Medical Research with or Without Informed Consent

Medical Research With or Without Informed ConsentIn 1952, paralytic polio peaked in the United States with 21,000 reported cases and numerous deaths. It was in February 1952; Jonas Salk developed the world’s first polio vaccine at the University of Pittsburgh and by testing it on cultured “HeLa” cells, proved it to be effective for distribution by 1955. The cells he used were collected from a poor black tobacco farmer named Henrietta Lacks, born August 1st, 1920 in Roanoke Virginia. In January 1951, Henrietta went to the gynecology clinic at John Hopkins Hospital in Baltimore Maryland and complained of having a “knot” in her womb. A malignant tumor, about the size of a nickel, was discovered on her cervix and when she returned the next week to receive radium treatments, Henrietta signed a consent form for the procedure. Before her treatment began, her doctor collected cancerous and healthy tissue from her cervix and sent them to Dr. George Gey. As head of tissue culture research at John Hopkins, Dr. Gey had spent three decades determined to grow the first immortal human cells in hope of finding the cause and cure for cancer. All cells collected for a culture were labeled using the first two letters of the patients first and last name, therefore Henrietta Lacks culture was called HeLa. Henrietta’s healthy cells died within days, but her cancer cells continued to multiply and those cells are still alive today. Dr. Gey’s successful growth of the HeLa cells was one of the biggest medical breakthroughs of the 20th century. Although doctors collected Henrietta’s cells without her knowledge, the research performed on the HeLa cells and subsequent medical advances resulted in benefitting all of humanity, which justifies the unethical decision not to provide informed consent. Some people believe that because Henrietta never gave informed consent to collect her cells, that the doctors acted unethically. It wasn’t until 1973, the Lacks family found out that Henrietta’s...

You May Also Find These Documents Helpful

...Bartholomaus
English 102
27 March 2013
InformedConsent
What is an informedconsent? What do we know about it? Where did it come from? What purpose does it serves? These days, there is a variance in what informedconsent means. Its definition depends on what specific manner it accentuates in accordance with the pertinent setting of application. The American Medical Association (AMA) has definitions on a clinical setting and on the field of research. However it is defined, informedconsent was the product of a period of work and experience.
Informedconsent is the cornerstone of human subject research protection. (Rowbotham et al.)
The principles of informedconsent were laid down in the context of American medical practice in a landmark case dating from the 1914: Schloendorf vs New York Hospital Society (Bennett). Following a surgical procedure was carried out a patient who had previously refused the surgery, the judge ruled that every human being of adult years and of sound mind has a right to determine what shall be done with his own body.
In 1947, during the after-effects of the Second World War, the Nuremberg trials of Nazi war criminals; to address the inhuman research practices of...

...LAW AND ETHICS |
IS INFORMEDCONSENT AN ABSTRACT CONCEPT IN HEALTH TODAY? |
|
This essay will focus on both negative and positive attributes on ‘Is informedconsent an abstract concept in health today’. For this essay we have interpreted the topic as Medical staff in health care has to use abstract means, such as word books or demonstrations to promote patients having understanding whilst vulnerable for informedconsent. |
|
|
16th November 2010 |
|
With the development of medical sciences, mortality and morbidity related to medical treatment and management has reduced. Further effort to reduce this further is an ongoing process (Subhash, 2005). Unforeseen and expected complications and even death do occur during the treatment process and many a time this is not accepted by patients or their relatives. This results in many court cases or unpleasant situations, it is for these reasons that Informedconsent needs to be obtained for any invasive procedure
This essay will focus on informedconsent, and whether or not it is an abstract concept in health today. For informative purposes, Information will include definition of the topic and both the negative and positive attributes pertaining to the topic. This will be very informative and incorporate legal and ethical...

...InformedConsent
By Rachel
Health Care Systems Administrations 202
April 21st 2013
Table of Contents
Various ways to gain informedconsent…………………………….Page 3
Factors that play into gaining informedconsent……………………Page 4
Clinical Research……………………………………………………Page 5
United States Government Guidelines………………...……………Page 6
Timing of Consent…………………………………………………..Page 7
Consequences……………………………………….......…………..Page 7
Conclusion ………………………………………………………….Page 8
References…………………………………………………………. Page 10
Various ways to gain informedconsent
There are various different ways to gain informedconsent such as written, orally, or even a waiver. Written consent is when the patient or guardian has carefully read the risks, side effects, and procedure and then signed the paper for consent to precede. It is suggested that the patient read over the materials carefully in order to fully understand the entire procedure so the patient should be given the time to think about every option they have and every risk that may come up.
Oral consent is when the patient is given the risks, side effects and procedure verbally and then will have to sign a short form stating that they clearly understand everything they have been informed of. Oral...

...Healthcare Consent legislation applies to everyone above the age of 18 (some places 16) and has the following rights (Ref 1)
1) The right to give or refuse consent
2) The right to choose a particular form of healthcare on any grounds including moral or religious grounds
3) The right to revoke consent
4) The right to expect that a decision to give, refuse or revoke consent will be respected
5) The right to be involved to the greatest degree possible in all case planning and decision making
Mostly all nursing actions are an invasion of a person’s privacy and giving consent is carried out by going into the hospital or being treated at home. So one can say that consent is based on the principle of respect for a fellow human being. (Ref 1,2)
This legislation tells me that all patients and clients have a right to receive information about their condition. As a nurse I should be sensitive to their needs and respect the wishes of those who refuse or are unable to receive such information. (Ref 1,2) For instance, there may be a language barrier and I should not just go about reading the consent form in English, rather I should arrange for a interpreter or find a nurse who speaks the clients language. I also respect their decision of autonomy-their decision to accept or decline any health intervention even if a refusal means loss of life, example Jehovah s witness...

...Ethics Paper
InformedConsent in Industrial/Psychological Research
July 31, 2011
Foundations of Industrial/Organizational Psychology
Abstract
There are certain conditions where reasonable exceptions that APA ethical standards and federal guidelines insure in research that human participation will be ethical due to informedconsent. In federal guidelines the preferred mechanism is informedconsent in order to protect the human participants (APA, 1992).
InformedConsentInformedconsent is when an individual gives permission to participate in future events after receiving instruction about the events they may wish to be a part of. Informedconsent is put in place to prevent lawsuits. Obtaining consent is similar in all circumstances (Jones, 2011).
In order to be considered valid, informedconsent must be given voluntarily from a participant that is competent (Cherry, 2011).
When is InformedConsent Required?
In order to arrive at a better understanding of the subject matter, research is necessary. When conducting research and using human participants, the need to know whether informedconsent is necessary is vital....

...Explain what is meant by “informedconsent” and “implied consent”.
When should written consent be obtained?
Informedconsent is a phrase often used in law to indicate that the consent a person gives meets certain minimum standards. As a literal matter, in the absence of fraud, it is redundant. An informedconsent can be said to have been given based upon a clear appreciation and understanding of the facts, implications, and future consequences of an action. In order to give informedconsent, the individual concerned must have adequate reasoning faculties and be in possession of all relevant facts at the time consent is given. (Wikipedia). UK case law on consent has established three requirements that need to be satisfied before a potential client can give informedconsent:
1. Consent should be given by someone with the mental ability to do so.
2. Sufficient information should be given to the participant.
3. Consent must be freely given.
A therapist must always get informedconsent to give treatment. This should be done by clearly explaining the treatment you will be giving, any risks that may be involved and any other alternative treatments that may be possible. A record of the treatment plan...

...topic I chose is informedconsent. It is a difficult and complex topic with many different laws and viewpoints. The laws of consent often vary by state and in my opinion are often not fully understood by many people. There are many ethical issues that can take place from not completely understanding the consent form. Many people do not read the form at all and consequently do not know their rights as a patient. Patients sometimes sign the consent form without fully understanding everything that is required for them to know. When an issue comes up it can then quickly escalate to an ethical issue that can only be resolved in court because they were not aware of all the possibilities. Patients must not agree to the consent form without being entirely aware of all the possibilities. Nurses and physicians can be extremely busy and overwhelmed. Heath care professionals should have the time to go over all aspects of the consent form to help prevent an ethical issue.
In my essay I will explain the basics of informedconsent, ethical issues associated with informedconsent, some of the problems with the consent form itself, and some theories that may improve the consent form. It is imperative for heath care professionals and patients to be educated about the...

...Running Head: INFORMEDCONSENT IN MEDICAL MALPRACTICE
InformedConsent in Medical Malpractice
Insert Name
Insert Grade Course
Insert Instructors Name
December 10, 2010
Outline
Medical malpractice
Standard of Care for medical practitioners
InformedConsent
Competency
Information
Voluntariness
Exceptions
Michigan Cases of InformedConsent in Medical Malpractice Law
How to mitigate potential claims
Conclusion
InformedConsent in Medical Malpractice
Medical malpractice
Medical malpractice is negligence. It is said to have taken place the time a medical specialist acts in an inattentive way when administering treatment to a medical situation. Malpractice may occur either because of action undertaken by the health specialist or by failure to undertake a suitable medical action. Examples of aspects of medical malpractice include not diagnosing or simply misdiagnosing a health condition, inability to accord a suitable treatment for a health condition and implausible delay in administering treatment after diagnosing a health situation (Larson, 2010, p.1). A set of regulations that govern malpractice lawsuits differ from one state to another....