Alright before I explain everything, I checked and there was a thread made about the same idea, however its four years old, and it's not the exact same as my idea.Okay so this is how it goes. Someone posts (I start) about two monsters, volunteer chooses first and then you represent the other monster, thus preventing being cheap like a mosswine vs Velocidrome for example, and you obviously choosing Velocidrome. You and the poster have a showdown on which monster would beat each other in a well thought out battle. This is realistic measures, so do not take the games logic into the subject (ex. Bullfango has higher attack so he hits first) just don't get all technical, have fun. Also be a team sport. Don't be mad or upset if the other person triumphs over you and has a better argument, admit defeat when necessary, don't be stubborn. However that is not to say these battle should last a few posts, they can last a few pages! Who decides who has the better argument? The spectators (forumers), of course!

Rules;

-First person to post to volunteer is the one representing the monster. So be the first to post

-Volunteer chooses first

-The person who wins the argument is decided by the people "over-viewing" (forumers) the thread

-"Over-viewers" or forumers cannot join the conversation. This could lead to helping one or the other win the argument

-"Over-viewers" or forumers can ONLY join in when the argument has been going on for awhile and one person is being stubborn

-Posts by BOTH arguers have to be very well thought out and clever.

-Once a person wins the argument, he sets up one of his own and another person volunteers to argue with him. NOTE; The person you just argued with cannot volunteer again, give others a chance.

-YOUR POST MUST CONTAIN IT LEAST 10 WORDS I DON'T WANT THIS BEING SHUTDOWN BECAUSE OF SPAMMERS; PLEASE RESPECT ME, MY THREAD, THIS FORUM AND YOURSELF BY NOT SPAMMING. THANK-YOU.

First Battle - Felyne VS Rathalos!

Volunteer, go and choose your side!

Note; I make up the rules. I may add a few rules and will put in the title when I do so. I wont drastically change things, so don't worry. Also if I don't post within 12 hours it may mean I am studying so sorry about that but I'll try to get on a lot until I have *cough*won*cough* this battle. Hehe okay post up.

- Alright so the volunteer will post their monster and then provides a paragraph why that would beat the opposing opponent.

FELYNE FTW!!!! They are smart, quick and can hide if need be. They wouldn't fight a Rathalos head-on, they would use their ultimate intelligence to gain the upper hand.

Oh darn lol, I was hoping you would choose Rathalos. Alright, gotta pull my brain out for this one.

If anything, the Rathalos has more intelligence. Felyne waddle around and when threatened they will then attack, giving the Rathalos the upper edge. Rathalos on the other hand, see's something, goes after it, and it will not back down until it's limping. The wussy felyne's will bury into the ground abandoning their team members making it easier for the rathalos because he has to deal with less felyne.

Also, I just thought of something. When a felyne burrows into the ground, it leaves the map for good, meaning its for-fitting. Rathalos finds a quick safe haven to heal and get right back to battle. So rathalos don't even have to get brutal with them until they just run away.

I'm going to go study and sleep. This will give you some time to think (lucky). I will be back in around 10 hours.

You mean this is a debate thread but it only uses Monster Vs Monster Topics?

Yeah,is this Mod Approved?

also:

quote luvtehMHF

If anything, the Rathalos has more intelligence. Felyne waddle around and when threatened they will then attack, giving the Rathalos the upper edge. Rathalos on the other hand, see's something, goes after it, and it will not back down until it's limping. The wussy felyne's will bury into the ground abandoning their team members making it easier for the rathalos because he has to deal with less felyne.Also, I just thought of something. When a felyne burrows into the ground, it leaves the map for good, meaning its for-fitting. Rathalos finds a quick safe haven to heal and get right back to battle. So rathalos don't even have to get brutal with them until they just run away.

Definitely wrong,Felynes are much much smarter than Rathalos' since Felynes are able to work together,make weapons,cook and act as hunting partnersRathalos does everything based on his instincts,instincts does not equal smartBtw,when they burrow into the ground they don't permanently leave the mapHow do you know if they left the map or not?They could probably just go back to their Village to heal or gather other felynes to help them,making some sort of hunting group,proving how great their teamwork is.Rathalos is tough that is all,but with twenty Felynes working together,bombing,slashing and whacking him at the same time,he won't last long

You mean this is a debate thread but it only uses Monster Vs Monster Topics?

Yeah,is this Mod Approved?

also:

quote luvtehMHF

If anything, the Rathalos has more intelligence. Felyne waddle around and when threatened they will then attack, giving the Rathalos the upper edge. Rathalos on the other hand, see's something, goes after it, and it will not back down until it's limping. The wussy felyne's will bury into the ground abandoning their team members making it easier for the rathalos because he has to deal with less felyne.Also, I just thought of something. When a felyne burrows into the ground, it leaves the map for good, meaning its for-fitting. Rathalos finds a quick safe haven to heal and get right back to battle. So rathalos don't even have to get brutal with them until they just run away.

Definitely wrong,Felynes are much much smarter than Rathalos' since Felynes are able to work together,make weapons,cook and act as hunting partnersRathalos does everything based on his instincts,instincts does not equal smartBtw,when they burrow into the ground they don't permanently leave the mapHow do you know if they left the map or not?They could probably just go back to their Village to heal or gather other felynes to help them,making some sort of hunting group,proving how great their teamwork is.Rathalos is tough that is all,but with twenty Felynes working together,bombing,slashing and whacking him at the same time,he won't last long

I'm not sure about approving, however you just went against a major rule in the thread you are NOT allowed to get involved into the conversation until it is near over. Everything said here is irreverent and does not count towards the debate.

Please read my thread and not just the outlines before you post, it makes you look very ignorant when you do something that isn't suppose to. Thanks

felyne would probably wait till the Rathalos is asleep before it makes a move.

The rathalos has lots of babies, they where never put into the game but they where seen in early MHF1 trailers, not to mention in some quests he would work with a rathian.

The rathalos babies would guard and make sure nobody got near the rathalos as he was sleeping, as would the rathian. Then when the rathalos has woken up, it would be Rathalos+Rathian+4-8Rathalos babies vs your felynes. Even the best coordination, which felynes don't have, couldn't fend from as they would be outnumbered. Also they would be in the cave area. All the cave areas in this game are well wide open so they can't hide, and if they burry away it's considered a forfeit.

9 – Game Threads-Before creating any type of game thread, please PM the rules to the moderator first either through PM or in the Suggestions thread. Badly designed games can result in a lot of spam.

Look who's ignorant now

Urgh I didn't understand that rule. Game thread? This is a specific video game discussion board so every post here should be game related, and if people are following the rules by not spamming then it should be fine. Yes, it's one on one, as mentioned in the thread, again you didn't even have the decency go back and read it, spectators only join in when the argument has gone on for too long and someone is being stubborn, thus preventing spam. Also these moderators must be out of touch with what admins want. The creators of these websites, infact, websites in gerenal, as much as they dis value spam, it helps the admins on the website a lot. If you don't know why, that's for me and the admins to know and for you to find out. Also two wrong don't make a right, if you're trying to set a good example coming on my thread acting all huff and tuff telling me what I should and shouldn't do and trying to imply rules without even reading over the thread and the rules this one has itself, don't even bother. Moderators should approve this thread, it was late at night when I made it and I made it clear they cannot post until the argument is over and their post must be 10 words or more, its very thought out and clever, if spam reaches this thread it would be out of my hands and the mods would lock it up, it shouldn't be of your concern. And if you where really trying to help me you would have it least read the thread.

Urgh I didn't understand that rule. Game thread? This is a specific video game discussion board so every post here should be game related, and if people are following the rules by not spamming then it should be fine.

Game threads are specific threads like this that requires people to play some sort of game that's related to the forum

quote luvtehMHF

Also these moderators must be out of touch with what admins want.

Moderators are admins

quote luvtehMHF

Moderators should approve this thread, it was late at night when I made it and I made it clear they cannot post until the argument is over and their post must be 10 words or more, its very thought out and clever, if spam reaches this thread it would be out of my hands and the mods would lock it up, it shouldn't be of your concern.

Someone's being selfish

quote luvtehMHF

if you're trying to set a good example coming on my thread acting all huff and tuff telling me what I should and shouldn't do and trying to imply rules without even reading over the thread and the rules this one has itself, don't even bother.

As far as I'm concerned this is an illegal game thread,I was trying to tell you to get mod approval to make it legal

I'm sorry but what you're trying to explain wasn't clear enough,in fact it was sort of confusingIf it was clear,Higashizawa should've told me off,instead he accepts the help

Urgh I didn't understand that rule. Game thread? This is a specific video game discussion board so every post here should be game related, and if people are following the rules by not spamming then it should be fine.

Game threads are specific threads like this that requires people to play some sort of game that's related to the forum

quote luvtehMHF

Also these moderators must be out of touch with what admins want.

Moderators are admins

I'm sorry but what you're trying to explain wasn't clear enough,in fact it was sort of confusingIf it was clear,Higashizawa should've told me off,instead he accepts the help

That's the WHOLE POINT of this forum, isn't it?! So you're telling me ON TOPIC threads have to be approved? That's backwards! If that's the case I will just leave here, that's just messed up and wrong.

Well that's odd. So theres no "higher power" so its like a democracy then? Nobody can ban a moderator and have the final say?

Also what I'm saying is you're not helping me or this thread at all by;

I'm not being selfish. If you continue to be an ignorant prick I'm going to report you or something as I've politely asked you to leave and you haven't left. With the direction this thread has headed BECAUSE OF YOU, it will be locked, so I advise you to be a good samaritan and just stop.

That's the WHOLE POINT of this forum, isn't it?! So you're telling me ON TOPIC threads have to be approved? That's backwards! If that's the case I will just leave here, that's just messed up and wrong.

No,I meant Game Threads as in a thread where you play a game that can be played in a forum(Hangman,Who's that monster,etc)Those kinds of thread require Moderator approvalNo,On Topic threads does not require approval but game threads like these do

quote luvtehMHF

Well that's odd. So theres no "higher power" so its like a democracy then? Nobody can ban a moderator and have the final say?

There are Supermods,but I don't really know how the power ranking goes in Neo

quote luvtehMHF

Also what I'm saying is you're not helping me or this thread at all by;

1.No,I'm not trying to start a fight,I'm trying to save you from embarrasment2.I read the thread,it's just that I didn't fully understand what you were trying to say so that's a mistake on my part3.I'm not trying to play the game,I'm trying to tell you to get approval for this game thread4.No,I am not a Troll,feel free to call me whatever you want though

Game threads have to be approved, not normal threads. That's what King of Ice is saying. You're best off PMing either Machienzo/Xeros the Slayer with your game idea, or posting about it in the Moderators' Corner thread.

If game threads didn't have to be approved, the forum would get bogged down by poorly thought out and disorganized games (aka spam-fests) pretty quickly.

Game threads have to be approved, not normal threads. That's what King of Ice is saying. You're best off PMing either Machienzo/Xeros the Slayer with your game idea, or posting about it in the Moderators' Corner thread.

If game threads didn't have to be approved, the forum would get bogged down by spam-fests (aka poorly thought out and disorganized games) pretty quickly.

That's the WHOLE POINT of this forum, isn't it?! So you're telling me ON TOPIC threads have to be approved? That's backwards! If that's the case I will just leave here, that's just messed up and wrong.

No,I meant Game Threads as in a thread where you play a game that can be played in a forum(Hangman,Who's that monster,etc)Those kinds of thread require Moderator approvalNo,On Topic threads does not require approval but game threads like these do

quote luvtehMHF

Well that's odd. So theres no "higher power" so its like a democracy then? Nobody can ban a moderator and have the final say?

There are Supermods,but I don't really know how the power ranking goes in Neo

quote luvtehMHF

Also what I'm saying is you're not helping me or this thread at all by;

1.No,I'm not trying to start a fight,I'm trying to save you from embarrasment2.I read the thread,it's just that I didn't fully understand what you were trying to say so that's a mistake on my part3.I'm not trying to play the game,I'm trying to tell you to get approval for this game thread4.No,I am not a Troll,feel free to call me whatever you want though

quote luvetehMHF

One question; is neoseeker a company, does it receive revenue?

Why?

Well the Supermod Treasurer will know what I'm saying by spam is good but bad.

Lies. If you don't want to start a fight why do you continue to post negative things. The rules where clearly and easily stated, you didn't bother to read them. If you weren't trying to play the game then why was your first post directed towards the discussion, which also goes against one of the most easy, clearly understood rules of the thread mentioned twice? You are a troll, and a very bad one. Everything you state is irreverent because it goes against your actions. Look at what Aurora did. It took him one post to explain and get his point across. It took you like 7 not to mention the ignorance because you went against so many thread rules. You did nothing to help this thread.

This message was merged with other messages by Xeros the Slayer (moderator)