This restaurant's overall star value is determined by comparing its ratings against
those of other restaurants in the same city.

A teacher might call this grading on a curve. At Seamless, this means that regardless
of their actual tally, restaurants with the highest ratings will have five stars,
those with average ratings will have three, and the not-so-favorite restaurants
will have the least number of stars.

So pay it forward to the Seamless community. Rate and review places you've tried
so we can all find food happiness!

Please check back for future deals.

Thalia is centrally located in the heart of New York City's Theatre District. The main dining rooms' soaring ceilings and elliptical bar, huge theatrical posters and massive columns make a fitting tribute to the neighborhood. In addition to the aesthetically pleasing interior, Thalia’s food is outstanding. Each dish is prepared with the freshest ingredients available, creating a menu that is filled with mouth watering options. Thalia is ideal for entertaining clients, birthdays, anniversaries and other romantic evenings. Allow their private dining professionals to assist you in putting together a successful and memorable experience for your guests.

Reviews for Thalia

based on 31 ratings

This place is fairly solid. I had the burger, which was very tasty, even though it was closer to the wrong side of midrare than medium. Fries are herbed and pretty good, though the container they were in left them soggy and undersalted. The chocolate chip cookie was awesome, very big and cake-y, and delicious all the way through.

Written by
Anik S.
on
9/24/2014
|
23 other reviews |
Member since
2006
Anik
ordered from here
within the last year

Update: I must say the food is still the best. I eat here more than 3 times per week. The sushi additions are amazing. I highly recommend the Angry Ebi Roll - there is nothing like it! My friend ordered $1 oysters one night and found the oysters to be of very high quality. Some of the items in the restaurant are not on the take out menu. Which is a shame. But I don't know what the other reviews are talking about with regards to delivery. I have never had a problem. I am so particular that if the food was not amazing I would not be spending my hard earned money in this restaurant! When you can, go inside and enjoy the fine food, atmosphere and service. Tell them Don B sent you!
I have been a customer for years. I have rented the place for private parties. The food, the service, the management - they are all superb. If you like burgers, you are in for a real treat - the best in town and the fry's to die for. The seafood is great, although they have the best shrimp cocktail ever, but they only seem to serve that at the restaurant. Maybe we can convince them to add it to the take out menu. The short ribs are amazing as is the scallops. Everything is great there - you cannot go wrong!

Written by
Donald B.
on
7/23/2014
|
14 other reviews |
Member since
2007
Donald
ordered from here
within the last year

Never arrived at time.

Written by
Ying L.
on
5/7/2014
|
5 other reviews |
Member since
2012
Ying
ordered from here
within the last year

I've never had a problem with delivery, and this is, by far, the best food I've ordered on Seamless. Always tastes fresh, no matter the item.

Written by
Brad C.
on
5/31/2013
|
Member since
2011
Brad
ordered from here
within the last year

Lived up to the reviews - 50 minutes late and delivered the wrong thing. Not even close to what I ordered. Unfortunately I have to chose 1 star - should be a zero.

Written by
Matt C.
on
5/20/2013
|
2 other reviews |
Member since
2010
Matt
ordered from here
over a year ago

Love! The food is amazing. Fortunately, I read the reviews before ordering and knew to expect a late delivery. I have ordered from Thalia a total of 5 times and they haven't been late once. The food is so good, I'd be willing to wait!

Written by
ciji s.
on
5/12/2013
|
3 other reviews |
Member since
2012
ciji
ordered from here
within the last year

Absolutely the worst service. Was so late and never arrived. The manager was said to be on the phone with delivery man but the manager apparently was the delivery man. I had enjoyed this place but no more.

Written by
Stephanie C.
on
1/25/2013
|
3 other reviews |
Member since
2006
Stephanie
ordered from here
over a year ago

DO NOT ORDER FROM HERE. Terrible service. I was given an estimated arrival of 30-45 mins. When I called after 50 mins had passed, they told me it would be at least an hour. Ridiculous! Will never attempt to order from here again. Even worse, I asked them to cancel my order and refund my credit card which they NEVER did. They are the WORST!!

Written by
Erica F.
on
1/19/2013
|
10 other reviews |
Member since
2007
Erica
ordered from here
over a year ago

Just ordered the salmon. I'm only two blocks away but it was fast and came hot. Good stuff, just under $25 with tax and tip.

Written by
Alexander M.
on
1/18/2013
|
Member since
2011
Alexander
ordered from here
over a year ago

Serves consistently good food. Quick delivery.

Written by
Birgitte D.
on
8/13/2012
|
2 other reviews |
Member since
2006
Birgitte
ordered from here
over a year ago

Skirt steak was perfect, salad had amazing dijon dressing, and the Chocolate Chip cookies were to die for. $3.00 for two, still hot, freshly made cookies is a great (and delicious) deal!

Written by
Yorgo B.
on
5/9/2012
|
1 other review |
Member since
2011
Yorgo
ordered from here
over a year ago

The order arrived after nearly two hours....very cold and the sandwich was ruined by cold, soggy bread. Seems like a fluke and probably not the restaurant's fault, but an unfortunate lunch nonetheless.

Written by
Matthew M.
on
4/25/2012
|
4 other reviews |
Member since
2011
Matthew
ordered from here
over a year ago

excellent food

Written by
Brian M.
on
2/23/2012
|
1 other review |
Member since
2009
Brian
ordered from here
within the last year

Over an hour and a half and still no food...

Written by
Irina V.
on
10/17/2011
|
25 other reviews |
Member since
2006
Irina
ordered from here
within the last year

The chicken was so tender and had great natural flavor....I will order it again.

Written by
Judith C.
on
11/7/2010
|
6 other reviews |
Member since
2010
Judith
ordered from here
over a year ago