Changes made in 2009 to loitering rules on Pacific Avenue—commonly known as Santa Cruz's “sit/lie ordinance”—have some locals asking whether panhandlers and loiterers should be treated differently than artists and merchants.

The rules aim to keep sidewalks clear for walking and entrances to businesses accessible, according to Mayor Ryan Coonerty. However, there is no nuance written in to distinguish between performers and people who choose to hang out with no apparent purpose.

Before 2009, Chapter 5.43 of Santa Cruz Municipal Code made it illegal for anyone to perform or sit within 10 feet of public art, business entrances or kiosks. The new version extended that distance to 14 feet from any business, sculpture or kiosk, and 50 feet from automated teller machines. Without a special events permit from the Parks and Recreation Department, the law also requires people to move 100 feet down the street after one hour. The permits are given for non-commercial events, which puts artists looking to sell their work in a sort of legal limbo. There is not currently a system set up for permitted sales of work except on the basis that it is by donation.

Street performers are frustrated at being squeezed closer to the gutter and asked to move along just as they are getting into their set, says software developer and local musician Peter Lindener.

“When you chase the talent off the street, you end up with musicians who are a bit of an embarrassment,” Lindener says. “When you don't chase the good talent away, this vacuum that creates this embarrassment doesn't happen.”

He supports extending the time limit to an hour and a half to allow musicians time to get set up and put on a full performance, but believes the most fair way would be to leave the time limit and other rules on public space up to popular vote through what he calls “Informational Theoretical Democracy.” In this process, people would vote through social networking websites to determine the time limit and other issues.

Peter Salvano, a Santa Cruz resident and political activist, agrees that street performers add a reason for people to come downtown. Although he says he personally doesn't like some of the music being played, he is against having any sort of fee or permit process for performers.

“It's the funky ambiance of Downtown Santa Cruz, and I wouldn't have it any other way,” says Salvano. “That's why I live here.”

After studying the loitering rules here, San Francisco has passed similar sit/lie ordinances to deal with crime and aggressive panhandling, but has been able to do so without affecting the musicians and street merchants that line the sidewalks on streets such as Market and Haight streets. Performers and merchants there apply for permits from the Art Commission that allow them to be in one place despite the time limits as part of the city's Art In Public Places program. Lindener points to this model as a successful way to encourage and manage street activity, and as something that could add to the tourism industry.

“I [think] that Pacific Avenue [could] be a healthy social environment where musicians meet each other and discover each other’s talents, because that is where the music happens,” he says. “Sometimes business owners get so obsessed with the money they forget about the culture that draws people to Santa Cruz in the first place.”

Lindener feels that a more welcoming approach to street performers would make Santa Cruz a must stop destination for touring artists because it will become known as a place to network between skilled artists. This, he says, will increase tourism because people will follow these artists as they flow here.

Most shop owners and managers say they enjoy the performers on Pacific Avenue and see the cultural value. However, even if the acts are a draw for people, they say such performances don’t necessarily result in more customers.

Large crowds often gather in front O'Neill Surf Shop to watch outdoor music, dancing, or other artistic displays. While O'Neill's staff often has to ask the crowd to keep their front door clear, Manager of Advertising and Promotions Elfin Saffer says there is no evidence that onlookers come inside to shop during or after watching a performance.

“What really brings in customers is a hit movie,” says Saffer. “When people come out [of Regal Santa Cruz 9], they cross the street and shop. Between the Cinema 9, Urban Outfitters, [Pacific] Wave and ourselves we have a pretty [good mix].”

When the subject turns to street vendors, the community dialogue becomes more complicated. As of June, the City of Santa Cruz had an unemployment rate of around 11.5 percent. Coonerty, who says street vendors have had a terrible effect on the economy in the Bay Area, does not welcome the idea of added competition for businesses.

“To be frank, I would like to see a few more street performers downtown, but artists selling their goods is different,” says Coonerty. “I don't think you want to have businesses having people setup in front of their stores. ... It basically destroyed Telegraph [Avenue in Oakland and Berkeley].”

Matias Portela has become a regular downtown vendor recently, selling his jewelry at a table that takes several minutes to set up and break down. While this makes the one-hour time limit unrealistic, he says he is often able to stay for several hours without being bothered.

“It's impossible for me to rent a shop,” says Portela. “I work with my hands, so I can't [fill] a big shop.”

He has a permit to sell his work on the sidewalk in San Francisco, which he says works better for his business. He simply calls the city’s Art Commission in the morning when he wants to sell his necklaces and stones. In Santa Cruz he says he is often allowed to stay long past the one-hour time limit, but says he has also occasionally been asked to move by the downtown hosts.

Lindener says that creating competition with brick and mortar businesses can cause tension, but in hard times everyone should have a chance to get back on their feet.

“There does need to be a culture that is more receptive [to] the concept that street vendors could easily be part of the ecosystem,” says Lindener. “There is cramped view that says big money runs the commerce, and if you're not big money, you're out. That is what our economy is suffering from right now.”

Salvano is on the fence about merchants being allowed to do business free of the big costs that businesses have. After some thought, he arrives at the proposal of having a three day “grace period” for artists and craftsman that come downtown to sell their work.

“If it's just a fluke that you are down here and spreading your necklaces out, that is one thing,” says Salvano. “But if you are down here day in an day out and have basically opened a business on the sidewalk. ... After three days you [should] have to go get a permit.”

Comments (2)

...written by Robert Norse,
September 17, 2011

This article doesn't dig very deep and fumbles in some key facts.

The City Council's 2009 legal changes added a variety of new "sacred objects" around which it would be illegal to sit or sparechange within 14' and perform or politically table within 10' (not 14' as the article claims). Particularly cynical were the addition of "sculpture or artwork displayed on public property" to objects around which simple and natural things like sitting and playing music were banned.

The "forbidden zone" list now includes ""any building, street corner or intersection, kiosk, drinking fountain, public telephone, public bench, ATM machine or other cash disbursal machines or any other outdoor machine or device which disburses or accepts coins or paper currency except parking meters and newspaper vending machines" as well as "public trash compactor & information or directory/map signs" Gives the police pretty wide discretion to move along whomever they choose, doesn't it?

The Coonerty-Robinson Council attacked homeless people (as well as street performers, political tablers, and street vendors) by making any three infraction tickets that don't get paid trigger a misdemeanor prosecution and/or make all subsequent infractions misdemeanors. Aside from the fact that this is unconstitutional, it's cruel and stupid. Poor and homeless people have trouble making court dates and finding food and shelter much less paying absurd "get out of town" fines.

Street performers and vendors were thrown into the mix as collateral damage as part of the eager political witchhunt to satisfy conservative merchants and residents to remove visible poverty from the downtown area. You can't specifically single out the homeless community. So you have to specify that everyone is banned from sitting, sparechanging, performing for donation, vending, or political tabling on 95% of the sidewalk with these 10' and 14' forbidden zones.

That's downtown. All such "criminal" activities are completely banned on sidewalks in other business districts since sidewalks are 10' side or less. Gives the police lots of power, doesn't it.

Of course, the author doesn't go into this, nor into the functional and effective Voluntary Street Performers Guidelines that were overturned by these vicious ordinances (see http://www.buskersadvocates.or...Guide.html ).

We don't need permits, talent contests, or policing—just a return to the seminal VSPGs of 1980-2002. They worked just fine.

+0

...written by opus,
September 13, 2011

the day the music died.

+0

Write comment

Name

Title

Comment below-comments are moderated and may not post immediately. No Spam please.smaller | bigger

Share this on your social networks

Share this

Green Swell

Local surfboard company greens up the industry with an eco-conscious business model

Two Fish Bound by a Golden Cord

Until March 20, (Spring Equinox), Earth and her kingdoms (mineral, plant, animal, human) experience the influence of Pisces, sign of the World Savior. Whereas the task of Aquarius is as world server, the Pisces task is saving the world—tasks given to the two fishes. Pisces never really enters matter, and as the last sign of the zodiac includes all the signs. During Pisces, having gathered all the gifts of the previous 11 signs, it is a good time to prepare for new initiating plans when Aries (sign of beginnings) begins. No wonder Pisces, like Scorpio, is so difficult (both are ruled by Pluto, planet of death, new life, regeneration, transformations). Both signs (with Scorpio drowning in dark and deep waters) find life on Earth a hardship, disorienting (from the spiritual perspective), at times feeling betrayed. Life is a paradox, especially for Pisces.
Each zodiacal sign represents and distributes a different phase and facet (12) of the Soul’s diamond light, Pisces is the “Light of Life itself, ending forever the darkness of matter.” It takes two fish to complete this work (creating eventually an extraordinary human being). One fish turned toward the material world (in order to understand matter), the other fish toward the heavenly world. Around the two fish is a silvery cord binding them together. The two fish are forever bound until all of humanity is redeemed (lifted up into the Light). This is the dedication of all world saviors (Buddha, Christ, the NGWS). Thus the sacrifice and suffering experienced by Pisces. Knowing these things about Pisces, let us help them all we can. Sometimes all of humanity is Pisces.

The New Tech Nexus

Community leaders in science and technology unite to form web-based networking program