If this is your first visit, be sure to
check out the FAQ by clicking the
link above. You may have to register
before you can post: click the register link above to proceed. To start viewing messages,
select the forum that you want to visit from the selection below.

View Poll Results: Tie breaking Round: Vote for the best After School Club!

Re: Anime Character Showdown - #2 After-School-Club Edition

Aw man, I had no Idea the competition was going to move this quickly (alot of school work recently). I missed the 2nd round of voting, and I would've voted for Sket Dance, now Im a bit upset especially since I nominated it, damn it.

Re: Anime Character Showdown - #2 After-School-Club Edition

Since when this turned out in a battle of which club is more moe? There is other aspects that I listed before, Koten-bu solves mysteries with a briliant sense and all characters are interesting. Light Music Club, on the other hand, only drink tea and eat cake everyday.
Ask to a Student Council which is more useful and you will get your answer.

Re: Anime Character Showdown - #2 After-School-Club Edition

Since when you ask? It has always been a case of which one is more moe

Same could be said of your argument easily. Since when this is a battle of being more of a use?
But yeah, Light Music Club is the most realistic after school club from my point of view. They hang around, have dreams, do stuff when they feel like it and eventually disband. Perfect!

Re: Anime Character Showdown - #2 After-School-Club Edition

They are clubs. They must serve for something, I guess? lol

I'm not sure about what you said, in Kimi no Iru Machi there is a distinction between clubs and they call "circles", the first is more serious than the second. In other words, Light Music Club is not serious enough with its purpose. The best after school club should have these characteristics to be the best.
We see even in K-On that they are wrong in act like that, Azusa complains about that everytime. :P

When the poll will be closed? I want to see Koten-bu victory as soon as possible.

Re: Anime Character Showdown - #2 After-School-Club Edition

Those circles were in college, though, not applying to high-school or anything. Basically, a club is a club as long as it gets approval in high-school level. Saying that it has to be serious is a stretch. In that case, every sport club would shut its doors, since 99% of their members do not go pro, lol.

Plus, this is a character showdown by definition. It has got nothing to do with "the best" by any means. It's about which characters you like more, so, analyzing club structure is out of question for me, which makes it all more pointless for us to debate on this anymore.