With respect to everyone, the quote sent by Carlos does not state this 2nd photo is of Shuu Shiwa, but a teacher of Shuu Shiwa.

"Zheng Bu Su (also known as Zheng Xianji (郑仙纪, 1854-1929) was one of the most famous masters (5th Generation) who opened a school in Fuzhou and had taught many disciples ... [snip] ... In his later years, his most well known disciple was Zhou Zi He (周子和,) also known in Japanese as Shushiwa."

As I read it, there was no claim that this was another photo of Shuu.

For Fred, if we are talking about the same photo, the writing on the back of the photo (or drawing reproduction of a photo) of Shuu Shiwa says:

The Baike Wiki page and the Shushiwa Facebook page are much the same; the Facebook page is likely just a copy of the Wiki. There is a very brief history of Kanbun Sensei and UechiRyu, and the same interview with Mabuni and Kanbun Sensei. Nothing new or different from what has been known and posted for many years.

Sumako adds that the name "Joo Gee" (in the kanji I sent) is followed by "Matta-son". George Mattson.

"Zheng Bu Su (also known as Zheng Xianji (郑仙纪, 1854-1929) was one of the most famous masters (5th Generation) who opened a school in Fuzhou and had taught many disciples ... [snip] ... In his later years, his most well known disciple was Zhou Zi He (周子和,) also known in Japanese as Shushiwa."

Hi Carlos,

I don't think anyone can really know for sure based on the information and photo supplied.

Here's something very interesting sent to me by Steve Banchic of the Okinawan Karate Club in Stoughton Ma.

Quote:

Uechi Kanbun & das chinesische Boxen um 1900

Translated to English by one of our newest students at the OKC who happens to be from Germany working in the US as a nanny.

Translated:

Uechi Kanbun & Chinese Boxing around the year 1900

Published on Monday, September 15th, 2008

Unquestioned, Chinese Boxing (Ch’üan-Fa) had a great influence on the development of Karate. Uechi Kanbun (1877-1948), born in Okinawa, moved to China in 1897, where he got to know Chinese Boxing. A student named Mabuni interviewed Uechi and published the conversation 1934 in a version of the journal "Forschungen zur Leeren Hand". In this conversation, Uechi talks about his experiences with Chinese Boxing around 1900 as a witness.

This is my translation of the interview:

A conversation about Boxing

By Student Mabuni

One day I visited a certain student of the city Wakayama, Higashikashi-Cho.The first thing that caught my attention on this journey was the following sign:

Pangainun-RyuKarate-TeacherKyoshi Uechi Kanbun

That's right, Mr. Uechi moved to China when he was in his twenties! In this country he studied a pure Chinese type of Boxing [Ch’üan-Fa] for 13 years and he came back as a master in it. I admired the fact that even his sign had a chinese style.

That's why I delayed the duty I actually had come for. I thought I would love to hear something about my beloved Boxing. So I visited Mr. Uechi's dojo. Since he fortunately was home, our interview covered also the art of Chinese Boxing after some other topics . In the following I will recite the conversation.

"Master, does boxing in China still prosper?" "At the time I've been there, it was extraordinarily popular and therefore it will most certainly still be popular."

"Is a Chinese willing to teach you Boxing when you ask him to right away?""They do! But if there is no final vow from both of them after two or three days, they stop teaching.""How come?"

"People who want to train Boxing go to a house of a Boxing master and ask for training. If the master agrees, the people who are being trained will get together and open a dojo. From that moment on the master will guide them. Hosting a festival for gods in the dojo, they prepare several meals.

Afterwards they take final vows between master and students. At first the master trains the minds of their students, later he teaches them the Kata.

For that time, the students sign a contract with the master, for like one, two, three or five years, while they're training. If you have an outstanding master, you will train for 15 years, if you have a weaker master, you will train for one year or just 6 months!

"No doubt about that! On the other hand, it's a nice thing to practice and to go into business for yourself. Also on the street or in other public places, the boxers practice and let other people watch them doing their Kata. And if there's a master within the people walking by, it is said that he will correct the mistakes in your Kata."

"There is differences between the Japanese style of boxing and the Chinese style, isn't there?""Yes, there is."

"What's stronger in chinese style: The fist or the fingertips?""Japanese are strong with their fists, Chinese are strong with their fingertips."

"How to they strengthen their fingertips?"

"At the beginning you fill a box with sand. In this box you practice striking with your fingertips. If they've become stronger, you change to a box filled with big beans. If you're able to do that, your fingertips are considered strong. In china they call the fighting technique with fists Tai-Tsu and the technique with fingertips Lohan."

Who is online

Users browsing this forum: Majestic-12 [Bot] and 2 guests

You cannot post new topics in this forumYou cannot reply to topics in this forumYou cannot edit your posts in this forumYou cannot delete your posts in this forumYou cannot post attachments in this forum