Colon-Montanez is accused of exposing himself to an unidentified juvenile girl, who said the incident happened while the two of them were sitting in the same area in the rear of the bus. The girl said Colon-Montanez went from sharing a seat with her to sitting by himself directly across from her. She said Colon-Montanez claimed he was cold and placed a jacket over his lap like a blanket.

The girl said Colon-Montanez told her to look in his direction, and exposed himself when she did. She said that as he exposed himself, he told her "you know you like me."

The girl told police she was offended and did not ask Colon-Montanez to expose himself.

When officers spoke with Colon-Montanez, he said he did expose himself to the girl while they were on the bus. He said he told the girl to come sit beside him before exposing himself, but "could not provide an explanation as to why he committed this act," according to court documents.

A summons was sent to Colon-Montanez on June 9, which he accepted Thursday.