New York Film Critics Circle 2015 Winners: ‘Carol’ Takes Four Including Best Picture, Director

Weinstein Co.’s Carolcame up as the big winner at the New York Film Critics Circle Awards this morning earning best film, best director for Todd Haynes, best screenplay for Phyllis Nagy’s adaptation of Patricia Highsmith’s novel and best cinematography for Edward Lachman’s visuals. The groundswell comes on the heels of Carol earning six Film Independent Spirit noms last week, three Gotham noms and a best actress win for Rooney Mara at the Cannes Film Festival.

Outside of Carol, and a singled out best actor win for Michael Keaton in Open Road’s Spotlight — both titles which have dominated the early awards season buzz– the NYFCC results today provided kudo publicists plenty of hope that their hard work is actually paying off as a number of contenders entered the conversation for the first time.

Among those breaking through this morning: Kristen Stewart, who was namedbest supporting actress for her turn in Olivier Assayas’ Clouds of Sils Maria, a role which also won her a Cesar, France’s Oscar equivalent. In addition, Mark Rylance, popped into the awards chatter for his turn as Cold War Soviet spy Rudolf Abel in DreamWorks’ Bridge of Spies. Then there was Saoirse Ronan who won best actress for her portrayal of a young Irish immigrant woman in Fox Searchlight’s Brooklyn. To date, Ronan counts a British Independent Film nomination for her performance in the John Crowley-directed movie.

Keaton’s win is an anamoly for the Spotlight cast which has largely been recognized for its ensemble work by the Gotham Independent and Film Independent Spirit awards. In the movie, Keaton plays Boston Globe reporter/editor Walter Robinson, who led the paper’s Pulitzer Prize-winning exposé of the Boston Archdiocese’s complicity in covering up widespread sexual abuse of children by priests.

The first winner announced this morning was the Auschwitz drama Son of Saul, named best first film. Set in 1944,the harrowing film follows a concentration camp victim torn between participating in a camp uprising or somehow providing a proper Jewish burial for a Nazi victim who may have been his son. Hungary’s official nominee for the Best Foreign Film Oscar, Son of Saul also has been nominated in the best international film category at the Spirit Awards and won four prizes at last May’s Cannes Film Festival, including the FIPRESCI prize. Instead of naming Son of Saul best foreign film, NYFCC awarded it to a foreign film Oscar nominee from last season, Mauritania’s Timbuktu.

Unlike the National Board of Review which is prone to favoring titles that don’t exactly match up with those in the awards zeitgeist, NYFCC boasts a 43% bellwether rate when determining Oscar’s best picture. Last year, the organization named IFC’s Boyhood best picture, a title that remained in the conversation until Oscars were handed out. Back in February, many believed that if Birdman didn’t take best picture, then Boyhood would. While many were blindsided by Marion Cotillard’s best actress Oscar nomination last year for Two Days, One Night, the NYFCC already had some foresight and recognized her as their best actress for the film, along with her work in The Immigrant.

Last year NYFCC synced with the Oscars on the following winners: J.K. Simmons as best supporting actor for Whiplash, Patricia Arquette for her supporting role in Boyhood, Ida for best foreign film and CitizenFour for best feature documentary. Of those NYFCC choices for top film that went on to win best picture at the Oscars during the aughts: 2011’s The Artist, 2009’s The Hurt Locker, 2008’s No Country For Old Men and 2003’s The Lord of the Rings: Return of the King. Prior to that, NYFCC and Oscars didn’t see eye to eye on best picture until 1993’s Schindler’s List.

Here is the full list of NYFCC winners announced this morning. The awards will be handed out at the NYFCC ceremony on January 4 at Tao Downtown.

Best film: Carol

Best director: Todd Haynes, Carol

Best actor: Michael Keaton, Spotlight

Best actress: Saoirse Ronan, Brooklyn

Best supporting actor: Mark Rylance, Bridge of Spies

Best supporting actress: Kristen Stewart, Clouds of Sils Maria

Best screenplay: Carol, Phyllis Nagy

Best animated film: Inside Out

Best cinematography: Carol, Edward Lachman

Best first film: Son of Saul

Best foreign film: Timbuktu (Mauritania)

Best non-fiction film (documentary): In Jackson Heightsdirected by Frederick Wiseman.

Special Award: Posthumous award honoring the legacy of William Becker and Janus Films

11 Comments

Where is news about the Satellite Award nominations ? Taking into consideration that now about 50 % money Hollywood earns abroad, the discrimination of the international journalists is really sad.

Peter • on Dec 2, 2015 9:21 am

thanks for highlighting! Makes it a lot easier to steal a glimpse at work :)

DougW • on Dec 2, 2015 9:42 am

Best Picture pretty much has to be “Carol,” right? Best screenplay, directing and cinematography.

Spaghettiandmeatballs@yahoo.com • on Dec 2, 2015 1:10 pm

Taking the first precursers of NBR and the NY film critics into account, it looks like the relative positions of Carol, The Martian (won the big 3 at NBR) and, yes, Mad Max are strengthened. Max won’t win BP but has upped its chances of a nom. NY spread the love all around the artsy set, really. The only films with crushed hopes so far are The Revenant and Joy, which have not figured at all.

Can`t see Carol winning BP at the Oscars but NY critics were always going to love this.

rocknmovie • on Dec 2, 2015 12:04 pm

So Kristen Stewart got an award for playing herself… LOL!

turnitup • on Dec 2, 2015 12:10 pm

I was severely disappointed by this movie. I love Todd Haynes, Cate Blanchett and Rooney Mara. I was even happy to see Jake Lacy. But the entire way through, I felt like I was still waiting for the story to really take off with some more interesting complications. The detail for the period was flawless. I wonder if that’s blinding people at all to this film’s underwhelming plot.

AD • on Dec 2, 2015 1:12 pm

Amazing what a huge PR drive gets you in the end and from critics who’ve only ever ridiculed her (KS)in the past. SMH
Was Rooney Mara in contention for this ?
Doubt they’d have given her the time of day if it wasn’t for the French Cesar – heavily sponsored by Chanel – her fashion deal. Tut tut

Emma • on Dec 2, 2015 3:12 pm

Stay salty!

Nathan • on Dec 2, 2015 3:46 pm

Um, the top critics have not ridiculed KStew for a long time. She’s received great reviews for her last several performances. Also, tin foil hat much with the Cesars?

Nathan • on Dec 2, 2015 3:47 pm

Also, she hasn’t campaigned at all so how on earth has she done a PR drive?