HONORABLE MENTION: Most Confusing - Mayim Bialik

Hate this Oliver Tolentino gown cause she looks like an extra in the prom episode of Square Pegs…but that's also why we love it?! Its schoolmarmish qualities (ugh, that coif) are offset by its new-wave cobalt hue. On, say, Charlize Theron, this would look perfectly humdrum, but Mayim brings a depth to it. On the fence.