If this is your first visit, be sure to
check out the FAQ by clicking the
link above. You may have to register
before you can post: click the register link above to proceed. To start viewing messages,
select the forum that you want to visit from the selection below.

"while they were gone"

10 "But while they were gone to buy oil, the bridegroom came. Then those who were ready went in with him to the marriage feast, and the door was locked.

If the statement were "while they were going..," I could understand it as Past progressive tense (going on at a certain time in the past). But as you see that were gone is passive, isnít it? The word while and the rest of sentence, what comes after the comma, made me confused because the construction of past continuous in the first part needs verb to be were+verb-ing. In a word, I failed to get it. Will you clear it up?
PAST CONTINUOUS (PROGRESSIVE)
Passive form:
was/were + being + past participle
More: An English-Zone.Com Chart: Active and Passive Voice
"Use of Past Progressive"

Re: "while they were gone"

Originally Posted by 5jj

I have to have one of my rare disagreements with you there, ems.

X was/were gone is very common in BrE - there are hundreds of citations in the BNC.

I have no intention of disputing the BNC but for the life of me, I just can't get "while" to sound natural with "was/were gone" (even if the latter construction is correct), when followed by an infinitive. I have no problem with "They went to buy oil. While they were gone, the bridegroom arrived".

"I was gone ..." is a completed action but "while" needs some kind of ongoing action, surely. That's why I suggested "While I was away ..." - "During the time that I was in the state of being away from xxx situation ... something else happened".

While I was on holiday, my house was burgled.
While I was away on holiday, my house was burgled.

While I was gone on holiday, my house was burgled.

While I was out getting bread, my flat burnt down.
While I was getting bread, my flat burnt down.
While I was gone to get bread, my flat burnt down.

The s are my opinion.

Remember - if you don't use correct capitalisation, punctuation and spacing, anything you write will be incorrect.

Re: "while they were gone"

Originally Posted by emsr2d2

I just can't get "while" to sound natural with "was/were gone" (even if the latter construction is correct), when followed by an infinitive. I have no problem with "They went to buy oil. While they were gone, the bridegroom arrived".

Sorry. I was thinking of just 'they were gone' and didn't pay enough attention to what followed. I don't disagree with you after all.

Re: "while they were gone"

I think it sounds OK. Don't think of "gone" as a "completed action," think of it as a status. Are they here? No, they're gone. They were gone for a while, but now they are back. So there was a time during which they were gone. While they were gone.

Re: "while they were gone"

Originally Posted by SoothingDave

I think it sounds OK. Don't think of "gone" as a "completed action," think of it as a status. Are they here? No, they're gone. They were gone for a while, but now they are back. So there was a time during which they were gone. While they were gone.

I have no problem with "While they were gone" as a phrase. As I said "While they were gone, the bridegroom arrived" sounds fine. What I find unnatural is "While they were gone + to + infinitive".

Remember - if you don't use correct capitalisation, punctuation and spacing, anything you write will be incorrect.