There's something to be said about keeping a little bit of mystery in a relationship. Sure, you don't want him hiding important stuff (like say, he's a werewolf), but you also don't need to know every single detail of his every day. Make him feel like you trust him and maybe he'll realize he doesn't have anything to prove to you.

Watch Autumn Reeser (The OC) and Eddie Kaye Thomas (American Pie) navigate a problem that's really something to howl about. Tune-in to the premiere of the New ABC Family Original Movie, Nature of the Beast, Sunday, Oct. 21 at 8/7c, only on ABC Family.