I gave this 2 stars because I found the flavor really nice, even though I threw them all away. I wanted to make something different and special for breakfast today, and I had no eggs. This sounded perfect. I followed the recipe except that I doubled the ingredients. The results were dense and way too "moist". They were not fluffy and even when the outside was way too brown, the center had a wet texture as if it were not fully cooked. I will not make these again. ever.

Reviewer:

I added some flax seed meal and used whole wheat flour to make it a bit healthier.
Like other reviewers have said, batter came out really watery and the I didn't taste the bananas. I added a tad more flour as suggested but still a no go. Disappointed.

Reviewer:

I made this morning for the family and it came out great! I added 1/2 tsp. of vanilla extract (instead of 1/4) and 1 tablespoon of brown sugar (instead of 1 teaspoon), and chilled it in the fridge for 30 minutes to allow the baking powder to activate. I didn't find the batter to be thin and soupy at all. The pancakes came out fluffy and delicious and the flavour balance of peanut butter and banana was great. Will definitely make these again.

Reviewer:

My favorite pancake recipe so far, my family loved them. Next time I would try to cut much smaller chunks of banana, as the larger chunks seemed to keep some of the flipped pancake from cooking all the way through on the first pancakes I made. Lovely recipe, yum! :)

Reviewer:

This was great. I think there was just enough peanut butter and just enough banana. I used one frozen banana which I mashed and one fresh banana that I cut into chuncks. I did double the batter and used half whole wheat and half all purpose. It was great.

Reviewer:

i read everyone else's reviews AFTER making the batter and eating a pancake, and i feel as though maybe a lot of people who chose to try this recipe don't make pancakes regularly... if you haven't made pancakes frequently, and you haven't experimented making pancakes before, then you should before trying this recipe.
i followed the recipe as it were, adding all the dry ingredients, vanilla, and peanut butter together (two spoonfuls~1/4 cup) and then the whole banana (mashed while stirring).
once this appears mixed, i poured milk directly from the carton into the mix until the mixture was of the right consistency--this is always the recommended method when making pancakes, because then you are able to adjust your batter better. i found it should definitely be slightly runnier, because the peanut butter and bananas chunk up and make the pancake thick while it is cooking (leading to either burning on one side, or raw in the center)--
PERFECT PANCAKES, every time. and they're outstandingly delicious. the only pancakes i've ever wanted to eat without needing butter or syrup, so i'm not sure if others used bad pb or bad bananas, but Jif and normal-sized, raw (slightly blackened peel) bananas were fantastic in this.
*Only* thing i added was a teaspoon of baking soda. (baking powder+baking soda=awesome baked goods, especially pancakes)

Reviewer:

The pancakes were good. I used whole wheat flour, cinnamon, and extra vanilla as others suggested. But the pancakes stuck to the pan like glue, even when I put more oil on the pan. Maybe it needs oil in the pancakes.

Reviewer:

I followed the recipe, mostly. I used organic whole wheat pastry flour and I sifted it. Then I substituted the milk with un-sweetened almond milk and cut it to 1 1/2 cups. I also used crunchy peanut butter. And I used one large banana with large-ish pieces. I spread some more peanut butter on top with some lyke's golden syrup. GOOD stuff