“It’s clear that not only this defendant but many others were involved in that affray, none of whom were brought before this court for that conduct.

“It seems to me on the basis of the evidence that we heard that he was not the instigator of violence. That violence had already broken out and he became involved in it.”

He added: “It seems to me that a custodial sentenced would certainly not be justified in his case, although I do recognise that participation in affray of this kind can easily descend into more serious violence, with very serious or even fatal consequences.”

A fourth man, Reuben Edwards, 19, of Gardendale Avenue, Clifton, was acquitted of any involvement in Mr Somers’ death by jurors.

3 comments

Jimbob, as you were at the trial throughout and heard all of the evidence, what sentence would you suggest for someone convicted of affray? In fact jimbob, tell us all what constitutes 'affray' in criminal law terms.

"Rodney, 18, of Brecon Close, Broxtowe Estate, was sentenced to carry out 50 hours of unpaid work within the next year."
Yes Judge Mr Justice Parker, 60 whole minutes of unpaid work a week for the next year will certainly teach him a lesson or two and will also act as a deterrent to everyone else.