Taxing Petrol And Diesel

21 Feb 2018

Key Point

Under the polluter pays principle, tax rates on diesel and petrol fuels should be at a rate which is commensurate with the total environmental costs they incur. This suggests that the excise differential between the two fuels in favour of diesel should be unwound gradually.

Taxing Petrol and Diesel

The OECD has published its most recent environmental taxes data in ‘Taxing Energy Use 2018’. The effective tax rates for gasoline and diesel are shown in table 2 for the OECD 35 countries1. The countries are also ranked from highest to lowest respective of the price per tonne of carbon dioxide (EUR per t/CO2).

Taxing Petrol

Ireland has an effective tax rate on gasoline (petrol) of €260.2 per tonne of CO2, which is 13% above the OECD 35 average (€230.3). Ireland has the sixteenth highest effective tax rate on petrol in the OECD. The three highest tax rates on gasoline are found in United Kingdom (€353.4), the Netherlands (€339.2) and Turkey (€337.6). Ireland’s tax on gasoline for road use is almost fourteen times higher than that of the United States which is ranked as the lowest in the OECD 35.

Taxing Diesel

Ireland’s effective tax rate on diesel is €180.0 per tonne of CO2. This is 17% above the OECD average of €154.1 (less New Zealand). Ireland has the eleventh highest tax on diesel in the OECD. The three highest effective tax rates are found in the United Kingdom (€299.9), Switzerland (€267.1), and Israel (€251.1). New Zealand has the lowest effective tax rate on diesel in the OECD at €1.3 per tonne of CO2.

Tax Differential – Petrol and Diesel

The difference in the effective tax rates for petrol and diesel reflects the energy and environmental policies in place in various countries. Across the OECD, petrol is taxed on average 49% higher than diesel . Ireland’s average effective tax rate on petrol is 45% more than diesel2.

The OECD finds:

“At the current state of equipment and technology, diesel usually emits higher levels of harmful air pollutants per litre than gasoline, and also the carbon content of diesel per litre is higher. This suggests that on environmental grounds diesel should be taxed at rates which are at least as high as those of gasoline” (OECD, (2018: 39), ‘Taxing Energy Use 2018’).

Only two countries, the United States and Mexico, have higher effective tax rates on diesel relative to petrol. In 2015, the United Kingdom had the third lowest tax differential on petrol and diesel in the OECD at 18%, preceded by Switzerland (14%) and Iceland (5%).

Emissions and Consumers

Since 2008 – when taxes on vehicles were changed to reflect CO2 emissions – Irish consumers have increasingly sought to purchase diesel vehicles, which have lower taxation rates than petrol equivalents. The tax system has been effective in encouraging consumers to purchase new low-carbon cars. The average emissions of new cars purchased in 2017 was 112.7 g CO2 /km3 . This is a reduction of one-third relative to the level in 2007. However, diesel vehicles have higher emissions of air pollutants, fine particulate matter, and nitrogen oxides.

As of data up to 2016, Ireland continues to have the highest percentage (70%) of diesel vehicles in the new passenger car fleet in the EU4 . Vehicle licensing figures show that this share decreased to 65 per cent in 2017 among new private cars. Table 1 shows that the number of private licensed diesel cars remained unchanged in 2017 relative to 2016, while electric vehicles (EVs) increased by 80%, from 608 to 1,092.

The number of EVs has increased three-fold in three years. Hybrid licenses also increased to 7,392 – a significant increase of 78% on the previous year.

European Context and Budgetary Changes

A comparison of EU excise tax rates in July 2017 showed that Ireland had the 7th highest rate of excise duty on diesel in the EU28 at €479.02 per 1,000 litres. Changes to the taxation of cars from 2008 onwards resulted in a dramatic shift in consumer purchases in favour of diesel cars over petrol. The rate of excise on petrol is €58.7c, including 4.6c carbon charge per litre, while the excise on a litre of diesel is €47.9c, including 5.3c carbon charge. This is a differential of 23 per cent. The last increase in excise on motor fuels was applied in Budget 2012. The UK has no excise differential on petrol and diesel. The excise differential in favour of diesel arguably does not capture the negative externalities associated with this fuel type.

The Tax Strategy Group (TSG) papers for Budget 2018 outlined a pathway towards the gradual equalisation of excise duty for petrol and diesel by 2022. Equalising the excise rates over a 5 year period would yield, on average, an additional €67.4m (VAT Exclusive) per annum by 2022. A straight-forward increase in diesel excise of 10 cent would yield €251 million. Cross-border price comparisons from September 2017 show that auto diesel was 12 cent cheaper to purchase in Ireland relative to Northern Ireland5 . Total taxes and duties on diesel were also 17 cent lower than in Northern Ireland. These cross border price dynamics need to be considered in the context of any changes to excise duties.

Conclusion

Under the polluter pays principle, tax rates on diesel and petrol fuels should be at a rate which is commensurate with the total environmental costs they incur. This suggests that the excise differential between the two fuels in favour of diesel should be unwound gradually.

Table 2 – Petrol and Diesel, EUR per tonne CO2 (2015)

_______________________

Notes:

1 Latvia became a member on 1 July 2016

2 As petrol is taxed at such a higher rate (more than 100 times) than diesel in New Zealand relative to the rest of the OECD, it is excluded from the calculation of this average.

3 From 2020 onwards, EU Regulation 433/2014 sets a target of 95 g CO2 /km for the average emissions of the new car fleet (SEAI).

2 Comments

Vincent23 Feb 2018 at 3:23 pm

The polluter pays was set up to cover gigantic power plants and chemical companies not as a means to screw over the poorest citizens. Which in this case means those outside areas without public transport.

Tony Owens23 Feb 2018 at 4:11 pm

The proposed principles for taxation of road fuels seem sensible. There are three problems:
1. Taxation is not determined according to objective shared principles, least of all in Ireland. Water use taxation and property taxation are typical examples. Fuel tax will continue to be framed with no regard to principle and be focused on what can be extracted without political fallout.
2. Diesel use and environmental harm is a complex issue, despite the simplistic shouty media noise that has appeared post Dieselgate. Technically-speaking, diesel emissions compare favourably with gasoline emissions, per km, in most EU6 engines i.e those homologated post 2014. While NOx emission limits are slightly higher for diesel, CO2 production is significantly lower due to superior efficiency. Actual NOx outputs are very similar in both technologies as determined by ADAC in lab testing specifically designed to reflect ‘real world’ use cases.
3. Road vehicle fuel use is responsible for only ~20% of CO2 emission. HGV’s produce 5% or CO2. Yet there is no viable alternative to diesel technology for HGV’s and offroad and agricultural machinery. The technically illiterate flak being produced by ESRI and others intended to underpin policy change discriminating against diesel vehicle use will inflate cost of living with little real improvement in air quality in cities.
Perhaps the correct policy here is to penalise vehicles which emit more than EU6 mandated emission levels, encouraging the fitment of particle filters to EU3 diesels of which there are many still in use, which drawing attention to the environmental externalities of Irish utility power generation.