The personal blog of Peter Lee a.k.a. "China Hand"... Life is a comedy to those who think, a tragedy to those who feel, and an open book to those who read. You are welcome to contact China Matters at the address chinamatters --a-- prlee.org or follow me on twitter @chinahand.

Friday, July 09, 2010

It's Official: America Has a China-Containment Policy

If China's satellites and spies were working properly, there would have been a flood of unsettling intelligence flowing into the Beijing headquarters of the Chinese navy last week. A new class of U.S. superweapon had suddenly surfaced nearby. It was an Ohio-class submarine...[which holds] up to 154 Tomahawk cruise missiles...capable of hitting anything within 1,000 miles with non-nuclear warheads.

...alarm bells would have sounded in Beijing on June 28 when the Tomahawk-laden 560-ft. U.S.S. Ohio popped up in the Philippines' Subic Bay. More alarms were likely sounded when the U.S.S. Michigan arrived in Pusan, South Korea, on the same day. And the Klaxons would have maxed out as the U.S.S. Florida surfaced, also on the same day, at the joint U.S.-British naval base on Diego Garcia, a flyspeck of an island in the Indian Ocean. In all, the Chinese military awoke to find as many as 462 new Tomahawks deployed by the U.S. in its neighborhood.

With all due respect to Mr. Thompson's skills in tracking and interpreting the movements of America's nuclear submarine fleet, I would imagine he may have needed a heads-up from sources in the U.S. government, especially in the matter of keeping a bead on the location of the Florida and defining its appearance at Diego Garcia as a message to China.

It seems that the Florida has, as "America's first forward-deployed guided missile sub from the Atlantic fleet" been calling at Diego Garcia and swapping crews for a couple years. Also, Diego Garcia ("flyspeck" a.ka. supersecret military base created by secretly leasing the island and deporting all its inhabitants) is closer to hot spots Somalia, Iran, and Afghanistan than it is to China.

Anyway. Message received.

The move forms part of a policy by the U.S. government to shift firepower from the Atlantic to the Pacific theater, which Washington sees as the military focus of the 21st century.
...

The submarines aren't the only new potential issue of concern for the Chinese. Two major military exercises involving the U.S. and its allies in the region are now under way. More than three dozen naval ships and subs began participating in the "Rim of the Pacific" war games off Hawaii on Wednesday. Some 20,000 personnel from 14 nations are involved in the biennial exercise, which includes missile drills and the sinking of three abandoned vessels playing the role of enemy ships. Nations joining the U.S. in what is billed as the world's largest-ever naval war game are Australia, Canada, Chile, Colombia, France, Indonesia, Japan, South Korea, Malaysia, the Netherlands, Peru, Singapore and Thailand. Closer to China, CARAT 2010 - for Cooperation Afloat Readiness and Training - just got under way off Singapore. The operation involves 17,000 personnel and 73 ships from the U.S., Singapore, Bangladesh, Brunei, Cambodia, Indonesia, Malaysia, the Philippines and Thailand.

...

China is absent from both exercises, and that's no oversight. Many nations in the eastern Pacific, including Australia, Japan, Indonesia, South Korea and Vietnam, have been encouraging the U.S. to push back against what they see as China's increasingly aggressive actions in the South China Sea. And the U.S. military remains concerned over China's growing missile force - now more than 1,000 - near the Taiwan Strait. The Tomahawks' arrival "is part of a larger effort to bolster our capabilities in the region," Glaser says. "It sends a signal that nobody should rule out our determination to be the balancer in the region that many countries there want us to be." No doubt Beijing got the signal.

If, after all that, anybody believes that the joint US-ROK exercises in the Yellow Sea are primarily a response to the Cheonan sinking or, for that matter, part of an effort to deter the apparently undeterrable North Koreans, well, I have in my possession a stately edifice spanning the swelling bosom of the East River to link the County of Kings to the Island of the Manhattoes, available for purchase exclusively by such trusting souls.

The South Koreans get it, and Chosun Ilbo weighed in with an uncharacteristically cautious editorial on July 6:

These developments are showing signs of creating a Cold War atmosphere where South Korea, the U.S. and Japan face off against China and North Korea.

The U.S.-South Korea alliance forms the cornerstone of the South's national security and diplomacy. But China is South Korea's largest trading partner, and it also has a huge influence on peace and reunification on the Korean Peninsula. The time has come for Seoul to factor into its diplomacy and security policies both China and its intensifying competition with the U.S.

The code word for "containment" in the Asian press, by the way, is "Cold War atmosphere".

The message that the Time article was meant to send was that the U.S. Navy are now devoted to defining, countering, and to some extent creating a Chinese threat in the Pacific in order to preserve the scale of its forces and protect its budget.

The Chinese government, given the concerted efforts by the Obama adminstration to rollback China's influence throughout the world diplomatically and economically as well as militarily, will undoubtedly draw more sweeping conclusions.

I would take issue with two statements in Williams' article.

First, especially but not exclusively on the issue of the Korean peninsula, the U.S. is there as an unbalancer, not a "balancer" as Bonnie Glaser put it.

The tilt away from the Six Party Talks structure including China to a strengthened ROK-USA security condominium is a signal that a Western response to instability on the peninsula, be it from "provocations" or the demise of Kim Jung Il, will not include China as an equal partner.

The U.S. media has largely ignored the vitriolic response in the Chinese press to America's military moves, but the Chinese clearly see that the pendulum has swung away from stability--with the U.S. presence precluding a rush to rearmament by Japan---to containment.

Containment, to China, implies that the U.S. will continue to fan fears of China's military ambitions to encourage the rise of India and the the creation of pro-American governments and policies throughout Asia and turn a blind eye or, even worse, extend an enabling hand to Asian states that develop adventurist ambitions in challenging China on the issue of the uninhabited but contested islands that dot the region.

I guess we'll find out if the Obama administration has a long-term plan sees an upside in a near-open breach of relations with China beyond giving the opportunity for the U.S. to play to its military strength in Asia and cooperate with local political leaders like South Korea's Lee Myung-bak, who want to use Washington as a counterweight to Beijing.

My guess is that containment is pretty much a default strategy since the United States has not found a way to incorporate China as an effective partner in the U.S.-conceived international order, and the attractions of beating up on an undemocratic, opaque, and somewhat threatening--but not too dangerous--regime were too strong to resist.

I think Mr. Steinberg of the NSC et. al. decided that China was an easy mark because of its dependence on peace, global prosperity, and access to markets to advance its economics-based strategy of national development.

Also, I expect the fact that the Chinese military is a paper tiger figured into U.S. calculations.

The PLA has not fought a war since the border conflict with Vietnam in 1979. It didn't do particularly well then, and the current generation of officers has never been "blooded" (experienced the routine chaos and catastrophe of actual battle) and is unlikely to seek out on-the-job training by engaging the world's biggest and most experienced military in a genuine conflict.

But I wonder if going zero-sum with China in Asia is really where we want to be.

I'd say that Chinese distrust of the Obama administration is now terminal, its anxiety palpable, and its determination to come up with effective countermeasures implacable. I expect they'll come up with something interesting and, perhaps, unexpected.

Second, Mark, Australia, Japan, Indonesia, South Korea and Vietnam, are in the western Pacific, not the "eastern". That grinding sound you hear is Henry Luce churning unhappily in his grave.

56 comments:

Thompson's article was a bit smug and annoying. But really isn't it all about posturing? China refuses to acknowledge the Cheonan attack as anything significant, so the US has to try to show that it isn't going to sit back and let China have the last word as if they were the ones running everything. Plus China is getting a lot of mileage out of their purported aircraft-carrier killing missile, so the US has a chance to show that it isn't limited to only aircraft carriers for attack (reference cruise missiles on submarines). Not quite a containment policy IMO.

Origins of the hookah come from India along the border of around 1500 Years ago. These hookahs were simple, primitive, and rugged in design, usually made from a coconut shell base and tube with a head attached. hookah

Find away how so what time to get something done a repeal telephone reverse phone lookup or else a telephone search before still a mobile phone number search search so as soon as to locate elsewhere who is bringing up the rear so as to human being that has been calling you this total moment in time ok.

I enjoy this nice reorder cell phone search or cellular phone lookup otherwise mobile phone number lookup spot. I be able to discover a exalted amount of reverse phone lookup substance about turn around mobile phone lookup here these days while I checkered elsewhere this guide here.

Origins of the hookah come from India along the border of around 1500 Years ago. These hookahs were simple, primitive, and rugged in design, usually made from a coconut shell base and tube with a head attached.bohyme

Such a very useful article. Very interesting to read this article.I would like to thank you for the efforts you had made for writing this awesome article. agen bola, agen sbobet, judi bola, agen ibcbet

This is a smart blog. I mean it. You have so much knowledge about this issue, and so much passion. You also know how to make people rally behind it, obviously from the responses. Agen Sbobet, Agen Bola, Judi Online

Dompetpoker.org is a card game that shares betting rules and is usually (but not always) in hand ranking. The Poker Online game is different in terms of how cards are shared. In the most modern Poker Games, the first round of betting starts with several forms. Type of card arrangement in Online Poker.

Choosing an online casino agent is essential if people want to work on online gambling. http://www.dompetcasino.net/ to make the play scene should really be done so that the smoothness in playing gambling can be enjoyed gambling agency sites online casino agency page can also be done with a system of observing recommendations and recommendations from more experienced players. judi online

4KGOAL.com 4kgoal's live score Indonesia website provides live scores soccer, matches from all leagues and daily game schedules

is a soccer information site, Livescore, Soccer Schedule, Interactive Soccer Scores and as a community for bookies and bettors to get information.

With a good background in the football industry, 4KGOAL.com has an outstanding editorial team. Sports information and data is displayed in full including several types of sports such as football, basketball, tennis, badminton and so forth.

The best online gambling agent is Bandar Slot, Casino SBOBET 338a, maxbet, mr8asia, Betting Prediction, Biggest and Most Trusted in Indonesia. Free Signup Process! You can directly play with less than 3 minutes process.Judi Online is an agile basketball player, Casino SBOBET 338a, ibcbet, Betting Prediction and slot game, Biggest and Most Trusted in Indonesiajudi online

Best and Reliable Best Online Casino and Casino Agent in Indonesia. Bandarbola88 GIVING THE WARRANTY OF OUR CUSTOMER SATISFACTION WITH SUPPORTED BY OUR RELIABLE TEAM CUSTOMER SERVICE AND EXPERIENCED. WE GUARANTEE YOUR SECURITY AND COMFORT JOIN WITH US. OUR CUSTOMER SERVICE STAFF WILL BE READY TO BE CONTACTED 24/7 THROUGH VARIOUS COMMUNICATIONS METHOD WE HAVE PROVIDED. WE WILL PROCESS ALL ONLINE TRANSACTIONS OR E-BANKINGS IN TIME LESS THAN 3 MINUTES. Bandarbola88 Gambling Agent Online Casino, WINING WILL BE WILL PAY, JOIN TOGETHER WITH US !!!!!!

go88poker.com is a trusted online poker site for gambling games Poker, Domino, Bandar Ceme, Bandar Capsa. No matter how much you win, we definitely pay. The go88poker.com site is guaranteed to be safe and reliable. 100% player vs player without robot.poker online

JudiKartu is the jadwal bola, first trusted online betting agent in Indonesia that provides live baccarat, roulette and sicbo online services. Giving customer satisfaction and serving better than others.Always determined to be able to serve customers better. Trying to remain a Soccer Agent, Casino Agent, the best and most trusted Online Betting in IndonesiaJadwal bola

Kamusuka88 is Agent Maxbet, Agent Maxbet, Agent of the World Cup 2018, Poker Agent, Trusted Soccer Agent & is a Trusted Online Gambling Site that operates in the country of Indonesia and provides a variety of best games in Asia and Europe.

LIGA369.CO IS A LEADING ONLINE BALL AND TITLE AGENT. WE ARE LOOKING FOR PREDICATES AS SUPER MASTER AFFILIATE AGENTS FROM VARIOUS FAMOUS ONLINE BALL AND TITLE BETWEEN WORKERS IN THE WORLD. NOW WE SERVE MORE THAN THOUSANDS OF ACTIVE MEMBERS.

Liganation is one of the trusted ball agents in Indonesia. We have reliable and fast customer service in responding to problems and complaints of the members 24 hours a day every day. As a trusted footballer, we will pay in full every victory you play online.

Search engine optimization (SEO) or Indonesian SEO is the process of influencing the visibility of websites or web pages in search engine results - often referred to as "natural", "organic" or "earned" results. In general, the earlier (or rank higher on search results pages), and more often sites appear in the list of search results, the more visitors will receive from search engine users, and these visitors can be converted to customers.

Onekartu is a trusted online poker agent Site. Original Money Poker uses IDNPlay servers that are 100% proven trusted and fairplay. Deposit and Withdraw Process in Crotqq start from 10 thousand rupiah and with fast and safe process. Customer Service Crotqq is available 24 hours to help you if you are having problems. CrotQQ is always trying to become a trusted online poker agent for those of you who want a Fairplay Poker game.

Dompetpoker.org is a card game that shares betting rules and is usually (but not always) in hand ranking. The Poker Online game is different in terms of how cards are shared. In the most modern Poker Games, the first round of betting starts with several forms. Type of card arrangement in Online Poker.

Choosing an online casino agent is essential if people want to work on online gambling. http://www.dompetcasino.net/ to make the play scene should really be done so that the smoothness in playing gambling can be enjoyed gambling agency sites online casino agency page can also be done with a system of observing recommendations and recommendations from more experienced players. judi online

4KGOAL.com 4kgoal's live score Indonesia website provides live scores soccer, matches from all leagues and daily game schedules

is a soccer information site, Livescore, Soccer Schedule, Interactive Soccer Scores and as a community for bookies and bettors to get information.

With a good background in the football industry, 4KGOAL.com has an outstanding editorial team. Sports information and data is displayed in full including several types of sports such as football, basketball, tennis, badminton and so forth.

The best online gambling agent is Bandar Slot, Casino SBOBET 338a, maxbet, mr8asia, Betting Prediction, Biggest and Most Trusted in Indonesia. Free Signup Process! You can directly play with less than 3 minutes process.Judi Online is an agile basketball player, Casino SBOBET 338a, ibcbet, Betting Prediction and slot game, Biggest and Most Trusted in Indonesiajudi online

Welcome to AsetQQ.com, the Best and Most Trusted Indonesian Online Poker Site. AsQQQ provides 6 games that can be played in 1 User Id only. Online Poker, DominoQQ, Bandar Ceme, Capsa Susun, Live Poker, Ceme Keliling Games, using Indonesian real moneypoker online

go88poker.com is a trusted online poker site for gambling games Poker, Domino, Bandar Ceme, Bandar Capsa. No matter how much you win, we definitely pay. The go88poker.com site is guaranteed to be safe and reliable. 100% player vs player without robot.poker online

happydomino is also the best and trusted Online Domino Poker site in Indonesia which has been proven by reputation and gained the trust of International Online gambling. Both the review of reputable poker sites and the quality of the games we provide do not need to be doubted. By providing the best service and providing assistance that is not complicated and we will provide an explanation that is as easy as possible so that you can easily understand it. We also provide playing tips and tricks so you can easily win in the best online gambling agent games in Indonesia. happydomino is guaranteed to be the fair play 100% online gambling site. There are no Robots in pure games Member vs Member. Our site is also equipped with the most sophisticated security system that is always updated on online gambling issues.

JudiKartu is the jadwal bola, first trusted online betting agent in Indonesia that provides live baccarat, roulette and sicbo online services. Giving customer satisfaction and serving better than others.Always determined to be able to serve customers better. Trying to remain a Soccer Agent, Casino Agent, the best and most trusted Online Betting in IndonesiaJadwal bola

LIGA369.CO IS A LEADING ONLINE BALL AND TITLE AGENT. WE ARE LOOKING FOR PREDICATES AS SUPER MASTER AFFILIATE AGENTS FROM VARIOUS FAMOUS ONLINE BALL AND TITLE BETWEEN WORKERS IN THE WORLD. NOW WE SERVE MORE THAN THOUSANDS OF ACTIVE MEMBERS.

Onekartu is a trusted online poker agent Site. Original Money Poker uses IDNPlay servers that are 100% proven trusted and fairplay. Deposit and Withdraw Process in Crotqq start from 10 thousand rupiah and with fast and safe process. Customer Service Crotqq is available 24 hours to help you if you are having problems. CrotQQ is always trying to become a trusted online poker agent for those of you who want a Fairplay Poker game.

Search engine optimization (SEO) or Indonesian SEO is the process of influencing the visibility of websites or web pages in search engine results - often referred to as "natural", "organic" or "earned" results. In general, the earlier (or rank higher on search results pages), and more often sites appear in the list of search results, the more visitors will receive from search engine users, and these visitors can be converted to customers.

Specialist SEO.com is an Indonesian SEO Service launched in 2011 when search engines were in the early stages of developing their algorithms, Google was a big company that was very promising. Search engine optimization (SEO) has a completely different meaning. Since then many things have changed and internet marketing has become a necessity for every company that wants to survive in the online world competitively.

Specialist SEO Indonesia SEO Services deal with Web Marketing technology from the start. After hours of research and development, trial and error, we can now offer the most reliable solutions in the world of Digital Marketing.

There are alot of game development companies. It is a very difficult task to choose one. "RV Online Gaming" is the reputed Poker Card Game Development Company in Gurgaon. I took services from this. I recommend you too.