Lumber Prices Rising to Start 2017

The price of lumber, from framing to structural panels, has increased in recent weeks with some prices rising more than 30%.

Softwood lumber prices have been relatively steady since 2014. During this period, the largest one-week price increase of framing lumber (+6.8%), as measured by the Random Lengths Framing Lumber Composite Index, occurred in the middle of the recent price escalation.[1] The largest one-month swing of softwood lumber during this period was 2.9% in 2014 according to the Bureau of Labor Statistics Producer Price Index (PPI) (this index will not capture the recent monthly increases until the February data is released in mid-March).[2]

The trade agreement that has governed Canadian imports of softwood lumber since 2006 effectively expired at the end of 2016, the mechanics and consequences of which are discussed below. Failure to reach a new agreement is the primary catalyst of market-wide price increases.[3] The outlook of a new pact between the U.S. and Canada and thus, lumber prices, is highly uncertain at this point. However, price trends in the 2001-2006 period (the last time negotiations were held) may offer clues as to what lies ahead.

Recent Trading and Price Volatility

Since the start of 2017, the price of framing lumber is up 15%. In the three weeks between January 27thand February 17th, prices increased by 5% per week, on average. To put that in perspective, consider that the average weekly price change over the course of 2016 was +0.2%.[4] Though prices have increased in the aggregate, the composite index masks the magnitude of some of the most volatile, species-specific increases.

Spruce-Pine-Fir (S-P-F)

Canadian softwood lumber imports are predominantly S-P-F.[5] Speculation of retroactive duties being imposed on Canadian imports began in late January, as evidenced in a two-week, 12% increase in March delivery lumber futures. Producers hiked prices by double-digits on the heels of the futures price changes. Other Canadian mills dropped out of the market to mitigate the effects of uncertainty. Canadian price increases allowed U.S. mills to raise quotes—as buyers had nowhere else to turn for high-grade products—further boosting the aggregate price level. The framing lumber composite price rose $25 between February 3rd and February 10th, the largest one-week increase since August 2003.[6]

The graph below illustrates the disparity between the price increases of eastern versus western S-P-F from late January to mid-February. Western S-P-F 2x4s became 24% ($76) more expensive during this period, while eastern 2×4 prices rose just 8% ($31).

The baseline price of both products was responsible for most of this difference. Prior to these market changes, eastern S-P-F already traded at a premium relative to western. On January 27th, eastern S-P-F was priced relative high—$78 more expensive than its western counterpart. When buyers became true price takers, western S-P-F had more room to increase to a market-imposed price ceiling. As a result, the price disparity (shown below) shrank 50% by February 17th.

Southern Pine

Unlike S-P-F prices—which either held steady or declined during the week ending February 24th—price increases of southern pine (SP) 2x4s and 2x10s continued their rapid pace. An example of the pace of price growth is that southern pine 2x10s became 4% more expensive each week from January 27ththrough February 24th.

The recent surge in southern pine prices (shown above) reflects the fact that major appreciation of S-P-F products allows SP mills to hike quotes without fear of sacrificing their share of the framing lumber market.

Structural panel markets

In addition to framing lumber, the price of structural panel products has become worrisome for buyers. The volume of orders for and prices of OSB and plywood accelerated in the beginning of February. These increases came on the heels of OSB price increases throughout 2016. Builders have received little relief since November 2016, as the OSB Composite Price ended 2016 with increases in six of the final seven weeks.[7]

The pain has not been contained to OSB; plywood prices have climbed relatively steeply since the beginning of the year. The two following charts capture those increases in the panel market.

Some western plywood suppliers said the first week of February was their busiest in two years. Elevated demand allowed mills to hike prices several times without affecting sales.

The Softwood Lumber Trade Dispute

The root of these price increases is the long-running dispute between Canada and the U.S. regarding softwood lumber imports to the United States.

Imposed charges on Canadian regional exports if the volume to the U.S. in any given month exceeded a “trigger volume”

Exempted softwood lumber products exported by dozens of Canadian companies

The 2006 SLA officially expired On October 12th, 2015. However, the agreement included a key provision: upon the expiration of SLA 2006, there would be a 12-month “cooling off period” during which no new trade disputes could be filed.[8] Thus, on November 25th, 2016, litigation began in earnest as domestic lumber producers filed a petition with the International Trade Commission (ITC) requesting an investigation into softwood lumber imported from Canada.[9]

How Expiration Has Fueled Price Increases

As was widely expected, the ITC issued a preliminary determination siding with domestic softwood lumber producers on January 6th.[10] Soon after, lumber price increases took hold as the market reacted to the initial ITC investigation. In late February, the U.S. Department of Commerce decided to postpone its preliminary determination of countervailing duties to late April. Cash deposits from Canadian exporters would then be required in the beginning of May. The eventual magnitude of duties placed on imports remains uncertain, but recent price increases indicate that producers are bracing for charges on the order of 20%-30%. As a result, Canadian mills have priced lumber at a premium high enough to not only make up for surcharges tied to February purchases, but also to make up capture funds to be remitted to the U.S. tied to shipments going back to December 2016.[11]

Outlook

Fortunately, lumber prices have generally remained level over the past two weeks. Hiking prices has recently been challenging for producers as trading volume slowed. One explanation is that the pricing increase drove many buyers to shift purchases forward to hedge against future price increases. The price of lumber futures came down modestly in the last week, but the trend since late January is unmistakable. Futures prices of lumber­­ with May and especially July (shown below) delivery dates have risen consistently since the beginning of 2017.[12]

Identifying prospective price hikes early has allowed NAHB to actively pursue solutions to protect builders from the deleterious effects of another prolonged softwood lumber trade dispute. For the time being, it looks like mills have largely priced future, retroactive duties into the market. However, any news, regardless of the source, is sure to cause market changes. Moving forward, the announcement of preliminary duties is of paramount importance. It will not be until then that market prices truly reflect all the facts.Post by – NAHB Eye on Housing

Archives

It’s time to hit the lake and reel in the big one with your fellow HBA Members! Join us for the HBA Fall Fishing Tournament at Tablerock Lake, Mill Creek on Wednesday, September 20th from 7am – 3pm. Entry fees are $75 per boat and are due to the HBA office by September 15th. ... Read More

If you haven’t signed up for the HBA Fall Golf Tournament… what are you waiting for? Come hit a few balls, enjoy the cooler weather and connect with your fellow HBA Members. The Tournament will be held on Monday, September 11th at Hidden Valley Golf Links. A hamburger lunch, including baked beans and potato salad, ... Read More

Residential Construction Builder Education This builder education series will cover eight inexpensive ways to build a better house according to Travis Miller, P.E. of Miller Engineering (View PDF) Below the sill plate: Soil Compaction Crawlspaces - what is a vapor barrier and when do you need one? Drainage away from the residence ... Read More

Workforce development is critical – but, how do we connect with the next generation of workers? One fantastic opportunity is the Build My Future event. This event is a One Day Construction Career Day targeting high school students. The inaugural Build My Future event in the Springfield market attracted almost 800 high school students from ... Read More

Membership Recruitment Competition 2017 - Who Do You Know That Would Make A Fantastic HBA Member? It’s time to look through your contacts and start making membership recruitment phone calls! The HBA membership recruitment competition is starting to heat up – you have until November 30th to recruitment new HBA members for a CHANCE TO ... Read More

The International Builders Show 2018 will be held in Orlando - January 9th through 11th. Register NOW for your FREE IBS Expo Pass During the month of August, all HBA members can register for a FREE IBS Expo Pass OR you can save $100 off a full registration (including education classes). See you ... Read More

The softwood lumber trade dispute between the U.S. and Canada has sent prices significantly higher in the first seven months of 2017. The Random Lengths Composite Price—a weighted-average measure consisting of multiple species and dimensions of softwood lumber products—increased 14% over just three weeks in February. Certain framing lumber—such as spruce-pine-fir (S-P-F) studs—remains 40% more expensive ... Read More

When browsing through the "50 Political Pros you Need to Know" you should recognize one Political Pro who happens to be connected to the HBA of Greater Springfield. These pros are the people behind the scenes and behind the people making history. They rarely receive any awards or accolades for their hard ... Read More

Rock Solid Renovations Awards Rock Solid Renovations is excited to have received two awards from 417 Home Magazine in 2017. Susie Edie and Jeremiah Lee were the joint recipients of the Bathroom Design Award and the Laundry Room Design Award. Learn more about these two design projects and Rock Solid Renovations' Awards at ... Read More

The real estate market is moving fast. If you see something you love, it’s a good idea to be ready to move on it quickly. Homes that are priced right are selling in no time. Some homes are only on the market for a few days, so timing is of the essence. Your Murney ... Read More

Since 1942, NAHB has been committed to improving the housing industry and helping its members build communities. Walk with us down memory lane as we revisit some of NAHB’s most notable milestones, like builders mailing 2x4s to Washington DC in the 1980s, as well as other significant turning points in American history. Below are a ... Read More

We’re willing to bet that you don’t go out of your way to waste water. Even with the best of intentions, however, more than 10,000 gallons of water per family is squandered each year (due to things like small household leaks). Since water is one of our most valuable resources, it’s in everyone’s best interest ... Read More