Re: Somebody give me the lowdown on Fighting Cock.

Very much not gimmicky. It's just good 6 year 103 proof rye bourbon with a simple sweet-sometimes-a-little-spicy flavor profile and a low price. Nothing spectacular, but a good/great value depending on your preferences. Regarding the whole "bottom-shelf" question, I would describe it as a good value bourbon. Noticeabely better than the very solid / high value EW black, if that provides any reference point.

Re: Somebody give me the lowdown on Fighting Cock.

Originally Posted by Alden

I can get OGD BiB for the same price.

Are the similar? I think the proofs are about the same.

IMHO opinion, similar in quality (with a nod to the OGD) but very different in flavor. FC is sweet-sweet controlled heat with a little spice whereas OGD in my experience has a dryer and more rye intensive flavor / spice to it.