Gerard Butler

Arguments for: -Personally I can’t think of any-If I had to stretch, I’d say that some people think he did a good job in Coriolanus and it’s making an Oscar run so the studio might be pushing for it-Some horny ladies are into this Scottish mess. Specifically, his rabid fan club which is mobilising to get him some kind of nomination. Contain your laughter. -He does qualify as Man, I suppose. Barely evolved, but Man nonethelessArguments against:-So many. Like, he’s gross-Machine Gun Preacher sucked. -Is the MiniVan Majority, those who don’t belong to the Gerry B fanclub, actually going to see Coriolanus???-He’s not American. If PEOPLE is to go two years in a row naming a non-USA to the SMA title, it’ll be Robert Pattinson before Gerard Butler.