Tibetan and Himalayan Library - THL

Memorization and Liturgical Discipline

Memorization is an important element of the disciplinary practices on which Tibetan monasticism rests. It integrates monks into the
monastic community by enabling them to take part in the monastery’s collective
rituals, which are its central activities. On entering a monastery, the young monk
must first memorize its liturgy (chöchöchos spyod), which
is of two types. The exoteric liturgy contains a few short sūtras (such as the Heart
Sutra), confessional texts, prayers in the proper sense of the word (mönlamsmon
lam), and devotional practices such as the
Seven-limb worship. The esoteric liturgy comprises a
large number of tantric texts as well as the texts necessary to propitiate the
protectors.

The centrality of these liturgical practices varies from monastery to monastery. In
those specializing in liturgical services, such as the Tantric Monasteries and NamgyelRnam rgyal, ritual is the main activity. The
liturgy of these monasteries includes hundreds of folios whose memorization requires
several years of extremely demanding effort. The knowledge of new monks is tested: on
a number of occasions they must recite the entire liturgy of the monastery in front
of their peers. They are also sometimes examined privately by the higher authorities,
who may deliberately disrupt the recitation in order to see how deeply ingrained a
monk’s memorization is. A friend from NamgyelRnam rgyal recalls that the Dalai
Lama suddenly entered the room where he was reciting. Not content with
just listening to the recitation, the Dalai Lama proceeded to
scratch my friend’s back to test if his memorization was unshakable. Despite the
considerable emotion provoked by this gesture, my friend did not lose his
concentration and was able to continue to recite flawlessly.

In smaller monasteries like Rgan
Blo bzang rgya mtsho’s, the requirements are usually less
stringent, and the life of a young monk memorizing the liturgy can be quite pleasant,
provided that his teacher is not too harsh. By the age of seventeen (he had started
at eleven), GenlaRgan lags
had finished the first part of his task. He had memorized the exoteric part of the
liturgy, presumably together with the rituals of propitiation. Having finished the
bare minimum of memorization, he was ready to go on to the next step: a three-year
visit to one of the three monastic seats.

In the monastic universities, liturgy plays a less important role (relatively
speaking). Accordingly, in these institutions less time and effort are spent on
memorizing liturgical material. Nevertheless, only after mastering this liturgy are
monks admitted as full members of the monastery, able to take part in scholastic
activities.9 Thus, memorization of liturgical texts is a basic practice of Tibetan monasticism. Unlike scholarly training, which is
undertaken only by a small minority through many years of intense dedication,
memorization is the province of all the monks. It inculcates in them a sense of
discipline central to the monastic enterprise as they follow a daily routine under
the supervision of an authority. They start the day with an assignment from their
teacher and end it with the teacher’s examination of that same task. This cannot help
but greatly strengthen the sense of obedience that young monks develop toward their
teachers – a sense particularly reinforced by the ordeals of the daily examination,
and the possible punishments associated with it. But memorization’s most important
disciplinary role is that it forms monks into efficient members of the ritual
community. Rituals can be performed well only when they are properly memorized and
recited uniformly by all monks to the same tune and rhythm. This uniformity creates a
powerful effect that satisfies performers and supporters alike. The monks can feel
confident of the religious power or value of such practices, and sponsors, in turn,
feel justified in their support of the monastery.