“I’m not affiliated with the Confederacy nor do I have any particular agenda other than to preserve a piece of established architecture,” Stage said. “I do have a connection to the memorial in that several generations of my family have served in the military, myself included.”

As a veteran, Stage said he primarily views the controversy in two ways.

The first, he said, is the aspect of “acknowledging and even respecting the general principle of the courage and beliefs of all men at arms.”

The second is “the cliché of erasing history and that it serves no one well,” he explained. “It’s all of our history and maybe it’s good that it’s there for both the people who are offended by it and the people who enjoy it because it gives us something to talk about. It could be a springboard for dialog.”

Sharon Tyus explains why the monument should be removed

It’s not just a race thing, Alderwoman Tyus said. “It’s a false narrative of what the Civil War was about. I’m objecting to it because, I looked around and started doing research … I don’t find statues of Benedict Arnold, Adolf Hitler,” Tyus said. “I don’t find statues of people who fought in the German wars but all of the sudden we’ve got these memorials and statues to the Civil War of the Confederacy.”

Tyus explained that she doesn’t think a Confederate monument should be displayed on public land.

“I don’t have a problem for people to have stuff on personal property or in a history museum that tells the full tale,” she said. “It’s not just a race thing but that you attempted to secede from the United States of America.”

Listen to the interview to hear more of the discussion.

Listen

Listening...

/

33:32

A pro and con discussion about whether the Confederate monument in Forest Park should stay or be removed.

What do you think should happen to the Confederate monument in Forest Park? Email your comments to talk@stlpublicradio.org?

St. Louis on the Air brings you the stories of St. Louis and the people who live, work and create in our region. St. Louis on the Air host Don Marsh and producers Mary Edwards, Alex Heuer and Kelly Moffitt give you the information you need to make informed decisions and stay in touch with our diverse and vibrant St. Louis region.

Related Content

On Christmas Eve last year, St. Louis Mayor Francis Slay used what is traditionally a quiet period for news to announce that he wanted a 102-year-old monument to Confederate war dead removed from Forest Park.

A year later, the statue remains in place. But city officials say they are committed to fulfilling the mayor's promise.

That was the intriguing — and very large — question that Steve Flick submitted to Curious Louis. “We just can't seem to be able to get beyond the Reconstruction Era in this state,” said Flick, a lifelong St. Louisan.

In the aftermath of the church shooting on June 17 that claimed the lives of nine black churchgoers in Charleston, much debate has been sparked around the country’s ties to the Confederacy. Since the attack, officials discovered that Dylan Storm Roof, the shooter in this case, had ties to white supremacist groups. The Confederate Flag, often noted as a representation of racism and segregation, serves as a symbol for many of those groups.