Arrow‘s Suicide Squad officially has a new member, as seen in a photo shared by star David Ramsey on Instagram.

In this season’s 17th episode, titled “Suicidal Tendencies,” Supernatural alum Amy Gumenick — who in November made her debut as Carrie Cutter aka Arrow’s stalker, Cupid — reprises that role, having been drafted by A.R.G.U.S.’ Suicide Squad for “safe keeping.”