Transaction Analysis

Maicer Gets the Cheese

the archives are now free.

All Baseball Prospectus Premium and Fantasy articles more than a year old are now free as a thank you to the entire Internet for making our work possible.

Not a subscriber? Get exclusive content like this delivered hot to your inbox every weekday. Click here for more information on Baseball Prospectus subscriptions or use the buttons to the right to subscribe and get instant access to the best baseball content on the web.

As easy as it was to envision Tekotte as a future fourth outfielder entering the season, his initial exposure to Triple-A and the majors has exposed a potentially fatal flaw in his game: making contact. Tekotte fanned 27 percent of the time in Triple-A, and has whiffed on 43 percent of his career big-league swings. He does enough things decently—walking, fielding, hitting for power—that there’s still some hope here if he can improve on making contact. The White Sox are doing no harm getting an up-close look at Tekotte in exchange for a 27-year-old minor-league reliever.

Spence reached the majors within a year of signing as a 10th-round pick out of Arizona State. In 40 big-league innings, Spence has shown the ability to sit down left-handed batters with a low-80s-fastball/slider combination. The mediocre stuff forces Spence to approach each encounter carefully, thereby leading to some nibbling and free passes. Surprisingly, Spence generates more fly balls than grounders, making him a weird fit for Yankees Stadium. If he does have a big-league future, it’ll be as a left-handed specialist.

Signed INF-S Maicer Izturis to a three-year deal worth $9 million with a $3 million club option. [11/8]
Acquired RHP Jeremy Jeffress from the Royals for cash considerations. [11/8]
Designated LHP Scott Maine for assignment. [11/8]

Izturis’ bat-to-ball skills and defensive versatility earned him the 45th spot on our top-50 free agents list, and intrigued the Jays enough to merit a three-year deal to take over as their second baseman. In addition to the contact skills and defense, Izturis has what you might call smart speed—his instincts on the basepaths allow him to play quicker than he is. Izturis came off the bench for the Angels because of superior options and because of his own durability concerns. Add in that Izturis is coming off a down season and recently celebrated his 32nd birthday and you have the makings of a questionable and perhaps unnecessary move, even if the average annual value is reasonable.

Jeffress is a lottery ticket. Kansas City acquired him in the Zack Greinke trade because of his live arm. His fastball sits in the mid- to upper-90s and he complements the heat with a power curveball. Jeffress has two notable flaws, both involving control. He has not shown the ability to throw strikes consistently. The other issue is character-based. Jeffress’ substance abuse issues led the Brewers to add him to the 40-man roster prematurely. When Jeffress is on he looks like a frontline closer, when he’s off he looks like waiver-wire fodder. The Royals soured on Jeffress; the Blue Jays will try salvaging him.

Bay wins because he still receives the $21 million remaining on his contract. Not only does Bay get his money but he gets freedom, too—freedom to pick a new, better situation in an attempt to revive a fading career. Concussions and other injuries limited Bay’s effectiveness with the Mets. His bat is slowed, his actions woodened, and his most recent season inspires little optimism. Still, some team will look at Bay’s 2010-2011 seasons and give him a shot.

The Mets win because of the money situation. No, they won’t be able to avoid paying Bay but they do get to defer some of the cash, which is something they would not have been able to do had they released the outfielder in the spring. The other big pro about this arrangement is the vacating of a roster spot. Valuating that benefit is difficult; however, it does allow the Mets to entertain some outfield options with higher upsides than Bay.

I don't want to steal the thunder here, but MLB doesn't immediately suspend after a weed test, whereas MILB does. Jeffress was suspended twice in the minors after testing positive for marijuana. If testing positive a third time, I believe he was subject to a lifetime ban. By putting Jeffress on the 40-man, he was no longer subject to the MILB drug policy

I am not quite sure why BP is down on the Izturis move. The Jays have no real options for second base or substitute infielder; Hechaverria needs more time in Triple A to work on his swing and the backup infielder as it currently stands is Mike McCoy. The contract looks pretty cheap overall, there were not a lot of other options available and even if Hech makes it as the starting second baseman, you now have reasonable depth if an injury occurs. At the end of the day, who cares if the Jays overpaid by $200,000 or so grand compared to production? This is not going to cripple them if it doesn't work out - it is not like they are giving him Vernon Wells money.

I don't think the issue is exactly with the money as it is with the years. There's no mention above that this is a potentially crippling move, just that a 3-year deal seems like it may have been a year or two longer than necessary.

I don't think there's anything wrong with being down on the move - many Jays fan don't like the third year (which Anthopoulos admitted was the reason Izturis signed quickly) either

What I don't get is calling it potentially unnecessary. As you pointed out, after Aviles was traded Hechavarria was the incumbent 2B. Not to mention all the rumblings about Escobar being on his way out (although I hope this doesn't happen). Part of why this deal makes sense is because it was entirely necessary

Three years really isn't that long. Izturis is likely to still be helpful at the age of 35. If people were happy that a 45 year old Vizquel played for the Jays last year despite the fact that he no longer had any range or ability to hit, then they should be thrilled to have a player who is 13 years younger play his role on the team.