Reader Comments and Retorts

Statements posted here are those of our readers and do not represent the BaseballThinkFactory. Names are provided by the poster and are not verified. We ask that posters follow our submission policy. Please report any inappropriate comments.

I remember Bill James writing about Glenn Braggs that Braggs was a great athlete. James essentially said (and I'm paraphrasing here) that Braggs was big, strong, fast, agile, and a mediocre ballplayer.

Kirby Puckett once said that his fantasy was to have a body like Glenn Braggs'. Kirby was a short, squat man who didn't look like a baseball player; Braggs was about 6-3, slender, fast, very graceful--and, of course, not one-tenth the player that Kirby Puckett was.

Not only was Thomas a tight end at Auburn, he went there on a football scholarship (and not a baseball scholarship).

He stopped playing football fairly early in his time at AU, but I've got to think that footspeed aside, an SEC football recruit who's 6'5" 240 of solid muscle who becomes a no-brainer Hall of Fame baseball player is a pretty terrific athlete.

Ron Reed played a couple of years in the NBA, but I don't think of him as a great athlete.
Gene Conley also played in the NBA long ago.
Greg Luzinski was supposed to have been a college-caliber linebacker but I'm not sure you want him in your athlete group. He does a fine ballpark BBQ, IMO.

Jaime Quirk had a schollie to play QB at Notre Dame. Willie Wilson was a five star recruit for Maryland football as a wideout.

Josh Fields (Oklahoma State), Todd Helton (Tennessee) and Adam Dunn (Texas) DID play college football (I think Dunn didn't actually play though, just held a clipboard). But I don't know if anyone would consider Dunn a great athlete.

Joe Mauer was going to QB at Florida State. Actually, he was the only athlete ever to be selected as the USA Today High School Player of the Year in two sports and was also the 2001 Gatorade National Player of the Year in both football and baseball. In high school, he also had a 90+ mph fastball and scored 20+ points per game as an All State point guard.

Drew Henson set many Michigan High School baseball records along with being a star quarterback. Of course his NY Yankee career was a cup of coffee, football he had success at University of Michigan and then one year with some starts for the Dallas Cowboys. Great athlete maybe a stretch but he sure had some tools for both sports.

Josh Fields (Oklahoma State), Todd Helton (Tennessee) and Adam Dunn (Texas) DID play college football (I think Dunn didn't actually play though, just held a clipboard). But I don't know if anyone would consider Dunn a great athlete.

I wouldn't consider Helton a great athlete either; he has to be one of the slowest non-catchers in baseball. I suppose it just points up what a nebulous concept "great athlete" is.

The funny thing about Helton being a college quarterback is that you almost literally never see him display QB-like skills on the diamond. As a first baseman, he's rarely called on to throw the ball, and when he does, his arm is nothing special. And as I said, he's godawful slow. You do see evidence of his athletic intelligence, though.

Hippo Vaughn was a circus strongman in the off-season. Big trick, IIRC, was straightening out horseshoes with his bare hands.
Maybe he didn't look all that "athletic," but I bet not too many people charged the mound on him, either.

EDIT: I don't know whether he ever tried them, but I'm confident Honus Wagner would have been good at football, basketball, track, or any other sport he set his mind to.

Along with Hendrickson, Ainge, Conley, DeBusschere, Reed, Groat, Conley, and Connors - Frankie Baumholtz, Cotton Nash, and Steve Hamilton were in both MLB and the NBA. More recently, Ryan Minor was good enough to play in the NBA as well. Tony Clark and Tony Gwynn weren't, but were good college ball players.

The MLB and NBA drafts were not around back then, but the aforementioned Connors played for the Brooklyn Dodgers and Boston Celtics, and was drafted by the Chicago Bears.

But I believe Winfield is the only one to be drafted by three.

Tony Gwynn is not typically thought of as an athlete, especially if you see pics of him now, but he was a standout basketball player at San Diego State (two time All-WAC), enough to get drafted by the NBA's San Diego Clippers.

The Yankees gave this guy a look-see

The Royals in the 80s drafted not only Bo Jackson, but John Elway, Dan Marino, Steve Bartkowski and Deion Sanders (none of them signed).

I think what all this points to is that you can succeed in baseball, more than most sports, with not a lot of athletic ability by having great skill. I mean, no one who is a really good MLBer is "non-athletic". Take Luzinski, mentioned above. We guffaw about him as a slow, fat oaf. Well, that slow, fat oaf would probably beat 95% of the world in whatever foot race you wanted to hold (in his prime, of course). But he could be much, much slower than all the guys he's on the field with because in one very important skill, he was usually better. The same is almost always true of pitchers. They may be slower, weaker, less agile than everyone else on the field and yet dominate because of a single particular skill.

All that is also true of QBs in football. You can be a really good QB without a lot of foot speed if you have a strong arm and quick mind.

We see in the NBA that skill often loses due to lack of athelticism. Think some of the great college shooters. They get to the NBA and never get within 10 feet of an open shot and, so, can't use their skill. So being athletically dominant becomes more important the less a sport isolates a particular skill.

Football All-American at halfback, two-time scoring leader in Pacific Coast Conference basketball, NCAA broad jump champion in 1940, and would likely have gone to the Olympics as the gold medal favorite had they not been cancelled. Baseball was clearly his fourth best sport in college.

The question of the greatest multi-sport athlete to have been a major track athlete comes up periodically on track boards. Robinson wins this argument more often than anyone else.

Dave Logan (WR for the Browns in the 70s-80s) was drafted by all 3 major sports (Browns, KC/Omaha Kings, Reds)

Geez, as the guy who asked the original "anybody besides Winfield" question, I feel dumb for not knowing/remembering that, considering I live in Boulder and he's a CU alum who's very much in the public eye here -- he's currently the multiple state-championship-winning coach at Mullen High in Denver, as well as the radio voice of the Broncos.