What's with the spy plane over Compton?

Compton

Los Angeles Times

Ellen Harris, 67, a resident of Compton for the past 36 years, responds to reporter informing her that the L.A. County Sheriff's Department secretly conducted aerial surveillance of the entire city of Compton for nine days in 2012.

Ellen Harris, 67, a resident of Compton for the past 36 years, responds to reporter informing her that the L.A. County Sheriff's Department secretly conducted aerial surveillance of the entire city of Compton for nine days in 2012. (Los Angeles Times)

The most egregious thing about the Compton surveillance test: elected officials and residents weren't alerted

Citizens in a democracy need to be aware of their choices in order to make educated decisions

The recent revelation that the Los Angeles County Sheriff's Department secretly conducted aerial surveillance of the entire city of Compton for nine days in 2012 prompted outrage from the city's mayor, its residents and civil liberties groups.

A lot of people do have a problem with the eye in the sky, the Big Brother.- Sheriff's Dept. official

The Sheriff's Department justified the surveillance by saying it was only a brief test of a program provided by a private security company. A small, manned Cessna plane equipped with an array of cameras flew six hours a day and only in daylight, beaming video information back to the local sheriff's station. The video allowed sheriff's officials to go back and track images of several fender-benders, a series of necklace snatchings and a shooting. But the resolution was so bad that it was impossible to tell a man from a woman or a subcompact car from an SUV. So the Sheriff's Department decided not to continue the program. No arrests were made based on the surveillance, according to a department spokeswoman. Nor has the department kept the recordings, officials say.

The surveillance program was first disclosed by the nonprofit Center for Investigative Reporting.

These days, police have all sorts of increasingly sophisticated (or invasive, depending on how you see it) surveillance techniques to choose from, including manned aircraft, drones, GPS devices and cameras mounted outside buildings, and they raise complicated questions about how much privacy Americans may want to relinquish in pursuit of security. But one thing is certain: Citizens in a democracy need to be aware of their choices in order to make educated decisions. The most egregious thing about the Compton surveillance test was not that it was done but that the department chose not to tell Compton's elected officials or its residents about it ahead of time. The city of Lancaster also uses aerial surveillance, but at least officials and residents there have been informed.

One of the department's explanations for not telling people about the aerial surveillance program was that it already makes use of security cameras in Compton city parks and at the Gateway Town Center. But that's an insufficient justification for a program of such enormous breadth. Maybe citizens and officials would all have agreed that increased security was worth sending a camera-strapped Cessna flying over every inch of the city taking pictures of residents' backyard barbecues. But there are indications that the Sheriff's Department knew very well that people would not be happy with this. One department official involved with the project told the Center for Investigative Reporting that it was kept confidential to avoid complaints. "A lot of people do have a problem with the eye in the sky, the Big Brother," he said.

After learning this week of a nine-day aerial surveillance program conducted in 2012, Compton Mayor Aja Brown proposed a policy that would require authorities to notify the public before installing monitoring equipment.

What with all the vegetarians, vegans and flexitarians around, you might be surprised to learn that we now consume more animal protein than ever: 200 pounds per person in 2000, up some 40 pounds since the backyard barbecues of the 1950s. But no longer do we gorge on porterhouses, racks of lamb,...

Last fall, farmers working the flat land along the Colorado River outside Blythe, Calif., harvested a lucrative crop of oranges, lettuce and alfalfa from fields irrigated with river water. But that wasn't their only source of income. They made almost as much per acre from the seemingly dead squares...