Casper vs Tempurpedic: A Complete Comparison Guide To The Best Mattress

This in-depth, unbiased guide is a Sleeping Ninjas showdown between Casper vs Tempurpedic to help you select the best mattress. Disclosure: Sleeping Ninjas has an affiliate relationship with some companies where we get a small percentage of sales if you click over from our site.

Here, we’ve compiled a complete comparison review of Casper vs Tempurpedic to help determine which of these two mattresses will be fit your individual needs.

Construction: What’s It Made Of?

One of the first things to consider when you find yourself shopping for a new mattress is the overall construction of the product. There are so many different materials available these days and they all offer different qualities and benefits.

Below, we’ll compare the construction of Casper vs Tempurpedic to determine which mattress offers the best quality.

Casper Construction

The Casper is a hybrid mattress that combines the best qualities of both latex and memory foam to provide their customers with a top-notch comfort that doesn’t fall short on support.

Breathable Memory Foam

The topmost layer of the Casper mattress features ultra-breathable memory foam. The memory foam used by Casper is constructed with an open-cell formula. This allows the Casper mattress to guarantee all of the cradling, molding, and pressure relieving abilities that you’ve come to expect while remaining cool and breathable, unlike conventional memory foam.

Pressure Relieving Memory Foam

Underneath the layer of breathable, open-cell foam is a layer of pressure relieving memory foam. This layer provides consumers with all of the very best properties that memory foam has to offer. This layer is specially designed for top-notch pressure relief. It cradles joints and problem areas such as the hips and shoulders which helps to reduce pain, stiffness, and numbness – allowing Casper users to wake up well-rested, rejuvenated, and ready to take on the day.

Zoned Support Memory Foam

The Casper company is just as concerned about their support as they are their comfort. Casper makes sure that your body is getting all the support it needs in all the right places by equipping their 3rd layers with zoned support memory foam. They user firmer memory foam materials in the areas that rest under the lower back and neck while equipping it with softer materials under areas like the shoulders and hips – allowing for a perfect firmness vs softness ratio and proper alignment.

Supportive Latex Foam

To ensure that their mattress will provide their customers with optimal, crucial support, the last layer of their mattress is equipped with thick, supportive latex foam. This latex layer reinforces the above layers of the mattress and enhances their overall performance as well as adding to the firm support.

Casper has combined all these layers perfectly to create one comfortable, supportive mattress.

Tempurpedic Construction

Smart Climate System

The topmost layer of the Tempurpedic mattress is equipped with a 2-layer Smart Climate System that’s been specifically designed to safeguard against heat retention under all conditions. The Easy Refresh top cover is designed to work in conjunction with the Smart Climate System. The top cover wicks away sweat and heat quickly and efficiently while the Smart Climate System features an inner layer that guarantees a cool to the touch feel against the skin.

Comfort Layer

The next layer of the Tempurpedic mattress features TEMPER-ES material, exclusive to Tempurpedic. This super-soft, ultra-luxurious material actually determines the overall feel of the mattress and works in unison with the dynamic support system a few layers below to allow the mattress to adapt to the individual body, making for unsurpassed, customizable support that folks have come to expect from the Tempurpedic brand.

Response Layer

The next layer of the Tempurpedic mattress does just what it says – provides top-notch, crucial bounce-back and responsiveness. The TEMPUR-Response material used in this layer is exclusive to the Tempurpedic brand and provides just the right amount of springiness, helps provide overall support, and distributes body weight evenly to avoid areas of pressure and also increases the durability and lifespan of the mattress.

Dynamic Support Layer

The dynamic support layer is designed to work in perfect harmony with the layer above. The innovative precision coils are placed densely throughout the mattress Thanks to these coils in combination with the response layer, the Tempurpedic mattress can provide instant and active reactions to each and every movement of the body.

Base Layer

The base layer of the Tempurpedic mattress serves a few purposes. It reinforces the durability and stability of the entire mattress, enhances the performance of the above layers, and disperses heat through the bottom of the mattress away from the body.

Easy Refresh Top Cover

While it’s not uncommon for mattresses to feature some sort of plush cover, it is a bit rare for them to be removable and washable. However, Tempurpedic has made sure that theirs is. The Easy Refresh cover is designed with a double zipper that makes removal quick and easy from any side of the mattress ensuring that you can wash or even replace the cover with no hassle. The cover has been wear-tested to ensure durability and allows you to keep your mattress clean and hygienic as well as soft and plush against the skin.

Who Wins?

We’re thoroughly impressed with the plush, luxurious layers featured in the Tempurpedic mattress. But, when comparing the overall construction of Casper vs Tempurpedic, we actually have to give the win to Casper on this one. They take a more minimalistic approach, but hey use high-quality materials and utilize latex to ensure that you’re getting the firm support you need as well as the comfort that you desire.

Temperature Control

Sleeping on a too-hot mattress is a miserable experience. It leaves you tossing and turning through the night, reducing the amount of quality REM sleep, and causes you to be unfocused and groggy upon waking. It’s fairly commonplace for mattresses to come equipped with some sort of heat retention safeguards these days.

Here, we’ll be comparing the temperature regulation of Tempurpedic vs Casper to see which mattress will keep you the coolest and most comfortable.

Casper

Every last inch of the Casper mattress is equipped with some level of temperature control properties. The very top layer of the mattress features an open-cell formula that harnesses the powers of convection and conduction to draw heat in and move it away from the body.

Underneath the layer of open cell memory foam is an additional layer of memory foam that’s designed to pull the heat away from the top layer of the Casper mattress, ensuring that no heat is trapped against the body. It also ensures that you’re always getting fresh air against the skin by providing ideal breathability as well as air flow.

Casper even utilizes the very bottom layer of their mattress to guarantee that it always stays cool and comfortable under any conditions. The latex foam is guaranteed to absorb the body heat that’s been pulled from the top layers and disperse it evenly throughout the bottom of the mattress – keeping it far away from the skin.

Tempurpedic

It’s fairly well known that conventional memory foam is usually a pretty hot material. It’s definitely plush and comfortable, but thanks to its density, it often traps heat and isn’t known for its breathability. However, the Tempurpedic company has found a way around this problem.

All of the mattresses available through Tempurpedic are equipped with at least 3 individual layers of temperature controlling properties. Much like their Casper competitors, Tempurpedic utilizes their base to draw heat from the top layers and disperse it evenly and effectively far away from the top surface of the mattress.

Each Tempurpedic mattress also features the Smart Climate System that wicks away sweat and heat within the top layer and provides a cool feel to the touch through the inner layer. The easy Refresh cover featured on the Tempurpedic mattress works in conjunction with the Smart Climate system to quickly wick away moisture and heat and is also completely washable to ensure that it always stays fresh.

While these temperature regulations are standard in every mattress, you can also add the TEMPUR-Breeze Cooling System for an additional cost which according to the official website is an “integrated system of technologies to help keep your body cooler as you sleep”.

Who Wins?

When comparing the overall temperature controlling properties of Tempurpedic vs Casper, Casper takes the win again. Both mattresses integrate most all of their construction as a defense against heat retention. However, to get the very most out of the Tempurpedic mattress, you’re stuck forking out additional cash.

Overall Comfort: Softness vs Firmness

There are tons of things to consider when you’re shopping for the perfect mattress. But, most importantly is the comfort. A mattress isn’t worth bringing home if you’re not going to be comfortable sleeping on it night after night. It’s truly impossible to find a mattress that meets the firmness desires of every individual. But, usually, a medium-firm option is most popular.

Let’s compare the firmness to softness ratio as well as the overall comfort featured in Tempurpedic vs Casper.

Casper

The Casper mattress is marketed as a medium-firm option, which is the most common firmness level. Like the Tempurpedic, Casper’s primary material is memory foam. However, they equip their mattresses with a firm, supportive latex base that ensures the mattress provides the stability and firmness that most sleepers desire.

This guarantees that their mattress provides all the best pressure relieving properties and joint cradling abilities of memory foam without skimping on the crucial firmness and support.

Tempurpedic

The designers of Tempurpedic had a top-notch luxury in mind when creating their mattress. Like their Casper competitor, their primary material is memory foam, which is known for its pressure relieving and joint cradling but not for its firmness or support. But, once again, Tempurpedic believes they’ve found a way around this common memory foam issue.

The Tempurpedic company offers a wide variety of mattresses ranging in firmness levels that are made to meet the needs of several different individuals, allowing you to tailor your mattress to your specific needs. Their most common mattresses are their medium-firm options that seem to meet the needs of the largest percentage.

If you use the official website, you can narrow down your search based on the firmness level you’re looking for as well as other amenities and benefits.

Who Wins?

You’ll notice in the review section of our comparison that consumers of both mattresses are highly satisfied with the comfort they get out of their respective mattresses. But, you’ll also notice that some Tempurpedic users complain that no matter the mattress option they chose, the Tempurpedic is still a bit too soft and unsupportive for their taste. So, in the overall comfort category of Casper vs Tempurpedic, Casper takes the win once again.

Price: Casper vs Tempurpedic

You want to ensure that your new mattress will offer you prime comfort and cooling technology as well as high-quality construction. But, it’s always nice if all those benefits don’t have to break the bank.

Let’s take a look at the price tags that come along with Tempurpedic vs Casper to determine which mattress will give you the best bang for your buck.

Casper

The queen-size Casper option comes in at just under $1000. Considering the amenities and benefits and amenities that the mattress has to offer, this isn’t a bad price point.

The prices of the Casper mattress are as follows:

Twin – $595

Twin XL – $645

Full – $895

Queen – $995

King – $1195

California King – $1195

It’s also worth noting that you can upgrade your Casper purchase from a king to a California king-size option at no additional cost.

Tempurpedic

It’s no secret that the Tempurpedic mattress isn’t a cheap option. Their mattress screams luxury and their price tag proves it. In fact, even their smallest size option is over $2000. Plus, the addition of the extra cooling system will run you between $1000-$2000 more on the price.

The prices of the TEMPUR-Flex Supreme mattress, one of their most popular options, with and without the additional cooling system are as follows:

Twin – $2299

Twin Long – $2299/ An additional $1000 for the cooling system

Double – $2649/ $1000

Queen – $2799/ $1000

King – $3499/ $1000

Split King – $4598/ $2000

California King – $3499/ $1000

Split California King – $4598/ $2000

Unfortunately, Tempurpedic does not offer sales on their mattresses either. But, you will be receiving top-of-the-line quality, and they do offer to finance your purchase.

Who Wins?

Pros & Cons Of Casper vs Tempurpedic

It’s important to gather all the technical details of your potential purchases. But, definitely, don’t forget to take a look at the review section. It allows you to get real-world experiences and opinions as well as determine some of the common issues before you ever have to spend a dime.

Let’s take a look at some of the good and bad reviews of Tempurpedic vs Casper.

What Do Reviewers Love About Casper?

The Casper mattress certainly isn’t short on great reviews. But, the biggest praises come from the perfect ratio of softness to firmness. The makers of the Casper mattress were determined to create the perfect level of firmness in their mattress and it seems that they’ve made good on that promise. According to some reviewers, their Casper mattress has even alleviated many symptoms of illnesses or ailments such as pain and stiffness.

Pros

Nearly every inch of the Casper mattress is equipped with temperature control properties

The Casper mattress features a perfect balance of softness and firmness, backed by reviews

Reviewers have noted that Casper’s customer service department is timely and courteous

The Casper mattress comes with a pretty budget-friendly price tag for the benefits and amenities that it offers

Casper offers an industry standard sleep trial and warranty

What Are The Drawbacks Of Casper?

The biggest complaint revolving around the Casper mattress isn’t related to its performance, rather the smell. Because the Casper is compressed for shipping, the foam can accumulate an odor within the plastic. When the seal is broken the odor is released. This is a common issue, but many Casper users have noted that it took upwards of 2 weeks for the off-gassing odor to fully dissipate.

Cons

The Casper mattress leaves you susceptible to rolling off the bed as well as causing additional damage by sitting on the edge, due to a lack of sufficient edge support

The mattress has a tendency to lean to one side, especially when sleeping with a partner that’s larger than you

Some reviewers have noted that their Casper mattress wore down in as little as 6 months

Because of the way it’s compressed for shipping, it can take up to a full 72-hours for the Casper mattress to fully expand

What Do Reviewers Love About Tempurpedic?

As we expected, customers are absolutely in love with the comfort and plushness they get out of their Tempurpedic mattress. In true Tempurpedic memory foam style, the mattress perfectly cradles joints, relieves pressure points, and eliminates the pain, stiffness, and numbness that consumers were experiencing with their previous mattress.

Pros

A Tempurpedic mattress is a great option for couples, as split king or California king options are available to meet the needs of both individuals

The Tempurpedic company offers a free, complimentary white glove service to assist with set up and removal of your old mattress

Reviewers have noted that they’ve never experienced low spots or indentations even when they’re of a larger size

The memory foam construction allows for almost zero motion transference

The Tempurpedic company offers a wide variety of mattress, some even made especially for adjustable bases

What Are The Drawbacks Of Tempurpedic?

The makers and designers of the Tempurpedic mattress have worked very hard to try to provide a variety of mattresses to fit a variety of needs. However, it’s nearly impossible to actually please everyone. A handful of reviewers have complained that their Tempurpedic mattress, despite the hybrid construction, is a bit too soft for their liking. And find that it still lacks the adequate support they’re looking for.

Cons

The Tempurpedic company feels that their prices are a fair reflection of their quality, therefore they do not offer sales on their mattresses at any time

The use of heating pads or electric blankets are not advised as the memory foam reacts to heat and the use of these products may cause the material to become too soft

It can take upwards of 1-2 weeks for your Tempurpedic mattress to arrive

While all of their actual products are available online, some replacement parts can only be ordered through their phone order lines

Warranty: Casper vs Tempurpedic

When you’re searching for a new mattress for you or your family you want to make sure that you’re not skimping on a good warranty. Mattresses aren’t exactly cheap, even the budget-friendly ones, and you don’t want to be left footing the bill for a mattress that isn’t comfortable or breaks down quickly.

Below, we’ll be comparing the warranties offered by Tempurpedic vs Casper to see which company will keep you best protected.

Casper

The Casper company offers their customers a pretty standard sleep trial in addition to their standard warranty. When you purchase your Casper, you get 100 nights to use it in your home to determine if it’s the best fit for you. If you find that you’re not completely satisfied with your purchase, Casper will issue you a full refund and pick the mattress up from your home.

If you decide to keep your mattress after the sleep trial period is over, you will still be protected for the next 10 years of ownership by their limited warranty. The Casper company will repair or replace your mattress at their discretion and at no cost to you if the damage meets the terms of their warranty. They are not responsible for any damages resulting from improper use or strenuous abuse.

Tempurpedic

The Tempurpedic company also offers a fairly standard sleep trial and warranty with the purchase of their mattress. They offer a 90-day sleep trial that allows you to use your new Tempurpedic mattress in your home to determine if it’s perfect for you before you have to make any firm decision. If you’re unhappy with your purchase, Tempurpedic will give you a full refund within the 90-day period, less your shipping cost, and come to pick the mattress up from your home.

After the 90-day trial period is up, your purchase is still protected for the next 10 years. As long as the damage meets the terms of their warranty, you have all the necessary proof of purchase, and the mattress has been used properly, Tempurpedic will repair or replace your mattress at no cost to you.

The official Tempurpedic website does note that they are not affiliated with any third-party sellers such as Amazon or eBay. If you purchase your mattress from one of these dealers, they cannot guarantee the quality and it will not be covered by a valid Tempurpedic warranty.

Who Wins?

When comparing the warranties offered by Casper vs Tempurpedic, Casper has the slight leg up. Both companies offer a standard 10-year limited warranty, but Casper offers 10 more days on their sleep trial period.

About The Companies

Gathering all the details about the mattress companies you’re considering isn’t necessarily on the top of your to-do list. But, it’s never bad to get a rough idea of who you’re buying from. You can determine why they chose mattresses, how long they’ve been in business, or if they’ve received any recognition or awards. It can also help you make your decision if it’s been a tight race between two companies.

Here, we’ll take a look at a few of the pertinent details about the Casper vs Tempurpedic company.

Casper

The founders of Casper, much like many online mattress company founders these days, found themselves frustrated and fed up with the commonplace mattress buying process.

5 folks came together in 2014 to create a solution to their mattress buying problems. They created an online, direct-to-consumer mattress company that cut out the middleman cost as well as the big box experience to provide their customers with a high-quality, comfortable, and affordable mattress, less all the hassle.

Since their founding, the Casper company has been recognized by the New York Times, Forbes, and Good Morning America. The also received Good Housekeeping’s Lab Pick in 20018 as well as named one of the most innovative companies in 2017 by Fast company.

Tempurpedic

We couldn’t find anything on the official Tempurpedic website take gave any details pertaining to the company or its startup. However, we did do a quick internet search and determined that the company was first founded in 1992. So, they’ve certainly been around for a while. We also know that they partnered with the Ronald McDonald Charities to provide them with mattresses for their rooms in 2010. They also won the Electronic Retailing Association Award for direct marketing in 2009.

What’s Our Final Conclusion?

We certainly don’t deny that the Tempurpedic mattress offers top-notch luxury and comfort. But, it comes at a price that we’re not completely certain is worth it.

If you happen to be someone that can afford the splurge it would take to purchase the Tempurpedic, then we’re sure that you’ll find yourself highly satisfied. But, when it comes to overall satisfaction at an affordable cost, we feel that the Casper mattress can’t be beaten.