"American Idol" Gives Back, Then Takes Away ...

So who got kicked off American Idol last night? Pretty boy Tim Urban got the boot after a less than stellar performance -- though, arguably, not his worse -- of "Better Days" on IdolGives Back night.

Advertisement

We may have felt all warm and fuzzy watching the fundraiser, which benefits several charities and featured performances by a host of stars including Carrie Underwood, Elton John, Annie Lennox, Alicia Keys, Black Eyed Peas, Mary J. Blige, Russel Brand, Jonah Hill, and Wanda Sykes. But the end of the night brought us back to harsh reality with Urban's elimination.

Most viewers weren't too surprised to see him go; however, the fact that Casey James landed in the bottom three proved quite a shock.

*And in case your DVR cut off before the end of the show -- like it did for so many viewers -- the video above is Part 1 of the missing clip. Here's Part 2.

What did you think of last night's Idol elimination? Were you glad to see Tim go or do you think it should've been Aaron or Siobhan?