You actually wear the black really well but I wouldn't go that dark with your fair skin. I just think it can look so harsh. I agree with @Brianna about a chocolate brown if you want a "darker" look.....I like you with the red or honey blonde the best though.....just my opinion!

Although I think the black isn't terrible, I think going a little lighter would fall around your face more flattering with your skin tone. I do agree going darker than your current tone looks nice on you as it really brings out the natural tone of your beautiful blue eyes. Going a few shades lighter than black like a chocolate brown will also be easier to change if you ever are in the mood for something different.