The purpose of the Manual Cervical Distraction: Measuring Chiropractic Delivery for Neck Pain Clinical Trial is to examine the patient‐centered clinical and biomechanical outcomes, doctor treatment delivery, and believability characteristics of a commonly used chiropractic procedure for the treatment of neck- or neck-related arm pain or disability.

We will evaluate the clinician's ability to deliver three randomly assigned manual interventions to the cervical spine within specified traction force ranges (<20 Newtons [N], 20-50N, >50N). The primary outcome of this study is to determine the accuracy and consistency of traction force delivery ranges both between clinicians and within individual clinicians. Traction force ranges will be measured at each study visit (visits 1, 2, 3, 4, 5) for 2 weeks.

The NDI is a 10-item questionnaire modified from the Oswestry Low Back Pain Disability Index. The NDI has been shown to be a reliable and valid measure of disability due to neck pain, and responsive for measuring change. Study Visit 1 and Study Visit 5 Measures occur 2 weeks apart.

The VAS has excellent metric properties, is easy to administer and score, and is commonly used in pain research. Our anchors will be no pain to worst pain imaginable. We will ask participants to rate their current neck pain at baseline and pre-/post-treatment for all 5 study visits.

The PROMIS-43 questionnaire will be used to measure general functional health status. PROMIS-43 questions measure physical function, anxiety, depression, fatigue, sleep disturbance, social role satisfaction, and pain interference and intensity.

We will ask all participants whether they feel the study procedure would relieve their neck pain using the Procedure Believability Questionnaire. The response choices will be: "Strongly believe the procedure will relieve my neck pain; Somewhat believe the procedure will relieve my neck pain; Somewhat believe the procedure will NOT relieve my neck pain; Strongly believe the procedure will NOT relieve my neck pain; and Don't know if the procedure will relieve my neck pain". A baseline evaluation will be completed based upon treatment description, and compared to assessments following study visit 1 and study visit 5 over a 2-week time period.

Vital signs, including temperature, pulse, respiration and blood pressure, as well as height and weight (for calculation of Body Mass Index) will be collected at baseline using standard clinical procedures.

Manual Cervical Distraction forces will be limited to greater than 50N in the high force group. Dosing for this clinical trial is limited to 3 sets of 5 repetitions with a hand contact on one cervical vertebra of highest clinical importance and 3 sets of 5 repetitions with a hand contact on the occiput.

Procedure: Manual Cervical Distraction

Manual Cervical Distraction (MCD) is a form of Low Velocity Variable Amplitude Spinal Manipulation (LVVA-SM). MCD procedure is performed with participant lying prone on a load instrumented table with moveable headpiece allowing guided head movement while recumbent. Clinician gently grasps posterior aspect of participant's neck with a broad contact (contact hand) between thumb and index finger at specific vertebral level. With opposite hand, clinician grasps control handle. Using contact hand, clinician exhibits superior traction to maintain a contact at a single vertebral level and ensuring a gentle movement via contact with control handle. Goal is to create a slow rhythmic (1-3 sec) localized distractive movement. In this trial, only axial distraction (Cox protocol 1) will be used.

Active Comparator: Manual Cervical Distraction Medium Force

Manual Cervical Distraction forces will be limited to between 20N-50N in the medium force group. Dosing for this clinical trial is limited to 3 sets of 5 repetitions with a hand contact on one cervical vertebra of highest clinical importance and 3 sets of 5 repetitions with a hand contact on the occiput.

Procedure: Manual Cervical Distraction

Manual Cervical Distraction (MCD) is a form of Low Velocity Variable Amplitude Spinal Manipulation (LVVA-SM). MCD procedure is performed with participant lying prone on a load instrumented table with moveable headpiece allowing guided head movement while recumbent. Clinician gently grasps posterior aspect of participant's neck with a broad contact (contact hand) between thumb and index finger at specific vertebral level. With opposite hand, clinician grasps control handle. Using contact hand, clinician exhibits superior traction to maintain a contact at a single vertebral level and ensuring a gentle movement via contact with control handle. Goal is to create a slow rhythmic (1-3 sec) localized distractive movement. In this trial, only axial distraction (Cox protocol 1) will be used.

Sham Comparator: Manual Cervical Distraction Low Force

Manual Cervical Distraction forces will be limited to less than 20N in the low force group. Dosing for this clinical trial is limited to 3 sets of 5 repetitions with a hand contact on one cervical vertebra of highest clinical importance and 3 sets of 5 repetitions with a hand contact on the occiput.

Procedure: Manual Cervical Distraction

Manual Cervical Distraction (MCD) is a form of Low Velocity Variable Amplitude Spinal Manipulation (LVVA-SM). MCD procedure is performed with participant lying prone on a load instrumented table with moveable headpiece allowing guided head movement while recumbent. Clinician gently grasps posterior aspect of participant's neck with a broad contact (contact hand) between thumb and index finger at specific vertebral level. With opposite hand, clinician grasps control handle. Using contact hand, clinician exhibits superior traction to maintain a contact at a single vertebral level and ensuring a gentle movement via contact with control handle. Goal is to create a slow rhythmic (1-3 sec) localized distractive movement. In this trial, only axial distraction (Cox protocol 1) will be used.

Detailed Description:

The purpose of the Manual Cervical Distraction (MCD): Measuring Chiropractic Delivery for Neck Pain Clinical Trial is to examine the patient‐centered clinical and biomechanical outcomes, and believability characteristics of a manually‐localized cervical distraction procedure for the treatment of neck- or neck-related arm pain or disability. One challenging issue in the study of manual therapies, including spinal manipulation (SM), is the development of sham and/or minimal intervention procedures suitable for use with control groups in clinical trials. With SM, active treatment requires substantial physical contact between a study clinician and the study participant, either directly or through a mechanical intermediary. Consequently, it is difficult to introduce differences in manual therapy procedures that distinguish sham and/or minimal interventions from the active treatment, but are not immediately obvious to the study participant. Another challenging issue is training clinicians to deliver a standardized SM treatment within specified force ranges. The muscles surrounding the neck could alter the forces transmitted to the cervical spine, and could alter the treatment effectiveness. The purpose of this pilot randomized controlled trial is to examine the patient‐centered clinical, biomechanical, and believability outcome characteristics of a manually‐localized cervical distraction procedure for the treatment of neck or neck-related arm pain or disability. We also will evaluate the ability of the doctor of chiropractic to deliver the MCD treatment within specified force ranges. An exploratory aim of this study is to evaluate EMG measurement during MCD delivery.

Drug or alcohol abuse or dependence, suspected or confirmed through self-report questionnaires and clinical interview.

Depression rated as ≥ 29 on the Beck Depression Inventory.

Cognitive or memory impairment identified during eligibility exam.

Pregnancy, under either of the following 2 circumstances: 1) Participant safety, if participant is unable to tolerate or undergo study procedures; or 2) Fetus safety, if x-rays are required for diagnosis.

Weight greater than 300 lbs (table weight limit).

Referral for evaluation, diagnosis, or management of other health conditions, or additional diagnostics required for neck pain diagnosis.

Retention of legal advice or seeking a health-related insurance claim.

Household member previously enrolled in MCD Clinical Trial.

Compliance concerns identified during baseline eligibility process.

Contacts and Locations

Choosing to participate in a study is an important personal decision. Talk with your doctor and family members or friends about deciding to join a study.
To learn more about this study, you or your doctor may contact the study research staff using the Contacts provided below.
For general information, see Learn About Clinical Studies.

Please refer to this study by its ClinicalTrials.gov identifier: NCT01765751