"We can't imagine which segment of the movie-going audience would see them and say, 'Hey, this looks like a movie I want to see.' Perhaps only people who think stomachs should have faces." - Blastr

"The posters could have been created by a 5 year old with PhotoShop." - Screen Crave

"To date, they've [Fox] released some fun and interesting still images, a terrific trailer... but now they completely drop the ball with two ridiculously amateurish one sheets depicting Magneto and Professor X and the faded visages of the men they once were? Gah." - JoBlo

But in with the counter claim was Movie Line telling everyone to chill out calling the posters, "Not terrible!"

So here's your chance to help X-Men: First Class have some posters that don't look like they were designed by first-graders. We're declaring a Photoshop contest! Create your own X-Men: First Class posters and post them in the comments — we'll put up the best ones in a gallery in a few days.