Concealed Carry Now

by Ari Armstrong

Sept. 15, 1999. More
on the carrying of handguns for lawful protection.

On Friday evening, September 3, Chad Anderson
drove to a Grand Junction City Market grocery store and asked for his estranged wife
Sarah, whom he had assaulted a month earlier. After leaving briefly and returning,
Anderson dragged Sarah from the store by her hair while cursing her. Hobert Franklin, Jr.
attempted to stop Anderson inside the store. Anderson pulled a .22 Ruger revolver from his
pocket and shot Franklin in the chest, killing him. Once in the parking lot, Anderson shot
Sarah twice, once in the body and once in the head, killing her.

Meanwhile, David Gilcrease had herd about the
emergency while inside the store and had exited to the parking lot to confront Anderson.
Anderson shot and killed Gilcrease and then killed himself. Five shots, three innocent
deaths and a suicide. A horrible tragedy. Would a "shall-issue" concealed carry
law in Colorado have stopped it?

While it's impossible to predict what the
effects of a law might have been in a particular case, what's clear is that the rate of
murder, rape, aggravated assault, and robbery declines in states that permit citizens to
carry concealed handguns. Colorado is one of a minority of states that either prohibits
concealed carry by law-abiding citizens or limits the practice. In Colorado, county
sheriffs may issue concealed carry permits at their discretion.

Professor John Lott, Jr. of Yale Law School
conducted a comprehensive statistical study of crime and compiled the results in his book,
More Guns, Less Crime. Lott writes that if counties now without "shall-issue"
concealed carry requirements "had been subject to state concealed-handgun laws and
had thus been forced to issue handgun permits, murders in the United States would have
declined by about 1,400... the number of rapes in states without nondiscretionary laws
would have declined by 4,200, aggravated assaults by 60,000, and robberies by
12,000."

Notably Lott found that mass public shootings
drastically decline because of concealed carry laws. "For those states from which
data are available before and after the passage of such [nondiscretionary concealed
handgun] laws, the mean per-capita death rate from mass shootings in those states plummets
by 69 percent."

So, while it's impossible to predict whether
a nondiscretionary concealed handgun law in Colorado would have prevented Anderson from
murdering three innocent people on September 3, it's clear that such a law would have
saved lives over-all by preventing many of those types of murders state-wide.

Of course, the anti-gun lobby uses every
tragedy involving guns to push their political agenda to eventually ban guns altogether.
"If Anderson hadn't been able to steal that .22, he couldn't have used it to murder
three innocent people." But this line of argument ignores some important facts. Even
if guns had been banned altogether, Anderson still could have purchased one on the black
market or resorted to some other weapon like a knife or a crow-bar.

And if guns had been banned, thousands of
lives would have been lost because victims would have been defenseless in their homes
against violent rapists and thugs.

The deterrent effect of concealed carry laws
does not even depend on citizens using their guns for defense. Instead, many would-be
criminals avoid getting into situations where they might be confronted by citizens bearing
arms. Thus, potential crimes are avoided altogether. It's possible that if Chad Anderson
had known he would have faced several concealed handgun carriers at City Market, he would
never have gone there in the first place. If that had been the case, those who took the
responsibility to carry handguns and train to use them safely and effectively would have
prevented the terrible tragedy, and they would never even have known it.

That's why the sentiments of some are biased
against guns. Murders make for dramatic television. But the crimes prevented by handgun
ownership can only be studied through academic statistical research. The lives saved by
gun ownership, however, are no less important simply because they go largely unnoticed by
the media.

Ari Armstrong is a Senior Fellow with the
Independence Institute, a think-tank in Golden, http://i2i.org

Make a donation to support Dave Kopel's work in defense of constitutional
rights and public safety.

Nothing written here is to be construed as
necessarily representing the views of the Independence Institute or as an
attempt to influence any election or legislative action. Please send
comments to Independence Institute, 727 East 16th Ave., Denver, Colorado 80203 Phone 303-279-6536. (email)webmngr @ i2i.org