I think all the restaurants (even Bella Vista - the beach grill during the day) are all romantic with excellent service. Casanova is the fancier restaurant and very romantic followed by Pallazina. You will need to make reservations for both of these. You can do this when you arrive or just call the reservation extention during your stay. We've also heard the in room dining is excellent and very romantic on your balcony, so we're going to try that this time too. Have a great trip, I know you will love it!

I would concur with Ristorante Cassanova, on the Terrace.
There are just a few tables set up, it is very quiet, and you have quite a few servers fawning over your every need.
The soft lighting and seclusion makes it more romantic than Palazzina, IMHO.
The second most romantic spot would've been just the two of us, on our balcony, enjoying the superb room service option.

Thanks everyone. Special special thanks to Shari n James, you have made planning our vow renewal so exciting. I must have studied your video/pix a zillion times. Amazing. Looks like we're going to do the room service dinner on our balcony for a private reception the night of our renewal. It's on a Monday. Any other suggestions? Again, thanks.

The absolute most romantic dinner (and best food) for us was through room service. We ordered the fillet mignon - and they even delivered a bottle of wine. It was private, romantic and the best we had.

We thought that dinner on the terrace at Casanova was very romantic - candlelight, great view, quiet, fantastic service (no long waits between courses, just long enough that we did not feel rushed). However, we also managed to have dinner one night on the beach at Bella Vista. You have to get there when they first open for dinner (I believe 7:00?) to score one of the tables on the beach (not that eating on the patio is bad). It was so romantic being right on the beach, with the gentle waves practically lapping at our toes.

Thanks everyone. Special special thanks to Shari n James, you have made planning our vow renewal so exciting. I must have studied your video/pix a zillion times. Amazing. Looks like we're going to do the room service dinner on our balcony for a private reception the night of our renewal. It's on a Monday. Any other suggestions? Again, thanks.

Stop your local dollar store and get a bunch of flameless votive candles to deck out your balcony for your in room dinner. Don't forget to order a bottle of wine or two with your dinner and get every corse they are on the small side and maybe two types of desserts to - yep I'm a piggy!