Severe Weather

Bulger: Government must honor alleged immunity deal

The FBI had offered a $2,000,000 reward for information leading directly to the arrest of James J. Bulger.

BOSTON -

Federal prosecutors are again saying that reputed Boston gangster James "Whitey" Bulger's claim he had immunity from federal prosecution in exchange for cooperating with the government is "absurd."

Prosecutors responded in a brief filed Tuesday to one the day before by Bulger's attorneys that said he should be able to present evidence about the alleged deal during his trial over his role in 19 killings.

The prosecution said they have nothing to support the claim and Bulger also hasn't provided any proof. They say it would be a waste of time to bring it up at trial.

The 83-year-old Bulger, who is allegedly a former FBI informant, is accused of committing his crimes in the 1970s and 1980s, when he ran the Winter Hill Gang. He fled Boston in 1994 and was captured in California in 2011.

THIS IS A BREAKING NEWS UPDATE. Check back soon for further information. AP's earlier story is below.

Reputed Boston gangster James "Whitey" Bulger kept his end of a bargain to cooperate with the government in exchange for immunity from federal prosecution, and now the government should keep theirs, Bulger's attorneys say.

Bulger should be able to present evidence about the alleged deal during his trial over his role in 19 killings, his attorneys argued in papers filed Monday in federal court in Boston.

They said Bulger has never claimed — as prosecutors have said — that he had "a license to kill," only that he can't be prosecuted for federal crimes committed while the deal was in effect. They concede he could be prosecuted by state authorities.

"The defendant did not possess a license to kill but rather an agreement with the Department of Justice," they wrote. "He seeks only that the DOJ honor its promise to refrain from prosecution."

Prosecutors have said Bulger's claim about an immunity deal is baseless.

The 83-year-old Bulger, who is allegedly a former FBI informant, is accused of committing his crimes in the 1970s and 1980s, when he ran the Winter Hill Gang. He fled Boston in 1994 and was captured in California in 2011.

Bulger's deal with the prosecutor, the late Jeremiah O'Sullivan, was valid until O'Sullivan left the U.S. attorney's office in 1989, Bulger attorneys J.W. Carney Jr. and Henry Brennan argued.

"The Department of Justice is therefore barred from prosecuting the defendant for any crimes that occurred prior to 1989," they wrote.

The defense argued that the court can't invalidate the agreement because it has no legal basis to review a federal prosecutor's decision not to prosecute someone.

The defense also said Bulger performed "his duty" throughout the deal but weren't specific about what that duty was and have said Bulger will testify he was never an informant.

In court documents, prosecutors have said 700 pages of FBI reports prove Bulger was an informant. And they've called Bulger's argument that he was free to commit crimes, even though he wasn't an informant, "strange and unsubstantiated."

A message requesting comment was left with a spokeswoman for the U.S. attorney. Prosecutors have until Monday to respond to Bulger's arguments on the immunity claim.

In a separate filing, Bulger's attorneys moved to have a previous judge's rulings on the immunity claim vacated and reconsidered by "a judge of unquestioned neutrality."

The previous judge, U.S. District Judge Richard Stearns, was removed from the case because he worked in the U.S. attorney's office when Bulger says O'Sullivan gave him the immunity deal.

Stearns had barred Bulger from claiming he received immunity for future crimes but requested more information about the alleged deal clearing him for past crimes.

And in a third filing Monday, prosecutors said it would be "unnecessary and ill-advised" to force them to turn over an informant's name, as Bulger has requested.

Bulger's lawyers argue the informant could help discredit a key witness against Bulger, his longtime associate Kevin Weeks, by contradicting Weeks' story that he, Bulger and two other men legitimately won a $14.3 million lottery prize that they split. The informant told an FBI agent the prize was part of a money-laundering scheme.

But prosecutors say the informant's identity is irrelevant to Bulger's case because Bulger isn't charged with any crime related to the winning lottery ticket. They also argue disclosing the name would endanger the informant.

"(Bulger) is charged with killing a number of government informants and, if freed, would undoubtedly seek revenge on anyone who assisted the government in making a case against him," prosecutors wrote.

Copyright 2013 by The Associated Press. All rights reserved. This material may not be published, broadcast, rewritten or redistributed.

Comments

The views expressed are not those of this site, this station or its affiliated companies. By posting your comments you agree to accept our terms of use.

The Obama administration will unveil a major climate change plan Monday aimed at a large reduction in greenhouse gas emissions from the nation's coal-burning power plants, a senior administration official told CNN.