Redsteel or Madden 07

Sorry if there are already discussions on this. But, I plan to getting either Redsteel or Madden 07. And I just wanna know opinions from people have played the games or have them. Are they so good that I should get both ? Should I rent them first ?

Why would you have bought a ps3 if you wanted to play sports games? The Wii shines for all sports. Madden 07 for the Wii brought so much life back to Madden 07 I would not even want to play it on a PS3 after experiancing the Wii.
For the TS get Madden it has many more hours of play then Red steel I have both.

Madden 07 is the best football game ever made. My brothers and I have been playing it since sunday religiously. The controls are amazing and in a 2v2 the things you can do as a team are unheard of. If you like football games you will love this one to no end.

Red Steel is amusing and that is about it. The multiplayer is simplistic and juvenile, the single player is mediocre at best. Sword KO? WTF are you talking about it's a freaking sword, how do you KO someone with a sword? Red steel is my least favorite game and I have them all, MUA is probably a close second