In Sweden, A Tempered Approach To Nuclear Waste

European geologists have conducted experiments in caverns like this one, at the Aspo Hard Rock Laboratory, since 1995. The Swedish nuclear company SKB hopes to store used nuclear fuel more than 1,500 feet below ground.

A model of a storage container illustrates how used nuclear fuel will be placed in cast-iron inserts, then encapsulated in large copper cannisters and buried more than 1,500 feet down in the Swedish bedrock.

As many as 10,000 people per year visit the underground Aspo Hard Rock Laboratory in Sweden — a test area for used nuclear fuel. Asa Nielsson (left) encourages visitors to the caverns to touch samples of clay that will be used to help seal canisters of the fuel.

Jacob Spangenberg, the mayor of Osthammar municipality, says the nuclear waste repository could lead to an economic boost, provided strict safety assurances are met.

Ingrid BeckerKQED

Listen

Listening...

/

Originally published on July 28, 2011 8:13 pm

First in a two-part series about the long-term storage of nuclear waste. Read Part 2

At least two dozen countries around the globe get energy from nuclear power, yet not one has been able to pull off a permanent disposal site. Finding communities willing to live with such dangerous stuff has been a big sticking point. But in Sweden, two communities have stepped up, and are willing to take the country's waste.

Like many countries, Sweden has had its share of political meltdowns over nuclear power. Protests stirred an uproar in the early 1980s when the Swedish nuclear industry simply decided where to begin testing for a possible geologic disposal site.

But today, instead of deflecting protesters, the nuclear industry shuttles visitors by the busloads for guided tours of facilities. More than 1,100 feet below the surface, exotic machinery and copper tubes wide enough to fit two men fill an underground cavern carved from crystalline bedrock.

In this working lab in eastern Sweden, a private nuclear waste company tests methods for permanently storing used fuel. It plans to encase the fuel rods in copper capsules, then bury them 1,500 feet down in bedrock where it is supposed to sit for the next 100,000 years.

"It's very exciting to see, and it's an enormous project," says Jonathan Svensson, who is studying nuclear safety as part of his government job. "Just the time scale is incomprehensible."

Communicating With The Community

So how did nuclear waste in Sweden go from a toxic topic to a field trip? People in the area said the industry needed to start over with things like public participation, a transparent, predictable process and trust. The industry took these lessons to heart.

"We know that we have to meet people and communicate what we want to do, why we want to do it and how we will find a place for it," says Inger Nordholm, a spokeswoman for the Swedish Nuclear Fuel and Waste Management Company, or SKB.

Initially, company officials spent a lot of time just having coffee with people, explaining their plans. Then they began focusing on towns with stable geology, but also places where the people were used to living near nuclear power plants.

Oskarshamn was one of two communities in eastern Sweden that stepped forward after nuclear waste officials asked for volunteers willing to let them start geologic testing. Charlotte Lilliemark, who lives about 12 miles north of the town, was just the kind of person a nuclear power executive would want to avoid.

The former Stockholmer moved to the country to raise dressage horses and didn't want a waste dump anywhere near her.

"I couldn't see anything that was positive," she says. But then local government officials asked her to lead a community advisory group. She says they told her: "We think you could contribute to the work — we need to open all the questions and be clear and transparent, and we want you to participate if you want to."

And she did.

Over coffee in the kitchen with her daughter, Lilliemark says she has spent 10 years studying the issues and advocating for her community. In the end, her community wasn't selected for the repository but through her involvement with the issue, Lilliemark says she learned a lot about the risks of not dealing with the used fuel. And it changed her thinking.

"I can't just close my eyes and imagine that the fuel is not here, because it is," she says.

Benefits For The Region

This spring, Swedish nuclear officials applied for a licensing application to build a geologic vault in the municipality of Osthammar, about a two-hour drive north of Stockholm. If they get it, the facility could open in 2025.

"We believe that it will not create a stigma, but on the other hand create an interest in how to solve this very difficult issue that people in Japan and California and Germany must solve in one way or another," says Jacob Spangenberg, the mayor of Osthammar.

The community will see some financial benefits: Besides new jobs and infrastructure, Osthammar negotiated a deal with the company to receive approximately $80 million for long-term economic development if the repository is approved.

Already the community gets money from a national waste fund to help it chart an independent course. It has retained technical consultants and hired five full-time employees. Spangenberg says Osthammar learned how to ask tough questions, press for conditions and also to keep cool.

That's because, Spangenberg says, there are many people out there who want to manipulate the situation to their own advantage, "both from the industry, as well as those that are very much opposed."

There are still a lot of questions about the proposal, and there are critics who feel the community has fallen for a very sophisticated PR campaign. Ultimately, the community still has the power: Once regulators have completed their review, three or four years from now, Osthammar gets to either veto the proposal or say, "Yes, in our backyard."

More than 20 countries rely on nuclear power, but not a single one has built a permanent site to dispose of nuclear waste. That includes the United States, where a presidential commission tries again this week to offer solutions.

KELLY: This morning we'll visit one country that is working on a plan for a permanent disposal site - Sweden. Two communities there say they are willing to take the nuclear waste. Ingrid Becker of member station KQED explains how that happened.

(Soundbite of protest)

INGRID BECKER: Like a lot of countries, Sweden has had its share of political meltdowns over nuclear power.

(Soundbite of protest)

BECKER: Protests like this one stirred an uproar in the early '80s when the Swedish nuclear industry simply decided where to begin testing for a possible geologic disposal site.

Today, instead of deflecting protesters, they're shuttling visitors by the busloads for guided tours at facilities like this one.

Unidentified Woman #1 (Tour guide): So we are 340 meters down and here you can see that even if this is the crystalline bedrock and we are...

BECKER: In this working lab in eastern Sweden, a private nuclear waste company is testing methods for permanently storing used fuel. It plans to encase the fuel rods in copper capsules, then bury them 1,500 feet down in bedrock, where it's supposed to sit for the next 100,000 years.

Mr. JONATHAN SVENSSON: It's very exciting to see and it's an enormous project. Just the time scale is incomprehensible.

BECKER: Jonathan Svensson is studying nuclear safety as part of his government job, and I met him on a tour that ended with colored lights and this music as we waited for the lift to the surface.�

(Soundbite of theme to "Chariots of Fire")

BECKER: OK. So how did nuclear waste in Sweden go from a toxic topic to a field trip? The people I met said the industry needed to start over with...

Unidentified Woman #2: A transparent process.

Unidentified Man #1: Trust.

Unidentified Man #2: Have a predictable process.

Unidentified Woman #3: Real public participation.

Unidentified Man #3: And you have to take the time needed.

BECKER: And the industry took those lessons to heart. Inger Nordholm is a spokeswoman for the Swedish Nuclear Fuel and Waste Management Company, or SKB.�

Ms. INGER NORDHOLM (SKB): We know that we have to meet people and communicate what we want to do, why we want to do it, and how we will find a place for it.

BECKER: Initially, company officials spent a lot of time just having coffee with people, explaining their plans. Then they began focusing on towns with stable geology, but also places where the people were used to living near nuclear power plants.�

Oskarshamn was one of two communities in eastern Sweden that stepped forward after nuclear waste officials asked for volunteers willing to let them start geologic testing. Charlotte Lilliemark was just the kind of person a nuclear power executive would want to avoid.

Ms. CHARLOTTE LILLIEMARK: This is stable?

(Soundbite of horse whinnying)

BECKER: The former Stockholmer moved to the country to raise dressage horses and did not want a waste dump anywhere near her.

Ms. LILLIEMARK: I couldn't see anything that was positive.

BECKER: But then local government officials asked her to lead a community advisory group. She says they told her...

Ms. LILLIEMARK: We think that you could contribute to the work. We need to open up all the questions and to be clear and transparent and we want you to participate if you want to.

BECKER: And she did.�

Ms. LILLIEMARK: (Foreign language spoken)

Unidentified Child: (Foreign language spoken)

BECKER: Over coffee in the kitchen with her daughter, Lilliemark says she's spent 10 years studying the issues and advocating for her community. In the end, her community wasn't selected for the repository, but through her involvement with the issue, Lilliemark says she learned a lot about the risk of not dealing with the used fuel. And it changed her thinking.

Ms. LILLIEMARK: I can't just close my eyes and imagine that the fuel is not here, because it is.

BECKER: After 30 years of research and development, Swedish nuclear officials applied this spring for a licensing application to build a geologic vault in the municipality of Osthammar, about two hours northeast of Stockholm. And if they get it, the facility could open in 2025. Jacob Spangenberg is the mayor of �sthammar.

Mayor JACOB SPANGENBERG (Osthammar, Sweden): We believe that it will not create a stigma but on the other hand create an interest on how to solve this very difficult issue that people in Japan and California and Germany must solve in one way or another.

BECKER: Of course the community of Osthammar will see some financial benefits. Besides new jobs and infrastructure, Osthammar negotiated a deal with the company to receive approximately $80 million dollars for long-term economic development if the repository is approved.�

Already the community gets money from a national waste fund to help it chart an independent course. They've retained technical consultants and hired five fulltime employees. Spangenberg says �sthammar learned how to ask tough questions, press for conditions, and also to keep...

Mayor SPANGENBERG: Very cool.

BECKER: Because he says there are many people out there who want to manipulate the situation to their own advantage.

Mayor SPANGENBERG: Both from the industry, as well as those that are very much opposed.

BECKER: There are still a lot of questions about the proposal and critics who feel the community has fallen for a very sophisticated and lengthy PR campaign. Ultimately the community still has the power. Once regulators have completed their review, three or four years from now, Osthammar gets to either veto the proposal or say yes, in our backyard.