Socialized medicine is a somewhat slippery term to define since people may perceive it in different ways. This is especially the case in the US where efforts to create some form of large scale government-involved health system have been underway for a long time. The push towards this system didn't just begin in the 1990s when then First Lady Hillary Clinton worked on creating a plan. Instead it goes back to President Theodore Roosevelt, who suggested public health insurance in the early 20th century.

By socialized medicine, some people mean that the government would pay for health care, often in exchange for higher taxation. People would not pay for most health care services as covered by the government. Such systems exist in places like Canada and the UK. There are options in both countries to carry other private insurance, and in Canada, most citizens pay extra for prescription drug coverage. Yet most costs for doctor’s visits or surgeries are fully covered.

Ad

The term “socialized” as is presently used, can be considered pejorative, especially for any who oppose US government involvement in health care delivery. It is used in place of socialism, and may be used to create fear or concern that government exerts too much control on people as is, and that allowing government to “control” health care would be taking the country in a socialist direction. When used in a negative sense, there tends to be glossing over of the fact that the US government has several “socialized medicine” programs. These include the Medicaid system and the State Children’s Health Information Program (SCHIP). To a degree, the health programs that cover the US military and Medicare are also socialized.

Those in favor of creating a government health system, even if it retains many private options, do not necessarily call systems proposed socialized medicine. They can refer to them as public health, universal health, single payer or public option. The idea of socialism, especially as evoking fear of the Cold War or sometimes communist states is given little credence. In fact some opponents of the term suggest "socialized" would have to become the adjective in front of many government systems that rely on taxpayers, and note few people refer to road systems as socialized roads, or to post offices as socialized mail.

What this really means when trying to define the system from a US perspective is that definition can very much depend on political orientation. It should be noted there’s a shift in this, as it was a Republican president who first proposed national health care. Today, it would be fair to state that most on the right are more opposed to what they deem socialized medicine, while most on the left support some form of government health care.

Discuss this Article

anon62957Post 2

I am disappointed in the failure of our political leaders to find a way to insure every American equally. They have failed the basic American in every imaginable way. More taxes will surely ensure the demise of working class people.

If people in or near retirement age could get health insurance coverage in earlier years then many would retire and make more jobs available for the young.

Then gain we already have a government run health care system "Medicare." Elderly people are freezing to death in their homes because they used what little money they have to buy badly needed prescriptions, instead of paying their gas bill.

People are so busy working to care for themselves or their family, that

they do not have time to be sick. They just want a pill to make it go away so they can move on. The mortgage payments do not wait.

Many of us already pay half of our wages to government. Should we all start raising pigs to pay for the taxes?

A side effect that I have noticed to socialized medicine is that people, slowly over time turn over their own responsibility toward health to their doctor.

Simple issues, like getting a cold, suddenly needs a visit to the doctor's office and of course you come home with a prescription that needs a visit to the pharmacy; when simple rest, hot tea, and some over the counter medicine would handle the job equally well.

I was appalled while visiting one of the countries with socialized medicine, where intelligent people who used to know how to take care of simple medical problems, over time became so dependent on the advise of the doctor, and I am talking about minor issues.

That is one disadvantage of socialized medicine, or anything else socialized for that matter. We turn over the responsibility to somebody else, and in turn become helpless.

Post your comments

Please enter the code:

Login

Register

Make changes/additions/deletions to the article below, and one of our editors will publish your suggestions if warranted.

Optional: Explanation of your recommended changes

Thank You!

One of our editors will review your suggestion and make changes if warranted.
Note that depending on the number of suggestions we receive,
this can take anywhere from a few hours to a few days.
Thank you for helping to improve wiseGEEK!