Time for Arsene Wenger to move upstairs?

Scarcely had Arsene Wenger been eulogised by a leading sports columnist that he was under fire for his controversial decision to take off Olivier Giroud, his top scorer and chief potential threat to Chelsea’s defence, after his German centre-back Per Mertesacker had been sent off for a clumsy foul.

“Wenger panicked,” wrote one reporter. “Substituting his obvious goal threat and sending on Gabriel to partner Laurent Koscielny was a baffling call.”

A baffled Olivier Giroud is replaced by Gabriel.

In essence, arguably, a sort of surrender. True, Theo Walcott, named captain for the day, could thus fill his preferred role as centre forward, but it didn’t work. Walcott, for all his virtues, doesn’t present the sheer physical challenge and menace in the air offered by Giroud, who went off looking unsurprisingly baffled.

It might have made more sense taking off Walcott himself, though I could make little sense of the opinion cited here and there that making Walcott captain at all weakened Arsenal’s challenge. With very few exceptions, football’s captains have no more than a cosmetic role. Leadership, for better or worse, tends to come from the bench.

Wenger beyond doubt has had a remarkable role at Arsenal, whom he joined from Japan in 1996. In contrast, Herbert Chapman, who surely has the strongest claim to be the Gunners’ most influential manager, reigned only from 1925 to his premature death in 1934.

Wenger in the past – and even in the past two FA Cup final-winning seasons – has amassed a profusion of trophies. But two seasons ago, shocking defeats by Chelsea, Manchester United and Liverpool would have cost any equivalent Italian club manager his job.

And this season, in the European Champions Cup, the rash decision to pick David Ospina in goal at home to Olympiakos instead of the supremely reliable Petr Cech – an inspired purchase by Wenger, even at £10m – cost the Gunners the game. Somehow or other they limped through their qualifying group despite a humiliating 5-1 thrashing at Bayern Munich.

Arsenal’s board is so firmly behind Wenger that there seems no prospect of him leaving, though perhaps ideally he should move marginally upstairs while a younger coach sits on the bench.

Free Newsletter

Sign up to our free newsletter to get the latest updates from WorldSoccer.

Please keep me up to date with special offers and news from World Soccer and other brands operated by TI Media Limited via email. You can unsubscribe at any time.

We'd also like to send you special offers and news just by email from other carefully selected companies we think you might like. Your personal details will not be shared with those companies - we send the emails and you can unsubscribe at any time. Please tick here if you are happy to receive these messages.