Historic Jacob Wirth could become a sports bar

No more piano singalongs: Two restaurant operators are seeking to lease the old Jacob Wirth on Stuart Street and turn it into a more modern sports bar named JW's Sports Bar and Restaurant.

William Gateman and Nancy Maida formally asked the Boston Licensing Board this morning to let them buy the restaurant's liquor license. Board Chairwoman Kathleen Joyce, however, deferred any action on the request until after they meet with three neighborhood associations to discuss their plans. One of those groups, the Midtown-Park Plaza Neighborhood Association, meets next week.

Gateman and Maida's attorney, Mark Zuroff, said the new eatery would use the same space as the current restaurant , which opened at its present location in 1878 and closed last year due to water damage after a fire in a floor above the restaurant.

Zuroff said his clients would build out the new restaurant - and renovate the rest of the building - with "due respect" to the historic nature of the exterior and interior of the Greek Revival structure, which both Boston and the National Register of Historic Sites have designated as a landmark. He said the building "is fairly run down" and that fixing it up would "really require someone with capital to come in and renovate it."

Following the hearing, Zuroff estimated it would take nine months to a year to renovate the building and open the restaurant once the liquor-license transfer is approved, in part because of the extent of the work needed, in part because of the difficulties of finding contractors these days.

Inside the bar in 1977:

1877 poster (from the BPL print collection) when Wirth's restaurant was located in a different building less than a block away and when Stuart Street was called Eliot Street):

And the concept change. I don't think it needs to be a halfway German bar with piano sing-alongs any more, but a sports bar? Between the Theater District and Chinatown? Who conceptualized that?

I expect it to die quickly.

Theater/nightclub goers aren't going to get dinner at a sports bar. Chinatown isn't going to go to a sports bar. The fancy hotel attendees aren't going to a sports bar. Tufts hospital visitors aren't going to look for a sports bar. Sports fans are going to go to Fenway or the Garden.

Unless Kraft is putting a soccer stadium over the I-90/93 interchange, I don't know who is going to go to "JW's".

insists that every single one of their bars be another replica of McGreevey's. All their bars are the same exact place. You walk in, and ESPN is tuned to some idiotic show with a few clowns yammering at one another, except it's on mute so you can't even hear what the morons are saying.

I remember when the Downtown Crossing Foley's had a 19" TV over the bar- didn't have cable and was usually off- one visit around 1999 or so asked bartender to put Bruins West Coast game on channel 38- bartender refused and told me I should have stayed home if I wanted to watch the game