I dont know all the shoes you are talking about, but if you are talking about running shoes with a midsole (lift) we have no disagreement (I think I have stated this quite a lot of times now). We do however disagree on the stableness of being very close to the ground. As JohnMT states and I can confirm it is really hard to roll in barefeet/minimal shoes, unless perhaps you step on a ball or something (but this is the same with shoes). And shoes worsens the impact.