YOUR SOURCE FOR TRUTH

Wednesday, April 8, 2015

Condors, Already F*cked, Get Fracked

Expanding fracking in a California condor
sanctuary could kill an endangered species we’ve worked hard–and spent
millions–to save.

ancy
Mauthe remembers walking along the Sespe Wilderness in the early 1980s
and wondering if she would ever see a California condor there again.

In 1982, there were only 23 wild condors left in the world.
The majestic species—with the largest wingspan of any North American
bird—was nearly extinct. Lead and DDT poisoning, habitat destruction
and poaching had crippled the population.

The condors have made a slow comeback, aided by more than $60 million in federal and private funds. Today, there are 230 condors living in the wild, but the species still teeters on the edge of survival.

Now, a new report suggests that the condors may face another enemy.

A draft environmental impact report by California’s
Division of Oil, Gas and Geothermal Resources (DOGGR) suggests that oil
and gas production could have significant and unavoidable impacts for
endangered species, potentially devastating entire populations.

“Well-stimulation treatments could cause displacement
or mortality of fish and wildlife,” reads the document.
“Well-stimulation” includes hydraulic fracturing, aka fracking, the
practice of blasting water, sand and chemicals into a well to crack
underground rock and extract more fossil fuels. For most species,
“displacement, mortality or injury would not cause populations to drop
below self-sustaining levels,” the report says. “However, adverse
effects to listed or fully protected species could jeopardize the
population viability.”

Condors stand out in the state document. “Due to its
state and federal endangered species status, large home ranges and
curiosity, the California condor is the most important special-status
bird that could be found on well-stimulation sites,” the report notes.

It specifically cites the risk fracking poses to the
birds in the Sespe Condor Sanctuary, which has been federally designated
a “critical habitat” for condors, meaning it is essential to the
species’ conservation. The Sespe, the only sanctuary for the birds in
the world, is home to more than 60 condors, one of the largest wild
populations.

How safe a sanctuary?

The 53,000-acre Sespe Condor Sanctuary juts out of
Southern California like a closed fist. Oaks and chaparral stud the
sandstone. The sanctuary is part of the Los Padres National Forest,
which stretches along much of the mountainous coast from Monterey to
Ventura.

It’s also the address of a large oil and gas
operation—there are more than 300 active wells in the Sespe. Most of the
16,000-acre oil field is within the national forest, and about 1,000
acres lie inside the sanctuary. Seneca Resources Corporation, the oil
company responsible for most of the drilling in the Sespe, also has 12
injection wells here, which it uses for fracking and for disposal of
fracking wastewater. Recent investigations have found that the state has
failed to regulate wastewater injection wells, and that fracking waste
routinely pollutes underground aquifers that may hold usable drinking
water. The EPA is now looking into the matter.

Seneca wants to expand its operations in the Sespe.
The company has submitted plans to drill eight new fracking wells and
install 8,000 feet of new pipeline, 285 of which would traverse
previously undisturbed areas. The Los Padres National Forest and Bureau
of Land Management, which also oversees land in the Sespe, are preparing
an environmental analysis of the project, which will help determine
whether it can go forward.

The U.S. Fish and Wildlife Service, which manages the Condor Recovery Program, maintains that fracking shouldn’t negatively affect the birds
as long as mitigation measures laid out by the service are followed. In
the Sespe, oil operators are currently banned from drilling within a
mile and a half of a nest site. They're also required to install landing
deterrents on wells, place new power lines underground when possible,
and clean up “microtrash,” like bottle caps or bits of plastic or glass,
which often kills condor fledglings.

“They are inquisitive birds, and they are social and
want to interact with their environment, but if [the oil companies]
follow those rules, condors are not really affected by drilling
activities,” says Michael Brady, project leader for the California Condor Recovery program.
The DOGGR report, however, proposes additional protective measures,
such as monitoring for the presence of condors and preventing litter or
microtrash from entering the worksites.

But even these efforts may not be enough.

Nursed back from the brink

Condors, with their tenuous grasp on life and their
stature in American history—they are revered by many Native American
tribes and once flew in great numbers over Western skies— have inspired
heroic measures. About $60 million has been spent trying to save the
condor since 1982, says John McCamman, the California condor co-
ordinator for the U.S. Fish and Wildlife Service. The federal government
provides almost $2 million a year to the program, and about $3 million
annually comes from private sources.

Condors were first reintroduced to the wild in 1992,
in the Sespe. Since then, small wild populations have also been
established in other parts of California, as well as Arizona, Utah and
Baja, Mexico.

Biologists zealously monitor the birds—each one has a
large, numbered tag affixed to a wing—and when a chick is born, field
workers often rappel to the nest and clean it of microtrash. If an egg
is not viable, they will try to swap it with one from a zoo.“It’s a
year-round job for the field biologists as they’re watching the bird,”
Brady says.

Each year, zoo-bred condors are released to keep up
the populations, which are not yet at self-sustaining levels. Too many
birds die before they can reproduce, or reproduce enough. Often chicks
born in the wild do not survive. Nearly a tenth of the wild population
died last year.

Lead is still largely to blame, says Myra Finkelstein,
an associate adjunct professor of microbiology and environmental
toxicology at UC Santa Cruz who is studying condors. Scientists believe
spent lead bullets and their fragments are a major source of poisoning
for the birds, which primarily eat dead mammals. Of the condors that
died last year, three were killed by lead, three died of unknown
reasons, two of predation and one of trauma, and 15 are still awaiting
autopsies. A new state law prohibiting hunters from using lead
ammunition does not go into effect until July 2019.

But habitat destruction and other chemicals in the
environment—such as those from fracking—could also be a potential threat
to condors, Finkelstein says.

Though no research has been conducted on fracking
pollution in the Sespe, a number of recent studies have found elevated
levels of carcinogens— arsenic, benzene and toluene—in the air, water
and soil surrounding other fracking sites. Don Smith, a UC Santa Cruz
professor who studies how chemicals affect humans and animals, including
the condor, says “any exposure [to these chemicals] could increase the
risk of cancer over a lifetime.” Benzene and toluene can also alter the
immune function of humans and animals, he says, and arsenic can be toxic
to cells. The effects can be cumulative, Smith explains: “Endangered
animals are often exposed to multiple different toxins in combination
over time, and these exposures may interact to put them at a greater
risk for a negative health effect.” Some chemicals can also
“bio-magnify” up the food chain, leaving condors especially vulnerable
because they prey on dead animals.

“The condor is a species recently brought back from
the brink of extinction,” Smith says. “There is enough evidence to raise
concerns.” Finkelstein warns, “The population is not at a place where
it can withstand any additional stress.”

Seneca Resources Corporation
is confident its fracking won’t threaten the condor. “Protective
measures are taken by Seneca to protect the area we do business in, so
it has little to no impact whatsoever on those condors,” said Luke
Faith, a senior operator for Seneca, during a February public comment
meeting on the DOGGR report. He explained that the company follows the
Fish and Wildlife Department’s rules, such as the stricture that new
wells must be a mile and a half from known condor nest sites.

But these measures aren’t foolproof. Condors do not
always return to historic nest sites. Nor do the measures address
pollution from fracking. It’s not even known how far water, air and
ground pollution extend from each fracked well.

Condors aren’t the only endangered species in the
Sespe. The ecologically rich area is also home to Steelhead trout,
bighorn sheep and arroyo toad, all of which are on the federal
endangered species list and could also be harmed by fracking, according
to the DOGGR report.

If oil development continues to threaten the habitat
of a species that we, at the same time, have been spending huge amounts
of money and time trying to save, what does that say about our
priorities as a nation?

An elusive bird

Even if mitigation measures can eliminate most of the
everyday hazards associated with fracking, expanding oil production in
the Sespe increases the chance of an accident, points out Alasdair
Coyne, conservation director of the environmental nonprofit Keep Sespe Wild.
“The more fracking there is, the more possibility of spills on the
ground, and the more potential for condors to come along and ingest
something,” he says. Fracking fluids that spill during transport or
because of a pipeline break could contaminate surface and groundwater,
the DOGGR report states. Crude oil is also harmful to wildlife; it can
cling to birds’ feathers, making it difficult for them to fly, and can
kill embryos if it contacts eggshells.

Nancy Mauthe—one of the Keep the Sespe Wild activists
who sat by a “don’t frack my nest” sign at the DOGGR report
hearing—doesn’t want to see the condors devastated again. “You can see
them fly overhead now, but they still need help,” she says.

Sightings remain rare. Coyne recalls seeing three
condors last July. It was hot, and the hikers were focused on
maneuvering down a steep gorge on a mission to remove an invasive shrub.
Out of the corner of his eye, he caught the motion of wings. A condor
landed “on a ledge, about 1,000 feet above us,” he says. “You’re looking
at a creature that has been born in captivity and is now wild again.”

One overcast Saturday in February, I drive out to the
sanctuary, hoping to see one of the birds myself. As the skies threaten
rain, I survey the gorge. Bits of trash—broken glass, a sandwich bag,
bottle caps—litter the side of the road near the entrance. The chaparral
is green against the red clay of the mountains. It is quiet, but up on
the hill, I see an oil pump churning. I drive on, and soon the silence
is punctuated by the eerie whooshing of the pump.

I move to a quieter part of the sanctuary and stay a
while, scanning the sky obsessively. I see no condors. I wonder if I
ever will.

HELP END PET HOMELESSNESS

Just $25, and best of all, $17 from the sale of each plate will fund spay and neuter services for dogs and cats across Arizona. Click ad to order now at www.azpetplates.org ~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~

~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~

TO ADVERTISE ON OUR BLOG

The above are paid ads. To place yours for just $25/month, call Jim Keyworth at (928) 474-8787 or e-mail peoplesgazette@gmail.com. Banner ads are also available across the bottom and top of the blog.

(The Rim Country Gazette Blog is currently averaging over 5,000 visits per month. Our readership survey shows Gazette readers are better educated and more affluent than the average newspaper reader. Gazette Blog ads reach the people most likely to vote and to use your services and products.)