When the Tarnish Brothers appeared as back-up singers on "This Frog" and "Salida," the Orange Gold character had been dropped in favor a Lavender one. Aside from this change, however, their look stayed mostly the same. Their eyelids, however, which had all been purple in their first appearance, now matched the color of each character's skin.

In "This Frog," the characters are once again puppeteered by Frank Oz (Fat Blue), Jerry Nelson (Pumpkin), and Richard Hunt (Lavender),[1] while Nelson, Hunt, and Christopher Cerf provided the vocals.