In two seasons with the Tigers, Kincade threw for 6,011 yards with 56 touchdown passes and 11 interceptions, rushed for 811 yards on 228 carries with 12 rushing touchdowns, and earned SWAC Offensive Player of the Year both years. Kincade also led the Tigers to the 2016 Celebration Bowl title as a junior.

Kincade joins former Southern wide receiver Mike Jones as the only HBCU members on the team.