Are the premier XL's just as succeptable to the re-boot problem as the Elite/XL4?

I need to upgrade my HD unit which just died, the power won't turn on. I wanted to get another premier or elite. So this a good time. I am just concerned about the issues I keep reading about Elite/XL4 units.

Am I way off base thinking the premier XL is more stable than the Elite/XL4?

My Premiere XL was a flaky beast with reboot problems, my Elite has never rebooted unless requested, in fact my Elite has been the most reliable and best performing Tivo I have had since I came to the flock in 2000

__________________"There is a distinct difference between having an open mind and having a hole in your head from which your brain leaks out."

You know it would be helpful if people that respond provide some info on their set up. In reading about this issue it seems that the tuning adapter seems to be in the mix and a system like FIOS without an adapter seems to be problem free. So it would helpful if people indicated the system and whether they have a tuning adapter.

Quote:

Originally Posted by dianebrat

My Premiere XL was a flaky beast with reboot problems, my Elite has never rebooted unless requested, in fact my Elite has been the most reliable and best performing Tivo I have had since I came to the flock in 2000

My Fios based (No adapter) Premeire XL has been problem free. All HDMI connections for output. It was a significant improvement in stability over the HD it replaced.

My Comcast connected TPXL has also been problem free and i have a 2Tb drive upgrade installed. I should note that I only use the SDUI and that may make a difference in anybody's re-boot problems. (no tuneing adapter)

You know it would be helpful if people that respond provide some info on their set up. In reading about this issue it seems that the tuning adapter seems to be in the mix and a system like FIOS without an adapter seems to be problem free. So it would helpful if people indicated the system and whether they have a tuning adapter.

I am running Fios with no adapter and I do not use any of the online or streaming features I have a Roku for Netflix, HBO Go, etc...

I have two TiVo Premiere units, one upgrade to 1TB and the other upgraded to 2TB drives with M-cards on Comcast in the Bay Area with no SVD. I have had zero problems with either one. I received the first Premiere right when they came out and the second about 9 months ago. No complaints here.

I just purchased a TiVo XL4 (Elite) this weekend on sale; couldn't resist.

I also have two TiVo HDs and previously had a Series3. When I did have problems in the past, one ended up being RMA'd and that fixed the flaky issues. The others have all been rock solid. I haven't owned a TiVo that I didn't uprade the hard disk in, maybe that helps in some way? I do know I have had low signal which caused problems like pixelation and hanging that appeared TiVo related, but ultimately weren't. I agree with others, have your signals checked and make sure they are clean across the range.

I will be selling my two Tivo Lifetime Series3 HDs (500GB and 1TB upgraded drives) now and going all in on Premiere and hoping the streaming box works out.

Is anyone getting Elite reboots who does not have MoCA internet connection? Mine reboots when you change or add or backup season passes at the Tivo.com site, and I'm thinking it is Internet related. I've had two spontaneous reboots while just watching something too and don't know what kind of background activitiy might have been going on.

I had 3XLs and an Elite. FiOS. Not a single problem with any of the XLs, but the Elite was a nightmare. Pixellation, reboots, freezing, constant complaining about signal strength. I returned the Elite at 29 days and bought a 4th XL.

3 months later, and not a single spurious reboot on any of the XLs. I have had a freeze happen 4 times in that period of time, across 3 different machines. I'll live with that until the fix all of the problems that Elite has.