Recently, a Catholic church posted a sign that read "To edited With 'Happy Holidays' Say 'Merry Christmas' Again" and I must say that I was shocked. "Happy Holidays" is not a term used to replace "Merry Christmas." It is a term used to replace the names of ALL winter Holidays, NOT Christian ones. Think about it this way. Say you are Jewish, and you start up a conversation with a christian on one Christmas Day. If at the end of your conversation they said "Merry Christmas" would you stand up and hit them just because you were Jewish and they told you "Merry Christmas? Of course not. You might have been polite and said Happy Haunnaka, indicating that you were jewish, or you might have just left it without conflict. So as you can see, my views are that saying "Happy Holidays" is just a way of saying "Happy FILL IN THE BLANK"

In response to your post, well I'm jewish. I am offended by that sign, but if a christian came up to me on Chrismas day and say "Merry Christmas" to me, I would say "Merry Christmas" back. It's sort of like acknoledging their holiday. Actually, ony about 2% of America is jewish, and now you're just going to throw islam into my face. But I don't think that anyone should be offended by a christian saying to them "Merry Christmas!" Just be polite and say "Merry Christmas" back! You don't have to be offended. It's like acknoledging their holiday. By doing so, you are complementing them, on some level. Here's a little anecdote for you:

Every shabbat (for non Jews out there, that's a holiday we have every friday at sundown until sundown on saturday) my dad's coworker says to him (that friday, right before shabbat, before my dad comes home from work), "Shabbat Shalom" --which means in hebrew "Good/Peaceful Sabbath." Now this guy is a devout Christian. But he's ACKNOLEDGING our holiday! It's kind and polite.

Now if I were to initiate the conversation with a Christian that I knew I would say "Happy Holidays." Why? Because it would be misleading if I said "Merry Christmas." They would think that I was Christian or had recently converted (I think, I don't know much about Christianity, and which sects allow that, but moving on). There is a difference between acknoledging and condoning.

Who is online

Users browsing this forum: No registered users and 1 guest

You cannot post new topics in this forumYou cannot reply to topics in this forumYou cannot edit your posts in this forumYou cannot delete your posts in this forumYou cannot post attachments in this forum