When Columbus' proposal was initially rejected, Isabella I of Castile convoked another assembly, made up from sailors, philosophers, astrologers and others to reexamine the project. The experts considered absurd the distances between Spain and the Indies that Columbus calculated. The monarchs also became doubting, but a group of influential courtiers convinced them that they would lose little if the project failed and would gain much if it succeeded. Among those advisors were the Archbishop of ToledoHernando de Talavera, the notary Luis de Santángel and the chamberlain Juan Cabrero.[1] The royal secretary Juan de Coloma was ordered to formulate the capitulations. The agreement took three months to prepare because the monarchs were busy with other matters.[3] The capitulations were sealed at the Santa Fe encampment, on the outskirts of a besieged Granada.[4]

The original version has not survived. The earliest surviving copy is contained in the confirmations issued by the Crown in Barcelona in 1493. The omission of the word 'Asia' has led some historians to suggest that Columbus never intended to go there, but only to discover the new lands. In 2009 the Santa Fe Capitulations were inscribed on UNESCO’s Memory of the World Register. [5]