Would yall agree that more mental stuff is "scarier" than flat out gruesome/gross right?

And as far as best horror goes that would simply mean the best movie overall right? Plot, Acting, Killing scenes, etc.. not necessarily whether or not it was the scariest? Or maybe the best should be the scariest? I don't know the rules here..

I don't think Let the right one in was as good as advertised. Scream was a classic and deserves to be up there. I haven't seen enough horror to know tho.