Janel and Tyler may play enemies on the show, but in real life they seem super tight. Check out this video of the two giggling co-stars from the “Keep a Secret” convention in Paris. In it, the moderator tells Tyler that before he came in the room, Janel admitted that he was a good kisser. An embarrassed Janel insists that “They asked me,” but Tyler seems to take it in stride, reminiscing about the infamous “car scene.”

“I think we both said to each other, ‘You’re a good kisser,’” Tyler tells the audience. “It’s because she has really nice big lips.” Oh la la!

“We actually did have that conversation,” Janel confirms. Seeing these two having so much fun together in real life makes us sad we never got to see their characters find common ground on PLL. Oh well. There’s always Ravenswood. We think Mona might be able to outwit a ghost or two, and Caleb could sure use the help.