Hey friend! Have fun exploring Q&A, but in order to ask your own
questions, comment, or give thumbs up, you need to be logged in to your
Moz Pro account.
You can also earn access by receiving 500
MozPoints
from participating in YouMoz and the Moz Blog!

Changing on-site SEO without interrupting repeat customers

We have a site with lots of repeat customers. Now that Google Analytics has been gathering keywords for years, I want to do an overhaul on the site incorporating keywords we're not incorporating presently.

But I'm afraid that repeat customers are going to search for their term that they find us with and we wouldn't be in the same spot so they'd go somewhere else.

Unless you are planning on "un-optimizing" your site for the keywords you are currently targeting and changing the entire focus of the site, targeting new keywords by making sure they are present on the site, or in your off site link building efforts should not have any negative effect on your current rankings.

Also, unless the user has disabled it in their browser, Google does attempt to remember the sites you visit and what you like. So in theory, returning users may even see your site in a higher position than they previously did.

In the old days of the WWW (like 10+ years ago) sites often begged users to bookmark the site. I don't think you want to go on that path, but relying on search traffic for customer retention is probably not the best way to handle it. Offer newsletter subscriptions, and definitely use Facebook like, Google +1 and Twitter follow buttons. That way when users search the same phrases, they will definitely find you again if they have hit Like, +1 etc. Search is social - especially now that Google has crippled user query tracking.

Say we rank 2nd for blue shoes. It is a very small term, but a customer is finding us each time by typing that in and going to the 2nd result and clicking on it to come to our site. I"m pretty sure some people do that

Now say I erase "blue shoes" because "red shoes" is a very popular term. I optimize for red shoes and now 'blue shoes' drops to 5th. The return customer comes in, types "blue shoes', doesn't see us in the top 3 so he goes somewhere else. We lose a lot of money.

If you are still selling blue shoes, why would you remove "blue shoes"? If you are not selling blue shoes, then you shouldn't really expect to rank for it.

Honestly, I don't think your worries about a two or three position drop are realistic. People don't usually do a search, remember which position they clicked on before, count that many results down and then click on it without reading the link. If they are looking for blue shoes and your site comes up again in approximately the same area, and the title they see is mostly the same as what they clicked on before, chances are they will remember you and click on it again. This is a good reason to have your company or site name prominent in your title - branding. Now if the change from blue shoes to red shoes resulted in you moving off of page one, that might be a different situation.

Now, let's say you do have customers who know they have usually found you at position 2 and you drop to 5. When they blindly click on result number two and it isn't your site, if they were looking for your site and not just any old blue shoes, they will likely go back and look for you.

Also keep in mind that your keyword positions will fluctuate naturally anyway. In some cases it may even be more than a few positions. You simply cannot rely on search results to act like a bookmark for users - it changes constantly. Instead, make sure your site is memorable enough that users will simply bookmark it, type in the URL, or remember it when they see it in the results. Now if you have one of those spammy URLs that is all keyword and no branding, like "your-best-blue-shoe-stores.com", that may not be so easy.

It's an ecommerce site, but (in the above example) maybe I could leave "blue shoes" and write a blog post about "red shoes with a couple of internal links to the blue shoes category or specific blue shoes. I think that's a great idea.

Is that what you're talking about EGOL:?

So restructuring the on-site SEO to incorporate Google Analytics keywords, erasing what's not performing and adding what is performing might not be a good idea?

But it sounds like I don't have to worry about people not finding us through typing a keyword into Google (repeat customers that is)

In my opinion, the best ecommerce sites have more and better information than most of the information sites. All about the product, history of the product, how to use it, information on repair, everything that anybody anywhere would want to know about it. This is not chest thumping content about your company, it is genuine information content that is a pleasure to read and learn from. Also, it is not a bunch of random blog posts. It is a carefully planned and executed library of information written by enthusiasts.

I decided to go with your plan and only add keywords to a page if it was only optimized for like one keyword. Using mainly content to optimize for new terms

I can see how to organize a bunch of good articles, but how should our blog posts be organized? We were going to do a bunch of random posts based on keywords and experience with customer's questions, but you're right - they need to be organzed: how?

So I should stick to all articles and not use a blog, then use one keyword per page? And should I write articles for all major products, even if they already rank well for their product name?. Should I also write articles for each new keyword that I find through G Analytics that the site is not optimized for, and should I stick to one keyword per page for that or should I pair them up?

Am I on the right track? I hope you don't mind the questions, I have a good feeling about your advice.

Hey friend! Have fun exploring Q&A, but in order to ask your own
questions, comment, or give thumbs up, you need to be logged in to your
Moz Pro account.
You can also earn access by receiving 500
MozPoints
from participating in YouMoz and the Moz Blog!
Learn more.