HereticalRants ltd denies any and all such allegations as per our bilateral nondisclosure agreement with {UNDISCLOSED}. We would like to direct you to section 1.3A of our undisclosed user agreement, which clearly states
| {UNDISCLOSED}

Thank you for your considerations, and remember to keep shopping at {UNDISCLOSED}!_________________butts

Well, it's "critical analysis" in the sense of the same speculation everybody's been doing in forum and blog threads since the reveal.

I personally find all of that to be a waste of time because people are rarely correct and there is a strong tendency along two lines whenever such speculation happens: pre-emptive headcanon assembly, and prejudice. The latter is a bit disappointing coming from an adult fandom for My Little Pony: Friendship is Magic, given how this all started and the several reality checks against every knee-jerk ragesplosion along the way.

So instead of bothering with all that crap, I just wait for the new official content to come to me in due course, while making my own in the meantime.
Celestia made me a cake for my upcoming birthday, but then she eated it. Because she's some kind of eatbeast* when it comes to cake based on two little things from the show. THAT kind of ridiculous extrapolation I can get behind because nobody takes it seriously.

The author has also written a very nice series of vignettes set in the world of the conversion bureau, called The Lost In The Herd Series: 1234, each being an exercise in trying a different style or trick.

2) Celestia Sleeps In
...as a result, she accidentally makes first contact, and Dale (everyone's relatively open-minded redneck uncle) naively assumes that she and her kind are stereotypical technologically advanced aliens.

This is not human in Equestria, this is xenofiction, complete with language barrier and many of the common tropes (and, of course, magical ponies), but it is still quite distinct from other pony xenofictions such as Arrow 18 (where Twilight learns all about human spacecraft).
Misunderstandings abound!
Sequel: Onto the Pony Planet

Described as "almost militantly inaccessible", this is the very best unreadable literary self-indulgence I've seen this fandom produce.

_____________

These fics are all old. Even the ones that are ongoing are old, wow. But you can't possibly expect me to be up-to-date on this stuff, I've got 524 fics in my "read later" list to catch up on and counting! Counting fast! I'd need to take a year off in a pocket universe or something to catch up!