Photo: United States Senate – Official Photo of Mike Crapo from Senate Website, Public Domain

Paul Ryan (R-WI), the House Speaker, said the bill’s passage was a step toward “freeing our economy from overregulation… Our smaller banks are engines of growth … By lending to small businesses and offering banking services for consumers, these institutions are and will remain vital for millions of Americans who participate in our economy.”

Representative Nancy Pelosi (D-CA), the Democratic minority leader, disagrees, “It’s a bad bill under the guise of helping community banks …The bill would take us back to the days when unchecked recklessness on Wall Street ignited an historic financial meltdown.”

To cut costs, between 2012 and 2017, Capital One cut 32% of its branches while SunTrust slashed 22%, including about half of its locations in rural areas. Since 2009, 137 community banks in California have closed.

The truth is Dodd-Frank was not great for banking as a whole. And the high cost of compliance it demanded seriously hurt our community banks. However while it looks as if the days when Dodd-Frank had a stranglehold on banks may be over, we may have been sold some spin.

A Harvard University working paper released in early 2015, argues Dodd-Frank is the culprit contributing to fewer community banks. They simply could not keep up with the cost of compliance. The number of community banks has fallen by two-thirds in the last 30 years.

The Crapo Bill hammers away at capital and leverage requirements and gives a green light to larger regional banks to scoop up smaller community banks. Under the guise of helping community banks, the bill may actually allow for bigger banks to grow even larger.

In fact, by loosening regulations on medium sized banks it may be encouraging a rush of consolidation so even more community banks will disappear.

Just the day after the Senate passed the deregulation bill in March, Wells Fargo analyst Mike Mayo told CNBC: “We absolutely expect bank consolidation to accelerate.” The reason? Banks no longer face the prospect of stricter and more costly regulatory scrutiny as they grow.

Although the bill is praised by many as only providing relief for the community banks, there are also many very subtle changes in this bill that will actually provide relief to the megabanks. One such change reduces capital requirements for “custodial banks” with language allowing most of the large banks to possibly take advantage of this provision. Another changes the frequency of the mandated stress tests and the number of stress scenarios required.

Previously, banks over $50 billion in assets fell into that megabank category. The bill moves the threshold to $250 billion—a 400 percent jump that erases the mandate of enhanced scrutiny for 25 of the 38 largest banks in the country.

Yes, change to Dodd-Frank was sorely needed. And Wall Street and its lobbyists had already whittled down the 2010 Dodd-Frank financial reform legislation by a thousand cuts. The bill was originally passed to largely reign in egregious behavior, primarily by the big banks leading up to the 2008 financial crisis, but it unfortunately imposed heavy burdens on community banks, especially in regards to compliance. Some assert that the very rule which was formulated to curb the “too big to fail,” instead created a system of “too small to succeed.”

So Dodd-Frank turned out to be a real gift to the banking giants, which have many more resources to cope with increased regulation. It could be argued the big banks have grown larger as a result. The three largest — J.P. Morgan, Wells Fargo and Bank of America —now hold 32% of deposits, up from 20% in 2007. About 45% of new checking accounts last year were opened at one of the big three.

This bill has been sold to the public on the grounds that it eliminates some constraints on the high cost of community banking but, in my opinion and others, the new $250 billion threshold is an overreach.

Guess we have not yet learned that breaking up the TBTF and largely deregulating many of the remaining banks may be the right path to take. Until this is done the largest of the banks will still have the lobbying muscle to continue to further weaken those provisions of Dodd-Frank pertaining solely to them, thus increasing the chances that the largest banks will again lead our country into another financial crisis.

If you’d like to read more about the details of how many of the subtle changes in this bill benefit the TBTF, I recommend this article in The Intercept.

Ethics on your mind? Subscribe to my ezine to get my latest article delivered right to your inbox. Click Here to Subscribe

Richard Bowen is widely known as the Citigroup whistleblower. As Business Chief Underwriter for Citigroup during the housing bubble financial crisis meltdown, he repeatedly warned Citi executive management and the board about fraudulent behavior within the organization. The company certified poor mortgages as quality mortgages and sold them to Fannie Mae, Freddie Mac and other investors.

What People Are Saying About Richard M. Bowen

"Richard Bowen is one of my heroes. His is a story of human fortitude at its best and Wall Street at its worst."

~ William D. Cohan, NY Times Best Selling Author

2017-06-30T10:08:59+00:00

"Richard Bowen is one of my heroes. His is a story of human fortitude at its best and Wall Street at its worst." ~ William D. Cohan, NY Times Best Selling Author

http://www.richardmbowen.com/testimonials/2556/

"Richard Bowen reinforced my motto that "there is no right way to do a wrong thing.” Long after his presentation, the conversation has continued about personal responsibility and the courage to challenge things that appear to be wrong. We encourage this dialog and rely on it to help make our business stronger."

~ Eileen McDonnell, Chairman, CEO, & President, Penn Mutual

2015-02-13T19:51:19+00:00

"Richard Bowen reinforced my motto that "there is no right way to do a wrong thing.” Long after his presentation, the conversation has continued about personal responsibility and the courage to challenge things that appear to be wrong. We encourage this dialog and rely on it to help make our business stronger." ~ Eileen McDonnell, Chairman, CEO, & President, Penn Mutual

http://www.richardmbowen.com/testimonials/711/

"Richard Bowen, you are a star and a hero."

~ Ben Stein, Economist and Political Commentator

2015-02-13T19:50:26+00:00

"Richard Bowen, you are a star and a hero." ~ Ben Stein, Economist and Political Commentator

http://www.richardmbowen.com/testimonials/712/

"Richard's speech at the April Financial Executives International dinner was informative, interesting, riveting, and fast moving. The feedback from members was overwhelming positive, and Richard received one of the few standing ovations given by our membership."

"Richard's speech at the April Financial Executives International dinner was informative, interesting, riveting, and fast moving. The feedback from members was overwhelming positive, and Richard received one of the few standing ovations given by our membership." ~ Jim Farrell, Program Chairman, Dallas Chapter, Financial Executives International

http://www.richardmbowen.com/testimonials/532/

"Richard Bowen has been there, done that, and has the scars to prove it, and his message of corruption at the highest levels of industry and government needs to be heard. I only wish that more bankers had the courage that Bowen exhibits. He is not only one of the most talented bankers I have ever met, he has more integrity than all the bankers on Wall Street put together. If his former employer had listened to him taxpayers would not have had to bail out Citi for the third time in the last 30 years."

~ Dennis McCuistion, Host of the McCuistion TV program

2014-12-28T19:48:06+00:00

"Richard Bowen has been there, done that, and has the scars to prove it, and his message of corruption at the highest levels of industry and government needs to be heard. I only wish that more bankers had the courage that Bowen exhibits. He is not only one of the most talented bankers I have ever met, he has more integrity than all the bankers on Wall Street put together. If his former employer had listened to him taxpayers would not have had to bail out Citi for the third time in the last 30 years." ~ Dennis McCuistion, Host of the McCuistion TV program

http://www.richardmbowen.com/testimonials/533/

"Richard Bowen is a dynamic, entertaining speaker and story-teller - a CPA with a great personality!"

~ Betty Garrett, Garrett Speakers International

2014-12-28T19:47:50+00:00

"Richard Bowen is a dynamic, entertaining speaker and story-teller - a CPA with a great personality!" ~ Betty Garrett, Garrett Speakers International

http://www.richardmbowen.com/testimonials/531/

"I believe Richard Bowen is the only keynote speaker to ever receive a standing ovation from the Texas Society of CPA’s at any of its annual conferences."

~ Fred Timmons, Chairman of The Texas Society of CPA's

2014-12-28T19:47:22+00:00

"I believe Richard Bowen is the only keynote speaker to ever receive a standing ovation from the Texas Society of CPA’s at any of its annual conferences." ~ Fred Timmons, Chairman of The Texas Society of CPA's