On November 6th, 2011, 2 year old Sky Metalwala disappeared under suspicious circumstances in the midst of an ugly custody battle between his parents. The day after Sky's father was finally given visitation rights, his mother says that that he was taken from her parked car after she ran out of gas and went looking for help. But, the problem is... all evidence indicates that she is lying and it is even possible that Sky Metalwala was never even in his mother's car that day.

On Halloween 2002, Chris Jenkins got kicked out of a bar in Minneapolis and was forced to walk home. And that was the last he was ever seen alive. The authorities hastily came to the conclusion that Chris had accidentally drowned in the Mississippi River, but over the years, new details have come to light that suggest otherwise.

In 2013, Brandon Lawson ran out of gas on a remote stretch of highway in Texas. He called his brother for help, who arrived not too long after, but found no sign of Brandon. While Brandon was stranded, he made a strange call to 911 that has led to countless different theories as to what exactly happened to him that night.

On Christmas Eve, 1945, the Sodder family home burned to the ground. George and Jennie Sodder, along with four of their children, managed to get out. The five remaining children weren’t so lucky, and George and Jennie would spend the rest of their lives trying to figure out exactly what happened to them.

In 1922, the maid of a family living in a small German town quit and fled in a panic after she reported hearing footsteps and voices coming from the attic. A few months later, the entire family was savagely murdered.