Wednesday, 30 December 2015

In a giant capability boost for the Indian
Navy, a naval warship today test-fired a new missile that can shoot down
incoming aerial threats --- such as aircraft and missiles --- whilst they are
still 70 kilometres away.

A defence ministry press release today
stated: “Adding a quantum jump in its air defence capability, INS Kolkata,
Indian Navy’s state of art, indigenous stealth destroyer, successfully test
fired the Long Range Surface to Air Missile (LR-SAM). Two missiles
were fired on 29th and 30th of December on high-speed targets, during
naval exercises being undertaken in the Arabian Sea.”

Israel Aerospace Industries (IAI) and
India’s Defence R&D Organisation (DRDO) have jointly developed the LR-SAM.
The Israelis call this cutting-edge missile system the Barak-8, while India
calls it the LR-SAM.

In earlier days, ship-to-ship battles were
fought with heavy-calibre guns, requiring warships to come within gun range of
each other. Once a shell was fired from a gun, there was no way of intercepting
it in mid-flight.

Guns have now been replaced with long-range,
anti-ship missiles, which are fired from submarines, ships or aircraft up to
150 kilometres away. Many of these, such as the US-made Harpoon II, are
extremely accurate, with sensors on the missile homing it unerringly onto its
target. They have a key vulnerability, though. Since a missile is bigger and
much slower that a gun shell, it can be detected at long ranges with radar, and
then shot down in mid-flight with another missile.

The LR-SAM detects and shoots down incoming
missiles and aircraft with a reliability that is said to exceed 95 per cent. DRDO
sources say there will be further tests to verify that the missile has been
integrated properly onto INS Kolkata.

Mechanics
of engagement

To engage an incoming missile or aircraft
at the maximum possible range, INS Kolkata’s on-board radar --- called the MF-STAR
(multi-function surveillance, tracking and acquisition radar) --- can detect it
while it is still 200 kilometres away.

After detecting the target in the recent
tests, the MF-STAR began tracking it, communicating its key parameters --- distance,
altitude, direction and velocity --- to INS Kolkata’s command centre in real
time.

Meanwhile the LR-SAM interceptor, located in
a vertical canister on the warship’s deck, began its pre-launch checks. Simultaneously,
the LR-SAM’s command system was generating engagement scenarios, calculating
the exact point where the outgoing missile would impact and destroy the
incoming target.

As INS Kolkata’s weapons officer gave the launch
command, the interceptor roared out of its canister, engulfing the deck in a
ball of fire. At the designated height, it switched to level flight, gained
supersonic speed, and streaked towards the incoming target, guided by the
MF-STAR over a data link.

About five-to-seven kilometres short of the
target, a seeker on the interceptor’s nose switched on, locking it onto the
target. To accelerate the interceptor, which was by now merely coasting, the
dual-pulse motor fired for a second time. This increased the interceptor’s
velocity up to Mach 5-7, enabling it to manoeuvre sharply in tandem with the
target’s evasive zigzags.

A few metres from the target, the
interceptor’s proximity fuse detonated its 23-kilo high-explosive warhead,
disrupting it and preventing it from reaching the Kolkata.

The DRDO termed the test a success,
although the “high-speed targets” that the LR-SAM shot down were significantly
slower than the actual threats it must counter. Simulated targets travel at
500-550 kilometres per hour (kmph), while the Harpoon anti-ship missile comes
in at about 865 kmph; and the Exocet missile at 1,150 kmph.

LR-SAM
origins

During the Kargil conflict of 1999, when
the navy was preparing for war, the admirals realised to their dismay that they
had no counter to the Pakistan Navy’s Harpoon anti-ship missiles. The bigger
and more sophisticated Indian warships, some costing half a billion dollars,
were vulnerable to being sunk by the Harpoon, which costs less than $2 million.
New Delhi approached Tel Aviv for an emergency procurement of the Barak
anti-missile missile, which tided over that crisis.

Pleased with the Barak, New Delhi and Tel
Aviv agreed in January 2006 to develop a 70-kilometre version of the Barak to counter
anti-ship missiles of the future. Given the navy’s “blue water” ambition to control
wide swathes of the Indian Ocean, a destroyer or frigate equipped with the LR-SAM
would not just protect itself; but also create a protected “air defence bubble”
for smaller warships in the flotilla.

India allocated Rs 2,606 crore to this
project, which includes Rs 1,700 crore for fitting three Kolkata-class
destroyers with the LR-SAM. The Israeli Navy made an equal commitment,
undertaking to fit the Barak-8 on its three Sa’ar corvettes.

The work share was divided, with 30 per
cent going to the DRDO, which was charged with developing the LR-SAM’s solid-fuel,
two-pulse propulsion motors. Israeli company, Rafael, has developed the rest of the interceptor missile. IAI has built the rest of the systems, including the sophisticated MF-STAR radar.

The delay in the LR-SAM of three-to-four
years has been caused mainly by the DRDO’s difficulties in building the
sophisticated two-pulse motor. Eventually, it succeeded in developing a stable
propellant for this purpose.

The
way ahead

After the LR-SAM is integrated on all three
Kolkata-class destroyers (Project 15-A); it will be built for another four
Project 15-B destroyers being constructed in Mazagon Dock Ltd, Mumbai (MDL);
and seven frigates that will begin construction in MDL and Garden Reach
Shipbuilders & Engineers, Kolkata (GRSE). The LR-SAM will also be installed
on INS Vikrant, the indigenous aircraft carrier being built in Kochi. It is
almost certain that several more warships would be equipped with the LR-SAM.

The manufacturing supply chain that is now
emerging includes several private sector companies, such as Godrej & Boyce,
and SEC. The LR-SAM system will be integrated at state-owned Bharat Dynamics
Ltd. DRDO officials say that indigenising numerous sub-systems will bring down
the cost of the system.

If Barak-8 has been tested against a 500 km/hr simulator then how can we have 95% confidence of its success against a Exocet missile which will fly at 1000+ km/hr?Will the next round of tests be conducted against a high velocity simulator?

Hello Ajai, I heard LCA is on it's way to Bahrain Airshow. What's your view on it's maiden debue outside of India whilst FOC is still pending. Do you consider this to be waste of resources or are there really any benefits in doing so.

@Ankit is asking the right question. Will the next round of tests be conducted against a high velocity simulator? How can the Barak-8 be trusted to perform against the best missile in PN's inventory without being tested at that speed?