2013 Kentucky Derby: It's Time to Raise the Stakes

There
have been a lot of questions surrounding the new 2013 Kentucky Derby qualification
system. There has also been a lot of agreements and of course a few disagreements.
Until we see the finished product and which 20 horses make field I’ll be
reserved about making my overall judgment. So far, however, I have yet to see a
horse earn a position that would not have under the old system. Therefore, I can’t
disagree a great deal thus far.

The consensus is that anywhere between 35 to 50
points is going to be the amount that earns the final spot. Since that is
presumed to be accurate we have seen three contenders earn their position
with a win in one of the last three preps. Those races fall into
the first leg of the Championship Series and 50 points were awarded to the winner. So,
by all accounts these three will be racing in the main event on the first
Saturday in May.

Some race fans may believe that these recent win and you’re in races have given too much
praise, credit or points to the winners. But, even if you still don’t think that
any of these horses have done enough to earn their place in the starting gate, one stat proves that they have.

Each
of these races ran for a total purse of $400,000. Each winner took home their
share which equals $240,000. Under the former qualification system that amount
in graded stakes earnings would be enough for them to qualify almost every time.
To provide further evidence that Orb, Vyjack and I’ve Struck a Nerve haven’t
unfairly earned a spot, I went back and looked at recent winners in each of
these stakes races.

What
I came up with was pretty interesting. Not
only did I validate those wins as enough to earn a position in the 2013
Kentucky Derby but I also realized that this weekend is a very big turning point
in the prep season. On deck is the G2 Tampa Bay Derby and G2 San Felipe Stakes, two
qualification races that have become very big stepping stones in the journey
towards the claiming of the roses.

First,
let me conclude my initial findings. Now, I am aware that other
races outside of these three preps also qualified past winners to race in the Kentucky
Derby and of course earn more graded stakes earnings along the way. But, recent
history still proves that the winners of these Kentucky Derby preps almost
always entered the field of 20. With the exception of injury, and few years in
a row at the Gotham Stakes where no winner was moving, the winner always did.

Stakes winners dating from 2012 to 2004

Risen
Star Winner

KyDerby Entry

Finish

El Padrino

Yes

13th

Mucho Macho Man

Yes

3rd

Discreetly Mine

Yes

13th

Friesan Fire

Yes

18th

Pyro

Yes

8th

Notional

No - Injury

-

Lawyer Ron

Yes

12th

Scipion

No - Injury

-

Gradepoint

No - Injury

-

Gotham
Winner

KyDerby Entry

Finish

Hansen

Yes

9th

Stay Thirsty

Yes

12th

Awesome Act

Yes

19th

I Want Revenge

No - Injury

-

Visionaire

Yes

12th

Cowtown Cat

Yes

20th

Like Now

No

-

Survivalist

No

-

Saratoga
County

No

-

FOY
Winner

KyDerby Entry

Finish

Union Rags

Yes

7th

Soldat

Yes

11th

Eskendereya

No - Injury

-

Quality Road

No - Injury

-

Cool Coal Man

Yes

15th

Scat Daddy

Yes

18th

First Samurai

No - Injury

-

High Fly

Yes

10th

Read the
Footnotes

Yes

7th

Because
this tells me that the Fountain of Youth, the Risen Star and Gotham have almost
always been recent win and you’re in preps, I can’t argue that any of the three
winners in 2013 are getting into the Derby due to a points bias. What I can
argue is how important these preps have been over recent years.

Although
the winners of these stakes may have earned a spot in the starting gate, the
amount of times that it became a stepping stone to winning or racing well in the Kentucky Derby
is minimal. The last time and may be the only time a winner came out of the Risen
Star was War Emblem in 2002. As for the Fountain of Youth you have to travel
back to Thunder Gulch in 1995 and Go for Gin in 1994. In the Gotham Stakes, Secretariat is still the only Kentucky Derby winner that raced in it.

The
reason I am pointing out recent lack of Kentucky Derby success from these preps (only 1 top 3 finish by any of their winners) is because under the
new system they have been included in the same leg of the championship series
as the races we are going to see this weekend. But, when you pull that same
data on the Tampa Bay Derby and San Felipe Stakes you will notice a world of difference.
For this reason, we may have reached the point in the Kentucky Derby prep
season where we should begin to pay more to our winners and top
three finishers.

Earlier
in my research of past winners for the Risen Star, FOY and Gotham, I know that I
didn’t dig too far back (Only 9 years; 2004) but there is a reason for that as
well. Inaugurated in 1981 it wasn’t until 2002 that the Tampa Bay Derby officially
became a graded stakes race. Once that happened, it changed the minds of many
trainers because the Tampa Bay Derby then became another option for graded
stakes earnings. In 2004, Limehouse became the first Tampa Bay Derby winner to
use the prize money for Kentucky Derby qualification and earn a spot in the field.
Since 2004, every winner of the Tampa Bay Derby, with the exception of Odysseus in 2010 (injury), also qualified for the Kentucky Derby field.

Furthermore,
in the last six years alone we have already seen two champions use this prep on
their way to a Kentucky Derby victory; Street Sense ’07 and Super Saver ’10 (always
bet a TB Derby horse in the KyDerby if he has two names that begin with S??). As you can see this is one reason why Verrazano is getting so much attention
and the race itself is brewing with anticipation.

The San Felipe Stakes is a race that dates back much further than the TB
Derby and has a much more successful and storied history. In fact, a total of
11 San Felipe Stakes horses have gone on to wear the roses, including our last Triple Crown winner Affirmed in 1978. Although the Tampa Bay Derby had a more recent derby winner it wasn’t by much: Giacomo 2005. Prior to that we saw three in four years: Fusaichi Pegasus ’00, Real Quiet ’98 and Silver Charm ’97. When you add this information to the equation it may make it clear why the 2013 showdown between Flashbackand Goldencents has become so exciting.

I’m pretty confident that our first three Championship Series winners deserve
their place in the starting gate for the 2013 Kentucky Derby. As
you’ve also noticed I may be a little skeptical of their chances of winning.
History only tells one side of the story however. Therefore, while I may doubt
them to a certain degree based on trends, I most definitely have not reached
the point where I’ve thrown them out completely. For starters, the second leg
of the Championship Series is yet to come and they will be racing so it would
be foolish for me to jump to any conclusions.

But,
I am also intrigued by this stage of the Kentucky Derby trail. Derby fever is rising
and it’s only going to keep getting more interesting from here.

Older Comments about 2013 Kentucky Derby: It's Time to Raise the Stakes...

The 3rd place finisher in the Bredders Cup Juvenile should get AT LEAST as many points as the horse that wins the San Felipe or the Tampa Bay Derby. We're talking about a Grade 1 champioship race versus a couple of Grade 2 races, one of which (Tampa Derby) should be a Grade 3.

The San Felipe is not at all a good indicator of success in the kentucky Derby. In the last 25 years, only 2 winners have won the Derby, those being Sunday Silence (who won the Santa Anita Derby) and Fusiachi Pegausus (who won the Wood). Alysheba ran 2nd in the 1987 San Felipe to Chart The Stars.

It seems to me that one of the purposes of the new points system was to keep out obvious mis-fits like Trinniberg, who clearly had no business running in a route race. I can't recall if he took a spot of a legitimate contender or not, but that certainly was a possibility under the old system. It will be interesting after this Derby cycle concludes what changes they may to the system. Some tweaks no doubt will be made. On the whole I like the new system. They could have made the Derby an invitational only, but many would have found that to be less than desirable.

Nice work. I think horses need at least 40 points to make the derby, unless there are a few that have the points and elect not to go due to injury or the like. I do think that there will be a horse that uses the wild card races to get some extra points. If a horse is sitting at 30 points, because they finished 3rd or 4th in the 100 point prep race, I wouldnt be suprised to see them double back for the 1 mile derby trial.

Related Pages

About Me

Meet Bryan Brinkmeyer – Chicago, IL

Growing up across the river from the Bluegrass State I was able to spend a lot of summer days at Ellis Park, Henderson, KY.

Likewise, the first Saturday in May was always a celebrated family event. In 2000, I made my inaugural Kentucky Derby appearance and since, I have made it an annual tradition because there’s no other city, or weekend, in the racing world like Louisville, KY on Derby Day.

Although the story of a Kentucky Derby winner is legendary, a champions trail is what The Kentucky Derby Post is all about. The coverage begins when Juvenile season starts and continues until the field is set, the picks are in and the roses are earned.