About Me

I am a lawyer in Melfort, Saskatchewan, Canada who enjoys reading, especially mysteries. Since 2000 I have been writing personal book reviews. This blog includes my reviews, information on and interviews with authors and descriptions of mystery bookstores I have visited. I strive to review all Saskatchewan mysteries. Other Canadian mysteries are listed under the Rest of Canada. As a lawyer I am always interested in legal mysteries. I have a separate page for legal mysteries. Occasionally my reviews of legal mysteries comment on the legal reality of the mystery. You can follow the progression of my favourite authors with up to 15 reviews. Each year I select my favourites in "Bill's Best of ----". As well as current reviews I am posting reviews from 2000 to 2011. Below my most recent couple of posts are the posts of Saskatchewan mysteries I have reviewed alphabetically by author. If you only want a sentence or two description of the book and my recommendation when deciding whether to read the book look at the bold portion of the review. If you would like to email me the link to my email is on the profile page.

Saturday, August 31, 2013

Assassins of the
Turqouise Palace by Roya Hakakian – Late in the evening of September 17,
1992 three men entered the Mykonos Restaurant in Berlin while a driver waited for
them in a black BMW. They went to a private dining area in the back of the
restaurant where Kurdish exiles from Iran were meeting to discuss political
actions. After cursing the diners as “You sons of whores!” the leader of the
intruders opened fire. Four men died.

Each chapter is headed by a quote from Iranian satirist,
Hadi Khorsandi and the quote for For Chapter relates to killer’s remark:

Terrorists nowadays! It’s not
enough that they kill you; they must also insult you as they do it.

The other quotes equally have a bite to them.

The Kurds of Berlin and the rest of Europe were immediately
convinced that the murders were committed by agents of the Iranian Intelligence
Services who were killing Iranian dissidents around the world who had been
marked for death by the late Ayatollah Khomeini.

German police are less certain. The German government would
prefer that the killers were part of the armed section of the violent Kurdish
PKK (Kurdistan Workers Party).

While the killers swiftly exit Germany the other two members
(Youseff Amin and Abbas Rhayel) of the killing quartet need time to ready
themselves to leave the country as they require new passports. Intelligence
tips from Britain and the BfV (the federal office for the protection of the
constitution) lead the police to the pair and they are arrested before they can
depart the country.

The organizer and financier (instructions and funding came
from Iran) whose cover was a Berlin grocer (Kazem Darabi) was also arrested.

Once in custody Youssef , the watchman for the killers,
provides valuable information on the assassination.

Bruno Jost, the federal prosecutor, assigned to the case is
a dedicated, meticulous, incorruptible lawyer determined to build a case not
only against the arrested trio but the Government of Iran. He assembles 187
volumes of evidence.

While the actual evidence of guilt is overwhelming many
Kurdish exiles doubt there will be a trial. There have been too many examples
in Europe during the 1980’s of governments either perfunctorily investigating
the deaths of Iranian dissidents or making deals that allow them to go back to
Iran. With Germany becoming Iran’s largest European trading partner there is
great pressure within the German government to quietly make the prosecution go
away.

The laying of the charges is a triumph for the integrity of
the German Department of Justice.

While the roles and actions of the lawyers were of the
greatest interest to me a large section of the book is focused on the lives of
leading dissidents and Shohreh Dehkordi, the widow of Noori Dehkordi, one of
those slain.

Amidst doubt the killers would be tried and then doubt there
would be an actual verdict the activists persevered in publicizing the case and
participating in the trial.

The actual trial consumed 4 years with the court sitting two
days each week. I had not known that a major German criminal trial would
involve 5 judges. The questioning is essentially done by the judges. It is a
torturous process though, when there are judges of ability, there is a thorough
examination of the evidence.

There were lawyers for the victims who, under German law,
take part in the case. Hans Ehrig provided years of representation pro bono for
the victims.

The book provided a great view of how a German trial
patiently searches for the truth.

I would have preferred the author to concentrate on one of
the groups rather than trying to the stories of the victims, the prosecutors
and the lead judge. Telling all the stories diluted the focus of the book.

As I read the book it was like a good mystery. There were
bad guys being controlled by a dangerous foreign power. There were victims
essentially powerless in the swirling machinations of international politics.
There was a dedicated prosecutor and an honest head judge. The intrigues and
twists near the end of the trial rival those of skilled writers of crime
fiction.

I found myself eager to know if there would be a verdict. Would
the trial be prematurely ended by negotiations between the Iranian and German
governments?

Having just finished The
Kill Room by Jeffery Deaver which dealt with the U.S. Government
arbitrarily killing those it identifies as its enemies in foreign lands it was
very interesting to see how the issue had been dealt with in a trial a
generation ago in Europe when it was the Iranian government which was arranging
and carrying out the killing of its citizens outside Iran.

I had forgotten about the murderous actions of the Iranian government
though they were but 20 years in the past. Iran was rightly condemned. What
will history say about America 20 years from now?

Hakakian has written a good book. In my next post I shall discuss
this case and two other German cases spanning a century. (Aug. 21/13)

Friday, August 30, 2013

James Laurenson as Bony in the T.V. Series with a modern means
of tracking, the airplane, and his traditional personal observation

The art of tracking is both similar and vastly different
between Death of a Swagman by Arthur
Upfield in 1945 and Trackers by Deon
Meyer in 2011.

The tracking is comparable when it involves the examination
of human tracks in rural areas. Whether the 1940’s or the 2010’s the tracking
involves a person observing and assessing the imprints.

Bony explains the basic difference between rural and urban
tracking:

I leave the body to a uniformed
constable, and the cause of death to the doctor and the coroner, and to the
experts at headquarters I leave fingerprints if any, the weapon, if any, and
objects more closely associated with the crime. In a city the scene of a crime
is confined to a room, an office, a flat, and, if on a street, to a space
within a few feet of the body.

Here in the bush the scene of a
crime is extended far beyond the immediate locale. Someone has had to go to the
scene of the crime in order to commit it, and, afterwards, to leave the scene
of the crime. As the criminal does not grow wings, he needs must walk, and he
does not walk about without leaving tracks of his passage for me to see. To the
city detective his fingerprints: to Bony his footprints. So you will now
understand how it is that I am much more interested in the ground outside a
house or hut or camp than I am with the interior.

Bony uses the training of decades and the skills of his aboriginal ancestors in examining
tracks.

In Trackers there
is tracking in the bush by men using the same skills Bony used almost seven
decades ago. I am acquainted with tracking prints left upon ground.

My father was a trapper which meant he was a tracker. In an
ever more urban world there are not many today who can distinguish which animals
made the tracks they see upon the ground. I am far from being a skilled tracker
but I learned some basics of tracking from my Dad such as where to look for
animal tracks. You need to search where you would expect animals to be based on
terrain, food sources, shelter offered and the quickest safest and most
efficient way to travel through an area.

The title to Trackers
in Afrikaner translates to spoor in English. It is an apt word for traditional
tracking which looks to the traces left behind.

What has changed significantly, even in rural tracking is
the use of technology to aid trackers.

In Trackers I noted 26 different types
of tracking. They were tracking of vehicles in rural areas by anticipating roads,
tracking done by teams of cars following cars, tracking of vehicles by
transmitters placed upon them, tracking on foot in the city by visual contact, tracking of people by observation from nearby
buildings, tracking of telephones with electronic intercepts, tracking through
talking with friends and enemies, tracking through sleeping with a source and
listening to pillow talk, tracking through informants within organizations, tracking
through computers searching the world wide web, tracking through the satellites
continually orbiting the earth, tracking through reading newspapers and
magazines for information on those being tracked, tracking through searching
government records, tracking through breaking into buildings, tracking through
searching desks and computers, tracking through the mind with skilful questions
and brutal demands for knowledge, tracking through the sharing, often
reluctantly, of information between powerful organizations, tracking through
careful examination of financial records, tracking through the sources of funds
in bank accounts, tracking through hidden microphones, tracking through the
closed circuit cameras that inhabit every city, tracking through the
examination of personal public records, tracking through the study of bodies and
tracking through examination of wallets, clothing and other personal items.

Modern trackers would be lost without all their electronic
devices.

Yet current technology has its limits. In Murder One by Robert Dugoni the
investigators deal with footprints leading up to the window of a home through
which a killing shot was made. The investigators try to determine size from
computer analysis of the size of the tracks and distance between steps. I
expect Bony could have told them by his experience. I believe he would have gleaned
more information about the killers if study of the tracks had been left to him.

The powers of observation and reflection are less prized by
modern crime fiction trackers. In our instant world we want answers and
analysis instantly. Good trackers need patience to find the tiny signs that let
the tracker follow their quarry. Bony often takes the time to sit down, make
and smoke a cigarette, and deliberate about what he has seen. Few modern
trackers pause to think.

Tuesday, August 27, 2013

"U” is for Death of a
Swagman by Arthur Upfield (1945) – For the letter “U” in the Alphabet in
Crime Fiction meme being hosted by Kerrie Smith at her fine blog, Mysteries in
Paradise, I am posting a review of a Napoleon “Bony” Bonaparte mystery by the
Australian author, Arthur Upfield.

It is another Bony mystery set in the vicinity of a
prominent Australian geographic feature. Death
of a Swagman takes place in and around the Walls of China in the southwest
corner of New South Wales. On the opening page Upfield describes the area:

The colour of the country is
reddish-brown, and upon this reddish-brown land the soft fingers of the wind
built a wall of snow-white sand some twelve miles long, three quarters of a
mile wide, and several hundred feet high.

In The Will of the
Tribe the Wolf Creek Meteorite Crater in Northwest Australia had been
featured in the book.

Bony arrives at the small town of Merino some six weeks
after the

death of swagman, George Kendall, at a hut adjacent to the Walls of
China. Where modern crime fiction perpetually emphasizes the importance of the
first 24 to 48 hours after murder in conducting the investigation Bony is
unperturbed about arriving weeks later.

For this investigation he chooses to slip into town as a
stockman, with the name of Robert Burns, looking for work. Only after being
arrested as a vagrant does he reveal his official status to Sgt. Richard
Marshall of the local police detachment. Bony consents to a sentence of 10 days
in the local jail during which time he will paint the police compound fence,
whitewash the cells and have the chance to talk to the residents as a casual
stranger rather than a police inspector.

There are interesting local characters led by Mr. Jason, a
former Shakespearean actor, who owns the garage. Merino is so small he is also
the Justice of the Peace dispensing justice, the town undertaker carrying the
deceased to the cemetery in a spectacular hearse and presiding over the
coroner’s inquest.

Among the touches that mark the book as set almost 70 years
ago is the role of tobacco. Almost everyone smokes. Bony does a lot of thinking
while rolling his own humpbacked cigarettes. The community times how long it
will take Mr. Jason to exhale great draughts of pipe smoke.

The ever shifting sands of the Walls of China are at the
heart of the detection of the book. Bony’s skills as a tracker are evident
throughout the story. It is a physical art lost to all but a few current
detectives. My next post will compare the trackers of the past and the present.

What modern detective could discern that faint straight
lines in sand showed a clever killer was covering his tracks by using a flail
for the wind creates curved lines in the sand. Only man produces straight
lines.

There is also a fascinating explanation of the use of
noughts and crosses or X’s and O’s to provide information.

Bony is always professional in his investigations. He sets
out the problem with emotional involvement by the police:

Many young detectives, and older
ones too, are too liable to the emotion of indignation because of a brutal
killing. They accept such a crime as a personal matter and so permit their
judgment to be clouded by animosity towards the killer.

Would that the fictional police of today avoid the righteous
indignation that fuels so many of them?

The book differs from earlier Bony mysteries I have read in
having a strong child character. Little Rose Marie is a spirited and clever
girl.

The strength of the book is in the investigation. Unlike The Bone is Pointed or The Will of the Tribe or The Bushman Who Came Back it does not
venture into the relations between white and aboriginal Australians. As always
there are some passages that will make a contemporary reader cringe but I
accept them as a reflection of that era.

While the solution ventured into the bizarre I enjoyed the
book. I find Bony a remarkable character.

Sunday, August 25, 2013

With my last post about the National Historic Site of
Batoche and its connection to The Third
Riel Conspiracy by Stephen Legault being my 500th post I have
been reflecting on the 500 posts and being a blogger.

I had wanted to create a place on the worldwide web where
readers of mysteries could have information on mysteries set in the province of
Saskatchewan and the authors of those mysteries.

I am glad to have posted reviews of 28 mysteries set in Saskatchewan
and will shortly be filling in a gap with a review of A Political Addiction as part of my post for “W” in the Crime
Fiction Alphabet meme.

Saskatchewan authors, Anthony Bidulka and Gail Bowen, have
generously responded to questions which have made for interesting Q and A
posts.

I created a page for the Rest of Canada which, together with
my participation in the Canadian Book Challenge for the last 2 years, has
broadened my reading of Canadian mysteries. I have now committed myself to
reading at least 13 books by Canadian authors each year.

I doubt I would have had the pleasure of reading L.R. Wright
had I not started blogging and been looking for Canadian mysteries.

As a lawyer whose practice includes a substantial amount of
criminal and civil litigation I enjoy reading legal mysteries. I have not come
across another blogger who puts together a list of legal mysteries. I think
there are more good legal mysteries being published now than ever.

The introduction of the Harper Lee Prize for Legal Fiction
has added to my focus on legal mysteries. I will shortly be reading Havana Requiem by Paul Goldstein which
was the 2013 Prize Winner.

I set up a page in which I discuss mystery bookstores I have
visited. I have been alittle disappointed that the page is not often visited. I
fear the lack of page views is an illustration of the decline in bookstores.

While my focus is on mysteries I continue to read
non-fiction and put up reviews of those books. I find I need some non-fiction
amidst the crime fiction to maintain my reading interest in mysteries.

I have chosen but one book reading challenge, the Canadian
Book Challenge, each year as I feel I would be too restricted in my reading if
I was taking part in multiple challenges.

I have enjoyed the memes hosted by Kerrie Smith at her blog,
Mysteries in Paradise. She is an amazing blogger. Taking part in the Crime
Fiction Alphabet memes has been great fun. For last year and this year I
adopted themes. Last year each letter was a post of an author I had read. This
year I am putting up a post about a book or an author or a crime topic with
which I have a personal connection. I admit the letter “X” which is looming is
proving a challenge. I do not seem to have many connections with “X”.

The most unexpected joy has been meeting virtually fellow
bloggers from around the world. I never expected to make new friends through
blogging. I am always impressed by the depth of knowledge and kindness of the
bloggers and readers I have met through the web.

An unexpected bonus has been making comments on other blogs
and getting comments on my blog. The indefatigable Margot Kinberg of
Confessions of a Mystery Novelist has been a welcome and constant commenter. I
am amazed how many places she travels to in the world of blogging while
maintaining her superb daily posts.

I have found I neither have the energy nor inclination to
put up daily posts. I admire those bloggers who have that dedication. If I can
average 3 posts a week I am content.

The post which has garnered the most page views is “N” is for
Stuart Neville. The image of “N” I borrowed from Kerrie’s blog somehow ended up
on Google images for “N”. Blogger tells me there have been 17,354 page views of
the post and counting. One of the ironies of the world of blogging is that my
most popular post has nothing to do with the content of the post.

I started blogging as I wanted to talk about books. The
first 500 posts have been fun. I look forward to more blogging adventures.

Friday, August 23, 2013

I think it is fitting that my 500th post on this blog is about Saskatchewan. Batoche is my favourite historic place in Saskatchewan. The Third Riel
Conspiracy by Stephen Legault, which I reviewed in my last post, is focused
on the major battle of the Riel Rebellion at Batoche in 1885. Batoche was at
the heart of the Metis community in the Northwest Territories of that time. (In
1905 the province of Saskatchewan was created out of territory that included
Batoche.)

The Metis settlement around Batoche had grown up in the 1860’s
and 1870’s. The settlers created long narrow farms moving away from the
Saskatchewan River in the style of early Quebec farms. The Metis of that era
were great hunters and annually went south for buffalo until the buffalo were
almost exterminated.

The Metis people were the descendants of intermarriage
between French fur traders and the Indian inhabitants of the prairies.

A variety of grievances, including the fear their farms
would not be recognized by the Government of Canada because they did not
conform with the grid being surveyed, caused the Metis, led by Louis Riel and
Gabriel Dumont to rise in revolt.

The Rebellion did not last long mainly because the Metis
political leader, Riel, would not allow their military leader, Dumont, to fight
when and how Dumont wanted to take on Canada.

The founder of Melfort, Reginald Beatty, had just
homesteaded in 1884 in the area that would become Melfort. During the Rebellion
he was a scout for the Canadian forces and a negotiator persuading Indian
communities not to join in the Rebellion.

The Third Riel
Conspiracy is excellent at describing Batoche and the surrounding area. It
is a beautiful spot on a bend in the South Saskatchewan River.

The site is almost unchanged in the past 128 years. There is
no development around the site. To travel there is to go back in time.

The church and rectory have remained intact with some bullet
holes in the rectory to mark its role in the battle.

The photograph above shows the view from the cemetery on the
riverbank looking towards the church and rectory.

I first visited the site 45 years ago. My father had a keen
interest in

An aerial view showing the Saskatchewan River in the background

Western Canadian history and knew men who had participated in the
Rebellion.

Over the years I have made many visits to Batoche with my
family and visitors to our area. Each visitor has said going to Batoche made
history come alive for them.

In 1985 my Dad and I attended the centennial celebration of
the battle. At the official event the Red Cross donated the flag flown by that
organization during the battle. It was the first time the Red Cross had raised
their iconic flag on a battleground.

I am glad that Legault set his second book in the Durrant
Wallace series at Batoche. Every NWMP of that time had some participation in
the Rebellion.

For any reader crossing central Saskatchewan in the summer a
trip to the National Historic Site of Batoche will be a worthwhile stop.

While a place of battle and death it is now a serene site. I
feel a sense of peace whenever I visit Batoche.

Tuesday, August 20, 2013

The Third Riel Conspiracy by Stephen Legault - It is 1885 in Western Canada when the Riel Rebellion, equally referred to as the Northwest Rebellion is under way in the heart of what is now Saskatchewan and then was part of the Northwest Territories.The Third Riel Conspiracy is my entry for "T" in the Alphabet in Crime Fiction meme hosted by Kerrie Smith at her blog, Mysteries in Paradise.NWMP (Northwest Mounted Police which is the original name of the Royal Canadian Mounted Police) Sargeant, Durrant Wallace, is on duty in Calgary.

He has just returned to duty after losing part of a leg and having a hand severely injured.

Despite his physical restrictions Durrant is eager to participate in the Rebellion and feels stuck in Calgary, a boomtown of tents and new buildings, growing rapidly on the prairie. When the forces advancing on Batoche, the small community on the South Saskatchewan River at the centre of the Rebellion, are ambushed his superior sends Durrant a wire to come to help the Canadian forces.The headstrong Durrant ignores a further wire saying he need not leave Calgary.By the time he arrives at Batoche the final battle is over and the Metis forces have been routed. In the midst of that battle a Regina teamster, Reuben Wake, has been murdered in the zareba where the Canadian forces are camped. A captured Metis fighter, Terrence La Biche, has been arrested for the murder. He had in his coat pocket the Colt revolver used to shoot Wake.While Sub-inspector Dickenson is content to close the investigation Durrant finds the accusation implausible and starts an investigation. Thought it is a time when forensic science is very limited and there is not a lab in the territory Durrant applies the science of the day to the investigation.Mainly he explores the lives of those involved and, in so doing, sets out the history of Western Canada that led up to the Rebellion. In my next post I will go into some of the history and my personal connections with Batoche. For those readers unacquainted with Canada it will provide a basic understanding of our past.What is striking is how the investigation takes Durrant over a significant part of what is now Saskatchewan, eastern Alberta and northern Montana.

Participating with him is a young woman, Charlene Louise Mason, separated from an abusive husband. Their relationship feels more modern than late 19th Century.The conspiracies are more plausible than the usual fictional conspiracies.It is an interesting book. I liked the plot which deals with a time and place with which I am very familiar. The mystery is capably set up. At the same time the dialogue did not capture me. There was too much of the characters' personality and appearance in their actions and role in the plot. Wake is such a dark character it is hard to imagine how he could have survived in the real world. I wanted the book to be better because of its subject and location. In the end, I found it an average book. It is worth reading. I intend to read another Wallace mystery to see if the other book in the series is beyond average.

****

My connection with the book comes from its location in Batoche which is about 120 km from Melfort and is my favourite historic spot in Saskatchewan.

****

The Third Riel Conspiracy is the 2nd book of 13 I have read in the 7th Canadian Book Challenge hosted by John Mutford at the Book Mine Set blog.

Sunday, August 18, 2013

Jeffery Deaver in The
Kill Room goes into major contemporary issues that are not often dealt
with in crime or thriller fiction.

This post does not
directly involve spoilers but it does have more information about the books
discussed than some readers may want to know about the books.

As set out in my review the criminal investigation involves
the death of an expatriate American, Roberto Moreno, who is executed in a hotel
room in the Bahamas by an American intelligence services drone airplane. What
is the authority of the United States to kill its citizens or non-citizens
without due process of law?

In an age where threats of terrorism and actual acts of
terrorism occur what rights do governments have to pre-emptively kill those
they believe will harm their citizens?

In Fool’s Republic
by Gordon W. Dale which I reviewed 2 years ago the protagonist, Simon Wyley “has
been cast into one of America’s new secret prisons where those persons, the
authorities fear threaten her security, are held captive without rights”.
Interrogators seek to break Wyley to get the information they want from him.

Recently I was in Germany where I
spoke with a German lawyer about the Nazi takeover of his country. The Rule of
Law was thrown aside when the Nazis perverted the German judicial system. He
expressed unease over the development of secret courts in the United States. I
stated it was America’s public courts that restrained the legal excesses of the
internal War on Terror. He remained concerned for America’s future when
confidential charges and proceedings become part of the judicial system.

A year earlier I had reviewedCrossing Hitler by Benjamin Carter Hett. The book discussed the
actions of a courageous German lawyer:

Hans Litten was a radical Berlin
defence lawyer in 1932, acting as a private prosecutor with the public
prosecutor, helping prosecutor SA storm troopers charged with attacking
Communists partying at the Eden Dance Palace. Litten convinced the Court to
summon Adolph Hitler to testify about the SA. Litten carefully crafted
questions that challenged Hitler to reconcile the Nazi Party’s public
proclamations of pursuing power only by legal means with the SA taking violent
actions in the streets of Germany. Litten’s probing questions provoke Hitler
into a profound rage.

When Hitler gained power he immediately imprisoned Litten
who eventually committed suicide in prison.

In The Kill Room the
good guys and the bad guys, with blurring on both sides as to character, use
modern data mining techniques of the American Federal Government, often with no
official authorization.

A vast increase in the power of police and intelligence
agencies to investigate and surveil American citizens and non-citizens has
taken place since the terrible events of 9/11. In the years after 2001 crime
fiction dealt with these new powers.

Lost Light by
Michael Connelly in 2003 was the first book I read involving these issues.
Harry Bosch, in the interval when he is retired from the LAPD, finds out during
a murder investigation how much power has been assumed by the anti-terrorism
units of the FBI.

A year later, V.I. Warshawski, in Blacklist by Sara Paretsky explores issues involving the treatment
of American Arabs and goes back 50 years to the McCarthy hearings on
Un-American Activities.

Outside North America John Le Carre has dealt with the new
world of intelligence in such books as Mission
Song. In that book Congolese interpreter Salvo learns of the duplicitious
nature of the English and other Western intelligence agencies while translating
secret recordings of private conversations.

While this post reflects my concern with the actions of
intelligence agencies apparently beyond the supervision of legislative bodies
and courts I recognize that in an age of terror governments must have swift
means to prevent and react to terror. Having been a criminal defence counsel
and a lawyer for plaintiffs taking on big government and large corporations I
am uneasy about abuses of the power entrusted to the intelligence services of our
times.

Thursday, August 15, 2013

The Kill Room by
Jeffery Deaver – Lincoln Rhyme is adjusting to the physical freedom gained from
an operation to his right arm which has restored some feeling and the ability
to use the hand and arm. Deaver examines the impact of modern medicine
partially reversing the effects of crippling injuries. What happens to someone
physically and emotionally who has regained physical abilities thought
permanently lost?

More mobile, but still as irascible as ever, Rhyme is sought
out by Assistant D.A., Nance Laurel, to assist in the investigation of the
killing of an anti-American activist, Robert Moreno, in the Bahamas.

He has been killed by a sniper bullet that smashed the
window of his hotel room. Two other men in the room bled to death from the
shards of glass blown about the room as the powerful bullet shattered the
window.

Ordinarily a murder in another country would not be the
subject of a New York state prosecutor. Moreno’s death has been Laurel’s
interest because of a whistleblower email that a secretive American
intelligence agency, the National Intelligence and Operations Service (NIOS),
using flawed information has killed Moreno. The State of New York is pursuing
the killer because Moreno, despite his anti-American rants, was an American
citizen. Nance has been assigned to build the case for a conspiracy to murder
charge.

If she can establish the killing was outside the authority
given to NIOS the State of New York will charge those responsible. Killing an
American can cause prosecution. Killing a non-citizen is not an issue for a
state court.

Deaver thus delves into the murky legal and moral right of
America to kill those it considers its enemy wherever they are located in the
world. It was timely reading the book as an American drone aircraft was
reported to have killed two people in Yemen as I finished reading the book.

Where earlier books in the series were fascinating
assemblies of forensic evidence to solve crimes The Kill Room examines an important current legal issue.

While the New York City police department and the District
Attorney’s office seek to maintain secrecy through running the case out of
Rhyme’s home NIOS almost instantly knows of the investigation.

Both the police/D.A. and NIOS use unauthorized datamining to
find information. Deaver is touching upon another thorny American issue, the
right of governments to spy upon their people without the checks of statute and
public court consents. Deaver makes it clear that the security and proper use
of vast American tapping of phone and other electronic communication is dependent
on the integrity of those conducting the surveillance.

Rhyme is hampered as the crime scene is thousands of
kilometers away and the Royal Bahamian Police are unenthusiastic about sharing
information concerning a killing they consider the work of Venezuelan drug
cartels.

In New York City Amelia Sachs is diligently aiding Rhyme
though the effects of osteoarthritis are becoming more severe. She can no
longer walk without pain.

As she starts to search out information concerning Moreno’s
recent trip to New York City there is a chilling development. Someone is trying
to remove all evidence and witnesses that might lead to the killer.

Can it be that a federal American agency is willing to kill
American citizens so that its actions in protecting America’s security can be
concealed?

Where the initial forensic evidence is limited it builds
during the book to the extent, as usual in this series, that it is hard to
analyze all of the facts. Deaver is among the world’s most gifted authors at
giving the facts that will lead to conclusions but I rarely make the correct
deductions from his facts.

Deaver does not take one-sided view on the
extra-judicial killing by the United States government. It is among his most
challenging books. Deaver a grandmaster of deception and layered plots. As
common with his books there were unnecessary extra twists near the end. It is a
mystery that compels the reader to think. (Aug. 10/13)

Tuesday, August 13, 2013

On Sunday I put up a review of The Taking of Libbie, SD by David Housewright as my post for the letter “S” in the Crime
Fiction Alphabet being hosted by Kerrie Smith at her fine blog, Mysteries in
Paradise. It is a good book.
At the end of my review I indicated in my next post I was going to outline my South Dakota
connection and discuss a couple of issues concerning the book not related to
the plot.

I have a personal connection to the setting of the book. Not
only did my grandfather homestead in South Dakota a century ago the community
at which he homesteaded, Clark, has numerous similarities to the fictional
Libbie.

It is also a town of just over 1,000 people in a farm based
area. It is the county seat. It has a high school and a nursing home.

While Clark is located in a different part of the state and
I doubt they consider themselves in the type of decline as Libbie was portrayed
I kept thinking of Clark as I read the book.

I also have not heard in real life Clark of comparable
stories to the busy sexual lives of the fictional Libbie residents.

****

It was a book for which I had no knowledge when I opened the
covers. I bought it at the Once Upon a Crime bookstore in Minneapolis in
January when I was looking ahead for books for the Alphabet in Crime Fiction
meme hosted by Kerrie Smith at Mysteries in Paradise. It has been some time
since I read Tin City by Housewright
and when I saw The Taking of Libbie, SD
I knew I had my “S”.

Generally I know something of the plot to determine if I
want to read the book. For The Taking of
Libbie, SD I knew no more than than I had read a book earlier in the
series.

With nothing but the title to guide me my mind tried to
anticipate the plot. It seems impossible to keep a completely open mind until a
book is read. For no specific reason I expected the “taking” to refer to a form
of attack upon the community instead of the “taking” referring to a fraud
perpetuated on the town.

How easy it is to mislead yourself!

****

The one issue unrelated to the plot that upset me is the
cover. The photo of the big city has absolutely nothing to do with the story
and is blatantly misleading. The fictional Libbie is a small town of 1,200
people whose whole population might occupy one of the skyscrapers shown on the
cover. The story spends but minutes in the opening pages in Minneapolis and
little more later in the book. Had they shown the beautiful sunset sky alone it
would at least have had a connection. When I started the book I thought it
would involve a large fictional South Dakota city such as Rapid City (about
70,000 people) or Sioux Falls (225,000 in the metro area). I have no idea why
the publisher chose a cover that deceives readers. (I show the cover again to
illustrate the deception.)

Sunday, August 11, 2013

“S” is for The Taking
of Libbie, SD by David Housewright – The book gets off to a rousing start
when retired Minneapolis police officer, Rushmore McKenzie, is snatched from
his home and thrown into the trunk of a car and driven for 6 hours to the small
town of Libbie, South Dakota. Roughed up in the local police station he learns
the mayor has hired bounty hunters to bring him from Minnesota because he has
defrauded the town of hundreds of thousands of dollars. It is hard to take a
breath reading the opening chapter.

Once in Libbie the authorities realize he is not the Rushton
McKenzie who has swindled them. He does not look like the crook. A few
questions and it is clear that they have the wrong man.

McKenzie learns that the fraudster has stolen his identity
to set up a new Rushton McKenzie in South Dakota. Cleverly the crook has not
used any of McKenzie’s credit cards or accounts. He is using the stolen identity
to cheat the town not McKenzie.

Desperate to make amends lovely town councillor, Tracie
Blake, sweeps into his cell to offer an apology to McKenzie who is justifiably
furious over his treatment.

He learns the fake McKenzie has enticed investment in a
regional mall to be located on the edge of town. She further asks him to track
down the imposter for the town administration and many citizens who are facing
financial disaster if the money is lost.

While he does not forgive McKenzie finds himself fascinated
with the fraud scheme and returns to Libbie to solve the mystery.

The South Dakota town is a central character in the mystery.
As with most real life towns in rural Saskatchewan there has been a declining
population in Libbie recent decades that diminishes the well being of the
community and forecasts a doubtful future.

The people of Libbie want to save their town and are ready
to listen to a smooth talking stranger on the prosperity to follow the
development of a mall.

Trevor Herriot, in his book River in a Dry Land, sets out the rise and painful decline of the
real life town of Tantallon in southeastern Saskatchewan. It is a story that
could be written about hundreds of communities on the Great Plains of Canada
and the United States.

While Housewright effectively describes Libbie and the readiness,
even eagerness, of some to get out of town he does not do as well at capturing
the spirit and joy of living in a town where everyone knows you. I believe the
townspeople are less greedy than desperate for trusting and investing with the
imposter.

Within Libbie McKenzie is struck by the number of beautiful
women in the town. Temptation is present as he works to solve the mystery.

I would not say it is a great book. There are some
implausible developments near the end. I consider it a very good book. I liked
it better than Tin City.

This review is my entry for "S" in the Alphabet in Crime Fiction meme hosted by Kerrie Smith at her blog, Mysteries in Paradise. In my next post I will discuss my connection with the book and a couple of aspects of the book. (July 21/13)

Thursday, August 8, 2013

My last two posts
are about Stranglehold by Robert Rotenberg. On Sunday I posted a review of the
book. On Tuesday it was a Q & A with the author. Tonight I pass on some
thoughts about the answers from the Q & A. I have put my thoughts in
italics.

1.)
In the book DiPaulo has a sign in his office

from Anatomy of a Murder:

A trial was after all a savage and primitive battle
for survival itself.

Do you also view
Canadian criminal trials as bloody combat? In my experience in Saskatchewan
criminal trials they can be intense but I would not characterize them as
“savage”. While sometimes “primitive” I think most trials involve sophisticated
work by the lawyers.

Savage might sound a bit extreme, but it is the perfect quote. (Hint, I
used it at the front of my second novel, "The Guilty Plea," which in
some ways was an homage to that novel and great film.)

But I do it is true. When we strip back all our civility in Canadian
courts (and thank goodness for that civility) the core of what we are dealing
with are the most basic…savage…of emotions. How else can you describe someone
shooting, stabbing, or strangling another human being. (And thank goodness they
do, or how would I make a living as a lawyer or a writer!)

Is a trial a savage
and primitive battle for survival? Actual trials can feel stilted at times
because of the formal civility. Lawyers in Canada in court will refer to each
other as their friends or learned friends. Yet at the core of the trial will be
fierce emotions. Whether freedom, money or reputation are in issue the
witnesses and parties to the court action are involved in matters for which
they have strong feelings. Words can be fought just as fiercely as swords.

3.) Has it become
perilous to be the Head Crown Prosecutor in your books with Ralphie Armitage
going to jail and Raglan being murdered? Or is it perhaps a defence counsel
author exacting a subtle revenge upon the Crown?

Crowns have a good life. No client calls in the middle of the night.
Paid vacation. Pensions. Sick days. (I haven't had a sick day or a paid
vacation ever.) So if one gets killed and another ends up in jail, I say:
"suck it up."

Robert is a
committed defence counsel. I fear for the future of Crown counsels in future
books. I expect Crown counsels of his acquaintance would have something to say
to him about the benefits of defence counsel such as being able to choose
clients, not having to deal with unreasonable police officers and able to
withdraw from cases as counsel.

4.) The book has an
interesting bail hearing but no preliminary inquiry. Have you decided to avoid
prelims in your books? If so, I would be interested in knowing why the prelim,
often held in most major criminal proceedings, is not in the books.

I try to switch things around. If I wrote a book with a bail hearing, a
preliminary inquiry, a trial, an appeal, another appeal to the Supreme Court, a
retrial…well you get the idea. Damn boring.

Indeed, in "Old City Hall" the prelminary hearing is about to
take place.

But the bottom line is a "prelim" as we call them is usually
deadly dull. A judge once told me it was like baby-sitting a sleeping child.

Prelims can be
boring in real life if the questioning is perfunctory. No verdict is given at
the conclusion. Only rarely will there be a dismissal of the charge. Normally
there will be committal to trial. Yet I have been able to use the chance to
question witnesses at the prelim to establish the evidence needed to convince
the Crown not to go to trial or set the framework for the defence to be argued
at trial. It is a subtler drama to set up a case for trial through the
questions in a prelim.

5.) On some websites
it is now the Ari Greene series. How did that happen? I still think of it as a
unique series with equally powerful police and lawyers.

Thanks. I agree. This is a marketing thing I guess that I have no
control over. Note, none of the books use this phrase.

I have never thought of this as an "Ari Greene Series." I'd
say for example, that the third novel "Stray Bullets" is really Nancy
Parish's book.

I've always been interested in writing about a whole cast of characters.
In fact, Ari kind of appeared on the scene a bit by accident in Book One,
"Old City Hall" and just kept hanging around.

But I do see him as the moral centre of the series. And knowing Ari as
well as I do, I'm sure he wouldn't want his name on it. That's for sure.

There appears a
compulsion to market a series by identifying it through the lead character.
Rotenberg’s books are not suited to such an approach. There are continuing
characters in the series but who will be most important varies from book to
book. In a comment exchange with Margot Kinberg from Confessions of a Mystery
Novelist I said I thought the series should have a name comparable to the 87th
Precinct series of Ed McBain. I keep trying to think of a suitable name but
none seem appropriate. Toronto Law seems routine. Toronto Courts is apt but far
from catchy. Toronto Justice is but alittle better. I invite readers to add
their own submissions for a series name.

6.) There were
issues raised in the story that received little attention during the book but
were featured in the resolution. As an example, there was a letter received by
Greene but never acted upon him. Were there subplots cut from the book?

Afraid I can't agree with you that Greene never acted on the letter. I
think that's the whole point of how he handled himself. And the novel.

Beyond that I'd rather not say. I think it's pretentious when authors
talk about the deeper meaning or real themes of their books.

Suggestion: re-read the letter again. Then perhaps re-read the last
chapter.

As for the plot and subplot. In this book they are extremely
complicated. (That seems to be my way.). But in the end, I think they all fit
together. That's the struggle of writing and the real fun of making it
work.

It is a hard answer
on which to have thoughts for a blog post as I do not want to put up spoilers.
I continue to think the subplot was not well fleshed out in the book.

I agree Robert’s plots are complicated but
they are not convoluted. Robert trusts readers to grasp complex plots. I
appreciate his confidence in readers.

Even more I
appreciate the candour, even bluntness, of Rotenberg. He is not a man afraid to
tell you what is on his mind. I believe his writing skill has him poised to
become an author of international renown. He has interesting characters both seeking
to solve crimes (the police) and fight court cases (the lawyers).

Tuesday, August 6, 2013

My last post was a review of Stranglehold, the new book by Robert Rotenberg. I appreciate Anneliese Grosfield at Simon & Schuster providing me with a copy. I thought it an excellent book. I wrote Robert a letter with some questions that with Anneliese’s assistance I was able to get answered from me. My questions and Robert's answers in bold are below.

****

To: Robert

I have enjoyed reading Stranglehold and will be posting
a review on my blog Mysteries and More from Saskatchewan next week.

I have appreciated past email exchanges and would like to ask you a few
questions:

1.)
In the book DiPaulo has a sign in his office

from Anatomy of a Murder:

A trial
was after all a savage and primitive battle for

survival itself.

Do you also view
Canadian criminal trials as bloody combat? In my experience in Saskatchewan
criminal trials they can be intense but I would not characterize them as
“savage”. While sometimes “primitive” I think most trials involve sophisticated
work by the lawyers;

Savage might sound a bit extreme, but it is the perfect quote. (Hint, I
used it at the front of my second novel, "The Guilty Plea," which in
some ways was an homage to that novel and great film.)

But I do it is true. When we strip back all our civility in Canadian
courts (and thank goodness for that civility) the core of what we are dealing
with are the most basic…savage…of emotions. How else can you describe someone
shooting, stabbing, or strangling another human being. (And thank goodness they
do, or how would I make a living as a lawyer or a writer!)

2.) When Ari Greene
reflects on the murder he thinks there is something about the murder scene that
has been arranged to set him up for the murder. He is already suspicious over
the timing of the 911 call. I do not recall reading about anything being done
in the room to compromise him. Was there something I missed suggesting he was
set up beyond the timing of the phone call?

I just emailed Ari a copy of your email. He's tough to get a hold of. So
if you don't hear back from him about this, don't be offended. Half the time he
never returns my calls either!

3.) Has it become
perilous to be the Head Crown Prosecutor in your books with Ralphie Armitage
going to jail and Raglan being murdered? Or is it perhaps a defence counsel
author exacting a subtle revenge upon the Crown?

Crowns have a good life. No client calls in the middle of the night.
Paid vacation. Pensions. Sick days. (I haven't had a sick day or a paid
vacation ever.) So if one gets killed and another ends up in jail, I say:
"suck it up."

4.) The book has an
interesting bail hearing but no preliminary inquiry. Have you decided to avoid
prelims in your books? If so, I would be interested in knowing why the prelim,
often held in most major criminal proceedings, is not in the books.

I try to switch things around. If I wrote a book with a bail hearing, a
preliminary inquiry, a trial, an appeal, another appeal to the Supreme Court, a
retrial…well you get the idea. Damn boring.

Indeed, in "Old City Hall" the prelminary hearing is about to
take place.

But the bottom line is a "prelim" as we call them is usually
deadly dull. A judge once told me it was like baby-sitting a sleeping child.

5.) On some websites
it is now the Ari Greene series. How did that happen? I still think of it as a
unique series with equally powerful police and lawyers.

Thanks. I agree. This is a marketing thing I guess that I have no
control over. Note, none of the books use this phrase.

I have never thought of this as an "Ari Greene Series." I'd
say for example, that the third novel "Stray Bullets" is really Nancy
Parish's book.

I've always been interested in writing about a whole cast of characters.
In fact, Ari kind of appeared on the scene a bit by accident in Book One,
"Old City Hall" and just kept hanging around.

But I do see him as the moral centre of the series. And knowing Ari as
well as I do, I'm sure he wouldn't want his name on it. That's for sure.

6.) There were
issues raised in the story that received little attention during the book but
were featured in the resolution. As an example, there was a letter received by
Greene but never acted upon him. Were there subplots cut from the book?

Afraid I can't agree with you that Greene never acted on the letter. I
think that's the whole point of how he handled himself. And the novel.

Beyond that I'd rather not say. I think it's pretentious when authors
talk about the deeper meaning or real themes of their books.

Suggestion: re-read the letter again. Then perhaps re-read the last
chapter.

As for the plot and subplot. In this book they are extremely
complicated. (That seems to be my way.). But in the end, I think they all fit
together. That's the struggle of writing and the real fun of making it
work.