9 Eyeliners Not Worth Your Money

Why these eye makeup products made you march to the return counter

L'Oreal Paris Micro Liner Ultra Fine Lining Pencil, $8.49 TotalBeauty.com average member rating: 4.2*
Grand offense: No staying power. "It goes on well, but doesn't stay on. I always end up with eyeliner gunked up at the corner of my eyelids and underneath. It's a constant look in the mirror and wipe under the eyes!" -- Jessica_Long, TotalBeauty.com member