Showrunner Steven S. DeKnight breaks down who survived and who died in the 'Spartacus' series finale and why

[SPOILER ALERT: Read on only if you have already watched Friday’s series finale of Spartacus: War of the Damned.]

Would he live or die? That was the question heading into the series finale of Spartacus tonight. While history tells us the titular hero and his rebel forces were defeated by the might of Rome, some historians have claimed Spartacus’ body was never actually found, lending a glimmer of hope that the gladiator slave turned rebellion leader (originally played by the late Andy Whitfield and then by Liam McIntyre) might actually make it out of the series alive.

Those hopes were dashed when Spartacus, on the verge of killing Marcus Crassus, was speared by a solider from behind. After being carried off by Agron, he died peacefully as a contingent of former slaves he worked to free and protect indeed made it to safety. Other warriors like Gannicus — who was strung up on a cross and left to die — were not so fortunate. We spoke with Spartacus showrunner Steven S. DeKnight about why Spartacus had to die, why he died the way he did, and a whole other planned section to the finale we did not see. [NOTE: Also make sure to check out our finale post with Spartacus himself, Liam McIntyre, or just click on the video player at the end of the two page interview.]

ENTERTAINMENT WEEKLY: I remember when I spoke to you at the start of the season, I said, “Hey they never found Spartacus’ body on the battlefield,” and I wondered if you would use that as an out to have him not die — but nope, he’s dead.
STEVENDeKNIGHT: There was some minor debate, and I hear this from the fans nonstop, “Hey, they never found his body. We’d love to see him wonder off into the sunset.” My feeling is Spartacus incited this rebellion — thousands and thousands of slaves got killed. It would be disingenuous to have him walk off into the sunset. Plus, just the simple fact that he has nothing to walk off to. His love for his wife, which brings us all the way until the final scene of the series — his love for his wife and that loss really keeps him from ever having a life beyond this. His life really ended with her — any chance of a happy life, of a simple life. For him he was either going to win or he was going to die. There’s really no middle ground.

EW: And he couldn’t win.
DeKNIGHT: No he couldn’t win, but he came damn close.

EW: And you mentioned that there was some debate, and Liam mentioned it, too. What would that have looked like had Spartacus survived? Did you plan it at all?
DeKNIGHT: No, actually I was pretty adamant that he had to fall. Story-wise, it just didn’t ring true for me, that he slips away. I was also pretty adamant that somebody we cared about had to get away and carry on the story of Spartacus. But for me, with Spartacus it always needed that powerful ending, which I think is probably a little more in keeping with history. I don’t believe that Spartacus got away. I think if he did you would have heard from him again. He doesn’t seem the type of guy to slip quietly into the dark night, so I never really went down that path. From the beginning of the series, my plan has always been that he either dies on the battlefield and is carried off, or mortally wounded and carried off.

EW: Tell me about that decision to not have Crassus be the one to kill him. In fact, Crassus looked bested in that battle until the spear came through Spartacus’ midsection.
DeKNIGHT: That went through many different versions. The first version was we’d do a call-back to where Crassus was fighting the gladiator in episode one and he uses the same trick on Spartacus, and in an earlier draft it actually works and he runs Spartacus through. And we looked at it and some of us didn’t feel right about Crassus besting Spartacus in a fight, even though it was very clear that Spartacus was seriously wounded before the fight started. So we went round and round and finally settled on, “You know what would be cool? If Crassus does that same trick and Spartacus stops him and almost kills him.” Which was much better. And then I also wanted to mirror a little bit of how Crixus died, that basically these two giants died by being stabbed in the back. It gives it, just a little hint, of the cowardly Romans — that they can’t kill you straight on, these titans, these giants.

EW: I sort of felt that one of the main characters would end up dying on one of the crosses. It looked like it would be Agron a few episodes back. Tell me why you settled on Gannicus and talk about the way you made that scene really tragic and yet heroic?
DeKNIGHT: Yeah that’s another one. That scene was very difficult, I must have written six or seven different versions of that scene. Early on, he didn’t see Oenomaus in his final moments, he just started Spartacus’ name in defiance. And that worked okay, but ehhh, it needed something. So I added in seeing Oenomaus because I thought that really wrapped up everything Gannicus was always saying about seeing his brother again on the shores of the afterlife, and Oenomaus’ dying words saying him and Melitta would greet Gannicus in the afterlife. So I added that part and it worked pretty well.

And then really I think the master stroke came from our director Rick Jacobson, who really orchestrated that transition on the cross, the arena, and Gannicus returning to the only true home he ever had, the only place he ever felt he belonged, which was in the arena. And the combination of that, all those elements together, and then transitioning to Spartacus waking up was just such a one-two punch — it just really could not have worked better.