If this is your first visit, be sure to
check out the FAQ by clicking the
link above. You may have to register
before you can post: click the register link above to proceed. To start viewing messages,
select the forum that you want to visit from the selection below.

He is not garbage. He is a terrific person with great personal character, who has given much to this team over many years and could have been named SB MVP in either of his two appearances. His production has fallen way off and perhaps should not be starting and perhaps should not be back next year but he is not garbage.

Thank you!! Well said. The guy goes all out. I think injuries may have done him in as a starter because he's not old by any means, but to say he's garbage is just dumb. I have a feeling some of you wouldn't say the things I have been reading if he was standing next to you. I appreciate and haven't forgotten everything this guy has done for this team in winning 2 SUPERBOWLS...

He is not garbage. He is a terrific person with great personal character, who has given much to this team over many years and could have been named SB MVP in either of his two appearances. His production has fallen way off and perhaps should not be starting and perhaps should not be back next year but he is not garbage.

I feel like I'm being setup on a blind date with a charming obese chick... JK. Tuck will be fine and fat chicks are cool.

Tuck at this point is done as a pass rusher. He can still play the run well. I was a little surprised they didnt take an end in the 2012 draft. U could see the decline last year. Good news is this draft is overflowing with athletic defensive ends. Wherever the Giants pick in th first round they should be able to get a good 1.

Hes a waste at E would suggest he be used as a DT.
When W. Beatty makes more Tackles then Tuck there is something really wrong.

Your thoughts.

He's a sure shot to be be on one of the ESPN or NFL Network shows next year. He's done as a football player. How many times in the last few weeks have they shown Tuck on the sidelines on crucial drives by the opponents. I can't count there's been so many of them.

He could easily finish the season with 7 sacks and 55 tackles. That is still average for a LDE that kicks inside on 3rd down and is part of a rotation. QBs aren't holding the ball very long against this secondary.