Two Planets Separated by Less than 5 Earth Moon Distances

In this artist’s conception, a “hot Neptune” known as Kepler-36c looms in the sky of its neighbor, the rocky world Kepler-36b. The two planets have repeated close encounters, experiencing a conjunction every 97 days on average. At that time, they are separated by less than 5 Earth-Moon distances. Such close approaches stir up tremendous gravitational tides that squeeze and stretch both planets, which may promote active volcanism on Kepler-36b.Credit: David A. Aguilar (CfA)

By using data from NASA’s Kepler spacecraft and asteroseismology, the study of stars by observing their natural oscillations, scientists discovered two planets circling a sub-giant star that are at times separated by less than 5 Earth-Moon distances.

Cambridge, Massachusetts – Few nighttime sights offer more drama than the full Moon rising over the horizon. Now imagine that instead of the Moon, a gas giant planet spanning three times more sky loomed over the molten landscape of a lava world. This alien vista exists in the newly discovered two-planet system of Kepler-36.

“These two worlds are having close encounters,” said Josh Carter, a Hubble Fellow at the Harvard-Smithsonian Center for Astrophysics (CfA).

“They are the closest to each other of any planetary system we’ve found,” added co-author Eric Agol of the University of Washington.

They spotted the planets in data from NASA’s Kepler spacecraft, which can detect a planet when it passes in front of, and briefly reduces the light coming from, its parent star.

The new found system contains two planets circling a sub-giant star much like the Sun except several billion years older. The inner world, Kepler-36b, is a rocky planet 1.5 times the size of Earth and weighing 4.5 times as much. It orbits about every 14 days at an average distance of less than 11 million miles.

The outer world, Kepler-36c, is a gaseous planet 3.7 times the size of Earth and weighing 8 times as much. This “hot Neptune” orbits once each 16 days at a distance of 12 million miles.

The two planets experience a conjunction every 97 days on average. At that time, they are separated by less than 5 Earth-Moon distances. Since Kepler-36c is much larger than the Moon, it presents a spectacular view in its neighbor’s sky. (Coincidentally, the smaller Kepler-36b would appear about the size of the Moon when viewed from Kepler-36c.) Such close approaches stir up tremendous gravitational tides that squeeze and stretch both planets.

Researchers are struggling to understand how these two very different worlds ended up in such close orbits. Within our solar system, rocky planets reside close to the Sun while the gas giants remain distant.

Although Kepler-36 is the first planetary system found to experience such close encounters, it undoubtedly won’t be the last.

“We’re wondering how many more like this are out there,” said Agol.

“We found this one on a first quick look,” added Carter. “We’re now combing through the Kepler data to try to locate more.”

This result was made possible with asteroseismology. Asteroseismology is the study of stars by observing their natural oscillations. Sun-like stars resonate like musical instruments, due to sound waves trapped in their interiors. And just like a musical instrument, the larger the star, the “deeper” are its resonances. This trapped sound makes the stars gently breathe in and out, or oscillate.

Co-author Bill Chaplin (University of Birmingham, UK) noted, “Kepler-36 shows beautiful oscillations. By measuring the oscillations we were able to measure the size, mass and age of the star to exquisite precision.”

He added, “Without asteroseismology, it would not have been possible to place such tight constraints on the properties of the planets.”

The research was funded by NASA, the Space Telescope Science Institute and the National Science Foundation.

Headquartered in Cambridge, Massachusetts, the Harvard-Smithsonian Center for Astrophysics (CfA) is a joint collaboration between the Smithsonian Astrophysical Observatory and the Harvard College Observatory. CfA scientists, organized into six research divisions, study the origin, evolution and ultimate fate of the universe.

Supposing our Sun is viewed from another star, only gas giants like Jupiter, Saturn, Uranus and Neptune can be observed as exo-planets occluding our star, the Sun, since all other planets are mere specks not to be observed. Again, if Jupiter is occluding our Sun, along with its satellites it is possible for the observer to conclude that a giant gas exo-planet and its close neighbour an earthly planet are going round in close orbits as found in this case of a nearby star which is a sub-giant. These sub-giants have dragged all their gas giant planets in close orbits along with their train of satellites. Thank You.