Welcome to SS&GF! Make sure to subscribe to my RSS or e-mail feed and get new recipes as soon as they're posted. You can also subscribe to my monthly newsletterhere.

Pumpkin butter has been on my ‘to-make’ list for the last three years. And every year, the leaves would fall from the trees and the icy-cold months would show up and somehow the pumpkin butter never made it to the top of my list.

This year was different. And, gosh, am I thrilled! Better yet, you get to make it in your CrockPot. (Or slow cooker if that’s what you prefer to call it…)

Before I tell you how delicious it is – because I’ll get there – I’ll tell you to NOT base your opinion on this recipe when the pumpkin butter is still hot. It’s not that tasty. The flavor is there but the smooth, almost creamy-like texture doesn’t show up until the pumpkin butter has been chilled overnight.

If you look through most pumpkin butter recipes, they use apple juice. Apple juice has a nearly neutral flavor when used in desserts. Personally, I think you need a little orange with your pumpkin. It brightens the entire spread and makes it memorable and utterly delicious.
As for the recipe name, I shared the ingredients on Facebook and asked what they would call the recipe. I took bits and pieces of a few different ideas. I’ve got some very savvy readers – thanks for your help! (And Jennifer – I loved the suggestion for ‘Skinny Pumpkin Butter!’)

Some folks asked what you do with pumpkin butter. Spread it on toast, muffins, quick breads, mix it in applesauce, or, eat it right out of the jar with a spoon.

Wow Amy!!! This was SO worth waiting for! The flavors of pumpkin, spices and orange are one of my absolute favorites. I could see this being a dipper for a gluten free gingersnap or some such cookie also. Great with a cup of tea or a pumpkin latte! I know what I will be doing this weekend! Thank you! Hugs!

About Amy

Living free of refined sugars and gluten since 2004 has allowed me to live a fulfilled, healthy life. My food cravings, migraines, and depression vanished and was able to maintain a 60+ pound weight loss. Today I live with enormous freedom. Join me as I create healthier food that's SS&GF and delicious. I hope to help you do the same. Read more about my story here.