TMC is an independent, primarily volunteer organization that relies on ad revenue to cover its operating costs. Please consider whitelisting TMC on your ad blocker and becoming a Supporting Member. For more info: Support TMC

Tesla is finally going to start charging for Mobile Internet

The good news is, us current owners are all grandfathered in! I think this is very fair from Tesla and $100 a year is reasonable for Slacker streaming (as much as I am not a fan of slacker) and Live Traffic for Navigation. I would probably end up paying for it if I bought a new Tesla since Bluetooth streaming sometimes is an issue for me.

The price itself for the concept is reasonable, I totally agree... it's too bad the maps and traffic are so bad, though... I don't know anyone that uses the in-car navigation. I know people do use it, but most people that have used it for any length of time end up switching to their phone and something like Waze. The in-car navigation, while better than pretty much all stock systems from any other manufacturer, is still garbage when compared to Waze and the like. Traffic navigation is hit or miss, there are no alerts for construction or other pop-up issues (police, etc...), maps are years out of date (the latest update finally fixed some of the out of date issues, thankfully) - and will only get worse as time goes on. The in-car browser is painfully slow.

Slacker is nice, but it's not great - not really worth $100yr IMHO. So... I'm not sure I would bother paying the fee, since the offerings are pretty crappy, all told. I don't care about OTA LTE updates, as my car is on WiFi every night. What is the fee buying me that I don't already get better solutions from my phone with?

Honestly, though - it's patently obvious any Premium option should also include a tier for Wifi Hotspot capability, or it's going to be viewed as a non-competitive feature. It just stinks that mediocre OnStar offers this on new GM vehicles and, as Elon has mentioned before, Tesla has the guts & gear right there built-into the car to offer it...and doesn't.

Once the service is a paid service Tesla needs to maintain a performance level generally matching that of tablet via LTE. It is going to be a balancing act for Tesla to cover running costs of "services" without appearing greedy. Hopefully, Tesla makes a commitment that internet connectivity "will never be a profit center" for Tesla like they have with Superchargers.

I see a way owners can now get updates without having to wait, and get a free carwash with it. If you paid for EAP or FSD or any other feature not yet complete, every time the update rolls out, call the service center to schedule an installation because you only have a standard connectivity package and no wifi in the garage at home. Tesla committed to give you updates when the sold you unfinished features, so without wifi the only way for them to deliver is a service center visit.

Of course this could just be a sales lever. After July 1st free lifetime premium connectivity with a referral code.

The price itself for the concept is reasonable, I totally agree... it's too bad the maps and traffic are so bad, though... I don't know anyone that uses the in-car navigation. I know people do use it, but most people that have used it for any length of time end up switching to their phone and something like Waze. The in-car navigation, while better than pretty much all stock systems from any other manufacturer, is still garbage when compared to Waze and the like. Traffic navigation is hit or miss, there are no alerts for construction or other pop-up issues (police, etc...), maps are years out of date (the latest update finally fixed some of the out of date issues, thankfully) - and will only get worse as time goes on. The in-car browser is painfully slow.

Slacker is nice, but it's not great - not really worth $100yr IMHO. So... I'm not sure I would bother paying the fee, since the offerings are pretty crappy, all told. I don't care about OTA LTE updates, as my car is on WiFi every night. What is the fee buying me that I don't already get better solutions from my phone with?

Click to expand...

Do you have the new Nav? I've found the new Nav to be equal to Waze from a route to destination perspective. I still use Waze to figure out why traffic is slow and sometimes just as a point of comparison. And the map display on the IC is really helpful. Don't disagree about Slacker. Was hoping we would get an option to pay for an alternate provider like Spotify or Pandora.

I don't know anyone that uses the in-car navigation. I know people do use it, but most people that have used it for any length of time end up switching to their phone and something like Waze.

Click to expand...

Basically everyone on TMC has used or uses the navigation. Basically every Tesla blogger on youtube uses it. It comes in handy with that whole thing where it routes you through superchargers on long road trips.

i don't use it frequently, but the nav has worked well for me when I have used it. much more convenient for it to show up on the MCU and the dash and it's definitely better since that last update - queues for upcoming streets and directions pretty comparable to google nav.

Basically everyone on TMC has used or uses the navigation. Basically every Tesla blogger on youtube uses it. It comes in handy with that whole thing where it routes you through superchargers on long road trips.

That's cool. I'd rather have the navigation show up on my dashboard rather than on a tiny 5 inch screen but to each their own.

Click to expand...

Getting you to a Supercharger is about the only thing it does well... and that's questionable if you already know where the Supercharger is and have it saved in a good GPS system. As I said, the traffic routing is horrible and the nav routing is questionable at best. Lots better options out there.

Sure, it's nice to have it on the main screen for navigation, but if you're stuck in traffic because it doesn't route you around it or it takes you over non-existent roads or drives you off a cliff... I'm gonna say the 5" screen is better than the 17" one, since it actually gets you where you're going.

Nav and Slacker worthless? I completely disagree.
I don't use Nav often - I usually know where I am going. It is a lot easier to interface with the car than a phone.
Just yesterday, I was driving a route I know well. Nav showed an unusual traffic pattern - an obvious accident. Later in the day, a similar thing happened but you could tell it was a thunderstorm cell.

Sure if you always hook a phone up to a mount and sync it - then you have gotten over a big hurdle and may prefer that. My only experience with that is the poor Uber drivers - seems like a pain.

But a true power user probably has a LTE full size Ipad. Ok - I am sure that is better. But that puts you in a separate category.

Nav and Slacker worthless? I completely disagree.
I don't use Nav often - I usually know where I am going. It is a lot easier to interface with the car than a phone.
Just yesterday, I was driving a route I know well. Nav showed an unusual traffic pattern - an obvious accident. Later in the day, a similar thing happened but you could tell it was a thunderstorm cell.

Sure if you always hook a phone up to a mount and sync it - then you have gotten over a big hurdle and may prefer that. My only experience with that is the poor Uber drivers - seems like a pain.

But a true power user probably has a LTE full size Ipad. Ok - I am sure that is better. But that puts you in a separate category.

I expect a 90% take rate for the $100.

Click to expand...

If the Tesla nav showed a problem, you can bet Waze showed it much sooner and much more accurately. The Tesla nav is like looking through a dirty window into a telescope compared to other nav solutions. Not sure what you mean by sync it? I get in my car, put the phone on it's magnetic mount and drive away. It takes all of about 1.8 seconds... in fact, it takes longer for my car to wake up when I press the pedal and put it in drive than it does to make my phone ready to drive. If it takes longer, then something has gone wrong somewhere.

The Tesla nav is terribly slow as well, something I didn't bother pointing out. The whole Model S MCE is basically glacier slow - anything that requires you to interface with it just pisses me off every time, so I avoid it. I can't believe my $150,000 car has such a slow, ancient interface, honestly... but it is what it is. It used to be awesome, but time marches on and Tesla never did with regards to that, unfortunately. We were promised a new browser years ago... still waiting. the Nav update is nice, but it's quite underwhelming. After using the interface in a Model 3, I'm even more disgusted with the MS/X interface, so I try not to think about it.

If I want to go anywhere local, it's Waze all day long. If I'm going cross-country, the built-in Nav works fine for On-ramp to off-ramp the majority of the time.

I didn't say Slacker was worthless, but it's pretty lackluster with all of the other offerings out there. I don't care about Spotify, like so many others, but I sure would like Google Music on there. IF they'd just do Android Auto, basically all problems would be solved with the Model S interface. Then we wouldn't have to worry about it.

Meta

Do you value your experience at TMC? Consider becoming a Supporting Member of Tesla Motors Club. As a thank you for your contribution, you'll get nearly no ads in the Community and Groups sections. Additional perks are available depending on the level of contribution. Please visit the Account Upgrades page for more details.