Not all pranksters feel this way, however. In fact, Gatto’s co-host James Murray is up for the April 1st challenge. “Really, it’s the perfect day to do a prank because you don’t have to apologize to anyone,” Murray argued. “I wish we could do every episode on that day.”

Our take away from this debate is that being a professional prankster would be pretty awesome. Although we suspect the only way to go pro in pranks is to first master April Fools’ Day, warts and all. Get out your fake spiders and novelty vomit, folks.