Measles vaccination and SSPE

SSPE is a persisting measle infection of the central nervous system; infiltrates with B and T lymphocytes can be found in the nervous system as well as measle viruses which display typical mutations. Excessively high antibody titres against measles can be found in the blood of the people who have contracted the disease. Generally the disease is lethal.

According to American figures the risk of SSPE is ten times as high after measle vaccinations were introduced, presumably due to a relatively higher number of measles in very early childhood. (William J. Bellini,1 Jennifer S. Rota,1 Luis E. Lowe,1 Russell S. Katz,1 Paul R. Dyken,3 Sherif R. Zaki,2 Wun-Ju Shieh,2 and Paul A. RotaSubacute Sclerosing Panencephalitis: More Cases of This Fatal Disease Are Prevented by Measles Immunization than Was Previously Recognized, The Journal of Infectious Diseases 2005;192:1686-1693)

This tendency would correspond with Arenz’s figures from the his pediatric practice, which, however, seem somewhat exaggerated.

SSPE-cases caused by measle vaccine viruses could not be confirmed: during autopsies of measle-vaccinated SSPE victims wild viruses were frequently found in the CNS. Whether the vaccination triggers SSPE despite preceding measles is not clear.

This also holds true for the measle vaccine viruses to which a smaller part of the people vaccinated react by skewing in the direction TH2. The fact that there is no specific cellular immune response can entail a primary or secondary vaccine failure. It has not been determined to what extent this is favored by mumps or rubella viruses during the MMR vaccination. (Dhiman N, Ovsyannikova IG, Ryan JE, Jacobson RM, Vierkant RA, Pankratz VS, Jacobsen SJ, Poland GA., Correlations among measles virus-specific antibody, lymphoproliferation and Th1/Th2 cytokine responses following measles-mumps-rubella-II (MMR-II) vaccination, Clin Exp Immunol. 2005 Dec;142(3):498-504.)

Wakefield and Co postulate a similar mechanism as with SSP for their “autistic enterocolitis” after MMR vaccination. Children who have autistic enterocolitis display an immune system which is skewed in accordance with TH2. The consequence is that the measle virus persists in the CNS and in the intestinal mucous membrane. Vaccine viruses can be found in the intestinal walls, the lymphocytes and the spinal fluid of people who are affected. Furthermore, they have an excessively high measle vaccine antibody in their serum and in their spinal fluid.

I wonder whether autistic enterocolitis isn’t a kind of SSPE with a weakened (vaccine)virus. A imbalance of TH1/TH2 system seems to be the prerequisite for both CNS diseases. Possible causes for an imbalance are mercury (thimerosal) and vaccinations during the first months of life.

“At the level of the immune response, the newborn tends towards a TH2 response to pathogens and gradually shifts towards a TH1 response with age. If this transition does not take place appropriately, the infant is likely to be at greater risk of mounting aberrant immune responses in later life, as seen in patients with allergies. Given that, under normal circumstances the age of this transition will be different for different children, it seems inevitable that a ubiquitous viral exposure of all 15-month-old children could induce an immune response that is consistent with the individual dynamics of this TH2-TH1 transition.” (Wakefield AJ, and Montgomery SM. Autism, viral infection, measles-mumps-rubellavaccination. Israeli Med Ass J 1999;1:183-187).

When considering at which point in time the measle vaccination poses less of a risk we must therefore ask ourselves when the immune system in the TH2-TH2 area is sufficiently stable. Achieving a stable balance seems to vary from each child to the next but it is completed after the age of three to five years. (http://pressearchiv-kubitschek.www.de/pharma-presse/presseerklaerungen/texte/pharma_medikamente/alk_scherax/alk_scherax_140400.html). This could be the reason why it would be better not to vaccinate against the measles but at least not to vaccinate MMR.

In the USA and Finland SSPE has become extremely rare since the drop in wild measles.

As is known, subclinical measles occur in the first year of life if maternal antibodies are present. ( http://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/entrez/query.fcgi?cmd=Retrieve&db=pubmed&dopt=Abstract&list_uids=10195680&query_hl=1 ). It is these types of cases that seem to have a predisposition for SSPE (the wild virus CNS is then discovered in them). Measles that do not include a visible rash could be a decisive factor for the development of SSPE. The children apparently do not manage to eliminate the virus in this case. It is also possible that administering medication that lowers fevers could prevent elimination of the virus.