Referring to his two daughters, before Hayley was born, the star explained that his girls don’t quite grasp the concept of his job as an actor, despite loving the film “Cloudy with a Chance of Meatballs,” in which he voices the main character.

“They’re very young,” Hader told host Conan O’Brien.

“We’ll be watching and she’s really into the movie and stuff, and I’ll go, you know, that’s daddy and she kind of looks at me and she’s like, that’s a cartoon.” Hopefully, Hader was calmer in the delivery room than he was when his first daughter was born.

The star told PEOPLE just after welcoming his oldest child Hannah, “I was drunk, knocking stuff over, ‘We gotta do the picket fence!’ And they’re like, ‘What are you talking about? We’re having a baby!’ Then they threw me out, ‘Get him out of here!'” Sounds like Hader definitely had new dad syndrome.