Hi-tech toilets save lives – and mean big business

In a world where 2.5 billion people still do not have access to basic sanitation facilities, and 1.5 million children die each year from preventable diseases as a result, there is a pressing need to find sustainable solutions to this most ancient of human problems.

But this isn’t just a humanitarian issue – it is also about hard-headed economics.

“The United Nations estimates that achieving the Millennium Development Goal for sanitation could save us $66bn [£41bn] in time, productivity, averted illness and death,” says Sanjay Bhatnagar, chief executive of WaterHealth International, a provider of water purification centres to developing economies.

The conditions were tough. Designs had to be hygienic, sustainable, cheap to operate, and capable of working “off-grid” – without connections to water, electricity, or sewerage networks.

Ideally, they should also be capable of reclaiming reusable materials from human waste.

In August this year, Bill Gates awarded the $100,000 first prize to Dr Michael Hoffmann, professor of environment science and engineering at the California Institute of Technology, for his team’s solar-powered loo.

Caltech PhD student Clement Cid with the new solar-powered sanitation system

It uses an electrochemical reactor to break down human waste into fertiliser and hydrogen gas, which can then be stored in electric fuel cells. The treated water can be reused to flush the loo or irrigate crops.

A panel of photovoltaic cells captures light and converts it into electricity stored in rechargeable batteries. One day’s light can produce enough power to run the entire electrochemical sanitation system night and day.

Human waste is channelled into a septic tank and undergoes an initial step of sedimentation and anaerobic digestion.

The “supernatant” liquid above the sediment is siphoned off into an electrochemical reactor and oxidised and the hydrogen extracted from the water.

Chloride from table salt is oxidised to form chlorine, which disinfects the water. This decontaminated water is then passed through a microfiltration system and stored.

The second prize of $60,000 went to the UK’s Loughborough University for a loo that produces biological charcoal, minerals and clean water from human waste, using a process they call “continuous hydrothermal carbonisation”.

This is a kind of high-pressure cooking followed by a drying and combustion process that ends up producing carbonised pellets. The dried material can be used as soil conditioner or as fuel for cooking or powering the sanitation system.

Cost-conscious
While these sustainable technological solutions are undoubtedly clever, they are relatively complex. Will they ever be affordable and simple enough for use in poor areas of developing economies?

“It’s great that someone is investing in blue-sky thinking and innovation, and something good may well come out of it, but we’re still left with the problem of how to provide such a service at a viable cost to poorer households,” says Erik Harvey, head of programme support unit for the charity WaterAid.

But M Sohail Khan, professor of sustainable infrastructure at Loughborough University, told the BBC: “Prototypes are always expensive because they’re in the experimental stages. The cost will come down in time.”

He argues that moving away from centralised sewerage collection and treatment systems, with all their attendant infrastructure expenditure, to self-contained, sustainable units like his team’s prototype, will also help reduce overall costs.

“Hi-tech doesn’t have to mean high cost,” he says.

Prof Khan also believes there will be business opportunities for firms installing and maintaining the systems, and selling on the useful minerals and by-products.

Mr Harvey agrees.

“The business opportunities are huge for entrepreneurs and communities to sell on the fertiliser and fuel by-products of these sustainable sanitation systems. This is where our focus should be, rather than on the design of the toilet itself.”

Better sanitation will also confer significant commercial benefits to businesses employing healthier and more productive workforces.

“By 2015, the world will have reached only 67% coverage, well short of the 75% needed to achieve the MDG target.”

Although the number of people who do not use any facility and resort to “open defecation” has decreased by 271 million since 1990, 1.1 billion people, or 15% of the global population, still have no sanitation facilities at all.

Shockingly, about 650 million people in India still practise open defecation – 60% of the world’s total – despite the country’s status as a rapidly growing emerging economy.

Parents are understandably reluctant to send their children – particularly girls – to schools that have no sanitation facilities.

This means young people are chronically under-educated and then join a low-skilled workforce of less commercial value to businesses, in a competitive global economy where higher skills are required.

This is why India’s highest court this month ordered local authorities to build up to 100,000 “bio-degrading” toilets for pupils in all government schools within six months, using powers granted under the country’s 2010 Right to Education Act.

Bill Gates writes in his blog: “In addition to building new toilets that are affordable and sustainable, we have to develop solutions to empty these new latrines and treat the human waste.”

“We also have to work closely with governments, businesses, and communities to stimulate demand for better sanitation, encourage investment, and create supportive public policies that will allow these innovative solutions to succeed.”

“Inventing new toilets is one of the most important things we can do to reduce child deaths and disease and improve people’s lives.”

Sanitation and economic development are inextricably linked. Better loos will mean big business.

Dear Sir
we r planning to provide essential basic facilities such as drinking water, toilets & sanitation for our village Tajpur (H), Dashyal, Dhanyal,Kotiyal & Ratnapur in Vijayapur. District .Karnataka State were there is no proper sanitation or basic essential for human kind

Dear all, great, to read these posts about your work in the sector, thank you for sharing! We would like to include this thread in the upcoming SuSanA news mail and make a collage from all the profile pics. If you have any objections against the use of your profile picture in the newsmail kindly let us know in the course of this week, no problem. Best wishes […]

Hi Elisabeth, Regarding the question of sludge management in ponds, in my last revision I had clarified the issue of removing frequency for the three different types of ponds (anaerobic, facultative, maturation). Now I added a paragraph (last one in the section Operation and Maintenance) describing the different desludging techniques. I edited directly in Wi […]

Hi Imad, thanks for your post and presenting your solution. I don´t really understand how your toilet system works. On your website you state this: "The solid waste will be treated by our special formulated bacterial culture, which eventually will turn into ashes, killing all the pathogens." 1) What is that bacterial culture? Why do you need more b […]

Hi David, thanks for your response and now I am curios and want to know how you do this. I assume your organization is Sanitation First, correct? How does the toilet looks like in the inside? Does it has 3 compartments including urine and wash water separation? Could you present a picture? Did you come across severe misuse? Meaning that, the feces were to we […]

Search for:

Maintained by

IRC and the USAID Water Team.

Follow Blog via Email

Enter your email address to follow this blog and receive notifications of new posts by email.