How the hell are Silfverberg, Wiercioch and Caporusso ahead of Butler? And for that matter, how is Rundblad ahead of Cowen?

Silfverberg and Wiercioch could realistically become much better players than Butler, even though Butler is 4 years older and much closer to making an impact in the NHL.

Silfverberg for example arguably just had a better season at 20 yo in the SEL (a comparable league to the AHL) than Butler did at 24 in the AHL. Plus, Silfverberg is much bigger and expected to be a much better defensive player at the NHL level. Silfverberg was 22nd in points and 8th in goals in the SEL.

How the hell are Silfverberg, Wiercioch and Caporusso ahead of Butler? And for that matter, how is Rundblad ahead of Cowen?

Rundblad just had a record breaking season in the 3rd best league in the world (the SEL is usually regarded as a better league than the AHL.) Cowen was still playing in the WHL and they're the same age. Plus, if you watch Rundblad play he just oozes talent, he has size, he's strong, and he has the ability to really become the best defenceman on this team by quite a bit.

Quote:

Originally Posted by trentmccleary

Silfverberg and Wiercioch could realistically become much better players than Butler, even though Butler is 4 years older and much closer to making an impact in the NHL.

Silfverberg for example arguably just had a better season at 20 yo in the SEL (a comparable league to the AHL) than Butler did at 24 in the AHL. Plus, Silfverberg is much bigger and expected to be a much better defensive player at the NHL level. Silfverberg was 22nd in points and 8th in goals in the SEL.

Again, Silfverberg has a much better two-way game, size, and skill on Butler plus he's younger and did better in a better league this year. Wierchioch is regarded as a project but again, very young (compared to Butler) and showing signs of promise early in his career.

Robyn Lehner should easily be our top Prosepct, he has top 10 NHL goalie potential, besides Cowen he has such an incredible resume already for a 19 year old - He and Cowen are our top prospects in my eyes - as far as guys that help you win games,

Rundbald = Kaberle
Lehner = Thomas
Cowen = Chara

I know which of these plyers I'd take, easily Cowen and Lehner above Rundblad.

Robyn Lehner should easily be our top Prosepct, he has top 10 NHL goalie potential, besides Cowen he has such an incredible resume already for a 19 year old - He and Cowen are our top prospects in my eyes - as far as guys that help you win games,

Rundbald = Kaberle
Lehner = Thomas
Cowen = Chara

I know which of these plyers I'd take, easily Cowen and Lehner above Rundblad.

I would take Keith over Seabrook over Neimi.

Your comparisons aren't very helpful, they look like spur of the moment comparisons without a lot of consideration put into making them.

Nothing alike? They're mobile, very skilled players that don't contribute a whole lot to the physical game and have question marks around their defense? They're a lot alike, although I'm certainly hoping David will be a little more physical than Kabs.

Nothing alike? They're mobile, very skilled players that don't contribute a whole lot to the physical game and have question marks around their defense? They're a lot alike, although I'm certainly hoping David will be a little more physical than Kabs.

I agree, and because you are so great with Swedish prospects, I have a question.

Despite the similarities to Kaberle, don't you think Rundblad's major difference is that he likes to jump up in the play more?

Silfverberg and Wiercioch could realistically become much better players than Butler, even though Butler is 4 years older and much closer to making an impact in the NHL.

Silfverberg for example arguably just had a better season at 20 yo in the SEL (a comparable league to the AHL) than Butler did at 24 in the AHL. Plus, Silfverberg is much bigger and expected to be a much better defensive player at the NHL level. Silfverberg was 22nd in points and 8th in goals in the SEL.

17 points in his first AHL playoffs > Silfverberg's SEL season. 21 points in 36 NHL games is what makes him a better prospect than Silfverberg. Silfverberg hasn't even proven he's capable of playing on a smaller ice surface.

17 points in his first AHL playoffs > Silfverberg's SEL season. 21 points in 36 NHL games is what makes him a better prospect than Silfverberg. Silfverberg hasn't even proven he's capable of playing on a smaller ice surface.

Most of those 21 points were earned while playing on Spezza wing, on the first line. Plus, Silfverberg is about 3 years younger than Butler, so even if Butler is the better player now, im convinced that if everything goes well, Siflverberg should become the better player.

If Petersson's recovery goes well, he might, as will Rundblad. Silfverburg is signed but on loan next season to the SEL. I don't think any of the other Swedish prospects are ready.

God, I'm still amazed we got Rundblad for a mid round 1st. His stock has done nothing but rise since then.

It will be an interesting situation on defense this year. With Cowan and Rundblad trying to get a job, and at least 6 others on one way contracts, something has got to give. I assume there will only be room for one of those 2 guys, so it should be a good training camp and pre-season.

It will be an interesting situation on defense this year. With Cowan and Rundblad trying to get a job, and at least 6 others on one way contracts, something has got to give. I assume there will only be room for one of those 2 guys, so it should be a good training camp and pre-season.