Re: A good addition to my existing collection?

You have the citrus, orientals, and gourmands covered. I think you would benefit from something more floral or powdery, lacking in sweetness, like a Narcisco Rodriguez, one of the pradas, Rive Gauche, or an oud fragrance.

Re: A good addition to my existing collection?

I would suggest you try Chanel's Sycomore from the Les Exclusifs line. It's a rich and woody vetiver...one of the best IMO. If that's too expensive try Encre Noir, it's a nice smoky, slightly "dirtier"...in a good way, version of Sycomore.

Words of caution, don't take most of the recommendations at face value. Some of the recommendations are just for connoisseurs. For example bulgari black has a rubber smell that not everyone appreciates. Vetiver is not for every one. Be careful from leather, some of it is has very strong civet note. My recommendation is to sample before you buy any.

Re: A good addition to my existing collection?

The OP was asking for recommendations based on his current collection. Not fragrances to go blind buy. I don't think anyone here would recommend purchasing something as personal as fragrance without testing first...

Originally Posted by kimo

Words of caution, don't take most of the recommendations at face value. Some of the recommendations are just for connoisseurs. For example bulgari black has a rubber smell that not everyone appreciates. Vetiver is not for every one. Be careful from leather, some of it is has very strong civet note. My recommendation is to sample before you buy any.

Re: A good addition to my existing collection?

Originally Posted by rynegne

I would suggest you try Chanel's Sycomore from the Les Exclusifs line. It's a rich and woody vetiver...one of the best IMO. If that's too expensive try Encre Noir, it's a nice smoky, slightly "dirtier"...in a good way, version of Sycomore.

Sycomore would be a bit too indulging, don't you think? :P
How about Dior Homme or Chanel Egoiste?

- - - Updated - - -

Originally Posted by kimo

Words of caution, don't take most of the recommendations at face value. Some of the recommendations are just for connoisseurs. For example bulgari black has a rubber smell that not everyone appreciates. Vetiver is not for every one. Be careful from leather, some of it is has very strong civet note. My recommendation is to sample before you buy any.