I figured why not have Deborah reprise Dahlia, as she said she enjoyed that character and it'd be kinda cool if she got to be the much more sinister Dahlia of the original game, plus she's now closer in age these days to how Dahlia is in the game. Roberto did a great job as PH in the original two movies and deserves to return as him, and in a proper SH2 adaptation of all things. Trying to think of who else for the other characters.

_________________5:00Darkness that brings the choking heat. Flames render the silence, awakening the hungry beast. Open time's door to beckon prey.

I figured why not have Deborah reprise Dahlia, as she said she enjoyed that character and it'd be kinda cool if she got to be the much more sinister Dahlia of the original game, plus she's now closer in age these days to how Dahlia is in the game. Roberto did a great job as PH in the original two movies and deserves to return as him, and in a proper SH2 adaptation of all things. Trying to think of who else for the other characters.

I love the choices you made in Silent Hill 2 ^^I kind of agree too on Dahlia being reprised by her original actress in my opinion she was just about perfect for it. What would your choices be for Silent Hill 4, I would like to see that lol

Those are pretty good choices for SH4. I can totally see Bill Skarsgard as Walter after his turn as Pennywise.

Also forgot for SH3, also have Doug Jones in a dual role as Valtiel. Both Valtiel and Leonard would require a performer who can emote under heavy make-up with no dialogue and has a certain physical volcabulary to the way they move, and Doug would be great for both.

_________________5:00Darkness that brings the choking heat. Flames render the silence, awakening the hungry beast. Open time's door to beckon prey.

Figured I'd give Doug Jones dual roles as both Valtiel and Leonard, as both roles would require a skilled, seasoned performer who knows how to perform and emote under heavy make-up with little to no dialogue, and he'd be excellent for both.

Also for Downpour, I think William Moseley looks so much like a real-life Murphy it's honestly kind of scary:

_________________5:00Darkness that brings the choking heat. Flames render the silence, awakening the hungry beast. Open time's door to beckon prey.