Why this Oscar voter thought 'Mad Max: Fury Road' was 'really stupid'

One of the big surprises of the awards season has been the
momentum of "Mad Max: Fury Road."

A hit summer movie with over $375
million earned worldwide and a 97%
rating on Rotten Tomatoes, it seemed like another one of
those beloved blockbusters that would be shut out come
awards time.

But since its surprise best-movie win from the
National Board of Review earlier this month, the latest entry
in the "Max Max" series of action films has raked in honors from
other critic guilds as well as two Golden Globes nominations
(Best Picture and Best Director).

So is Oscar next?

“At this point I'd be shocked if ‘Mad Max’ didn't get a Best
Picture nomination,” Yahoo Movies’ senior editor Kevin Polowy
told Business Insider. “Recognition from the Golden Globes,
National Board of Review, and AFI has really validated it as a
serious Oscar contender.”

This is the kind of situation Hollywood wanted following the
snubbing of 2008's "The Dark Knight," which many thought should
have received a Best Picture Oscar nomination. That backlash led
to the Academy expanding the Best Picture category's number of
potential nominees to a maximum of 10 to give more than cerebral
dramas a chance.

But the love for “Fury Road” is not universal among Academy
voters — and the history of what gets awarded is stacked
against it.

“When I saw it, I thought that it was really stupid,” one Oscar
voter told BI. “I’m not going to vote for it.”

And it sounds like he’s not alone. “I had dinner with another
voter the other night and that person felt the same way I do.
That person isn’t voting for it,” the voter said. “It’s fun and
interesting to look at, but it’s definitely not in my top five.”
Which is the number of films each voter selects for the Best
Picture category's nominating process.

Since the Best Picture expansion to 10 potential nominees in
2009, only four genre-oriented films have made it into the
Best Picture category: "Avatar" (2009), "District 9"
(2009), "Inception" (2010), and "Gravity" (2013). And of those,
none was a sequel from a longtime franchise, and none won.

We’ll see when Academy Awards nominations are announced on
January 14 if "Fury Road" will be added to this short list.