I personally would like to get the Conventioneer Achievement but I'm not planning on attending any cons in the near future.
However, I did attend Otakon in 2008 and was at the Gaia Panel.
While at that particular Gaia Panel I received codes to redeem Gaia items and did just so.
Unfortunately, the Achievement System wasn't released until 2010.
Personally, I think that because I have already attended an IRL Gaia-related event that I should be rewarded with the Conventioneer Achievement.

I believe that the Conventioneer Achievement should be updated to automatically check for past code redemptions from IRL Gaia-related events.

If it's actually possible for them to check for past code redemptions, sure, that would make sense.

Though, if they don't actually have a log on-site from that long ago of such a specific detail ( and, I'm gonna' level with you: I don't think they would ) then that's not really an option. And I think they would have done that if they could have, to begin with.

If it's actually possible for them to check for past code redemptions, sure, that would make sense.

Though, if they don't actually have a log on-site from that long ago of such a specific detail ( and, I'm gonna' level with you: I don't think they would ) then that's not really an option. And I think they would have done that if they could have, to begin with.

I actually disagree with you on Gaia being smart enough to think of checking for past redemptions.
However, I do agree with you in doubting that they have a log of such information, which is unfortunate.
If they are unable to check for past redemptions, then I'm sure there's some other way to figure this issue out.

Gabriella Ellenor

Personally....
While I think it would be nice of them to do... I dont really see the need for it.

So you went to a con in the past, good for you, you got the reward that was due at that time. Just because there is a new reward for them now does not mean you should automatically get that as well.

Would you rather current con attendees simply pass out, or even sell, the codes to people to didn't even attend a previous event?
At least give the people who attended a Gaia event proper credit.

If they are unable to check for past redemptions, then I'm sure there's some other way to figure this issue out.

Not.. really? I mean, if they don't have a log, then they don't have proof. And if they don't have proof, then they've got nothing, and-- unfortunately-- that'll just be one of those situations where life isn't fair and people who attended pre-achievement conventions won't be able to get the achievement based on those.

I mean, if you're sure and you actually know a way other than checking previous logs which most likely don't exist, then I'd love to hear it. But otherwise.. Ehhh?

Would you rather current con attendees simply pass out, or even sell, the codes to people to didn't even attend a previous event?
At least give the people who attended a Gaia event proper credit.

If thats what the current people want to do, then sure. More power to them.

People that attended the events in the past got their credit, in the past.... where it belongs.
By the retro logic, people like me should automatically have the achievements for logging in for how ever many days. After all, its only fair cause we were here in the past before those achievements were ever made/thought up, right?

To me, its like a sale at a store. Just because you bought something one day and then it goes on sale the next does not mean you deserve the sale price. You got it in the time frame when you got it, and if you want the new 'special' then you have to partake in the event during the new 'current' time frame.

Not.. really? I mean, if they don't have a log, then they don't have proof. And if they don't have proof, then they've got nothing, and-- unfortunately-- that'll just be one of those situations where life isn't fair and people who attended pre-achievement conventions won't be able to get the achievement based on those.

I mean, if you're sure and you actually know a way other than checking previous logs which most likely don't exist, then I'd love to hear it. But otherwise.. Ehhh?

Gaia could always check members' inventories for the Gaia-Con items, check post histories and/or journal entries for mentionings of attending a Gaia event.
The latter shouldn't be too had on Gaia's end.

Gabriella Ellenor

If thats what the current people want to do, then sure. More power to them.

People that attended the events in the past got their credit, in the past.... where it belongs.
By the retro logic, people like me should automatically have the achievements for logging in for how ever many days. After all, its only fair cause we were here in the past before those achievements were ever made/thought up, right?

To me, its like a sale at a store. Just because you bought something one day and then it goes on sale the next does not mean you deserve the sale price. You got it in the time frame when you got it, and if you want the new 'special' then you have to partake in the event during the new 'current' time frame.

I do see your point and it does make sense.
However, logging in every day is a lot simpler than attending an IRL Gaia event.
The last convention in general that I, myself, have been able to attend was Otakon back in 2008.
Haven't been able to attend since; and it's right here in my hometown!
The Conventioneer Achievement is the one of the hardest to get because of the fact that there are many members unable to attend such events.
I personally believe that those who were lucky enough in the past to attend should be rewarded for attending, especially since some of them may not be able to attend for years to come (if ever again).
Now, I haven't heard anything from Gaia's perspective, but I wouldn't think that they'd approve of the sharing of codes that are specifically meant for a select few.

When achievements came out, they said they would set it so anyone who redeemed a convention code would get the Conventioneer achievement. But they didn't go through with that. If it's possible, it would be nice if they could do it.

I do see your point and it does make sense.
However, logging in every day is a lot simpler than attending an IRL Gaia event.
The last convention in general that I, myself, have been able to attend was Otakon back in 2008.
Haven't been able to attend since; and it's right here in my hometown!
The Conventioneer Achievement is the one of the hardest to get because of the fact that there are many members unable to attend such events.
I personally believe that those who were lucky enough in the past to attend should be rewarded for attending, especially since some of them may not be able to attend for years to come (if ever again).
Now, I haven't heard anything from Gaia's perspective, but I wouldn't think that they'd approve of the sharing of codes that are specifically meant for a select few.

Like I said before, if they choose to retro it, then great. I have no problem against it, and it would be super nice of them if they did. But also not going to actively support trying to get it done. Guess its a 'to each their own' sort of thing.

While I agree we would need to hear from Gaia staff specifically, again I wouldnt see the issue with it. Its not like extra items are being pumped in from it. The same few number of people will get the prize... it just wont be the same few people.

But I said my peace, and since we see clearly (least I think) each others points... I wish you luck in getting your achievement as I take my leave. ^.^

Gaia could always check members' inventories for the Gaia-Con items, check post histories and/or journal entries for mentionings of attending a Gaia event.
The latter shouldn't be too had on Gaia's end.

Well, they could if they had the ability to, but then, remember, the Con Items are NOT Soulbound and can be bought on the MP and the Exchange. (From the MP listing: Gaia-Con Registration Goodies (Any) and there are many requests for the codes in the Achievement Forums so others can get the Achievement without having attended.

They had to draw the line some place and making it from the date of the Conventioneer's Achievement existence seems rather fair to everyone. I live in the States and even though they have the Cons in Seattle, I doubt I would ever be able to attend due to my work. I like getting Achievements as much as the next person, but, it doesn't mean a thing if I don't get that one ... there are plenty others that I can get by just being on the site.

Gaia could always check members' inventories for the Gaia-Con items, check post histories and/or journal entries for mentionings of attending a Gaia event.
The latter shouldn't be too had on Gaia's end.

Well, they could if they had the ability to, but then, remember, the Con Items are NOT Soulbound and can be bought on the MP and the Exchange. (From the MP listing: Gaia-Con Registration Goodies (Any) and there are many requests for the codes in the Achievement Forums so others can get the Achievement without having attended.

I realize this.
Are you certain that Gaia staff can't look into one's inventory and seeing item details?

I tend to believe that the staff has more control over this site than they let on at times.