Jennifer Hudson and Ashanti are two pop gals you will rarely see being compared to each other. Jennifer pretty much lives on a different planet of talent, let’s just be honest. However today the two have collided, in a “Wizard” of very odd ways.

Firstly, in 2005 Ashanti rocked ruby slippers in the TV version of “The Muppets’ Wizard of Oz.” Then earlier this year she played the Dorothy-esque character in an off Broadway production of “The Wiz.” And now, Ashanti has produced and arranged a new version of the Judy Garland classic “Somewhere Over The Rainbow” to celebrate the 70th anniversary of “The Wizard of Oz,” which she performed on CBS last week. Obsessed much?

Well apparently Miss Jennifer Hudson was not having that. Last night, she headlined a free Netflix-sponsored concert to celebrate the launch of a newly remastered “Wizard of Oz” movie in New York’s Central Park. I bet you can guess what song she sang. Take a look below and you decide who makes the better Dorothy.