Irene Still on Track for Serious, though Non-Catastrophic, Hit

For a variety of practical reasons, I’ve had to focus my Irene-related energies exclusively on Twitter all day, and haven’t posted an update here in more than 12 hours. But, truth be told, I don’t have much new to say about the storm, meteorologically at least, that I didn’t say this morning.

Irene is continuing to move north (now slightly NNE, as expected) on the predicted track, with the computer models now tightly clustered around a path that, after walloping North Carolina’s Outer Banks, should take the storm’s center right up the coast, directly along the shore of the Delmarva and New Jersey, and then into (most likely) west or central Long Island. As for the storm’s intensity, it’s now down to 100 mph, a minimal Category 2, and re-strengthening still looks unlikely. After hitting North Carolina tomorrow morning at roughly its current intensity, Irene is still expected to start weakening more steadily, and hit the Mid-Atlantic and New York/New England as a Category 1 or strong tropical storm.

Really, at this point we’re in the stage of waiting and watching what the actual impacts will be. We can be fairly confident that the flooding rains will be severe, and that power outages will be widespread — but that otherwise, the winds won’t cause much severe damage beyond North Carolina (although the duration of sustained tropical-storm force winds will create some problems). The big question is how bad the storm surge will prove to be. (Speaking of which, you can watch various NOAA tidal gauges in Irene-affected regions here.)

It’s expected that the sheer size of Irene, coupled with astronomical high tides, coupled with the storm’s slow movement (meaning that, at any given location, winds of at least tropical-storm force may extend through an entire tide cycle or two), will result in a greater surge than you’d expect given what Irene’s wind speed will be. This expected surge is seen as a major threat to various coastal locations, including low-lying areas in New York City, as well as to the NYC subway system, which is why New York ordered an unprecedented mandatory evacuation of “Zone A” and all of the Rockaways, and announced it would shut down its entire transit system starting Saturday at noon. (It also led to New Jersey governor Chris Christie’s epic rant at dawdling beachgoers, in the YouTube clip at the top of this post.)

But will the surge predictions be borne out? I remember well the predictions of a catastrophic, higher-than-the-winds-would-indicate storm surge with Hurricane Ike in 2008, and those predictions weren’t borne out by the reality (although the surge was plenty bad). Will the same thing happen with Irene, or will the surge meet (or exceed) forecasters’ expectations? I just don’t know. I certainly continue to strongly urge everyone to assume the predictions are true, and prepare for the worst. But I’m really very curious to see what will happen. Will the subways flood? Will the airports and the Rockaways be submerged? Will much of Hoboken be underwater? We’ll find out soon!

In the mean time, some smart decisions were made today. Mayor Bloomberg proved he’s not an idiot — well, at least not on this issue — and that he’s no Ray Nagin (who, incidentally, is apparently MSNBC’s new disaster preparedness expert), by ordering the mandatory evacuation around midday today, instead of tomorrow morning as he’d foolishly planned. Also, the NFL preseason game between the Jets and Giants, which had been absurdly scheduled to go forward tomorrow afternoon amid evacuations and transit shutdowns, has been rightly postponed to Monday evening. Sanity prevails over indefensible idiocy. Hooray!

Of course, the biggest decisions are the ones to be made in the next 12-18 hours by individual people in the path of this storm, deciding whether to take it seriously and what precautions to take. Bottom line: take it seriously. If you’re in an evacuation zone, leave. If you’re not, hunker down and make sure you have everything you need for a potentially long and unpleasant aftermath. Maybe some of the evacuations will prove, with the benefit of hindsight, to have been unnecessary, and maybe some of the hurricane-kit items won’t be needed, but it’s far better to be safe than sorry, especially when dealing with something as difficult to predict as a hurricane. So, as I keep saying on Twitter, take Irene seriously and #PREPARE.

And remember that, if the worst doesn’t happen, that doesn’t mean the storm was “overhyped.” It means that, of the various plausible scenarios that presented themselves to forecasters, we ended up experiencing one of the numerous “less bad” scenarios. Worst-cases are always unlikely, and most hurricane “alarms” end up being, at least in part, “false” alarms. That’s just the nature of the beast, as I wrote in my “misconceptions” post. It doesn’t mean we shouldn’t prepare for the worst — every time. Hope for the best, prepare for the worst. There’s just no other choice. That’s exactly what people should keep doing now.

Oh, and get the Hell off the beach.

Click here to view the 15 legacy comments

Click here to hide legacy comments

15 Comments, 15 Threads

1.
bastiches

iAnd remember that, if the worst doesn’t happen, that doesn’t mean the storm was “overhyped.”/i

Yes, actually it can mean that it was. Youre not the sum total of reporting on the storm so why are you waving off criticism?

Heres the question; can you name a storm that iwas/i overhyped. How was this different?

We left NYC and our 17th floor lower Manhattan apartment yesterday and drove to Ithaca. Our cats, having never left the confines of our home since they were kittens, are totally freaked out. Truth be told, I am too.

Strange Hurricane this Irene was,pressure and winds did not match nor the warm waters of the Gulf Stream strengthen it.
Its like it had a mind of its own.
The weather experts called it as they saw it and Irene played them along,weakened and petered out with the goal of making them look bad,just like the boy who cried wolf.
Could it be an unintended set up for an even greater disaster down the road ?
The next time another Irene comes a callin the majority will remember Irene and ignore all the warnings and die and the few will heed the Weathermens next warnings and survive.

Seems not enough consider J.J.Seftons option in the previous comment. And Brendan doesnt suggest it as an option (and government officials should highlight this as an option).

Seems to me that people who have any concern about their structure or location should consider evacuation days ahead of a storm. Go inland to a friend or familys sturdy non-floodable house (even 30 more miles inland could save your life).

IOW, dont stay just because your arent in a mandatory evacuation zone.

And just what authority/expertise does Brendan Loy claim in this matter? Unlike the usual PJM article, there is no information at the bottom of the article stating his credentials as a weather forecaster. Ive never heard of him either. He looks to be about 17 in his photo, not like a man with a wealth of experience in meteorology – or anything else for that matter.

Obama screwed up another one! Some woman on MSNBC was trying to cover for him last night. Of course, the media over-hypes these things but Obama under-hyped it. He should have come home IMMEDIATELY, stood on the White House lawn and DEMANDED that the storm cease and desist all, well, storming.
When the storm fizzled, he could have taken credit; the media would gladly give him endless credit and he would have demonstrated supreme leadership, for once.
This is a puzzling failure by Obama and, especially, his advisers.

Sparky, you shouldn’t take my words as gospel, as I wrote on Thursday; scroll down to the part where I address the “misconception” that “I, Brendan Loy, should be your primary source for information about this..”

I’ve always been very clear about my lack of meteorological credentials. I’m just a guy who likes to follow hurricanes and knows a fair amount about them as a layman. I got a lot of attention for my coverage of Katrina. But I don’t make independent predictions. I just try to summarize, sythesize and at times “translate” the information from actual meteorologists that’s out there.

Im just an interested amateur ( not nearly as knowledgable as you appear to be). On the lack of strengthening, I wonder whether the storms very size was a factor in that – the strenghtening energy may be dissipated over a wider area.

Whatever, the reason, Im glad its not going to be the disaster everyone feared; at least that seems to be the trend. You are right to say that this should not cause us to lower our guard next time. Every hurricane is unique, there is no such thing as just like [insert storm name here]. With hurricanes, the past never predicts the future.

Mother Nature can be extremely powerful. Its so interesting to think about how susceptible we are. Our only option for safety is preparedness. There is actually a really great webinar online that talks about protecting yourself from emergencies and getting prepared for them if they do happen.
Check it out:http://www.provpubs.com/webinars/webinar-emergencypreparedness/