If Halo Top is the only low calorie, high protein ice cream game in your market, it's pretty good. However, I started buying Enlightened's version of pint ice cream. Holy shit. It's exponentially better, IMO. Their movie night ice cream is the tits. Highly recommended if anybody is watching their calorie count but loves ice cream. They've been in the "pop" game for far longer, too. I have some of their salted caramel and chocolate peanut butter ones in the freezer as we speak, but the pint ice cream is a weekend treat. Anyway... totally not an Enlightened ice cream shill, but I would suck a... nevermind. I really like their ice cream.

I have to respectfully disagree. Movie Njght is the only Enlightened flavor I thoroughly enjoy because it doesn’t leave a disgusting after taste. Every other flavor I’ve tried, and I’ve tried many, including seasonal flavors, just leaves the worst after taste. Maybe it’s an individualized thing, but my boyfriend only likes Movie Night too, and prefers Halo Top over Enlightened. I will still always try Enlightened flavors, though, and just hope that they don’t have an aftertaste. Haha. I’ve been trying to find Glazed Donut forever!!

Haven’t gotten myself to try Arctic Zero since I’ve heard so many people say it tastes like frozen flavored water. Haha. To me, Halo Top is king.

Arctic Zero is garbage. The description you have is on point. It used to be the only low calorie ice cream around. I think the flavored water thing comes from the fact that they don't have any dairy. I'm not sure if that's the case anymore, but I know that it was allergen free for awhile, so that's why it lacked basically any kind of texture and flavor.

My grocery store has, like, six flavors of Enlightened, but I always come back to movie night. I'll switch it up with peanut butter/chocolate and salted caramel from time to time, but movie night is my favorite. I wish they had all of those seasonal flavors I get e-mails about, but I guess I'm not in a test market. I shop at HEB, a pretty large grocery chain in Texas, in Austin, and we still don't get a huge selection (well, huge compared to, say, Ben & Jerry's).