Nixon library offers candid new take

By Michael R. Blood
Associated Press

Published: Thursday, March 31 2011 10:00 p.m. MDT

Visitors Colleen Green, left, Darlene Sky, middle, and Maggie Zwart tour The Watergate Gallery, a new exhibit on the history of the Watergate scandal leading to the resignation of former President Richard Nixon, at the Richard Nixon Presidential Library in Yorba Linda, Calif., Thursday, March 31, 2011. (AP Photo/Damian Dovarganes) (Associated Press)

YORBA LINDA, Calif. — For years, Richard Nixon's presidential library was accused of committing another Watergate cover-up. But now, archivists say, the stonewalling is over.

The library opened an expanded new exhibit Thursday that scholars say provides a more balanced and accurate account of the scandal that brought down a president.

"The public deserves nonpartisan, objective presidential libraries," said library director Tim Naftali, who alluded to the original display as "inaccurate and whitewashed."

Among other things, the old exhibit portrayed Nixon's epic downfall as a "coup" by his enemies and suggested the press behaved unethically in pursuing him.

The $500,000 makeover was undertaken by the National Archives after it took control of the library in 2007 from the private organization of Nixon loyalists that had overseen the site since its opening in 1990.

The new display features sections called "Abuse of Power," "The Cover-Up" and "Dirty Tricks," complemented by taped interviews and text. In one interview, Nixon aide Alexander Haig, who died last year, says the president once asked him if he would be willing to burn White House tapes. "I said no," Haig recalls.

File - In this May 11, 2002 file photo, a visitor at a time-line narration of the Watergate developments leading to the resignation of former President Richard at The Nixon Library & Birthplace in Yorba Linda, Calif. On Thursday March 31, 2011, Richard Nixon Library archivists will present a retold and expanded version of the Watergate scandal at the library, a $500,000 makeover they say is faithful to fact, balanced and devoid of political judgment. (AP Photo / Damian Dovarganes, File) (Associated Press)

Some material has never before been shown publicly, and it includes interviews with such figures as Watergate burglar G. Gordon Liddy and Nixon aide Charles Colson, who went to prison for crimes that came to light as the scandal unfolded.

Among the changes: the old exhibit blamed a "mechanical malfunction" for the notorious 18 1/2minute gap on one White House tape, and added that Nixon enemies "wasted no time in finding sinister and devious motives" for the blank space. The new exhibit notes that audio experts identified five, and as many as nine, erasures on the tape.

The scandal began with a burglary at Democratic National Committee headquarters at the Watergate Hotel complex in Washington, and eventually exposed widespread wrongdoing in the Nixon White House, including abuse of government agencies for political purposes. Nixon announced his resignation on Aug. 8, 1974.

Dismantled several years ago, the library's original Watergate exhibit was the largest of any at the site at the time, consisting of documents, text and photographs along a long, darkened hallway. But academics ridiculed it.

Mary Fuhrman, with the League of Women Voters of North Orange County, listens to a presentation of "The Gap," the infamous 18 1/2-minute gap in a White House tape recording, as part of The Watergate Gallery exhibit on the history of the Watergate scandal leading to the resignation of former President Richard Nixon, at the Richard Nixon Presidential Library in Yorba Linda, Calif. Thursday, March 31, 2011. (AP Photo/Damian Dovarganes) (Associated Press)

When the site opened, Nixon biographer Stephen E. Ambrose said the commentary on one heavily edited Watergate tape "would almost convince a listener that Nixon never ordered a cover-up or a payment of hush money."

"The presentation makes the best possible case for Nixon, mainly in Nixon's own words, and is entirely self-serving," Ambrose wrote in a Los Angeles Times column.

One section of the old exhibit, titled "The drum beat swells," said: "Allegations took on the weight of fact in the minds of those who were determined to engineer a coup of their own." The section went on to say that Washington Post reporters Bob Woodward and Carl Bernstein, who played a major role in exposing the scandal, might have broken the law and violated ethics standards in their zeal to uncover wrongdoing.

Richard Nixon Presedential Library curator, Tim Naftali, presents a time-line narration of The Watergate Gallery, a new permanent exhibit on the history of the Watergate scandal, leading to the resignation of former President Richard Nixon, at the Richard Nixon Presidential Library and Museum in Yorba Linda, Calif. Thursday, March 31, 2011. (AP Photo/Damian Dovarganes) (Associated Press)

(Woodward and former Post executive editor Benjamin Bradlee are scheduled to make their first visit to the library in April for a conversation about Watergate. Bernstein visited in 2007.)

The private Richard Nixon Foundation, which used to run the site, has argued that the exhibit was "President Nixon's perspective" and that no one had found any factual errors in its text or exhibits.

The foundation, which now serves in an advisory role, filed extensive objections to the new exhibit with the National Archives last year, saying it lacked context to explain Nixon's decision-making.

In a statement Thursday, foundation Chairman Ronald H. Walker called the new exhibit "one interpretation of the events that led to President Nixon's resignation." He called Watergate "just one chapter in the enormously consequential life."

Nixon White House aide Bruce Herschensohn said Nixon's perspective should have remained, arguing that presidential libraries should be a shrine.

"I can only come to the conclusion it will probably be a hit piece," he said the night before the new display opened. "This is the Nixon library. This is his place. He's buried there ... and so is Mrs. Nixon."

An architectural model shows small red led lights revealing the locations of hidden microphones in furniture as part of the The White House taping system, showcased in the Watergate Gallery, a new exhibit on the history of the Watergate scandal, leading to the resignation of former President Richard at the Richard Nixon Presidential Library in Yorba Linda, Calif. Thursday, March 31, 2011. (AP Photo/Damian Dovarganes) (Associated Press)

At Bill Clinton's presidential library, which opened in Little Rock, Ark., in 2004, an alcove exhibit along a timeline of Clinton's career addresses his impeachment and acquittal over the Monica Lewinsky affair.

John Taylor, who worked for Nixon after he left the White House and helped design the original exhibit, said it was difficult for those who revere Nixon to deal with Watergate. He said the content in the new exhibit made him uncomfortable but with the passage of time, "you can hear the truth, you can accept the truth and you can learn from the truth."

"In the next 50 years America is going to answer the question, what is the sentence that goes with Mr. Nixon?" Taylor said. "Is it, he went to China, or that he quit? For that to be a fair dialogue, this day had to happen."