"I've actually fought for both," Harrison says of both the old and new scenarios. "Can we go back to somebody who's an unknown? My theory is yes, we can do it."

"It would have to be a good story. But I also walk the fence and subscribe to the theory of, 'When you show up, you know Ali and you're invested. Whether you love her or you hate her, you're vested and you're going to watch.'"

"On the other hand, I just want to get someone new, break the cycle!"

What do you think? Will Chris have a change of heart and become the star of The Bachelor? Or will the Cape Codder happily go back to his normal life instead? Would you prefer he do that and the show pick a new star for once?