Thanks trum01, I went to Brooks Brothers, and tried on their OCBD shirts. I found the 14 1/2 not very baggy, and bought a few online (they were out of them in the store). Supposed to get here tomorrow, will wash them and see if they shrink a bit.

Let me know if they shrink a bit ... I may pick some up then as well. Did you get the Non-Iron or the regular ones? I imagine the non-iron ones will be less comfortable ...

I just ordered a Charles Tyrwhitt in 14.5, Tailored Fit. Let's see how it compares to the Zara slim fit.

An interesting tidbit - I'm pretty damn skinny, and I once ordered a Calvin Klein Collection slim fit in size 37, and it was too tight around the stomach and waist. I'm not sure how that could fit anyone.

That's quite a useful metric! it does a great job of showing how different brands and lines compare to one another.

One of the biggest factors for me in selecting a slim fit shirt (aside from the chest, waist, and sleeve measurements) is the positioning of the armholes. While it's not as big an issue with regular fit shirts, armholes that are too low feel uncomfortable, especially when raising the arms.

Quote:

Originally Posted by apack

Here is the Nordstrom regular/slim/extra-slim size chart, which is useful because it compares many brands:

Though I realize that bringing up the subject of Carlo Franco shirts is likely to be touchy, it was certainly my experience that the first generation shirts was definitely what I call slim. Not sure what the status of their shirtmaking operation is these days, however.

In italian men-wear shops now I can hardly find the suitable size for myself and my brother, especially for clothes do-looking-slim. Not because of our heavyset figure but the design has some problems! Aronin's point makes sense to some extent but not absolute! Still appreciate such a good analysis.

The shirts I'm always searching for are Polo "Custom Fit" shirts. For me, they fit better than some MTM shirts. However they are very hard to come by. I can never find them at the Polo store and the 1-2 shirts they have on Polo.com are usually atrocious. There are plenty of tent-like "classic fit" shirts available.

Thanks a lot for provide us genuine information!!! I really impressed ***

I have tried Charles Tyrwhitt Tailored Fit shirts and for the price I'm happy with the quality but they are too baggy in the waist. I am thinking of having a tailor slim the shirts down.

I am wondering for future orders (made with the intent of having the shirt slimmed down by a tailor) should I order the slim fit or the tailored fit? I asked because the tailored fit has back darts where I understand the slim fit does not. Would the lack of darts be more conducive to adjustment?

I have tried Charles Tyrwhitt Tailored Fit shirts and for the price I'm happy with the quality but they are too baggy in the waist. I am thinking of having a tailor slim the shirts down.
I am wondering for future orders (made with the intent of having the shirt slimmed down by a tailor) should I order the slim fit or the tailored fit? I asked because the tailored fit has back darts where I understand the slim fit does not. Would the lack of darts be more conducive to adjustment?
Thanks.

I have this exact dilema. I bought a bunch of slim-fit shirts while losing weight. At some point I crossed over to Tailored fit, but then I wasn't wearing my slim-fit shirts anymore, so I had a tailor take them in. Now, they fit better than the tailored fit, and no darts. So I recommend using the slim-fit as a base, though I suppose it depends on how baggy the tailored fit are for you. For me, they were only slightly baggy.

Also make sure you use a decent tailor. I am not sure if this is standard practice or not, but when my tailor took them in, he took it in all the way down to the sleeve cuff to avoid having the shirt look "off."

I have this exact dilema. I bought a bunch of slim-fit shirts while losing weight. At some point I crossed over to Tailored fit, but then I wasn't wearing my slim-fit shirts anymore, so I had a tailor take them in. Now, they fit better than the tailored fit, and no darts. So I recommend using the slim-fit as a base, though I suppose it depends on how baggy the tailored fit are for you. For me, they were only slightly baggy.

Also make sure you use a decent tailor. I am not sure if this is standard practice or not, but when my tailor took them in, he took it in all the way down to the sleeve cuff to avoid having the shirt look "off."

Agreed. This is exactly what I do with my CH shirts, and now they are perfect, or damn well near it, and excellent value. and yes, please make sure you use a decent tailor.....

As soon as the budget allows, I will be shopping at their website again!

What's a common/popular length for a cropped shirt, one that doesn't require tucking in if need be. I'm taking a shirt to a tailor to hem it shorter. The shirts a Medium Brooks Brother Extra Slim. I'm about 5'9", 15.5 neck, 33 sleeve.