The Experiment of Night: Jan Patočka on War, and a Christianity to Come

Martin Kočí

Abstract

In the wake of the present-day crises, social conflicts and growing divisions, Patočka's reflections on war and totalitarianism appear abiding. Moreover, the enigmatic language, which Patočka uses, especially in his late Heretical Essays, sounds provoking and paradoxical. This article elaborates on the hypothesis that Patočka's reflections provide us with something more than a historical analysis interpreting the wars of the 20th century, and the 20th century as a war. I will argue that Patočka finds an intrinsic link between modernity, as a particular mode of being, and war and totalitarianism as unavoidable consequences of such a mode of being. To describe this situation, Patočka puts forth the dialectic of the light of day and the darkness of night. Paradoxically, in a somewhat mystical turn, Patočka gives preference to the night as the driving force of transgressing modern logic and the defective mode of modern being which throws crowds to the hell-fire of modern warfare. Against this background, this paper will present an innovative reading of Patočka's reflections as a specific search for an adequate spiritual response to the discontents of modernity. I will suggest that the trajectory of Patočka's thought can be read through the lens of a particular philosophy of religion, even though Patočka never elaborated on this avenue explicitly. Thus, I will propose that Patočka's thought opens up the possibility of reconsidering a heretical idea of Christianity that is coming after Christianity.

De Warren, Nicolas. "The Gift of Eternity," in The New Yearbook for Phenomenology and Phenom-enological Philosophy, vol. XIV, "Religion, War and the Crisis of Modernity", A Special Issue Dedicated to the Philosophy of Jan Patočka, ed. by Ludger Hagedorn and James Dodd. London: Routledge, 2015. 161-180.

Patočka, Jan. The Natural World as a Philosophical Problem. Translated by Erika Abrams. Evans-ton: Northwestern University Press, 2016.

Patočka, Jan. "The Danger of Technicization in Science according to E. Husserl and the Essence of Technology according to M. Heidegger," in The New Yearbook for Phenomenology and Phe-nomenological Philosophy, vol. XIV, "Religion, War and the Crisis of Modernity", A Special Is-sue Dedicated to the Philosophy of Jan Patočka, 2015a. 13-22.

Patočka, Jan. "On Masaryk's Philosophy of Religion," in The New Yearbook for Phenomenology and Phenomenological Philosophy, vol. XIV, "Religion, War and the Crisis of Modernity", A Special Issue Dedicated to the Philosophy of Jan Patočka, 2015b. 95-135.

Patočka, Jan. "Life in Balance, Life in Amplitude" in Living in Problematicity. Edited by Eric Man-ton. Praha: Oikoymenh, 2007. 32-42.