Jimmy Kimmel‘s Halloween candy prank is the gift that keeps on giving.

While he already released this year’s compilation of clips of parents filming themselves telling their kids they ate all the Halloween candy earlier this week on Jimmy Kimmel Live, it turns out he received even more submissions after the deadline that just couldn’t be ignored.

“As you know, we started what I believe to be the most important Halloween tradition since someone rhymed the words ‘Trick or treat’ with ‘Smell my feet,’ ” said Kimmel, 48, in reference to the beloved YouTube challenge, which is now in its sixth year.

And the special bonus edition certainly didn’t disappoint, ranging everywhere from shocked gasps to teary declarations of anger.

“All gone? All gone, Mommy?” one girl repeatedly asked her mother, cradling an empty Trick-or-Treat bucket to her chest.

RELATED VIDEO: Jimmy Kimmel Explains the Challenges of Potty Training

In another household, one brother desperately tried to comfort his older sister about the news, promising to share his candy – only to realize that was gone, too. Another kid took off running — all the way down the block!

And of course, there are the kids that are just a little too Internet-savvy for the prank to work.

“I know this is the Jimmy Kimmel trick,” said one boy matter-of-factly. “That used to be my favorite show.”