It feels like they restricted themselves to one player per team and felt compelled to include a player from each of the top 6. They made an exception and included 2 Newcastle players. As the only defender on the list it would imply Moore is the best defender in the Championship and I'm not really convinced. He's good and we look a shambles defensively with him out of the side but I wouldn't put him in a top 10.

As mentioned if I had to pick any player it would be McCleary, perhaps Swift would have been a contender if injury hadn't ruined his form and momentum.

Don't think these lists are particularly thought out to be honest. Just something some journo on a site which is 99% focussed on the prem put together in a lunch hour. Think the editor is a Huddersfield fan and they tend to get a bit of a presence because of that, but most other clubs ignored totally

That much is McClear. Would you rate him amongst the top 10 players in the league?

I wouldn't say I'm overly qualified to judge as I rarely watch Championship games other than our own, but yeah I probably would have McClreary in the top 10. He'd get into all Championship sides I'd imagine perhaps with the exception of Newcastle.