Share “Review: Metcalf sparkles in B'way's 'Other...”

Review: Metcalf sparkles in B'way's 'Other Place'

Published on NewsOK
Modified: January 10, 2013 at 8:01 pm •
Published: January 10, 2013

Advertisement

NEW YORK (AP) — The first sign that things may not be what they seem in "The Other Place" appears on page 4 of Sharr White's script: The whip-smart scientist at the story's heart has confused the gender of a doctor treating her.

This undated theater image released by Boneau/Bryan-Brown shows actress Laurie Metcalf, left, and Zoe Perry during a performance of "The Other Place." (AP Photo/Boneau/Bryan-Brown, Joan Marcus)

It's a mistake that's quickly brushed aside. But the slip-ups soon begin piling up in this 80-minute gem of a play until what's real and what's not collapse in a heap. It's confusing and thrilling stuff.

"I'm having a hard time figuring out where I am," our heroine, dementia expert Dr. Juliana Smithton, says meekly at the end.

For much of the play, which opened Thursday at the Samuel J. Friedman Theatre, we know the feeling — White is stingy with his clues.

Among the questions swirling about: Who is lying? Is the good doctor getting divorced? What happened to the couples' daughter? Who is the woman in a yellow bikini who sparked Smithton's meltdown? And, ultimately, what is wrong with our heroine? Something definitely is, since her command of English slowly betrays her, with "thingy" creeping in and exasperated references to "the other place," her Cape Cod summer home.

The play — so buffed and polished it now seems to squeak — is matched by a searing, brilliant performance by Laurie Metcalf, who is simply astonishing as she goes from snippy, bossy scientist to a broken, confused intruder wolfing down Chinese food on the floor.

Director Joe Mantello keeps up a blistering pace — snippets of scenes dissolve into another, past and present collide. Speed is important to keep the audience guessing, but it leaves no room for a moment's error. Mantello proves as sharp as the narrator is unreliable.

"The Other Place" had its world premiere off-Broadway at the MCC Theater in March 2011, starring Metcalf and helmed by Mantello. The Manhattan Theatre Club has happily given a rebuffed version a bigger platform with some other supporting actors. It simply gleams.