Rated 1 out of
5 by
mkm19 from
Floppy BrushI bought this product a couple of days ago, thinking the large, plush brush would be fun to use. The brush was not sturdy at all, and look as if I could snap it pretty easily. The "Mega Plush" brush was not mega plush. It looks sparse as a regular brush. The mascara was a bit oily but coated my eyelashes well enough (not much volume, though). I usually love Maybelline product but haven't chosen a steady mascara to buy again. I was really disappointed.

Date published: 2018-08-16

Rated 1 out of
5 by
hrobin1975 from
This BRUSH IS HORRIBLEThe brush for this mascara is terrible. It is too flexible and takes way too long to apply a decent amount. It dries instantly and it impossible to remove without makeup remover. (I've used other waterproof mascara's where you had time to remove the excess that may have gotten on your skin but this dries instantly) I will never buy this again. I have to go buy a different brush so I can use the mascara and didn't completely waste my money.

Date published: 2018-07-23

Rated 5 out of
5 by
Cancandrea from
My holy grail!!This is my all time favourite mascara hand down! I don't wear anything but waterproof and I find this to have the best coverage and most comfortable wear! My only gripe is that I used to be able to buy the waterproof formula in the colour blackest black and now I can only find it in the colour black brown. I still buy it because of the amazing definition it gives to my lashes, I just would rather have the option of buying the darker shade colour. You didn't discontinue the blackest black in the waterproof formula by chance?

Date published: 2018-06-21

Rated 5 out of
5 by
kornsilky_pie from
Natural Looking LashesPersonally I love this product. The gel mousse mascara feels weightless and is very comfortable to wear; it also does not clump up or appear heavy giving a natural lash look. I never thought that I would like a flexible brush but I might be lucky that this was the first mascara I used with that feature. The flexible brush moves with the lashes and coats them evenly instead of pulling or pushing them together causing them to clump. This is one of my favorite mascaras.

Date published: 2018-05-28

Rated 2 out of
5 by
Mary82 from
Good product, but poor brushI bought this mascara and was shocked when I saw the brush. I thought it was defective, but found out it is made this way to be flexible. The mascara works well if I use a brush from another product, but this brush is too flexible & doesn't work well at all.

Date published: 2018-01-11

Rated 5 out of
5 by
Michele01 from
Oh my god it worksI bought this a week ago to wear as I play football. Then next day I put it on and it lasted all day. I had a scrimmage and it down poured rain and that mascara stay on smudge free! #amazing

Date published: 2017-08-22

Rated 1 out of
5 by
DEWB from
Floppy brush is no-goodI would love to see how the formula works but the brush wand is "flexible" so much so that I cannot get any mascara on my lashes. I now use a different wand/brush to apply so this purchase is not a total loss.

Date published: 2017-07-03

Rated 4 out of
5 by
Blewbary from
The only one with a real brushI use this mascara because it is the only one with a non-plastic brush left by Mabelline. I really dislike the plastic brushes they put in other mascaras. This formula seems to dry out faster than others and needs replacing sooner, but it does the job for me.