Pizza

It's not about twirling dough over your head or having stonemasons fly in from Naples to install a custom wood-fired oven. It's about the ingredients: a handmade cracker-like crust full of basil and asiago cheese, brushed with our own pesto. A deliciously uncomplicated sauce made from San Marzano tomatoes and garlic. Fresh mozzarella. The same Molinari pepperoni we sell retail--and plenty of it. No shortcuts, no preservatives, no bulk ingredients. And that makes all the difference. Please note that all pizzas are twelve inches, which we cut into eight slices when we bake them here. You also have the option of baking them at home.

Deli Salads

Scooped and priced by weight

$10.99 per pound

CRANBERRY CHICKEN SALAD

"Oh, you're going to Boyne City? Stop at Lake Street and get me some chicken salad!" Yeah. That happens. We make it--several times a day in the busier months--from house-roasted chicken, dried cranberries, celery, pickles, green onions, Hellman's mayo, honey mustard, and spices. Literally world famous.

$10.99 per pound

$10.99 per pound

TUNA SALAD

Eleven years into our deli-ship, we thought we really should have tuna salad. The results are worth the wait: pole-caught wild Albacore tuna, capers, roasted sweet red peppers, cucumber, celery, Hellman's mayo, lemon, a touch of sriracha, herbs and spices. Soooo not like our moms used to make!

Soups

Lake Street Market soup is one of the great benefits afforded only to those who either live in Boyne City year-round or at least visit in the off-season; we don't have it in the summer. Made here from scratch, right down to the noodles. We run two a day. Please call 231-582-4450 for today's selection or check our facebook page.

Pastries

$1.50

BROWNIES

Made from Lindt chocolate, local eggs, sugar and butter, and baked on a layer of shortbread, the nearly fudge-like texture of these house-made treats conquers all.

$1.50

$1.50

PECAN BARS

A mixture of pecans, local honey, brown sugar, Shetler's heavy cream, and butter baked on the same shortbread we use for the brownies. Definitely addictive.

$1.50

$3.00

SCONES

Well, these are just legendary. Our unusual style of making them allows us to use ingredients that can't be put in a traditional scone, like fresh berries and apple. Try them--you'll be back. And ask about taking them frozen to bake at home!