John Steinbeck lawsuit: Judges to hear appeal over control of author's classic works

John Steinbeck, right, admires a prize-winning poster made by his son, Thomas Steinbeck, in 1963.(Photo: AP)

ANCHORAGE, Alaska (AP) — Another chapter is set to play out this week in a decades-old family dispute over control of the classic works by author John Steinbeck.

A three-judge panel of the Ninth U.S. Circuit Court of Appeals will be in Alaska's largest city on Tuesday to hear arguments in an appeal by the estate of Steinbeck's late son, Thomas Steinbeck, over a 2017 jury verdict in California.

In that case, a federal jury awarded the author's stepdaughter, Waverly Scott Kaffaga, more than $13 million in a lawsuit claiming Steinbeck's son and daughter-in-law, Gail Steinbeck, impeded film adaptations of the iconic works.

It was up to the Los Angeles jury to decide if Thomas and Gail Steinbeck interfered with deals and should pay up. Kaffaga had sued her stepbrother, his widow, Gail, and their company.

Attorney Matthew Dowd, representing the Thomas Steinbeck estate, said part of the appeal contends the 1983 agreement was in violation of a 1976 change to copyright law that gave artists or their blood relatives the right to terminate copyright deals. The appeal also disputes the award handed up by the jury, maintaining it was not supported by "substantial evidence."

Kaffaga — executor for the estate of her mother, Elaine Steinbeck, the author's widow and third wife — had alleged that long-running litigation over the author's estate prevented her from making the most of his copyrights at a time when marquee names such as Steven Spielberg and Jennifer Lawrence were interested in bringing masterpieces "The Grapes of Wrath" and "East of Eden" back to the screen. She said the deals instead fell apart over the years.

Kaffaga had contended Thomas Steinbeck secretly signed a $650,000 deal with DreamWorks to be an executive producer on a film remake of "The Grapes of Wrath," the Pulitzer Prize-winning novel that starred Henry Fonda on the silver screen and won two Oscars. She also said Gail Steinbeck learned of projects and threatened moviemakers, saying she and her husband had legal rights to the work.

Dowd said Thomas Steinbeck, who died in 2016, conveyed his intention to exercise those rights, prompting Kaffaga to claim the contract breach. He said Steinbeck was fully within his right to do so, under the 1976 "termination rights" clause.

"The problem with the 1983 agreement is that it violates the statute by basically binding up, or restricting, Thom's ability to exercise his termination rights for 'The Grapes of Wrath,'" Dowd told The Associated Press. Gail Steinbeck was not allowed to fully address the issue in court, he said.

In the same case, a judge earlier ruled the couple breached a contract between Kaffaga's late mother and Thomas Steinbeck and his late brother, John Steinbeck IV. The brothers' mother was the author's second wife, Gwyndolyn Conger.

"We would like the court to rule that the 1983 Agreement violates the statute and therefore cannot prevent the heirs from exercising their termination rights," Dowd said. "Relatedly, we are asking for a new trial and that the damages awards be vacated because they are too speculative and there is no legal basis for awarding punitive damages under California law."

John Steinbeck, pictured here, won the 1962 Nobel prize in literature for his novel "The Grapes of Wrath."(Photo: AP)

In a brief to the appeal, however, Kohlmann and another attorney say multiple courts have already upheld the agreement as binding and valid. The agreement, which resolved earlier litigation, gives Elaine Steinbeck's estate the "exclusive power and authority to control the exploitation and termination" of some of Steinbeck's works in exchange for the sons getting a larger share of domestic royalties, according to the attorneys.

"Yet, Appellants again seek to hijack this lawsuit and use it as a mechanism to relitigate the issue of the validity of the 1983 agreement by arguing that it is an 'agreement to the contrary' under the Copyright Act," they wrote. "The District Court properly excluded such argument, evidence, and testimony that sought to undermine the holdings of multiple courts confirming the validity of the 1983 agreement."

The lawsuit followed a decades-long dispute and litigation between Thomas Steinbeck and Kaffaga's mother over control of the author's works.

Thomas Steinbeck had lost most rounds in court, including a lawsuit he and the daughter of his late brother, John Steinbeck IV, brought that spurred Kaffaga to countersue in the case being appealed.

Gail Steinbeck's previous attorney, Matthew Berger, had argued Kaffaga's claim had no merit and she wasn't entitled to any damages because most movies optioned are never made and that estimated revenue from unproduced projects was speculation.

Berger also said Gail Steinbeck never intentionally interfered in deals she and her husband would have benefited from and that would have served their interest promoting the Nobel Prize winner's legacy.

Posted!

A link has been posted to your Facebook feed.

Writers go about their craft in private. But many have led fascinating lives, and have provided the inspiration for some of our favorite films. Here is a box-office gallery, beginning with Gwyneth Paltrow as tragic poet Sylvia Plath in 2003's 'Sylvia.' Focus Features

In 2017's 'The Man Who Invented Christmas' Dan Stevens (left, with actor Christopher Plummer) portrays author Charles Dickens. The film tells the story of the creation of his classic 'A Christmas Carol.' Kerry Brown

The film, based on the book 'The Invisible Woman' by Claire Tomalin, tells the story of the love affair between Dickens and actress Nelly Ternan, played by Felicity Jones. David Appleby, Sony Pictures Classics

Jennifer Jason Leigh starred as poet Dorothy Parker in 1994's 'Mrs. Parker and the Vicious Cicle.' The film told the story of the 'Algonquin Round Table,' the group of writers, critics and artists who met weekly at Manhattan's Algonquin Hotel during the 1920s. Joyce Rudolph

Dorothy Parker was a prolific poet, short story writer, critic and satirist. Among her better known quotes are "Men don't make passes at girls who wear glasses" and "This is not a novel to be tossed aside lightly. It should be thrown with great force." AP

In the 2012 film 'On the Road' Garrett Hedlund (pictured, right) portrayed Sal Paradise, a character loosely based on the author Jack Kerouac, who wrote the novel of the same name that the film is based on. Gregory Smith/IFC

In 'Julie & Julia' (2009) Amy Adams stars as Julie Powell, author of the book 'Julie & Julia: 365 Days, 524 Recipes, 1 Tiny Apartment Kitchen,' based on her blog, the Julie/Julia Project that chronicled her journey in cooking all the recipes in Julia Child's famous 'Mastering the Art of French Cooking.' Jonathan Wenk/Columbia Pictures

1987's 'Prick Up Your Ears' is a film about the life and death of British playwright Joe Orton, played by Gary Oldman (left). Alfred Molina co-stars as Orton's lover, actor and writer Kenneth Halliwell. Metro-Goldwyn-Mayer Studios

2007's 'Becoming Jane' features Anne Hathaway as author Jane Austen. The film, partly based on the book 'Becoming Jane Austen' by Jon Hunter Spence, depicts the early life of the English author. AP/Miramax

Truman Capote, author of 'Breakfast at Tiffany's' and 'Other Voices, Other Rooms' was the subject of two films in 2006. Both focused on the time in the author's life when he researched and wrote his non-fiction best seller 'In Cold Blood.' Hulton Archive/Getty Images

Gwyneth Paltrow and Joseph Fiennes star in 1998's 'Shakespeare in Love.' The romantic comedy follows a young Shakespeare during an imaginary love affair. The movie won multiple Oscars, including best picture. LAURIE SPARHAM, MIRAMAX FILMS

Playing a young Ernest Hemingway, actor Chris O'Donnell is assisted by actress Sandra Bullock, playing the role of American nurse Agnes von Kurowsky in a scene from 1996's 'In Love and War.' Alex Bailey/AP

Actor Giovanni Ribisi in a scene from 2015's 'Papa Hemingway in Cuba.' The biopic portrays the budding friendship between Hemingway, played by Adrian Sparks, and a young journalist, played by Ribisi, in 1959 Cuba. Ramon Espinosa/AP

Helen Mirren stars as Ayn Rand and Eric Stoltz as Nathaniel Branden in 'The Passion of Ayn Rand.' The film, based on the book of the same name, is a biography of the author of 'Atlas Shrugged' and 'The Fountainhead.' Michael Gibson/Showtime

Meryl Streep stars as author Susan Orlean in 2002's 'Adaptation.' The film is based on Orlean's non-fiction book 'The Orchid Thief.' It follows screenwriter Charlie Kaufman's struggle to adapt the book into a film. Columbia Pictures

Mathieu Amalric, right, and Max Von Sydow appear in a scene from 'The Diving Bell and the Butterfly.' The film follows the true story of Elle editor Jean-Dominique Bauby after he suffers a stroke and must learn to live while only communicating through his left eye. It is based on Bauby's memoir. Miramax Films, AP

Kate Winslet as British writer Iris Murdoch in 2001's 'Iris.' Winslet portrays the author in her younger years in the film about Murdoch's life long romance with her husband John Bayley. Clive Coote/Miramax