Thoughts from a scientist who is a Christian (not a Christian Scientist)

I Always Knew Cats Were More Elegant…

Dec.15,2010

Cats have an elegant means of drinking. (Click for image credit)

I have always been a cat lover. It’s not that I don’t like dogs; I do. In fact, I have one friend who says his dog misses me for a while every time I leave his home. Nevertheless, when it comes to what pets I want to have in my home, cats win over dogs every time. I have always found cats more… well… elegant than dogs. Now, a new study confirms this is true, at least when it comes to how they drink.

Pedro M. Reis, the lead author of the study, was watching his cat (Cutta Cutta) drink one day. He knew that like dogs, cats cannot use their cheeks to suck in liquid. Thus, they must pull liquid into their mouths using their tongues. As he watched his cat, he wondered what physical mechanisms were at work. He thought surely someone had studied how cats drink water before, but the best thing he could find was a 1940 film called Quicker ‘n a Wink, which featured MIT professor Harold “Doc” Edgerton.1 While it had some nice high-speed photography of a cat drinking, it didn’t really explore what was going on in terms of the physics involved. As a result, his team decided they would find out for themselves.

Using high-speed imaging, Reis and his colleagues studied Cutta Cutta’s drinking habits in a very detailed way. They found that while a dog forms a cup-like shape with its tongue and simply scoops water into its mouth, a cat’s way of drinking is significantly more elegant. As they say in their article:

Almost everyone has observed a domestic cat lap milk or water. Yet casual observation hardly captures the elegance and complexity of this act, as the tongue’s motion is too fast to be resolved by the naked eye.2

Essentially, the cat quickly sticks out its tongue, forming it into the shape of a “J.” The tip of the tongue (which is curled under) simply touches the water, and then the cat pulls its tongue quickly back into its mouth. Because water molecules are attracted to the tongue, some water comes back up with the tongue. But because water molecules are also strongly attracted to one another, an entire column of water (or milk) follows. Just before gravity can overcome the liquid’s motion and destroy the column, the cat catches the column in its mouth.

In order to fully test how this elegant mechanism works, the team actually built an “artificial lapper,” in which a disk touches the surface of the water and is then rapidly pulled upwards, dragging a column of water with it. One interesting result from this phase of the study was that a smooth disk worked better than a rough one. Niavely, I would think that the roughness of a cat’s tongue would help in this process, but a smooth disk made the most efficient artificial lapper.

Well…guess what? While most of a cat’s tongue is incredibly rough, there is one part that is quite smooth…the tip of the tongue that touches the water during the lapping process! In other words, the cat’s tongue is perfectly designed to exploit the fluid dynamics of water and other aqueous mixtures, such as milk. Of course, that’s not surprising, since the original cats were designed by the One who determined the rules of fluid dynamics to begin with!

Interestingly enough, when the researchers examined videos of other species of cats (like lions and tigers) drinking, they found that each species has its own pace at which it laps, and that pace is set to maximize the amount of water that the cat can drink in a given amount of time.

So why bother to study how a cat laps liquids? As the authors state near the end of their paper:

The subtle use of the tongue in the drinking process of F. catus is remarkable, given the tongue’s lack of skeletal support. Complex movement in the absence of rigid components is a common feature of muscular hydrostats, which in addition to tongues include elephant trunks and octopus arms. The functional diversity and high compliance of these structures continue to inspire the design of soft robots, and a fundamental understanding of their functionality can lead to new design concepts… (emphasis mine)

In other words, when we learn how the Ultimate Engineer designed things, we can make better designs ourselves.

PLEASE NOTE: I have written an update to this article, which grudgingly admits that cats aren’t more elegant than dogs…at least when it comes to drinking.

REFERENCES

1. Susan Milius, “Cats lap liquids with a flick of the tongue and fluid dynamics,” Science News178(12):5-6, 2010.Return to Text

8 Comments

AutumnDecember 15, 2010 4:25 pm

I recall watching a show called Time Warp that would film everyday occurrences with high-speed cameras so the film could be replayed in super slow motion. One of the films was of a dog drinking. While the tongue does cup the liquid and then pull it into the mouth, it does do by forming an upside down cup. In other words the tongue cups downward which would not seem as efficient. This blog reminded me of that!

jlwileDecember 15, 2010 4:52 pm

Interesting comment, Autumn. I will have to see if I can find some detailed info on a dog drinking.

My pet birds, parakeets and cockatiels, dip their beaks into the surface of water and pull up, essentially, droplets holding onto their upper and lower mandibles and then use their tongues to break the droplets and have the water flow downwards.

jlwileDecember 16, 2010 8:44 am

That’s very interesting, Ben. Do they spend time in between drinks? I am just thinking that in the wild, they would want to have their eyes up as much as possible to watch for predators.

Each time they take a drink, they bring their heads up from out of the surface of the water. They could be doing that to watch for predators, but I don’t know. In a creation model, they wouldn’t have had predators initially, however, for them since they can make a new generation once per year, they would have at least a few thousand generations to gain an instinctive paranoia. Of my birds though, only the oldest male, Picasso, displays any paranoia and that’s probably due to his time at Petco. Aside from his mate, Patricia, all of the other tiels were hatched and raised here and neither they nor even Patty display paranoia yet they also drink by dipping their beaks into the water, bringing their heads up with a droplet between their upper and lower mandible, and using their tongues to break the surface tension of the water.

Don’t birds see out the sides of their heads? Perhaps they can still watch for predators when their heads are tilted downward for drinking?

jlwileDecember 16, 2010 11:35 am

Birds have a wider field of vision because their eyes are on the sides of their heads. A pigeon, for example, sees about 320 degrees around itself. However, that still leaves 40 degrees that are not seen, so the head must move about to be able to see all around.

Dr. Jay L. Wile

You have stumbled across Dr. Jay L. Wile's Blog. Dr. Wile holds an earned PhD from the University of Rochester in Nuclear Chemistry. He is best known for the "Exploring Creation with..." series of textbooks written for junior high and high school students who are being educated at home. He has also just released an elementary science series!You can read about that here.

Links to Investigate

Just {Extra} Ordinary
This is the blog of marine biologist Sherri Seligson, the author of Exploring Creation with Marine Biology. She discusses a wide range of topics of interest to homeschooling parents.

Answers in Genesis
While I disagree with some of the theology on this website, the science discussed is pretty solid.

True Origin
This website contains works from a good mix of young-earth creationists.

Todd's Blog
This is the blog of Dr. Todd Wood, one of the leaders in baraminology. He covers current topics of interest to young-earth creationists.

The GeoChristian
This is the blog of Kevin Nelstead, an old-earth creationist geologist. He covers many topics related to the age of the earth and offers a nice contrast to the young-earth writings listed above.

Discovery Institute
An interesting "think tank" that contains the major players in Intelligent Design

Pharyngula
This is atheist PZ Myers's blog. While I disagree with most of what he says, he is a provocative writer. This is one of the few blogs I read regularly. Please note that there is a lot of foul language in his writing. Those who cannot defend their positions rationally tend to descend into such nonsense.