DVDActive uses cookies to remember your actions, such as your answer in the poll. Cookies are
also used by third-parties for statistics, social media and advertising. By using this website, it is
assumed that you agree to this.

Good Luck Chuck (US - DVD R1)

Troy Anderson wonders what some people find funny about Dane Cook

Feature

Charlie Logan was cursed by a slutty Goth girl back in 1985. Twenty-two years later, Charlie is now a successful dentist who can't get anywhere with women past the first date or so. The kicker is that everyone he sleeps with will meet their true love after leaving Charlie. Charlie's plastic surgeon pal Stu wants to live vicariously through his friend, but Charlie doesn't want to have anything to do with this bit of bad luck. Especially, since he just met the beautiful Cam Wexler.

Cam is nutty over penguins and she wants a guy in her life that can maintain their frosty sense of monogamy. Charlie and Stu try to come up with a plan to break his curse, while Cam slowly starts to drift away from Charlie. Then, there's some sex and a few pratfalls. Eventually, we slam headlong into the typical romantic comedy finale and we're finished.

Good Luck Chuck brings nothing new to the table, but it's charming. When you look at the Dane Cook films that preceded this release, that's enough to make you readdress past problems with the MySpace Generation comedian. The unrated cut's five extra minutes are dedicated to increased nudity and more of the raw sexuality that's so key to the film's plot. Dane Cook finally cuts loose with this adult material and finds a way to break out of that teenage comedy album funk in which he's been trapped. If Cook's new film marks this much of an improvement, then consider me sold.

Video

Good Luck Chuck comes to DVD with this unrated edition. Somewhere along the line, Lionsgate chose to open the transfer up from the theatrical flat showing to a home theatre friendly 1.78:1 HD remastered transfer. There's not a lot of information lost, as the periphery seems intact. In terms of the clarity, you don't lose any detail during the standard scenes. It's just that I noticed some haze towards the film's finale in Antarctica.

Audio

The Dolby Digital 5.1 track is pretty clean and clear. It's just that the film doesn't have an engrossing mix to draw you into a theatrical experience. That is unless you like having a surround sound approach to moaning and the pop song soundtrack. A Dolby 2.0 surround track is also included for those that don't want the 5.1 surround experience.

Extras

Dane Cook leads a funny commentary track that also feature's the film's director, producer and screenwriter. None of the other men seem to be able to get a word in when Cook starts talking. Maybe Dane Cook should've been given his own track. There are a couple of featurettes about the oddities included in the film. So, if you ever wanted to learn more about Polymastia, then this is your chance to be informed.

The greatest special feature would have to be the ‘Sex Matrix’. Towards the middle of the film, we're given a sex montage where Charlie bangs his way through about twenty different women. The gag reel and ad-libs are only funny for one viewing, but what I thought was neat were the deleted/alternate scenes. I'd recommend watching the alternate ending immediately after finishing the film to see what could've been. I'm not sure who got it changed, but maybe this first ending could've saved the film from into yet another predictable romantic comedy.

Overall

Good Luck Chuck isn't anything that you haven't seen before. The Farrelly Brothers were perfecting this kind of manly romantic comedy back when Dane Cook was working dive comedy clubs. The film succeeds because it manages to take a comedian that many people have written off and turn him into something not so horrible. I'm not going to make the early call and say that Cook has actually found something that works for him, but I will say that he works better in an unrated environment.

Dane Cook is actually starting to develop an identity on film. If you would've asked me if such a thing was possible after the one-two punch of Waiting... and Employee of the Month, I would've said that you were on drugs. By addressing the constraints of his material and giving him an excellent comedic partner in Dan Fogler, Dane Cook is starting to take the energy of his live shows to the big screen. Cook has an army of fans for a reason and I'm glad that I'm starting to catch a little of that enthusiasm with this surprising performance. There's still going to be some people out there that won't want to give the film a chance due to Cook's involvement. All I'm saying is to bite the bullet and give it a rental. A few bucks aren’t that much to take a shot on a changed man.

Advertisements

Comments

Reply

Message

Enter the message here then press submit. The username, password and message are required. Please make the message constructive, you are fully responsible for the legality of anything you contribute. Terms & conditions apply.

You're truly an idiot, if what you just said is true. There's nothing remotely funny about Dane Cook, and if you laugh at his c**p, I suggest you sign yourself up for Special Ed....quick.

Ok im going to forget that you just insulted me TWICE,but heres a better question for you,If you Hate Dane Cook so much,If you dont think he is funny,Why are you even wasting your time to click on the link to a movie with a guy in it you dont even like and then insult the people who do like it??? Why dont you click the movie you like and stay away from the ones you hate??? You're lucky the internet is not a in person thing!

You're truly an idiot, if what you just said is true. There's nothing remotely funny about Dane Cook, and if you laugh at his c**p, I suggest you sign yourself up for Special Ed....quick.

Ok im going to forget that you just insulted me TWICE,but heres a better question for you,If you Hate Dane Cook so much,If you dont think he is funny,Why are you even wasting your time to click on the link to a movie with a guy in it you dont even like and then insult the people who do like it??? Why dont you click the movie you like and stay away from the ones you hate??? You're lucky the internet is not a in person thing!

I happend to think Dane Cook is a comic god,so obviously I loved this movie I didnt read the whole review except for the overall because i thought he was going to rip Dane a new one,but was surpirsed by what he said!But still ANYONE Whose doesnt find Dane Cook Funny...I feel bad for you guys!

I've never understood why people are so fanatical about Dane Cook. I've watched HBO special after HBO special, and I canNOT find one damned thing funny about him. He and his fans make me scratch my head at what they find so humorous about him. He's no Bill Hicks...

Stand-up comedians should stick to stand-up comedy (see: Ned "Carlos" Mencia in The Heartbreak Kid). This was worse than Employee of the Month (I'd give Employee a 4 out of 10 and Chuck a 2). If you're forced to watch Dane Cook in anything, get Mr. Brooks.

P.S. Alba doesn't get naked. Not that I care, but for those of you who do, don't expect anything. Want girls getting naked? Look in a Playboy. There's hotter than Jessica Alba. She's got herpes anyway.

I'm usually open to seeing almost any movie out there but I really can't stand Dane Cook so the chances of me ever seeing this are really low. It has Jessica Alba but I could see better movies with hotter actresses' that have so much more talent.

I didn't hate Dane Cook. Hell, I found him to be quite charming and capable in this film. He's slowly but surely becoming a better mainstream actor and he's starting to channel his act more into his film performances.