Wonderwall

Former Bachelorette Ali Fedotowsky is "freaking out" that Bachelor producers have been courting her ex-fiance, Roberto Martinez, to star in Season 17, an insider tells the new issue of Us Weekly (out now).

"Roberto has never shared his side of the breakup, and Ali is terrified about what he would say on the show and how she would come off," a source explains of Fedotowsky, 27. The two split in November 2011 after dating for 18 months.

Luckily for 1st Look host Fedotowsky, Martinez, 29, may not want to look for love on camera again. "He's happy being out of the spotlight," a source close to the San Diego insurance agent explains. "But he hasn't ruled it out 100 percent."