Transcription

1 April 017 Why effective leaders must manage up, down, and sideways Strong team leadership isn t enough. New research shows the importance for business impact and career success of also mobilizing your boss and colleagues. by Thomas Barta and Patrick Barwise Most of the leadership advice aimed at senior functional managers is how to build, align, energize, and guide a world-class team. This is a challenging task in its own right, but we all know it isn t the whole story. Leaders, even those in the C-suite, must also extend their influence upward and horizontally. Organization theory suggests that managing upward and sideways is good for both the company and the individual leader s career: CEOs need the insights and pushback of trusted executives to help sharpen strategy. And complex modern organizations benefit when people engage with their peers across functional and business-unit boundaries to bring a range of perspectives and drive change and innovation. Our research confirms this theory, and then some. In a wide-ranging study of the leadership actions of chief marketing officers (CMOs) a good proxy, we believe, for the skills and behaviors of functional leaders in general we ve shown how managing the CEO and mobilizing colleagues increases business impact and career success. (For leadership research on another C-suite proxy, the CFO, see How functional leaders become CEOs, on McKinsey.com.) To test our hypothesis, we asked more than 1,00 senior

2 marketing executives from 71 countries about their perceived business impact (contribution to revenue and profit growth), their career success, and their characteristics against 96 variables. Using statistical techniques (explained below 1 ), we were able to relate to these outcomes the 96 variables (which included leadership behaviors, functional skills, personality traits, sociodemographic variables, and external factors, such as peoples fit with the company). We supplemented this research by analyzing existing 60-degree data on 7,9 marketing and nonmarketing leaders a total of 67,78 individual evaluations by these leaders bosses, peers, subordinates, and themselves. Our findings lend support to the notion that senior executives should pay more attention to mobilizing their bosses (managing upward) and functional colleagues (managing horizontally) (exhibit). Taken together, these upward and horizontal actions were about 50 percent more important than managing subordinates for business success (5 percent versus 0 percent) and well over twice as important for career success (7 percent versus 19 percent). Clearly, there s more to success than managing up and sideways: leading a high-performance functional team accounted for 0 percent of the explained variation in our CMOs business impact, and 19 percent for career success, and managing yourself accounted for the remaining variation. Mobilizing subordinates, in particular, is the base executives need to build from if they want to establish credibility with the CEO and with colleagues. The best executives build strong teams, relentlessly enhance team members skills, keep subordinates focused with objective performance measures, and establish an environment conducive to trust and loyalty. But they also do much more. Our model helped us identify the most important specific actions associated with managing upward and horizontally, and our 60-degree survey data confirmed that some of those actions receive less emphasis than they should. 1 For the main research, 1, senior marketers from a wide range of midsize and large companies in 16 different BB and BC industries rated, in confidence, how well 96 statements described them and their situation using a six-point scale (1 = not at all, 6 = very well). We then modeled the data using a neural-network-based, causal-analytics algorithm to estimate the network of causal relations among the 96 variables. Besides external factors such as the organizational context, the model revealed 1 sets of leadership behaviors that account for most of the explicable variance in these leaders business impact and career success. We used additional statistical techniques to reduce the 1 behaviors to four components: mobilizing your boss, colleagues, team, and self. See Thomas Barta and Patrick Barwise, The 1 Powers of a Marketing Leader: How to Succeed by Building Customer and Company Value, McGraw-Hill Education, September 016.

3 Exhibit Managing upward and horizontally can improve your business impact and career success. CMO example, relative share of explicable variation,¹ % Business impact of mobilizing your boss Returns orientation 1 Big-issue focus 10 Working with the best service 1 suppliers Walking the halls 1 colleagues Role modeling Storytelling 6 team 0 Team skills and composition 0 Performance management 6 Trust and confidence building Career success from mobilizing your Returns orientation Big-issue focus 10 boss 15 Working with the best service suppliers Walking the halls 1 colleagues Role modeling Storytelling 1 7 team 19 Team skills and composition 7 Performance management 9 Trust and confidence building 1 CMO = chief marketing officer; share for mobilizing self not shown: business impact = 5%, career success = %. Mobilizing your boss: Focus on strategic issues and demonstrate financial results When we asked CMOs about their primary role, some responded that they ran the marketing organization or led their companies advertising and brand campaigns. We believe many other functional leaders would provide similar departmentally focused responses. By contrast, the most effective and successful leaders in our study were more likely to describe their

4 primary role as increasing company growth or better outreach to customers to improve performance. We found that a key determinant of success was taking on the big issues, those in sync with the CEO s agenda and contributing to the company s overall performance. Aligning with the CEO s strategy explained 10 percent of CMO business impact and 10 percent of career success. But are functional leaders well aligned with the CEO s agenda? Seventy-six percent of our CMOs said yes but just 6 percent of the bosses in our 60-degree database believed their marketers knew where the organization was going. Many functional leaders, it seems, could and should better align with the top. Building a reputation as an effective user of resources also increases standing with the CEO. In our study, the ability to demonstrate returns explained 1 percent of CMO business impact and percent of career success. Here, we again found a gap: while 67 percent of our CMOs said they had a strong returns orientation, only 9 percent of C-suite executives in another study reported that marketing executives were delivering measurable return on investment for their expenditure. Mobilizing your colleagues: Forge strong ties with peers to build momentum If you want to build a movement within the company, lead from the front with an inspiring story to win the hearts and minds of colleagues, including those who don t report to you, and with a clear action plan to deliver tangible results. That can initiate a virtuous circle of internal recognition by energizing a cadre of early followers among colleagues. Our research suggests that leading from the front and having a strong narrative together explained nearly 10 percent of business impact and about 0 percent of career success. The ability to reach beyond the marketing silo to executives in areas such as IT and finance explained an additional 1 percent of the variation in both business impact and career success. Only 56 percent of CEOs, however, described their marketing leaders as role models who lead from the front, and only 61 percent of CMOs said they use their storytelling skills. Tellingly, while marketers are adept at telling stories that mobilize customers to buy their products, we find they are less likely to ply that strength internally, despite the importance of effective engagement with colleagues. Outside looking in: The CMO struggles to get in sync with the C-suite, Economist Intelligence Unit, 01.

5 Mobilizing horizontally means walking the halls, getting out of the office to share ideas with peers, listening to their concerns, and working jointly to attack strategic issues. In theory, leaders could do many of their interactions on video these days. But that s rarely inspiring. Instead, the best leaders connect directly with as many people as possible through town halls when they travel to local markets, and hunker down to help teams solve their biggest problems. Fortunately, the actions needed to mobilize the CEO and colleagues are often mutually reinforcing. For instance, moves by functional leaders to build support horizontally are often related to their simultaneous efforts to show tangible results and advance the organization s strategy. While CEOs rely on functional leaders ability to build high-performance teams, much more needs to be done to help these leaders extend their influence upward into the C-suite and horizontally across the organization. Happily, our work suggests that not only business impact but also career success redounds to those CMOs (and, we believe, functional leaders of all stripes) who can increase their span of leadership influence upward and across functions. Thomas Barta, CMO leadership talk with Diageo s Syl Saller: Life s too short for PowerPoint, Forbes, February, 017, forbes.com. Thomas Barta is a McKinsey alumnus and was a partner in the firm s Cologne office; Patrick Barwise is emeritus professor of management and marketing at London Business School. They are coauthors of the new leadership book The 1 Powers of a Marketing Leader: How to Succeed by Building Customer and Company Value (McGraw-Hill Education, September 016). Copyright 017 McKinsey & Company. All rights reserved. 5

HIRE MARKET SELL LEARN Small business Big ambitions Marketing Playbook for SMBs SMBs have the advantage of flexibility. Your business may be small, but your ambitions are huge. LinkedIn can help get you

COURSE CATALOG 2018 vadoinc.net Welcome Welcome to the Vado 2018 Course Catalog. Vado provides any organization or learner numerous opportunities to build the skills needed to lead and manage others, as

The Business-HR Alignment Action Plan If it s not about the business, it s not about the business Do we really need this kind of PUBLICITY? Our Bad Grades* 61% of HR leaders and 72% of business leaders

HR s Role in Culture Change FTI Consulting A Case Study April 2017 Culture is as critical as strategy and organization All three must be in sync How a company wins in a market Coherent Business Strategy

America s Workforce: A revealing account of what employees really think about today s workplace 2013 Leading the charge In recent years, tough economic times and an unsteady job market have made most people

#CFOPERFORMANCE Building Your Brand The Value of Reputation Your firm is looking to grow, but you re not sure of the next step. Traditional client referrals are no longer enough to keep ahead of the increasing

BUILDING CREDIBILITY Overview Topic Overview Being a credible business partner is critical to our ability to lead and develop trusted relationships, as well as to influence and deliver results. A key element

The Coaching Playbook Your Must-Have Game Plan for Maximizing Employee Performance CONTENTS Coaching Overview What is Coaching? Coaching Categories Coaching Relationships Who Can Be a Coach? Coaching Personas

Developing Yourself as a Strong Leader Jasmine Youssefzadeh, Founder filmanthropos TODAY S OBJECTIVES Introduce stepping-stones that lead to personal growth and development Inspire you to create your own

THE HR GUIDE TO IDENTIFYING HIGH-POTENTIALS What makes a high-potential? Quite possibly not what you think. The HR Guide to Identifying High-Potentials 1 If you agree people are your most valuable asset

KORN/FERRY INTERNATIONAL Navigating the Uncertain Road from CONTROLLER to CFO: The Leadership Imperative By Charles B. Eldridge and Kenneth R. Brousseau, Ph.D. As organizations of all sizes struggle to

The CMO s Role in Activating Corporate Messaging Inside the Business How marketing can cross organizational boundaries and bring the corporate story to life in the customer experience. As marketers begin

BUILDING MARKETING CAPABILITIES TO FUEL GROWTH BUILDING MARKETING CAPABILITIES TO FUEL GROWTH Of all strategic levers to drive competitive advantage, building marketing capability was identified in Marketing2020

A package full of change: An interview with Ian Andrews of Commonwealth Bank of Australia Operations July 2016 Christian Johnson Jonathan Michael A package full of change: An interview with Ian Andrews

Job Title: Location: Reports to: Major Donor Fundraising Manager MS National Centre, London Head of Partnership Fundraising Introduction to MS Society The MS Society is the UK s leading MS charity. Since

Secrets of the Masters: The Business Development Guide for Lawyers DAVID H. FREEMAN, J.D. PUBLISHED BY IN ASSOCIATION WITH Contents Executive summary... V About the author...ix Acknowledgements...XI Chapter

Guide How to attract and retain good employees How to attract and retain good employees Some of the most successful organisations are those that recognise that their employees are their most valuable assets,

National Programs Maximum Term 1 year, Full time Title: National Programs Team: Health Outcomes Position type: 1 year maximum term, full time Reports to: General, Health Outcomes Company: National Company

Manager Goal Setting Toolkit CEB HR Leadership Council For Midsized Companies A Framework for Member Conversations The mission of The Corporate Executive Board Company (CEB) and its affiliates is to unlock

2012 ceo, social media & leadership survey Foreword by Ann Charles, CEO BRANDfog In today s digital world, social media has become an increasingly important communications channel for building a connection

BRINGING MORE HUMANITY TO RECOGNITION, PERFORMANCE, AND LIFE AT WORK 2017 Survey Report EXECUTIVE SUMMARY Since Globoforce launched the WorkHuman movement, the concept of working human bringing more humanity

Chief marketing officers face many challenges today from the pressure to deliver results to the need to keep pace with the explosion of digital technologies and the dramatic changes in the way consumers

The Power of Personal Branding for Career Success Karen Wensley Why should you develop your Personal Brand? You already have a brand You may not know what it is It may not be accurate It may not be the

december 2016 Modern Selling MARKETING in the MICROSOFT DYNAMICS COMMUNITY this month s topic... modern selling Are people buying what you re selling? In today s modern selling world, what sort of process

The One Thing You Can Do to Radically Transform Your New Employee Orientation A popular ad tagline reminds us that you never have a second chance to make a first impression. And yet, for almost all employees

Differentiation The SunTrust Guide to Competitive Strategy 1 From the Expert: Differentiation and Its Role in Competitive Advantage Sales training consultant Bill Caskey explains what companies need to

DRAFT 01 Feb 2017 CEO Performance Planning and Review Process A good leader is not the person who does things right, but the person who finds the right things to do. Anthony T. Padovano, theologian and

thought paper getting the most out of the middle Why your middle and frontline managers are more important than ever - and how to make sure they succeed 03 introduction 04 what's changed and why 05 a shift

MGM RESORTS INTERNATIONAL LEADERSHIP COMPETENCIES Mission, Vision, Core Values and People Philosophy Our Mission MGM Resorts International is the leader in entertainment and hospitality - a diverse collection

Research Report: Forget about engagement; let s talk about great days at work May 2017 What does engagement mean? And what exactly does an engaged employee look like? There are many different conceptual

Our Second Century Begins ACCE Strategic Plan 2014-17 Preamble As ACCE s second century begins, we recognize that any plan we write is more likely to be about what you are doing than what we hope to do

McKinsey Global Survey results The secrets of successful organizational redesigns While large-scale change efforts have become common, few organizations get them right. Executives suggest that alignment,

Centering your business on customers ClearAction.com 1 877 236 7644 Experience Jenga by Lynn Hunsaker Do we manage customer experience strategy like playing Jenga? (Jenga is the game with a stack of blocks

An Executive s Guide to B2B Video Marketing 8 ways to make video work for your business [Video] Content Is King Companies that utilize video content to present their products and services can experience

PREVIEW GUIDE Make It Matter How to Make Yourself and Your Organization Essential Table of Contents: Sample Pages from Discussion Guide and Personal Branding Workbook...pgs. 2-7 Program Information and

REPRINT H02I7C PUBLISHED ON HBR.ORG NOVEMBER 20, 2015 ARTICLE CHANGE MANAGEMENT Getting Employees Excited About a New Direction by Douglas A. Ready CHANGE MANAGEMENT Getting Employees Excited About a New

G00276712 How to Create Successful Shared Services Using Northern Ireland's Enterprise Shared- Service Best Practices Published: 20 May 2015 Analyst(s): Simon Mingay, John Kost In this research, we provide

Bringing the Consumer in the Mix: Using Agent-Based Modeling to Power Marketing Mix Optimization informs New York Metro Chapter November 14 2012 The Marketplace is Changing Rapidly More diversity among

POSITION DESCRIPTION YAVAPAI BIG BROTHERS BIG SISTERS (YBBBS) CHIEF EXECUTIVE OFFICER The Board seeks an experienced executive to inspire, lead and strengthen YBBBS as it continues to support our youth

Our Second Century Begins ACCE Strategic Plan 2014-17 As ACCE s second century begins, we recognize that any plan we write is more likely to be about what you are doing than what we hope to do in coming

Managing Corporate Culture A SalesEquity.com White Paper INTRODUCTION To execute a business strategy successfully, executives frequently must change the ways their managers operate: the way they think,

It is important to note that this job description is a guide to the work you will initially be required to undertake. It may be changed from time to time to meet changing circumstances. It does not form

Managing reputation risk Laura Toni, Deloitte Romania November 28, 2014 Executive summary What is your company s reputation worth? According to a study by the World Economic Forum performed in 2012, on

The 2017 Retail Technology Report: An Analysis of Trends, Buying Behaviors and Future Opportunities Leveling the Playing Field in the Age of Amazon Radial delivers on the brand promises you make to your

The Age of Stewardship Welcome! We re together for 90 minutes During the presentation, there will be several Q & A s Email your comments and questions any time 2 Agenda 1. Imagine achieving a culture of

THINKING OF YOUR CAREER A A PHYICIT: CIENTIFIC REEARCH IN INDUTRY Dr. Frank L. Lederman October 17, 2012 2 Leading Assumption You want to make a significant change in the world. ignificant change requires

Job Title: Location: Reports to: Governance Manager MS National Centre, London Head of Governance Introduction to MS Society The MS Society is the UK s leading MS charity. Since 1953, we ve been providing

Reorganization The Credentialing Advisory Board proposed, and the Leadership Advisory and Executive Boards agreed, that the ICMA Practices should be organized as a narrative rather than a list. The following

Security s Role in Corporate Social Responsibility Greg Kane Originally Published in Security Magazine Last Updated December 2016 Security s Role in Corporate Social Responsibility Created by Greg Kane,

#CFOPERFORMANCE Getting It All Done Smarter Strategies for Today s CFO From managing core finance responsibilities to pursuing top-line growth opportunities, finance has more on its plate than ever before.

UNIVERSITY OF TEXAS AT AUSTIN EMPLOYEE ENGAGEMENT GUIDE WHAT IS THE SURVEY OF EMPLOYEE ENGAGEMENT? The Survey of Employee Engagement facilitated by the UT Austin Institute for Organizational Excellence,

Medallia Customer Experience Certification Practical guidance for your customer experience journey Whether you are just getting started on your customer experience journey or are looking to evaluate and

Six Degree People Thought Leadership THE 5 STAGES TO A SUSTAINABLE BUSINESS Six Degree People - Thought Leadership The 5 Stages to a Sustainable Business Six Degree People is a leading executive search

Digital Brand Strategy MKTG5605: Digital Brand & Product Management February 15, 2017 Discuss (20 minutes) From reading Building a Brand Online, what are some of the key takeaways? Carnival Cruise Line

LIKES ARE GREAT, LEADS ARE BETTER How to Grow Your Business Using Social Media Copyright 2016 Act-On Software Social Media is a Beautiful Thing It allows you to do three important activities: connect with

Coaching for Success Seminar April 2014 A Coaching Culture A Coaching Culture What is it? Why is it important? Explore values and beliefs Investing in the coaching relationship Advance the notion of self

EXECUTIVE SUMMARY In this paper, the focus will be on organizational culture, often defined as the social glue that keeps the organization together, and the transfer of cultural understanding in organizations.

Overcoming Mobile Measurement Challenges to Drive Sales Growth Published January 2017 Topics Mobile, Measurement Mobile has become an extension of consumers, and a critical tool in every marketer's toolkit.

McKinsey Global Survey results: Innovation and commercialization, 2010 After coping with the global economic crisis, companies are beginning to aim for growth again. But their approach to managing innovation