Turkey, jailer of journalists, hedges bets on democracy

More reporters are jailed in Turkey than in any other
country in the world. According to CPJ's recent survey, at least 61 are imprisoned
directly for their work, representing the second biggest media
crackdown in the 27 years we have been documenting such records. (Only Turkey
itself has rivaled the extent of this crackdown, when it jailed 78
journalists in 1996.) In the country hailed as the model moderate Islamic
republic, how is this possible?

The fact is that Turkey abounds in contradictions too dangerous for the world to ignore. Yet a strong and democratic Turkey has never been more important than today, as the region is rocked by turmoil and violence. Achieving it is impossible without a free and fearless press.

Here are a few examples of the confusing and sometimes
disturbing political, social, and media
landscape I observed on a recent mission on behalf of CPJ. It is the third such mission I have
undertaken in the past decade and a half.
The country I found this time is booming. Ankara and Istanbul's skylines
are dotted with more construction cranes than elsewhere in Europe. Three
different ultra-high-tech trains zip me from Istanbul's Taksim Square to the Beyoğlu
quarter, filling my New Yorker's heart with public transport envy. On the surface, Ataturk's secular state seems
to have smoothly adjusted to rule under Recep
Tayyip Erdoğan's Islamic Justice and Development Party. I recall meeting
the then-rising politician and his wife a decade ago. My husband, Richard
Holbrooke, and I were surprised that this seemingly modern politician's wife wore
a headscarf and refused to shake Richard's hand. Today, Turkey's first lady is still wears a
headscarf, but now shakes men's hands. Veiled and unveiled women jostle each
other in roughly equal numbers on the subway. Giant billboards advertise chic
ways to wear the headscarf--the veil seems a non-issue.

Major intersections feature news kiosks with dozens of colorful
newspapers, in glaring contrast to U.S. cities, which can barely support one or
two major newspapers. The press corps itself is a rowdy
bunch, and the papers are salted with photos of curvaceous "personalities"
and irreverent cartoons. A recent one
depicted Erdoğan, asleep, a dream bubble
over his head in which the tomb of Kamal Ataturk, the country's revered
founder, is being turned into a shopping mall.

Beneath this shiny surface of a modernizing Islamic republic,
there are signs of a hedging of bets on democracy. If you want to find out just
how pervasive the country's security
apparatus is, try taking a picture of a government building. I did, in
Ankara the other day, and suddenly a scruffy youth in a t-shirt and ragged
jeans jumped in front of me and vigorously shook his head. I quickly put away
my camera, but he already had his walkie-talkie in hand.

The works of Orhan Pamuk, the country's Nobel Laureate, are
displayed in every bookstore in Istanbul.
And yet this national treasure was recently tried, convicted, and
sentenced for "unTurkishness." Pamuk referred to the mass killings by Turks of
Kurds and Armenians--two of the taboo
subjects in this land of increasingly limited free speech. "UnTurkishness"
is a crime--and an extremely elastic one. While the law is not always enforced,
it nonetheless instills fear and encourages self-censorship in some
journalists. In general, writing
about the PKK, the Kurdish separatist movement, can get you in trouble. And
yet, when Erdoğan assumed power, he vowed to reach out to the restive Kurdish
population. Instead, he has cracked down on them and on those who cover them.

For one and a half hours, Justice
Minister Sadullah Ergin stubbornly disputed our report on his country's jailed
journalists. A thick pile of notes in his hand, it was obvious that the minister
had studied our report carefully. Ergin refused, however, to address specific
cases, merely asserting that many of our "reporters" are terrorists in disguise.
He then reviewed Turkey's history of military coups: 1960, 1971, 1980, and 1982.
"My job is to keep the country secure," he insisted. "That is as important as
free speech." Listening to him, you could easily believe that this is a country
on the boil, not a regional powerhouse.

This being Turkey--a state with a split personality--the minister
concluded our meeting almost apologetically. "I am not always like this," he
said sheepishly. He said the upcoming constitutional reform of the anti-terror
law will improve matters for journalists. That is as close as he came to
admitting there is a problem here after all.

Sometimes it seems as if this emerging democracy hasn't
really thought through the process it has embarked on. Democratization here proceeds
in fits and starts: one-step forward, one step backward. The prime minster announced
that it is ok to criticize public figures, just not to insult them. But shortly thereafter, he compared the head
of the main opposition party to the "unlucky Bedouin," who, according to an off
color Turkish saying, "gets f___ed" in the desert by a polar bear. Not to be
outdone, his rival shoots back that Erdoğan knows a lot about deserts, having
spent so much time in the Syrian desert (a reference to the prime minister's controversial
role in opposing Syrian President Bashar al-Assad). The next day, the papers
are full of cartoons of this exchange, one depicting Erdoğan and his rival in
bed, a smiling polar bear between them. In this confusing environment, there
are no clear lines between free and "unTurkish" speech.

For journalists like Nedim
Şener and Ahmet Şık, none of this is a laughing matter. Both have served
time and are prepared
to be rearrested in connection with a vast conspiracy trial known as
Ergenekon. Meant to deal with Turkey's authoritarian past, the trial has now
devolved into one more way to bring the government's perceived foes to heel.
But the prime minister is wildly popular, and is expected to stay in power for
a long time to come. Though his supporters bridle at the comparison, Erdoğan
has chosen a Putin-like route to guarantee his political longevity, pushing legislation
to strengthen the ceremonial presidency, which he plans to fill once his term
as prime minster expires.

Erdoğan is supported by a population obsessed with the past,
now reaching back beyond Ataturk to the glory days of the Ottoman Empire, the
subject of a recent spate of books,
movies, and soap operas. Erdoğan's popularity is also fueled by the country's hard-core
nationalism,
which seems at odds with an emerging democracy.

But prison seems only to harden his critics' resolve. At a
reception in CPJ's honor hosted by American Ambassador Frank Ricciardone, I
meet a pink-cheeked, lanky young man who tells me he spent his second and third
wedding anniversaries in
a cell. Barış Terkoğlu,
of Odatv,
matter-of-factly predicts he will spend his fourth there too.

But the press is as divided
as the population. At the same gathering, pro-government reporters peppered me
with questions more hostile than any from the minister of justice. After I explained
that my involvement with press freedom originated in my early childhood when my
parents were jailed as spies for reporting the truth in Communist Hungary, one reporter
sharply asks, "Were your parents terrorists?" No, I answer, they were neither terrorists
nor spies, just reporters. The next day, this exchange is reported on the front
page of an independent daily.

So many impressive strides have been made here, and Turkey is
still the single best role model for a modern, prosperous, democratizing
Islamic nation. But the fact that the country's rulers often deem security and
free speech as mutually exclusive is disturbing. Turkey's friends have an
obligation to speak out, to voice the hard
truths that many of Turkey's own journalists face prison for speaking.

[Reporting from Ankara]

Kati Marton, an author of eight books, is a board member and former chair of the Committee to Protect Journalists.

Share

Turkey Crackdown Chronicle: Week of July 30, 2017

July 31, 2017 11:40 AM ET

News website censored for 57th time Turkish regulators blocked access to the leftist news website sendika.org for the 57th time yesterday, the website reported at its new address, sendika58.org. Three journalists jailed for reporting on arrest Police in the southeastern city of Gaziantep today arrested Metin Aybey, a columnist...

Turkey Crackdown Chronicle: Week of July 23, 2017

July 25, 2017 12:05 PM ET

Journalists to stand trial on charges of obtaining secret information Hatay's Second Court of Penal Peace yesterday ordered Dihaber journalist Erdoğan Alayumat jailed pending trial on charges "obtaining secret information of the Republic of Turkey with the means of political and military espionage" and ordered Nuri Akman released on...

A year after attempted coup in Turkey, media landscape purged of critical voices

July 13, 2017 11:30 AM ET

The history of modern Turkish politics is rife with military intervention--the army has toppled elected governments four times since Mustafa Kemal Atatürk founded the modern Turkish state in 1923, and has strong-armed them into submission countless other times. One of President Recep Tayyip Erdoğan's greatest accomplishments has been returning...

Turkey Crackdown Chronicle: Week of July 9, 2017

July 10, 2017 12:08 PM ET

Police detain two journalists Police in the southern Turkish province of Hatay detained Erdoğan Alayumat and Nuri Akman, two correspondents for the pro-Kurdish news website Dihaber last night as they worked, their employer reported today. Police detained them on a complaint that they were "suspicious," according to the report....