Blog

Co-op on a Budget: The Wedge Co-op vs. Cub Foods

This is the second post in our Co-op on a Budget series, which explores the different ways that we can shop co-op effectively and affordably. Also check out the first post, on shopping bulk.

About three
years ago our young family went through a financial crunch, which I’m sure most
Americans shared. My employer was on a two-year wage freeze
and hiring-freeze. Rumors of layoffs were the smaller waves of a larger
fear that the company might fail altogether. As a relatively new employee, I
was confident that layoffs would affect my position. My wife, pregnant with our
second child, had recently quit her job to stay home with our 3-year-old
daughter and the expected baby, so my income was solely driving our household,
and, to be honest, we were scared shitless.

We decided
to budget, budget, budget! Luckily, we had committed ourselves to a modestly
small (and beautiful) home, so our mortgage was realistic. We suspended any
unnecessary expenses. We took our delayed honeymoon driving up the magnificent
north shore of Lake Superior instead of our original plan of traveling to the
Grand Canyon and Las Vegas. Oh yeah, and we decided to start doing a large
portion of our grocery shopping at Cub instead of the Wedge Co-op. We were
proud of the decisions that we made, and in retrospect three years later, I
think for the most part we made good choices. Sound familiar? Thought so.

I’ve always
been a math nerd. Math creates puzzles, and I’ve always been a big puzzle guy.
So it wouldn’t surprise many people to know that I’ve charted, graphed, and
meticulously organized a budget several times over the last fifteen years since
I moved out on my own. It was almost a guilty pleasure to stuff my pockets with
every last receipt and compile lists and categories in my budgeting. I remember
a similar exercise in my early twenties when my bar/booze budget outspent my
rent … a proud moment.

As a
husband and father, I’ve somewhat reallocated my priorities. Our grocery budget
has consistently come in second in our expenses, far below our mortgage but
much more than any other item in our budget. I’d imagine that most families are
in a similar situation. Our own food budget situation is compounded by my
preference for shopping at a member-owned food co-op. I am definitely biased
towards co-ops having grown up in a home that used one as well as having worked
at both Linden Hills Co-op and the Wedge Co-op for several years. I know the
idea of “buying local” is trendy now, but it’s always been that way for co-ops —
historically, a small, member-owned neighborhood business which provides a
service directly back to the community. Farmers like my dad’s parents have been
using co-ops for decades for seed, fuel, food, tools, etc. as a way of banding
small communities together to afford discounts on commodities by purchasing in
bulk.

Besides
supporting an important local business I also support the type of food that the
co-op typically provides. So it was with reluctance that we began shopping at
Cub for some of our food in an effort to save money. But there were some things
we were going to still buy from the co-op, such as bulk grains and various
specialty items that you won’t find at a big box grocery, so we began shopping
at both.

I wondered
from the very first trip how much money we would really save. I’ve always been
a pretty good grocery shopper in that I stick to the list and resist impulse
buys, but that takes considerably more restraint at a Cub. You’ve got to admit,
they’ve sure mastered the art of advertising in the store. The junk food at Cub
is ridiculously inexpensive compared to the co-op, so a few bags of chips or
crackers would sneak into the cart. Maybe a box of cookies? By the time all was
said and done, I noticed our weekly grocery bills were hardly less than when we
were shopping exclusively at the co-op.

As the last
couple of years played out we kept sliding more and more towards the co-op
until we were hardly ever shopping at Cub anymore. And with every visit, I became
more and more aware of all of the other reasons that I loved the co-op besides
the quality of the food. To sum it up, I just find those big grocery stores
overwhelming and often depressing. The amount of choices piled to the ceiling make
me dizzy. The organization is confusing … you want yogurt? There’s some in the
dairy aisle, there’s some in the “organics” aisle, there’s some in the cooler
end-cap on sale. The lines are long, and inevitably I always choose the line
that gets held up because there’s an argument about whether this or that coupon
is valid, the register isn’t accepting someone’s credit card, or there’s a
dispute about price. I have to say, the employees at Cub are generally very
friendly and willing to help, but what non-autistic human would be able to keep
track of that kind of inventory in that size of a store?

Additionally,
bringing the kids to a Cub always turns into a headache. Again with the
advertising, they know what they’re doing. There’s Hello Kitty and superhero
logos on cereal, snacks, jelly, really just about everywhere in the store as
well as all the candy and junk food they want piled high on the end-caps.
Bringing the kids means spending an hour saying “no” every thirty seconds to
any flashy, expensive item that they want to throw in the cart. Maybe I'm being neurotic, but
I just couldn't handle it anymore. Contrastingly the co-op always feels to
me like I'm shopping at a farmer's market, and I get the opportunity to meet my
farmers and processors with frequent in-house demos. The co-op had
everything that I wanted not only in my food, but also in a complete shopping
experience, and so I decided the extra expense was worth it.

When SGT
began this “Co-op on a Budget” series I thought, what a good excuse to actually
figure out exactly how much “extra” it cost to shop at the co-op. So I planned
out seven dinners, wrote down all the ingredients that we needed, and bought the
exact same list from both the co-op and Cub. Before I talk any numbers, I do
think it’s worth mentioning that there are a lot of variables that could make
any grocery trip much more or less expensive. In part that ends up dictating
how we shop and what we eat. For example, because meat tends to be more
expensive at the co-op, we only eat meat at three or four dinners a week. We
always have a red beans and rice Monday, which is an extremely inexpensive
dinner. It’s also often the kids’ favorite meal, and it makes me nostalgic for
when I cooked in New Orleans. Lunch is almost always leftovers from dinner, so
there is very little food waste at the end of the week. And the summer is spent
primarily based around what’s ripe in the garden. Because produce is generally
the biggest expense at any grocery store we often cut our grocery bill by a
third in the summer because of the garden.

Now, onto
the numbers. These are the dinners that I planned for the experiment.

-Sunday: Roasted chicken with broccoli,
potato, and oranges.

-Monday: Red beans and rice.

-Tuesday: Bean and cheese quesadillas with
corn and peaches.

-Wednesday: Turkey and bacon sandwiches with
chips and refrigerator pickles.

-Thursday: Blueberry waffles with sausage
links.

-Friday: Cheeseburgers with grilled sweet
potato and cole slaw.

-Saturday: Pizza night with salad.

The
shopping lists for both the co-op and Cub were identical, and they included
only what ingredients and condiments we didn’t currently have at home. While
the lists are identical the product at each store were varying as the co-op
tends to favor local and organic produce, meat, and dairy while Cub will ship
in from California and Mexico at lower prices. Also
remember I’m buying to feed a family of two adults and two young children. The total
at the co-op was $87.49 and the total at Cub was$64.46. That’s a $23.03 difference, which is about 35%. Maybe a family with four teenage
boys will argue that 35% will be a lot more than $20/week. Maybe a family who
doesn’t cook from scratch will find that prepared deli foods and frozen foods
(items we don’t buy) at the co-op are prohibitively expensive. That said, our
average weekly grocery bill is $120, which is less than what is allotted in
food stamps to a family of four in Minnesota, so you have to set your own
priorities.

With that
in mind, do I think it’s worth an extra $20/week to eat exclusively from the
co-op? Absolutely.

Benjamin Krikava lives
in north Minneapolis with his family. After over a decade of restaurant
work he has moved on to be employed in the medical field, now helping
to prevent heart attacks rather than cause them. When he's not at work
or on his bicycle you will find him in the kitchen drinking the rest of
the bottle of wine that the recipe didn't call for. His last article for
us was: Feeding Your Kids Fair Food.