In honor of their awesome new HGTV show Brother Vs. Brother, we challenged them to a series of tasks, both physical and mental. First up? Like all of America’s favorite competitions, we tested the guys on their singing abilities. Find out which guy would be going to Hollywood if they tried out for American Idol.

Brother Vs. Brother airs Sunday night at 10 p.m. ET on HGTV. For more fun from Drew and Jonathan follow them on Twitter @MrDrewScott and @MrSilverScott.

Are you #TeamDrew or #TeamJonathan? Have you been watching Brother Vs. Brother every week? Who do you think won the singing competition? Tell us all your thoughts in the comments below or on Twitter @OKMagazine.