You'll Never Guess Who Selena Gomez Left Justin Bieber's AMA After-Party With

It's been a confusing week for Jelena fans. First, Justin Bieber serenaded Selena Gomez with two songs (including "Sorry") on the piano over the weekend, and they definitely appeared close in a video of them hanging out together. Next, they reportedly asked to sit together at the American Music Awards. Their request was reportedly denied, so they simply sat across the stage from each other as they each performed songs inspired by their on-again, off-again relationship. Or at least, we think that's how it went down, since the camera never panned out to confirm whether they were in the audience during each other's AMAs performances. After the award show, Selena actually went to the after-party Justin hosted.

Advertisement - Continue Reading Below

Still with us? 'Cause the story is about to take another twist. (We know, we know, it's a lot.)

After the after-party, Justin actually left with Halsey, who he was spotted getting super close to on stage recently. But if it was more than a friendly ride home, Selena didn't seem to mind. She was smiling as she left Biebs' after-party with Hailee Steinfeld.

Splash News

So maybe Selena was just at Justin's party as a friend. Or maybe... just maybe... based on that sneaky little smile on her face, there's something going on between them, and she can't wait to tell Hailee all about it.

Splash News

Advertisement - Continue Reading Below

After all, can it be a total coincidence that Justin and Selena wore matching outfits on the red carpet? Or is that just wishful thinking on our part?