Riggleman was awarded the Individual Interview Award and was first runner-up. Her talent presentation was a jazz dance to "Orange Colored Sky" by Natalie Cole.

Nelson was awarded the Individual Talent Award and was crowned Miss West Virginia's Outstanding Teen for 2007. Her talent presentation was a vocal rendition of “Wishing You Were Somehow Here Again” from the Andrew Lloyd Weber musical "Phantom of the Opera."

Nelson will be competing at the Miss America's Outstanding Teen Competition in Orlando from August 7 to 11.