9 Worst Summer Skin Care Products

See which self-tanners and sunscreens get two thumbs down from our readers

No. 1: Neutrogena Sunless Tanning Foam, $8.92 TotalBeauty.com average reader rating: 3.2*
Why: One woman says, "wanna look like an orange?" then use this. Adding the product "should be named 'tang glow." Another reader says, "I turned orange like the drink mix Tang. The foam was easy to apply, but did not stay on my skin (rubbed off even when I dried out and did not wear tight clothing for over an hour later)." Another reviewer says she, "did not like it at all! Since it wasn't a lotion, my skin didn't feel moisturized after using it, and the blending was difficult. My tan ended up looking blotchy, and my skin still smelled weird when it dried." One woman says, "I usually love Neutrogena makeup and skin care products, but every Neutrogena sunless tanner I have tried (especially this one!) is terrible. I tried this foam several years ago when it first came out and the experience was so awful I remember it to this day. It was so orange and streaky and it smells disgusting." Bottom line: "It deserves minus one star. I had to throw it away, don't waste your money," says a reader.