The massacre that “saved thousands of lives” – a response

The brutal actions of Germany’s SS in a Czech mining village one day in 1942 have rightly entered the history books as an exemplar of collective punishment, enacted largely to invoke mass terror among the population of an occupied country.

In deliberate planned revenge for the earlier assassination of a senior German official, ten truck loads of personnel from the elite Nazi unit descended on Lidice and calmly executed every male over 16. The exact number given as killed varies between sources, but one standard text on the Third Reich puts the final tally at 199.

Some 184 village women were sent to Ravensbruck concentration camp, where 52 of them died. Those children deemed capable of being Germanised were sent away for adoption; 80 kids weren’t so lucky and perished in the gas chambers of Chelmno. Lidice itself was raised to the ground.

The massacre at Amritsar ordered by a British officer in 1919 – described by David Cameron on a visit to that Indian city earlier this week as ‘a deeply shameful event’ – must surely be considered an atrocity of similar design and intent, and certifiably more costly in terms of human life.

Yet not all sections of the political right see things quite in this light. Hence a remarkable article by Thatcherite historian Andrew Roberts in – where else? – the Daily Mail, which effectively portrays the event as a sadly misunderstood humanitarian masterstroke.

Roberts is happy to accept that Brigadier Reginald Dyer ordered his troops to open fire on a peaceful gathering, but doesn’t buy into the ‘wildly exaggerated’ Indian claim that 1,000 people did not emerge with their lives.

Yet even if the slaughter was limited to the 379, as suggested by the subsequent British-led official inquiry – and even he concedes that sum is several dozen too low – Amritsar nevertheless topped the bloodshed seen in Lidice.

Central to Roberts’ bid for Dyer’s exoneration is that a single day’s display of marvellous imperial resolve averted a full scale revolt in the Punjab, and thus ‘saved thousands of lives’. This is a curious piece of moral calculus, which skirts round the issue of Britain’s lack of entitlement to plunder India in the first place.

The millions of deaths that would have been averted without colonisation – for instance, the minimum of 1.5m who perished in the Bengal famine of 1943, to pluck just one example at random – are airbrushed out of the equation.

What’s more, Roberts insists, one must take into account that the locals in Amritsar were getting horribly uppity. Three days before the incident, mobs had rampaged through the streets, putting banks – and bankers – to the torch, and beating up elderly British spinsters, he stresses.

What he somehow doesn’t mention is that the unrest had been triggered by clashes with troops following the announcement that nationalist leader Gandhi had been arrested, which had left 20-30 Indians dead. That’s hardly an unimportant detail here.

But what is perhaps crucial is what Dyer understood himself to be doing, and it’s worth quoting the man himself to make the point:

I fired and continued to fire until the crowd dispersed, and I considered that that this is the least amount of firing that would produce the necessary moral and widespread effect it was my duty to produce … It was no longer a question of merely dispersing the crowd, but one of producing a sufficient moral effect, from the military point of view, not only on those who were present, but more specially throughout the Punjab.

In other words, the Amritsar Massacre was a deliberate endeavour to instil fear in the name of ‘sufficient moral effect’. Substitute ‘Protectorate of Bohemia’ for Punjab, and I suspect that the officer in charge at Lidice could have boasted much the same thing. Any attempt to relativise either crime is equally disgraceful.

One Comment

Heydrich was not just a ‘senior official’, he was Hitler’s chosen successor upon his death.
The Czechs did well under Heydrich’s occupation, trading ample food supplies for war armaments and production.

The Czech Government, in London exile, were more than put out by their Countrymen not fighting back like Warsaw and France.
In the pecking order of post war rebuild, the Czechs were way down the list.

To put this right, the exiled Government put out a secret mission launched from England to assasinate Heydrich.
The attack took place and the assassins were told fromthe start, they would not survive any capture and neither would their families.

They somehow met with the underground (breaking all orders not to do so) and were holed up in a church.
They allegedly committed suicide.

Post war, Leaders of the underground sought out senior Czech Generals and politicians demanding an explanation of why such an attack took place without their approval.
They wanted answers for an obvious slaughter of innocents (Lidice) surely to take place.

The Generals put a blank piece of paper on the desk of the underground Leaders and asked them to fill in all ‘resistance’ attacks made against the occupiers of ‘our Country’.

The meeting dispersed and the paper remained blank.

The assassins were betrayed by an ‘insider’ who was kept from scrutiny by Russian intelligence post war.

Search

Left Futures is...

The best that’s Left in Labour. Good writing. Sharp criticism. Open debate. Campaigning. Red or green, aligned or not, Left Futures seeks to refresh and activate your politics.

Subscribe!

On Facebook

By Gianluca Ferrara Almost nobody talks of the war in Yemen. It is a conflict that reveals how disgusting and dangerous our trading partners are in the Middle East. Amid international indifference, Yemen and its 28 million inhabitants are suffering from the consequences of Saudi Arabia’s criminal policies since March 2015. The Yemeni Houthi rebels, […]

Up to 4,000 workers at Amazon’s despatch centre at Piacenza in northern Italy will be striking for better pay and conditions on Black Friday. In addition, the workers organised by the unions Tertiary Ugl, Fisascat-Cisl, Filcams-Cgil, and Uiltucs-Uil decided on an overtime ban until 31 December, hitting Christmas shopping. Amazon’s strong growth justifies a more […]

“Jamaica” coalition talks collapsed on Sunday night after Christian Lindner (Fdp) said no to governing with the CDU and Greens, and Angela Merkel was forced to acknowledge that the margins for negotiation were depleted. For Lindner the biggest obstacle lay in defining the political line on European issues. Federico Ferraù caught up with Italian economist […]

Vittorio Agnoletto does not regret his native Milan lost out to Amsterdam in the bid to replace London as home of the European Medicines Agency. His concerns lie elsewhere The European Medicines Agency will move to Amsterdam, it has been decided by a draw. This has left a bitter taste in the mouth of Italians […]

About Left Futures

Meta

Left Futures

Left Futures is a new Labour Left network. If you want to get involved as a contributor, please contact James Elliott using the form on this page.
Header images: Wind farm [credit]. Balloons [credit] and crowd scene [credit].