Share

Richard Dawkins, the world’s best known atheist-for-hire, was recently in New Zealand, preaching at events in Auckland and Christchurch and hoping to rally the troops and win new converts.

As a Bible-loving Christian who believes in God, angels, heaven and hell, I guess people would assume I’m angry or nervous about having the High Priest of Unbelief in town. Actually, I’m cautiously glad that he’s here.

But my thankfulness for his visit goes beyond the obvious belief in freedom of speech and freedom of religion.

It goes to the heart of who we are as a country.

New Zealand has quietly become one of the most spiritually apathetic nations on earth.

In our relative comfort and prosperity, many of us have become immune to even considering the deeper meaning of life.

Maybe he can save us from drifting into a half-baked non-answer and drive us to examine the evidence, carefully look at ourselves, and search for the truth.

Don’t get me wrong.

It’s not like I’m doing cartwheels that Dawkins will be spreading his vitriolic and ill-informed ideas.

Almost every Christian I know finds listening to the man to be an intensely frustrating experience – not because he threatens our beliefs, but because he simply doesn’t understand them.

He may be a good scientist, but when he strays beyond his field he’s a pseudo-intellectual, spewing far more heat than light, preaching a distorted and anger-fueled message against religious straw men.

Sloppy thinking and contradictions mark his speaking and writing.

He presents himself as a man of science interested purely in evidence – even if he believes that the evidence leads to bleak conclusions of a godless universe filled with “blind, pitiless indifference”.

But in the next breath, he rails against religion based on ideas that, while important, contribute nothing to the question of whether or not God actually exists: things like evil done in the name of religion (some of which is true) and his distorted version of God’s supposed character (most of which is based on a simplistic, context-free misreading of the bible).

The argument is emotive: “God isn’t real because I hate him”.

Dawkins presents himself as a radical sceptic, yet when it comes to seeing and confronting his own cherished assumptions he isn’t nearly sceptical enough. Continue reading

Geoff Robson is a Christchurch-based church pastor and university chaplain, and the author of The Book of Books: A short guide to reading the Bible.

Opinion

Negative reaction to John Murphy’s confession of having watched the Royal Wedding was interesting! I too, watched, without the slightest twinge of an uneasy conscience, one of the most fascinating television presentations that I have ever watched. I sent texts to many of my friends in the dead of night, which, alas, mostly went unanswered. Read more

Wednesday, the Vatican issued a letter, Oeconomicae et Pecuniariae Quaestiones on economic and financial matters. Quite unlike many recent communications on those issues, it was elegantly written – almost a joy to read. It is a serious and constructive contribution to the debate and, in its earlier sections, it is, if not quite original, a vital Read more

Features

The Chilean bishops announced their collective resignation last Friday following a series of sex abuse cases that have shaken the church. But far from ending the crisis, the decision heralds the beginning of a long rebuilding process in which Pope Francis will have a free hand to choose their successors. After their week in Rome, Read more

Like many Catholics across the Northeast and Midwest, parishioners in Pittsburgh are adjusting to a difficult new reality. On April 28 Bishop David A. Zubik announced plans to reduce the diocese’s 188 parishes to 57 by 2023. The parish closings follow years of falling Mass attendance—the diocese reports it is down by more than 40 Read more

Get CathNews by Email

Email Address *

First Name *

Last Name *

* = required field

Search CathNews

Search for:

Comments

KieranDoes Cardinal Brandmuller think that his opinion on women priests and women deacons, along with that of Pope John Paul II, will be binding for all time? An eternal decree? It must be wonderful to know the mind of God. Funny thing. I believe St Paul speaks of women deacons in Romans 16:1 and...

mel
Did the bishops resign in protest against the Pope's telling them off or did they resign because they failed their diocese and people and need to re'evaluate whether they should continue on within the clergy or within Church?

KieranI find it interesting that Pope St John Paul II gave us the Luminous Mysteries of the Rosary because the the three others sets lacked reference to the public ministry of Jesus, which, of course is found at the heart of the Gospels. The main sources for the presence of the Lord as Irenaeus puts it...

Patricia GrahamThe communion table is not closed because of "denomination" its closed because one denomination believes the bread in the Eucharist is the "Body" of Christ the other denomination believes its only a memory so by definition you really can't take part in a celebration that you have a different belief...