"As if they know. If we did see the devil, they'd be equally spaced across the skull," Brian Kilmeade said.

"They'd be curvy," Elisabeth Hasselbeck said.

And Time also went on the offensive with this: a gallery pointing to numerous cover stars who have gotten so-called "horns," including Pope Francis, Prince Charles and Darth Vader, writing, "Any resemblance to cats, bats or devil horns is entirely coincidental."