Lac-Mégantic settlement only a fraction of what's needed, town says

Workers comb through debris after a train derailed Saturday, July 9, 2013 causing explosions of railway cars carrying crude oil in Lac-Megantic, Que. The funds earmarked for those affected by the Lac-Megantic train disaster represent just a fraction of what's needed, a town official says.Paul Chiasson / THE CANADIAN PRESS

The funds earmarked for those affected by the Lac-Mégantic train disaster represent just a fraction of what’s needed, a town official says.

As it stands, about $50 million is destined for relatives of the 47 people who died in the July 2013 disaster, although the amount could rise.

Given the magnitude of the tragedy, which also left the community’s downtown core a fire-ravaged mess, the town’s deputy mayor says what seems like a large sum of money isn’t very much.

“Two hundred million can seem like a lot of money but in my opinion, it’s very little,” Richard Michaud said in a phone interview Monday.

“Much more than $200 million has been injected by the federal and provincial government to decontaminate the devastated territory alone, and we’re not even talking about reconstruction.”

A runaway train hauling tanker cars loaded with volatile crude oil broke loose and barrelled into the town in the early morning hours of July 6, 2013, before derailing and exploding.

The families of the victims will share in the settlement money, which is “very little considering there are more than 20 orphans who must rebuild their lives,” Michaud said.

“It will help the families and the governments — but it’s not an astronomical sum.”

The settlement involves the Montreal Maine and Atlantic Canada Co., its insurance carrier, rail-car manufacturers and some oil producers. Three major companies have declined to participate — World Fuel Services, Canadian Pacific Railway and Irving Oil.

Much more than $200 million has been injected by the federal and provincial government to decontaminate the devastated territory alone, and we’re not even talking about reconstruction. — Deputy Mayor Richard Michaud

U.S. bankruptcy trustee Robert Keach is hoping the $200 million amount rises considerably before final approval of the plan in U.S. and Canadian courts.

Keach, a court-appointed trustee in the defunct railroad’s bankruptcy case in Maine, said the draft sets aside about $50 million of the $200 million pool for wrongful death claims, which could increase through a reallocation of the federal government’s share to as much as $57 million.

Up to $29 million could go to property damage, while another $19 million could go to bodily injury and moral damage claims, Keach said.

Those amounts reflect a possible reallocation of the federal government’s take.

As it currently stands, more than 52 per cent of the overall funds would go to provincial, federal and municipal governments. The formulas could change if the amount goes up.

“This is only a draft, so there are separate but parallel processes on both sides of the border,” Keach said. “The hope is we’ll have all the approval orders in place in early to mid-April so we could have a distribution in place by June or July.

New train tracks and the contaminated area at the train explosion site in Lac-Mégantic, 270 kilometres east of Montreal on Wednesday, December 4, 2013.

“We are hoping (the final amount) grows between now and then, but the deadline for it growing is going to be those final hearings,” he added.

The case was put off on Monday until mid-May by a judge in Sherbrooke.

Yannick Gagné, owner of the Musi-Café, a business that was destroyed and where the majority of the victims died, said money won’t bring back the lives lost but could help with the relaunch of the downtown.

Plenty more money will be required, however, to rebuild the town centre essentially from scratch, he said in an interview.

Reconstruction costs are significant and Gagné himself has taken out loans, used insurance money and paid out of pocket. He also spent seven months out of work.

“For many people, it was a difficult time financially,” said Gagné, whose café quietly reopened on Dec. 15. “The mayor said it best — that $200 million is not sufficient.

“We are a long way from what we need. And it’s not up to the population to pay for this tragedy.”

Lac-Mégantic Mayor Colette Roy Laroche said on the weekend the estimated cost of rebuilding the town is about $2 billion.