What does it mean to be a Freak?
How do we make an Ethical Choice which moves beyond the simply utilitarian?
What do we do as citizens when our city is under Siege by forces that we cannot understand?
How do we live in a world where the elected guardians of morality and justice are corrupt and venal?
What does it take to be a Hero?

Christopher Nolan poses these questions and more in his The Dark Knight, a film which is skillfully crafted and moves beyond “the blow them up, throw them up” genre of the Super Hero Blockbuster.

Nolan’s films seem to be primarily about troubled men; his stunning “Memento”, “Insomnia”, and later “The Prestige” were all about his lead characters grappling with their frustrations, desires, and their troubled pasts, as they struggle to lead a life.
In this film too, the two lead characters, the Joker and the Batman have to deal with a violent past - a past that is dominated by the Father. For the Joker it is the vengeful, sadistic Father, while for the Batman, it is about the loss of the protective Father shot dead in a random street robbery. Both are troubled men; both are fractured, and they choose different ways to deal with their respective legacies.

The Joker’s character is the Shadow Archetype; the repressed weaknesses, shortcomings, negatives, and the irrationality that we see in ourselves but do not accept, but instead project onto the other, the Villain. The Batman is that part of us that struggles to do good, but is beset with internal demons and instinctual desires. The Batman chooses violence to tackle crime, but that brings him face to face with his own Shadow, the Joker. He has to struggle not to cross the limit, armed with his gadgets and martial arts skills; the Batman has to choose not to kill. Compared to Jack Nicholson’s Joker in Tim Burton’ film, Heath Ledger’s Joker oozes menace and mayhem. Jack Nicholson was campy, goofy, and over the top, here Heath Ledger is violent and dead serious, if not downright psychotic.
(The use of the knife as the favourite weapon of the Joker is a masterstroke).

Christopher Nolan sets up the drama with finesse; both the Joker and the Batman become more and more desperate as they engage in their protracted struggle. No one wins, in fact the struggle takes a heavy toll, people die, loved ones are lost for ever, and there seems no way out of the quagmire. Into this impasse, Nolan introduces the character of Two Face aka Harvey Dent the District Attorney, the once White Knight of Gotham, who now has surrendered to the Shadow.

Nolan’s hand is muted and restrained: right from the back ground music to the dialogues, he handles things in an understated and subtle manner. The supporting cast is superb; Morgan Freeman as Lucius Fox, the inimitable Michael Caine as Alfred, Maggie Gyllenhaal as Rachel Dawes, and Gary Oldman as Lieutenant Gordon. For Nolan, Gotham city is not a city of dread and mist and dark, a city that exists in never never land, but is instead recognizably real, filled with real people with real desires, anxieties, frustrations, and most importantly beliefs.

This is not your usual blockbuster film where you ooh and aah at the loud sounds and action on screen in between mouthfuls of flavored popcorn and fiddling with your mobile phones. With this film Christopher Nolan does for the Blockbuster / Super Hero genre, what Alan Moore’s Watchmen and Frank Miller’s The Dark Knight Returns did for the comic book: turn what essentially seems to be an escapist fantasy into a brooding and dark allegory for our world and our times.

Watch this film as soon as you can and wonder at what a director with a keen sensibility can do with a good script and a vision without compromising on a cracker jack of a story.

This review is by guest reviewer Anand S. Anand lives in Pune and is a Miscellaneous Culture Vulture. He is deeply interested in music, food, books, films, and intelligent women. He views himself as a Falstaffian figure, who does his best to indulge his appetites.

This page has additional observations, other than the ones noted in the main review.

Plot Summary

Batman tries to clean up Gotham City with the help of Lt. Gordon and the new District Attorney, Harvey Dent. Into this situation, enters the Joker, who forces the Batman to make choices which have devastating consequences for all concerned.

What Worked

The action scenes are superbly done; one, where Batman goes to Hong Kong and “extradites” an accountant who launders money for the crime families, and two, the chase sequence where the Joker is arrested by Lt. Gordon, with the help of the Batman and Harvey Dent.

The dialogues between Michael Caine and Christian Bale coruscate with subtle wit and meaning. As also the scenes written for the Joker; the scene where he disrupts a meeting of the crime bosses is adroitly written and excellently enacted so as to manifest the immanent violence and menace of the Joker’s character. The soundtrack is also very well done: in the Joker’s scenes the soundtrack goes all hiss and buzz in a spiraling droning sort of way which only amplifies the sense of menace and disorientation

What did not

Note: This section simply lists the things that I did not like in this movie. This is not the overall impression about this movie. Please read the full review here

The sound track is muted, and this sometimes affects the comprehension of the dialogues as our audiences are not used to “soft” speech and keep making sounds to fill up the void! This is not a black mark against the Director, but against the multiplex audience!

Nitty-Gritty

This section lists things that I think are not important to the overall impact of the movie. In most cases, it could be explained away by something like, "we noticed the glitch after the scene was shot and there were schedule/budget issues and thus we could not re-shoot it". I like giving the makers the benefit of doubt, but I am amused nevertheless. Hopefully, they will tickle you too.

Comments (6)

the only glitch , (cannot call it a glitch, could be the compulsions that come with movie-making) was when the seemingly good guy refused to blow up the ship of criminals. I sincerely hoped he did, but later I read a peice vindicating this act, which looked at the experiment from a group vs individual point of view.. here is what the writer said "In the climactic boat scene, the groups don't have any other goal than to save their own skins. But when it comes time for a single individual to take action, when it comes time to shed the anonymity, they act for the public good".. and you brought out a nice point by comparing how both dealt with their violent past. My favorite dialogue is when joker admits that he is not a man of "plans" and how he goes onto describe how a little anarchy can upset the system. What a movie.. cleverly written.

Lash has posted 2 comments and has rated 0 movies. See Lash's page for more details.