Secondary Menu

How to Make Nail Polish

About: I work at instructables by day, and turn into a stitch witch by night. follow me on instagram @jessyratfink to see what i'm working on! ^_^
More About jessyratfink »

This instructable will teach you how to make your own nail polish colors using eyeshadow and glitter.

It's an excellent way to get custom nail polish colors you couldn't get otherwise. And I love the way this nail polish goes on and the way it dries - it's much more matte and shimmery than regular nail polish.

Plus, making your own nail polish is very cheap and fast - so why not give it a try?

P.S. Know there are lots of tutorials on how to make your own nail polish floating around online, but I really wanted to give it a try. :D Even sunshiine has one - make sure to check her instructable out!

Step 1: What You'll Need:

clear nail polish

eyeshadow (I bet blush would work too!)

craft glitter

a couple sheets of paper

a toothpick

I bought the cheapest stuff available at Walgreen's - Wet n Wild. The name is cringeworthy, but at a dollar each for the clear polishes and three dollars each for the eyeshadow compacts, it was a really good deal! And I am actually really impressed with how my nail polish turned out.

The polish is pretty runny, but that's the only downside. :)

Step 2: Empty Out Some of the Polish

Step one and the most important step!

Pour a tiny bit of polish out of the bottles into/onto something you were throwing away anyway. I used a ziploc bag. You'll need extra room in the bottle for the eyeshadow or glitter you're adding.

In the picture, the polish on the left has had a little poured out, and the polish on the right is a full bottle.

Step 3: Make a Paper Funnel

This will help you get everything into the polish bottles with very little mess.

You'll need a new funnel for every color of eyeshadow or blush you use, otherwise cross contamination is going to happen!

I folded a piece of printer paper twice so I ended up with fold lines to cut it into four smaller pieces and then used those to make my funnels.

Step 4: Prep the Eyeshadow

Use a butter knife or whatever you like to scrape the eyeshadow from the compact and onto a piece of paper. Then chop the eyeshadow up - you don't want any big clumps, because those will be trickier to mix into the polish.

Step 5: Funnel It Into the Bottle and Shake!

Unscrew the cap and wipe the excess polish off the brush and set it to the side on a scrap of paper so it doesn't ruin anything. :)

Use the piece of paper you've chopped the eyeshadow up on to transfer the eyeshadow - just fold it in half and tip it into the funnel.

Tap the funnel to get the eyeshadow to fall down into the bottle. If the eyeshadow gets grumpy and starts to clump at the bottom of the funnel, use a toothpick to help push it through. This happened almost every time.

Try to be quick while doing this, otherwise the nail polish brush can dry out and you'll have to get the nail polish remover after it to clean it up.

Screw the top back on and shake like a madperson. I did lots of shaking and rolling it between my hands - it took a minute or so to get everything nice and smooth. You don't want to see any clumps or dark spots in the polish!

This polish will settle after it's been sitting around for a few hours, but it is easily remedied by a bit more shaking. :D

If you're unsure about how much eyeshadow to use, see the next step!

Step 6: How Much Eyeshadow Should I Use?

The eyeshadows I'm using are 4 oz each. Using the whole 4 oz gave a highly pigmented opaque polish, while using half the eyeshadow gave a really sheer polish (shown on my thumb).

I'm not a fan of sheer polishes, so I went with the full 4 oz tray of eyeshadow.

Both photos are shown using only one coat. :)

Step 7: Glitter Polish!

I chose not to mix the glitter + clear polish + eyeshadow because I'm not a fan of colored glitter polishes... but I'd love to know how it works out if anyone tries it!

I used the same method as the eyeshadow - tipped some glitter into the funnel and then lots of shaking. I'd say I used about 1/2 teaspoon of glitter per bottle. You just want it to look nice and full when shaken.

Keep in mind that the glitter will settle to the bottom when not in use - just shake well before every use and shake occasionally while applying too and you'll be good to go!

Step 8: Final Photos + Comments

I really do like this more than most polish I've bought! The polish I made from eyeshadow is really matte and shimmery, and it dries quicker than normal polish as well.

The glitter polish turned out great as well - just make sure to do a clear top coat over it because craft glitter can be a little chunky. You don't want the glitter snagging on your clothes/hair/pets/whatever. :D

Now we'll have to see how long it lasts! I ended up doing a base coat of the purple polish I made, covering that with the gold glitter polish, and topping that with a clear top coat. I'll report back! It's held up well so far and I've had a hot shower and washed a load of dishes since yesterday.

POLISH UPDATE: It ended up lasting four days, which is not bad for cheapy nail polish. I think I could have worn it longer - I only had one tiny chip on my right hand! Came off pretty easy too, but the glitter is always tricky. :)

COMMENT UPDATE: A few of you have suggested putting either a bb or a glass bead into the bottle to help the polish get mixed. I'm going to do this myself and I think anyone who tries this should do it too. I hadn't thought of it! :D

I read the first page of comments, but did not see the most obvious way to crush the eyeshadow. Use a PILL CRUSHER! It is very durable, inexpensive can be found almost anywhere, simple to use, no mess, easy to pour into funnel, easy to clean, won't hurt your hands, easy to clean, and small enough to store with your polish making materials in a makeup caddy or bag.

The pictures below give you an idea of the various kinds of pill crushers available on the market today. As you can see there is one for everyone no matter what ailment you may have. They do make automatic pill crushers if you have problems with your hands.

The first one is available at Walgreens for around $7. This is the one I use. It all comes as one piece that breaks down into 3 separate sections: the pill cutter on top, the crusher in the middle, and the drinking cup on the bottom. I found that to just use the crusher, the pill cutter is a real pain and is in the way and more difficult to use. I took it off permanently, but when I need to use it, I do not need to put it back onto the other two sections. It is still very easy to use without being attached to the parts.