Loyalty and Your Car Insurance Company: When It’s Time to Move On

By InsuranceHotline.com Team

Loyalty is an important backbone of any relationship, but it’s not always one you want to have when it comes to your car insurance. Stay loyal to the one you love, but not necessarily to your car insurance company; there may be a better deal out there for you and it may be time for you to consider seeing someone new.

Loyalty and Insurance

Car insurance companies offer loyalty discounts to help keep their people in the fold, but that doesn’t mean that it’s always the right thing to do. In many cases, you can save a lot of money by going somewhere else, even if it means giving up that longevity discount you get for sticking around.

When comparing insurance rates, it’s important to take into consideration all of the factors, not only the rate. Loyalty to an insurance company should be something they earn with more than just a discount. Strong customer service, attention to your policy and needs, and good claims service are all important things to consider about your car insurance company when you’re deciding if you should move on.

The Cost of Leaving Vs. the Cost of Staying

Many people choose to stay with their insurance company because of the potential cost of switching. While it’s true that there can be some costs involved in making the move, it’s important to get a realistic look at what they are and whether they actually outweigh the cost of staying where you are.

Leaving your insurance company in the middle of the policy term can cost you. Some insurance companies won’t charge you a penalty for an early cancellation, while others do something called short-rating in which they don’t return to you the full unearned premium. Take into consideration any down payment the new company requires before you make your decision.

That doesn’t mean you should wait until the renewal date to make the break; in some cases you can still save money overall simply by moving on now and not waiting until later. Consider how much you will pay for the duration of your policy term and compare it against the new policy with all fees and penalties added in. You might be surprised to see that you still come out on top by changing right away.

You should also consider other potential costs, such as loss of accident forgiveness waivers. If you have had an accident with your current insurance company that fell under accident forgiveness, that forgiveness won’t transfer to a new company, so you may be charged for the accident.

Shopping Around for New Insurance

It’s important to remember that there is no obligation whatsoever to shopping around for a better rate on car insurance. Thanks to online quoting it doesn’t take a lot of time, and if you don’t find a better option, you can stay right where you are.

When you’re shopping for car insurance quotes, be certain that you are comparing policies offering the same coverage. In some cases a new policy can appear to be a better deal only because the coverage levels are lower. It’s also a good idea to take some time to research the insurance company and find out how they do with customer satisfaction. That way you can be sure that you are making the right decision, one you won’t regret.

When to Make the Switch

If you’ve done your research and determined it’s time to move on to a new insurance company, you can ensure a smooth transition by following a few simple steps. First, apply for the new policy and make certain that everything is in place before you cancel the old policy.

Check with your current insurance company to find out what their procedure is for cancellation. Some will accept a cancellation over the phone, while others may require it in writing. Some insurance companies will even take care of notifying your current company for you when you sign up for a new policy, so you don’t have to worry about it.

Loyalty to a company can be a good thing, but only when you are benefiting from the relationship. If you could benefit more from starting a new relationship than by sticking with the old, it’s time to make the switch.

Not ready to shop for insurance today?

Set a renewal reminder and we'll let you know when it's time to start shopping for savings.

This email is invalid

Also subscribe to InsuranceHotline.com's Insider Newsletter.

Yes, I would like to receive InsuranceHotline.com electronic renewal reminder emails as well as The Insider Newsletter if I checked the box above to get relevant articles, tips, alerts, and news. I am able to unsubscribe at any given time.

Our Users Say

1,099 reviews on TrustPilot.
See some of the reviews here.

appreciationPrompt response was appreciated. Agent very helpful with info.
I needed to supply.

0 years agopatricia Manning

I loved that InsuranceHotline.com was fast and easy to useI loved how fast and easy it was to use InsuranceHotline.com to compare insurance quotes. By using InsuranceHotline.com I found a new insurance broker and new insurance company that will save me almost $50 per month compared to my current home and auto insurance. If you're looking for cheaper insurance, start here.

0 years agoJennifer A.

Good but a little too highMy manager did it for me. He asked me questions and it seemed pretty easy to follow.

0 years agoFrancine

Got the best rate and a wonderful…Got the best rate and a wonderful broker!

0 years agoMarijana G

Michael Washington was amazing and took…Michael Washington was amazing and took the time to go over everything in detail. Really nice to have someone know their job extremely well and walk you through the process. Thanks M.W. for going over my file and saving me money.

0 years agoBMorales

Was very simple and easyWas very simple and easy. Would recommend it.

0 years agoM. M.

Done with easeDone with ease, and several leads

0 years agoBurton Hamilton

prompt and very informativeprompt and very informative.
lots of information about various auto insurance companies.

0 years agonizar premji

Fast and efficient !I use the website to find my car insurance quotes. It was easy to use and the response was quick. I called the provider with the cheapest quote and was happy with their service.

0 years agoKim

Quick and easy with multiple choices…Quick and easy with multiple choices for travel insurance options. Only thing that didn’t work on my I phone was the policy wordings, when I clicked to open it the brochure did not download on my iPhone

Our site uses cookies to provide the best online experience.
By continuing to browse the site, or clicking okay, you agree to allow cookies.
Our privacy policy has more information on the use of cookies and how to manage them.
OK