The main trouble there is that the asking price is higher than it should be for a 2001, and this in spite of some minor cosmetic issues the Wolfsburg has (most notably, the alloy wheels are starting to delaminate...)

The more I'm thinking about it, the more I'm leaning towards the GTI. It's priced better than both of the others, the reviews I've read on the models seem to suggest better things about the GTI, and I know that if I don't take the leap I'm always going to feel like I settled. I'm very tired of settling.