Utah man admits shooting, killing his father

Joseph Allen Nance, right, appears before the Second District Court in Farmington, Utah with his attorney Todd Utzinger Monday, SeJoseph Allen Nance appears before the Second District Court in Farmington, Utah Monday, September, 26, 2012. Nance is charged withJoseph Allen Nance appears before the Second District Court in Farmington, Utah Monday, September, 26, 2012. Nance is charged withJoseph Allen Nance appears before the Second District Court in Farmington, Utah Monday, September, 26, 2012. Nance is charged with

Joseph Allen Nance, right, appears before the Second District Court in Farmington, Utah with his attorney Todd Utzinger Monday, September, 26, 2012. Nance is charged with the shooting death of his father in a motel in Kaysville.(photo by Matthew Arden Hatfield)Joseph Allen Nance appears before the Second District Court in Farmington, Utah Monday, September, 26, 2012. Nance is charged with the shooting death of his father in a motel in Kaysville.(photo by Matthew Arden Hatfield)Joseph Allen Nance appears before the Second District Court in Farmington, Utah Monday, September, 26, 2012. Nance is charged with the shooting death of his father in a motel in Kaysville.(photo by Matthew Arden Hatfield)Joseph Allen Nance appears before the Second District Court in Farmington, Utah Monday, September, 26, 2012. Nance is charged with the shooting death of his father in a motel in Kaysville.(photo by Matthew Arden Hatfield)

This is an archived article that was published on sltrib.com in 2013, and information in the article may be outdated. It is provided only for personal research purposes and may not be reprinted.

A 30-year-old Roy man admitted Monday to shooting and killing his father two years ago at a Kaysville motel.

Joseph Allen Nance was originally charged in 2nd District Court with first-degree felony murder and being a restricted person in possession of a firearm, a third-degree felony, for the slaying of his father, 52-year-old Gregory Nance.

However, Nance accepted a plea deal Monday in which he pleaded guilty to a reduced count of second-degree felony manslaughter and to second-degree felony obstruction of justice.

He faces up to 15 years in prison on each count when he is sentenced May 20 by Judge John Morris.

Davis County Attorney Troy Rawlings said Monday afternoon that prosecutors will recommend to the judge that Nance serve the sentences consecutively, and they will recommend to the parole board that he serve all 30 years of his sentence.

Rawlings said the plea deal was offered because after his office reviewed the facts of the case, they felt a jury would likely have found Nance guilty on the lesser charge of manslaughter.

"We truly believe this is what a jury would have done," he said.

Rawlings said issues that played into the plea deal, including mental health issues and an imperfect self-defense claim that could have been used at trial, will be discussed during Nance's sentencing.

Nance killed his father at the Far West Motel, 410 N. Main St., on March 19, 2011.

Police have said the son confronted his father about a fight the older man had with Joseph Nance's mother.

"There was a domestic dispute between the suspect's parents," Kaysville police Capt. Brent Ward said at the time. "His mother and father were currently divorced, but they had been living together at a motel for the last month or two and had gotten into a domestic dispute."

Joseph Nance told police he shot his father in self-defense, according to court documents.

Police said that after Joseph Nance shot his father, he ran into a wooded area near the motel and was later picked up by some friends who did not know a shooting had occurred.

Officers found Nance hiding in a wooden bunker near Layton the next morning.