Tragedy in Mumbai

Words may fail us, but actions cannot.

At times like this, words fail us. We are struck silent by the sheer barbarism and scope of the tragedy: the cold blooded murder of Rabbi Gavriel and Rivkah Holtzberg -- a young couple who left behind all of the creature comforts of life in the West to go and help other Jews -- four other Jews shot dead inside the Chabad House, another 169 people killed, and 240 wounded.

I personally benefited from the self-sacrifice of the Holtzbergs. In 2003, they moved to Mumbai, giving up the comforts of the West in order to spread some light in one corner of the world. They purchased and renovated the building formerly known as the Nariman House into a beautiful five-story hotel, full of rooms for guests, dining rooms, and large pantries to hold all the kosher foodstuffs necessary to feed the multitude of visitors each week. The Chabad House was a glowing beacon of holiness in a city filled with poverty and starvation.

A few months ago, I left my family behind to travel to India to carry out fieldwork and research. Long before I stepped onto the airplane, I knew I'd be in good hands -- friends contacted the Holtzbergs to ensure that I would have a place to connect with other Jews, pray, and have a warm, home-cooked meal.

During my month-long stay in India, I met Sandra Samuel, the helper and nanny for the Chabad in Mumbai for several years. Sandra overcame the natural instinct of self preservation and re-entered an upper floor of the Chabad House to rescue Moshe, the Holtzberg's 2-year-old son. She later recalled, "I just grabbed the baby and ran out."

The baby became an orphan in blood-soaked clothes.

I doubt that many of us would be able to look past our own selfish desire to save ourselves and put ourselves in harm's way. She is one of no doubt many quiet heroes who have emerged at these horrendous times.

The Holtzbergs made sure that all of us felt welcomed and comfortable. Most of all, they helped us to feel Jewish.

Every night that I visited the Chabad House, the place was packed with Jews from around the world who had come to Mumbai. Some were Israelis looking for a chance to relax after an intense tour in the Israeli army; others were businessmen seeking to cut deals with the well-known textile merchants nearby. Some were tourists looking to experience the local Indian Jewish community known as the Bnei Israel. The Holtzbergs made sure that all of us felt welcomed and comfortable.

Rabbi Holtzberg was a Torah scholar and trained as a mohel and shochet. Together with his wife they ran a synagogue, taught Torah classes, counseled drug addicts, and fought the poverty they saw all around.

Most of all, they helped us to feel Jewish. Even those soldiers who had long ago stopped attending synagogue wiped back a tear as we sang "Shalom Aleichem" around the Shabbat table.

Moving Forward

This is not the first time that a Chabad rabbi has been cut down by a terrorist. Back in the 1950s, a rabbi and four students were killed in the Israeli village known as Kfar Chabad. These residents had arrived from Europe, leaving a land decimated by the Holocaust to rebuild a new Jewish society in the miniscule land of Israel. After their death, many of their friends felt the hopelessness and despair we feel now.

It is said that the Lubavitcher Rebbe sent a telegram to the survivors of the attack that had only three Hebrew words: B'hemshech habinyan tenu'chamu -- "You will feel comfort through continuing to build."

And that is the message for us today: Continue to build. Do not give up. Do not let hate or a desire for vengeance blind us to the positive impact that all of us can have.

Because if we become afraid, immobilized, hesitant, then we've handed the terrorists a victory.

Words may fail us, but actions cannot. The Jewish community has already come together over this issue; thousands of emails, blogs, and websites have called upon Jews around the world to say Psalms, give charity, and do acts of kindness. On online bulletin boards where tempers can too often flare, arguments were quickly shelved and cooperation ensued.

We can all put our grief, our disbelief, our desire to do something into action -- and we must do it quickly.

We can all put our grief, our disbelief, our desire to do something into action -- and we must do it quickly. Send money to a Jewish cause. Spend some time telling your parents, children, and friends how much you love them and care for them. See what positive things you can do for an ailing neighbor or a depressed friend.

We are at war with many enemies, those who seek to turn our planet to darkness. The Holtzberg's were on the front lines of dispelling that darkness, putting the beauty of Judaism against loneliness and despair. For many of the backpackers and visitors, coming into contact with the joy and love extended by Rabbi Gavriel and Rivkah Holtzberg gave them their chance to embrace their Jewish heritage.

They were struck down in the line of duty. So in their memory, learn about the beautiful Jewish heritage they sought to spread. And share it with others.

Related Articles:

About the Author

Rabbi Dr. Daniel P. Aldrich received his semicha from Rav Dan Channen, shlita and he is a alumnus of the Darche Noam Yeshiva of Jerusalem. After his house was destroyed in Hurricane Katrina, he and his family spent a year living in East Asia. He currently lives with his family in West Lafayette, Indiana where he and his wife Yael work to spread the love of Torah among Purdue University students and the community.

Visitor Comments: 268

(268)
Fawzia Usman,
January 2, 2009 6:17 AM

I grieve for the Jews in Mumbai

I'm an Hindu Indian girl, the daughter of a Muslim father and a Hindu mother and I'm as horrified and saddened by this tragedy as Jews' are, probably more as far more Indians were killed.The tale of the Jews' in Christian Europe somewhat reminds me of the Hindus in the Indian sub continent. Just as the Jews were tormented by the Christians for being (supposedly) "Christ killers" the Hindus were tormented for being idolaters by the Muslims. India has done everything in its power to keep the Muslims placated, but to no avail. While Jews got back their ancestral land Israel after two millennia, the Hindus gave up large portions of their land to Muslims to make their Muslim nation Pakistan, while India remained secular.In our country remembering the Hindus killed by iconoclastic Muslims or the Hindu religious sites destroyed by fanatic Muslims is greatly discouraged,if not punished so Hindus do their own Holocaust denial.
I find the Jews the nicest of the Abrahamic faiths,and the smartest given their Nobel Prizes!Islam of course is the exact opposite. A Jew Jonas Salk invented the Polio Vaccine, while many Muslims in India claimed that it was a Western Ploy(sic) to reduce their birthrates! India has suffered numerous bombings by Muslims every year and yet we do nothing. Hopefully, this latest and greatest tragedy will lead us to pick up a few lessons from the Jews in Israel who so bravely protect their homeland, their faith and the security of their citizens.
Just for those who don't know this, Jews have lived safely in India for more than two millennia, and many historians say they arrived in India the very year their temple was destroyed by the Romans,and unlike the Jewish experience in Christian Europe or Muslim nations, in India they have never suffered any Anti Semitism at the hands of Hindus.
To Carl Sandberg and Rosen, maybe I'm biased due to my very tolerant Muslim father but as a Non Muslim\Non Jew,who's read both the Koran and the Torah- many, maybe even most Muslims accept those Koranic verses against Jews and others as pertaining to a particular situation ie Mohammed's wars on those who supposedly threatened him, and not as orders to kill for all time.Jews accept many verses in the Torah too as no longer applicable and quite a few Muslims do the same.
Anyway my deepest condolences.

Hello sir,
I came across this article when i searched about RABBI(a word which i came to know after the mumbai terror attacks). I deeply regret the killings of the rabbi, his wife & other jews.
U have mentioned about Mumbai city in your article as "The Chabad House was a glowing beacon of holiness in a city filled with poverty and starvation." I would like to say that u dont have enough information before writing like this about the city. I am an indian & i am hurt by your comment. Mumbai is called the Financial capital of india. I agree there is poverty but not filled with poverty as u hav mentioned. Poverty is such a prelevent condition today in world & every country has poverty & are trying to eradicate it, but to tell that a city like mumbai is filled with poverty and starvation is gross injustice.. Mumbai probably houses some of the richest people in india & the world too..

(265)
Dana,
December 8, 2008 3:55 PM

All of Klal Yisrael grieves with the families of the victims of the Mumbai tragedy. HaMakom yenachem eschem besoch shaar avlei tzion v'yerushalaim and may you and all of Am Yisrael not know of any more Tsa'ar.

(264)
E. R. Grunwald,
December 7, 2008 10:55 AM

we are our brothers keepers

Today there were 6 Jewish Hostages killed in cold blood In the Mumbai’s Chabad Jewish Center, a place filled with love The brutal murder of Gabriel Noah Holtzberg and his young wife, Rivka. Their 2 year old Son orphaned right before his birthday, Moshe. We all feel their suffering. Our lives are created to bring out something beautiful to this world, a legacy to be left Rabbi’s who cared for spiritual children, They spread that light Digging holy wells in the old Bombay. The Holzberg’s were doing Abraham’s life efforts, Welcoming weary guests with a lasting memories and Shabbat sweetness They fed my husband when he was alone in a foreign land. My tears will not stop. Two strikes for the terrorists. Afghanistan’s Opium trade goes to the Taliban 100 Million last year. Tell me world, are you oblivious? Iran has enough enriched uranium to build a nuclear bomb, One Holy Jihad weapon! Will we and all the terrorists “get to heaven” in one big mushroom cloud? A pigs head on a Cemetery Gate with the English words “6 Million Lies.” Circumcision is proposed to be banned in Denmark. In Belgium this week the public broadcast channel had to cancel “Adolf Hitler’s Favorite Meal”! We must continue the light to reach out to the world, spread goodness and kindness. To love our brothers in our sect and all others, the only way to combat this unbridaled hate. We are all one nation, we are all one tribe. We fight hate and terror with common decency and righteousness. Through love, prayer, smiles and taking care of others. The world’s attention all focuses on these amazing people whose lives were lost. Let their mitzvot and loving kindness not be for naught!

(263)
Anny Matar,
December 7, 2008 3:59 AM

Condolences

This terrible personal tragedy was aptly reported in the Israeli Media. However shocking the whole event was, the schemed takeover of Mumbai by terrorists whose only goal was to murder innocent people,the personal tragedy of Gavriel and Rifka Holzberg, two young people in the prime of life,
was,is and will forever be with us. People whose life was devoted to "give" others a helping hand,and as we all know those who lose their way in life and society certainly needed it, they had to give their young lives because "Moslems don't like Jews" for no other reason !!!
And even in this dark hour a ray of light, through the incredible courage and presence of mind of one woman who saved Moshe and giving him his life, and as we know "to save one life is to save a whole world" which, with G'ds help, he will devote, like his parents, to save others.
My deepest and heartfelt condolences to the courageous Grandparents and the family.
Sincerely.
Anny Matar

(262)
michael villaflores,
December 7, 2008 3:35 AM

condolence from villaflores family,Philippines.

(261)
Ab Chaim,
December 6, 2008 10:13 PM

We go forward in order to build a more just and kind world.

We must all keep our faith in G-d and know that these people did not die in vain. While it is quite sad that these good people died a horrible, terrible death. It is also true that the Holtzbergs will be known throughout the world as a righteous symbol of the loving-kindness of the Jewish people. I know we have all shed many tears of this tragic event, but we must not lose sight of what G-d has sent us here to do - be a shining light to the nations. Rabbi and Rebbetzin Holtzberg and the others that were murdered would want us to do just that.

(260)
yvonne attie,
December 6, 2008 9:59 PM

How terribly cruel and sad!!

Like flowers that had begun to bloom, our brethren were cut down, cruelly, viciously, violently, so young and full of strength and valor. May Hashem bless their son wiht a long life and may he know no more sorrow.

(259)
Judy Langberg,
December 6, 2008 8:13 PM

May their lives inspire all of us to acts of courage and faith.

I grieve with you in the loss of your loved ones, who dared to share that most sacred part of themselves with Jews in need of help and home and faith and hope.
May your loved ones stay with you in spirit, and give you strength.

(258)
Natalia Thalheim,
December 6, 2008 1:43 PM

We will rebuild

Welcome, Moishele, to the land of orphans. Here in Israel, you won't be alone, growing up with murdered parents. You join the ranks of countless children whose lives have been shattered by terrorism. When we beg G-d to gather the Jews from the four corners of the earth we dare not dream of the return of an orphan baby with his righteous Indian nanny to his mother's birthplace. Shattered lives are not new to the Jewish people. Not throughout history, and not in our times. We are all travelers, attempting to locate the road signs of our lives' journeys, and to follow them. Your parents, little Moishele, knew why they were here and where they were going. We don't know why, we can't understand and certainly we cry. But we trust in G-d's plan. Senseless, to our apprehension, yes, but as Jews, we are part of a collective whole that has been sustained against all odds through the ages. We, the survivors, keep marching forward. In building there is comfort. We will keep building. Terror victim families in Israel have been rebuilt. The Chabad House in Mumbai will be rebuilt. Our broken hearts will begin to be rebuilt as we fill them with acts of kindness, taking our cues from the incredible love which your selfless parents showed the world.

(257)
Anonymous,
December 6, 2008 9:14 AM

Nothing changes

I lived through WW2, Anti Semitism and now its back. First we had the Romans, than the Egyptians, then Hitler and the Nazi's and now the Arabs. My heart was aching for the good people to die in this tragedy. When will 2 people learn to live together in peace. Why all this hatred. Nobody knows. It is just fashionable to hate and the Jews seem to fit the bill throughout the centuries. Thank G-d for Israel and its army. At least we now have the capability to defend ourselves.

(256)
Beverly,
December 6, 2008 8:57 AM

A universal tragedy

Is it possible that there still exists a "religion" which condones slaughter of wonderful innocent people who have spent their lives helping others? Throughout history, Jews have been a candle of light burning in a hostile savage world - this is a reason never to let the light be extinguished. Happy Chanukah!

(255)
sara,
December 6, 2008 6:42 AM

thank you

Thank you Rabbi for your comfortng and inspiring words

(254)
cottus,
December 5, 2008 9:14 AM

A bright , shining light for all

Well, you Jews may take solace from the efforts of the Holtsbergs and feel strengthened in your faith and tradition. But this story is much more than that. All of us in the Western tradition can take pride and feel uplifted by their example of push - back against the sense of decline and malaise that affects us all. In a sea of uncertainty and self - doubt, their example shines forth like a mighty beacon in the fading twilight. Thank you all for this opportunity to post.

(253)
Anonymous,
December 5, 2008 12:43 AM

A Horrifc Tragedy

I did not know of the Holtzbergs before this tragedy, but they seem like they were genuinely kind and loving people, shining stars of Judaism. I myself have have had several tragic losses recently, including the death of my only child and my parents. We must remember that Hashem does NOT make mistakes, this, as everything, has a reason, as painful as it is, and we need to somehow take comfort in this. Jews have always been persecuted, we all need to unite (Jews and Gentiles alike) against such barbaric terrorists. Wrong is wrong, no matter what religion you are! May Hashem bless the memories of all the good people who were tortured and murdered in Mumbai and keep a protective eye on Moishe. May he grow up to be a fine man, knowing how wonderful his parents were and what a great legacy they left him. I will keep them all in my heart and prayers.

(252)
Vashi Ram Chandi,
December 5, 2008 12:19 AM

Mumbai, With Sincere Hopes, Thoughts and Humble Prayers

This is totally unfair, innocent Lives being cruelly snatched by perpetrators of such condemnable actions. When will the perpetrators of such condemnable actions ever understand that by committing such actions, they are literally committing the very most sinful of actions! Why don''t they realize and understand that the World needs Peace, Love, Progress and Prosperity, that when they first contribute and invest in Peace and Love can they expect to reciprocate likewise, "When" will they ever learn? By committing such actions, they are only creating more hatred for themselves primarily, as well as further distancing and surrounding themselves with a vicious circle of further infinite hatred. With sincere Hopes, Thoughts and Humble Prayers, Vashi Ram Chandi.

(251)
Miriam,
December 4, 2008 9:17 PM

Al Kiddish Hashem

Why has the massacre of the 5 Jews in the Mumbai Chabad House touched us so poignantly? Is it because none of them were natives of India? Is it because out of the 10 terrorists, two (a full 20% of their force), were designated for the specific mission of murdering a handful of Jews in a city of millions? Is it because an orphaned toddler drenched in his dead parents' blood was saved by his blessed care-giver? Is it because Chabad is an international haven for all Jews who are far from home?
May the memories of all those who have died al Kiddush Hashem throughout our history be sanctified by our deeds of lovingkindness.

(250)
Harry Abram,
December 4, 2008 7:43 PM

Jewish Tragedy in Mambai, India

Hashem has given us Jews an opportunity to to find achdus (unity). Whether we are religious or not we are all Jews and, simultaneously, targets of anti-semitism. Every Jew feels the pain of another Jew because we are one big soul. If we will wake up to the reality that we need one another, then we can bring Moshiach to the world-NOW!

(249)
Beverly KurtinUn,
December 4, 2008 7:07 PM

The few mar the many

Underlying this tragedy is the victory of the many over the few. The nanny who whisked away little Moshe who like Moshe Avenu saved yet another Moshe. The bravery of the Indian troops showed how honorable and loyal they are. At the Chabad memorial service in Dallas all who were killed or injured were recognized and mourned. It has forever changed the direction of my life as a Jew and as a citizen of the world.

(248)
Berta,
December 4, 2008 5:58 PM

Words are not enough

Words are not enough to express what I am feeling. I hope and pray that the Messiah soon will come to free all of His children. And evil will leave this earth forever.
My heart is crying for all the people who are directly involved in this tragedy, may God give you the strenght to go on.

(247)
Rabbi Yaakov Palatnik,
December 4, 2008 4:50 PM

We are all family

My second cousin, Bentzion Chroman, was among those brutally murdered at the Chabad house in Mumbai. He left behind a wife and three small children. His father, Chaim, left Chicago and went to Israel around the same time that I did, in 1978. Chaim Chroman's grandfather actually did the ceremony of the redemption of the first born (pidyon haben) for me. He was a Kohen and I was a first-born son who needed to be redeemed. Does it change one's perspective when you know those killed were family? What if they were relatives you have never met? The greater pain is what I should have felt from the beginning, because all the Jewish People are family. We know this.

(246)
Anonymous,
December 4, 2008 4:50 PM

My condolences.

We here in Mexico City, the jewish comunity, feel very bad about what happened in India.
May hashem send us peace for all of us.

(245)
Ymina,
December 4, 2008 3:35 PM

Please remember ALL of the Jewish victims

Wonderful video however you left out Norma Schvartzblat-Rabinovitz. She too was Jewish and was working on getting her immagration status in Israel to join her children. She died on her son's 18th birthday, and left behind two daughters one back in Mexico City. The video and article was very beautiful but please remember everyone who died. Not just the rabbi's, the wife and the Israeli grandmother. Everyone needs to be remembered because if they aren't we will forget them and forget this senseless crime. G-d Bless, the Holtzberg/Rosenberg family (especially little Moishe'le) the Teitelbaum family, the Kruman family, Yocheved Orvatz's family, and especially remember the Schvarblat-Rabinovitz family.

(244)
nava,
December 4, 2008 1:50 PM

a korban for klal yisroel

its very unfortunate that these two almost flawless people were taken away from us. They were taken away from people who needed them. They were the sacrifice for all of klal yisroel! the korbanot must be flawless!! through this tragedy, may we all repent and merit to bring mashiach!

(243)
Anonymous,
December 4, 2008 12:00 PM

May G-d comfort them

May God comfort the families. I know that I have been inspired to harness the legacy of these special individuals, and try to better my own character because of them.

(242)
Cheryl Ellis,
December 4, 2008 11:47 AM

Well said

Thank you for sharing your experience with us. What amazing people the Holtzberg's were - an inspiration to all of us.
Regards to Yael.

(241)
Benjamin Holzman,
December 4, 2008 4:11 AM

my experience in Mumbai

I lived in Mumbai for 6 months last year, and would go to the Beit Chabad with friends for a Shabbat meal about every second week. Over the course of 6 months, we got to know the Rabbi and his wife quite well. They were wonderful people, warm, inviting and engaging. Gabi would get visibly excited to have so many guests for Shabbat, you could tell it really made his week. He would have a grin on his face almost the entire meal, including during his Dvar Torah. He was always so eager to create a communal feeling that he insisted everyone go around the table and say a few words to the group, giving guests 4 options: either delivering a Dvar Torah, relating an inspirational story, declaring to take on a mitzvah, or leading a song. I can still hear him reciting those 4 options to the group now, as if he had discovered some miraculous way to make everyone involved in the Shabbat with no escape, impressed by his own genius week in and out. Rivki was a certified sweetheart. She’d generally sit apart from Gabi, to spread herself out, and usually sat with the girls. She too relished Friday night dinners—I think she needed her weekly female bonding time. She’d talk to the girls about the challenges of keeping kosher in India, and share exciting new finds at the market together. You could tell she was far from home, in this dense Mumbai jungle, but she was tough and really made the best of it. That was Rivki. Brave, fun-loving, and super sweet.

(240)
Yoel,
December 4, 2008 1:39 AM

Scar/Heal

Praying for 2 year old Moshe and all the orphans from recent attacks...
Let us be strong and courageous agents of G-d's love in this world!

(239)
Menashe,
December 4, 2008 1:24 AM

Kudos to Aish & Klal Yisroel

I am proud to see that achdus is the theme of the hour today. It is only a shame it takes a tragedy to reveal it.

(238)
alibaba taj mohamad,
December 3, 2008 11:59 PM

A proof to fight against fanatics-terror

I am unable to express my emotions towards this tragedy, may almighty save us from those who commit sinful acts

(237)
Sydelle Freifeld,
December 3, 2008 10:29 PM

My heart goes out to the families of this "special" young couple who gave so much of themselves. They will be remembered in my prayers as will their son, Moshe.

(236)
RH,
December 3, 2008 9:56 PM

Tenachamu Min Hashamayim-May you be comforted by Hashem

The greatness acheived by this couple for dedicating and ultimately losing their lives for the mitzvah of hachnasat orchim-caring for guests-is tremendous and they surely are reaping the rewards. May their families be consoled by the thought of all they achieved in the short time they had. What they did in a few short years, some don't bother getting around to in a lifetime. It is surely an indication of the wonderful homes in which they were raised.

(235)
Leo Sushner,
December 3, 2008 9:32 PM

.

Rabbi and Rebbetzin Holtzberg gave their lives for what they loved and believed in. They had merit not only in this world but the world to come.

(234)
avigayil,
December 3, 2008 8:36 PM

2year old

i just wanna note that the blood on the 2 year olds clothing was not because he got hurt, the blood from his parents got on2 him. this is really a terible tragedy. its teriible that such wonderful people who helped klal isroel so much got killed just 4 being a yid. we really have to daven now especially, 4 hashem 2 bring us a yeshua , vey quickly

(233)
Joey,
December 3, 2008 6:24 PM

May God bless all of the victims of the Mumbai massacre, and be with those who remain behind. Amen!

(232)
Saul,
December 3, 2008 3:15 PM

A terrible loss

I can not rid myself of the constant thoughts about the 2 year old son Moyshi and the plight of his dear parents...It is so painful....My heart goes out for the family and for Chabad community. Barbarity savaged purity.

(231)
Shoshana Devorah,
December 3, 2008 2:43 PM

Baruch Dayan Emes

My condolences to all the grieving families of the Mumbai tragedy. They are all kedoshim! May HaShem comfort you amongst the mourners of Zion and Jerusalem. HY"D--May the Almighty avenge their blood.

(230)
Regina Brenner,
December 3, 2008 1:40 PM

A brutal reminder of the past

To see innocent people being killed because they are Jewish is a painful reminder of what happened before. Let us not let this kill our spirit ! Let us unite to defear the forces of evil. Am Israel Chai.

(229)
Anonymous,
December 3, 2008 11:16 AM

May their dear souls rest in peace and be with G-D at rest. May all the killers be brought to justice and get their punishment as soon as possible.

(228)
devorah,
December 3, 2008 9:56 AM

KULANU AM ECHAD WE ARE ALL OF 1 NATION
CHAREIDI, ZIONIST, CHABAD, IT MAKES NO DIFFERENCE. WE ARE ALL AFFECTED BY THIS TRAGEDY & WE MUST ALL SAY TOGETHER "AD KAAN" NO MORE EVERYONE SHOULD TAKE ONE THING UNTO THEMSELVES & TRY TO BETTER THEMSELVES & WE SHOULD ALL ACT AS A UNIFIED NATION. A JEW IS A JEW

(227)
Anonymous,
December 3, 2008 9:53 AM

with my deepest sympathy to those who lost their loved ones

God will reward His faithful servants.

(226)
Meir,
December 3, 2008 9:02 AM

Tortured & Murderd

The Kdoshim were tortured before being murdered. We have to always remember who we are dealing with.

(225)
Anonymous,
December 3, 2008 8:37 AM

All Jews

Perhaps a tragedy as great as the murder of these two special human beings is that it has taken their murder to break down the barriers of religius sect and made world Jewry one unified nation mourning together

(224)
Yael,
December 3, 2008 8:30 AM

Prayer

My heart weeps for all who lost their loved ones in Mumbai. The pain is unimaginable to me and I pray for them to find strength to live a life that will honor the deceased.

(223)
Judith Levy,
December 3, 2008 7:58 AM

Zachor, remember!

Every Yom Kippur I will light a yurtziet candle for the Rabbi and his wife Rivka as though they are members of my family, which they are.

(222)
Devorah,
December 3, 2008 6:50 AM

Ahavat Israel and Achdut Israel

May the Achdut & Ahavat Israel that is being experienced in honor of the Kedoshim of Mumbai not just be a temporary tease. May our Ahavat Israel grow stronger and stronger and lead us straight to the Geulah so we can all bask in the ultimate peace, love and light!

(221)
Risyl Edelman,
December 3, 2008 5:37 AM

Sharing in our pain

I'd like to hear Rav Noach's approach to this - he has mentioned the pain the shechina feels at these times - this couple LIVED for the sanctity of heaven, and apparently that was NOT enough. The horror of how they were murdered is just not going to go away... To die for the sake of heaven - to leave behind little Moishy - it is a bitter pill to swallow.

(220)
Sunday Olisaeloka Obinwa,
December 3, 2008 3:11 AM

GOD BLESS THOSE THAT BLESSES ISRAEL

GOD BLESS YISRAEL, GOD PRESERVE THE JEWS, MAY THE TWO YEAR OLD SON OF RABBI HOLTZBERG AND RIVKA GROW TO THE KNOWLEDGE OF TORAH...AMEN.
MAY THE HOLY ONE BLESS THE SOULS OF THOSE WHO LOST THEIR LIVES IN CHABAD HOUSE MUMBAI...AMEN

(219)
Helen,
December 3, 2008 12:31 AM

May Hashem bless the rabbiner couple

In deep sorrow I have been thinking about the loss of a young jewish couple with several children. May Hashem bless them all.

(218)
karen lenefsky,
December 3, 2008 12:29 AM

its beyond sad

my life brought me to many places where chabad gave myself and family a chance to live like real jews. making sure our spiritual,physical and education for our children was all in place. we would have been lost without them. even though i did not have the privilege of knowing the rabbi and rebbetzin i understand 1st hand what they accomplished. im so sorry for your losses. chabad taught me to serve hashem with gladness somehow we must get back to that. hashem is only good i know its hard to feel this now. but one day it will come back. sometimes we need time.may you find comfort together with the mourners of zion.

(217)
Donna Karen Rosenblum,
December 2, 2008 3:47 PM

Condolences

....is a word that cannot impart the profound sadness the Jewish community feels at the loss of this young couple who only sought to do good in the world. May their memory be an eternal blessing.

(216)
michael,
December 2, 2008 3:29 PM

the world learns

In my travels around the world ,on Shabbatot & Chagim,I had the honour to experience the warm reception offered by numerous Chabad houses.These memories have and will always remain with me.
After reading about the Holtzberg family and the ways they welcomed their guests-this truly was on a level
similar to that of Avraham Avinu.
As I read comments following articles
about this wonderful couple,on Aish and numerous news websites,the entire world ,Jew and non-Jew,religious and not so religious,were learning about the incredible work Chabad does and the selfless challenges and duties in life that people achieve.
Into a dark evil world,the Rebbe has sent out glowing Jewish candles(neshamot)to illuminate and show this
world the way of Hashem.
May the dear souls of all who died in Chabad House Mumbai rest in peace,and may their loves ones be comforted.

(215)
Antonette,
December 2, 2008 2:51 PM

Hi my name is antonette im from holland and i wached the terrorist attacks in india on the news especially when i heard about the jewish center.. Im sad about what happend to the rabbi and his wife i hope there son moshe wil be safe and blessed in his life! This is a terrible los... I hope the people are stil there wil be safe amen...

(214)
Lauren Adilev Cohen,
December 2, 2008 2:46 PM

murdered, not killed

Daniel:
The people in Mumbai weren't killed, they were brutally murdered. "Killed" is a pareve term,it doesn't accurately describe what happened.
Also, Jews in the Holocaust didn't "die", weren't "killed", didn't "perish". Every Jew, no matter if their death was through starvation, gunshot, or gassing was murdered because he/she was Jewish.

(213)
Zipporah,
December 2, 2008 2:45 PM

Beautiful Memories Of The Chabad Scholars

1992 - 1999 I was visited by The Chabad Scholars every Friday morning. Without fail a small group of Chabad Scholars would enter the company with smiling faces and glowing hearts to wish me Good Shabbos, on Purim they always arrived with Hamantashen(like my Bobba used to bake :) their sweetness and unconditional love was a Gift in itself!
I will NEVER 'retire' the word SHALOM and replace it with 'nekomah'(vengeance)
The only way the 'wheel' of violence will come to a screeching halt is when those who think to take a Life is the way, finally 'get the message' vengeance is NOT the answer, as is proven for thousands of years with war and destruction, nothing has changed !
G0D BLESS all Souls who perished in the Chabad House, The Hotels etc. May their Families know the World stands united as ONE in Prayer. The darkest hour is just before the dawning of the Brightest Light
SHALOM FOREVER
(there is far more to the word SHALOM than we understand)
Zipporah

(212)
Sheila Singer,
December 2, 2008 12:57 PM

Prayers

My thoughts and prayers are with you during this difficult time. All of Klal Yisrael is mourning the loss you have experienced.

"OUR LOSS GODS GAIN"
My sincere condolences to all the families who lost there loved ones
THE POWELL FAMILY/ MAY GOD BLESS THEM ALL

(209)
Dr. George Marcus,
December 2, 2008 11:59 AM

MAY THEIR MEMORY SERVE AS AN INSPIRATION TO US ALL.
Y'HI ZICHRAM BARUCH

(208)
nirmala,
December 2, 2008 11:02 AM

sick of the madness

I mourn the loss of the innocent lives lost through terrorism in the city of my birth which has a wonderful spirit and has been targetted since the last fifteen yrs.I can't stop crying when i see the little baby Moshe crying for his mother at the prayer service in a mumbai synagogue. The Almighty has saved his life as a symbol of hope against evil.I hope he will grow up to carry on his parents good work and remind us of God's mercy too.

(207)
Simon,
December 2, 2008 10:01 AM

The LORD the shepherd of His people Ps.23:

Let these words comfort you----
...l will fear no evil, For you are with me, Your rod and your staff, they comfort me.
You prepare a table before me in the presence of my enemies, you anoint my head with oil, My cup runs over.
Surely goodness and mercy shall follow me All the days of my life, And l will dwell in the house of the LORD Forever.

(206)
frank morris,
December 2, 2008 9:38 AM

may our G-d bring a peace to the children.

My heart is crush of this hate that keeps going on, my prayers our for the family of both Rabbi and his wife's, may G-d send peace only he can give, may he hold the family memember's close to him, one day he weap all tears from our eyes, L-rd touch this family, may Hashem send real shalom

(205)
Anonymous,
December 2, 2008 9:14 AM

EVERYTHING IS A WONDERFULL PLAN OF HASHEM EVEN IT HURTS SO MUCH

I AM NOT A JEWISH BUT WE HAVE LOVE JEWISH PEOPLE SINCE ALWAYS AND SINCE SOME YEARS AGO WE START TO STUDY SOME OF YOUR BOOKS, WE LEFT THE CHRISTIANISM
VERY CONVINCED THAT WE BELEIVE ONLY IN THE GOD OF ISRAEL. I CRY AND FEEL WITH YOU ALL THIS. MAY HASHEM GIVE THE STRENGHT AND WISDOM TO ALL OF US TO CONTINUE BUILDING NO MATTER WHAT.

(204)
carol,
December 2, 2008 8:39 AM

I never knew them but now I do

I am from the UK. I never knew of the Holtzbergs nor of their work in their lifetime. However, horrific as what has happened is, the information of their lives and work and love has been brought to everyone's attention as a beacon of light and love in this bleak world. Like a beautiful jar of fragrant light and perfume being broken so the precious substance can be released to be experienced by everyone. Thank you for their lives and love. They made their lives count, it was not wasted but has brought life. It must have brought delight to Ha Shem to enjoy their lives for a while. Shalom to them

(203)
Anonymous,
December 2, 2008 8:22 AM

A Christian mourns with you.

Our love for the G_d of Abraham, Isaac and Jacob, for the Jewish people and the land of Israel gives us continual joy, but at this moment and others like it, we mourn. I am comforted and would like to share the comfort I receive from Daniel 12:2-3. It helps us to think of the hope we have in our G_d and the promise that the Holtzbergs "will shine like the brightness of the heavens." Their life was chosen long before their murders took a breath. G_d bless little Moshe. He will surely be taught the lesson of Isaiah 57:2 along with the tremendously loving legacy his parents left behind.

(202)
kathleen wynne-peters,
December 2, 2008 5:40 AM

Tribute to our very own martyrs

I am an Indian Jewess from Kolkata. When I read in the media about the attack in Mumbai I immediately put on my tv. It was really one of the worst sights I have ever viewed - didn't seem real, just like a movie. My sis & her husband are here from London on holiday and me and my family were invited to join them for Shabat. We had just finished our dinner after Shabat prayers when a friend came over and gave us the sad news about the Holtzbergs. All of us at the dining table burst out crying unanimously. It was horrific. Poor little baby Moshe, may Hashem protect and keep him safe to continue his lovely parents work. Amen. And as for the Nanny she must be a martyr in her own right. Bless her. Me and my family offer the families on both sides, our heartfelt condolences and pray that Hashem gives them the courage and fortitude to bear this irreparable loss. Amen

(201)
Judy Grunfeld,
December 2, 2008 3:31 AM

A Huge Loss for Humanity

The murder of innocent people is a tremendous tragedy, but when someone like the Rabbi and his wife are targeted it is a huge loss for humanity. People like these, who reach out and embrace strangers, giving food, comfort,and help fellow Jews reacquaint themselves with their roots, such people are treasures, beacons of light that make this tragedy one of immense proportions.
I agree that doing mitzvot is a way to show tribute to the memory of those who were murdered. However it is equally important in my opinion to be alert to the rising problems that are faced by Jewish Communities around the world, and be prepared to help.

(200)
Michael Elias,
December 2, 2008 3:27 AM

Deadly outcome

We handed the terrorists a victory , because once again we werent able to protect Rabbi Gavriel and Rivkah Holtzberg and the other jews from their enemies .
All jewish organisations and jews should have their leaders and followers safety as a top priority , the holiness of the chabad house clearly wasnt enough to save their lives .
Jews should stop relying on the Torah to stop deadly bullets .
I am fustrated that this event could occur in a country well known of its hatred of the jews with such ease .
My condolences go out to those that were once again sacrifised for their beliefs .
Hopefully Moshe will one day follow in the step of his parents ,but learn to use if need be weapons to protect himself against his enemies and not solely rely on religion to shield him against deadly force .
Michael Elias

Many blessings to Moshe, may his ears be filled with stories of the beautiful people that were his late parents.

(197)
Dr. Alan (Abraham) L. Smith, CH,RH,
December 1, 2008 9:16 PM

All Jews Are Related

Firstly, May The Omnipresent One comfort the victims' families amongst the mourners of Zion and Jerusalem.
Once again, those who sought to bring goodness and kindness to the world were tragically destroyed in the prime of their life by those who are the death merchants. To think that all we need to do is "sit down and talk and appease" and all will be well is delusional at best. You cannot reason with one who is dead set on your destruction. The bravery of Sandra Samuel the helper and nanny should continually be acknowledged. That she saved a baby named Moshe from the flames may be a foreshadowing of the sparks of Yiddishkeit that will ultimately hasten the coming of Moshiach.

(196)
Cindy,
December 1, 2008 8:46 PM

I am terribly saddened to hear of this horrific and senseless act of hatred and violence. My heart aches for the family, and friends of Gavriel and Rivkah Holtzberg, and their precious little Moshe. I pray for our ability to forgive. There is no greater revenge which we can seek as people--than the revenge these men will face in their own final hour before God. Let Gavriel and Rivkah Holtzberg's lives be a reminder that we must learn to love each person for the wonderful gift they are.

(195)
Noach,
December 1, 2008 8:45 PM

Today, we are all Chabad

B'rov Am Hadras Melech. I wear a kippa sruga, cleanshaven, and ever since Friday, I have never felt more like a Lubavitcher. There are no politics, provincial walls, sectarian differences. Today, we are Am Echad, B'lev Echad. The neshamos of Reb Gavriel Noach and Rebbetzin Rivka are smiling because their sacrifice brought more jews to G-D, together, united on a global level, not just limited to the geography they served. This is ultimately how I believe the Rebbe intended to inspire by telling us that continuing to build will bring true nechama and ultimately the Moshiach. Through their sacrifice, millions of New Year's resolutions have morphed into the committment to do more mitzvos, light shabbos candles, put on tallis and tefillin, and kindle the pintele yid that is inside everyone of us into a blazing fire of glory and dedication to Hashem, performing Middos Tovos, and keeping the Mitzvos that have kept this small, but strong nation alive against all odds. Hashem Yikom Damam.

(194)
Rav Bialik,
December 1, 2008 8:10 PM

Let us continue to build upon what the Holtzberg's started.

Tradgedies come and tradgedies go, but the great love and passion that these two shared with their fellow Jew and with complete strangers, reminds us of the mission that we are on. Our Father Avraham began this same mission and passed it down to his descendants, to carry the light of emet and emunah to a world full of darkness. In their memories let us build upon what they started. Also for the others that died in this tradgedy. Lets not let it be a tradgedy but a blessing to little Moshe and to those that stand even today in the front lines. May Hashem bless the families that have lost loved ones in Mumbai.

(193)
Yoshe Revelle,
December 1, 2008 8:03 PM

Thank you Rivkah and Gavriel

Thank you Rivkah and Gavriel for your bright examples of kindness, courage, and warmth. We are fortunate that you reminded us of the light that we are to show. May we never forget. May we strive even more. :)

(192)
ANNIE ZRIHEN,
December 1, 2008 7:51 PM

We all prayed that H.... will do a mirable.
I am sur that they were the flowers H...
needed to save the world
May H... give you koah to pass this terrible time of sorrow

(191)
Anonymous,
December 1, 2008 6:59 PM

We must have them with us always...

It is silly to say only this or that Jew will be at the levaya for these holiest of Yidden. I am in NY but every day I will feel Rav and Rebbetzin Holtzberg in my heart. Any Jew with a heart will "be there" because we will always have them in our minds. Of course the other 4 Yidden are included in our thoughts and prayers and will be in our hearts always as well. May we (all the different Yidden) learn to unite together as our enemies seem to view us as one entity anyway...

(190)
Leah Angerman,
December 1, 2008 6:58 PM

Words cannot express how deeply sorry I am for you. May it comfort you to know what a beautiful kiddish H-shem your children made in a world needing much light. May H-shem comfort you during this time and may the memory of your children continue to shine throughout the hearts of Klal Yisrael.

(189)
Laurel-Esther,
December 1, 2008 6:33 PM

So sorry,truly their memory will be a blessing and continue to help us as we work towards repairing world.

(188)
Rosenblum Family,
December 1, 2008 6:13 PM

Hamakom Yinachem Eschem Bsoch Sha'ar Aveilei Tzion Vi'Yerushalayim

It is difficult to express in words the anguish we feel as fellow Yiddin to this tragedy. May Hashem watch over little Moishele and the other children who lost a parent in this barbaric terrorist attack. May Hashem always guide Sandra to continue doing selfless acts of kindness. Hashem Yinkom Damam.

(187)
David,
December 1, 2008 4:49 PM

Long life to the family of the victims, and to all of Klal Yisrael, who have been so deeply affected by this atrocity.

(186)
Gail Peltzer,
December 1, 2008 4:22 PM

Please accept both my and my husband's heartfelt condolences for your losses. May Hashem watch over you and protect you and give you strength. I want you to know that you are in our hearts and thoughts and prayers and May Hashem answer your prayers in a revealed manner. Once again may you be comforted among the mourners of Zion and Yerusahalayim. We are truly sorry.

(185)
Robert Stern,
December 1, 2008 4:03 PM

My heart, just as every decent person's, goes out to the Holtzberg family and may they be comforted among the mourners of Zion.

(184)
diane,
December 1, 2008 3:44 PM

a powerful connection

My husband and I cried over the loss of these beautiful people in Mumbai. We are not Jewish but have been talking about conversion. My husband said he felt the pain as if it was his own brother that had passed. We are moving forward in joining the people of Israel

(183)
Roxanne,
December 1, 2008 3:41 PM

Chabad

My heartfelt condolences to each of the Chabad victims in Mumbai. May G-d protect Moshe and give him strength in his awful circumstances of losing both parents to this horrible tragedy. I am not jewish, but I have so much respect for Chabad, and my first exposure to the beauty and sanctity of Judaism was through Chabad. Truly each and every member at Mumabi is a sheliach for the One G-d and the Rebbe.

(182)
Anonymous,
December 1, 2008 3:21 PM

inspired us by their strength

The self sacrifice and dedication of the Holtzbergs for Am Yisrael is humbling and inspiring. This terrible tragedy is pushing Am yisrael to pray even more intensly for our redemption, may it come speedily.

(181)
Dvirah,
December 1, 2008 1:58 PM

May you be comforted with the other mourners of Israel and Zion.

(180)
Joe,
December 1, 2008 1:14 PM

I want to give Chabad thanks.

Dear everyone
Please never, ever give up on your outreach and chesed to your fellow Jews. Please never let the actions of monsters deter you from the goodness and light you bring to the world.
To Chabad in particular,
Please know that you are deeply loved appriciated.

(179)
Orlando Osher,
December 1, 2008 1:11 PM

29 Years ago, I became an orphan, under almost identical circumstances, the differance being that my parents healed the medical pains and suffering and Rabbi Holtzberg and the Rebbetzen did the spiritural and in my haste to think and believe that my email would get to them in time before tragedy struck, I wrote the following: " Subject: Prayers
From: orlandoosher@gmail.com
Date: November 27, 2008 9:29:31 PM EST
To: chabadmumbai@yahoo.com
Cc: ShalomChabad@aol.com
Rabbi Holtzberg,
My prayers and those of others Jews are with you, your family, your congregants, and every Jew held along with you. It's my most sincere desire that all of you be taken out of harm's way ASAP.
Orlando Osher"

(178)
Shirah,
December 1, 2008 1:02 PM

May their memory be a blessing

Please accept my condolences on the tragic loss of Rabbi Holtzberg and Rebbitzin Holtzberg. May the memory of their work in Mumbai inspire others to bring light into a dark world, and may their son grow up to know and to follow his parents' kindness and love of G-d. I will recite Psalms in their memory this week.

(177)
Terri D.,
December 1, 2008 12:43 PM

condolences

Dear Ones,
I send my humble condolences and prayers. The Holtzbergs are models for us and
I will ever think of them when I am afraid to reach out to a hurting world.

(176)
Anonymous,
December 1, 2008 12:27 PM

Yizkeraim Elokeinu L'Tova Im Shear Tzadikai Olam

Av Horachamim was never so meaningful! Memories of the geshmake shabbos I spent with you will now be tinged with overwhelming sadness--but not despair, because you modeled a derech of avodas Hashem b'simcha uv'tuv laivov.Yehi Ratzon shetanuchu b'shalom al miskavchem, that the aveilim should have true nechama b'soch shaar aveilei tzion v'yerushalayim, that Moshe should continue to receive the bracha made at his bris--l'Torah, L'chupa ulemaasim tovim, bderech avosov, and Sandra to receive the blessings for tzadikei umos haolam.

(175)
leah,
December 1, 2008 12:05 PM

May Hash-m soften the hearts of the IDF,the Israeli government, the Jewish police forces throughout Israel

And begin the renewal of their pledged missions as the protectors and defenders of all Jews, no matter what their Jewish religious affiliation is, conservative,secular,reform,chabad,haredi,modern orthodox, just Jewish... etc. This is the light that they should kindle - to be the defenders and protectors of all Jews, no matter where we live in Israel or in the Diaspora. The government and armies of Israel need to wake up in light of intentional attempts at the genocide of the Jewish People, and cease and desist from aiding and abetting the criminals who seek the extinction of the Jewish People. The IDF and the Israeli government is corrupt and the People and citizens of Israel and Diaspora Jews everywhere must put a stop to their abuse,terrorism,and attacks on Jews, by Jews. Period. Our collective actions of putting a stop on this desecration of G-d's Name is mandatory for each and every Jew in the World. Otherwise we are all aiding and abetting this abuse, because we sit idly by. We must, for our own survival, put a stop to the abuses of the IDF and the Israeli government against our fellow Jews. Their atrocious behavior is emboldening those who seek our total destruction. If our own government and military do not protect us, it gives the green light to terrorists to continue to threaten,murder,plan to attack, and carry out their attacks against us. And guess what, IDF and government of Israel, those Arabs,and others could care less that you define yourselves as secular Jews, they will kill you too, you are just helping them by not protecting those who define themselves as religious Jews.

(174)
Anonymous,
December 1, 2008 12:01 PM

Feel Comfort

I hope you take comfort in the fact, that your parents or your children, are viewed as completing their mission in this world. How many of us are able to say that we know our parents fulfilled their mission in this world. We are now one day closer to Moshiach,

(173)
Marvin Shaw,
December 1, 2008 11:38 AM

Please don't forget the others

I lost a nephew (by marriage) Bentsy Kruman in the Chabbad House tragedy. He was a wonderful father, so friendly and with a lovely light sense of humour. He leaves behind my niece Emunah and three beautiful children. Please don't forget the others in this tragedy.
Shalom
Marvin

(172)
Anonymous,
December 1, 2008 11:16 AM

condolences

My family extends condolences to those families who lost loved ones in this cowardly act and tragedy.

(171)
Sharon Fleming,
December 1, 2008 10:43 AM

prayer helps

I am praying for the family and friends of this wonderful couple and especially for their children, for the grandfather who rushed to India to take care of his grandchild. I pray for Sandra, brave Sandra, who saved his life. May God bless her in wonderful ways. Because this is so sad and because it was such a barbaric act, it has touched lives around the world and perhaps let them see the fruitlessness of violence and hate. It was a horribly high price to pay, though.

(170)
Lidia,
December 1, 2008 10:16 AM

The whole Jewish World must stand together!

Our heart and prayers go out to little moshe and his family. To loose such a wonderful, dedicated couple shows what kind of world we live in. Jews all over the world must stick together and pray. Must of all we must make sure to stop the Barbarics around the world.

(169)
malka,
December 1, 2008 9:44 AM

they are kedoshim!

Hamokom menachem eschem m'toch kol aveilo tzion yerushalim. may you know of no pain and no sadness. only the coming of mashiach to be reunited with all loved ones in glorious holy days

(168)
ST,
December 1, 2008 9:43 AM

The world is built on kindness

When my husband first arrived in America and wished to experience a Shabbos in Crown Heights he was hosted by the Holzbergs. Now, more than fifteen years later, he still remembers the warmth and hospitality he experienced in your home. May the kindness and hospitality displayed by your beautiful family, both in NY, Israel and India HI"D continue to serve as inspiration to us all. May your family only know of simchot in the future and may we be zoche to biyas mashiach tzidkeinu bimheira biyameinu.

(167)
Nina Mogilnik,
December 1, 2008 9:42 AM

Light vs. Darkness

The only response to darkness is to spread light. The Holtzbergs seem to have lived that ideal. But the rest of us can to, and we can remind one another daily of the power within each of us to make even one little corner of the world a little brighter, a little better. That much we must do. It is the price we should feel privileged to pay for being on this planet.

(166)
Brenda Trobaugh,
December 1, 2008 8:09 AM

Fear No Evil

God will be with all those who lost a loved one in this unthinkable tragedy and all those who were touched by these wonderful people. Words just can not say what my heart breaks with. The Psalms are the only comfort that I can give that will be heard and understood. My heart and my prayers go out to you.

Brenda

(165)
Leah,
December 1, 2008 7:35 AM

thank you

We are all blessed to have brothers and sisters like the Holtzbergs who have the ability to unite us in this world. I thank G-d and their parents for bringing their beautiful lights into our world. Now what can we each do to keep their light going? Commit to doing something right now and make a difference for all of us. The Holtzberg's showed us the power of one. Thank you.
And may Sandra, the precious Nanny, know the blessings of saving a whole world, the life of Moshle.
May the Holtzberg extended families find comfort amongst all the mourners of Israel and Jerusalem.

(164)
Polly,
December 1, 2008 6:48 AM

MY hearrt breaks when I read and hear stories like this ,my the familys be spared further sorrow.

(163)
Rabbi Shia Leigh,
December 1, 2008 6:04 AM

"You will feel comfort through continuing to build"

In this time of great sadness, we must put the Rebbe's words into practice.
I suggest everyone take upon themselfs one new Mitzvah, especially in strengthening the unity of Klall Yisroel.

(162)
Anonymous,
December 1, 2008 5:27 AM

Self defense training for saintly people

Dear families of Rivki and Gavriel Holtzberg and the other innocent people who were holy and doing good deeds until their untimely deaths, I am so sorry for their loss. I am still crying for days over this senseless tragedy.
Among the good deeds that can be done in the merit and honor of these dear people, let us start giving classes in self-defense training for all shluchim, for all teachers, for all Jews everywhere. Part of Hashem's protection includes prayer, doing good deeds, study, and learning how to protect ourselves. Our enemies must have counted on us to not be armed and trained. They are indeed cowards of the worst kind. They seem to know only how to destroy, not to build, how to make people sad instead of happy.
We must not allow such fine people as the Holtzberg's and the other Jews, as well as the other innocent people who were killed to be so easily harmed. They came here to help people, and they succeeded greatly. Let part of their legacy be to help other Jews and innocents be able to do good works without fear of being harmed and stopped.
I heard that Rivki and Gavriel referred to their little son Moshe as their "miracle" child, and his rescue by his heroic caretaker Ms. Samuel is a miracle. His name being Moshe, and his birthday being on the Shabbat of his rescue seems prophetic, and one thinks of Moshe Rabbeinu. Hashem rescued us with an outstretched arm in dire situations, yet we must meet Him halfway and do something ourselves, too.
May you be comforted among the mourners of Zion and Jerusalem.

(161)
Bernie Mandell,
December 1, 2008 5:26 AM

A tragic event in a very sad world.

(160)
leah,
December 1, 2008 5:11 AM

Hamakom Ynachem Etchem Betoch Avelei Tzion V'Yerushalaim

To Moshe Holtzberg, the Holtzberg and Rosenberg families, may you know no more tza'ar. May HaKadosh Baruch Hu bring Moshiach in our time, when there would be no more tears.

(159)
Fay,
December 1, 2008 4:17 AM

Deepest Sympathy

Deepest sympathy on the loss of these fine people. From a lover of Israel in Australia. Shalom.

(158)
Talya,
December 1, 2008 3:25 AM

Through my tears

Baruch Dayan Haemet. The horror and evil of terrorism is unspeakable, and the only thing that comforts me is the overwhelming connection all Jews feel to each other and how everyone has responded to the tragedy. To the sinat chinam of the terrorists we must respond with ahavat chinam towards each other - loving and giving to each other without having to have a 'reason' to do so.
To the families of those who were killed in Mumbai: Hashem yenachem etchem betoch she'ar aveilei tzion ve'Yerusahalyim - may Hashem comfort you amongst the rest of the mourners of Zion and Jerusalem.

(157)
Tzila,
December 1, 2008 3:21 AM

There no words that can describe the feeling I have in my heart.

Looking at little Moshe with his nanny, haunts me once again with the horrrific time of the holocaust. Once again I ask where is Hashem and where is the civilized world. May Hashem watch over us and may we all be zoycher to see mesiach in our time. May Hashem give strength to the the Holberg families and may baby Moshe be a light unto his emma and abba. And let us not forget who we are and where, what and why we exist on this universe.

(156)
Chaya Rosengarten, MSW,
December 1, 2008 3:18 AM

Hamakom Yinachem Eschem...

To the Holtzberg family and relatives,
I am so deeply saddened at this horrible tragic news. I was watching the news alerts and CNN all of Friday crying, hoping and praying that through some miracle Rabbi and Rebbetzin Hotlzberg a"h and the other victims a"h would come out alive, safe and well. The only thing that gives me some comfort is that little Moshe'le was saved by his righteous nanny, who risked her life so save Moshe'le. May the family know no more tza'ar and be comforted with having Moshe'le and Sandra close by. If I can do anything to help, to please contact me. Hamakom Yinachem Eschem B'soch Avielie Tzion V'Yerushalayim.
Chaya Rosengarten, MSW

(155)
Anonymous,
December 1, 2008 2:47 AM

My sincerest condolences to Moshe and the Holtzberg family.

(154)
Chana Jenny Weisberg,
December 1, 2008 2:10 AM

Hamakom Yenachem Etchem

What an extraordinary young couple, an example for all of us in their love for their fellow Jews- and their self-sacrifice for the Jewish people.
We are broken by their loss. This past Shabbat, when we did not know what their fate was, reminded me of the dark Shabbat we spent years ago waiting for news about the captive Nachson Wachsman HK"D. May their memory inspire all of us to love each other more and to bring more light to our fellow Jews, all Jews, as they did.
Thank you to Aish.com for printing this article.

(153)
The McCartney Family,
December 1, 2008 2:04 AM

We wish you strength, courage and with G-d's help a light to guide you

(152)
rachel,
November 30, 2008 11:44 PM

Blessed Memory of our brothers

The Holbergs' they live in Kidush Hashem, and they continue their route to the Olam Haba with it, is a great example for all of us, my sincere condolences to the family of these tzadikim, and to all the families of Jewish Nation in all the world, in this tragedy, BARUCH DAYAN HAEMET!!

(151)
sheila miranda,
November 30, 2008 11:33 PM

mumbai tragedy

This message comes from Mumbai. I am deeply saddened at the death of Rabbi Gavriel and his wife Rivkah in the recent Mumbai tragedy. May they rest in eternal peace. My heart goes out to their baby Moshe and his brave nanny Sandra Samuel who I hope gets to stay with baby Moshe on their return to Israel. May peace and love return to this very troubled world.

(150)
angela (rachel)brown,
November 30, 2008 11:24 PM

they were two angels, god bless their son Moshe

Both I and my cousin Grace met Rivka and rabbi Gavriel in 2005 through my cousin Sam Marshall(grace's brother) and his wife Irma. We all went to their apartment across from radio Club for Shabbath and were immediately impressed by their warmth, generosity, intelligence and courage. When we visited again on Hannukah,there were a number of other people who were either backpacking or visiting bombay etc. Rivka explained to me that she cooked all the wonderful dishes that we were all enjoying. She later had a number of Hannukah games she organized and presents for the winners. We all laughed , and shared experience and feeling at Rivka's and Rabbi Gavriel's encouragement and sense of joy. When we left Rivka and I just hugged tightly. I knew she suffered her own personal tragedies but she did not show it to any of her friends. Their courage just shone through. There was a lot of love there and I just wished them both so much happiness. They were in the process of getting Nariman House and I was told that they were delighted to have succeeded. I am so happy that they got Moshe and can only imagine the love they showered on their son. It is for this reason and for the loss of these two lovely angels that my family, and friends are so totally devastated at the news of their loss. The sorrow has spread to many countries and people who have been touched by these two incredible human beings. It is in their memory that we will all strive to be better human beings ourselves. We all send Moshe our hugs, our love and hopes for an incredible future.

(149)
David Geffner,
November 30, 2008 10:41 PM

It is hard to see the power of G-d's light shining through in moments like this. The senseless and brutal loss of life to a couple so blessed with kindness and a life's mission of mitzvot are met with torrents of tears and anguish which blind us to the one startling fact about their lives, not their deaths: they touched more people, Jew and Gentile alike, then many of us can ever hope to, despite the precious little time they were given. Their lives, not their deaths, are what must always be remembered. For Rabbi Gavriel and Rivkah Holtzberg were a beacon of g-d's light, dim as it may seem in this tragedy, it shines through the darkness still, and many of us can see it well enough to find our way.

(148)
Michal,
November 30, 2008 10:21 PM

May Hashem give the families of Rabbi and Rebbitzen Holtzberg a nechama as well as the strength and courage to continue spreading the light of Torah throughout the world. Though I have never met them, I have learned from them the true essence of ahavas chinam, loving your fellow Jew. It does not matter who you are, how religious you are, whether you are chassidic or litvish, ashkenazi or sefardi, but that you are a Jew that counts. We are all brothers and must unite as one! May their neshamos have an aliyah, and may they be a meilitz yosher for their children, their families, and all of klal yisroel.

(147)
Anonymous,
November 30, 2008 10:07 PM

We feel your pain

My family and I followed the news anxiously waiting to hear the Holzbergs were OK...davening, crying, giving tzedaka... We cried so much when the terrible news came - even thinking about it gives us pain. Such a wonderful couple, so beautiful and pure, such mitzvos they merited to accomplish, such light they were able to spread... Our tefillos are with you and Moishele, may he live and be well and grow up to be a tzaddik and continue the holy legacy of his parents. May we merit to greet Moshiach speedily in our days!

(146)
Esther Rodriguez,
November 30, 2008 10:07 PM

Sandra Samuel and little Moshe

B"H
Avrohom entrusted Eliezer with the holy mission of finding a suitable wife for Yitzchok, the beloved Rabbi and Rebbetzin Holtzberg entrusted a special woman with the care of their son Moshe. Because of his love for Avrohom and for the duty entrusted to him, Eliezer was successful in finding Rivkah. Our Mumbai Rivkah, o.b.m, entrusted Sandra Samuel with her precious Moshe. Eliezer's efforts assured the continuity of the Jewish people, their holiness. Sandra Samuel by serving her Rivkah, saved this precious offspring of the Holtzberg that he may grow, be educated and continue to bring the light of Torah as his Parents did.

(145)
Anonymous,
November 30, 2008 10:01 PM

We wish to extend our heartfelt codolences to all the families that are grieving.
The little Holtzberg boy and his sibling are now under the direct care of Hashem, our Father in heaven and they will merit much Siyata D'shmaya, until Moshiach comes speedily in our day.

(144)
Lisa Stallman,
November 30, 2008 9:56 PM

Hashem y'racham al klal yisroel

To the families who lost loved ones please accept our deepest heartfelt condolences. May the Rabono Shel Olam comfort you with all of the mourners of zion and Yerushalayim. And may we see the bringing of mashiach soon and may He rebuild our bais hamikdash soon we truly need it. May you find comfort and the good in all.

(143)
Joshua,
November 30, 2008 9:48 PM

Words fail me.....

Oh soooo....very, very sad...!! My sincere condolences to family left behind.

(142)
Anonymous,
November 30, 2008 9:40 PM

l'ilui nishmas

I cried upon hearing the news. My heart bleeds for the families, for Moishie, for all of Klal Yisrael. I explained my tears to my children. "Mommy is crying because when some Jewish people are hurt, all Jews feel their pain since we are all one family." I have taken upon myself, bli neder, to make brachos out loud. I hope that hearing the brachos aloud will improve my own kavanah and will also give others a chance to say Amein. I accept this kabalah in the zechus of the niftarim tzadikim who dedicated their lives to making people aware of Hashem Yisbarach. HaMakom Yinachem Eschem b'soch Shear Avlei Tzion v'Yerushalayim.

(141)
Michelle Abukasis,
November 30, 2008 9:15 PM

I am So Sorry

Its so heart breaking that people would sincelessly want to harm others in thier politiical agenda! My thoughts and prayers of love are w/all.

(140)
Eli,
November 30, 2008 9:12 PM

Please be strong...

It is such a sad situation that we see such great people torn from this world. I wonder, if I can't reach their greatness, what can I do? I just daven to Hashem that we be the best Jews we can be and accomplish our different individual Tafkid (mission) in this world and be able to be zoche for Mashiach (if not through my zechus, please help us be strong and do things properly in the merit of those who returned to Hashem al kiddush Hashem...) May Hashem help the families be strong and courageous.

(139)
Harry Thomas,
November 30, 2008 8:47 PM

Jamaica is my homeland.We too experience terrorism.Each year almost 1,800 persons are murdered, and several hundred disappear.It is all too easy for a terrorist to walk in a crowded public space and murder at will.It is full time the civilized world responds.

(138)
Renoldson J A Joseph,
November 30, 2008 8:43 PM

I would like to express my deepest condolances to the family of Rabbi Holtzburg. We all can learn a great lesson from the Rabbi and his loving wife such sacrifice is rare but greatly needed in this troubling time that we live in.

(137)
Trish,
November 30, 2008 7:57 PM

So Sorry

My husband and I send our love and prayers to the community who have suffered this great sadness. May HaShem protect you and comfort you in your distress. May He bless Gavriel and Rivkah's son and keep him all his days. May evil be put down and righteousness prevail !

(136)
Anonymous,
November 30, 2008 7:46 PM

"Oh what fools these murderers be!!!!!"

My heartfelt condolences to the relatives of the deceased in particular and the Jewish community in general. We often ask, why? what is the reason for such senseless murders?. May God comfort and heal the wounds. This is truly hard to bear.

(135)
Shira,
November 30, 2008 7:34 PM

hamakom yenachem eschem b'soch shaar avlei tsion veyerushalayim

Thank you for raising and supporting your heroic inspiring children. Thank you for the gifts they have left the Jewish people. May your grandson know how fortunate he is to have had beautiful parents both inside and out. May you be open to the strength and comfort G-d gives you. My thoughts are with you.

(134)
reuel chanan,
November 30, 2008 7:22 PM

My deepest condolences

My condolences to the families of the victims! May Hashem comfort you in this time of grief! Come closer and more closer to Hashem. Amen

(133)
Anonymous,
November 30, 2008 7:19 PM

big mirracle

i don't know if any body noticed it is a big miracle for a lot of jews that this Chabadhouse catered to.
Many(hundreds)and same jewish business man traveled and staid by this Rabbis house for Shabbos toward the end of the of every month. And were very close with the rabbi.
If Not For Rappaport lowering his price list and disrupting regular buying and selling many jews would be in chabbad house at the time of the massacar(G-d forbid).
And I among my many friends with me would not be here today writing today my condolences to the family of Gaby and Rivka.
May HASHEM CONTINUE HAVE RAHAMIM ON KLAL ISRAEL.

(132)
Menashe Kaltmann,
November 30, 2008 7:06 PM

We too here in Australia feel your sorrow!

We too here in Australia a Jewish community of 100,000 (kein hora) feel the immense pain and wish you the traditional saying "HaMakom Yenachem Etchem BeTok Aveilei Tziyon Ve'Yerushalim" May you be comforted amongst the mourners of Tzion and Jerusalem"

(131)
Devorah,
November 30, 2008 6:24 PM

Heartfelt condolence

May HaShem look after all the families that were touched by this tragedy! May the sparks of good, spread by Holzbergs', Z"l, help us all to be best we can be as Jews and good people arrownd the world.

(130)
S Ehrlich,
November 30, 2008 6:23 PM

condolences

Their is nothing to add to the clever words of the Lubavitch Rebbi zt"l B'hemshech habinyan tenu'chamu -- "You will feel comfort through continuing to build."

(129)
ChayaEsther Greenstein,
November 30, 2008 6:19 PM

Unbelievable

It is unbelievable to me that two of the most giving, wonderful people on this earth could be murdered by these barbarians. The Rabbi and his wife dedicated their lives to help others live Jewishly. Surely they are in Gan Eden right now. What a tragic loss for mankind.

(128)
j insel,
November 30, 2008 5:51 PM

bekirovai akadesh they were truly children of aaron seeking and bringing peace to all israel we all need to commit to this we are one am yisrael chai moshiach needs to come now please hashem

(127)
Anonymous,
November 30, 2008 5:51 PM

This is true Achdus

there was a story which is used to describe what HaShem / G-d wants from us. It is about a King who could have any bird he wanted, but he wanted a very rare bird which sang in a very unusually beautiful manner, which made him very happy.
What G-d wants from us is to be "rare"....meaning to do that which is hard and unusual for us. To go about our day and be the best we can is wonderful, but to go OUT OF OUR WAY to do something very special and meaningful is RARE and this is what HaShem wants. This article is a rare and special, meaningful way of showing love for all Jews, by honoring these precious Jews who lived their lives by sharing and beautifying Torah the best they could. it hurts so much to think about such a precious Rabbi having to wrap his beloved Rebbitzen in a tallis just shortly before his own death. As a fellow Jew, you are one of the "body" of Am Yisrael, you have brought this out with love and Ahava.
Thankyou for giving us strength and hope for Jews in the future.

(126)
Anonymous,
November 30, 2008 5:49 PM

El Nikamot Hashem

We say every Shabbat in Av HaRachamim- "Sing the praises of His People- for He will avenge the blood of His servants". This great day cannot come too soon. May Hashem grant the families true nechamot.

(125)
Reb. Doris Feinstein,
November 30, 2008 5:43 PM

Baruch Dayan Emet

It has been so hard for me to think
these last few days because although
I did not know the Holtzbergs I as a
Mother and Savta feel tremendous pain
and grief for their son and their
families. To devote themselves totally
to Hakadosh Baruch Hu and the love they
exuded to so many was a true Kiddush
Hashem. I feel that in this day and
age we are up against the darkness of
extremists who are barbarians who are
truly heartless. May their memory forever be a bracha to their families,
to klal Yisrael and may Moshiach soon
come to bring us indeed from the 4
corners of the world back to Eretz
Yisrael, to usher in shalom and the
emes of One Hashem. May it be the
will of Hashem.

(124)
Goldie Klein,
November 30, 2008 5:33 PM

All of Klal Yisroel is mourning the terrible loss of Rabbi & Mrs. Holzcberg. This incident defies all reason. We can only say..Hashem will take 'nakama for their blood'. May the families of these two outstanding fighters for Yiddishkeit find consolation among the mourners of Zion.

(123)
Eli Trisker,
November 30, 2008 5:31 PM

My condolences to all of you

I extend my heartfelt condolences to all of you. It is so sad what is going on in this world. We are hated by so many. Lets pray for peace.

(122)
Wassim Muna,
November 30, 2008 5:15 PM

Outraged and Resolved

Firstly, condolences to all who are dealing with this tragedy.
As a current muslim, I am angered and ashamed by the actions of these people. I do not agree that they are vermin, I prefer to classify them as people who have sunk to the lowest of lows ultimately because the light that shone in them as babies has all but died out, drowned out by their own hatred. I'm not making excuses for people who do wrong, but I think it is easy to do the wrong thing in the absence of good leadership and Islam suffers from a lack of the scholarly leadership which Judaism boasts plenty of. These crimes against humanity must not be tolerated, the war on terror is real. I would like to add that I think Rabbis and Imams could do more to eliminate this disease of fundamentalism than soldiers ever could. The answer to bad religion is more good religion (not my words).
I still feel I should appologise on someone's behalf!

(121)
Sarah,
November 30, 2008 5:03 PM

Thank you, Aish

As a Chabad Shlucha, I am moved and touched by your warm words of chizuk in the face of this senseless hatred and horrific loss to all of the nation of Israel. May this be the first step in healing all the wounds of exile and bring Moshiach now, uniting Moshe'le with his parents once again.

(120)
Marcia R.,
November 30, 2008 4:58 PM

My sincere condolences go to the families of Rabbi Gavriel and Rivkah Holtzberg. May their memory be for a blessing...
To all the families of the 169 people killed, I send my sincerest and deepest condolences. Terrorism shall not win out. All the good people in the world will stand strong and stand together as we work to bring peace to our world. Good shall prevail over evil and light shall brighten the darkness.
May G-d give you all strength to carry on in the name of your loved ones.

(119)
Anonymous,
November 30, 2008 4:57 PM

If only words could comfort you at this trageic time...Please know that as a parent who has lost a child, no matter what the age, it''s the most difficult time that you will ever encounter. Bitachon with help you to survive and the more mitzvos you do, the higher level the neshamas of these special beings will rise. Their neshamas will always be with you. May you have the koach you need to survive and raise beautiful Moshe. May you be comforted amongst the mourners of Tzion and Yerushalyim.

(118)
suri steinberger,
November 30, 2008 4:53 PM

we share your misery - you are not alone - they will never be forgotten

I cried all Friday when I heard the news. I said what good is my crying. I ran to the store and bought flour and yeast and baked Challah in their memory - for a zchut for their neshamot. All Jews all over will unite in this tragedy - we are one.

(117)
Larry Segal,
November 30, 2008 4:52 PM

These are dangerous times

I feel for the family. Chabad has always been good to me and a light to the communities they serve in. This is one of many instances of radical Islam's war against the Infidels. We must begin to unite the various factions of Judaism and realize that these people do not care whether we are Reform, Orthodox, Conservative or unafilliated. During the Six Day War and other emergency times, we must unite all resources and open communication between all and protect each other. I hope this is not an over reation, however as I see what is going on in Europe and other areas of the world, it only seems to be spreading. At the same time, I would like us to bring the peace. It would be good to see the peaceful Islamic leaders condemn what has happened, however I have heard little.

(116)
Anonymous,
November 30, 2008 4:37 PM

Send bandit "insurgents" to Sheol

Jewish people badly need a new word to
show to the Islamists who insult
civilized societies and bastardize their own faith. Retire the Hebrew
word "Shalom" and highlight "Nekomah"
[vengeance]. Ten deaths to one for the worthless scum who act,praise,or encourage their kind to kill Jews.
How many more acts of terror or genocide will be tolerated by survivors
or bystanders in this confrontation with evil ?

(115)
Anonymous,
November 30, 2008 4:35 PM

Thank you Aish.com for posting this beautiful article, you can find a lot of more news about the Holtzbergs from Chabad.info www.CrownHeights.CH Chabadworld.net & from Chabad.org once again thank you very much for posting this article, now i can say clear out I am a fan of Aish.com

(114)
Kayla,
November 30, 2008 4:19 PM

Never again....but it is

We say, "Never again!".....but it keeps replaying itself for the Jewish people......We must survive....they can not win!!!

(113)
bluma,
November 30, 2008 4:11 PM

Well written Dr. Daniel

Daniel and Yael, we enjoyed the time we spent when you lived in New Orleans after Katrina. You expressed inspiring ideas beautifully. Thank you.

It is such a helpless feeling - What can we do? What can we do? Ribbono Shel Olam, we are commanded to protect the mother bird from emotional pain when we remove her eggs or her young from the nest, but we keep the reality of her pain in mind - as our sages have taught us that in so doing we are making a statement - a plea- to our Creator: "Look at the broken heart of this mere bird at her separation from her young, and you have mercy upon her. Please remember the anguish of our separation from you in this hard, hard, Galus, and bring us back, WHOLE, to our nest!" There is some Heavenly decree that your children, who were here accomplishing so much to help bring neshamos back, should come to such a tragic incomprehensible end. But they are now the holiest of Kedoshim. I believe their tefilot will continue to bring back Neshamos even now, and through this terrible pain you feel as parents you can daven like no one else to change any more of these decrees to good, so that there will never be another tear of sorrow shed by a mother for her child who has been taken. May Hashem bless you with strength and long life, and somehow, with the will to dispell the depression the Yetzer hara may want to cast over you, and replace it with emunah and music and simcha, that can strengthen the life of the sweet yasom who is now yours.

(110)
ROBERT,
November 30, 2008 3:44 PM

the words are hard

Isaiah 2:4
He will judge between the nations, And will render decisions for many peoples, And they will hammer their swords into plowshares and their spears into pruning hooks. Nation will not lift up sword against nation, And never again will they learn war

(109)
Ana Moriah Kaufman,
November 30, 2008 3:35 PM

I can't stop crying,,,

Even though I never had the privilege of meeting Rabbi Gavriel and Rivkah I feel like I have lost close family members and I cannot stop crying. My heart breaks for their families and for the extended Chabad family and for all of us Jews. The world has been able to SEE the selfless love that Gavriel and Rivkah had. Hopefully the world will respond by showing that type of love to others and by also shining that intense of a light into the world... Thanks and praise to HaShem for sparing Moshe. Thank you, Sandra Samuel, for risking your life to save him. May HaShem spread a balm of comfort over Israel. With love,
Ana Moriah Kaufman

(108)
Alan C. Horowitz,
November 30, 2008 3:27 PM

We Will Never Forget

Just as we will always remember the senseless and brutal murders of innocent people, we will never forget the mitzvot that good and decent people have done. And by so remembering their words and actions, we redouble our efforts at being proud Jews who are determined to fight for all that is right and just and to help extinguish evil. May the memory of those lost be an inspiration to us all.

(107)
Sheina Lerman,
November 30, 2008 3:23 PM

What did the terrorists accomplish in their murderous acts?

My heart breaks for the families of the victims of the criminal terrorist acts this past week in Mumbai. As a Jew, I am especially concerned by the obvious anti-semitic undercurrent evident in the targetted attack against the Chabad Centre and its staff. Each of us as individuals must speak out against the violent actions of fanatics who feel a depth of hate towards innocent people most of us cannot begin to understand.

(106)
Rivkah,
November 30, 2008 3:19 PM

Beautiful article, inspiring comments

This is a beautiful article. We are Shluchim of Chabad living in Germany. We applaud your site for publishing such a beautiful article about the Holtzberg's Hy"d. The comments are an absolute show of unity among the Jewish people. We are all one. We are all G-d's equal children. This unity will bring light into our dark world and the coming of the Geula. May it be NOW!

(105)
Anonymous,
November 30, 2008 3:19 PM

let this famjly know that not only the jews but a lot of decent people around the world share in their sorrow AND PRAY THAT THE GOOD WORKS THEY STARTED WILL CONTINUE TO GROW
joshua oladele

(104)
mordechai,
November 30, 2008 2:49 PM

Hmokom Ynachem

When i tagedy like this occurs, it is very easy to give up, close up shop. But NO is the cahabad response, we will continue with the job, untill it is completed. May little Moshe, grow up, and follow in his parents selfless footsteps.

(103)
N Barrett,
November 30, 2008 2:49 PM

I am once more saddened by the barbarism of certain blood-thirsty groups who have absolutely no regard for human life. My heartfelt sympathy to the families who have lost beloved ones.

(102)
Irv,
November 30, 2008 2:32 PM

compassion & hurt & a need for retribution

Words cannot and never will suffice to express the pain one feels at times like this. Please note that NOT ONE voice from the muslim community has been heard expressing outrage and regret. We will defeat them by continuing the work of the Rabbi and his wife (of blessed memory). May all those involved and responsible be subject to the wrath of Hashem.

(101)
Yve Beyfus,
November 30, 2008 2:31 PM

memory

We remember them
At the beginning of the year and when it ends
we remember them.
As long as we live,they too will live,
for they are now a part of us,as
we remember them.
May G-D comfort you and all who have mourned for Zion and Jerusalem.

(100)
laurence franks,
November 30, 2008 2:29 PM

I wish long life to their survivors and friends

May G-d watch over all Jews wherever we are.
The wonderful difference between Jews and most non Jews is that what you ask us to do- not to hate, not spending time with negative thoughts but push forward and build spiritually.

(99)
Yisroel Yitzchak Martin,
November 30, 2008 2:19 PM

Dont let a Sacrafice go in vain!

They sacraficed their lives to spread 3 things,
1. Torah
2. Chesed
3. Willingness
The willingness they showed to leave all of the easy things behind and move to a strange place,To keep yiddushkite alive, That is true bravery, The bravery to teach torah and emes even in a place where there is so much wrong, thats true bravery, and the light of two neshamos shining bright in a area surrounded by darkness, That, to all who may see it, is true bravery.

(98)
Zipporah,
November 30, 2008 2:09 PM

G-D Bless You and Yours Sandra Samuel

May G-D Bless You and Yours Sandra Samuel, the Angel who rescued Baby Moshe!
When I think of this tragedy, out of the darkness the Brightest Light shone forth, Baby Moshe !!
Shalom
Zipporah

(97)
Anonymous,
November 30, 2008 2:06 PM

Beautiful article

It's truly amazing how Hashem brought every Jew together in a matter of days. HY"D. May we only and always share good news.

(96)
Anonymous,
November 30, 2008 2:02 PM

moving video in memory of rabbi gavriel and rivkah holtzberg

I had the merit of meeting them and spending an amazing shabbos with them. There is a moving video of them on youtube under "heroes of mumbai" (it is the fifth video on the list when scrolled down).
Please pass it on to anyone you might think may be inspired by it.
If the editors of aish wish to use it, please please do.

(95)
Jan Schulman,
November 30, 2008 1:59 PM

Thanks to Sandra Samuel for her bravery

Thanks must be given to Sandra Samuel as well as to Hashem for helping save the baby Moshe, while his parents lay dying. This is a terrible tragedy but there must be a reason that Sandra was picked by the Holtzbergs to be with them and to be their baby's nanny. Now I hope she will be able to stay close with him and help to overcome this terrible loss, together they can comfort each other and she can help him remember his parents.

(94)
Anonymous,
November 30, 2008 1:53 PM

Thank you Aish.com

Thank you Aaish.com, for putting aside your differences with Chabad in these incredibly tumultuous times. We need to come together for a greater good, and realize the enemy did not and does not care what type of Jew one is. They want JEWISH blood! Am-Yisroel, now more than ever, needs to unite and send a message to OUR enemies of collective resolve and fortitude. Thank you, AM YISROEL CHAI!

(93)
Carl Goldberg,
November 30, 2008 1:48 PM

We are at war with many enemies,

The good Rabbi Dr. Daniel P. Aldrich writes: "We are at war with many enemies, those who seek to turn our planet to darkness." And, just who, precisely, might these "many enemies" be? Why doesn't the rabbi tell us? Rabbi Aldrich suggests that we take action quickly: "We can all put our grief, our disbelief, our desire to do something into action -- and we must do it quickly. Send money to a Jewish cause. Spend some time telling your parents, children, and friends how much you love them and care for them. See what positive things you can do for an ailing neighbor or a depressed friend."
Such action is purely selfish. It will help us to feel good about ourselves, but it will do absolutely nothing to prevent similar murders of Jews in the future. Constructive action first of all requires that we name the enemy. The enemy is religion/ideology of ISLAM! The Koran itself declares all non-Moslems to be the enemy, and Jews are singled out at the worst of the enemies of Moslems.
Muhammad said to the Jews: "If you embrace Islam, you will be safe. You should know that the earth belongs to Allah and His Apostle, and I want to expel you from this land. “
Muhammad also said: "You (i.e. Muslims) will fight with the Jews till some of them will hide behind stones. The stones will (betray them) saying, 'O 'Abdullah (i.e. slave of Allah)! There is a Jew hiding behind me, so kill him.' " This, by the way, has become part of the HAMAS Charter.
Certainly not all Moslems follow these precepts from the Koran and Muhammad, but many Moslems do. All Moslems are required to do so, which means that there will always be new recruits among Moslems who take these religious requirements seriously. That is the enemy that Rabbi Aldrich did not name.
Once we are aware of the nature of the enemy, we can begin to formulate a policy for action which will deter or prevent such brutal murders of Jews (and non-Jews, too!) that we saw in Mumbai -- and countless other places in the last twenty years.

(92)
Rosen,
November 30, 2008 1:46 PM

tragic!

It's so tragic that such a group of Islamic fundamentalists don't appreciate the life of others different from them to the point they take them away. Judaism certainly doesn't promote this killing mentality, since it is one of the most pro-life religions.

(91)
Sandra Lampach,
November 30, 2008 1:42 PM

HaMakom Yenachem Autchem Toch Aveili Tzion v"Yerushalayim

My heart aches for the parents of the Holtzbergs who died "al kiddush Hashem". May they and their families be comforted among the mourners of Zion and Jerusalem.

(90)
Leah,
November 30, 2008 1:42 PM

Difficult to bilieve

I was so sad and ¨angry¨when I heard the news, one of my friends have sent their names in order to read Thehilim for them, perhaps they were already dead. But it always hapen to me I get angry at Hashem, but reading this article have put everything in its ¨righ¨¨ place againg, thank you

(89)
Aviva,
November 30, 2008 1:42 PM

May their memory be for a blessing.

Truly, may we never forget Rabbi Gavriel and Rivka, as well the others so brutally murdered. What a blessing that their son was rescued. The woman who did so was an angel.

(88)
Deborahann Garcia,
November 30, 2008 1:41 PM

They will always remain lights in a dark storm.

I don't know what to say. There is
sorrow at such tragedies. What can be
said? Only that life must go on--it is
in living day-to-day that will be the
true victory of such hatred. Shalom.

(87)
Moshe,
November 30, 2008 1:37 PM

Baroukh Dayanei Emeth

Amakom Ynahem et'hem betoh chaarei avlei Tsion viYroushalaim
Hachem protected all the Rabbi Shlouhim around the world and all the Jews, Machia'h Now, AMEN.

(86)
Herbert Schwarz, MD,
November 30, 2008 1:34 PM

Tragedy in Mumbai

Mumbai was a tragedy waiting to happen. Sandra Samuel, the nanny who risked her life to save the baby is the true heroine of this story, and should be singled out and prayed for. And a prayer for all the souls in the Taj and the other hotels placing all the world in danger.

(85)
...,
November 30, 2008 1:33 PM

I don't know what to say.
They are an inspiration, and what happened was heart-breaking...beyond my ability to understand.
I hope we can put all these emotions into action, and for all those injured to have a speedy recovery.

(84)
Jeannette Noteboom,
November 30, 2008 1:25 PM

Heartfelt condolences

Please extend my heartfelt condolence to all those who stay behind. May Hashem use this terrible tragedy for His glory and may He use it for good as only He can.

(83)
Anonymous,
November 30, 2008 1:17 PM

inspiring

May the inspiration of the Holzbergs' legacy of mitzvot and ma'asim tovim be an everlasting source of zchuiot for them, and may that memory help us all to grow and add to the light in the world.

(82)
matisyahu,
November 30, 2008 1:17 PM

"hamakom yinachem eschem b'soch shaar aveiley tzion v'yerushalayim"
we need to thank hashem forever that he gave us the torah and saved us from turning out murderers like these evil brutal savages - that are worse than animals
"yesh koneh olamo bshaah achas" - somtimes a person earns his world in a short time and fullfills his task quickly
we are taught that those who die "al kiddush hashem" feel no pain
may we merit speedily in our days the fulfilment of the promise of the prophets that all mankind will return to the true creator and his torah and all the lies of the "made up" religions will be exposed and peace and prosperity and rightiousness will reign.

(81)
Anonymous,
November 30, 2008 1:16 PM

We will survive and live to see the elimination of terrorism

My heart it broken at yet another example of the best among us being snuffed out as a result of hatred and ignorance.
We will survive...as Jews and as citizens of a world gone mad. Righteousness must triumph in the end, but only with a willingness to seek out and exterminate all the terrorists who seek to destroy our civilization.
Exterminate is a word used for vermin.
I would not dignify them by using the word kill. That is used for humans, animals and insects. People who live by hate and murder are not people at all.
A Jewish woman in NYC who fears for the life of her prominent family. I might be a coward not to list my name, but I'd prefer to survive and fight the fight of our Jewish lives....all of us...Jews and non-Jews.

(80)
Mel Berger,
November 30, 2008 12:57 PM

Continue

We must fight the darkness that has descended on the world by bringing the light of Jewish belief and faith to the world. May those killed rest in peace and those injured have a speedy recovery.

(79)
Randall Bassin,
November 30, 2008 12:32 PM

May G'd comfort the bereaved families and friends

...of Rabbi Gavriel and Rivkah Holtzberg with strength and peace, and may their memories be for a blessing.

(78)
Fay,
November 30, 2008 12:26 PM

I am so sorry

I did not know the Rabbi and his wife but many of my family members are well aquanted with them. I have heard such incredible and beautiful stories about their generosity and kindness. They are what we should all aspire to. I am so sorry for their loss in our world, words do not exist for the sadness and pain I feel for my fellow Jews who were brutaly taken from us. may G-d find ways to comfort the mourners and all of Yisroel during these dark time. May we all participate in acts of kindness in their honour.

(77)
Shoshana Zakon,
November 30, 2008 12:25 PM

Many benefit from Chabad

I may not have traveled to India, but my husband O"H and I often benefited from the hospitality of Chabad -- in Santa Barbara, in Providence, in Halifax and other North American cities.
The centers are places of warmth and comraderie.
May Hashem comfort the mourners of their families amongst all the other mourners of Zion and Yerushalayim.

(76)
Anonymous,
November 30, 2008 12:24 PM

My husband was in Mumbai just 3 months ago and personally enjoyed Rabbi Gavriel and Rivka's hospitality. Although for me it is not so pleasant when he leaves home, it was a good feeling to know that there in Mumbai he would be at a heimishe place, where he could eat and pray and be in a homey jewish place, surrounded by such warm people. I'll always be thankfull for this. And now I too join in the pain of the mourners. Hamokom jenacheim eschem betoch shaar aveilei tsion vijerushalaim.

(75)
Ruby G.,
November 30, 2008 12:23 PM

Sending sincere condolences

BS"D
My deepest sympathy to the families of Gavriel and Rivkah Holzberg. Nothing I can say will take away the pain, but please know that the the Jewish world is feeling this terrible loss of a couple that gave so much to other Jews. May their souls be bound up in the bonds of eternal life. And may we see them again when Mashiach Comes and Tehiyas Hamasim.
Hamokom y'nachaym eschem b'soch sho'or avaylay tziyon virusholoyim.
A friend

(74)
Anonymous,
November 30, 2008 12:07 PM

"HaMakom yenachem etchem b'toch sh'ar aveilei Tsion v'Yerushalayim"

It is said that the mourning period for a child(or a spouse) is only one month because we never need any sort of longlasting reminder. This loss is absolutely never out of our minds.In time, the Rebbe's,A"H, words are exactly on target. To continue to build is truly our only comfort.

(73)
mg,
November 30, 2008 12:01 PM

2 beautiful Jewish Souls

there are no words to say on the terrible lost we should all pray for compassion and go back to HASHEM and scream for the redemtion

(72)
Anonymous,
November 30, 2008 12:00 PM

Peace

Words fail but prayers do not. Baruch Dayan Emet

(71)
Nancy W.,
November 30, 2008 11:59 AM

My Heartfelt Sympathy

I've read every comment submitted above. I suppose as a type of grieving (like we do when we as Jews sit shiva and reminisce about the departed). I think of the Holtzberg's children, of their parents and of those in the World who are also grieving over the loss of the couple (and the others whose names have thus far not been mentioned). In addition, I am thinking of how truly difficult it continues to be to comprehend the World in which we live in today (in relation to these horrendous terrorist attacks). G-d gives us strength. I agree with Rabbi and appreciate his informative e-mail. I WILL make a donation to my neighborhood Chabad in the Holzberg's memory. I will light a yahrzeit candle tomorrow (Monday) after their funeral. I will think of them and their unselfish lives. But, I will never comprehend terrorist activity. Yes, I suppose G-d's plan is not to question and those affected by this event will grow and find purpose. Words really are so simplistic.
G-d Bless us and gives us strength.

(70)
Chana Pombo,
November 30, 2008 11:55 AM

RE: Condolences to Family and Friends

I started to cry when I saw the picture of Sandra Samuel holding little Moshe, I am so thankful that she was able to rescue him from this horrible tragedy. I send my condolences to the families and friends who lost loved ones.

(69)
Anonymous,
November 30, 2008 11:51 AM

Hamokom inachem eschem bitoch sharei avlaon zion yerushalim

May they be a malitz yosher for klal yisrael, and may we all be reunited with these tahor neshamos very very soon. We cannot imagine your pain but you are in everybodys teffilos, and may Hashem give you all the strengh you need.

(68)
Verna M. Black,
November 30, 2008 11:45 AM

The Tallit wrapped around the Rebbitzen

What a gesture of sweetness from a loving husband who was physically destroyed along with his beloved.
The Tallit is worn at the happiest occasions and unfortunately at the saddest.May the almighty above bring solace to us all, and the Tallit bring peace as we view it.

(67)
Leah,
November 30, 2008 11:41 AM

We are all family

I would normally not put words in anyone else's mouth, yet I know that the whole Jewish community world wide feels pain and suffering over the tragic loss of these beautiful yidden who posessed such wonderful neshamos. I have cried many tears-they still flow. May you be comforted amongst the mourners and sufferes of Zion and Yerushalayim.

(66)
Sonia Braun - Freeman,
November 30, 2008 11:39 AM

My heart's breaking

Our Rabbi from Valley Chabad in NJ sent out a mass email to pray for Rabbi Holzberg and his family. Two righteous people killed because they were Jews. I do not believe that was not planned. My parents were both Holocaust Survivor's. My Father passed away 4 years ago. I am glad he was not here to see this.Our condolences go out to the family. Our Thanks go to Sandra Samuel.

(65)
Channie,
November 30, 2008 11:36 AM

"...the fragrance of the field which Hashem has blessed."

Rabbi kelemer dedicated yestday's sermon to the memory of Rabbi and Rebbetzin Holtzberg (as undoubtedly many Rabbis have done). He took his cue from the Parsha, citing a source that said that Rivka's contribution was not so much that she got the brachos for Yaakov, but that she borrowed Esau's clothing to put on Yaakov so that Yaakov could receive the blessings.
Sometimes it is necessary for a Jew to go out into the field, away from his own home and "ohel", to do Hashem's work and to spread the beautiful fragrance of Torah. This is what Chabad does so well, and what the Holtzberg's (yehi shemom boruch) excelled in. They brought warmth, Torah, and pride in Yiddishkeit to any Jew of any persuasion who came into their circle. Rabbi Kelemer emphaized how difficult it was to bring kosher food into India, how the Holtzberg's arranged for the shochtim (A"H) to come on a regular basis so that Rivka could cook proper kosher meals for Shabbos, often for one or two hundred people. All done with both a sense of humility and purpose, as the Rebbe had commanded. Finally, he said that when Gavriel and Rivka Holtzman meet Rabbi Schneerson in that olam hoemes, they will be able to stand with pride and say that they have fulfilled their mission, in spite of the few yars they had to do so.
He finished with a brocho for Moshe, who, without his parents physically, would undoubtedly be raised with stories of his martyred parents and would grow to continue their legacy.
May their neshomos find this rest tachas kanfei Hashchina and may they be forever bound in the bond of everlasting life.

(64)
Shimon From LA,
November 30, 2008 11:32 AM

Hamakom

I have committed to make an extra effort to smile @ everyone I meet just like Rav Gavriel did HY"D as a alias neshama.
Hamakon yinacaim eschem b'soch avlei zion v'Yerushalaiym

(63)
Rebecca Witonsky,
November 30, 2008 11:24 AM

Deepest condolences to the Holtzberg family

To the Holtzberg family and the broader Chabad family:
I send you my deepest condolences on the barbaric and brutal murders of Rabbi Gavriel and Rivka Holtzberg at the hands of hateful Muslim terrorists who show no respect for the sanctity of human life.
There is no doubt that you were targeted for destruction because you were Jews by an evil enemy.
I mourn for the fact that you were cut down in the prime of your lives, in your twenties, while in the midst of performing incredible mitzvot for the Jews of India. I mourn as well for the fact that your two-year-old son Moshe has become an orphan at such a young age. My heart breaks for your son and your parents.
Yet the legacy of your mitzvot will go on, giving us Jews strength to continue on the path of kindness and compassion after your example. I am with you in your sorrow.
Sincerely,
Ms. Rebecca Witonsky

(62)
Lori,
November 30, 2008 11:16 AM

Your loss is felt by the world

To my dear cousin and his family,
May your family be comforted among all the mourners of Zion.
And thank you Rabbi Dr. Daniel P. Aldrich for your words about Rabbi Gavriel and Rivkah Holtzberg.
My first reaction was to seek comfort in my own local Jewish community, with my family and friends. We spent Shabbat praying and talking about how this horrible act affected each of us. The words of the Lubavitcher Rebbe are the only that seem to bring my heart and mind any relief: B'hemshech habinyan tenu'chamu -- "You will feel comfort through continuing to build."
May this be true for all of us.

(61)
Anonymous,
November 30, 2008 11:01 AM

My heart goes out to the families

I want to extend my condolences (along with the thousands of others) to the families of the Holzbergs (as well as the families of all the other good people who were cut down viciously in Mumbai). When I heard about the situation at Chabad, I immediately began to read tehillim (something I am afraid I do not do often other than in davening on Shabbat and Yom Tovs and then of course "emergencies") and prayed with all my heart and soul for their safety and then was crushed to hear the sad news. I am continuing to study Torah more and more and am on my way to grow closer to my Judaism but if it is any small "consolation" to the Holzberg families, I just want them to know that we are all deeply aggrieved by your loss and will try to spread the light of Torah more often so maybe we can one day soon wipe out all evil for good. May Moshiach come now and may this make little Moishele stronger to grow happy and healthy and remember how brave his parents were.

(60)
Anonymous,
November 30, 2008 10:58 AM

My Sincere Condolences

I pray that the work the Holzberg's have done will continue on long after they are gone. The Lord is receiving them now, giving them rest for their wonderful labors of love. I am saddened about the brutal death they endured...although I did not know them personally, I know they enjoyed providing comfort to the people of God. May they rest in peace and the family be encouraged in knowing that we are all praying for them. Shalom

(59)
Esther,
November 30, 2008 10:50 AM

Register your mitzvah in their z'chus

Chabad.org has started a mitzvah registry where you can register the mitzvah that you choose to do in the merit of these shluchim. You can also donate to a fund for their baby Moishe and to rebuild the chabad in Mumbai.

(58)
Janis Fuhrman,
November 30, 2008 10:50 AM

Spread your love.

Thank-you for your beautiful and insightful article. I know that horrible things happen that we can never fully comprehend. There are so many lessons to be learned. I find that spreading love -- letting all who are important to you know that you are so fortunate to have them in your life -- should be #1. My heart is breaking...especially for little Moshe.

(57)
mike z,
November 30, 2008 10:45 AM

Naflu al kiddush hashem

Hamakom yenachemchem im shear avayla zion veyerushalayim. I had been in Bombay in 1977 prior to a Chabad presence and through Joint donated sidurim and machzot to the ancient Bnai Israel community. What a tragedy to the entire world for the murdered souls who in the prome of their lives maytu al kiddush hashem. May their memories be remenbered for the good. They did not die. Their memories will be remembered by all of us. Out of disaster something good will accrue.

(56)
maria spinelli,
November 30, 2008 10:42 AM

I am a woman Italian of Verona City.
I want to express my sorrow about a disaster in Mombay, i'm very sorry for
every people, expecially for Israelian
People.End for the family's Rabbi. I embrace iour san, and I hope for him a better future!
I hope in a better future for every people in the world.Expecially for Israele, a Country that I love very much.
Maria Spinelli, friend A.D.I. AMICI DI ISRAELE, and A.V.I.I. Associazione Veronese Italia Israele.

(55)
esther, Toronto, Canada,
November 30, 2008 10:41 AM

a Tragic and Sad Loss

In Toronto the Chabad movement is well known for its dedication to the Jewish community. That they are all over the world, often in dangerous locations, is a blessing for our fellow Jews.
Everything I have read about the Holtzbergs makes me admire and respect their work and devotion. All the peole who were fortunate to meet them in India, or elsewhere, must have come away enlightened and full of love for this fine couple.
May their families get through these painful days and ultimately find comfort in their memories. To the other families, Jewish or otherwise, who lost loved ones, my condolences and wishes for peace in your lives.

(54)
Laura,
November 30, 2008 10:37 AM

In their memory

Let us continue to practice mitzvot. Let us fight terrorism which threatens us all. Let us remember the Holtzbergs and emulate them.

(53)
Monika,
November 30, 2008 10:31 AM

grief

Words fail to express my sadness and my grief, when I think of this marvellous,selfless young couple and their little son who is an orphan now. Will that sort of thing never stop? I learned from the media that the attack was meticulously planned and that even many locals did not know that there was a Jewish centre. Apparently the terrorists were determined to kill Jews.

(52)
richard,
November 30, 2008 10:30 AM

condolences

I am very sorry to hear of the terrible slaughter of the Gavriel family.
I am a Christian and live in london. We said prayers in church today for all the victims in Mumbai.
the Lord spared the Rabbis youngest child and i pray that the young boy will grow up with forgiveness in his heart and be a beacon for peace in this world that so needs forgiveness and peace

(51)
Louisa Sassoon,
November 30, 2008 10:25 AM

God needed angels in heaven, and who better than the Holzberg's.

My deepest condolences to the Holzberg family who are left behind to mourn these beautiful souls who did so much good. I know that the baby will be surrounded with much love. We are in a world where people have no conscience.

(50)
Vivian,
November 30, 2008 10:21 AM

The murder of the Holtzbergs is a tremendous loss for the Jewish nation.

Rabbi and Rivkah Holtzberg accomplished so much during their short time in Mumbai. May their efforts continue and may their mitzvahs inspire all of us to follow their path of righteousness and good deeds.

(49)
Anonymous,
November 30, 2008 10:20 AM

I first heard this story while standing in a convenience store and watching the local news this past Friday morning..

and cried. I thought of our local Chabad Rabbi who was one of thirteen children. He said that all his brothers and sisters were scattered about the globe just trying to reach out to fellow Jews who need support in their spiritual growth. These people were not hurting anybody. Now I'm mad.........

(48)
Rifki Ross,
November 30, 2008 10:18 AM

HaMakom yenachem eschem b'csoch sha'ar avlei Zion v'Yerushalayim

Words are inadequate. We've been told by our Gedolim that tragedies happen to awaken us to renew our Avodas Hashem. While the message is to those of us left behind, those taken are the kedoshim whose z'chusim are many. The Holzbergs were doing avodas hakodesh. Many their neshamos have an aliyah and their families a nechama.

(47)
Rifkah,
November 30, 2008 10:17 AM

I can not stop crying

Every day since I heard of this horrific buttchery of the Holtzbergs I keep crying as though I lost someone I loved dearly. Yet I never knew this couple or heard of them until they were murdered. I am crying now as I write. Kol Yisrael Areivim Zeh Bazeh. This is what I am feeling. All of Israel are bound together. If one Jew is suffering we all are suffering. Even though we can not understand why such horrors happen we need to memorialize this young couple's lives by living the way did. May their son grow up to greatness amongst his people, Israel.

(46)
Yaffa Naomi,
November 30, 2008 10:15 AM

A Time To Live And a Time To Die

Hashem will comfort the mourners as HE comforts all those who mourn in Zion and Jerusalem. You join the martyrs of Israel and your light will continue to shine through your son, Moishe, and all others whose lives you touched for Hashem

(45)
Faith,
November 30, 2008 10:05 AM

My deepest and heartfelt sympathies to the families of the lovely and wonderful Holtzbergs. May we remember them always for their kindness, goodness, and courage and forl the sacrifices they made for all Jews around the world. Amen.

(44)
Dina,
November 30, 2008 10:00 AM

Kiddush Hashem

May Hashem comfort the mourners of Tzion- every Jew. This is a tradegy, a loss for every single Jew. May the Neshama / Soul of The Holtzbergs help bring the Guela closer. May Hashem protect over Baby Moshe and their family. I am so sad by this tremendous loss.

(43)
Anonymous,
November 30, 2008 9:55 AM

My heart is weeping!

This tragic loss of humanity caused by those who have no humanity makes me weep. I weep for all who were murdered pvin this latest horror. To the obviously much loved family, the Holtzberg, who were there, in Mumbai for the reason that so many Israelis are fascinated by India. They were a spot to go and reclaim their Jewish feelings in a strange land.
My niece, a sabra, a secularly brought up Jew, spent one year in India, and found the people to be so caring and yet, when Shabbat came, or any of the Holy Days or Festivals, she and her nonJewish English boyfriend sought out a place to be with Jews, and it was usually the Chabad. They were not trying to impose their depth of Judaism on those who came, but to make them feel welcome and at home. When she returned to Israel, she told her family that although her belief system had not changed, she felt more Jewish with these wonderful, self-sacrificing people that she did at home.
As a Reform Jew, I feel devastated that such a dreadful thing could have happened to these people, and they will be in my prayers.

(42)
Dr. Steve Weintraub,
November 30, 2008 9:50 AM

May Hashem bring the goodness and light that the Holzberg's represented above all the hate and darkness that these villains represent.

We must always look for the goodness and light that comes from the darkness.Sandra Samuel is just one but I am sure there are many others whose goodness rose above this hate...my prayeers and thoughts are with the families of all who lost loved ones...may they all find peace...Amen!!

(41)
Yitzchak,
November 30, 2008 9:49 AM

NO WORDS.

There are no words that can express the sorrow that I feel with you.
Hamakom Yenachem Eschem.............

(40)
Stephanie,
November 30, 2008 9:46 AM

My condolences

My condolences go out to the family. Hopefully you can find comfort in knowing that they are with Hashem now. Thank you Rabbi Dr. Daniel P. Aldrich for writing this article, which provided us some insight into the beautiful things this couple accomplished.

(39)
Chaim,
November 30, 2008 9:45 AM

My heart weeps for the families and friends of the murdered souls

What is it in the nature of mankind that allows such atrocities to happen? On the one side, the Holtzbergs and the other Jews in the Chabad House who exemplified love and kindness, and at the opposite end the murderers in Mumbai consumed with hatred and insanity. The wanton slaughter of people they did not know, but the specific murders at the Chabad House.
What statement were they trying to make? Was it political, religious fanaticism, or just the pure evil that they had been taught from childhood.
My sincere condolences to the families of all the murdered souls in this atrocity. May G-D grant them peace and strength in their mourning.
Words fail me in expressing my grief.
May the perpetraters who engineered this horror be discovered, and justice be served.

(38)
Stanley M,
November 30, 2008 9:39 AM

May the Almighty comfort you

There have been many atrocities in the Jewish world but this was barbaric and cruel the cold blooded murder of Rabbi Gavriel and Rivkah Holtzberg and their guests will be something that we will never forget nor should we. But the miraculous escape of baby Moishe and his nanny shows that the Almighty works in mysterous ways and although he has been orphaned I am sure that he was left for a special reason and in future years could be one of the leading lights of the Chabad - Lubavitch movement - May the Almight comfort the mourners amongst all other mourners in Zion and Jerusalem

(37)
philip a maria,
November 30, 2008 9:33 AM

my deepest condolences

so sorry for baby Moshe and its
parents,and the whole world,what a tragedy may g-d give us strengh to continue to repair the world.

(36)
FAL,
November 30, 2008 9:31 AM

Ms. Samuel

This entire despicable atrocity has sickened and brought heartache to many. I truly hope, when things quiet down to some extent that Ms. Samuel is recognized in person for her wonderous act. First of all, to find a person who had the presence of mind during such horror to think of the helpless child. AND even more so, to think of taking the time to bring the child out and not simply run and save her own life. She is a blessing on this earth and i do hope that people recognize her for her efforts.

(35)
Anonymous,
November 30, 2008 9:31 AM

extend my condolence to the Holtzberg family.I really pity them so with the other four Jewish.Whoever did this, hope they cannot sleep with their conscience and should pay back!

(34)
Helen,
November 30, 2008 9:27 AM

May Hashem bless the rabbiner couple

In deep sorrow I feel the importance to
pray for the murdered Chabad couple.
May Hashem bless their souls with an eternal peace and love.

(33)
Sara Ben-Zakai,
November 30, 2008 9:21 AM

May you be comforted among the mourners of Zion & Yerusalayim

The deaths of Gavriel & Rivka (Z"L)and all the other tragic deaths in Mumbai, will be mourned throughout the Jewish communities all over the world. I know I am speaking in lieu of the Toronto Jewish Community. We will be holding a memorial service this afternoon in their memories.
May G-d give you strength.
Sara

(32)
Yosef,
November 30, 2008 9:19 AM

Heroes are few !

Shalom !
In a world so filled with violence and hatred , true warriors for peace are few. I feel that the world grew a little colder with their passing. But, at the same time, I feel encouraged that there are still some people willing to make a difference. The flame of Torah burns brighter because of them. -Yosef

(31)
Anonymous,
November 30, 2008 9:19 AM

response to terror

I am a chabad shlucha and try hard to implement love of every jew no matter who they are.
Lets try in the religious jewish world to work much harder to love and unite
mashiach now!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!

(30)
R BenYacov,
November 30, 2008 9:12 AM

War on Terror

Vengence is the lords... The front line in the war on terror is not in India. It is not where Chabad missions exist or where business interests are. The front line is in Islam. I respectfully request that Chabad reconsider where these missions are established. The U.S. and Israel are my only suggestions.
My condolences to the family and friends of all those who lost their lives.

(29)
Elissa Schiff,
November 30, 2008 9:12 AM

To the Parents of Rebbetzan Rivkah and to Moshe, Your beautiful daughter and mother Rivkah shines forever as a perfect Pearl in a most imperfect world. As a mother, I can only offer you my personal sense of sorrow and consolation. But as a woman united to the millions of other Jewish souls around our entire globe, please know that Rabbi Gavriel and Rivkah are remembered in our prayers now and evermore - we are connected to them. To both sets of Parents, truly, your consolation will be with all the mourners of Tsion v' Yerushalim - millions and millions the world over.

(28)
Zissi,
November 30, 2008 9:10 AM

May G-d console the families and avenge their blood

Rabbi and Mrs. Holzberg died for G-d. May He comfort the families and avenge their holy names and blood. My condolences to the Holzberg and Rosenberg families in this difficult time and to all those who lost loved ones.

(27)
sarah bat zvi,
November 30, 2008 9:10 AM

Thank you for your words of encouragement.

How true! at such a time, there are no words of comfort, but in the continuation of building and supporting others, as the Holtzbergs have done, May Hashem revenge their blood, and may we find comfort and solace.

(26)
Ruth Housman,
November 30, 2008 9:06 AM

such deep sadness

I read these stories in the Boston Globe yesterday, being a little behind these shocking events. I am so mindful of the beauty of these lives, taken so suddenly and in such an inhumane, terrifying manner. I weep for this little boy and his sibling who survived in Israel, being too sick to be with her parents.
I found it terrifying to learn there is a movie that came out about the same time, that is somehow about Mumbai, about terrifying events Now I haven't seen this movie, but it frightened me to hear this. And yet... and yet...
I do not agree that the knee jerk reaction to such terrorism is wipe out Islam. I do not believe that we conquer terror with terror. I am so weary of all those innocents, those children caught in the cross-fire of hate. If this were the answer, after all these years of terror, inhumanity, genocide, well, maybe then we'd have the answer for we do fight back with weapons that do destroy, more than those responsible, the innocent too.
The answer is somehow in how we teach our children to love, around the Globe and how we teach them a different story. Because surely we are impelled by those stories we hear and what we experience of love, hate and cruelty, from those who have gone before us.
Seeds of Peace is an organization which is doing the right thing. People like John Rassias, who promote cross cultural understanding around the world are doing the right thing. They are US.
We are more connected to each other than we ever thought possible.
As to the larger, more cosmic dimensions of this sorrowful, terrible onslaught, I am saying God is about LOVE and so there is, must be, "another side", and I know that language itself contains deep answers to the dilemma that is the deepest of possible questions: how does God permit this? what is God's role in all of this? Because surely we say, God's mercy in saving those children seems to be part of a deeper, more profound, story.
Yes, condolences and love, and deep sorrow for these terrible days.

(25)
Evelyn Demanuele,
November 30, 2008 9:03 AM

Condolences

My condolences to the families of the victims! May Hashem comfort you in this time of grief!!

(24)
Herbert J. Michelson,
November 30, 2008 9:01 AM

"Goodness and Kindness."

Hello,
If you received this from me please read the entire email including the article because it is a kind of "confessional." You define "confessional" for yourself.
I am sending this story and article from AISH.com to friends and relatives both Jewish and non Jewish since it is my belief that the message that is contained in the Lubavicher message applies to all. Certainly, the attack on the Nariman House was a great tragedy in terms of the lives that were lost as was the case in the wholesale massacre in India but the response of the Hasidic community is very impressive in the context of all of this barbaric human behavior. But first, I want to tell a little story that will place my feelings about the Lubavitcher Hasidim (Chabad House) in a clearer perspective.
I have known, respected, and cared for Rabbi Chaim Adelman and his Rebbetzin Yochevid for many years. Since I was and remain a "Secular" Jew my feelings about Chabad House must be explained a little.
A number of years ago, after I made the acquaintance with Rabbi Adelman I was present at a Shabbat service. To my great consternation Rabbi C. invited me to make Aliya. Rather than offend I went to the Bima and when there I anxiously announced (or protested, I'm not certain even now) that I am a "Secular Jew." He said: "You are a Jew, that's all that counts." Still trying to avoid the inevitable reading from the Torah I said:
"But I forgot my Hebrew many years ago let alone Torah Hebrew!" He smiled and moved aside part of the cloth that covered the Bima and there, transliterated into English in large, unmistakable letters was the Blessing I was invited to recite. Of course I did it. And I survived, no one threw ripe tomatoes or eggs!
The Point of this is what Rabbi Adelman said: "The only thing that counts is that you are a Jew." That has stayed with me for a great many years along with the fundamental idea of the Lubavitcher Hasidic community which very simply is" (Do) Goodness and Kindness" all of the time. Although the Lubavitcher Hasidim believe that this will "bring the Mochiach sooner" I might or might not debate, but that is their belief and I won't argue that. I can heartily agree with the suggestion: "Do Goodness and Kindness" each day and I can't imagine how this could not lead to a better world,--to better Human interactions."
Finally, I must add that my much closer and much more frequent contact with Chabad House in the past provided me with a level and quality of "Yiddiskheit" that only those who experienced it in the past and then lost it, can understand. So please read the article that follows.It is a tribute to the murdered Rabbis and the Rebbetzin but it is more, it is a tribute to the mission of Chabad: "Goodness and Kindness."
Be Peaceful and "Carry a big stick,"
Herb

(23)
Daniel,
November 30, 2008 9:00 AM

Still targets

A wake-up call that as Jews we are still targeted and must work hard to rid the earth of those who want to destroy us. Our largest threat is Islam. It must be stopped dead in its hateful tracks.

(22)
Anonymous,
November 30, 2008 8:58 AM

the unforgivable crimes in india

words of condolences have very little meaning at a time like this for the families of people killed in the chabad, but admiration for the young people who gave up all to make a Jewish home for our children will never die! G-D bless their families!!

(21)
Anonymous,
November 30, 2008 8:52 AM

On my trip to India I had the pleaure of meeting Holtzberg's & attened Shabbath services. They made me feel at home.

(20)
Rivka,
November 30, 2008 8:50 AM

Hashem yirachaim

Hamakom Y'nachaim Eschem B'soch Shaar Availa Tzion V'yerushalayim. The pain of this tragedy can eat your heart from the inside. The thought of what k'lal yisrael has lost is just unbearable... but as with everything the lessons are sent from above for each of us to grow from and through.
My baby has been keeping my family up all night for a week straight with teething... as I held her last night wishing I could sleep I saw the picture of little Moshe in his blood stained pants being saved by Sandra and suddenly my whole world flipped upside down and I started crying and thanking Hashem over and over for the incredible gift of being able to hold and comfort my baby and watch my children grow!

(19)
Leah,
November 30, 2008 8:46 AM

B"H

Words escape me as my soul is riddled with pain. I felt an inner anxiety all of Thanksgiving day and did not know why until I came home to an email from one of the rabbi's I know and heard the horrifying state of affairs. I said psalms, I cried and as I laid my head down my mind began saying kaddish. I knew they were murdered. I spent the night online searching for any kind of updates. I could not sleep for two nights the first in hope and horror, the second in deep grief. I did not go to shul as I was unable to keep composure. A couple I have not even met and I could not feel more pain than if it was my family. Moshele is our beacon our miracle. What a name he has as Moshe Rebanu was found in the stream and also rescued. My own feelings aside, we need to see this as it is "there are many enemies against Hashem: terrorists, political figures, even public laws and policies" We must fight to preserve light and love of Hashem in a world determined to destroy it. Perhaps we can become even more righteous and our personal best so that their deaths will not have been in vain. Our sages tell us that there is meaning in every blade of grass. We must find meaning and do everything that we can to bring light and goodness into the world. Thanks for letting me share my rattled thoughts.

(18)
Allan,
November 30, 2008 8:44 AM

What a terrible tragedy and loss for all Jewish people everywhere. As a non relgious Jew I have great respect for the entire Chabad movement and their constant reaching out and acceptance of all Jews at any level of observance. I agree with Rabbi Aldrich that we each can and must do something to honor those that have made the ulimate sacrifice for all of us. If nothing else we should give something to a Jewish based charity ...such as any that helps feed the needy etc.. G-D bles the memory of those that were murdered may their families know no more sorrow.

(17)
Anonymous,
November 30, 2008 8:32 AM

they only make us stronger

All these lunatics target the Jews to attempt to destroy our people and our faith. They don't realize that all they achieve is the opposite: we become stronger with every blow!

i still believe that there is some good i can do- in their memory- chabad in ssn diego the carlbachs were always loving giving and kind- i never let them know of my alyiah or thanked them. this is my personal thanks to all chabad for the giving. i was a stranger and you treated me with sensitivity, bless their memory -

(14)
Edith Schwartz,
November 30, 2008 8:09 AM

Love and Cocern amidst tragedy

As a Christian, I and many others, am appalled at the tragedy that has occured at Mumbai. I join in prayers and love w/all concerned.

(13)
Anonymous,
November 30, 2008 8:04 AM

I'm so sorry

It's so hard to understand.Their worst crime was to spread Judaism.God bless Sandra Samuel for her heroism,God bless Moshe.God bless all who work and pray in the service of humanity.We don't understand these evils,but to bring us closer to Hashem.

(12)
Scott klein,
November 30, 2008 8:01 AM

I am so sorry. Your loved ones at the Chabad House of Mumbai sanctified the Name of God and are true heroes of the Jewish people. I cannot stop thinking about them. They have inspired me to take nothing for granted. I have given my children a lot more hugs and kisses today.

(11)
Jehudit, Vienna, Austria,
November 30, 2008 8:00 AM

Baruch Dayan Emet! I´m shocked by this tragedy. May the families and friends of the victims be comforted among the mourners of Zion and may Mashiach come soon! Let us continue saying tehillim and feel united as one caring and loving people! Thank you to the great deeds of Chabad - one always finds a place everywhere in this world like home! (I enjoyed being hosted in the Chabad House in Prague several years ago)!

(10)
brigitte,
November 30, 2008 8:00 AM

there is no words

i am so sorry and even that dont cut it
I am a mother and jew,and i give my deepest condolences to the family and the chabad friends
be strong and continue with faith

(9)
zipporah,
November 30, 2008 7:57 AM

I Have A Very Special Gift For Baby Moshe

Shalom
I don''t have much to say other than may the beautiful Souls who were taken before their time be cradled in the hands of God and all those left behind be protected by The Light of God.
Please email me with an address where I may send Baby Moshe a very special personalized gift that I request His Grandparents keep for him.
With Love
Zipporah

(8)
Anonymous,
November 30, 2008 7:52 AM

Continue to Build

So many of us watched and waited, prayed, felt uneasy and totally unable to control what was happening in Mumbai. After the terrible news, we were heartbroken. I experienced so many feelings of guilt, personal responsibility for the tragedy, sadness and depression. It really felt like an attack on all of us. The author, I think, is right, in that you can't lose hope because you cannot know what Hashem has in store for you. So, in whatever little way you are growing, whether by giving charity, creating closer bonds with Jews (or non-Jews), studying your rich history and learning about its beauty and value...it does mean something. It's not for nothing. The events in Mumbai have taught me that I am truly lucky to be alive, and it is MY responsibility to make the most of my lot in life, and to LOOK FOR all the gifts and blessings that I do have (not to despair over what I don't have)...It's such a difficult lesson to stomach when you know that beautiful Jewish neshamas had to perish in order to teach this lesson, but I just wanted to promise the family and friends of the victims that it is NOT a lesson that will be forgotten. Every person that perished - they are directly touching our hearts, awakening our senses and inspiring us not to give up but to continue to build. It is the most incredibly profound lesson I have ever learned and I am eternally grateful for these angels. To the families and friends of the Holtzbergs and all other victims: May you be comforted among the mourners of Zion.

(7)
EME,
November 30, 2008 7:52 AM

MY HEART FELT CONDOLENCES

i never had the honore of knowing the tzadikim who have lost their lives in this brutal act of terror, but i knew of them from freinds who had traveled to india and spent the holidays with them. I feel a deep sence of lose and grief. I send my prayers and condolences to their dear families.

(6)
Esther Asna,
November 30, 2008 7:51 AM

may their memory be for a blessing

We have to keep up the good work, all of us together. HaMakom Yenachem Etchem betoch shaar Avelei Tzion veYerushalayim.

(5)
inga,
November 30, 2008 7:36 AM

with love...

as a mother, as a daughter, as a baalat teshuva with ties to chabad, and as a jew, i send my warmth, my prayer for strength and my confidence in your familys' continuence and eventual redemption, with much love.

(4)
Minski Annie,
November 30, 2008 7:36 AM

feel so sorry....

(3)
Rena,
November 30, 2008 7:06 AM

Hamakom Yenachem Eschem

I have no words in response to such a tragedy and no comprehension of the evil disuised as humans. May your families be comforted among the mourners of Zion, and may you merit to be reunited with your loved ones through the coming of Mashiach very soon. May we all merit to witness the days when peace both spiritual and physical will reign in this world and we will be able to recognize and serve Hashem properly.

(2)
Heather,
November 30, 2008 5:19 AM

Jewish Unity

I felt united with the world Jewish community in my prayers to preserve such meaningful lives and now I feel united in good deeds to preserve their memory.
My condolences to the families of those who perished in the Chabad House of Mumbai.

(1)
Sharon,
November 30, 2008 4:09 AM

kiddush Hashem

The Holtzbergs died sanctifying G-d's name just as they lived. They were very holy people who inspire us all, even those like me who never knew them. I pray that their families are comforted among the mourners of Zion.

I just got married and have an important question: Can we eat rice on Passover? My wife grew up eating it, and I did not. Is this just a matter of family tradition?

The Aish Rabbi Replies:

The Torah instructs a Jew not to eat (or even possess) chametz all seven days of Passover (Exodus 13:3). "Chametz" is defined as any of the five grains (wheat, spelt, barley, oats, and rye) that came into contact with water for more than 18 minutes. Chametz is a serious Torah prohibition, and for that reason we take extra protective measures on Passover to prevent any mistakes.

Hence the category of food called "kitniyot" (sometimes referred to generically as "legumes"). This includes rice, corn, soy beans, string beans, peas, lentils, peanuts, mustard, sesame seeds and poppy seeds. Even though kitniyot cannot technically become chametz, Ashkenazi Jews do not eat them on Passover. Why?

Products of kitniyot often appear like chametz products. For example, it can be hard to distinguish between rice flour (kitniyot) and wheat flour (chametz). Also, chametz grains may become inadvertently mixed together with kitniyot. Therefore, to prevent confusion, all kitniyot were prohibited.

In Jewish law, there is one important distinction between chametz and kitniyot. During Passover, it is forbidden to even have chametz in one's possession (hence the custom of "selling chametz"). Whereas it is permitted to own kitniyot during Passover and even to use it - not for eating - but for things like baby powder which contains cornstarch. Similarly, someone who is sick is allowed to take medicine containing kitniyot.

What about derivatives of kitniyot - e.g. corn oil, peanut oil, etc? This is a difference of opinion. Many will use kitniyot-based oils on Passover, while others are strict and only use olive or walnut oil.

Finally, there is one product called "quinoa" (pronounced "ken-wah" or "kin-o-ah") that is permitted on Passover even for Ashkenazim. Although it resembles a grain, it is technically a grass, and was never included in the prohibition against kitniyot. It is prepared like rice and has a very high protein content. (It's excellent in "cholent" stew!) In the United States and elsewhere, mainstream kosher supervision agencies certify it "Kosher for Passover" -- look for the label.

Interestingly, the Sefardi Jewish community does not have a prohibition against kitniyot. This creates the strange situation, for example, where one family could be eating rice on Passover - when their neighbors will not. So am I going to guess here that you are Ashkenazi and your wife is Sefardi. Am I right?

Yahrtzeit of Rabbi Moses ben Nachman (1194-1270), known as Nachmanides, and by the acronym of his name, Ramban. Born in Spain, he was a physician by trade, but was best-known for authoring brilliant commentaries on the Bible, Talmud, and philosophy. In 1263, King James of Spain authorized a disputation (religious debate) between Nachmanides and a Jewish convert to Christianity, Pablo Christiani. Nachmanides reluctantly agreed to take part, only after being assured by the king that he would have full freedom of expression. Nachmanides won the debate, which earned the king's respect and a prize of 300 gold coins. But this incensed the Church: Nachmanides was charged with blasphemy and he was forced to flee Spain. So at age 72, Nachmanides moved to Jerusalem. He was struck by the desolation in the Holy City -- there were so few Jews that he could not even find a minyan to pray. Nachmanides immediately set about rebuilding the Jewish community. The Ramban Synagogue stands today in Jerusalem's Old City, a living testimony to his efforts.

It's easy to be intimidated by mean people. See through their mask. Underneath is an insecure and unhappy person. They are alienated from others because they are alienated from themselves.

Have compassion for them. Not pity, not condemning, not fear, but compassion. Feel for their suffering. Identify with their core humanity. You might be able to influence them for the good. You might not. Either way your compassion frees you from their destructiveness. And if you would like to help them change, compassion gives you a chance to succeed.

It is the nature of a person to be influenced by his fellows and comrades (Rambam, Hil. De'os 6:1).

We can never escape the influence of our environment. Our life-style impacts upon us and, as if by osmosis, penetrates our skin and becomes part of us.

Our environment today is thoroughly computerized. Computer intelligence is no longer a science-fiction fantasy, but an everyday occurrence. Some computers can even carry out complete interviews. The computer asks questions, receives answers, interprets these answers, and uses its newly acquired information to ask new questions.

Still, while computers may be able to think, they cannot feel. The uniqueness of human beings is therefore no longer in their intellect, but in their emotions.

We must be extremely careful not to allow ourselves to become human computers that are devoid of feelings. Our culture is in danger of losing this essential aspect of humanity, remaining only with intellect. Because we communicate so much with unfeeling computers, we are in danger of becoming disconnected from our own feelings and oblivious to the feelings of others.

As we check in at our jobs, and the computer on our desk greets us with, "Good morning, Mr. Smith. Today is Wednesday, and here is the agenda for today," let us remember that this machine may indeed be brilliant, but it cannot laugh or cry. It cannot be happy if we succeed, or sad if we fail.

Today I shall...

try to remain a human being in every way - by keeping in touch with my own feelings and being sensitive to the feelings of others.

With stories and insights,
Rabbi Twerski's new book Twerski on Machzor makes Rosh Hashanah prayers more meaningful. Click here to order...