I used to edit Innovation Management. My book, "The Elastic Enterprise", co-authored with Nick Vitalari and described as a must read for companies that want to succeed in the new era of business - looks at how stellar companies have gone beyond innovation to a new form of wealth creation. I speak on new innovation paradigms.
I started my writing career in broadcasting and then got involved in the EU's attempt to create an ARPA-type unit, where I managed downstream satellite application pilots, at just the time commercial satellite services entered the market. I also wrote policy, pre the Web, on broadband applications, 3G (before it was invented), and Wired Cities.
I have written for many major outlets like the Wall St Journal, Times, HBR, and GigaOm, as well as producing TV for the BBC, Channel 4 and RTE. I am a research fellow at the Center For Digital Transformation at UC Irvine, where I am also an advisory board member, advisory board member at Crowdsourcing.org and Fellow of the Society for New Communications Research.
Google.com/haydn

The Technology That Could Put Apple Back On Top

Apple is in need of a boost for the iPhone. With an update expected in the Fall, most of the attention has focused on the new iOS 7 operating system. No doubt iOS 7 will spur innovation, but people need to see a better phone. The iconic AppleApple device has slipped behind rivals like Samsung and HTCHTC, and maybe even SonySony‘s new Experia. Help is at hand, though.

By popular consensus the display on the iPhone and the display on its main competitor, the Samsung S4, are on a par. But they have different virtues. The Retina is crisp and precise as well as bright. The AMOLED on the S4 has a much richer color gamut. The difference in these virtues though is profound. Color is an essential part of the consumer experience and LCD screens, like the Retina, cannot compete with the rich colors of OLED. Until now.

3M3M‘s Optical Systems Division, and nanotech partner Nanosys, are finally bringing their QDEF, color enhancement technology to LCD displays, an advance that promises a 50% increase in the color experienced by users. The technology is twenty years in the making and was expected to be on the market in 2011.

The launch was announced back in May and the technology is now beginning to get traction across the smartphone, advertising and TV markets. The technology could be exactly the boost that Apple needs to draw the Retina ahead of the S4 (though it is worth noting that Samsung has just released an LCD version of the S4 – the Active).

QuantumQuantum Dot Enhancement Film, to give it its full name, is created by cultivating nano-sized crystals. Jeff Yurek, Product Marketing Manager at Nanosys, explains: “We use an electro-chemical process to grow crystals to between 2 and 12 nanometers, less than the size of a virus. The amazing thing about these materials is at the nano scale they have very different qualities. The size of the crystal determines a different color.” He quotes deeper reds as one stand-out example of the effect of QDEF. The technology also makes the displays more energy efficient.

Nanosys is an American success story. Founded 12 years ago, and still in an extended start-up phase, the basic technology used by the company comes with patents from luminary American research institutions like MIT and Harvard. Those patents go back to the 1990s.

“A new material can take up to twenty years to bring to market,” Jeff says. “That’s about the timescale we’re on”.

QDEF is packaged into LCD back panel films by 3M, who are currently ramping up production. The expectation is that smartphone makers will have the new color displays in the shops by Christmas, according to John.

“We have samples out with every one of them,” John tells me. “The evidence is, once people experience better color, they don’t go back. There’s an opportunity here for differentiation by being first into the market.” Apple is among the companies assessing QDEF.

The technology allows for a simple swap-out, swap-in on the production line. LCD manufacturers take out a diffusion film in the back panel and drop the QDEF in its place. It means a cost increase that Nanosys describe as marginal and 3M describe as a few percentage points.

Combined with the Retina, it should make for an awesome display. And the new color possibilities make Jony Ive’s new design for iOS 7 seem more astute. Apple’s old design would look confusing if color were the main virtue of the display. By clearing away visual clutter by going for flatter and whiter screens, the colors get a better chance of doing their job – enhancing consumer experience.

But the next generation LCD display also presents challenges for Apple. It will want to put its own stamp on the technology and if that takes too much time, Apple risks being a follower not a leader. It doesn’t need to go with QDEF, as there are competing options out there, but those are some way back from market. If it doesn’t move on display quality in the short term then it could look like a serious laggard. If it does then the Retina could be the standout display on the market.

And that brings us to the big complication. Samsung Ventures are an investor in Nanosys, so QDEF could bring further complexity to the Apple, Samsung relationship. More than that though, as I mentioned above, Samsung has now launched an LCD version of the S4. Popped up with QDEF technology, it is going to be considerably enhanced by the end of the year, leaving the iPhone in its trail unless Apple acts quickly. Having said that, there’s no reason why this technology should not put Apple back on top, with an awesome display, great color experience and an OS to do it justice.

Post Your Comment

Post Your Reply

Forbes writers have the ability to call out member comments they find particularly interesting. Called-out comments are highlighted across the Forbes network. You'll be notified if your comment is called out.

just got iphone 5 after 2 years with samsung galaxy 2. I have to say when it comes to ease of use my old galaxy has it hands down. there are so many things I find extrodinarily more difficult (and downright IMPOSSIBLE) than they should be on the iphone. color enhancement is smoke and mirrors when it comes to a tech device. if it isn’t easy to use it’s not practical or worth the time. i have 2 years on my contract with this phone. I’m sure there will be major advances in both in that time and I will be watching MUCH more closely.

The interpretation I get from “It sells the S4″ is that people are buying the S4 because it displays inaccurate over saturated colors on the AMOLED screen.

Yes, Day-glow colors do attract the eye, but it works against the S4 user when they want to take or view photos.

The colors you see on the display should be accurate and consistent with reality. Taking a photo that looks one way on the S4 display and very different on a color accurate computer monitor, HDTV, or sharing the photo with others, is NOT a feature… it’s a bug.

Well if we only get one third of what we are capable of seeing, how can they be consistent with reality? Anyway pose his question as I have tried to do in the post – would the iPhone be a better product with richer colors?

You’ve got an answer to everything, don’t you Shaughnessy? Why don’t you do a little basic research on the subject you’re trying to write about so you can at least claim to be an intelligent interlocutor …

My two biggest screen requirements are size and pixel density. You use your screen 100% of the time you use your phone. Assuming pixel densities are close or the same, a 5 inch screen is vastly easier to see and use than a 4 inch screen. Unless you have tiny fingers, even the typing is noticeably easier.

For all the other stuff like color, I could really care less. If you hold two screens beside each other, I might like the color or display properties of one over the other, but send me off with just one, and in 5 minutes, I won’t even notice a difference.