Friday, September 5, 2014

Vitaliano Brancati: The Beautiful Antonio

Still from the 1960 film
version of Il Bell’Antonio, starring Marcello Mastroianni

and Claudia
Cardinale, directed by Mauro Bolognini, written by Pier Paolo Pasolini.

It’s relatively rare to find a literary work centered on a
rare subject, but Sicilian writer Vitaliano Brancati’s Beautiful Antonio
(Il Bell’Antonio,1949), may be the first novel I’ve read concerning male
impotence. It will probably long endure as the most impressive.

The beautiful Antonio Magnano possesses a killing
handsomeness. Wherever he goes in his Sicilian hometown of Catania – even to
mass – women turn their heads. The frustrated priest even suggests the boy
would be better off dead, but reacting to Antonio’s mother’s tears, modulates
his careless remark into a hope that “God…in his infinite wisdom…will find ways
to mitigate your son’s satanic beauty without reducing him to dust and ashes!” Like
many other youth during Mussolini’s rise, Antonio ardently supports Fascism. In
order to angle for an elite position in the party and, presumably, to sow some wild oats, he moves from Catania to Rome. Rumors of his sexual conquests,
including of a high-ranking official’s wife, drift to Sicily. A few years of
this libertinism, though, seem sufficient to his parents, and they recall
Antonio home to marry the young bride they’ve picked out for him. The strikingly
beautiful but naïve Barbara Puglisi, daughter of the city’s esteemed, conservative
notary, hails from a family so proud of its normalcy - counting but three black
sheep in the past century - that it watches zealously for any sign of deviance.
Though not fully on board with the arranged marriage, Antonio spies Barbara in
the street one day and is immediately smitten. The marriage ceremony is a joyous
one. The young couple moves into the Puglisi palazzo. Three ostensibly happy
years pass. One day, an explosive truth suddenly emerges: Barbara is still a
virgin. Having learned at last that it takes more than mere “fraternal embraces
in the night” to consummate a marriage and produce an heir, Barbara feels
cheated. Her scandalized parents demand an annulment. News of Antonio’s
impotence is “heard all over Catania like an eruption of Mount Etna.”

The situation – a devastatingly handsome youth, two families
full of expectations, and a revelation that upsets everything – supplies plenty
of comedic potential, which Brancati exploits in spades. Beautiful Antonio
features snappy dialogue, humorous character sketches, and deftly spun one-liners
(such as a description of Hitler as having a “moustache like that of a hyena
whose trainer has been trying in vain to teach it to laugh”). But Brancati goes
well beyond this considerable comedy to demonstrate a fundamental compassion,
conveyed through splendidly drawn characters, and to use Antonio’s sexual
inadequacy metaphorically to target Italy’s disastrous experiment with Fascism.
The novel evolves from light-hearted bedroom comedy, widens out to grander notions
of love and relation, and reaches an apogee in portraying Italy’s potential as
a sort of agape betrayed by the
narrow and rigid funneling of the nation’s energies, sexual and otherwise, into
blind devotion to Mussolini. Fascism appears as a compensatory politics arising
from a lack of agency (or potency) rooted in an Italian gallisimo that places a social premium on male virility and public boasting
of sexual exploits, and that leads to a gender dynamic in which many men fail
to link the women they view as sexual objects in any way to their own “mothers
and sisters.” Regarding these last, a character in one scene tries to
interrupt the salacious boasting of a group of men by vainly asking, “But aren’t they
women too?”

The degree to which such virility is given vital importance
is best demonstrated by the most dramatic of Brancati’s terrific characters,
Antonio’s father Alfio, proud of his own sexual conquests and of those he
imagines for his son.Alternating wildly
between an obsequious desire to maintain a good reputation in Catania and a
volatile anger and mistrust of those around him, Alfio prioritizes virility over his love for his son. Hearing of a problem in his Antonio's marriage, he axiomatically
assumes it to be sexual insatiability, and is nearly driven mad by discovering that it's the opposite, seeing such inadequacy as a fate worse than
death. In one of the novel’s more outlandish scenes, Alfio’s distraught shame
over his son’s incapacity results in a demand that the Puglisi father accompany
him and Antonio to a brothel to watch the son prove his ability to perform.

The bedroom comedy aspect of the novel turns to more serious
subjects when an uncle, Ermenegildo, is invited to speak with Antonio and
divine the truth behind the boy’s problem. Ermenegildo serves as a moral and
philosophical lodestone in the novel, albeit a profoundly cynical one. Jaded by
what he’s seen in the Spanish Civil War, with “both sides…quite ready and
willing to butcher, burn and make mincemeat of Jesus Christ in person,” he has
lost faith in humanity, viewing with knowing contempt the “black supervisor’s
uniforms in which…so many bourgeois nonentities had been hiding for years.” When
asked to which party he belongs, he replies: “I belong to the party of the
worms who will shortly be eating the meat off of my bones; or, if you prefer,
it’s my fleshless skull that thinks that way, and I’m certain it will stay
intact until a time when Fascism and anti-Fascism no longer mean anything to
anyone.” His cynicism extends even to sex: “…is it possible that I have to go
on and on, mindlessly filling holes in flesh with other flesh? And, for crying
out loud, it’s always the same thing!” His eyes opened to the horrors of
dictatorship, he longs for a death that will deliver him from the scourge of
his fellow human beings, speculating that even Jesus Christ himself may one day seem nothing more than a “barbaric moralist.” But his compassion for Antonio
is genuine and generous, as he gains from the boy “what his nephew had shortly
received from him: the powerful distraction of an anguish other than his own.”

Antonio’s crushing frustration is depicted with great sensitivity in a lengthy, tortured and moving monologue in which he gushes out everything to his uncle, including recounting a first failed attempt with Barbara:

My blood boiled and my head seethed
with intense excitement, but this, at a certain point, leaked out through the
pores of my skin and was lost in the air, leaving me with the sort of
dispersed, ineffectual pleasure that children have in dreams, shortly before
they lose their innocence.

His impotence has conferred upon him a kind of annihilation
that evokes the rigidity and vitiated nature of Fascism. “There’s a dead man in
the midst of your life, a corpse so placed that wherever you move you’re bound
to brush up against it, against its cold, fetid skin.”

One of the few other persons to whom Antonio turns to relieve his anguish is his cousin Edoardo, another of Brancati’s memorable creations.
Self-absorbed, shifting with any political wind, and anxious to exploit
Antonio’s Fascist connections in order to become mayor of Catania, Edoardo
nonetheless fervently admires the great historian Benedetto Croce, scribbling
in the margins of Croce’s History of
Europe things like “No!...The man’s mad!...No, no, and no again!” in case
the book should fall into the hands of the Fascists. But Edoardo - displaying another kind of impotence - possesses
neither political courage nor the capacity for true empathy, as demonstrated when the two cousins go out for a walk
following the disclosure that has disrupted everything:

Lacking the courage to speak
open-heartedly about the terrible thing that had happened to one of them, they
spoke not at all. Any other subject would have aggravated the magnitude of the
one they were avoiding. So that the immense events of that September, the order
to black out the cities, Hitler’s bellowings filling the darkened streets from
loudspeakers positioned in windows, the call-up of recruits, Munich – all
failed to cohere into a single word on those two pairs of lips twisted with
bitterness.

The beautiful Antonio represents a fantasy in the microcosm
of Catania: the girls and women who feverishly dream about him, Antonio’s family members who exalt his virility, Barbara’s family who seek in the marriage increased
social standing and a vigorous heir, and an entire community that sees Antonio
as a paragon of the ideal Italian man. As with Italy’s experience of Mussolini
- “that man [who] pocketed our youth” – the unmasking of a flaccid fantasy
world also reveals its inherent violence, and the events at the end of the
novel prove considerably darker - “The lights are out all over Europe” - than
the book’s initial comic premise would suggest. Brancati’s brilliant choice of metaphor for
Italy’s destructive flirtation with Fascism – one that aims right at the libido
- makes Beautiful Antonio an unusual, biting, and especially trenchant contribution
to the genre of the Italian anti-Fascist novel. In combining such effervescent comedy with the gravity shown in so many of the genre’s other representatives, Beautiful
Antonio is a rare thing indeed.

Thanks, Brian. I've read neither of the novels you mention, but I might have guessed that Roth would have taken up this subject. It does appear often enough in literature, but I'd just never encountered it as the centerpiece of a novel.

Excellent review, Scott. I hadn't come across this author before, but Beautiful Antonio sounds terrific - the characters, the premise, the metaphor for Italy's relationship with Fascism. I think I'll add this one to my list.

Jacqui - thanks. This was easily one of the most enjoyable novels I've read this year. The film is very well done too, well worth watching (even if Claudia Cardinale doesn't exactly come across as naive…).

Cool! I thought the film was a terrific adaptation (by Pasolini, no less). But then Brancati obviously knew how to write with film in mind, since he worked with many of Italy's great directors - Fellini, Antonioni, Rossellini and others.