Too slow to be 7,either have him at 6 or at 9.Give him a Cameron Smith type role and he would excel.

Well, we need a kicking game and he has the best one. I would ask him where he should play and who what would be the best combinations around him, as:A) he seems clever and honest; and he knows more about the game than the England coach. Fwiw, the key question is how to spread our thin talent at 1, 6, 7, 9 and 13 so that we have a kicking game (Sinfield), runners (Sam plus?) and organisers (Widdop?), while finding a way to incorporate Roby. A big disappointment for mine this year has been the lack of development of new English halves. Maybe Powell and O'Brien will be part of the answer in years to come...

Too slow to be 7,either have him at 6 or at 9.Give him a Cameron Smith type role and he would excel.

maybe to slow, but very clever, great organiser and quick thinking.Sam and Gareth as the runners, Roby scooting from dummy half and lockers at 13 I'd be very happy..... its a far better option than chase, brough, lomax or myler @ 7

we need a player with a match winning kicking game, no one else comes close "at present"

Given the need to have Roby in the side, could you not play Burrow and Sinfield in the halves?

As for the outside backs, I would be controversial and put Hardaker at full back ahead of Tomkins (who still struggles with the high ball, disappointing to see), and shift Souper Sam to the wing, playing outside Reed (who I know is injured this Autumn):

Given the need to have Roby in the side, could you not play Burrow and Sinfield in the halves?

As for the outside backs, I would be controversial and put Hardaker at full back ahead of Tomkins (who still struggles with the high ball, disappointing to see), and shift Souper Sam to the wing, playing outside Reed (who I know is injured this Autumn):

Very good SL player but ###### on the International stage and doesnt have the fear or respect to frighten the Aussies that Scully or Faz had. I would put Faz and Scully infront of Sinfield by some distance

You only have to look at his achievments, he would be my first choice, Faz a close second.

Well, we need a kicking game and he has the best one. I would ask him where he should play and who what would be the best combinations around him, as:A) he seems clever and honest; and he knows more about the game than the England coach.Fwiw, the key question is how to spread our thin talent at 1, 6, 7, 9 and 13 so that we have a kicking game (Sinfield), runners (Sam plus?) and organisers (Widdop?), while finding a way to incorporate Roby.