ミドリ wrote:not convinced by this bandwagon. also interesting that Decretum started this one but didn't take part at all in K2's lynching. Not passing judgement just yet but if AA dies tonight and turns out to be innocent...

Literally went for a nap because I was ill.

I posted it upon request from others in the group, I think that would be obvious given that AA didn't direct his counterlynch towards me

And I looked, and behold, a pale horse! And its rider’s name was Death

scapegoat is most likely maf, btw. i PMed him, after the substitution, for a claim. since I questioned k2, ultimately leading to him posting that error filled role PM and his lynch, d1, it's pretty much irrefutable that i'm a villager and thus there'd be no reason not to claim to me, right? yet he didn't respond and now that day has rolled around i'm dead. fits his pattern of behaviour as a mafian where he just shies away w/e he's pushed, too. pls at least check this out village

I mean tbf you immediately asked for a claim after he's just entered the game so there's no real reason he would claim to you straight away especially if he's not even confirmed to have been following the game religiously.

If it had been 24-48 hours sure but don't use connor logic pls hass

And I looked, and behold, a pale horse! And its rider’s name was Death

"Someone didn't claim to me within 10 minutes of them being in the game, he's therefore mafia!"
Yes, you're village but how does this hold water? If he hadn't been following the game there was no reason for him to claim to you at all, for all he knows he's giving away the location of a power role to a mafian. As it happens that wasn't the case, but how was he to know that?

--Edit--
Been thinking about AA's record in the last couple of games and I don't think we can trust him.Lynch AlterntiveAntagonist

guess I'll stick the final nail in the coffin. Lynch AlternativeAntagonist

as for why I didn't respond to Hass immediately with a role claim, firstly I had to check the thread to make sure he was actually confirmed village, and secondly, I was out with friends all night so I couldn't really do much apart from replying with a 1 word message in response to him asking me whether I was subbing in or not.

people do have real lives that stop them from monitoring a game that they weren't even playing in 24/7.

AlterntiveAntagonist found himself surrounded by the people of Lordran, and his lineage came to an end.

-YOU DIED-

Nofes wrote:

"I'll repay my debt to you in battle. And I swear it by my sword. The road ahead's gonna be long, but I'm here to help. Gah hah hah hah hah!"

You are Benhart of Jugo. Hailing from the land of Jugo, you are a humble yet proud warrior who travelled to the continent of Drangleic in order to develop and perfect your swordsmanship. You wield the Bluemoon Sword, a weapon passed down your family for generations. Despite this, the sword is not as powerful you believe it to be - the sword you believe you possess is merely a replica of the true sword, the Moonlight Greatsword.

You are the Vigilante. As a staunch protector of those you care about, once per night, you may Kill a player of your choosing. However, due to your sword being a fake, there is only a 50% chance that this will work - if you successfully Kill your target, the next time you attempt to Kill, the chance will be reduced to 25%. For each subsequent time a Kill is successfully landed, the chance will be halved again. However, once a Kill misses, the chance will reset to 50%.

You are aligned with the Village, and win when all outside threats are eliminated.

NOTE: Please remember to include "Souls Mafia” or "Mafia Souls" in the title of your Night Action PMs. This is just to ensure it won't get lost among other PMs. Thanks.

Dusk falls upon Lordran, and what protection the sun's warmth may bring to Lordran vanishes.

Night begins.

Send all PMs to Nofes. Deadline is 10pm, 20th of February, but if all night actions have been sent before then and I'm awake, the next day phase will begin.

I'd like to thank everyone for their support of my works these past few games. While my first performance "The man who thought he was a wolf" was well received, I always felt it was sub par. The same with the second performance; In all honesty, it was a needless sequel. It was then that I realised I needed to add some more 'zazz' to my next performance, and so here I am zazzing things up.

Incidentally, I should mention that I did claim to my dear friend Pie that I was the vigilante, but he did not believe me due to the random nature of my killing ability which is unfortunately blocked to you all. Why, I countered, would the serial killer be restricted by chance and not I? Alas, Pie's suspicions denied me the heroic turnabout that I craved, yet this way also has a certain je ne sais quoi about it. Although I must say I am disappointed in those that believed this wasn't entirely in my character to do, I can honestly say I have no regrets about this.

where is aa? what? what do you mean you killed him!? wh-why?? he was my best friend! you thought he was mafia? why? he hasn't done anything wrong. so, was he mafia?

oh, he was innocent.

you killed an innocent man. an innocent MY BEST FRIEND. for nothing.

this is what i meant, when i said that if we lynched people we might become as bad as the mafia themselves.

THIS is what i meant. i hope you are all happy. i hope you're gooseberry fool HAPPY. the next time you sick gooseberry fool are about to kill someone because "you think they might be mafia", maybe think about the fact that they have friends and family? seriously. i am so done with all of you. aa, i will avenge you. it was the mafia that did this, i know it. the mafia orchestrated your death because they FEARED you. your death will not be in vain. i will use it to power my soul. to power my hopes and my dreams.

fluffyKittan - He's used to sitting in teamspeak with us where people don't cry when somebody tells you to go drink some H2SO4 for being bad at what you're doingregg - I entirely surrender to your superior wit.

Dawn broke over Lordran, and the body of ミドリ, reduced to ash by a Great Fireball, was found.

-YOU DIED-

Nofes wrote:

"Much trouble has thou caus'd. Thou was weak in spirit, broken by the weight of thy sin."

You are Oswald of Carim. Hailing from the far-off land of Carim, you are a pardoner, and worshipper of Velka, Goddess of Sin. For a price, you absolve the sin of the wretched, and can also make judgement through the usage of Indictments.

You are the Investigator. As a pardoner, the sins and wrongdoings of others are your domain. With the use of Indictments, once per night, you may either Track or Investigate a player of your choosing. However, you only have 4 available Indictments, which apply to both actions - as such, using one Track will reduce your amount of possible Tracks and Investigations to 3, and if you should use one Investigation at that point, your Tracks and Investigations would be reduced to 2.

You are aligned with the Village, and win when all outside threats are eliminated.

NOTE: Please remember to include "Souls Mafia” or "Mafia Souls" in the title of your Night Action PMs. This is just to ensure it won't get lost among other PMs. Thanks.

Day begins.

Deadline is 10pm, February 20th, but if a lynch consensus is met before then the next night phase will begin early.

To explain this briefly, both poke/chris and fluffy/matt have claimed a neutral role that hates the other. When one dies, the other joins the village. Essentially this means we have a free day phase where we don't necessarily have a good mafia lead and not lose much on the village side.
At this point both have been relatively inactive in the thread, so I'm going mostly by players and stuff outside of it.
As far as I'm aware chris hasn't really done anything outside of the thread, whereas I've at least been in contact with matt and talked through some things. I also personally value matt more than chris as a player, so I'd rather have him of the two on the village side.
Unless some amazing mafia lead comes out of nowhere at this stage today I'll probably be sticking to this conviction.

And I looked, and behold, a pale horse! And its rider’s name was Death

May I ask what the point of lynching me is though. I don't deny my role, but its hardly as if either Matt or I is going to work against the village in the meantime, so while technically we're not currently village, we may as well be for how we're going to play the game. Sure it means a villager doesn't die, but you still lose a non-mafian, and someone who is going to be playing as if they're a member of the village.

fluffyKittan - He's used to sitting in teamspeak with us where people don't cry when somebody tells you to go drink some H2SO4 for being bad at what you're doingregg - I entirely surrender to your superior wit.

Because you claimed a character that has barely any lore that I dont think the hosts would do, and you claimed possibly one of the most stupid roles to be in this game when it's an x shot cop.

fluffyKittan - He's used to sitting in teamspeak with us where people don't cry when somebody tells you to go drink some H2SO4 for being bad at what you're doingregg - I entirely surrender to your superior wit.