We post articles to make G4EF richer in terms of the available knowledge. As Nadr said in the other thread : he just wanted to share this piece of code with all other members ( so that it might save them hours of searching, at some point of time ).

So I don't think, we should continue any further discussion on this topic, because awards was never the aim of posting articles here. (at least not for me)

And lastly, I think the poster is perfectly eligible to contest for any award as long as he mentions the coding-standards used by him, correctly. I feel so because, we should judge codes on their logic and algo, instead of judging on other less important aspects.

We post articles to make G4EF richer in terms of the available knowledge. As Nadr said in the other thread : he just wanted to share this piece of code with all other members ( so that it might save them hours of searching, at some point of time ).

So I don't think, we should continue any further discussion on this topic, because awards was never the aim of posting articles here. (at least not for me)

And lastly, I think the poster is perfectly eligible to contest for any award as long as he mentions the coding-standards used by him, correctly. I feel so because, we should judge codes on their logic and algo, instead of judging on other less important aspects.

Click to expand...

Point taken- but if a poster want to share something- I feel it should be done in a correct way- because a lot of times. Non standard code is in use- can lead to sloppy coding habits...

Point taken- but if a poster want to share something- I feel it should be done in a correct way- because a lot of times. Non standard code is in use- can lead to sloppy coding habits...

Click to expand...

This codes are not for use but for reference but if you are using them then you are anyway sloppy in approach.

Also yes Awards are not aim of many of us and as you can see from couple of people already in this thread and I have seen many such incident. Its just that we have awards to keep things interested as well.