Tuesday, 18 December 2012

One of our new Commissioners, Fred, shares some of his thoughts about Christmas...

"Here we are again, Christmas round the corner, kids holidays
looming, demanding more by each advert that they see. So where does this leave many
families. Some are organised and all set for the big day, however these days there are
sadly more who are not.

The working family face the same challenges faced by the
unemployed and low income alike.

These problems escalate in number of different ways,
struggling to perhaps pay the mortgage/rent, we choose to perhaps delay December's payment, gives
us the money to buy the kids there toys.

How much is required, how long is a piece of string.

If we look at this in deeper scenarios it can paint a
darktime ahead. The parents argue over
money, leading to anything from the kids being upset to see this and feeling guilty
and stressed, to violence or even broken relationship. If these kids are of
teenage years, they may choose to spend time outside with similar kids in same
position, this can lead to these same kids being involved in anything to “get
away from it all”Alcohol? Drugs?

The low income families suffer severely at these times,
faced with a lot if difficult choices, just to pay for one day of celebration.
Why? Christmas is so now commercialised it's not Christmas, it's a time of
struggle which can lead into the preceding months of January through to March
or beyond just to find a balance again in the home.

Perhaps we really should be teaching our children the true
meaning of Christmas, a poor family arrive at a stable, Jesus was born, three
wise men give one gift each, and it is this event that we should be
celebrating, then our children won't be faced with the same financial problem
caused by us and the commercialisedChristmas.."

Tuesday, 4 December 2012

Recently Martin Johnstone, the secretary of the Poverty Truth Commission, was invited to visit Leeds to discuss the possibility of Leeds doing something similar to the Commission in that city. Andrew
Grinnell
from Leeds shares his thoughts about how the process could be used there:

"I
first heard about the Poverty Truth Commission in a meeting for a charity I
used to be a trustee for. Just as we were about to start the meeting a fellow
trustee thrust a copy of the commission’s findings into my hand and one quick
glance through got me asking 'what if we were to do this in my city of Leeds?'
There was something about the approach that caught my imagination. By valuing
the opinions of those who were directly facing poverty it enabled them to
articulate the issues as they saw them and built dignity as they testified as
to how this had impacted their lives. Whilst at the same time it allowed
decision makers the opportunity to look at the issues from a different angle,
to build relationship with people who were affected by their decisions and to
collaborate with them on effective responses to poverty.

From
my experiences of Leeds it seemed like an appropriate way of discovering a
meaningful response to the wide levels of inequality within the city. I’ve
listened to people in my neighbourhood who have many opinions about how things
need to change but struggle to know how to make them heard. I’ve listened to
council workers and officials who desperately want to increase the positive
impacts they are having upon the city but don’t quite know how best to work
with local people. I’ve seen how businesses within the city want to bring
positive and lasting change not only for the good of their business but also
for the cities residents. Our hope in Leeds that as we move from asking ‘what
if we did a poverty truth commission’ to ‘what are we discovering about poverty
through this challenge’ is that as people from all sectors encounter one
another, deep and lasting responses to the poverty we face may be found."

The Poverty Truth Commission will continue to support those in Leeds to take up this piece of work.

About Us

The Poverty Truth Commission brings together some of Scotland's key decision makers with those living at the sharp end of poverty. We work together towards overcoming poverty in Scotland; ensuring that those affected by decisions are central to decision-making. The Commission believes poverty will only truly be addressed when those who experience it first-hand are at the heart of the process.