I am interested in hand knit traditional ganseys. They were beautiful and extraordinarily functional garments. Here is my research journal and thoughts on related historical issues

Wednesday, July 01, 2015

Pure Wisdom

He, that I call "Pure Wisdom" is a member of my most extended family. He was one of the brightest stars at one of the world's most technical companies, and now is one of its most senior managers. He is no longer concerned with technical issues because he says, "Old must be BOLD!"

We are, after all, are writing our Epitaph. We are writing our grave stone. Writing in stone takes great force. Yes, we need to be very bold.

There are many manuals for writing resumes, but there are few guides to writing good Epitaphs.

One was laid out by Ina Corina Brown in the course she taught as a Peabody Scholar. Sometimes it was offered as a set of things to do on a regular basis, and sometimes it was offered as a personal performance test. Here is one of the test versions.

1.Do I seek
to to achieve personal growth and development by means of some plan whereby I
can enlarge my horizons as well as fill gaps in
my knowledge an experience?

2.Do I
subscribe to or regularly access:

2.1.Some
reliable news media?

2.2.Some
quality magazines dealing with current thought?

2.3.Some
magazines devoted at least in part to book reviews and literary
criticism?

2.4. First
rate professional journals?

3.Do I read
at least 2 dozen serious books in the field of biography, history, current
affairs, and literature (including classics read and reread)?

4.Do I make
some serious effort in increase my understanding and appreciation of art,
literature, and music through the use of pictures, lectures, concerts, records,
plays, books and the selective use of radio, TV, and Utube ?

5.Do I
follow some consistent plan for building a library, including dictionaries,
atlases, encyclopedias, religious texts, and reference books such as
Bartlett's Quotations, Fowler's English Usage, and more modern texts on the
topic?

6.Do I have
some consistent plan for professional reading, and for professional growth and
development?

7.Do I have
an interest in, and an awareness of, the world of nature so that I can identify
and enjoy birds, flowers, trees, stars, and landscapes?

8.Do I have
some enriching and relaxing hobby or interest such as weaving, wood or leather
working, cabinet making, book binding or gardening?

9.Do I
belong to and actively participate in at least 3 of the following:

9.1. A religious body?

9.2.A civic
group?

9.3.A
political group?

9.4.A
literary, art or music group?

9.5. A scientific
group?

9.6.A social
action group?

9.7.A
professional society?

10.Do I have some consistent and orderly
plan for budgeting and handling my income so that:

10.1.I am able to meet my obligations promptly?

10.2.Get
the greatest possible benefit form my income?

10.3.Make
reasonable provision for the future?

11. Do I have some consistent can orderly plan for
budgeting my time so that I can:

11.1.Meet
my personal and professional obligations?

11.2.Render
service to my fellowmen?

11.3.Have
time for enriching leisure?

12.Do I take care of my health through
habits of eating and sleeping, judicious use of exercise and rest, and regular
physical examinations including eyes and teeth?

13.Am I particular in habits of personal
cleanliness and grooming, and in selection, care and repair of clothing?

14.Do I fulfill my obligation as a
citizen by:

14.1.Voting
regularly and as intelligently as possible?

14.2.Civic
participation (serving on boards and committees, aiding in Red Cross and other
drives and etc.?

14.3.Some
regular volunteer service to an organization engaged in community betterment?

15.Am I careful in my oral and written
speech habits including enunciation, pronunciation, vocabulary and sentence
structure, and do I attempt to correct known deficiencies?

16.Do I practice the kind of good
manners that come of a thoughtful awareness and
consideration of others?

17.Have I honestly attempted to achieve
those qualities of character that I most genuinely admire such as integrity,
fortitude, compassion, tolerance?

18.Do I make a persistent effort to rub
off the rough edges of my personality and to become a friendly, likable person who brings out the best in
others?

19.Am I continuously enlarging the
horizons of my knowledge, interest and concern so as to become in the best
sense of the word, a citizen of the world?

20.Am I honestly trying to develop what
Overstreet calls “The Mature Mind”, so that I may grow up before I grow old?

See for
example http://scholar.lib.vt.edu/theses/available/etd-41198-154456/unrestricted/chap6.pdf

I transcribed the above from a hard copy, and I know there are some typos in it, but in accordance with "make it work, then make it pretty" I offer it up in its current state.

The other thing that I would add is that there is a lot of sloppy thinking out there. Sometimes details matter. And, when details matter, generalities fail. When someone tells you that woolen spun is warmer than worsted because woolen is looser and holds more air, ask yourself if they have the details correct.

Spinning, knitting, and waving are all technologies where details matter - a lot. And, yet I find that many modern hobby spinners, knitters, and weavers tend to gloss technical details. They pretend to want to spin or knit or weave fast, but avoid the tools that would allow them to work faster.

Thus, the 4 additional questions that I would add to ICB's exam are:

21. Am I honest with myself about my goals?

22. Do I test statements asserted by others as facts?

23. Do I keep my math sharp?

24. Do expand and deepen my knowledge of physical science?

Testing statements is not looking them up at some citation. It is either calculations from first principles, or going into the lab or studio, making the test equipment or preparing the test material and testing it. If you want to know whether I am telling the truth about what kind of fabrics are warmer, knit up some fabric swatches and test their insulation values. If you want to know if I am correct about knitting sheaths, make one and try it. Try it with pointy needles, then try it with blunt needles. I did.

8 comments:

The bulleted list you offered is not a test. It is a "personal rating scale" written by Ina Corinne Brown (you can't even spell her name correctly), and you have altered it significantly. It was written by a group of teachers who wanted suggestions of ways to increase their knowledge after their formal classroom training was complete. It was written in 1950, before the internet even existed. Ms. Brown died in 1990 at the age of 94. There is, indeed, a lot of "sloppy thinking," and it appears to be on your part, including plagiarizing an author, misrepresenting the purpose of the author's text, and altering it to suit your own agenda without noting that you have changed the original text, even going to far as to assert that you "transcribed it from a hard copy" (I found the original on the internet in about five minutes). You are busted, Aaron!

Aaron, irrespective of whether you were in her class or not, Ms. Brown could not - I repeat, - have suggested the use of the internet. It didn't exist when she wrote and published the article in 1950, and you have copied her rating scale from the published manuscript, but you have altered it to suit your own agenda.

You have deviated significantly from the original purpose of the rating scale as well as altering the content without the author's permission or without noting that you have changed the content and why and where. Words matter, Aaron.

And I don't care if Ms. Brown stripped down to her skivvies during class break. Your presence or absence in her class does not give you the right to alter her work. Period.

As noted by others, the test as taught by ICB was a collaboration. I worked from the hand written notes of her students (who took her class at Peabody in 1965 -- 15 years after the noted paper.), and who later worked with Dr. Miller (I'm OK, Your OK) and ICB to evolve the test for use in an adult reading program, which was used by several universities, mostly in the context of federally funded adult education programs. The material evolved with the input of several authors.

ICB encouraged her students to extend and adapt the test to fit their world. Yes I edited and extended the test. You should take the test and edit and extend it for yourself. It is a tool. Tools should be fitted for their purpose.

ICB was a very civilized woman who served a formal tea to her grad students during the break in the class. In fact that might be ICB's best lesson - be civilized.

No, Holin, I expect that you invent completely new patterns for each object, being very careful not to use any patterns or concepts similar to any in Walker or Mary Thomas or Knitting in the Old Way, Principles of Knitting, or any other previously extant notion of knitting.

I am sure that you make tea differently from your mother or any of your teachers! And, i am very certain that you are very careful not to infringe on the "formal tea during class break" principle established by ICB. Right??

Civilization requires that culture passed on from generation to generation. We stand on the shoulders of our teachers and see farther. We make incremental improvements on our teacher's work, and thereby their work becomes our work, and our work is improved by our students and it becomes their work. And, this goes on from generation to generation.

Holin said: " but I don't plagiarize the work of other knitters by passing their patterns off as my own."

You said: "No, Holin, I expect that you invent completely new patterns for each object, being very careful not to use any patterns or concepts similar to any in Walker or Mary Thomas or Knitting in the Old Way, Principles of Knitting, or any other previously extant notion of knitting."

You created a strawman. Holin didn't say she only used her own patterns, just that she didn't pass others' off as her own.

Intellectual Property

I reserve all intellectual property rights and copy rights for all material that I post here. You are welcome to look, read, study and learn. You are welcome to link to it. However, I worked very hard to develop this material and it is mine.