Business

Hot Topics:

Megan McCain learns something in 'Raising McCain'

By Willa Paskin, Slate

Posted:
09/13/2013 11:38:54 AM MDT

Roberta McCain, mother of Republican presidential candidate John McCain, sits with her granddaughters, Megan, during the first day of the Republican National Convention in St. Paul, Minnesota, Monday, September 1, 2008. (Marc Lester/Anchorage Daily News/MCT)

NEW YORK -- Megan McCain deserves credit for what her new TV show "Raising McCain," premiering this Saturday, is not: a reality series. McCain would be a reality TV natural. She's indefatigable, unembarrassable, fun to watch. She likes a fight and is not particularly cautious about what flies out of her mouth. If she wanted a reality series, she almost certainly could have had one, and it probably would have aired on a channel that, unlike Pivot, a newborn network for millennials, is carried by most major cable providers. Instead, McCain has opted to create something more civic-minded, a news hour that makes a good faith effort to "Dig deep into the issues that matter most to our generation." So, respect to Megan McCain for aiming higher than various Palins. And thus concludes the complimentary portion of this review.

McCain first appears in "Raising McCain" wearing a plaid shirt and the black, slouchy ski cap all the baristas in all the pour-over coffee places in all the land were wearing this morning, cursing and trying to nail a buck's head into the wall of her set. McCain's vaguely iconoclast vibe established, the show sets out to explore "privacy," a subject McCain is not worried about at all. If people want to stalk her on Twitter she's fine with that because "I don't think privacy exists anymore, and I don't care," like it's a discontinued line of Starbucks lattes.

Advertisement

McCain drafts journalist Michael Moynihan, a colleague from her Daily Beast days who's much more concerned about privacy issues, to help her explore a smorgasbord of privacy-related topics. McCain interviews a woman whose ex-boyfriend disseminated naked pictures of her, flies a drone, briefly talks to a guy who made a documentary about terms-of-service agreements and tries to dig up dirt on Moynihan, all in a crammed 22 minutes. The questions she asks are broad, the answers she elicits vague. "Are we just [expletive] as a culture?" McCain asks at one point, not exactly a topic-specific query. Ultimately, McCain agrees that privacy matters. "At the beginning of this episode I was a cocky little [expletive]," she says in her wrap-up, "but I was wrong."

This is the series' structure: In each episode McCain learns something. As the show's title promises, the series is educating her and, by extension, Pivot's hoped-for young audience. A protagonist learning alongside the viewers is an effective storytelling technique, but only if there's a higher, already educated intelligence operating off screen. On camera, it's great to ask questions and play the naif, so long as someone off-camera knows where all those questions lead. "Raising McCain" doesn't seem to have that guiding intelligence.

Raising McCain compares pretty unfavorably on this score to HBO's "Vice," another news program aimed at twentysomethings, of a more hipster-bro stripe. "Vice" expects that its viewers will be Googling wildly after, and maybe even while, watching it. It glosses complex issues like America's relationship with North Korea for entertainment's sake but with the added assumption that some audience members intrigued by Dennis Rodman's trip there will set out to learn more. It wants to be a serious issue gateway drug, though as with gateway drugs, not everyone goes on to become a news addict. "Raising McCain," in contrast, assumes that its potential audience, despite being forever on their smartphones, has no source of information other than "Raising McCain." It goes broad and shallow instead of narrow and relatively deep. It's a show for millennials, but it seems the show thinks millennials live in an information vacuum, instead of an information deluge.

Paskin, Slate's TV critic, has written for New York Magazine, The New York Times Magazine and Salon.com.

One-day event to run slide down University HillIt's not quite the alternative mode of transportation that Boulder's used to, but, for one day this summer, residents will be able to traverse several city blocks atop inflatable tubes.

DETROIT (AP) — In a story March 27 about a 'Little Syria' exhibit going to Ellis Island, The Associated Press, due to incorrect information from the Arab American National Museum, erroneously reported the date the exhibit will open. Full Story