So, that's a bit like saying that if you think that even a single line in SW sucks, you aren't a fan. Oh wait, that is what you're saying. Then I guess there are no true Star Wars fans in existence. If that is the case, then why does this site exist?

But here we don't have any original movie to compare to. Maybe it would just be crappy no matter what

You have to greatest book on the world, isn't that enough?
And as for the Movie...
[link=http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/The_Lord_of_the_Rings_%281978_film%29]Bakshi's film[/link]
[link=http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/The_Return_of_the_King_%281980_movie%29]Return of the King[/link]

Thus, maybe Bakshi's movie lacks of visualisation, has much better storyline and much better sticks to the book. As for the Return of the king, I haven't seen it.

Well... maybe it's not that good, but it's better than Jackson's there's no Aerwern dreaming about child, no "Isildur - the last king of Gondor" and so on I haven't seen any elves in helms Deep either.

I watched all the movies, though not all of them together in one day. The Saga looks different now. It is more brilliant that ever before. And when watching OT again, there is this extraordinary feeling. It all makes you love Star Wars even more!