How do they deserve an explanation Trav ?
The only one they will get is the reason the penalty was given......the ref thought he saw something that didnt happen. I have only seen it once or twice but judging by the refs position it seemed somewhat obstructed and the angle could have been misleading.

I cant see why Celtic should get special treatment, it was a bad call. Move on and get on with it we all have to put up with it.
Just because there was no contact people are up in arms. For me there is no difference to the guy who has the faintest touch and goes down, its cheating and we all have to suck it up......look at the Rangers game and the Jags goalie, minimal contact yet he tried to get Waggy booked or sent off. Its cheating and the same thing.

As for the appeal, of course Celtic should use it. Why not, everyone else does. As long as the ruling is there to be abused then clubs will do exactly that.....would love to see Gaffas idea of getting it looked at straight away.
Why does it take them so long, I mean we are all busy in our work places but a quick meeting at short notice is always easy to set up.

I don't want Celtic getting special treatment i want all supporters have decisions explained to them. There is no way a decision as poor as that should be given. The officials are all miked up!! Surely one of them saw what a horrendous decision that was.

wheresoever, whensoever and howsoever we are called upon to make our exit. We shall do so as free men.

I have no problem with you taking issue with my opinion of Brown.
Unfortunately, as is par for the course, your first reaction is to indulge in some deflection by attacking the poster rather than discussing the post.
But I am pleasantly surprised that you didn't come up with some whataboutery regarding a Rangers' player.

typical response and predictive , always playing the victim card lol

Attacking you by calling you paranoid , yet you implied in your response its ironic a celtic fan calling anyone it