9 Eyeliners Not Worth Your Money

Why these eye makeup products made you march to the return counter

Physicians Formula Eye Definer Automatic Eye Pencil, $5.50 TotalBeauty.com average member rating: 3.8*
Grand offense: Smudges. "While this eye liner goes on well, it tends to be a tad heavy and smudges. The color was good, but I needed to set it with powder or it would smudge, even with the lightest application." -- Sherryjbry, TotalBeauty.com member