Trouble logging in?If you can't remember your password or are having trouble logging in, you will have to reset your password. If you have trouble resetting your password (for example, if you lost access to the original email address), please do not start posting with a new account, as this is against the forum rules. If you create a temporary account, please contact us right away via Forum Support, and send us any information you can about your original account, such as the account name and any email address that may have been associated with it.

-So they did cut the OP. Well, that buys them a little time. Hope they use it wisely.

-Kinda wish they'd have cut the scene with Ange in the Golden Land down a bit. It's too late for this kind of lingering development, as important as this scene is. If it was kept to 'hey bitch get your ass back to the game' then we would have more time for the scenes that really count in this episode. Especially since the lack of red makes the scene kinda...

-No Ange's red...I liked the animation in Ange's sacrifice, though the music wasn't very fitting...would have been a lot more emotional with better music, because Satou and Ono both did a very nice job.

-Cut out the whole first half of the tea party. Can't say I didn't see this coming, but it's still a shame to lose it...though I guess, considering they changed almost everyone's deaths in the Anime, it makes more sense this way.

-Dragon!Kinzo was pretty cool, though the blue stakes could have looked more...well...blue...

-And one blue stake is enough to put Beato in such a state?! Dammit, where is the barrage of blue?!

-Endless Nine!! Well, at least they kept ONE godtracks in the scene...liking the remix, though I've liked most of the Anime remixes of songs that were already awesome.

-Extreme lack of red and blue...seriously, I expected it to be trimmed down, but from what I gathered a lot of the red statements were said, just...not in red. Nnngh...

-Okay, Beato being impaled on the spire of blue was AWESOME. I just wish the stakes looked more blue and glowy...they don't seem very representative of the truth, which they should.

-Not enough emotion in the final riddle...fanmade one is much, much better. Still, Thank You For Being Born gets me every time, and Sayaka Ohara > fanmade Beato's voice by far. If there's one reason I won't join the 'Umineko Anime Does Not Exist' bandwagon is because I love all the voices so much. Even with the joke of a script this series got, they managed to do a fantastic job throughout.

-...on second thought...having the emotional ending abbruptly cut by that irritating ending song (no, I don't like the song, and I haven't since episode 1) makes me reconsider the whole 'I won't pretend the Anime doesn't exist' thing I just said...honestly, the artists have gotten their songs plugged for 25 episodes so far...they cut the OP but can't even be bothered to cut the ED?! That's a minute and thirty seconds we could have gotten for the HUG and allowed the emotional impact to settle in!! I know it would have been asking too much to use Discode, but still...DEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEN!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!! !!!!!

-Even ????? was pointless. Yay lesbian loli fanservice. Yeah, I'd totally rather have that instead of my rightful emotional EP4 ending. I wasn't expecting Lambda's red, but they didn't even give us Trollkastel. What the fuck. Why bother animating it at all. Well, at least now I know that by Anime logic, Bern's tail is real. That always bugged me.

That was...more of a disappointment than 24. And somehow I was still holding out hope that it would be just a little better than that, my lowest-rated episode of the series (if only because I didn't start reviewing until after episode 11). I just...I'm raging so much that I can't even effectively put it into words. But what's it matter...the collective VN population has pretty much spoken for my feelings anyways, since before this episode actually aired. I don't really have anything new to say about it. The preview for this episode was better than the episode itself. That's not right. That's just not right, DEEN. Damn you all. Learn your lesson already...please, let there be no season 2, unless by some astronomical chance another studio picks it up. I don't care if they reanimate all of the first series, just let someone else animate (or at least replace Chiaki Kon in) Chiru, or let it not be animated at all...

4/10. And I'm being generous, because the voice acting was well-done, as always. As for you, Studio DEEN, ハブ・ア・ナイス・ドリーム。 シー・ユー・イヌ・ヘル。

Soooo...what's the status on that EP5 patch, Witch-Hunt? I need a nice Christmas present to wash the foul taste of this episode out of my mouth ^^;

Far better than I expected. Especially the voice acting was superb!
The only scene I felt was a bit off was when Beato was impaled before the final riddle. When she said "it hurts" and asked Battler to end it she didn't sound humble at all. I know it's difficult to speak when your mouth is full of blood but she sounded a bit angry/frustrated and not sad in my opinion.

I'm sorry to you people who rated this highly, but what Deen did in this episode is outrageously sloppy. I lack the words to properly describe it.

Spoiler for just the most important part of the series:

The toughest riddle that we've seen, and the final one "solved" in the question arcs...is Nanjo's death in Episode 3. Here is Battler's solution for it in episode 26 (more or less):

Quote:

In the early part of the 3rd game, someone played dead and waited for us to leave!
During the time that this person's death was still unconfirmed by the red, they murdered Nanjo.
Right after that, they died for some reason!
And after that, Eva-Beatrice proclaimed their death in red!

In the anime version, the only death Eva Beatrice ever confirms is Nanjo's.

But it's even worse. For some, unexplainable reason, the anime shows the victims of EP3's first twilight in the background here. Fortunately for Deen, only the VN version confirmed these deaths in red in the beginning of the game, so these are still suspects with the Anime's red text.

However, in that same episode 18, Deen had Beato saying "I've already confirmed their deaths with the red" even though she never actually did. So which is the mistake?

Spoiler for but wait, there's more:

Just that one huge error would be bad enough, but they do the same thing TWO MORE TIMES in this episode.

Ange, from the first part of episode 26:

Quote:

Beatrice said it with the red truth.
Battler Ushiromiya is not Asumu Ushiromiya's son.
*and*
You've declared two red truths.
"Battler is not Asumu's son."
"Only Kinzo's grandchild, Battler, is qualified to be Beato's opponent."

If you've been paying attention, you probably remember that Beatrice never said a single word of red text in episode 24. None of these red truths were said by anyone, ever...in the anime.

Spoiler for EP5 but not a spoiler:

I was seriously annoyed that Beato used only one red text in the entire episode. I mean, come on. She's barely fighting back at all. True, even the VN didn't have her fighting totally seriously, but nothing at all?

And on top of that, because she didn't say one particular line, it is now impossible for Deen to adapt EP5 correctly. I won't go into detail here, but those who have read EP5 probably know what I mean.

This proves that Ryuukishi wasn't overseeing this episode, or if he was, it proves that they didn't listen to him.

__________________

"The only moral it is possible to draw from this story is that one should never throw the letter 'q' into a privet bush. But, unfortunately, there are times when it is unavoidable."
--Hitchhikers

Well it took me until the last episode to learn to watch the episodes before reading the comments in the forum here.
That said, I really like this episode. I really do think they pulled it off well with the amount of time they had left.
I really do hope *someone* animates chiru. Whether it be deen or someone else. (Don't bother arguing me with this)

I imagined the Ange scene to be a lot bloodier. Wasn't she picked to pieces? They made it seem like she melted or something o_o And she wasn't holding his head this time, so it's not like he couldn't see what was happening to her, yet he still did nothing...

I loved it when Beato was like, "Whaat? 'Small Bombs'? LMAO" that part made me giggle. But I really imagined the "Who am I?" scene to be slow and sad, rather than Beato tastelessly throwing up blood everywhere. The scene also ended rather abruptly, it didn't seem like an ending at all.

Watching the anime this past half-year was an enjoyable experience, I look forward to reading Chiru, and hope an anime of that will come someday as well!

Thanks for the episode, Studio DEEN! You have a nice day too~

You are just better off reading the VN, even IF DEEN was able to make Chiru, it would just be a complete failure since they've already screwed it up big time with just Episode 4 alone. I don't think Beatrice and Battlers relationship would even make sense in a Chiru anime since other then the Ep 3 troll, they haven't had any moments together.

SO glad I wasn't the only one thinking that..
Also, what I didn't get, was why did Beato fall back and start crying when Maria was all happy when she got Sakutaro back and was all "Sugoi, sugoi!"
I wanna know, because It looked like Maria likes Ange better than Beato, which makes me sad

I'm sorry to you people who rated this highly, but what Deen did in this episode is outrageously sloppy. I lack the words to properly describe it.

Spoiler for just the most important part of the series:

The toughest riddle that we've seen, and the final one "solved" in the question arcs...is Nanjo's death in Episode 3. Here is Battler's solution for it in episode 26 (more or less):

In the anime version, the only death Eva Beatrice ever confirms is Nanjo's.

But it's even worse. For some, unexplainable reason, the anime shows the victims of EP3's first twilight in the background here. Fortunately for Deen, only the VN version confirmed these deaths in red in the beginning of the game, so these are still suspects with the Anime's red text.

However, in that same episode 18, Deen had Beato saying "I've already confirmed their deaths with the red" even though she never actually did. So which is the mistake?

Spoiler for but wait, there's more:

Just that one huge error would be bad enough, but they do the same thing TWO MORE TIMES in this episode.

Ange, from the first part of episode 26:

If you've been paying attention, you probably remember that Beatrice never said a single word of red text in episode 24. None of these red truths were said by anyone, ever...in the anime.

Spoiler for EP5 but not a spoiler:

I was seriously annoyed that Beato used only one red text in the entire episode. I mean, come on. She's barely fighting back at all. True, even the VN didn't have her fighting totally seriously, but nothing at all?

And on top of that, because she didn't say one particular line, it is now impossible for Deen to adapt EP5 correctly. I won't go into detail here, but those who have read EP5 probably know what I mean.

This proves that Ryuukishi wasn't overseeing this episode, or if he was, it proves that they didn't listen to him.

Chrono, Beato did say more lines in red. But DEEN was so budget-low they only used the red truth sound for it. The same applies for some of Battler's lines.

You are just better off reading the VN, even IF DEEN was able to make Chiru, it would just be a complete failure since they've already screwed it up big time with just Episode 4 alone. I don't think Beatrice and Battlers relationship would even make sense in a Chiru anime since other then the Ep 3 troll, they haven't had any moments together.

I've read the VN... twice...

I think the anime's fine, I don't really get what all the haters are so angry about, I read everything they say and it just seems as if they're trying too hard to make it look bad...

Oh well, I don't care what they all think, I enjoy the anime, I think it's a pretty decent adaption

I'm sorry to you people who rated this highly, but what Deen did in this episode is outrageously sloppy. I lack the words to properly describe it.

Spoiler for just the most important part of the series:

The toughest riddle that we've seen, and the final one "solved" in the question arcs...is Nanjo's death in Episode 3. Here is Battler's solution for it in episode 26 (more or less):

In the anime version, the only death Eva Beatrice ever confirms is Nanjo's.

But it's even worse. For some, unexplainable reason, the anime shows the victims of EP3's first twilight in the background here. Fortunately for Deen, only the VN version confirmed these deaths in red in the beginning of the game, so these are still suspects with the Anime's red text.

However, in that same episode 18, Deen had Beato saying "I've already confirmed their deaths with the red" even though she never actually did. So which is the mistake?

Spoiler for but wait, there's more:

Just that one huge error would be bad enough, but they do the same thing TWO MORE TIMES in this episode.

Ange, from the first part of episode 26:

If you've been paying attention, you probably remember that Beatrice never said a single word of red text in episode 24. None of these red truths were said by anyone, ever...in the anime.

Spoiler for EP5 but not a spoiler:

I was seriously annoyed that Beato used only one red text in the entire episode. I mean, come on. She's barely fighting back at all. True, even the VN didn't have her fighting totally seriously, but nothing at all?

And on top of that, because she didn't say one particular line, it is now impossible for Deen to adapt EP5 correctly. I won't go into detail here, but those who have read EP5 probably know what I mean.

This proves that Ryuukishi wasn't overseeing this episode, or if he was, it proves that they didn't listen to him.

..I like you
I havn't read the VN, I've only seen some parts, and, personally, I thought It was okay, but I like the anime better.

You should probably at least play the entire VN before you're able to decide which you like 'better'. Even if you like the Anime, you pretty much just said for yourself that it's pretty much all you know of the series. I wouldn't go into a 2-hour movie adaptation of a comic book I've only read 2 or 3 pages of and say 'I like this version better' - I'd say 'I like this, though I don't really have anything to compare it to'. Not trying to say your opinion is wrong and that you should hate on the Anime like many of us do, because if you can enjoy it despite all that they've ruined, that's great. But you really can't say you like something 'better' if you haven't fully experienced the source material. It makes no sense.

You should probably at least play the entire VN before you're able to decide which you like 'better'. Even if you like the Anime, you pretty much just said for yourself that it's pretty much all you know of the series. I wouldn't go into a 2-hour movie adaptation of a comic book I've only read 2 or 3 pages of and say 'I like this version better' - I'd say 'I like this, though I don't really have anything to compare it to'. Not trying to say your opinion is wrong and that you should hate on the Anime like many of us do, because if you can enjoy it despite all that they've ruined, that's great. But you really can't say you like something 'better' if you haven't fully experienced the source material. It makes no sense.

Ah, sorry, I wasn't clear enough
I had meant to say that from what I've seen of the VN, I like the Anime versions of the scenes better.
Sorry, I wasn't very clear on what I was saying

I thought this episode was done well. Though I think they could've removed the ending song for 2 reasons.,because I've never really liked the song,but that doesn't matter much. And 2, To,ya know, make some scenes longer.And they should've added the Beato and Battler hug in there. And add Trollkastel.

Although the anime doesn't reach up to VN's level (quite impossible anyway, not fully blaming DEEN for that) I'm glad this got animated. Even with the flaws it had I enjoyed watching it and seeing the characters voiced. Yeah, maybe another studio or director would've done a better job with it but at least it got animated, with the anime around more people will start reading the VN too and that makes the community bigger.