5. JUDICIAL BRANCH
COURTS Suffolk County to $136,700 for a judge of the
Supreme Court.
The Courts of Suffolk County are part of the
unified court system under the authority of New While the responsibility for providing and
York State’s chief judicial officer, the Chief Judge maintaining court facilities remains with local
of the Court of Appeals. The courts were last governments, Suffolk County is entitled to finan-
reorganized in 1962, by constitutional amend- cial aid from state court facilities funds for court
ment, and administrative authority was central- improvements and annual maintenance. Under
ized by another amendment approved by the recent legislation, funding for court cleaning and
voters in 1977. At the same time, the State took minor repairs will be fully provided by the state
over the costs of operating the court system, after fiscal year 2000/2001.
including the salaries of judicial and non-judicial
personnel. Judicial salaries were raised by the The authority of a certain court to act in a par-
State Legislature in 1999, and range between ticular case is its “jurisdiction.” There are two
$122,700 for a judge of the District Court in types of jurisdiction: (1) original (or trial), which
FIGURE 5.1 NEW YORK COURT SYSTEM
SUFFOLK COUNTY JUDICIAL BRANCH
NEW YORK STATE OFFICE OF
COURT ADMINISTRATION
NEW YORK STATE SUPREME COURT
SECOND DEPARTMENT APPELLATE DIVISION
SUFFOLK COUNTY
ADMINISTRATIVE JUDGE
SUPREME COURT COMMISSIONER OF
LAW LIBRARY JURORS
SUPREME COUNTY SURROGATE’S FAMILY DISTRICT COURT
COURT COURT COURT COURT (FIVE WESTERN TOWNS ONLY)
PUBLIC TOWN COURT
ADMINISTRATOR (FIVE EASTERN TOWNS)
17
is the power to hear a case in the first instance; Building. Appeals of Supreme Court cases go to
and (2) appellate, which is the power to hear the Appellate Division.
appeals from the decisions of other courts. Some
courts have either one or the other jurisdiction; The 28 Supreme Court Justices currently sitting
other courts have both. in Suffolk are elected in the bi-county
Suffolk/Nassau district for terms of 14 years.
The Court of Appeals. The Court of Appeals is They must have been members of the bar for at
the highest New York State court and is located least ten years. The elected justices are generally
in Albany. It hears appeals from the Appellate supplemented by a number of Acting Supreme
Divisions only, except in cases where a constitu- Court Justices who are members of other courts.
tional question is involved. There is no further An Administrative Judge is appointed by the
appeal from its decisions except to the United State Chief Administrator of the Courts to over-
States Supreme Court, and only in cases involv- see operations in the County.
ing a federal constitutional question. This court
has a Chief Judge and six associate judges The County Court. Judges of the County Court
appointed for 14-year terms by the Governor, in Suffolk County preside over felony criminal
with the advice and consent of the State Senate, cases. The Court also has civil jurisdiction in
from among persons found to be well qualified cases up to $25,000, but because of the volume of
by a nonpartisan nominating commission. At criminal cases, exercises it infrequently. The
least five judges must sit on any case and four Court meets in the newly expanded Criminal
must agree on a decision. Courts Building in Riverhead. In 1999, the Court,
assisted by the three criminal parts of Supreme
The Appellate Divisions of the Supreme Court. Court noted above, disposed of 3,269 criminal
New York State is divided into four Judicial cases. Appeals go to the Appellate Division of the
Departments, in each of which is established an Supreme Court.
Appellate Division of the Supreme Court--the
intermediate appellate court of the State. Suffolk The 11 County Court judges, who must have
County is part of the Second Judicial been members of the bar for five years, are elect-
Department, the Appellate Division of which sits ed by the voters of the County for ten-year terms.
in Brooklyn. This court hears appeals from trial They are supervised by a Supervising Judge of
courts within the Department, by panels of four the Superior Criminal Courts of Suffolk County,
to five justices, and conducts proceedings to appointed by the State Court Administrator.
admit, suspend or disbar lawyers. The justices of
the Appellate Divisions are designated by the The Family Court. The Family Court is located
Governor from among Supreme Court Justices in the new Cohalan Court Complex in Central
for five-year terms. Islip, except for two parts which sit in Riverhead
at 877 East Main Street. The Family Court hears
The Supreme Court. New York State is divided cases having to do with families and children.
into 12 Judicial Districts, Suffolk and Nassau These include cases involving juvenile delin-
Counties comprising the Tenth. The Supreme quency, minors in need of supervision, family
Court is the statewide trial court of the broadest assaults and offenses, abuse and neglect, paterni-
original jurisdiction, both criminal and civil. In ty, custody, support, adoptions, and foster-care
Suffolk, it hears primarily civil cases where the placements and review. The Court disposed of
monetary values exceed the jurisdiction of the 43,750 cases in 1999; appeals go to the Appellate
lower courts, divorce, separation and annulment Division of the Supreme Court.
proceedings, and equity suits. These civil parts,
which disposed of 33,000 cases in 1999, sit pri- The ten judges of the Family Court in Suffolk
marily in three locations: in the Supreme Court County are elected by the voters of the County
Building at 235 Griffing Avenue in Riverhead, the for ten-year terms and must have been members
Arthur E. Cromarty Court Complex (Criminal of the bar for ten years. One judge serves as
Courts Building) at 210 Center Drive in Administrative Judge.
Riverhead, and the Cohalan Court Complex on
Family Court judges are assisted by seven
Carleton Avenue in Central Islip. There are also
Hearing Examiners who handle support and
three criminal parts (judges hearing major crimi-
uncontested paternity cases. The Hearing
nal cases), sitting in the Criminal Courts
Examiners, required to be members of the bar for
18
five years, are appointed by the Chief Admin- Bureau in the State Office Building on Veterans
istrator of the Courts for three-year terms. Memorial Highway in Hauppauge. Altogether,
44,744 civil cases, excluding parking matters,
Further assistance to the judges is provided by were filed in 1999 and 64,245 criminal cases.
three Judicial Hearing Officers, retired or former Appeals of District Court cases go to the
judges who sit part-time and, with the consent of Appellate Term of Supreme Court which sits in
the parties involved, hear and determine cases
assigned to them by Family Court judges. One Mineola.
Hearing Examiner and one Judicial Hearing
Officer sit in the Riverhead location. There is a Supervising Judge of the District
Court, elected by all the voters in the five west-
The County Attorney's Office represents the ern towns. There are also 24 District Court judges
County in Family Court in most proceedings and elected by the voters in the separate districts for
acts as a prosecutor in appropriate cases. six-year terms. They must have been members of
the bar for at least five years.
The Surrogate's Court. The Surrogate's Court
has jurisdiction over probate, accounting, admin- Town and Village Courts. Sixty-one justices sit
istration and guardianship of estates of dece- in the local Justice Courts in the towns and vil-
dents and minors and also handles some adop- lages of the five eastern towns--East Hampton,
tion proceedings. There is one Suffolk County Riverhead, Shelter Island, Southold and
Surrogate who sits in Riverhead at 320 Center Southampton--and in some incorporated villages
Drive. The Court took in 12,955 new proceedings of the five western towns. They may hear civil
in 1999. Appeals of Surrogate decisions go to the cases involving amounts up to $3,000 and minor
Appellate Division of Supreme Court. crimes and offenses. The justices also act as mag-
istrates, holding preliminary hearings for those
The Surrogate is elected by the voters of the charged with more serious crimes. In the western
County for a ten-year term and must have been a towns, such hearings would generally be held in
member of the bar for at least ten years. the District Court. Appeals from the town and
village Justice Courts go to the Appellate Term of
The District Court. The District Court was the Supreme Court.
established in 1964 in the five western towns of
Suffolk County--Babylon, Brookhaven, Islip, The towns and villages elect their part-time
Huntington, and Smithtown. It replaced the justices for four-year terms. Justices need not be
Town Courts in these jurisdictions. State law pro- lawyers, but non-lawyer justices are required to
vides that any town contiguous to the District complete a training course before they may hear
Court system may, by a majority vote in a refer- cases. Acting Justices are appointed by Village
endum initiated by a Town Board Resolution, Boards for four-year terms to hold court when
become part of this system. the elected justices are not available. The costs of
the local courts are carried by the municipalities.
The First District Court in Central Islip handles
trials of misdemeanor criminal cases, prelimi-
nary hearings in felony cases, and civil cases
ARBITRATION PROGRAM
where the amount involved does not exceed Suffolk County operates a mandatory
$15,000. In addition, a domestic violence part Arbitration Program for cases involving dam-
was added in 2000, which handles misde- ages claimed of $6,000 or less These cases (2,539
meanors and violations in domestic violence in 1999) are heard by attorneys. While their deci-
incidents. There is also a Night Court, recently sions can be taken to court de novo, this is infre-
moved to Ronkonkoma, which hears small quently done.
claims cases. The Second, Third, Fourth, Fifth
and Sixth Districts each serve one of the separate SUPREME COURT LAW LIBRARY
towns in the system. Judges sit locally and are
responsible for non-jury civil cases, including This library currently has three branches, locat-
landlord-tenant cases, small claims and town ed in the Criminal Courts Building in Riverhead,
ordinance violations. Since 2000, some civil jury at the Cohalan Complex in Central Islip and at
cases are being heard in the outlying locations. 235 Griffing Avenue in Riverhead. It has the most
Traffic violations, formerly heard in District complete collection of law material in the County
Court, are now handled by the Traffic Violations and is maintained exclusively as a reference
19
library. The library serves the courts, various The Commissioner maintains three jury pools,
County departments, town officials, the Legal Aid one in Central Islip and two in Riverhead.
Society, attorneys, teachers and (with the excep-
tion of the location on Griffing Avenue) the public. Petit Jury. A petit or trial jury usually consists of
twelve members, but in some lower courts a six-
JURIES member jury is used. Its function is to decide mat-
ters of fact presented during the trial of a case. A
Commissioner of Jurors. The Commissioner of unanimous verdict of twelve jurors is necessary to
Jurors, whose office is located at 225 Griffing convict a person of a crime, but in civil cases,
Avenue in Riverhead, has the responsibility of pro- agreement of only five-sixths of the jurors is
viding qualified jurors for all the courts in Suffolk required.
County. The Commissioner is appointed by the
County Jury Board for a four-year term.
Photo by Hal Fullerton
Suffolk County Historical Society, Riverhead
1901 Lady Champion,
Shinnecock Links, Shinnecock, NY
Designed by Stanford White and opened in 1892, this was the first golf course in the United States
20
A juror must be a citizen, at least 18 years of The function of a grand jury is to determine
age, and a resident of New York State and Suffolk whether a crime has been committed and, if so,
County. Prospective jurors also must be able to whether there is a reasonable possibility that the
understand and communicate in English and defendant has committed the crime. New York
must not have any felony convictions. Jury lists State requires grand jury action on all felonies
are compiled by the Office of Court (crimes punishable by more than a year in
Administration from lists of registered voters, prison) unless waived by a defendant. Lesser
state and local taxpayers, licensed drivers, peo- crimes are prosecuted on what is termed an
ple on public assistance and people receiving information--i.e. on a sworn statement of a com-
unemployment compensation. A large number of petent public officer.
categories of persons who could claim exemp-
tion from jury service was abolished by State law THE DEPARTMENT OF PROBATION
in 1996. Some discretionary exemptions of up to
a period of 24 months remain for medical, finan- The Department provides three core services to
cial, transportation and public safety reasons and the Family, Criminal and Justice Courts with
for caregivers and clergy. jurisdiction over residents ages seven and older.
Prospective jurors are chosen at random from Intake personnel prepare petitions for individ-
the computerized pool of lists mentioned above, uals who desire access to Family Court in cases
and are sent questionnaires regarding their qual- of family offenses, support, paternity, custody
ifications. There are approximately 40,000 names and visitation. They also screen and monitor
already qualified to be jurors at the present time, youth populations such as Persons in Need of
with 60,000 more being processed. Summonses Supervision (PINS) and Juvenile Delinquents
to serve are then sent by mail. Jurors check in by (J.D.’s), with a view towards providing services
telephone prior to each day of service to see if in a pre-court status, where possible.
they are needed. The average term of service at
the courthouse for trial jurors is one day or the Investigation Probation Officers provide the
duration of one trial--or 1.4 days. Jurors may not courts with timely reports on adults and youth in
be recalled for a period of four years. order to assist the judges in their decision-mak-
ing.
Employers of more than 10 employees are
required to pay at least the first $40 of an employ- Probation Officers supervise both youth and
ee's wage during the first three days of service. adult populations, and monitor probationers‘
After this time, jurors who are not paid salaries compliance with the conditions of probation
by their employers are remunerated at the rate of while providing services that promote law abid-
$40 for each day they report to the courthouse. ing behavior in the community. Probation also
Jurors without employment receive the daily rate collects restitution payments from offenders and
throughout their service. distributes in excess of one million dollars annu-
ally to victims of crime.
Grand Jury. There is usually one grand jury
active per month in Suffolk County, supplement- The main office of the Probation Department is
ed periodically by one or more special grand in Yaphank, with other offices in Hauppauge,
juries. A grand jury consists of 23 members, 16 of Brentwood, Riverhead and Central Islip. In 1999,
whom must be present at all times to function, 17,514 cases were supervised by more than 100
and 12 of whom must agree on a verdict. Each probation officers. The individual supervisory
regular grand jury sits for one month, usually caseload varies between 30 cases, for intensive
two to five days per week depending upon the probation or other special programs such as
need of the courts. A grand jury may be extend- those involving sex offenders or domestic vio-
ed into the next month if necessary. The average lence, to over 100 cases of regular probation
term of service is 20 days. Grand jurors must ful- supervision.
fill the same requirements as other jurors in
Suffolk County and are paid at the same daily The Director of Probation is appointed by the
rate. County Executive and must be confirmed by the
Suffolk County Legislature.
21
THE DISTRICT ATTORNEY fore eligibility for Legal Aid Society services, is
made according to guidelines based on weekly
The District Attorney (DA) is the chief prosecu- income and family size related to federal pover-
tor for Suffolk County and is elected by the vot- ty threshold levels.
ers of the County for a four-year term. The main
offices of the DA are in Riverhead, Hauppauge The criminal division of Legal Aid employs 50
and Central Islip. Aided by approximately 135 full-time graduate attorneys in its Central Islip
full-time Assistant District Attorneys (ADAs), and Riverhead offices. Turnover is minimal, so
the DA represents "The People" in prosecuting that most Legal Aid attorneys have at least five
felony and misdemeanor criminal cases in the years of courtroom experience.
Supreme, County, District and Town and Village The Legal Aid Society also acts as Law
Courts. Guardian for minors requiring representation in
the Supreme and Family Courts. Sixteen Legal
THE LEGAL AID SOCIETY Aid attorneys, based in the Central Islip
The Legal Aid Society of Suffolk County, with Courthouse, serve as Law Guardians, and 9 more
administrative offices at 5 Shore Lane in Bay are active in other capacities in the Family Court.
Shore, is a private organization which has been
in existence since 1956 and was incorporated to THE CRIMINAL JUSTICE
provide legal services to the indigent in civil mat-
ters. A U.S. Supreme Court ruling in the same COORDINATING COUNCIL
year (Gideon vs. Wainwright) stated that all per-
This 28-member council, appointed by the
sons accused of felonies must be represented by
County Executive, is composed of heads of law
counsel and a further expansion of this ruling
enforcement agencies and representatives of the
requires counsel to represent all persons accused
County Legislature, town and village govern-
of crimes that could lead to imprisonment. Since
ments, and all levels of the unified court system.
there was no office of public defender in Suffolk
Its mission is to improve law enforcement and
County, the Legal Aid Society was appointed as
the administration of criminal justice through
the representative of indigent defendants in the
fostering coordination and cooperation among
County. The Society can accept private funds, but
component groups. The Council, whose office is
in practice, all of its funding comes from the
in the H. Lee Dennison Building in Hauppauge,
County and the State.
meets quarterly; its member serve without com-
The determination of "indigency," and there- pensation.
Photo  Adam Gaus
First Presbyterian Church of Smithtown, NY
Celebrating 325th Anniversary, 2001
22