Yeah, in the ad, it looks kinda strange. I liked the Superman Returns suit, apart from the size of the \S/ and the shade of blue used. If there was to be a standalone JL franchise that costume would've looked great next the Arkham Batman suit.

Yeah, that's what I don't get about all the "I wanted to see Routh back" people. He really looked like he just had no clue what he was doing in that movie. He was just so... blank. Some people will try and tell you it was subtlety, but if you think that was an example of good subtle acting, then you probably also think Channing Tatum deserves an Oscar for all his blank-faced performances.

It's a subjective thing, but I hate the Returns suit. A lot of the problems are related to Routh's physique and his structure (long torso, narrow shoulders), but the design choices greatly exacerbate those problems. That milk ad is a perfect example. He looks bottom heavy like a woman. You don't seen the iconic V-shape associated with a strong, well-built man like Superman. One of the issues is the cape attachment. Because it is narrow and connects at the neck, the overall shoulder/chest area seems smaller. Similarly, the low-rise trunks further elongate Routh's torso. The longer the torso, the narrower a guy looks. Also, the small chest symbol - makes the upper body look smaller. Overall, the suit just makes Superman look less masculine and powerful. SO I think there is good reason for people to hate the suit.

Yeah, that's what I don't get about all the "I wanted to see Routh back" people. He really looked like he just had no clue what he was doing in that movie. He was just so... blank. Some people will try and tell you it was subtlety, but if you think that was an example of good subtle acting, then you probably also think Channing Tatum deserves an Oscar for all his blank-faced performances.

Channing Tatum was at least great in 21 Jump Street, I haven't see one performance of Routh's in which I thought that he was anything but bad or verging on bad.

He was bad on Chuck

He was terrible in Dylan Dog

He was bad on a Fear itself episode

His performances in bit roles haven't been good either.

His best performance was in Superman Returns and that's probably because Singer is good at directing actors but that still is not a good performance in the slightest.

I hate to take us back to 2006 and re-litigate things but I just do not understand how anybody likes him as an actor. I am so happy that he is gone. I'm not saying that Cavill is Deniro or anything but I thought he was 1000 percent better than Routh in the few things I've seen him in.

Channing Tatum was at least great in 21 Jump Street, I haven't see one performance of Routh's in which I thought that he was anything but bad or verging on bad.

He was bad on Chuck

He was terrible in Dylan Dog

He was bad on a Fear itself episode

His performances in bit roles haven't been good either.

His best performance was in Superman Returns and that's probably because Singer is good at directing actors but that still is not a good performance in the slightest.

I hate to take us back to 2006 and re-litigate things but I just do not understand how anybody likes him as an actor. I am so happy that he is gone. I'm not saying that Cavill is Deniro or anything but I thought he was 1000 percent better than Routh in the few things I've seen him in.

Now I'm going to jump back into 2012...

Yeah, I don't get it either. I think Bryan Singer was out of his mind when he cast the role. I think he was so hung up on the whole "WOW THIS GUY LOOKS JUST LIKE CHRISTOPHER REEVE" thing that he would have cast him no matter what. I mean, I think he actually admitted that he decided on casting him just because when he met him, Routh spilled coffee on himself. I know Singer had seen his screen test, but you would think he would have wanted to have Routh read for him at least once before handing him the keys to the franchise. Bizarre.

Anyway, yeah, Cavill is a much better actor. Though I'm kinda hoping Cold Light of Day gets swept under the rug because it really doesn't look very good.

The part towards the end of SR, when Supes visits Jason's room where he is sleeping and says the line - "Son becomes the father.." is done very well by Routh (IMO.) I have a hard time imagining that even Chris Reeve could have done it better.

Now, just to ask those posters who just cannot give up their complaints against Routh as Superman, I have to ask this question- Could someone else in place of Routh done better (with all other elements remaining same.) for example could Tom Welling / Sam Worthington / Matthew Goode been a better Superman i place of Brandon Routh ?

Both Cavill and Routh are pretty ****** actors. Routh was fine as Supes. So will Cavill.

At least Cavill didn't get fired from a soap for bad acting, unlike BJ. Seriously, Im not yet sold on Cavill, but he's Jack Nicholson compared to Routh in the acting department. And Routh was anything but fine as Supes. What with no charisma, screen presence or charm, for starters. Cavill wouldn't have to work hard to surpass him by a country mile.

And I agree with LibidoLoca, this isn't a Routh/Cavill topic. In fact it would be nice to not bring up Routh at all (for his fans and non fans alike) in this forum. Past is the past.

According to the verified Warner Brothers Japan Twitter account and Walkerplus, a Japanese magazine and news outlet, the official promo tour of the most anticipated movie of this year, Man of Steel will begin next week. The first stop on the three-month tour will be Japan, which the new Superman, Henry Cavill will visit March 27-28.