******This album is the best thing I own. As soon as I heard the first single I was hooked, and bought the album as soon as I could lay hands on it. It didn't disappoint. Not one weak track on there, not to mention the perfection of Mr. Brightside. Nine of these songs could easily have been huge as singles, it's a pity they all couldn't be. Perfect.

****Still their best album and hugely successfull here in the UK. Their first UK#1 album. UK#1 and Ireland#1. 2.1 million copies sold in the UK.Twenty seventh biggest selling album of the 00's in the UK.Last edited: 16/09/2013 14:47

*****Yep, it was a great album and it still is. While there's a few so-so tracks here and there, the likes of 'Mr. Brightside', 'Somebody Told Me' and 'All These Things That I've Done' are definitely among the band's best.

****Quite a solid album and The Killers best and most overall consistent. Lots of interesting sounds on this. The best tracks include Jenny Was A Friend Of Mine, Mr Brightside, Smile Like You Mean It, best on the album and my favourite Killers track All These Things That I've Done, On Top and Midnight Show. Overall score around 4 - 4.5.