The Cardinals may have not have had a scheduled game yesterday, but they made news all the same, trading minor league outfielder Brian Barton to Atlanta for Blaine Boyer.

My initial reaction on the trade was a decided "ugh". That led to quite a bit of Twittering as I defended my position that Barton was more valuable than what we received. That line of thought seemed to be more prevalent at Viva El Birdos yesterday as well. (Of course, I also was taken to task for stating I'd have rather them move Brian Barden instead, something I still hold. Barden is more in line with the value of Boyer than Barton, in my book.)

Let me be clear: I'm not saying Brian Barton was a world-beater. I'm not saying that he'd have seen a lot of time in St. Louis. I'm not saying that he should have been kept at all cost. What I am saying is that Barton was more valuable than a relief pitcher with shoddy numbers and that had already been designated for assignment.

If I have $1 million dollars to spare and I decide to give you $100 for a piece of gum, I can do it, but it's still not the smart move. Even though we have a surplus of outfielders, giving them away for apparently mediocre talent isn't going to make the team any better, which is the purpose of minor league assets.

The positives on this trade seem to be that he had a decent first half but was over used (a la Kyle McClellan) and blew up in the second half and that we have Dave Duncan. However, there are some that think the McClellan comp is pretty weak. And while Duncan is the best pitching coach out there, remember that the last DFA pitcher that actually worked is Jeff Weaver. Everyone thought Duncan could fix Mike Maroth as well.

I just don't really see how this makes the team better. Boyer's allowed six runs in an inning and a third this season, and while I know he was kinda left out there to take one for the team, he still walked in two runs during a Phillies comeback against the Braves.

Time will tell, I guess. The other downside to the trade, or the necessity to make it at least, is the fact that the Cardinals are now going to go with 13 pitchers for a while, demoting David Freese to Memphis (of course, after I said he was probably safe yesterday). That means the bench, such as it is, will be Jason LaRue, Barden or Joe Thurston, whichever outfielder isn't playing, and Brendan Ryan. Not exactly a strength, huh? Which may means we see more pitchers batting when they shouldn't, pitchers staying in the game because we can't afford to pinch-hit, and pitchers pinch-hitting (I bet Adam Wainwright pinch-hits at least twice during this span).

All of that is intriguing, but the Cardinals have a game tonight to play. Todd Wellemeyer gets the call against Oliver Perez and the Mets. Wellemeyer has had some trouble with the big bats in the Mets lineup, especially David Wright and Carlos Delgado. If he's able to contain them, it could be a good night. Hopefully he gets into the seventh or later and keeps the bullpen activity to a minimum.

The rotation is on Duncan's mind as well, as they'd love to skip the fifth starter slot as often as possible. That's just not going to be possible too much, though. Still, if the pitchers keep throwing the way that they have, having to use a fifth starter pales in comparison of dealing with the bullpen.

Finally, if this blog isn't enough for you, you can also read my recap of the first two weeks of the Cardinals' season over at Baseball Reflections today.

3 Comments

Todd Wellemeyer had his contract awarded to the St. Louis Cardinals on an outright waiver claim. Wellemeyer was previously designated for assignment following the Royals' May 10, 2007, game against Oakland. So I would consider Todd to be the last DFA'd guy to have success with St. Louis.

And Wellemeyer had been DFA'd by Florida when the Royals picked him up off of waivers in 2006. So he go DFA'd by 2 teams prior to the Cardinals and he has been a very good success story up to this point.

While in theory the Cardinals may have been able to get more in return for Barton I'm not sure who they could have gotten for him right now that could potentially have an immediate impact. You know Mo is out there looking and this was apparently the best they could get at this specific point in time. Fingers crossed that it produces some positive results.

The BBA has, as a secondary aim, the goal of producing year-end
awards in a similar fashion to the Baseball Writers of America. These
awards can be found at the official site in October with links back to the voters,
ensuring transparency and, most likely, the onset of some good baseball
arguments.