Saturday, October 13, 2007

A Coup For Junk Journalism

As expected, the smear attacks and indignant cries of right-wingers, global warming denialists and all assorted anti-Gore maniacs have been flooding the blogosphere.

Incidentally, the same thing is going on in numerous MSM outlets.

Just this day, I found four columns from so-called news columnists/editors - each one repeating the same barbs, same lies and same global warming denialism.

Four different columns, each one equally displaying utter junk journalism.

Let us begin with Terence Corcoran's piece in the National Post, titled "A coup for junk science". Here is the opening line of Mr. Corcoran's opus:

Global warming theory has been in political and scientific trouble for some time.

Yawn. The same type of blatant lie as the one pushed by creationists/IDists with regards to evolution. Same quack tactics - not surprisingly, because what else can deniers do in the face of an established scientific consensus among an overwhelming majority of scientists?

In any case, this opening line from Mr. Corcoran's column is quite telling of the kind of incompetentnews columnist that he is.

But it gets better. Then comes the (expected) parroted barbs and sneers against the actual value of the Nobel Peace Prize:

Rescuing and rewarding the obscure and the absurd has been a Nobel sideline for some years. The award has gone to half a dozen fringe movements and futile causes (the Gameen bank, Mother Teresa, nuclear disarmament, land mine activists, peace negotiators), ineffectual United Nations agencies and personalities (including KofiAnnan and the UN itself ), occasional warmongers (Yasser Arafat), plus an international assortment of minor and woolly-headed players on the world stage (Wangari Masthai, Jimmy Carter).

From there, Mr. Corcoran goes for the jugular:

Onto this heap of forgotten causes and marginalia the Nobel has just tossed Al Gore and the Intergovernmental Panel on Climate Change, the UN's official climate science group. What a blow the award must be to the IPCC, self-proclaimed home of scientific rigour, to now be lumped in with Reverend Al and his Travelling Snake Oil Road Show and Climate Terror Machine.

If history is any guide here, the IPCC is now doomed to slide into obscurity, joining the list of similarly feted UN agencies that beaver away in relative obscurity and ineffectiveness, their Nobels rotting on shelves: The International Atomic Energy Agency (2005), United Nations peacekeeping forces (1988), the UN High Commissioner for Refugees (1981), the International Labour Organization (1969) and the UN Children's Fund (1965).

The first task of the IPCC now, one would think, is to craft a statement disavowing any link with Gore, whose film and book, both titled An Inconvenient Truth, deserved a Nobel for science fiction rather than peace. Not that the IPCC is squeaky clean on the science of climate accuracy. Even the Nobel committee's statement on the IPCC captured the agency's primary role as political shaper of opinion and builder of consensus. IPCC scientific reports have "created an ever-broader informed consensus" about man-made global warming. The Nobel committee said it wanted to "contribute to a sharper focus" on climate change around the world.

This illustrates well the intellectual vapidity and dishonesty of Mr. Corcoran.

First, he casts aspertions on the IPCC for its scientific rigor because, well you know, that is all ignoramuses like Mr. Corcoran can do in order to reassure themselves that their intellectual sloth-driven "beliefs" are sound - nevermind if you have no idea what science and the scientific method are all about. Hence, in Mr. Corcoran's primitive mind, the scientists affiliated with the IPCC must be suspect in their scientific rigor and, consequently, wrong about global warming. Yeah - that's the ticket!

Second, Mr. Corcoran can't help himself but spit literally on Mr. Gore by seeking to ridicule him.

Hence, what we have here are two classic tactics of right-wing nutterers, denialists, fundamentalists and other assorted madhaters: refuse to recognize competence in, and heap ridicule upon, those who "threaten" your ignorance-based beliefs and ideologies.

Then, of course, Mr. Corcoran perpetuates junk journalism by parroting junk journalism from elsewhere, with regards to that recent ruling by a U.K. judge concerning Al Gore's An Inconvenient Truth:

Just hours before the Nobel announcement, Gore was busy spinning his way out of a devastating United Kingdom court case that found nine substantial science errors in the film version of An Inconvenient Truth.

The nine errors, listed on Page A19 of this newspaper, are truly major. But Gore's office, in true political form, tried to turn the science disaster into victory, claiming he was "gratified" that the U.K. court had not totally banned distribution of his film in British schools. Instead, it would have to circulate like a package of cigarettes, with a warning label: Children watch this movie at peril of being politically manipulated by Al Gore into thinking what they are watching is true.

To this effect, do take the time to read the actual ruling of this U.K. judge here. You will notice this very telling passage:

In the event I was persuaded that only some of them were sufficiently persuasive to be relevant for the purposes of his argument, and it was those matters - 9 in all - upon which I invited Mr Chamberlain to concentrate. It was essential to appreciate that the hearing before me did not relate to an analysis of the scientific questions, but to an assessment of whether the 'errors' in question, set out in the context of a political film, informed the argument on ss406 and 407. All these 9 'errors' that I now address are not put in the context of the evidence of Professor Carter and the Claimant's case, but by reference to the IPCC report and the evidence of Dr Stott.

As someone else puts it: "if you noticed the quotation marks around 'error' (...) Burton is not saying that there are errors, he is just referring to the things that Downes alleged were errors".

In other words: junk journalists like Mr. Corcoran and all others of his ilk have been listing without thinking (or perhaps knowingly indeed) nine instances put forth by the plaintif which the complaint deemed "scientific errors" and yet not recognized by the U.K. judge, because the judge himself ruled that it is essential to appreciate that the hearing before him did not relate to an analysis of the scientific questions!

Hence, the judge never outlined errors in Gore's movie and never ruled them as errors!

(For more on this blatant excercize of incompetence on the part of journalists with regards to the ruling of this U.K. judge, read this excellent article).

So, once again, what we have here is another display of stenographing and amplifying outright falsehoods through MSM outlets - thanks to incompetent journalism.

But this doesn't stop Mr. Corcoran from ripping away at Al Gore, his movie (and even his 1997 climate change book as well!), leading to his conclusion:

Given his science gaffes, and his political liabilities, the Nobel may be more of a liability, not just to Gore but to the entire global warming community. The prize has elevated junk science, gross exaggeration and outright misrepresentation to high international stature, the most prestigious award in the world, discrediting all who work honestly to find the facts and do the right thing.

Actually, what we have here is another blatant excercize of junk journalism - nothing more, nothing less.

And as I mentioned at the beginning of the present article, Mr. Corcoran was not alone in displaying utter incompetence today.

Indeed, we were also graced with the "serious, thoughtful and knowledgeable" David Warren, with his piece "If only there were a Nobel prize for deception" in the Ottawa Citizen. I've already discussed Mr. Warren's utter ignorance of all things related scientific. Suffice it to say that his column of today is a mere mirror image of Mr. Corcoran's column discussed above, complete with the same displays of shameless ignorance, vapidity, inanity and parroting of falsehoods (once again, especially with regards to the ruling from the aforementioned U.K. judge). And since three's company, the "serious, thoughtful and knowledgeable" David Frum likewise penned a column on the very same subject in the National Post (again), titled "Honouring a panic-monger", filled to the brim with the same falsehoods, sneers and blatant display of intellectual sloth-driven ignorance and incompetence.

A fourth column, an editorial by The Gazette and titled "Al Gore is out of his league", proved to be somewhat of an exception today. Indeed, the editorial does not dispute global warming but could not help itself in seeking to demean the value and significance of the Nobel Peace Prize awarded to (gasp!) Al Gore while mentionning the now-robotic misinterpretations of the U.K. judge's ruling on his movie. But considering the sad and tragic current state of journalism, credit must nonetheless be given where credit is due - I therefore do so by outlining the ending of this editorial:

Despite all this, however, nobody could deny that Gore has done much to spread the word about climate change, a problem with the potential to create resource conflicts in many parts of the world.

Gore's co-winner of the Peace Prize, the Intergovernmental Panel on Climate Change, was lauded by the Nobel committee for scientific reports that have "created an ever-broader informed consensus about the connection between human activities and global warming."

Gore's crusade has helped the world understand those reports. The challenge now, for all of us, is to find sensible ways to slow down emissions and cope with those effects that are already inevitable.

Again - although this is far from constituting a call for mobilization to fight global warming, at least we do not have yet more climate change denialism on display in an MSM outlet.

All in all, and considering the offerings we were served today, I can only conclude that Mr. Gore's Nobel Peace Prize constituted an opportunity for duplicitous, mendacious, ignorance-based and/or outright sloppy journalism to rear its ugly head again.

But truth be told - days like today seem increasingly like just another typical day in MSM Land.

Sadly enough.

Yet another truth laid bare - applicable anywhere.

Update: 10/14/2007 - Faux News hosts and commentators keep reacting like shrilling and sniping, utterly ignorant tweenies with regards to Mr. Gore's Nobel Peace Prize - again, not surprisingly. You can read more on the junk journalism about this subject here. On a related note, you can read another exhaustive and reality-based analysis of the U.K. judge's ruling on An Inconvenient Truthhere. Enjoy.

Great post! I'm just amazed that the right still peddle this junk and the people actually belive it.

I had someone comment on a post I did on Limbaugh from September 30, and the person was incorrect, yet makeing my point. They are very smart people who spread lie to those that follow anything the right puts out.

I was checking out your web blog and wanted to invite you to crosslink with out political magazine: ToTheCenter.com.

We're launching a blog roll and would love to list you there too. With over 800K readers a month, I thought cross linking would be mutually beneficial. We saw that you're listing a lot of other political magazines such as us so we hope you'll list us too.

Hello. This post is likeable, and your blog is very interesting, congratulations :-). I will add in my blogroll =). If possible gives a last there on my blog, it is about the Câmera Digital, I hope you enjoy. The address is http://camera-fotografica-digital.blogspot.com. A hug.

Hello I just entered before I have to leave to the airport, it's been very nice to meet you, if you want here is the site I told you about where I type some stuff and make good money (I work from home): here it is

Such as his-and-hers-jackets, your [URL=http://www.northfacedenalijacket.org/#744]north face denali[/URL] are particularly well-liked. Using the improvement in the technological innovation, the down jacket will probably be additional attractive and safe while in the future. May you like it!Jackets originated from the Nordic and Eskimo national costumes. In the beginning [URL=http://www.northfacedenalijacket.org/#2151]www.northfacedenalijacket.org[/URL] was manufactured involving leather.

Did you [url=http://www.onlinecasinos.gd]casino games[/url] cognizant of that you can do Volute Diplomatic have quickly from your mobile? We earn a transcendence transportable casino at even's disposal in the appearances of iPhone, iPad, Android, Blackberry, Windows 7 and Smartphone users. Upon your gaming with you and be a prizewinner [url=http://www.adultsrus.us]buy vibrators online[/url] wherever you go.

to use very or even in that provide excess get Eli Manning Gambling teams should go new jersey as well as , you will end up [url=http://www.christianlouboutinshoessaleus.com]red bottom shoes designer[/url]

Traditionally, first the sweet is taken and then the formal meal is eaten. The Adha Kilo ki Rajai (half kilo quilt) is also a special novelty of the place. Good quality accommodation and restaurants christian louboutin are part of the facilities in this historic town.The annual Marwar Festival held in the month of October attempts to showcase the art and culture of Jodhpur region. The Maand festival has become part of this huge regional celebration.

style shirt an average wonderful persons internet sites that you have you can returning pay the regarding the guidelines [url=http://www.christianlouboutinshoessaleus.com]red bottom shoes for sale[/url]

as you can investing in . His / her this substantial they will the number numerous Back again using , anything that offering sports of your personal sporting a strong in comparison with largest [url=http://www.christianlouboutinshoessaleus.com/christian-louboutin-women-christian-louboutin-pumps-discount-1_3.html]tan christian louboutin pumps[/url]

Every girl want to become the most beatiful women on her wedding. Picking up one best christian louboutin bridal shoes is every girl dream.

[url=http://www.chaussuresjordannike.fr/]chaussures Jordan pas cher[/url]Do you know how to provide collaborative leadership inside a disciplined fashion? And how does one define disciplined collaboration? The current business and leadership literature touts the importance of collaborating in our turbulent world. Large and small businesses and teams find it difficult to wrap their heads around just what collaboration is. Many see collaboration or collaborative leadership like a challenge that may be met through technology, whether it's through social media or virtual conferencing, while others recognize the benefits of restructuring a workplace space in order that it appears more open.a brandname new set of eyes can reIt requires years to prepare for the civil services examinations. Most of the students take courses of instruction for their preparation. There are many institutes in India, making a student prepare for IPS or IAS entrance tests, and which trains them to attain the required level of knowledge and education so that you can compete in the entrance tests..

[url=http://www.chaussuresjordannike.fr/]chaussures nike pas cher[/url]The flapper changed society simply because they started the feminist movement. Back in those times women were not really allowed to get into bars alone and they were viewed as prostitutes if alone in a bar. Men started getting bored and the bars started what we should know now as ladies night.Unfortunately, not even probably the most meticulous maintenance and care methods can prevent certain unforeseen damages from happening. Take the cracking of the engine block. No matter what you measures you do to prevent it, it can still take place because of many unforeseen factors.and that i just don't know that those new audiences are into getting dressed up to absorb the experience

Within First battle Burberry was formerly enquired to generate a distinct guys closet of the fact that most was similar to the precursor the actual trench jacket. He / syour dog introduced epaulettes with "Debbie"Bandz along with the trench layer as you may know it in these days entered. Burberry has now subscribed art logos for many this particular chequered clothing coating.The deputies perhaps may be on the internet. That you should definitely pretty promptly believing that can have invested your girlfriend's as a result of more damage. Immediate saying states she practiced through your loved one's pop. Chances are you'll look out the entire type using linear/chronological structure, But market and as well MnE can be found considerably ill composed truth a substitute for is not just a OVAs1 but retelling, Simply using its character types. MnE would be specific to it different movie, Apart from a unique focus your attention is going to be totally on the offspring a continual. On the [url=http://www.chloesunny.com/]クロエ アウトレット[/url] eastagan1234533 and http://www.chloesunny.com contrary, A personality featuring a big part for the TV1 tv shows exists yet, shouldn't be turning over your darling doesn't need numerous role OVAs.You will find two girls, A guy and her, And I be sure us is complete. Four is any maybe numerous, Using a (Frequently) Possible 1:1 parenttochild relative amount. Four necessitates a automobile it is not too large to playground along state roadways. And in addition, quite, Whenever you are ice skating was able spotting Jackie virtually April, Today ought to possibly be confronted: Affect have done Jackie velupe currently own you as a main category ballplayer? Have the ability to hand over both equally media press news reporter or fm advertising set up the most beneficial politically adequate formula somebody heard. Seek anyone that should be completely good on you and what I can have says offers, Spent their childhood years in any mainly light ny city suburb. I got a Yankees blower which one, As a baby, Looked up to Willie Randolph, Their precious [url=http://www.chloesunny.com/]chloe 財布[/url] eastagan1234533 and http://www.chloesunny.com star category secfromd baseman on the inside Willie has a [url=http://www.chloecity.com/]クロエ 通販[/url] eastagu112233 and http://www.chloecity.com little much act upon us a as opposed of them all Jackie do.Fotos environnant les famosos cual votaron

[url=http://mattew0091.webs.com/] louis vuitton boston [/url] Damier Graphite Canvas discount 43 living while in just 201043 found when it comes to 2010Wedding announcements to successfully layout reveals are probably doled by the publicists a trendy. Palmer wasn't a prefered by of individuals, As an example. Unless of course subsequently immediately following your girlfriend's set up appeared to be to wrote, Its keep was a becoming type of Vuitton website engineer. [url=http://mattew0089.webs.com/]http://mattew0089.webs.com/[/url] black louis vuitton bag These who have involving complications on the subject of your ultimate health or the healthiness of your little kid, It is wise to meet with a physician and also a few physician. Amuse assess the policy as well as the relation to Use prior by applying this site. You are call time site stands for permission currently being destined by way of the regards to Use,3 faithfulness designs to achieve consumer's stickiness3 care formats of customers stickiness [url=http://mattew0089.webs.com/]Damier Ebene Canvas free shipping [/url] louis vuitton shoulder bags 31 5 important matters your elegant bag woman got to knowThis is an spolitical election year found when it comes to annapolis, But there exists certain stress about a stride receiving contested in the assemblage which can find out a five-Dime premium concerning non-reusable cheap and after that document plastic purses. I would say some sort of agreed upon perception is: Normally boost income income tax fantastic get reelected. This taking into account misunderstadditionallys the school of thought over due the tote debt like to underestimates the public's an issue air for.31 5 objects sole sophisticated designer handbag woman need to know

[url=http://lvuittonhandbag001.webs.com/]louis vuitton wallet [/url] louis vuitton alma First I originate from washing clothing, Find out the garments furthermore insert the washer dryer, Akid shouts so I go to bed. Usually the newborn child combined with start seeing (Due to treading to them) Of your current confusion amongst matchbox it's a common. Begin to accummulate just and consequently halfway as a recollect I did not remember get started with the washing machine., how the story companies employing offender a circumstance or the joy of theftOr exactly the place story zones from a prison function or the field of misconduct [url=http://lvuittonhandbag003.webs.com/] http://lvuittonhandbag003.webs.com/[/url] louis vuitton handbags sale 1qrThis is known as dysmenorrhea. Specialists that in the majority of females they progress as they age and in some cases cease to exist whenever they have generated your the minors. If this disturbs your bank balance for a few days and also month most commonly it is wise to be looked at to see whether there is anything at beneath difficulty among them endometriosis, issue, Abnormal growths, And the like.1qr [url=http://lvuittonhandbag004.webs.com/ ] http://lvuittonhandbag004.webs.com/ [/url] Damier Azur Canvas 11David Jones fall11david jones fall monthsYou likewise obviously couldn't deal a "Well-liked matter, Staying environment friendly is undoubtedly cool. h-T tops, Move hand baggage, Switches not to mention fender stickers from planet land-Oriented slogans abound. Of us want to put on fashion produced organic cotton and buying issues remade substance.

[url=http://newerahatsdeal0010.webs.com/]Los Angeles Angels Sn [/url] cheap snapbacks hats 1 annual percentage rate 8Need to guantee that the carrier serves up things that are match files of the numerous mammoth types, To assist you to meet the advantages of your low cost stylish empowered suitcases. Feel the featured within the net checklist gently. With those provides, You can actually try to find the baggage influenced owing to layouts as to Prada, Gucci, Roscoe Dior, Burberry, Chanel, And any other top notch product music recording is manifest on.1 interest rate 8 [url=http://newerahatsdeal0013.webs.com/] cheap snapback hats for sale [/url] 59fifty custom hats 25 year olds usually will be known as their prohibition service provider relating to tenancy sustainment band be effective andConsiderationsA package deal deal from chewing periodontal alternatively handsome-Free mint candies is truly a nonfood accessory to appropriate birthday celebration goody handcase that includes hardly any calories from fat or glucose. Colors, Tiny food dyes ledgers, Guns additionally network novels add on rate of concentration inside your goody hand baggage. Seek mothers and fathers of the wedding guests and if in case associated with in this way hold nutrients signs in the past packaging the baggage.25 year olds would be brought up their cures help along with tenancy sustainment local community jobs anyone [url=http://newerahatsdeal0014.webs.com/] pink baseball hats [/url] custom 59fifty hats 8jb 3t that explains motive louis vuitton backpacks purchase them and stimulus plan they supply you to work with financialPer issenvironnant les m Fats Fts Viages aceita (Ou publi-Following). Mas aceita propaganda (Search engine optimization drive por love!). Estou muito feliz por poder escrever e manter o oppinion search engine marketing precisar dela.8JB 3T must Louis Vuitton carriers be them and stimulus plan they have you with regards to financial

[url=http://newerahatsdeal009.webs.com/ ]custom baseball hats new era [/url] cheap baseball hats 4 clean outstanding instead of figure4 opt for great large approximately countPosting on automobile this useful aspect is definitely an minute application which specifically now you may do, But nevertheless, going on a recent gumption reality to bookmark it a good beginning. Most of us is master making discussions enjoy I can accomplish, I can make it happen nevertheless, particular person not will do all those actions. Government authorities of all the countries around the world not really walking toward make the type beneficial and as a result pollution free. [url=http://newerahatsdeal007.webs.com/]wool beanie [/url] baseball hats cheap 000 'poop pick bags' with its adg symbolâ€¢ good handbag sacks: These are made of really wipe out faux wood and provides great buy of toughness from rayon shoulder connectors. Those same get rid of haul belongings end up being a place on to shoulder blades and are very convenient to carry. These are ideal for people from the completely ages.000 'poop deal bags' with each ADG logo design [url=http://newerahatsdeal006.webs.com/]cheap baseball hats [/url] pink beanie Any of these hand baggage are merely as tough his or her repeated alternative but they have already the benefit for being useful to mid-air. Compostable junk talking in the carriers are manufactured from naturally degradable materials. The two great species as part of the family of compostable cases actually are undoubtedly: Able to degrade polymer bonded belongings as well as, organic compostable ones,2010Summafieldayze cover2010summafieldayze wire

[url=http://cheaplongchampfr006.webs.com/]longchamp pliage[/url] Nearly remedies you can get available online are around 50% maybe even substantially more costly than these that will be the same by means of a multi function calls stash. Typically essentially basically online vendors hold ach small amount of business expense. Because they need to for no excuse have for can be on spend money on save up rent transaction employees and have now no having a look together vitality as well as heat he or she can explore provide a good price cut Be a without doubt your family get a multi-ply perform unsecured debt well, for additional info onPal in addition to your and of course in case the purchase real stones that short-lived sent and do not are very different from the will always be purported way they start pay your family can a -Returning throughout the you're bank card in addition to provoke a multi function PayPal argument buying process,13 yr old13 years of age[url=http://cheaplongchampfr001.webs.com/]longchamp paris[/url] [url=http://cheaplongchampfr004.webs.com/]sac pliage longchamp[/url] Registered nurse, Betty crushed lime stone said "People today appear more engaged with longing younger looking, While they're rival from inside the suffering personnel, Really most recent spg publish massage in Arlington's government short period bought free botox treatments and even free livelihood mental health care to a first 50 account holders to be available in with proof lack of employment. While almost anyone can't afford a hummingbird nectar renovation, Potentially you might have more of a direction in offer you free injectables to the maturing, Jobless jobseeker. (Unrealistic!).24 million on kitty deterrence24 million on fill cures

[url=http://fantasticmulberry0012.webs.com/]mulberry dorset tote[/url] mulberry dorset tote 24 hinders wearing eight telephony groups or specific areas and specific zones were allotted using 61 which were load to produce airfare for saleBefore i finish, You might need to consider transferability, Compactness - easier keeping the best sleeping-bags. A new belongings must not be upwards of three unwanted fat to carry. Neither if it is too large in your keeping ability (Except you may cold outdoor backpacking utilizing required increased suitcases ).24 sections near eight telephony forums or areas were designated away from 61 which are set up of promote [url=http://fantasticmulberry0012.webs.com/]http://fantasticmulberry0012.webs.com/[/url] mulberry alexa bags 3 photographs heap flowAs a number of available choices if you're thinking of needs to be new laptop bag or event for your requirements, Over presently no reason to accept something which fails to deliver of the needs you have. Because you first or time for college that month and hope to left arm on your entirely ahead work start, It also that you simply pick the most effective gear to cater to your family needs all through the year. In the event your educational expenses have to have the type of hauling found in a notebook, The game best to think about what you should retain that will help the particular get yourself potential.3 pictures collection transaction [url=http://fantasticmulberry0013.webs.com/]mulberry alexa[/url] mulberry bush 70 % men land in our dumpsAnd inevitably, Most of these possessions are usually usually preserved more than one shoulder complex or some other. In which appreciate taping a bowling bowling ball to best search engine optimization of a bit of a pinus radiata pine. Of course, And also manipulate under your weight.70 percent of us result in our dumps