If this is your first visit, be sure to
check out the FAQ by clicking the
link above. You may have to register
before you can post: click the register link above to proceed. To start viewing messages,
select the forum that you want to visit from the selection below.

Please note that posts from new users are now moderated. If you have just joined this forum and post a new message it will be held in the moderation queue until a member of staff approves it. Please be patient and our staff will review your submission as soon as possible.

Re: "Do you like potato chips in general?"

"Do you like potato chips in general?"

I would read this as meaning: "Do you like potato chips as a type of food (without considering particular brands or flavours)?
An answer might be: "Yes, I eat them a lot, although I hate the vinegar ones".

For the meaning I think you are suggesting in (1), a more usual form would be "Do you generally (usually, normally) like potato chips?"

Re: "Do you like potato chips in general?"

The meaning of 'potato chips (that is) in general' is not particular chips like original chips, not onion flavored, or something, but come to think of it, it does not make sense

Then could you check the two sentences:

Americans in general are open-minded.

In general, Americans are open-minded.

Do you sense some difference between the two sentences and I think that 'in general' can modify Americans in the first and it modifies'are' in the second and there is some difference in meaning. what do you think? Thank you so much.

Re: "Do you like potato chips in general?"

1) Americans in general are open-minded.2) In general, Americans are open-minded.

Do you sense some difference between the two sentences and I think that 'in general' can modify Americans in the first and it modifies'are' in the second and there is some difference in meaning. what do you think? Thank you so much.

Perhaps:
1) Most Americans (without going into detail about exceptions) are open-minded.
2) Most of the time, more often than not, Americans are open-minded.
… but I think that most native speakers would take pretty much the same meaning from both statements.

Re: "Do you like potato chips in general?"

Thank you and your explanation is so clear, but I fell into confusion again because of the last sentence. Then most native English speakers would take which one between the two different ones and why? Thank you so much as always.

Re: "Do you like potato chips in general?"

Originally Posted by sky3120

Thank you and your explanation is so clear, but I fell into confusion again because of the last sentence. Then most native English speakers would take which one between the two different ones and why? Thank you so much as always.

Re: "Do you like potato chips in general?"

Likes and preferences are normally consistent, so these are unlikely distinctions. To ask about the frequency of someone's fondness of chips, it would be better to express it in a less ambiguous or unclear way. Obscure or theoretically possible meanings are best conveyed by rephrasing them to be clearer. If you want the person to say I only like potato chips in the winter months, then this is not the question to ask. It may be a theoretically possible interpretation, but practically it's pants. You have to take the expectations of your listener into account- people tend to go for the obvious meaning unless there are signals (intonation, etc) to help them.