Alchemy is dependant on herbalism
Leatherworking is dependant on skinning
Blacksmithing is dependant on mining/alchemy
Jewelcrafting is dependant on mining
Engineering is dependant on mining

Get over it and roll an alchemist, it really isnt that hard.

Wow, cant even have a typo in my post and you guys just flame me...

Of course I know Leatherworkers cant get skin of mobs without skinning. DUH.
It was just a typo.

The point is like you said

Leatherworking is dependant on skinning
Blacksmithing is dependant on mining/alchemy
Jewelcrafting is dependant on mining
Engineering is dependant on mining

Can you see it now?

You guys are mistaking gathering proffesions with crafting ones.

That's what i'm trying to say...

ALCHEMISTS need HERBALISM to be mostly self-sufficient at max skillLEATHERWORKERS need SKINNING to be self-sufficient at max skillENGINEERS need MINNING to be mostly self-sufficient at max skillJEWELCRAFTERS need MINNING to be mostly self-sufficient at max skillTAILORS need NOTHING(kill humanoids for cloth) to be self-sufficient at max skillBLACKSMITHERS need MINNING to level up to 600, but once there we need ALCHEMISTS or we cannot craft belt buckle / epic gear.

I think it's not that hard to get it...and see that there is a problem with BS.

The last bit, I don't know if you're new to the game but thats called skinning

It was a typo. I've played since Vanilla I'm not stupid...
Of course you need a Gathering proffession to support your Crafting proffession...that's logic.
The point is...Blacksmith needs one Gathering proffession, that's fine. But at 600 you need material from another Crafting proffession(alch) to be able to craft anything and epic gear. LW and Tailors don't have this problem...which is the same category: CRAFTERS.
See the point?

Originally Posted by HalseyUS

Leatherworkers DON'T get their own materials, Skinners get the mats needed for Leatherworkers, and honestly? Cloth is pretty common by everyone, Tailors just get a better drop rate for their cloth

Also Pro-Tip: Pick up mining

You obviously did not read anything I wrote.
I got minning DUH.Crafting+Gatherring proffession...

BLACKSMITHERS need MINNING to level up to 600, but once there we need ALCHEMISTS or we cannot craft belt buckle / epic gear.

In Cata, you needed Truegold to make all the first released crafted blacksmith epics AND the 346 weapons. In Mists, they shifted the required transmute mat from the crafted weapons to belt buckles. If you ask me, that is a great shift.

Originally Posted by ucplayer

Comments like "get a alt with alch" "buy off AH" are complete useless

Buying your mats off AH is useless? Do you really farm for all of your mats when you craft? What server are you on?

It was a typo. I've played since Vanilla I'm not stupid...
Of course you need a Gathering proffession to support your Crafting proffession...that's logic.
The point is...Blacksmith needs one Gathering proffession, that's fine. But at 600 you need material from another Crafting proffession(alch) to be able to craft anything and epic gear. LW and Tailors don't have this problem...which is the same category: CRAFTERS.
See the point?

You obviously did not read anything I wrote.
I got minning DUH.Crafting+Gatherring proffession...

Looks like you should have picked up alchemy instead and just bought the dirt cheap ghost iron from the AH.

"Im an alchemist, I can't make flasks or pots nor transmutes without a gathering profession ONLY OBTAINABLE BY AH-PURCHASES. Buhuu Alchemy sucks."

You must be stupid I think as he obiously stated that it was supposed to fit with mining, but since with mining you can only come to blue pvp crafted which is replaced by pvp vendors nowadays it's a huge flaw. please don't be so random.

How to fix - Give BS living steel on a shorter CD. I men living steel is like their bread and butter, they use it for crafting. Alchemy use it for what? Selling..

---------- Post added 2012-10-09 at 06:24 PM ----------

I am really upset now, it's almost like all of you don't care about it. It's like you say, okey, blacksmith is shit, who cares.

I wonder how I could use this in PVP, BM and Warrior is OP, who cares? roll a BM hunter or Warrior or stop whining? Exactly, that's your settings on the chat. Really silly and non constructive. I support OP with it, remove it for alchemy or give it to bs instead.

---------- Post added 2012-10-09 at 06:28 PM ----------

Originally Posted by JollyJoe

In Cata, you needed Truegold to make all the first released crafted blacksmith epics AND the 346 weapons. In Mists, they shifted the required transmute mat from the crafted weapons to belt buckles. If you ask me, that is a great shift.

Buying your mats off AH is useless? Do you really farm for all of your mats when you craft? What server are you on?

Some people don't buy their stuff of the AH. It's silly and should be changed, alchemists are ripping off people with that, 3-4k on my server at release, haha.

Looks like you should have picked up alchemy instead and just bought the dirt cheap ghost iron from the AH.

I guess the Alchemist should've choosen Mining instead of herbalism so he could buy his cheap ass flowers off the AH and farm his trillium bars. Right? It's not optional. Mining has been bound with BS. ALWAYS.

---------- Post added 2012-10-09 at 06:31 PM ----------

Originally Posted by JollyJoe

What server are you on?

Grim Batol. They're 800-1k atm. But if you read carefully and next time don't rush through stuff you migh've seen " AT RELEASE " (EU BTW)

I've posted this in another thread of the sorts, quoting a post like "alchemy is only there to limit other professions":

Originally Posted by Feio

We're speaking of transmute alchemists here, aren't we (everything else doesn't even gain a profit on Living Steel on most realms anymore, so I'm pretty sure most people are talking about transmute alchemy)? In that case, Alchemy with transmute mastery is there ONLY to feed other professions. What can a transmute alchemist produce? Gems: here to feed JCs. Bars: here to feed BSs.

Don't give me that bullcr*p of "but alchemists can create flasks and pots too". Yes, we can, but only at an extremely minor gain, or even at a loss if we haven't got the right mastery.

This is transmute alchemy's purpose. To support other professions/make mats for said professions. This is the sole purpose of it and if you don't have an alchemist and don't understand the concept of the profession don't bitch about it.

I'll give you that, I also find it rather stupid that the belt socket is made by living steel. But the fact remains that BS has been like this since WotLK (except for the belt sockets obviously).

How is being "dependent" of alchemy any different than being dependent of mining, skinning or herbalism?

It's not just being dependent upon alchemy. It's being dependent upon alchemy AND mining. The point he's making is that it's stupid that he has to rely on two professions when every other crafting profession relies on just one.

We saw a change happen with scribes today where you could trade inks that you couldn't before. It was an adjustment that blizz saw was needed. Maybe we just need to be patiend and we will see another adjustment soon.

It's not just being dependent upon alchemy. It's being dependent upon alchemy AND mining. The point he's making is that it's stupid that he has to rely on two professions when every other crafting profession relies on just one.

Actually Alchmemy needs herbing and mining. You can't make living steel without ore