Unlike the other four, Farmiga was one of the few Season 1 regulars who did not return for American Horror Story: Asylum. At a screening of the Season 2 finale last month, co-creator Ryan Murphy told reporters to expect more Season 1 cast members to return.

Farmiga will also next be seen in the drama The Bling Ring.

Are you glad Farmiga is coming back for another round of American Horror Story? Who should she play?