It’s been a while since I’ve taken Stats, but this is almost probably close to accurate.

Fact 6: Better battle worlds

Cards floating down from the sky? That’s thematically sound as fuck.

Madoka had like cake worlds and shit. Lame.

Fact 8: An emotional connection to the viewer

Macross simply connects with its audience better than Madoka ever could. For me, it managed to cross the full gamut of the human experience in the first episode alone. Some of the emotions I experienced were:

Surprise that the trailer I had watched was not an accurate representation of the show.

Sadness that there was still more of the episode to go.

Fear that the episode would not end.

Happiness when I hit the ED and knew it was almost ever.

Anger when the episode finally ended and I realized there were 11 more to go.

I don’t think Madoka made me feel anything but a desire to look up doujins. And according to Wikipedia, that ain’t a human emotion. Point to Macross.

Hell, I even found myself communicating with the show much more often than I did for Madoka.

“Please, for the love of god, don’t!” – Dark_Sage

Macross with the sweep.

Verdict: Macross wins.

And that’s why I don’t have to eat my words for saying this show would be good.

Pfft.
1) Everyone knows magic lesbian wings are high-tier.
2) I carefully watched the first two episodes of ManlycardCross Revolution and there was only one vague outline of wings at the beginning! In contrast HappyjoyMagica Rebellion had not just one but two sets of magic lesbian wings and one was all shining and shit also which is -4 to THAC0.
3) Eclairs are delicious.
4) Your arguments are all invalid.