Geoff Johns is now head of DC and he loves MOTU--so what the hell are we waiting for?

If this is your first visit, be sure to
check out the FAQ by clicking the
link above. You may have to register
before you can post: click the register link above to proceed. To start viewing messages,
select the forum that you want to visit from the selection below.

Geoff Johns is now head of DC and he loves MOTU--so what the hell are we waiting for?

DCCollector - Now that Geoff Johns is Chief Creative Officer, does he get to approve sculpts and kind of give direction for the license or is that done by someone else?

Mattel - Geoff is a huge fan of Mattel product (he and Toy Guru are actually good friends and they will often chat at conventions on all things DC and toy related!). In his new role at DC, he can have the final say in approvals, but Geoff does not handle day-to-day approvals. We have had him over to Mattel a few times and he has had some fantastic input to share. He is a great guy to work with and very creative. (He also really loves MOTU!)

Geoff Johns loves Mattel product and MOTU. And he's good friends with Toyguru! Seems like this is the perfect opportunity to get a new MOTU book on the stands!

Or at least some mini-comics with the figures!

Now keep in mind DC's contract with Mattel expires in 2012 (as stated in the link above. It's one of the questions!), so Mattel could be waiting to re-negotiate their deal with DC Comics. Comics could be part of that new deal, if nothing can be done right now.

I'd rather Geoff Johns stay as far from the MOTU property as possible. Otherwise we'll get people punching eachother's guts out in full detail, murder, rape and drugs. I know some people love this stuff, but I don't feel it belongs in the MOTU setting.

I'd rather Geoff Johns stay as far from the MOTU property as possible. Otherwise we'll get people punching eachother's guts out in full detail, murder, rape and drugs. I know some people love this stuff, but I don't feel it belongs in the MOTU setting.

Just because it happens in DC, doesn't mean Mattel would ever let it happen in MOTUC. I can't see more than a few stabs or cuts and bruises in MOTU-Related comics.

I brought this up on another thread somewhere, when Geoff mentioned in an interview he would love to write a MOTU series. I have to agree I can't understand for the life of me why Mattel isn't moving on this. Geoff is one of the hottest writers in comics right now, as well as writing episodes for shows like Smallville. Even a mini series written by him would be huge in terms of exposure.

I didn't know about Geoff's friendship with Scott, though. It's a really good idea to strike while the iron is hot in my opinion. If they truly want to grow the brand more, I think this is one of their the best opportunities.

If nothing is being planned now it's because both Scott and Geoff are busy with bigger projects.

Neither of them, especially Geoff for obvious reasons, has MOTU as a priority. Yes, Mattycollector is TG's baby, but the Green Lantern movie products are the biggest potential money-makers TG is working on, and I would think that that is going to be the focus of their working relationship (along with DCUC, Imaginext (if TG is even involved with that line), DCIH, JLU, and Retro-Action).

I hope we get a huge surprise at SDCC with the announcement of comics (I say comicS because there is no reason they couldn't do a She-Ra series separately.. it would sell as well).

It's gotten to the point where I've simply told my comic book guy to put in my box anything Johns writes. I haven't done that with anyone since 7th grade with Ron Lim.

Originally Posted by Mr_Yuck

I have to agree I can't understand for the life of me why Mattel isn't moving on this.

I would imagine they are. Just because we haven't heard about it doesn't mean it's not happening. However it is true that Geoff's DC duties and ToyGuru's GL movie and general DC duties are understandably their top priorities, when two geek friends get together nothing can stop them from talking about toys they love, so they may be developing an entire comic series without even realizing it!

I think this is fantastic news! If Johns does indeed love MotU, then maybe he also wants to see a new comic like we do.

Now, as much as I do love, LOVE Johns' writing, I do hope that if a book were to be produced, it would be written by Val & drawn by Emiliano. Imho, no one else gets MotU like those two fine gentleman. Those books are the epitome of what I love about He-Man, Skeletor and everything Masters.

Now, as much as I do love, LOVE Johns' writing, I do hope that if a book were to be produced, it would be written by Val & drawn by Emiliano. Imho, no one else gets MotU like those two fine gentleman. Those books are the epitome of what I love about He-Man, Skeletor and everything Masters.

Amen. I've liked some of John's stuff, but not all. Val and Emiliano understand what makes MOTU work better than anyone I've seen.

Of course, it all depends on whether or not DC is interested in licensing the property from Mattel to begin with. And you'd need to convince DC that Teela doesn't need skin tight party pants and a leather jacket...

"I will use this power for all the good that can be done, to work for peace, to encourage virtue, and above all, to preserve life in all its forms..." Superman

Amen. I've liked some of John's stuff, but not all. Val and Emiliano understand what makes MOTU work better than anyone I've seen.

Of course, it all depends on whether or not DC is interested in licensing the property from Mattel to begin with. And you'd need to convince DC that Teela doesn't need skin tight party pants and a leather jacket...

What Geoff Johns does well is taking nostalgia and history - lining it all up and making it work together - while updating it for new fans.

I agree that a lot of the stuff he has done has been more controversial, but that is what comic book fans want. No matter what you say - Blackest Night has been one of the best things that has happened for DC Comics in a while (for the whole DC Universe). If you agree with it or not the guy has done some amazing things for DC.

I would love to hear comments from someone who can say they actually regularly collected all DC titles every week like I did. I had every DC issue pulled for years. I have seen the changes and can account for most of them. I have also seen how fans have upped their DC pulls since Geoff Johns has taken more control.

In Midwinter, the heat from the oven baking my Shrinky Dinks is all I need!

I'd rather Geoff Johns stay as far from the MOTU property as possible. Otherwise we'll get people punching eachother's guts out in full detail, murder, rape and drugs. I know some people love this stuff, but I don't feel it belongs in the MOTU setting.

Drugs have already happened in a few episodes of MOTU. A little violence is ok. I could do without rape though.

What Geoff Johns does well is taking nostalgia and history - lining it all up and making it work together - while updating it for new fans.

I agree that a lot of the stuff he has done has been more controversial, but that is what comic book fans want. No matter what you say - Blackest Night has been one of the best things that has happened for DC Comics in a while (for the whole DC Universe). If you agree with it or not the guy has done some amazing things for DC.

I would love to hear comments from someone who can say they actually regularly collected all DC titles every week like I did. I had every DC issue pulled for years. I have seen the changes and can account for most of them. I have also seen how fans have upped their DC pulls since Geoff Johns has taken more control.

Oh, I'm not arguing that he's done great things for DC. I mean, considering that DC is run by a real... well. Let's say "idiot", Johns is probably the best pick to promote the comics in a good direction.

I'm just saying that there's no real indication he'd write a good MOTU comic, since most his stuff is pretty average. He's mostly the 2000 version of Dan Jurgens, a writer who's incredibly profilic and called in to "fix" titles, drawing lots of fans. But it's not stuff that will be remrembered as masterpieces in 10 years.

I'd rather Geoff Johns stay as far from the MOTU property as possible. Otherwise we'll get people punching eachother's guts out in full detail, murder, rape and drugs. I know some people love this stuff, but I don't feel it belongs in the MOTU setting.

I dunno why people are so gung-ho to see Johns handle something like this...

He's a very uneven writer, Blackest Night was pretty bad, and Brightest Day is too. His Flash title is as well, and he writes the worst Batman ever.

Oh, I'm not arguing that he's done great things for DC. I mean, considering that DC is run by a real... well. Let's say "idiot", Johns is probably the best pick to promote the comics in a good direction.

I'm just saying that there's no real indication he'd write a good MOTU comic, since most his stuff is pretty average. He's mostly the 2000 version of Dan Jurgens, a writer who's incredibly profilic and called in to "fix" titles, drawing lots of fans. But it's not stuff that will be remrembered as masterpieces in 10 years.

Wow, and people say I have strong opinions...

I couldn't be any further on the opposite side of the spectrum from this.

Can I ask you, why you feel Johns' stuff is so bad? What, IYO, was so bad about BN and BD?

I'd rather Geoff Johns stay as far from the MOTU property as possible. Otherwise we'll get people punching eachother's guts out in full detail, murder, rape and drugs. I know some people love this stuff, but I don't feel it belongs in the MOTU setting.

I doubt he'd bring drugs into MOTU. How exactly would that work anyway? Besides, not nearly everything that Johns writes has all that stuff. In fact, I can't recall the last thing that Johns wrote, that had rape in it.

Historically, "tie-ins" are not very profitable to the larger comic companies.* The money doesn't really exist for DC to pursue a property like MOTU. Yes, MOTU has a rather rabid, and loyal, fanbase... but it is a fanbase that is relatively small in the scheme of things.

Now, if a writer (preferably with a large "Straczynski-like" following) approached DC with an interesting pitch, it might be in their interest to pursue the license.

* The reason that companies like Devil's Due or IDW were able to capitalize on properties like GI Joe or Voltron is because it was not profitable for the BIG TWO(?) to do so. With a smaller operating budget, these companies were able to take advantage of the nostalgia niche... but only for so long. Take a look at Devil's Due recently, not long for this world. Even in the history of MOTU comics, Val and co. weren't able to keep the most recent comic going, even with most of our support.

The only chance that DC might add MOTU is just because of the DC Comics Presents issues that actually had MOTU meet up with DC Universe characters. Geoff Johns could actually make it work since he is so in to the nostalgia of DC comics.

Now if they could get Stanley "Antgerm" Lau to do some MOTU artwork - that would be amazing.

In Midwinter, the heat from the oven baking my Shrinky Dinks is all I need!

The big question for me is: would anyone doing a new MOTU comic need to work under the same restrictions we had to work with?
Because those restrictions were making impossible for us to write any story and I dubt something like DC would accept to operate under the same kind of restrictions.
It all goes back to the legal stuff. If Mattel is able to handle publishing license like Hasbro does with DC, then there is some chance that a comic can be done. Otherwise, it would be a nightmare for any writer. Me and Val had to give up at one point, and we are some of the biggest MOTU fan. How long would resist someone that isn't such a big fan to begin with?

Now, if a writer (preferably with a large "Straczynski-like" following) approached DC with an interesting pitch, it might be in their interest to pursue the license.

Personally, I think Straczynski is over rated. But besides that, who's to say he's even a fan? Geoff Johns is already a fan, and the hottest thing in comics right now, like him or not.

Originally Posted by Emiliano

The big question for me is: would anyone doing a new MOTU comic need to work under the same restrictions we had to work with?
Because those restrictions were making impossible for us to write any story and I dubt something like DC would accept to operate under the same kind of restrictions.
It all goes back to the legal stuff. If Mattel is able to handle publishing license like Hasbro does with DC, then there is some chance that a comic can be done. Otherwise, it would be a nightmare for any writer. Me and Val had to give up at one point, and we are some of the biggest MOTU fan. How long would resist someone that isn't such a big fan to begin with?

I think Mattel would be fools to let an opportunity with DC slip out of their hands, considering the relationship they already have with them.

Also, Geoff Johns is the right person, not only because of his talents as a writer, but also because of his position within DC right now. I doubt he'd negotiate a situation that wouldn't be good for all parties involved.

Last edited by SAMURAI36; July 2, 2010 at 08:19pm.
Reason: Automerged Doublepost

I couldn't be any further on the opposite side of the spectrum from this.

Can I ask you, why you feel Johns' stuff is so bad? What, IYO, was so bad about BN and BD?

I didn't want to keep derailing the thread, but in short.

Too much gore.

Too weak solution (to BN).

Too many characters written bland or uninteresting.

Generally weak ideas (BD).

I enjoyed his JSA run a lot, as well as Green Lantern: Rebirth and the GL regular series. I hated Flash: Rebirth, thought BN was all buildup to a bad payoff and dislike the BD series so far. It's hit or miss.

As for the question on "would they?", the question that's relevant is what sort of control Mattel would exert. They have shown in the past to be extremely protective of their trademarks, and I believe that because MOTU has never had any strong, iconic comics creators work on it in the past, Mattel do not feel they are obligated to maintain a comics presence.

The reason Transformers and GI Joe have been so successful as comics properties, and keep being so today, is that they have Simon Furman and Larry Hama respectively. Say what you will, having a very profilic author who has basically been a fan even while working on the 1980's versions of the comics helps -immensely- in building a presence in the comics industry.

MOTU had the DC series, then an all-new team for the Star series, and an entirely different team for the UK comics, which never really intersected, and another team for the mini-comics. The only heavy name attached to MOTU as a comics property is Bruce Timm, and I can't see him returning to MOTU now unless Mattel greases his wheels immensely.

Man, that would have been cool, a MOTU series in the style of B:TAS or S:TAS or JL/U...

The big question for me is: would anyone doing a new MOTU comic need to work under the same restrictions we had to work with?
Because those restrictions were making impossible for us to write any story and I dubt something like DC would accept to operate under the same kind of restrictions.
It all goes back to the legal stuff. If Mattel is able to handle publishing license like Hasbro does with DC, then there is some chance that a comic can be done. Otherwise, it would be a nightmare for any writer. Me and Val had to give up at one point, and we are some of the biggest MOTU fan. How long would resist someone that isn't such a big fan to begin with?

Are those same restrictions STILL in place with different people managing the brand nowadays? Or are the good ol' boys that ruined 200X still over at Mattel?

I enjoyed his JSA run a lot, as well as Green Lantern: Rebirth and the GL regular series. I hated Flash: Rebirth, thought BN was all buildup to a bad payoff and dislike the BD series so far. It's hit or miss.

BD is only 4 issues deep. It's supposed to be a 6 month long bi weekly story.

As for the question on "would they?", the question that's relevant is what sort of control Mattel would exert. They have shown in the past to be extremely protective of their trademarks, and I believe that because MOTU has never had any strong, iconic comics creators work on it in the past, Mattel do not feel they are obligated to maintain a comics presence.

That's a serious mistake on their parts, then. You can't escape having a toy line such as this, without a media form to push it. You mention TF's and GI JOE below, which are perfect examples of that.

Otherwise, Mattel wouldn't be putting all this effort into the bios. They're trying to find a way to push a story, without a proper medium.

The reason Transformers and GI Joe have been so successful as comics properties, and keep being so today, is that they have Simon Furman and Larry Hama respectively. Say what you will, having a very profilic author who has basically been a fan even while working on the 1980's versions of the comics helps -immensely- in building a presence in the comics industry.

See, I disagree with this. Furman and Hama haven't done anything worthwhile on both those franchises' comics (not anything worth while) in the 2+ years that they've been writing them. TF's still doesn't have an ongoing per se, and GI JOE is as bland and boring as you say BN and BD are.

I stopped reading them both, and I was an avid 80's comic reader.

IMO, TF's and GI JOE were their best, when they were in the hands of Dreamwave and Devil's Due, respectively. Same with MOTU, when they were in the hands of Val and Emiliano.

If anything, your are proving that "big names" aren't necessarily the best thing for these franchises, as was your point with Geoff Johns.

MOTU had the DC series, then an all-new team for the Star series, and an entirely different team for the UK comics, which never really intersected, and another team for the mini-comics. The only heavy name attached to MOTU as a comics property is Bruce Timm, and I can't see him returning to MOTU now unless Mattel greases his wheels immensely.

That especially won't happen, unless Mattel acquiesces to DC. Bruce Timm and DC are a package deal these days.

Man, that would have been cool, a MOTU series in the style of B:TAS or S:TAS or JL/U...

Now THAT would be absolutely awesome!! All the more reason why Mattel and DC need to link up... With DC doing the comics and the animation, and Mattel already doing DC's toys, it's win-win for everybody.