The Broadway.com staff is crazy for Culturalist, the website that lets you choose and create your own top 10 lists. Every week, we’re challenging you with a new Broadway-themed topic to rank.

Ahoy, kids! The SpongeBob SquarePants musical completed casting this week, and we've had the cast recording on repeat. In honor of the sweet sponge who lives in a pineapple under the sea, we were wondering: which other beloved Nickelodeon cartoon should get the Broadway treatment? We can't stop dreaming about what a CatDog puppet would look like or how great The Beets would be in a Doug musical (killer tofu!). So let your '90s/early 2000s cartoon-connoisseur flag fly. Broadway.com Content Producer (and Dino Spumoni enthusiast) Lindsey Sullivan got this challenge started. Now it's your turn!