Bobby Randolph was a high school student. He and two of his friends, Sein Martin and Jasper Gein, were fascinated by the lore of the Order and tried to learn all they could about it.

Walter Sullivan strangled him to death, removed his heart, and dumped his body on the college campus in Pleasant River alongside the third victim. Bobby Randolph is known as Victim 2 in the game. He left behind a book about occultism found at the crime scene.