Montag, 5. März 2012

"Touchwiz" (TW) is the name Samsung gave to the custom Android UI deployed on their mobile devices (except Nexus devices). It can be compared to "Sense" on HTC or "Motoblur" on Motorola. Now when talking about touchwiz most people just think about the launcher (twlauncher).

They don't get that Touchwiz is much more than just a launcher. It customizes several aspects of the phone's UI. So, I took the time to compare Touchwiz and to the default Android UI. I took my Galaxy S and loaded it with a recent build of a Samsung's stock firmware (gingerbread.JVZ, Android 2.3.6) and compared the experience to AOSP (Android Open Source Project) by installing a nightly build of Cyanogen 7.2.

Admittedly this approach is not completely accurate as CyanogenMod comes with some minor modifications to AOSP as well. Also the galaxy S only supports TouchWiz 3.5, while the Galaxy S2 is shipped with TouchWiz 4.0 which contains some improvements to its predecessor.

I don't want to start ranting about TouchWiz right away, so I'll do the rant about it a little later.

Launcher

The first difference is the Launcher.

Both offer several desktops that can be navigated by horizontal swipe gestures and a dock with configurable shortcuts. One of them takes the user to the "App Drawer".

The TouchWiz Launcher presents apps in pages that can be switched by horizontal swiping. Although the initial order is alphabetical, newly installed apps are appended to the end of the list, so the position of the icons remains stable. The order can however be customized manually by entering the "edit-mode". In this mode the user can also uninstall apps directly from the app drawer.
The AOSP Launcher presents the apps in a vertically scrollable list with the apps ordered alphabetically. New apps are inserted at the appropriate spot so that the ordering remains alphabetical. Icons cannot be manually rearranged.

The launcher can easily be replaced by installing a third-party launcher (like ADW or Launcher Pro) from the Market.

Dialer

The dialer is what appears when clicking the phone-symbol.

Both dialers support T9 contact matching. The TouchWiz dialer presents direct shortcuts for texts or video calls. To access the text-shortcut in the AOSP-dialer the user has to press the menu-key.

Calendar

Another major difference is the calendar app. They all provide month-, week-, day- and task overview.

TouchWiz uses a dark theme for the calendar while the AOSP one uses a white background.

The Touchwiz calendar does not show descriptions for entries in the week overview. All day events are indicated by displaying a blue triangle at the day-label.

The TouchWiz calendar marks days as occupied as soon as there is one entry. The AOSP calendar displays the entries of the days as a bar.

Music

The music apps look different but support similar features.

The main difference is that TouchWiz Music does not offer a widget, but a more powerful notification bar entry.

Clock

The clock apps differ quite a bit.

In addition to the alarm clock feature the TouchWiz provides a world clock, stop watch and a countdown timer. The AOSP clock provides an alarm feature and displays the weather on the main page.

Contacts

Messaging

The TouchWiz Messaging App follows the "iPhone-style" for displaying conversations.

Mail

Calculator

The TouchWiz calculator offers a two-line display and a few more buttons.

There are several other modifications Samsung made to the AOSP experience like