I re-watched the replay twice because I was so mystified about where that 1st point came from. Played it a 3rd time in slow motion just to be sure. All 4 enemy bots were travelling together, with at least two of them colliding. Several of them were carrying resources. The goal flashed and the score ticked up to 1 point when all 4 enemy bots were still near the center of the board. You can see the tail end of the goal flash animation in the screenshot I took.

I noticed that when watching a replay, if I exit out without watching the whole thing, it still shows up as "new" in the Log. Can you add a separate button in the replay watching screen (maybe on the lower right?) to exit the replay midway through and mark it as watched?