A few active, rule-following, respect to other members, contribution to PBA during that week and blah blah (you know the criteria) could be shortlisted from all users.Then theres a poll in which only the staff can vote (this could be done right here, or if you guys want it, in secrecy)

Whoever the staff feel is the best user based on the criteria, they vote for. And da man wid da highest votez winz!

As for staff of the week, The most active staff of the week should be shortlisted, and we (the users) vote for whoz helped them the most, basically for whos been the best staff member for that week. And the poll right here.