If this is your first visit, be sure to
check out the FAQ by clicking the
link above. You may have to register
before you can post: click the register link above to proceed. To start viewing messages,
select the forum that you want to visit from the selection below.

Re: New York Yankees 2012-2013 Offseason Outlook

he likes the west coast... in fact, he still lives in cali during the off-season

the only reason he came to NY was because no one was offering him a decent deal, and cashman was aggressive... but this winter, it's a different story - he actually has choices, and lots of teams are at his beckon call

all i'm saying is don't be shocked if he signs with someone else in a few weeks and we're left scrambling to fill out the rotation

Re: New York Yankees 2012-2013 Offseason Outlook

Oh, I won't be shocked if he does. I just think he will be back in NY. I think he knows his best chance at a ring is to stay here. He's smart enough to realize how stupid flukey it was for our offense to go flaccid like that.

Re: New York Yankees 2012-2013 Offseason Outlook

Originally Posted by flymick24

apparently the angels are in on kuroda now

the more teams get involved, the more likely i think it is that he leaves

You've been beating this drum for a while now but I don't see any other team besides the Dodgers giving us a run. Teams have always been interested in Kuroda but he's turned down deals to stay where he's at before. A lot of teams are going to be interested but I doubt he has interest besides us and LA (Japan notwithstanding).

Re: New York Yankees 2012-2013 Offseason Outlook

Originally Posted by ElDandy

You've been beating this drum for a while now but I don't see any other team besides the Dodgers giving us a run. Teams have always been interested in Kuroda but he's turned down deals to stay where he's at before. A lot of teams are going to be interested but I doubt he has interest besides us and LA (Japan notwithstanding).

yes, exactly, both LA teams now are now legitimate landing spots for kuroda... last year, neither team even made him an offer

Re: New York Yankees 2012-2013 Offseason Outlook

Originally Posted by dont_ya_know24

again i didn't include incentives. pettitte had a base of 2.5 last year with incentives. i don't think he's expecting a lot, he wants to pitch.
rivera is rivera, but he was out all year since may, coming off major surgery, in his 40s. a base of 5 mil shouldn't insult him. with those circumstances, that's what he's worth (again not including incentives) it's in his power to realize the incentive salary.

yeah, they gotta give up some to land someone like stanton. it would probably start with mason williams, sanchez, and then some.

Pettitte had a low base last year because he decided to come back after being a spring training instructor. The following is from a NY Times article on his signing last year:

Pettitte emphasized that he did not retire before last season because he no longer thought he could perform. He said he did so because his desire to be with his family outweighed his desire to pitch. In December, though, he began entertaining thoughts of playing, especially, he said, after hearing of an interview in which Cashman indicated he would welcome him back.

However, at the time Cashman had not signed the veteran free agent Hiroki Kuroda or traded for the talented Michael Pineda. When Cashman and Pettitte talked in December about a possible return, Pettitte expressed interest but stopped short of a commitment, even though Cashman was willing to sign him to a $10 million to $12 million deal. After the Yankees acquired Kuroda and Pineda, Pettitte shut down his workouts, but unbeknownst to Cashman, only briefly.

If Cashman was willing to offer him $10 to $12M last season after he had been out for a year, I find it unlikely that Pettitte is going to accept an offer of $5M to come back in 2013 unless he makes the decision VERY, VERY, VERY late in the off-season.

Re: New York Yankees 2012-2013 Offseason Outlook

I think we should be willing to trade anyone not named Sanchez for Stanton. I'll happily take the Nolasco contract and let him be an 11 million dollar mop up man.

Funny you should say this statement, since the Marlins now view Nolasco as their #1 starter.

Makes you wonder about the baseball knowledge in the Miami front office if they think a career mid-4 ERA starter can be your #1 in the NL.

As for taking on Nolasco's $11.5M - no problem. His contract is up at the end of next season, so he would not impact 2014. If he does not have a career season that necessitates a qualifying offer, no draft pick would result.

As for Stanton, yes - I am willing to pay for him, but I don't want to overpay. This team HAS to become younger and trading away the farm for just one player does not accomplish that task. We need to keep Sanchez and either Williams or Heathcott at a minimum.

Miami needs a CFer - offer them Granderson and agree to pay 1/2 his contract to start, then add Nova and prospects to get it done.

Re: New York Yankees 2012-2013 Offseason Outlook

Originally Posted by longtimeyankeefan

As for Stanton, yes - I am willing to pay for him, but I don't want to overpay. This team HAS to become younger and trading away the farm for just one player does not accomplish that task. We need to keep Sanchez and either Williams or Heathcott at a minimum.

Miami needs a CFer - offer them Granderson and agree to pay 1/2 his contract to start, then add Nova and prospects to get it done.

Sweet Jesus...you cannot be serious?

Younger!!?! What is Stanton like 22 or 23 years old. Do people understand how good Stanton is, his bat, his glove, his youth, his years of team control. You want Stanton, it starts with names like Profar, Bundy and elite elite prospects. Not Granderson and some junk spare parts.

Re: New York Yankees 2012-2013 Offseason Outlook

Originally Posted by eaganmafia

Sweet Jesus...you cannot be serious?

Younger!!?! What is Stanton like 22 or 23 years old. Do people understand how good Stanton is, his bat, his glove, his youth, his years of team control. You want Stanton, it starts with names like Pofar, Bundy and elite elite prospects. Not Granderson and some junk spare parts.

Re: New York Yankees 2012-2013 Offseason Outlook

Originally Posted by eaganmafia

Sweet Jesus...you cannot be serious?

Younger!!?! What is Stanton like 22 or 23 years old. Do people understand how good Stanton is, his bat, his glove, his youth, his years of team control. You want Stanton, it starts with names like Profar, Bundy and elite elite prospects. Not Granderson and some junk spare parts.

So you want to trade the Rangers and Orioles prospects to get Stanton for the Yankees?

Seriously, I understand your point - yes, it will take some prime prospects, which frankly the Yankees do not have that are ML ready.

Giving them Granderson at $7.5M per year would be a steal for a 40HR CFer. Nova would give them a pitcher equivalent to Nolasco, who really is not that great statistically. Essentially, the Yankees would be paying $19M for Nolasco in 2013 (his $11.5 plus the $7.5 from Granderson's contract).

Then, you begin adding prospects - I want to keep Sanchez for the future and we clearly have other needs. But, giving four of our top 20 prospects, along with Granderson & Nova would be value for value.

Re: New York Yankees 2012-2013 Offseason Outlook

So you want to trade the Rangers and Orioles prospects to get Stanton for the Yankees?

Seriously, I understand your point - yes, it will take some prime prospects, which frankly the Yankees do not have that are ML ready.

Giving them Granderson at $7.5M per year would be a steal for a 40HR CFer. Nova would give them a pitcher equivalent to Nolasco, who really is not that great statistically. Essentially, the Yankees would be paying $19M for Nolasco in 2013 (his $11.5 plus the $7.5 from Granderson's contract).

Then, you begin adding prospects - I want to keep Sanchez for the future and we clearly have other needs. But, giving four of our top 20 prospects, along with Granderson & Nova would be value for value.

I really don't think you understand my point if you think some package built around Granderson (who even at half his contract, the Marlins dont wanna pay) Nova sucks is gonna be expensive in a year or two and if you don't wanna part with Sanchez you have nothing.

This is a 23 year old 5 win player with years of team control. You're not gonna get that for spare parts.

Re: New York Yankees 2012-2013 Offseason Outlook

Funny you should say this statement, since the Marlins now view Nolasco as their #1 starter.

Makes you wonder about the baseball knowledge in the Miami front office if they think a career mid-4 ERA starter can be your #1 in the NL.

As for taking on Nolasco's $11.5M - no problem. His contract is up at the end of next season, so he would not impact 2014. If he does not have a career season that necessitates a qualifying offer, no draft pick would result.

As for Stanton, yes - I am willing to pay for him, but I don't want to overpay. This team HAS to become younger and trading away the farm for just one player does not accomplish that task. We need to keep Sanchez and either Williams or Heathcott at a minimum.

Miami needs a CFer - offer them Granderson and agree to pay 1/2 his contract to start, then add Nova and prospects to get it done.

Nova is still cheap, eats some innings and can probably be flipped later so sure he's got value to the Marlins.

Granderson at $8M could also easily be flipped for prospects so sure that would interest them too.

And dumping Nolacso's salary probably has appeal to them as well.

But you are delusional if you think Stanton can be had for prosepcts less than at least 2 of the ones you named in addition to package you propose.

BTW if the cost for Stanton alone is "just" Williams, Heathcot, Shancez, + Nova, I'd do that today.

Re: New York Yankees 2012-2013 Offseason Outlook

Originally Posted by eaganmafia

I really don't think you understand my point if you think some package built around Granderson (who even at half his contract, the Marlins dont wanna pay) Nova sucks is gonna be expensive in a year or two and if you don't wanna part with Sanchez you have nothing.

This is a 23 year old 5 win player with years of team control. You're not gonna get that for spare parts.

I agree. The trade has to hurt to get back a talent like Stanton. If we can keep Sanchez and develop him into a starting catcher at the MLB level, great. But I think the bigger problem is that when blockbuster deals are available, we just dont have the prospects to make something cool happen.

Re: New York Yankees 2012-2013 Offseason Outlook

Originally Posted by eaganmafia

I really don't think you understand my point if you think some package built around Granderson (who even at half his contract, the Marlins dont wanna pay) Nova sucks is gonna be expensive in a year or two and if you don't wanna part with Sanchez you have nothing.

This is a 23 year old 5 win player with years of teamcontrol. You're not gonna get that for spare parts.

Point taken, but I wonder how valuable team control is for a guy who once he hits arb is going to comp Ryan Howard and cost a ton of money during his team control.

Also, Im not saying the Yankees would or could do it, but this is the same team that traded Cabrera for relatively nothing.

Re: New York Yankees 2012-2013 Offseason Outlook

Cabrera got traded for Maybin and Andrew Miller. They haven't worked out, but both of those guys were bigger prospects at the time of their trade than any player in the Yanks' system now. I think they were both top 10 and Cabrera was already in arbitration which Stanton, I believe, has another year before he starts. I don't think they will trade Stanton this offseason and even if they did, I don't think the Yankees have the talent to make it happen. Stanton is one of the 3 or 4 most valuable players (Trout, Harper, Mccutchen, can't think of anyone else).

If Cashman was willing to offer him $10 to $12M last season after he had been out for a year, I find it unlikely that Pettitte is going to accept an offer of $5M to come back in 2013 unless he makes the decision VERY, VERY, VERY late in the off-season.

i dont know why this is so unbelievable. he made 12 starts last year. zero the year before and 21 the year before that.

sure, he's andy pettitte, but the man does not deserve 10 million dollars.

“I really thought I played great defense when the ball wasn't hit at me,” Alex Rodriguez said.

Re: New York Yankees 2012-2013 Offseason Outlook

Originally Posted by eaganmafia

Sweet Jesus...you cannot be serious?

Younger!!?! What is Stanton like 22 or 23 years old. Do people understand how good Stanton is, his bat, his glove, his youth, his years of team control. You want Stanton, it starts with names like Profar, Bundy and elite elite prospects. Not Granderson and some junk spare parts.

I want to copy and paste this post everytime I see fantasy trade proposals and just switch out Stanton for player whatever. Well said.

Re: New York Yankees 2012-2013 Offseason Outlook

I think there were legitimate reasons to avoid Cespedes. He's exceeded most expectations so it's hard to fault the team for not predicting that. Couldn't hazard a guess as to why they weren't more interested in CHapman. Darvish is the real bothersome one, though, for me. He would solve a lot of problems if he were under contract for another 5 years at an AAV of 9 million for the team. What's annoying is that his performance thus far seems like it was the most common expectation and the Yankees scouted him for years. The posting system favors the Yankees so either it was a scouting failure or, more worrisome, a short sighted front office/business decision.