Is Traditional Irish Food in America Accurate?

If an Irishman came to America on St. Patrick’s Day, he might be a little bit shocked by the leprechaun outfits, green beer guzzlers, and yes, even the corned beef and cabbage.

To be Irish in America is no rare thing—about 34.5 million people in the United States claim Irish heritage according to the 2011 U.S. Census, which is more than seven times the population of Ireland itself.

Despite the sizeable Irish-American population, the dishes Americans perceive as “traditional Irish food” are not entirely representative of actual Irish food, according to many respected people in the Irish food industry.

The first time Irish Chef Noel McMeel tasted corned beef and cabbage was actually in Connecticut when he was 20 years old. McMeel is the executive head chef at the Lough Erne Golf Resort & Hotel.

“Some Americans still think we still live in straw houses and we all have a donkey and cart, just like in the film ‘The Quiet Man,’” McMeel said.

Chef Darina Allen, owner of Ireland’s foremost cooking school called Ballymaloe, describes the country’s food culture over the past 30 years as a “food revolution,” with its artisan sector and farmhouse cheese makers emerging in prevalence.

“Gradually, the perception of Ireland as the land of corned beef and cabbage is changing,” she said.

Irish-American cookbook author Margaret Johnson, said that corned beef and cabbage is really an American interpretation of bacon and cabbage – a more traditional Irish food.

The farm to table produce movement has found a home in Ireland such as this farmers' market in Kildare. (Photo Credit: Tourism Ireland)

Though these are not the conditions modern Irish people deal with, those in the food industry are still very in touch with the land they farm.

“We in Ireland believe very much that we need to be putting Irish ingredient-led cuisine at every point from farm to table,” McMeel said.

He boils the Irish food industry down to five basic pillars: the quality of the food, ingredients and taste, the use of local and seasonal produce, the championing of local artisan producers, the personality of the cuisine and the service, and the hospitality and service.

Johnson said the defining characteristics of modern Irish cuisine include “seasonal produce, local meats and fish, and traditional ingredients like potatoes.”

“A Side of Mashed, Please.”

Though Allen said that the Irish are eating fewer potatoes than in the past, Chef Garrett Byrne, named Best Chef at the 2012 Irish Restaurant Awards, said it would be unusual not to get potatoes with your main course, even at a high end restaurant. Johnson added they are often served at home as well, fashioned in a variety of ways ranging from boiled to mashed to fried to a gratin.

Before the introduction of the potato to Irish cuisine, milk, cheese, meat, cereals, and certain vegetables composed the Irish diet, McMeel said. After the early 18th century, no meal was considered complete without them, he said. The Great Famine killed nearly a million people over a span of five years in the mid-1800s.

Corned beef and cabbage is not actually real Irish food. The traditional dish is Ireland's version of bacon with cabbage. (Photo: Tourism Ireland)

St. Patrick, Meet Uncle Sam

Oddly enough, Boston, not any city in Ireland, claims to have the oldest St. Patrick’s Day parade. Byrne believes that St. Patrick’s Day in general has become more of a holiday for foreigners over the years.

“It seems the further away from Ireland we are the more it is celebrated, especially in America where they go the extra mile as regards [to] the green Guinness and the cooking of the traditional Irish dishes,” Byrne said. “It is sporadic at best here and confined to a few pubs, especially in Dublin.”

However, Allen said that in more recent years Ireland has taken advantage of the tourism opportunity that St. Patrick’s Day provides, and March 17 has become more of a celebration. McMeel added that there will typically be someone playing music at the bar, and Riverdance style dancing ensues.

Want to insult an Irishman when you're trying to celebrate St. Patrick's Day? Drink a green beer.

Johnson noted bigger cities tend to have parades and smaller ones will feature local bands and children’s groups. However, she is insulted by America’s attempt to be festive. She views green beer as “totally offensive” and “something you would not find in Ireland.”

Though the off-colored beer could be considered controversial, America’s take on Irish soda bread has gotten a good review from Allen. She calls it “delicious,” though, “quite different to Irish Soda Bread, which is either brown or white.” She said the American version is closer to what the Irish deem ‘Spotted Dog,’ except with added caraway seeds. The Irish call it “emigrants’ bread”, she said.

You Have Potatoes, We Have Burgers

Some Irish people in the food industry consider hotdogs, burgers, and pizza to be “American,” but have learned from their own country’s faulty food stereotypes that America’s food culture has more to offer. Byrne believes that the Irish have a higher regard in recent years for American food largely due to the growing popularity of American chefs.

“Irish people see America still as the land of great opportunity, as for the food they think fast food and shining lights. How we all dream to be there,” McMeel said.

American cuisine has long been a combination of the culture of its people, so it is no surprise that America’s version of Irish cuisine is more of an adaption than a replica of traditional Irish food.

Probably because the baking instructions are usually on the pastry package. Mine has one for empty and one for filled. I can't wait to try this recipe. Cheese and mushrooms are a favorite combo. I wonder if the crisped sage leaves would keep if I made them a few days ahead and placed in a sealed container?

Thanks for a glimpse into a large family. I has 2 sisters and brother, but they were grown and moved out when I came along. My parents rule was stocking before breakfast, and tree after breakfast when often my oldest sister and her family would come to open presents under the tree. And my grandparents stayed with us over holidays.

I followed the recipe with the exception of adding chopped garlic to the ricotta ecause I just love garlic. I also switched from 375 regular bake to a 300 degree convection bake for the last 10 min to help some of the liquid evaporate. My crust was perfect all the way through! Also: pro tip: use full fat Greek yogurt! It's the closest to sour cream in f