Base Boston: Rape and Sexual Assault in the Coast Guard

It’s the headquarters for the Coast Guard’s entire First District. It’s where many victims of sexual assault in the service get sent. And it’s where, all too often, their military careers then come to an end.

The Coast Guard determined that E-3 seaman Panayiota Bertzikis wasn’t cut out for the “stresses” of life in the service. She sums it up more bluntly: “I was told I was having problems adjusting to being raped.” (Photograph by Minesh Bacrania)

The Coast Guard Academy responded to these numbers by hiring a new sexual-assault response coordinator in February, and unveiled a new training program shortly thereafter. But when the academy’s superintendent, Rear Admiral Sandra Stosz, spoke about the new program in March, she did little to alleviate the concerns of observers. “At a time when they’re exploring their identity, it’s somewhat natural to have people experiment with what it takes to attract a person of the opposite sex,” Stosz told The Day, New London’s daily newspaper. “If, one time, a guy or gal is clumsy or stupid and tries to touch someone and they’re repulsed, they learn. Someone who goes around and keeps trying many times, that’s a different kind of behavior than someone who is awkward and experimenting.” Her remarks reflect “the pure ignorance of the dynamics of sexual violence,” Stacy Malone, the executive director of the Victim Rights Law Center, in Boston, says. “She’s basically saying sexual assault is a miscommunication. And we know it’s not. Sexual assault is not about sex, it’s about power.”

According to Elsa Nethercot, who retired from the Guard as a first-class boatswain’s mate in 2007 after more than 20 years in the service, sexual harassment and assault have been endemic to the Coast Guard for decades. Back then, she says, they were “a condition of your continued employment.”

Nethercot says it’s unsettling to see these same problems playing out now. “These young women at small boat stations or ships, they’re getting raped by senior personnel and told to suck it up or deal with it, or they’re going to get booted,” she says. “It’s a corporate mentality. The Coast Guard will almost always support the person in whom they have the biggest financial investment.”

Mary Kelley Richard, who was among the first active-duty women to serve in the Guard, in 1974, and who later became an advocate with the National Women’s Veterans conference, says harassment was an “everyday fact of life” at her first two duty stations. “I just knew mine was coming,” she says. “I just didn’t know where it was coming from.” Seven months into her career, she was raped by a superior officer. “We had the same issues then that we have today,” Richard says. “It’s very disappointing to me to see that there has not been any significant progress.”

Panayiota Bertzikis is slight, with light-brown hair and delicate features. Her voice carries the hint of a New York accent; growing up, she spent summers boating on Long Island Sound. Those summers played a part in her decision to join the Coast Guard in 2005, at the age of 23. “I liked the job description,” she recalls. “The adventure, being out on the boat. I wanted to be a marine-science technician, cleaning up oil spills.”

Bertzikis wound up stationed in Burlington, Vermont. One afternoon in May 2006, she set off on a hike with her company when, she says, one of her shipmates pulled her aside, threw her to the ground, punched her in the face, and then raped her. Bertzikis reported the assault shortly after the attack, but she says that her commanders ordered her to “shut up,” and warned her that her accusation amounted to slander against her attacker. When she wouldn’t let it go, she says she was locked in a janitor’s closet during the investigation. Bertzikis says that when the investigation went nowhere, she was forced to live alongside her attacker, and the two of them were told to “work out their differences.”

Eventually, she was reassigned to Maine. There, she was given a performance evaluation and found competent by her new commander, who said he would try to move her back to Burlington. “I just started crying, and broke down,” Bertzikis says. The commander helped her open a new investigation. “He told me, ‘We’re going to send you to Boston. There are going to be people there that are going to help,’” Bertzikis says. “I felt like, ‘Finally they’re going to take care of this.’”

In July, Bertzikis was transferred to Base Boston. She arrived on a Friday and spent the weekend alone in the barracks. On Monday, her new shipmates returned from a weekend away. They already knew about her. “You’re trying to get him in trouble,” they said of her rapist. “He told us you were crazy.” For the next several months, she says she was shunned by the bulk of her shipmates. Those who did speak to her often harassed and threatened her, she says. One day, she says, a group of her shipmates surrounded her while she was walking back to her barracks during a lunch break. She says they started groping her and ripping her clothing. “You’re hot,” one said. “I’d like to rape you, too.” She reported the harassment, she says, but nothing happened. Instead, she says, her victim advocate—the person assigned to help her get assistance for the rape—encouraged her to remain silent.

Still, she continued to believe that eventually her investigation would validate her claims, that her rapist would be punished, and that she would move on with her career and up through the ranks. But in 2007, a Coast Guard psychiatrist diagnosed Bertzikis with an adjustment disorder. Deemed unfit to serve, she was given an administrative discharge. According to the Department of Defense, more than 93 percent of all rape cases in the military end without a conviction. Military doctors often diagnose rape victims like Bertzikis with personality or adjustment disorders after they report attacks. The military then considers them unfit to serve, and discharges them. Meanwhile, their accused attackers often continue with their careers.

Around the Web:

Please be respectful of our online community and contribute to an engaging conversation. We reserve the right to remove impersonators or personal attacks, threats, profanity, or flat-out offensive comments. By posting here, you are permitting Boston magazine and Metro Corp. to edit and republish your comment in all media.

Diana Danis

Until reporting, investigation, adjudication and sentencing of these felony crimes are removed from the Chain of Command, there will be no real justice for our military personnel.

Shawn

This behavior is totally unacceptable and deserves the exposure it has been given, but we are naive and myopic if we don’t start discussing this as the larger social issue it is. If we don’t think this is being experienced in all facets of life, whether corporate America, halls of academia, or right around the corner from us, we are turning a blind eye to the issue and most importantly the victims.

This issue is not a military issue… I am sure if the author looked into the prosecution success rate in civilian courts, she would find it even more disturbing. And again, if we believe this social castigation only occurs within the confines of our military, our blindness is keeping victims in the shadows.

Tony

Making castration the penalty for rape would IMHO drastically reduce the occurrence of rape.

jack_sprat2

Of course, you’d also be castrating those who’d been falsely accused. Every guy with his 20 in would be out the door at the first opportunity. Good luck getting new recruits.

That’s okay, though. I’m sure that the gals will be eager to pick up the slack, what with all of those great new shots at command and combat slots. Right?

Tony

False accusation does not mean conviction. I was a lifer and spent over 5 years in combat in French Indochina, I recall only one incident involving groping at a social function. The individual involved was out in 30 days in lieu of a court martial.

jack_sprat2

A very successful Sci/Fi novelist named Piers Anthony wrote a series that obliquely touched on the likely potential difficulties in a coed space navy of the far future. In it, some of the draftees, mostly but not exclusively female, found themselves assigned to sex duty as their MOS. No choices; no opting out.

It was always a cluster f*** waiting to happen. You generally get a situation in which the women confine themselves to the same small group of very attractive men. It’s a breeding ground for jealousy and resentment. You can’t function well under those circumstances. Something’s got to give. Good order and discipline, certainly.

Of course, the brass, many of them, duck and cover. They’ve never been entirely free of politics–couldn’t be, inasmuch as every star needs Congressional approval–but it’s gotten worse since the Johnson Administration pretty much required field commanders to lie through their teeth as a daily condition of their jobs. Nowadays, it’s made worse by the fact that their political masters punish those who so much as raise a dissenting voice to social engineering schemes.

Facebook User

What a crock of s—. Women, and men now, being raped in the CG. This is all liberal hyperbole, a topic now in fashion, something ‘creative’ to write about. Lies, lies and more lies fromthe obamanation.

Nick Cantalini

it’s bad…

CityMouse

What years did you serve, in which branch, which conflicts were you assigned, and how many women in the service did you personally know?

I ask because I served. I served in the Marines, during Serest Storm/Desert Shield, Afgan & Iraqi Freedom. I was with a Huey Helicopter unit. I will tell you, whom ever you are, that I know more women that have been sexually assaulted and/or raped than ones that have enjoyed their time in the ‘brotherhood’ of the military.

If you are speaking from experience, you are the exception to the rule, and the women that you know are fortunate. However, it appears to me that it is more likely that you are speaking from you ass.

Alex

That’s Ridiculous! It’s lesson learn for all the women out their you should use some self protection device I heard iZap has the best protection device you should check http://www.buyizap.com.

CityMouse

Instead of making a semi-intelligent comment, you are going to simultaneously argue that women should have to always be on the defense among there military brethren and advertise a weapon that you sell that these military women are not allowed to carry on base?

Your shameless self promotion is not nearly as atrocious as your concept that women should have to arm themselves against their co-workers.

Get a life.

No, wait. Get in the kitchen and make me a SPAM sandwich.

Facebook User

Hey shittymouse, I served my country for four years active, right out of base Boston.
Your an effing liar and a nobody, climb back in your hole shittymouse!

CityMouse

I poorly assumed you didn’t serve because I have never met a woman that served that has not at least been sexually harassed. I commend your unit for it’s high standards and you as well. My sincere apologies for making an incorrect assumption and handing you an unjust and undue insult. I am sorry that my negative experiences have clouded my judgment so far as to not give you all due respect. I hope I have your understanding.

Cows in the cabbage

Does anyone know how I can locate a network of former or current
female Marines? As a VA employee I was sexually harassed and stalked by a
supervisor (a former Marine.) When I reported him, I was fired. I am trying to
locate women who experienced similar treatment by him when he was in the
Marines. Thank you.

CityMouse

Because he works for the VA, he was given an honorable discharge. If he had a record while he was in, unfortunately it is now sealed. I’m sorry.

beckyblanton

Didn’t realize the Coast Guard was such a filthy, useless, worthless waste of tax dollars.

The Oral History of David Ortiz

Sponsor Content

Plastic surgeons at Beth Israel Deaconess Medical Center (BIDMC) are bringing new hope to cancer patients by offering innovative procedures for both preventing and treating lymphedema. Although not life-threatening, lymphedema More >>