Lancet Editor "Responds" to HR Critique

In July, HonestReporting took apart The Lancet medical journal’s collection of articles supposedly examining the state of the Palestinian healthcare system. Our research into the background of a number of contributors to The Lancet’s articles revealed some disturbing information and called into question the credibility of the content, particularly as most of those authors identified were active supporters of the boycott, divestment and sanctions (BDS) campaign against Israel.

We demonstrated a politicized anti-Israel agenda in The Lancet. Yet, instead of addressing our very legitimate criticism, the journal’s editor Richard Horton responded in The Lancet’s July 31 edition (available on The Lancet’s Facebook page):

The Lancet is grateful to our colleagues at HonestReporting for providing further international coverage of the research we published recently online, which drew attention to the health predicaments of Palestinians living under Israeli occupation and internal political fracture. With the help of HonestReporting, we have been able to reach a large, new, and largely unaware audience.

We believe that the “large, new, and largely unaware audience” are more likely to be readers who have now been made aware of The Lancet’s anti-Israel bias and abandonment of scientific and medical norms. We also received many communications from medical professionals who expressed their deep concern at The Lancet’s agenda.

But we shouldn’t be surprised. Richard Horton only this week exposed his personal animosity towards Israel in a letter to The Guardian on 24 August in response to an op-ed by Israel’s Ambassador to the UK, Ron Prosor. Some selected excerpts (emphasis added):

Gaza is not a terrorist enclave. It is a vigorous community of 1.4 million people struggling to exist under what the UN still considers to be occupation by Israel. Operation Cast Lead did not target “terrorist infrastructure”. On a visit to Gaza that I made in March this year, with colleagues from the UK, I witnessed the results of indiscriminate bombing of residential communities across the Strip, as well as the results of civilian casualties. …

Gaza is not “a golden opportunity tragically missed”. The people of Gaza are experiencing continued declines in child health, unchecked burdens of chronic disease, shortages of life-saving medical supplies and equipment, and the dramatic erosion of mental health. These unprecedented hardships are a direct consequence of Israel’s disregard for the health and security of people who they, as occupiers, have a legal duty to protect. …

In the classrooms I visited, there was no incitement against Israel. Instead, there was pride in being Palestinian, a plea for the facts of their lives to be told against the propaganda that Prosor repeats.

On one issue, Mr Prosor and I agree. Many Israelis are sceptical and do fear for their futures. But this is largely because it suits politicians to manufacture the scepticism and fear that destroy hopes for peace andjustice. If the full truth about the health of people living in the occupied Palestinian territory was more widely known, the international community would no longer tolerate Israel’s apparent indifference.

Much like his journal, Horton

Ignores Hamas terrorism and violence against its own people as well as Israelis, preferring to believe that the legitimate fear of missiles and mortars from Gaza is the manufactured product of politicians dealing in fear.

Blames the situation in Gaza solely on Israel, placing no responsibility whatsoever on Palestinian actions.

Richard Horton has clinically demonstrated and confirmed that The Lancet is not publishing anti-Israel articles out of naivety but is being guided in a politicized direction from the very top.

We’d also like to thank Richard Horton for bringing HonestReporting’s work to the attention of the medical community – a large, new, and largely unaware audience who will hopefully now see through The Lancet’s insidious agenda.

The de-legimitization and blaming of Israel as the source of all the maladies in the region and particulary in Gaza,other than distorting the true,presenting partial facts,and uncovering
deep irrational antisemitic feelings,is not serving the good interests of the palestinian people.
The lidership of Hammas declare openly war against Israel and their will to wipe Israel from the map.The Lancet editor and doctors reading this prestigious publication are invited to visit
any hospital in Israel and see how palestinian pacients,also from Gaza,are receiving the same medical attention as local israelis,with one of the highest medical services over the world.It is incredible,that people that consider themselves to be on the cientific-objective side of humanity are so blind to facts.

Another area/domain of biased faux -medical research is the whole “depleted uranium” kerfuffle, in which biased , anti -semite scientists— with research often sponsored by Islamists— accuse Israel and the U.s of toxifying the middle east with D.U. weoponry.

The name paola manducci, Mozhgan savabieasfahani and Douglas Rokke are prominent in this camp.

The latter has been a keynote speaker at events sponsored by the near- neo nazi holocaust trivializing “Barnes Foundation” while the middle name–an institutionally un -affiliated toxicologist– has joined her husband in harassing synagogues and jewish cultural events in michigan, often with signage that says “fuck israel”..