So, they're saying, "You're nothing special if you steal music." Maybe you should switch to big bank heists and then maybe, just maybe, MTV will recognize you as special. I'm guessing there's a translation/language barrier here.

bad strategy, bad insight and really horrible execution.
you're addressing the effect, not the cause.
you're insulting some of the audience (which will reject you) and you're giving a sense of pride to others that "Steal"; in fact, you're motivating them to be more than just a petty thief - so you're giving yourself buttkicks.

it's true what everybody said - MTV is not about music nowadays, but about crap reality shows.

to see much artists are respected, don't look at illegal music downloads, but how fast concert tickets sell. You can be sure that a good percent of concert goers buy music. Ahh, but wait.. music labels don't have their share from this. And the piracy bullshit is just a lame excuse for poor distribution, weak promotion and, most of all, lack of artistic value and durability.

stop this bullshit about greedy coporations, it's off the point
seems like if you were in burma, you'll justify the killings - hey, everyone's doing it! oh, and the victims were greedy assholes, you would say
it is still illegal, no matter how many 'fucks' do you put in your sentences

the ad is another question. i would deffend the straightforwardness, sugar-coating the piracy gives no effect - these comments is the evidence
yet i don't think the execution is great

and please, share good examples of anti-piracy campaigns, instead of raging