Cleveland Indians left-fielder Shelley Duncan used all of his six-foot-five frame to make spectacular – and eerily similar — catches on three consecutive Texas Ranger batters.

Elvis Andrus was the first victim of Duncan’s glove when he hit a drive to the left-field wall with one out in the bottom of the first. Then Duncan robbed Josh Hamilton at almost exactly the same spot to end the inning. Michael Young lead off the bottom of the second and, lo-and-behold, he hit a shot to the wall in left that Duncan leapt up and snagged. Watch all three great catches below: