Should It Be Illegal to Lay Off Pregnant or Postpartum Women?

Tough times call for tough measures and for some companies that means handing pink slips to even their pregnant and postpartum employees. While it may seem unethical, it's completely legal. A recent New York Times report said:

It may not sound fair, as the national layoff tsunami is swamping even households with new infants, or babies en route. But it is entirely legal to lay off a pregnant woman or a woman on maternity leave — as long as the employer can make the case that she is being let go for a reason unrelated to her pregnancy.

Do you think there should be a law protecting mamas-to-be or new mums?

I have been with my company for 5 years and am facing a layoff 10 days before my due date as our store is moving and merging with another. If I am laid off I will lose not only my FMLA but also my short term disability and my insurance to pay for the delivery of this child. Is that right? Is that fair & just? I do not have another source of income in the event that it does happen so guess what, all of those tax payers will see 3 more mouths to feed, shelter and insure as I CAN NOT immediately go back out into the work force with a newborn on my breast and stapled like a 5 year olds art project. Even if I was proactive and tried to find something now I would not be hired BECAUSE I am 7 months pregnant; though I am sure that would not be the "reason." Am I asking for special treatment? Yes & no.

If someone isn't doing her job, she shouldn't be protected by pregnancy any more than she should be protected by her race, sex, religion, etc. It's always unfortunate when someone loses a job, and losing one with a new baby or one on the way is particularly rough. Any reasonable employer should realize that a new mom may not be able to give her usual 110%, but if the bare minimum isn't being done, let her go.

Under FMLA employers are required to put you back in your job or a similar job when you return from leave. Before or after that should be up to the employer as long as they are eliminating your position and it isn't related to your status as a mom-to-be or new mom. I agree with the other posts, people who have kids get layed off and men with babies get layed off, a new mom should not be treated any different.

What's next not laying off people with kids, or people with more than 2 kids, or how about people that are single and don't have room mates? Don't they all need protection? We don't need to give people protection from losing their jobs, we need people to be motivated and not want to lose their jobs.

I don't think anyone should get special treatment. To be honest, I don't think a woman should be fired JUST because she's pregnant, but if she's a slacker or doesn't do her job I don't think the company should hold on to her "because she's pregnant". Thats not fair to the non-pregnant women.

If they get legal rights from being laid off than every working parent should have legal rights. They are just a worker, yeah it sucks if these women do get laid for for a reason other than their condition, but it sucks for everyone else as well.

If they aren't doing their job well or the company doesn't need their position anymore, it shouldn't matter if they are pregnant or have a new child. Excuses of any sort (related to this or not) only go so far IMHO. When I was working I was really frustrated when all of the people in my department with kids got special leeway to leave early, come in late, and generally slack off. Some of it is understandable, but when it interferes with performance (especially when others have to pick up the slack), they should be treated like anyone else. You can't always have your cake and eat it too. But if they are fired willy nilly just BECAUSE they are pregnant, then that is probably wrong.

Ugh, when I was on Maternity leave with my daughter I got fired - I found out through a letter from the insurance company saying I didn't have insurance anymore (which was fine because I get it through my husband) still it ridiculous but worked out and I couldn't be more happy to be outta there!

My work JUST laid off a guy here who had a baby a month and a half ago. He was a good worker but they said it was because of "lack of work". The next week someone else was starting in HIS position! This has bothered me enough to not want to be a part of the company...