Judge Dunn granted Rzeszutko a withheld judgment and placed him on probation for four years. The judge ordered Rzeszutko to pay $6,201 in restitution to Farmers Insurance, and $1,043 to the Idaho Department of Insurance. He must also pay a fine of $750 and court costs of $245. The court also ordered 120 days of discretionary jail time to be utilized by a probation officer.

An investigation revealed that while working as an insurance agent for Farmers Insurance in Pocatello, Rzeszutko began diverting customers’ premium payments to his personal accounts. While doing so, he also took steps to make sure clients were not receiving late notices on their accounts. Rzeszutko admitted his actions to investigators.