Avon Ultra Luxury Eyeliner is a product I've used in almost all of my tutorials. I've used at least 6 of them all the way through. I keep one in my purse, in the car, and one with my every time I do my makeup. Yet I haave a really hard time trying to review it. I've tried twice and failed. I think its because of how basic of a product it is, I feel like I'm stating the obvious. But I will try for a third and hopefully final time.Avon's Ultra Luxury Eyeliner is a basic eyeliner pencil. They retail for $6 but are usually available with some sort of deal, by one get one, 2 for $4, .99 with a purchase of another item, etc. I'm not sure how much I paid for mine.Packaging is a standard wood pencil with black coating and a plastic black cap. The cap is doesn't slit like some eyeliner caps do. I rarely have trouble with the wood splintering, unless the blades on my sharpener are dull.The liner its self is a really good texture, soft and smooth without being gel-like or overly creamy. I'd describe it as feeling velvety.It applies wonderfully to the waterline and lower lash line, but takes a little more work to apply to the upper lash line. It doesn't tug or pull, but might need two or three strokes to get a full, opaque line without skipping. I hardly ever apply pencil liner up there, so its not a problem I encounter with this pencil anyway.Wear time on the lids is 8+ hours with minimal fading and smudging. On the waterline I get 2-4 hours of wear before needing to reapply. I counteract the short wear time by setting it with a matte black eyeshadow, after which I get about 6 hours of wear.Pigmentation is good. It's very dark, but not the darkest black eyeliner I've used. NYX's Black Bean Jumbo Eyeshadow Pencil is darker. Swatches can be seen here.I highly recommend this eyeliner, especially if you can get it at sale price. This is excellent for lining the waterline and tighlining. This has been my go-to black eyeliner for years and will continue to be for quite a while.

This eyeliner is a very good deal for the price. The colors are really nice, and go on with a good amount of pigment. I did find that unless this liner was sharpened right before using, there were a few little clumps of liner that would stick to my eye, but nothing a qtip couldnt fix. One thing that I really like was that the pencils are soft, and dont hurt your eye when applying - even really close to the lash line.

These are very good eyeliners for the price. I have one in black, midnight blue, and dark brown. They go on creamy and smoothly and last pretty much all day. I find the black one goes on best, the midnight blue i have to keep drawing over a couple of times, same as the brown. They smuge a bit, mostly on the bottom lash area, but for the price you cant go wrong.

I have these liners in black and midnight blue. The liners are very creamy, easy to apply, and last all day. The black eyeliner is just your average e/l, does a decent job, but nothing too special. The midnight blue, however, is a beautiful navy that draws out depth and brightness from your eyes. I love pairing this with silver e/l, purple and lavender e/s and blend them into each other, the look recalls a glimpse of Debussy's Reverie, with a dreamlike softness to it. The only downside is that they don't blend easily, so you have to layer the e/s into the liner instead. However, for the price ($5 regular or 2/$5 on sale) I can't really complain. Will definitely purchase the midnight blue and a more unusual color again once I run out.

This is an okay eyeliner. It does not go on smooth; in fact it is rather hard - lots of pulling and tugging (it's summer right now - wonder how much harder it'll get when applying in winter!). It stays on for maybe a couple of hours, then i need to reapply. Unfortunately I bought two, and now regretting it :P