Our Consignment Policy

Items that are accepted for consignment must be clean and ready for the sales floor.
Items needing repair or cleaning may be charged a fee

Now Offering Estate Appraisals!

Call us today at (585) 314-7652 for more information

Great Expectations Consignment Shop was awarded the Victor, New York Retailer of the year 2015

Buyers Advantage

Why should you buy “gently used” home furnishings?It’s simple: Price and Quality!

Most items we purchase in life depreciate in value once we’ve used them. Just try and take that new car back to the dealer for a full refund! New furniture has a very high mark-up and depreciates immediately, once it has been purchased. When buying “gently used” home furnishings at Great Expectations, you can put the power of depreciation to work for you. We don’t accept any items worn, torn, dated or faded, clothing, appliances, fitness equipment, or “has beens”. At Great Expectations, we accept only attractive, clean and desirable furnishings for our customers. Best of all, if you can’t tell the difference from new… who will?

We do not pay our staff on commission. When you come in to our store, you will find helpful staff whose only interest is in helping you find what you are looking for.

From trendy contemporary to traditional elegance, we offer a wide variety of styles and designs conveniently displayed in our showroom, 5 days a week or shop by appointment. The consignment contracts are designed so there is a constant turnover of quality items to provide ever-changing inventory for our customers. A new shopping experience every time!

Thomasville, Ethan Allen, Drexel, Henredon and more. If it can be purchased, we may see it consigned in our showroom one day, and so can you!