What will our goalie trade look like?

NEELY

Mod

Number of posts : 20732Registration date : 2011-02-24

DirtyDave wrote:I'm not a scientist but if they told player or implied to players that Lehner would be traded and then they trade Anderson I would think /hope it was for an excellent return. Has Edmonton ever had a goalie of his caliber?

We are talking in the last 10-15 years right? I would say Roloson and Anderson are very similar.

SeawaySensFan

Franchise Player

Number of posts : 24828Registration date : 2008-12-02

DirtyDave wrote:I'm not a scientist but if they told player or implied to players that Lehner would be traded and then they trade Anderson I would think /hope it was for an excellent return. Has Edmonton ever had a goalie of his caliber?

How would you really know? Dubnyk looks pretty good away from Edmonton. Who's to say Khabiboozelin or Gerber might not have been good with a better team in front?

wprager

LeCaptain wrote:Forget about Edmonton, I'm worried about the Sens if we trade Anderson.

Ya. Could be a huge step backwards. Again. The return would have to be substantial. And not just taking dead weight contract. And more than the 33nd pick overall

Did pretty well with Anderson and Lehner on the IR.

EDIT: And, no, the point is not that we're fine with The Hamburglar, the point being that the team just needs someone they can trust enough who gives an honest effort and doesn't throw a tantrum or a team mate under the bus.

_________________Hey, I don't have all the answers. In life, to be honest, I've failed as much as I have succeeded. But I love my wife. I love my life. And I wish you my kind of success. - Dicky Fox

DirtyDave

LeCaptain wrote:Forget about Edmonton, I'm worried about the Sens if we trade Anderson.

Ya. Could be a huge step backwards. Again. The return would have to be substantial. And not just taking dead weight contract. And more than the 33nd pick overall

Did pretty well with Anderson and Lehner on the IR.

EDIT: And, no, the point is not that we're fine with The Hamburglar, the point being that the team just needs someone they can trust enough who gives an honest effort and doesn't throw a tantrum or a team mate under the bus.

SeawaySensFan

LeCaptain wrote:Forget about Edmonton, I'm worried about the Sens if we trade Anderson.

Ya. Could be a huge step backwards. Again. The return would have to be substantial. And not just taking dead weight contract. And more than the 33nd pick overall

Did pretty well with Anderson and Lehner on the IR.

EDIT: And, no, the point is not that we're fine with The Hamburglar, the point being that the team just needs someone they can trust enough who gives an honest effort and doesn't throw a tantrum or a team mate under the bus.