2008-10-06

choices

Let's say, hypothetically speaking, that you're a producer of wealth. Let's also say that you are ethically opposed to foreign occupations your government is involved with. Finally, and this is another BIG hypothetical, let's say your government imposes a nice hefty income tax on you to fund such activities.

Now. What are your choices, in maintaining your own personal ethical standards? Regardless of what anyone else thinks, or what you think about other people's conduct.

I guess first the basic conflict should be underlined, in case the above hypotheticals didn't make that obvious: you are a nice person who likes to be nice to people, and you don't like hurting people. You don't want your own efforts to go towards enabling the destruction and killing being wreaked by your government. But a significant fraction of every dollar you pay in taxes is going towards that.

Now, let's break it down.

Option 1: Don't pay your taxes, and risk imprisonment. If done for these reasons, this could pass as nonviolent protest.

Option 2: Pay your taxes, and ignore your conscience. Or don't ignore your conscience completely, but rationalize what you are doing: "it's not my fault" that the government is using my efforts in this destructive fashion. I would guess that most people pick this option, if they bother to think about how their taxes are connected with wars. Would you voluntarily work to give somebody you don't trust the ability to do things you would never do yourself? Probably not. But somehow people get mixed up with the government, even though that's exactly what they're doing.

Option 3: Don't produce. Or at least produce the minimum amount possible to survive while legally avoiding taxes as much as possible.

So look at this, and think for a bit about what would be the easiest for you. Option 1 is scary: you face very serious loss of freedom (and what for with our current media)? Option 2 is probably more difficult for some than others, depending on how strong one's convictions are. Option 3 is, well, pretty damn easy for just about anyone.

Is it any wonder why socialism makes countries poorer?

The income tax is just plain unethical. At least, I can see no way around it.