Would Roger have been killed if: he had ordered something to eat? he had ordered something else to drink? there was another bartender - not Neville - at work? he had ordered the same but said it differently? Would Roger have been killed before getting a drink?

Would Neville had been killed if: Roger was a woman? Roger had ordered something to eat? Roger had ordered something else to drink? Roger had ordered the same but said it differently? Would Neville have been killed before Roger getting a drink?

I knew it would be FYOI, but you do understand...I had to eliminate the possibility Understood

did Gervaise kill the other two on behalf of someone else? No

did he in fact kill them both for the same reason? No

does Roger get the chance to drink the drink? No

is the type of drink important? Yes alcoholic? Assume it was a cocktail? It easily could have been this water? But not this

Would Roger have been killed if: he had ordered something to eat? Probably nothe had ordered something else to drink? Also probably notthere was another bartender - not Neville - at work? No - good q!he had ordered the same but said it differently? YesWould Roger have been killed before getting a drink? No

Would Neville had been killed if: Roger was a woman? YesRoger had ordered something to eat? UnlikelyRoger had ordered something else to drink? Also unlikelyRoger had ordered the same but said it differently? YesWould Neville have been killed before Roger getting a drink? No

Gangs as in Bloods and Crips? Were Neville and Roger in different gangs? The same gang? Neville and Gervaise? Roger and Gervaise? Were all of them in one gang or another?

And speaking of dreaming about being in bars, I dreamt last night that I was locked in a bar and the police were coming to arrest me for underage drinking and then I got woken up by the locksmith knocking on my door to fix the lock.

Gangs as in Bloods and Crips? Yes Were Neville and Roger in different gangs? The same gang? Neville and Gervaise? These two were in different gangs Roger and Gervaise? Were all of them in one gang or another? No

And speaking of dreaming about being in bars, I dreamt last night that I was locked in a bar and the police were coming to arrest me for underage drinking and then I got woken up by the locksmith knocking on my door to fix the lock. At least the locksmith didn't arrest you. I haven't had any dreams like that lately. For that matter, I can't remember any recent dreams.

So then Roger isn't in any gang at all? So are the two gangs the Bloods and the Crips? Or other (real) gangs? [LTPF list of gangs]? Was the drink something that members of a certain gang frequently drank? Something that members of a certain gang wouldn't drink? (Sort of how Crips wouldn't order a Bloody Mary because it's red and that's the Bloods' color)

Was Gervaise waiting for someone? Did Gervaise mistake Roger for someone else? No to both

So then Roger isn't in any gang at all? Correct So are the two gangs the Bloods and the Crips? No, I made them up Or other (real) gangs? So no [LTPF list of gangs]? But you can give them names if you'd like Was the drink something that members of a certain gang frequently drank? No Something that members of a certain gang wouldn't drink? No (Sort of how Crips wouldn't order a Bloody Mary because it's red and that's the Bloods' color)

Did Neville have any relevant tics or gestures? No, but... Specific manner of speaking? No Specific manner of preparing drinks? No, but...

Did G know that his target works as a bartender in this bar? No

when Roger ordered the drink did he mention Neville's name? or something else which would have helped Gervaise identify him? No to both

did Gervaise actually say anything out loud? did he speak with an accent? a stammer? was there anything special about his voice or the way he spoke? Irrel, assume No to all

did Neville actually say anything out loud? Only to Roger, concerning his drink. Anything he said is irrelevant. did he speak with an accent? a stammer? was there anything special about his voice or the way he spoke? Irrel, assume No to all

Can we call Neville's gang the Funkanas and Gervaise's gang the Murderettos?

Did Neville's tattoo identify him as a member of the Funkanas? Some high ranking officer? The leader? Was he a high ranking officer? A leader? Or did it simply identify him as the Funkana who had done some wrong to a Muderetto, so Gervaise was getting revenge?

Can we call Neville's gang the Funkanas and Gervaise's gang the Murderettos? Sure...

Did Neville's tattoo identify him as a member of the Funkanas? Yes Some high ranking officer? The leader? Was he a high ranking officer? A leader? No to these Or did it simply identify him as the Funkana who had done some wrong to a Muderetto, No so Gervaise was getting revenge? Noish/Yope

was the tatto on his wrist? Here his hand? his neck? his ankle? getting desperate now Permit me to aid with a

RECAP:

Roger walks into a bar and orders a drink, which could have been a cocktail, but not beer. Something happens that reveals a tattoo on Neville's wrist. This tattoo reveals Neville to be the member of a certain gang. Gervaise, the customer sitting next to Roger, is a member of a rival gang, so he shoots Neville. And then shoots Roger to remove any witnesses.

To solve: Why does the type of drink matter? And what caused the tattoo to be revealed?