Wednesday, October 19, 2016

Welfare, Work and War

Relaxing at home recently, I happened to pick up a copy of the book
Schindler’s List, a copy of which has been sitting on my coffee table
since I first read the book back in 1996.

Having read the book in its entirety several times, I also
occasionally pick it up and browse randomly for inspiration - the story
being so rich with anecdotes and vignettes of Jewish resistance to Nazi
oppression. The one thing that struck me this time around about the
dramatic tale of Oskar Schindler, a German businessman who used his
ceramics and cookware factory to disguise his courageous effort to save
over a thousand Jews from almost certain death in Nazi concentration
camps – was not the fact that Schindler sacrificed so much of his own
fortune and risked his own life to save his fellow human beings. The
thing that really struck me was in fact that other Germans did so little
to prevent the genocide of over six million of their fellow citizens.
Though Schindler saved a thousand people and is rightly commended for
his act of courage, many other people failed in their duty to stand up
for justice and humanity.

How, one wonders, could one of the world’s oldest and most stable
democratic republics fall prey to such an autocratic and ultimately
barbarian practice as mass slavery and extermination?
In some sense it all came down to economics, the distribution of
resources, and the instability that economic panic causes. In Nazi
Germany, even wealthy Jews were eventually confined to ‘ghettos’ –
basically encircled neighborhoods, from which they were forbidden to
emerge except for work. The term ghetto has been somewhat bastardized in
the American context as places reserved only for poor people. In
Germany under Nazi occupation, the rich and poor alike were lumped
together. Jewish wealth was largely confiscated and Jewish companies
either taken over by the state, or sold off to private German interests
at a fraction of their value.

Initially some Jews, it seemed, wanted to try to get along with the
system. The more educated and wealthy Jews tried to find allies within
the Nazi party, advertising their skills and ‘usefulness’ and often
pledging their capital for the German war effort. But as time went on,
and Germany’s expansionary plans became ever more expensive, the
Faustian bargain did not hold. Even Jews loyal to the Nazi regime were
singled out for oppression and expropriation.

As an entrepreneur, I have always believed that controlling one’s
economic fortune means controlling one’s destiny. Why wait for the
government to do something for you, when with hard work and ingenuity,
you can do much, much more for yourself? I firmly believe that my own
destiny is up to me. And so, it seems, did many Jewish entrepreneurs in
Germany.

Although business thrived in Germany, the conception of
national socialism offered a utopic vision that in the end proved to be
unsupportable in the absence of freedom and entrepreneurship.

Underground economies among the poorer Jews flourished in this
environment of social dislocation. Other Jews pooled their resources to
create more legitimate economic endeavors, and some indeed thrived
despite the declining economic conditions facing the country as a whole.
But at the end of the day it was all for naught. Despite their attempt
to control their destiny, having been thrown out of the social welfare
system, Jews were still targeted, their wealth, freedom and lives stolen
from them.

The real lesson here seems to be that at the extremes of socialism
lies despotism. Becoming dependent upon government largesse and social
welfare imperils us, because it attaches us to a system that is no
longer viable for far too long. Entrepreneurship and wealth, while not a
panacea, create far more options under conditions of crisis than
poverty and dependence.

The welfare state, while well intended, sets the stage for state
control over resources. It limits ones political choices, and constrains
freedom. Government should really be in the business of defending
liberty and upholding the constitutional rule of law. When it expands
into other areas of life – education, social welfare, and even
scientific investment, it often crowds out better solutions.

America at
its best is a society that fosters prosperity by protecting freedom,
equal justice, freedom of expression, freedom of association. It is not a
system of government that attempts to guarantee equal outcomes.

America is a country that shines because it offers individuals the
opportunity to control their destiny. Immigrants are attracted to our
nation, not because it promises subsidized living, but because people
are free to benefit from the fruits of their works, ideas and talents.

Nazi Germany utterly failed for two reasons. Its government,
attempting to offer a panacea, actually created horribly unstable
society. Secondly, by stifling the freedom and creative efforts of a
large part of its population – it deprived itself of the necessary
entrepreneurial power it would need to provide benefits for those in
true need. We should heed those lessons of history, and make sure
America’s list is much bigger than Schindler’s.

Followers

Follow My Posts by Email

The Patriot Factor

I’m an American Patriot...part of the grassroots movement of bloggers spreading the truth about the corrupt and traitorous Obama regime and his sanctioned islamization of America. I'm also co-host with Craig Andresen of RIGHT SIDE PATRIOTS on American Political Radio. http://tunein.com/radio/American-Political-Radio-s273246/