Two Men Staged a Fake Proposal to Catch Their Cheating Girlfriend

In a plot that sounds like the concept of a decade-old Usher or R. Kelly video, a pair of men who were dating the same woman teamed up to pull a prank on her that left her red-faced (and probably feeling like kind of a dick). They also caught her reaction on video.

Here’s how it went down:

One-half of the men dating the woman showed up to surprise her at the sports bar she works at. From there, he got down on a knee to propose to her. Based on the look on her face, she was pretty stoked. So too were her co-workers, who did that weird thing everyone does when someone proposes in public, as they started cheering in delight and saying “Oh my god!” loud enough for anyone within earshot to hear.

At this point in the video, the guy on a knee looks around nervously, almost as if his cue for boyfriend No. 2 to enter the picture was too early. He nearly played himself, but luckily he was able to filibuster his way through it. He eventually stalled for enough time until the other boyfriend walked in. At first she doesn’t react, but then she figures it out because it’s not like it was subtle.

“You had two good men!” the second guy yells. “Two good f*cking men! You f*cked it up!”

At this point the woman walks away and bails out of the door while the jilted loverone of the jilted lovers shouts, “You see how you played me?”

While this would seem confusing to restaurant-goers, the two men explain that they had both been dating her since November, and one of the poor guys even claimed to have bought her a car. At least Usher and R. Kelly figured out they were dating twins in the end. Here’s a list that can hopefully prevent this from happening to you.

A Part of Hearst Digital Media
Men's Health participates in various affiliate marketing programs, which means we may get paid commissions on editorially chosen products purchased through our links to retailer sites.