“*Nsync” is all Desi posted with the photo, to which Jill verified: “This was real.” But at least she had some company! According to our friends at Buzzworthy, Taylor Swift was one of many who were also overcome with emotion as soon as the words “Bye Bye Bye” first echoed through the Barclays Center. (Is the Swifty *NSYNC face the new surprised face?)

If this is how Jill reacts just being in the audience for *NSYNC, we’d hate to see what would happen if she ever came face-to-face with Ben Savage…

+ Were you, like Jill and Tay, paralyzed at the sight of *NSYNC? Relive the epic reunion and share your reaction in the comments!