i think he is a good championship player......and im sure my views are shared by many based on the last few seasons. i doubt that even his closest friends or family would say he has 'stood out' in the championships.......

Go on then what does one think of Luke??
For your information Luke did really well at widnes and made a really good impression and was in fact offered a deal with widnes.
Luke was unable to accept the deal as it wasn't enough for him to leave his day job and go full time.

Menzies is a solid championship player. If he had made such a good impression, Widnes would have made the deal happen and offered more money. If he has gone to Swinton, then I wish him all the best.

As for Luke , great potential , but still has to fufill it, we used him in a game for like 2 x 20 minute spells , I liked him , would still like him to be with us, but he could have done more for us with the time he was on the pitch.

Luke recently recovered from a horrendous injury and is still taking the ball into contact fearlessly and at full tilt...You get 100 per cent effort from him, as we did at Oldham, does the hard yards and tough as teak. never goes missing!He and Saed Tamgahart were my favourite forwards!