This is an Open Access article distributed under the terms of the Creative Commons Attribution License (http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/2.0), which permits unrestricted use, distribution, and reproduction in any medium, provided the original work is properly cited.

Abstract

Background

The impairment of the pontine reticular formation (PRF) has recently been revealed
to be histopathologically connected with focal-cortical seizure induced generalized
convulsive status epilepticus. To elucidate whether the impairment of the PRF is a general phenomenon during status epilepticus, the focal-cortical 4-aminopyridine (4-AP) application was compared with other epilepsy
models. The presence of "dark" neurons in the PRF was investigated by the sensitive
silver method of Gallyas in rats sacrificed at 3 h after focal 4-AP crystal or systemic
4-AP, pilocarpine, or kainic acid application. The behavioral signs of the developing
epileptic seizures were scored in all rats. The EEG activity was recorded in eight
rats.

Results

Regardless of the initiating drug or method of administration, "dark" neurons were
consistently found in the PRF of animals entered the later phases of status epilepticus. EEG recordings demonstrated the presence of slow oscillations (1.5-2.5 Hz) simultaneously
with the appearance of giant "dark" neurons in the PRF.

Conclusion

We argue that the observed slow oscillation corresponds to the late periodic epileptiform
discharge phase of status epilepticus, and that the PRF may be involved in the progression of status epilepticus.

Background

Status epilepticus is an emergency in clinical practice, but the detailed mechanism of its pathology
is less well known. In fact, very few studies have examined the clinical consequences
of status epilepticus as a single morbidity [1], although a progressive sequence of electroencephalographic (EEG) changes during
generalized convulsive status epilepticus (GCSE) has been described [2]. GCSE typically begins as partial-onset status epilepticus and secondarily generalizes [3].

Recently, by combination of EEG monitoring and a sensitive silver method of Gallyas
[4-7], we discovered two "dark" neuron populations that may be of crucial importance in
generalization of epileptic seizures and the progression of status epilepticus [8]. Histopathologically, epileptic seizures can produce "dark" morphological change
in neurons [9], and these affected neurons are selectively and "spectacularly" visualized by the
Gallyas silver method [10,11]. In our study, epileptic seizures induced by focal-cortical application of K+ channel blocker 4-aminopyridine (4-AP) developed into status epilepticus with a slow oscillation (~1.5 Hz) at 6 h, which was correlated with the appearance
of both "dark" neurons in the pontine reticular formation (PRF) and "dark" interneurons
in the hippocampus [8]. The temporal profile of neuronal injury in the hippocampus is well described [6] and it is known that spontaneous seizures preferentially injure interneurons in the
hippocampus [4]. Therefore, in this study we focused on the PRF.

It is not known whether the giant neurons of the PRF are involved in the progression
of status epilepticus, although electrophysiological studies have suggested that the PRF may participate
in generation and maintenance of the epileptic state [12-15]. Nevertheless, experimental histopathology experiments have not investigated the
PRF for the presence of "dark" neurons following pilocarpine- or kainic acid-induced
status epilepticus [6].

In this study, we investigated the PRF for "dark" neurons 3 hours after the induction
of epileptic seizures. Focal-cortical application of 4-AP was compared with systemic
administration of 4-AP, pilocarpine or kainic acid. "Dark" neurons were found in the
PRF in all prolonged status epilepticus cases. It is also known from previous studies that brief seizures can confer tolerance
against prolonged seizures and neuronal damage [7,16-19] for example, prior administration of 4-AP protects against kainic acid-induced neuronal
cell death [20]. To investigate this, a cumulative approach was invoked to bring about status epilepticus. When the first attempt with 4-AP or pilocarpine failed to induced status epilepticus, we used kainic acid on the following day. Despite possible tolerance against cell
injury, "dark" neurons were still consistently found in the PRF.

Results

Focal-cortical 4-AP crystal application

Out of the four rats examined histopathologically, three entered status epilepticus at 3 h. All three rats had giant "dark" neurons in their PRF (Table 1), both in the oral and caudal pontine reticular field (PnO, PnC; Figure 1A,C) and also in the medullary reticular field (Gi; Figure 2A). One animal did not enter status epilepticus, and no "dark" neurons were found in its PRF (Table 1).

Figure 2.The "dark" gigantocellular network in the ponto-medullar reticular formation at 3
hours survival time, after the administration of focal-cortical 4-AP crystal, pilocarpine
or kainate. The giant "dark" neurons are stained together with their long dendrites in the gigantocellular
reticular field (Gi). Scale bars: A, B and C = 80 μm.

Systemic injections of 4-AP

Out of the four rats examined, two entered status epilepticus at 3 h, and they had giant "dark" neurons in their PRF (Table 1), in the PnO, PnC and in the mesencephalic and medullary reticular field (Gi). Two
animals did not enter status epilepticus, and no "dark" neurons were found in their PRF (Table 1).

Systemic injections of pilocarpine

Five of the six rats examined entered status epilepticus at 3 h, and all five had giant "dark" neurons in their PRF (Table 1), in the PnO, PnC (Figure 1B, D; and see Additional file 1) and Gi (Figure 2B). One animal did not enter status epilepticus, and no "dark" neurons were found in its PRF (see Additional file 1; Table 1).

Systemic injections of kainic acid

Two out of the four rats examined entered status epilepticus at 3 h, and both had giant "dark" neurons in their PRF (Table 1). The two other animals did not enter status epilepticus, but they reached Stage-3 of the behavioral scoring: forelimb clonus and "wet dog
shakes". In one of these animals 4-5 "dark" neurons were found in its PRF, the other
had none (Table 1).

Systemic injections of kainic acid as a second treatment

In these animals, the 4-AP or pilocarpine injection did not produce status epilepticus. Kainic acid was injected on the following day. Despite the possible tolerance effect
in these animals that would reduce the numbers of "dark" neurons, the "dark" neurons
were consistently found in the PRF. Out of the four rats examined, two received 4-AP
a day before. After kainic acid injection, these rats entered status epilepticus at 3 h and their PRF contained 15-30 giant "dark" neurons (see Table 1 and Figure 3). Two rats received pilocarpine treatment a day before. After kainic acid injection,
one of these rats entered status epilepticus at 3 h and had 10-15 "dark" neurons in its PRF. The other rat had multiple seizures
without status epilepticus and had 4-5 "dark" neurons in its PRF (Table 1).

Figure 3.Giant "dark" neurons in the pontine reticular formation (A and B) at 3 hours survival
time after intramuscular injection of kainic acid (KA). The Golgi-like staining highlights the giant "dark" neurons of the oral pontine
reticular field (PnO; A) and caudal pontine reticular field (PnC; B). The representative
EEG period demonstrates the generalized convulsive status epilepticus (C). On the
one-hour PSD graphs, there is a smaller peak at 2 Hz after the 4-AP injection a day
before the kainic acid treatment (red line), while there is a prominent, high peak
in the PSD at 2-2.5 Hz at 3 hours after the KA (D). The control PSD (gray line) was
calculated from a 30 min EEG recording before the kainic acid treatment. Abbreviations:
ISS and CSS: ipsi- and contralateral somatosensory cortex, CFC: contralateral frontal
cortex. Scale bars: A = 100 μm, B = 50 μm, C = 300 μV.

EEG analysis

The EEG was examined in eight rats (see ac4E, pi4E, pi6E, ka1-4E and ak2E in Table 1). Five rats entered status epilepticus after their respective treatment. The one-hour power spectral density (PSD) showed
a high peak at 1-1.5 Hz in case of focal-cortical crystal treatment (Figure 1G), a prominent peak at 1.5-2.0 Hz and a high increase in power at around 6 Hz in case
of pilocarpine treatment (Figure 1H, and see Additional file 2) at 3 hour. From the four kainic acid injected rats as a single treatment two entered
status epilepticus and they had a prominent peak at 1.5-2.0 Hz in their PSD (see Additional file 2). In case of rat ak2E, after its 4-AP i.p. injection, the one-hour PSD showed only a smaller peak at 2
Hz, but after its kainic acid injection there was a prominent, high peak at around
2.0-2.5 Hz (Figure 3D).

Discussion

In this study, we demonstrated that the pontine reticular formation is affected in
status epilepticus. It is not completely unknown that the PRF may participate in the generalization
and maintenance of epileptic state. Glutamate microinjections into the pons induces
electrographic seizures and clonic convulsions [13]. Infusion of NMDA antagonists into the PRF inhibits the generation of tonic and clonic
seizures induced by electroshock or pentylenetetrazol [12,14]. PRF neurons are implicated in seizure propagation in several forms of generalized
clonic seizures, including audiogenic seizures [15]. Furthermore, human fMRI and SPECT studies have also shown the involvement of the
pons in epileptic seizures [21-23].

The injured giant "dark" neurons of the PRF in this study were found by the Gallyas
silver staining method. This sensitive method highlights the injured cells in a Golgi-like
manner, but does not provide any information about the fate of the highlighted "dark"
neurons. On the other hand, it has long been known that the epilepsy-induced "dark"
neurons are able to recover [24]. Previous histopathological studies have demonstrated that the compacted "dark" neurons
have a high potential for recovery, but this capacity is influenced by the local environment
with its (patho-)metabolic processes [25,26]. The "dark" neurons at issue are in an otherwise undamaged environment, so we regard
the observed "dark" neurons in the PRF as injured cells with the capacity to recover.
Nevertheless, the gigantocellular network of the PRF was affected in our study during
status epilepticus, independently of the way the status epilepticus was induced.

Regarding the functional consequence of injury to the gigantocellular network of PRF,
it is well known from the classic discovery of Moruzzi and Magoun, that high-frequency
stimulation of the reticular formation produces an arousal response in the cortex.
The stimulation is the most effective in bringing about arousal when it is applied
to the PRF [27]. Lesions of the reticular formation produce a state of deep sleep or coma, block
the arousal, and lead to low frequency/high amplitude activity in the EEG [28,29]. This resembles the slow oscillation developed in our experiments in connection with
status epilepticus, so we could regard the observed slow oscillation as the electrophysiological consequence
of the formation of "dark", compacted, dysfunctional neurons in the PRF.

The observed slow oscillation is not completely unknown in epilepsy research. In kindled
animals, delayed slow rhythmic outlasting activities were reported at ~1.5 Hz, which
gradually developed following successive acute seizures [30]. The occurrence of interictal slow delta activities were also reported in patients
with epilepsy, and the presence of these electric activities was associated with more
severe forms of epilepsy [31-33]. Rhythmic diffuse delta frequency activity was also reported in non-convulsive status epilepticus [34,35].

Treiman et al. described the distinct EEG patterns that occur during prolonged episodes
of status epilepticus. They found that these identifiable EEG patterns occur in a predictable order during
status epilepticus, and the progression of EEG changes during status epilepticus follows a common electrical sequence regardless of the initiating factors [2]. The last phase of these patterns was called periodic epileptiform discharges, and
it has a low frequency. Later this periodic epileptiform discharges (PEDs) phase was
subdivided into early and late PEDs [36]. Early PEDs were characterized by monomorphic periodic discharges with a relatively
short flat background at around ~1.5 Hz. Late PEDs showed complex polymorphic periodic
discharges with a longer flat background at less than ~1.0 Hz [37]. The slow oscillations in our study would represent the early PEDs, and it is worth
noting that significantly elevated glucose utilization rates were observed in the
PRF during this phase of status epilepticus [36].

Our hypothesis about the generalization of the slow oscillation is the following.
The giant neurons of the PRF are receiving intense activation during the repeated
epileptic seizures, and their intense activation causes the ascending reticular activating
system (ARAS) to promote the generalization of the seizures. The giant neurons of
the PRF are glutamatergic, and they innervate each other, sending their long ascending
projections primarily to the intralaminar nuclei of the thalamus, which in turn project
to widespread cortical regions [38]. The seizure-related hyper-excitability of these glutamatergic neurons is reflected
in their elevated glucose utilization. The sustained depolarization, on the other
hand, results in elevated intracellular Ca++ levels in the PRF and ultimately an injured, compacted state: the formation of "dark"
neurons. We think that the giant "dark" neurons are suspending their activity or not
responding properly to synaptic (sensory) activation. This will result in a depression
of the functioning of the PRF network and because of the depression of the ARAS, generalized,
synchronized slow oscillation in the cortical EEG develops [28]. It is notable that the observed slow oscillation, and especially the late PEDs phases
of the status epilepticus are resemble to the 'slow' neocortical oscillation described by Steriade [39,40].

Generalized slow neocortical activity is also associated with EEG changes during the
state of coma [29,41]. This could be important, as experimental animals in prolonged status epilepticus could also enter post-ictal coma before full recovery [42,43]. Lesions in the PRF are associated with brainstem coma [29], but lesions in the reticular formation have been found in brains of people who have
post-polio fatigue syndrome [44,45]. Similarly post-ictal fatigue is one of the symptoms that can help distinguish patients
with epileptic seizures from those with non-epileptic seizures [46], and this could also suggest the involvement of the PRF in epileptic seizures.

Conclusion

We argue that the PRF is affected during status epilepticus, and its involvement could be important in the progression of the observed slow oscillation
corresponding to the periodic epileptiform discharges phase of status epilepticus.

Methods

Animals

Twenty-six adult male Sprague-Dawley rats (250-300 g; Charles RiverLaboratories, Hungary)
were kept in standard conditions under a 12 h light-dark cycle and food and water
were supplied ad libitum. The experiments were carried out on the basis of local ethical rules in accordance
with the Hungarian Act of Animal Care and Experimentation (1998, XXVIII, section 243/1998),
which conforms to the regulation of animal experiments in the European Community.
All efforts were made to minimize pain and suffering and to reduce the number of animals
used.

Focal-cortical 4-AP application

Rats (n = 5) were anesthetized with a 1-1.5% halothane (Narcotan, Leciva, Praha, Czech
Republic)-air mixture and secured in a stereotaxic frame (David Kopf, USA). For the
focal 4-AP application, a hole (1.5 mm in diameter) was drilled into the skull above
the right parieto-occipital cortex (A: 6.2 mm, L: 2.5 mm) [47]. The dura mater was carefully removed, and a piece of 4-AP crystal (0.5 mg/kg, Sigma-Aldrich,
Hungary) was locally placed onto the cortex. The hole was covered with a piece of
artificial fibrin sponge (Spongostan, Hungaropharma, Budapest, Hungary). Forty minutes
thereafter, the hole was washed out with physiological saline, covered with bone wax
(Medicommers Kft., Budapest, Hungary), and the halothane anesthesia was discontinued.
Four rats were examined histopathologically, out of the five receiving this treatment.
One rat died at 2-h, and it was not examined.

Systemic injections of kainic acid as a second treatment after 4-AP or pilocarpine

As a cumulative approach to bring about status epilepticus when the others failed, kainic acid was also injected as a second treatment. The kainic
acid treatment was performed on 4 animals that received 4-AP (n = 2) or pilocarpine
(n = 2) injections a day before, but did not produce status epilepticus. Kainic acid (kainic acid, Sigma-Aldrich, Hungary, 10 mg/kg; n = 4) was injected
subcutaneously on the following day, and in about 1.5 hours most of the animals entered
status epilepticus.

Behavioral scoring

To score the behavior of the rats after the induction of epileptic seizures, the Racine
Scale was used [48] with modifications [49,50]. Specifically, Stage-0: no response; Stage-1: behavioral arrest (motionless), hair
raising and rapid breathing salivation or hyperactivity, restlessness and vibrissae
twitching (movement of the lips, tongue and vibrissae); Stage-2: head nodding, head
and eye clonus (myoclonic jerks); Stage-3: forelimb clonus (unilateral or bilateral
limb clonus) and "wet dog shakes"; Stage-4: clonic seizures (forelimb clonic seizures)
and clonic rearing; Stage-5: generalized clonic seizures with falling, uncontrollable
jumping, and in the later phase, atonia.

EEG recordings

In eight rats (4-AP crystal, pilocarpine and kainic acid), EEG recordings were also
made before the histology. In these animals, one week prior to the induction of the
epileptic seizures, under halothane anesthesia, six holes were drilled into the superficial
layer of the skull above the frontal, the somatosensory and the parieto-occipital
cortices bilaterally; each was filled with conductive paste, through which a stainless-steel
electrode was inserted. The electrodes and the connector were embedded in dental acrylic.
This way the electrodes were firmly fixed to the skull but the dura were not pierced.
In five animals, 2-3 hours prior to the induction of the epileptic seizures, under
halothane anesthesia, six EEG electrodes were firmly clipped to the bare skin above
the skull in similar positions as above. These electrodes and the connector were also
embedded in dental acrylic. The EEG activity was recorded by a Grass EEG 8B model
(Grass Instruments, Quincy, MA, USA), filtered at 0.3 Hz to 70 Hz and amplified (20
k). Data was recorded with a CED 1401 system using SPIKE2 v2.1 software (Cambridge
Electronic Design Limited, Cambridge, UK). The sampling rate was 3000 Hz. From the
60-minute records the power spectral density (PSD) was calculated (NeuroExplorer v.3.2,
Nex Technologies, MA, USA). The specific parameters used were: Max. Freq. (Hz) = 10
Hz; Number of fr. values = 512; Interval filter = None; Smooth = None.

Perfusion and tissue sectioning

Rats were deeply anesthetized with an overdose of urethane (2 g/kg i.p., Sigma-Aldrich,
Hungary), and perfused through the aorta with physiological saline followed by 4%
buffered paraformaldehyde [11]. Brains were removed from the skull 1 day later, then immersed in the same fixative
for 1-3 days and frozen-sectioned at 60 μm.

Silver staining of "dark" neurons

Sections were incubated for 16 h at 56°C (esterification) in 1-propanol (Reanal, Budapest,
Hungary) containing 1.2% sulfuric acid (Carlo Erba Reagents, Italy). Following a 5-minute
treatment in 1% acetic acid (Reanal, Budapest, Hungary), they were immersed in a silicotungstate
physical developer until the background turned yellowish-brown [11]. Development was terminated by washing in 1% acetic acid for 30 min. Sections were
dehydrated, mounted, embedded in DePex (Fluka, Hungary) and coverslipped.

Authors' contributions

BP conceived of the study and carried out the experiments. VK participated in the
experiments. KAK participated in the design of the study and coordination. GJ participated
in the design of the study, coordination and helped to draft the manuscript. AC conceived
of the study, participated in its design and drafted the manuscript. All authors read
and approved the final manuscript.

Acknowledgements

We thank I. Vida and J. Csicsvari for reviewing the manuscript. This work was supported
by the National Office for Research and Technology (NKTH): DNT/RET, TÁMOP-4.2.2/08/1
and CellKom/RET, Hungary.