Neighborhood Impact on Boys' Dropout Rates Seen Limited

A new report by the Urban Institute suggests that family factors
outweigh neighborhood characteristics in influencing the dropout rates
of urban boys.

While having even a few poor residents in their neighborhood appears
to substantially increase the chances that teenage boys will drop out
of school, compared with those of boys living in areas with no poor
people, the correlation appears to level off when the poverty rate
reaches just 5 percent, the study found.

At the same time, the study indicates, living in a two-parent
household is one of the strongest predictors that such boys will stay
in school.

The analysis of data from the 1980 U.S. Census challenges the
presumption that social problems such as dropping out tend to spread
like an epidemic, concludes the report's author, Rebecca L. Clark, a
research associate at the Washington think tank.

Working from such a model, earlier research on dropout rates has
suggested that decreases in neighborhood quality cause a steady
increase in dropout rates, and that, once neighborhood quality falls
below a certain level, dropout rates skyrocket, Ms. Clark observes in
the study issued late last month.

She writes that she found "no evidence to support an epidemic
model,'' and much to challenge the notion that dropout rates skyrocket
after neighborhoods deteriorate beyond a certain point.

Comparisons of social problems to diseases, she argues, tend to
obscure the fact people can be influenced by good examples--or, in
effect, "catch health.'' Moreover, she says, research based on such an
analogy tends to focus solely on either positive or negative influences
in a neighborhood.

In her study, Ms. Clark simultaneously examined both positive and
negative influences on 22,534 urban boys in their neighborhoods,
including their family characteristics.

Two-Parent Homes

The presence of two parents at home appears to have a far greater
influence than neighborhood poverty levels in determining whether boys
will stay in school, the report notes.

Boys who live with both parents appear about 80 percent less likely
to drop out of high school than boys who live with one parent or with
another older relative, it says.

A boy living with one parent or a relative, Ms. Clark found, would
have to see his neighborhood's poverty rate decline by 68 percentage
points in order to have the same chance of staying in school as a boy
in a two-parent family.

A boy also was less likely to drop out as the education levels of
his parents increased, the author found, and a parent's lower job
status--or absence of a job--tended to increase the odds that a boy
would leave school.

As a neighborhood's poverty rate climbs from zero to 5 percent, the
odds that a boy living in that neighborhood will drop out of school
increase by about 90 percent, the report says.

As the poverty rate of a neighborhood rises from 5 percent to 10
percent, however, the odds that a boy will drop out show an additional
increase of less than 4 percent, it says.

Over all, black youths are more likely than whites or
Asian-Americans to drop out, the study found. But, when blacks' family
characteristics--such as the decreased likelihood of their living with
two parents--are taken into account, they actually are more likely than
whites or Asians to stay in school.

Hispanic boys appear to be more likely all than others to drop out,
even when family influences are taken into account, the study
found.

Copies of "The Effect of Neighborhood Characteristics on Dropping
Out Among Teenage Boys'' can be obtained from the Urban Institute for
$8 by calling (202) 833-7200.

Vol. 12, Issue 16

Notice: We recently upgraded our comments. (Learn more here.) If you are logged in as a subscriber or registered user and already have a Display Name on edweek.org, you can post comments. If you do not already have a Display Name, please create one here.

Ground Rules for Posting
We encourage lively debate, but please be respectful of others. Profanity and personal attacks are prohibited. By commenting, you are agreeing to abide by our user agreement.
All comments are public.