First he offered Frank Francisco for Madison Bumgarner. I countered with Lance Lynn for Aroldis Chapman. His current offer is Chapman for Jordan Zimmerman. Baseball monster has Chapman currently ranked 15th in our league format and Zimmerman 64th.But I just can't wrap my head around the idea of Chapman being more valuable. I know Chapman could be a Starter someday. But being realistic there's gotta be some regression due on his current stats, right?

My trading Partner's Pitching StaffNolascoHumberHansonPorcelloNeftali FelizSamardzjiaJurrjens(minors)Pineda(DL)Minor Leaguers TallionPaxtonMontgomerySo I guess my question is would you do Zimmerman for Chapman Straight up in a dynasty league, or would you ask for some additional Starting Pitching in return