In the episode, Lucifer (Tom Ellis) and the team investigate the murder of a child psychiatrist, while Ella (Aimee Garcia) thinks about a big childhood secret that she’s been hiding. Then, in Part Two, which was directed by cast member Kevin Alejandro, an alternate dimension is visited where Lucifer not only has never met Chloe (Lauren German), but is granted the freedom of choice.

American Gods author Neil Gaiman voices God, who serves as the narrator. Charlyne Yi of House also guest stars.