Reader Comments and Retorts

Statements posted here are those of our readers and do not represent the BaseballThinkFactory. Names are provided by the poster and are not verified. We ask that posters follow our submission policy. Please report any inappropriate comments.

Oh yeah, I'm pretty sure Morgan will be first on my ballot for '76 and I was one of the holdouts in '73 and '74 (I voted for third basemen Darrell Evans and Mike Schmidt in those years). Still, 3 MMPs in 4 years would be pretty impressive. Willie Mays is the only player to have done it so far ('62, '64, '65).

Joe Morgan is the first unanimous MMP since Bob Gibson in 1968. He also joins Willie Mays ('62, '64 and '65) and Carl Yastrzemski ('67 and '70) as the 3rd multiple winner.

Jim Palmer is the first AL pitcher to win the outright pitching MMP since Dean Chance in 1964 and only the second to date (Gaylord Perry of the Indians tied for the award last year). This marks five straight years in which the AL MMP was won by a pitcher beginning with Vida Blue in 1971 (Perry won in '72 and '74, Blyleven in '73).

Rod Carew was named the top position player in the AL for the second straight year. He joins Mickey Mantle ('61 and '62) and Carl Yastrzemski ('67 and '68) as back-to-back winners.

Tom Seaver is pretty good in odd numbered years. He's been the top pitcher in the NL in '71, '73 and '75. However, Seaver's 7th place showing this year is the lowest for the top NL pitcher since Jim Bunning finished 8th in 1967.

Goose Gossage just missed becoming the second reliever to finish in the top ten. He was 11th overall with 5 votes. John Hiller has the best showing for a reliever so far (6th in 1973).

Agreed, Munson is the highest without a vote on my ballot (albeit in 21st).
For pitchers I have The Count (Montefusco)(22nd) the highest without a vote.
I didn't even have Busby in my consideration set... (which either means I pooched it or he
didn't do well enough in the systems I use to bother with... I have no idea which at this point!)

I have Thurman Munson as the best position player to not receive a vote. Among pitchers it's Steve Busby or Phil Niekro

I agree about Munson, but I have Al Hrabowsky as the best pitcher not to be seen on any ballots.

Morgan has a great chance at a 1st, 2nd, 1st and 1st in 4 years. This is some serious dominance.

How many of us thought he was an inner-circle great back then, though? For me, it wasn't until the early '80s before it was clear. I can't recall anyone seriously placing him near the top of the second baseman list outside of sabermetric circles, but, of course, he belongs there.

How many of us thought he was an inner-circle great back then, though?

I may be misremembering, but in my memory I had Morgan as a dead-certain HoFer (although maybe not inner-circle) from about 1977 onward. Of course, I was a bit of a Reds' fan back then. When the AL introduced the DH, I abandoned the Tigers and started tuning in to WLW's signal, which was loud and clear in Detroit. (That quite possibly saved me from becoming a Cubs' fan. You had to get towards Jackson before picking up WGN.)

After some more thought, I can't remember having any idea of 'inner-circle' before I started reading Bill James in the late 1980s, even if then. For me it was a binary thing: you were either in or out. Even the idea of ranking HoFers never occurred to me beyond 'knowing' that Babe Ruth was the best of the best. Why, it would be like ranking saints after St Peter!

I was a little kid in the mid-70s and biased to the Reds because of living in central Kentucky, but I never heard anyone doubt that Morgan & Bench were the greatest ever at their positions. That was just a default. Rose may have been more beloved (not by me as Bench was my personal hero until I was 12 or 13 and replaced him with Huey Long--I was a strange kid) but everybody at least in that area knew Morgan was just incredible. Probably people thought Bench was better or more unusual, and probably that verdict has reversed over time.

1976. The Twins always played in the Metrodome. Harmon Killebrew was always a Hall of Famer. Rod Carew was an Angel.

Cool. I was born in '74. I grew up in Northern Ontario, became an Orioles fan because '82 was Cal Ripken's rookie year and saw my first game at the Metrodome back in the days of Puckett and Hrbek (my memory is a little hazy but I'm pretty sure they played Mattingly and the Yankees).