At 8/5/10 11:55 AM, Domo wrote:
They should finally let you play as some one else besides sonic. The last game where you can play as tails was like in 2007 I think. They should add unlockable characters

The only games I can think of where you get to play as the other characters are the 3rd party and racing games.

At 8/5/10 09:18 AM, majormario wrote:
Amy tags along with Shadow to save Sonic. Shadow and Amy gameplay will be similar to the gameplay of the God of War series. (Insert ShadAmy here)

Sonic eventually breaks free of his confinement and starts destroying Metal Sonic's base from the inside out. This would be more along the lines of a Splinter Cell/Assassin's Creed game, but sped up. At the end of the game, Knuckles and Rouge give him the Emeralds, allowing him to go Super and beat Metal Sonic.

This is a somewhat good idea, finally!
Everything was originally and good, but did you have to shit all up in the end?
If something is like some other game, for example what you mentioned, that means it is a ripoff.
Ok, but since you only made the end shitty ripoff, I guess I could give you a bit credit for the other stuff, that was really well thought.

At 6/16/10 07:27 PM, KeroKeroMario wrote:
Here's an idea: no more new ideas. Seriously, every Sonic game for the past decade and a half went with a form of a "new idea." The Werehog was one of those ideas.

My advice to Sega: stop being idealistic.

/thread. Sonic needs to go back to basics, like in the Genesis games. That's what made him great, and Sonic 4 will prove that that's the only thing that will keep him great. And that's just gameplay. New characters, I'd say from Cream onward, need to go too. It's like cramming fifty characters into a dating sim and expecting you to be able to romance all of them: You're gonna get confused, and your experience will be a bad one.

Pardon the analogy, I've only played one dating sim in my life, that was just a comparison and in no way am I saying that Sonic is like a dating sim.

At 7/1/10 01:03 AM, joe9320 wrote:
There should be a Sonic game that should only have Amy, Tails, Knuckles, Sonic, Rouge (?), Shadow (?) and Dr. Eggman. Also, stylise it in some sort of Sonic 1, 2, 3, 4 and Advanced series. 3. ??? 4. PROFIT!!! And lots of accliam from fans and reviewers alike.

New characters, I'd say from Cream onward, need to go too. It's like cramming fifty characters into a dating sim and expecting you to be able to romance all of them:

News flash: Cream hasn't appeared since ShTH, Shadow hasn't appeared since 06, (Neither have Blaze or Silver for that matter) and pretty much every character in the Sonic series has only been in like 1 game for story reasons (Don't start) and then they disappear. The fact that you assume every character reappears in every Sonic game now is seriously ignorant.

At 6/16/10 07:27 PM, KeroKeroMario wrote:
Here's an idea: no more new ideas. Seriously, every Sonic game for the past decade and a half went with a form of a "new idea." The Werehog was one of those ideas.

/thread. Sonic needs to go back to basics, like in the Genesis games. That's what made him great, and Sonic 4 will prove that that's the only thing that will keep him great. And that's just gameplay. New characters, I'd say from Cream onward, need to go too. It's like cramming fifty characters into a dating sim and expecting you to be able to romance all of them: You're gonna get confused, and your experience will be a bad one.

You can't just keep trying the same ideas over and over again. I'm sure no one would like it if Sonic had ten games in a row that were the same. Sure, what if they recaptured the speed and fun of the very first games? People would like them, but after the first 4-5 games, they'd get bored of the same old ideas.
Just look at Mario, he had a great run with his 2D sidescrollers, then Nintendo made the jump to 3D and did an exceptional job. Then they had the idea to make party games and sports games, which sold well. Then they had an idea: "Think Super Mario 64, but in SPACE!".
The thing is, just because Sonic is doing poorly doesn't mean that he should have no new ideas.