I feel terrible for answering this. But the way I see it, if the innocent one died, that doesn't mean the ten others that should've died didn't. It was one or the other, so the ten would've gotten what they deserved.

We incarcerate thousands upon thousands of completely innocent people every year. Odds are at least 10 are sentenced to the death penalty for crimes they didn't actually commit. So an 11th wouldn't be such a big deal...

Hard to try and vote on this, Would I see the people that were let free, would I know there names where they went. Or poof vanished. Does the innocent person know he is taking the bullet for a better cause? This question has questions its self. -JWC

Considering my father is one of those listed in the latter option, naturally I'm biased and choose the left. But I don't think murderers and rapists shouldn't get off scot-free! Yes, I'm sure that one person had a life, but imagine the ten guilty people who could ruin more lives!

The innocent man would walk free. I'd ask all of you to ponder on being the innocent person in this situation being executed. If you aren't comfortable with having your life taken to keep ten offenders from walking free, I ask, what would give you the right to play God?

What kind of murderers? What kind of rapists? Child molesting as in touched child inappropriately on the playground by accident and the parents made a big fuzz about the totally unintentional slip of hand and in court there were 10 witnesses who didn't witness sh*t? or child molesting as in catholic priests?