Hmmmm..... his mug faces are one reason that I think he'd be perfect for Broadway. In a Broadway show the actors have to emote and overact, in a sense. That's just what they need to do in order to communicate to the entire theater. It wouldn't work on tv, or in a movie, but on a stage it's the number one requirement. Derek would be perfect on stage.

Danny's part requires a tenor. Tonight was a good test for Derek and he tanked it again. His vocals weren't good and I'd worry too if I were David Ian. Add a unteresting lackluster romantic performance to his weak vocals and not even his dark Danny good looks can earn him this part. He truly had no chemsitry with Laura during that number. Bottom two and could be going home.

Danny's part requires a tenor. Tonight was a good test for Derek and he tanked it again. His vocals weren't good and I'd worry too if I were David Ian. Add a unteresting lackluster romantic performance to his weak vocals and not even his dark Danny good looks can earn him this part. He truly had no chemsitry with Laura during that number. Bottom two and could be going home.

I do not agree at all! I thought Derek was better than either Austin or Chad (not as good as Max though) except for the little crack on a note. I think his chemistry with Laura was quite good. Austin is waaaay to effeminine and Max is just not sexy enough. Chad, however, is adorable and if a younger looking Danny is better, then he would be the one. However, IMO he is the weakest singer of the remaining four.