Yesterday we reviewed why the iPhone 4s is a worthy update to the iPhone 4. Today we offer an alternative view and discuss why the iPhone 4s might not be worth an upgrade for some users.

As Apple’s iPhone event wound down yesterday, many people were hoping Tim Cook would pull out Steve Jobs famous line, “One more thing,” and introduce the iPhone 5 that so many of us were anticipating.

That line never came, and we were left with the iPhone 4S as the new Apple phone. Some people were fine with the announcement, but others, who had been waiting for a new form factor and a bigger screen, were left disappointed. As soon as that iPhone 4S flashed on the screen in Cupertino, Apple stock dropped 2%. Twitter exploded with tweets from angry Apple fans, and message board entries displayed the dissatisfaction of receiving an iPhone 4S instead of an iPhone 5.

The iPhone 4S is a significant upgrade to the iPhone 4, just as the 3GS was a much faster version of the 3G. But here’s the problem: The iPhone 4 design is 16 months old. It’s stale. It’s boring. We’re used to Apple giving us faster, thinner, sleeker devices on a regular basis. Every other iPhone release was in the month of June or July, with an update coming every year.

The iPhone 4S marks the first fall release, and it was a reasonable assumption that since an upgrade took 16 months instead of 12, something big was coming. And Apple scheduled a big event. The iPhone 4S announcement plus the news that the iPod Touch now comes in white was not big at all. People would be less disappointed if Apple hadn’t made such a hubbub about an incremental upgrade.

Beside the iPhone 4, the iPhone 4S is a decent upgrade. It features an improved camera, an A5 dual-core processor, dual-core graphics, and faster downloading speeds. But beside other top of the line Android phones (Samsung Galaxy S II, Motorola Droid Bionic, HTC Titan), the iPhone 4S is nearly outdated.

Those phones all have faster processors and more memory. The Galaxy S II beats or equals the iPhone 4S in almost every category, from display technology and display size to battery and weight. The only thing the iPhone 4S stands out for is its significant internal storage, display resolution, and media playback time, but it really falls behind on processing speed, memory, and display size. The iPhone 4 is 3.5 inches, while other top of the line phones from Apple’s competitors all feature 4”+ screens.

Where’s the innovation? Where’s the blow-your-mind designs that Apple is famous for? The designs that every other manufacturer tries to emulate? This is a barely competitive phone that looks exactly like a phone that we’ve been using for 16 months. It’s hardly worth an upgrade.

My iPhone 4 works fine. It’s sufficiently speedy, the camera is fine for Twitter pictures, and while Siri is cool, I’m not enthralled with the idea of speaking to my phone. The iPhone 4S might be moderately faster, but it doesn’t entice me to buy the iPhone 4S at this point.

If you have an iPhone 3GS or earlier model, then the 4S is definitely a huge upgrade that’s worth a new contract. Go for it, get the iPhone 4S and revel in the amazing speed increase and retina graphics. Likewise, if you’re a Sprint customer, you will be awed by the splendor of an iPhone. It’s a must have, especially compared to the other lackluster phones that Sprint offers.

If you have an iPhone 4, this is an upgrade you should probably skip. The iPhone 4S is faster, but the screen size and resolution are the same. With iOS 5, you’re getting the same software, and the touted network speed advantage is only a minor increase that’s not 4G. The only feature you won’t have access to is Apple’s new built-in personal assistant, Siri.

The iPhone 4 will last at least another year, and a mid-season upgrade will lock you into a new contract, making you ineligible for an upgrade during a summer or fall 2012 iPhone 5 release. Many of you who purchased an iPhone 4 at release, like I did, will soon be eligible for an upgrade. But purchasing an iPhone 4S within the next few months will mean you’re not eligible for another phone until April of 2013 or even later (at least, with carriers in the U.S.). And that means no shiny new iPhone 5 for you when it comes out, unless you’re willing to pay the non-subsidized price, which is pretty hefty.

I won’t be upgrading. The iPhone 4S doesn’t have enough to offer, so I’m going to hold out and hope that Apple bounces back and releases a phone that’s truly innovative rather than a rehash of an old product.

Are you going to upgrade to the 4S, or stick with your current phone? What’s your reasoning? Let us know in the comments.

Add comment

iPadaccessories Reviews

iPad Mini Details starting to emerge! Friday, 05 October 2012 News of the iPad Mini launch is heating up! We will be launching the new product line just as soon as products are available. In the meantime, check out this video from our friends at CNet! ... Read more...

Wednesday, 19 September 2012 If Indiana Jones, John Wayne, and the Dos Equis’ Most Interesting Man in the World teamed up- Saddleback would be the company born from their combined manlinesses. Saddleback Leather Co makes what can honestly be called the best quality and most...

Great iPad 3 cases on Amazon! Friday, 14 September 2012 While the iPad 2 and iPad 3 are nearly identical in form factor, they are different enough that some cases are not directly compatible. These tend to be form fitting cases and skins while folio cases and sleeves usually have enough play in the fit... Read more...

New iPhone 5 announced Wednesday, 12 September 2012 It’s been 27 months since the launch of a new iPhone platform and today Apple debuted its latest smartphone. Claiming it is the world’s thinnest to date! iPhone 5 has a larger screen and weighs 112 grams, or about 4 ounces – 20% lighter... Read more...

iPad Mini Poll and Rumor Roundup- Vote Now! Monday, 20 August 2012 September is almost upon us and Apple’s big event is nearly here. The rumor mill is literally churning with new rumors about the iPhone 5 and the elusive iPad Mini. iPad Mini case and cover designs are already surfacing, a couple parts may or may... Read more...

Poetic Hardback iPad 3 Case Review Friday, 17 August 2012 “To find a good iPad cover, is as hard as finding a lover,” said the Poetic HardBack iPad3 case. It has a beautiful folding cover made of a soft cleansing microfiber interior lining that will serve both as a slip and scratch preventer. The back tray... Read more...

Toyota Creatures YetYet and Robotto iPad Toys Monday, 13 August 2012 This just in: Kids love iPads. In other news- water is wet. Yes, it seems the new parenting tool of choice these days is the iPad. How do you quiet a wailing child? Why, how about some cute videos and angry birds! iPad toys are all the rage now,... Read more...

Adonit Jot Touch Review Monday, 13 August 2012 Adonit has done-it! They have finally released their much anticipated pressure sensitive iPad stylus! The Adonit Jot Touch is here people, it’s the world’s smartest stylus, and the world is better for it! The iPad is a powerful device, and it’s a... Read more...

iLounge Reviews

Using Find My iPhone from a PC or Mac Tuesday, 09 October 2012 Q: I have the Find My iPhone App on my iPhone and can use it from my iPhone, but I would like to know how to use it from my computer. It doesn’t do me any good to use it if I know where my iPhone already is. - Darlene A: Although there is no... Read more...

Taking Right-to-Left Panoramic Photos | iLounge Tips Tuesday, 09 October 2012 If you have an iPhone 4S or iPhone 5 you can take advantage of a new iOS 6 feature that allows you to capture panoramic photos without the need to resort to third-party apps. The feature is only available for shooting in portrait orientation and can... Read more...

Monday, 08 October 2012 In preparation for the November 1st release of iLounge’s 2013 iPhone + iPod Buyers’ Guide, we are opening voting today for our annual Readers’ Choice Awards. In the short, four-question survey, you’ll have the opportunity to vote for Apple’s top...

Happy Columbus Day + Canadian Thanksgiving! Monday, 08 October 2012 Our editors are celebrating Columbus Day and the Canadian Thanksgiving holiday today, but will be making modest updates to iLounge. We’ll all be back tomorrow, October 9, with our full slate of news and reviews. We hope you, your family, and friends... Read more...

Reviews: Speck CandyShell, Flip + Grip for iPhone 5 Friday, 05 October 2012 As they’re part of the same family, these cases all share the same basic design with CandyShell as the base model. At first glance, CandyShell is almost identical to the iPhone 4/4S version down to the rubber lines at the corners. It combines an... Read more...

Flutter Flutter | iLounge + Mac Friday, 05 October 2012 This isn’t the first Mac app to offer audio playback control via hand gestures, but none has worked as well as Flutter (Free), developed by the company of the same name. Described as “Kinect for Mac,” the app only recognizes three gestures, but they... Read more...

Reviews: Focusrite iTrack Solo | iLounge Friday, 05 October 2012 Sporting an aluminum housing, the iTrack Solo includes XLR and 1/4” inputs on the front for professional microphone and guitar connections, respectively, each with its own gain controls, plus a 48V phantom power button for the mic input. An... Read more...

Virtual classic iPod a tribute to Jobs Friday, 05 October 2012 On the anniversary of Steve Jobs’ death, web design company Inventika Solutions has posted a fitting tribute: a virtual classic iPod that works within your browser. The virtual iPod works just as the original did — operate the clickwheel and play... Read more...

Reviews: IK Multimedia iRig PRE XLR Microphone Interface Friday, 05 October 2012 Designed to be as unobtrusive as possible, the iRig PRE is an in-line preamp with an XLR connector on one end and a 20” hardwired 3.5mm cable for connecting to the headphone port on an iPhone, iPad or iPod touch on the other; they’re accompanied by... Read more...