I think it's fine where it is - it forces you to make hard decisions on which players you want to give your RS to. Expanding it would make that decision easier, and then we have half the FR classes being RS, which is ridiculous. If WIS eventually expands the rosters, then it would make sense to expand RS by an equal proportion.

Posted by chetty1963 on 4/18/2014 4:16:00 PM (view original):I think it's fine where it is - it forces you to make hard decisions on which players you want to give your RS to. Expanding it would make that decision easier, and then we have half the FR classes being RS, which is ridiculous. If WIS eventually expands the rosters, then it would make sense to expand RS by an equal proportion.

I agree with this. You actually have 12 RS on the squad. As long as everyone has the same rules - what does it matter? If everyone had more, everyone's teams would be better and there would be no real advantage anyway.

more options to manage roster = better. I agree the limit on redshirts is nonsensical. Not everyone would decide to use their redshirts the same way or in the same classes. There still would be plenty of variation from team to team.

Posted by curtains on 4/18/2014 7:33:00 PM (view original):I think that a limit of 3 (or some hard limit), is a very good idea. I absolutely do not share the outrage expressed by some in this thread :)