Amanda Beth, but how does that come into play with Renesmee, who Alice also can't see? She is an individual entity and Alice can never seen anything to do with her, mental or otherwise.

And even if it is mental, that's the whole basis of Alice's power. It is based on people's decisions, the decisions they make in their minds before they take any action. That's why she saw Bella being killed by James before Bella had done anything outwardly to end up putting her in James's power. She made the decision to go, so Alice saw her dying at James's hand. Alice's powers responds more to mental than other stimuli.

Also, there have been enough examples throughout the series of Alice not being able to see wolves, whether it was as the result of physical or mental actions. She has never been able to see them at all, either as humans, wolves, packs or individuals.

Ultimately, as I said in my review, the scene was just so cool I don't care. But it is a bit of a bugbear for me. I'll just believe that Alice painted in the wolves to make up for her blind spot so that Aro could see the full effect of what happened when a member of his guard 'disappeared' because they were fighting wolves and were spat out in pieces, like Jane.

Whoa.. I feel like I'm one of the few that didn't really think about the fact that Alice shouldn't be able to see the wolves. I was so freaked by the battle that I didn't notice..nor did I catch that Seth died eek! I personally liked the vision of Jacob and Renesmee in the future very sweet to know they're all going to be happy together, canon or not. But that's just me.

Just a quick drive by b/c I have to spend time with the hubby. I just went to my 3rd viewing. I have seen it now everyday it has been released. I didn't tell me friend a thing and I it was great to see her expression at that part especially because she get very emotional on movies. Not sure if I am going to see it again since it is $12.00 here.

Hi, Y'all!! Everybody check out the sibling list and make sure I've got everyone added now. I'm listening to the BD2 Soundtrack as we speak! I have to say that this go-around, I had to hear the music in the movie before really wanting to run out and by the soundtrack. What I really want my hands on is the score! I can't wait to have the time to write some fanfiction while the score plays in the background! Can't hang around long! I need to be in bed soon. It's been a full day, and tomorrow will be even fuller!Talk to Y'all soon!

Hi, Y'all!3rd viewing today! The battle scene is still not easy to watch, but at least I made it through without hyperventilating today. I was actually able to cry during it today instead. I'm still not ready to talk about it yet. I'm sure by the 4th viewing tomorrow I'll be ready. Just about the time for me to get back to reality and leave this bittersweet but gloriously awesome weekend behind.

CARYN~~ I looked intensely today during the CampFire scene and could find only one item of possible nostalgia... The Tent from Eclipse. But I know that's not what you've discovered. So... do tell!

QUESTION: Isn't it Leah who falls into the crevass (sp?) after helping Esme? I thought at first it was the pup with the white patch over his eye, but it wasn't.