Underwood couldn't resist laughing as the before-and-after shots of her appeared on screen. "I'm glad you're applauding, but I'm more worried about scaring the children," she told the audience. Underwood also joked that the producers had put the wrong picture in the "before" slot, replacing the one of her in makeup with one of Rev. Al Sharpton.To see the other hosts' hilarious responses to their make-unders, watch the video below.