First up (one that didn't surprise me at all) clawlike nails: Those babies are scary. No explanation needed.

But the one that shocked me? Reflective lips: Apparently, according to Jonathan, 36, “too much can be trashy.” I’m going to be honest: This is throwing me off my game a bit. As a huge gloss fan, I’ve never given any thought to whether my shiny lips were freaking guys out before. I suppose now I’ll pay extra attention from now on to make sure the formulas I reach for don’t make me look like I’ve got a couple of chrome bumpers on my face.

Now, if you haven’t read about the other 5 looks that make men run in fear, click here, then tell me: Did any of them surprise you? Have any of you ever noticed that guys aren’t in love with super shiny lips? Is there a look we missed you think dudes just don’t get? Already have your Valentine’s Day look picked out? Discuss.