... also in Britain we never use "grade" to refer to a school year. So let's put this whole misunderstanding down to two nations divided by a common language :)
–
slimJan 24 '12 at 13:50

2

Thanks for the edit--I wouldn't say this site has an "anti-structure" bias, it's just that those questions tend to be subjective and unanswerable. I believe this one has been made sufficiently objective, so I've cleaned up the comments at jdarnel27's suggestion.
–
NReilingh♦Jan 25 '12 at 0:35

Well, it's always sensible to attempt a piano piece. It's not like attempting to skydive without sufficient training to make it successfully to the ground, after all.

That said, after looking at the repertoire requirements for the top ABRSM grade, grade 8, you would have to be well beyond this stuff to be able to play the Emperor with any degree of success. For example, you should be able to pretty much sight-read most Chopin waltzes, and work up Beethoven Op. 10 1 or 2 in a week without much difficulty, say a week of practice.

If you have a copy of all the Beethoven Sonatas already, have a look at Op. 81a, the "Les Adieux" sonata. It has similar technical challenges to the Emperor although it is much shorter. (It so happens it's one of his greatest sonatas as well.) If you can play that in a manner that you find satisfactory, you are probably ready to tackle the Emperor.

It is inadvisable to lump together pieces of music with other pieces merely because they are on an exam syllabus together. Music isn't grades. Some music is used to test one's progress in learning fingerings in small exams called grades. The piano solo part to Beethoven's piano concerto no 5 is not defined by its grade standard and cannot be played by someone who has only passed grade 8, and hasn't got any further in their learning.

What they might be able to do is to have a go at playing the notes for the piano concerto. If this is the case then the grade 8 connection doesn't make any difference to whether they can do that or not. If anyone wants to have a go at playing anything, the answer is to try it and see how they get on.

To play Beethoven's piano concerto no 5 so that the interpretation is as near as possible to what Beethoven intended needs a highly skilled professional pianist.

There appears to be a lack of education in the UK about the limitations of grade exams. For this I blame instrumental teachers in not making clear to their pupils what these exams test and also what standard they are in relation to general music playing.

I am sure that if the person who asked this question had had this information properly explained by their teacher so that they understood that grade 8 is an elementary exam and is part of learning the basics of playing the piano they would have realised that the best that they can do with the piano concerto is to have a go at the notes. If this is the case there are lots of pieces that people can play the notes in without needing to worry about whether they need to have passed a certain grade exam first.

What is this grade nonsense anyway, but somebody's (maybe many people's) opinion that this is "harder" than that.

You can make rational judgments like that for yourself. If you find the piece is "too hard", you may at least gain insight into what kinds of techniques you need to work-up to get there. This may guide your practice toward the goal faster than waiting until you're ready.

Edit:

There are many issues with the above post. While I stand by the content of what I wrote (as far as it went), the tone was unnecessarily aggressive. And it's oversimplified; it should have lots of caveats and appologies.

So instead of all that, I'll just try again.

Grading systems wouldn't exist if they weren't found to be useful by many people. But there's an exception to evey rule, and it might as well be you (assuming you wish to be "exceptional").

There is value in challenging oneself. And desire is a very potent energy source that can be used to feed the necessary practice.

But this piece may indeed be too much for your current skill set, and "pushing it too hard" runs the risk of things like uncontrolled muscle tension, which can lead to pain and physical damage. But awareness of this danger should be sufficient to mitigate it. If something "feels wrong" when you play, it probably is.

Even so, if you really like the piece, then go ahead and "attempt" it. You may be able to execute the simpler passages well enough to get enjoyment from it. And difficult parts can be taken at a very slow tempo (where you can concentrate on making smooth motions), or you can simplify them to facilitate playing longer passages. Knowing more about the piece and what techniques you will need can give you a head start on the right exercises and intermediate pieces to bridge the gap.

-1 I see no justification for this hostile response. Many people's opinion that "this" is harder than "that", is a perfectly reasonable thing to ask about. If you try something too difficult, too early, you will only be discouraged. ABRSM publishes its syllabus online; there are well known pieces in the piano exam. Which ones are of similar difficulty to the piece in question?
–
slimJan 24 '12 at 13:20

It can be extremely detrimental to your playing ability if you pick up an overly-complex piece of music before your skills are at the level required to play it. Lack of knowledge about the instrument can promote bad habits and poor technique. Both are very difficult to reverse and will stint your musical growth for a good period of time.
–
enthdegreeJan 24 '12 at 16:00

@slim. There was no hostiity intended. It's called "tough love". You phrase it harshly so it cuts through.
–
luser droogJan 24 '12 at 18:05

1

I don't agree that playing a piece that is too complex is always detrimental. While more complex pieces will tempt students to 'cheat' by not following good technique, can discourage students who do not anticipate the piece's difficulty, and will not be learned or played correctly if the student does not have the requisite skill, these potential drawbacks need to be weighed against the student's work ethic and patience. It is fully possible to work carefully with a student to ameliorate many of these issues. I side with droog in this regard (only); warn, but do not discourage, the student.
–
BabuJan 24 '12 at 20:42

1

OP is at grade 3. Only just learning to play two arpeggios at once. He has no shortage of challenges on his plate.
–
slimJan 24 '12 at 23:31