think its insane for Rossi to ask malkin directly or have contact with his inner circle as to how he's feeling.

Pitt87 wrote:About Iran, I agree... about sports though? How many sources can there be about a player injury?

The way he's claiming one of his sources was in the room as Malkin was being looked at suggests that their either is no source or his source is on the medical staff and isn't supposed to be giving him the information. The fact that he's writing this stuff with such conviction suggests me to believe it's the latter. It also means we'll never know for sure because nobody on the medical staff is going to speak up and if Rossi outs them then they're out of a job and he's out of a source.

So, to recap your point then. You think its more plausible that Malkin,who skated/was hit into the boards at full speed and had what we all witnessed as a nasty hit/whiplash/possible head hit that looked like a horrific car accident, had zero concussion like symptoms than it is that Rossi, a long time Penguins beat writer, has a good source for penguins player related news?

Also, see the post above mine. That combined with the Pens having a history of this, no matter how people try to spin it otherwise or forget most of the actual history, I just dont see how Rossi is taking the blame at this point.

Again, maybe Malkin is fine and in the end he ends up not missing much. It doesnt make Rossi's story wrong.

I don't know after watching that hit from that FLA guy a few times it seems a little dirty. What was he doing shoving Evgeni so hard that far away from the boards. Seema like you should know better than to start a hit that far away from the baords. I know i am a homer but this happened to another player not to long ago, contact was inintiated far away and the guy when head first into the board. Maybe we should send him a message for good measure.

Nope. Rossi said severe headaches and disorientation. He actually has short term memory loss and nothing else. Completely different.

Lol If this is not a joke. As if Malkin couldn't have had a headache and been disoriented before when he reported it. Malkin went from a horrid whiplash, with no side effects at all, then poof short term memory loss according to the pens timeline. I'm sure he felt just dandy after the game.

Nope. Rossi said severe headaches and disorientation. He actually has short term memory loss and nothing else. Completely different.

Lol If this is not a joke. As if Malkin couldn't have had a headache and been disoriented before when he reported it. Malkin went from a horrid whiplash, with no side effects at all, then poof short term memory loss according to the pens timeline. I'm sure he felt just dandy after the game.

I'm not sure, but I know that if concussed like they now report, that plane travel should be out. Make it a strong trip; judge BB as to whether he's really ready. Hope that Shero strikes before the deadline like he did in grabbing Neal & Nisky. Unfortunately, I have a gut feeling that it will cost us Despres.

no name wrote:I don't know after watching that hit from that FLA guy a few times it seems a little dirty. What was he doing shoving Evgeni so hard that far away from the boards. Seema like you should know better than to start a hit that far away from the baords. I know i am a homer but this happened to another player not to long ago, contact was inintiated far away and the guy when head first into the board. Maybe we should send him a message for good measure.

Let's not get all Melnyk about this. It wasn't a dirty play. If anything, it was a bit reckless of Malkin.

no name wrote:I don't know after watching that hit from that FLA guy a few times it seems a little dirty. What was he doing shoving Evgeni so hard that far away from the boards. Seema like you should know better than to start a hit that far away from the baords. I know i am a homer but this happened to another player not to long ago, contact was inintiated far away and the guy when head first into the board. Maybe we should send him a message for good measure.

Let's not get all Melnyk about this. It wasn't a dirty play. If anything, it was a bit reckless of Malkin.

Jack Edwards was talking about the hit during the Bruins/Panthers game yesterday. Apparently Gudbranson was asked about it, and he said he thought it was a bit reckless of Malkin to put himself in that position. He followed up saying that Malkin was driving the net, and that he has to make that hit 10 times out of 10.

All-in-all, it's a pretty fair evaluation and it's hard to be mad at Gudbranson for doing his job and hitting a guy driving the net.

Yeah I have no issue at all with what Gudbranson did there. I know Errey and Steiggy were saying how the league should look at stuff like that and think about assessing a penalty etc, but I thought that was a good clean hockey play. Sometimes crap just happens.

Could the ice have been a factor, its been bad at CEC this year. My White Russian was watered down (eww.... all the Russian Puns of late, had to get one in). But, it also could have been a factor, no one will every know.

skullman80 wrote: I know Errey and Steiggy were saying how the league should look at stuff like that and think about assessing a penalty etc, but I thought that was a good clean hockey play. Sometimes crap just happens.

Yeah, I'm glad you mentioned this. I heard them bloviating about this during Sunday's game and thought it was ridiculous. They deserve most if not all the "loathsome homer" comments they get from other fanbases. It's embarrassing.