Windows 8.1 given first official outing, and yes, the Start button is back

New operating system builds on what we have now but makes it better.

Microsoft has given a first look at Windows 8.1, the free update to Windows 8 that it plans to deliver this autumn.

Though it will disappoint some, it should surprise few to learn that Windows 8.1 will not revert all the user interface changes made in Windows 8. Instead, 8.1 will be an incremental update that builds on the Windows 8 interface and its Metro design, but does not replace it.

As such, Windows 8.1 still has the Start screen. It is, however, a more customizable Start screen. There are new tile sizes: a double height tile, to allow apps to show more information, and a smaller tile size, to allow apps to be packed more tightly. There are more options for the Start screen background and colors, including animated backgrounds and the ability to use the same background as used on the desktop. This last change should make the Start screen feel a little less visually disconnected from the desktop world.

Enlarge/ The Windows 8.1 Start screen allows for bigger tiles, such as the pretty weather app, smaller tiles, such as the quartet in the upper right corner, and the use of the desktop background.

Microsoft

The Start screen is also more respectful of personalization. In Windows 8, newly-installed applications just dump their tile or icons on the Start screen. This undermined the personal nature of the screen; you'd have your own, neatly organized apps, but then you'd install a desktop program and it'd just spew a dozen icons all over the place. In Windows 8.1, new apps don't get to automatically stick a tile on the Start screen. They'll still show up in the all programs app view, and they'll be highlighted as new, but the decision to pin them rests with the user.

That all programs view is also more flexible, with a variety of sorting and filtering options. Microsoft says that it will be possible to make "alternate screens" the default when you boot the system. The company mentions explicitly the ability to boot directly to all programs view, rather than the tile view, and it's believed that it will also be possible to boot directly to the desktop.

Not content with putting Start buttons on mice (in addition to keyboards, tablets, and the charms bar), Microsoft is reinstating the taskbar Start button. Clicking it will bring up the Start screen.

Within Metro apps, the button will remain invisible; putting the mouse cursor near the bottom left of the screen will show the button, as it does in Windows 8, but the button itself has changed its appearance. In Windows 8, the button is a miniature thumbnail depiction of the Start screen. In 8.1, it will simply be the Windows logo.

Search is getting reworked to aggregate search results from multiple content sources, including files, apps, settings, and the Web, simultaneously.

Enlarge/ Searching now aggregates results across apps, files, and the Web.

Microsoft

Some of Windows 8's obvious limitations are being lifted. In 8.1, Metro apps can be run on multiple monitors simultaneously. On any single monitor, more than two applications can be run simultaneously. Instead of Windows 8's fixed split, where one application gets 320 pixels and the other application gets the rest, the division between apps will be variable. It'll also be possible to have multiple windows from a single app so that, for example, two browser windows can be opened side-by-side.

Enlarge/ The split view that allows the simultaneous use of multiple Metro apps is now flexible, allowing you to pick how screen space is apportioned. Note also the task switcher is visible, showing off the new Windows logo-based Start button, replacing Windows 8's thumbnail design.

The built-in applications will get a bunch of updates, and some new apps will be added. Microsoft gave a little information about what we can expect to see—fewer restrictions on the Photos app so it can open files from more places and perform light editing, a "completely redesigned" Music app to make it easier to play your own music (and, we hope, have less of the hard sell that the current app has), and built-in saving directly to and loading from SkyDrive, even when offline. The company says that it'll provide more information on the new and updated apps later in the year.

Enlarge/ Like Windows 8, you'll be able to save to SkyDrive, but unlike Windows 8, SkyDrive will be usable even offline.

Microsoft

Work is also being done on two of the "special" built-in apps: Settings and Internet Explorer. A major flaw with using Windows 8, especially on a tablet, is that many, many settings can only be found in the desktop Control Panel, forcing finger-based users onto a mouse-based interface. Microsoft claims that in 8.1, the Settings app will contain "all" of the settings on your device, including things like joining domains and changing the screen resolution.

Internet Explorer 11 will, of course, be faster, have better standards support, and include all the other things we expect new browsers to do. One of those features—not yet confirmed, but strongly hinted—is support for WebGL 3D graphics. The browser will also catch up to Chrome and Firefox in other regards, with tab sync across machines.

Overall, these sound like sensible changes. The new operating system will keep the same core elements as Windows 8 but assemble them in a way that's more flexible, more personal, and fundamentally more useful. A beta of the new version will become available on June 26, coinciding with Microsoft's developer conference, BUILD.

"Not content with putting Start buttons on mice (in addition to keyboards, tablets, and the charms bar), Microsoft is reinstating the taskbar Start button. Clicking it will bring up the Start screen."

This has nothing to do with a Start button. It's a Windows button and that is not what people wanted. They wanted the start menu back so please stop confusing these two completely separate and distinct concepts.

^This, a million times this. Microsoft apparently completely misunderstood what people were saying. For a lot of users the "start button" is synonymous with the "start menu" and it's the menu we want, not a stupid button per se except in the sense that it's used to open the start menu.

"Not content with putting Start buttons on mice (in addition to keyboards, tablets, and the charms bar), Microsoft is reinstating the taskbar Start button. Clicking it will bring up the Start screen."

This has nothing to do with a Start button. It's a Windows button and that is not what people wanted. They wanted the start menu back so please stop confusing these two completely separate and distinct concepts.

Where was the confusion. It was pretty specific. The Start button is coming back. It will open the Start screen. The Start Menu was never mentioned.

"Not content with putting Start buttons on mice (in addition to keyboards, tablets, and the charms bar), Microsoft is reinstating the taskbar Start button. Clicking it will bring up the Start screen."

This has nothing to do with a Start button. It's a Windows button and that is not what people wanted. They wanted the start menu back so please stop confusing these two completely separate and distinct concepts.

^This, a million times this. Microsoft apparently completely misunderstood what people were saying. For a lot of users the "start button" is synonymous with the "start menu" and it's the menu we want, not a stupid button per se except in the sense that it's used to open the start menu.

They didn't misunderstand at all. They understood and rejected the idea that you needed a tiny menu visible simultaneously with your desktop.

I just wish they would get rid of the charms bar in Win8, it's especially annoying on laptops when you're writing a paper and just a little tap brings it up and then moves the cursor to line 1 of a 10 page research paper.

"Not content with putting Start buttons on mice (in addition to keyboards, tablets, and the charms bar), Microsoft is reinstating the taskbar Start button. Clicking it will bring up the Start screen."

This has nothing to do with a Start button. It's a Windows button and that is not what people wanted. They wanted the start menu back so please stop confusing these two completely separate and distinct concepts.

^This, a million times this. Microsoft apparently completely misunderstood what people were saying. For a lot of users the "start button" is synonymous with the "start menu" and it's the menu we want, not a stupid button per se except in the sense that it's used to open the start menu.

They didn't misunderstand at all. They understood and rejected the idea that you needed a tiny menu visible simultaneously with your desktop.

Which is absurd, I have lots of windows open, and sometimes I am even watching live content in one while I want to open another program or search for it. Watching a stream, playing a game, etc and I want to open a music player, there's no reason I should be thrown out of my desktop into a full-screen page that serves no real purpose other then accepting "music<enter>" as input.

I do use Windows 8 and like it in general, but while I can safely ignore all the metro apps and use my computer as regular desktop the start screen still annoys me.

I just wish they would get rid of the charms bar in Win8, it's especially annoying on laptops when you're writing a paper and just a little tap brings it up and then moves the cursor to line 1 of a 10 page research paper.

You know... I have to give MS some breathing room with metro, since they're trying to play catch up with iOS and Android... But You'd think with all of their billions, they could get the Control Panel ported to the metro interface on day one.

I still think its amazing they're forcing so much of this on the end user, when the desktop is still an extremely powerful and important UX Paradigm for people.

I'm glad they're making 8.1 a free release. But with that said, they've got to step up the game.

(no doubt porting all of this is difficult, but... its just, you know... thier entire business).

"Not content with putting Start buttons on mice (in addition to keyboards, tablets, and the charms bar), Microsoft is reinstating the taskbar Start button. Clicking it will bring up the Start screen."

This has nothing to do with a Start button. It's a Windows button and that is not what people wanted. They wanted the start menu back so please stop confusing these two completely separate and distinct concepts.

"Not content with putting Start buttons on mice (in addition to keyboards, tablets, and the charms bar), Microsoft is reinstating the taskbar Start button. Clicking it will bring up the Start screen."

This has nothing to do with a Start button. It's a Windows button and that is not what people wanted. They wanted the start menu back so please stop confusing these two completely separate and distinct concepts.

I don't want the Start menu back. Please do not speak for me.

I'd like to say, on Cabal's behalf, that the Start menu is freakin awesome. He want's everyone to know that he's thrilled about this development.

"Not content with putting Start buttons on mice (in addition to keyboards, tablets, and the charms bar), Microsoft is reinstating the taskbar Start button. Clicking it will bring up the Start screen."

This has nothing to do with a Start button. It's a Windows button and that is not what people wanted. They wanted the start menu back so please stop confusing these two completely separate and distinct concepts.

^This, a million times this. Microsoft apparently completely misunderstood what people were saying. For a lot of users the "start button" is synonymous with the "start menu" and it's the menu we want, not a stupid button per se except in the sense that it's used to open the start menu.

I would be totally fine with the Start Screen itself and the tiles with these new improvements if you could snap it to a section of your desktop like any other app. 20% of the left for the old start menu feel, or people could snap it to the top or bottom for a menu-like experience if they prefer. This hijacking and entire large desktop monitor screen is just crazy and dumb. (And no, I don't think the same background will help much.)

I'm going to bite the bullet and upgrade when 8.1 comes out, but one of the add-on utilities might be in order.

Mega has the right idea, except for expecting users to use crap like Chrome. "The leading browser, by far" my ass.

Actually, Mega now recommends Firefox over Chrome. Of course, you've always been able to use any browser you wanted, you would just miss some features with certain browsers (because they weren't possible to implement).

Start menu/button/whatever aside, there are some pretty forward thinking concepts in this release. We may not be technologically ready for our computers to be doctors... but people still use computers to diagnose themselves and telemedicine is coming soon. And the OS telling me what I am really searching for could be done pretty poorly, but we do have a need for our computers to start helping us filter through the massive gobs of information that are now out there. The Google Play store is an undiscoverable mess; so improvement in finding apps are very needed.

In a way, this reminds me a little of Active Desktop -- we all hated it, but it was way ahead of it's time which is why it failed. Perhaps MS has got their timing right on some of this this time and it'll stick.