Going off script, Trump bashes immigration at tax cut event

By Catherine Lucey and Jonathan Lemire

Published
3:29 pm PDT, Thursday, April 5, 2018

EDS. RETRANSMISSION TO CORRECT BYLINE TO DOUG MILLS *** President Donald Trump tosses his "prepared" remarks into the air as he participates in a roundtable discussion on tax reform in White Sulphur Springs, West Virginia, April 5, 2018. (Doug Mills/The New York Times) less

EDS. RETRANSMISSION TO CORRECT BYLINE TO DOUG MILLS *** President Donald Trump tosses his "prepared" remarks into the air as he participates in a roundtable discussion on tax reform in White Sulphur Springs, ... more

Photo: DOUG MILLS, NYT

Photo: DOUG MILLS, NYT

Image
1of/3

Caption

Close

Image 1 of 3

EDS. RETRANSMISSION TO CORRECT BYLINE TO DOUG MILLS *** President Donald Trump tosses his "prepared" remarks into the air as he participates in a roundtable discussion on tax reform in White Sulphur Springs, West Virginia, April 5, 2018. (Doug Mills/The New York Times) less

EDS. RETRANSMISSION TO CORRECT BYLINE TO DOUG MILLS *** President Donald Trump tosses his "prepared" remarks into the air as he participates in a roundtable discussion on tax reform in White Sulphur Springs, ... more

Photo: DOUG MILLS, NYT

Going off script, Trump bashes immigration at tax cut event

1 / 3

Back to Gallery

WHITE SULPHUR SPRINGS, W.V. — Tossing his “boring” prepared remarks into the air, President Trump on Thursday unleashed a fierce denunciation of the nation’s immigration policies, calling for tougher border security while repeating his unsubstantiated claim that “millions” of people voted illegally in California.

Trump was in West Virginia to showcase the benefits of Republican tax cuts, but he took a big and meandering detour to talk about his tough immigration and trade plans. He linked immigration with the rise of violent gangs like MS-13 and suggested anew that there had been widespread fraud in the 2016 election.

“In many places, like California, the same person votes many times. You probably heard about that,” Trump said. “They always like to say, ‘Oh, that’s a conspiracy theory.’ Not a conspiracy theory, folks. Millions and millions of people. And it’s very hard because the state guards their records. They don’t want us” to see them.

Though there have been isolated cases of voter fraud in the U.S., past studies have found it to be exceptionally rare.

Trump initially claimed last year that widespread voting fraud had occurred in what appeared to be a means of explaining away his popular-vote defeat. Earlier this year, the White House disbanded a controversial voter fraud commission amid infighting and lawsuits as state officials refused to cooperate.

In recent weeks, Trump has been pushing back more against the restraints of the office to offer more unvarnished opinions and take policy moves that some aides were trying to forestall. His remarks in West Virginia, like so many of his previous planned policy speeches, quickly came instead to resemble one of his freewheeling rallies.

“This was going to be my remarks. They would have taken about two minutes,” Trump said as he tossed his script into the air. “This is boring. We have to tell it like it is.”

As he has done before, Trump conjured images of violence and suffering when he described the perils of illegal immigration, though statistics show that immigrants commit crimes at a lower rate than citizens. He dubbed MS-13 gang members “thugs” and said his administration’s crackdown on the group was “like a war.”

“MS-13 is emblematic of evil, and we’re getting them out by the hundreds,” said Trump, who sat on stage at a long table in a gym draped in American flags and decorated with signs that read “USA open for business.” “This is the kind of stuff and crap we are allowing in our country, and we can’t do it anymore.”

Invoking the lines of his June 2015 campaign kickoff speech, in which he suggested that some Mexican immigrants were rapists, the president mused about the threat of violence among immigrants and appeared to make reference to a caravan of migrants that had been working its way north through Mexico toward the United States.

All of that overshadowed any time spent promoting the tax plan.

It underscored the frustration of many congressional Republicans with the president’s frequent indiscipline. Many members of his own party have blamed the president’s lack of focus for helping to stymie their agenda.