We had 1 red and 2 black. The red started laying at 14 1/2 wks, the 1st black hen started at 17 wks and the other black one brought up the rear at 20 wks. For us, the red one was a much more regular layer and seemed friendlier (although my son held her more as a chick). I would definitely get them again! Just an after thought, Our last laying black one consistently laid eggs that were too large to fit in the container. The others were always nice sized!

i don't have any blacks, so i'm no good for comparison - BUT we do have 2 reds (from mypetchicken) and LOVE them. very sweet, very tame - and excellent layers... one started laying at 15weeks, the other the following week. that was in january, and between the two of them and our rir we've pretty much had 3 brown eggs every day.