Do or Don't? A Cat-Eye THIS Dramatic, Like Jena Malone's

When it comes to makeup, the cat-eye is the new pants—but is there a point at which this reborn-classic eye makeup shape gets a little too dramatic for your taste? Case in point: the extreme black cat-eye Jena Malone wore to last night's Hunger Games: Catching Fire screening in NYC.

If I might chime in with my own personal opinion—because what kind of beauty blogger would I be if I didn't?—I think Jena totally has the cuteness, style, and bubbly personality to pull off this makeup. I love the edginess of the eyeliner paired with the cool retro flip of her hair, and that lipstick that gives a pop of color without being too harsh against the cat-eye's graphic lines. The structured color-blocked outfit is also balancing the makeup well.

What do YOU think? Is this a cat-eye gone too far, or do you love the drama?