Transcription

1 1 Module C: Fiscal Policy and Budget Deficits Note: This feature provides supplementary analysis for the material in Part 3 of Common Sense Economics. Fiscal and monetary policies are the two major tools available to policy makers to alter total demand, output, and employment. This feature will focus on fiscal policy, what it is and its potential and limitations as a tool with which to promote economic stability and strong growth. What is Fiscal Policy? When the supply of money is held constant, government expenditures must be financed by either taxes or borrowing. Fiscal policy involves the use of the government s spending, taxing and borrowing policies. The government s budget deficit is used to evaluate the direction of fiscal policy. When the government increases its spending and/or reduces taxes, this will shift the government budget toward a deficit. If the government runs a deficit, it will have to borrow funds to cover the excess of its spending relative to revenue. Larger budget deficits and increased borrowing are indicative of expansionary fiscal policy. In contrast, if the government reduces its spending and/or increases taxes, this would shift the budget toward a surplus. The budget surplus would reduce the government s outstanding debt. Shifts toward budget surpluses and less borrowing are indicative of restrictive fiscal policy. It is important to note that a budget deficit is different from the national debt. A deficit occurs when government spending exceeds revenue during a period such as a year or a quarter. A deficit will increase the size of the national debt. Put another way, the deficit adds to the outstanding stock of IOUs issued by the U.S. Government. Conversely, a budget surplus will make it possible for the government to reduce the national debt -- the total amount it owes to those holding Treasury bonds and bills. Keynesian View of Fiscal Policy

2 2 The English economist, John Maynard Keynes (pronounced canes ) popularized the use of fiscal policy as a stabilization tool. Writing during the Great Depression of the 1930s, Keynes argued that output and employment were well below their potential because there was insufficient total demand. If demand could be increased, output and employment could be expanded and the economy would return to its full employment potential. Moreover, Keynes believed this could be achieved with expansionary fiscal policy. During a recession, Keynes argued that, rather than balancing its budget, the government should increase its spending, reduce taxes, and shift its budget toward a deficit. According to Keynes, higher levels of government spending would directly increase total demand. Further, lower taxes would increase the after-tax incomes of households and they would spend most of that additional income, which would also stimulate total demand. Thus, the Keynesian prescription to cure a recession was a larger budget deficit. In contrast, if the economy was experiencing a problem with inflation during an economic boom, Keynesian analysis called for restrictive fiscal policy to temper excessive demand. In this case, reductions in government spending, higher taxes, and a shift of the budget toward a surplus would reduce total demand and thereby help to fight inflation. Thus, Keynes rejected the view that the government s budget should be balanced. He argued that appropriate budgetary policy was dependent on economic conditions. According to the Keynesian view, governments should run budget deficits during recessionary times and surpluses during periods when inflation was a problem because of excessive demand. Can Fiscal Policy Be Used to Reduce Economic Instability? The Keynesian view of fiscal policy swept the economics profession and, by the 1960s, it was also widely accepted by policy makers. During that era, most economists believed that fiscal policy exerted a powerful impact on the economy and that it could be instituted in a manner that would smooth the ups and downs of the business cycle.

3 3 However, this is more difficult than was initially perceived. If changes in fiscal policy are going to exert a stabilizing impact on the economy, they must be timed correctly. Proper timing of fiscal changes is difficult. There will be a time lag between when an economy is dipping into a recession and when policy-makers figure out what is happening and what to do. It will also take time to develop a fiscal package on which the majority will agree and pass it through Congress. Finally, there will also be a time lag between when additional government spending is passed and when contracts are extended and the spending actually occurs. The combination of these time lags is long and variable, typically 12 to 24 months. Given these time lags, if fiscal policy is going to exert a stabilizing influence, policy makers need to know what economic conditions are going to be like 12 to 24 months in the future. But this is a big problem. The ability to forecast when the economy is about to dip into a recession or experience an economic boom is extremely limited. Therefore, in a world of dynamic change and unpredictable events, macroeconomic policy-making is a little bit like lobbing a ball at a target that often moves in unforeseen directions. Predictably, policy-making errors will occur. Sometimes fiscal policy changes will end up adding stimulus during periods of strong demand and restraint during periods of recession. Changes of this type would add to, rather than reduce, economic instability. Because of these timing problems, most economists, including many Keynesians, now believe that it is a mistake for policy makers to be constantly changing fiscal policy in response to minor changes in economic conditions. Such constant changes are likely to be timed incorrectly and add to the uncertainty with regard to future business conditions. Put another way, it is unrealistic to expect that political decision-makers will consistently alter fiscal policy in a manner that will add stimulus during recessions and restraint during inflationary booms. Automatic Stabilizers However, there are a few fiscal programs that tend automatically to apply demand stimulus during a recession and demand restraint during an economic boom. Programs of this type are called automatic stabilizers. They are automatic in that, without any new

4 4 legislative action, they tend to increase the budget deficit (or reduce the surplus) during a recession and increase the surplus (or reduce the deficit) during an economic boom. The unemployment compensation system provides an example. This system levies a payroll tax on employment and uses the revenues to provide benefits to workers who are unemployed. When an economy begins to dip into a recession, the government will pay out more money in unemployment benefits as the number of laid-off and unemployed workers expands. Simultaneously, the revenues derived from the employment tax will decline because fewer workers are paying into the system. Therefore, this program will automatically run a deficit during a recession. In contrast, during an economic boom, the tax receipts from the program will increase because more people are now working, and the amount paid out in benefits will decline because fewer people are unemployed. As a result, the program will automatically tend to run a surplus during good times. Thus, without any legislative action, the unemployment compensation system will tend to shift the budget toward a deficit during a recession and toward a surplus during a boom. The corporate income tax and progressive nature of the personal income tax also tend to act as automatic stabilizers. Automatic stabilizers minimize the problem of appropriate timing. They help keep the economy on track even without any legislative action. They are important because they shift the budget toward deficit during recessions and surplus during booms without having to depend on politicians to time a policy change in an appropriate manner. Current Debate About the Potency of Fiscal Policy Will increases in government spending, reductions in taxes, and large budget deficits stimulate output and employment? Fifty years ago during the heyday of Keynesian economics, most all economists believed that expansionary fiscal policy exerted a strong impact on total demand and output. But this is no longer the case. Today, many economists argue that there are important incentive and secondary effects that largely erode the potency of expansionary fiscal policy. There are two major reasons why Keynesian critics believe that expansionary fiscal policy is not very potent. First, there is the interest rate effect. Budget deficits will have to be financed by increased borrowing. But when the government borrows more in

5 5 the loanable funds market, this will increase interest rates. In turn, the higher interest rates will crowd out private investment and consumption and this reduction in private spending will largely, if not entirely, offset the stimulus effects of the increase in government spending. Second, other non-keynesians stress that the budget deficits will result in a larger government debt and higher taxes to cover the interest costs. These economists believe that the expectation of the higher future taxes will dampen private spending and thereby offset the stimulus effects of deficit spending. The potency of expansionary fiscal policy is a hot topic of current debate among economists. Even though they recognize that it is extremely difficult to time fiscal changes correctly, modern Keynesians believe that increased government spending and enlarged budget deficits will help promote recovery from a serious recession like that of On the other hand, many non-keynesians argue that higher interest rates and expected future taxes accompanying the higher levels of government borrowing will largely offset the expansionary impact of the budget deficits. Even if the government is able to borrow at low interest rates during a recession, as was the case during , some combination of higher interest rates and higher taxes will be required for the financing and re-financing of the larger debt as the economy recovers. Non-Keynesians believe that these higher interest rates and tax rates will reduce private investment, weaken the recovery, and lead to a slower rate of long-term growth. It is interesting to observe the response to the recession. During , the United States ran budget deficits of nearly10 percent of GDP, levels only present in the midst of World War II. Keynesian analysis indicates that these large deficits would exert a powerful impact on total demand and help propel the economy to a strong recovery. This did not happen. In fact, the recovery from the recession was the weakest of the post-world War II era. But, this did not resolve the debate about the potency of fiscal policy. Keynesians merely argued that the recession would have been deeper and the recovery weaker if the government had not run the large deficits. Thus, the potency of budget deficits is a continuing topic of debate among economists.

6 6 Tax Cuts Versus Spending Increases When using expansionary fiscal policy to promote recovery from a recession, would it be better to reduce tax rates or increase government spending? There are at least four reasons why a tax cut is likely to be more effective than a spending increase as a tool with which to promote recovery and long-term growth. First, a tax cut will generally stimulate aggregate demand more rapidly. As recent experience illustrates, the federal government is able to get checks to people in just two or three months. Even if a substantial portion of the funds is not spent quickly, there will be an immediate positive impact on the financial position of households. In contrast, spending projects are often a lengthy process spread over several years. For example, the Congressional Budget Office estimated that only 15 percent of the spending funded by the stimulus package passed in February 2009 would occur during the initial year while nearly half (48 percent) would not be spent until 2011 and beyond. Second, compared to an increase in government spending, a tax cut is less likely to increase structural unemployment and reduce the productivity of resources. New government spending programs generally change the structure of total demand more than a tax cut. Other things constant, larger changes in the composition of demand will mean more unemployment, at least in the short run. Moreover, the additional government spending is likely to be less productive. Government has a tendency to become heavily involved in allocating scarce resources through spending programs that favor sectors, businesses, and interest groups. By contrast, households will tend to purchase items that are valued more than the cost of producing them when their spending increases as the result of lower taxes. Third, a tax cut will be easier to reverse once the economy has recovered. Once started, the interests undertaking a government project and benefiting from it will lobby for its continuation. Therefore spending projects started during a crisis are likely to continue long after the crisis is history. Fourth, a reduction in tax rates will increase the incentive to earn, invest, engage in business activity, and employ others. From a supply-side view, the marginal tax rate imposed on income is particularly important. The marginal tax rate determines the breakdown of a person s additional income between tax payments on the one hand and

7 7 personal income on the other. Lower marginal tax rates mean that individuals get to keep a larger share of their additional earnings. This incentive effect will encourage more productive activity and help speed a recessionary economy toward recovery. Concluding Thoughts During the past 70 years, views about fiscal policy have come full circle. Prior to the Keynesian Revolution, it was widely believed that governments should balance their budget during times of peace. Keynes changed all of this and, by the 1960s, fiscal policy was perceived of as a powerful tool that could be used effectively to reduce economic fluctuations. But during the past four decades, both analysis of political incentives and real world experiences have convinced many economists that it is unrealistic to expect political decision-makers to institute fiscal changes in a stabilizing manner. Greater recognition of the secondary effects of budget deficits has also caused many to question the potency of fiscal policy. Further, the persistence of large budget deficits and growth of government debt as a share of the total economy has generated fears that, if unconstrained, the political process will result in excessive debt that will threaten the solvency of even wealthy countries like the United States, Japan, and those of Western Europe. As we have noted, debate continues with regard to how fiscal policy can best be used to promote growth and prosperity. But once again, many economists, particularly those with expertise in public choice, are now calling for something like a balanced budget constraint as a means to control government spending, excessive debt, and the political incentive structure that undermines the sound use of fiscal policy. For an analysis of how the political incentive structure promotes debt financing, See, Common Sense Economics, Part 3, Element 6, Unless restrained by constitutional rules, legislators will run deficits and spend excessively.

8 8 Short response questions 1. Can fiscal policy changes be instituted in a manner that will reduce economic fluctuations? Explain. 2. Will increases in government spending financed by borrowing help promote recovery from a recession? Why or why not? 3. If there is a shift to a more expansionary fiscal policy during a recession, does it make any difference whether tax rates are cut or government expenditures are increased? Explain your answer. The answer key is available to instructors who adopt Common Sense Economics (St. Martin s Press). Details on how to adopt are provided at:

1 Supplemental Unit 5: Fiscal Policy and Budget Deficits Fiscal and monetary policies are the two major tools available to policy makers to alter total demand, output, and employment. This feature will

The Fiscal Policy and The Monetary Policy Ing. Mansoor Maitah Ph.D. Government in the Economy The Government and Fiscal Policy Fiscal Policy changes in taxes and spending that affect the level of GDP to

Is the Australian economy heading for a severe recession? If so, what (if anything) can policy makers do about it? Christopher M. Fleming Department of Accounting, Finance and Economics GriffithBUSINESS

Chapter 18 MODERN PRINCIPLES OF ECONOMICS Third Edition Fiscal Policy Outline Fiscal Policy: The Best Case The Limits to Fiscal Policy When Fiscal Policy Might Make Matters Worse So When Is Fiscal Policy

Government Budget and Fiscal Policy 11 CHAPTER The National Budget The national budget is the annual statement of the government s expenditures and tax revenues. Fiscal policy is the use of the federal

Chapter 15 FISCAL POLICY* The Federal Budget Topic: The Federal Budget 1) Which of the following is considered a purpose of the federal budget? I. To help the economy achieve full employment. II. To finance

CHAPTER 30: FISCAL POLICY, DEFICITS, AND DEBT Introduction Changes in aggregate supply and demand affect output, employment, and price level in the economy. But as a result of Keynesian theory, government

Copyright 2011 by Pearson Education, Inc. Chapter 14 Deficit Spending and The Public Debt All rights reserved. Introduction Since 2007, the ratio of the official real net public debt to real GDP has increased

Chapter 30 Fiscal Policy, Deficits, and Debt QUESTIONS 1. What is the role of the Council of Economic Advisers (CEA) as it relates to fiscal policy? Use an Internet search to find the names and university

Chapter 15 review Multiple Choice Identify the letter of the choice that best completes the statement or answers the question. 1. Every hour, the federal government spends about a. $250 thousand. c. $250

Chapter 1 Introduction to Macroeconomics Multiple Choice Questions 1. The two major reasons for the tremendous growth in output in the U.S. economy over the last 125 years are (a) population growth and

The Great Recession, the Great Depression, and Great Macroeconomic Debates Previously The aggregate demand and aggregate supply model is a simplified view of the economy that helps us evaluate short-term

Defining Surpluses and Debt Politics, Surpluses,, and Debt Chapter 11 A surplus is an excess of revenues over payments. A deficit is a shortfall of revenues relative to payments. 2 Introduction After having

Chapter 15 Macro Stabilization Policy After reading Chapter 15, MACRO STABILIZATION POLICY, you should be able to: Describe how stabilization policy works and the arguments for and against Activism. Define

CHAPTER 7: AGGREGATE DEMAND AND AGGREGATE SUPPLY Learning goals of this chapter: What forces bring persistent and rapid expansion of real GDP? What causes inflation? Why do we have business cycles? How

Chapter 26 An Aggregate Supply and Demand Perspective on Money and Economic Stability Learning Objectives Analyze the debate centering on the stability of the economy around its full employment level Define

Answers to Text Questions and Problems Chapter 4 Answers to Review Questions 1. The catastrophic economic collapse of the 1930s convinced economists and policymakers that there were major gaps in their

MACROECONOMIC AND INDUSTRY ANALYSIS VALUATION PROCESS BUSINESS ANALYSIS INTRODUCTION To determine a proper price for a firm s stock, security analyst must forecast the dividend & earnings that can be expected

KrugmanMacro_SM_Ch12.qxp 11/15/05 3:18 PM Page 141 Fiscal Policy 1. The accompanying diagram shows the current macroeconomic situation for the economy of Albernia. You have been hired as an economic consultant

Homework 16 1. Fill in the blanks for the following sentence: A rise in taxes on households will shift AD to the, this will push. A. right; down B. left; down C. left; up D. right; up 2. During a recession,

JOHN MAYNARD KEYNES AND MILTON FRIEDMAN ECO54 UDAYAN ROY The questions on Keynes are taken from chapter IX of The Worldly Philosophers and chapter IX of New Ideas from Dead Economists. 1. According to,

Chapter 8 Business Cycles Multiple Choice Questions 1. One of the first organizations to investigate the business cycle was (a) the Federal Reserve System. (b) the National Bureau of Economic Research.

Fill in the Blanks. Module 1 S.Y.B.COM. (SEM-III) ECONOMICS 1. The continuous flow of money and goods and services between firms and households is called the Circular Flow. 2. Saving constitute a leakage

Chapter 18 Debates in Macroeconomics: Monetarism, and Supply-Side Economics Keynesian Economics In a broad sense, Keynesian economics is the foundation of modern macroeconomics. In a narrower sense, Keynesian

Economics 101 Multiple Choice Questions for Final Examination Miller PLEASE DO NOT WRITE ON THIS EXAMINATION FORM. 1. Which of the following statements is correct? a. Real GDP is the total market value

Fiscal Policy chapter: 28 13 ECONOMICS MACROECONOMICS 1. The accompanying diagram shows the current macroeconomic situation for the economy of Albernia. You have been hired as an economic consultant to

Quarterly Update: The Economic Recovery in Historical Context Paul Swartz Analyst, International Economics pswartz@cfr.org August 16, 2010 How do the recent economic collapse and recovery match up with

2W EB CHAPTER Monetary and Fiscal Policy in the ISLM Model Preview Since World War II, government policymakers have tried to promote high employment without causing inflation. If the economy experiences

Exam Name MULTIPLE CHOICE. Choose the one alternative that best completes the statement or answers the question. 1) Inflation can be started by 1) A) an increase in aggregate supply or a decrease in aggregate

Economics Revision: Conflicts between Macro Objectives This revision note looks at possible conflicts between macroeconomic objectives and some of the policy prescriptions for over- coming them. hen conflicts

Fiscal Policy: Structural/Cyclical Size of government Questions And Business Cycle Smoothing Issues When is government a preferred provider of goods? What is a PURE PUBLIC GOOD? My consumption of the good

2.5 Monetary policy: Interest rates Learning Outcomes Describe the role of central banks as regulators of commercial banks and bankers to governments. Explain that central banks are usually made responsible

Chapter 28 Aggregate Supply, Aggregate Demand, and Inflation: Putting It All Together Principles of Economics in Context (Goodwin, et al.) Chapter Overview This chapter introduces you to the "Aggregate

The Case for a Tax Cut Alan C. Stockman University of Rochester, and NBER Shadow Open Market Committee April 29-30, 2001 1. Tax Increases Have Created the Surplus Any discussion of tax policy should begin

Standard 1: Scarcity Productive resources are limited. Therefore, people can not have all the goods and services they want; as a result, they must choose some things and give up others. Section 1 Savings

Potential GDP and Economic Growth CHAPTER17 C H A P T E R C H E C K L I S T When you have completed your study of this chapter, you will be able to 1 Explain the forces that determine potential GDP and

Chapter 11 Keynesianism: The Macroeconomics of Wage and Price Rigidity Multiple Choice Questions 1. Keynesians are skeptical of the classical theory that recessions are periods of increased mismatch between

Chapter 12: Gross Domestic Product and Growth Section 1 Key Terms national income accounting: a system economists use to collect and organize macroeconomic statistics on production, income, investment,

Macroeconomic policy Fiscal Policy What is fiscal policy? Fiscal policy is the use of government spending and taxation to influence the level of aggregate demand and economic activity List the main types

Rethinking Fiscal Policy Janice Eberly Whereas much of the policy innovation during the financial crisis focused on monetary policy and especially unconventional monetary policy there has since been renewed

CHAPTER 23 FISCAL POLICY: COPING WITH INFLATION AND UNEMPLOYMENT Chapter in a Nutshell To say that an economy is in equilibrium tells us very little about the general state of the economy. The model showing

ECONOMICS U$A PROGRAM #26 STABILIZATION POLICY: ARE WE STILL IN CONTROL? AUDIO PROGRAM TRANSCRIPT ECONOMICS U$A PROGRAM #26 STABILIZATION POLICY: ARE WE STILL IN CONTROL? (MUSIC PLAYS) ANNOUNCER: Funding

We have already briefly talked about Keynesian arguments for government intervention, where we found that Keynesian Economist believes that because prices are sticky, it may take a sufficient lag in time

AP Macroeconomics: Vocabulary 1. Aggregate Spending (GDP): The sum of all spending from four sectors of the economy. GDP = C+I+G+Xn 2. Aggregate Income (AI) :The sum of all income earned by suppliers of

Chapter 12 Aggregate Supply and Aggregate Demand After reading Chapter 12, AGGREGATE SUPPLY AND AGGREGATE DEMAND, you should be able to: Use an Aggregate Demand and Aggregate Supply model to explain output,

Federal Budgets: The Tools of Fiscal Policy Previously In the recent Great Recession, we experienced lower output and high unemployment. However, the Great Depression in the 1930s was much worse and lasted

Macroeconomics Revision Essay Plan (2): Inflation and Unemployment and Economic Policy (a) Explain why it is considered important to control inflation (20 marks) (b) Discuss how a government s commitment

Agenda. Introduction to Macroeconomics What Macroeconomists Do.. 1-1 1-2 Macroeconomics is the study of: 1. The structure, dynamic adjustment, and performance of national economies, and 2. The government

Workshop 7 Monetary and Fiscal Policy Description The government uses monetary and fiscal policy to manage the economy. Monetary policy and fiscal policy are tools to increase or decrease aggregate demand

General ertificate of Education dvanced Subsidiary Examination January 2013 Economics EON2 Unit 2 The National Economy Monday 28 January 2013 1.30 pm to 2.45 pm For this paper you must have: an objective

Keynes and IS-LM analysis (Chapter 33 in Mankiw and Taylor) Short-run fluctuations The next four lectures will cover different aspects of macroeconomic policy, in particular, the role of fiscal and monetary

John Maynard Keynes ''The difficulty lies not so much in developing new ideas as in escaping from old ones'' Dr David Rees 1883-1946 British Founder of Keynesian Macroeconomics (Western economic paradigm

OCTOBER 2013 THE POTENTIAL MACROECONOMIC EFFECT OF DEBT CEILING BRINKMANSHIP Introduction The United States has never defaulted on its obligations, and the U. S. dollar and Treasury securities are at the

To ensure the functioning of the site, we use cookies. We share information about your activities on the site with our partners and Google partners: social networks and companies engaged in advertising and web analytics. For more information, see the Privacy Policy and Google Privacy &amp Terms.
Your consent to our cookies if you continue to use this website.