Today Deadline reported that screenwriting and directing duo Scott McGehee and David Siegel had closed a deal with Warner to remake GCSE syllabus classic Lord of The Flies. But - a-ha! - unlike in the original, the group who violently turn on each other will be female.

McGehee commented that the pair were "taking the opportunity to tell it in a way it hasn't been told before, with girls rather than boys" because "it shifts things in a way that might help people see the story anew" and "breaks away from some of the conventions, the ways we think of boys and aggression."

The decision to gender swap Golding's story is a particularly strange one as some of the overarching themes of the book are what we now call 'toxic masculinity' and power structures that occur within male groups. As feminist writer Roxane Gay plainly noted, "An all women remake of Lord of the Flies makes no sense[...] because the plot of that book wouldn't happen with all women."

Director/producers Scott McGehee and David Siegel, or as they are formally known The Women Whisperers

Getty

'Gender-flipped remakes', as Vanity Fair terms the genre, have been all the rage in recent years with the controversial 'Feminist Ghostbusters' proving a critical hit (but - perhaps tellingly - a commercial flop, losing around $70m). That some people felt offended about Kirsten Wiig et al putting on jumpsuits to vacuum up some ghouls no doubt said more about our outrage culture than it does the film itself, but the need for it to exist in the first place was always questionable.

Advertisement - Continue Reading Below

Meanwhile next year Sandra Bullock, Cate Blanchett, Anne Hathaway and Rihanna will join forces for Oceans Eight, a reboot of the Clooney/Pitt heist franchise and, for the sake of fairness, Channing Tatum will wriggle into a merman tail for the macho remake of Splash.

If you weren't familiar with the dearth of female directors or disparity in male and female pay in Hollywood, you've be forgiven for think we'd conquered sexism with these right-on reboots, but is something more sinister going on?

With 69% of girls identifying as feminist, marketeers are more than aware of the fact that female empowerment is shifting albums, t-shirts and - therefore - cinema tickets. But to my mind dragging up old classics and giving them an all female cast is at best a patronising gesture towards equality and at worst cynical commercialism dressed up as female empowerment.

For all their cheerleading feminist messages, all of the above mentioned reboots have male directors, a fact that can hardly shock given there are 24 of them for every female equivalent.

Erasing men from films does nothing for genuine representation, especially when the strings are all still being pulled by men out of sight. This was one of the reasons Patty Jenkins' recently released Wonder Woman felt so revolutionary and was spectacularly vindicated at the box office.

She added, "I hope when we include female storytellers they will be more like the women I know in my day-to-day life. They are proactive, have their own point of view and don't just react to men around them."

There may be more reason to be cheerful in the world of the small screen. Although Kidman noted that there had been only 183 directors for 4000 episodic television series last year, a spate of recent shows is cause for some hope. The TV adaptation of Margaret Atwood's dystopian drama The Handmaid's Tale has seen two Emmy nominations for female directors Reed Morano and Kate Dennis. Their talent brought a sense of authority and authenticity when addressing issues like female enslavement and ritualised rape. It has been by some margin the most challenging and rewarding piece of television produced this year.

Similarly the genuinely diverse female characters being explored in Jenji Kohan's Orange Is The New Black and Glow. These shows explore female sexuality, mental health and the experience of imprisonment by men with brilliant results - no male control required.

Sign up for the best in style, food, and culture direct to your inbox.

We will also let you know about discounts and great offers from us, tick this box if you'd rather not know about these.
Hearst Partners would like to let you know about some of their fantastic discounts, special offers, and promotions. We promise you wont be bombarded. Tick here if you would like to receive these.