User Reviews

Cafe Amore's

Posted by Jane L. on 12/25/2009

Pizza not recommended

My husband and I have had such a horrible experience in this place. We came in for a quick bite before the movies-and sure enough it was quick. The slices were cold and probably sitting there for quite some time. We ended up throwing out the food and left really fast. Needless to say,we`ll never return and suggest you stay away too.

Cafe Amore's

Posted by Anonymous on 07/25/2009

The Food is Poor, the Service is Poorer

The pizza is served lukewarm even if you ask for it hot. The cashier is less than helpful and you have to beg if you want more than 1 napkin. Worse, they charge you one dollar for EACH extra topping. A slice with three extra toppings will cost you $3 PLUS the charge for a slice. Stay Away from this place

Cafe Amore's

Posted by Union Square Luncher on 09/04/2008

Subpar food and service

They charged me $9.70 for baked ziti that was super soggy and tasteless. When I asked for the hot pepper flakes and cheese to help it taste more like food, they told me that it's probably at one of the tables in the dining room and that I should go find it myself. I didn't feel like hovering over people's meals in search of the shakers, so I tossed the ziti mush and left. I wanted to ask for my money back, but didn't want to waste my time since I knew they would cause a scene.

Cafe Amore's

Posted by Terrible service and food on 10/24/2007

Subpar service and food

I went inside and stood in line for almost 10 minutes. I was completely ignored, and then when I finally did order my food, they forgot one of the items that I requested and had to wait even longer while they heated it up. Meanwhile, my other food got cold. Terrible service and mediocre food. Not worth it.

Cafe Amore's

Posted by Anonymous on 07/31/2007

too expensive

the pizza is mediocre, and they have the audacity to charge $2.75 for a plain cheese slice. not worth it.

Cafe Amore's

Posted by Anonymous on 02/13/2007

It used to be good and consistent

I used to eat here for a quick slice of Pizza when I was hungry and and on the go. Although a slice cost over $2, it USED TO BE WORTH IT. But the last several times I went there, it seemed to have changed. When they first opened, the pizza was more fresh. The dough was light in colour and soft to chew. It wasn't hard & crispy. It didn't cut the roof of my mouth. The sauce was fresh and natural tasting. It was red in colour and seperate from the melted cheese on layered on top of it. The cheese tasted very fresh and melted in your mouth. It was soft and gooey. But things changed! Did a new owner take over? A new manager? A new cook? What happened? The pizza started coming out browner and crispy. The sauce was orangey like it had been mixed in with the cheese. The cheese is sprinkled on ever so lightly like they're trying to save a few pennies. The pizza tastes as if it has been sitting around overnight. It doesn't smell or taste fresh and doughy anymore. The tomato sauce tastes cheap, not fresh. WHAT HAPPENED? Can you go back to your original recipe & technique? Until then, I won't eat there anymore. I will go up to Mike's Pizza on 24th Street where its fresh and tasty.

Cafe Amore's

Posted by mark0708 on 01/31/2007

generous portions

price is good, for a slice of pizza, large slices. pizza taste best, when cooked to well done. Other foods on menu, are good, and reasonably priced.