Review: Britain’s best 100 railway stations by Simon Jenkins

Stations, according to Simon Jenkins, are the forgotten part of the railway experience. People love the trains, the journey, the passing countryside, the leisurely pace and the locomotives, especially steam ones. The stations, however, have been rather ignored. Sure, the ubiquity of Prêt, Upper Crust and all those coffee chains on station concourses has made the experience somewhat tawdry at times but even the worst is better than an airport. Brief Encounters would not have worked in a departure lounge.

As Jenkins discovers, there is still plenty to celebrate and enjoy, and the modern disdain of stations is partly borne of our reluctance to linger in the face of modern life’s myriad competing demands. Linger, though, we must, to enjoy the variety of stations that have been left, largely by our Victorian forebears. Of course Beeching cut a swathe through the station network, closing more than 2,300, but many weresmall or of little architectural interest. The most infamous loss was the old Euston, with its wonderful sweeping staircases in the Great Hall and overrated Doric arch.

For a while after British Rail had stopped closing lines, stations were still in its crosshairs, including, notably, St Pancras, not least because there was the potential of a quick buck from property sales for the cash-strapped organisation. Jenkins claims a role here in stopping the destruction. He was appointed to the British Railways Board in 1980 and was shocked by the disdain for heritage shown by a continued programme of station demolition. He tried to stop the destruction of the Derby Tri-Junct, a station, as its name suggests, linking three lines, but was told by the chairman, Sir Peter Parker, that it was too late.

Victorian buildings were out of fashion and Jenkins, appointed head of BR’s environment panel, trooped around the country ‘visiting distressed railway heritage, if only to draw attention to its plight’. However, Jenkins says that he managed to persuade Parker to fund a Railway Heritage Trust with £1m per year and as a result no major stations have been subsequently lost, apart from Newmarket.

The book, therefore, is a celebration of what’s left, rather than a lament for what is gone. There is the occasional expression of anger, such as when Jenkins relates how British Rail, in what he calls ‘the 1970s Devastation’ ripped out the free-standing wooden ticket office designed by James Bell in the 1890s at Edinburgh Waverley and replaced it successively with ‘a travel centre, a shopping kiosk and then a Costa Coffee stand’, which was in turn removed, leaving a few rows of metal seats.

Nevertheless, with more than 2,500 surviving stations, there was no shortage for Jenkins from which to select his best 100. The cover of the book is a good place to start. I confess that I had no idea of the location of the remarkable glass roof, sprouting out of a circular ticket office like the underside of a mushroom. It is in fact Wemyss Bay, on the Firth of Clyde, a station mainly used by passengers transferring from train to ferry or vice versa, and consequently needing to offer both shelter and speed, which explains the huge concourse that seems out of scale for such a small place.

Divided geographically, Jenkins admits that London is over-represented in the book but that is understandable given the grandeur of several of its termini, built as demonstrations of power by the private companies whose main offices they housed. Nevertheless, this is a genuinely national selection, and while the larger stations undoubtedly predominate, Jenkins has unearthed a lot of gems in small places such Betws-y-Coed and Gobowen.

The photography is stunning, but since Jenkins’s focus is on the architecture – he is after all the author of England’s Thousand Best Churches – there are few people in the pictures, which rather belies the very purpose for which the stations exist. There are even fewer trains or locomotives but that is understandable. Jenkins wants us to look at these spaces that are ignored as we rush through, and to look behind the modern ‘improvements’ that have so often been added with little regard for their impact on the historic design.

In recent years, though, much more attention has been paid to heritage (sometimes excessively but that is another story) and there have been welcome improvements. One great cause for celebration has been the recent removal of the nasty 1960s lean-to that completely wrecked the wonderful clean lines of the yellow-brick frontage of King’s Cross, creating a pleasant piazza from which to admire what is my favourite London station (although Jenkins prefers the Gothic extravaganza next door, ‘which gives me the greatest thrill’).

Of course I have to quibble with some of Jenkins’s choices and, particularly, his ratings. He seems to slap four or five stars on much Victorian architecture while giving only grudging praise to such 1930s Underground masterpieces as Charles Holden’s Southgate (one star) or Gants Hill, with its subterranean art deco concourse that would not be out of place in Moscow’s remarkable metro system (two stars). Inevitably, as he admits, there will be countless complaints about his omissions, which, he says, will hopefully be remedied in a future volume listing the next best 100.

Stations, as Jenkins notes, are enjoying a renaissance. Look at how shabby, car-dominated entrances, as at Newcastle, Nottingham and St Pancras, have been turned into pleasant human-friendly spaces, and at how several major cities – and in particular London – are being blessed with a remarkable series of new or rebuilt stations which, in the capital, include many rebuilt Underground stations. And we are being encouraged to linger more, with many stations managing to escape the Costa Coffee fate and providing independent pubs and cafés instead.

Christian Wolmar’s new book, Railways and the Raj, how the steam age transformed India, will be published on November 2

Dan

I flicked through this in the bookshop – it looks good, but like Christian I thought it a bit thin on 20th century entries – not sure if it includes any of the rather good 1930s Southern offerings, and BR itself (despite a lot of very poor replacement buildings in many locations – esp post 1965) can be credited with a few good examples in my view – eg Chichester, Manchester Oxford Road, Coventry and maybe also Stafford are some that come to mind.

But if it were not for listed status I suspect BR would have flattened a lot more.

Well done to Simon J for pushing for the Railway Heritage Trust – I’ve found that whenever I am at a station where some uplifting architectural feature catches my eye, it turns out the RHT has had a hand in repairing or helping restore it!

Chris Redman

Shame the illustration with this blog post doesn’t represent the real colours of the Wemyss Bay pic on the book’s cover. Have you used a CMYK or negative image?

RT @FranklinGrimsby We were very privileged today to have @christianwolmar in college to deliver a fascinating and thought provoking presentation to our students. He was able to engage the students on topics ranging from driver-less cars to the recent budget. Thanks very much!