If this is your first visit, be sure to
check out the FAQ by clicking the
link above. You may have to register
before you can post: click the register link above to proceed. To start viewing messages,
select the forum that you want to visit from the selection below.

Re: Rebecca theories and ideas

Originally Posted by Blanka

Rebecca would be a good candidate to get it as she will obviously be at minimum a friend. Until we see a special skill or a reason to go out to sea for her dream it is a toss up. The more hillarious version, would be Luffy winning in the final round against Cavendish and to add insult to injury (not in Luffy's mind) give the DF to Cavendish for ruining his rep and forcing Canvendish to owe him. Kind of like Buggy.

well they say she has never lost a fight..... that is pretty impressive

Re: Rebecca theories and ideas

We have much too less information to start a discussion about if she will joining the crew or not...
Really...
If we start a Thread for every character right after the chapter he was introduced (and that were many lately) and start a discussion about if he/she will join the crew, this forum will collapse in nonsense and stupidity...
I dont even have an opinion about her yet. We just know nearly nothing.
We even know more about cavendish as we know about her, why not also making a thread about why Cavendish will join the crew? Sounds stupid? Yes just like this thread (for the time now).
Reopen a discussion after we saw a flashback with her, or much more about her personality, motivations and stuff.

That she wants to kill Dofla is no indicator for her joining the crew!

Re: Rebecca theories and ideas

Why do you insist on putting down our conversing on the subject? If you don't like it, don't write on it. Sure, Rebecca's mysterious but that's what's so interesting about her. We already know Cavendish's story so there's no reason to talk about that. Many assume that it's possible for her to join the Straw Hats for a number of reasons:

1) She seems like a powerful fighter, a criteria of the crew

2) She appears to have a troubled past, another criteria

3) She already appears to be on good terms with Luffy

4) Based on her desire to get Doflamingo, it seems that she'll be an asset in taking him down, and we know what usually happens when someone fights alongside the Straw Hats

If don't like this thread fine, but don't go saying things like we're being stupid for already discussing her.

Re: Rebecca theories and ideas

Almost everything this threads discussin material is about, is pure imagination. "She seems a strong fighter"
We know almost nothing about here, just here pure existence and that she wants to take down Dofla with the DF. That sure isnt enough to discuss about her joining SHC, i'm seious!

Originally Posted by EddyBob15

1) She seems like a powerful fighter, a criteria of the crew

Since when is it Criteria? *cough*Usopp*cough* Luffy even wanted a Zombie Horse and a Zombie Tree to join...

Originally Posted by EddyBob15

2) She appears to have a troubled past, another criteria

Who does not have a troubled past? Especially people coming from the Grand line.

Originally Posted by EddyBob15

3) She already appears to be on good terms with Luffy

Not really confirmed. Since Luffy is icognito and she just talked to him. Its not like "OH MY GOSH! That dude talked to Luffy, he is totally joining SHC!"

Originally Posted by EddyBob15

4) Based on her desire to get Doflamingo, it seems that she'll be an asset in taking him down, and we know what usually happens when someone fights alongside the Straw Hats

There are many, who fought alongside SHC also with a troubled Past and didnt join. Skypia Arc for example.
On the other point, Luffy didnt want someone to join the SHC just for helping taking down certain enemies.

Until now there were no _real_ indicators for her joining the SHC.
But if you want to go on with your wild imagination and think of all the bazillions of possibilities, then do so.
For the poor amount of information we have to really start discussing about her joining is in my opinion nonsense, because same could be said to hmm like 100 different characters which just appeared as well.

Who knows what the next chapters bring, but at this point of the time its just too early. She just appeared in 1 Chapter.
You might say that the way she was introduced was somewhat special, but that alone is not enough.
She needs more interaction with the SHC, but before that she definately needs more apperance.

Re: Rebecca theories and ideas

Though I want her to be the next SH, Oda has gotten good at making us think certain people would join the crew, but we gotta wait to see if Luffy drops that famous line: "I want you to join my crew." So far we have two people that didn't take the invitation. It would be nice to have another woman on the crew that could be a part of the monster trio. But it also has to even out with the number of people on BB's crew in the end. And BB has 10 so far. And only one of them is a female. So unless BB has gotten a bigger crew - which is possible since he is considered a Yonkou at this point.... we are still up in the air.

When you cross paths with a beast, are there any guarantees... that you won't be mauled by it