DARK AND LIGHT BY TURNS

RODERIC DUNNETT writes about 'Arthur Part 1: Arthur Pendragon'
in the light of the recent London première

The problem with Arthur, however, was Bintley's comic-strip
approach to storytelling. While the lighting department (Peter Mumford)
served up a running sequence of dramatic cyclorama pinks and blues, greens
and yellow, the narrative rather limped along, prefaced by a garish and
slightly spurious flurry of rape and violence, moving on to Uther (David
Justin) and Igraine (Sabrina Lenzi), not to mention her athletic but overshowy
cuckolded husband (Wolfgang Stollwitzer), flickering forward to Arthur's
boyhood, the introduction of the charming Guinevere, the incestuous threat
from his half-sister, and finally the suitably grotesque but perhaps ineptly
expressionistic birth of Arthur's odious bastard and future destroyer, Mordred
: another of those moments that hit you in the stomach, yet seemed, in its
graphic caricature of good and evil, gratuitous surface parody rather than
imagery possessed of any depth.

Part I, then, proved a mixed bag : dramatically far less incisive than
Edward II; visually alluring, yet somehow intellectually trite and verging
on the infantile populist, an error to which the late Christopher Gable's
widely popular, narrative-focussed last works for Northern Ballet Theatre
were also prone. It's good for ballet to pack the aisles - but then the
ideas have to be as good as, say, The Lion King.

Bintley has a chance to pull things round with Arthur Part II,
early next year. McCabe's score remains his trump card : the woodwind
writing, in particular - dark and light by turns - has countless stunning
moments, and the Royal Ballet Sinfonia (music director : Barry Wordsworth)
have at last, in Edward and Arthur, a challenge worthy of
their considerable, though generally unsung, abilities.