Can Trying to Look Young Actually Age You?

I pride myself on being pretty good at deciphering the true age of an actress, Botox or no. But recently, I've been completely thrown off by one of my favorite stars, Kristin Chenoweth. I loved her on Broadway, and thought she was sprightly and adorable (no wonder she once played Tinkerbell) in 2009's Pushing Daisies.

Just over a year later, she looks like she's aged at least five, and I suspect her "anti-aging" style and beauty tricks may be to blame. Recently, she stepped out to a premiere with an intentionally youthful ponytail, bronzed skin, and a mini-dress—a look someone usually rocks at 22, not 42.

Instead of making Chenoweth appear younger, she seemed overdone: her skin was too tan and tight, her eye makeup was harsh, her ponytail severe, and her pale pink lipstick was a little too...much. We've written about celebs who instantly look younger by toning down their hair and makeup. If Cheno softens up, she could definitely make our list of the best anti-aging makeovers next year.