Combine all the number, intangibles, playoff clutchness, the fact Troy even played some defense and choose, if you like...

For me I love both to the max but I'm going to take Troy. While WW may be the best player to ever play the slot I just loved troy's versatility and being able to do more things. Also for whatever reason I loved that Troy made alot of plays outside the numbers and vertically.

Troy Brown , hands down! You didnt include his Punt returns total which EAT Wes' numbers alive and also, Wes got more opptys on a one dimensional team with no Defense and no Run game. Troy put up 101 catches when it wasnt normal for slot Wrs to do so and also played full season as an outside WR getting 97 catches, something Wes coulnt do IMO.

Troy Brown is an all-time favourite. The numbers say otherwise, but Troy was the better Partiot to me. Take nothing away from Wes, but Troy did it all.

Really though it's just the recieving numbers that dictate WW may have had a better career. It's my fault for not including kick and punt return stats which I know Troy was awesome at. I don't want anyone thinking I'm knocking Wes cause that's absolutely not my intention.. Wes is a Patriot Hof'er...

But, Troy was big in big games and played with lesser talent around him in a more difficult era for WRs to shake free in coverage.

Wes has had it easier in an offensive based era, which is why he does 120 receptions every year.

Give me Troy, though. My favorite Pats player of all time, actually.

Troy is my favorite Pats player of all time as well and that goes back quite awhile LOL.

BTW, I did watch the re-run of the Pats/Colts 2004 playoff game the other night and Troy was big in that game and was as usual Mr. Reliable in crunch time. I was also re-impressed at just how good our defense was back then.

Troy browns punt return beat Pittsburgh in the playoffs in 2001. Troy bown caught the catch that gave vinitari the game winner in the sb. I hope to see Wes in the pts HOF Maybe the donkeys won't want to py him 6 m next year and he will be back lol.