HVAC-Talk site will be slow for the next few days. It's normal site/server maintenance. Thx -Dad

Welcome to HVAC-Talk.com, a non-DIY site and the ultimate Source for HVAC Information & Knowledge Sharing for the industry professional! Here you can join over 150,000 HVAC Professionals & enthusiasts from around the world discussing all things related to HVAC/R. You are currently viewing as a NON-REGISTERED guest which gives you limited access to view discussions

To gain full access to our forums you must register; for a free account. As a registered Guest you will be able to:

Participate in over 40 different forums and search/browse from nearly 3 million posts.

Should you switch doors?

Suppose you're on a game show, and you're given the choice of three doors: Behind one door is a car; behind the others, goats. You pick a door, say No. 1, and the host, who knows what's behind the doors, opens another door, say No. 3, which has a goat. He then says to you, "Do you want to pick door No. 2?" Is it to your advantage to switch your choice?

Suppose you're on a game show, and you're given the choice of three doors: Behind one door is a car; behind the others, goats. You pick a door, say No. 1, and the host, who knows what's behind the doors, opens another door, say No. 3, which has a goat. He then says to you, "Do you want to pick door No. 2?" Is it to your advantage to switch your choice?

I would assume a game show would do that to get you to change your door choice. The big question is, do they want you to win a car or lose?

I took a statistics class that addressed this in a lecture. The conclusion was that you should pick another door. I wish I could remember the whole thing! It had something to do with at first having a 1 in 3 chance of picking the prize door, and once you know what one of the doors is, you now have a 50/50 chance of picking the prize door. Surely someone around here knows what I'm talking about because I sure don't!

I took a statistics class that addressed this in a lecture. The conclusion was that you should pick another door. I wish I could remember the whole thing! It had something to do with at first having a 1 in 3 chance of picking the prize door, and once you know what one of the doors is, you now have a 50/50 chance of picking the prize door. Surely someone around here knows what I'm talking about because I sure don't!

You're close. If you switch doors, you have a 2 in 3 chance of winning. If you stay with the original door, you have a 1 in 3 chance of winning.

Nope, this is wrong. We ran this problem in statistics class, too. Originally, yes, you had a one in three chance of winning. Once one door was revealed, that reduced it to two chances remaining--not three. Therefore, if offered the opportunity to change your choice, you would be left with a one in two or 50/50 chance of winning.

One of the problems in your 2 in 3 model is the two. When changing or offered a change, you don't count the original plus a second, meaning you don't get to choose two doors at once. You get either/ or. A 2 in3 means they offer you to choose two doors and keep both choices.

Nope, this is wrong. We ran this problem in statistics class, too. Originally, yes, you had a one in three chance of winning. Once one door was revealed, that reduced it to two chances remaining--not three. Therefore, if offered the opportunity to change your choice, you would be left with a one in two or 50/50 chance of winning.

One of the problems in your 2 in 3 model is the two. When changing or offered a change, you don't count the original plus a second, meaning you don't get to choose two doors at once. You get either/ or. A 2 in3 means they offer you to choose two doors and keep both choices.

I don't think you have a 50/50 chance. If you did, you should not switch doors. The people who switch doors have a 66.67% chance of winning. Classrooms around the country did this test 100 or 200 times, and by switching doors they were able to win 66.67% of the time. If you had a 50/50 chance of winning, you would only win 50% of the time.

the math can be hard to wrap your head around, but it is better to switch doors after one is revealed. DLS is right, the mythbusters did an episode on this, and the results clearly support switching doors. When first choosing, you are picking one door from three possible choices. Odds are 1 in 3 that you are choosing correctly. After one door is revealed as a loser, only two choices are left. If you stay with your original guess, it is still 1 in 3 odds that you are right, as that is what it was when the door was originally chosen. If you switch, you are now choosing between two doors, and your odds are 1 in 2 that you will be guessing right. seems counter-intuitive, i know. But the results after repeating the test many times over clearly support this. They also did another test on that episode about human nature, with the participants overwhelmingly staying with their original choice, and most of them losing

It matters not how strait the gate,
How charged with punishments the scroll,
I am the master of my fate:
I am the captain of my soul.

the math can be hard to wrap your head around, but it is better to switch doors after one is revealed. DLS is right, the mythbusters did an episode on this, and the results clearly support switching doors. When first choosing, you are picking one door from three possible choices. Odds are 1 in 3 that you are choosing correctly. After one door is revealed as a loser, only two choices are left. If you stay with your original guess, it is still 1 in 3 odds that you are right, as that is what it was when the door was originally chosen. If you switch, you are now choosing between two doors, and your odds are 1 in 2 that you will be guessing right. seems counter-intuitive, i know. But the results after repeating the test many times over clearly support this. They also did another test on that episode about human nature, with the participants overwhelmingly staying with their original choice, and most of them losing

I will venture to say I cannot wrap my head around it because it is wrong. As for Mythbusters, they have a good show but if you want to see them perform a bogus test watch them test pyramid power. It was a sham.

Prior to picking one out of three doors you have a choice to pick a door. That gives you a one out of three chance IF you open the other two doors at once. If you open just one and are given another chance to pick a door to open then your chances become 50/50. It can never be more than 50/50 with two doors remaining and you have a choice between them.

If this is wrong then it must be explained…not left up to Mythbusters. If they ran a few hundred tests on their method and came up with a 66% advantage, that test is also a sham. Anybody can go out in Vegas a beat the 47% to 53% odds against them for a night. But try doing that for a few million hands.

i don't know where the 66% advantage came from, i said 1 in 2 (50-50) if you switch. I believe that is what they said on the show as well. That being said, i just looked at the link above, and maybe i am wrong. I do know that it is in your favor to switch after one door is revealed

It matters not how strait the gate,
How charged with punishments the scroll,
I am the master of my fate:
I am the captain of my soul.

i don't know where the 66% advantage came from, I do know that it is in your favor to switch after one door is revealed

Sorry, you didn’t say the 66% part. It was in post #7.

The only advantage comes from having the opportunity to switch doors after one has been revealed. No opportunity 33%, opportunity 50%.

Switching doors is like flipping a coin, it’s 50/50. Watching someone do this test manually is not the way to test it. Not enough information. It would be like following one person on a night in Vegas…not enough test data. Do it on a computer where you can run a few million tests.