This blog is where works in progress by Philip Sanderson are posted along with thoughts on the moving image, sound, photography and anything else. Scroll down for an index of previous posts.

Friday, November 02, 2012

A Redemptive Reading - I know its Gonna Happen Someday

See original blog posting onPushing Ahead of the DameComment by Gnomemansland..."I Know It’s Gonna Happen Someday: is a cover of a cover of a cover – a deliciously circular retelling that achieves through the process a salvation of sorts. Morrissey’s original is all Manchester pathos; the homeboy living with his mother, NME clippings in the top drawer, walking the streets in a second hand overcoat, yearning, hoping for some way out of the place, for an immaculate reconception of self. At the heart of the song though is failure. When Morrissey sings "I Know It’s Gonna Happen Someday" you know it just isn’t gonna happen, today, or tomorrow, anyday or in anyway. Morrissey using "Rock N Roll Suicide" as a template is singing to himself, or his former self. He has made the great escape, but he sings to the mirror Morrissey still stuck in Manchester bedroom, chased home by catcalls or worse from skinheads. It is an all but patronising pat on the shoulder for his other self’s failure, and implicitly in some way our own. Bowie takes the song and sings through it, back to the original or originals. Back to "Rock N Roll Suicide", and to every song that inspired it, and to all the 50’s faded Vince Taylor inflections and influences that Morrissey so assiduously copied. In doing so he (almost inevitably) overblows it completely. It starts almost where it should end, tortured and tormented, crashing drums, strained vocals. For once in all of the overblown Bowie performances of the 80s and 90s this is perfect, and just what is required. If Morrissey’s "I Know It’s Gonna Happen Someday" is a song to slit your wrists to, Bowie’s is all stomach pump and salvation. His offer of hope is genuine. Maybe this is because Bowie like Morrissey was a star struck teenager who escaped suburbia, but in Bowie’s case it was a genuine escape, it took longer but once away he rarely looked back. Morrissey in contrast for all his elder statesman and recent US chart success is stuck. Endlessly making LPs that sound just like the last. Hiring faceless musicians who sound just like Marr, forever (in his mind) revisiting haunts he has not seen for decades and bemoaning a lost Britain he has long since left. His other self cripples him continuously, Bowie in contrast may not have made a decent new record in years but in some way is free of all of that and his version of "I Know It’s Gonna Happen Someday" is ultimately a validation of that freedom.