Why is it that last nite when one of "in guys" (was it Scott or Alex or Beau) said that Toni was the girl "most playing the game" she seemed kind of flattered and made some cutesy comment while she was watching off-stage. Minutes later when Dave said the same thing, she flew off the handle like a crazed harpy calling him all kinds of foul names.

Why is it that last nite when one of "in guys" (was it Scott or Alex or Beau) said that Toni was the girl "most playing the game" she seemed kind of flattered and made some cutesy comment while she was watching off-stage. Minutes later when Dave said the same thing, she flew off the handle like a crazed harpy calling him all kinds of foul names.

I think it was Beau that said it before Dave. And you bring up a good point. The whole Inner Circle is a bunch of hypocrites. In fact, you could probably say everyone on the show is a hypocrite to one degree or another, but the Inner Circle takes hypocrisy to a new level.

How about Amy responding to anything that was said between the guys and the two prospective female roommates.

Re-enactment (not actual conversation..but it seems like it was)

Prospective roommie girl: "Which girl do you like the most and why"

Keith: "Well, I would have to say Charla. She is very quiet, respectful, and didn't attempt to cut off my penis last night like Amy and Toni did"

Amy: "That little bastard!"

Amy (to charla): "He is just saying that. You are a lil' stuck-up prissy bi@#$ and there is no way that he would think nice things of someone like you. You're ugly too! He's just trying to get on your good side. Trust me girlfriend. I have your back."

Charla: " "

Toni: "The only reason I wanted to help cut his penis off was because I feel like an outsider. I want someone else to go through what I went through."