A number of key figures in leasehold were in the audience of the All Party Parliamentary Group and several asked questions.

Ground rent sale prices have risen ten-fold since 2007

David Thomas, CEO of Barratt Developments

David Thomas, CEO of Barratt Developments, says his group has built 900 leasehold houses in the Manchester area

In the North East and in the North West houses have traditionally been sold leasehold whether on the second hand market or new-build market.

Barrett’s practice has been to link ground rent with RPI and that has been our practice for a long period time.

In Manchester we sold 900 houses last year that were sold on a leasehold basis for around £200,000. The ground rent was slightly below £200 on an RPI basis.

The final point I would make is that ground rent whether it is £200 or £5,000 it is an asset class. What you have seen over the last seven or eight years is that while bank base rates have dropped to zero, ground rents have traded at significantly higher values.

So back in 2007, typically a ground rent would trade at around 10 times it annual value. So a £200 ground rent would trade for around £2,000.

Today ground rents would trade at around 40 times. So therefore that £2,000 would now be, say, £8,000.

£38,000 to buy out ground rents

Ground rents are worse for flats

Louie Burns explains that onerous ground rents are widespread in new-build London flats

Louie Burns, managing director of Leasehold Solutions

I just wanted to make the comment that although it is really good that we are recognising these issues with ground rents on leasehold houses, there is actually a much bigger problem which has been happening throughout the last ten years.

This is informal lease extension on leasehold flats which aim to do this very thing [of introducing onerous ground rent conditions].

They are a carrot on a stick. They are made to look as though the leaseholder is getting a deal [because an informal lease extension seems cheap and quick] but the implications are hugely damaging to the leaseholder.

On our estimation this is happening between 10,000 and 15,000 times a year on lease extensions.

There are vast swathes of flats in inner London that have signed up to these deals without understanding the future implications.

So it is a much, much bigger problem and it does not just affect houses.

Just today we have been contacted by a lady who was bullied into an informal lease extension at a vulnerable time in her life. She paid £13,000 for an informal lease extension.

Two years later she decided to get rid of the freeholder and she now has to pay the freeholder £38,000 just to buy out the onerous ground rent terms that were introduced.

This has £38,000 in just two years. So it is a much bigger problem that we are facing here.

Leasehold keeps on paying … in unfair conveyancing fees

Beth Rudolph, Conveyancing Association

Beth Rudolph, of the Conveyancing Association, says there are many more fees from leasehold than just ground rent

It was interesting hearing about this being a feudal system and the exercise control in leasehold, which resonates in another area of concern.

This is the increasing fees that are being charged by leasehold administrators in the sale process.

One of these is the certificate of compliance, which is to confirm that a deed of covenant has been entered into and is simply a construct of the lease administrator to raise money as of course the signed Deed is evidence in and of itself. They often charge hundreds of pounds and without this document being paid for, it actually blocks the ability of the leaseholder to register the purchase of the property at the Land Registry.

So it is actually depriving the leaseholder from their own asset and the security of registration.

These fees are another area that we do need to look at as it is not just ground rents that are fuelling this asset class it is also the unreasonable administration fees for which there is no redress scheme due to a loophole in the Commonhold and Leasehold Reform Act.

No ground rents = higher property prices?

I wholeheartedly agree with Philip Rainey that ground rents should be expunged and it would be quite easy to legislate.

Mr Rainey also said that developers have to profit somehow and that should come from sale price. So does he not envisage that if you expunge ground rents completely all developers will do is hike up sale prices?

So, for example, a flat that would currently cost £400,000 will then just be put on the market by the housebuilder for, say, £600,000.

How are you going to deal with that situation where you can stop developers from hiking up the price in order to make up for their lost ground rent investment?

[Both Philip Rainey and housebuilder Bob Bessell believed that the market would decide prices, rather than ground rent terms. Their answers are given in the reports of their speeches.]

We ‘won’ at Canary Riverside, but billionaire freeholder is running rings around the system

Some things have not been covered at this meeting. We have 999 year leases with no ground payable in a mixed-use development. We have had desperately poor management and we took the only route open to us which was a section 24 application [the appointment of a court appointed managing agent].

We won that application, but it does not feel as though we have won because the property tribunal cannot enforce its own decision. The landlord, a billionaire, is running rings around the legal system. So we feel that we have not won.

As leaseholders, we are the people who own our own homes … but somehow we don’t. I agree with my friend here who said that leaseholders are a cash cow.

Jim Fitzpatrick, MP commented: “This lady is a constituent of mine and with the greatest respect to everybody else in this room she is the most important person here.”

Time to act for leaseholders

Cherry Jones, Home from Home

I am a property manager I’m here to talk about leaseholders in Swindon

Large builders and developers are such an influential group. Many are making huge sums of money often at the expense of leaseholders. The government has no stomach to legislate to make changes.

Some property managers working with developers see poor old leaseholders simply as a cash machine.

The leaseholders do not appreciate that they’re being relieved of huge sums of money until it is too late

The time has come to do something. I’ve been attending these meetings for four years. I am urging people particularly in government to make the changes.

RTMs collapse

Maryanne Bowring, MD of Ringley Group

Maryanne Bowring, MD of Ringley Group property management, has found RTMs can fold

We have got a number a number of right to manage companies collapsing because RTM companies are not transferrable on sale.

So, ten people get super excited and do it and then after a few sales with the best will in the world you can cannot find people willing to be RTM directors. The costs of running the RTM should become service charge expenses, but that’s not allowed under the current legislation.

As people see good management, apathy sets in and new buyers and even existing owners opt out of the RTM to avoid paying the RTM costs. We have got sites where one poor person is left carrying almost £1,000 of expenses purely because RTM is not transferrable.

Samantha Cameron’s step-dad

Viscount Astor, step-father of Samantha Cameron and father of ground rent investor William Waldorf Astor, attended the All-Party Parliamentary Group meeting on leasehold reform.

Sadly, he did not share his thoughts at the meeting.

Lord Astor’s son Will, who worked for six years with mercurial, wrongly-arrested ex-tycoon Vincent Tchenguiz, runs Long Harbour, a fund of £700 million of residential freeholds. Adriatic Land freeholds are managed by him.

Lord Astor’s interest in land law has been limited to accusing Nicola Sturgeon and her SNP friends of staging “a Mugabe-style” land grab in wanting to place a million acres in Scotland public ownership by 2020. Edinburgh is also asking disobliging questions about landed estates owned offshore.

We were delighted to learn that he is concerned about unaffluent first-timer buyers burdened with doubling ground rents in Bolton, and reforming landlord and tenant law.

Contact LKP

The leasehold game is weighted against ordinary home-owning leaseholders, who aren’t professional players. LKP was set up to redress the balance, to help you win your disputes or at least avoid disasters.

If you have a leasehold problem, you can email sok@leaseholdknowledge or take a chance on calling 07808 328 230.

All Party Parliamentary Group

The Leasehold Knowledge Partnership was presented with a prestigious award by the All Party Parliamentary Group for leasehold and commonhold reform, which represents 171 MPs. Former housing minister Gavin Barwell, the current chief of staff of Number 10, was to have presented the award to Sebastian O’Kelly, LKP chief executive, and to Martin Boyd, the […]

By Harry Scoffin As the political arms race over leasehold and commonhold rages on, LKP is pleased to report that Boris Johnson has joined the All Party Parliamentary Group on leasehold reform. The decision by the presumptive prime minister to join the bipartisan caucus of parliamentarians is a coup for campaigners pushing for abolition of […]

Current number of members 167 + 11 friends Listed below are the members of the All Party Parliamentary Group looking into Leasehold and Commonhold reform in the new parliament. The list is updated as new members join and will be updated on this page throughout the parliament. Any member of parliament in the Commons or […]

UPDATING … A £200 million fund to remove Grenfell cladding from private blocks was announced this morning by Communities Secretary James Brokenshire on the BBCR4 Today programme. It can be heard at 07.10 here This action has been long predicted by LKP, believing that ministers’ appeals to freeholders and developers to “do the decent thing” […]

The Leasehold Advisory Service, the government funded Leasehold Advisory Service, has been under review by the government for much of the last ten years. This seems to suggest that something is wrong, yet the government’s long-standing support for the Leasehold Advisory Service continues. LKP has, after many requests, obtained the two most recent reviews of […]

By Sebastian OKelly, LKP trustee The controversial issues of ground rents and exit fees in retirement housing were discussed at this week’s meeting of the All Party Parliamentary Group on leasehold and commonhold reform. These were the main event in a meeting which also had an insider’s examination of leasehold insurance commissions, and why developers […]

Does the UK have the greediest, most venal and least competent housebuilders in the world? The Labour deputy leader Tom Watson joined the APPG on leasehold and commonhold reform yesterday, while the Communities Select Committee still has not called in the housebuilders. Mr Watson, the MP for West Bromwich East, joined on the prompting of […]

Labour MP for Ellesmere Port & Neston, Justin Madders has delayed the second reading of the Leasehold Reform Bill until October 26 2018. The Bill seeks to introduce a statutory formula for enfranchisement and lease extension similar to schemes in Northern Ireland and Scotland. It will end the incessant game-playing and revenues from the lease […]

We are all waiting for Sajid Javid The All Party Parliamentary Group on leasehold and commonhold reform met on December 6 at Westminster. Overshadowing all was the conclusion of Communities Secretary Sajid Javid’s report on “Tackling unfair practices in the leasehold market”: the review that he announced in the summer, that concluded in September, into […]

A fulsome denunciation of the present rip-off leasehold system has been made in the starkest Corbynista terms … by Tory MP Crispin Blunt, who represents leafy Reigate, in non-leasehold Surrey. He says: “Present-day “onerous ground rents” are, more likely than not, the resultant of unconscionable conduct carried out by one sector of society who have […]

An application for a backbench debate on leasehold issues is due to be heard on Tuesday 21st November 2017 http://www.parliament.uk/business/committees/committees-a-z/commons-select/backbench-business-committee/ The application asks the committee to consider: The APPG on leasehold and commonhold reform continues to grow and to date has 127 members. Government recently issued both a consultation and a call for evidence on […]

Thousands of homeowners on new build estates are facing escalating management charges for unadopted roads and patches of ground. Speculators are hoovering up these assets for the lucrative income streams, enforced through covenants on freehold houses and lease terms in leasehold properties. A campaign group called the HomeOwners’ Rights Network is asking the All Party […]

Self-regulation and codes of conduct have failed. Bring in commonhold and end the leasehold rip-offs. APPG pays “public tribute” to the work of LKP in revealing these abuses “LKP have helped hundreds of leaseholders keep their homes and continue to do so with very limited resources,” it says. Leasehold Sector ‘cannot be trusted’ All Party […]

Ground rents should simply be banned; commonhold introduced and made compulsory; developers should be summoned for ‘Philip Green’ shaming by select committees; and rip-off ‘fleasehold’ permission fees should be ended. These were issues discussed at a standing-room only meeting of All Party Parliamentary Group on leasehold and commonhold on Monday, that attracted more than 100 […]

The Commons library has done a superb job of spelling out the problems of leasehold. It is the first time we have seen a third party report into this sector with no regard to the disingenuous interventions from self-interested professionals, trade bodies, dubious “stakeholders” or compromised quangos. Its report, published yesterday and written by Wendy […]

… and MPs says profiteering freeholders will be treated ‘like Philip Green’ … LKP patrons call for another Commons debate on leasehold Mortgage lenders and conveyancers yesterday told MPs in the All Party Parliamentary Group that leasehold is in desperate need of legislative reform. The cautious Council of Mortgage Lenders, now renamed UK Finance, spoke […]

The All Party Parliamentary Group on leasehold reform today calls for leasehold houses to be banned and for end to onerous ground rents. It can be read here This follows the work of the APPG and its secretariat the Leasehold Knowledge Partnership in exposing the scandal of leasehold houses. Today, Taylor Wimpey undertook to spend […]

In the House of Commons today one of the latest members of the leasehold reform APPG spoke passionately about the scandal of leasehold houses. MP for South West Bedfordshire, Andrew Selous, raised the unacceptable practice of large developers buying freehold land on which they then sell houses on a leasehold basis. This is currently taking […]

The Commons debate on leasehold reform took place after the intervention of LKP patrons Jim Fitzpatrick and Sir Peter Bottomley. The debate can be seen here: http://www.parliamentlive.tv/Event/Index/fc53bd87-8abf-4986-b7ce-6a7a488b8cfc The debate can be read here: https://hansard.parliament.uk/commons/2016-12-20/debates/4F15110B-F6D5-4FA1-9154-536BD848130E/LeaseholdAndCommonholdReform The catalyst was the scandal of Taylor Wimpey selling homes between 2007-2011 with doubling ground rents and then selling the freeholds […]

Taylor Wimpey has undertaken to cease building revenue generating leasehold houses from January 1. The announcement comes in a letter to LKP MP patrons Jim Fitzpatrick and Sir Peter Bottomley, and was made before the All Party Parliamentary Group meeting last Wednesday. Taylor Wimpey says that it sold leasehold houses in the North West, a […]

Commons debate leasehold. Tuesday December 20 The case made for the debate by Jim Fitzpatrick and Sir Peter Bottomley can be watched on parliament’s own TV here: http://parliamentlive.tv/event/index/5069cc08-aeee-4451-93d8-fef9b0802407?in=14:31:10 The Commons library briefing on the debate is here: http://researchbriefings.parliament.uk/ResearchBriefing/Summary/CDP-2016-0253

… and Taylor Wimpey backs down on building more leasehold houses More than 70 stakeholders, MPs and peers attended last night’s meeting of the All Party Parliamentary Group on leasehold reform. The meeting, chaired by Jim Fitzpatrick (Labour, Poplar and Limehouse), was called at short notice following the upsurge of anger at Taylor Wimpey. The […]

The first speaker at the APPG was Patrick Collinson, Money editor, at the Guardian, who has been campaigning with this story over the past month and half. Although Mr Collinson kindly acknowledged the activities of LKP, he was first alerted to doubling rents by his 90-year-old father. The latter was advising Mr Collinson’s brother on […]

Bob Bessell, founder of retirement housebuilder Retirement Security, told the All Party Parliamentary Group that he has never charged ground rents. His company, based in Stratford on Avon and founded in 1985, has built 1,600 retirement flats around the country at 30 sites. “I started as a social worker and I had to invent things […]

One of the leading barristers in landlord and tenant law questioned the purpose of ground rents and urged legislators to be bold in the wholescale reform of leasehold law. Philip Rainey QC, addressing the All Party Parliamentary Group meeting on December 14, quoted his historically minded colleague Philip Wood, whose book “The fall of the […]

The All-Party Parliamentary Group on leasehold and commonhold reform invited Peter Wells, of the Open Data Institute to address the meeting on December 14 2016. The Leasehold Knowledge Partnership had been accepted as an accelerated start-up by the ODI. Peter’s speech in full: Hello, thank you for inviting me. I’m from the Open Data Institute […]

LKP’s patron MPs Jim Fitzpatrick and Sir Peter Bottomley have secured a three-hour Commons debate next Tuesday (December 20) to discuss reforming leasehold tenure. It is the first full-on debate over leasehold issues since the debates that led to the 2002 Commonhold and Leasehold Reform Act. The MPs made the announcement to the All Party […]

Labour MP Justin Madders has demanded a ban on the building of leasehold houses where there is no justification for them. Leasehold houses have proliferated as housebuilders exploit the housing crisis to make extra revenues by selling off the freeholds, often to shady investors based overseas who hide behind nominee directors. Worse, some housebuilders – […]

This afternoon Pete Redfern the CEO of Taylor Wimpey has responded to the All Party Parliamentary Group on leasehold reform saying that the issue of homeowners with doubling ground rents is under “review”. Mr Redfern’s full letter is below. He points out that the doubling ground rent leases, which LKP is aware apply to leasehold […]

Sir Peter Bottomley (right) has demanded that Taylor Wimpey explain its “unfair ground rent” provisions to the All Party Parliamentary Group on leasehold reform. Yesterday he told fellow MPs at the APPG meeting chaired by Jim Fitzpatrick, Labour MP for Poplar and Limehouse: “The ground rent increase may have been legal. It is clearly undesirable. […]

This morning Pete Redfern, Taylor Wimpey CEO, was on the Today programme (BBC Radio 4) discussing the housing crisis. This afternoon MPs are demanding he explain a housing crisis of Taylor Wimpey’s own making: building leasehold houses and flats where ground rents double every ten years. This has left first-time buyers with homes that they […]