There was a young woman with a coupon in front of me in line and I had this dilemma. Should I tell her how many calories are in the drink she was buying? How would I phrase it?

“Excuse me, miss, put the drink down. See my cape? I am Snack Girl and that drink is 530 calories!!!!”

Then I remembered that she hadn’t clicked on me, so I kept my big mouth shut.

When I first wrote about the Frappé, I was blown away by its 560 calorie label see: 560 Calories For Your Rapid Consumption From McDonald's. McDonald’s started McCafé to compete with Starbucks and the Frappé is the obvious competitor to the Starbucks Frappuccino. A 12 ounce (Tall) Cookie Crumble Frappuccino is a mere 310 calories at Starbucks.

I am actually recommending the 12 ounce Cookie Crumble Frappuccino as a healthier choice. You save 220 calories by choosing the same size drink at Starbucks.

While I am at it, a 12 ounce can of Coke is a better choice at just 140 calories. I'm sure I can come up with tons of suggestions that are still really unhealthy that are STILL healthier than the McD's Frappé.

We can all agree that this drink is a treat wherever we get it. If you like these kind of drinks, I have two truly healthier suggestions:

Thanks for the info.... After the last couple of years of dieting and exercise, I have not the slightest interest in even trying one, coupon or not!

Kristinon July 17, 2012

I received a coupon for a free one & threw it in the trash! 530 calories is wayyyyyy too much for a drink.

Shanaeon July 17, 2012

Food should be priced according to how many calories it contains. What an eye opener that would be!

Sarahon July 17, 2012

O my goodness!Thanks so much for that info on the frappes.I would like to also let people know about the burgers and fries and bread haven't molded or rotted yet. A group my son is in has been doing an experiment since Jan 17 2012!

carollon July 17, 2012

I am so glad I am not a coffee lover. I am tea junkie, though. It sure seems like the world of tea hasn't been abused yet, unless you count the chai tea latte at Starbuck's which is my favorite beverage treat of all! I can get a grande for 310 calories or a tall for 260 and that's if i get 2% milk in it. On a separate note, I'm with @Denise Ryan - I'd love to hear your research on the Shakeology craze, too. I've tried it. The chocolate is just plain gross, but the tropical is not bad. Kinda gritty. Is the nutrition in it worth the price? Or can I get it in a multivitamin or other supplement to add to my homemade smoothie for a fraction of the price? I really don't think it's worth it but I'd love to hear what you find out if you're ready to do some homework for us!

Angie M.on July 17, 2012

I would also like to know your take on Shakeology. I keep thinking that there is a cheaper way to do a homemade version.

My teeth hurt just thinking about these drinks. I have digestive problems anyway so drinking one of these wouldn't do much for that plus the sweet factor. If I get anything cold it's at Starbucks decaf with skim milk and fat free vanilla. That's about as sweet as I can go.

Noreenon July 17, 2012

Making a protein shake at home is a great alternative and you know exactly what's in it. Fresh fruit, whole grain, fiber, protein and they are delicious! You still have to carefully measure what you're putting in there and use this as a meal replacement vs a side or the calories can add up quickly. Favao protein is a good, clean protein source they offer 12 different recipes from 160 to 330 calories depending on milk/water, type of fruit, type of cereal/grain you are using. cpearce1010@gmail.com

Charleneon July 17, 2012

Caroll, I know the hamburgers aren't good for us. However, that test is not totally accurate when a burger is digested. The acid in our stomachs would help break it down. When you have it just sitting there, there is nothing to break it down. Also, we chew it and make the pieces smaller to digest. You're talking about it being whole just sitting with no other factors. In science terms, there are other variables that cause different results when we eat them.

Susanon July 17, 2012

@Ken

"This works for me: Whenever I pass by these places, I say to myself: Poison. I'm not interested in digesting poison."

I do the same exact thing when I'm flipping through ads, coupons, looking at fast-food/drink billboards, bagged/boxed/canned stuff in the grocery store, etc., but I use the word "garbage".

Andy Don July 17, 2012

@ Susan / Caroll But if you made some home made rolls and burgers and left them out or even in the fridge since Jan they would be growing - what are people putting in their bodies?

Charleneon July 17, 2012

I love Frappaccinos from Starbuck's. Thankfully, I don't live anywhere near one and if I find myself near one, I'm a cheapskate so I don't want to spend $4 on a drink. I consider them to be treats. I may search one out though if I had a coupon. However, I would never go to a McDonald's, coupon or not. I don't like what they stand for - subquality "food". Starbuck's is a coffee place and they sell coffee, makes sense. McDonald's sells junk food. No thank you.

Janeton July 17, 2012

I have quite the Starbucks dilemma quite often. See, the way teenagers see it, when a Starbucks opens in a small boring town like ours, it's the ultimate hang out spot. So, very often, when I go there I try so, so hard to get something not as bad as a medium caramel frappuccino with 2% milk and 5 shots of coffee instead of 3.......you can see that I've gotten this far too many times. Quite frankly, after drinking it I do feel sick. Recently I've been getting an iced tea black lemonade, but I'm afraid to even look up the nutrition info for that either. I wish Starbucks hadn't opened in my town, or it wasn't so walkably close. <3 you Snack-girl

Rachel "Bubbles"on July 17, 2012

Unbelievable! I used to go every morning that I could to order a Large Caramel Frappe. I would seriously get mad if my morning wasn't going well enough for me to stop. I was very addicted to them. When I started PointsPlus I stopped them cold turkey! Once I finally got that out of my system I have not gotten another, not even for a snack. It is not worth sliding back down that slippery slope!

Melissaon July 17, 2012

Just wanted to respond to Denise above (re: Shakeology). Something you make at home (a shake or a smoothie) is always a better choice. The reason is because you can control what goes into it. If you're making a smoothie with real fruit and yogurt (and maybe some raw honey) you are getting a final product made without chemicals and ingredients made in a lab. Shakeology is very expensive. It's just always seemed like a scam or pyramid scheme to me (the way it is sold).