Top 10 Best Dog Shock Collar Reviews

1. PetSafe Yard & Park Rechargeable Dog Training Collar:

If you find hard to change some of the behaviors of your chubby dog, you must buy this collar. It is one of the favorite training devices to train your canine companion without using any leash. It helps in hindering your dog from pulling, digging, barking and other such irritating activities. Also, it seems amazing in teaching the commands like come, sit, stay, etc.

To change your dog’s behavior, all you have to do is push a button on the handheld remote, and this waterproof, durable, adjustable, 28 inch collar. This collar works with 8 levels of adjustable static stimulation and tone. Both the remote and collar are rechargeable. That means you need not buy extra batteries. With this training device, your dog can easily differentiate between undesirable and desirable behavior depending on the tone.

This collar is best for dogs that weigh 8 pounds or up. The best part is that it works efficiently from up to 400 yards away. You can use the same remote to train up to three dogs at the same time by adding extra collars.

2. SportDOG Brand Field Trainer SD-425

If your dog loves sports, then you must check out for this collar. Designed especially for vigorous and stubborn dogs, the SportDOG Brand FieldTrainer SD-425S is the right choice if you want to take your dog out for hunting or field work.

It can be extended to 3 dogs provided you additional SDR-AF Add-a-Dog collars. Its range is up to 500 yards and is the optimal choice for dogs of 8 pounds of larger.It works with 7 levels of low/medium stimulation along with vibration mode and tone.There is no external antenna on the collar. Also, both the remote and receiver are waterproof and submersible to 25 feet.

It comes with 2-year warranty and is estimated to work amazingly great for 40-80 hours in one time recharge. It is basically recommended to keep your dog under control when out in the field.

3. Educator E-Collar Dog Trainer

An Educator training collar is one of the most reliable and advanced dog training collars found throughout the world. It uses the lowest levels of ‘blunt’ stimulus to control the behavior of your dog and provide you a peace of mind. This feature is not available in other regular shock collars.

This remote controlled collar is made especially for smaller hands or to be used in the case where alertness is required. It is designed with highest quality standards to perform perfectly even in most extreme environmental dog training conditions. This waterproof and rechargeable collar works with “Lock and Set” technology. It includes a dual battery charger (120V/22V) that lasts for longer with a 2-hour full charge.

It provides a very ordinary stimulation without the head jerking motion. If you love your dog from the corner of your heart and does not want to heart your beloved in any situation, order this collar now!

5. Dogtra IQ Plus Remote Trainer

This IQ Yard Training Collar from Dogtra’s is as small as 10 pounds but still it is the most powerful electronic training collar for dogs.

This is world’s finest e-collar and can function appropriately in a range of 400 yards. Both the transmitter and receiver are rechargeable. In fact, a battery can perform accurately for a longer time after a 2-hour full charge. As it is waterproof, you can train your pet even in the rain. Just like Dogtra Field Star Remote Collar, it also works with three types of stimulation- Nick, constant and non-stimulating vibration mode.

With 100 precise stimulation levels, you can adjust the training and intensity for your individual dog’s needs. Easy to use, and comfortable. It does not have any external antenna.

It is suitable for a dog as small as that of 10 pounds in weight. Again, it has a blue LCD screen to display Stimulation levels.It is available in colorful two-tone casing design and the case is antimicrobial. The receiver comes with a magnetic on/off switch.

6. SportDOG Brand SD-350 YardTrainer

Simple yet versatile, the SportDog YardTrainer 350 offer the ease of primary training system as well as the strength of an advanced sporting dog trainer. Able to operate smoothly with up to 300 yards, this collar is suitable for giving you the confidence to train your fluffy friend even from a distance.

The transmitter enables instant correction level adjustments with eight levels of both continuous and momentary static stimulation. It also allows continuous communication.

Being completely waterproof, it is fit for all- weather. The transmitter and collar receiver works with the exclusive SportDog DryTek technology.

The batteries are convenient and can last up to 40hrs between charges. The best thing is that a low battery indicator is there on the collar. Thus, you can determine when your collar is charged and when not. This avoids the situation of taking your dog outside with a dead e-collar or transmitter.

7. Pet Resolve Dog Training Collar with Remote

Do you have more than two dogs? Pet Resolve Dog Training Collar helps in training up to 3 dogs with a range of acceptable behaviors. This Dog Training Collar with Remote has a super long 1200 meter range for comfortable outdoor training in the widest areas. It is the perfect alternative to the GPS dog training collar. It gives variable shock levels with up to 10 levels of continuous or single shocks to train up to 3 dogs at once.

It provides safe, efficient training, allowing you to teach your dog a range of commands and orders. It has a water resistant construction which means it won’t harm the collar or the dog if they go swimming. It has the rechargeable Li-ion battery for long lasting training without having the trouble of changing the batteries constantly.

10. Petsafe Stay and Play Fence Receiver Collar

It is a small, light, comfortable, and ergonomically designed collar especially made for your best buddy who is 5 pounds and up.

It fits the neck sizes from 6 to 28 inches.

It can get recharge in 2-3 hours, and an LED light indicates when recharge is needed. The rechargeable batteries are built-in and non-replaceable.

The Pass-through receiver allows you to use any non-metallic, 3/4-inch-wide collar strap for your dog.

It has five adjustable levels of static correction for the safety of your dog. The Tone-only mode alerts your dog with a beep.

They are the waterproof collars that are submersible up to 5 feet. It is compatible with PetSafe Wireless Pet Containment System (PIF-300 system, IF-100 transmitter) and Stay+Play Wireless Fence (PIF00-12917).

You can add an endless number of pets with additional wireless receiver collars.

Dog Shock Collar – Top 5 Reasons to Use

A lot of controversy upon the subject. It’s not my purpose to enter in lengthy and usually pointless discussion. I assume that you have a healthy dog 6+ months of age and the dog is active and you really care about its health, education and socialization with other animals and people. If you don’t live alone in an island and you love your hairy friend, read further.

1. Save the Life and Health of You and Your Dog!

Yes, i am talking about life and death situations here and that is why i recommend using dog shock collars. Avoid disasters like car, bike, traffic accidents which can lead to death and injuries to both parties. I can write a book here, just imagine what could happen if you lose control of your pet.

Teach faster and easier the dog. Spend less time trying to avoid problems and instead use it to enjoy life and give more love to your dog and the people around you.

5. Be Really More Human to The Dog and Yourself

Lets face the truth. At least 99% of the dog owners on one occasion or another, have shouted like crazy, kicked or beaten their dog. Even if they love him a lot. And i am not talking about a gentle slap here! Be sincere and improve your life together! People like talking about humanity and behave in the totally opposite manner sometimes. While the dog perceives raising voice and aggressive behaviour like something personal and suffers as it is a pack animal and a friend, short electric impulse means nothing personal to him other than “I must stop what i am doing”. Yes, it is that simple.

What Else A Dog Shock Collar Can Do

Apart from correcting the dog via high voltage pulse many remote collars also implement one or more of the following functions: emit ultrasound,various sounds and beeps, vibration, night safety light. This functions can be used as a separate call or whatever command. Many find their dog reacts only to vibration, so they not use the shock function at all. However Please Note: Vibration or sound command if issued like a warning and then issued shock command is believed by many people, including myself as a mistake. In a future post this would be investigated more profoundly.

Dog Shock Collars Buyers Guide

There are many liabilities associated with dog ownership and providing them adequate and efficient training is right at the top of the list. Training the dog makes it easier for the owner to handle its unwanted behavior.

Shock collars are not designed as a punishment, but more as a training instrument that help in controlling their harmful or unsafe behavior.

The theory behind this shock collar is that when your dog shows unwanted behavior, an uncomfortable shock will be given to it until they no longer require such a reminder.

The shock delivered by an approved shock collar is safe, so with these collars your dog’s certain behaviors will be discouraged, but it won’t do any physical harm to your dog.

With most shock collars, there are various levels of enforcement so you can set the level to admonish the unwanted behavior accordingly.

Many shock collars produce a beep or a vibration as warning before giving a severe shock to your dog. These shock collars also allow you to give a verbal command “No!” or “Down!” with the vibration or warning beep to further interrupt the unwanted behavior.

Need help to decide on dog shock collar purchase? Learning to ask yourself the right questions will help you more than listening to others opinions!

Read further below.

1. Dog shock collars & Dog Breeds

Dog breeds are obviously different so electric dog collars differ from one another . Will speak about dog and collar sizes later, what is discussed here is how a typical dog behavior can influence the choice of dog shock training collar.

The dog shock collars are in fact 2 main types:

– for dogs with normal sensitivity
– for dogs with lower sensitivity

Learn to filter the information about the dog shock collars! Separate the personal opinion from the facts!

How? Analyze like this:

– What info will give you a person who tries to sell you a training dog collar? From them you will hear what you want to hear. Most of them do not believe firmly or have a stable opinion on what they sell, they will twist like snakes to find your weak point and offer you what you will like, not what you need.

– What people say in forums or over the internet? Most of them don’t have the slightest idea or usually have experience first hand from only one product. Not to speak about the crappy webs with stolen content or written by asian “article writers”.

– Will you fall into the trap of the false humanity talk? is it more human to have a dead friend from a car crash, cause he did not listen to you when you called him?

So be smart and understand: There are no bad dogs, difficult to handle dogs, aggressive dogs, lazy dogs, whatever…etc.

There are dog owners who treat the dog in different ways and the dog behavior is influenced by the breed, owner and living conditions, in that order and equal by importance.

Hence you control 2 of 3 in total, so more than 60% of dog behavior is dependent on your actions.

And that is not interesting right now, the real interest is to understand the previous when buying a dog shock collar, so our only concern should be:

Has my dog low, normal or high physical sensibility? Nothing more, nothing less! That is exactly what you need to know making the choice!

With the psychical sensibility you will deal later, when choosing the way to start and train him with the dog shock collar.

Below on the buying guide there will be a clear hint against each dog shock collar about this.

2. Range of the dog shock collar

The usual ones from exact distance point of view, self explaining:
1. up to 100m or yard
2. up to 300m
3. up to 500m
4. up to 800m
5.up to 1000m
6.up to 1500m
7.up to 2km

For better understanding they should be grouped like this:

1.Short range : up to 100 to 300m
2.Medium range: up to 500 to 800m
3.Long and extra long range:up to 1 to 2+ km

How not to fall in the trap of : “up to x00 meters”:

Very simple. “Up to” means at plain place without any obstacles like trees, hills, bushes, houses, buildings, etc.Rule of a thumb choosing remote dog trainers: “up to x00 meters” / 3= real range in mountain, forest, town, etc.Rule of a thumb on cheap Chinese knock-offs “up to x00 meters” / 3= real range / if it works at all/Note: Not all knock offs are bad, one of the main purpose of this page is to review them and find the good ones in the pile of totally unuseful dog training collars. Cheap is the word.

3. Types of batteries that dog shock collars run on

Straight to the point. Two types of electric dog collars:

1. using one time disposable batteries
2. using rechargeable batteries

Nothing wrong to go for a cheaper collar with disposable battery, however must make shure that these little batteries are available locally and they doesn’t cost a fortune.

Below rechargeable batteries ordered by the less desired first to most desirable last, hence from heaviest , slowest to recharge, least holding charge, lowest life time :

Note on Li-ion and Li-po batteries. They must have IC / integral circuit/ integrated in each battery otherwise they can burst some day on your dog’s neck/ yes i read this happened/ or can explode while charging. Take a screwdriver and check if yours say :”IC protected” , if not check the number and buy some new ones from eBay or amazon or your trusted seller.

No joke!

4. Water resistance of dog shock collars

“Waterproof” is not the same as “Water resistant” Dog shock collar!

“Water Resistant” usually is used by sellers to trick you and most cases refers to “Rain Resistant”

“Waterproof” mostly means – can be submersed a bit. But NOT always. Don’t get caught by marketing tricks!Apart from the misuse of such statements there has to state somewhere IP Code / Ingress Protection Rating/. This is the real thing!

Like IP67 or IP68 , that’s what is needed if the dog will swim with the collar.

The info below is for the more technical,so don’t bother if not interested, what you can do is simply make sure yourself that it can be submerged, reading carefully in the description or asking the seller. Any way, in the recommended categories of collars to buy, below in other post , there will be note about this, so there is no real need to worry and waste time.

Note that many times sellers refer to “water-resistant” or “waterproof” and they mean the receiver, not the transmitter, so this has to be checked also as mostly they don’t have the same protection.

The first number means protection level of the case against particles:

The second number means protection against water:
1. Falling drops/2.Dripping water, tilted up to 15°/3. Spray at any angle up to 60°/ 4.Splashing water/5.Projected water / 6.Powerfull jet/7.Immersion up to 1 m/8.Immersion beyond 1m

Some additional letters can mean:

H: High voltage device

W: Weather conditions

5. Size and weight of the remote dog shock collar receiver

Common sense is all needed. Dogs can carry a lot of weight without bothering them. Simply is not a good idea to buy a collar meant for small dogs and try to fit it on a large one, and vice versa.

6. Dog Shock Collar Transmitter size and weight

The smaller the antenna and transmitter, the more expensive. However the ones with the long-range that are cheaper have detachable antenna, so that will not be a big problem if they can do the job.

7. Functionality and Ease of Use

Should be considered what is needed now and what features can become handy in the future. Mostly has to be taken in account if it can control more than one receivers and up to how many. Most of the dog shock collars can control 2, 3, 6 or more dogs at once. Just adding extra receivers.

Ease of use is connected with the quantity of functions. The choice has to be balanced. Most people prefer the exact functions they need with simple operation. After all it can be quite challenging to browse complicated menus in the dark to find a simple function even if it has LCD display. Personal choice there, people usually stick with no more than 5 buttons, often without LCD is preferred.

However before making the right choice the following should be absolutely clear to avoid unsuspected future frustration:

1. How the transmitter pairs to the receiver and how long it takes, should this be repeated every time battery is changed or down on charge, etc.2.Does the receiver ”sleep” by going on standby and how long it takes to waken the receiver?3. Does the receiver show by light or via the LCD on the transmitter its state and battery?4. Is there step by step user manual?

8. Reliability of dog shock collars

How buttons react, does it have a dial, pistol grip, belt clip and so on. Most importantly:

Can a button stick? Does it have protection against malfunction?

Can a button accidentally be pushed while in the pocket?

9. Buying a secondhand used dog shock collar

Not recommended. Every year there are so many changes, new better batteries, smaller dog shock collars, more functions, some previous manufacturing mistakes are fixed and so on.

For saving usually a couple of $ it may result in a waste of money or even more expensive at the end when batteries are changed, etc.

If this is the way to go: only good brand ones, no Chinese and from reliable sellers. Ebay is a good place to look.

10. Prices of Dog Shock Collars

These are generally the price ranges:

1. Up to 100$ – Cheap
2. 100- 200$ – Normal use
3. 200-400$ – Professional use
4. More than 400$- Extreme use and functionality

Anybody can decide for himself about what he needs and how much he can afford. At the next post there will be information about the real deals in every price range and what we try to find is : Could there be Pro and Normal dog shock collars at under the 100$ tag. Also will be first hand reviews, video and pictures, so stay in touch!

Types of Dog Shock Collars

There are various types of shock collars available in the market, and dog owners can choose the collars suiting their training needs. But the three main shock collars are:

Dog Containment Systems

Containment systems, also known as underground or invisible fences, work by keeping the dog within a defined section of the yard.

They require expert installation, in which an electric wire is hidden along a selected boundary of outdoor space.

The underground wire is linked up with the collar that dog wears while going outside.

When the dog surrounds the border of the electric fence, it gets a warning noise, and if it continues in the wrong direction, a shock is produced via the collar.

There are many modifications to this system. Some collars require owners to control it manually and increase the shock value if the dog consistently crosses the boundaries while others adjust the shock level automatically depending on the dog’s behavior.

The overall intention is to keep the dog safe, and these types of collars have proved to be very efficient in doing so.

Owners who cannot prevent their dog from barking regularly can think of buying a barking collar.

As the name suggests, these collars have one primary function.

They produce an electric shock or vibration through the collar whenever the dog barks loudly.

Most of these collars have flexible settings in which the owner can determine the volume that is acceptable for the dog to handle.

These collars have proved themselves to be very effective in attaining their objective, as the dogs make the connection immediately and respond accordingly.

Obedience Collars

Also known as e-collars or remote shock collars, these devices work with a handheld remote.

The remote allows the owner to pass the shock with the push of a button whenever the dog misbehaves.

The remote control has many intensity levels that the owner can match up with the hardships of the dog’s aggression.

Obedience collars are very useful if used properly.

How Do Shock Collars Work?

From a psychological prospect, the idea is exceptionally simple. Pets have such behavior that force you to give substantial punishment to them. Here “punishment” refers to the intended effect, which is the removal of undesired behavior. A perfect example of substantial punishment is when a child offends and a parent yells at him.

Notwithstanding the fact that the Father of Operant Conditioning himself, B.F. Skinner, maintained that reinforcement was more productive than punishment in modifying dog’s behavior.

Shock collars apply a slight electric trauma to the dog’s neckline through two round plates that touch the skin. The owner can set both the sharpness and endurance of the stimulus.

Some models frequently allow more severe injuries each time they’re initiated. A shock collar invented to prevent a dog from continuous barking gives the mild discomfort to the dog rather than the intense pain. The shock caused by an acclaimed shock collar is 100 % secure. It is surely sufficient to get your dog’s consciousness and discourage its certain unwanted behaviors, and it won’t do any constant physical abuse to anyone.

Placing the Shock Collar Properly

If the collar is too big or placed wrongly, the prongs that deliver the shock will make alternate contact, or no contact at all and this alternate contact can be dangerous, because the shock becomes irregular. Due to these irregular shocks, the dog may have a hard time making an association with the prongs.

The manuals that come along with the shock collars have various directions for the owners. Different dogs adapt shock collars in their own ways. There are various positions in which the shock collars can be placed:

Front or side?

Some hunting dogs have loose skin that collects and folds under the chin. As a result, these prongs do not make good contact.

The collar shifts to the side and hence make poor contact.

Sometimes the dog head shake seems to remove a collar’s position and always winds up on the side of the neck.

So, the suitable position for the prongs is on the side of the neck.

You can either put them on the right side or left side depending on your dog’s comfort.

You can also consider a shuffle in the position of the prongs as it gives rest to the dog preventing pressure sores.

Up High Or Down Low?

Dog’s neck somewhat appears like a cone.

The diameter is widest near the shoulders and smallest near the skull.

Prefer putting collar high on the neck, near the skull because if the collar is placed lower, the main issue is that the collar move towards the skull and become too loose to make contact.

And if you put the collar high close to the skull, gravity will automatically pull it slightly down and keep it in place on the dog’s neck.

How Tight?

If you put the collar on the dog too loose, you will get no response.

It takes some patience to get a good tightness.

Don’t mark the “right” hole until you have worked on the comfort of your dog.

Keep in mind that you should be able to get a finger or two under the collar, but not much more.

If it is new to the dog, you can have it loose as there is nothing wrong with it.

The best way to proceed is, start loose and get tighter with the time.

Pros of Shock Collars for Dogs

Fast results: Sometimes it only take a few shocks to correct the unwanted behavior in the dog and after that, the vibration or beep for the warning is enough. Shock collars are also very effective in keeping the dog in your area, which will help keep them safe while giving them the required freedom. Of course, more stubborn dogs may take longer to train.

Adjustable intensity: Most modern shock collars give the owners the right to adjust the warning beep or vibration mode, and these adjustable settings ensure the level of shock which has to be given to the dogs.

Owner Availability not required: Shock collars, when used to control unwanted behavior work even when you’re away from home or inside the house. But of course, we don’t recommend leaving your dog unattended outside for extended period, with or without a shock collar.

Affordability: A shock collar is a more affordable alternative to a professional dog trainer or a fence. Shock collars range from $30 to about $250, depending on the features such as shock levels, remote control, adjustable warning, the range of usage and the number of collars included. You can select the collar depending on your requirements and the budget.

Cons of Shock Collars for Dogs

The fear: Fear in dogs can be very dangerous, and you never want to train your dog with fear. With these shock collars, some dogs may learn to fear objects, people, or situations they associate with the collar.

Over-correction: When a shock is given to your dog and you are not there to control or administrate, the automatic shock collars may unintentionally confuse your dog and can keep shocking them unnecessarily.

No positive reward: Shock collars don’t reinforce good behavior with a positive reward such as your affection, verbal approval or a tasty treat on their own. So while a shock collar may effectively prevent negative behaviors, but it doesn’t reward positive behavior. But your dog needs to be pampered for its positive behavior with a reward of affection, playtime or a small treat.

Survey of Various Dog Owners Using Shock Collars

92.8% of owners reported improvements in their dog’s behavior when they use these shock collars. All the owners were highly satisfied with the results. This suggest that the use of shock collars is effective if they are used properly. It helps in making them obedient.

Conclusion

While opinions may differ from person to person, you need to must be clear about your requirements and if you have decided that a shock collar is the right training device for your dog, use it effectively and it will stand up to your expectations without providing any harm to your dog.