Considering that we get to make the decisions as Lee, why not choose him as the best leader?

Rick- Are you talking about tv Rick or comic Rick? The comic Rick has grown into a scared man that's afraid to do anything. Surprised he's still alive. Hell, his own kid is shaping up to be a better leader than he is. Tv Rick is great, but he still has his own faults.

Shane- Really? This guy seems like he would eventually kill off everyone in the group if it means to have Carl and Lori all to himself.

Kenny- Guy is cool, but we'd be screwed.

Lilly- Lilly was a great leader apart from blatant group relations. I didn't like how she handled the food rations, but I admired her perseverance.

Rick is the best I think, but I've only read up to Issue #90, so he might be different now from what I remember. He and his group completely destroyed the Governor's army during the prison assault and he managed to get everyone to D.C. ok..

Shane was going to get everyone killed waiting outside Atlanta for a rescue that would never come.

Lee is player controlled. In some games he'd be a rgeat leader, and in others he would get everyone killed.

Kenny can think on his feet, but for long term survival he would be useless.

Lilly fails to inspire confidence and keep up morale, although she's pretty good at longterm survival. The rationing was smart, if not the way she handled it.

Considering that we get to make the decisions as Lee, why not choose him as the best leader?

Rick- Are you talking about tv Rick or comic Rick? The comic Rick has grown into a scared man that's afraid to do anything. Surprised he's still alive. Hell, his own kid is shaping up to be a better leader than he is. Tv Rick is great, but he still has his own faults.

Shane- Really? This guy seems like he would eventually kill off everyone in the group if it means to have Carl and Lori all to himself.

Kenny- Guy is cool, but we'd be screwed.

Lilly- Lilly was a great leader apart from blatant group relations. I didn't like how she handled the food rations, but I admired her perseverance.

Out of everyone? Lilly is, she wasn't completely heartless, she just didn't want the group poking around in other survivors business and wanted to keep the group out of harms way.

Haven't seen Lee-tatorship yet, only lee-ocracy, so I can't cast a opinion on that.

Rock114;699648 said:

They could have starved without her rationing you know...

I think they would have, its a definite for me.

KingOfTheDead;699735 said:

maybe and nice name man

Thanks I guess

Let's think about this guys, moving and moving and moving like Kenny wants to do, will that even work? As far as I can tell in the comics it didn't, Kenny is a valuable group member, but even though Lilly seems to have a entire different set of morals than I do, she still seems the better leader... thats my opinion.