In a H2H (5 categories offense/pitching) 10 keeper league, I was offered Wieters ($13) for Motte ($11). I am of the belief that saves are the easiest category to find during the season (and I also have Rodney and Hanrahan as reasonably cheap keepers). Catchers are hard to find, obviously, so should I make this deal?

I rather have an $11 top closer than a $13 mid-tier catcher. 250 with low 20's HRs is good for a C, but not something I am paying $13 for. You can get a $1-3 C at the end of most auctions who will be sufficient.

C position is very deep this year; in 1 C leagues everybody gets a good 1 and theres good 1's in the FA pool too. If it is a 2 C league $13 is decent value, if it is a 1 C league its just OK. To me, both players fall into the 4-7 rankings at their positions

When asking for roster advice in these pages, remember there are thousands of different sets of league rules & many different active roster settings. If you want the best replies, be sure to include your leagues particulars in the original post