@hunterbergfeld You cannot possibly attack people who think this season of Game of Thrones will be “epic” and tell them they have no proof, and then in the NEXT post write about how you have a sneaking suspicion that Mr. Robot will be “amazing” next season. No one has seen footage from either season, so you can’t attack the GoT people for judging unseen content and then do the exact same thing they did for Mr. Robot.

A) I’m not attaching anybody

B) I’m not calling Mr.Robot a lock to win everything

C) of course I know Game of Thrones will be amazing. I love Game of Thrones. My pic was Jon Snow forever. But I’m just not convinced it’s a lock to win everything.

D) I didn’t say it won’t win, if predicting it right now, I’m just saying we shouldn’t call it a lock to win everything when it couldn’t even beat Stranger Things at PGA and still can’t win anything at SAG.

Wait, I am confused about Twin Peaks (I’ve been avoiding that thread since I have never seen the original and I am in the middle of catching up). I presumed that it was a limited series?

The timing for them is seriously so wonky. Why start airing so late into the eligibility period that you don’t even have the requisite number of episodes to qualify? Twin Peaks and Lynch are big enough names to potentially keep themselves in the conversation until awards season 2018 rolls around but it really feels like they shot themselves in the foot here.

Oh, and unless Game of Thrones somehow completely bombs – it will (deservedly or not – that’s a different topic) win drama series in 2018 and 2019. Still not sure if it will ever win another acting award but I’d be pretty disappointed if GOT ended its run without Lena Headey taking home the prize at least once.

Comedy series I think is still pretty up in the air. I don’t see Will and Grace or Roseanne nominated for series, though. Seriously, I understand that there is a lot of nostalgia on here for those two shows but so far no revival has managed to get a top series nomination so I would be pretty cautious. I think some of the actors probably have a better shot than the shows themselves.

X Files was drama so I’m assuming this will also be drama. Gilmore Girls went limited but it also has a subtitle and is only 4 episodes. Twin Peaks is 18 episodes. There isn’t a limit but that seems like a stretch to get an appeal.

I do think it is worth noting though that most revivals are listed on the same IMDB page, Gilmore Girls doesn’t count because it has a subtitle, but this Twin Peaks is on a completely different page. I don’t know if that’s relevant but who knows?

X Files was drama so I’m assuming this will also be drama. Gilmore Girls went limited but it also has a subtitle and is only 4 episodes. Twin Peaks is 18 episodes. There isn’t a limit but that seems like a stretch to get an appeal.

I do think it is worth noting though that most revivals are listed on the same IMDB page, Gilmore Girls doesn’t count because it has a subtitle, but this Twin Peaks is on a completely different page. I don’t know if that’s relevant but who knows?

Good points – I am pretty sure Twin Peaks also has a subtitle. Isn’t it Twin Peaks: The Return?

As for X-Files, that has already confirmed additional episodes so drama makes sense in that case whereas I really can’t see Lynch making more beyond these 18 (and he has stated as such).

X Files was drama so I’m assuming this will also be drama. Gilmore Girls went limited but it also has a subtitle and is only 4 episodes. Twin Peaks is 18 episodes. There isn’t a limit but that seems like a stretch to get an appeal. I do think it is worth noting though that most revivals are listed on the same IMDB page, Gilmore Girls doesn’t count because it has a subtitle, but this Twin Peaks is on a completely different page. I don’t know if that’s relevant but who knows?

Good points – I am pretty sure Twin Peaks also has a subtitle. Isn’t it Twin Peaks: The Return? As for X-Files, that has already confirmed additional episodes so drama makes sense in that case whereas I really can’t see Lynch making more beyond these 18 (and he has stated as such).

I thought the return was just the name of the premiere. I could be wrong though. I’m still on season 2.

Ya the second half of season 2 seemed like it was all set up for some epic shit in season 3. The ending of season 2 made it seem like season 3 was going to be a huge scale event. And the show still has support so if season 3 is amazing it could easily get another nom (assuming season 2 is snubbed).

Ya the second half of season 2 seemed like it was all set up for some epic shit in season 3. The ending of season 2 made it seem like season 3 was going to be a huge scale event. And the show still has support so if season 3 is amazing it could easily get another nom (assuming season 2 is snubbed).

Well I am somewhat foolishly holding out hope that it survives the lineup this year even though I know that it’s not likely.