Two Long Island men were arrested yesterday for ripping off a Hicksville church by issuing themselves double checks every week and spending $86,000 on a parish credit card, Nassau County police said.

Anthony Fusaro, 61, a maintenance foreman at the Holy Family Parish and School, and Joseph Cavaco, 61, who served as the church’s business manager, were charged with grand larceny for hiking their salaries and fraudulently using the church’s American Express card.

A diocesan auditor found the duo spent $85,663 between August 2001 and May 2004 on the card, which was authorized by Cavaco for church business only, cops said.

Police said Cavaco tried to cover up his illegal expenses by falsifying ledger entries.