The Carlton Edinburgh: Hotel Review

The Carlton Hotel

Since this review was written, the Carlton
Hotel has changed ownership, with the result that what is said here may no
longer be current. We hope to be able to update the review in the near
future. The Carlton Hotel stands in a prominent position in the
Edinburgh landscape. The hotel occupies
the entire eastern side of North Bridge south of its ceasing to be an actual
bridge over Waverley Station. Yet it hides its sheer size behind and above
street level shops and a bank, and as a result is all too easy to overlook. And
this is a hotel which should not be overlooked. The Carlton combines good
quality accommodation with excellent dining and outstanding service and is a
hotel we would recommend to anyone staying in the city. You can read our
dining review for The Carlton Hotel
here.

North Bridge was built to allow access between the Old Town and the
New when the latter was developed in the 1760s. The railway then arrived in the
valley below in the mid 1800s and North Bridge was widened between 1894 and
1897. The very fine buildings that stand on its east side were added in 1898.
The Carlton Hotel originally occupied the northern half of the building it
occupies today. It was only in more recent times that the hotel expanded to
take over the rest of the block.

On entering from North Bridge you are greeted by an airy reception
area finished in light shades. Off to one side you find the long reception
desk, but your attention is drawn first to the magnificent staircase that leads
up to the first floor and cries out "Hollywood" or, more prosaically, a
solution to the problem of wedding photographs on a rainy day. There is also an
entrance from Market Street, almost opposite the southern exit from Waverley
Railway Station.

The rest of the public areas are on the first floor. Here you find
the Bridge Bar and Lounge. This is open throughout the day (and late into the
evening), offering snacks and light meals, afternoon teas and drinks. To one
side of this is the Bridge Restaurant. Here guests are served breakfast over an
unusually long service period, and here, too, are served the excellent dinners
on offer. You can read our dining review for The
Carlton Hotel here.

The rest of the first floor is occupied by meeting/conference
function rooms, which can accommodation events of up to 220 seated in theatre
layout, or weddings of up to 200. The Carlton's central position makes it an
obvious location for a meeting, and it no surprise that it is also becoming
increasingly popular as a wedding venue. The hotel's leisure facilities are
also very popular, both with guests and local members. Hidden way in one of the
lower levels of the hotel is a swimming pool, unusually large fitness and
training areas, a gym and a steam room, beauty treatment areas, and,
remarkably, two full size squash courts.

There are 189 en-suite guest bedrooms at The Carlton. They are
housed on the upper four floors of the hotel and enjoy outlooks in every
direction, including over North Bridge itself and the High Street (part of the
Royal Mile), while others look north towards the New Town and east towards
Holyrood Palace and Park. There are three main types of room on offer: doubles,
twins (which can be linked to form doubles) and premium rooms, though some
larger family rooms, and some singles, are available. All are equipped to the
standards you would expect from a good four star hotel, and standards of
maintenance and, especially, housekeeping, are very good indeed. The emphasis
is on straightforward comfort rather than a design-led boutique approach,
though the more recently refurbished bathrooms would give many boutique hotels
a run for their money. As with any city centre hotel, some rooms look out onto
nearby roads while others have a quieter outlook.

Accessibility is good. There are six largely accessible rooms, and
access is straightforward in the public areas, where facilities are
available.

We approached our visit to The Carlton with high expectation, while
recognising it is about as "city centre" as a city centre hotel can be. Our
expectations were easily surpassed in all areas. Guest accommodation is
comfortable and the beds and bathrooms are especially good. The public areas
are welcoming and well thought through. And the free WiFi is very welcome. But
the one thing that holds all this together and really makes your stay a
memorable one is the commitment of every single member of staff you meet to
giving you the best possible stay: from those on the reception desk to the
waiting staff in the dining room and the man with the ladder emerging from the
lift as we were departing.