Peer Review Cake Club!

A few years ago there was a group of members that called themselves (I think?) The Cake Club. They critiqued people's cakes if you asked for it. I want to get it started again! Who's with me????

In case you weren't around then, here's what it is all about:

Upload photos of your cake in the Galleries. Please do not upload photos here!

Make sure in the comments under the photo in the Gallery that you describe the cake, techniques used, and that you are asking for critique from the Cake Club. This will help us know that we have clicked on the right cake photos and also to confirm that you are asking for critique.

Post in this thread to let us know you uploaded a new cake and post the hyperlink to your photoset.

Those subscribed to this Cake Club thread would then pop over to your album and give honest but encouraging feedback.

Anyone can offer opinion on the cake, but the goal is to help decorators (new and old) improve and build on their skills. If you see something that needs improvement please try to share tips on how to do something better. And of course, if you see something done well, let that person know!

This is not a way to ask for pricing on your cake, and I ask any members participating to not answer pricing questions if asked.

This is also not a way to get "favorites" so you can land on the home page. This is only to get constructive feedback!

Your photos also have to be uploaded to the galleries HERE on Cake Central, please do not direct up to critique on your blog, Facebook or website.

If you want to sign up to be a member and are willing to critique, just post below! Just make sure you are subscribed to this thread and you opt for immediate notifications.

If you want feedback on your cake, lets make sure we get more then a few people to sign up to be members, I don't want to be the only one critiquing cakes!

It's too bad that you feel that way ddaigle, I am trying to start get some positive energy going so a negative comment right out of the gates on this thread is a big downer. Any chance you'd consider deleting your comment so we can try and keep the positive energy flowing?

AI would say do my profile picture. I'm on my phone, so can't link or move or whatever. If anyone would like to review it, please, as stated earlier, be constructive? I have heard that piping is coming back, and hadn't done this much piping before, so be gentle!

I would say do my profile picture. I'm on my phone, so can't link or move or whatever. If anyone would like to review it, please, as stated earlier, be constructive? I have heard that piping is coming back, and hadn't done this much piping before, so be gentle!

Alooks like a great idea, I would love to hear constructive criticism from other bakers (I think I could very easily fall into the 'my baby is the best baby' mentality with only my husband brave enough to point out what needs improvement)

That cake is really quite flawless. The only criticism I have is that I would like the cake & border to be on the stand. I can see the board. I'm guessing the stand was for the photo so that's not really helpful. Really excellent piping skills.