Posted on
Thursday 28 May 2009

Top Senate Republican strategists tell POLITICO that, barring unknown facts about Judge Sonia Sotomayor, the GOP plans no scorched-earth opposition to her confirmation as a Supreme Court justice. More than 24 hours after the White House unveiling, no senator has come out in opposition to Sotomayor’s confirmation. "The sentiment is overwhelming that the Senate should do due diligence but should not make a mountain out of a molehill," said a top Senate Republican aide. "If there’s no ‘there’ there, we shouldn’t try to create one."

Barring something currently unforeseen, this one is over.

Even so, the process of the appearance of a fight still holds a lot of potential benefits for Democrats and progressives. First, a weak opposition to Sotomayor by Senate Republicans could open a real "rootsgap" between Republican Senate leaders and an activist base that has long rabidly focused on the judiciary. Second, Democrats can continue to concern troll the racially charged conservative media attacks on Sotomayor, which threaten both to drive a further wedge between Latinos and Republicans, and also to further the process story of "Republicans in serious electoral trouble."

Confirming Sotomayor will be a substantive victory for Democrats [at least compared to the sort of nominee a Republican would have picked, if not over Souter’s rulings]. Right now, however, with that victory all but guaranteed, we need to keep hammering on the process of the fight, because it can do real long-term damage to the conservative movement and the Republican Party.

At the risk of extreme naivity, I disagree with "we need to keep hammering on the process of the fight, because it can do real long-term damage to the conservative movement and the Republican Party." I’m not sure that’s even right. Right now, the Republican Party could help itself by slacking up on these reflex attacks, but instead, they’re bringing out their "nasty’s" for no real reason. Their criticism of Sotomayor is because Obama the Democrat picked her. Why hammer them when they’re doing such a good job by themselves? And I don’t want to do damage to the conservative movement and the Republican Party. What I want is for them to have an internal rebellion and purge themselves. In my opinion, when we fight them gratuitously, we interfere with that process.