This name's title and reputation is all about fresh seafood -- and it is, with a menu dominated by cod sandwiches, fried catfish platters, and tilapia three different ways -- but it's also sporting a beefy burger selection topped with everything from the classic fixings to quinoa and banana pepper mustard alongside their crowd favorites -- the salads, the offering of which changes every week (and that you can always add shrimp, fish, or oysters to).

Smithtown Seafood

This name's title and reputation is all about fresh seafood -- and it is, with a menu dominated by cod sandwiches, fried catfish platters, and tilapia three different ways -- but it's also sporting a beefy burger selection topped with everything from the classic fixings to quinoa and banana pepper mustard alongside their crowd favorites -- the salads, the offering of which changes every week (and that you can always add shrimp, fish, or oysters to).