Rohan wrote:Yes, Bonds , then Helton have no argument, will contribute to 6 out of 8 excluding 3b and RBIs.

Guess I misread your question, sorry about that. I would take Edmonds over Jeter because he isn't all that far behind Helton in production since he came to STL. He is a stud in R,RBI,HR,OPS and very strong in BA and 2B.

As far as injury goes Edmonds and Bonds are bothl somewhat of an injury risk. Although Edmonds has played in more games in the last 3 years than Jeter and Bonds is only slightly behind.