Rocket Activity Pop Can Hero Engine

Transcription

1 Rocket Activity Pop Can Hero Engine Objective To investigate Newton s third law of motion using thrust produced by falling water. Description Small student teams will construct waterpropelled engines out of soft drink cans and investigate ways to increase the action-reaction thrust produced by water shooting out of holes punched in the can sides. National Science Content Standards Unifying Concepts and Processes Change, constancy, and measurement Science as Inquiry Abilities necessary to do scientific inquiry Physical Science Position and motion of objects Motions and forces Science and Technology Understanding about science and technology National Mathematics Content Standards Number and Operations Measurement Data Analysis and Probability National Mathematics Process Standards Reasoning and Proof Communication Connections Representations Materials 4 empty aluminum soft drink cans per team, with pull tabs intact Carpenter s nails of different sizes ( 6,12, 16D, etc.) String (about 50 cm) Water tub (large plastic storage tub, small kiddy pool, sink, etc.) Water Towels Rulers Stickers or bright permanent marker Management Divide your students into small groups. Set up one or more water tubs around your classroom and fill the tubs with about 20 cm of water. Have no more than one or two teams test their engines at one time. Discuss the importance of keeping the water in the tubs. When engines are filled, they should not be raised any higher than the rim of the tub. This will keep water coming out of the holes from falling on the surrounding floor. Be sure to recycle the cans at the conclusion of the activity. 34

2 Tip Ask students to bring undented and washed soft drink cans from home. You will need at least three cans per student team. Background This activity simulates the operation of the classic aleoliphile engine invented by Hero of Alexandria more than 2,000 years ago. (See page 2.) Hero s engine was a spinning copper sphere that was propelled by a thrust produced by a jet of steam. The engine was an early demonstration of the action-reaction principle (third law of motion) stated by Sir Isaac Newton 1,700 years later. (See page 4.) Steam, shooting out through two L-shaped holes, creates an action force that is accompanied by an equal reaction force in the opposite direction. Hero s invention was not self-contained and therefore, not a true rocket device. Heat to generate the steam had to be applied externally. Rockets are completely self-contained. In this activity, a Hero engine-like device is created by the students. Holes are punched in the side of a soft drink can. The holes are angled pinwheel fashion. A string, tied to the pull tab, supports the can and permits it to rotate. The can is immersed in water and pulled out. Gravity draws the water through the angled holes, and streams shoot out in either a clockwise or counterclockwise direction. The streams produce an action force that is accompanied by a reaction force. The can spins in the opposite direction. There are many potential variables with the Pop Can Hero engine. Hole size, hole angle, number of holes, and the placement of the hole above the base of the can all affect the thrust produced. The most significant of these variables is the hole placement. The greatest thrust occurs when the holes are punched just above the bottom of the can. This is a gravity effect. The strength of the water stream (thrust) is based on the pressure. Water pressure in a container is the greatest at the bottom. The pressure at the top of the water in the container is zero (ignoring air pressure in this example). Water dribbles out of a hole near the top of the column. The water stream gets stronger the closer the hole is to the container bottom. Thrust stops when water drains out to the level of the holes. Holes at the bottom of the container produce thrust for a longer time. However, the magnitude of the thrust diminishes as the water column lowers (pressure drops with column height). The three holes in this container each produce a water stream. Greater pressure at the bottom makes the stream shoot out farther. The effects of the other variables are many. For example, more holes means more water streams out of the can, but the water drains from the can more quickly. Large holes drain water more quickly than small holes. Holes angled in different directions counteract each other. Holes that are not angled produce water streams that leave the can perpendicular and no rotation occurs. (The object is to have students discover the effects of the different variables themselves.) Procedure Making the Pop Can Hero Engine 1. Divide your students into small teams of two or three members. 2. Demonstrate the procedure for punching holes in the cans. The idea is to punch the hole without crushing the can sides. Place the nail point near the bottom rim of the can. Apply pressure with the nail, turning it, if necessary, to make the hole. 3. When the hole is punched, push the nail head to the right or to the left. This will angle the hole so that water will stream out on a 35

3 tangent to produce thrust. 4. Rotate the can 1/4 turn and punch a second hole. Again angle the hole (in the same direction as before). 5. Repeat the procedure two more times to make four holes in total. (Cans may have different numbers of holes.) 6. Tie a string to the pop tab. 7. Place a sticker or a dot with a permanent marker near the top of the can. (The sticker or dot helps students count the rotations.) 8. Immerse the can in the tub of water. 9. When the can is full of water, lift it out by the string and observe the rotational motion. Procedure Student Team Experiment 1. Provide each team with copies of the Pop Can Hero Engine experiment sheet. 2. Review the instructions on the page and discuss the objective. ( Design an experiment to find a way to increase the number of rotations the Pop Can Hero Engine makes. ) 3. Make a list of student ideas for variables to test (hole size, number of holes, etc.). Discuss the importance of changing only one thing at a time. The first Hero engine they create will serve as the baseline experiment. The second and third engines will vary just one thing (e.g., Can 1 - medium size holes, Can 2 - smaller holes, Can 3 - larger holes) 5. Discuss ideas for keeping track of the number of rotations the cans make. (Place a large bright mark on one side, etc.) 4. Give teams time to pick their experiment, devise their hypothesis, and write the procedures they will follow on their experiment page. 5. Distribute the materials to the teams and have them begin their investigation. Discussion What provides the force that causes the cans to rotate? Actually, there are a combination of factors that contribute to the force that causes the cans to rotate. The most important is the force of gravity. It attracts the water COLA COLA Tip Make sure the nails used for punching holes have good points on them. They do not have to be needle sharp, just not blunt. in the can and causes it to stream out the holes. The shape of the hole directs the water streams. The diameter of the hole determines how fast the water streams out, etc. Which of Newton s laws of motion explains why the can rotates in the opposite direction from the direction of the water streams? Newton s third law of motion Based on the results of the individual team experiments, what could you do to maximize the number of rotations of the Pop Can Hero Engines? Individual answers: combine best hole size with the right number of holes, best placement, etc. 36

4 Assessment Ask teams to state their experiment hypotheses, explain their procedures, and present their results. Make a list of the different ways one can increase the number of rotations the Hero engine makes. Have teams submit their completed data sheet with their written conclusion based on their results. Extensions Construct an actual steam-powered hero engine and use it as a demonstration device. Although not difficult to construct, the engine will require some basic construction skills, principally soldering. You will need the following materials: - Copper toilet tank float (available from plumbing supply stores and from on-line plumbing supply stores - search copper toilet tank floats copper tube, 3/16 diameter (from hobby shops) - Thumbscrew to fit threads for float arm attachment - Metal file - 3/16 drill - solder - propane torch - pliers - string - water - eye protection 1. File a notch in the center of the tube. Do not file all the way through. In Instruction 3, the tube will be inserted completely through the sphere. This supports the tube while it is being soldered. (See diagram to the right.) 2. Drill 3/16th holes through opposite sides of the float just above the equator joint. 3. Insert the tube through the holes. Lightly heat the place where the tubes contact the sphere. Touch solder to the contact point to seal the tube to the float. 4. Apply heat to soften the opposite ends of the tube until they bend easily. Using pliers to grasp the ends, bend the tube ends into an L shape. Be careful not to overheat or bend too forcefully, or the tube may flatten on the bend. 5. Drill through the center of the threads for the attachment point for the float arm. This will open a water-filling hole into the float. 6. Drill a hole through the flat side of the thumb screw to permit tying of the string. 7. Pour about 30 milliliters of water (about 1 tablespoon) into the float through the filling hole. 8. Thread the thumbscrew into the hole and attach the string. 9. Suspend the engine from above and gently heat the bottom of the engine with a torch. Be sure to wear eye protection. When the water boils, steam will be produced that will jet out of the two nozzles and propel the engine. Filing produces an opening in the tube through which the steam can pass. Tip Before using your steam Hero engine, confirm the tubes are not blocked by blowing through them. If air comes out the opposite tube, the engine is safe to use. 37

Rockets: Taking Off! For every action there is an equal and opposite reaction. Rockets and Balloons What happens when you blow up a balloon then let it go? Does the balloon move through the air? Did you

Rocket Activity Foam Rocket Objective Students will learn about rocket stability and trajectory with rubber band-powered foam rockets. Description Students will construct rockets made from pipe insulating

DESIGN CONSIDERATIONS FOR WATER-BOTTLE ROCKETS 1 Read the following information. It is provided to help in the design of your water-bottle rocket and will help you answer questions in your Water-Bottle

General Laboratory Equipment 1 Science Laboratory Workbench Purpose: This is a simple science all-purpose worktable that can be easily built in any home or schoolroom. The laboratory contains a power supply,

Gear PEPSI CAN STOVE INSTRUCTIONS [NOTE: Updated Instructions are now available. The new stove is less likely to develop flame leaks and the fuel/air mixture is improved. Instructions for a simmer ring

Activity 1: Measuring Magnetism Science is built up with facts, as a house is with stones. But a collection of facts is no more a science than a heap of stones is a house. - Jules Henri Poincare Activity

Understanding the motion of the Universe Motion, Force, and Gravity Laws of Motion Stationary objects do not begin moving on their own. In the same way, moving objects don t change their movement spontaneously.

What is a Mouse-Trap Car and How does it Work? A mouse-trap car is a vehicle that is powered by the energy that can be stored in a wound up mouse-trap spring. The most basic design is as follows: a string

Introduction Overview This first program introduces students to the idea of motion, and the forces that start the movement of an object. Students are introduced to Isaac Newton who is best known for the

Bottle Rockets Vanderbilt Student Volunteers for Science Fall 2008 I. Introduction: History of Rockets Explain to the students that rockets are more than two thousand years old. Give the students a BRIEF

Clicker Questions Chapter 10 2010 Pearson Education, Inc. Essential College Physics Rex/Wolfson Question 10.1 Density If one material has a higher density than another, does this mean that the molecules

Description: SC250/400 Vent button Part number: 0752492/3230716 Look for Service Centres, Point of Sale addresses and other Version: 1 Date: pril 2010 Tools required: - Using the sliding cover as a lever

Flashing LED Circuit Assembly Activity Project: Each student will build a flashing LED circuit to take home. Skills: Safety first Listening to directions Following directions and diagrams Learning to solder

CITY OF SAN JOSE BUILDING DIVISION POLICY Policy on Water Heater Installations Policy No. UPC 510-1-94 Effective: September 1, 1995 Revised: February 10, 1996 All new and replacement water heaters installed

1 Glasses for Missions, Inc. Instruction Manual All praise and thanks to Jesus Christ, our Lord and Savior, who has blessed us with a vision to help restore sight and vision to His people in many lands,

Density of Materials v061813_810pm Objective: The student will be able to determine the density of a regular solid, an irregular solid, a liquid, and test their understanding of density by determination

Rocket Principles Outside ir Pressure Inside ir Pressure ir Moves Balloon Moves rocket in its simplest form is a chamber enclosing a gas under pressure. small opening at one end of the chamber allows the

Water Rocket Physics Principles Forces and Motion Newton s First Law An object at rest remains at rest, and an object in motion remains in motion at constant speed and in a straight line unless acted on

Civil Air Patrol s Fizzy Rocket For Use As Enrichment After CAP Foam Rocket by AAS/SW Joint National Project: STEM Outreach Partners in Aerospace and STEM Education: Arnold Air Society Civil Air Patrol

Newton s Second Law Objective The Newton s Second Law experiment provides the student a hands on demonstration of forces in motion. A formulated analysis of forces acting on a dynamics cart will be developed

Experiments (4 different experiments) Teacher Demonstrations & Info: Pour iron filings on a transparency to demonstrate that the iron bits make a pattern around the magnet. More bits go to the poles where

Aquverse Water Cooler Installation and Troubleshooting Instructions For any needed assistance please call 1-866-872-5722 ****Warning do not plug water cooler in until water line is in place and dispensing

BASIC PLUMBING The simple skills required for basic plumbing are explained in this project. It helps to have some metalworking experience. Take care when working with a blowtorch in loft spaces. Be aware

Air Apparent: A Program About Air and Air Pressure Presented by the Sciencenter in Ithaca, NY Program Overview Air Apparent introduces students to air, focusing on the key properties of air as a kind of

CENTRIFUGAL PUMP OVERVIEW Presented by Matt Prosoli Of Pumps Plus Inc. 1 Centrifugal Pump- Definition Centrifugal Pump can be defined as a mechanical device used to transfer liquid of various types. As

L06-1 Name Date Partners LAB 6 - GRAVITATIONAL AND PASSIVE FORCES OBJECTIVES And thus Nature will be very conformable to herself and very simple, performing all the great Motions of the heavenly Bodies

Fan Cart A physics classic If a sailboat is stranded because there is no wind, is it possible to set up a fan on deck and blow wind into the sail to make the boat move? This is a classic physics problem

SURFACE TENSION Definition In the fall a fisherman s boat is often surrounded by fallen leaves that are lying on the water. The boat floats, because it is partially immersed in the water and the resulting

Foundations and Mathematical Application of the Water Rocket Students Utilize 2-Liter Bottle Rocket Launcher will help students to explore the science of rocketry. Students build &propel 2-liter bottle

SPACE ENGINEERING-REBELLING ROCKETS MAKING ROCKETS AND LAUNCHING COMPETITION Experiment Objective: Students will design and construct a small rocket and rocket fuel. They will then launch the rockets and

Described by Isaac Newton States observed relationships between motion and forces 3 statements cover aspects of motion for single objects and for objects interacting with another object An object at rest

Magnetism Introduction This topic explores the key concepts of magnetism as they relate to: the phenomenon of magnetism magnetic forces and fields a theory of magnetism. Key concepts of magnetism The activities

4 TH GRADE AIR AND AIR PRESSURE Summary: Students experiment with air by finding that it has mass and pressure. Warm air is less dense than cool air and this is tested using a balance. Students experiment

Chapter 14: Magnets and Electromagnetism 1. Electrons flow around a circular wire loop in a horizontal plane, in a direction that is clockwise when viewed from above. This causes a magnetic field. Inside

I CLOCK KIT INSTRUCTION SHEET GETTING READY Before you start, read through the instructions, including the "Trouble Shooting" section. Ifyou received a dvd with the kit, watch the entire dvd. If you have

Chapter 4 Dynamics: Newton s Laws of Motion Force Units of Chapter 4 Newton s First Law of Motion Mass Newton s Second Law of Motion Newton s Third Law of Motion Weight the Force of Gravity; and the Normal

Torque and Rotation Physics Torque Force is the action that creates changes in linear motion. For rotational motion, the same force can cause very different results. A torque is an action that causes objects

American Stirling Eco-Power Stirling Engine Kit www.stirlingengine.com (SKU=Eco-Power) Power this engine with nothing more than a cup of steaming hot coffee. The Eco-Power engine is perfect as a fascinating

55 Name Date Partners LAB 6: GRAVITATIONAL AND PASSIVE FORCES And thus Nature will be very conformable to herself and very simple, performing all the great Motions of the heavenly Bodies by the attraction

National Aeronautics and Space Administration CLEANING WATER Student Section Student Name This lesson challenges you to create and test a water filtration system. During this lesson, you will design and

Simple machines OBJECTIVES When you have completed this lesson you will be able to: identify some common simple machines explain how simple machines make work easier A machine is an invention that makes

RECOMMENDED MAINTENANCE: The following matters should be dealt with as frequently as necessary in your particular case. If your gaslight has been out of use for a period of time, examine it before lighting

Weather reports in the media provide information on variables such as temperature, precipitation and wind speed. In this chapter, we discuss three physical quantities that help determine weather: (1) Temperature,

National Aeronautics and Space Administration SPEED IT UP Activity topic selected from NASA s KSNN 21 st Century Explorer newsbreak How can we travel faster in space? Educator Section Introduction NASA

A cart full of water travels horizontally on a frictionless track with initial velocity v. As shown in the diagram, in the back wall of the cart there is a small opening near the bottom of the wall that

Understanding the motion of the Universe Motion, Force, and Gravity Laws of Motion Stationary objects do not begin moving on their own. In the same way, moving objects don t change their movement spontaneously.

Newton's Laws of Motion in Motion Objectives: Students will use simple techniques to demonstrate Newton's 1 st and 3 rd Laws of Motion. Students will demonstrate their understanding of thrust, drag, lift,

How Are Water Pressure and Water Flow Related? Overview In this activity, students apply the scientific method as they attempt to answer the question, How are water pressure and water flow related? A large

Moving Forward: Propulsion and Newton s Third Law of Motion Students will understand the aerodynamic force of thrust and how that force is influenced through the use of aircraft engines and their designs.