Comments

Comment by robspierre

Comment by Thirsom

I wonder... will there be this one or the Bubblier Brightbrew Charm, Bubblier Brightbrew Charm, - because the stats look pretty similar to me... or even both, which would mean that Brewfest 2011 will be the place to be for aspiring tanks of a stamina-oriented approach... the main difference seems to be the on-use-effects in terms of real numbers... anyone got an idea what "will smite your foes with empty tankards" does? I mean, the animation won't be much of a surprise, but does that mean it does physical damage, or increases threat, or... well, what's that stuff in terms of game mechanics?

---

Okay, I've now seen both drop , so, including the Brawler's Trophy, we got 3 tanking trinkets (and at the moment, luckily and for once, for a change, no lack of tanks queueing for them...

Comment by Troopcd

Comment by sanjiyan

The maiden does 20 melee hits of about 100-250 damage. Can crit, and can also miss. No ranged or otherwise distance attack, she also won't move from the spot you summon her. Do not expect much more than 3k total damage.

All in all, a pretty much useless "use".Considering she has around 4.8k hp i am guessing she has not been updated.

Comment by Gratze

Can these and the other loot from the 2011 version be Disenchanted?

Comment by Muspel

In terms of stamina trinkets, this is mediocre at best. Moonwell Phial and Symbiotic Worm both offer far more powerful on-use effects, so I wouldn't run with this unless I didn't have any other options.

Comment by tahini

This is when us weekend warrior tanks catch up to all those hardcore raiding tanks - woo hoo! Nobody will be laughing at our health with these puppies equipped! Muhahahaha... this > firelands dailies for 1,000 hours, thank you very much.

Comment by tahini

You are right, but try to tell that to a typical pug healer. LOL good luck with that sell!

Comment by kakurenaide

Comment by basementcat

this may be better than many tanking trinkets and stacking stam better in last few expansions but this is and has always been more of a fun trinket, used 80 version for wotlk pvp might grab this for 85 ppv just cause bar maid is fun

Comment by Gratze

Downrated for asking a question? Everyone is a critic, oh but PLEAASE tell me what this trinkets name is a "reference" to like every single post on here with some stupid reasoning and it get upgraded to the hundreds. /yawnThanks for the replies I found out about an hour after that by running it with guild enchanter.

Comment by ryankam10

Yeah continue to not do firelands daily casual$%^ and miss out on all the good loots

Comment by Gollam

I used both the +510 stam trinkets dropped by Coren Direbrew (Bubblier Brightbrew Charm and Bitterer Balebrew Charm) to help get the Drunken Stupor achievement. Just equipped both for more hp and thus survivability, and dropped from my mount after downing about 10 or so drinks. Hope this helps people having difficulty getting it.

p.s. cant drop in to water anymore... and i am very certain you can't parachute down.

Comment by Hannibal08

I didn't mean to imply that it has no use at all to a tank. I meant it's not a tank trinket by design, and is actually a poor choice for one when compared against blue (and sometimes green) tanking trinkets at much lower item levels.

Sure, stamina is useful to tanks. It's also useful to rogues, for example, that might need to melee inside an AE. Or warlocks that want to lifetap more. That still doesn't mean it's a rogue or a warlock trinket. This thing was designed as a toy and was given a stat that is useful (though not ideal) for all characters. The single heirloom ring, which was intended to be helpful to all character types and specs, also has stamina as it's sole main stat. That isn't because it was made for tanks. Just like these trinkets. They were made for the fun effect and given a broadly useful stat on par with their item level. I have no issue with tanks needing on them, or even wearing them in the absence of something better, but when they claim they are tank trinkets, either through lack of understanding of tanking or selfish greed, then I take issue.

Comment by childofnewlight

I said it was overrated. I did not say it was not a tanking stat nor a tanking trinket. I wouldn't equip these in lieu of better trinkets, but a better trinket doesn't make this trinket "not a tanking trinket". It just means there are better trinkets. There will always be "a better trinket". It doesn't make the non-optimal trinkets not tanking/dps/healing trinkets. Also notice my entire quote:

You'd be better off with avoidance and mitigation trinkets for most tanking needs.

Most. Not all.

Comment by DemoraX

Tired of your group ninja pulling?Use Bitterer Balebrew Charm to summon a dwarf to do it for you!"Bitterer Balebrew, Pulling mobs since 2011"™

Comment by breadbutt

whether or not this is a good tanking trink, it's a nice flavor item for free beer.