Torn between the old and the new versions of the deservedly loved Marshall Kilburn? The Marshall Kilburn II is getting lots of praise, but for now the original is still on sale and often discounted. So which should you get?

We’ve done a thorough meta-analysis of the reviews for both, and this was one speaker that we ourselves also very much enjoyed and were happy to recommend.

We’ll take apart the differences in a side-by-side table so you can see for yourself if the new one is worth it for you, with a lot of our own commentary below that. Do note that the Kilburn II remains one of our favorites of the larger, louder Bluetooth speakers.

While at first glance there has hardly been a grand departure here, the Marshall Kilburn II does represent a significant step forward.

While keeping the same shape and overall styling, it’s slightly taller than the original but also just a bit lighter. The lovely throwback of volume, treble, and bass dials is still there, which make it much more inviting to fine-tune your sound than when using the equalizer apps that you have to deal with for most quality Bluetooth speakers. In addition, there is now a battery-level meter, aptly resembling a soundboard’s level indicator. There is also now a Bluetooth pairing button.

The corners of the unit have plastic caps, suggesting that the Kilburn II will be able to handle a bit more abuse. Add to that the new IPX2 waterproof rating, which means that you still shouldn’t dunk it in a pool, but it should be able to handle the odd drizzle, small splash, or other bit of water.

The insides of the Kilburn II have been upgraded as well to one woofer running on a 20-watt amplifier and two rear-firing tweeters on 8-watt amplifiers. The rear-firing is intended to give a bit more multidirectionality to the sound, though really the speaker still sounds best from the front as that’s where the stereo effect can really be heard properly.

Criticsso farhaveabsolutely loved the way the Kilburn II sounds, noting punchy crispness and dynamism throughout the mids and highs at any volume, and a potent, balanced, deep bass. There’s even more power and depth on bass-heavy tracks, but the original was no slouch here.

As with the first version, the Kilburn II gets quite loud and performs quite well doing so. Distortion isn’t apparent unless you twist all the dials — volume, bass, and treble — to their max, but of course that’s a silly thing to do and you’re well above uncomfortable volumes before then. The update goes a bit louder than the original, unsurprisingly given its improved guts.

There are a few other minor improvements. The Kilburn II works with Bluetooth 5.0 aptX, which offers increased range and, if you’re an audiophile who deigns to use Bluetooth, bragging rights (we doubt you can actually hear the difference with aptX, as most can’t). It can also connect two Bluetooth devices simultaneously, so you can war with your friend over who controls the music.

The Original Marshall Kilburn Is Still One of the Finest Large Bluetooth Speakers Out There

We recommended the originalMarshall Kilburn as our favorite larger Bluetooth speaker for more than a year. We loved the way it sounded, whether outside or filling large indoor spaces. In fact, my Brazilian dance teacher used it daily with his classes to fire up sambistas in a large dance studio, and nobody for a moment complained that we weren’t using a large built-in sound system.

The bass end is full and satisfying, and vocals and other instruments are reasonably separated and balanced. There’s fabulous clarity and heart to its performance. Neither the Marshall Kilburn nor the Kilburn II will sound as good as high-end bookshelf speakers — but to most listeners they will be close.

The consumerorganizations, critics, andaudiophileblogs have largely agreed with this assessment. As with the Kilburn II, they reported it didn’t distort at top volumes, and it got surprisingly loud. There was fullness and richness across various types of music.

We thus don’t hesitate to recommend the original Marshall Kilburn if you can still find it at a good price (the links in the table above can help with that). The Kilburn II is an improvement, but the first time out of the gates it was already a winner.

Wrap-Up: Is the Upgrade Right for You?

We think both units are great and anyone would be fine with the old version, though the new version definitely sounds better. To get the best prices, click through to Amazon and check on color and refurbished options in these listings as well.

One last note: If you’re buying a speaker for doing a lot of festivals, outdoor partying, or pool use, you should probably consider the more durable, fully-waterproof and 360-degree party monster the Ultimate Ears Megaboom 3 instead. We loved how it sounded too.

What is SelectoGuru.com?

We recommend the best stuff, particularly stuff for minimalist travel. In addition to testing out gear ourselves, we analyse the results reported from all major American and European consumer organisations and read copious press and tech site reviews. We also bring our own heavy dose of realism concerning how these products are actually used.

Who are you?

Nice folks, based out of frequently changing European cities. We released our first article in November 2014 and have continued to write obsessively ever since about whatever it strikes our fancy to research.

How do you know what’s best?

In addition to trying out the products, we review every scrap of information available on them, in many languages, before we make a recommendation. Our meta-analysis includes links to the sources we have found most useful, so you can verify them for yourself.

What do you mean by ‘best’?

The most useful, reliable stuff at the best price. We (usually) don't agree with tech sites' fawning over the most decked-out, crazy cool gadgets; we look for what works best for most people's real-life needs.

Why should I trust you?

We never accept payment from product manufacturers; our revenue is from affiliate networks, especially Amazon. This means we have no motivation to recommend one particular product over another (as long as they're available online, and pretty much everything is). Our goal is to recommend products that will serve you well, so that you'll come back to us as we expand this site to cover more products.

How can I support this research?

If you like what we're doing, just use our links on the day that you're ready to buy. Your prices will be the same and we'll hopefully get a small cut from Amazon or whomever. If you hate us, skip our links; we'll get nothing and have a sad.