According to Life & Style, Catherine and Sean were spotted at a DWTS after-party, and they didn't exactly appear to be all lovey-dovey. A source says, "They sat side by side at a table at the back of the restaurant with some friends, but they hardly talked. Catherine was on her phone while Sean drank beer and palled around with some Dallas buddies. He was being very goofy, very frat boyish, and Catherine looked like she didn’t want to be there."

Uh-oh, frat boyish, huh? (That kinda behavior is never pretty.)

Advertisement

Or at least the frat daddy behavior I've witnessed in my lifetime hasn't been exactly endearing. (Loud, obnoxious, gross, and realllllly drunk is what immediately comes to mind.)

If this report is true, I don't blame Catherine one bit for being ticked off.

And then supposedly later on in the night, they were seen arguing again at The Sayers Club in L.A. A witness says, "Sean was trying to talk to her, but she didn’t want to hear it. She was fed up with him and rolled her eyes. Then she started crying, wiping her eyes and looking away from him."

(OMG. Say it isn't so!)

Couple these two instances with another report saying Sean and Catherine almost broke up back in January -- and you've got yourself a recipe for what is likely the beginning of the end for these two.

And I hate to say it, but none of us should really be surprised that the "trouble in paradise" rumors have already started. There is a clear pattern that most Bachelor and Bachelorette couples seem to follow after getting engaged on their respective seasons, and Sean and Catherine have obviously entered the "we're not on TV so now we can be ourselves and act like real people" phase.

Right after the engagement, couples find themselves in the midst of a media frenzy, so there's really no time for them to annoy each other.

But then things start to calm down just a tad, and they find themselves out and about like regular people -- and that's when the quirks come out. All the wacky stuff they didn't notice about each other on The Bachelor or Bachelorette suddenly becomes the only thing they see, and that's when they start questioning their decision and second guessing themselves.

It happened with Jake and Vienna. It happened with Brad and Emily. It happened with Emily and Jef. And now it's happening with Sean and Catherine.

And even though we're all rooting for them to beat the odds and make it to the altar, for some reason, I really don't have a good feeling about them. Something just seems "off," though I can't quite put my finger on it.

My prediction? They'll remain together for the duration of Dancing With the Stars -- but the TV wedding they've been getting everyone all excited about will never actually happen.

Do you believe the reports about Sean and Catherine fighting? Do you think they'll get married?