Most, but not all. Wasn't intended to be an attack or a summary of people for and against supplements or anything. Simply stating the opinion that supplements do you more good than case books do. You're free to disagree, that was simply my experience

I never thought you intended any ill will towards anyone via your comment. However, I perused the entire thread after you made the comment, and it still doesn't make much sense, which was the reason for my first reply to your comment. Even if it's true that some people disagree with you, you admit that most people in this thread stated that supplements are better. So it's odd for you to make a statement along the lines of, "I can't believe that the percentage of people who would take supplements over casebooks isn't 100," since you're rarely going to find a unanimity on anything in life, especially on a law students' forum.

Not sure if I'm being stalked or it is just too obvious, but we are in fact two people posting from this account. One current 1L and one '08 graduate who is not yet fired from her job (yay!).

Yeah, I had no clue that 2 people are posting from this account. That's interesting. Why not just use 2 separate user names?

The "other person" would be my girlfriend, and she graduated from law school in '08 and do not really seem all that interested, so she just used my account a couple of times to make some posts regarding her school.