Almost two years ago the real estate new development world was rocked by the New York Times epic page one story by Louise Story and Stephanie Saul about foreign investment in U.S. real estate. The vehicle for “Towers of Secrecy” purchases was the ubiquitous LLC shell corporation. While I’m no advocate of illegal activity for the sake of preserving the health of a real estate market, I was very skeptical and outspoken about the challenge of measuring the impact of this new rule. Especially since the new development market had already started to show signs of over supply by mid 2014 in both Manhattan above $3M and Miami above $1M. It also seemed to single out wealthy buyers who did not want to get a mortgage. How could the effectiveness of this six month rule be measured reliably enough to be extended or made permanent when the market was already falling?

Since these series of articles came out, I have learned a lot more about the scale of kleptocracy around the world and more appreciative of what the rule attempted to accomplish.

Fast forward to 2017 and the super lux (≥$5M) new development condo market cooled sharply. The rule has been extended but is now up for renewal in a month. It is not clear whether the new administration will renew it. Nicholas Nehamas of the Miami Herald penned are great recap of the rule status. To make it even better, he included a YouTube video of bulldozers playing chicken in the piece.

I have to say I admire the messaging that came out of Homeland Security to justify the rule’s impact. Whether or not the following is an exageration, the mere existance of the rule is probably an effective deterent.

“We don’t come across [money laundering in real estate] once every 10 or 12 cases,” said John Tobon, U.S. Homeland Security Investigations Deputy Special Agent in Charge for South Florida. “We come across real estate being purchased with illicit funds once every other case.”

Here are the areas current covered by the Treasury rule.

Using the parameters of the rule, the Miami Herald asked that I analyze sales in the five boroughs of NYC since enactment. I stuck with condos and 1-3 families since co-ops tend not be a preferred property type of foreign buyers. I found that sales dropped 6% year over year for the aggregate of Manhattan sales over $3M and the outer borough sales of $1.5M. This included legacy contracts that closed during the rule enactment period but went to contract before it started. Those sales likely softened the actual decline in sales.

While it appears reasonable that the rule had some drag on demand, a possible repeal in February won’t likely have much of an impact on the oversupply that currently exists.

GET BLOG POSTS DIRECTLY TO YOUR INBOX!

Sign up to stay updated and get Jonathan Miller's blog posts by email.

One Response to ““Kleptocracy Initiative” to Stop Money Laundering in Real Estate up for Renewal”

It’s interesting to see the different impacts the crackdowns having in different areas. It will be interesting to see which way these trends go or if they stay the same in the months to come. Thanks for sharing Jonathan.

Follow Jonathan

Newsletter Signup:

If you haven't already, sign up for
'Housing Notes' to receive weekly insights and research.

First Name

Last Name

Email Address

About Jonathan Miller

Jonathan Miller is President and CEO of Miller Samuel Inc., a real estate appraisal and consulting firm he co-founded in 1986. He is a state-certified real estate appraiser in New York and Connecticut, performing court testimony as an expert witness in various local, state and federal courts. He holds the Counselors of Real Estate (CRE) and Certified Relocation Professional (CRP) designations. He is an Appraiser “A” Member of the Real Estate Board of New York and a member of Relocation Appraisers and Consultants, Inc.Learn More...

Subscription Service Coming Soon

You'll be able to choose from an array of robust housing metrics compiled using research developed during the preparation of our market report series. Expanded significantly from prior offerings, use this resource to build charts and custom data tables or leverage your own information for more powerful research and presentations.

In the meantime, here is a small sample of the aggregated data we will provide.

“New York real estate maven Jonathan Miller.”–Slate

“If New York real estate is a sport, one of its most prominent score keepers is Jonathan Miller.”–New York Daily News

“Miller is arguably the most influential voice in residential property valuation markets today.”–Altos Research

“His prescient 2012 declaration that “luxury real estate is the new global currency” was repeated as gospel...”–New York Post

“Jonathan Miller, the go-to expert on all residential real estate figures.”–Crain’s New York Business

“His market reports are to the Manhattan housing market what those brackets are to the NCAA Tournament.”–New York Observer

“Jonathan Miller: One of the most famous appraisers in America today.”–Phil Crawford, 'Voice of Appraisal' Radio Show

“Our sherpa in the land of broker euphemism for the current state of the housing market.”–New York Observer

“Should we have seen this coming?...I spoke to appraiser Jonathan Miller 3 years ago.”–Jane Wells, CNBC

“Jonathan Miller—the data whisperer”–Brick Underground

“Jonathan Miller is the most trusted (and quoted) man in New York real estate.”–New York Observer

Matrix Blog

An earlier version of this post appeared in my weekly Housing Notes, March 15, 2019 edition. I’ve since added more information and insights as the situation unfolds. This proposed “pied-a-terre” tax law has a name that infers it concerns “pied-a-terres”… Read More