Are One Direction the new Beatles?

They obviously have the talent, and they are prompting the same levels of hysteria we saw when the Beatles were at the height of their fame. I can see Liam becoming the new Paul McCartney and Harry the new Lennon.

They obviously have the talent, and they are prompting the same levels of hysteria we saw when the Beatles were at the height of their fame. I can see Liam becoming the new Paul McCartney and Harry the new Lennon.

Agreed.

That's the first thing I thought when General Zod put them together at bootcamp.

They obviously have the talent, and they are prompting the same levels of hysteria we saw when the Beatles were at the height of their fame. I can see Liam becoming the new Paul McCartney and Harry the new Lennon.

Don't be absurd.

They're talented boys but the Beatles? The biggest top-selling-band of all time?

Don't forget the Beatles were considered as a teeny pop band in the beginning. Harry writes a lot of songs, that in time will probably be considered as classic as "Let It Be" and "She Loves You".
Yeah, yeah, yeah

Don't forget the Beatles were considered as a teeny pop band in the beginning. Harry writes a lot of songs, that in time will probably be considered as classic as "Let It Be" and "She Loves You".
Yeah, yeah, yeah

They obviously have the talent, and they are prompting the same levels of hysteria we saw when the Beatles were at the height of their fame. I can see Liam becoming the new Paul McCartney and Harry the new Lennon.

They are a manufactured pop band with no demonstrated song-writing skills.

I'd love if one of the tasks on the X factor was that the contestants had to write their own song...

Either way One Direction are not the new Beatles going on what we've seen of them so far... but I think you are just windiing people up anyway

They obviously have the talent, and they are prompting the same levels of hysteria we saw when the Beatles were at the height of their fame. I can see Liam becoming the new Paul McCartney and Harry the new Lennon.

They are a manufactured pop band with no demonstrated song-writing skills.

I'd love if one of the tasks on the X factor was that the contestants had to write their own song...

Either way One Direction are not the new Beatles going on what we've seen of them so far... but I think you are just windiing people up anyway

You couldn't rule out $imon saying something like that at the weekend. as some of the hype about some distinctly average performances from distinctly average performers has gone into hyperdrive this year.

They obviously have the talent, and they are prompting the same levels of hysteria we saw when the Beatles were at the height of their fame. I can see Liam becoming the new Paul McCartney and Harry the new Lennon.

Op I don't mean to be rude but I don't think any of them has the talent the Beatles had no way whatsoever.