Re: Can a Crit "Crit" ?

Originally Posted by Shibba

nope i dont have any scroling combat text addons, so it shows each hit seperatly...
i also opened my recount during the fight and hovered over MB and max crit was 16k... few sec later i got the other 24k one... and recount updated acordingly :/

i asked other priests in guild noone ever saw it happen... so i got puzzeled and decided to ask here.

this makes me think you're lying, and i'm sure you're not being honest about something

you said that the 16 and 24k crits were "a few seconds apart"

but you took time, mid-fight, to open recount (you said you opened it) and saw the 16k crit "then a few seconds later the 24k crit, which recount updated accordingly"

i call BS, if you double checked it as it happened, in the middle of a boss fight, then you were already thinking OMG WTF but then you "accidentally deleted it"

Re: Can a Crit "Crit" ?

That recount must be from more than just Lord Jaraxxus. There is no way in hell you did ~7M dmg on him alone.
736 VT ticks ~ 2208secs=37mins of combat, he would enrage 5times by then, so it has to be from twins.

"There's a difference between us. You think the people of this country exist to provide you with position. I think your position exists to provide those people with freedom. And I go to make sure that they have it."
- William Wallace

Re: Can a Crit "Crit" ?

this makes me think you're lying, and i'm sure you're not being honest about something

you said that the 16 and 24k crits were "a few seconds apart"

but you took time, mid-fight, to open recount (you said you opened it) and saw the 16k crit "then a few seconds later the 24k crit, which recount updated accordingly"

i call BS, if you double checked it as it happened, in the middle of a boss fight, then you were already thinking OMG WTF but then you "accidentally deleted it"

c'mon

no, a crit is a crit is a crit

and yes he had to give whole night log coz we had to many attempts after lord jaxx...

i can see your point that n twins this is easyly doable... i have no argument about that

yet i still saw the 16k and the 24k from jax fight, which brings me to my very first post when i said i had no proof of it and asked do not start this BS...
some thing strange "never happens" ppl only lie in this world...

Re: Can a Crit "Crit" ?

Originally Posted by Shibba

and yes he had to give whole night log coz we had to many attempts after lord jaxx...

i can see your point that n twins this is easyly doable... i have no argument about that

yet i still saw the 16k and the 24k from jax fight, which brings me to my very first post when i said i had no proof of it and asked do not start this BS...
some thing strange "never happens" ppl only lie in this world...

Re: Can a Crit "Crit" ?

Couple of things...

1. MB has a 5.5 sec CD at best, so there is no way there were 2 simultaneous MBs
2. It's a bug with recount, I suggest you update your version. I too had an issue where my recount log was giving me higher damage than what actually was occuring. My log told me I had VT crits of 10K on Jaraxxus but when I mentioned this to the other spriest in the raid his recount said something different. Then after refreshing the information in recount it normalised back to what actually happened. After that night I updated the version and it hasn't happened again.

Re: Can a Crit "Crit" ?

Originally Posted by Jimbo2345

sounds the most logical reason in my view, my MSCT shows when that stuff happens

This happens when 2 same abilities comes at the same time (like Hunter's Lock&Load with 3 shots in a row) or when 1 abilitiy does multiple damage (Dots on multiple mobs, Chain Lightning) Mind Blast has a cooldown so it's impossible for any Combat Test addon to sum them up at the same time.