2012-13: Witzel pitched 76 innings in 25 appearences for the Cobras. He started in 16 of those games collecting a record of 7-6 with an ERA of 4.86 while striking out 45 batters. Witzel was named second team All-Conference and was honored as the Conference Carolinas player of the week on 2/26/13.

2011-12: Witzel made 18 appearnaces in 2012, starting 13 games and posting a record of 4-4. He finished the year with a 3.87 ERA in 83.2 innings on the mound. He led the team in strikeouts with 58 and was second in ERA.

2010-11: Witzel played and started in 39 games for Coker, while hitting a team best .279 (36-for-129). He also had 13 appearances from the mound starting 11 games with a 6-4 record. Witzel posted a 2.79 ERA in 84 innings. Tyler struck out 63 hitters, while opposing teams hit just .236 against him.

2009- 10: Witzel made 17 appearances during the season, including four starts. Posted a 4-3 record with a 6.42 ERA in 54.2 innings. Struck out 29 hitters and pitched one complete game.

High School: A standout three-sport athlete in baseball, football and wrestling at Melbourne High School, Witzel earnd Second Team All-Conference honors in baseball. He played AAU ball for the Florida Stars and the Brevard Aces.