I'm currently using an OTC local brand shaving cream (though looks more like a gel to me) concoction in a tube that is heavily menthol infused. I swear though it leaves my skin very cool and soft as it's ever been. The only thing is the oils in it do tend to leave your skin looking a little shiny/oily immediately after, but I think that's because it doesn't rinse off so easily and nothing a quick buff with a towel won't resolve. If you can find anything similar at your local drug store, I'd recommend it.

Most weekdays I shave in the shower with a Mach III and Anthony Logistics unscented shave cream. I've found that some of the tube creams tend to stay creamy (i.e. do not lather well), but this one doesn't have that problem--it lathers up quickly in my hands. I've only recently discovered it, but so far I've been very pleased.

For weekends and special occasions when I feel like taking more time, I shave at the sink with a Merkur safety razor and badger brush. For this I prefer Truefitt and Hill, but I've used Proraso before and it also works well. FWIW, I think Proraso is the best value at its price point, but T&H is probably worth the extra cost.

I'm the type who doesn't have a problem spending money on a premium brand of anything to try it. But I find that the cheap, drugstore stuff does fine. What is important to me is to spend money on changing blades regularly. That is what the shave is all about.

Proraso vs Truefitt & Hill (ultra comfort) : (Fighting it out!) I just compared both - one day after the other. Both were very good, but the T&H (ultra comfort) provided a slightly smoother shaving experience (gliding just a bit better) and the closeness was a bit better. Definitely worth the extra money in my opinion. The Proraso is "fun" to have around, but I prefer TH.

I really like GEO F TRUMPER shaving creams. I have limes, violet, rose and coconut. I am not crazy about coconut, but love the others. So far I have purchased the tubes and use them interchangeably. I was thinking about buying the shaving soap in limes (or violet or rose), but am not sure how that compares to the shaving cream. Anyone have experience with both and have an opinion? Thanks.

I like Kiss my Face and am months away from running out. I am willing to try a new cream, and want something with similar qualities. Specifically something that is not drying, and does not leave a tacky film on the face after the first pass. Great scents are also a plus since the bedrock of any happy day is an enjoyable shave. I use a brush and DE. Nancy Boy is out of the question since I protest its name.