“My producer tells me that you said to him, ‘I hate strawberries.’ You hate strawberries. But you also told New York magazine last year, ‘I have never eaten a strawberry in my life.’ Which is it, Tom?” he asked. “Do you hate strawberries?”

Colbert then presented Brady with a bowl of strawberries and dared him to take a bite of one. It took some convincing but Brady couldn’t turn down Colbert’s challenge.

“Not that bad,” he said after trying the red fruit for the first time.

Brady stopped by The Late Show to promote his new book about his holistic lifestyle, The TB12 Method, but he revealed that he’s changed his diet drastically from his younger years, which included cheeseburgers and beer regularly.

“You don’t drink beer?” Colbert asked as soon as he brought it up.

“Rarely,” Brady responded.

Colbert then pulled two glasses of beer out from behind his desk.

“I was a pretty good beer-chugger back in the day,” Brady warned Colbert.