CIA Response to Dec. 31 NY Times Editorial

January 7, 2008

The
following letter to the editor, published in the January 7 edition of The New
York Times, responds to a December 31 editorial:

To the Editor:

Your Dec. 31 editorial "Looking at America"
does a great disservice to the men and women of the C.I.A. You describe the lawful questioning of hardened
terrorists as "sickening behavior." The interrogation methods the C.I.A. has employed over the years have been
closely reviewed by lawyers and others in the executive branch, and they have
been briefed to our oversight committees in Congress. That is a fact.

It is absurd to suggest that the C.I.A. has an interest in any process that would produce bad
intelligence. To dismiss as "barbaric acts" a small, carefully run
effort that has disrupted terrorist plots and saved innocent lives -- and done
so in accord with the law -- is wrong and unfair.

The officers of the C.I.A.
who put their lives on the line to gather intelligence on the terrorist threat
-- and are as committed as anyone to protecting American ideals -- deserve
better.