“When I was 4-years-old I thought Aaron Carter was so cool,” Moretz said in an interview for Variety‘s Power of Young Hollywood cover shoot. “And then my friend, when we were both little babies back in Georgia, she liked Aaron Carter, too. We used to fight about who would date Aaron Carter one day. Who knows? Maybe we’ll meet,” said Moretz, who once dated Brooklyn Beckham.

The younger brother of Backstreet Boys heartthrob Nick Carter reached out to Moretz on Twitter, writing: “Mmmm may I take you to dinner @ChloeGMoretz ?” And in a follow-up post, Carter tweeted, “Hey @ChloeGMoretz – let’s set up a date. The crush is mutual.”

“It wasn’t until I was about 17 until… there was somebody I had a small relationship with,” he recalled, adding how he’s currently “a single man.”

Previously, Carter, who had high-profile relationships with Lindsay Lohan and Hilary Duff, first revealed in a tweet on Saturday that his sexuality “has been weighing on my chest for nearly half of my life.”