New Jersey teens charged in newborn's death plead not guilty

NEPTUNE TOWNSHIP, New Jersey (WABC) -- A young mother accused of killing her newborn and the teenage father accused of disposing of the baby's body in a dumpster pleaded not guilty Wednesday during an emotional court appearance.

Family members and friends burst into tears as soon as the defendants walked into the courtroom, and both McClain and Mohammed were crying while talking to their attorneys. McClain was visibly trembling as she entered her plea.

Neptune Township police say they were contacted by Asbury Park police on April 4 to report that a female student at Neptune High School had reported that her friend recently gave birth to an infant who was now deceased.

Authorities say she wrapped the body in a blanket and placed it in a bag before she and Mohammed disposed of the bag in a dumpster in the parking lot of the Washington Village Apartment complex in Asbury Park.

Police say the friend who initially reported the incident told them McClain had attempted to kill the baby prior to the birth by drinking, smoking marijuana and taking pills.

McClain reportedly told police she hid her pregnancy from her parents and considered getting an abortion, but she was underage at the time and didn't want her mother to find out.

They say she also admitted that several days prior to the birth, she and Mohammed had a conversation about what she would do after giving birth. One option they allegedly discussed was that she would kill the baby after the birth, and McClain advised that Mohammed stated "They have to do what's best for them."

She later traveled with detectives to the Washington Village Apartment complex for the purpose of identifying the trash dumpster where Mohammed discarded the baby's remains, and authorities then recovered surveillance video showing McClain's vehicle arriving at the complex and Mohammed exiting the front passenger seat and discarding what appeared to be a blue colored bag into the dumpster.

"Neither one of them should be in that predicament," Mohammed's cousin Cory Watts said. "They both have parents, uncles, aunts, family members...There's no reason that they couldn't turn to somebody, whether it was family, in house, out house."

In 2000, New Jersey approved a Safe Haven law allowing parents to drop off their unharmed baby less than 30 days old with staff at any hospital emergency room, police station, fire station, ambulance, first aid or rescue squad.

The investigation is still active and ongoing, and anyone with additional information is urged to call Monmouth County Prosecutor's Office Detective Wayne Raynor at 800-533-7443 or Neptune Township Police Detective Nick Taylor at 732 988-8000 ext. 410.