Fogle was one of Subway's most lucrative spokesmen, reportedly contributing to nearly half of Subway's growth over the last 15 years — since he became famous for losing more than 200 pounds while eating the restaurant's sandwiches.

Subway cut ties with him last month following an FBI raid on his Zionsville, Indiana, home.

But the company's troubles are far from over.

With or without Fogle, the ubiquitous sandwich chain is suffering a disturbing sales decline.

Subway's sales dropped 3% last year to $11.9 billion, despite opening 778 new stores, according to QSR magazine.

The decline was steeper than for any other of America's top 25 food chains last year, according to The Washington Post. The chain's performance was worse than even struggling McDonald's, which saw US sales decline 2.2% last year.

So what went wrong?

Subway has more than 43,000 outlets worldwide. Andrew Winning/Reuters Subway rose to become one of the biggest restaurant chains in the world with more than 43,000 outlets by advertising a healthier, fresh alternative to traditional fast food like McDonald's or Burger King.

Subway was a pioneer in made-to-order sandwiches, prepared right in front of customers by employees taking orders in an assembly-line fashion.

But then, other rivals, such as Chipotle and Panera, started offering even fresher options — like antibiotic-free meats and additive-free guacamole prepared on site.

According to analysts, Subway didn't evolve quickly enough to meet diners' changing ideas about what is considered fresh and healthy.

As a result, the chain is facing an eroding public perception regarding the quality of its food. Subway did not respond to a request for comment on this story.

Jared Fogle is no longer Subway's pitchman. AP Subway's public image was hit particularly hard last year when FoodBabe.com blogger Vani Hari launched an online campaign against the chain for using the additive azodicarbonamide in its bread.

The campaign was successful, and Subway was forced to change the recipe for its bread as a result.

Now Subway is committing to remove all artificial flavors, colors, and preservatives from its food over the next two years.

It remains to be seen whether any of these changes will actually improve Subway's reputation.

But things aren't looking great for the sub chain.

"We're in a new environment — the Chipotle environment ... the fast-casual environment — with a new type of rhetoric, quality, and marketability," Andrew Alvarez, a food analyst with IBISWorld, told The Post. By comparison, "Subway's platform, its presentation almost looks primordial."

Popular from BI Prime

Close iconTwo crossed lines that form an 'X'. It indicates a way to close an interaction, or dismiss a notification.Check mark iconA check mark. It indicates a confirmation of your intended interaction.