Harrison Schmitt

Harrison Schmitt is a former NASA astronaut and engineer and is currently an Adjunct Professor of Engineering at the University of Wisconsin at Madison. Schmitt was also the Chairman and President of the Annapolis Center for Science-Based Public Policy between 1994 and 1998, and remains "Chairman Emeritus."[1] He was formerly listed as a member of the Board of Directors of the Heartland Institute.[2] He was reportedly the next-to-last person to walk on the moon and is credited with taking the iconic "Blue Marble" photograph of the earth from space.[3]

In 2009 Harrison Schmitt submitted a paper to NASA which claimed the Earth was cooling. It included the claim that Arctic sea ice had returned to 1989 levels of coverage. It has been widely debunked as evidential cherry picking.[6][7]

"In Defense of Carbon Dioxide"

In a two author op-ed piece featured in the Wall Street Journal entitled "In Defense of Carbon Dioxide", Harrison Schmitt and William Happer make the case that excess carbon dioxide is not bringing about detrimental climate change but is in fact necessary and beneficial. The authors criticize global warming theories as they relate to carbon dioxide, stating, "Thanks to the single-minded demonization of this natural and essential atmospheric gas by advocates of government control of energy production, the conventional wisdom about carbon dioxide is that it is a dangerous pollutant." The authors follow with their take on how to interpret scientific evidence on the matter, concluding, "There isn't the slightest evidence that more carbon dioxide has caused more extreme weather."[8]

As a direct response to the claims made and scientific evidence used in this piece, Media Matters for America, a progressive nonprofit watchdog group, published a specific response addressing several points posited in the op-ed. Beginning with a reference to Schmitt and Happer as "authors with no peer-reviewed papers on the topic and ties to groups funded by the oil industry," Media Matters presents contrary evidence to the information in the op-ed, citing work by the Intergovernmental Panel on Climate Change, NASA, the World Bank, the National Research Council, Smithsonian Magazine, the New York Times, Skeptical Science, and several other scientists and academics.[9] This response goes on to expose the authors' history, illustrating their lack of peer-reviewed research on the topic and their ties to the oil industry. Media Matters' profile on Schmitt highlights his former position as Director at the oil industry-funded Heartland Institute. Happer's profile identifies his status as current chairman of the George C. Marshall Institute, a recipient of funding from the oil industry as well as the Koch brothers.

Jack Williams, the director of the Nelson Institute Center for Climatic Research and geography professor from the University of Wisconsin - Madison, where Schmitt serves as an adjunct professor, also responded critically to the piece. "I think they're ignoring the scientific evidence," Williams posits, "...it's a bit of a one-sided perspective on the effects of CO2."[10]

Harrison Schmitt- cherrypicking

Quotations

"Natural warming is clearly happening but there is absolutely no evidence, no observational evidence whatsoever that the increase in carbon dioxide that has been measured in the last fifty years has had anything to do with that"[12]