Council ban on ‘offensive’ remarks may clash with Human Rights Act

Controversial plans to ban Belfast councillors from using “offensive expressions” may conflict with the right to freedom of expression, a unionist has warned.

UUP Cllr Jeff Dudgeon was speaking after City Hall passed a Sinn Fein proposal preventing councillors from using “offensive expressions in reference to any person or section of society”.

Branding the move “ludicrous”, Cllr Dudgeon said the plan may be open to legal challenge as it could conflict with Article 10 of the European Convention on Human Rights, which guarantees freedom of expression.

Cllr Bunting, who was recently banned by Facebook for 30 days after posting messages in support of a member of far-right group Britain First, added: “We must be able to speak our minds and stand up for our constituents.

“Do we have to wait until people are dying on our streets until people actually speak about Islam, before we speak about the Koran, and what it says in it?”

Responding to Cllr Bunting’s comments, SF member Jim McVeigh told the chamber: “We just got a glimpse of the nasty side of this city in some of those remarks.

“These comments are a very good example of why we should make these changes (in the proposal).”

Alliance Cllr Emmet McDonough Brown, who backed the motion, said “damaging remarks” have been made in the council chamber about sections of society here.

He added: “We feel there are minority groups in this city who are being targeted at a political level and it is important that we uphold their rights in their absence.”