October makes us want to make pies: It’s not just pumpkin spice latte mass hysteria we’re all experiencing right now, it’s pie hysteria as well (if that’s a thing). Once that crisp air hits, it’s just all we want to bake on weekends.

Get some space from the PSL and make your own pie at home this weekend with this recipe roundup. We dug through our archives for the best pie recipes – and only one of them includes pumpkin (for those who aren’t sick of it yet). Scroll above for the twelve best pies to make this weekend.