This is pretty much my worst nightmare (as a Geno fan). The Chiefs pass on him and the Raiders take him and he crushes the AFC West for years to come. Basically plays out like the Gannon situation, only this time the Raiders get the guy for 10+ years.

Quote:

#Raiders: Rumor mill is working through the league that Oakland scouts love Geno Smith. Front office is ready for a new QB.

I'd rather find out if he is going be good or not with the Chiefs than the ****tard raitards. We deserve the #1pick to be the best QB in the draft and looks like that is Geno Smith. The only reason any one not to like Geno Smith is if they are racist or coward.

I don't agree with that last sentence.

I believe there are some games, especially the Pinstripe Bowl, that raised some questions for many, and for many, if not most, that have raised those questions, those games might be the only ones they saw.

That said, Dorsey and the Chiefs have 3 years of game tape, including a sophmore season that was played in a pro set, and a number of games against top level talent, including last year's Orange Bowl, to recognize and appreciate the tools he brings to the table.

This is a guy that has all the tools to succeed at a high level with top notch coaching.

The top QB or 2 NEVER ****ing go to the senior bowl why is this hard to understand? Is Matt Ryan a coward how about Eli Manning? They didn't go.Posted via Mobile Device

I'd think you'd want to go if you're not considered a sure fire top ten prospect. Ryan and Manning were. I really like Smith, but it seems a lot of important people question his game. He needs to improve his draft stock in the next few months show he's worthy of the first overall pick, not to me or anyone on CP, clearly we're convinced, but to the teams that question him.

I'd think you'd want to go if you're not considered a sure fire top ten prospect. Ryan and Manning were. I really like Smith, but it seems a lot of important people question his game. He needs to improve his draft stock in the next few months show he's worthy of the first overall pick, not to me or anyone on CP, clearly we're convinced, but to the teams that question him.

IMO if the 4 years of in-game tape don't convince anyone, a meaningless scrimmage won't do it either.

I believe there are some games, especially the Pinstripe Bowl, that raised some questions for many, and for many, if not most, that have raised those questions, those games might be the only ones they saw.

That said, Dorsey and the Chiefs have 3 years of game tape, including a sophmore season that was played in a pro set, and a number of games against top level talent, including last year's Orange Bowl, to recognize and appreciate the tools he brings to the table.

This is a guy that has all the tools to succeed at a high level with top notch coaching.

I keep wavering back and forth on whether I think the Chiefs draft him or not. There's a long time until the draft, the Chiefs will most likely have signed or traded for a veteran QB before then, and everyone will freak out because they'll think that means no QB in the first round. But if Geno works his way up the board, like I think he will, the Chiefs will take him.

Maybe we shall see. But my only concern I have seen so many qb`s light it up in college and not the nfl. A big concern is when he faced a top defense he folds and pouts like a baby. A Randall cunningham or doug williams he is not. Those players fought when challenged. They did not fold. Also that fact he did not even bother to show at the senior bowl shows a serious lack of character and commitment and thats a big red flag.

Quote:

Originally Posted by tony77

You guys act like geno is everything . Like hes a can `t miss prospect. I think alot of you are only looking at one thing when it comes to geno. If he was so good he would of sucked it up and been at the senior bowl. Him not being there just made him look like a coward period.

You haven't raised any legitimate or serious concerns.

Your comments are vague and without foundation.

Sure, he's struggled against some good teams, as do all QBs whose OL struggles to provide protection.

He has also made big plays against top notch opponents, even with pressure in his face, and kept his team in games that they had no business being in otherwise.

The talent deficit between his WVU team and the better teams they faced was Grand Canyon wide chasm.

He and his receivers, the only other real talent on that team, were Evil Knevel trying to jump that chasm.

Every college QB is a question mark coming into the NFL.

And the contention that skipping the Senior Bowl is cowardly is pure drivel.

IMO if the 4 years of in-game tape don't convince anyone, a meaningless scrimmage won't do it either.

hey, I thought he was a can't miss first overall pick halfway through the season, but then WV started losing a lot, and Geno, while he still looked good was struggling a bit against better competition. I stopped thinking of him as a can't miss QB, and more as a first rounder that may or may not pan out.

hey, I thought he was a can't miss first overall pick halfway through the season, but then WV started losing a lot, and Geno, while he still looked good was struggling a bit against better competition. I stopped thinking of him as a can't miss QB, and more as a first rounder that may or may not pan out.

I'm just saying that the tape doesn't lie. When our team's scouts look over everything, the last thing they look at, if they even look at it, will be the Senior Bowl. The only real reason for a player to attend Senior Bowl is to allow teams a chance to talk with you and see your personality more, which will be taken care of in excess with the Combine and College Pro Days. If a team needs more face time there is also the chance to call the player in after the Combine and talk with him face-to-face.