Microsoft states that starting with the Better Together update, players will need to sign in to Xbox Live services for online multiplayer, regardless of the device they are playing the game on. This will allow them to configure their privacy settings and multiplayer preferences, also enabling Microsoft's Enforcement team to take direct action regarding players against whom complaints have been lodged. Xbox Live sign-in will not be required for local multiplayer on the same network.

Players will also have the chance to add someone as a friend. However, if they find the person bothersome, they can mute, block, or report them instead. Microsoft cautions that extreme cases of misconduct may result in a permanent Xbox Live ban or a console suspension. Chat filters are being introduced as well.

In terms of server moderation, volunteers from Microsoft's server partners will be keeping an eye out for any unacceptable behavior. Private messaging is also being removed to allow for more "thorough moderation across all parts of the server".

Microsoft notes that Xbox Live parental settings allow for more control as well, including blocking the ability to join multiplayer games or to communicate with other gamers. These settings will be disabled by default for children under the age of 13, who will also require their parents' permission to create an Xbox Live account in the first place.