to be quite honest, i didn't like the Donner too much. its design was very loopy and curvy, pretty similar to the Lois and Clark - however, the they used in STM was, indeed, better than the merchandise that they created for the promotion of the film. their promotional , even though had a very strong resemblance from the comics, was very scrunched together.

__________________

For this is the love of God, that we keep his commandments: and His commandments are not burdensome.

It's the benefit of hindsight. I think flared jeans, open-necked shirts and headbands are incredibly cheesy now, but at one point in the 70s they were considered ultra fashionable. I don't dislike the original 'S' symbol but I agree that it now looks a little cheesy compared to newer ones, even the Superman Returns one. It doesn't make it a bad thing; it's just aged and looks very cartoonish next to more modern versions.

As for the new MOS crest, I love it. It retains the fluid lines of the original 'S' symbol from years ago, but adds much more texture, detail and layers. It's the first Superman crest I've seen which (in MY opinion ) is believable as a family crest, and not just a big 'S' which writers are trying to come up with a history or reason for Superman having it.

The very rich red/gold used in it are also less vibrant than the normal bright red/yellow used in the comics, and look more regal - which reinforces the whole effect.

I like the logo on the suit, but I never understood the love for this version of the logo. The curvy lines seem random.

I like the logo on the suit, but I never understood the love for this version of the logo. The curvy lines seem random.

I think they're just there to add detail and texture and make it more crest-like. Otherwise it's yet another variation of the 'S' we've gotten all these years, with a slightly different font.

Compare it to the SR 'S', which is the most recent modern version used in a film. I don't think anyone could say the MOS version doesn't look more like a family crest, and this is largely down to the detailing on it rather than the curves of the S or the font used.

Your analogy is flawed. The classic \S/ is not a passing trend like clothing styles. It's an icon the world over. Even when new versions of the \S/ are created, the original, CLASSIC shield continues to be used in the bulk of merchandising.

The New 52 shield won't be used in such a widespread manner, nor will this MOS shield.

Perhaps it's a flawed analogy, but my point still stands. Just as there are progressions in fashion and certain things fall out of taste, so too are there progressions in artwork. Comics now are much more detailed, richly illustrated and vivid. The original Superman logo (as pictured below) is reminiscent of older artwork, not more modern.

I totally agree that it's iconic the world over. However, that doesn't change the fact that I still think it looks quite dated now in terms of artwork and style. The MOS logo is the flipside, showing a more modern approach. It's just my opinion, I'm sure there are plenty who will disagree.

I agree also that the new logos probably won't be used in such a widespread manner, but I think that's more to do with a natural reluctance to change any global brand (especially one which is one of the most recognisable icons on Earth) rather than the new logo somehow being inferior in any way.

At the end of the day, at least the new logos are fairly faithful to the original - they could have easily butchered the iconic 'S. Remember this version?

to be quite honest, i didn't like the Donner too much. its design was very loopy and curvy, pretty similar to the Lois and Clark - however, the they used in STM was, indeed, better than the merchandise that they created for the promotion of the film. their promotional , even though had a very strong resemblance from the comics, was very scrunched together.

Agreed. The promo for STM was really funny looking. I remember being irked by that even as a kid.

The same could be said for my favorite -- Superman Returns. I feel the promo shield is little too curvy where the costume shield has softer lines, particularly where the "S" meets the border.

I love the variety of S-shields we've seen over the years, and I really love the Man of Steel version. Compared to the Returns shield (the logo/poster version), it makes me like that one less. Side-by-side, the Returns version looks chunky and stiff, whereas the Man of Steel shield looks more elegant, like it naturally flows better from start-to-end of the letter.

See my response to Project862006.
See my response to Project862006 and WoodyRom.

You have now received a 2 months probation.

The last time you received a probation, it was under your original name...you then created a new name (this one) and posted with it while your original name was serving probation....and, as per the rules in our FAQ, that name was banned and this name was put on an extended probation. So....feel perfectly free to ignore the rules and create another new name and post with it...because as per the FAQ, then you any and all names you make will be permabanned on sight.

I think it looks very cool. The added design marks on the obliques aren't too distracting, and the belt looks very alien and cool. Personally I find the added Aquaman pattern on the shield is unnecessary, and I think the texture and design found on the shield in the promo image (and at the end of the trailer) would look better. I do wish the reds and yellows were more vibrant (especially the yellow in the \S/), but at least the S isn't that shade of Superman Returns red that it's been in other photos.