As if the Chicken of the Sea Affair wasn’t enough to convince Tony that cooking is not Jessica’s strong suit, the Dallas Cowboys QB became painfully aware that his girl is culinarily-challenged when he got a mouthful of plastic along with his burger.

Jessica was hoping to impress boyfriend Tony Romo with a juicy cheeseburger but left the wrapper on the cheese, Star Magazine writes.

“Jess blamed it on the manufacturer,” a chatty spy chuckles. “She said they should really warn people!”