Rookie maximums for at-bats (130), games pitched (30) or innings (50) in the major leagues"

If the 2 leaders are within 5% of each other, or the leader has less than 35% there will be a run-off between the top 2. If a run-off results in a tie the tiebreaker will be vote total in the previous poll, we will continue to "go back" in the polls until there is a clear leader.*Rosario ineligible*Dom ineligible

P.S. don't stress too much if you feel player X deserves to be on this list vs. player Y. It's extremely unlikely someone not yet nominated would be win any given poll. Nominate those you see fit.** Executive decision, pulled the plug early on #7. By having the polls begin in the morning it allows for a more lively discussion. Lindsay was running away with the vote. Same with #10. Poll #11 will only have 9 options, I accidently had Kay listed a second time (copy and paste, sue me lol)

I don't know much about McGeorge, so I could be wrong, but there's like 6 or 7 guys some not nominated yet, who I have a grade above him.

I will say this, reading up on some lists, Metro was right and I was wrong on Crismatt. There's some praise written about him here and there. Amazin Avenue ranked him #14 overall and MetsMinors said he had the best changeup in the metsminors.net and MMO (articles may be identical, I haven't looked closely).

Ok I think the fact Becerra is potentially not a top 40 prospect in the weak farm system of the Mets is a lil naive.

Yes he had a down year... Yes he was dropped off the 40 man and cleared waivers...

But he obviously has some intangible tools to be a highly rated prospect at the start of last season...

Guy had a down year... but it could of been a injury...He was recovering from an injury during the previous season...

2 down years. Not one. .734 OPS in 2016 with 1 home run over 65 games, followed that up with a repeat of the level .667 OPS 4 homers... 132 k's over 469 ab's... and a late season move to 1b. This isn't a guy who put up big numbers, bad year and everyone is jumping ship.

His OPS the last 3 seasons... .765, .734, .667. In that time he's hit a whopping 14 homers over 311 games (roughly 2 MLB seasons) while striking out 280 times (roughly 140 per season). He's a CO and has thickened up over the years to the point he has very little speed (yes he stole 16 bases). His career OPS in the minors is .724

Ok I think the fact Becerra is potentially not a top 40 prospect in the weak farm system of the Mets is a lil naive.

Yes he had a down year... Yes he was dropped off the 40 man and cleared waivers...

But he obviously has some intangible tools to be a highly rated prospect at the start of last season...

Guy had a down year... but it could of been a injury...He was recovering from an injury during the previous season...

2 down years. Not one. .734 OPS in 2016 with 1 home run over 65 games, followed that up with a repeat of the level .667 OPS 4 homers... 132 k's over 469 ab's... and a late season move to 1b. This isn't a guy who put up big numbers, bad year and everyone is jumping ship.

His OPS the last 3 seasons... .765, .734, .667. In that time he's hit a whopping 14 homers over 311 games (roughly 2 MLB seasons) while striking out 280 times (roughly 140 per season). He's a CO and has thickened up over the years to the point he has very little speed (yes he stole 16 bases). His career OPS in the minors is .724

Yes Yes... but he was injured in 2016 too...Anyway, I just can’t justify not selecting a guy who even with limited opportunity could turn it around with solid AA/AAA production vs choosing others on this list who have at best limited MLB prospects.

Ok I think the fact Becerra is potentially not a top 40 prospect in the weak farm system of the Mets is a lil naive.

Yes he had a down year... Yes he was dropped off the 40 man and cleared waivers...

But he obviously has some intangible tools to be a highly rated prospect at the start of last season...

Guy had a down year... but it could of been a injury...He was recovering from an injury during the previous season...

Urena was a former Top 10 prospect in the system as well, is coming off a solid season, and wasn't a Top 30 prospect this season. Sometimes guys don't pan out, and once it's clear that they're not going to pan out, there's no point in pretending otherwise.

Beccera was considered "toolsy" at one point, but what tools does he have at this point? The power potential scouts originally thought he had basically doesn't exist. He's strictly a corner OF. What's interesting about that profile?

You could make an argument that his profile isn't too different from Kaz's or Brodey's at this point but I have more confidence in Kaz's hit tool and eye and Kaz has better speed and is more likely to be able to play CF in a pinch.

And McGeorge has gotten great reviews on his slider. He's probably not anything more than a middle reliever but he's on a similar track to Sewald. Definitely a better prospect than Beccera at this point.

And McGeorge has gotten great reviews on his slider. He's probably not anything more than a middle reliever but he's on a similar track to Sewald. Definitely a better prospect than Beccera at this point.

I think if McGeorge had recently been aquired from another system in a trade, he might have ranked ahead of Nogosek or Rhame. There's just not much reason to report on these guys unless they are traded.

Who is online

You cannot post new topics in this forumYou cannot reply to topics in this forumYou cannot edit your posts in this forumYou cannot delete your posts in this forumYou cannot post attachments in this forum