I don't think this is a kayfabe list so Storm should get votes, his match with Roode was MOTYC.
Overall, Austin Aries and Bobby Roode are up there. Bully deserves respect too.

The reason why we don't get fresh ideas and promotions rising in American Pro Wrestling is because the majority of the community is happy with the same old shit and will reject any chance of change. There is a risk in doing new things, 9 times out of 10, it leads to 50+ pages of bitching and moaning. While business gets turned into a dictatorship and more and more out of touch. Support the indies, support New Pro Wrestling.

Amazing how the support for Storm has fallen off since right before Lockdown.

I would have to give it to Aries. Bully & Roode was great character wise, matches were fine not great while Hardy really didn't do much until winning the title while Aries was pretty much great on everything just about all of the year.