Subscribe To

Saturday, November 22, 2014

Gov. Blaine and the Ku Klux Klan

It was an
"all-electric" fiery cross that led the Ku Klux Klan parade in
Livingston, Wisconsin on August 2, 1924.
The Livingston Band followed Klanswomen carrying flags. Behind the band, 82 Klansmen marched in full
hooded regalia. A large crowd, estimated
at 2,500 came out to cheer and listen to a speech by a "Dr. Stout of
Detroit, Mich." Ira Stout was the Kleagle (leader) of the Detroit Ku Klux
Klan.

The meeting
started with the band’s rendition of On
Wisconsin, followed by the Lord’s Prayer.
Stout said the Klan never bothered other creeds, "but we're fighting their system." He said the Klan was cleaning up the
"booze evil." As his speech concluded a large cross was set afire
while the astounded townsfolk watched and cheered. It was a typically theatrical Klan rally. Years later (1968) a witness to the rally
recalled: “Many of
those in attendance were there only for the curiosity and were not Klansmen.
The speech was an attack on the three K's the "Koons", the
"Kikes", and the "Katholics". Many of the people who heard
the speech were repelled by the speaker's remarks and left the meeting quietly
before it was over.” Contemporary
accounts show no such reaction by the townspeople.

In the
early 1920's the Ku Klux Klan was an organization on the rise, touting what
they called "Pure Americanism."
In fact they were a hate group, which, like so many others used
patriotic themes to wrap bigotry and hate in.
In the south racial hatred was still the main theme, but as the Klan
moved north, they emphasized hatred of immigrants, Catholics and Jews. They used pageantry, theater and color to
draw the curious and slander their enemies.
They ingratiated themselves with the local citizens by contributing
small sums to churches and charitable organizations. For example the local news
section of a newspaper in Richland County reported: “During
church services Tuesday evening a number of Klansmen entered the church
remaining near the entrance while one walked to the platform and presented Rev.
Pfaffman with a sum of money and a letter of thanks for his interest here.” A small town community building financial ledger
reads “March 3, 1928. Received from the
Ku Klux Klan five dollars” The Richland Observer of October 28, 1926 gives
another example: “The order of the knights of the Ku Klux Klan
gave an oyster supper in honor of their friends and neighbor, Rev. J. C. Hatch,
Friday evening. The table decorations
consisted of a large American flag.
Supper was served to nearly one hundred.” Many were fooled by the Klan’s
pretensions to patriotism and Christianity.
Many were not.

Wisconsin's
governor, John Blaine, who hailed from Boscobel, was one of those who were not
fooled, and he was a vehement opponent of The Klan. Blaine was first elected Governor in 1920. In 1921 citizens of Milwaukee and Kenosha petitioned
the governor asking that he take steps to prevent the Ku Klux Klan from taking
root in Wisconsin. “With such a record as the Ku Klux Klan had during the period following
the Civil War,” he said, “and steeped
in crime as the Klan was, do you think that any liberty loving, law abiding
sensible citizen of Wisconsin is going to join an order that is alleged to be
the counterpart of the Klan of rebel days, if in fact it is?” He was to discover that a large number of
Wisconsin citizens would take the bait and join.

Because
of Blaine’s “unalterable opposition” the Klan was determined to defeat him in either
the primary or general elections of 1924.
They had their grievances against Blaine. He had refused the support of the Klan and instead
denounced them when his opponent in the 1922 election wrongly stated that he
was supported by the Klan. He had
refused them the right to use public property for rallies. He declared that as long as he was governor "state property will not be used by any
organization which suppresses the identity of its membership, or permits the
masking of its officers and members operating in the dark or otherwise…I have
through executive orders and communications and through campaign speeches let
the people of the state know my stand against this organization and similar
organizations."

Both
of the major political parties adopted platforms opposing the Klan in
1924. The Democratic State Platform
read:“We
pledge the Democratic Party to oppose any effort on the part of the Ku Klux
Klan or any organization to interfere with the religious liberty or political
freedom of any citizen or to limit the civic rights of any citizen or body of
citizens because of religion, birthplace or racial origin.” The Republican
platform proclaimed “We are opposed to the Ku Klux Klan or any
organization that would deny to any citizen the free exercise of those
sacred rights because of race, nationality,
language or religious belief.

The evident purpose
of the Klan and every other secret political organization
is to disorganize and disrupt the harmonious development and existence
of economic organizations of workers and farmers, by stirring up dissension among them, and such secret political organi­zations are encouraged by organized privilege to
spread dissension, hate and
suspicion that cooperative economic organizations may be destroyed… We oppose any attempt
to divide our people into warring factions that destroy the harmony and friendships of neighborly cooperation.”

The
reality was often at variance with these pronouncements as many candidates were
more than happy to speak before the Klan and accept its money and influential
support.

In 1924 the
Klan threw considerable support to Governor Blaine’s primary opponent, Arthur
R. Hirst. In the summer of 1924 small
blue buttons reading “Back to Boscobel” began to appear all over the
state. By August, the press was
reporting that it was the Ku Klux Klan that was distributing the buttons to
show opposition to Blaine. The Klan was
also planning a visit to Blaine’s home town.
On August 6, 1924 the Madison Capital Times reported that the Milwaukee
headquarters of the Klan was negotiating with the Milwaukee Road to charter a
special train to carry Klansmen from Madison to Boscobel on August 15th
to march in the streets as part of the “Back to Boscobel” movement.

In
the same year, a civil war of sorts was being fought in Muscoda. Boscobel itself had no Klan organization, so
Muscoda served as the meeting place of most Boscobel Klan members. The mayor of Boscobel was Ben L. Marcus, who
was also manager of a number of industries and stores in the town. Marcus was Jewish, and the Klan was anti-Semitic. Other issues, such as disagreements on public
improvements fueled some of the antagonisms, but the Klan was the catalyst that
brought affairs to the level of vehement antagonism and violence. There were many Catholics in Muscoda also, who
knew of the bigotry of the Klan regarding their faith, and the organization of
their church. In June 1924 the
activities of Klan members led the editor of the Muscoda Progressive Newspaper
to write an article denouncing the KKK.
Klan leaders were nervous and they called Grant County District Attorney
George B. Clementson, asking for members of the Sheriff’s Department to be on
hand for their conclave to be held on June 25th. Clementson dispatched the Sheriff and a
deputy who witnessed over a hundred fully uniformed Klansmen take part in
ceremonies at the edge of town. There
was no violence that night, but feelings were not soothed by the hooded circus,
and in the dark of night on August 9th stickers were placed on the fronts of
certain businesses reading:

NOTICE

Every criminal, every
gambler, every thug, every libertine, every girl ruiner, every home wrecker,
every wife beater, every moonshiner, every crooked politician, every pagan
papal priest, every shyster lawyer, every K. C., every white slaver, every
brothel madam, Rome controlled newspapers, every black spider – is fighting the
Klan. Which side are you on?”

The editor of the Progressive, reporting the sticker placing wrote: “if there are any “deadbeats,” “bootleggers”
and “women-chasers” in Muscoda that don’t belong to the Klan, we don’t know
about it. From inquiry in other towns in
this neighborhood we find the same thing is true.” Tempers were heating up, and the fuel was
about to be cast on the fire.