Legal thrillers, common fare on Broadway a half century ago, are rare birds these days. Still, critics didn't seem to mind the genre's long absence much, as they found ATime to Kill less than thrilling.

"After decades of legal procedurals on TV and film, however," said Newsday, "it takes fresh urgency, irresistible casting and a real pulse to justify a big-ticket Broadway version. Under Ethan McSweeny's conscientious direction, what we get instead is 2 1/2 hours of competent acting and monotonous storytelling that seldom elevate the serious plot — a black man shoots the white men who raped his 10-year-old daughter — from the genre of theatrical hokum."

Some critics, however, found the show engaging.

"A thriller of the sort rarely seen on Broadway these days, John Grisham's A Time to Kill brings a satisfying, if unsettling, courtroom drama to the Golden Theatre with an engaging cast playing juicy dramatic characters in a lurid tale spiked with a mild frisson of sex," Bloomberg said. Time Out New York, also praised the cast, saying, "Arcelus exudes decency without losing charm, but more notable is Thompson as the unrepentant vigilante. Hailey could have been indigestibly dignified and tragic, but thanks to Thompson's gruff yet light touch, he's richly human: neither fully innocent nor guilty."

Reviews were tepid, despite the acclaim Parker and Sullivan achieved in their previous pairing, as well as Sharr's well-received spring 2013 production The Other Place.

The Times scratched its head over the production, wondering "how this lifeless play wound up on Broadway. I can answer that question in two words (or three, if you don't count hyphens): Mary-Louise Parker...On its own, though, Mr. White's play remains a muddle of pastiche parts that never cohere into an original and organic whole. And the cast members — who include the excellent Broadway veterans Victoria Clark and Danny Burstein and several attractive young newcomers — fail to convince us, and perhaps even themselves, otherwise. The same might be said of Ms. Parker, whose preternaturally youthful face seems frozen in mild astonishment, as if she were surprised to find herself here." Added Hollywood Reporter, "the overwhelming impression remains that a lot of care and effort has been put into a play that acquires a pulse only intermittently."

Several reviewers noted the play's slow start, but said it was worth the wait.

"...in time, The Snow Geese, as directed by Daniel Sullivan with his characteristic polish, turns into the atmospheric character study that White intended. Jonigkeit's emotional transformation in disposition is the unexpected centerpiece of this production," said AM New York.

USA Today concurred, saying, "White's play evolves, under Daniel Sullivan's meticulous direction, into a lovely, moving account of a clan's struggle to adapt to trying circumstances and a changing world."

***

Off-Broadway boasted two significant musical premieres this week. The first came at the Public Theater, where Fun Home, by composer Jeanine Tesori and playwright Lisa Kron, opened. The show was based on the darkly comic, coming-of-age graphic memoir by Alison Bechdel, and directed by Sam — "He Directs Everything" — Gold.

The musical tells the story of a graphic novelist whose father dies unexpectedly, causing the woman to dive deep into her past and tell the story of "the volatile, brilliant, one-of-a-kind man whose temperament and secrets defined her family and her life."

"The work is sui generis," wrote the Los Angeles Times, "as much a play as a musical and not at all concerned with conforming to the expectations of either form." Stated Variety: "How refreshing — a queer coming-of-age play in which the hero(ine) is not a diva, the parents are not monsters, and people are never mean, even when they're being cruel. Lisa Kron's warm, funny, heartbreaking book…accomplishes all this without being sentimental."

Gold, said the Daily News, "as always, makes every moment — light, dark, disturbing — totally honest and creatively staged. Be glad you didn't live there. But this Fun Home is an unforgettable place to visit." The Times said the production, "finds a shining clarity that lights up the night."

As the Public Theater's current leadership tends to award its shows a commercial future if given even slight critical encouragement, it may be that Fun Home will find a new home in the near future. ***

The other important new musical to arrive Off-Broadway was The Vineyard Theatre's production of John Kander's The Landing, starring David Hyde Pierce and Julia Murney. It officially opened Oct. 23.

As every musical theatre geek in New York is aware, The Landing is the first new Kander musical not written with his late partner, Fred Ebb, to receive a commercial New York production. Kander's partner on the show was playwright-lyricist Greg Pierce. The show is comprised of three mini-musicals tied together by the themes of desire, love and loss.

Critics were, on the whole, pleased with the effort, even if they found the end product somewhat unprepossessing. "Mr. Kander's music for The Landing, which opened on Wednesday night in an elegantly slender production directed by Walter Bobbie," wrote the New York Times, "is on a smaller scale. Often it has the chiming simplicity of children's songs. But linked and woven into the book and lyrics by the young playwright Greg Pierce…these innocent melodies shade into sorrow and sourness, a bit like those tinkling music-box motifs so beloved by makers of horror movies."

Entertainment Weekly called the show "a modest evening of three one-acts for four performers," adding "except for Kander's recognizably lush and hook-filled melodies, the show often seems like the work of a gifted apprentice who's written a lot of short fiction." Newsday, however, rather liked that gifted apprentice: "Kander recently described his new collaborator as 'a present someone gave me.' It appears the gift, in this small package, was also given to us." ***

It ain't over 'til it's over, said Yogi Berra. And apparently the producers of the New York Yankees drama Bronx Bombers have decided to follow Berra's dictum.

The new Eric Simonson drama opened to mixed reviews at Primary Stages earlier this month. But the show will transfer to Broadway nonetheless, it was announced. In early 2014, it will move to the Circle in the Square, the same theatre that hosted Simonson's Lombardi a couple seasons ago.

The Broadway production will include two significant new cast additions. Husband and wife actors Peter Scolari and Tracy Shayne will take on the roles of Yogi and Carmen Berra. The Off-Broadway premiere featured Richard Topol and Wendy Makkena in the respective roles. Scolari previously appeared in Magic/Bird, the third of Simonson's sports-related plays to reach Broadway.