"The left shoe fit better than the right, so I can understand dmc16's review about it being too loose and rubbing, but also the 2 shoe lovers' reviews that they fit well. They feel GREAT with a sock, but that won't work with the peep toe. So I will probably line them with black fleece, or cut open the toe of a pair of socks. Too adorable to send back when the rubbing can be fixed and I plan to wear them with jeans. I have a fairly narrow foot and they fit in the width. I wear a 7.5 in heels (8 in flats) and the 7.5 worked well with this shoe."