Search watoday:

Search in:

Matt Todd misses out as All Blacks welcome back Carter

Marc Hinton

Back in black: Dan Carter has been named in a 31-man New Zealand squad for the Rugby Championship. Photo: Getty Images

Dan Carter is back, as is Charles Piutau, but it is the selection of Sam Cane ahead of unlucky Crusader Matt Todd that might be considered the chief talking point of Steven Hansen's Rugby Championship squad named on Monday.

Crusaders bench prop Joe Moody has also been called in to cover for the crocked Tony Woodcock (shoulder) who will miss the start of the competition, while an injured Victor Vito makes way for the return of rejuvenated Blues loose forward Steven Luatua.

In a largely predictable 31-strong squad that will look to extend the All Blacks' perfect record in the competition starting in Sydney on August 16, the newly-available Carter and Piutau return at the expense of Crusaders backs Colin Slade and Ryan Crotty.

Carter, the world record holder for Test points, was not available for the June series while he rounded out his six-month sabbatical, while Piutau - one of the finds of last season's historic perfect year - had been sidelined with a knee injury.

Advertisement

Carter has quickly found form playing at second five-eighth for the Crusaders in their charge to the Super Rugby final, while Piutau confirmed his readiness with a couple of sharp outings for the Blues at the end of their campaign.

The return of both Carter and Piutau would have been a no-brainer for coach Steve Hansen who understands how important those two men are in his ambitions over the next season or two. Carter, when fit, remains the All Blacks' premier playmaker and his recent reminder that he retains the ability to slot in at No 12 makes him an even more valuable figure.

Piutau also has significant utility value with an ability to cover fullback, wing and centre, and provides much-needed depth behind the likes of Ben Smith, Julian Savea and Israel Dagg in the back three.

Cane's selection, though, might raise an eyebrow or two after he missed the back half of the Chiefs' season with a knee injury. The 22-year-old replaces Todd as backup openside, and must be considered a little fortunate to do so.

Todd has been in excellent form for the Crusaders as they have reached their 11th Super Rugby final, keeping Richie McCaw at No. 6 for the knockout matches. It is a big call to replace him with someone who hasn't played since he went down with a knee injury on May 9.

Luatua's full return, with Vito not considered because of injury, comes on the back of a strong finish to his Super Rugby season.

The 23-year-old Aucklander was omitted from the original squad named for the June series against England, but gained a reprieve when he was brought in to cover for Kieran Read.

Vito had had a strong season for the Hurricanes, and was preferred ahead of the struggling Blues loose forward for the England series.

But Luatua's form over an impressive end to the Super Rugby season saw him answer the challenge of the All Blacks selectors, and his inclusion in this squad is reward for that.

Hansen said it had been a difficult task trimming the squad down to 31.

"In doing so, we had to leave out players who are performing at a very, very high level and they could consider themselves unlucky not to be selected," he said. "But while we feel for those guys, unfortunately, we have to make the hard decisions."

Back-to-back Bledisloes to open the competition would again prove a challenge for the All Blacks, Hansen added.

"It's going to be another intense competition. South Africa and Australia are ranked second and third in the world and both had successful June test series, while Argentina will again bring the physicality and passion which we know they are renowned for. They will also bring the knowledge and experience which comes from playing in the Rugby Championship and we are expecting them to improve further."

The squad includes three Highlanders players, eight Crusaders, seven Hurricanes, five Chiefs and eight Blues.

Chiefs and Bay of Plenty hooker Nathan Harris will assemble with the All Blacks for the domestic part of the season as part of his ongoing "apprenticeship".

Luke Romano was also not considered as he recovers from a broken bone in his leg.

The All Blacks squad will assemble on Wednesday for a two-day camp on Auckland's North Shore minus the eight players in the Crusaders, who will be preparing for this weekend's Super Rugby final.

In their absence, the following players will be brought into the camp: hookers Harris and the Hurricanes' Motu Matu'u; props Pauliasi Manu from the Chiefs and Highlander Kane Hames; Hurricanes lock Jeremy Thrush; loose forwards Liam Squire from the Chiefs and Shane Christie from the Highlanders.

7 comments so far

Cane did the job last year when McCaw was hurt. He knows the structures & I believe was in the leadership group last year as well. Pretty tough on Todd who continues to play good rugby but Hansen will generally go for the incumbent in a tight call. In reality though unless injury hits McCaw is going to play the majority of the games at 7.

Commenter

Shane D

Location

Perth

Date and time

July 28, 2014, 9:00AM

@ Shane D

Pretty much 'groundhog day' with this AB's selection.... especially with the usual suspects back from sabbaticals et al.Just wondering, with the upcoming Super 15 Final this w'end, why is DC playing at 12 for the 'Saders ? It's as if the 'Saders have got two flyhalfs playing at the same time, and the 'best in the world' one is playing out of position. I know the Tahs have a similar predictament but at least they play a true flyhalf in his rightful position with the other guy at 12.Seems a little strange to me.... mmmm ?

Commenter

Machooka

Location

inner west sydney

Date and time

July 28, 2014, 9:50AM

Machooka,

Slade is genuine 1-5/8 and Carter can defend a lot better than him. Carter is a great defender (for his size) and reads the game especially well and slides across to cramp up the flanks.

Commenter

Crusaders.Fan

Date and time

July 28, 2014, 10:29AM

Chook - I thought it strange when the 'Saders named Carter at 12 as well but watching them play he seems to be at flyhalf a heck of a lot in anycase. Slade has been playing a wider role in the backline in nearly all broken play situations. I think more than anything the Crusaders needed a 12 with some line breaking ability & defensive grunt of set play & Carter can play that role better that Slade or Taylor.

Commenter

Shane D

Location

Perth

Date and time

July 28, 2014, 10:35AM

@ Shane D & @ Chook..... Last weekend, the Crusaders against the Sharks, were doing exactly the same as what Beale & Foley, have been doing the last few games for the Tah's, like alternating their plays between first five, & second five, swapping around, as to say, for Crotty on the outside, to straighten the attack. It's going to be a great game, & hopefully I can get down to Sydney for it. It has been mentioned that Todd, is carrying an injury, and might not play this coming weekend, this I think was taken into consideration by Shag, in the selection of the All Black squad. Cheers

Commenter

Muzzo

Location

Orange

Date and time

July 28, 2014, 5:53PM

Doesn't really matter where they play they are ALL Blacks. The teamwork organisation whatever you want to call it will click into place and they will beat all comers. Any loss they have is merely an aberation. They will bounce back and when the next half a dozen.Similarly the Crusaders machine will prevail on Saturday against the Tahs. I would love for it not to be but the Crusaders have slowly built to this point and will peak right at the right time. The Tahs played their final on Saturday against the Brumbies and will struggle to lift to the level required against the Crusaders.

Commenter

Peter

Location

Newcastle

Date and time

July 28, 2014, 2:41PM

I gotta say, I'm a nervous ABs fan this year. Expecting some great games and not necessarily expecting the ABs to come out on top.