If this is your first visit, be sure to
check out the FAQ by clicking the
link above. You may have to register
before you can post: click the register link above to proceed. To start viewing messages,
select the forum that you want to visit from the selection below.

Re: He talked if he were a millionaire

He talked as if he were a millionaire.
He talked as if he had been a millionaire.

Do the above two samples sound as right and good to you? If yes, are they the same in meaning? Thanks.

They sound fine to me. The first sentence refers to a man that is still a millionaire or at least talks like one. The second sentence refers to a man who perhaps once was a millionaire or at least talks as if he once was one.

Re: He talked if he were a millionaire

Originally Posted by Naamplao

They sound fine to me. The first sentence refers to a man that is still a millionaire or at least talks like one. The second sentence refers to a man who perhaps once was a millionaire or at least talks as if he once was one.

I don't mean to question your interpretation as I'm not a native speaker myself, but reading this sentence:

'' He talked as if he were a millionaire.''

I have a different impression.

Here's how I see it:

1. First of all, it's someone talking in the past (talked)
2. But in my opinion, the person here isn't a millionaire, but rather talks as if he was one.

Re: He talked if he were a millionaire

I don't mean to question your interpretation as I'm not a native speaker myself, but reading this sentence:

'' He talked as if he were a millionaire.''

I have a different impression.

Here's how I see it:

1. First of all, it's someone talking in the past (talked)
2. But in my opinion, the person here isn't a millionaire, but rather talks as if he was one.

This has effectively the same meaning as 'He talked as if he had been a millionaire' - that is 'He talked like a millionaire'.

If you want to make the past perfect version refer to a state that had actually been true at one stage, you need to add an adverb:

'He talked as if he had still been a millionaire.' [In this case he had indeed been a millionaire once, and still talked as if he was. You could convey a similar meaning with 'He talked as if he was/were still a millionaire', but the past perfect emphasizes the fact that the one-time millionaire had a change of fortune.]