Paul A. Casetta

Professional Background

Paul Casetta has been practicing law since 2005 and concentrates his practice in the area of subrogation.

As counsel for plaintiffs, Mr. Casetta’s practice focuses on complex property and energy subrogation for various North American and European insurance companies. His successes include:

Trying to verdict in Maricopa County, Arizona a seven-figure property damage claim arising from the flooding of a school, which, after settling with several other defendants before trial, resulted in a recovery in excess of what the Insurer and School District paid to remediate the flooding damage

Settling on the eve of trial with an engineer and a electrical contractor for an amount in excess of what was paid to repair the damage caused by an electrical fire at a hospital in Florida, after prevailing on several key motions that resolved important legal issues in favor of his clients

Securing an eight-figure settlement from an uninsured tool and die company that broke a die owned by a large, high-end vehicle manufacturer, which resulted in the manufacturer losing several months of production

Leveraging a seven-figure policy limits settlement from a sprinkler contractor for a large warehouse after the sprinkler system inspected by the contractor on a monthly basis failed to activate in response to an intentionally set fire

Paul Casetta

Bar Association Memberships: State Bar of Michigan; State Bar of Arizona.

Subrogation Approach

“Our practice provides the unique opportunity to blend the scientific and creative. No two losses are ever the same and the investigation into why and how a catastrophe occurs immerses us in the scientific process.

The fact that we practice across all U.S. jurisdictions and internationally allows us to exercise creative lawyering to take advantage of different nuances in the law.”

– Paul Casetta

From DT Teammates

When Paul Casetta made law his profession, he brought with him the tenacity and grit that made him an outstanding lineman in college football. I have worked on many cases with Paul where his persistence and passion made the difference in turning a difficult case into a winner. Any client is lucky to have Paul Casetta representing them in any legal matter. I look forward to each opportunity I have to work with Paul.

Paul practices law with passion and aggression. Some may say that this a result of playing college football, but I think it is a result of being a driven and skilled lawyer. I have worked with Paul extensively on many files, especially on Arizona losses, and have witnessed how his skills often result in an early subrogation recovery.