Our Mother company is pushing us to integrate Active Directory and have our domain under their forest. We are two different companies and we have our own IT infrastructure and IT team. We might have plans to go seperate in the near future but they are still pushing too hard for the integration phase. What is the Disadvatanges/Advantages of such an integration? I would appreciate a detailed answer. Thanks

Answer Wiki

<b>Benefits of Active Directory integration</b>
For networks deploying DNS to support Active Directory, directory-integrated primary zones are strongly recommended and provide the following benefits:

<b>Multimaster update and enhanced security based on the capabilities of Active Directory.</b>

In a standard zone storage model, DNS updates are conducted based upon a single-master update model. In this model, a single authoritative DNS server for a zone is designated as the primary source for the zone.

This server maintains the master copy of the zone in a local file. With this model, the primary server for the zone represents a single fixed point of failure. If this server is not available, update requests from DNS clients are not processed for the zone.

With directory-integrated storage, dynamic updates to DNS are conducted based upon a multimaster update model.

In this model, any authoritative DNS server, such as a domain controller running a DNS server, is designated as a primary source for the zone. Because the master copy of the zone is maintained in the Active Directory database, which is fully replicated to all domain controllers, the zone can be updated by the DNS servers operating at any domain controller for the domain.

With the multimaster update model of Active Directory, any of the primary servers for the directory-integrated zone can process requests from DNS clients to update the zone as long as a domain controller is available and reachable on the network.

Also, when using directory-integrated zones, you can use access control list (ACL) editing to secure a dnsZone object container in the directory tree. This feature provides granulated access to either the zone or a specified RR in the zone.

For example, an ACL for a zone RR can be restricted so that dynamic updates are only allowed for a specified client computer or a secure group such as a domain administrators group. This security feature is not available with standard primary zones.

Note that when you change the zone type to be directory-integrated, the default for updating the zone changes to allow only secure updates. Also, while you may use ACLs on DNS-related Active Directory objects, ACLs may only be applied to the DNS client service.

<b>Zones are replicated and synchronized to new domain controllers automatically whenever a new one is added to an Active Directory domain</b>.

Although DNS service can be selectively removed from a domain controller, directory-integrated zones are already stored at each domain controller, so zone storage and management is not an additional resource. Also, the methods used to synchronize directory-stored information offer performance improvement over standard zone update methods, which can potentially require transfer of the entire zone.

By integrating storage of your DNS zone databases in Active Directory, you can streamline database replication planning for your network.

When your DNS namespace and Active Directory domains are stored and replicated separately, you need to plan and potentially administer each separately. For example, when using standard DNS zone storage and Active Directory together, you would need to design, implement, test, and maintain two different database replication topologies. For instance, one replication topology is needed for replicating directory data between domain controllers, and another topology would be needed for replicating zone databases between DNS servers.

This can create additional administrative complexity for planning and designing your network and allowing for its eventual growth. By integrating DNS storage, you unify storage management and replication issues for both DNS and Active Directory, merging and viewing them together as a single administrative entity.

<b>Directory replication is faster and more efficient than standard DNS replication.</b>

Because Active Directory replication processing is performed on a per-property basis, only relevant changes are propagated. This allows less data to be used and submitted in updates for directory-stored zones.

<b>Notes</b>

Only primary zones can be stored in the directory. A DNS server cannot store secondary zones in the directory. It must store them in standard text files. The multimaster replication model of Active Directory removes the need for secondary zones when all zones are stored in Active Directory.

The DNS Server service includes an option to initialize the DNS Server service by reading parameters stored in the Active Directory database and the server registry. This is the default boot option.

By submitting you agree to receive email from TechTarget and its partners. If you reside outside of the United States, you consent to having your personal data transferred to and processed in the United States.
Privacy

Processing your response...

Discuss This Question: 3 &nbspReplies

There was an error processing your information. Please try again later.

By submitting you agree to receive email from TechTarget and its partners. If you reside outside of the United States, you consent to having your personal data transferred to and processed in the United States.
Privacy

The benefits of a single domain /domain consolidation would be in infrastructure simplicity, less hardware/domain controllers, less staff to manage the environment, consolidated security management, hence save money.
On the other hand, if you are planning to become separate companies in the near future like 12-18 months, then consolidation does not make sense.

By submitting you agree to receive email from TechTarget and its partners. If you reside outside of the United States, you consent to having your personal data transferred to and processed in the United States.
Privacy

Processing your reply...

Ask a Question

Free Guide: Managing storage for virtual environments

Complete a brief survey to get a complimentary 70-page whitepaper featuring the best methods and solutions for your virtual environment, as well as hypervisor-specific management advice from TechTarget experts. Don’t miss out on this exclusive content!

Share this item with your network:

To follow this tag...

By submitting you agree to receive email from TechTarget and its partners. If you reside outside of the United States, you consent to having your personal data transferred to and processed in the United States.
Privacy