It does cool the eye. Good price. Yet it leaves creases on eyelids after a few hours. Lighter colors can double as a lipstick too. The smearing is the worst part, becasue its's too creamy.
— 6 years, 2 months ago

This is not really recommended if you have oily lids like me, since it creases after a few hours of wear. I don't care much for the cooling effect, especially when the weather is cold. I like to travel with this since it's very portable, I can do the smokey eye effect effortlessly smudging with my finger using the black or the gray shade. After a while, the crayon shrinks and it gets harder to sha...read morerpen without breaking off. It could be better, and they need to expand on the shade selection.— 7 years, 3 months ago

I really like this product but I do wish this product was a bit better, like I would like it if it did not crease as much, but I think if used in conjunction with a powder shadow, as in after you line your eyes you add a black eye shadow on top, it will help seal in the liner. I wish maybeline would bring this back, it was really a great product, just not the whole smearing part!
— 2 years, 6 months ago