These two composers share one thing only: the year
of their death. However it is perhaps only CD reviewers who feel duty
bound to discover themes and logic in CD couplings. To the music …

Norrington and his Stuttgart orchestra give us a slow
paced Planets. They do so with conviction, tight delineation
and a convincing narrative sense. Try the balefully emphatic Mars
and compare this version with the DG disc from fellow early music refugee
John Eliot Gardiner. At this pace the lessons learnt by Vaughan Williams
writing his Sixth Symphony fifteen years after Holst's death or plain
to hear. If you are not irritated by the tempi (and you should not be)
you will revel in this freshly envisioned Planets. Speaking of
influences, Neptune pre-echoes Bax's epilogic sunset dreams (Sixth
Symphony) and RVW's Sinfonia Antartica. Also I wondered whether
Holst had heard Sibelius's En Saga before writing the Planets.
This is like hearing this concert-worn work afresh and I recommend it
firmly. A concert-worn work casts of its shabby carpet slippers!

This has reshaped my attitude to Norrington. I hope
to hear in other British 20th century repertoire before too long. And
I do hope that he can be encouraged to avoid the most obvious choices.
How about Norrington tackling Nystroem’s Sinfonia del Mare, Holmboe’s
Sixth Symphony, Rosenberg’s Fourth Symphony? I live in, possibly vain,
hope.

The weakness of the disc is its not desperately generous
timing and the soothing unprepossessing and sickly charm of the Elgar
Serenade. Others may be more drawn to the work. My problem with
the Serenade is with the work itself not with Norrington's way with
it. It is just a pity that Norrington had not struck out into Egdon
Heath or surprised us with Constant Lambert's Music for Orchestra
- of which, on this showing, the conductor and the SWR orchestra
would have made a grand event.

Decent multilingual booklet. Recording quality excellent.
As far as I could make out there was no audience noise. This is part
of Hänssler Classics ‘Faszination Musik’ series.

Reviews
from previous monthsJoin the mailing list and receive a hyperlinked weekly update on the
discs reviewed. detailsWe welcome feedback on our reviews. Please use the Bulletin
Board
Please paste in the first line of your comments the URL of the review to
which you refer.