On Arab(-Canadian)s and Canada Day

On July 4, the Vancouver branch of No One is Illegal, Canada’s foremost immigrant and refugee rights group, will be holding a Movie Marathon Madness event. Films to be screened at the event include Home Feeling: Struggle for a Community, about Toronto’s Jane and Finch neighbourhood; You are on Indian Land, about the 1969 protest by Mohawk Indians against violations of the Jay Treaty by Immigration and Customs officers; and Brown Women Blonde Babies, about the thousands of Filipina women who work in Canada as domestic workers.

In its entirety, the event schedule showcases the gamut of oppressive realities that mark Canada’s history and contemporary existence. They cover topics as varied as the ongoing systemic racism targeted at working-class African-Canadians, the WWII internment of Japanese-Canadians in British Columbia, and current intersections of sexuality and immigration policies. On Canada Day, when we are asked to congratulate ourselves on how well we treat our ethnics, screenings like these expose the lived realities of marginalised peoples across Canada. These are realities that resist reduction into easy parades of colourful clothing and exotic foods. This is not a diversity of commodifiable cultures, but a diversity of class positions, gender performances, linguistic practices, and race identifications. This is a diversity of privileges and discriminations. In discussing them in public spaces, we highlight the many injustices that are enacted on a daily and systemic basis in Canada by the Canadian nation-state.

What I’m saying here is simple: for many of us, it is difficult to celebrate the creation of a state that was founded on the theft of territory from its indigenous inhabitants, a state that has continued to refuse to address in any meaningful way that inaugural violence. For many of us, constructions of Canada as a nation of polite peacemakers ring hollow, because we know too well the myriad and systemic ways by which Canada oppresses its indigenous peoples, its migrant labourers, and its racialised poor, among others.

What I’m saying is simple: it’s July here in Toronto as I write this, summer has finally broken, and I’m enjoying the day off from work, but I have no flags to wave.

Meanwhile, media darling Tarek Fatah has a post on his blog entitled “An Arab Canadian’s way of celebrating Canada Day.” The approximately 300-word long post can be split into three basic sections. Only a few sentences have anything to do at all with the titular Arab-Canadian, Omar Shaban, who Fatak singled out for attention for having a Facebook status on the morning of July 1 that read “Happy Genocide Day Canada.” The rest of the post – approximately two-thirds of it – is about comments that Fatak claims Ali Mallah, VP Ontario of the Canadian Arab Federation, made on “a Muslim cable TV show” in which Mallah said the election of Iranian President Mahmoud Ahmedinejad was valid. Fatah fails to give the name of this show or the date of this episode. Nor does he specify if Mallah was speaking in an official capacity. Needless to say, Fatah also fails to note that the election results and discussions about Western involvement are arguments currently raging across the world, including in Canada by Canadians (who aren’t Arab). Fatah adds some visual oomph to his post with screenshots of Shaban’s Facebook page, including a pixelated photograph of Shaban in a ghutrah. It’s worth noting that this photograph is not Shaban’s profile picture, which means Fatah must have clicked around to find it. The post closes with a screencap from the CAF website showing the names of its Executive Committee, of whom Shaban is VP West. In short, there is very little of any substance in Fatah’s post, primarily because he provides almost no commentary at all, but it is valuable as an instructive example of sloppy and xenophobic citizen “journalism.”

To begin with, there’s the issue of post’s title and subtitle, which are “An Arab Canadian’s way of celebrating Canada Day” and “As Canadians celebrate their country’s birthday, Canadian Arab Federation VP says, ‘F**k Canada Day,’” respectively. Were Fatah so offended on behalf of the upstanding citizens of Canada (of whom, according to Fatah, Shaban is apparently not one) that he felt compelled to devote an entire blog post to criticizing Shaban, one imagines he’d have actually done so. That is, one imagines he’d have actually written a blog post on how misguided Shaban’s politics are. But this Fatah does not do. Instead, he barrels right along without so much as a by-your-leave into a criticism of Mallah. Apparently, one Arab-Canadian can stand in for the next, the implication being that, after all, they’re all the same: not really Canadian.

I don’t know about the rest of Canada, but I’m insulted on behalf of my intelligence.

But in presenting Shaban and Mullah as interchangeable, Fatah isn’t only making a comment about Arab(-Canadian)s or CAF. He is also collapsing all critique of Canadian oppression with support for Iranian oppression. I’m not sure how one makes that leap in logic, but Fatah manages to do it without the slightest assistance or provocation.

Nor does Fatah have anything to say about the CAF as an organisation. He leaves all that to the imaginations of his readers who, with few exceptions, are only too happy to chorus “go back home.” Happy Canada Day to you, too.

But who exactly are the Canadians who, according to Fatah, are en-masse celebrating Canada Day? Certainly they aren’t the survivors of Canada’s residential schools, who have spent years trying to hold the Canadian government responsible for the mass murder and rape of indigenous children. On June 11, 2009, a group of indigenous elders released the following statement: “A year ago, ‘Prime Minister’ Steven Harper exonerated his government and these churches with a hollow ‘apology’ that released them from any responsibility for their murder of our children. Today, we declare that these institutions are not absolved from their guilt, or their liability, for their murder of our people.”
Perhaps these insufficiently grateful denizens should also be sent back home? … Oh, wait.

So, to extrapolate from Fatah’s article, to be Canadian is to refuse to acknowledge that Canada is deeply invested in oppressive policies at home and abroad. Yet there are many of us who, for a variety of reasons, claim ownership of Canada, and who, as a result, feel it is ethically incumbent on us that we recognise and resist the oppressions that Fatah totally elides in his post. In other words, it is because we are residents and/or citizens of Canadian that we are opposed to mindless displays of nationalism. Home is not for us the hollow utopia that Fatah has constructed, but a deeply contested space. Thus, at the same time that we resist oppressions that marginalise us, we resist oppressions carried out against others in our names by the Canadian government. This too is a practice of citizenship, but perhaps one more self-aware than what Fatah prefers.

I would not dignify someone like Tarek Fatah with any respond about his lies and ill spirited rush to please his masters.

No doubts that there are important discussion taking place re: Iran, some of this discussion is very genuine and based on the desire to understand what is going on, while the rest is based on political agenda driven by USA and western governments aided by corporate media. The same corporate media that were golfing in pleasure and sheer excitement when embedded with USA forces and its allies in illegally invading Iraq and causing the death of hundreds of thousands iraqis, displacing of millions and permenantly injuring many dozens of thousands as well. The same could be said about Afghanistan.

While the people of Iran and everywhere have the full rights to decide for themselves, we in the outside, must exercise a fair and objective approach when reacting to what is taking place.

It is no secrets that G.W. Bush has approved a plan tapped at cost of more than 400 Million Dollars to infiltrate Iran and create havoc and instability over there in order to topple the Iranian regime. Check most recent article here.
“Iran and Washington’s Hidden Hand”http://www.counterpunch.org/alamin06302009.html
And here:”U.S. Funding Armed Groups to Overthrow Iranian Govt. “Interview with Reese Erlich”http://ipsnews.net/news.asp?idnews=36961

It is also interesting to note that when talking about Iranian youth, western TV don’t show the pictures of Hundreds of thousands of Iranians ( majority are youth) demonstrating for Nejad, even the BBC had to retract and apologize when it aired images of huge rally and referred to it as opposition rally.

Now, when it comes to Western Corporate Media and governments, The hypocrisy is beyond appalling. You could easily spot their Islamphobic views, Racism, Ignorance, Stereotypes and all kind of lies and deception.

There is an old say” if live in a glass house, don’t through stones at others”. Well, Here in Canada, when the three opposition parties agreed to exercise their democratic rights and topple the Harper’s minority Government (No insane person could argue against the facts that these 3 parties has the higher number of MPs and the total populace votes), An unelected G.G and a PM of a tiny minority shut down parliament and hijacked democracy. Where is the outrage? and where were they when G.W. Bush stole the 2004 election?

How about Canada, USA, western Europ and their support to israel. an Occupier and oppressive entity or have they took a clear position on the Palestinian question and the latest brutal massacres of more than 1400 Palestinians in late Dec. 08 and into Jan. 09?

When Hamas was elected by the majority of Palestinians, Canada was the first country to punish them for their “democratic choice” and almost all western media and governments boycotted Palestine.

Or, If the opposition in Lebanon who got close to 200.000 more votes than Pro-western group but still lost the election due to a back-warded seats distribution that was put in place during and after the French mandate (occupation in Lebanon) rejected the results of that election and descended to the streets in protest, would the USA, Canada and Western Gov. and Corporate Media, extend any support? God forbid, I must be hallucinating! No all deomcratic elections are the same, only the ones that produced followers of USA and the west will be accepted and supported!

Oh, I forgot, it is always the white’s man and women’s burden to liberate the rest of world

* Above are my own personal views and do not reflect CAF and or any other group that I am associated with.