An entrée of Cognitive Science with an occasional side of whatever the hell else I want to talk about.

Thursday, May 25, 2006

Children's Acceptance of Testimony About the Spiritual and the Scientific

Via Coturnix, I learned about this post and this article about this paper by Harris and Koenig (this is not the final version) in this month's issue of Cognitive Development. I don't know about people in other sciences, but I think this is the first time I've ever seen press coverage of a literature review. It's a very interesting literature review, though, so I'm glad it's getting attention. Only, I wish the whole review was getting attention, instead of one small part of it.

The review focuses on children's acceptance of testimony from adults about things that the children either haven't or cannot observe. They describe several examples of acceptance, and integration into coherent beliefs, of scientific knowledge, including knowledge of the importance of the brain for thought, personality, etc., the roundness of the earth, and the inevitability and permanence of death. They also describe similar examples for spiritual phenomena including God's ability to have knowledge that humans cannot have (e.g., God doesn't have false beliefs, and God can see objects that are occluded), beliefs about the afterlife, beliefs about the origins of humans and other animals (including a discussion of the work of Margaret Evans mentioned in this post). In the grand scheme of things, children's willingness and ability to accept testimony from adults about spiritual matters is very similar to their willingness and ability to accept testimony from adults about scientific matters.

Still, there are differences between the two, and this is the focus of the press report. I'll give you an example of the way children's beliefs about scientific and spiritual entities differ, from the article. In a study by Harris et al.1, children between the ages of 4 and 8 were presented with five different types of entities:

Realentities: Things that they can see (e.g., tigers)

Scientific entities: Things that they can't see, but have been told exist, such as germs and oxygen.

Endorsed entities: Things they can't see, but that are endorsed by parents and other adults, like God, Santa Claus, and the Tooth Fairy.

Equivocal entities: Things they've heard about, but that aren't often endorsed by adults, like monsters or ghosts.

Impossible entities: Red elephants and barking cats... enough said.

For examples of each type of entity, children were asked whether they or other people would say they exist (whether there are any in the world), and then asked to say how sure they were. Children were most likely to say that real entities exist, and were the most confident about this belief, though scientific entities followed close behind in each experiment (and the difference between the two was not statistically significant), and they were the least likely to say that impossible entities exist, and were very confident in this belief as well. Endorsed and equivocal entities fell in between, with children being less likely to say that endorsed entities existed, and to be less confident in their belief in them, than they were for real and scientific entities, but were more likely and more confident for endorsed than for equivocal entities. In other words, children had slightly more doubt about the existence of endorsed entities like God and Santa Claus than they did about scientific entities, despite the fact that both types of entities are unseen, and their knowledge of the existence of such entities is entirely dependent on adult testimony.

Since the existence of things like germs and oxygen are likely no less counterintuitive (or counter to experience) for children who don't have sophisticated scientific knowledge than are things like God and Santa Claus, it's likely that the reasons for the difference in certainty about the existence of the two kinds of entities are pretty subtle, and may have to do with how people talk about them. Harris and Koenig offer the following explanation:

[C]hildren hear people talk in a matter-of-fact fashion about the causal properties of germs or oxygen. Such remarks do not explicitly attest either to the existence of those entities or to the speaker’s faith in their existence. Thus, children rarely hear utterances such as, “There really are germs” or “I believe in oxygen.” Instead they hear claims and warnings that take the existence of the entities for granted, for example, “Throw that away – it has germs” or “He needs oxygen to breathe.” In the case of God or Santa Claus, on the other hand, children may well hear avowals such as “There really is a Santa Claus” or “I believe in God.” Such avowals may lead children to conclude that the existence of these special beings is not altogether beyond doubt. (p. 35)

They also suggest that children may occasionally hear people express doubt about God or Santa Claus, while they would rarely hear people express doubt about the existence of germs or oxygen, and thus children are less confident in the existence of spiritual entities.

So, there is a small difference between children's beliefs about scientific and spiritual entities, and the explanation for this difference may reveal a lot about children's ability to detect subtle cues when assessing testimony from adults. Still, the bulk of the article is actually about the similarity between children's acceptance of testimony on scientific and spiritual entities. It's a really interesting literature review, so if you're into cognitive development, check it out.

143 comments:

Neat!I believed in Santa until I was 5....kinda slow.It's good to believe sometimes, even if the object of the belief does not "really" exist.Many adults don't believe in anything anymore, which I think is sadder.

You got a really useful blog I have been here reading for about an hour. I am a newbee and your success is very much an inspiration for me. Please come visit my site find life coach give me any valuable feedbacks. Thanks.

That is some inspirational stuff... Never know that opinions could be this varied. Thanks for all the enthusiasm to offer such helpful information here. Please come visit my site Clothing Storey when you got time.

You do have a point here :) I admire the stuff you post and the quality information you offer in your blog! Keep up the good work dude. Please come visit my site real estate give me any valuable feedbacks.

can download somewhere, or is it a custom theme you had made? Soon i will be launching my own blog, however i’m not great with designs but i do like the style of your site so it would be excellent if i could find (or buy) something with a similar look as my last designer cannot finish my site. Thanks! Please come visit my site Memphis Business Directory when you got time.

What a blog filled with vital and important information this is .. It must have taken a lot of hours for you to write these yourself. Hats off from me for your hard work. Please come visit my site home improvement give me any valuable feedbacks.

Awesome! I have read a lot on this topic, but you definitely give it a good vibe. This is a great post. Will be back to read more! Please come visit my site Ontario, yellow page give me any valuable feedbacks.

Really great work. Congrats to everyone who are involved with this project. The website layout and graphics are really cool. Please come visit my site Business Reviews Of Louisville City when you got time.

Nice, I think it could be interesting to add some more entries following this one, and probably it's not only me having this opinion. Cheers! I would love some feedback on my site free divorce advice when you got time.

There are certainly a lot of details like that to take into consideration. That’s a great point to bring up. I offer the thoughts above as general inspiration but clearly there are questions like the one you bring up where the most important thing will be working in honest good faith.

incredibly Its about materialism and can make you or break you. It means getting excited about Fall and Spring. Keep it in check or it love affair.cheap rain wearthey should be kept for the future. Who knows when discount

Specific ingredients: clothing, accessories, and shoes, but most recently handbags have become a cornerstone to the aura that is mainstream fashion. Designer purses and handbags cheap bagsare what make your style unique and different from every other girl walking by you on the street. are not only used to carry along personal accessories and luggage, they are also engaging conversation starters, lavishly represent your personality and lifestyle, and can also turn you into eye candy that makes you pop and stick out from the others.Tommy and Kate handbagsdiscount bags

and purses burst onto the scene in July 2004, offering a variety of models and styles on bidding websites. The design poses a style that is both unique and wearable in all different types of situations. Whether you wear it to work, to school, to dinner, or out with friends, newest handbags

it doesn't matter, and that's the great thing about the Tommy and Kate handbag. You can find a design and color that suits your style, personality, and lifestyle the best and take it with you wherever you go. Tommy and Kate is a designer label handbags outletthat has developed its brand name through discount websites and programs, and because they are always kept a little out of the mainstream spotlight, they consistently focus their attention on introducing fresh new and improved designs that create a sense of individuality and keen sense of style for the buyer. Tommy and Kate handbags aim to give you the best bang for your buck, perfecting it's combination of impressive designs, handbags 2010especially the leather interior and We will go through the most popular technologies that Nike has developed some thirty-years after the original Nike Air.

took this concept and applied shock-absorber-like columns on the heel area of their shoes featuring this technology. This gives the runner something very similar to an independent suspension of a road car. The effect is more traction and cushioning that adapts to where it is needed. basketball air jordan shoes

LunarLiteThe Nike Lunarlite foam that has just gained popularity is Nike's inner material of choice among their top running shoes. The Lunarlite material was meant to give an experience very unique to Nike running shoes. cheap Jordan shoes outlet

Zoom AirThe Nike Zoom Air is a thin material that provides cushioning inside the midsole of the shoes jordan

Depending on the application this can be segmented into the heel and toe, lay flat on the entire stretch of the shoe, discount jordan shoes

or even just be present in the forefoot portion of the running shoe. Nike developed this technology to provide cushioning while maintaining extreme responsiveness. Jordan2010

FlywireThis is one of the newer technologies introduced by Nike.

The Flywire technology tries to eliminate slippage of foot during running. It does this by using fibers placed around the shoeJumpman 23

are sold and worn worldwide. They are really popular among teenagers or outdoor enthusiasts, famous by 'hip-hop' style in rap and hip-hop videos and also well-known for their strong and enduring work boots varieties. They can carry you from the office to the woods in both fashion and comfort.Since the Timberland branddiscount timberlands

was introduced in 1973, it has quickly taken the casual boot market by storm Unlike traditional leather boots that most in the industry make, Timberland makes their boots in suede material for those who fancy extreme-strong and durable footwear which can withstand any condition. These boots are specially made of strongest leather for excellent durability. . timberland

Also they are soft and hard in all the right spots to ensure maximum comfort for the user.As for their styles, every detail on them makes it clear that the Timbers are seamless boots. As for their classic look in the unrivaled boots, they stand for a type of special fashion favored by many people. Due to all their attracting benefits, there are more and more people desirable them. But as today's phony things are everywhere on the market, particularly online. How we tall them apart?Usually a lot of people still stick to buying the genuine things and stay away from the look-likes. Unfortunately, the Timberland boots are equipped with a style number. Each pair has only one so that you can look into them at the Timberland site. cheap timberland uk

Of course there are some cheap Timberland boots online. But the truth is that they are on sales or discounted. Often this happens as the suppliers buys in bulk and selling at a discount. Or it could also be some individuals simply with no regard of price probably because the shoe size is not so perfect for her or him, or just not their style.But on the other hand there are usually quite few real Timberland discount timberland outlet

lines being sold for a fraction of the price. In a word, you probably get a knock off if you find your Timberland boots without style number. In such a situation you can simply visit the real site and send you problem over email with descriptions of your boots. All these service is just to make sure every Timberland boots lovers can get the real things they want. Right?

are not limited for the summer season alone. You won't have to worry about having your sunglass merchandise to gather dust on its display racks waiting for the summer season to commence.

This is basically because sunglasses

are now one of the staple accessories that most people wear, male or female, on a daily basis. Therefore, it should likewise follow that your point of purchase fixtures should be one-of-a-kind and attractive enough to call your customers' wandering eyes. discount coach sunglasses

Here are five simple steps that you should follow to come up with spectacular sunglass displays: discount sunglasses

In Marketing, you should understand who your target market is. Create one-word adjectives that best describes your target market. For example, you may describe the customers of your classic aviators as "macho" or "rebel" for your polarized wayfarers. After zoning in on the adjective, make sure that your eyewear displays likewise share that adjective. Imagine if you display your hot pink sunglasses in black metal sunglass racks. It would not be effective.Custom sunglass fixtures can easily be the solution to personalize a "look" for your sunglasses. sunglasses outlet

Keep in mind that your sunglass fixture units are as important as your merchandise itself. These eye wear display racks will ultimately serve as advertisements for your products. Commissioning custom sunglass display racks will ensure that your merchandise will surely stand out. Traditionally, retail POP fixtures units came in modular black stainless steel or clear acrylic. Now because of customized sunglassnewest sunglasses racks, you will only be limited to what your creative mind can come up with.

are very popular among people at all ages. The style and quality match most people's taste. Nike Air Max a line of shoes released by Nike Inc. in 1987 first time. Since then Nikenewest air max

has been frequently introducing new as well as updated models in it. Just as we all know, this year is the Nike Air Max 90 that double the 20th anniversary of the birth of a classic style, Nike natural for this trend in the field of running shoecheap air max shoes. cheap air max shoes

and have made outstanding contributions to the ashes of class to do something to celebrate their praiseworthy Nike 90 shoes, which is none other than the best way with a few more a color.Just because athletes are popularizing the act of wearing Nike shoes, air max

the company has made great strides in giving the average consumer a good reason for buying their shoes: the Nike sense of fashion is considered to be quite trendy. Several different lines exist for different occasions, such as the Black Nike air max 2003 shoe which is intended for formal occasions. Clearly, consumers are just as happy as athletes.Nike always brings out the nicest color ways on their Air Max 90's line up and here is one more to add to that collection. One of my favorite Air Max 90 shoes feature a cool grey base color with a white Nikeair max outlet

swoosh and hyper blue accents along the sole of the sneaker and heel. Also on this pair they kept their mesh toe box design for added comfort and breathability.

This is such a great resource that you are providing and you give it away for free. I love seeing websites that understand the value of providing a quality resource for free. It’s the old what goes around comes around routine.

There are certainly a lot of details like that to take into consideration. That’s a great point to bring up. I offer the thoughts above as general inspiration but clearly there are questions like the one you bring up where the most important thing will be working in honest good faith.

This is such a great resource that you are providing and you give it away for free. I love seeing websites that understand the value of providing a quality resource for free. It’s the old what goes around comes around routine.

There are certainly a lot of details like that to take into consideration. That’s a great point to bring up. I offer the thoughts above as general inspiration but clearly there are questions like the one you bring up where the most important thing will be working in honest good faith.

Hello, i am glad to read the whole content of this blog and am very excited and happy to say that the webmaster has done a very good job here to put all the information content and information at one place, i will must refer this information with reference on my website ...

There are certainly a lot of details like that to take into consideration. That’s a great point to bring up. I offer the thoughts above as general inspiration but clearly there are questions like the one you bring up where the most important thing will be working in honest good faith There are certainly a lot of details like that to take into consideration. That’s a great point to bring up. I offer the thoughts above as general inspiration but clearly there are questions like the one you bring up where the most important thing will be working in honest good faith