Related Search

Three investment conclusions from Leicester City’s first Premier League title

Leicester City's 5000-1 English Premier League triumph has shown investors the value of defeating the behavioural bias of loss aversion.

05/05/2016

Stuart Podmore

Investment Propositions Director

Contributes toUnstructured Learning Time

Well, they did it. And if you, like me, felt a strange, momentary anti-climax given Leicester City Football Club didn’t need to kick a ball on Monday night to win the English Premier League, you should be over it by now.

With superlatives coming thick and fast, we might conclude that this is one of the most striking moments in the history of British sport.

As we discussed previously, it is hard not to hear the echoes in the challenges of successful fund management and behavioural bias.

Defeating the behavioural bias of loss aversion

Perhaps more admirable than winning the Premier League while defeating those wealthier, stronger clubs, is the stark fact that in spite of the temptation to limit their play and consolidate their gains, Leicester City collectively defeated the behavioural bias of loss aversion.

It was the equivalent of avoiding the fund manager’s temptation to lock in gains too soon and become overly protective, or an advisory client’s counter-productive desire to avoid losses at all costs without understanding risk as manifested by volatility.

It raises the question of how they have done it and what might we learn, so for those advisers facing clients who insist on trying to time the markets, here are three Schroders conclusions from Leicester City’s success:

1. Predictably unpredictable

Let’s start with the manager, Claudio Ranieri. This is his first title as a manager in his 28 year career and many pundits predicted he would be a failure at Leicester. Those pundits forgot that the world is unpredictable. Markets and economies ebb and flow, and are often at the mercy of sentiment. Our Schroders value team believes that the price you pay, more than the growth you get, is the biggest driver of future returns.

It’s fair to say that most Premier League clubs are anchored to high prices and a cascade of rising prices has created a herding effect.

When a relevant value (an anchor) is available, people make estimates by starting from that value and adjusting to yield the final answer. Investors, like football clubs, often fail to adjust sufficiently from anchors, which impairs investment decisions. Leicester City managed to seek out the value in non-league clubs and abroad. They weren’t chasing the glamorous and expensive names that were over-analysed by the market. From our value perspective, we too look for genuine, cheap names that deliver strong returns over time.

3. High conviction and concentration

And the Leicester squad is an interesting collective observation. This is a smaller, more concentrated group of players, about whom Claudio has great conviction.

The low turnover in the squad represents value investing over time. We buy our stocks and play the long game. It’s worth also mentioning that there is no space for misplaced egos in an unemotional appraisal of risk and return.

And finally, what does the future hold? Leicester’s odds to win next year’s Premier League have come in from 5000-1 to 33-1. In some respects, this is where the work really starts and when loss aversion might really take hold.

For over 200 years, we at Schroders have not unnecessarily tampered with our processes, our values and our client relationships.

If Leicester City sticks to its long-term, tactical success with low squad turnover and an absence of fear, history might just repeat itself.

Sentiment moves in long-term cycles; emotion, investor positioning and press coverage all change as an asset progresses through its life cycle. The graphic below takes you through the eight stages of the sentiment cycle.

Important Information

This website is for professional financial advisers in the UK only and should not be relied upon by retail clients. Retail clients should refer to the Investor Centre. Reliance should not be placed on the views and information on the site when taking investment and/or strategic decisions.

Views and Opinions. Schroders has expressed its own views and opinions on this website, and these may change.

Accuracy of Information. Schroders uses all reasonable skill and care in compiling the information. However, errors or omissions in the information may occur because of a number of factors which are inherent in any Internet access system and are not within Schroders' reasonable control. For example, unauthorised access to this service, or the effects of machine, software or operator error or malfunction in connection with data transmission. This service is accurate only on the date that such information is supplied by Schroders via its Internet service. The relevant date for any particular information is the date shown on the page on which the information appears. In view of the above, Schroders advises you to confirm the accuracy of any information with Schroders before seeking to rely on such information.

Cookies: Most websites use "cookies" to identify users and improve their browsing experience. Cookies are small text files that are downloaded on to a user's device by websites that the user visits. Schroders uses cookies to provide you with a better online experience and, in particular, to tell us how and when pages of our websites are visited, what our visitors' technology preferences are and whether our websites function properly. To find out more about the cookies that we use, their purpose and how you can manage them, please visit: How we use Cookies. By using this site, you agree that we may store and access cookies on your device.