All the Perl that's Practical to Extract and Report

Navigation

The Fine Print: The following comments are owned by whoever posted them. We are not responsible for them in any way.
Without JavaScript enabled, you might want to
use the classic discussion system instead. If you login, you can remember this preference.

Actually I was just pondering that the other day. Electoral systems are a complicated
topic, but I basically think that, at least for single-member districts (i.e., positions
where you only get to elect one person), plurality is not good enough. If nothing
else, it does a poor job at manufacturing consensus, because you end up with everyone
having to put up with a minority's choices -- the fact it was the largest minority's
choice is not much of a consolation. So I think that if, in an election, there is

But without mandatory participation in the electoral
process, it's very difficult to obtain
a true majority, as the basis for such a determination
much be a percentage of possible votes, vice those
that participate. US elections are notorious for
"number of people eligible to vote" > "number of people registered to vote"
> "number of people who vote". You could lump these
into a "they vote to not vote", but that's not the same as
"none of the above", and more or less validates plurality
as an electi

One of the issues with our (U.S.) current voting system is that it's binary -- your vote counts just as much whether you think a candidate is the lesser of two evils or if you'd follow her into battle against Megatron. This is great for mindless robots who vote with the party, but stinks for everyone else, particularly since parties are much less powerful (and meaningful) than they once were.

There are lots of academics talking about this issue. IMO one of the more implementable (and non-radical) proposals

What would happen if the cumulative voting proposal also allowed "none of the above"?

We had a mayoral election here last November, with seven candidates ranging from Mr. Cannot Be Trusted with a Stapler to Ms. Literary Deconstructionism Ate My Brain. Unfortunately, of the two serious candidates, the incumbent had a questionable run-in with the police as well as the odd timing of pushing a foggily explained tax increase referendum a mere week before everyone discovered their property tax for the year had