Re: What eyeshadow palette do you regret purchasing?

MUFE Midnight Glow. The colors looked beautiful and I wanted to like it so badly!! But they were barely pigmented and did not show up on my lids even with a good primer. This baby went back to Sephora.

Also, Too Faced Shadow Bon Bons. Love the mascara and primer it came with, but this palette is seriously fallout city!! I still use it sometimes, but it is really annoying to deal with

Re: What eyeshadow palette do you regret purchasing?

Re: What eyeshadow palette do you regret purchasing?

I almost never use Naked 1 either. I use Toasted, and the matte brown shade in there. Other than that I don't really like the other colors in there. I hate the last two shades which are loaded with glitter.

Re: What eyeshadow palette do you regret purchasing?

Definitely the Naked 2 for me. It is the last palette I ever reach for because the colors and looks I can create are just so boring and don't really make my blue eyes stand out much. I wish I had returned it.

Re: What eyeshadow palette do you regret purchasing?

If I could get WOS (Walk of Shame) on its own, I would probably go through it quickly - but I rarely use Foxy. I think there's a shade or two like that in every palette and small palettes make it more obvious/feel like more of a waste.

Re: What eyeshadow palette do you regret purchasing?

I can't recall the name - but it was Urban Decay and all the colors looked black when they were on. In the container they looked green, purple, etc. - but on the skin they were really pretty much black. I ended up throwing it away after it gathered dust for a couple years. I don't really love any of my Urban Decay palletts and I have not bought the Nakeds for that reason. Too much glitter and fallout in too many of their other colors.

Re: What eyeshadow palette do you regret purchasing?

Largely agree with y'all. I do love the colors, but there is a very fine line between enough color and way too much with that palette. Often, I would use it when going out to metal shows, and if I got too much on, just tried to balance it and call it heroin chic. In comparison, the Smoked palette is more user friendly. Still, I think of it as a challenge I'd like to master at some point before I'm 60, lol.

Re: What eyeshadow palette do you regret purchasing?

I bought a bunch of Too Faced palettes all at once and regretted every one of them. Chalky, not enough of a range of colors.

I love my Kat Von D palettes but kind of regret buying Poetica - I have Sinner, Saint, Ludwig, and Ladybird and Poetica is just too warm and the colors it does have that work have better counterparts in the other palettes.

Re: What eyeshadow palette do you regret purchasing?

It has fewer mattes than Naked 1, which is sad because I love matte shadow. It's more cool-toned than Naked 1, so if you have a warm complexion, I'd go with Naked 1. Overall, I like it, I just don't reach for it as often as I do others because it's so shimmery. I picked it over Naked 2 because it felt more wearable - I've still debated going back and getting Naked 2 to see which I like better, in reality.

Re: What eyeshadow palette do you regret purchasing?

The only palette I own that I regret buying is the KVD Poetica palette. The shade I was most excited about (the purple duochrome) is really underwhelming even over a white base, it just looks like a plain lavender. The two dark matte colors I'm not a fan of either, they have this chunky glitter and are a pain to blend. And, the eyeliner that came with the palette smudges terribly on me. I'm trying to make the orange/copper color work for me though, we'll see how that goes.