I talked to Loot Crate who told me “The oven mitt is a known issue. It was tested to 500 degrees and we are more than happy to replace any defective gloves. In the scope of the number of units we shipped out the number of issues we’ve seen is less than 0.1%”

Which isn’t great if you are that 0.1%. But it is good to know that there is another option if yours ends up looking like Nick Borelli’s…