critical reviews of history exhibit practice in an age of ubiquitous display

Monday, November 28, 2011

The Toynbee Tiles: Viral exhibitry from the pre-Internet world

The Toynbee Tiler's main style, in Philadelphia's Center City.

At its heart an exhibition is a display of objects, grouped together by a shared theme, style or message, and designed for public consumption. In the award-winning 2011 documentary Resurrect Dead: The Mystery of the Toynbee Tiles, four men from Philadelphia search for the creator of an idiosyncratic series of public art pieces that, in its consistency and repetition, can be seen as an exhibition.

While the film plays out as History Detectives for hipsters, the story is compelling. The tiles have a central, cryptic message that invoke historian Arnold Toynbee and filmmaker Stanley Kubrick:

“Toynbee idea
In Movie 2001
Resurrect Dead
On Planet Jupiter"

The Toynbee Tiler has been prolific, installing his pieces
since the 1980s in the asphalt of urban streets from his home base in Philadelphia,
across the Rust Belt, to South America. The tiles defy explanation, though they
have the stylistic consistency of a single artist. While the basic message
doesn’t vary, he adds, at times, addenda and marginalia that range from
mentioning the USSR to critiquing the media.

While the film is fascinating on a variety of levels, one of its most poignant
aspects is the way the filmmakers create a portrait of the unknown
Tiler. Through interviews and by tracing clues scattered in the tiles,
newspapers, and minutes of an esoteric organization, they suggest that the
tiles were primarily a means of communicating a public message in a
pre-Internet world. Today, the Toynbee Tiler would have an easier time writing
a blog, but the film shows his attempts to use other methods to find an outlet
and audience for his message, from ham radio transmissions to calling in to
talk radio shows. These strategies were small and inconsequential, and he found
himself blocked by corporate media control of the airwaves.

City street as faulty archive: remnants of a decaying tile.

His response? An exhibition of public street art, curated against asphalt grids, through the creation and placement of a series of tiles carved out of linoleum and adhered to the street with tarpaper. (To try this tiling technique yourself, check out the tutorial from Make magazine.) The ultimate ephemerality of the pieces as they erode under years of traffic renders them less archive than temporary exhibition. While the message of his tiles is unsettling--including one known as “The Manifesto” that disturbingly veers into anti-Semitism--the audacity of it as exhibition practice is intriguing.

Of course, in the age of the Internet, interest in the tiles has only grown as scattered individuals who had seen a tile in their city became aware of their spread. Interestingly, contemporary art groups have incorporated the tiles into their own street art. House of Hades, one of the more prolific of these collectives, creates
their own tiles that critique the media, adopting one of the Toynbee Tiler’s favorite themes while purging it of its more unsavory aspects. Such approaches preserve the formal qualities of the tiles while effacing much of the haunted affect inhering in the obsessive repetition and syntactical unhingement of the originals. Connected today with a street art culture derived from graffiti and expressed in ways that strategically repurpose public space (for example, in the images of artists like Banksy), the contemporary tilers’ method is necessarily different in meaning from the Toynbee Tiler.

Other artists adopt the tile technique for less ambiguous messages.

While it seemed that he utilized his unique exhibition method for lack of other options, today’s street artists reclaim public spaces as an explicit means of countering corporate dominance and its ubiquitous expression through advertising. Like the tiles, today’s street art injects mystery into the public sphere, making familiar territory unfamiliar and altering perspective but its purpose is much more knowable. It aims to challenge power while also sending a message--a DIY ethos shared by the contemporary craft movement and quite different from the solitary statements of the Toynbee Tiles.

Not only are the messages themselves quite different, they are now received by more jaded eyes. For instance, many people leaving a screening of Resurrect Dead in Philadelphia admitted that they first assumed the tiles were either a student art project or a viral marketing campaign. Changes in technology, meaning, and modes of dissemination since the 1980s have gutted the semiotic landscape in which the Toynbee Tiles first appeared, leaving us more knowing about these kinds of visual languages but also perhaps nostalgic for the more truly mysterious affect of the Tiler’s exhibits. While contemporary modes of cultural signification build off his techniques, they also make impossible this kind of unknowable world created by a singular vision.

~ Mary Rizzo and Whitney Strub

Easily missed at 9th and Walnut, this small tile's ambiguous message can be read as step one of an instructional series or a plaintive expression of solitude.

3 comments:

Through interviews and by tracing clues scattered in the tiles, newspapers, and minutes of an esoteric organization, they suggest that the tiles were primarily a means of communicating a public message in a pre-Internet world. Today, the Toynbee Tiler would have an easier time writing a blog, but the film shows his attempts to use other methods to find an outlet and audience for his message,travertine paving

Hi there! I just wanted to point out that the Toynbee Tiles have had a very inspirational effect on the wider artistic community. A quick search on Spotify will yield a handful of pretty good songs based on or inspired by the Toynbee Tiler. Then there was the documentary film that you mentioned, which inspired me to write a novel about the tiles: "Do Not Resurrect" is available from most online retailers as an eBook. Point being, whether the tiler's medium and message(s) are lasting or ephemeral, he imbues others with artistic and creative energy by the very act of their transmission. Personally, I'm quite happy to live in a world made just a little bit better by the likes of the Toynbee Tiler. ;-) http://my.bookbaby.com/book/do-not-resurrect