The [[Updates_Policy]] defines the rules for marking update candidates as ''stable''. The [[QA:Updates_Testing|QA updates-testing page]] provides some information for testers on using this repository. The [[Package_update_HOWTO|package update guidelines]] provide information for packagers on submitting builds to ''updates-testing'' and to ''stable''.

The [[Updates_Policy]] defines the rules for marking update candidates as ''stable''. The [[QA:Updates_Testing|QA updates-testing page]] provides some information for testers on using this repository. The [[Package_update_HOWTO|package update guidelines]] provide information for packagers on submitting builds to ''updates-testing'' and to ''stable''.

−

The ''updates-testing'' repository is enabled by default for Branched releases, but disabled by default for stable releases. The switchover is made around the time of the [[Release freezes|Final Freeze]] for each release. Testers moving from Branched to stable may encounter errors running updates around this time, caused by dependency mismatches between packages already installed from the now-disabled ''updates-testing'' repository. Running {{command|dnf distro-sync}} (or with yum command) or re-enabling the ''updates-testing'' repository will both usually alleviate the issue; it is up to the individual user whether they wish to continue using the ''updates-testing'' repository after the stable release or not.

+

The ''updates-testing'' repository is enabled by default for Branched releases, but disabled by default for stable releases. The switchover is made around the time of the [[Milestone freezes|Final Freeze]] for each release. Testers moving from Branched to stable may encounter errors running updates around this time, caused by dependency mismatches between packages already installed from the now-disabled ''updates-testing'' repository. Running {{command|dnf distro-sync}} (or with yum command) or re-enabling the ''updates-testing'' repository will both usually alleviate the issue; it is up to the individual user whether they wish to continue using the ''updates-testing'' repository after the stable release or not.

The ''updates-testing'' repositories for both Branched and stable releases can be found in the {{filename|/fedora/linux/updates/testing/XX}} directory on the mirrors (where XX is the release), and can also be queried from [[MirrorManager]]. For instance, https://mirrors.fedoraproject.org/mirrorlist?repo=updates-testing-f{{FedoraVersionNumber}}&arch=x86_64 will return mirrors for the x86_64 ''updates-testing'' repository for {{FedoraVersion|long}}.

The ''updates-testing'' repositories for both Branched and stable releases can be found in the {{filename|/fedora/linux/updates/testing/XX}} directory on the mirrors (where XX is the release), and can also be queried from [[MirrorManager]]. For instance, https://mirrors.fedoraproject.org/mirrorlist?repo=updates-testing-f{{FedoraVersionNumber}}&arch=x86_64 will return mirrors for the x86_64 ''updates-testing'' repository for {{FedoraVersion|long}}.

Revision as of 17:54, 30 October 2015

This page explains the various Fedora repositories that exist for different Fedora Releases, the relationship between them, and what packages they contain.

The fedora repository

The fedora repository exists for all Fedora releases after they have Branched from Rawhide. It is represented for Yum or DNF in the fedora.repo file in the repository path. For any Fedora installation, this repository will be enabled by default, and should usually remain so.

The fedora repository in stable releases

For stable releases, fedora represents the frozen release state. It is a part of the frozen tree that is created by Release Engineering when a release is approved at a Go_No_Go_Meeting. The package set it contains never changes after that time. It represents the stable state of a stable release in conjunction with the updates repository.

In Branched releases - the state a release is in between branching from Rawhide and stable release, see Branched for more details - the fedora repository alone represents the release's stable state. The updates repository for Branched releases is not used until they become stable. Before the Bodhi enabling point, package builds for the Branched release are sent directly to this repository. After the Bodhi enabling point, package builds that pass the Updates Policy move from the updates-testing repository to this repository.

The rawhide repository

In Rawhide - Fedora's rolling release repository, from which release are Branched before finally going stable - rawhide is the only repository. All package builds are sent there. It is represented for Yum or DNF in the fedora-rawhide.repo file in the repository path. For any system running Rawhide, it should be enabled. For any other system, it should not.

The updates repository

The updates repository exists for Branched and stable releases, but is only populated and used for stable releases. It is represented for Yum or DNF in the fedora-updates.repo file in the repository path. It exists in Branched releases solely to prevent various tools that expect its existence from breaking. For any Fedora installation, this repository will be enabled by default, and should usually remain so.

For stable releases, updates together with fedora represents the current stable state of the release. Package builds that pass the Updates Policy move from the updates-testing repository to this repository. This difference from Branched is a result of the need to maintain a precise representation of the initial, 'frozen' state of a stable release.

The updates-testing repository

The updates-testing repository exists for Branched releases after the Bodhi enabling point, and for stable releases. It is represented for Yum or DNF in the fedora-updates-testing.repo file in the repository path. For both, it is a 'staging' location where new package builds are tested before being marked as 'stable' (and hence moving to the fedora repository or the updates repository, respectively).

These builds are sometimes referred to as update candidates, and are reviewed with the Bodhi update feedback tool, according to the update feedback guidelines.

The updates-testing repository is enabled by default for Branched releases, but disabled by default for stable releases. The switchover is made around the time of the Final Freeze for each release. Testers moving from Branched to stable may encounter errors running updates around this time, caused by dependency mismatches between packages already installed from the now-disabled updates-testing repository. Running dnf distro-sync (or with yum command) or re-enabling the updates-testing repository will both usually alleviate the issue; it is up to the individual user whether they wish to continue using the updates-testing repository after the stable release or not.

stable is not a repository

It is not unusual to see references to the 'stable repository', but this is something of a misnomer. stable is more of a state that can be considered to exist for both Branched releases post-Bodhi enabling and for stable releases. It consists of package builds that were part of Rawhide at the time they Branched, package builds sent directly to the Branched fedora repository between the branch point and the Bodhi enabling point, and package builds that passed the Updates Policy and moved from updates-testing after the Bodhi enabling point.

For Branched releases, the stable state is represented solely by the current contents of the fedora repository (and, arguably, the bleed repository, but that is a small case).

For stable releases, the stable state is represented by the contents of the fedora repository combined with the contents of the updates repository.

stable is also a state a package can be considered to be in (or an attribute it can be considered to have) when it has been pushed stable or tagged stable and exists in, or will soon exist in, a stable repository for a release - whichever literal repository that is (see above).

The repositories referred to above are neither associated with a specific Fedora.nextProduct, nor part of an installable tree (a tree containing the necessary files to be used as a base repository by Anaconda, the Fedora installer). Specialized repositories exist for these purposes.

For Fedora.next releases - Fedora 21 and later - there is (as of September 2014) no installable tree not associated with a specific Product. The installable trees for various Products can be found under /fedora/linux/releases/XX/ on the mirrors for stable releases, and under /fedora/linux/releases/test/ for Branched pre-release milestones. They can also be queried from MirrorManager. For instance, https://mirrors.fedoraproject.org/mirrorlist?repo=fedora-server-33&arch=x86_64 will return mirrors for the x86_64 current installation repository for Fedora 33 Server.

These repositories are frozen (new packages are not pushed to them) and are created at various points in the Fedora Release Life Cycle. A new installation tree (containing a repository) is built for several Products for each test compose or release candidate build, and the trees for the Alpha and Beta releases are made available on the mirrors in the /releases/test directory (see above). They contain a subset of the full package set that is considered to define each Product (see comps for the technical details of this).

The Product trees for the GA (Final) release are made available in the /releases tree on the mirrors.

At any given point in the release cycle, the MirrorManager request for a Product repository may redirect to a test compose / release candidate tree, a pre-release milestone tree, or the Final release tree.

These repositories are usually not used or enabled by default on installed systems, as for that purpose they are redundant with one of the three primary repositories described above. However, one could use a Product repository in place of the fedora repository to keep a system limited to the Product package set. They are represented for Yum or DNF in the fedora-(product).repo file in the repository path, which may well not be installed on many systems.

Other repositories

There are other repositories that fulfil various niche purposes, which are documented here for the sake of providing a comprehensive reference. They should not usually be significant to the vast majority of Fedora users. None of these repositories is represented in a packaged repository file, enabled by default, or should usually be used in a Fedora installation.

The bleed repository can be found here, but again, is not usually of interest to the vast majority of Fedora users. The packages it contains are always also available from the build system, Koji, and usually from the updates-testing repository.

The latest repositories

The latestrepositories contain packages for various build 'tags' as they arrive in the Koji build system. They are not mashed, a process which principally handles multilib, and using them can cause various problems, in addition to overloading Fedora's development servers. It is almost always a better idea to cherry-pick new builds from Koji or Bodhi via their web interfaces or command line tools.

Repositories FAQ

As described above, updates for both Branched pre-releases and final, 'stable' releases go through the updates-testing process before being moved to a stable repository. Before the final release, they are placed in the fedora repository. After release, they are placed in updates.

The reason for the difference is that we want to have a record of the exact 'state' of a given Fedora stable release. That is, at the time a Fedora release is declared to be done at a Go No Go Meeting, we consider the state of the release at that time to be the canonical definition of that release, and we wish to preserve a record of that state. For a stable release, the tree containing the fedora repository is that record, and the fedora repository it contains is the canonical record of the precise frozen package set that formed the main part of that stable release.

Since we wish to maintain this frozen state for the fedora repository, we cannot place updates directly into it. The necessity for the updates repository therefore becomes obvious - we need a place to put updates to stable releases that is outside the frozen state of the release.

Before a stable release occurs, this mechanism is not necessary. Before the release is declared to be done, there is no frozen state of the release: effectively, the whole Branched development process is working towards what will become the frozen state of the release, so of course package builds for the Branched release land directly in the fedora repository.

Why is updates-testing enabled by default in pre-releases?

While Branched development releases and stable releases both use an updates-testing repository together with the Bodhi update feedback system to stage packages before they reach the release's stable state, it is enabled by default in Branched, but not in stable releases.

The reason is that the purpose of the updates-testing system is somewhat different in each case. For stable releases, the system's goal is to prevent broken updates reaching the general Fedora user population. In most cases, Fedora systems are expected to have the updates-testing repository disabled. Some QA testers then enable the repository on testing systems to try out the updates and provide feedback. The testers perform the job of making sure the updates are OK before they reach the general user population.

When it comes to a Branched pre-release, the expectation is that anyone who installs it wants to help test it: we effectively consider anyone running a Branched release to be a tester. The function of updates-testing is different in this case. There is not a 'general user population' of Branched users who run with updates-testing disabled, and are protected from problematic updates by the group of update testers. Instead, updates-testing in Branched serves other important functions.

The main purpose is to insulate image builds from potentially problematic changes. Branched images - nightly images, and the Alpha, Beta and GA (Final) milestone builds and their test compose and release candidate builds - are built from the stable packages, that is, only those in the fedora repository, not those in updates-testing. In this sense, updates-testing protects not a set of users, but a set of builds, from potentially destabilizing changes. Especially when we are building an Alpha, Beta or GA release, we need to be able to reduce the amount of change in the package set between composes in order to produce an image of high quality. The updates-testing mechanism allows for that: during Milestone freezes, new builds can be sent to updates-testing, but cannot move from there to stable (fedora) without special circumstances (see the blocker and freeze exception processes). In this way, we can work on release images while not preventing packagers from sending out builds.

For this and other less important functions, we need as much feedback as possible, so it makes sense to have all pre-release testers have updates-testing enabled by default, and encourage them to provide feedback through Bodhi.