We noticed that you're using an unsupported browser. The TripAdvisor website may not display properly.We support the following browsers:Windows: Internet Explorer, Mozilla Firefox, Google Chrome. Mac: Safari.

As locals, we’ve eaten here several times. The food and service are always great. I decided to try something new and go for their pork chop “special.” It was awful. It was tough, over cooked, and the BBQ sauce made it taste like hospital food....More

My fiancé and I love this place. Always fantastic dishes no matter what you order! My all time favorite is chicken piccata with the angel hair pasta. my fiancé loves The Godfather pizza. They allow you to split the entrees which was really the best...More

While walking through St. Augustine we notice this small restaurant, hole in the wall, serving pizza and other Italian dishes. Pizzalley's is a narrow restaurant with seating in the front and back of the store. The atmosphere reminds me of a neighborhood pizzeria found in...More

Samples are given out in front of restaurant advertising happy hour. So good we came back after shopping. M-F 3-6. Buy one drink get one free plus free slice of cheese pizza and $5 off pizza. Had The Garabage Can pizza 10 inch was plenty...More

It was a Hit and Miss. We had dinner Saturday. We order calamari and a 10" pizza with onions, mushrooms, half with pepperoni and banana peppers. Extra crispy. The calamari was great. The 16" pizza was delivered with extra cheese on top. We reminded our...More