Highlights

Scouting report

James is an active, athletic defensive lineman who lacks the physical traits of an NFL interior lineman and the athletic traits of a defensive end. While his instincts and awareness are top-notch, he might struggle to find a home on an NFL roster unless he can bulk up and carve out a niche as a sub-package interior rusher.

From Dane Brugler’s draft guide:

In the Badgers’ 3-4 base, he played primarily head up or inside the offensive tackle and was clearly out of position. James has adequate point of attack strength and the toughness is there, but he is stiff-legged, struggling to bend, create leverage and combat drive blockers. As a pass rusher, he lacks the get-off burst to threaten the corner with any consistency. Overall, James, whose father (Jimmie) had a cup of coffee in the NFL, is a try-hard competitor who projects best as a base end in a 4-3, but doesn’t make enough plays run in his direction.

Alec James is a bit of a man without a position as he heads into his professional career. Mentioned at his Pro Day both 3-4 and 4-3 teams have talked to him. Likely ends up as a 4-3 base end who kicks inside on pass rush downs, however he likely struggles to get on the field in front of other pass rushers other than in a rotational role. He’ll do anything you ask of him, just the perception of lack of athletic upside to garner more interest than an undrafted free agent gig.

Outlook

James is a player to watch. At defensive end, there are really only three spots that appear to be locked up. A fourth or fifth is completely up for grabs. His motor will catch the attention of coaches and fans. Because he is very football smart and disciplined, if he shows he has enough strength or athleticism to hold up, he can find himself on the roster in September.