I think I would do that deal. I am not very high on Goldy but I know a lot of people especially around here are but I still think this is a solid move. SP is easier to find and there are some pretty major concerns with Weaver: K/9 was under 7 last year- Not Good, BABIP was .240 - unsustainable, FIP was 3.75 and xFIP was 4.18 - Not Good.

Maybe Weaver figures it out and he continues to be the Ace many some people think he is but if it were me I would be selling and looking for pitching elsewhere.