The stock initially rallied after a better-than-expected showing last time out, with adjusted revenue and earnings per share rising 16% and 14%, respectively. The shares initially rallied on the strong report, and Wall Street gave it a standing ovation. However, Dave & Buster's stock has gone on to surrender all of those gains, and it's back to trading below where it was just before early April's monster report.

Continue Reading Below

One can argue that the stock's recent slide discounts a rough quarter this week, but the other side of that coin is that the shares can bounce back into favor with another strong earnings release. We'll know the answer soon, as Dave & Buster's reports shortly after Tuesday's market close.

Token of appreciation

Analysts are holding out for solid yet decelerating growth on both ends of the income statement in the upcoming report. They see revenue rising nearly 12% to top $370 million with a profit of $1.12 a share. Dave & Buster's checked in with earnings of $1.04 a share during last fiscal year's first quarter.

The only real surprise in the report is if Dave & Buster's doesn't earn quite a bit more than $1.12 a share. The "eatertainment" chain has done nothing but trounce Wall Street earnings expectations.

Quarter

EPS Estimate

EPS Actual

Surprise

Q1 2018

$0.93

$1.04

12%

Q2 2018

$0.67

$0.84

25%

Q3 2018

$0.24

$0.30

25%

Q4 2018

$0.63

$0.75

19%

Advertisement

Dave & Buster's has come through with double-digit percentage beats every quarter over the past year. It routinely offers conservative guidance, and momentum continues to be in its corner. However, a beat isn't enough. Dave & Buster's wouldn't be trading closer to its 52-week low than its all-time high two years ago if topping bottom-line targets was enough. In fact, comps were negative in three of these four blowout reports.

Analysts tend to rally following the better-than-expected results, and in April, that meant BMO Capital and Maxim pushing their price targets higher. Andrew Strelzik at BMO Capital was impressed with the all-around beat, dismissing the chain's ho-hum guidance for all of fiscal 2019 as conservative. The goal as he saw it at the time was for Dave & Buster's to keep the positive comps going into the second quarter of this year when it laps last year's initial virtual reality launch.

Stephen Anderson at Maxim was encouraged to see continuing strength in Dave & Buster's amusements business and a return to positive comps on the food and beverage end of its business for the first time in two years. He boosted his full-year earnings outlook following the chain's ambitious stock buyback plan.

Strelzik's and Anderson's price targets were raised to $66 and $67, respectively. The stock is well below those marks now, so it won't be a shock if they lower their price goals and maintain their bullish ratings even if we see a strong report. This is a game that never ends, and Dave & Buster's stock will be on the move this week.

10 stocks we like better than Dave & Buster's EntertainmentWhen investing geniuses David and Tom Gardner have a stock tip, it can pay to listen. After all, the newsletter they have run for over a decade, Motley Fool Stock Advisor, has quadrupled the market.*

David and Tom just revealed what they believe are the ten best stocks for investors to buy right now... and Dave & Buster's Entertainment wasn't one of them! That's right -- they think these 10 stocks are even better buys.