I love Sugar Loaf! Lindsay made the cutest and most delicious baby bird cupcakes for my friend that we still talk about them over a year later. I also love how she even offers vegan options, AMAZING!

Reply

Tarah Durnbaugh

8/4/2014 03:59:58 am

Lindsay created custom cupcakes for my dad's 50th birthday that were a huge hit! They were delicious, adorable, and she even made variations to accommodate vegan and gluten free diets! We will always use Sugar Loaf for our baked goods needs!

Reply

Nicole Pellegrino

8/31/2014 03:47:05 pm

Lindsay was fabulous and made both our engagement party cupcakes as well as our wedding cake and cupcakes. She made them all perfect to order, natural, adorable, and delicious. We actually had a tasting at the engagement party to poll which flavor would become our cake-- and it spurred some serious debate because they were all so delicious! High fives to Sugar Loaf for being amazing and good for both the taste buds and the organic soul. :)

Reply

Chris De Groote

9/4/2014 04:13:19 am

I give Lindsay 100% approval rating for her creative ideas and first rate service, including delivery ! She made a great cake, shaped and decorated like a Brownie Camera ,for a friends 70th. Everyone was impressed.

Reply

Jen Berman

10/5/2014 12:50:34 pm

Sugarloaf is my go-to for cakes, tarts and pies that impress! So very talented and wonderful at combining unique flavors. Most of all the owner, Lindsay, really understands and accommodates her customers--if you want "not too sweet" it's done--heavier on fruit than crust--it's done--and it's perfect, possibly defying the laws of baking! Worth every penny (and at that, prices are very reasonable!) looking forward to my next order (Oooh my bday is coming up!!)

Lindsay made the most tremendous Cake for me, at a price that was unbeatable. Everyone was gushing at the party, and it was a HUGE hit.

Perfect company to order from. You feel good ordering from a small local business that has high end flavors and skill!

Excellent experience.

Reply

Marissa Moritz

10/6/2014 01:05:25 am

Sugar Loaf (and the amazing talent behind it...Miss Lindsay Shepherd) created my husband & I's wedding cake (as well as my bachelorette cupcakes and birthday cake of the same year). The display cake was beautiful - exactly what we were looking for and more. There were so many amazing flavor combinations, we ended up going with two different ones for the cake that was passed. We continue to receive compliments on our wedding cake(s) to this day :) Sugar Loaf has the heart behind the flavor...something so completely necessary!

I could not be a bigger fan of Lindsay and her passion for creating that which leaves my stomach so happy :) THANK YOU, LINDSAY!

Reply

Kevin Durnbaugh

10/6/2014 05:37:23 am

Lindsay was fantastic at every step of the process, and made an incredibly cute assortment of cupcakes for a family birthday party. The delicious treats were carefully packaged up for the trip to Michigan, and perfect upon our arrival.

Even more impressively, Lindsay was able to customize the order for two dietary restrictions (gluten free and vegan), and kept everyone happy! I personally sampled all the cupcake versions, and each were equally satisfying and tasty.

I would definitely work with Lindsay again, and recommend her for any baking needs you have now or in the future.

Reply

Lauren Wenzel

10/7/2014 02:09:23 pm

Lindsay was such a joy to work with. After tasting one of her cupcakes and acquiring her business card, I emailed her rather last minute to see if she would be available to make cupcakes for our wedding. She was friendly, accommodating and went the extra mile to make everything look beautiful and taste even better. I have already recommended her to a friend and I will continue to do so.

We were blown away by Lindsay's decadent and beautiful cake she made for our wedding. It was more than we could have ever asked for. She made a butterscotch filling that I will dream about for a long time. She is truly an artist of her craft. Can't recommend her enough.

Reply

Sean Lamont

9/15/2015 12:24:00 pm

Lindsay is the consummate professional. Working remotely with my newly married wife and I to custom create a pastry menu for our wedding guests, she was able to inject a flair of fun into each of the delectable treats she created for us. From simple bars, elegant pastries, and an adorable wedding cake; all were a smash hit amongst those in attendance for their looks as well as their taste. One of the best decisions we made in our wedding planning process was to allow Lindsay the freedom to craft desserts in her own style, while following base guidelines we set, to surprise us all with her culinary skills. She will certainly be hearing from us a year from now (and for years to come) to recreate the magic she harnessed on our special day. Thank you Lindsay!

Thank you so much Sean and Beth- it was such a pleasure making them for you! Thanks for trusting me and giving me creative freedom, and I'm happy to do it again for you any time.

Reply

Victoria York

2/15/2016 02:00:23 pm

Oh my goodness, how delighted I was to see the beautifully presented pie pops!! I know, having tasted your delicious treats, that they will be an amazing delight! Thank you so much!!

Reply

Jeanne

6/14/2016 05:58:45 pm

I first had Sugarloaf at a birthday party and could not believe how amazing the cupcakes were...salted caramel. I remember it like it was yesterday! I've used Sugarloaf twice since, once for my sons graduation and for my wedding which was a large order. Both times I was beyond happy with the orders. Lindsey worked with me to make sure that I was happy with my selection. The guests loved them and luckily we ordered enough for people to take home. There is a large selection and everything is fresh and delicious. I can't wait for the next event to order more!

Reply

Jenni Reynolds

2/11/2017 06:58:03 pm

We had a birthday party for THREE 4-year-olds, each wanting a different theme. Lindsay incorporated all 3 themes (fire trucks, Thomas the Train and Curious George) into one adorable cake. All 3 kids LOVED it, and everyone at the party was commenting on how delicious it was. Thank you Lindsay - you knocked it out of the park!

Reply

Vlada R.

7/19/2017 01:44:33 pm

Lindsay and Sugar Loaf Cake were a life saver for me since the baker I retained months before had a family emergency and we were left in the lurch only 2 weeks before my daughter's birthday. Lindsay responded quickly, was helpful in coming up with ideas for flavors, size, and composition of the cake and was EXTREMELY responsive. On the day of, she showed up on time and took extreme care in setting the cake up appropriately. I sent her a picture of my vision for the cake when I placed the order, and it came out exactly the way it was supposed to. Beyond being BEAUTIFUL it was also absolutely delicious. We did a different flavor combination in each layer and the cake was almost demolished by the end of the affair (and many people took to-go boxes). Overall a wonderful experience from start to finish! Couldn't recommend her more.