Love this name, very handsome! I'm a fan of most unusual ancient Greek names though. Also the Orpheus and Eurydice myth is one of my favourites. The only potential fault I can see with Orpheus is the lack of usable nicknames.

PS: To some posters above, Orpheus was not 'gay', it even says in the description he had a wife! At the most he was bisexual. And even then... does it really matter?