as i said in the other thread, a starter shoulod never lose his job due to injury. you may need to work him back from the bench to his starter's role if he's been out for a while, but he should be given every opportunity to try to get back to where he was. if he can't hack it, demote him, but he doesn't deserve to be demoted just because he got injured.

being the kind of guy jose is, though, he may volunteer to come off the bench.