President Abraham Lincoln (Daniel Day-Lewis) looks across a battlefield in the aftermath of a terrible siege in Lincoln.

David James
/ DreamWorks

Listen

Listening...

/

Originally published on November 9, 2012 12:52 pm

Two icons, Abraham Lincoln and James Bond, make triumphant appearances this week in movies with more in common than you'd expect. True, Lincoln is a titan of history, liberator of slaves, and as such an adversary of Western colonialism, while 007 is an outlandish stereotype embodying white male Western authoritarian power. But the makers of these films do a sterling job of testing their respective subjects in front of our eyes — before pronouncing them fit to carry on in our collective imagination.

Steven Spielberg's Lincoln begins in a way that subtly alludes to the Lincoln memorial. We see him first from above and behind. He's reviewing the troops and gazing down on a pair of black soldiers. Like us, they're in awe. But then one of them challenges the president on the grounds that they're paid less than whites — and Lincoln is suddenly more man than monument. He doesn't have a good answer.

Tony Kushner's script is based in part on Doris Kearns Goodwin's book Team of Rivals, which focuses on Lincoln the politician. Here, the war is all but won — now the challenge is getting Congress to pass the 13th Amendment prohibiting slavery. You say the Emancipation Proclamation did that? Ah, but that was an executive order in wartime. Lincoln needs a law.

The actor taking on the president's light, cracked voice is Daniel Day-Lewis. It's a running joke that Lincoln will launch into an illustrative anecdote at the drop of a stovepipe hat, and the actor lets you taste Lincoln's pleasure in choosing each word. He captures Lincoln's famous private sadness — as well as the ability to shake it off and become a master politician who knows when to compromise and when to go to the mat.

This is the Lincoln we don't know as well, the one who made his rival for the presidential nomination — William Seward, played by David Strathairn — his secretary of state. The one who could come down off that pedestal and bargain.

Is Lincoln the movie as great as Daniel Day-Lewis' performance? Oh, yes. The shoptalk around passing the 13th Amendment is a bit thick in the early scenes, but all goes swimmingly once Seward engages a lively trio of lobbyists played by John Hawkes, James Spader and Tim Blake Nelson to descend on Congress dispensing threats and rewards.

Tommy Lee Jones, eyes sagging under a thick-locked toupee, has the show-stopping part of abolitionist congressman Thaddeus Stevens, who's counseled to hold his famous temper and misrepresent his anti-racist beliefs for the sake of the vote. The movie makes you root for his white lie — because politics for Lincoln was about passing laws by hook or by crook.

Director Sam Mendes' Skyfall also shows its hero from a different angle. Mendes has a cheeky attitude toward James Bonds old and new — toward the conflict between the traditional Bond established by Sean Connery and the rough, hurting, rather self-indulgent persona of Daniel Craig's Bond. Mendes and co-writer John Logan are old Shakespeare hands, and they play up the Coriolanus-like reluctance of Craig's 007 to do what's expected of him: to don the tuxedos, take his martinis shaken not stirred, and commit himself unreservedly to queen and country.

Craig's Bond is disillusioned with Judi Dench's M, that mother hen all too ready to sacrifice her chicks for the good of the Mother Country. But in the course of Skyfall, Bond — and we — have to make peace with her less-than-humanist regime, which has produced in ways I won't reveal a psychotic super-cybervillain named Silva, played brilliantly by Javier Bardem.

The filmmakers run out of invention in the last act, but until then this is an unusually funny, rewardingly literate action picture with a cavalcade of glorious stunts and a shocking punch line. Each familiar trapping has been inspected, reconceived and pronounced fit for duty — and the myth of Bond is mightier than ever.

Copyright 2013 NPR. To see more, visit http://www.npr.org/.

Transcript

DAVE DAVIES, HOST:

Two of the year's most highly anticipated movies arrive this week: Steven Spielberg's "Lincoln" starring Daniel Day-Lewis at the 16th president of the United States, and "Skyfall," the third Bond film starring Daniel Craig as 007, directed by "American Beauty" Oscar winner Sam Mendes. Film critic David Edelstein has this review of both.

DAVID EDELSTEIN, BYLINE: Two icons, Abraham Lincoln and James Bond, make triumphant appearances this week in movies with more in common than you'd expect. True, Lincoln is a titan of history, liberator of slaves and as such an adversary of Western colonialism, while 007 is an outlandish stereotype embodying white male Western authoritarian power. But the makers of these films do a sterling job of testing their respective subjects in front of our eyes - before pronouncing them fit to carry on in our collective imagination.

Steven Spielberg's "Lincoln" begins in a way that subtly alludes to the Lincoln memorial. We see him first from above and behind. He's reviewing the troops and gazing down on a pair of black soldiers. Like us, they're in awe. But then one of them challenges the president on the grounds that they're paid less than whites - and Lincoln is suddenly more man than monument. He doesn't have a good answer.

Tony Kushner's script is based in part on Doris Kearns Goodwin's book "Team of Rivals," which focuses on Lincoln the politician. Here, the war is all but won - now the challenge is getting Congress to pass the Thirteenth Amendment prohibiting slavery. You say the Emancipation Proclamation did that? Ah, but that was an executive order in wartime. Lincoln needs a law.

On a late night in the military's telegraph office, he learns the operator is an engineer in civilian life, prompting a meditation on Euclid.

(SOUNDBITE OF FILM, "LINCOLN")

DANIEL DAY-LEWIS: (as President Abraham Lincoln) Euclid's first common notion is this. Things which are equal to the same thing are equal to each other. That's a rule with mathematical reasoning. It's true because it works. Has done and always will do. In his book, hmm, Euclid says this is self-evident.

(as President Abraham Lincoln) You see? There is it. Even in that 2000-year-old book of mechanical law it is a self-evident truth that things which are equal to the same thing are equal to each other.

EDELSTEIN: It's hard to believe that light, cracked voice belongs to Daniel Day-Lewis. It's a running joke that Lincoln will launch into an illustrative anecdote at the drop of a stovepipe hat, and the actor lets you taste Lincoln's pleasure in choosing each word. He captures Lincoln's famous, private sadness - as well as the ability to shake it off and become a master politician who knows when to compromise and when to go to the mat.

This is the Lincoln we don't know as well, the one who made his rival for the presidential nomination - William Seward, here played by David Strathairn - his Secretary of State, the one who could come down off that pedestal and bargain.

Is "Lincoln" the movie as great as Daniel Day-Lewis's performance? Oh, yes. The shoptalk around passing the Thirteenth Amendment is a bit thick in the early scenes, but all goes swimmingly once Seward engages a lively trio of lobbyists played by John Hawkes, James Spader and Tim Blake-Nelson to descend on Congress dispensing threats and rewards.

Tommy Lee Jones, eyes sagging under a thick-locked toupee, has the show-stopping part of abolitionist Congressman Thaddeus Stevens, who's counseled to hold his famous temper and misrepresent his anti-racist beliefs for the sake of the vote. The movie makes you root for his, so to speak, white lie - because politics for Lincoln was about passing laws by hook or by crook.

Director Sam Mendes' "Skyfall" also shows its hero from a different angle. Mendes has a cheeky attitude toward James Bonds, old and new - toward the conflict between the traditional Bond established by Sean Connery and the rough, hurting, rather self-indulgent persona of Daniel Craig's Bond.

Mendes and co-writer John Logan are old Shakespeare hands, and they play up the "Coriolanus"-like reluctance of Craig's 007 to do what's expected of him: to don the tuxedos; take his martinis, shaken not stirred; and commit himself, unreservedly, to Queen and country.

Craig's Bond is disillusioned with Judi Dench's M, that mother hen all too ready to sacrifice any one of her chicks for the good of the Mother Country. But in the course of "Skyfall," Bond - and we - have to make peace with her less-than-humanist regime, which has produced, in ways I won't reveal, a psychotic, super cyber-villain named Silva, played brilliantly by Javier Bardem.

The filmmakers run out of invention in the last act, but until then this is an unusually funny, literate action picture with a cavalcade of glorious stunts and a shocking punch line. Each familiar trapping has been inspected, reconceived and pronounced fit for duty - and the myth of Bond is mightier than ever.