The art of the “arrange album” is somewhat lost these days. So it comes as a surprise that in 2011, Xenogears is the focus of a new orchestral album performed by the Bulgarian Symphony Orchestra.

Read on if that sounds like fun.

Some quick history for the uninitiated: when Xenogears was released in 1998, it was during a huge jump in scope and ambition for games. The plot was completely insane – everything from breaking up a wedding to the origin of God was touched upon in some kind of ridiculous (and awesome) way.

The soundtrack was also ambitious. An intense opening sequence, “Dark Daybreak,” followed by Joanne Hogg’s “Stars of Tears” was a breath of fresh air. I don’t think I really heard vocals of that caliber on a soundtrack before – this was right before the excellent Soukaigi score – and I was barely on track two.

Around the same time, Yasunori Mitsuda banded together a group of international musicians, mostly from Ireland and Japan, and as “Millennial Fair” the group released CREID, an album based on the Xeno soundtrack. Combining Celtic mysticism with Japanese rock created a beautiful, enduring album with character and style that holds up well today.

So it is strange that after a quiet thirteen years, Mitsuda pops up with a brand-new orchestral album, released digitally, on CD and even on vinyl. I was anxious to hear MYTH as I always thought Xeno would sound great in an orchestral setting.

The Bulgarian Symphony Orchestra’s clear strength in this recording is the string section. Their style is rich and expressive, if at the expense of being technically perfect. I prefer this style of playing to the more straight-laced performances, and the emotion from the strings works for this music. The brass, winds and percussion are weaker links in the ensemble- accordingly, the arrangements are thick with strings, focusing on the innate strengths of the orchestra.

As for the arrangements, MYTH generally holds tightly to the source material. I was happy to hear “upgraded” versions of classics in the vein of an old arrange album. Changing the identity of the music seemed unnecessary, since CREID had already accomplished that.

The opener, “Dark Daybreak,” sticks largely to the original format. It is not as explosive as the OST, but the live orchestra lends a more natural sound. Also true to its roots is “Flight.” I was pleased to hear the French horn part exactly as I remembered from the soundtrack, adding warmth and character. The arrangement has little flourish, aside from a newly written break-down/build-up in the center, but the original melody and harmony are strong enough to carry the track on their own.

“Unstealable Jewel” was also subtly expanded for drama. The gentle dialogue between the violin and cello sections is particularly effective. “The Gentle Breeze Sings” follows, featuring better instrumentation than the OST. The heartfelt cello solo carries the melody throughout the piece, occasionally lending it to the woodwinds for a line or two.

The more adventurous renditions mostly work too. “My Village is Number One” is better than the original. A gentle introduction plays out before moving straight into a Celtic beat, followed by the full orchestra. This track is a big improvement that brings out the strengths in Mitsuda’s writing that were previously hidden behind MIDI patches. “In a Prison of Peace and Regret” is made over, replacing the harpsichord with a string orchestra for a fuller, darker sound. “Bonds of Sea and Flame” is another successful experiment, in which the orchestra effortlessly passes Bartholomew’s theme around, section to section, tempo to tempo, before an epic finale. “Lost… Broken Shards” clocks in at barely over one minute – but a beautiful minute it is. This is a favorite theme of mine, and this rendition is expressive and rich. The lone piano is joined by a cello, like words of encouragement.

Unfortunately, “Stage of Death” didn’t work as well. It’s not bad, but it is unremarkable. The song needs some excitement and spice. There’s a lack of color and vivaciousness to the performance that a track like this requires. “The Wind Calls to Shevat in the Blue Sky” is also on the bland side. A little ethnic percussion or piano, like the original, would have gone a long way. Many fans like this tune, but on MYTH, it stands out in my mind the least of the album’s fourteen songs, and is also one of the shortest tracks. Also mildly disappointing is “The Beginning and the End,” which is basically the original version plus a string orchestra (good), but the vocals are much weaker than those belted out in the original (bad).

A couple of piano solo arrangements are here too. While very pretty, CREID’s version of “October Mermaid” is more expressive, and “Faraway Promise”, the final track, sounds a little like its on autopilot. Both songs are pleasant but unremarkable. A little darkness in the timbre of the piano, a la Brandish Piano Collection, would have given the songs stronger identities.

I guess a Xenogears album would not be complete without “Small Two of Pieces,” and it’s here, complete with Joanne Hogg. However, her vocals are just copy-pasted from the original track – it’s not a new performance. Her voice is fantastic, but since she was singing for a pop song originally, it’s the wrong style for a soft orchestral arrangement. Someone on the production side should have sprung for a new recording. And though classier in its new arrangement, the orchestral version lacks not only the excitement and anxiety of the original, but even that from the rest of MYTH. It meanders, maintaining a low volume without much of the song’s characteristic climax and release.

Having listened through a few times, I feel like MYTH is unbalanced – part masterpiece, part phone-in. It begins strong, and retains a rich quality through most of the album. But there small moments of weakness, and the final two or three tracks are underwhelming, strangely missing the passion they should have. Like a row of books with only one bookend MYTH lacks a defined ending. There’s no resolution to the album – it just kind of ends, mostly due to an unconvincing “Small Two of Pieces.”

Two-thirds or more of the album is very appealing, so despite a weak finale, the quality of several individual tracks makes it a worthwhile listen. Though it fails to tell a complete story the way CREID did, the chance to hear Xenogears played by an orchestra is a rare treat.

Don’t forget to watch Jayson’s unboxing video too, if you’re interested in the physical packaging, as it is quite nice. It’s currently available from both CD Japan and Play-Asia.

8 Comments

I really wonder about the motivation and timing behind this album. More Xenogears is great, and more Mitsuda certainly isn’t bad– but I wonder if this was just to drum up excitement for the PSN release of XG? It just seems so random.

I agree with your assessment, as well. It’s by no means a bad album– but it isn’t consistently good throughout, either.

On 02.26.11 popo said:

It’s not a bad album but it’s pointless next to CREID.

On 02.26.11 Wolf said:

I totally agree about the album ending on a low note. I thought “The Beginning and the End” would finally shine as much as I knew it could given the right orchestra treatment but it comes off so un-passionate… And I can’t believe they couldn’t get Joanne Hogg to sing again, Mitsuda had her do two ballads for Xenosaga so I don’t understand why she couldn’t give us another *new* great performance.

I will say I love many of the songs, especially “In a Prison of Peace and Regret” and “Bonds of Sea and Flame”. And like you said the new version of “My Village is Number One” is a great improvement over the original, which was not one of my favorite songs.

I’m really glad they released the album on itunes, I really didn’t want to spend a lot on importing a disc.

“Having listened through a few times, I feel like MYTH is unbalanced – part masterpiece, part phone-in.” Dude, yes. Dark Daybreak and Flight were worth the price of admission for me. I hope the fact that they were finally arranged for an orchestra means we’ll see them performed live at some point in the future.

The rest I sort of glossed over — it felt far less polished than even some of the fan efforts like OneUp’s Time&Space.

Still, Flight. Yeps.

Glad you went into such detail with this review. Pleasure to read. Cheers.

On 03.02.11 Maggie said:

I do mostly agree with the review, I enjoy listening to it and it is a sound upgrade, but the quality in it, be it technical side like the mixing and mastering, to performance and arrangements, was a bit of a mixed bag. I still LOVE Small Two of Pieces though despite Joanne not able to re record, I feel the orchestral version bought out her beautiful voice better than the original.

To celebrate the release of the game on PSN and this album, I made these videos. Its the Opening and the Ending+Credits video with the Myth tracks edited in, and oh god is the opening track a pain to edit, cause the speed of the music is totally different.

I quite agree with this review and especially Maggie’s comment about mixing/mastering – the sound especially on more paced sections can be digital, edgy and muffled.

The lack of clavecin “In a beginnin of Peace and Regret” disappointed me. I really liked it on the original track and would have wanted to have it on this version too in some form.

However I have to disagree about “The Beginning and the End” (aka Alpha and Omega). In my opinion the original one was rather cheesy and screeching towards the end, and I liked more mellow approach on Myth.

Based on my first time listening to this, it’s a decent pick for fans but quite unremarkable for others. In the end I found many tracks better on original soundtrack or on Creid.

On 08.08.11 Olaf said:

I, too, disagree about “The Beginning…” In the original version, the vocals are just intolerable. Hurts my ears from about 2:30 to the end. The Myth version, on the other hand, is nice.

Also, is this review based on the preview tracks or the released album? Because Small Two of Pieces definitely got a new recording from Ms. Hogg. Before release, however, the preview used a copy-pasted vocal track. I was very relieved when that turned out not to be the final version.