Do you cake-like vanilla or flowery vanilla? Those are really the only 2 vanilla flavors in the hookah world. Af would be a cake-like vanilla. Very sweet and creamy, less on the extract side. AW and AAE vanilla for example are flowery, more towards the extract side, but some people dislike this flavor.

For me, Romman Vanilla is the best Vanilla i have tried to date. It's cake-like, but has a strong natural vanilla flavor