When this bluray was released i was put off by the reviews saying it was a live performance of The Wall,interspersed with documentary/interview footage as i thought it would interfere with the flow of the story.I lucked upon a 3 discs for £10 deal and thought i`d give it a shot.WOW!,it is brilliant,the sound and vision of the immense spectacle of his show are amazing.The footage that worried me is actually complimentary to the story as it`s Water`s travelling to the graves and sites of the deaths of his father and grandfather during WW2 and WW1 and how the death of his father,who he never met,affected him negatively throughout his life.I am irritated that the numerous reviews didn`t put this across,but glad i got it at a bargain price.Highly recommended!Now i`m looking forward to his Hyde Park show next year,that the BBC will likely televise!

A very high recommendation from me. I saw the show live in San Jose and San Francisco, and also paid to see the recorded show pre-DVD release in a local theater. It's absolutely fantastic, I put the digital download on my phone and have it playing in the background while I work a lot. I usually stop and watch when he reaches the two grave sites and when he is telling the bartender (who doesn't speak English) about his father's death. This is pure Waters, and a must-have.

I saw the live show twice, but I didn't really enjoy the movie, which like Ryan I saw in a theater. It felt like a bold reinterpretation of The Wall as a horror film about being trapped in a car with Roger Waters for two hours listening to him talk about politics.

I thought the footage of soldiers and cemeteries was moving and effective in the live show, but it struck my as exploitative as part of the movie.

As I recall, Waters said in the movie it was the first time he'd visited his father's grave, which if true, is pretty surprising, since I'd have assumed a millionaire rock star could have made that detour many times over the past 40 years. He reasons would be revealing, I think.

I saw Roger this past June on his Us & Them tour. It was unsurprisingly great.

I lucked out and was an exchange student in '90 and saw the show live in Potsdam Platz. It was something else hearing that many people yelling "tear down the wall" where it had been a year earlier. The other thing I remember is having to re-record songs at the end because they had been mucked up the first time around. (I think Cyndi Lauper kept forgetting the words to ABITW).

That said, I didn't care for this latest take on the Wall. It seemed like going back to the well for Waters. I never liked 95% of his solo work either, so maybe I just wasn't the audience.