A UVA law professor married to the University’s president is coming under fire from an advocacy group that claims his recent legal arguments in favor of religious exemptions are aiding anti-gay and anti-woman agendas.

Douglas Laycock, School of Law faculty member and husband of UVA President Teresa Sullivan, is one of the country’s leading experts on religious liberty, and is well-known for a legal stance that often puts him on opposite sides of polarizing political issues: He supports individual religious rights, but also a total separation of church and state, and he’s argued several Supreme Court cases from that position, defending conservative Lutherans and Santería sect members alike.

Some of his recent writings have been heavily cited by members of the religious right, and now he’s facing the ire of activists on the other end of the political spectrum.

“His work, whether he understands it or realizes it or not, is being used by folks who want to institute discrimination into law,” said Heather Cronk, co-director of Berkeley, California-based LGBT activist group GetEQUAL.

In February, Laycock penned a letter to Arizona Governor Jan Brewer in support of SB1062, a highly controversial and ultimately scuttled state law that would have given individuals and businesses broad rights to exempt themselves from state laws they’re opposed to on religious grounds. Critics slammed the bill as a thinly veiled attempt to give anybody in the state the right to refuse to serve gays and lesbians.

Laycock’s letter, written under a University of Virginia School of Law letterhead and signed by 10 other law professors from institutions around the country, argued that the Arizona law was a fair extension of the existing federal Religious Freedom Restoration Act because it didn’t pick winners: The government “could still show that compliance with the law was necessary to serve a compelling government interest,” he wrote.

Similar arguments underpin an amicus brief he filed in Sebelius v. Hobby Lobby Stores, Inc., the high-profile contraception coverage case currently before the U.S. Supreme Court. Laycock sides with the corporation, which claims that under the RFRA, its president’s religious beliefs should allow it to opt out of covering certain kinds of birth control.

“When we started connecting the dots between Laycock’s work on religious discrimination bills and contraceptive coverage and access for women—that’s when it began to be a big concern,” said Cronk. She said when conservative commentators like Maggie Gallagher, former head of the National Organization for Marriage, started pointing to Laycock’s arguments as support for their own strongly anti-gay agendas, GetEQUAL decided to push back with a campaign of their own.

Through the activist group Virginia Student Power Network, GetEQUAL found two UVA students willing to take up the cause of calling out Laycock: rising fourth-year Greg Lewis and now-alum Stephanie Montenegro. Last week, the pair sent an open letter to Laycock asking him to consider the “real-world consequences that [his] work is having.” They also submitted a Freedom of Information Act request seeking e-mails between Laycock and various right-wing and religious liberty groups.

Lewis said they’re not trying to smear Laycock, and they’re not trying to undermine academic freedom. They just want a dialogue, he said.

“I think it would be really constructive for him to hear how his work is being used to hurt the LGBTQ community,” said Lewis. “I don’t think he has any ill intent. I think he’s very thoughtful and moderate, and willing to hear both sides. But I think that everyone really has a lot to learn.”

Laycock said he’s anything but anti-gay.

“My position has always been that liberty in America is for everyone,” he said. “It’s for both sides in the culture wars. I believe that we should protect gays and lesbians in their right to live their own lives, including their right to get married, and we should protect religious conscientious objectors.”

He pointed out that he’s fought “tooth and nail” against some of the same religious rights groups he’s represented when he disagrees with them.

“I can’t help what other people do with my arguments,” he said. “I have told some of the folks on the religious right that their own claims to religious liberty would be taken more seriously if they would quit messing with the liberties of other people.”

Thomas C. Berg of the University of St. Thomas School of Law in Minneapolis has known and worked with Laycock for years, and said he has always held that the government should stay out of religious matters.

“In some cases, that leads to results that the left likes, and in some cases it leads to results that the right likes,” said Berg. He and Laycock made few friends among religious conservatives when they jointly filed an amicus brief in 2012’s landmark United States. v. Windsor case that urged the court to extend same-sex marriage benefits to every state in the union. Also not endearing him to the right: Laycock is preparing to argue another case before the nation’s highest court, this time on behalf of a Muslim prisoner’s right to wear a beard.

Laycock and others like him are used to criticism, Berg said; it goes hand-in-hand with defending civil liberties regardless of your personal feelings about the moral argument at hand.

“The positions all of us take as advocates are certainly open to vigorous criticism, and that’s just fine,” said Berg. “But that criticism should be accurate, it should be informed, and it should recognize that there is complexity in these issues.”

Just what kind of dialogue will grow out of the flap at UVA is still up in the air; Lewis said he’s been in touch with Laycock, but hasn’t set up a meeting. Meanwhile, GetEQUAL has launched a national e-mail campaign calling out Laycock for his role in shoring up the legal arguments of those who support “religious bigotry.”

“I take him at his word that he’s a moderate, that he supports marriage equality,” said Cronk. “The problem is his work is being used, potentially misused, potentially abused, by folks who do not show those values.”

For his part, Laycock said he’s happy to talk to the students, though, he said, “they picked a very odd way to go about the conversation.”

“I can’t help what other people do with my arguments,” he said.“I have told some of the folks on the religious right that their own
claims to religious liberty would be taken more seriously if they would
quit messing with the liberties of other people.”

Hear, hear! Likewise, the zero-tolerance position of those criticizing this professor is ultimately undermining their argument. You really need to pick your battles. Choosing an intellectually honest scholar with the utmost integrity as your target is a fool’s mission.

Chris Candide

Sharpen the pitchforks!

Gmama

It really is sad how intolerant leftist groups have become. They are anything but liberal. Why would you get private emails to start a dialogue? Sounds like a witch hunt, not

regexp

Stop framing this as a “left” or “right” issue. Right wing groups have used the exact same tactics to go after Professors they don’t like.

K.P.

Can you actually list some please?

LightswitchRaves

See above. A pretty recent example, too! Cool, right?

K.P.

If above means the witchhunt against Michael Mann, then that’s incredibly inapt as a parallel as Cuccinelli argued that Mann had actually committed a crime.

Not that I’m defending Cuccinelli’s actions here but it is an AG’s job to investigate fraud.

Gmama

Yeah I always hear that. It is lie. Maybe you can name a commencement speaker canceled because a right leaning group didn’t want them or a witch hunt at a public university from the right. How about a speaker on the left not allowed to speak or being harassed by the right?

LightswitchRaves

Really? What about Cucinelli’s witch hunt against Mike Mann. How soon we forget…

Gmama

His research grants were investigated.The hockey stick has been proven to be false and he refuses to release raw data. There is a big difference between launching and investigation and refusing to let someone speak.

LightswitchRaves

Wow. “Horribly unscientific” = published in peer-reviewed journals…. Oh… okay. I understand now; I’m not quite sure you GET science. Good try though! Maybe next time!

John Williams

Really? Name one. Can’t? Didn’t think so.

rocinante2

Still waiting.

LightswitchRaves

See above, you don’t have to wait any longer! It’s even a pretty recent example! Happy now? I’ll wait until you tell me why you’re not. =)

rocinante2

Anecdote =/= data.

Just sayin’.

The left in the US has been politicizing science since at least the 60’s. In Europe, since the late 19th century. Soviet Russia? Trofim Lysenko and Andrei Zhadanov, if you’ve never heard of them, are only a Wikipedia/Google search away.

If you think the partisan targeting of academics doesn’t point heavily in one ideological direction, you’re delusional. Academics themselves admit it and self-reporting (voting behavior, party identification, etc.) understates the imbalance, if anything.

When there are more Marxists than Republicans on a college faculty, that’s a problem – for both balance and academic freedom.

rocinante2

More crickets.

Brian

The self-righteousness of the people trying to “start a conversation” (intimidate and isolate Prof. Sullivan) is nauseating.

Mr. Lewis says that he thinks “that everyone really has a lot to learn.” I wonder what he thinks he has to learn? That goal would require him to listen more than speak. I hope that he realizes that.

http://rhymeswithright.mu.nu RhymesWithRight

Only that knowledge that the Left declares “double plus good” may be promulgated. The rest must be suppressed. How soon until we see an American “Cultural Revolution” akin to that of Mao’s China?

rocinante2

Wingnuts unbellyfeel IngSoc! Minitrue duckspeak doubleplusgood.

George Purcell

Greg Lewis and Stephanie Montenegro, for the rest of your lives you’ll wear the tag of being little Brown Shirt fascists.

nemomen

Perfect irony.

docscience

I wonder if UVA will refuse to respond to the FOIA as they did with Professor Mann’s climate-gate emails?

Win8-TrackBlows

First two words in the title sound like a Grisham novel: “Sullivan’s Law”.

sukietawdry

“I think it would be really constructive for him to hear how his work is being used to hurt the LGBTQ community,” said Lewis. “I don’t think he has any ill intent. I think he’s very thoughtful and moderate, and willing to hear both sides. But I think that everyone really has a lot to learn.”

And you know who has the most to learn? You, that’s who, snotnose. Who are you to lecture anybody about anything, you little “rising fourth-year” pissant.

Win8-TrackBlows

School’s almost over for them – now commences their education.

jburack

These people are Nazis. I normally hate Hitler analogies and that is not what I am doing here. It is no analogy. Their mentality is the same exactly. They respect no difference of opinion at all and see no reason to allow any difference at all, and would very likely imprison and kill anyone who disagreed with them in the slightest if they were ever in a position to exercise such power. Anyone who thinks that characterization is unfair does not know the first thing about the history of the past century.

FutureLegacy

“They just want a dialogue..”

“Having a dialogue” and “being in conversation”: battle cries of intolerant LGBTQ bullies.

NDaniels

There are no minorities when we recognize that every human person, from the moment of conception, is in being, a son or daughter, not an object of sexual desire/orientation. Every human person has the inherent unalienable Right to be treated with Dignity and respect in private as well as in public.

Brendan

This is another article that is quick to mention that Laycock supports SB 1062 and the religious liberty of Hobby Lobby, but then fails to mention that Laycock also filed amicus briefs in support of the gay and lesbian couples in the recent DOMA and Proposition 8 cases.

You don’t need to “take him at his word,” because his work has had positive “real world consequences” for LGBTQ individuals.

Azarkhan

Those two students are left wing scum. Their only interest is in killing free speech.

A local real estate developer is now one of the top election officials in Virginia. Clara Belle Wheeler was approved by the General Assembly last week as the newest member of the State Board of Elections, which oversees the work of local electoral boards and registrars. Wheeler, a Republican

After nearly seven years on the market, Seven Oaks, the Greenwood estate owned by Dave Matthews Band manager, MusicToday founder and real estate tycoon Coran Capshaw sold October 31 for $5.5 million. The 100-acre historic estate was listed for $12.5 million when it went on the market in 2008.

Wes Bellamy lost to Bob Fenwick in the 2013 Democratic primary for Charlottesville City Council by five votes—a frustratingly small margin, he said. But now, as the 28-year-old teacher and youth mentor launches his second bid for a Council seat, he’s glad he didn’t win last time around. A lot

The man accused of killing a mother and daughter in their Rugby Avenue home before torching it was in court February 19 for a preliminary hearing for the murder of Robin Aldridge. Gene Everett Washington, 30, is charged with two counts of first-degree murder in the deaths of Robin, 58, and her

Last week, C-VILLE revisited the case of Robert Davis, who after five hours of interrogation by Albemarle County detectives in 2003 admitted to killing Crozet mom Nola Charles and her toddler son. He has since maintained his innocence, and the two siblings who initially told police Davis was

The 2015 General Assembly session is in its final sprint, with talk of both houses agreeing to a budget and voting on it one day before the session ends February 27—a nearly unprecedented rapprochement. Contributing to the speedy resolution was taking Medicaid expansion off the table, despite

Dominion has announced that it is exploring several alternative routes for its planned Atlantic Coast Pipeline through Nelson County. The 550-mile natural gas pipeline, which the company hopes to have online by the end of 2018, would be routed through West Virginia, Virginia and North Carolina,

How do you get teens to talk about race in a way that prompts action and meaningful change? That’s a central question posed in the 2013 documentary “I’m Not Racist…Am I?,” which follows 12 New York City teenagers from diverse racial and socioeconomic backgrounds as they go through a

A handful of bills to reform gerrymandering died February 12 in a seven-person House of Delegates subcommittee by voice vote. Delegate Steve Landes (R-25th) was one of those voting to kill the bills. “Our districts are not gerrymandered,” he said. “They’re approved by the Department of

Twelve years ago this week, firefighters found Nola Charles and her toddler son William dead inside their burning Crozet home. Someone had duct taped Charles to her bed before stabbing her and slitting her throat. Three-year-old William had died of smoke inhalation. Three teens were convicted

Mike Signer grew up in Arlington, but Charlottesville tugged on him from an early age. The 42-year-old Fifeville resident and father of two spent summers here as an elementary school student in the ’70s, taking enrichment courses at UVA. “I remember vividly falling in love with the city back

Republican Delegate Steve Landes has announced his plan to run for an 11th term. Landes represents Virginia’s 25th House district, which includes part of Albemarle County as well as localities in the Shenandoah Valley. “It has been an honor and privilege to serve the citizens of the 25th

A Missouri real estate investment trust, EPR Properties, has picked up Wintergreen Resort for an undisclosed price, it announced last week. Coal and resort baron Jim Justice, who bought Wintergreen for $16.5 million in June 2012, poured millions into infrastructure before putting the Nelson ski

Accused Hannah Graham-murderer Jesse Matthew, who was convicted of trespassing in 2010, inspired three bills in the General Assembly to add misdemeanors to the crimes for which DNA samples are collected. However, the versions that passed would not have prevented Matthew from crossing paths with

Last summer a phalanx of cop cars lined up at Psychic Readings by Catherine on U.S. 29 and closed one lane of traffic. The Department of Homeland Security’s Immigration and Customs Enforcement led the June 14 search warrant execution, removed four cars, and left a lot of locals wondering what

Star guard Justin Anderson’s fractured finger did not stop Virginia from topping ninth-ranked Louisville 52-47 February 7, nor did it prevent Virginia from being ranked No. 2 in the country again this week. But what does it mean for the Cavaliers for the rest of the regular season, with

When Charlottesville City Manager Maurice Jones began the ceremony to mark the opening of the final segment of the John W. Warner Parkway and the intersection that ties the road to the city’s downtown last Thursday, February 5, he couldn’t help driving home just how long locals had been waiting

There was one big trending topic heading into this year’s state legislative session, thanks largely to events that unfolded in Charlottesville. The death of UVA second-year Hannah Graham, allegedly at the hands of a man who left two Virginia schools under suspicion of sexual assault, and the

White Hall resident Angela Lynn knows she’s got an uphill battle challenging Republican Delegate Steve Landes for the 25th District seat, which he’s held since 1996. Most of the district is in more conservative Augusta and Rockingham counties, with a chunk of western Albemarle thrown in. It was

Unregulated short-term lodging is a booming business in Charlottesville, but as more and more locals rent out rooms and houses to guests on sites like Airbnb, city officials are increasingly anxious to get rules on the books and find a way to make hosts pony up for required taxes and fees.