The exclusive sneak peek of tonight’s White Collar episode that you’ll see below is one of the funniest scenes between Neal (Matt Bomer) and Jones (Sherif Atkins) I’ve ever seen, and, of course, it involves Peter (Tim DeKay) too.

In the scene, Peter is having an exchange with a fellow FBI agent, who Neal and Jones quickly determine is no stranger. In fact, using their powers of perception, they put together the pieces of this puzzle, with juicy results.

The episode, which marks the directorial debut of cast member Willie Garson, airs tonight on USA.