Why Was Socrates Found Guilty? Was He Fairly Tried

2988 words - 12 pages

At the time of Socrates' trial in 399 BC, Athens was still badly shaken by it's unstable political and military past. The surrender at the Battle of Aegospotami marked the loss of the Peloponnesian war to Sparta, a long and hard fought war which waged from 432-404 BC. Earlier in 411 BC a group of discontent Athenians led by Antiphon, Critias and Charmides briefly overthrew Athens? democracy and established an oligarchy. While it only lasted until 410 BC, it was still fresh in the memory of Athenian citizens when it occurred again with Sparta's victory. Sparta established a government of oligarchs known as the Thirty Tyrants in 404 BC. Critias and Charmides were both involved again, Critias ...view middle of the document...

Another important factor came about through Athens' shaky political past. The citizens became fearful and easily manipulated, well illustrated by Cleon's rise to power. The citizens soon realized what was going on however, and became rather hostile towards the Sophists who had taught the demagogues such manipulative skills. Though Socrates had little to do with this, most of the general public made no distinction between him and the Sophists, and thus again by association he was the target of hostility.The last factor was of Socrates' own doing. His daily ritual of questioning people and exposing their ignorance left the subject embarrassed and destroyed their reputation. The practice was understandably not appreciated, as Socrates acknowledges in his defense (?I incurred the resentment of the man himself and a number of others?). This resentment was only compounded when the youth who followed Socrates began to imitate his techniques and question their elders.All of these factors left people angry and resentful of Socrates, and with the decline of Athens he was just the scapegoat they were looking for. His associations with Critias and Charmides would have made it easy for Socrates to be such a scapegoat, were it not for the amnesty declared following the Thirty Tyrants which did not allow him to be tried for such ties. Thus it may have been that these ties were the real reason for his trial, but due to the amnesty the charges had to rest elsewhere. To quote Xenophon from Memorabilia, "The indictment was to this effect: "Socrates is guilty of crime in refusing to recognize the gods acknowledged by the state, and importing strange divinities of his own; he is further guilty of corrupting the young."" Facing these charges in 399 BC Socrates was brought to trial, with the prosecution led by Meletus and his two sunêgoroi (supporting prosecutors), Lycon and Anytus (a powerful politician). A jury of 501 found him guilty by a narrow margin and he was subsequently sentenced to death. But was it a just decision? The greatest problem faced in the study of Socrates is that Socrates never wrote anything himself. Everything we know of him is drawn from a variety of sources, all of which have their own biases and inaccuracies to account for. The death of Socrates gave birth to a whole new literary genre of 'Socratic' dialogues. Many were by close friends keen to defend his name, while some, such as the works of the Sophist Polycrates (who wrote a pamphlet which reproduced a version of Anytus' prosecution speech, justifying Socrates' execution) were hostile to Socrates. Unfortunately, of these dialogues only the works of Plato and Xenophon survive. There are, however, a few other sources that we can draw information from.Of all the surviving works those of Plato are both best known and most numerous. We have many of his Socratic dialogues, though it may be argued that some of the later dialogues are less representative of the real Socrates, as Plato tends...

Other Essays On Why Was Socrates Found Guilty? Was He Fairly Tried

1276 words - 6 pages
realised that Russia was falling further and further behind the west technologically. He decided to invest heavily in the machine-building industry in order to stimulate technological progress. While investing considerably more, however, it was expected that living standards would rise due to the fact that there would be more funds available for consumption - a contradiction in terms. It also attempted to devolve more responsibility to the

851 words - 4 pages
imagine being on the Royals without his friend Cal. He found it difficult to imagine life with the Royals without Cal's advice and friendship, without his smile and wink. When Ted was sent to a new team he knew no one. It is hard to play on a team when you don't have anyone cheering for you or giving you motivation. Ted Bell was lucky and got the help from the experienced Cal who was a veteran pitcher. When Ted came to the Royals he was not

513 words - 3 pages
company decides to promote?After much discussion with my own supervisor, I went and sought consultation from our departmental director. At twenty-nine, he is the youngest person to become a director at our company. I inquired about what he thought the key points to his success were and what he thought I could do to model my career after his. His advice was simple and to the point; go back to school to pursue a Masters degree and keep working hard

875 words - 4 pages
Activity 6: Courage in the Face of InjusticeOskar Schindler, in the eyes of many, is a true hero. This is a man who wanted to make a difference and do things that he thought was humane and rightful. Although Schindler was part of the Nazi Party during the tragic time of World War Two, Schindler saved approximately 1,200 Jewish lives. Oskar Schindler, a single man, saved the most Jews during World War Two and is a hero to the Jewish community. He

831 words - 4 pages
Chinese population into following communism blindly and repressed anyone with political ideas different to Maos, and is a perfect example of Mao using terror and repression to consolidate his power and control the population.Mao often used repression more than terror, for example in the three and five antis campaigns, which he arguably used as an excuse to punish people to demonstrate his power. Those found guilty of any of the antis were only

1307 words - 6 pages
C/PVT Hopper, David CharlesMS 1100Career Branch ChoicesSpeaking as a newly appointed second lieutenant in the US Army, my three choices of main service would be quite varied. In no particular order they would be Air-Defense Artillery, Aviation, and Infantry. I've always liked the idea of flying, be it transport or actual combat vehicles wouldn't matter to me. I would like to fly attack or combat support choppers though. I've always wanted the

1560 words - 7 pages
The Nineteenth Amendment was a great victory for women, which had been in the works for decades before its ratification. This amendment says that, "The right of citizens of the United States to vote shall not be denied or abridged by the United States or by any State on account of sex." Surprisingly, this amendment was not ratified until August 18, 1920. (Find Law 1) It took years of struggle and protest before women achieved the right to vote

1886 words - 8 pages
trial he was found guilty. He was then in the end killed because of his idea of universal truths.In Greek society religion must have played a very important role if someone was killed because of a disagreement with it. Why was religion so important to the Greeks? One of the main reasons was:The Greek polis also had begun has a religiousinstitution, in which the citizens sought to maintainan alliance with their deities (Perry, 46)If one is seeking

469 words - 2 pages
Socrates' Acceptance of Death: Right or Wrong? Socrates believed in the immortality of the soul and that no one committed wrong willingly, but only because he had been mistaken on the true nature of right. So whether he did right or wrong, he believed himself to be innocent. And if he did commit wrong, he did not do so consciously. However, the courts decided that he was guilty. And for Socrates, any avoidance of the price of truth telling would

520 words - 3 pages
that this information will make the would-be criminal capable of sympathy. If the thief knew what it was like to have his property taken, he would never do such a thing.Socrates thinks that it is better to suffer wrong than to do wrong. The logic he uses is that happiness comes from virtue and enlightenment. He thinks the experience of having been done wrong builds character. Wrong doers will have guilty consciences. He also maintains that the

1407 words - 6 pages
toward the Athenian state and the established religion, many people were displeased with his affect on his pupils. Athenian jury found him guilty of corrupting the youth and interfering with the religion of the city, and sentenced him to death, by drinking poisonous hemlock in 399 B.C.E. He was also charged with neglecting the god of the state and introducing new divinities, a reference to the mystical inner voice that Socrates often spoke of.At

Similar Papers

1324 words - 6 pages
, Kreon tells Oedipus that in his anger he has made and ugly mess of things, which seems to be what Oedipus does makes decisions when he is angry.Iokaste asks her husband to tell her what has happened he does, he asks her to describe Laios, when she does he tells her he may himself be the guilty one he is in search of. He tells her of how one night a feast a drunken man told him he was not Polybos' son; he then confronted his parents who denied

1232 words - 5 pages
ApologyIn Plato's Apology, Socrates is on trial for subverting the minds of Athens' youth and not believing in its gods. The text is Plato's rendition of Socrates' defense of his alleged crimes, and his reasoning for why the allegations were placed in the first place. While many claim that Socrates was wrongly tried for trumped up charges, one must examine whether or not he was truly innocent of the root of his alleged crimes: harming the

973 words - 4 pages
Russia was a dictatorship. The ruler Of Russia was the Emperor (Tsar) and in principle everything that happened in Russia was his responsibility which he joint with no one and was responsible only to God for his actions.From 1894 until 1917, Nicholas II was the Tsar and autocrat of all the Russias and he had succeeded his father Alexander III who had died while still relatively young (49 years old). Alexander's father, Alexander II, had tried to

516 words - 3 pages
The czech army consisted of prisoners and deserters from the Austria-Hungarian empire from the provinces of Bohemia and Slovakia. The Tsar gave his consent to set up a national force which they became to fight against Austria-hungary in the summer of 1916 with their leader called Tomas Masaryk. When Masaryk noticed that Lenin was making peace with the central forces, and lenin refused to let them fight against the western forces, he decided to