That changed last week when Spider-Man was captured on video robbing a 7-Eleven in Altamonte Springs, Florida, with the aid of a rifle and a masked sidekick, presumably one Andy Maguire, aka Alpha.

According to Orlando’s WESH Channel 2, the two men — one wearing a Spider-Man mask and winter hunting cap with ear flaps — entered the store shortly after midnight on March 4 and approached a clerk. When she told them she couldn’t open the safe, she was pushed to the ground; they then turned to a second clerk, who gave the duo an undisclosed amount of money from the register.

Spider-Man and his not-so-amazing friend were seen fleeing, not in the Spider-Mobile, but rather a dark car with tinted windows.