Pages

Wednesday, June 6, 2012

Dealing with Plagiarism

This
morning I learned that one of the worst things that can happen to a writer
happened to me. I was plagiarized. My hard work was taken without permission from
me or the site I wrote for. It was posted on another site and passed off as being written by someone else. However, before I continue I want to take a moment to define
plagiarism:

See what I did there with the *? That’s called crediting the
source. If you are going to use word for word, paraphrase or slightly rework something some one else wrote, then it is imperative that you give a source. It’s even
better if you check with that source and get permission before using it, but always credit the source. It’s as
simple as that. This however is not how things happened for me.

As
many of you know, over the past few months I’ve been writing for an online news
site that posts articles and editorials on the latest movies and TV shows. In
the recent weeks, the site I write for discovered that another online TV and
movie site took not one, but dozens of articles, slightly reworked them, posted them on their site
without permission or citation and passed them off as their own work. When I
initially heard this, I was extremely angry and it wasn’t even my articles that
had been stolen. Without ever experiencing it prior, I knew having your work stolen
is heartbreaking.

After
today I can now say I know exactly how it feels and heartbreaking doesn’t even
begin to cover it. This morning I woke up to a tweet that said (and out
of respect for the person that runs the site I work for and the site that has
been stealing I will not cite names.) “By the way XXX site ripped off one of your
articles too. I thought you should know.” After reading that comment I was a bit taken
back, one because I just woke up and two because I was completely shocked that
it happened to me. I couldn’t even spell plagiarism and I haven’t even had the “pleasure”
of being rejected by editors or agents, so how was my work being stolen? The site
stealing the work is a much larger site than the one I write for, so why would
they need to steal from someone else? Maybe they were looking for fresh ideas
or one of the writers really didn’t know what they were doing was wrong.
Whatever the reason, what they did was stealing and I was crushed.

After the swirling questions and emotions, I decided I
wanted to see for myself. Not that I don’t trust the person who told me,
because I do 100%, but because I needed to confirm with my own eyes. So I
logged on to the offending site and began to scour their lists of articles.
Nothing recognizable for pages until….. oh wow that title, and supporting image
looks awfully familiar. I clicked on the article and my heart sank into my
feet. It probably would have fallen into my downstairs neighbor’s apartment if
there wasn’t solid flooring below me. Right there before my eyes was my article
down to some of the exact pictures and formatting with a slight twist of words.
And the stake to the heart was seeing that the author’s name, picture and bio
at the bottom of the article did not belong to me. This was an article that I spent
weeks toiling and agonizing over and finally perfecting until it was just right.
One of the most difficult articles I ever compiled and wrote was stolen, badly
rewritten and said to be authored by someone else. I couldn’t believe my eyes.

After I picked up my jaw off my desk, I wanted to start
hurling things and write nasty comments like This is a great article but I
liked it even better when I wrote it. But I stopped and took a deep breath before
I burst into tears or spontaneously self combusted.

When I finally wrapped my
head around what happened, I started to wonder what one does when this sort of
thing happens. And after some careful consideration, I came up with the
following list:

Take
a deep breath: It’s first important to realize that although this is a horrible
thing that happened to you, you are not alone. There are some things you can
do about it even if you feel powerless and broken.

Do
not act out of anger: Acting on extreme emotion will only make the situation
worse and could mean that you lose all chance of remedying the situation. So
think long and hard before you submit that nasty comment, email, or even
facebook, twitter, or blog post trying to defame the offender. Professionalism is
key.

Document:
Take screen shots or copies of every instance of plagiarism. If it is a website,
don’t rely on the link of a site in case the site is later taken down but do
make sure the link is visible in your screen shots. Then gather your work that
was plagiarized and if possible show proof of dates your work was written. You
will want evidence of every instance of plagiarism and copies of your work to
compare, to ultimately prove that your work was stolen.

If
you are working with an agent, editor, company, or site owner, contact them and
send your evidence. Unless they ask for more information or ask you to do
something specific, let them handle it.

If
you are independent, try contacting the author of the offending article, with a professionally written email
informing them that they have copied content that does not belong to them and
ask that they either remove the content or credit you as the source. Do not get
angry, it’s possible that it was just a case that they forgot or didn’t know.
If you receive a reply back saying they will comply and they do, then your work
is done, but if not see the next step.

If
you are ignored or the person does not act appropriately, try contacting the
manager, site owner, or person in charge of the overall content with a similar
professionally written email informing them of the copied content. Provide your
proof, and information about your correspondence with the author of the
article. Again be calm and polite, the owner or manager may not even be aware
of the issue and if that is the case they may not be at fault. They can however
take action and if they do deal with the issue then you are done.

But
if you are again ignored or met with any other response than compliance, then
it’s time to make a decision. Do you let it go or continue on with this? If
this is something you decide you want to pursue further, you will probably want
to seek out legal representation. Although expensive, they will have more
advice and know the laws. They can help draft a formal cease and desist letter
or seek further action.

While
plagiarism is a horrible thing, in a weird sort of way, I am a little bit flattered. If
someone stole my work it is probably because they liked it enough to try
and pass it off as their own. While that doesn't make it right and I’m still very angry about the whole
situation, I’ve learned a lot from this
experience. You are not immune to the horrible things that can happen to a
writer, even if you are new to writing, and/or unpublished. But you are not
powerless to the situation either. You can choose to let the anger and sadness
of the situation overtake you or choose to rise above it and be the bigger
person, by dealing with the situation in a professional manner. Although my
case is not fully resolved, I know that this is not going to destroy me as a
writer. I am merely choosing to take the backhanded compliment and keep writing in the future, working even harder than before.

Daryl,So sorry to hear you were pirated. I will never understand why people think its ok to steal. Pirating really hurts the author and their sales and could mean they don't get to write more books in the future. Why is it so hard for people to just buy the book or get it from the library if they really want to read it :(

Thanks for you kind words on my advice. I hope you were able to get the pirating links taken down.Jamie

About Me

I'm an aerospace engineer that has been exploring my creative side. I love young adult and middle grade literature, especially science fiction and fantasy. I'm currently writing several science fiction pieces both MG and YA.