Get Email Updates

The Dispatch E-Edition

All current subscribers have full access to Digital D, which includes the E-Edition and
unlimited premium content on Dispatch.com, BuckeyeXtra.com, BlueJacketsXtra.com and
DispatchPolitics.com.
Subscribe
today!

Three years after Worthington Christian High School hired Jason Crary, officials heard that
something inappropriate had happened with a student at his former school.

But no criminal charges had been filed and, after speaking with the parent of the student,
Worthington Christian officials didn't lend credence to the rumors. That was in 2002.

Yesterday, Crary pleaded guilty in Wisconsin to four felony counts of sexual assault by a school
staff member.

Last week, he resigned from Worthington Christian, where he taught English and coached the girls
soccer team.

He's out on bail until April 3, when he'll be sentenced. The prosecutor in the case said he will
recommend a suspended prison sentence -- meaning it won't take effect -- and probation.

After the plea was announced, Worthington Christian's superintendent sent parents a letter
offering officials' prayers and explaining why they didn't take action after their 2002
investigation.

"The charges to which Mr. Crary pled guilty today are substantially different from what (former
Worthington Christian Superintendent) Taylor Smith recalls being discussed in 2002," Superintendent
Bill Williams wrote.

Crary wasn't arrested until last October, days after the resignation of a different Worthington
Christian soccer coach who reportedly had fondled a student several years earlier. Worthington
Christian immediately suspended Crary.

The Wisconsin criminal complaint said Crary had a sexual relationship with a 16-year-old girl
who played on the soccer team that he coached at Heritage Christian School in Milwaukee.

The girl reported the abuse to police in 2007, Assistant District Attorney Kenneth R. Berg said.
She said that Crary fondled her several times between 1997 and 1999 at his house.

He resigned from the Milwaukee school at the end of the 1998-99 school year to take a job at
Worthington Christian.

Crary's arrest came a few days after the completion of a
Dispatch series, "
The ABCs of Betrayal," which included
information on his colleague Dwayne Smith.

In 1996, Smith admitted that he had fondled a middle-school girl, church leaders said. He
resigned, attended Christian counseling and was forgiven by the school and associated church, Grace
Brethren. He later was rehired by the school but resigned again after the
Dispatch series ran.

If there was uncertainty as to Crary's guilt before, Assistant Superintendent Troy McIntosh said
yesterday, there shouldn't be now.

"He admitted to his guilt in the matter. We love Jason, and that will never change. We care
about his family a lot, but we also want justice for his victim. So we've been willing to wait
until this was resolved in court," McIntosh said.

After the
Dispatch series, Worthington Christian did new background checks of its
employees and sought two outside reviews of the school's hiring practices. Those should be
completed in the next couple of weeks.

A permanent replacement for Crary will be hired.

"In some sense, we've had to rely on God's sovereignty and a sense that his righteousness is
going to come through in this," McIntosh said. "Our hope is that we can continue to assure parents
that this is a safe place."