Search form

Farmers Agree on Slaughterhouse Plan

The Martha’s Vineyard Agricultural Society and Island Grown Initiative have joined forces in a venture to build a slaughterhouse behind the fairgrounds in West Tisbury.

The project is still in the very early stages of discussion and no permits have been obtained, but preliminary talks between the agricultural society and the nonprofit IGI are under way to allow a slaughterhouse facility to be built behind the new barn on society land.

“The MVAS is very supportive of your efforts with IGI to facilitate the construction and operation of a USDA-approved and regulated facility that reflects small-scale local, humane, sustainable slaughter and processing of four-legged animals for our farms, members and residents of Martha’s Vineyard,” agricultural society president Dale McClure wrote in a March 1 letter to Richard Andre, IGI meat coordinator.

“In addition to the $5,000 we pledged toward the USDA feasibility study, the MVAS is ready to commit to a land access arrangement, whereby a USDA-inspected facility would be built on land owned by the MVAS or land purchased in the future. In the next few months, we look forward to working with you and IGI in investigating all legal, funding, design and cost evaluating for this very important project,” Mr. McClure wrote.

The venture comes at a time of growing support for and interest in locally-grown food both nationally and on the Island — including locally grown meat.

A feasibility study for the slaughterhouse project is already under way by the Island Grown Initiative, which received a $40,000 grant from the state rural business enterprise program last June. The study will evaluate the size and cost of the facility as well as market factors and employment opportunities. It is targeted for completion by the fall. The agricultural society land is zoned for agricultural use, and IGI members are also exploring what sort of permits would be required to build a slaughterhouse.

Farmers and private livestock owners currently must transport their animals off-Island to be slaughtered at places such as Adams Farm in Athol, Blood Farm in Groton and other farm slaughterhouses in the region. If the project becomes a reality, it would mark the first time in more than 30 years that Vineyard livestock owners would be able to slaughter their animals on the Island.

“We want to do it right, we want it do it where you’re bringing the town and the community with you,” Mr. Andre said. “Whatever process you go through, you want to have the most people behind you.” He continued:

“There are approximately 600 [livestock] animals on the Island that are brought off-Island. It impacts the way people raise their animals and limits the number of animals raised.”

He estimated nearly $120,000 is being spent off-Island to process Island farm animals. At Adams Farm in Athol, for example, the cost to process one cow is $65, plus 87 cents per pound for vacuum sealing and 58 cents per pound to wrap the meat for resale. Then there is the added cost of $150 for the ferry and the cost of gasoline for the truck that hauls the trailer containing animals.

Mr. Andre said it will probably cost the same amount to process animals on-Island as it does to go off-Island for the first few years but he said the stress on the farmers and more importantly the animals will be greatly reduced.

“What we’re hoping to do at some point is — because you’re raising more money [over the years] — we’ll be able to lower the cost of local meat,” he said. “It’s not about people making money off of this thing, it’s hopefully going to be run as a community-based project.”

Mr. Andre said the feasibility study has already determined that the slaughterhouse will likely need five part-time employees including skilled butchers and apprentices, and will be open for eight to 12 weeks in the first two years of operation.

The facility would be open four days a week, during which a USDA inspector would come to the Island.

Mr. Andre said they expect animal production on the Island to increase 30 per cent in the first five years of operation.

He said the size of the facility is envisioned at about 3,000 square feet, but there is no building design yet. He said they are also considering processing chickens and venison at the facility.

“The agricultural society takes pride in what they do and it will be aesthetically pleasing,” Mr. Andre said, adding they hope to develop preliminary designs over the next six months. “However that gets through, it’s going to be tastefully done.”

Comments (8)

john waller,

I can hardly wait to see what a "Tastefully Done" slaughterhouse looks like! Maybe the 4-legged critters who visit can let us know what they think? Will they say "WOW, what a great place to get your throat cut".

To the 2 commenting above - do you eat meat? If the answer is yes, then you should support this. Your meat most likely now comes from a factory farm where animals are processed in inhumane ways that would make your head spin. Then they are hacked to bits and transferred here using fossil fuels. By contrast, animals raised here are raised with dignity and respect and would be slaughtered humanely. There is a difference.

To Out of sight out mind?
I am confused. Do you mean that if I don't eat meat I should not support this proposal? See how a sales-pitched-political-double-speak oxymoron like the vision of a "tastefully done" slaughterhouse can get our thinking all messed up?
I do eat meat-But not human meat. Heck, on the battlefield we just shoot those humans or blow them up or whatever, and leave them to slowly bleed out and die painfully and inhumanely if that is how it happens to work out at the time. Who wants to eat meat processed like that?
I do not have a strong opinion of the slaughterhouse proposal, but I would love to hear the plan for a "tastefully done" battlefield. Do you think that our priorities might be just a little out of line for folks living in the 21st century "age of information"?
Happy Easter to the Lions and the Lambs alike, I say.
John Waller
Culpeper, VA

This island can and should raise much more of its own food, including meat.
I raised both dairy and meat goats for several years and am aware of the financial burden of taking animals off-island for slaughter and butchering and then shipping them back.
To the naysayers, I believe the quote, 'tastefully done' refers to the aesthetics of the building and was not to meant as a reflection on the function of the building. While many people may be aghast at the idea of a small slaughterhouse on this island I personally support it 100%. Our food does not magically appear in the supermarket wrapped in plastic as much as some people would prefer to believe. Leave Disney and Doolittle to the kids.