All Rise...

Editor's Note

The Charge

"World, here I come."—Hellboy

Opening Statement

Hellboy II: The Golden Army springs from the imagination of Guillermo
del Toro fully formed with its own unique vision and style marking the meeting
of the superhero genre with fantastic fairy tale. The film serves as the
director's follow-up project to the amazing and critically lauded Pan's Labyrinth, and his passion for
the big red demon seems to run just as high. There is nothing like this in the
superhero world, and too bad the release was timed right around the arrival of
the far more traditional The Dark Knight
and The Incredible Hulk.
This is more Lord of the Rings rather than Superman, and it's all dark and twisted
like a grim fairy tale brought to life with an amazing blend of practical and
CGI moments. In this review we look at the "three disc" Hellboy II:
The Golden Army: 3-Disc Collector's Set, which might be just the first in a
string of collector's editions if the last film gives us any indication of how
many times the studio can dip at this well. Yet no worries, because this three
disc set has plenty of material to keep fans satisfied until some mysterious
director's cut or ultimate collection arrives.

Facts of the Case

Hellboy II: The Golden Army frees del Toro from having to establish
the characters, and deals with an adventure that promises plenty of action
sequences mixed with pure fantasy. A grudge match erupts between the human world
and mythical beasts, all led by an evil elf named Prince Nuada (Luke Goss, Blade II). He wants to summon a legendary army of
mechanical soldiers known as the golden army, which could destroy man's
civilization, but he needs three separate crown pieces to do this. Trying to
stop him is his twin sister, Princess Nuala (Anna Walton, Vampire Diary),
who owns the final piece he'll need. Of course, Hellboy (Ron Perlman, Blade
II) and his fellow members of the Bureau for Paranormal Research and Defense
have to take on the dark forces that threaten humanity. They decide to help the
princess and fight her brother, but the temptation for them is to get back at
the society that has shunned them. Back from the first film we get Hellboy's
girlfriend Liz (Selma Blair, A Dirty
Shame) and fish man sidekick Abe Sapien (Doug Jones, Men in Black II), but there are some
new additions as well. Johann Krauss (physically acted by James Dodd, Layer Cake and voiced by Seth McFarlane,
Family Guy) is an ectoplasmic "by the book" agent in a smoke
filled work suit, and Tom Manning (Jeffrey Tambor, Arrested Development)
provides the human bureaucratic direction. The team has to take on tooth
fairies, forest gods, and the urge to join the monsters in destroying the human
race. It's an adventure that takes them through New Jersey, New York City, an
underground troll market, Ireland, and countless underground chambers where
creatures hide.

The Evidence

Guillermo del Toro developed this continuation with Hellboy's comic
creator Mike Mignola, so the film feels true to the source material even if it
is a different animal removed from the graphic novel plot lines that formed the
first film. What works best here is the exposition was handled by Hellboy's first installment, and you can feel
the director's freedom to open up the sequel to incorporate more of his vision
of what he wants from the franchise. The action sequences are much more
elaborate, the creatures are far more varied, and there is a dark beauty to
every single shot that is a signature of Guillermo. Filmmakers that dabble in
CGI adventure should take note, because Hellboy II: The Golden Army finds
the right balance of practical and CGI effects to create a world that is both
physically convincing and has weight and drama for viewers. Guillermo del Toro
passed up the chance to direct Halo, I Am Legend, One Missed Call, and Harry Potter and the Half-Blood Prince
to do this sequel. It's a labor of love for him, and it shows in every
frame.

The cast is also extremely committed to the film, and good thing most of the
original crew is back. Ron Perlman turned down a role in Dragonball, and
found himself working out four to five hours every day to get back in the full
body red makeup of Hellboy. His performance is surprisingly believable, and
easily one of the best superhero portrayals committed to celluloid. Selma Blair
is back as Liz the girlfriend, and this round her fire color has changed since
she has embraced her powers. Blair provides the right sass and spunk to play off
Perlman. Doug Jones continues his character of the fish inspired Abe Sapien, and
in the sequel he also gets to do the voice which is a nice move. Abe gets more
to do this time, and he adds a lot to the film. The only actor not returning
from the original is Rupert Evans (Agent John Myers) who had a scheduling
conflict that prevented him from doing this film. He is replaced by Jeffrey
Tambour, which works fine in the world of the sequel where the humans just don't
seem to be anything other than interchangeable. Also new to the franchise is
Seth McFarlane, who is a gas literally and figuratively as Johann Strauss, a
being made of mist. Luke Goss and Anna Walton get to play twin elves around whom
all the action centers.

Technically the DVD does not disappoint in terms of audio or visual
presentation. The five channel Dolby Digital surround track is as active as they
come with bullets and fairies whizzing by from speaker to speaker. Dialogue is
presented as well as the bombast, and Danny Elfman's score sounds sumptuous and
fully realized. The visuals are artifact free without scratches or dirt, and a
delicate color palette is executed beautifully. Certainly preparation for a
simultaneous HD release probably helped to insure that we get a stunning DVD
transfer as well.

The amount of extras found on the set is dizzying, and even the director
states on the start of the second disc that his intention is to show the viewer
every aspect that went in to making the film. For young aspiring filmmakers this
is a chance to take a course in Superhero Fantasy 101, and for the rest of us it
will make you feel like you were a part of the crew before it is all done with.
Here is a breakdown of everything you get inside Hellboy II: The Golden Army:
3-Disc Collector's Set:

In the box • A production journal that features a look at
the director's notes and sketches for eight pages. It includes a two sided
mini-poster if you want to remove it and hang it up somewhere.
• A limited edition Golden Army action figure made of plastic
standing 3 1/2 inches tall. A nice piece for your desk or shelf (be sure to
collect all 4,900 for a complete Golden Army set).

Disc One • Deleted Scenes with Optional Commentary offers a
look at only a handful of excised beats and moments adding up to five minutes in
total. • Director's Commentary with Guillermo del Toro
solo—extremely informative and detailed. • Actor's
Commentary with Selma Blair, Jeffrey Tambor, and Luke Goss—a fun gab
session that doesn't tell you too much about the film but plenty about our
cast's strong personalities. • Seven "Set Visits,"
which runs about 14 minutes in total. • Troll Market Tour,
which offers a specific and long look at a major set. • An
animated comic treatment, which serves as an epilogue to the film and possibly a
jumping off point for a third installment.

Disc Two • Prologue simply an introduction from
Guillermo del Toro for the set. • Hellboy: In Service of the
Demon, which is a two and a half hour exhaustive look at the production. • Production Workshop offers a look at story boards and
animatics used for the opening sequence when young Hellboy's father tells him
the story of the Golden Army. • Preproduction Vault
shows us sketches and conceptual material for the film.
• Production Photo Gallery offers close to 200 sketches and
designs. Included are commentary from both del Toro and Mingola.
• Marketing Campaign is a gallery of posters and ideas for
them. • CD Rom Script gives you a chance to print the
film's paper source.

Disc Three • A digital copy of the film for portable media
devices like the iPod.

The Rebuttal Witnesses

There are three versions of the DVD set already floating around on this first
release date, including a single disc and a three disc set in addition to this
collector's edition. The only difference between this one and the three disc set
is the inclusion of the booklet and the toy, which might separate this version
only for the hardcore faithful who want the swag in addition to everything else.
The toy and the book are fun, but they don't add much in the grand scheme of
things. I could see consumers going either way on this one, and the real get is
all the extras including the extensive documentary and the commentaries.

What's up with all these "three disc" collector's editions, which
is really code for "we included a digital copy for you on a separate
disc"? It's misleading, since that third disc is nothing more than a
compressed file for your iPod, which savvy computer users already know how to
create on their own. To add insult to injury, this one warns that it might
expire in October of 2009, meaning you have less than a year possibly to get any
use out of it. What is this? Didn't anybody learn anything from DIVX?

Closing Statement

Including the journal and the Golden Army figurine, Hellboy II: The Golden
Army: 3-Disc Collector's Set is the most exhaustive form of the sequel to be
found on DVD. Fans of the franchise will definitely want to pick this up, and
the less faithful among the Hellboy legions may settle for the single disc or
three disc set. It's an amazingly well done flick, so you can't lose no matter
how you slice it. Hellboy II: The Golden Army may not have made the box
office of Iron Man or The Dark Knight, but it is certainly just as
spectacular and inventive. You gotta love the effort and passion put in to this
film, and it shows in every frame. Bring on part three already!

The Verdict

Guilty of being a great time and the template for how to do a convincing CGI
fantasy. Hellboy is free to go on singing the hits of Barry Manilow!

Give us your feedback!

Did we give Hellboy II: The Golden Army: 3-Disc Collector's Set a fair trial? yes / no

What's "fair"? Whether positive or negative, our reviews should be unbiased, informative, and critique the material on its own merits.