This is an important development. If Amazon can publish the books which would otherwise go to the traditional publishers, it changes the whole balance of power.

So, I was curious…how is Amazon doing?

What I decided to do was look at Thomas & Mercer, Amazon’s mystery & suspense imprint, and see how their topsellers are doing in the store, how many titles they have, and if authors do as well with them as they do with other publishers. The last one is hard to figure exactly, since no two books are the same. However, I could take a look at the author’s other popular books and compare rankings.

You may have noticed that the books aren’t in order. Amazon’s popularity sort and their sales ranks don’t always match up, which is the case here. I don’t think they are updated at the same time, so they can get out of sync.

How are the authors doing with Thomas & Mercer?

All of the David Lender books in the Kindle store are published by T&M, so there isn’t a comparison to do.

Looking at Michael Wallace’s books, from most popular down:

Independent

T&M

T&M

T&M

Independent

T&M

Balsalom (independent?)

Balsalom

Balsalom

Independent

and then it goes on…forty titles (!) showed up in the search.

T&M does better for Wallace than the other choices…except for the very bestseller.

Both of Grundler’s books are T&M.

Aaron and Charlotte Elkins:

T&M

Independent

Independent

Westlake (independent?)

Westlake

Westlake

So, the Elkins benefit from T&M.

How about Nelson DeMille?

T&M

Grand Central (an imprint of Hachette, one of the big six US trade publishers)

Grand Central

Grand Central

Grand Central

Grand Central

Grand Central

Grand Central

Grand Central

Grand Central

and on through twenty titles.

That one is interesting! It could be because it’s a Kindle Single, but Amazon beating Hachette is pretty impressive.

T&M has also been spending money. They licensed the backlist for the Ed McBain books…and the original James Bond books (which should get a boost from the next Bond movie, Skyfall, opening November 9th). You have figure there was some bidding for those.

My opinion?

This is informed partially by my experience as a brick-and-mortar bookstore manager.

I think they are making it work, and doing better than might be expected. They are being somewhat conservative at this point, and that’s working for them.

They aren’t there yet, but the progress is good. I suspect that some brick-and-mortars, including Barnes & Noble, refusing to carry the books in paper is hurting. However, that will become less important in the next year or two (especially in the Barnes & Noble chains dwindle seriously as B&N concentrates on digital with the Microsoft cash influx).

Owning the major backlist like that will move people towards Amazon…if that means away from stores that choose not to carry them, so be it. They may have to change their minds…or give up and just sell toys. 🙂

If Amazon stays committed to this for another five years, they could be have a seat at the major players table.

What do you think? Will major authors have to pick sides…and will they pick Amazon? Will Amazon promote their tradpub books over the KDP? How important is the backlist to credibility? Feel free to let me and my readers know your opinion by commenting on this post.

You mention backlists. I know a lot of authors, esp romance ones, that have self-published their backlists as ebooks on Amazon and Smashwords. I think a few of them have just done it on Amazon to see how it goes. And some of them have got more readers this way. I don’t know if Amazon will publish their tradpub books more, we shall have to see. Interesting times for us indies.