The legendary band took to Maple Leaf Gardens on August 17, 1965 for just an hour. A woman with a ‘60s bob is pictured on the front page of that day’s afternoon edition. She’s being held by security staff, between the headline “Bewitched, bothered ... and Beatled: 300 girls swoon in 100-degree frenzy.”

The Beatles were back in town exactly a year later for a concert. A similar motif took over the next day’s front page, with the headline “Enter the Beatles … exit Beatlemania.” John Lennon also held a news conference that day to show support for American draft dodgers.