Both judges had provided letters of interest seeking reappointment, but the Supreme Judicial Court had recommended that no reappointment should be for longer than two five-year terms unless special circumstances warranted it.

In a statement, Carey praised Johnson and Scheier, but said that “no exceptional circumstances exist within these court departments to require re-appointment.”

“Leadership change contributes positively to the health and well-being of any organization,” Carey said. “I strongly believe that the Trial Court must expand the leadership opportunities provided to the many dedicated judges with the vision, talent, and skills to advance its mission.”

Carey said she is actively soliciting nominations for chief justice for both courts. She requested the legal community send her comments “on the condition and operations of these two court departments; the priorities, future goals and direction of the courts; and the role of the Chief Justice in leading the courts to meet those goals.”