re: DECLINED - App: Samawi - by Charmagon

Personal InformationReal Name: Ahmed samawi Age: 24 Battletag: samawi#2706 Where are you from?: iraq Character InformationCharacter Name: samawi Class: Warlock Applying as social or Raider: Raider If you are applying as a raider what roles would you prefer to fill: DPS Please detail your previous raiding/guild experience: Done Antorus HC from 4 to 9 times, was in Odyssey guild. Addons and interface informationDo you have a microphone and are you able to use communication software such as Teamspeak: Yes What addons do you use to improve raiding performance?: Big wings, WeakAuras 2, lvUI, SpellFlash, DBM Miscellaneous - Please ensure you have read the guild rules before completing this section.What is your favourite colour?: Red Do you have anything else which may support your application.: No. AvailabilityApplication Availability Info: Sunday -> 3x a Month Monday -> 3x a Month Tuesday -> 3x a Month Wednesday -> 3x a Month Thursday -> 3x a Month Friday -> 3x a Month Saturday -> 3x a Month

re: DECLINED - App: Samawi - by Charmagon

I've reviewed your application and I must admit there are a few things which are of great concern to me.

The first thing which struck me as odd was that you had been part of Odyssey since December but I was unable to find any logs to which you attended one of their raids. It's clear that you have completed the latest content on heroic in pugs, which isn't an issue, but it does suggest there was an issue between you and your previous guild.

Fortunately some of the pugs in which you did attend, enough logs were recorded to allow me have an indication of your performance as a player, but unfortunately these logs do not paint you in a very good light.

As you can see from the link above, your best parse history isn't terrible but it isn't great either. My concern here is that your average parses are around 19% which implies that 81% of warlocks with the same gear level as you are out performing you.

Based on the date of the parses, they don't show a clear week on week improvement but only a single log for each fight were you did ok and subsequent kills where you performed worse.

During you application, you may have also noticed an odd question which seems completely unrelated to wow. This question is a trick to see the kind of person who is applying to the guild to allow us to get an idea of if you are a good fit or not. Your answer to this question implies that you did not read the guild rules as instructed which is yet another black mark on your application.

With the exception of the guild rules the other points I have raised are potentially circumstantial, so I decided to contact a trusted source we have inside Odyssey.

They unfortunately did not portray you positively, so based on the points raised, I'm going to decline this application.

Normally we would offer people a social spot for the chance of attending one of our farm raids, but in this instance I don't feel that you would be a good fit so I've also declined you for a social spot as well.

Thanks again for taking the time to make an application and I hope you find a guild more suited to you in the future.