My opponent is arguing that the Whovian fandom is, in fact, not filled with fangirls that only care for the eyecandy.

My first point is the uproar over the casting of Peter Capaldi as the latest Doctor. The only points made against it referred to his age, while nobody seemed to claim that he was not a good enough actor. It boils down to the fangirls being upset that Peter Capaldi wasn't a young pretty-boy.

My second point is the disregard for the classic episodes. Many members of the fandom have never heard of Susan Foreman or how the Doctor worked for UNIT when he was stuck on Earth. These classic episodes do not provide the appealing actors that the fangirls desire. I will accept that many of the classic episodes are lost, but there are enough to form the linear storyline that crucially shows up in the reboot.

It doesn't really matter if the episodes who has never heard of her as long as they like that series and or show people shouldn't have to like a show just becuase of the people only the love for the show

Oh YES! Definitions! The standards for this debate will be by these definitions:

Fangirl: A person, gender not relevant, who is only part of a fandom to be a part of something.
Eyecandy: An attractive actor playing the role
Filed: To a point where the unmentioned group is overshadowed.