Young: To Be? No, Not to Be

Friday, August 25, 2017
| 783
| 0
| 0 min read

A bill to reform the $120 million Return to Work Fund is dead for this year.

Julius Young

The bill, AB 553 (carried by Democrat Tom Daly of Anaheim), will become a “two-year bill,” meaning it may resurface next year. This week’s scheduled Senate appropriations hearing on the bill was canceled.

The bill was designed to address the fact that the $120 million fund has been underutilized. This fund, one of the components of the 2012 SB 863 reforms, was established as a sweetener to get some unions off the fence and on board with the reform package. The RTW Fund is meant to give extra aid to workers with disproportionately large earnings losses.

Implementation of the program took a long time, and the DWC relied on a Rand study of various methodologies to distribute the funds garnered from employer assessments. Publicity and outreach to launch the program was anemic.

While participation rates have been rising, the fund is distributing $5,000 RTW payments to workers who apply and have received a supplemental job displacement benefits voucher. But the RTW Fund is still distributing far less than $120 million per year.

This was the subject of an inquiry by Democratic state Sen. Tony Mendoza, and a study was done by Department of Industrial Relations staff for presentation at the March 24 Commission on Health and Safety and Workers' Compensation meeting. More information about the status of the RTW Fund can be found in the minutes of that meeting.

In March 2017, CHSWC voted to approve the draft report on the RTW Fund and also voted to approve a plan for CHSWC to develop a contracted study of the fund.

Proponents of AB 553 see no reason why whatever balance of the $120 million is left in the fund each year could not be parceled out to those who qualified.

But obviously the bill is not supported by the powers that be at the DIR/Division of Workers' Compensation.

What better way to kill a bill than through an unfriendly cost analysis? The Department of Finance estimates large extra staffing costs that would appear to be questionable.

The analysis by the Department of Finance also notes that, “In addition, the allocation of additional benefits on a pro-rata basis would bear no relationship to a worker’s actual loss of earnings, which is inconsistent with the purpose of the program.”

This statement makes no sense, since the methodology of the current program (as recommended by Rand) is already on an arbitrary, fixed, $5,000-per-worker basis. Apparently Rand and the DWC settled on this amount rather than establishing a distribution methodology, which would be more complicated. So if the current methodology is not tied to individualized wage loss, what is the problem with distributing any unused portion of the $120 million fund in the same fashion?

This is an issue that will linger until more of the RTW Fund is utilized or until another administration decides to fulfill the original spirit of the program. Keep in mind that those eligible for the fund tend to be the more severely injured in the system and must be unable to return to their former work.

Julius Young is a claimants' attorney for the Boxer & Gerson law firm in Oakland. This column was reprinted with his permission from his blog, www.workerscompzone.com.

Comments

Be the first to comment.

Related Articles

Today's Round Up

12/14/2017 |
54 |
0 |
0 min read

Claims administration services will need to score better in 2018 than they did this year to pass the initial stage of annual audits and avoid a more stringent review of claim files.
The Division of Workers’ Compensation said the Profile Audit Review performance standard for 2018 will be 1.47573, down from the PAR standard of 1.47885 in 2017.
Claims administrators that receive a score equal to or less than the standard set by the division will be required to pay any outstanding compensation but will not face administrative penalties. Shops that score higher will be subject to .
Read More

12/14/2017 |
18 |
0 |
min read

The rate of occupational injuries and illnesses dropped 14.3% from 2015 to 2016, the Utah Labor Commission’s Occupational Safety and Health Division announced.
The agency said the overall combined incidence rate in the public and private sectors fell to three injuries or illnesses per 100 workers in 2016, from 3.5 in 2015.
Private sector employees drove most of the decrease. The occupational injury rate among them fell to 2.9%, from 3.5% in 2015.
The decrease was smaller in the public sector, where the incidence rate fell to 3.6%, from 3.8% in 2015.
The Occupational Safety .
Read More

12/14/2017 |
18 |
0 |
min read

Despite their best efforts to uncover the root causes, officials in Montana are unable to explain the state’s high workplace injury rate, according to a report by the Billings Gazette.
The occupational injury and illness rate in 2016 dropped to 4.2 per 100 workers, from 4.3 in 2015. But the state still ranks behind only Washington, Vermont and Maine.
Eric Strauss, administrator for the Employment Relations Division of the Department of Labor and Industry, said the agency has tried to determine whether there is something driving the higher rate of injuries in Montana, to no avail.
.
Read More

12/14/2017 |
15 |
0 |
min read

Oregon Gov. Kate Brown on Wednesday appointed Cameron Smith as the director of the Department of Consumer and Business Services, the parent agency of the Workers' Compensation Division and Board.
Cameron Smith
If confirmed by the Senate, Smith will replace Patrick Allen, who left DCBS in August to become the director of the Oregon Health Authority.
Smith is now director of the Oregon Department of Veterans’ Affairs, a position he has held since 2013. From 2009 to 2013, Smith served as senior policy adviser to Govs. John Kitzhaber and Ted Kulongoski, managing a portfoli.
Read More

12/13/2017 |
132 |
0 |
0 min read

Erie Insurance has promoted Dionne Wallace Oakley to executive vice president of human resources and strategy, the carrier said in a press release.
Dionne Wallace Oakley
Wallace Oakley’s role will expand to include oversight of “several strategic functions,” the carrier said.
Wallace Oakley joined Erie Insurance in 2011 as vice president of human resources business partners, following a 22-year career at State Farm where her responsibilities included commercial lines service, personal lines underwriting, auto claims, corporate public affairs, agent recruiting and human r.
Read More