Pages

Total Pageviews

Saturday, June 2, 2012

Will the Dustin Jenson Tragedy Teach Us Something? UPDATED 7/14/2012

For those who are not aware, a young man named Dustin Jenson died this week subsequent to a 5/18 unregulated amateur MMA bout in South Dakota in which he tapped to a triangle choke. Shortly after, he had a seizure, was hospitalized, had surgery to address cerebral edema, and sadly died 12 days later. This is such a sad story on many levels. My thoughts and prayers go out to Dustin's family, friends and training partners. Also to the coaches and promoter. Nobody wishes this to happen on their watch.

I do want to share some thoughts as I believe this sad event highlights our sport's dark shadow...the amateur ranks. I had a few conversations with Steven Marrocco and Nick Lembo of the New Jersey Athletic Control Board about this tragedy. Here is a compilation of thoughts I shared with them. I am sharing with you because I feel this is a discussion that needs to be taking place within our sport.

Dustin Jenson fought in Ring Wars four times since January 27; that's 4 fights in less than 4 months.

As per Ring Wars' Facebook (they don't even have a website that I can find) Jenson fought on:

Ring Wars 74 on May 18, 2012 (the one after which he died)

Ring Wars 73 on April 21, 2012 (he won via tap, can't find a video)

Ring Wars 71 on Feb 24, 2012 (he got badly KO'd) Less than 3 months prior to the bout after which he died. In a state with regulation of amateurs, he would have most likely been suspended for 90 days...it was a real bad KO. Not being permitted to fight again until Dr.'s OK to assess the state of the post KO concussion. Meaning, he would never have been able to fight on April 21 or May 18.

Ring Wars 70 on Jan 27, 2012 (he wins via tko)

Tracking records and prior injuries of fighters in these unsanctioned/unregulated amateur events is very difficult. I face this all the time when trying to assess the background of my own fighters' opponents. I can't locate Jenson's supposed 5th fight. But, I have to say that this is such a sad story on several levels. Especially when one considers that were the bouts regulated (which they may not have been as amateur bouts are often not regulated by state athletic commissions or any kind of national sanctioning body), Jenson may not have been allowed to fight on the show that killed him.

It shows questionable judgement on the part of Jenson's coach (who as it turns out is also the promoter of Ring Wars). This kid should not have been fighting...regardless of regulation. Yet, can we blame coaches and promoters who don't know any better? No we can't. This unfortunate tragedy highlights problems, not only with unregulated fights (pro and amateur), but also untrained coaches and promoters who may have had the best of intentions.

When the fighter's coach is also the event promoter, that is an added problem. As an aside, I used to promote events and as a rule never put my own guys on the fight cards. The only thing worse than actual bias from a promoter is the appearance of bias from a promoter.

Standards for pro regulation are not ubiquitous among state and tribal commissions, but amateurs are much worse...or none in many cases. This sad story is an example of why unified regulation standards - of pro and amateur MMA - is so important. It shows why coaching education is critical as well. Many coaches in these small local shows have no idea what they are doing, how to assess for medical concerns, how to prepare fighters for a bout, etc.

In fact, to get a pro second's license for MMA it is essentially a matter of paying a fee and filling out some papers. This is an area of serious need for improvement in our sport. There is no baseline education required.

Unlike amateur boxing, in which there is a national standard that includes coaching education long before coaches take fighters into the pro ranks, MMA has nothing. The fact that MMA started as a pro sport and is trying to re-engineer the amateur sport after the fact is a serious problem.

When you take the foundation USA Boxing Level 1 Coach Training (required for any coach that has a fighter in any USA Boxing event - there are 4 levels of training in total), you learn that after a head blow stoppage USA Boxing standards are: 30 day immediate suspension, 90 days if fighter is unresponsive for under 2 min, 180 days if fighter is unresponsive for over 2 minutes. Dr. clearance to fight again.

In the KO Jenson suffered on February 24 he was out for the last 1:10 of the video...who knows how long after. I am only pointing this out in within the context of amateur boxing where there is a standard to go by. There are no national amateur MMA standards to compare to. While MMA pros can generally expect an immediate 60 day suspension after a KO (or longer), what is standard in pro MMA does not apply as this was not a pro fight, nor was it regulated.

Having said all this, regulation, pre-fight medicals, etc, may have not saved Jenson (let's not forget that the two other US MMA deaths were on regulated shows). But, I think we all would have preferred the requirement and opportunity. And, I feel in my gutt that if this kid had been suspended after the KO on Feb 24, he would be alive today.

Our sport needs to learn from this horrible event. Let's take care of our amateurs.

STORY UPDATE: Fight likely cause of death, but eveidence not conclusive according coronor.

The coroner's autopsy report was released on July 12, 2012. According to the Rapid City Journal

"the cause of death was a subdural hemorrhage resulting from blunt force trauma to the head. A subdural hemorrhage is a collection of blood on the surface of the brain and often causes brain injury and death. The cause was related to an injury about a week earlier [before hiss death, not the fight], according to the autopsy. The Sheriff's Office said there is no conclusive evidence the injury was sustained in the fight."

"The autopsy indicates Jenson's cause of death was a subdural hemorrhage due to blunt force trauma to the head that was related to an injury approximately a week prior [to his death, not the fight]. The Coroner's Office went onto say the injury is consistent with the Ringwars event, but there is no conclusive evidence that the injury was sustained in the fight."

"According to a news release, the autopsy indicated the cause of death was a subdural hemorrhage, due to blunt force trauma to the head, that was related to an injury approximately a week prior. Although the timeline for the injury is consistent with the event on May 18, 2012, there is no conclusive evidence that the injury was sustained in the fight."

3 comments:

I got a 30 day suspension in Ohio after I got TKO'd. But If I had wanted to fight in another state, it would have been no problem whatsoever. The sport definitely needs to be organized on a more national level to prevent these sort of abuses.

Even after a tragedy like this, legislators in South Dakota still try to keep regulation out with ignorant rationale like this from Representative Steve Hickey: http://www.argusleader.com/videonetwork/2185016435001/Rep-Hickey-Mixed-Martial-Arts-is-the-child-porn-of-sports-

About The Coalition

Coalition to Legalize Mixed Martial Arts in New York: A non-partisan group of organizations, gyms, business owners, and individuals who volunteer to support the legalization and regulation of mixed martial arts in the state of New York. For information about how you can help us, contact Stephen Koepfer at 718-728-8054, follow on Twitter @sambosteve, or e-mail NYMMANOW@gmail.com

SUPPORT NY MMA

If you would like to support the ongoing educational and lobby efforts of the Coalition to Legalize Mixed Martial Arts in New York, please click the button below. Thanks for your generosity! For suggested donations, check our Donor page. Let's bring MMA to NY!