Thanks everyone for your feedback and input. You should always go with your first instinct. I actually bought that same kind of mirror before @Ross for $16.99, convinced myself and return it. Went for a $180 mirror and they forgot the screws. Fast forward a month later, got this one at Home Goods for $24.99.

So the decision is final, taking all the other mirrors back and keeping the stainless frame mirror. Will be checking back in on placements of glass shelves and should I use one or two along with towel bar.