Us Weeklyexclusively revealed that the How I Met Your Mother actor, 33, and Williams, 32, split in early February after a year of dating. "They had a lot of fun, but it just didn't work," a pal told Us. "The breakup was mutual," another insider said.

A source also explained to Us that Segel and Williams' bicoastal relationship became too difficult to make work. Williams lives in New York with daughter Matilda, 7, while Segel lives in Los Angeles to film his CBS sitcom.