HISTORY:- Born in Menfi, Agrigento but moved to Marsala, in
Trapani Province, on the west coast of Sicily. Arrived in USA as a 16
year-old in 1903, possibly fleeing a murder charge, although his age would
appear to refute this. Settled in Mulberry bend district of Manhattan, joining
his Father, who had emigrated in 1899. His first arrest in America came in
1907, for burglary. He may have worked for Ciro Terranova at this time. During
these early years Masseria was a street criminal, specialising in burglary. He
also compiled arrests for assault and extortion. There was also a suspicion
that he was involved in the Blackhand kidnapping of a child in 1910.

Some writers suggest that Masseria fell out with the
Terranova/Morello group and split from them in 1913. They also state that he
was responsible for the murders ofThomas[1915] and Fortunato[1914] LoMonte, cousins of the Morello
brothers. At this time the Morello’s were involved in a conflict with local
Neapolitan gangsters, so it’s not clear who killed the LoMonte’s. What we do
know is that in 1913 Masseria was arrested, again for burglary. Tried the
following year, he was convicted and sentenced to 4 years. Salvatore and
Giuseppe Ruffino, his accomplices in this crime, ironically, would later be
closely associated with the Castellamarese Family, Masseria’s future
enemies.

He seems to have been released in 1916, and returned to the Lower East Side. At this time the Terranova/Morello gang
were involved in a war with the Brooklyn Camorra. Although emerging victorious,
they were seriously weakened, and retreated to their Harlem stronghold around
116th street, leaving Little Italy open territory. Masseria was only
one of many ambitious gunmen hoping to dominate this territory. Over the next
few years he built-up his alliances. Masseria must have been inducted into
Mafia by this point, probably by the Morello’s. But who exactly were his allies
and supporters, is a question never answered. Some writers claim he was already
an important gang leader by 1920, and credit him with inducting young
Italo-Americans, like Luciano. This seems unlikely as Masseria only emerges as
a leader after 1922.

The coming of prohibition in 1920 was the trigger for a huge
upsurge in crime. The Italians, used to brewing their own wine for centuries,
had no inhibitions about breaking a law many saw as unworkable. Soon Little
Italy had hundreds of home stills and speakeasies. Masseria’s sister ran a
speakeasy on Forsythe Street.
Masseria, among many others, started organising the new trade, using contacts
like Gaetano Pennachio. Pennachio, known as Tommy the Bull, ran a sort of
bootleg market, known as the Curb Exchange, at the corner of Mulberry and Grand
streets. Here bootleggers would meet on the street, only one block from Police
HQ, to sell or trade their alcohol.

Masseria soon became a big man on the Curb Exchange, using a
social club on the corner of Mulberry and Kenmare streets as a HQ. One of his
neighbours was Luciano, who had an office across the street, over a garage. At
this early stage, it’s not clear if Luciano was totally independent or working
for Masseria.

Masseria first came to public notice late in 1920, when a
rival bootlegger called Salvatore Mauro, ambushed him on Chrystie Street. When the gun smoke
cleared it was Mauro who lay dead. Masseria was arrested, but claimed
self-defence. Mauro was a partner in a speakeasy, on Grand Street, with Umberto Valenti.
Valenti, who lived on Mulberry
Street, was a feared gunman and ally of Salvatore
D’Aquila, an enemy of the Morello’s and NYC Mafia Head.

We now enter a confusing period, where it’s hard to
establish who was allied to whom. Joseph Morello had been NYC Mafia Head, until
jailed in 1910, D’Aquila succeeded him. Morello had been released in 1920, but
D’Aquila had condemned him and his followers to death. Valenti had been
D’Aquila’s favourite killer, but they had fallen out, and he too was condemned.
This much we know from Nicola Gentile. If Valenti returned to D’Aquila’s
allegiance, Mauro’s attack on Masseria may have been the first shot in the
conflict. This would put Masseria in Morello’s camp, which would be in line
with future alliances. But if Valenti was allied with Morello, both being
condemned by D’Aquila, Masseria may have been D’Aquila’s man. Take your
pick.

Whatever, the Morello/Terranova group had lost several men
during 1920-21, including Joseph Peppo[Viserte], George Terranova, and Joseph
Lagumina. At the Peppo murder, a witness put Masseria in the vicinity. Then in
May 1922 Vincent Terranova, Ciro’s brother was killed in Harlem.
The same day Valenti was ambushed on Grand
Street, he survived but his bodyguard eventually
died of his wounds. Masseria was arrested fleeing the scene and charged with
murder.

The conflict had now become a personal fight between Valenti
and Masseria. After laying low for 3 months, vainly hoping the law would remove
his rival, Valenti struck back in August. Masseria had just left his home on 2nd.
Avenue, when two gunmen ambushed him. Masseria fled into a shop, one of the
gunmen followed and took several shots at point blank range. This is where the
Masseria legend was born, as he somehow dodged the bullets, surviving without a
scratch.

Masseria had been lucky, and he knew it, the next move had
to be decisive. Contact was made, possibly between Morello and D’Aquila, and a
peace meeting arranged. Valenti and Masseria, plus one bodyguard each, met in a
restaurant on East 12th Street. Valenti’s bodyguard may have been
Rosario Dongarra, who was questioned by the police about the incident.
Masseria’s bodyguard is unknown, although legend has it that it was Luciano.
After a meal, drinks and an amicable talk, the foursome walked along the
street, towards 2nd Avenue. But Masseria had stationed two more of
his men at the corner, seeing them Valenti ran, almost reaching a cab, before a
bullet hit him in the spine, killing him. Masseria was now the dominant Mafioso
in Little Italy.

Masseria had no discernable gang, no connected relatives,
his brother John is the only possible exception, no known compare’s from Marsala. Therefore he had
to rely on alliances, and he had to be practical, rather than traditional, in
those alliances. Little Italy’s population was a mixture ofSicilians, Neapolitans and Calabrians. He
could not be clannish, like the other Family groups, so he made a virtue out of
this, and made allies among the non-Sicilian gangs. The most important of these
were Frank Ioele[Yale], a Calabrian and the dominant power in South
Brooklyn. His longstanding alliance with Ciro Terranova, a native
of Corleone, led to further allies among the Corleonese, notably Gaetano
Reina’s faction in the Bronx. And then there
were the younger, Americanised gangsters, like Luciano and his associates
Genovese [Neapolitan] and Costello [Calabrian].

With these allies, Masseria grew in influence, wealth and
power, until by 1928 he posed a serious threat to D’Aquila’s position as Head
of the NYC Mafia. Following his usual plan, Masseria was already in contact
with disgruntled members of D’Aquila’s Family.

It was at this point that Frankie Yale was killed, and
although his murder wasprobably ordered
by Capone in Chicago,
rather than his local Sicilian enemies, it was the spark that set off several
conflicts. D’Aquila saw an opportunity to move into Yale’s territory, and
meeting opposition from Yale’s men, he ordered the murder of Michele
Abbatemarco, a Yale ally. Anthony Carfano, the new leader of Yale’s old gang,
went to Masseria for support. This was the opening Masseria had been waiting
for, an opportunity to eliminate his main rival, and gain a foothold in Brooklyn. Contacting his ally in D’Aquila’s Family, Manfredi
Mineo, they agreed a strategy. Four days after Abbatemarco’s murder, D’Aquila
was confronted by 3 of his own men, on a Brooklyn
street. After a violent argument, they shot him dead.

Following this killing, confusion reigned among the Brooklyn gangs. A meeting of Sicilian Mafiosi was held in
Cleveland, to
discuss this and the Capone-Aiello conflict in Chicago. The police raided this meeting,
thereby disrupting mediation efforts. It should be noted that members of the
D’Aquila and Profaci Families were present, but Masseria does not seem to have
been represented.

The failure of the meeting, and the arrests, weakened the
D’Aquila Family. To replace D’Aquila as NYC Mafia Head, Masseria backed former
Head Joseph Morello, a long time ally. Morello then appointed Mineo the new
Boss of the D’Aquila Family, over the heads of more senior members. Morello
with a strong following among the Corleonese, and Masseria had influence over
and allies within, almost all the other Families and factions. The only holdouts
were the Castellamarese and Profaci Families.

Masseria has been portrayed as stupid, uncouth, a
megalomaniac and a failure. But although there is no doubt he was a gangster,
rather than a traditional Mafioso, he somehow rose from street thug to the most
important Italian criminal on the east coast, in 10 short years. To achieve
this he showed courage, ruthlessness, craftiness and a much more modern
attitude than his “Mustache Pete” adversaries. He also left the corpses of a
long line of, supposedly more intelligent, enemies behind him. There may be
some truth in the theory that Morello was responsible for some of this success.
He had himself survived for 30 years, in the violent world of Mafia, and
Maranzano was known to fear him more than Masseria.

Joe the Boss was now
at the peak of his power, but he, like Maranzano later, was to discover holding
onto that position was harder than attaining it. He had by now moved into a
luxury apartment, on Central Park West. Wealthy, respected and feared, but his
dominance would be brief. For now though his advice was sought by important
Mafiosi nationwide.

In 1929 Joseph
Aiello, the leader of the Sicilians in Chicago
and an enemy of Capone, invited Masseria to Chicago to mediate the dispute.Aiello had been unsuccessfully fighting
Capone’s mainly Neapolitan gang since 1927. He had allies in Detroit, Buffalo and Brooklyn,
but was unable to overcome the powerful Capone organisation. With Aiello at the
meeting was Gaspare Milazzo, a native of Castellamare, an important Detroit
Mafioso and close ally of Aiello. The meeting did not go well, Masseria
seemingly upsetting his host. He returned to NYC and angrily denounced Aiello
and Milazzo. Masseria instead made a deal with Capone, promising to induct him
into Mafia, after he had eliminated Aiello. Capone was not only a Neapolitan,
but had been involved in prostitution, both anathema to the Sicilians.
Opposition spread among the more traditional Mafiosi.

Sensing this Masseria called Milazzo to NYC, and tried to
get him to betray Aiello. Milazzo refused and informed his fellow
Castellamarese in Brooklyn and Buffalo. This was how
things stood when in February 1930 the head of the Detroit Mafia died of natural
causes. The obvious successor was Milazzo, but Masseria secretly backed another
non-Castellamarese candidate.

Back in New York,
Masseria was about to make a fatal mistake. Gaetano Reina, a “compare” of
Morello and head of a Family, had organized a monopoly on Ice distribution in
NYC. He operated an Association of Ice distributers, collecting dues, and
controlling prices. This racket was very lucrative in the days before
refridgeration, and Masseria demanded a share of the profits. Reina resisted,
trying to protect his Families independence. Masseria and Morello followed the
usual tried and trusted plan. They eliminated Reina, shot outside his mistress
home in the Bronx, in February 1930. The actual
killer may have been Vito Genovese. Morello, acting as NYC Mafia Head,
appointed an outsider, Joseph Pinzolo, as the new Family Boss. Pinzolo was an
old Black Hander, and ally of Masseria. An opposition faction, led by Tommaso
Gagliano, formed to resist Pinzolo, Morello and Masseria. Initially they
pretended loyalty, waiting for their strength to grow, and seeking the right
moment to strike back.

Meanwhile Masseria was still trying to bring the
recalcitrant Milazzo under control. Attempts to influence him through fellow
Castellamarese Stefano Magaddino in Buffalo,
and Nicola Schiro, the leader of the Castellamarese in Brooklyn,
failed. Masseria found their resistance and solidarity annoying, but sensed a
weakness in Schiro. Rumour has it that he kidnapped a leading Castellamarese,
held him hostage in a noose, and extorted $10,000 for his release. This was to
humiliate and intimidateSchiro and his
Family. Schiro’s prestige was destroyed, and he would soon flee the city.

At this period several murders took place in Brooklyn, Giuseppe Peraino, an important ally of Profaci
,victim of a Sicilian-Calabrian conflict, and Joseph Riggio a victim of the Ice
racket conflict, being the most prominent. There is also evidence of early
casualties among the Castellamarese, both Anthony Bonventre and John Torres
died in March.

By summer 1930 the situation in Detroit had deteriorated into open warfare
between Milazzo and Masseria’s ally Cesare Lamare. In June a peace meeting was
arranged, in a fish market. Milazzo and his aide Salvatore Parrino attended,
but it was a trap and they were killed. This led to an upsurge in gang warfare
over the next few months.

The murder of Milazzo caused the Brooklyn Castellamarese to
call a meeting to discuss their response. Schiro called for caution, but a new
power in the Family Salvatore Maranzano, spoke for retaliation. The question
was still unresolved when, a short time later Vito Bonventre, a senior member
of the Family, was killed outside his home in Brooklyn.
Now there could be no pretence, Masseria had declared war.

With the Castellamarese now leaderless, Maranzano and
Magaddino came to an agreement to prosecute the war. Maranzano would be Boss in
Brooklyn, Magaddino and Aiello would support
him with men and money. Maranzano targeted Morello, who he considered the
strategist of the opposition. So in August 1930, Morello was killed in his
office in Harlem, by the Castellamarese killer
Buster Domingo.

The loss of Morello forced Masseria to depend more on his
allies Mineo and Terranova. In September he suffered another loss, when the
Gagliano faction murdered Joseph Pinzolo, gunned down in Gaetano Lucchese’s
office. Gagliano, Lucchese and followers continued to pretend loyalty, even
attending a meeting called to discuss the Pinzolo killing. Following this
Maranzano contacted Gagliano and proposed an alliance, against the common
enemy. It was agreed that Maranzano would lead, with Gagliano, essentially a
businessman, providing finance.

Masseria and his allies continued to strike back, Frank
Italiano, a known Castellamarese, was wounded and his partner killed. Capone
finally ended his war in Chicago, Aiello being killed, also in October. Despite
this success, the war took a decisive turn against Masseria in November. One of
Gagliano’s spotters, Joseph Valachi, had moved into an apartment in the Bronx near Stefano Ferrigno, Mineo’s Under-Boss. One day
in November 1930 he spotted Masseria, Mineo and Ferrigno entering the
apartment. Several other supporters attended, what seems to have been a
strategy meeting. A combined Maranzano-Gagliano hit team rented the apartment
next door to Ferrigno, and waited for Masseria to emerge. He, cautious as ever,
remained indoors, but when Mineo and Ferrigno appeared, they were killed.
Masseria was reputed to have discovered Gagliano’s treachery by tracing
Valachi’s furniture.

With this loss, and a warning from the Chief of Police to
stop the violence, Masseria seems to have lost heart. A commission to mediate
the war was appointed, at a meeting in Boston.
Masseria offered to retire, but Maranzano insisted on his death. Atruce was finally arranged early in 1931,
after pressure from Capone. Masseria went into hiding, possibly living with his
ally Anthony Carfano.

The truce lasted only until February, when Joseph Catania,
Terranova’s nephew was murdered in the Bronx.
Within days Masseria’s ally in Detroit,
Cesare Lamare, was killed. The war was lost and Masseria’s remaining supporters
knew it. At this late point Luciano finally emerged as a dominant force.
Meeting with Maranzano, he agreed to kill Masseria and end the war.

The conspiracy to kill Masseria contained several close
allies of his. Carfano was seen at the murder scene, Scarpato’s restaurant in Coney Island, hours earlier. Terranova reputedly drove
the killers car, losing respect by panicking after the murder. Scarpato, who
may have been connected, conveniently went for a walk. The actual murderers
were Masseria men, probably Frank Livorsi, Joseph Stracci and Joseph Rao. And
of course Luciano the organiser, who lured him out of hiding and into a trap.
The legend of Luciano remaining after the murder, is open to question. Only
Scarpato was on the scene when police arrived.

It was reported that after the murder 20 supporters gathered
at the family home on 2nd
Avenue, to protect his family. At the funeral no
known gangsters were present. John a brother was killed in 1937.

There is no need to recount events after Masseria’s death,
except to note that Maranzano lasted only 6 months, Scarpato a year, and
Terranova was forcibly retired and dead within 6 years.

Tuesday, 18 March 2014

I first became interested in Mafia history after reading the
book The Canary that Sang in the late 1960’s. Then, in 1974, I hitched around
the USA and collected more OC books along the way. Eventually I decided to try
to compile a chart of “original” members of the NYC Families. Using the Valachi
charts as a starting point, and adding more names from every book, document,
article and any other informed source I could find. Slowly it became a
nationwide search, with the other cities Cosa Nostra Families involved.

The spread of the Internet, the easy access to Government
and State records, newspaper archives, websites like Ancestry, NARA, Ellis
Island, ect., have made researching much easier. Modern authors on the subject,
have been much more diligent in their research.

Like most researchers I always meant to write a book, but
found it beyond my capabilities. I feel that I have reached the point where I
need outside input. Keeping information to yourself is pointless. So I have
decided to put all my “stuff” on a blog, and encourage viewers to contact me to
suggest changes, additions or deletions.

I am not conceited enough to believe my charts are anywhere
near perfect. If they are 60-70% accurate i would be happy, but I think 40-50%
is more likely. There has to be a starting point, so I have used the 1931
reorganization of the American Mafia / Cosa Nostra as that starting point. In
some instances members from the 1910-20’s are included, but only if the source
is unimpeachable [i.e. Valachi, Gentile, Bonanno, ect.].

Ethnicity was important in the early days, so I have
included place of birth, where known. Relatives are even more so, and are
listed if known. Any name with an asterisk * is a probable, but unconfirmed,
member. Members will only be listed once, irrespective of the length of their membership. The charts are divided into time periods as follows : - 1920/30’s-1950
– originals

1950’s-70’s
– including the large increase of the 1950’s

1980’s-2000
–

Present members – this is others research, and can be found elsewhere i.e.Pogo's present NYC Family charts on the Real Deal forum. The last chart is of names of possible members [NYC, NYS and NJ] whose Family membership is unknown.

I hope this helps viewers to understand the charts, and am
looking forward to any feedback.