Tomorrow, the first-ever Hollywood blockbuster to feature a do-rag-wearing kitten premieres nationwide—but before the release, the film’s human stars stopped by Reddit to explain how this absurd premise for a script became a reality.

“… we wrote the whole thing, the first draft, without a kitten in it,” Jordan Peele explains. “And then we realized we needed something to … bring the heart to the movie, so we came up with this idea of this kitten that wears a do-rag …”

“You have the most vulnerable, fluffy, cute thing in the world,” co-star Keegan-Michael Key adds, “and the majority of our movie takes place on the gritty streets and in a dank, grimy strip club with a bunch of gangsters.”

The result? Hopefully comedy gold.

As the Mad TV vets behind Comedy Central’s hit sketch show Key and Peele answered redditors’ questions in a video AMA (Ask Me Anything), they dished on everything from their comedic father figures, a new dinosaur called the “Keanu-osaurus Rex,” and why they’d prefer CGI kittens to a team of “cat actors.”

Of course, the pair didn’t simply answer questions about their new film.

They also settled the age-old question every creative duo must face: Which one is the Simon and which one’s the Garfunkel?

To watch all of their (hilarious, often eerily synchronized) answers to redditors’ questions, check out the full YouTube playlist from their Reddit AMA. But before they left for the next stop on their promotional tour for the film, Peele made this humorous plea to fans on the fence about seeing the movie: “Keanu, once again, remember it comes out on April 29th, at a theater near you. Please go see it. Tell everybody you know to go see it. Tell your friends to see it, if you love it. If you don’t love it, tell your enemies to go see it.”