"...a pitch-perfect, raunchy send-up of every other holiday show in town and on TV."- Thirdcoast Digest

"...hysterically funny..."- Totaltheatre.com“...unapologetically crass, unexpectedly addictive experience that seems to fly by just as quickly as Santa’s guests tear through his liquor reserves. Who Killed Santa? may just be the perfect remedy for any Scrooge who wrinkles their nose at the standard, wholesome features of the holiday season.”

“Who Killed Santa? simultaneously shocks and charms with its blunt irreverence to Christmas’ most beloved figures. Haven’s sucker-punch dialogue had the crowd cackling from start to finish (a few self-deprecating, Wisconsin-specific digs received particularly riotous responses), and the plot kept the audience on their toes as it veered further and further into the realm of insanity.”

"Let the hilarity ensue . . . and it DOES – non-stop, in fact – not even when the audience has a chance to catch its breath during the intermission, as we were still laughing and wiping our eyes from the first act."

​”The genius of this show is in its incorporation of incredibly dark subjects into the world of puppets. The dialogue is punchy, the comedy blue and the speakers adorable—a formula for over-the-top laughs.”​"...somewhere near the end of the play, you realize that you’ve watched a triple homicide at a holiday party with Rudolph, Tiny Tim and Frosty and the vague sense of the bizarre becomes quite clear. It’s fun and it may be something of a guilty pleasure, but there’s a genuine heart to it all..."

"...hysterically funny, completely improbable and undeniably entertaining...It spoofs nearly every Christmas tradition one can imagine, all the while holding together the play’s interesting plot twists."