This hardly qualifies as a shocker. Of course, I have gone on record as saying that I am not sure that one or both sides is entirely dedicated to the idea of getting an extension done. The Tigers might believe that extending Scherzer right after he won the Cy Young Award would be the ultimate case of buying high. They might believe that his price will be lower next winter. Or they might already know he's not going to fit into their budget, depending on what their long-term budget stands.

On the other hand, if you are Scherzer, why not wait? He could add to his resume with another outstanding season in 2014. Having multiple bidders always drives up the price. Also, doesn't it seem like the free-agent market gets better for players every day? (Homer Bailey just got a six-year deal worth more than $100 million even though he's never won more than 13 games in a season and has a career 4.25 ERA while pitching in the National League.)

So, will Scherzer and the Tigers agree on an extension this offseason? I say, "No." What do you say? Vote in the poll and post your thoughts in the comments section below.