I like your girl naming style. We chose Hadley for our DD. She is due friday, so I hope I don't have to wait much longer! Here are a few from my original list I don't think have been mentioned that might be your style (DH nixed all of these)

My favorites from your list are Connelly, Greer, Waverly, and Penelope. I know most will be against Connelly, but I find it oddly charming, probably because it reminds me of the family in the movie "The Secret of Roan Inish", though I think they spell their surname Coneely? Anyways, I think all of these options are very nice, and would suit any girl.

I've enjoyed Elliott for a girl ever since the show Scrubs. It's a spunky set of sounds, on a man or woman or other. It's on my long boy list. Of your original choices, it's my pick after Penelope (which is one of my favourite names).