Autonomy and Motivation

Daniel Pink has identified autonomy as one of the key intrinsic motivators. That is, if we have a complex, creative task to perform (like software development), we enjoy it more if we are given the freedom to make real decisions. From long experience, I have observed that programmers value autonomy almost above anything else. Programming is fundamentally problem-solving - if you put too many restrictions into the process, you rob it of much of it's joy.

Security - no fear of punishment for experimentation and honest mistakes

A clear purpose - an understanding of what one is trying to accomplish

Information - access to relevant facts and sources

These are pretty clear, I think. The opposite approach is known as "micro-management", and it is loathed by programmers. I've known managers who insist on personally inspecting every line of code written by their subordinates. This sort of thing simply destroys motivation.

Does this mean we are left with a free-for-all? Not at all - everyone understands there needs to be boundaries, and these are often captured in standards and practices documents. Ideally these should be negotiated up front, and the relevants parties should "buy in" to whatever boundaries have been established. Then, so long as the boundaries are respected, the programmer ought to have autonomy.

One of the reasons I like Scrum is because it establishes and protects programmer autonomy. In a proper Scrum, the development team must agree to the amount of work to be done in a sprint. Furthermore, once the sprint has started, it is up to the team to implement the functionality as they see fit - neither the Scrum Master nor the Product Owner are permitted to interfere. And teams are highly motivated to complete a piece of work that they voluntarily agreed to - much more so than a schedule that is imposed by fiat.

Granting autonomy is not hard for "Big Picture" people - it is much more difficult, I think, for detail people, who want to know and control every little thing. If you are guilty of micro-management, I'd encourage you to change your course - the impact on motivation will be spectacular.