An evaluation stem cell research

Do the benefits associated with using embryonic stem cells for medical and research purposes outweigh the negatives associated with loss of life?

Problem: Embryonic stem skin cells result in loss of life

Embryonic stem cells are unspecialised skin cells that have the power under certain conditions to generate any of the various types of muscle in early human growth and can renew themselves through cell department1. The ability of stem cells to specialise into over 220 types of skin cells in the mature human body is what interests scientists and potential to make a variety of clinical therapies to treat disease2.

Embryonic stem cells are gathered from fertilised human being embryos which may have either been donated or have been created artificially in a lab. Embryos are created by in vitro fertilisation and donated for research with the donor's consent2. The embryoblast, the interior cell mass, of the blastocyst is removed and is put into a culture dish made up of a managed culture of nutrition that permit the cells to separate and create stem cell lines that are maintained and shared between experts3.

Fig. 1 - A microphotograph of real human embryonic stem skin cells4.

Scientists are studying the use of stem skin cells in medical research to harness that they identify into specialised skin cells that define the tissues of the human being body2. Many diseases happen scheduled to problems associated with cell differentiation so better knowledge about what goes on in cells can help prevent these problems in the future2. Furthermore creating new tissues can help to repair damage caused by disease or the creation of new skin cells can assist patients who've deficiencies including the inability to generate insulin in the case of diabetes patients or have broken or diseased organs. Such therapies could also reduce the demand on transplant organs and loss of life as many people die looking forward to a transplant. Stem cell solutions desire to reduce morbidity for such people in the foreseeable future. Stem cells are also used to check drugs before tests on live animals and humans2.

In order to use embryonic stem skin cells, in researching and producing such therapies, a living individual embryo, which would usually have the potential to develop into your baby in the right conditions, is demolished by removing stem cells when it is about 4 to 6 6 days old. Destroying embryos in this manner has resulted in controversy over the sanctity of individual life versus the potential to treat a number of human diseases.

The sanctity of real human life in quarrels about embryonic stem cell research follows similar rationale to the ones that oppose abortion. Various religious groupings see life as sacrosanct and hold that life is treasured and the harvesting of embryonic stem cells and the causing devastation of the embryo brings life to an end albeit to a collection of skin cells with potential to develop into a person4.

Research using embryonic stem cells is still quite recent. Several clinical trials are currently underway that are looking into the security of the utilization of the techniques and stem cells in restoring spinal-cord function among others in retinal stem skin cells being used to take care of eye disease2.

Solution: Use Animal Embryos and Human Cells

Using individuals embryonic stem skin cells means destroying human embryos so alternatives is highly recommended that do not involve using real human embryos. Research in to the use of animal embryos instead has prevailed in creating embryonic stems cells that might be used for individuals medical therapies. For example in 2003, human cells were fused with rabbit eggs to generate an embryonic chimera (an assortment of two animals in a single body) that was then used to harvest embryonic stem skin cells5. For many years animal structure has been used in humans with pig and cow heart valves serving as a replacement for faulty individuals center valvies5.

Implications:

Ethical - Mixing man and animal mobile material

Ethical issues centre on artificially creating embryos filled with both animal and human cells. This creates moral issues worried about tampering with animals and using animals in research as well thoughts of such science being immoral or missing sufficient knowledge on the results of blending animal and individuals genetic materials. Animal welfare organisations may also be concerned about any damage that involves animals therefore of research.

These moral issues fall within the four main guidelines of biomedical ethics: autonomy, nonmaleficence, beneficence and justice which underpin the moral obligations of health professionals and modern culture on get together the needs of the ill to improve health, prolong life and remedy diseases as well as the amount at which experts can improve medical interventions to do so6.

Social - Chimeras Are Unnatural

Creating chimeras is seen as unnatural as it interferes with natural boundaries between different species. Various chimera combinations have been created to understand more about individual diseases, including mice with some mind structure to assist with understanding more about Parkinson's Disease or Alzheimer's Disease5. However, culture is still struggling to comprehend how such interference is of benefit to humankind.

Religious objections are also made by humans playing God and interfering with the natural order of life as it was divinely created. The bases of religious beliefs and morals have taught us that the worthiness of a human being life differs to that of your animal and this is just about the socially accepted norm in many ethnicities. Arguably we already hinder nature in different ways, like organ transplantation, why should developing alternative stem cell ethnicities from animal embryos with real human skin cells be any different? The solution appears to rest in what's considered to be moral appropriate and confusion as to what constitutes a individual and an animal.

Economic - Profitable Research

Countries, such as Canada, have banned the creation of animal chimeras through the Assisted Human being Reproduction Work, which prohibits transferring a nonhuman cell into a individuals embryo and placing human skin cells into a nonhuman embryo5. There's also concerns that diminishes real human dignity or violates either individual or animal integrity as chimeras can't be distinguished as real human or not human. However, such is the demand in research that other countries perform this research instead. Success in creating lasting and appropriate stem cell remedies could be very beneficial in conditions of trademarks and pharmaceutical control that it may also be very profitable for those included. Beneath the Obama administration the USA is defined to reverse restrictions in stem cell procedures to enable analysts to build up stem cell therapies and competition among scientists has supposed that other countries are trying to ensure that money and expertise is in place to develop therapies to become market leaders in stem cell research2.

Impacts on humans:

Benefits

Embryonic stem skin cells offer the possibility to develop clinical remedies you can use to treat a range of serious, life threatening diseases including heart disease. For instance stem cells can be brought about to develop into cardiomyocytes1 (cardiac muscle cells) that can be injected into the destroyed hearts of patients to treat heart failure.

The main benefit chimeras have is they can use cells extracted from the patient mixed up in treatment, which reduces problems with transplant rejection.

In developing stem cell solutions researchers can also find out more about individuals development and appreciate how undifferentiated stem cells differentiate to create the cells and organs found in the real human body1. This knowledge will help to understand more about mobile processes, which will assist scientists with studying diseases, such as cancer, and beginning defects that induced by abnormal cell division.

Risks

The use of embryonic stem skin cells includes issues with the impact of using real human tissues made out of animals, ethics on animal research, potential aspect effects.

Stem cells must be implanted into patients. The patients' body must recognize these cells for transplantation to reach your goals. Stem skin cells need to specialise in sync with the patient's skin cells, for example, neural cells must have the ability to communicate with the intricate network of neural skin cells in the body to function properly. Immunological rejection is a potential hurdle to successful transplantation as a patient's immune system may view the stem skin cells as foreign in the same way as traditional organ transplants require strong immunosuppressive drugs to lessen the probability of rejection2. It isn't known if implanted stem skin cells would cause secondary problems later in the patient's life, such as cancers or tumours.

Use of animals and real human/animal embryos requires honest assistance and legal frameworks to be established. Embryos have to be harvested or created in an appropriate manner that is socially or morally satisfactory. Lack of understanding and the controversy associated with this research are also seen as risks to growing treatments.

Alternative solutions:

Adult stem skin cells do not require real human or animal embryos at all. Adult stem cells can replenish specialised skin cells from simply a few unspecialised skin cells. Mature stem cell remedy aspires to create healthy cell lines in a lab and then use these to displace dysfunctional skin cells in the patient. The use of adult stem skin cells is apparently more socially satisfactory as it generally does not involve the damage of a real human embryo. Adult or somatic stem cells most easily create cell types of the organ they are really harvested from including the brain, bone marrow, blood vessels and blood vessels, skeletal muscles, skin and the liver3 (see Fig. 1).

Adult stem cells can be created using a patient's own cells which are re-programmed by forcing them to express genes that produce them respond like embryonic stem skin cells. This creates induced pluripotent stem skin cells that can create the same cell layers as an embryo1.

Adult stem cells were first extracted from bone marrow in the 1960s4. Experts, in 2007, have genetically manufactured adult stem skin cells to mirror the qualities of embryonic stem skin cells that might be used to build any cell or muscle type, for example individual liver cells from bone marrow cells8.

Stem cells can be extracted from umbilical cable blood vessels, placenta and also from fetal cells4. Research found that stem skin cells from individual umbilical cord bloodstream were transplanted into the brains broken rats the effect of a stroke7.

There is a problem that mature stem cells can be found in small quantities and this makes it difficult to get them in sufficient statistics to utilize them therapeutically2. Experts have found that adult stem skin cells aren't as successful as embryonic stem cells nor do they proliferate as well. Due to being adult skin cells they are more than embryonic cells and contain much more DNA abnormalities which may limit their suitability for medical use2.

Adult stem skin cells already are being used for creating medicine solutions and can be used for trialling new drugs as well.

Adult stem skin cells can be extracted from human being umbilical cord blood. Cord blood stem cells are used to take care of around 70 blood-derived diseases, such as anaemia, leukaemia and lymphomas7. Umbilical cords are thought to be medical waste products but these scientific developments mean that they is now able to be placed to use as a probably life-saving resource and research continues to see if other cell types can be created.

Other services that we offer

If you don’t see the necessary subject, paper type, or topic in our list of available services and examples, don’t worry! We have a number of other academic disciplines to suit the needs of anyone who visits this website looking for help.