Playoff Prospectus

ALCS Game Five

the archives are now free.

All Baseball Prospectus Premium and Fantasy articles more than a year old are now free as a thank you to the entire Internet for making our work possible.

Not a subscriber? Get exclusive content like this delivered hot to your inbox every weekday. Click here for more information on Baseball Prospectus subscriptions or use the buttons to the right to subscribe and get instant access to the best baseball content on the web.

With the Yankees in the unusual position of being in an elimination game, the question Wednesday was whether they could at least end their last home series of the long season with a victory. Whatever happens in Texas may not stay in Texas—the National League has got World Series home-field advantage, after all. But Wednesday's contest was about staying alive while giving a desperate crowd something to feel glad about, should this be the end of a season, of an era, or of an association with the complete quartet of the Core Four.

In this, the Yankees were entirely successful with a 7-2 victory over the Rangers in Game Five of the American League Championship Series, giving the Bronx a band as well as a drama worthy of the name. They did so in the face of a major setback—Mark Teixeira's hamstring injury takes him out of any calculations for this series as well as the next one. And they did so with CC Sabathia pitching through trouble time and again, while dispelling the spectre of whether they could beat C.J. Wilson on the merits instead of as a measure of managerial misconduct.

Wednesday, such things didn't matter, because with everything at stake, all sorts of happy, scrappy bits of joy came into play. Granderson, having good at-bats against lefties? Sure, why not? Baserunners taking the extra base, or advancing on outs to the outfield? Sure, works for Texas in its offensive innings, so why not? But add in Swisher and Robinson Cano jumping all over the second pitch in their second at-bats against Wilson in the third--they'd seen enough, and they knew what to do with it, which was smoke it first, and ask questions about where it landed later. The two bombs made it 5-0, enough to win, but a lead made more comfortable later, courtesy of Charlie O. Finley and his sub-amazing ass.

That wasn't the only bit of role reversal, though. Where the Yankees were moving up on fly-ball outs and trying to create the odd happy accident—like adding a run on Jeff Francoeur's throw in the second—the Rangers were taking their best shot at honing in on a Yankees trademark, generating a ton of baserunners against Sabathia and forcing him to burn through a lot of pitches, to the point that there was little doubt he'd come out after a long sixth inning, having already given up 11 hits and averaged more than four pitches per batter three complete trips through the order.

That still left three frames to go, but Girardi commented before the game that, in an elimination game, “you might stretch Woody and you might stretch Mo more than you would normally stretch them.” He did exactly that, letting Kerry Wood face six batters. Where Sabathia had pitched into and out of trouble, Wood simply eradicated his own, picking Elvis Andrus off second base while striking out three of the other five batters he faced. Then he turned to Mariano Rivera, and the game was already gone.

One thing to notice is the reliability with which the charges of Rangers pitching coach Mike Maddux seem to carry out their gameplans. In Game Four, Tommy Hunter wasn't going to give Alex Rodriguez the inside corner, brushing him back the first time out before beaning him the next time around. Wednesday, Thames didn't get around on anything, while Derek Jeter kept hitting tappers to the infield. On a day like Wednesday, when Wilson was struggling with location from the outset, you could still see—and respect—elements of a plan.

Even in defeat, however, it's worth also noting the very Yankee-like things that the Rangers did. Rookie first baseman Mitch Moreland battled Sabathia at length—if fruitlessly—during the sixth inning, for example, but he was only one Ranger among many delivering something veritably Yankee-like in its well-spanked new digs. It's worth wondering if equally valid brands of desperation are inspiring better patience from the Rangers as well as more fully invested baserunning efforts.

Furthermore on the Rangers' side, if Wilson's control went missing in the second, and he left pitches out over the plate in the third, you can credit Ron Washington and Maddux alike for not panicking three innings in, down 5-0. Instead, they traded another two innings for another run, left the balance of the ballgame to their least-used relief duo of rookies Michael Kirkman and Alexi Ogando, and settled for just two runs allowed in the last six. It wasn't quite Derek Holland's Game Four heroics, but it was remarkable just the same, because they stranded a trio of Yankees at third base. In short, there was a lot less to complain about as far as managerial decisions, and beyond Wilson's lost sense of command and control in the early going, it was another game in which the expectations of a big score and big innings early didn't exactly come to pass, absent the late-game humiliation and pain.

The question that's left is whether the Yankees sans Tex can win two in Texas. In the broad strokes, I'm inclined to say of course they can, except that Game Seven will put them up against Cliff Lee. Even if they beat Colby Lewis or—more likely—the Rangers bullpen on Friday in Game Six, there is still the expectation of perfection to deal with in a seventh game, either as a matter of combating it or producing their own in kind. Even if you might charitably consider Game Four an evener for Game One's outcome, there's still the decision to match Phil Hughes up with Lewis, and the need to reverse that the next time around.

Christina Kahrl is an author of Baseball Prospectus. Click here to see Christina's other articles.
You can contact Christina by clicking here

Thames manhandles lefties, and Grandy has righted the ship against southpaws himself over the last couple months, so there's no way he sits. Gardner isn't useless against same siders, and his speed and defense are really why he's in the lineup. But agreed on Berkman, of course. I think the problem, from Girardi's perspective, is that -- whatever his current production might be -- Berk is an "all star" (much in the way that Chad Qualls is a "closer"), and Girardi is... well... not much older than him, and wasn't an "all star" himself in his playing days. Simply put, I think it is difficult/awkward for Girardi to treat a guy with Berkman's track record as a bench bat, even if he may now be a "has been," whereas it's much easier for him to do so with a "never was" like Kearns. That said, there's a difference between a reason and an excuse, and this seems more like the latter. Just as Berkman must know that these are the times to put personal pride aside, Girardi should understand that now is not the time to worry about hurt feelings.

It's just Austin Kearns though. Berkman for his career is just slightly worse than Kearns against LH, and as recently as '08 and '09, he was better. Even giving Kearns the advantage, Berkman's D at 1st (vs. Swisher's) and Swisher's D in RF (vs. Kearns') could at least arguably make up for that.

Kearns probably should have come in the game when Teix went down, but I don't think it's worth getting upset over keeping him on the bench for a CJ Wilson start, considering Wilson's penchant for walking batters and above average ability to strike guys out. Kearns K's a ton and Berkman can still work a walk.