The 10 Largest Auto Insurance Companies in the U.S.

The 10 largest auto insurance companies in the country represent more than two-thirds of the market share in the United States. Among top insurance companies, auto discounts such as multiple policy bundles and safe driver discounts reign supreme. We rounded up the largest U.S. auto insurers to give you a good idea of what’s available. To get the right rates and find the ideal policy for your needs, use a car insurance comparison tool or get quotes from multiple companies to make sure you’re getting the most competitive rates available.

State Farm

With more than 18% of the market share, State Farm is the largest automobile and home insurer in the U.S. It has more than 18,000 agents spread across its nationwide network and an extensive menu of more than 100 services, so it’s easy to see why so many drivers turn to State Farm for their insurance needs. This carrier offers multiple discounts on auto insurance, including:

Accident-free discounts

Anti-theft

Defensive driving course

Drive Safe and Save

Having a homeowners policy

During a 2016 State Farm review, J.D. Power ranked State Farm as above average in overall satisfaction. A.M. Best ranks it as superior in financial strength. On the downside, you have to go through a State Farm agent to get a policy, and the agents don’t offer any information about competitors who may provide policies with more favorable terms.

Geico

If you prefer managing your account online rather than in-person, Geico may be an excellent option for you. Geico offers some of the lowest prices on auto insurance in addition to simple online applications and account management tools. Some of the other features that make Geico stand out include optional coverage types such as mechanical breakdown, emergency roadside assistance and rental reimbursement.

During a 2016 Geico review, J.D. Power ranked Geico as average in overall satisfaction. Both A.M Best and Standard & Poor’s rate Geico highly for its financial strength.

Allstate

Although Allstate’s prices are on the higher end, the insurance company offers a solid menu of discounts that help shave up to 30% off premiums, including a premier discount that rewards you for driving for three years without accidents or violations with a 22% discount. This carrier offers a large selection of services ranging from home and auto insurance to life insurance, annuities and mutual funds.

J.D. Power’s 2016 Allstate review gave the company an average rating in overall satisfaction. It also earns a superior rating from A.M Best based on its financial strength.

Progressive

What sets Progressive apart from other insurers is its “Name Your Price” tool, which helps you find the policies that fit your budget. Progressive also has an online quote tool that gives you an estimate of the company’s rates along with the rates of some of its top competitors. With numerous integrated discounts, including multi-car and safe driver discounts, it’s easy to create a custom package with just the right amount of coverage and a premium that works for you.

In its 2016 Progressive review, J.D. Power ranked Progressive as average in overall satisfaction. A.M. Best gives Progressive an A+ for financial stability and strength.

USAA

USAA’s auto policies are created specifically for military families and include added features such as discounted long-term auto insurance. To be eligible, you need to qualify according to USAA’s criteria, which include being one of the following:

Active Military: A member of the Air Force, Navy, Army, Coast Guard or Marines

Former Military: An individual who separated or retired with an honorable discharge

Family: Un-remarried former spouses, widows and widowers of USAA members or children whose parent(s) had or have USAA property or auto insurance

Cadets and Midshipmen: Individuals enrolled at U.S. service academies, on ROTC scholarship or in advanced ROTC

In its USAA review, A.M. Best granted USAA an A++ for financial strength. This carrier also consistently earns high marks for customer satisfaction.

Farmers

Farmers offers 85 years of experience to go beyond simple, bare-bones legal coverage. If you’re interested in additional features for your auto insurance policy, Farmers Insurance has some great options. Optional add-ons include accident forgiveness, small-claim forgiveness and new car replacement. Some of the discounts that it offers include the company’s affinity discounts, which are open to professionals such as teachers, accountants, architects, doctors, engineers, lawyers, pilots, firefighters, scientists and police officers.

In its 2016 Farmers review, J.D. Power ranked Farmers as average in overall customer satisfaction. A.M Best gives it an excellent rating based on the company’s financial strength.

Liberty Mutual

Liberty Mutual includes some value-added extras in its auto policies, which makes this company a smart option if you’re looking for these benefits. Some of the added benefits of a Liberty Mutual auto insurance policy include accident forgiveness after spending five years violation- and accident-free, a lifetime repair guarantee and 24-hour roadside assistance.

A 2016 Liberty Mutual Review by J.D. Power ranked the company as average in overall customer satisfaction. A.M Best gives it an excellent rating based on the company’s financial strength.

Nationwide

Nationwide carries everything from auto and home insurance to pet and identify theft insurance and financial services, which makes this company ideal as a one-stop shop if you need several types of policies. Where Nationwide sets itself apart is with some of its add-ons, including the vanishing deductible that rewards you for every year you drive without an incident by reducing your deductible.

American Family

American Family is the ninth-largest auto insurance company in the United States, and it’s well regarded for its low prices and large menu of services. In addition to auto insurance, you can get homeowners, boat, condo, farm, business or ranch insurance along with financial products such as investments and retirement accounts.

In American Family reviews, both J.D. Power and Consumer Reports give American Family excellent ratings for claims satisfaction. A.M Best ranks the insurance carrier as having excellent financial strength.

Travelers

Travelers is a big name in the insurance game, with a high profile and a history that dates back to 1864. In addition to being the 10th largest auto insurance provider in the country, Travelers is also the sixth largest homeowners insurance carrier. The company’s website is simple to use, and the insurer offers a variety of discounts. Travelers offers an in-person insurance experience and sells auto insurance coverage through a network of 13,000 agents located across the country.

A 2016 Travelers review from J.D. Power reveals average overall customer satisfaction. A.M Best ranks it as having superior financial strength.

You can trust that we maintain strict editorial integrity in our writing and assessments;
however, we receive compensation when you click on links to products from our partners and get approved.

Published September 6, 2016

Caryn Anderson combines extensive behind-the-scenes writing experience with her passion for all things food, fashion and finance. Anderson honed her craft while earning her B.S in Communication Studies from New York University.

Protect Credit

The credit card and loan offers that appear on this site are from companies
from which this site receives compensation. This compensation may impact how
and where products appear on this site (including, for example, the order in
which they appear). This site does not show all credit card or loan offers available
in the marketplace. Credit Sesame is an independent comparison service provider.
Reasonable efforts have been made to maintain accurate information throughout our
website, mobile apps, and communication methods; however, all information is presented
without warranty or guarantee. All images and trademarks are the property of their
respective owners.