[Late at night a young girl is seen leaving the Casey's Great Plains Diner carrying a to-go box. She locks the door behind her.

She walks around the corner and sets the to-go box next to a homeless man who is asleep leaning against the wall.]

GIRL Nighty night, Slim.

[She walks down the sidewalk and then pauses as she hears a low breathing behind her. She walks quicker and then looks behind her again.

She rushes to her car and in her nervousness drops her keys. She crawls under her car to reach them. As she does she hears footsteps and decides to crawl all the way under. She pulls out her taser and turns it on. The electric light illuminates her frightened face. Suddenly the car is lifted up above her and a shadow of a person lights up in a hot blue fire.]

[The unconscious girl is seen being dragged across a dirty floor. A trap door is open and she is dropped in as the hatch is slammed behind her.]

ACT ONE

MEN OF LETTERS BUNKER -- KITCHEN

[SAM is fast asleep lying over the table. He is snoring. DEAN enters and pours himself coffee. He grabs a bowl and slams it on the table, waking SAM up.]

[SAM, DEAN are sitting at a restaurant booth and JODY and the homeless man SLIM join them.]

JODY Okay, Slim. My friends here want to talk to you about the missing girl.

SLIM Honor. Her name was Honor. Nice girl. Always left me meatloafs.

DEAN Mm.

SAM Slim, why don't you tell us what you saw that night?

SLIM I heard a big noise, got woke, and there's somebody over there lifting a car up -- like this.

[SLIM lifts his hands above his head]

DEAN And did you happen to see who it was?

SLIM I was too far. But I saw a light go off.

SAM A white light?

SLIM Blue. Blue like fire. But not. Then she was -- she wasn't there.

DEAN Could you think of anything else?

SLIM No.

DEAN Okay. Well...Slim, thank you for your time.

[DEAN takes out his wallet and hands SLIM a $20 bill. SLIM takes the money and leaves.]

SAM Okay. So, no white light.

DEAN No angel. Has anybody talked to the victims' families?

JODY It's next on my list.

DEAN Okay, and you said that they were all part of the same church?

JODY Mm-hmm.

DEAN [to SAM] Ready to get your worship on?

[Scene switches to a wide shot of a very tall and imposing white church with GOOD FAITH CHURCH in large letters on the front.]

[Camera switches to a lady, BONNIE FUTCHKO, sitting down at a large desk with DEAN and SAM on the other side.

BONNIE We hope you enjoyed the tour. Any questions before we get you boys registered?

SAM Uh, yeah, uh, look, um, Ms. Futchko --

BONNIE oh, please... Bonnie will do just fine.

SAM Bonnie. Okay, um, we...love the church. We do. But...Well, we've heard that a few members have gone missing, and, to be honest...that kind of scares us.

BONNIE Let me assure you, with our increased security, Good Faith has never been safer. And those people who have gone missing, well, they are front and center in our prayers.

DEAN What a relief. Now, you must have been, uh, close to them.

BONNIE Well, we do share the A.P.U. bond.

DEAN "The A.P.U."?

BONNIE Our chastity group... "Abstinence Purifies Us."

SAM Oh. W-wow. You mind if we sit in on that, maybe see if it's for us?

BONNIE I'm afraid it's members only. I'm sorry, but it can get pretty personal.

SAM Then count us in.

BONNIE Well. I'll be a squirrel in a skirt. I'll be back in a jiff with the papers.

[BONNIE leaves and we see her outside the office pulling papers from a large filing cabinet. Camera pulls back to DEAN as he leans over to SAM.]

DEAN A chastity group?

SAM Dean, listen, if all the members were in A.P.U., then maybe whatever took them is stalking virgins.

DEAN And that Slim guy said he thought he saw fire. So, what are you thinking, dragons?

SAM Mm. [SAM looks up to see BONNIE returning.] Shh.

BONNIE All righty. [She hands both of the boys clipboards.] You can just sign there, and your purification can begin.

SAM [reading] "Purity pledge"?

BONNIE It's a commitment to your virginity.

DEAN I don't think we can really un-ring that bell. You know what I mean?

BONNIE [A little taken aback] Oh. I see. Well... If you just ask for God's forgiveness for your sins and make a new vow of chastity, well, then, you'll be born again as a virgin in his eyes.

DEAN So, you just hit the "virginity do-over" button, and all is good with the man upstairs?

BONNIE [Looking shocked] It's not a button. And...this isn't just a piece of paper. I mean, this is your clean slate, your chance to be a virgin until marriage.

DEAN Well, you had me at "clean slate"" Let's do this.

[DEAN and then SAM both sign their real names to the bottom of their purity pledges. They then hand them back to BONNIE.]

BONNIE Congratulations, Sam and Dean Winchester. You are both virgins.

SAM and DEAN Ah.

[DEAN smiles sheepishly at SAM]

[Scene switches to a dark underground room with a few tiny candles burning high on ledges in the wall. Sounds of a girl crying. We hear the sound of a taser and HONOR's face lights up with the blue electric light.]

[HONOR walks around, limping, exploring her prison with the light of the taser. She sees a ledge with some Talcom Power and soap. She is then startled by movement behind her. She gasps in fright.]

HONOR Please. Stay away from me!

ACT TWO

GOOD FAITH CHURCH -- SUNDAY SCHOOL ROOM

[The A.P.U. group sitting in a room. It is a circle of six women and DEAN and SAM. The group leader, SUZY, welcomes everyone.]

Uh...But, uh... Sometimes, it just makes you feel bad, you know? You're drunk. You shack up.

[DEAN smiles]

Then, it's the whole morning thing. You know, "Hey, that was fun." And then, "adios," you know? Always the "adios."

[DEAN looks wistful.]

But, you know, when you get down to it, what's the big deal, right? I mean, sure, there's the touching and the feeling all of each other, my hands everywhere, tracing every inch of her body, the two of us moving together, pressing and pulling... Grinding.

[All the women start shift uncomfortably.]

Then you hit that sweet spot, and everything just builds and builds and builds until it all just...

[DEAN makes a exploding noise. TAMMY crushes her paper with the written verse in her lap.]

SUZY Well, I provide individual counseling. If you ever need to talk --

DEAN So, everybody in the group, they dish to you?

SUZY They confide. Abstinence is -- it's really rough without support and education. Hey, you know what? I have some great books on the vow that really helped me. I-I live close. I'll just go grab them.

DEAN Whoa, whoa, whoa, whoa. With a, uh, with a kidnapper on the loose?

SUZY No, I'll be fine.

DEAN Tell you what -- why don't I walk with you just to be safe, okay? Just give me one second.

[Camera switches back to SAM listening in exasperated silence to TAMMY rambling about HONOR...]

[Scene switches back to DEAN and SUZY. SUZY is bending down to grab books off a shelf. Her shirt rids up baring her lower back. DEAN rolls his eyes and tries to look away. SUZY stands up and hands eight books to DEAN.]

SUZY Okay. So, why don't you breeze through these, and I'm gonna head to the little girls' room.

DEAN Mm, yeah.

[SUZY leaves and DEAN walks over to the entertainment center and sets the books down as his cell phone rings. He hits the answer button but before he can lift the phone to his ear he notices a cracked drawer with some DVDs in it. He opens the drawer wider and in shock pulls out two CASA EROTICA DVDs. He stares at them as Sam tries to get his attention from the phone.]

SAM Hey. Dean? Hey, Dean. Are you there?

[DEAN makes the connection that the naked girl on the front of the DVDs is SUZY.]

Hello? Dean? Dean?

[DEAN finally snaps out of his shock and raises his phone to his ear.]

DEAN Sammy! Hey.

SAM What's going on?

DEAN I found something big.

SAM Yeah. So did we. So, get this -- it's not a dragon.

DEAN [still reading the CASA EROTICA DVDs] Uh-huh. Uh-- ooh.

SAM Dean?

DEAN Copy that.

[DEAN quickly hangs up as he hears SUZY coming back. He tries to hide the DVDs behind his back as he swings around to face her.]

DEAN Hey. Or should I say... "Hola"?

SUZY [looking confused] Uh, why?

DEAN No reason. No reason.

SUZY A-are you okay?

DEAN Me? Ah -- I'm great. Why?

SUZY Uh, you seem... I-I don't know, nervous.

DEAN [Laughing nervously] Nervous? No. I'm not nervous... Carmelita.

SUZY [face falls in resignation] So, you've seen my...work. Listen, I don't blame you if you want to be assigned a new counselor. I-I get it.

DEAN No. No, no. Are you -- are you kidding me? I mean, you're -- you're a freaking legend.

SUZY [in a panic] No! I-I am -- I'm not that girl anymore. I moved here. I changed my name. That girl was -- was horrible. DEAN [interrupting her] Listen, uh, Suzy, I've seen a lot of awful things, stuff of nightmares, okay? But you -- you're the good dreams.

[SUZY smiles slightly]

DEAN And nobody in Hartford knows?

SUZY Yeah, what am I supposed to say? "Oh, yeah, hey, I used to be a porn star. Let's pray"?

DEAN Well... They do not appreciate you. I mean... the things you can do -- the scene with the tacos.

SUZY [smile getting wider] Yeah.

DEAN Made me want to join a mariachi band just to be near you.

SUZY [looking at DEAN enticingly] Well, you are now.

DEAN [suddenly comprehending what she is saying] I am, aren't I?

[SUZY moves in on DEAN]

SUZY You're not like... the other guys in town, are you? You're kind of a... a bad boy.

DEAN I don't know. Why don't you ask me that in Spanish?

SUZY ¿Eres un Chico malo?

DEAN Sí

[SUZY quickly closes the gap between them and kisses DEAN passionately. He pulls her head in and hungrily kisses her back. He lift her up on to his hips while they are still kissing and together they slowly fall out of the camera view.]

[Scene switches to HONOR in the dark underground room. HONOR hears strange noises and is petrified. She finds a cupboard with matches and a lamp. She lights the lamp.]

HONOR Aah! Oh. [HONOR sees a body on the floor. She bends over it.]

HONOR Pastor Fred.

[Pastor Fred's eyes fly open and it scares HONOR who jumps away right into the faces of two other people.]

HONOR Aah! Neil? Barb? What happened to him?

NEIL What do you think? He's starving to death. Just like we will if we don't get out of here.

HONOR Why didn't you tell me who you were? I was so scared.

BARB We were scared!

[A loud creaking sound is heard above them. NEIL, BARB and HONOR hide as there is a bright flash of blue fire. When it ends, they crawl out to see that PASTER FRED is nowhere to be seen.]

HONOR [in a panic] Where'd he go?

[Off in the distance above their heads they hear PASTOR FRED's bloodcurdling scream.]

[Scene switches to JODY typing on her laptop and she looks up to see SAM putting on his jacket.]

JODY What's up?

SAM This thing is taking people that break their vows, right?

JODY Yeah.

SAM Dean and Suzy -- been over an hour.

JODY [leaping up for her jacket] Right.

[Camera switches to SUZY and DEAN walking to her door putting their clothes back on.]

SUZY I got to say... I really missed that.

DEAN I miss it already.

[DEAN gently pulls her head toward him and kisses her again. SUZY wraps both arms around DEAN's neck and kisses him back. They pull away.]

DEAN Okaaaay.

[DEAN turns to open the door and when he does both him and SUZY are thrown back in the apartment in a blinding flash of blue light. The camera fades to black from a shot of their unconscious bodies.]

ACT THREE

DARK UNDERGROUND ROOM

[BARB is dragging her broken and bleeding fingernails down the stone walls.]

HONOR What are you doing?

BARB [crying] I'm so thirsty. So thirsty! There has to be a way out!

[NEIL turns away and HONOR watches as BARB puts her bleeding fingers in her mouth to drink her own blood. They suddenly all hear the trap door being opened above them. They go to investigate. They see SUZY regaining consciousness next to a still unconscious DEAN.]

SUZY Hey. Dean. [she shakes him] Dean. Hey, come on. Dean. Dean.

[DEAN jerks awake.] DEAN Where are we?

NEIL Hell.

[Scene switches SAM in SUSY's apartment. He has found the CASA EROTICA DVD's and is starting to put things together. JODY walks into the apartment.]

SAM Hey.

JODY Hey.

SAM Neighbors see anything?

JODY Flash of blue.

SAM Huh.

JODY You sure Dean was here?

[SAM holds up the DVD's]

SAM Oh, yeah. And I think he crossed someone off his bucket list.

[Back in the dark underground room. DEAN is on the ladder trying to push open the tightly shut trap door.]

NEIL We tried. There's no escape.

SUZY Are we gonna run out of air?

NEIL I don't think so. Somebody wants us to die nice and slow.

HONOR And then it's gonna take us, just like it took Pastor Fred.

DEAN What took him?

HONOR We couldn't see, exactly. It -- it was so bright. I-it was like it was on fire.

[SAM and JODY back in the hotel room. JODY is back searching on the laptop.]

JODY Hey. Virgins, fire -- sound familiar?

SAM [reading over her shoulder] "Vesta, Roman Goddess of the Hearth"

JODY in ancient Rome, six virgins were dedicated to this chick every year. Their main duty was to tend Vesta's hearth.

SAM Wait, so, fire is connected to virginity?

JODY Yeah, the girls had to be pure because fire is the symbol of purity.

SAM Huh. Okay, as long as Vesta's fire was kept lit, Rome received a good harvest.

JODY The virgins had to stay celibate for 30 years. If they broke their vows, they were buried alive.

[Back in the dark underground room. DEAN tries once more to heave the trap door open but to no avail.]

DEAN Son of a bitch.

[DEAN climbs down the ladder.]

SUZY Dean. Maybe God wants us down here -- because of what we did.

DEAN Trust me -- this is not God's work.

DEAN Son of a --

[DEAN is franticly checking his pockets.]

SUZY What's wrong?

DEAN They took my phone. Luckily...

[DEAN pulls out a second phone.]

I keep a spare.

[DEAN holds the phone over his head.]

Come on, bars.

[HONOR watches DEAN attempt to use his phone and then catches NEIL staring at her suspiciously.]

[Camera switches to JODY and SAM in the hotel room.]

JODY [still reading from the laptop] Vesta was often enveloped in a blue halo of light, which she could control at will to disorient, to maim -- ohh -- or to kill.

SAM Okay, what about some way to kill her? A-a weapon or -- or something.

[JODY goes back to typing but is interrupted as SAM's phone rings loudly. SAM answers.]

SAM Dean?

DEAN Sam! Sammy!

SAM Dean. Hey.

DEAN [his voice full of static] Hey, listen to me. I'm --

SAM Dean, wh--

DEAN underground.

SAM Say it again. I can't hear you.

DEAN We're -- Some kind of --

SAM Dean! I lost him.

JODY What?

SAM Listen, is there some kind of train station around here or something? I-I could have sworn I heard a whistle.

[Back in the dark underground room. BARB and NEIL are whispering in the corner.]

BARB Don't, Neil. Please, don't.

NEIL Shh. Shh.

DEAN [overhearing them] Don't what, Neil?

NEIL Just mind your beeswax, pal.

DEAN [marching over to NEIL] Hey. Hey! Listen, we're all stuck down here together. So, you got something to say, you say it.

NEIL Okay, look, whatever that fireball thing was, it's taking the weakest, and I am not gonna be next. So, the way I see it, her leg's busted anyway. [NEIL motions to HONOR.] We serve her up. It could buy us some time.

VESTA Actually, I figured if you can't beat them, join them. That's right. [VESTA throws a tarp off a slaughter table covered in blood.] I adapted! Now I chew on the cud of prayer. Heck... I even got a sweater set.

[Underground. DEAN is running his fingers over the trap door. He finds a rusty screw.]

DEAN Screwdriver, anybody?

HONOR [finds scissors in the first-aid kit] Hey. From the first-aid kit.

VESTA They used to beg to stay pure for me. And now I have to drag them kicking and screaming. And they're not even real virgins. They're born-again. You want to talk about pathetic?

JODY Yeah. You're a real charity case.

VESTA Oh, no, sweetheart. This isn't charity. I take what I deserve.

[DEAN works on screwing out the rusty screws in the trapdoor.]

When those trollops are about to die soaked in their juicy fear, I...eat...their...livers! Because that's the only part of them still working to purify the body that they've trashed. Now, normally, I like them weaker, but let's just call this a hunter's exception, shall we?

JODY Sure.

[JODY pulls out the oak stake dipped in virgin's blood. She tries to stab VESTA but VESTA pulls in out of her hands and holds it over JODY.

VESTA This is how a goddess acts!

[SAM attacks VESTA from behind and VESTA falls forward stabbing JODY in the chest. VESTA flings SAM back into the stall.]