Excelpt in pretty deep leagues, Phelps probably isn't worth waiting for. If he were behind the plate it would be another matter, but he won't put up numbers good enough to make up for his dh-only eligibility.

I agree Josh Phelps is an over rated prospect. He hit a wall in his
career and by the look of it he is not willing to clear it. In my mind
I would rate Kevin Cash, (who just came up from the minors) as a
better catcher than Josh Phelps. Cash's only down fall would be his batting. Phelps needs to go down to the minors and get it together then give the majors another shot 2 or 3 years down the road.