Took me 3 runs to get that eye on my warrior but I gave it to a friend cuz I don't really play that character anymore. And those runs were for fun with friends, wasn't really farming anything. Also 1 of the bindings for thunderfury dropped during one of these runs.

look at it this way, drop rate is 1%. This means you have a 99% chance to not get it.

Statistically speaking .99^99 = 36.9%. So statistically speaking after 99 runs you'll see an eye 36% of the time. So maybe a little unlucky but you're still at the point where you shouldn't really be surprised.

Woah, i thought the eye was a 100% drop if you were on the quest. I started farming for waterlord rep in wotlk, got a binding on the 3rd or 4th clear, started the quest and got to the point u needed the eye, both bindings, and 10 bars, went and killed rag in the same reset and he dropped the eye. Of course it took probably 40 more clears for the other binding....and the fact shamans cant equip swords....but i have it....and im somehow still not exalted....

Woah, i thought the eye was a 100% drop if you were on the quest. I started farming for waterlord rep in wotlk, got a binding on the 3rd or 4th clear, started the quest and got to the point u needed the eye, both bindings, and 10 bars, went and killed rag in the same reset and he dropped the eye. Of course it took probably 40 more clears for the other binding....and the fact shamans cant equip swords....but i have it....and im somehow still not exalted....

Well not Ragnaros, but I have killed Attumen the Huntsman in Karazhan almost every week for over 3 years for Fiery Warhorse's Reins. Since 2013 I'm killing him with four different chars each week, but still no luck.

I'll bet Blizzard will redo Kara removing this old mount like they did with old Zul'Gurub, that was kind of hard for me since I had been farming almost every reset (and it's reset was like twice a week) for over two years, doing it with three different chars every reset for the last 4-5 months before the mounts got removed. Didn't get any of those mounts.

My fiancee got it on her 3rd try and she didn't even know what the mount was, just that the boss dropped a mount. I'm still crying.

130 yogg0 kills after cataclysm - no mount. 200 ultraxion kills - no mount. Dunno even who should be more upset, you or me.
And ye, got thunderfury, an eye and the actual legendary mace on the mage (which means I had 2 eyes drop for me - while farming this silly rep for achivment ...)

I had been running this exclusively on my warrior for a while. Guildie was like "why not run it on your shaman anyway?" Two weeks later, end up getting the eye on the shaman. Shaman is exalted with Waterlords, and my warrior is about 2/3 or 3/4 of the way through revered to exalted, just to give an idea of how long it took.

I have had stupid good luck with old legendaries so far this year, though...last 3 months, I've gotten HoR, TF, Thoridal, and both Warglaives. The only one not on my warrior being HoR. Not a big deal, being my shaman is my main, although I admit being able to TG it with Shadowmourne (which I'll have in a couple months tops...I hope) would have been cool.

I have 10 Rag kills, half of them in MoP and i have had 3 bindings drop for me only in MoP and it was under the first 4-5 weeks. Good rng is good but i havn't seen the eye.
And im a priest so i cant use Thnderfury but i will still finish it (havn't done it yet) ^^

Well not Ragnaros, but I have killed Attumen the Huntsman in Karazhan almost every week for over 3 years for Fiery Warhorse's Reins. Since 2013 I'm killing him with four different chars each week, but still no luck.

I'll bet Blizzard will redo Kara removing this old mount like they did with old Zul'Gurub, that was kind of hard for me since I had been farming almost every reset (and it's reset was like twice a week) for over two years, doing it with three different chars every reset for the last 4-5 months before the mounts got removed. Didn't get any of those mounts.

Same bad RNG over here regarding Attumen.

Killed him every week since WotlK with at least 1 character, it is up to 11 now.