Fergie's greatest 11 is almost impossible to pick barring a few spots in the side i.e Scholes, Giggs, Neville. I know most wouldn't agree but I would have Van Der Sar as Fergie's best ever keeper. I'd have Van Nistelrooy ahead of Rooney as well in my all time 11. Van Der Sar, Neville, Stam, Vidic, Irwin, Ronaldo, Scholes, Keane, Giggs, Cantona, Van Nistelrooy.

VDS over Big Pete- you clearly don't remember the penalty save in the semi final at Villa Park against Bergkamp!!!!!

Schmeichel was a true genius......his shot stopping was incredible but his biggest asset was his distribution. A certain final against Barca comes to mind when VDS put 6 balls into touch from goal kicks.......

Schmeichel was an over rated arrogant prick who gladly went and played for them bitter blue cunts and celebrated like one when they beat us. My first game was the 2nd division title presentation in '75 so ur comment re '99 is tripe. It was VDS who saved a certain penalty against the rent boys in Moscow u might remember

NYDUDE: Erm yes I was a red in 99. I my first memory as a United fan was the 94 cup final against Chelsea when I was 7 watching on tv with my dad. Schmeichel will always have his place in United history but you can make a case for him or Van Der Sar. Van Der Sar made less mistakes than Schmeichel if you look at their careers. I can remember Van Der Sar making 2 mistakes in his whole career at United - away to Boro in a 4-1 defeat and at home to West Brom in a 2-2 draw. Schmeichel on the other hand I remember dropping a lot more clangers. They're both great goal keepers but Van Der Sar gets my vote. I think he's a more likeable bloke as well.