“I wasn’t one of those ‘I need a baby!’ people until my goddaughter was born,” Dunst said. “I love her so much. That love is just like … you can’t experience that unless you have a kid. I put her to bed last night and she woke up this morning and said to her mom, ‘Where’s Kiki?’ I just love that. That’s what I want.”

Though Dunst didn’t reveal if there are any babies arriving in the near future, for now, she and Plemons, 29, seem to be enjoying every moment of their engagement bliss.