This is a political forum that is non-biased/non-partisan and treats every persons position on topics equally. This debate forum is not aligned to any political party. In today's politics, many ideas are split between and even within all the political parties. Often we find ourselves agreeing on one platform but some topics break our mold. We are here to discuss them in a civil political debate. If this is your first visit to our political forums, be sure to check out the FAQ and RULES. Registering for debate politics is necessary before posting. Register today to participate and remove the ads - it's free!

Re: Does constructive encheatering make you a cheater?

Originally Posted by Surtr

And I never said it was. You can create whatever examples you want, but for the vast majority, that isn't the case. Marriage is an absolute. It's a formal contract between two people that they will be loyal and faithful to each other. Just because you know some swingers doesn't change this.

I never wrote anything about "swingers" and when you have been married for 40 years and are comfortable in your old-age marriage then you can tell of your perfect marriage to your "absolutes." But if you actually do believe in "absolutes," I do not believe a lifelong good marriage is even possible for you.

Nearly everyone on this forum tells of their perfect values of absolutes and perfect goodness to their definition on almost any topic. I rarely believe it.

The old folks I was writing about have done what few couples will ever accomplish.

Been together a lifetime and most married young. didn't sleep around before marriage, didn't get abortions, didn't cohabitate - claiming those don't count if you break up. What they are doing is a lifelong marriage "for better or for worse."

The modern standard? "For better or its over." And then bitch about your ex and how unfair it all is. Then to claim superiority in marriage number 2, 3, 4 - as the kids bounced back and around under the slogan "the children are better off if the parents are both separately happy with their new lovers and spouses." They stuck it out, made it work.

They had their troubles along the way. But now they have a nice home paid for, retirement saved up, and spend holidays with their children, grandchildren and some even great grandchildren. They go on vacations and travel. Have piles of friends they socialize with. Go fishing. And lay back and watch television. Sleep together at night, wake up together in the morning, go to the doctor with each other for their growing health issues and all in all figure they a had and have a pretty good life and - all in all - a half way decent marriage and old age security. But they evolved to have some space between them now and then, just a tad of independence now and then - rather than your "do or die" modern values. They will be together until one of them dies too.

Yes, you can put on your white purity Bible beater robe and call them names if that's what makes you feel superior and good about yourself - likely having nothing yourself to actually show for it.

But here's the thing. They don't give a damn what you think about them. They probably think your values are wrong too. And they have done what now the chances are maybe 1 in 10 you could do, because YOU believe in divorce. They don't.

Re: Does constructive encheatering make you a cheater?

Originally Posted by MaggieD

This is a scenerio out of your imagination. If you can show me any statistic that correlates significant weight gain to cheating in any significant percentage, perhaps it's worth considering. But you can't just make up stuff in your head and say that accounts for cheating. It doesn't. Most cheating is all about the cheater, not the cheatee.

It's about chasing that wonderful hormonal feeling we call "lust." It's about chasing youth. It's about chasing danger. It's about hurting our spouse or significant other. It's about dodging responsibilities. (It's sooo much more fun to **** when you don't have to worry about paying the mortgage or change a diaper.) It's about chasing foot-loose-fancy-free. It's about chasing the person who doesn't care about your faults because he/she doesn't know about them.

You will never convince me that cheating is about weight gain.

I took my weightgain-to-cheating idea from a thread here at DebatePolitics (or maybe another forum like this), where there was a poll whether you would leave your partner upon his/her weightgain. The answers were overwhelmingly a "yes".

Re: Does constructive encheatering make you a cheater?

Originally Posted by joko104

OK, OK. Come clean. Tell YOUR story. Stop being abstract and be specific. What happened to you or by you?

Well, I didn't want to make this thread be linked to that, but my story is here on DebatePolitics, about a year ago (a little less). Here is the abstract. That time I was told a few times that I was wrong to blatently and openly enter into every relationship like it is just a game. So, I decided to experiment with my then GF to build a relationship on a cooperative basis, where we both define each-other's identities. She was very enthusiastic about this, and we went ahead with it. (And she did define my identity, although I don't think I defined any of hers.) Then she needed an operation which lead to pain killers which lead to addiction, and at the end she did many things against me that I don't want to write any more, she destructively drove me in her hope that I would stop trying to get her off the pills. After she stabbed me I cheated on her, and soon after that the relationship ended. If I had not cheated on her, I would be stabbed many more times up till today. I wrote these things on my thread then, but I don't want to link it here, you can find it if you want to.

Re: Does constructive encheatering make you a cheater?

The notion of lifelong marriage/relationship not only is actually becoming quite rare - replaced instead with the last relationship/marriage is the one that lasts to the end. Increasingly, people argue that lifelong marriage is totally contrary to human nature anyway. Yet even with this, most people still try to blend "old fashioned marriage rules" with new fashioned 1,001 justifications for divorce when the do marry (or enter a same-as-marriage no-license commitment or start a family.

My wife was super fixated on the question of who she should marry, wanting no relationships along the way until them, and since she is basically a perfection and lives perfectly to her values (and always has), this quite a challenge, since those values include what are grounds for divorce - of which there are only 2. Highly damaging abuse in real terms of the children and severe ongoing physical abuse (beating) of her. Otherwise, no basis. So if she married a man who became a boring, apathetic, wandering alcohol drug addict adulterering bum, then that was who she was married to and she'd make the best of it. Since this would conflict horribly with her ultimate goal of being foremost a parent, wife and homemaker, the seemingly perfect guys that wanted her as the seemingly perfect future wife were lacking. She also recognized unique aspects of herself and seeming contradictions making it all quite the challenge. It odd ways, that was me. And she latched on almost instantly. I never wanted a relationship, never had one before in my life either, but I'd have been a total fool not to recognize what she offered to me in return.

For a marriage to work right takes many things. But one of those I think has to do with how long or short the "I will divorce if _______" list is.

It somehow pisses me off to read a man write "I'd kick her ass to the door if she..." about his wife. I don't think that was in those marriage vows. And in my view it means he really does not love her in a true love sense and is more in love with himself and his own ego.

Her list has only 2 theoreticals on it. Mine has only 1 - severe abuse of the children. The one thing we both know as much as can possibly be known, it is our proven exact opposite natures from those basis of divorce. She is the pied piper of children. I've never seen anyone who likes children so much and children feel that way about her too. She'd never hurt a child, certainly not her own. I have quite the history of extreme intolerance of any man abusing a child and (circumstantially) a woman. So I not a risk of that either.

That's it. That's the divorce list. Now, whether the marriage is a good one or not for both of us is up to us. Doesn't matter a damn how anyone else would evaluate it. But our marriage isn't static either. Her goal is to live her live as an ongoing romance novel of her own life - something that must evolve, face challenges, advancements, setbacks and newness, a path of joint romantic discovery. A curious challenge. Keeps life interesting.

That's my view of it anyway for MY marriage. Do whatever the hell you want with yours.

Re: Does constructive encheatering make you a cheater?

Originally Posted by ab9924

Well, I didn't want to make this thread be linked to that, but my story is here on DebatePolitics, about a year ago (a little less). Here is the abstract. That time I was told a few times that I was wrong to blatently and openly enter into every relationship like it is just a game. So, I decided to experiment with my then GF to build a relationship on a cooperative basis, where we both define each-other's identities. She was very enthusiastic about this, and we went ahead with it. (And she did define my identity, although I don't think I defined any of hers.) Then she needed an operation which lead to pain killers which lead to addiction, and at the end she did many things against me that I don't want to write any more, she destructively drove me in her hope that I would stop trying to get her off the pills. After she stabbed me I cheated on her, and soon after that the relationship ended. If I had not cheated on her, I would be stabbed many more times up till today. I wrote these things on my thread then, but I don't want to link it here, you can find it if you want to.

Well, good for Joko. He finally got it out of you. Grow a set, my friend. Stop trying to fix people. "If I had not cheated on her, I would be stabbed many more times up till today." What???????? The first time someone uses physical violence against you, it's over!!!!!!!! Read that twice!!!!!!!!

Re: Does constructive encheatering make you a cheater?

Originally Posted by MaggieD

Well, good for Joko. He finally got it out of you. Grow a set, my friend. Stop trying to fix people. "If I had not cheated on her, I would be stabbed many more times up till today." What???????? The first time someone uses physical violence against you, it's over!!!!!!!! Read that twice!!!!!!!!

Exactly. Never let it get to the point of being stabbed; the first time they punch you somewhere other than the arm, or threaten you with a weapon, walk.

Fiddling While Rome Burns
ISIS: Carthago Delenda Est
"I used to roll the dice; see the fear in my enemies' eyes... listen as the crowd would sing, 'now the old king is dead, Long Live the King.'.."