A New Poll Has A Democrat In Much Better Shape Than Everyone Thought, And Conservatives Say It's 'Bogus'

Brett LoGiurato, provided by

Published 11:33 am, Wednesday, April 23, 2014

The conventional wisdom in Washington holds that Sen. Mark Pryor, a Democrat from Arkansas, is perhaps the most vulnerable incumbent senator in the country. He is relatively unpopular in his state, he supports the Affordable Care Act, and he's facing a rising star of a Republican challenger in Rep. Tom Cotton.

Kristol's main problem with the poll comes in a subset of the data showing 32% of the survey's respondents did not vote in 2012. Of those who voted in 2012 and responded to the poll, 27% said they voted for Republican presidential candidate Mitt Romney, and 26% said they voted for President Barack Obama. The actual 2012 vote split in Arkansas was 61-37 in favor of Romney.

He wasn't alone in his skepticism. Others noted their suspicions with the poll's data — but Huffington Post polling editor Mark Blumenthal points out Kristol is wrong when he asserts the "whole point" of the data subsection in question is to "provide a reality test for the sample." There's also a well-known bias toward the victor in post-election surveys, as the NYT's Nate Cohn explains. And the sample that reported not voting so heavily for Romney (general adults) is not the same as the sample who reported their Senate preferences (registered voters).

The poll does contain a couple of warning signs for Pryor, however. Though his approval rating split sits at a positive 47-38, it's below the traditional comfort-level threshold of 50 percent for incumbents. And 52 percent of Arkansans say they will not vote for a candidate who doesn't share their views on Obamacare — a question, though, that is more ambiguous than it sounds.

In addition to Arkansas, the poll surveys close Senate races in North Carolina, Kentucky, and Louisiana. However, overall, the poll shows a favorable political climate for Republicans. In spite of these encouraging signs for conservatives, the GOP needs a net gain of six seats to take back control of the Senate, and flipping Arkansas is key on the path to takeover.

Some of the other highlights from the polls:

Sen. Kay Hagan, the Democratic incumbent from North Carolina, appears much more vulnerable than Pryor. She leads anticipated Republican challenger Thom Tillis, the Republican state House speaker, by just a 42-40 margin. Her approval-to-disapproval split is an even 44-44, a more dangerous level than Pryor.

Sen. Mary Landrieu, the Democratic incumbent from Louisiana, starts out with an early lead over a large field of Republican challengers. It will likely take a runoff to determine who will get Louisiana's Senate seat.

In Kentucky, Senate Minority Leader Mitch McConnell is in a dead heat with Democratic challenger Alison Lundergan Grimes. He leads only 44-43 in the poll. McConnell's approval rating, which sits at only 40 percent, makes him extremely vulnerable. But Obama is more unpopular in Kentucky than in any of the other states, with only 32 percent approving of his job performance.