We noticed that you're using an unsupported browser. The TripAdvisor website may not display properly.We support the following browsers:Windows: Internet Explorer, Mozilla Firefox, Google Chrome. Mac: Safari.

This area has more pizza shops per houshold than NYC. Most of the pissa found here is very much the same. Gaetanoes in different. its heavy, the slice is so good you want to eat more,.. but two slices is alot of food. the quality...More

have always heard the raves so after 10 years tried the Springfield store-which is only open Thurs-Sat-cheese on bottom and lots of sauce on top-very tasty will try again sometime in the future-this is take out only-just 1 small table by the door

OMG !
Gaetano`s is a Clifton Heights Staple !
They also have a location in Springfield ,Delaware County.
The crust is crunchy and chewy at the same time,
The Sauce is some kind of secret recipe with chunks of tomatoes , onions and seasoning.
The...More

I guess when you have a pizza as delicious as Gaetano's that you can write your own ticket for customer service. Allow plenty of time for pick up (no delivery.) They're a bit like the soup nazis, but just as the soup nazis have amazing...More

They don't coupon, they don't deliver, and they don't have to - their pizza is so good you come pick it up yourself and pay full price. When you call to order, prepare to wait 45 minutes or more before you pick up your pizza...More