Examine the Controversy that Surrounds the Question of what Judges are doing when they are deciding Cases.

If we accept the hypothesis, that judges do indeed make law through their decisions, we need to look closely at the judges themselves to decide whether they are capable of performing that function. Judges are not, in this country, elected, as are the other law-makers (the legislators). If judges had no law-making role, then the uncertainty over judicial decision making would not arise; it would not matter whether the judiciary was representative of the society within which it operates, or whether it was capable of acting impartially. Lord Denning stated that: "Every judge on his appointment discards all politics and all prejudices. You need have no fear. The Judges of England have always in the past - and always will - be vigilant in guarding our freedoms. Someone must be trusted. Let it be the Judges." However, if judges were simply applying the law when making decisions, then it would not matter who was fulfilling that role, because, everybody would reach the same decision in every case, unless a judge happened to misapply the law, in which case another court could put him right.

Suffragettes - Labor Day '13 (LOC)

Ronald Dworkin

English: Queen Anne in the House of Lords

But judges reach very different decisions upon the same facts; there is no common agreement as to what the law is, and Hart argues that in many cases the judges are not only applying the existing law, but they are making new law. Another question which must be addressed is whether or not the largely similar background of judges results in judicial clones that not only think alike but tend to think along conservative or at any rate 'establishment' lines. Positivists, such as Herbert Hart, argue that judges require discretion to fill in criticism gaps. On the other hand critics of Hart, such as Ronald Dworkin, state that decisions in hard cases should be made through...

Citation styles:

Examine the Controversy that Surrounds the Question of what Judges are doing when they are deciding Cases.. (2004, March 13). In WriteWork.com. Retrieved 22:06, September 26, 2017, from http://www.writework.com/essay/examine-controversy-surrounds-question-judges-doing-they-d

WriteWork contributors. "Examine the Controversy that Surrounds the Question of what Judges are doing when they are deciding Cases." WriteWork.com. WriteWork.com, 13 March, 2004. Web. 26 Sep. 2017.

WriteWork contributors, "Examine the Controversy that Surrounds the Question of what Judges are doing when they are deciding Cases.," WriteWork.com, http://www.writework.com/essay/examine-controversy-surrounds-question-judges-doing-they-d (accessed September 26, 2017)

Reviews of: "Examine the Controversy that Surrounds the Question of what Judges are doing when they are deciding Cases.":

More Law & Government Essays essays:

... of the main flaws of perceiving the judicial system as having the quality of a fixed outcome slot machine is that machines are unable to make moral decisions and view the case in a retrospective of circumstances. For example in, Albraith (Kim luise) v HM Advocate (no ...

... of Lord Donaldson MR. It was not until the Factortame II judgment in 1991 that the House of Lords finally disapplied the Act of Parliament on the grounds that it was inconsistent with EC law , fundamentally changing the legal structure of ...

... , which is of questionable legality under international law. [8]The decision to continue with ... of mass destruction; he's determined to make more. Given Saddam Hussein's history of aggression...given what we know of ... is becoming a major topic of discussion. With no real signs of progress in Iraq in ...

... of People's Republic of China, deprivation of political rights refers to deprivation of the right to cote and to stand for voting; the rights of freedom of speech, of the press, of assembly, of association, of ...

30 pages7Dec/20120.0

Students & Profs. say about us:

"Good news: you can turn to other's writing help. WriteWork has over 100,000 sample papers"