However, an eyewitness tells HollywoodLife.com exclusively, “During the entire performance, Mariah was dancing in her chair and loving every single minute of it. When the confetti dropped, Mariah took some of it and waved it around in celebration of how well J.Lo did. She eventually stood up, but cameras might have not caught it, and her dresses don’t allow her to get up that often. But overall, Mariah couldn’t have been happier with the performance. Whatever was caught on TV must have been misconstrued — the entire look and feel of things — but she was a huge fan of the performance. There is no feud.”

Mariah Carey & Jennifer Lopez’s Complicated Past

The fellow pop stars do have a complicated history. Around 2001, Mariah’s Sony boss ex-husband Tommy Mottola reportedlygave Jennifer material Mariah had wanted for her Glitter soundtrack after she left his label. Following Mariah’s divorce from Tommy, the music exec allegedly tailored J.Lo to be the next Mariah. Also, Mariah reportedly demanded to be paid $2 million more than Jennifer to appear on Idol.