However, Judge S. James Otero in U.S. District Court said that Trump was using “rhetorical hyperbole,” and his speech was protected under the First Amendment, according to Newsmax.

Advertisement - story continues below

“To allow the complaint to go forward and to have one consider this to be defamatory in the context it was made would have a chilling effect,” Otero said, as reported by the Los Angeles Times. “This is the type of political discourse and commentary that takes place in elections all the time, and I’m troubled that there’s a claim here for defamation.”

Michael Avenatti, Daniel’s attorney, disputed Otero’s decision.

Do you think this lawsuit should be thrown out?

YesNo

Completing this poll entitles you to The Western Journal news updates free of charge. You may opt out at anytime. You also agree to our Privacy Policy and Terms of Use.

You're logged in to Facebook. Click here to log out.

“This was not political by any stretch of the imagination,” Avenatti said.

Otero said he would rule on the case soon, but Trump’s speech appeared to be opinion that would be protected under the First Amendment.

Attorney Ken White, who often blogs about the case, said it is similar to one that was thrown out in New York. That case involved a woman who said the president ruined her reputation when he took to Twitter to say she “begged” him for a job.

Advertisement - story continues below

“The court basically said, ‘It’s Trump, it’s Twitter, he’s known for throwing around insults and this can’t be understood as anything other than exaggerated rhetoric,” White said.

Avenatti, however, made it clear that he would appeal if the case were dismissed.

“I witnessed something here today that I never thought I’d witness. That is: Donald Trump having a lawyer stand up in a federal court and espouse on his behalf the virtues and how important the First Amendment is in America,” Avenatti said.

“This is the same Donald Trump that has crapped all over the First Amendment and the news media for years,” he added.

Steven is a follower of Jesus, husband to an amazing wife, and a father to two beautiful girls. You can find him enjoying listening to or playing jazz piano, enjoying the Disney parks, or hiking the Arizona landscape.