Could we have given him 5.5 million pineapples instead?

Today, the Maple Leafs made Mikhail Grabovski their highest paid forward, at least until Phil Kessel is due up for his raise next season, with a five-year, $27.5 million contract extension.

It’s safe to say, with a $5.5 million annual salary taken in combination with the long term duration (five years), it cost the Leafs more than we expected to get their number one center under contract. It was rumoured Grabovski wanted Kessel money, which sounded ridiculous given Kessel signed his current deal coming off of a 36-goal season at age 22. Grabovski meanwhile is 28 and does not have a 30-goal season to his name yet, nor will he after this season, barring a scorching hot goal scoring streak to end his season (he sits at 20 goals). He has not broken the 60 point barrier yet in his career, and it’s unlikely that will happen this season either, though he would have had a shot if he didn’t miss five games to injury.

Let’s take a look at each team’s highest paid center after the jump.

Team

Center

Salary

Career Production

Anaheim

Ryan Getzlaf

5.35 million

0.93PPG

Boston

Patrice Bergeron

5 million

0.75PPG

Buffalo

Derek Roy

4 million

0.79PPG

Calgary

Olli Jokinen

3 million

0.66PPG

Carolina

Eric Staal

8.25 million

0.90PPG

Chicago

Jonathan Toews

6.3 million

0.89PPG

Colorado

Paul Statsny

6.6 million

0.88PPG

Columbus

Derek Brassard

3.2 million

0.54PPG

Dallas

Mike Riberio

5 million

0.76PPG

Detroit

Pavel Datsyuk

6.7 million

0.98PPG

Edmonton

Shawn Horcoff

5.5 million

0.58PPG

Florida

Stephen Weiss

3.1 million

0.61PPG

Los Angeles

Anze Kopitar

6.8 million

0.90PPG

Minnesota

Mikko Koivu

6.75 million

0.74PPG

Montreal

Scott Gomez

7.375 million

0.76PPG

Nashville

David Legwand

4.5 million

0.59PPG

New Jersey

Zach Parise (originally a center)

6 million (pending UFA)

0.82PPG

New York Islanders

John Tavares

5.5 million (starting next)

0.81PPG

New York Rangers

Brad Richards

6.66 million

0.91PPG

Ottawa

Jason Spezza

7 milllion

1.018PPG

Philadelphia

Daniel Briere

6.5 million

0.79PPG

Phoenix

Daymond Langkow

4.5 million

0.62PPG

San Jose

Joe Thornton

7 million

1 PPG

Toronto

Mikhail Grabovski

5.5 million

0.64PPG

Vancouver

Henrik Sedin

6.1 million

0.84PPG

Washington

Nicklas Backstrom

6.7 million

1.01PPG

Every single one of these players has at least one 60+ point season to their name except Derick Brassard, who makes only 3.2 million.

Production wise, it’s safe to say the Leafs are overpaying Mikhail Grabovski and by more than a little.

In many cases it appears teams got hometown discounts on their highest paid (and in most cases number one) centers, and the Leafs have not been able to gain that luxury with Grabovski.

Closest comparables in terms of salary are Ryan Getzlaf, Patrice Bergeron, Shawn Horcoff, Mike Ribeiro, John Tavares, and Zach Parise. Bergeron broke 70 points multiple times before signing is current deal. Getzlaf, Ribeiro and Parise (one-year extension) had all broken 80 before theirs. Tavares posted 67 points in 79 games at age 20 before signing his current $5.5 million extension back in September. Obviously Grabovski is in none in these players’ leagues, and in terms of production, Grabovski’s contract is much closer to Horcoff’s in value for the money.

The Leafs can somewhat be excused for overpaying on Grabovski. He poses more value to the Leafs than whatever they could have got for him in a trade at the deadline. He is the Leafs’ best two way center and consistently drives possession in the right direction. He has shown he can be a heart and soul player with a dogged determination, willing to take the physical punishment necessary to make a play. It also seems Grabovski will be Carlyle’s go-to center in key matchups.

Perhaps the biggest reason of all the Leafs overpaid for Grabovski is that there probably won’t be a better option in unrestricted free agency this off season. Even if a guy like Parise hits the open market, the type of bidding war Burke would have to enter into, and the amount of cap circumvention (by his rules) he’ll likely have to perform, would make the Leafs an unlikely candidate to land him. As Grabovski was a pending UFA, to an extent this speaks to how whacked the open market has gotten recently, to the point where Ville Leino can make $4.5 million a season for the next six years. But Grabovski wasn’t a UFA yet, and it’s unfortunate the Leafs could not get Grabovski signed at a more reasonable price like most teams seem to be able to do when extending the contracts of their top center talent.

Alec Brownscombe is the founder of MapleLeafsHotStove.com, where he has written daily about the Leafs since September of 2008. He was also the editor of the 2009-12 Maple Leafs Annuals. You can contact him at brownscombealec@gmail.com.