Into the DTV era, with no broadcast flag mandate

Today (June 12, 2009) marks the completion of the U.S. transition to digital television, as TV stations switch off their analog transmitters.

Just a few years ago, some broadcasters and movie studios argued that this transition couldn't happen without a DRM mandate -- a legal requirement for devices to obey the broadcast flag and apply DRM restrictions to free, over-the-air broadcasts. And they said they would hold up and obstruct this transition unless they got their way.

The DMCA has already been used to restrict the ability to produce innovative, useful products that copyright holders disapprove of. But at least the DMCA only applies to proprietary, encrypted media. The broadcast flag rule proposed to apply the same kinds of controls even to an open, unencrypted format, something Congress originally specifically declined to do with the DMCA. The broadcast flag concept threatened to give the entertainment industry a veto even over features of devices that want nothing to do with DRMed media. And it was just one in a series of technology mandates Hollywood was after; each one was meant to plug yet another "hole" in Hollywood's control of technology, including "holes" left behind by previous mandates.

We and our colleagues said no; we said that entertainment industries already have too much control over our living rooms. We went to the meetings where the broadcast flag was planned, we lobbied the FCC, and together with Public Knowledge, the American Library Association and other library associations, Consumers Union, and the Consumer Federation of America, we went to court to stop the broadcast flag mandate from becoming law. We won, ultimately succeeding in getting the FCC's broadcast flag mandate thrown out.

But while all this was happening, the entertainment industries made a series of dramatic threats. They said the DTV transition would suffer unless the mandate went through; they said they would pull programming off the air and not license movies for broadcast.

MPAA's Fritz Attaway said that "high-value content will migrate away" from television if the broadcast flag wasn't imposed; he told Congress that fears of infringement without a broadcast flag mandate "will lead content creators to cease making their high-value programming available for distribution over digital broadcast television [and] the DTV transition would be seriously threatened". Most famously, Viacom said that

[i]f a broadcast flag is not implemented and enforced by Summer 2003, Viacom's CBS Television Network will not provide any programming in high definition for the 2003-2004 television season.

It's six years later and these threats have all fallen flat. This week, CBS will broadcast dozens of popular programs, like CSI, Without a Trace, Survivor, and The New Adventures of Old Christine, in high definition via over-the-air broadcast. So will all the other major networks. Digital TV also continues to feature popular movies with no DRM.

Entertainment industries like to argue that they "need" DRM to make works available. And policymakers have eagerly adopted this argument. But when the bluff is called, it turns out that the DRM wasn't so necessary after all.

We're proud of our part in defeating the broadcast flag and we're grateful to all of our partners in that fight. We want to extend a special thanks to Public Knowledge and to Gigi Sohn and her staff, past and present, for the tremendous amount of work they've done on this issue, and to the legal team at Steptoe and Johnson for adroitly and effectively handling a complex court challenge to the FCC's ruling.

As we said all along, digital TV is more functional and the equipment to view it is cheaper and more available without the "compliance and robustness" requirements MPAA sought to impose. If you have a computer, the cheapest way to get digital TV broadcasts isn't to buy a fancy new TV. It's to get an innovative, inexpensive device to let your computer receive TV signals. Some of these devices stream TV over a LAN to a computer, some connect externallyvia USB, and some install inside a desktop case. It's cheaper than a new TV, it's convenient, and it's DRM free. Happy DTV transition!

Related Updates

EFF established that the FCC and Hollywood don't control your TiVo - you do. The FCC's "broadcast flag" mandate would have given copyright holders and the government a veto over development and use of digital television tuners. Only technologies crippled by copy protection would have been legal. The DC Circuit...

It's the dawn of a new year. From our perch on the frontier of electronic civil liberties, EFF has collected a list of a dozen important trends in law, technology and business that we think will play a significant role in shaping online rights in 2010. In December, we'll revisit...

Digital Video Recorders, once considered a mortal threat by the entertainment industry, have now become its new best friend. It's just the latest example of how the industry's constant warnings of the dangers of "piracy" frequently turn out to be baseless hysteria. Remember 2001? Digital Video Recorders ("DVRs") like TiVo...

The British MP Tom Watson has highlighted a digital TV consultation by UK regulator Ofcom, held in response to an inquiry from the BBC (the consultation deadline is this Wednesday): The BBC has indicated that third party content owners are seeking to ensure that reception equipment will implement...

In the absence of NBC or Microsoft coming clean about what they've done - what flags NBC sent, and what flags Microsoft obeys, we've been doing some detective work of our own -- and we'd like your help. NBC have already said that their activation of their copy-control system was...

After reports of Vista refusing to record select programming from NBC, online interest group The Electronic Frontier Foundation (EFF) says the same thing is happening for over-the-air (OTA) programming. One user has reported that while attempting to record TV shows from Raleigh's WNCN high definition channel -- the NBC affiliate...

The Electronic Frontier Foundation has begun investigating why Microsoft Vista Media Centers were blocked from recording two NBC Universal shows Monday night. The group, which advocates for Internet users, said indications are that NBC sent a "broadcast flag" that triggered the block. But Danny O'Brien, EFF's international outreach coordinator, said...

While its customers are still puzzling over why Vista Media Center is suddenly refusing to record over-the-air NBC digital TV, Microsoft has come out with an astounding admission, courtesy of Greg Sandoval at CNet News: "Microsoft included technologies in Windows based on rules set forth by the (Federal Communications...

After further investigation of reports of Vista refusing to record NBC, we have found at least one case where a user receiving digital TV over-the-air has been blocked from recording TV shows. Justin Sanders, who took this screenshot, says he was recording Raleigh's HDTV channel WNCN-DT1 on his...

Reports are coming in of digital video recording systems refusing to record NBC programs - both on digital cable and over-the-air transmissions. We're still investigating whether these involved over-the-air digital TV, which would mean that NBC was the first broadcaster to attempt to revive the abandoned ATSC...

The leading nonprofit defending digital privacy, free speech, and innovation.