American Horror Story fans can now rejoice in the possibility that Lily Rabe will be joining the upcoming Hotel. While Rabe has appeared in the four previous seasons of the horror series, the last time she played a major character was on Coven, when she was Misty Day, a Stevie Nicks-obsessed swamp witch. She made a brief appearance last season in a flashback as her second-season Asylum character, Sister Mary Eunice.

According to Entertainment Weekly, Rabe, who can be seen on ABC’s The Whispers, is in talks to play a serial killer on the show’s fifth season. If she takes the role, Rabe will join AHS regulars Angela Bassett, Kathy Bates, Sarah Paulson and Evan Peters and newcomers Matt Bomer and Lady Gaga. American Horror Story: Hotel will premiere in October.