I feel like this is gonna get many pages. I will reserve this spot tehehe. Will post list later after i have thought for a while.
Still i must say i`m surprised. Cant believe you posted guilty crown as the biggest disappointment.

Least Favorite series: Shining Hearts, Eureka Seven: AO, Arcana Familga
Series that disappointed me the most after the first episode: Arcana Familga
Series that has the best soundtrack: Kuroko no Basket
Series that has the best OP song: Dusk Maiden of Amnesia
Series that has the best ED song: Shinsekai Yori
Series that I should of dropped: Guilty Crown, Black Rock Shooter
Series that will likely have another season: Kuroko no Basket

Most Intelligently Written Dialogue - Humanity has Declined -- depending on my mood, Nisemonogatari.Best Romance - My Little Monster, but there are a lot of deserving titles.Best Drama - Chihayafuru, with Kokoro Connect and Kids on the slope close behind.Worst Show That I Finished - Total EclipseFunniest - Pet Girl of Sakurasou, with Nyarko in a semi-close second.Favorite Art Style - Shin Sekai YoriBiggest Surprise - Bodacious Space Pirates and Listen to me Girls, I'm your FatherBest WTF? - Nisemonogatari toothbrush.Best Scene - Fate/Zero S2, although I can't remember all the great scenes this year:

Spoiler Alert! Click to show or hide

Kiritsugu's final conversation with his mentor, knowing that he will kill her. That was the highlight of the show for me.

Best Character - Watashi from Humanity has Declined.Best Antagonist - Sakata Kintoki from Kintama or Gilgamesh/Archer from Fate/ZeroBest Eye Candy - Cryska Barchenowa from Total Eclipse, but Mashiro from Sakurasou has her moments, and Aoyama deserves at least a mention.

Best OP
1. Psycho-Pass
2. Sword Art Online 1 (Say what you want about the show -- the intro is awesome)
3. Jormungand: Perfect Order
4. Bodacious Space Pirates

best non-OP/ED song in an OST:
"her name is koko she is loco i said OH NO" by Someone who sounds like Ya Kid K

best 2011 show that ended in 2012
Fate/Zero (AKA Iskandar/Owns Everything Around You)
. . .I just started Another(AKA Daria Of The Dead), if I like that one it goes here too.
I didn't see Mirai Nikki yet, so I can't think of a nickname for it.