I don't know about proc rates, but our paladin got the Eye of Blazing Power trinket and it made up 6% of his heals. Assuming the proc value is similar, I'd say it'll account for a similar amount in your overall healing.

Tbh, datas please. So far ive passed on conq. Tokens but i sure as hell am next in line to get one this lockout. I really want to know how often this procs. Ill update once I can give more input but in the meantime I'd be very happy if someone else has anything to say about this.

Originally Posted by Dyra

Because what they are atm are plait tugging, sniffing, glaring, prissy, clothes obsessed bitches who I would quite cheerfully drown.

I often post from my mobile device, typos in my posts are 99% likely to be because of that.

Tbh, datas please. So far ive passed on conq. Tokens but i sure as hell am next in line to get one this lockout. I really want to know how often this procs. Ill update once I can give more input but in the meantime I'd be very happy if someone else has anything to say about this.

Even if you don't value the four piece (and it's value is pretty low), all five tier pieces are best-in-slot considering the itemization of non-set pieces in Firelands. Unless you're giving it up in favor of DPS 4 pieces, you really should not be passing.

We haven't raided since I hit my 4-pc on Wednesday, but I can post logs after tomorrow's raid if no one else has provided the data you're looking for by then.

Even if you don't value the four piece (and it's value is pretty low), all five tier pieces are best-in-slot considering the itemization of non-set pieces in Firelands. Unless you're giving it up in favor of DPS 4 pieces, you really should not be passing.

We haven't raided since I hit my 4-pc on Wednesday, but I can post logs after tomorrow's raid if no one else has provided the data you're looking for by then.

I'm very well aware of the itemization, but we've had a greedy guildmaster paladin who took the conq. tokens that dropped so far. I'm next in line. I know very well that they're BiS and I wouldn't pass on them to some random moron. But I'd be very grateful if you could upload some data on the proc.

Edit: Can this procc from Atonement? It says any helpful spell, atonement heals but it's original purpose (smite) isn't exactly helpfull... is it? I'd assume that it cannot proc from atonement as long as noone can state facts about the opposite.

Originally Posted by Dyra

Because what they are atm are plait tugging, sniffing, glaring, prissy, clothes obsessed bitches who I would quite cheerfully drown.

I often post from my mobile device, typos in my posts are 99% likely to be because of that.

I don't know about proc rates, but our paladin got the Eye of Blazing Power trinket and it made up 6% of his heals. Assuming the proc value is similar, I'd say it'll account for a similar amount in your overall healing.

Sorry I can't help that much

That's pretty amazing. Either your paladin had incredible luck or his healing outside of the trinket is awful. I got the trinket on my holy paladin alt during our alt run yesterday, and the trinket averaged out to 266 HPS during several boss kills. If that was 6% of his healing, does that mean he does 4-5k HPS?

As for the OP's question, yes. You should go for the 4 piece bonus. "Gear with better itemization" doesn't exist this tier.

I can give you numbers in a few days. I currently need 400 more VP to get my legs, we've been progressing on heroic bosses and I havn't bothered to do random heroic dungeons to get the last piece for my 4 set yet.

"That's his talent, the dead answer his call."
"They answer his call. And there are a lot more of the dead than there are of the living."

That's pretty amazing. Either your paladin had incredible luck or his healing outside of the trinket is awful. I got the trinket on my holy paladin alt during our alt run yesterday, and the trinket averaged out to 266 HPS during several boss kills. If that was 6% of his healing, does that mean he does 4-5k HPS?

I don't remember the exact fight... I think it was Majordomo? Maybe he just got confused and told us another percentage on recount, since he definitely doesn't pull 4k HPS :P Or maybe he got really lucky. I'll still take the trinket for myself... the intellect alone is awesome.

As for the OP's question, yes. You should go for the 4 piece bonus. "Gear with better itemization" doesn't exist this tier.

This. Have fun with the 3 spirit pieces in firelands. I have to keep making deals with our mages

Why would you pass on the 4 piece? As others have said, it's not as if there's alternative gear that has waaay better itemisation. In fact, other than the legs, tier 12 has pretty decent stats on it ie spirit & haste/mastery.

Beth'tilac was obviously going to be the best fight for this because everyone is constantly losing health. As you can see it healed for 433 388. It did roughly 4.2% of my healing done on that fight. Obviously it faired worse on other fights were people spent most of the time topped.

With regards to proc chance and ICD, I haven't done any real tested so I'm afriad I cant help you there.