Welcome to HVAC-Talk.com, a non-DIY site and the ultimate Source for HVAC Information & Knowledge Sharing for the industry professional! Here you can join over 150,000 HVAC Professionals & enthusiasts from around the world discussing all things related to HVAC/R. You are currently viewing as a NON-REGISTERED guest which gives you limited access to view discussions

To gain full access to our forums you must register; for a free account. As a registered Guest you will be able to:

Participate in over 40 different forums and search/browse from nearly 3 million posts.

I had forgotten about What Price Glory another Cagney movie The Fighting 69TH.

As far as the most realistic that would depend on the criteria. For pure realism modern movies would be more realistic because one they are bigger budget but also the restraints on violence and gore are much more relaxed. When I and many of us were kids they could not show graphic violence so in many ways it sanitized the movies.

As for a true depiction of what it was like and true to the truth To Hell and Back with Audie Murphy. Nothing like having the actual most decorated soldier of the second war or history of the US military portray himself.

Battle cry was written by a real marine and was based on his own life.

As much as I like movies like Kellys heroes MASH and Operation Petticoat can those be considered war movies. I think of them as comedies.

The war themed movie is one of the most prolific genres of film and within that genre exist numerous variances. Some are real to life others comedy and some just made to thrill young boys and men with excitement. I know growing up watching the DUKE all I ever wanted to be was a grunt mud MARINE hitting the beach.

I can name a hundred or more war movies that are worth watching and probably 50 that at one time or another would be could be considered by me to be in the top ten.

Like:
Command Decision with Clark Gable

Wake Island Brain Donlevy

Air Force

Fighter Squadron

Tuskegee Airman

Task Force

Wings of Eagles

Go Tell the Spartans (Burt Lancaster)

Destination Tokyo Carry Grant

Guadalcanal Diary Lloyd Nolan

Battle of the Bulge (Henry Fonda)

The Longest Day for sure

Patton

Midway

The Battle of Britain

Tora! Tora! Tora!

In Harm's Way

Stalag 17

The Big Red One Lee Marvin Marc Hamil

Sahara Humphrey Bogart

U-571

The Enemy Below Robert Mitchum

A Walk in the Sun Dana Andrews another very realistic battle but also delves onto the thoughts of the men.

The War Lover Steve McQueen and get this Bob Newhart.

IF you leave the modern war picture there are many more.

Civil War probably the best was Red Badge of Courage two versions both excellent. The original was with Audie Murphy and the other not quiet as good Richard Thomas.

Glory

Shenandoah

Gettysburg

Gods and Generals

North and South
Ancient wars how about Spartacus Kirk Douglas or 300 Spartans with Richard Egan.

Wow! What a bunch of great war movies. I did not care for Thin Red Line or The Deerhunter though.

Das Boot...what a great movie. You really get the feel of the claustrophobic conditions inside a sub full of really hyped up and scared sailors. I highly recommend watching this in the original German dialogue with sub titles to get the full affect of the fear and dedication in the voices of the submariners.

...seek, and ye shall find;..

So always seek the Truth, not just what you want to believe to be true

Thanks Classical, also reading your favorites one of them was Stalg 17. I wrote Stalag 13 that was the Stalag # for Hogans Heroes. Stalag 17 was the movie I was referring to allthough I loved and grew up on Hogans Heroes.

Matt I knew just let is slide William Holden was great. I liked animal he really was gone for Betty Garble. Did you know that Betty Garble was pregnant when she did that picture you always see in the movies?

There was two other escape movies I remember can't think of the names. One was about Brits digging a tunnel under a pommel horse and the other they built a glider in the roof of an old castle on a mountain.