Yes but that discussion is happening else where but thanks for the input.

You asked for reasonable thoughts and got one. Unreasonable would be adding another small winger as its literally the last thing they need.

As far as value i think you're coming up short from the Leafs offering. I don't think Colborne holds much value and neither does MacArthur not just because he's a pending UFA but since his preseason suspension last year he's taken the "once bitten twice shy" attitude towards physical play. Gardiner's a beauty but the Oilers need solid defensive defensemen so it doesn't address either teams deepest needs.

Thats ignoring the fact Yakupov is the shiniest new toy in the box and that cuts deep into peoples ability to reason.