Elton John has a famous fan in Lady Gaga, but not everyone appreciates the awesome power of "Tiny Dancer." A Georgia man was arrested Wednesday for making terrorist threats against Sir Elton. Last month Neal Horsley, 65, posted a YouTube video of himself standing in front of the singer's Atlanta apartment complex holding a large red sign that said "Elton John Must Die." Horsley was upset about a Parade magazine interview in which John said he thought Jesus was a "compassionate, super-intelligent gay man who understood human problems."

"We're here today to remind Elton John that he has to die," Horsley says in the video. "What Elton John has done is desecrated the image of the Lord Jesus Christ, blasphemed the Lord Jesus Christ." He goes on to use homophobic slurs and quote scripture.

This isn't the first time Horsley — who has a surprisingly thorough Wikipedia page — has raised eyebrows. A militant anti-abortionist, he started a Website in the late 1990s that listed the names and addresses of doctors who performed abortions. Two years ago, Horsley founded the Creator's Rights Party in Georgia and claims to be a candidate for the 2010 governor's race. According to the AP, he kicked off his campaign wearing a placard showing a picture of an aborted fetus. The state ethics committee, meanwhile, has no record of his campaign.

Horsley's bail is set at $40,000. Elton John's publicist confirmed that the singer has an apartment in Atlanta, but wouldn't tell the AP anything more.