Trump Appeals Court Nominee Draws Fire For Blog Posts

Louisville lawyer John Bush is still awaiting a vote on his confirmation by President Donald Trump to be a judge on the Sixth Circuit Court of Appeals. During hearings last month, he dodged questions dealing with controversial blog posts he penned under a pseudonym.

In a post from 2008 on the Elephants in the Bluegrass blog, Bush wrote that the landmark Supreme Court decision dealing with abortion, Roe vs. Wade, was decided by “activist judges.”

He also said that abortion was one of the nation’s “greatest tragedies”—along with slavery. In the post, Bush said both Roe vs. Wade and the Dred Scott case, which denied a black man’s right to sue for his freedom, precipitating the Civil War, relied on similar judicial reasoning.

“There are millions of Americans who have a different viewpoint about Roe. I’m setting that completely aside,” Bush said. “If I were to be confirmed, I will faithfully apply the law of Roe vs. Wade and all other precedent following it.”

Bush made more than 400 posts to the blog, discussing his opposition to same-sex marriage, former President Obama’s Kenyan heritage and calling former House Speaker Nancy Pelosi “Mama Pelosi.”

Bush is Trump’s second nominee to the appeals court, which handles cases from Kentucky, Tennessee, Ohio and Michigan.

Earlier this year, the Senate confirmed Judge Amul Thapar to serve on the court—he previously served as a U.S. District Judge in the Eastern District of Kentucky.

“Mr. Bush, as we all do, has his own personal views about politics, which he enjoys discussing,” McConnell said. “But this does not diminish the professional esteem in which his colleagues hold him, their fondness for him, or their belief that he will follow the law.”

NARAL Pro-Choice America launched a six-figure ad campaign opposing Bush’s nomination in home states of Senate Judiciary members last month.

The Senate Judiciary Committee hasn’t yet scheduled a vote on Bush’s nomination. If he is approved, his confirmation would be voted on by the full U.S. Senate.

Related Content

A liberal group has come out against President Donald Trump’s nomination of a Louisville lawyer to a federal appeals court, criticizing him for opposing a landmark ruling dealing with freedom of the press.

John Bush is currently a partner at the Louisville law firm Bingham Greenebaum Doll, and according to his website practices complex litigation dealing with financial institutions, intellectual property and product liability disputes.

He is also an influential member of the Federalist Society, a conservative group that advocates for the literal interpretation of laws and the Constitution based on their original meaning.

During a Federalist Society event in 2009, Bush said that a landmark Supreme Court ruling that strengthened press protections from libel claims was probably “wrongly decided.”

Kentucky state Sen. Reggie Thomas says he is running for the U.S. House.

Thomas, a Democrat, made the announcement Saturday at the historic Lyric Theatre in Lexington. A lawyer and professor at Kentucky State University, Thomas was elected to the Kentucky state Senate in 2013.

He is challenging Republican U.S. Rep. Andy Barr for the 6th District congressional seat.

Senate Majority Leader Mitch McConnell has rejected President Donald Trump’s advice to nix the GOP’s complex health care proposal in favor of a bill that would simply get rid of “Obamacare” once and for all.

McConnell told reporters after an event Friday in his home state of Kentucky that the Republican health care bill remains challenging but “we are going to stick with that path” in response to a question about the president’s tweet. Former President Barack Obama signed the Affordable Care Act into law in 2010, and Republicans have been trying to get rid of it ever since.