bigh0rt wrote:Okay, after reviewing the different roles in the sign-up thread, it seems obvious that the mafia killed and disposed of Big Pimpin, so we don't get to know what his role was, and that the Vigilante killed NorthSider, since we were given his role. We have now lost both our Cop and our Insane Cop, though we were never told which was which, so it seems wise, at this time, if the Amnesiac would assume one of those roles, so we can at least do some night investigating -- unless you want to roll the dice and see if we lose the Doctor, and take that role over.

To recap, the roles we have remaining are Doctor, Bulletproof x2, Vigilante, Amnesiac, and both mafia roles (Janitor and Hooker) -- except one of those belonged to BP, so we're minus 1 there, and we don't know which. Now that the Janitor has presumably used his power to dispose of BP, he'll just be a regular Mafia -- ThatDude, if I am completely off here, please point it out -- I'm still referring to the Sign-Up Thread to read about the roles.

I'm going to take a look back at Day 1 and see if any links jump out.

Since this is a new experience for everyone....

That is one possibility.

Another possibility is that Northsider was the Amnesiac, claimed the dead Cop role last night, and was then killed.

Sometimes it takes a crazy person to see the truth. If so, I'm a freaking lunatic.

Having all these roles does make it interesting but because we haven't had a mafia game in a while, we probably should of started out slow. Instead of introducing all these roles all at once, maybe you should of introduced them one or two at a time so that we could of gotten a feel for each.

So the mafia killed BigPimpin and the vigilante killed Northsider. Interesting that both of these people had votes on them during Day 1. I don't think the people who made these votes would then go and kill that person the same night, so I think someone was trying to set up both Snakes and h0rt. Not that means either of them are innocent.

I guess if this is the case the question is why the vigilante would want to set someone up? Either they weren't, or the vigilante believed whoever they were setting up was mafia, and this would be a good way to cast suspicion on them.

I don't remember the point I was going to make because now the only thing I can conclude from this is that maybe the vigilante thinks Snakes is mafia...I guess.

GiantsFan14 wrote:i'm still pretty convinced that snakes is mafia. just a bit here and there from posts he has made and the way the killings went down.

This is the feeling I have, as well. The only reason I'm hesitant is because having the vote on NorthSider just seems too obvious, and even then, would paint him as the Vigilante*, who we'd also want to get rid of (provided * is accurate). This sticks out to me, though...

Snakes Gould wrote:so bp is missing? what in the world does that mean? also, reading from the description, there were 2 cops and now both are dead, correct?

When I read that, it just came off as phony to me -- I was in the process of re-reading the sign-up thread, so I had assumed I was right on what the missing part meant, but it just rubbed me as him being the Janitor, fully aware of what he had done, and playing the IDK card.

Speaking of The Janitor, where's he been? It's hard to vote off another quiet type, since we're already down 3 townies to begin with, but I'm afraid he may just be trying to see how long he can skate by, knowing we'll be hesitant to roll the dice the way we did in Day 1. If we are able to nab one mafia, though, I think we have an enormous chance at winning this thing, especially with the Vigilante still alive -- though they figuring out who that is becomes the question, provided * is the correct assumption, again.

I dunno, it's been awhile, I think we all may be a little rusty here.

I'm not ready to vote, there are so many I am suspicious of, but right now I am most suspicious of Snakes; but I generally am anyway.

* ThatDude, the Vigilante is trying to be the last person alive, like in previous Mafia games, correct? Or does he count as a regular townie and once all the mafia are eliminated, the town and he win together??