In 2011, Faroqi was already in her first trimester when she came back to her Orange County home in California. Ahmad, wanting to discuss the future of their relationship came to visit her from Virginia and met her at a friend's apartment.

It was at this point that he learned he was not the father.

He seemed supportive at first even saying he could "accept the baby" and wanted to show Faroqi the engagement ring that was in his car that he said he bought her. But when he stood up a knife fell out of his pocket and the friend recognized the knife as one of hers from her apartment.

A bit of a scuffle ensued shortly after and Siddiqi grabbed another knife from the kitchen and ended up chasing Soraya out of her apartment and into some bushes where he stabbed her 18 times!