Nice when someone who's been reading PS decides to become an active poster. Welcome.

Great that you obtaineda piano, and a free one at that. It does not sound so bad to me, I hear no obvious problems with it. Perhaps its age would be more apparent with a more direct sounding recording.

You playing sounds rusty but musical and with good expression and dynamics, I guess you have had lessons at some stage, and you know this particular piece well ?

This recording is promising but would need some polishing before being acceptable for inclusion on the site. If you are serious about recording for PS you should consider buying at least a portable mp3 recorder (Zoom, Edirol, Tascam or similar). The iPhone sound quality, while not exactly bad, does not quite cut it.

Hi grafpiano and welcome! I think you play very well! This would be fine for the site if the sound-quality was better. Since we already have some good recordings of this piece, we can be picky. Your new/old piano sounds pretty good, except it's a bit thumpy. But that may improve with a better recorder.

This file has only been up for a few hours, yet there are so many downloads already. Interesting.....

_________________"Simplicity is the highest goal, achievable when you have overcome all difficulties." ~ Frederic Chopin

No it would not, there's a number of flubs that we would ask to correct first. Nothing really drastic, but as said, we are a bit picky in Audition room. Especially when it comes to such popular and often-recorded repertoire.

No it would not, there's a number of flubs that we would ask to correct first. Nothing really drastic, but as said, we are a bit picky in Audition room. Especially when it comes to such popular and often-recorded repertoire.

Ok, I don't know this music as well as you.

_________________"Simplicity is the highest goal, achievable when you have overcome all difficulties." ~ Frederic Chopin

Glad you finally got your piano! The piano sounds pretty good, I agree that a better recording setup will be helpful for you (and for your listeners )I remember my first piano, which my grandparents bought for me for $200. It was an upright grand piano made by the Becker Bros in 1895. Although the piano was old it was capable of producing a lovely tone.

Overall, a nice performance here. As Chris has said, there are areas that need to be cleaned up, but it is obvious that you have an affinity for this piece and this type of music. I look forward to more recordings from you.

Hi Chris and pianolady,Thanks for your kind comments and warm welcome~Yes, I've had lessons for many years, but it's been almost 10 years since I stopped playing.I Know my fingers are weak and clumsy. Need more work from the beginning...Just wanted some comment, advice, or encouragement, (etc.) from others Thanks for all your advice. I'll polish this piece as well as start practicing my daily bread, Bach.Hope to submit good recordings in the near future.

and Thanks Dave,It's actually not my First piano. I left My beloved one in my country.I'm lucky enough to have this piano at home, and finally, I can play whenever I want. That means everything for me.

Let me express my admiration for your perseverance and for the fact you managed to solve your problem in such a way! I will not pretend that your piano is good and that the recorfing will do, but I believe your spirit will overcome that. If nothing, you can practise on this one and record on a better one.

I for a time had the same problem, so I can understand what it means to leave your piano behind when going to a new copuntry, though, in my case, I now have a better one than the one I left behind.

_________________Richard Willmer"Please do not shoot the pianistHe is doing his best."Oscar Wilde: Impressions of America: Leadville

Who is online

You cannot post new topics in this forumYou cannot reply to topics in this forumYou cannot edit your posts in this forumYou cannot delete your posts in this forumYou cannot post attachments in this forum