Tom Hayden Taught Us How to Get Beyond Trump and Trumpism

What I loved most about Tom Hayden was his faith that the politics of division could be overcome.

October 24, 2016

In this December 6, 1973, photo, political activist Tom Hayden tells newsmen in Los Angeles that he believes public support was partially responsible for the decision not to send him and others of the Chicago 7 to jail for contempt. (AP Photo / George Brich)

Want to Fight Back?

Sign up for Take Action Now and get three actions in your inbox every Tuesday.

Thank you for signing up. For more from The Nation, check out our latest issue.

Subscribe now for as little as $2 a month!

Support Progressive Journalism

The Nation is reader supported: Chip in $10 or more to help us continue to write about the issues that matter.

Fight Back!

Sign up for Take Action Now and we’ll send you three meaningful actions you can each week.

Travel With The Nation

Be the first to hear about Nation Travels destinations, and explore the world with kindred spirits.

Sign up for our Wine Club today.

Did you know you can support The Nation by drinking wine?

Tom Hayden and I spoke and corresponded a good deal during the last year of his life about the 2016 presidential race. The great radical thinker and doer, who has died too young at age 76, understood the dynamics of a race that has seen wounds he sought to heal not just reopened but rubbed raw.

Hayden took seriously the threat posed by Donald Trump and Trumpism. He was old enough to have confronted McCarthyism, racism, sexism and anti-immigrant hysteria in all their awful incarnations during the 1960s, ’70s, ’80s, ’90s, the 2000s and 2010s. He had succeeded sufficiently to maintain a faith in what he described as “rare moments when hope and history rhyme.”

Yet his experience as a civil-rights activist, voting-rights activist, antiwar activist, anti-corporate activist, environmental activist, and political leader (state assemblyman, state senator, gubernatorial candidate, US Senate candidate) told him that those moments do not come by chance. They are forged in the crucibles of campaigns and movements. And they demand an honest assessment of dishonest politicians and disconcerting times.

Hayden knew enough to be unsettled by what the 2016 campaign was exposing about America’s ongoing capacity for political cruelty. Yet, he was not simplistic or resigned in his response to that cruelty. Raised in a Detroit-area Catholic church that was led by Father Charles Coughlin, a nationally-known “radio priest” whose preaching anticipated the crudest populism of the current moment, his first rebellions were against those who would use economic instability do divide workers along lines of religion and ethnicity.

Hayden’s lifetime was devoted to challenging the dogmas of the right, and the false populism of conservative politicians who would exploit global uncertainty for domestic gain. As the primary author of the Port Huron Statement, Hayden reflected on how “discontented, super-patriotic groups would emerge through political channels and explain their ultra-conservatism as the best means of Victory over Communism.” And he explained how this politics “becomes an umbrella by which to protest liberalism, internationalism, welfarism, the active civil rights and labor movements.”

Tom Hayden never lost faith. He believed to the end in great awakenings

Hayden was offended not just by the rhetoric of right-wing politicians and parties but by the political exploitation of human beings he believed to be “infinitely precious and possessed of unfulfilled capacities for reason, freedom, and love.”

“We oppose the depersonalization that reduces human beings to the status of things—if anything, the brutalities of the twentieth century teach that means and ends are intimately related, that vague appeals to ‘posterity’ cannot justify the mutilations of the present,” Hayden and his comrades declared in 1962. “We oppose, too, the doctrine of human incompetence because it rests essentially on the modern fact that men have been ‘competently’ manipulated into incompetence—we see little reason why men cannot meet with increasing skill the complexities and responsibilities of their situation, if society is organized not for minority, but for majority, participation in decision-making.”

3

4

5

What I loved most about Tom Hayden, and I loved a lot about him, was his faith that the politics of division could be overcome, that coalitions could be bigger and bolder, more inclusive and more powerful. When we went together into the streets of Seattle in 1999 for those great protests against corporate-defined globalization, Tom was joyous at the sight of “Teamsters and Turtles”—blue-collar trade unionists and environmentalists—marching together. Like our great comrade Tim Carpenter, the late national director of Progressive Democrats of America who celebrated Tom’s intersectional politics as visionary, Hayden believed that the most effective organizing involved a search for shared experience and the solidarity that extends from it.

Ready to Fight Back? Sign Up For Take Action Now

To that end, Hayden wrote his most inspired book: Irish on the Inside: The Search for the Soul of Irish America (Verso). A memoir and manifesto published in the fall of 2001, it explored the “colonization of the mind” that causes peoples to abandon their own true history to gain acceptance by the elites they once battled.

Irish on the Inside argued for a re-identification of “white” Americans with the liberation struggles of immigrants, people of color and other victims of discrimination. Hayden did this by returning to his roots—in Ireland and in rural Wisconsin—where he unearthed the seeds of his radicalism.

Hayden mixed a history of the Irish experience with inspired reflections on the specific experience of his ancestors, such as Peter Hayden, who died with United Irish insurgents from County Wicklow in a 1798 uprising, and immigrant Emmet Owen Garity, who settled in Wisconsin and made his farm a stop on the Underground Railroad that transported slaves to freedom.

The dark machinations of British colonialists caused the Irish Famine of the 1840s and dislocated millions of Irish like Emmet Garity to a young United States where they experienced new forms of impoverishment and derision. Hayden argued that a recollection of the experience of those immigrants—who were portrayed as wild, criminal, and intellectually deficient, and who encountered “No Irish Need Apply” signs well into the 20th century—ought to make Irish-Americans sympathetic to the plight of new immigrants, of the descendants of slaves, of gays and lesbians and others who continue to suffer discrimination.

Tom Hayden searched for those “rare moments when hope and history rhyme.”

Drawing from his own experience, Hayden recalled how, upon visiting Northern Ireland in 1968, he was profoundly moved to hear Irish-Catholic civil-rights marchers singing the songs of the African-American freedom struggle.

It was then, explained Hayden, that he began to overcome the suppression of his own Irish heritage by parents who were determined to fit themselves and their son into the white, middle-class models of mid-20th-century America. “I saw marchers in Northern Ireland singing ‘We Shall Overcome’ and, in an epiphany, discovered I was Irish on the inside,” he wrote.

The great contribution that Hayden made with Irish on the Inside, and the activism that extended from the book, was a definition of what “Irish on the inside” ought to mean. He spoke for a vision of his own ethnicity not as an excuse to drink green beer on St.Patrick’s Day but as an inspiration to struggle for justice at home and abroad. And he extended that vision to an ideal of Americanism that reaches beyond cheap shows of patriotism to embrace the revolutionary spirit that so appealed to immigrants “yearning to be free.”

Hayden’s book—which he finished on July 4, 2001, in Belfast—closed with a rumination on a restoration of that “yearning to be free” consciousness:

In my dream I am taking a handful of soil from Emmet Garity’s grave in Sullivan Township, Wisconsin, and my Nannie’s grave in Oconomowoc, and my parents’ graves too and I am packing up that soil of the dead to be taken back to Ireland.… In this dream Irish from all over are migrating home. They come in ones and twos and in groups. When they arrive, they leave their sod and stone in a field, which in time becomes a field of flowers, a graveyard, an oak grove, a mountain, a place to bury pain and grow our history until memory surpasses forgetting and the sod of the dead becomes the fertile soil of awakenings.

Tom Hayden never lost faith. He believed to the end in great awakenings—not merely for Irish-Americans but for the descendants of every immigrant who ever embraced the revolutionary ideal of justice and solidarity that rejects walls and declares: “Give me your tired, your poor, your huddled masses yearning to breathe free, the wretched refuse of your teeming shore. Send these, the homeless, tempest-tost to me. I lift my lamp beside the golden door!”

To me, essentially, Tom Hayden was all about "nobody gets left out." As I remarked here at the Nation in another column, he was one of the first very well known straight men to speak to the big wave of the gay movement that happened as the 1970's rolled on, fearlessly and without reservation. At the time, a good comparison would have been Harvey Milk when he ran for supervisor in San Francisco. Harvey spoke to every group in the city, union hardhats on the high rises included, and they liked him. Nobody was left out of Milk's world, same with his friend Mayor George Moscone. Everybody comes to the table, and it works.