Tuesday, November 25, 2008

What does all this mean for the Valle del Sur? Part II

The New Mexico Senate is currently embroiled in a struggle over the leadership of that body. Sen. Tim Jennings, from Roswell, is challenged by a faction of Northerners that would elect Carlos Cisneros, from Santa Fe and Taos, as President Pro Tem. Evidently, the election of new liberal senators earlier this month has convinced some that power has shifted from the coalition of moderate Democrats and Republicans that elected Jennings, enough to warrant a challenge. The showdown will probably be over this coming Sunday.

I remember the Northern coalition of legislators that produced House Speaker Walter Martinez, from Grants, back in the 1970s. The coalition was called the "Mama Lucy Gang," a reference to a restaurant frequented by the major players in the faction. Walter lost his Speakership after conservative Democrats from Southern New Mexico, frustrated by the habit of the Northern liberals to ignore them and their bills, formed a coalition of 10 Democrats and 26 Republicans and placed Gene Samberson, from Lea County, in as Speaker. The rebels were known as the "cowboy coalition," and governed the House from 1979-1982 and then again in 1985-1986. At the time of the overthrow there were howls of protest that, horrors, some Democrats would actually vote with Republicans, but I also remember the very real frustration of most Southern Democrats in the House who suffered at the hands of Martinez simply because they were from the South.

The South Valley helped remedy this injustice in the form of Rep. Ralph Hartman, from Anthony. He and Rep. Bud Hettinga and Rep. Russell Autrey (also from Dona Ana County) did a lot of the legwork to put the cowboy coalition together. After the overthrow of Martinez, Southerners could once again, as if by magic, get their bills passed. A similar situation developed in the state senate a few years later.

Then, as now, the South Valley tended to be ignored by the state, or worse, insulted. In Hartman's case, Martinez literally gave him a broom closet for an office, an insult that bothered him, but not as much as Martinez's refusal to help him pass needed legislation for the South Valley. I was county chair of the Democratic Party when that coalition was formed in 1979. In spite of many appeals from people all over the state, I never once criticized Hartman or the others for breaking with the nortenos to control the House

The bottom line for a legislator is getting things done for your constituents, not satisfying some sort of perverted party loyalty by voting for people who may not support your agenda, but offer you perks instead. The late Ralph Hartman did a lot for the South Valley, and it took political courage for him to stand up to the nortenos who thought they could bully him.

Today, after more years of neglect, the South Valley needs all the help it can get from Santa Fe. The challenge to Sen. Jennings will have local repercussions whether it succeeds nor not. Let us hope our legislators will think about the good of the county, rather than their own marginal and possibly short-term advantages.

3 comments:

Anonymous
said...

Gov Denish should clean house Gov Richardson appointed people that have no skills to do the job they were hired for. I heard they hired a director whose role is to work with Mexico Border trade that can not even speak spanish?

Army Unit Assigned to Juarez

Links

Is it a conflict of interest for Cynthia Nava to be GISD Superintendent and State Senator at the same time?

The New Electoral Map

Click on Map for Larger View

Will President-elect Obama give Governor Richardson a job in his administration?

Senator John Arthur Smith and Speaker Ben Lujan

Mark Bralley, photographer

Comments Policy

Comments are important means of stimulating debate, learning other points of view, criticizing what is going on or being said, praising someone who deserves it, and keeping in touch with the community. While it doesn't always need to be polite or phrased nicely, a comment should contribute to a community discussion. It should not be seen as an opportunity to attack someone personally. This shuts down debate and splinters community.

All comments are approved before they are posted. Each will be evaluated on a case-by-case basis. These are some of the ground rules:

1. Anonymous Comments: For the moment I will allow comments to remain anonymous. Most of the time there is no valid reason for someone to wish to remain anonymous, and I would encourage people to sign their names. It seems cowardly for someone to sharply criticize a person without being willing to identify her/himself. But in some cases, there may be a valid reason for anonymity. If there are further efforts to orchestrate anonymous comments to further a political objective I will change this policy and require everyone to register before making a comment.

2. Personal Attacks: These are not permitted. It is fine to speak out against a public official or criticize me or someone else, but the emphasis should be on constructive criticism. Giving reasons why you think someone is wrong is fine, but calling people names is not. One objective in this blog is to encourage debate, and name-calling and personal attacks produce the opposite result.

3. Libel: I will not post libelous comments. While public figures do not enjoy quite the same protection against libel as the rest of us, they have rights. If you do not know what libel is, I would refer you to the Wikipedia Encyclopedia (google it in), where you can find a great, readable article about it.

4. Campaigning: This is not a forum for candidates to use as campaign vehicles. Candidates are welcome and even encouraged to participate in the discussion, as well as people favoring causes, but they should stick to the issues.

5. Be factual: If I see serious factual errors in your comments I will not post them. If you submit as fact a statement that cannot be verified, I will not post it. This is not a forum for spreading rumors.

6. Be Brief: I have posted some rather lengthy pieces and have edited others, and I will deal with this on a case-by-case basis. I don't have a word limit, but please be as brief as possible.

7. Grammar: Incoherent comments will not be posted.

8. Profanity: This is not allowed.

9. Retractions: Should a retraction be necessary I will evaluate whether to remove the posting entirely or explain the reason for the retraction at the beginning of the piece.

10. Privacy: This site does gather standard personal information about users in the course of recording statistics on the number of daily visitors to the site. That information includes IP addresses, internet service provider, type of operating system, and internet browser used, screen resolution and color depth, language, and the pages the user visited on this site. I take privacy seriously and will not share users' personal information with any third party, except as required by law.

11. Third Party Links: users of this blog agree that this site and its owner are not responsible for any damage, injury, or loss that results from interaction and transactions between the user and web sites the user visits by clicking on links to this site.

About Me

Dr. Jose Z. Garcia taught at New Mexico State for three decades before becoming Secretary of Higher Education, a post he occupied during the entire first term of Governor Susana Martinez. He specializes in Latin America, the U.S.-Mexico border, and New Mexico politics. He was chairman of the Democratic Party in Dona Ana County the early 1980s. Currently he is on sabbatical but will return to teaching in 2016.