It’s a significant embarrassment for the panel, which exists to provide quality scientific information on climate change and its implications. This tragicomedy of errors can get confusing. Here’s a Cliffs Notes version.

Speculation or Fact?

The UN panel’s prediction referenced an environmental NGO (non-governmental organization) report, which in turn cited a popular science magazine’s news article, which used remarks from an Indian scientist who, the magazine now asserts, now calls his comment speculation.

Sound like tales spreading through your neighborhood or office? These are big players with significant stakes.

The UN’s Intergovernmental Panel on Climate Change (IPCC) shared the 2007 Nobel Peace Prize with Al Gore. In lauding the IPCC’s mobilization of scientific knowledge about climate change, the Nobel presenter said, “Similar procedures to the IPCC’s should be considered as ways of approaching problems also in other fields.”

The NGO, global environmental group WWF (formerly World Wildlife Fund—the panda people), now has issued a major retraction of their 2005 warning about Himalayan glacier melting projections, saying they failed to double-check the primary source.

The secondary source WWF cited was a 1999 New Scientist magazine news article featuring an Indian scientist’s views that many Himalayan glaciers could disappear by 2035 because of global warming. New Scientist now says the Indian scientist “has never repeated the prediction in a peer-reviewed journal” and that he now calls his own statement “speculative.” The scientist says he was “misquoted.”

Some scientists also suggest that “2035” may represent inaccurate copying of “2350” from another report. Sound like a mess?

“Glaciers in the Himalaya are receding faster than in any other part of the world … and, if the present rate continues, the likelihood of them disappearing by the year 2035 and perhaps sooner is very high if the Earth keeps warming at the current rate.”

A prominent Indian glaciologist disputed the IPCC 2007 statement in a 2009 Indian government report. IPCC chair Rajendra Pachauri shot back, calling the report “voodoo science” that lacked peer review.

The Times notes that the WWF report which the IPCC cited “was a campaigning report rather than an academic paper so it was not subjected to any formal scientific review.”

After the prediction recently unraveled, the IPCC, while still concerned about glacier melting, called the prediction “poorly substantiated” and said “clear and well-established standards of evidence … were not applied properly” in this case.

Getting to the Truth

Getting to the truth can require persistent, discerning questions and multiple critiquers. I’m reminded of a biblical proverb: “The heart of the discerning acquires knowledge; the ears of the wise seek it out.” Another says, “There is safety in having many advisers.”

Trent University (Ontario, Canada) geographer Graham Cogley, who helped uncover the mistake, laments that “nobody who studied this material bothered chasing the trail back to the original point when the claim first arose.”

All this comes on the heels of another controversy, variously dubbed “ClimateGate” and “SwiftHack, in which hacked emails suggest some scientists may have sought to conceal data that did not support their climate change views.

This global warming debate is getting curiouser and curiouser.

Rusty Wright is an author and lecturer who has spoken on six continents. He holds Bachelor of Science (psychology) and Master of Theology degrees from Duke and Oxford universities, respectively. www.RustyWright.com

Editors:

Rusty Wright makes his articles and audio/video resources available to editors gratis. All we ask is that you give proper credit, let us know when you post and/or translate our stuff, and link back to RustyWright.com. Click the Topics tab to see what is available.

About

Rusty Wright is an award-winning author, lecturer and syndicated columnist who has spoken on six continents. His audiences have included academic, business and government leaders and university students. He has appeared on television talk shows in cities around the world, and also trains professionals in effective communication.

Subscribe

Want to be kept abreast of future releases? Every month or so when we post new articles, we notify Internet editors of their availability via short emails. Just let us know and we’ll send you these email alerts. We send them blind to protect your privacy, and only to those requesting them.