I kind of see what you mean. It's kind of like wanting your MVP to be on one of the more successful teams in the league. Having said that, I think DPOY is a little different because it's based on one facet of the game. Also mixed with the idea that his team may not have offensive fire power, the defensive record still stands.
Having said that I'd still go with Emeka. His chances may be hurt because of injury, but i like his chances. Respond to that you drunken mess.

I don't have time to stat crunch this, but I would give high priority to players who routinely lower the efg% of the guys they guard. If guys usually shoot 45%, and a certain defender can keep them under 35%, then that's some great defense. Even greater priority to defenders who can shut down a large variety of players (both guys who are quick for their position and guys who are big for their positoin).

Help defense stats (steals and blocks) should be extra credit, but not the main thing you look at.

If you want to have a team defensive award thats fine. Because that is what you are proposing. Dallas' defense improved when Avery Johnson installed a better defensive scheme, do you want to nominate Dirk as a DPOY?

Mike Fratello teams are always defensive minded, but I never saw Nique nor Craig Ehlo get any All Defense nods.

The DPOY is an indivdual award for the league's best defender, which means that he'd be the best defender no matter if he was on a winning team or a losing team. Some of the so called best defenders, becomse so because of schemes which allow them to use their talents. Take them out of their element, ala Bruce Bowen in last years international tournament, and they become less effective.

you are without a doubt, the biggest idiot on this site. stop referring to yourself in the 3rd person. and what makes you think your opinions/criteria are more important than that of others? i really cannot stand you