@luckynumber8 wrote:Having a tough time with this. Would you guys take the gamble on Edwards if you had 14 trades remaining or bring in a nuffie to fatten the bank balance?

He looks like he could be a 40pt player which would be great.

I bought him in last week and I had like 14 trades left after upgrading to McInnes. Granted you missed a big price rise but as long as the Panthers are winning he'll be fine to keep his spot as Cartwright would go back to the forwards I presume. Even Griffin ain't stupid enough to change a winning formula.

The other backs are Leilua, Croker, Fui, RTS, Walker, Hayne, with Munster in the halves.

he would fit the same mould as most of your backline, you would still need to get Raps and or Teddy in there, so youd be looking at at least 3 trades in the backline min (+ cashouts). If your set in the frf and 2fr like some then yeah.

i think munster is a keeper at wfb and i own rts who may make way for teddy or rapana soon. Walker could be a good 18th (CWalker?)

In all seriousness though, Guth wasn't goal kicking then. He has an extra 6 points on his average this year because of goals. So to compare his form this year with when he was in the centres, if he was goal kicking back then he'd be at 41 over 5 games at Centre.

He has averaged 35 at fullback with goalkicking this year.He has averaged 48 at 5/8 with goalkicking this year.He would have averaged 41 at Centre if goalkicking last year.

Anyone holding him through his fullback games could do worse than see what he offers this round. Mind you I don't have him so easier said then done.

Well put together! Clearly you havent started on the beersies yet like I have hahahaha.

also, I am holding onto BJ so well done to anyone that has Guth over him!

Heres a question for those playing at home - does anyone in the NRL world at the moment have a more smug face than Gaz? Fucking beak nosed cunt,