On Monday night, the underwear-clad duo, The Skivvies (actor-musicians Nick Cearley and Lauren Molina), hosted several Broadway stars a for ‘stripped down’ performance of various pop songs to the delight of those in the audience at 54 Below in New York City. Wes Taylor (Smash), who is a regularly featured guest on the show, performed a medley of TLC’s “Unpretty,” Carly Rae Jepsen’s “Call Me Maybe” and Robyn’s “Call Your Girlfriend.”

Andrew Keenan-Bolger (Newsies), who was looking fine in his Diesel underwear, performed a sweet rendition of Lily Allen’s “Fuck You.”

Rory O’Malley (The Book of Mormon) sang a mashup of summertime songs including Weezer and Nicki Minaj.

More videos of the full performance including Laura Benanti here. The Skivvies will next be seen performing at the Broadway Bares annual summer show.