…While staking out a hotel room suspected of hosting prostitution activity, local police observed Mason [Ohio] Councilman Rich Cox entering and, about 15 minutes later, leaving. Surprise, surprise, Mason Police Chief Ron Ferrell said he does not expect charges to be filed against Councilman Cox…somehow I suspect that not everyone in Cox’s circumstances would get such fair treatment from the city police…the councilman offered up an astoundingly far-fetched explanation for what he was doing at the hotel…[he said that] “he visited the [hotel]…to pass a note to a Chinese woman whose father he met at a nearby Verizon Wireless store…[because] the man’s car was broken down“…

In the US, this would be called a “trafficking circuit”, Queenstown would be called a “hub” and the reporter would interview cops talking about how “pimps” make all the arrangements because women are too stupid to do that for ourselves. But in New Zealand:

Queenstown is the adventure sport capital of New Zealand. But as the tourist numbers swell during the ski season, so do the stag parties, boy’s weekends, corporate retreats, and international business meetings. As a result, the city has developed a largely hidden yet hugely profitable sex industry…Jasmine tours New Zealand’s South Island throughout the year, but spends most of her time in the mountain town…she is one of the longest-staying sex workers in Queenstown. “Most of the girls book a room for about five days,” explained Alice, a receptionist at a bustling motel in town. “Jasmine stays for longer because she’s so busy”…July to October and December to March [are] the busiest periods. The seasons on either side are so dead that girls working in strip clubs can make as little as $50 a night, and escorts…often make nothing at all. During this time, Jasmine drives to towns like Nelson, where she…has regular customers who guarantee her income…The women say the quiet months are worth it though, as they more than make up for it during the busy ski season…

Bad enough that they’re isolated by race, culture and language and, worse, stigmatized by a false human trafficking narrative, but they’re also endangered unjustly by the Harper government’s anti-prostitution laws. Now those working legally in Canada say they’re being further victimized, dealing with constant police harassment, illegal detention and invasion of privacy…Elene Lam…is the face of Butterfly, the Asian and Migrant Sex Workers Network, established last fall to advocate for the rights of Asian women in the trade. The group’s mission includes countering the myths that…have been perpetuated by the…”rescue industry”…even before the new law was introduced, police had been intimidating legal sex workers…in…operation…Northern Spotlight, plainclothes officers…posed as clients and…bullied [sex workers] as they pretended to rescue them. For Asian sex workers, who may not speak English and have no reason to trust police, these recent warrant-less incursions into their homes and workplaces are especially frightening…

A new study out of the University of California Los Angeles suggests porn addiction does not exist. Researchers found that people who said they had trouble controlling their consumption of pornography did not show a typical addiction response to sexual images. With addiction, increased brain activity is expected in response to relevant stimuli—heroin in the case of a drug addict, for example. But the porn study’s participants showed decreased brain activity in response to pornography…This builds on a previous study conducted by the same researchers in which they found no connection between the extent of participants’ pornography problems and their brain responses to sexual images…

A South Florida cop is accused of pulling a lesbian couple over [without even a pretext], taking one of them into custody and ordering her to undress as he rubbed his penis…”[He asked me] how do I have intercourse, and I told him, ‘Why do I need to answer that? Why is that necessary?’ He insisted me to answer it”…the [17-year-old] victim said. “After, he asked if I was a virgin…[and] if if I had any diseases”…The woman explained that she…followed the officer’s orders out of fear…[and] believed that she was going to be raped…[when she protested he] said “Oh, I thought you wanted to fuck”…The cop…has been identified as…Jesus Menocal, Jr., the son of a recently retired police chief…who was caught on video during the 1980s plotting a cocaine rip-off…Menocal’s grandmother…said there was no way he would order a female to strip because he was once named “officer of the year”…

They pimped me for a while, six months or so…Later on, I was trafficked by other men…Pimps are very good at torture, they’re very good at manipulation…When people describe prostitution as being something that is glamorous, elegant, like in the story of Pretty Woman, well that doesn’t come close to it. A prostitute might sleep with five strangers a day…These are not relationships, no-one’s bringing me any flowers here, trust me on that. They’re using my body like a toilet. And the johns – the clients – are violent. I’ve been shot five times, stabbed 13 times. I don’t know why those men attacked me, all I know is that society made it comfortable for them to do so…on 1 April 1997, when I was nearly 40 years old, a customer threw me out of his car. My dress got caught in the door and he dragged me six blocks along the ground, tearing all the skin off my face and the side of my body. I went to the County Hospital in Chicago…emergency room…they gave me a bus pass to go to a place called Genesis House, which was run by an awesome Englishwoman named Edwina Gateley, who became a great hero and mentor for me. She helped me turn my life around…I stayed almost two years…

I believe that Powell was a streetwalker, and even that she had a few bad pimps; what reveals her story as propaganda is its absolutism. All the pimps were evil and controlling, though in real life more than half aren’t; all the clients are abusive and “used her body like a toilet” (a classic prohibitionist slur); all sex work is equated with street work, though every street worker I’ve ever spoken to knows that isn’t so. And of course there’s the classic car-dragging tale; let Powell produce her medical records (it should be easy enough, given that she knows the exact date and hospital) and I’ll believe her. Otherwise, I call bullshit; it’s pretty obvious that part of her two-year stay at Genesis House was the usual prohibitionist brainwashing sessions, including lessons in “reframing experiences”.

…while working at Scarlett’s Cabaret in Pembroke Park [Florida, Adonay Encarnacion]…got fed up. Her frustration fueled a fight that could now result in a $6 million settlement, after a collective action involving 4,709 dancers who worked at three Scarlett’s cabarets. “They treated us like employees when it was convenient to them and like independent contractors when it was convenient to them…If they were going to treat us like employees, then they needed to be paying us minimum wage and overtime”…Katherine Koster works for the Sex Workers Outreach Project, an organization that advocates for the human rights of sex workers and aims to raise awareness on the negative impact of their criminal status in the U.S…”Disorganized labor markets are fertile ground for the sort of labor practices that victimize low-income and marginalized female workers,” Koster said. “Most of them…just don’t really know that they have rights”…

…I believe that the eroticization of trans bodies and the resulting homophobia from the rejection of that body are the primary drivers of many instances of…anti-transgender violence…Sabrina Rubin Erdely’s claim in…Rolling Stone that…“no community living in America today is as openly terrorized as transgender women” is correct…questioning of a trans woman’s gender identity leads the questioner to their subjective identification of a trans woman as a man. If the questioner is a heterosexual cisgender man, the reaction that follows the initial eroticization is one of visceral disgust as he sexually rejects the “man” he sees in the trans woman’s place. The transphobia and anti-transgender violence that follows are inherently political acts, meant to discipline the trans woman for attracting the male gaze in the first place…eros to thanatos, lust into vengeful rage…

A different kind of “video game” designed to profit from sex workers (and in this case, our clients) without giving us anything in return. This one’s especially revolting for its badge-licking subtext, but there are many in the genre.

Two men [are] on a cross-country bike ride…to bring awareness about a serious issue…Mike Rutter and George Cook…started…in Santa Monica California on May 24…When it gets tough, Cook says they think about why they are riding. “The more uncomfortable the day, the more we realize about the discomfort of the girls being human trafficked and sexually exploited,” said Cook…It’s part of Bright Hope’s “Break the Chains Cycling Tour”…Rutter [said] “It’s like a mission. I feel like a Navy Seal…The girls we are trying to do this for, they don’t have a choice what’s happening to them that day so we’re going to plow ahead”…

…a woman…[climbed] the flagpole at the South Carolina Statehouse…removed the Confederate flag, and then returned to the ground where she was [arrested]…Many believe that Bree Newsome was courageous for her act…however someone who claims to know her stated that she did it all for fame and to show off her ex-stripper skills…

12 Responses

I’m in Newcastle (a couple of hours north) and just checked the classifieds in my local newspaper. All the quoted hourly rates are between A$120 and A$160 (US$90 to US$120) for full service. That applies to both brothels and independents. I also looked up a few websites of local high class escorts and while they tend to charge in the US$300-400 range I’m pretty sure they represent a small proportion of the market.

Maybe there’s some very exclusive escorts bringing the average up and maybe the ones who advertise their rates are all at the bottom of the market but I still find the claim of a US$340/h average hard to credit.

For that study, if I remember, they used only data from profiles in one international (unnamed) website for escorts. So it’s very high rates and not representative. For example, Montreal’s actual prices for agencies are 200/h (not so far off their 220). But anything above 200 is a minority and there are a lot of much cheaper online ads.

The title of the chart should not be ”one hour with a female prostitute”, but ”one hour with an escort advertising on site XYZ”. You can’t even generalize by countries, because people from different places may not be using that kind of website in the same proportion (the average of the high-end may not be proportional to the averages for the rest of the market).

Incidentally, if we assume the changes are somewhat representative, the trend in the graph is not so different from the one for high-quality IT consulting by independents and small companies here, including the slight improvement last year. This may be a more general trend in markets that sell services and have low base costs besides wages.

That would be yet another indicator that sex work is just regular work.

If the data is meaningful, I suppose it could also be a case of “end demand” in action — if police activity is driving away customers, escorts may be competing harder for customers by offering lower prices.

But as the name implies, “end demand” is intended to affect demand by reducing it. If it were successful at that (a big assumption), it would be the demand curve that shifts, and in a direction that reduces the clearing price.

The error people make is they think of this as one homogenous market being policed uniformly. Complete enforcement is impossible so it is targetted to the most undesirable parts of sex work. What this means is that clients are ”scared” away from some type of providers and will look for the safer options. The clients don’t go away, they just go to those that are less targetted by the police.

When there is a new law or enforcement strategy, people will be unsure for a while, but the market quickly recalibrates and whatever small initial deterrence effect they had soon disappears. In Sweden prices for foreign providers are said to have gone down because of enforcement, but Swedish-born escorts are able to charge higher, because they are seen as more safe for clients.

From the New Zealand story:Antonia and Jasmine say they both choose to work in Queenstown because the clients are nicer than in the rest of the country. “Ninety-five percent of people are good” says Jasmine, but adds that making friends with local police has helped her when clients have tried to skip out without paying.

This is the essence of decriminalization; that state agents don’t have to be the enemy of the people peacefully going about their business.

Regarding the “Simultaneous Having and Eating of Cake” story, I get the impression that you regard the club as trying to have their cake and eat it too by treating the dancers as both contractors and employees. But to me it seems the other way around.

There are of course some real abuses by those clubs (e.g. harassment) but the complaints about the cash flow ring hollow to me. Almost all of the money spent by customers goes straight to the dancers, so how else could the club keep operating unless the dancers pay the operating costs? Where else would the money come from for the real estate costs, sound system, D.J., advertising, security, and so on?

Would the dancers really prefer an employment model? Say one where the customers pay the cashier for the dances and the house uses the money to pay all its operating expenses, including a fixed hourly wage for the dancers? Because that’s how most businesses with employees work. I don’t tip the mechanic who changes the oil in my car, I just pay the shop.

The club owners may be dicks, but it seems to me the dancers took the club’s deal for years, and now they want to go back on their agreement and try to squeeze the club for more money. They ate their cake, and now they want more.

Whorish Media

Maggie on Twitter

Boring but necessary legal stuff

All original content on this website (i.e. all of my columns, pages and anything else which I write myself) is protected under international copyright law as of the time it is posted; though you may link to it as you please or quote passages (as long as you attribute the quote to me), please do not reproduce whole columns without my express written permission. In other words, you have to say "pretty please with sugar on top" first, and then wait for me to say "okey-dokey".