-Unplugged Cable Modem/Battery (Battery is for the phone line) and Router1 then waited 30sec or so and powered Cable Modem (Waited for Lights to all be green) and then plugged Enthernet Cable to WAN Port on Router1. Disable SPI Firewall, UPnP, NAT is enabled and then setup Wireless with WPA2 with Channel 6 selected. once i had Internet Access i went down stairs i plugged a Enthernet cable to port3 to Router2 and set it up. i disabled Wireless, SPI Firewall and set MTU to 1492 and same goes for Router1. i then disbaled DHCP and then i was up and go connected Lol

Also, Router2 is doing NAT routing? Router 1 is set up as a switch? So you have Cable Modem --> Router(Routing Disabled/Only Switching) --> Router2 (Routing + Switching)? I'd suggest swapping Router 1 and Router 2 as the closer you move your NAT to your ISP device the better performance you will get internally for your network (Routers break up broadcast domains).

** Edit #2 **

regarding ping times, you'd be lucky to get a ping of 80 to 110 for a gaming server.. 120+ seems to be the norm unless your ISP is awesome.. check your ping times between local computers for a comparison.

And you can hook up one computer to the modem without any of your networking equipment. That will help you determine if you problem is with your ISP or is related to your networking equipment.

If all is fine with just one computer connected...
Cheap consumer networking equipment (routers, etc) can be flakey. Maybe you can obtain another router (borrow from a friend? Buy?) for testing.

If you can prove that you have problems with just a computer hooked up to the modem it will be easier to prove to your ISP. Otherwise they will just come out and blame your networking equipment so they can get to their next service call.