How ACA rollback could affect the growing gig economy in 2017

Its continued growth may take a hit from potential changes to U.S. policy.

By
Alexia Elejalde-Ruiz
Chicago Tribune

January 1, 2017 — 11:14pm

Kristan Lieb, Chicago Tribune/TNSGabby Golub updates the Dry DryHop Brewers growler chalkboard on Dec. 16, 2016, at the brewpub in Chicago's Lakeview East neighborhood. Golub does chalkboard art for different bars and restaurants in addition to driving for Lyft and working part time at her old high school.

CHICAGO – If you are accustomed to traditional employment — a steady biweekly paycheck, reliable health benefits and a 401(k) with company match — Gabby Golub’s patchwork of jobs might send you into a panic.

Golub cobbles together a living chauffeuring passengers through the ride-hailing app Lyft, working part-time in the IT department at her old high school and sketching chalkboard art for restaurants and other businesses on a freelance basis. Sometimes one gig leads to another, such as when a conversation with a Lyft passenger got her a job doing illustrations for a children’s book.

“I enjoy the hustle so much more than the grind of full-time work,” said Golub, 24, who lives with a roommate and is on her parents’ health insurance plan, thanks to an Affordable Care Act provision that extended the cutoff age to 26.

Enjoy it or not, more people are hustling.

A growing share of the U.S. workforce relies on alternative work arrangements, which include on-demand gigs through online platforms like Lyft or Uber as well as work through temporary help agencies, freelance assignments and independent contracts.

The Bureau of Labor Statistics plans to conduct a comprehensive survey of these so-called contingent workers next year, its first since 2005, helping policymakers understand the size and makeup of a workforce not covered by many labor protections or privy to the benefits that come with a traditional employer relationship.

In the meantime, private research has shown significant growth in alterative arrangements that at best offer workers flexibility and at worst deprive them of economic security.

Nearly 16 percent of workers were engaged in alternative work arrangements in 2015, a jump from 10 percent in 2005, according to research released this year by Harvard economist Lawrence Katz and Princeton economist Alan Krueger. The rise over the prior decade was comparatively tiny, up from 9.3 percent in 1995.

All of the net employment growth from 2005 to 2015 occurred in alternative work arrangements, the researchers concluded, suggesting there was no net employment growth in traditional jobs.

That research only counted work that was considered someone’s main job. If you include moonlighters who have traditional jobs and hustle on the side, the freelance population this year was estimated at a third of the workforce, or 55 million Americans, an increase of 2 million people since 2014, according to a survey released in October by the nonprofit Freelancers Union and Upwork, an online freelance work marketplace.

“Many people expect that by 2020 to 2025 up to 50 percent of the workforce will get some income from independent labor,” said Kristin Sharp, executive director of the Shift Commission on Work, Workers and Technology, an initiative of New America, a public policy think tank.

Whether policy will catch up to the labor shifts is a question experts will watch in 2017. A major conversation point has been how to develop portable benefits that give gig economy workers access to retirement plans, unemployment insurance and paid sick leave even as they move from job to job.

The Affordable Care Act, which allows individuals to buy insurance on health care exchanges, has been credited with freeing people from the reliance on employers for health insurance. So the law’s fate under President-elect Trump, who has vowed to repeal at least parts of it, could affect people’s willingness to work independently, said Brian Kropp, human resources practice leader at business advisory firm CEB.

Under President Obama the Labor Department has been aggressive on issues of worker misclassification — that is, companies classifying workers as independent contractors or using temporary staffing agencies in order to avoid paying benefits like overtime, unemployment insurance and workers’ compensation. The National Labor Relations Board, a separate independent agency, under Obama expanded the joint-employer definition that holds parent companies liable for infractions alongside franchisees.

Puzder, CEO of CKE Restaurants, parent of the Hardees and Carl’s Jr. restaurant chains, is expected to be sympathetic to businesses wanting flexibility in their workforces, “so it places even more importance that social policy makes sure that nonprofits can offer ways for people to choose benefits,” said Sara Horowitz, founder and executive director of Freelancers Union, which provides advocacy and health insurance to its members.

The potential reasons for the recent growth of the gig economy range from necessity, for those who lost their jobs during the Great Recession, to workers’ desire for flexibility and efforts by companies to cut costs.

The rise in platforms such as Airbnb and Uber also have made it easier for people to transact with customers and turn their homes and cars into income streams, though they represent a minuscule fraction of the growing contingent workforce. And their growth, while still rapid, appears to be slowing.

Eduardo Izquierdo, 62, of Chicago, said he makes $600 to $800 a week driving Uber, transporting not only passengers but also delivering food and sometimes laundry. He gets frustrated by the meager pay of some of the newer services like Uber Pool, which sometimes nets him $1.25 on a ride, but the platform has been a savior after a tough financial period that included the loss of his convenience store business and several buildings he owned, which he returned to the bank during the housing bust.

“Without Uber I might be in the line for food stamps,” Izquierdo said.

Payday lenders got regulators to rethink rules on how closely to vet borrowers. E-cigarette makers got a delay in federal oversight of many vaping products. Candy makers praised a decision to hold off on more stringent labeling standards. And title insurers declared "victory" for getting changes that benefited them in the tax overhaul.

The Wisconsin Assembly planned to finish its work for the year Thursday by approving $350 million to build a new prison and provide all parents a $100 per-child tax rebate, although it's uncertain whether either will pass the Senate.