Sen. Harkin’s Report: For-Profit Colleges Leave Students With Debt But No Degree

Senator Tom Harkin (D-IA) and his Senate Health, Education, Labor and Pensions (HELP) Committee staff released Sunday a report based on a comprehensive investigation of 30 of the biggest for-profit college companies. It’s full of stark revelations about this controversial, troubled industry.

I’ve been saying for a couple of years that, no matter how cynical one’s view of Washington is, it cannot encompass the perpetuation of the terrible impunity of America’s for-profit colleges. For over a decade, these corporations have taken billions from taxpayers — now about $33 billion a year — for a toxic mix of high-priced, low-quality programs that leave many students — veterans, students of color, low-income students, immigrants, and others — deep in debt, their hopes crushed, their lives ruined.

For-profit colleges now account for about 10 percent of U.S. students but 25 percent for federal financial aid and nearly half of all student loan defaults. Many schools get 85-90 percent or more of their revenues from federal taxpayers, and they spend most of it on items like marketing, recruiting, and big executive salaries, rather than education and job placement. Not all for-profit colleges are that bad, but many, including most of the big ones, are.

There is stalemate in Washington on holding this industry accountable, because the big money that it spends on lobbying, lawyering, and campaign contributions has bought the allegiance of many congressional Republicans and Democrats and has thwarted federal regulations. Thus determined reform efforts by the Obama Administration, and principled leaders like Senators Harkin, Dick Durbin(D-IL), and Kay Hagan (D-NC), and Representatives Elijah Cummings (D-MD), Maxine Waters (D-CA), and Keith Ellison (D-MN), have largely been blocked.

But after an extended period of scrutiny by federal officials, nonprofits, and diligent news reporters, the truth is coming out and having an impact. Federal investigators are probing for-profit institutions including giants the University of Phoenix and EDMC and smaller operations like Florida’s FastTrain College, where, on the day of an FBI raid, one student told a reporter that she had been charged for room and board — at a school that does not offer student housing.

More than 30 state attorneys general are accelerating a joint investigation of fraud by for-profits including Corinthian, Kaplan, and Bridgepoint. Long lethargic accrediting bodies are at last reconsidering the free pass they have given these schools. Investors are realizing that the reckless joy ride may be over soon. Most importantly, students are getting the message that they need to look elsewhere for educational opportunities. Veterans are especially incensed, and more and more of them are speaking up about the deceptive and coercive recruiting tactics many for-profits use to exploit lucrative GI bill dollars. Check out the hard-hitting video from the Iraq Afghanistan Veterans of America, above.

The latest blow is the detailed report by Harkin. Among its conclusions:

54 percent of students who enrolled in these 30 for-profit colleges in 2008-9 left without a degree, within a median of four months. Among 2-year associate degree-seekers, 63 percent left without a degree.

“In 2010, the for-profit colleges examined employed 35,202 recruiters compared with 3,512 career services staff and 12,452 support services staff, more than two and a half recruiters for each support services employee.”

“During the same period, the companies examined spent $4.2 billion on marketing and recruiting, or 22.7 percent of all revenue. Publicly traded companies operating for-profit colleges had an average profit margin of 19.7 percent, generated a total of $3.2 billion in pre-tax profit and paid an average of $7.3 million to their chief executive officers in 2009.”

“Documents demonstrate that in order to achieve company enrollment goals, recruiting managers at some companies created a boiler-room atmosphere, in which hitting an enrollment quota was the recruiters’ highest priority. Recruiters who failed to bring in enough students were put through disciplinary processes and sometimes terminated. Before a ban on incentive compensation was reinstituted in mid-2011, recruiters’ salaries at many for-profit colleges were tightly tied to enrolling a certain number of new students.”

“[M]any companies used tactics that misled prospective students with regard to the cost of the program, the availability and obligations of Federal aid, the time to complete the program, the completion rates of other students, the job placement rate of other students, the transferability of the credit, or the reputation and accreditation of the school.”

“Internal documents show that some schools’ pursuit of military benefits led them to recruit from the most vulnerable military populations, sometimes recruiting at wounded warrior centers and veterans hospitals.

“In addition to aggressively seeking military personnel, the investigation showed that some recruiters misled or lied to service members as to whether their tuition would be fully covered by military benefits.”

“In the absence of significant reforms,the sector will continue to turn out hundreds of thousands of students with debt but no degree, and taxpayers will see little return on their investment.”

For his leadership on his issue, Senator Harkin has allegedly faced threats from this arrogant industry and unremitting hostility from Republican members of his own committee. He deserves enormous credit for his determination to protect students and taxpayers.

The for-profit colleges have adopted a talking point — see here and here — asserting that those who question their industry are driven by “their political or ideological agenda.” But the agenda that Harkin and his allies are pursuing is purely common sense: Taxpayer money should not fuel waste, fraud, and abuse. There can be a constructive role for for-profit institutions in educating Americans, but the current race to bottom — where profits depend on abusing and exploiting students — must end. With federal dollars already scarce, policy must instead reward schools that compete by helping students train for careers and obtain good jobs. This straightforward approach could be considered contentious only in a warped world where slick industry lobbyists and campaign money distort the debate.

We’ll have more on the Harkin report in the days to come. The Senator, joined by Rep. Cummings, will hold a press conference Monday afternoon.

UPDATE: Rep. Cummings, who is the top Democrat on the House Oversight and Government Reform committee, issued his own report on Friday after seeking information from 13 of the largest publicly traded for-profit college corporations about how they determine executive compensation. The report concludes that these companies calculate executive pay “predominantly on the profitability of their companies rather than the success of their students.”

Meanwhile, the for-profit college’s lobbying organization, APSCU, attacked the Harkin report, taking issue with a few factual assertions and employing the same talking points I described above: “Unfortunately, Senator Harkin’s report continues in the tradition of ideology overriding reality. The report twists the facts to fit a narrative, proving that this is nothing more than continued political attacks on private sector colleges and universities.”

UPDATE: Read more on Republic Report about the Harkin and Cummings reports and press conference:

This epitomizes our money-influencing-politics system = The taxpayers are losing, the students are losing, the corrupt members of Congress are winning, the corrupt corporations are winning and the corrupt accrediting agencies are winning. The accrediting agencies are recognized by the U.S. Department of Education (USDE) and agree to fulfill specific federally defined responsibilities. The absolute dysfunction of this particular scenario must also include the failure of the USDE as well as the Office of the Inspector General. What a mess!

David Halperin

Agree 100%, and thanks for your comment. We are going to win this fight, though. Even Washington can’t condone something this egregious forever.

Unfortunately this writer failed to even mention one of the fattest pigs at the trough, Liberty University, a barely accredited “college” that teaches creationism as a science. Their credits are worthless at any real school, but their share of Federal Student monies is huge! Become a minister and spread the word… Cha-ching!!!

Tmutton65

I was a LMS student at FMU, Florida Metropolitan University, graduated, but did’nt pass my exam to get licensed due to one of my instructors ( the one that was suppose to teach us Asian techniques) being out sick for 4 months. when i went to go do my exam, most of it was on the Asian..missed getting my license by only 2 points!! Now i’ve had to default on my student loan, which is still accumulating interest as we speak. So what am i suppose to do now??

Republic Report is dedicated to rooting out the corruption that is so corrosive to American values. We investigate and uncover the buying and selling of politicians and of institutions entrusted with upholding the public interest. We expose how big money distorts major policy decisions – harming our economy and our people.