OK--Here goes.
Boy, I'm setting myself up to sound stupid, but I will do it anyway.
I shoot 200gr LSWC .45ACP bullets. I get them from the only gun shop around that has them.
They have been out for about a month, so I figured that I would get a box of .45 Colt RNFP bullets.
I haven't reloaded them yet, but I can't figure that there would be any difference from the other bullets except shape.
I'm looking to start with 4.5gr of 231 powder and work my way up.
On my .45ACP loads, I use 4.8gr of 231.
I will definitely have to play with the OAL because they are shorter than the .45ACP LSWC.
Am I thinking correctly on this one, or am I way off base, and playing with fire.
I will wait for responses from you guys before proceeding with any reloading.
My thinking seems too easy on this one to not ask you guys where I am going wrong.

I think you should be ok, just watch the rim so it headspaces alright, and load a few to make sure they go up the ramp smoothly(if your shooting them in an auto) but then again I'm new to reloading as well so I don't know a whole lot about it. I am doing the opposite, loading acp bullets in a 45lc case!

Eric - what is the diameter of the .45 Colt bullets? Some .45 Colt lead bullets are sold in .454" size for use in certain revolvers. Lead bullets for .45 ACP are almost always .451" or, more commonly, .452". The larger bullet will work ok, but you have to be careful about pressure. Obviously, the larger bullet will cause a higher pressure and you should back off from your normal load a bit until you know the load is safe for your gun.

The diameter is .452", and yes, there is a crimp groove on them which I am planning to ignore.
I always load on the low side, and all of my accuracy loads pretty much stay on the low end.
Sorry, but I forgot to tell you guys that I will be using both of my 1911's with this load.

I would try seating one to match the load density of the acp bullet, then check to see if the round will chamber properly in the barrel, should look something like this;reloading 010.jpg if the round sticks up past the end of the barrel shroud you'll need to seat deeper, which will increase the pressure.

looks like your a fine canidate for cast bullets.if you cast your own you dont have to rely on ANY shortage.the Lee set up can be done for about $100.depending on source.MIDSOUTHSHOOTERS.COM best prices.I am thaking a rest from casting at this moment.

I just came from the range and fired 10 rounds at 4.8gr of 231 oal of 2.115", and 10 rounds at 5.2gr of 231 oal of 2.115"
All of the loads fed just fine, but enough stuff hit the air that I think that even the 5.2gr was too light of a load.
Tomorrow I will load some 5.4gr, and 5.6gr to see if it shoots cleaner and more accurate.
The recoil was minimal but I was hit in the face with some unburnt powder.
I think that the oal of 2.115" if fine. No feeding or ejection problems, and the case stops just a few thousandths short of the crimp groove.
I can also try some Clays powder also.

Teddy, you are right about me starting to cast. I think that it is about time to start thinking about it.

In the stubby .45 ACP case, what matters is seating depth. That cartridge is very sensitive to seating depth for two reasons. One is that it takes very little change in how deep the base goes into the case to raise pressure significantly. For example, 5.0 grains of Bullseye under the 230 grain FMJ round nose bullet (a standard mimic load for government hardball) seated to 1.275" will produce only about 16,200 PSI. If you seat it to 1.19" COL, as the Alliant web site erroneously shows, you will get about 25,000 PSI; well above the +P upper limit of 23,000 PSI. (I have written Alliant on this point but received no reply to date, so don't believe what you see there on COL; I own a pressure test barrel for .45 ACP and have been able to validate what I am saying here.)

The second issue is that most cases, especially mil spec, but excepting Remington cases with their thin upper case web brass, thicken in the web below normal hardball seating depth. Some .45 Colt bullets try to seat deeper, which not only raises pressure but bulges the thicker web brass out until it won't chamber. In the 200 grain range that should not be a problem. Just double-check that your base isn't going in any deeper than the those of the 200 grains SWC's you normally use, and you will be fine. Indeed, the loads you mention are below normal military pressure levels with 230 grain pumpkin ball, so as long as the bullet base goes into the case no deeper than 0.267", you will be fine.

This email link is to reach site administrators for assistance, if you cannot access TFL via other means. If you are a TFL member and can access TFL, please do not use this link; instead, use the forums (like Questions, Suggestions, and Tech Support) or PM an appropriate mod or admin.

If you are experiencing difficulties posting in the Buy/Sell/Trade subforums of TFL, please read the "sticky" announcement threads at the top of the applicable subforum. If you still feel you are qualified to post in those subforums, please contact "Shane Tuttle" (the mod for that portion of TFL) via Private Message for assistance.

This email contact address is not an "Ask the Firearms Expert" service. Such emails will be ignored. If you have a firearm related question, please register and post it on the forums.