Dear members,
Really I am having very good regards and high opinion about sri Jaldhar H
Vyas. But the message of his saying
"Yajurveda is just a rearrangement of rks for the use of the adhvaryu
priest. Samaveda is a rearrangement of rks for the use of the udgatr
priest. Even the Atharvaveda mostly consists of rks also found in the
Rgveda. Thus is can be said that the Rgveda is the source of the other
three. However it must be said, that all three contain material which is
not found in the Rgveda and cannot be simply dismissed as
younger".------------------
-is quite unexpected from an eminent scholar like him. I am unable to
assimilate the analysis made about the Vedas with younger and older theory
and also the rearrangement of the veda mantras, to suit according to the
convenience of the purohits or priests theory. I had to change my opinion
that he is deeply under the influence of the western historians who
actually wanted to create an impression that all our beliefs about the
Vedas and other scriptures are false and baseless. They wanted to say that
the Vedas are the collections of hymns composed by some Aryan tribal
leaders to suit their own needs. They wanted to fix up a date line for the
Vedas. They also wanted to say the mantras have been changed by the
Brahmin purohits to keep their superiority among others.
All these arguments were clearly condemned upto the roots, and the theory
of ApourushEya of the vEdas was re-established very long back itself. All
the westerners became silent, but the doubts created by them are still
lurking in the minds of our own Indians. I am not so efficient to put
forth any proper arguments to convince them and weed out all the doubts,
but could not resist keeping quiet.
Any one who knows the pAramparika sampradAya, that any of the mantras
should not be changed or altered by any one at any time for any reason.
Even the Parama Siva, from whom it is said that all the Vedas were
originated, has no right to change even a single letter from them because
he also was not the author of those mantras.
"anAdiniDhanA nityA vAgutsristA swayamBhuvA |
Adau vEdamayii nityA yatah sarvAh pravrittayah || .
The vEda has no beginning at all. They have manifested themselves, which
were there safely kept in the Parama Siva`s belly at the time of the
previous destruction of that creation. They came out from the mouth of
Siva quite involuntarily as a vomit. As Sankara says, "aprayatnEnaiva
liilA nyAyEna puruSha niSSwAsavat". They came out from Siva just like the
expiration of breath of any individual. Veda itself says the same,
"asya mahatOBhUtasya niSSwasitamEtat" It also says
"vEdo~nAdih sivastasya vyanjakah paramArdhatah |
aBhivyakti mapEkshyaiva praniitEtyuchyate Sivah ||"
Siva is only an insinuator or a medium for expressing them out.
"yaDhA vyAGhrii harEt putrAn damstABhih na cha piiDayEt |
Bhiita patana cHEdabhyam tadvad varnAn prayOjayEt |
Evam varnAh prayOktavyA nAvyaktA na cha piiditAh ||
Utmost care must be taken while pronouncing the letters and words of the
vEda mantras, just like a tiger carrying her cubs with her sharp teeth,
but very cautious about the cubs to be un-hurt. Only to keep that
tradition, not to be changed in the text, 'pada, karma, jata Ghana like
perturbations also came out along with the vEdA texts.
"Eta arShanti hridyAt samudrAt cHatavrajA ripuNa navachakShE |
Ghritasya DhArA aBhi chAkaSImi hiranyayO vEtaso maDhya AsAm ||"
The vEda mantras were called 'SatavrajAh'. It means every mantra in the
vEda., contains hundreds of meanings. Those meanings can not be
understood while you are in the physical plane. You have to enter in to
the mental plane i.e., subtle body.
This can be attained only under the guidance of an expert Guru, after
undergoing some disciplinary codes of conduct. If you just go through
only the literary meaning, from the physical plane, the meaning of the
mantra may appear to be absurd and with out any sense. That kind of people
may say, that these vEdas were written, and also re-arranged for
convenience of some Brahmin priests.
"vEdO~si yEna twam dEva vEda dEvEBhyO vEdO~bhavah |
tEna mahyam vEdo BhUyAh ||"
O Veda! You are the vEda for the dEvas. Please be the same for me also.
If the vEdas were written by human beings, how can they become vEdas for
the gods also? I request sri Vyas to correct himself in this regard.