Ezra’s MIA baby mama continues to exact a toll on ‘Ezria’ in Tuesday’s installment of Pretty Little Liars (8/7c, ABC Family). Will the semi-reformed Liar be able to cope with her relationship’s new third wheel? We have an exclusive first look that sheds some light on that very quandary.

When Aria shows up with birthday goodies for Ezra — who, let’s face it, has pretty much become a crotchety old man is recent weeks — she’s hit with the news that he was up all night penning a letter to his ex-love. (To his credit, he says the reason he’s so torn again about this whole Maggie sitch is that his mom’s attempt to buy off Aria opened old wounds — but we’re still skeptical.)