Best Action: Kill la Kill
Best Adventure: Log Horizon
Best Comedy: Monthly Girls
Best Drama : Samurai Flamenco
Best Ecchi Series: No Game, No Life
Best Fantasy: Log Horizon/Log Horizon 2, Second: Yuki Yuna is a hero
Best Harem: Nisekoi
Best Horror: Parasyte (only horror I've watched in a long time)
Best Mystery: Mekaku City Actors
Best Psychological: N/a (not voting)
Best Romance: The World Is Still Beautiful
Best Science Fiction: The Irregular at Magic Highschool
Best Slice of Life: Silver Spoon S2
Best Sports: Yowamushi Pedal
Best Short Series (3-10 minutes): Tonari no Seki-kun
Best Anime Movie: N/a (Not Voting)

Biggest Surprise of 2014: Yuki Yuna is a Hero
Biggest Let Down (Disappointment) of 2014: Terraformars, more specifically its censorship...
Must Watch of 2014 (think of it like if there was 1 anime you had to watch from 2013 it would be...): Tie between Kill la Kill and Samurai Flamenco
Best of 2014!: Samurai Flamenco (It's in my top 5 of all time (see my top 50 all time on my profile))

Biggest Surprise of 2014.....
Was in romance, I really hate that genre but these were really good to my surprise!
Monthly Girl's Nozaki-kun
Wolf Girl and Black Prince
Blue Spring Ride

Biggest let down (disappointment ) of 2014
Your lie in April..this one was a real let down, not even the good music could save this boring story.
Glasslip..another disappointing romance/slice of life. It was a tad weird too.
DRAMAtial Murder... the game was so good......but the anime, need anymore be said?

Must Watch ...The Best of 2014 I don't know any from 2013 to 2014 but for 2014
Tokyo Ghoul
Monthly Girl's Nozaki-kun
Fate/stay night :Unlimited Blade Works

Best Action: The Irregular at Magic High School
Best Adventure: Log Horizon 2
Best Comedy: Seitokai Yakuindomo 2
Best Drama: Blue Spring Ride
Best Fantasy: When Supernatural Battles Become Commonplace
Best Harem: Rail Wars
Best Romance: A Good Librarian Like a Good Shepherd
Best Science Fiction: Sword Art Online 2
Best Slice of Life: A Good Librarian Like a Good Shepherd

Best Male Character: Kyoutaro Kakei (A Good Librarian Like a Good Shepherd)
Best Female Character: Satone Schimiya (Chuunibyou)

Biggest Surprise of 2014: One Week Friends
Biggest Let Down (Disappointment) of 2014: No Game No Life
Must Watch of 2014: Kawai Complex Guide to Manors and Hostel Behavior
Best of 2014!A Good Librarian Like a Good Shepherd

2nd:

Best Story: One Week Friends
Best Animation: Chuunibyou
Best Character Design: One Week Friends

Best OP: Rising Hope by LiSa (Irregular at Magic High School)
Best ED: No More Time Machine by LiSa (Sword Art Online 2)
Best OST (Original Soundtrack): Chaika the Coffin Princess~Avenging Battle

Best Action: Chaika the Coffin Princess
Best Adventure: Chaika the Coffin Princess
Best Comedy: Wolf Girl and Black Prince
Best Drama: One Week Friends
Best Fantasy: Chaika the Coffin Princess
Best Harem: When Supernatural Battles Become Commonplace
Best Romance: Wolf Girl and Black Prince
Best Science Fiction: Black Bullet
Best Slice of Life: One Week Friends

Before I go on, I would like to list the anime I watched but did not give an award to:
D-Fragments
Noragami
Saki-The Nationals
Pilot's Love Song
Wizard Barristers
Brynhildr in the Darkness
If Her Flag Breaks
Date A Live 2
Is the Order a Rabbit?
Nanana's Buried Treasure
Bladedance of Elementers
Free! Eternal Summer
Jinsei
Magimoji Rurumo
Amagi Brilliant Park
Yuuki Yuuna

All great anime I recommend watching, but not good enough (or bad enough in the disappointment category. Go figure) to place for any awards.
I would also like to take a moment to do an honorable tribute for the late Monty Oum's RWBY series. Monty brought a fantastic series. Please honor Monty Oum by watching RWBY: http://www.crunchyroll.com/rwby

And now, the gold medals.

Best Story: Chuunibyou
Best Animation: Glasslip
Best Character Design: Chuunibyou

Best OP: Black Bullet by fripSide (Black Bullet)
Best ED: Born to Be by nano (Magical Warfare)
Best OST (Original Soundtrack): A Good Librarian Like a Good Shepherd

Best Action: Chaika~Avenging Battle
Best Adventure: Chaika~Avenging Battle
Best Comedy: Kawai Complex Guide to Manors and Hostel Behavior
Best Drama: Chuunibyou
Best Fantasy: Chaika~Avenging Battle
Best Harem: A Good Librarian Like a Good Shepherd
Best Romance: Chuunibyou
Best Science Fiction: Irregular at Magic High School
Best Slice of Life: Chuunibyou