Re: Green Irish Tweed or Cool Water? Which is a better scent?

I never realized the fragrances were even similar until I started reading some of the recent threads. I was considering purchasing GIT in the winter and then someone on here mentioned it smells like a urinal puck and when I went to try it, that's all I could smell from it. Now with all the discussions about CW and GIT, I reinvestigated and smelled CW and GIT. They are quite similar. GIT may be come off as being better blended and softer, but CW has a more dynamic and fresher appeal to it. GIT may have the appeal of being exclusive as well. So to counter what someone mentioned above, CW may be held in a higher esteem if it was retailing for over $100 and GIT may be considered the opposite if it was mass marketed.