Not really a realistic view. Even against 126 tai immunity, I am able to win every once in a while with -53 tai imm and and its not like its crawling with ninkame teams. Why not just leave things the way they are instead of spitting on people who has worked for years to get where they are?

The day Carlimas has spent as much time as Sparhawk lvling his summon you won't stand a chance even if you've spent an equal amount of time on your team. Does that seem fair to you?

Besides the immunity nerf discussion is as much about ls nin teams getting hammered as us having crit teams :)

__________________
Train ninjas and save the world from evil on NinjaManager.com!

The day carli has spar's lvl of summon is years from now if ever so why is it even worth mentioning?

And if you are interested in beating nin imm teams, then tai is the answer, not nerfing imm until its beatable with nin.

Why is it not worth mentioning? What is discussed here is really long term camping or did you miss that? Besides Carli won't need much more nin-kame lvls before leaving you behind for good and it won't take years. He'll always have 50% win rate regardless of your crit dmg and he's probably beating quite alot even if you're doing well on the crits and that part will only increase more and more untill he has 100% win chance against you. There are quite a decent amount of active teams with lvl 40 ish nin-kames and most of them are red fox or purple fox campers so your previous argument of the low amoung of nin-kame users is not really valid.

Also ls nin can't beat any1 as it is now, atk campers have no real shot at beating immunity teams either so I don't really get why you're against an immunity nerf? It is clearly overpowered and should be first priority on the list of fixing.

__________________
Train ninjas and save the world from evil on NinjaManager.com!

Why is it not worth mentioning? What is discussed here is really long term camping or did you miss that? Besides Carli won't need much more nin-kame lvls before leaving you behind for good and it won't take years. He'll always have 50% win rate regardless of your crit dmg and he's probably beating quite alot even if you're doing well on the crits and that part will only increase more and more untill he has 100% win chance against you. There are quite a decent amount of active teams with lvl 40 ish nin-kames and most of them are red fox or purple fox campers so your previous argument of the low amoung of nin-kame users is not really valid.

Also ls nin can't beat any1 as it is now, atk campers have no real shot at beating immunity teams either so I don't really get why you're against an immunity nerf? It is clearly overpowered and should be first priority on the list of fixing.

What you are doing is trying to predict what will happen. My answer is, why not wait and see if thats really how it will turn out?

And no I still dont think imm is OP, ninkame can be countered with nin and katsuyu can be countered with tai and crit. Its just a matter of matching teams against eachother. Dont get greedy and try to win against all possible teams.

Crit has been known to have this 100%+ issue ever since it was implemented but at that time no one thought anyone would get such high levels. But it did, several years ago even. It needs to be fixed and that's the end of the story. Almost no teams will even notice the fix so whining about it is just plain pointless.

The task at hand is to do it and do it properly. Not discuss weather or not it needs it, for it does.

The task at hand is to do it and do it properly. Not discuss weather or not it needs it, for it does.

That being said I think further discussions should be based on immunity being nerfed at the same time in a quite large ninjamanager makeover? I think by assuming immunity/-immunity will get a dimminishing returns formula/soft cap we can get a constructive process started here.

If that is done I don't see why we couldn't introduce a similar system for cd at 100%. Since the immunity summons will get more and more useless the higher lvld they are I don't see the same problem with the crit summons anymore. In fact atk camping will get a decent advantage over other team types so that they can be balanced. Atk summons will be weaker in the beginning but stronger later in camping. Just some ideas from me, not 100% processed tho so pls don't bash me ;D

__________________
Train ninjas and save the world from evil on NinjaManager.com!

I guess the great man with all the answers has spoken. I better shut up.
But I cant. You just said that almost no teams will even notice it. Except me. Thanks.

This right here took away anything your post might of had behind them. You seem to be doing more complaining then good and its like your taking it personally (which you even said in one post that you are).

Your point is "The point I've been trying to make is that there is no solid proof that crit needs to be nerfed at all." (And that imm doesnt need to be nerfed either)

Your point however is hidden under the complaining and taking this personally.

Yes I'm taking it partially personal because I'm the only active player at this point in top 50 who would be affected but I have a lot to gain by imm being nerfed but all I see is imm becoming less and less useful. And now when xagashi and spar is starting to get beat, the imm is being nerfed? The timing just seems a bit off.

In my opinion the timing is because of all the things being added. The more Immune, -Imm, Crit damage and crit chance Summons/ FNKs/ ETC. that are being added makes the problem a lot more apparent and a lot more obvious that it needs to be fixed. And also a lot more of a priority sense it is a lot easier to exploit.

Why is it not worth mentioning? What is discussed here is really long term camping or did you miss that? Besides Carli won't need much more nin-kame lvls before leaving you behind for good and it won't take years. He'll always have 50% win rate regardless of your crit dmg and he's probably beating quite alot even if you're doing well on the crits and that part will only increase more and more untill he has 100% win chance against you. There are quite a decent amount of active teams with lvl 40 ish nin-kames and most of them are red fox or purple fox campers so your previous argument of the low amoung of nin-kame users is not really valid.

1) In my opinion I do have 100% win rate against any regular tai based team when I use my strongest lineup (62-50-83-40-40-126 Tai immu)
There is no way of beating tai immunity with pure tai/crit power, you need other factors to kick in - elemental damage, stamina penalties, LOTS of luck on crits and etc.
2) There are 5 ninkame teams in top50 summons list (37lvl or higher).

Only cap Critical Damage bonus to at most 100% That way it will still have a 50/50 shot at beating a similarly levelled/equipped LS Nin team with UNCAPPED Reroll chance. And only cap Critical Damage IF you cap Taijutsu Immunity to below 100% as well. And if you cap Taijutsu Immunity, you should cap Ninjutsu Immunity. And if you cap Ninjutsu Immunity you should cap Reroll. And if you cap Reroll you should cap +/- Attack Damage. And if you cap +/- Attack Damage you should cap Elemental Advantage. And if you cap Elemental Advantage you should remove L5 Death. And if you remove L5 Death you should make it so FN only fit in their appropriate slots (1 FNK per team being the most pertinent) maybe even just doubling the stamina penalty or Chakra cost for misslotting Forbidden Ninjas would be enough.