[Games] Mafia Game Thread - Welcome back to Brazil - Game 9 END / Discussion

If this is your first visit, be sure to
check out the FAQ by clicking the
link above. You may have to register
before you can post: click the register link above to proceed. To start viewing messages,
select the forum that you want to visit from the selection below.

Re: Mafia Game Thread - Welcome back to Brazil - Game 9

Originally Posted by dark lord

okay then

Vote Kill pirulito

Random vote is random.

I can't see a reason to make a random vote with the accusations and suggestions flying around here. So far there are more than one person throwing as-valid-as-a-day-two-reasoning-can-be conclusions towards one (or more) suspect(s). Therefore, both a no_kill and a "random" vote, is a quite wasted vote.

Either you're trying to remove steam off CBlitz and Piru, or you're not playing your a-game by wasting your first vote like that, and I want you to play your a-game so that we can win!

Though I find both Piru and CBlitz as the most likely suspects taken in account what scav and Org said, as well as your past actions.

I won't throw my vote out there yet but will instead, like some of the posters above, await further information from Imp as he's, so far, the one I find most likely to be who he claims to be, as well as having useful information.

You're not paid to think;
A mindless worker is a happy worker,
so shut up and do your job.

Re: Mafia Game Thread - Welcome back to Brazil - Game 9

I didn't wanted to play this time so I decided to kill myself. My mafia pals acepeted

Originally Posted by Ustegius

The second part makes me think there is mafioso or two in the ones who voted Banana.

If your theory is true then at least one Mafia voted for BBB.

Let's see who actually did vote for him.

Originally Posted by Evil3ye

VOTE KILL BBB BANANA 4x (scav, Imperium, Xadyu, Blai )

Scav, Imp, Xad and me.

Let's take a closer look at the people who actually did vote for BBB Banana

If we assume that Imperium is indeed telling the truth then he is a Mason and therefore innocent. I won't go into any further investigation until I see the facts he's presenting, the validity of them, and potential slip-ups from a good Mafia, or the evidence from a good Mason.

Second of all, I thought BBB was trolling and switched to vote for him because I did not want my no_kill to get myself killed and everyone thought he was a Mafia. I'm by no means Mafia member who "supposedly" agree'd to his successful suicide mission.

scav, voted BBB down very quickly, first of us all, after some BBB troll posts. I don't know if he did it on a whim or because it was a good reason and time to throw the first rock at a fellow Mafia (who wanted to go down). Though he wanted me to change my vote so that only BBB would go down. Did he simply not want a townie to go down with his fellow Mafia, or was he, as a townie, looking out for another townie, hoping that he'd vote for the obvious Mafia troll?
He then made a quite convincing argumental post against CBlitz and Piru -here- the former whom is the major suspect of Organizized.

Fourth and last, Xadyu started off with a vote no_kill in his first post after BBB trolled around and the first random votes were cast. He continued to vouch for the option to vote a no_kill despite of that (like I did myself).

Then, after Evil presented the "scoreboard" (lol) he instantly switched to BBB because he "just went along with everybody else." earlier and suddenly found a valid reason to vote for BBB. What, exactly, was that valid reason? That "he already claimed three roles and I don't buy any of them. gtfo."? Then why vote no_kill and defend that choice when BBB already had claimed those three roles and he didn't buy any of it?
He then accuses Ust and Freid, two hard-to-read players because they were merely having a light argument and "without reason" vote_kills Channy.
Channy, so far, has been quite a low-key player, probably a townie with a mediocre role. Not the more important, but not the less important role and I really don't see a "random" vote during the 2nd day-phase as valid. Especially not towards someone without any amount of suspicion cast upon them.

Instantly after that, Zeltrax vote_kills Channy.

Is there something you'd like to explain to us Xadyu? Or maybe Zeltrax can give us an interesting insight in Channy's Mafia-life?

(Not defending anyone, just curious)

This is just an analytic post made as a try to check the validity of his statement. i.e. did the Mafia really vote for him, or is he saying this to cast suspicion upon townies.

Personally I believe that the only suspect on that list so far is Xadyu. Apparently BBB trolled enough to gain the mistrust of three townies that led to his doom, thus only needing one Mafia to back him up.

However I'd only class Xadyu as a minor/moderate suspect as one really don't need a super-valid reason to vote BBB when he's trolling like that, but the unjustified attack on Channy was kinda unnecessary (unless I missed something, then please tell me).

(I just want to clear as many people as possible from the Mafia accusation/suspicions)

Last edited by blai; March 23, 2011 at 11:02 AM.

You're not paid to think;
A mindless worker is a happy worker,
so shut up and do your job.

Re: Mafia Game Thread - Welcome back to Brazil - Game 9

btw i think Imp is a townie and something popped in my head, a good thing would be if the detectives investigate Imp tonight, so the insane detective will know if he's insane, the normal and naive detective will know at least that they aren't insane. that could help later in the game (day 3 or 4).