I like your pick for Van Buren as the Eagles best running back in franchise history. However, you could make the argument Wilbert Montgomery based off of his yardage amount and games played for the Eagles. I would still give the edge to Van Buren based on his dominance in the '40s.

Ricky Williams is a terrible choice for the Dolphins. He had a monster 1,853 yard season followed by a 3.5 yards per carry season and he only topped 1,000 yards once more for the Dolphins. Not Dolphins GOAT RB in my opinion.

I immedately thought of Csonka for the Dolphins. But since someone on the team labeled him a full back instead of a half back, then he can't be considered the best Dolphins running back of all time. Never mind he ran the ball.

i think Dillon's departure from Cincinnati was rough and might not be viewed as the best RB by Bengals fans. I know I can't stand the guy only due to his comments at departure.

If I had to choose a best RB for Cincinnati, it would be James Brooks and his 8 pro bowls.

Brooks was a great all around back (only 4 Pro Bowls though) but Pete Johnson should be in the discussion as well. 82 career TD's in only 8 seasons and helped get the Bengals to their 1st Super Bowl appearance.

How does The Juice keep getting the nod over Thurman Thomas for the Bills? Simpson had a great five year stretch, but I think we glorify what he did over the course of his career. Thomas had over 16,000 yards from scrimmage.

How does The Juice keep getting the nod over Thurman Thomas for the Bills? Simpson had a great five year stretch, but I think we glorify what he did over the course of his career. Thomas had over 16,000 yards from scrimmage.

The talent surrounding Thurman was head and shoulders better than anyone OJ had on his Bills team.

EDIT: Not taking anything away from Thurman at all, still one of the greats but I think OJ still has the edge. 2003 rushing yards in 14 games is absolutely ridiculous.

Holy crap! This thread is getting ridiculous! I don't even know where to start. Sayers over Payton!!? Gore over Craig!!? Williams or Csonka!?! Faulk over Dickerson?!!? etc etc. The average age on this forum must be about 13. I am just going to save myself the trouble and leave this thread never to return.

Holy crap! This thread is getting ridiculous! I don't even know where to start. Sayers over Payton!!? Gore over Craig!!? Williams or Csonka!?! Faulk over Dickerson?!!? etc etc. The average age on this forum must be about 13. I am just going to save myself the trouble and leave this thread never to return.