10 Most Controversial Beauty Products

No. 5: Jergens Natural Glow Daily Moisturizer, $6.99 TotalBeauty.com average reader rating: 6.8*
Why it's controversial: Readers seem to agree that this looks "natural," however they don't agree that this is always a good thing. While some say, "this product gives a very natural glow and subtle color," others contend there was "close to no color difference whatsoever on my skin." Some like the moisture level of the lotion and say "this is a great self tanner for those who are new to self tanners," but others say, "I don't feel I really get adequate moisturizing." One thing they can all agree on: they "don't like the smell."