My lashes are definitely not a strong point, and perhaps that's why I am continually trying one mascara after another. I found another one which I can say I truly love, Benefit's "BADgal Lash." The brush is a wonder itself--huge and very dense, making application easy, especially when you are trying to define and highlight every little lash. This gives me great volume and nice length, while las...read morehes stay soft and pliable. I like the fact that it wears a very long time with no hint of clumping, smudging, or flaking. Thank you, Benefit!— 1 year, 9 months ago

I used to love BADgal mascara (the original), but eventually gave up on it because it would smudge under my eyes by the end of the day. I really had higher hopes for the waterproof version, because it's WATERPROOF, right? Wrong. Not only is it not waterproof at all, even this version smudges under my eyes early in the day--not because I rub my eyes, just from normal wear. And yet somehow it is sti...read morell difficult to remove, and often I can't get it all cleaned off even with eye makeup remover made specifically for waterproof makeup. Even if the formula was good, the brush is not nearly as dense and nice as the original BADgal brush. I would return this if I could and I definitely will never buy it again. — 1 year, 2 months ago