The Official Site of theNew York Giants Message Boards

If this is your first visit, be sure to
check out the FAQ by clicking the
link above. You may have to register
before you can post: click the register link above to proceed. To start viewing messages,
select the forum that you want to visit from the selection below.

No one, absolutely no one paints Webb as a "golden boy." He's got s great attitude, physical tools you want in a QB, works hard, has some good college tape, etc. Why on Earth would it be bizarre fans to want him to be the next guy after Eli? I know I do. People discuss these things on a forum....

Leave a comment:

I agree these examples aren't comparable whatsoever, and I hate when people do it, but Pat Shurmur didn't really have a chance in Cleveland either...ownership changed after his 2nd year and there was no way he was going to be kept. Still agree with you that as much as I like Shurmur, we did not bring...

Leave a comment:

Because RBs outside of round 1 didn't have more receiving production in college than Marshall Faulk. Or combine the best measurables of the combine into a 230 lb package. Or display the top notch character Barkley does...I can continue if you want....

Leave a comment:

This is such a tired and incorrect argument and doesn't take into consideration data that totally blows this up. For example: The average NFL career is 3 years as well, right in line with that specific position. Additionally, any player making their clubs opening day roster their rookie year has an...

Leave a comment:

I'm just comparing their skill sets. And the year the rams won the superbowl, Marshall Faulk set the record for all purpose yards in a single season by a running back. He rushed for 1,381 yards at 5.5 yds per carry and caught 87 balls for 1,048 yards. That type of receiving threat from RB has never...

Leave a comment:

You're very often pointing out coincidental things which are at their best, maybe correlative, but probably not. Also you're missing Marshall Faulk as a centerpiece. There also happened to be a lot of other good players on that offense, but without him, it doesn't work. There hasn't been a back like...

Leave a comment:

Also...I don't see the single RB theme applying here. It's a Marshall Faulk skillset. That hasn't been in this league since Tomlinson's prime. Tiki also fit this mold but wasn't the same build. There's a whole other dimension here. It's not the same as Elliot or Fournette or the other, later round ...

Leave a comment:

That's how I feel about him, without obviously seeing the same things you were able too. Every time I listened to an interview I liked him more and didn't want us to draft a QB. I hope he can translate to a live setting because I think it would be great if he were the next guy....

Leave a comment:

Yes, I think taking the consensus best player in the draft was a horrible mistake. Why would we want to have the closest thing to Marshall Faulk since Marshall Faulk in our offense that emphasizes RBs who can catch the ball? Dalvin Cook was not impressive at all last year before he got hurt in Shurmur's...