I found it terribly sad. The guy's obsession. His obvious talent that points to genius. Genius forfeited early. Me missing all of that until it is gone. Seeing you recognizing that genius all along. You being deprived of that way before I even noticed it gone. Your love, your loss, all youz guyz. It's sad.

In the end I recognize the tribute but this talented musician worked like a maniac to put together a piece that copies exactly what Freddy Mercury pulled out of his ass. No disrespect intended to either, I am certain it was harder to compose than ass-pulling but I'm trying to make a point over here about genius compared to regular talent plus obsession, and love and musical appreciation, and it making me sad.

Yes, and then the arc of watching this tribute. Same as everyone else, slow to accept and then, what?, oh, that's quite good.

...there's something missing that's so important that it's horrible to hear its absence...

What I notice missing is the vocal technique Mercury uses on the lyrics "Gotta leave you all behind and faaace the truth" and "But now I've gone and thrown it aaall away" where his voice kind of "burns".

I stayed on the arc at amazing. This tribute in no way says he's incapable of being original or a genius in his own right. He's simply demonstrating dedication, discipline, and talent. I don't think that diminishes him at all.

I sometimes write, play and record songs. They are not good to anyone else, but I'm amazed that I can even do it at all. I was born with no natural talent, and have done nothing to develop any since but play around for pure enjoyment.

I have nothing but envy for this kind of ability and dedication.

I doubt that most people we consider musical geniuses could do this.

In my experience it's much easier to perform your own music and make it sound right - who can say it's not.

Duplicating someone else's sound really well is very hard. This is about the best I've ever seen and with a very tough composition - one that has been tried by many.Most avoid trying to copy it, and just do their own version, which is much easier.

And this reminds me of what a great and original song it was in the first place. I remember when it was first released, and I've grow to like it more every year. Mercury was a special talent.

He did manage to bring out and give some slight but pleasant emphasis to details that were lost in the original mix. I'd prefer to see a reworking of the song where it's taken down to its bare bones and reimagined.

Was only able to make through about three minutes before I had to stop it. Mr. Castellano is obviously a talented musician, and maybe this will help him get more studio work, or whatever it is he does to put food on the table.

Back in 1976 Todd Rundgren released an album called "Faithful" -- one half or which was devoted to slavishly produced copies of his favorite 60s rock classics. While the work was superficially impressive, he still managed to wrangle all the soul out of the originals.

He's good! He loves what he's doing, and makes a great homage to a great piece of music.

For all those who essentially say "Freddy Mercury pulled this out of his ass"... Really? Do you really think Mercury had the production cojones to put this all together? No way. He was produced within an inch of his life: BR represents both the Zenith and Nadir of his talent.

No matter what you say, this guy rocks. Good for him for having fun with his talent and sharing it.

Several months ago when I first saw this recording (on Wimp I think) I couldn't listen to it all the way through, but I didn't think too much about it. Now, after this discussion, I still don't quite know what's missing. Call it soul for lack of a better word. It's certainly not the "cute" thing. Freddy Mercury was many things, but "cute" was not one of them.

He's at least a semi-pro musician and is currently a member of Blue Oyster Cult, so its not like he is just some fanboy. Apparently he was in some Queen-related competition and felt inspired to put this together.

His day job? He is a member of Blue Oyster Cult. He is a professional musician, and a pretty good one, at that.

I suspect that most of the criticism is coming from people who aren't musicians.

Real musicians who take their skills seriously will often perform (and record) studies of work by other musicians in order to improve their own technique. This is not so different from engaging in depth with the legal writings of influential jurists in order to improve one's own legal reasoning. YouTube is loaded with videos of musicians doing exactly this kind of thing, ranging from the unlistenable to the sublime.

Obviously, it is next to impossible for even the finest musician to rival Freddie Mercury and Queen when performing what is arguably their signature song, but what this guy did was very professional, very good from a technical perspective, and not creepy at all.

Okay, fine maybe the use of the Brian May guitar copy was a little creepy...