Cantata BWV 149

Man singet mit Freuden vom Sieg

This cantata was first performed in Leipzig 1728 for the feast of St. Michael. It is one of three cantatas Bach wrote for this feast in his lifetime (the others are the chorale cantata BWV 130, in 1724, and BWV 19, in 1726). Some scholars think the performance of this work may not have occurred until a year later, in September, 1729.

Given St. Michael’s position in the Christian (and Jewish) faith, the tone of this cantata should be no surprise. But the bright D major chorus, triumphant in character, using trumpets and timpani, was not entirely new – Bach adapted a chorus form the Weimar cantata BWV 208, Was mir behagt. In its previous guise, the chorus is part of a secular hunting cantata. This same movement was later adapted for yet another cantata, BWV Anh. 193, Herrscher des Himmels, König der Ehren. The choir appears only in the opening and closing movements, and in very different scorings and textures:

Opening Chorus

Final Chorale

D Major

C Major

Polyphonic

4-part homophonic

3/8

4/4

3 trumpets, timpani, 3 oboes, bassoon, strings, continuo

strings, oboes, and continuo double the voices; trumpets and timpani appear only in the final cadence to provide closure

Except for the final movement, which sets a stanza of a chorale tune (text by Martin Schalling, tune anonymous), the cantata sets a text by Picander, one of Bach’s most important poets. There are numerous examples of “collaborations” between the two, the most notable of which is the St. Matthew Passion.

Returning to the first movement for a moment, it is hard to imagine this movement in any role other than the present. With the brilliant D major sound, trumpets, and timpani, it sets a perfect stage for either a rallying cry for battle or an anticipation of the triumph of good over evil. Furthermore, the text and choral parts (written anew for this setting, rather than recycled form BWV Anh. 193) send the clear message “Man singet mit Freuden vom Sieg” (Man sings with joy of victory). The polyphonic, imitative entrances truly are a rallying cry, with the joyous sounds rising gradually from among the ranks of angels and man alike. The most glorified word in this passage is “Freuden”, emphasized through melismas, chromaticism, and a rise to a temporary high point in the line:

The bass part, which begins this imitative passage, lacks the chromaticism, but has a far longer melisma; thus “Freuden” retains its importance in all vocal parts.

As a bridge between choral entrances, Bach transforms the opening orchestral passage into a ritornello of various lengths. There are two distinct ideas in this ritornello: a fanfare-like passage which occurs in the trumpets or bassoon, and a syncopated one which occurs in the oboes or strings.

At one point, Bach even uses this orchestral passage during a longer choral statement, adding to the complexity of the texture while at the same time faintly reminding the listeners of that orchestral tune.

The five interior movements are of a smaller scale. These might be considered to be representatives of Michael in his battle with Satan – the bombast of the chorus is absent from here out. These five movements are summarized in the chart below:

2. Aria for Bass

Accompanied by Violone and continuo; b minor; 4/4

The fury of the battle is clear in the active, intense continuo line (see example 149c, below)

References the struggle between God and Satan referenced in the day’s Epistle and introduced in the opening chorus

There’s a certain dance-like quality and elegance to this movement, in the triple meter, A major, moderate tempo, and parallel 3rds and 6ths in the violins. (see example 149d, below) For Mozart (half a century after Bach wrote this piece), a gentle A major piece like this would represent love: is it possible that Bach is conveying the same emotion here? Love for God? God’s love for us?

Is the 3/8 a musical reflection of “God’s angels are with me on all sides,” as the text suggests, or to the Trinity?

5. Recitative for tenor

Accompanied by continuo alone; tonally mostly G major; 4/4

A prayer of thanks to God – from the angels?

6. Duet for Alto and Tenor

Accompanied by obbligato bassoon and continuo; G major; 4/4

It is unusual to have the bassoon so distinct from the continuo part, and to play such a prominent melodic role throughout, as Bach does in this movement. (See example 149e below) The resulting character is almost comical, though I doubt that was Bach’s intent, given the occasion and audience.

“Be wakeful, you holy watchers, the night is almost past”.

night=the battle with evil

Example 149c

Example 149d

Example 149e

Note that the large orchestra rests throughout these movements as well, leaving the bulk of the work to the continuo instruments.

The final chorale is not nearly so simple as it appears on paper. It is a theory student’s nightmare! I’ve marked the many keys Bach establishes and implies so you can see how complicated (and generally unstable) this “simple” chorale really is!

Want to stay in-the-know?

Subscribe to our newsletter to get performance announcements, Choir news, and updates about recordings or Bach Choir touring. Simply fill out the form and you’ll get regular updates about The Bach Choir of Bethlehem delivered straight to your inbox!

"The performance was one of integrity, movement, passion and weight. The effortless virtuosity and stylistic homegeneity of the combined forces in the chapel's stone sanctity, allowed Bach's music to sing out with infectious, exhilarating enthusiasm."

—The Huffington Post, 2017

"Nestled in the Pennsylvania countryside, on and around the bucolic campus of Lehigh University, the Bethlehem Bach Festival, under the artistic direction of conductor Greg Funfgeld, is in its 108th season and going strong. If it has flaws, they are like those that distinguish a fine emerald from the perfect clarity of a fake...their choral sonority is so rich you can feel it in your bones."

—The Wall Street Journal, May 2015

"Two days later I am Newark bound again, with a head full of the history of a town I previously had no awareness of, and with a heart full of the music of Bach, presented in a context that felt less like a festival than a glorious friendship between a great composer and the orchestra, conductor and choir at the heart of an extraordinary town."

—The Whole-Note - Toronto, June 2015

"The audience was thrilled by this outstanding performance of a Bach Cantata by seasoned experts immersed in the composer and informed by Greg Funfgeld's wisdom and enthusiasm...The Bachs [J.S.B and C.P.E] could not have been better served, not to mention two English Renaissances, as well as our own time. It went beyond mere intelligent programming and committed performance, enriched by a deep sense of the mutual nourishment of music and faith."

—New York Arts, 2015

"The Bach Choir of Bethlehem, founded in the 19th century, has gained international recognition through its annual Bach Festival, tours and recordings. The more than 100 vocalists displayed clean tone, excellent pitch and blend, and kept good tempo even in the most stressful numbers…outstanding, energetic and crisp. The orchestra was a collection of top freelancers from around the Eastern Seaboard including several from Washington… baritone Dashon Burton, was the standout. He has a clarion instrument that projects well throughout his range…a splendid dramatic performance. Soprano Rosa Lamoreaux was also excellent, expertly modulating her silvery tone for the various roles she took…This was the choir’s big night, though, and it gave great pleasure…”

—The Washington Post, March 2013

“A handsome account of Bach’s St. John Passion on this new release confirms that the Bach Choir of Bethlehem doesn’t rest on anything resembling laurels. Greg Funfgeld has trained his singers to articulate words crisply, dance lightly when the music must move and blend elegantly. Funfgeld brings a sure sense of phrasing, texture and pacing to the narrative, and the Bach Festival Orchestra—mostly modern instruments, with viola da gamba, violas d’amore and portative organ supplying period flavors—are cohesive and nimble. Charles Daniels stands out as a poetic and powerful Evangelist, William Sharp as a warmly inflected Jesus and Julia Doyle as a shining champion of the soprano arias.”

—Gramophone, November 2012

“The Bach Choir of Bethlehem sang a Brahms motet (“Lass Dich Nur Nichts”) with all the polish and fervor it brought to cantatas by its namesake.”

—New York Times, September 2011

“..inspired program of hope, optimism and comfort …disarmingly powerful…overflows with jubilation”

—The Morning Call, October 2011

“America’s venerable Bach Choir of Bethlehem makes its Analekta debut on a disc brimming-over with festive D major trumpets-and-drums brilliance…Julia Doyle and Daniel Taylor heading up a distinguished solo line-up.”

—BBC Music Magazine, May 2010

“Conductor Greg Funfgeld coaxed a lovely rich chamber orchestra sound from the Bach Festival Orchestra strings...The hauntingly beautiful voices of Taylor and Zsigovics—she in her festival debut—melted together like two precious metals, hers of bell-like clarity, his a more complex alchemy, with a sheen like liquid mercury.”

—The Morning Call, May 2010

“As I listen to The Bach Choir of Bethlehem with Greg Funfgeld conducting…I find it hard to believe this is an all-volunteer choir but it’s true…a well polished vocal ensemble, and a true level of musicianship and understanding of the choral music of Bach.”

—Minnesota Public Radio Review, December 2009

“…an American musical treasure… they sing with a fervor and a level of musicianship that carries one away—from bass to soprano, the supple strength and solidly integrated tone of this amateur choir reflects the most admirable qualities of the European-American tradition of choral song.”

—Wall Street Journal May, 2007

“By all accounts the chorus remains as vital an institution as ever…The B-Minor Mass performance was rousing, committed and touching…Bach’s ‘St. Matthew Passion’ too was ardently and lovingly performed…”

—New York Times, May 2007

“This is Bach at its finest. The conductor, orchestra, soloists, and chorus are eminently capable of the nuances of the rich harmonic texts …spirited and vivacious…It is not likely to get any better than this on this side of the Atlantic.”

—The American Organist, January, 2004

“America’s venerable Bach Choir of Bethlehem sang Bach and Mendelssohn with good-natured and ruddy-cheeked elation. And their centerpiece was a BBC/Bach Choir co-commission, the world premiere of Libby Larsen’s I It Am, a jubilant cantata based on the writings of Julian of Norwich…this highly coloured and disarmingly unsophisticated work came from, and went straight to, the heart.”

—The Times, London, July 2003

“The Bach Choir of Bethlehem…had their audience enthralled…The choir knows and loves this work – and it shows…transatlantic magic.”

—The Scotsman, Edinburgh, July 2003

“…the Choir and Festival Orchestra, under their director, Greg Funfgeld, perform these three cantatas beautifully and convincingly. The work of the soloists is excellent, too…Excitement, dedication, power—all things that we hear more and more seldom in Bach cantatas—lend distinction to this beautiful and well-produced recording.”

—American Record Guide, November/December 2002

“Nearly one hundred strong, the Bach Choir of Bethlehem tempers its power and energy with the intimacy of a much smaller group. It also blends seamlessly with the excellent modern-instrument Festival orchestra which Greg Funfgeld conducts with an obvious knowledge of, and sensitivity to, modern performance practice.”

—Early Music News, California, October/November 2002

“…intoxicating but precise choral sound that reminds you why choruses grew this large in the first place. The elemental power is startling…the Bethlehem approach under Greg Funfgeld isn’t anachronistic, but meets the historically enlightened approach halfway…We know from Bach’s often irritable correspondence that he campaigned for more singers. The Bach Choir of Bethlehem gives him all he could have wanted. Maybe this is “in-his-dreams” Bach.”

—Philadelphia Inquirer, December 2000

“The Bethlehem Bach Festival is one of the most venerable musical institutions in the USA, with an unmatched tradition of introducing Bach’s music to our shores. Greg Funfgeld…has revitalized this Pennsylvania institution, and Dorian is doing well to document its vibrancy in a recording series… genuine honesty and intelligence informs this performance…Funfgeld has forged a fine body of singers and players…tightly disciplined ensemble …rousing spirit and sacred joy aplenty. This recording will not disappoint.”

—American Record Guide, November/December 2000

“…a performance that confirmed my belief that this is one of the finest large amateur choruses in the United States.”

—The Washington Post, May 1999

“Sheer jubilance…exceptional elegance and grace…radiant performance…Having heard the Bethlehem Bach Choir pour its heart into the master’s vocal music, one will never listen to it in quite the same way again.”

—Musical America, May 2001

The Bach Choir gratefully acknowledges and thanks our sponsors and media partners for supporting our organization and the arts.
The Choir is supported in part by the National Endowment for the Arts and the Pennsylvania Council on the Arts.