Personally i say yes, for reasons i will happily argue about for hours :D

Asamiya

02-13-2013, 10:22 PM

Isn't Holy is spell not for destruction how is that possible?

Varent Istari

02-13-2013, 10:29 PM

Well, it backfires after Sephiroth is defeated and protects Meteor, making it stronger. Holy was created by the Cetra to destroy anything that could harm the Planet. Meteor alone was not enough to destroy everything so Holy helped. Now that i think about it, Aeris may not have been evil, but probably manipulated she could hear the Ancients in her head. I can't help but think that she was told Holy would destroy Meteor when it wouldn't

Darth Revan

02-13-2013, 11:29 PM

This should be posted in the Final Fantasy VII subforum, not in General Discussion as it has to do with Final Fantasy VII.

Enkidoh

02-14-2013, 12:04 AM

Heh, looks like someone did. :p

This arguement has been going since the game was first released, with all kinds of stupid theories being made up by fans on the subject (the most infamous was the 'Holy Kills Humanity' one, which was, of course, completely invalidated by Advent Children and the Compilation.) Holy is the Ultimate White Magic - it's essentially the power of the Planet. Hence, it's not up to the spell's caster to decide how the spell functions - it's the Planet itself who decides that (it's what Bugenhagen mentions, which was the source of that stupid theory I just mentioned).

Besides, Holy's very reason for existence is just as a counteragent to Meteor - the Ultimate Black (or Destructive) Magic. So therefore, Holy is merely a counterweight to Meteor, rather than a 'magic of mass destruction', and so is not by nature an 'offensive' spell.

These are the facts as they're presented in the game and in related official documentation (ala, the Ultimania guides, info from which in most cases I would take with a grain of salt), so if you'd like to argue about it, go ahead. Just be aware it's an arguement that would be rather one sided.

Varent Istari

02-14-2013, 04:19 AM

I'll agree with the fact that it's one sided but hell, wheres the fun otherwise. An also Bugenhagen states that it could destroy everything Holy perceived to be a threat to the Planet. He actually says that it could destroy humanity along with Meteor and WEAPON. So wouldn't it be easier to do that knowing that Meteor wasn't capable of destroying the Planet? Which does make sense, it's hardly something ignorable. Plus after defeating Sephiroth. Red XIII (Nanaki) says that Holy is having the opposite effect than intended, rather than destroy Meteor it aided it. I never said it was a destructive magic. You can tell from the after the end fight that it's shielding Meteor, making it stronger, but not destroying anything itself. I wouldn't say it was invalidated, by Advent Children especially as if Sephiroth could manipulate the Lifestream, why not Aeris? Especially as she was an Ancient. I also didn't say Aeris knew what she was doing or that she had control over Holy. In fact the that Holy is rather the Planet's own power, wouldn't it attempt to protect itself? Going back to my point about Aeris, she could easily have been tricked by the voices into thinking it was the right thing to do. Only realizing when Holy shielded Meteor that she was wrong.

Enkidoh

02-15-2013, 12:39 AM

A number of points here:

Holy only had the opposite effect because Sephiroth's strong will blocked it from 'doing it's job' for so long. By the time it finally was able to activate, Meteor was already hovering above the Planet and had gotten too powerful and was essentially absorbed into it. So it's not a question of whether Holy was a destructive spell - it's White Magic after all and traditionally White Magic's very nature is to heal or nurture - in fact, in the very first FF game Holy-elemental spells would only damage undead entities, which is the opposite of life. Hence, in the same way, in FFVII Holy ('life' in a sense) is the opposite of Meteor (essentially, 'death'). As well, I don't think Holy actually shielded Meteor, more in it tried it's hardest to stop the Meteor, but it was just overpowered (that's why you still see it swirling around Meteor, attempting to destroy it without success).

As for Aeris, why would she want to do that? Using Holy in such a way is ultimately perverse and anathema to someone like her who is kind and gentle and only desires to heal and help others. Aeris cast Holy because that was what she had been taught to do by her mother - it was a directive handed down through the Cetra for thousands of years with the White Materia, as the Cetra knew ultimately, Jenova would eventually escape and threaten the Planet.

To paraphrase Bugenhagen: "When the time of Calamity comes, Holy must be called." Even Cloud realizes that Aeris knew all along what she had to do - only she alone could cast Holy as she was the final inheritor of the Cetra's history and wisdom. No one else could do it. It's also the very reason for Aeris's demise - even Sephiroth himself knew that as Holy was meteor's counteragent, she alone was the only real threat to his plans so he strove to eliminate her before she could do that. Unfortunately for him though her prayers had managed to reach the Planet before she met her destiny on Masamune. ;)

And besides, the Planet does protect itself in the end - why else do you think the Lifestream erupted out of the Planet to destroy the Meteor in the final moments of the game? This is even clearly mentioned in Advent Children during Marlene's monologue at the film's beginning (Ironically this was exactly what Sephiroth had aimed for all along - he didn't want to destroy the world itself, just threaten it's existence, knowing that doing so the Planet would use the Lifestream to defend itself in exactly that way, which he would then absorb at the nexus point of the Lifestream's energy to ascend into godhood. That last point seems to be overlooked or forgotten though by most fans, simply preferring him to be a mindless megalomaniac who just seeks destruction, despite him clearly mentioning this was what he was planning on accomplishing even back in disc 1 at the Temple of the Ancients).

As for 'manipulating the Lifestream', I seem to recall that in Advent Children Aeris did actually consider using the Lifestream to create 'avatars' to help Cloud out (like Sephiroth did with the three Remnants), but she decided not to, as she didn't want to ruin Cloud's memory of her. Or at least, that's what the FF Wiki mentioned, which evidently took it's info from the Ultimania.

Varent Istari

02-17-2013, 06:05 AM

I know Holy wasn't trying to stop Meteor. Red XIII states that it was having the opposite effect. I don't think Sephiroth knew that the Lifestream would defend the Planet simply because it had to strike North Crater for his body to absorb it. I don't see how Sephiroth's will could have changed the effect of the spell as you said yourself that Holy is the Planet's power so it would react as the Planet wanted it too, not as the caster. Sephiroth could not have made any effect on Holy other than to retain it. Assuming Holy was the counter to Meteor it would not have been overpowered by it in any case. Also in the Temple of the Ancients (having conveniently just gone through disc 1 again :D) Sephiroth does say he wants to injure the Planet, "An injury to threaten the very life of the Planet" i think he says or something similar. Still truth be told you have good points, partly due to Ultimania, which yes i know are official documents, but i just can't help feeling they were only do for extra profit. But still i do have to take them with a pinch of salt as they are official. I didn't say Aeris did want to help Meteor (Well, actually i did, but that was bad wording on my part) There is the chance (admittedly small) that while Sephiroth wanted to damage the Planet, Holy and the Planet itself wanted to destroy humanity, as it was threatened by the Mako energy being made by the Shinra. Aeris, being able to hear the Planet could have been manipulated by it into casting Holy. More proof that it was Aeris that manipulated the Lifestream than the Planet can come from this point as if the Planet could manipulate the Lifestream to protect itself it would have destroyed the Mako reactors. (Odd coincidence that with Holy aiding it, Midgar couldn't be saved from Meteor, along with most of Shinra's Mako Reactors