Welcome to the PokéCommunity!

Hi there! Thanks for visiting PokéCommunity. We’re a group of Pokémon fans dedicated to providing the best place on the Internet for discussing ideas and sharing fan-made content. Welcome! We’re glad you’re here.

In order to join our community we need you to create an account with us. Doing so will allow you to make posts, submit and view fan art and fan fiction, download fan-made games, and much more. It’s quick and easy; just click here and follow the instructions.

If they happened at the same time that means that Hoenn pokemon would've had to been known at the time of Gen I(with Brawly and Bruno confirmed to have known each other a while, surely they would have told of fun times in their respective regions?; though it still doesn't mean the two gen's main events necessarily happen together). How would a whole region of pokemon go undiscovered when Hoenn is pretty decently populated all over?

They don't ever say Steel was discovered it Hoenn, read my first post closely, I'm saying it was more of my "headcanon" reason that just seemed logical, considering its established that the games have a simultaneous timelines with Gen. II and Gen. IV. and not chronological ones.

Also, Prof. Oak himself visits the Johto region on a regular basis, he even has a talkshow there but all these Pokemon right next to Kanto go undiscovered for a definite three years. Also, Unova is populous too but hardly any Pokemon from previous regions appear there because its father away. Which explains what I said about Hoenn.

BACK ON TOPIC; the Pokemon games have always been based around technology since the very beginning, it seems that they're actually ahead of the real world when it comes to science but not when it comes to practical things. So if XY had a huge timeskip, but introduced many familiar elements of our world into the Pokeworld that would be pretty neat too. Maybe we could actually have a plane ride event or such, since things like that -do- exist.

Also, if XY was super far "in the future" there might be some family links with the BW protagonist... That would be interesting, no doubt. I don't think it will happen, but someone could always pull a Skyward Sword and say that Pokemon XY happened in some far off region before any other Pokemon game known to date. Unlikely, but that's always a possibility, considering how little we know at the moment.

Oh, SO, how neat would it be for future technology to include a city in XY with moving sidewalks? Like in the Destiny Deoxys movie.

They don't ever say Steel was discovered it Hoenn, read my first post closely, I'm saying it was more of my "headcanon" reason that just seemed logical, considering its established that the games have a simultaneous timelines with Gen. II and Gen. IV. and not chronological ones.

I wasn't saying you said that. I was more implying that there is nothing that shows it as a possibility. Surely someone in Hoenn would've mentioned it? Haha...

Quote originally posted by Michimo:

Also, Prof. Oak himself visits the Johto region on a regular basis, he even has a talkshow there but all these Pokemon right next to Kanto go undiscovered for a definite three years. Also, Unova is populous too but hardly any Pokemon from previous regions appear there because its father away. Which explains what I said about Hoenn.

If anything, this just shows that Pokemon being in other regions probably doesn't have much to do with a timeline; more of it probably has to do with retconning to connect the games. I doubt even Johto would go so long without anyone seeing any Johto pokemon. This only goes along with the whole idea that the games come out as they come out and there is no real pattern(as was said by someone at Gamefreak wasn't it?)

Quote originally posted by Michimo:

BACK ON TOPIC; the Pokemon games have always been based around technology since the very beginning, it seems that they're actually ahead of the real world when it comes to science but not when it comes to practical things. So if XY had a huge timeskip, but introduced many familiar elements of our world into the Pokeworld that would be pretty neat too. Maybe we could actually have a plane ride event or such, since things like that -do- exist.

Also, if XY was super far "in the future" there might be some family links with the BW protagonist... That would be interesting, no doubt. I don't think it will happen, but someone could always pull a Skyward Sword and say that Pokemon XY happened in some far off region before any other Pokemon game known to date. Unlikely, but that's always a possibility, considering how little we know at the moment.

I think when it comes to RSE on the timeline it comes down to plain ol' Pokemon logic... And we all know how that works.

With what has been seen about the overworld for Gen. VI, they do have the player swinging from vines and this lush looking deep green forest area, seems pretty environmentally healthy so that could be a sign it takes place later in history on the timeline instead of in the future because if we give Unova the title of "most modern" the areas shown to us in XY seem a lot different from our fancy towns and bridges.

With what has been seen about the overworld for Gen. VI, they do have the player swinging from vines and this lush looking deep green forest area, seems pretty environmentally healthy so that could be a sign it takes place later in history on the timeline instead of in the future because if we give Unova the title of "most modern" the areas shown to us in XY seem a lot different from our fancy towns and bridges.

I thought the rope area could've been a grass gym because of the obstacles and such(if you look closely, when the protagonist is swinging on one of the ropes, another right behind it looks like it could lead down to that lower floor maybe?), although of course could be mistaken at this point. It just looks like it's indoors to me.

I thought the rope area could've been a grass gym because of the obstacles and such(if you look closely, when the protagonist is swinging on one of the ropes, another right behind it looks like it could lead down to that lower floor maybe?), although of course could be mistaken at this point. It just looks like it's indoors to me.

I guess it could be a gym, the whole spider web clip looked like a gym puzzle to me, and there is this one scene that looks the area is taken out of Orre. I guess it's still too early to try and guess anything based on the areas.

Hmm, I'm not sure where exactly, though maybe around BW2, but maybe during the 3 year period? I kind of imagine this region farther away so we might not even have any clue at all as to where this is.

Since the regions and all the characters are usually completely different I haven't actually spent time thinking about the overall timeline, since each could almost be happening at the same time, since each has different characters. (HGSS/DPPt/BW) Is there really a definite way to put these all together with such little evidence? I guess it's kind of like Zelda's screwy timeline, though in a different way for me I guess.

I guess it could be a gym, the whole spider web clip looked like a gym puzzle to me, and there is this one scene that looks the area is taken out of Orre. I guess it's still too early to try and guess anything based on the areas.

Are you talking about the area where he walks up to what looks like a desert? I thought the exact same thing because it reminded me of something similar to Realgam Tower, just a big building out in the middle of nowhere.

THANK THE GODDESSES FOR HYRULE HISTORIA THE ZELDA TIMELINE THEORIES. NEVER AGAIN OH GOSH.

Um, besides the connections stated between Gen. I and Gen. II, and the Gen. V games, there are some big hints that DPPt happens at the same time as Gen. II events, three years after Gen. I events. (And possibly the RSE events as well, but that has been summed up as ambiguous placement because Pokemon logic.)

Quote originally posted by C Payne:

Are you talking about the area where he walks up to what looks like a desert? I thought the exact same thing because it reminded me of something similar to Realgam Tower, just a big building out in the middle of nowhere.

We placed it simultaneous with FRLG back in 2004, because of the lack of a time machine for trading like there was between RBY and GSC.

The release of XD in 2005 screwed with that theory, and it was conclusively busted as evidence when BW1 and BW2 could trade without a time machine. We're only keeping RSE there because we have no better place to put them.

Professor Oak also mentions that there were only ~ 150 known pokemon at the time of Gen I; If RSE took place at the same time(which means Hoenn pokemon would've had to be known) then how would that last statement be possible? Same idea.

Firered and Leafgreen basically retcon the Gen I storyline anyway, so this is a little moot. You can't even find any more than the original generation's Pokemon in FR/LG until you hit the Sevii Islands or grab the National Dex. Also, your Pokemon that could evolve into a Pokemon of a later generation didn't. They'd stop evolving as if you pressed the B button. Perhaps at the time of Red's adventure, only 150 Pokemon were discovered in Kanto, but new species were found in the Sevii postgame, which was not included in the original Gen I, and would've occurred slightly after RGBY's storyline.

The Brawly/Bruno connection does not necessarily imply that Bruno would know anything about the Hoenn Pokemon. Brawly could've hailed from Kanto and then settled in Dewford later.

I'm personally hoping for a before Gen 1/Gen 3 placement in the timeline. We unfortunately see some Unova Pokemon in the trailer, so that could mean the this new region is just as far or farther from the Japan-based regions. That would explain why Gen 1/3 only had discovered 386 Pokemon, as this region is so far away that the newer Pokemon that appear here wouldn't be an issue. The XY postgame could happen contemporaneously with the beginning of Gen1/3's adventures, opening up trading if the player beat the game in XY to a possible Hoenn remake.

Firered and Leafgreen basically retcon the Gen I storyline anyway, so this is a little moot. You can't even find any more than the original generation's Pokemon in FR/LG until you hit the Sevii Islands or grab the National Dex. Also, your Pokemon that could evolve into a Pokemon of a later generation didn't. They'd stop evolving as if you pressed the B button. Perhaps at the time of Red's adventure, only 150 Pokemon were discovered in Kanto, but new species were found in the Sevii postgame, which was not included in the original Gen I, and would've occurred slightly after RGBY's storyline.

The Brawly/Bruno connection does not necessarily imply that Bruno would know anything about the Hoenn Pokemon. Brawly could've hailed from Kanto and then settled in Dewford later.

I think I just worded some things oddly. What I'm saying is that we have just as many things that completely screw with that idea as well(of them happening simultaneously), although nobody has really brought many solid pros, if at all; One of the more notable things that opposes the idea is how Team Magma/Aqua's actions weren't even noted in Gen V until B2W2(which shows that Gen III could possibly have happened inbetween the two sets), while they clearly mention their thoughts on why Galactic and Rocket failed in BW.

Trading, etc. have been retconned all throughout the Pokemon games so that's why I put out the idea that those don't really prove a thing when it comes to where a gen is placed. B2W2 are a perfect argument to further show that because you can freely trade/battle between both sets of games regardless of the fact that the latter two happened two years later.

We really don't have anything solid that gives Gen III a specific place is my main point.

As for the whole Brawly/Bruno issue, I'm not even sure why it was brought up(simply knowing someone from other regions a while =/= the main events of their respective regions' games having to take place at the same time. That conversation just turned into a mess really.

Quote originally posted by Deokishisu:

I'm personally hoping for a before Gen 1/Gen 3 placement in the timeline. We unfortunately see some Unova Pokemon in the trailer, so that could mean the this new region is just as far or farther from the Japan-based regions. That would explain why Gen 1/3 only had discovered 386 Pokemon, as this region is so far away that the newer Pokemon that appear here wouldn't be an issue. The XY postgame could happen contemporaneously with the beginning of Gen1/3's adventures, opening up trading if the player beat the game in XY to a possible Hoenn remake.

From what I've been trying to point out this whole time...I'm just going to ignore some of that and just say that it would be interesting if Gen VI turned out to be more of a prequel, although as of now I think it happens in the future.

I say Pokemon X and Y will take place at the same timeline as Gen I and Gen III, because of the gentics theme it's going for, which could retcon Mewtwo's backstory, as well making R/S remakes possible.

The PokéCommunity

Meta

Pokémon characters and images belong to The Pokémon Company International and Nintendo. This website is in no way affiliated with or endorsed by Nintendo, Creatures, GAMEFREAK, or The Pokémon Company International. We just love Pokémon.