NOGALES, Mexico (CNS) — Dominican
Sister Donna Markham, president and CEO of Catholic Charities USA, grew
emotional talking about the harrowing stories she heard from immigrants about
the life they left behind to seek refuge in the United States.

“The suffering they are going
through is unimaginable,” she said after listening to stories from families
waiting to apply for asylum at the international border at Nogales in the Mexican
state of Sonora.

Sister Markham, who recently
completed a tour of a detention facility for children in McAllen, Texas, said
she wanted to visit Nogales to get the whole story behind the current public
debate over immigration.

“Their stories,” she said, pausing
to compose herself. “They are running for their lives. Literally, they left at
gunpoint.”

She was joined July 11 at the
Nogales Port of Entry by Jesuit Father Sean Carroll, executive director of the
Kino Border Initiative, an organization that assists mostly families who have
been sent back to Mexico following deportation proceedings.

With the large influx of
refugees seeking to enter the U.S., Father Carroll, along with other religious-based
and nonprofit agencies in Nogales, Arizona, have set up temporary shelters and
a check-in system for families seeking to enter the U.S. and to apply for asylum.

Were it not for those shelters, families
would have to wait in line at the port of entry in the humidity and heat of 100-plus
degrees for about two weeks, Father Carroll told Catholic Outlook, newspaper of
the Diocese of Tucson, Arizona.

The first family Sister Markham
met included 11 members, four of whom were young children. They left the
Mexican state of Guerrero, one of the poorest and least safe areas in the
country.

Father Carroll interpreted their
story, explaining how their lives had been threatened by a local political
party during the recent presidential election. At the border, their biggest
fear is that the father and uncle would be detained, the children taken from
them, and the women deported. Knowing that risk, they waited anyway because
“they were threatened with death” in their hometown, Sister Markham said.

While such conditions might
easily fall into the classic example of political asylum, Peg Harmon, who is executive
director of Catholic Community Services in the Diocese of Tucson and has been a
Catholic Charities USA board member, acknowledged that under the current
vetting system, there were no guarantees.

Another family — two women and
two young children — also spoke to Sister Markham. One woman held a young girl
close to her who appeared to be no older than 9 and was crying inconsolably.
The mother, also from Guerrero, spoke of her husband being taken and her
daughter’s life being threatened. She was with another woman, with a son about
same age. They had tried to cross into the U.S. in January but were stopped and
deported in February. Under current U.S. policy, they would not be eligible to
enter the country because of the previous attempt, but have no other place to
go.

Sister Maria Engracia Robles Robles,
a Missionary Sister of the Eucharist, works at a “comedor” — a combined soup
kitchen and food pantry — run by Kino Border Initiative in Nogales, Sonora. As
she listened to the families’ stories, she used her cellphone to put their
names on the list of applicants waiting to file for asylum.

Several people passing the
families as they entered the U.S. from Mexico offered them candy and money.
Local charities also supplied blankets and water bottles, kept in large
coolers, at the border station.

Following her meeting with the
families, Sister Markham said there were two things she hoped to accomplish
when she returns to her organization’s national headquarters outside
Washington.

“We need to call all believers
to prayer, and we have to educate people who don’t have the opportunity to come
here,” she said.

Sister Markham said that
visiting Nogales was a completely different experience from her trip to visit
the juveniles held in Texas. In McAllen, “they are already going through the
process; there the process is very slow.”

“Here, it is very painful to
hear the stories, to know how people have suffered to get this far, especially
the children,” she said. “It’s emotionally overwhelming. It’s more painful than
I imagined.”

The next day in Tucson, Sister Markham was
joined by Bishop Edward J. Weisenburger of Tucson at Casa Alitas, a family shelter run by
Catholic Community Services. Casa Alitas receives families in
transition from Immigration and Customs Enforcement, or ICE, after being
processed from the border and immigration court.

Early July 12, two families were
preparing to leave Casa Alitas and another four were being placed there. When
the bishop and Sister Markham arrived, Olga, a Honduran refugee, was preparing
to leave with her two children to board a bus for a three-day trip to stay with
family in Baltimore.

A few hours later, Valentia, a
Mexican native, was leaving with her two children for her own cross-country
trip to a community in New Jersey. Soon the Casa Alitas staff welcomed new families —
three from Brazil and one from Mexico — brought to the facility by ICE.

Sister Markham visited the home
the night before and had a chance to spend some time with the departing
families. During her morning visit, she gave hugs and smiles to the familiar
faces, and later, interviews with local media who arrived to document the
visit.

“Our goal is to do everything we
can to see that these families are treated with dignity,” she told one
reporter.

A glance around the now-crowded
living area revealed weary women and children, some of whom looked ready for a
nap. Some needed clothing, which was available from a supply room. The smell of
a hot breakfast began to waft out of the kitchen where signs and wipe boards
and children’s drawings created a homey atmosphere.

Bishop Weisenburger noted that
“20 percent of the Gospels is about taking care of the poor and needy.” Taking
care of immigrants and refugees is important for those who want “to really live
the Gospel of Jesus Christ and to call ourselves Christian.”

As she began to describe her
experience from the day before, Sister Markham again paused to fight back tears
after talking about “the babies sitting at the border in the heat.”

“I have a big heart,” she
explained, smiling again.

Before leaving to catch her
flight back east, Sister Markham showered praise upon the more than half dozen
workers and volunteers gathered at Casa Alitas as new families arrived. “I am just amazed at the staff and the level
of attention they give to the families here.”

– – –

Brown is managing editor of
Catholic Outlook, newspaper of the Diocese of Tucson.

The Author

Catholic News Service

Catholic News Service has a rich history of journalistic professionalism and is a leader in the world of Catholic and religious media. With headquarters in Washington, offices in New York and Rome, and correspondents around the world, CNS provides the most comprehensive coverage of the church today.