Considering their primary goal for the BMAH is to remove gold from the economy, I think they should add really rare stuff like this that can't be obtained anywhere else. Sure, some lucky ducker will probably max out the bid instantly, but that is a lot of gold being removed at once.

tbh, since 999,999g is max at BMAH, it isn't that much gold removed from each realm. Maybe a low pop realm, but it would not take the realm as a whole to gain the 999,999g back they spent, and with these items been extremely rare, even on BMAH, it's not a good way of removing gold. They remove large chunks, but as a whole, it's not even a dent in the overall server market.

No. I don't have Ashbringer but I do not want it to be obtainable through BMAH. Ashbringer made no sense to be an obtainable item in the first place, leave it removed.

This

also the fact what makes most people "want it to have" is that its so rare, when it would be on the bmah it would become just an other epic (with a bit lore behind like for example Skull of Guldan, but rly who cares about that?) Putting T3 on BMAH was a big fail, putting such an item on BMAH would completely destroy my hope in Blizzards Gamedesigner, and no i dont have one either

Btw the WoW Economy is totaly broken the BMAH didnt change something here, prevent Botting more and make Herbs/Minerals and overall Crafting more Rare would have been a better solution but this would just end in another big QQMIMI

Sure. I personally wouldn't want it, I thought it was an ugly item, but there isn't really any reason why items with unique models like that (and the misplaced servo arm) shouldn't end up on the BMAH eventually. It's not like there is any real prestige to those items or anything. A lot of the people with Naxx era transmogs before the BMAH just did runs at level 70. Removes large sums of gold from the economy and people get a semi-unique look to their items. Go for it.

I personally think it's the coolest and most epic looking weapon Blizz have ever designed.

Do you really? I never understood that. It's too big, weird shape, old ugly low res texture, weird floating skull. I think it's hideous. So, do you really think it's better then any other weapon out there, or do you just say that because... well.. I don't know.

Do you really? I never understood that. It's too big, weird shape, old ugly low res texture, weird floating skull. I think it's hideous. So, do you really think it's better then any other weapon out there, or do you just say that because... well.. I don't know.

Yes, but the voices which came with the weapon, that made it "the" weapon

It should be put up there, 1 mil gold for a transmog are people really going to be upset?

This is WoW, people get upset about everything. People are upset that plate wearers can transmog the ugly low-res Tier 3 model. As long as people keep paying insane amounts of gold for old transmog gear, the look is still going to remain pretty uncommon.

tbh, since 999,999g is max at BMAH, it isn't that much gold removed from each realm. Maybe a low pop realm, but it would not take the realm as a whole to gain the 999,999g back they spent, and with these items been extremely rare, even on BMAH, it's not a good way of removing gold. They remove large chunks, but as a whole, it's not even a dent in the overall server market.

To be fair WoW is kind've like irl when it comes to wealth, in my guild of 800 people only 3 (including myself) have over 100k on them at all times. Thats a ton of people and majority of them don't have 10k. Sure the whole realm has lots of gold but its more like this 70% have under 20k 20% have under 50k 5% have under half a mill and 4% around 1 mil and only like 01% has multiple millions.

---------- Post added 2013-04-25 at 02:49 PM ----------

Originally Posted by RoKPaNda

This is WoW, people get upset about everything. People are upset that plate wearers can transmog the ugly low-res Tier 3 model. As long as people keep paying insane amounts of gold for old transmog gear, the look is still going to remain pretty uncommon.

You could get it in BC, at 70 its not like naxx was a challenege. People just like to act superior because they were raiding back then. It's not like back then you couldn't pay for a carry and pay for the wep.

Besides, gamewise tirion is using it but he cleansed it. This did not happen with any of the other legendaries or epic looking rare purples, they can still be obtained the same way or they arent enough important in warcraft story.

I have Nightmare Blade from Nightmare dragons and its pretty sweet to have it and nobody else has it. :P

Besides, gamewise tirion is using it but he cleansed it. This did not happen with any of the other legendaries or epic looking rare purples, they can still be obtained the same way or they arent enough important in warcraft story.

I have Nightmare Blade from Nightmare dragons and its pretty sweet to have it and nobody else has it. :P

So reasoning here is, don't help stop inflation because people want to be special snowflakes? To be fair were talking BMAH its going to be cap to get it when it does pop on your realm and big deal lorewise (gorehowl drops in kara).

So reasoning here is, don't help stop inflation because people want to be special snowflakes? To be fair were talking BMAH its going to be cap to get it when it does pop on your realm and big deal lorewise (gorehowl drops in kara).

Your kidding right? The BMAH doesnt do shit to the economy. When you have unlimited resources the only thing thats going to happen is mass inflation. These people sitting on millions of gold arent ever going to run out, they arent going to be crippled after buying an item on the BMAH.

Your kidding right? The BMAH doesnt do shit to the economy. When you have unlimited resources the only thing thats going to happen is mass inflation. These people sitting on millions of gold arent ever going to run out, they arent going to be crippled after buying an item on the BMAH.

The most ive ever met someone with was 8 million and thats 20% of his gold for one transmog, hate it all you want a million gold can effect the market if its all being used. This is how blizzard is trying to get some of that gold out of the picture.

Because everyone that has a good sum of gold must have botted it right?
They might aswell add it to BMAH, it's not like getting it at level 70 with a couple of mates was that hard.

Not unless those "mates" had raided Naxx at 60. The original Naxx was not trivial even at 70. The mechanics in it were designed to kill, you needed at least 15 people (at a t6 level) to have a chance to clear the whole place. To top that off the Ashbringer was not a common drop.

As to the topic itself, the Corrupted Ashbringer shouldn't be put on the BMAH. As Tommo has said, what Blizzard should really be focusing its efforts on is working on making good armor rather than crap that people don't want to be seen wearing.

Not unless those "mates" had raided Naxx at 60. The original Naxx was not trivial even at 70. The mechanics in it were designed to kill, you needed at least 15 people (at a t6 level) to have a chance to clear the whole place. To top that off the Ashbringer was not a common drop.

As to the topic itself, the Corrupted Ashbringer shouldn't be put on the BMAH. As Tommo has said, what Blizzard should really be focusing its efforts on is working on making good armor rather than crap that people don't want to be seen wearing.

ToT gear is great in 2 xpacs you'll still see groups doing it from transmog.