Discussion of Round #2

Story: "It was the day after the festival and the mood in the morning was good at first, however that good mood was short lived. After a while the group noticed that their good friend guam was missing. After searching a while there was no sign of her, the Chief was worried as guam was never one for not showing up.

That is when Ali looked n the teepee guam lived in, and saw the body but before she could call for help the The Three Amigos appeared behind her, and with bows in hand ended any hope of her calling for help. Also with just as swift movement they were gone to hide their weapons.

A few minutes later the three amigos were back in the group as the group discovered the bodies. Back as the tension grew."

Stewie

---This message was edited on 2013-03-04 13:18:52---Did you know? In Pueblo Colorado, it is illegal to grow dandilions.

Going with someone who hasn't logged in today. Happy ever after in the marketplace, Desmond lets the children lend a hand. Molly stays at home and does her pretty face, and in the evening she's the singer with the band!

Hey there! Just checking in. Will vote in the morning, after more have had a chance to post.Take all sorrow out of life and you take away all richness, and depth, and tenderness. The capacity of sorrow belongs to our grandeur. It is the furnace that melts hearts together in love.

Getting ready to go to bed, will SPV for now for slammngirl92 but will be back in the morning to see what others have to say and confirm or change. Formula for success: rise early, work hard, strike oil. J. Paul Getty

I do suggest creating a majority on an inactive like Jmoney or limerickHappy ever after in the marketplace, Desmond lets the children lend a hand. Molly stays at home and does her pretty face, and in the evening she's the singer with the band!

Placed an SPV on scrub this round.Take all sorrow out of life and you take away all richness, and depth, and tenderness. The capacity of sorrow belongs to our grandeur. It is the furnace that melts hearts together in love.

Well, obviously can't be too happy with current majority :p Tempted on a revenge vote on slammn, but, for now going with Melody on the basic theory that 1) She posted shortly after round end, but not first to draw attention 2) No votes against her, which honestly, at this point in the game with 3 wolves out there who probably won't vote for themselves seems to make that a safer bet than not

1st round, majority was formed on guamgirl, so, yes, I agree it is reasonable to think a wolf would be likely to support a majority against her. Rhythmic was part of said majority, so suggesting that strikes me as a bit too close to home if he were a wolf, so I am inclined to trust him even if he doesn't trust me :p

Also in the first round, Alikat was eaten who both debc and Melody voted against. I find it unlikely that the wolves would eat who they voted for with so much choice available in the first round, suggesting that they may well be innocent.

Now, also of note, with the wolves knowing who is who, they are the most likely to be able to pull off zero votes against. Right now that would be catmandon, Melody, Rhythmic and pottercrazy.

pottercrazy is particularly of note as we have some rather vocal support of voting inactives, yet he has no votes.

There are also several players playing cards pretty close to their vests in Melody, snow, and bradon which is a fairly safe strategy for those wishing to avoid attention.

As far as majority forming, I think it is a bit early focusing on a majority unless we have definitive information. As what difference is there really between a random person being shot and us choosing one unless there is real information behind such a choice. This brings koin and slammn to attention, though interestingly enough, though both are going for a majority, they chose against eachother.

As mentioned before, seeing as a wolf voting makes the round end, it seems logical that they are most likely to be around at the start of the next round as they have a rough idea when it will start. This leads to koin, slammn, Rhythmic, catmandon... Although the night may have timed out or come close, there is no real reason to believe that the final voter if there was one wouldn't be active to start the round. Although maybe not all three wolves, I would expect some of them to be active early and often. Being a wolf is exciting you know!

So we have a lot here, but also, we need three who actually fit together, at least somewhat, strategically. Probably not voting for the same people but not openly opposing.

Right now, there are few out there to trust, but right now, I am leading towards trusting catmandon (due to his vocal response against majorities), Rhythmic (as it seems unlikely he would call attention to a group which includes himself if he is a wolf), debc and Melody (admittedly, these are weaker, but I don't think they would have went with eating the one they voted for, it draws unnecessary attention), and obviously, I trust myself :p

For right now, my suspicions are pointing towards koin, slammn, and pottercrazy. I am switching my vote to pottercrazy as he is inactive and, to me, suspiciously, remains unvoted for.

Limerick's post makes a lot of sense to me. I'm switching to pottercrazy since he hasn't voted and also voted for guamgirl in Round 1.

I wonder about koin and JMoney as well...

Also, I think the Ali eating may be a ploy to point people towards the alphabetical eating that happens when wolves don't vote. That logic would lead to 4wheels, but I'm not sold on it. 4wheels may or may not be a wolf, but I'm pretty sure we don't have 3 inactive wolves.

Some good reasoning there Limerick. Glad to see some logic being used . I'm not really sure why the majorities that have formed are there, though most likely it's because several players were previously inactive and the night round timed out or nearly timed out and long night rounds could be because of an inactive wolf or wolves. Past experience tells me that the long nights could also be based on the fact that there were inactive humans and the wolves didn't want to potentially clear anyone so they let the night run long. This is not an uncommon thing with recent werewolf games, especially over the weekends when a lot of people are inactive.

I'm keeping my SPV vote for someone without a vote for now because I truly don't have any suspicions of anyone but I do want to help shield the seer. Formula for success: rise early, work hard, strike oil. J. Paul Getty

Limerick, I was just going for an "inactive" but I don't think its you actually since your post actually made sense to me about some people and since your active it makes me think the others that were inactive are it.

Im going to switch my vote to someone who doesn't have a vote on them yet.

I'm not a wolf, just trying to move the game along. Guamgirl was at least a day inactive.

Limerick, have you played before under a different account?

I like a pottercrasy maj, he hasn't been posting anything this round even though he was online. I did actually talk to him in chat - he said he was not being as active for a personal reason. However, this does not alleviate any suspicion, as night did time out and he hasnt been as active lately.

Normally active players have been playing the sidelines a lot this game. Myself included, but I was specifically thinking of snowmonster and scrub. We really need to rile things up to get them out of their shell.

The majority on wheels isn't making a lot of sense, so in a sense to defend her, but also because I worry about potter, I am changing to pottercrazy.Happy ever after in the marketplace, Desmond lets the children lend a hand. Molly stays at home and does her pretty face, and in the evening she's the singer with the band!

4wheels voted for snowmonster
bradon182001 voted for slammngirl92
catmandon voted for 4wheels
Jmoney95 voted for 4wheels
koin_era345 voted for pottercrazy
Limerick voted for pottercrazy
Melody_Pond voted for debc1
Rhythmic voted for pottercrazy
scrub88 voted for bradon182001
slammngirl92 voted for catmandon
snowmonster voted for scrub88Happy ever after in the marketplace, Desmond lets the children lend a hand. Molly stays at home and does her pretty face, and in the evening she's the singer with the band!

No, not under a different account. I have played before though, in fact this is my 5th game here. I haven't been around much in a while though.

As far as snowy and scrub, I have to agree, they are awfully hard to read when all they say is SPV for... lol, though they are not the only ones. We have very little to go on for debc with her inactivity this round and just voting last round, as well as Melody.

I am not currently sure what I think about the sudden votes for potter, I mean, I believe my logic is sound, but it is almost getting too much support. My vote stands for the moment, but I am still really interested in what we learn next round.

I have changed my vote very often this round, so I will stay out of the majority this round and wait till I can get my head together. I hope potter is a wolf, but I'm just not sure at this point. I'm gonna go back and really focus on this game and try to figure some stuff out.

Not understanding 4wheels vote. She's not putting me in any danger of being shot, but. . . . . wouldn't she vote for pottercrazy, simply to secure her position in the game? She has 2 votes, and with 2 1/2 hours left, anything could happen. Makes me wonder if her head is in this game. or if she simply feels safe enough to vote for me, someone who's not in a majority.Take all sorrow out of life and you take away all richness, and depth, and tenderness. The capacity of sorrow belongs to our grandeur. It is the furnace that melts hearts together in love.

I can appreciate the vote for potter, but I am surprised we have not discussed money more. I am afraid we have put another human in harm's way. I will leave my vote for now since it won't change anything.