Alternatives for Matteo and Micah?

We were somewhat shocked to find out we were having a boy this time around. We had 2-3 favorite girl names all set, but we've always had a hard time with boy names. We both love Matteo, but one of my close friends has a son named that and I almost feel like I would be stealing. I ADOREMicah, but my husband isn't a fan. I've been trying to think of names similar to these two. Any suggestions? We want something strong, masculine and unique (but not too weird). His middle name will probably be Reid, if that helps. Much appreciated!