When Follieri was busted for pulling a mini-Madoff (using his fake Vatican connections to steal millions from investors), Hathaway turned over the baubles her ex had gifted her (over the four years they dated) to the police. And let us tell you, this guy showered her with some serious sparklers, including not one, but two Rolex watches (one in silver and one in gold, obviously), a Louis Vuitton box, several other pricey watches, and a five-strand pearl necklace, all of which will be up for sale.

We doubt the actress, who has a new beau, Adam Shulman, will be bidding. But hey, one woman's trash is another woman's treasure, right?