I would take Gay I think. With Gasol out, he is the man now in Memphis. I think what sets them apart is consistency. Johnson has plenty of shooting off nights and doesnt do a whole lot on tne defense end when compared to Gay IMO. Gay is a special player because he averages nearly a block, steal, and three a game which is a rarity. I think a few may disagree with me here, but other than assists, Gay seems like the best option.

That same question was on NBA TV ---Fantasy Basketball show. Was that you on the phone? The host said that he would rather have JJ, and usually I agree with their opinions. However, this time I didn't. I'd rather have Rudy Gay...Especially after Gasol was traded...Huge upside with Gay. His defensive numbers have been a little down. But, the guy is a fantastic player and will eventually be an all-star. Rudy Gay all the WAY!

this is very tough. with pau gone Gay could be a good choice. Joe Johnson is much better offensively averaging 1 more point and around 4 more assists. Defensively Gay but he could get better offensively. since Pau left he has had a 15 point game and a 28 point game. I believe he would average aroung 22 points or 23 with no Pau. I would wait and see how it goes