Who wore French Connection better?

This bright frock turned up exactly four months apart on two different stars! Melissa Joan Hart was the first to wear the blue and black French Connection Sarah dress ($168) while in LA to the Gain Better Together Party on Feb. 24, where she paired her get-up with black t-straps and a necklace. Next, Shawn Johnson sported the same exact frock to the LA premiere of Eclipse on Jun. 24, where she accessorized with black and white sandals and a bracelet. While both gals look put together in the dress, I don’t think it did much for Shawn’s petite frame. What do you think? Who wore the French Connection dress best?