"The thing is, I can't date anybody without it being portrayed as a serious relationship in the tabloids," she previously told InStyle. "I don't actually have sex with every male I come into contact with."

Either way, her next love interest will find some ruff competition in Finn.

"I'm obsessed with my dog," Seyfried told PEOPLE in 2010. "He's become my son and my light source and kind of a savior to a lot of people."