Being curious I did a census search for a Paddleford in Harpursville NY. I came up with a Charles in Broome NY, 16.7 miles away. He was 26 in 1910. One possibility...http://2.bp.blogspot.com/-ofsAN0QJkwA/TayMA-k8s5I/AAAAAAAAHps/ql_TLQit_-0/s1600/paddleford.jpg