Twitter user @hawks21david commented “Isn’t she and her fam born-again christians? Why would she sing for the pope?”

This received a reply from Matteo. “Catholic. But it doesn’t really matter what she is. The beautiful part is people are united and at peace,” the boyfriend of Sarah answered.

Then, the said netizen explained that he and Sarah used to be churchmates. “We used to be churchmates when we were young sa saved by grace full gospel church. That was before she joined star for a night (im not sure). I hope she still remembers,” the netizen shared.