You're speaking as a spectator. You or I have no idea what was said behind closed doors. Colangelo isn't a dimwit, the guy has two executive of the year awards, has been a GM in the league for over a decade and has made many block buster trades. I can rhyme out reasons why Bosh should have been moved before the deadline all night long now in hindsight but it's not going to get us anywhere and on top of the we don't have a clue because we're not privy to any REAL information, just rumors, hearsay and speculation.

i dont need to be an insider to know that bosh's contract was about to end.

i dont need to be an insider to know that in the summer of 2010, almost every team in the league was going to make an offer for bosh ?

i dont need to be an insider to know that bosh wanted media attention (primarily US / ESPN media attention)

i dont need to be an insider to know that bosh is not worth max money.

i dont need to be an insider to know that bosh is not a franchise player.

i dont need to be an insider to know that even if bosh swore on his mom's grave to BC that he would re-sign with toronto. unless he puts his signature on the extension, im not going to risk the entire franchise's future based on chris bosh's word, or anything chris bosh has promised.

Chandler was good, but probably would have bolted at the end of the year. Gallinari is solid, but nowhere in Melo's league. Felton was having a fantastic season, but the Knicks got a good PG to lead them in Billups. Sure he's not the same guy as the Detroit days, but he can still bring it in the playoffs. Mozgov was just that - a project. In the end, New York got the man they wanted and paid a price, but I don't think it'll be one that bites them in the butt. They got a star in his prime.

Chandler was good, but probably would have bolted at the end of the year. Gallinari is solid, but nowhere in Melo's league. Felton was having a fantastic season, but the Knicks got a good PG to lead them in Billups. Sure he's not the same guy as the Detroit days, but he can still bring it in the playoffs. Mozgov was just that - a project. In the end, New York got the man they wanted and paid a price, but I don't think it'll be one that bites them in the butt. They got a star in his prime.

Yeah, but offense won't win you championships, and I really don't see Amare and Melo working well together. Sure they'll win maybe even 50 games or more, just like the Suns, but a championship? What makes the combo of Melo and Amare better than the Boston and Miami trio? They aren't even as good as Chicago, and they have no more flexibility. They have no PG for the future, no center or shooting guard...

Yeah, but offense won't win you championships, and I really don't see Amare and Melo working well together. Sure they'll win maybe even 50 games or more, just like the Suns, but a championship? What makes the combo of Melo and Amare better than the Boston and Miami trio? They aren't even as good as Chicago, and they have no more flexibility. They have no PG for the future, no center or shooting guard...

So Felton was their PG of the future? A guy who was considered a stopgap until after next season? Is Mozgov that big of a loss? As for a shooting guard, they have Fields, who has been playing great so far this season. They also have Corey Brewer. In 2-3 years when KG is gone, Allen is gone, the C's are not gonna look as hot.
People asked the same questions regarding Lebron, Wade and Bosh - if they could work together and it did. I can't see this union not working out.

Yeah, but offense won't win you championships, and I really don't see Amare and Melo working well together. Sure they'll win maybe even 50 games or more, just like the Suns, but a championship? What makes the combo of Melo and Amare better than the Boston and Miami trio? They aren't even as good as Chicago, and they have no more flexibility. They have no PG for the future, no center or shooting guard...

Yeah. Neither Melo or Amare are good defenders. They might beat a few teams in the playoffs with scoring punch but defensively weak teams always get exposed. We all know that first hand. LOL

D'Antoni isn't a champion level coach unless he suddenly figures out how to get players to play defense effectively.

So Felton was their PG of the future? A guy who was considered a stopgap until after next season? Is Mozgov that big of a loss? As for a shooting guard, they have Fields, who has been playing great so far this season. They also have Corey Brewer. In 2-3 years when KG is gone, Allen is gone, the C's are not gonna look as hot.
People asked the same questions regarding Lebron, Wade and Bosh - if they could work together and it did. I can't see this union not working out.

No, but he was signed for 2 years and was in his prime, and after his two years were done, the Knicks were 'planning' on getting CP3, which is now impossible. And Mozgov is actually a really good rebounder, and post player and was just recently becoming more confident. I still think the Knicks were better before the trade.

No, but he was signed for 2 years and was in his prime, and after his two years were done, the Knicks were 'planning' on getting CP3, which is now impossible. And Mozgov is actually a really good rebounder, and post player and was just recently becoming more confident. I still think the Knicks were better before the trade.

How is them getting CP3 impossible? We won't know that until after the dust clears on the new CBA. Would it be tough for them to get him? Yes. Impossible? No.

The Knicks have a way of finding talent through the draft, so I think they'll be okay in terms of getting a new 5 (if they don't move Amar'e there anyways). But I don't think the Knicks could live with themselves if the reason why they didn't pull the trigger on Carmelo Anthony was Timofey Mozgov.

How is them getting CP3 impossible? We won't know that until after the dust clears on the new CBA. Would it be tough for them to get him? Yes. Impossible? No.

The Knicks have a way of finding talent through the draft, so I think they'll be okay in terms of getting a new 5 (if they don't move Amar'e there anyways). But I don't think the Knicks could live with themselves if the reason why they didn't pull the trigger on Carmelo Anthony was Timofey Mozgov.

They don't have the cap space to sign Paul...

And they traded away most of their picks, unless you are talking about in like a few years time, when Melo and Amare will be nearing their 30s...

And they traded away most of their picks, unless you are talking about in like a few years time, when Melo and Amare will be nearing their 30s...

New York's payroll will be a bit over 45 million for next season, so unless it's a hard cap set at 50 million (which I don't think it'll be), there will be money to pay for Paul - and Paul's a FA the season after next, not after this one.

New York's payroll will be a bit over 45 million for next season, so unless it's a hard cap set at 50 million (which I don't think it'll be), there will be money to pay for Paul - and Paul's a FA the season after next, not after this one.

Are you sure it's that low? Melo's salary is at least $15M, Amare's is $20M, is Billups an expiring? Plus, Paul will probably want a max contract, or near max. And the Knicks would have to end up just having 3 good players, and the rest scrubs.

Are you sure it's that low? Melo's salary is at least $15M, Amare's is $20M, is Billups an expiring? Plus, Paul will probably want a max contract, or near max. And the Knicks would have to end up just having 3 good players, and the rest scrubs.

Billups is pretty much an expiring (Team option for next season at a bit over 14 mil) - depends on what the Knicks do for next season, they might pick that option knowing D-Will and Paul are FA's after next season. As for the 3 good players and the rest scrubs, Miami makes it work, so why wouldn't New York?

Billups is pretty much an expiring (Team option for next season at a bit over 14 mil) - depends on what the Knicks do for next season, they might pick that option knowing D-Will and Paul are FA's after next season. As for the 3 good players and the rest scrubs, Miami makes it work, so why wouldn't New York?

Well Miami has Wade, LeBron and Bosh. Wade and LeBron are clutch shooters, athletic, can both play point, can both rebound, defend, are both very long etc... And Bosh is an all-star PF. Amare and Melo are no where near as good as LeBron and Bosh. Paul is a great PG, but Wade can do a lot more whilst on the floor. In other words, Miami's big three plays defense.