Perry says Arencibia and her family staged her dream proposal. Kimberly explains that she stepped out of the house and saw J.P. and her loved ones under the large oak tree on her family's Greeneville property, and realized "this is really happening." She says her mom then took her back inside so she could change into the pink dress she said she wanted to be wearing if she were ever asked for her hand.

Her mom also gave Kimberly a bracelet her grandfather gave her grandmother when they were dating, and a letter from the family. Perry says when she returned outside J.P. got down on one knee, adding that "it was perfect."

Arencibia's off-season home is in Nashville. He first met Perry after arranging to get backstage for the trio's meet and greet in February 2012, when The Band Perry performed at the Florida Strawberry Festival. They were officially a couple a few months later. Kimberly and J.P. plan to get married next summer.