7. “I Dreamed a Dream”

OK, one more. Their voices just come together so seamlessly! Plus, as much as we all love Anne Hathaway’s racking sobs, there’s also something nice about a cleaner version of the song. The crying is implied.

9. “Gorgeous”

You may not be as familiar with Idina’s music career off Broadway — this is a good example. “Gorgeous” is obviously more pop and rock than most of the other numbers on the list. Hey, we could all use a little variety, right?

11. “Defying Gravity”

And here it is — her signature song. Kristin Chenoweth is great, too, but this is Elphaba’s number. Regardless of how you feel about Wicked as a whole, this is truly one of Broadway’s great showstoppers.

12. “What I Did for Love”

Always a good (and melancholy) number to close on. Here’s Idina’s rendition of the gorgeous Chorus Line song. She adds some creative flourishes a couple minutes in, and that’s when her performance really becomes her own.