A Regular Commentary on Strategic Affairs from a Leading Commentator and Analyst
2018 book project: Little Europe? Twenty-First Century Strategy for Declining Powers

hms iron duke

Thursday, 13 September 2012

BAE Systems is Selling Britain Down the Euro Drain

Alphen,
Netherlands. 13 September.There is not
much these days on the news that makes me sit up and say, “what”?However, the news that BAE Systems, Britain’s
leading defence contractor, is in talks to “merge” with EADS made me sit bolt
upright.The proposed “merger” is
nothing of the sort. It is a straight forward take-over of BAE Systems by the
French and Germans who will together own 60% of the new company.BAE Systems say the imperative is purely business,
driven by the massive cuts to the UK defence budget that the British government
has foisted on the armed forces.For the
French and Germans the imperative is purely strategic; to make the costs of any
future British departure from the EU exorbitantly high and effectively kill at
birth any hope of an alternative defence Anglosphere.

A few
years ago I would have fully supported such a move.In November 2010 Britain joined France at the
heart of efforts to better integrate the European defence effort.Falling defence orders and defence cuts were
driving up the costs of defence production and with it the cost to the taxpayer
of each piece of military kit.Moreover,
with Britain, France and Germany representing 88% of all defence-technological
research in Europe merging the efforts of Europe’s prime contractors made for some
strategic logic.

And
then came the Eurozone crisis which has changed all Europe’s strategic and
political relationships and shifted Britain from being one of Europe’s big
powers to a high-paying, low benefit peripheral irrelevance.This deal will only make a bad situation worse.BAE Systems is not any old company.

Therefore,
if PR-Meister Cameron has any political and strategic nous at all (and I am really
beginning to wonder) he would understand that London needs as much strategic
room for manoeuvre as possible.This is particularly important in the defence realm which for all the
damage done by the accountants remains about the only ‘strategic’ card London
can play in the re-ordering of European power that is taking place.

And
yet, the very day European Commission President Manuel Barroso calls for more
treaty changes and a federation of European states BAE Systems announces that
it is seeking to tie Britain into a political Europe that Britain and the
British people want no part of.The
political implications of this move will not have been lost on Paris and
Berlin.

Furthermore,
BAE Systems has spent years making itself a player in the dominant US market.Not only would such a merger raise profound
questions about BAE Systems access to US contracts, be it as a prime contractor
or as a partner, the EADS takeover will raise serious doubts in the American
mind as to whether Britain can any longer be trusted with sensitive
defence-technological information.

London
is making much about guarantees and ‘golden shares’ but in reality when the
takeover is complete Britain will find the defence-industrial tail wagging
the defence-strategic dog. The usual meally-mouthed nonsense has of course been uttered about protecting the
national interest.A spokesman (who are
these people?) said, “Given the nature of the companies’ activities we would of
course want to ensure that the UK’s public interest was properly protected”.And yet the Government feels unable to veto
this deal as it is purely of a business nature. It is not!

This is
simply another example of an incompetent government that does not understand
the strategic implications of its own weakness sacrificing the strategic
long-term for the balance-sheet short-term.Can you imagine a French or German government being as supine?Absolutely not!

By
all means deepen defence collaboration BETWEEN BAE Systems and EADS and indeed between
Britain, France and Germany, as there is a long and by and large successful
history of such joint ventures.However,
to permit Britain’s one true defence prime contractor to be effectively taken
over by a company that operates under the edict of two foreign governments who
have shown themselves to be less than friendly to Britain of late is utter
folly.Two governments who are
spearheading a political venture that is increasingly at odds with Britain’s
strategic interest.When will British governments
realise that the job is not to keep foreigners happy, but to stand up for the
British people and their strategic interests?

London
has led Britain into the worse of all Euro-worlds.The relationship between costs and benefit of
EU membership for Britain is already so distorted as to render Brussels an
appalling tax on British jobs and society.Britain gets nothing from the EU; it is about to get even less.

BAE
Systems is selling Britain down the Euro Drain.The British Government is letting it happen.This is a strategic error of the first
magnitude - the wrong decision at the wrong time.Why am I not surprised?

About Me

Julian Lindley-French is Senior Fellow of the Institute of Statecraft, Director of Europa Analytica & Distinguished Visiting Research Fellow, National Defense University, Washington DC. An internationally-recognised strategic analyst, advisor and author he was formerly Eisenhower Professor of Defence Strategy at the Netherlands Defence Academy,and Special Professor of Strategic Studies at the University of Leiden. He is a Fellow of Respublica in London, and a member of the Strategic Advisory Group of the Atlantic Council of the United States in Washington.
Latest books: The Oxford Handbook on War 2014 (Paperback) (2014; 709 pages). (Oxford: Oxford University Press) & "Little Britain? Twenty-First Strategy for a Middling European Power". (www.amazon.com)
The Friendly-Clinch Health Warning: The views contained herein are entirely my own and do not necessarily reflect those of any institution.