Inside Tasmania is opposed to religious, government and corporate psychopaths. Inside Tasmania is protected by international laws and treaties covering free speech and the freedom of journalists. We maintain the right to publish and be damned. insidetasmania@gmail.com

Lindt Cafe Siege - Government Incompetence Covered-Up By Inquiry

By Paul Bibby SMH
A public inquiry into why Man Haron Monis was on bail at the time of the
Lindt cafe siege – despite facing serious criminal charges – has been
prevented from examining crucial communications between solicitors and
police, after they were found to be privileged legal documents.
In a decision
that may make it impossible to fully answer some of the key questions
from the December 2014 incident, the NSW Coroner has largely upheld an
application by the NSW Director of Public Prosecutions to exclude the
documents from the coronial inquiry.
Coroner Michael Barnes upheld the DPP's application for 62 of the 74 disputed documents or sets of documents.

They are understood to include discussions between police and DPP
solicitors before the siege about appealing Monis' release on bail in
late 2013 when he was charged with accessory to murder.

It is understood there are also conversations within the DPP about
whether it was futile to oppose the continuation of Monis' bail in
October 2014 when he was charged with dozens of sexual offences over
attacks on women at healing clinics in western Sydney.
There are also email conversations among the police who were investigating Monis over his various criminal matters.
The
DPP argued that the relationship between the police and the DPP
solicitors involved in these conversations, and that between the
solicitors and their more-senior colleagues in the office of the
director himself, was akin to that of a client and solicitor preparing
for legal proceedings.
As such, the communications were covered by "professional legal privilege" and thus could not be used as evidence in court.
After
almost two full days of legal argument, in which counsel for siege
victims Katrina Dawson and Tori Johnson strenuously opposed this
position, Coroner Michael Barnes upheld it in all but 12 cases.
The remaining documents will be included in the hearing when it commences on Monday.
"At
all material times, the director had taken over the prosecutions
involving Mr Monis, pursuant to s. 9 of the DPP Act," Mr Barnes said in
his judgment.
"Upon doing so he became the client of the ODPP
[Office of the Director of Public Prosecutions]. Any advice or evidence
sought from the police involved in the investigation of the offences
being prosecuted or any communication for the purposes of those
proceedings, between solicitors employed by the ODPP and the police,
provided in each case that they were confidential, are liable to attract
privilege which can only be waived by the director."
The decision
will not only exclude the documents from the inquest but will prevent
any examination of key witnesses that relates to them.

No comments:

views

The Controlled Expansion Of Building 7

Everyone is entitled to their own opinions but they are not entitled to their own facts.Moynihan

'When we follow the money trail up through the pyramid of world power, past the corporations, past the corrupt politicians, past the front groups and past the mainstream media propagandist – we always find it leads to the Rothschild Banking Cartel, which is sitting quietly at the top, well behind the scenes'.