Paul Wesley & Phoebe Tonkin: New Couple Alert?

“[They were] on a double date with Ben McKenzie and Shelley Hennig,” a source told the mag about the group on an outing this past weekend. “It looked like Paul and Phoebe might have set Ben up with Shelley — seemed like a first date.”

Ben and Paul met on set of The O.C., while Shelley and Phoebe starred on The Secret Circle together.

“Paul and Phoebe were 100% romantic – they were across the table from Ben all cozied up on the couch kissing each other,” the source continued. “She had her head on his chest.”