Revisiting DVC...again!

Been to WDW 3 times as a kid. Always stayed off-site. Always wanted to stay onsite. My DH (then BF) came along with on these vacations

When we married and had kids, we took a trip in 2009 and stayed at the Poly. LOVED IT. We're a deluxe kind of family, and the mods and values do not appeal at all.

Listened to the DVC talk. Very interested, but the recession hit,so timing was not good.

Went back again in 2010 - WL. It was very nice. A bit smaller than the Poly (room), but loved the theming during christmas. Re-thought DVC, but 2011 and 2012 had their fair share of issues (not financial) that prevented us from taking action.

Just came back from the YC (5 day stay) and loved it, too, and I'm now thinking of DVC again.

We vacation at least every other year there and spend a lot of money doing so. We only like the deluxe resorts. I can pay cash for a resale (only considering resale), so no financing. Looking to get my feet wet with a small 100 point contract with SSR (one of the lowest MF combined with a low p/p cost. edited to add that we don't have any pref where we stay as long as it is deluxe. We've decided to take the least expensive cost of entry approach to this instead of "buy where you love to stay". We also plan our trips out at least a year in advance. We've visited in april and december. No interest in going during the hot summer months. Perhaps fall, for the F&W (knowing staying at BCV or BWV would be out of the question)

Our two kids are tween aged and love Disney. I'm a bad parent and don't mind pulling them out of school to vacation. We have a boy and a girl and this trip made me realize we will need more privacy space with our lodging.

I'm not interested in using points for exchanging into RCI.

I would like to have enough points to go once a year - my way of thinking is that if Im paying a yearly MF, I should try to go down yearly. I also see our vacatioing changing from less park commando style to more relaxing by the pool.

Does any of what I've described suggest that DVC makes sense for our family?

If you stay mostly, or always, at a deluxe resort, DVC can save you money. However, know that the DVC Villas are not quite up to the same par as Deluxe, as far as furnishings and housekeeping. DVC has limited housekeeping...for stays of 7 nights or less, you will receive trash and towel service on Day 4. That is all they will do, replace your towels and empty the trash cans. If you stay 8 nights or more, you will receive a full housecleaning on Day 4, and Trash and Towel Service on Day 8. Also remember that DVC Studios do not have two beds, unlike a Deluxe class room. DVC studios offer a queen bed and a full sized sleeper sofa, except for OKW, they have 2 queen beds.

I think you need to consider the number of points for the type of accommodations that you want. For summer months a studio is 134 points for a week. A one bedroom is 269 points a week. (April 7 -30 is the same as summer months. First two weeks of Dec is 97 studio/ 197 one bedroom)

We have twin girls (almost 11) and to conserve points, we stay in studios .We have 200 points and usually travel to Disney twice a year: 9/10 days in summer and 4/5 days in winter. We are always borrowing from the next year.

Since you travel every three years, you will have 300 points to play with.

One more thought - this on the "buy cheapest" - remember that you can book your home resort at 11 months, all other DVC properties not until 7 months. If you truly like to plan a year in advance are you going to be okay with booking travel (airfare, etc) a year in advance before you have a place to stay, unless you are okay staying at SSR. One strategy is to book your home resort at 11 months and then try to switch at 7 months - but it does not always work out.

I bought at BWVs because i wanted an Epcot resort but didn't want to pay the money for BCVs (my preferred location). I ended up a couple years later buying a BCV contract so I can stay where i really want to.

Just another thought - is it worth it to buy DVC - yes if you stay deluxe! I love knowing I can go every year for just the annual dues!

Been to WDW 3 times as a kid. Always stayed off-site. Always wanted to stay onsite. My DH (then BF) came along with on these vacations

When we married and had kids, we took a trip in 2009 and stayed at the Poly. LOVED IT. We're a deluxe kind of family, and the mods and values do not appeal at all.

Listened to the DVC talk. Very interested, but the recession hit,so timing was not good.

Went back again in 2010 - WL. It was very nice. A bit smaller than the Poly (room), but loved the theming during christmas. Re-thought DVC, but 2011 and 2012 had their fair share of issues (not financial) that prevented us from taking action.

Just came back from the YC (5 day stay) and loved it, too, and I'm now thinking of DVC again.

We vacation at least every other year there and spend a lot of money doing so. We only like the deluxe resorts. I can pay cash for a resale (only considering resale), so no financing. Looking to get my feet wet with a small 100 point contract with SSR (one of the lowest MF combined with a low p/p cost. edited to add that we don't have any pref where we stay as long as it is deluxe. We've decided to take the least expensive cost of entry approach to this instead of "buy where you love to stay". We also plan our trips out at least a year in advance. We've visited in april and december. No interest in going during the hot summer months. Perhaps fall, for the F&W (knowing staying at BCV or BWV would be out of the question)

Our two kids are tween aged and love Disney. I'm a bad parent and don't mind pulling them out of school to vacation. We have a boy and a girl and this trip made me realize we will need more privacy space with our lodging.

I'm not interested in using points for exchanging into RCI.

I would like to have enough points to go once a year - my way of thinking is that if Im paying a yearly MF, I should try to go down yearly. I also see our vacatioing changing from less park commando style to more relaxing by the pool.

Does any of what I've described suggest that DVC makes sense for our family?

Click to expand...

What is it about deluxe resorts that you find the most beneficial? What do you like best about your stays in deluxe resorts and what would you not like about stays in moderate or value resorts?

We didn't have a preference either because we were just happy to be at WDW. After a couple of years owning the DVC our tastes changed and we found out that we liked other resorts better than our original purchase. We ended up selling and buying where we really loved to stay after we had trouble getting our desired reservations.

Been to WDW 3 times as a kid. Always stayed off-site. Always wanted to stay onsite. My DH (then BF) came along with on these vacations

When we married and had kids, we took a trip in 2009 and stayed at the Poly. LOVED IT. We're a deluxe kind of family, and the mods and values do not appeal at all.

Listened to the DVC talk. Very interested, but the recession hit,so timing was not good.

Went back again in 2010 - WL. It was very nice. A bit smaller than the Poly (room), but loved the theming during christmas. Re-thought DVC, but 2011 and 2012 had their fair share of issues (not financial) that prevented us from taking action.

Just came back from the YC (5 day stay) and loved it, too, and I'm now thinking of DVC again.

We vacation at least every other year there and spend a lot of money doing so. We only like the deluxe resorts. I can pay cash for a resale (only considering resale), so no financing. Looking to get my feet wet with a small 100 point contract with SSR (one of the lowest MF combined with a low p/p cost. edited to add that we don't have any pref where we stay as long as it is deluxe. We've decided to take the least expensive cost of entry approach to this instead of "buy where you love to stay". We also plan our trips out at least a year in advance. We've visited in april and december. No interest in going during the hot summer months. Perhaps fall, for the F&W (knowing staying at BCV or BWV would be out of the question)

Our two kids are tween aged and love Disney. I'm a bad parent and don't mind pulling them out of school to vacation. We have a boy and a girl and this trip made me realize we will need more privacy space with our lodging.

I'm not interested in using points for exchanging into RCI.

I would like to have enough points to go once a year - my way of thinking is that if Im paying a yearly MF, I should try to go down yearly. I also see our vacatioing changing from less park commando style to more relaxing by the pool.

Does any of what I've described suggest that DVC makes sense for our family?

Click to expand...

DVC for a studio will save you money in this situation, a 1 BR likely won't but may give you more value. You need to plan ahead and be prepared to give up housekeeping and accept some minor other compromises. If you decide to buy and just want deluxe and want to try most or all of the resorts, SSR is likely to be the best value.

Value dislikes: (from what I can see without having stayed in one)
Smaller rooms
double beds
not close to parks/attractions
"loud" theming
no slides for pool (although I know mods have them)
exterior hallways (seems motel like to me)

I just get the impression that with the values it seems like they are trying to cram in as many people into the complex as possible...seems sardine-like packed to me somehow.

If I were to buy, I have decided to do it with SSR because of the longer contract, lower price/point and lower MF.

Now the number of points...it seems that 100 would allow me to go every other year staying in a studio during either magic or adventure seasons, with a few points left over. BCV, OKW or SSR one bedrooms are possible, too, during adventure season. It seems as if I would need 120-130 points if I wanted to stay at a one bedroom during magic season, though - or bank and borrow for those trips to combine for 300. Is my math correct?

It also looks like 120-130ish points would allow me to go every year during adventure or magic season in a studio.

WWYD? 100 points at first and see how that works going every other year, or 120-130 to allow me to go every year?

Looks like you have a good plan. SSR is a good value for all your stated reasons. Just so you know, SSR does have exterior doorways/entrances. Some are in "hallways" but have no carpet and are cold/hot depending on the season. This is the main reason my DD does not like SSR. Pools fit your criteria though and the grounds are beautiful. It's a great resort.

Personally, I would go for the 125 to 150 range to give you the flexibility to be in a 1br if you want to (they are much nicer than a studio especially for a longer trip). The space is awesome. We like the studios because there is just 2 of us and we like to go multiple times a year. Studios stretch our points but I would certainly not compare them to a deluxe experience.

If I were to buy, I have decided to do it with SSR because of the longer contract, lower price/point and lower MF.

Now the number of points...it seems that 100 would allow me to go every other year staying in a studio during either magic or adventure seasons, with a few points left over. BCV, OKW or SSR one bedrooms are possible, too, during adventure season. It seems as if I would need 120-130 points if I wanted to stay at a one bedroom during magic season, though - or bank and borrow for those trips to combine for 300. Is my math correct?

It also looks like 120-130ish points would allow me to go every year during adventure or magic season in a studio.

WWYD? 100 points at first and see how that works going every other year, or 120-130 to allow me to go every year?

Click to expand...

Quote me months/weeks of the year instead of Disney seasons since I don't follow the seasons at all (not for 15 years). I know when I want to go and don't base it on the number of points required. But those seasons could change (and they do based on the holidays that fall during those time frames).

Because, if you were planning on going the first week of December and not staying at SSR (which should be on your "con" list instead of "pro" list because of the exterior corridors), you would have to wait until seven months out to book. BWV, BCV, BLT and others can be very difficult to get during that time. If you are looking at BWV or BCV for October because of Food & Wine, that, too, is tough to get at seven months out. Studios are usually booked first because they require fewer points and sleep just about the same number of people as the one bedroom. So at seven months out, yo might not be able to get a studio at BWV or BCV for F&W.

OKW is the same as SSR, exterior corridors (like an apartment or town house complex). So, if you can only stay at SSR or OKW because that is all that is available at seven months, would you be happy? If not, buy at a resort that meets your "pro" list. You will pay more for the points and the dues will be higher, but you will probably be happier at one of the other resorts.

We like to travel in april - the weather is nice at that time of year...but avoid easter and march break like the plague. We like early christmas, too. We've stayed at WL at that time, so that is off the bucket list - I know that you would have to own there to stay at WL during that time.

No real need for the F&W festival. Would be happy at either SSR or OKW. Seeing as we've been to WDW park commando style 3 times now, I see our park experiences slowing down where we spend more time at the resort and less at the parks.

I should clarify with the exterior hallways. I've seen SSR at the open house and we went to Olivia's @ OKW for dinner once and toured the resort. Those entryways are nice because it does resemble a townhouse (we live in one currently). When we stayed offsite, it was at a condo that had a similar set up. I just don't like the exterior hallways of the values that go on forever and have windows that overlook them.

We like to travel in april - the weather is nice at that time of year...but avoid easter and march break like the plague. We like early christmas, too. We've stayed at WL at that time, so that is off the bucket list - I know that you would have to own there to stay at WL during that time.

No real need for the F&W festival. Would be happy at either SSR or OKW. Seeing as we've been to WDW park commando style 3 times now, I see our park experiences slowing down where we spend more time at the resort and less at the parks.

I should clarify with the exterior hallways. I've seen SSR at the open house and we went to Olivia's @ OKW for dinner once and toured the resort. Those entryways are nice because it does resemble a townhouse (we live in one currently). When we stayed offsite, it was at a condo that had a similar set up. I just don't like the exterior hallways of the values that go on forever and have windows that overlook them.

Click to expand...

Makes sense. OKW was our first home and it's our favorite of all. We also like SSR for the same reason. Wide open spaces, lots of room to move around the resort. We own at VWL for the taste of Yellowstone (we used to live in Montana and Yellowstone was-and still is-a favorite place to go).

The first week of December is extremely popular with members. So if you plan to go then, make sure you like where you buy. It's real hard to change resorts at 7 months out for that week.