Alexander Hamilton vs Thomas Jefferson

Alexander Hamilton and Thomas Jefferson had very different political views, which is why our first president, George Washington, had them both in his cabinet. Hamilton was the first Secretary of the Treasury, while Jefferson was the first Secretary of State.

These differences begin with who they thought should govern and what type of government was the best. Hamilton thought we should have a strong central government in the interests of commerce and industry, while having the national government in charge. However, Jefferson felt that the people should rule with a decentralized, agrian government in the terms of freedom and the people should rule themselves. They also had conflicting ideas for what economy suited us best, Hamilton believing it to be industrial and Jefferson believing the best was agricultural.

Along with those conflicts, they didn't agree with how the constitution was to be interpreted. Hamilton was a loose constructionist, wanting to stick closer to the thought of the central government ruling. Jefferson was a strict constructionist, believing that the constitution was to be followed closely.

Lastly, their difference in ideas helped formed political factions. They became two sides, the Federalists and the Antifederalists - or Republicans. Alexander Hamilton's side was the Federalists, they stood for the urban mercantile interests of the seaports. Thomas Jefferson's was the Republicans who represented the southern and rural interests. Alexander Hamilton and Thomas Jefferson had very different political views, which is why our first president, George Washington, had them both in his cabinet. Hamilton was the first Secretary of the Treasury, while Jefferson was the first Secretary of State.

These differences begin with who they thought should govern and what type of government was the best. Hamilton thought we should have a strong central government in the interests of commerce and industry, while having the national government in...

You May Also Find These Documents Helpful

...Hamiltonvs. Jefferson
During the Revolutionary- Federalist Era, politics, parties, programs, policies, and people made an enormous difference in how the new nation should be structured and run. During this era, two men in particular championed politics and their respective parties. These two men were AlexanderHamilton, a Federalist, and ThomasJefferson, a Democratic-Republican. Both Hamilton and Jefferson were successful college educated intellectuals and politicians who made significant contributions to the development of the United States policies and programs. However Hamilton, despite never being elected President, had more influence over the development of the United States’ policies and programs during the Revolutionary-Federalist Era. Historically Hamilton and Jefferson are known for agreeing to disagree over just about every policy being discussed during the establishment of government structure, and decorum. And it is Hamilton’s policies on economics, government structure, and constitution interpretation, which took precedent over Jefferson’s.
Hamilton and Jefferson both understood the importance of a Nations economic success and its direct relationship to its government’s strength. However, both developed two economic plans completely opposite the other....

...ThomasJefferson and AlexanderHamiltonJefferson and Hamilton’s ideas and ideals differ about economics. The Jefferson and Hamilton debate changed a nation in the early stages of development. Hamilton’s economic plan for the nation included establishing a national bank like that in England to maintain public credit. All of Hamilton’s arguments would strengthen the federal government’s power at the expense of the states. Jefferson and his political party opposed these reforms. Jefferson feared that the bank of the United States represented too much English influence and Jefferson argued that the constitution did not give congress the power to establish a bank. ThomasJefferson and the Democratic- Republican Party emerged as complete opposites of AlexanderHamilton and the Federalist Party. Contrasting ideas about paying the debt, English influence and the supporting sides show their polar opposition.
The first contrasting ideal between Jefferson and Hamilton was paying off the American national debt that was left after the Revolutionary War. Jefferson’s belief about paying off the debt was a belief that the nation’s future must not lay with the Federalist bankers and merchants but with plain Democratic- Republican farm folk to be labors to the...

...important men. AlexanderHamilton, the leader of the Federalist Party, and ThomasJefferson, the leader of the new Democratic Republicans, shared many different visions for the future of America, stemming back from their days on George Washington's cabinet. As the country flourished, and these two became leaders of America's political parties, their views on foreign policy, the federal government versus state governments, and economic policies contrasted even more.
The national government was just beginning to work well, and after the ratification of the Constitution, the state and local governments still very strong. Hamilton, a lax Constitutionalist, wanted an organized strong central government, fearing anarchy without a central power. He felt one strong government would be able to deal with national problems much more efficiently than many state and local governments, in which strong divisions might arise. Jefferson wanted things to stay the way they were with the state and local governments in charge, fearing another monarchy. This caused him to become a strict Constitutionalist. By doing carefully analyzing the Constitution, Jefferson would be able to see any loopholes in it, allowing the state laws to override the federal laws.
Jefferson and Hamilton also did not agree on foreign policy. During the beginnings of the French Revolution both...

...Research Paper: Jeffersonvs. HamiltonThomasJefferson and AlexanderHamilton were two very influential people with very different ideals. With land inherited from his father, Jefferson set himself up as a Virginia tobacco farmer. Once established as a planter, Jefferson entered Virginia politics. As a politician, he did not have the ability to make rousing speeches. Instead, Jefferson spoke eloquently through his writing. His words in the Declaration of Independence and other writings are still admired today. Since Hamilton had no money or family connections to help him rise in the world, he made his way on ability, ambition, and charm. George Washington noticed Hamilton’s talents in the early stages of the Revolutionary War. Washington made Hamilton his “aide-de-camp”, also known as a personal assistant. Near the end of the Revolution, Hamilton helped his cause by marrying Elizabeth Schuyler. She was born into one of New York’s most powerful families. With her family’s political background, after the war was over, Hamilton was elected to represent New York in Congress . Later, he served as a delegate from New York to the Constitutional Convention . Although they had different upbringings, the two had huge influences on the upbringing of the United States....

...Hamiltonvs. Jefferson and Their Oppositions
Jennifer Maine
American History to 1865: AMH2010-08
February 22, 2013
The country of the United States had many contributing factors to become what it is today. There are two important people that pushed against each other so much when America started, that they helped to shape the United States towards what it has become. AlexanderHamilton and ThomasJefferson were such different people that they could not help but challenge each other to be the best they could. This led them to do their best work for our country, even if it was only to show the other who was right. Together, they contributed to providing the foundation for the American political system. Their policies and influences shaped the development of the new republic. Many times they disagreed, but this only helped our first officials to see that they should consider all sides if they were to run this new country. Hamilton and Jefferson were a great pain to each other, yet a great help to our country.
AlexanderHamilton, to start with, helped settle the dispute between the Virginia Plan and the New Jersey Plan by coming up with the Connecticut Compromise. He said that not only should the larger states be in control, but the people who could retain money were responsible enough to run the government....

...ThomasJefferson and AlexanderHamilton
Lily Dugas
3 Hour
3/2/11
In the making of America, there were many different opinions on government. Two of the most opinionated people were AlexanderHamilton and ThomasJefferson. They both had very strong voices and were looked up to by many people. They always seemed to disagree with each other; they didn’t have the same ideas on the American government at all.
AlexanderHamilton was born on January 11, 1755 on the island of Nevis in the West Indies. His father was James Hamilton, a Scottish Merchant, and his mother was Rachael Fawcette Levine. During his adolescence, he served as a clerk and apprentice. Eventually he was enrolled in the Grammar school in Elizabeth Town, New Jersey. During the Revolutionary War, he helped greatly, teaming up with Washington for 4 years. Later, Hamilton was voted a member into the Continental Congress. While Washington was President, he became the first Secretary of Treasury.
ThomasJefferson was born on April 14, 1743, in Shadwell, Virginia. His father was Peter Jefferson, a successful surveyor and...

...post-revolutionary war period of the Unites States saw the establishment of the first party system and an enlarging gap in viewpoints between the wealthy and the common man. One might argue that a political party develops in response to a series of controversial issues yet to a great extent the contradictory views of AlexanderHamilton and ThomasJefferson over issues related to views of government, the role of government and social philosophy in foreign and domestic affairs, were primarily responsible for shaping the rise of political parties from 1783-1800.
Originally feared by the forefathers, the rise of political parties emerged from intense ideological struggles over views of government between two political leaders important to President Washington’s Cabinet, AlexanderHamilton as Secretary of the Treasury and ThomasJefferson as Secretary of State. AlexanderHamilton exerted the most influence within the newly emerging Federalist Party. He believed that only an enlightened ruling class could produce a strong, stable and effective federal government. The government therefore needed the support of wealthy men and the promotion of manufacturing interests. ThomasJefferson and the Republicans defended more the rights of the common man and an agrarian society with limited power from the federal...

...O’Shea
US History
November 29, 2012
JeffersonVs. Hamilton
During the years after the Revolutionary War, the founding fathers introduced a very weak form of government through the Articles of Confederation. These articles were created to give more power to the states than the federal government. Eventually, the Constitutional Convention was called to edit the Articles of Confederation, but the members of this convention completely gutted the documents. This led to the development of a very important document of United States history. Thus, the Constitution was born. This new document sparked mass controversy amongst the states and led to a huge debacle. The federalist states supported the Constitution; whereas, the anti-federalists did not approve of the ratification of the Constitution. Soon after the 9 to 13 ratification of the Constitution, the leaders of the federalists and anti-federalists emerged. The federalists were headed by AlexanderHamilton, the county’s treasurer; and, the anti-federalists were led by ThomasJefferson. Due to their contrasting backgrounds, stern differences in political ideals, and different economic priorities, Hamilton and Jefferson quickly formed a huge two-partied rivalry in the United States that eventually led to a gigantic schism in American politics.
ThomasJefferson and...