While i think robin, chopper, laboon and franky are all sad, I seriously thought I was going to cry when they showed brooke's past. Like when their captain dies and when they were all sing binks sake for the last time into the tone dial.

everyone in the strawhat members has a sad n touching past ...specially Franky, Robin, Usop n Nami...except Luffy coz his past isn't clear yet....they only showed how he decide to be a pirate n nothing more....im realy curious to know his past in details >.<...n as u said i was about to cry too wen i saw Brooke's past n how their captain died....the scene was soooo touching ...

While i think robin, chopper, laboon and franky are all sad, I seriously thought I was going to cry when they showed brooke's past. Like when their captain dies and when they were all sing binks sake for the last time into the tone dial.

i think Brooke's past is the saddest.
to be alone for sooo long.....hearing ur crewmates all the time
it was so sad when he does the last song with his friends ........all of them start dieing one by one nd he says Duet, Solo

hmm...
i think some of saddest past from SH's crew was luffy's, nami's, usopp's, sanji's, chopper's, and brook's...
but, from all of those i feel more sad when watch luffy's past... esp, when shanks helped him from sea king in the middle of sea, and ofc bcz of it i like OP...

hmm...
i think some of saddest past from SH's crew was luffy's, nami's, usopp's, sanji's, chopper's, and brook's...
but, from all of those i feel more sad when watch luffy's past... esp, when shanks helped him from sea king in the middle of sea, and ofc bcz of it i like OP...

Yeah! Thinking how did his training goes done by his grandfather(for me not a training, but torture), And realizing the recklessness he did that caused to loose his friend's(shanks) arm. But we still don't know if he's still longing for his parents. "Do I have a father?" << double meaning. Well it's up to us perhaps....

which one?????????? never seen it before...
but, if i think if he ever have a sadness past... it should be when his body weakling bcz of the sake he've drunk... huahahaha... but, i think he has no sadness past but ofc he has happiness past and life... just to see his life being around with lot of beautiful nurse and faithful crew, he must be a very happy guy in OP.... huahahaha...

While i think robin, chopper, laboon and franky are all sad, I seriously thought I was going to cry when they showed brooke's past. Like when their captain dies and when they were all sing binks sake for the last time into the tone dial.

i think Brooke's past is the saddest.
to be alone for sooo long.....hearing ur crewmates all the time
it was so sad when he does the last song with his friends ........all of them start dieing one by one nd he says Duet, Solo

hmm...
i think some of saddest past from SH's crew was luffy's, nami's, usopp's, sanji's, chopper's, and brook's...
but, from all of those i feel more sad when watch luffy's past... esp, when shanks helped him from sea king in the middle of sea, and ofc bcz of it i like OP...

hmm...
i think some of saddest past from SH's crew was luffy's, nami's, usopp's, sanji's, chopper's, and brook's...
but, from all of those i feel more sad when watch luffy's past... esp, when shanks helped him from sea king in the middle of sea, and ofc bcz of it i like OP...

Yeah! Thinking how did his training goes done by his grandfather(for me not a training, but torture), And realizing the recklessness he did that caused to loose his friend's(shanks) arm. But we still don't know if he's still longing for his parents. "Do I have a father?" << double meaning. Well it's up to us perhaps....

which one?????????? never seen it before...
but, if i think if he ever have a sadness past... it should be when his body weakling bcz of the sake he've drunk... huahahaha... but, i think he has no sadness past but ofc he has happiness past and life... just to see his life being around with lot of beautiful nurse and faithful crew, he must be a very happy guy in OP.... huahahaha...

in every strawhat's past someone has either died or lost a limb, in luffy and sanji's past someone lost a limb, and the rest all had a death of someone close to the character.....sooo they are all sad but probably robin's or brook(e)'s seem the saddest to me