Wow, I'd make this trade, only if you can lock Kovalchuk up long-term. As good as I think Staal and Letang are going to be, the Penguins are deep defensively and I don't think that Staal will ever reach his full potential here in Pittsburgh. Satan's most likely a 1-year rent-a-player anyways. I'd hate for them to give up another first round pick though.

i would not want Letang or GoGo in that trade - they are cheap and will replace Gonchar after next season, if Staal is that much of a stud he and a 1st ronder should be able to get us Kovy (i watched the Thashers game lastnight and it was just awfull- they should trade Kovy and then move to a differnt city and just start over)

I think this is interesting. I'm fine with the Pens sticking it out with Staal and letting him develop, but at the same time, we're probably looking at him being a third line center this season - albeit a good one - and then things really get fuzzy this summer because I don't think this team should match a potential crazy offer sheet that he could get from a team that has the money to spend and a lack of talent in the pipe line, should their be a suitable match. Kovalchuk is more attractive than Gaborik because he's proven he can stay in the lineup, proven he can put up elite numbers, and he's a relative bargain through next season. He'd be gone after next season, but that gives the team two prime playoff runs to win championships. I think that'd be a better compensation for Staal than the draft picks you'd get from an offer sheet.

The Pens don't need Armstrong so take him out of the deal - they have better versions in Dupuis and Kennedy. Ii wouldn't give up Satan either. You can fit Kovalchuk under the cap and Satan is a least worthwhile depth. I really don't like moving either Letang or Goligoski if you're already giving up Staal. Make it Staal plus a lower level prospect or two and I could probably endorse that.