These are the laws which impose artificial limits on how much money Canadians can donate to political parties and how much those political parties can spend during elections.

As such they infringe on free political expression; they confer an unfair advantage to incumbents and hurt smaller political parties; they almost guarantee candidates for a party’s leadership will face mountains of personal debt; and apparently they force political parties into undertaking questionable accounting practices.

In short, they undermine Canadian democracy.

That’s why instead of being revised, these campaign finance laws should be scrapped.

6 comments:

I don't have a problem with spending limits, but I agree completely about donation limits. If some millionare wants to fund an entire campaign without a single donation, why in the world is it illegal?

So you're advocating a US-style free-for-all where campaigns can be financed by a few uber-wealthy individuals, corporations, and unions rather than from a broad base of popular support? You're getting redder every day... why not just make it official and buy a Liberal party membership?

Nice theory but I don't think the evidence is on your side. The problem with unlimited funding is that one large benefactor can hold undue sway in an election. Think of GE and its influence in getting Obama elected. One of the reasons the Liberals in Canada were so successful is that they could tap a number of crony corporations and swamp the other parties with advertising. Since Chretien decided to screw Martin the large donors have been eliminated and the Liberals are in a tailspin. In short which is more democratic. A thousand people donating a thousand dollars each or one company or union donating a million dollars?

All the previous posters are wrong. American study shows that there is actually no correlation between the amount spent and the success of a campaign. The only difference is that in a free system (which America, with myriad regulations on donors, doesn't have), there is a greater chance to round up the funds necessary to challenge an incumbent. I believe large business donations had much to do with the start of Reform. If the 'conservatives' here had their way, that would never have been.

About Me

Gerry Nicholls is a communications consultant and writer who has been called a “political warrior” a “brilliant strategist” and one of the “canniest political observers in Canada.”
He has worked as a consultant in both the United States and Canada and was formerly a senior officer in the National Citizens Coalition.
A regular columnist with the Ottawa Hill Times, his work has also appeared in the Globe and Mail, the National Post and in the Sun Media chain; and he has appeared on countless TV and radio public affairs programs. He is the author of the book, Loyal to the Core, Harper, Me and the NCC.

Twitter Updates

Twitter Updates

Reviews for Loyal to the Core

“Loyal to the Core is a daring and provocative work. It deserves to be read by conservative activists and politicos.” – Western Standard

“This is a very important book.” -- Michael Coren, TV host

“A fascinating read” --- Seamus O'Regan, Canada AM

“I really enjoyed Loyal to the Core. It’s a great book”, - Charles Adler, radio host.

"Loyal to the Core should be required reading for anyone considering or starting a career at a conservative think tank or in electoral politics in general …Consider Loyal to the Core a cautionary tale that’s also a funny, easy read – with a few highly “stealable” ideas for media campaigns thrown in for good measure.”- Kathy Shaidle, author Tyranny of Nice

“Every Canadian remotely interested in politics and the state of the country should have a read of Loyal to the Core. – blogger Wendy Sullivan

"It’s rare to find a politico, however, who is equally passionate about policy and strategy, but columnist, pundit, author and Western Standard blogger Gerry Nicholls is such a person." Matthew Johnson, owner Western Standard

"If you are a conservative who wonders how conservatives can communicate their message in a hostile media climate, Loyal to the Core is a must read." -- At Home in Hespeler