Mr. Phread and Mr. Juggernaut,
I already read all the pages here (Was like reading War and Peace ). I was just surprised, that you don't need to play various scenarios. Most of the people mentioned here, that you need to playmore scenarios on all the theaters.
Anyway, thanks for investigation and sharing the information here to all of you guys!

I won on all maps, so both sides,and more than 20 wins on every map,432 plays, and still I am a Major

I will try to help you, some questions:
Do you have ten wins as Axis and ten wins as Allies in each theatre? ( not counting the newer ones, see first post)
Has all this been after your promotion to Major? (previous wins do not count here)

If so then you might try this (speculations not certainties):
Play more Majors
Play more different ranks

If you win all the maps as Axis & allies you got more then 20 wins, for instance, Western, excluding the ones that do not count, you have 32 wins, or does the counting go like this?
You have to win from 1 scenario,for instance St.Vith 10 x Axis and 10 x Allies?

Look I have for instance now 7 wins for First assault wave for Axis, so I need 3 more, for Axis, then I got for instance for Alies 6 wins on St mere Eglise,so I need 3 wins on a other front? Or if I win 10 lonely fronts I can count them as 10 too?

Look I have for instance now 7 wins for First assault wave for Axis, so I need 3 more, for Axis, then I got for instance for Alies 6 wins on St mere Eglise,so I need 3 wins on a other front? Or if I win 10 lonely fronts I can count them as 10 too?

However, I remember someting about "beating your peers", meaning you have to beat other majors, ain't it right ?

To Goekawar : I really think it's not very "fair-play" to play vs cadets on Red Barricade Factory...

That's me, but I used to only play cadets on western front and "no more rules than western front" maps (Tunisia, Montelimar, Gallabat, Toulon).
The only exception is joining an open game, finding a cadet waiting to play japs, russians or ergs !

And about RBF, I never invited someone with less than 60 games, asking most of the time (when my opponent did have less than about a 100 games) "do you know that map ?".
It's so tricky, technical and complex, that it would have meant no glory beating a cadet or 6-games 2nd lieutenant on that one.
I even remember playing vs a major (IIRC) who DID NOT know the map, obviously, and was so upset during the game (complexity, mines, snipers, anti-tanks obstacles, medals on buildings..., I still don't know) that he did throw a damaged tank on mines, just to finish the game, when I was leading 9-x.

May be a non issue at this point, but having kept records, I am certain that it is 10 / side / theater AS a Major...

I agree, for Lt. Colonel you need to all this after becoming a Major.

And it is never a non issue. Maybe this promotionseeker has been helped, but there will be more!

@Goekawar, if you have ten wins in each front as each side and are not promoted. Hunt for your peers, fight other Majors and maybe ranks above that. As said before we still do not know everything there is to know about this promotion.

The idea that requirements for promotion were not publicized in a specific, step by step manner *is* perhaps unique ( ish ) to Memoir as far as on line gaming goes, but it does mirror the real world - at least the military...

Goeka : Start a list - you'll probably not need it more than a few days. Van Voort has done a lot of looking at the records for you - just start where he left off as of 7/7 @ 22:09

10 wins on each side in each theatre after promotion to Major.. 80 wins in total.

I'm not sure where the problem is.

The 80 wins are certainly neccessary, but there are a bunch of people who managed this and were not promoted after reaching this goal. So, as we might suspect of DoW by now, there is some other requirement that we have not yet fathomed out. We mostly focus on the beating of peers and advise them to play more majors. Playing some more games has helped all of them gain the promotion but we are still uncertain what specific requirement has been met then.

( this is actually mine - I'm assuming it will default to yours when you use the link - if not, perhaps just chop off everything after career/ )

Achievements ( medals ) and promotions are easy to spot - they are off to the right...

This link indeed links to your (trentdep) career. If you want to go to your own career (GoekaWar) click on your signature banner. Or use the above link substituties trentdepth number with your own (39344). (It might be handy to save it in your browser favourites.