If this is your first visit, be sure to
check out the FAQ by clicking the
link above. You may have to register
before you can post: click the register link above to proceed. To start viewing messages,
select the forum that you want to visit from the selection below.

Re: Shingeki no Kyojin 39 Spoiler Thread

Assuming what is happening in pages 20-22 is a flashback to when the titans attacked his village and their attempts to escape as it appears, this chapter should put to rest the Reiner/Bertholdt as the titans that attacked the wall speculation as it fills in the biggest question mark in their story.

Re: Shingeki no Kyojin 39 Spoiler Thread

Chapter is focused on the guys at uthgar castle. From what is being shown the theory on ymir and the 2 guys being giants themselves are looking pretty wobbly. But why are they so fixed on getting back to their hometown? It brings the possibility that they are not the people of inside the wall. probably from outside and the outside and inside wall faction are the ones at war. Maybe the royalties and the nobles are really the bad guys and those outside are trying to get in to confront them. But even tho reiner and ymir and co might not be titans themselves they might know a lot more than they're willing to tell

Re: Shingeki no Kyojin 39 Discussion / 40 Predictions

I don't think this chapter has done anything in regards to any Ymir theories. There is no inherent requirement for her to be able to transform into a titan to have some connection to the titans (depending on the source of these titans, there are a number of explanations as to why they are attacking her), nor has this chapter really done anything to say she cannot turn into a titan. If she can and wants to hide it, she'll wait until she does not have any options left and she isn't there yet. (You could also possibly question her super-human strength on page 33)

Re: Shingeki no Kyojin 39 Discussion / 40 Predictions

There's too much inconsistency on the consipracy theory that Reiner is the armored titan.
I think it makes sense only if Reiner doesn't aware of his power.
He really thought he's going to die when the titan broke in,
this should be enough to show that Reiner is not aware of his power,if any,otherwise i think we can just end.of.topic and blame the author.

I don't think this chapter has done anything in regards to any Ymir theories. There is no inherent requirement for her to be able to transform into a titan to have some connection to the titans (depending on the source of these titans, there are a number of explanations as to why they are attacking her), nor has this chapter really done anything to say she cannot turn into a titan. If she can and wants to hide it, she'll wait until she does not have any options left and she isn't there yet. (You could also possibly question her super-human strength on page 33)

i think it's pretty clear that the ape titan toys not only the Scouting Legion but also those regular titans
but it's indeed interesting to think that the ape titan wasn't just pass by and he came here for Christa,Ymir or any other purpose.

Re: Shingeki no Kyojin 39 Discussion / 40 Predictions

Originally Posted by lolnameless

There's too much inconsistency on the consipracy theory that Reiner is the armored titan.
I think it makes sense only if Reiner doesn't aware of his power.
He really thought he's going to die when the titan broke in,
this should be enough to show that Reiner is not aware of his power,if any,otherwise i think we can just end.of.topic and blame the author.

Oh, you could come up with some explanations that allow him to be a human/titan that are consistent with his actions in the chapter. (As I mentioned, the flashback is the deathblow) If he was told that he has to maintain his cover and cannot transform under any circumstances, his thoughts that he was going to die are reasonable. Hell, you could explain his desire to jump out of the building as an attempt to give him the space to at least partially transform without others seeing him.

Now, I'm not sure that I would be happy with those as explanations, but they are possible.

Originally Posted by lolnameless

---------- Post added at 04:02 PM ---------- Previous post was at 03:36 PM ----------
i think it's pretty clear that the ape titan toys not only the Scouting Legion but also those regular titans
but it's indeed interesting to think that the ape titan wasn't just pass by and he came here for Christa,Ymir or any other purpose.

That would require the Ape Titan to have knowledge that the trainees were going to be detained on suspicion that one of them was an ally of Annie, him cross the wall and bring/create titans to cause a ruckus and somehow know that unequipped trainees would be dragged with the rest of the scouting legion to find the hole, then find them. That seems unreasonable.

Re: Shingeki no Kyojin 39 Discussion / 40 Predictions

Ape titan could be trying to find out about something or trying to goad the other titan party so that something might happen. If not i cant understand what hes doing out there. Why throw rocks? he could climb that tower and smash them. Clearly hes trying to provoke some kind of response.

Tho 1 thing that annoys me is that we have to wait a month for the next chapter revelation and this chapter tho action packed but i dont know if its weekly publish then its okay but its monthly i feel like its punishing @_@

Re: Shingeki no Kyojin 39 Discussion / 40 Predictions

Fuck, i really like that theory. haha. But still has a chance, i think...
Those guys from scouting legion dying, was so coward. They were fighting so well and suddenly a giant piece of rock come flying and hit them, with no chance of scape, it'so unfair D:.
The scene of Ryner putting the titan on his back was awesome.
Next chapter, Eren and the team must arrive at the castle, otherwise...