In a letter sent today to Ohio Supreme Court justices Robert Cupp and
Terrence O’Donnell, former Judge William O’Neill asked the Republican
justices to recuse themselves from a case presenting conflicts of interest or
refuse the campaign money that caused the conflicts of interest to begin
with.
“The First Energy Family has contributed more than
$44,000.00 into re-election campaigns for Justices Cupp and O’Donnell
this year alone,” O’Neill, a Democrat who is running for the Ohio
Supreme Court, wrote. “It is simply wrong for them to continue sitting
on First Energy cases.”
The Ohio Supreme Court, which has seven justices decide
the state’s top judicial cases, is currently handling a case
involving FirstEnergy, an energy company based in Akron. More than
300,000 customers are suing the company over alleged fraud. The 11th
District Court of Appeals previously ruled against FirstEnergy, and the case was appealed to the Ohio Supreme Court.
The lawsuit is the fifth Ohio Supreme Court case involving FirstEnergy this year.
O’Neill pointed out the lawsuit “could easily be a billion
dollar case” before writing, “And the public has a right to know that
the ruling was not purchased by one side or another.”
Ohio Sen. Mike Skindell, a Democrat who is also running
for the Ohio Supreme Court, endorsed O’Neill’s letter. In the past, he
also criticized Cupp and O’Donnell for potential conflicts of interest.The offices of Cupp and O'Donnell did not immediately respond to CityBeat's requests for comment on the letter. This story will be updated if responses become available.UPDATE OCT. 4, 4:12 P.M.: Mark Weaver, spokesperson for Cupp, responded: “Mr. O'Neill previously raised this argument with disciplinary authorities by filing a complaint. It was reviewed by disciplinary authorities, and they unanimously dismissed it as having no merit.”