You should already be CTC capped as Prot in current gear, the lack of master (Except on the head and chest, which are the best of their slot yet) here is good, just as low Def rating on T10 was good. Because you don't want it anymore.

---------- Post added 2011-11-27 at 11:02 PM ----------

Originally Posted by Hextor

3 Ret items with haste, I am disappointed.

Seeing as crit and haste are almost interchangeable on most good sims, why would crit have been any better?

Actually, mastery isn't going to be that bad in 4.3. Due to the holy radiance giving mastery on heals crit falls behind on mastery. I believe in the holy paladin BiS list only 4-5 items are going to be reforged. We get it pretty good this patch no doubt.

Ehh? Last time I checked def was the best avoidance rating you could get no matter how much avoidance you had.

No, when Defense stat was still in game, going any higher than crit cap on Bosses, and forsaking Stam/Other Avoidance Stats was a Avoidance loss, as pure avoidance beat out the minor avoidance Def gave.

Troll? Mastery is what Rets want. It's ridiculously superior to any other secondary stat after hit/exp cap.

He said crit/haste, not mastery.

But take a good look at that hit and expertise on prot gloves + shoulders. Why increase tank threat to 500% and then keep threat stats to tanking items. If there would have been off-pieces, then I'd understand but since we are forced to use the set (afaik) I sadly don't see the logic in this. They made hit obsolete and expertise less valuable, but still put them on tanking items. I thought that since this was the last tier, the itemization would be awesome (like previous expansions) but I might have gotten my hopes a little too high for that...

Not enough mastery on protection & retribution.
Too much mastery on Holy.
Too much haste on retri, not enough on holy.

Would it be SO HARD to make the best tier set in the expansion be usable? Just look at the protection shoulders, they have PARRY and EXPERTISE. Who uses that, really?

nothing wrong with parry. also, 2/5 of the holy pieces are haste, 2 are mastery, 1 is crit. still usable. for ret, 3/5 of the pieces have mastery. still plenty of mastery. and for the tanking set well.. 2/5 are mastery, 1 is dodge/parry, and then the other 2 are hit/expertise with an avoidance stat. it's honestly not terrible, it could be far worse