We noticed that you're using an unsupported browser. The TripAdvisor website may not display properly. We support the following browsers:
Windows:Internet Explorer,
Mozilla Firefox,
Google Chrome.
Mac:Safari.

This has been a "go to' spot in Sodus Point - but over the past few years have noticed a decline in experience at the bar. But hey, it happens.
What you can count on is consistent good food and a quirky atmosphere, which in this case works!

If you think you have a favorite restaurant and are basing your decision on all aspects including service, quality of food etc., then you need to upgrade - have travelled all over and experienced numerous raved about eating spots - none can hold a candle to Bay Street Hotel - The server, Rebecca was familiar and eager to explain any...
More

First of all, Thank You Trip Advisor. I would never have tried this restaurant without you. I would not have even realized it was there. And I would have hated to miss it. It is totally different than any other restaurant in the Sodus Bay area - which cater to diners coming off of their boats and run toward fried...
More

Walking down Bay street it is very easy to pass the Bay St. Hotel. It's dark, hidden behind trees,no signs, in fact the name of the hotel is block letters on the front porch post painted in the same color OF the hotel so it's almost indistinguishable. Anyway, you stand on the street looking at this dilapidated building wondering what...
More

Excellent food--fresh ingredients, plentiful servings, attentive but not imposing service. Oysters w moray sauce over spinach-- light and unique. House made salad dressings well mixed and balanced. Soused scallops and shrimp were delicious--scotch bonnet peppers were the main and clean taste. Seared diver scallops came w both mashed potatoes and wild rice and a side of spinach. Scallops were tender...
More

If exterior appearance Is a deciding factor you probably will keep on driving. The brave and adventuresome souls will find good food and friendly people.
A take off on old Key West, the bar boasts a 150+ assortment of martins, and a back bar that is up to the challenge of your order.
The surprise is through the back arch...
More

My wife and I took a nice long drive one Sunday afternoon from SW Rochester to Sodus Point to check out this place that was recommended by several people to us. They warned us it didn't look the greatest on the outside. They were right, BUT INSIDE!!!!!!
First, a spectacular bar specializing in Martini's (and they make GREAT Martini's).
Next...
More

It is a long drive from Pittsford on a Sunday night but well worth the time for a dinner and service as outstanding as this restaurant. Does not look like much from the outside but the selections on the menu were thoughful and very well prepared. It is very unusual to get your food so hot that you have to...
More

* TripAdvisor LLC is not a booking agent and does not charge any service fees to users of our site... (more)

We noticed that you're using an unsupported browser. The TripAdvisor website may not display properly. We support the following browsers:
Windows:Internet Explorer,
Mozilla Firefox,
Google Chrome.
Mac:Safari.

TripAdvisor LLC is not responsible for content on external web sites. Taxes, fees not included for deals content.