I have adored Ruben ALWAYS with every song, but this one I wasnt impressed with,and I thought he was actually a little off in places,.,,,never seen him miss a note before,! In spite of that he sounded good as usual, and Clay was great as well

I'm *not* loving Josh at all! What is up with the pointing thing? And the toe tap was not cute.... I think this is one of the weakest performances tonight, and would not doubt that he is the one to go tomorrow

My ranks:
1. Trenyce- OMG, this has to be one of my fave performances of the competition so far! Just amazing!
2. Kimberley L- Other than the first 2 lines, which were too low, it was AWESOME- and SUCH a difficult song to sing!
3. Clay- Good song choice, good job. But this wasn't his night to shine.
4. Kimberly C- Did really well tonight! But the song just wasn't difficult enough. But she rocked it out.
5. Ruben- Just okay. He did it very well, but it was such an easy song.
6. Carmen- Just okay. One of her better performances, but still kinda screechy and vibrating. Nice one the "syncopated rhythm" part.
7. Rickey- Painful.
8. Josh- Even more painful.

Man alive - I just started cringing when I heard Josh's song choice even before he started singing. Country and disco really don't mesh anyway, but singing Celebration? Oy vey - not a good plan.

Much as I love Josh, I do believe he's earned a spot in the bottom three. I didn't dig Carmen, and although I liked Rickey, someone's gotta be the third in the bottom three, and I think he's it - it's not any of the others.

Clay, I loved. Trenyce, I really liked, although I hate the song. Ruben was good, but he just sang it straight - where was the Ruben flair??