I'd like to once again invite anyone who is hungry for thorough and honest feedback to post their comic. If you post your comic, I will read as much of it as I practically can and then give you as meaty a review as I deem appropriate.

What you should know about me: I've only been here for 4 months, and I am in no way a professional or commercially successful artist. I have a hard time engaging with anime/slice of life/school drama/quirky comedy. This doesn't mean I won't read yours, it just means I do not have as refined a palate for those niches. I have no intention of passing judgement on any comic. This is not me writing reviews for consumers. I am only here to say what I think is working and what is not working in your comic. I have no intention of subscribing to any comic I do not genuinely love.

You are welcome to review my comic (and I am as hungry as anyone for feedback), but THERE IS NO OBLIGATION TO DO SO. Giving reviews is time consuming, I definitely understand.

I'm new to the webcomic scene (a few months). That said, I have seen an astonishingly vast number of people, across all webcomic forums, ask for meaningful critiques and receive few or no responses. The ratio of requests to answers is heartbreaking. Even here, which seems one of the more active forums, the Review category is comparatively tiny compared to its counterparts. Lots of people are asking, and comparatively few are answering.
Anyway, the point is that I want to try and answer the cal…

I'd like to once again invite anyone who is hungry for thorough and honest feedback to post their comic. If you post your comic, I will read as much of it as I practically can and then give you as meaty a review as I deem appropriate.
What you should know about me: I've only been here for 3-4 months, and I am in no way a professional or successful artist. I have a hard time engaging with anime/slice of life/school drama/quirky comedy. This doesn't mean I won't read yours, it just means I do n…

TL;DRPost your comic, get a meaty, VERY honest, but NEVER mean-spirited review. I am here only to encourage.When you post your comic, give me:--1-3 sentence premise (Whether this is a pitch or a conceptualization, it makes no difference--or does it?)--Genre and >>>TONE<<<--Your inspirations and/or source material--Summary of your intentions and expectations. What are you trying to do with this comic? What is your target AUDIENCE? How would you rank yourself among other comics you see?

I will take between 12-15 total entries this week.

I hope I can be of some service you guys. God knows I've gotten game changing advice.

Thank you so much for this opportunity! I don't know if you can formulate a review from the little content I've put out but here it is;

Premise: Main protag's kingdom surrenders in a war that has lasted 7 years, he escapes imprisonment with the help of his best friend and try to find a new place to call home.Genre & Tone: Fantasy/Adventure with a 'heart-warming' tone.Inspiration: I'm trying to go for a similar feel to 'Boku No Hero Academia' My intentions:I'm trying to make a loveable and long-running series with a somewhat nostalgic feeling to it, I'm also trying to use the comic as a way to improve my art. I want to make realistic characters and dialogue but I don't know if it's working.Audience: I'm going for a mainly teenage audience demographic. tapas.io

~UPDATES EVERY MONDAY~
In this world, there are four classes of magic; movement, protection, light, & telum. Due to the existence of magic, technology isn’t as advanced, which means kingdoms and war. The two strongest being Korium & Apex. Seven...

Premise: The adventures of an alcoholic vampire, a straight laced math teacher and a Twilight fangirlGenre: Sort of slice of life drama with a lighter, comedic tone, mixed with darker moments.Inspirations: Lupin iii, Dark Shadows, Patrik the VampireIntentions: Trying to get fans of classic vampires, or maybe just the people tired of stuff like Twilight. I'm trying to do something new with vampires, but also have it feel very classic. Hugh is a person and not just a vampire with the typical vampire problems. He has human issues and his life as a human will be just as important to the story as his vampire life.

Note: I don't have much comic yet, but I hope you can take a look anyways. I have extra pages I didn't post that I'll pm to you

I only have a few episodes on this comic but might as well get an early opinion. Pls and ty

Premise: A dying knight accepts a deal with a she-devil, proceeds to hunt down a demigod. Genre: Dark fantasy, action, maaaybe horror/thriller later down the line, with some dry humour to break it up.Inspirations: Castlevania, Jojo's Bizarre Adventure, Devilman, BerserkMy Intentions: Working on something with a more serious art style and testing out vertical scroll panels w/ action scenes. Target audience would probably be young adults.

A dying knight is offered a contract by a passing she-devil in exchange for his soul and voice. Revived with a fraction of the devil’s power, ‘Red’ begins down a bloody path of vengeance against the deity who destroyed everything he once knew—...

Here is mine. By all means, let me know how to improve. For the record, I already know about the background problem. I address it later in book 2 in case 3.

It is an adaptation of the famous tale, but with several twists both comical and fantastical.

The genre falls under fantasy with a mix of comedy and mystery.

My intentions is to entertain the reader as well as leave them with the deep meaningful messages that our old "Jekyll and Hyde" concept is wrong. We are not black and white. We are all gray and complex.

In this more comical and lighthearted take on Robert Louis Stevenson's classic story, in attempt to better himself through science, the brilliant, kind yet meek Dr. Henry Jekyll drinks his hyde formula, but the results are not what he expected. He...

Premise: Mihai has always been intimidating and socially awkward preferring to stay within his social circle that includes his grandmother, two friends and his beloved cat Muffins…Well, that how it used to be until he started university and a new neighbour moves in with his friend and she turns out to be almost the exact opposite of him.Genre and Tone: Drama/Romance - It's a slow paced romance that deals more with friendship and different social problems, contains mental health issues (like anxiety and depression) which aren't obvious from the start but the story builds up to them more and more.Inspirations: Fruits Basket, A silent voice (I don't think my comic is too similar to them, the inspiration is mostly for the character writing)Intentions: I honestly just want to tell the story of my characters that I really enjoy drawing and writing for and create something that I hope people enjoy and relate to.Audience: Probably young adults, although I think the audience that my comic has right now are people who identify with the main characters either in terms of social awkwardness or the metal health issues in the comic

My comic is pretty long and it was started in mid 2015 so the art style improved a lot since then, I'm not sure how much you'll read so for art critique do you check the latest episodes?tapas.io

Ever since he was young Mihai had always been intimidating and socially awkward making others avoid him. He grew up preferring to stay within his social circle that include his grandmother, two friends and his beloved cat Muffins.... Well, that how...

Even though it's just a one-shot that is halfway through, I think it'd be fun to see your thoughts on Alpha Alapca so far. (Maybe if you do another, I could submit it for a re-review when I finish the one-shot?)

Premise: By day, Al Pacasso is a mild-mannered alpaca who seems like an unassuming average joe. He likes to spend time with his girlfriend, intrepid reporter Alice Pacino, he works at a museum, and he likes to eat waffles. But when trouble strikes, Al flies into action as the Amazingly Awesome Atomic Alien Alpaca Avenger from the Planet Argon, The Alpha Alpaca! One day, a mysterious rash of tornadoes blows into town, threatening the lives of everyone, but especially the farms! Can Alpha figure out just who or what's behind these terrible twisters and put a stop to them? Or will he be reduced to just dust in the wind?

Genre and Tone: A fun, campy, somewhat genuine, somewhat tongue-in-sheek, throwback to old corny silver age superhero comics with some light elements of shonen battle manga.

Inspiration: Mostly just old comics like Superman (especially the one shot Stan Lee did in 2001), Super-Goof, and a little bit of Dragon Ball. (At least in terms of the character's backstory and abilities.)

Intentions: Mostly as just a fun one-shot to help change my pace between projects and practice more dynamic art and traditional sequential storytelling. Also, if I have the time or skill to do so, maybe might revive it as a continuous series or as a graphic novel.

Audience: Again, mostly just anyone who wants to enjoy a campy superhero adventure.

Can't wait to hear your thoughts on it! (Even if it is incomplete at the moment.)

Faster than a bolt of lightning! Stronger than a driving storm! Mightier than a roaring hurricane! Windier than a howling tornado! Able to leap tall mountains in a single bound!
It's a bird! it's a plane! it's a flying wool sweater! IT'S THE ALPHA...

Thank you so much for offering this kind of review and assistance to us creators Because I've been working on it for so long and consistently with no time to go back, I miss things that could be done better or improved on.

Premise: Young woman goes on a journey with a group who's fate is oddly intertwined together to discover the truth behind her powers and why the dragon Altyn Tagh wants them back.

Genre and Tone: Fantasy rom/com. Hopefully relatable relationships even though it's set in a fantasy world.

Inspiration: Long running manga, such as Sailor Moon, Cardcaptor Sakura, and light novels like Slayers have always inspired me. Plus stories with dragons that actually focus on dragons.

My Intentions: to share a long running, entertaining story that has been bouncing around inside my head and on paper for years. I hope that it encourages other people to be brave and share their stories, too, just like my friend encouraged me to share mine.

Audience: Well, I was initially just doing it for myself, but I think anyone that enjoys long-form stories might be interested in reading it.

The great dragon, Altyn Tagh, seeks to regain all the powers he once held so that he can once more spread terror and fear across the world. There's just three things he didn't count on to get in his way; a small cat, an idiot of a pond monster and a...

I've just barely started, so I've only got 6 pages, and that includes the cover. But this is my first comic, and I was wanting to see what was working and what wasn't. Thank you so much for doing this sort of thing!

Premise: Tom Handsen is the least noticed in his family, and outside of it. Having no friends, his father, who is the star of a major football team in their city, wants to have a manly son - but Tom is not that. Wanting to impress his father, he comes up with stunts that always go wrong. One day, when one of his stunts goes wrong, he befriends a slug, who he actually believes will be his key to making his father proud.

Tom Handsen has always been looking to impress, especially his father - a major football star for the Super Mollusks. A slug named Shelldon being the only friend he can make after a stunt gone awry, Tom discovers that his newfound pal may be the key...

premise: proud and energetic outcast girl plays the "loving" girlfriend for a scientist who just want's to be left alone. The reason: His rich mum stoped funding him because she was feed up with his lazy ass.

Genre: Romance(very slow)/Adventure with soem slice of life stuff (I'm very unsure if this fitts ) Tone: Even thought there are some dark parts, especially on the ending, it's never going to be too much as I'm intending it to be something fun to read. Still there are some action and fightscenes and I highly focus on character growth.

inspirations: I once was listening to a very EPIC Gloryhammer song, and started to fantecise about a world, that later became the world, my characters life in. I don't really had much inspiration from other stuff. But the backgrounds and buildings are hightly inspired by reallife places, like the medival buildings and stuff. The characters then just kinda happened.

The comic itself was just meant for improving my art. But I got so much into it, I wasn't able to stop.

I never really planed for an audience, as I expected low numbers to begin with. I basicly do this comic for me, and for everyone who enjoys this kind of stuff.

I started off with a 2 of 10 and improved since then. I think with the following pages, that aren't uploaded jet, I might be at 6 or maaaybe 7 (but I'm pretty hyped at the moment, so my selfreflection might be a bit blurry xD )

And here is the link to my comic. It starts with chapter 4 though, because I have over 100 pages and the old ones aren't that nice to look at ^^' But if you want and have too much time, feel free to review the other ones aswell, just be warned xDtapas.io

The people in the city of Ark are put into three categories Greats, Fates, and Outcasts.
Follow Dark Fire, Hana and others as they stumble onto the truths of their home Dark World.
Updates: Active. Once a week on Sundays.
Reads Left to...

Premise: After knowing that the house he brought was built on a graveyard, A teacher put up his house as student homestay. So, this is the comic of the lives of the students and the teacher and how their secrets revealed.

Paranoid after knowing the scary fact of the big and cheap house he just bought, Rul put his house up for student homestay for a nearby boarding school. He intends very much to keep the scary fact a secret from the students living in his house. But,...

--1-3 sentence premise A goddess is bent on taking justice into her own hand,however when her act of justice against heaven went too far she is faced with the consequences of her actions.--Genre and >>>TONE<<<Dark Fantasy/Supernatural/Romance--Your inspirations and/or source materialThe show supernatural XD--Summary of your intentions and expectationI would probably like to know which character is interesting so far,is the motivation clear do i still need to work on establishing the world of the plot.I feel that there is still something i need to work on,are the characters worth liking.-AudienceOlder Teens/Young Adult.P.S Hopefully by the time you get to this i have an entire chapter out,qwq .tapas.io

"Merlin's my father.And they murdered him.I was too young to do anything about it."
Driven by a desire for justice,Sophie goes on a mission to find the rumored "Heaven's enemy".Her discoveries led her to an abandoned chapel,one that Tiandi is...

Premise: The Action Fruit Society is about four mutated fruits who have a knack for wanting to take action, trained by their banana master as they seek to protect New York City from the likes of their toughest foes including: Destructo, Renegade Peach, and Man-Snake. (This is where the mainstream continuity of Amazement Comics resides)

The action fruit society centers around the surreal adventures of four mutated fruit ninjas; Apple, Pear, Pineapple, and Orange as they protect New York from the likes of Dirf and his gang to Destructo, under the guidance of Master Banana.

The Action Fruit Society season 2 introduces new characters including Renegade Peach, Katherine Sanders, The Amazon Intelligence Organization, and The Mighty Allegiance incorporated. The action fruits will also see the return of Destructo as he...

Alternatively, if that doesn't appeal to you, you might like this series which is mostly a collection of comic series that are not part of the mainstream continuity

This is a collection of shorts that is not in canon to the mainstream continuity. It will involve all characters existing in the Amazement Universe in bizarre adventures including many references to TV shows, movies, video games, and of course, other...

Premise: L, an awkward chef, and R, a bubbly artist, are both experiencing mostly the pros and cons of everyday living in the Philippines, as well as dealing with family, career and their relationship.

Genre and Tone: Slice of Life/Heartwarming/Romcom, but the tone is hopeful.

Inspirations: It started with reading Super Mario romance fanfictions... But mostly inspiration comes from my everyday life experiences.

Intentions: Wanting to share my characters' story that I've been writing since 2013, as well as spread awareness of certain happenings in our country for those who do not understand or are curious about it.