My friend got this for me from Japan, and sad to say, it's terrible. I do like the packaging, as it is a twist-up eyeliner without a lid, and seems to be self-sharpening. However, I can't apply this to my eyelids because it is SO hard, difficult to apply, and tugs on my skin like none other. The black color is also not deep enough, and fades really quickly. I was so excited to try Kate Cosmetics, but this one went in the trash almost immediately.