What People Were Saying About Eminem 18 Years Ago

It was February 23, 1999, and it was the day Eminem released The Slim Shady LP. From the beginning, it was obvious that the world would have a complicated relationship with this white rapper from Detroit. Now we’ve had 17 years of getting to know and understand the man behind some of the most controversial music that the mainstream has ever dealt with. And the relationship is still pretty complicated. You can read what people were saying about Eminem before and after the release of The Slim Shady LP:

❝ He’s a charlatan and a fraud, who is as bad musically as he is content-wise. There is talent there, but he could be doing so much more with it.❞

– Jim DeRogatis, Chicago writer (1999).

❝ “You can’t take all the blame off him, but you also got to put the blame on a society that, in America at least, raises boys to be sexist, to be homophobic, to be knuckleheads that’s the American way. Eminem, the shit that he says, is ‘Fight For Your Right To Party 2000.’ It’s ignorant but it gives me hope people can change.❞

– Ad-Rock, The Beastie Boys (1999).

❝ Don’t be surprised when Eminem comes out and he just blows up because the majority of this country has more in common with him than they do with Rass Kass. Then the black folks who couldn’t relate to Em in the first place are gonna diss him and his fans citing a racist society and media. Eminem will then loose sic his props and become the next House of Pain.❞

– NDN’z, Davey D’s Hip Hop Corner (1998).

❝ Only a year into my career as a music journalist, I couldn’t articulate what made Em so compelling. Obviously, his music was strong but there was something else. From the moment we exchanged pounds I knew he had something. For lack of a better term, it was a star-charisma, unlike any other artist I’d interviewed. It’s why I bought a disposable camera and documented the trip. I have never taken a picture of an artist before and I haven’t done it since… So when I came back to NYC, naturally, I regaled everyone that would listen about how I’d heard the future of rap.❞

– Noah Callahan-Bever, Complex (1998).

❝ Point blank, this ain’t your average cat. This Motor City kid is a one-of-a-kind talent and he’s about to blow past the competition, leaving many melted microphones in the dust.❞

– Riggs Morales, The Source (1998).

❝ When Eminem’s in obnoxious Itchy ‘n Scratchy meets Benny Hill mode (like on the opening ‘Public Service Announcement’) he’s hilarious (misogynist and homophobic but undeniably hilarious). But when he gets all pious and whining and develops a social conscience (like on ‘If I Had’), then – ugh! He fucken’ SUCKS!❞

– Unknown author, NME (1999).

❝ I honestly didn’t think he was gonna become a superstar. Even though I heard ‘My Name Is,’ I didn’t think it was gonna blow up as big as it did. And I didn’t think he was gonna have that huge pop appeal. I thought ‘My Name Is’ was novelty. But lyrically and his flow both were very good. I didn’t think he was like one of those Young Black Teenagers, ‘Tap the bottle and twist the cap’ type of rappers. I didn’t think he was a flash in the pan.❞

– Darin Byrne, MTV News (1999).

❝ Give this kid a magazine rack, because he’s got a lot of issues.❞

– Charles Aaron, SPIN (1999).

❝ It started because he is a bitch ass nigga! Right now it stands with me kicking in his fucking face, real horrorshow, I ain’t lettin’ all the shit he said slide.❞