Is the Staffing Shortage a Myth?

Chris Nedza|April 23, 2019|12:58 PM

At a recent conference I attended, the attendees were buzzing about the number one problem in the salon industry—a shortage of stylists. I listened as a CEO of a very large organization explained the reason for this shortage is a combination of: 1) For-profit schools and cosmetology schools have been defunded, so fewer students are attending; 2) The aging baby boomers have not been replaced by enough workers; and 3) The economy is so good that we’re at full employment. These are all valid points and realities.

Later the same night, I spoke to a salon owner who dejectedly told me he couldn’t compete with his larger competitor because “they had more resources, including a full-time recruiter and HR professional.”

By the end of the night I wondered how anybody made it in the beauty industry. Is there really a shortage of staff? Is all lost?

The truth is there are more stylists available to work for you than you could ever hire – they just work for someone else. And guess what? Many are just one bad day away from leaving their current salon. I’m not suggesting you go on a raiding spree, but if the large competitor mentioned above was such a good organization, why do they need a full-time recruiter? They have one because their staff keeps leaving and they need constant replenishment.

In his book The Truth about Employee Engagement, Author Patrick Lencioni describes job misery as the combination of anonymity (not being understood and appreciated by someone in a position of authority), irrelevance (everyone needs to know that their job matters, to someone), and immeasurement (not being able to gauge their progress and level of contribution).

Workforce expectations are changing, and the change has a lot to do public praise and timeliness versus raises and bonuses. Simply put, your staff wants to know what is expected (measured) and then they want to be noticed and appreciated – and quickly, because of the prevalence of social media, they are eager to share the good news. When they accomplish the goal, they want to hear from leadership that they notice the achievement, immediately. The annual review no longer cuts it.

There’s also been a pivot in reputation management. Most people think of reputation management (Yelp reviews, customer satisfaction comments) as something reserved for customers. However, those same principals apply to attracting and retaining a great workforce. In today’s world, potential employees check a salon’s web presence and where the business appears in search.

One of the speakers at the upcoming Data Driven Salon Summit is Stefanie Jackson, a bright, energetic thought leader who speaks about what she calls the “epidemic of mass comparison.” It’s the pressure people feel because they are constantly comparing their lives through the lens of social media. That doesn’t sound so good, but organizations can take the cue and use social media to demonstrate kindness, recognition and appreciation for their staff.

Today’s employers should blend social media with employee recognition. So how does that convergence happen? Recently, we coordinated a nationwide contest for a chain of salons where employees received a raffle ticket each day they “hit” a target. For example, if they sold a unit of retail, they got a raffle ticket into the grand prize drawing. Once a week we conducted a Facebook live interview of the stylist who had the most raffle tickets for that week. Almost without exception, the stylist’s immediate family, friends and co-workers shared, commented or reposted the accomplishment. Measurable, relevant, public – and fast.

While I agree it’s as challenging as ever to attract and retain employees, I am confident success will follow those organizations who set clear targets and focus on “catching” their staff hitting those targets. They’re also building a great reputation as <I>the place to work<I> and word travels – especially on social media!

While at the conference, I played in a golf tournament. The course was in the desert, and it wasn’t long before my cart partner and I were thirsty. We only saw one water station along the course, and we were so thirsty we washed out the nasty coffee cup we had from earlier in the morning and shared water out of the cup. We were impressed that the two other players in our foursome had planned ahead, and we jealously watched as they drank out of their water bottles. As we finished the day, my partner was laughing. I was parched, then stunned as he lifted the cover of the small cooler we both somehow overlooked. In the cooler? You guessed it, ice cold water bottles—right under our noses the entire time - just like your available talent pool. Think about it.

Chris Nedza is the founder of ZeeZor, a real-time data analytics and employee engagement app for salons and spas. Visit zeezor.net.

More from Team Building

Through Beauty Changes Lives scholarships, two encore professionals find new career paths. They share their thoughts about career reinvention and offer owners inspiration on why hiring an older beauty school grad is fabulous investment.

One of the best ways to grow your own team is to hire them right out of school and train them in your systems, but how do you get your salon in front of graduating students? Be Inspired's Kati Whitledge offers some key tips for networking with your local cosmetology schools.

Cy Wakeman, a leadership expert and best-selling author, will scrutinize the impact of drama in the workplace at the 2019 ISBN conference, helping the salon owners find strategies for eliminating drama and helping team members focus on what's important.

After years of visiting area cosmetology schools, the leadership at Cutting Loose Salon hosts a recruitment-oriented social hour designed to give students a chance to soak in their salon's culture and envision their future.