@Waco - I had You-Priest, Fonti-Aco as a possible world very very early on D2 (You can see it in #QT #37, #38 (It's meant to read as Waco/Fonti), #51, #54, #58. #68, #69 and #70.). I also had another world being you two being partners and defending each other, the fact that you softed an oracle Miner-Town result at one point made me think the latter was more plausible than the earlier one. I pretty much had two worlds coming into D2, 1) D1 was S/S wagons and Math is scum or 2) D1 was S/T wagons and you were mafia. I genuinely never town read Math a single time while being in the game ftr.

Well, I wasn't right as to the 3d scum per say and probably made D3 more scary than it had to be, but I'm still fairly happy with this game. Feeling a definite sense of improvement over AYAW 4 anyways. miner11121 6-1 now ey? I'm still 100%!

I loved reading every single one of Regfan's posts. Being able to dedicate yourself fully to this one mafia game and exude that much effort into posting and solving the game - all the while never losing motivation or drive to scumhunt - is something I want to aspire for in my own play.

Jarizok What role causes an experienced player to play scummy, post weird wall reads that barely reflect the game state and is UNCONDITIONALY town read by another experienced player who should know better?

Oh it's not a big thing. It took me way too long in retrospect to clue in. The clue was more Waco's bizarre play and Fonti making up flimsy reasons for townreading him for it. Read her qt, if Waco wasn't mod confirmed she'd probably be voting for him and that mindset showed in her postings.

Finally can actually look at this - always like to read QTs, and throughly enjoyed the game. Thanks as always to Snow for having the best QT.

On another note, I'm sure Eido is going to tell me all of the ways I was shit now, but feel free to pile on - making a concerted effort to play more/improve my play, and I thought this was a decent step (super townread, managed to misdirect people on my role, did the whole activity thing, pretty decent reads although I had a massive Q sized blindspots after D1) but also acknowledge I have a good ways left to go. Advice is appreciated if you guys are feeling it.

@Jarizok What role causes an experienced player to play scummy, post weird wall reads that barely reflect the game state and is UNCONDITIONALY town read by another experienced player who should know better?

Click to expand...

It got kinda obvious at EoD2. It was part of the reason I had Jaro/HF at the bottom of my list D3, because I figured others should have figured it out. Then Von had his question to Fonti mid D3, and I'm like, maybe not then.

FWIW, I would have played D1 the same regardless of my role there. You'll probably see a lot more of this version of me in the future. It's too difficult for me to play my many posts game with the time restrictions I have

Also The Waco Kid you were just so different from HP mafia... Once it was clear scum were bussing each other hard your pushing of Math wasn't worth much of anything anymore. Besides, most all of us pushed both Miner and Math at some point. You were never the most vocal so you never got sll that much cred.