Xoom vs iPad 2

A couple of posts ago I wrote of the Motorola Xoom tablet, extolling its virtues while trying to convince myself that I don’t need one. And truly, I don’t. My little netbook is all the portable computing I really need. What I might want, and might actually get (if it was in the budget), is another question.

This question has recently been complicated by the announcement of Apple’s iPad 2. Uh oh, Motorola, has your leapfrogging the leader been leapfrogged? The short answer appears to be: No.

The most telling comparison I was able to find was over at The Mac Observer. Though one understands they might have a bias, given the name of their site, here’s what they manage to come up with: “The iPad 2 is clearly the best when it comes to size, weight, price, and battery life.” I suppose that’s one way to sell the smaller, lower resolution screen as a good thing.

Of the Xoom’s virtues, they write:

﻿The Xoom is the clear favorite in four categories, starting with its display resolution (1280 x 800 compared to 1024 x 768 for iPad and iPad 2). Some users who fancy holding a tablet up as a camera may fancy the Xoom’s back-camera flash, as well. The Xoom also features stereo speakers, a feature Apple doesn’t offer, and the device includes a full GB of RAM. The iPad featured 256MB, and it appears as if iPad 2 has double that, at 512MB.

What they don’t note, and isn’t clear from the accompanying chart, is the megapixel rating of the iPad 2’s cameras. And don’t go looking for that information on the Apple site, because you won’t find it. That suggests it’s not worth boasting about, so if you’re one of those strange people who, as macobserver puts it, “fancy holding a tablet up as a camera” and care about the resolution of the pictures you take, the choice is clear.

Also missing from their comparison is consideration of support for USB and SD. Again, that may be because the iPad 2 doesn’t support either. The Xoom does both.

Also no mention of support for Flash (though it does come up in the comments). Apple has developed an allergy to Flash, believing that HTML 5, CSS, and javascript are better alternatives. Consequently, iPad 2 offers no support for the junky legacy product. I’m not unsympathetic, having predicted the demise of Flash myself a few columns ago. But here’s the thing — it’s not dead yet.

With regard to price, a not maxed-out version of the iPad 2 will save you a few bucks over the Xoom, but as ﻿Wolfgang Gruener concludes in his article ﻿5 Reasons Why You Should Not Buy The iPad 2, you could save even more “﻿if you . . . consider the original iPad, which we hear is seeing dropping prices. The crappy camera, the software update and the dual-core processor may not be worth the extra expense.” Now may be the best time to buy the original iPad at clear-them-out prices.

One gotcha about the Xoom: While it’s intended to support Flash and SD, it may or may not, depending on the version of the OS. Ask before you buy. If it’s from an earlier batch, you may have some geeking to do to bring it up to scratch.

Nevertheless, it appears as though Apple has gone from first-to-market leader, to having to play catch up. Stay tuned to see if the iPad 3 finally delivers on the promise of the form. Perhaps by that time Flash really will be dead. Hopefully Steve Jobs won’t be.

Oh, Xoom is my dream tablet computer!!!
When I played yesterday with one at BBuy….mmm! Xoom is all I need in one black aluminum case.
Incredible web-browsing. Xoom looks and works like a multimedia candy,
i have only $630 for now:(
I want Xoom 4G sooooooo bad…how to wait for wifi-only verison? No, I need Xoom now….
tomorrow.

The Xoom is not for sale but the ipad / ipad2 is.
Without the machine in our hands, it’s all just speculation and babble.
I may change my mind about the ipad if and when Apples competition can actually sell me something.
Maybe Apples competition will be better but for now it’s all just talk.

The iPad 2 is a joke of an upgrade. They slapped on some really poor quality cameras and a dual-core CPU with very low amount of RAM. . . and made it a bit thinner?!?! Big whoop!

It still lacks standard USB & HDMI ports, SD expansion slot to increase memory, HD screen, stereo speakers, 4G, enough RAM to play HD gamed (1GB–it may only have 256MB RAM, 512 at the most), the 4:3 ratio screen makes it impossible to thumb type, and iOS is so far behind Android Honeycomb for a tablet OS that it’s laughable. So now Steve Jobs tries to say “specs don’t matter” but that’s what he’s always crowing about. Now that they’ve been left in the dust. . .they don’t matter–classic!!!

Anyone that’s looking for a tablet needs to watch some good videos on Honeycomb, go play with the tablets for a while in the store. maybe even wait for some other form factors–Android can support docking to a keyboard and mouse, thus it can be used like a traditional PC. iOS devices CANNOT use a mouse–ever try to work with spreadsheets, long documents, or graphic drawing without a mouse? It’s very frustrating.

Once again, Apple starts “strong” but doesn’t innovate after the first step and gets left behind.

By Alison@Creekside
The most interesting and innovative idea to come out of the first meeting of the all-party Special Committee on Electoral Reform, or ERRE, was Nathan Cullen's suggestion, … [Read More...]

By Jim Henshaw
There have been several bewildered as well as angry accounts coming out of the USA lately about how little media time has been spent covering the Democratic Presidential Primary … [Read More...]

By Frank Moher
On this dreadful day, I don't want to write about the shootings in Orlando. I want to write about my friend, Rick.
Rick lives just outside of Nanaimo, a city of about 80,000, … [Read More...]

By Frank Moher
Two drama nerds have recently moved into high profile positions. Before I name them (or perhaps you’ve already guessed who they are; or perhaps you’d like to scroll down and look at … [Read More...]

Originally published on Our Rape Blog, the author's account of the aftermath of a violent sexual assault.
By Mary Fraughton
Have you ever played Hearts?
It’s a card game. For our purposes, … [Read More...]

From Creekside: The B.C. provincial government is trying to green light the construction of a massive LNG terminal on Lelu Island in the Skeena Estuary -- Pacific Northwest LNG, backed by Malaysian … [Read More...]