*Not really "borrowed" as he was originally a Giant, and then made a Pro Bowl with the L.A. Raiders.

Before Eli Manning and excepting Phil Simms, the Giants had a long tradition (about 45 years, roughly 1960 to 2004) of borrowing quarterbacks who starred with other teams. You can excuse this, as when they veered from that course they usually ended up with Joe Pisarcik, Scott Brunner, Dave Brown, or some other legend of the game. Well, anyway, oftentimes the quarterbacks whom they borrowed would also find success AFTER leaving the Giants. The quarterbacks on this quiz had varying degrees of success in New York as compared to elsewhere.