Egypt: Into the Unknown

An Egyptian army soldier stands guard near debris from a Russian airliner which crashed at the Hassana area in Arish city, north Egypt (Mohamed Abd El Ghany/Reuters).

Share

Share

Tweet

Post

Email

The Egyptian state is weak. The country’s leaders are in a state of either panic or perpetual confusion. No one is in control. As in the darkest, most contested days of former President Mohammed Morsi’s tenure, Egypt’s failure once again seems plausible. Despite what supporters of President Abdel Fattah al-Sisi claim about webs of conspiracies hatched in Washington, Doha, Istanbul, Jerusalem, or wherever, Egyptians have no one to blame but themselves.

One need not have some special insight or training to understand that all has not been well in Egypt: The garish Sisi-mania of 2013, the Jacobin-like nationalist discourse, the scores upon scores who have been arrested, and the intimidation of the press. Against the backdrop of all this is the disturbing, craven, vehement insistence that all is well and that only a Muslim Brother—meaning a terrorist—would see things otherwise.

The last ten days have been particularly bad and especially revealing of Egypt’s pathologies. Two Saturdays ago, Metrojet flight 9268 disintegrated high above the Sinai Peninsula, killing all 224 souls aboard. In their insistence against mounting evidence that the plane was not blown out of the sky and thus security at the country’s airports failed to meet international standards, officials brought back memories of the mad scramble to deny the culpability of First Officer Gamil al-Batouty for intentionally flying EgyptAir flight 990 nose first into the Atlantic Ocean near Nantucket Island sixteen years to the day earlier. One can understand the Egyptian government’s panic after the Russian jet fell given the importance of Sharm el-Sheikh to what remains of the country’s tourism sector. Yet when confronted with American and British intelligence, had Sisi acknowledged the likelihood of terrorism and publicly vowed to improve security, he would have no doubt been showered with international assistance to help Egyptians in their increasingly nasty war with terrorists. Despite the ongoing threat of violence, tourism would likely have picked up again in due time with the confidence that, in time, Egypt, with the help of international partners, would establish proper procedures for baggage screening and ensure that ramp workers were above reproach. Instead, Egyptian officials maddeningly chose to dissemble, deflect, and blame others.

Things have been just as damning on the domestic front. On Wednesday,a judge extended the detention of a young woman named Esraa al-Taweel for forty-five days, who wept as she pleaded for the medical assistance she desperately needs that has seemingly been denied to her by the authorities. As Nervana Mahmoud explains, Taweel, a photojournalist, is on crutches after suffering a spinal injury when she was shot as security forces dispersed a protest in January 2014 and has already spent 155 days locked up pending the outcome of an investigation. Taweel is alleged to have used her Twitter account to call for violence against the police and is accused of belonging to an extremist group. There is no actual evidence of these charges, but even if there were, why deny her a visit with the doctors? It seems that the presiding judge, Counselor Moataz Khafagy, paid no attention to her request because he could, leaving the young woman trembling and in tears. There can be no justice without mercy. The fact that Taweel is likely innocent only adds to the cruelty visited upon her.

Then, on Sunday, Military Intelligence detained, interrogated, and charged one of Egypt’s most well-known journalists and human rights activist, Hossam Bahgat, with publishing material harmful to the armed forces. On the same day, Salah Diab, the founder of the newspaper Al-Masry al-Youm, was also arrested over an alleged shady real estate deal. Bahgat has received the most attention because of his track record of extraordinary and meticulous work exposing the misdeeds of Hosni Mubarak, the Supreme Council of the Armed Forces, Mohammed Morsi, and Abdel Fattah al-Sisi. I once told Max Fisher of Vox that Bahgat and Amr Hamzawy, who recently left the country fearing arrest, were the only two liberals remaining in Egypt. I was exaggerating for effect, but they were the most effective and, for now, at least both have been silenced. For what reason? One is tempted to say no reason, but both men are dangerous to the regime in an important, though nonobvious way. Neither Bahgat nor Hamzawy command legions of followers, but through their work they have highlighted the gap between what Sisi and his media machine tell Egyptians about their lives and how people actually experience it. That difference is important because it is available to political entrepreneurs to advance an appealing alternative to Sisi’s vision—such that it is. That’s why the soft-spoken, bookish Hossam Bahgat is a threat. The simple fact is that he would not be if Egypt’s leaders were confident that their people were buying what they were selling.

Sisi has failed spectacularly when it comes to learning the lessons of the Mubarak era. The new Egypt, with its over-reliance on violence, coercion, and lies, looks strikingly similar to the old one—the difference being that the deposed president seemed far more adept than the incumbent. The unfortunate result is an Egypt that combines the worst of all possible worlds: A flailing, groping, vainglorious effort to establish legitimacy and political control that does precisely the opposite. There is no precedent for this particular set of circumstances in Egyptian history, no familiar pattern that might help observers make sense of what is happening and what might come next. Whatever it is, it seems it will be self-destructive.

The West cannot afford for Egypt to be converted into another failed state such as Libya and Yemen have become. To allow for this potential scenario to transpire would definitely upset the peace accord with Israel; it would make the Sinai peninsula even more dangerous; and it could open space for ISIS and Al Qaeda to operate from thus creating a more volatile Middle East than what it is currently now experiencing. It is imperative for the remaining months of the Obama administration as well as for the EU to focus their attention on Egypt. For better or worse the West must maintain the Egyptian Armed Forces unscathed; to permit a dismantling such as it happened when the overthrow of the Shah of Iran would be catastrophic. Unquestionably President Abdel Fattah al-Sisi by his litany of political errors is creating his own demise (most surely by his peers within the Armed Forces if the latter see a rise in popular unrest amid the Egyptian street) but will his replacement fare any better? It is apparent that the promise of a democratic Arab Spring is turning into the winter of discontent in the land of the Pharaohs and in the rest of the region.

Posted by Sherifa El Tabei KhairatNovember 11, 2015 at 2:05 am

I have two reservations on the above:
1. “Webs of conspiracies hatched in Washignton, Doha,Istanbul,Tel Aviv not Jerusalem by the way!Tel Aviv is atill Capital right?) Are not claims,myths or allegations. The net is filled with Western (not Sisi supporters based articles) to the sudden creation of ISIS by USA and its allies. The support of the Moslem Britherhood terrorist group is not a secret. A member of the Senate did question Obama about the millions received by the MB. Amy answer?
2. Most of you on blogs analyse and write without the slightest notion of the Egyptian people,their culture or mentality. You base all your inpessions on your own mentality,reactions and habits. You address the West with your thoughts not ours!
So keep on..spread the poison Mr. Cook. But should you visit Egypt soon ,you may contact me and others to clarify to you What is Egypt all about and why 90% of its people support their president El Sisi!

Posted by Maissa HamzaNovember 11, 2015 at 3:23 am

Unfortunately this is a very negative description of Egypt status now, the majority of Egyptians are happy including me of President El Sissi achievements. we feel secure walking in the streets and in our home. Egypt now is having international relations with most important countries in the world, the economic situation is difficult, the debt is great, this is true, but eventually if we are left alone without outside negative interference I am optimistic we will survive and Egypt will regain a good position internally and externally. Tahya Masr.

Posted by AdamNovember 12, 2015 at 3:56 am

Much that is written in this piece may be true, and yet might lead to a different conclusion. The arab authoritarian police-state has shown itself to be the most stable form of government in the region since WWII. The demise of so many of these regimes since 2011 has unleashed all hell in the Middle East. Perhaps that is the lesson Sisi has learnt. And perhaps the conclusion that he has drawn is that a return to the old order is the least risky choice.

Posted by IsmaielNovember 12, 2015 at 10:39 pm

“There is no precedent for this particular set of circumstances in Egyptian history, ”
Oh yes there is Nasser the only difference is in nasser’s era there was no internet for the news or the people to be heard but it was the same exact stupidity , failures and defeat. The problem is this time the enemy is real and it’s in charge . But I hope one day the Egyptian people will realize they don’t need a Ruler or A leader but they need a democratically elected Administration . And until they know the difference between regime and administration Egypt is going nowhere

Post a Comment

CFR seeks to foster civil and informed discussion of foreign policy issues. Opinions expressed on CFR blogs are solely those of the author or commenter, not of CFR, which takes no institutional positions. All comments must abide by CFR's guidelines and will be moderated prior to posting.

New Independent Task Force Reports

India now matters to U.S. interests in virtually every dimension. This Independent Task Force report assesses the current situation in India and the U.S.-India relationship, and suggests a new model for partnership with a rising India.

Rates of heart disease, cancer, diabetes, and other noncommunicable diseases (NCDs) in low- and middle-income countries are increasing faster than in wealthier countries. The report outlines a plan for collective action on this growing epidemic.

The authors argue that the United States has responded inadequately to the rise of Chinese power and recommend placing less strategic emphasis on the goal of integrating China into the international system and more on balancing China's rise.

Campbell evaluates the implications of the Boko Haram insurgency and recommends that the United States support Nigerian efforts to address the drivers of Boko Haram, such as poverty and corruption, and to foster stronger ties with Nigerian civil society.