MARGARET O’CONNOR. Reforming the Catholic Church: it’s up to the laity

The task of reform of the Catholic Church has to fall to the Church’s laity. This work is too important to be led by media figures and personalities with their twitter accounts, large public platforms and endless opinions.

I have vague memories as a child in the early 1970s of seeing ‘Brother Sun, Sister Moon’, Franco Zeffirelli’s counter-culture-infused biopic of the life of the popular Catholic saint, Francis of Assisi. St Francis, the Patron Saint of Ecology, and Pope Francis’ namesake, preached to the birds and animals (according to folk tales) and committed himself to a simple lifestyle free from greed and material indulgence. And yet, after he passed away, a whopping great big ostentatious basilica was built commemorating his life.

How very Catholic Church. Monumental human flaws and vices interspersed with fragments of a core spiritual heart. In terms of my faith of choice, I wouldn’t blame other people for asking: why?

I’m not entirely sure.

No-one knows more about the Church’s monumental flaws and vices than those most affected by them, as I know all too well having grown up near a town called Mortlake in the Western District of Victoria. The infamous Gerald Ridsdale was parish priest there in 1981 and 1982 when I was 14 and 15 years old. He is now in jail after sexually abusing scores of kids both in Mortlake (mostly younger than me by a few years) and elsewhere in the Ballarat Diocese. His shtick was to present an image of himself as being a big genial friendly bear of a man who loved children. By way of example, at his first Mass at St Colman’s Church, (as I vividly recall after all these years) he warmly invited small children in the congregation to come up and sit around the altar, which they did, excitedly.

Photo Courtesy of the Mortlake and District Historical Society

Ann Ryan, who taught at St Colman’s Primary School for years, outlined her connection to Case Study 28 (Catholic Church Authorities in Ballarat) in her statement to the Royal Commission into Institutional Responses in Child Sexual Abuse. She described an intuitive dislike of Ridsdale right from the get-go, learning of his abuses from distraught parents after he left town, and subsequent persistent attempts to try to engage the Bishop of Ballarat, Ronald Mulkearns, on the issue. Her statement alludes to a hastily arranged celebration at St Colman’s Parish Hall – tea, coffee, biscuits ̶ to farewell Ridsdale when he left Mortlake suddenly in around October 1982. When I learned later of what he had done in the town I realised why, in his farewell address to parishioners there, he had, weirdly and obliquely, inserted a reference to ‘forgiveness’ into the acknowledgements of the ‘support’ ‘love’ and ‘good fellowship’ characterising his time at Mortlake.

In late 2015 and early 2016, when the Royal Commission hearing was held in Ballarat, Mortlake was thrust improbably into the spotlight during the accompanying media storm. There’s nothing more surreal than spending your early years near a town so small, and making your way into polite society courtesy of the Whitlam era educational reforms, then decades later observing the Australian commentariat, most of whom would have previously struggled to locate the Ballarat Diocese or Western District region on a map, let alone Mortlake, suddenly appoint themselves subject matter experts on events which occurred there in the early 1980s.

But the opinionated reaction on the part of national celebrities and media personalities and their pretenders both in mainstream and social media shouldn’t be allowed to obscure the solid public interest contributions of regional Victorian newspapers with respect to highlighting the facts of Case Study 28. In the 1990s, the Warrnambool Standard covered Ann Ryan’s attempts to engage with the Church after she gave up in desperation and turned to the media. It reported Ridsdale’s initial charges and conviction in 1993 and 1994, his subsequent convictions, and ‘Operation Arcadia’, a police operation which examined the feasibility of charging Bishop Mulkearns for concealing his crimes.

‘Hindsight experts ‘ on twitter, that oh-so-reactive medium (and I’m as prone to this as anyone) could do worse than check out the work of Melissa Cunningham from the Ballarat Courier, who won a Quill Award for stellar coverage of the Commission’s Ballarat hearings. She didn’t make unsubstantiated allegations. She didn’t flaunt her ego or her subjective views. She simply reported on the daily revelations and allowed the devastating story to speak for itself. Regional media cut backs and brutal efficiencies notwithstanding, it could be possible that reports of the death of public interest journalism have been greatly exaggerated.

But more telling than media reports, even if they undoubtedly serve the public interest, is primary evidence. The story of how Australian institutions comprehensively failed to address allegations of child abuse over a period of decades is writ large in the transcripts of the Royal Commission cases (to which the Catholic Church contributed roughly 70 per cent). Also of interest is how recurring Royal Commission themes compare and contrast with those – half a world away – of the recent Dame Janet Smith review into the culture and practices of the BBC when Jimmy Saville worked there. Organisational and institutional truth is stranger, more pertinent and a lot more devastating than twitter fiction and conjecture. And way more telling than a single narrow emphasis on individuals such as Cardinal Pell.

Many who have experienced or surveyed this truth of institutional corruption and abuse have fled the Catholic Church in abject horror. Some, including myself, reject the institutional Church, but, hanging in there by our fingernails, still call our faith of choice ‘Roman Catholic’. And every day we ask ourselves: why?

It’s time to sidestep the current failings of both mainstream and social media to and turn our thoughts to serious reform. All over the world, groups are springing up agitating for the Catholic Church hierarchy to accept improved governance with a greater involvement on the part of Catholic laity, gay marriage, female priests, married clergy, and much more. Here in Canberra, the group ‘Concerned Catholics Canberra and Goulburn’ is keen to explore how lay people can have an effective role and voice in the administration and direction of their Church. The convener/chair, John Warhurst, would be very happy to discuss the main elements of the approach adopted by Concerned Catholics with anyone from another diocese who thinks that they could be applied to their situation.

We, the global Catholic laity, must take the lead. It’s the only way forward; this work can’t be led by media figures and personalities with their twitter accounts and large public platforms and endless opinions. Not even by those who are Catholic.

They won’t be able to prevent a recurrence of this devastating life-ruining global tragedy and recover the shattered fragments of our core spiritual heart. That will be up to us.

7 Responses to MARGARET O’CONNOR. Reforming the Catholic Church: it’s up to the laity

While I agree with all you say I find myself in despair about the “global Catholic laity” taking the lead. Having spent 80 years as a member of that laity, I think most of it has been well and truly conditioned to being just that, a laity. It’s a kind of learned helplessness appropriate to sheep. We were often so described in clerical jargon. My fear is that all of the potential leaders have long since turned their back on the institution for very good reasons, and left behind an aging rump without the skills or the energy to give a lead. People like me.

Education is the reason the “Institution” has ceased to be relevant to recent generations in the first world..It is no coincidence that the “church” is thriving in the third world. When their education catches up with the first world is perhaps when the final implosion will take place. Any talk of “Reforming the Church” almost always ignores this basic issue. The Institution is not reformable (even by laity) as it cannot acknowledge that its core theology is based on a medieval world view of God, that is intellectually and spiritually unsustainable with current knowledge in evolution, science and Biblical scholarship. Consequently it has obscured and distorted the spiritual message that Jesus tried to leave us which was to bring forward the Kingdom here – not build a worldly political power. Perhaps that message will be carried forward when this political organisation which incorrectly claims to have been founded by him finally ceases and “Followers of the Way” bring the Kingdom forward here by living life as he lived his – i.e. as The People of God — the true definition of “Church” as defined by Vatican II

Congratulation Margaret on your forthright presentation.
Though I for one remain underwhelmed.
With respect, I can’t get excited about people now coming out of the wood work, to tell us we told you so It seems to little to late, for the multitudes permanently damaged and in torment.
The fact is, we can site similar stories in Newcastle, Wollongong, Sydney, Melbourne, Perth and beyond. In fact, in each and every Dioceses and Provincial Order across the Nation and beyond are exactly the same. The same Modus Operandi. Together with the same dismal failure of the duty of care, by all concerned. Together with the ineffective voice of any ‘Insider’ Conscious Objectors.

On behalf of our most precious, our most vulnerable, most innocence and most violated – with it all happening on our watch.

I do agree with you that by being mesmerised by these so called Media figures, we are missing the forest for the trees and the elephants in the room – It’s a rampant systemic failure of abuse, and not just individual perverted aberrations.

We understand that to properly face these issues, is a direct threat to their very spirituality, their view of reality and even their chosen career.

Be as it may, why are conscious objector’s labeled heretics and in anathema, whilst it is these criminally corrupt Leaders and the untold numbers in collusion with them, who are the heretic and in anathema. Clearly breaking the Law of God, the law of the Land and the Law of Human Decency.

None of which has been forthcoming or recognised, except by the stockades of external public pressure, the fierce Civil Litigation and the direct duress of personal incarceration and servere financial penalty.

However with the utmost respect to you Margaret, this is not about you or I moving on, to start again somewhere in the sunset.
It’s about you and I taking ownership and responsibility of the heinous crimes committed on our watch.
Its about our duty of repatriation, as informed adult members of our society
Its about the higher good of real Truth, Justice and Compassion, for the lost, the broken, the disempowered and marginalised children and their devastated parents and families, be they churched and unchurched.
Its about effectively embracing those permanently damaged, as collaterally damaged, by our Systemic Abuse of Power, Trust and Rape – Both sexually, emotionally, spiritually and financially – I believe it is here the living church could emerge. And where, I suspect, you and I, might be freed to discover, we are all victims of the Childhood Abuse of Trust and Power.
Maintain your voice of Conscientious Dissent, Margaret, I like your spirit.
Regards Michael J Wood OM. (michaeljwood2u@gmail .com) 25/7/17

Thank you Margaret for your article. As a 61 year old survivor of the Catholic Church I believe reform maybe too late, but I do believe in a spiritual revolution. I look to inspiration from priests like Richard Rohr and ex priests like Michael Morwood.
You can reach me on waynemcmillan746@gmail.com
Best Wishes
Wayne

Only total structural reform can achieve the outcomes rightly called for here. Only when the Eucharist presided over by a male cleric masked in vestments hiding too often corruption beneath ceases to be believed to be the pivotal apex and fulcrum of church life rather than a self believing lay community to be the centrepiece of church life will the structural reform required occur. Bring it on.

Thanks all. As my article says, I’m struggling at the moment with the lack of opportunity via social media to unpack these issues and to have an open, engaged and respectful conversation about faith related issues, including Catholicism, so I appreciate your candour and your comments. I understand and expect that there will be a divergence of views about this topic.

Comments are closed.

Search for:

Subscribe to our weekly and daily Pearls and Irritations newsletter!

Please leave this field empty

First name

Last name

Email *

Which newsletter? Daily Weekly

To confirm you must click on the link in the email we've just sent you. Please check your junk mail folder if you can't find it. Thank you, John.