Fairytail has the power to become a member. But without three, you can't really call it the big 3 anymore, now can you? The third seat is ripe for the taking. Not that I care. I acknowledge One Piece as well researched, but I dislike the style so I never got more than a few episodes in. Bleach I long dropped, and it's killing itself finely anyways. (I kept up with summaries to get a good laugh, but when even that gave me a headache...fullbringer arc im looking at you ) Naruto. Well Naruto became DBZ, and I haven't kept up since Madara was still vsing the 4 kages. Kind of like the three Abyssal ones in Claymore lol.

Plenty of anime has always captivated me without the big three, and it'll stay that way. This season I already have 6 I have a huge investment in, and I doubt any of them will last more than 12-25 episodes, yet I'm much happier watching them than the so called big three.

I would say AoT, only because it pretty much fulfills the airing on TV and huge manga sales slots. Fairy Tail would probably qualify internet-popularity wise, and sells pretty well, but is probably too fanservicey to gain any real traction with a TV network.

Toriko was great but its already finished, and Gintama was one of the big popular ones and now its finished too :S and yes SKET Dance was great but I feel they didnt quite complete it totally...BUT ....Fairy Tail now thats a series that incredible and is still ongoing its fantastic if none of you have seen it I would give it a try even if it isnt your cup of tea :)