Pop Culture: Napa Valley Soda Co. Orange & Cream

It didn't take long for Napa Valley Soda Co.'s marketing shtick to work on our tasters. "Look, it's from Napa Valley, I bet it's good," said our art director, Peter Storch, upon seeing four bottles of the stuff, purchased from Big Lots for $2. After trying the stuff, he wasn't disappointed.

Verdict: NVSCo.'s Orange & Cream tastes a lot like creamsicle, and that's a good thing. Perfectly balanced with just the right amount of sweetness, and a creaminess so real it leaves your mouth feeling milky.

Jasmine: "Oh, I like it. Mmmmm, yummy."

Jessica: "It tastes just like a creamsicle, it even has that aftertaste."