Gimmick or next big thing? The verdict is still out on curved phones

“Real women,” I read once on a movie poster somewhere, “have curves.” And while I can’t say I actually got around to seeing the film, the point stands. In fact, I’d go so far as to suggest that the sentiment can be applied to most of us, fairer sex or no — increasingly so, in these days of desk jobs and bacon-wrapped cheeseburgers. So, why then have our phones grown increasingly flat as society has become, well, more rounded?

If you map the body image of the telephone over the past few decades, you’ll see a gradual transformation of an object built with the shape of the human head in mind, to what’s essentially a flat slab of plastic and glass. That’s the primary motivation behind the LG G Flex and Samsung Galaxy Round, two recently released handset that harness new technologies to offer a slightly different bent to the standard smartphone slab.

If humans are creating the technology, shouldn’t technology be created with humans in mind?

The announcement of both was largely written off by much of the press and public alike as gimmicky, an attempt for two device manufactures to set themselves apart (albeit at the same time) from a market flooded with samey devices. Samsung, in particular, has never really been above such whiz-bang maneuvers. Over the past few years, the company has earned a reputation in the industry for its “throw everything against the wall” approach to gadgetry, largely regarded as the popular opposite of Apple’s “one device to rule them all” approach.

LG and Samsung both seem, at best, cautiously optimistic. After all, the companies have both unveiled new flagship devices in the past month, which, contrary to rumors, take a pre-Magellan approach to phone construction. At the moment, both companies seem to be, at best, dipping their toes in the curved waters at the moment, in hopes that bowed screens will become the next mobile phenomenon, on-par with the phablet explosion of the past few years.

That said, the fact that two off the biggest mobile players embraced curved mobile displays at nearly the exact same time does seem lend some credence to the technology — or at the very least, it calls for a closer examination of the claims put forth in their respective press material. Let’s start with the big claim: We’ve got curves, so why shouldn’t our phones?

This point is part of a larger backlash that we’re seeing pop up all over the electronics industry, and it’s a valid concern. If humans are creating the technology, shouldn’t technology be created with humans in mind? This is why you hear phrases like “natural user interface” to describe the sort of motion control enabled by devices like the Xbox Kinect and leap motion. It’s an attempt to rethink technology in a way that works with our natural movements. And it’s easy to see why it’s been such an appealing concept.

Who wouldn’t want a phone that feels a little better on your face, or sits a bit more comfortably in your back pocket? It’s something we think about every time we hear more promises about flexible displays. It’s exciting to imagine a time when, instead of carrying around massive 7-inch phones for maximum screen real estate, we’ll be able to just pull the things from our back pockets and unfurl them like a roadmap.

But such fantasies only drive home what these new devices aren’t. As much time and effort as no doubt went into building, say, the G Flex (keep in mind that the screen isn’t the only thing you’ve got to curve here), the “Flex” part is hugely overstated, as anyone who’s ever played with the device can tell you. The flexing here is limited to the ability to push the center of the phone down ever so slightly when the phone is resting on its face. Ultimately, the Flex is yet another six-inch phone, bringing with it all of the downsides of lugging around a massive handset. And while you may feel a slight difference with the device pressed up against your face, is anyone using the “phone” part of their smartphone enough for a small curve to make that huge of a difference?

Not really. This ultimately seems to be a case where, like the touchscreen keyboard before it, man has adapted to machine, and we’re doing just fine, thank you very much.

The other principle advantage manufacturers claim for the technology is the same reason they’re now trying to curve all of our TV sets: viewing angles. If you’ve seen one of those new curved sets from (shocker) Samsung or LG, you’ve probably struggled to take in those purported advantages. Now shrink that technology down to six inches, and it becomes harder to detect by orders of magnitude. It also makes one wonder exactly who is gathering the whole family around the old Galaxy Round to watch the latest from Pixar. The argument can be made, perhaps for curving larger displays, but in this form factor, the advantages are minimal at best.

Now keep in mind, none of these are actually arguments against the technology, but rather arguments against picking up a curved phone for the sake of the curve. In fact, in the time I spent with the G Flex, the only notable downside I could find (so far as the curved was concerned) was the fact that the giant phone didn’t fit as comfortably in my front pocket. Slipped in the back pocket and it becomes pretty clear: This is a phone designed with the butt in mind.

So long as manufacturers continued to relegate curved displays to handsets without much else going for them, the technology will likely never take off. Added to an already great flagship phone, however, the small improvements the curve brings will only serve to make the phones better. I’m all for smartphone manufacturers working to distinguish themselves from the pack of handsets running the same operating system on the same components, but until a company is willing to go all in with the curve, it will continue to be innovation for innovation’s sake.

The views expressed here are solely those of the author and do not reflect the beliefs of Digital Trends.

Google’s Pixel 3 smartphone is the best Android phone you can buy. It doesn’t have the best looks or the best hardware, but you’ll be hard pressed to find better software and unique A.I. functionalities.

Need a better phone but don't want to spend a fortune? It's never a bad time to score a new smartphone and save some cash. We rounded up the best smartphone deals available that can save you as much as $850.

It looks like we should get ready for more LG V-series phones. LG has trademarked names for the LG V50 all the way up to the LG V90. We may have to wait some time before we see these phones; the next LG flagship is expected to be the LG G8.

At $350, the Nokia 7.1 is a nearly perfect budget phone. It has a gorgeous body, good hardware, and a capable camera. Recently purchased the Nokia 7.1? Here are a few of our favorite tips and tricks to get you started with your new phone.

Is your Amazon tablet giving you grief? Is it refusing to behave the way you expect? Take a deep breath -- everything will be fine. Here are some widely reported Kindle Fire problems and a few possible solutions to go with them.

Tumblr for iOS is currently only allowing searches in Safe Mode, and it is not available on the App Store. The speculation is that the app's disappearance had something to do with inappropriate content.

Barnes & Noble recently launched its largest mobile device to date, the Nook Tablet 10.1. Now the company has released a couple of accessories designed exclusively for the new Nook: A keyboard cover and a charging dock.

The mega-retailer opens its doors to the most competitive shoppers at 6 p.m. on Thursday, November 22, and signs indicate that the retailer means business this year. We've sifted through all of the deals, from consumer electronics to small…

Smartwatches make your life easier by sending alerts right on your wrist. Many also provide fitness-tracking features. So if you're ready to take the plunge into wearables and want to save money, read on for the best smartwatch deals.

Previously, Apple was awarded a patent for a foldable phone, and the company has been rumored to be working on one. But it's not at all similar to other concepts. Here's everything we know about a folding iPhone.

Amazon may be an online-only retailer, but that doesn’t mean its Black Friday sales are anything to sniff at. In fact, due to its online status, Amazon has huge flexibility with the range of products and deals it can offer. Here's our…

Modern smartphones can charge in mere minutes instead of hours. How does fast charging work? Here's a guide to the most popular standards, including Qualcomm Quick Charge, Apple fast charging, OnePlus Dash Charge, and more.

We've been hard at work assembling all the best Black Friday deals Best Buy offers in 2018 and putting them in one place to save you time and money this holiday season. From laptops to TVs, game consoles to smart speakers and much more…