Emma Roberts and Evan Peters are engaged

It’s a match made in heaven – or at least by Ryan Murphy. Emma Roberts is engaged to her American Horror Story costar Evan Peters, People confirms. Peters reportedly popped the question over the holidays. The two have been dating since 2012.

Their betrothal comes nearly six months after Roberts, 22, was arrested in Montreal following a physical altercation with Peters, 26. (In a joint statement, reps for both actors called the July incident “unfortunate” and a “misunderstanding.”)