Peyton Manning is without a doubt the smartest quarterback in the game.

Does that make him the best?

No!

His ability to read the defense, call audibles at the line is leaps and bounds above all other quarterbacks. His accuracy is unparalleled. He has a very quick release thus avoiding getting sacked. He reads through his progressions very well and finds the open receivers. He doesn't force the ball like some other quarterbacks .

He rarely gets sacked and rarely throws interceptions.

His mobility leaves a lot to be desired, but he stands confident in the pocket which is good enough. His leadership is unmatched and what this conversation comes down to is: you're down by six and need a touchdown to win it...who do you want marshaling your team down the field.

The answer to that is I would want Peyton manning above all other quarterbacks in history.

Because on any given Sunday you're either going to win or lose. I prefer to win though.