If this is your first visit, be sure to
check out the FAQ by clicking the
link above. You may have to register
before you can post: click the register link above to proceed. To start viewing messages,
select the forum that you want to visit from the selection below.

Steelers Notebook: Decision on Porter must be made soon

i hope they keep porter for at least this year......... and for starks, it looks like he's staying, he isn't worth giving up a second or first round pick, they might as well give him the 1.8 tender, what's 500g more?? lol

Friday, February 23, 2007
By Ed Bouchette, Pittsburgh Post-Gazette

INDIANAPOLIS -- Free agency starts a week from today and the Steelers still have not made their intentions known about linebacker Joey Porter.

Coach Mike Tomlin said yesterday he has talked to Porter but gave little indication what plans he may have for him.

Porter, who turns 30 March 22, is due a $1 million roster bonus March 6 and a $4 million salary next season, his last under contract. He threatened to hold out for a new contract last training camp until then-coach Bill Cowher convinced him not to.

Porter had a subpar season for him in 2006 after making the Pro Bowl in three of the previous four seasons. He has been their starting right outside linebacker since 2000 and moved into third place on their career list with 60 sacks, seven of them last season.

Porter, one of the defensive co-captains, would become an unrestricted free agent immediately if the Steelers do not pay him the bonus by March 6.

Tomlin said yesterday at the National Scouting Combine that he has talked to Porter, but when he was asked yesterday if Porter would be back with the Steelers for 2007, he deferred.

"I have no thoughts on that regard," Tomlin said. "I talked to Joey just like I talk to every other player. He's under contract. He's a Pittsburgh Steeler."

That fell far short of any warm endorsement for a player of Porter's status, and it might be that the new coach will bring some cold, hard decisions to a team and its players, who won a Super Bowl a little more than one year ago. Kevin Colbert, the director of football operations, has said he welcomes Tomlin's objective opinions of players for whom others in the organization might have stronger emotional feelings based on what they've done in the past.

After the season, Porter was asked if he felt he would be with the Steelers in 2007.

"At the end of the day it's going to be up to the organization," said Porter. "I am here. This is home for me. But it is a business, and just like everybody else I want to make sure I make the right business move for my family. I would love to finish my career here. I am going to just sit back and wait."

Tight on salary cap
The Steelers squeezed under the NFL's salary cap when they reported Jeff Hartings retirement and erased his 2007 salary from their books. But they remain tight and must find ways to create even more space if they are to add anyone in free agency or sign some of their own players to long-term deals.

"We're looking at several options and we're going to weigh those in the upcoming days and move forward in that regard," Tomlin said. "But we have several options and we're exploring those."

Starks question
Team officials have not yet decided what kind of one-year salary tender to give tackle Max Starks, who will become a restricted free agent next Friday, their only free agent among their 22 starters.

They will pick from one of two -- a $1.3 million tender or a $1.8 million tender. Either would maintain their right to match any other contract Starks would receive in free agency, but if they decided not to match, the different tenders would provide different compensation to the Steelers. If they tender him a $1.3 million salary, they would receive a second-round draft pick if he signs elsewhere and they don't match; a $1.8 million tender would bring them a first-round draft pick from the team that signs him.

Contracts expire
The Steelers have been talking to the agents for some of their players whose contracts expire next Friday, all of them backups. Among those they'd like to sign is halfback Najeh Davenport.

Intelligence testing
The NFL has issued the Wonderlic test to prospects for years as a way to determine a player's intelligence. It again became a controversial subject when quarterback Vince Young's low test score was revealed publicly last year, incorrectly at first.

"Personally, I've never been a Wonderlic guy," Tomlin said. "That's just me. It doesn't measure football intelligence. You don't know the background, the way guys have prepared for the test and all that. You've got to go based on your interactions with people and what you see on tape.

"The Wonderlic is a form of measurement and it's just one form of measurement. You can't put too much stock into it in my opinion. I think it's a combination of all of the above that you need to use in terms of evaluating a player."

Tomlin said he puts more stock in the Steelers' psychological test that they give each of the prospects.

Contracts expire
The Steelers have been talking to the agents for some of their players whose contracts expire next Friday, all of them backups. Among those they'd like to sign is halfback Najeh Davenport

.

Unlike many on here I'd like to see Najeh come back and let's give him a chance to see what he can do with a full offseason and camp under his belt. Maybe he'll flourish,maybe he won't, but I think he's got a shot.

The Wonderlich test is so overrated, I don't know why they bother using it anymore

Bring back Porter, the dude needs to come back and finish his career as a Steeler. Everybody keeps saying he had a sub par year in 2006...The entire DAMN TEAM had a sub par year. Even if Porter doesn't finish with double digit sacks everybody said he sucked that year, the guy does alot more than just get sacks, all our LB's do.

If Im the Steelers I definitely tender max the 1.8 million offer, that's a no brainer if you ask me. We're thin at Tackle since Essex and Colon have barely a handful of starts and actual game experience between them. Bring back Max without breaking the bank and let him fight it out with Colon for the starting job.

I just hope we can get some contracts restructured to free up some cap space and go splashing in the FA market.

Well here is the thing House of course Joey and Max will be back and I agree with you. But if not who in the hell is going to replace them? The Steelers don't have alot of depth our experience at OT or OLB. So its not even a question to bring both back.

As for Dookie? I'm not a big Davenport fan he is ok and he would be good for depth. But even if he is resigned the Steelers better look to draft a RB. I wouldn't be to confident with Dookie being the starter if Willie went down with a long term injury.

If James harrison could stay healthy we'd wouldn't have such an immediate need. Even so we'd still want to draft a LB/DE this year, and more than 1 for future help, but with Haggans not playing well and both Harrisons injured more than we'd like we have no choice but to look early and often for DE/LB help.