The Resurrection of Hakimullah Mehsud

According to a senior unnamed official from Pakistan’s Inter-Services Intelligence yesterday, Tehreek-e-Taliban leader Hakimullah Mehsud is actually alive. According to the Guardian, “Mehsud was reported to have died in a CIA drone strike in South Waziristan in January but, although Pakistan’s interior minister claimed he had been killed, the death was never confirmed by either U.S. or Pakistani intelligence.” Yesterday, the anonymous official told reporters he had seen video footage of the missile attack on Mehsud “but other intelligence had since confirmed the insurgent leader survived.” He noted, “He is alive. He had some wounds but he is basically OK.” Dawn quoted him stating further, “It was just a miracle that only one person escaped that attack, and he was Hakimullah Mehsud. Miracles do happen.”

Reuters also quoted the ISI official, who emphasized, “Initially, our intelligence in the field suggested that he was killed from the wounds he sustained in the strike but we have made checks and our intelligence has now concluded that he was wounded, not dead. It’s all based on intelligence.”

Seriously, am I taking crazy pills here? Back in January, reports of Hakimullah’s death, though not officially confirmed, were legitimized by numerous sources. For example, a local government official, citing paramilitary sources, told CNN that Mehsud was seriously injured and subsequently moved to the Orakzai region, where he died and was buried more than a week ago, a story that was then confirmed by Pakistan’s state-run television, PTV. And, although the Taliban never confirmed Hakimullah’s death (they did, in comparison, eventually confirm Baitullah‘s death), news agencies did report that at least three other Taliban sources and a government official confirmed the report, though these sources differed when he died.

What’s interesting is that even though there was a degree of certainty in past media reports about Hakimullah’s death, news agencies are now all pointing to why this could never have been true. According to numerous outlets, including Dawn and BBC News, the reasons were: (1) There was no leadership challenge to replace Hakimullah, and (2) there was no martyrdom video or official announcement of his death posted on jihadi websites or released to media outlets (a cell phone video of Baitullah’s body, in comparison, was aired on Pakistani television).

Unnamed ISI officials now indicate Hakimullah has become less effective in the hierarchy of the Pakistani Taliban, and that Waliur Rehman (who was reportedly Hakimullah’s rival in the leadership dispute following Baitullah’s death) and Qari Hussain (the suicide bomber recruiter) are now the most powerful commanders.

The story is so convoluted that it lends itself to a number of questions: First, if previous intelligence pointed to Hakimullah’s death, how can we have any faith that today’s intelligence indicating he’s alive is any better? Anonymous officials throwing around statements like, “Miracles do happen” and “It’s all based on intelligence,” do nothing but undermine the state apparatus providing this so-called intelligence. Given that getting information independently from FATA is virtually impossible and almost always devolves into a he said-(s)he said debate, media agencies can only speculate on the credibility of the stories they receive. Finally, if Hakimullah’s role is now irrelevant within the TTP command, what good does it do to confirm that he is alive three months later? Why now?

Developments like these only further expose how little we know about this entire situation, and that deaths of top leaders don’t necessarily impact the overarching TTP command. At the end of the day, though, we should treat every revelation with cautious skepticism, remembering that we still have the ability to reason, rationalize, and question. Even if it’s only speculation, we don’t have to swallow everything with doe-eyed naivete.

Like this:

LikeLoading...

Related

9 Responses

[…] claimed he had been killed, the death was never confirmed by […] Read more at: CHUP! – Changing Up Pakistan cia drone, cnn, crazy pills, death news, getty image, government official, insurgent leader, […]

OMG! I think that it’s not a good news that leader of TTP whose agenda is just to spread unrest in Pakistan is still alive. I think that figures behind the news of his death should be penalized as such factors spread false news just for their interest.

I think it’s irrelevant whether Hakimullah is dead or alive – behind him are another 30 Taliban leaders the same if not worse than him, all with the same agenda. Plus, if media reports are true (who knows at this point), if he IS alive he isn’t really in power anymore.

I thought the Taliban are good. Oh wait thats the Afghan Taliban. I hope Pakistanis condemn Taliban without discrimination. What TTP did to Pakistan, the Taliban did to Afghans for years. Afghan case was even worse- They were being ruled by these brutes. And, Pakistani establishment is responsible for supporting these maniacs.

I dont believe in the concept of Karma ,but if I did, this would be a damn good example of it working- ‘You get what you did to others’.

There is no evidence (not even a shred), pakistan army and ISI have entirely abandoned the idea of sponsoring terrorism on civilians in India and Afghanistan. They are still preserving the “assets”, free to run terrorist training camps, etc.

Paks generally give lip service, look the other way or smugly say address the “root causes of terrorism” as long as the victims are elsewhere and not in Lahore or Islamabad.

That’s why paks need more of the terrorism medicine. Good to know TTP chief is alive!.

Although reports yet need to be confirmed but this is indeed not a good news. This should not signify Pak army’s operation as a failure, this might be a minor setback but we should believe that the Pak army will overcome it.

The return Hakeemullah from dead is indeed perturbing! But Kalsoom before questioning the effectiveness of Intelligence we must also note that Hakeemullah was silent for the last three months which could mean that his injuries were crucial. Also most of the intelligence leaks comes from the Taliban who had reported that a succession meeting was in progress.
The intelligence agencies in Pakistan need to work in cooperation rather than competing, agencies such as ISI, MI or IB should have sharing mechanism.