This DVD, and the production it enshrines, represents one of the
most exciting musical collaborations to come from the Met in a
generation. You may well be slightly nervous at the thought of
a Chinese opera sung in English by a Spanish tenor, but don’t
be scared: the results are mostly riveting and if you give it
a go then I’m confident you’ll enjoy it.

Of all the composers that have come out
of contemporary China, Tan Dun is probably the one best known
in the West. He wrote the film score for Crouching Tiger,
Hidden Dragon and, though he has been based in New York
for the last while, he continues to employ Oriental modes of
music while using a western orchestra and, broadly, western
conventions. The First Emperor, his fourth opera, is
his most successful so far and has been championed by the Met’s
artistic director, James Levine. The Met assembled a mostly
Chinese team to bring this opera to the stage, including director
Zhang Yimou, whose films include Hero and House of
Flying Daggers. This staging shows his cinematic vision
and eye for colour, in much the same way that Anthony Minghella
did for ENO’s Madam Butterfly. In fact, the presenter
for this DVD is actress Zhang Ziyi, who appeared in Yimou’s
films, though we only see her at the outset in a pre-recorded
introduction.

In the booklet notes Dun argues that his
combination of Eastern and Western musical training had
enabled him to stress not the differences between the two worlds
but the ways in which they complement one another: he sums it
up as “1 + 1 = 1”. The opera contains many of the things that
western opera-lovers are used to: there is a love scene, an
oath duet and a triumphal scene, to name but a few. What make’s
Dun’s work unique, however, is that he presents these in a uniquely
Oriental style. The orchestra is broadly a western one, though
it is augmented by one or two eastern instruments, but Dun gets
them to play in a Chinese style, such as through exaggerated
glissandi on the strings. In an extra rehearsal film we see
him urging the orchestra that “every beat is a down beat”. This,
combined with the remarkable music he writes for them, means
that the Met orchestra produce a totally unique sound. No matter
how often you’ve heard them before, you’ll never have heard
them sound like this, and the effect is truly spellbinding.
They even chant and clap during the Intermezzo of Act 1.

These effects, however, are not mere effects
in themselves: instead they serve Dun’s compelling dramatic
vision. The marriage of East and West is made explicit in the
opening scene where a Yin-Yang Master, one of the stars of the
Peking Opera, dances on stage and “sings” – in an indeterminate
pitch – in Chinese the story as it will unfold. His deliberately
eastern moves and sounds are then echoed by a more western Shaman
figure (an unrecognisable Michelle DeYoung) who sings an equivalent
passage in English. In the background the massed chorus of the
Met stand in rows and enact the ritual with gestures and chanting,
while towards the front of the stage a row of performers strike
drums with stones. It’s a remarkable opening and one that left
me hungry for more. Yes, it’s not what we’re used to, but I
found it fascinating.

The story, roughly, is of Qin, the brutal
Emperor who first unified China, built the Great Wall and created
the Terracotta Warriors to watch over him. It traces the steps
he takes to consolidate his power, but we also see him destroy
everything he holds dear so that in the final scene he has attained
absolute power but is entirely alone. Dun created this role
specially for Domingo, and the great tenor rises magnificently
to the occasion. This is apparently the first time he has created
a role. His voice has grown darker with age and there is tension
in some of the higher writing, but his singing is as remarkable
as ever and every note rings out fully at whatever range. He
portrays the tortured tyrant like a wounded lion trapped in
web of his own making. His duets with the other characters are
tender and moving, while he conjures a strained pain for the
great crowd scenes. As Jianli, Qin’s friend turned Nemesis,
Paul Groves is a striking contrast: where Domingo’s voice is
dark and burnished, Groves is bright and airy with a refreshing
ping to it. Their duets are fantastic for this reason, and the
end of their Act 2 confrontation is the only time the audience
interrupt with applause. Elizabeth Futral is an equally bright,
exciting coloratura soprano who sings her exacting role with
a freshness to the top notes and an anguish in her equally secure
lower register. Hao Jiang Tian’s dark baritone suits the authoritarian
General Wang, while Michelle DeYoung copes admirably with the
vast range of the Shaman: she hits top, bottom and everything
in between with security and confidence.

The staging is just as good at telling the
story. The basic set is a huge row of steps which is used for
every scene but subtly altered so that it can serve as an intimate
boudoir for the love scene, the building site for the Great
Wall and the vast arena of the final triumph. Zhang Yimou brings
every aspect to life with colour and great pace. He is very
good at managing the big chorus scenes – the opening and closing
spectaculars are truly compelling – but honourable mention should
also go to the love scene which is especially beautiful: it’s
not just the couple on the bed who are subtly lit, but around
them we see three dancers who play eerie Chinese instruments
and evoke the depths of the lovers’ erotic passion which we
do not see. All the individual singers inhabit their roles visually
as well as vocally, even down to the well observed hand gestures
which add extra authenticity.

It’s not really surprising that the cast
should be so ideal as Dun will have written the parts with them
in mind. Equally he will have collaborated closely with his
director to create his setting. All of this would count for
nothing, however, were it not for Dun’s remarkable music, challenging
but accessible; eastern and strange, yet Western and memorable.
The key melodies, most notably the slaves’ chorus, are every
bit as memorable as those in operas much older than this and
the sound-world he creates is one of the most exciting I’ve
come across in a long time.

The Met took a real risk in undertaking
this project, but this DVD vindicated them triumphantly and
it is a credit to everyone involved, not least to EMI who have
shouldered the responsibility for its issue. If you love opera
but you’re looking for a challenge, or if you would like to
explore something contemporary then snap it up while you can.
This disc deserves to do well.

Review
IndexesBy
Label Select a label and
all reviews are listed in Catalogue orderBy
MasterworkLinks
from composer names (eg Sibelius) are to resource pages with links to
the review
indexes for the individual works as well as other resources.

Reviews
from previous monthsJoin the mailing list and receive a hyperlinked weekly update on the
discs reviewed. detailsWe welcome feedback on our reviews. Please use the Bulletin
Board
Please paste in the first line of your comments the URL of the review to
which you refer.