Who is Samuel Gilman!- Visist Central Park, get to know other Sims and ask them about Samuel Gilman- Visit Gilman Hill Graveyard and explore the grave on the right side next to the entrance- Visit the Mausoleum at night and ask the guard about Samuel Gilman- Explore the Catacombs. This will unlock the Zombie Bears, Oh My! achievement.- Visit the library for more information (click on the bookshelfes)- Visit Captain's Refuge and dig through the scrap on the right handside next to the haunted house- Visit Central Park, get to know other Sims and ask them about these artefacts

Remains of the Queen- Visit Captain's Refuge and find a specific NPC- Befriend with specific NPC and ask him/her about the artefacts- Visit the Town Hall cellar between 10 p.m.-7 a.m.

At Last, the Pirate Treasure- Visit the Coastal Cave- Find the anchor in front of the cave. This will unlock the The Missing Link achievement.- Explore the Coastal Cave- Purchase a book about the Coastal Cave and search for hints (click on the book in your inventory and this option will show up)- Explore the cave with a pet

Conclusion, As it Were- Visit the Town Hall and report the pirate treasure- Challenge completed. Pirate outfits unlocked.

There is 1 comment relating to this Solution | Please log in to comment on this solution.