User Reviews

Nick & Toni's Cafe

Posted by Neighbor on 2014-11-20

Waiter

Will not return because of this waiter. He was overtly rude, condescending and behavior was shocking. Clearly, nobody is paying attention. He disappears, can't get bread, wine takes long and nobody checking on us. Do not know why this man has a job.

Nick & Toni's Cafe

Posted by Jordan on 2014-05-27

Terrible In Every Way

I was so excited to try this restaurant after walking by it so often, and I was disappointed in every way. We did not make a reservation and were given a terrible table by an unfriendly person when we entered. The food was terrible and the presentation wa

Nick & Toni's Cafe

Posted by Long time patron. LTP on 2013-07-23

Disappointed

Been a customer over 20 years. Now disappointed . The upgrade is staid and sterile.. The Hampton panache has been replaced by nouveau Manhattanism ,almost a "diner" like setting. The service was mediocre,waiting for bread etc. had to ask....unacceptable

Nick & Toni's Cafe

Posted by anonymous on 2011-02-14

Chicken sandwich to die for

I found the experience to be extremely pleasent, I took my mom here for mother's day and we just loved the small area and friendly waiters. The coffee was perfect and the chicken sandwich was so amazing that driving a hour from upstate is all worth it.

Nick & Toni's Cafe

Posted by dana P. on 2011-01-05

A night well spent

I went here for dinner with a few friends from out of town. As soon as we were settled in a man with a huge voice welcomed us to dinner and we started the party. His recommendations were so good (I could order two platters of the zucchini chips and have

Nick & Toni's Cafe

Posted by ladycaterina on 2010-03-01

service issues

The quality of the meal was destroyed by the service. We waited 10 minutes just to get the menus, another 10 to get the check, and another 10 for our credit card to return (AND they had given us the wrong person's check). The food is decent, but for the

Nick & Toni's Cafe

Posted by Anonymous on 2009-08-11

No Enchanted Evening

Should have been tipped off by the empty dining room. A very long wait for our supposedly fresh fish entrees was followed by a miniscule portion of an overcooked filet.
No bread was offered, and when we asked for some, it did not arrive until long af

Nick & Toni's Cafe

Posted by Cam on 2009-03-12

Pleasantly surprised!

Service sealed the deal! Never been before, although I am very familiar with its tony East Hampton location, will certainly go again. Food is vaguely similar, I believe they source most locally, and wonderfully left alone to its own strengths. The scallop