I've looked on the internet for weeks comparing screenshot after screenshot, looking up color charts, and even comparing cosplayer's photos. But I still don't know what to do! The people I send asks to or questions on anywhere from Tumblr to this site never respond back, and I don't want to order the wrong color. My concern is the Dark Brown is too light, or the Natural Black is too dark.

Please, please, please, help me find a color. I will take the majority vote. Thank you for your time.

__________________My Cosplays:Fem!America (Nyotalia) from APHAmerica from APHTohru Honda from Fruits BasketHungary from APHBelgium from APHAang from A:TLAFem!Canada (Nyotalia) from APHHipster Rapunzel from Disney's Tangled

While his hair is technically a very dark brown, based on the images for the two colors I'd go with Black just because the "dark brown" seems a little light. I think you'd be fine with either option though. And the style is great! If you're still unsure, maybe search for other Sherlock cosplayers to see what they have done.

You can always dye a lighter wig darker, but it's impossible to dye a darker wig lighter. If getting the color exact is a big thing for you, I would get the Dark Brown and dye it. If you don't have time to dye it before the con, just wait. No one (well, no REASONABLE person, anyways) will judge you for having a slightly off-color wig.