I know they lost this week. But I swear, after seeing Luck play three games this season. He feels like the best pro QB prospect since Peyton Manning. Anybody feels the same?

I speak this because I hate the fact that Bradford and Sanchez are doing well. And Freeman to an extent too. While I fear an injury riddled career with Stafford. Not saying I want to draft Luck because we already made our bed with Stafford. I know I didn't want to draft him, but he won me over in the Cleveland game. I just pray he gets a healthy long career.

Otherwise I will always have this what-if scenario swirling in my head, had we done the "Add QB as final piece" strategy. We might have been in a position to draft Luck.

We may still be in position to draft Luck. Might end up with #1 the way this season has been going. Esp considering I assumed wed be ahead of the Chiefs and Browns...

It might not be a bad thing though if there is a new rookie wage scale in place, meaning that #1 picka nd a shot at Luck will actually be worth trading for for multiple teams that need a QB, and since it wont cost 90million, many teams may be willing. Might even get a bidding war.

We may still be in position to draft Luck. Might end up with #1 the way this season has been going. Esp considering I assumed wed be ahead of the Chiefs and Browns...

It might not be a bad thing though if there is a new rookie wage scale in place, meaning that #1 picka nd a shot at Luck will actually be worth trading for for multiple teams that need a QB, and since it wont cost 90million, many teams may be willing. Might even get a bidding war.

You can't be awarded the #1 pick when you win 7 games. LOL.

October 5th, 2010, 12:37 am

Blueskies

Player of the Year - Offense

Joined: September 13th, 2007, 12:43 pmPosts: 2862

Re: Andrew Luck

Even if Stafford comes back and immediately goes on IR, you can't write him off. Too soon. If for nothing else, his contract.

The Lions won't be picking first, but if they theoretically were, and there was a Peyton Manning version 2.0 sitting there, you trade the pick to Cleveland or Buffalo and call it a day.

October 7th, 2010, 5:09 pm

steensn

RIP Killer

Joined: June 26th, 2006, 1:03 pmPosts: 13429

Re: Andrew Luck

With no season next season stafford has a whole year to get healthy anyways.

Even if Stafford comes back and immediately goes on IR, you can't write him off. Too soon. If for nothing else, his contract.

The Lions won't be picking first, but if they theoretically were, and there was a Peyton Manning version 2.0 sitting there, you trade the pick to Cleveland or Buffalo and call it a day.

You don't pass on Peyton Manning, you trade Stafford for what you can get and go win a Super Bowl!

So if we are pikcing #1 and Luck is there you take him? You cant trade Staff for anythign because of his cost. Nobody would pay. Youd have to cut him and eat all the losses, and we dont even know what the kid has got left.

You trade the pick in a giant bidding war, unless Staff comes back AND sucks the rest of the season. Then you KNOW hes not "it".

I know Stafford has been hurt, which sucks, but why are we giving up on him???

Most of us haven't. Only a couple have given up on him. And they didn't want him from the very start. So, they are starting to beat the "BUST" drums without coming out and calling him a bust yet. They have been looking for the opportunity to demonize him. And so they are latching onto the injuries as their main focus right now.

And, they won't stop until they get what they want. They want to make him the next Joey. Some people just refuse to be happy with what we have, if it isn't who THEY wanted.

edited to add:

I am not calling out anyone in particular. I am also not saying that the author of this post is one of the "THEY" people. Because, I don't think he is.

October 8th, 2010, 3:32 pm

wjb21ndtown

Re: Andrew Luck

kdsberman wrote:

I know Stafford has been hurt, which sucks, but why are we giving up on him???

I don't think that anyone is giving up on him. It's just a hypothetical. I never understood why people take a hypothetical situation (Payton Manning available at the top of the draft and we have the #1 pick) and extrapolate craziness (that we're giving up on Stafford) out of it...

I haven't given up on him, at all. That said, I don't expect much from him, I think he was the wrong pick, and I think we're building the team the wrong way. People will say "you shouldn't be so down on him" as if my thoughts somehow play a role in his success or failure... I just sit back and watch - he hasn't shown much to me thus far...

October 8th, 2010, 3:40 pm

steensn

RIP Killer

Joined: June 26th, 2006, 1:03 pmPosts: 13429

Re: Andrew Luck

I have no problem seeing how the season plays out... but if after two seasons he misses 50% of the games I think that we should e concerned if he can't finish the year if he has another injury.

We may still be in position to draft Luck. Might end up with #1 the way this season has been going. Esp considering I assumed wed be ahead of the Chiefs and Browns...

It might not be a bad thing though if there is a new rookie wage scale in place, meaning that #1 picka nd a shot at Luck will actually be worth trading for for multiple teams that need a QB, and since it wont cost 90million, many teams may be willing. Might even get a bidding war.

This is a great point. Assuming a CBA is worked out, a wage scale is a foregone conclusion. And Luck would be had for much cheaper than Stafford. And any could be used as a trade chip. Stafford's price is all in the signing bonus which the Lions have already fronted. And depending on how the CBA is structured, Stafford might be the cheaper more attractive option, from here going forward.

All that said, I still hope to use our first pick on defense. Hence, I hope for a healthy Stafford.

IF there was a BARRY and you knew in advance that he would be all of that, wouldn't you take him even though we have Best. OF course you would pick him.

Stupid question if you ask me.

But.....

I also have concerns about Staffords health. Were these just unlucky landings or is he fragile. Hard to say, but IF he cannot stay healthy...he cannot stay on the field....therfore is of no use to us.

Frok

_________________I feel more like I do now than when I first got here.

October 11th, 2010, 7:56 pm

Wayne Fontes

Color Commentator - John Madden

Joined: January 19th, 2007, 3:21 amPosts: 1919Location: A2

Re: Andrew Luck

Yes, you take Manning, but remember how there was debate about Manning and Leaf? The draft is such a crap shoot that you can't assume that Andrew Luck is going to be the next Peyton Manning or the next Joey Harrington. What if he ends up like Joey Ballgame? Would you want to get rid of Stafford, who has shown flashes, for Jeff George?

Mayhew knows how to bilk teams when trading, so it would totally surprise me if he does something crazy, but this might be even beyond crazy.