Luuup VS Petmate Giant Litter Pan

This website features affiliate links. For purchases made via these links, we earn commissions that allow us to keep producing helpful content. To find out more click here. Close

With this Petmate Giant Litter Pan vs. Luuup comparison, you can decide between your 2 favorite litter boxes in minutes. View our side-by-side analysis below, discover their major strong and weak points, and find out which of them has received a higher total score from our experts.

Compare Features

Type

Open Litter Box

Design

Petmate Giant Litter Pan features a simple one-piece design that hides a lot of useful and convenient features. The biggest portion of the box is reserved for the actual litter area with two convenient storage compartments on the side. The comfort-grip rails enable users to lift the box and carry it around without any problems. The base is specifically designed for stability. The box currently only comes in beige.

Dimensions

Petmate Giant Litter Pan measures:

34.7" in length;

19.8" in width;

10" in height.

Installation Process

Petmate Giant Litter Pan does not require any setup whatsoever. Just pour your favorite litter into the designated area and the box is ready for use.

Scooping Proces

Petmate Giant Litter Pan requires manual scooping. The frequency of scooping largely depends on your choice of litter and the number of cats in your household.

Noise Level

Petmate Giant Litter Pan does not produce any noise.

Durability

Petmate Giant Litter Pan is made of heavy-duty pet-friendly plastic with a Microban layer for anti-microbial protection. It is a solid piece of sturdy plastic resistant to any types of structural damage, so it can last 5+ years.

Odor Control

Petmate Giant Litter Pan is coated with a layer of Microban, which destroys odor-inducing microorganisms.

Recommended For

Petmate Giant Litter Pan is primarily designed for larger cats. It can also be used by multiple smaller felines, but it is not recommended for kittens under 6 months of age and older or disabled cats.

Suitable For Multiple Cats

Litter Compatibility

Petmate Giant Litter Pan can work with any type/brand of litter.

Recommended Liners

Petmate Giant Litter Pan does not use liners.

Cleaning & Maintenance

Petmate Giant Litter Pan is extremely easy to clean. Depending on the number of cats in your household, you can thoroughly clean the box once a month with a soft cloth and some mild detergent. It can be fully immersed in water.

Training Considerations

Your cat should not have a problem with using Petmate Giant Litter Pan from day one.

Luuup is an attractively designed open-top litter box. It comes in only one color scheme: white-turquoise. It consists of 3 identical white sifting trays stacked together and features a detachable turquoise spill guard. No custom accessories are available.

Dimensions

Luuup litter box has been redesigned to accommodate cats of different sizes. It measures:

20.2 inches in length;

15.4 inches in width;

5.2 inches in height (7.5 inches with the spill guard).

Installation Process

Luuup litter box arrives assembled, with all 3 trays stacked together. The detachable spill guard is simply placed on top of the 3-tray structure. The trays feature smart stacking tabs that make restacking quick and simple. You can dismantle and assemble the litter box in seconds, making sure that the adjacent trays alternate, with the top tray matching the orientation of the bottom tray and the medium tray rotated by 180 degrees.

Scooping Proces

Luuup litter box is a lift-and-sift litter box, which means that there is no scooping. You simply lift the top tray, sift the clumps, and drop them into a garbage bag.

Noise Level

Luuup litter box emits zero noise.

Durability

Luuup litter box is made of durable, pet-safe materials. There are no elements that could get easily broken and the litter box can easily last for years.

Odor Control

Luuup features an anti-microbial surface that prevents microorganism growth. Thus, the unpleasant litter box odor is significantly reduced, but it is not fully eliminated due to the open-top design.

Recommended For

Luuup litter box is best suited for small and medium cats that are extroverted and used to open-top litter boxes. It may be a bit small for Maine Coone and other large cat breeds and its open-top design may not suit the needs of shy cats.

Suitable For Multiple Cats

Litter Compatibility

Luuup litter box works best with crystal and clumping litters. Recommended litters include Arm & Hammer Slide, World's Best Cat Litter, Mimi Litter, and Pretty Litter. Wheat, pine, and walnut-based litters should be avoided due to clumping and sticking issues.

Recommended Liners

Luuup litter box does not require the use of liners.

Cleaning & Maintenance

With Luuup, you need to sift the clumps once a day and dispose of the waste by tossing it into any garbage bag. After sifting, simply wipe the tray clean with a towel or tissue. From time to time, you can clean the trays more thoroughly with mild soap.

Training Considerations

With Luuup, no special training is required. Since Luuup is a modernized version of the classic sifting tray litter box, most cats get used to it right away. However, if your cat is particularly shy, the open-top design may be problematic, in which case an improvised hood or enclosure may be necessary.

Safety Considerations

Luuup litter box is completely safe to use. It is electronics-free, it contains no protruding elements that may cause harm, and it is made of pet-safe materials.

Luuup comes with a 30-day money-back guarantee. If you are not satisfied with the litter box, you can return the product within 30 days after the date of delivery. A 15% restoking fee may apply. Shipping and handling costs are non-refundable.

Warranty

Luuup litter box comes with a 30-day warranty. The warranty covers manufacturing defects and ends on the 30th day after the date of delivery.

Compare User Reviews

Submitted By Mia Black on 09/20/2018

This thing is a beast! My babies absolutely love it and there were no problems with transition whatsoever. The storage thingies on the bottom (I guess) aren’t really necessary imo, but ok you can put a scoop in there and other things your cats wouldn’t be tempted to play with. It’s also pretty big for our small place but it is what it is.

Submitted By Jenna Baylis on 07/20/2018

I couldn’t believe how big this thing really is. I mean, I read the measurements online, but seeing it in person is a whole different experience. My fat spoiled brat fits without any problems with a lot of room to spare. I like how I can just dump a bunch of litter inside and just scoop the clumps every day instead of having to replace everything every couple of days.

Luuup seemed like it would be a nightmare to clean but it’s really easy once you get your litter right. It really does reduce unpleasant smells but doesn’t contain them 100% if you’re using anything but top-quality crystals in our experience.

Submitted By Stephanie Jackson on 01/15/2019

The only place in our apartment where we can store this giant box was pretty open and exposed and our shy little girl had some issues using it. We had to improvise to give her a makeshift cover and that fixed the problem so keep that in mind if your furballs are as shy as our lyra.

Submitted By Sandra Harris on 10/28/2018

Luuup doesn’t mix well with any litter that doesn’t dry quickly. If you try to sift while the litter is still moist, it will stick to the grooves at the very bottom and make the whole thing much more complicated than it needs to be. Once I switched to a quick-dry brand though everything just fell right into place.

Submitted By Dorothy Thomas on 10/20/2018

Higher railing on this box almost completely eliminated litter tracking in our apartment. That said, our oldest cat had some troubles getting in and out so I wouldn’t recommend it for old or sick pets since they definitely won’t be able to use it as intended.

Winner

Luuup litter box boasts a unique 3-tray sifting system that lets you forget about scooping, clean the litter box more easily and quickly, and even save in litter. In this Luuup review, we explore how this popular litter box works, whether it is suitable for all cats, and most importantly, whether it lives up to cat guardians’ high expectations.

* All the prices on this website are subject to change without notice. While we put a great deal of effort into making sure that all the prices are accurate, one or more products may have outdated prices.
Please visit the specific product’s official website for exact prices.

TopLitterBoxes features honest reviews and comparisons of some of the best litter boxes you can find. As cat lovers ourselves, we know what cat owners want in litter boxes - and we know what can make both you and your furry friend happy. Combining our research and hands-on testing with verified information and experiences from our cat-loving readers allows us to objectively measure the strengths and weakness of every product featured on our site, which can help you choose the purrfect litter box for your cat(s).