Perspectives on the Social
Scientific Study of Genocide
Charles Anderton
Professor of Economics
College of the Holy Cross
Worcester, MA
[email protected]
Roger Williams University
April 17, 2013
1
Overview
 History of the term “genocide” and the UN Genocide Convention
 The emergence of the field of genocide studies
 Examples of genocide
 Four disturbing “stylized facts” about genocide
 Genocide prevention and the responsibility to protect (R2P)
 Social scientific study of genocide risk
 Economics of genocide
 Statistical risk factors for genocide onet
 Roger Williams, genocide studies, and the practice of toleration
 Discussion
2
Question
● Have you studied any genocide cases in your
courses at Roger Williams or in high school?
If so, which cases?
3
Where did the term
“genocide” come from?
 Winston Churchill called the Holocaust “a crime without a name”
 Raphael Lemkin (1900-1959)


A Polish Jew with expertise in law and languages
In the 1920s, he became interested in the Armenian genocide
(1915-1923)



Soghomon Tehlirian’s assassination of Mehmed Talaat (March 15,
1921) was a catalytic moment for Lemkin
Published Axis Rule in Occupied Europe (1944) where he
coined the term “genocide” (Genos = race/tribe + Cide = killing)
He worked tirelessly to have the United Nations codify
genocide as a crime in international law
4
The United Nations and the
Genocide Convention
 Genocide Convention
 December 9, 1948, the General Assembly of the United Nations
unanimously passed the “Convention on the Prevention and
Punishment of the Crime of Genocide”
 Article 2 of the Genocide Convention defines genocide as “...any of
the following acts committed with intent to destroy, in whole or in
part, a national, ethnical, racial or religious group, as such:
(a) Killing members of the group;
(b) Causing serious bodily or mental harm to members of the group;
(c) Deliberately inflicting on the group conditions of life calculated to bring
about its physical destruction in whole or in part;
(d) Imposing measures intended to prevent births within the group;
(e) Forcibly transferring children of the group to another”
 Raphael Lemkin on the word “genocide” (CBS News)
5
The Emergence of the Field
of Genocide Studies
 Began to emerge following Lemkin’s work and the Holocaust
 Extensive work by social scientists, historians, and others on


What genocide is and is not (definitional and categorical controversies)
Why genocides happen and what can be done to prevent them
 Multidisciplinary



Social sciences: social psychology, sociology, political science, economics…
Life sciences: biology, biological psychology, mathematics, statistics…
Humanities: history, languages and literature, philosophy, religion, culture…
 Multiple methodological perspectives




Statistical studies of risk factors for genocide onset and severity
Mathematical and non-mathematical theories/models of genocide onset and spread
Case studies (single and comparative) of genocide onset and spread
Laboratory experiments
 Synergies between academics, policymakers, and activists
6
Selected Examples of Genocide
●
●
●
●
●
●
●
●
●
●
●
●
●
Hereros of SW Africa, 1904
Armenian genocide, 1915-23
Soviet Union, 1920-53
Nazi Holocaust, 1939-45
China, 1958-62
Indonesia, 1965-66
Bangladesh, 1971
Burundi, 1965-73, 1988, 1993
Afghanistan 1978-92
Angola, 1975-94, 1998-2002
Cambodia, 1975-79
East Timor, 1975-79
Bosnia, 1992-95
Execution of Ukrainian Jew by member
of Einsatzgruppen (mobile killing unit)
7
Examples of Genocide Cont’d
Photos of Rwandan Genocide Victims
●
●
●
●
●
Guatemala, 1978-90
Uganda, 1971-79, 1980-86
Iraq, 1988-91
Rwanda, 1994
Sudan-Darfur, 2003-????
Child’s Drawing of Attack on Village in Sudan-Darfur
8
Four Disturbing “Stylized Facts” About Genocide
1. Genocides keep happening again and again and again
45
Stock of PITF Genocides
Stock of Ulfelder and Valentino Mass Killings
40
35
Number
30
Ulfelder and Valentino
Mass Killings
25
20
15
10
5
PITF Genocides
0
Year
Data Sources: Political Instability Task Force for genocides and Ulfelder and Valentino (2008) for mass killings.
9
Four Disturbing “Stylized Facts” About Genocide
Genocides are shockingly severe
2.
Estimated fatalities from selected genocides, 1966-2011
Afghanistan, 1978-92
1,176,000
Angola, 1975-94, 1998-2002
666,000
Bosnia, 1992-95
228,000
Burundi, 1965-73, 1988, 1993
189,750
Cambodia, 1975-79
2,700,000
China, 1966-75
480,000
El Salvador, 1980-89
49,450
Guatemala, 1978-90
71,400
Iraq, 1988-91
336,000
Rwanda, 1994
750,000
Sudan-Darfur, 2003-11
400,500
Uganda, 1971-79, 1980-86
456,000
0
1,000,000
2,000,000
3,000,000
Estimated Fatalities
Data Source: Political Instability Task Force
10
Four Disturbing “Stylized Facts” About Genocide
3.
There are “reasons” that genocides start and spread
 Under certain conditions, leaders of an authority group
choose genocide
 Genocides are not spontaneous and random events
 Genocides tend to be systematically planned and executed
 Most genocides can be viewed as “disturbingly rational”
11
Four Disturbing “Stylized Facts” About Genocide
4.
Many “ordinary people” perpetrate or condone
genocidal actions
 100,000-500,000 people were involved in genocidal
actions during the Holocaust (≈ 6 million killed)
 About 200,000 people conducted genocidal acts in
the 1994 Rwandan genocide (≈ 800,000 killed in 90100 days)
 Most genocide perpetrators must be “ordinary people”
rather than psychopaths because psychopathology is
relatively rare
How is it possible for so many ordinary
people to perpetrate (or not resist)
genocide?
12
Genocide: Worse Than War
 Daniel Goldhagen’s documentary, “Genocide: Worse
Than War” (show first 6 minutes)
13
Genocide Prevention and the
Responsibility to Protect (R2P)


Genocide prevention is a critical part of the work in
Genocide Studies
At the United Nations 2005 World Summit, leaders
made a commitment to protect populations from
genocide, war crimes, ethnic cleansing, and crimes
against humanity. This commitment is known as the
Responsibility to Protect (R2P)
14
Genocide Prevention and the
Responsibility to Protect (R2P)

R2P stipulates the following three “pillars”
1.
2.
3.
A State has a responsibility to protect its population from
genocide, war crimes, crimes against humanity and ethnic
cleansing (mass atrocities).
If the State is unable to protect its population on its own, the
international community has a responsibility to assist
the State by building its capacity.
If a State is manifestly failing to protect its citizens from mass
atrocities and peaceful measures are not working, the
international community has the responsibility to
intervene at first diplomatically, then more coercively, and as
a last resort, with military force.
15
Genocide Prevention and the
Responsibility to Protect (R2P)

R2P appears to be an emerging international policy
norm
 R2P was invoked on March 17, 2011 when the United
Nations Security Council approved resolution 1973,
which reiterated the responsibility of the Libyan
authorities to protect the Libyan population.
 Resolution 1973 laid the legal groundwork for foreign
military intervention in the Libyan civil war.
16
Social Scientific Study of
Genocide Risk

Theoretical models of genocide choice and spread
 Statistical models of genocide risk


Analogous to medical research on risk factors for disease
Almost 20 published statistical studies of genocide risk

Pales in comparison to the thousand or so statistical studies for
interstate conflict risk, several hundred such studies for civil war risk,
and about two hundred such studies of terrorism risk

Laboratory experiments
 Case studies
17
Economics of Genocide
Ways That Economics and Genocide “Go Together”
1. Genocide
Affects the
Economy
2. Economic
Conditions
Affect Genocide
3. Genocide
Requires Forms
of “Business”
Organization
4. Genocide is a
Mode
of Wealth
Appropriation
5. Segmentation
of Security as a
Fundamental
Service
6. Genocide
is a Choice
18
Statistical Risk Factors for
Genocide Onset

Working on statistical risk assessment project with J. Carter
 Sample: 155 countries, 1955-2006, about 8,000 obs.
 Risk factors








Threat of political/territorial loss to an authority group
Monopoly (autocratic) control of the polity
New state (≦ 3 years)
Low per capita income
Discrimination, particularly economic discrimination
Cold war period (pre-1990)
Low trade openness (??)
Low internet/mobile phone access (??)
19
Statistical Risk Factors for
Genocide Onset

We found in our study that




If a state is in the “bad sides” of the 6 major risk factors, it has
over a 90 percent chance of genocide in 10-year period
If a post-cold war state is in the “bad sides” of the 5 other major
risk factors, it has over a 60 percent chance of genocide in 10year period
Our work is just one study in a developing literature
We have much to learn
20
Roger Williams, Genocide Studies,
and the Practice of Toleration






Genocide and Atrocity Crimes (course in the Law School)
Prejudice and Institutional Violence (CORE course that
covers Holocaust and genocide)
Student Presentation, “Polemics and Denial: Redefining
the Assyrian Genocide”
RWU event, STAND: A Student Anti-Genocide Coalition
Services in Commemoration of U.S. Holocaust
Remembrance Day
Roger Williams and the Promotion of Civil Discourse
21
Discussion
 What would you like to talk about?
 Thank you!
22