“The Lovers of Valdaro" Archaeologists unearthed in 2007 two skeletons from the Neolithic period locked in an embrace and buried...

Thursday, December 30, 2010

Helen Thomas: Thrown to the wolves

Did any Arab or Palestinian support her..??

In 1960, I was fixated on emulating the courageous media personalities of the times, from Edward R. Murrow to a distinctive figure I came to admire at presidential press conferences - a wire service reporter named Helen Thomas.
In recent years, my faith in the power of dialogue in politics has been severely tested - as, no doubt has hers - in an age where diatribes and deliberate demonization chills debate and exchanges of opposing views.
Once you are labeled and stereotyped - especially if you are denounced as an anti-Semite - you are relegated to the fringes, pronounced a hater beyond redemption, and even beyond explanation.
As the legendary Helen Thomas soon found out.

The rise of a legend:
As a member in good standing of an activist generation, I saw myself more as an outsider in contrast to Helen’s distinctive credentials as an insider, as a White House bureau chief and later as the dean of the White House Correspondents' Association.
Yet, beneath her establishment credentials and status, she was always an outsider too - one of nine children born to a family of Lebanese immigrants in Winchester Kentucky, who despite their Middle East origins were Christians in the Greek Orthodox Church.
She became a woman who broke the glass ceiling in the clubby, mostly male, inside-the-beltway world of big egos and self-important media prima donnas.
Her origins were more modest. She grew up in an ethnic neighborhood in Detroit.
Helen received her bachelor's degree from Wayne State University in 1942, the year I was born. Earlier this year, her alma mater, of which she had taken so much pride in her achievements, canceled the award in her name.

A fall from grace:
The withdrawal of her name from the prominent award was a striking gesture of cowardice and submission to an incident blown out of proportion that instantly turned Helen from a 'she-ro' to a zero.
The Simon Wiesenthal Center put her on their top ten list of anti-Semites after angry remarks she made about Israel went viral and exploded into a major story.
President Barack Obama who cheerfully brought her a birthday cake, later labeled her remarks as "reprehensible".
You would think that given all the vicious ad hominems, Godwins and putdowns directed at him, he would be more cautious tossing slurs at others.
But no, all politicians pander to deflect criticism whenever the wind of enmity blows their way.
Now it was Helen who was being compared to Hitler in the latest furor.

Snakes and Foxes:
Then suddenly last June, I, like everyone in the world of media, was stunned to witness her public fall from grace, partly self-inflicted, perhaps because of the inelegant language used in response to an ambush interview by provocateur father-son Israeli advocates posing as journalists.
They were following in the footsteps of the vicious comments by Ann Coulter earlier denouncing Thomas as an "old Arab" sitting yards from the President as if she were threatening him. She refused to dignify that smear with a response.
I didn't know until she told me that she had also been hounded for years by Abe Foxman, a leader of the Anti-Defamation League who demanded she explain 25 questions she asked presidents over the decades.
"I didn’t answer," she told me, "because I don’t respond to junk mail."

Bait and switch:
Helen always stuck to her guns. She was considered the marquise of journalists that presidents respected. She even went to China with Nixon.
She has, however, always been polite enough to try to answer questions from strangers without always realizing who she was dealing with in a new world of media hit jobs, where "gotcha" YouTube videos thrive on spontaneous embarrassing moments, what we used to call "bloopers."
She had been baited and fell for it. Unaware of how the video could be used, she vented and then regretted doing so. It was too late. That short media snippet triggered millions of hits.
Helen later apologized for how she said what she did without retracting the essence of her convictions.
But by then, it was too late. Her long career was instantly terminated. The perception became everything; the context nothing.

Damage control:
She tried to be conciliatory, saying, "I deeply regret my comments I made last week regarding the Israelis and the Palestinians. They do not reflect my heart-felt belief that peace will come to the Middle East only when all parties recognize the need for mutual respect and tolerance. May that day come soon."

Her remarks were derided and dismissed, with the pundits and papers demanding her head. She had no choice but to resign after her company, agent, co-author and many "friends" started treating her like a pariah.
"You cannot criticize Israel in this country and survive," she says now.

She was forced into retirement and thrown to the wolves in a media culture that relishes stories of personal destruction and misfortune. It's the old 'the media builds you up before they tear you down' routine.
As blogger Jamie Frieze wrote, "I don't think she should have been forced to resign. After all, freedom of speech doesn't come with the right to be comfortable. In other words, the fact that you're uncomfortable doesn't trump my free speech. Thomas made people uncomfortable, but that doesn't mean her speech should be punished."
But punished she was.

A lesson learned:
When I called Helen Thomas to ask if she might be willing to share some of her thoughts on what happened, I found her as eloquent as ever, supportive of Wikileaks, critical of grand jury harassment in the Mid West against Palestinian supporters and angry with President Obama for his many right turns and spineless stands.
She was, she said, on a path outside the White House when a rabbi, David Nesenoff, asked to speak to her, and introduced his two sons whom he said wanted to become journalists (one of whom wasn't actually his son).
"That happens to me a lot," she said, "and I told them about my love of journalism and that they should pursue their goals. I was gracious, and told them to go for it."
Then the subject abruptly changed. "'What do you think of Israel' they asked next. It was all very pleasant and I don't blame them for asking,” she told me. But, then, she added, she didn't know the people would've "shoved a microphone in my face like a jack knife."
It wasn't just any rabbi making conversation. Nesenoff is an ardent Israel supporter who runs a website called 'Rabbi Live' and can be a flamboyant self-promoter. He says, "Even though I was born in Glen Cove and grew up in Syosset Long Island, Israel is my Jewish homeland. It is the homeland for all Jewish people."

The sin of silence:
She remembered being moved by a rabbi who spoke alongside Martin Luther King Jr at the March on Washington in 1963. I was there also, and heard him speak too, and so I looked him up.
It was Joachim Prinz of the American Jewish Congress who made a speech that influenced a younger Helen Thomas. He said, "When I was the rabbi of the Jewish community in Berlin under the Hitler regime, I learned many things. The most important thing that I learned under those tragic circumstances was that bigotry and hatred are not the most urgent problem. The most urgent, the most disgraceful, the most shameful and the most tragic problem is silence."
Helen says her whole career has been about combating the sin of silence. She says she has now been liberated to speak out.
"All I would like is for people to know what I was trying to say, that Palestinians are living under tyranny and that their rights are being violated. All I want is some sympathy for Palestinians," she says.

Forgotten but not forgiven:
Now it's the holiday season, allegedly a time of peace and forgiveness when presidents issue pardons to convicted criminals and reflection is theoretically permitted, a time when even a State Department hawk like Richard Holbrooke can, on his deathbed, it is said, call for an end to the Afghan war that he had dogmatically supported.
We have watched the rehabilitation of so many politicians over recent years who have stumbled, taken money or disgraced themselves in sex scandals, including senators and even presidents.

Helen Thomas is not in that category:
Yet, many of those "fallen" are back in action, tarnished perhaps, but allowed to recant, to work and then reappear in the media.
But, to this day, there has been almost no compassion, empathy or respect shown for one of our great journalists, Helen Thomas, who has been presumed guilty and sentenced to oblivion with barely a word spoken in her defense.
How can we expect Israelis and Palestinians to reconcile if our media won't set an example by reconciling with Helen Thomas?

Danny Schechter edits Mediachannel.org. He directed Plunder The Crime of Our Time, a film on DVD about the financial crisis as a crime story. (Plunderthecrimeofourtime.com)
The views expressed in this article are the author's own and do not necessarily reflect Al Jazeera's editorial policy.

1 comment:

Blair is the most known among those politicians who had been generously awarded by Arabs after leaving office.. Contracts of millions and formal receptions.. Why not a single Arabic institution offered Helen something in return for what she scarified for their cause..?

She would transfer long experience and true knowledge rather than the politics of greed.. She would coach how to dig with dignity and respect for truth.. How to build neutral consensus in times of madness.. How to be sincere to your own beliefs.. How never to feel old to speak your own mind..!There is great question here, on the true moralities among Arabic public and civic societies..!!

Search This Blog

About Me

Both my Brain and Heart, never stops or relaxes..!! It is a scientific fact, yet my own distinction..
I take nothing as granted till proven reasonable.. Value questioning and rationalizing everything.. Therefore, knowledge is my core substance..
I am driven by Love.. in all forms and shapes.. yet not to downgrade it for materialistics or indecency.. This is how I realize the world, the people, and my Creator swt..!!

Blog Archive

Allah... swt

يمكنك أن تدرس الله من خلال كل شيء وكل شخص في هذا الكون، لأن وجود الله لا ينحصر في المسجد، أو الكنيسة أو في الكنيس. لكنك إذا كنت لا تزال تريد أن تعرف أين يقع عرشه بالتحديد، يوجد مكان واحد فقط تستطيع أن تبحث فيه عنه، وهو قلب عاشق حقيقي، فلم يعش أحد بعد رؤيته، ولم يمت أحد بعد رؤيته. فمن يجده يبقى معه إلى الأبد"You can recognize God through everything and everyone in the universe, because the existence of God is not limited to the mosque, church or synagogue. But if you still want to know where exactly is His throne; there is only one place where you can be looking for; which is the heart of a true lover.. No one did live after observing the God.. No one did die after either.. Who finds Him; stays with Him forever.. "

A Worldly Sudanese..

A Sudanese with a Global core.. Realizing how the taste marvelously varies across Countries, Continents, Religions and Cultures.. Believing we have to share it.. Denouncing the 2011 Sudanese Partition.. Follow ‏@adilsud

The People of Sudan

I feel greatly proud as my 2009 poster is appreciated among many people, websites and imaginations.. This is my own personal FACE; till my wounded SUDAN is inevitably retrieved..

Today's Tomorrow..

Despite both pain and frustration: nurture the kids, incubate the poor and mentor the illiterate.. Pray for their tomorrow to be better than our today..!

Stigma 2016

Trump-zitional Shock..

Stigma 2015

It was not the indescribable and unimaginable flood of refugees to Europe, but the media pitfalls reflecting the historical suspicion among nations.. Europe can't be raped by who already been unknowingly raped..!!

Stigma 2014

The search for happiness continues with no predictions.. Technology breakthrough failed to make the people happier, and when surveyed it was Nepal scoring the peak.. The ultimate contemporary contradictions between science and faith..

Stigma 2013

The Lady in Red at Gezi Park of Taksim Square; is a Turkish symbol of resistance to defend their Cultured Livelihood and Universal Competences..!

Stigma 2012

When women are tortured, raped, imprisoned for been outspoken against injustices, the entire Sudanese society is stigmatized and condemned

Stigma 2011

I’m absolutely provoked..! An Egyptian Muslim-dressed-women Protester been stripped-naked by Egyptian army soldiers in Cairo, on 17th December 2011.. Maybe it was a foolplay, an awful plot or a real drama; but certainly was a Dawn of Chaos..

Welcome with Love..

My Friend: Don't visit unnoticed.. Please put a note, a comment or a follow.. Your amazing journey had brought you here.. I’d love to get to know you.. This is all what LIFE is about..!!

Come or Return..!!

Return (in repentance), return! Whatever you are, return! Even if you are an unbeliever or a Magian or an idol worshipper, return! This court of ours is not a court of despair.Even if you have broken your repentance a hundred times,return!

Rumi

Homosapian

My ancestors were not Apes..

Sorry Mr. Darwin, as the current known Mankind was created from Adam PBUH only 15,000 years ago..!!

HOMO-SAPIAN or Human were investigated to be 90,000 years old on earth, as evolution from HOMO-NEANDERTHALENSIS or Neanderthals..

The conflict between Religion and Science was and still confused as Children of Adam had groomed with existent Homosapians; which was never documented..

This is my own acceptable rationale to explain or resolve..

Regretfully, scientists with religious affiliations are few; which hindered many issues from elaboration.. Where Adam & Eve been on earth? Was Noah's Flood allover earth? What were the attributions of Adam & his immediate Children? Should we distinct Adam's Children from Homosapian?

There are a lot to question..!!

Followers

Stop Violence Against Women

As a Muslim, I’m instructed to be gentle to women, as a Man, I’m obliged by good manners as well, and as a Human, I’m wondering why some men will behave alike psycho animals to them..?? There is a big wrong-thing with those bully-men; and it is time to stop such shame.. Pls support..!

Cafe Sudan...

A Celebration of a Wonderful Country & People.. Click the Picture to Visit..!!