zhutou wrote:i will throw up if cliff lee starts the asg. it has to be halladay.

I won't, because I can actually see the argument behind Lee starting. He's pitched very well over the last 3 months.

However, I do agree that it should be Halladay, partly because he is a "star" and a far more recognizable figure than Lee, his long track record of success, and also because of his lead in the categories I mentioned. 7 CG at the AS break is an absolutely insane pace considering what pitching has become. The last time anybody got even more than 10 in the majors was in 1999 with Randy Johnson (12).

He doesn't deserve it. His numbers sure as hell dont justify him being the SP in the ASG. Yeah, hes got a nice ERA, but he has half the saves Krod does and guys like Lee and Halliday are putting together far more impressive seasons... Just cause hes a Yankee it shouldnt mean anything.

I think it would be a fantastic idea... it would be a cool way to honor a classy HOF pitcher in the final season at Yankee stadium and it would generate a ton of interest for a game that a lot of people simply don't care about it. I understand what people are saying about wanting Mariano to close out the game, but there's a huge possibility that opportunity doesn't happen. To pull if off, Francona would have to state explicitly that it will be a one-inning deal no matter what, but I don't see the problem there.

All that said, it'll never happen... and since it won't, it should be Cliff Lee in my opinion. Halladay is almost as good a choice and I bet he'll get the nod, and Duchscherer has a pretty good argument himself, so there's no wrong answer there.

"The government cannot give to anyone anything that it does not first take from someone else"

Bobbleheadrusty wrote:He doesn't deserve it. His numbers sure as hell dont justify him being the SP in the ASG. Yeah, hes got a nice ERA, but he has half the saves Krod does...

Why was Krod even brought into this conversation? Mo's ERA is lower than Krod's WHIP, and he has more K's in fewer IP than Frankie. So what if he only has 2/3 the number of saves? He's yet to blow one.

I wouldn't mind at all seeing Halladay, Lee, or Mo in the first. They've all been tremendous so far this year, and a case can be made for all 3.

Just cause hes a Yankee it shouldnt mean anything.

That's not what Francona thinks. Otherwise he never would have mentioned it as a scenario.

As for the fact that he shouldn't start because he's a Yankee, I don't know. The home team always makes certain concessions with their own guys, and when their own guy is the best relief pitcher in baseball (aside from the save cat, that is...) this year (and arguably ever), I wouldn't be opposed to it in the least.