Perhaps it's the consistency-same fluorescent lighting, same (different, but same) pop song playing, same row overstocked with candy and plush toys to mark whatever holiday is coming up or has just passed-and of course, all the cult beauty products that keep us returning time and again.

Though it’s hard to break your routine and try something new from the packed shelves, one could argue that a tip on what’s great (and affordable!) is the best kind of beauty advice there is. So, we asked ten Vogue editors to reveal their go-to products—and here are their picks.