Despite receiving mixed (at best) reviews from critics, "Gershwin's Porgy and Bess" won the Tony Award for best revival of a musical.

The win is a surprising, considering Broadway purists cried foul when the production rewrote much of the book ... We love the flawless Audra McDonald and Norm Lewis, but our vote would have went to Stephen Sondheim's seminal "Follies." It was pure magic.