Kelly Osborn is a woman with a steel spine. She sits surrounded by friends and family watching the mysterious death of her daughter play out on Dr. Phil.

Osborn was a guest on the show, face to face with her daughter Sheena's ex-fiance, Joe Genoese, who agreed to take a lie detector test on national television to prove he was not involved in her death. The test suggested otherwise. The FBI agent that administered the test determined Genoese was deceptive when asked if he killed Sheena.

Osborn has long thought Bradenton Beach Police botched the death investigation, who ruled it a suicide, saying Sheena hanged herself in a her hotel room shower. Now with the results of the lie detector test, Osborn and her friends are more sure than ever that Sheena met with foul play.

Unsatisfied with the original police investigation, Osborn launched her own investigation into Sheena's death, and came to the conclusion that police were in over their heads. They requested that the FDLE step in. She says Bradenton Beach Police Chief Sam Speciale has refused to revisit the case and even admitted he didn't watch the Dr. Phil expose bombshell.