Society for Humanistic Psychology

Tuesday, October 20, 2015

A Discussion of a Hermeneutics of Love versus a Hermeneutics of Suspicion

by Alexandria Bright, Point Park University

On
Sunday, September 13, 2015, while stopping to eat during a “typical adventure
trip through the White Desert,” in Egypt, a group of Mexican tourists were
gunned down by an Egyptian Apache helicopter.At least two people were killed while many more were wounded.Despite their Egyptian police escorts and valid
permits to be on the trail, these innocent tourists were mistaken for
terrorists and attacked (Thomas,Kirkpatrick, Malsin, & Malkin, 2015).

This brief summary of an article
from the New York Times is an example
that I wish to use to begin to describe and differentiate between the
interpretative stances of a hermeneutics of suspicion
and a hermeneutics of love.Although brief in description, there are many
elements I believe that this mistaken, and not so rare, killing of civilians in
the name of “justice” might reveal to us about the dangers inherent in
interpreting through a hermeneutic of suspicion, as well as the potentiality
for an increased openness, understanding, and empathy towards others in
shifting to an interpretative stance of love.

In Borne Forward Ceaselessly Into Love: A Theory of the Hermeneutics of Love Exemplified by Martin Luther King Jr., Jennifer Selig utilizes the teachings of Martin
Luther King Jr. to both depict a practice and describe a theory of a
hermeneutics of love.Selig states her
loose definition of a hermeneutics of love, “as a way of interpreting
experiences and people…with love, through
love, and for love” (Selig, pg.
2, 2015).She presents how King
interprets with, through, and for love utilizing the definition of agape love as used by the Greeks.As cited in Selig (2015), King explains this
form of love as it was understood by the Greeks in his sermon “Loving Your
Enemies”.

The Greek language comes out with another word for love.It is the word agape.And agape is more than eros; agape is more than philia; agape is something of the understanding, creative, redemptive
goodwill for all men.It is a love that
seeks nothing in return.It is an
overflowing love; it’s what theologians would call the love of God working in
the lives of men.And when you rise to
love on this level, you begin to love men, not because they are likeable, but
because God loves them.You look at
every man, and you love him because you know God loves him.And he might be the worst person you’ve ever
seen (pg. 7).

Agape for the Greeks and for King was seen as an abundant and deep
caring for human beings that went far beyond likeability or tolerance for
others.This is the kind of love through
which King interpreted the acts of hate and persecution he received from others,
and it is this agape love that is
seen as the foundation of interpretation through a hermeneutics of love.In her article, Selig goes on to break down
each of the three facets of this type of love that, for King, made this the
most vital and effective route to transformation, both for the individual and
for society as a whole.

In Brent Robbins’ article, The Heart of Humanistic Psychology: Human Dignity Disclosed Through aHermeneutic of Love, an interpretive stance of agape love emerges from the
understanding and belief that human beings have a kind of preciousness and dignity that differentiates them from
objects or things in the world (p. 2-3).It is this notion of dignity
that is the ontological basis for humanistic psychology as a hermeneutic of
love (p. 7).To describe what determines
one to have dignity, Robbins (2015)
uses the work of Immanuel Kant andpresents
a paradoxical understanding of dignity
in that it is the fact that human beings are finite beings, mortal beings whose worth has no equivalent match,
which gives them infinite worth.And it is in this “pricelessness” that
therein lies one’s dignity (p. 5).

With an epistemology
grounded in phenomenology, the
understanding of dignity in
humanistic psychology stems from the understanding that human beings bring
something unique and specific to their experiences through the ways in which
they make meaning from their experiences (p. 7).Through recognition as beings with intrinsic worth, humanistic psychology,
according to Robbins (2015), has an ethical
obligation to preserve and protect the basic
human rights of all human beings (p. 7).

This event that took place in Egypt last month demonstrates
the lack of a hermeneutics of love in the interpretation of the situation that
ironically and tragically results in the killing and wounding of innocent
civilians.The impulsive way in which
this attack was carried out by the Egyptian military alludes to a “shoot now,
ask questions later attitude” that, when dealing with terrorists, seems to be
the appropriate and widely accepted stance to take in the evermore present “War
on Terror”.In this instance it may be
argued that those who carried out the attack were operating more from a
hermeneutics of suspicion, seeing through a “mood of fear” (Robbins, 2015, p.
9), than from one of love, that sees with the eyes of “charity, empathy, and
openness” (p. 9).

In Hunting Terrorists:
A Look at the Psychopathology of Terror, Joe Navarro presents an outline of
what distinguishes the mind of a terrorist from those of others.One of the qualities on which he focuses is passionate hatred that, when present, dehumanizes
and devalues others to such a great degree that their dignity and worth as
human beings is no longer seen (2013, p. 55).“Passionate hatred blinds the terrorist, shunting logic; that can lead
to risk-taking, making mistakes, and exposing others, including the innocent,
to unnecessary danger” (p. 57).

He continues to explain these characteristics of terrorists,
reducing them down to comorbidpsychopathologies of terror.Much as cognitive-behaviorists might, these
people are no longer identified as individual human beings, but categorized by
their symptoms and seen as a kind of tumor that, “…we must surgically target…”
(p. 112).Navarro uses an intentional stance of cognitive
psychology where he presents these characteristics to describe the cognitive framework of a terrorist through
which the actions of terrorism are explained as a means to reach the end goal
(Widdershoven, 1999, p. 246).From an
interpretative stance of a hermeneutics of suspicion, Navarro informs his
readers of how to uncover a potential terrorist in their midst and expresses
that it is only through an understanding of the psychopathology of terror that terrorists can be successfully
“hunted” (p. 113).Throughout this book
he creates a totality of the
terrorist.Providing a specific list of
symptoms and reducing human beings, who may or may not exhibit these symptoms,
to the overarching term terrorist and
in doing this he, according to McInerney (2015), “assaults the dignity” of
those others much in the same way that the terrorists, which whom he is against,
do to those they attack (p. 10).

One might argue that the finitude of the “terrorist” is not
taken at the same level as any other “innocent” human being.Their human dignity is no longer recognized
when operating from a hermeneutics of suspicion.The Egyptian military thought they were
protecting their country in shooting down these “terrorists”, but in this act,
in this mistake, they themselves became the terrorists.In agreement with how Navarro (2013)
describes what passionate hatred does
to an individual, Selig (2015) presents Martin Luther King’s opinion on how
hate distorts one’s vision so much so that one will behave in “irrational” ways
and if not remedied, the hate will become all-consuming to the very personality
of the hater (p. 9).This example speaks
to exactly the reasons that Martin Luther King practiced and preached the
propagation of nonviolence.

The Beloved
Community, as discussed by both Selig (2015) and Robbins
(2015) was Martin Luther King’s vision for a peaceful society- his idea of a
“heaven on earth”, and it was towards this end that King structured his social
activist movement with agape at its
center.“For King, agape was the cure
for individual and social pathology; the key to individual and social
redemption and transformation; and the necessary power and principle to enact
the coming cultural and worldwide revolution—agape coupled with nonviolent resistance”
(Selig, 2015, p. 11).With the
nonviolent ideas of Gandhi paired with his personal Christian ontology
inspiring him, King was convinced and certain that this beloved community could and would only be achieved through nonviolent
means that were congruent with the community he endeavored to create (p. 11).

For Robbins (2015), humanistic psychology is the vehicle
through which psychologists can do their part in creating King’s Beloved Community (p. 8).Unlike the implementation of a hermeneutics
of suspicion utilized by Freudian psychoanalysts, which seeks to “demystify”
and see past the “illusions” that are concealing the “real meanings of symbols”
(Itao, 2010, p. 4).Psychotherapy
grounded in a hermeneutics of love or faith,
as Itao (2010) describes in Paul
Ricoeur’s Hermeneutics of Symbols:A
Critical Dialectic of Suspicion and Faith, employs a hermeneutic centered
on “… the belief that the symbol which calls for interpretation is saying
something truthful, meaningful, and worthwhile” (p. 8).This stance, according to Robbins (2015), is
an essential and determining element of humanistic psychology (p. 9).

This recent tragedy in Egypt is an extreme example of what a
world operating from a hermeneutics of suspicion looks like, but through it one
might gain a deeper understanding for what nonviolent social activists like
Martin Luther King and Gandhi taught and propagated through their actions.When one fights hatred with hatred, there is
only a society of hatred to be found. But through the stance of love, a stance that
accepts human beings as they are and therefore, allows an opening for perhaps
the mutual recognition of dignity that might call each party to employ an ethical caring toward one another
(Robbins, 2015, p. 7).This may
eventually bring about a kind of therapeutic transformation when enacted on
personal, societal, and worldwide levels.

Monday, October 19, 2015

In an article by Swedish scholar, Hildur Kalman, she explores the concept of "successful sexuality" and its relevance to the phenomenon of the faked orgaism. Kalman explores survey research from Nordic countries which examines the extent to which women fake orgasm and their stated reasons for doing so. The author raises new questions in regard to the faked orgasm which touch upon the role of the lived body and sexuality not only as an expression of love, or a way to gain pleasure, but also as a way to fit in, to be "normal" and to be "successful" at sexuality. The paper's analysis recommends a capacity to play as vital to moving beyond sex as a performative, instrumental activity and, instead, toward sexual expression as an end in itself, with or without orgasm.

The article is available full-text on-line at the interdisciplinary journal, Janus Head.

Carl Rogers remains one of the most influential psychologists in the field, and continues to inspire not only humanistic psychologists, but psychological theory and practice across the entire field of psychology. Research evidence continues to support many of Rogers' key concepts.

In the latest study, researchers Carmel Proctor, Roger Tweed, and Daniel Morris (2015) studied the fully functioning person from a positive psychology perspective, drawing upon constructs commonly used to measure indicators of well-being. In their study, they used a variety of measurements to examine constructs such as life satisfaction, positive thoughts and feelings, authenticity, organismic valuing, aspirations, basic psychological needs, anxiety and the use of strengths. As expected, the found that one factor, dubbed the "fully functioning person" factor, was identified using variables akin to Rogers' theory of the fully functioning person.

The researchers looked at correlations between the fully functioning person, and various indicators of psychological well-being. The fully functioning person factor was positively related to life satisfaction and positive thoughts and feelings, while negatively related to negative thoughts and feelings, as well as anxiety. In addition, participants who ranked high on scores of fully functioning were more likely to endorse intrinsic, rather than extrinsic, values.

The researchers also examined correlations between the fully functioning person and various character strengths. They found that a fully functioning personality was positively related to virtues such as enthusiasm, bravery, honesty, leadership, and spirituality. However, the fully functioning personality was negatively related to modesty and fairness traits.

Saturday, April 4, 2015

A qualitative study interviewed 1 male and 12 female mental health providers working at torture treatment centers. The mental health providers were all members of the National Consortium of Torture Treatment Programs with a range of 4-30 years of experience working with trauma victims. The researchers -- Pilar Hernandez-Wolfe, Kyle Killian, David Engstrom, and David Gensei (2015) -- performed a modified grounded theory method to identify themes in the interviews.

The analysis of the qualitative data identified themes relevant to both vicarious resilience and vicarious trauma. The trauma workers identified themes of vicarious trauma including sleep disruption, nightmares, fearfulness, irritability, fatigue, flashbacks, intrusive thoughts, dissociation, hyperarousal, negative affect, and numbness. Themes of vicarious resilience were also discovered and included changes in goals or priorities, increased hopefulness and client-based inspiration, change/impact on spiritual beliefs and practices, increases in self-care practices, increased resiliency and perspective-taking on one's own challenges, increased racial, cultural and structural consciousness, and awareness of relative privilege, marginalization, and oppression.

The researchers noted, "trauma therapists can be potentially transformed by their clients' resilience in positive, but not painless, ways. Choosing to work in the trauma field with survivors of torture and politically motivated violence involves immersion in profound ongoing experiences of intertwined pain, joy, and hope, and expanding the boundaries of self -- personally and professionally" (p. 153).

Tuesday, March 31, 2015

In a new study published in Journal of Humanistic Psychology, Jane Simms conducted case studies of three victims of political violence in Northern Ireland. The study was guided by the model of growth developed by Tedeschi and Calhoun. The case study participants reported greater appreciation of life and changed relationships resulting from their trauma, and new possibilities that emerged from these changes. All but one participant felt increased personal strength, although all participants continue to struggle with distress in their lives. Religion and spirituality appeared to play a role in the narratives of the participants in ways that distinguished the participants from the others. A full text version of the article is available here.

Wednesday, March 25, 2015

A recently published study coauthored by Division 32 Fellow Jonathan Raskin looks at psychologist attitudes toward the DSM-5 and finds that psychologists are not particularly satisfied with the manual.

Raskin, along with his coauthor and SUNY New Paltz colleague Michael Gayle, surveyed over 100 psychologists. They found that even though over 90% of psychologists report using the DSM, they are dissatisfied with numerous aspects of it and support developing alternatives to it.

The full study has been published in the Journal of Humanistic Psychology. It currently appears as an advance online publication and will appear in an upcoming print issue. For the abstract and access to the article in full, see the JHP website.

Sunday, March 22, 2015

Evidence-Based Practice in Psychology is the current dominant paradigm for evaluating psychotherapy practice. At best, its aim is to help assure that therapists develop and utilize the appropriate clinical skills and employ strategies to help clients that are rooted in evidence, broadly understood. This replaces, though is often confused with, the previous paradigm of the empirically supported treatments, which sought to determine which rigidly applied modalities were appropriate for psychotherapy with particular diagnoses or problems based upon a more narrowly defined type of evidence.

While existential therapy is often criticized for lacking evidence based support for its practice, the article "Emotion, Relationship, and Meaning as Core Existential Practice: Evidence-Based Foundations” by Hoffman, Vallejos, Cleare-Hoffman, and Rubin provides strong evidence to help dispel this misconception. Drawing upon the standards of evidence-based practice, the authors utilize recent research and scholarship to demonstrate that when an appropriately trained and skilled therapist utilizes an existential therapy approach, it is consistent with the principles of evidence-based practice in psychology. This article should prove useful for existential therapists advocating for this approach in managed care and other settings that sometimes discourage its use with clients.

The article identifies how existential therapy's relational focus, emphasis on working with emotion and experience, and meaning-centered approach is an empirically valid approach to working therapeutically with a wide variety of clinical issues.

Contributors

Mission Statement

Humanistic psychology aims to be faithful to the full range of human experience. Its foundations include philosophical humanism, existentialism, and phenomenology. In the science and profession of psychology, humanistic psychology seeks to develop systematic and rigorous methods of studying human beings, and to heal the fragmentary character of contemporary psychology through an ever more comprehensive and integrative approach. Humanistic psychologists are particularly sensitive to uniquely human dimensions, such as experiences of creativity and transcendence, and to the quality of human welfare. Accordingly, humanistic psychology aims especially at contributing to psychotherapy, education, theory, philosophy of psychology, research methodology, organization and management, and social responsibility and change.