If he is this big a liability this season through 18-19 games you want him to be the unquestioned starter next season?

For me is he continues like this and we do not see a marked improvement then we need a contingency plan for next year. Either we sign a LT like Clady or Bushrod and we send Webb to compete at RT or we get a really good back up RT.

He is the worst starter on the team right now and that should be reserved for Kellen Davis._________________John Fox
2-9 this season, 8-19 overall, 3-10 at home

If he is this big a liability this season through 18-19 games you want him to be the unquestioned starter next season?

For me is he continues like this and we do not see a marked improvement then we need a contingency plan for next year. Either we sign a LT like Clady or Bushrod and we send Webb to compete at RT or we get a really good back up RT.

He is the worst starter on the team right now and that should be reserved for Kellen Davis.

This is just going over old ground before but Carimi hasn’t been quite as bad as many are making out…yes he has struggled badly in pass pro…he has been slow out of his stance on a number of occasion and has been too aggressive leaving him open to counter moves…the pressures & penalties are without doubt the biggest concern and giving up an average of a sack every two games is also unacceptable…however his run blocking has been very solid on the right side combined with Louis…it’s no coincidence that Forte is averaging a career high in YPC because the Oline as a whole are run blocking better this year…Carimi himself is 10 games into an NFL career…a career that was stalled by a long term injury and a positional switch…he has to be given time to adjust to not only playing in the NFL with the extra speed but to playing a position that isn’t natural to him yet…pulling the plug on anyone after 10 games is extremely short sighted...even if he does play at the same level for the rest of the season he has to go into next year at the unquestioned starter at RT for next season IMO even if we do go out and draft or sign another OT in the offseason._________________Adopt-a-Bear...Adrian Amos

Not much longer if he keeps his up. His "pass protection" is really bad. I mean could cause an injury bad. I guess that's the only thing that'll in MM90's mind be enough to bench him._________________
^^ props to LBC on the sig

If he is this big a liability this season through 18-19 games you want him to be the unquestioned starter next season?

For me is he continues like this and we do not see a marked improvement then we need a contingency plan for next year. Either we sign a LT like Clady or Bushrod and we send Webb to compete at RT or we get a really good back up RT.

He is the worst starter on the team right now and that should be reserved for Kellen Davis.

This year and the next as MM said.

Now this does not mean he cannot be beat out but they are not likely to spend a first on another tackle (though, even not displeased with Carimi, I would not mind it if they did.) We are going to need a new middle LB before too long.

Carimi is basically a rookie so struggling is to be expected. If he is having problems with pass blocking the coaches are going to have to give him some help. I still think they need more rollouts as well as draws and screens. All these will help our line. As will running about 40 times a game.

Not much longer if he keeps his up. His "pass protection" is really bad. I mean could cause an injury bad. I guess that's the only thing that'll in MM90's mind be enough to bench him.

Well here is the question...is Jonathan Scott who has bounced around the NFL between the Lions x2, Bills, Steelers & us going to be better than Carimi? IMO no...It’s easy to say bench a guy but who steps in? Especially on the Oline were continuity is key to everyone…yeah we could go out and spend another high draft pick on an OT but is that really a good idea after only seeing a guy play 10 times? Again IMO no._________________Adopt-a-Bear...Adrian Amos

If he is this big a liability this season through 18-19 games you want him to be the unquestioned starter next season?

For me is he continues like this and we do not see a marked improvement then we need a contingency plan for next year. Either we sign a LT like Clady or Bushrod and we send Webb to compete at RT or we get a really good back up RT.

He is the worst starter on the team right now and that should be reserved for Kellen Davis.

This year and the next as MM said.

Now this does not mean he cannot be beat out but they are not likely to spend a first on another tackle (though, even not displeased with Carimi, I would not mind it if they did.) We are going to need a new middle LB before too long.

Carimi is basically a rookie so struggling is to be expected. If he is having problems with pass blocking the coaches are going to have to give him some help. I still think they need more rollouts as well as draws and screens. All these will help our line. As will running about 40 times a game.

Well this has been a problem that I have pointed out in the game thread last week and the week before. Our OC is not doing alot of this._________________
^^ props to LBC on the sig

Not much longer if he keeps his up. His "pass protection" is really bad. I mean could cause an injury bad. I guess that's the only thing that'll in MM90's mind be enough to bench him.

Well here is the question...is Jonathan Scott who has bounced around the NFL between the Lions x2, Bills, Steelers & us going to be better than Carimi? IMO no...It’s easy to say bench a guy but who steps in? Especially on the Oline were continuity is key to everyone…yeah we could go out and spend another high draft pick on an OT but is that really a good idea after only seeing a guy play 10 times? Again IMO no.

Well like you said thats your opinion. I have no idea whether Scott is better than Carimi. But lets not act like its completely far fetched that he wouldnt be. Gabe isnt playing very good football right now. Im extremely afraid to see tomorrow when JJ Watt takes those outside routes to the QB(like he likes to do) what'll happen. Cutler will probably take a major beating tomorrow._________________
^^ props to LBC on the sig

Not much longer if he keeps his up. His "pass protection" is really bad. I mean could cause an injury bad. I guess that's the only thing that'll in MM90's mind be enough to bench him.

Well here is the question...is Jonathan Scott who has bounced around the NFL between the Lions x2, Bills, Steelers & us going to be better than Carimi? IMO no...It’s easy to say bench a guy but who steps in? Especially on the Oline were continuity is key to everyone…yeah we could go out and spend another high draft pick on an OT but is that really a good idea after only seeing a guy play 10 times? Again IMO no.

Well like you said thats your opinion. I have no idea whether Scott is better than Carimi. But lets not act like its completely far fetched that he wouldnt be. Gabe isnt playing very good football right now. Im extremely afraid to see tomorrow when JJ Watt takes those outside routes to the QB(like he likes to do) what'll happen. Cutler will probably take a major beating tomorrow.

There's a reason Scott was still on the street a month into the regular season…Tice has already shown patience with one of our OTs and frankly it has paid off since Webb has been solid for us this season…there is no reason to believe he won’t do the same with Carimi._________________Adopt-a-Bear...Adrian Amos

Not much longer if he keeps his up. His "pass protection" is really bad. I mean could cause an injury bad. I guess that's the only thing that'll in MM90's mind be enough to bench him.

Well here is the question...is Jonathan Scott who has bounced around the NFL between the Lions x2, Bills, Steelers & us going to be better than Carimi? IMO no...It’s easy to say bench a guy but who steps in? Especially on the Oline were continuity is key to everyone…yeah we could go out and spend another high draft pick on an OT but is that really a good idea after only seeing a guy play 10 times? Again IMO no.

Well like you said thats your opinion. I have no idea whether Scott is better than Carimi. But lets not act like its completely far fetched that he wouldnt be. Gabe isnt playing very good football right now. Im extremely afraid to see tomorrow when JJ Watt takes those outside routes to the QB(like he likes to do) what'll happen. Cutler will probably take a major beating tomorrow.

There's a reason Scott was still on the street a month into the regular season…Tice has already shown patience with one of our OTs and frankly it has paid off since Webb has been solid for us this season…there is no reason to believe he won’t do the same with Carimi.

Yeah I understand Scott's story. Tice has also shown he is extremely impatient especially when a guy is blowing blocks._________________
^^ props to LBC on the sig

Not much longer if he keeps his up. His "pass protection" is really bad. I mean could cause an injury bad. I guess that's the only thing that'll in MM90's mind be enough to bench him.

Well here is the question...is Jonathan Scott who has bounced around the NFL between the Lions x2, Bills, Steelers & us going to be better than Carimi? IMO no...It’s easy to say bench a guy but who steps in? Especially on the Oline were continuity is key to everyone…yeah we could go out and spend another high draft pick on an OT but is that really a good idea after only seeing a guy play 10 times? Again IMO no.

Well like you said thats your opinion. I have no idea whether Scott is better than Carimi. But lets not act like its completely far fetched that he wouldnt be. Gabe isnt playing very good football right now. Im extremely afraid to see tomorrow when JJ Watt takes those outside routes to the QB(like he likes to do) what'll happen. Cutler will probably take a major beating tomorrow.

There's a reason Scott was still on the street a month into the regular season…Tice has already shown patience with one of our OTs and frankly it has paid off since Webb has been solid for us this season…there is no reason to believe he won’t do the same with Carimi.

Yeah I understand Scott's story. Tice has also shown he is extremely impatient especially when a guy is blowing blocks.

Not much longer if he keeps his up. His "pass protection" is really bad. I mean could cause an injury bad. I guess that's the only thing that'll in MM90's mind be enough to bench him.

Well here is the question...is Jonathan Scott who has bounced around the NFL between the Lions x2, Bills, Steelers & us going to be better than Carimi? IMO no...It’s easy to say bench a guy but who steps in? Especially on the Oline were continuity is key to everyone…yeah we could go out and spend another high draft pick on an OT but is that really a good idea after only seeing a guy play 10 times? Again IMO no.

Well like you said thats your opinion. I have no idea whether Scott is better than Carimi. But lets not act like its completely far fetched that he wouldnt be. Gabe isnt playing very good football right now. Im extremely afraid to see tomorrow when JJ Watt takes those outside routes to the QB(like he likes to do) what'll happen. Cutler will probably take a major beating tomorrow.

There's a reason Scott was still on the street a month into the regular season…Tice has already shown patience with one of our OTs and frankly it has paid off since Webb has been solid for us this season…there is no reason to believe he won’t do the same with Carimi.

Yeah I understand Scott's story. Tice has also shown he is extremely impatient especially when a guy is blowing blocks.

Not much longer if he keeps his up. His "pass protection" is really bad. I mean could cause an injury bad. I guess that's the only thing that'll in MM90's mind be enough to bench him.

Well here is the question...is Jonathan Scott who has bounced around the NFL between the Lions x2, Bills, Steelers & us going to be better than Carimi? IMO no...It’s easy to say bench a guy but who steps in? Especially on the Oline were continuity is key to everyone…yeah we could go out and spend another high draft pick on an OT but is that really a good idea after only seeing a guy play 10 times? Again IMO no.

Well like you said thats your opinion. I have no idea whether Scott is better than Carimi. But lets not act like its completely far fetched that he wouldnt be. Gabe isnt playing very good football right now. Im extremely afraid to see tomorrow when JJ Watt takes those outside routes to the QB(like he likes to do) what'll happen. Cutler will probably take a major beating tomorrow.

There's a reason Scott was still on the street a month into the regular season…Tice has already shown patience with one of our OTs and frankly it has paid off since Webb has been solid for us this season…there is no reason to believe he won’t do the same with Carimi.

Yeah I understand Scott's story. Tice has also shown he is extremely impatient especially when a guy is blowing blocks.