How do publishers decide whether to release manga in print, digitally, or both? My understanding is that a digital release is cheaper, so some titles that wouldn't be profitable in print can support digital-only releases, but what are factors that go into print-only releases? Shelf-space is at a premium for me, and I was hoping to get digital copies of Fullmetal Alchemist: Fullmetal Edition, as well as Kaoru Mori's A Bride's Story, but they're only available in print.

Since I'm not privy to what's behind all of the decisions that North American manga publisher make regarding what gets published in print, what's digital-only, and what's released in both print and digital format, I can only make some educated guesses. There are many things that are considered, but if I had to sum it up, there are two important factors that go into these print/digital/both decisions: 1) the manga publishers' best guess about the projected sales/popularity/profitability of a given manga series, and 2) the Japanese manga creator/rights holders' consent.

We've pretty much established in past Answerman columns that it's much faster and less financially risky to publish a manga in digital format. With digital publishing, there's none of the costs associated with printing, shipping, and warehousing that comes from publishing and selling printed books. However, with both print and digital, there's still the costs associated with paying people to translate, localize, letter/touch-up art, edit, and market/sell books, plus licensing fees (among other things), so it's not exactly free and easy to publish manga digitally either. But digital gives publishers greater latitude to try out manga with readers, to see if there's enough interest to warrant putting it out in print.

Kodansha Comics' Digital First program is a good example of this. Digital publishing allows them to put out much-requested but longer or niche-interest series like Ace of Diamond and Chihayafuru, bring back and complete the run of incomplete or out-of-print series like Beck and Nodame Cantabile, or publish the latest serialized chapters of brand new series like Eden's Zero by Hiro Mashima or Aposimz by Tsutomu Nihei before the first volume of the collected graphic novel or tankobon is even available in Japan. It also lets them try out new series like Tokyo Tarareba Girls and Peach Girl Next (the 10-years-later sequel to this popular shojo series is debuting in mid-September, along with the return of the other Peach Girl manga, which was previously published by TokyoPop).

SuBLime Manga also offers some boys love manga titles as digital-first or digital-only releases, with the added bonus of them being DRM-free (digital rights managed) files you can download and read on any device.

In the case of Tokyo Tarareba Girls, a fun romantic comedy/drama about three 30-something single women by Akiko Higashimura, it was initially only available as a digital release, but thanks to strong sales and reader buzz, it is now being released as print editions.

It won't end up this way for all digital-first manga titles, but isn't it nice to know that it's a possibility, if there's enough support from readers?

But what about those other examples you mentioned: Fullmetal Alchemist by Hiromu Arakawa (published by VIZ Media) and A Bride's Story by Kaoru Mori (published by Yen Press)? In this case, my best guess is that both series are pretty popular and would likely sell well in both print and digital, so financial risk is less of a factor. However, I'm guessing that these titles are not available for purchase in digital format at this time because the authors/manga creators have specified that these series be released as print-only editions.

Why? Well, it's hard to say specifically without asking each artist directly, but the most frequently-cited reasons for why a manga creator might say “no” to digital editions of their work are 1) fear of piracy and 2) they want their work to be presented as they originally intended: as printed books.

Regarding the piracy anxiety bit, for some manga artists, there's a lingering fear that even when their work is released as official editions from a publisher, digital manga pages are easier to pirate and upload to unauthorized distribution sites. Whether this is statistically true or not is irrelevant – what matters most is if the manga creator is comfortable with digital publication and distribution of their comics, and they get the final say. For some manga creators, the answer is “no” to digital, and there's not much publishers or readers can do about that.

However, as digital publishing makes up a bigger and bigger portion of manga sales in Japan and abroad, these attitudes are shifting, and it looks like there are fewer holdouts in the print-only camp than there were before.

The other reason why a manga series might not be available digitally is that it may require separate negotiations or additional fees to get both print and digital publication rights. For example, before digital publishing was common, publishers may have paid for the print publication rights. If, at a later date, they decided that they wanted to get digital publication rights too, then they would have to negotiate a new contract and probably pay additional licensing fees to cover this.

Specific circumstances may be different for different manga series, manga creators and publishers, so there's no one answer that will address the “why” question for the many manga titles that are currently not available for purchase in digital format. It doesn't hurt to let publishers know that you're strongly interested in buying these titles in digital format. A lot of the things we're seeing now, like same-day-as-Japan releases of new manga chapters are due in part to comments and suggestions from readers. So make your voice heard, and maybe someday, you'll be able to free up space on your bookshelves by having more of your favorite manga available in your digital library instead. You never know.

Do YOU have a question for the Answerman?

We want your questions! Send in as many or as often as you like. We can only pick three questions a week (and unfortunately I don't have ALL the answers) so if you haven't been chosen, don't be discouraged, and keep on sending.

Deb Aoki was the founding editor for About.com Manga, and now writes about manga for Anime News Network and Publishers Weekly. She is also a comics creator/illustrator, and has been a life-long reader of manga (even before it was readily available in English). You can follow her on Twitter at @debaoki.

Paul takes a look at Madhouse's avant-garde movie about the underworld with a dub produced by Youtubers, plus a brand-new Shelf Obsessed submission and all this week's new anime releases!― By the time you read this, I'll probably be digging out from a foot or more of snow. I was totally planning on going outside and being productive over the weekend and definitely wasn't looking for an excuse to st...

The infamous Slayer's story extends beyond the anime in these two action-packed volumes. How will these new challenges affect these unconventional adventurers?― While the story arcs covered by the 2018 anime adaptation begin the work of showing how Goblin Slayer's new party helps him recover some of his lost humanity, the events of volumes five and six really kick that job into high gear. What's als...

As it turns out, "you've been transported to another world!" has been a storytelling device since the dawn of time. Mike takes a fascinating trip through the history of the genre.― Just a couple of weeks ago, I saw a remarkable animated film about the chronicles of a troubled man with a life full of problems, who's whisked away from the world he knows to a new and different parallel universe—one whe...

This fantasy adventure indulges some familiar tropes but strays just far enough from the beaten path to keep things interesting. Rebecca Silverman dives in.― Cross Infinite World tends to focus more on light novel translations, but the few manga titles they've also licensed are interesting. Tia la Cherla is a straight fantasy (as opposed to the historical fantasy, isekai, and urban fantasy of their ...

A young woman gets spirited away to a world of ayakashi and discovers new passions in this charming romance manga. Rebecca Silverman has the details.― Kakuriyo: Bed & Breakfast for Spirits' first volume and its 2018 anime are both adaptations of author Midori Yuma's original light novel, and as such, this book brings something a little different to the table than the anime. That said, even if you ne...

Shoji Kawamori's latest fantasy mech adventure has finally come to an end on Netflix, leaving lots of crazy questions in its wake. Nick and Micchy share what they loved about the show and what left them scratching their heads.― Shoji Kawamori's Last Hope has finally come to an end on Netflix, leaving lots of crazy questions in its wake. This week, Nick and Micchy share what they loved about the sho...

Lauren Orsini takes an in-depth look at this Perfect Grade model kit to determine if this beloved release is a good choice for newcoming or veteran Gundam builders.― Gundam Astray Red Frame has its origins in the manga Mobile Suit Gundam SEED Astray. Published by Tokyopop, this manga has been out of print in the US since 2004. Nevertheless, its lead mobile suit's samurai-inspired design has captiva...