May 22, 2006—RFID might be a great technology for identifying and tracking goods, but according to a draft report from a subcommittee of the Privacy Office of the U.S. Department of Homeland Security (DHS), it's not a panacea for long lines and forged IDs at border crossings and airports. Furthermore, the report claims, its use could weaken the privacy of individuals whose government-issued identity documents might carry RFID tags. The report urges the DHS to consider "other technologies that may serve the same [identification] goals with less risk to privacy."

The DHS Emerging Applications and Technology Subcommittee of the Data Privacy and Integrity Advisory Committee wrote the 15-page report to guide the department's secretary, Michael Chertoff, acting chief privacy officer Maureen Cooney and DHS program managers in deciding whether to deploy RFID technology within DHS programs to identify or track individuals. The report has not yet been submitted to Cooney, who has the lead role at DHS in analyzing and deciding the legal implications of various programs and their impact on privacy.

James Harper

The Privacy Office is tasked with ensuring that no DHS programs or policies negatively impact the privacy of U.S. citizens and visitors, based on the Privacy Act of 1974, the Freedom of Information Act and other laws, including Section 222 of the Homeland Security Act. Within the Privacy Office sits the Data Privacy Integrity Advisory Committee, which advises Chertoff and Cooney on a number of matters, including technological issues relevant to the DHS that affect individual privacy.