Arizona: Open for Business

Click on the Title to read the full post.

I was at a function the other day when I was challenged to take a position on the stupid ’black lives matter vs. all lives matter’ false dichotomy. I was fortunate to be in a group that actually let me answer with more nuance. Here is essentially what I said:

There is a real problem with police accountability and police violence in this country, one I have been writing about since long before the BLM movement was even created.

The harm of these police accountability issues falls disproportionately, but not solely, on blacks and other minority ethnic groups

For any number of reasons, fixing racism is not the immediate answer. Most obviously, because racism is super-hard to eradicator and has persisted (though improved, IMO) despite a lot of attention over many decades. It is hard to point to any time and place in human history when some folks have not been seduced by in-group-out-group thinking

There are real, identifiable steps that can actually increase police accountability and transparency and reduce the types of police violence incidents BLM was formed to oppose. Early on, BLM actually identified a pretty good list.

BLM did a fabulous job of raising awareness and putting these issues near the center of political discussion.

Having done so, BLM now has gone completely off the rails. It appears to be entirely focused on virtue-signalling and disruption and support of progressive issues completely tangential to its initial focus. It has no coherent action plan. Colin Kapernick torpedoed his own football career to bring attention to BLM, but once he did so and had microphones thrust in his face from every direction, neither he nor any of his supporters had anything specific to advocate for, other than outrage and telegraphing their victim status.

Progress can be made on these issues, but what it will take is a hard city by city slog to change the rules that govern police discipline and transparency. As I wrote before, BLM “could learn a lot from Conservative and libertarian groups like ALEC, that focus on creating model legislation and local success stories that can be copied in other places.”

Republicans often oppose police accountability steps — they don’t just support the police, they fetishize them. But the cities that most cry out for new accountability rules – New York, Chicago, Detroit, Baltimore, St. Louis, Los Angeles — are have Democratic super-majorities and governments whose officials almost to a one have come out publicly in support of BLM. So why no progress? One big barrier is the Democratic Party’s unwavering support for public employee unions, and it is police unions that are the biggest barrier to implementing the steps BLM should be demanding. This is another side of this issue discussed earlier in the week.