Caron Cakes Review: Is This The Best New Yarn Ever?

I bravely tried a brand spankin’ new yarn this week to bring you this Caron Cakes review! I hope you find it helpful!

If you spend time in any crochet groups online, you’ve probably seen a lot of buzz about this new self-striping yarn with the cutest name ever! Caron Cakes, aptly named because it resembles a stripy dessert, is sold exclusively at Michaels. I scooted right over there as soon as I saw this yarn! I had to get my hands on this smooshy, super-colorful yarn ASAP!

It seems like people either love Caron Cakes or absolutely hate it, so I thought I’d do a little Caron Cakes review now that I’ve had a chance to make a project with it.

(Note: This is NOT a sponsored post. I bought my yarn the old fashioned way and all opinions are my own. ;))

Caron Cakes Review

So! Is it the best new yarn ever? The answer to this question depends on what you like to do with your yarn. 🙂

Background Bias Disclosure

When I started playing with yarn, I was a knitter who kind of looked down her nose at crocheting and manmade fibers, as any self-respecting knitter who was a fan of the Yarn Harlot c. 2006 would. (Imagine!) I would not have touched acrylic yarn with a 10 foot knitting needle.

I eventually learned how to crochet so I could make amigurumi. As I got older and wiser, I came to the realization that using only natural fibers would become prohibitively expensive if I continued tearing through my yarn stash with a crochet hook.

So I *ahem* relaxed my standards a little.

Now if it looks like yarn, and sometimes even if it doesn’t, it ends up on a hook or the needles.

Fiber Content

Caron Cakes is 80% acrylic, 20% wool. It is SUPER soft. When I picked up the skein I was really surprised by how light it felt. It looked heavier because it is such a large yarn cake. That may be because it is short and squat rather than elongated like most commercially made skeins. I think this yarn also contains 50% fluffy puffs of air.

Colors

I bought two skeins to play with: Funfetti (purples, oranges, pink) and Rainbow Sprinkles (red, orange, yellow, blue, green). These two colors are really vibrant! I mean they are POW IN YOUR FACE hello I am colorful vibrant! I decided to use the Funfetti for this Caron Cakes review, and noticed that the purples had a very, very slight heathered appearance. Behold!

When you see photos of this yarn, you see bright color, but up close the colors have more nuance than that. You can see where drips of the dye splashed onto adjacent colors – faintly, but enough to add interest and depth to your finished work.

Handfeel

Caron Cakes yarn is a joy to work with! It isn’t splitty like some acrylic/wool blends can be, and it isn’t squeaky like some of the other Caron yarns I’ve used. It isn’t scratchy at all. If I had to compare it to something, I would say it feels like a nicer Paton’s, but much less dense. It feels light as it glides through your fingers.

Criticism

Around the watercooler, the biggest complaints about this yarn seem to be:

abrupt color changes

it’s itchy

long color runs

Let’s start with the colors. Yep, the color runs are long and it changes abruptly. You will be hooking along PINK pink pink pink pink…ORANGE orange orange…NEW ORANGE new orange new orange… If you like to determine precisely where color changes happen in a project, this yarn probably isn’t for you. Unless you are way more awesome at planning than I am, you’re going to have a sudden color change in the most inconvenient spot. That’s just Murphy’s Law.

The color runs are long. So, if you’re the kind of person who likes to work on small projects like hats or amigurumi, you’re probably not going to love this yarn. At best you’ll only get to see 2 or 3 of the colors in your project.

Yes, you could just go pick out five different colored yarns and accomplish the same color changing effect. I like not having to think about color and weave in ends that for a change, since I mostly make amigurumi. Using Caron Cakes yarn is relaxing for me!

Is it itchy? You might think it is if you are used to working with acrylic yarn. When I first touched acrylic yarn after working exclusively with wool and alpaca for years, I had to keep stopping to wash my hands because SQUICK SQUICK SQUEAKY.

UPDATE: A reader asked about washing/drying (Thanks! I can’t believe I forgot that!). The care instructions recommend hand wash/lay flat to dry, which makes sense because it is 20% wool. This might impact the practicality of using this yarn for items that need frequent washing – baby blankets and garments, bedspreads, etc. – if you don’t like to wash things by hand.

I have a front loading washing machine with a delicate cycle that hasn’t hurt anything wooly yet, so I’ll try a swatch in the washer and give you an update on how it comes out.

It’s all in what you are used to. So far, the people I’ve seen with the “it itches” complaints are crocheters who usually work with synthetic fibers (or are allergic to wool). So take the itchy criticism for what it’s worth and go squeeze a skein for yourself.

Some people just hate wool.

The Verdict

Of all of the new yarns I’ve tried recently, this is the yarn I am most excited about! It’s floofy, it’s pretty, and I love how it works up. I made a V-eekender Shawl because I thought if the project grew out from the middle, the number of rows I’d get out of each color would vary and be more interesting. I was right!

I love how my shawl turned out. Well, I say “my shawl” but this one will be sold at a vendor event I have coming up in October.

Here’s how much yarn I had left (I eliminated two pattern repeats…so I cut it pretty close!)

I will definitely be picking up a few many more skeins of this yarn. I’ve heard that this may be a limited edition yarn so if you are on the fence, go grab it now!

Have you tried it yet? What do you think? Show me what you’ve made!

Thank you for reading my Caron Cakes review! Don’t forget to pin and share if you found it helpful!

Pssssst. Are you on Instagram? Come say hi so I can stalk you check out your awesomeness!

Reader Interactions

Comments

Hi Pam! The care instructions on the label say “hand wash, lay flat to dry,” which makes sense because it contains wool. This is a fantastic question and I’m going to update the blog post to include this information. Thank you!

I saw this yarn in Michaels and came home to check it out online before buying. Unbelievably I can’t find it on the Yarnspirations website under Caron or anywhere else for that matter. Am I missing something? I was looking to find out what pattern suggestions they offered.

Thank you for your review. I thought just by looking at the ball that the colours had long runs in them and then changed very abruptly. I really wish they had blended more gently and not had so many feet between colours.

Hi Jordi! The Caron Cakes are only appearing on the Michaels Stores websites right now, since they are exclusive to those stores at the moment. Last time I checked, there weren’t pattern recommendations on the Michaels site. BUT, I did a post the other day with some pattern ideas (both paid and free) that might help you: http://www.jensalittleloopy.com/caron-cakes-pattern-ideas/ There are also lots of finished projects popping on up Ravelry for even more ideas. Thanks for stopping by to check out the review! =)

Hello Jen! Found Caron Cakes (CC) at Michaels on my weekly yarn run (don’t always buy but a lot of visual candy). Fell in love with yarn and bought “Rainbow” color to make a scarf for my adult daughter who is an artist. Used pattern on packaging and it is nice and simple. Yarn is beautiful and lovely to work with. I don’t find it itchy at all. You will notice how soft it is once you start to knit your pattern. I love long color run but to change pattern a bit, I cut yarn in between run and adjusted colorway. A lot easier than buying several colors of yarn etc. I am now looking at making a baby blanket so I am pleased that wash on gentle and cold dry would work well. Thanks to all of you who made comments and to you Jen for your overview of this new yarn.

Hi Susan – the yardage is 383 yd. / 350 m. It’s a medium worsted, so just slightly thicker than Red Heart SS or I Love This Yarn. If you are a fan of the long color runs but not a fan of wool, Premier Yarns has a yarn coming out in October that you might like: Sweet Roll. That is a three color cake and is 100% acrylic. I’m really excited to try it — the colors look gorgeous! Keep your eyes peeled! =) Thanks for reading my review! =)

Thanks for the review! I just bought myself 4 cakes and am trying to decide what to make. I clicked on your review first and I don’t think I need search any further 🙂 Just one question where in the pattern did you eliminate two pattern repeats please?

Hi Jen,
Thank you for the great review. I am like you. When I read/heard all the hype about this yarn I hurried over to Michaels and purchased 2 skeins of cherry chip. It is not what I am used to using, because I have always used only the natural fiber yarns. However, these Caron Cakes are so pretty and soft, I just had to try them. I chose to make a baby blanket with the yarn I bought. This was a bad choice because of the different colors in this yarn. The yarn would work for a shawl or sweater I think, but not a baby blanket. It could be the pattern I chose too. I can’t say if I love or hate this yarn yet. I will know when I finish this project in another day or two. I will take a picture of it and send it to you, then you can tell me what you think!!

Oh my goodness the Life of Change pattern is gorgeous! I just added it to my queue! Thank you for pointing it out, I hadn’t seen that one before. 🙂 I am so glad that Caron Cakes will be sticking around for awhile!

To Shelley Z. Must be an oddity as I went through 2 skeins without any knots. I would write to Michaels headquarters in Texas and complain. I have brought the knot situation on one of their other yarns to their attention and was reimbursed. You might do well since Cakes is a new yarn and knitters depend on the established color ways to complete projects.

I’m making a bed cover for my 12y using a modified version of the mosaic pattern. I bought 8 cakes, need at least 2 more! I absolutely love the Funfetti colors. I have no doubt that once washed it will be very nice and soft.

Thanks Sandy! I didn’t cut the yarn for my shawl, but I know other people have done it. I think I just got lucky, but if you look closely you can see I did have colors start in weird places. That doesn’t bother me so much.

I purchased the premier sweet roll cakes before the Caron yarn was available. It is wonderful to work with. The color runs are long and do switch suddenly but the colors are beautiful. I crochet blankets for charity collections so the fact that this can be machine washed and dried is perfect. It is soft and fluffy. I’ll definitely be getting some more.

Thanks for your review. I did a corner to corner blanket for a baby in the colorway Boston Cream Pie. I washed it on the gentle cycle and dried with no heat, it came out even softer. I also cut the color to avoid an abrupt color change.

Have been crocheting with wool, acrylics, wool/acrylic blends (like Lionbrand Wool-Ease) for 20+ years. Purchased Caron Cakes yarn during a promotion from Michael’s. First thing I noticed is that the yarn I received has a strong “chemical” smell combined with the smell I associate with wool. Last night I worked for several hours on a cowl pattern and noticed a red, swollen, very angry rash developing on my forearms. Yikes. I finished the project which was to be a gift. I’m afraid that there is some chemical used in processing that is highly irritating. Will try washing the cowl. Haven’t heard any complaints from the many happy “Cakes” fans but I won’t buy again.

I was searching to see if anyone else had gotten a rash from using this yarn and sure enough someone else did. I started using it on Tuesday night and woke up with a rash on my right forearm. I didn’t connect it with the yarn at first. So I continued using it on Wednesday and by Wednesday night started seeing the rash on my left forearm. My husband said could it be the yarn? So I decided to do some searching. I want to finish my project so I am thinking maybe I can knit with latex gloves when I use this yarn and a long sleeve shirt so it doesn’t touch my skin. I hope washing my finished blanket might help. I will keep reading comments to see if anyone else has had this problem. I see doubleshort’s comment was a year and a half ago.

Hi, have you heard of any complaints re the cakes ? I bought two Macaroon cakes. I didn’t realize one is missing an outer yellow color. It also had purple yarn barf. It doesn’t appear to have been cut. I was curious if anyone else has experienced this. Thank you !

There are definitely irregularities with the cakes sometimes. I’m working with Cherry Chip now and have found 6 knots in the skein, which is really messing with the length of the color repeats. Yarn barf is typical for these cakes, though. I still love them, but consistency from skein to skein is not their strong suit.

I love this yarn! Yes I had a knot in one ball, I will contact Michaels. BUT — I need to edge my blocks that I’m making. Do you have a recommendation for a solid yarn that will works with the Caron Cakes yarn?

Hi Melody! Ooof, I feel your pain! About half of my skeins have had knots in them, and two of the skeins had multiple knots. My workaround was cutting the knots out and weaving in the ends, but if I wanted to do the extra weaving in work I would have just bought separate skeins of yarn! 😉 I still love Caron Cakes though. They do a fantastic job with the color selections.

[…] are so many different yarn cakes these days I can’t even keep up! I’ve tried the Caron Cakes (LOVE LOVE) and the Sweet Rolls (okay but a little squeaky for my taste). I haven’t spotted the Bernat […]

So many pins, so little time!

Footer

Instagram

I'm on a mission to empower women to have crafty misadventures by encouraging them to make time for creativity; try new products and techniques; and have fun while making lots of mistakes. My core belief is that any creative project can be improved by adding a cute face to it. Read More →

This site uses cookies to personalize content and ads, to provide social media features, and for site analytics. By using this website you consent to the terms and conditions contained in the Disclosures/Privacy Policy.Accept CookiesRead more