European Institutions Office

Transcription

1 European Institutions Office Amnesty International s Concerns about the Fourth Amendment to Hungary s Fundamental Law March 2013

2 INTRODUCTION In a letter sent to Viktor Orbán Prime Minister of Hungary on the 8 th of March, Amnesty International outlined its concerns regarding the proposed Fourth Amendment to the Fundamental Law of Hungary (the Constitution). Hungary is bound by a number of international human rights treaties, including the International Covenant of Civil and Political Rights, International Covenant on Economic, Social and Cultural Rights, as well as the European Convention on Human Rights. As a state party to these treaties, Hungary is obliged to respect the rights protected by them, and to ensure them to all individuals in their territory and subject to their jurisdiction. Pursuant to the principle articulated in article 26 of the Vienna Convention on the Law of Treaties, Hungary is required to give effect to the obligations under these human rights treaties in good faith. With regard to the proposed Fourth Amendment of the Constitution (the proposal), Amnesty International is particularly concerned by three provisions that may limit the scope of rights in the following areas: protection from discrimination on the basis of sexual orientation (Article 1); the right to adequate housing (Article 8); the right to freedom of expression (Article 5(5)). PROTECTION FROM DISCRIMINATION ON THE BASIS OF SEXUAL ORIENTATION The proposed Constitutional amendments include a proposal to introduce a restrictive definition of family, defining it as obtaining only in respect of marriage, and parental children relations. In full the new article would read: Article (1) Hungary shall protect the institution of marriage as the union of a man and a woman established by voluntary decision, and the family as the basis of the nation s survival. The basis of a familial relation is marriage and parent-child relationship. The definition of marriage as a union between a man and a woman was introduced in the new Constitution in The proposed amendment goes beyond this already restrictive provision and by conflating family and marriage and parent-child relations, it excludes from the definition of a family same-sex couples; nonmarried heterosexual couples without children ; or orphans who are in the custody of their side relatives such as their aunt or uncle. Furthermore by only defining "marriage and parent-children relations" as family, the proposal creates a legal uncertainty as to whether an unmarried heterosexual couple with common children could be identified as a family, or whether only the individual parent-children relationships would be recognised as such. The proposed constitutional definition of the family is unnecessarily restrictive and discriminatory on the basis of sexual orientation and marital status. The proposal is contrary to the jurisprudence of the European Court of Human Rights which held in a number of cases that there is not just one way or one choice when it comes to leading one s family or private life. 1 In the case of Schalk and Kopf v. Austria the Court made it clear that it was artificial to maintain the view that, in contrast to a different-sex couple, a same-sex couple cannot enjoy family life for the purposes of Article 8. 2 In its recent decision of X. and others v. Austria 3, the Court stated that...the relationship of a cohabiting same-sex couple living in a stable de facto relationship falls within the notion of family life just as the relationship of a different-sex couple in the same situation would. The proposed amendment of the Constitution presents a departure from a decision of the Hungarian Constitutional Court which held in its judgement of AB 14/1995 (III. 13.) [T]hat the prolonged 1 European Court Of Human Rights, Kozak v. Poland, application no /02, 2 March European Court of Human Rights, Schalk and Kopf v. Austria, Application no /04, 24 June European Court of Human Rights, X. and others v. Austria, Application no. 1910/07, 19 February

3 relationship of two people can create a certain value which could amount to the legal recognition of people cohabiting without regard to their gender. 4 Furthermore, the proposal contravenes the decision of the Constitutional Court 154/2008 (XII. 17.) in which the Court highlighted the need for legal or institutional protection for same-sex couples since they cannot marry stems from human right to dignity, and from the related right to self-determination, and also from the freedom to act. 5 In the case of Schalk and Kopf v. Austria the European Court of Human Rights also clarified that the notion of family under [the] provision [of Article 8] is not confined to marriage-based relationships [emphasis added] and may encompass other de facto family ties where the parties are living together out of wedlock. A child born out of such a relationship is ipso jure part of that family unit from the moment and by the very fact of his birth. 6 The Hungarian Constitutional Court in a recent decision also annulled certain provisions of the 2011 law on the protection of families for applying this discriminatory definition of the family. 7 PROTECTION OF THE RIGHT TO ADEQUATE HOUSING Article 8. This will replace article XII. (1) Hungary endeavours to guarantee for all the basic conditions of housing with dignity and access to public services. (2) The state and the local governments can assist in ensuring the basic conditions of housing with dignity by seeking to provide alternative accommodation to all homeless persons (3) A national law or a statute of a local government can outlaw habitual living in public spaces with reference to the protection of public order, public security, public health and the cultural values. Amnesty International is concerned that the proposed constitutional amendment (Article 8), would create the possibility for national laws or for local decrees to penalise homelessness contrary to Hungary s international obligations to guarantee the right to adequate for housing for all. We would like to remind you that as a state party to several international and regional human rights treaties, including the International Covenant on Economic, Social and Cultural Rights (ICESCR) (Art. 11.1), Hungary is required to guarantee the right to adequate housing for all without discrimination, including the homeless, regardless of the absence of a corresponding provision in the Constitution. The UN Committee on Economic, Social and Cultural Rights (CESCR) which monitors State parties implementation of ICESCR has clarified states obligations vis-à-vis the right to adequate housing in General Comment 4. In paragraph 12, the UN Committee points out While the most appropriate means of achieving the full realization of the right to adequate housing will inevitably vary significantly from one State party to another, the Covenant clearly requires that each State party take whatever steps are necessary for that purpose. This will almost invariably require the adoption of a national housing strategy which, as stated in paragraph 32 of the Global Strategy for Shelter, "defines the objectives for the development of shelter conditions, identifies the resources available to meet these goals and the most cost-effective way of using them and sets out the responsibilities and time-frame for the implementation of the necessary measures". Both for reasons of relevance and effectiveness, as well as in order to ensure respect for other human rights, such a strategy should reflect extensive genuine consultation with, and participation by, all of those affected, including the homeless, the inadequately housed and their representatives. 4 Hungarian Constitutional Court Resolution No. 14/1995 (III. 13.), Hungarian Constitutional Court Resolution No. 154/2008 (XII. 17.), European Court of Human Rights, Schalk and Kopf v. Austria, Application no /04, 24 June Hungarian Constitutional Court Resolution No. 43/2012 (XII. 20.),

4 Criminalising homeless people especially in the context of the absence of concrete measures to fulfil the right to adequate housing for all therefore runs contrary to Hungary s obligations under ICESCR and, in particular, to address the housing needs and situation of the most vulnerable. This approach of ensuring adequate protection of the rights of the homeless rather than penalising them has been endorsed by international experts as well as Hungary s own Constitutional Court. In November 2012, the Hungarian Constitutional Court annulled the legislative provision providing for the criminalisation of homelessness, on the basis that it was contradictory to the Fundamental Law s requirements for legal certainty, the protection of the right to human dignity and the right to property. 8 The United Nations Special Rapporteur on Adequate Housing commented [T]he recent decision of the Constitutional Court rightly highlights the fact that homelessness is a social issue, which needs to be addressed by the provision of adequate services and not by criminal proceedings and recently, the United Nations Special Rapporteur on Extreme Poverty stated that [T]he criminalization of rough sleeping and other life sustaining behaviours in public spaces is an infringement on the basic rights of homeless persons to liberty, privacy, personal security and protection of the family. 9 FREEDOM OF EXPRESSION Article 5(5) The practice of freedom of expression cannot violate the dignity of the Hungarian Nation, or any national, ethnic, racial or religious community. Persons belonging to these communities as prescribed by law have the right to challenge these kinds of expressions that violate the dignity of their community or their own human dignity. Amnesty International is concerned that the broad wording of this provision could lead to violations of the right to freedom of expression contrary to Hungary s obligations under International Covenant on Civil and Political Rights and the European Convention on Human Rights. As the Human Rights Committee and the European Court have emphasized, the scope of the right to freedom of expression includes even expression that may be regarded as deeply offensive. 10 The treaties are clear that any restrictions on the exercise of freedom of expression must be only such as meet all three elements of a stringent three-part test: they must be 1) provided by law which must be accessible and formulated with sufficient precision to enable an individual to regulate their conduct accordingly; 2) only for one of the legitimate purposes recognized under international law which include protection of the rights and reputations of others; and 3) demonstrably necessary and proportionate for the achievement of that aim. 11 This could include, in extreme cases, prohibiting advocacy of national, racial or religious hatred that constitutes incitement to discrimination, hostility or violence. But the UN Human Rights Committee has stressed that any such restrictions must not put in jeopardy the right itself, and that the relation between right and restriction and between norm and exception must not be reversed. The proposed provision is set out in terms which go much wider than these very narrow circumstances in which it is permissible under international law to impose restrictions on the exercise of freedom of expression, and in terms which effectively reverse the relation between the right and the permissible exceptions to it. With regard to restrictions which may be permissible to ensure protection of the rights or reputations of others, the Human Rights Committee has clarified that the term others relates to other persons individually or as members of a community, but that the primary focus of this provision is on protection of the rights of individual members of such a community defined by its religious faith or ethnicity 12 ; human rights law does not provide protection for abstract entities such as nations or religious beliefs as such. While in certain 8 Hungarian Constitutional Court Resolution No. 38/2012 (XI. 14.), UN experts urge Hungary to uphold Constitutional Court decision to decriminalize homelessness, 11 December 2012, 10 Human Rights Committee, General Comment No. 34, 12 September 2011, UN Doc. CCPR/C/GC/34, para. 11; European Court of Human Rights, Handyside v. UK, application 5493/72, 7 December 1976, para UN Human Rights Committee, General Comment No. 34, paras UN Human Rights Committee, General Comment No. 34, para. 28 4

5 circumstances, in line with the criteria outlined above, it may be permissible to restrict some expression if it leads to violations of the rights or reputations of individual Hungarians or members of other national, ethnic, racial or religious communities, it is not clear how prohibiting expression aimed at "hurting the dignity of the Hungarian nation, or any other community as such, would comply with this focus of human rights law on individuals. RECOMMENDATIONS In view of these concerns, Amnesty International calls on Hungary not to enact the Fourth Amendment unless it is modified to ensure that it is in line with Hungary s obligations under international law. Amnesty International also urges the EU to state publicly its misgivings over these developments and engage with Hungary directly on these issues 5

FREQUENTLY ASKED QUESTIONS FROM COUPLES WHO ARE CONSIDERING GETTING MARRIED IN SAN FRANCISCO On February 12, 2004, the county clerk in San Francisco began issuing marriage licenses to same-sex couples,

Same Sex Unions and the ECHR Gregor Puppinck, PhD. Director of the ECLJ, Strasbourg, 20 April 2015. Debate is escalating in Western countries with the opening of marriage to same-sex couples. To this day,

You can find the latest version of this guidance on our website at www.gmc-uk.org/guidance. Published 25 March 2013 Comes into effect 22 April 2013 Personal beliefs and medical practice 1 In Good medical

IDSN position paper on the Interrelations between Caste, Descent and Race Caste discrimination and similar forms of inherited social exclusion affect an estimated 260 million people around the world. Most

Marriage equality in a changing world POSITION PAPER ON MARRIAGE EQUALITY Introduction The Australian Human Rights Commission considers that the fundamental human rights principle of equality means that

Unofficial translation The Law of Georgia On the Elimination of All Forms of Discrimination Article 1. The Objective of the Law The present law aims to eliminate any form of discrimination and to ensure

/unofficial translation/ LAW OF THE REPUBLIC OF GEORGIA ON CITIZENSHIP OF GEORGIA Citizenship is the stable legal relationship of a person with the state which is expressed in the totality of their mutual

Tal av utrikesminister Laila Freivalds inför FN:s kommission för mänskliga rättigheter, Genève 15 mars 2005 Recognition of the inherent dignity and of the equal and inalienable rights of all members of

European Citizens Initiative on Unconditional Basic Income ANNEX Initiators of the ECI The persons presenting the proposal for our ECI are citizens out of 15 EU Member States (Austria, Belgium, Denmark,

Farzad Family Law Scholarship 2014 Should the right to marry for same-sex couples become a federal constitutional right by amendment to the United States Constitution or remain a State issue? The United

Linked Law Solicitors Equality and Diversity Policy (based on the Law Society s model policy issued under Rules 3 and 4 of the Solicitors Anti- Discrimination Rules 2004 and amended in the light of the

EUROPEAN PARLIAMT 2009-2014 Committee on Civil Liberties, Justice and Home Affairs 17.12.2013 2013/2183(INI) REPORT on the EU Roadmap against homophobia and discrimination on grounds of sexual orientation

Full list of mistakes and omissions of the English Version of the Hungarian draft- Constitution This document contains the full list of mistakes and omissions of the draft-constitution English version.

COUNCIL OF THE EUROPEAN UNION Brussels, 11 February 2010 6092/10 Interinstitutional File: 2008/0140 (CNS) SOC 75 JAI 108 MI 39 NOTE from : The Presidency to : The Working Party on Social Questions on :

EUROPEAN COMMISSION Proposal for a Brussels, 24.3.2010 COM(2010) 105 final 2010/0067 (CNS) C7-0315/10 COUNCIL REGULATION (EU) implementing enhanced cooperation in the area of the law applicable to divorce

MARRIAGE FOR SAME-SEX COUPLES IN CALIFORNIA Frequently Asked Questions Last Updated: July 9, 2015 NOTE: This document is intended to provide information for same-sex couples who are considering getting

Position Paper on Adoption Law Reform March 2013 Department of Health and Human Services Introduction What is adoption? Adoption is the legal process which permanently transfers all the legal rights and

300 Appendix A Advocate for Women s Rights Using International Law The United Nations (UN) brings together almost every government in the world to discuss issues, resolve conflicts, and make treaties affecting

Belfast Feminist Network Written evidence on the proposed amendment to the Justice Bill brought before the Justice Committee by Jim Wells MLA on 2 July 2014 Belfast Feminist Network is a community collective

Corporations and Human Rights: Do They Have Obligations? International law has traditionally been understood as a system set up by states to regulate the affairs between them. 1 Especially, since the Second

1 of 8 A summary of how to avoid discrimination under the Equality Act 2010 when defining who can benefit from a charity A. About the Equality Act and the charities exemption A1. Introduction All charities

Annex 1 Primary sources for international standards 1. The United Nations The 1948 Universal Declaration of Human Rights Article 20 1. Everyone has the right to freedom of peaceful assembly and association.

EL SALVADOR Open Letter on the Anti-Maras Act Amnesty International shares the concerns that have been expressed by a number of Salvadorean institutions and non-governmental organizations regarding Decree

IN RE MARRIAGE CASES (California): 2008 These cases present the issue of the legality of gay marriage bans, in the context of previous State domestic partnership (CA) or civil union (CT) Statutes, under

Liberty s Briefing: Forced Marriage (Civil Protection) Bill January 2007 1 About Liberty Liberty (The National Council for Civil Liberties) is one of the UK s leading civil liberties and human rights organisations.

Human Rights Council Eleventh Session Resolution 11/3. Trafficking in persons, especially women and children The Human Rights Council, Reaffirming all previous resolutions on the problem of trafficking

ANTI-DISCRIMINATION LAW IN SWITZERLAND Legal Memorandum March 2013 EXECUTIVE SUMMARY The purpose of this memorandum is to provide an overview of the structure and content of anti-discrimination laws in

Equality with Human Rights Analysis Toolkit The Equality Act 2010 and Human Rights Act 1998 require us to consider the impact of our policies and practices in respect of equality and human rights. We should

ONE OF US, questionnaire on bioethics f o r candidates for European elections 2014 Europe, protection of life and respect for human dignity Last year, almost 2,000,000 EU citizens all over the 28 Member

LEGISLATION COMMITTEE OF THE CROATIAN PARLIAMENT 2300 Pursuant to its authority from Article 59 of the Rules of Procedure of the Croatian Parliament, the Legislation Committee determined the revised text

Unofficial translation Adoption: 09.11.2004 Signature: 08.12.2004 Entry into force: 19.04.2005 THE LAW OF THE REPUBLIC OF ARMENIA FAMILY CODE PART I GENERAL PROVISIONS CHAPTER 1 FAMILY LEGISLATION ARTICLE

Universal Declaration of Human Rights Preamble Whereas recognition of the inherent dignity and of the equal and inalienable rights of all members of the human family is the foundation of freedom, justice

Code of practice for employers Avoiding unlawful discrimination while preventing illegal working [xx] April 2014 Presented to Parliament pursuant to section 23(1) of the Immigration, Asylum and Nationality

ABA Section of Family Law 2012 Fall CLE Conference Philadelphia, October 2012 Surrogacy and Employment Law: When it s not your pregnancy is it your leave of absence? The UK position Colin Rogerson Solicitor

Summary of the law on SEXUAL ORIENTATION DISCRIMINATION This booklet sets out the basic employment rights to which workers are entitled under the sexual orientation discrimination provisions of the Equality

Supplementary Submission to the Human Rights and Equal Opportunity Commission Same-Sex: Same Entitlements Australian Lawyers for Human Rights Inc (ALHR) is a national network of Australian lawyers active

Rev. Rul. 2013-17 ISSUES 1. Whether, for Federal tax purposes, the terms spouse, husband and wife, husband, and wife include an individual married to a person of the same sex, if the individuals are lawfully

RIGHTS OF CHILDREN RAISED IN LESBIAN, GAY, BISEXUAL OR TRANSGENDER FAMILIES: Written by Dr Loveday Hodson on behalf of ILGA-Europe December 2008 Written by Dr Loveday Hodson on behalf of ILGA-Europe December

A BRIEF SUMMARY OF FAMILY LAW AS IT AFFECTS LGBT (LESBIAN, GAY, BISEXUAL, AND TRANSGENDERED) PERSONS IN FLORIDA By Michael E. Morris, Attorney at Law Updated January 2013 First, this is a summary of some

UNITED NATIONS CCPR International Covenant on Civil and Political Rights Distr. GENERAL CCPR/C/21/Rev.1/Add.9 ** 1 November 1999 Original: ENGLISH HUMAN RIGHTS COMMITTEE GENERAL COMMENTS ADOPTED BY THE

Report: Knowledge, Skills and Values DOCTRINAL AREA: FAMILY LAW 1. Knowledge What core elements are essential for students to enable them to have a substantive understanding of the field? The common global

UNITED NATIONS A General Assembly Distr. GENERAL A/RES/53/144 8 March 1999 Fifty-third session Agenda item 110 (b) RESOLUTION ADOPTED BY THE GENERAL ASSEMBLY [on the report of the Third Committee (A/53/625/Add.2)]

Equality between women and men Gender equality means an equal visibility, empowerment, responsibility and participation of women and men in all spheres of public and private life. It also means an equal

SUBMISSION TO THE UNITED NATIONS COMMITTEE ON THE RIGHTS OF THE CHILD CONCERNING THE DRAFT GENERAL COMMENT ON CHILD RIGHTS AND THE BUSINESS SECTOR APRIL 2012 Background The Institute for Human Rights and

Submission to the Human Rights Committee Regarding the Forced and Coerced Sterilisation of Women Living with HIV/AIDS in Namibia Submitted in advance of the consideration of the list of Issues for Namibia

HX.127.1 Equality, Diversity and Inclusion Handbook This publication is available in large print and easy read Welcome! At Calico, we are dedicated to promoting and celebrating the positive effect that

REPUBLIC OF SOUTH AFRICA CIVIL UNION BILL (As presented by the Portfolio Committee on Home Affairs (National Assembly)) (The English text is the offıcial text of the Bill) (MINISTER OF HOME AFFAIRS) [B

[ ENGLISH TEXT TEXTE ANGLAIS ] OPTIONAL PROTOCOL TO THE CONVENTION ON THE RIGHTS OF THE CHILD ON THE SALE OF CHILDREN, CHILD PROSTITUTION AND CHILD PORNOGRAPHY The States Parties to the present Protocol,

COMPETITION COMMITTEE BEST PRACTICES FOR THE FORMAL EXCHANGE OF INFORMATION BETWEEN COMPETITION AUTHORITIES IN HARD CORE CARTEL INVESTIGATIONS OCTOBER 2005 BEST PRACTICES FOR THE FORMAL EXCHANGE OF INFORMATION

Violations of Human Rights Obligations under the International Covenant on Civil and Political Rights through the New York Police Department s Stop and Frisk Practices Suggested List of Issues to Country

UNIVERSAL DECLARATION OF HUMAN RIGHTS UNITED NATIONS HIGH COMMISSIONER FOR HUMAN RIGHTS Universal Declaration of Human Rights Preamble Whereas recognition of the inherent dignity and of the equal and inalienable

International Covenant on Economic, Social and Cultural Rights Adopted and opened for signature, ratification and accession by General Assembly resolution 2200A (XXI) of 16 December 1966 entry into force

NEWCASTLE UNIVERSITY REPORT TO COUNCIL Revised Code of Practice for Freedom of Speech 1. Under the terms of the 1986 Education Act, the University is required to take measures to protect freedom of speech

Custody and guardianship of children Felicity!Owoses-/Goagoses Introduction Pursuant to its powers under Article 44 1 of the Namibian Constitution, Parliament 2 enacted the Children s Status Act. 3 The

Provided By Touchstone Consulting Group Benefits for Same-sex Couples and A significant number of U.S. companies provide benefits, such as health insurance coverage, for their employees domestic partners

The Netherlands: Gender discrimination in the field of employment This document outlines legislation in Belgium that prohibits discrimination on the basis of race and national origin in the provision of

2014 Executive summary This analysis examines the compliance of the 2014 News Media Law of Myanmar with international standards on freedom of expression and media freedom. The News Media Law introduces

REPRESENTING SAME-SEX FAMILIES IN CALIFORNIA AFTER WINDSOR AND PERRY 2014 Deborah H. Wald As published in the Journal of the California Association of Certified Family Law Specialists (ACFLS), Winter 2014,

France: candidate to the Human Rights Council Human rights are among the founding values of the French Republic and lie at the heart of its foreign policy. France is presenting its candidacy to the Human

Cyprus: The Status of Lesbian, Gay, Bisexual and Transgender Rights Submission to the United Nations Human Rights Council for its Universal Periodic Review of Cyprus (6 th Session) INTRODUCTION 1. This

PRINCIPLES OF THE TRANSFER OF PERSONAL DATA TO A THIRD COUNTRY Introduction The continuous globalization of the world economy influences the international transfer of personal data. The transfer of personal

United Nations Advance edited version Distr.: General 30 September 2011 CERD/C/GC/34 Original: English Committee on the Elimination of Racial Discrimination Seventy-ninth session 8 August 2 September 2011

Professional Capability Framework - Senior Social Worker Experienced Social Worker Professionalism Social workers are members of an internationally recognised profession, a title protected in UK law. Social

MARRIAGE RIGHTS I N I L L I N O I S FOREWORD At Equality Illinois, we work to promote a fair and unified Illinois where everyone is treated equally with dignity and respect and where all people live freely

Parent or not? Civil unions and parentage in Illinois By Carl W. Gilmore Woodstock Legal Consultants Woodstock, Illinois. The Religious Freedom and Civil Union Act is the second time in six years Illinois

1 US and UK Responses Observations by the Governments of the United States and the United Kingdom on Human Rights Committee General Comment No. 24 (52) relating to reservations Note: On 2 November 1994

15 February 2005 Original: English Committee on the Elimination of Discrimination against Women Thirty-second session 10-28 January 2005 Concluding comments: Italy 1. The Committee considered Italy s fourth

Submission on General Comment on Article 6 (Right to Life) under the International Covenant on Civil and Political Rights (ICCPR) to the United Nations Human Rights Committee By Reproductive Health Matters

ENOC Position statement on Children on the move Children on the Move: Children First Adopted at the 17 th ENOC Annual General Assembly held on 27 September 2013 in Brussels 1 We, European Independent Children

OVERVIEW OF THE EQUALITY ACT 2010 1. Context A new Equality Act came into force on 1 October 2010. The Equality Act brings together over 116 separate pieces of legislation into one single Act. Combined,

L 122/28 Official Journal of the European Union 16.5.2009 DIRECTIVE 2009/38/EC OF THE EUROPEAN PARLIAMENT AND OF THE COUNCIL of 6 May 2009 on the establishment of a European Works Council or a procedure

LAW OF GEORGIA ON INTERNALLY DISPLACED PERSONS Last amended 9 June 2006 The Law of Georgia on Internally Displaced Persons is based on the Constitution and internationally recognised principles of international

Clearer rules for international couples frequently asked questions Why does the EU need to act to help international couples? There are around 122 million marriages in the EU, of which around 16 million

MOROCCO/ WESTERN SAHARA COMPREHENSIVE REFORMS TO END VIOLENCE AGAINST WOMEN LONG OVERDUE Amnesty International Publications First published in March 2013 by Amnesty International Publications International

Name of Country and Jurisdiction: United States (Federal). What forms of legally recognized relationships are available? 2. What are the requirements to be able to enter into the above relationships? 3.