Senate Minority Leader Aquilino Q. Pimentel, Jr. (PDP-Laban)
today called for the dissolution of the Judicial, Executive and Legislative
Advisory and Consultative Council (JELAC) because it will undermine the independence
of the judiciary.

Senator Pimentel said there are disturbing signs that
certain unscrupulous power holders are out to manipulate this ad hoc body along
the partisan agenda of the majority.

He said the Senate leadership must withdraw its endorsement JELAC. “To avoid
embarrassment, the Senate leadership should scuttle JELAC. First, it undermines
judicial independence. And second, its real nature as an instrument of
majoritarian (sic) policy manipulation has emerged,” the minority leader said.

The opposition has no role to play in JELAC and even
if it did, the constitutional intent of ensuring the non-partisan nature of the
judicial system could eroded by the fraternization of the head of the Supreme
Court with the heads of the Executive and the Legislative houses.

The JELAC was created on May 13, 2008, “to serve as a forum and venue for
representatives of the three branches of government to undertake measures on
matters affecting the primacy of law, to identify the problems and issues, to
formulate solutions and to implement the same.”

The JELAC is composed of nine members, namely, the President
of the Republic as Chairperson with the Vice President, the president of the
Senate and speaker of the House of Representatives and the Chief Justice of the
Supreme Court as members of the Council. The other members are a Cabinet member
to be designated by the President, one senator and one congressman to be
designated by the respective leaders of the Senate and House, and an associate
justice of the Supreme Court to be designated by the Chief Justice.

Mr. Pimentel noted the explanation of the proponents of
JELAC that this body was created not by law but by a memorandum of agreement
among the heads of the judicial, executive and legislative branches so that at
any given time, any party to the agreement may send notice to the other parties
if it desires to withdraw its participation from the Council. # # #