Starting off reading "To Love a Maurderer" was jsut another story to me, one that i wanted to read when i was in the mood for a Sirius/OC story. As the chapters grew on, i couldn't believe how attached I was getting to these characters, and in this story, when Rhian and Sirius broke up, even though you wrote it all cheery, and neither of them were upset about the break up, i almost cried. And that's alot to say because i haven't cried in 4 years. I want to commend you on your brilliant writing skills, and i hope there are many many many more stories to come. I sit here writing this and think "and to think, getting roped into the characters of Rhian's time, it all happened when i started reading about Saskia Lin!" I fell absolutely in LOVE with the Saskia Lin stories, and i figured it would do me much good to read some of your other writings. this is my first review for this book, but let me tell you, i appreciate your writing so much, and i hope it is something you continue, because you have an amazing talent of turning your passion into something that everyone can enjoy reading!!! 10/10

Author's Response: Aw, thanks! This was my first fanfic (or this series was), so it still has a special place in my heart. Ultimately I want to become a screenwriter, and we'll see how that goes, but I definitely want to do something with writing professionally one day ^_^.

i am really mad you killed Will that is next to unforgivable and then james and lily die, diroiouse in prison, longbottoms crazy i know yu didn't make all those fact but you could have saved will. And right after she told him about magic to. kinda depressing. poor rhian

Author's Response: Thank you for ALL of your reviews, I genuinely appreciate them. I created Will to kill him off, if that makes sense. There are many unfair deaths during wartime, and sometimes the good die young.

yey little harry is now a character namless but we all know his name anyway. Rhian will have to fez up soon.

anecdote. Day haloween day two of my freinds have been roused by the principal to dress up as dementors, principal is dressed as dumbledore and the elementary principal as macgonagall. the two death eaters skeak up on me making the sucking sounds and then my other friend coems form behind screaming expecto patronus. Then the alleged dementors bcak up and fall over laughing at my delighted face. the rest of the day teachers all over showed theri harry potter costumes. coolest day ever.

ok this was a sad chapter i hate how these things have to go. but it was good nontheless.

k anecdote: for hte last chiristmas i got this great harry potter sweater that his this huge hogwarts crest on the front. basically everyone knows i'm harry obsesed but still things like that never go without coment so for the rest of the day people would keep asking what house i belkonged to and they would choose a house themselfs. It continued for hte rest of the day good fun but teachers found it quite annoying

I loved the chapter and the anecdoetes in case you still want one i got a 10 out of 10 in a discussion for being able to relate every hero we talked about to harry potter while still making the comparisons realsitic.

oh my god that is so sad i can't belive it i mean i know that's what really happens that they don't speak for 14 year but really for a girl i know it's rhian but still. arhh i hate this part in the stories.

uy you see remus is really smart that is why he is sucha good person. At this point my favor is for Will i'm still a tad resentful towards sirious i guess. Anyway that is so great for James and lily i'mvery happy for them.

You made me cry! Poo on you!
Now you have to read my story and I will specifically make something bad happen to Ezza so that you will cry. Hmph.

JK, i loved every second of it. If I still didn't have to finish my NHS app (I stayed home sick from school to start my Jackson paper) I would read your other stories. Au revoir.

Author's Response: Aww, I'm sorry for making you cry! But it's kind of a good thing, since it probably means I made you care about my characters. And I cried while writing this chapter (I think--I don't really remember).

Oh my godness. That's a helluva long time. It makes me sad, because they're so cute when they make up, finally.

Author's Response: That was my own little explanation for Sirius & Lupin's feud. I've kind of developed a new theory since then, but the purpose of this entire trilogy was essentially to explain why Lupin and Sirius were so quick to blame each other for ratting out Lily and James.