If the packers don't tighten up that o-line, Rodgers is gonna be looking like a 40 year old man by the end of the 2010 season.

As for 2009, its really tough to compare their performance. Favre sticks out as better because his team did better... but he had arguably the best team behind him. Anything from defense to running game to special teams, the Vikings were among the top in the league. ARod had a horrible o-line, a fairly weak running game along with a solid defense and fared pretty damn well.

The stats can say whatever you want them to say but at the end of the day, the W or L is the only stat that matters.

All other comments aside, this is completely wrong in evaluating a player's individual skill. And what do you know, we have a perfect example in Favre vs. Rodgers last year. A good QB on a average team will lose to an average QB on a great team. It's why football is a team sport. If Favre beat Rodgers twice in a row in ping pong, I'd agree that he is better. But this is football.

That would be ridiculous. Especially if Williams ends up being a good NFL receiver. Maybe Brett will want to come back to the Packers and they will trade Rodgers :wink2:

Aaron Rodgers is one of my favorite QBs, not only because of his playing style and skill, but because of how he handles himself. This guy was most affected by the Favre roller coaster ride a few years ago, but he stayed strong and didn't complain to the press or anything. Seems like a good guy and is definitely a good QB.

No doubt that Aaron Rodgers is a top notch QB at this point, but its Favre people. Until Rodgers is in the conversation of best of all time, it's Favre for me. The dude is like a Vince Young but 10X better at the QB position, he just wins. He's a legend, his mom has a tat that reads "Brett". NFL Network camps outside his house for months. Who's stalking Aaron?

That would be ridiculous. Especially if Williams ends up being a good NFL receiver. Maybe Brett will want to come back to the Packers and they will trade Rodgers :wink2:

Aaron Rodgers is one of my favorite QBs, not only because of his playing style and skill, but because of how he handles himself. This guy was most affected by the Favre roller coaster ride a few years ago, but he stayed strong and didn't complain to the press or anything. Seems like a good guy and is definitely a good QB.

We should have traded Young and Gage along with our two 3rd round picks from this year's draft and whatever else it takes to get Rodgers and Jennings.

No doubt that Aaron Rodgers is a top notch QB at this point, but its Favre people. Until Rodgers is in the conversation of best of all time, it's Favre for me. The dude is like a Vince Young but 10X better at the QB position, he just wins. He's a legend, his mom has a tat that reads "Brett". NFL Network camps outside his house for months. Who's stalking Aaron?

Does Brett Favre have another 10-12 seasons left in him? NOPE. In fact, I don't think he'll be coming back this season. The dude is too freakin' old and his ankle is banged up pretty bad.

Favre is a legend. He has done more than Aaron Rodgers in his career. He is one of the greatest QBs of all time. No doubt about it. But, as of today, Rodgers is better in every single way. He's younger, he's quicker, he's not selfish, he's not a prima donna, he's in the prime of his career, and there's only one way for Rodgers to go from here... UP. There's only one way for Favre to go from here... DOWN.

Why advertise on goTitans.com?

With 4,000+ members and over 1 million posts, goTitans.com is the place for Tennessee Titans fans to talk Titans. Have those diehard fans see your logo scroll across the bottom of every page of the site linked to your website by becoming a sponsor. Click here for details.

The Tip Jar

For those of you interested in helping the cause, we offer The Tip Jar. For $2 a month, you can become a subscriber and enjoy goTitans.com without ads.