I forgot who it was against or what event, but Ian Rotten performing one of the sicketest blade jobs ever at an IWA-MS show. Also noteworthy are of course Zandig vs Mondo at TOD, John Rare vs Spider Boodrow (box cutter incident, the blood out of Spiders arm is insane).

I cant really recall any non-deathmatches that were really bloody, but I think JBL had some bloody matches in 2004 and early 2005.

If we are talking non-deathmatch, then Eddie/JBL is definitely up there, HHH used to pull off some sick blade jobs back around 2000-2004, the awesome last man standing match against Jericho is one example. Jay Briscoe in ROH has had some pretty bad ones. Steen/Generico was rather bloody aswell, especially Generico. Generico with his mask half ripped off and blood all over his face was like something from a horror movie.

The first match I thought of when I saw this thread title was Jay's cage match against Samoa Joe from "At Our Best" in '04. It's not the bloodiest match of all time, but for some reason it stays in your memory. I can still see those dangling bits of flesh hanging off of Briscoe's forehead.

The Crypt of Cross: New Review - The Cabinet of Dr. Caligari (1920) Posted 11/29/11