I've had these oakleys before, but they...

You may want a darker lens since I feel like you look towards the sky quite a bit playing volleyball. The style though, should work fine. If you liked the ones you had before, I'm sure you will like the again.

Try the Black Iridium POLORIZED lens for really sunny days. But for overcast days, maybe the Grey Iridium, or even transistions* lens may work better. You can, of course, order a frame with multiple lens so you'll be "covered" not matter what!

If you go on the Oakley site, they have a really 'cool-tool' that lets you see a simulated view a variety of their lens (tons of choices!), in a variety of outdoor settings (golf, bright light, overcast, trail, etc.). It's "ingenious"! You can check it out there, and still purchase here!