As they decided to set events away from Britannia, there are not that many
continuity mistakes in Ultima VIII. However, you'll still find more than
enough inaccuracies in foreign Pagan as a nitpicker, because the actually good,
Ultima-ish plot was apparently not finished. A pity. Yet it's not even
half as bad as in Ultima IX: Ultima VIII sheds light on your dark side and
forces you to do evil deeds; an aspect of your character that Ultima IX
completely ignores. The Guardian's voice creates a thrilling atmosphere. In
Ultima IX, the speech is boring, emotionless, and unprofessional. Another
important thing to note is that Ultima VIII plays on a strange new world with
foreign locations and characters, whereas Ultima IX rehashes old stories like
the False Prophet affair in a miserable way. At the end of the day, Pagan makes
much a better impression than Ascension.

Ignorance of predecessors (5)

Technical shortcomings (10)

General problems (22)

Ignorance of predecessors

Mors Gotha mentioned the Guardians Palace in
Pagan at the end of Underworld II. Yet there's no sign of such a place
anywhere in Ultima VIII. (by Time Lord)

In Serpent Isle, the Forest Master Morghrim seemed to be a
druid, and was explicitally said to be native from Pagan. However, this
leads to a lot of problems.

First he must be very old then, and/or time passed much more
quickly between Ultima VII Part 2 and Ultima VII. He said he had fled
from his world's destruction but he didn't say anything about when it
had happened. Of course, since he was an outworlder, he might have been
"ageless", but we had no explanation about how long he had been around.

Second, he knew of the Guardian's duplicity so he must have been a
Zealan priest, for the bulk of the Zealans cared only for the Pagan's
worship of the elements. His powers and artefacts were related to nature, thus
were very "druid-like". This presents a big problem in Ultima VII, when we are
told that Zealans were following only the Ancient Ones. Of
course, druids could have existed but we have no notes about them even in
Mythran's extensive library.

(Personally, I am sure Morghrim was originally meant to be mentioned in
Ultima VIII, i.e. before the game was rushed by EA. I'm also sure they would have
explained some of these flaws.) (by Sir Klaus
Dragon)

In Underworld II, you obtained a Blackrock Serpent from
the Goblins at the sewers. They mentioned that they had got it from a
stranger who had come to their camp and said only one word: "Pagan". How did he
arrive there, and why did he have the Serpent stone?

Thanks for cutting 1/2 of Ultima VIII, EA. By the way, do you notice the
big number of references to future games in Ultima VII, Serpent Isle,
and Underworld II? Clearly proofs that the Guardian trilogy was meant to be a
continuous storyline from the beginning. (by Natreg
Dragon)

An obvious nitpick: What happened to all the Hierophant
stuff the Avatar was wearing at the end of Serpent Isle? (by Hacki Dragon)

Technical shortcomings

Why can't you teleport out of the obsidian
fortress? (I thought only Blackrock is a good magic blocker.) (by Tribun Dragon)

On Argentrock Isle, after learning of the Breath of Wind from
Stratos, the Avatar will immediately get conversation options for trying to get
the Breath of Wind. However, at this point in the game, the Avatar
hasn't found out yet that the fragments of the Blackrock Obelisk must be
used to defeat the Titans and gain their powers, which leaves the
player in the dark as to why the Avatar wants the Breath of Wind. (by Evil_Freak Dragon)

When you're crossing the River of Fire for the first time, Beren
will appear and warn you not to offend the Sorcerers. However, his
remark is phrased as though it came at the end of a long conversation,
and he seems completely nonplussed that you're braving fiercest dangers in order
to reach the Sorceror's Enclave, as though you'd already explained your reasons
behind this all. (You can only have the full conversation if you angered Beren
before and didn't apoligize, or if you never talked to him.) (by Evil_Freak Dragon)

Why are there britannic runes on the cloth
map of Pagan? (by Tribun Dragon)

Isn't is most strange that Earth and Fire magic still
works even after the Avatar has stolen the respective blackrock items?
(by Tribun Dragon)

There is a Blackrock fragment for each element. The one related to
air is called the "Breath of Wind" by Stratos, the Air Titan,
however everyone else refers to it as the "Breath of Air".
(by Dino the Dark Dragon)

In Pagan, things are even worse than in Britannia: There are
no missile weapons at all!(by Dino
the Dark Dragon)

The Zealan gods say Hydros' temple at Carthax Lake is
below the surface. But that's not possible:
1.
The lake is marked on the map, so it must be above
the surface.
2. When Hydros is free, there is rain and fog at Carthax Lake,
too. That's only possible on the surface. (by
Tribun Dragon)

Why doesn't the spell to get the truth out of
someone work with everyone? It would sure come handy with Vardion or
Bane. (by Tribun Dragon)

When they almost execute Devon, the Avatar is struck by a
lightning of Mordea. Why isn't he dead? Such a lightning always kills a
human. The only reason is probably: "Because of the plot!"Even
worse: Darion and Shaana survive, too. Why? That's not very credible, the more
so because the guards are killed by the lightning.
(by Tribun Dragon)

General problems

How did the Obelisk Tip get into the possession of
Kumash-Gor? He died centuries before the temple was destroyed. How can
it be in his possession now? After all, the temple is deep beneath the surface,
forgotten long since. Did the Zealans hide it there? (by
Tribun Dragon)

Where is Vengeance Bay? It is mentioned in the
manual, and it says it's a great destination for pilgrims. (by Tribun Dragon)

If there is really just one jewel of passage in
the test of Lithos (at least you see only one), then the next candidate will
automatically fail. (by Tribun Dragon)

After the Ceremony of Eternity, Vividos will tell you that, in
time, he will teach you other Necromantic spells once you've
been tested in the Catacombs and the Hall of the Mountain King. However, he
never does, that sneak! (by Evil_Freak Dragon)

According to the book "The Destruction of the Temple", the
Tear of the Seas is hidden in an underwater city. Later on in
the game, however, Devon reveals that he just happened to find the Tear
of the Seas while out fishing, and just happened to decide an
ordinary-looking rock was important enough for him to keep it for all these
years. If that's not a sign of an unfinished plot thread, I don't know what
is... (by Evil_Freak Dragon)

Your Necromantic pilgrimage is to find the Birthplace of
Moriens, where, according to Vividos, you will see an incredible
vision. However, you never see anything special; in the "Birthplace of Moriens"
you merely find an entrance to an ancient Zealan Temple. (by Evil_Freak Dragon)

What is the Skull of Quakes? In the course of
Ultima VIII, you will find two letters, correspondence between Mordea and one
"Lieutenant Vittek", talking about how the Skull of Quakes has mysteriously gone
missing from its resting place in the Upper Catacombs. Eventually, you will find
the Skull of Quakes in a trapped chest in the Temple of the Ancient Ones.
Placing it on a glowing red spot in the Upper Catacombs will cause the screen to
rumble, go black, then fade back in with a new passage opened up. This passage
leads to a room with a recall pad and absolutely nothing else. This brings up a
number of questions:

1. What is the Skull of Quakes?
2. What is this tiny room?
3. Who stole the Skull of Quakes and why, especially when they
just dumped it in a trapped chest in somewhere incredibly out of the way?
4.
Why are Mordea and this Vittek so desperate to get the Skull of
Quakes back? (by Evil_Freak
Dragon)

In the whole Daemon's Crag/Sorceror's Enclave sequence, Malchir
talks of how important it is that he conducts the Ritual of Flame. When he does
so, we see that it is so that he can ask Pyros about a mythical "great fire in
the sky" (the sun). Pyros is either ignorant of this or pretends to be. However,
right after the Ritual of Flame, the Avatar heads off to kill Malchir and loot
his corpse; what Malchir was trying to learn of the sun is
never explained nor even mentioned ever again in the game.Did Malchir want
to have the sunlight back? Then he most certainly didn't ask Pyros the first
time. (by Evil_Freak Dragon)

After you free Hydros, Devon tells the Avatar to go to the
Sorceror's Enclave, since they might have a way of stopping her. However, there
is absolutely no dialogue at all regarding any of the Sorcerers that
even mentions that Hydros is free, much less the fact that you're here
to find a way to stop her. (by Evil_Freak Dragon)

There is a book in Tenebrae that mentions strange balls of
glowing light that were seen on the Plateau, where Mythran lives. Makes
you wonder if Wisps were originally going to appear in Ultima VIII. (by Evil_Freak Dragon)

Why is a mundane stranger like the Avatar allowed to enter
the Palace of the Tempest? (by Tribun
Dragon)

Mythram says that you can only leave Pagan if you control the
powers of the Titans... Makes you wonder how Mordra could leave
Pagan. (by Natreg Dragon)

We know that the Guardian built the Blackrock obelisk to
have a Black Gate allowing him to enter the world. However, he
destroyed it as soon as he was through. How could he then leave it again?
(by Tribun Dragon)

After you free her, Hydros tells you she will kill
Devon, and that you better go and try to save him. Unfortunately, she
never tries to kill him. An unfinished strand of the plot. (by Tribun Dragon)

Isn't it strange how little information we get about the
connection between the Titans and the Guardian in Ultima VIII? It's
mostly Ascension's fault, of course, but
still... (by Tribun Dragon)

In the valley north of Tenebrae, there's a Torax herdsman called
Gwillim. When you initiate a conversation with him, he will mention the
plateau, and that he's been there once or twice, calling it quite a
beautiful place.

Perhaps this is too nitpicky or exaggerating, but doesn't it strike you as
mighty strange that a simple Torax herdsman would brave the
caverns that lead up to the plateau, which are filled with ghouls and
other diabolical traps (like primed death disks, trapped chests, and a
subterranean lake with a Minion of the Lurker in it) as well as a lever puzzle,
just to view the scenery of the plateau? In addition, Gwillim also just
happens to neglect to mention that the way to the plateau is filled
with ghouls. Instead, he makes it sound as if it's as easy as a casual stroll,
that sneak! (by BlueClaw)

If Mythram knows about Britannia and Mordra, then
why you can't ask him about it? Also, since he knows about Mordra, he should
know about another way to leave Pagan (the one Mordra used). (by Natreg Dragon)

You can read Salkind's book with the accusations of Bentic
and Devon as much as you like, but you'll just not get a dialogue about
it with imprisoned Devon. (by Tribun Dragon)

You have to wonder why the Tempests of Tenebrae never allowed the
Theurgists into civil service. With their "find out the truth" spell, they'd be
better than all torture instruments. (by Tribun
Dragon)

In either the Tenebraen Library or Salkind's ornate mansion,
there's a book called "Brogdan's Helpful Guide to Mushrooms". In one of his
statements, he describes the humble mushroom as one such plant that has survived
the disaster when the sun had disappeared. Er, Mr. Brogdan...mushrooms aren't
plants, they're fungi. (God, we nitpickers are a nitpicky lot, aren't we?)
(by BlueClaw)

This is not so much a nitpick as it is indicative of Pagan's incompleteness.
To the west of Tenebrae, there is a small stream with a gentle waterfall pouring
into it. This would appear to be the scene of a burial or death of some sort, as
there is at least one ghoul patrolling. Also, there are several scarce reagents
on either side of the stream. Now, the waterfall is being fed from a cave
entrance. If you approach the ledge and manage to gain purchase, you actually
enter a new cavern.

Within, there is a lone skeleton warrior, and further down a twisting
passage, a pair of mandrills buzzing around a chest. At the end of the passage,
there are some bones. Checking the inventory, you'll find some explosives,
reagents, and curiously enough, an item you don't see anywhere else in the game.
It is a blue vial of some kind, but when you double-click on it, it has no
purpose. You have to wonder, is this frazzled plot thread another victim of the
impetuousness of EA? Was
the blue vial supposed to have a purpose of some kind? Judging by the cavern
itself, it looks to be incomplete as well. (by
BlueClaw)