Magic is in the air.

Anyone who can’t just dish out $150 for a ticket to a Broadway show (raises hand) was in for a real treat last night because Peter Pan Live! finally aired after months of teasers and gorgeous shots of Allison Williams’s pixie cut. Fortunately, it was totally worth the wait. (Which, duh.

So what did the night hold? There was magic. There was fairy dust. There was flying, crocodiles, and an all-star cast including Christopher Walken as Captain Hook. It was a Disney fan’s dream come true and no one can stop talking about it: #PeterPanLive is still trending on Twitter the morning after the main event, and some very familiar faces couldn’t resist chiming in with their thoughts on the show:

There’s still no word from any of Allison’s Girls co-stars, but we’ll be patiently waiting to see what they think. After that three-hour-long performance, we’re sure Peter is going to be catching up on sleep most of the day anyway, as anyone should when they spend the whole night flying around Neverland. Those thousands of congratulatory texts and tweets will just have to wait.

Did you watch Peter Pan Live!? Did you love it? Hate it? Tell us below!