Tuesday, January 26. 2016

Update: When I wrote this blog post it was an open question for me whether using Address Sanitizer in production is a good idea. A recent analysis posted on the oss-security mailing list explains in detail why using Asan in its current form is almost certainly not a good idea. Having any suid binary built with Asan enables a local root exploit - and there are various other issues. Therefore using Gentoo with Address Sanitizer is only recommended for developing and debugging purposes.

Address Sanitizer is a remarkable feature that is part of the gcc and clang compilers. It can be used to find many typical C bugs - invalid memory reads and writes, use after free errors etc. - while running applications. It has found countless bugs in many software packages. I'm often surprised that many people in the free software community seem to be unaware of this powerful tool.

Address Sanitizer is mainly intended to be a debugging tool. It is usually used to test single applications, often in combination with fuzzing. But as Address Sanitizer can prevent many typical C security bugs - why not use it in production? It doesn't come for free. Address Sanitizer takes significantly more memory and slows down applications by 50 - 100 %. But for some security sensitive applications this may be a reasonable trade-off. The Tor project is already experimenting with this with its Hardened Tor Browser.

I see this work as part of my Fuzzing Project. (I'm posting it here because the Gentoo category of my personal blog gets indexed by Planet Gentoo.)

I am not sure if using Gentoo with Address Sanitizer is reasonable for a production system. One thing that makes me uneasy in suggesting this for high security requirements is that it's currently incompatible with Grsecurity. But just creating this project already caused me to find a whole number of bugs in several applications. Some notable examples include Coreutils/shred, Bash ([2], [3]), man-db, Pidgin-OTR, Courier, Syslog-NG, Screen, Claws-Mail ([2], [3]), ProFTPD ([2], [3]) ICU, TCL ([2]), Dovecot. I think it was worth the effort.