If a stranger asked you to take off your clothes, don questionable swimwear and perform a bellyflop in front of a panel of judges on national television, you’d probably walk away as quickly as possible. Luckily for Jimmy Kimmel (and us viewers), these five folks obliged with spectacular results.

It was all part of Jimmy Kimmel Live‘s hilarious 8th Annual Pedestrian Belly Flop Competition, which pitted two women and three men—plucked off the streets of LA—against each other for the illustrious title of “bellyflop champion.” The three panel judges—including two-time Olympic gold medallist Greg Louganis—had a hard time deciding who flopped the best. (Partially due to the fact that they themselves got soaked every time someone jumped.)

Whose flop was your fave? Watch the above video and sound off in the comments below.