From the research i've done the odds of getting a legit cuban anywhere on the island are quite low. the ones in the duty free shop are 100% fake, seems kinda low class for these fine resorts but it is what it is. I'd personally like to see the fakes removed and either replaced with real cubans or some good quality domicinan or nicarguian cigars.

you can find very easily online how to spot a fake Cuban...I've had the dominican Monte Cristos and I can taste the difference. There is a shop at the Time Square mall that you can take the shopping shuttle to and he's legit. Don't ask the bus driver or any other driver because they will take you to someone that they know and that is where you end up with the fakes. Also they usually have a guy at the resort a couple of nights. He was happy to show us the sealed box and then open it and sell to us. Also try some of the Jamaican Cigars...we had a couple Blue Mountain ones that were amazing!! Like I said...do your research. We even bought a book on clearance that told us how to tell the real from the fake Cubans. Oh and I personally prefer the Monte Cristos...get the number 2 tubo's. Not impressed with the Cohiba's. And make sure you have a glass of rum cream with your cigar...it will become your nightly ritual!

They did make a Reserva but it was only made for a festival in 2003 I believe, and they were very rare. As Cigarmanpa said, the bands are wrong, and more importantly, the wrapper is way too dark (maduro). The Cohiba Maduro line has only been around since mide 2007 and they aren't Reserva nor that sizing.

Hate to tell you Cigarmanpa but Cohiba has made a Gran Reserva since around 2002. Sooooo.........

Personally I wouldn't begin to authenticate one from that picture. What I see looks good but unless I had it in my hand I'd be hard pressed to say either way. It does appear that the word Cohiba is embossed and not just printed from the picture. Most fakes won't be embossed. They don't go to the extra expense.

You are familiar with the "new" style Cohiba band, right? Personally I think this one looks fine. I'd be kinda slow about maligning the resort's Gift Shop unless I was really really sure.

A friend of mine whose opinion I respect was recently at CSA and he said what they had were legit.

Hate to tell you Cigarmanpa but Cohiba has made a Gran Reserva since around 2002. Sooooo.........

Personally I wouldn't begin to authenticate one from that picture. What I see looks good but unless I had it in my hand I'd be hard pressed to say either way. It does appear that the word Cohiba is embossed and not just printed from the picture. Most fakes won't be embossed. They don't go to the extra expense.

You are familiar with the "new" style Cohiba band, right? Personally I think this one looks fine. I'd be kinda slow about maligning the resort's Gift Shop unless I was really really sure.

A friend of mine whose opinion I respect was recently at CSA and he said what they had were legit.

you're right they do make one, on that note I was wrong. However, the two boxes I looked at while at css were fake. I am 100% sure of it

Sadly, I must agree. While at the resort I checked out the cigars sold there and found some disturbing things missing from the boxes. I ruled them as fakes. They looked nice but they were fakes. I don't understand that either as they could easily sell legitimate Cubans. That would really be a draw too. I'd love to give them business and was more than willing to do so. I'm glad I brought my own. As far as negatives on the resort, this would be my only one. If I could appeal to the Couples management; supply and sell legitimate Cuban cigars at your Jamaica resorts. (please)

Sadly, I must agree. While at the resort I checked out the cigars sold there and found some disturbing things missing from the boxes. I ruled them as fakes. They looked nice but they were fakes. I don't understand that either as they could easily sell legitimate Cubans. That would really be a draw too. I'd love to give them business and was more than willing to do so. I'm glad I brought my own. As far as negatives on the resort, this would be my only one. If I could appeal to the Couples management; supply and sell legitimate Cuban cigars at your Jamaica resorts. (please)

Are the gift shops sublet out or does Couples own and manage them? I'm sure the reason for fakes is that the profit margin is much, much better.