Search This Blog

According to the City of Saint Paul, This House is a Threat

This is a turn-of-the-century home in my neighborhood, currently a duplex, just steps from a park and on a quiet, one-block stretch of Iglehart. The block has some beautiful homes, and is an original part of the Historic Hill District, the city's first historic district established in 1976. It was moved into the lot in the 1980s, when a new housing complex was built across the street, so has new mechanicals and a new foundation. I haven't been in it, nor has anyone I know, but the reports I have seen show damage but not insurmountable issues. It's the kind of home that dozens of people I know would love to move into.

According to the City of Saint Paul, this house is a major threat to public safety and must be razed immediately. Yes, the city (including some neighbors, my councilmember, licensing, and various other city officials) considers this empty house not an opportunity, but a major threat to the community. Yes, more of a threat than the weekly break-ins in the bar parking lot next to me, or the daily drug sales in the empty lot next to the playground on the next block.

The house has been empty for the last twelve years, and it's frustrating. The owner keeps on saying he'll "get around to working on it," but doesn't do anything. It's had multiple "repair or remove" orders, and has even gone to tax forfeiture. Recalcitrant as the current owner is, he actually could not sell it (except under special circumstances) — due to the "Bostrom Amendment," a Category 3 vacant building cannot be sold without bringing it entirely up to code.

I've been working with a task force of neighbors for 6 months to come up with solutions to this, and gotten nowhere. Nicole Curtis has leveraged as much as she can, and made me appreciate her passion and commitment to old homes. To be fair, city officials have tried what they can, including tax court. Approved CDCs, such as Historic Saint Paul and Preservation Alliance of Minnesota, have tried to purchase it, but the owner simply won't respond.

There's much that's not ideal about this, which I'll admit from the beginning. But that long and short of it is, that this is a beautiful, historic, desirable and eminently rehab-able home that will be irreplaceably lost because no one has the courage or innovation to save it. It will be an empty lot, likely for the next several decades like the other empty lots in the neighborhood. It will likely draw more undesirable activity than a home with potential. And, according to the city's own studies, it will bring down the values of the immediately surrounding properties by 20% or more.

That's what's scarey. Not an empty home.

-----

Edited to add: I really mean it when I say everyone has tried everything. The neighbors I have worked with have asked to buy it, cash in hand, multiple times, only to be rudely rebuffed. We have offered to keep up the maintenance of it while the issues was solved — again turned down. The city has come up with new ideas and taken it all the way to tax court — only to have the owner pay the back taxes and redeem the house literally at the last second. Licensing has attempted to stabilize it. Preservation non-profits have offered to but it and fix it up. Nicole has given an incredible amount of time and energy to the process. Literally hundreds of hours have been put in so far to try to find a solution. Although I am frustrated with city ordinances that leave only razing the home as a resolution (and one that will be so very costly, in so many ways, to the neighborhood I love), the ultimate fault here is with an owner who will not respond to the situation and who will basically force it to be torn down.----Edited to add: RIP. Demo'd June, 2013.

Get link

Facebook

Twitter

Pinterest

Google+

Email

Comments

It would look immensely better with a good pressure washing. I'd love to buy the house and fix it out. It'd be wonderful. The owner is just being a lazy jackass. I'm sure there's someone that would be willing to hire the contractors needed to bring the house to code, as long as they have a signed contract stating that once to code he'll sell it to them. It always makes me sad to see vacant houses or empty lots.

My City of Jackson Michigan has knocked down 100 of these homes that have been deemed unsafe.The City is now targeting the Historic District homes for demolitions!It is easy for my City to knock these homes (mostly foreclosed) down for $13K which is provided by HUD funds.It is a complete misuse of governmental funds. Nicole's show really shows what SHOULD happen to these "threatening" homes!

My thought exactly - this seems like what eminent domain *should* be used for - rather than to confiscate property for private profit. If the city can eventually tear it down, it's just stupid that they can't confiscate it before that becomes necessary. Maybe the one thing that hasn't been tried is changing some laws.

This breaks my heart and makes absolutely no sense. I'd love to have a house like this, in fact, plenty of people would jump at an opportunity like this. I'm not a lawyer but how about the "Adverse Possession Law"? Someone with more knowledge of MN law than me should look into that law quickly. It might be the "loop hole" needed to save this house and others like it.

Careful: My experience with eminent domain in St.Paul is that the city then tears down single family homes to put in unattractive apt bldgs because they cant get more tax dollars for "for profit" property with multiple units. These apt bldgs. often don't hold up well and in a few years the owner is looking to dump them. There is absolutely no commitment to the neighborhood.

As you know its Preservation Month, so I'd go to the newspaper and MPR and keep on blogging. All else fails...break on in and take over..law of adverse possession. Recheck possible foreclosure and tax issues. If this loser has any relatives they may be able to talk some sense into him...and oh yeah find out where he lives and have folks PICKET outside the house he lives in DEMANDING that he sell this one to you or to the City of STP or Historic St. Paul!

Unsure what the address is on this home...may have old info and may have talked to owner sometime between 2004-2008...just need address/owner name if have...unsure what threatening issues here but have seen a really sad case where vacant duplex owner had fully secured somehow deceased female's body was found inside...sex offenders...serious crime issues that sadly do cause buildings to be torn down. Would love to try to help...love saving houses...know how hard it really is and so much general public needs to be truthfully informed about!

Popular posts from this blog

The other day I posted on a neighborhood page:Our Little Free Library has been totally pillaged lately - as in, someone comes every day and totally cleans it out to take it to Half Price Books or something. I think we're going to close it down for awhile, which bums me out.
And I do mean "totally pillaged." I love it when the books fly off our shelves —it means that people are reading — but this was about the 12th time in the past couple of months that someone had completely cleared it from stem to stern. I'm a voracious reader, when everything from an ABC board book to old-school westerns to Faulker's As I Lay Dying all go in one fell swoop, I know that something is up.

After I posted, I noticed that a LOT of people were posting in neighborhood pages about this. Especially in my neighborhood, it seems like one person is coming along and emptying everyone out.

I'm starting to seem like one of the awesome Minnesota Theater Bloggers with my frequency of theater blogs (yeah, I only wish!), but I can't stop thinking about Refugia at the Guthrie last night. Thanks to my years at Jeune Lune I've known Dominique Serrand for over half my life, and it was clear to me last night that this was the play that he has wanted to create for at least that long a time. I'm stopping just short of calling it his magnum opus (because I hope there's a lot of great work left of his to see), and I don't want to take away from the other great work he's directed and co-created over the years, but this is the most significant and complete piece he's directed.

I need to start by saying that the Guthrie was the most lively and intense I had ever seen it last night. With three stages active (Refugia on the proscenium, The Bluest Eye in the thrust, and Mu's Charlie Chan in the Dowling studio, plus some prom photos being taken), the lobb…

After a glass of wine tonight, I was reflecting on how our ideals have become a household:

- Patrick and myself, who met later in life, whose ideas are often counter-instinctual (i.e. minimalism vs. semi-hoarder), but whose values are almost identical and who love each other fiercely;
- Our daughter, a crazy mix of both of us and her own ideals;
- Our wonderful housemate, who has been gone on vacation for not even 48 hours and who I already miss greatly;
- 4 fish (enough said);
- Crazy rescue dogs Coya (heroically rescued by our friend Wendy from a cruel backyard breeder) and neurotic Winston (equally heroically rescued by our friend Sandy after being dumped)
- Cats Mimi (found at the doorstep), Belle (who we took in for a friend) and Dandelion (who we found on CraigsList), and now new foster kitty Tiger Lily, already settling in.

Add tho those:
- Our amazing network of friends and family, who we love to pieces and see too little;
- Our client base, many of whom have become fr…