Retired Michigan State Police Officer, Matt Whitman, tells his story of how his life was miraculously saved by a nurse and why hospitals need a monitoring technological safety net to not rely upon miraculous interventions.

Former State Trooper Matt Whitman – “to all hospitals that care about their patients’ safety and welfare — Electronically monitor ALL your patients, not just the ones at high risk.”

Amanda Abbiehl and I share a similar story. Both of us were on patient-controlled analgesia (PCA) pumps to manage our pain.

However, the difference is that, by the grace of God, an observant nurse who just happened to walk by my room when I stopped breathing, called a “Code Blue”, and that ultimately saved my life. I would have been just another statistic if it wasn’t for that nurse. Unfortunately, Amanda was not so lucky.

What are the odds of a nurse putting her head into a patient’s room just as that patient is experiencing respiratory depression? Slim.

What are the odds of that same nurse putting her head into the patient’s room after she had just checked on him 15 minutes before? Almost none. Yet, that is what happened to me and I ask why.

My story begins in 1990, when I was a state trooper. My squad car was struck by a car driven by a drunk driver. Although the accident left me close to being a quadriplegic, I went through 6 months of physical rehabilitation and returned to work.

Although my doctors told me that I would always have trouble with my neck, I was able to function at my job despite the pain. I was even named a district Trooper of the Year in 2001 and prior to that in 1994 received a statewide traffic safety award for arresting the most drunken drivers per capita.

But, despite being recognized again in 2003, as Trooper of the Year for in Bridgman, MI, my neck injury increasingly gave me problems.

In December 2002, the neurologist who read my MRI told me that I shouldn’t be a trooper anymore. He said, if I get hit again, I’d be a quadriplegic.

In January of 2003, I met with Indianapolis neurosurgeon Dr. Henry Feuer, who was (and I believe still is) a consultant for the Indianapolis 500 and the National Football League.

Dr. Feuer told me that my condition had worsened and that my neck looked like that of a retired football player with arthritis, bone spurs and spinal fluid unable to circulate effectively. Dr. Feuer gave me two pieces of bad news. The first was that I needed surgery. The second confirmed that I couldn’t be a state trooper any more.

So, I underwent neck surgery that year at Methodist Hospital in Indianapolis. Because of the pain that I was in, I was on a morphine pump after my surgery.

The night after my surgery, a nurse had just checked on me and then continued to check on other patients on the very large hospital floor.

Another patient she was caring for needed something. Although it was on her cart, she decided to go to the supply room and restock her cart. Fortunately for me, her path to the supply room led her passed my room.

So, even though she had just checked on me 15 minutes earlier, she just so happened to be passing my room when she noticed I was not breathing and called a “Code Blue”. She would tell me later while she was crying that she did not know what made her walk past my room. While she continued to sob she told me that she had never seen anyone live after they had coded.

I remember feeling warm, calm and in a better place. There was a point where I had to decide if I wanted to fight back and live or stay dead and remain in that warm pleasant place. I chose to fight and recall being jolted back, I remember doctors over me, bright lights, and someone holding my hand. Miraculously, I survived. The doctors told me that 96% of Code Blue patients die; only 4% live. I remember later on that morning that I was somewhat of a spectacle for the student nurses. They would come into my room and stare at me to see the patient who had cheated death.

I had been without oxygen for 6 minutes. At seven minutes, I was told, I would have been brain dead, if not dead permanently. I died at 4:11am, and for many years after I would wake at 4:11 in the morning remembering what happened to me.

I was never electronically monitored. There was nothing that would have indicated to a nurse that I was about to experience respiratory depression and almost die. I was 39 years old and in terrific health. I was not a high risk patient.

Why?

Had my PCA pump been integrated with a capnography like the one just recently discussed at the Notre Dame class, the pump would have shut off and alerted my nurse that I was not breathing.

Instead, I am alive today because my nurse, who had just checked on me 15 minutes earlier, just happened to be passing by my room when she didn’t have to.

I say to Brian and Cindy Abbiehl – My deepest condolences. Know that your daughter died peacefully. Know that that she was not in any pain or under any stress.

I say to all hospitals that care about their patients’ safety and welfare — Electronically monitor ALL your patients, not just the ones at high risk. A human life is too valuable for you not to. All hospitals need a technological safety net for their patients. All nurses and caregivers need that safety net too.

When I read this, I had to grab my chest. I can’t believe out of all the research and stories I’ve read, I’ve actually found one almost identical to mine. Unfortunately my father was part of the 96% that didn’t live. One would thing with all the technical equipment this shouldn’t happen. However if you have a staff that don’t follow proper protocol, all the equipment in the world won’t mean a hill a beans! Matt Whitman, it’s a shocking relief to know I’m not alone in this when it comes to the serious and forgotten issue of proper monitoring. I really appreciate the seven minute point you brought out. My father went UN-monitored and it makes me wonder just how long he went without oxygen to sustain those type injuries. I was the one who found him UN-responsive. He suffered brain damage, paralysis, coma, and sadly death after seven days on life support. A multiple code took place and no knew he had coded, too. Mr. Whitman I would like to email my full story to you. It will floor you. Thank you for sharing your story. Thank goodness for the nurse who believed in constant VISUAL monitoring. Someone needs to raise awareness to the highest level and I hope to be the one…

Notice to Email Subscribers

PPAHS has changed web service providers. As a result you may not receive email notifications, particularly if you received them on the old web platform.

Please subscribe to PPAHS by entering your email address in the field in the footer below.

Thanks,
The PPAHS Team

PPAHS Ground Rules

Comments and articles are welcome to be submitted, so long as such submissions:
(a) Discuss patient safety.
(b) Do not mention or endorse a company or its products.
(c) Do not discuss political issues or legislation.
(d) Is in keeping with previous posts on PPAHS.

PPAHS reserves the right to decline comments and articles submitted that, in its opinion, are not in accordance with the above principles.

The opinions expressed in each article in this blog are solely those of the article’s author and of any health experts quoted therein.

About Us

Physician-Patient Alliance for Health & Safety is a national advocacy force for addressing patient health and safety priorities that are shared by patients, physicians, regulators and industry. By doing so, we seek to ensure that the best medications, medical invention and technology can improve care and reduce cost. PPAHS works to advance patient health and safety by developing and highlighting best practices and recommendations through better use and application of clinical practices and experiences, information technologies and checklists, and healthcare information. As a voice in support of ideas and innovation that can improve care, we encourage a health ecosystem culture of patient safety.