Fat Sal's Pizza (9th Ave)

Fat Sal's Pizza (9th Ave) Reviews

Written by
Mindy R. on
3/1/2014 |
2 other reviews |
Member since 2013
Mindy ordered from here over a year ago

delicious pizza :)

Written by
Mary R. on
1/12/2014 |
22 other reviews |
Member since 2014
Mary ordered from here over a year ago

I've eaten a lot of pizza in my life. A lot. Every Friday growing up from various places in Central Jersey and nowadays from New York. Is Fat Sal's pizza good? Yes. Reasonably priced? Mmhmm. Big pies? Absolutely. But does it stand out to me? Not particularly. It was good and they absolutely won't steer you wrong, it just didn't "Wow" me. If there were half-stars on Seamless I would give them a 3.5.

Written by
Colin G. on
1/10/2014 |
14 other reviews |
Member since 2011
Colin ordered from here over a year ago

Baked pasta dishes are great. The most popular dish ordered in our office is broccoli, garlic & olive oil pasta with grilled chicken.

Written by
Manni K. on
12/18/2013 |
3 other reviews |
Member since 2010
Manni ordered from here over a year ago

The lasagna was terrible.

Written by
candice v. on
11/22/2013 |
7 other reviews |
Member since 2013
candice ordered from here over a year ago

Delivery was fast - and on time at 30min. Small pizza is HUGE but totally doughy and sad :(

Written by
Kelly M. on
10/4/2013 |
2 other reviews |
Member since 2012
Kelly ordered from here over a year ago

Solid food, and fast delivery. I wish the baked ziti had more sauce, though!

Written by
Brett W. on
7/18/2013 |
1 other review |
Member since 2012
Brett ordered from here over a year ago

Chicken fingers were not chicken fingers.. they were literally shreds of chicken. pizza is enormous and not that good

Written by
lisa m. on
2/25/2013 |
1 other review |
Member since 2012
lisa ordered from here over a year ago

Ordered three times from here and the food has come piping hot and fast each time. Tasted pretty good as well.

Written by
GERRARD S. on
2/3/2013 |
2 other reviews |
Member since 2010
GERRARD ordered from here within the last year

very bad

Written by
sinan t. on
12/4/2012 |
2 other reviews |
Member since 2012
sinan ordered from here over a year ago

Do not order from this restaurant!!! The delivery time took an hour longer than what was advertised on Seamless. I called the restaurant but they were not truthful about the food delivery time estimate. Order elsewhere, there are many Italian restaurants on Seamless that are just as good!

Written by
Eunice H. on
11/24/2012 |
1 other review |
Member since 2010
Eunice ordered from here over a year ago

prompt delivery (ordered in advance) and good pies at a great price for this area. Chopped salads were of poor quality, would give them a miss next time.

Written by
Shara C. on
8/23/2012 |
3 other reviews |
Member since 2012
Shara ordered from here over a year ago

Fat Sal's consistently posts delivery times of 15 - 30 minutes, yet consistently takes an hour to deliver. Good food, but I will not order from them anymore.

Written by
Christine S. on
8/1/2012 |
1 other review |
Member since 2005
Christine ordered from here over a year ago

Food good but delivery takes forever.

Written by
Marco P. on
7/30/2012 |
4 other reviews |
Member since 2012
Marco ordered from here over a year ago