I loved iTunes but after every fucking update I had to scroll through all my music updating everything since it would break one album into 4 different albums. Takes way too much time. and thanks ill look into that

i use google play if im listening at the PC, browser based and not a complete mess like spotify, even if you dont use their streaming service you can upload your music to their cloud and use it on their phone app

foobar is the best if you want to spend about 3 hours setting it up. it has the most functionality and the most options out of any of the players, but it comes at the cost of you literally having to build the player yourself.

other than that theyre all basically the same. you loose something in one that you get in another and vise versa. it all comes down to personal preference.