Van Etten and Jones recently collaborated on an Amazon Original version of the Remind Me Tomorrow standout, and it’s that soulful, subdued iteration of “Seventeen” they performed on Colbert Thursday night. Van Etten and Jones, playing acoustic guitar and keyboard, respectively, trade verses, then sing in unison on the song’s choruses and bridge, delivering husky and emotive vocals as they lock eyes from opposite ends of the stage.

Van Etten continues to tour in support of Remind Me Tomorrow, performing at Wilco’s Sky Blue Sky Festival in Mexico in January before returning to the States for eight southeastern stops in April.

Watch the duo’s Late Show performance below, then revisit their respective 2010 and 2013 Daytrotter sessions further down. Keep scrolling for Van Etten’s tour dates.