The earliest card picturing Chief Bender originates from the 1902-11 W600 Sporting Life Cabinets set. The following year, an extremely scarce 1903 E107 Breisch Williams card picturing Bender was produced. During 1906, a Bender card was produced as part of a playing cards game set called Fan Craze - AL, thus picturing only American League ballplayers. Also produced during 1906 was an extremely scarce postcard issued by the Lincoln Publishing Company and picturing members of that season's Philadelphia Athletics. Finally, another early Bender card was included as part of the 1908-10 E91 American Caramel set.