Friday, May 8, 2015

Sharing: MY VIEWS ON #SALMANVERDICT

A penitentiary in olden days was created for a criminal to be isolated, giving him a chance to do penance so that he corrects his ways. Over the past few centuries, prison has become a place of incarceration that makes the inmates worse than what they were before they went in. I wonder what the purpose of a judicial system is, which keeps supposed criminals behind bars, allowing them to fester in boredom with a high probability of making them more dangerous to the public when they get released. Well, that’s one aspect.

Then there are the hardcore criminals – read industrialists, government employees, politicians and the like; self-proclaimed dons; paid assassins; etc – who roam freely in the country. I am not sure if imprisoning them is exactly the answer to the problem. But then again, their roaming the country as free citizens is definitely not a solution. And how do they get away with it? By bribing, of course! (On an aside, Gabbar Is Back is a movie worth watching).

Talking of movies, do you remember Rajesh Khanna’s famous film Dushman (1972)? He plays a lorry driver who kills the earning member of a poor family when he drives his lorry in a drunken stupor. When he’s taken to court, the dead man’s father (I think) asks the judge of what use will it be if the killer is sentenced to prison for some years? Will that help the dead man’s family survive? That’s when the judge comes up with a landmark judgement. That the murderer (Rajesh Khanna) should earn money and take care of the deceased’s family for the number of years he was supposed to have been imprisoned. Over the next few years, a lot of healing happens between the family and the lorry driver until they finally forgive him. Now, that is what I would call a great solution to a bad situation.

Now, getting to our Sallu Bhai, I don’t think there is a doubt in anyone’s mind that he was the one who drove the car and killed those people. That he drove the car after drinking was “wrong”. That he ran the car over people and killed them was a grave mistake, but still a mistake. It’s definitely not something that he set out to do deliberately. While the case has been going on, Salman Khan has turned around a lot. There is his Being Human Foundation and a number of other acts of philanthropy that make life easier for a lot of people. Some might say that a few good acts do not compensate for one bad act. But why not? I don’t think the man would have been very comfortable with his conscience after the death of all those people. He has definitely done a number of good deeds to set that right in his own way. Yes, those will not bring those people back to life. Then again, Salman Khan languishing in jail isn’t going to bring them back either.

Does it make sense to put the actor behind bars? It’s not as if he’s a hardened criminal. There are many of those running around free and our judicial system seems to be doing nothing about those people. While, if Salman Khan is free, the film industry stands to make a lot of money, in turn helping the lives of many of those who are dependent on Bollywood. And there are those families who have received a lot of financial help from the Bollywood star. They stand to benefit too. And I am sure there will be more such people whose lives he will make better with his monetary backing.

Hence I, for one, vote that our society will gain more with Salman Khan continuing with his regular life than his going to prison for 5-10 years. Any of you willing to join me?

I feel he should get community service for the poor and help to the victims. We can say that because criminals are free, he should not be punished. each to its own, at least his punishment will set an example.

Example for what? I think the law has already become very strict with drunken driving. If they had sent him to jail immediately after the accident, I would have applauded. Not after all these years, especially when he is doing so much good to the public.

Though I have promised not to comment on #SalmanVerdict posts, I have to drop in to say one thing. I agree with your theory of Dushmann. The families lost a bread winner, make him their breadwinner. The kids who lost a father, make Salman thier gaurdian. That would be a positive punishment. Many are saying that then every hit and run case will run scott free. No. We do have a judiciary system. Let them decide taht on the spot. Not when 13 years have passed and the man has tried to make amends everyday of his life. Neither marrying and starting a family - waiting for the verdict. Second Chance has to be earned. It has to be given .. many of the people are willing to give. It does not mean we are supporting his hit and run action. But what is the meaning of second chance if this man does not deserve it?