Derek Mooney: Lights, Camera, Inaction

As part of the hoopla to mark Leo Varadkar’s first year as Taoiseach, Fine Gael produced the nifty infographic (top) setting out some of the new leader’s biggest achievements.

The list offers an interesting insight into what the Taoiseach cares most about or, to be more accurate, what the Fine Gael pollsters tell him that his potential voters care most about.

Pride of place goes to the very frequently hyped national framework plan, Project Ireland 2040, followed by “Brexit Leadership” and the “8th Referendum”.

At the other end you find “and gardai” shoehorned into a claim about hiring more nurses and teachers, followed by curiously worded item on housing, though the word itself fails to make an appearance.

To avoid embarrassing Leo by putting a figure on the number of houses and apartments built over the past year, the copywriters had to come up with some phrasing that managed to convey the idea of progress, without breaching the standards in advertising code.

The result is this extraordinarily clunky and impersonal boast that:

“There were 4,700 exits from homelessness in 2017”.

“Exits”? If ever a single phrase summed up Orwell’s description of political language “… as giving an appearance of solidity to pure wind”, it is surely this.

It reads as if it came from the pen of someone who writes real estate ads. You know the ones, where “open plan apartment” means the bed is between the cooker and the lavatory and “close to nightlife” means the place is directly over an all-night, bikers’ bar.

No one even vaguely familiar with the presentation of political issues could have signed off on such a phrase. Some alternative wordings must have been considered, such as “families housed”, “homes built” or even the horrid stock civil service phrase “net reductions”.

The fact that these were rejected in favour of “exits” tells you what a tough task some poor Fine Gael wordsmith had trying to script anything even vaguely resembling an achievement on housing or tackling homelessness.

They knew they had to mention the issue somewhere on the list, so there the line sits. Not mentioning it would have caused a bigger outrage. That is the problem with a record like Leo’s, when it comes to housing not only are the statistics bad, they cannot even be trusted not to be worse.

Up to very recently the Government was claiming that 85,000 houses had been built between 2011 and 2017. In reality, as the CSO has recently confirmed, only 53,000 houses were built over that period. An over-estimate of 31,000. Meanwhile, nationwide between 2014 and 2017, local authorities only built 818 houses.

When it comes to the housing crisis there is no end to the bleak statistics. Over 9,500 people are homeless in Ireland today, over 3,500 of whom are children. Rents increased last year by 7.1%.
So why, with this being such a horrendous issue for Fine Gael, is Leo talking up the chances of there being a no confidence motion in his Housing Minister?

Well, because that is what today’s Fine Gael does. Gone are the days of Enda’s obfuscation and microphone dodging, Leo’s Fine Gael is now the party of high theatricality.

Every event, every issue, every announcement is approached as if it was a one-off scene in a theatre or movie production. The focus is not on the narrative or the plot, it is all about the staging and the positioning.

Since the judicious leaking of Leo’s comments at the Fine Gael party meeting, warning of a possible Sinn Féin motion of no confidence in Minister Eoghan Murphy that would see Fianna Fáil take a kicking, the focus has not been on the issue of housing but on the party politics of the issue of housing.

We are talking about housing while not talking about it. It is the perfect Fine Gael production. Lots of high drama, plenty of column inches and dozens of social media posts featuring pictures of Leo and Eoghan, but no content.

Not a single word about policy or actual outputs. At the end of the drama everyone is precisely in the same place as they were at the start. Nothing progresses. It’s lights, cameras and no bloody action.

But through it all, Leo gets what he wants. There is a little less public discussion of the substantial housing and cervical smear controversies. He positions himself as the man above the partisan political fray, not wanting an election but caught between the warring Fianna Fáil and Sinn Féin tribes.

And, in a piece of masterful timing, all of this just after a very well received visit to Northern Ireland and just before welcoming Jean Claude Juncker to Ireland for discussions in advance of the following week’s June EU summit on Brexit.

As political productions go, it was spot on. Well executed, beautifully timed and nicely played, but as with all cinematic and theatrical productions, the appearance should not be confused with reality.

The production crew who brought you last weeks’ no no-confidence motion spectacle also staged last November’s weekend long melodrama turned farce: The Saving of Frances – and that one did not turn out the way they had planned.

The worry is that this is all the FG crew has in store for us over the coming weeks and months, more and more productions and no governing. If so, then the election cannot come soon enough.

Yes, we do have Brexit looming on the horizon and there is an argument that we do not need a month or so of uncertainty at this critical juncture, but there is no major disagreement between the major parties on Brexit and anyway the negotiations are being led on a day to day basis by Barnier and his Brussels team with input from senior Irish officials.

A three-and-a-half week long, high octane campaign that results in a government team that is really prepared to govern, even if getting that government takes a few weeks of horse trading, is far preferable to a year or more of maximum quality, minimum content productions only timed for the next opinion poll.

Derek Mooney is a communications and public affairs consultant. He previously served as a Ministerial Adviser to the Fianna Fáil-led government 2004 – 2010. His column appears here every Tuesday Follow Derek on Twitter: @dsmooney

Post navigation

22 thoughts on “Derek Mooney: Lights, Camera, Inaction”

…in fairness…you seldom get any laughs in Derek weekly rants but he has surpassed himself this week…nice to see him spreading some of the vitriol he normally reserves for shinners to his partners in government…

FG have had over 7 years in government at this stage. The housing crisis is entirely of their own making. A free market, small government, obsession sooner or later bites you in the ass when essential services are ignored for the guts of a decade.

HA, nice article. It does indeed feel like this is a bumpy 4d experience. I can almost feel Leo spitting in my face as he blows smoke up my ass, quite a feat. At least my glasses were free….well my eye test was!

Meh…he’s about as effective/ineffective as most Irish Governments are. Our Governments are in a constant state of crisis management, pretty much like the previous Government, and the one before that, and the one before that. Irish polictics are mundane, uninspiring and have a tendancy to waffle, while living standards/ quality of life deteriorates and anxiety about homes and financial security go up.

I don’t think we’ve ever had a politician who became a politician because they wanted to help run the country well, or any kind of patriotic or honest reason. Each and every one of them just want to get in there, get the salary and pension and then do as little work as possible.

All his achievements have not happened
Homelessness ?
45000exit but 6000 plus enter
Brexit in ribbons
Health in a mess
And the crowning achievement the repeal of the eighth amendment has not happened yet
And after all the permitted objections are played out by an accommodating government maybe 50 years might be the time it takes to ensure no more savita’s
It amazes me blowing a trumpet for wishful thinking
I see the SCUnit is still operating in the background

How is Britain’s inability to agree what they want from their departure from the EU, their utter failure to consider the consequences of that departure, and the total incompetence of their negotiating team in any way the fault of the Irish government?

Ireland’s position, which is the same as the EU’s, has been consistent from day one.

How come no broadsheet contributor provide a solution. Homelessness is a problem, not a crisis. Providing homes, takes time, money and proper thought. You cannot build a home overnight (ignoring that half the people on here would object to soical housing beside them). Look at past mistakes in our cities – ghettos. The 8000 homeless people do not live in the one area.

“How come no broadsheet contributor provide a solution” – it is not their responsibility. it is the governments. if i was a plumber, and you called me to fix your toilet i wouldnt say “well why don’t you do it?”

“Providing homes, takes time, money and proper thought” – Fine Gael have been in government for 7 years. That’s a lot of time. As for money, they boast of the economy being in great nick. As for thought, that’s what is missing.

+1 Dr. Also, they can increase supply without them having to all be social housing. Homelessness, house prices & rent prices are all a result of insufficient supply. The only solution is to build more or compel those who can to build more.

That’s simply not true. Where are they going to be built? What about schools, roads, sewers, flooding. Its not that simple. Look at the likes previous social housing experiments, and what social disasters they have been.

If the Government really wanted to quickly build way more affordable housing then they would do some easy research and learn about 3D industrial printing. This is being used to create very low cost, highly insulated homes in Denmark, while being tested in many other EU countries and Canada. Modular home complexes are smart, use space very well, cost less to build, use less materials.
My guess is that they don’t want this type of building because it would rock the boat too much in the construction industry here, which has ridden the behinds of many Irish generations for years and stashed lots of cash in the Caymen Islands.

The Irish government built 52,000 social housing units in the 1950s, at a time when the country was in abject poverty. And with a far lower population base to house. Over 5,000 a year.

The Irish government built 2000 social housing units last year. If a much smaller, poorer, Ireland could build houses in that quantity 70 years ago our current wealthy Irish state can certainly solve the homelessness problem quite easily. FG just don’t want to.