6. Bret Favre. So close, but oh so far in his quest for Lombardi number 2.

7. Aaron Rogers. The NFC North figures to be a helluva race if Brett returns.

8. Matt Shaub. The Texans finally will make the playoffs!

9. Donavan McNabb. Maybe a change of scenery will help Donavan get over the top?

10. Tony Romo. One of these years?

11. Eli Manning. Mediocre numbers, but often gets results.

12. Matt Ryan. Needs to take that next step.

13. Joe Flacco. Is he the real deal or a pretender? We might find out this year?

14. Mark Sanchez. The playoffs sold me on this kid.

15. Carson Palmer. A good one, but he's not great.

I pretty much agree with your rankins, Zu, but I'd have to put Favre, Rogers and McNabb all above Boo Boo Rivers. I think they are all much more talented QB's overall than Crybaby Phil. I put Romo in the same boat as Rivers - highly overrated. If Joe Flacco had better targets, I think this guy would be simply amazing.

silver & black

02-18-2010, 03:55 PM

JaMarcus Russell

F-

HometownGal

02-18-2010, 04:04 PM

JaMarcus Russell

F-

Bwa ha ha ha! :rofl::rofl:

supa_fly_steeler

02-18-2010, 04:07 PM

JaMarcus Russell

F-

I would say G-

silver & black

02-18-2010, 04:10 PM

I would say G-

:thumbsup:

supa_fly_steeler

02-18-2010, 04:11 PM

:thumbsup:

How about ingradeabe so it's like left blank. :hatsoff:

Indo

02-18-2010, 04:18 PM

I think I would give Sanchez a B-
and, hate to admit it, but Flacco, too

and I agree with HTG about Rivers

Vincent

02-18-2010, 04:36 PM

JaMarcus Russell

F-

Wonder how many JaMarcus McFarlanes they sold. And they did 2 of them. What were they thinking?

steelreserve

02-18-2010, 04:52 PM

At the local Babies R Us, they actually sell JaMarcus Russell baby onesies and T-shirts. About halfway through the season, they were in the discount aisle. A couple weeks later, they were in the clearance 70% off rack. Most of them were still there last I went up there about a week ago.

Seriously, if my choices were starting Russell at QB or taking a meteor to the head, I'd choose the meteor.

silver & black

02-18-2010, 08:26 PM

How about ingradeabe so it's like left blank. :hatsoff:

You mean kind of like his mind? :noidea:

silver & black

02-18-2010, 08:29 PM

Wonder how many JaMarcus McFarlanes they sold. And they did 2 of them. What were they thinking?

The same thing Al Davis thinks; "JaMahcus is a great playah... get ovah it!" :banging:

he looks like he skived off english and snorted cocaine at the back of the school.

HometownGal

02-18-2010, 09:13 PM

Word of the day......irony.

http://www.timewarptoys.com/mortimer.jpg

lionslicer

02-18-2010, 09:49 PM

Can't rank Romo above eli, till he wins something.

He's pretty much talking about quarterback performances recently, Eli won the superbowl 2 years ago, and really hasn't had a great year since...

Galax Steeler

02-19-2010, 04:37 AM

Word of the day......irony.

http://www.timewarptoys.com/mortimer.jpg

That is funny:rofl:

CantStop85

02-19-2010, 09:00 AM

Word of the day......irony.

http://www.timewarptoys.com/mortimer.jpg

:chuckle:

XxKnightxX

02-19-2010, 09:31 AM

Yea Eli's a winner but he's quite strange. He has a better passer rating away from home
I couldn't agree more that Carson Palmer is the most overrated Quarterback in the league.

When u had weapons like Housh, Johnson and Henry and that criminal offensive line you should throw for alot of touchdowns.

Thats because of the "Swirling Winds" of the meadowlands, and he still hasnt adjusted to that. As odd as it sounds the winds play a huge factor inside that stadium.

I worked there doing secuirty and one night after a preseason game we decided to fool around and test the theory out. And sometimes the winds are so unpredictable, that wherever u see the winds blow, you basically have to kick or throw Opposite or away from the side where your intended to. Yeah odd but Jeff Feagles is one of the few thats mastered the winds down there.

zulater

02-19-2010, 07:14 PM

Thats because of the "Swirling Winds" of the meadowlands, and he still hasnt adjusted to that. As odd as it sounds the winds play a huge factor inside that stadium.

I worked there doing secuirty and one night after a preseason game we decided to fool around and test the theory out. And sometimes the winds are so unpredictable, that wherever u see the winds blow, you basically have to kick or throw Opposite or away from the side where your intended to. Yeah odd but Jeff Feagles is one of the few thats mastered the winds down there.

If he had Bruce Arians as his OC he wouldn't have that problem as BA would have him throwing so much more that he'd have those cross winds mastered by now.

:chuckle::wink02:

supa_fly_steeler

02-19-2010, 07:16 PM

If he had Bruce Arians as his OC he wouldn't have that problem as BA would have him throwing so much more that he'd have those cross winds mastered by now.

:chuckle::wink02:

:toofunny::toofunny::toofunny::toofunny::toofunny:

Wow never really knew about this swirling winds

Gnutella

02-20-2010, 03:31 AM

Top 12 NFL QBs

1. Drew Brees - His career in New Orleans reads like a sports fairy tale.

2. Tom Brady - He can stat-pile with the best, and he's a proven commodity in big games.

8. Donovan McNabb - He's been a very steady performer, but he's helpless when the Eagles don't have the lead.

9. Carson Palmer - He has tremendous physical skills, but I question whether or not he has "it."

10. Tony Romo - He has improved since becoming the starter in Dallas, but he still needs to prove himself in big games.

11. Eli Manning - The more I look at his body of work, the more convinced I am that his 2007 post-season performance was a fluke.

12. Matt Schaub - His numbers look pretty, but in spite of that, he hasn't been a very "memorable" QB.

X-Terminator

02-20-2010, 10:55 AM

Thats because of the "Swirling Winds" of the meadowlands, and he still hasnt adjusted to that. As odd as it sounds the winds play a huge factor inside that stadium.

I worked there doing secuirty and one night after a preseason game we decided to fool around and test the theory out. And sometimes the winds are so unpredictable, that wherever u see the winds blow, you basically have to kick or throw Opposite or away from the side where your intended to. Yeah odd but Jeff Feagles is one of the few thats mastered the winds down there.

Well they're moving into the new Giants Mega-Stadium next year that's right next door to ...wonder if it'll have the same effect? Personally, I think Eli just sucks and Plex made him look better than he really is.