Idea 2: "Cat and Mouse". An indestructible warrior hunts an undetectable shape-shifter in a perpetual game of cat-and-mouse. The Foundation has decided it must either contain the warrior, or kill the shifter.

Idea 3: "An Opportunity". A copy of 8 Mile: Music from and Inspired by the Motion Picture, that, when played, opens a portal into a world where you 'ceased everything you ever wanted'.

Idea 4: "scp-wiki.net". A trip into meta-surrealism, the Foundation discovers a website chronicling the exploits of the Foundation in perfect detail.

I've been constructing these ideas for a while now, and feedback is certainly desired! Thanks for reading.

The first idea is intriguing but how does the Foundation come to know of it? Does it stay low always? The second idea sounds cliché for we have lots of warriors that are hard to kill such as Able. What are the two beings relationship anyway? Why must the Foundation have the ultimatum of containing one or killing one? Does one action ceases the other? Why kill the shape shifter? The Foundation can surely contain it. The third idea sounds uninteresting since what I am getting is that one gets teleported to where they can get whatever they want. Doesn't sound like much conflict or anything. What story are you trying to tell with it? The fourth idea sounds better as a joke article than a main list article because it's too meta and has greater potential for being silly if written as a joke article.

The first idea is intriguing but how does the Foundation come to know of it? Does it stay low always?

What I was thinking is that, when it moves, it makes a physical, visible 'bulge' in the universe. It can be detected by just about anyone who has working eyes.

The second idea sounds cliché for we have lots of warriors that are hard to kill such as Able. What are the two beings relationship anyway? Why must the Foundation have the ultimatum of containing one or killing one? Does one action ceases the other? Why kill the shape shifter? The Foundation can surely contain it.

The relationship between the two is never stated, as both are uncontained. Meanwhile, killing the shifter stops the warrior, as the warrior would no longer have a purpose.

The third idea sounds uninteresting since what I am getting is that one gets teleported to where they can get whatever they want. Doesn't sound like much conflict or anything. What story are you trying to tell with it?

The story I'm trying to tell is basically that of 'the man who got everything he wanted'. The people in this world are completely and totally happy. As such, wouldn't everyone want this? Foundation policy is the only thing keeping every member from trying to rush into a perfect world. This anomaly is the very definition of greed.

The fourth idea sounds better as a joke article than a main list article because it's too meta and has greater potential for being silly if written as a joke article.

Oh, perhaps. But there are a lot of meta joke SCPs. Should I put this one on the backburner for now?

Reminds me a lot of SCP-3000, to the point that without a radical reworking I think this one's off the table.

This one has potential, but I think you're just slightly missing the mark on where to go with it: the foundation has an indestructible hunter and an uncatchable prey keeping each other occupied. If they capture the hunter, they free the prey to run amok. If they kill the prey, they free the hunter from its task and deny it the satisfaction of a finished hunt. Figure out a way to bait or herd the prey into an isolated area, on the other hand, and they can carry on their chase for all eternity.

This one depends on if that was supposed to be "ceased" or "chased".

"Chased" sets you up for a stock wish fulfillment/be careful what you wish for plot, which isn't a strong place to start from for this audience.

On the other hand, if it really is supposed to be "ceased", that could be interesting. It would hinge quite a bit on the storytelling and your ability to play with expectations- the obvious route is a world where they destroyed their lives by not chasing a dream, but I could see other paths like a struggling musician who in the alternate life took that scholarship instead of going on that disastrous nationwide tour, leading to a successful career in accounting which allowed them to found a respected recording studio and record label.

It's been tried before, and the problem is really that there is such a thing as too much meta. I'll never say its impossible to make an idea work, but if anyone ever pulls off I'll be extremely impressed.

Alright, so I can say for certain Idea 4 is completely off the table until I can hone my skills as an author.

This one has potential, but I think you're just slightly missing the mark on where to go with it: the foundation has an indestructible hunter and an uncatchable prey keeping each other occupied. If they capture the hunter, they free the prey to run amok. If they kill the prey, they free the hunter from its task and deny it the satisfaction of a finished hunt. Figure out a way to bait or herd the prey into an isolated area, on the other hand, and they can carry on their chase for all eternity.

I'm actually rather liking this. I'm wondering, though, if letting the shifter out in the world would be a bad thing? Like, the shifter can't be identified, and it's only ability is shapeshifting, so it's basically harmless. Besides, it could lead to some rather interesting discoveries in shifter behavior… but this is just a thought.

If comic books and science fiction teach us nothing else, it's that shapeshifting is actually one of the more dangerous superpowers, so that kind of puts a hitch in the plan there. X3

That aside, though, the Foundation generally operates on the assumption that everything they encounter is only biding its time to unleash armageddon. There's a chance that the prey could be harmless, but its just as possible that the only thing preventing it from trying to destroy all life on Earth is that it's been busy trying to get away from the hunter.

What they do know is that the two are keeping each other busy, so as long as the Foundation can get them to do that somewhere far away from populated areas, containment is achieved.

On #1, The wormlike part doesn't help, but the bigger issue is that both are cosmic entities consuming forgotten reality. Like I said, radical reworking might salvage it, but as written you're putting up hurdles for yourself at the start.

For the class on #3, Thaumiel would be if they had created this pair of anomalies to contain a third anomaly, so not that one. Sticking to the SEKT system, I'd peg them at high-end Euclid or low-grade Keter since containment would be a little tricky, but mostly a matter of keeping them in an isolated area.

If you're feeling adventurous, SCP-3240, SCP-3310, and SCP-3700 are object class "Hiemal"1: "SCP's that are their own box, and all the Foundation has to do is keep the lid closed". There's been some knee-jerk reaction as with anything like this, but reception has been okay so far, and the eternal chase here would fit the concept perfectly. So long as they're chasing each other, they aren't doing anything else, ergo, containment just means making sure they keep doing that and stay out of populated areas.

If you're feeling adventurous, SCP-3240, SCP-3310, and SCP-3700 are object class "Hiemal"1: "SCP's that are their own box, and all the Foundation has to do is keep the lid closed". There's been some knee-jerk reaction as with anything like this, but reception has been okay so far, and the eternal chase here would fit the concept perfectly. So long as they're chasing each other, they aren't doing anything else, ergo, containment just means making sure they keep doing that and stay out of populated areas.