In December, a New York City waiter who received a $1,000 tip on a $111 bill identified Selby.

"As I was about to drop the check off, one of the men said they would ‘make my night.’ They called me over, gave me the check," Aruj Dhawan, a waiter at Bo's Kitchen, told the New York Post. "I was amazed. ... I was just really thankful.”

The week before, ValleyWag.com reported that Selby — who made millions on PayPal's sale to eBay — was likely behind the big tips.