The Comedians

You know Plaza as Parks and Recreation’s deadpan assistant, April. Her style? “I went to Catholic school, so a plaid skirt, a button-down and leather shoes were all I knew,” she says. “That’s still how I dress.”

The Nerdy One

Gerwig jumps effortlessly from mainstream hits (No Strings Attached) to indies (Greenberg). “In high school, all I wanted was a T-shirt that said BEBE in rhinestones,” says Gerwig. “That’s what all the popular girls wore.”

The Sweet One

MacLemore makes her feature-film debut in Damsels. “I’m obsessed with white sundresses,” says the Alabama native, who recently got married to her hometown sweetheart. “He was my blind date to the debutante ball!”

The Low-Key One

Tipton got her start on America’s Next Top Model and broke out in Crazy, Stupid, Love. “I wear high-tops all the time,” Tipton says. “They’re held together with duct tape. When I have a date, I have to ask, ‘We’re going to a dive bar…right?’”

The Fashion-Forward One

Echikunwoke has done the TV circuit (CSI: Miami, 90210) and is now moving into the major leagues. “I change, like, three times a day,” she says. “I’ll put something on and be like, ‘Eh—over it.’ I don’t know why!”

Like NBC’s Parenthood—or adorable puppies? You’ll love this next girl.

The Tomboy

Mae Whitman, 23, plays Amber Holt in NBC’s Parenthood and appears next in The Perks of Being a Wallflower. And of course, we can’t forget Whitman’s dog, Chet Baker!

Her “Aha!” Style Moment:

“I wore shorts every single day of school until a girl in my class dared me to wear a skirt. The next day I wore one and thought, ‘this is nice!’”

What She Wears Now:

“I kind of dress like a boy from the nineties. I like wearing baseball hats. I just like to be really comfortable.” Her phobia: “I have a random fear of the apocalypse, so I usually have extra boots in my car in case s—t goes down. I picture myself walking around during the end of times and everyone being jealous of my boots while they’re in little heels.”

Click through to meet a high-heel-wearing, motorcycle-riding musician.

Dress, Versus; heels, Vivienne Westwood.

The Music Maker

Brooklyn-based musician Santigold, 35, has a second solo record, Master of My Make Believe, out this month.

In Her Closet

“I’m a little bit of a hoarder. I have a hard time throwing out clothes because I know styles always come back.”

Her Recent Injury

“While shooting my video in Jamaica, I was on a motorcycle, and I had these insane Rodarte heels on the whole time. I actually sprained my ankle.”

What She Wears at Home

“I have all kinds of animal-print one-piece pajama sets. One has a cat face with little buttons for eyes.”

Want to meet the lucky gal who gets to work with Elton (aka Jeremy Sisto) from Clueless everyday? Click here!