Frank commentary from an unretired call girl

A Mound of Filth

Every civilization when it loses its inner vision and its cleaner energy, falls into a new sort of sordidness, more vast and more stupendous than the old savage sort. An Augean stable of metallic filth. – D.H. Lawrence

I grew up in an area of south Louisiana whose primary industry (in those days) was sugar production; one of the places we used to play was in a sugarcane field near our street, and from the late 19th century until the 1960s the majority of the area’s population worked for a large sugar refinery. Once the sugar-bearing juice has been extracted from the cane, the remaining vegetable matter is called bagasse; it can be burned to generate power and is also used for an agricultural fertilizer. But as you can imagine, it has a powerful odor, and the vast heaps of bagasse which are piled up in holding areas look and smell a lot like huge mountains of manure after sitting for a while in the damp Louisiana climate.

That was the image which entered my mind unbidden when I read this article almost two months ago. Like bagasse or manure, there is absolutely nothing new in it; it’s the end result of other processes, piled up in a 3000-word mound (and this is only part two!) and reeking to high heaven. And like those vegetable waste products, this type of filth is also very useful as fertilizer; unfortunately, the only crop it works on is the unwholesome one called the police state. “Sex trafficking” hysteria is prime manure for encouraging the growth of internet censorship, mass surveillance, border control, police violence, sexual repression and state control of women’s bodies, and though humanity would be better off if these noxious weeds were exterminated, all too many “journalists” are happy to nurture them instead by generating mounds of reeking rubbish like this one:

…“The technology of…phones and…computers and everything…is also a curse because we can’t track all the places our kids go,” said Kathleen Winn…[of] Phoenix’s sex trafficking task force…“we can’t control who reaches our children.” Social media…provides an egress for pimps into the lives of their victims, and a way for them to monitor their victims, according to…Dominique Roe-Sepowitz…the Phoenix Dream Center, a task force affiliate…said…“We even try to break up Internet businesses…We are looking for ways…[to destroy] Backpage.com…they make millions of dollars a year on their adult services ads”…

One of the most psychologically fascinating things about fanatics is that they’re so completely unable to recognize their own fanaticism, they often make statements that blatantly demonstrate it. The freakish need to “control” every interaction adolescents (the real meaning of “children” in this context) have with other people (at a time in their lives when they’re supposed to be learning how to function in adult society) is used as an excuse for schemes to “break up” internet businesses and a larger campaign to destroy the internet as we know it; this and the Luddite hysteria itself are openly avowed without any attempt to disguise them to fool non-fanatics. I’ve noticed this about many articles (whether anti-sex, anti-migration or pro-censorship) coming out of Arizona these days; due to the process of group polarization Arizonans seem completely unable to recognize how extreme their beliefs and rhetoric are in comparison with the rest of the country. When delusional maniacs like Joe Arpaio or John and Cindy McCain start barking at the moon, they do not realize how deranged they sound to others because everyone in Phoenix political circles encourages and applauds their howling. Dominique Roe-Sepowitz was completely unable to recognize what her creepy statement about “body fluids” and “normal relationships” sounded like to normal people until it started to be quoted in articles critical of Project ROSE; even then her response was not introspection, but simply refusing to give interviews to anyone other than a religious magazine. But I digress:

Two years ago…a civil case was filed…“against Backpage.com and the pimps…alleging that these kids were trafficked on Backpage.com,” said Erik Bauer, a Tacoma-based attorney…

Bauer predicted that Backpage’s future is foggy at best. “There are some weird legal decisions in our country, and so far they have enabled Backpage to exist and even thrive,” said Bauer. “Blatant prostitution advertising is what they are…I actually believe that Backpage’s days are numbered…We have a legal theory that works and they don’t”…

Blah blah blah pimps, blah blah children, blah “promoting prostitution”. I find it especially interesting that the only non-Arizonan quoted at length in this dungheap is from Washington…which foams at the mouth over sex nearly as much as Arizona does. And that’s a lot of foam:

Katie Resendiz of Arizona Training and Resources to Stop Trafficking (AZ TRUST)…said…“The hypersexualization of the youth and commodification of women’s bodies is exactly why we have a sex-trafficking crisis in the United States. We train young boys to think of women as objects and sex as something to be purchased, and we train women to think of their bodies as purchasable”…

Another astonishing aspect of “sex trafficking” rhetoric is the repeated assertion (not limited to Arizona) that prostitution is “accepted” and “normalized” in the United States, the only developed country in which the sale of sex is itself illegal. It requires an almost incomprehensible level of provincialism and ignorance to make such a statement, yet we see it over and over again like the tenet of faith it obviously is (often in close proximity to “prostitution is not a victimless crime”). And just in case you needed more proof of how deeply statist “trafficking” cultists are, Resendiz delivers this gem: “If you see something, say something, because if it looks bad, it probably is.” The conventional wisdom is that the police state, big religion and “feminism” are all different things, and some will claim that different proponents of “sex trafficking” hysteria have different motives. But that simply isn’t so; even if it had been true before the advent of the moral panic it certainly isn’t now, and Arizona’s fascist “trafficking” establishment is a perfect example. Much has been written about Project ROSE’s fusion of police state, religious and “feminist” social work elements, and the “Dream Center” featured in this article is no different:

…the Phoenix Dream Center is one of the municipal sex trafficking task force affiliates…There are 183 churches in the…Dream Center’s network. Its $2 million budget is supported…[in part] through…government programs…Classes at the center are life-recovery and spiritually based, and are taught by retired police…The organization works intimately with the U.S. Department of Homeland Security and the Federal Bureau of Investigation…

Nor is it only streetwalkers they label as “trafficked”:

The organization is the largest strip club outreach in the region, and has handed out gifts to more than 800 women on its Phoenix route…“We have outreaches at the malls, games, concerts, and Backpage. We’re working on the massage parlors, we will get there by 2015,” [operative Jessica] Knight said…“Whether it is a girl being trafficked…or a mom selling herself on Backpage to feed her family, we are there for them…[with] a…rescue squad that snatches the victim away from her pimp”…

Her ideas about “what sex trafficking abduction looks like” include “[letting] a person you do not know take pictures of you with their cell phone” and “kids talking to people they don’t know.” And like Resendiz, Knight encourages adolescents to report “suspicious” people “to the proper law enforcement authorities”; after her “training”, one shudders to think how many men are being investigated by the Phoenix Stasi as “pimps”, especially given that her philosophy is “It is better to cry wolf and be wrong, than to have a friend, neighbor, or family member disappear and end up in slavery.” Too bad for all the innocents who end up caged in Arpaio’s dungeon, I guess.

This article was a particularly large, particularly fragrant heap of prohibitionist manure, but the American journalistic landscape is dotted with them and they’re especially common in places like Arizona and Washington; puritanical control freaks are right at home in these mounds and can always be found wallowing ecstatically in their decomposing environment without as much as a clue about how they look and smell to everyone else.

15 Responses

“Social media…provides an egress for pimps into the lives of their victims…”

We were told a story in primary school about just how gullible some people are. We were told that in BT Barnum’s circus, at the end of the show, a sign went up saying “To the egress” together with the price for this “exhibit”; I think it was 10 cents. Apparently, lots of people paid to see the “egress”, but found themselves outside. The teacher explained that it was all a con; and that “egress” was just a posh word for “exit”.

I was a bit concerned to see that the escort advertising Website myredbook was recently taken down and its assets seized by the FBI. Now, it’s possible that the owners of the Website were doing something foolish and breaking some law that doesn’t currently fall under first amendment protection. On the other hand, I’m sure that it was an FBI fishing expedition pushed by the sex hating Obama administration, even if they found something legitimately criminal.

Not that you actually have to break the law to get a takedown along with your assets seized, as Steven Jackson Games found out (one of the events leading to the founding of the Electronic Frontier Foundation). It’s possible that after having their business destroyed for months a judge will force the FBI to give back their assets and let them go. My opinion in the case of myredbook is if you are going to run this type of business, run it from some foreign land with no extradition treaty with the US.

Well, it’s more than a bit concerning. MyRedbook was the main venue for Bay Area sex workers to advertize. From a clients POV, it had lots of ads, a good search engine, discussion boards, links to reviews, and so on, generally an excellent resource for someone to find exactly the kind of service they’re looking for without the hit-and-miss of answering random ads. (And by “random ads”, I’m particularly thinking of Backpage.) And via MyPinkbook, offered similar resources to sex workers for warning about bad clients, hotel policies, law enforcement activity, etc. I don’t think I’ve seen any site that’s so thorough.

Obviously, a lot of sex workers would point to some major downsides to RB, notably, the very vocal and often misogynistic “hobbyist” subculture that would frequent the boards, threats of downrating on the review boards to leverage for “extras”, and so on. But overall, a really key resource for doing business as an indoor sex worker in California. For many, its loss is the equivalent of doing much of your business over eBay, then waking up one day and having your eBay page, including years of feedback, gone for good. A lot of Bay Area sex workers are now finding themselves in a situation where with no prior warning they’re having to rebuild their business from scratch.

What’s also disconcerting is that this may be the tip of the iceberg. If they can take down MyRedbook specifically for “facilitating prostitution”, they can probably go after ErosGuide, Backpage, TER, and the rest on largely the same grounds.

I agree with you on your final point – anybody who’s going to do something like this is going to have to “offshore” it. Punternet, the UK escort review site, keeps their servers, hosts, etc outside the UK. Of course, the problem comes if a site actually tries to make money from escort advertizing. If the person running the business is taking money from someone doing illegal sex work (and in the US, most is illegal), there’s all kinds of “racketeering” laws that come into play, which is one of the things they’re hitting the RB owners with. So to be safe (or at least *safer*), site owners would have to be in a different country than the site covers, use things like BitCoin, etc.

I remember something similar happened to a board in Tampa, but it was strictly local LEO. It was not as good as what you describe, but a lot of people depended on it. A few people got hurt, but it didn’t amount to much in the end, most of the cases it generated didn’t get far in court. Still it was nerve wracking when it was going on.

My thinking is that if it was this easy to kill these kinds of Websites, it would have happened already. Certainly law enforcement has monitored them as long as they’ve been aware of them. Of course, new, crazy laws are being passed every day, and spectacles like this might just be the FBI taking one of them “for a spin” but I’d need to check with someone more knowledgeable about the laws passed lately on the Federal level.

I would suggest tomato juice, since it works when you get sprayed by a skunk. Just make sure when you are done (it does take two or three applications of tomato juice to get rid of skunk stench) to use lots of moisturizer, it tends to dry out the skin. Perhaps something with aloe.
I am not certain if they live in another universe, or it’s a matter of their having received their final decree in their divorce from reality.
It was great to meet you in person at Chooper’s Tuesday night. The book is excellent, and I am about 40% through it (I have reserved if for bedtime reading only. since my other reading (Jung’s Seminar on Zarathustra, and Dr. Donald W. Black’s Bad Boys, Bad Men) tends to require too much concentration.

Maggie on Twitter

Boring but necessary legal stuff

All original content on this website (i.e. all of my columns, pages and anything else which I write myself) is protected under international copyright law as of the time it is posted; though you may link to it as you please or quote passages (as long as you attribute the quote to me), please do not reproduce whole columns without my express written permission. In other words, you have to say "pretty please with sugar on top" first, and then wait for me to say "okey-dokey".