Note: This story series
includes depictions of gay sex, straight sex, bisexual sex, and incest.
If that's not your thing or if it is illegal for you to read
this
story, then stop. This story is completely made up and does not depict
anything true.
Comments, suggestions, and helpful feedback are welcome - e-mail me

Recap: Four
freshmen pledges have completed two of their three final tasks. The
first was a fuck-a-thon with their sister sorority. The second was
matching fraternity dicks to their owner. Now Ethan, Jaden, Caleb, and
Doug face the results of the second task.

Part Four – Consequences
On the evening after their penis-guessing task, the four pledges
returned to the fraternity basement for the results. It was Tuesday,
November 7 and had started to turn a little chilly. Upon arrival, they
found the entire fraternity as well as Haley.

“Gentlemen, your results,” Chet began. Haley pulled out a piece of
paper and began to read from it.

“Caleb – of 16 dicks, you identified 14 correctly. You swapped Austin
and Noah.
Doug – of 16 dicks, you identified 13 correctly. You swapped Brian,
Logan, and Ethan.
Jaden – of 16 dicks, you identified 12 correctly. You swapped Elijah
and Elisha, and also Caleb and Craig.
Ethan – of 16 dicks, you identified 12 correctly, you swapped Dylan and
Doug, and you swapped Jaden and Logan.”
No one missed more than 4. Together you all missed 13. You each pass
and the group passes. You boys certainly know cock.”

“Jaden, I’m disappointed,” Logan called out. “You’re letting these
straight boys do better on cocks that us homos. Get your head back in
the dick!”

The pledges breathed a sigh of relief. It had turned out Noah and
Austin were each blessed with 8” although in truth they didn’t look a
lot alike, Caleb was actually bigger than his brother, while Logan and
Ethan had similar sized 6” uncut dicks. Brian and Jaden were likewise
uncut and about the same 6.5” or so. And Ethan had gotten confused on
the circumcision status of Dylan and Doug.

“If you’re curious,” Haley added on the way out, “Mackenzie was the
only sorority pledge to get a perfect score in identifying all 17 of
you.”

“And now the consequences,” Chet began after she left. “Knowing your
brothers completely is the responsibility of each pledge. Failing to
identify a significant part of their life is serious indeed – almost an
insult. We have to make sure this never happens again, that you can
identify a brother by any part of his body, especially his manhood.
Therefore, you will each give a blowjob, tonight, to all the brothers
and pledges you misidentified.”

Ethan had been steeling himself for this moment, What he wasn’t
prepared for were the actual specifics: Two fellow pledges, two gay
guys, but worst of all, one of them was his own brother! He wanted to
throw up. Doug was delighted with his punishment. He could finally do
some gay stuff without Dylan giving him shit about it. And he realized
he’d be the first guy to ever blow Ethan. Jaden was kind of pleased
with his results and had to admit that he must have subconsciously
missed the twins and his roommate. Caleb knew this was coming and was
glad he only had to do two, but they were both so big. How did he
confuse them?

“Caleb, you’ll receive your reward only after the successful completion
of the consequences by all of your pledge class. Gentlemen, let’s…”
Before Chet could finish, Brandon cleared his throat and beckoned his
friend over. After a moment of whispering, the other senior boys and
Craig also joined the quiet conversation. Before long, all 13 brothers
were part of the discussion while the four pledges waited. The extra
time only added to both Caleb’s and Ethan’s anxiety. Ethan was
sweating, not sure what he would do.

Finally, the brothers broke and Chet addressed them. “I seem to have
been a little hasty. My brothers have reminded me of some details about
you all. Caleb and Ethan, am I correct that this will be the first
blowjob you’ve ever given?”

As both boys nodded yes, they noticed that Doug wasn’t being asked the
same question. “Well, Caleb, you’re going to have a baptism by fire, as
it were. Both of the brothers you need to pleasure are well-endowed as
you know. If you’d like to practice on someone smaller, I am sure we
can find a volunteer.”

“Now Ethan,” Chet turned to the pale eighteen-year-old. “You never
sucked a dick?” Ethan shook his head. “Have you ever been blown by
guy?” Ethan signaled no again. “Well, have you ever gotten a blowjob?”

“You have a real challenge ahead of you. As you know, you missed
correctly identifying the two biggest guys here. And, then there’s your
brother Logan. The brothers have decided that the normal order must be
adjusted. You will blow Jaden first then Doug then Dylan and then
Logan.”

Jaden didn’t know if that was a signal to begin until Noah pushed him
forward calling to Ethan, “Take off his pants!” Another voice added,
“And get on your knees.”

Ethan had never, ever touched another guy on purpose until the task
yesterday. Having a gay brother, he was well aware of the details and
nature of gay sex, and no longer found himself completely disgusted by
it. But he remained thoroughly straight and didn’t find guys at all
physically attractive. How could he blow four guys while being mildly nauseous?

Ethan then remembered Cornelia. She was a dumpy pimply girl he had met
during a summer on the lake. At a make-out party a friend brought him
to, everyone paired off. Cornelia was the only girl left and matched
with Ethan. Seeing the other guys in action, he had, for his own pride
and honor, kept up with the other guys and ended up messing around with
her. He wasn’t attracted to her. In fact, he didn’t even like thinking
about her. But he powered through and still made her squeal when he
finger-fucked her that night. He had done that and these guys were all
better looking than that skank, using a word that he had hear Neil use
the previous week.

He unzipped Jaden’s pants. The skinny teen kicked them off and then
decided to go completely buff. You can count his ribs, Ethan noticed.
And Jaden was already hard. His cock was similar to Ethan’s. A little
skinnier perhaps and perhaps a little larger.

“I’ll help you through this, buddy,” Jaden whispered, and he began to
offer helpful advice. Ethan, ignoring the fact that 15 guys were
watching his every move, did just as he was told and followed every one
of Jaden’s words instantly. It was easier to concentrate on doing what
he was told than to think about what he was actually doing. Jaden’s
dick felt weird in his mouth. It was warm. His throat
rebelled against the entry and he continually had to struggle with
gagging. But as he relaxed, so did his throat, and he began to move
his head back and forth.

“Use your tongue,” Jaden advised. “You need to stimulate me with more
than just your lips.” Ethan involuntarily shuddered, but understood.
“And stick to the head if you can’t take too much in.” Ethan began to
review the handful blowjobs he’d gotten. He knew he’d need to be
forceful or this would take all night. And he had three much tougher
challenges ahead. The fact that Jaden was gay was actually quite
discomforting to Ethan. Straight guys were only doing it cause they had
to. Jaden desired it. But Jaden was being gentle and so helpful, and
Ethan realized that this was the best first cock to suck.

Since Ethan was doing so well, Chet compelled Caleb to get started on
Austin, and Doug to begin on Brian. Austin called Caleb towards the
couch where the senior dropped his own pants and revealed his skinny
8”. Caleb began to jack him, trying to get him hard. He knew from his
brother that Austin was a bit homophobic, but being a GZO brother he
had to follow the rules. Caleb knew he would have to do some unpleasant
things to get into the fraternity. He figured something gay would
happen. Caleb couldn’t deny that he had once-in-a-while wondered what
it might be like to be with a guy. And especially since he started
rooming with Jaden, he always felt that at any moment he could hook up
with him. Now he’d find out. Nick came by and stood near Austin, his
former roommate, to show support – and to watch Caleb in action.

Always prepared for every task, Caleb had consulted Jaden for some
advice early in the morning in anticipation of what might happen that
night. And he watched Ethan’s initial suck carefully seeing Jaden’s
words put to action. He also successfully solicited a tutorial from
Alexis that afternoon. Using one of her dildos as a model, Caleb had
practiced repeatedly and seemed to have the basics down. Alexis said he
was a natural and she was impressed. But that was on a 9” dildo. This was
a real cock attached to a real person.

When Caleb’s nose hit Austin’s pubes, just shy of all 8” in his throat,
Nick exclaimed with delight, “You’re no first-timer!”

Caleb quickly pulled off and briefly explained his preparation. Nick,
and the other brothers who had gathered around were impressed. Austin
told him to shut the fuck up and get this over with. Caleb’s experience
settled, he went back to work.

Doug had never desired to hide his bisexuality. While he agreed to keep
his physical relationship with Dylan a secret, he was less comfortable
with his brother’s demand that Doug keep a straight profile. As he
unzipped Brian’s pants, he knew the entirety of the frat house would
have a lot more information about him now. He spotted Dylan on the edge
of the room working hard to “not look” at his brother in action.

Doug could suck a cock. He was really good when he was 16 and sucking
the pledge class as part of their blowjob task. He was even better last
year on America’s Teachers. Although it had been a few months, those
skills would never leave him. Brian’s six and a half inches didn’t
present a particular challenge and Doug used his physical strength to
control Brian’s rhythm. Brian was the least known member of the house.
He was very quiet and kept to himself, studying science and building
electronics. He had, in fact, helped expand the hidden camera system in
the basement. While some assumed he was gay, in actuality, he was shy.
6’ tall with curly light brown hair, he had recently begun dating
Erica, a pretty and similarly quiet junior at the ETO house. His only
male-male experiences had been his freshman pledge year and last year’s
pledge class. He was prepared for whatever pledging brought. Being
blown by the 6’3” boyish and beautiful Doug who had a finger up his ass
at this moment, was certainly a more enjoyable gay task than the
previous years.

“Get off…I’m almost there…” Jaden warned Ethan as he tried to help his
straight fellow pledge. Chet had been unclear about swallowing or
facials, so Jaden grabbed his own cock, jerked himself and shot
accidentally hitting Ethan’s shoulder and then mostly the carpet. Jaden
was breathing heavy as his hand slowed and his orgasm subsided. “Not
bad, rookie,” Jaden congratulated Ethan. The straight 18-year-old was a
bit queasy, but also glad to hear he could do a good job. One of the
brothers threw each of them a towel, which they used to wipe up their
sweat and the globs of cum. Ethan went to get a drink of water. Jaden
motioned Craig over to began his consequences.

Brian shot next and Doug swallowed every drop. Brian rarely had found a
girl who would swallow – Erica wasn’t into oral sex at all – and was
completely drained and satisfied. Austin gave Caleb a facial, enjoying
the humiliation he perceived by coating the boy’s face in his jism.
Caleb decided he didn’t like facials and he didn’t like Austin.

Ethan and Doug had to swap blowjobs. For roommates, it was surprising
they both misidentified each other. Ethan was told to go first and soon
he was face to head with the largest dick he would ever touch in his
life. It was 4” longer than Jaden’s and much thicker. It also was
circumcised, which looked so different to Ethan whose own cock was
uncut. Ethan tried to replicate his earlier actions, but found he could
barely get a couple inches in his mouth. Ethan knew enough to use his
hands to stimulate the rest of the cock while he tongue-bathed the
head. The pre-cum surprised him and he thought he’d lose it, but he
once again powered through.

Doug was likewise gentle with his pledge brother, suggesting ways to
make it easier. This conflicted boy was doing a pretty fair job of
cock-sucking, Doug recognized. If you only heard about Ethan – his
caution, his sexual discomfort, his lack of assertiveness, his
awkwardness in many social situations, his clear brother issues – you
might assume he was some dorky looking social misfit. But Ethan was
nearly 6’ tall and in great shape. He was funny when he was relaxed and
wicked smart. He had short dirty blond hair and really great teeth,
Doug had noted. If he only found more confidence, Ethan would be a big
man on campus.

It took about 15 minutes of consistent effort to get Doug to cum. He
too warned Ethan and shot with force over Ethan’s head and onto the
carpet. The next couple volleys landed on Ethan’s left ear, Doug’s
shorts lying on the floor, and Ethan’s leg. After some mopping up, they
switched places. Ethan sat down and Doug leaned in, swallowing Ethan’s
member completely. Ethan couldn’t believe his roommate was blowing him.
Logan was still watching his brother intently, but had thus far
remained silent. Ethan was surprised that he had gotten pretty charged
up from giving head, so he found himself involuntarily getting hard
quickly. Doug’s skilled mouth took over then. This was without a doubt
the most physically pleasing blowjob in his whole life. It wasn’t long
before he too had his cum swallowed by Doug, his first ever blowjob
from a guy. And, he hoped, his last.

Jaden finished Craig off quickly and then turned to Caleb who was right
there. It had been fascinating for Caleb to watch his brother get
sucked by a guy up close. He had no idea what gay experiences Craig
might have had, but Caleb had to admit that even though it was queer –
and even though it was his brother – he was fascinated. Per Doug's
suggestion, Caleb had blocked the whole experience with Chloe out of
his mind. But staring at his brother, it came back and he couldn’t help
but imagine his siblings together in one position or another. Chloe
might be in Jaden’s role…or Caleb might be.

As Jaden began to pleasure his own roommate, Caleb realized he had
gotten hard staring at his brother’s dick being sucked. He was a
twisted fuck. But he was a horny one and. Jaden didn’t need to do too
much to bring his roommate to climax. Jaden was disappointed that
Caleb’s first male blowjob was over so quickly. As he always did, he
swallowed up every drop from Craig and Caleb.

All four pledges had now been blown by one of their own. How times have
changed, Dylan thought, as Ethan went to work on him. Three years ago,
it had taken days of sex to get his pledge class to experiment gay –
and Austin never blew anyone, he remembered. Now, as a matter of
course, he had a completely straight boy trying to tame his python
simply because the fraternity had told them so. That was Chet’s
influence on the pledging process.

Noah had a dick similar to Austin’s, but thicker. At 21, Noah was
simply hot. His smile, his eyes, his abs, his ass – all were
captivating. He even made the fuzz on his chin work, where Caleb
usually thought it looked silly. As Caleb began to suck, he wondered
how many girls had done this in Noah’s busy sexual career. He knew
Austin preferred a fuck to a blowjob, but Mackenzie had mentioned that
Noah was a huge fan of fellatio, and Autumn’s reluctance to suck him
regularly had led him to Riley and then later to Mackenzie. Caleb knew
he couldn’t match those girls, but he’d give it his all to complete his
consequences. For some reason, he didn’t want to disappoint.

Just a few feet from where Ethan was trying to get his mouth around
Dylan, Doug was sucking Logan. Here were the younger brothers sucking
the other’s brother. Doug looked up at his brother mournfully. He
wanted to be where Ethan was. Dylan wasn’t really enjoying his blowjob.
Ethan was having trouble with Dylan’s size – and Dylan usually took a
while to cum from only fellatio. But he was more concerned because this
was bringing up lots of old feelings. Dylan had been able to completely
mask his gay experiences of late from the world – and his lingering
lust for his brother from himself. Now everything was potentially
falling apart.

Doug wished he could find a way to get Dylan to be open to being
intimate with each other again and get past whatever Puritan hang-ups
he projected his brother was having. Doug also noticed that Logan was
completely naturally hairless – and in other places, he was shaved. But
Ethan wasn’t hairless at all. Doug thought that was odd for two
brothers. Logan watched Ethan with a smile - he was next. Ethan was too
focused on finishing the task at hand to notice others.

Jaden beckoned the twins, Elijah and Elisha, to sit next to each other
on the couch. He asked them to remove all their clothes revealing that
their trim bodies were really fit and truly identical. They both left
on the rimless glasses that made them look smart and clever and totally
adorable. Most guys have had a sexual fantasy about identical twin
girls. For Jaden, it had always been about two boys. From the moment he
saw them, he needed to consume them, but they both presented themselves
as straight. Jaden’s gaydar had unclear signals about them, but now was
his chance.

Their dicks did truly lean slightly left and right. With his fantasy
ready to go, Jaden began sucking one boy’s dick and jacking the other.
He moved back and forth and back and forth between the two quickly
erect cocks, delaying the end, and heightening the sexual tension.

“Fuck it, just suck me!” Elisha demanded in lust. While he still rubbed
Elijah’s identical 7-incher, Jaden devoted his entire mouth to
pleasuring Elisha. With all the starts and stops of earlier, Elisha and
Elijah were both ready to burst. Elisha came down Jaden’s throat, and
Elijah shot within a minute of Jaden mouth engulfing him. Jaden was
again disappointed to have finished so quickly. Maybe he’d be able to
arrange another rendezvous.

Noah and Logan both came at about the same moment. Caleb tried
swallowing this time mostly because he didn’t want another a shot of
cum in the eye. Much of it dribbled out the sides of his mouth, and
Caleb found it slimy, but Noah declared it was a decent blowjob. Caleb
was surprisingly delighted to hear that. Logan, transfixed on the sight
of his brother working on Dylan’s enormous dick, finally couldn’t hold
back. Doug naturally swallowed it all.

Dylan continued to take a while. With Ethan’s amateur, but earnest
efforts, it took even longer and the poor freshman’s jaw was throbbing
in pain. But Dylan did cum at last and did so without warning, nearly
killing Ethan whose mouth, filled with this huge dick, had trouble
adding the streams of cum to the mix. “Sorry,” Dylan muttered
recognizing his thoughts had been somewhere else and with someone else.

When Ethan had gained his composure and had something to drink, Chet
signaled everyone to listen. “Great work boys! Everyone has completed
his blowjobs, except for one. Ethan needs to blow Logan.”

Logan had known this was coming for 24 hours. Chet had shared with all
the brothers the list of which pledge missed which identification. At
first, he thought it was hysterical that his own brother missed him.
Then he was kind of bummed that his dick was apparently identical to
17-year-old Jaden’s. Then he was depressed knowing the anxiety that
this would cause Ethan – they may not have been the closest of
brothers, but he still cared for Ethan’s well-being. Finally, he was
delighted – Ethan would lose his supposed moral high ground when he
judged Logan’s actions.

Ethan had not had time to process this. So he simply looked at Chet and
said, “No.”

Experience had shown Chet how to get beyond this moment. A combination
of time, pride, praise, peer pressure, and the desire for the ultimate
reward: Fraternity Membership. “You’ve come so far, Ethan,” Chet began,
“why make it all a waste? Why did you do the others if you won’t do
this?”

“I may have given into the peer pressure tonight and completed my tasks,
however much I might not have preferred to do them. But this is just
really wrong. It’s incest. It’s immoral. It’s just not right,” Ethan
was struggling for the right words. He knew he couldn’t – and shouldn’t
– argue this on the grounds of homosexuality, but incest he figured was
safe.

“I don’t think it is actually technically incest,” Craig interrupted –
but no one wanted to hear.

“You’d be surprised what has been done in this room,” Chet was talking
calmly and compassionately. “Just a few days ago, you saw Caleb and
Chloe together. And among your brothers are all sorts of stories and
secrets.” The brothers shifted uncomfortably. Caleb, Doug, Elijah,
Elisha, Craig, Austin, Dylan, and Chet had all been with a brother or
sister as a result of fraternity pledging. And who knew what else some
of the brothers had done outside of fraternity life? “You just sucked
three dicks. And did it quite well. Close your eyes and do number four.
Otherwise, hasn’t everything you’ve already done been in vain?”

Ethan looked to his brother for support. But Logan’s face simply seemed
to say, “fraternity rules superseded all else during pledge tasks.”
Ethan asked for a few minutes to think. He sat down with a strong drink
in his hand.

Jaden was baffled as to what would happen. He had heard Ethan’s
discomfort towards homosexuality, and especially towards Logan, spewing
all year long. Jaden was shocked when Ethan blew him. But sucking his
own brother? Jaden had done some crazy stuff in the 4 ½ years he
had been “sexually active.” He had been with two brothers separately
and he and his sister had shared a guy, but he had never seen two
siblings having sex until Chloe sucked Caleb. Jaden’s brothers were
much younger than him so he had never even really thought about it for
himself.

Caleb, however, had imagined having sex with a sibling. Sex with Chloe
had been a fantasy. Sex between Craig and Chloe was something he had
visualized, only recently realizing it had happened when Craig
was a freshman. Sex between Caleb and Craig – that had never occurred
to him. Until he watched Jaden suck Craig. And he discovered that he
wasn’t that shocked by the idea.

Having engaged in an on-again, off-again very physical relationship
with Dylan, brotherly sex was part of Doug’s world. Plus, he had
discovered some things about Ethan’s resentment towards gay sex. Much
of it was simply a substitute for being mad that Logan stopped spending
time with him when he started getting physical with boys. Being at a
university with out gay classmates had forced Ethan to rethink his
discomforts. Jaden was the first gay person other than his brother that
Ethan had really taken the time to know. It was eye-opening. But the
biggest influence was Brandon.

Before Logan and Brandon began to date, his brother was a sex-crazed
bundle of hormones. He was dismissive and harsh to Ethan and shoved his
free sexuality in his brother’s face. Logan had never sought to
maintain a intimate relationship. But since Logan and Brandon became a
couple, Ethan saw positive changes in his brother. Furthermore, Brandon
was impressive in every way – brilliant, self-made, successful,
popular, friendly, kind, caring for his brother, and, even Ethan
recognized he was one great-looking guy. Ethan would never be able to
forget the vivid image of walking in on Logan getting butt-fucked by
the 20something cable installer when Logan was 14 and Ethan was 12. Nor
the seemingly endless parade of boys that snuck in and out of their
house – often through Ethan’s bedroom window – to sneak a quickie with
his brother. It had made Ethan uncomfortable around sex because his
brother was so loose with it. But Brandon was different. He was someone
to love and idolize – and Brandon was gay. Brandon had helped Logan
become a socialized, reasonable, even moral human being. Doug had
noticed that Ethan had begun to accept both his brother’s sexuality and
his brother.

When rationalizing, one small fact can be all you need to do something
otherwise impossible. Having already sucked three dicks, Ethan wasn’t
stuck on the blowjob part of the task. A fourth tonight wouldn’t make
much of a difference in the long run. It was the brother thing. That
was the new wrinkle that he was having trouble getting past. But that one
small fact can be what you hang major actions upon. “He isn’t really my
brother,” Ethan reminded himself. “Not by blood.” Logan’s parents
hadn’t planned on having a second child for several more years after
Logan was born. 20 months after Logan’s birth, his parents’ best
friends were killed in a car wreck while their four-month-old son was
home with a nanny. With no family capable of raising the child, they
had brought little baby Ethan home and soon after adopted him. He had
never known another family and his parents had loved him no differently
than they loved Logan. But, technically, Logan wasn’t his brother.

That fact was enough for Ethan. He sighed, chugged a second drink, and then
gave a weak wave of his hand to direct his brother to the couch. All of
the fraternity brothers had seen brother-on-brother sex. The memory of
Elijah and Elisha together from last year’s class would always stay
with them. So as Ethan took his brother’s already hard dick
and put it in his mouth, the boys, outside of Caleb, had
neither the shock nor titillation one might expect. However, Ethan’s
latent hostility to gay people all year long and Logan’s “essence of
queerness,” as Nick called it, created a tension charged atmosphere
that seemed to excite them all.

Ethan’s jaw ached. Doug and Dylan had been a massive task. He had
wrapped his jaw around two giant salamis for who knew how long. His
brother’s dick was a relief in comparison, but didn’t soothe his aches.
He really wanted to get this over with and then forget about. If he
ever could.

Logan began to push his brother’s head with force. His hips thrusting
forward aggressively. Ethan was not yet a skilled cocksucker and Logan
enjoyed receiving a masterly tongue. Doug had shown some impressive
talents and Logan knew it’d take longer to cum this second time in such
a short period. But he was 20 and he was looking at his naked little
brother sucking on him. Who would have thought it? He had won. All
those years of Ethan judging him, looking upon him as if he was some
sort of lesser person because he was gay and because he was with a lot
of guys were all past. He would have this moment to hold over him and
the power surged through Logan.

Things weren’t progressing the way Ethan might have wanted. Logan
seemed no closer to orgasm after an extended period of sucking than he
had at the start. They shifted positions with Logan lying back on the
couch with Ethan on his knees from the floor approaching from above.
Logan then saw something that changed the whole meaning of the event.
Ethan was hard. He could see his brother’s erection poking against the
couch. Occasionally, Ethan dropped an unconscious hand on it. His
brother, Logan realized, wasn’t disgusted in the moment, but turned on.

Logan didn’t want to waste the moment. Ethan might not be aware of his
body’s responses, but Logan would make him aware. He maneuvered Ethan
to climb more onto the couch. Ethan’s naiveté blinded him to
what was about to happen. He stretched out to swallow Logan’s cock
again, his own legs reaching towards Logan’s head. Then he felt an
unexpected sensation. Logan had grabbed his legs and swallowed his
little brother’s dick himself. Ethan was unable to process this fact
and then found Logan’s cock was again pushing against his lips, so he
opened wide.

Some of the brothers began to more openly jerk-off watching this
brotherly 69. Caleb was surprised to see Craig totally into it and
unashamed to slap his salami in public watching his former roommate
blow his little brother. Caleb’s cheery red-headed brother was
revealing all sorts of new sides to him. And, he thought, he was
looking really good too. Fraternity president agreed with him. His acne
was a thing of the past. He was in shape and had more muscle
definition. He even was trimming his red curly pubic hair, Craig noted.
He looked damn good. And it had paid off. He knew Craig had slept with
at least a dozen of the girls in ETO, probably more.

For five minutes the brothers slurped on each other’s man popsicle.
Logan, being so much more skilled, got a quicker response from his
little brother. Ethan dropped Logan’s cock out of his mouth and grunted
a few times as he came and spewed into Logan’s mouth. When he had
finished, he took a few quick breaths and resumed his task. Logan, his
mouth free, offered a few suggestions. Finally, Ethan used his hand to
aggressively jerk off his brother who came suddenly fully into Ethan’s
face.

A round of applause burst from the group watching, even as a few
disappeared into various bathrooms to relieve themselves. Logan and
Ethan were each handed towels to clean up. Logan looked kindly at his
brother as he watched him rub his own spunk of his face. Ethan couldn’t
look at anyone in the eye and after a visit to the bathroom, sat
quietly on the couch with another stiff drink.

After a short break, the other three pledges, now fully clothed, sat
next to Ethan and gave him silent support. Chet then addressed them,
reading from a typed sheet.

“Your next – and final – task will begin on Thursday night and is
called ‘fantasy fulfillment.’ Each of the pledges will draw the name of
a fraternity brother and a sorority sister. Those whose names are drawn
can request anything they want from the pledge that can be completed in
one session. The pledge must comply. If the brother or sister requests
an action that requires a specific individual other than the pledge,
there must be alternate choices given in case that specific individual
refuses. The brothers and sisters have also been given secret
instructions regarding limitations and requirements of their requests.”

The four pledges each raised their eyebrows in confusion.

“I told you it was too wordy,” Nick interrupted. “It’s simple: You’ll
pull a name. That person can ask you to do anything or arrange anything
– although it’ll probably be sexual in nature. They can’t make you a
sex slave for a week or anything – only a one time event.”

Chet continued Nick’s explanation. “And if the person says, as well
they should, I want to have sex with Chet, well what if I refuse? Which
I wouldn’t, but if I did, the person must have other names in mind. But
if they want to do something with you, well, you can’t refuse. There
are also a few surprises that’ll you’ll see. And this will be
surprising for us since we don’t know what names you’ll draw or what
each person wants, Thursday will be a real wild card.”

The pledges nodded to each other and to Chet that they understood and
got ready to leave. “One more thing,” Chet called to them, stopping
them in the move to the stairs. “We still have Caleb’s reward for
winning the identification game. That’s two-in-a-row, Caleb.
Impressive. You’re more of a success than even your carrot-topped
brother.”

Craig punched Chet for this remark who simply kept going. “Your reward,
Caleb, for knowing best the dicks of the 16 others in this room, is to
have someone know your dick. You may pick anyone…from among the 16 of
us and that brother or pledge needs to give you a full, awesome
blowjob.”

Caleb was only mildly surprised by the reward. He had a sneaking
suspicion – and Doug had agreed that this was likely. He looked around
the room. Jaden had already blown him tonight, so that was out. Ethan
had gone through enough. It seemed cooler to make someone straight do
it, so that eliminated Logan and Brandon. Dylan kind of intimidated him
and Doug was becoming such a good friend – plus there was something
about Doug’s past that he wasn’t telling them. He wanted to know more
first. He worried about asking the pledge master, Chet, and what it
might mean and Austin was an ass. He didn’t really know Brian, Shaun,
and Neil, so that held no interest. He was left with the twins, Noah,
and Nick. How could he choose one twin over the other? He couldn’t tell
them apart most days. Noah was intriguing – reciprocation for the
earlier blowjob and making this “player” kneel before him. And as for
Nick, well he was so much fun – probably the fraternity brother that
Caleb was the most attracted to as a friend, outside of Doug. If he
made Nick do it, that budding friendship might fall apart.

“What’s your decision?” Chet interrupted Caleb’s silent analysis.

I guess, Noah it is, Caleb thought. But he realized the words hadn’t
actually come out of his mouth. And then he understood why. The answer
was obvious. How had he not realized it immediately? His subconscious
was smarter than his conscious. Could he do that? What would everyone
say? What did it mean? In uncharacteristic spontaneity, Caleb just went
for it.

Caleb cleared his throat, stood up a little taller, and in the most
relaxed and casual voice he could find, said, “I choose my brother,
Craig.”

To be continued...

Check out my other stories on Nifty:Pledge Class - The Blow Job Task
(Found in Bisexual:College) - Five fraternity pledges are given their
final challenge: Give each other a blowjob or get their girlfriend or
sibling to take their place (7 parts, last post 1/15/06) /nifty/bisexual/college/pledge-classThe Sex Life of Zack and Cody (Found
in Gay:Celebrity) - Zack and Cody Martin discover they have more in
common than just being identical twins one afternoon in their suite.
(posted 2/24/06) /nifty/gay/celebrity/sex-life-of-zack-and-codyYouth Group - Hotel Room Truth or Dare
(Found in Gay:High School) - Four high school students - a junior, his
freshman younger brother, his junior best friend, and a senior - are
stuck in a hotel room together on a youth group trip. With nothing to
do, they decide to play truth or dare with unexpected results. (3
parts, last post 3/21/06) /nifty/bisexual/highschool/youth-group