This five-hour serial looks at the life of Francis Percy Toplis, who on 6
June 1920, at the age of 23, was shot and killed, ending a manhunt which had
seen him labelled in the press as 'Britain's most wanted man'. The story begins
in sepia, almost in the style of a newsreel reconstruction, bringing together
dramatic and violent highlights from Toplis's final days before switching to
colour, aesthetically signalling a more subjective mode. As the picaresque story
of his various adventures unfolds, we are left in little doubt that Toplis was a
victim of his environment. For the most part this never feels like special
pleading, though a maudlin late scene between Toplis and his drunk and
half-blind mother eventually descends into bathos.

Paul McGann exudes charisma in the title role as he cheerfully cocks a snook
at authority and exposes the petty hypocrisies of the upper classes. He is just
as good displaying Toplis's despair and apathy as the story reaches its bitter
conclusion, filling in the blanks behind what, belatedly, we now see was a very
tendentious opening montage.

The Monocled Mutineer was a highly controversial broadcast. Vilified in
conservative publications for allegedly distorting historical facts (the Daily
Mail called it "a tissue of lies"), it was held as an example to bolster the
Thatcher government's ongoing complaint of leftwing bias at the BBC. It even led
to questions being asked in the House of Lords, with Lord Orr-Ewing arguing that
"it appears that... the BBC drama department are at pains to intertwine truth
with falsehood as inseparably as possible." The polemics mainly raged over
Toplis's role in the mutiny at Etaples, Northern France, in September 1917, when
thousands of soldiers at the training camp revolted. Many, in fact, believe that
Toplis was not even there at the time but was actually with his unit in Bombay.
Criticism was further fuelled when Julian Putkowski, the programme's historical
adviser, gave interviews distancing himself from the finished product.

Irrespective of the debates over historical accuracy, Alan Bleasdale's
scripts remain completely credible as drama for their incisive and masterful
dissection of working-class exploitation and of the class-based issues
underlying the Etaples mutiny. Toplis's officer disguise, with its trademark
golden monocle, crystallises to great dramatic effect the twinning of the
depictions of trench and class warfare, making the serial, even decades after
its initial broadcast, consistently thought-provoking and compelling
throughout.