How I Organized My Nail Polishes

Earlier this week, I asked readershow they organize their nail polish to get some input on how to organize mine! Surprisingly, the majority of these polishes are from awhile ago – I go in phases with nail polish; I buy bottle after bottle for a few weeks, but then nothing for months.

Anyway, I’ve always just stored them upright in plastic “shoe box” containers from The Container Store, but there’s never been any organization within that method beyond keeping them in one place! (Sometimes, I hate The Container Store, and sometimes, I love it…)

The stash was kind of growing out of control, so I figured it was time to think about actually organizing it with some method to the madness — I ended up going for by brand, and then by color. I don’t have enough polishes to start micro-organizing (e.g. further organizing by finish) quite yet. Even with what seemed like a healthy amount of polishes, I ended up mixing brands within the same container!

I love, love The Container Store’s Clear Storage Boxes – I use them for EVERYTHING. I have like 20 shoe-box sized containers, lots of the sweater boxes… They’re just really affordable, easy-to-use, and they all stack together, which is something I like. I like the shoe-box size for polishes because they’re just high enough to fit even the taller polishes (I think Dolce & Gabbana is the tallest brand I have), but not so tall that you feel like you’re wasting space.

One thing I noticed is that usually there is a little gap of space on the side, since the polishes don’t fit perfectly snug in them. I’m going to have to pick up a few rolls of non-skid material to lay underneath the polishes so they stay in place better. In the meanwhile, I put some bubblewrap in the gaps to keep everything in place ’til I get the non-skid stuff in. Otherwise, I’m satisfied with the solution!

P.S. – I know others enjoy Ikea’s Helmers, but I just found it so cheap-feeling, way too wobbly, and doesn’t really go with anything in my house, so that just wasn’t a viable option for me. (But trust, I love me some Ikea — a TON of my furniture is from there–huge fan of the Expedit series! This particular piece just wasn’t for me.)

Get Updates by Email

110 Comments

Discussion and debate are highly encouraged, and we expect community members to participate respectfully. When asking a question, please check the post above for information regarding pricing, availability, dupes, and availability, and keep discussion on-topic. If you have general feedback, an off-topic question, or need technical support, please contact us.

Comments that include advertisements, self-promotion, insults, etc. may be in violation of our comment policy and subject to deletion. Please see our comment policy for more information.

This is really good and very neat. I am one of those anal people that have to see what I owe to keep from rebuying it or similar products.

I have a room that is my woman cave where I store all my stuff and have these shelves from floor to ceiling where I stack stuff and can clearly see it. Being a professional MUA it helps if ever I have to have an assistant pack stuff for me.

That’s awesome 😉 In my dream home, I’d have a whole room that would be filled with my stuff (OK, the office is pretty much like 80% my stuff…) where I could me super SUPER organized and keep everything tidy and pretty, haha. Lucky you!

Wow, what a collection! I wouldn’t expect anything less from you though 😉

I have similar clear shoe boxes that I got from the dollar store here. Only 3 boxes full of polish for me though. I want to get a nail polish rack though to display nail polish and MAC pigments. I just don’t have a lot of wall space to put one up, so maybe one day when I move again. I put an old t-shirt or towel in the top of my boxes to prevent the polishes from moving around too much. It’s not pretty, but helps.

I don’t have a lot of wall space, and I don’t know if those racks would do it for me. I can do the cheap plastic boxes as something to hold me over, but my dream is beautiful, dark wood shelving in my own lil’ makeup/Christine room, haha. The bubble wrap ain’t pretty either, but it’s holding up for now. I’m hoping the non-skid stuff will work like a dream!

PS. Am not a fan of the Helmer either. It didn’t match my room and I didn’t feel like it would be functional for me. I’d be worried about the bottles banging against each other. (That is if I didn’t have another organizer within it.)

I have the cheap IKEA containers and LOVE them for almost everything…. my closet looks so neat since I have been using the containers and it’s easy to track stuff too 😉
I looooove your nailstash!! Completly blowes me away! I only have one container full (but hey, I’m working on it).

I love your pics – gorgeous polishes! I go back and forth on how I want to separate my collection, but I have them separated by color right now. I also use the plastic shoebox method! When the pinks started to overflow, I created a “light pinks” shoe box. I am ashamed to say how many polishes I own (or not…I’m a polish fanatic! It’s in my nature!), and how many untrieds there are in their own collection of shoe boxes! Thanks for sharing this!!

Weeellll…I used to be a DM for Sally’s and my very close friend/ nail tech owns a prof. nail supply, I actually have a couple of retail nail racks, I am shameless when it comes to polish, we are talking high 3 digit possibly 4 and counting…*sigh*. The hubby says I’m a polish hoarder, I say conniseur.

I haven’t bought them all, as some were definitely sent over for consideration for review. I’ve bought the majority of the China Glaze polishes (like 80%), MAC (like 90%), and OPI (100%). I think I paid for maybe half of the Chanel shades, and the rest were likely sent over as samples.

I haven’t bought them all, as some were definitely sent over for consideration for review. I’ve bought the majority of the China Glaze polishes (like 80%), MAC (like 90%), and OPI (100%). I think I paid for maybe half of the Chanel shades, and the rest were likely sent over as samples. HTH!

Don’t remind me, LOL! At year-end, I see how much I spend on makeup/beauty, and a little part of me dies inside!

I store them all on top of each other, next to a 2×2 Expedit furniture piece from Ikea.l Right now, 8 of them goes to just below it, so it works. I have a separate holdover container (same size) for polishes I get in after this point, ’cause I’m way too lazy to re-organize *every* time I get something new, so I tend to wait ’til there are several that need to be put into their places!

Serious nail polish envy going on over here! Lol. My nail polishes start of in a drawer and work their way all over the place. Currently there are some in drawers, some in the wardrobe, some on the bedside table, some in the glove compartment, some in the bathroom cabinet, some on the bedroom floor,… I could go on! 🙂

Oh My Christine, I thought I was bad… you collection is out of control, lol!
WOW, My collection is my VS bag with nail accessories etc. When I move into my new house, I’ll have more space to organize 🙂
Amazing collection!

On a side note, did you remove the makeup look sections in your forum, can’t find it 🙁

Go on, use me to show ‘IT GETS WORSE.’ lol! Show him my makeup collection! No worries, I know a few ladies who’ve got even larger collections than me – I show my boyfriend and tell him, “See!! I’m not alone!!”

And nah, I don’t use the majority. Here’s the thing – as a beauty blogger, most of the time, it’s about the latest and greatest. I tend to wear skittle nails half the time ’cause I’m testing out new shades and the like, lol. But hey, maybe one day I’ll have enough where I can remember and hunt around for dupes…. My goal!

Hi!
That’s an excellent way of organizing your nail polish! I’ve been using those office supply floppy plastic cases, and not only do they not fit, they’re unstable. I’m so glad you did this blog, but I just have one question. How many shoe boxes did you end up filling, and how do you store them? On top of each other? I can’t think of where I would put them all!

I ended up filling 8, and one thing I really, really like about this method is as I need to get more, it’s not a big deal ($1.49 per container) – and I don’t have to reinvent my storage solution to expand!

I do just store them on top of each other, in a corner, next to a piece of furniture that I use to store makeup stuff 🙂 8 of them stack about hip high, I think.

ohmigod, that collection is awesome, and the packaging is amazing. I have similar love/hate feelings about the container store. Right now my biggest storage nightmare is my closet though – I can never find anything!

Exactly, with the amount of makeup you and I have we need a pro making a costom made organizer like on stackable thing with all pink lipglosses in one thing, reds in the other and so on. I am seriously thinking of getting one soon like an interior designer. Whoa I dream too mcuh hah.

Looks great – I did something similar with mine but with bigger containers (which was a mistake as they are almost too heavy to carry lol). I had mine organized by brand, but recently I changed it to by color instead – it’s easier for me if I want to wear blue – pull out the blue bin and look through it to pick a shade, rather than have to go through each brand bin. 🙂

WOW! that is a lot. I only have a few, around 20, and it fits perfectly in a drawer standing up. Anyway, I think you should organize it in color scheme instead of brand. It would make it easier to search for specific colors. When I do my nails, I don’t think what brand I feel like wearing today, I just think what color I feel like today.

I like it by brand, because everything looks more uniform, since the bottles match. I also like to compare within a brand, and *then* compare against other brands myself 😀 Thanks for the suggestion, though!

OMG I could go and buy some nail polish at your place, probably you have a widest selection than many stores LOL I envy that LOL
You did a great job, really neat and easy to use now!!! I think I would only need 1 box LOL

how long do you find the polishes last for before they start getting goopy?? I only have one box full because I got rid of a lot that went too thick or sticky. I barely ever wear them, so I stopped buying them.

Holy cow, that’s a lot of nail polishes! I’m like you; I buy loads of polishes for a while, then none for quite some time. I used to go and have my nails done, but I’ve recently discovered the joy of doing my own!

wow thats a wonderful collection. I always loved owning many, but dint as they may get old. Could u tel me how long can we store nail polishes without getting dry, and do u change ur nail paint every week

You don’t understand how happy this makes me. I LOVE nail polish. Currently I’m at 80… Nothing compared to your collection! But I just ordered a wall rack, and I plan on organizing them that way! For those interested to see photos, check out my blog (mayachehade.wordpress.com) sometime early next week. 😀

If you don't see your comment yet, it's still in our moderation queue. We try our best to approve comments within 24 hours (and reply to them within 72 hours) but can sometimes get behind. Thank you for your patience!