I think if you were to base the voting on radio play, definitely CRAP, but I have to respect them for what they do and continue to do. I would not like to own more than, say, three albums by them. NOT CRAP.

2nd Rick wrote:I got a boot version of a modern studio re-do of In Color that was supposed to be done by Steve, it includes some new versions of old B-Sides and unreleased material... BTW, It sounds phenomenal.

Hey Steve!!, any comment??

Are any others done?? and are they going to officially see the light of day??

Dylan wrote:I think if you were to base the voting on radio play, definitely CRAP.

I disagree.

"I Want You To Want Me", "Surrender", "Dream Police", "Voices" and "Ain't That A Shame" are beautiful rock radio singles, and more than make up for "The Flame" and "Don't Be Cruel".

And I think that "Tonight It's You" and "If You Want My Love" work well as rock radio singles, too.

But, as Dylan also indicates, Cheap Trick is much more than their radio hits. The first four Cheap Trick studio albums (plus "Live At Budokan") are great and beautiful. How I love those records.

And even during their non-Tom Peterson "down" years, they were able to knock out great singles like "She's Tight".

And having seen them in concert recently, I will attest to the fact that they still bring it. Are they a better band than they were in 1978? They just might be. In my book, there is much to be said for a band that comes back with such a vengeance.

One day me and my friends went to ATP it was the Shellac curated one we saw lots of good bands like Dead Moon and Plush and also Shellac. We had a very good time and also The Breeders played and lots of good bands. At the end of the three days we were very tired. The last bands to play were Cheap Trick and The Fall we tried to choose between them. Me and my friends had never listened to Cheap Trick only heard one or two songs and knew the silly man with the guitar and knew they had a very famous live album done in Japan. Some of my friends chose The Fall but me and some others chose Cheap Trick it was a real gamble but that is the one we chose.

The nice man from Shellac his name is Steve Albini he came onto the stage and told the audience he was not in Cheap Trick but he was proud to call them friends and his name was Steve. Then the band called Cheap Trick came on the stage and started playing songs and I liked the sound of it and went near the front to see the band better. I was close to the silly guitarist man and the singer and they played songs which I didn't know but when I heard them play the songs I thought that I knew them all already and that they sounded like classic famous songs that I loved straight away. Each song after the next seemed better and better and all with great choruses and then I started thinking the guitarist man is not really silly he just pretends to be silly like a funny clown but he is not silly when he plays the music on his guitar.

Then I realised that the man who was singing he was very good and his voice was a very good voice and he did not speak to the audience not even once because he was concentrating on the singing he was doing so much. I looked around me and saw that some people maybe thought the band was a silly rock band and were funny but they were enjoying it as well and some of the people liked it a lot. I stayed at the front and I realised that the band Cheap Trick were not silly and I started to feel strange like it was special. The guitarist man said the singer was his favourite singer in the world and the singer's name was Robin Zander and I looked at him and he was very sweaty and not saying a word to the audience still but singing as if they had told him he was going to die very soon and this might be his last ever time to sing.

I looked at the other men in the band and they were called Bun E. Carlos on the drums and Tom Petersen on the bass and the funny guitarist was called Rick Neilsen and he threw plectrums into the audience and I got some of them and when I watched the other men in the band playing the songs I thought maybe they had been told that this might also be their last concert so better make it a special one. But I was more looking at Robin Zander the man who was singing because I could tell he used to be a famous rock star on people's posters on their bedroom walls and now he was much older and maybe he once wanted to give up singing because he was older but instead decided to concentrate on the singing and get better and better at it as he got older. He was very sweaty and it didn't put him off and he was very exciting to watch and he didn't move around.

As I heard more and more songs in the concert I thought about how the band Cheap Trick had played big stadiums and had girls screaming at them and been very famous and probably had lots of drugs and other things like that but now they were here playing to some people who didn't know them or really care about them like I didn't know them and some of the people watching probably wanted to see The Fall instead. But they did not get sad and instead they played like they did not want to be anywhere else or be doing anything else in the whole world. The more I watched and listened the more I thought that maybe they were much better than a lot of bands I had seen before who were even much younger than them. I became lost in the power of the band and I think that maybe someone like a doctor or a powerful ghost told them that if they do not play the best concert they can possibly play they will not live anymore and the band Cheap Trick played the show at ATP as if it was for their lives.

Cheap Trick played for their lives and because they want to live and want to play rock music more than most other bands I had ever seen in my life. As I watched them I understood what true rock music was and it was maybe the best band playing a concert I have ever seen.

I have never seen a band give so much and I was in a daze afterwards and thankyou to the nice man Steve Albini and Shellac for asking them to play at the festival where I was I will never forget it. Some of my friends didn't like it but some of them said it was one of the best things they had ever seen and we couldn't really talk to eachother properly. Then we went home the end.

When I was a child of 6 or so, my parents took me on my yearly trip to Disneyworld ('cos the grandparents lived nearby.)

I was a huge fan of "I Want You To Want Me" and sang along to it every time it poured out of the radio in my mom's '72 Dodge Dart (seats 8, for dinner) to the point where my parents actually purchased the record for me.

In any case, my parents and I were waiting in line for the Pirates of the Caribbean ride, and my father points over my shoulder and says to me "Hey, it's that guy from that band, they sing that song you like..." and I turned around to face Rick Nielsen.

In an act that to this day remains one of the coolest things my father has ever done (eclipsed only, perhaps, by his bequeathment to me of his Canon FT-QL from 1965), he jockeyed me into position so that when they loaded the boats for the ride, I got to sit between Rick and Bun, with Robin and Tom behind me.

burun wrote:When I was a child of 6 or so, my parents took me on my yearly trip to Disneyworld ('cos the grandparents lived nearby.)

I was a huge fan of "I Want You To Want Me" and sang along to it every time it poured out of the radio in my mom's '72 Dodge Dart (seats 8, for dinner) to the point where my parents actually purchased the record for me.

In any case, my parents and I were waiting in line for the Pirates of the Caribbean ride, and my father points over my shoulder and says to me "Hey, it's that guy from that band, they sing that song you like..." and I turned around to face Rick Nielsen.

In an act that to this day remains one of the coolest things my father has ever done (eclipsed only, perhaps, by his bequeathment to me of his Canon FT-QL from 1965), he jockeyed me into position so that when they loaded the boats for the ride, I got to sit between Rick and Bun, with Robin and Tom behind me.

Apparently they spoke to me, and I spoke back. They were nice to me.

If they were to be judged by this alone, they would be Not Crap.

However, they made some incredible records.

So still, not crap.

Salut, burun's Dad! Salut, Cheap Trick! This post, she is to make me cry!

So good to hear this beautiful tale of childhood heroes, especially now!

Salut!

"You get a kink in your neck looking up at people or down at people. But when you look straight across, there's no kinks."
--Mike Watt