The Twelve Lives of Samuel Hawley by Hannah Tinti | Review

The Twelve Lives of Samuel Hawley by Hannah TintiPublisher: The Dial PressRelease Date: March 28, 2017Length: 400 pagesBuy on Amazon

Single Sentence Summary: Samuel Hawley’s teenage daughter, Loo, is just beginning to put together the pieces about her father’s dark history – his very dark history.

Primary Characters: Samuel Hawley – Samuel has been a lot of things in his life: a desperate teenager, a common thief, a killer, a loving husband, a father, a protector. Loo Hawley – A brilliant girl, teenage Loo finds herself settled for the first time and it’s in the town where her mother grew up. Questions inevitably follow.

Synopsis: For as long as she can remember Loo and her father have led a life on the move. Their homes? Motels. Their stays? Weeks to months. Her schooling? Sporadic. Their traveling companions? Guns, rifles, a licorice jar stuffed with money, and a bear skin rug. As Loo reaches her teens, Samuel wants to give her a more normal life, so settles them both in Olympus, Massachusetts where Loo’s mother grew up. Such a huge life change brings with it questions: questions about her mother, questions about their life on the run, and most of all questions about Samuel, for he is the biggest unknown in Loo’s life.

Review: The Twelve Lives of Samuel Hawley, Hannah Tinti’s new book, is definitely one of my favorites this year. She did a masterful job of combining a coming-of-age story with a dark mystery. The chapters alternated between Samuel’s past and the life Loo and Samuel shared in Olympus. Samuel’s life unfolded through the bullet wounds on his body. Each scar revealed a little more about the man that he was and the life of crime he’d chosen for himself. The other chapters focused more on Loo and her reactions to being the new girl in her mother’s hometown. But, the more Loo learned the more questions she had about Samuel and his dark past.

It’s easy to love a book when you love the characters and I was crazy about both Samuel and Loo in The Twelve Lives of Samuel Hawley. Taking an objective look at Samuel Hawley, there really is far more to dislike than to like. He was a criminal and a killer. The choices he’d made spilled over into the lives of the people he loved most, his wife, Lily, and his daughter, Louise. Somehow, Tinti managed to give this man redeeming qualities so that I couldn’t help but care about Samuel. He was a man in pain who, above all else, loved and wanted to protect his daughter.

“Hawley told her it was her mother’s hometown…..A normal life, Hawley said. With a real house and a neighborhood and friends her own age and a school where she could find a place to belong.”

Loo captivated me even more than Samuel. This was a girl who’d led a life on the run, and the transition to “normal” was not an easy one for Loo. She was different than most kids and making friends was not a skill she’d ever learned. Loo had holes in her life, the biggest being her mother. She’d only known Lily through Samuel and the small shrine he built to her in the bathroom everywhere they had lived. As a teen walking the same streets her mother had, Loo’s appetite for details about Lily could not be quenched, and Samuel couldn’t give her more. When she looked to others for answers, Loo began to see her father with fresh eyes. What she saw slowly eroded their bond.

“Loo watched him shoulder the rifle and understood, in a flickering moment, that her father was exactly that – a professional. All the guns in their house. All the scars on his body. All the ways that he was careful. It was because of this.”

Hannah Tinti’s writing was truly magnificent. She didn’t judge her characters, but treated them with empathy. She gave reasons for Sam’s actions without excusing them. In Loo she created a character that elicited both sympathy and hope. I’m predicting that The Twelve Lives of Samuel Hawley will be high on my list of top books for 2017! Grade: A

If you liked this book you might also enjoy:

Dear Fang, With Love by Rufi Thorpe – Another coming-of-age story that centers on a father-daughter relationship. Dear Fang, With Love also has some dark edges to it, but in a much different way. (My review here.)

The God of Animals by Aryn Kyle – Another story of a young girl, Alice, trying to make sense of her family. The God of Animals is set on a horse boarding ranch in a desert community.

Close Your Eyes, Hold Hands by Chris Bohjalian – In this 16-year old Emily is left to fend for herself after the nuclear power plant her parent’s helped run experiences a massive meltdown. The world is furious, but Emily still loves her parents.

Note: I received a copy of this book from the publisher (via NetGalley) in exchange for my honest review.

Disclosure: There are Amazon Associate links included within this post.

I called this one a love story in my own review because that is what I think it ultimately is. Hawley is scary and should be so easy to dislike given his past, but man, can you imagine him as your husband or father? A man who can pretty much do it all and who is willing to risk all so you will be happy without suffocating you or demanding reciprocity? It is so difficult to find a man like that despicable. And Loo! Oh, I just wanted to hug and protect her, even though she would have just kicked me with her boots. So much to love in this story!

I liked this one but I think I was expecting something different. My favorite part was the beginning and I struggled a bit in the middle. I also read it in a hospital, which might have influenced my experience… Amazing review <3 Mine will also be published today