Does the disk or packaging have the official “Compact Disk” logo on it anywhere? Theoretically, if it does, that shouldn’t happen. Of course, manufactures can lie and claim that the disk is in-spec when it really isn’t.

I’ve got one CD (“Roll the Bones” by Rush) that seems to have some sort of copy protection on it. I can rip every other Rush CD I own just fine, but that one is problematic.

You could try using a 3rd-party ripping app. Back when I still used Windows, that often worked for me.