Ansel Elgort

The Fault in Our Stars may only be Elgort's second film credit -- his first project, Divergent, comes out in March 2014 -- but the lifelong New Yorker is no stranger to acting. Performing off-Broadway with Alexis Bledel during his senior year at NYC's prestigious LaGuardia Performing Arts High School, Elgort spent seven summers as a kid at the Stagedoor Manor acting camp. And if his stage cred isn't enough, Teen Vogue tapped the hunk to appear in a 2009 magazine spread!