If this is your first visit, be sure to
check out the FAQ by clicking the
link above. You may have to register
before you can post: click the register link above to proceed. To start viewing messages,
select the forum that you want to visit from the selection below.

No they couldn't have and wouldn't have. She only did it because she was alone and because they had no other way to stop them from shooting the evacuation ships. Did you watch the movie? Really watch it?

So you agree. Yes that was dumb, what rose did, was in character. And yes she risked it all but there were no repercussions. Saving those doors would've just lead to them starving to death on there without a way out.

She did something for a person she cared about. As far as I'm concerned that's nothing new.

- - - Updated - - -

Oh and Poe ordered them to retreat, so Finn is to be blamed here, for not following orders.

No they couldn't have and wouldn't have. She only did it because she was alone and because they had no other way to stop them from shooting the evacuation ships. Did you watch the movie? Really watch it?

So you agree. Yes that was dumb, what rose did, was in character. And yes she risked it all but there were no repercussions. Saving those doors would've just lead to them starving to death on there without a way out.

She did something for a person she cared about. As far as I'm concerned that's nothing new.

- - - Updated - - -

Oh and Poe ordered them to retreat, so Finn is to be blamed here, for not following orders.

They could've done the same Escape pod plan and 1 person stay behind and do it. It would've even had less casualties :lmap

Yes, because Rose is a retarded character. Finn was going to go out a hero and Rose went to prevent his sacrifice in a way that could've potentially killed them both anyway

They could've done the same Escape pod plan and 1 person stay behind and do it. It would've even had less casualties :lmap

Yes, because Rose is a retarded character. Finn was going to go out a hero and Rose went to prevent his sacrifice in a way that could've potentially killed them both anyway

That was never the plan. It wasn't even a part of plan H. They had limited resources and a move like that would've gotten every single evacuation ship destroyed. The first order would've sent ships to blast them off while they were in space. The objective was to get to safety.

And you are really wasting your time with this. It's a cliche, rax. Last minute save. Countless times replicated in movies. She tried making him stop already. So did poe.

Finn wouldn't have even stopped the cannon looking how sturdy and big it was.

And if they just did that from the start they would've been fine instead of letting their ships get shot at for a day

It was a last minute save though that made absolutely zero sense.

It was clear that he would've damaged its internals and it woulda blown up

Ships, those ships, were in deep space. With no planet to land to. If the big ship kamikazes, that still leaves them vulnerable with no way to reach this planet in time. They were defenseless ships. This was explained in the movie.

Yeah, so? Fire in space doesn't make sense either. Maybe impulsive actions don't make sense other than to ones who made them. She saved Finn . That was all we needed to know.

I like Fin as well but it was clear they didn't know what to do with him. So they stuck him with Rose and they went off on a pointless adventure. Also, I don't get why Phasma is treated like an important person but she has zero build up and was just Fin's commander in the first one. That's it.

I really liked what they decided to do with Luke, for the most part. And Rey and Ren were quite good as well. Developing those two in that way was pretty good but I do wish they had grown more when it was all said and done.