You should try this: https://xfrocks.com/posts/1628/
Also, if you are testing with your admin accounts, make sure you connected the two accounts first in WordPress Dashboard > Users > Profile, scroll to bottom, connect to XenForo.

Click to expand...

Thank you, that worked perfect. I think this was set up before, don't know why it got cleared. Maybe I set up a new client down the road when I updated XF.

You should try this: https://xfrocks.com/posts/1628/
Also, if you are testing with your admin accounts, make sure you connected the two accounts first in WordPress Dashboard > Users > Profile, scroll to bottom, connect to XenForo.

Click to expand...

Maybe this is why I can't post. At the bottom of my profile, I get the following:

It only says "Connect to an account," and clicking it takes me right back to my profile. I am running this on a WP Network, although I am thinking of turning it off on the network and only using it on individual WP sites instead.

The plugin is designed to work with Network too. So that should not be a problem.

Can you take screenshot when you click the link? It may take you to XenForo. Or it may take you to WordPress login page. It should never redirect you back to profile.php though. It's important to take screenshot of the address bar of your browser too, there are some debug information there.

Do you use Chrome? Please enable developer tool, go to Network tab, check the Preserve option. Click the link again. Then go to the Network tab, right click the first entry, choose Save as HAR and send me the file.

If you don't have the browser, can you share the login credentials so I can test myself?