Broad Language of Waiver in Prenuptial Agreement Is Sufficient to Waive a Spouse’s Claim to Assets Acquired – See more at: /notable-cases/#sthash.ImR5ceC1.dpuf

Florida Supreme Court Approves Fourth DCA Decision That Broad Language of Waiver in Prenuptial Agreement is Sufficient to Waive a Spouse’s Claim to Assets Acquired or Enhancement in Value

Hahamovitch v. Hahamovitch, SC14-277 (Fla. Sept. 10, 2015).

The Florida Supreme Court recently approved of a Fourth DCA decision holding that broad language of waiver in a prenuptial agreement is sufficient to waive a spouse’s claims to any assets titled in the other spouse’s name, and to any enhancement in value from assets titled in the other spouse’s name acquired during the marriage.

The parties’ prenuptial agreement was executed in 1986. Both parties had the advice of separate counsel, and multiple drafts of the agreement were exchanged prior to its execution. In the executed agreement, the wife waived and released any potential claim to alimony of any kind. The agreement also contained broad language of waiver and release as to assets, whereby the wife ostensibly waived and released any claim to assets titled solely in the husband’s name that were acquired during the marriage. The parties filed for dissolution of marriage in 2008, and the trial court found that the prenuptial agreement was valid.

The Fourth DCA analyzed the wife’s challenge to the prenuptial agreement under Casto v. Casto, 508 So.2d 330, 333 (Fla. 1987). As to the first basis for challenge under Casto, the Fourth DCA affirmed the trial court’s conclusion that the wife failed to establish that the agreement was invalid for fraud or misrepresentation. Hahamovitch v. Hahamovitch, 133 So. 3d 1008, 1011 (Fla. 4th DCA 2014). As to the second basis, the Fourth DCA also concluded that the agreement was fair at the time it was entered. The Fourth DCA also interpreted the language of the prenuptial agreement as “broad enough to waive the wife’s right to any asset titled in the husband’s name that was acquired or enhanced during the marriage with marital labor or earnings.” Id. at 1013. However, the Fourth DCA certified conflict with decisions of the Second DCA and Third DCA on the issue due to case law from those courts that construed substantially similar title provisions in prenuptial agreements as insufficient to waive a spouse’s claim to the enhancement in value of the other spouse’s non-marital property that resulted from marital earnings. Id. at 1016.

The Florida Supreme Court approved the Fourth DCA’s decision. The Florida Supreme Court rejected the wife’s argument that the absence of any reference in the prenuptial agreement to enhancement in value of nonmarital property attributable to marital labor or funds made the enhanced value subject to equitable distribution. The Florida Supreme Court also rejected the wife’s argument that the lack of a provision that the husband’s earnings would be his separate property meant they were not protected assets. The Florida Supreme Court concluded that the plain meaning of the broad language of waiver and release was sufficient for the wife to have waived any claim to property titled in the husband’s name, or enhancement in value of such property. The Florida Supreme Court also rejected the reasoning expressed in contrary cases from the Second DCA and Third DCA as inconsistent with the plain language of the prenuptial agreement.

* THE DECISION IS NOT FINAL UNTIL TIME EXPIRES TO FILE A REHEARING MOTION, AND IF FILED, DETERMINED. *

The Law Offices of Robin Bresky is a dedicated appellate law firm handling
civil and criminal court appeals in all District Courts of Appeal in
Florida. The firm also provides effective trial and litigation support.
The firm serves Boca Raton, Delray Beach, Boynton Beach, West Palm Beach,
Coral Springs, Parkland, Margate, Lauderhill, Fort Lauderdale, Deerfield
Beach, Miami-Dade, Broward and Palm Beach Counties, and all the trial courts and
lower tribunals within the jurisdiction of the Fourth District Court of
Appeal, the federal Eleventh Circuit Court of Appeals, and the Florida
Supreme Court and all other appellate courts in Florida, including the
appellate divisions of the circuit courts (which hear appeals from county
courts).

Boca Raton Office

Bank of America Building

150 East Palmetto Park Rd.
Suite 340
Boca Raton,FL33432-4848

West Palm Beach Office

West Palm Beach

319 Clematis Street
Suite 1006
West Palm Beach,FL33401

Miami Office

One Biscayne Tower

2 S. Biscayne Blvd
Suite 3760
Miami,FL33131(Available by Appointment)

Phone

Email

Connect With Us

The information on this website is for general information purposes
only. Nothing on this site should be taken as legal advice for any
individual case or situation. This information is not intended to
create, and receipt or viewing does not constitute, an attorney-client
relationship.

No content on this site may be reused in any fashion without written
permission from The Law Offices of Robin Bresky.