9gag hasn't gotten to it yet. It's currently in the stage of reddit, tumblr, and facebook pages killing it. In a couple months after it's completely dead it will be on 9gag. After the meme has already been raped to the point that it no longer resembles it's original form hot topic will make shirts of it, and that will be the final nail in it's coffin.

Jimmy Wars... the Rustlement Due
Jimmy 18
Rustle no Jimmies
Five Jimmies (the chorus being I ruuuustle, fiiive jiiiimiiiies)
Rustling Was the Cure
Rustlecretia
Tornado of Jimmies
Rustle Patrol
Rustle In Peace... Jimmy

brutal_descent

05-29-2012, 09:53 AM

Mastodon edition:

The Jimmy Is Rustled
Rustling Jimmy (Sleeing Giant)
Rustlers of the Jimmy (Hunters of the Sky)
Rustle the Jimmy (Crack the Skye)
All the Rustled Jimmies
Where Rustles the Jimmy
Rustled Under Jimmy

BloodoftheKings

05-29-2012, 10:24 AM

Mastodon edition:

The Jimmy Is Rustled
Rustling Jimmy (Sleeing Giant)
Rustlers of the Jimmy (Hunters of the Sky)
Rustle the Jimmy (Crack the Skye)
All the Rustled Jimmies
Where Rustles the Jimmy
Rustled Under Jimmy

It's not funny when you can't really tell what song it's supposed to be.

Sanitarium78

05-29-2012, 05:43 PM

It's not funny when you can't really tell what song it's supposed to be.

No, it's not funny because no internet meme has ever been or ever will be funny.