Indyk and Sidiropoulos (2007) proved that any orientable graph of genus g can be probabilistically embedded into a graph of genus g − 1 with constant distortion. Viewing a graph of genus g as embedded on the surface of a sphere with g handles attached, Indyk and Sidiropoulos’ method gives an embedding into a distribution over planar graphs with distortion 2O(g), by iteratively removing the handles. By removing all g handles at once, we present a probabilistic embedding with distortion O(g2) for both orientable and non-orientable graphs. Our result is obtained by showing that the minimum-cut graph of Erickson and Har Peled (2004) has low dilation, and then randomly cutting this graph out of the surface using the Peeling Lemma of Lee and Sidiropoulos (2009).