they feature a similar concept of literal 'mise en scene', kind of randomly placed in a scenery. except that apparently this features girls that people seem to love and Givenchy featuring Gisele, who seems to be disliked by anyone who 'gets' high fashion.

basically a double standard

difference being that the Givenchy images (especially the ones with Gisele, and this is coming from someone who wouldn't call himself a fan) portray much more of a mood that fits the clothes and complements them, while here it's kind of random how 4 girls in nude lace dresses are placed around a ruin. apparently waiting. for Godot perhaps?

as it seems, people love this campaign mostly cause they like seeing 'their' girls here.

but that's a different story again

tbh i like the concept and all from both campaigns. Though i see them very differently. I think the whole mood is different.
I just this cause it's romantic, i like the mood and sure i love bette!
Tbh, i really like Gisele and I do like the givenchy campaign, only i think gisele and mbc could have modeled in better.

^I'm not the biggest fan of any of this girls, but I accept the campaign is one of the best of the season, you don't have to think that much the concept or anything, is just beautiful, I like more Gisele than this girls, but this campaign is PERFECT. Nothing to do with favorite models. I also admit that I miss Caroline Brasch Nielsen

I think some of us are so used to "in your face" that you find these images are a bit quiet, but if you're a fan of Turbeville work, this is actually very much in tune with her style. I love how the images are used on Valentino's website.