Remember that time Chris Rock, Kevin Hart, Marlon Wayans, The Roots’ QuestLove and Bill Bellamy joined Dave Chappelle on stage at the Comedy Cellar in New York? You probably don’t, seeing as you probably weren’t there. But if you were, tell us about the experience in the comments. Anyway, in the June issue of GQ — on sale now! — all six modern-day icons recounted what went down on Feb. 27, 2013 at the Comedy Cellar on that otherwise normal Wednesday night in the West Village. Check out an excerpt below!

Chris Rock: Dave is like Prince.

Marlon Wayans: Like Bigfoot.

Rock: You never know when he’s going to show up. That night was a comedy booty call from Dave. [in Chappelle's voice] “I’m in town, man! You should come on down!” Dave’s my favorite comedian. So…

Ahmir “Questlove” Thompson: I was on a date, and I was trying not to look at my phone, but I heard a beep and saw the name Rock: “I’m down here at the Cellar. Chappelle’s going on in twenty minutes.” That was the fastest “Check, please!” I’ve ever said in my life. I lied to my date and said I’d been called into the studio.

Bellamy: Kevin Hart walks out. And here comes Chris Rock. Then Dave was like, “Who else is in here?” That was rich. So then me and Marlon come up. People go goddamn crazy. And we just start passing the microphone, telling stories about each other. It was a Black Pack moment.

Bellamy: But we all had our moment to say how much we love and appreciate each other’s talent. It wasn’t a roast. It was a tribute.

Rock: And it’ll never happen again. There’s no Coachella of comedy where we all get together, you know?

Dave Chappelle: I had no idea all those guys were going to be there. You know, comedy is surprisingly competitive. It’s like being in the Karate Kid tournament every night. I’ve known these guys for years and have always respected their talent, but on that night, I got to experience it up close. That’s why it was special. But it made me laugh that Ahmir told his date he needed to go to the studio. Why didn’t he just bring her to the show?