Transcription

1 Supreme Court Clarifies Statute of Limitations Applicable to False Claims Act Whistleblower Suits Against Government Contractors In Kellogg Brown & Root Services, Inc., et al. v. United States ex rel. Carter, Supreme Court Holds That Statute of Limitations Suspension Applicable to Criminal Fraud Charges Does Not Apply To Civil Fraud Claims and That First-to-File Bar Does Not Preclude Suits Following Dismissal of First-Filed Action SUMMARY On May 26, the Supreme Court issued a unanimous decision concerning the scope of civil fraud claims brought by whistleblowers under the False Claims Act ( FCA ) against government contractors. In Kellogg Brown & Root Services, Inc. et al. v. United States ex rel. Carter, slip op., 575 U.S. (2015), the Court held that the Wartime Suspension of Limitations Act ( WSLA ) applies only to criminal charges, and does not suspend the limitations period for civil claims brought by individual whistleblowers under the FCA. The Court also held that the FCA s first-to-file bar which bars subsequent claims brought with regard to the same underlying allegations as an earlier filed action does not bar seriatim litigation if the first-filed claim has been dismissed. STATUTORY BACKGROUND The FCA provides for criminal and civil liability for government contractors that knowingly present[]... a false or fraudulent claim for payment or approval to an officer or employee of the United States. 1 Private parties may bring whistleblower claims, also known as qui tam actions, to enforce this provision, by filing as relators on behalf of the United States. 2 If the lawsuit succeeds or is settled, the whistleblower New York Washington, D.C. Los Angeles Palo Alto London Paris Frankfurt Tokyo Hong Kong Beijing Melbourne Sydney

2 is eligible to receive a portion of the government s recovery. 3 A qui tam action must be brought within six years of a violation or within three years of the date on which the United States should have known about a violation, and in no event may such an action be brought more than ten years after a violation. 4 The FCA also provides a first-to-file limitation, barring any later suit based on the facts underlying [a] pending action. 5 The WSLA, originally enacted in 1921, suspends any statute of limitations applicable to any offense [] involving fraud or attempted fraud against the United States. In 2008, Congress amended the statute to provide for suspension of the statute of limitations not only when the United States is at war, but also when Congress has enacted a specific authorization for the use of military force. Congress also extended the suspension period from three to five years after the termination of hostilities. 6 THE PROCEEDINGS BELOW The whistleblower claim was brought by Benjamin Carter, a water purification operator who worked in Iraq for Kellogg Brown & Root Services ( KBR ), a defense contractor that provided logistical services to the U.S. military in Iraq. Carter alleged that KBR had fraudulently billed the Government for water purification services that were not performed or not performed properly in The United States District Court for the Eastern District of Virginia dismissed Carter s complaint because a qui tam suit alleging similar claims was pending. 8 The first suit was later dismissed for failure to prosecute and Carter filed his complaint anew; his second complaint was dismissed under the first-to-file rule because the original suit was still pending on appeal. 9 In 2011, after that appeal was resolved, Carter filed his complaint for the third time, but by then more than six years had elapsed since the alleged fraudulent conduct. 10 Carter argued that the FCA s six-year statute of limitations had been tolled by the WSLA. The district court disagreed and dismissed Carter s complaint, holding that the WSLA applies only to criminal charges. The court also held that the suit was barred by the first-to-file rule, because two related cases had been filed before Carter re-filed his complaint. 11 The Fourth Circuit reversed on both grounds, holding that the WSLA applies to civil claims and that the first-to-file bar no longer applies after dismissal of the first-filed case (the two related cases noted by the district court had been dismissed by the time of the Fourth Circuit s decision). 12 The Supreme Court subsequently granted certiorari. THE SUPREME COURT S DECISION In a unanimous decision authored by Justice Alito, the Supreme Court reversed in part and affirmed in part the Fourth Circuit s decision. The Court held that the WSLA applies only to criminal actions and does not suspend the statute of limitations for qui tam civil actions under the FCA; and the Court agreed with -2-

3 the Fourth Circuit that the FCA s first-to-file bar ceases to apply if the first-filed suit has been dismissed. 13 In reversing the Fourth Circuit with respect to the WSLA, the Court analyzed the statute s text and legislative history, concluding that the Act only applies to criminal offenses. 14 The Court relied principally on the fact that the statutory language refers to offenses in connection with the suspension of the statute of limitations, and offenses, both in common usage and in legislation, refer to criminal acts only. 15 With respect to the FCA s first-to-file rule, 16 the Court focused on the statutory text, which provides that no person may bring a related action based on the facts underlying the pending action. The Court reasoned that the common usage of the word pending means that an earlier suit bars a later suit while the earlier suit remains undecided but ceases to bar that suit once it is dismissed. 17 The Court thus rejected KBR s argument that the term pending should be interpreted to mean that the first-filed action remains pending even after it has been dismissed, and it forever bars any subsequent related action. IMPLICATIONS Decision affirms the statute of limitations for qui tam suits. The decision, by declining to suspend the statute of limitations applicable to qui tam claims brought during times of war or when Congress has authorized the use of military force, should provide certainty for companies in opposing untimely civil whistleblower suits. Seriatim qui tam suits remain possible. The Supreme Court made clear that its decision as to the first-to-file provision was limited to holding that a qui tam suit under the FCA ceases to be pending once it is dismissed. 18 Notably, the Court expressly declined to reach the question of whether subsequent suits would be barred after a settlement or a decision on the merits of the first-filed suit. 19 The Court recognized that its interpretation of pending might produce practical problems and offered as an example that if the first-to-file bar is lifted once the first-filed action ends, defendants may be reluctant to settle such actions for the full amounts that they would accept if there were no prospect of subsequent suits asserting the same claims. The Court noted that the United States had argued that claim preclusion would protect defendants from seriatim suits if the first-filed action were decided on the merits, but the Court determined that issue was not before it. 20 In addition to claim preclusion, the FCA statute itself may provide important protections against copycat filings. The FCA bars qui tam actions brought on the basis of publicly available information where the relator was not an original source of that information. * * * Copyright Sullivan & Cromwell LLP

5 ABOUT SULLIVAN & CROMWELL LLP Sullivan & Cromwell LLP is a global law firm that advises on major domestic and cross-border M&A, finance, corporate and real estate transactions, significant litigation and corporate investigations, and complex restructuring, regulatory, tax and estate planning matters. Founded in 1879, Sullivan & Cromwell LLP has more than 800 lawyers on four continents, with four offices in the United States, including its headquarters in New York, three offices in Europe, two in Australia and three in Asia. CONTACTING SULLIVAN & CROMWELL LLP This publication is provided by Sullivan & Cromwell LLP as a service to clients and colleagues. The information contained in this publication should not be construed as legal advice. Questions regarding the matters discussed in this publication may be directed to any of our lawyers listed below, or to any other Sullivan & Cromwell LLP lawyer with whom you have consulted in the past on similar matters. If you have not received this publication directly from us, you may obtain a copy of any past or future related publications from Stefanie S. Trilling ( ; in our New York office. CONTACTS New York Robin D. Fessel Tracy Richelle High Theodore O. Rogers Jr Washington, D.C. Julia M. Jordan Jeffrey B. Wall SC1:

JUNE 2015 COMMENTARY Supreme Court Affirms Narrow Scope of Wartime Suspension of Limitations Act, Interprets False Claims Act First to File Rule In a unanimous decision issued on May 26, 2015, the United

Fraud Enforcement and Recovery Act of 2009 SUMMARY On May 20, 2009, President Obama signed into law the Fraud Enforcement and Recovery Act of 2009 ( FERA ), a statute intended to strengthen the federal

New York City Council Passes Bill Banning Use of Credit Checks in Employment Decisions Amendment to the New York City Human Rights Law Makes It an Unlawful Discriminatory Practice for Most Employers to

(Slip Opinion) OCTOBER TERM, 2014 1 Syllabus NOTE: Where it is feasible, a syllabus (headnote) will be released, as is being done in connection with this case, at the time the opinion is issued. The syllabus

Recent Legislative Developments in New York State Regarding Reductions in Force and Criminal Conviction Records SUMMARY A number of new New York State statutes of significance to employers will soon become

SEC Issues Final Rules Implementing the Dodd-Frank Whistleblower Provisions SUMMARY On May 25, 2011, the Securities and Exchange Commission voted 3 to 2 to approve the final rules implementing the whistleblower

Department of Labor Proposes New Overtime Regulations DOL Proposes Substantially Raising Salary Thresholds Used in Determining Who Is Exempt from Overtime Pay and Requests Comments on Potential Changes

New York Court of Appeals Announces New Rules Governing Practice in New York by Attorneys Not Provisions Permit Temporary Practice by Non-New York Attorneys and Registration of Non-U.S. Lawyers as In-House

IRS Publishes Final Regulations on Deductibility of Fiduciary Expenses Incurred by Estates and Trusts SUMMARY On May 8, 2014, the Treasury Department and the Internal Revenue Service ( IRS ) adopted final

Tax Court Addresses Implied Waiver of the Attorney-Client Privilege The Tax Court Holds That Raising Good-Faith and State-of-Mind Defenses to Accuracy-Related Penalties Could Result in an Implied Waiver

Supreme Court Holds that Agencies Can Amend or Repeal Interpretive Rules Without Notice-and-Comment Procedures SUMMARY The U.S. Supreme Court yesterday held that agencies are not required to follow notice-and-comment

Private Securities Fraud Claims Under Section 10(b) Based on False or Misleading Statements U.S. Supreme Court Holds that Private Actions May Be Brought Only Against Parties With Ultimate Authority Over

Changes to New York Power of Attorney Law New York Imposes New Requirements on All Powers of Attorney Executed in New York by Individuals Effective September 1, 2009 SUMMARY Effective September 1, 2009,

PCAOB Report and New SEC Rules Address Audit, Financial Reporting, Internal Control and Risk Management Issues Relating to Broker-Dealers These Developments May Be Relevant for Audit Committees of Public

Patent Infringement and Declaratory Judgment U.S. Supreme Court Holds That a Patentee Has the Burden of Proving Infringement in a Declaratory Judgment Action Brought by a Licensee SUMMARY The U.S. Supreme

NYSE Amends Rule on Material News Notification and Trading Halts NYSE Extends the Pre-Market Notification Period During Which Listed Companies Are Required to Notify the NYSE Prior to Disseminating Material

New York Amends Power of Attorney Law Retroactively SUMMARY The New York Legislature has now passed, and the Governor has signed, amendments to the New York Power of Attorney Law, Sections 5-1501 5-1514

October 29, 2014 IRS Issues Audit Directive on Worthless Debt Deductions for Banks and Bank Affiliates LBI Directs Its Auditors Not to Challenge Certain Worthless Debt Deductions SUMMARY The Large Business

New Audit Regime Allows IRS to Assess and Collect Tax at the Partnership Level SUMMARY The Bipartisan Budget Act of 2015 (the Budget Act) replaces the current partnership audit procedures with a very different

IRS Issues Final Regulations on Cancellation of Indebtedness Income and Other Consequences of an Exchange of Partnership Debt for Partnership Equity SUMMARY The Internal Revenue Service (the IRS ) recently

FINRA Provides Guidance on the Obligation of Broker-Dealers to Conduct Reasonable Investigations in Regulation D Offerings SUMMARY FINRA has published a regulatory notice providing guidance to broker-dealers

IRS Launches Third Offshore Voluntary Disclosure Program SUMMARY On January 9, 2012, the Internal Revenue Service (the IRS ) issued a news release announcing that the IRS is opening a third Offshore Voluntary

IRS Addresses Consequences of Purchasing and Selling Life Insurance Contracts Revenue Rulings Provide Guidance to Policyholders Who Surrender or Sell Life Insurance Contracts and to Investors Who Purchase

UPDATED OIG Guidelines for Evaluating State False Claims Acts Note: These guidelines are effective March 15, 2013, and replace the guidelines effective on August 21, 2006, found at 71 FR 48552. UPDATED

New York State Executive Budget Proposal Would Make Important Changes to Tax Laws Affecting Individuals and Trusts SUMMARY On January 19, 2010, New York State Governor David A. Paterson released his executive

Internal Revenue Service Issues Regulations Affecting REIT Conversions and Spinoffs IRS and Treasury Issue Regulations to Extend the Period During Which a REIT Is Subject to Corporate Tax on Built-in Gains

April 2014 In re Hawker Beechcraft, Inc.: Southern District of New York Holds that a Private Whistleblower May Assert Non-Dischargeable Claims under the False Claims Act at Any Time Contents Introduction

French Parliament Adopts Proposed Legislation on Financial Transaction Tax with Few Amendments SUMMARY Draft legislation to introduce a financial transaction tax (the FTT ) in France was presented by the

Corporate Governance of Delaware Corporations Delaware Adopts Amendments to the Delaware General Corporation Law Relating to Corporate Governance SUMMARY The Delaware legislature has enacted a number of

SEC Adopts Final Rules and Issues Guidance to Safeguard the Custody of Client Assets by Investment Advisers SUMMARY The SEC has adopted and published amendments to Rule 206(4)-2 under the Investment Advisers

IRS Issues Final and New Proposed Regulations Implementing the 3.8% Tax on Investment Income Final Regulations and New Proposed Regulations Implement the 3.8% Tax on Net Investment Income of Individuals,

dentons.com Insights and Commentary from Dentons The combination of Dentons US and McKenna Long & Aldridge offers our clients access to 1,100 lawyers and professionals in 21 US locations. Clients inside

The FDIC Issues a Final Rule Regarding Changes to the Ratios and Ratio Thresholds to Align the With U.S. Basel III Capital Rules On November 18, 2014, the Federal Deposit Insurance Corporation (the FDIC

Chinese Affiliates of Big Four Accounting Firms Ordered Barred from Practicing Before the SEC for Six Months; Suspension Stayed Pending Appeal Administrative Law Judge Finds that the Firms Willfully Refused

Healthcare Reform Law: Healthcare Fraud and Abuse and Program Integrity Provisions March 31, 2010 The Patient Protection and Affordable Care Act of 2010, as amended by the Health Care and Education Reconciliation

Case: 13-20206 Document: 00512651962 Page: 1 Date Filed: 06/04/2014 IN THE UNITED STATES COURT OF APPEALS United States Court of Appeals FOR THE FIFTH CIRCUIT Fifth Circuit FILED June 4, 2014 UNITED STATES

Seventh Circuit Expands the Based Upon Exception to Jurisdiction in False Claims Act Lawsuits Robert R. Stauffer and Sandi J. Toll As the authors explain, a recent appellate court decision should expand

Expansion and strengthening of protective measures, and reforms to procedures relating to bondholders and to accelerated financial safeguards SUMMARY French bankruptcy law has been recently modified by

European Court finds that Spanish tax rules were not unlawful state aid because they did not give a selective advantage SUMMARY In two recent cases on fiscal state aid, the General Court of the European

Bank Levies in the UK, France and Germany A Comparison of the New Levies on Banks SUMMARY The United Kingdom, France and Germany have all recently finalised, or are in the process of finalising, details

CLIENT MEMORANDUM FEDERAL CIRCUIT HOLDS THAT HEIGHTENED PLEADING REQUIREMENTS APPLY TO FALSE MARKING ACTIONS In a decision that will likely reduce the number of false marking cases, the Federal Circuit

November 9, 2006 Deficit Reduction Act Employee Information Requirements The Deficit Reduction Act ( DRA ) requires states participating in the Medicaid program to amend their State Plans to mandate that

Pharmacy Fraud, Waste and Abuse Policy 1.0 Compliance Assurance This Fraud Waste and Abuse Policy ( Policy ) reiterates the commitment of this pharmacy to comply with the standards of conduct established

PLEASE NOTE: Legislative Information cannot perform research, provide legal advice, or interpret Maine law. For legal assistance, please contact a qualified attorney. Be it enacted by the People of the

French 50% Withholding Tax on Interest Paid in Tax Havens Administrative Guidelines Provide for Safe Harbors under Which Interest Paid with Respect to Certain Notes Would Be Exempt SUMMARY Interest paid

Who is a whistleblower under the False Claims Act? Anyone who sees a Government contractor cheating the United States and wants to do something about it can blow the whistle. If you d like to put a stop