Ancient Mathematics

When did mathematics begin? A natural question to ask, but unfortunately a very difficult one to answer, explains June Barrow-Green

Mathematics is so integral to human existence that the development of mathematical thinking cannot be separated from the development of thinking itself.

So rather than look specifically for origins, we study archaeological and other artefacts for evidence of mathematical activity. However, attributing mathematical meaning to very ancient objects is no easy task.

It not only requires mathematical knowledge but it requires historical and cultural knowledge as well. And it often leads to controversy!

The Ishango Bone

A famous example, and one of the oldest objects believed to be of mathematical significance, is the Ishango bone which was dug up in the 1950s at a village called Ishango on the shores of Lake Edward in the Democratic Republic Of Congo.

The bone, which is engraved with a series of notches, has been carbon-dated to about 20,000 BCE. The bone’s discoverer suggested that the notches may represent an arithmetical game and that the patterning is strongly suggestive of a counting system based on 10 and knowledge of multiplication.

But other scholars have criticised this view, suggesting instead that the notches can be better explained by relating them to time-keeping and a count of periods of the moon.

Which of the two views is right? Or are they both wrong? We cannot know for sure. However, one thing we can be certain about is that historical sources do not speak for themselves. They require interpretation.

And that interpretation should take account not only of the content of the source but also of the context in which the source was produced. In the case of the Ishango bone, for example, it is its age combined with its mathematical content that makes it especially significant. Its mathematical content alone is not enough.

When considering ancient mathematical texts, such as those from Egypt and Mesopotamia, it is very easy to get seduced into considering only the numbers in the texts and to exclude everything else. This is because once you know the number system, the numbers themselves are easy to read—you do not need to be an Egyptologist or an Assyriologist to read them—and interpreting the ‘everything else’, including words in the text, is hard!

But if we allow ourselves to be seduced in this way, we not only run the risk of arriving at misleading or erroneous conclusions but we gain no understanding of the underlying culture.

Plimpton 322

A good example of the perils of the number only approach is the case of the Babylonian tablet known as Plimpton 322 (named after its first Western owner, the New York publisher George Plimpton, who bought it in 1922), arguably the most famous of all Babylonian mathematical tablets. The tablet contains elements of Pythagorean triples (sets of numbers that satisfy the equation x2 = y2 + z2) and in the past it was seen by some scholars (who considered only the numbers on the table) as a trigonometric table. But by considering the text in its entirety and placing it in its historical context, the leading Assyriologist and expert on Babylonian mathematics, Eleanor Robson, has shown this interpretation to be erroneous.

The fact that Robson knew from her detailed study of Babylonian culture that the Babylonians had no conceptual framework for angle measurement or trigonometry is, of course, no coincidence.

Image 'Exploring mathematics: maths in nature and art' - Copyright: The Open University 2009

Image 'Cows with the number two ' - Copyright: BBC

Image 'Photograph of Moraine lake, Alberta. The photo shows a blue-green expanse of lake water, with dense forest on the left, and rocky mountainous terrain to the right of the lake.' - Pexels under Creative Commons BY-NC-SA 4.0 license

Image 'Exploring mathematics: a powerful tool' - Copyright: The Open University 2009

Tags, Ratings and Social Bookmarking

Ratings

Ratings

Share

We invite you to discuss this subject, but remember this is a public forum.Please be polite, and avoid your passions turning into
contempt for others. We may delete posts that are rude or aggressive; or edit posts containing contact details or links to other websites.

Feeds

If you enjoyed this, why not follow a feed to find out when we have new things like it? Choose an RSS feed from the list below. (Don't know what to do with RSS feeds?)
Remember, you can also make your own, personal feed by combining tags from around OpenLearn.

What does mathematics have to do with nature or art? The video tracks in this album trace the origin of the mathematics of chaos and describe how the chance discovery of fractals became the basis for some real - and revolutionary - commercial applications such as the fax and the modem. A closer look at ancient fabric designs and the spiral of a nautilus shell also reveals repeating patterns that can be analysed in a mathematical way. This material forms part of The Open University course MS221 Exploring mathematics.

How can mathematics help us to understand the world around us? The tracks on this album take us to Antarctica, Hong Kong and New Zealand to find out how mathematicians work with scientists and biologists to create mathematical models, and how collaborations like these can help decipher and predict a range of natural phenomena. We learn how the 17th Century saw the birth of one of the most important mathematical tools - calculus, and modern mathematicians examine the contribution of its three inventors - Fermat, Newton and Leibniz. This material forms part of The Open University course MS221 Exploring mathematics.