LOVE the style and fit of this penny loafer. This isn't your traditional penny loafer. This is shaped through the toe so it has a narrow feel to it. If you have wider feet, you may want to be careful with the sizing. I have relatively average feet and I ordered my regular size and am happy. I can wear this shoe all day and my feet feel like I just put them on at the end of the day.

Question. After wearing the shoe for a month or so, my left shoe has developed a clicking noise in the heel with every step. Any one else experience this, or have suggestions for fixing it? I bought the shoe in San Francisco and do not have a Cole Haan store anywhere in my vicinity. Plus, I'm pretty sure I've lost the receipt and box by now. Appreciate suggestions!!

I wore these shoes, no socks, all day long moving a loved one into college. I couldn't believe the comfort, stability and of course, style! Buy all you can in both colors. Great with just about anything. Only negative I would share is, the 'penny' slot is not real. I think even more of a statement would be made with a shiny penny in there!