Maggie Conway has had it with big-city living; especially after her husband-to-be leaves her at the altar - literally! She moves to small-town Washington State, opens a toy store dedicated to expanding kids' imaginations...and meets Mark Nagle, proprietor of the local coffee shop. Mark's number one priority is his six-year-old niece, Holly, whose mother has passed away, leaving him caregiver-in-chief along with her two other uncles. Holly hasn't spoken a word since her mother died, and the three men try relentlessly to get her to speak. Is there room in Maggie and Mark's busy lives for romance? To be (in love) or not to be (in love) - that is the question!