If this is your first visit, be sure to
check out the FAQ by clicking the
link above. You may have to register
before you can post: click the register link above to proceed. To start viewing messages,
select the forum that you want to visit from the selection below.

RELENTLESS robbing!

This is my second season of beekeeping and the robbing by my stronger colonies has not relented all summer. I had two colonies survive the winter, then I took in four new nucs in April. Because of this robbing, I have 4 hives left and one is being raided into oblivion as I write. Three out of six is not good.s

What do I do? I have no idea how to make this stop.

Is this nature's cruel way of bee natural selection???

I'm going to add some more nucs shortly. What should I do with these? Put them in another location on my property? ANY advice is desperately needed and would be greatly appreciated.

Re: RELENTLESS robbing!

Robbing needs to be stopped immediately. Plug every crack and entrance (duct tape may help) use screen wire on the entrance so they can ventilate. Maybe put some water in an empty comb or a feeder so they can get water. But stop the robbers getting in altogether. After a few hours most will go home. Then you can open it up to one bee wide (3/8" by 3/8") in the screen wire you stopped the entrance with. Meanwhile you can be making a robber screen if you like. You can also put wet sheets over the hive both to confuse the robbers and to keep the hive cool. If you don't stop it immediately they will kill the queen and the hive will be doomed. After that they will steal every drop of honey and the hive will starve. And that is if they haven't already killed them all...

Re: RELENTLESS robbing!

Michael,

Thank you for your comment, and for this article - which I read before and found very useful.

I believe the problem is that here in the Northeast we've had a drought situation for the last month. No rain, hungry bees. Every time I look inside my hives I find the stronger hives with some stores - not a great deal though - and I find the colonies started from nucs with absolutely NOTHING. (There is so little honey inside my colonies that the only honey I have taken was to keep on reserve to feed - and I've used this up already on the robbed colonies.) Even to my inexperienced eyes I conclude robbing. And it just has NOT stopped. I leave for the weekdays and every weekend I find the same thing.

When I have witnessed it, I start moving hives around - placing the robber where the robbee is and vice versa. This immediately stops it. Problem is I can't be here all the time.

I'm thinking I'll have to move either the stronger or the weaker to another location on my property. But that means placing them in an area unprotected by my electric fence. Yes, we have bears. So it's a gamble that they'll not get hit by bears, or a sure bet they WILL be robbed.

Re: RELENTLESS robbing!

Like I said. Stop it even if you have to stop the hive altogether, then leave only enough room for one bee in and out. Do this on ALL the hives and the robbers will have a traffic jam at home as well... make sure you use screen so they can ventilate.

Re: RELENTLESS robbing!

Locking the nucs up for a couple days (with food-water-ventilation) will not hurt the nucs, and you'll know for sure weather it's robbing.
From MB's link:"One issue is being sure they are being robbed. Sometimes people mistake an afternoon orientation flight with robbing."
Does the robbing happen all day long or at certain times of the day?
Drones coming to feed in the early afternoon make a ruckus that can look like fighting but they are just fat, hungry beggars whining for food. I do look for fighting as a sign.
Also your stronger, established colonies will naturally gather more stores than the starting nucs (i.e. one colony of 60000 will store more than two nucs of 30000 bees.) Seeing more stores in last years colonies is normal and does not incriminate them.