Edging Away from Cruel Eggs: Part 1 - California’s Prop 2

My Hipster
Hens live the good life. They have plenty of space to move around—each bird has
9-10 square feet of coop space, they can go outside every day as long as the
weather allows it, and “outside” is either the spacious “hen pen” or the half-acre
chicken run. Both the run and the pen
have plenty of dirt for scratching and lots of trees for shade. Both coops have ample roosting space, plenty
of nest boxes and a large container of sand for dust bathing. The birds get free choice commercial chicken
feed, grit, and oyster shell as well as some scratch grain every night as a
treat and all the garden waste and kitchen scraps that I’ve got.

The Hipster Hens - July 2014

The typical
laying hen living on a factory farm is a whole different story.About 75% of all egg laying hens live in
battery cages.Each cage holds a huge bunch
of hens.By law, a hen only has to be given
67 square inches of floor space.A
standard sheet of printer paper is 93.5 square inches, so if you imagine a hen
sitting on that sheet of paper, she doesn’t even get the whole sheet.The caged hen can’t do any of the things
chickens naturally do—no dust-bathing, scratching in the dirt, or nest
building.In fact, the cage is so
crowded the hen can’t even manage to flap her wings or turn around.What can she do? Well, she can stick her head between the bars
of the cage to get food and water, she can lays eggs—right where she stands (they
roll down the slanted wire floor to a conveyor), she can poop, and that falls
through the wire floor onto the rows of cages below her, just as the poop from
the cages above her rain down on her, and basically she can stand in one place
for her whole life. From the hen’s point
of view, the world outside her cage consists of rows and rows of other cages
that fill up a cavernous, windowless barn.The air is filled with the stench and ammonia of accumulating manure,
and the sounds of thousands of other chickens.

She and her
cage mates are always stressed due to their living conditions and crowding,
and the stress and crowding make them more prone to diseases such as avian
influenza (stay tuned for a post on bird flu). Not surprisingly, crowding compels
the hens to peck each other a lot. To
prevent pecking injuries every hen has the end of her beak cut off when she is
still a baby chick. “Beak trimming” is
done without anesthetics and not only is it intensely painful for the baby
chick, but it causes chronic pain for the rest of the hen’s life. A hen, after a season of laying eggs, needs
to molt in order to renew her feathers. Since
hens don’t lay eggs during their molt and since not all of the hens in a flock
molt at exactly the same time, it creates annoying imprecision in the
well-oiled machine that is the factory farm.
So the hens are forced to molt simultaneously by manipulating the light,
by withholding water, and by starving them.
When the second season is drawing to an end, to avoid another molt and
another period of lagging egg production, the entire flock is slaughtered. Thus, after about two years, a hen’s life
ends and she is turned into dog food.

Battery Cages (Maqi~commonswiki)

These are
the basic facts of the egg industry and it is both appropriate and important that everyone
who eats eggs is aware of them. If some of
the practices sound cruel to you, that’s because they are. But having said that, I think that we all
also need to acknowledge this truth:
Factory farmed chickens are a business.
Egg companies expect to make a profit, and they do whatever necessary to
stay competitive. The factory farm
battery cage system that I’ve just described is a sterling model of efficiency
that produces the cheapest eggs possible for the least amount of capital
invested. My chickens, on the other
hand, are a money losing
proposition. I sell a few eggs to
friends, but the money generated by egg sales is a fraction of my
expenses. I’m in the chicken business
for the fun of it, and the Hipster Hens provide me with an abundance of joy and
gratification. But as a business model
it’s ridiculous.

But here’s
the other important truth we also need to never lose sight of: The battery cage model of egg production depends
on the torture of living, sentient creatures.
As
Andrew Lawler points out in “Why Did the Chicken Cross the World?” “You don’t
have to be vegan to wonder if it is right to put another entire species in
perpetual pain in order to satisfy a craving for chicken salad and deviled
eggs.” So here’s the question: Is there
a middle ground somewhere between my happy Hipster Hens and the abused battery
caged hens? Is there some sort of
compromise situation where hens can be humanely and ethically treated and the
egg company can still make a profit?

As someone
who takes time to read this blog, I’m sure that you agree with the majority of
consumers (58%) who, according to a survey conducted by Public Opinion
Strategies, would be willing to pay more for eggs that are labeled “humanely
raised.” The majority of voters in
California (63.5%) had similar sentiments in 2008 when they voted in favor of
Proposition 2. Proposition 2 created a
new state law that would prohibit “the confinement of farm animals in a manner
that does not allow them to turn around freely, lie down, stand up, or fully
extend their limbs.” Other states had
previously voted to eliminate crates for pigs and calves, but this was the
first legislation to end the abuse of chickens.

Proposition
2 finally went into effect in 2015 and once in place, it has had a huge impact
not just in California, but in the entire country. This year, we’ve seen almost continuous announcements
by national retailers and restaurants that they will no longer use eggs from
hens in battery cages. Some of these
companies include Starbucks, Burger King, Subway, Kraft Heinz, and Unilever (the
maker of Hellmann's Mayonnaise). Recently
MacDonald’s, which uses over two billion eggs per year, made the switch. Don’t assume the battle is over, but it has
been a hard fight—both before and after the California vote—just to get to
where we are.

The run-up
to the 2008 vote saw intense campaigning by both proponents and opponents of
the proposition. Proponents argued that it
was cruel to confine any animal in a cage that was barely big enough for its
body, that better conditions for our food-producing animals would result in
better health for us, that standards to raise chickens humanely would allow
those farmers already operating humanely to be more competitive, and that if
all egg producers had humane practices, the scale would cause the price to go
down. The primary contributor to the “Vote
Yes” campaign was the Humane Society of the United Stateswhich contributed over 4 million dollars.
Here’s a typical
ad run by the “Vote Yes” people.

Opponents of
Proposition 2 argued that uncaged production methods were more expensive and
would cause the cost of eggs to go up, that uncaged chickens would be more
prone to predator attacks, and that the costs and regulations resulting from
Prop 2 going into effect would put California producers out of business because
their prices would be undercut by producers in Mexico and other states not
subject to the Prop 2 regulations. The
big contributors to the “Vote No” campaign were, not surprisingly, the big egg producing
companies. The top contributor was Cal-Maine Foods, which is currently
the largest producer and distributor of eggs in the U.S. and the world. Here’s an ad run by the “Vote
No” coalition.

The success
of Prop 2 in 2008 did not mean an immediate victory for California’s abused
hens. The proposition itself dictated
that the new laws would not take effect until 2015, and of course, once the
vote was in, a whole bunch of lawyers immediately began to construct a whole
bunch of law suits. After the 2008 vote, Prop 2 still had a
long rocky road to travel before the 2015 implementation. I’ll tell that story in my next post.

Translate

About Me

Privacy Policy

Randy’s Chicken Blog doesn’t share personal information with third parties or store any information about your visit other than to analyze and optimize your content and reading experience through the use of cookies.

You can turn off the use of cookies at any time by changing your specific browser settings.

Randy’s Chicken Blog is not responsible for republished content from this blog on other blogs or websites without permission.

This privacy policy is subject to change without notice and was last updated on November 13, 2016. If you have any questions feel free to contact me directly.

Whew! I think that pretty much covers it!

Disclosure Statement

Starting November 17, 2016, an advertising program Google Adsense began to run on my blog. Your clicks on the ads shown on the blog don’t cost you anything but may result in a small commission for Randy’s Chicken Blog. While Google has guaranteed that the ads placed on my site will be relevant, I don’t have a great deal of control over which ads are displayed. I’ll do my best to block any content that goes against my values or that I believe to be questionable.

On November 27, 2016, Randy’s Chicken Blog became a participant in the Amazon Services LLC Associates Program, an affiliate advertising program designed to provide a means for sites to earn advertising fees by advertising and linking to Amazon. If you click on a sponsored Amazon link and make a purchase Randy’s Chicken Blog may receive a small commission. Again, this costs you nothing, but it allows me and the Hipster Hens a little pocket change.

Mission Statement

Hi! I’m Randy and this is my chicken blog. I write it, edit it, take the pictures, feed the chickens, hug the chickens, etc. I blog because a few years ago, I got these chickens…I had no idea when I got my first chickens that I would get attached to them and become this sentimental, crazy old chicken guy. I had no idea that each chicken would have its own personality, that chickens had such a huge range of vocalizations that they literally “talk” to each other, that they have this amazing, intricate social structure, or that there would be so much drama in the coop—love, conflict, friendship, sex, motherhood, anxiety—a virtual soap opera playing out before my eyes every day.

So I write these little vignettes about my birds that are mostly whimsical but also mostly true. In the process of telling my stories I also pass along a variety of views and opinions which are completely my own. Please also bear in mind that the information I share regarding my care of my chickens has come from my experience caring for my flock. I’m not a veterinarian and I have had no formal education in any kind of chickenology.

There are a few facts that I hope to get across to anybody who regularly reads my blog:

1.My chickens are really cool.

2.All chickens are really cool.

3.The majority of chickens being raised for meat or egg production, in spite of their inherent coolness, are treated cruelly. You can help make changes by your purchasing habits. Educate yourself! Read labels! Check company websites!