Saturday, November 11, 2017

Patient's recovery convinces doctor to fight euthanasia laws.

This article was published by The Australian on November 11, 2017, link, for pdf, link.

By Cameron Stewart

Dr. Kenneth Stevens

When American doctor Kenneth Stevens heard about Victoria’s
plan to introduce assisted dying for the terminally ill he couldn’t help but
recall the story of his patient Jeanette Hall.

Hall, then 55, came to
Stevens in 2000 after being diagnosed with inoperable colon cancer in Portland,
Oregon, a state that in 1997 introduced laws enabling doctors to prescribe fatal
pills to the terminally ill. She walked into Stevens’ office and told him she
wanted to die, but Stevens, a cancer specialist, disputed the diagnosis of her
original doctor.“I told her that I believed this was
potentially curable but she said ‘Dr. Stevens, you don’t understand, I voted for
the law and I don’t want to go through all the treatment, I don’t want to lose
my hair, I don’t want to go through all that’,’’ Stevens says.

The
specialist delayed her ­request to write a prescription for the fatal drugs and
instead tried to talk her out of it.

Jeanette Hall

“I learned she had a son who is in
the police academy and I said, ‘wouldn’t you like to see him graduate, wouldn’t
you like to see him get married’ and eventually she realized she really did have
something to live for,” Stevens says.Hall, a bookkeeper and a single
mother, agreed to have radiotherapy and chemotherapy. Within months, Stevens
says her tumor “just melted away.” “She’s still alive 17 years later
with no evidence of any recurrence of the cancer and one of her favourite
phrases is ‘it’s great to be alive’,” he says.Hall’s unusual story
turned Stevens from being merely an opponent of assisted suicide into an
activist against it. A professor emeritus and a former chair of the
Department of Radiation Oncology at the Oregon Health & Sciences University
in Portland, he has treated thousands of patients with cancer.He
says he came to oppose assisted suicide from his observations as a doctor,
rather than from any religious standpoint.“Actually, my first wife died
35 years ago of cancer so I’ve seen it not only from the professional side but
also from the family side,” he says. “I continue to be against because I
don’t feel that is the role of a doctor to kill a patient or to order them to
die.”Hall, now 72, no longer wants to speak to the media about her story
because of the attention it has garnered after it was co-opted by campaigners
against assisted suicide.

But several years ago she wrote of her
experience. “I did not want to suffer,” she wrote. “I wanted to do our law and I
wanted Dr Stevens to help me. Instead, he encouraged me to not give up and
ultimately I decided to fight the cancer. I had both chemotherapy and radiation.
I am so happy to be alive.” “If Dr. Stevens had believed in assisted
suicide, I would be dead. Assisted suicide should not be legal.”

When
Stevens read about Victoria’s proposed assisted suicide laws he wrote to The
Australian in a letter published this week.

“With the legalisation of
assisted suicide, Oregon’s health plan has been empowered to offer patients
suicide in lieu of treatments,’’ he wrote. “Don’t let legal assisted suicide
come to Victoria.”

Victorian politicians say they have closely followed
the Oregon model for the state’s voluntary assisted dying scheme, which will go
before the upper house for a final vote next week.

The scheme’s authors
say they were drawn to the Oregon model because after 20 years it was still
regarded internationally as one of the most conservative
schemes. Cameron Stewart is also US contributor for Sky News
Australia.