If this is your first visit, be sure to
check out the FAQ by clicking the
link above. You may have to register
before you can post: click the register link above to proceed. To start viewing messages,
select the forum that you want to visit from the selection below.

Split-thread softhackle SBS

this feather would be perfect for a #8 but I'm interested in something more like a #18

insert the barbs in clip (extend about shank length); Petijean's is a nice tool, and makes it easy to show the process in photos, but any clip will do the job

trim the butt ends close, but leave enough to grab with the thread

split thread (UTC 70 used here)

insert clip

slide thread down till it captures the barbs and release clip

spin bobbin to lock in feather barbs

wet fingers, stroke fibers back while wrapping "hackle"

half hitch, SHHAN

Craig Mathews http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=MbZlVPsKv9M and Walter Wiese http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=0-dfsN0ZPkc have put together excellent instructions using oversize feathers, but for the life of me, I can't spin one like Mathews and when I use Walter's method, I often get uneven distribution around the fly (more a matter of lack of ability on my part). Using the split-thread really doesn't take much longer and I've found it produces consistent results for me; YMMV.

Sorry Scott, and this is solely a matter of personal aesthetics, but I don't care for the look of the butt ends of cut hackle as a collar. If someone wants or needs to use 'oversize' fibers for a collar then simply cut them from the stem, measure to the length you wish to use, grasp them at the tie in point, wind the thread and then maneuver the fibers around the shank as the thread is tightened. Even if a 'split thread' method is used, the butts of the feather should be cut as close to the thread as possible.
But just to let you know, I appreciate all of your SBSs. Always well done and described.

Thank you for your honest opinion and criticism; I realize this technique isn't for everyone and your method certainly produces excellent results, in the right hands (not mine, apparently). Also, cutting the butts closer would certainly make for a neater appearance; I don't mind the stubs and I don't know if the fish care, but a person should be happy with the fly they're tying/using.

Thank you for your honest opinion and criticism; I realize this technique isn't for everyone and your method certainly produces excellent results, in the right hands (not mine, apparently). Also, cutting the butts closer would certainly make for a neater appearance; I don't mind the stubs and I don't know if the fish care, but a person should be happy with the fly they're tying/using.

Regards,
Scott

Scott,

Appreciate and thank you for your SBSs and your reaction to my comment. It was solely from a personal viewpoint. I completely agree that the fish are the final arbiters and that "a person should be happy with the fly they're tying/using." Anyway, looking forward to your next set of sequential tying instructions.

For me, I usually learn something from every post I read but there was something extra this time. It was so nice to hear polite, considerate and open opinion and response. It makes me feel good to enjoy an activity with a group of true sportsmen. Just say'n.

Scott,
I truly appreciate the time you put into sharing your SBS patterns. You always have very useful information. It was very refreshing to hear polite, considerate and open opinion along with response without getting worked up. FAOL has a long tradition of people sharing and learning ideas and that continues tonight. Good stuff. Thanks again for all the patterns you have shared of late.