This week, actor Jesse Eisenberg revisits a painful chapter of his youth when his beloved basketball team the Phoenix Suns lost to the Chicago Bulls in the final seconds of Game 6 of the 1993 NBA Finals.

Wracked by guilt at the possibility that his fan letter to the Suns’ Dan Majerle provided a fatal distraction, he imagines an alternate reality where he never put pen to paper. NBA legends Charles Barkley and Michael Jordan also make an appearance. And there’s a bonus conversation between Mike and Jesse.

Get Episode 1 of Upon Further Review, “If Nixon Was Good at Football, History Might Be Different,” here.

Podcast production by Derek John and Jonathan Mitchell of The Truth podcast.