Talking about Mike J- so, Ask That Guy run away screaming in pain when he saw the 2 Girl 1 Cup video, while the British person just stared, smiling creepily. Let's say this again: That Guy = screaming in pain , Mike J = smiling creepily. Why do I find that so cute? And God, isn't that just the most adorable smile EVER?

Well, now that we're on the subject, Epic Fail episode 20. Mike J, with a laptop on his lap. With porno music blasting from the speakers. Staring with the creepiest smile EVER on his face at the camera. I had to stop the video.

In his review of the Ghoulies 4, MikeJ quotes the infamous "I hope it's not Chris's blood". With a lovely deep voice that made this troper rewatch the scene again and again...

This troper totally loves his accent, and that suit. And being British myself, I have no idea where he's supposed to be from (sounds like he's just being stereotypically posh to troll Americans) but it's an awesome accent.

He's so big and tall, I can't help but fantasize about being at his mercy. Sexually.

In MasakoX's video about soda he mentions that he used to be quite overweight, until he discovered that his weight would mean having to pay for the next step up from economy class on a plane trip in order to be comfortable, and that spurred him to exercise and cut soda out of his diet entirely, resulting in the skinny guy we see today. While the weight thing probably hits somebody's kink button, it's the commitment and willpower that got to this troper. Self control: it's sexy!

Seriously. I wouldn't say I'm attracted to him in general (although he is amazing) but his eyes are incredibly nice.

This troper finds his calm, deadpan, slightly smug delivery in his Fanfic Theatre videos kind of attractive. There's just something about the detached-intellectual act that works.

Bennett wearing a black tank top and singing in the Nostalgia Chick's Grease video just pole-vaulted him up my list of bunkable contributors.

I think Bennett is in fact Kavorka Man. Which of course makes him even more sexy.

Never mind that he scares me like fuck-all, he also looks just insanely cuddly. He gives me PAC as badly as Spoony does, with the notable upside that I don't want to punch him in the face nearly as often.

After watching Linkara's 100th episode, I'm suddenly wanting to hear him sing a full song. Seriously, I know it's just one line which is easy even for the most tone deaf of people, but... *shudder*

And now there's this.Hot damn. It's incredibly sweet to see him so into it.

Two words: Dark Rob. (Yeah, it was only for two brief scenes and only as a gag, but still...)

Oh God yes. Nice to know that looking good in make-up and being a pretty woobie runs in the family.

I loved his appearance in Linkara's "Previously On" segment. Something about the way he said "Life isn't a game..." *shudder* You know, squiggly feelings and all that....

According to Iron Liz (who was on hand for the filming of the Third Anniversary special), he's an absolute sweetheart who has "the patience of a saint". Gawww!

The Nostalgia Chick chloroforming the Nostalgia Critic at the end of her Transformers review, anyone?

Seconded. His squirming and muffled shouting with her hushing him and stroking the back of his neck? Unf. Damn you, nostalgia duo!

And gets tranqed in an Armageddon one in retribution! On the floor, with half-open eyes fluttering...

Can some nice person please tell me why I always sigh like a little fangirl when I see either the Nostalgia Critic or Linkara with their guns? Especially when I get freaked out by guns and their users in real life?

Speaking of nice things that both of them have, I'm pretty sure I'm not the only one who has a deep love for them in those hats, right? Linkara because, well, trilby hats tend to be awesome anyway and as for the Critic, managing to look hot in a baseball cap when most guys look ridiculous has to be an accomplishment.

Anyone for a third thing? They both have inexplicably yummy forearms. Linkara with his jacket missing in the Mechakara showdown folding his arms (to be specific), and the Nostalgia Critic just in general with his sleeves rolled up. Godamnit, guys, why do I want to lick both of you so much?

And have we really missed the most obvious fetish here? Guys, loads of attractive, snarky geeks hating each other and wanting to beat the shit out of each other! No wonder why the Nostalgia Critic and the Chick looked better fighting than they did on their actual date.

This troper has come to conclusion that if you are a regular visitor to TGWTG, it's only a matter of time before you will develop a serious crush on somebody on the site. I guarantee it. There is something there to suit everybody's tastes.

I would argue that if you spend enough time on the site you'll develope at least a little bit of a crush on all of them.

No love for LordKat and Sean Fausz? It might be the fact she just loves the Tiny Guy Huge Girl aspect of it, but I mean, come on! This troper couldn't be the only one that squeed when Lord Kat ate that strawberry during the Dragon Ball Evolution review. It definitely hit the Erotic Eating fetish button. *blushes*

The concept behind Until We Win alone is a Geeky Turn On for this troper, but combine that with the fact that Lord Kat has a very pleasant voice... (His one sung line in Linkara's 100th video solidified this. Fangirl status: WON OVER.)

You should stop by his Ustream chat sometime. LK enjoys singing, and he breaks into song rather frequently. Believe it or not, he likes Broadway showtunes. (He seems particularly fond of Sweeney Todd and Les Misérables.) Yes, really.

A large number of TGWTG-ers (Todd, Jesu, Fausz, Y, Nella, Angry Joe, Rollo T, Brad, JewWario and Obscurus Lupa) recently discovered a kink-meme thread dedicated to them and spent several hours pouring over it. This actually became part of the kink meme in progress.

This Troper had the good fortune to hear the entire thing live. And it was glorious.

A year later, this troper was talking to JesuOtaku on RadioDeadAir via PM and mentioned that there was an mp3 of that night. Hope instantly expressed interest in hearing it, so I linked it to her. She ended up tweeting the link I sent her. Holy crap.

The majority of them can sing incredibly well. Add that onto the fact that they're attractive and like showing off their voices? You can see why this is pleasing.

Talking about the Q&A- let's spend some words on Welshy, can we? That lovely, lovely accent, and all that alcohol, and his fanboying over Anne Hathaway, and his glasses, and he's so cute and did I mention his ACCENT?!

Remember the Q&A where Panda slipped Welshy a mind-control drug? Because I do. Fondly.

Rollo T is adorable, especially when he's reporting in a suit and hat in Kickassia. It doesn't hurt that he's shown himself to be approving and enthusiastic about the fanfic.

It's not really a sexual thing, but This Troper thinks Michaud's lisp is adorable.

Oh yes. When he's saying on his Kickassia commentary about how it's interesting that they're steadily getting more female viewers? Awww. (AndIwonderifheknowswhythatis...)

He and Film Brain recently did a"Live Action Fanfic" together. Film Brain was his usual adorkable self, but Luke was downright sexy.

Also, the end of Lindsay and Kyle's 'Freddy Got Fingered' review has him being spanked with a sausage by Lindsay. This airing only about a week after the video mentioned above. What exactly does it take for a reviewer to get their own page? Because he's definitely headed in that direction.

I'd love to see my favorite contributors hook up. Todd In The Shadows and Pushing Up Roses were very cute together in their collaborations. Also Lupa and Todd. Lupa looked so adorably angry in her cameo for Todd's Usher review.

Anyone else notice the sexual tension between Todd and Roses in their Barbie LP? ....or was that just me?...

Agreed. This troper clearly remembers the Charleston-y dance that Joe competed in; immediately afterwards, "dance the Charleston with Joe" is on her bucket list.

Original poster here. God, yes Spoony. He just looked so cute in that cap! And his long hair...mmmmm. And the way he worked those hips? Gaaaah...dammit, I'm a married woman!

Doug for this male troper. Or, to be accurate, Doug's ass. It's a nice one, you cannot deny.

Wait, what about Skitch? ...but than again, maybe it's just me and my long hair fetish...

While at MA Gfest Iron Liz, Jew Wario, and Scarlett played the XX Xenophile card game for 'You're Such a Card...Game'. As XX Xenophile is adult themed there is almost non stop innuendo from all three players. The best part though is that many of the cards say to remove clothing. We can't see anything but the cards and the players hands, but all three are sure to point out that for all we the viewers know, they're getting very naked.

...Link or it didn't happen.

Link, but one can be on the fence as to whether or not it "happened." There's a lot of joking disclaimers as to whether or not they're actually getting naked, but... use your imagination.

Spoony's D&D Campaign has some driveby fetish fuel once in a while, but special mention must be given to what happens during the 9/26/10 Part 1 video, where the gang runs into what was dubbed in the chat as "a bunch of S&M elves" who blind and deafen some of them with flashbangs, tie them all up, gag the spellcasters, kick Liz in the ribs , don't gag Garrett because of his 'charisma,' and then one elf says that he's always been fascinated by how humans can grow beards and how he'd like to experiment with shaving one. THEN they get taken to a camp where ... well, Liz said it best: "So we're tied to a pole, we've been stripped to our underwear, and we're in mud." How many fetishes can YOU count?

To say nothing of what happens next morning, when Tamier grabs Liz's character Lilea and taps her on the head with his dagger, saying that if any of the others are lying or try to run off, sure THEY might escape, but "this pretty thing is MINE."

In LordKat's DnD campaign (aka the Wyrmwick Campaign ), Rollo T's character, a female elf named Caitlin, is becoming the firstborn of the dragon god Bahumut; as a result, she's slowly and painfully transforming into a dragon, one body part at a time (wings, tail, spikes, and so on). Naturally, this has led to a great deal of anguish, both physical and mental. However, it has also had some unexpected benefits; for example, Caitlin's wings enable her to (allegedly) have awesome crazy sex in mid-air. The whole thing is a fetish fuel goldmine.

...A fact that certainly hasn't been lost on the fans: Caitlin is the favorite subject for fan art of the campaign.

Oancitizen (Brows Held High) recently mentioned this very wiki. I thought he was absolutely gorgeous before but now, guh. And his singing in the Nostalgia Chick's Les Mis review? I melted.

Oh his singing. Of course it wasn't enough for him to be handsome, he has to have a great singing voice too.

Was it just me, or did Film Brain and Luke have quite a bit of Ho Yay and Foe Yay in Suburban Knight? And they were both freaking adorkable in their Harry Potter costumes.

Just stopping by to add that Blockbuster Buster is actually quite cute in Badass Adorable sense.

Luke Mochrie showing us clips from his "pretentious" and "weird" earlier short films, one of which features a scene where he pours a bottle of soda over himself and then stands in the shower, fully clothed. *fans self* All that wet fluffy hair ...

The Moulin Rouge musical review gave us plenty to squee/drool over. We have Critic, Linkara, Lindsay, and special guest Brentalfloss singing. Then there's Team NChick dressed in burlesque outfits and if that wasn't enough the title card features Rule 63 Critic dressed more or less as a hooker.

This female troper thinks that Tara (Nash's live co-host for WTFIWWY) is freaking beautiful. And her smile is adorable, too.

Be honest: don't you wanna see a clearer version of this pic? To clarify: it's Joe, Linkara and Spoony during their trip to Washington D.C. to protest SOPA. All three are wearing suits. And from what I can tell, they look good.

Personally, I have a thing for ERod, The Blockbuster Buster. I don't know exactly why but I find him very cute and attractive... Come on, I can't be the only one who like him?

JesuOtaku was already a cutie, but when she began her Paradise Kiss review by modeling a very form-fitting dress and striking several sexy poses, it was probably a little more fanservice-y than she intended.

New hire Sursum Ursa; ginger(and I do mean ginger) Scottish girl with glasses, gushing over Rachel Weisz in The Mummy and how awesome the new Star Wars trailer looks. Want. Most definitely want.