Tire Rack and ASA wheels / warranty claim

I bought a set of ASA wheels from Tire Rack 90 days ago. I noticed yesterday that one of the wheels is flaking badly. I called the Tire Rack and they offered to send me 4 new wheels and would have someone pick up the old wheels a week later.

So far, I am very pleased with their service. I've ordered two sets of wheels and three sets of tires in the last two years from Tire Rack.

I was getting ready to call Tire Rack to make the arrangements for a warranty pickup and decided to get out another set of ASA wheels from storage to clean them up before putting them up for sale. I noticed that they are also having a surface erosion issue. Instead of flaking, they have squiggly etchings that look like something ate a winding trail through the surface.

I guess I'm done with ASA wheels. As someone noted earlier, you get what you pay for.

The Tire Rack asked me to email photos so they could make a determination of how to proceed. One set is under warranty. The second set is one month out of warranty.

I was getting ready to call Tire Rack to make the arrangements for a warranty pickup and decided to get out another set of ASA wheels from storage to clean them up before putting them up for sale. I noticed that they are also having a surface erosion issue. Instead of flaking, they have squiggly etchings that look like something ate a winding trail through the surface.

I guess I'm done with ASA wheels. As someone noted earlier, you get what you pay for.

The Tire Rack asked me to email photos so they could make a determination of how to proceed. One set is under warranty. The second set is one month out of warranty.

Think I could trade both sets for some nice BBS wheels?

I think I would probably ask if it was me. You might have to pay a little "boot" to do so but I think it's worth it.

I was getting ready to call Tire Rack to make the arrangements for a warranty pickup and decided to get out another set of ASA wheels from storage to clean them up before putting them up for sale. I noticed that they are also having a surface erosion issue. Instead of flaking, they have squiggly etchings that look like something ate a winding trail through the surface.

I guess I'm done with ASA wheels. As someone noted earlier, you get what you pay for.

The Tire Rack asked me to email photos so they could make a determination of how to proceed. One set is under warranty. The second set is one month out of warranty.

Think I could trade both sets for some nice BBS wheels?

I had the same disappointing experience with JH9s with Dunlop WS 3Ds on them. That corrosion that etches through the machined surface, just like little worm trails like you said.
I even did the wheel wax as a preventive treatment after winter and it didn't prevent it. I was ticked (actually still am). I called Doc and he gave me a break on some 18" Bremmer Kraft wheels.

The experience has me telling friends, stay away from ASA!

Tire Rack did the best they could to keep me as a satisfied customer. The BKs are my fourth wheel/tire combo purchase from TR.

Back in 1996 I bought a used set of 3 piece BBS RS for my E30 325is. I have no idea how old the wheels were but they looked fantastic. I drove my car for another 100K miles afterward and the wheels still looked new (with proper care of course). If it wasn't because my nephew destroyed the car (literally) and the wheels, I'm sure those BBS would still be around today looking as good as new. Even used they were expensive, but worth every penny.

On the 2nd set, now out of warranty, this is the explanation I received from Tire Rack about the winding trail of errosion.

"Worm trail corrosion is caused by stone chips in the clear coat. Moisture is then able to get under the clear coat and works its way under the finish making those trails."

They are replacing both sets even though one is a month outside the warranty period. I am awaiting the arrival of the new sets, which I had to pay for (and will receive a credit for), before I return the older sets. I'm assuming that all is well at this point. However, I won't know for sure until they receive the wheels I'm returning and the credit is applied.