Blaming the Victims: The tragedy of IDPs in South Sudan

April 28, 2014 - The recent politically motivated violence against unarmed civilians seeking shelter from the violence in South Sudan in the United Nations compound in Bor exposed not only the criminal act of the perpetrators but also the mindset of those who ordered and executed it. The unprovoked brutal attacks on the Internally Displaced Persons (IDPs) camp had been justified by the government spokesperson Minister of Information and Broadcasting, Michael Makuei Lueth, and interlocutors’ reaction to the IDPs celebration of the fall of the city of Bentiu in the opposition hands. The IDPs were labelled as ‘rebels’ and ‘supporters’ of the opposition who deserved to be punished for their act of celebrating the defeat of the government forces. Hence, the victims were asking for it. The attacks and its bogus justification have raised questions about how the government of South Sudan understands the key concepts of citizenship, responsibility to protect, and the rule of law. These three concepts are considered to be the sacred pillars of any modern political community.

After all, those who were subjected to violence in their UN shelter are South Sudanese citizens. Their rights and duties as citizens of South Sudan are enshrined in and protected by the Transitional Constitution of the Republic of South Sudan which the government claims to respect and defend in its war against the opposition forces. None of this has stopped the government from blaming the IDPs, calling them pejoratives such as ‘lazy’, ‘lovers’ of free food and handouts from the UN. The justification of the attacks not only dismisses the claim to equal treatment of the IDPs as citizens of South Sudan, but also denies their very existence as human beings. Ironically, instead of exposing the fraudulent assertions of the government spokesperson, government supporters, including a handful of intellectuals, bought into the bogus explanation. The bogus official narrative about the IDPs began earlier when the violence erupted last year. Government officials circulated distorted propaganda about the IDPs’ connections with opposition forces. They were unsuccessfully portrayed as enemies of the state – ‘rebel fighters in civilian clothes’, and ‘potential agitators’ from within.

However, the truth is the government is attempting to escape responsibility by placing the blame for crime at hands of the victims. The IDPs are not guilty for violence committed by government forces and armed youth in Bor. This violence occurred because the government failed to protect them in the first place. The government could have prevented the attacks by disarming the youth and holding those who broke the law accountable. To say that government’s claim is a woeful over simplification would be to give it way too much credit. In fact, the claim is an embarrassing debacle filled with worthless platitudes to back an argument that is insulting not only to the IDPs and the people of South Sudan but to anyone who respects critical reasoning. It also seems to make the tribalistic assumption that all Nuers are rebels and worthless of trust. And even those Nuers who have the interest of mending bridges of peace and reconciliation are categorized as potential enemies. The tendency to smear a whole population of IDPs or an ethnic group reflects what is among the worst aspects of the human condition, where perpetrators blame the victims for their experiences. The danger of this kind of mentality and attitude may worsen hostilities between the conflicting communities, incite ethnically driven revenge, and drag the whole South Sudan into chaos and an uncontrollable bloodbath with unimaginable human tragedy in the 21th century.

The unfolding tragedy in South Sudan is a man made one. And to end it and restore the deep respect for human virtues in particular respect for life to all South Sudanese irrespective of their ethnic, religious, and gender identities, collective political efforts have to be made by the victims and the perpetrators of the violence. This of course can be done if the government and the opposition first recognize that the IDPs are human beings and citizens deserving their constitutional entitlements including protection from both the government and the opposition forces. No valuable lessons will be learned from this inhuman tragedy in South Sudan so long as the government and the opposition and their interlocutors continue to perpetuate the monstrous claim that those who are victims of political violence, including unarmed IDPs, deserve such a fate.

The writer is a Professor and Chair of Department of African and African American Studies, Fordham University, New York City, USA. He can be reached at idris@fordham.edu

The views expressed in the 'Comment and Analysis' section are solely the opinions of the writers. The veracity of any claims made are the responsibility of the author not Sudan Tribune.

Sudan Tribune reserves the right to edit articles before publication. Please include your full name, relevant personal information and political affiliations.

Comments on the Sudan Tribune website must abide by the following rules. Contravention of these rules will lead to the user losing their Sudan Tribune account with immediate effect.

- No inciting violence
- No inappropriate or offensive language
- No racism, tribalism or sectarianism
- No inappropriate or derogatory remarks
- No deviation from the topic of the article
- No advertising, spamming or links
- No incomprehensible comments

Due to the unprecedented amount of racist and offensive language on the site, Sudan Tribune tries to vet all comments on the site.

There is now also a limit of 400 words per comment. If you want to express yourself in more detail than this allows, please e-mail your comment as an article to comment@sudantribune.com

Kind regards,

The Sudan Tribune editorial team.

29 April 2014 05:36, by Toney Toney Matot

Amir Idris,
your article is so bias though your name suggest to be an Arab but you are a Nuer in Hyena skin. If those you claimed to be IDPS have sympathy and gut for South Sudan, they would have mourn the death of those innocent civilian murdered by Rebels in Bentiu instead of making celebration. this would have actually answered your claim.

Idris,
how do you feel if your father, Brother, Uncle and so on were cowardly murdered the way those people in bentiu were executed by the rebels and some people who pretend to be IDPs under protection of UN who have nothing to do with rebels celebrate the whole night, what could be your reaction?

Amir
I have read through your article with the clarity of mind and I fall short of how you picked the Bor incident which is the most recent leaving behind the very first incident where Civilians were massacred in Akobo inline with 2 UN soldiers from India, not only that, you never mention the worse cases of Bentiu, Bailiet which are strongly condemned by the whole world......

all this cases would have presented you a clear view of the atrocities committed by any party involved in the conflict and for sure your conclusion could have been use to avoid further incident of the same kind by those holding arms. I wonder what you mean when you refer to word "IDPs in UN camp", or protection being killed yet you failed to mentioned the "IDPs who were killed in UN camp in Akobo"

Amir, your governemnt in Khartoum is doing the same and no one including you has ever condemn it.Have they respected the rights of citizens of Darfur, Nuba and Blue Nile?Daily bombing of civilians settlemet, refugees has been Khartoum daily actibvity, did you guys condemn this?

Amir
Youth of Nuer are the ones fighting and destroying civilians property, how do you expect Bor youth to be disarmed, do you mean you want them to be venurable to rebels who always come to loot their cattle?

If your guess is as good as mind, today’s victims are tomorrow’s perpetrators. The people in the camps are soldiers who enter the cocoon after town change hand and come out another time to town revert to those they identify with.

Land ownership and conflict of laws in South Sudan 2015-08-01 05:39:05
By Ajo Noel Julious K.
Land in South Sudan is a prickly thing, complicated even further by the confusion associated with legal land ownership. The parallels and discrepancies between provisions (...)

In memoirs of Dr John Garang de Mabior 2015-07-30 06:14:54
By Mabor Maker Dhelbeny
The event of commemorating this day, as a memorial day of our martyrs since 1955 to 2005 was because of the Late Dr John Garang de Mabior. He died in a helicopter plane (...)