The bizarre case of meteors with two identities

Dec 20, 2011

(PhysOrg.com) -- Astronomers have discovered why we see meteors flash through the night sky while they seemingly rain down on us gently at the same time. In a paper published in the December 20 issue of the Astrophysical Journal, models of the zodiacal cloud are reconciled with radar observations, revealing a game of hide and seek and an interesting identity switcheroo.

This detective story was much a case of meteors you can see and those you cant, says lead author and planetary astronomer David Nesvorny of the Southwest Research Institute in Boulder, Colorado.

Meteors are caused by meteoroids that hit the Earths upper atmosphere at astronomical speeds, although some hit slower than others. Out in space, those meteoroids move feverishly between the planets. They are seen as a diffuse glow of scattered sunlight in the night sky, called the zodiacal cloud.

While zodiacal cloud models predict that meteoroids should hit Earth relatively gently, raining down the micro-meteorites that lace the Antarctic snow, radar observations of meteors consistently see the sky filled with rapidly speeding ones, too fast for anything to survive.

How is that possible?, asked Nesvorny and his collaborators. To reconcile things, we improved our model to predict meteor rates and took into account how radars are able to see meteors. And things worked!

The new model showed that radars are nearly blind to slow meteors, but pick up just the right collection of fast meteors to explain what they see in nature.

One bizarre observation remained unexplained. Radars sensitive to small 100 micron sized sporadic meteors see the same speeds and approach directions as those sensitive to meteoroids ten times as big.

That was a conundrum, says meteor astronomer and co-author Peter Jenniskens of the SETI Institute and NASA Ames Research Center. Bigger particles should disappear more quickly. Instead, they seem to survive for about the same time.

In their new paper, Nesvorny and Jenniskens explain why: Meteoroids in the zodiacal cloud are born one way, and then turn into another after shedding most of their plumage.

Meteoroids are born from comets in a fragile form, prone to rapid destruction, most likely from heating and cooling in day-night cycles. These large centimeter-sized meteoroids cause the meteor showers we see at night. Meteoroid streams dont seem to survive for more than a few thousand years, says Jenniskens.

They are broken into pieces a tenth to one millimeter in size that are observed as sporadic meteors by radar and as the diffuse zodiacal cloud in the night sky. It is those meteoroids that survive for almost 100,000 years before they are destroyed by collisions among themselves. The radar data show that small and big ones are destroyed in this way at much the same rate, concludes Nesvorny.

Related Stories

(PhysOrg.com) -- The eerie glow that straddles the night time zodiac in the eastern sky is no longer a mystery. First explained by Joshua Childrey in 1661 as sunlight scattered in our direction by dust particles ...

The annual Perseid meteor shower is coming, and forecasters say it could be unusually good. The shower begins, gently, in mid-July when Earth enters the outskirts of a cloud of debris from Comet Swift-Tuttle. Dust-sized meteoroids ...

Surprising but true: Every day, on average, more than 40 tons of meteoroids strike our planet. Most are tiny specks of comet dust that disintegrate harmlessly high up in Earth's atmosphere, producing a slow ...

Its the finale of this years meteor showers: The Geminids will start appearing on Dec. 7 and should reach peak activity around the 13th and 14th. This shower could put on a display of up to 100+ meteors ...

Recommended for you

Designed to detect the fossil radiation of the universe, the Planck satellite, working in tandem with Herschel, can also help to understand the macrostructure of the universe. A just-published experimental ...

A scene of jagged fiery peaks, turbulent magma-like clouds and fiercely hot bursts of bright light. Although this may be reminiscent of a raging fire or the heart of a volcano, it actually shows a cold cosmic ...

By combining observations of the distant Universe made with ESA's Herschel andPlanck space observatories, cosmologists have discovered what could be the precursors of the vast clusters of galaxies that we ...

Stars form when gravity pulls together material within giant clouds of gas and dust. But gravity isn't the only force at work. Both turbulence and magnetic fields battle gravity, either by stirring things ...

Luke Skywalker's home in "Star Wars" is the desert planet Tatooine, with twin sunsets because it orbits two stars. So far, only uninhabitable gas-giant planets have been identified circling such binary stars, ...

User comments : 1

This article is as clear as mud - to me anyway. Maybe my English has deteriorated.

Bigger particles should disappear more quickly. Instead, they seem to survive for about the same time

Why? Not explained, but one can begin to put it together with the following:

These large centimeter-sized meteoroids cause the meteor showers we see at night. Meteoroid streams dont seem to survive for more than a few thousand years

This then begins to ask why we should be seeing them at all because they should have disappeared over the billions of years of the existence of the solar system. Since it is assumed they come from comets, it presents another problem-comets don't last that long either - and on top of it the Oord cloud is a myth. Hence the conundrum. At least this is how I read this enigma.

Please sign in to add a comment.
Registration is free, and takes less than a minute.
Read more

Click here to reset your password.
Sign in to get notified via email when new comments are made.