EDIT: Oh right, gamefly, I was thinking gamestop. They're used of course. No wonder the markdowns. You're actually getting ripped off. 9$ to rent super paper mario. $40 to buy on top of that. $50 for a used game?

Are you sure? When I clicked on some there is only a rent it button, no buy it button. There is a "keep it" which is keeping a copy of the game you've rented. Some games have buy it buttons, but it clearly says they are previously played.

Dang that is a good deal, I already have money saved up for Diamond, and I just bought a PC game controller, so I guess I will have to hope the sale will last long enough for me to get some extra money.....