Has Uber and Lyft killed the taxi business?

Passengers from hell? Complaints or suggestions for Uber and Lyft? Glaring problem with the industry? Do you have stories of your horrible experiences with rideshare services? Leave your comments here and share your stories.

I'm a dispatcher, they haven't killed us but they have surely given us a wound we can't really recover from. Most of our drivers if they're not answering our calls or alerts from their systems about potential jobs we're assuming are doing Uber jobs.

Uber, Lyft, and Juno are all apps that show up on their phones during monthly inspections. We also have to make sure they're not using GPS cheaters to fake being somewhere while doing an Uber job.

Mostly what keeps us in business is SUV work and specialty vehicles like Mercedes Sprinter Vans and Passenger Vans, we also offer a lot more hands on responsibility than Uber. Our customers like knowing if they have a problem they can speak to someone who will give them an answer then and now. They also get to know and request their drivers and with Uber it's always random, so mostly it's older people who don't trust this new technology enough to let someone random drive them home a way they're unaccustomed to.

Comments

I frequently go to EWR Airport. They have an entire lot filled with yellow taxi's so they must still be able to make money. I also go into NY city (which I hate) they are stilled filled with taxi cabs. In some markets they are still being used and still making money. I always wondered why when I am looking for car unsurance they ask how many times per week I drive in NJ and NY. I now know why. NY and NJ have some of the most ignorant, rude, crazy drivers I ever seen. I thought CC Philadelphia was bad. NJ and NY are far more rude and dangerous. You can always tell a NY driver, they are always beeping their horns. Bumper to bumper traffic no where to go but NY taxi drivers are still beeping their horn. If I am ever given less than a year to live going to buy an old army jeep with reinforced bumpers. Then I am going to take a few rides into NJ and NY:) #hateNJ&NYtaxidrivers

By ignoring the changing technology, cab companies killed the business themselves. They had it their way so long they had no inkling it would ever change. A halfway functional phone app back in 2012 would've cut Uber et al off at the ankles; instead cab companies kept functioning as if there were still kerosene lamps lining city streets.

Whining about rideshare is a bunch of crocodile tears. Time to bury the old cab business and start calling rideshare by its true name: TAXI.

I agree that they fell behind the time with the dispatching technology. However the taxi industry tried but they couldn’t keep up. Why?

Localized regulations, localized taxi companies, localized taxi and medallion ownerships. There was no centralized organization that could invest, adopt such technology, and implement it everywhere. Uber has no regulations to deal with (in the beginning) and the world as the targetable audience, they had a huge leg up over localized taxi companies.

Speaking of regulations and medallions, the government who enforced those rules on them should have protected them or at the least made a move on Uber at much earlier stages. Not sure if that would have worked, but the complete ignoring of the taxi companies and medallion owners was purely pathetic.

Here at RideGuru we notice a lot of people write in with questions about scheduling rides. I think that is an area that taxi companies could really own.

Yes, Uber and Lyft allow ride scheduling, but it's flaky. There is no guarantee that a driver will be available, and we have heard anecdotes of people getting stood up by Uber and Lyft in those situations.

Limos do guaranteed scheduling, obviously, but are more expensive than taxis.

Market yourself as the go-to source for scheduling rides in your area and maybe you can carve a profitable niche.

I opened this thread thinking it was a question and when I read the OP's text I actually found it super fascinating. It is rare to hear insight from a dispatcher. Thanks for sharing! Would love to hear any other stories you might have, I am sure there are a few.