Boxwave vs. TreoCentral's screen protectors...

I have heard that the screen protectors that are sold here at TC's website are very similiar if not the same as the Boxwave's. I was asking which Boxwave are they comparing it to, the Crystal clear or the Anti-glare? I've also heard that the Crystal clear, even though you can't tell that anything is there, it picks up smudges, etc... And the Anti-glare gives the screen a dull look. Can anyone comment on this?