I saw a tweet on Friday from AP reporter David Koenig (HT: Seth) stating that the DOT had ruled on the multiple motions in front of them on the Haneda slot.

The link in the tweet is to the actual motion. I gave it a quick scan and was a little surprised to see that the DOT had essentially told Delta to pound sand. Quoting from the motion:

By this Order, the Department (1) approves the request of American Airlines, Inc. (American) for an extension of the startup date applicable to its authority to provide service between Los Angeles, California, and Tokyo’s Haneda Airport; and (2) dismisses the motion of Delta Air Lines, Inc. (Delta) requesting that the Department revoke American’s U.S.-Haneda authority. The Department has also decided to award backup authority to Hawaiian Airlines, Inc. (Hawaiian) for its proposed Kona-Haneda services, should American not meet the conditions and requirements attached to its Los Angeles-Haneda slot pair authority.

Interestingly, it wasn’t just Delta objecting to Hawaiian’s request for backup authority. United did as well, saying:

United asserts that Hawaiian’s request is outside the scope of the instant proceeding, which stems from American’s need to seek a startup extension. United also asserts that Hawaiian’s request is unprecedented in its breadth, as the Department has historically not awarded backup authority to primary U.S.-Haneda slot pair awards, and on the only occasion the Department did award backup authority, it tied that backup authority to a specific primary award. United argues that Hawaiian has not presented any justification to deviate from that precedent.

Despite this and other objections, the DOT found that the Hawaiian proposal was in the public’s best interest if American could not fulfill the promise to operate the route. They did put one small caveat on the backup award to Hawaiian:

The Department has decided to impose a startup condition on the backup award, and will require Hawaiian to institute its proposed service within 90 days of the activation of its backup award. Should the backup award be activated, the allocation of the slot pair to Hawaiian would remain in effect indefinitely, subject to the Department’s standard 90-day dormancy condition.

The Hawaiian proposed route is roughly 1,500 miles shorter than the LAX-HND route. That could make scheduling a bit easier with more tolerable arrival/departure times. That being said, there’s quite a bit of competition on flights from Tokyo to Hawaii, though current flights land in Honolulu, not Kona.

I still think that American is in the Haneda game for the long haul, even if the flight loses money. They’re weaker in Asia and this is a chance to grow. Record profits allow them to hemorrhage cash on this route to some degree for the foreseeable future. I’ll be interested to see if they can make Haneda work.

In the interim, Delta is left on the outside looking in, though that may be where they want to be. At any rate, it appears they’ll have to wait for both American and Hawaiian to fail on Haneda before they get another shot.

You May Also Enjoy

Share this Post

About the Author

My goal in life is to fill my family’s passports with stamps, creating buckets of memories along the way. You’ll find me writing about realistic ways for normal people to travel the world, whether you’re on a budget or enjoy luxury. I also enjoy taking us on the occasional detour to explore the inner workings of the travel industry.

Each week, we cover some of the most interesting stories on BoardingArea of the week on the NowBoarding podcast. This week, we covered five stories that should help you get the most out of your travel. Alaska Airlines Newest Partner Alaska Airlines has added El Al Airlines as a partner. Details are still a bit thin on what award redemptions will look like, but more ways to redeem our miles is generally better. Hyatt’s New Partnership with American Airlines The partnership between Hyatt and American Airlines has launched. Members in […]

Resort fees are uniformly hated by customers. They don’t bother me as much as some other folks. However, a recent announcement by Booking.com does bother me. The online travel agency is poised to make more money when you book a hotel with a resort fee. And, that’s not good for consumers in any way, shape or form.

April marks the fourth month in a row where I’ve kept track of the Wi-Fi reliability on all of my flights. With over 40 flights in the books, we have enough of a sample size to start making some reasonable conclusions.

Those low-cost carriers always have very appetizing fare sales. Who wouldn’t want to pay $20 to fly somewhere? But, what does $20 really buy you? I found out exactly what Frontier does (and doesn’t) offer customers on my first flight with them recently.

People talk about how bad the traffic is in places like Los Angeles with plenty of adjectives. And, it is quite bad. But, the traffic in DC is what I refer to as “stealthy bad”. It doesn’t get the same press that LA traffic does, but a trip that normally takes an hour can easily turn into a 3-hour ordeal. With visiting dignitaries, protests and construction as variables, weather can also wreak havoc on a system that consistently backs up during rush hour. For those of us that live in […]

As travel has gotten more stressful the benefits of elite status are even more valuable. In some cases, what used to be free for everyone is now only free for those customers that fly most frequently. I value my American Airlines Executive Platinum status more highly than any status I’ve earned, including 1K service with United Airlines. However, Global Services is another matter. For those not aware, Global Services is an invitation-only status level that United bestows on their best customers. What defines a best customer? Well, United doesn’t list […]

I have to admit, I was pretty pleased with the original announcement that American Airlines was creating bundled pricing that included change fees at a lower apparent cost. Things got a little better when American also announced they were expanding the timeframe you could request a same day change to your flight. And, then things started to get a bit screwy. It started with just one flight I couldn’t get to price right with Choice Plus as an add-on. But, then I did a bit more digging and found out […]

Venture Beat doesn’t think so, and I’m not 100% sure they’re wrong. But, before I discuss the article, a little background on why someone allergic to social media like me became a Foursquare nut. A few years ago, a company called TopGuest came up with this concept where you could earn airline miles and hotel points for checking in at various places on Foursquare. I can’t say I thought it was a terribly good business model, but they convinced a bunch of hotel chains to hand out miles for this. […]