2 358 Y.Köksal&O.Dema / An Investigation of the Essential Factors on Customer Loyalty in Banking Sector: A Case Albanian Retail Bank providing a wide range of services and increasing the customer services by leveraging their service standards and technologies (Shinde, 2011) in Albania as well. To increase their economic lines, they are continuously looking at ways of reaching organic growth through acquisition of new customers and retaining existing customers (Ramkelawon et al, 2010). The customer retention depends directly on the service quality and customer loyalty. Customer loyalty is the certain attitude and behavior that customers show (Szűts & Tóth, 2008). Customer loyalty can be obtained if companies listen to their clients and understand customer needs and make right decisions in this regard to please them (Buttle, 2009). Banks should offer to customers more than their expectations, and anticipate their needs and fulfill them (Malfa 2007). According to Winer (2001), to reach this purpose, new and different tools and mindset are required. Giving importance to human and organizational resources as much as technological capabilities is necessary to manage good relationships with the customers (Keramati 2008). Surviving in today's competitive environments require a heart to understand the customers; a brain to analyze; and hands to deliver the products to them (Ghahfarokhi and Zakaria 2009). To describe effective factors on customer loyalty, the literature studies have been examined of different authors from different countries and five factors described that have positive and significant relationship with customer loyalty. The service factor plays an important role on customer loyalty in banking sector and was studied by Hinson et.al, (2006), Fragata and Gallego, (2009), Hafeez and Muhammad, (2012), Tariq and Moussaoui, (2009), Kheng et.al, (2010), Titko and Lace, (2010), Gan et.al, (2011), Siddiqi (a), (2011), Siddiqi (b), (2011), Monsef et al, (2012) and Mohsin et.al, (2012), Security was emphasized as an important factor by Kheng et.al, (2010), Relationship was studied by Akhter et.al, (2011), Reliability is perceived as substantial for clients in banking sector Kheng et, al, (2010), Annamalah et.al, (2011), Hassan et.al,, (2012) and. Loyalty was previously studied by (Tariq and Moussaoui, 2009, Afsar et al, 2010, Annamalah et.al, 2011 and Siddiqi(a), (2011), Siddiqi (b), 2011; Mohsan et.al, 2011; Ghazizadeh et.al, 2010), Staff, today is considered as an important asset of banking sector and was studied by (Mylonakis, 2009). The aim of this study is to measure and demonstrate efficiency of each factor on customer loyalty and their effects on banking sector in Albania. Finding the answer of the question that; which factor is most efficient on customer loyalty? will be main purpose of this study. In this regard theoretical background will be examined, then collected data analyzed. In order to bring out the efficiency of each factor, confirmatory factor analysis method will be conducted. 2. Theoretical Background and Hypotheses In the marketing approaches and applications, attention has shifted to loyalty. Customer loyalty has been among main focuses of marketing strategies. It provides exceptional advantages and opportunities to companies by customer retention and cost reduction. We know that the cost of acquiring a new customer

3 Yönetim ve Ekonomi 21/1 (2014) is five to ten folds more costly or expensive than to continue the business with the existing customers (Gray and Byun 2001). Customer loyalty is the willingness of clients to be faithful to a company. This means, even if the company makes any minor mistake, customers will still maintain loyal and do not switch them. According to Kincaid et.al, (2003) customer loyalty is a positive experience and value, which even if the decision is not the most rational, customers still keep willingness buying and maintaining the relations with the company. At the moment, customers became loyal to a company, obviously repeat buying and also referrals will be increased and also the revenue and the market share will be increased. Meanwhile, they do free marketing by word of mouth while they are enthusiastic. Thus, customers become your protectors. At the time, the superior value is delivered to the customers; it also increases the employee s loyalty as they feel pride and become an important asset to the company. The aim should be to build long-term relationship with customers, and to pay more attention on the loyalty of the existing customers rather than gaining new ones Service satisfaction in banking sector Service quality is comprehended by customers as the difference of expected service and the received one (Dhandabani, 2010). Service quality of banks is one of the most important elements for customer satisfaction and loyalty. Customers consider service satisfaction as a reason of establishing long-term relationship with the bank and also it is a crucial success element that affects the competitiveness of the bank. One way for banks to differ from competitors is by offering high quality service. To survive in this intense competitive market structure, banks should develop some capabilities and strategies to increase satisfaction of their customers (Siddiqi et.al, 2011). Service quality is an important element that makes difference companies to success or fails (Mishra et al, 2010). In this respect, the hypothesis; H1: There is a significant relationship between service satisfaction and customer loyalty Security Security is essential to every trade and especially in banking sector where clients leave their money based on promises done (Knell and Stix, 2009). Gaining customers trust and making them feel secure have a great influence on the bank performance. Absolutely the banks should be very reliable in its any decision. The essential thing is not only to be reliable and trustworthy, but also trustful to their customers and to develop a win- win relationship with them. What customer expects from the bank is to listen, care and deal with their problems (Bell, 2000). By customers, witnessed weaknesses of the bank spread very quickly among customer. In order to save and increase market share, banks should pay attention their reputation and image as well (Hassan et. al, 2012) and they don t damage their positive intangible possessions such as trustworthiness. In this regard, the hypothesis; 359

4 360 Y.Köksal&O.Dema / An Investigation of the Essential Factors on Customer Loyalty in Banking Sector: A Case Albanian Retail Bank H2: There is a significant relationship between security and customer loyalty Relationship Customer relationship raises in 90 s and has been very important in the business approach. To emphasize importance of relationship, a new marketing approach has been created and named as relationship marketing. Even relationship marketing has been termed for banking industry as relationship banking to establish long-term bonds with customers (Mukherjee and Nath, 2003). For banking industry, after the 2000s, with the increasing number of internet users, customers had great opportunities to be more powerful and effective against the banks. Thus, banks understood that they could only be successful if they focused on customer long lasting relationships (Koçoğlu and Kirmaci, 2012) because developed positive relationships with the customer link him/her loyalty and loyal customer has a potential to provide various advantages and benefits (Roig et al, 2006). In this respect, the hypothesis; H3: There is a significant relationship between relationship and customer loyalty Reliability Reliability is considered to be an important indicator of service quality (Kheng et. al, 2010). It is one dimension of SURVQUAL researches and its efficiency has been measured in several studies in banking sector (Baumann et al, Bahia and Nantel, 2000). Berry et al, (1988) measured and remarked reliability as the most influential factor on service quality and customer satisfaction (Kim et al, 2006). Also Bloemer et al, (1998) determined reliability one of the important components of customer loyalty as an intangible asset in banking sector. Furthermore, reliability is seen among vital traits of banking service. For a bank, failing in this field bring out significant degree of dissatisfaction (Johnston, 1997). In this regard, related hypothesis; H4: There is a significant relationship between reliability and customer loyalty Staff The willingness of staff to help clients and to provide prompt service makes customers highly please. Likewise, demoralized staff pulls customer satisfaction down (Joseph et al, 1999). This pleasure is particularly important when clients have requests, questions, complaints and problems surrounding the service. So, staff plays an important role on bank s performance. The professional staff transmits to customer courtesy and inspires confidence, trust and loyalty (Iymperopoulou et al, 2006). The way how staff gets, share and interpret knowledge in an enterprise is very important in aiming to retain competitive advantage (Moreno and Melendez, 2011). Staff is frontier between customers and organization and their approach very essential on customer loyalty. To gain customer satisfaction and loyalty by staff approach there are three stages that staff should consider forever; the first stage consist in being aware of bank prestige Hearing it, then, understanding importance of themselves in the meet of bank

5 Yönetim ve Ekonomi 21/1 (2014) promises Believing it, finally becoming impassioned promoter of the bank Living it (Yazdanifard et al, 2011). In this respect, the hypothesis; H5: There is a significant relationship between staff and customer loyalty. 3. Methodology In this research face-to-face survey method was conducted for data collection and the data collected among BKT (Banka Kombëtare Tregtare) bank customers. BKT is the second largest and the oldest commercial bank in Albania. 5-point Likert scale has been used in this research and 1 indicates strongly disagree, 5 indicates strongly agree. The asked demographic variables of the respondents have been gender, marital status, age, monthly income, education and the profession. 421 people participated in the survey and 11 questionnaires have been eliminated in the data entry process because of missing questions. 410 questionnaires have been analyzed to observe the effect of 5 factors on customer loyalty through confirmatory factor analysis method such as; service satisfaction, security, relationship, reliability and staff. We used SPSS 18 to conduct exploratory factor analyses (EFA) and AMOS 19 for confirmatory factor analysis. 4. Findings Analyzed sample characteristics of the participants are shown in table 1. Gender Marital Status Category Male Female Table 1: Demographic Samples Freq. % Category Freq. % or less Inco-me Level or more TOTAL TOTAL Single Married Married one child Married two children Married three children Education Less than high school High school Bachelor Post Graduated Age Category TOTAL TOTAL Pensioner Student Occupation Unemployed or more Private Sector Public Sector Other TOTAL TOTAL General characteristics of the data samples that % 58 participants were male, % 31 of their age were 31-40, % 40 participants have bachelor degree, % 42 of them work for private sector, % 57 of participants have 350 or less individual income and % 32 of them married and have one child. 361

6 Y.Köksal&O.Dema / An Investigation of the Essential Factors on Customer Loyalty in Banking Sector: A Case Albanian Retail Bank To find out efficiency of different factors on customer loyalty, factor analysis has been conducted. The Exploratory factor analysis conducted on six main factors with 19 factor items and results were found out by Principal Component Analysis method. Reliability analyzes of the scale factor questions conducted by Cronbach α method obtained a.746 result for 19 items. Table 2: Explanatory Factor Analysis (EFA) Factors and Sub- Items Mean Values Stand. Dev. Factors Loads Staff Factor Factor Variance: 15.81% The staff of my bank is kind and helpful when dealing with them The staff of my bank is understandable while giving service Staff of my bank is customer focused I know that staff of my bank is available to address my problems and concerns. Loyalty Factor Variance: 13.22% I would enlarge the use of my bank s services and products I do not think of switching my bank easily I consider myself loyal customer to my bank I would suggest my bank to my friends and family Service Satisfaction Factor Variance: 8.83% My bank gives me good advice regarding the services I received My bank attempts to figure out my business and needs Information provided by my bank is up to customers expectations Customers get full and clear explanation on bank charges and interest rates regarding their accounts Relationship Factor Variance: 7.83% I can always count on my bank to follow up on problems to make sure they have been resolved. In my bank, I am always treated with consideration, appreciation and respect My bank ensures precious ideas that assist in increasing profitability Reliability Factor Variance: 7.78% I find my bank very credible

8 Y.Köksal&O.Dema / An Investigation of the Essential Factors on Customer Loyalty in Banking Sector: A Case Albanian Retail Bank Table 4 summarizes certain results of CFA between each factor and customer loyalty. According to the results only relationship and staff factors have direct impact on customer loyalty. Absolutely the other factors have a potential on customer loyalty too but on Albanian customer structure their efficiency comes behind relationship and staff factor and impact is not enough to provide loyalty on customers alone. Table 4: Confirmatory Factor Analysis Results Hypotheses Results H1 Service Satisfaction Customer Loyalty Not Supported H2 Security Customer Loyalty Not Supported H2 H3 Relationship Customer Loyalty Supported *** H4 Reliability Customer Loyalty Not Supported H5 Staff Customer Loyalty Supported ** *** p<0.01, ** p<0.05 Relationship is one of the main components of customer loyalty in banking sector as in other businesses. Padmavathy et al. (2012) evaluate relationship satisfaction as basis for loyalty in banking sector. Also, Leverin and Liljander (2006) obtained in their study that relationship satisfaction leads customer loyalty. Akhter et al. (2011) assess relationship factor as predetermine of establishing customer loyalty. They have measured significance of relationship on customer loyalty and emphasized that customer loyalty is significantly dependent on customer relationship. Staff is another major element has direct impact on customer loyalty. Staffs, who deal with customers, directly represent brand. Their kind and gentle approaches impress customers positively and also, cultivating strong relationships with customers can be possible struggle of employees. Approaches of employees have a critical role not only on obtaining customer loyalty but also on customer retention, according to a research 13% of customers, who closed bank accounts, show as reason rude and unhelpful staff approach (Mylonakis, 2009). There is a significant relationship between staff service satisfaction and behavioral loyalty as well as attitudinal loyalty (Monsef et al. 2012). That also has been confirmed in this study by CFA results. Conclusion In particular, the main objective of this research was to reveal the impacts of different factors on customer loyalty in Albanian banking context. So this framework would show that if the bank wants to create loyalty between then and clients, should apply all the factors that were designed for the questionnaire. The 364

9 Yönetim ve Ekonomi 21/1 (2014) research shows that, service, security, relationship, reliability, loyalty, and staff can increase the loyalty among Customers and banks in Albania. Taking in consideration the analysis done to the questionnaire we can conclude that most of the respondents responded very positively on all factors of the questionnaire. The factors are: service, security, relationship, reliability, loyalty, and staff. The majority of variable answers was agreeing and strongly agrees. In fact, each factor is important on customer loyalty but relationship and staff factor are essential than other factors in terms of having potential to build customer loyalty alone. In Albanian market, according to CFA results, importance of relationship has been emphasized significantly as first factor with p<0.01 CFA value. Secondly, staff factor on the other word staff approach has an essential power to build loyalty alone with p<0.05 CFA value. Undoubtedly, the other factors (service satisfaction, reliability and security) are important components of customer loyalty in banking industry but not powerful as much as creating loyalty alone. Limitations and Further Research This study has some limitations as well as useful findings. In this study only relationships of 5 factors have been analyzed with loyalty by confirmatory factor analysis method. For further research besides analyzing different factors, efficiency of relationship and staff factors can be analyzed by structural equation modeling method as latent variable to reveal relationships of those factors with the others. In this field, valuable another further research for banks can be examining details of staff approaches and revealing its sub-items or factors. Understanding customer expectations in this regard provides a right direction to bank managers. Managerial Implications This study provides an opportunity to evaluate main factors on customer loyalty in banking sector. It will be helpful to bank managers to define priorities and to design appropriate marketing or public relation campaigns in order to enhance customer satisfaction and loyalty. In organizational trainings, educating bank staff regarding power of relationship and teaching them on details of cultivating kind relations with customers should provide competitive advantage to your bank. Also, making bank staff aware about the importance of their positive and kind approaches toward customers should be very useful behalf of your brand. Firstly improving positive relationships with customers and demonstrating kind staff approaches, then applications of the other factors from this study are going to be helpful for banks to create a strong, positive and long-lasting customer relationship. 365

Service Quality Value Alignment through Internal Customer Orientation in Financial Services An Exploratory Study in Indian Banks Prof. Tapan K.Panda* Introduction A high level of external customer satisfaction

A Proposal Framework for investigating the impact of customer relationship management on customer retention in e-commerce Abbas Keramati Industrial Engineering Department, Faculty of Engineering University

277 CHAPTER VI COMPARISONS OF CUSTOMER LOYALTY: PUBLIC & PRIVATE INSURANCE COMPANIES. This chapter contains a full discussion of customer loyalty comparisons between private and public insurance companies

Business Profitability Through Customer Loyality and Satisfaction in India with Special Reference to Dehradun (Uttarakhand) Vikas Agarwal* Ajay Chaurasia** Prateek Negi** Abstract This research paper s

MEASURING CUSTOMER SATISFACTION IN BANKING SECTOR: WITH SPECIAL REFERENCE TO BANKS OF SURAT CITY DR. SNEHALKUMAR H MISTRY PROFESSOR, C.K.PITHAWALLA INSTITUTE OF MANAGEMENT, SURAT ABSTRACT With the economic

SERVICE QUALITY AND ITS IMPACT ON CUSTOMER SATISFACTION TOWARDS LIFE INSURANCE IN DHARMAPURI Mr. R. MURUGESAN Assistant Professor, Department of Business Administration, Sri Vidhya Mandir Arts and Science

, pp.40-44 http://dx.doi.org/10.14257/astl.2015.114.08 The Effect of Perceived Value on Customer Loyalty in a Low-Priced Cosmetic Brand of South Korea: The Moderating Effect of Gender Ki-Han Chung 1, Ji-Eun

CUSTOMER SERVICE AND ORGANIZATIONAL GROWTH OF SERVICE ENTERPRISE IN SOMALIA Ismail Ali Yusuf Hassan Faculty of Business and Accountancy, SIMAD University, Mogadishu, SOMALIA. ismartyou@gmail.com ABSTRACT

Journal of Scientific Research and Development 2 (1): 167-171, 2015 Available online at www.jsrad.org ISSN 1115-7569 2015 JSRAD Check the ratings of the attractiveness of the target for banking products

(A Study of State Life Insurance Corporation Peshawar - Pakistan) Shahzad Khan Abstract This study primarily attempts to investigate the relationship among the variable to create rational motivation in

Jon Satisfaction and Organizational Commitment in a Malaysian Public University s Huam Hon Tat Faculty of Business, Management and Social Sciences, Quest International University Perak Teo Pei-Ni, Amran

International Journal of Business and Social Science Vol. 2 No. 16; September 2011 Impact of Customer Satisfaction on Customer Loyalty and Intentions to Switch: Evidence from Banking Sector of Pakistan

A Study of the Relationship Between a Successful Enterprise Risk Management System, a Performance Measurement System and the Financial Performance of Thai Listed Companies Kittipat Laisasikorn Thammasat

Modern Applied Science; Vol. 10, No. 6; 2016 ISSN 1913-1844 E-ISSN 1913-1852 Published by Canadian Center of Science and Education Analysis of the Relationship between Strategic Management and Human Resources

Investigating the Determinants of e-banking Loyalty for Large Business Customers: Two Empirical Models A. Fragata and E. Moustakas Abstract The current research paper proposes two models for the determinants

CODIFYING THE MARKETING STRATEGY WITH AN APPROACH TO THE COMPETITIVE ADVANTAGE- CASE STUDY: THE COMPARISON OFCUSTOMER RELATIONSHIP SYSTEM IN STATE BANKS Jalaledin Gavazi and *Seyed Reza Hassani Department

International Journal of Emerging Research in Management &Technology ISSN: 228-3 (Volume-3, Issue-) Research Article July 204 To Identify Service Quality Gaps in Banking Sector: A Study of Private Banks

The Effect of Information Technology (IT) Support on Innovations Concepts: A study of Textile Sector in Pakistan Abstract Muhammad Mohsin MBA (Quality Management), Govt College University Faisalabad, Pakistan

Antecedents and Consequences of Consumer s Dissatisfaction of Agro-food Products and Their Complaining through Electronic Means Costas Assimakopoulos 1 1 Department of Business Administration, Alexander

2012 International Conference on Economics, Business Innovation IPEDR vol.38 (2012) (2012) IACSIT Press, Singapore Evaluating the Relationship between Service Quality and Customer Satisfaction in the Australian