You guys don't think the channel can create 2 ridges on its side, which puts more pressure there compared to a non-cut-out saddle?

I have ridden both cut out and non-cut out saddles, and would agree with the above.

If there is any real pressure on the area where most cut out saddles have their cut out, it would be a sign for me that I am are sitting wrong (i.e. not on my sit bones). At that time, you indeed are distributing a lot of load on two narrow "rails" which is less than comfortable and can't be healthy. Again, that just my finding after trying some 10+ saddles over time.I have not seen any reliable study (i.e. no marketing brochure) yet that would show any significant change in blood flow or nerve pressure between cut vs. non-cut saddles, provided they are used correctly - but I might just be ignorant about this. Anyone?

You guys don't think the channel can create 2 ridges on its side, which puts more pressure there compared to a non-cut-out saddle?

I have ridden both cut out and non-cut out saddles, and would agree with the above.

If there is any real pressure on the area where most cut out saddles have their cut out, it would be a sign for me that I am are sitting wrong (i.e. not on my sit bones). At that time, you indeed are distributing a lot of load on two narrow "rails" which is less than comfortable and can't be healthy. Again, that just my finding after trying some 10+ saddles over time.I have not seen any reliable study (i.e. no marketing brochure) yet that would show any significant change in blood flow or nerve pressure between cut vs. non-cut saddles, provided they are used correctly - but I might just be ignorant about this. Anyone?

So I did notice although the ridges / rail on a hard cut-out saddle causes some discomfort for me on long rides, I didn't get any cramps even if I pushed hard on the climbs, which seems like there is something different going on. Going back to my original saddle suddenly feels like a sofa.

Hey thisisatest, "secondly, comfort and good blood flow are completely independent. you can be riding with a big grin on your face right up until your genitalia falls off." WTF?!! I hope not.

I have gone from a Fizik Arione, to a Selle Italian SLR Carbonio flow and have found it much more comfortable. I have protruding sit bones and am quite flexible so my hips roll forward and with a full saddle this resulted in pressure under my junk.It is all very dependant on the individual. A friend of mine got to the point where he was pissing blood and so switched to a Selle SMP cut out and has been fine since. I have tried his saddle and it feels to me like sitting on nails. It is definitely not for all but is worth considering. As they say, there are only 2 types of cyclists, those with erectile dysfunction and those yet to get it.

It takes getting used to a cutout saddle and some people might take longer than others.

I went from a Prologo to a Toupe and it was glorious on my taint, but took my sitbones a while to adjust. Going from that to the Romin took some more time as it had 0 padding.

I oscillated between those 2 for 1.5 years before finally giving an SMP a try. So far its been great, but you have to get used to your tuberosities supporting all of your weight. You will never get perenium pressure again.

Its all individual anatomy. I'd prefer not to ride an ugly, heavy, and expensive saddle but if its this much better then screw it.

Who is online

You cannot post new topics in this forumYou cannot reply to topics in this forumYou cannot edit your posts in this forumYou cannot delete your posts in this forumYou cannot post attachments in this forum