This is an Open Access article distributed under the terms of the Creative Commons Attribution License (http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/2.0), which permits unrestricted use, distribution, and reproduction in any medium, provided the original work is properly cited.

Abstract

Background

Mediterranean spotted fever (MSF) is an acute febrile, zoonotic disease caused by
Rickettsia conorii and transmitted to humans by the brown dogtick Rhipicephalus sanguineus. Nearly four hundred cases are reported every year (mainly from June to September)
on the Italian island of Sicily. The aim of the study was to analyze the clinical
and laboratory characteristics of patients with MSF and the efficacy of the drugs
administered.

Methods

Our study was carried out on 415 children with MSF, during the period January 1997
– December 2004, at the "G. Di Cristina" Children's hospital in Palermo, Sicily, Italy.
On admission patients' clinical history, physical and laboratory examination and indirect
immunofluorescence antibody test (IFAT) for Rickettsia conorii were performed. Diagnosis was considered confirmed if the patients had an MSF diagnostic
score greater than or equal to 25 according to the Raoult's scoring system. All patients
were treated with chloramphenicol or with macrolides (clarithromycin or azithromycin).

Results

Fever, rash and tache noire were present in 386 (93%), 392 (94.5%) and 263 (63.4%)
cases respectively. Eighteen (4.6%) children showed atypical exanthema. Chloramphenicol
and newer macrolides all appeared to be effective and safe therapies.

Conclusion

Clinical features of 415 children with MSF were similar to those reported by other
authors except for a lower incidence of headache, arthralgia and myalgia and a higher
frequency of epato-splenomegaly. Concerning therapy, clarithromycin can be considered
a valid alternative therapy to tetracyclines or chloramphenicol especially for children
aged < eight years.

Background

Mediterranean spotted fever (MSF) is an acute febrile, zoonotic disease caused by
Rickettsia conorii and transmitted to humans by the brown dog tick Rhipicephalus sanguineus, which is generally considered to be the most common tick in the Mediterranean area.
Nearly four hundred cases are reported every year (mainly from June to September)
on the Italian island of Sicily [1]. Interestingly, the number of cases in Italy and elsewhere appears to have increased
over the past 20 years. Sporadic cases have also been diagnosed in travelers to other
countries, and, in North America, MSF is one of the most frequently imported types
of rickettsioses [2]. Until recently Rickettsia conorii was thought to be the main species in Europe. However, in the last decade newly recognized
tick-borne rickettsioses have been shown to be prevalent in Europe; in 1996 and 1997,
the first documented cases of infection due to Rickettsia mongolotimonae and Rickettsia slovaca respectively, were reported in France [3,4]. More recently Rickettsia helvetica has been identified in Sweden and France [5,6] and Rickettsia Israeli in Sicily and Portugal [7,8]. In Sicily two subspecies of Rickettsia conorii has been found: Rickettsia conorii conorii and Rickettsia Israeli [9]. MSF is typically characterized by fever, skin rash and a black eschar at the site
of the tick bite ("tache noire") [10]. Actually more and more frequently severe forms are described and the current fatality
rate of MSF is increasing [11]. Diagnosis is based on epidemiological, clinical and laboratory criteria [12]. Serological confirmation of infection is obtained using indirect immunofluorescence
against Rickettsia conorii. Promptly administered antibiotic treatment shortens the symptomatic period of MSF
infection and prevents the appearance of severe complications. Over the last few years
the new macrolides have been widely employed and have became the antibiotic of choice
for treating pediatric MSF [13,14].

The objective of this study was to analyze the clinical and laboratory characteristics
of patients diagnosed with MSF at our hospital over the last eight years and to analyze
the efficacy of the drugs administered.

Methods

All patients diagnosed with MSF at the "G. Di Cristina" Children's hospital in Palermo,
Italy, during the period January 1997 – December 2004, were included in this case
series. Clinical suspicion of MSF was based on a history of a tick bite or direct
contact with dogs, and on the presence of fever, non confluent maculopapular rash,
tache noire, lymphadenopathy. On admission, a complete physical and laboratory examination
(complete blood cell count, kidney and liver function tests, determination of the
erythrocyte sedimentation rate, urine analysis) was carried out on most children.
An indirect immunofluorescence assay for Rickettsia conorii was performed using a commercial kit (Rickettsia conorii-Spot; bio-Merieux, Marcy l'Etoile, France) when the first blood sample was taken
and then, again, two weeks later (acute and convalescent-phase serum samples). Diagnosis
was considered confirmed if the patients had an MSF diagnostic score of ≥ 25 according
to the scoring system described in Raoult et al. [12].

All patients were treated with chloramphenicol or with macrolides. Chloramphenicol,
administered orally or intravenously at a dosage of 50 mg/Kg/day in four divided doses
for 7 days, was the first choice therapy until 1999. Since 2000, clarithromycin or
azithromycin have been administered orally at a dosage of 15 mg/Kg/day in two divided
doses for 7 days and 10 mg/Kg once daily for 3 days, respectively. Intravenously administered
chloramphenicol was used for patients suffering from allergy, those having side effects
(vomiting or profuse diarrhea), fever that persisted for > 5 days or relapse after
therapy with macrolides. Antibiotic treatment prompted a clinical response in the
shape of defervescence and an improvement in the clinical profile. Defervescence time
was defined as the period from when antibiotic treatment began to the moment when
defervescence first became constant (i.e. an axillary body temperature of ≤ 37°C for
at least 3 consecutive days). Relapse was defined as the reappearance of fever within
a week after the end of therapy.

Statistical analysis

Analysis was carried out using the parametric ANOVA test for continuous factors; simultaneous
comparisons of several proportions were performed using chi square test.

Results

A total of 415 patients were diagnosed with Rickettsia conorii infection during the study period. The annual incidence of MSF infection ranged from
29 cases in 2004 to 98 in 1999. Most of the cases (n = 334) occurred between July and September, one case occurred in December. The median
age was 6 years (range: 1 month-15 years). Two-hundred and forty-five (59%) of the
children were male. A history of a tick-bite was given in 142 (34.2%) cases. Direct
contact with dogs was reported in 86 (20.7%) cases. Patients were seen to in the emergency
department after a median of 3 days (range 1–9) of fever. Table 1 shows the main clinical characteristics of the 415 cases.

With regard to exanthema it was observed in 392 (94.5%) patients and was typical (maculopapular
spreading to the palm and soles) in 374 (95.4%) of the cases and atypical in 18 cases
(4.6%). Among atypical exanthema, petechial or purpuric rash was observed in nine
cases (2.3%), papulovesicular in eight (2%), both purpuric and vesicular in one case
(0.2%). Two hundred and thirty six patients presented exanthema, fever and tache noire
together. Among 23 (5.5%) children without exanthema, 14 had fever, tache noire and
lymphadenopathy, 2 fever and tache noire, 2 tache noire and lymphadenopathy, 2 only
tache noire, 1 fever and lymphadenopathy, 1 fever and at last 1 headache and vomiting.
In all tache noire was observed in 63.4% patients; it was a solitary lesion in 257
patients, while six patients presented two or three lesions.

Arthralgia and/or mialgia generally affected the joints and the muscles of the lower
limbs and only in three (0.7%) cases restricted children's mobility. One girl aged
14 years developed meningo-encephalitis.

Indirect immunofluorescence to Rickettsia conorii was performed in 365 (87.9%) cases. Serological confirmation of infection was obtained
for 232 (63.6%) patients; 154 patients had diagnostic antibody titre on admission,
while 78 showed a 4-fold titre elevation after two weeks. Among 133 cases not serologically
confirmed, 124 patients had negative serology on admission and did not came back after
two weeks; in nine cases with negative serology both on admission and in convalescence
the diagnosis has been made on the grounds of clinical and epidemiologic criteria.

With regard to therapy, chloramphenicol was used from the beginning in 107 children
(87 orally and 20 intravenously); 230 children were given clarithromycin, 78 azithromycin.
All drugs were well tolerated, without evidence of toxicity or major side-effects.
Twenty-eight patients initially treated with macrolides had to change therapy to i.v.
chloramphenicol because of occurrence of vomiting and/or diarrhoea (15 patients treated
with clarithromycin and one treated with azithromycin), itching rash (one patient
treated with clarithromycin), fever that persisted for > 5 days (two patients treated
with clarithromycin and nine treated with azithromycin). A further 19 patients treated
with clarithromycin developed irrelevant side effects which did not require discontinuation
of therapy.

Defervescence time and the mean duration of hospitalization in the three different
groups of treatment are shown in table 2. There was no difference in the defervescence time (p = 0.093); in contrast, hospitalization
was significantly longer in the chloramphenicol group compared with clarithromycin
group (p = 0.018). The course of the disease was favourable in all cases.

Table 2. Efficacy and tolerability of the different drugs used in 415 patients with Mediterranean
spotted fever.

Discussion

MSF is an acute disease caused by Rickettsia conorii, which is transmitted to humans by the brown dog-tick Rhipicephalus sanguineus. Ticks are not only vectors, but also reservoirs of Rickettsia so that physical contact with dogs is not necessary. In fact in our case series only
a few patients (20.7%) presented this risk factor.

In our area the disease affects individuals of both sexes and all ages, and, in contrast
to what was reported by Anton et al. [15], no peak is found in the pediatric population [1].

Comparing the results of our study with previous ones, we found clinical features
similar to those reported by other authors except for a lower incidence of headache,
arthralgia and myalgia and a higher frequency of hepato-splenomegaly (table 1) [10,15-17]. Headache is one of the typical and more discomforting symptoms of the disease in
adults [15] and its lower frequency in children certainly contributes to the milder clinical
presentation in this age group.

In the last decade newly recognized tick-borne rickettsioses have been shown to be
prevalent in Europe. In 1997 Rickettsia slovaca, transmitted by the Dermacentor marginatus tick was linked to the illness occurring especially in children < 10 years, during
the autumn and winter and characterized by scalp lesions due to tick-bites and enlarged
regional lymph nodes. This clinical syndrome was denominated TIBOLA (tick-borne lymphadenopathy)
[18]. In our case series, eight patients with tache noire in the scalp and lymphadenopathy,
six of them also showing fever, could fit the diagnosis of TIBOLA. Because of the
scarce specificity of standard serological methods [18] we are not be able to make a definitive diagnosis that could be made using isolation
or molecular biology to establish and clearly identify agents.

Severe involvement of the central nervous system has been reported in adults with
Rickettsia conorii infection [19-22], but is extremely rare in children [23-25]. We report a case of meningoencephalitis in a 14-yearold girl. The patient came to
our notice after nine days of high fever, headache, arthralgia with no history of
tick-bite. On clinical observation there was no evidence of tache noire and only a
few maculopapular elements, involving neither the palms nor the soles, were present.
The patient had a severely-affected central nervous system with obtunded consciousness,
facial nerve deficit and meningeal signs. Examination of cerebrospinal fluid did not
reveal any significant findings. Magnetic resonance imaging of the brain showed contrast
enhancement in the meninges. Indirect immunofluorescence to Rickettsia conorii was positive on admission and showed a 4-fold titre elevation after two weeks. Intravenous
administration of chloramphenicol for 15 days led to the disappearance of symptoms.

Standard treatment for MSF has been tetracyclines or chloramphenicol [26]. According to the American Academy of Pediatrics tetracyclines are not indicated
for the treatment of common infections in children younger than eight years of age.
However doxycycline is recommended for treatment of Rocky Mountain spotted fever in
children of any age [27]. The milder clinical presentation and the benign course of MSF allow us to utilize
macrolides, which are often used to treat infections in children, that lack adverse
effects and are effective in vitro against Rickettsia conorii [28-30].

Several randomized clinical trials have been performed to compare macrolides in the
treatment of MSF [31-33]. More recently good in vivo results were obtained for the new macrolides, identifying clarithromycin as a valid
alternative therapy to tetracyclines or chloramphenicol for children aged < eight
years [13,14].

In our case series there were no differences in the three groups of treatment with
regard to the defervescence time (p = 0.093); the incidence of relapses and of side
effects requiring a change of therapy was quite low, even if significantly different
for the three drugs (p < 0.01). On the other hand, the shorter hospitalization stay
in the clarithromycin group (p = 0.018), good compliance observed both in patients
treated with clarithromycin and azithromycin, together with the withdrawal of oral
formulation of chloramphenicol, confirm the leading role of clarithromycin in the
treatment of pediatric MSF.

Conclusion

As already known, MSF confirms to be an acute disease with a benign course in pediatric
age. Nevertheless sporadic severe clinical manifestation can be observed. Complete
evaluation of epidemiological, clinical and serological criteria is necessary to establish
a prompt diagnosis and safe therapy. Clarithromycin and azithromycin, because of the
lack of adverse effects and a good compliance, can be considered a valid alternative
therapy to tetracyclines or chloramphenicol in the treatment of pediatric MSF especially
for children aged < eight years.

Competing interests

The author(s) declare that they have no competing interests.

Authors' contributions

All authors contributed equally to this work.

Acknowledgements

We thank the staff of Infectious Diseases Department laboratory for the serological
analysis and Bernardo Patti for the statistical analysis.