Electronic dog training collars; facts and fanciful fiction

You are here:Home>Electronic dog training collars; facts and fanciful fiction

Not a Tool for Fools

Wales moves to ban electronic dog training collars in a swift albeit short-sighted move last week; making their use punishable by fine of up to 20 thousand pounds or 6 months in prison.

I would make the ‘pound’ symbol, but I am a computer dolt and I can’t.

But anyway…

In one perversely broad stroke, Wales has transcended the absurd and banned the tool itself. All thirty thousand of the units currently speculated to be in circulation in that country at this time are now illegal to own and/or use.

It appears that the Assembly committed to a ban as far back as 2006 despite the call for research by an overview committee prior to any final decision.

Germany had already enacted ecollar legislation limiting their sale and use, based on the findings of research conducted between 2003 and 2007.

Additional information on related legislation throughout Europe is found here.

Of the two studies conducted in 2003 and 2007 which peremptorily facilitated the ban, they are humorously broken down here by Ruth Crisler over at SpotCheck.

Anyone with any degree of comprehension would soon discover that these two ‘studies’ are not science.

By 2008 however, it appears that Wales had already made a decision and simply waited for enough ground support to pass it through their parliamentary procedures, even as another study was underway in Muenster and Hannover Germany, which revealed strikingly different results.

Hey, thanks for the shout-out. And I’m glad you linked to the recent Hannover study. It’s really in a whole different league in terms of credibility. And it’s more than ten times the length of either of the studies I was having fun dissecting. I read it last year and have been thinking about writing a review.

I was impressed with it’s length also, and it’s findings; which the Schalke study alluded to but never fleshed out, since it was contraindicated in their ultimate goal. Howevah… I can’t WAIT to finish the first piece about the genesis of tools. I have been working on it (it seems like) forEVER and it’s time to let that puppy fly. I was particularly fond of the discovery from the UK’s K9 Magazine taking the KC to task. Either way, I think blog land is gonna get real interesting pretty soon.

I’m sure that those who’ve already made up their minds will look at that thesis and say that the “quitting signal” wasn’t taught well enough. But at least they’ll be introduced to what experimental design is.

All I can say is that I don’t want to be an innocent citizen in a municipality where police dogs are taught to “Out” by a “quitting signal”.

Good point. Neither do I. But those that argue against balanced training don’t seem especially interested in training police dog stock. As I recall, part of the conclusion of the Schilder study was the recommendation that these dogs be bred for less drive, because that would allow for gentler methods.

It’s all about serving the methodology, very little more in my opinion.

Oh wow, I saw one of those years ago on a Great Dane while I was working at a pet supply store. Didn’t have any idea of what to even call the thing. I was not impressed with the design…it’s basically a glorified Alaskan-style limited slip collar with a HANDLE on it.

Indeed, it’s all about the methodology. And about the serious competition to be the “next best thing”.
I find it rather disturbing that they try so desperately to pound every animal on the planet into the same mold. That wonderful paradigm that it’s good for dogs because “I SAID so”!

Trackbacks/Pingbacks

Under pressure; a new look at an old adversary | The Stone Soup Diaries -
November 16, 2010

[…] use is the cause of moral and ethical dilemmas across the globe, with countries banning or attempting to ban their sale, people in violent opposition of their use for any reason and the pseudo-science that had sprung up […]

Leave a Reply

Upcoming Seminars and Workshops

We ARE the solution to your dog’s problems!

If you have a dog that's giving you fits because he runs away, pulls you on walks, ignores you or is just getting too hard to control, we are committed to helping you accomplish your goals of a well-trained companion that you can enjoy and be proud of, anywhere! Guaranteed!

Give us a call at 410-857-0555 for additional information!

Located in Westminster, Maryland, we are conveniently located near, and offer reliable, results based dog training in Maryland, DC, Delaware, Virginia and Pennsylvania.

Delaware Dog Training Coverage by County

Lionheart K9 offers pick-up service for a fee to our Delaware dog training and puppy training customers in the following counties and surrounding areas:
Delaware Dog Training Coverage by County
New Castle
Kent
Sussex