The Murky World of High-Fructose Corn Syrup

In the Kitchen with Mother Linda

The Murky World of High-Fructose Corn Syrup

By Linda Joyce Forristal, CCP, MTA

Think of sugar and you think of sugar cane or beets. Extraction of sugar from sugar cane spurred the colonization of the New World. Extraction of sugar from beets was developed during the time of Napoleon so that the French could have sugar in spite of the English trading blockade.

Nobody thinks of sugar when they see a field of corn. Most of us would be surprised to learn that the larger percentage of sweeteners used in processed food comes from corn, not sugar cane or beets.

The process for making the sweetener high fructose corn syrup (HFCS) out of corn was developed in the 1970s. Use of HFCS grew rapidly, from less than three million short tons in 1980 to almost 8 million short tons in 1995. During the late 1990s, use of sugar actually declined as it was eclipsed by HFCS. Today Americans consume more HFCS than sugar.

High-fructose corn syrup (HFCS) is produced by processing corn starch to yield glucose, and then processing the glucose to produce a high percentage of fructose. It all sounds rather simple--white cornstarch is turned into crystal clear syrup. However, the process is actually very complicated. Three different enzymes are needed to break down cornstarch, which is composed of chains of glucose molecules of almost infinite length, into the simple sugars glucose and fructose.

First, cornstarch is treated with alpha-amylase to produce shorter chains of sugars called polysaccharides. Alpha-amylase is industrially produced by a bacterium, usually Bacillus sp. It is purified and then shipped to HFCS manufacturers.

Next, an enzyme called glucoamylase breaks the sugar chains down even further to yield the simple sugar glucose. Unlike alpha-amylase, glucoamylase is produced by Aspergillus, a fungus, in a fermentation vat where one would likely see little balls of Aspergillus floating on the top.

The third enzyme, glucose-isomerase, is very expensive. It converts glucose to a mixture of about 42 percent fructose and 50-52 percent glucose with some other sugars mixed in. While alpha-amylase and glucoamylase are added directly to the slurry, pricey glucose-isomerase is packed into columns and the sugar mixture is then passed over it. Inexpensive alpha-amylase and glucoamylase are used only once, glucose-isomerase is reused until it loses most of its activity.

There are two more steps involved. First is a liquid chromatography step that takes the mixture to 90 percent fructose. Finally, this is back-blended with the original mixture to yield a final concentration of about 55 percent fructose--what the industry calls high fructose corn syrup.

HFCS has the exact same sweetness and taste as an equal amount of sucrose from cane or beet sugar but it is obviously much more complicated to make, involving vats of murky fermenting liquid, fungus and chemical tweaking, all of which take place in one of 16 chemical plants located in the Corn Belt. Yet in spite of all the special enzymes required, HFCS is actually cheaper than sugar. It is also very easy to transport--it's just piped into tanker trucks. This translates into lower costs and higher profits for food producers.

The development of the HFCS process came at an opportune time for corn growers. Refinements of the partial hydrogenation process had made it possible to get better shortenings and margarines out of soybeans than corn. HFCS took up the slack as demand for corn oil margarine declined. Lysine, an amino acid, can be produced from the corn residue after the glucose is removed. This is the modus operandi of the food conglomerates--break down commodities into their basic components and then put them back together again as processed food.

Today HFCS is used to sweeten jams, condiments like ketchup, and soft drinks. It is also a favorite ingredient in many so-called health foods. Four companies control 85 percent of the $2.6 billion business--Archer Daniels Midland, Cargill, Staley Manufacturing Co. and CPC International. In the mid-1990s, ADM was the object of an FBI probe into price fixing of three products--HFCS, citric acid and lysine--and consumers got a glimpse of the murky world of corporate manipulation.

There's a couple of other murky things that consumers should know about HFCS. According to a food technology expert, two of the enzymes used, alpha-amylase and glucose-isomerase, are genetically modified to make them more stable. Enzymes are actually very large proteins and through genetic modification specific amino acids in the enzymes are changed or replaced so the enzyme's backbone won't break down or unfold. This allows the industry to get the enzymes to higher temperatures before they become unstable.

Consumers trying to avoid genetically modified foods should avoid HFCS. It is almost certainly made from genetically modified corn and then it is processed with genetically modified enzymes. I've seen some estimates claiming that virtually everything--almost 80 percent--of what we eat today has been genetically modified at some point. Since the use of HFCS is so prevalent in processed foods, those figures may be right.

But there's another reason to avoid HFCS. Consumers may think that because it contains fructose--which they associate with fruit, which is a natural food--that it is healthier than sugar. A team of investigators at the USDA, led by Dr. Meira Field, has discovered that this just ain't so.

Sucrose is composed of glucose and fructose. When sugar is given to rats in high amounts, the rats develop multiple health problems, especially when the rats were deficient in certain nutrients, such as copper. The researchers wanted to know whether it was the fructose or the glucose moiety that was causing the problems. So they repeated their studies with two groups of rats, one given high amounts of glucose and one given high amounts of fructose. The glucose group was unaffected but the fructose group had disastrous results. The male rats did not reach adulthood. They had anemia, high cholesterol and heart hypertrophy--that means that their hearts enlarged until they exploded. They also had delayed testicular development. Dr. Field explains that fructose in combination with copper deficiency in the growing animal interferes with collagen production. (Copper deficiency, by the way, is widespread in America.) In a nutshell, the little bodies of the rats just fell apart. The females were not so affected, but they were unable to produce live young.

The medical profession thinks fructose is better for diabetics than sugar, says Dr. Field, but every cell in the body can metabolize glucose. However, all fructose must be metabolized in the liver. The livers of the rats on the high fructose diet looked like the livers of alcoholics, plugged with fat and cirrhotic.

HFCS contains more fructose than sugar and this fructose is more immediately available because it is not bound up in sucrose. Since the effects of fructose are most severe in the growing organism, we need to think carefully about what kind of sweeteners we give to our children. Fruit juices should be strictly avoided--they are very high in fructose--but so should anything with HFCS.

Interestingly, although HFCS is used in many products aimed at children, it is not used in baby formula, even though it would probably save the manufactueres a few pennies for each can. Do the formula makers know something they aren't telling us? Pretty murky!

About the author

Linda Forristal, CCP, MTA is the author of Ode to Sucanat (1993) and Bulgarian Rhapsody (1998). Visit her website at www.motherlindas.com.

This article appeared in Wise Traditions in Food, Farming and the Healing Arts, the quarterly magazine of the Weston A. Price Foundation, Fall 2001

NOTICE: The information on this page was brought to you by people who paid this website forward so that someone such as you might also profit by having access to it. If you care to do so also please feel encouraged to KEEP THIS SITE GOING by making a donation today. Thank you.

Freedom-School
is not affiliated with the links on this page - unless otherwise stated.
This enterprise collectively is known and generally presented as "Freedom-School.com"
- "we," "us" or "our" are other expressions of Freedom-School.com used throughout.
"You" is in reference to the user / visitor.

This is the
fine print that so important. Freedom School and other information served
is so for educational purposes only, no liability expressed or assumed for
use.The information you obtain at this site is not, nor is it intended
to be, legal advice.Freedom School does not consent to or condone unlawful
action.Freedom School advocates and encourages one and all to adhere
to, support anddefend all Law which is particularly applicable.Information
is intended for [those] men and women who are not "US CITIZENS" or "TAXPAYERS"
- continued use, reference or citing indicates voluntary and informed compliance.
Support is not offered.

Freedom School
is a free speech site, non-commercial enterprise and operation asthere
is no charge for things presented.Freedom-School.com site relies on
this
memorandum and others in support of this philosophy and operation.

The noteworthy failure of [the] government or any alleged agency thereof
to at any time rebut anything appearing on this website constitutes a legal
admission of the fidelity and accuracy of the materials presented, which
are offered in good faith and prepared as such by Freedom School and any
and all [third] parties affiliated or otherwise. THIS IS AN ELECTRONIC AGREEMENT
AND IS A LEGALLY BINDING CONTRACT, EQUIVALENT TO A SIGNED, WRITTEN CONTRACT
BETWEEN PARTIES - If the government, or anyone else, wants to assert that
any of the religious and/or political statements appearing on this website
are not factual or otherwise in error, then they as the moving party have
the burden of proof, and they must responsively meet that burden of proof
under the Administrative Procedures Act 5 U.S.C. § 556(d) and under the
due process clauses found in the Fifth, Sixth, and Seventh Amendments to
the national Constitution BEFORE there will be response to any summons,
questions, or unsubstantiated and slanderous accusations. Attempts at calling
presented claims "frivolous" without specifically rebutting the particular
claim, or claims, deemed "frivolous" will be in deed be "frivolous" and
prima facie evidence that shall be used accordingly. Hey guys, if anything
on this site is found to be in error a good faith effort will be made to
correct it in timely fashion upon notification.

Freedom-School.com
is not responsible for content of any linked website or material.In
addition, users may not use Freedom-School.com to engage in, facilitate
or further unlawful conduct;use the service in any way, or manner, that
harms us or anyone connected with us or whose work is presented;damage,
disable, overburden, or impair the service (or the network(s) connected
to the site)or interfere with anyone´s use and enjoyment of the website.

All claims to be settled on the land - Austin, Travis county Texas,
united States of America, using Texas Common Law.All parts of this contract
apply to the maximum extent permitted by law. A court may hold that we cannot
enforce a part of this contract as written. If this happens, then you and
we will replace that part with terms that most closely match the intent
of the part that we cannot enforce. The rest of this contract will not change.
This is the entire contract between you and us regarding your use of the
service. It supersedes any prior contract or statements regarding your use
of the Freedom-School.com site. If there exists some manner of thing missing
we do not forfeit our right to that thing aswe reserve all rights.
We may assign, or modify, alter, change this contract, in whole or in
part, at any time with or without notice to you. You may not assign this
contract, or any part of it, to any other person. Any attempt by you to
do so is void. You may not transfer to anyone else, either temporarily or
permanently, any rights to use the Freedom-School.com site or material contained
within.

GOOGLE
ANALYTICS: While we do not automatically collect personally identifiable
information about you when you visit the Freedom-School.com site, we do
collect non-identifying and aggregate information that we use to improve
our Web site design and our online presence.Visitors to this site who
have Javascript enabled are tracked using Google Analytics. The type of
information that Google Analytics collects about you includes data like:
the type of Web browser you are using; the type of operating system you
are using; your screen resolution; the version of Flash you may be using;
your network location and IP address (this can include geographic data like
the country, city and state you are in); your Internet connection speed;
the time of your visit to the Freedom-School.com site; the pages you visit
on the Freedom-School.com site; the amount of time you spend on each page
of the Freedom-School.com site and referring site information. In addition
to the reports we receive using Google Analytics data, the data is shared
with Google. For more information on Google´s privacy policies, visit:
http://www.google.com/privacy/ads/
Here is Google´s description of how Google Analytics works and how you can
disable it: "Google Analytics collects information anonymously, and much
like examining footprints in sand, it reports website trends without identifying
individual visitors. Analytics uses its own cookie to track visitor interactions.
The cookie is used to store information, such as what time the current visit
occurred, whether the visitor has been to the site before, and what site
referred the visitor to the web page. Google Analytics customers can view
a variety of reports about how visitors interact with their website so they
can improve their website and how people find it. A different cookie is
used for each website, and visitors are not tracked across multiple sites.
Analytics requires that all websites that use it must update their privacy
policy to include a notice that fully discloses the use of Analytics. To
disable this type of cookie, some browsers will indicate when a cookie is
being sent and allow you to decline cookies on a case-by-case basis."

Freedom-School.com site, the DVD, or work computers´ DMCA Policy

the Freedom-School.com site, the DVD, and/or work computers, make effort to be in compliance with 17 U.S.C. § 512 and the Digital Millennium Copyright Act ("DMCA"). It is our policy to respond to any infringement notices and take appropriate actions under the Digital Millennium Copyright Act ("DMCA") and other applicable intellectual property laws.

If your copyrighted material has been posted on the Freedom-School.com site, the DVD, or work computers, in other than fair use capacity or if links to your copyrighted material are returned through our search engine and you want the material removed, you must provide a written communication that details the information listed in the following section. Please be aware that you will be liable for damages (including costs and attorneys´ fees) if you misrepresent information listed on the site that is allegedly infringing on your alleged copyrights. We suggest that you may want to first contact competent legal assistance on this matter.

The following elements must be included in your copyright infringement claim:

* Provide evidence of the authorized person to act on behalf of the fully disclosed alleged owner of an exclusive right that is allegedly infringed. Please notice that we generally do not deal with third parties.
* Provide sufficient contact information so that we may contact you. You must also include a valid email address.
* You must identify in sufficient detail the copyrighted work claimed to have been infringed and including at least one search term under which the material appears in Freedom-School.com search results.
* A statement that the complaining party has a good faith belief that use of the material in the manner complained of is not authorized by the copyright owner, its agent, or the law.
* A statement that the information in the notification is accurate, and under penalty of perjury, that the complaining party is authorized to act on behalf of the owner of an exclusive right that is allegedly infringed.
* Must be signed by the authorized person to act on behalf of the owner of an exclusive right that is allegedly being infringed. (Proper ratification of commencement.)

Send the infringement notice via email to the postmaster at Freedom-School.com

Please allow 1-3 business days for an email response. Note that emailing your complaint to other parties such as our Internet Service Provider (ISP) or server host(s) will not expedite your request and may result in a delayed response due the complaint not being properly being filed.