I think the only two Carnival ships sailing outta Long Beach are Paradise and Pride. I certainly favor the Pride over Paradise for the ship and itinerary. BUT, I wouldn't call any Carnival ships "luxurious". Funs is their mission, and fun they are!

I have sailed both RCCL and Carnival and I think the RCCL ships are much nicer. My DS pointed out that there were not as many activities scheduled, as compared to Carnival, but I always felt there were more than enough options while on board. (DS and DIL did Carnival for their honeymoon and then RCCL with my DH and I the following year.) The food and service were comparable. There were fewer children on RCCL. As you said, options, options.... Read some of the ship reviews to give you a better idea. You will find lots of different opinions, so you finally just go with it! I promise you, you will not be disappointed.

__________________
DarleneMariner of the SeasCarnival Magic Bloggers Cruise 5Mariner of the Seas