When I saw WHY? at the Middle East Downstairs in summer 2010, it became firmly lodged in my mind as one of the best shows I had ever seen up to that point. The setlist was nearly immaculate -- they were touring a record that they didn't really care about too much -- and so most of the songs that they played were from Elephant Eyelash and Alopecia, two of the best fucking records of the aughts.