Bloodborne over Dark Souls?

So As most people know the next major arc is a rift arc and it will be either between Skyrim or Dark Souls. However I have been watching a good sum of Bloodborne gameplay and I kind of feel like leaning towards Bloodborne more than Dark Souls. I personally feel the dark gothic fantasy theme may fit the site better, also to were Dark Souls you play as a Hollow, Bloodborne you play as a Hunter. I was thinking the Hunters would actually act like a race specific enemy starting to draw more on race than I yet have to. Like an encounter with a Hunter for a Human, Mutant or Cyborg, or Angel, or Elf, would be different for a Demon, Vampire and Lycan. While half breeds like Half Devils and Dhampir get frowned upon but not exactly hated? Half Phantoms would more or less be like a bit of a mystery to them intriguing them a bit though. I am still deciding but I would like to hear your guy's opinion, leave a comment if you have any input.

Sorry Skyrim is huge and just no way to incorperate it fully or even half of it into an arc. There is literally over hundreds of hours to Skyrim so I wont be able to add every little thing just a few key things for the arc. I just wanted you to know so you don't get the wrong idea.