The Makeup We're Hoarding in Our Fallout Shelters

Because if these are ever discontinued, there's going to be a serious crisis

Rimmel London Exaggerate Waterproof Eye Definer, $5.99 "Most people would look at this purple eyeliner and think it's a color for a night out, but it's an everyday staple for me. With dark eyes and dark hair, black eyeliner has never looked daytime appropriate on me, and I just haven't found a brown eyeliner I like. This purple shade is the perfect pop of color to make my eyes stand out without making me look like a raccoon. The unusual color always draws compliments and I never have to worry about it smudging down my face. Even after swimming, the product still stays on until I scrub it off." --Hayley, Editorial Intern