Buying vs Leasing Comparison

More and more drivers are weighing up whether it's better to buy or lease a brand-new car. We know which we prefer, but buying and leasing each have their own benefits and potential drawbacks and which best suits you really depends on your preferences and circumstances.

Whatever your position, there are a few things you should consider before you make your decision.

Benefit

Leasing

Buying

Lower up-front cost

Brand new car

Delivered to your door

New car every few years

You own the car

You can sell the car

No mileage costs

Advantages of leasing a car

1

Lower up-front cost

The costs of initial rental are usually much lower than the deposit for a brand-new vehicle – and certainly much cheaper than saving up to buy the car outright. The ongoing lease cost tends to be lower, too - and it’s fixed each month, so you know what you’re paying.

2

Added value

Road tax and breakdown cover are included in the monthly lease price and your MOT and other maintenance costs can also be included in your lease package (for an additional fee), so you don’t have to pay out separately when the time comes. If you’re a business customer, you may also get tax benefits through business contract hire agreements.

3

You get a brand-new car

Having a brand-new car means that you can enjoy all the latest entertainment and safety features – and you don’t have to worry about the car’s history like you do with a used car. What’s more, you get the reliability and fuel economy of a new car.

You can drive a new car every few years

Who doesn’t love the feeling of driving a new car? At the end of your lease, you can pick out another brand-new car (subject to status) and enjoy all the benefits all over again and you never have to worry about depreciation.

Business Contract Hire benefits:

Whether you need a single vehicle or a fleet of cars find out more about your business leasing options.

In summary, the advantages of leasing:

Costs such as road tax and breakdown recovery are included in the monthly rental

Costs such as MOT and maintenance can also be covered as part of the lease (for an additional fee)

No depreciation worries

Only paying for part of the vehicle cost

Enjoy the benefits of a brand new car including better fuel economy and safety features

Simple delivery to your front door

Hand the car back at the end of the contract - no hassle in having to sell a used car

If you are a business, you may get positive tax benefits through business contract hire agreements

No worries about the history of the vehicle as all our vehicles are brand new

Disadvantages of leasing a car

1

You don’t own the car

This seems like an obvious one; on a contract hire agreement, there is no option to purchase the vehicle so you must return the vehicle at the end of the contract.

2

Wear and tear

Wear and tear is still your responsibility, like it would be if you owned the car. You can read more in our leasing wear and tear guide.

3

Must be able to pay

You must make your monthly requirements and if you have a poor credit history, you may also find it difficult to pass the leasing finance process – and you can’t just save up and pay the whole cost up front like you can if you’re buying.

4

You need to watch your mileage

When you’re agreeing your lease contract, you set your annual mileage limit. If you exceed this during your contract, you’ll need to pay excess mileage charges as an additional cost on top of your monthly contract fee.The cost will have been outlined in the process of agreeing your lease, but the extra cost can still come as a bit of a surprise if you’ve clocked a lot of extra miles.

Advantages of buying a new car

You own the car

Depending on how you buy it, the car is yours from the moment you drive it home. That pink V5C document means you’re free to make any legal customisations you want.

2

You can sell it

Because you own the car, you can sell it whenever you want. So, if you want to upgrade, change models, or just need the cash, you’re free to arrange the sale and agree the highest price.

3

No extra mileage costs

There’s no limit on the number of miles you drive, so you don’t need to worry about extra costs on top of what you’ve already paid for the car. You only need to think about mileage for insurance and maintenance.

In summary, the advantages of buying:

Ownership of vehicle

Sell the car anytime

There is no mileage penalty

The car can be modified if required for business

No worries about past history

Disadvantages of buying a new car

1

Depreciation

New cars lose their value dramatically, so your car starts to lose value as soon as you buy it. In fact, most cars depreciate fastest in the first year of ownership. This means that, unless you’re buying a classic car, your car is unlikely to ever be worth as much as you paid for it and you won’t make back what you paid when you come to sell.

2

Higher up-front costs

Even if you’re paying for the car over many months, the lump sum up-front is often much more than the initial rental on a lease car.

3

You pay for road tax and breakdown cover

Unlike with a lease contract, breakdown cover and road tax need to be paid separately to the cost of the car. Unexpected post-warranty repairs can be costly, especially if they start to accumulate as the car gets older.

4

Cars develop more problems as they age

After a few years, your new car will just be your car and as it gets older it’s more likely to experience mechanical, electrical and computer issues. This is largely due to wear and tear and ageing components, and it means that your wallet is likely to take more of a hit the longer you have the car

5

Selling your car can be a pain

It’s not always easy to sell a car and there are many pitfalls you need to avoid on the way to a successful private sale. There are services that take away much of the labour, but they also take some of the money, making the whole process that bit less worthwhile.

Vehicle depreciation

One of the key benefits of choosing to lease is not having to worry about how much value a new car will lose.

Our website uses cookies

We use performance, social media and advertising cookies to improve your browser experience, integrate with social media and show relevant, personalised advertisements tailored to your interests. Click ‘Accept’ to accept these cookies and continue browsing. For more information or to amend your preferences, visit our privacy policy.