What Shadows

The Birmingham Speech. That is what Enoch Powell termed his diatribe better known to most by the moniker ‘Rivers of Blood’. Powell’s title hid beneath its innocuous words a virulent tirade that incited racist attacks and seemingly welcomed a civil war along the lines of race.

In What Shadows, writer Chris Hannan takes Powell (Ian McDiarmid) and his speech as a starting point for examining English identity, through a story set in 1968 and 1992. The focus is Rose (Amelia Donkor), and her attempts to write a book on identity and conflict with ex-academic Sofia (Joanna Pierce).

Regrettably, the play asks only garbled questions about identity and then fails to answer them or provoke satisfactory answers from its audience. During the excessive running time, a variety of two-dimensional clichés in the guise of characters trot out to talk briefly at cross-purposes about what it means to be English. Stalking through this confusion is Powell himself.

We should not demonise people like Powell, for by doing so we lose the power to understand what drives them and how we can learn from them. Unfortunately, Hannan’s overly sympathetic treatment results in jarring missteps, including a clichéd gay character and a bevy of laugh-out-loud lines for Powell himself. These are not used to make the audience ashamed of laughing along with a racist, but seem to be included to make us like him. We do not need to like Powell to understand what drives him.

In any case, what drives Powell is merely petty resentment over thwarted political ambition and a fantasist’s idea of England. In trying to understand Powell, What Shadows provides no answers to what might have driven the disenfranchised white working class who spurred him on, and therefore no answers to the similar events of today which the play is responding to. These are the people Powell relies upon, who give him power. What Shadows only tries to understand the symptom, not the cause.

There is a hint of what might have been possible in the character of Sofia. A genuinely well-rounded character, she evokes sympathy and distaste in equal measure. If Hannan really wanted to examine what it means to be English, and why so many follow extremist leaders and ideologies, then a play based on fewer characters, more like Sofia, would have been the way forward.

The production of What Shadows, is also disappointing. Ian McDiarmid is effective as Powell, although his lack of redeeming features makes him rather tiresome to watch. Several of the other performances are regrettably significantly weaker.

The actors are not helped by the staccato dialogue, and frequently stumble over their lines, lines which never engage with each other, but simply fly about the stage at cross-purposes. Although this may be intentional in order to make a point about the need for conversation, without any satisfying pay-off they swiftly become tiresome to hear.

What Shadows seeks to ask questions about English identity, but by involving Enoch Powell so heavily, becomes bogged down in a race war it barely addresses. Much like the difference between ‘The Birmingham Speech’ and ‘Rivers of Blood’, the Powell of What Shadows claims his arguments are about immigration, but couches them in the language of racism. The play never challenges this, which leaves a very nasty taste in the mouth.

About The Author

Ben is an Art History graduate currently working for the National Museums of Scotland. He is a keen watcher and reader of all things theatrical, particularly at Edinburgh’s intimate Lyceum, and has even been known to occasionally tread the boards himself.

Support Plays To See

We need sponsors in order to expand our network of contributors and our connections with theatres and cultural organisations around the world.

We are now able to accept credit/debit card donations directly from this site, with the security of PayPal. No sum is too small.

Thank you for your support!

Donate Today!

What Shadows

2017-09-14

2.0Reviewer's Rating

Playstosee.com is a showcase for talent, particularly young talent, allowing them a platform to share their knowledge and appreciation of drama, musicals, opera, comedy, cabaret, ballet and even the circus. Our reach is truly global so our reviewers have the pleasure of knowing that their reviews will be read by people around the world.

We need sponsors in order to expand our network of contributors and our connections with theatres and cultural organisations around the world.

No sum is too small.

To pledge a donation by cheque, select ‘Offline Donation’ below. For a donation via credit card, select the PayPal option – you do not actually need a PayPal account in order to make a credit card donation through PayPal.

Add 25% more to your donation at no cost to you. A Gift Aid declaration allows Plays To See to claim tax back on eligible donations. It means that for every £1 you donate to Plays To See we can claim back 25p, at no extra cost to you.

By ticking the "Yes" box, I agree I would like Plays To See to reclaim the tax on all qualifying donations I have made, as well as any future donations, until I notify them otherwise. I understand that if I pay less Income Tax and/or Capital Gains Tax than the amount of Gift Aid claimed on all my donations in that tax year I may be asked to pay any difference. I understand that Plays To See will reclaim 25p of tax on every £1 that I give.

What is Gift Aid?

Gift Aid does not cost you a penny more, but can add an additional 25p to every £1 you donate. When Plays To See receives a donation from a UK taxpayer, we're entitled to claim an amount of tax (calculated at the basic rate of income tax in that year) paid on that donation. Once you have given your permission for us to do this on your behalf, there is no need for you to do anything else.

All that is required is that you must be a taxpayer and that would have paid or will pay sufficient Income and/or Capital Gains Tax to cover all the Gift Aid claimed on all your donations in that tax year. Please note that it is your responsibility to pay any difference.

The amount of tax we claim will be 25% of the total value of your donations in that tax year. Furthermore, if you are a higher taxpayer, you are also entitled to claim the difference between the basic rate which we will claim and the amount of tax you have actually paid. For further details on how you can do this, please contact your tax office. If your tax situation changes and your gifts will no longer be eligible for the Gift Aid scheme please contact us and we will amend your record accordingly.

Because I will be travelling for a bit, I decided to see the new bio-musical Tina in one of its last previews. So techni...

Our Mission

Plays To See explores diverse cultures through the medium of the performing arts. It aims to promote interest in the theatre and foster dialogue, understanding and appreciation for different artistic productions around the world.
Our scope is wide-ranging, from Greek tragedy to stand-up comedy; from ballet and opera to mime and experimental theatre.