DVDActive uses cookies to remember your actions, such as your answer in the poll. Cookies are
also used by third-parties for statistics, social media and advertising. By using this website, it is
assumed that you agree to this.

Watchmen: The Complete Motion Comic (US - BD)

Who Watches The Watchmen? Marcus Watches The Watchmen and on BD too

Feature

‘Who Watches the Watchmen?’ Well now we all can and not only in the new big screen adaptation by Zack Synder. We lucky masses get to see this new motion comic version of the classic graphic novel by Alan Moore, Dave Gibbons and colourist John Higgins, and frankly it’s a staggering piece of work.

Set in an alternative 1985 where Nixon is still President, cars run on electricity, airships fill the sky and a super powered being works with the US government, Watchmen begins with the death of Edward Blake (AKA the Comedian). Blake is thrown from his high-rise apartment window and this begins a series of events that leads to the literal changing of the world.

I shall start by saying that I am a massive fan of Watchmen and have been for a long time. I’ve read and re-read the graphic novel countless times and every time I do I get something else out of it. I feel that Watchmen is one of those perfect stories, with its many dense elements and high level of detail all coming together exquisitely for a comic book finale to top all comic book finales. So how does this all translate in this motion comic form?

Well, for starters, for those of you who don’t know, a motion comic is literally just that—the original graphic novel with ever so slight animation to give it motion. The speech bubbles and boxes are all intact. Nothing is overly animated in regards to mouths speaking or liberties taken with new frames to fill the gaps between the original work’s panels; this is literally the graphic novel coming to life with a narrator reading the dialogue in all of the characters voices.

The Watchmen narrator is Tom Stechschulte and for the most part he does a grand job providing enough thought and understanding of the work to make the entire experience very rewarding. His Rorschach and Dr Manhattan voices are great representations—and let's face it, if those two are done well that's half the battle. Generally every voice he does fits the style of how I'd imaged them in my head, though it's admittedly sometimes a little weird when he’s doing the female characters' voices and as it goes with these sorts of things, but sometimes the emphasis on lines sometimes doesn’t feel like it has the right intent you placed on it as a reader, but none of this is enough to take away from the whole —and what a whole Watchmen it is.

With the story split down into the twelve chapters as in the graphic novel, barely a frame or line of dialogue is missed and unlike in Snyder's current big screen version this includes the Black Freighter elements, which is a subtle but hugely important part to the entire Watchmen experience, giving that extra pinch of insight into the story's fallout without you even realising it until it's importance hits you.

Sometimes the small moments of nudity are ever so slightly edited from the original artwork, dropping the odd nipple out of frame and what not and once in a while a line or two of dialogue is missed out or passed over for the sake of flow of the story. The only real exclusion from having the entire Watchmen experience are the extracts that are included at the end of each chapter in the novel. Which considering they are made up of autobiographies, book extracts or written reports is an understandable omission (for a die hard, they were still a little missed though).

To see all of this artwork so beautifully realised in another medium is a delight, but the added fact it remains so engaging and as powerful as the graphic novel is surely a rare occurrence in the history of these sorts of thing. Dave Gibbons supervised the project and the entire team behind it have done a respectful and outright stellar job of keeping Watchmen, well, Watchmen. The little tweaks on key moments with the ever so slight animation works wonders, the subtle score that's been added to it captures the tone perfectly and just seeing it all this bright and clear and frankly big, is a Watchmen fans dream come true. I’ve watched it a couple of times already and I can imagine that I’ll no doubt leave it playing on my TV screen through a day, providing one of the greatest background art shows I could imagine, so all in all I’m happy as Nite Owl getting his swing back on his Owlship.

Video

If you know the graphic novel well or have even glanced at it, the motion comic is every panel captured on the screen as bright and beautiful as it has ever looked. It's Gibbons art shining off of the TV screen with John Higgin's colours popping like they've never popped before.

In some scenes, the boldness of the artwork is a joy. There are large areas that are one colour or deep blacks and this holds up extraordinarily well. You'll notice some dancing grain in the blue of Dr. Manhattan's skin and initially I was a bit miffed as to why he was the only element showing this, maybe it was the shade of blue he was or something? After a few scenes with him I concluded this had to be intentional to give Jon Osterman's blue self a different feel to everything else around him and frankly it works well for the character.

Audio

In all honesty this probably didn't need a 5.1 mix at all. All of the audio sits in the front speakers and other than adding a slightly fuller feel to the audio, the rears are barely used.

Saying that, the narration is clear and as I mentioned before the music is great and sits well in the mix even if it all resides largely in the fronts.

Extras

I'll start by saying the cover art and general look of this release is great. The spine is exactly what I'd want from a Watchmen product and while this isn't an extra as such, it has to be said that having such satisfactory packaging for a product is enough to be deemed an 'special feature' as far as I'm concerned.

Unfortunately there's not a big blow out Watchmen documentary on this release—a shame because Warner normally spoil us with their other animated projects.

Watchmen wise they've included one of the online Video Journals for the Watchmen movie, that focuses on Dave Gibbons but running at a mere two minutes and forty seven seconds it's not exactly rich with detail.

Other than that there's access to a scene from the movie via BD-Live and while I'm usually pretty down on the use of BD-Live, the Warner Bros. version of this was actually quite good and easy to look around. Oh, and there's a Digital Copy included too.

Lastly, in a bit of cross promotion, the sneak peak at the new and frankly great Wonder Woman animated feature (00:10:26)is thrown in.

Overall

Anyone who loves the Watchmen really should seek this out. I don't know how much better it is than the much cheaper standard definition DVD as I haven’t been able to compare, but I can say compared to the downloadable version I had been watching over the last few months it's a solid step up in quality.

Having seen the Zack Snyder movie on the big screen and not wishing to throw any negativity towards it, I can whole-heartedly say that I found The Motion Comics to be a far more rewarding and satisfying Watchmen experience. This represents a genuine alternative to experiencing the story in its entirety outside of the pages and really is a great way to quite literally watch the Watchmen and fans should eat it up.

* Note: The images on this page are not representative of the Blu-ray release.

Advertisements

Comments

Reply

Message

Enter the message here then press submit. The username, password and message are required. Please make the message constructive, you are fully responsible for the legality of anything you contribute. Terms & conditions apply.

i just want to add, it is a fantastic addition to any fan's collection. but if you are in fact VERY familar with the graphic novel from the begining of the disc to the end you will notice frames of art work left out and dialog left out as well. it is NOT an exact duplication/translation to the motion comic format. but it is fantastic non the less.

whats with the recent trend of not giving a full ticket to see a movie for free with these things? i remember when dvds either came with a pass to see a movie or at the very least the movie cash was worth 10$ or more so you were covered no matter what. now lately, they give you like 7 or 8 dollars....whats that about?

Oddly enough, probably the last ten dvd's I bought that included "Movie Cash" had the tickets go unused, either because I just didn't have enough time to use them before they expired, forgot they came with the vouchers, or in the case of "The Dark Knight", I had already had to purchase my tickets in advance to the two screenings I actually attended in Imax, and ended up with two vouchers that went unused.

What's funny though, I do recall a point several years back that I used a "Movie Cash" ticket at an AMC in Orlando that was good for $10, and the ticket was only $7.50; oddly enough, the box office girl gave me CASH BACK for the difference. Only time that has ever happened, and I didn't question it any more than I questioned a 7-11 clerk who once charged me for a pack of cigarettes when purchasing a cartoon.

whats with the recent trend of not giving a full ticket to see a movie for free with these things? i remember when dvds either came with a pass to see a movie or at the very least the movie cash was worth 10$ or more so you were covered no matter what. now lately, they give you like 7 or 8 dollars....whats that about?

My guess is about as good as yours, but like just about everything else that's been going wrong in the world lately, I guess this is another one for the ol' "blame it on the recession/bad U.S. economy" file. Still, I'm glad it allowed me to not have to pay the full $8.50 for the 4:35 matinee on Saturday....

whats with the recent trend of not giving a full ticket to see a movie for free with these things? i remember when dvds either came with a pass to see a movie or at the very least the movie cash was worth 10$ or more so you were covered no matter what. now lately, they give you like 7 or 8 dollars....whats that about?

anyway...they're really pushing this thing because even xbox live here in canada is offering the first 4 chapters.

This is a brilliant work, not sure why a second actor of the female persuasion wasn't hired as well but Tom Stechschulte does quite an admirable job. The musical score by Lennie Moore is absolutely perfect in every way (actually much better than the film score by Tyler Bates). Any fan of the graphic novel will need to have this (especially if you're coming home from the new movie with a slight sting of bewildered disappointment). I do wish that some behind the scenes material had been included but that notwithstanding this is an excellent presentation.

I want to like the film (haven't seen it yet) but I have no interest in graphic novels. A part of me wishes I did, but I can't get into them.

I was intersted in reading the review but no disrespect to Marcus (as I think he's doing a bang up job with the reviews) I ended up doing the same thing I do when trying to read graphic novels, I ended up yawning.

I used to read the odd comic when I was younger but it was things like the original Star Wars or Indiana Jones adaptations but back then there was no video or DVD to re-experience the film with so maybe I stuck with them cos that's all there was.

I appreciate this might (as a post) seem like a rather long winded way of saying 'comics suck' but it isn't and I'm not. I just wonder from time to time what it is about them that switches my brain off.