28 Comment(s) for Police and Family Seeking Answers in Bobby Atwal's 2006 Murder

RIP to my big bro, it’s been 9 years today since this bullshit happened. I wish you were here in physical form so I could give you a bear hug. Im sick of reading about other young indo canadians being murdered, it reminds of me the bad times that I went through. This is a public service announcement to end this lifestyle and beef. The only beef people should be seeing is the one in their burger. Ain’t no greater pain then losing a loved one, I wish Bob was still here. All you g’s and wanna be g’s think of your actions and their consequences. Fuck street fame the game gets you nowhere. The game is lame……..fuck living in the fast lane……..it’s only going to bring your family pain. End this shit…… RIP Bobby, I still workout in your honor I love you eternally, and miss you greatly……. life is difficult without you, I hope you are ready to pop bottles when I show up to the gates……

Thanks Kim, it’s easy to accept death when a person passes from natural causes. But dealing with a murder is hard to accept, when you know there is people out there that did this. It’s something that is always on your mind, they say time heals all wounds…….mine haven’t healed yet……..

Who the fuck committed this grisly act? I was young when my bro got murdered it didn’t seem like reality to me. Now I’m older and this shit has got me wondering, why did this happen to my bro? I was with him everyday of his life, this guy wasn’t into any gangs or drugs. In fact this guy just used to stay home and play video games and take care of the nieces and all the little kids of my family. Bobby put me onto the right path, brought me up to do good. He’d train me everyday in his garage, helping me reach my goal of building muscle when I was a young buck. Everyday I think of my brother, I miss him and keep on wondering wtf happened to him. I can’t believe theres motherfuckers out there that would take someones life for no reason. I miss my bro. life is hard without him.

Who do the initials HD and MB belong to? KIM SAYS: Given the accusations being leveled against them on here, please stick to initials. They are NOT charged in this case. If anyone knows more, they should call police at the numbers I provided.

Who ever knows anything should really come forward. Imagine if this happened to someone in your family. The parent’s lives have been changed forever and they go through the constant reminder everyday when they see their son is not at home like he used to for the past 22 years. If you ever been to a funeral than you know how much the parent’s hearts are broken. So take some time and help a grieving family out. It will only help you in the future with good karma.

T Mali. I went to high school with him and bobby atwal. Bobby is short, like 5’7 or so and kept to himself. Cambie highschool in Richmond has produced a majority of thugs and wannabees for the lower mainland. RS was started in jail by richmond people. KIM SAYS: Are you saying Mali knew BA?

what ever happened to the brother that shot and killed that guy with his own gun? did he get out of jail, or did he even go to jail for that? KIM SAYS: If you are talking about the youth in the Abbotsford case, the charge against him was stayed. So it never even went to trial.

While he may of been an honest Atwal, the family name is tarnished and tainted, perhaps unfairly, but true. Nobody should believe that gang enforcers are great spellers. Like the would-be RS assassin who was killed with his own gun after breaking into the wrong Amin residence to execute a hit last year. This was probably a case of mistaken identity. KIM SAYS: I don’t think the name is tarnished at all by the acts of others not related to this family. And I think we need to do what we can to help Bobby Atwal’s family get justice.

all i have to say is HD(hes one in the new west cop show) and MB(hes the one who did it probably, listening to HD)…………kim you can tell crimestoppers im not a rat just feel bad for the parents………..alot of people know they did it cuz he was talkin *** KIM SAYS: Can you email me more info? kbolan@vancouversun.com. You can email anonymously – just set up a fake hotmail or gmail account. Or you can call Crimestoppers anonymously.

Could it be mistaken identity of Bobby Harminder Singh Atwal, and this bobby atwal?? KIM SAYS: I really doubt that. Their two full names are different. And there is about a foot difference in height – this young man was just 5’6″ and the other Bobby Atwal (convicted in a gangland kidnapping a couple of years back) is really tall. But anything is possible. That’s why it is so important for people with knowledge to go to the police.

This is a sad story. Feel for the parents of the victim. Raising him for 22 years, and having such high hopes for a bright future for their son, and one night its all gone. I hope someone comes forward with information to this. Even if charges aren’t laid, as long as the parents get some information as to why this happen. Could be very well a case of mistaken identity, who really knows, unless someone comes forward and relays some information. KIM SAYS: I hope charges are laid. It is really important to make people accountable for the worst thing imaginable – taking someone else’s life. It could be mistaken identity, but it could also be someone getting into an argument with him in a pub and taking it outside. It is hard to say.

yes that guy. didnt bal buttar himself tell you he did it and made him swallow gasoline first? KIM SAYS: No, Bal Buttar said Derek was shot by Bindy Johal and that Bal realized at that moment he would have to do something about Bindy.

kim do u think the u.n. will get held accountable for that kl hit in langley last year cause first they said something about a van erraticcly driving away and then we never heard zilch again. KIM SAYS: I assume there was video surveillance seized by police that shows something – whether it is enough for charges, I can’t say. I do think we will see more arrests this year in some of these high-profile killings.

you are right kim. i was thinking about that other guy found in the same area years before KIM SAYS: You mean Derek Shankar? That was way earlier. A lot of bodies have been dumped under bridges over the years.

who are the friends he went out with? they know who popped him. some people say it was the buttars. KIM SAYS: I don’t think it was the Buttars – first of all there was only ONE Buttar active at that point and I have never heard any link between him and this young man.