Is there a "1995 internet simulator?" I want to know what surfing the "information superhighway" was like in 1995.

Lol....In 1995 the information superhighway was more of an unpaved country road. usenet, the older message boards were still running, but were fading. The number of websites was much lower than today, and they were largely text. We surfed via dial up modems. And frankly, in those days, you had more content on aol than on the web.