I remember on the beach dinner we had fillet minion, lobster tail, mashed potatoes and veggies...I have the menu somewhere...but not sure where it is! We also had a really good soup to start (can't remember what it was though) and an assortment of desserts. I can tell you it was awesome and would 100% do it iagain!

we did the island dinner. it was beautiful and sweet. we chose this over the beach because the menu seemed significantly better.
would we do it again, probably not-but only because it was not an everytime affordable option. i completely recommend that you do it once though. it was delicious, special, and the service was really worth it!
what a great way to spend resort credits!!!!!!