Has anyone ever tried them? Did you feel they were helpful improving health of your teeth? Dirty mouth from Primal life organics popped up today and made me curious. It seems quite easy to make my own.

Any difference from what? I never use toothpaste which contains fluoride, so I can only compare other tube brands that are made naturally. I find the tube toothpastes more convenient, but it seems to be the same as homemade.

I feel like the homemade has more control over plaque, as it is more abrasive than the manufactured tube type. Baking soda is only slightly abrasive and dissolves well while brushing, so I guess it is psychological. I suspect the bentonite clay or charcoal is more abrasive, so I would personally stay away from that.