The Dutch government's proposed revision of the country's data retention law is not enough to bring it into compliance with a recent European Union court ruling, the Dutch privacy watchdog said Monday.

An effort by the Dutch government to adjust a law requiring telecommunications and Internet companies to retain their customers' location and traffic metadata for investigatory purposes should be dropped, as the infringement of the private life of virtually all Dutch citizens is too great, the Dutch Data Protection Authority (DPA) said on Monday.

The Dutch government is looking to change data retention obligations for telephone and Internet communications operators following a decision last year by the Court of Justice of the European Union (CJEU). The court invalidated the European data retention directive, on which the Dutch law is based, because it violates fundamental privacy rights.

The government sees the law as indispensable for the investigation and prosecution of serious criminal offenses, and proposed maintaining it with minor adjustments to who will have access to the data and under what circumstances to bring it in line with the CJEU ruling.

Retaining the telephony and Internet data of virtually all citizens for six to 12 months is a far-reaching measure which requires an irrefutable demonstration of necessity, it said, adding that during the 4.5 years this data has been retained, law enforcement authorities have not been able to show why data retention is necessary.

Moreover, the draft bill does not address the question whether less far-reaching alternative measures would be available to obtain the same result. If the bill was to go ahead, "the infringement of the private life of virtually all Dutch citizens is too big and disproportionate," it found

The government for instance proposed to retain telephony data for 12 months but only make it accessible to law enforcement for six to 12 months depending on the crime. However, this distinction between the retention and the use of the data does not alter the disproportionality between the purpose of the data collection and the infringement on the private life. Therefore, this general data retention obligation is unlawful, the DPA said.

The DPA's opinion is one of several that will have to be taken into account, said a spokesman for the Dutch government, who added that the government will comment on every suggestion in detail when the bill is submitted to the Parliament.

A DPA spokeswoman said the bill could still be altered before it will be discussed in parliament based on the advice.

Other data retention laws in EU countries have already been ruled unconstitutional, In Austria for instance, the local law was invalidated in the wake of the CJEU ruling. In Germany, the local data retention law was ruled unconstitutional in 2010, long before the ruling.

In Sweden though, the government is looking to maintain a data retention obligation for telecommunication data on much the same grounds as in the Netherlands.

Loek is Amsterdam Correspondent and covers online privacy, intellectual property, online payment issues as well as EU technology policy and regulation for the IDG News Service. Follow him on Twitter at @loekessers or email tips and comments to loek_essers@idg.com

Channel Deals

Tely HD Pro & Wireless Audiopod

ARN Distributor Directory

ARN Vendor Directory

Slideshows

​Inside the new HP Customer Welcome Centre in Sydney…

HP unveiled its new Customer Welcome Centre (CWC) in Sydney this week, following on more than a year after the vendor opened the doors of its Experience Centre in Melbourne (MEC). The new space offers on-site HP technicians and visiting channel partners the ability to reconfigure equipment and put together tailored solutions based on the needs of individual end clients or target vertical markets. The centre can also be booked by customers and partners for meetings, events, workshops, seminars, and training. Photos by HP.

Zscaler Australia toasts the channel at Xmas drinks

Zscaler recently hosted its partner update and Christmas drinks event in Australia where more than 20 partners attended the event at the QT hotel in the Sydney. The event provided a forum for the company to update its Australian partners on the company's strategy for cloud security in the year ahead. It was also a great opportunity for the company to introduce Sean Kopelke as country manager for A/NZ. The event ended with Christmas drinks and a celebration of momentum gained in 2016.

IN PICTURES: ​Nutanix X Tours

Nutanix recently held two ‘X Tours’, which brought the company’s flagship event .NEXT to Brisbane and Melbourne. Customers and partners got a firsthand look at the new era of IT and exposure to the potential of the Nutanix Enterprise Cloud platform. Both events featured key speakers both from Nutanix and its partners.

iasset.com is a channel management ecosystem that automates all major aspects of the entire sales, marketing and service process, including data tracking, integrated learning, knowledge management and product lifecycle management.

Copyright 2016 IDG Communications. ABN 14 001 592 650. All rights reserved. Reproduction in whole or in part in any form or medium without express written permission of IDG Communications is prohibited.