eBooks & Readers

Despite being a bit of a technophile, I have so far avoided eBooks and readers. However, given the pain of lugging half of the Dresden files around South East Asia last year I figured it was time to get on board before I go on holidays again.
I'm struggling with the array of choices though. First of all, ecosystem. I'm worried about flexibility if I lock in with one, particularly Amazon. I'm not a fan of DRM, and only really started buying music electronically when it was DRM free. The book industry doesn't seem to have gotten to that point yet, so there is a concern for me that I'm going to get lumped with books in a format which is redundant/unsupported in a few years.

Secondly, devices. I was thinking of buying a Nexus 7 (I'm heavily invested in the Google ecosystem) but am thinking that an e-ink screen and associated improved battery life are a better option for reading. Obviously I don't have the extra functionality associated with the tablet, but I'm wondering if I need it.

Finally cost of books. Looking at Google Play, Kindle Store and Kobo Whispers Under Ground was $16-18. I just bought the physical book for $7.30 from the Book Depository. Are eBooks consistently priced so high? I don't like the idea of starting to purchase them if it's going to cost me twice as much for books.

In the UK, ebooks are subject to VAT and as such can be a little more expensive than print books via Amazon, but the pricing tends not to be crazy.

As for DRM - most vendors use one or two types of DRM (can't tell you the kinds, though), but publishers are slowly starting to turn towards DRM-free. Tor US/UK recently went DRM-free (and I was not impressed by Tor UK's implementation), Baen have always(?) been DRM-free (and incredibly reasonably priced) via their Webscriptions service, which also encompasses some publishers like Night Shade Books, and I believe Angry Robot in the UK are also DRM-free, but don't sell in Kindle-supported formats (though do provide links to a programme to convert the files).

I've never felt too locked in with a Kindle, largely because the Kindle store has quite a lot of titles as it is, but publishers are working on their own methods of provision.

It's going to take a while for the situation to balance out - there's contracts to be resigned (I believe Bradbury's books became e-format because that was part of the new contract, so it was a compromise for him) and renegotiated, a market to rebalance and so on. But for the foreseeable future I think we're looking at a similar situation to the iPod and the music market. The Kindle will dominate for now, and how long that will be the case I don't know, but I reckon a few years at least.

I've had a Kobo (was OK) and now Kindle (heaps better, page turns much faster) and I think the e-ink screen is excellent for reading. From what I've read on the topic, the e-ink reader is the best format for reading books. But there's no backlighting so you need light if reading at night.

I agree with Loerwyn that with a Kindle and Amazon alone you're spoilt for choices. With regards to prices I've found generally they are similar (though like your example sometimes they're way out), but often go the other way too.

With regards to format, you really don't have any issues - there's free software such as Calibre that will convert files into any other format. DRM can be an issue sometimes, but there is also software that will easily strip it. I've bought a couple of DRM epub books from iTunes so had to strip the DRM and convert to mobi for my Kindle, but this took a couple of minutes.

As you mentioned, one of the key advantages is travel with an ereader, and the ease of storing multiple (and heavy!) books in one spot (I'm enjoying reading GRRM's Song of Fire and Ice series on mine).

In summary (and without knowing much about many other ereaders), I think you'd be fine with a Kindle.

As you mentioned, one of the key advantages is travel with an ereader, and the ease of storing multiple (and heavy!) books in one spot (I'm enjoying reading GRRM's Song of Fire and Ice series on mine).

Trust me. The portability is worth it. I bought a couriers bag specifically sized to take an ereader, wallet, passport, tickets etc. Much easier to get through the x-ray machine without having to empty pockets etc and on a 12 hour flight you don't have to disturb your neighbours by getting up to change books.

Thanks for the feedback so far everyone. At this stage I'm leaning towards a dedicated eReader rather than a tablet. The main question now is around whether I go for a Kindle or something else (Kobo?). It sounds as if using Calibre removes my concern about ecosystems, so at least that gives me the option of getting the best reader.

I am in a similar position - considering getting an eBook reader because of lack of space (if I kept all the books I bought over the years, I would rival a big library. Alas I keep having to sell off books to fit into my tiny apartment space). I am considering Amazon's Kindle.

I am in a similar position - considering getting an eBook reader because of lack of space (if I kept all the books I bought over the years, I would rival a big library. Alas I keep having to sell off books to fit into my tiny apartment space). I am considering Amazon's Kindle.

Anyone has NOT been happy with it?

Click to expand...

Depends on which version of the Kindle you get. I got the cheapest one and returned it. I read in bed at night, so I needed something I could read in the dark with. Plus, the cheap version ($79 at the time) doesn't have a touch screen and the clicky noise of turning the page bothered my husband as he tried to get to sleep. I ended up getting the Nook with Glowlight (and touch screen). I love it, but while trying to move over my Amazon ebook collection (I previous read using the Kindle app on my iPhone), I discovered what everyone was complaining about in regards to DRM. Some I could convert over to ePUB, some I couldn't. Just something to consider if you buy most of your books through Amazon.

Thank you - I did read through his review. This convinced me not to try jump through hoops to get one (I cannot buy the Paperwhite if I live in Canada). Still trying to decide between Amazon Touch or a Nook.... I see that he posted link to the Kobo as well, but it doesn't seem to be as popular as the other two.

I have a Kobo touch, had it for almost a year and I love it. I really like the eInk screen. I have not used a Kindel, but I imagine I would also like it based in the screen. If you can get to a Chapters or Indigo store you can test drive a Kobo for yourself.

I picked a Nook when I was looking for eReaders a year ago for the simple fact that B&N still has B&M stores, so I'd rather support them than throw more money to Amazon, where it disappears from my community completely.

The Chapters in my area have Kobos on display but they always seem to be broken - the buttons and screens are really unresponsive. Granted, people are pretty careless with floor models, but it made me doubt their durability!

B&N isn't in Canada so Amazon or B&N, so either way, money disappears from my community Going to try the Kindle, partly because I have been buying physical books through Amazon.ca for a long time and love the Amazon customer service.