Just Causes

Password required

April 05, 2008

"If you want to avoid turbulence, you have to stay at home"

Never one to avoid turbulence if it means gaining access to the cat-food larder, Babe assertively applies the Think System yesterday atop the late-afternoon kitchen counter during the countdown to supper.

"The visit should be seen and interpreted in the spirit with which the pope himself comes to the United States, and not be instrumentalized. It's always a sign of weakness to instrumentalize someone else," papal nuncio (ambassador) Archbishop Pietro Sambi -- organizer of the Pope's imminent US visit to DC and NYC April 15-20 -- told National Catholic Reporter's John Allen recently in a wide-ranging interview published yesterday:

It means that you don't have a clear purpose or vision, and so you have to manipulate others for your own interests.

The Most Reverend Archbishop had put his finger on the very essence of our national "debate" in this extended and contentious campaign season Stateside in order to separate the purposes of Benedetto's forthcoming apostolic journey to these shores from the cacophony of voices who will be trying to spin the Pope's every carefully chosen word and gesture to their own advantage. We loved the advice of American Catholic "rock-star" blogger Rocco Palmo, whose wildly popular blog "Whispers in the Loggia" is said to have "made three quarters of a million readers smile and/or wince and thousands return obsessively every day for the inside dope on the Church":

To repeat an earlier word of advice, given the emergence of this Every-One-a-Vaticanologist climate in advance of the trip, the insights of the visit's lead planner and spokesman-in-chief -- who formally announced the event at last November's plenary of the US bishops -- are worth considerably more than anything else you've seen out there.

National Catholic Register: The pope will be meeting with leaders of other faiths at a time of some turbulence in a couple of Catholicism's relationships with other religious. Some Jews have protested the Good Friday prayer for the conversion of Jews in the old Latin liturgy, while some Muslims have criticized Benedict's decision to baptize a convert from Islam and fierce critic of Islamic fundamentalism during the Easter Vigil Mass. Are you worried that this turbulence will cast a shadow over the visit?

Archbishop Pietro Sambi: I travel quite a bit, and I've learned that turbulence is part of the travel experience. If you want to avoid turbulence, you have to stay at home. Turbulence, in other words, is part of what it means to move forward towards greater understanding and collaboration, both in the ecumenical and inter-religious field.

NCR: Some people have asked if there will be 'another Regensburg' on this trip, meaning another phrase in one of the pope's speeches which is open to misinterpretation. Will we see a more careful choice of words?

Sambi: First of all, misinterpretation doesn't depend primarily upon the one who is speaking. It depends upon the good will, or the bad will, of those who are listening. I think the pope will do whatever he can to be clear, and not to be misunderstood. His first obedience, however, is to the truth.

And this reflects something of a sea change that I have witnessed in Vatican attitudes toward the United States over the last decade. When I first started reporting on the Vatican 10 years ago or so, at that stage I think the mainstream view of the United States was still a bit ambivalent in the Vatican. A lot of people over there would regard the United States as basically a Protestant culture -- that is, one shaped under the impress of Protestantism and particularly Calvinism -- would see it as sort of a cowboy culture with a certain recklessness and so on. And also some concerns about what was seen as the rambunctiousness and independent-mindedness of the Catholic Church in this country.

While all of those concerns, in a way, are still there, I think what has come to be the much more dominant note in terms of what Vatican people see when they look across the water these days is a real fondness and appreciation for what they see as the religious health of American culture in
comparison with contemporary Europe. And I think the critical ingredient here is not that anything particularly has changed in the United States; it’s more what has happened in Europe in the last 10 years.

"Cowboy culture with a certain recklessness and so on"? Mr. Allen should take another look at his Sambi interview notes:

Turbulence, in other words, is part of what it means
to move forward towards greater understanding and collaboration, both
in the ecumenical and inter-religious field.

Comments

You can follow this conversation by subscribing to the comment feed for this post.

Once again I say that I believe the Judeo-Christian culture is the best interpretation of the wisdom of the ages of Humankind and belief in God is not to be belittled by atheists such as myself. The current Pope is an inspiring example of one who supports a tolerant view of those who support these values.

Great post that reminds us how the MSM will be shocked to learn how Catholic the Pope is.

It's hard not to love this Pope who loves cats, hats and Fanta and who, better than anyone else in the West, realizes what's at stake in the world today. When the EU in its arrogance would prefer not to be reminded that its roots are in Christendom, the Pope stands tall and almost alone against the 'dictatorship of relativism.'