Jonathan is asked by Just Jared about a story that fellow Spring Awakening co-star Skylar Astin supposedly knows involving a laughter-filled trip taken by the Spring Awakening cast to Lancaster, PA. But Jonathan is confused by the question, since the only story he knows about being in Lancaster involves skinny dipping. So he might as well tell that one, too.

"When we went to Lancaster, we went as a cast," Jonathan recalls. "I went skinny dipping in my pool with my brother and John Gallagher Jr. Skylar was in bed, so that doesn’t make any sense for that, but what I think he’s trying to say is when we went with Lea’s family to the Hamptons."

"He and I and Lea and a couple of the other cast members were staying up till all hours, and he had us laughing so hard because he was doing an impression of Jenna Ushkowitz [in Spring Awakening. She] is a cast member on Glee and was in Spring Awakening with us," J-Groff says. "It made us all hysterically laugh. She was there as well. That’s when he was doing it."

Now, we want to hear Skylar do his impression of Jenna Ushkowitz (Tina)! Well, we also want to go skinny dipping with Jonathan, but we have a feeling that might be a little less likely to happen.