I signed up just for reddit gifts based on Wil Wheaton's post about his SS last year. Arbitrary Day was my first exchange and I was a total lurker. Never even bothered to read much on reddit. I sent my gift and three rematches.

I have been a rematcher on EVERY exchange.

I've given to people who were "real" redditors with years and badges and comments all over the place and got shafted on them posting their gifts.

So you wanting to ditch newbies? Not really going to help when there are oldtimers who are just dickish as newbies.