Friday, February 21, 2014

The counter-intuitive gold play

Gold has so far enjoyed a terrific start to
the New Year, most recently closing at its highest level late October
2013. It has even succeeded in closing
above its psychologically significant 200-day moving average for the first time
in over a year.

In summary, gold futures have risen over 12%
through Feb. 18, reversing its biggest annual drop in over three decades. It also hit a three-month high on
Tuesday. Holdings in ETFs backed by
bullion increased by 3.2 metric tons last week – the greatest amount since
December 2012 – after slumping 869.1 tons in 2013, when prices were down 28%.

Yet despite the impressive rally, gold
analysts remain bearish on the yellow metal’s prospects for 2014. An article
appearing in the Feb. 18 International
Business Times underscores just how negative many forecasters remain on the
metals’ interim trend.

According to the article by M. Rochan, “A
majority of all gold forecasters are sticking with their bearish forecasts for
2014 even after the precious metal logged its best start to a year since
1983.” The article quoted Robin Bhar,
head of metals research at Societe Generale in London, who said she sees the
recent gold rally as merely a “corrective move.” To her credit, Bhar was the most accurate
gold analyst tracked by Bloomberg over the past two years, yet she stated “we
would still want to be bearish about gold.”
Bhar predicts a fourt-quarter average gold price of $1,050.

Meanwhile Goldman Sachs chief commodities
analyst Jeffrey Currie believes that gold will “grind lower” as U.S. growth
improves, reaffirming a forecast for prices to hover at $1,050 by the end of
the year. The likelihood of weakening currencies
in emerging-market economies will increase the risk of further declines for
gold, “given the price-sensitive nature of jewelry demand in local currency
terms,” Goldman said in its report last week.

The bearish bets of most institutional
analysts who track gold seem to be based on the expectation of an improving
U.S. economy. What these analysts have
apparently failed to factor in is the possibility of a weaker U.S. dollar,
which would likely put upward pressure on gold and silver.

Could it be that gold is setting up for the
ultimate counter-intuitive play in 2014?
Already a majority of analysts have found themselves on the wrong side
of the gold trade at the start of the year.
Perhaps 2014 will be the year these same analysts – who mostly were on
the right side of the gold short trade in 2013 – will end up with egg on their
faces.

Another factor driving higher gold prices so
far this year, ironically, is China. I’m
not just speaking of China’s voracious demand for physical bullion. After all, China imported 1,158 tons of gold
through Hong Kong in 2013, more than double its 2012 total. But I’m also referring also to the growing
potential for a China credit crisis.
China’s stock market (below) is definitely reflecting major
vulnerabilities to the country’s business sector, if not outright internal
weakness.

To put into perspective how vulnerable to a
credit crisis China has become, consider the following analysis by the esteemed
economist Dr. Ed Yardeni: “When China joined the World Trade Organization during
December 2001, the country’s banks had $1.4 trillion in loans outstanding,
which was equivalent to 35% of US commercial bank loans. At the start of this
year, Chinese bank loans rose to a record $12 trillion, now equivalent to 162%
of their US counterparts! Those numbers don’t include the lending of the shadow
banking system.”

Yardeni points out that
China’s Producer Price Index (PPI) is down 1.6% year-over-year through
January.“It has been deflating since
March 2012. China’s CPI is still inflating at a moderate pace, with an increase
of 2.5% y/y through January,” he said.Yardeni’s conclusion is that “The combination of lots of debt and
mounting deflationary pressures increases the risks of a credit crisis in
China.”

If 2014 is the year that
China’s credit market melts down, as many respectable analysts expect, then
this could explain why gold has suddenly become the safe haven asset of choice
for many investors. The anticipation of
economic pain in the world’s number two economy is an easy answer for gold’s
latest rally since the metal benefits from uncertainty and economic
volatility.

Indeed, the combination of a
weak dollar and the potential for a weak credit market/economy in China is all
the fuel gold theoretically needs to continue confounding institutional
analysts in the months ahead.