I decided to try this one after falling for Black Opal's Barely Wine lipstick. This has all the same positives: sheer color that can be built up, good staying power, no feathering/bleeding, moisturizing glossy texture, good packaging. Lipsticks tend to turn orangey on me (even sometimes pinky MLBBs), and unfortunately this was no exception. The color is a deep reddish caramel, and it would be lovely on someone who can wear that color well. On me it was the color of Kraft caramels, but with more orange. For reference, I am fair, neutral, dark green eyes, dark brown hair.