Verily, We did offer the trust [of reason and volition] to the
heavens, and the earth, and the mountains:87 but they
refused to bear it because they were afraid of it. Yet man took
it up88 - for, verily, he has always been prone to be
most wicked, most foolish.

The fact is that We offered the Trust ( "freedom of choice" and
to voluntarily use this option according to the will of Allah) to
the heavens, to the earth and to the mountains, but they refused
to undertake it and were afraid, but man undertook it. He was
indeed unjust and foolish.

We did indeed offer the Trust to the Heavens and the Earth and
the Mountains: but they refused to undertake it being afraid
thereof: but man undertook it he was indeed unjust and foolish
377737783779378037813782

Note - 87

The classical commentators give all kinds of laborious
explanations to the term amanah ("trust") occurring in
this parable, but the most convincing of them (mentioned
in {Lane I, 102}, with reference to the above verse) are
"reason", or "intellect", and "the faculty of volition" -
i.e., the ability to choose between two or more possible
courses of action or modes of behaviour. and thus between
good and evil.

Note - 88

Sc., "and then failed to measure up to the moral
responsihility arising from the reason and the
comparative free will with which he has been endowed"
(Zamakhshari). This obviously applies to the human race
as such, and not necessarily to all of its individuals.

Note - 3777

The Trust is something given to a person, over which he
has a power of disposition; he is expected to use it as
directed or expected, but he has the power to use it
otherwise. There is no trust if the trustee has no power,
and the trust implies that the giver of the trust
believes and expects that the trustee would use it
according to the wish of the creator of the trust, and
not otherwise.

Note - 3778

Cf. lix. 21, where the hypothetical sending down of the
Qur-an to the Mountains is mentioned, and it is mentioned
that such Parables are put forth in order to aid men to
reflection.

Note - 3779

The Heavens, the Earth, and the Mountains, ie., other
creatures of Allah, besides man, refused to undertake a
Trust or a responsibility, and may be imagined as happy
without a choice of good or evil being given through
their will. In saying that they refused, we imply a will,
but we limit it by the statement that they did not
undertake to be given a choice between good and evil.
They preferred to submit their will entirely to Allah's
Will, which is All-Wise and Perfect, and which would give
them far more happiness than a faculty of choice, with
their imperfect knowledge. Man was too audacious and
ignorant to realise this, and the result has been that
man as a race has been disrupted: the evil ones have
betrayed the Trust and brought Punishment on themselves,
though the good have been able to rise far above other
Creation, to be the muqarrabin, the nearest ones to
Allah: lvi. 11 and lvi. 88. What can be higher than this
for any creature? It follows incidentally from this that
the Heavens and the Earth were created before man was
created and this is in accordance with what we know of
the physical world in science: man came on the scene at a
comparatively late stage.

Note - 3780

Hamala: to undertake, bear, carry (the Trust or
responsibility), to be equal to it. This is the ordinary
meaning, and the majority of Commentators construe so.
But some understand it to mean "to carry away, run away
with, to embezzle (the thing entrusted); hence to be
false to the Trust, to betray the Trust." In that case
the sense of verses 72-73 would be: "Allah offered the
Trust to other creatures, but they refused, lest they
should betray it, being afraid from that point of view:
but man was less fair to himself: in his ignorance he
accepted and betrayed the Trust, with the result that
some of his race became Hypocrites and Unbelievers and
were punished, though others were faithful to the Trust
and received Allah's Mercy". The resulting conclusion is
the same under both interpretations.

Note - 3781

See ii. 30-34 and notes. Allah intended a very high
destiny for man, and placed him in his uncorrupted state
even above the angels, but in his corruption he made
himself even lower than the beasts. What was it that made
man so high and noble? The differentiating quality which
Allah gave man was that Allah breathed something of His
own spirit into man (xxxii. 9; xv. 29 and n. 1968; and
other passages). This meant that man was given a limited
choice of good and evil, and that he was made capable of
Forbearance, Love, and Mercy. And in himself man summed
up Allah's great world: man is in himself a microcosm.

Note - 3782

Zalum (translated "unjust") and Jahul (ignorant) are both
in the Arabic intensive form; as much as to say, 'man
signally failed to measure his own powers or his own
knowledge.' But Allah's Grace came to his assistance.
Where man did his best, he won through by Allah's Grace,
even though man's Best was but a poor Good. How did man
generically undertake this great Responsibility, which
made him Vicegerent on earth (ii. 30)? Here comes in the
doctrine of a Covenant, express or implied, between Allah
and Humanity. See vii. 172,73 and notes 1146-48 also v. 1
and n. 682. A Covenant (Mithaq) necessarily implies
Trust, and its breach necessarily implies Punishment.

Thanks for visiting Alim.org, The Alim Foundation's flagship site that provides the world's only social network built around Qur'an, Hadith, and other classical sources of Islamic knowledge.

We are a free service run by many volunteers and we need your help to stay that way. Please consider a small donation(tax-deductible in the USA) to help us improve Alim.org by adding more content and getting faster servers.

Don't remind me for 30 days

Tags

×
Any content page on the site can be “tagged” by clicking on the “Add Tag” button. A tag is any word or group of words which best describes the subject of the page it belongs to. So for example, let’s say you want to search for ayaat pertaining to the subject of tawhid (i.e. Islamic monotheism). Searching for the word tawhid itself won’t yield many results. What you really need is a way to find ayaat whose subject is tawhid but the word tawhid doesn’t necessarily appear in them. Tagging solves this problem. If you were to be reading, for example, Surah Ash-Shura ayah 11 it might come to your mind that the subject of the ayah includes the topic of tawhid. So you can now tag that page with the word “tawhid”. Thereafter, whenever someone searches for the word “tawhid”, Surah Ash-Shura ayah 11 would appear in the search results.

Asad 87The classical commentators give all kinds of laborious
explanations to the term amanah ("trust") occurring in
this parable, but the most convincing of them (mentioned
in {Lane I, 102}, with reference to the above verse) are
"reason", or "intellect", and "the faculty of volition" -
i.e., the ability to choose between two or more possible
courses of action or modes of behaviour. and thus between
good and evil.

Asad

0 votes 0 dislikes

Asad 88Sc., "and then failed to measure up to the moral
responsihility arising from the reason and the
comparative free will with which he has been endowed"
(Zamakhshari). This obviously applies to the human race
as such, and not necessarily to all of its individuals.

No Comments Found

No Comments Found

Yusuf Ali

0 votes 0 dislikes

Yusuf Ali 3777The Trust is something given to a person, over which he
has a power of disposition; he is expected to use it as
directed or expected, but he has the power to use it
otherwise. There is no trust if the trustee has no power,
and the trust implies that the giver of the trust
believes and expects that the trustee would use it
according to the wish of the creator of the trust, and
not otherwise.

Yusuf Ali

0 votes 0 dislikes

Yusuf Ali 3778Cf. lix. 21, where the hypothetical sending down of the
Qur-an to the Mountains is mentioned, and it is mentioned
that such Parables are put forth in order to aid men to
reflection.

Yusuf Ali

0 votes 0 dislikes

Yusuf Ali 3779The Heavens, the Earth, and the Mountains, ie., other
creatures of Allah, besides man, refused to undertake a
Trust or a responsibility, and may be imagined as happy
without a choice of good or evil being given through
their will. In saying that they refused, we imply a will,
but we limit it by the statement that they did not
undertake to be given a choice between good and evil.
They preferred to submit their will entirely to Allah's
Will, which is All-Wise and Perfect, and which would give
them far more happiness than a faculty of choice, with
their imperfect knowledge. Man was too audacious and
ignorant to realise this, and the result has been that
man as a race has been disrupted: the evil ones have
betrayed the Trust and brought Punishment on themselves,
though the good have been able to rise far above other
Creation, to be the muqarrabin, the nearest ones to
Allah: lvi. 11 and lvi. 88. What can be higher than this
for any creature? It follows incidentally from this that
the Heavens and the Earth were created before man was
created and this is in accordance with what we know of
the physical world in science: man came on the scene at a
comparatively late stage.

Yusuf Ali

0 votes 0 dislikes

Yusuf Ali 3780Hamala: to undertake, bear, carry (the Trust or
responsibility), to be equal to it. This is the ordinary
meaning, and the majority of Commentators construe so.
But some understand it to mean "to carry away, run away
with, to embezzle (the thing entrusted); hence to be
false to the Trust, to betray the Trust." In that case
the sense of verses 72-73 would be: "Allah offered the
Trust to other creatures, but they refused, lest they
should betray it, being afraid from that point of view:
but man was less fair to himself: in his ignorance he
accepted and betrayed the Trust, with the result that
some of his race became Hypocrites and Unbelievers and
were punished, though others were faithful to the Trust
and received Allah's Mercy". The resulting conclusion is
the same under both interpretations.

Yusuf Ali

0 votes 0 dislikes

Yusuf Ali 3781See ii. 30-34 and notes. Allah intended a very high
destiny for man, and placed him in his uncorrupted state
even above the angels, but in his corruption he made
himself even lower than the beasts. What was it that made
man so high and noble? The differentiating quality which
Allah gave man was that Allah breathed something of His
own spirit into man (xxxii. 9; xv. 29 and n. 1968; and
other passages). This meant that man was given a limited
choice of good and evil, and that he was made capable of
Forbearance, Love, and Mercy. And in himself man summed
up Allah's great world: man is in himself a microcosm.

Yusuf Ali

0 votes 0 dislikes

Yusuf Ali 3782Zalum (translated "unjust") and Jahul (ignorant) are both
in the Arabic intensive form; as much as to say, 'man
signally failed to measure his own powers or his own
knowledge.' But Allah's Grace came to his assistance.
Where man did his best, he won through by Allah's Grace,
even though man's Best was but a poor Good. How did man
generically undertake this great Responsibility, which
made him Vicegerent on earth (ii. 30)? Here comes in the
doctrine of a Covenant, express or implied, between Allah
and Humanity. See vii. 172,73 and notes 1146-48 also v. 1
and n. 682. A Covenant (Mithaq) necessarily implies
Trust, and its breach necessarily implies Punishment.