Beliebers lost their little minds when their hero got a teensy cross tattooed on his face. So we imagine they just about imploded when they saw Justin Bieber’s new torso tattoo, a Hieronymous Bosch–worthy scene with gargoyles, a skeleton and cathedral arches (not to mention the chest and tummy tats he’s accumulated over the years). The Biebs debuted it on Instagram over the weekend, after a three-day, 26-hour session with the New York-based Bang Bang tattoo shop. Some fans were into it; most just miss his immaculately sculpted abs. Here, an annotated guide to every image on JB’s torso.