The first year the team was managed by Mordecai Brown, who also doubled as their pitcher. Unfortunately they lost a lot more games than they won and came in last place in their league of six teams, a mere 25 games out of first place.

After the 1915 season the league was disbanded in a settlement with Major League Baseball and former Terriers' financier Phillip de Catesby Ball was able to purchase the St. Louis Browns as a part of the settlement.