I know i'm late but my opinion... I gave each QB rating, 1 worst 10 best, and added them up
1. Marino 9- very good QB
2. fouts 3- not at all on the level most of these guys are
3.manning 4- i repeat fouts
4.rothlisberger 2- one of the worst of this level of QBs
Total: 17
1.rodgers 6- a very good QB but not the best right now, so who cares about all time
2.brees 5- i repeat rodgers
3.namath 1- the worst here
4.plunkett 3- umm no
Total:15
1.Elway 8- won championships, and was elite
2.staubach 6- good QB
3.warner 7- not top 5 all time (maybe 10)
4.mcnabb 2- ummmmmm no
Total: 23
1.unitas 7- people dont realize how good he was
2.favre 8- this story may not be done?
3.moon 6- repeat unitas but slightly worse
4.tittle 3- i dunno for him in modern nfl
Total: 24
1. young 8- he WAS a backup
2. graham 5- like tittle, but better
3. baugh 4- i repeat graham
4. anderson- 2 hmm
Total: 19
1.Brady 9- one of the best
2.Tarkenton 5- nice
3.dawson 5- nice
4.griese 2- he coudnt earn a starting job
Total: 21
1.Manning 9- one of best
2.Starr 3- wasnt featured in their offense
3.kelly 7- elite
4.jugenson 5- good finish
Total: 24
1.Montana 9- super bowls galore!
2.Bradshaw 6- super bowls galore!
3.aikman 6- hmmm
4.cunningham 6- very good
Total: 27
Winners: Montana, Bradshaw, Aikman, Cunningham