This is an Open Access article distributed under the terms of the Creative Commons Attribution Non-Commercial Licens (http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by-nc/3.0/)which permits unrestricted non-commercial use, distribution, and reproduction in any medium, provided the original work is properly cited.

We investigated factors affecting primary cultures of Pacific abalone
Haliotis discus hannai
ovary-dissociated cells to identify general aspects of their early-phase culture. Ninety-seven cell populations derived from 30 individuals were cultured in different media with varying compositions of medium supplements, and initial attachment, subculture, and survival for ≥10 weeks were assessed according to medium composition and individual. We also examined the time required for subculture and the rate of cell death according to both culturing period and passage number within 10 weeks. A lack of fetal bovine serum (FBS) and hemolymph significantly inhibited the growth of cultured cells, while we detected no significant effect of medium composition on initial cell attachment. Through data reallocation, with the omission of data from cell populations cultured in FBS-free and hemolymph-free media, we showed that growth inhibition was also affected by individual differences among the abalones used. During the culture, we observed four different types of cell morphology. Moreover, considerable time was required for subculture—18.4 and 19.5 days for first and second subcultures, respectively—and cell death did not occur within 30 days or for passage 0. Our results will provide valuable information for developing universal cell culturing guidelines in abalone species and suggest the feasibility of culturing abalone ovary-dissociated cells.

Abalones which belong to mollusc are important in aquaculture, and their cell lines can be used as in vitro models for biological and pathological research on marine molluscs (van der Merwe, 2010; Pichon et al., 2013; Yoshino et al., 2013). In particular, in vitro cultures of germline stem cells such as ovarian or spermatogonial stem cells have more utility than somatic cells due to their greater developmental competence; they can be applied to the production of transgenic animals and the preservation of species through cryopreservation (Guan et al., 2006; Zou et al., 2009; Lacerda et al., 2010; Wong et al., 2013). Therefore, developing cell culture techniques for germline stem cells in abalone is important to future biotechnological applications of this organism, and thus we must establish general guidelines for abalone cell culture.

For these reasons, we conducted primary cultures of cell populations derived from Pacific abalone Haliotis discus hannai ovaries to determine optimal culture conditions. We determined which components of the culture medium are involved in in vitro cell survival and growth, and assessed the feasibility of culturing abalone ovary-dissociated cells by evaluating their general culture characteristics. Based on initial culture conditions from our previous reports, which showed the importance of media salinity and growth factor addition in primary cultures of radula-derived abalone cell populations (Kim et al., 2014a), we carried out primary cultures of H. discus hannai ovary-dissociated cells and evaluated the effects of media supplements. We also examined general culture characteristics such as cell morphology, time required for subculture, and cell death according to culture period and passage number.

Materials and Methods

- Animals

Pacific abalones were obtained from the Genetics & Breeding Research Center of the National Fisheries Research and Development Institute (Geoje, Korea). To obtain mature ovaries, abalones with swollen, dark green ovaries were selected and transported directly to the laboratory. The ovaries contained many late vitellogenic oocytes with distinct nuclei and nucleoli, and were classified as stage III of maturity (Najmudeen, 2007). Thirty abalones were sacrificed for this study, with an average shell length and total weight of 9.85 ± 0.36 cm and 99.07 ± 9.07 g, respectively.

- Hemolymph preparation

Prior to dissecting the abalones for tissue collection, we collected hemolymph from the body cavities around the heart using 3-mL syringes as a medium supplement. Hemocytes were separated by centrifugation at 3,500 g for 15 min, and the supernatant hemolymph was kept at 4℃ overnight. The next day, after additional centrifugation at 3,500 g for 30 min, the supernatant was inactivated at 56°C for 30 min, filtered with a 0.1-μm syringe filter (Sartorius Stedim Biotech, Göttingen, Germany), and stored at –20℃ until use.

Dissociated cells were seeded in 0.1% gelatin (Sigma- Aldrich)-coated 48-well culture plates (Becton Dickinson, Franklin Lakes, NJ, USA) filled with 800 μL of culture medium at 2 × 105 cells/well density; 200 μL of mineral oil (Sigma-Aldrich) was used to cover the medium to prevent its evaporation. Cells were cultured in an 18℃ incubator in an air atmosphere. After 3 days of culture, cells were washed twice with WS and filled with fresh culture medium. Thereafter, half the media were replaced every 4 or 5 days. When cells reached 100% confluency and cell sheets were formed, we conducted subculturing. For the subculture, cells were washed twice with 1% (v/v) P/S-containing calcium magnesium-free artificial seawater (CMFAS) consisting of 26.2 g/L NaCl, 0.67 g/L KCl, 4.62 g/L Na2SO4, 0.21 g/L NaHCO3, and 0.37 g/L Na2∙EDTA and trypsinized with CMFAS containing 0.05% trypsin–EDTA. After detachment of cells, L15 adjusted to 35 psu containing 10% (v/v) FBS and 1% (v/v) P/S were added for trypsin inactivation, and the cell suspension was centrifuged at 400 g for 4 min. The collected cells were plated at different ratios according to the subculture. Until passage 2, cells were subcultured at a 1:1 ratio in a 48-well culture plate, while from passage 2 to 3, cells were split at a 1:2 ratio in a 48-well culture plate. From passage 3 to 4, cells cultured in two wells of a 48-well culture plate were subcultured together in one well of a 24-well culture plate (SPL life Sciences) and from passage 4 to 5, cells were split at a 1:2 ratio in a 24-well culture plate. In all subcultures, 50% (v/v) conditioned media were used. Initial cell attachment, survival, and cell morphology during maintenance were visually investigated under an inverted microscope (TS100-F; Nikon, Tokyo, Japan).

- Hoechst 33342 staining

To investigate the state of the nuclei in cultured cells, we conducted nucleus staining. Live cells after initial attachment (passage 0) and the fourth subculture (passage 4) were washed twice with WS, and fresh media containing Hoechst 33342 (Molecular Probes, Eugene, OR, USA) at a final concentration of 5 μg/mL were added. After incubation for 30 min, cells were washed twice with WS and culture wells filled with fresh culture medium. Stained nuclei were visualized under an inverted microscope equipped with a fluorescent lamp (Nikon).

- Experimental design and statistical analysis

To investigate the effects of seven medium supplements consisting of FBS, hemolymph, bFGF, EGF, LIF, AEE, and MEE, the composition of the culture medium was varied by removing one supplement from culture media containing all seven supplements. That is, we produced a total of eight culture media including one complete medium (containing all seven supplements) and one each without FBS, hemolymph, bFGF, EGF, LIF, AEE, or MEE, and cultured H. discus hannai ovary-dissociated cells in each. Each single supplement-deprived medium was designated as the “supplement name”-free medium. We used a generalized linear model (PROC-GLM) in Statistical Analysis System software (SAS Institute, Cary, NC, USA) to analyze the numerical data. When a significant main effect was detected, treatments were subsequently compared by either the least squares or Duncan’s method. Significant differences among treatments were defined as P < 0.05.

Results

- Initial cell attachment of ovary-dissociated cell populations

On day 3 of culture after initial cell seeding, we identified initial cell attachment. All ovary-dissociated cell populations cultured in these experiments showed successful initial cell attachment regardless of medium composition (total attachment in all 97 trials = 100%; Table 1). Moreover, the rate of initial cell attachment was an average of 70% in all cell populations and reached a maximum of 100% when scored visually. The morphologies of initially attached cells were very similar in all cell populations regardless of treatment, and all displayed thick, irregular forms harboring one nucleus with two or three nucleoli and many granules within their cytoplasm (Fig. 1A and 1B).

Model effects of treatments in the number of cell populations subcultured to passage 1, the number of cell population subcultured to passage 2, and the number of cell populations that survived ≥10 weeks were <0.0001, 0.0412, and 0.0077, respectively. *Composition of complete medium is as follow; Leibovitz 15 (L-15) medium supplemented to FBS, hemolymph, bFGF, EGF, LIF, AEE, MEE, and antibiotics. “XX”-free indicates the medium that XX is removed from complete medium. †Percentage of number of cell populations tested. ‡Percentage of number of cell populations initially attached. a-cDifferent letters within the same column indicate significant differences (P < 0.05)

In contrast to the results for initial cell attachment, we detected significant differences in the growth of initially attached cells among treatments. As shown in Table 1, cell populations cultured in FBS-free or hemolymph-free media showed significantly lower rates in the first subculture. Only 18% (2 of 11) and 0% (0 of 8) of the initially attached cell populations cultured in FBS-free and hemolymph-free media, respectively, survived beyond the first subculture, while 79%–93% of cell populations cultured in the other six groups did so (0%–18% vs. 79%–93%, P < 0.0001). Of all cell populations cultured, 60% (58 of 97) survived more than 10 weeks, and cell populations cultured in MEE-free media showed the highest survival rate at 86%. No cell populations cultured in hemolymph-free media survived past 10 weeks, while those cultured in FBS-free media survived better than those in hemolymph-free media (45% vs. 0%, P < 0.05) despite their similar survival in the first subculture. Only one cell population cultured in MEE-free medium was subcultured to passage 5, for a total culture period of 170 days (Table 1). Morphological inspection assisted by Hoechst 33342 staining confirmed that after the fourth subculture, cells still possessed one nucleus containing two or three nucleoli with no abnormal appearance (Fig. 1B).

- Effects of individual differences on primary culture outcome

To examine the effects of individual differences among abalones on culture outcomes, we rearranged the data from Table 1 according to the replicates (Table 2). In this reallocation, data from cell populations cultured in FBS-free and hemolymph-free media were excluded as they differed significantly from the other six groups. Results showed that 65 of 78 (83%) cell populations and all cell populations in 12 of 15 replicates grew and survived beyond the first subculture, while significantly different results were detected in cell populations from the other three replicates. These did not grow enough to progress to subculturing, with the exception of one cell population (0%–17% vs. 100%, P < 0.05; Table 2). Subsequently, 37% (29 of 78) of the cell populations were subcultured twice but additional cell populations from four different replicates stopped their growth, and they did not progress to the second subculture. Sixty-eight percent (53 of 78) of cell populations survived beyond 10 weeks, but significant differences were detected among replicates. No significant data correlation was detected between the subculture results and survival after 10 or more weeks.

Effects of individual difference of abalones used on primary culture outcome

PPT Slide

Lager Image

This table was made from reallocation of the data from Table 1. Model effects of treatments in the number of cell populations subcultured to passage 1, the number of cell population subcultured to passage 2, and the number of cell populations that survived ≥10 weeks were all <0.0001. *Number of cell populations analyzed in each replicate except for cell populations cultured in FBS-free and hemolymph-free media. †Percentage of number of cell populations tested. ‡Percentage of number of cell populations initially attached. a-dDifferent letters within the same column indicate significant differences (P < 0.05)

- Cell morphology during culture

Throughout the culture of H. discus hannai ovary-dissociated cells, we observed different cultured cell morphologies, which we arbitrarily classified into four types (types I–IV; Fig. 1C). Almost all initially attached cells corresponded to type I, which showed thick and irregular shapes harboring many granules within their cytoplasm. In contrast, the other three cell types appeared during the maintenance period. Type II cells were flattened and had fewer granules within their cytoplasm than type I cells, while type III cells formed large cell aggregates. Type IV cells displayed fibroblast-like morphology, with a thick, elongated shape. In most cases, two or three cell types coexisted in a cell population.

- Subculture period and cell death in early-phase cultures

The period after initial cell seeding until first subculture varied from 7 to 65 days according to the cell populations analyzed, and the average period was 18.4 days. Likewise, the period between the first and second subculture varied from 4 to 43 days, with an average of 19.5 days (Fig. 2A). For analysis of early-phase cell deaths, the cell populations that died before 10 weeks of culture were subjected to these analyses but those cultured in FBS-free and hemolymph-free media were excluded. No cell death took place during the first 30 days of culture; the first deaths occurred on day 31, and 32% (25 of 78) of cell populations died prior to day 70. Cells deaths were concentrated between days 41 and 70, and increased over time until day 70 (Fig. 2B). In terms of passage number, cells deaths did not occur in passage 0, and their frequencies in passages 1 and 2 were 48% and 52%, respectively (Fig. 2C).

General culture aspects in early phase of culture. (A) Periods required for subculture were analyzed in all cell populations from each treatment group and the average days were presented. Average days required for first and second subcultures on all cell populations cultured were 18.4 days and 19.5 days, respectively. (B) and (C) indicate the rate of cell death of cell populations in early phase of culture (within 10 weeks) according to culture period (day) and passage number, respectively. No cell death were identified within 30 days of culture and in passage 0.

Discussion

In this study, we investigated the effects of medium supplements on cultures of H. discus hannai ovary-dissociated cells and described the general properties of these cultures during in vitro maintenance.

We demonstrated that initial attachment of freshly isolated cell populations is not affected by either a lack of specific medium supplements or by individual differences, showing that all cell populations cultured attached at an average rate of 70% regardless of treatment. In a previous study, we revealed that supplements added to media containing FBS and hemolymph improved the initial attachment of abalone cells (Kim et al., 2014a). Since the same factors used in this previous report were added in this study, we assumed that similar effects on cell attachment would be induced, even if one factor was omitted in each experimental group. Another possibility, based on previous reports that gonad extract enhances the growth performance of oyster heart cells (Chen and Wen, 1999) and abalone mantle cells (Suja et al., 2007), is that ovary tissue extracts, which might be extracted during the tissue dissociation procedure, might positively affect cell attachment. Otherwise, H. discus hannai ovary-dissociated cells may simply have an exceptional ability to attach to substrata.

The growth of cell populations cultured with FBS-free or hemolymph-free media was significantly lower than that of other groups, indicating that FBS and hemolymph contain critical components for the stable growth and maintenance of H. discus hannai ovary-dissociated cells. Indeed, FBS is known to be an important component of cell cultures and is used in almost all animal cell cultures (Freshney, 2010). Additionally, some studies have used hemolymph in several invertebrate cell cultures as a medium component (Srivatsan and Peretz, 1997; Chen and Wen, 1999; Khurad et al., 2009; Kim et al., 2014a) and occasionally in mammalian cell cultures as a substitute for FBS (Choi et al., 2005; Rhee et al., 2013). Several studies that attempted in vitro cultures of molluscan cells also support our results. For example, Domart-Coulon et al. (1994) and Chen and Wen (1999), which examined cultures of Crassostrea gigas heart-derived cells, demonstrated that FBS and/or hemolymph promoted cell growth and viability. In addition, others have reported that the insulin contained in FBS can increase in vitro incorporation of amino acids in the mantle collar of Helisoma duryi (Sevala et al., 1993) and that the molluscan insulin-like peptide, acetylcholinesterase, or nerve growth factor-like molecules within molluscan hemolymph may promote neurite outgrowth and synaptogenesis in neuronal cell cultures of Aplysia californica (Ghirardi et al., 1996; Srivatsan and Peretz, 1997; Hyland et al., 2014). Here, we showed that the removal of other medium supplements, including bFGF, EGF, LIF, AEE, and MEE, did not affect cell growth and maintenance, which can be explained by the overlap of signals provided by each supplement (Andrae et al., 2008; Klingseisen et al., 2009). We propose that additional experiments in which two or more supplements are removed are conducted to more clearly determine the critical components necessary for primary cultures of H. discus hannai ovary-dissociated cells.

The growth and maintenance of cell populations cultured in several replicates were significantly lower, suggesting that individual differences play a major role in the outcome of culturing—although, as we used abalone pairs as single replicates, the term “individual difference” may be inappropriate. Regardless, the presence of individual differences is unsurprising and is a well-known phenomenon in biological experiments (d’Agostino, 1998). This should be carefully considered in invertebrate cell culturing, a field that is still under development, to reduce experimental error in future studies.

During maintenance of cell populations, we investigated general culturing aspects such as which cell morphologies appeared, the time required for subculturing, and the cell death rate during the early culture phase. We identified four distinct morphologies among the cultured cells, which may reflect different cell types. Alternately, cell populations initially consisting of one cell type may change their cell morphology during culture according to the culturing environment. Whatever the case, our data provide fundamental information on the morphologies that may appear during the culture of H. discus hannai ovary-dissociated cells. Although high variation was observed, the average period required for subculture was longer than for mammalian and fish species whose cell culture systems are well established (Freshney, 2010; Lee et al., 2013; Kim et al., 2014b), indicating very poor growth performance in the cells cultured in this study. This suggests that the optimization of cell culturing systems for abalone should be prioritized, and that data from the general culturing conditions we examined can provide valuable information in this regard.

Because abalone ovarian tissues consist of germline cells and various types of somatic cells (Wetakan et al., 2001; Awaji and Hamano, 2004), the cell populations cultured and maintained in this study need to be characterized to identify their cellular origin. The cell populations derived from germline cells can be used directly in biotechnological applications. On the other hand, somatic cells can be used as feeder cells for culturing ovary-derived germline stem cells. Molecular characterization of the cells cultured in this study should be conducted in further studies.

In conclusion, primary cultures of H. discus hannai ovary-dissociated cells can be significantly affected by two medium supplements, FBS and hemolymph, and by individual variation. Our results can contribute to the development of universal conditions for the primary culture of abalone cells and further suggest the feasibility of culturing ovary-derived germline stem cells in this species.

Acknowledgements

This research was supported by Golden Seed Project, Ministry of Agriculture, Food and Rural Affairs (MAFRA), Ministry of Oceans and Fisheries (MOF), Rural Development Administration (RDA) and Korea Forest Service (KFS).