This JSA annual serves three functions. First, it’s a terrific exercise
in nostalgia that recalls a particular time and specified iterations of
a large group of characters. Secondly, it advances the storyline
presently rolling in the regular book. And third, it holds larger
implications about the state of the continuity of the DC Universe,
suggesting that reveals that we’ve seen about the nature of the 52
might not be completely accurate. All three of those functions are
supported by the fact that this is a damn fine read.

First part, then. It should be clear to anyone that’s paying attention
that Geoff Johns and a number of other creators (certainly James
Robinson, David Goyer, and more) have successfully mined and updated
the Earth-2 characters for today’s audience. In the mid-‘80s, these
characters were represented in titles written by Roy Thomas (All-Star Squadron, Infinity Inc., and later, Young All-Stars).
Today, many of those characters still survive and thrive in the regular
JSA book or as supporting characters across the DCU. What a kick, then,
to see the original versions of Infinity Inc. and the JSAers of that
time. And they look great. Ordway, who worked on those books,
does a fantastic job here, beautifully rendering the characters; it’s
like he never left them.

On the second notion: Yes, this is a critical chapter if you’re a
regular JSA reader. This issue follows up on where Gog sent Power Girl
in that title. Power Girl fondly wished to go “home”, but as it turns
out, what looks perfect might not be. This is played against a strong
character study of the Earth-2 Huntress as she works through her issues
with anger, fate, and one of her late father’s old enemies.

As to the relative importance of this issue where the confluences of
continuity are concerned, that will become obvious as you near issue’s
end. Johns deftly suggests several mysteries with an 11th hour twist,
and it’s likely that we’ll see those implications continue to play out
in several avenues.

All in all, this is a smarty written, wonderfully drawn issue that keys
to the old-school while remaining entirely accessible. Check it out.