Networx: Pick your plastic plumbing pipe: PEX vs. PVC

Laura Firszt More Content Now

Thursday

Feb 14, 2019 at 9:44 AMFeb 14, 2019 at 9:44 AM

Are you planning to install or replace plumbing pipes in your home? You’ve probably heard that plastic pipes made of PEX or PVC are competing with copper in popularity, but what are they, exactly? And PEX vs PVC … which is best for your home?

What is PEX?

Household plumbing systems use PEX for pipes to supply water and carry away sewage. The term PEX stands for "crosslinked polyethylene." PEX piping is manufactured by melting high-density polyethylene and extruding it in the form of a tube. This material was first introduced to the United States only 40 years ago, but it’s catching on fast.

PEX - Pros

- Easy install. PEX pipes are flexible and therefore simpler to install than PVC. Your plumber will have to create fewer connections, because PEX can bend to accommodate changes in direction. What’s the payoff for you? Fewer potential sources of plumbing leaks. The small number of connections still necessary will be made using cold expansion rings or crimp fittings. No need for glue, which can leach into the water with PVC pipes.

- Compatibility with metal pipes. When a connection to copper or other metal pipes is required, PEX works better than PVC because crosslinked polyethylene won’t corrode.

- Freeze resistance. It’s resistant to freezing (once again, due to its flexibility, which allows the PEX piping’s diameter to expand as the water pressure changes). In plain English, this means that you’re less likely to end up with burst pipes.

- Quiet. PEX piping eliminates the problem of noisy plumbing due to water hammer. (While water hammer is commonest with metal, PVC pipes can produce their fair share of strange banging sounds.)

PEX - Cons

- Price. When you compare the material costs of PEX vs PVC, PEX comes out more expensive. (However, balance this factor against the lower labor cost to install PEX.)

- UV intolerance. PEX cannot tolerate exposure to sunlight, which limits its possible usages. It’s fine for inside your home but if you’re having PEX piping installed outdoors, you will not be able to locate it above ground.

PVC ("polyvinyl chloride"), a type of thermoplastic, is commonly used for household plumbing and drainage pipes. CPVC, "chlorinated polyvinyl chloride," is a related product made from chlorinated PVC resin; it's more temperature-resistant, but costs about six times the price of PVC.

PVC - Pros

- Long life. PVC has a predicted lifespan of 50-70 years or more, compared with 40-50 years for PEX.

- Lower cost. PVC is less expensive to purchase than PEX, although it usually will cost you more in labor.

- Outdoor safety. PVC is fine to use outdoors, even above ground - you just need to cover the exterior of PVC piping with a coat of water-based paint.

- Eco-friendliness. Unlike PEX, old PVC piping is accepted for recycling once its useful life is done.

PVC - Cons

- Higher leak risk. Rigid PVC pipe means that every connection will require an elbow. This opens up greater possibilities for plumbing leaks. You’ll also run the risk of cracked pipes if PVC freezes.

- Temperature limitations. Because the ASTM does not approve PVC plumbing pipe above 140 degrees, it can only be used for cold water (toilet plumbing, for instance). For applications involving hot water (bathroom or kitchen sinks, showers, etc.), you must install CPVC, which is safe to 200 degrees.

A word about copper pipes

Copper pipes are a longtime favorite for domestic plumbing, with the pluses of strength, ability to handle high temperatures and suitability for outdoor use. A downside: Copper plumbing pipes can develop pinhole leaks or corrosion buildup. Also, not all plumbers have the know-how or willingness to work with copper. The most disturbing problem is that science has linked ingestion of copper through drinking water or other sources to Alzheimer’s disease.

Laura Firszt writes for networx.com.

Never miss a story

Choose the plan that's right for you.
Digital access or digital and print delivery.