universetwisters

While Family Guy may be funny for offbeat, immature humor that I have a fondness for, it feels like that the plots themselves aren't funny and most of the humor comes from cutaway gags, as opposed to the actual episode itself.

On the other hand, I love American Dad more than Family Guy, and I don't even know why. I'm guessing it's that the show takes place in Northern Virginia and the fact that I'm originally from there. f*ck, could be anything, though.

RoadRunner71

It's a welcome escape from all the liberal propaganda crap that MacFarlane wants to shove down my throat.

I love family guy, I love how they make fun of absolutely everything but the newer episodes are being a let down. Just like The Simpsons, maybe it's time to end it, or at least, put it on hiatus. Therefore, I think I'd choose American Dad, which is getting better and better. Only Roger and his characters could make a whole separate series haha.

Also, I liked Cleveland's Show. It wasn't as good as the other two series but I enjoyed watching it. It got a lot of hate, though...

na89340qv0n34b09q340

I'd take seasons 1-3 of Family Guy over all of it, but American Dad is usually better than Family Guy after that.

The plots were a little more fun then, and it seems like they focused on the family's lives (and politics) a little less, and more on the humor. The show died when Brian started talking about nothing except politics and his atheism.

The best adult cartoon is still King Of The Hill. You don't need to be obnoxious and lewd to be a funny adult show.

Mr Rabbit

The show died when Brian started talking about nothing except politics and his atheism.

I wouldn't say it died then, but it did become frustrating to watch, and that is coming from someone with some similar political views to MacFarlane (Brian's opinions were mostly essentially MacFarlane's). I would say however they sorta went some way to fixing it by making Brian absolutely ridiculous at the same time, plus the episodes with him and stewie (Road to...) are brilliant in my opinion

Andreas

I do like both shows, but I feel that Family Guy isn't as funny as it used to be. It is the opposite with American Dad; it wasn't all that funny a few years back, in my opinion, but it got better over time.

BMW Sterling

I used to HATE American Dad but over the course of time it has gotten a lot better than family Guy. family Guy isn't as funny as it used to be back then. Now the jokes are kind of cheesy. American dad on the other hand is hilarious now. It's like Seth McFarlean ditched family guy and brought his comedy into the AD Series.

Arcadax

I want to say American Dad since I like Stan and that his boss is Patrick Stewart...but Roger then comes along and clogs every episode up with his drama-queen bullsh*t. It's not that he's ever not funny but he usually makes me cringe.

Surprisingly Family Guy has gotten better in the last season or so and Brain seems to be back (I didn't see the one where they killed him.) Seems like they finally hired some new writers...thank God, it got really bad for awhile.