An already tight atmosphere for the press in China has continued to tighten in recent weeks. Most recently, the news retrospectives Chinese media have typically compiled at year’s end in recent years have come under pressure. Guangdong’s Southern Weekend, a newspaper with a reputation for bolder news coverage, had published its annual list of distinguished journalists and media, “Salute to the Media,” every year since 2001. But authorities put a stop to the list last month, the latest in a series of unfortunate warning signs.

The first hints of trouble for news retrospectives and similar lists came in early December, as Time Weekly, published by the Guangdong Provincial Publishing Group, invited a group of scholars to select a list of “100 Most Influential People of Our Time” (最有影响力的时代100人). The list included the recently jailed food safety activist Zhao Lianhai (赵连海) and several signers of the Charter 08 political manifesto, including Beijing Film Academy professor Cui Weiping (崔卫平) and renowned scholar Xu Youyu (徐友渔).

Time Weekly‘s list of 100 influential people included artists, grassroots activists, educators, lawyers, officials, public intellectuals, scientists, entrepreneurs and journalists, all seen as having, as the newspaper wrote, “an irreplaceable influence on public life this year and on the development of our times.” The list was received well in China and drew attention from international media as well, all surprised at the publication’s boldness. But an order quickly came down for the recall of copies of the newspaper in circulation, and the list and related coverage was deleted from the Time Weekly website. Peng Xiaoyun (彭晓芸), the chief editor of Time Weekly‘s opinion section, who had been in charge of the list, was placed on involuntary leave.

While these are worrisome signs that must be closely watched, restricting open reflection on the major news and issues of 2010 cannot prevent Chinese journalists from pursuing the truth — nor can it erase their memories of major news events.

No one can forget the staggering case in Yihuang, Jiangxi province, in which citizens protesting the demolition of their home set fire to themselves in desperation. No one will forget the way local officials in Yihuang dispatched police to surround relatives of the victims at the local airport as they attempted to reach Beijing to appeal for justice in their case, or the way Phoenix Weekly reporter Deng Fei (邓飞) reported the story live on his microblog, taking it national and making Chinese news history. And no one can forget how the efforts of the Chinese media on this case eventually brought a small measure of justice to the Zhong family.

Brutal cases like that in Yihuang have continued. Late last year, The Beijing News exposed audacious land practices in Pizhou, Jiangsu province, where the government had submerged thousands of acres of farmland by diverting the course of a local river. The government even attempted to hide their misdeeds by deceiving the remote sensing satellites of the Ministry of Land Resources, blanketing areas of illegal land development throughout the city with black plastic netting. The Beijing News report drew the attention of central leaders, and Politburo Standing Committee member Zhou Yongkang (周永康) and Ministry of Public Security chief Meng Jianzhu (孟建柱) ordered an investigation that uncovered staggering abuses in Pizhou.

When a fire tore through a high-rise residential building in Shanghai last November, the local First Finance Television (第一财经电视) reported the story live for three days straight, the first time in the history of Shanghai media that a negative local story was reported live. New Century magazine, led by former Caijing editor-in-chief Hu Shuli (胡舒立), followed up this major news story with a professional in-depth report looking into the deeper causes of the tragedy, “Shanghai’s Lamentation: Bund Redevelopment Project Never Went Through Open Bidding Process.”

There was more important work accomplished by Chinese journalists in 2010 than can be summarized here. It was a year of intense pressure, and yet Chinese journalists — from Party media as well as commercial media — made important inroads despite tightening restrictions, reminding us of their professional grit and idealism.

2 Comments to “Big 2010 stories hushed, but not forgotten”

Very well written article. Gives us an alternative perspective on the usually negative commentary about Chinese media sphere. And definitely a good job to all those journalists in China with a conscious. Even if the majority of journalists and editors are still too afraid to report anything that’s remotely provocative to the Party-state, I do believe that many of them still maintain their independent consciousness and will report the truth when the opportunity arrives.

Leave a Comment

Archives

People's Daily: Cautions on WeChat
― In an article on page five of the Chinese Communist Party's official People's Daily newspaper today, new media expert Xu Danei (徐达内) addresses the benefits and disadvantages of the WeChat platform, focusing on the conversations happening in private chatrooms. The piece, which begins by enumerating the new conveniences offered by WeChat, quickly moves on to the risks -- rumours and unverified information. It concludes: "Of course, Tencent has been advancing the platform all along, with the reporting and complaints function on the backend constantly improving. Recently, the 'original content' label (原创标签) has also been tested, and can be seen as a further effort at advancement on Tencent's part. I'm sure that as a mature internet company, it can continue to do better and better."

SIIO Director Lu Wei: Choice Quotes on Internet Controls
― On October 30, 2014, at a press conference ahead of the World Internet Conference in Zhejiang, State Internet Information Office head Lu Wei (鲁炜) -- the hardline internet chief that lead the crackdown on the "Big V" account holders on Sina Weibo in 2013 -- was asked why sites like Facebook were shut down in China. He responded: "I haven’t used these websites [like Facebook] before, and I don’t know whether or not they’ve been shut down. But as to there being some websites that cannot be visited, I think this is situation probably exists. However, I want to say that our management [of the web] is all done according to the law, and all of the measures we take are to protect China’s national security and the rights Chinese consumers in accord with the law." Lu also used the metaphor of the home to explain China's information restrictions: "Your websites are in your home. How can I shut down shut down sites in your home? China is friendly, but it has a choice on which guests can visit."

Xinhua Releases Full Version of "Decision" from the 4th Plenum
― Here is a full version from the official Xinhua News Agency of the "Decision" on "rule of the country according to the law" issued from the 4th Plenum of the 18th Central Committee of the CCP. It begins: "In order to implement the Party's strategic deployments at the 18th National Congress and accelerate the building of a socialist nation governed by rule of law, the Fourth Plenary Session of the 18th Central Committee issues the following decision after researching the comprehensive advancement of the major issue of ruling the nation by law." China Copyright and Media has done a full translation of the "decision" in English, available here: http://bit.ly/1tfQ4Rn

Xinhua Commentary: "Let Faith in Rule of Law Put Roots Down in the People's Hearts"
― In a commentary posted to the internet late this afternoon, and said to reflect the "spirit" of the recent Fourth Plenum, China's official Xinhua News Agency said that "the authority of the law lies in its being truly believed and treasured in the hearts of the people." The commentary said there was a need to foster widespread "faith" in the law among both leaders and ordinary people. At one point the commentary even used the word "citizens," or gongmin (公民), which has grown somewhat less common in state media over the past year as it is associated with the idea of "civil society." The Xinhua piece said: "Of all laws the most important laws are not those engraved on marble or etched in copper, but those inscribed on the hearts of citizens."

Xi Jinping: Thoroughly Promoting Governing of the Nation By Law Also Requires Deepening Reforms
― Topping most major internet sites in China today (presumably by order) as well as the People's Daily, an official news release summarizes an "important speech" made by President Xi Jinping yesterday at a Work Group on the Deepening of Reform. In the speech Xi sought to integrate that objectives of the recent Fourth Plenum with the decision on deepening reform introduced at the Third Plenum. He emphasizes that the promotion of "rule of the nation according to the law (依法治国), the focus of the Fourth Plenum "decision," is a critical step in the deepening of reforms in China.