I didn't adore the ones I tried, but these 3 actually sound considerably more interesting. Go read the description of Spirit of the Tiger at luckyscent though…sounds like it is a clove-lovers scent more than a dupe of Tiger Balm (luckily!)

“Spirit of the Tiger” just stuck me with an earworm of “Eye of the Tiger,” but it's okay… it'll make washing up the dishes tonight seem almost like a heroic action.
I'm kind of with Stanzi – too many memories of sore calves, and I think I might associate the smell too strongly with end-of-the-day aching

I'd love to try these, although I must confess that I'm wary of the tiger balm scent too, not due to memories of muscle aches and pains but due to memories of pot smoking. For some inexplicable reason, when I was in college we put tiger balm on our temples when we smoked. Very spiritual.

The Esprit du Tigre scent is one my favourites from his line. It is very complex and develops beautifully. It manages to be simultaneously fresh, green, warm, sweet and comforting all at once. This is an amazing masculine, I think it ranks high up with the best men’s scents out there. Wouldn’t be out of place on a young, trendy web designer or a middle aged lawyer having a cigar and port at his gentlemen’s club………!