I currently digitize vinyl working with a technics 1210, an audio-technica at-95e, and the preamps built into my native instruments traktor kontrol s4. presumably, few people here will know what an s4 is. for purposes of this thread, it should be sufficient to note that the s4 is a midi controller (roughly speaking--actually, it uses a different protocol) which includes a 4-in, 4-out audio interface with 2 phono preamps that's geared towards DJs. the audio interface in the s4 might be comparable to standalone 4-in, 4-out USB 2.0 audio interface with 2 phono preamps in the $200 range (again, it would be an audio interface geared towards DJs so it would come with very low-latency asio drivers).

i am unsatisfied with the results i'm currently getting. i record with audacity at default settings (32-bit floating point, 44.1kHz). the gain in windows' volume mixer for the channel to which the 1210 is connected to is at 100%. the peak levels i'm getting during recording are at about -12dB to -15dB. (there's no way in audacity to further boost the volume during recording.) i don't perceive the audio quality as good at all despite the fact that i'm digitizing records in mint condition. (i'm trying to digitize vinyl-only releases so buying digital is not an option. unfortunately, in the genres i listen to--certain areas of house and techno--, vinyl-only release are relatively common.) on some recordings, the kick drum sounds muffled. on most recordings, i feel noise levels are excessive.

now, i certainly don't think the preamps in my audio interface are any good. the at-95e cartridge which i recently bought for EUR 20 is entry-level, too. does anyone have suggestions as to what preamp and cartridge to buy? as for my budget: EUR 500 (~$650) is my absolute max. ideally, i'd like to spend less. so i'd be happier if i can get something reasonable for, say, EUR 300 or so.

I'm amazed that two supposedly working RIAA pre-amps can sound so different. The EQ is completely different, and different in different ways on each channel.

I agree that the difference is striking. I was already wondering if it is due to some kind of artifact during recording such as dust on the needle. But I do remember clearly that I cleaned the stylus in between recordings so I don't think so.

I'm kinda curious now to get to the bottom of this. In response to what db1989 wrote, I've just ordered up a vinyl where I already own the digital release. I'll do another round of recordings, trying to make 110% sure that everything is kosher. Might take a few days till the vinyl arrives but then I'll post new samples, including a sample from the digital release which may then act as a point of reference.

I'm kinda curious now to get to the bottom of this. In response to what db1989 wrote, I've just ordered up a vinyl where I already own the digital release. I'll do another round of recordings, trying to make 110% sure that everything is kosher. Might take a few days till the vinyl arrives but then I'll post new samples, including a sample from the digital release which may then act as a point of reference.