"(Finders) Keepers" by M Saunders & J Kahn on "Save The Rainforest So We have Some Place To Boogie"

"Keepers (Finders)" by Saunders on "Merl Saunders and Friends"

"Keepers" by Merl Saunders and John Kahn on "Pure Jerry 4: Keystone, Berkeley"

"Finders Keepers" by General Norman Johnson and Jeffrey Bowen on "Garcia Live Volume 6"

Matt Schofield has tracked down the Johnson/Bowen tune from 1973 (recorded by Chairmen Of The Board) and says it is more or less the
same tune, though perhaps with enough differences for Merl Saunders to decide (sometimes!) subsequently to copyright it separately.

The Chairmen Of The Board recorded two versions, one with lyrics, one without. The lyrics were:

I found the love you threw away
Now you realize you made a mistake
But now she's mine and we're doing fine
You can't steal her love, no use in trying
Your eyes may shine, your teeth may grit
But none of this good loving are you gonna get

Chorus
Finder's keepers, losers weepers
I found the love you lost and I'm gonna keep her
Finder's keepers, losers weepers
I found the love you lost and I'm gonna keep her

This love of mine is super fine
Lord knows I'm glad I made her mine
You treat her bad, you know you made her sad
Now you realize the good thing you had
But it's too late, don't even try
Never gonna give her up, and I ain't lying

[chorus]

Your eyes may shine, your teeth may grit
But none of this good loving are you gonna get