Whisky flavoured foods

Should whisky &quot;flavouring&quot; be banned?

Yes

11

37%

No

19

63%

Total votes : 30

Whisky flavoured foods

by Deactivated Member » Sun Feb 26, 2006 3:26 pm

I have a thing about mass produced whisky flavoured items such as fudge, marmalade, shortbread(!) etc. I think it is a gimmicky and spoils the taste of both the original products and tries to generalise the flavour of whisky.
There is a difference in home made goodies where the decerning cook/chef can match the whisky of choice with foodstuff.
So, I call for a ban on cheap, tacky and tasteless items that claim to contain whisky. Who is with me on this?

Re: Whisky flavoured foods

Crieftan wrote:So, I call for a ban on cheap, tacky and tasteless items that claim to contain whisky. Who is with me on this?

I concur Crieftan if someone wants to pick up a whisky flavoured item, make sure it's in a bottle. A well meaning relative has brought me a fruitcake from Halifax laced with Glen Breton. 1) Not my favorite whisky 2) I don't like fruitcake
so we'll toss it to the hounds at the next whisky tasting. (ah hah ha ha haa ha). Came in a nice tin 'though. Musky P.

Re: Whisky flavoured foods

Muskrat Portage wrote:........if someone wants to pick up a whisky flavoured item, make sure it's in a bottle. A well meaning relative has brought me a fruitcake from Halifax laced with Glen Breton. 1) Not my favorite whisky 2) I don't like fruitcakeso we'll toss it to the hounds at the next whisky tasting. (ah hah ha ha haa ha). Came in a nice tin 'though. Musky P.

Here here.... but whiskey in a bottle ... that would be a novel idea.. you could be on to something there

I love my whiskey and probably drink too much of it so I have no real interest in food that has whiskey laced through it. I get enough out of a bottle as it is

Sorry for digging up this old thread but yesterday I went hunting for blue stilton cheese and found that my local store had - not only my favourite "Cropwell Bishop Creamery's Blue Stilton" but also something called "Blue Shropshire With Whisky". The back of the jar states it contains whisky. This is a top quality cheese producer so I'm not concerned about that but I was wondering if any of you have tried it and what you think?

I've had two whisky-flavored tablets recently. I have to say I didn't really care for either one, and will stick to the straight stuff from now on.

Harry, I'd gladly send you the remnants of my Moine Mhor tablet, but the stuff doesn't travel well. I carried a couple of these in my jacket pocket on the flight home, and I guess my body heat caused them to soften up; they have stayed soft, rather than returning to their proper texture. I hope the ones I mailed to a friend fared better.

I've had a couple of whisky-flavored cheeses, and liked them fine.

Whiskey sauce on steak always seems to mean bourbon, or worse, Jack Daniel's, even in Scotland. Can't anyone do a good malt sauce? In restaurants, especially, this concept suffers from the notion that it's not worth using the "good stuff" for this purpose. GIGO. (Don't mean to imply that bourbon is G--just that, in such cases, it seems the cheapest ingredients possible are used.)

I've not had any whisky flavored foods, but have had Whiskey (bourbon) flavored stuff.

Most chain restaurants here in the states have some sort of "whiskey" BBQ sauce for chicken or beef (often JD brand). I think the stuff is universally awful, but it must work in marketing for the TGIF's, Applebees, ruby tuesdays, Chilli's,... of the world. When I see stuff like this though, I feel it's less an offence to fans of fine bourbon, but more to the BBQ aficionados out there who must really be saddened in seeing these BBQ abominations being pandered out en mass.

Choochoo wrote:I think the stuff is universally awful, but it must work in marketing for the TGIF's, Applebees, ruby tuesdays, Chilli's,... of the world.

Good point (and add Wetherspoon's, UK pub chain, to the list). I'm afraid I spend far too much time in this kind of prefab faux restaurant, thanks to the fact that I so often find myself involuntarily in Strip Mall World.

I have mixed the fruit cake up with the 'mighty' christmas pudding we have over here, its kind of a steamed fruit cake that gets fed whisky or brandy or sherry for a few months, then, after christmas dinner, you set fire to it with even more spirit !!!. When it goes out, you tuck in !!!

Thesh wrote:Government aint there to nitpick and control or even worry about meaningless issues like whisky and cooking.

That's what disgruntled mobs are for.

Yeah, governments are there to claim they have a better record on whisky and cooking than the opposition parties. I can just see an angry mob descending on Keith Floyd's (notoriously boozy English chef) restaurant to destroy his recipe for whisky soaked clams...

Speaking of Keith Floyd my missus was shocked to see him make a guest appearance on a children's show she was watching with our 3yo expression until I explained it was filmed just down the road from a distillery.

I have finally tried "Blue Shropshire With Whisky" from Cropwell Bishop Creamery. It is the strangest cheese I've ever tasted and I cannot help but think both the whisky and the chease would be better off enjoyed separately? I'm very much a cheese lover but this one is a strange beast and I cannot decide if I like or dislike it? I'll try again later.

Whisky flavouring should be banned by law. However real whisky if fresh ingredients cooked fresh can be fantastic. Its the syntheticaly produced flavourings that are just too disgusting. Just like cheap Cola lollies when you're young. Yuuuukkkkkkkkkkkk.

les taylor wrote:Whisky flavouring should be banned by law. However real whisky if fresh ingredients cooked fresh can be fantastic. Its the syntheticaly produced flavourings that are just too disgusting. Just like cheap Cola lollies when you're young. Yuuuukkkkkkkkkkkk.

Good products sympatheticaly used always work together in my opinion.

I agree with you but the "Blue Shropshire With Whisky" from Cropwell Bishop Creamery went straight into the bin last night. Bloody awful it is - and this isn't a producer cutting a few corners, but the most renowned Stilton producer. 10 percent of the jar's contents was whisky of some sort - not a flavouring agent with "whisky qualities" .