In upstate New York, Abe (Krumholtz), a high school baseball coach, wakes up to discover that his beautiful wife Kitty has disappeared. When someone sends Abe a photo from a newspaper showing a rock star and his entourage, including a woman that could be Kitty, Abe heads to New York City to find her. Abe hires a private detective, a loner ex-cop named Jack (Burns), who is burying himself in his work to avoid dealing with the death of his own wife. Facing eviction from his apartment, it’s an offer Jack can’t refuse. Jack sees in this case a chance to finally put to rest his own grieving by reuniting Abe and Kitty. What emerges from this investigation changes both of their lives forever.