In Times of Adityanath, a Look at Kebabs, Crocodile Meat & More

As far as I know, buffalo and mutton are legal. Why then does the government want to shut down these businesses?

These are trying times. Even some friends are turning. They probably see their interest better protected by keeping their options open for adjustments, should excesses increase. And even if they show their residual spunk by digging in their heels in favour of Lucknow's iconic Tunday Kababi, how will it help matters?

Tunday has already made his compromise; he will now sell chicken and mutton kebab. All those anchors and headline writers reflecting wistfully on the passing away of the "galawati" as distinct from "Shaami" may need to know a thing or two.

From Syria to Shaami – A Short History

Shaami derives from Shaam, the old name for Syria. The kebab was developed during the Ottoman period. Mince and soaked lentil, ground with spices is patted and shaped like a small-mac and dipped in egg white to hold. It is then fried. The best Shaami kebabs in Delhi are at the Gymkhana Club.

A Distinct Galawti Recipe

The "galawati" is a short hand for kachche-keemey-ke-kebab. The mince is marinated for hours with a paste of raw papaya, mixed with spices and in small blobs is allowed to fry in a flat "lagan" or vessel on a very slow fire. The juicy softness comes from the marination. The best "galawati" in Delhi is a difficult-to-reach Chef Khemraj Sharma.

Hindus of Beef

Sharma is not the only Brahmin in the business. The iconic La Closerie des Lilas in Paris boasted, until last year, of Satish Mishra for his classic Tartar steaks, which is mostly raw minced beef (yes, cow), richly spiced.

Tartar steak, derived from Tartaristan of Caucasus, is different from the uncooked beef steaks in, say, Belgrade. These steaks replicate the 200 or 500 mile steaks made famous by the Mongol hordes in the 13th century. This needs explanation. To start a fire to cook food was dangerous for Gengiz Khan and Halaku's cavalries. The smoke would give them away.

To avoid detection, they developed a system of placing hunks of lightly marinated beef between the lining on a horseback and the saddle. By the time the horse had trotted, cantered and galloped for 100 miles or even less, the intense heat generated by sheer friction had cooked the meat.

In Fiji, Sitiveni Rabuka, the Melanesian strongman, who ousted the socialist government of Timothi Bavandra which had a large number of Indian descendants of 19th century indentured labourers, acquainted me with the macabre dietary habits of his ancestors.

When the first Christian missionary entered his village to convert his grandfather, the village head, he was promptly slaughtered.

A traditional Fijian way of roasting a full animal (in this case a human being), was to dig a large pit in the ground called the "Lovo". It was lined with read hot coal, and the body was placed on this fiery bed. Palm leaves were placed on the carcass which was then piled with mud. It was allowed to steam until the time to feast.

The second priest met the same fate. But the Church would not give up. By the time the third priest appeared, the old man had softened. A whole generation of Rabuka's vintage are today the stoutest pillars of the Christian church.

BJP’s Aversion to “Exotic” Cuisines

There are a chain of expensive restaurants stretching from Nairobi to a part of South Africa called the Carnivore, known for esoteric meats like Giraffe, wilder beast, Zebra, crocodile and, on rare occasions, a lion, dying of natural causes. I have a video footage of Dara Singh, the original Hanuman of Bollywood, burping outside Carnivore – well, almost.

In the Asia Pacific region – China, Vietnam, Korea – dairy produce, one of the reasons for our attachment to cow, is at a discount. These societies obtain their protein directly from anything that moves, including snakes, lizards, insects, and dogs.

Those currently monitoring our dietary habits may be averse to noticing some of bizarre exotic cuisines — like rats and rodents as regular fare for Musahirs in Bihar.

Every urban settlement has a "bustee", or a settlement for Dalits, with rows of scavenger piglets playing in the gutter. Pasis, the community which owns these animals – together they are supposed to keep the neighbourhood clean – is required to devour them on ceremonial occasions, every morsel chased by large quantities of home-made hooch.

Since unlicensed butcher shops have been abruptly closed in Uttar Pradesh so that unclean meat may not find its way to your table, I am sure the government in its benign wisdom will find ways to disinfect rats and gutter pigs.

Beef Ban Not About Cow Protection

Everyone knows that the present step is not to protect the cow, because beef is not in the bargain. The question of slaughtering cows does not arise. That is illegal. The petrified meat seller will never take that risk. The burgeoning population of the holy cows foraging on our garbage dumps is ample testimony that the cow is safe from the butcher’s knife.

As far as I know buffalo and mutton are legal. Why then is the government insistent on shutting down these businesses? I am told they are cleaning up the trade. Will illegal cart vendors, selling sweets, gur and other fare that attract swarms of flies also attract the attention of "Swachch Bharat" brigands?

So what if the garbage dumps outside hospitals and schools have not been cleaned. A beginning has been made with the slaughterhouses.

(This piece has been published in an arrangement with IANS. A senior commentator on political and diplomatic affairs, Saeed Naqvi can be reached on saeednaqvi@hotmail.com. The views expressed are personal.)