Now that we’re ramping up our releases of Fairy Tail on Blu-ray and DVD, we’re nearing one of the biggest Fairy Tail arcs of all: the Tenrou Island arc. The most powerful wizards in the Fairy Tail guild travel to a remote island rich in magic—and history. There, they compete against one another to see who among them deserves to be given the title of “S-Class.”

We won’t spoil how the story ends—you’ll need to buy Fairy Tail Parts Nine and Ten for that –but we wanted to see who YOU think would win in head-to-head fights between Fairy Tail guild wizards. And it just happens to be March, so welcome to the Fairy Tail S-Class Showdown!

Each weekday, fans will vote for who they think would win in a fight between two Fairy Tail guild members. The next day, we’ll let you know who won!

Of course, no tournament would be complete without a prize, so take a look below for details.

How to Play:

- Vote for who you think will win in the match up below

- Come back each day to see winners and vote in the next round of matches

Fairy Tail S-Class Showdown – FINAL!

Natsu vs. Gildarts: NATSU WINS!
In a blazing turn of events, Natsu proves that when he takes a battle seriously and sets his mind to it, there’s little that can stop him. In a fiery attack that will leave a scorch mark on the Fiore Kingdom for decades to come, Natsu manages to take out Gildarts, proving he is the one wizard in Fairy Tail you definitely don’t want to mess with.

Prizes:

One Grand Prize will be awarded to the entrant that guesses ALL of the matches correctly when the bracket is first released (entry period for this stage is now closed.) If there is more than one winning entry, then the winner will be determined by random draw. Grand Prize includes:

Two random entrants will win a copy of Fairy Tail the Movie: Phoenix Priestess and a Fairy Tail Guild temporary tattoo. Winners will be drawn randomly from all completed entries. Be sure to come back each day to vote in the new rounds so you have a better chance at winning, and don’t forget to get caught up on Fairy Tail on Blu-ray and DVD!

214 Responses

Tough Call on some of these. Some underdogs could surprisingly turn up a win and some might lose when they should win. But that’s Fairy Tail for ya. lol Already have the movie so I really just want the poster. I know w buddy who’d want the movie though.

Mystogan would beat Freed. Mira would beat Levy. Erza vs Pantherlily would be a good fight and could end either way but taking into account how long he can stay in his real form would really call it. He’d have to get the upper hand and win quite quickly to beat her. Gildarts vs Wendy just doesn’t seem fair… Natsu would be Cana unless she pulled out Fairy Glitter and then he might be beat, also a good fight there. Gray vs Juvia, I think Juvia is a stronger wizard but her love for him would

probably cause her to throw the fight. Laxus vs Gajeel would be really close. When Gajeel fought him during Fantasia he got beat up pretty bad even with Natsu and they beat him. Both have gotten stronger since then so it’d be a tough call. Elfman vs Lucy would be quite fun. They both have a few different tricks up their sleeves that you don’t see them use very often in battles like Natsu’s Fire Dragin Wing Attack or Gray’s Ice Make Shield. Elfman has brute strength on his side but Lucy has wits

which can usually give you an advantage over someone without that ability. They both come through when needed but if it came down to it I believe Lucy would come out victorious if just barely and in quite bad condition.

Knew it would come down to Fairy Tails Strongest Male vs Fairy Tails Strongest Female and it honestly is a tough call. If Erza releases her second origin like I stated previously, she would defiantly win. But assuming that she didn’t store enough power for it yet Gildarts would win but still a very close battle.

Natsu and Gray always fight, and though they both are hard headed Natsu ends up like a z fighter, when he is on the brink of losing(equal level of dying in DBZ) he gets stronger.

I put mine through when they first posted this. I was wondering if we had to re-post or not. If we try to post this through that’s a double submission. And we’re not suppose to do that or we are removed for a chance of winning I though. Just hoping they take the 1st one.

Why does everyone seem to think that Natsu would beat Laxus.???Did we not see when Laxus knocked him out with one punch.? I mean I know he’s gotten stronger since then but I doubt he could still beat Laxus… Natsu has the heart, but Laxus has gained that same heart too & I just don’t think it would be fair if they made he win given all the evidence that he wouldn’t in the past. & Lucy vs Elfman..? I love Lucy & her spirits but come on..We know Elfman could def take her.It would be close though.

Mirajane Vs Levy is a hard one because Mira in her demon form is super reckless but seriously powerful. Levy could outsmart her but then would fall if she ever got hit by Mira in take over. Gajeel vs Laxus would be an epic fight each one going tit for tat. Laxus would ultimately win because Gajeel would start losing power plus Gajeel’s metal abilities would act as a conduit to Laxus’ Electrical Dragon Slayer magic. Ultimately, it would be whoever doesn’t run out of magic power. That would Laxus

I agree. I think Levy actually does stand a chance against Mira. During the series we do know that Levy gets stronger thanks to Ultear, but we havent seen her fight since then. Also Levy definatly can outsmart Mira because when Mira takes form it’s like she loses her true self. So I think Levy may have a chance. She may not be the strongest but dont judge her as weak.

yes, I know it looks impossible but Levy is known for her knowledge. I think she can use that to her advantage. It is true that Mira is one of the strongest mages, and that Levy doesn’t like to fight. I think instead of a full on fight Levy would use her power to win by not engaging into physical territory. Who knows? I think it’s a close call. We don’t know much of Levy’s true power so we can’t be quick to judge. One thing I do know for sure is that Fairy Tail is awesome!

Natsu would win against Canna
Natsu vs Gray is tough but Natsu HAS to win simply because he is one of the Dragon Slayers (plus, Gray’s Ice Make Magic is stationary for the most part…)
Gray should win against Juvia (and has before) simply because she is just too distracted in love
Laxus is super strong, but he is a second generation Dragon Slayer, and only has the magic due to lacrima so Gajeel should win, or he would disgrace the 1st generation of Dragon Race (Natsu won against Laxus…

Lucy would definitely win against Elfman, but that’s as far as she’ll get without Happy/Natsu.
Seeing Gajeel beat up Lucy yet again, Natsu will be super mad and avange Lucy, winning agains Gajeel.
Mystogan would definitely win against Freed, MiraJane would definitely win against Levy, and Erza would definitely win against Lilly. Wendy would totally lose against Gildarts hands-down.
Mystogan would lose against Mira, and Gildarts would lose against Erza.
The battle with Erza and Mira would be

awesome, but Erza could win by a little against Mira and have an epic battle with Natsu, who would finally have the opportunity to battle Erza seriously.

Natsu would win with the encouragement of Happy and Lucy–Those two make Natsu strong because of how much Natsu loves them, and Love is the one true magic. Anyways, I’m 99% sure that’s how Hiro Mashima would write it.

Elfman will probably do something clumsy an get distracted [aargh.... that wasn't manly at all!] and lucy will probably take advantage of the opening more then likely for one lucky KO blow from leo or something.

Ok if you used the link that sent you to the site where you could just fill in the entire chart does it count? I’m wondering because so far I’ve been right Or do we have to come in daily to do all the matches.

I think it’s a little un-fair to everyone participating to have the voting up for Lucy vs Elfman and Mystogan vs Freed for 3 days already when all the others only had one. It allows more people to vote which makes the chances of winning the 2nd Prize less likely.I hope people entering a bunch of fake emails and addresses to vote for who they want to win so they’ll get a prefect bracket >.<

Elfman v Lucy = Elfman any day. So why did he lose!?! Unless he lost purposely. Because Elfman beat that dude with the drunken fist attack in the grand magic games who was dominating. Elfman a real man wouldn’t hold back.

The thing is, that was after 3 months of training. This is before that. Elfman hasn’t bulked out as of Tenrou and is not that strong yet. Lucy is also smarter than Elfman and Elfman, being a ‘real man’ is one of the few men in the series who would probably be unable to go all-out against a girl. Most of the other guys don’t hold back against women though.

Guildarts beats Wendy hands down. But not really the best match up. It’s kinda overkill in my opinion. Erza beats Pantherlily even though it’s a good fight. Mira beats Levy. Levy can be powerful but she’s up against Mira. Nuff said. Close call but Mystogan beats Freed. Freed is strong but Mystogan is just a lot stronger. Natsu beats Cana with relative ease. Some parts would make it seem like Cana is coming back but Natsu is just to stubborn and powerful to lose. Gray beats Juvia because she will

most likely let her emotions get in the way. It’s a really really close call but Laxus will pull out the win against Gajeel. He’s just more powerful than Gajeel. And contrary to popular belief, Lucy will pull out the win against Elfman because Elfman is almost 100% offense. Lucy has offense and defense with her spirits. She also has great tactics so she will pull out the upper hand against Elfman.

Round 2 is so tough to see. This may be wrong but I think Erza is going to end up pulling out a very very close win against Guildarts. That is only because she is a) extremely powerful as is guildarts and b) she is simply to stubborn to lose. Next Mira vs Mystogan. I think Mira will pull out the win. She has more emotional stability than mystogan. She is able to plan everything precisely on the spot while mystogan (or at least jellal as mystogan) may end up acting rashly to pull out the win. And

plus both are extremely agile but Mira is sooooo freaking fast that I think she’ll be able to pull off the win against Mystogan. Next is fire vs ice. Ultimately I think Natsu will win. Both are extremely powerful and I believe they are equals. Gray has a bit more control but Natsu’s recklessness comes in handy a lot for him. It’ll be a close call but Natsu (as I said for Erza) is simply to stubborn to lose. Especially to Gray. Laxus vs Lucy. Laxus will win even though lucy will put up a good

tactical battle. she will hold him on the edge for a fair amount of time but his strength and smarts will get him the win. Unlike Elfman, Laxus has a great strategic side as well so he should be able to beat lucy with moderate amount of struggle. Don’t know how accurate these predictions are so I’ll wait till the winners of these are announced to do my next guess and reasoning.