Transcription

1 Case MDL No. 557 Document 167 Filed 08/08/14 Page 1 of 5 UNITED STATES JUDICIAL PANEL on MULTIDISTRICT LITIGATION IN RE: AUTO BODY SHOP ANTITRUST LITIGATION MDL No. 557 TRANSFER ORDER * Before the Panel: Pursuant to 8 U.S.C. 1407, plaintiffs in all actions move to centralize this litigation in the Southern District of Mississippi or, alternatively, the Eastern District of Louisiana. The litigation consists of five actions pending in five districts, as listed on Schedule A. Plaintiffs are principally individual collision repair shops in five states. They allege a conspiracy in the automobile insurance industry to suppress the reimbursement rates for automobile collision repairs, in violation of Section 1 of the Sherman Antitrust Act and various state laws. There are two potentially related actions a putative nationwide class action in the Northern District of Illinois (Crawford) alleging a similar course of conduct by the top insurance carriers in the nation in violation 1 of federal anti-racketeering laws, and an individual action in the Western District of Louisiana. I. Collectively, there are over 80 insurers named as defendants in the actions, and their positions with respect to centralization vary significantly. The Allstate companies support centralization in the * Judge John G. Heyburn II, Judge Sarah S. Vance, and Judge Ellen Segal Huvelle took no part in the decision of this matter. 1 These and any other related actions are potential tag-along actions. See Panel Rules 1.1(h), 7.1 and 7.. The responding defendants are: Allstate Fire and Casualty Insurance Company, Allstate Insurance Company, Allstate Indemnity Company, Allstate Property and Casualty Company, Allstate Vehicle and Property Insurance Company, Allstate Property and Casualty Insurance Company, Allstate Corporation, Allstate County Mutual Insurance Company, Allstate New Jersey Insurance, Allstate New Jersey Property and Casualty Insurance Company, Esurance Property & Casualty Insurance Company, and Encompass Indemnity Company (collectively, Allstate ); Nationwide Mutual Insurance Company, Nationwide Assurance Company, Nationwide Insurance Company of Florida, and Nationwide Property and Casualty Insurance Company (collectively, Nationwide ); 6 companies on the GEICO brief, including 1st Century Centennial Insurance Company, 1st Century North American Insurance Company, American Family Mutual Insurance, Bristol West Insurance Company, Direct General Insurance Company of Mississippi, Foremost Insurance Company, GEICO General Insurance Company, GEICO Indemnity Company, Hartford Accident and Indemnity (continued...)

3 Case MDL No. 557 Document 167 Filed 08/08/14 Page 3 of 5-3- a substantial role in facilitating the alleged scheme. The Panel, in the past, has centralized antitrust cases involving allegations of concerted anticompetitive activity in the insurance market. See, e.g., In re: Blue Cross Blue Shield Antitrust Litig., 908 F. Supp. d 1373, (J.P.M.L. 01). Transfer under Section 1407 does not require a complete identity of common factual issues or parties as a prerequisite to transfer, and the presence of additional facts or differing legal theories is not significant where, as here, the actions still arise from a common factual core. See id. Transfer under Section 1407 will offer the benefit of placing all related actions before a single judge who can structure pretrial proceedings to accommodate all parties legitimate discovery needs while ensuring 4 that common witnesses are not subjected to duplicative discovery demands. Additionally, the actions are pending in five districts, which will make voluntary coordination impracticable especially given the large number of involved defendants. In these circumstances, Section 1407 centralization will ensure streamlined resolution of this litigation to the overall benefit of the parties and the judiciary. On the basis of the papers filed and the hearing session held, we find that these actions involve common questions of fact, and that centralization of the actions on the motion in the Middle District of Florida will serve the convenience of the parties and witnesses and promote the just and efficient conduct of the litigation. All actions share common factual questions relating to the allegation of an industry-wide conspiracy spearheaded by State Farm to suppress the reimbursement rates applicable to automobile collision repair shops, including complex issues concerning the role of direct repair 5 programs in furtherance of the alleged scheme. Centralization under Section 1407 will eliminate duplicative discovery; prevent inconsistent rulings on pretrial matters; and conserve the resources of the parties, their counsel and the judiciary. Weighing all factors, we have selected the Middle District of Florida as the transferee district for this litigation. The overwhelming majority of responding defendants support this district as their first or second choice, and it is easily accessible for this nationwide litigation. Judge Gregory A. Presnell, to whom we assign this litigation, is an experienced transferee judge who already is familiar with the factual and legal issues raised by this litigation. II. Although several parties ask that we also determine now whether the Northern District of Illinois Crawford action should be included in this MDL, we decline to do so. The action was not included in the motion for centralization, and many parties have not had an opportunity to present their arguments to the Panel. The arguments concerning transfer of Crawford may be presented as 4 Thus, we deny the request of defendant Farm Bureau Property & Casualty Insurance Company for simultaneous separation and remand of the claims against it to the District of Utah to be litigated on its own. 5 In direct repair programs, participating businesses allegedly agree to accept certain fixed rates in exchange for preferred provider status under which they obtain referrals of business.

4 Case MDL No. 557 Document 167 Filed 08/08/14 Page 4 of 5-4- an opposition to a conditional transfer order covering the action, if issued. See Panel Rule 7.1. IT IS THEREFORE ORDERED that pursuant to 8 U.S.C. 1407, the actions listed on Schedule A and pending outside the Middle District of Florida are transferred to the Middle District of Florida and, with the consent of that court, assigned to the Honorable Gregory A. Presnell for coordinated or consolidated pretrial proceedings. IT IS FURTHER ORDERED that the request of the Farm Bureau Property & Casualty Insurance Company for separation and remand of certain claims to the District of Utah is denied. PANEL ON MULTIDISTRICT LITIGATION Marjorie O. Rendell Acting Chairman Charles R. Breyer R. David Proctor Lewis A. Kaplan

Case 6:14-cv-00310-GAP-TBS Document 167 Filed 06/28/14 Page 1 of 73 PageID 934 IN THE UNITED STATES DISTRICT COURT FOR THE MIDDLE DISTRICT OF FLORIDA, ORLANDO DIVISION A & E AUTO BODY, INC., AMERICAN PAINT

2012 HOMEOWNERS COMPLAINT INDEX Please note that when a carrier has a small number of policies in force, the complaint ratio will be large. For example, if a company has a few hundred policies in force,

2014 HOMEOWNERS COMPLAINT INDEX Please note that when a carrier has a small number of policies in force, the complaint ratio will be large. For example, if a company has a few hundred policies in force,

Case: 1:14-cv-03146 Document #: 1 Filed: 04/30/14 Page 1 of 164 PageID #:1 IN THE UNITED STATES DISTRICT COURT FOR THE NORTHERN DISTRICT OF ILLINOIS EASTERN DIVISION Crawford s Auto Center, Inc., On Behalf

IN THE UNITED STATES DISTRICT COURT FOR THE NORTHERN DISTRICT OF ILLINOIS EASTERN DIVISION Crawford s Auto Center, Inc. and : K&M Collision, LLC, : On Behalf Of Themselves And All Others : Similarly Situated,

Insurance Company Claims Filing Telephone Numbers Find Your Insurance Company Policyholders with questions regarding their coverage for damage caused by a disaster should call the number provided on their

teen BEGINNING drivers INSURANCE INSTITUTE FOR HIGHWAY SAFETY BEGINNING DRIVERS AND CRASH RISK Getting a license is an important milestone for teens and parents, but being a beginning driver carries special

Composite of Insurance Investigated by the Illinois Department of Insurance in the Year HMO 437 Insurance Company 7,883 8,320 Not Categorized 2,074 Total 10,394 by Line of Coverage Auto 2,449 24% Homeowners

NOTICE Decision filed 05/03/12. The text of this decision may be changed or corrected prior to the filing of a Petition for Rehearing or the disposition of the same. 2012 IL App (5th) 100579-U NO. 5-10-0579

IN THE UNITED STATES DISTRICT COURT FOR THE NORTHERN DISTRICT OF OHIO EASTERN DIVISION MAIN PAINT & BODY, INC. On behalf of itself and all others similarly situated, v. Plaintiffs, STATE FARM MUTUAL AUTOMOBILE

Case: 3:04-cv-07762-JGC Doc #: 39 Filed: 07/25/05 1 of 7. PageID #: 407 IN THE UNITED STATES DISTRICT COURT FOR THE NORTHERN DISTRICT OF OHIO WESTERN DIVISION Allstate Insurance Co., Case No. 3:04CV7762

Case 3:07-cv-00172-MJR-CJP Document 8-1 Filed 03/12/2007 Page 1 of 7 IN THE UNITED STATES DISTRICT COURT FOR THE SOUTHERN DISTRICT OF ILLINOIS EQUAL EMPLOYMENT OPPORTUNITY, Plaintiff, and PEARLE PHILLIPS,

Case: 1:12-cv-10064 Document #: 137 Filed: 07/29/14 Page 1 of 11 PageID #:1365 IN THE UNITED STATES DISTRICT COURT FOR THE NORTHERN DISTRICT OF ILLINOIS EASTERN DIVISION IN RE CAPITAL ONE TELEPHONE CONSUMER

UNITED STATES DISTRICT COURT FOR THE DISTRICT OF RHODE ISLAND NICOLE MARIE CRUZ, Plaintiff, v. C.A. No. 05-38S HARTFORD CASUALTY INSURANCE COMPANY, Defendant. DECISION AND ORDER WILLIAM E. SMITH, United

The information in the report cards is as of October 18, 2013. It covers the insurers who make up the majority of the insurance market in areas affected by Storm Sandy, including: Consumer policies such

As of February 2016 Table of Contents How to Shop for Auto Insurance 2 What Factors Impact Rates 2 How to Use This Guide 3 About Financing Insurance 3 Notes to Rate Tables 3 Scenario Descriptions 4 A Comparison

IN THE CIRCUIT COURT OF THE NINTH JUDICIAL CIRCUIT, IN AND FOR ORANGE COUNTY, FLORIDA PROGRESSIVE AMERICAN INSURANCE COMPANY, CASE NO.: 2014-CV-000079-A-O Lower Case No.: 2012-SC-002127-O Appellant, v.

New Data Sources & Auto Insurance Shopping Greg Flemming Lightspeed Research Financial Services Group Car Shopping Isn t What It Used To Be... And Neither is Shopping for Auto Insurance Insurers are not

Page 1 of 7 Auto Insurance AAA s 2010 Your Driving Costs study found that the average cost to own and operate a sedan rose by 4.8 percent to $8,487 per year, compared with the previous year. Rising fuel,

UNITED STATES DISTRICT COURT FOR THE DISTRICT OF CONNECTICUT If you settled a personal injury or worker s compensation claim with Hartford Accident and Indemnity Company, Hartford Casualty Insurance Company,

Written Testimony to Texas House of Representatives Committee on Judiciary and Civil Jurisprudence - Subcommittee on Asbestos Interim Charge 4: Study the degree of transparency in asbestos bankruptcy trusts

The State of Nevada Department of Insurance Earthquake Insurance Nevada Consumer s Guide This guide contains information provided by the Nevada Seismological Laboratory at the University of Nevada in Reno,

FIND YOUR INSURANCE COMPANY: TOLL-FREE NUMBERS FOR POLICYHOLDERS PCI wants to help ensure that citizens are prepared in case of a severe storm or other natural catastrophe. Property insurance policyholders

Goodridge v. Hewlett Packard Company Doc. 13 IN THE UNITED STATES DISTRICT COURT FOR THE SOUTHERN DISTRICT OF TEXAS HOUSTON DIVISION CHARLES GOODRIDGE, Plaintiff, v. CIVIL ACTION H-07-4162 HEWLETT-PACKARD

Case 4:10-cv-00019-CDL Document 13 Filed 05/12/10 Page 1 of 9 IN THE UNITED STATES DISTRICT COURT FOR THE MIDDLE DISTRICT OF GEORGIA COLUMBUS DIVISION ATS INTERMODAL, LLC, a corporation; GARLAND B. BEASLEY;

Find your insurance company: Toll-free numbers for policyholders PCI wants to help ensure that citizens are prepared in case of a severe storm. Property insurance policyholders who have questions about

PROLOGUE THE ASCENDANCY AND CONCENTRATION OF MDLs CONSIDERED MDL litigation serves as yet another example of the innovation that has arisen in the last century, as we have struggled to address the problems