The Younger actress and her personal trainer have called it quits just two months after going public with their romance, a source confirms to PEOPLE.

“They weren’t on the same page,” a second source tells PEOPLE. “He wants to move to New York, but her life is in L.A.”

Duff, 29, confirmed their relationship in October when she shared an adorable black-and-white photo of the pair kissing on Instagram — marking the first time the actress confirmed she was dating the trainer on social media.