Philppine Senate President Juan Ponce Enrile yesterday disclosed notes written by Philippine Ambassador to China Sonia Brady that he said showed Sen. Antonio Trillanes IV was working for Beijing in the dispute between the Philippines and China over Panatag Shoal in the West Philippine Sea.

On the day the Philippine Daily Inquirer in an exclusive report outlined the emergence of Trillanes as President Benigno Aquino’s back-channel negotiator working independently of the Department of Foreign Affairs (DFA), Enrile read into the Senate record Brady’s purported notes of a meeting with the junior senator.

This followed a rare clash on the Senate floor before a national TV audience when Trillanes, who walked out as Enrile was interpellating him, accused the Senate President of being a “lackey” of former President Gloria Arroyo.

The senate president ticked off 20 items in the Brady notes, including a point Trillanes purportedly said that in the Philippines “no one cares” about Panatag Shoal (Scarbourough Shoal), where Manila had a confrontation with Beijing in April when the Philippine Navy intervened to stop the poaching of endangered marine species and corals by Chinese fishermen.

“I do not want to discuss anymore this sordid matter. It is enough that I read the notes of Ambassador Brady to unmask this ‘Phantom of the Opera’ in Philippine politics. My God, this guy is a fraud.”

He also called Trillanes a “fifth columnist”—referring to a clandestine force in Madrid supporting rebels from within—before he walked off the rostrum.

The harsh exchanges between Trillanes and Enrile revealed deep divisions in the conduct of Philippine diplomatic initiatives in the standoff with China.

Del Rosario’s curt remarks

Foreign Secretary Albert del Rosario, in a series of interviews with senior Inquirer reporter Gil Cabacungan, complained that “while back-channelling has its purpose, it’s doing more harm than good.” He said that it was important that “we speak with one voice on this matter.”In the interviews, Trillanes accused Del Rosario of drawing the United States into the dispute that he said tended to exacerbate tensions instead of ease them.

Yesterday, Del Rosario issued a curt message, saying he would not dignify accusations by Trillanes.

“The DFA executes the foreign policy of the President. We will not dignify those who are working to divide us,” Del Rosario said.

In a privilege speech on Camarines Sur, Trillanes decried Enrile’s alleged “bullying” of other senators just so the Senate would approve the controversial bill dividing Camarines Sur into two provinces.

He said Enrile was either “deeply indebted to” or a “lackey” of Arroyo. He said Arroyo had “personally called up” the senate president to ask that he “speed up the measure.”

Enrile accused Trillanes of trying to control the damage wrought by the Inquirer report. He said Trillanes delivered a privilege speech on the Camarines Sur bill to “camouflage” his mistake.

Protecting China

According to Enrile, the items in the Brady report dated August 17 purported to show:

That the Chinese wanted the Philippines to “tone down the rhetoric” on its incursion in Panatag Shoal.

That Trillanes suspected that the United States was involved in creating tension in Panatag Shoal and that Del Rosario was “committing treason”.

That Trillanes “was protecting the Chinese,” “was alarmist” and accused Del Rosario of “creating a war event”.

That Trillanes asked businessman Manuel V. Pangilinan, a close friend of Del Rosario, to advise the secretary “to keep quiet, to quiet down” apparently because the secretary held a press conference decrying Chinese presence in Panatag Shoal

That Trillanes stated “no one cares about Panatag Shoal in the Philippines.”

That Trillanes said the Philippines “cannot enforce coastal protection” since fishermen subsist only on fishing and cannot venture far out.

That Trillanes boasted that he was able to make 40 Chinese ships leave Panatag Shoal.

That Trillanes volunteered to become the “direct channel” between China and the Palace.

Bullying

Enrile also said Brady quoted Trillanes saying that Del Rosario should be replaced by incoming Interior Secretary Manuel Roxas.

Before Enrile took out Brady’s notes, he and Trillanes engaged in a heated debate following the younger senator’s speech.

Raising the bullying charge, Enrile asked whether there had been any instance when he asked Trillanes “to vote according to my wishes.”

“That’s irrelevant,” Trillanes shot back.

“You’re telling falsehoods here. You are angry at me because you asked me for an additional budget in your oversight committee and I did not allow it,” the senate president revealed.

Special envoy status

Enrile also recalled that after Trillanes won a Senate seat while incarcerated in Camp Crame for leading the Oakwood mutiny in 2003, he “went out of my way to talk to people to guarantee your presence in the Senate” in an effort to convince authorities to free Trillanes.

Enrile said Trillanes apparently resented his question during a Cabinet meeting in May on who authorised Trillanes to talk to the Chinese.

“The president told it to your face,” Trillanes said, referring to his special envoy status given by the Palace.

“Wasn’t it your duty to notify the Office of the Senate President when you leave this country?” I don’t know how many times you have been to China but I recall six times? I am now hearing reports you were there 15 times,” Enrile noted.

“Are you becoming the fifth columnist of China in this country? Who paid for those trips to Beijing?” he then asked Trillanes.

Enrile then showed the Brady notes and asked whether Trillanes would want him to read them.

“Do not teach me about proceedings,” Enrile answered in a raised voice.

Out of order

At this point, Trillanes walked out of the session hall.

“He’s a coward. Senator Trillanes even instructed Mrs. Brady not to take notes,” Enrile said and began to read from the ambassador’s report.

“The senate president may reveal sensitive information pertaining to foreign relations and national security and I believe it is out of order,” Trillanes had warned the floor.

Trillanes said his trips to China were authorised by President Aquino.

“I have already informed the people. I’m not obliged to inform the senate president and all this line of questioning is irrelevant again. And should this line of questioning continue I will have to say that I will refuse to yield anymore,” Trillanes said.

“Either way, I have lost trust, faith and confidence in Senator Enrile’s capability to lead the Senate along the path consistent with the reform agenda that I espouse,” he added.

Trillanes, a member of the Nacionalista Party, said he was leaving the majority coalition in the Senate and joining the minority.