His record previously included one pitching appearance for the 1885Cincinnati Red Stockings, also of the AA. This was likely the work of another player, a local player from Baltimore, MD hired to start one road game against the local Orioles - this man won the game in spite of allowing 9 runs (6 of them earned) in pitching a complete game. This person was long klnown only by the last name McCaffery, although he has now been identified as Bill McCaffrey, about whom nothing else is konwn.