Transcription

1 Guided Inquiry Forensics Lab hapter 26 Lab Investigating Hominoid Fossils Problem What can a comparison of skulls and hands reveal about the evolution of humans? Introduction paleontologist takes photographs of a newly discovered fossil while it is in the ground and after it is removed. He or she also makes many measurements. These observations make it easier to compare the new fossil to fossils that have already been classified. How can a scientist know whether a skeleton is typical of its species? For example, a scientist may find that one skeleton is much taller than another. Does this variation in height indicate that the individuals were members of two different species? Does it reflect a range of heights within the same species? To deal with this problem, scientists use indexes. n index is a ratio that compares the value of one measurement in relation to another. Indexes are useful because they do not depend on overall size. Very tall and very short members of the same species should have similar indexes. With indexes, it is more likely that variations are related to differences in species, not just differences in size. In this lab, you will measure the skulls and hands of different hominoid species. You will use your measurements to calculate indexes that will help you compare these species. ig Idea The changes that occurred in certain bones as hominines evolved facilitated bipedal locomotion and tool use. Skills Objectives Students will be able to calculate indexes from pairs of related measurements. relate skeletal indexes to differences among species. lass Time 45 minutes Group Size Individuals Skills Focus Measure, nalyze Data, ompare and ontrast Materials metric ruler Term uild Vocabulary variation Definition The degree, or extent, to which a set of similar items differ, or vary uild Vocabulary Students will have a more successful lab experience if they understand these terms. proportion part considered in relation to the whole 161

2 Pre-Lab Questions 1. Use Models What will you use instead of actual skulls and hands to make your measurements? I will be using images of skulls and hands. 2. Interpret Visuals The bony cavities in a skull that protect the eyes are called orbits, or eye sockets. On the skulls, what does line measure? What does line measure? Line measures the distance from the bottom of the eye socket to the top of the skull. Line measures the distance from the top of the eye socket to the top of the skull. 3. Use nalogies Shoe sizes such as 9 and 11E (or 9 narrow and 11 extra-wide) are an example of an index. What two measurements are being compared in a shoe index? Sample answer: In a shoe size, the width of the shoe is being compared to the length of the shoe. Teaching Tip If possible, have at least one skull available for students to observe and discuss. Procedure Part : Supraorbital Height Index in Hominoids Figure 1 shows side views of skulls from four hominoid species. You will use these drawings to determine distances from the top of the skull to the upper and lower edges of the eye socket. Then you will calculate the supraorbital height index (SHI). This index indicates the proportion of the skull that is above the eyes. The prefix supra- means above. 1. Measure the distances and in centimeters for each skull. Record the measurements in Data Table For each species, divide the value of by the value of and multiply the result by 100. The result is the supraorbital height index (SHI). Round the answers to the nearest whole number, and record them in Data Table 1. Sample Data Data Table 1: Skull Measurements Species (cm) (cm) SHI Pan troglodytes ustralopithecus afarensis Homo erectus Homo sapiens

5 Part : Thumb Index in Hominoids Figure 2 depicts the thumb and index finger of Pan troglodytes, ustralopithecus afarensis, and Homo sapiens. You will use these drawings to calculate a thumb index for each species. The thumb index compares the length of the thumb to the length of the hand. 3. For each species, measure the length of the thumb and the length of the index finger in centimeters. Make these measurements from the tip of the digit to the point where the finger and thumb meet at the wrist joint. Record your results in Data Table To calculate the thumb index, divide thumb length by index finger length and multiply the result by 100. Round the answer to the nearest whole number and record the result in the table. Sample Data Data Table 2: Hand Measurements Thumb Length (cm) Index Finger Length (cm) Thumb Index Pan troglodytes Part Homo erectus is not included in Part because there are no known thumb bone fossils for this species. ustralopithecus afarensis Homo sapiens Figure 2 Hand bones of three hominoids Pan troglodytes ustralopithecus afarensis Homo sapiens 165

6 nalyze and onclude 1. nalyze Data Of the species you investigated, which had the smallest SHI and which had the largest? What is the relationship between the SHI value and the shape of the skull? Sample answer: Pan had the smallest SHI and Homo sapiens had the largest. In skulls with a higher SHI value, a larger proportion of the skull is above the eye. 2. Infer How might an increase in a hominoid s SHI value affect the size of its brain? Sample answer: When the proportion of the skull above the eyes increases, there is more room for the brain. Thus, the size of the brain could increase relative to the overall size of the skull. 3. nalyze Data Does the data support the hypothesis that the thumb index increased as the opposable thumb hand evolved? Explain. Sample answer: The data (although limited) seems to support this hypothesis because Pan, which does not have an opposable thumb, has a smaller thumb index than H. sapiens, which has an opposable thumb. 4. Relate ause and Effect How could an increase in the thumb index affect a hominoid s ability to use its hands? Sample answer: s the thumb index increases, the length of the thumb increases in relation to the rest of the hand. Longer thumbs can touch the fingertips, making it easier to grasp objects and use them as tools. 5. Design an Experiment Suppose you repeated this lab with drawings that were half the size of the drawings you used. Would your results be the same? Why or why not? Sample answer: The measurements would have been different, but the indexes would not have changed because the drawings would have the same proportions. uild Science Skills skeleton retains clues about the life of its owner. How can fossils be used to determine a hominid skeleton s age, sex, or diet? How can fossils be used to tell how heavy or muscular an individual was? Students may know about wisdom teeth and pelvic shape (from a previous lab). one fusing is another clue to age. Teeth wear provides clues to diet. one mass and surface texture are clues to musculature. 166

Name: Date: Human Evolution - Skull Analysis Prior Knowledge Questions (Do these BEFORE using the Gizmo.) 1. Label one of the skulls below as human and the other as a chimpanzee skull. 2. What features

Name: Date: Student Exploration: Human Evolution - Skull Analysis Prior Knowledge Questions 1. Label one of the skulls below as human and the other as a chimpanzee skull. 2. What features did you use to

Early Human Evolution Overview and Chronology What makes us human? Ardipithecus and early Australopithecus Robust and gracile australopithecines Oldowan tools Overview First hominins appeared late in the

Study Guide Primates and Human Evolution Describe the traits of primates.! Classify yourself taxonomically.! What traits make you human?! Describe the evolutionary trends in hominin species over the past

Mammals Grew 1,000 Times Larger After the Demise of the Dinosaurs The largest land mammals that ever lived, Indricotherium and Deinotherium, would have towered over the living African Elephant. Indricotherium

Where Do We Come From? An Introduction to Primate Biology GK-12 Inquiry Science Lesson Kristin De Lucia Fall 2002 Background: This lesson is designed to correspond with units on human anatomy, especially

STRUCTURED INQUIRY: Investigating Surface Area to Volume Ratio in Cells Introduction: All organisms are composed of cells. The size and shape of a cell determines how well it can deliver nutrients to its

TEACHER GUIDE Human Evolution: One Step at a Time 60-Minute Life Science Lesson Interactive Video Conferencing Grades: 6-12 Human Evolution: One Step at a Time Description Trace the development of modern

32 3 Primates and Human Origins Section 32 3 Our own species, Homo sapiens, belongs to the order that also includes lemurs, monkeys, and apes. Carolus Linnaeus named our order Primates, which means first

Name Class Date Chapter 37 Circulatory and Respiratory Systems Measuring Lung Capacity Introduction The amount of air that you move in and out of your lungs depends on how quickly you are breathing. The

DESCRIPTION IN-DEPTH FILM GUIDE Paleontologists have studied the fossil record of human evolution just as they have done for that of other major transitions including the transition from fish to tetrapods

Cenozoic Climates Human Evolution and Adaptation Life Styles of the Merely Hominid Miocene Climates Miocene Habitats The increase in climate variability would have been evident in many regions as increased

Bipedalism and Tool Making And the fascinating history of the extended phenotype What exactly does it mean for big toes to be abductible (opposable)? I was wondering how scientists were able to distinguish

Primate Evolution What You ll Learn You will compare and contrast primates and their adaptations. You will analyze the evidence for the ancestry of humans. Why It s Important Humans are primates. A knowledge

Measuring Length Goals You will be able to choose, use, and rename metric length measurements measure perimeters of polygons solve problems using diagrams and graphs Running in a Triathlon Racing Snails

MTP Science Animals, including humans Science National Curriculum Pupils should be taught to: identify that animals, including humans, need the right types and amount of nutrition, and that they cannot

Australopithecines the extinct southern apes of Africa: a fresh light on their status? A.W. (Bill) Mehlert The now-extinct hominid subfamily Australopithecinae has long been a hot and contentious topic

Name: Date: WALKING WITH DINOSAURS Part One Making Observations We will walk through the dinosaur trackway together. There are two different scenes. List observations of what you see in the boxes below.

Experiment #2. Density and Measurements Goals 1. To measure and record length, volume and mass accurately with the correct number of significant figures 2. To use significant figures correctly in calculations.

Orientation of the Foramen Magnum in Late Miocene to Extant African Apes and Hominids XLIII/2 3 pp. 103 110 2005 MARTIN PICKFORD ORIENTATION OF THE FORAMEN MAGNUM IN LATE MIOCENE TO EXTANT AFRICAN APES

The Toledo Zoo/ThinkingWorks Teacher Overview for the Primate Lessons Teacher Overview: Primates Primates have many traits that are unique to this particular order of animals. Below is a list of general

Objective The Determination of the Value for Molar Volume Using a chemical reaction that produces a gas, measure the appropriate values to allow a determination of the value for molar volume. Brief Overview

University of Iowa Iowa Research Online Theses and Dissertations Summer 2010 Three-dimensional morphometrics of the proximal metatarsal articular surfaces of Gorilla, Pan, Hylobates, and shod and unshod

Fish Dissection The Fish Dissection program at Hatfield Marine Science Center is a 50-minute hands-on program for 4th through 12th grade students. Students will work in small groups as they examine a variety

A New Kind of Ancestor: Ardipithecus Unveiled The oldest known hominin skeleton reveals the body plan of our very early ancestors and the upright origins of humankind Every day, scientists add new pages

Experiment 1 Introduction to Some Laboratory Measurements Introduction In this experiment you will familiarize yourself with the English & metric systems of measurement, weigh with a centigram balance,

DOI: 0.08/s67-07-00997- OPEN Evidence of a chimpanzee-sized ancestor of humans but a gibbon-sized ancestor of apes Mark Grabowski,,, & William L. Jungers 5,6 Body mass directly affects how an animal relates

The Deuterostomes and the rise of the Vertebrates: from Echinoderms to Man 1 The Deuterostomes Calcarea and Silicea Cnidaria Lophotrochozoa Ecdysozoa Deuterostomia 2 The Ancestral Deuterostome Bilateral

Chapter 1 Driving the Roads An error that cannot be corrected by calculation is called a random error. No measurement is perfect. When you measure something, you make an approximation close to a certain

Inquiry Module 1: Checking the calibration of a micropipette 1. Introduction Larger volumes (1mL and more) are usually measured using pipets or measuring cylinders. Such cylinders and pipets are labelled

Field Evaluation for Boone and Crockett Score Alaska Yukon and Canada Moose by Craig Boddington Of all the living members of the deer family, moose have the greatest amount of antler material. They also

ONE MILE RUN Aerobic Capacity Test Option 1 Run one mile as quickly as possible. If a student cannot run the entire mile, walking is permitted. Students will begin on the signal Ready, Start. If necessary,

Hawaii s Coral Reefs Concepts Students will learn how coral grows and how their forms are important for function. They will also learn about divergence by learning about four major types of coral. Guess

Levers In the last lesson, we spent a lot of time on this strange concept called work. Work happens when something moves a distance against a force. Swell...who cares?! Well, believe it or not, this is

CHAPTER 3 2 Buoyant Force SECTION Forces in Fluids BEFORE YOU READ After you read this section, you should be able to answer these questions: What is buoyant force? What makes objects sink or float? How

PROCESS OVERVIEW Please read the whole instruction series through once carefully before you begin tapping. x x 3 x 4 x 5 x 6 x The cortices tapping process is easy to do and easy to remember, once you've

Chapter 30 Nonvertebrate Chordates, Fishes, and Amphibians Name Lab Dissecting a Perch Background Information Fish are the largest group of vertebrates found in fresh and salt water. In fact, over 25,000

Lab: Biology of Fishes The Basic Fish: The essential elements of the fish framework include a skull, a backbone made up of a series of vertebrae, and two pairs of fins- the pectorals and the pelvics. The

Lay on your stomach, your head on your hands. Contract your thighs. Press your pubic bone into the mat while lifting your belly-button as if an ice cube was underneath. Place the Mambo Max Soft- Over-Ball

Bicycling FOR Women Gale Bernhardt BOULDER, COLORADO The information and ideas in this book are for educational and instructional purposes and are not intended as prescriptive advice. Copyright 2008 by

CHAPTER 10 Origin and Evolution of Human Postcranial Anatomy Brian G. Richmond and Kevin G. Hatala INTRODUCTION One of the oldest questions in paleoanthropology concerns what stages, or body shapes and

Name lass Date 14. Law of osines Essential Question: How can you use the Law of osines to find measures of any triangle? Resource Locker Explore Deriving the Law of osines You learned to solve triangle

Displaying Quantitative (Numerical) Data with Graphs DOTPLOTS: One of the simplest graphs to construct and interpret is a dotplot. Each data value is shown as a dot above its location on a number line.

Page 1 of 5 KEY ONEPT Waters rise and fall in tides. BEFORE, you learned Wind provides the energy to form waves in the ocean Ocean waves change near shore The ocean is a global body of water NOW, you will

Lesson 3: Crossing Intersections Safely Time: approximately 40 minutes This curriculum does not cover every possible scenario that a child may encounter as a pedestrian, but instead addresses the basic

Nervous System: Reaction Time Student Version Key Concepts: Your nervous system allows your body to react to different stimuli (external events) Reactions can be voluntary (eg: swinging a bat at a ball

K-12 Partnership Lesson Plan Overview Invasion: Total Take-Over! Exploring invasive species and the methods to control them Invasive species are non-native, introduced species that have a negative impact

Intended Class: Marine Science Intended Grade Level: 11-12 Neutrally Buoyant No More Time Allotment: Two, 55-minute periods. Day one should be lecture, background information and giving the students time

Measuring Lung Capacity Background: The amount of air that you move in and out of your lungs while breathing normally is referred to as TIDAL VOLUME. While it is possible to inhale and exhale more forcefully

NAME: Using Darts to Simulate the Distribution of Electrons in a 1s Orbital Introduction: The quantum theory is based on the mathematical probability of finding an electron in a given three dimensional

Chapter 13: The Behavior of Gases I. First Concepts a. The 3 states of matter most important to us: solids, liquids, and gases. b. Real Gases and Ideal Gases i. Real gases exist, ideal gases do not ii.

Circulation and Respiration: Vital Signs Student Version In this lab, you will learn about the circulatory and respiratory systems. You will test the capacity of your lungs, measure your blood pressure