Coexistence with China or Cold War II?

On
China, Trump is the first realist we have had in the Oval Office in
decades. But both parties colluded in the buildup of China… The mighty
malevolent China we face today was made in the USA.

Under fire for his handling of the coronavirus pandemic, President
Donald Trump, his campaign and his party are moving to lay blame for the
80,000 U.S. dead at the feet of the Communist Party of China and, by
extension, its longtime General Secretary, President Xi Jinping.

“There is a significant amount of evidence” that the virus originated
in a Wuhan lab, said Secretary of State Mike Pompeo last week.

Trump himself seemed to subscribe to the charge:

“This is worse than Pearl Harbor. This is worse than the World Trade
Center. There’s never been an attack like this… It could have been
stopped in China. It should have been stopped right at the source.”

There is talk on Capitol Hill of suspending sovereign immunity so
China may be sued for the damages done by the virus that produced a U.S.
shutdown and a second Great Depression where unemployment is projected
to reach near the 25% of 1933.

The Trump campaign has begun to target the Democratic nominee as
“Beijing Biden” for his past collusion with China and his attack on
Trump for “hysterical xenophobia” when Trump ended flights from China.

What is the historical truth?

On China, Trump is the first realist we have had in the Oval Office
in decades. But both parties colluded in the buildup of China as she
vaulted over Italy, France, Britain, Germany and Japan to become the
world’s second power in the 21st century.

Both parties also dismissed Chinese trade surpluses with the U.S.,
which began at a few billion dollars a year in the early 1990s and have
grown to almost $500 billion a year. Neither party took notice until
lately of our growing dependency on Beijing for products critical to our
defense and for drugs and medicines crucial to the health and survival
of Americans.

The mighty malevolent China we face today was made in the USA.

But what do we do now? Can we coexist with this rising and
expansionist power? Or must we conduct a new decades-long Cold War like
the one we waged to defeat the Soviet Empire and Soviet Union?

The U.S. prevailed in that Cold War because of advantages we do not possess with the China of 2020.
From 1949-1989, a NATO alliance backed by 300,000 U.S. troops in
Europe “contained” the Soviet Union. No Soviet ruler attempted to cross
the dividing line laid down at Yalta in 1945. Nor did we cross it.

East of the Elbe, the Soviet bloc visibly failed to offer the
freedoms and prosperity the U.S., Western Europe and Japan had on offer
after World War II. America won the battle for hearts and minds.
Moreover, ethnic nationalism, the idea that separate and unique
peoples have a right to determine their own political and cultural
identity and destiny, never died in the captive nations of Europe and
the USSR.

China today does not suffer from these deficiencies to the same
degree. Unlike the USSR, China has four times our population. Where the
USSR could not compete economically and technologically, China is a
capable and dynamic rival of the U.S.

Moreover, if we begin a Cold War II with China, we would not be
starting with the advantages Truman’s America, undamaged at home in
World War II, had over Stalin’s pillaged and plundered land in 1945.

Where ethnic nationalism tore the USSR apart into 15 nations, today’s
China is more of an ethno-nationalist state with Han Chinese
constituting 1 billion of China’s 1.4 billion people.

There are millions of Tibetans, Uighurs, Kazakhs in southwest and
west China, and tens of millions of Buddhists, Christians, Muslims,
Falun Gong and other religious minorities. But China is unlike the
multiracial, multiethnic, multicultural, multilingual Moscow-centered
and Russian-controlled Soviet Empire and USSR that shattered after 1989.

China’s weaknesses?

She is feared and distrusted by her neighbors. She sits on India’s
lands from the war of the early 1960s. She claims the whole South China
Sea, whose waters and resources are also claimed by Vietnam, Malaysia,
Singapore, Indonesia, the Philippines and Taiwan.

The peoples of Hong Kong and Taiwan fear that Beijing intends to overrun and rule them.
Even Vladimir Putin has reason to be suspicious as Beijing looks at
the barren but resource-rich lands of Siberia and the Russian Far East,
some of which once belonged to China.

China is thus a greater rival than the USSR of Stalin and Khrushchev
and Brezhnev, but the U.S. is not today the nation of Ronald Reagan,
with its surging economy and ideological conviction we would one day see
the ideology of Marx and Lenin buried.

Three decades of post-Cold War foolish and failed democracy-crusading
have left this generation not with the conviction and certitude of Cold
War America, but with ashes in their mouths and no stomach to spend
blood and treasure converting China to our way of life.