I would like to see a challenge with a timer like the ones in the campaign. As in, a countdown timer. You must eliminate all enemy AIs within 30-90 minutes, depending on the size of the map. Say, 30 minutes for a 2P map, 60 minutes for a 4P map variant of this type of challenge, and 90 minutes for a variant of this challenge on an 8P map.

"There is no greater Void than the one between your ears." - Void Ray, StarCraft 2.Especially the Void between the ears of people who think that No VTOL is a good idea, and won't lead to arty wars. I've won one, and I have to say: I hated it.

Umm... This is where you are supposed to post suggestions for new challenges. This is a suggestion for a new challenge. What do you mean "Please post this in the proper place"?

This most definitely does not belong in Ideas and Suggestions, unless one of the webmasters/developers says otherwise.

"There is no greater Void than the one between your ears." - Void Ray, StarCraft 2.Especially the Void between the ears of people who think that No VTOL is a good idea, and won't lead to arty wars. I've won one, and I have to say: I hated it.

Well, then, please specify so in your initial post. Any one of the mods, go ahead and lock this thread. I'll repost in the appropriate place.

"There is no greater Void than the one between your ears." - Void Ray, StarCraft 2.Especially the Void between the ears of people who think that No VTOL is a good idea, and won't lead to arty wars. I've won one, and I have to say: I hated it.

Hmmm, well, those of us that broke the rules and made a thread for an idea rather than a completed challenge, will just have to make the ideas into challenges- or at least do 90% of the work (making the map, setting player conditions, placing structures, etc), so that it is a *challenge*, not an *idea for a challenge*

Well, I'm not entirely sure that threads for challenge ideas is a bad idea. I'm leaving these here, for now, k? The idea thread is for brainstorming, while new threads can be for complete ideas that we're looking for feedback on.

Sure. Works for me. By the way, how about a ranking thread? I can even take care of it.

"There is no greater Void than the one between your ears." - Void Ray, StarCraft 2.Especially the Void between the ears of people who think that No VTOL is a good idea, and won't lead to arty wars. I've won one, and I have to say: I hated it.

"There is no greater Void than the one between your ears." - Void Ray, StarCraft 2.Especially the Void between the ears of people who think that No VTOL is a good idea, and won't lead to arty wars. I've won one, and I have to say: I hated it.