Board & Card Games Stack Exchange is a question and answer site for people who like playing board games, designing board games or modifying the rules of existing board games. It's 100% free, no registration required.

I have found Elder sign by normal rules to be too easy to need a real strategy. Is this game much harder?
–
AndreyNov 4 '11 at 13:00

I can't win any of the rooms in the museum. Most of the time, it requires a perfect roll in order to beat the adventures. I just watched a "How to play" video and the board game plays exactly like the digital version.
–
OghmaOsirisNov 4 '11 at 14:10

4 Answers
4

I went ahead and asked the creators of Elder Sign: Omens and here's some responses from them and other members of their message board:

There are easier/less difficult adventures. Sure, you are still at the whim of the dice, but target some of the easier ones - specifically with the investigation tokens. These are easier to roll and succeed at and in turn provide you additional items and rewards that can be used to overcome some of the more difficult adventures down the turn.

Don't write off an investigator. My two guys were slouchs at first but when I started picking my adventures a bit wiser they ended up coming on strong.

The footprint token that allows you to reroll glyphs is priceless. Added dice is nice but the reroll is fabulous.

Target adventures that don't have sequential phases with investigators that don't have reroll abilities. This allows you to use the dice that are available when you have them and not in the order the adventure dictates.

Remember the odds of the dice. Each green dice has the following sides - Investigation ×1, Investigation ×2, Investigation ×3, Lore, Peril, Terror. Be sure to Focus according to the odds and the needs of the adventure. Yellow dice replaces Terror with an Investigation ×4. Red dice is like the Yellow dice but replaces Investigation ×1 with the Wild token - lovely, lovely wild.

Cashing in trophies tokens at the Entrance seems to be a waste if you are using four investigators - especially if you have the adventure that is hitting you for 2 trophies every midnight. With four investigators, you only get two turns per investigator per day. I'm going to try with less than four to see if that dynamic will change.

Assist is a great feature that works if you fail an adventure and then have a second investigator come in. Instead of focusing one dice, you'll be able to focus two. A nice synergy in the game and makes getting past some of those tough adventures a little bit easier.

I used some/all of these tips and I was finally able to win a couple games.

First, if you hare having trouble winning any rooms I would recommend reviewing the rules.
Don't forget that:

You can hold one die after a failure

Special items let you have more dice

Clues let you re-roll any number of dice

Characters have special abilities

Investigation requirements can be made out of a few dice.

General strategy:

Don't hoard items

If you don't have items, try an easy room to get items

If you do have items go for a hard room to gain elder signs

Take special successes before investigation

Do not remove many dice to complete an investigation, unless you are finishing a room

Unlock dice as soon as you can

I have found the digital version to be much harder. The board game tends to add 1 or 0 doom tokens every midnight. In the digital version I have gained 3 in one turn. There are other differences, some making the game easier.

Mandy Thompson is a close second, since her ability doesn't depend on
items

My key exception is Kate Winthrop: her ability to ignore terror
effects is powerful, especially considering that adventures with
terror effects tend to be easier to accomplish.

Gloria Goldberg and Jenny Barnes are a toss-up: Gloria is a touch
more useful since there are more other world locations at the end
game, and they tend to have elder signs to win.

Darrell Simmons has had some success for me, mainly clearing out
lower end adventures

One trick I've found useful - you don't have to complete a task just because you have the glyphs to do so. I've discarded so I could focus (reserve) a special glyph that I need for later.

Monsters aren't always bad - sometimes a monster can make an adventure easier by covering a more complex task.

The game moves very quickly, and if you get behind the doom count it gets difficult to catch up. Don't waste time buying/hoarding items, only heal when you have to. The one exception is elder signs - I've won a couple of games by buying the last elder sign or two.

Dexter Drake is handy for picking up extra spells. I agree with Gloria for the Otherworld Levels, good way to pick up elder signs. You have to clamp down on the midnight effects, and remember you can kill a monster even if you can't complete the tasks. Take the hit (and reward) and come back next time for the tasks.