Ahead of Colin Walker's first start to a season as manager, York signed nine players before the summer transfer window closed. The season started with an eight-match unbeaten run, but Walker was sacked in November 2008 after three successive defeats. Martin Foyle was appointed as his successor, and after the turn of the year York won only five league matches. Survival in the Conference Premier was achieved with a seventeenth-place finish. York reached the 2009 FA Trophy Final at Wembley Stadium, being beaten 2–0 by Stevenage Borough. They were eliminated from the 2008–09 FA Cup in the fourth qualifying round, and from the 2008–09 Conference League Cup in the Northern section fourth round.

Thirty-three players made at least one appearance in nationally organised first-team competition, and there were fourteen different goalscorers. Defender Danny Parslow missed only one of the fifty-eight competitive matches played over the season. Richard Brodie finished as leading scorer with nineteen goals, of which fifteen came in league competition and four came in the FA Trophy. The winner of the Clubman of the Year award, voted for by the club's supporters, was Parslow.

New home and away kits were introduced for the first time in two years.[17] The home kit comprised red and navy blue halved shirts with red collars, navy blue shorts and navy blue socks with two white strips on the cuffs.[17] The away kit included white shirts with black shoulders, white shorts and white socks with black cuffs.[18] Last season's third kit was retained, which featured light blue shirts with a maroon collar, bar a section under the neck which was light blue, and maroon trims on the sleeves, maroon shorts and light blue socks.[19][20] CLP Industries continued as shirt sponsors for the fourth successive season.[17][21]

Review

August

York's season started with a 1–0 victory away to Crawley Town, Farrell scoring the winner nineteen minutes from time.[30] The second match was a 1–0 home win over Wrexham, who had won their opening fixture 5–0 against Stevenage Borough, with Greaves scoring the winner.[31] Krysiak suffered a dislocated finger during this match, which resulted in him returning to Birmingham prematurely from his loan spell,[32] and was replaced by Mimms, who gave an assured performance.[33] York's winning start to the season ended after a 1–1 home draw with Histon,[34] who took the lead through a Daniel Wright penalty kick in the first half, before McBreen scored the equaliser for York on sixty-nine-minutes.[35]

Winger Simon Russell signed for the club from Kidderminster Harriers.[36] York drew 2–2 away to Northwich Victoria, which saw the team fight back on two occasions after twice being a goal down, with Brodie scoring his first goal of the season.[37] He then scored in the third minute against Barrow, who equalised seven minutes later through Lee Hunt, in a home match that finished a 1–1 home draw.[38] Beadle was loaned out to Northern Premier League Premier Division club Whitby Town for a month, having not made any appearances in 2008–09.[39] Sodje scored with a late volley after coming off the bench to give York a 1–1 draw away to Torquay United to maintain the team's unbeaten record, which looked under threat after Danny Stevens gave Torquay the lead on sixty-five minutes.[40] Sodje's goal against Torquay won the first Conference Premier Goal of the Month competition, for August 2008.[41]

An eighty-sixth-minute equaliser from McBreen gave York a 1–1 draw at home to Salisbury City,[49] which maintained the team's unbeaten record at Bootham Crescent.[34] Parslow signed a new contract with the club,[50] and Rotherham midfielder Peter Holmes joined on a one-month loan.[51] A second defeat of the season came after losing 2–0 away to Kidderminster,[34]Brian Smikle and Justin Richards scoring for the home team.[52] Beadle was released by the club towards the end of his loan spell at Whitby, due to him looking for regular first team football.[53] This was followed by the departure of Bore, who returned to Grimsby from his loan spell early.[54] A 3–3 draw away against Stevenage was achieved after the team were 2–0 down after nineteen-minutes, with the York goals coming from Sodje, Holmes and Farrell.[55] Sodje picked up a hamstring injury during this match, meaning he would be out of action for four to six weeks.[56]

October

Despite having the better chances, York drew 0–0 at home with Cambridge United,[57] before being beaten 3–1 away by Wrexham, in which Wilkinson scored a late consolation goal.[58] The club made an attempt to re-sign former striker Clayton Donaldson on loan from Crewe Alexandra, but were told to make an inquiry four weeks later, due to him being injured.[59] York's first double of the season came with a 2–0 away win over Woking,[34] the goals coming from Wilkinson and McBreen.[60]Iyseden Christie's loan spell at Kettering from Stevenage was to be terminated for a loan move to York to go ahead, but this deal fell through.[61] Walker revealed he was interested in signing striker Bruce Dyer, shortly after he played against York's reserves for Bradford City.[62]

York lost 2–1 at home to Torquay, in their first home defeat of the season.[34] After Roscoe D'Sane gave the visitors the lead, Greaves equalised for York with a header from a Purkiss cross in the eighty-fifth minute, before Mark Ellis scored for Torquay on ninety minutes.[74] A third successive defeat came[34] after losing 1–0 away to Cambridge.[75] It was agreed that Brodie's loan at Barrow would be extended after he scored four goals in six appearances,[76] but York decided to overturn this decision a day later.[77] Barrow hoped to open talks over signing him on a permanent contract in January 2009.[77]

December

A 1–0 home defeat by Grays Athletic through a Wes Thomas goal followed; this was Grays' first away victory of the season.[84] York followed this with a 1–1 draw away to Histon, in which they took the lead through Brodie in the fourteenth-minute, before Parslow scored an own goal on fifty-nine minutes.[85]North Ferriby United striker Steve Torpey was appointed as youth team coach to succeed Redfearn.[86] Foyle's first win as manager came in a 2–0 away victory over Northwich Victoria in the FA Trophy first round, both goals coming from Brodie.[87] This was followed with a 3–1 home win over Ebbsfleet United, with goals from Adam Smith, Brodie and Sodje after being one goal down.[88] Dyer retired from football, having only made three appearances for York through back and hamstring injuries, while Rothery was released.[89] York's two-match winning run ended after a 2–1 defeat away to league-leaders Burton Albion, which was secured after Greaves scored an own goal.[90] A 2-1 home defeat by Altrincham followed; Brodie scored a free kick in the thirty-second minute to give York the lead, before Chris Senior and Dale Johnson scored for the visitors in the second half.[91] Redfearn left the club to take charge of the Leeds under-18 team and Andy Porter, a former teammate of Foyle at Port Vale, was appointed as assistant manager.[92]

January

The New Year began with a second defeat of the season to Burton,[34] this time being beaten 3–1 at home, in which Brodie scored in the first half with a shot from the edge of the penalty area.[93] Wrexham defender Kyle Critchell was signed on a one-month loan, who Foyle knew while he was a coach at the club.[94] Adam Smith returned to Gainsborough following the conclusion of his loan, while a permanent move had been stalled as Gainsborough were holding out for a fee.[95] Progression to the third round of the FA Trophy was ensured with a 2–1 away victory over Oxford, with goals from McBreen and Brodie.[96] Further signings from Wrexham took place when striker Simon Brown and midfielder Christian Smith signed on loan and permanently respectively.[97] Hirst was released having failed to break into the first team.[98]Lewes were beaten 3–0 at home; Brodie opened the scoring with a volley into the top corner from outside the penalty area, and Christian Smith scored from thirty yards before Brodie finished the scoring with a low shot into the bottom corner.[99] Henderson was released having fallen out of the reckoning for a first team place.[100]

York were knocked out of the Conference League Cup following a 3–1 away defeat by Barrow in the Northern section fourth round.[101] Midfielder Levi Mackin was signed on loan from Wrexham until the end of the season.[102] He debuted in York's 2–1 away defeat to Eastbourne Borough, in which Christian Smith scored a header from Brown's cross.[103] Adam Smith rejoined York from Gainsborough on a permanent contract for an undisclosed fee.[104] His return came as a substitute in York's 1–1 draw away to Altrincham, in which Brodie scored the equalising goal after Shaun Densmore put the home team in the lead.[105] Farrell was loaned out to Oxford for the remainder of the season, as he sought more game time.[106] York drew 1–1 away with Kidderminster in the FA Trophy third round, in which Boyes scored his first goal for York, meaning a replay was to be played.[107]

February

Critchell's loan at York was extended for a second month, with the fitness of several York defenders in doubt.[108] York were beaten 1–0 away by Mansfield, courtesy of a Robert Duffy penalty, in the teams' fourth encounter of the season.[109] A 13–12 penalty shoot-out victory over Kidderminster followed a 1–1 extra time draw in an FA Trophy replay; in normal time, McBreen scored a header from a corner delivered by Simon Rusk before the away team equalised shortly after through Justin Richards.[110] A new record for the most consecutive penalties scored in a shoot-out was set, at twenty-five.[111] McBreen was reported to have signed for North Queensland Fury of the A-League,[112] although the transfer had yet to be confirmed by York.[113] It was confirmed that he would join the Fury for the start of 2009–10 in August 2009.[114] Former Wrexham defender Shaun Pejic signed after a successful trial at the club.[115] York beat Conference South team Havant & Waterlooville 2–0 at home in the fourth round of the FA Trophy to secure a place in the semi-final, with both goals scored by McBreen.[116] This was followed by a 2–0 away defeat to Rushden in the league.[117] York's first league victory in a month[34] was a 2–0 home win over Weymouth, who were forced to play a weakened team due to their financial situation, and Brodie scored headers in each half.[118]

March

Ingham made several important saves as York drew 0–0 away to Ebbsfleet.[119] The first leg of the FA Trophy semi-final tie against AFC Telford United ended in a 2–0 away win, with goals in each half from Rusk and Purkiss.[120] A late goal from Sodje with a shot from the edge of the penalty area earned the team a 1–1 draw away to Forest Green Rovers, after Kaid Mohamed had given the home side a first half lead.[121] A 2–1 home win over AFC Telford in the second leg of the FA Trophy semi-final, with goals in each half from Brodie and McBreen, saw York progress into 2009 FA Trophy Final at Wembley Stadium with 4–1 aggregate victory.[122] This was followed by a 0–0 home draw with Kettering in the league.[123] Wilkinson joined divisional rivals Altrincham on loan until the end of the season, having failed to feature in the team since January 2009.[124] York drew 0–0 with play-off contenders Kidderminster at home,[125] which was followed by a 2–0 home defeat to Stevenage.[126]

April and May

York dropped into the relegation zone after a 1–0 away defeat to Grays, who themselves moved out of the relegation zone and above York,[127] and this was followed with a 0–0 home draw with Oxford.[128] They were beaten 2–1 at home by Northwich; Jonny Allan gave the visitors the lead in the first half and Robinson equalised with a penalty on sixty-eight minutes, before Allan scored a stoppage-time winner for Northwich.[129] This was followed by a 0–0 draw away to fellow strugglers Barrow.[130] Before York's penultimate home match against Eastbourne, Parslow was named the 2008–09 Clubman of the Year, voted for by the club's supporters.[131] A 1–0 victory saw York move out of the relegation zone, in what was their first league win in ten matches.[34] It was achieved after McBreen scored from a Purkiss pass in the thirty-fifth minute.[132] A second successive win came at home to Forest Green,[34] who York beat 2–1 with second half goals from Boyes and Brodie.[133]

A 2–1 away victory over Weymouth saw York secure survival from relegation, with their opponents facing relegation as a result.[134] Brodie gave York a fourteenth-minute lead, and after Cliff Akurang equalised for Weymouth late in the first half, Boyes scored the winning goal thirteen minutes from time.[134] York's last league match was a 1–1 away draw with bottom placed Lewes, Greaves scoring on eighty minutes before the home team equalised three minutes from time.[135] This result saw them finish the season seventeenth the table.[136] York were defeated 2–0 by Stevenage in the 2009 FA Trophy Final at Wembley, who scored with second half goals from Steve Morison and Lee Boylan.[137]

Summary and aftermath

York were in a mid-table position for most of the season, and were as high as fifth in August 2008, while dropping as low as twenty-second in April 2009.[34] Their goalscoring record of forty-seven goals scored was the fifth lowest in the division; whereas, their defensive record of fifty-one goals conceded was better than that of the champions Burton.[136] Parslow made the highest number of appearances during the season, appearing in fifty-seven of York's fifty-eight matches.[138] Brodie was York's top scorer in the league and in all competitions, with fifteen league goals and nineteen in total.[96][138] McBreen was the only other player to reach double figures, with ten goals.[96][138]