The reds were circling. They knew they were so close to gaining contol. All they had to do was wait for the pirates to jump on another unsuspecting pirate, and then pile on. When WK targeted loaf, they knew they had their chance. When loaf was thrown to the sharks it was discovred that he was

Spoiler:

a pirate

With the numbers remaining... the four who were impersonating pirates revealed themselves, surrounded the pirates and declared victory. COGRATULATIONS TO Sam’s Drunk Dog, Ulf, MRandall25, and Canaan!