I really like the original ones Tara. If you really were dead set against them then I would go with option #1. I just think that #2 would get lost on you cause they are crystal clear along with your coloring and the white dress... kwim? I think the ones you have add a little bit of a vintage look. If that's what you are going for.

Not knowing what "feel" you are going for at the service, I much prefer the original choice. I have a Givenchy pair that are very similar in antique styling that look fantastic with my cushion cut ER according to Fiancee. The other choices will lend a more casual feel and are indeed pretty, but not as beautiful as your gut #1 choice. Just my 2 cents....

I love the first choice earrings but I would consider finding a dainty (not bulky) necklace to match them with your dress. Your dress is beautiful and simple, so you could get away with having a pretty necklace along with it. Hope that helps!

so for those of you that said add a necklace with the origional earrings, what kind of necklace? I'm SO BAD at matching jewelry - which is why I usually only wear either earrings or a necklace. But I'm totally open to a necklace, just have no ability to pick one!