Overall favorite NFL player of all time? I can't believe no one has mentioned his name yet. This man successfully allowed me to pee my pants in fear and then cry tears of join in a 30 sec time frame. (download the audio clip from the game in the downloads section and get pumped)
Az-Zahir Hakim

Saints player of all time:
Joe Horn- can't carry a team on your back and more than he has
Norman Hand- I loved seeing his chubby a## chasing guys down
Will Smith, Charlest Grant- the future