It’s tough to justify another eyeshadow palette, but with so many new releases coming out (it seems a new must-have hits Sephora every single week), it’s easy to see why palettes get so much attention. Even if you’ve just finished purging your collection, the Too Faced Just Peachy Velvet Matte Eye Shadow Palette ($45) is worth a second look and maybe some consideration.

A little more grown-up than some other palettes hitting the shelves, the Just Peachy palette is part of Too Faced’s larger Peaches and Cream collection. The O.C.-based brand is known for creating plenty of things to keep beauty bloggers lusting, but this all-matte collection is just the thing for people who aren’t into looking like sparkling unicorns every day of the week.

Formulated to be long-wearing and highly pigmented, the palette’s colors work together for more natural looks and dramatic smoky eyes alike. Too Faced even laid out the colors in an ombré pattern, so creating different looks is as easy as going from left to right. And while you may be used to seeing Too Faced at just about every beauty emporium out there, the Peaches and Cream collection is the very first time that the line’s created something exclusively for Sephora. That means limited quantities, a surefire frenzy, and total holy grail status. Don’t say we didn’t warn you.