Young people not straight, not narrow

UNIVERSITY & COLLEGE COUNSELLING | SEPTEMBER 2017 | NON-BINARY CLIENTS
YOUNG PEOPLE: NOT STRAIGHT, NOT NARROW
Growing numbers of young people are resisting traditional, binary gender identities and do not de ne themselves as heterosexual.
In conversation with therapists, academics and youth workers, NeilYoungexploresthissigni cantsocialchangeandoffers pointers and resources to support good therapeutic practice
No, I’m not gay
No, I’m not straight,
And I’m sure as hell not bisexual, dammit, I am whatever I am when I am it
Andrea Gibson 1
I don’t relate to being boy or girl, and I don’t have to have my partner relate to boy or girl
Miley Cyrus 2
We are witnessing a sea change in
how teenagers and young adults are experiencing their sexuality and gender identity. In a 2015 YouGov survey, half (49%) of young people aged 18–24 said they did not see themselves as
100 per cent heterosexual.3 What we are seeing
in the UK are large, and growing, numbers of young people who are comfortable with at least some same-sex desire in their sexual and romantic fantasises and behaviour. Comparable, American research has crowned these ‘mostly straight’ – or arguably bisexual – young people as making up the largest sexual minority group in their age range: they are more open to relationships with people across the gender and sexuality spectrum and
are busy critiquing and rejecting identities that emerged from the 1970s and 80s, especially
binary notions of ‘gay’ and ‘straight’.4
In parallel with these changes, there has been an explosion in gender identities, with ‘trans’ –
an inclusive umbrella term for gender difference –
04

NON-BINARY CLIENTS | SEPTEMBER 2017 | UNIVERSITY & COLLEGE COUNSELLING
becoming mainstream, and the emergence of ‘non-binary’ – meaning ‘any gender that is not exclusively male or female’, ref lecting wider societal patterns in which people are owning parts of themselves that are the other, both or neither genders.5
Part of the challenge to conventional lesbian, gay, bisexual, trans and queer (LGBTQ) labels has come from young people being able to nd a wide range of uncensored information about sexuality and gender, mainly via the internet and social media but also through networks, campaigns, literature, blogs, popular culture and friends. The recent emergence of out, mainly LGB, role models in traditionally
more macho arenas – rugby, boxing, American football, athletics and hip-hop – alongside the positive coverage of trans role models such as
Laverne Cox, Janet Mock and Paris Lees, have inspired young people. Celebrities using social media, including Angel Haze, Olly Alexander, Miley Cyrus, Lady Gaga and Ruby Rose, also act as cultural cheerleaders, magnifying information about sexual and gender f luidity and non-binary identities.
In the past decade we have also seen the increasing visibility of people who experience their sexuality as ‘asexual’. This development, according to academic Dr Meg-John Barker, offers welcome relief within a culture pushing sex as compulsory, permitting space to relax within a spectrum of sexual desire, or none at all. As Barker notes: ‘…if your sexual desire f luctuates over time or you just don’t have much sexual attraction, that’s not a problem; it’s nothing to
be worried about’.5
05
For illustration purposes only: posed by models
UNIVERSITY & COLLEGE COUNSELLING | SEPTEMBER 2017 | NON-BINARY CLIENTS
As practising counsellors working with students, some of us will have already sensed a shift away from mainstream labels – which can be seen as too sexualised (‘bisexual’), too narrow (‘heterosexual’), too political (‘queer’), too clinical (‘lesbian’) or too
It is important to recognise that, from a young age, LGBTQ people often have to develop sophisticated coping strategies to avoid and minimise the impact of hatred and rejection. Often subject to signi cant unconscious or conscious pressure from their families, friends and wider communities to be straight and stereotypically male or female, LGBTQ young people can repress who they are
and construct what Winnicott described as a ‘false self’ to ‘protect the real self from pain’.10, 11
Adaptive strategies adopted by LGBTQ children can become destructive in later life, while others can actually help to build resilience in adolescence and adulthood. This can be seen in LGBTQ young people who are practising ‘visibility management’, where they are very careful about where, when and to whom they are out, monitoring what they say, their body language and even dating someone
to ‘pass’ as straight.12 Such management can be particularly useful, and necessary, for many
black and minority ethnic young people and
those from conservative religious communities:
it allows young people to be ‘out’ when they can, while keeping them safe.
In short, as Darla Linville observes, young people are ‘in the process of making spaces safe for themselves, while demanding the opportunity to do desire the way they want’.13 So how does this affect what LGBTQ young people want from therapy?
The largest UK study found that a non-judgmental, supportive approach from the therapist was the biggest factor for LGBTQ young people in forging
a successful working alliance.8
Using this as a starting point, I have developed
10 recommendations for therapists working with young people. These insights have been informed
by interviews I conducted in January 2017 with counsellors (Kim Davies14 and Amy Walters15); psychotherapists (Meg-John Barker5 and Lara Smith16); a psychiatrist who contributed anonymously; an academic (Natacha Kennedy17); and a trans and non-binary youth worker (Finn Greig18).
1 Examine your sexual and gender identity and relationship style: as Lara Smith, a psychosexual therapist and a young people’s counsellor working in a secondary school, reminds us: ‘…don’t underestimate the unconscious’. Lara advocates for therapists to have enough personal therapy so that we are aware of assumptions and judgments about our own gender and sexual identity, underpinned by supervision from an experienced supervisor who understands LGBTQ work.16
YOUNG PEOPLE ARE INVENTING AND EMBRACING LABELS THAT REFLECT THEIR FANTASIES, EXPERIENCES AND AN INTERNAL SENSE OF THEMSELVES
associated with negativity and weirdness (‘gay’) –
to newer identities based on a more relaxed attitude to sexuality
and gender.4 While, outside of contemporary Western culture, many societies have historically acknowledged and
celebrated gender and sexual diversity,6 the UK is fast playing catch-up. Young people growing up here are inventing and embracing labels that ref lect their fantasies, experiences and an internal sense of themselves, while some are rejecting all identities as inherently inadequate and restrictive.
Nowhere is this change clearer than in relationships. So-called ‘intentional’ relationship styles have now moved beyond the traditional notions of swinging, monogamy and open relationships into a complex, growing menu of choices for intimacy. For example, young people
are being drawn to ‘polyamory’ or ‘poly’ (having ‘simultaneous multiple love/romantic relationships with the knowledge and consent of all concerned’),7 including ‘relationship anarchy’ (‘deliberate non- possessive style of relationship, a more explicitly political version of polyamory’),7 the ‘new monogamy’ (‘a form of monogamy that is somewhat open to other sexual/emotional connections’),7 and ‘fuck buddies’ (people ‘who have a friendship and who have sex together, but who are not romantically attached’).5,7
In the midst of such fast-paced change, it could
be easy to lose sight of the ongoing struggles that LGBTQ young people still face, especially those who belong to racial and other minority communities. While many of today’s students have grown up within more accepting cultures, LGBTQ students are still more likely to drop out or take time out of study – including half of all trans students – while homo-, bi- and transphobic abuse and harassment remain
a persistent problem for young people.8,9 Thankfully, most LGBTQ young people do go on to lead satisfying, ordinary lives, yet in the therapy room we can nd ourselves supporting clients acting out from a place of trauma, shame, guilt and other unprocessed, internalised beliefs connected to historic and ongoing hostility towards their gender and/or sexual identities.
06
2 Proactively educate yourself about LGBTQ issues:
no matter how good our therapy training has been, most courses still have little or no positive LGBTQ content. The dilemma, as Kim Davies, a counsellor practising in Milton Keynes, points out, is that, although ‘we are always learning from our clients… [we must] …make sure we are not relying on them to teach us’.14 As such, we have an ethical responsibility to seek out specialist training and resources – as listed at the end of this article – to relieve the burden from young LGBTQ clients of educating their therapists. For example, sharing this article with other therapists and professionals would be an excellent way to encourage debate.
3 Be open and know your limits: building on the
rst two recommendations, you can then be more transparent with clients about what you do and don’t know about gender, sexual identities and relationship styles. If you still feel that you are not the best t for an LGBTQ client, make sure you have developed networks with therapists and LGBTQ-speci c and -friendly services so you can safely refer on.
4 Be an LGBTQ af rmative therapist: have materials that signal your support for LGBTQ young people
in your waiting area, such as leaf lets, posters and magazines. Ensure any forms you use are thoughtful about sexuality and gender identity questions – ideally having a blank space for the client to decide for themselves. Check out their preferred pronoun: don’t assume that ‘he’ or ‘she’ is appropriate – clients may want you to use ‘they’ or another pronoun.
5 Allow for certainty and uncertainty, exploring what these mean for
abused and is angry about it, saying something like, ‘that would make quite a lot of people angry’, to empathise, is supportive, rather than appearing to question what is really healthy rage against bigotry.16
7 Focusing on gender and sexual identity can be a red herring: young people report that therapists can too often link dif culties back to their LGBTQ identity. The danger here is that these young people – who may already be extra-sensitive to not being accepted and have split off parts of their identities to stay safe
– may then avoid talking about their gender and sexual identity, even when they need to. Finn Greig, Lead Youth Worker at Gendered Intelligence, says this is a common experience for trans and non-binary young people, who often report that even when they have many other important issues to talk about – such as exam stress, diagnoses or problems with relationships or school – therapists spend a disproportionate amount of time on their trans identity.18
8 Be focused on what is happening for the client:
therapists highlighted several unhelpful reactions to LGBTQ young people coming out. Kim Davies spoke of professionals saying clients were ‘too young to have formed an identity’ when in fact [they had] …quite positively formed an identity’,14 while Lara Smith asserted that therapists should never say ‘perhaps
it’s a phase’ or ‘are you sure?’ because ‘it might be an exploratory phase in [their] life; it may not; but it doesn’t really matter; that is where [they] are at’.16
9 That said, making mistakes often helps the therapy:
you will probably get someone’s pronoun wrong at some point or have to correct a wrong assumption about someone’s sexuality or gender. Don’t beat yourself up, because acknowledging your mistakes or ignorance can open up opportunities to nd out more about what their life is like, for you to say to them, as Meg-John Barker suggests: ‘I’m not perfect, I’m really sorry I messed it up’ or just ‘I don’t know; how would you like me to refer to you?’ and thus provide what can be a meaningful, reparative experience.5
10 Therapy with LGBTQ young people can be hugely rewarding: Amy Walters describes the ‘real honour’ she feels working with young people for whom therapy – and the coming out it often involves –
can be ‘terrifying’ and yet at the same time ‘hugely empowering… at different points in their journey’.15 Authenticity is the key; otherwise, as Lara Smith warns: ‘If you are not genuine, if you are not congruent, [young people] will sniff you out a mile away’.16
NON-BINARY CLIENTS | SEPTEMBER 2017 | UNIVERSITY & COLLEGE COUNSELLING
IT COULD BE EASY TO LOSE SIGHT OF THE ONGOING STRUGGLES THAT LGBTQ YOUNG PEOPLE STILL FACE
the individual client in the here and now: for example, Amy Walters, a counsellor working in Wiltshire, argues for the importance of giving
trans young people: ‘…permission to go on this journey without knowing the answers at the beginning’.15 It is still a big deal for a young person to feel able to safely explore their gender and sexual identity without being subject to guilt or shame.
6 Support young people’s feelings in response to anti-LGBTQ prejudice: Lara Smith encourages therapists to ‘normalise feelings’ in the face of widespread prejudice. When a student has been
07
UNIVERSITY & COLLEGE COUNSELLING | SEPTEMBER 2017 | NON-BINARY CLIENTS
A positive experience of therapy can support young people to explore and accept who they are, deal with the challenges life throws at them and make healthier choices. Such relational, therapeutic work with young LGBTQ and non-binary clients also offers much for us,
4. Savin-Williams RC. The new sexual minority teenager: freedom from traditional notions of sexual identity.
In: Kaufman JS, Powell DA (eds). The meaning of sexual
identity in the twenty- rst century. Newcastle upon Tyne: Cambridge Scholars Publishing; 2014.
5. Barker M-J. Interview. 4 January 2017.
6. Trently D. 10 examples of nonbinary genders throughout history. http://listverse.com/2015/10/21/10- examples-of-nonbinary-genders-throughout-history (accessed 5 March 2017).
7. Barker M-J, Richards C. Sexuality and gender for mental health professionals: a practical guide. Sage: London; 2013. 8. METRO. Youth Chances. 2014
9. National Union of Students (NUS). Education beyond the straight and narrow: LGBT students’ experiences in higher education. London; NUS; 2014.
10. Winnicott DW. The maturational processes and the facilitating environment. Madison, WI: International Universities Press; 1965. 11. RowanJ.Therealitygame:aguidetohumanisticcounselling and psychotherapy. London: Routledge; 1998.
12. Lasser J. Tharinger D. Visibility management in school and beyond: a qualitative study of gay, lesbian, bisexual youth. Journal of Adolescence 2003; 26(2): 233–44. In Clarke V, Ellis SJ, Peel E, Riggs DW. Lesbian gay bisexual trans & queer psychology: an introduction. Cambridge: Cambridge University Press; 2010.
13. Linville D. Resisting regulation: LGBTQ teens and discourses of sexuality and gender in high schools. New York: City University of New York; 2009. http://academicworks.cuny.edu/cgi/ viewcontent.cgi?article=2428&context=gc_etds
(accessed 19 February 2017).
14. Davies K. Interview. 14 January 2017.
15. Walters A. Interview. 8 January 2017.
16. Smith L. Interview. 14 and 15 January 2017.
17. Kennedy N. Interview. 15 January 2017.
18. Greig F. Interview. 21 January 2017.
RESOURCES:
Gendered intelligence: offers training on working with trans and gender variant young people; runs youth groups; and its ‘Knowledge is Power’ section is for and by young trans people: http://genderedintelligence.co.uk
Pink Therapy: therapy organisation working with gender and sexual diversity clients in the UK; therapist database and CPD training programme: http://pinktherapy.mobi and YouTube channel: https://www.youtube.com/user/ pinktherapyuk
Brook: https://www.brook.org.uk/our-work/training- on-gender-and-sexuality
Bish: ‘A guide to sex, love and you’ for young people aged 14 plus. http://www.bishuk.com
FURTHER READING:
Barker M-J, Richards C. Sexuality and gender for mental health professionals: a practical guide. London: Sage; 2013. Practical advice and an excellent glossary.
Borstein K. My new gender workbook (2nd edition). London: Routledge; 2013. For use with clients exploring their gender identity.
ACKNOWLEDGEMENTS:
Thanks to Dr Meg-John Barker, Kim Davies, Natacha Kennedy, Finn Greig, Lara Smith and Amy Walters for their thoughtful, grounded ideas. Also to Jane Czyzselska, Paul Harris, David Mair, JC Niala, Dr Madura Rasaratnam, and my partner Edmund for feedback on an earlier draft.
IN THE THERAPY ROOM,
WE CAN FIND OURSELVES SUPPORTING CLIENTS ACTING OUT FROM A PLACE OF TRAUMA, SHAME, GUILT AND OTHER UNPROCESSED, INTERNALISED BELIEFS
as therapists, to ref lect on and learn from. Set against the pain that any one of us can experience in the face of rigid gender stereotypes, Lara Smith provides an inspiring reality check for our work and our lives: ‘We don’t have to t a certain way of being – who wrote
those rules? Where did they come from? We don’t have to live like that. We can be the people we are’.16
ABOUT THE AUTHOR
Neil Young is an integrative arts psychotherapist training at the Institute for Arts and Therapy in Education. He has 20 years’ experience as a trainer and queer community advocate, founding Mosaic LGBT Youth Centre in north-west London and working as an LGBT advisor for the rst two Mayors of London. A Pink Therapy conference presentation that inspired this article can be viewed here: http://bit.ly/1UrpIvn: neilyoungtherapy@gmail.com
REFERENCES
1. GibsonA.Andrew,from‘whentheboughbreaks’
[CD]. Self-published; 2006.
2. Cyrus M. ‘I don’t relate to being boy or girl’. The Guardian
2015; 10 June. https://www.theguardian.com/music/ 2015/jun/10/miley-cyrus-i-dont-relate-to-being-boy-or-girl (accessed 19 February 2017).
3. Dahlgreen W. 1 in 2 young people say they are not 100 per cent
heterosexual. YouGov. https://yougov.co.uk/news/2015/08/16/ half-young-not-heterosexual (accessed 19 February 2017).
08