I got some more Hermes scarves from various sources, with varying results. These four are from burning521 on iOffer; they shipped a bit slowly, but were very friendly and prompt to reply and I wouldn't hesitate to buy from them again.

Springs
This one is very pretty, but the edges are rolled toward the back, which is incorrect. They are well sewn, however. It should have the title and Hermes Paris in the centre but doesn't; however, I believe that other than that the design is correct. It arrived folded incorrectly.

Title unkown - pocket watches
The silk on this one is less nice than my others from this seller, and once again, the edges are rolled toward the back. The design is very pretty and well-printed, but as I can't find a picture of the authentic scarf, I don't know about its accuracy.

Soiree de Gala
A beautiful scarf - it is missing the Hermes Paris which should be printed at the bottom near a corner. Edges rolled to the back. Outstanding fabric and printing - photo-accurate as far as I can tell apart from the lack of "Hermes Paris."

La Promenade de Longchamps
Another really gorgeous scarf. It should have a plaque like the one with the title with "Hermes Paris," but besides that and the edges, it's wonderful.
----------------------------------------------------------
These two are from www.exacthandbag.com. I would not buy from them again; they say that EMS shipping comes free, so their prices are higher than other places, but they shipped mine via First Class mail instead. Communication wasn't great. They do, however, have some hard-to-find designs.

Title unkown - carriages

A very pretty pattern (it makes me think of Cinderella), and I haven't been able to find a photo of the authentic scarf, but it does have some problems. The silk is too silky and slippery (I know that this is frequently a problem with Italian fakes), and it also has a shine that it shouldn't have. The edges are machine-sewn and obviously incorrect.

Fantasies Indiennes

Fabulous, vivid colours and photo-realistic printing with lots of detail. Once again, edges are rolled to the back and are sloppily sewn in places, but I am very happy with this scarf. The silk twill is slightly coarser than some of my others, but not owning an authentic scarf, I can't tell if that's correct or not.
----------------------------------------------------------
And, finally, this one came from fyongvv on iOffer; it was a perfectly smooth transaction.

La Treve de l'Eau

My favourite of this haul by far. I can't even tell you how beautiful this design is (although the artist took some serious license here, since these animals are from all over the world). Printing is absolutely spot-on. The colours are slightly more... garish than the authentic scarf. I think this is only something you'd notice in comparison; you'd never look at this scarf and say, "Wow, those colours are garish." The fabric is excellent and the edges are neat, but rolled to the back.
-----------------------------------------------------------------------------
In summation, I believe that the "Chasse en Inde" from Eric is the closest to perfect, but these are all older designs, and I don't think there are multiple versions of scarves, so I think if you want the older designs, you have to deal with imperfect replicas. I suspect that the other 2009 reps that Eric and others carry are just as great as Chasse en Inde, and presumably the 2010 reps will be great too...

mad, Jacky has a very limited selection but I think the designs he has are exactly the same as Eric's (and everyone else's). I don't think that there are multiple versions of the same designs - I think that if one design is done well, it doesn't matter where you get it, it will be the same.

diormouse; I know you said Eric had the closest to perfect scarves you had seen.... I just wanted to point out that my Hermes Attrape tes Reves scarf from him has the edges rolled towards the front as they should be.

__________________Every time I say the dirty word exercise, I wash my mouth out with chocolate.

Lv scarflv scarf viola.jpg
This is a present from Catty as she says on her website: one free gift with any order in october!
I'll give to a friend of mine since I don't really like it and have no idea of how to wear!!