Any time we undervalue a draft pick in the NFL, we are reminded when a productive player — a Pro Bowler, even — is traded for a third-round pick. “That’s all they got for him?” we inevitably say. So you can imagine the value of a top 10 pick. Who will start Week 1? How will they fare? Here’s a look at what is expected from the top 10 picks in the 2012 NFL draft.

Photo Credit: Joe Robbins/Getty Images

1. Andrew Luck, QB, Indianapolis Colts

Fourteen years after drafting Peyton Manning No. 1 overall, the Colts hope they struck gold again with Luck. There’s no reason to think they didn’t. Luck ran a pro-style offense to perfection at Stanford, often calling the plays himself. In fact, the Stanford offensive coordinator will now be known as the Andrew Luck Director of Offense. Even Peyton can’t claim such an honor at Tennessee. But Luck will have his work cut out for him on a Colts team that notched just two wins in 2011. A winning season is unlikely.

Photo Credit: Patrick McDermott/Getty Images

2. Robert Griffin III, QB, Washington Redskins

Historically, when quarterbacks are taken with the first two picks, it doesn’t work out well for both teams. Luck and Griffin will try to change that. The Heisman Trophy winner is electric on the field and charismatic off of it, and will be given the keys to the Redskins offense from week 1. Griffin ran a 4.41 40-yard dash at the combine, second fastest among all players, not just quarterbacks. And he’ll be doing a lot of running, given the Redskins’ sub-par offensive line that’s already facing injury questions in the preseason.

Photo Credit: Jason Miller/Getty Images

3. Trent Richardson, RB, Cleveland Browns

Richardson was a Heisman finalist and the only back taken among the first 30 picks. His runs at Alabama were highlight-worthy more for his power than his speed. At 5’9”, Richardson has great leverage and body control. “Trent can get his foot down and slash it up in the line of scrimmage and by the nature of his build, he is sometimes hard to get your arms around and tackle,” said Browns head coach Pat Shurmur, who also praised Richardson’s patience and vision. That being said, the AFC North is rarely kind to opposing backs.

Photo Credit: Hannah Foslien/Getty Images

4. Matt Kalil, LT, Minnesota Vikings

Minnesota general manager Rick Spielman said the Vikings were considering a wide receiver or a defensive back with the fourth pick, but knew good players at those positions would be available via free agency. “Dominant left tackles are not available in the open market. We felt we had to do it through the draft,” Spielman said. “There was no doubt about his physical stature or his athleticism,” he added, specifically referring to Kalil’s long arms. Kalil will start from Week 1 and games should be easy considering he’ll be going against last year’s sack leader, Jared Allen, every day in practice.

Photo Credit: Rick Dole/Getty Images

5. Justin Blackmon, WR, Jacksonville Jaguars

Blackmon finally signed after missing 11 days of training camp. Part of the hold-up was Blackmon’s DUI in June; the Jaguars wanted to include language in the contract to protect the team against future off-field troubles. The Jaguars traded up for Blackmon because general manager Gene Smith feels that, right now, Blackmon falls between Anquan Boldin and Hakeem Nicks, with room to improve. Says head coach Mike Mularkey: “I like the way he lines up and says, ‘The guy across from me can’t cover me.’ He just has an edge to him. He has a confidence and air about him that you like receivers to have.” He’ll need that attitude as part of a weak Jaguars receiving corps.

Photo Credit: Joe Robbins/Getty Images

6. Morris Claiborne, CB, Dallas Cowboys

Playing on a defense with so much talent, as Claiborne did at LSU, can make it tough to assess individuals. But Cowboys assistant director of player personnel, Tom Ciskowski, said Claiborne’s skills were evident. “When they blitzed, he was on an island. He was challenged and he did well.” That has carried over to preseason practice, where Claiborne has proved to be very coachable. “He doesn’t make the same mistake twice,” Ciskowski said. “If he continues to progress, I expect him to start.”

Photo Credit: Al Messerschmidt/Getty Images

7. Mark Barron, SS, Tampa Bay Buccaneers

After Barron signed with the Bucs, new head coach, Greg Schiano, said he spoke with him on the phone and Barron asked if he could have a playbook. Schiano’s response: “You’re going to be down here tomorrow, Mark. We’ll get you a playbook [then], I promise you.” Both Schiano and general manager, Mark Dominik, praised Barron’s work ethic, which should help the safety learn new schemes and get on the field as soon as possible. “We drafted this guy to come in here and be our safety for a long time, god willing, and I’m excited,” Schiano said. Expect to see him on the field on opening day.

Photo Credit: Joel Auerbach/Getty Images

8. Ryan Tannehill, QB, Miami Dolphins

Here’s a list of quarterbacks who have started at least five games for the Dolphins since Dan Marino retired after the 1999 season: Jay Fiedler, Ray Lucas, Brian Griese, A.J. Feeley, Gus Frerotte, Joey Harrington, Cleo Lemon, Trent Green, Chad Pennington, Chad Henne and Matt Moore. It’s unfair to put the weight of a franchise on a guy who played wide receiver in college until halfway through his junior season at Texas A&M. But with veterans David Garrard and Matt Moore still on the roster, it’s unlikely Tannehill will see too much playing time this season.

Photo Credit: Joe Robbins/Getty Images

9. Luke Kuechly, LB, Carolina Panthers

The Panthers drafted Kuechly partly because they love his versatility. “He’s so smart and athletic that you can use him in a lot of different roles,” general manager Marty Hurney said after the draft. Kuechly’s production at Boston College was impressive; he had 23 tackles in a game last year. Carolina expects him to make an immediate impact regardless of which linebacker position he plays.

Photo Credit: Rick Stewart/Getty Images

10. Stephen Gilmore, CB, Buffalo Bills

George Catavolos, Buffalo’s secondary coach, said he expects Gilmore to be the Week 1 starter because of his size, speed and athleticism. “He’s been progressing nicely in camp. He’s handled the information. He’s cut down his mental errors. His technique is getting better.” Going against Tom Brady and the Patriots twice a year will force Gilmore to grow up fast.