Wednesday, May 8, 2013

GE13 ‘partially free but not fair’, say think tanks

GE13 ‘partially free but not fair’, say think tanks

UPDATED
@ 12:30:57 PM 08-05-2013

By Zurairi ARMay 08, 2013

Malaysian Insider

People wait to cast their vote during the general election on Sunday. — file picPUTRAJAYA,
May 8 — Non-Barisan Nasional (BN) parties played on a very uneven field
for Election 2013, said think tanks Institute for Democracy and
Economic Affairs (IDEAS) and the Centre for Public Policy Studies (CPPS)
today.

The uneven playing field was caused by issues such as a media with a
heavy bias towards BN, the use of government facilities during
campaigning and doubts over the Election Commission’s (EC) impartiality —
all of which are seen to have benefited BN in the polls.

“Although the official campaign period and electoral processes may
have proceeded smoothly and without major issues, wider issues that are
not within the EC’s purview have built up over the last few years,” said
the think-tanks’ joint report ‘Was GE13 Free and Fair?’ today.

“These issues conspired against non-BN parties, therefore creating a
very uneven field. Due to these reasons, we conclude that GE13 was only
partially free and not fair.”
While presenting their report here today, both think tanks agreed to
recognise the result of the polls, saying the EC ran the polls according
to the proper procedures and by the book.

“To me, I think the result is credible the way it is now because we followed the process; it is simply just not a fair election.
“It is the best result we can get, bearing in mind the challenges
that we’re facing,” said Wan Saiful Wan Jan, the chief executive officer
of IDEAS.
IDEAS and CPPS were partly-funded by the EC as observers, and the
team sent 311 short-term observers to 99 out of 165 parliamentary
constituencies in peninsula Malaysia. The report, however, encompasses
the whole electoral process across Malaysia.

During their observation, they have found out that the integrity of
the electoral roll was questionable, the Registrar of Societies (RoS)
was not free from partisan interference, and funding of political
parties was not transparent.

The team also discovered that despite the sizeable participation of
ethnic minorities in the polls, manipulation of racial issues was
widespread, including the increase of racial rhetoric that sometimes
bordered on the incitement of racial hatred.

The biggest issue concerning the team was the unequal delineation of
constituencies, which they feel should be fixed as soon as possible now
that the polls are over.

In the report, several recommendations have been made towards the EC,
including making its members explicitly accountable to a permanent and
bipartisan special parliamentary committee. Its members should also be
recruited from experts of the field, instead of being seconded from the
civil service

To improve the electoral roll, the team suggested that the EC
co-operate with more specialist groups who have undertaken in-depth
studies about the roll.

The report by IDEAS and CPPS will be available on both organisations’ websites starting today.
In Sunday’s elections, BN won 133 out of 222 federal seats, short of a two-thirds majority and worse than in the previous polls.

It also lost the popular votes to Pakatan Rakyat (PR) parties, and
was bested on the popularity front for the first time since 1969, when
it had contested as the Alliance Party.