This is a blog advocating the overturning and/or ignoring of the controversial IAU planet definition that demoted Pluto, the adoption of a broader planet definition that includes all dwarf planets, and the chronicling of worldwide efforts toward these goals.

Wednesday, December 23, 2015

The Solstice of the Year of Pluto

A
year ago, in my Winter Solstice entry, I jubilantly noted that 2014, the year
referred to by fans of Pluto and New Horizons as “Pluto Eve,” was giving way to
the “Year of Pluto.” Anticipating the “something wonderful” mission Principal
Investigator Alan Stern predicted we would find on the small, distant planet, I
noted, “The light is about to shine on a very dark and mysterious world.”

As
Tim Dean, editor of “The Conversation” website pointed out in his 2015 review
of science and technology—which placed Pluto first—2015 seems to have come and
gone nearly as fast as New Horizons flew by Pluto.

This
is the year Pluto was a star, a celebrity that made the cover of multiple
magazines and was recognized by many news outlets and websites as a top science
story.

Like
many who have followed this mission, I already miss the building buzz and
excitement that characterized the final six months of New Horizons’ approach to
Pluto.

Does
the Year of Pluto end with 2015, I’ve questioned over the last several weeks.

Our
view of this small planet has been transformed from a tiny dot, at best a pixelated
Hubble image, to an actual world, with jagged mountains, valleys, snakeskin
terrain, flowing ices, a layered haze, and one particular feature that has generated
awe and wonder worldwide—the prominent heart-shaped region known as Tombaugh
Regio, named in honor of Pluto discoverer Clyde Tombaugh.

Everything
about this tiny world that is more geologically active than Mars has surprised
scientists, who continue to brainstorm in an effort to explain its complex
surfaces and processes.

Only
about 25 percent of the data New Horizons’ seven instruments took on flyby day has
been returned. The rest is still on the spacecraft, and the downlink will not
be complete for approximately another 300 days.

The
fact that 75 percent of the data is still to come makes a compelling case for
the position that the Year of Pluto will go on past the calendar year 2015.

Even
when all the data is back, its study and analysis will take years, as can be
seen from the fact that 25 years after Voyager 2 flew by Neptune, a scientist
studying those images identified an undetected moon orbiting the ice giant.

And
because the data is generating so many more questions, particularly regarding
Pluto appearing to have an internal heat source, it seems inevitable scientists
will want to go back for another view.

Stern
often describes the sequence of planetary exploration as starting with a flyby,
then moving to an orbiter, a lander, a rover, and finally, a manned expedition.

So
far, the only planetary body that has undergone all these levels of exploration
is the Moon. Mars has been explored with several rovers, and plans are underway
to send astronauts there sometime during the 2030s.

The
development of new technologies could reduce a spacecraft’s travel time to
Pluto. Small cube satellites could be sent in a follow up mission. Significantly,
the US has just now resumed manufacturing the type of plutonium required for a
mission so far from the Sun.

Pluto
remains a prime destination because it is one of several solar system worlds
that has or might have a subsurface ocean that could host microbial life. That
puts it in a category that includes Ceres, Jupiter’s moon Europa, Saturn’s
moons Titan and Enceladus, and possibly other, similar worlds at the forefront
of the search for extra-terrestrial life.

We
will never again see Pluto the same way we did just a year ago. When in 2006,
four percent of the IAU voted to “reclassify” Pluto, they effectively made a
decision for a world about which they knew nothing. How can anyone classify a
world without knowing what it is, what it is made of, and what processes are
taking place on it?

Recently,
French scientist Jon Luc Margot published a mathematical formula which he
claims astronomers can use to determine whether an individual exoplanet “clears
its orbit” and therefore should or should not be classed as a planet by the
IAU.

Incredibly,
Margot actually stated on record that it
doesn’t matter what an object is made of because its composition has no bearing
on whether or not it is a planet. The only thing that counts, in his view,
is whether the object clears its orbit.

Most
people who look at the complex world imaged by New Horizons see a planet. Far
from being fundamentally different from those sometimes referred to as “the big
eight,” Pluto actually has much in common with them. Ironically, Pluto shares
some surface characteristics with Earth and Mars. It is not a rubble pile
loosely held together or a “giant comet” composed largely of ice.

2015
ends with the debate over Pluto’s status and the question of how to define a
planet remaining unresolved. It might remain unresolved for a long time.
Meanwhile, every new image and detail sent back across four billion miles
serves to confirm that this strange world is not just a Kuiper Belt Object but
half of a binary planet system.

For thousands
of years, the Winter Solstice on Earth has been a time of rebirth and renewal,
the beginning of the transition from darkness to light.

We’ve
only begun that transformation from darkness to enlightenment when it comes to
Pluto. Regarding the adventure of unraveling Pluto’s secrets, the only
appropriate language is, “To be continued…”

About Me

I am a freelance writer and community activist who has worked on many progressive and Democratic political campaigns over the last 25 plus years and a lifelong resident of Highland Park, NJ. I have a BA in Journalism from Rutgers University, an MA in Middle East Studies from Harvard University, and an MEd in English Education from Rutgers Graduate School of Education. An enthusiastic amateur astronomer, I have just completed Swinburne University Astronomy Online's Graduate Certificate of Science in astronomy and am pursuing a Masters of Science in astronomy at Swinburne. I am also an actress with experience in theatre and film and have written a full length play. I am currently working full time on a book "The Little Planet That Would Not Die: Pluto's Story."