How about a goalkeeper's strike winning the league? Colchester stopper Scott Barrett basically did just that with a goal in injury time against Wycombe in 1992.

The match was level when a mammoth Barrett punt downfield took an equally mammoth bounce and ended up in the back of the Chairboys' net. Not only did that goal win the game, it also won them promotion to the Football League as Colchester went on to lift the Conference title. On goal difference. Over Wycombe. You couldn't make this stuff up...