2 Bottles of Old Weller

One is hand numbered 5135-D and the other 11761. Both are unopened/sealed and have original tags. One is in the original clear box. I am having a hard time looking up thier value with the numbers - I know they make a difference. Does anyone have a suggestion?

You might want to explore the website Bourbon Enthusiast.com ... you could post this question at their Member Forum and hopefully a whisky expert, familiar with your two bottles, will reply.
Good Luck!