You voted in the direct democracy that is The A.V. Club’s readers’ poll, and the results below represent the final, no-futzing tallies of 2016’s pop culture you found the best, worst, and most disappointing. A.V. Club readers are enthusiastic about Arrival and Stranger Things, dislike Batman V Superman: Dawn Of Justice as much as we did, and—in a rare consensus between A.V. Club staff and readers—you agree with us that David Bowie’s Blackstar is the best album of 2016. Thanks for voting. You can view all your valuable opinions below.

The biggest comics disappointment of 2016 is…

1. Captain America rewrites Steve Rogers’ history to make him a Hydra (Marvel)2. Civil War 11 (Marvel)3. Watchmen in DC Rebirth (DC)4. DKIII: The Master Race (DC)5. The cancellation of Prez’s second half (DC)