Despite her shock and sadness, Cavallari, 24, harbors no resentment. "I've had such an incredible experience," she said. "I've made new friends. We've all become such a little family. I'm a huge fan of the show. I'll continue to be a huge fan of the show."

As for her prediction for who might win season 11, she said it was hard to choose – but she'd put her money on J.R. Martinez, who stirred the crowd Monday with his emotional routine, or Ricki Lake, who's atop the leader board this week.