I think a broader 'Is it possible for someone to eat so many carrots that they turn orange?' would be a good contribution.
– RogerFeb 7 at 14:51

All it needs to make it a good skeptics question is a better notable claim ("This source did say it at this time" rather than "I think I remember this source sayign this onece years ago".)
– Ben BardenFeb 7 at 15:40