The highly hydrophobic neat alkanethiol-coated SAM on evaporated gold shows an unusually low interfacial capacitance in aqueous media. This result cannot be explained by a simple parallel plate model of the double layer with the alkanethiol monolayer as a sole dielectric separator. Interestingly, a hydrophilic SAM prepared from a neat hydroxy thiol does not show any such capacitance lowering in aqueous media. Our results suggest the existence of a “hydrophobic gap” between the alkanethiol SAM–water interface. Such a model is also very much consistent with the predictions of Lum, Chandler, and Weeks theory of length scale dependent hydrophobicity.