She is remembered for lasting less than an entire episode, after being disqualified for not following the rules of her Mute. Despite not lasting very long, she has become a fan favorite from the season.

In She's One Tough Bitch, Evil Valentine is Punished with Mute by Buckley, after being warned multiple times but refusing to not speak, Evil Valentine is harshly eliminated. This makes her the only non-quitter to be eliminated outside of an official elimination, (if one counts London's elimination as official). In fact, she never attended an elimination ceremony or recieved a vote.

Evil Valentine was one of the four previously eliminated contestants to return in Knowing Things Is Mainstream, I Like Surprises. Despite being disqualified, she was given another shot due to the Outcasts Twist, and was there instead of Buckley, Carmonte, or Sophie. However, she lost the challenge to Lindsey, and called it rigged, due to the fact that players who had lasted in the game longer than she had would have an advantage. However, a player who was eliminated in the same episode won.