The Hills Market Downtown

With only delivery available, Rogue Bakery can focus its energy on cookie baking instead of minding a store. The result is creative flavors like buttermilk ranch (yes, like the salad dressing), the WTF made with potato chips and pretzels, and even a chicken dinner box (don't knock it until you've tried it). There are traditional flavors, too, like chocolate chip and lemon, a few vegan and gluten-free options, and seasonal specialties galore (the ones for Thanksgiving are especially fun). Orders are delivered locally on Mondays, and most cookies can be shipped out of state. A few goodies like the brownie-in-a-cookie can only be found in Columbus, though. It's time to get outside your cookie comfort zone; you can order online or find them at the Hills Markets.