I must say that the last few chapters where an emotional rollercoaster for me... I loved the fighting scenes and I loved all of the flashbacks. And at the end you made me want to stay at Hogwarts and have the story continue. Thank you so much for posting this story! And now... I am on to the sequel!

Oh. My God! Way to make me freakin' hyperventilate! I actually thought some of this was happening for a minute! Then I didn't and thought it was some kind of April Fools joke from Dumbledore but you made it seem so real! I've literally been sitting in this chair practically hyperventilating for the past five minutes! And oh my god, the spy is Bethany? I had thought through the entire story that if was Meliflua (or whatever her name is)! I actually thought that she was Bellatrix Lestrange in disguise and that's how she knew Sirius! Well, I still think that but can't find any more reasons why at the moment.

actually its really a sad happy ending for james and lily... after that sirius... then finally for remus... but i didnt really feel sad when peter died... i mean if it wasnt for him james n lily would still be alive and harry would have his parents... but great story ... it was nice to read about the marauders!

I love this story. All of the characters are totally IC and I love how everything happened. There were so many twists and you handled them all totally well. I love how you have Lily and James get together, it was totally different from the whole 'she falls for him the day after they come back' thing. I also love Sirius and Remus. Sirius is so caring and Remus is just so...Remus. They're both totally IC. You characterized Peter amazingly as well. You didn't drop him or anything and I love how you got him to start being bad-ish. I loved how everything unfolded.