Rated 1 out of 5Â by Millbrook Mama Warning: Dye Runs!
I purchased two sets of the smaller size in "jewel tone" thinking they'd be good for my children (ages 2.5, 8, 10 & 12) to use. The size was good for small hands and the weight sturdy, but the dye immediately ran and also scraped off when stacked. And that was with gentle hand washing. I've sent them back and I think this is the only item I've ever returned to VCS.
August 31, 2016

Rated 5 out of 5Â by Mommabearb Love them
Used them as a kid and got some for the camper
They keep things a lot cooler, just as I remember
August 26, 2016

Rated 1 out of 5Â by Angie from Montana Disappointed
I ordered both sets (jewel and pastel) colors of the Old Fashioned Aluminum Tumblers and received them about a month ago. The color on all eight glasses has either begun to fade or is chipping off. I've washed the glasses by hand, they have not been in the dishwasher. I'm disappointed in the quality of the glasses, especially for the $16.95 price I paid for each set.
August 26, 2016

Rated 4 out of 5Â by Sara M Brings me back...
I was looking for an aluminum cup like we had at our cabin when I was little. These are almost just like them. They make cold drinks even colder! That said, the only problem I have is that I didn't see to not put them in the dishwasher (it was not listed on anything in the shipping box or catalog, and you have to go to a specific tab online) and the insides of all the cups turned a strange gray and black color that won't come out. :-( Now nobody wants to use them. So while I would recommend them, but I would also think The Vermont Country Store would take better care to make the no dishwasher instructions a little more prevalent considering the outcome if you do put them through one! I got a set of both sizes and in all colors - VERY expensive - and now most of them are useless.
August 26, 2016

Rated 3 out of 5Â by SWT tumblers
they do remind me of when I was a child however, when I received them, they were very much scratched. I would have liked them to be in good condition, would have loved them more.
August 18, 2016

Rated 1 out of 5Â by ShirleyH One Week & Color Is Coming Off
Very dissatisfied with these tumblers. We have had them about one week (maybe less) and the color is coming off. We have hand washed them exclusively. Never been in dishwasher. Also, we have never stacked them. We ordered the large size and we are happy with the size. Tumblers make drinks super cold instantly. Also a good thing. But the quality is terrible. VCS really shouldn't sell these tumblers. Can't imagine anyone being happy with their purchase. Will be calling Customer Service for refund or replacement.
July 14, 2016