SEASON 1: ALEX MICHEL & AMANDA MARSH

Michel, who picked Marsh over Trista Rehn (now Trista Sutter) regretted his decision. "Basically he told me that he thought he had made a mistake," Rehn told TV Guide in 2003. "He'll probably deny that he said [that he'd made a mistake]." When Marsh learned of the hush relationship, she dumped him.