Should You Tell Your Probation Officer About a New Arrest?

Posted on Jan 19, 2012 10:14am PST

The considerations and thoughts listed below is what I often tell my clients
in response to the question, "Should You Tell Your Probation Officer
About a New Arrest?"

Many probation clients find themselves faced with a dilemma after they
have been arrested and have bonded out on new charges. They ask: should
I tell my probation officer in Georgia of the new charges (which could
result in an immediate probation violation arrest)?

Condition #1 of just about any criminal sentence in Georgia is "Do
not violate the laws of this or any other governmental unit." The
commission of a new offense while on probation would constitute a violation
of that condition. However, being
arrested for violating a law is not the same as having
committed a violation of the law, and being arrested for a new offense is notk in
and of itself, a probation violation; nonetheless, if a probationer is
arrested for a new offense and his or her probation officer (PO) learns
of it, a blazing red flag appears that the probationer may have violated
Condition #1. So, what to do about it?

Breaching Trust of Your Probation Officer

Most probation officers will want to develop a rapport with their probationers
and establish a level of trust that better serves both parties throughout
the monitoring process. If a probationer fails to disclose an arrest,
that failure may not only break a signed 'rules of understanding'
agreement that might have been originally signed with probation, but it
will also breach the trust of the probation officer. When that PO/probationer
trust is breached, the consequences can be serious: any sentencing or
resolution recommendation the PO may make as to the
probation violation will likely be much worse than if there had been full disclosure; if/when
the PO ultimately finds out about the arrest, there will definitely be
a warrant for the probationer's arrest; the PO may not speak favorably
to the prosecutor in the new case; getting the probationer on a revocation
court calendar gets delayed and, accordingly, the wait-time in jail could
increase, and the terms of future reporting are negatively affected and
any 'breaks' the PO may be willing to give are probably gone.

When a probationer has bonded on a new offense and then tells the probation
officer about the new charges, many times the probation officer will take
a 'wait and see' approach and, prior to seeking revocation, will
see what the disposition is of the new, "underlying" charges;
or, even if the PO does not take a 'wait and see' approach, the
PO may be willing to give a "walk-in" court hearing for the
probation revocation; this "walk-in" hearing would not require
that the probationer first turn himself in before he goes before the judge,
which is a really, really helpful perk for the probationer.

While it is true that a PO may still arrest a probationer on-the-spot if
a new arrest is reported, the consequences of not telling the PO of the
new arrest can be dire. Obviously, if the PO has no way of finding out
about the arrest, then the only way the PO learns of it is through an
admission of the probationer, and probationers sometimes choose to hide
the new development and hope to get away with it. Depending on how on-the-ball
or actively involved the PO is, this could, on occasion, be successful.

We Live in an Age of Technology

However, the technology that allows for immediate sharing of criminal records
information between government agencies has greatly improved over the
past few years, and most probation officers (especially those working
with the Georgia Department of Corrections, such as county felony probation
officers) will not have any difficulty in checking on a probationer's
current criminal status with GCIC (the central database where
criminal arrests and convictions are transmitted in Georgia). As such, a probationer crossing
his/her fingers and hoping the PO will not learn of the arrest is a significant
gamble, and the odds are
not in the probationer's favor.

Navigating through the thicket of probation concerns in the middle of worrying
about the consequences for the new arrest itself is very difficult. Dealing
with these issues without a
Lawrenceville criminal defense lawyer is like jumping out of a plane using a parachute with a poor safety record:
with so much at stake, it would seem like a good idea to invest in a good lawyer.

At
Fox Firm, P.C., providing a safety net and the security of a good lawyer is our pride
and specialty. Probation violation cases are no exception and Fox Firm,
P.C., located in Lawrenceville, Gwinnett County, Georgia, welcomes the
opportunity to represent probationers charged with probation violation
all around metro Atlanta.