Nick Graham and Sam Harris as well. Thought those 2 blokes were gonna be awesome for us, massive disappointment. Also thought Bwaiff was going to be good for us.......still ashamed of that thought to this day.

I think for a player to count, they need to have played at their best or close to their peak here.

For instance:
Michael Buettner scored 58 touchdowns for Norths in 4 years, but only 2 for us in two.
Terry Hill... Great player for Manly.
Braith Anasta, Who was a genuine superstar for the Bulldogs and did play well for easts till his final year there.

None of these people should count in our best 17. They were no where near their best for us. If you are going to count them, you might as well add Jason Taylor, Terry Lamb, Ivan Cleary and Tim Sheens. In their haydays, they were really great players.

None of the coaches pulled on a boot for WT though.
If the criteria was for players who were at peak form for our club, not elsewhere, then that would rule out Fifita, probably Taupau, Packer, Matulino etc.

Yeah I noticed that I had forgotten to include The Largest Halfback Ever in my list.

"This club means a lot to me and I really love this club, I love playing here, I love playing with all of the boys, it's what I've known for pretty much all of my life and I'm happy to be here." - Luke Brooks.

Nick Graham and Sam Harris as well. Thought those 2 blokes were gonna be awesome for us, massive disappointment. Also thought Bwaiff was going to be good for us.......still ashamed of that thought to this day.

Another player I was stoked to see come and never fulfilled his potential is Lolesi, the coach jerked him around though and that probably contributed to his form and sudden departure.