I tend to agree, so I'll stick with Eliminate 2 teams, but allow any prestige. With the Heisman recruiting, and the new recruiting set up as it is, I don't see it being an easy road for any of us to just pull in studs class in and class out.

I think that we go unlimited, but those confident in their skillz that killz (I am drunk from celebrating my imminent incursion into the real world with the men and womenz that I fought for four years against mediocrity with so cut me some slack) should recuse themselves from taking the top teams. If that doesn't work, then commissish makes an independent veto on say... elite player taking an Ohio State or Bama.

Whole new game this year with way passing & defending will work , so prior stick skills may not be same.

I say we take 4star and under , that gives us plenty of options for teams in ACC & B1G , as well as SEC maybe.

I dislike idea of 12 guys splitting 2-3 of the six star teams and everybody else gets the leftovers.

Click to expand...

I Personally like to see guys with mich st go in and have to contend with Ohio st. When they win its that much more gratifying. Even more so if you steal a recruit from a user ohio st over a cpu ohio st.

I think limiting it is just a way of taking the easy way out, because guys dont want to end up playing a better team than them. Ya know? just my 2 cents on the topic

Unlimited. I don't think it matters who we take the games are gonna always be close. If we have a good set of sliders it doesn't matter who you have. I like default Heisman slightly adjusted because you see guys losing or barely winning against strong teams and the scores are more realistic.

If we go unlimited I will probably pick a 4 star and if we go 4 star or less I will probably pick a 2/3 star. To put it simply either one works for me. I do agree with the above to eliminate a couple of the top teams like Alabama lol

If we go unlimited I will probably pick a 4 star and if we go 4 star or less I will probably pick a 2/3 star. To put it simply either one works for me. I do agree with the above to eliminate a couple of the top teams like Alabama lol

Click to expand...

I second your logic here, but am a bit concerned about how exactly we'd determine that. Eliminate 6* teams? Just selectively choose which teams to eliminate? A lot of grey area if that's the case, so we'll have to think.

Lets say we do B1G/SEC. If we eliminate LSU and Bama, will we keep OSU? Is that fair? Especially with all the OSU fans in this OD. Idk, something I want to continue to discuss here

I second your logic here, but am a bit concerned about how exactly we'd determine that. Eliminate 6* teams? Just selectively choose which teams to eliminate? A lot of grey area if that's the case, so we'll have to think.

Lets say we do B1G/SEC. If we eliminate LSU and Bama, will we keep OSU? Is that fair? Especially with all the OSU fans in this OD. Idk, something I want to continue to discuss here

Click to expand...

Yea, I definitely see where it would be tough to decide which teams are not allowed because of something like this. By saying that it might just be better for us to pick 4 star or less teams and then we wouldn't have to worry about a situation like this.

I second your logic here, but am a bit concerned about how exactly we'd determine that. Eliminate 6* teams? Just selectively choose which teams to eliminate? A lot of grey area if that's the case, so we'll have to think.

Lets say we do B1G/SEC. If we eliminate LSU and Bama, will we keep OSU? Is that fair? Especially with all the OSU fans in this OD. Idk, something I want to continue to discuss here

I second your logic here, but am a bit concerned about how exactly we'd determine that. Eliminate 6* teams? Just selectively choose which teams to eliminate? A lot of grey area if that's the case, so we'll have to think.

Lets say we do B1G/SEC. If we eliminate LSU and Bama, will we keep OSU? Is that fair? Especially with all the OSU fans in this OD. Idk, something I want to continue to discuss here

Click to expand...

You gotta realize too that some 4 and 5 star teams are better than 6 star teams.