In 2007, Witmer was a contestant on first season of VH1's reality dating show Rock of Love.[3] Although she made it into the house, she exited after the second episode along with three other contestants.[4] She later returned for both the special Clip and Reunion episodes after the completion of the first season.

In 2009, Witmer was a contestant on the second season of the VH1 competition show I Love Money. She appeared in only the first episode, after losing an arm wrestling match.[5][6]