Recent Posts

About

Matt was born and raised outside Boston, and after his hockey career fizzled at age 13 he decided to become a writer. Now he covers retail and all things shopping for DailyFinance, where he’s constantly finding new ways to help readers save money. He’s as thrifty as you can possibly be while living in New York City, and the only time he’s ever made an impulse purchase was when he bought himself one of those singing fish for $20 a few years ago. He still hasn’t forgiven himself.

Alamy
Some people don't need to be told to stay away from the mall on Black Friday.

The long lines, teeming crowds, packed parking lots and occasional eruptions of violence are enough to convince many people that shopping on Black Friday is a fool's errand. They know there are some good discounts to be found, but they just can't stomach all that chaos.

Still, tens of millions of Americans will throw caution to the wind and descend on the mall on Thanksgiving and Black Friday, seeking those huge doorbusters and deep discounts.

We understand the impulse to want to save money at all costs. But is Black Friday really the deal bonanza that it's cracked up to me? Are the prices good enough to justify standing in line and braving the crowds?

We're not so sure they are. Here are a few reasons why hitting the mall on Black Friday is one family tradition you may want to abandon.

We're not saying you should give up shopping on Black Friday altogether. Just do it online instead.

At one point it may have been true that Black Friday was for in-store deals, while Cyber Monday was for the e-commerce set. But these days, retailers are taking pains to offer a seamless experience between their online and bricks-and-mortar channels, and that means many of the marquee Black Friday deals can be had from the comfort of your couch. "[Retailers] continue to get better at syncing the online and offline experience," says Brad Wilson of BradsDeals. "95 percent-plus of deals are going to be available both online and offline."

Plus, shopping online can offer the ability to do comparison shopping, something that's harder to do when you've committed to standing in line at a given store. "If you go to a certain store, you're limited to the prices there, unless they do price matching," says Lindsay Sakraida of DealNews. "Online, you can quickly check other stores."

OK, so most of the deals are online. But not all of them! The marquee "doorbusters" that headline retailers' circulars are available only in stores, and they tend to be doozies -- TVs priced well below market value, for instance, are a common lure. If you want one of those, you'll have to hit the stores.

But they're called doorbusters for a reason: Usually you need to be one of the first people in the door to get them. Expect to find them in very limited quantities: Some circulars only promise 10 or 15 units actually available in each store.

That means you'll need to be among the dedicated shoppers camped out hours before opening. And with many major retailers opening in the evening on Thursday, you may have to duck out on your Thanksgiving meal early if you want to save an extra $100 on a TV.

"Typically, the TVs on Black Friday are not going to be high end, but third-tier manufacturers like Westinghouse," says Sakraida. If you want to get, say, a Samsung, you'll find the best price early next year when the new models come out and the old ones are discounted. And the same holds true of other consumer electronics: Often you'll see a circular headlined by a $200 laptop, but you can be sure that it's not a top-notch model.

These deals are loss-leaders intended to get you in the door, and as a general rule they're not going to offer such a deal on a premium brands. So unless you're truly in need for a new TV or laptop and can't afford a better-quality choice, it's probably not worth the effort.

Going later in the weekend will likely net you many of the same discounts, but with a fraction of the crowds. And online deals will abound all weekend and beyond. On Cyber Monday, you'll find a lot of apparel deals, and most online retailers will keep the deals going throughout what's now known as "Cyber Week."

Beyond the Black Friday/Cyber Monday weekend, the outlook gets a bit more hazy. Wilson points to historic data showing prices rising on subsequent weekends, so there is an argument to be made that you should find some way to get your shopping done on or around Black Friday. On the other hand, if the sales figures for Black Friday are disappointing, you can expect the retailers to keep the big discounts going well into December. And for certain product classes, like toys, the data shows that you're actually better off waiting until mid-December.

Finally, keep in mind that you can kick off your holiday shopping before Thanksgiving, too. That's something to keep in mind if you have your eye on one of this season's best-selling toys.

"If you're looking for something very specific and you find it in mid-November, it may be worth buying it at that price, because there's no guarantee that it will be avail on Black Friday," says Sakraida.

Opening for Black Friday on Thanksgiving evening is quickly becoming the new standard in the retail industry. That's in part because it makes sense for consumers: Instead of starting their shopping at midnight or 4 a.m., they're able to get in the door at the more reasonable hour of 8 p.m. and be back home before bedtime.

But it's a tough schedule for retail workers, many of whom will have to cut their Thanksgivings short so they can go in that afternoon to set up for the big night. And while retailers do endeavor to get volunteers for the big day, it's generally understood that some employees won't have a choice in the matter. Last year, this led to petitions and boycott calls, but they fell on deaf ears: Whatever bad publicity retailers get from making people work on a national holiday is outweighed by the huge sales they do that evening.

Ultimately, then, the only thing that's going to stand in the way of this Thanksgiving Creep is if shoppers stop showing up that night. We harbor no illusions that enough people could be convinced to skip their post-Thanksgiving dinner shopping to get the retail industry to do an about-face on this issue. But the more people come to shop that evening, the more entrenched it becomes -- and the more likely it is that stores will open even earlier next year. If you can resist the allure of Thursday-night doorbusters, you'll be doing your small part to keep holiday shopping from completely swallowing up Thanksgiving.

Introduction to Retirement Funds

Add a Comment

65 Comments

Filter by:

hsstempe

with all the i stay home votes, who the hell is at the malls? You guys take all the fun out of a giant party that gives people a buzz and they feel good about themselves. who in hell needs needs you folks. STAY HOME AND SHUT UP! AMAZON WAS INVENTED FOR YOU.

LET ME TELL U WHAT GOES ON ON BLACK FRIDAY. I USED TO WORK IN A FAMOUS DEPARTMENT STORE. A FLIER GOES OUT TO THOUSANDS OF PEOPLE WITH UNBELIEVABLE DEALS AND SALES. THE STORE WILL ONLY GETS '"6" OF AN ITEM OR NEVER EVEN RECEIVE IT AT ALL. WE R INSTRUCTED TO SAY " SORRY BUT WE R SOLD OUT. JUST TO GET U INTO THE STORE!! IT'S NOT WORTH IT. I RATHER SPEND THE EXTRA MONEY AND AVOID ALL THAT BS!!!!!

Anyone who goes near a mall on Black Friday or shops at the malls on weekends during the holiday season is a gluton for punishment or just nutz. You have to be a kid, a teenager, or out of your mind to have the kind of patience to deal with those crowds and the insanity. I prefer.... serenity now!!

If u r looking for major discounts, u can do your shopping online and throughout the year. I start shopping and putting things away around early September. Thanksgiving is one of the few times that I get to enjoy my family and I\'m not going to ruin that to fight the cold and crazy people to save $100 dollars on a TV. I guess I\'m a traditionalist and believe in preserving the integrity of Thanksgiving.

I NEVER head out anywhere on Black Friday. You have to be suicidal or crazy to get in your car and head out to go shopping on Black Friday. You're also not that bright considering that everything can be done online now. No reason whatsoever to go out shopping.

I stay away from all stores Thanksgiving weekend! You couldn't PAY me to brave the psychotic crowds at the mall! I haven't set foot in a store on Black Friday since my days working retail from 2000 through 2006!