Darren Criss isn’t set to star in the upcoming Broadway adaptation of Disney’s Aladdin, but that didn’t stop him and fellow stage star Lea Salonga from delivering a beautiful rendition of “A Whole New World” at New York’s premier gay piano bar, Marie’s Crisis.

Can you imagine the reaction when these two walked in? It must have been a 5.0 gayquake. It was a spontaneous night out in the West Village, but the duo had sung the song a few years back at a tribute to Alan Menken.