Please note: we have been online over ten years, and we want The Trek BBS to continue as a free site. But if you block our ads we are at risk.Please consider unblocking ads for this site - every ad you view counts and helps us pay for the bandwidth that you are using. Thank you for your understanding.

Welcome! The Trek BBS is the number one place to chat about Star Trek with like-minded fans. Please login to see our full range of forums as well as the ability to send and receive private messages, track your favourite topics and of course join in the discussions.

If you are a new visitor, join us for free. If you are an existing member please login below. Note: for members who joined under our old messageboard system, please login with your display name not your login name.

When it comes to her authority over Starfleet personnel, how long is Kira's reach?

Kira gives legal orders and instructions to Starfleet officers and enlisted on DS9 and aboard the Defiant. I figure that there is some form of "status of forces" agreement between the federation and Bajor. But does that agreement have limits.

But if Kira were to be aboard a Starfleet vessel other than the Defiant, could she give an order to say an low level enlisted member of Starfleet, and have be obeyed? Not a request, but an order.

If a modern day naval officer from India, gave a order to a US Navy seaman, the seaman would not carry out that order, and actually could be charged with a legal offense if he did.

Kira only has authority on DS9, the Defiant, and DS9's runabouts. That's because she was posted there, and Starfleet (cooperating with the Bajoran government) gave her the authority. Those are the only places she has it.

__________________
"But here you are, in the ninth
Two men out and three men on
Nowhere to look but inside
Where we all respond to PRESSURE!" - Billy Joel

I don't think it is precise to say that she only has authority on DS9 and the Defiant. Rather, she has authority only through her position on DS9 and the Defiant. Indeed, when Sisko is affected by the closing of the Wormhole, Kira takes over the command of the Defiant. There is no indication that when she did, the Defiant surrendered its lead role in the assault. Quite to the contrary, it appears to continue to lead the Federation efforts to destroy the weapons platforms.

^ That's exactly what I just said. The Defiant is part of Kira's posting, as are DS9 and its associated runabouts. In any of those places, Kira has full command authority. But OUTSIDE of them, she has none.

__________________
"But here you are, in the ninth
Two men out and three men on
Nowhere to look but inside
Where we all respond to PRESSURE!" - Billy Joel

^No, it wasn't what I wrote. Kira being able to give commands to other starships in the midst of battle is not the same thing as her authority being limited to DS9 and the vessels it operates. Of course, I am open to evidence from the series that shows something different.

I never even liked that Kira was given command of the Defiant so much. To me that seemed rather out of place, especially when Worf showed up and was supposed to essentially be the ship's first officer.

^The first officer should have been determined by the nature of the Defiant's mission, whether it was for the station or for the Federation. That said, Kira had no business being on the bridge of the Defiant, let alone commanding it, at the Battle of Chintoka. (Wasn't the non-aggression pact still in place?)

To be fair, in the middle of a battle is not the time to hash out if she had authority over the rest of the fleet. The other ships may have followed her orders as the captains of those ships were wise enough to realize it was not the right time to argue over something like that.

Similarly if the 1st officer of the Defiant was a starfleet officer it would have been inappropriate for the other captains to be like, "I am not listening to you I am a captain and you are only a commander." There would have been chaos in the middle of battle as everyone bickered over who was in charge.

Side note - when I was in the Navy we had a British officer on our sub a couple of times. I have no idea who he was or what he did as I was engineering so we worked in our own little world and he wasn't allowed in the engine room. I always assumed he was just an observer but now I wonder if he ever served as OOD. We always did weird stuff that was never explained to me.

I never even liked that Kira was given command of the Defiant so much. To me that seemed rather out of place, especially when Worf showed up and was supposed to essentially be the ship's first officer.

I had the assumption that an officer had to have official training to be qualified to command a Starfleet ship.

Like knowing about engines, logistics, policies and procedures. I know she was an experienced resistance soldier, but it did look kind out of place.

It makes sense that she'd know everything about DS9, but commanding a starfleet ship just like that seemed a little odd.

It's like BElana Tores from Voyager, being made chief engineer over commissioned officers, even though she never graduated from the academy. i think she spent only a year there and then left.

In terms of comparison to modern day combat, I look at it from the viewpoint of Bajor being a Coalition Ally to the Federation.

For example I currently work in a Joint Command on a Coalition run base. Since the base is run by one of our Coalition partners we have to abide by the rules and regulations they have put in place for the base. However, if a Canadian Colonel walks into my office and starts issuing orders that are in direct conflict to the orders for my actual command I am under no obligation to follow them because that Colonel is not in my chain of command. I only have to follow his orders in regards to the base or if something is a safety issue.

If a modern day naval officer from India, gave a order to a US Navy seaman, the seaman would not carry out that order, and actually could be charged with a legal offense if he did.

Nightdiamond wrote:

It makes sense that she'd know everything about DS9, but commanding a starfleet ship just like that seemed a little odd.

Sigokat wrote:

In terms of comparison to modern day combat, I look at it from the viewpoint of Bajor being a Coalition Ally to the Federation.

For example I currently work in a Joint Command on a Coalition run base. Since the base is run by one of our Coalition partners we have to abide by the rules and regulations they have put in place for the base. However, if a Canadian Colonel walks into my office and starts issuing orders that are in direct conflict to the orders for my actual command I am under no obligation to follow them because that Colonel is not in my chain of command. I only have to follow his orders in regards to the base or if something is a safety issue.

One thing that I thing makes current military relations a poor example of Kira's relationship with Starfleet is that Bajor is a potential Federation member. It's clear from the pilot that the Federation leadership wants Bajor to join, and it wouldn't make much sense to alienate the planet's military leadership. [STRIKE]I think that the process of German re-unification would have been slowed had the Bundeswehr resisted the integration of East German soldiers and commanders.[/STRIKE]

Deep Space Nine wasn't actually a Federation Starbase during the series. It was a Bajoran Station under Federation Administration. Given that, it stands to reason that command of the Defiant would have been granted to Kira as a courtesy/part of the treaty just as command of the station would have been granted to The Federation. I'm sure if Bajor had really pushed the issue, a Bajoran officer could have been in command from day one.

I imagine Kira would have command authority on all Federation assets within the Bajoran Sector as part of the agreement between Bajor and the Federation. However if Kira were to go aboard the Enterprise in a different sector for example i'd imagine she would be an observer/consultant and only be given command authority if Picard authorised it.

I did notice though that once Worf arrived on the scene Kira commanded the Defiant a lot less.

Last edited by mickmike; October 23 2013 at 07:40 AM.
Reason: clarification