Welcome to Echoing the Sound. You'll find that quite a few things have changed here since the last iteration of the board so be sure to check out the FAQ. This is a completely fresh start - You'll need to register before you can post: click the register link above to proceed (and look for the registration email in your spam folder). To start viewing messages, select the forum that you want to visit from the selection below.

I've placed them under the album version since there really isn't much to be said about them. If you guys think they should have their own entries, let me know and I'll tweak my work.

From an organizational standpoint, does it make sense to have, say, Spoiler:"Hurt (Reverse)" listed seperately? You're right, there isn't much description to add at this point. I was just thinking perhaps since it's an officially released work and does vary from the original, it might be worth it's own entry?

Well, it's a tough call. I also thought that leaving them as a tiny sidenote would help to preserve their status as interesting little surprises for people to find, but maybe there's no need for that. I'm also wondering if they should be on the list of remixes and alternate versions. Anyone else wanna chime in on this and help us decide?

Well, it's a tough call. I also thought that leaving them as a tiny sidenote would help to preserve their status as interesting little surprises for people to find, but maybe there's no need for that. I'm also wondering if they should be on the list of remixes and alternate versions. Anyone else wanna chime in on this and help us decide?

I don't think a simple reversal is enough to constitute a full other version paragraph, but should definitely be mentioned in their respective songs Album version paragraphs. Then again I can't edit the wiki, so

Well, it's a tough call. I also thought that leaving them as a tiny sidenote would help to preserve their status as interesting little surprises for people to find, but maybe there's no need for that. I'm also wondering if they should be on the list of remixes and alternate versions. Anyone else wanna chime in on this and help us decide?

The wiki is a bit undecided overall about this kind of thing. Single and vinyl versions get lumped into the album version description, but radio edits don't, do they? Seems like it needs to be all-or-nothing imo: either list every officially released variation separately, or group things together by halo release and include descriptions for edited/alternate versions under those.

I noticed on this page http://www.nin.wiki/Halo_numbers, there is no reference to Gone Girl whatsoever. Although it does not have a Null number, should it no be referenced much in the same way Juno is?

I noticed on this page http://www.nin.wiki/Halo_numbers, there is no reference to Gone Girl whatsoever. Although it does not have a Null number, should it no be referenced much in the same way Juno is?

The thought there is that The Null Corporation wasn't involved in Gone Girl at all; it was published entirely by Columbia, so with no Null number, it's not relevant.

I think Gone, Girl was supposed to be through Null, originally. Since it wasn't, they went ahead and skipped the catalog number and proceeded with Null 04 for Before the Flood. When Patriot's Day comes out on Vinyl, it should be Null 05. And of course, The Vietnam War is Null 06.

If Null re-issues Gone, Girl, somewhere down the line, it should have the Null 03 label.

I think Gone, Girl was supposed to be through Null, originally. Since it wasn't, they went ahead and skipped the catalog number and proceeded with Null 04 for Before the Flood. When Patriot's Day comes out on Vinyl, it should be Null 05. And of course, The Vietnam War is Null 06.
If Null re-issues Gone, Girl, somewhere down the line, it should have the Null 03 label.

I'm not able to edit the main page. My authority was inadvertently taken away when the wiki was revamped. Wish I didn't have that problem, as people request main page edits from me all the time and I'd like to be able to oblige them. I have added the new tour date. As for song descriptions, there is someone who typically does those and does a really good job that I wouldn't be able to do. Can't remember who it is at the moment.

You edited the warm place page... was thinking about the illandro vocal mix thing... the description has nothing to do with the text along the official download page ? She was saying it was an unofficial mix but trent liked it and invited her in studio ?

I posted this in the Fragile Deviations 1 thread. The feedback on it seems to explain it to be legit!Here’s something interesting. In the first 18 seconds of “Feeders” there’s a sample of someone whispering “This is it...” then followed by mechanical/machinery like sounds. In the movie “Real Genius” there’sa scene where Mitch dismantled the closet to find Laslo and discovers a sign saying ‘This is it’ which is also whispered by Mitch. It’s in the enclosed clip at the 19 second mark. Is it the same sample? I’m pretty damn sure but I need more ears:https://youtu.be/Qa8kCQQUjHM

I posted this in the Fragile Deviations 1 thread. The feedback on it seems to explain it to be legit!Here’s something interesting. In the first 18 seconds of “Feeders” there’s a sample of someone whispering “This is it...” then followed by mechanical/machinery like sounds. In the movie “Real Genius” there’sa scene where Mitch dismantled the closet to find Laslo and discovers a sign saying ‘This is it’ which is also whispered by Mitch. It’s in the enclosed clip at the 19 second mark. Is it the same sample? I’m pretty damn sure but I need more ears:https://youtu.be/Qa8kCQQUjHM