Elmo and Zoe are in a disagreement over what to play with: Elmo wants to play with crayons, but Zoe wants to play with blocks. Big Bird calls Maria for help, and she suggests that they take turns. Once she leaves, they still have trouble coming to a unanimous decision on what to play with first.

Animation

Wooden shapes group themselves by color, then regroup by shape, then assemble themselves into a rocket ship.(EKA: Episode 3286)

Big Bird brings Maria back to solve Elmo and Zoe's argument. She points out that Big Bird's input will help bring them to a fair vote. However, when voting, Big Bird doesn't want to upset either Elmo or Zoe if they lose, so he keeps switching his decision back and forth, and realizes they still have a problem.

Once again, Maria is called upon to solve the argument. She has an idea for a game: the Chucky Choosing game, similar to "eeny meeny miney mo." The words are hard for them to remember, except for Big Bird, and he ends up choosing Elmo. Maria comes back, thinking she'll be able to help them with the game like she promised earlier, but they let her know that they decided on crayons first.

Big Bird tries to talk Elmo and Zoe into playing catch, and they agree to do so before the crayons and the blocks (since Big Bird's tried so hard to help them today). For the second time, Maria comes in too late for another Chucky Choosing round.

Cookie Monster paints a cookie so that he can compare for the audience how true the likeness is to the real thing. After he shows how he even got every little macaroon, he eats both the cookie and the painting.(EKA: Episode 3769)