I have no doubt that you know your deer herd better than any of us, however, just from looking at those pictures, I'm not convinced it is the same deer. The reason I wonder is that all of a sudden, now he has really long brow tines where he didn't before. Also, look at how this year his right beam curves in a lot more than in the past. Just a thought, but I'm no expert.

I have no doubt that you know your deer herd better than any of us, however, just from looking at those pictures, I'm not convinced it is the same deer. The reason I wonder is that all of a sudden, now he has really long brow tines where he didn't before. Also, look at how this year his right beam curves in a lot more than in the past. Just a thought, but I'm no expert.

I would be curios to know your ďtellĒ. Iím horrible other than looking at horns to tell if itís the same deer. Without out any history and a couple pics he would be a little tricky. A ton of old man features with a 3 year old body. I had seen all of the previous pics over the years so i had a pretty good idea of who it was. So question is would you shoot him if you saw him? Not sure where your other buck came from.

I would be curios to know your ďtellĒ. Iím horrible other than looking at horns to tell if itís the same deer. Without out any history and a couple pics he would be a little tricky. A ton of old man features with a 3 year old body. I had seen all of the previous pics over the years so i had a pretty good idea of who it was. So question is would you shoot him if you saw him? Not sure where your other buck came from.

Its cool seeing them get that old. I was fortunate enough to kill a 10 year old buck last year that I have sheds and tc pics from 2012 on as well. We estimated he stayed within 10-12'' each year until I killed him.