Thursday, 23 May 2013

Broadsword book review: The Way of the Knife: The CIA, a Secret Army, and a War at the Ends of the Earth, by Mark Mazzetti

Title :
The Way of the Knife: The CIA, a
Secret Army, and a War at the Ends of the EarthAuthor : Mark Mazzetti

Publisher : The Penguin Press, New York,
2013-05-15

Page length : 381

Cost : USD 29.95 (Rs 1,662)

The Way of the Knife tells the riveting
tale of how America’s efforts in the War on Terror fundamentally transformed
the US national security establishment. The Central Intelligence Agency (CIA),
fearing retribution from US investigators for its growing reliance on torture, morphed
into a killing unit that launched Hellfire missiles from Predator drones at
terrorists sheltering in no-go areas. Meanwhile the Pentagon, a killing machine
that was starved for targets, increasingly focused on setting up its own intelligence
units that would locate Al Qaeda targets for Special Forces strikes.

It tells the story of how functional
boundaries between national security organisations got blurred as agencies like
the CIA and the Pentagon that were structured primarily to combat conventional
threats struggled to take on new enemies like Al Qaeda, the Iraqi resistance
and the Taliban.

And it tells --- like never before --- the inside
story of the Predator drone, which changed from an intelligence gathering to a
killing machine after an incident in 2000 when an early unarmed Predator
spotted who analysts agreed was bin Laden dismounting from a convoy at the Al
Qaeda training camp at Tarnak Farm near Kandahar. But it would take six hours
for a Tomahawk missile to be launched from an American submarine in the Arabian
Sea, and to travel to Tarnak --- by when Osama would be long gone. Clearly, the
Predator had to not just see but to kill as well. The first Predator-launched
Hellfire missile was tested successfully in Feb 2001 and the rest, as they say,
is history.

Mazzetti recounts in intricate details the
moral and ethical debates within the CIA as the Predator fleet effectively
provided the intelligence agency with its own air force. Controlled remotely through
satellite signals transmitted from US-based operations centres, the Predator
was a weapon of war that required nobody to go to war. Richard Clarke, the
Counterterrorism Coordinator for the president, argued in favour of the drone,
“(I)f the Predator gets shot down, the pilot goes home and f*#ks his wife. It’s
OK. There’s no POW issue here.”

The author, Mark Mazzetti, Pulitzer Prize
winning national security correspondent of The New York Times, has long enjoyed
deep access to the CIA and the Pentagon, which are the prime focus of this
book. While such linkages generate priceless inside information they can also
damage the objectivity that is central to a journalist’s or author’s worth. Mazzetti
has faced sharp criticism for unquestioningly accepting the word of his sources.
After the killing of Osama bin Laden, he indirectly justified the use of
torture by gullibly reporting the official line that Osama had been tracked
down thanks to information obtained through torture. Soon after that Mazzetti’s
colleague, the widely respected columnist Maureen Dowd, asked him to fact-check
a column that she was writing on the movie, Zero Dark Thirty. Mazzetti emailed Dowd’s
pre-publication draft to the CIA’s spokesperson, with the message, “see,
nothing to worry about,” and “this didn't come from me... and please delete
after you read.”

Nevertheless it is hard not to be impressed
by how Mazzetti weaves together a ringside view of multiple events into the
larger theme of this book: how organisations adapt during acute stress, making cynical
calculations, ethical compromises and functional adjustments to safeguard their
corporate interests. A discredited CIA, facing the blame for 9/11, launched a
detention-and-interrogation programme that violated every ethical canon except
those in its lawyers’ books. So much so that, in June 2003, CIA lawyers advised
the White House against issuing even a bland statement of support on a day that
the UN had set aside to support torture victims, knowing that the interrogation
methods it was using were widely considered torture. After a scathing internal
report on its interrogation methods in May 2004, CIA officers became convinced
that they would be called to account some day. That was when the CIA adopted
armed drones and targeted killings as its new direction. As Mazzetti writes,
“Killing by remote control was the antithesis of the dirty, intimate work of
interrogation.”

The Way of the Knife also offers an
exciting account of the secret war in the tribal areas of South and North
Waziristan, detailing the double and triple game that the Pakistan Army was
playing there. A web of American agents operating from bases guarded by the
Pakistan Army could see that their protectors were also their prison wardens.
Repeatedly striking peace deals with Waziri militants, the Tehrik-e-Taliban
Pakistan was dictating terms to the men in khaki, setting timings for their
convoys and other moves. A nice portrait is of the spider at the centre of the
web, ISI chief Lt Gen Ashfaq Pervez Kayani, a “rumpled and unpretentious (man)…
with sad, hollow eyes and stooped shoulders… (who) golfed obsessively and went
everywhere trailing a cloud of cigarette smoke.”

Written in the terse, readable prose of a
professional reporter who is trained not to waste a word, this book is a must for
serious students of international security and Pakistan in particular. The lack
of atmosphere and colour in the writing is compensated for by a wealth of
anecdotal detail. And given how carefully Mazzetti was servicing his contacts, most
those anecdotes would be correct.