Damn you guys have more balls than me. I had doom 3 on my pc and i go to the part when i had to go investigate why this place waaayy out on the edge of the base went dark and i was like HELL NO!! Never played again! (I dont do horror)

I didn't find Catherine scary at all. If you want scary/creepy then look to Amy, it's a darn good game.

it had some nice suspension to it, but I was never really scared either. Best attempt I have played so far tbh.

The penumbra series is supposed to be scary aswell, but haven`t tried it myself so can`t really say much more than that.

Key thing is with horror games is that you have to be in the right kind of mood. Let yourself dwell in it so immersion factor is much higher. Good sound, shut off the lights, and just focus. It usually works, if not, take some shrooms or light it up. lol

I do too. DOOM 1 and 2 are not scary at all. They are quite humorous to me.

Dead Space made made me crap myself more than once, especially in the med lab area where the main lights go out and some pulsating lights go on. All hell breaks loose in there.. To many times have I crapped myself in that game.

Amnesia loses its scares ones you realize that for most of the game, there's just you and the dark.

This. I mean the monsters are broad casted so aggressively I found it hard to not avoid the monster. Searching room for item, Oh noes the monster coming after you, Keep searching the room. Monster walks in on opposite side of the room, follow it around the room keeping to it's back, it leaves, music stops, I leave.

I can understand him a bit. Amnesia to me wasn't scary at all. I don't like the feeling of helplessness there from the start but rather a build up of it. Silent Hill is a great example. Sure you have a gun but teh deeper into the game you get, the more the town itself screws with you leaving you to feel insignificant. For me, I prefer that over the straight anxiety Amnesia had to offer.

As far as Dead Space goes, I loved both games but never found them scary. I jumped once or twice but the fear wasn't really there for me. And Doom... finding a portal to Hell on Mars is an odd plot. I could never take it seriously.