Somalia at the Turn of the 21st Century

For Somalia to reestablish itself as a nation, we need to put an end to our deranged behavior. I for one trace our strife not to an inherent antagonism between clan families but to the defeat we suffered at the hands of the combined forces of Ethiopia and Cuba in 1978 over the control of the Somali-speaking Ogaden, then and now administered by Ethiopia. Once our army came home vanquished, the defeat became an infestation in the body politic, eventually resulting in an implosion, which took the shape of an all-out war, a war on all and everyone, Somali killing Somali. With no faith in ourselves as a nation, we fragmented into blood communities and then further into smaller units. Civil wars erupt when a people are no longer in touch with their reality. In 1991 we lost touch with the reality of our Somaliness.

You could say that we have more of a penchant for obsessing about each other’s family origins than for building a viable, modern, democratic society. The war, however, has forced us to come around to the idea that what matters more now is not who one is but what role one plays in the scheme of things. Today, more of us are prepared to give peace a chance so that we can re-create a nation out of the rubble of our self-destruction. Our faith in the family-based ideology, which once determined all, is no longer supreme. Nor are there any longer certainties when it comes to identifying our enemies or friends based on clan affiliations.

Nonetheless, we speak of “before” and “after” with equal certainty, even though we talk of “before” and “after” civil war. Before the civil war we were a one-city nation, Mogadishu, the swallow-all metropolis, run by one man, [Maxamed] Siyaad Barre, our absolute supreme. Since the collapse, we’ve been turned into a collection of fiefdoms, with boundaries drawn by warlords, each of whom murderously rules his assigned territory. Of late it’s become de rigueur for each clan family to reinvent its history, as though this would give legitimacy to its control of its so-called ancestral territory. Is this the “after” that Somalis will content themselves with?

There are those who argue that there can be no viable peace in the Somali peninsula, no possibility of democracy or social and political stability until we work in tandem with the clan elders, the religious leaders, and the like. I do not agree.

I believe that we won’t resolve the crisis until we work toward a unity in which our differences are celebrated. After all, our problem stems from our investment in the authority of the clan, which has put our country where it is today—in ruins. We do not wish any longer to be under mob rule, which is what happens when herds of clansmen take control of the affairs of a modern state. Peace is our priority, but not peace at any price.