After seven lead changes and six ties in overtime, Manhattan's Aaron Walker Jr. dunked to tie it again at 82 with 49 seconds left, but Davis and Kendley combined for three free throws and the Bears led 85-82 with one second left. Walker got the ball on the next possession and his 3-pointer at the buzzer fell short.

The Jaspers led 35-34 at halftime and led 67-64 after Thomas Capuano's 3 with four seconds left in regulation when Kendley tied it with a 3 at the buzzer.