This $9 Eyeliner Was the Most-Popular Eyeliner at CVS in 2016

Beauty-product recommendations are hardcore subjective. The skin-clearing toner that transforms your face into an ethereal angel may break your friend’s out in hives, and the super-creamy lipstick that your friend swears by might make your mouth look like a flaky, shriveled grape. But the one recommendation you can’t argue with? The one that’s chosen by numbers—cold, hard, numbers, like those on CVS’s list of the most-sold beauty products of 2016. Yeah, get excited.

But the top, best-of-the-best, all-purpose eyeliner across all CVS purchases in 2016 was the Revlon ColorStay Eyeliner in literally any of its seven colors (which include an eggplant, forest green, and sapphire blue, because why not?), with CoverGirl Perfect Point Plus Eyeliner in Black Onyx winning the title of the best-selling black eyeliner of all CVS eyeliners. Not only are these eyeliners under $9 each, but both come with a built-in smudger and self-sharpener, so you have literally no reason not to fall in love with both of these products.

Photo: CVS

Check out the rest of the best-selling CVS list (in no particular order), and then head over to the drugstore a.s.a.p. to pick up literally every single thing below.