Sometimes classics are the best, but when it comes to peanut butter and jelly, there’s no wrong way to eat it. If you thought the only way to enjoy it was in sandwich form, well you were mistaken. These 12 recipes show you new takes on a classic— but they are sure to be just as good as the original.

For the kid in all of us, let’s find out how to implement some more PB&J into our diets, shall we?

Throw some fruit, peanut butter, orange juice and ice into a blender and you’ve got yourself a PB&J in drink form. Who knew that was even an option?

If you’re not craving these peanut butter and jelly concoctions now, oh, who am I kidding? I know you are! So, get in that kitchen and make yourself one (or more!) of these recipes. What’s great is that if you aren’t into peanut butter or have an allergy, all of these could surely be made with a peanut butter substitute like Nutella or almond butter. So what are you waiting for? Go enjoy more than just a sandwich with these classic flavors!