TMC is an independent, primarily volunteer organization that relies on ad revenue to cover its operating costs. Please consider whitelisting TMC on your ad blocker and becoming a Supporting Member. For more info: Support TMC

I came across another attempt by a utility in NM to stifle their distributed competition and preserve their profits. You have to admit... what these guys lack in morals they make up for with cojones...

Rate 3 for the Jemez mountains electric coop states that for solar PV systems >30kW you are still required to pay all demand and energy charges at full retail including for the what you produce. You have to pay Jemez retail rates for your own production. Jemez will then credit you 'cost avoided' for your production (typically fuel-based only ~$0.03/kWh)

This is another case were you get no credit for self-consumption... no credit for generating clean energy... no credit for relieving stress on the grid by generating locally...

Attached Files:

That's insane. But to do that, wouldn't they have to have your PV system connected through its own meter to the grid, and then back through the normal meter to the house/factory/whatever? If the system was connected behind a single meter, they'd never know how much you used or produced, right?

That's insane. But to do that, wouldn't they have to have your PV system connected through its own meter to the grid, and then back through the normal meter to the house/factory/whatever? If the system was connected behind a single meter, they'd never know how much you used or produced, right?

Appalachian Electric Power (part of American Electric Power) is attempting a massive anti solar billing. They will slap Solar generators, and only solar generators, with a massive demand charge. Looking at my bills my power rates will be 75% higher than my bills before solar. And I now generate 95% of my usage. So installing solar will result in a negative return.

Appalachian Electric Power (part of American Electric Power) is attempting a massive anti solar billing. They will slap Solar generators, and only solar generators, with a massive demand charge. Looking at my bills my power rates will be 75% higher than my bills before solar. And I now generate 95% of my usage. So installing solar will result in a negative return.

Click to expand...

That is completely outrageous! How is this rate change regulated in your state? What can be done to mobilize public support to have this reversed?

That is completely outrageous! How is this rate change regulated in your state? What can be done to mobilize public support to have this reversed?

Click to expand...

A group of us met with the regulators and we gave them copies of bills and proposed bills but we received virtually no feedback. We are unsure of the best way to fight this as the official hearings are 300 miles distant from us.

Honestly this is more a stalemate than a victory... there's still a $0.036/kWh fee on self-consumption. So even if I used my batteries and never used the grid; if I produced/consumed ~1500 kWh I'd pay ~$60/mo just to have the grid available... Repeal of net-metering is no where near the greatest threat to solar.

Appalachian Electric Power (part of American Electric Power) is attempting a massive anti solar billing. They will slap Solar generators, and only solar generators, with a massive demand charge. Looking at my bills my power rates will be 75% higher than my bills before solar. And I now generate 95% of my usage. So installing solar will result in a negative return.

Click to expand...

I am happy to report KINGSPORT power FULLY retracted the proposed demand charge for solar. Sometime we can win.

If you can avoid "air conditioning" and electric heating it should not be that hard to go off grid. Your main usage is refrigeration, typically 1 kw, and charging the EVs and these could be done while the sun is out. Most consumer devices today are very efficient. If one refrains from opening the freezer at night one might actually begin to lose some weight! A single Tesla Powerwall just might be able to bridge usage from 4pm until 9am the next day.
--

Personally, and especially in such situations as described in the OP, I favor going totally off-grid if financially possible. A combination of solar, wind, and battery storage (PowerWall?) should be possible (but may not be affordable) in many instances.

Personally, and especially in such situations as described in the OP, I favor going totally off-grid if financially possible. A combination of solar, wind, and battery storage (PowerWall?) should be possible (but may not be affordable) in many instances.

In my case, affordability is the reason why I have not gone off-grid.

Click to expand...

Should Tesla get into wind energy? I'm not sure of the energy efficiency of wind turbines, but a few small ones on the roof or a larger one in the backyard would actually be pretty sweet.

Should Tesla get into wind energy? I'm not sure of the energy efficiency of wind turbines, but a few small ones on the roof or a larger one in the backyard would actually be pretty sweet.

Click to expand...

Residential wind turbine are almost universally a terrible idea. The only areas where they make sense would be somewhere with really terrible sun (worse than Seattle) and with very consistent wind. Small wind (<100kW) is now ~4x the cost with 1/2 the life span of solar.

I have read that most small wind turbines are better described as "Kinetic Sculptures" than actual productive energy producers. A productive wind turbine really has to get up into the undisturbed flow high above the ground.

I agree, I looked into wind turbines for residential use and even though they have come a long way in the past few years they need at least 6mph of consistent wind and a minimum of 30 feet above any obstructions. They just did not pencil out for me and I do not have consistent wind like they recommend.

A single Tesla Powerwall just might be able to bridge usage from 4pm until 9am the next day.
--

Click to expand...

I'm by no means an off-grid advocate... I really hope that the we can find common ground with the utilities so excess distributed generation can be utilized instead of curtailed. But there are A LOT of cheap tricks that can be cheaply employed to reduce dependency on the grid. My favorite is adding a timer to your hot water heater. $50 = ~3kWh of 'storage'... can't beat that.

Meta

Do you value your experience at TMC? Consider becoming a Supporting Member of Tesla Motors Club. As a thank you for your contribution, you'll get nearly no ads in the Community and Groups sections. Additional perks are available depending on the level of contribution. Please visit the Account Upgrades page for more details.