Obesity remains a serious health problem and it is no secret that many people want to lose weight. Behavioral economists typically argue that “nudges” help individuals with various decisionmaking flaws to live longer, healthier, and better lives. In an article in the new issue of Regulation, Michael L. Marlow discusses how nudging by government differs from nudging by markets, and explains why market nudging is the more promising avenue for helping citizens to lose weight.

Two long wars, chronic deficits, the financial crisis, the costly drug war, the growth of executive power under Presidents Bush and Obama, and the revelations about NSA abuses, have given rise to a growing libertarian movement in our country – with a greater focus on individual liberty and less government power. David Boaz’s newly released The Libertarian Mind is a comprehensive guide to the history, philosophy, and growth of the libertarian movement, with incisive analyses of today’s most pressing issues and policies.

Search form

Draft Registration: It’s Time to Repeal Carter’s Final Legacy

The Soviet invasion of Afghanistan seven Decembers ago did more than turn that nation into the globe’s newest killing field. It also caused an embarrassed Jimmy Carter to adopt several desperate measures designed to demonstrate toughness in foreign policy. One of his responses—ordering the resumption of draft registration—has proved to be his most lasting legacy.

Ironically, conservative Ronald Reagan was one of Carter’s most articulate critics. Reagan argued that the draft sign-up not only would “do little to enhance our military preparedness” but could “actually decrease our military preparedness, by making people think we have solved our defense problems.” An even more “fundamental objection,” said Reagan, was moral: “draft registration destroys the very values that our society is committed to defending.”[1]

With Reagan’s election in November 1980, various commentators expected registration to be one of the first programs to be swept away by the Reagan Revolution. But it was the middle of 1981 before he even established the Military Manpower Task Force to review the issue. Several tortuous months of bureaucratic warfare then ensued before Reagan announced, on January 7, 1982, that “we live in a dangerous world” and that he was maintaining registration.[2]

As a result, Reagan, whose record of opposition to the draft extended back to his days as California’s governor during the 1960s, when he signed a petition calling for the end of conscription, became the president who restarted Selective Service prosecutions.

So far, the total number of indictments—20—has been small. This statistic, however, understates the enforcement effort. The Selective Service System has used driver’s license, high school, and voter registration lists, as well as federal student loan records, to locate nonregistrants. According to Selective Service, “data [have] also been provided by the Federal Aviation Administration, the Social Security Administration, the Department of Defense, the Department of Transportation, and the Veterans Administration.”[3] Selective Service has used these voluminous information sources to identify nonregistrants, send them threatening letters, and, ultimately, refer their names to the Department of Justice for prosecution.

Moreover, nonregistrants are ineligible to receive federal student loans or job-training benefits or to hold federal jobs. Several states have copied the federal provision regarding educational aid, and in 1985, Selective Service director Thomas Turnage expressed the hope that “private corporations, when made aware of the law” regarding federal job eligibility, would “adopt an employment policy based on the federal model.”[4]

This ongoing campaign of intimidation is all the more disturbing because there is no justification for retaining the increasingly costly and intrusive draft registration program. Mandatory peacetime registration, along with the government’s ever-more-draconian enforcement practices, is not only inconsistent with Reagan’s professed political philosophy; for the very reasons once cited by Reagan, it also fails to advance America’s security.

Finally, even if a special pool of manpower was needed for immediate induction in the event of a national emergency, it could be raised through a voluntary program—one consistent with what Reagan termed the “values that our society is committed to defending.” Today’s pool of 15 million registrants could be replaced by a Reserve Volunteer Force with barely 1 percent as many members, which would better ensure the availability of the untrained manpower needed to fill the army’s training camps during a large-scale mobilization.

Read the Full
Policy Analysis

Doug Bandow is a senior fellow at the Cato Institute and a nationally syndicated columnist with Copley News Service. As a special assistant to President Reagan in 1981 and 1982, he worked with the Military Manpower Task Force.