At pure face value, this move makes sense as it addresses two need areas. It is hard to offer more than this superficial analysis.

Mewelde Moore played spot duty in Minnesota, and garnered some decent stats, both as a back up and an occasional starter. His punt and kick return numbers are not stellar, but he could easily be an upgrade.

The Steelers talked good game about having confidence in Davenport, but the fact that they didn’t even once try to pound the ball in at the goal line in the 2007 debacle at New England speaks volumes. Davenport did show flashes, but overall Davenport did little to indicate that he was anything beyond a serviceable back up.

Regardless, this move could tell us a lot more than the Steelers’ real feelings about Davenport. Moore is coming in form Minnesota, so it is a safe assumption that Mike Tomlin had a big role in his acquisition.

Therefore, this move bears watching because it serves as another test of Tomlin’s ability to evaluate free agent talent. One of the real knocks against Tomlin in his rookie year were his personnel moves. Sean Mahan’s play at center was woeful at best, and Allen Rossum’s play at kick returner was extraordinarily average.

These were Tomlin’s two signature signings, and both decisions turned out to be pretty poor. As the Steelers sign Mewelde Moore, looking forward, it will be revealing to see how Tomlin fares in this third talent evaluation test.