The Methodist rectory was once housed in the old Chadwick homestead.
In 1917 the rectory was remodeled as headquarters for Fire Insurance Patrol
No. 4. The facade of this flat-roofed, brick structure had two windows,
a centered door and a garage door on the first floor, and three pairs of
windows on the two upper floors.

Sources:

GHS: Historic Buildings Box 1, "Houses 1958" folder: part
of this building is visible to the left in a photograph with the caption
"Typical of early Germantown farmhouses is this sturdy dwelling at
54 E. Haines St. The doorway...."