Cheap but not tacky accommodation in Balearics/ Mallorca?

Planning to go to Mallorca or Minorca next month but I am struggling to find accommodation I like the look of. We went pre kids and stayed in a lovely rural finca which was adults only in the middle of nowhere for less than £500.

Must haves are a pool suitable for young children, and no requirement for a car. Ideally it would also be near a beach, do good food all inclusive / half board or have self catering facilities, and have some activities for preschool age kids.

We stayed here many years ago. Looks like it's been refurbished since we stayed and has decent reviews.Blancala apartmentsCala Blanca was a small resort (not sure if it still is) with nice beaches and a small water park nearby, It was also easy to catch the local bus for day trips.

We stayed at Club Martha -SC apartment but it does HB and AI - I'd recommend AC as eating out is cheap in local fantastic restaurants! It's in Cala Egis bear Cala d'or and you can walk through the marina to Cala d'or or get the tourist train. Local resort was great and beach was lovely even if it was a cove. U fortunate name though cala d'en pou so 8 year old ds had to call it pooh beach.,. It was very clean! Then we went to Puerto pollensa and it was about 3 times the price everywhere to eat out and not as nice. Felt really let down after all the positive comments on here. Found it pretentious rather than welcoming like Cala egos! We wouldn't go back to PP I'm afraid. The Pune walk was nothing g special and neither was the beach!

I also don't like Puerto Pollensa and thought the beach was a bit crap, even though we did find a bar on the Pine Walk with a gin menu, so perhaps that's the appeal to a lot of Mumsnetter?

I think next time we go to Mallorca we're going to stay in or near Cala D'Or or Cala Egos and have heard good things about Club Marthas from others on here and elsewhere so that's on the list of where to stay.

Have a look at the Cala D'or Playa apartments in Cala D'or Mallorca. They're with Thomson I think.

We took our kids there 4 times when they were younger. You can go SC or half board. We did SC, there's a supermarket just a two minute walk up the street with a bakery for fresh bread. We'd do breakfast and lunch in the apartment and eat out at night.

There's 2 beaches close by, very safe, with shallow water. The hotel has a good sized pool and a splash park. It's great for kids.

I just adore Puerto Pollensa, pine walk is one of the most beautiful places I've ever been and the calm sea where you can walk for miles is perfect for little ones. The surrounding area is also wonderful. We have travelled around the whole of the island and it's the one place that when we are away we think that it can't be that great and we go back and remind ourselves that actually, yes it is! Other nice areas are Illetas, andratx, soller, port portals but not cheap