How to Choose Baseball Gloves and Mitts

When you think of baseball gear, the very first thing you think of is the baseball glove. Most kids have a family glove passed down from sibling to sibling just for playing catch in the yard. It’s almost always too big or too small, and by the time it’s finally retired, it’s literally coming apart at the seams.

For players who play baseball regularly, the family glove just won’t do. They need a glove that fits, that has been created for their position, so they don’t sacrifice any dexterity or safety on the field.

How to Choose a Glove Size

The glove size is determined by two factors, age and position. For the youngest players, position may not matter as much, but the more specialized a player becomes on the field, the more they will require the glove that matches.

Have the player hold out their catching hand, palm flat, in the “stop” position, fingers vertical, wrist facing down.

If a player is right-handed, they will use their left hand to catch.

If a player is left-handed, they will use their right hand to catch.

Using a ruler, measure from the top of the index finger to the wrist. The finger should be as straight as possible. Write the measurement down.

Find the closest size up from your measurement. If you measured at 6-1/2’’, then choose the smallest baseball glove near that size, which will typically be 9’’.

Right-Handed vs. Left-Handed Gloves

A right-handed glove will actually belong on the left hand. That is because a right-handed player will throw with their right hand and catch with their left hand.

A left-handed glove will actually fit on the right hand. A left-handed player throws with their left hand and catches with their right.

Make sure, when shopping online, to check which hand the glove should fit on, and order accordingly.

Youth Sizes

Youth gloves should be small enough to help the player learn how to catch accurately. They may be one type fits all positions, and measure from 9 to 11 inches across.

Types of Gloves and Positions

What separates one kind of glove from another? By the time a player has moved into high school and college baseball, not only have they learned what position they are best at, they also have specialized glove needs.

Outfield gloves are larger than infield gloves and have deeper pockets for catching long fly balls and longer reaches for that extra distance needed to cover a grounder.

Infield gloves are smaller with shallow pockets for better fielding and faster throwing reactions for those awesome double-plays.

First basemen gloves are unique among the infielders, as it is typically longer for a better reach than other infielder gloves, while retaining the shallow pocket.

Second basemen have the smallest gloves in order to make quick throws to first, third, or home.

Pitchers are also infielders, and need to react like them, but their gloves are often slightly larger than a typical infield glove, for ease of ball control before the pitch.

Catcher’s mitts are fingerless, heavily padded to reduce ball impact, and extra reinforced for both safety and wear and tear. The catcher is the player that will use his or her mitt the most, and so they will need to replace it more often than other players.

Outside of baseball, softball gloves tend to be larger to accommodate the larger ball size.

Remember that the correct size of glove for the player gives them the best comfort, safety, and dexterity on the field, so size charts should be used as guidelines, but not absolutes.

Glove Materials and Features

Materials

These three types of materials will make a difference in the feel and durability of the glove.

Leather

The majority of gloves are made from this material.

Leather offers the best comfort, control, and feel.

Sturdy leather means stiffer gloves, but after they are broken in, this sturdiness becomes durability.

These gloves will be stamped with a label saying “Genuine Leather”

Treated leather

Leather is treated and softened with chemicals for faster break-in.

Treated leather also reduces the care needed for the glove and helps the glove keep its shape.

Treated leather should not be regarded as the same as a part fabric, part leather glove. These gloves are often very flimsy and can’t be repaired.

Synthetic materials

A lighter, less-durable material that doesn’t hold up to the rigors of the game as well.

Less expensive, and good for youngsters to learn with.

Unlike leather gloves, when a synthetic or plastic glove wears out, it can’t be repaired by a professional leather worker, and should be replaced.

Find the Features that Fit Your Game

Today's gloves have different features built-in to help your game and to suit your ability. Here are the key features constructed into gloves and what to consider when finding the glove that suits you.