GM 1885 DXM 808 or newbery thruxton?

I need to buy a new cricket bat I am looking for a 5 star cricket bat and from what I understand the bats mentioned in the title are both star short handle cricket bats. Can anyone tell me which is better or if there are any other better bats that I could possible purchase. I am from South Africa and I am going to order from overseas so my budget is around 200-250 dollars.

Have you tried either out, just with the downswing and the balance in your hands?

I walked into Kingsgrove with my heart set on a Puma but the guy somehow picked up my physique and offered me a Kookaburra to have a swing with. It was like batting with the Force. Bought it on the spot.

"The Australian cricket captain is the Prime Minister Australia wishes it had. Steve Waugh is that man, Michael Clarke is not." - Jarrod Kimber