Mostly well-thought out analysis, mostly.

No Title Needed (Since I Originally Forgot One)

Most Valuable Player. What does it mean? Is someone “valuable” on a team that ultimately played poorly over the course of a 162 game season? Or is a lesser player more valuable on a team that reaches the postseason, even though his numbers are inferior to that of the kind of player that was first mentioned? Andre Dawson? Alex Rodriguez? Were they less valuable because they played on last place finishers? Maybe these players, or any players on bottom dwellers, should be evaluated on what they were individually, rather than what the team around them was made up of. “MVP” is not a clearly defined term, its meaning changes from one person to the next.

My perception states that the MVP should be the best player in the league. Because there is no smaller version of the award. There is no “Best Player” award. And I for one believe that no one player can lead a team to the postseason, or even come close. This isn’t basketball where a single player can have a much greater impact on the outcome. This is baseball, where a hitter steps into the batters box approximately four times a game, while making a few plays in the field. Where a starting pitcher throws once every five days. Where a great reliever throws only 70 or 80 innings a season. And this is a game where the most important defensive figure, the catcher, cannot be properly evaluated through metrics, at least not enough for me personally to feel comfortable evaluating what he truly accomplishes within a season. Trust me, it takes well more than a single player to make a baseball team good, or great. So should I really penalize Grady Sizemore for playing on a team that watched its components struggle early in the year, basically putting them out of contention? Because last season Sizemore was plenty capable of helping his team to October, and his numbers were not as good as they are this year. His team may not be playing for anything late in the season, but that doesn’t mean that his opponents are not. Point being, teams aren’t exclusively throwing pitchers that have no business being in the big leagues at Grady Sizemore, simply because HIS team is out of the race. His opponents are still competing, still trying to win…most of them anyway.

Jason Bay is another great example. Bay has been putting up good numbers his entire career, but never gained recognition from the voters because he played on a crummy team. Now all of a sudden, he is on a good team, with a great surrounding cast, and if he continues to play well in 2009 he will all of a sudden be MVP worthy. Is that fair? Or should voters just look past the team a player happens to be playing for. Jason Bay was good then, and he is good now. Sizemore was good last season, and is this season too.

Then there is the argument that some fans make, the one where games in September are more important than the ones in April. That is created by the fans. Every win is exactly the same. Just as in life, where everyone says to themselves, “Well if I had done things differently, than I wouldn’t be in this position.” Same goes in baseball (although with much less of a drastic effect), if they played well early, then September would come more easily to a team, whichever team. Just as if one didn’t do certain things in their life, they wouldn’t have to face those consequences later. Or if they DID do something early in life that aided them, and made their life easier in the future. I don’t want to sound completely negative, so I added in that last line.

That last paragraph was more for Dustin Pedroia, who is a serious MVP threat, but has really pushed himself into the discussion late in the season. Now, I don’t know who the MVP is, I haven’t decided and won’t decide until the season concludes. But I will include the entire body of work for an individual, with emphasis on each month equally. I will not put extra stress on September, and less on April. Pedroia is a good defensive second baseman, and has hit very well this season. And his tear coincides with the stellar play that the Red Sox are experiencing. But again, trust me, there is a lot of help there. A lot of talent to aid Pedroia in his goal, the postseason.

perhaps you should consider how a player performs in september–perhaps a situation will arise where almost every game becomes a must win and lets say a certain player who has been very good to great all year really steps it up a notch or two when his team really needs him. that would be my MVP.

But whether or not a game is considered a must win in september is set up by the other five months of the season. I feel that gets overlooked in the heat of the September races . People forget about the past games, because there is no reason to focus on those, yet they have the same mathematical value as the games in September, so I am going to count them all the same. I guess that is just the way I feel.

i dont forget about early losses–believe me–when you look at the last few yankee seasons you know i don’t. and i completely understand that the games count just the same–but just consider–down the stretch–you really might have a player who maybe puts a team on his back for a week or two and gets them into the playoffs. that’s my MVP—moreso than just a player who has played exceptionally well all year. i give the award to the most valuable player when the team needed him most.

i just don’t go for “best player” the award isn’t called “best player” i like the fact that the award title is somewhat vague and open to interpretation.

Meta

The following are trademarks or service marks of Major League Baseball entities and may be used only with permission of Major League Baseball Properties, Inc. or the relevant Major League Baseball entity: Major League, Major League Baseball, MLB, the silhouetted batter logo, World Series, National League, American League, Division Series, League Championship Series, All-Star Game, and the names, nicknames, logos, uniform designs, color combinations, and slogans designating the Major League Baseball clubs and entities, and their respective mascots, events and exhibitions.