Jess is officially ready for love — with Nick! — in this Tuesday’s New Girl (Fox, 9/8c), but there’s just one gorgeous problem: Odette Annable.

As TVLine first reported, the House alumna visits Girl as Nick’s new bar boss who decides she just must have a one-night stand with her employee. Not knowing that Jess is finally acknowledging her feelings for him, Nick decides to do the deed because… well, it’s Odette Annable!