Is it ok to clone a human being?

Cloning isn’t just about making copies of humans - it helps us to fight diseases. But is it right to mess with nature? And what about the accidental consequences of cloning? Wow, this is complicated…

Can cloning save lives?

When you think of cloning you probably think of a copied creature. But there’s much more to cloning than giving you that identical twin you’ve always wanted - most of the work that's being done is less about copying ourselves whole and more about copying bits of us. But why?

More

Therapeutic Cloning

Therapeutic cloning (also called Somatic Cell Nuclear Transfer - SCNT) is the combining of the body of an egg cell with the nucleus of an ordinary cell from elsewhere in that organism. When these parts of the two cells are combined they make something amazing - stem cells.

What are stem cells?

A colony of embryonic stem cells

Stem cells are the basic building blocks of plants and animals. When we were an egg, we were made almost entirely of stem cells, but as we developed, these cells changed and developed into all the different types of cells that make up our bodies. Scientists hope that they'll be able to use these stem cells to help cure serious diseases, as the cells would be able to grow and replace damaged parts of our bodies.

Eventually, it might be possible to use therapeutic cloning to grow new organs for transplant, meaning that we'll no longer need to rely on organ donation. It might also be possible to use stem cells to cure or reduce cancers - replacing damaged cancerous cells with brand new healthy copies. This sort of therapy is already being used to help treat Leukaemia - a cancer of the bone marrow and blood. Patients would undergo radiotherapy (a very intense treatment given to some cancer sufferers where powerful radiation is used to destroy cancer cells) and then be given a transfusion of stem cells. These stem cells then travel from their blood to their bone marrow and change into new cells - white blood cells, platelets and red corpuscles.

How might they be used?

There aren't any other working stem cell treatments at the moment, but there's a huge amount of work going on to make treatments based on therapeutic cloning and stem cells:

Degenerative brain diseases: it might eventually be possible to cure or reduce conditions like ALS, Parkinson's or Alzheimer's by using stem cells to replace damaged brain tissue.

Spinal cord injuries: early experiments have shown that stem cell treatments might be able to repair damaged spinal cords - curing or reducing the paralysis that’s caused by a broken neck or back.

Heart disease: your heart is a very special muscle - it works all your life but it never stops, sleeps or gets tired. However, unlike your other muscles, it can't repair itself if it gets damaged. So scientists have begun to work out how stem cells could be used to repair damaged hearts.

Missing teeth: Scientists can use stem cells to grow complete teeth in the laboratory. They're now working on whether it would be possible to use these techniques to grow ‘tooth buds’ that would be used to grow new teeth in human patients.

Diabetes: Diabetes causes around 4 million deaths each year, so a cure would be a major life saver. Scientists have already been able to make stem cells turn into pancreatic beta cells in the lab. In theory, these could be transplanted into a patient to repair their malfunctioning pancreas.

HIV/Aids: The Aids virus destroys the immune system. Scientists have recently begun experimenting with the use of stem cells to repair the immune system and cure the patient.

Can cloning save lives?

It’s safe to say that Therapeutic Cloning can save lives. And not only that but in the future cloning technology and stem cell therapy could entirely change the way we think about curing diseases.

But should we use it? There’s a whole host of ethical questions that come with this new scientific territory - and just because we can do something doesn’t mean we should. But what do you think?

3 ways human cloning could help us

Some of these technologies don’t exist yet and others aren’t legal - but should they be? Are the possible risks of cloning worth it given how much it could help us?

Growing new body parts

The ability to clone could really help you out if you get injured - instead of using plastic and silicone, or spare skin from somewhere else on your body, your injuries could be repaired using brand new parts! New skin, tissues, muscle, or even whole new limbs - all an exact match to your own DNA. So if you lose your leg in a car crash, a new one could be cloned and sewn back on. Cool, right? Or what about plastic surgery - silicone breast implants can make women sick if they leak into their bloodstream, but if breast tissue was cloned there could be a completely harmless alternative. And who knows, with head transplant surgery soon to be tested, you could one day replace your entire body with a younger, stronger copy.

Giving people children

Lots of people want children, but can’t have them - infertile couples, same-sex couples, people who married later in life, etc. But with reproductive cloning, there’s a chance people could beat these biological boundaries and have children no matter their age, health or sexual orientation. It also might mean we could eliminate pregnancy and childbirth altogether (which some women may be happy about) and bring all children into existence through cloning.

Creating an ultimate human race

Imagine a future where no one gets sick, or becomes dangerously overweight, or suffers from severe depression. Cloning could allow us to produce the perfect human race - one which was hardy enough to withstand all diseases. We could create a world where every human lived to an old age without the genes which create psychological or physical problems. Everyone could be a genius with an IQ of 180+. What would life be like if every one of us was physically, psychologically and aesthetically 'perfect'?

Is it ok to do genetic experiments on humans before they’re born?

If we could change the DNA in a human embryo we might be able to stop that baby from having a horrible disease or disfigurement. But is it ok to mess with a human life if that person can’t give you permission? Oxford neuroethics professor Tom Douglas explores whether or not a human embryo has any rights or moral status...

Weird and wonderful facts about cloning

What was the name of the first successfully-cloned dog at South Korea’s Seoul National University in 2005?

Cluppy

Skuppy

Snuppy

What was the first animal to ever be successfully cloned?

A tadpole

A sheep

A rat

In what year did the UN adopt the declaration on human cloning?

2003

2005

2006

What fruits are all clones of one another?

Pineapples

Watermelons

Navel Oranges

A biotech company in Canada created a substance called BioSteel by cloning which animal?

Monkey

Goat

Rabbit

Bananas are all clones - but why is that a problem?

You’ll never get to eat an interesting banana

You’ll never be able to grow them in your back garden

The earth’s entire supply of bananas could be wiped out

Are identical twins clones?

No

Yes

Which actor became a champion of stem-cell therapy research following a horse-riding accident that completely severed his spinal chord?

Dean Cain

Christopher Reeve

Henry Cavill

Where can you have your pet dog cloned (for a substantial fee)?

The US

Switzerland

South Korea

Although the idea of cloning has been around awhile, the word itself is fairly new - who came up with it?

Julia Bell

JBS Haldane

D Bernard Amos

Prev
Next

The first cloned sheep, Dolly, was named after US country singer Dolly Parton.

The first cloned sheep, Dolly, was named after US country singer Dolly Parton.

Is designing your own animal a good idea?

For the first time ever, we can design life - we can create ‘ligers’ (a cross between a lion and a tiger) or dogs that glow in the dark. But do these new skills bring new responsibilities? Bioethicist Prof. Paul Root Wolpe (Emory University) thinks that we need some ethical guidelines in our cloning work and that just because we can do things, doesn’t necessarily mean that we should.

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=ovV7v2XYJAI

The history of cloning

It all started with a strand of hair and a salamander embryo...

More

1902 - The first step

Hans Spemann, a German embryologist, came up with the idea that if you were to split a two-cell salamander embryo then it might be possible for two identical salamanders to develop individually. Hans fashioned a loop from a strand of baby hair and separated the embryo into two - and it worked.

This then led him to what he called ‘The Fantastic Experiment’ - the idea that an embryo could be grown from an egg without insemination. More accurately, he believed that if we were to replace the nucleus of an egg cell with another kind of cell, we could create an exact copy of the ‘parent’. Not quite Jurassic Park - but close.

Hans Spemann (June 27, 1869 – September 9, 1941)

1952 - The fantastic experiment

Hans’s Fantastic Experiment was proven successful when English biologist Robert Briggs and American researcher Thomas King transferred the cell nucleus from a tadpole embryo into a frog’s egg cell. But it took us until 1975 for this same experiment to be attempted with a mammal. They called the process an embryonic nuclear transfer, which British science-whizz J Derek Bromhall first tried with a rabbit. This experiment didn’t go any further than the initial test, but it paved the way for further research.

1984 - Cloning mammals

This was the year of Dutch scientist Steen Willadsen’s great breakthrough - he created history’s first-ever mammal clone. Once the embryonic nuclear transfer was complete and the fused cells began dividing, he popped the cells into the womb of a surrogate sheep and hey presto - three lamb clones were born.

1990 - A new law is made

Once mammal cloning had been achieved, naturally thoughts began to turn to the impact this could have on humans. But there was huge, public, moral opposition to the idea of human cloning, so the UK parliament created the Human Fertilisation and Embryology Act 1990. It required researchers to be properly licensed by the newly-appointed Human Fertilisation and Embryology Authority. It also stated that no embryo used in research could be transferred to a woman, and an embryo is only allowed to be developed for 14 days after fertilisation. Evil science geniuses need not apply!

1996 - Somatic cell nuclear transfer

How Dolly the sheep was made.

This is when cloning moved into the fast lane. Megan and Morag were born - two lambs cloned without the use of embryonic cells. British science duo Ian Wilmut and Keith Campbell switched the nuclei of cultured cells with the nuclei of egg cells. This new method gave rise to the new method of using somatic cells (non-embryonic cells). In this case, they used the nuclei of udder cells to create 277 embryos. Only one survived: Dolly - our shining totem to humanity’s power over nature.

1988-1999 - Cloning takes off

Experiments abounded across the world and a wide variety of animals - including mice, goats and cows - were cloned. They even managed to clone a male mouse - all other clone animals had been female up to this point. Then in 1997 a team at the Oregon Regional Primate Research Center successfully cloned two Rhesus monkeys, called Neti and Ditto. This seemed to bring the idea of cloning humans even closer.

2001 - Fighting extinction

Scientists understood that cloning could offer the world something different - give endangered species a fighting chance to beat extinction. Many animals don’t take well to breeding in captivity, but it was thought that cloning could help endangered species to overcome their unwillingness to procreate. Whilst cloning is still not seen to be a good means of conservation, the success rate is around 5% - so perhaps one day it might still have a role to play in saving some species from extinction.

2009 - Resurrecting the dead

Cloning endangered species wasn’t the end game - next on the horizon was the resurrection of the dead. Goats were used as egg donors and surrogates for the genes of the extinct bucardo, a type of Spanish mountain goat. The first goat kid died due to a lung defect, but for a brief moment, the species was brought back to life. To this day, Professor Hwang Woo-Suk and his team in Siberia are attempting to resurrect the woolly mammoth after several thousand years of extinction!

2008 - Human cloning begins

Embryonic Stem Cells. Image shows hESCs

The first successful human embryos created using somatic cell nuclear transfer were announced in 2008 by Andrew French (an Australian scientist) and Samuel Wood (an American fertility specialist). Five years later, the first human embryonic stem cells were created. Shoukhrat Mitalipov and his team in x used somatic cell nuclear transfer of a patient's skin cells to a donated egg cell. This created an embryo that was used as a source of embryonic stem cells.

Now - the law

The UK was one country to vote against the UN’s decision to create a non-binding global ban on human cloning in 2004. Because this is a non-binding ban, we can still continue our research - but cloning is currently only allowed for therapeutic reasons, such as stem-cell research and organ printing. Reproductive cloning of humans is still off the table. So... no living, breathing human clones for the time being.

The future - where will cloning lead us?

It seems like creating an army of clones or getting that identical twin you’ve always wanted is still the stuff of science fiction - for now. But the tools and knowledge we have mean there’s just no telling where cloning might lead us...

Is it OK to clone a human being?

Therapeutic Cloning can save lives

Therapeutic cloning involves combining the body of an egg cell with the nucleus of an ordinary cell from elsewhere in that organism, to make a stem cell. Stem cells are the basic building blocks of plants and animals. Scientists hope that they'll be able to use these stem cells to help cure serious diseases, such as spinal cord injuries and heart disease, as the cells would be able to grow and replace damaged parts of our bodies.

Designer cats and dogs

Bioethicist, Paul Root Wolpe said “For the first time in the history of this planet, we are able to directly design organisms. We can manipulate the plasmas of life with unprecedented power, and it confers on us a responsibility. Is it okay to manipulate and create whatever creatures we want?” What do you think? Is it fair for us to design animals exactly how we would like them?

Giving people children

Lots of people want children, but can’t have them - infertile couples, same-sex couples, people who married later in life, etc. But with reproductive cloning, there’s a chance people could beat these biological boundaries and have children no matter their age, health or sexual orientation. It also might mean we could eliminate pregnancy and childbirth altogether (which some women may be happy about) and bring all children into existence through cloning.

Protecting human life

In 2005, the UN adopted the declaration on human cloning, which prohibited any forms of human cloning, as it was considered to go against the idea of human dignity and the protection of human life. Some people argue that we shouldn’t try to ‘play God’ and mess with a human life (in the form of embryos) if that person can’t give you permission.