Is Pyhrra Really Dead

Posts (708)

I just have a funny feeling that Phyrra is not dead. Before Monty died I remember him saying that none of the main 8 ( Team Rwby and Team Jnpr) would die for the first 8 seasons. If RT stick to Monty's words, could this mean that she is not dead?

Also in one of the later episodes in the season, when Cinder, Emerald and Mercury are on the rooftops after they ruin everything, Emerald seemed to feel guilty over what they have done. Is it possible she has turned and Cinder is seeing an ilusion in her fight against Pyhrra? I mean we haven't really seen her or Mercury for a while.

What do you guys think

+21 Cool

schurgy16FIRST Member Star(s)Indication of membership status - One star is a FIRST member, two stars is Double Gold

She may be dead, but probobally not gone. While I don't watch any other anime but this, I know that death is not important or permanent. Yes it is possible that the fight was an illusion but I think Phyrra is not permanently dead. I have 2 theories:

1. Killing Cinder will bring her back.

2. Juane's Semblance can heal/raise the dead.

-I think Juane will find a way or at least try to bring her back in Vol. 4

+7 Cool

mangokattFIRST Member Star(s)Indication of membership status - One star is a FIRST member, two stars is Double Gold

I don't think she's dead. I saw a theory saying that she got teleported somewhere, possibly to the place where Salem is. But the possibility of Cinder seeing an illusion is very likely though. And if Jaune's semblance is healing people that would be pretty great.

I can buy it, why would Cinder disintegrate Pyrrha's body, for bragging rights? Sorry but that doesn't seem like something she'd do. It just seems like a weird thing for her to do and the illusion thing could easily be feasible.

I guess part of me wants to believe she's not dead because of how depressing it is. I know that bad things can happen to good people and that' life, but that doesn't mean I have to like it or accept it in this case unless it's definitively proven otherwise.

In reply to DMortal1There are two ways this can go: If Pyrrha is 'dead, dead' then I hope theyhave it written out well enough to have a VERY noticeable effect as in myopinion JNPR's reaction to her 'death' was a bit weak. In my opinion Rubygrieved harder (although she was the only eyewitness) than Ren andNora. Hopefully there's more to it than what we got in V3.

If's she's 'mostly dead' (yeah I took that from Princess Bride) well that would also make sense in a way. Don't get me wrong, it's not that I can't accept Pyrrha can actually be deceased but I do find it a bit odd that one of only two characters on Team JNPR who actually got characterdevelopment (arguably even more than some members of Team RWBY) gets killed offso early if they planned for 10+ Volumes.

Character deaths can pave room for more development of another (it's been used so many times) but it's rarely another protagonist unless the series is reaching its absolute end.

I agree. While Pyrrha's death is quite an exciting development, it is also quite suspicious with all this other information brought to light. It only makes it all the more interesting if there is more to her death than seems. A good base for more plot twists from our friendly neighborhood Monty Oum?

Number 2 would work perfectly as Juane's high amount of aura give him one special field of abilities. That field being most commonly called, "PALADIN". Warriors of holly light and users of aura to help those around them.

Probably alive if I had to guess, no way he died that easily.....Come to think of it, perhaps maybe he saved Pyrrha somehow. It's possible, he likely knew Pyrrha wouldn't run away and perhaps he did something to help her. I mean we don't know what he can do, so whose to say.

I just have a funny feeling that Phyrra is not dead. Before Monty died I remember him saying that none of the main 8 ( Team Rwby and Team Jnpr) would die for the first 8 seasons. If RT stick to Monty's words, could this mean that she is not dead?

Hey until someone at RT says she's dead, I can dream all I want. Nothing wrong with that, plus that's the fun part about series like this. Leave stuff ambigious to make us speculate and be more eager to see what happens next.

2. Perhaps knows the future and knew he needed to take action elsewhere, namely saving Pyrrha since he would know that Ruby could save everyone with her eye magic. Actually that would make sense, I mean he knew Ruby would probably save them in the end but perhaps orchestrated things so Ruby would think Pyrrha was dead so as to activate her power.

Perhaps Emerald secretly worked for him perhaps all along and that was part of his own plan since he knew even if he beat Cinder that wouldn't stop the dragon. I mean Emerald, Oz, Emerlad city, that can't be a conicidence.

Hey Ozpin certianly seems lie a behind the scenes kind of guy. I mean the whole thing with the Great and Powerful Oz was that he wasn't what he appeared to be. In the story he was a powerless guy using illusions, where was here, he is powerful and all knowing but still does use illusions to an extent.

I mean smoke and mirrors were what the original Oz was all about, whose to say Ozpin isn't the same.

Okay, so lets take a head count here between these two forum threads. One: Monty stated he would not kill off any of the main characters until after volume 8. Two: the voice actor obviously said that to keep the character alive in the fan basis, makes sense in the long run. Three: Juane showed healing abilities during the very first volume.