You usually don't associate spying with being Zen, but that's exactly what the nation's chief intelligence officer did this week at an intelligence gathering in Orlando, Florida.

Director of National Intelligence James Clapper was the keynote speaker at the annual Geoint Symposium and what the audience of intelligence officers, contractors and academics heard probably rank as one of the more unusual presentations.

Clapper unfurled some "heavy philosophy" as he told the audience what intelligence professionals could learn from motorcyclists. And he tied it all together with a reference to Robert Pirsig's nearly 40 year old best seller, "Zen and the Art of Motorcycle Maintenance," which is more a discourse of life philosophy than motorcycles.

It's all, Clapper explained, about finding the elusive "Truth."

These initial comments set up the body of his speech which focused on what he feels is his primary mission as DNI–the integration of all facets of intelligence gathering.

Here are Clapper's remarks:

"I'm especially pleased to be here in Orlando. Actually these days I'm pleased to be anywhere outside Washington. Walt Disney didn't pick this place by accident. The weather here is usually perfect, so it's a great place to do things outdoors... things like riding a motorcycle.

Now, I'm not a biker, but buying a Harley, and riding across America has crossed my mind once or twice – especially lately. Sue always uncrosses it for me. In fact, the closest I'm allowed to come to a motorcycle is my Harley-Davidson pen.

But, I believe there's profound wisdom that comes from old bikers – in life, and for intelligence.

You may have heard a few of their wise musings:

-A bike on the road is worth two in the shop.

-There are old bikers, and there are drunk bikers, but there are no old, drunk bikers.

-If you think your head is only worth five dollars, get a five dollar helmet.

-And last but not least: Maintenance is as much art, as it is science.

All this brings to mind a best-selling book written some 40 years ago, called "Zen and the Art of Motorcycle Maintenance."

It wasn't really about Zen. And it wasn't really about motorcycle maintenance, either. It was a philosophy book – about the search for "Quality," and what that really means.

I think that book, and bikers, have some important insights for what we all do, because I think it can help us all better understand intelligence integration, and why, I think, we need to pursue it.

One important theme in the book is the attempt to reconcile what's called the "classic" mode – reason, science and fact – with the "romantic" mode – imagination, art, and feeling. In a nutshell, putting together logic with creativity and innovation. And when you think about it, the profession of intelligence is a unique amalgam of science and art. It rings with the theme of this year's symposium: "Creating the Innovation Advantage."

Anyway, back in ancient Greece, around the time Socrates was still a kid, there was a split in the way academics started thinking. Before then, there was no division in western thought between: Good and truth. Mind and matter. Subject and object. Form and substance. Those are all man-made divisions, and they started right about then.

"Zen and the Art of Motorcycle Maintenance" argues that Quality, and Value, and Truth, are what actually exist in the real world. And I think you could easily extend that thesis to intelligence as well.

We split Intelligence into HUMINT (human intelligence), SIGINT (signals intelligence), and GEOINT (geographic intelligence) – any number of INTs – even as we try to improve them. But those are all man-made constructs, too. We refer to them as stovepipes, silos, or cylinders of excellence.

But we actually achieve the highest Quality and Value when we put them all together. That brings us closer and closer to the Truth, to perfect Intelligence, acknowledging, of course, that we'll never achieve absolute perfection, the absolute "God's eye, God's ear" certitude about events – past, present, or future. I would ask that you hold that thought, since I'll come back to it later.

And even if we figured out every secret, there will always be unsolvable mysteries. But the more we can bring everything together, and the closer we can actually integrate intelligence from different sources, the nearer we'll get to that always elusive Holy Grail – Truth, and Quality.

So – some "heavy philosophy" to explain why I feel so strongly about intelligence integration as my primary focus as DNI."

I suppose it could have been worse. He was just saying nothing while trying to be entertaining. At least he didn't reveal anything confidential to the world at large. We've had more than enough of that already by other people.

Clapper sagely acknowledges a problem inherent in science–which often must use inductive logic, where it is required that you connect the dots to create a picture based on imperfect or incomplete information. In deductive reasoning, if your premises are true and your reasoning is sound, your conclusion is true. But intel coming from human agents or patterns in sensor data is not always a matter of simple deduction. This is the point he addresses, and he does it artfully with the reference to Zen, etc.

Post a comment

CNN welcomes a lively and courteous discussion as long as you follow the Rules of Conduct set forth in our Terms of Service. Comments are not pre-screened before they post. You agree that anything you post may be used, along with your name and profile picture, in accordance with our Privacy Policy and the license you have granted pursuant to our Terms of Service.

Search Security Clearance

Share this blog

About this blog

CNN's Security Clearance examines national and global security, terrorism and intelligence, as well as the economic, military, political and diplomatic effects of it around the globe, with contributions from CNN's national security team in Washington and CNN journalists around the world.