REPRESENTING JEWISH COMMUNITIES IN 100 COUNTRIES ACROSS SIX CONTINENTS

Anshel Pfeffer: Azerbaijan, the land of no anti-Semitism - Haaretz

BAKU − “There is no anti-Semitism here and there never has been.” This sentence was repeated to me over and over during my stay this week on the shore of the Caspian Sea. Jews, non-Jews, government officials, dissidents, local residents and Israeli diplomats and rabbis. Not only was this the constant refrain but I don’t remember ever being in a country where I felt so comfortable being identified as an Israeli. And Azerbaijan, in case you were not aware, is 95 percent Muslim, of the Shi’ite variety, and literally down the road − about an hour’s drive from Baku − is the Islamic Republic of Iran.

I was offered a host of reasons for this phenomenon of philo-Semitism. The fact is that Azeris and Jews have lived together in this region for over two and a half millennia, apparently from the first exile after the destruction of Solomon’s temple, and Judaism in these parts preceded the other religions. And as the centuries rolled on, both nations suffered under the imperial rule of the Greeks, Persians, Ottomans and Russia. The Azeris never actually ruled over the Jews.

The last empire, the Soviet one, greatly added to the number of Azerbaijan’s Jews when the dispersion of populations carried out by Joseph Stalin brought at least 100,000 additional Jews, most of them well-educated. As a result, I was told that “nearly everyone who grew up in Baku remembers being treated by a Jewish doctor, studying under Jewish teachers and having a Jewish lawyer take care of their affairs.”

And then of course, not all Shiites are Hezbollah, a great many of them believe that the cult of Ali actually calls upon them to be tolerant to the members of other religions and anyway, even before the communists came and forced upon them godlessness, the Azerbaijanis were predominantly secular.

Their friendliness toward Israelis can be easily explained by the fact that Israel was one of the first countries to recognize Azerbaijani independence in 1991 and the two countries have built a formidable strategic alliance ‏(more about this elsewhere in this paper‏).

And still all these reasons don’t add up to a full explanation of how over 100 generations in which in neighboring lands pogroms and expulsions were regular occurrences and in later times evolved into virulent anti-Zionism, the land of the Azeris remained a safe haven. To this day, President IlhamAliyev is a frequent visitor to the Jewish community centers − he even gave money for a Sefer Torah and directed that the government finance the rebuilding of a synagogue.

There was another question, though, that bothered me even more. This wasn’t a peaceful land. Not far away the war of Nagorno-Karabakh was waged less than 20 years ago, and with it ethnic cleansing on both sides of Armenians and Azerbaijanis. When such hatreds are playing out, Jews have rarely remained unscathed. And even with the fighting reduced to a trickle in recent years, Azerbaijan had hardly become a shining beacon of democracy. Huge oil revenues began coming in as new offshore wells were discovered, but instead of benefiting the entire society, it merely served to bolster a kleptocratic regime which beats up demonstrators, arbitrarily jails journalists and dissidents and fixes election results.

As a firm believer in the rule that a litmus test of the human rights situation in a country is how it treats its Jews, I began to wonder whether that rule is still true in countries like Azerbaijan ‏(and Putin’s Russia‏), where the autocratic leader uses his security forces to fight against anti-Semitism, allows the Jewish community to run its own state schools and contributes to the community from his own pocket ‏(though, of course, it’s not really his own‏).

Can a dictator be bad for his people and at the same time good for his Jews? And what if he is doing so in the hope of receiving the backing of the 'Jewish lobby' in Washington?

Frustrated, I looked up Azerbaijan’s record in the websites devoted to monitoring anti-Semitism across the globe. I’m not a great fan of these sites as they tend to magnify the trivial and miss the real trends, but I had little choice. They seemed to bear out what I had been hearing − there were remarkably few incidents and those that had taken place were dealt with swiftly by the authorities. They seemed to be mainly nasty conspiracy theories put out by marginal politicians from fringe Islamist or crypto-communist parties. There was a pattern here: Anti-Semitism in Azerbaijan is something that comes from the opposition.

According to the Coordination Forum for Countering Anti-Semitism, no anti-Semitic incidents whatsoever were reported in Azerbaijan in 2012, and only one in 2011 − the Jewish-Russian journalist Vladimir Solovyov received anti-Semitic hate-mail from Azerbaijanis after he had criticized Azerbaijan Airlines’ refusal to allow an Armenian passenger on one of its flights.

I probably shouldn’t extrapolate from one isolated case, but it seems that Jews are tolerated and protected when they are acting in the role of loyal Azeri citizens. What would happen if they joined the ranks of the real opposition, that which is not allowed even to win a few seats in the tame parliament?

Throughout the annals of Diaspora, Jews have adopted a policy of not giving the ruler undue reason to resent them. That finally began to change in the 20th century when Jews were at the frontline of freedom and human rights movements. From Jews fighting apartheid in South Africa that didn’t feel they had to remain on the sidelines or else they would be inviting persecution of their community, to Jews taking part in the civil rights movement in the US, to Jews advocating an end to the monarchy in Britain, they felt free to represent unpopular views without worrying about wider repercussions.

I do not grudge the Jews of Baku their safety and prosperity, but it seems that they know their place, with the gallery of pictures hanging in the synagogue foyer of President Aliyev lighting Hanukkah candles and meeting ShimonPeres. The real test will come when a sizable group of young Jewish men and women join the growing protest movement against Aliyev: Will the community still deserve his protection then?

Ultimately, the real guarantee for a minority’s security can only be democracy, not the good will of a corrupt and despotic dictator.

We welcome any comments you may have on this article.
Comments are moderated and we reserve the right to edit or remove any which are derogatory or offensive.
The WJC is not responsible for the content of any comments.

“The notion that a figure such as Stepan Bandera – a Nazi collaborator during the Second World War who is deeply controversial within Ukrainian society and beyond – will be celebrated in this way is deeply troubling."

Rona Ramon was a brave and courageous woman, who taught an entire nation how to gracefully and nobly contend with the greatest griefs. Following the great disasters that took the lives of her husband and child, Mrs. Ramon dedicated her own life to helping others live theirs – not only coping, but also rising from pain and sorrow.

“We are extremely concerned by the steady rise of antisemitic vandalism facing the Jewish community in Greece and elsewhere in Europe. This desecration, as well as the vandalization of cemeteries in Poland and in France in the past week alone, should ring alarm bells for anyone who believes that these incidents are isolated and passing.

The attack is “shocking and dismaying in itself, made all the more distressing by the fact that it took place on Yom Kippur, evoking the terrible tragedies that occurred in German-occupied Poland during the years of the Holocaust,” WJC President Ronald Lauder said.

Cookies allows us to recognise and remember visitors to our website. Cookies are used for various purposes and you can choose which types to accept below. Not allowing cookies may effect the way you are able to interact with the WJC website. Our detailed Cookie Policy can be found here.

Mandatory cookies help make this website usable by enabling basic functions like page navigation and access to secure areas of the website. Our website cannot function properly without these cookies.

Statistics cookies

Statistic cookies help us understand how visitors interact with this website, for example seeing which pages are most popular. This information is collected anonymously and helps us improve the site by making the most sought after information easy to find.

Marketing cookies

Marketing cookies are used to track visitors across websites allowing the display of ads that are relevant and engaging for the visitor. Whilst we do not display any advertising on the WJC website, allowing marketing cooking may allow other sites to see that you have visited our site.