Medicine’s Barbaric Little Secret: IV’s Don’t Have to Hurt

I was speaking to an old friend, a fellow physician, the other day about what makes hospitalized patients most uncomfortable. Incredibly, one of the things he told me was that when he is doing rounds in the intensive care unit (ICU), the blood drawings for the daily testing take place around 4:00 AM. I was shocked! How can patients get adequate rest when someone is jabbing a needle in their arms at that ungodly hour?

This led to a discussion about what doctors and nurses do to patients that, in my opinion, border on barbarity. One of them is starting intravenous lines with no local anesthesia on the skin. I consider this one of medical practice’s dirty little secrets. Let me explain…

When I entered anesthesia training in 1986, I was introduced to a practice that has long been the standard of anesthesia personnel, from physician anesthesiologists to nurse anesthetists to anesthesia assistants and pre-op nurses: the use of local anesthesia on the skin to start an IV.

When I was an internal medicine intern and medical student, I witnessed the unnecessary infliction of pain on patients who had their IVs started without local anesthesia, often by inexperienced students and interns. This horrible and immoral practice was just considered the norm. It wasn’t intentional, it was just the way things were done.

In 1986, as a new anesthesia resident, I was taught how to start an IV and, more importantly, how to do so relatively painlessly: with the use of less than 1 cc of the local anesthetic lidocaine. What we were taught is still in practice by many in my specialty today. A small wheal (bubble) of local anesthetic is applied with a tiny (and I mean tiny!) needle just where the IV is to be started in the vein. After five seconds, the practitioner can, with virtually NO pain to the patient, search for and find the proper site for insertion of the IV catheter. I know this to be true because, in my estimation, I’ve done this an astounding 80,000 times (you read that right) over a nearly 32-year career.

There is absolutely no reason that this should not be standard practice for every patient in need of an IV. The training takes five minutes and the results are dramatic. The amount of lidocaine administered is so minute that it causes no ill effects. And the patients are spared the painful ordeal of IV starts, especially when multiple sticks are involved.

My physician friend and I agreed that another area where this can be employed is when an arterial blood gas is drawn. This procedure is even more painful than an IV start. A needle is inserted into an artery to obtain an arterial blood sample for analysis. Let me tell you, it hurts like hell. Yet health care personnel still inflict it and patients endure it.

So, let 2019 be the year that patients stand up for themselves. Let it be the year that health care professionals ease the pain of patients. And let it be the time that Bottom Line put the message out: this barbaric practice is unnecessary and unwarranted. A touch of lidocaine in the right hands can make all the difference in the world!

For more with Dr. Sherer, click here for his podcast and video interviews.

print

Advertisement

About What Your Doctor Isn't Telling You

Dr. David Sherer is bold enough to tell you what others in the medical profession haven't the courage to say, with inside information on health, healthcare, related public policy and the latest in prevention, diagnosis and treatment of disease.

About David Sherer

David Sherer, MD, is an American physician, author and inventor. He is the lead author of Dr. David Sherer’s Hospital Survival Guide: 100+ Ways to Make Your Hospital Stay Safe and Comfortable. He is a member of Leading Physicians of the World, and a multi-time winner of HealthTap’s leading anesthesiologists award. Currently, Dr. Sherer practices anesthesiology in the suburbs of Washington D.C., and has held two U.S. patents in the fields of critical care medicine and telecommunications.
Appearing in all forms of media, he is a tireless advocate for hospitalized patients, and believes that individual responsibility, and not government intervention, is the key to improving the general health and wellbeing of all Americans. His memoir, The House of Black and White: My Life with and Search for Louise Johnson is his first work of non-medically related nonfiction.

Blogs

About Us

For over four decades, we’ve brought you the best in wellness and wealth advice from our family of experts. Isn’t it time that you get “inside” America’s trusted source? bottomlineinc.com brings you useful, expert, actionable information to help you navigate your world, saving time and money along the way. Bottom Line… empowering your life with expert advice!

Bottom Line, Inc. publishes the opinions of expert authorities in many fields These opinions are for educational and illustrative purposes only and should not be considered as either individual advice or as a substitute for legal, accounting, investment, medical and other professional services intended to suit your specific personal needs. Always consult a competent professional for answers specific to your questions and circumstances. Our content is further subject to our Terms and Conditions

Medicine’s Barbaric Little Secret: IV’s Don’t Have to Hurt

I was speaking to an old friend, a fellow physician, the other day about what makes hospitalized patients most uncomfortable. Incredibly, one of the things he told me was that when he is doing rounds in the intensive care unit (ICU), the blood drawings for the daily testing take place around 4:00 AM. I was shocked! How can patients get adequate rest when someone is jabbing a needle in their arms at that ungodly hour?

This led to a discussion about what doctors and nurses do to patients that, in my opinion, border on barbarity. One of them is starting intravenous lines with no local anesthesia on the skin. I consider this one of medical practice’s dirty little secrets. Let me explain…

When I entered anesthesia training in 1986, I was introduced to a practice that has long been the standard of anesthesia personnel, from physician anesthesiologists to nurse anesthetists to anesthesia assistants and pre-op nurses: the use of local anesthesia on the skin to start an IV.

When I was an internal medicine intern and medical student, I witnessed the unnecessary infliction of pain on patients who had their IVs started without local anesthesia, often by inexperienced students and interns. This horrible and immoral practice was just considered the norm. It wasn’t intentional, it was just the way things were done.

In 1986, as a new anesthesia resident, I was taught how to start an IV and, more importantly, how to do so relatively painlessly: with the use of less than 1 cc of the local anesthetic lidocaine. What we were taught is still in practice by many in my specialty today. A small wheal (bubble) of local anesthetic is applied with a tiny (and I mean tiny!) needle just where the IV is to be started in the vein. After five seconds, the practitioner can, with virtually NO pain to the patient, search for and find the proper site for insertion of the IV catheter. I know this to be true because, in my estimation, I’ve done this an astounding 80,000 times (you read that right) over a nearly 32-year career.

There is absolutely no reason that this should not be standard practice for every patient in need of an IV. The training takes five minutes and the results are dramatic. The amount of lidocaine administered is so minute that it causes no ill effects. And the patients are spared the painful ordeal of IV starts, especially when multiple sticks are involved.

My physician friend and I agreed that another area where this can be employed is when an arterial blood gas is drawn. This procedure is even more painful than an IV start. A needle is inserted into an artery to obtain an arterial blood sample for analysis. Let me tell you, it hurts like hell. Yet health care personnel still inflict it and patients endure it.

So, let 2019 be the year that patients stand up for themselves. Let it be the year that health care professionals ease the pain of patients. And let it be the time that Bottom Line put the message out: this barbaric practice is unnecessary and unwarranted. A touch of lidocaine in the right hands can make all the difference in the world!

For more with Dr. Sherer, click here for his podcast and video interviews.