They didn't stay in one place. Have a small sticky spot on the bottom which is supposed to hold the insert in place. Between wearings, it slipped further into the shoe and when I tried to remove it, the spot came off the insert.

I have worn custom arch supports for 20 yrs. Some shoes cannot accomodate the bulk. I found the ECCO support at an outlet store and have been a fan ever since. Just ordered more. The men's is more supportive and fits my narrow shoe.However, a firmer metatarsal would be a big improvement. The soft material in them has to be replaced to be of any benefit. That is why I gave 4 stars.

I have used identical arch support insoles for at least 10 years. They work well in almost any shoe or boot. They are essential if a person has experienced plantar fasciitis or low arch pain. They are very durable and the leather seems to not absorb or emit any odor. Try them and you will have a half dozen pair soon. NOW if Ecco would please bring back their superb fisherman sandals, we would not have to fit these into other lesser sandals.