On the night of Saturday, June 17, a man came into the bar for the famous drink and stole the famous toe when he left — a big faux pas.

Police are offering a reward for anyone who brings “The Toe” back. Apparently, the man in question was from Quebec and even left his Sourtoe Cocktail certificate (which is given to customers who try the cocktail) at the bar, so police know the name of the thief.

“We are furious,” the hotel’s Toe Captain, Terry Lee, said in a statement. “Toes are very hard to come by. Stunts like this adversely affect the whole community, not just the Downtown Hotel. We fortunately have a couple of back up toes, but we really need this one back.”

Apparently, the man stopped into the hotel after the designated “Toe Time,” when the cocktail is served, between 9 p.m. and 11 p.m. and demanded the drink. The bartender served him anyway out of courtesy, and he even joked about stealing the toe before leaving.

According to the CBC, this particular toe was donated by a man who had to have it surgically removed and it was cured in salt for 6 months.