The place—separated into a no-reservations bar area and reservations-only dining room—is decked out in salvage shop finds (like bicycles and suitcases from the Junction’s Smash) and distressed subway tiles. And it was designed with Instagram in mind. “We realized when people Instagram food under neon lighting, it makes everything pink,” says Sidhu, so unlike his other restaurants, Cafetería has just the one neon sign. It’s now open for dinner, and will start serving lunch the first week of February.