Share this post

Link to post

Share on other sites

Every version of IRS uses the exact same vocal tracks as the one released on CD.

The same is true of ALL of the demos. The actual vocals are identical on every single version, even Oh My God. Exceptions being the few lines changed at the end of The Blues and of course the This I Love remix which appears to actually have been re-recorded.

There's no difference in the rest of the versions as far as the vocals go.

Either I have a different 99’ version than you, or the vocals have been manipulated. Axl sounds like Axl of 91-94 on the “99’” i got

Share this post

Link to post

Share on other sites

Interesting that TWAT is in there again, we have about five versions now of this. When, oh when are we gonna gear the short punchy version of Chinese Democracy, as in the song. That, scrapped and Sorry are the only ones we only have the album realeasd version of? Oh and TIL too

I also wanna hear a studio version of CD the way it sounded at RIR2001. That’d be epic!

these are the TWAT’s we have: 1999, 2001, MSL Short, MSL Long, Antiquiet, album version, and 2009 (alternate intro/outro).

Share this post

Link to post

Share on other sites

The real reason to re record appetite is to cut out royalties to other band members of the original recordings by selling off the new rerecordings for soundtracks etc (and undercut by offering these versions to the originals)

They probably sounded much shitter than the originals and therefore deemed a waste of time.

Share this post

Link to post

Share on other sites

The real reason to re record appetite is to cut out royalties to other band members of the original recordings by selling off the new rerecordings for soundtracks etc (and undercut by offering these versions to the originals)

They probably sounded much shitter than the originals and therefore deemed a waste of time.

Share this post

Link to post

Share on other sites

I don't think that TWAT clip is the same as the version that's been out for years. Unless the quality is so much higher that you can hear guitar noodling that hasn't been heard on any other version of the track (and I assume is probably Axl based on the guitar playing on the Madagascar that was reportedly his playing)

Share this post

Link to post

Share on other sites

Please don't speculate about who leaked what. If we (or anyone else) find out who is behind the leaks, the less likely it is we'll get anything else for reasons that should be obvious.

I don't so much care about the speculationg one way or the other.

I've always been the type that doesn't care who gets credit for what, as long as I get the hear tunes. Having said that, when they dust settles on this whole deal I'm certain that we'll find out who did what. These hoarders love taking credit for this stuff, so I'm sure they'll fill us in on all the details eventually

1

1

Share this post

Link to post

Share on other sites

Interesting that TWAT is in there again, we have about five versions now of this. When, oh when are we gonna gear the short punchy version of Chinese Democracy, as in the song. That, scrapped and Sorry are the only ones we only have the album realeasd version of? Oh and TIL too

That's wrong! We do have a leaked version of CD. It leaked around the same time as the others. The solo was a bit different I think. Haven't listened to it in ages. Prefer the album version, but I'd love to hear a version of the song that's more like the early live version.