A direct comparision, no, Mafia II is much much better. The old one was good, back in the day, but the gameplay tweaks such as cover and much better aiming makes Mafia 2 better. It's not like Dragon Age where you can compare I and II and say I is still better.

A direct comparision, no, Mafia II is much much better. The old one was good, back in the day, but the gameplay tweaks such as cover and much better aiming makes Mafia 2 better. It's not like Dragon Age where you can compare I and II and say I is still better.