For The First Time, Mr. Gay World Crowned In Africa

Andreas Derleth of New Zealand was named Mr. Gay World 2012 on Sunday in Johannesburg. It marked the first time the competition was held in Africa, where being gay is a crime in many countries on the continent.

Wendelinus Hamutenya, 23, of Namibia, took part in the Mr. Gay World competition. When he first told his family he was gay, they put him in a mental institution. But now he says they fully support him.

Ethiopia's Robel Hailu, who took part in the Mr. Gay World competition, says his family has not spoken to him since they found out nearly two months ago that he would be a contestant. He also says he fears for his safety if he returns to Ethiopia.

Denis Farrell
/ AP

Listen

Listening...

/

Originally published on April 9, 2012 2:14 pm

At a golf resort in suburban Johannesburg, a group of men lounged by the pool. They cheered as five competitors sprinted around a grassy field — in Speedo swimsuits — to the sounds of "Yellow Polka Dot Bikini."

This was sports day at Mr. Gay World 2012.

Gay men from 22 countries took part, and this year's competition was noteworthy because it was the first time it was held on African soil. It addition, it also marked the first time that black African men participated, though there were just two.

Mr. Gay World was a five-day competition that includes a wide range of events. They included physical fitness tests, interviews and, of course, the nightwear and swimsuit competitions.

Looking For A Global Representative

Coenie Kukkuk, a co-founder of Mr. Gay South Africa who helped organize this year's event, said it's not about finding a pretty face or rock-hard abs — though that doesn't hurt.

"This is not a beauty pageant," he says. "It is a search for an LGBTI [lesbian, gay, bisexual, transgender, intersex] representative and an ambassador. There's no age limit; they have to do written tests and have knowledge — even in part of the sports challenge today, the clues were questions about LGBTI history and LGBTI rights."

Kukkuk says the organizers were excited to hold the event in Africa and hope it will bring attention to the challenges that gays and lesbians here face.

"In 37 countries, out of the 52 in Africa, it is still illegal just to be gay," he said.

Wendelinus Hamutenya, a 23-year-old nurse and midwife from Namibia, was one of just two black Africans in the competition. He says it's difficult for African men to participate and still be accepted at home. His own family refused to believe he was gay for a long time.

When he was a teenager, "The first time I told my parents that I am gay, I [was] taken to the mental institution," he said. He sneaked out of that institution; eventually, his family members decided to accept him, and they gave him full support for his participation in the competition.

Ethiopian Contestant Fears For His Safety

The other black participant, an Ethiopian graduate student named Robel Hailu, hasn't been as fortunate. Rather than telling his family he was gay, he let them read about the competition in the newspapers. That was nearly two months ago.

"I don't have any communication with them," he said. "Not only my family; my relatives, my best friends, a lot of people."

And he says he's scared to return to Ethiopia, where homosexuality is illegal. He fears he'll be imprisoned by the government or worse.

"If I go back home, they arrest me," he says. "I don't have the right to go back home."

Africa wasn't the only region that had thin representation. Asia, the Middle East and Eastern Europe had a noticeable lack of competitors, all of them regions where gays are still stigmatized.

Around sub-Saharan Africa, some governments are taking a stand against homosexuality.

Nigeria recently banned same-sex marriages and made it illegal to work with LGBT groups — a move that could hamper AIDS prevention efforts.

Uganda removed the death penalty from a proposed anti-gay bill but may still impose lengthy jail sentences.

And in South Africa, where homosexual rights are strongly protected, many gays and lesbians are still highly stigmatized, attacked and even killed.

Hints Of Growing Tolerance

But Graeme Reid, the director of the LGBT Rights Program for Human Rights Watch in New York, says there are also signs of growing tolerance.

"I think Rwanda's a good example in which, when there was a proposal to introduce discriminatory legislation, that the minister of justice stood up very clearly," he said. "Kenya, with its new constitution, is more open to protecting human rights. Botswana is open to new dialogue and discussion."

At a U.N. meeting in Geneva last month, Secretary-General Ban Ki-moon sent a powerful message to LGBT people around the world.

"To those who are lesbian, gay, bisexual or transgender, let me say, you are not alone," Ban said. "Your struggle for an end to violence and discrimination is a shared struggle."

Meanwhile, South Africa has introduced a resolution that would force countries to provide equal rights to all, regardless of gender or sexual orientation.

Reid from Human Rights Watch says the fact that South Africa introduced the resolution has made a huge difference.

"Because here's this African nation, leading this discussion around sexual orientation and gender identity," he said. "It's a very different dynamic than if it was a former colonial power, for instance, initiating the discussion."

He says African nations are also feeling pressure from Latin America and parts of Asia — places that used to abstain from such discussions.

Back at the pageant, the five finalists stood onstage in suits, sashes draped over their shoulders. Then came the announcement that the winner was ... Andreas Derleth, 32, of New Zealand.

Hailu of Ethiopia didn't make the finals but says he'll continue fighting for LGBT rights.

"I have a [big] job to do for Ethiopia, and for African LGBT rights," he says.

But getting back into his country — and staying safe — could be a challenging first step.

Copyright 2017 NPR. To see more, visit http://www.npr.org/.

AUDIE CORNISH, HOST:

From NPR News, this is ALL THINGS CONSIDERED. I'm Audie Cornish.

ROBERT SIEGEL, HOST:

And I'm Robert Siegel. This weekend, men from 22 countries travel to Johannesburg, South Africa to compete in the Mr. Gay World pageant. It's not a new competition, but it is the first time the pageant has been held on African soil and it's the first time black Africans have participated.

Reporter Anders Kelto got a firsthand look at the Mr. Gay World pageant.

ANDERS KELTO, BYLINE: At a gulf resort in suburban Johannesburg, men in tiny swimsuits surround a pool. They cheer as a group of competitors races around a grass field to the sounds of "Yellow Polka Dot Bikini."

This is Sports Challenge Day at Mr. Gay World 2012. Mr. Gay World is a five day competition that includes a wide range of events - fitness tests, quizzes about LGBT rights and, of course, evening wear and swimsuit competitions.

Coenie Kukkuk is a cofounder of Mr. Gay South Africa and organized this year's event. He says it's not about finding a pretty face or rock hard abs, though neither of those hurt.

COENIE KUKKUK: This is not a beauty pageant. It is the search for an LGBTI representative and an ambassador.

KELTO: Kukkuk says the organizers were excited to hold the event in Africa and hope it will bring attention to the challenges that gays and lesbians here face.

KUKKUK: In 37 countries in Africa, it is still illegal just to be gay.

KELTO: Wendelinus Hamutenya is a 23-year-old midwife from Namibia. He's one of just two black Africans in the competition. He says it's difficult for gay African men to participate in the pageant and still be accepted at home.

WENDELINUS HAMUTENYA: When I told - same time I told my parent that I'm gay, I have to be taken to the mental institution.

KELTO: He snuck out of the mental institution and his family eventually supported him, but the other African delegate, an Ethiopian student named Robel Hailu, hasn't been as fortunate. He didn't tell his family he was gay. He instead let them read about the pageant in the newspapers.

ROBEL HAILU: I'm fighting with my family. I don't have any communication with them. My relatives, my best friends, I lost all of those people.

KELTO: He fears that, if he returns to Ethiopia, where homosexuality is illegal, he'll be imprisoned. Around the continent, some African governments are cracking down on homosexuality. In November, Nigeria banned same-sex marriages and made it illegal to recognize or assist LGBT groups. Uganda is considering legislation that would impose lengthy jail sentences. And, in South Africa, where homosexual rights are strongly protected, gays and lesbians are often victims of hate crimes.

But Graeme Reid, the director of the LGBT Rights Program for Human Rights Watch in New York, says there are also signs of growing tolerance.

GRAEME REID: Kenya, for example, is more open to protecting human rights. I think Botswana is open and we might see some move towards decriminalization there.

KELTO: He also mentions Liberia, Rwanda and Mozambique as countries that have taken steps to protect gays. South Africa has also introduce a UN resolution that would ban discrimination based on sexual orientation and Reid says African nations are facing new pressure from Latin America and Asia, not just from the West.

(SOUNDBITE OF APPLAUSE AND CHEERING)

KELTO: Back at the pageant, the finalists stand on stage awaiting the final announcements, white sashes draped over their suits.

UNIDENTIFIED MAN: Mr. Gay World 2012 is New Zealand.

(SOUNDBITE OF APPLAUSE AND CHEERING)

KELTO: After the show, Robel Hailu of Ethiopia says he's disappointed he didn't win, but he says he'll continue fighting for LGBT rights in Ethiopia, even if he has to do so from abroad.