Andy is seen on the Tantamount set when Tobias and Maeby visit the lot to help Tobias spread his name for the role of "Confidence Man 2". He is later approached by Tobias to read his resume. ("Switch Hitter")

It is revealed that Andy is a member of identical quintuplets that all have different personalities (a reference to Andy Richter's real life short-lived sitcom Quintuplets). The quintuplet are: Andy, Donnie, Chareth, Rocky and Emmett.

Michael asks Donnie to ask Andy to sing and dance at the Bluth family's "Save Our Bluths" fundraiser and vaguely threatens him. Andy shows up but instead claims to be Emmett (who never shows his face on TV). ("S.O.B.s")

Andy takes a brief leave from Conan O'Brien's show Conan to help Michael rush the movie about the Bluth family to production. When he couldn't make it to Conan on time, he has Rocky fill in for him. ("The B. Team") He is later trying to get into the Ealing Club, but Rocky pretended to be Andy earlier to enter the club on Andy's account. ("It Gets Better")

Andy Richter is an American actor, writer, comedian, and late night talk show announcer. He is best known for his role as the sidekick of Conan O'Brien on each of the host's programs: Late Night and The Tonight Show on NBC, and Conan on TBS. He is also known for his voice work in the Madagascar films and for starring in the sitcoms Quintuplets, Andy Richter Controls the Universe, and Andy Barker, P.I..