After Banning Circumcision, German Courts Are Going After Ear Piercing

In the debate in Germany over circumcision,
you often hear people say jokingly that if cutting the foreskin
off a baby boy’s penis for religious reasons is outlawed then
piercing little girls’ earlobes shouldn’t be allowed either.

But that’s just the scenario that may be shaping up. After a
Cologne court ruled in June that circumcision was
illegal, a Berlin judge is examining whether or not ear-piercing
should be as well.

The issue has come up in conjunction with a suit against a tattoo
studio by the parents of a three-year-old girl whose ears
were pierced at the studio.

A judge must rule on whether the parents should be punished for
having sought the piercing, and whether the studio can be
prosecuted for not having refused to perform
the procedure. A decision is expected by August 31.

The parents of the girl said in their suit that the child cried
from an inordinate amount of pain as her ears were being pierced.
During a medical examination three days later the child was still
manifesting a traumatic reaction.

Many doctors argue that the same holds true for circumcision:
although it’s just a small cut,