Crisis in boys' performance at school overblown, study says

Both genders have improved their GPAs since 1990, analysts find.

May 20, 2008|By Queenie Wong, McClatchy Newspapers

WASHINGTON -- Both boys and girls are doing better in school, so there's no reason to fear that school systems favor girls at boys' expense, a women's advocacy group says in a study to be released today.

It's the freshest argument in the boys vs. girls debate in education, one in which the group, the American Association of University Women, has been a major player.

Having said in an influential 1992 study that the education system worked against girls, it now argues that the real crisis is racial and economic disparities, not gender.

"The mythology of the boy crisis continues to be influential," said Catherine Hill, the association's director of research. One reason, she added, is that "people feel uncomfortable with the success of girls and women."

High-school girls are getting better grades than boys, but from 1990 to 2005 both genders have improved their average GPAs, the study found. Men also are earning more college degrees today than in the 1970s, although women are earning more degrees than men.

"Educational achievement is not a zero-sum game, in which a gain for one group results in a corresponding loss for the other," the AAUW study concluded.

On the college testing front, boys have a slight advantage in both the math and the verbal sections of the Scholastic Aptitude Test, according to the new analysis, titled "Where the Girls Are: The Facts About Gender Equity in Education."

On the ACT, girls score better in English and reading while boys score better in math and science, the study found. SAT scores have risen for both sexes since 1994, and the boy vs. girl gaps are small -- for example, three to eight points on the verbal test.

By comparison, differences between the average SAT verbal scores of white and black students are on the order of 100 points. So are those between students whose families are in the top and bottom third in income.

Michael Gurian, author of The Minds of Boys, an influential book on boys' educational disadvantages published in 2005, agreed that ethnic and income differences are more powerful than gender.

But he called the new study a "straw-man argument" that distracts from the fact that boys are still falling behind.