To Save a Marriage, Split Up?

Transcription

1 R. C. AULETTA and COMPANY, LLC 59 East 54 th Street New York, NY Tel (212) The Wall Street Journal August 9, 2011 Frequency: Daily To Save a Marriage, Split Up? Separating Is Difficult, Success Is Hard to Predict; But for Some, It's a Last, Best Resort Get Breathing Room: Jeanine and Mark Earnhart, walking on the beach in San Juan Island, Wash., were barely speaking when they split up after 35 years of marriage. After 35 years of marriage, Mark Earnhart came home one day and told his wife, Jeanine, that he wanted a separation. He said he was tired of the bickering and tension, the lack of communication, how they never did anything together anymore. His wife sadly agreed that the marriage seemed broken. So Mr. Earnhart, a chiropractor, moved out of their home to a furnished apartment on the other side of San Juan Island, in Washington. Three months later husband and wife were back together. They have been married now for 42 years. It seems counterintuitive: How can a separation save a marriage? When a couple splits even for a trial period isn't that just a pit stop on the way to divorce?

2 Recall Better Times: They were teen sweethearts on their wedding day in The Earnharts began to irritate each other over the years. Surprisingly, many marriage therapists recommend a separation, albeit as a measure of last resort. They say that if both spouses set specific parameters, the space and time to think that a trial separation provides just might be what is needed to save the relationship. Still, there are few, if any, statistics that show whether it works or how many couples try separating. Sharon Gilchrest O'Neill, a marriage and family therapist in Mount Kisco, N.Y., has helped about 40 couples arrange trial separations over the past 20 years and says that about half reconciled and remained married. Ms. O'Neill recommends that a separation shouldn't just happen after one partner storms out, say. The couple should decide who will move out and where that person will live, how the finances will be handled, the care-giving of the kids, what to tell friends and family, and very importantly how long the separation will last. She believes that six months is ideal, and most experts agree. It's long enough to set up a second household and gain perspective, but not long enough to seem permanent. Share Sparingly: The Earnharts discussed their plan to split, and their reasons, with their family, shown on a recent visit. Therapists suggest sharing details only with those closest to you who If a couple has experienced infidelity, they should deal with that issue in therapy before planning a separation, says Ms. O'Neill. Marriage therapists say that by the time most couples show up in therapy talking about divorce it's often too late to salvage the relationship. There's so much anger, hurt and mistrust that the partners can't work out their issues. But what if the partners took a break before the hatred set in? It wouldn't have to be the formal separation that is often a legal precursor to divorce, but an informal break to give the spouses some space to breathe, think and calm down. Often, the reality-check that marital separations provide the prospect of unraveling finances, facing dating again, fully grasping the collateral damage done to the kids is enough to make people resolve to work harder on the marriage.

3 "Sometimes having a dress rehearsal for divorce makes them realize they don't want to do it," says Richard Levak, a psychologist who works with couples in Del Mar, Calif. Linda Lea Viken, a divorce attorney in Rapid City, S.D., and president of the American Academy of Matrimonial Lawyers, says it's important for each party to understand the other's motivation. She has seen cases in which one person isn't really interested in reconciling, but wants to use the separation to buy time to rearrange or dispose of assets. Ms. Viken also warns couples that the arrangements made during a trial separation, such as who pays the bills and where the children live, may have a big impact on an eventual divorce, if there is one. It will be hard, for example, to convince a judge to award full custody of the children to one parent if in the separation period the couple had agreed to a split. For this reason, she suggests that each spouse consult a divorce attorney. Then there's the fraught issue of whether each party is allowed to see other people during the separation. Some therapists believe that dating is OK, as long as both parties are truly comfortable with the decision. Ms. Viken disagrees. "If one of the parties wants to date, this is not a trial separation, it's the end," she says. Another tricky issue: What to tell family and friends? Experts say couples should decide together what the party line is, then tell only those people who really need to know. "Until a marriage is going to go down the path of divorce, you should keep as much to yourselves as you can, otherwise it may come back to haunt you if you stay together," Ms. O'Neill says. The Earnharts, who are both 61 and live in Friday Harbor, Wash., decided to separate in They say they had gotten to the point where they barely spoke. He spent his spare time golfing, and she went shopping or to lunch with friends. They ate dinner in front of the TV without talking, gave each other the silent treatment for days on end, and rarely had sex. By the time Mr. Earnhart decided to move out, the couple had read numerous selfhelp books, taken separate vacations and gone to see tw o marriage therapists. Nothing helped. Ms. Earnhart wrote down a list of things that irritated her about her husband. At the top: The way he chewed, monopolized a conversation and walked like a duck. The couple separated for three months then reunited.

4 "We repelled each other," Mr. Earnhart says. "I thought, 'Why not do what you want to do?' " adds his wife. "Life is too short and I don't like you anyway." So he moved to a condo, yet continued to pay the couple's bills. She stayed in their house. They told their adult son and daughter why they were separating and were relieved when their kids said they understood. And they talked regularly, at first on the phone. Then Mr. Earnhart started coming over to the house with a bottle of wine. They would sit outside, look at the water and discuss how to divide up their assets in a divorce. They talked about how they could communicate better and be less judgmental. After awhile, they realized they missed their friendship. They talked about the memories they shared how they'd bought a house and built a life together and wondered what they were doing by throwing it all away. One night, they ended up in bed together. Mark and Jeanine Earnhart, with their daughter, Laura Holden, center, cooking at their home in San Juan Island, Wash. "It was kind of like falling in love again," says Ms. Earnhart. "He would come over for some silly reason, and we would have a heck of a conversation and a really good time. "When you are apart, you have time to reflect, first on all of the things that were upsetting in your life with each other," says her husband. "And then you realize that you've allowed things that maybe aren't really important to take on a life of their own." After three months of living apart, Mr. Earnhart moved back in. Now, the couple tries to talk out problems as soon as they arise, often leaving each other polite, little notes about an issue, like the one that Ms. Earnhart recently left her husband, telling him she felt he had been rude and didn't want to stew on the issue. He left her a note, apologizing. They also entertain friends and travel, taking road trips to California and Alaska. Mr. Earnhart cooks dinner each night, and the two often eat while watching and discussing whatever is on the Food Network. They have self-published a book about marriage, called "Marriage Works."

5 "You can get to the point where you feel that there's no way that you will ever fall in love with this person again, but you can," says Ms. Earnhart. "He still waddles like a duck, but now I love him for it."

A BAD BET Mr. and Mrs. Bates had been married for forty years. In those forty years they had never had a fight, much less an argument. They were a happy couple because they always agreed on everything.

I M NOT AN ADDICT How could I be an addict? My life is great. I live in a very good area of Los Angeles, drive a nice sports car, have a good job, pay all my bills, and have a wonderful family. This is

Connectedness and the Emotional Bank Account Directions This is a self-guided activity that can be completed by parents, teens or both. It contains five parts and should take about 45 minutes to complete.

The following is a real-time transcript taken as closed captioning during the oral argument proceedings, and as such, may contain errors. This service is provided solely for the purpose of assisting those

This is the most effective and powerful script for securing appointment with FSBO's you will ever put to use. This scrip will increase your appointment closing ratio by 50-60%. The thing to keep in mind

What You Need to Know About Divorce There are four main steps in a divorce: 1. 2. 3. 4. Your lawyer writes the divorce papers and files them with the court. The sheriff s department gives (serves) your

Weaving the Pieces Together By Annette Unten Life is a woven tapestry. All the people and the events that enter my life become a part of the threads in my tapestry. Bright colors are woven with pastels.

p T w o T h a n k s g i v i n g D a y G e n t l e m e n THERE IS ONE DAY THAT IS OURS. THERE IS ONE day when all Americans go back to the old home and eat a big dinner. Bless the day. The President gives

Announcer: Announcer: Effects of Social Media on a Relationship. This is Stay Happily Married, Episode number 294. Welcome to Stay Happily Married. Your source for weekly updates on the latest tips and

Ohio Judicial Conference Family Matters: The Legal System People go to a divorce lawyer for many reasons. Some want to get their spouse's attention, change behavior or send a warning. Others, having given

Seven Things You Must Know Before Hiring a Divorce Lawyer Introduction Divorce is a stressful time for everyone. Whether you ve been together for 3 months or 30 years, it s important that you follow through

What Makes a Healthy Relationship? Hopefully, you and your significant other are treating each other well. Not sure if that's the case? Take a step back from the dizzying sensation of being swept off your

SOCIAL SECURITY OVERPAYMENTS: RESPONDING TO A NOTICE THAT SAYS YOU HAVE BEEN OVERPAID This document contains general information for educational purposes and should not be construed as legal advice. It

1. They are the United States. a) to b) for c) from d) with 3. is your favourite colour? a) How b) This c) Who d) What 5. This is my car. a) mother b) mothers c) mother is d) mother's 7. Are these shoes

WHERE DO I STAND? A child s legal guide to separation and divorce. INTRODUCTION This is a pamphlet for children whose parents separate or divorce. Separation or divorce is the result of problems between

THE BASICS Getting a Divorce in New York State Either the wife or the husband can ask a Court for a divorce. In this booklet, we say that the wife is the person who will go to Court to request a divorce

Shutting Off Central Air During Long Weekend Can anyone shed some light? My wife and I disagree (surprise) about whether when leaving the house for a longer period of time, eg a weekend, it is better to

My name is Tim Sain, and you guys are in a budgeting workshop. Has anyone ever done any kind of financial literacy? No. Budgeting? Workshop? Talked about money? Has anybody ever showed you how to spend

What you should know about IN ONTARIO This booklet contains information about the law as it was at the time it was written. The law can change. Check the Ministry of the Attorney General website at http://www.attorneygeneral.jus.gov.on.ca

DIVORCE General Information Packet#1 Are you heading for a Divorce? This first packet of information will give you an overall view of what is needed in order for you to get a divorce. You will find out

1 Tom and Daisy That spring, the sun shone every day. I was lonely at first in the East. But I felt that this was the real beginning of my life. I walked in the fresh air. I bought books. I worked hard.

Running head: MOVIE REVIEW: MY LEFT FOOT 1 Alexis Naugle 2-15-13 Intro to Special Education Dr. Macy 2 The movie I chose to review was called My Left Foot, The story of Christy Brown filmed in 1989. The

p T h e L a s t L e a f IN A SMALL PART OF THE CITY WEST OF Washington Square, the streets have gone wild. They turn in different directions. They are broken into small pieces called places. One street

(2) FEAR OF FEAR This lady was cautious. She decided she wouldn t let herself go in her drinking. And she would never, never take that morning drink! Ididn t think I was an alcoholic. I thought my problem

WEEKEND INVESTOR Five Strategies to Get a Better Deal in Mediation Tilt the process in your favor in a divorce or a dispute with a broker or business partner Beth Pickenpaugh, seen here with her daughter,

Depression Is Common Lately Lindsay hasn't felt like herself. Her friends have noticed it, too. Kia was surprised when Lindsay turned down her invitation to go to the mall last Saturday. There was really

Being a Carer and Having a Carer s Assessment How to get help if you are doing a lot to look after another person Introduction What is this pack about? This pack is to help people with learning disabilities

Test name: L1U8test Listening Making plans Listen. Then complete the sentences. 1. In this phone call,. a. Mike is talking to Gary b. Mike is leaving a message for Gary c. Gary is leaving a message for

T h e C o p a n d t h e A n t h e m p The Cop and the Anthem S OAPY MOVED RESTLESSLY ON HIS SEAT in Madison Square. There are certain signs to show that winter is coming. Birds begin to fly south. Women

Dialog: VIP LESSON 049 - Future of Business A: We really embarrassed ourselves last night at that business function. B: What are you talking about? A: We didn't even have business cards to hand out. We

Tricia Stouch I lost my daughter Pamela on March 27th 2010 to a heroin overdose. She was nineteen years old. Pamela's struggle began when she was a senior in high school. Pamela left me a journal on her

How to Save Money on Your Divorce An overview of the Divorce process in California, and how to choose the right Attorney for your budget. Brought to you by: Legal Action Workshop The Law Firm that offers

You're Getting Divorced: Now What? You've decided that your marriage just isn't working out, and that you need to get a divorce. It's not an easy decision, but it's one you feel you have to make. Or, your

W ashington State Developmental Disabilities Council Partnering with People with Developmental Disabilities to Build Better Lives A Troubling Tale: Results of Washington s No Paid Services Caseload Survey

The present perfect verb tense is a little difficult in English it is used in several different ways, and there are lots of rules to remember. This lesson will teach you everything you ever wanted to know

C O L L A B O R A T I V E frustrating and infuriating is how Marty S. describes communication with his exwife and her attorney throughout their divorce. Tense and horrific is what Tama B. remembers about

Pastor Spotlight Martha Fisher, CBC Women s Pastor Inspiration Martha Fisher, Women s Pastor at Community Bible Church, leads with a passion to reach, teach and help the women of our community for Jesus.

Role of husbands and wives in Ephesians 5 Summary The aim of this study is to help us think about relationships between men and women. It is meant to get us thinking about how we should behave in intimate

Who Are You Married To? Balancing Graduate School and Marriage Chris Labosier Department of Geography Texas A&M University College Station, TX 77843 E-mail: clabosier@tamu.edu Anna Labosier Speech-Language

Does Marriage Counseling really work? Rabbi Slatkin answers All of the questions you are too afraid to ask. 1 Does Marriage Counseling really work? Rabbi Slatkin answers all the questions you are too afraid

SPARE THE CHILD - PARENTING DURING FAMILY DISSOLUTION Page 1 of 10 I recently came across a great 18 minute long video produced by The Virginia State Bar Family Law Section to help parents understand how

Present continuous The present continuous is used to talk about present situations which we see as short- term or temporary. We use the present simple to talk about present situations which we see as longterm

Daddy version Over There (Place your family photo here) By the (write in your family name) family Developed by ZERO TO THREE gratefully acknowledges the Iraq Afghanistan Deployment Impact Fund administered

"A Young Child's Point of View on Foster Care and Adoption" Michael Trout Director, The Infant-Parent Institute Reprinted by permission Mr. Trout is a trainer and course leader in infant mental health,

Alabama Cooperative Extension System, Alabama A&M and Auburn Universities HE-687 PRINCIPL E S OF Something Better Than Punishment When we think of discipline, we may think of threats and punishment. They

How to Use Retirement Accounts As Your Private Lender Jim Ingersoll back with you on how to partner with and utilize retirement accounts to work with you on your real estate deals. Doesn't that sound cool?

Matrimonial Property General Information Introduction What is the Matrimonial Property Act? Each province in Canada has its own law to deal with the division of property on marriage breakdown. In Alberta,

COUNSELING AFFILIATES SEXUAL ADDICTION TREATMENT PROGRAM GUIDELINES FOR WRITING A DISCLOSURE TO RELATIONSHIP PARTNERS 1. Start with the text of the First Step if available. Only do disclosure after completing

The Mental Capacity Act The Mental Capacity Act Helping and supporting people who are unable to make some decisions for themselves Easyread This booklet gives information on a law called the Mental Capacity

T h e G i f t o f t h e M a g i p T h e G i f t o f t h e M a g i ONE DOLLAR AND EIGHTY-SEVEN CENTS. That was all. She had put it aside, one cent and then another and then another, in her careful buying

~ The Great Banquet ~ You can learn much more about this story by doing these three things: 1. Read Luke 14:1-24 2. Discover key cultural and historical insights. 3. Answer the reflective questions. 1.

Utah Divorce Survival Kit An Instruction Manual Prepared by Common Ground Divorce Mediation THIS KIT IS FOR: This kit has been put together by experienced divorce professionals for couples who desire to

Page 1 of 5 back to article Printed on page A1 Lies a new tool in foreclosure Lawyers, in rush to regain properties, can exploit judges' workload By Todd Ruger Published: Sunday, May 10, 2009 at 1:00 a.m.

Addiction: The Family Disease Symptoms, Behaviors, Feelings Reference: Claudia Black, Ph.D.,MSW Family Strategies Definition of Family Disease Addiction affects the entire family. In an addictive family

Dialog: VIP LESSON 001 - Alimony A: Why is Kevin selling his house? B: He's getting a divorce and says he won't be able to pay for it after he pays alimony and child support. A: Why is he getting a divorce?

Resolving Conflict in Intimate Relationships The Problem of Conflict 2011 Homewood Human Solutions. This workbook accompanies the e-course Resolving Conflict in Intimate Relationships and is for the exclusive

1 CULTURE More than two million people visit San Francisco every year. San Francisco is famous for its shops, its restaurants, its beautiful old buildings, and its cable cars. San Francisco s Chinatown

Stepping Forward A Self-help Guide for Low Mood in later Life 1 Everyone feels sad or down sometimes. If these feelings have not passed after a few days, you may be experiencing the signs of low mood or

A Residential Treatment Center specializing in the treatment of Adolescent Pornography Addiction and Sexual Compulsion Brian Pace, MHC, MA, ED - Executive Officer Brian Pace was one of the original contributors

Step down in style Look at all that's involved before taking a buyout 12:00 AM CDT on Monday, April 10, 2006 By PAMELA YIP / The Dallas Morning News When Don and Marge Thompson were presented with a buyout

The Story of Ruby Bridges Our Ruby taught us all a lot. She became someone who helped change our country. She was part of history, just like generals and presidents are part of history. They re leaders,

CD Our Own Way Lyrics Beverly Granoff 2012 1. All The Things We See 2. Remember the Rules 3. You and Me 4. This Too Shall Pass 5. My Best Try 6. Our Own Way 7. A Little Help From You 8. My La La Melody

HOW TO LOWER YOUR GENERAL LIABILITY INSURANCE BY THOUSANDS OF DOLLARS! AN INSIDER'S GUIDE TO GETTING THE BEST POLICY AT THE LOWEST PRICE AVAILABLE If you are a small contractor, you or your wife have to