Nectar vs Casper: A Complete Comparison Guide To The Best Mattress

This in-depth, unbiased guide is a Sleeping Ninjas showdown between Nectar vs Casper to help you select the best mattress. Disclosure: Sleeping Ninjas has an affiliate relationship with some companies where we get a small percentage of sales if you click over from our site.

Let’s dive right into a complete comparison review of two popular mattresses, Casper vs Nectar, to determine which mattress will best fit your individual needs.

Construction: What’s Each Mattress Made Of?

Mattresses are constructed from so many different materials these days. And, while no one material is necessarily better than the other, they do offer different qualities and properties. You’ll want to make sure that you know what your mattress is constructed of, so you’ll be familiar with the benefits you should expect from it.

In this category, we’ll be comparing the overall construction of Nectar vs Casper to see which one offers the high-quality and best amenities.

Nectar Construction

The Nectar mattress is marketed as a hybrid memory foam option, featuring 3 different types of memory foam set above a firm, breathable base layer. Nectar has set out to provide their consumers with the very best qualities that memory foam has to offer, such as joint cradling and pressure point relief, while doing away with the drawbacks of conventional memory foam, such as the sinking sensation and heat retention.

Tencel Cooling Cover

The entirety of the Nectar mattress features a breathable, custom-milled Tencel cover. Their cover is specifically designed to be healthy and cost-effective, as it’s naturally resistant to bed-bugs, which can be harmful and expensive to get rid of.

Their Tencel cover is also designed with cooling properties in mind. It quickly wicks sweat and heat away from the body and is made to be highly breathable, allowing for fresh air to circulate through the cover upon movement, guaranteeing that you stay fresh, dry, and cool.

Quilted Gel Memory Foam

The top layer of the actual mattress is constructed with a layer of quilted gel memory foam. The official Nectar website notes that the quilting of the memory foam is an expensive and tedious process. However, the makers of the Nectar mattress feel that the additional work is well worth it for the extra level of plushness and comfort. Thanks to this quilting process, this layer provides consumers with loftiness, exceptional comfort, and an added layer of breathability.

Gel Memory Foam

The second layer, beneath the quilted memory foam, is a layer of gel memory foam. Nectar’s foam currently holds five different patents featuring a unique, semi-open formula. This particular kind of memory foam is most often used in a medical environment, as it’s known for its cooling properties, soft, plush comfort, and quick recovery time. Nectar’s gel memory foam is considered one of the most premium gel memory foams on the market.

Adaptive Hi-Core Memory Foam

The next layer, serving as the core of the Nectar mattress, is a layer of Nectar’s adaptive Hi-Core memory foam. This special version of memory foam is exclusive to Nectar and cannot be found in any other direct-to-consumer mattress. The adaptive Hi-Core foam is extremely heavy, making it expensive to ship.

But, Nectar insists on its use anyway as they feel that its benefits and amenities make the extra shipping hassle worth it. The makers of the Nectar mattress feel that this special material is crucial in providing their customers with the best joint cradling and contouring pressure relief available on the market as well as avoiding that dreadful sinking feeling that can sometimes be common in memory foam.

Breathable Base Layer

Nectar takes a lot of pride in the construction of their proprietary base layer, which is why they hold the title of the densest yet the most breathable base layer of any mattress available on the market today. Like almost all mattress base layers, this layer is designed to reinforce the overall performance of the above layers as well as provide added durability and stability.

But, unlike many other options, the Nectar’s base layer is designed with specially molded channels which allow for fresh air to be drawn in and dispersed through the mattress.

According to the official Nectar website, all of the materials and foams used in the Nectar mattress are Certi-PUR US Certified against harmful emissions and guaranteeing high indoor air quality.

Casper Construction

The Casper is a hybrid mattress option as well. They utilize the very best qualities of 3 individual layers of memory foam and a base layer of latex to provide their users with a comfortable mattress that doesn’t skimp on support.

Breathable Memory Foam

The very top of the Casper mattress is equipped with a layer of super breathable memory foam. Casper’s memory foam features an open-cell formula which allows this layer to provide all the comfort and cradling properties of conventional memory foam while still remaining cool and breathable against the body.

Pressure-Relieving Memory Foam

The second layer of the Casper mattress is designed to provide consumers with all of the great benefits you’ve come to expect from memory foam. This layer is equipped with memory foam specifically designed for optimal pressure relief. It cradles the joints and relieves pressure from problem areas such as the hips and shoulders, reducing pain and stiffness and allowing Casper users to wake refreshed, rejuvenated, and pain and stiffness free.

Zoned Support Memory Foam

Casper is certainly concerned about comfort, but that doesn’t mean they skimp on the support aspect. To guarantee that you’re getting the crucial support you need in all the right places, the Casper mattresses 3rd layer is constructed with zoned support memory foam.

Different areas of the mattress are equipped with differing levels of firmness to guarantee that you’re getting the proper support and comfort in the proper places. The area under the shoulders is designed to be softer to avoid numbness or stiffness, while the areas under places such as the lower back are designed to be firmer to ensure proper support and alignment.

Supportive Latex Foam

The very last layer of the Casper mattress features a thick, supportive base layer of latex foam. This layer guarantees that you’re getting the best overall support as possible. It also reinforces and enhances the performance of the above layers.

Who Wins?

When comparing the overall construction of Casper vs Nectar, we give Nectar the win in this category. The Nectar mattress features more layers and the materials used seem to be of higher quality with several patents and even medical-grade memory foam.

Temperature Control

We all know that a too-hot mattress is a miserable experience. It leaves you tossing and turning through a restless night and you often stuck waking up sweaty and groggy. To avoid this issue, you want to guarantee that the mattresses you’re considering will offer adequate temperature regulation.

Here, we’ll take a look at the temperature control properties featured in Casper vs Nectar to determine which mattress will provide you with the coolest sleep.

Nectar Temperature Control

The only layer of the Nectar mattress that was not specifically noted to have cooling properties was the adaptive Hi-Core layer. Otherwise, every last inch of the Nectar mattress, from the Tencel cover to the breathable base layer, seems to be equipped with some sort of temperature control construction.

The very first line of defense against heat retention is featured in the Tencel cover, directly against the skin. Their cover is designed to keep you cool in two different ways; the material is specifically designed to wick away sweat and body heat quickly while also drawing in fresh air and releasing it against the skin upon motion, making sure that every movement you make releases a “breath” of fresh air against your body.

The quilted memory foam layer of the Nectar mattress is designed with top-notch breathability and airflow to ensure that the mattress will never trap and hold heat. The premium gel memory foam under the quilted layer is specifically designed to absorb body heat and distribute it evenly through the mattress, away from the body. This also ensures that no body heat is trapped within the mattress and guarantees that you won’t experience any hot spots.

Unlike many other competitors, even the very bottom layer of the Nectar mattress is designed with temperature regulation in mind. Their dense base layer is specifically constructed to remain breathable, featuring molded channels within the material that draws in fresh, cool air while absorbing and dispersing any body heat drawn down from the above layers.

Casper Temperature Control

When they designed the Casper mattress, they ensured that every last inch of the mattress was utilized in safeguarding against heat retention. The topmost layer o the mattress features an open cell foam that actually draws in heat and moves it away from the body with the power of conduction and convection.

Below the layer of open-cell foam is a layer of high-quality memory foam. This layer is designed to extract heat away from the body through the top layer, guaranteeing that no heat is trapped against the body. It also provides ideal breathability and airflow to ensure that you’re getting fresh air against the skin.

Like their Nectar competitor, Casper also utilizes their base layer to avoid heat retention and guarantee that their mattress remains cool and comfortable. Their latex foam is designed to absorb heat from the top layers and distribute it evenly through the bottom of your mattress, guaranteeing that it’s far from your skin.

Who Wins?

In the Nectar vs Casper temperature control category, we believe that Nectar takes the win. While it’s true that they don’t specify the use of every individual layer the way that Casper does, we feel that the cooling properties featured in the Nectar mattress are of higher quality than the Casper.

Overall Comfort: Firmness vs Softness

There’s a long list of things to consider when you’re shopping for a new mattress. But, perhaps the most important consideration of them all is the comfort that you’ll be getting out of the potential mattresses. If a mattress isn’t comfortable, then it’s not worth packing home.

Below, we’ll take a look at the firmness vs softness ratio as well as the overall comfort of Nectar vs Casper.

Nectar Firmness

The Nectar mattress rates between 5.5 and 7.5 on the firmness scale, with 10 being the firmest, 1 the softest – making the Nectar mattress a medium-firm option. According to the official Nectar website, the creators of the mattress have perfected that just right harmony of firmness vs softness.

Much like their cooling properties, Nectar has taken advantage of every individual layer of their construction to provide their customers with top-notch comfort and plushness while remaining firm and supportive where you need it. Their quilted memory foam layer provides unequivocal loftiness and plush comfort while still contouring perfectly to each individual body shape and size.

Underneath the layer of quilted memory foam is a layer of gel memory foam that’s specifically constructed to absorb and evenly distribute body weight, guaranteeing to relieve and pressure or possible pain. It also helps to increase the longevity and overall durability of the mattress.

You’re guaranteed to never sink into your Nectar mattress either. Their layer of Hi-Core adaptive memory foam is designed to provide top-notch bounce-back, responsiveness, general support, and reinforces the overall contouring properties of the above memory foam layers.

Casper Firmness

The Casper mattress, like its Nectar competitor, is also marketed as a medium-firm option. Its primary material is memory foam, which isn’t usually known for its firmness properties, but rather its molding and contouring abilities that relieve pressure and stiffness.

But, the folks at Casper made sure that they wouldn’t be skimping on that crucial support and firmness that most consumers desire in their mattress. This combination guarantees that Casper is providing their users with a totally comfortable yet stable and supportive mattress.

Who Wins?

We certainly don’t doubt that the Casper mattress is comfortable. But, when we compare the overall comfort provided by Casper vs Nectar, once again Nectar takes the win in the end. They have utilized every inch of their mattress to provide their customers with the very best in both comfort and support.

Price: Nectar vs Casper

Obviously, you want to purchase a high-quality mattress. It needs to be comfortable, keeps you cool, comes backed by a decent warranty, and be constructed of high-quality materials. But, it’s always nice if all those attributes don’t have to break the bank in the end.

Let’s dive into the price tags accompanying Casper vs Nectar to determine which mattress will give you the most bang for your buck.

When we take into consideration all of the stellar benefits and amenities that the Nectar mattress has to offer, the price of the mattress is truly amazing. You can get any size for under a grand and you can upgrade your purchase from a king to a California king-size option without any additional cost.

Casper

The Casper mattress has a handful of pretty great benefits and amenities to offer. When taking those into consideration, the price tag that comes with the Casper isn’t too terrible. You can get a queen-size option for just a hair under $1000, and their king-size option for just over.

The prices of the Casper mattress are as follows:

Twin – $595

Twin XL – $645

Full – $895

Queen – $995

King – $1195

California King – $1195

Of course, there are cheaper options available as well as more expensive ones. But, for the quality you’ll be receiving out of the Casper mattress, it’s not a bad price point. Plus, you can get the California king-size for the same price as a regular king.

Who Wins?

When we compare the price of Nectar vs Casper, it’s pretty clear that Nectar has the leg up in this category. They offer tons of high-quality materials and benefits and all at a price point that’s well under $1000 for every size option available.

Pros & Cons Of Nectar vs Casper

Gathering up all the technical details of your potential mattress choices is always important. But, it’s never a bad idea to take a quick skim through the reviews as well. Real-life customer reviews are the best way for you to get your hands on true experiences, opinions, and common issues before you ever have to purchase the product.

In this section, we’ll be taking a look at a few of the great, and a few of the not-so-great reviews of Nectar vs Casper.

What Do Users Love About Nectar?

With just a quick look at the reviews of the Nectar mattress, it’s easy to see that most customers are absolutely in love with their purchase. However, the biggest admiration of the Nectar mattress boils down to the perfect harmony of softness and firmness that many customers have simply never found in previous mattresses.

Based on reviews, the Nectar mattress is perfect plush, soft, and comfortable while still remaining entirely stable, supportive and perfectly firm in all the right places. Several reviewers have even noted that they suffer from ailments such as fibromyalgia, arthritis, or chronic pain issues and the Nectar mattress either greatly reduced or completely alleviated their symptoms.

Pros

It’s fairly common for most foam mattresses to arrive compressed in plastic which can cause a noticeable off-gassing odor upon opening, however, Nectar reviewers have noted that they do not notice any off-gassing with this mattress

No matter what sleeping position you choose, the Nectar mattress remains completely comfortable and supportive

Unlike common competitors, the cover of the Nectar mattress is removable and washable

The Nectar mattress is equipped with sufficient edge support to prevent sagging or rolling, which can be uncommon in foam mattress options

The Nectar company offers their customers an industry-leading forever warranty

What Are The Downfalls Of Nectar?

When we pinpointed the biggest complaint about the Nectar mattress, we discovered that it had nothing to do with the comfort or overall performance of the mattress, but rather the shipping process.

According to a handful of reviewers, it can take several weeks for the Nectar mattress to actually arrive at your home. Several of these complaints have even noted that their orders were continuously pushed back and sometimes it took months to actually receive their purchase.

Cons

Unfortunately, the Nectar mattress company does not currently offer replacement covers

The Nectar mattress proudly offers financing on their products, but it does come with additional fees

It can take upwards of 30 days for your body to adjust to the new materials and construction of the Nectar mattress, meaning you may find yourself a bit uncomfortable until you’ve made it through the adjustment period

What Do Users Love About Casper?

The Casper company worked very hard to ensure that their mattress would provide their users with the perfect firmness to softness ratio and it seems that they’ve made good on that promise. Again, like Nectar users, many reviewers have noted that their Casper mattress has alleviated the symptoms of many painful ailments.

Pros

According to a large majority of reviewers, Casper’s customer service representatives are always very timely and courteous

The Casper mattress makes use of nearly every last inch of their mattress to safeguard against heat retention

Reviewers rave about the perfect balance of firmness to softness

The Casper mattress company provides their customers with a fairly standard warranty and sleep trial

The price tag that comes with the Casper mattress is pretty neutral for the benefits and amenities that come with it

What Are The Downfalls Of Casper?

Once again, like Nectar, the biggest complaint surrounding the Casper mattress isn’t so much about its performance. However, a large percentage of reviewers complain that they’ve experienced some pretty harsh and lasting off-gassing upon opening their Casper mattress.

The Casper mattress, like most online direct-to-consumer mattresses, is shipping compressed in a medium sized box. This is to help guarantee fast and hassle-free shipping. However, the foam materials under compression can develop a chemical-like odor. Usually, the smell will dissipate within a few hours to a couple of days with adequate ventilation. But, a good handful of Casper users have noted that the off-gassing odor tends to linger for 2 weeks or longer.

Cons

The Casper mattress, like many foam options, lacks sufficient edge support leaving users susceptible to rolling off the bed and causing premature wear if you sit on the edge often

A large number of reviewers have noticed that the mattress has a tendency to lean to one side when sleeping with a partner

It can take up to 72-hours for the Casper mattress to fully expand and be ready for use due to the way it’s compressed and shipped

Some users have noticed that their mattress wears down quite quickly, some in as little as 6 months

Warranty: Nectar vs Casper

A good warranty is a crucial aspect of the buying process. The longer the warranty, the more the company trusts their product. And, of course, you don’t want to be left footing the bill if your mattress breaks down prematurely. Not to mention, most mattress companies offer a pretty substantial sleep trial period these days to give you adequate time to make your final decision.

Let’s take a look at the sleep trial and warranty offered by Casper vs Nectar.

Nectar Warranty

The Nectar mattress company offers an unsurpassed and industry-leading warranty and sleep trial. Most commonly, companies offer their customers somewhere around a 100-night sleep trial and a 10-year limited warranty. But Nectar has taken it upon themselves to truly go above and beyond.

When you purchase your Nectar mattress, the company gives you a full year to decide if you absolutely love your new purchase. This is 3x longer than the average sleep trial offered in the industry.

According to the official Nectar website, less than 3% of Nectar buyers actually return their mattress within the sleep trial period. But, if you do decide that you don’t want to keep your Nectar mattress, you can return it within the 365-day time frame and Nectar will give you a full refund and even pick the mattress up from your home.

Unlike many of their competitors, after your trial period is up, Nectar keeps you covered with a lifetime warranty. This means that Nectar guarantees the quality and performance of their mattress, to the original purchaser, for as long as you own it.

For the first 10 years of your warranty, Nectar covers any damages that meet the terms of your warranty at no cost to you. Now, most companies that offer an extended warranty will begin to prorate your original purchase cost after the 10th year. Oftentimes, by the end of your warranty period, you’ll be left paying upwards of 95% of your original cost. However, Nectar only charges a $50 transportation fee both ways after the 10th year. Plus, if your mattress is truly found defective Nectar will waive this fee completely.

Casper Warranty

The folks at Casper offer their customers a fairly standard sleep trial and warranty. They offer 100 nights to try your mattress out inside your own home before you’re forced to make any final decisions. If you’re not completely satisfied within this time frame Casper will give you a full refund and pick the mattress up from your home.

If you decide to keep the mattress after the sleep trial period, you’ll remain protected with an industry-standard 10-year warranty. The Casper mattress company will repair or replace your mattress at no cost to you if it’s found to have a noticeable indention of greater than one inch, any failures in the zipper mechanism, or any defects in the materials of the mattress. They are not responsible for any damage incurred from strenuous abuse or misuse of the mattress.

Who Wins?

When we compare the warranty offered by Casper vs Nectar, Nectar clearly takes the win once again. The warranty and sleep trial offered by Casper is standard and certainly sufficient. But, the Nectar company guarantees that you’ll remain protected for as long as you own the mattress and offers a year-long sleep trial.

About The Companies

The details surrounding a mattress company may not be on the top of your list of priorities. But, it never hurts to get a rough idea about the companies that you’re considering purchasing from. How did they get started? Why did they choose mattresses? Are they involved in any philanthropy?

Below, we’ve compiled a few of the important details about the Nectar vs Casper companies.

Nectar Mattress Company

We couldn’t find a whole lot of detail surrounding the history of the company on the official Nectar website. But, the website does feature their Better Sleep Blog and also a complete FAQ section to answer just about any questions that you may have.

When it comes down to it, it’s pretty evident that the Nectar mattress company has set out to provide their customers with a high-quality, comfortable, and supportive mattress that they believe will literally last forever – all at a budget-friendly, affordable price.

They also use their warranty to show how much they care about the environment. One of the main reasons they offer their forever warranty is to help keep additional mattresses out of landfills.

Casper Mattress Company

The founders of the Casper mattress company found themselves in the same position as several other online mattress company founders – they were sick and tired of the standard mattress buying process.

In 2014, 5 individuals came together to create a solution to the mattress buying problems. They cut out the middleman process as well as the middleman cost and created an online, direct-to-consumer mattress company that would provide customers with a high-quality and comfortable mattress without the hassle of a big box store.

Since their founding in 2014, the Casper mattress company has been recognized by the New York Times, Forbes, and Good Morning America. They were also named one of the most innovative companies by Fast company in 2017 and received Good Housekeeping’s 2018 Lab Pick.

What’s Our Final Conclusion?

We certainly think that the Casper mattress is a great, high-quality mattress at a pretty neutral price point. But, when we compare every category of Nectar vs Casper, it’s pretty clear that Nectar takes the overall win in this comparison review.

Nectar offers high-quality, top-notch construction, cooling properties within nearly every layer, a perfect harmony of softness and firmness, and a price tag that’s extremely budget-friendly considering all the amenities.