If this is your first visit, be sure to
check out the FAQ by clicking the
link above. You may have to register
before you can post: click the register link above to proceed. To start viewing messages,
select the forum that you want to visit from the selection below.

Threaded View

ASP.NET vs. Flash vs. Java

Fellow programmer's, I would appreciate your opinions based on your many years
of experience about client technologies and technical strategy.

My customer wants a cross platform, offline capable, data entry application.
Before I knew of the cross platform and offline requirements, I was pushing
Windows Forms or Web Forms. Due to the new requirements, the following matrix
was proposed:

Basically, he is leaning towards Flash first and Java Second. The predetermined
delivery date is March 2003 (They wanted January). 2 - 3 months have been
slated for development. This would compete against an existing product that
is a pre-.NET Win32 desktop application from a competitor. They want to beat
out the competition by getting in Mac users. Offline is debateable and was
to be put off until the next phase but they didn't want two or more UIs.

My recommendation is ASP.NET if rich data entry and offline are acceptable
tradeoffs. Flash would come next. However, I am getting the sense that Java
or Flash would be the best tool for the job.

Several questions:

1. Am I missing anything related to the breakdown of the technologies?
2. Is there a way to maintain the .NET technologies and achieve the customer's
desires? I am thinking, no, but I have to double check just in case. The
decision will be based off of all relevant parameters.
3. Would anyone do anything differently?

I will post this in a few areas to get different perspectives. Thank you
in advance.