Jolé and Gnoffo, whose relationship has been documented on the Lifetime show since season 1, welcomed a baby girl named Penelope Charlevoix Gnoffo on Monday, March 16. Penelope weighed in at 6 lbs. and 2 oz.

"I definitely was shocked when I found out I was pregnant," the reality star told Entertainment Tonight in January. “[The baby] is only 25 percent average height percentage, and then 75 percent some form, either Joe's or mine or a mixture of the both of us, when it comes to both of our dwarfisms," Jolé explained. "While it lives a perfectly normal life in the womb, it's the lungs — they don't develop fully — so they would die at birth or within a few hours of birth,” she added, explaining her fears prior to Penelope’s birth. “To me that would be like my all-time biggest fear. It has been suggested maybe there are possibilities for extreme health risks with Joe and I and that's something to think about, but currently the child is living healthy in the womb. Why think negative when I'm this far along?"