I have a feeling they might feel he's the guy.
And I don't necessarily not like him, I just worry about his arm strength in Buffalo's weather. It just seems like this would not be the ideal place for him, and I just feel it wouldn't work out.

I'd be upset. We are talking about another Southern California pretty boy. He threw over 50% of his passes within 3 yards of the line of scrimmage. You want the next Trent Edwards/Mark Sanchez? I doubt he will be a top 3 QB taken like everyone thinks.

I'm sitting here thinking about it. I think there is ZERO chance coach Marrone takes this guy. Coach Marrone has that tough guy attitude. I don't think he'd take him in the 4th round._________________

I want Corderelle Patterson but if they really feel they need a QB I would take Barkley over Geno Smith. His arm while not the strongest is strong enough to Play in Buffalo's weather. His pro day could really be the clincher that gets him drafted in top 10_________________

Nah, I think Barkley is the second to go, although I still wouldn't feel he's worth our pick at #8. Now Nassib at 8 would make me furious. After some of his coaching selections, I'm already nervous that Marrone cares more about helping out his buddies than getting the best possible talent, so Nassib is a possibility.

But I consider him the 6th best QB in the draft, and a third-fourth round talent. If we took him at #8 I'd be livid. Not only because it's a wasted pick, but because it means Marrone is probably too loyal to his own QB, and might not even seize the chance to get Teddy Bridgewater next year if Nassib plays us into contention for him, preferring to give Nassib more time to develop.

Nah, I think Barkley is the second to go, although I still wouldn't feel he's worth our pick at #8. Now Nassib at 8 would make me furious. After some of his coaching selections, I'm already nervous that Marrone cares more about helping out his buddies than getting the best possible talent, so Nassib is a possibility.

But I consider him the 6th best QB in the draft, and a third-fourth round talent. If we took him at #8 I'd be livid. Not only because it's a wasted pick, but because it means Marrone is probably too loyal to his own QB, and might not even seize the chance to get Teddy Bridgewater next year if Nassib plays us into contention for him, preferring to give Nassib more time to develop.

Same here after Geno I think Barkley goes. I wouldn't be too upset, I mean, it is not like when we took Whitner at #8. I mean it is, but it is a QB as opposed to safety reach.

Interesting note, I think the notable QB reach will be QB Zac Dysert. Bottom of the 1st or top of the 2nd. EJ Manuel I don't think being picked int he first will be a reach, seeing how Mayock has had him as his #2 QB since after the combine._________________

Nah, I think Barkley is the second to go, although I still wouldn't feel he's worth our pick at #8. Now Nassib at 8 would make me furious. After some of his coaching selections, I'm already nervous that Marrone cares more about helping out his buddies than getting the best possible talent, so Nassib is a possibility.

But I consider him the 6th best QB in the draft, and a third-fourth round talent. If we took him at #8 I'd be livid. Not only because it's a wasted pick, but because it means Marrone is probably too loyal to his own QB, and might not even seize the chance to get Teddy Bridgewater next year if Nassib plays us into contention for him, preferring to give Nassib more time to develop.

Same here after Geno I think Barkley goes. I wouldn't be too upset, I mean, it is not like when we took Whitner at #8. I mean it is, but it is a QB as opposed to safety reach.

Interesting note, I think the notable QB reach will be QB Zac Dysert. Bottom of the 1st or top of the 2nd. EJ Manuel I don't think being picked int he first will be a reach, seeing how Mayock has had him as his #2 QB since after the combine.

pretty much the way i feel. I don't mind Barkley and at least we would be trying to upgrade the QB position._________________
thanks for the sig NS922!

Listen! I am standing at the door, knocking;
if you hear my voice and open the door,
I will come in to you and eat with you,
and you with me.
Revelation 3:20

I'd be disappointed because I wouldn't draft Barkley at #8 myself, but I can understand how a GM struggling to keep his job after failing to acquire or develop a legit franchise QB for a few years would pull the trigger on that selection._________________

Nah, I think Barkley is the second to go, although I still wouldn't feel he's worth our pick at #8. Now Nassib at 8 would make me furious. After some of his coaching selections, I'm already nervous that Marrone cares more about helping out his buddies than getting the best possible talent, so Nassib is a possibility.

But I consider him the 6th best QB in the draft, and a third-fourth round talent. If we took him at #8 I'd be livid. Not only because it's a wasted pick, but because it means Marrone is probably too loyal to his own QB, and might not even seize the chance to get Teddy Bridgewater next year if Nassib plays us into contention for him, preferring to give Nassib more time to develop.

Same here after Geno I think Barkley goes. I wouldn't be too upset, I mean, it is not like when we took Whitner at #8. I mean it is, but it is a QB as opposed to safety reach.

Interesting note, I think the notable QB reach will be QB Zac Dysert. Bottom of the 1st or top of the 2nd. EJ Manuel I don't think being picked int he first will be a reach, seeing how Mayock has had him as his #2 QB since after the combine.

pretty much the way i feel. I don't mind Barkley and at least we would be trying to upgrade the QB position.

Same here. If Geno is gone I'd be fine with Barkley. I have Barkley as the clear #2 QB, so I wouldn't hate the pick.

As far as Nassib goes, I heard that our scouts didn't like him at all, and compared him to Fitzpatrick. Hopefully Marrone listens to them enough to stay away from him until at least the 3rd._________________
#BMI

However, I think the dislike for Barkley is unwarranted.. The fact that he is from USC makes him a bad QB?

While they had busts with Leinart and Sanchez, they also had Carson Palmer who was hugely successful before a major career injury, and now back with the Raiders was among the most underrated QBs in the NFL..

The fact is, the guy can throw, and is a confident leader on the offense..

I would be happy with him (just not at #

Barkley, Glennon, Bray.. All are better options in the 2nd (or 3rd) than Geno is in the 1st..

I see no reason to believe Geno is the better QB, and it will come at a much lesser price.._________________

However, I think the dislike for Barkley is unwarranted.. The fact that he is from USC makes him a bad QB?

While they had busts with Leinart and Sanchez, they also had Carson Palmer who was hugely successful before a major career injury, and now back with the Raiders was among the most underrated QBs in the NFL..

The fact is, the guy can throw, and is a confident leader on the offense..

I would be happy with him (just not at #

Barkley, Glennon, Bray.. All are better options in the 2nd (or 3rd) than Geno is in the 1st..

I see no reason to believe Geno is the better QB, and it will come at a much lesser price..

I agree 100% with the bolded. The same thing was said about Cal QB's, that they were a product of Tedford's system, and not NFL caliber. Then this guy named Rodgers came along...

Not comparing Barkley to Rodgers AT ALL, just saying that where a guy plays college ball means nothing when it comes to talent._________________
#BMI