Google’s Updated reCAPTCHA Service May Require No Clicking

Nobody likes CAPTCHAs. They’re annoying. They slow you down when you’re trying to log into a site that has data you need. Unfortunately, CAPTCHAs themselves proved necessary to help weed out bots and keep them at bay.

They come in a variety of shapes and sizes, but in Google’s case, they began using text digitized during the course of the company’s massive Book Indexing project.

As that project began winding down, they shifted gears, using street names and other data taken by their global mapping project. Later still, they shifted gears again, adopting a much simpler and less annoying “I am a Human” checkbox, which is a notable improvement, but still an extra step that keeps you from the information you need longer than necessary.

“Google is introducing “invisible reCAPTCHAs,” or CAPTCHAs that automatically disappear when a human user is detected. Form fillers that trip Google’s Advanced Risk Analysis algorithms will still have to solve the CAPTCHA test, but most users won’t see it at all.”

It’s a huge win in terms of convenience, if it works, and that’s the catch.

While great strides have been made in machine learning with Google at the forefront, it remains to be seen whether the technology is up to the task of differentiating humans from machines.

It’s important, because as smartphones eclipse the personal computer as the king of the digital world, CAPTCHAs are problematic. They’re hard to use effectively, given the small screen sizes of the vast majority of smart devices sold today.

At the root, of course, the problem is the existence of the bots themselves. CAPTCHAs of any kind would be unnecessary if they weren’t a factor that needed to be taken into account. Unfortunately, there’s no way to un-ring that bell. They’re as much of a fact of life on the web as web pages themselves, and until some better paradigm can be developed, the CAPTCHA is the best and most effective method found to date of dealing with them. Of course, there are critics, such as Brian Feldman, select/all, NYMag, who writes, “Google’s CAPTCHA system is a large-scale operation for harvesting data to use however it sees fit. Is it nefarious? Hardly. But will it pose challenges in the long term? Definitely.”