Last night on the premiere of Dancing with the Stars, Bill Nye danced the cha-cha with his partner Tyne to Oingo Boingo’s 1985 hit “Weird Science”. Despite overwhelming approval from the crowd, they only scored 14 out of 30.

Many have tried to decipher the meaning of this profoundly confounding quote by retired pro-baseball player Oscar Gamble, with the most plausible interpretation being “they incorrectly believe that this is an atypical state of affairs.”