If this is your first visit, be sure to
check out the FAQ by clicking the
link above. You may have to register
before you can post: click the register link above to proceed. To start viewing messages,
select the forum that you want to visit from the selection below.

Announcement

Collapse

No announcement yet.

1 week away and the GMEN SWAMI Says trade for Braylon and draft Britt and Robiskie

1 week away and the GMEN SWAMI Says trade for Braylon and draft Britt and Robiskie

04-19-2009, 12:08 PM

I say package up a deal to trade Smith a #2 and 5 for Braylon. Thats right Steve Smith. I would rather keep Hixon who is more valuable than Steve Smith due too him being a Pro Bowl type return man. The truth is guys we are wasting him by playing WR every down. He needs to return punts and kickoffs and be on special teams as well as a third down receiver as well as coming in on 3 or 4 side packages. He is the best in the league right now on returning kicks and we are wasting him every down at WR. Besides this gives Moss some reps. I say if Cleveland wants Smith so be it as we need to trade someone good to get a #1 receiver.
After spending some time looking at all the WR in this draft and where the Giants pick at #1 and there 2 #2 picks they can end up drafting Kenny Britt at 29 and Robinskie with their other second round pick. These guys clearer are #1 and #2 type big time receivers in the making. Check out the Daily news article today on Kenny Britt. The dude can play.

[quote user="oldschoolGMEN"]I say package up a deal to trade Smith a #2 and 5 for Braylon. Thats right Steve Smith. I would rather keep Hixon who is more valuable than Steve Smith due too him being a Pro Bowl type return man. The truth is guys we are wasting him by playing WR every down. He needs to return punts and kickoffs and be on special teams as well as a third down receiver as well as coming in on 3 or 4 side packages. He is the best in the league right now on returning kicks and we are wasting him every down at WR. Besides this gives Moss some reps. I say if Cleveland wants Smith so be it as we need to trade soemone good to get a #1 receiver.
After spending some time looking at all the WR in this draft and where the Giants pick at #1 and there 2 #2 picks they can end up drafting Kenny Britt at 29 and Robinskie with their other second round pick. These guys clearer are #1 and #2 type big time receivers in the making.

Comment

Read this and understand one thing you need to trade something someone wants to get something we need. You do not think Hixon is more valuable on special teams then you really do not watch Giant games or understand football. Hixon is better than Smith for all the reasons I stated. Hixon is better than Smith. There are many #2 players like Smith you can develop but there are very few special team players liuke Hixon who are so versitale.
I will say it again you have to trade something someone wants to get something we need. Read thata 100o times and maybe you will get it.

Comment

Please answer this Question ? If you had to trade Smith to get Braylon Edwards straight up would you do it knowing he is a #1 receiver and we need a true #1 receiver knowing we have a number of #2 receivers already on the team ???

I will say it again you have to trade something someone wants to get something we need.

Comment

[quote user="oldschoolGMEN"]Read this and understand one thing you need to trade something someone wants to get something we need. You do not think Hixon is more valuable on special teams then you really do not watch Giant games or understand football. Hixon is better than Smith for all the reasons I stated. Hixon is better than Smith. There are many #2 players like Smith you can develop but there are very few special team players liuke Hixon who are so versitale.
I will say it again you have to trade something someone wants to get something we need. Read thata 100o times and maybe you will get it.
[/quote]

Ill say it again.....I stopped reading at trade Smith.......

why does everyone think a WR is a WR is a WR?

yes Hixon can run back kicks...so can Bradshaw...is he now more valuable than BJ?
so can Ross is he more valuable than Webster?

I dont think YOU understand football friend.....Smith will be as good a possession guy as any above average guy in the league who makes his money in the middle of the field..

Smith for Edwards makes no sense........apples and oranges........
dont get me wrong I dont want to lose Hixon either .....

I would part with Kiwi before any reciever

Comment

[quote user="oldschoolGMEN"]Read this and understand one thing you need to trade something someone wants to get something we need. You do not think Hixon is more valuable on special teams then you really do not watch Giant games or understand football. Hixon is better than Smith for all the reasons I stated. Hixon is better than Smith. There are many #2 players like Smith you can develop but there are very few special team players liuke Hixon who are so versitale.
I will say it again you have to trade something someone wants to get something we need. Read thata 100o times and maybe you will get it.
[/quote]

The old "you don't know anything about football if you don't agree with me" arguement. Brilliant!!

Luckily, it would seem our GM feels the same way. Guess he doesn't know very much about football either.

Moron.

I stopped fighting my inner demons. We're on the same side now.

Comment

[quote user="oldschoolGMEN"]Please answer this Question ? If you had to trade Smith to get Braylon Edwards straight up would you do it knowing he is a #1 receiver and we need a true #1 receiver knowing we have a number of #2 receivers already on the team ???

I will say it again you have to trade something someone wants to get something we need.
[/quote]

Cleveland would have to be as moronic as you to trade straight up for Smith. You're posts are getting worse.

I'll say it again........moron.

I stopped fighting my inner demons. We're on the same side now.

Comment

[quote user="YATittle1962"][quote user="oldschoolGMEN"]Read this and understand one thing you need to trade something someone wants to get something we need. You do not think Hixon is more valuable on special teams then you really do not watch Giant games or understand football. Hixon is better than Smith for all the reasons I stated. Hixon is better than Smith. There are many #2 players like Smith you can develop but there are very few special team players liuke Hixon who are so versitale.
I will say it again you have to trade something someone wants to get something we need. Read thata 100o times and maybe you will get it.
[/quote]

Ill say it again.....I stopped reading at trade Smith.......

why does everyone think a WR is a WR is a WR?

yes Hixon can run back kicks...so can Bradshaw...is he now more valuable than BJ?
so can Ross is he more valuable than Webster?

I dont think YOU understand football friend.....Smith will be as good a possession guy as any above average guy in the league who makes his money in the middle of the field..

Smith for Edwards makes no sense........apples and oranges........
dont get me wrong I dont want to lose Hixon either .....

I would part with Kiwi before any reciever

[/quote]

Comment

[quote user="oldschoolGMEN"]Please answer this Question ? If you had to trade Smith to get Braylon Edwards straight up would you do it knowing he is a #1 receiver and we need a true #1 receiver knowing* we have a number of* #2 receivers already on the team ???

I will say it again you have to trade something someone wants to get something we need.
[/quote]Straight up I'd trade Smith for Edwards anytime. I like Smith but.....

Comment

Hixon is more valuable than Smith in the Special Teams game. But for some reason we dont use Hixon as a returner like we should. Smith is a much more polished WR than Hixon and is key on 3rd downs. Not trading Smith. Braylon could be had for 2nd and a 5th. Its just about being patient.

Comment

[quote user="TuckYou"]Hixon is more valuable than Smith in the Special Teams game. But for some reason we dont use Hixon as a returner like we should. Smith is a much more polished WR than Hixon and is key on 3rd downs. Not trading Smith. Braylon could be had for 2nd and a 5th. Its just about being patient.[/quote]

"For some reason"? Starting #1's (even if they are filling in for a guy who shot himself) don't return kicks.

I stopped fighting my inner demons. We're on the same side now.

Comment

[quote user="oldschoolGMEN"]Read this and understand one thing you need to trade something someone wants to get something we need. You do not think Hixon is more valuable on special teams then you really do not watch Giant games or understand football. Hixon is better than Smith for all the reasons I stated. Hixon is better than Smith. There are many #2 players like Smith you can develop but there are very few special team players liuke Hixon who are so versitale.
I will say it again you have to trade something someone wants to get something we need. Read thata 100o times and maybe you will get it.
[/quote]

Of coarse its something for something common sense right. I don't want to see smith or hixon goanywhere to valuable to the team. imo I just don't see the Giants putting all their eggs in one basket BE would be nice but giving up S or H would be stupid. imho