Sephora Collection Long-Lasting 12HR Wear Eye Liner

You might head to this beauty superstore for more expensive brands, but the store's namesake line that proved itself in this test. The Sephora Collection Long-Lasting 12HR Wear Eye Liner was our top liquid pick. It earned the best performance score for lasting six hours in our test, and it produced the desired liner looks our consumer testers wanted. "It goes on easy – not too wet, so it's hard to make mistakes – and stays on all day without smudging" one volunteer said. And it's a true treat for color lovers and makeup mavens: The line boasts an expansive 13 shades.