Fodor's may use your email address to send you relevant information on site updates, account changes, and offers. For more information about your privacy and protection, please review our full Privacy Policy.

Train Travel safety in Italy

I am looking for some forum safety advice. I am a seasoned traveller to Italy, familiar with the trains and ticketing, etc. However, for my upcoming trip in November, I will be "solo" and travelling distances with luggage (ie. Genoa to Stuttgart). Prior trips were either with a companion, or day trips without luggage, so leaving the compartment to use the restroom, etc. was never an issue.

My question is if it is reasonable safe to leave your luggage (locked) or should I travel wtih a bike lock or someting to chain it up while I run to the toliet? (I'm laughing as I am typing this and thinking perhaps I should just by some Depends....). In this day in age, asking someone to "watch your bag" is not often an option.

In all seriousness, I am aware that there are "gypsies" that are more than willing to help you board your luggage, and I'd hate the thought of leaving for 5 minutes and finding it "gone." I only travel with a carryon, and a small sachtel("You bring it, you sling it!") and use first class whenever possible.

I don't think you have much to worry about, but I also don't laugh at your concerns. Personally, I wouldn't want to lug around a bike lock.

The advice to take to the bathroom everything you would hate to lose -- your passport, computer, camera -- but ask a fellow passenger to watch your luggage is good. Also good advice to use the facilities before boarding the train, or just when you leave the station.

Bigger problem is finding an Italian train toilet you want to use unless you are traveling 1st class!

I have a bike lock that has a cable almost as thin (but not quite) as the retractable ski cable that I take and use when traveling by train, since it can slip through quite a few backs and the luggage rack, and is very lightweight.

But are you in a single sleeping compartment that has a lock? You mentioned "compartment" -- if that's the case, I don't see any reason to lock it up inside a locked compartment (although I'd still take my purse).

I can understand your apprehension, I have travelled solo for some time by choice and have never had a problem in Europe on trains with my luggage. If you are seated near a few people who are not travelling all together in a compartment I'm quite sure one of them will not try to lift your bag when the others know it is not theirs. Sounds a bit corny but true. Also not everyone is a suspect thief and I've always managed to pinpoint someone I thought I could trust for the short time it takes to find the 'loo'. Geuinine and honest people are very helpful when travelling solo and thank goodness there are still plenty out there.I have travelled solo in France, Italy, Austria, Switzerland, Holland and Germany on trains and they are my favourite form of transport over there. Just keep your valuables on you at all times but I'm sure we don't need to remind you of that. Have a great time.

I traveled first class on FrecciaBianca from Milan to Genova (the line runs both ways) and I highly recommend it over the old IC trains. which still have uncomfortable compartments. Nobody is going to steal your luggage on that FrecciaBianca line. It only makes a very few stops and the cars are completely open to view with lots of train personnel on them, and plenty of trustworthy fellow passengers. And they have cleaner bathrooms.

>>>I traveled first class on FrecciaBianca from Milan to Genova (the line runs both ways) and I highly recommend it over the old IC trains. <<<

I doubt the OP can wait until after 1 pm to catch a Frecciabianca train (the earliest departure shown on Trenitalia is 13:12) and still make connections to Zurich and Stuttgart in one day. There are multiple early departures for IC or R trains, none shown for Frecciabianca.

Too bad. I hate those old trains with first class compartments. Sometimes 2nd class is actually more comfortable than first, especially in November, when air conditioning is not an issue. However, but not to count on working toilets.

Thanks everyone for you great input. I'm not paranoid and I have taken the Genoa>Milan train before. And heavens, I my crossbody purse never leaves me. Right now, it will be the Milan>Zurich connection, unless I decide to change everything and take an overnight train Florence>Munich.

I went from Milan>Genoa, Genoa>Florence, Florence>Venice, and Venice>MilanMalpensa in February and honestly, never had a problem with the train toliets. Not my first choice, certainly, but hey, when you gotta go, you gotta go!

I'm sure I will manage fine, but it never hurts to get great suggestions from fellow travellers! Grazie!