Seamus McGarvey should never have been nominated for Atonement (or any other film).

By: crack3d

10.20.2012 @ 7:36 PM

It’s funny that Pfister took issue with the camera man wanting to show off the set. I feel like there were plenty of instances in the Dark Knight trilogy where shots were done purely to show off the scale of the set and the awesomeness of the IMAX camera.

By: BigAl6ft6

10.20.2012 @ 11:55 PM

Yeah, in Dark Knight & Inception & Dark Knight Rises the movie is chock full of “LOOK AT HOW COOL AND HOW MUCH SCOPE THIS IS AND HOW MUCH MONEY WE SPENT!!” shots. Seems a very hypocritical argument.

By: Pat

10.20.2012 @ 8:19 PM

The real question is, “Did McGarvey even shoot the scenes Pfister was complaint about?” Or was it second unit stuff for the big battle?

Also, why did EW contact Whedon? It sounds like the beef was with the cinematography?