What Is to Be Done

By Michael Reuben aka mreuben

Ever since I returned to the hobby in full force a few years ago, I’ve been reading blog after blog all proposing different ideas which would bring flocks of people to the hobby. More high-end products. More low-end products. Make it easier for set-builders. Make it more exciting for white-whale chasers. For prospectors. For kids. Of course, all of these proposals are worthwhile and needed for any good industry. As someone who is back fully into the hobby I say we don’t need to go out there and expect to find the magic bullet that will bring thousands more buyers into the market. It’s not like the next idea is really going to bring the masses back to the card industry.

First, as collectors we have to ask if we really want the hobby to return to its hey-day. The industry seems to have hit its peak in the late 80s and early 90s. Though there are some iconic cards from this era, it’s hard to disagree that this is the worst period of time for so much of what we look for in the hobby. Cards were poorly designed, companies found a variety of ways to swindle hobbyists to make a quick buck, everything was horribly overproduced. Many of the blogs I read on a regular basis note that many of the cards from that era are better used as kindling for a fire than as individual cards on the secondary market. Between the neons of the early years of Score and the unreadable, ‘futuristic’ designs of the mid 90s, these cards are simply painful to look at. If this is what will result from bringing a mass market back to card collecting, is this something that we all want – if we are already in the hobby?

Just like any other industry, the hobby should be comfortable with a steady 2% to 5% growth. This can be accomplished by continually putting out solid products that hit the markets we already have. Personally, I like vintage and sets that remind us of those looks. Because of that, I have Heritage, Allen and Ginter, and a variety of other products that come out to capitalize on that. I know I don’t like ‘prospecting’. Because of that, I almost never buy Bowman or Pro Debut, or those sets. I like to consider myself a mid-level hobbyist so I don’t go low-end with Opening Day, and I can’t afford to go high-end with Triple Threads. I’ve found my niche like so many others. So long as Topps – or whoever is making cards – makes sure to keep their consumers happy, the industry should be fine.

I roll my eyes at the gimmicky cards that still occasionally come out, but I know that is a draw for many of us. It’s not going to get me to buy a product or get me to stop buying. What I can’t stand though, is when there are obvious faux pas. The epic failure of the curved 2010 Topps Chrome really could have turned me off from a set I enjoy putting together. Poley Walnuts and Kaz Uzuki wouldn’t do the damage that a printing error almost did. I’m not a huge fan of this year’s Allen & Ginter design, but It’s a set that I’ll keep going after. However, the vintage-looking market is getting close to being over-saturated. I can’t put all of the sets together, between Ginter and Gypsy Queen and Lineage and Heritage. It gets to the point where instead of breaking boxes to try to complete sets like I did when I was a kid, I’ll either give up on sets all together or use trades and the secondary market to get the set put together, which doesn’t necessarily benefit the producers.

Ultimately my proposal is this: do well what you already do. Quality over quantity. Instead of five vintage looking sets, stick with two – Ginter and Heritage. If you come up with a design you want to use like Gypsy Queen, make it an insert for Ginter, not a whole separate set. Make Lineage an insert for the base set. Make one Chrome-like mid-level set, maybe two. There is no need for five different sets at the same price point that accomplish the same goal. We don’t need Triple Threads and Marquee and Tier One and whatever name they will use next year. Prospectors can accomplish their prospecting goals by going after one set with a bunch of inserts, subsets and parallels instead of having to break various different boxes.

Ultimately, while you’re looking for your new audience, don’t offend your current market.

Quality over quantity for sure. Thats why i am desperate for Stadium Club to return, beautiful cards where you could hold each one in your hands and no matter who the player was you could admire what the card looked like – a borderless high-gloss high contrast deep-colored action picture, this to me is what I personally want in baseball cards.

I think the 80′s and 90′s could have been great if Topps wasn’t so greedy and mass produced so many cards. Collectors want production to be down and makers want to sell as much as possible. Makes for a tough common ground. I do think that we can bring the youth back into the hobby by making it less expensive yet worth while. High end products only narrow the collecting pool. Most young collectors can afford to enter without breaking the piggy bank. That said however..Dealers are only making this hobby worse by lowering prices. I would rather sit on cards for years than continue to lower standards and value by giving in. If this keeps up, Beckett will be useless.

By Ryan Kalmoe aka SWOWannabe I still remember sitting on my hideous fake brown leather couch watching Game 6 of the 1991 World Series between the Minnesota Twins and the Atlanta Braves. With the game tied and going into extra innings and the Twins’ championship hopes on the line, my father was more than willing…

By Guy Mitchell aka sweetg1 As we embark upon the new season, I’d like to share what the 2012 season meant to me and my son. On June 24, 1976, my dad changed my life when he took me to my very first baseball game. I remember the event well. We were in Houston on…

By Richard Mueller aka Ripken When people ask “Why do you collect?” many of us would probably simply say, “well, because it’s fun.” But there’s always something behind why we find it enjoyable. The origins of collecting go way back. Humans have a deeply ingrained need to hoard things that will help us survive the…

By RiceBondsMntna2Rice Ever had one of those weeks where you realize you’re trying too hard get a trade done? Yeah me too. After some time away from the hobby, I was eager to again experience the rush that comes from making two collections better all at once. My last trade left only good memories since…

By J.R. Lebert aka jrlebert 50 years. 8,019 games. To type those two numbers seems almost laughable, but there they are, in black and white. Tim Kurkjian and Jayson Stark of ESPN marvelled at the streak’s length. Gary Cohen and Howie Rose, the Mets’ play-by-play voices on television and radio, thought it would never…

By J.R. Lebert aka jelebert Does Matt Kemp have a chance at the Triple Crown? *NOTE: As of the time of writing this article, Matt Kemp and the Los Angeles Dodgers had played 20 games. Kemp was leading the NL in batting average at .452, home runs with 10, and was second, by one, in…

By Michael Reuben aka mreuben Because it’s not one of the major companies, Tristar doesn’t get enough credit for its Obak sets. Far from the most attractive set, it does what amateur historians of sports want to see. While the major companies, Topps, Panini and Upper Deck, allow us to look to the present to…

By Phillip White aka Phill11ASU It’s almost opening day and here’s this year’s first power rankings for Major League Baseball. 1. Anaheim Angels The addition of Pujols makes this a very powerful team. They are deep in the outfield and have some great pitching. Their biggest concern heading into the…

By Jeff Hacket aka txtaz1102 What does card collecting mean to you? To me, growing up it was another way to connect with my parents, they would buy the packs of cards and we would open them and spend time together going over the cards we had gotten and the ones we still needed. My…

By Sean McCafferty aka 30ranfordfan I’m not going to write another cliché filled article about why Toronto’s Rogers Centre is a bad place to watch baseball. If you go to Google, and spend about 30 seconds searching, you’ll be able to find lots of them. Truth is the Rogers Centre (formally known as Skydome) is…