"With fond memories of educational titles like 'Granny's Garden', and less educational ones like 'Pole Position' and 'Boffin', the BBC B seemed like a worthy machine to bring back to life inside an FPGA." The Hacker News thread has links to more FPGA implementations of older home computers.

The BBC was very much the computer we used in schools in the 80's. I knew very few people with them as their home machines. One was the sons of my Senior School English teacher (Senior School == High School for American readers.) Then I had 2 friends with Electrons. Other than that 99% of people had either a ZX Spectrum model, a C64 or Amstrad CPC. Then Amiga and ST happened and the BBC computers were even more niche. The tail end of my school years (I was in 6th form college doing A-Levels - for Americans, the last two years of High school) we had Archimedes. But they were very niche. A couple of people owned them. My parents got one, but then my Mother used it for about 10 years after that (circa 1990) as she was in education (working with kids with learning difficulties and milt disabilities) and Arc's were still predominant till the late 90's.

The main problem with the Electron was that it was a bit of a rush job. They replaced a whole load of discrete electronics with an ASIC and then lopped off mode 7. It had most of the "cool" I/O removed and really wasn't 100% compatible with BBC software.

No. AFAIK you *never* got mode 7, which was used in a lot of educational software. Mode 7 was aka as the "teletext" mode. Because they replaced a chunk of the guts with a custom ULA (ASIC) it was more like a "very good" BBC clone. It did almost everything, but not with absolute compatibility. The BBC emulator that came with RISCOS had better compatibility with software, for example.

There were modules you could add to an Electron to get most of the functionality of the BBC.. but by the time you'd spent all that money, you probably could have just got a BBC.

I love these projects, whether in hardware or software emulation. Both thresholds (CPUs powerful enough to emulate hardware, and FPGAs large enough to accommodate entire systems) have made amazing things possible.

It is not only fun to play with these old systems, but it puts into perspective where we are in computer history. And it's sometimes enlightening to discover/remember how we used to squeeze more out of less.

I had a model B and all the paraphernalia, I'm amazed that anyone though can still remember all the nitty details in getting this old stuff working. I sold off the hardware but I still have all the old books for most of the languages that were sold for it.

Time for some Raspberry Pi tinkering, wonder if anyone has run a Beeb/QL/ZX emulator on it.

"I'm amazed that anyone though can still remember all the nitty details in getting this old stuff working."

Well, it's still within one life frame. I can still remember my early projects and probably will till I'm senile. It is still a part of *us*. I wonder what kind of emotions early computing will bring back to the generations who are more disconnected and never experienced the stuff first hand. The most popular computers/software may still have working models and get featured on the history channel. Most of our work will probably be forgotten to rot in attics for a few generations until there's no record.

Hollywood is eventually going to make a dramatic movie about early computing from the perspective of the (future) present. They're bound to fumble the facts so badly that it'd be hilariously inaccurate if any of us were to see it. I hope they don't try to draw too many facts from crap like "Hackers"...

My own kids are obsessed with computers as most are, as long as it is shiny bling and plays games on the web, its a computer. They have no concept of a computer being useful that isn't connected to the web. If I showed them whats inside, total disinterest, "whatever"!

It would be interesting to see how well the Colossus and Tommy Flowers is portrayed in a movie. The UK war secrecy didn't help any. In them olden days, a mag drum was hacked together from metal drums and tape heads lying around the work shop.

The most popular computers/software may still have working models and get featured on the history channel. Most of our work will probably be forgotten to rot in attics for a few generations until there's no record.

And I wonder... appstores might actually harm preservation, software "lost" in them over time (after few upgrades of the platform), without physical copies...

Generally, I guess future generations will see our computers and software in a similar way we see early sound recordings, films, and their equipment. Which is to say - they will mostly not care.

Although the BBC Micro was never as popular as certain other 8-bit micros primarily because of its price, it still remains the world's best 8-bit micro ever produced by some distance. Its OS, BASIC, keyboard and standard ports were never surpassed by any other 8-bit machine and it was one of the few 8-bit machines that were a pleasure to program on (I never owned a Spectrum, but I can imagine how painful that must have been to write code on).

For nostalgia fans with Android devices, can I point you to Beebdroid: