Davis v. The Board of County Commissioners of Dona Ana County Essay

Davis v. The Board of County Commissioners of Dona Ana County
Dr. Bobby Barrett
HRM510 Business Employment Law
October 22, 2014

In the case of Davis v. The Board of County Commissioners of Dona Ana County the problem was pure and simply the County Detention Centers decision to inexplicably give an former employee a letter of recommendation, misleading and giving the new employer an inadequate picture of the employees’ character and accomplishments with their company. The critical issue was the negligent referral that was given about the circumstances in which the employee left the detention center. Mr. Joseph Herrera was a mental health technician while employed at the detention center. There were allegations of sexual harassment of female inmates that were under his authority and an investigation ensued. The investigation exposed inappropriate conduct of Mr. Herrera, which deemed it appropriate that he undergo disciplinary action. A hearing was scheduled for the disciplinary action to be given, however that hearing never resulted. Before the hearing was able to take place, Mr. Herrera voluntarily resigned his position with the detention center. Upon his resignation, he requested of his immediate supervisor a letter of recommendation, the supervisor obliged and gave Mr. Herrera a shining recommendation of hard work and superb behavior. Mr. Herrera then went to Mesilla Valley Hospital (MVH) and applied for a position as a Mental Health Technician, he took that letter his prior supervisor had given and was hired based on that recommendation. Upon employment at MVH, employee Mr. Herrera sexually abused a patient. The patient when on to sue the Detention Center, Mr Herrera’s’ former employee, claiming they negligently misrepresented the character and ability of the prior employee. Had they given an accurate representation in the recommendation, MVH would not have offered the position to Mr. Herrera.
The decision of the court established that Dona Ana County Detention Center would be liable for negligent referral due to the supervisor’s recommendation of Mr. Herrera’s character and behavior while employed there. It is the duty of the recommending party to exercise good judgment when giving referrals. They “did owe a duty of care” to MVH when they elected to give the technician a recommendation (Walsh, 2010, p.149). Being that the immediate supervisor and or employer knew that there was a foreseeable risk to others, it should have been their duty to caution that company and give the accurate facts in the recommendation. Inexplicably omitting information of the upcoming hearing in that reference was negligent and the courts agreed.
The matter of whether or not there was confirmed abuse in the allegations played a minor role in this case. The fact that detention center discovered inappropriate conduct and were working towards disciplinary action is what mattered in this case. Though the report of sexual favors was not concluded, they did conclude that “questionable” and “suspect” behavior of Mr. Herrera did take place (Walsh, 2010, p.148). Plain and simple, it was the duty of the employer to not create a risk of foreseeable physical harm. Since the company concluded that they would take disciplinary action against technician to have him suspended without pay and be demoted and reassigned, it was their duty to report that. To recommend an employee to another company with that type of disciplinary action to ensue there must have been substantial evidence of the questionable and suspect behavior. Since the employer chose to give additional information about the employee other than the position, title, and whether or not that employee was re-hirable, they put themselves in a position of liability. Anytime you give an inaccurate picture that could be detrimental to others by not providing the complete…

Related Documents: Davis v. The Board of County Commissioners of Dona Ana County Essay

Broward County Mayor
Jane M Rentas
HAS 339 Health Law
Professor Moss
Barry University
I usually do not follow politics, but when I was assigned this assignment, I found myself interested in our Broward County Mayor Barbara Sharief. Sharief was born and raised in South Florida. Sharief graduated from North Miami Senior high school and right after high school, she immediately enrolled in Miami Dade community college. She…

As a student of the Horry County schools system, my concern of school safety has risen immensely. With all of the recent incidents involving school shootings that have occurred in the past few years around the country, what can Horry County do to improve safety in the school system? Every school system has its’ flaws in safety, but there are a few steps and precautions Horry County schools can take to avoid certain dangers.
When people hear about school shootings, the first question that pops…

November 7th, 2012 | By Amy Sherman
When Miami-Dade County Commissioners approved the 2012-13 budget in September, it didn't involve the fireworks of the recent past, the Miami Herald reported. One reason was that layoffs were not part of the deal.
Commissioners approved the $5.9 billion budget on Sept. 20, 2012, in an 11-1 vote with Joe Martinez, the county chairman who lost the mayoral race against Gimenez in August, voting against it. (Commissioner Dennis Moss was absent.) The budget did not include…

How did brown v board changed america
The change that the Supreme Court court demanded had not happened overnight. Many counties in many States simply refused to go along with it. Sometimes, the problem of integration was rarely ever done peacefully. The first instance of the policy being enforced was in Little Rock, AK. President Eishenhower had to use a section of his military troops to protect the Black students who went to Little Rock Public High under the experiment of seeing whether black…

Chemung County is located in the Southern Tier Region of New York State. The name comes from pioneers who named it after a Native American Village that was destroyed during the battle of Newton. The county was named back in 1779 and was being settled as early as 1784. The county seat is named Elmira and has been referred to as the Soaring Capital mostly due in part to the national sailplane competitions that have been hosted there as far back as 1930. The county also has many signs referring…

How would that make you feel? The Logan family is a lower African American family. Their school Great Faith elementary school, is being treated like a dump while the all white school Jefferson Davis county school was being treated like loyalty. Great Faith has no school buses while Jefferson Davis county school has 3. We all pay our taxes, why shouldn’t Great Faith have at least one school bus? A school bus could protect the students from any harm outside of school.
One day when the Logan chirliden…

Davis vs. The Board of County Commissioners of Doña Ana County
Dana Richmond
HRM 510 Business Employment Law
October 28, 2012
What was the legal issue in this case?
In my opinion there are several legal issues that can be derived from this case. The first is whether Dona Ana County Detention Center misrepresented a former employee to Mesilla Valley Hospital by giving Joseph Herrera a letter of recommendation for work even though they knew he had a recent history of sexual abuse and misconduct…

Disaster in Franklin County
Jennifer Wadsworth
Western Governors University
Disaster in Franklin County
Role of Major Public Health Personnel
The roles of major public health personnel must be delegated properly in a disaster situation in order to facilitate effective action. In the incident presented, a chain of command was established and assignments given to the appropriate personnel based on their skills and experience. As a whole, this group reports to the Incident Commander, an individual…

Words 2194 - Pages 9

* Test names and other trademarks are the property of the respective trademark holders. None of the trademark holders are affiliated with this website.