The new British crime series, Broadchurch, has all the pathos, intelligence, drama and twists that mystery fans have come to expect from the genre, but it also unites two popular Doctor Who stars for the very first time.

Arthur Darvill just came off a successful run on Doctor Who as beloved companion Rory Williams and co-star David Tennant was one of the most beloved Doctors in the show’s history. So, naturally, their meeting had to be an auspicious occasion…or was it?

Ever since Matt Smith suddenly announced his departure from Doctor Who, fans have been chomping at the bit to find out who will be his replacement. We spoke to former Doctor Who star Arthur Darvill to find out whom he thinks could wield the Sonic Screwdriver next and also to address some of those pesky 50th Anniversary rumors about Amy and Rory…