One possible suspect was found walking on Route 434 in the town of Vestal, just over a mile from the crime scene. New York State Police Major Brian Shortall said he was taken into custody without incident.

Police searched for a second suspect for several hours after the shooting. He was located and was being questioned by investigators.

Classes at Tioga Hills Elementary School, which is located just northeast of the crime scene, were canceled Thursday. Other schools in Tioga and Broome counties were locked down as a precaution as police searched for the other suspect.

Police on Dorothy Road in Apalachin after a fatal shooting on May 9, 2019. (Photo: Bob Joseph/WNBF News)