Hens & Kelly began as a dry goods store at 485 Main St in 1879. The original owner was Jeremiah F. Sheehan. In 1882 Sheehan partnered with John J. Klaus. They opened their new store together, Klaus & Sheehan, at 446 Main Street. Mathias J. Hens was hired as a bookkeeper for Klaus & Sheehan.

Hens came to Buffalo from Germany in 1871, and began to
work at Klaus & Sheehan after graduating from Canisius
College. He met Patrick J. Kelly, who just arrived to the
country, while on a buying trip in New York City. Kelly was
employed at Simpson & Crawford.

Jeremiah Sheehan decided to leave Klaus & Sheehan and create his
own company, J.F Sheehan & Company in 1887. Mathias Hens bought
Sheehan’s share in J. F. Sheehan & Company shortly before the
company dissolved, in 1892. Hens invited Patrick Kelly to join,
and they created their store together, Hens & Kelly. The
first store opened on May 1, 1892 at 488 Main Street, photo above as
part of the Miller Block. They stocked “ladies and gents furnishings.”

Hens & Kelly survived the Panic of 1893, they in fact prospered
during this time. They took over the neighboring Benson Art Shop and
made it their millinery department. The store’s founders made “Good merchandise at the lowest prices,” the store policy.

Hens & Kelly was one of the first stores to adopt S&H Green Stamps.
This was a rewards program that provided stamps with each purchase.
These stamps could be used to buy products from a catalogue at a later
date.

The department store was able to survive another depression in 1907 and continued to grow.

View of Hens & Kelly expansion of 1910 from Palmer’s Views of Buffalo, 1914, posted at the Library of Congress

The store kept expanding to meet demand,
eventually consisting of six little stores, nearby, on Main
Street. In 1922 Hens & Kelly began the biggest expansion of
their downtown store, compressing all the stores into one department
store. This renovation cost one million dollars, which would be
$13 million today. They also added a six story addition.

Photo by Frank Schifferle, from the SUNY Buffalo State Archives and Special Collections, Courier Express Collection

Hens & Kelly added a special feature for
men shoppers. The owners realized that most men do not enjoy
shopping, and wanted to make the shopping experience easier for them.
The department store created a special entrance for men, leading right
into the Men’s Department.

The two Hens & Kelly partners were unusual in business because they
never retired. Kelly was quoted saying “I would rather wear out than
rust.” Kelly died in 1927 doing what he loved. The following year the
department store had a notable robbery. Thieves broke in around 7:00
am, tied up two watchmen, and blew open the safe door using
nitroglycerin. The thieves were able to escape with $20,000, which
would be $250,000 today. In 1935 the remaining original owner, Mathias
Hens, died. Arthur P. Wesp became the new president for the department
store.

The 1950s brought expansion outside of
downtown. Hens & Kelly opened a store in South Buffalo at
2262 Seneca Street in December 1950. The location did poorly and closed
in 1959. Despite this start, new stores opened in Lackawanna and
Clarence. In 1960, Hens & Kelly opened their largest suburban
department store in Hamburg. The store cost $4 million and was the
largest S&H Green Stamp redemption center in Western New
York. Hens & Kelly placed a time capsule in the brick wall
with signatures and messages from the Hens & Kelly Board of
Directors. Another store opened in Amherst in 1961.

Sperry & Hutchinson, the parent company of S&H Green Stamps,
bought Hens & Kelly, deciding it would be more profitable to
purchase the department store chain then to work through them.
Sperry & Hutchinson added two branches to the chain. 1970s
sales were not performing. Hens & Kelly was sold to Twin Fair Inc.,
a Western New York discount chain, in 1978. Twin Fair hoped to bring
back the glory days of Hens & Kelly, but sales continued to
decline. The first store of the chain closed in 1981, followed soon by
four more, launching a domino effect for the rest of the stores.
By 1982 the final Hens & Kelly store closed, a victim of the
depressed economy in Western New York and changing trends in national
retailing.

Twenty-five years later, in 2007, there was talk of demolition of the
South Shore Hens & Kelly store for construction of a new
Walmart. There were protests urging retrieval of the 1960 time
capsule, but they were not headed. The store was demolished, but fifty
four small scrolls containing the history of the Hens and Kelly stores
were found in the rumble and saved.