This blog presents news items and resources relating to trial advocacy and the legal system, with a focus on Washington State. It was developed to support the Trial Advocacy Program at the University of Washington School of Law, but now has a broader coverage and a wider audience. In addition to information about trials and trial practice, you'll find notes about appellate practice, the courts, access to justice, and related topics.

Saturday, July 13, 2013

Witness in Zimmerman Case Testifies by SkypeTwo problems arise with the new technology: The witness's testimony in this case was interrupted by pranksters; and appearing via Skype may violate the constitutional right to face your accuser. Weekend Edition Saturday host Scott Simon talks with attorney John Hutchins about using Skype in criminal cases.

3 comments:

Aside from the two problems listed, there are problems inherent with the witness not being physically in the room, as Hutchins stated.

This isn't just a legal issue, it's an emotional and personal one. When a witness (or anyone) is communicating with someone in person, the emotional appeal and personal attachment to the message or the context of the message is much stronger than over any other line of communication; that is, the emotional impact of a story is stronger in person. One wonders how a jury would perceive the same exact testimony had it been done in person, and if there's enough of a difference to change the course of a court case.