This one is definately better than the other version, this has warm tones which suit the warm mood of the scene - it has more life in it - the model seems to be very relaxed and comfortable in this brightly lit setting. However the other version is colder, darker and the flip doesn't work too well.
Beautiful piece of art.

I think I like this one better. I't the mood I guess. The light is so beautiful on her and this tone is more fitting cause it's more traditional, or beautiful in a calssical kind of way. As is she. And I like the bg better too. I think I have to fav this

very difficult question.. this picture has got more warm colours and the other one more of cold colours ... her position is nearly the same in both, but i think I like this one a bit more.. I can&#180;t explain why...

ps.: have you taken another cutout??? and have you reflected the picture?? I think its the SAME position ... or not??

very difficult question.. this picture has got more warm colours and the other one more of cold colours ... her position is nearly the same in both, but i think I like this one a bit more.. I can&#180;t explain why...

This is nice too but I do like first one more.
Tones are good here but somehow model seems to be little 'too' soft, maybe if she were more sharp in picture
then I would like this one more.
The floor and walls looks really good here.
Great Work !

i prefer the other one. it has that interesting walla t the end on the very left that adds more interest to the shot. Two windows are expected a la this one, but the other one has a smallwindow that has more interest

I prefer this one as well. I like how this really shows the beauty in a spontaneous moment rather than a more tainted dark visual of that moment in time (which I see more in the other version). But both are amazing, in their own mood. I like the crop on this one much better also. The windows are so bright, and look like eyes starring at her, but she doesn't have a care in the world...except for that shoe.

I have to agree with ~vcrimson Both are lovely for their own reasons. The first one is soft, hazy and dark~ more dreamy to me. The new revision is a little warmer and brighter. They give different feelings. You should play with these some more and do a collage of them conveying multiple moods. Just a thought...I think it could be very interesting..seeing as how successful you were with making one photo look like two different ones already. :cheers:

tought choice....they both work wonderfully individually for different reasons.....i don't think i can pic a favourite between the two, because they are such different images despite being the same! they both have very different feelings to them!

That is very interesting, apart from the pose being familiar, I wouldn't have guessed it was the same photo. I prefer the previous askepot, the blueish tones and the larger proportion of black areas in the frame are more appealing to my tastes