Monday, 13 October 2008

The UAE should rethink its organ donation policy

It is ironic that if I die in Britain my organs will be donated to any person who may be in need of them, as per my expressed permission on my UK driving licence (I ticked the box). In what some may refer to as a "circle of karma", my elder brother is a seasoned blood donor and some of my relatives have benefited from cornea transplants in the USA.

The fact that the UAE along with other Middle Eastern states has yet to introduce an organ donation law – even though the Ministry of Health has been "mulling" doing so for as long as I can remember – is shameful. It should require only a few months to study the law, take it to the Federal National Council (and give them some much required work) and then present it to the country's President to sign in as legislation, should it be acceptable of course.

Until then, Emiratis will continue to travel to places like the Philippines and South Asia to seek organs. The reason for this delay can partly be attributed to the various religious edicts that cast a shadow of doubt on the concept of organ donation. Despite the fact that the Holy Quran is very clear on the value and the sanctity of life as expressed in the Al-Ma'ida Sura of the Holy Scripture: "Whoso saves the life of one, it shall be as if he had saved the life of all mankind" (Chapter 5: Verse 32). Note that the verse highlights the value of human life in general and not just that of Muslims.

Recently, an Omani scholar stated: "Our body is sacred and a dead body is respected in Islam and there's no need to scavenge it for organ donations." The numbers beg to differ with the scholar. In neighbouring Muslim Saudi Arabia, there were 8,500 patients waiting for kidney transplants alone.

These sorts of fatwas lead to confusion in Islamic countries including the UAE, Egypt and Pakistan, where a study found that only 60 per cent of people were willing to donate organs while 73 per cent were willing to receive such donations.

In Israel, a country that, like the UAE, that has mixed feelings about organ donations due to confusing rabbinical edicts, the parents of Ahmad Khatib, a 12-year-old Palestinian boy who was shot dead in Jenin in 2005 by Israeli soldiers, donated his organs for use in Israel. The organs ended up saving the lives of five Israeli children and an elderly woman. This compassionate gesture was praised as remarkable by the occupying power's parliamentary speaker as the organs went to save the lives of Arabs, Jews and Druze.

One of the recipients, also a 12-year-old child from Israel's Arab minority, has been waiting for an organ for five years. "I feel that my son has entered the heart of every Israeli," said Ahmad's father.

The issue with the validity and the enforcement of consensual organ donation is not simply restricted to the developing countries of the Middle East. A study in the British Medical Journal in 2006 showed that 41 per cent of families in the UK blocked the harvesting of organs from patients who, when they were alive, had given written permission for them to be taken.

In fact, Britain has a surprisingly low ratio of organ donations, with only 16 in every one million persons per year donating their organs compared with more than double that ratio in Spain. The problem mostly was the 41 per cent – up from 30 per cent in the 1990s – of families who denied consent after their relative's death, with the ratio rising among the ethnic minorities.

There are several ways that governments can encourage organ donations, according to the UK's Parliamentary Office of Science and Technology, the body in charge of issuing such recommendations. Amongst the POST's suggestions is to follow Spain's Presumed Consent, which means that a deceased person's organs could be taken for transplant unless he or she specifically "opts out"; of course this system can also be coupled with the family's permission.

The most common method is the Opt In system, where people fill in a form that indicates their wish to donate organs after death. Finally, there is the so-called Incentive Scheme, where priority for certain medical treatments is given to patients who are willing to be organ donors.

In June of this year, Mubadala, the Abu Dhabi owned sovereign wealth fund, invested more than Dh340 million ($92.6 million) in a hospital in Kobe, Japan that will specialise in organ transplants and regenerative medicine, where it will send doctors to acquire organ transplant knowledge.

The hospital is due to open in 2010, so let's hope that by the time it is ready the UAE's Ministry of Health will have done mulling and finally drafted the organ donation law. If it hasn't, Mubadala will have to find other uses for these valuable and well trained physicians – or maybe it will just send them to the Philippines.

*This article was originally published in The National newspaper on 12 Oct 2008

3 comments:

i think islamically it IS allowed to donate organs. it is even allowed for living people to donate their organs, as long as it doesn't damage their own health, and make a life-saving change for the donee. the doner isn't allowed to sell organs either.

definite research should definitely be carried out and a conclusion should be reached. if it does turn out to be religiously alright from majority of scholars, then a law should be passed immediately, so as not to waste any more time.

I've been discussing this issue lately with my family .. while death issue appeared in one of our conversation... my mother didn't approve that much on the fact that I'm willing to donate my organs .. it's very emotional to the people here .. they still can't go beyond that to see how it will affect other's !mabye some families who had an incident that they needed other human's organs .. it kid of less shocking & acceptable .. since they suffered & know how it will change ppl's life around them ..

Sultan Sooud Al Qassemi is an Op Ed contributor to a variety of publications. His articles have appeared in The National & Gulf News in the UAE as well as Foreign Policy, New York Times, The Guardian, The Independent and the Financial Times.