Thursday, February 7, 2019

February 7, 2019T&T is grateful to have guest contributor David in Tennessee provide an update on the Christian- Newsom case. Sprocket.

Guest Entry by David in Tennessee
I've been following major trials going back to Manson and Patty
Hearst. The Christian-Newsom torture-murders are distinguished by the
sheer horror, length of time, convoluted events, twists and turns.

Channon Christian's SUV was
abandoned by the killers after wiping it down. However, a fingerprint
was found on an envelope in the car. The AFIS database linked the print
to one Lemaricus Davidson, with an address in Knoxville. When the police
arrived, they found Channon Christian's body stuffed in a garbage can.

Eventually
five suspects were arrested. Four were tried in Knox County. One, Eric
Boyd, was tried and convicted in Federal Court. More on Boyd presently.

The
four tried in state court were convicted. The "ringleader," Davidson,
was sentenced to death. His half-brother, Letalvis Cobbins, to LWOP (life without parole). George Thomas was sentenced to life with parole after 50
years. The lone female, Vanessa Coleman, to 35 years. Thomas and
Coleman had two trials. Why? Judge Richard Baumgartner was doing drugs
and having sex with a woman who was a probationer in his court. The
other defendants didn't get new trials due to rock-solid DNA evidence
against them.

In April 2018, KnoxNews.com reports a Knox County grand jury indicted Eric Boyd, who had long been suspected as one of the perpetrators.

"The
grand jury returned a 36-count presentment March 20 against Boyd, 46,
including charges of first-degree murder, felony murder, especially
aggravated robbery, especially aggravated kidnapping, and aggravated
rape in the January 2007 case."

Authorities
previously thought they didn't have enough evidence to charge Boyd.
There wasn't DNA from Boyd (at the time) on the victims and he was
crafty enough not to admit being in the death house, unlike the others.

Boyd
did give a lot of details in his police interrogation, but claimed he
heard them from Davidson. Boyd was convicted in Federal Court of hiding
Davidson and sentenced to 18 years.

Christopher Newsom's parents had pushed for Boyd's prosecution, whom they believed raped and murdered their son.

"Two
volunteer sleuths -Tom Hyman and Kevin Cowans- have helped the Newsoms
piece together evidence to present to Knox County District Attorney
General Charme Allen."

The Knox County DAG has declined to say what new evidence resulted in the grand jury indictment.

According to a KnoxNews.com story in June 2018, Cobbins and Thomas
implicated Boyd in their interrogations, but those statements can't be
used as evidence against him. The U.S Supreme Court ruled defendants
"have the right to confront their accusers via the witness stand, not
through unchallenged statements of co-defendants."

The
witness list against Boyd indicates his own words will be used against
him, something all suspects are told. Several corrections officers and
investigators are on the witness list.

Last week KnoxNews.com reported, Lemaricus Davidson, "ringleader" of the Christian-Newsom murders, was in Knoxville for a hearing requesting a new trial.

One
of the oddities of the whole case is Davidson and his lawyers insisting
on a Knox County jury. In all the other trials, a jury was brought in
from elsewhere in Tennessee. Judge Baumgartner in open court pleaded
with them to have a jury outside of Knox County. He sighed when the
defense lawyers still insisted on it.

Eventually,
Davidson was convicted and sentenced to death. Supposedly, the defense
can't use the Knox County jury as an issue for appeal. It sounds like
they are doing just that.

Why did they call for
a local jury? The answer is the defense talked themselves into
believing 12 impartial jurors couldn't be found. And defense attorney
Doug Trant suggested in testimony at the hearing, hoped not to.

Trant said: "I told (Davidson) if we were not able to seat a jury, he could not be convicted."

The
defense attorneys hoped jury selection would be "interminable" and the
prosecution might offer Davidson a plea deal on a reduced charge. The
District Attorney General's office had offered the defense a guilty plea
to life without parole. Davidson said no, declaring he preferred death
to life in prison.

After being convicted and sentenced to death, Davidson regretted his decision.

Trant
said: "I remember when he got the death sentence, he cried. He said it
was one thing to anticipate a death sentence and another to actually get
it."

The other defense attorney, David Eldridge, complained about the "level of publicity."

The defense also said it was common knowledge in the legal community that Judge Baumgartner was a heavy user of painkillers.

Davidson's
conviction was nearly overturned because of Baumgartner's drug use on
the bench, but the Tennessee Supreme Court ruled there was no
"structural error." The defense is trying again.

CONTRIBUTORS

T&T Readers To Date:

CORRECTIONS

T&T is always happy to make a correction, if warranted, upon request. Correction requests or demands received from a lawyer will be referred to our counsel and will, unavoidably, slow down the correction review process. We consider corrections to be a matter of journalistic integrity and not legal compulsion.

DISCLAIMER:

The expressions in this blog are our opinions or the opinions of our featured writers. Please remember we are not lawyers and those opinions expressed here are each of our individual opinions and should not be taken as legal advice and/or legal opinions. The comments following the blog articles are the opinions and sole property of the commenter's and do not necessarily reflect those of the site owners.