Last July 15, Calcione called the office. He left voicemails detailing what would happen to the agent if he ever called him again in regards to tax issues, specifying he would torture the agent, rape and kill the agent’s wife, injure the agent’s daughter and then finally kill the agent.

The IRS agent reported the calls to the authorities, who determined the voicemails were brutal enough to find charge Calcione. A federal judge found him guilty of threatening to assault and murder (on the accounts of the agent and his two family members.) A judge will determine his punishment this September, the maximum sentence is twenty years behind bars. The U.S. Attorney's office threatened to see the "toughest, appropriate sentence in this case."