Contents

Story

Day 31

Day 31's Tree Mail announced a surprise Immunity Challenge instead of the Reward Challenge that the castaways expected. When they got to the challenge site, Jeff announced that it would be a combined Reward/Immunity Challenge. With the castaways balanced on the first set of slats, Jeff offered up a plate of donuts and a glass of milk to whomever jumped off. Erik and Eddie agreed to jump off together. When the castaways moved up to the second set of slats, Jeff offered three hot dogs and a soda, which Cochran took. Thirty minutes into the challenge, the castaways moved to the top of the a-frame where Dawn, Sherri, and Reynold fell off, leaving Andrea and Brenda to fight it out. They tried to negotiate for one of them to win, but neither wanted to step off. They continued the challenge for three hours when they agreed to share the reward note and to make up their own fourth stage of the challenge by lifting their left foot off the top of the a-frame. Jeff counted down to this new fourth stage and Brenda fell off the top shortly thereafter to give Andrea the win. Back at camp, the reward note turned out to be a clue to the Hidden Immunity Idol. Andrea shared the clue with her whole alliance and they went looking for the idol. Erik found it and handed it over to Andrea. Brenda's determination to stick it out in the challenge made Andrea suspicious of Brenda as she could be a big threat in future challenges. Andrea pushed Cochran, Dawn, and Sherri to blindside Brenda instead of splitting the vote between Eddie and Reynold. But when Tribal Council came, the Favorites did not blindside Brenda and instead sent Reynold to the jury by a vote of 4–2–1–1.

Day 32

Day 33

After Tribal Council, Andrea was still lobbying hard to Cochran about blindsiding either Brenda or Dawn. Cochran told Brenda and Dawn about Andrea's plan. Brenda immediately turned against Andrea. Erik won the Immunity Challenge by a blowout over Brenda. Back at camp, Andrea continued to push for a blindside. Cochran figured out that Andrea wanted to take Eddie to the final three, possibly displacing Cochran in the final three. Suspicious that Andrea was leaving him out of her plans, Cochran talked to Brenda, Dawn, and Sherri about blindsiding Andrea. Just in case Andrea got paranoid at Tribal Council and played the Hidden Immunity Idol, Cochran got his alliance to split the vote between Andrea and Eddie. Andrea told Erik that she would like to go to the final three with him. Erik wasn't sure if he should join Brenda and Cochran in blindsiding Andrea or joining Andrea in voting out Brenda. At Tribal Council, the timing of a "big move" was discussed. When the vote came, Erik made his "big move" and decided to vote against Andrea. Andrea was not paranoid enough to play her Hidden Immunity Idol and she took it with her to the jury by a vote of 3–2–2.

Challenges

Challenge:Bermuda TrianglePlayers will stand on an unstable triangular platform. They would move up a rung at regular intervals until they reach the top. Jeff Probst will tempt the castaways with food. If they fall off for any reason, they are out. The last person standing wins.Reward: A clue to a Hidden Immunity Idol.Winner:Andrea Boehlke

Challenge:Fun ClimbThe castaways would maneuver a buoy through a rope maze to a post. They would then untie a series of knots to release a key. The released key would open a chest that contained a set of ladder rung puzzle pieces. The first castaway to assemble their ladder and climb to the top of the tower would win.Winner: Erik Reichenbach

Tribal Council

Day 31

Tribal Council 12:Enil Edam

VotedAgainst

Voter

Reynold (4 votes)

Andrea, Brenda, Dawn, Sherri

Eddie (2 votes)

Cochran, Erik

Erik (1 vote)

Reynold

Sherri (1 vote)

Eddie

VOTED OFF: Reynold Toepfer

Voting Confessionals

“

(voting against Reynold) I think things would've gone a lot better for you if you would have been a little bit more humble in this game.

Final Words

“

Here I am, adiós. I put my trust in a lot of people and that wasn't reciprocated, and I had no more rabbits I could pull out of my hat. No more Immunity Idols, but, uh, I'll tell you one thing for sure: I had the time of my life.

Final Words

“

Unfortunately, I was confident with this plan I set up that I wasn't even thinking about playing the idol. I should have learned my lesson the first time that when the day's really calm, people are napping and you feel comfortable, you're probably gonna get blindsided, and it happened again, but I will always have this beautiful necklace souvenir that will remind me about trusting people too much.

Trivia

Behind the Scenes

Andrea describes herself as a "Stubborn German" during the Day 31 Immunity Challenge. She explains that she was hungry for an immunity win and the clue to the Hidden Immunity Idol, hence the deal she brokered with Brenda.

Life at Ponderosa

Reynold reflects on how bittersweet it is to be out due to the harsh conditions on the island. Reynold immediately goes to his post-game check-up, where he learns he has dropped from 203.7 lbs. to 181.0 lbs. Reynold comments that he has not weighed that much since his freshman year of high school. Reynold arrives at Ponderosa, where Michael and Malcolm welcome him. Michael, Malcolm, Phillip, and Reynold sit down and eat. Reynold expresses his surprise at how down-to-earth Phillip really is, contrary to his view of Phillip being egotistical in the game.

Despite her blindside, Andrea leaves Tribal Council in good spirits, saying that she wanted to play hard, but it she deduces that she might have played too hard to vote Brenda out. Instead of moping about her elimination, Andrea laughs her elimination off. During her post-game check-up, she learns her body weight dropped from 126.6 lbs. to 115.6 lbs. Andrea cheerfully arrives at Ponderosa, where she is warmly welcomed by the other jurors, including Malcolm, whom Andrea thinks is bitter towards her. She then reflects her experience in two seasons, saying that she is just as surprised by how dirty and scruffy she looked when she was voted out from Survivor: Redemption Island, and now. She happily wears her unused Hidden Immunity Idol and intends to keep it as a souvenir.

Other

This is the ninth episode in which a contestant was voted out by a plurality (i.e., less than half of all counted votes), with Andrea receiving only 3 out of 7 votes.

This is also the second time in which Cochran and Dawn are involved in a Tribal Council that ends with the eliminated contestant being voted out by a 3-2-2 plurality, after "Taste the Victory".

Reynold's elimination marks the first time this season that the remaining female contestants outnumbers the remaining male contestants (4 to 3). The balance would be restored by the end of the episode and the female contestants wouldn't form the majority again until Day 39.

Brenda and Erik, the only Favorites who voted against Andrea during the Day 33 Tribal Council, are also the only Favorites (and in extension, castaways) to make the merge that voted against Andrea during the first Tribal Council vote of the season, in "She Annoys Me Greatly", where they failed to vote out Andrea.

With Andrea's elimination, she becomes the first female jury member of the season.

As of this episode, Erik has given away all three forms of immunity (tribal, individual, and hidden) to another contestant.

Reynold's elimination briefly interrupted the streak of eliminations of players that were on Bikal at one point in this season, which started in "Persona Non Grata". Afterwards, the streak continued until Eddie's elimination.