The Libbie Carter went down between 1907 and 1912.
"Barkhausen (1947) reports the schooner Libbie Carter wrecked off Manitowoc in 1912. However, a brief check of the DCA for that year yielded no such information. The Libbie Carter is listed in the MV for 1906, but not in the years 1908 or 1910-1912 (1907 was not available). Again, DCA for 1907 did not list the Libbie Carter as wrecked."