When the duo previewed the album at a recent engagement at the New York nightclub Feinstein's at Loews Regency, Will Friedwald raved in the Wall Street Journal, "The Stewart-Charlap combination is, eternally, like a master class in interpretation. The team is so subtle, so understated, so specific in their approach that even a clinking glass might break the spell. Ultimately, by the encore Feinstein's has become nothing less than a serenely reverent church of the Great American Songbook."