So, what about the idea of Thechuck51 in targeting ourselves? That would be a crack in the system....or we better play within the obvious patterns from the thread?

unvote vote Falko for trying to mine the system. and because I've never played with you yet... That being said I assume a crap D1 case is going to show up somewhere

Thats the thing... there can't be a GOOD case day 1 because nobody can slip up because nobody knows if they are mafia. FWIW, my plan to target ourselves was a joke. if it actually worked it would take any fun out of playing the game.

i think we have four options:

1 - vote no lynch (i'm leaning toward this as of right now)2 - random lynch3 - lynch the player we think will be the least helpful in the upcoming days4 - lynch the player we think would be the hardest to catch as mafia.

So, what about the idea of Thechuck51 in targeting ourselves? That would be a crack in the system....or we better play within the obvious patterns from the thread?

unvote vote Falko for trying to mine the system. and because I've never played with you yet... That being said I assume a crap D1 case is going to show up somewhere

Thats the thing... there can't be a GOOD case day 1 because nobody can slip up because nobody knows if they are mafia. FWIW, my plan to target ourselves was a joke. if it actually worked it would take any fun out of playing the game.

i think we have four options:

1 - vote no lynch (i'm leaning toward this as of right now)2 - random lynch3 - lynch the player we think will be the least helpful in the upcoming days4 - lynch the player we think would be the hardest to catch as mafia.

I am willing to agree with that logic. And the chances of hitting town are 5/6th vs. 1/6th. Its going to be interesting.

aage wrote: Maybe you're right, but since we receive no handlebars from the mod I think we should get some ourselves.

/ wrote:There are fourteen alive, it takes 8 to lynch, deadline is in approximately 72 hours.

Deadline is sometime April 5th so we don't have a lot of time. unvote vote no lynch

I agree with chuck's logic. We have absolutely zero information as a whole, or even as an individual. A random lynch would be sad for whomever we choose to target, pretty much not being able to take part in the crazy setup that is this game. Unvote, vote no lynch.

so are we going to go into the night with some type of plan or are we just going to wing it? A plan would be nice but we have no way of verifying that it was followed. But with no plan, if a couple of people target the same player and he dies we could have a couple townies thinking they are SKs.

Well because we dont know who we are yet, theres no real way of verifying that anyone wants to follow the plan. If the SK's follow the plan, then they are screwed. Since nobody knows if we are SKs yet, nobody would follow the plan anyways, and so I feel like having a plan would just add confusion since obviously the first question of the day would be "hey, so uh, if everyone followed the plan, this person is the killer, but can we really know that?". Just my input.

Since any plan we put together would probably not be followed (unless someone wants to play the odds) it seems a wasted effort. Once people figure out if they are SK or Town then a plan can be more useful.

Nendreel wrote:Since any plan we put together would probably not be followed (unless someone wants to play the odds) it seems a wasted effort. Once people figure out if they are SK or Town then a plan can be more useful.

Even if town knows they're town we can't use a plan to defeat them, unless there secretly are blockers, trackers or watchers among us. And since I don't think there are, good luck beating the setup. Doom couldn't. Otherwise he would have joined.