I had an idea while reading all the posts: How about a new thread, combining Italo- and US-Westerns (and maybe also other westerns) and voting for a combined Top 20 (or Top 30 or 50) ?

This would be mine at present (this list might not be consistent with either the lists of favourite spags or favourite US westerns I have submitted elsewhere on the board previously; that is because these lists are constantly shifting):

The Good, the Bad & the Ugly (1966)

Unforgiven (1992)

High Plains Drifter (1973)

For a Few Dollars More (1965)

The Big Gundown (1966)

The Proposition (2005)

The Wild Bunch (1969)

A Fistful of Dollars (1964)

True Grit (2010)

Day of Anger (1967)

Django Kill… If You Live, Shoot! (1967)

The Assassination of Jesse James by the Coward Robert Ford (2007)

Death Rides a Horse (1967)

Once Upon a Time in the West (1968)

Django (1966)

3:10 to Yuma (2007)

Tombstone (1993)

Keoma (1976)

Cemetery Without Crosses (1969)

A Bullet For the General (1966)

The Mercenary (1968)

Face to Face (1967)

Pat Garrett & Billy the Kid (1973)

Mannaja (1977)

10,000 Dollars For a Massacre (1967)

The Forgotten Pistolero (1969)

The Dirty Outlaws (1966)

Navajo Joe (1966)

The Great Silence (1968)

The Return of Ringo (1965)

My Name is Nobody (1973)

The Outlaw Josey Wales (1976)

Django Unchained (2012)

Rango (2011)

The Quick & the Dead (1995)

Pale Rider (1985)

Companeros (1970)

God Forgives, I Don’t! (1967)

Django, Prepare a Coffin (1968)

The Good, the Bad, the Weird (2008)

Massacre Time (1966)

The Grand Duel (1972)

If You Meet Sartana, Pray For Your Death (1968)

No Country For Old Men (2007)

Blazing Saddles (1974)

The Bounty Killer (1966)

Light the Fuse… Sartana is Coming (1970)

A Fistful of Dynamite (1971)

Johnny Yuma (1966)

A Pistol For Ringo (1965)

33 Spags, a couple of remakes, a bunch of American revisionists, an Australian “Meat Pie” western, a Korean movie set in Manchuria, a couple of contemporary westerns - one of which is an anthropomorphic animated feature, and a Mel Brooks comedy.

The parameters of the list are too restrictive. A top 20 list doesn’t begin to tap the well of several thousand American westerns to choose from. Because of the vast scope of the American western, the list should be expanded to the Top 40. Yes, a Top 40 list would not be unreasonable. Even then, the problem is which and how many should be left out when you know they should be included. So many American westerns are among the best films ever made, anywhere, at any time. In contrast, there are only a few hundred spags to choose from, so assembling a list of the Top 20 spags is much easier.

Why are some of you listing European films in a thread about U.S. westerns?

ALL lists are “valid”, fella (although, if a list was to be “invalid” it would be yours since you’ve ranked them reverse-chronologically rather than by preference). These lists are entirely subjective. Claiming that everybody’s lists MUST include those thirty-five movies otherwise they don’t count is a little insulting, tbh; I’d like to think that that wasn’t your intention, however.

[quote=“Richard–W, post:153, topic:3170”]Bad Lieutenant, did anyone ever tell you that your facebook page is infantile?
There is not iota of cinematic aptitude or talent on your facebook page.[/quote]
And the winner of the swdb SD award 2015 is…

Longer lists are no problem, as long as only the first twenty of a list are taken into account for a final Top 20 or whatever.
But if someone wishes his list will be taken into account, he should put the movies in order of preference. After all the idea is: N°1 getting 20 points, N°2 19 points, etc. If the movies are put in random or chronological order, the most logical idea would be to award them one point each, which would harm their chances.

I find lists with American and Italian movies included also very interesting, but we should create another thread for such lists, this thread is called ‘Vote for our Top 20 U.S. westerns’, so only American movies should be included.

[quote=“Richard–W, post:153, topic:3170”]Bad Lieutenant, did anyone ever tell you that your facebook page is infantile?
There is not iota of cinematic aptitude or talent on your facebook page.

If you don’t like my list or my reasoning, don’t read it.

If you’re not to lazy to review the thread, you’ll find that some members have posted more than one list, exceeded twenty titles, and bent the rules this way and that way.

So what I did fits right in.

Why don’t you post your own list before criticizing others?[/quote]

Richard W, did anyone ever tell you that you’re belligerent and condescending, or that you bring up things that are utterly irrelevant for matters at hand?

Why don’t you read the list I posted, instead of criticising me unjustly for not posting it? But even if I hadn’t made such a list, I still would have made valid points. However, I’m sure you are a legend in your own brain, and therefore anybody else does not make any sense.

Richard, you’re a bit of a bellend, mate. I’ve had a look through your posts and you’ve definitely got form for talking like a complete weapon. Constantly talking down to people, you. Do you talk in that patronizing manner all the time, out in the real world? Would you do it to my face? Not a chance, fella. Not a chance. So don’t do it here.

Have a try at actually reading the posts before charging in with your “Why are some of you listing European films in a thread about U.S. westerns?”, you lemon. You’re obviously just lightly scanning everyone else’s contributions before wading in with your judgments and declarations, so if you’re showing everyone that little respect why should anyone give a lubricated cockrub for anything you’re chatting on about?

Politeness costs nothing, but it’s worth everything. There’s nothing here but decent people, and a limp salad like you tends to stand out. So you can either wind your fucking neck in and join the community, or take off. Simples. This brilliant, brilliant place isn’t going to be turned into a shithole by the likes of you, sunshine.

(with apologies to Sebastian and the wider SWDB community; but people like this helmet here, are not my sort of people)

Richard - you’ve had warnings from mods previously on this website and you’re essentially being warned again. It’s not you’re opinions that are wrong (they’re subjective and have as much legitimacy as everyone else’s), but the way you express them. Please act in the cordial manner that we’re used to on this forum.

I limited it to 20 as I feel for most people, after that it becomes a more arbitrary and less interesting list to read. I also wanted a US counterpart to the site’s official Spaghetti Western list.