Now that the season is over, I am sure a few of us had ideas that ended up being totally wrong. I am curious to know what wild ideas everyone had. Come clean, what's a theory you were completely off the mark with?

OK from a satanic-horror stand point, it's very likely that she wasn't possessed by THE devil. If you remember the exorcist, the demon CLAIMED it was the devil incarnate, but it turned out to be a minor demon escaped from hell.

That Johnny would turn out to be Grace and Kit's alien son and he was just utterly confused about who he came from and would end up killing himself when he found out he wasn't BF's son. Would have been AWESOME.

No way! I totally thought that for a while that maybe Lana did abort her baby and kit and graces kid would turn out to be bloody face....again obviously wrong when we found out Lana was still pregnant, but I was right there with you!

Here it is. Basically, at that point in the season, she hadn't used any "powers" yet. I figured the demon in the boy could be a trick to make us assume the demon in her was real as well. Prior to the possession, she was already helping Arden feed his monsters, so she was never truly that innocent.

I thought the twist of the season would be none of if was real. It was a season focused on crazy people after all.

The Monsignor was possessed with the devil, and was going to become the pope one day, and therefore wreak havoc among humanity (maybe there would even be some connection from season 1 about the Pope's Box).

When the Angel of Death kissed Sister Eunice and took her and the devil, the devil possessed the Angel. The devil was messing with Jude when she was seeing the Angel as the mobster female inmate, and now instead of kissing people and taking their souls, she would kiss them and posses them.

I was convinced the alien story was all in Kit's mind, that he was actually insane. I thought that he and Alma were attacked by those thugs from the very first episode and that they killed Alma and he created the story as a coping mechanism. I too posted my elaborate theory, no one bought it. Stupid aliens.

This would have been a MUCH better story! I think we'd all be sitting around calling them brilliant, had they done your idea. But no, instead they do a lame wrap up and I'm left to wish you were one of the writers.

I expected there to be a big twist towards the end where you found out most of the characters were actually insane. Like lana was never kidnapped by "bloodyface". Kit never being abducted and was actually bloodyface. Normally i'd be annoyed by a story like that but with it being in an asylum and them spending an entire season making you truly believe that they were sane and in briarcliff unjustly (which i assume everyone in an insane asylum claims) i thought it would have worked really well. It would have added to the mystery which i really feel season 2 was lacking in comparison with season 1.

i would have very much liked this. i feel like too many sane people were trapped here, i guess grace was insane, but didnt seem it. i would of loved for all the characters to have be insane. WHY ARENT YOU AN AHS WRITER

I initially thought that Arden, the Monsignor and Threadson were all in on something together. I thought the Monsignor was basically running the asylum as a way to supply Arden and Threadson with victims.

Well, at least you were right on some points. Arden and Timmy did have a blood accord. Arden did use patients from the asylum. Maybe Timmy didn't run the place solely for that reason, but the "resources" were utilized. It was just that Threadson was an independent operator. That's what I like about this show. It makes us think, even if initial theories turn out incorrect.

I thought it would turn out that kit was an alien but doesn't remember and that's why both women he got pregnant had been abducted. I thought it was a fairly good explanation for why he was chosen and everyone around him was affected but I guess that was wrong.