Japan’s Ellroy Compares Performance of Primes vs. Fujinon Zoom lenses

The first part of the testing was to verify the resolution of the Fujinon Cabrio Series lenses by testing them in comparison to a prime.

Tokyo-based video production company Ellroy decided to see for themselves how FUJIFILM zoom lenses compare to single-focal length PL mount cine lenses in terms of image quality.

To independently assess the lens performances, Ellroy crew conducted a side-by-side test, pitting three Fujinon 4K Cabrio PL-mount lenses—the 85-300mm Cabrio, 19-90mm Cabrio, and 14-35mm Cabrio—against high-quality single-focal length primes on actual commercial shoots and performed a variety of quality checks. Led by veteran DP Kazumi Takahashi, the Ellroy team focused on resolution, distortion and how the lenses handled color.

Ellroy, a high-end visual creative firm, uses prime lenses every day and have extensive experience shooting video at 4K and even 6K resolution. The technically progressive company has a feature film production system with an integrated workflow that handles all tasks from start to finish - including planning, direction, shooting, lighting, editing, and computer graphics

Resolution

The first part of the testing was to verify the resolution of the Fujinon Cabrio Series lenses by testing them in comparison to a prime. The benchmark for 4K performance was a TVL (horizontal resolution) of greater than 2000, as measured on relevant charts. Two patterns were configured corresponding to a maximum aperture and a T2.9 value. Footage of a female model was also shot to compare aspects of sharpness, such as lines, text, skin and hair.

In the T2.9 comparison, the PL mount prime lens imaging is at least indistinguishable from the Cabrio, but the FUJINON zoom is superior in the four corners of the image. Even the seasoned photographer Takahashi was surprised by the sharpness of the resolution.

“To capture images with a wide range of light frequencies in a balanced manner with 4K resolution is extremely complex,” Ellroy’s report states. “Frequencies have to be quantified and then revalidated from scratch. Fujifilm did an amazing job with that. Add in their experience developing cine style lenses, and the result is an overwhelming sharpness across the entire zoom range, which is evident even at a glance.”

Looking at color rendition, the Ellroy crew compared how the Fujinon lenses responded when capturing live models and on commercial shoots.]

Distortion

Distortion is often discussed as a quality issue inherent in zooms. Ellroy tested this perception by shooting a grid comprised of simple, uniform vertical and horizontal lines. Any distortion produced in capturing the lines would be readily apparent. A variety of PL-mount prime lenses, beginning with a 14mm wide-angle, were tested against the Cabrio ZK2.5x14 (14-35mm) and the ZK4.7x19 (19-90mm) with different focal lengths and T-Stops. At the 14mm wide angle setting, where peripheral distortion is most likely to occur, there is slight distortion from both lens types. As the focal length is extended to 24mm and 32mm, the performance from both sets of lenses is virtually identical.

“The number of lens elements that comprise a zoom are extremely large in comparison to a single-focal length prime,” said Thom Calabro, Director, Marketing and Product Development, FUJIFILM North America, Optical Devices Division. “Our Cabrio series lenses have roughly 30 lens elements. A large diameter aspherical lens helps to prevent distortion. Thanks to our work designing optics for cinema and broadcast, we’ve been able to fine tune the composition ratio of low-dispersion glass and highly refractive index glass—which have different light dispersion properties. This results in the Cabrios’ low distortion and high levels of contrast and 4K resolution.”

Color

A main advantage often cited for choosing single-focal length primes is that they produce nuanced images that are pleasing to the eye in terms of color, contrast, blur quality, etc. To test this, the Ellroy crew compared how they responded when capturing live models and on commercial shoots. Of the Cabrios, Takahashi said, “The skin tones and hair color on our live models was extremely natural, including the sharpness and accuracy of the contrast between light and dark areas and a softly blurred quality in other areas.”

Takahashi cited the Cabrios’ nine-blade aperture diaphragm as demonstration of Fujifilm’s commitment to quality: “FUJIFILM decided on this design after examining a wide range of possible aperture configurations. The nine-blade aperture captures light in a beautiful, circular shape in all scenes – whether set at a wide or narrow setting. And when it comes to crepuscular rays [sun rays], it draws out beautiful rays without excessive glare.

“Our tests showed that the Cabrio Series enables rich image expression that goes far beyond the scope of existing zooms,” said Takahashi.

FUJINON’s Cabrio PL lens series includes: the PL 25-300mm, PL 19-90, PL 85-300, and PL 14-35mm. The PL 19-90, PL 85-300, and PL 14-35 Cabrio feature exclusive detachable servo drive units. The PL 25-300 servo is optional, making all four Cabrios suitable as a standard PL or ENG-style lens. And all Cabrios can be controlled using cinema industry standard wireless controllers as well as existing FUJINON wired and wireless units.

Designed using the latest proprietary optical simulation software, the entire range of Cabrio lenses offer optical performance in the center of the image and in the corners of the frame. The digital servo’s 16-bit encoding assures operators that all lens data output—including the position of the zoom, iris, and focus—is extremely accurate. The zooms support Lens Data System (LDS) and other metadata formats.

Related Categories:

You might also like...

For years, I have written about the problems associated with trying to be a one-man band television reporter. Now, shooting alone has become the reality for many journalists. How does one balance so many disciplines at once and still do…

Canon’s new Cine-Servo 17-120 T2.95-39 compact lenses are parfocal lenses. Once focus is achieved, focus will be held at all focal lengths. However, when you need auto-focus, the parfocal design is a perfect match to the Canon’s Dua…

When I look back on 2017, one word jumps out when I think of audio, video and associated gear: Miniaturization. Yes, everything — and I mean virtually all of it — is getting smaller, lighter and more compact while the quality gets better.

In the five months since The Broadcast Bridge published Frank Beacham’s article discussing Using the iPhone for Professional Video there have been many world events that offered ideal opportunities to cover events with smartphones rather than traditional ENG camcorders. O…

Broadcasters are moving to the cloud, but the change requires careful planning. Consultant Tony Orme provides a tutorial on important factors to consider when moving to cloud operations. The first critical question to ask is Private or Public? This article…

Latest

Latest Jobs

Browse By Type

The Broadcast Bridge is at the heart of the broadcast media technology industry, delivering a new and exciting platform that delivers high quality, relevant technology content in a uniquely segmented and interlinked web-based platform.