Here Are All The Moments When Joe Biden Laughed At Paul Ryan During The Debate

The immediate reaction after the vice presidential debate on Thursday night was that Vice President Joe Biden's excessive smiling and laughing during the arguments delivered by his opponent was "openly contemptuous and disrespectful."

Below is a chronological mashup of the moments when Biden laughed through Paul Ryan's answers and rebuttals. Of the nine topics covered, Biden managed to control his laughter only in the last one on abortion (and in the closing statements.)