This restaurant's overall star value is determined by comparing its ratings against
those of other restaurants in the same city.

A teacher might call this grading on a curve. At Seamless, this means that regardless
of their actual tally, restaurants with the highest ratings will have five stars,
those with average ratings will have three, and the not-so-favorite restaurants
will have the least number of stars.

So pay it forward to the Seamless community. Rate and review places you've tried
so we can all find food happiness!

Please check back for future deals.

Reviews for Tony's Pizza, Pasta & Gyro

based on 40 ratings

Exceptional pizza. They don't skimp on the toppings. Everything is fresh, tasty and arrives hot. Lots of cheese, lots of combinations and inexpensive. Don't change! This is great pizza. I have yet to try their other food, the pizza distracts me. My favorite continues to be their spinach and mushroom pizza with garlic. I've also tried their Greek salad and buffalo chicken pizza. Delicious. The only place I order pizza from in the neighborhood.

Written by
rowan b.
on
3/2/2014
|
8 other reviews |
Member since
2012
rowan
ordered from here
within the last year

Good solid greasy food - decent prices and fair delivery. I ordered Hawaiian pizza, zeppolis and breaded shrimp and while I felt like a pig afterwards, Tonys gave me exactly what I expected ??

Written by
kimberly c.
on
12/20/2013
|
1 other review |
Member since
2010
kimberly
ordered from here
over a year ago

I've tried Tony's several times. Reason being I don't think once can be fairly judges since anyone can have a bad day. Well, Tony's is full of bad days. First off they consistently get your order wrong often causing you to pay for things (cheese, meatballs) that you didn't get. It has happened several times even after I put it in the special instructions. The meatball dishes aren't half bad but then I ordered some breaded chicken and it was horrific. It was burned and tough and once again, they didn't get the order right. Look anyone can get the order wrong here and there. But Tony's is a disaster. Next I will try Pizza Haven.

Written by
Pete R.
on
12/7/2013
|
1 other review |
Member since
2012
Pete
ordered from here
over a year ago

Love this pizza! The salads are really good too. Haven't tried much of the other food yet.

Written by
Andrea K.
on
12/3/2013
|
4 other reviews |
Member since
2013
Andrea
ordered from here
within the last year

okay, so. According to the angry on the phone, "a Margarita Pizza doesn't have no sauce" so if you order a Margarita Pizza from here it will not have sauce on it even if every Margarita Pizza you EVER ORDERED IN YOUR WHOLE LIFE had sauce on it.

Written by
Dustin C.
on
11/20/2013
|
12 other reviews |
Member since
2010
Dustin
ordered from here
over a year ago

I gave another pizza place on Seamless a bad review - so I should give props where they are due. Tonys is great. Good food and amazing service. I even once ordered a root beer of brand x, they called to say they only had brand y. Good folks.

Written by
Steven B.
on
11/2/2013
|
1 other review |
Member since
2013
Steven
ordered from here
within the last year

Tony's is consistently prompt and serves up decent enough pizza here in Inwood. However, on some orders, a pizza with fresh mozzarella actually arrives with ordinary mozzarella instead - a disappointing thing to discover on delivery.

Written by
Peter S.
on
9/21/2013
|
6 other reviews |
Member since
2011
Peter
ordered from here
over a year ago

I first tried Tony's Pizza about a month ago and I can't believe its taken me almost two years of living here to try the place. The pizza is delicious and they are generous with the toppings, and the price is very reasonable for the area. They always have my order ready to go in a flash and the staff is super friendly when I go in to pick it up. I would definitely recommend this to anyone who wants to do a night in.

Written by
Jared W.
on
8/1/2013
|
Member since
2013
Jared
ordered from here
within the last year

Pizza's okay, but don't ask for anything too complicated like a side of ranch. They don't pay attention. And the delivery people are completely clueless. I don't know why I still order here, when they've only gotten my order 100% right once.

Written by
Raymond W.
on
7/20/2013
|
1 other review |
Member since
2012
Raymond
ordered from here
over a year ago

Written by
Jon L.
on
4/30/2013
|
Member since
2008
Jon
ordered from here
over a year ago

I received a phone call to ask how my dinner was. That's a big plus as to why he got five stars out of five. The gyros were seasoned well. The dinner was not overly saturated with grease. The only difference between here and Astoria Greek was how the gyros were packaged. Otherwise, you will be pleased with authentic Greek. Enjoy!

Written by
Christopher V.
on
3/10/2013
|
Member since
2010
Christopher
ordered from here
over a year ago

Fast service, good pizza, Highly recommended!

Written by
Lasha T.
on
2/25/2013
|
Member since
2011
Lasha
ordered from here
over a year ago

I absolutely love Tony's! Best pizza in Uptown in my opinion. They've been in the game longer than those other guys. They staff is fast and consistent. Great quality and great prices.

Written by
Othello G.
on
2/24/2013
|
Member since
2013
Othello
ordered from here
over a year ago

Ordered a plain personal pizza with a soft drink. Everything went smoothly, or seamlessly :-P. The service was prompt, and delivery instructions were followed to the letter. The pizza i'd had before, as I live close by, so I knew what to expect. It was very good and cheesy, the way i like it! Will definitely be ordering again!! Good job Tony's!

Written by
Lester A.
on
8/30/2012
|
Member since
2012
Lester
ordered from here
over a year ago

I ordered the personal pizza (added eggplant) and garlic bread
Cons:
-took an hour to deliver
-WORST "Garlic Bread" I've ever had. It's like a baguette with sesame seeds all over, and the inside is covered with spoonfuls of herbs and crushed garlic. Also, it's mushy...not toasted at all.
Pros:
-the crust is on the thicker side (which I happen to like)
-overall it's not the worst pizza I've ever had and I would order the pizza again (the eggplant was delicious)
-good portions for the price

Written by
Liz W.
on
6/7/2012
|
8 other reviews |
Member since
2012
Liz
ordered from here
over a year ago