My only experience with these two movies are from Spoony's reviews of them. However, looking at both movies and what he explained about them, I would say The Source is worse. It violates almost everything established in the series and is extremely poorly made as well. Then again it was a Skiffy channel production so...

I've seen them both....and I can't choose.....actually, I conditioned myself to forget every Highlander sequel..Wait a minute...what are we talking about again? There are no sequels to Highlander, you silly goose.

I've seen them both....and I can't choose.....actually, I conditioned myself to forget every Highlander sequel..Wait a minute...what are we talking about again? There are no sequels to Highlander, you silly goose.

Not even the cartoon series?

Logged

Terms & Conditions: By reading this signature, you, the reader willfully acknowledge that you owe me a dollar.

I've seen them both....and I can't choose.....actually, I conditioned myself to forget every Highlander sequel..Wait a minute...what are we talking about again? There are no sequels to Highlander, you silly goose.

I've seen them both....and I can't choose.....actually, I conditioned myself to forget every Highlander sequel..Wait a minute...what are we talking about again? There are no sequels to Highlander, you silly goose.

Highlander 3 was okay. The Quickening just seemed to puke all over everything that was good about the first film. I haven't seen "The Source", but seeing as it was made in 2007, there's absolutely no chance that I ever will.

Highlander 3 was okay. The Quickening just seemed to puke all over everything that was good about the first film. I haven't seen "The Source", but seeing as it was made in 2007, there's absolutely no chance that I ever will.

It aired on Sci-F- oh I'm sorry! Syfy, for a few months then died in a hole. Or rather a DVD discount bin. Guess which movie has no chance of being upgraded to Blu-Ray!

I've seen them both....and I can't choose.....actually, I conditioned myself to forget every Highlander sequel..Wait a minute...what are we talking about again? There are no sequels to Highlander, you silly goose.

I haven't seen "The Source", but seeing as it was made in 2007, there's absolutely no chance that I ever will.

It probably should stay that way. Even the effects not in CGI are horrendous, even though there is a surprising balance of both. In case you ever get a weird feeling to watch it, just look at this review and save yourself a load of time.

I voted for The Quickening because of the crappy explanation for the Immortals. They're from another planet? A planet full of skateboarding assassins? The original did just fine without explaining anything. I liked the mystery of not knowing.If you're going to come up with an explanation it had better be a good one.

I voted for The Quickening because of the crappy explanation for the Immortals. They're from another planet? A planet full of skateboarding assassins? The original did just fine without explaining anything. I liked the mystery of not knowing.If you're going to come up with an explanation it had better be a good one.