We Need Your Help, Shape The Future of Hearing Aids With Your Input Find Out More

Which? Survey, NHS vs Private High Street Hearing Aid Retailers

Written by Geoffrey Cooling

Updated December 11, 2018Published December 11, 2018

Satisfaction With High Street Retailers High, But NHS Not Far Behind

Which surveyed hearing aid users in April 2018 to compare satisfaction rates of people provided services by the NHS and by private High Street retailers such as Boots, Specsavers, Hidden Hearing and Amplifon. The results were interesting, to say the least, and overall; private retailers pipped the NHS generally. The only area that was dramatically different was in the hearing aid questions. People were overall much happier with private hearing aids. The survey raises questions about what consumers are looking for as well, let's take a look.

The Survey

Which? surveyed members who have recently got a hearing aid via the NHS or bought hearing aids from a private provider. They asked questions that covered the entire process and asked them to rate their experience. The results reveal that overall satisfaction with hearing aid providers is high among UK consumers, whether they use the NHS or go private. Of 3,183 Which? members surveyed, the total average satisfaction score was 84%.

Which? reported that there was not a significant difference in overall satisfaction between those paying privately (88%) compared with those who got their hearing aids from the NHS (84% ) and those for whom the NHS paid to go privately through the Any Qualified Provider scheme (75% satisfaction score). But I think that is a pretty strong spread and statistically significant. For me, it appears that the NHS and Private providers are similar while the AQP scheme lags significantly behind. As I said, the most significant differences in answers were all to do with the hearing aids provided as you can see below

NHS hearing aids vs privately bought hearing aids

NHS

Private sector

Waiting times

78%

95%

Cleanliness of hearing test facilities

96%

98%

Comfort of hearing test facilities

86%

90%

Level of privacy

96%

98%

Professionalism and knowledge of staff

93%

95%

Dealing with questions or concerns

91%

95%

Clarity of written and verbal information provided

89%

93%

Thoroughness of examination/ testing

94%

96%

overall customer service

92%

95%

Range of hearing aids offered

23%

84%

Appearance of the hearing aids

72%

95%

Comfort of the hearing aids

75%

92%

Extent to which the hearing aid/s suited you

74%

91%

Replacing lost or damaged aids

88%

90%

Dealing with repairs

87%

92%

Ease of booking follow-up appointments

78%

95%

Continuity of care (e.g. seeing the same audiologist)

48%

88%

Follow-up serv1ce

74%

92%

Overall price

N/A

72%

Value for money

N/A

75%

The Hearing Aid Questions

Hearing aids provided was really where the difference between NHS and private showed up. While I wasn't surprised by the difference in satisfaction in either the answers to the range or appearance questions, I was surprised by the answers to the answers to the comfort and extent of suitability responses. I expected them to be pretty level. Some of that could be explained by the fact that NHS users weren't satisfied with what was offered, therefore their feelings about comfort and suitability were swayed.

Up to 84% of private customers rated the range of aids as above average in the private sector, compared with just 23% of NHS patients. While customers can access the same hearing aid brands on the NHS as they can by buying privately (not the latest models). The NHS does not offer a choice of different models. Interestingly enough, where people could name the brand of hearing aids that the NHA had provided, they didn't really differ between the NHS or private. The bulk of the aids were Phonak, Oticon or Signia.

Having said all of that, the satisfaction rates that were achieved by private retailers also have a story to tell. For instance, why was the range of hearing aids provided only met with an 84% satisfaction rate? That surprised me considering that many of the high streets would offer a full range of models from many of the leading hearing aid brands. What more where the consumers looking for? I would dearly love to know the answer to that question.

If you like what you see, share it so others can benefit

Geoffrey Cooling

Co Foundergeoff@audiologyengine.comGeoffrey (Geoff, anything else makes him nervous) Cooling is an Irish hearing aid blogger and has been involved with the hearing aid industry for over ten years. He has worked in private practice dispensing hearing aids and as a manufacturer's rep. He has written two books and they are both available on Amazon. He loves technology, passing on knowledge and is legendary for many other things, primarily the amount he curses, his dry and mischievous sense of humour and his complete intolerance of people who are full of themselves. Please feel free to connect with him

ReSound LiNX Quattro™

Rediscover The Joy Of Good Music, Expand your world with an unmatched quality of sound

Trial the new LiNX Quattro at your local Amplifon centre in the UK now

Rate this article

Search Blog

Confused about buying a hearing aid?

Looking for clear, no-nonsense advice on hearing aids, their technology levels, features, pros and cons? We might have the book for you, purchase the Little Book of Hearing Aids on Amazon. The only hearing aid Buying guide you will ever need.

About The Authors

Hearing Aid Know is written by Steve Claridge and Geoffrey Cooling. Steve has been wearing hearing aids
for over thirty years and Geoff is a veteran of the audiology industry. Together they give a holistic
view of the hearing aid industry and the equipment available from both sides of the fence.

Looking For Hearing Aids or A Hearing Test?

Hearing Aid Know

We deliver clear independent advice on hearing aids, hearing aid technology and hearing aid types combined with honest advice on who's good at providing them. We aren't tied, contracted or obligated to any hearing aid company or hearing aid manufacturer.

Steve has been wearing hearing aids for over thirty years and Geoff is a veteran of the hearing aid industry. Together they have a vast knowledge of hearing aids and the people that provide them.

Advertising

Company Address

We use cookies to improve your customer experience on this website by recognizing your browser and capturing certain information. By clicking “Got It!” or further navigating this site, you allow Hearing Aid Know and associated third parties the placement of cookies. Learn More