As a founder member of Mystery Women in 1997, promoting Crime Fiction has always been my passion.
Following the closure of Mystery Women, a new group was formed on 30th January 2012 promoting crime fiction.
New reviews are posted daily, but to search for earlier reviews please click on the Mystery People link below and select 'reviews' from the welcome page. This will display an alphabetic option for you to find the review you would like to read

Recent Events

For PREVIOUS REVIEWS- Click on MYSTERY PEOPLE below -

Wednesday, 22 April 2015

The Alexander Seaton Sequence by S. G. Maclean

These
four novels, set in Scotland and Ulster in the 1620s and 1630s, all feature the
same protagonist, Alexander Seaton, at a time just before the outbreak of the
English Civil War while terrible religious wars were raging on the Continent
particularly in Germany where the fighting was especially brutal and savage.
Although each novel is a separate stand-alone story with a mysterious death at
its heart, they also chronicle Alexander’s life and psychological and emotional
progress. Alexander, son of a Scottish blacksmith and an Irish mother who had
eloped with Alexander’s father and had been cut off by her family, was born and
brought up in the town of Banff at a time when most Scots practiced a
particularly rigid form of Calvinism which held that although some might be
saved from hellfire most were predestined to suffer eternally and could not be
saved. Alexander himself was pretty sure of salvation and also of a good career
on earth: a clever boy who did well at school and university he was destined to
be a minister in the Kirk of Scotland. Even better, through his boyhood
friendship with Archibald Hay of Delgatie and heir to his father’s lands,
Alexander has hopes of marrying Archie’s sister Katherine. But Archie is a wild
boy, not content with university studies, and he sets off for the wars in
Germany to fight for the Protestant cause. News of Archie’s death is a double
catastrophe for Alexander: not only has he lost his best friend but with
Archie’s death Katherine’s family decide that she must marry well. But then
Katherine’s parents learn that she and Alexander have become lovers and she is
hastily married off to an elderly relative. She begs Alexander to elope with her
but he rejects her, fearing that such disgrace would lose him his career as a
minister. When Alexander is denounced by Katherine’s father in public,
Alexander not only has to do public penance but his hopes of becoming a
minister are dashed and all he can aspire to is a menial teaching job in a
local school. In his bitterness, with only a few friends, and all too aware
that he is doomed to eternal perdition, he takes to drink.

‘The
Redemption of Alexander Seaton’

Published
by Quercus, 7 May 2009. ISBN: 978 1 84724 791 9 (pb)

In his
self-disgust Alexander thinks he can fall no further. But he does. Staggering
home from a drunken evening in the tavern he sees a man fall. Assuming that he
is also drunk, Alexander ignores him and falls asleep in his attic bedroom room
at the school where he teaches. But the man was not drunk; he was desperately
ill and the town’s two bedraggled prostitutes, their toleration in the rigidly
Puritan town illustrating the hypocrisy of the town’s elders of the Kirk who
constitute the ruling elite, help him into the nearest building which is the
school. Next morning his body is discovered, he is identified as Patrick
Davidson, apprentice to the Banff apothecary, and an investigation establishes
that he died of poisoning. Alexander, consumed with guilt by his failure to
help Patrick, further devastated by the news that suspicion has fallen on one
of his few friends, the music teacher Charles Thom, and convinced that the
perpetrator could not be Charles, is drawn into the investigation. Then further
complications arise: detailed maps drawn by Patrick – are they part of a
Catholic plot to assist the Spanish to invade Scotland? And his friendship with
Marion, the apothecary’s daughter and Charles’s possible jealousy of that
relationship, not only adds to the suspicions against Charles but, with further
suspicions as to witchcraft, threatens Marion. To find out the truth Alexander
goes to Aberdeen and contacts old friends and begins to restore his self-esteem
but will he find out there the truth about Patrick’s death? Or is the truth
somewhere else?

My only
caveat regarding this excellent first novel is that there are an enormous number
of characters (18 in the first 24 pages alone and a lot more as the book
continues), all important and some recurring in later books, and the plot is
highly complex, a list of their names would have helped. Apart from this,
highly recommended.

‘A Game
of Sorrows’

Published
by Quercus,2 September 2010. ISBN: 978 1 84916 244
9(pb)

This is the
second novel in the series and Alexander, having uncovered the identity of
Patrick Davidson’s murderer, is now in Aberdeen. Although he will never be able
to achieve his earlier dream of the ministry, he has a post in the Aberdeen
College and has resumed his life with his former friends. And he is intending
to marry Sarah Forbes: in the earlier book, Sarah, a maidservant, had been
raped and impregnated by her brutal employer; illustrating the hypocritical
misogyny of the times, she was expelled from Banff and forbidden to return under
pain of death. Alexander had helped Sarah and now, attracted by her proud and
independent spirit, he would like to marry her. Finally, he is entrusted by the
College Principal to journey to Poland there to recruit candidates to study
divinity in Aberdeen.

All this
is put in jeopardy when Alexander, returning to his rooms late one night, finds
a stranger there, a man who could be his double. He is Sean O’Neill, and he is
Alexander’s cousin on Alexander’s mother’s side. He carries a plea for help
from his and Alexander’s maternal grandmother, Maeve O’Neill. It seems that all
those who are of the O’Neill blood have been placed under a curse – one by one
they are going to die. Only Alexander may be immune because his existence is
unknown to most people in Ireland. Alexander agrees to go with Sean to Ireland.
Once there he finds that the threats to his family are all too real and he is
drawn into wild conspiracies and wilder adventures, before he is able to return
to Aberdeen and to Sarah.

As with
all the novels, earlier and later, the historical background is impeccably
researched showing the depth of the author’s knowledge of the period and the
location. In this instance the background is the settlements in Ulster carried
out by James the First in which the native Irish, descendants of the original
inhabitants of Ireland, and the Old English, descendants of those who had been
settling there for centuries and were now as Irish as the native Irish, were in
conflict with the most recent English and Scottish settlers who had been
installed on land confiscated from the native Irish and the Old English: a
situation which still has repercussions today. However, I have to admit that I
think this the least satisfactory of the four books: Maeve herself with her
wild attachment to the heroic Irish myths I found unconvincing, and Alexander’s
decision to abandon his bright prospects in Aberdeen is never satisfactorily
explained, at least to me. On the other hand, I liked the way in which
Alexander realises that not all Catholics, even Catholic priests, are
manifestations of the Devil; this is part of his growing-up process and of his
acceptance of toleration. And it is a good and exciting adventure, similar, I
thought, to John Buchan’s historical romances. As such, recommended.

‘Crucible’

Published
by Quercus, 12 April 2012. ISBN: 978 1 84916 316 3(pb)

Alexander is now
back in Aberdeen and at his old post at Marischal College. And he is now married,
and has a daughter as well as a son. And
all is going well. As well as his continuing friendship with the lawyer William
Cargill and his family, he has made new friends, in particular Robert Sim the
scholarly and reclusive College librarian, and he is held in high regard by Dr Patrick
Dun, Principal of the College. He has two other friends, John Innes and Andrew
Carmichael, but his relationship with the latter is somewhat problematic. When
Robert is found in the library with his throat cut, Alexander is asked by Dr
Dun to make his own enquiries, in particular, as to whether there was a connection
between Robert’s death and a bequest of books to the library by the scholar
Gerald Duncan, a bequest about which Robert had wanted to speak to Alexander
but had not had the opportunity to do so. Some of the books are histories of
the Netherlands, Flanders and North Germany, currently being torn apart by the
turmoil of the German religious wars; others seem to be delving into the arcane
mysteries which were obsessing many scholars of the time as they attempted to
unravel the workings of chemistry and physics for which we now have scientific
explanations. Alexander’s investigation takes him into the world of the
Rosicrucians and the Freemasons, a world which many others regarded as deeply
dangerous, blasphemous and bordering on witchcraft.

This is
an excellent account of the way in which scholars of the time attempted to
unravel the mysteries of the physical world and thus began to develop
scientific knowledge. Wisely the author has not introduced too many characters
so the reader can concentrate on the plot and the inter-reaction of the
characters. Recommended.

‘The
Devil’s Recruit’

Published
by Quercus, 8 May 2014.ISBN: 978 1 84916 319 4 (pb)

Having solved the
mystery of Robert’s death, Alexander is now established at Marischal College.
His life is settled and stable and he is about to achieve his lifelong ambition
to become an ordained minister of the Kirk (Church) of Scotland. But into this
calm and serene way of life comes a vessel which anchors in Aberdeen harbour.
It is seeking recruits for the protestant forces in the German religious wars
and many young men and boys are attracted to what they see as a heroic ideal. Among
those young men are two of Alexander’s students, Seoras Mackay, heir to the
Highland clan chief, Donald Mackay, Lord Reay of Strathnaver, and his
foster-brother Hugh (in the Gaelic Uisdean) Gunn who is bound to Seoras by ties
stronger than blood. Alexander prevents Seoras and Hugh from being enlisted but
almost immediately afterwards both disappear. A few days later Hugh is found,
badly wounded and delirious, but there is no trace of Seoras. Then there is an
amazing revelation: one of the recruiting officers is someone whom Alexander
had long thought dead. At the same time there are allegations of witchcraft or
demonic possession swirling around a minister of the Kirk, and some clearly
strange events relating to the artist George Jamesone and two French gardeners
whom he employs and Christiane, the sister of the young French Huguenot teacher
Louis Rolland. And the horrors of the Thirty Years’ War come ever closer to
Scotland. The search for Seoras intensifies when his father appears,
accompanied by 40 fierce Highlanders, and the book ends with a final tragedy
when Alexander’s life must change yet again.

Although
this is the fourth book in the sequence, it is the first I read with a view to
reviewing. This is one in which the backstory which formed the foundation of
the earlier novels re-emerges as if to establish that we are never free of the
past. That backstory can be understood without recourse to the earlier titles;
nonetheless I decided to review all four together so as to gain a more complete
picture. I am glad I did so; the author’s deep knowledge of the period provides
an outstanding of events of the time. The plotting is highly complex but hangs
together in a way that is utterly convincing. It is very much a tale of divided
loyalties, clashing loyalties, love and betrayal of old friends, old loves, of treachery,
revenge and tragedy. I highly recommend all four novels, but do read them in
order – and it might be advisable to keep a note of the numerous characters,
many of whom are real-life historical personages, while you read!

------

Reviewer: Radmila May

S G MacLean was born in 1968 in Inverness
and grew up in the Scottish Highlands where her parents were hoteliers. She is the niece of world-famous thriller writer
Alistair MacLean. Shona who lives in
Conon Bridge with her husband, Dr James Vance, the rector at Golspie High
School, and their four children, has a PhD in history from Aberdeen University,
specialising in 16th and 17th- century Scottish history.

No comments:

Post a Comment

About Me

From an early age I have been a lover of crime fiction. Discovering like minded people at my first crime conference at St Hilda’s Oxford in 1997, I was delighted when asked to join a new group for the promotion of female crime writers. In 1998 I took over the running of the group, which I did for the next thirteen years.
During that time I organised countless events promoting crime writers and in particular new writers. But apart from the sheer joy of reading, ‘I actually love books, not just the writing, the plot or the characters, but the sheer joy of holding a book has never abated for me. The greatest gift of my life has been the ability to read'.