Much of the book and film involve Don’s difficult recovery and subsequent service to others. Two weeks in Intensive Care, 34 surgeries, a year in a hospital bed, plus chronic pain grant him (and his wife, Eva) access to many suffering hearts. Their film is touching, moving and inspiring. But did he really visit heaven?

Purpose through tragedy

Over dinner and on the film set, I found the Pipers warm, gracious, sincere people who’ve found profound purpose through tragedy. Don calls Eva the real hero. She supported the family, managed finances and cared for him amid myriad uncertainties.

The Pipers often cite a biblical statement encapsulating their purpose:

“… the God of all comfort … comforts us in all our troubles, so that we can comfort those in any trouble with the comfort we ourselves receive from God.”

I have longtime personal and professional interest in Near-Death Experiences (NDEs). My late mother had one. I’ve written, lectured extensively, and broadcast about them. Was Don Piper’s heavenly experience real?

Don’s serious head trauma included, he told me, symptoms of brain damage. That he did not bleed out during 90 minutes suggests his heart stopped or slowed, limiting brain oxygen. Could his Christian background have planted mental images that influenced his interpretations?

Evidence timeline

Alas, we don’t have a mind/spirit-reading machine to validate NDEs. So we examine limited data.

Consider the evidence timeline. Don says he was aware of his heavenly experience immediately upon regaining consciousness. He kept it a personal secret until telling a friend about a year-and-a-half later. Two years post-event, he wrote down some details. Six or seven years post-event, a church taped his oral account.

13 or 14 years post-event, his coauthor Cecil Murphy interviewed him, establishing the book’s sources (all “purely oral,” Don says) for its accounts of Don’s heavenly experience. Film producers wanted the film to adhere closely to the book.

Memories can, of course, shift over time. Enough event-to-account gaps exist in that timeline to raise concerns. I don’t question Don’s integrity, but a fair analysis must consider the evidence trail and human memory’s limitations. His story could be completely accurate, or it could be modified unawares by selective memory or post-event interpretation.

Skeptics’ questions

I told Don I write for skeptics, ask questions skeptics might ask, and that some elements of his heavenly account confused me. Some of his responses confused me even more. For instance, his book speaks of being unaware that his wife and children were not in heaven with him:

“By faith, I knew that they would be residents of heaven someday. Being separated from them had never crossed my mind while I was in heaven. People in heaven simply don’t have an awareness of who is not there. They do know who is coming.”

I asked how he could know what was in other heavenly residents’/visitors’ minds. To his credit, he admitted, “If I’m extrapolating…perhaps I’ve gone too far.” Then he raised a dissatisfying philosophical argument: Awareness of those not present would introduce mourning, when the Bible posits a mourning-free heaven. But if “they do know who is coming,” aren’t they aware of at least some who are not there?

On other similar questions, Don sometimes seemed defensive and testy: “Are you looking for contradictions [in my story]? Is that what you’re looking for?” He did not like analyzing “every…sentence” and asked if I could disprove his statements. Of course, that’s beyond my capability. Rather, a skeptic might ask, “If some NDE account elements are based on supposition or inappropriate extrapolation, could other elements be similarly based?”

Did Don Piper visit heaven? Perhaps. Can his coping message help hurting people? Absolutely. Is the film worth seeing and discussing? Without question. And is his method of ensuring eternal life – accepting Jesus’ forgiveness – worth applying? Yes; I highly recommend that.

Rusty Wright is an author and lecturer who has spoken on six continents. He holds Bachelor of Science (psychology) and Master of Theology degrees from Duke and Oxford universities, respectively.www.RustyWright.com

Editors:

Rusty Wright makes his articles and audio/video resources available to editors gratis. All we ask is that you give proper credit, let us know when you post and/or translate our stuff, and link back to RustyWright.com. Click the Topics tab to see what is available.

About

Rusty Wright is an award-winning author, lecturer and syndicated columnist who has spoken on six continents. His audiences have included academic, business and government leaders and university students. He has appeared on television talk shows in cities around the world, and also trains professionals in effective communication.

Subscribe

Want to be kept abreast of future releases? Every month or so when we post new articles, we notify Internet editors of their availability via short emails. Just let us know and we’ll send you these email alerts. We send them blind to protect your privacy, and only to those requesting them.