Ex-inmates launch babies-behind-bars lawsuit

Mothers in prison could soon keep their newborns behind bars if a B.C. lawsuit succeeds.

Five years after Victoria cancelled the Mother-Child Program — claiming infants were being exposed to dangerous prison conditions — two ex-inmates in Maple Ridge’s Alouette Correctional Centre for Women launched a constitutional case in B.C. Supreme Court Monday.

“There was no reasoned basis for cancelling the program,” lawyer Geoffrey Cowper said. “The cancellation of the ACCW program (is) symptomatic of our collective disregard of our interest in helping these women care for their children, rather than making it impossible.

“The effects of separation of these women and their infants are visited even more unjustly on the babies who have committed no wrong, but have simply been born needing nurture and care.”

The plaintiffs are Patricia Block, 35, whose baby was removed by the Ministry of Children and Family Development when she was jailed in 2008, and Amanda Inglis, a 27-year-old aboriginal inmate.

As of May 22, there were 162 women in Inmates and B.C. Corrections custody, more than a third of them aboriginal. Since 2004, 34 have given birth in jail, with 22 of the new arrivals coming after the end of the Mother-Child Program.

A ministry spokesperson couldn’t comment on the lawsuit as it is before the courts.

Interveners from legal advocacy group West Coast Legal Education and Action Fund said separating mothers from their infants unfairly punishes both and has a negative impact on society.

“Most of us can relate to that fundamental relationship between the ability to parent and your sense of dignity,” said the group’s executive director Kasari Govender. “It’s hard to imagine a deeper violation of human rights.

“It’s like an additional punishment added, and it has huge ripple effects not just in that moment of being denied … but it also has impacts for the rest of that child’s life.”

About David P. Ball

I’m an enterprising & versatile reporter with more than 15 years of experience at Canada's most-read outlets — in online, daily print, magazine, photo, video and radio storytelling.

Most recently covering the politics beat for the Star Vancouver (The Toronto Star's B.C. bureau), my journalism has been recognized with three of Canada's top media awards and multiple nominations. I've had bylines in more than 40 publications, including the National Post, Globe & Mail, VICE, Toronto Star, The Province, New York Post, iPolitics, HuffPost, The Tyee, 24 Hours, Daily Mail UK, Ottawa Sun & several nonfiction anthologies.

CAJ Award-Winner & Multiple Finalist

Webster Award Award-Winner & Finalist

CJF Co-winner

Search my reporting:

Search

Published in 30+ publications, with a combined 10-million-plus readers: