From the desk of Gary R. Entz

The book Llewellyn Castle: A Worker’s Cooperative on the Great Plains is the result of a lot of old-fashioned detective work. I was born in Kansas and spent my formative years there and in the mountains of central Colorado. As much as I loved (and still love) Colorado, when it came time to advance through my education it was the history of Kansas and the Great Plains that captured my attention. As a descendent of German Mennonites who used cooperative methods to transplant entire communities of Eastern European farmers to the grasslands of central Kansas, I came from a heritage where the mutual aid and communal thought of the past shapes the present and continues to be a part of living memory. The idea of a cooperative narrative of the American past as an alternative to the myth of the so-called rugged individualist is an intriguing concept. At the same time, however, the German Mennonite tradition has been heavily researched by others, and I had little interest in revisiting the thoroughly investigated topic.

Llewellyn Castle was a settlement in northeastern Kansas that only a few people have ever heard about. Although I was a student of Kansas history and had sifted through the minutia of state history, before 1995 I had never encountered a reference to the place. The settlement nearly disappeared from historical memory for a number of reasons, not the least of which was the fabrication of a new name for the colony by a 1930s journalist. If one is looking to make an already obscure place disappear from history, an effective way to accomplish that feat is to give it a new name and embellished background for which there are no corresponding contemporary records. When I first encountered a reference to the settlement it was nothing more than the place name (the fabricated one, which I did not know at the time) and question marks next to the dates of its possible existence. It appears that once the fabricated colony name and story was accepted into local folklore, the myth took over and the reality of the settlement faded away.

I was looking for intentional communities to study for my dissertation but the prospect of taking on such a project was intimidating, to say the least. I had no information about the settlers or their point of origin. Nonetheless, I was intrigued enough to conduct a preliminary investigation to see if there might be enough material about Llewellyn Castle to include in my dissertation. Unfortunately, my initial foray into the public record proved fruitless. I found no references anywhere to a settlement called Llewellyn Castle during the time when it was thought to have existed. It was a frustrating moment. I had intended to conduct a comparative study of three communities: an entirely cooperative community, a religious charismatic perfectionist colony, and a political pragmatic colony. The Singleton Colony, an African American settlement that built cooperation out of necessity, and Zion Valley, a Mormon colony of the Bickertonite branch, would serve as the cooperative and religious case studies, respectively. I still needed the third subject, and Llewellyn Castle fell into the time period I was studying and had the potential to provide the case study I needed.

Other political pragmatic colonies existed in Kansas, but most had already received article-length treatment in scholarly journals. I needed something original and only Llewellyn Castle and another settlement called Thompson’s Colony fit the requirements. Thompson’s Colony, however, barely lasted a year, so I focused my attention on learning more about Llewellyn Castle. The Llewellyn Castle settlement had found a chronicler in the past and was not completely unknown. In the 1930s journalist John T. Bristow had written a series of newspaper articles detailing his childhood memories of growing up near the settlement. He collected and published these together in book form in the 1940s. Unfortunately, Bristow’s recollections were of little help and, as I later realized, mostly embroidered tales woven out of his own adolescent memories. It was Bristow who used the name Llewellyn Castle.

Bristow claimed that the settlers were English, which was confirmed by British researcher Andrew Whitehead. Working from London in the mid 1980s, Whitehead traced to Kansas the followers of a Chartist reformer named James Bronterre O’Brien and subsequently wrote a pair of articles about the group. Both articles were brief and published in a pair of obscure journals that were difficult to find and had not yet been referenced on any database in those early days of the Internet. Once found, however, the information was a treasure. Whitehead’s articles had little detail of what had happened in Kansas, but they clearly proved a link between O’Brien’s London following and the colony Bristow described as Llewellyn Castle. This was the crucial information I needed. Whitehead’s work confirmed the dates of existence, suggested an alternate name for the colony (as it turned out, the correct name), and opened the door to the possibility of much more material yet to be uncovered.

I had found my political pragmatic case study, and in 1996 I began my own quest to uncover the full history of Llewellyn Castle.

-Gary R. Entz

Share this:

Like this:

Related

2 Comments

Renee Begley May 21, 2014

I don’t know if there is a way to talk to you in email but John Robert Molineux was my great grandfather and my maternal grandmother was Amelia Cecelia Molineux. I have been trying to find out more about this part of my family for years and it wasn’t until today, Wed. 5/21/2014 that I ran onto your book because someone referenced the Llwellyn Castle group in the Molineux Alliance in Facebook. I have been searching for years because there was some controversy about why my g.g. grandfather left England and it had to do with lands and titles according to my grandmother but she was too young to understand all the details of why solicitors came to their farm to talk to her father. I don’t know how much information about the backgrounds of the settlers are in your book but I hope you did go into that to a degree. i don’t know what happened to my great uncle Percy who left the farm after a disagreement with his father. He was my grandmothers favorite brother and she never found out what happened to him. I’m very anxious to ready your book but I have to save for a bit since I am on a set income and now 67. Thanks for taking the time to write the book.

Hi Renee,
Thank you for the comment, and thank you for your interest in my book. I don’t have a tremendous amount of information concerning the background of John R. Molineux, but the book does cover his 1874 immigration to Kansas as part of the John Radford Party. This takes place in the final year of the colony. You can also learn a bit about his brother, James, in an old 1874 book by C. Maurice Davies entitled “Heterodox London; or Phases of Free Thought in the Metropolis.”