A:
There are those who suspect Wildflower Center volunteers are the culpable
and capable culprits. Yet, others think staff members play some, albeit small, role. You
can torture us with your plant questions, but we will never reveal the Green
Guru's secret identity.

Thursday - September 12, 2013

QUESTION:

We recently removed the dead undergrowth of white pines that were used for privacy. We need advice as to what type of evergreen would be suitable for growth beneath the branches above. It is VERY shady most of the time. I am looking for something that will grow at least 6ft tall and spreading wide. I'll probably need at least 14 plants. This is primarily for privacy from the road (about 150 foot line). Here is the big problem..DEER!! Thank you for your help.

ANSWER:

OK, Mr Smarty Plants has a few suggestions for you! My normal process is to use the Wildflower Centers Recommended Species pages for a certain area. Of course, for you I looked at the “Recommended Species for Rhode Island”. This didn’t work too well, especially as Evergreen is not a choice, but then I went to the Plant Database directly and was able to successfully search for "Rhode Island, Forb or Shrub, Evergreen, and in the 6 ft. plus height range.

One interesting “but” is that Deer Resistance is not one of those selection factors, so you actually need to read the plants description to see how it handles deer. This will normally be a “Deer Resistance” comment under Benefits. The kicker - - None of the plants I found listed for Rhode Island had one of these comments, although I list one below that had a comment that it was valuable wildlife food! So, with that bit of frustration here’s a good set of plants that meet your requirements in general.

For Shrubs, I found 4 plants, and allowing the herbs to also be 3-6 feet tall, I found 5 more. Here are the top candidates with some important comments about each:

After I wrote up all of this, I went looking elsewhere on the internet and found a bit more on Deer Resistance.I was delighted to see that Old Farmers Almanac, had a good piece – and also many other Blogs referenced this piece from Better Homes and Gardens.I see many favorites mentioned in these, but they are normally smaller than you requested and/or not native to your area.

From the Image Gallery

More Privacy Screening Questions

Fast-growing non-invasive shrub for privacy fence in Sugar Land TXDecember 06, 2011 - I live in South Texas in Sugar Land. I was going to plant oleanders in my backyard along the fence as a privacy hedge, about 20 feet from my house. However, I was told they were a bad choice becaus...view the full question and answer

Native Texas shrub for privacy screen in hot areaAugust 31, 2007 - Dear Mr. Smarty Plants,
I have a lot facing dead west which I'm sure you can understand is brutally hot in the summer. I'm putting in a pool in my backyard and would like to plant a native Texas...view the full question and answer

Need a fast growing shrub to quickly create a 6' privacy screen in Magnolia, TX.February 28, 2011 - Can you please recommend a fast-growing shrub to quickly create a 6' plus-tall privacy screen in an area with mottled shade along a north/south oriented wrought-iron fence? This is under a canopy of...view the full question and answer

Thoughts on non-native Italian Cypress in AustinJanuary 01, 2014 - I would like to know your thoughts on growing Italian Cypress trees in Austin Texas?
We are looking to create a privacy screen(and prepared to pay more for mature trees to cut down the wait to grow...view the full question and answer

Replacement for Amber Jubilee Ninebark in CaliforniaNovember 22, 2014 - AMBER JUBILEE bush separating my neighbor and me, is spreading its roots into our water pipes. Want to rip out. What plants are root friendly and also give you privacy?view the full question and answer