We’ve collected all the available Reaper of Souls reviews into a wiki article, for one stop shopping (clicking). The article compiles 60 reviews, but a few of them don’t list a score. Metacritic only lists 45, but they’ve got an average of all of those, and it equates to… 86. This is interesting since 1) Diablo 3’s Metacritic average is 88, and 2) practically every RoS review says “big improvement over Diablo 3.”

We’ve added another huge batch of Diablo 3 Console reviews to the article in DiabloWiki.net. There are now 81 reviews listed, which is good number, though it’s still far short of the 145 we cataloged from Diablo 3’s PC/Mac release. I’m not going to paste them all in here since that would be overkill, but here are the handful of perfect scores, and handful of scores below 75, for easy comparison three by three.

We saw a bunch of early Torchlight 2 reviews that compared the game to Diablo III, for better or worse. Those types of articles have kept coming, and the debate is interesting since TL2 intentionally does many things differently than D3, and many of those things (such as the quantity/quality of loot) are exactly what many D3 fans complain about.

Another dozen Diablo III reviews that we’ve just added to the wiki article. The pace is slowing as pretty much everyone who is going to review the game already has, but a few more may trickle in yet. This brings the total to 135 reviews (including the 19 no scores). Of those, seventy-nine ranked the game with a 90 or higher, vs. 37 at 89 or lower.

Our fifth news post with a batch of Diablo III reviews is a heavy one, as I just added upwards of 50 more to the already burgeoning Diablo III reviews article in the DiabloWiki. It’s got more than I can easily count (literally). There are about 129 on the wiki page now, but honestly, I counted while clicking down the page very quickly and I might be off by a couple. MetaCritic currently lists just 66 Diablo 3 reviews, if you wanted a comparison.

Fmulder hopped on his googlehorse (of course of course) and dug up a bunch more Diablo III reviews from gaming sites, which have been added to the wiki article. Quick links and score, since there are lots and I’m not about to start reading all of them at this point.

After a lot of time with the game, IncGamers’ Tim McDonald finished up his review of Diablo 3. As I mentioned last week, I opted not to take on the review as its hard to be 100% objective if you’re a fan. Tim has played all the previous games and has not followed Diablo 3’s development quite as religiously as most of us so I wasn’t sure how he would take it having played the Beta for only a short period of time.