This eyeliner has the worst packaging I have ever experienced! First, the brush is tiny! This sounds like a good thing because you'd think you could be really precise, but that's completely wrong. Since the brush is like a delicate feather, you have to apply a lot of pressure to get the product to transfer from the bitty brush to your eyelid. You have to smoosh the brush onto your eyelid, which makes it hard to control the thickness, and when you're done, the brush's bristles are all bent out of shape!

Second, the construction of the tube is awful. It feels heavy and luxe, and the tube is a nice, rich gold color, but the inside is poorly constructed. When you try to unscrew the cap, the gold part comes off, instead of unscrewing the cap. Also, there's a rubber part of the tube that also comes out all the time.

I developed sensitive eyes and lately any eyeliner or pencil. This time reviews were right-I discovered that brown eyeliner is better and more natural-love the color-the truth is that black eyeliner is too stark and not really for day time use. I am not expert at putting eyeliner on. There were no issues. Brush is very thin and line is created very nicely. It allows you to go back and put another small line, it's so easy, anybody can do this. There is only positive things I can say about this product. It does not irritate eyes, cleans out perfectly. no issues whatsoever.

This is a superb eyeliner! Makes a great, clean line, sets well, doesn't smudge - I love it! I have it both in the black and the brown. I use the black on the upper lid and the brown to dot between the lashes on the lower lid. Fabulous look! I get a thinner line than with the BB gel eyeliner, (which I love and smudge for a smokey eye). It is similar to the luxurious Guerlain eyeliner, but costs less, but the Guerlain comes in more color choices, of which the bronze is exquisite! I have gone through multiple tubes of the Hauschka eyeliner and have never had a clumping problem - perhaps those users were not closing it tightly and it was drying out?

I liked other products of Dr Hauschka's make up line and this product was even better! I must admit my friends all compliment my eye liner and its application and I have never been good at putting on eyeliner! It goes on smooth and the bristles are so thin that you can make a nice thin line- very classy/sharp looking. It does what an eye-liner says it's supposed to- accent the eyes- not drown them out. I thus purchased in brown and have had the same results- although the brown is dark and looks similar to black when applied.

This fairly expensive eyeliner is just awful! The bristles in the brush are uneven and they sharply stab the eyelid when applying the eyeliner. The liquid goes on unevenly and leaves weird clumps that are hard to remove. I would never buy this again