Obama hailed Meyer for defying orders and rushing into the heart of an ambush to retrieve fallen comrades, save 13 fellow Americans, kill eight Taliban insurgents and leave his gun turret to rescue two dozen Afghans.
But the McClatchy report, written by Jonathan Landay, a journalist who was accompanying Meyer's unit and witnessed the 2009 battle in the Ganjgal Valley, said details of that account were untrue or unconfirmed.
It was not possible for Meyer to have saved 13 US troops, the article said, because 12 Americans were ambushed in the battle, including the McClatchy reporter, and four troopers were killed, it said.
And military documents indicated that the arrival of helicopters secured the survival of the remaining personnel, not Meyer's vehicle.
There are no statements from fellow troops confirming that Meyer, who has since left the military, killed eight Taliban as claimed on the Marine Corps website, the article said.
The driver of Meyer's vehicle, Staff Sergeant Juan Rodriguez-Chavez, reported seeing Meyer kill one insurgent.
There were also no sworn statements that backed up the portrayal of Meyer leaping out of his gun turret and pulling the 24 wounded Afghans into his truck, according to the report.
Meyer's driver described nine Afghan soldiers getting into the Humvee armored vehicle by themselves while Meyer remained in the turret, it said.
The article also said there was no evidence that supported the White House and Marine Corps account that Meyer defied orders by heading towards gunfire to help his comrades.

Obama hailed Meyer for defying orders and rushing into the heart of an ambush to retrieve fallen comrades, save 13 fellow Americans, kill eight Taliban insurgents and leave his gun turret to rescue two dozen Afghans.
But the McClatchy report, written by Jonathan Landay, a journalist who was accompanying Meyer's unit and witnessed the 2009 battle in the Ganjgal Valley, said details of that account were untrue or unconfirmed.
It was not possible for Meyer to have saved 13 US troops, the article said, because 12 Americans were ambushed in the battle, including the McClatchy reporter, and four troopers were killed, it said.
And military documents indicated that the arrival of helicopters secured the survival of the remaining personnel, not Meyer's vehicle.
There are no statements from fellow troops confirming that Meyer, who has since left the military, killed eight Taliban as claimed on the Marine Corps website, the article said.
The driver of Meyer's vehicle, Staff Sergeant Juan Rodriguez-Chavez, reported seeing Meyer kill one insurgent.
There were also no sworn statements that backed up the portrayal of Meyer leaping out of his gun turret and pulling the 24 wounded Afghans into his truck, according to the report.
Meyer's driver described nine Afghan soldiers getting into the Humvee armored vehicle by themselves while Meyer remained in the turret, it said.
The article also said there was no evidence that supported the White House and Marine Corps account that Meyer defied orders by heading towards gunfire to help his comrades.

Obama hailed Meyer for defying orders and rushing into the heart of an ambush to retrieve fallen comrades, save 13 fellow Americans, kill eight Taliban insurgents and leave his gun turret to rescue two dozen Afghans.
But the McClatchy report, written by Jonathan Landay, a journalist who was accompanying Meyer's unit and witnessed the 2009 battle in the Ganjgal Valley, said details of that account were untrue or unconfirmed.
It was not possible for Meyer to have saved 13 US troops, the article said, because 12 Americans were ambushed in the battle, including the McClatchy reporter, and four troopers were killed, it said.
And military documents indicated that the arrival of helicopters secured the survival of the remaining personnel, not Meyer's vehicle.
There are no statements from fellow troops confirming that Meyer, who has since left the military, killed eight Taliban as claimed on the Marine Corps website, the article said.
The driver of Meyer's vehicle, Staff Sergeant Juan Rodriguez-Chavez, reported seeing Meyer kill one insurgent.
There were also no sworn statements that backed up the portrayal of Meyer leaping out of his gun turret and pulling the 24 wounded Afghans into his truck, according to the report.
Meyer's driver described nine Afghan soldiers getting into the Humvee armored vehicle by themselves while Meyer remained in the turret, it said.
The article also said there was no evidence that supported the White House and Marine Corps account that Meyer defied orders by heading towards gunfire to help his comrades.

Click to expand...

Click to expand...

Click to expand...

What does the formal name of the award have to do with the story Evil posted?

Obama hailed Meyer for defying orders and rushing into the heart of an ambush to retrieve fallen comrades, save 13 fellow Americans, kill eight Taliban insurgents and leave his gun turret to rescue two dozen Afghans.
But the McClatchy report, written by Jonathan Landay, a journalist who was accompanying Meyer's unit and witnessed the 2009 battle in the Ganjgal Valley, said details of that account were untrue or unconfirmed.
It was not possible for Meyer to have saved 13 US troops, the article said, because 12 Americans were ambushed in the battle, including the McClatchy reporter, and four troopers were killed, it said.
And military documents indicated that the arrival of helicopters secured the survival of the remaining personnel, not Meyer's vehicle.
There are no statements from fellow troops confirming that Meyer, who has since left the military, killed eight Taliban as claimed on the Marine Corps website, the article said.
The driver of Meyer's vehicle, Staff Sergeant Juan Rodriguez-Chavez, reported seeing Meyer kill one insurgent.
There were also no sworn statements that backed up the portrayal of Meyer leaping out of his gun turret and pulling the 24 wounded Afghans into his truck, according to the report.
Meyer's driver described nine Afghan soldiers getting into the Humvee armored vehicle by themselves while Meyer remained in the turret, it said.
The article also said there was no evidence that supported the White House and Marine Corps account that Meyer defied orders by heading towards gunfire to help his comrades.

Click to expand...

Click to expand...

Click to expand...

What does the formal name of the award have to do with the story Evil posted?

Click to expand...

No, it doesn't get to the crux of the story. But why does asking for accuracy bother you? Is this not a journalism board?

Obama hailed Meyer for defying orders and rushing into the heart of an ambush to retrieve fallen comrades, save 13 fellow Americans, kill eight Taliban insurgents and leave his gun turret to rescue two dozen Afghans.
But the McClatchy report, written by Jonathan Landay, a journalist who was accompanying Meyer's unit and witnessed the 2009 battle in the Ganjgal Valley, said details of that account were untrue or unconfirmed.
It was not possible for Meyer to have saved 13 US troops, the article said, because 12 Americans were ambushed in the battle, including the McClatchy reporter, and four troopers were killed, it said.
And military documents indicated that the arrival of helicopters secured the survival of the remaining personnel, not Meyer's vehicle.
There are no statements from fellow troops confirming that Meyer, who has since left the military, killed eight Taliban as claimed on the Marine Corps website, the article said.
The driver of Meyer's vehicle, Staff Sergeant Juan Rodriguez-Chavez, reported seeing Meyer kill one insurgent.
There were also no sworn statements that backed up the portrayal of Meyer leaping out of his gun turret and pulling the 24 wounded Afghans into his truck, according to the report.
Meyer's driver described nine Afghan soldiers getting into the Humvee armored vehicle by themselves while Meyer remained in the turret, it said.
The article also said there was no evidence that supported the White House and Marine Corps account that Meyer defied orders by heading towards gunfire to help his comrades.

Click to expand...

Click to expand...

Click to expand...

What does the formal name of the award have to do with the story Evil posted?

Click to expand...

No, it doesn't get to the crux of the story. But why does asking for accuracy bother you? Is this not a journalism board?

Click to expand...

In this instance, it's a swerve from the crux of the story in asking if the military manufacturers heroes for good PR.

Obama hailed Meyer for defying orders and rushing into the heart of an ambush to retrieve fallen comrades, save 13 fellow Americans, kill eight Taliban insurgents and leave his gun turret to rescue two dozen Afghans.
But the McClatchy report, written by Jonathan Landay, a journalist who was accompanying Meyer's unit and witnessed the 2009 battle in the Ganjgal Valley, said details of that account were untrue or unconfirmed.
It was not possible for Meyer to have saved 13 US troops, the article said, because 12 Americans were ambushed in the battle, including the McClatchy reporter, and four troopers were killed, it said.
And military documents indicated that the arrival of helicopters secured the survival of the remaining personnel, not Meyer's vehicle.
There are no statements from fellow troops confirming that Meyer, who has since left the military, killed eight Taliban as claimed on the Marine Corps website, the article said.
The driver of Meyer's vehicle, Staff Sergeant Juan Rodriguez-Chavez, reported seeing Meyer kill one insurgent.
There were also no sworn statements that backed up the portrayal of Meyer leaping out of his gun turret and pulling the 24 wounded Afghans into his truck, according to the report.
Meyer's driver described nine Afghan soldiers getting into the Humvee armored vehicle by themselves while Meyer remained in the turret, it said.
The article also said there was no evidence that supported the White House and Marine Corps account that Meyer defied orders by heading towards gunfire to help his comrades.

Click to expand...

Click to expand...

Click to expand...

What does the formal name of the award have to do with the story Evil posted?

Click to expand...

No, it doesn't get to the crux of the story. But why does asking for accuracy bother you? Is this not a journalism board?

Click to expand...

In this instance, it's a swerve from the crux of the story in asking if the military manufacturers heroes for good PR.

Obama hailed Meyer for defying orders and rushing into the heart of an ambush to retrieve fallen comrades, save 13 fellow Americans, kill eight Taliban insurgents and leave his gun turret to rescue two dozen Afghans.
But the McClatchy report, written by Jonathan Landay, a journalist who was accompanying Meyer's unit and witnessed the 2009 battle in the Ganjgal Valley, said details of that account were untrue or unconfirmed.
It was not possible for Meyer to have saved 13 US troops, the article said, because 12 Americans were ambushed in the battle, including the McClatchy reporter, and four troopers were killed, it said.
And military documents indicated that the arrival of helicopters secured the survival of the remaining personnel, not Meyer's vehicle.
There are no statements from fellow troops confirming that Meyer, who has since left the military, killed eight Taliban as claimed on the Marine Corps website, the article said.
The driver of Meyer's vehicle, Staff Sergeant Juan Rodriguez-Chavez, reported seeing Meyer kill one insurgent.
There were also no sworn statements that backed up the portrayal of Meyer leaping out of his gun turret and pulling the 24 wounded Afghans into his truck, according to the report.
Meyer's driver described nine Afghan soldiers getting into the Humvee armored vehicle by themselves while Meyer remained in the turret, it said.
The article also said there was no evidence that supported the White House and Marine Corps account that Meyer defied orders by heading towards gunfire to help his comrades.

Click to expand...

Click to expand...

Click to expand...

What does the formal name of the award have to do with the story Evil posted?

Click to expand...

No, it doesn't get to the crux of the story. But why does asking for accuracy bother you? Is this not a journalism board?

Click to expand...

In this instance, it's a swerve from the crux of the story in asking if the military manufacturers heroes for good PR.

Click to expand...

And I'm sure it's the first time in the history of the board that happened.

Fact is, the original poster screwed up the name of a prestigious honor. It's at a minimum worth noting.

Hell, had I seen it I would have noted it because the fact that people mess it up drives me batty.

And my noting it wouldn't have been an attempt to move the focus of the discussion. My intent would have been simply to remind that it's the medal of honor rather than the congressional medal of honor.

I posted this in July about Doug Sterner, who was quoted in the story above, and I think it's worth reposting here:

buckweaver said:

DanOregon said:

I agree - but I think a website that could call these fake heroes out would be more effective than another law. Isn't just posing as a member of the military a crime?

Click to expand...

That site already exists: http://homeofheroes.com/

And I'll make this personal plug: I e-mailed Doug quite a few times whenever I was editing obituaries for a military-town newspaper, and I was able to make some important factual corrections on some of those stories over the years because of his help. Veterans -- and their families -- are notorious for inflating their military accomplishments (often innocently), especially after death. As stories get told over the years, details get lost. That's why you gotta check it out.

You can go to Home of Heroes and search Doug's database — and his is the best because the federal government doesn't make one available, unfortunately — any time you encounter a vet who claims to have earned a certain medal. It's searchable by medal, by war, and often by U.S. state.

For instance, here's an alphabetical list of all 398 winners of the Silver Star during the War on Terror: http://homeofheroes.com/valor/08_WOT/ss_GWOT/01_main.html#Alphabetical%20Index

The same database exists on the site for the Medal of Honor, the DSC, Brevet Medal and others. (Purple Hearts are too numerous to mention.)

Looks like the Military Times has started hosting his site in recent years, and they've now got an awards database, too: http://www.militarytimes.com/citations-medals-awards/

Anyway, if you have any journalism duties relating to veterans in any capacity, it would serve you well to bookmark these invaluable sites.

Click to expand...

Hollywood feels compelled to exaggerate stories even when the truth is sufficiently heroic/dramatic ... why should the military be any different? It's sad to see it from the Marines, but I'm glad it's getting exposed.