In his latest blog post, Moose Peterson rails, gently albeit, against the art of post-capture cropping and I would have to agree that several of his points are quite valid. He talks about appropriate lens and distance from subject and getting it right in camera which the Holy Crop! blog applauds. I even admire the passion he feels for getting the best possible image at shutter snap. Ultimately, I find his admonitions fall short of reality as they proceed from an base assumption that is flawed.

Just the old cropist’s opinion here but Moose’s cropping philosophy is based upon an erroneous notion that a 3:2 Aspect ratio, or whatever ratio at which your camera captures, is the true and best aspect for the final image. In a world where 3:2 is your only output aspect ratio, Moose’s comments are very valid. Unfortunately, the space in which your image’s subject ultimately lives is hardly, if ever 3:2. My Monitor is 16:9 for example, a Facebook cover photo is 8.51:3.14, for example. I can’t fit those 3:2 aspect images into these spaces without slicing something off. Cropping is a real world necessity.

On another front, an image can be made stronger than the capture aspect ratio as in the moose shot (small “M”) shown above. The top and bottom portions removed aren’t really important to the image but, as you frequent readers know, the space and placement is. Why would you ever limit the aspect ratio of your output to the limitations of your capture device?

The output aspect ratio should make your image the strongest it can be.

Just a quick note: Moose is careful to say this is ‘his way’ and that every photographer must find their own path.

Last Season’s Crops

Holy Crop’s mission: Improving your image through cropping.

Holy Crop is the blog dedicated to all things cropping.

Learn how to crop an image.
Discover how to improve composition.
Find different strategies for cropping an image.
Analyze how to make your image as strong as it can be.

Holy Crop touches on all the software tools, the art theory, and the latest advances in camera technology as it brings you the most comprehensive coverage of the single greatest improvement you can make to your image: The Crop.

Rikk Flohr: The Cropist

Holy Crop!™ is a trademark of Rikk Flohr and Fleeting Glimpse Images, LLC