EmeraldAsh

Amazing

I have tried countless eyeliners and this product is by far the best this product goes on super easy , dosent smuge and stays in place all day long . I had to use my make up remover twice for it to completely come off . The colors are really pigmented as well and its really well priced a great value great for anyone who is new to eyeliner or expirenced

Storm10

smudges and dries out

At first i enjoyed using this eyeliner because it was easy to use but I to also found that it smudge and caked in corner of eyes....also over time, it dries out which makes it difficult to apply! so overall not an happy camper with this product and would not recommended it to friends

beyourownhero

needs improvement

I would not recommend this eyeliner. It smudges and bleeds into my corners by the end of the day. It transfers down onto my lower lash line. And the application isn't always easy. I really regret buying it and will go back to my usual liquid liner.