‘Avoid the Ghetto’ App and Pegging Neighborhoods as Dangerous

Critics have dubbed a feature for GPS tools that would direct pedestrians to take alternate routes based on crime and demographic data the “Avoid the Ghetto” app. They say it could redirect people away from low-income or minority neighborhoods, or reinforce stereotypes about such areas. Others say the app makes GPS devices more intelligent by giving people useful information.

According to Microsoft’s patent for the app, which was approved last month, pedestrian routes can be calculated relying on demographic and violent crime data, among other things. The potential result: a pedestrian would be directed to walk a route where violent crime falls below a certain threshold, according to the patent.

Dubbing neighborhoods as “dangerous” can be tricky. Calculating the probability that you’ll be the victim of a crime is actually quite difficult, University of Maryland criminology professor Charles Wellford says. For one, it’s most useful when examined by block, not by an entire neighborhood. That’s because crime is highly localized, partially having to do with the conditions of specific locations, he says. However, calculating an accurate probability by block is difficult because it’s affected by how many people travel there, not just by who lives there.

For example, downtown D.C.’s population swells during the day as commuters increase the city’s daytime population by 73 percent. Is the probability that you’ll be the victim of a crime in downtown D.C. based based on how many people live there? The app patent is unclear on how it would take that into account. Wellford cites another example: he says the “most dangerous” place in San Francisco last weekend was Candlestick Park, where the New York Giants played the San Francisco 49ers.

“Any city that has an NFL team, the day they play at home, there’s a lot of crime around and within the stadium,” he said.

The app could potentially tell you to avoid that area. Depending how the data is used, the app can “paint pictures of communities that aren’t useful or accurate,” Wellford says.

Wellford says there is a “triangle” used to explain most crime: how motivated an offender is, the vulnerability of victims and the “absence of guardianship.” That last point refers to low police presence or having few people around. If an app tells pedestrians to avoid an area, it could potentially mean fewer eyes on the street, making it easier for people to commit crimes.

The other issue has to do with the types of crime. Pedestrians should be interested in the types of crimes that affect them. Victims of armed robberies don’t usually know their assailants, and robberies often happen outdoors, Wellford says. But victims of homicides, sexual assaults and aggravated assaults tend to know their assailants, and such crimes typically happen indoors. Not always, “but a substantial number,” Wellford says.

D.C.’s first and third police districts led the city in total number of crimes, according to 2009 Metropolitan Police Department statistics. Those districts include communities such as downtown, Logan Circle, U Street and Adams Morgan, areas with high concentrations of residents and businesses. The third district also leads the city in robberies. The seventh district, which includes Wards 7 and 8*, has the most homicides. So which areas are “most dangerous,” and for whom?

Figuring out if an area or block feels dangerous can be based on a number of things: personal experience, a gut feeling, stereotypes. Wellford says if the app does provide accurate information, it could be useful in helping people decide whether they want to adjust their behavior, such as walking down a different road.

In the end, such micro-decisions about safety are highly personal. One person may feel safe walking down the street at night in Columbia Heights or Anacostia, while another person wouldn’t. So should you allow an app to change your mind, or is it just a useful tool giving you a suggestion?

*This post originally stated the police department’s seventh district includes Ward 7; it’s in the department’s sixth district.

MORE POSTS ABOUT

Today is my last day as the senior reporter for DCentric. It’s been a little over a year since I started writing for this blog, and I’m blown away at just thinking about all of the interesting topics I’ve had … Read More

Reducing unemployment among D.C.’s young people will help reduce crime, according to a new report by D.C. think tank Justice Policy Institute. The group, whose mission is to lower the incarceration rate, found that neighborhoods with high crime rates also … Read More

Reducing unemployment among D.C.’s young people will help reduce crime, according to a new report by D.C. think tank Justice Policy Institute. The group, whose mission is to lower the incarceration rate, found that neighborhoods with high crime rates also … Read More

Newer Post

Older Post

Obviously, the whole term ‘ghetto’ has become a pejorative word for people of color in our popular lexicon now. I find it rather disgusting to hear people use the term ‘ghetto’ to describe anything in a negative light. This app also lends credence to the labeling of neighborhoods as ‘bad’ areas such as S.E. DC or PG county simply because they have dense minority populations. I can just hear the jokes now-’My app basically says not to drive through any parts of PG County lol!’. I think it’s quite sad and shows we are not ‘post-racial’ as some pundits would like to suggest.

Ward 7 resident

speaking of generalities, lack of information and stereotypes…you might want to revise your statement about Ward 7 being near the 7th district police department by saying “a portion of Ward 7.” As a Ward 7 resident that lives down the street from 6th District headquarters, I’d say you are overgeneralizing that all of East of the River is near 7th District police department. That’s untrue. Such subtleties lend themselves to misinterpretation about EOR communities and policing.

hb

if there is any useful, non-racialized pretext for this app, it is nullified by it highly pejorative name, as a previous commenter noted.

http://dcentric.wamu.org/ Elahe Izadi

Thank you for pointing this out. I’ve updated the post to reflect the correction.

Eeaea

”
This app also lends credence to the labeling of neighborhoods as ‘bad’ areas such as S.E. DC or PG county simply because they have dense minority populations”

Right, it’s because of phone apps and racist white people that these areas are considered ‘bad’. Not because they actually have enormously high crime rates. What sort of mental gymnastics do you have to do to seriously write what you did?

Smith

I’d rather be safe than politically correct. I can’t wait for this App.

About DCentric

DCentric was created to examine the ways race and class interact in Washington, D.C., a city with a vibrant mix of cultures and neighborhoods. Your guide to the changing District is reporter Elahe Izadi.GET IN TOUCH

FOLLOW US

ABOUT THIS SITE

DCentric was created to examine the ways race and class interact in Washington, D.C., a city with a vibrant mix of cultures and neighborhoods. Your guide to the changing District is reporter Elahe Izadi.

IN CASE YOU MISSED IT

The 14th Street NW corridor continues its transformation, as work on luxury condo buildings marches on and announcements of restaurant openings stream in. The older businesses that opened along the strip in the aftermath of the 1968 riots are, one-by-one, closing shop (and getting millions of dollars in exchange for their buildings, if they own them). Some newer businesses are … Continue reading →

The quality of life for the elderly varies by race, and a new report from the Council on Contemporary Families sheds light on how loneliness affects seniors. The report, by the nonprofit, non-partisan group based at University of Miami, found that elderly women are more likely to live alone and face higher poverty rates than men. But … Continue reading →