I was pretty much in agreement with your least played choices until I came to 'Love Tried to Welcome Me'! Definitely give that some more spins, it cuts me deep every time.

'Paradise' and 'Easy Ride' are both two of my faves from the respective albums; 'Like It or Not' is also really underrated but I know most people rank that low on the album and that the album is practically perfect from start to finish anyway.

Yes for 'Deeper & Deeper' and 'Devil' getting most played though!

Unfortunately I have no way of tracking my most and least played, but I could post a list of my faves and least faves and that would probably be a similar list.