Leading Catholic Journalist Addresses the Role of Catholic Media in the Challenges Facing the Church Today

Catholic news media might be the remedy for three of the greatest challenges facing the church in the United States today, according to a leading Catholic journalist who spoke on January 30 at St. Charles Borromeo Seminary in suburban Philadelphia. Greg Erlandson, director and editor-in-chief of Catholic News Service, delivered the Cardinal John Foley Lecture for about 50 attendees at the seminary, including Philadelphia Archbishop Charles J. Chaput.

In his talk, Erlandson recalled the words of Cardinal Foley that could be considered the mission statement of Catholic communicators. Media professionals, the cardinal said only weeks before his death in 2011, have a “sacred bond” with media consumers.
“They look to you for information, for formation, for inspiration,” the cardinal said at the time, repeating a theme he had offered Catholic journalists many times in his long ministry in the church and in the Catholic press. Foley supported and encouraged generations of Catholic journalists, and his words still apply to the issues facing Catholics and journalists today, Erlandson suggested.

He offered context to his talk titled “The Power of the Word: Catholic News Media and Spiritual Formation” by describing three crises in the church today.
“My conversations with Catholics around the country suggest that they are unaware … of the challenges we face now and will face ‘in extremis’ in the near future,” Erlandson said. First, an aging priesthood faces a “demographic cliff” that in coming years will not have enough active priests to sustain parish life in the United States as it is structured today. “Each year an average of about 400 new priests are ordained nationwide, while an average of 1,500 retire or die,” Erlandson said.

He also cited the decline in sacramental marriage as well as baptism and the reception of other sacraments, driven largely by divorce and remarriage outside the church.
Lastly, Erlandson described the dearth of Catholic faith formation for children and especially of adults. Citing a statistic that only 15 percent of Catholic school-age children attend a Catholic school and despite valiant efforts of volunteer religious educators in parish programs, “nearly everyone agrees that many Catholic parents are too distracted, undereducated in the faith or broken to assume their role as ‘primary educators’ of their children,” he said. Putting it bluntly, Erlandson said two generations of parents “have been educated primarily in, at best, 40-minute class sessions 20 or so weeks a year from first through eighth grades or until confirmation, whichever comes first. Too many of them are, in terms of their religious IQ, children inhabiting adult bodies.”
It has been said that Catholics today are the best educated in the history of the church, but “in this country, this applies to their MDs and their MBAs, not to their religious education,” Erlandson said.

If Catholic families are the building blocks of parishes that are stressed by a gap in clergy resources, then a “parish- and family-centered religious education system” is sorely needed, he said. “At this point the greatest strategic need facing the church may be in the area of adult faith formation and education.” Erlandson suggested Catholic media including television, radio, digital and print publications may best address the need to form lay Catholics to accept the leadership roles they will increasingly need to take in the church.

Catholic news and commentary can inform Catholics on the issues of the day by “helping them to see reality through Catholic eyes,” Erlandson said, adding the church “needs a voice to tell the stories that are not being told, or not being told well, and it needs a voice to mobilize Catholics.” Secular media might not present issues such as the Health and Human Services contraceptive mandate, health care reform, immigration reform or the Christian diaspora in the Middle East with the Catholic perspective that offers not propaganda but the truth of the Gospel. “The regular appearance of a Catholic publication with news, analysis, columns and features in a virtual or actual mailbox does more to help form more adult Catholics than any other method or tool,” Erlandson said.
Catholic news media’s stories of ordinary people striving in extraordinary ways for holiness have an undeniable power “to show that what God asks of us, what the church teaches, can be lived out in the real world,” he said. “It is being done. And the lesson is that we can do it too.”

Just as secular media are experiencing seismic changes in their business model and even in their quality, the Catholic press is also under great stress “but it remains a vital and valuable tool in service to the church,” Erlandson said.
“It needs the resources to flourish and to fulfill its role to inform, to form and to inspire, particularly at this time when other institutions of the church, especially the parish, are facing equally daunting challenges and are in need of a well-formed laity.”
And while he pointed out “print is not dead” and delivering a publication into homes remains “the ultimate push technology,” he also acknowledged social media, video, print and digital all are tools the church can use to preach the Gospel “and to reach modern men and women effectively.”