Francis on Maddy

First impressions? Attractive, definitely a girl I'd spot at a party.

What did you talk about? Life in Sheffield (it turned out we went to the same university and lived in the same halls of residence – small world). The latest Vampire Weekend album (apparently it takes 15 listens to get into but is brilliant).

Any awkward moments? The conversation flowed without any great effort.

Good table manners? Yes, she was polite and friendly and we shared dishes.

Best thing about her? Warm and confident. She's clearly not afraid of doing something different.

Did you go on somewhere? Sadly, it was a school night and we both had to get home.

Marks out of 10? 8. She was good company and I had a great evening.

Would you meet again? I think we'd both agree there weren't any sparks flying, so if we do, it will be as friends.

Maddy on Francis

First impressions? I was glad he was still there because I was a little late as I'd managed to go to the wrong place. He was nice-looking, friendly and very smiley.

What did you talk about? Why we'd signed up for the date, running, birthday celebrations, travelling, housemates, growing up (or not!), jobs, football and politics (both of which I think I just about pulled off).

Any awkward moments? Nothing to top arriving at the wrong restaurant.

Good table manners? Admirable.

Best thing about him? He was positive, friendly, open and polite. He even averted his gaze quickly when the belly dancer started gyrating.

Did you go on somewhere? It was a school night and we were being sensible.

Marks out of 10? I'd give the evening a 7 – the food was nice, the venue relaxed.

Would you meet again? I invited him to come running with me, but he wasn't sure he'd be able to hack the pace.