Artisanal cheese making in the United States is at an all time high, both in quantity and in quality. We are now blessed with hundreds of producers across the nation, many of whom are garnering attention and accolades worldwide. Many of these fall into the cheddar category, as American Artisans put their own spin on this popular cheese which originated in the village of the same name in Somerset, England. This fantastic collection gathers four of our favorites, each typifying the fearless spirit of these new-world cheddar producers.

Fiscalini 18 Month Bandage Wrapped Cheddar: Rich, buttery and sharp, this world-class bandage-wrapped cheddar hails from California. This cheddar was awarded Gold Medal at the 2007 World Cheese Awards in London, making Fiscalini the first Non-British Cheddar to win the title of "Best Cheddar"! (7.5 oz)

Widmer's Six Year Reserve Cheddar: Much like a limited edition book or lithograph, every piece of Widmer's cheese is handcrafted in small batches to ensure quality. This Wisconsin six year aged cheddar is rich with notes of caramel. While it is aged for a considerable period of time, it is still moist and creamy on the tongue with a noteworthy tanginess and slightly salty finish. (7.5 oz)

Goat Cheddar: From Montchevre comes this aged goat's milk cheddar. Sharp and smooth, this Wisconsin cheddar is aged a minimum of one year, giving it a complex, nutty flavor. (7.5 oz)

Great rich texture. Never had cheese so good. Rich, thick creamy goodness. LOVE IT

By SeanOfrom CTon Jul 16, 2013

Six Years , A Boast, Not To Be Taken Too Seriously

A perfectly good creamy Chedder for its age. I like with my brown soda bread and a touch of butter.

By Johnnfrom Tampa Floridaon Jul 01, 2013

Cheddar orgasm

If you like cheddars holy crap this is the one for you.

By Lonniefrom Greensboro, NCon Sep 15, 2012

Cheddar Selection

Cheddar ain't just cheddar. This selection covers the spectrum of prize cheddars. Advise that you stock up for Fall.

By Tomfrom Seattleon Apr 20, 2012

Love the variety

A nice range of rich, delicious cheddars

By woodhick803from Lewisburg WVon Feb 17, 2012

NOT IN THE LEAST CHEESY

I'll be as brief as possible. Buying from igourmet.com was easy. The pages were self explanatory (my first time using igourmet). I often judge whether I'll return for further purchases on how user friendly a website's pages are. I'll be back to igourmet when these excellent cheeses are gone.
Now to the cheeses. Basically, as advertised. We like some better than others, no biggie there. All are of high quality and well packaged individually so that they do not need to be eaten quickly after arrival (although they probably will be). Thus far the Fiscalini is my favorite but I have not tried the goat cheddar yet. I look forward to trying other cheeses from igourmet.

By donna mosherfrom sand creek mion Apr 01, 2011

GREAT american cheddars

outstanding communication and very fast service
will definately order from here again thanks you

By NHFoodiesfrom New Hampshireon Dec 28, 2010

Fast Service, Excellent Product

Very satisfied

By Susan Moorefrom MAon Sep 13, 2010

Fabulous!

You have such an array of delightful products that it made it difficult to choose what I wanted to buy! My boyfriend however, made the choice quite simply...he LOVES Cheddar Cheese (only great C.C though), so together we decided to order the 'Great American Cheddars Collection'. The order arrived in 2 days as specified and as we opened the package, we were pleased as to how thoughtfully the cheeses were wrapped. With the same anticipation as a young children on Christmas Morn', we dove in and tasted all 4 cheeses! Each one had a unique depth of flavor and texture that exceeded our expectations!! How clever of you to put such a wonderful "collection" of cheeses together.I would love to know if there are other "collections" maybe from, France or Italy...it would make it easier to experience the best from each region...especially if you don't know that much about cheese. I, we, will definitely be ordering again as this has been a most pleasant experience. Thank You igourmet!!!