my list...
1. McNair .... doubt I'll ever put a TN signal caller above Mac 9
2. V-Y .... I know he isn't popular around here, but I loved watching him play
3. HAAS .... Played well, overall. Was a class act during his tenure.
4. O'Donnell ....Excellent game manager when called upon. Nothing flashy, just got it done
5. Volek .... Was fun to watch him sling that football,.Wish he'd have got a shot (POST MCNAIR)
6. LOCKER .... in time I see him moving up the list, just haven't seen much to get him there..yet
7.COLLINS...I'll give him credit for holding it down for awhile, but really bored the hell outta me.
8.RUSTY... always be my fave 3rd stringer QB..that one start was a shame. lol
9. (HONORABLE MENTION) INGLE MARTIN...I love my TN players

I'm not going blame Kerry Collins for the fact that the titans kept him around for a year or two longer than they should have. They should have known that 2008 would be about the last of the quality play we could get from him but VY was acting like a child and we had nobody else so we signed him to a 2 year deal.

Would have helped to have some better WRs here also a major weakness of those 2008 and 2009 teams.

Still to compare a QB who led us to a 12-3 record one year to a guy who was not even bench material is stupid. Why do discussions like this always gravitate to the stupid?

Clark Johannson was the third best QB in titans history! Why? Because he didn't ever exist and that's better the crap we had. Who thinks that way?

you gonna tell me there's 30 QB's/RB's you'd take over McNair/George? I'd be interested in knowing who those people are.

There are 23 QBs in the hall of fame.
Plus ken Stabler and multiple snubs from years past. Plus Manning, Brady, Kurt Warner, Rodgers, Brees, (ugh....maybe even Favre) and questionably Rich Gannon who I would take over him. That's just from the past decade.

There was a lot of football played before McNair, and McNair was only top of the league (even shared that) for one season. There has been and will be a lot of football played since McNair.

McNair was not top 30, or he'd be in the HOF.

Eddie George was a good RB for a decent span. Not top 30 except for in our hearts.

There are 23 QBs in the hall of fame.
Plus ken Stabler and multiple snubs from years past. Plus Manning, Brady, Kurt Warner, Rodgers, Brees, (ugh....maybe even Favre) and questionably Rich Gannon who I would take over him. That's just from the past decade.

There was a lot of football played before McNair, and McNair was only top of the league (even shared that) for one season. There has been and will be a lot of football played since McNair.

McNair was not top 30, or he'd be in the HOF.

Eddie George was a good RB for a decent span. Not top 30 except for in our hearts.

There's tons of HoF players who couldn't play in todays game, McNair is IMO by far better than at least 5 or 6 of those men in the HoF

get in a time machine and bring all those slow ass white guys back, see how good they do vs these machines like Revis and Watt, they couldn't cut it in this day in age. McNair would put Watt on his back in his prime. Same goes for Eddie.

There's tons of HoF players who couldn't play in todays game, McNair is IMO by far better than at least 5 or 6 of those men in the HoF

get in a time machine and bring all those slow ass white guys back, see how good they do vs these machines like Revis and Watt, they couldn't cut it in this day in age. McNair would put Watt on his back in his prime. Same goes for Eddie.

Nobody plays in a vacuum. Everyone plays their sport in the parlance of their times.
These HOF players were the top of their sport at their time.. that's all they could be. McNair was 2nd-20th best through all of his career but one year where he split #1. If you can't dominate the league for a number of years, I don't think top 30 all time status is in order.

he was a very efficient QB, top 20 in pass intercept %.

The only other thing he's top 20 statistically in is yards per rush and fumbles recovered.

If you don't
1. Blow up the record books. (Marino)
or
2. Win a super bowl or 2 (most other hall QBs.)

Why advertise on goTitans.com?

With 3500+ members and over 1 million posts, goTitans.com is the place for Tennessee Titans fans to talk Titans. Created in 2000, we have multiple advertising opportunities available for those interested. Email TitanJeff for more information.

The Tip Jar

For those of you interested in helping the cause, we offer The Tip Jar. For $2 a month, you can become a subscriber and enjoy goTitans.com without ads.