Texas accuses Google of withholding evidence

Jun 22, 2012 by MICHAEL LIEDTKE

In this July 25, 2011 file photo, Texas Attorney General Greg Abbott talks with the media as he leaves the Tom Green County Courthouse, in San Angelo, Texas. Abbott is accusing Google of improperly withholding evidence sought in an investigation into whether the company has been abusing its dominance of Internet search. (AP Photo/Eric Gay, File)

(AP) -- The Texas attorney general is accusing Google of improperly withholding evidence to stymie an investigation into whether the company has been abusing its dominance of Internet search.

The allegations surfaced in a court filing earlier this week as part of Texas' 2-year-old probe into Google's business practices.

Texas is among at least six U.S. states examining whether Google manipulates its Internet search engine's influential recommendations to stifle competition and drive up online advertising prices. The Federal Trade Commission and European regulators are conducting their own investigations into the same issues.

As regulators and other government authorities pursue their inquiries, Google Inc. is being asked to turn over reams of internal emails and other records that could illuminate the company's strategy and provide insights into the mindset of its top executives.

Google's has refused to hand over more than 14,500 documents covered in formal demands issued by Texas Attorney General Greg Abbott in July 2010 and May 2011. Abbott filed a petition Monday in a Texas state court seeking an order that would require the company to surrender more of the requested material.

News of the filing broke in The Wall Street Journal a few hours before Google's annual shareholders' meeting Thursday at its headquarters in Mountain View, California. The uncertainty posed by Google's legal battles with government regulators and authorities around the world is one of the reasons the company's stock has been lagging the rest of the market since co-founder Larry Page became CEO more than 14 months ago.

This isn't the first time a government agency has lashed out at Google for perceived stonewalling. In April, the Federal Communications Commission fined Google $25,000 after concluding the company deliberated impeded an investigation into a Google project that scooped up emails, passwords and other personal information transmitted over unsecured wireless networks in homes located around the world. Google denied it did anything wrong, although it wound paying the fine.

In a Thursday statement, Google cast itself as a good corporate citizen  an image that it seeks to cultivate as part of its "Don't Be Evil" motto.

"We have shared hundreds of thousands of documents with the Texas Attorney General, and we are happy to answer any questions that regulators have about our business," Google said.

The Texas dispute hinges on whether the documents in question are legally protected communications between Google's lawyers and the company's employees.

Abbott contends Google is trying to conceal documents that don't fall under the shield known as attorney-client privilege.

The Texas attorney general reached that conclusion after reviewing Google's justification for withholding the requested documents.

In many instances, Google is asserting the attorney-client privilege on communications between non-lawyers, according to Abbott's petition. The disputed records reflect but don't contain advice directly from a lawyer, according to the petition. Abbott says Google is withholding other records that don't appear to have been prepared by lawyers.

To prove his point, Abbott wants a Travis County court judge in Texas to review a sampling of the documents that Google is trying to protect to determine if they fall under attorney-client privilege. The review would be done in the privacy of the judge's chambers, a process known as "in camera."

"The Attorney General's office believes an in camera review of these examples will likely demonstrate that Google has significantly overreached in its effort to prevent disclosure of documents," lawyers on Abbott's staff wrote in the petition.

Google, meanwhile, is asking Abbott's investigators to return or delete 12 documents that the company had previously turned over, according to the petition. Abbott wants a judge to look over those records to determine if they fall under attorney-client privilege.

Related Stories

(AP) -- Google Inc.'s methods for recommending websites are being reviewed by Texas' attorney general in an investigation spurred by complaints that the company has abused its power as the Internet's dominant ...

(AP) -- A Delaware judge has given Google Inc. until April 9 to give a pension fund investors company documents involving what authorities said was the illegal online marketing of prescription drugs to U.S. consumers by ...

Recommended for you

A unanimous Supreme Court ruled Tuesday that federal courts can hear a dispute over Colorado's Internet tax law. One justice suggested it was time to reconsider the ban on state collection of sales taxes from companies outside ...

Hillary Rodham Clinton used a personal email account during her time as secretary of state, rather than a government-issued email address, potentially hampering efforts to archive official government documents ...

Drones are the symptoms of a sick nation (the USA) & forewarns of more atrocities in the making.The corrupt and murderous culture of USA is caused by many leaders, including each & every member of Congress who must be held accountable for the crimes that they authorized, sponsored, financed, approved, covered up, committed, etc.: