Favorite Schools

Favorite Teams

Greater New Orleans

Change Region

comments

New Beginnings school board cited for open meetings law violation

New Beginnings school.jpg

The New Beginnings school board, which operates Gentilly Terrace Charter, shown here at a 2011 ribbon-cutting ceremony, has been cited by the state Education Department for violating the Louisiana Open Meetings Law.
(The Times-Picayune archive)

Mildred Labostrie stormed out of a New Beginnings Schools Foundation board meeting in early June -- when the chair of the board that governs her granddaughter's school told her she had missed her opportunity to offer public comment. But New Beginnings' blatant disregard for state open meetings law didn't go unnoticed that night: The network received a "formal notice of concern" from the state Department of Education.

At that packed board meeting June 6, no members of the audience offered public comment when board chair Tim Ryan asked for it at the beginning of the meeting. Little did they know that would be their one opportunity to communicate their thoughts and opinions.

That was the only time Ryan asked for public comment, even though state law requires that the public be allowed to comment before each action item. The board took several votes that night.

Parents and teachers grew visibly frustrated at times as Ryan plowed through the meeting. At one point, Labostrie spoke up after Ryan asked if anyone had a comment. She quickly found out he was referring only to board members when he told her she couldn't speak.

As the two spoke over each other, Ryan interjected: "I'm sorry, we had our time for public comment. We can't have the public participate in the board meeting." Labostrie left.

It was The Lens' article that alerted the Louisiana Department of Education to the open meetings law violation that occurred during the meeting, department spokeswoman Anna Gatlin confirmed Monday.

Six days after the meeting on June 12, Patrick Walsh, the executive director of Charter Accountability, wrote a one-page letter alerting the network to the violation and requiring it take action to rectify the situation and "return to good standing."

"This letter serves as a formal notice of concern to the New Beginnings Schools Foundation regarding failure to adhere to the Louisiana Open Meetings laws," he wrote.

In order to return to good standing, the network had to review portions of the open meetings law in a public meeting, which it did on June 25. Ryan also had to submit a signed letter stating the law was reviewed by the board of directors and "will be adhered to in the future."

The next day, Ryan sent a letter to Walsh stating the network had complied with the requirements. On June 27, Walsh responded, stating the department was satisfied and New Beginnings had been returned to good standing.

New Beginnings isn't the only charter school board that has struggled with open meetings law requirements: