Player A is the Marlins’ Josh Johnson, who has a 0.83 ERA over his last nine starts. Player B is the Rockies’ Ubaldo Jimenez, who has hit a bit of speed bump lately, but is still having an amazing season overall.

Both players are having near identical seasons. The difference is that Jimenez is 14-1 while Johnson is 8-3.

Yet another reason why pitching wins and losses never tell the whole story.