Hal, on the basis of Youth and more experiance inaffairs of cosmic magnitude. Most of Alans experiance was in terrestrial level fights. They are however, about as close to identical in power and ability as you can get. This was deliberate on the part of DC as they were stated as being alternate universe versions of the same basic character.

Except Alan Scott weilds a much more powerful energy source. Things have changed since the Silver Age, and Alan Scott has a lot more experience in dealing with his powers than Hal does, as well as having much more power, and his will power is practically second to none.

This is a very, very tough call for me, but ultimately I'm going to have to go with Hal Jordan.

Age and experience counts for a lot, but it is not the deciding factor; the few times Alan Scott went head-to-head with Kyle Rayner, for example, the matchs were hardly one-sided, and we're talking completely opposite spectrum in terms of age and experience.

__________________I'll kick down the walls around me; they don't know how strong I am
I'm not defined by boundaries; they could never understand, I'm so much more than status quo

I am a Starship Ranger!
I'm gonna do everything I can to always be a Starship Ranger; it's everything I am!