this would be easier if you let us know what genre to prefer..
I'm a big FF fan, but I can't recommend FF13 unless you get it dirt cheap

If you haven't played Fallout 3. than get that..because it's a great games
deadspace is a great 3rd person shooter, it's not scary but it'll get you jumpin if you player it by yourself in the dark, with the sound system turned up

sorry, my eyes was playing tricks on me
I thought you wanted games from the list

So my new recommendation is Batman AA, get the 3D
at first I thought the 3D was a lame gimmick to sell the game, but it's actually really good..
the 3D works way better than I thought it would...the game is also really good