WOW. That chapter was amazing. You have so many creative ideas... I have so many un-creative questions!
What happened to James? Why was he so mad? When, oh, when, oh, when, oh, when will Lily and James get together? What do you mean, 'it was just a drill'???
PLLLLLLLEAASSEE UPDATE SOON!!

OMGOMGOMG update i can't stand it you CAN"T leave it at a cliffie like that i've been waiting and waiting and waiting but i cann't wait any more!! hurry up before i have to hunt you down and squeez the update out of you (hehe only joking )

Well, I was a bit confused on many points. Why are they taking a train to Hogsmeade? The station is in Hogsmeade. Why in the world was James so angry? Where did James go and why hasn't anyone gone to look by the trees? Why was that one chapter with the griffin nearly completely italicised? Why does everyone think James and Lily are going out?
Well, anyway. I don't know if this is honesty one of the best stories I have read, but it's not bad. Be a good author and update for the readers, eh? Hehe.

This is pretty good story so far, and I just finished this chapter. Before I go on, I just want to review to say: "How many titles does this story need?" It starts out as "James and Lily: Hate and Love: Life and Death". Then it goes to "Arrogance and Perfection: Two People, One World", then "James and Lily: Life and Death" then finally "James and Lily: A Series of (Un)Fortunate Events". Oi. It's just seems kinda wierd, that's all. *goes to finish story*

Hmmm. It seems a bit rushed, but I know you wrote this when you were twelve, maybe even eleven, so it's really good for a kid that age. I'm sure the later chapters are better, so I'll keep reading. 6/10