That's why I brought it up Then Jasper would feel the lust, and everyone else would notice how they're growling at the human and put two and two together... I'd feel sorry for the kid, but not that sorry, because he'd be a slimy little hornball.

|Allie (Red) and Sami (Cocoa) and Sydney (Yank) are ❤|Conch=twin||SBS|Major V|Heidi Volturi|Veronica Ricci|Some other stuff I forgot||Banner Screenshots by Squid, Avie by Abby|

SenorGimp wrote:Oh My God!! What do you think Edward would do if he heard the thoughts of a little hornball boy just out to use Renesmee for a piece?!?!There has never been a fatherly wrath like the whirlwind of terror that Edward would become in that situation!Jeez!That's frightening to consider!

who_needs_fangs? wrote:That's why I brought it up Then Jasper would feel the lust, and everyone else would notice how they're growling at the human and put two and two together... I'd feel sorry for the kid, but not that sorry, because he'd be a slimy little hornball.

But, I have to agree with you Who_Needs_Fangs, with Jacob there, no mortal boy is going to have a chance. Then again, I have a feeling no mortal boy in his right mind is going to try to go anywhere near Renesmee when she is constantly chaperoned by a beautiful, 6'8", overmuscled Quileute guardian.

Huh? It does beg the question, though, and I know we've lightly touched on this before, but now quite in this way. What do you think Edward's reaction is going to be when Jacob is the "hornball"? Like it or not, he's eventually going to start thinking about Nessie that way In BD, he talks about how impressed he was that Jacob didn't acknowledge it when they found out how long it would take her to mature. But, that's only going to last until the first time he catches Jake fantasizing about his daughter and a latenight motorcycle ride somewhere! Uh-oh.

So, I'm going to disagree with you guys here. It's not that I don't think Edward will be protective of Renesmee. We all saw how overbearingly protective he was of Bella. He's going to be doubly bad with Renesmee because it's his daughter. And, most fathers still consider their teenage daughters "little girls." In Edward's case, she'll be a teenager after only a few years, so she really will be his little girl. I think with any random guy, Edward would be off the charts protective. But, with Jacob, there is a level of respect and trust. He knows Jacob is a good guy. He has accepted that Jacob will be a part of Renesmee's life. He called him "My son," in BD. He saw how well Jacob treated Bella (most of the time) when he was chasing after her. Of course, Edward won't like hearing Jacob have less than pure thoughts about his daughter, but I think he is happy for them and accepting that they will be together. It won't be like Renesmee is with some random guy who will break up with her or doesn't really care about her. Edward understands how strong imprinting is and how strong Jacob's feelings for Renesmee are.

Here's another thing to think about. Edward can hear Renesmee's thoughts as well. How awkward will it be for them when he can hear her thinking about having sex with Jacob? I feel bad for her!

POOR EDWARD!That's going to be so awkward!I imagine Bella will have to do her little shield trick more and more often, shielding Jacob and Renesmee to keep Edward out when they are together.Damn, what a convoluted state of affairs!

SenorGimp wrote:POOR EDWARD!That's going to be so awkward!I imagine Bella will have to do her little shield trick more and more often, shielding Jacob and Renesmee to keep Edward out when they are together.Damn, what a convoluted state of affairs!

Actually, I am kind of hoping that maybe Bella will develop her shield to where she can "protect" Edward from hearing everyone else's thoughts. It just seems a little less ...icky...to me. I mean, can you imagine trying to make out with your honey while your mom's hiding just out of eyesight so she can protect you from your dad's mind reading.... Ewwww!!!!

Edward would never be able to repay her for THAT!!That's been one of the most difficult parts of his existence, and even more than Bella being able to show him her thoughts, I think he would be absolutely eternally grateful to her if he could get just a few moments of alone time in HIS thoughts...That would be awesome!Jazz, you are a gentlewoman and a scholar!

i think renesmee is adorable!!! But i don't like that jacob imprinted on her. lamo, yes some serious practicing on shields must be done way before anyone does anything with anyone who can read certain people's minds/send mental images/etc. but i still think jacob should've just went after leah or some other girl. Also we saw bella's reaction when jacob imprinted on renesmee (typical angry-psycho-i'll-kill-you-for-messing-with-my-baby-mother-reaction, except bella is a vampire so now it's like a thousand times worse) but how did edward react? and i can't believe jacob acted like imprinting on renesmee was no big deal, how dare he, if that was my daughter i'd kill him and no other vampires/etc. would stop me.

As we've seen throughout the series, Edward does not want to do anything that will cause Bella grief or pain in any way, so he took a step back and let Bella handle the Jacob imprinting on Renesmee situation, trusting, and rightly so, that her wrath would be there in full force, and would absolutely put any anger he could have mustered to shame!But I think that Jacob and Renesmee will be a great couple, and don't see how you can really fault him (Jacob) for doing something that is in his genetic makeup to do, and which he has no control over. Plus he deserves to have someone to love who loves him back absolutely!thanks for listening- senorgimp(P.S. Ariadnee, I stole your end-post quote. sorry)