I'm not sure I want to revisit any past islands, with the exception of Monkey Island. I mean, going back to Melee Island in EMI wasn't as great as I had hoped it would be. I say just keep doing new islands.

Plus, I'm assuming we're going back Flotsam Island at least once, since I have a feeling that courthouse will play a part in the Trial and Execution of Guybrush Threepwood episode.

Hey, wow, Curse of Monkey Island is the third game in the series and Plunder Island is still considered classic. Wouldn't it have been terrible if, instead of Plunder Island, we got to go back to Melee and Monkey Island for every single game?

I wouldn't mind not seeing Flotsam any more. It had what it takes to be a MI Island, but somehow, I suspect there are better things waiting for us. And yes, if there was a slightest possibility of revisiting Plunder Island, I'd second the motion to have it reintroduced (but only if its designed well; somehow, the 3D graphics doesn't portray the jungles so well).