Honestly, you can never make something "original", or something that will make old timers happy. They will always say: […] They'll also probably say something along the lines of "Its not clinical enough."

http://www.scp-wiki.net/forum/t-2053640/nazis-and-scps#post-2721828 (thread about Nazis, part of this feedback included a post with "You act like Im a Nazi sympathizer. No, I'm not. I've studied WWII quite a bit. I know about the germans. This is the SCP Foundation after all, I thought its supposed to be sickening and terrifying? Don't take my advice, then. What is not wanted is sometimes not needed.")

So far it seems more whining than outright malice, but keep an eye on them. The negativity doesn't really help anyone.

Not a bad idea. Maybe when they touch it, it actually has extremely negative effects and can kill them.

(the idea in question was "I'm thinking of a object that, when in the sight of humans, transforms into a representation of their greatest desires. And if multiple people view it at the same time, it turns into an abomination of the two peoples greatest desires.")