Another clear case where we have to weigh contradictory evidence from two different categories of morphology one microscopic, one macroscopic.

Mykoweb has chosen to go with macroscopic evidence (a justification/explanation would be helpful), whereas I am inclined to go with the microscopic evidence (more stable, also corresponds with the lack of distinct umbilicus in the cap).

Not passing judgement, but let’s discuss our criteria, and our need for a third way of supporting our assertions…