Brooke Astor's Son Sentenced

The ugly case of Anthony Marshall, convicted of "siphoning millions from his mother" Brooke Astor--heiress and legendary New York socialite--is drawing to a close. Mr. Marshall was sentenced Monday to one to three years in prison for stealing from Astor as he cared for her in her old age. Here's what journalists and attorneys think of the outcome:

Melancholy All Around Providing end-of-case analysis, The New York Times' James Barron says the testimony of witnesses called to "flesh out prosecutors' claims" regarding Mr. Marshall "perhaps without meaning to ... also described the dark complement to Mrs. Astor's glittering
social life, her deterioration as she passed 90 and then 100." Barron writes that "if Mr. Marshall has a good record in prison, he is likely to serve roughly eight months behind bars."

Short Sentence "We wondered," writes The Business Insider's Erin Geiger Smith, "whether a judge would take Marshall's age into account and hand down a
light sentence. He was given the lightest sentence possible."

The Moral: Don't Get Greedy "Not even the rich and powerful can get away with elder abuse," declares attorney Chris Johnson. His take on the case is that Marshall "couldn't say no to his wife, who unfortunately was
not prosecuted. He was set to receive a large inheritance anyway, and
was receiving money from his mother also, so if he (or his wife) could
have been content with what they had, he would not be facing this."

The Moral: Also--Don't Be Stupid About It At The Huffington Post, Ralph Gardner Jr. argues that this "is a
textbook case in how not to defraud your incredibly rich, famous and
beloved mother's estate if you don't want to get caught. But lesson #1--perhaps exceeded only by not marrying someone of whom your purse
strings-controlling mom disapproves--is to do everything in your
power to avoid alienating the help, at which the thrifty Marshalls
showed singular skill." Mrs. Astor's butler, Christopher Ely, was crucial in the case against Mr. Marshall, and had "encouraged the maids to keep notes about all those meetings where the demented Mrs. Astor was hustled into her
library to sign codicils to her will that gave away more and more of
her assets to [Mr. Marshall and his wife] at the expense of such charities as the
Metropolitan Museum and the New York Public Library."

This article is from the archive of our partner The Wire.

We want to hear what you think about this article. Submit a letter to the editor or write to letters@theatlantic.com.