Ratings & Reviews

ahatfield's Review

amateurcook's Review

These were easy to make and tasted like Reese Peanut Butter Cups. Very rich and can only eat a few at a time but very hard to stop. Will make again. Would be fun to take to a gathering to share as a dessert.

erikisst's Review

Growing up in Ohio "buckeyes" were a staple just about everywhere. They served them everyday in our school cafeteria (which also ended up stuck on the ceiling on a regular basis). It brought back such good memories making (and eating) this treat. They didn't disappoint either. They were absolutely delish! I am so glad I made them. I can't make them again for a long time though because I ate just about the whole batch myself. I need a few weeks at the gym to work off 30 buckeyes...lol!!