Which verification qubits perform best for secure communication in noisy
channel?

In secure quantum communication protocols, a set of single qubits prepared
using 2 or more mutually unbiased bases or a set of $n$-qubit ($n\geq2$)
entangled states of a particular form are usually used to form a verification
string which is subsequently used to detect traces of eavesdropping. The qubits
that form a verification string are referred to as decoy qubits, and there
exists a large set of different quantum states that can be used as decoy
qubits. In the absence of noise, any choice of decoy qubits provides equivalent
security. In this paper, we examine such equivalence for noisy environment
(e.g., in amplitude damping, phase damping, collective dephasing and collective
rotation noise channels) by comparing the decoy-qubit assisted schemes of
secure quantum communication that use single qubit states as decoy qubits with
the schemes that use entangled states as decoy qubits. Our study reveals that
the single qubit assisted scheme perform better in some noisy environments,
while some entangled qubits assisted schemes perform better in other noisy
environments. Specifically, single qubits assisted schemes perform better in
amplitude damping and phase damping noisy channels, whereas a few
Bell-state-based decoy schemes are found to perform better in the presence of
the collective noise. Thus, if the kind of noise present in a communication
channel (i.e., the characteristics of the channel) is known or measured, then
the present study can provide the best choice of decoy qubits required for
implementation of schemes of secure quantum communication through that channel.