Thursday, May 4, 2017

Jammu and Kashmir - A Reality Check

Every day I keep seeing questions on Jammu and Kashmir. Who does it belong to? How did we get here? What are the solutions? Who is to blame?

Let me answer the four most pertinent questions:

Will India be able to improve relations with Pakistan?

What is wrong with Kashmir, the Kashmir people, Hurriyat, and the governments of India and Pakistan?

Which nation does Aksai Chin belong to : China or India?

Why doesn’t India give Kashmir to the Kashmiris?

----------------------------------------Part 1) Will India be able to improve relations with Pakistan?

Pakistan
is a country built on a faulty foundation. The 2 nation theory wherein
Muslims can't live with Hindus (mostly) was their firm belief. But after
losing Bangladesh due to their own crime, that theory is now flushed.
Also, the gradual prosperity of Indian Muslims, who are living with
Hindus well for most part, has shocked the 4th generation of Pakistan
since independence. Economically, Pakistan is nothing in front of India. Pakistan's economy is much less than just one state of India, that is
Maharashtra.

The only
thing that is keeping Punjabis, Sindhis, Pathans, Baluchs and others is
the artificially created hate against India (victim hood). India will be
able to improve relationship with Pakistan only to the extent of keeping
away mad Generals of Pakistan from actually triggering the danger buttons on
missiles. Beyond that, it is more of a stick, carrot, stick, carrot...
relationship. Because you can't have perfect relationship with someone
whose only dream is to destroy you.

---------------------------------------- Part 2) What is wrong with Kashmir, the Kashmir people, Hurriyat, and the governments of India and Pakistan?

Basically who is blaming whom..

There is
nothing wrong with Kashmir. What we have is a dispute cultivated by
Britain and USA, during 1940s and early 1950s. Now it is an issue cultivated by China for its economic benefits and access to Arabian sea and Indian ocean via Pakistan. Even after 7 decades,
there is no end in sight.

Kashmir is generally a term used for the whole of Jammu and Kashmir
state. The state as it was in 1947, is a big one. Today, 60% of the
state is within India, even after the Maharajah who ruled in 1947 (Hari
Singh) formally signed an accession document to merge his state into
India, like 100s of other Rajas. Pakistan has control of 30% which it
invaded in the form of "tribal" invasion. China has control of about
10%. China might have a bit more than 10% as, Pakistan in 1960s "gifted"
a lush green Shaksgam valley in the north, to China.

The Maharajah of Jammu and Kashmir princely state signed with India in 1947 an instrument of accession. That's it. J&K belongs to India eternally or at least close to eternity :)

This map (and another map in Part 3)
shows approximately the areas held by India, Pakistan and China. PoK =
Pakistan Occupied Kashmir and CoK = China Occupied Kashmir. These are
standard terms used in Indian parliament. Some also use PoJK and CoJK.

Now coming to "Kashmir".. there are five distinct parts of Jammu and Kashmir state.

1) Kashmir valley - Small valley around Srinagar.2) Jammu - Southernmost part of J&K. Most populated place.3) Ladakh - Eastern Himalayan hills. Has the world's highest motorable road etc. Very sparely populated. 4)
Pakistan Occupied Kashmir (PoK): This has two distinct parts. One is
the southern strip along India's Kashmir valley, which Pakistan calls as
"Azad Kashmir". Then the bigger northern part which is Gilgit and
Baltistan. Now-a-days, these two areas - Gilgit and Baltistan, are
together termed as Northern Areas. 5) Aksai Chin (CoK) - North
Eastern J&K under China's control since 1962 war where Chinese
walked into this area. Aksai Chin is almost a desert where no one lives.
China also controls the lush green Shaksgam Valley (CoK 1 in the map),
"gifted" by Pakistan in 1960s, in return for things which you can
imagine.

Only two of these five places actually have protests
and people movements today. That is Kashmir valley within India, and PoK
or Azad Kashmir in Pakistan. The former is larger and louder. The
latter is smaller, but simmering. Kashmir Valley has separatist groups
under a Hurriyat banner, which represents overall less than 5% of the overall Jammu
and Kashmir. But media projects them as the true representatives of
"Kashmiris". Some of them want to become independent and some opt for
Pakistan. On the Pakistan side, low key movements are there to join
India. They are not given much publicity in media.

So if you
look at the overall picture, majority of Jammu and Kashmir is peaceful
or without any movements today. It's only the 10 to 20% of the overall
state, centered around the valley, that has disruptions. There are zero
problems in the large populated part of Jammu and Kashmir state, the
Jammu region. Jammu is predominantly Hindu and Ladakh is predominantly
Buddhist. That might explain why those regions have no issues with
India.

India blames Pakistan sponsored terrorism and
support to separatism for all the problems. And they keep coming inside
India regularly. Almost every month you will see a gun battle, with
cross border infiltration bids being stopped. You also see many
demonstrations in Kashmir valley, with Hurriyat groups mobilizing 1000s
of Kashmiri Muslim youth to come against India. India's claim is, just
like 500+ princely states that signed the accession document, J&K
also signed. So the whole state legally belongs to India. That is the
final settlement.

Pakistan blames India for all the
trouble. Pakistan talks of occupation by India. Pakistan goes back to
1940s and 50s when a three step process was discussed. It shows that
India had agreed to do a plebiscite for the whole state then considering
a war situation. But India says that one of the pre condition put by UN
was that Pakistan should withdraw from all the areas of Jammu and
Kashmir that it had army on. Pakistan refused to withdraw its troops. So
India conducted democratic elections in its part of J&K and the
matter is closed since then. China does not openly blame much, but quietly sides with Pakistan. After all China got parts of Jammu and Kashmir with almost no effort, and it wants Pakistan for its CPEC (economic corridor) to open a gateway to Arabian Sea/Indian ocean. Without PoK, China has no direct border with Pakistan, so it is vital from China's expansionist agenda to support Pakistan at any cost, even when Pakistan sponsors terrorism on large scale against India and other countries. China also keeps offering 'mediation' which India rejects every time within minutes.

Hope this gives a glimpse of the
core issue. Frankly, the issue is not as bad as you see in the media.
More than 12 million people live on the Indian side of J&K today.
More than 10 million of those live peacefully. "Kashmir Problem" is
essentially a problem in a small part within Kashmir valley, of a huge
Jammu and Kashmir state.

----------------------------------------Part 3: Which nation does Aksai Chin belong to : China or India?

Aksai Chin belongs to India.

Two reasons:

It
was a part of Jammu and Kashmir princely state. In fact, the Maharajah
of Jammu and Kashmir had even constructed a fort at Shahidulla
(modern-day Xaidulla, a part of Xinjiang in China today), and had troops
stationed there for some years to protect caravans. So it was more than
Aksai Chin that was under Jammu and Kashmir ruler’s control.

It
was a part of 1865 Johnson line during British survey of India. William
Johnson, a civil servant with the Survey of India had drawn the
"Johnson Line" in 1865, which had put Aksai Chin into Jammu and Kashmir.
After 1947 October, Jammu and Kashmir joined India through a legally
signed accession document by the Maharajah. This was similar to 100s of
other Maharajahs who signed to accede to India during that year, which
British left India, creating India and Pakistan as two separate nations.

If you
look closely, Aksai Chin has borders with both Xinjiang and Tibet. Both
were not with China 70 years ago. Chinese call the 1949 occupation of
Xinjiang (a Turkish Muslim dominated province) as the “Peaceful
liberation of Xinjiang”. Before that in 1878, Chinese had “reconquered
Xinjiang” once. Not sure why they needed a second “liberation” in 1949.
They also term the 1951 occupation of Tibet by China as “Incorporation
of Tibet into the People's Republic of China”. In short, both are huge
central Asian regions and both were not a part of what we know as China
today, before 1949.

Then how did India lose Aksai Chin to China?

Because
post 1947 independence, India was going through a big turmoil. Civil
war, massive poverty and other issues had kept the first Prime Minister
Jawaharlal Nehru busy with highly populated places, taking focus off
Aksai Chin which had almost no population. It was a barren land in the
high altitude of Himalayas, at the tip of Northern India. Moreover,
Tibet was a buffer state between India and China, and a friendly one. So
India had nothing to worry on Aksai Chin area. But the newly resurgent
China had just “incorporated” massive provinces of Xinjiang and Tibet,
and was building China National Highway 219. That highway runs through
Aksai Chin connecting Lazi and Xinjiang in the Tibet Autonomous Region.
Despite this region being nearly uninhabitable and having no resources,
it remains strategically important for China as it connects Tibet and
Xinjiang. The highway construction started in 1951 and the road was
completed in 1957. This was one of India’s biggest blunders, as they did
not “notice” this highway built through Aksai Chin, fully claimed by
it! By the time they lodged complaints with China, it was too late.

So
China literally got 10s of 1000s of sq. KM of Aksai Chin area, while
India was sleeping or busy with internal issues. Now they are using it
as a bargain to get more strategic lands east of Himalayas.

So Aksai Chin belonged to Jammu and Kashmir.

It became a part of India after Jammu and Kashmir acceded to India via a legal signature in 1947.

But
it mostly is under Chinese control since 1950s as India was “too busy”
to notice a massive highway being built by China through Aksai Chin.

It is officially termed as CoJK in India - China occupied Jammu and Kashmir

There
is also another part of Jammu and Kashmir state of India, called
Shaksgam valley. That is not barren like Aksai Chin. It is a beautiful
lush green Himalayan mountain region, “gifted” by Pakistan in 1963 to
China for other “favours” extended by China. It is CoJK - 2 (China
Occupied Jammu and Kashmir part 2) in Jammu and Kashmir.

Shaksgam
Valley must be the only land on this planet, which belongs to one
country (India) legally, but “gifted” by a second country (Pakistan) to a
third country (China) for other favours received!

So
Aksai Chin and Shaksgam Valley issues would remain a thorn between
India and China relations for decades to come.. if not longer.

Lastly,
not only Aksai Chin, but China technically has no business with
Himalayas. Even today, 94% of Chinese live east of the Heihe-Tengchong
line or Hu Huanyong line. Yes 94%!!

Sorry: J&K map is not accurate in this population density map found on the net.

Look on
the Indian side. There are 100s of millions of Indians living within
100–200 KM from Himalayas all across its west to East length. So all
these claims of Tibet, Aksai Chin, Shaksgam valley, Arunachal Pradesh,
Xinjiang are fairly strategic and new from Chinese point of view,
without any basis from historic or population existence logic. The Hun
Chinese have historically been limited to the east of Hu Huanyong line.
And it holds true even today.

Just like
modern India was formed by 500+ such accession documents signed by
erstwhile Rajas, Nawabs, and other leaders, Jammu and Kashmir joined
India in 1947.Once a part of Indian union each state has freedom
within its territories, as defined by the constitution of India.
Compared to rest of Indian states, J&K has a lot more freedom and
autonomy. More than 200 constitutional amendments to Indian constitution
are not even applicable in J&K as of today.

So
no matter how many decades this talk goes on, No Pakistani or No
Chinese can ever claim an inch of Jammu and Kashmir state, as the entire
state is a legal part of India due to the accession document.

China is illegally occupying Shaksgam valley (COK 1) and Aksai Chin (COK 2). See map at the top of this blog post for details.

So
Kashmir is already with Kashmiris. There are Kashmiri Chief Ministers
governing the state for decades. Just like a Kannadiga governs
Karnataka, a Odia governs Odisha, a Kashmiri is governing now.

Whatever
violence and trouble we have there is sponsored by Pakistan which is
illegally occupying a big portion of J&K. The moment China and
Pakistan vacate their illegal occupations, and return the entire J&K
to the rightful owner India, all problems would be solved immediately.

PS: All images used in this blog post are found using public search on internet. All credits to original rights holders.

Thanks for sharing your brilliant information about the green valley in Kashmir and snow fall capped mountain, peak, and river. And also BlogSpot designing also amazing I’m feeling so happy and along with if anybody make plan visits to Kashmir I hope they will feel better and if you want get more information click here Rajasthan tour packages India Tour packages

Nice and brilliant blogs on bloggers about the #Rajasthantourpackages Express enfolds in its lap a diverse kaleidoscope of dynamics which range from gleaming sands to tough amounts to good-looking scenery. It really is this charisma of aspect that delighted the royal dynasties of the bygone period who additional a resplendent feel to their state by building a few of the most luxurious palaces, formidable forts, ornamental backyards, beautiful temples and colorful havelis - every and architectural masterpiece. Following that emerged some very nice stories of heroism and love still echoing in the gold landmarks that dot the inclusive status of Rajasthan. Rajasthan Tour packagesIndia tour packages

Lovely BlogSpot publish on blogger.com I have read you all article it was amazing and meaning full contend Rajasthan , Kashmir , Kerala , himachal, a different different destination apart of incredible India I have get new great experience read your article thanks for you BlogSpot I ‘ m glad to you India tour packages Rajasthan tour packages

My name is.Mrs.Juliet Quin. I live in Canada and i am a happy woman today? and i told my self that any lender that rescue my family from our poor situation, i will refer any person that is looking for loan to him, he gave me happiness to me and my family, i was in need of a loan of $ 73,000.00 to start my life all over as i am a single mother with 3 kids I met this honest and GOD fearing man loan lender that help me with a loan of $ 73,000.00 Canada Dollar, he is a GOD fearing man, if you are in need of loan and you will pay back the loan please contact him tell him that is Mrs.Juliet Quin that refer you to him. Contact Dr Purva Pius via email: reply to email (urgentloan22@gmail.com)

My name is.Mrs Cynthia Corvin. I live in Ukraine i am a happy woman today? i need to use this time to tell all people how i got my loan from this honest and God fearing man loan lender that help me with a loan of $140,000 please contact him. if you also need a loan without any problem he name is Dr Purva Pius email {urgentloan22@gmail.com} tell him that is Mrs CYNTHIA CORVIN that refer you to he contact Email {urgentloan22@gmail.com}

Great post! Thanks you so much for the share. It is indeed a helpful one. I am looking forward of reading more article with the similar topic as this one. Good luck and More Power.Computer waste disposal Tamilnadu, India