Todd arrives at the mansion with a copy of The Sun reading, "I Am Todd Manning." He demands Blair help prove to everyone that he's not an imposter. Todd screams for Starr, but Blair claims she left early. He rants that Blair and Starr should know he's Todd just by looking in his eyes. What does he have to do to convince Blair? "This," Blair says and kisses Todd. Blair admits she felt something when T.M. kissed her, like a feeling only brought on by the love of her life. She wanted to put Todd to the test. "How'd I do?" he asks. The kiss felt familiar to her, but why wouldn't it since she was married to him? Todd stomps off. Blair thinks back to kissing T.M., Todd and Tomas.

Jessica comes face to face with T.M. at Llanfair. Viki told her about the man running around with her Uncle Todd's old face. "You look exactly like him, but who are you?" Jessica asks. T.M. fills Jessica in on his captivity, all the way up to the DNA results. After T.M. reminds Jessica she was always his favorite, she questions his true identity. T.M. takes offense and laughs when Jessica tells him about her D.I.D. and how Todd helped her when she was Tess. "His behavior was off," Jessica admits. T.M. is furious that no one questioned Todd's strange actions, especially him falling in love with Marty. Talk turns to Jessica's troubles with Natalie and how Tess locked her in the basement. T.M. offers to talk to Natalie. "You take care of your twin," Jessica says. "I'll take care of mine." Jessica leaves to spend time with her kids. T.M. wishes he could do the same. Later, Todd barges in, calling out to Viki, and finds T.M. making himself at home.

At the Manning Estate, Tea brings up the possibility that T.M. and Todd could be twins. Todd thinks John forged the DNA results. T.M. is trying to steal his life. Tea assures Todd he's not going to lose anyone. He thinks Viki's already chosen T.M. and everyone except Jack thinks he's an imposter. He challenges Tea to look him in the eye and deny that she's wondering if T.M. is the man she really loves. Tea takes out a board game.

At the Manning Estate, everyone questions how both Todds have the same DNA. "Two Todd Mannings?" Viki asks. John assures them the test was secure. They still think someone could've tampered with the results. Tea wonders if Tomas knows anyone who would. Dani arrives, stunned to see T.M. Blair holds Todd back when T.M. tells Dani that he's her father. As everyone tries to figure out how the Todds could have the same DNA, Starr interjects, "They must be twins." Jack suggests maybe they're clones. Both Todds refuse to believe they're brothers and demand another test. Samples are taken. Everyone gets ready to leave. Jack wants to stay. Blair agrees to let him come back later if it's okay with Tea and Todd. Dani rushes off, refusing to talk to T.M. Todd's irked to hear Viki posted T.M.'s bail and is taking him to Llanfair. She reminds Todd they'll all get answers tomorrow, to which T.M. replies, "Then I'll get my life back." Later, Tea grabs a drink, reminds Todd she's still there and anticipates the test results tomorrow.

At Todd's house, both Todd and T.M. both claim to have raped Marty. T.M. is shocked when he learns that Todd had a relationship with Marty. An incredulous T.M. thinks that should have been a clue that Todd was an imposter. John then reveals that the DNA sample that matched Marty's rape kit belongs to T.M. Todd claims the test proves nothing. Viki asks who he really is, but he screams, "What happened to innocent until proven guilty?" Todd is disgusted no one believes him, but Jack pipes up that he believes him. Blair yells at Todd to stop playing games. John announces they will know who Todd is when they open his DNA results. Todd brings up the illegal procedure used to obtain his toothbrush, but John believes it is irrelevant at this point. Todd wants a new test, but John opens the envelope. John causes further confusion when the results show Todd's DNA is also a match. The group is stunned when John says, "According to this test, you are Todd Manning, too."

Todd is shocked when Jack comes home and reveals that Starr doubts he is her father. Todd asks where Tea stands, but she remains silent. She changes the subject to the DNA test. Todd knows he will pass it. Tea offers to go so he can avoid another confrontation with John. As she leaves, Blair and Tomas arrive, but Todd orders Tomas out. Blair sends Jack away, and Todd gets defensive that she doubts him.

A terrified Tea and Viki return to Todd's, as John arrives with Starr and TM. John tells an annoyed Todd, "We're going to find out who the real Todd Manning is."

At home, Todd wonders how Tea can question if he is an imposter. A disoriented Tea admits she went to see T.M. in jail. A tearful Tea can't look Todd in the eyes. He begs her to look at him and tell him she believes him. Tea doesn't understand how T.M. could know so much personal information. Todd chalks it up to the Internet, and then rattles off other personal details only they would know, including conceiving Dani. An upset Tea screams at him and demands that he tell her everything. Todd claims that Baker wanted him to launder money and use his business as a front, as a favor for his country. He insists that he got out when Tea got sick, but Baker won't let it go. Tea still doesn't know how T.M. factors into it all. Todd buries his head in his hands and can't give her answers he doesn't have. He thinks T.M. might be an assassin before yelling that Tea is playing right into their hands and begs her not to let them do that. Jack interrupts and boasts that he believes Todd and will always be on his side.

Trying to get Nate to leave her house, Dani agrees to keep his secret. Todd emerges and wonders what they are hiding. Todd eggs Nate on with porno names before ordering him to leave. Dani tells an angry Todd he has kept secrets from her, too. He is disgusted she compared him to Nate, a punk. Dani won't back down and claims he has done worse. Nate doesn't want to cause any more trouble and leaves. Todd warns him he will kill him if he returns. Dani tells Todd he can't protect her forever and has to let her go. He says he never will. She assures him she can handle it, but appreciates having a safety net.

Tea returns home and Todd asks where she has been. A disheveled-looking Tea asks, "Are you an impostor?"