Room 1: Godric (Knife, Key to the Conservatory, Smoking Pipe) a regular Guest killed on day 5Room 2: mac5155 (revolver, ket to the library, fedora) a regular guest was Killed on Day 2.Room 3: thehockeyguru (Key to the Study, Wrench, Bow Tie) a regular guest was Killed on Night 2 in the Conservatory with a Revolver, next to a Smoking Pipe.Room 4: the errey i breatheRoom 5: LITT (Key to the Kitchen, lead pipe, wrist band), a regular guest killed on Night 6 with a revolver, in the conservatory, amid a puff of smoke from a smoking pipeRoom 6: MWB (Key to the Billiard room, Revolver, Smoking Pipe) a regular guest was killed on Night 3 in the Kitchen with a Wrench, holding a bow tie.Room 7: relantel (Key to the Library, Wrench, Sunglasses) a regular guest was killed on Day 3.Room 8: GauchoRoom 9: ExPatriatePen (Key to Conservatory, Rope, Wrist Band), a regular guest, was killed on Night 4 in the Library with a knife, and a bow tie lay nearby in a pool of blood.Room 10: Rylan (Lead Pipe, Study, Bow Tie) a regular guest Killed on Night 5 in the Conservatory with a Revolver next to a Smoking PipeRoom 11: columbia (Key to Conservatory, Lead Pipe, Fedora), a regular guest, was killed on Night 6 in the Kitchen with a Wrench, and a bow tie nearby.Room 12: obhave (Key to the Library, Knife, Bow Tie), a Murderer committed suicide (mod killed) on Night 5.Room 13: bhaw (key to the billiard room, wrench, wristband,) Detective was killed on Night 1 in the Library with a knife, and he held a bow tie in his fist.Room 14: IrishEyes (key to the study, rope, smoking pipe), a regular guest was killed on Day 1.Room 15: Troy Loney (Revolver, Key to the Conservatory, Smoking Pipe), a regular guest Killed on Day 6.Room 16: pittsports87Room 17: newarenanowRoom 18: shafnutz05 (Key to the Library, rope, fedora a regular guest was killed on Day 4.Room 19: redwillRoom 20: Zarovich

Room 1: Godric (Knife, Key to the Conservatory, Smoking Pipe) a regular Guest killed on day 5Room 2: mac5155 (revolver, ket to the library, fedora) a regular guest was Killed on Day 2.Room 3: thehockeyguru (Key to the Study, Wrench, Bow Tie) a regular guest was Killed on Night 2 in the Conservatory with a Revolver, next to a Smoking Pipe.Room 4: the errey i breatheRoom 5: LITT (Key to the Kitchen, lead pipe, wrist band), a regular guest killed on Night 6 with a revolver, in the conservatory, amid a puff of smoke from a smoking pipeRoom 6: MWB (Key to the Billiard room, Revolver, Smoking Pipe) a regular guest was killed on Night 3 in the Kitchen with a Wrench, holding a bow tie.Room 7: relantel (Key to the Library, Wrench, Sunglasses) a regular guest was killed on Day 3.Room 8: GauchoRoom 9: ExPatriatePen (Key to Conservatory, Rope, Wrist Band), a regular guest, was killed on Night 4 in the Library with a knife, and a bow tie lay nearby in a pool of blood.Room 10: Rylan (Lead Pipe, Study, Bow Tie) a regular guest Killed on Night 5 in the Conservatory with a Revolver next to a Smoking PipeRoom 11: columbia (Key to Conservatory, Lead Pipe, Fedora), a regular guest, was killed on Night 6 in the Kitchen with a Wrench, and a bow tie nearby.Room 12: obhave (Key to the Library, Knife, Bow Tie), a Murderer committed suicide (mod killed) on Night 5.Room 13: bhaw (key to the billiard room, wrench, wristband,) Detective was killed on Night 1 in the Library with a knife, and he held a bow tie in his fist.Room 14: IrishEyes (key to the study, rope, smoking pipe), a regular guest was killed on Day 1.Room 15: Troy Loney (Revolver, Key to the Conservatory, Smoking Pipe), a regular guest Killed on Day 6.Room 16: pittsports87Room 17: newarenanowRoom 18: shafnutz05 (Key to the Library, rope, fedora a regular guest was killed on Day 4.Room 19: redwillRoom 20: Zarovich

the errey i breathe wrote:Why aren't we asking the question more like "Does Zarovich have a key to the conservatory?" instead of putting he and I both in there? This is a legitimate question not me proposing another question.

It is best to eliminate half the remaining players with a question. To eliminate only one leaves 3 suspects. The current question eliminates 2.

Room 1: Godric (Knife, Key to the Conservatory, Smoking Pipe) a regular Guest killed on day 5Room 2: mac5155 (revolver, ket to the library, fedora) a regular guest was Killed on Day 2.Room 3: thehockeyguru (Key to the Study, Wrench, Bow Tie) a regular guest was Killed on Night 2 in the Conservatory with a Revolver, next to a Smoking Pipe.Room 4: the errey i breatheRoom 5: LITT (Key to the Kitchen, lead pipe, wrist band), a regular guest killed on Night 6 with a revolver, in the conservatory, amid a puff of smoke from a smoking pipeRoom 6: MWB (Key to the Billiard room, Revolver, Smoking Pipe) a regular guest was killed on Night 3 in the Kitchen with a Wrench, holding a bow tie.Room 7: relantel (Key to the Library, Wrench, Sunglasses) a regular guest was killed on Day 3.Room 8: GauchoRoom 9: ExPatriatePen (Key to Conservatory, Rope, Wrist Band), a regular guest, was killed on Night 4 in the Library with a knife, and a bow tie lay nearby in a pool of blood.Room 10: Rylan (Lead Pipe, Study, Bow Tie) a regular guest Killed on Night 5 in the Conservatory with a Revolver next to a Smoking PipeRoom 11: columbia (Key to Conservatory, Lead Pipe, Fedora), a regular guest, was killed on Night 6 in the Kitchen with a Wrench, and a bow tie nearby.Room 12: obhave (Key to the Library, Knife, Bow Tie), a Murderer committed suicide (mod killed) on Night 5.Room 13: bhaw (key to the billiard room, wrench, wristband,) Detective was killed on Night 1 in the Library with a knife, and he held a bow tie in his fist.Room 14: IrishEyes (key to the study, rope, smoking pipe), a regular guest was killed on Day 1.Room 15: Troy Loney (Revolver, Key to the Conservatory, Smoking Pipe), a regular guest Killed on Day 6.Room 16: pittsports87Room 17: newarenanowRoom 18: shafnutz05 (Key to the Library, rope, fedora a regular guest was killed on Day 4.Room 19: redwillRoom 20: Zarovich

Room 1: Godric (Knife, Key to the Conservatory, Smoking Pipe) a regular Guest killed on day 5Room 2: mac5155 (revolver, ket to the library, fedora) a regular guest was Killed on Day 2.Room 3: thehockeyguru (Key to the Study, Wrench, Bow Tie) a regular guest was Killed on Night 2 in the Conservatory with a Revolver, next to a Smoking Pipe.Room 4: the errey i breatheRoom 5: LITT (Key to the Kitchen, lead pipe, wrist band), a regular guest killed on Night 6 with a revolver, in the conservatory, amid a puff of smoke from a smoking pipeRoom 6: MWB (Key to the Billiard room, Revolver, Smoking Pipe) a regular guest was killed on Night 3 in the Kitchen with a Wrench, holding a bow tie.Room 7: relantel (Key to the Library, Wrench, Sunglasses) a regular guest was killed on Day 3.Room 8: GauchoRoom 9: ExPatriatePen (Key to Conservatory, Rope, Wrist Band), a regular guest, was killed on Night 4 in the Library with a knife, and a bow tie lay nearby in a pool of blood.Room 10: Rylan (Lead Pipe, Study, Bow Tie) a regular guest Killed on Night 5 in the Conservatory with a Revolver next to a Smoking PipeRoom 11: columbia (Key to Conservatory, Lead Pipe, Fedora), a regular guest, was killed on Night 6 in the Kitchen with a Wrench, and a bow tie nearby.Room 12: obhave (Key to the Library, Knife, Bow Tie), a Murderer committed suicide (mod killed) on Night 5.Room 13: bhaw (key to the billiard room, wrench, wristband,) Detective was killed on Night 1 in the Library with a knife, and he held a bow tie in his fist.Room 14: IrishEyes (key to the study, rope, smoking pipe), a regular guest was killed on Day 1.Room 15: Troy Loney (Revolver, Key to the Conservatory, Smoking Pipe), a regular guest Killed on Day 6.Room 16: pittsports87Room 17: newarenanowRoom 18: shafnutz05 (Key to the Library, rope, fedora a regular guest was killed on Day 4.Room 19: redwillRoom 20: Zarovich

redwill wrote:That's right. I am. And I left my wrench, Mr. Bash-Bash, in the middle of that peon's skull.

How...could...you?!

I will kill you.

redwill wrote:Don't you want to see my Key to the Kitchen, first?

AAAARRRRRHHHHHHH!

(With that Frank shoved redwill backwards toward the open cellar door. Frank just stood and watched as redwill fell backwards down the stairs and snapped his neck)

(A key to the Kitchen fell from redwill's lifeless palm)

redwill was :

Spoiler:

a murderer

Guests:

Spoiler:

Room 1: Godric (Knife, Key to the Conservatory, Smoking Pipe) a regular Guest killed on day 5Room 2: mac5155 (revolver, ket to the library, fedora) a regular guest was Killed on Day 2.Room 3: thehockeyguru (Key to the Study, Wrench, Bow Tie) a regular guest was Killed on Night 2 in the Conservatory with a Revolver, next to a Smoking Pipe.Room 4: the errey i breatheRoom 5: LITT (Key to the Kitchen, lead pipe, wrist band), a regular guest killed on Night 6 with a revolver, in the conservatory, amid a puff of smoke from a smoking pipeRoom 6: MWB (Key to the Billiard room, Revolver, Smoking Pipe) a regular guest was killed on Night 3 in the Kitchen with a Wrench, holding a bow tie.Room 7: relantel (Key to the Library, Wrench, Sunglasses) a regular guest was killed on Day 3.Room 8: GauchoRoom 9: ExPatriatePen (Key to Conservatory, Rope, Wrist Band), a regular guest, was killed on Night 4 in the Library with a knife, and a bow tie lay nearby in a pool of blood.Room 10: Rylan (Lead Pipe, Study, Bow Tie) a regular guest Killed on Night 5 in the Conservatory with a Revolver next to a Smoking PipeRoom 11: columbia (Key to Conservatory, Lead Pipe, Fedora), a regular guest, was killed on Night 6 in the Kitchen with a Wrench, and a bow tie nearby.Room 12: obhave (Key to the Library, Knife, Bow Tie), a Murderer committed suicide (mod killed) on Night 5.Room 13: bhaw (key to the billiard room, wrench, wristband,) Detective was killed on Night 1 in the Library with a knife, and he held a bow tie in his fist.Room 14: IrishEyes (key to the study, rope, smoking pipe), a regular guest was killed on Day 1.Room 15: Troy Loney (Revolver, Key to the Conservatory, Smoking Pipe), a regular guest Killed on Day 6.Room 16: pittsports87Room 17: newarenanowRoom 18: shafnutz05 (Key to the Library, rope, fedora a regular guest was killed on Day 4.Room 19: redwill (Wrench (Mr. Bash-Bash), Kitchen, Bow tie) a Murderer was killed on Day 7Room 20: Zarovich

Question:

Spoiler:

Day 1: Is a guest staying in an even room wearing a bow tie? Yes.Day 2: Of the people that are still living, does only one of them have a bow tie? No.Day 3: Did four of the original twenty guests possess a revolver? Yes.Day 4: Does a person in an odd room that is currently living have a wrench? Yes.Day 5: Does either columbia or LITT possess a wrench? No.Day 6: Does NAN possess a wrench? No.Day 7: Does either Zaro or TEIB have a Key to the Conservatory? No.

Hello, again guests. I must apologize for my actions last night. In some ways, I'm sure Mr. redwill had it coming. But that's still no excuse to let my anger get the best of me. I urge you to bring the remaining murderer to justice. I fear that our days are numbered and we might not be afforded the luxury of another sunrise.

Troubled by both my encounter with redwill, and our grim chance of survival, I went back to the video surveillance room last night. I though maybe after knowing his identity I could uncover some additional clues. Sadly all I uncovered was this footage from the night columbia was killed.

Spoiler:

On my way back to my room I could hear a lot of moving around from the floor above. It almost sounded as if someone suddenly broke into a run. I went up to check it out, but saw nothing. Just before I reached my door I heard a gun-shot down stairs in the Conservatory. I'm not too proud to admit that instead of running to investigate, I instead flew into my room and blocked the door. You see, I feel as though I've been fortunate enough to stay out of harms way, but fearing retribution from yesterday, and that my luck may be running out, I decided to just wait until morning to venture downstairs.

In the morning, I summoned my courage and went to see what had happened. After all the occurrences as of late, I was expecting the worst. Unfortunately, my expectations were met as I saw our latest victim laying in a pool of his own blood, shot by a Revolver. I removed his Fedora from his face to find that the killer had murdered:

Spoiler:

Gaucho a regular guest

I found only a Knife in his pocket, that he apparently never got a chance to use, as well as a Key to the Kitchen. There was nothing else found in the Conservatory other than some ash from a Smoking Pipe.

Guests:

Spoiler:

Room 1: Godric (Knife, Key to the Conservatory, Smoking Pipe) a regular Guest killed on day 5Room 2: mac5155 (revolver, ket to the library, fedora) a regular guest was Killed on Day 2.Room 3: thehockeyguru (Key to the Study, Wrench, Bow Tie) a regular guest was Killed on Night 2 in the Conservatory with a Revolver, next to a Smoking Pipe.Room 4: the errey i breatheRoom 5: LITT (Key to the Kitchen, lead pipe, wrist band), a regular guest killed on Night 6 with a revolver, in the conservatory, amid a puff of smoke from a smoking pipeRoom 6: MWB (Key to the Billiard room, Revolver, Smoking Pipe) a regular guest was killed on Night 3 in the Kitchen with a Wrench, holding a bow tie.Room 7: relantel (Key to the Library, Wrench, Sunglasses) a regular guest was killed on Day 3.Room 8: Gaucho (Key to the Kitchen, Knife, Fedora, a regular guest was killed on Night 7 in the Cconservatory with a revolver near a smoking pipe.Room 9: ExPatriatePen (Key to Conservatory, Rope, Wrist Band), a regular guest, was killed on Night 4 in the Library with a knife, and a bow tie lay nearby in a pool of blood.Room 10: Rylan (Lead Pipe, Study, Bow Tie) a regular guest Killed on Night 5 in the Conservatory with a Revolver next to a Smoking PipeRoom 11: columbia (Key to Conservatory, Lead Pipe, Fedora), a regular guest, was killed on Night 6 in the Kitchen with a Wrench, and a bow tie nearby.Room 12: obhave (Key to the Library, Knife, Bow Tie), a Murderer committed suicide (mod killed) on Night 5.Room 13: bhaw (key to the billiard room, wrench, wristband,) Detective was killed on Night 1 in the Library with a knife, and he held a bow tie in his fist.Room 14: IrishEyes (key to the study, rope, smoking pipe), a regular guest was killed on Day 1.Room 15: Troy Loney (Revolver, Key to the Conservatory, Smoking Pipe), a regular guest Killed on Day 6.Room 16: pittsports87Room 17: newarenanowRoom 18: shafnutz05 (Key to the Library, rope, fedora a regular guest was killed on Day 4.Room 19: redwill (Wrench (Mr. Bash-Bash), Kitchen, Bow tie) a Murderer was killed on Day 7Room 20: Zarovich

Question:

Spoiler:

Day 1: Is a guest staying in an even room wearing a bow tie? Yes.Day 2: Of the people that are still living, does only one of them have a bow tie? No.Day 3: Did four of the original twenty guests possess a revolver? Yes.Day 4: Does a person in an odd room that is currently living have a wrench? Yes.Day 5: Does either columbia or LITT possess a wrench? No.Day 6: Does NAN possess a wrench? No.Day 7: Does either Zaro or TEIB have a Key to the Conservatory? No.