Evaluation of Oral Tobacco as a Harm Reduction Method for Smokers

The safety and scientific validity of this study is the responsibility of the study sponsor and investigators. Listing a study does not mean it has been evaluated by the U.S. Federal Government.
Read our disclaimer for details.

ClinicalTrials.gov Identifier: NCT00711100

Recruitment Status
:
Completed

First Posted
: July 8, 2008

Results First Posted
: September 16, 2015

Last Update Posted
: May 12, 2017

Sponsor:

University of Minnesota - Clinical and Translational Science Institute

Collaborator:

National Cancer Institute (NCI)

Information provided by (Responsible Party):

University of Minnesota - Clinical and Translational Science Institute

Recently, tobacco companies have developed new oral tobacco products that are purportedly less harmful than conventional tobacco products. These products have not been tested by independent research for their health effects or consumer palatability. In addition, it is not known if these products will be used in addition to cigarette smoking or as a substitute to cigarettes. These two studies will examine four oral tobacco products to answer some of these questions.

The goals of this first study will be to examine: 1) the brand of oral tobacco products which is preferred by cigarette smokers and the pattern and amount of product use when used as a switching tool; 2) the characteristics that are associated with product choice; 3) nicotine exposure from these products; and 4) the withdrawal symptoms from the tobacco products and potential for continued use.

Specifically, our primary aims hypotheses were: 1) the product that will be chosen by most smokers will be based on taste and sensory aspects of the product with products higher in nicotine content more likely to be chosen as the preferred product; and 2) subjects will experience no difficulty using the product for complete cigarette substitution, but a small minority will engage in dual product use.

For the secondary aims, we hypothesized: 1) that compared to the subjects' own brand of cigarettes, the biomarkers for exposure for the oral tobacco products will be significantly lower; 2) withdrawal symptoms from the oral products are likely to occur, but are likely to be mild compared to cigarette withdrawal.

This study will be accomplished by allowing subjects to sample the products and choose one oral tobacco product that they will use instead of cigarettes for a two week period. After the two weeks, they will discontinue all tobacco use and withdrawal symptoms and abstinence rates will be observed.

Subjects will attend an orientation visit where the study will be explained in detail. Interested subjects will sign a consent form and be scheduled to return for baseline measures. Subjects will have a review of medical history to verify that they are in generally good health and do not have contraindications to the study products. Eligible subjects will collect one week of baseline measures while smoking at their normal rate: measures include daily diaries of smoking, questionnaires and urine samples. At the second baseline visit, they will receive samples of the oral tobacco products. The tobacco products tested are five novel oral products recently introduced to the market: 1) Camel Snus (higher nicotine); 2) General Snus (higher nicotine); 3) Marlboro Snus (lower nicotine); and two compressed tobacco tablets, 4) Ariva (lower nicotine), or 5) Stonewall (higher nicotine). All of these tobacco products are purported to have reduced levels of tobacco-specific nitrosamines.

During sample weeks, subjects will be given 10 pouches/tablets of each product in a within-subject design and instructed to use at least three of the daily products in the morning of sample day and resume smoking in the afternoon and through the following day. They will sample the next product in a similar manner. The order of product was randomized. All subjects will sample all five products. This design will allow a short, but adequate trial of each product to determine preference. After the sampling weeks, subjects will choose the product they will want to use to quit smoking. They will be supplied that product over the next two weeks.

During the two weeks of product use during smoking abstinence, subjects will come to weekly clinic visits and then a follow-up visits at 1 week and a phone call at 4 weeks after the end of treatment. At baseline, and 2 weeks post cigarette cessation, subjects will bring in a urine sample from their first morning void and bloods will be drawn. At each visit, subjects will have vital signs obtained (blood pressure, heart rate, weight and carbon monoxide level), they will complete several subjective forms regarding tobacco use, withdrawal symptoms, and mood. Subjects will receive brief behavioral counseling for smoking cessation at all visits.

In addition, during the sample weeks and at the end of two weeks of study product use, subjects will submit three used chews that will be sent to CDC to be analyzed for the tobacco constituents.

All subjects will sample Camel Snus and determine if they would prefer to use this product during the abstinence phase over the other products sampled. Sampling period (duration: 1/2 day) requires use of at least 3 samples of Camel Snus. Intervention period (duration: 2 weeks) involves ad libitum daily use (if Camel Snus is chosen for use) during abstinence phase.

All subjects will sample Marlboro Snus and determine if they would prefer to use this product during the abstinence phase over the other products sampled. Sampling period (duration: 1/2 day) requires use of at least 3 samples of Marlboro Snus. Intervention period (duration: 2 weeks) involves ad libitum daily use (if Marlboro Snus is chosen for use) during abstinence phase.

All subjects will sample Stonewall and determine if they would prefer to use this product during the abstinence phase over the other products sampled. Sampling period (duration: 1/2 day) requires use of at least 3 samples of Stonewall. Intervention period (duration: 2 weeks) involves ad libitum daily use (if Stonewall is chosen for use) during abstinence phase.

All subjects will sample Ariva and determine if they would prefer to use this product during the abstinence phase over the other products sampled. Sampling period (duration: 1/2 day) requires use of at least 3 samples of Ariva. Intervention period (duration: 2 weeks) involves ad libitum daily use (if Ariva is chosen for use) during abstinence phase.

All subjects will sample General Snus and determine if they would prefer to use this product during the abstinence phase over the other products sampled. Sampling period (duration: 1/2 day) requires use of at least 3 samples of General Snus. Intervention period (duration: 2 weeks) involves ad libitum daily use (if General Snus is chosen for use) during abstinence phase.

Choosing to participate in a study is an important personal decision. Talk with your doctor and family members or friends about deciding to join a study. To learn more about this study, you or your doctor may contact the study research staff using the contacts provided below. For general information, Learn About Clinical Studies.