Headlines

Erick Erickson

I don’t like Rubio’s immigration plan

The most significant policy fiction is premised on the idea of reform. The plan does nothing to address the black market for unskilled, low cost migrant work. It does nothing to deal with the long delays in the present immigration system. It does nothing to actually solve our immigration problems, but hides behind the construct of “comprehensive” reform. Along the way, it potentially adds more people to already overwhelmed entitlement programs, but then that too is another kicked can.

The desire to “just do something” overwhelms Washington too much. This immigration plan gives orgasmic relief to that desire, but in all the hype and show does nothing to address the real needs of employers and the hopes and dreams of those still longing to come to United States whose wait will now most likely be extended and grow even more complex.

Immigration is an issue that keeps hispanic voters from trusting the GOP. Many call it a “gateway” issue. I get that. But pandering in the name of a solution does not actually fix the problem.

Blowback

Note from Hot Air management: This section is for comments from Hot Air's community of registered readers. Please don't assume that Hot Air management agrees with or otherwise endorses any particular comment just because we let it stand. A reminder: Anyone who fails to comply with our terms of use may lose their posting privilege.

This immigration plan gives orgasmic relief to that desire, but in all the hype and show does nothing to address the real needs of employers and the hopes and dreams of those still longing to come to United States whose wait will now most likely be extended and grow even more complex.

Is he saying that it needs to be easier for them to gain citizenship, or that the real needs of employers require those unskilled, low wage jobs?

You gotta love how Eric Erickson waits until everyone has chimed in on this issue to take pieces of what Tucker Carlson said or Krauthammer said or Levin and Rush said and then fashion himself an opinion.

Erickson is missing the boat on this, as I believe the entire dextrosphere is.

We already have a raft of laws on the books concerning how to deal with immigration and citizenship issues. ENFORCE THEM. Anybody who essentially says “we can’t enforce the laws we have so we need more laws” pegs my bullshit detector something fierce.

Rubio’s amnesty plan is only popular with illegals, democrats and Republican progressives – no one with a brain likes it, or thinks the “enforcement” aspect would ever be implemented as written (and no one with a brain trusts Rubio).

Rubio is an obama-style opportunist – with his eyes on the White House.

Immigration is an issue that keeps hispanic voters from trusting the GOP

No it isn’t. And even if it were, we already know that passing amnesty will do nothing to change that. And frankly, arguments like this make me cringe, because it seems to imply that Hispanics believe they are above the law, or are deserving of special treatment. If wrong, it’s kind of racist to think this way. If right….well, the last thing we need to do is make 30 million more of them legal.

We already have a raft of laws on the books concerning how to deal with immigration and citizenship issues. ENFORCE THEM. Anybody who essentially says “we can’t enforce the laws we have so we need more laws” pegs my bullshit detector something fierce.

gryphon202

In Chuck Schumer’s own words, enforcing the law is harassment. And then in the next breath, he tells you their new, tougher laws against future illegals will be enforced. So to be clear…enforcement today is harassment, but enforcement 5 years from now when 5 million more illegals are here is not harassment.

Rubio’s amnesty plan is only popular with illegals, democrats and Republican progressives – no one with a brain likes it, or thinks the “enforcement” aspect would ever be implemented as written

[Pork-Chop on January 30, 2013 at 10:33 AM]

Well it will be implemented to the same exacting degree that the laws on SS disability, Medicaid, Medicare, Unemployment Insurance, Foodstamps, Housing Assistance, Obamaphones, or any of a hundred other policies which have rules to be enforced. They implemented previous rules of immigration enforcement just as strongly.

The problem is that in spite of enforcement millions of illegal immigrants have ensconced themselves in the country over the last 25 years. Like the argument we are now having with gun control, more enforcement mechanisms just burden law-abiding people with a lot more regulations, like a creating a national employment registry, and putting the onus on all law-abiding employers and creating nothing but a larger bureaucracy sucking up taxpayer dollars. It will do little to nothing in stopping illegal immigration; even putting aside the machinations of those in power to emasculate enforcement, ever watchfulness will evolve to complacency, which will lead to turning a blind eye, which will plant resistance that waters the Do Something! tree.

The border will never be made impenetrable and we will proceed down this distracting, argumentative line to no end

Yeah, forget about the borders, unlike every other nation on earth

Employers must prove that no American could be found to do the job the illegal alien would otherwise do. This is impossible, absurd, and turns employers to liars in the pursuit of running their business

They have to do this now, to get special visas

The most significant policy fiction is premised on the idea of reform. The plan does nothing to address the black market for unskilled, low cost migrant work.

And it shouldn’t. Agriculture is the only migrant work, and that is only about a million jobs. Give a visa for Agriculture only, and register the itinerary.

, but in all the hype and show does nothing to address the real needs of employers and the hopes and dreams of those still longing to come to United States whose wait will now most likely be extended and grow even more complex.

The hopes and dreams of Americans are the purpose of government. Whom does the government serve?

Notice he call’s it Rubio’s plan. The target of this article has to be Rubio, since these two seem to share the same goals

I dislike Rubio’s plan.This guy argues for it while arguing against Rubio

I can’t see all these illegals registering to pay fines and back taxes.

ctmom on January 30, 2013 at 10:03 AM

I don’t either, as I’m sure there are plenty of illegals that will not have the means to pay. But I wouldn’t doubt for a minute that the monetary cost, at some point down the road, will somehow be forgiven.