Three RiversHudson~Mohawk~SchoharieHistory From America's Most Famous Valleys

The
Campaign of Lieut. Gen. John Burgoyneand The Expedition of Lieut. Col. Barry St. Leger.by William L. Stone.Albany, NY, Joel Munsell. 1877.

XIII.
At eleven o'clock on the morning of the 17th, the royal army left their fortified
camp, and marched to the green in front of old Fort Hardy, on the meadow just
north of Fish creek, at its junction with the Hudson.1 Here in the presence
only of Morgan "Lewis and Wilkinson, representing the American army,
they left their cannon and small arms. With a longing eye the artilleryman
looked for the last time upon his faithful gun, parting with it as from his
bride, and that forever. With tears trickling down his bronzed cheeks, the
bearded grenadier stacked his musket to resume it no more. Others in their
rage, knocked off the butts of their arms, and the drummers stamped their
drums to pieces. 2

1 Fort Hardy was a military work built by the English, during
the governorship of Sir Charles Hardy, and was intended to supersede the old
fort which had been erected as early as the war of William and Mary, during
the latter part of the 17th century. The lines of the entrenchments embrace
about fifteen acres of ground. The outer works yet retain the appearance of
a strong fortification, bounded south by the north side of Fish creek, and
east by the right bank of the Hudson. Human bones, fragments of fire-arms,
swords, balls, tools, implements, and broken crockery, are frequently picked
up on this ground. In excavating the earth for the Champlain canal, which
passes a few rods west of this fort, such numbers of human skeletons were
found, as make it highly probable that this was the cemetery of the garrison.

2
" General Riedesel was deeply affected by the sad events. At eight o'clock
in the morning of the 17th, he collected all the German troops, and informed
them of their fate. In solemnity and in silence, and with drooping heads,
the brave and tried warriors heard the words from the mouth of their beloved
leader, whose voice, manly at all times, trembled on this occasion, and who
was obliged to summon all of his self-control to hide his emotions. ' It was
no lack of courage on your part,' said he, among other things, to his men,
' by which this awful fate has come upon you. You will always be justified
in the eyes of the world.' He concluded his address, with the exhortation,
that as good soldiers they should bear their misfortune with courage, and
do their duty at all times, displaying order and discipline; for in so doing,
they would retain the love of their sovereign, and the respect of their enemies.

"
General Riedesel's next care was to save the colors. He, therefore, had them
taken down from the flag staff, and gave them to his wife, who had them sewed
up by a faithful soldier who was a tailor. Henceforth he slept upon them and
fortunately saved them. What a dreary future was now in store for the weary
soldier in this distant land ! Certain of victory a few days ago after so
many glorious battles, all prospect for honor and glory was lost in this campaign.
In a few hours they were to lay down their arms, those arms with which they
had so bravely fought against their enemies, those arms, too, that were now
to be surrendered to the enemy, on whose will they were now dependent. Verily,
a sadder fate than this cannot be imagined for a soldier !

"
Inwardly, however, Riedesel chafed exceedingly at the result and at the bad
management which had brought it about. In the first moments of vexation he
wrote to the reigning prince at Brunswick as follows :

"
' Your serene highness will understand by the accompanying report, now submitted
to you, into what a desolate position our fine maneuvers have placed me and
the troops of your highness. The reputation I have gained in Germany has been
sacrificed to certain individuals, and I consider myself the most unfortunate
man on earth.'

"
But neither the court nor the public of Brunswick laid anything to the charge
of Riedesel, or the troops. On the contrary, they felt the greatest sympathy
with them in their unfortunate fate. This is shown, not only by the letters
of Duke Charles, and Duke Ferdinand, the hereditary prince of Brunswick, but
by the newspapers of that day, in which neither the troops nor their generals
are in the slightest degree reproached. On the contrary, they acknowledge
their good behavior."- Memoirs of General Riedesel.

Immediately
after the surrender, the British took up their march for Boston, whence they
expected to embark, and bivouacked the first night at their old encampment
at the base of the hill where Fraser was buried.

As
they debouched from the meadow, where they had deposited their arms, they
passed between the Continentals who were drawn up in parallel lines. But on
no face did they see exultation. '' As we passed the American army,"
writes Lieut. Anbury, one of the captured officers, and bitterly prejudiced
against his conquerors, " I did not observe the least disrespect, or
even a taunting look, but all was mute astonishment and pity ; and it gave
us no little comfort to notice this civil deportment to a captured enemy,
unmarred by the exulting air of victors." 1

Early
the same morning General Wilkinson, before the capitulation, visited Burgoyne
in his camp, and accompanied him to the ground where his army were to lay
down their arms. Having inspected the place, the two generals rode to the
bank of the Hudson, where Burgoyne, surveying it with attention, asked his
companion whether it was not fordable at that place ? " Certainly, sir,"
said Wilkinson, " but do you observe the people on the opposite shore
?" " Yes," replied Burgoyne, "I have seen them too long!"

The
English general having expressed a wish to be formally introduced to his old
comrade. Gates, Wilkinson arranged an interview a few moments after the capitulation.
In anticipation of this meeting, Burgoyne had

1
"General Gates showed himself on this occasion, exceedingly noble and
generous toward the captives. That he might show in some manner the feeling
of the Americans, he commanded his troops to wheel round the instant the English
laid down their arms. He, himself, drew down the curtains of his carriage
in which he had driven to the ground, and in which he was then seated."
-Brunswick Journal.

bestowed
the greatest care upon his toilet. He had attired himself in full court dress,
and wore costly regimentals and a richly decorated hat with streaming plumes.
Gates, a smaller man and with much less of manner, on the contrary, was dressed
merely in a plain blue overcoat, which had upon it scarcely anything indicative
of his rank. Upon the two generals first catching a glimpse of each other,
they stepped forward simultaneously and advanced, until they were only a few
steps apart, when they halted. The English general took off his hat, and making
a polite bow, said. " The fortune of war. General Gates, has made me
your prisoner." The American general, in reply, simply returned his greeting
and said : " I shall always be ready to testify, that it has not been
through any fault of your excellency."1 As soon as this introduction
was over the other captive generals and their suites repaired to the cabin
which constituted the head-quarters of Gates, where they

1
A marginal note - supposed to be in the hand-writing of George Clinton - in
Burgoyne's orderly book, gives the conversation between the two generals as
follows : " ' I am glad to see you,' said Gates. ' I am not glad to see
you,' replied Burgoyne, ' It is my fortune, sir, and not my fault that I am
here.' " Wilkinson, however, an eye-witness of the scene, and generally
very accurate, gives the version in the text, which is more in keeping with
the urbane manner that invariably characterized the English general.

The
place where this meeting took place is about a hundred rods south of Fish
creek, and fifty rods notch of Gates's headquarters The bridge over the Champlain
canal at this point probably indicates pretty accurately the precise spot.

The
headquarters of Gates was, in the language of Wilkinson, " A small hovel,
about ten feet square, at the foot of a hill, out of which it had been partially
dug , the floor had been prepared by nature, while in one corner four forks
with cross-pieces, supported the boards which received the general's pallet."

were received with the greatest courtesy, and with the consideration due to
brave but unfortunate men. After Riedesel had been presented to Gates, Morgan
1 and other American officers, he sent for his wife and children. It is to
this circumstance, that we owe the portraiture of a lovely trait in General
Schuyler's character. " In our passage through the American camp,"
the baroness writes, "I observed with great satisfaction, that no one
cast at us scornful glances. On the contrary, they all greeted me, even showing
compassion on their countenances at seeing a mother with her little children
in such a condition. I confess I feared to come into the enemy's camp, as
the thing was so entirely new

1
'Morgan was a large, strong bodied personage, whose appearance gave the idea
history has left us of Belisarius. His manners were of the severer cast, but
where he became attached he was kind and truly affectionate. This is said,
from experience of the most sensitive and pleasing nature, activity, spirit
and courage in a soldier, procured his good will and esteem. He was a strict
disciplinarian. Permit an anecdote. He had obtained the command of the rifle
corps from Arnold without any advertence to the better claim of Hendricks,
who, though the younger man was of the three captains, in point of rank, by
the dates of commissions, the superior officer. Hendricks, for the sake of
peace in the army, and of good order, prudently and good naturedly acquiesced
in his assumption of the command, for Morgan had seen more service in our
former wars.

At
this place Morgan had given it out in orders, that no one should fire. One
Chamberlaine, a worthless fellow, who did not think it worth while to draw
his bullet, had gone some hundreds of yards into the woods, and discharged
his gun. Lieut. Steele happened to be in that quarter at the time; Steele
had but arrived at the fire, where we sat, when Morgan, who had seen him coming,
approached our camp, and seated himself within our circle. Presently Chamberlain
came, gun in hand, and was passing our fire, towards that of his mess. Morgan
called to the soldier, accused him as the defaulter, this the man (an arrant
liar) denied. Morgan appealed to Steele. Steele admitted he heard the report,
but knew not the party who discharged the gun. Morgan suddenly springing to
a pile of billets, took one, and swore he would knock the accused down unless
he confessed the fact. Instantly, Smith seized another billet, and swore he
would strike Morgan if he struck the man. Morgan knowing the tenure of his
rank receded. This was the only spirited act I knew of Smith. Such were the
rough-hewn characters which, in a few subsequent years, by energy of mind
and activity of body, bore us safely through the dreadful storms of the revolution.
Morgan was of an impetuous temper, yet withal, prudent in war, as he was fearless
of personal danger. His passions were quick and easily excited, but they were
soon cooled. This observation is applicable to many men of great talents,
and to none more than Morgan. His severity, at times, has made me shudder,
though it was necessary, yet it would have been a pleasing trait in his character
if it had been less rigid."- Henry's Journal of Arnold's Expedition
against Quebec in 1775.

to me. When I approached the tents a noble looking man came toward me and
took the children out of the wagon ; embraced and kissed them ; and then with
tears in his eyes helped me also to alight. He then led me to the tent of
General Gates, with whom I found Generals Burgoyne and Phillips who were upon
an extremely friendly footing with him. Presently, the man who had received
me so kindly, came up and said to me : ' It may be embarrassing to you to
dine with all these gentlemen , come now with your children into my tent,
where I will give you, it is true, a frugal meal, but one that will be accompanied
by the best of wishes.' ' You are certainly,' answered I, 'a husband and a
father since you show me so much kindness.' I then learned that he was the
American General Schuyler."

The
English and German generals dined with the American commander in his tent,
on boards laid across barrels. The dinner which was served up in four dishes
consisted only of ordinary viands, the Americans at this period being accustomed
to plain and frugal meals. The drink, on this occasion, was cider, and rum
mixed with water. Burgoyne appeared in excellent humor. He talked a great
deal and spoke very flatteringly of the Americans, remarking among other things
that he admired the number, dress and discipline of their army and above all
the decorum and regularity that were observed. " Your funds of men,"
he said to Gates, "are inexhaustible. Like the Hydra's head, when cut
off, seven more spring up in its stead."

He
also proposed a toast to General Washington, an attention that Gates returned
by drinking the health of the king of England. The conversation on both sides
was unrestrained, affable and free. Indeed the conduct of Gates throughout,
after the terms of the surrender had been adjusted, was marked with equal
delicacy and magnanimity, as Burgoyne himself admitted in a letter to the
Earl of Derby. In that letter, the captive general particularly mentioned
one circumstance which he said exceeded all he had ever seen or read of on
a like occasion. It was, that when the British soldiers had marched out of
their camp to the place where they were to pile their arms, not a man of the
American troops was to be seen. General Gates having ordered his whole army
out of sight, that not one of them should be a spectator of the humiliation
of the British troops. This was a refinement of delicacy and of military generosity
and politeness reflecting the highest credit upon the conqueror; and was spoken
of by the officers of Burgoyne in the strongest terms of approbation. 1

As
the company rose from table, the royal army filed past in their march to the
seaboard. Thereupon, by preconcerted arrangement, the generals stepped out,
and Burgoyne drawing his sword presented it in the presence of the two armies
to General Gates. The latter received it with a courteous bow, and immediately
returned it to the vanquished general. Colonel Trumbull has graphically depicted
this scene in one of his paintings in the rotunda at Washington.2

1
Remembrancer of 1777, pages 482 and 3. A letter published in that repository
of the American Revolution, at the same time, stated that " some few
of the New England men desired to have Burgoyne in their hands for half an
hour. Being asked for what purpose, they said they 'would do him no harm ,
they would tar and feather him, and make him stand on the head of one of his
own empty beef-barrels, and read his own proclamation.' " p. 481-82.
If made at all, the suggestion must have been merely the sportive sally of
a wag.

2
The headquarters of General Gates-when the surrender took place were situated
about one hundred and fifty rods south of Fish creek, very nearly on the west
side of the present river road from Schuylerville to Stillwater, in a rude
cabin partially dug out of the bank on that side of the road. By some-and
it has given rise to much discussion - it has been supposed, that these headquarters
were on a bluff overlooking the scene of the laying down of arms, just south
of Fish creek, and nearly fronting Schuyler's house. This mistake, how-ever,
probably arose from the fact, that, during the negotiations between the two
generals for the surrender, a tent, for the accommodation of General Wilkinson
on the part of Gates, and of Major Kingston of Burgoyne, was pitched, says
Wilkinson, " between the advanced guards of the two armies, on the first
bank just above General Schuyler's saw-mill." Thus, very naturally, the
mistake arose - that it was a mistake, there can be not the shadow of a doubt,
as any one, who will read Wikinson attentively, must at once perceive.- See
General Mattoon's Letter, Appendix XIII.

"My
father, then a small boy, living a mile and a half west of this village (Ballston,
N. Y.), which was then a wilderness, remembers to have heard the noise of
the artillery in both engagements. Several of the neighbors went over to Saratoga
(Schuylerville) to witness the capitulation. He remembered that Judge Beriah
Palmer stopped at the house on his return and said he saw Gen. Burgoyne surrender
his sword to Gen. Gates, and gave many particulars of the occurrence."-Hon.
Geo. G. Scott of Ballston, N. Y., to the author, June 13, 1877.

General
Schuyler, as we have seen, was in the camp with Gates at the time of the surrender
; and when Burgoyne, with his general officers, arrived in Albany, they were
the guests of Schuyler, by whom they were treated with great hospitality.
Madame Riedesel, also, speaks with much feeling of the kindness she received
on this occasion at the hands of Mrs. Schuyler and her daughters. The urbanity
of General Schuyler's manners, and the chivalric magnanimity of his character,
smarting as he was under the extent and severity of his pecuniary losses,
are attested by General Burgoyne, himself, in his speech in 1778, in the British
House of Commons, He then declared that, by his orders, " a very good
dwelling house, exceeding large store-houses, great saw-mills, and other out-buildings,
to the value altogether perhaps of £10,000 sterling," belonging
to General Schuyler, at Saratoga, were destroyed by fire a few days before
the surrender to give greater play to his artillery. He said further, that
one of the first persons he saw, after the Convention was signed, was General
Schuyler, and when expressing to him his regret at the event which had happened
to his property. General Schuyler desired him " to think no more of it,
and that the occasion justified it according to the rules of war." "He
did more," continued Burgoyne ; " he sent an aid-de-camp' to conduct
me to Albany, in order, as he expressed it, to procure better quarters than
a stranger might be able to find. That gentleman conducted me to a very elegant
house, and to my great surprise, presented me to Mrs. Schuyler and her family.
In that house I remained during my whole stay in Albany, with a table of more
than twenty covers for me and my friends, and every other demonstration of
hospitality."2

1
The late Col. Richard Varick, then the military secretary of General Schuyler.

During
Mrs. Riedesel's stay at Albany, as the guest of Gen. and Mrs. Schuyler, one
of her little girls, on first coming into the house, exclaimed, " Oh
mama ! Is this the palace papa was to have when he came to America?"
As the Schuyler family understood German, Madame Riedesel colored at the remark,
which, however, was pleasantly got over.- Life of Peter Van Schaick.

The
Schuyler mansion, which stands on Clinton street facing Schuyler street, was
not built by Schuyler, himself, but by the wife of General Bradstreet while
the latter was on his expedition to Oswego in 1759. The barracks stood some
fifteen rods back of the house, between which it is supposed an underground
passage existed, though no traces of it have ever been found. The mansion
even for this day is a fine one , and for that period must have been superb.
It is now (1877) owned and occupied by Mrs. John Tracey. Mrs. Tracey, who
cherishes all the traditions of the place, received the author with great
courtesy, and kindly acted as his cicerone in visiting the interior
of the house and the grounds. For the attempt to capture Schuyler by the Indians
and Tories see Lossing's Field Book of the Revolution. The mark of
the tomahawk, which, hurled at Mrs. Schuyler's daughter as she snatched her
infant sister from its cradle to bear it to a place of safety, is still clearly
seen on the banister.