Diner & Coffee Fix in Long Island City

Before my husband and I bought our house last year, I was an Astoria resident for eight years. Living in the western part of Queens, closest to Manhattan — Astoria and in neighboring Long Island City — was delightful. New restaurants, stores, residential buildings popped up all the time. For a curious explorer like me, this aspect of change was exciting.

Magasin Wells Diner, more colloquially known as “M. Wells”, opened a few months after I left the area. Hearing all the great reviews about this place, I knew it would be a matter of time before I visited. But weeks became months and months became a year. I was embarrassed that even visitors to NYC (like this awesome foodie couple from California) even got here before I did! They live 3,000 miles away from the restaurant. Me? 10 miles away. What was wrong with this picture? So I corrected the problem TODAY.

The food at M. Wells has been described as “Quebecois-American”. The owners are a married couple, and the husband was a former chef at Au Pied de Cochon in Montreal. I hit the jackpot by arriving on this Friday morning before Memorial Day. I was seated right away and as I looked around, I noticed there were still some empty seats to spare. My waitress said this occurrence was unusual and we agreed it was probably a function of the long holiday weekend.

While reviews rave of the offal dishes, I was in the mood to trying something else since it was only 10:30 am and my stomach was not ready for foie gras, tongue, or veal brains. All right, I’ll be honest. I don’t think my stomach will ever be ready for veal brains… Gasp! Will you still respect me and view me as a “foodie”?

Instead, I opted for the egg and potato hash because the bacon and fiddleheads in the dish appealed to me. I was disappointed to learn that the hash had been altered to include crab meat, asparagus, and peas. I still chose it anyway since I was in the mood for potato hash and a soft egg. While the dish was tasty, it would’ve been SURELY out of this world had it been made with the salty, savory bacon paired with the earthy fiddleheads.

My husband opted for the Cubano sandwich, which was pressed flat allowing the meat edges poking outside of the bread to become crisp.

I’ll be sure to come back here again. I know I was spoiled today since the place was relaxed and calm with no wait. Perhaps I’ll check out the dinner scene and stop by one of three weeknights they are open in the evening. I’m sure by that time, I’ll be in the mood for this.

I only drank water at M. Wells because I knew I would head to Sweetleaf next, just two blocks away. A charming coffee shop with baked goods made on the premises, the place was warm and flooded with natural light thanks to several large windows in the storefront. As my senses adjusted to the place, it took less than a few minutes to encounter this amusing sign.

Co-owner Rich Nieto was behind the counter. Without knowing what to order, I asked him to suggest something for me. Since it was a hot day, he suggested the “Iced Rocket Fuel”, an iced coffee, cold brewed with chicory and maple syrup. But I also wanted a hot coffee so he suggested a “pour over” coffee made with Stumptown coffee beans of his choice.

We followed him to the back and settled by the pour-over “bar”. It was hard to stay seated on the bar stools because I curiously wanted to watch each preparation step. It was mesmerizing. Rich reminded me of a scientist in the lab sans the white medical coat. To brew this individual cup, he sought accuracy and precision with various tools: thermometer, measuring cup, and scale. In this age of mass commercialization and high production, making one 12-ounce cup of coffee took time, patience, and dare I say, love? It was a nice change of pace from the usual way I ordered coffee. It gave me the chance to get to know the man behind the counter and find out how this fellow Queens native, who always loved coffee, went from being the owner of a telecommunications company to the owner of a coffee house. He decided to follow his coffee bliss after his good friend started Sweetleaf. “Even though I’ve been to Colombia, Honduras, Guatemala, Costa Rica, I’ve never been to a coffee farm in any of these countries. But people always think I have. I was more likely to connect you if you ever called these places,” he laughed as he recalled his former life.

I was thankful for his leap of faith. For in a few minutes I sipped on a Stumptown Finco El Injerto Bourbon from Guatemala, which was bold but smooth with absolutely zero acerbity. It was one of the best cups of coffee I had because I managed to taste the complexity and combination of flavors free of milk and sugar. I always believed that excellent coffee should be drunk black so as to truly taste it. I couldn’t discern my coffee’s “fragrance of jasmine” but I was able to pick up the super subtle hint of chocolate. The Iced Rocket Fuel, surprisingly didn’t have any acerbity either and it finished with the sweet smoothness of maple syrup.

While I didn’t get a chance to sample the baked goodies, I did manage to sneak behind the counter! As a totally inexperienced barista, I may have freaked out this disturbingly obsessed coffee geek. I’ll spare him the heart attack so that we can all continue to benefit from his talent and passion. I shall gladly return to my rightful place on the other side of the bar, sipping a delicious cup o’ joe…or two.

E! So happy you stopped by! Thank you so much for your encouragement! I am trying to get back to blogging after a several weeks of derailment! Onward, I say! When you come visit NYC, I’ll show you around and we can eat our way through the city and then we can detox it all out with some bikram. 😉 xoxo

We get butterflies in our tummy every time we read about M. Wells in Long Island City. It’s a delight to see LIC on the foodie map, and M. Wells has been making quite some noise both locally and nationally. If you go back for the Escargot, let us know how it is!

Hi Rockrose, thanks for stopping by! Sorry for the delay — I was on vacation and I totally unplugged the entire time. I came back from vaca to learn that the M. Wells is closing at its current location but then possibly opening up at a new location in LIC? Let’s hope so!!