Shareholder Disputes Series (Part 5 of 10): Exclusion from management / No Involvement in important decision making

Majority, you not allowing me to be a director or be employed by the company as expected. You’re not running anything by me at all!

Introduction

Proprietary companies are often controlled by a single shareholder or a group. The majority’s nominated directors will control the board and therefore the activities of the company. If the majority (whether as shareholders or with their nominated directors) run the company in their own interests, the detriment to the minority can be serious. The minority shareholders have limited options because they cannot vote the directors out, in a general meeting, without the majority’s support. Getting out is difficult because they cannot force the majority to buy them out. As it’s not a listed company, they are also likely to find it hard to find a buyer of their minority stake. They are locked in with no control of their investment. It’s a difficult position to be in.[1]

The following are the most common complaints made by minority shareholders[2]:

The majority are paying themselves excessive remuneration;

Little or no participation in profits;

The majority are diverting corporate opportunity / are operating a competing business;

Exclusion from management;

No involvement in important decisions;

Limited access to information about the company’s affairs;

Inability to prevent dilution of their equity stake;

No freedom to transfer shares;

No market for their shares;

Bad management by the majority.

The following is a consideration of the forth of these complaints, with recommendations on how a shareholders agreement will assist to prevent it.

Shareholders Agreement – What is it?

Shareholders agreements are a fundamental tool to help a company’s shareholders establish expectations and manage their risk. They are particularly useful to establish rights for minority shareholders and arguably, its primary purpose is “to eliminate the tyranny of the majority”[3].

Starting Point – The Company’s Constitution

To properly appreciate how to address a risk in shareholders agreement, you first need to understand what the legal position would be without a shareholders agreement. To do so, the first point of call is the company’s constitution. This is because the company’s constitution contains provisions relating to the day-to-day internal management and proceedings of the company – the rules.

Legally, a company’s constitution has effect as a contract:

between the company and each shareholder; and

between the company and each director and company secretary; and

between a shareholder and each other shareholder;

under which each person agrees to observe and perform the constitution and rules so far as they apply to that person[4].

Every company’s constitution will be different, depending on who originally helped the company founders establish the company. Typically, however, the constitution provides that the business of the company is to be managed by or under the direction of the directors. The directors may exercise all the powers of the company except any powers that this Act or the company’s constitution (if any) requires the company to exercise in a general meeting.[5].

Without any control of the board of directors, let alone having a director on the board (or having a nominee appointed) a minority shareholder has no say in the management of the company.

Protection

The shareholders agreement can incorporate the following provisions to protect the minority:

Nominee Director: a provision giving minority the right to appoint and replace a director should be considered.

Employment: a right for the minority to be employed by the company or provide services to the company incapable of variation or termination but for breach.

Veto: a power to veto critical management matters is also an option. This is usually achieved by requiring unanimity or concurrence of a higher percentage of voting units for a resolution.

Shareholder Disputes Rights and Remedies

This post is not a consideration of the legal duties and remedies that may prohibit the conduct or the remedies available when such conduct occurs. If you have, or anticipate, a dispute between shareholder in your company as a result of any of these complaints, please call Joe Kafrouni to discuss how we can help.

The information provided by Kafrouni Lawyers is intended to provide general information and is not legal advice or a substitute for it. Business people should always consult their own legal advisors to discuss their particular circumstances. Kafrouni Lawyers makes no warranties or representations regarding the information and exclude any liability which may arise as a result of the use of this information. This information is the copyright of Kafrouni Lawyers.

When handed the keys and security codes to its new business premises, a business buyer may be excused for feeling like a short holiday to Bali even before the hard work has actually begun. Let’s not kid ourselves; the process of buying a business is not easy.... read more

Providing your personal and/or business assets as security for the debts of another business/person involves the highest amount of risk to the financial security of yourself and/or your business. Think it’s safe to rely on what a member of your own family tells you... read more

We recently interviewed Iain Horne from Benchmark Business Brokers. Iain won the REIQ Business Broker of the Year award this year, and in 2011 was named AIBB Australian Senior Business Broker of the Year. He has personally settled over 120 deals over the past few... read more

Has your business considered its standard terms and conditions that apply to its customers to ensure they do not break the law? Did you know that customers may have a right to challenge unfair terms in your contract to supply goods or services, regardless of what the... read more

What do you need to do if you want to sell or advertise a business in New South Wales (NSW) if you are already licenced in another state? To practice as a Business Agent in NSW you must apply for mutual recognition of your state licence or certificate. You must also... read more

Shane Dingley, Managing Director of Business Brokers Queensland and the Treasurer of the Australian Institute of Business Brokers, has reported to us his experience of a renewed appetite on the part of some of the major banks to lend to the SME sector. Shane reports:... read more

With the tightening of lending in Australia in recent years, and its impact on business sales, Joe asked Don Farquharson, Principal of All About Loans, what “outside the square” financing options are available to support business sales… Don replies: Traditional... read more

We believe there is a misconception amongst business owners that registering a business name with ASIC provides them with ownership of that name or exclusive rights to trade under that name. It doesn’t! Registering a business name simply allows others to search... read more