why do you say not as complete? is he a liability in the passing game?

Ronnie is terrific out of the backfield catching the football, is probably the best block-picker-upper in the league, and falls forward more often than Tate does.

How is Tate in the passing game? I hope he can catch because all the video I see on him is purely running the ball which he does well. Don't get me wrong I love Ronnie Brown but my knock on him was once he got through the first wave of tacklers he went down, he couldn't take it to the house like Peterson, DeAngelo Williams or Jones Drew or LT just a few years ago. I love explosion in a back and Ronnie never really had that.

He looks no faster then Ronnie. Sorry. Actually, I think Ronnie is faster. Remember this is Ben Tate running by College players.. Not pro players..

Watch Ronnie's College videos and then compare. They are close in speed. But, Ben Tate doesn't approach the physicality the Ronnie plays with. Ronnie punishes defenders. I hope we get to see a healthy Ronnie this year with Marshall on the team.

This is not Ronnie with speed. Just because he's from Auburn doesn't make him Ronnie. Ronnie has some impressive vision, great explosion and great hands. Tate has some decent hands, but when it comes to finding a hole, Tate doesn't have that. As far as finishing off a run, Tate doesn't have that. Tate is a 4th rounder while Brown was the 2nd overall pick.

He looks like a solid rb prospect. Maybe we could get him if we are able to make a deal on draft day and get that 3rd round pick for Smiley. If we manage to do that, then we could draft him and trade someone like Cobbs or Sheets. I would be pretty happy if we pulled that off.