As many who work in television know: Ratings may determines whether a show lives or dies, but it doesn’t always indicate whether a show is good or bad. Take, for instance, MSNBC’s All In with Chris Hayes.

The 8 p.m. show routinely rates poorly in the competitive time slot, especially against Fox’s primetime powerhouse The O’Reilly Factor. And we’ve reported multiple times that the show is among those being considered for the chopping block as MSNBC looks to revamp its image.