Do Business Analysts make good dimensional modellers??

Recently I had the (dis)pleasure of working with Business Analysts, who also thought that they are good in dimensional modelling. so, I had to implement BI solutions (including cubes) on top of their database design. I will show an example (about 95% the same as the actual design), where the idea of letting BAs go into dev territory does not yield the best results:

This “dimensional model” was created by an experienced BA. Some “features” are missing here:
1. The fact table had EffectiveFrom and EffectiveTo dates
2. The relationships between some Dim Tables were 1-1 ?!
3. The Time dim (the only one properly implemented on its own – on the bottom of my example) had columns like: DateTimeName nvarchar(100), DateTimeKey nvarchar(100), YearName nvarchar(100), etc..
4. The Some Tables on the top had nothing to do with the rest (in fact a colleague of mine reckons they are there to fill in the white space on the top of the A3 printout)

Another design, which is better, but still pretty bad showed up after my training on Dimensional Modelling (1hr to go through EVERYTHING, including M2M relationships, Parent-Child hierarchies, Type 2 dimensions, etc):

Obviously, the designer (a developer actually) did grasp some concepts. However, my explanation of a star schema must have been not too clear..

Hope that you had some fun with these two diagrams..and I am sure many developers get in a similar situation, especially when someone else designs their databases. But two points:

1. Ask the BAs to analyse the business and their requirements – not to design the database
2. 1 hour of training on dimensional modelling will not make you an expert