Jon Stewart’s Replacement: 7 Reasonable Candidates

Tuesday night, Jon Stewart announced he’ll leave his role as host of The Daily Show later this year, a position he’s held since 1999. The franchise will continue (Stewart wasn’t the show’s first host, after all), and we all know what that means: cue the listicles!

Everyone and their dog is making a list of replacements, most of which read like an “anyone living or dead” fantasy dinner party list. (Is Jesus available? He’s with WME, right?)

But because there’s nothing better than a speculative pile-on, here’s a slightly more rational look at the options to fill Stewart’s shoes.

1) Bassem Youssef

It’s not a question of whether he’d be right for the job — it’s whether he’d take it. Youssef is often called the “Egyptian Jon Stewart” for hosting his own satirical news show there, but he also has the same playfully sharp appeal as Stewart. He’s done great in the Daily Showguest chair, and killed it in his own segment just this past Monday night. The two fake newsmen deeply admire each other, and it’s hard to imagine Stewart being more honored to pass the baton to anyone else. But Youssef is a star in the Middle East. Would he want to uproot his family to New York to face a new audience that, for the most part, doesn’t know him?

2) Wanda Sykes

3) John Fugelsang

The comedian and SiriusXM host has paid his dues in other television hosting roles (remember him on the TVGuide Channel?), and has been holding his own in the political commentary arena since the days of Politically Incorrect. The choice wouldn’t quell the accusations that the Daily Show is a mouthpiece for the left, but at the same time we all kinda love hearing Fox News anchors bellyache, don’t we?

4) Samantha Bee and/or Jason Jones

Jones filled in for Stewart one night last fall, and did as good a job (with Bee at his side for part of it) as any previous correspondent substitute. Bee is the veteran correspondent of the two, by a hair. And as a married couple, one has to imagine the possibilities of a tag-team hosting duo. The argument is the same for either or both: they have seniority and the recognition factor among viewers. But have they been invested enough in the show’s day-to-day operations to take on the showrunner role as well? Their comfort in being correspondents could be a reason why John Oliver and Larry Wilmore have come and gone during their tenure.

5) John Mulaney

Fans petitioned for him to get the Weekend Update chair when Seth Meyers left Saturday Night Live, and while that didn’t work out, it was easy to picture him behind a fake news anchor desk. The Daily Show needs a sharp writer, and Mulaney is certainly that, despite not being known as a political guy. Besides, it’s very likely that by the end of this season of Mulaney, he’ll be a free agent.

6) Greg Proops

As his podcast title states, he may very well be the Smartest Man in the World. (If anything, he could be too intellectual for the gig.) He’s never at a loss for words when ranting about current events, we already know he looks good in a suit, and audiences already know him from his decades of standup and his run as a regular on Whose Line Is It Anyway? A dark horse for sure, but a name worth pondering.

7) Jessica Williams

Not since John Oliver had a new Daily Show correspondent found their legs – and a following – so quickly. She has the point of view and likeability to sit in the host chair on-air, so there’s a reason why she’s popping up on lists like these. But despite her performing chops, she’s still a kid at 25, and may not be ready to fill the showrunner role.

8) Sen. Al Franken

This was a list of seven reasonable choices, people. I just didn’t want to be left out of the make-an-absurd-suggestion trend.

9) Craig Kilborn

About the Author

Sharilyn Johnson is the author of the book Bears & Balls: The Colbert Report A-Z. Called "one of the city’s most discriminating comedy critics” by NOW Magazine, Sharilyn has been covering comedy for longer than she cares to admit. She served as the comedy reporter for Winnipeg's Uptown Magazine for five years, and was the host of the radio show Laugh Tracks for three seasons. Her work has also appeared in the Toronto Star, the Winnipeg Free Press, The Apiary, and on CBC Radio's national comedy programs LOL and Definitely Not the Opera.

3 Responses to Jon Stewart’s Replacement: 7 Reasonable Candidates

How about John Oliver? I’ve seen much discussion (admittedly, from armchair viewers who don’t analyze the comedy business like Third Beat does) who have tossed his name as either a sure thing or an “anybody but” (no real middle ground). Your opinion on Oliver? (Myself, being one of those aforementioned “armchair viewers” who, admittedly, hasn’t watched the show that much, I’m familiar with Oliver and think it could take the show in a familiar, yet interesting direction.)

I’ll address Oliver and Wilmore in the same breath, because I think the situation is similar. Both those guys would’ve known that Jon was on his way out. That “restless” feeling has been apparent to me as a viewer for about a year, and I’m not even connected to the show. Knowing that, they both opted to accept their own shows. What does that say? I don’t entirely know the answer to that. But it’s something to consider.

Oliver in particular would be perfect, as far retaining viewers, retaining staff, and refreshing the show to integrate the longer-form pieces he’s become known for. But I feel like it won’t happen. HBO will want to hold onto him, and he’s built his own thing with his own staff… Does he want to go back to being referred to as “Jon Stewart’s replacement” for god knows how many years? He’s in a good place right now.

Ah, but that’s my problem with Youssef. He’s got a good gig now, being the Egyptian Jon Stewart, why should he give that up just because we need an American Jon Stewart? And I’m pretty sure that if he did take the Daily Show job, Youssef’s shoes would be a lot harder to fill in Egypt than Jon’s shoes were here, I don’t think the Egyptian version of Third Beat would have even 3 obvious choices to fill his shoes there. It seems like giving us occasional spots of Youssef to show us how good he is gives him the best of both possible worlds, building fame and reputation in his homeland while bringing them the best satire possible (and not depriving them of it if he left), while introducing us to him and letting us know how awesome he is.