“American Idol”: Jasmine, Jorge sent packing

“American Idol” announced a new judges veto rule Wednesday night, but it didn’t come into play for Jasmine Murray and Jorge Nunez, who both got the boot.

The new rule — called the “Judges’ Save” — gives Simon Cowell and his pals the power to save a singer voted off by the fans. In other words, had it been around back in Season 3 it could have been used to save Jennifer Hudson.

I don’t know about you, but I like it. I even wrote a column a couple of years ago suggesting the show implement something along these lines as a way to stave off bone-headed eliminations. And I like how it cannot be used frivolously. As explained by Ryan Seacrest, it’s a one-time-only option that must be used before the field is cut down to the final five or not at all. And the judges have to be in unanimous agreement.

The judges didn’t think it was worth using on Murray or Nunez, both of whom departed on a night when Kanye West and Kelly Clarkson were around to show everyone what real stars look like. Spared from elimination was the popular Anoop Desai, who was on shaky ground after a poor performance Tuesday.

So what do you think of the voting results? Were the right singers sent home? Are you glad Anoop was spared? And what do you think of the new rule? Do you like it — or do you think the judges already have had too much say this season?

Chuck Barney

Post navigation

I was shocked that Jasminne was the first to go. As they said, she’s commercial but she’s what? 17? She could come back in a year or two…..or be the first #13 finish to be a star!

Nancy West

The first thing about last night’s show that struck me funny, was the IDOLS perched on the stairway to ‘heaven’, with Seacrest below, bright light shining upon him like God himself… shouting WELCOME TO AMERICAAAAN IDOLLLL…
I reserve judgement on the new one time rule, but it seems to totally contradict the voters’ wishes, in my opinion… why vote when it doesn’t even count… even if it is ONLY a one time thing??
I think the correct singers went home last night. I like Alexis the best. COOL VIBE and personality. CURRENT LOOK and seems to be humble about it.
GEEZ, that house they’re living in. WOW! That ALONE would make me wanna stay in it!

Nancy West

I meant to say Allison was my favorite.. in case anyone’s taking notes.

Where is everone???? hellloooo!!!! :>)

Mac McDonald

What? Only two replies? I guess Jasmine and Jorge going is just too
underwhelming to comment. I wouldn’t have minded if either Michael or
Anoop were gone either. Tallk about underwhelming! And Scott’d got to pick
up his game if he wants to continue. His performance was nice and safe,
but nice and safe doesn’t win “Idol.” The top 3 are obviously Lil, Danny and
Adam, with Alexis, Allison and Matt (or Kris, hard to tell them apart
sometimes) as the also-rans.

Karen N

I think everyone fails to see that a lot of people vote for popularity, underdog, etc. Not everyone votes for the best or the most likely to be The American Idol. I like Jasmine but she’s not as good as Lil; however, I can’t stand Megan and would have liked Jasmine to have been voted in instead of her.

However, I am not sure Anoop can pull it off. We’ll see. I do think it will come down to Adam, Danny, Lil, Alexis and Allison and maybe Matt.

I liked the twist and I know they are saving it for one of the “better” singers just in case. I also appreciated that Paula’s meds were working again and that she acted normal.

Lastly, what’s with the Kelly Clarkson weight gain?

Truly enjoying Season 8.

Mac McDonald

You’re right, Karen, about popularity often trumping talent in Idol (hello,
Jennifer Hudson!) which is precisely why the whole, judges’ veto was instituted this season. I like that it has to be unanimous and can only be used once.

Paul is on meds? Really?

I was more alarmed by Kelly’s hair. What, she can’t afford a stylist?

Diane

I think this new Judges Save rule is great. I can’t remember when it was that Constantine got surprisingly eliminated, but perhaps this rule could have saved him that year — I thought he could have won it all.

I thought Jasmine and Jorge were the weakest two in the Final 13, so was glad to see them go home. Sure, Jasmine can sing but she is BORING. This competition is about the whole package: charisma plus singing talent, and she only had the latter. Adam and Danny on the other hand , … wow. I fully expect to see those two in the Final.

I think Anoop is charming as heck, but his vocals are not as strong as they should be — for that reason, I see him lasting another couple of weeks only (sadly, coz I really like him). I also like Megan, but she’s probably too quirky for Ye Olde Members of the Masses.

Carrie

I love this season so far. Megan, like her needs to step up her game. Danny, love love him! Adam’s great, too! I’m soooooo glad that Jasmine got out. She
wore the most ugliest outfit and is plain boring. Michael is too boring for me.
The judges may like him, but I think he needs to get out of there! Can’t wait for next for Tuesday! It’s going to be fun!!!

Hoops100

Completely shocked that Anoop got to spend another week in the mansion. I was pulling for him early on, but after that excruciating performance, I was ready to give him the boot, myself. But the Idol Gods intervened once more. No argument from me that Jorge left. It was like having a scoop of bland vanilla ice cream when there are 12 other flavors to savor. I wasn’t totally convinced that Jasmine deserved to go. But she didn’t distinguish herself from the rest, and that earned her a ticket to nowheresville. And how ironic were their song choices “Never Can Say GoodBye” & “I’ll Be There.”

The new rule is growing on me. The idea is the Ying to the Yang of the “voting by America” theme. It also adds another dimension to the suspense building up to elimination night. After all, isn’t American Idol all about opportunity & second chances?

Katie

Jasmine was gorgeous. And Jorge– ehh, not much i saw in him. sorry, its just what i thought.. :\ Jasmine was pretty good though. Sad to see her go. I would of liked to see more of her.

Hey we was just viewing your post on my Samsung Phone and I was wondering how well it will work on the new ipad coming out . Fleeting thought. Anyway thanks!

http://is.gd/60Y3wX OLLIE

I ran into this web page on accident, astonishingly, this is really a superb web site. You have completed a superb occupation of placing it together, the info here is truly insightful. Now i am about to bookmark this internet web page so that I can revisit within the long term.

http://goo.gl/Y20Pu Vapor Pro White Limited Edition

I also favor to optimize my system by myself. This approach seems additional dependable for me. Many thanks for the write-up.

http://libcom.org/user/748662 senna laxative

Great post, I conceive people should learn a lot from this blog its very user pleasant. So much good info on here :D.

http://www.frumusetealafeminin.blogspot.com sexshop

I in addition to my guys have already been examining the excellent secrets from the blog and then the sudden came up with a terrible suspicion I never thanked the web site owner for those strategies. Those guys were definitely certainly happy to read sexshop Iasi them and already have unquestionably been taking advantage of those things. Appreciate your really being well considerate as well as for making a choice on variety of very good guides millions of individuals are really desperate to understand about. My personal honest regret for not expressing gratitude to you sooner.