DVDActive uses cookies to remember your actions, such as your answer in the poll. Cookies are
also used by third-parties for statistics, social media and advertising. By using this website, it is
assumed that you agree to this.

Clerks II: Special Edition (US - DVD R1)

Gabe overcomes his preconceptions and enjoys Kevin Smith's sequel...

Feature

Randal (Jeff Anderson) and Dante (Brian O'Halloran) are back, and just as unhappy about their jobs as ever. After the Quick Stop burns to the ground, our disgruntled professionals are forced to find employment at a fast food burger joint called Mooby's. Dante has found love, and at the end of today's shift will be on his way to Florida with his fiancé. Needless to say, Randal isn't happy about the prospect of being best friend-less. Matters are complicated when Dante begins to realize his true feelings for his store manager, Becky (Rosario Dawson), and must make an important choice in a matter of hours.

I was the perfect age for the original Clerks when it came out. I was in high school, and my band had retrofitted my dad's garage with a TV, a VCR, and a crude surround sound system. We practiced on Saturdays, and then watched movies loudly while eating junk food all night long. Clerks was on the menu pretty much every weekend. Over the years I've gotten a little sick of it.

In turn, I ended up pretty sick of the whole View Askewiverse. I've since found new love for Dogma, but honestly thought Jay and Silent Bob Strike Back was one of the most disappointing trips to the movie theatre I'd made in years. I just didn't think it was funny. After Jay and Silent Bob Kevin Smith said he wasn't going to make any more flicks in his hometown universe, and as a bored film goer I was happy. Then his first post Silent Bob film was Jersey Girl, and it looked pretty dull. I never saw it, but apparently no one else did either. After that failure Smith announced he was going back to his 'roots', and I (like a lot of folks) pretty much gave up.

The one bit of the Askewiverse I still held close was the Clerks animated series (ask my friends, I quote it all the time), which may be one of the most underrated, short lived TV series ever cancelled after three episodes. Smith's return to familiar territory was going to be with these characters I actually still liked, though I assumed in a less fantastical sense. When I heard that Rosario Dawson would be co-staring, and that the flick got an eight-minute standing ovation at Cannes, I almost, almost went to see it in theatres. In the end I still wasn't excited enough about Smith or his universe to spend the ten bucks.

I was wrong to judge the film, but in my defence there really wasn't any evidence in favour of the thing being any good. My reservations were not at all unfounded. The final product isn't a masterpiece, but it's about as good as we can expect Smith and Co. to muster, and what Smith can muster is heart—a big, fat, blood oozing, glucose laden, cholesterol-encrusted heart.

Clerks II takes a long time getting to the good stuff—a really long time. I'm not saying that the first forty-five minutes aren't amusing or important to the overall plot, but up until the moment Jason Lee shows up as a successful co-high school graduate of Randal and Dante's, I was revelling the fact that I was right. I was positive that this guy had nothing left to say about life, art, or film. Long, boring conversations about pop-culture, and crude sex jokes for the sake of crude sex jokes are so 1994. Lord of the Rings versus Star Wars? Lame. Minus one potent scene between Dawson and O'Halloran, this wasn't an impressive return.

After Lee's appearance, and Anderson's reaction to it, I was presented with a new film. Clerks II actually did have something to say, and it was ‘be yourself’. If I'd read that sentence I just typed I'd be even more judgmental of the film going into it, but I mean it in a positive way. There really are only two salvageable places you can take the characters from the original film, you can make them happy in their element, or take them out of it. Or I suppose you can kill them, but that's the alternate View Askewiverse as seen on the deleted scenes on the original film. Smith picks the harder choice and brings about genuine warm fuzzy feelings.

The tree's vein is tapped, and the sap flows freely, but it's not cheap sap, it's the refined, expensive stuff you have to buy at the carpeted grocery store. It's the kind of sap that makes you feel good and a little ashamed of yourself as the end credits roll. It's the kind of sap filmmakers like John Hughes have refined for years, and that's what Smith seems to have always wanted to be in the end, the new, potty-mouthed John Hughes. There are some great speeches here, where characters bare there soles to one another in a very Hughes like fashion, only these aren't angsty, antipathist teens, they're adults approaching middle age whose stories I can related to. Yeah, there's a silly musical sequence where the characters stew in self-pity (and the irony of how much Smith hates Magnolia was not lost on me for a second), but we don't, and shouldn't expect David Mamet from Kevin Smith. Perhaps we should expect something slightly funnier from Smith, but perhaps this is all part of the growing experience.

At his best Kevin Smith has always been able to do poignant emotions, what impresses me is his growth in filmmaking beyond writing. Clerks II looks good, which is more than I can say for most of the Smith cannon. There are beautiful crane and tracking shots throughout, no-centred framing, and a definite lack of static cameras. The film reunites Smith with cinematographer David Klein for the first time since Chasing Amy, and the amount to which the couple has grown is immense. I'm also very impressed with Smith's editing abilities, for which he takes the sole credit.

The fact that I didn't find the film particularly hilarious is no fault of the actors, who sell the jokes with total conviction. What can be blamed on the actors, as much as the writer/director, is the fact that the film moved me. Rosario Dawson is always good, so I almost feel no need to praise her for doing her thing, but Brian O'Halloran and Jeff Anderson deserve some props and high-fives. O'Halloran has always been the whiny, straight man, and Anderson the smart-ass, but several scenes see them emoting just like real people trapped in a total bummer of a situation. I'm not sure if I can credit them for staying in character because they seem to be these guys in real life, but I believed them, and not once did I think I was watching a amateur attempt performance, I was watching actors at work.

Video

Shot on HD to save time and money (edt: I'm wrong, it was shot of film but digitally processed in some magical way in post), Clerks II looks fantastic. It's medium budgeted and doesn't have a lot of bravado visuals, but everything here is crisp, clean, and detailed. I was most impressed with flesh tones during shadowed sequences, which showed little to no cross-colouration or noise, the bane of some of the best transfers on the market. There is some noise here and there, but nothing beyond what should be expected from the medium. Had there been more night shots (almost the entire film takes place under the warm glow of fluorescent lights) there may've been more grain or low-level noise. I can't call it perfect due to the lack of contrast, but it's one of the better non-animated discs I've seen in a while.

Audio

I can't abide by Smith's taste in music. Some of it's okay, and some of it works for the scene, but often it's too obvious. There's been some great use of acquired songs in film lately, especially songs that've been played out, or weren't good in the first place (see Devil's Rejects, The Matador, or Layer Cake), and I was hoping for more of this re-appropriation from Clerks II. Oh well.

The film is song heavy, but not sound effect heavy, so to judge the Dolby Digital soundtrack one must take Smith's intentions to heart. The music sounds very good, though sometimes it's awkwardly split amongst the surround channels, leaving the centre channel empty. LFE is huge, to the point that I actually turned down my subwoofer. I hate the song 'Frustrated Incorporated', I hate it, but it sounds great here (great being a relative term). Smith dialogue is always clear, and the occasional sound effect is high in its fidelity.

Extras

Fans know they can count on Smith to deliver good DVD extras, and he does not disappoint here. The first disc of this two-disc set houses not one, but three commentary tracks, a hefty selection of deleted scenes, and a featurette on ‘interspecies erotica’. Disc two has a feature-length documentary about the making of the film, trailers, bloopers, and hours of behind the scenes footage originally created for the web.

Kevin and friends can always be depended on for entertaining commentary tracks. The first is Smith, producer Scott Mosier, and DP David Klein. They call it the 'technical track', and that pretty much sums it up. It's technical, and great for people interested in the filmmaking process.

The second track is the cast track, and is the best track. I laughed quite a bit more at this track than I did while running the film in Dolby Digital. Anyone who's heard any other Smith track knows what to expect here, and there is no disappointment to be had. The most intriguing part of the track is Jason Mewes, who is now sober, actually seems to have something to add to the conversation this time.

The last track is a podcast track. I don't really know the story behind it, but I guess it was something fans could stick on their iPods before seeing the film for a second time, and thusly not have to wait for the DVD release for a commentary. It's a cool idea, but with two solid tracks already adorning the disc it seems a little moot, though there actually isn't too much of the same ground covered. Only for hardcore fans.

There's a decent selection of deleted scenes, all of which feature an introduction by Smith and Mosier (who self indulgently introduce just about every thing on the set, including the film itself). As per the norm, the film is better without these scenes, but they're good to have.

The first disc finishes itself with a featurette about Zak Knutson and his ‘Interspecies Erotica’ scene. The making of the scene is funnier than the scene itself, and the featurette finishes with Knutson saying that he told his mother that she's not allowed to see the finished film. It's cute.

Disc two brings us to the making-of documentary entitled ‘Back to the Well: Clerks II’. This is a great doc, very entertaining, well shot and edited, and it covers everything you ever needed to know about the making of the film. The doc's creators are careful to include footage of Smith stating publicly that he'd never again be revisiting the characters of his Askewiverse post Jay and Silent Bob Strike Back, along with new interview footage of Smith admitting that he felt down on himself after the failure of Jersey Girl. Every problem met and conquered prior to filming is covered, including the fan disapproval, and actor Jeff Anderson's initial disinterest.

The varying array of actresses approached to play the role Rosaria Dawson eventually took is impressive, as is the story of Jason Mewes' road to sobriety, and it's all here. The actual filming process is slightly glossed over, but that's what those hours of production diaries are for. The story behind the making of the film is, as seems to happen quite often, more interesting and valuable than the film itself, and the whole thing culminates with the film's Cannes premiere. I knew about the eight-minute standing ovation, but there's still quite a bit of suspense to behold, as I didn't realize how much of Smith's personal mental health was riding on the event. That's the real meat of the matter, the human drama behind the scenes.

The blooper reel is long, but there's some gold in the mix. Personally, I just feel more in love with Rosario Dawson, who shouts ‘Mooby’s’ in an adorable little voice every time someone says cut. Often these things aren't worth it, but Smith culled out the junk here, it seems.

And it's all wrapped up with the web based production diaries, entitled ‘Train Wrecks’. I lied a bit when I said there were hours of them, technically there's just two hours of them. Each featurette is about ten minutes long, and some are better than others, but they're a great addition to the full documentary. My favourite was actually the first one, which features Jason Mewes and Smith getting hair weaves to look more like the original versions of their characters.

Overall

I liked this film a whole bunch more than I thought I would. It's not highly recommend to non-fans, but even casual fans should give it an open-minded look. The DVD is great, featuring a really gorgeous video transfer, and a big old array of extras. This is a nice send off for the View Askewiverse, though I'm not sure I believe Kevin Smith is entirely done.

Advertisements

Comments

Reply

Message

Enter the message here then press submit. The username, password and message are required. Please make the message constructive, you are fully responsible for the legality of anything you contribute. Terms & conditions apply.

Love the Clerks series. The first one is my all-time favorite movie. There are so many things I could talk about that I liked about this movie. Clerks 2 was another classic. I love the Soul Aslyum tracks that are put for the credits. Can't Even Tell for the 1st one and Misery for the 2nd. Made me cry at the end for both.

The digital intermediate is just technospeak for scanning the film, frame by frame, into a computer at a high resolution (I think at HD quality) for further color timing and tweaking. Instead of getting a negative or an interpositive, the film lab transferred the print directly to the digital storage unit. They did not cut this on a negative - everything after shooting they did in the digital domain. Most people develop the negative, make an interpositive, and *then* scan that into the computer for editing.

Look at "Clerks II" again, and if you'll notice, the first part of the film is rather grainy and the colors are desaturated - the grain and desaturation were done in post-production. Then, during the dance scene, they take the grain out and everything goes to full color to highlight how things seem a little bit brighter when you're in love. Then, immediately after the big "twist", it all goes back to the way it was, grainy and drained of color.

That technical commentary is really great. I encourage all you readers to give it a listen. The DP (Dave Klein), producer (Scott Mosier) and director all give some very good detail of what went into working behind the camera on "Clerks II", and when Klein and Mosier start getting way too technical, Smith has the good nature to ask them what it all means for the layman. One of the reasons I like Kevin Smith is because he isn't afraid to share the experience and techniques with his audiences. Steven Spielberg and M. Night Shyamalan may not do commentaries because they feel that the magic of movies shouldn't be laid bare like that, and that's all well and good, but I appreciate Smith's endeavors to help the average viewer understand how the process is done.

I thought this was as good as the original, whereas the original was a funnier and more clever movie, this was the better all around movie, and Smith's filmmaking has definitely evolved. I just picked it up at Best Buy, with the cool looking Mooby's happy meal set. One of my favorites from this year.

Ray Waterway wrote: This wasn't shot on HD - it was done in 35mm. They mention this in the first ten minutes of the commentary. Kevin Smith wanted to shoot on digital video, but Director of Photography Dave Klein thought that it wouldn't be right for the movie due to technical issues.

Really? Dammit! I was forced to cut between tracks due to time restraints on the review (I was visiting family for Thanksgiving), and I came in the technical review while Mosier was yaking about HD and HD dailies and the process of such. I made an assumption.

I see that imdb.com lists a Digital Intermediate master format process. Which one of you smart readers wants to explain this to me?

This wasn't shot on HD - it was done in 35mm. They mention this in the first ten minutes of the commentary. Kevin Smith wanted to shoot on digital video, but Director of Photography Dave Klein thought that it wouldn't be right for the movie due to technical issues.

No disrespect meant, Gabe. Great review!!

Also, for LLCruize and Chaos -

SPOILER AHEAD:

Smith's mom *is* in the last scene of "Clerks II", reprising her role as the "Milk Maid". Right before they cut to the credits, you see Grace Smith looking through the milk jugs again on the right side of the screen.

mikey mike wrote: wish you had written a negative review to this so Smith would have written a blog talking trash about you Ha Ha. It's funny because I actually thought about that. I know he checks the site on occasion, so I'm pretty sure he'll read this someday.

Chaos, in the first flick it is a woman (Smith's mother) who is checking the milk and a guy checks/breaks the eggs (Smith's highschool buddy Walter Flannagan who also does other parts in the first one). Guess his mom didn't want a cameo or they threw that in there to see if anyone would catch it (I bet they mention it in the commentary).

Would have loved to done the podcast in the theater.

I will be picking this one up, loved the film can't wait to check out the extras.

The podcast commentary was gonna be listened as you guessed by fans when watching the film for a second or third time, but most movie theaters in the US banned the idea, because it would have been kinda weird for moviegoers watching the movie without earplugs when others are laughing at random things....that's why it was placed on the DVD. It would have been an awesome idea and I would have loved to watch the movie another time in theaters with my iPod. Oh well. I'm meeting Mr. Smith, Mr. Mewes, Mr. Anderson and Mr. Ferhman at a signing at Smith's West Coast Secret Stash store......I AM SO STOKED!!!!

I've been a huge fan of the Askewniverse since day 1 back in '94. I was very skeptical about this flick, but it was totally worth the wait. It's funny and actually has something to say. Easily his best film since Chasing Amy. He returns to the style of writing/directing he does best. Emotional stuff, not the comic book trappings of Dogma and Strike Back. I was rolling on the floor when 'pillow pants' came up. I can very much relate to the film because I was a slacker then and I'm a slacker now. I'm sure the vast majority of people on the net in their late 20's & early 30's will find a lot to love and relate to in this movie. It's hilarious, well written, well acted, well shot.....not perfect by any means, but still a zillion times better than everyone was expecting it to be. Check it out

An excellent review & justified at that. I split my ass laughing at certain scenes, it did what it said on the tin. Doesn't beat the original & I'm not even going to mention JG. The guy at the very end scene though, isn't he checking the eggs rather than the milk in the first one?

Props for mentioning Jeff Anderson's effort, Gabe. I thought the film was solid but not outstanding, but Jeff Anderson was incredible for a guy who's not really an actor by profession. He was so convincing, especially in the big monologue in the final act. You actually feel for Randall, which will make me revisit this on DVD when it hits the shelves.

Might get it for Christmas, but only for the extras (which are the main reason to buy Smith's DVDs). I was fairly disappointed with this one, although it played better on the big screen than on version I originally saw.

I saw this on the big screen 5 times and was lucky enough to have Kevin on hand at 4 of those 5 screenings! As you can probably tell from that I am a big fan and I think this is the best thing he has ever done - although I still think it's a shame that Jersey Girl has got such a bad reputation.

There is a much longer original cut of Jersey Girl that is a vast improvement over the theatrically released version (although I enjoyed that version for what it was too) - hopefully that original version will see the light of day on DVD one day so it can be seen than more than just the die-hard fans (that is to say the hardcore View Askew fans... and not fans of Bruce Willis! Ironically Bruce Willis was originally supposed to be in the Will Smith role back when the movie was going to be set in the eighties... but I digress!).

So yeah I whole-heartedly recommend Clerks II - it's full of heart and funny as hell (and if inter-species erotica is your bag then it's got you covered too)!