"The New Tolkien Newsletter : A Review of the Works of J. R. R. Tolkein. " (sic)

Of course, one could just laugh at Giddings and Holland - when I joined the Tolkien Society, one of the first articles I read in Amon Hen was a review of 'The New Tolkien Newsletter' by Jessica Yates, called 'Who do they think they're Gidding?' (AH 50, IIRC).

So bad, it's funny.

Posted on: 2011/6/26 1:51

(edited)

Edited by garm on 2011/6/26 2:41:51Edited by garm on 2011/6/26 2:52:22