Malaysiakini carried out a check on the Election Commission (EC) website with the IC data provided, and the result shows that it belongs to one P Kamalanathan, who is a voter in the Sungai Siput parliament constituency and Jelong state assembly seat.

The EC data also shows that this Kamalanathan address is Heawood Garden, and votes in Simpang Tiga.

Xavier later told Malaysiakini that Kamalanathan is living in Rawang, and his IC address is Rawang, and now he is a BN candidate for Hulu Selangor by- election, yet he votes in Sungai Siput, so it is clear that he is a phantom voter.

"I think a man who wants to be a member of parliament should be principled and accountable for what he has done before.

"It shows that he not to be trusted and is willing to break the law."

However, there is some doubt over this issue, as the relevant electoral law had been amended prior to the 2004 general election making situations like Kamalanathan's to be legal.

Malaysiakini called P Kamalanathan for clarification who said he will explain the issue when the time is right.

"I am now focusing on the election in Hulu Selangor, I want to meet the voters, I want to make friends with the voters, I will not comment it now.

"I will comment it at the right time. I want to go a meeting, bye bye."

Malaysiakini also SMSed the IC number to Kamalanathan for verification but there was no response.

At an earlier interview, Kamalanathan had admitted that in his younger days, he had stayed in Sungai Siput for a while, although he maintains that he has been a Rawang resident for 44 years.

OK OK lets get this straight here. Antares is a cunt and witso is a prick.Then,let me guess...hmmm.. that makes you a prunt???Just in case you ask me to do the impossible and f*** myself,which doubtless you are able to do yourself with consummate ease, maybe you cud youtube it for all of us to see??vaseline or KY jelly dear chap??

hey witso the mandore ,don't flatter yourself .you think too highly of yourself.you are nothing but ass kissing bastard for the chinese.antares don't act as if you are colour blind because you are not .a typical closet racist.muka dua talam!

And for Anon. Bola kurang satu. Have the bricks and decency to own what you say in your own name.

Otherwise, be ignored as the votes swan away. Or better yet, be exorcised along with the rest of the BN phantom voters and bloggers. The world doesn't need another zombie trooper serving the undead masters of BN.

WHy thank you for pointing out my feminine virtues. SO nice of you to finally say something nice at last. I acknowledge you having at least half a brick more for saying cunt to me in public. Pity it's wasted by not having it properly signed.

Too much fire. here's some political humour on the value of having smart people in government.

President Bush visited England and saw the Queen. He asked, How do you run the country so well? The Queen replied, Easy. Find out who are the smartest people you have. To illustrate, she calls up No 10 Downing and asks Tony Blair a Question.

"Tony, if your parents had a child but it's not your brother or sister, who can it be?"

Mr Blair immediately answers, "Well that would be me your highness".

The President, so inspired by the result, flies back on Air Force 1 to the White house and calls on Colin Powell to test this out.

He said, "Colin, if your parents had a child but it's not your brother or sister, who can it be?"

Mr Powell thinks for a while and then said he's get back to the President after using the washroom.

At the urinals, Colin bumps into Dick Cheney. He asks "Dick, if your parents had a child but it's not your brother or sister, who can it be?"

Mr Cheney immediately replies, "Well, that'll be me".

Upon hearing this, Colin Powell runs out of the washroom and heads to the Oval office yelling.

Dear anonymous prunt. I will gladly meet you anytime if you want. Lets see if your face is as foul as your mouth.Or you cud come out of your anon shell and show yourself.I am most happy to exchange words with you if you want.I am quite free and need some fun.

Wow, a fan club now. Considering you're ashamed to use the name your own beloved parent's gave you I'm honored you would call a Chinese male by his given name. Thanks so much. So let me see if i can remove some of this veil of secrecy on this anon. Doesn't matter if it's is all wrong, anon will find it offensive anyway.

Looking at all the raging testosterone, anon here is a male of the age between 18-24. His lack of capitalisation is evidence of an inherent laziness to forming coherent ideas. As such, Anon probably didn't advance further than B's in English due to the chaos in the composition. Likely attempted the GCE 1119 paper for the heck but did not get more than a C due to the same reason.

As such, this ne'er do well spent his time in cyber cafes playing DOTA and surfing porn with his buddies [who would also include some Malays and Chinese pals], and generally wanking the time away. I say this because the anon this time is a youth of Indian descent because of who is currently contesting [Mr Kamalanathan of MIC] and the fact that the UMNO BN goons are known to keep blowing the Ketuanan Melayu horn.

This young male has gone a different track by continuing to uplift the image of the MIC man [which is laudable because none of the other BN mercenaries have done so] in addition to his poorly worded and structured diatribes. There is a chance he is either a relative of the man or under close supervision under the MIC youth wing [Communications] due to the personal nature of some of the postings. In this case, it would be relatively easy to keep narrowing down the subject.

Even if it's all wrong I find making this as ridiculous as possible more fun than a barrel of monkeys [no offense to Planet of the Monyet].

And as for meeting me in person, well and good since I'm rather easy to find. I can connect this misguided anon to a number of counselors and youth support services. Also, kindly note that anyone intending bodily harm must bear in mind some points of the law. That a public declaration of such intention is enough for an investigation. God help you if the police find you in Malaysia. Especially an Indian male with nothing to do.

Otherwise, if harm is intended then you're going to need a silver bullet. I do have a police report with my name on it. It says, Gerald Wee survives machete injuries to the head after fighting off a robbery. Which means, certified by your government as HARDCORE in addition to smart.

So keep at it young man, your remaining ball is shrinking by the minute.

And with that, even this will pass. Just note that in light of the win by BN, something terrible has occured. UMNO has basically picked their successor for MIC. The coming months will either see a resurgence of the MIC or their continued degeneration. This will rankle with the higher ups of the party considering how vengeful that bunch has shown to be.

The fallout when that happens will be incredible. When that occurs, I wonder what side this anon will be on? Likely the bigger pussy says the wise cunt. Because brave men cannot hope to rely on him.

hey gerald the cunt, you assume too much ,which makes you a poofer.your assumptions are as good to be fitted on the base of my shoes. brave men ,you ! ha! ha! ha!.brave man don't make threat like police report, only man with... yes Cunt, do that.

outside of this virtual world ,lies reality , where real men exists but unfortunately,you have absolutely no inkling of that lexical phrase ,don't you? why? oh! that's right you have a cunt.so goodbye gerald the cunt.

Okay bye. Also, kindly use Lexical after phrase as it is an adjective to be used after a noun. Example: No inkling of that phrase in a lexical [lexical referring to the body of language itself]. Really, it's clear why you got your marks for your examinations if your sentence construction is this poor.

See, even if you feel I'm a Cunt you have come away from this entire episode learning proper Queens English from one. SO who's the Bitch now.

Remember, the day you pick sides in the MIC/BN meltdown to come, know who to thank for your better use of language.

hey gerald the cunt,now you just a show off arrogant cunt poofer.this is a comment post,moron .it's about the spur of the moment ,moron.i guess you, being a chinese say it all,you think you smarter than everybody due to racist upbring parents who believe in the middle kingdom fantasy but you are not,your words does not impress me at all.so,jangan shiok sendiri anak bodoh sombong pantat,puto madre is what you really are!

Let it all be known to your BN masters that this anon has wasted all their man hours and time on a single comment thread, instead of cluttering the later more valuable one. That means my own job of poking relentless fun at you has paid off. So keep at it because it gets funnier [and your manhood smaller] with each reply.

So please keep to your quality of writing. I'm very sure you will maintain your unenviable position with such vitriol. That also mean anon will not advance any further for fear of embarrassing your relatives in MIC. The day you finally decide to uplift yourself from such anger and low language standards, you know where to find help.

Sincerely

Gerald Wee

[And yes, this evil and arrogant Chinese gets an orgasmic high from all the posting. It's like a work of literary art for the creatively sarcastic.]

ha!ha!ha! hey gerald the poofer aka cunt,you must have now realized that anon 7.03 was referring to ME.and to that idiot 9.01 who post anon 7.03 name, shame on you!.at least i believe in freedom of expression unlike you so called pakatan rakyat supporters whom keep going on and on about "democracy". if you can't take the heat ,well you know what do...

Who? Are you finally on the verge of acknowledging your parents when they named you?

Well good for you then. Even the current PM adheres to filial piety whenever he refers to his dad [the late Tun Razak]. I wait with bated breath the moment you announce yourself to the world. Go for it.

hey gerald the poofer aka cunt ,bn master???? girl! you are stupid and a sucker to boot!.

ahhh!i am hurt boo hoo...is that all you can muster ? pathetic attempt to insult me,do better poofer.for someone who feels, he is witty in his retort.girl! you really need to come out of your egotistic shell.

queen english is for the pretentious toffee- nosed poofer such as yourself.you are not very smart,are you? who was the first person to address me and continue to do so?

See the longer this guys replies, the better his English. I'm betting there's a dictionary close by to use for such rarely seen words like pretentious and egoistic.

See, that's what is required for effective English language education. Challenge, proper stimulus and adequate resources for reference. Keep replying here. I'm sure you'll be able to get better grades with constant practice.

See, I'm being encouraging without being condescending at the same time. I'm sure if your parents gave you the same treatment, you would love and honour them by writing beautifully and signing off properly in the name they gave you.

I feel for them. They must be very sad if they knew you did this in your spare time. No matter. You are getting professional level English Lessons for free so this is not a waste of time.

hey gerald the poofer aka cunt,why do i need a dict for words like pretentious and egoistic? those are common words during my school days.hammond innes,agatha christie,thomas hardy are the few books i have studied .are you a malaysian? still a pathetic attempt in undermine me .here's a hint,it's not going to work at all .and why my english is better ? because my reply is now longer ,again this is a comment post,moron and hence,spur of the moment remarks.i don't care about grammar when comes to expressing myself in a goddamn comment post.please!professional lessons ehmm..don't let me puke !girly man.like i said,you assume too much .as the saying goes assumption is the mother of all fuckups! such as yourself.only the arrogant and racist supremacy who belittles and looks down and pass judgement on others without having all the facts .language is not the anchor of intelligence,it's number.remember that!.see it's you the egoman ,who's prejudice rules his mind when it comes to the indian ,a typically chinese behaviour in this country.i will retire from this ,since i have better things to occupy myself .but before that ,some pre-emptive insults -puto madre poofers,anak bodoh sombong,

you must understand that, at the end of the day,i could not care less what you think of me.your opinion of me means didly squat.have nice day ,poofer!