The point of this post isn't, "Why isn't God giving everyone free guitars, and since he isn't that means he must not be real." The point is that this person believes that they are receiving a material gift that was an intention of "God." But why would any just God do such a thing when there is so much unneeded suffering in the world that is not being taken care of? But apparently he has the time to give someone a guitar, and possibly some drums.

What good would a free guitar do a homeless man? If God gave everybody a free guitar, there would be no demand for his musical skills. Pawn shops/ instrument stores would be overflowing with second hand guitars, and there would be no market for them since everyone who wanted one kept theirs, so that would eliminate chances of him being able to make money using it.

They didn't say everyone would get a good guitar. Everyone could get teh same ****** guitar (ie. people would still buy better guitars (especially since they're acoustics can't be upgraded/customized))

"Some trees flourish, others die. Some cattle grow strong, others are taken by wolves. Some men are born rich enough and dumb enough to enjoy their lives. Ain't nothing fair. You know that."
-John Marston