Got a chance to feel up some different putters at my local PIAS. They have brought in a few discs other than Innova. And I mean a few, one-sies and two-sies...

Felt a Challenger that was really nice and handled a Wizard. Have to say that I didn't like the feel of the Wiz and wish I'd had a chance to check one out before ordering two. The bead doesn't feel right in my hand... The Mercy also felt really good.

I should have my order in the next day or two and I'll get a chance to throw them this weekend.

Yeah, so I got my order in.... Not super stoked about how any of the putters I picked up feel in the hand except for the Omega AP. It's fairly soft, if a little slick, so maybe this will work for me. I realized now that I know some of the terminology that I don't care for how beaded putters feel in my hand... I guess I never really noticed it since the bead on my Omega AA is all but worn off. Maybe it won't matter, but I'm going to go out and practice putt these guys tonight.

I think I'm going to also pickup a soft Challenger and either a Pure or Mercy (or both to try this weekend as well.

Is it weird that I don't really feel any of these putts better or much differently than the others?

Is it that my form is so inconsistent that the putter I use doesn't make one damn bit of difference? Possibly...

When I fondle the putters at home, some feel better in hand than others, but in the field, i can't say it makes much difference to me one way or the other.

I will say that the softer plastics definitely grab the chains way better than the slicker plastics.

The wizard is pretty sweet for approaches. Seems to hold a line well. It putts ok as well, but I'm surprised how stiff and not sticky the SS is that I received. I think it would putt better if it were grippier.

My favorite plastic of all the discs I tried were the soft Discraft models. The EZE I thought was rather slick, albeit soft. The AP may also make a nice approach disk, but I'll have to throw it and the Wiz some more...

I may also pickup a Pure to try at DoDo disc golf on Allentown when I'm up there for work tomorrow. Is there any harm in trying so many different discs together at one time?

DiscSniper wrote:Is it weird that I don't really feel any of these putts better or much differently than the others?

Is it that my form is so inconsistent that the putter I use doesn't make one damn bit of difference? Possibly...

Putting, especially inside the circle, is 98% confidence, the disc's characteristics make precious little difference. On longer putts, in the range of 40-100' the discs themselves start to matter somewhat.

Parks wrote:If the posts on this forum are any indication, the PD is like a Teebird with sunshine coming out of its butthole so hard that it flies faster.

i love the soft challenger, but before they went to the new stamp w the big X on it instead of the same stamp as the Pro-D. the new ones are almost gumbputt soft and floppy. the older ones are much stiffer and have a chalky feel instead of tire rubber. hope they get this fixed soon, otherwise i'll switch to something else.

My soft Challenger is surely a newer one. It has a nice soft feel to it but I find it to be firm enough for my putting style. I am finding that I actually like these newer soft discs for putting. I think that my old Omega SS is just beat to death making it so floppy it's like throwing one of those old Frisbees I used to have as a kid that was made out of cloth with a weighted ring around the outside.

I visited DoDo disc golf in Allentown PA today. Managed to make it out of there with only another wizard. It is a black super stupid soft.

Had a nice chat with the gentleman behind the counter, who did make it clear that wizards are hitter mess with consistency. He must've had 40 or 50 wizards on the shelf, all marked as super stupid soft, but I can't say that any two of them were the same.

DiscSniper wrote:Had a nice chat with the gentleman behind the counter, who did make it clear that wizards are hitter mess with consistency. He must've had 40 or 50 wizards on the shelf, all marked as super stupid soft, but I can't say that any two of them were the same.

Partly intentional, they purposefully mix up blends that produce not only different stiffnesses but also different surface feels. Their logic is that everyone likes something different, so they'll do everything and let the people find what they want. Makes ordering them online a total crapshoot though...

Parks wrote:If the posts on this forum are any indication, the PD is like a Teebird with sunshine coming out of its butthole so hard that it flies faster.

jubuttib wrote:Partly intentional, they purposefully mix up blends that produce not only different stiffnesses but also different surface feels. Their logic is that everyone likes something different, so they'll do everything and let the people find what they want. Makes ordering them online a total crapshoot though...

Here and lies the problem with me and wizards. The closest physical store to me that stocks any Gateway is over an hour away. To be honest with you I think I'm leaning towards the consistency (from what I hear) of the Discraft putters.

It's not going to stop me from giving them a go however. I'm definitely liking the look of the black Wizard. If I could find some challengers or magnets in black that would really be sweet.