Not the OP video, no. That's already been explained, to those of you less accustomed to filming and photographing the sun, as glare - with other,
much better quality, pictures of the sun taken around the same showing that in reality there is nothing there

I can't believe there are still people around who think this Niburu stuff is real...

Now, whilst I'm not one of the people who thinks
"planet x" is real, it looks nothing like a sun dog, according to the pictures in that wiki link. I'm not going to pretend I know what it is, or
what it isn't, as i'm fairly (a drunk and b ) unqualified to comment on what a picture is or isn't. But it bears no resemblance to a sun dog, in
the pics that I've seen.

Of course, I doubt that this video is of the fabeled lanet x, but I'm hard pushed to see what it actually is. Even if it was a sun dog, would it not
move with the camera? (again, I'm not a photo boffin, so I don't know)

Is Nibiru supposed to be a Planet or a Brown Dwarf Star? If it's a Planet then someone better tell everyone else it's on fire. It's a sundog IMHO,
the phone camera is being used behind a single or double pane of glass, you can do this yourself, try it. I also think if this is Nibiru we would be
experiencing massive upheavels right now if it's that close, sorry but I don't buy it.

Why do people still belive that planet X is comming to get us all??..i mean i have been an amateur astrnomer for few years..i have good equipment ( a
C6-SGT scope, and ETX-125, meade DSI camera. Canon XSi Cam, a lot of eyepices and Solar filters) and for my equipment when i watch the sun with the
proper filter i dont see anything resemble like in the picture posted? I just see the sun with his magnificent, but only that ..

I do believe that there can be some more planets far away than pluto in our solar system to be discover that could actually be the legendary planet X
or may be call like that, but saying a brown dwarf may travel thousands and thousands of miles around the solar system, that thousands if not million
of avid amateur astronomers didnt notice with all their equipment plus the rest of 6 billion people that daily go out and watch the sun from time to
time, (like i said you can buy this days a scope for 100 dls and a solar filter for around 50 bucks for a minimum to see the sun properly, you dont
need expesive equipment this days) and the earth and the rest of the planet didnt notice his gravitational effects all around (and more because of his
supouse size of jupiter) is just insane.

People should at least read some amateur astronomer sites, planet X may exist, but not like many explains it here in ATS (brown dwarf, advancing at
high stop, no planets detects his gravitational pull or no effects at all, and just appearing to some singular guy with a mobile phone???) to
undretsnad how things work out.

I am so amaze how poeple are so gullible with some crapy pic or video thats comes ouot and preach is the truth and when its confronted with real
evidence they still think everybody is in a cospiracy, that millions of amateur astronomers see planet X but denies it, that nasa pays all of them no
question ask, if this was turth dont you think everybody in the world would become one just to get some bucks for free????

Sorry pals but at least this planet X pic is not true for me, just another guy who catch another anomaly in te sky and people are so gullible to
believe it and not do at least some research with some amateur astronomers sites...

I think ATS has become the laughing stock with this kind of poor treaths and supouse "evidence" when poeple just see something and instantly wants
to believe is true before asking themselves or research a litte bit with real science.

thank you, well said. I must confess that looking at PX threads has been my guilty little pleasure for some time. However, the video depicted in
this thread is misleading for several reasons:

1. If this phenomenon was visible from X location, if would be visible again the next day and the next, etc.

2. If it WERE visible and photographable, there would be at least thousands of folks who produced consistent photos/video of it.

3. My observation is that photos that claim Planet X/nibiru show it always in relation to the sun, and the position of the alleged object is never
fixed -- it changes from photo to photo, which inclines me to believe that people are intentionally creating the conditions that make those photos.

4. Are ALL of these photographers/videographers completely unaware of the use of filters and aperature control? I have been taking photos of
sunset and sometimes sunrise nearly every day for the last three years. I pursue photos of the green flash (which I will be doing a thread about
shortly). I see all manner of cloud backlighting, sundogs, other phenomenon. I could fairly easily "make" a photo that mirrored some of these,
but I choose to accurately capture visible conditions. I'm not above changing the shutter speed and/or aperature to make the picture more warm, but
I intentionally try to avoid lens flares and the like.

I look at my photos on a large screen monitor, and only save the best ones. Still, I'm certain as I'm sitting here, that I'd have noticed before
now a companion to the sun. See, to capture the green flash, it takes a good amount of telephoto, a small bit of elevation above the horizon, as
well as clear air and a warm air layer above the horizon. It's not uncommon at all for me to take 150 or so photos in an evening.

As you apparently did, I can look at the photos on ZetaTalk that allegedly depict NIbiru, and even within those cherrypicked photos, one can see the
change in them within the same time period. For that to occur, Nibiru would have to be impossibly large, combined with impossibly absent of mass,
along with the propensity toward not just an eliptical orbit, but an abberant one -- and orbit that was in advanced retrograde ALL the time.

It'll continue to be my guilty pleasure.......... I can't seem to help myself.

There is a number of things we must address in this thread that out of the first 9 pages I read, I did not see. Keep in mind that I am not a
scientific expert, but consider myself fairly well learned about things.

First, if the object were 'next to' (visibly) the sun on that day, it does not necessarily mean it is going to be in the same spot again, ever.
Figuring out where the object would be next would require us to have the knowledge of IF it is traveling, and WHICH WAY it is traveling. We know we
are moving around our sun, and around our galaxy (presumably anything we can see, be it with eyes, or optics, would be moving with the galaxy as well
though). So, if the object were coming this way from straight on, then the day after that, the object would have been behind or in front of the sun,
or farther off in one direction or another. It would not have been in the same position ever again unless it followed some style of orbit around the
sun, of which we would be aware.

The object could not be in front of the sun, anyone should know this. If it were, then only two things would be possible to make the light. A: It
would have to be a star, and stars do not just creep up into a solar system unnoticed. Or B: it would have to be so large, that it would in fact bend
light around it somehow into looking like it was glowing, if that were the case, an object of such mass would wreck our entire solar system's
gravitational balance.

Assuming the object in the video was in fact behind the sun, reflecting light, this would assume it is either VERY large, or VERY reflective. Now,
reading through everyone's posts, it doesn't seem like anyone here really knows much about the Nibiru legends. Apparently, the residents of the
supposed planet, often referred to as the Annunaki, were supposedly responsible for mining gold from this planet some time ago for their atmosphere.
Something about keeping the geothermal heat inside the atmosphere required gold insulation in the air because the planet ventured so far away from its
parent star (supposedly Sol). Now, taking this 'extreme' venture into consideration, should there be a way to lace a planets atmosphere with VERY
large quantities of gold (or perhaps even a global gold-plated shell) this object would indeed reflect a great deal of light. Maybe even looking like
the sun itself. Ah, and another question arises...

Should there be a race out there advanced enough to build a gold plated shell around their planet, it doesn't necessarily mean that the whole planet
is the size of the shell. Then this could also mean that the mass of the planet could be misjudged by an outside appearence. Not to mention how much
materials would be mined from the planet itself to make the shell, instead of bringing it all in (which to any race would be an exhausting task,
importing gold, and who knows what other ores to create such a structure.) This could be an explination of the lack of gravitational effects we ARENT
seeing. If something like a basketball with a golfball in it (where the basketball is the shell, and the golfball is the planet inside), we may have
an answer to the gravity problem.

But I digress, these are all very extreme explinations... Things that I consider when explaining anything. Not everything is simple, and sometimes
thinking outside the normal is required to find your answers.

This content community relies on user-generated content from our member contributors. The opinions of our members are not those of site ownership who maintains strict editorial agnosticism and simply provides a collaborative venue for free expression.