SF Tries to Curb Panhandling with Puppies and Stipends

When it comes to tackling San Francisco’s entrenched panhandling problem, City Hall has tried just about everything: laws banning aggressive panhandling and sitting on sidewalks, teams of service providers who attempt to get beggars off the streets, and an employment program to get them hired at nearby businesses.

But it’s never tried puppies – until now.

Starting Aug. 1, the city – in a program believed to be the first of its kind in the country – will attempt to lure panhandlers to give up their cardboard signs and metal cups in exchange for a small stipend to foster problematic puppies at the city’s Animal Care and Control, making them ready for adoption.

Bevan Dufty, Mayor Ed Lee’s point person on homelessness, is calling his new program Wonderful Opportunities for Occupants and Fidos, or Woof. Dufty said it’s a win-win for the panhandlers and the puppies – even if it may prompt eye-rolls at first.

“I’m tired of pushing people around. You can make it difficult for people to panhandle, but ultimately they’re just going to go do it somewhere else,” he said. “Why not try to meet their needs for income in a way that helps the city and its animals?”
Ideal pairing in Tenderloin

Dufty points to Matt Traywick and his best friend, a 4-year-old bichon mix named Charlie, as an ideal pairing.

Eighteen months ago, Traywick was a formerly homeless man living in the Empress Hotel, a supportive housing complex in the Tenderloin. He struggled with severe depression and isolation after leaving the streets.

“You have no phone, and there’s nobody knocking on your door,” said Traywick, 52. “It’s not as happy an experience as you’d think it might be.”

A friend finally dragged him to the Animal Care and Control shelter, where he fell in love with Charlie, who was so skinny you could count his ribs and whose fur was so matted it had to be shaved off. Traywick adopted Charlie, and now the two venture out for walks eight or nine times a day.

Charlie is now well fed, sports fluffy white fur, and easily bounds up the six steep flights of stairs to his owner’s hotel room. Traywick, too, is healthier and happier.

“I never go to bed by myself, and I never wake up by myself,” he said. “It makes me walk with my head a little higher.”
Finding the right fit

Traywick adopted Charlie without the help of a city program. But he thinks Dufty’s idea could help other formerly homeless people and puppies find the same kind of enjoyment.

Animal Care and Control will screen applicants to ensure they’re a good fit for Woof. They must be living in supportive housing and not on the streets; the city has anecdotal evidence to suggest the majority of panhandlers are housed, but supplement their income through begging or just don’t have anything else to occupy their time.

The applicants must also show they’re not severely mentally ill, aren’t hoarders, don’t have a history of violence, and are seeking treatment if they have addictions. They also must pledge to forswear panhandling, and if they’re caught begging with the puppy, the animal will be taken back to the shelter.

In exchange, they’ll receive $50 to $75 a week, several training sessions provided by an animal behavior specialist at Animal Care and Control as well as regular check-ins by that person, and all the dog food, toys, leashes and veterinary care they need. A $10,000 grant to Animal Care and Control from Vanessa Getty will provide the seed money for the program, and Dufty said he’ll seek more philanthropic donations.
S.F.’s huge influx of dogs

Dufty said Woof will start with just a handful of guardians, but he hopes to expand it to include many more and eventually train them in grooming, dog walking or other animal-related skills so they can hold regular jobs.

Rebecca Katz, director of Animal Care and Control, said the program will help the city’s shelter cope with its huge influx of dogs caused by the economic downturn. The shelter is receiving 500 more dogs per year than it did before the recession struck because owners can no longer afford their pets.

But about 15 percent of dogs are deemed not adoptable because they’re not socialized and are rowdy, hyper or too shy to interact with humans – and those dogs are eventually euthanized.

Katz hopes more of them can be made adoptable by being fostered in the Woof program. She said the formerly homeless people living in supportive housing could be ideal foster guardians because they can spend the entire day with the puppy. The Woof participants could opt to adopt the animal at the end of two to six weeks or return the animal to the shelter and foster another one.

So far, the groups that run the supportive housing units are cautiously supportive of the idea. Krista Gaeta is the deputy director of the Tenderloin Housing Clinic, which operates 1,600 units – none of which allows regular pets, but all of which allow service or companion animals as deemed necessary by medical providers.
Protecting dogs, residents

Gaeta said she wants to ensure that the dogs fostered in the program aren’t aggressive, which could scare other already on-edge residents, and that the clinic will have the right to say a particular pairing isn’t working.

But Katz hopes Woof can be successful, and she still carries a letter she received from Traywick three months after he adopted Charlie.

“My case manager dubbed him TLC – Tenderloin Charlie – because everyone needs a little TLC now and then,” Traywick wrote. “If I do a decent job as a parent, he’s going to be a magnificent animal when he grows up. I can’t believe how lucky we both are.”

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Comment

Name *

Email *

Website

Annie Dillard

Our life is a faint tracing on the surface of mystery, like the idle, curved tunnels of leaf miners on the face of a leaf. We must somehow take a wider view, look at the whole landscape, really see it, and describe what's going on here. Then we can at least wail the right question into the swaddling band of darkness or, if it comes to that, choir the proper praise.

Jane Addams

“[T]he good we secure for ourselves is precarious and uncertain, is floating in mid-air, until it is secured for all of us and incorporated into our common life.”

Albert Einstein

"Our task must be to free ourselves by widening our circle of compassion to embrace all living creatures and the whole of nature and its beauty. "

Buckminster Fuller

"You never change things by fighting the existing reality. To change something, build a new model that makes the existing model obsolete"

Dr. David Hawkins in “Power vs. Force”

“In this interconnected universe, every improvement we make in our private world improves the world at large for everyone. We all float on the collective level of consciousness of mankind, so that any increment we add comes back to us. We all add to our common buoyancy by our efforts to benefit life. It is a scientific fact that what is good for you is good for me.”

Deepak Chopra

“Every problem that we face right now, whether it’s war, terrorism, social injustice,economic disparities, or global warming, would be creatively addressed by our collective consciousness moving to a new level.”

Professor Tom Regan

“The other animals humans eat, use in science, hunt, trap, and exploit in a variety of ways, have a life of their own that is of importance to them apart from their utility to us. They are not only in the world, they are aware of it. What happens to them matters to them. Each has a life that fares better or worse for the one whose life it is.”