The third-season sitcom edged out another NBC cult fave (and last year's runner-up to Supernatural), Chuck, for the top honors. The network caused an uproar earlier this month when it announced Community won't be on its midseason schedule; online voting for the Fan Favorites award closed before that story broke. Retweeting the news of his show's triumph, star Joel McHale spoke for all of Community's fans: "Holy crap!"