Violence toward Women and Our Immigration Laws: Time to Make Noise

The radio is full of stories of women made refugees by domestic violence. Though there are laws in place to protect spouses and children who suffered abuse at the hands of family, immigration enforcement systems have made that relief moot for many women.

In 2002, the Homeland Security Act established the new Department of Homeland Security and with it, three new agencies: Citizenship and Immigration Services (CIS), Customs and Border Protection (CBP), and Immigration and Customs Enforcement (ICE). These three agencies have, for the past 17 years, administered current immigration law enforcement. Revisiting these agencies in the context of the changes in this country since then show a need for change.

The study authors, Catalina Amuedo-Dorantes and Esther Arenas-Arroyo, find that the reduction in self-petitioning is driven by fear that the self-petitioners may be deported themselves or have their existing status jeopardized in this new era of increased immigration law enforcement. In effect, victims of domestic violence are fearful of speaking up or seeking relief from their abusers; they are condemned to endure their abuse for fear of deportation or detention under increased immigration enforcement activities in the US.

Amuedo-Dorantes and Arenas-Arroyo were aware that a reduction in the overall rate of domestic abuse might account for their data, so they took care to examine this aspect of their data and overall domestic abuse data. Even under this scrutiny, their premise held up. They were able to connect the reduction in applications for legal permanent status to fear of deportation or detention, and not to a change in the women’s domestic abuse situations. According to the authors, “Changes in official policy reducing the protection from deportation for individuals facing domestic violence, announced in June 2018, can only serve to worsen these outcomes.”

There are so many urgent needs for comprehensive immigration reform: economic needs, security needs, and humanitarian needs. When women tolerate domestic abuse for fear of reprisal at the hands of government agencies when safe options are available, the time for reform is past due. Is anyone paying attention?—Carole Levine

About The Author

Carole Levine is a principal consultant at Levine Partners, providing consulting services to nonprofit organizations. She has held senior management positions in national nonprofits: The National PTA (Deputy Executive Director); Communities in Schools (Vice President of Expansion and Technical Assistance); The Family Resource Coalition (Director of Technical Assistance); and National Lekotek Center (Director of Development). Carole holds a BA in education and political science from Washington University, and an M.Ed. in Early Childhood Leadership and Advocacy from National Louis University. Carole has served on the boards of numerous organizations, holding national positions on the board of National Council of Jewish Women and on the International Council of Jewish Women. She is currently the Chair of Courts Matter Illinois, serves on the Steering Committee of Chicago Women Take Action and is the co-chair of BenchMark: NCJW’s Judicial Nominations Campaign. Carole is passionate about nonprofit, purposeful work, justice for all and her family (which includes 5 amazing grandchildren!).