If this is your first visit, be sure to
check out the FAQ by clicking the
link above. You may have to register
before you can post: click the register link above to proceed. To start viewing messages,
select the forum that you want to visit from the selection below.

The NCAA Division I schedule kicks off this Friday, Feb. 16, which marks the unofficial start of MLB draft season as well, although some high schools and junior colleges in the south and west are already underway. This year's Rule 4 draft will take place June 4-6, with the Detroit Tigers holding the first pick, followed by the Giants, Phillies, White Sox and Reds. The class looks strong right now, the deepest overall since 2011, although the upper tier is less certain right now and heavier on the high school talent some teams have shied away from in recent drafts.

1. Ethan Hankins, RHP, Forsyth Central High School, Cumming, Georgia: By all accounts, the best high school player in the draft class is this 6-foot-6 right-hander, who brings plus velocity already with an advanced feel for pitching. Of course, the annual disclaimer that no high school right-hander has ever gone first overall is required.

2. Casey Mize, RHP, Auburn: The best college arm has big velocity, a hard slider and a wipeout splitter, but some questions about his durability and his elbow remain. A strong, uninterrupted junior year would likely quell those concerns.

3. Travis Swaggerty, OF, South Alabama: Swaggerty -- his nickname has to be Swaggy T, right? -- has hit for two solid years for the Jaguars and was one of the leading hitters on the USA Collegiate National Team last summer, while also bringing above-average speed that gives him a good chance to profile in center field. He's sub-6-feet … but so was 2015's No. 2 overall pick, Alex Bregman.

4. Nolan Gorman, INF, Sandra Day O'Connor High School, Glendale, Arizona: Gorman stands out as the one elite high school bat in the class, which is deep with likely big leaguers but not with potential stars. He's not a shortstop in the long run, but with his swing and huge raw power, it won't matter where he plays.

5. Matthew Liberatore, LHP, Mountain Ridge High School, Peoria, Arizona: Liberatore could give Hankins a run for his money as the top high school arm taken, with a projectable body and three average or better pitches right now. He'll work mostly 89-92 mph, along with a slow but tight curveball and above-average changeup, throwing strikes with all three offerings. If he gains velocity, he could end up with three 60-grade pitches in his arsenal.

6. Griffin Conine, OF, Duke: Conine's dad used to be Mr. Marlin, although I feel like that might not apply anymore. Griffin is seen as the safest college hitter in the class, returning from an injury-wrecked freshman year to hit .298/.425/.546 for Duke last year and finish in the top 10 in the Cape in OBP and slugging. He'll end up at a corner in pro ball.

7. Logan Gilbert, RHP, Stetson: Gilbert shows plus velocity from a slightly low three-quarters slot that's very deceptive, with present control more than command and still some projection left in his body.

8. Kumar Rocker, RHP, North Oconee High School, Bogart, Georgia.: Rocker is bigger than most big leaguers already, listed at 6-foot-5 and a perhaps generous 250 pounds by MLB, with a tremendous arm -- his velocity sits in the mid-90s and he also shows a power breaking ball -- but he lacks the command or feel of Hankins and Liberatore.

9. Jake McCarthy, OF, Virginia: The younger brother of Rays prospect (and Cavaliers alum) Joe, Jake is a similarly polished hitter but is faster and more athletic, much more likely to stay in center and with a projection to hit and show average power.

10. Ryan Rolison, LHP, Ole Miss: A strongly built lefty with a solid-average or better fastball and tight-breaking curveball, Rolison is a draft-eligible sophomore who will turn 21 about a month after the draft and is Ole Miss' best starter even though he started 2016 in its bullpen before entering the weekend rotation.

11. Jackson Kowar, RHP, Florida: Kowar will be the Gators' No. 2 starter to begin the spring, but he's their best pro prospect, with a plus fastball, starter's delivery and plus changeup.

12. Carter Stewart, RHP, Eau Gallie High School, Melbourne, Florida: Stewart will pitch with solid-average velocity already, but it's his knockout curveball -- the best in the draft class -- that could push him into the top half of the first round, even with the industry bias against prep right-handers.

13. Shane McClanahan, LHP, South Florida: McClanahan has thrown up to 99 mph, complemented with at least a solid-average changeup, although he's so slight of build that there's concern he won't hold up throwing that hard as a starter.

14. Nander de Sedas, SS, Montverde Academy: Montverde Academy gave the world Francisco Lindor, and we shall be forever grateful. The school's next great shortstop prospect is de Sedas, yet another switch-hitter, with loose hands and physical projection for future power, at least from the right side. He has the glove and plus arm for short but is a below-average runner.

15. Jarred Kelenic, OF, Waukesha (Wis.) West High School: Kelenic is a toolsy prep outfielder from the baseball hotbed of … um, Wisconsin, which has produced one first-round pick in the past 30 years. He has power, a plus arm and average running speed, with a good idea at the plate but questionable bat speed.

16. Steele Walker, OF, Oklahoma: Walker outhit Swaggerty for Team USA last summer, mostly because he showed more power, but he'll end up in left field in pro ball because he lacks Swaggerty's speed. Also, Steele Walker is a great name if he decides to switch careers and become an actor, a professional wrestler or a superhero.

17. Seth Beer, OF, Clemson: Beer is famous for his walk totals, with 126 so far in 583 plate appearances over two years with Clemson, and he has power, but he has to show he can play a position to end up a top 5-10 pick like his offensive stat line might imply.

18. Nick Madrigal, 2B/SS, Oregon State: Madrigal can really hit and never strikes out, and he might fly off the board given his offensive performance, but he's just 5-foot-8, 160 pounds, doesn't have much power and has been bumped to second base by junior Cadyn Grenier.

19. Will Banfield, C, Brookwood High School, Lawrenceville, Georgia.: High school catchers are considered the riskiest class of players to take in the draft, especially up top; since the Twins took Joe Mauer first overall in 2001, the top-producing high school catcher taken in the first round who reached the majors as a catcher is Devin Mesoraco (15th pick, 2007), with 3.7 WAR. The past two drafts haven't seen a catcher taken before the second round, but Banfield might break that streak, as he’s a very good defensive catcher with a plus arm. His bat is the bigger question; he has a solid swing that should produce average power, and he should end up in the first round with a strong spring at the plate.

20. Brice Turang, SS, Santiago High School, Corona, California: Turang is the best shortstop among top prospects in this year's class, but as more scouts saw him last year, questions emerged about how much offensive upside he'd offer, or whether he was more of an Adam Everett type, who would have big value on defense but not at the plate.

21. Cole Wilcox, RHP, Heritage High School, Ringgold, Georgia.: Wilcox has a super-quick arm and throws up to 95 mph, also boasting an above-average slider and changeup, but there's effort to his delivery, and he could use his lower half more to show he can hold up as a starter.

22. Brady Singer, RHP, Florida: Singer is the Gators' Friday night starter, and the more famous of their two prospects, but his stuff has been inconsistent -- he can throw 94-96 mph as a starter but then be more 90-91 mph -- and his very low arm slot and short-arm delivery are less than optimal for the rotation.

23. Tristan Pompey, OF, Kentucky: Yep, that's Dalton's younger brother, a bigger but less speedy model, coming off a strong .361/.464/.541 sophomore year for the Wildcats, albeit with some of the same swing-and-miss concerns that bedeviled other recent college outfield prospects like Jeren Kendall and Corey Ray.

24. Tim Cate, LHP, UConn: Cate has one of the best lefty curveballs in the class, giving teams the comfort of a high floor, but he’s on the smaller side for a starter, and the last time the Huskies had a premium starter prospect (Anthony Kay), they overpitched him so badly he blew out his elbow before he could ever throw a pro pitch.

25. Jeremy Eierman, SS, Missouri State: The younger brother of the Rays' third-rounder in the 2011 draft, Eierman is a strong-bodied shortstop with a powerful, balanced swing that produced 23 homers last spring, albeit with some swing-and-miss. He's an average runner and probably moves to third base in the long run.

26. Mason Denaburg, RHP, Merritt Island (Florida) High School: A traditional prep right-hander with a fastball clocked up to 95 mph as well as a hard slider, with good athleticism and some growth ahead of him as a pitcher. He's at the same school that produced Brady McConnell, now a freshman at Florida and a potential high pick for 2020.

27. Tristan Casas, 1B, American Heritage High School, Plantation, Florida.: It's bat-only tools, but Casas looks like he'll hit and hit for power, and he comes from a school with a great track record of producing players, including 2008’s No. 3 overall pick, Eric Hosmer.

28. Cole Winn, RHP, Orange (California) Lutheran High School: Winn moved to California from Colorado for this academic year and impressed West Coast scouts in the fall with the uptick in his stuff now that he's not pitching at altitude and is facing better competition.

29. Konnor Pilkington, LHP, Mississippi State: A big, strong college lefty with three average pitches who works in the best baseball conference, although he's going to have to work on his command and control and may not have a single plus pitch right now.

30. Joey Bart, C, Georgia Tech: The top college catcher generally comes off the board fairly early, and that's Bart this year in a weak group of collegiate backstops. He's a solid defender with a plus arm and has average or slightly better power, but he strikes out too often and projects to a below-average hit tool.

Eierman has started the season horribly. I know it's only 6 games but it was Lamar and Texas Southern. They scored a bunch and all he did was K. Can I end up souring on another one of my "can't miss" underclassmen

Originally Posted by weams

You have to realize we have a real life celebrity who posts on our boards Roy firestone.

Eierman has started the season horribly. I know it's only 6 games but it was Lamar and Texas Southern. They scored a bunch and all he did was K. Can I end up souring on another one of my "can't miss" underclassmen

I've never actually looked at JD's college stats. He's an interesting study. Really average for the Metal bat era during his first two seasons and even struck out 3 times more than he walked. Then his Junior year he goes for 30 XBH (out of 75 hits), walks 38 times and just strikes out 27. In 2600 minor league and college PA's he had just 109 HR's then 150 in his first 2600 PA's as a pro.

Originally Posted by weams

You have to realize we have a real life celebrity who posts on our boards Roy firestone.