From the trailer (the one I had seen at least), and from the description, it really didn’t do it justice. My expectations of what this was going to be were wildly wrong. I only decided to give it a chance because it was new, had Julia Roberts in it, and I was looking for something to watch.

I really had no idea that it was such the important must-see that it is, so hopefully I can save anyone else from missing this one. The first episode in I was only half paying attention and then, things just kept getting better, and more interesting, and there was a familiar style to it all. Then I realized by episode 2 “Oh! No wonder, this is Sam Esmail!” the master behind Mr. Robot. At that moment, everything made sense, and I knew that I had to give this my proper attention, and that I was in for something special.

Even at that point, I wasn’t prepared for the stylistic, Hitchcockian, film noir, almost sci-fi and horror mystery that was going to unfold. The entire story played out very much like a classic paranoid episode of The Twilight Zone. You’ll only find this show listed under drama and thriller, but it is a truly masterful and genre-less achievement of storytelling, enriched with the most ingenious soundtrack probably ever conceived, comprised heavily of scores taken directly from great horror films, including:

I mean, wow. That is really cool. Whenever a filmmaker does something so specific and intimate like this, where it feels like they personally consulted with you, taking music from your very own obscure collection, it’s a kind of conversation where after you get the “Fuck yeahs!” and high-fives out of the way, you say to each other, “I understand you.” When I heard music from Halloween III come on, my ears perked up in excitement. There’s so much music from John Carpenter in this, he should almost have a “Music By” credit.

While there are undoubtedly both sub-text and overt tones and aspects of the story that are indeed sci-fi, I definitely won’t make the stretch of claiming this is horror. While Homecoming is for sure not horror, it without question, is a fan of it, wears its clothes, sits in its chair, drinks its fancy drinks from a decanter, and smokes its cigars. And so, definitely worth an honorable mention in our Horror, But Not Horror segment.

I actually only have one problem with Homecoming, it’s been green-lit for a season 2?! Normally, that would be a good thing, but this story was told so well, and so completely, what’s there left to say? But, we’ll see. There have been countless times where I couldn’t see how they could pull off a season 2 and was proven wrong. I’ll tell you what though, it’ll only get stranger. Where they kept the “deleting people’s memories” sci-fi part of the story to a minimum this time around, they’ll have to dig into it more deeply next time.

Support Halloween Love

If an item was discussed in this article that you intend on buying or renting, you can help support Halloween Love and its writers by purchasing through our links: