In a clip from Monday’s episode, A League of Their Own director Penny Marshall tells Costas about casting the film. Demi Moore was originally signed on to play star catcher Dottie Hinson, but the film took so long to get made that Moore was pregnant by the time production came around.

“Bruce [Willis] literally screwed her out of the part,” Marshall jokes in the video.

“The best possible outcome for people in my business is when they stop remembering something and start reliving it,” Cornblatt says. “Occasionally when you get it, you can see it in the looks in their eyes. You can see it in the sound of their voice.”

Costas at the Movies airsMondays at 8 p.m. on the MLB Network. After each episode, the network will air the film that was discussed.