I've hated the show for years and years, but i have to admit the first 2 seasons were VERY promising and well made. But once season 3 rolled around, it started to flush down the toilet..

Well considering season 3 was one of the best seasons, I'd have to disagree with you. It never started flushing down the toilet, I loved the show beginning to end. I am a psycho Buffy Fan.... :|
I endured years of torture form my classmates in highschool just because I liked the show.