i remember ICC... wasnt even in a guild and still managed to be #28 warrior on the realm gear wise and my dps was awsome =P

You're a fine example of how gamer communities have become infested with endlessly whining and bitching, arrogant, opinionated, unreasonable, all the way immature, completely delusional, tendentially psychotic, insulting individuals one really doesn't want to be linked with. And playing with you guys is certainly no fun at all. I don't know where this kind of folks spawns from. Must be a nest somewhere ...

100% armor pen with zero armor pen gems... mmm - however now that I think of it.. I even moreso miss my prot pvping with full armor pen gems and smashing people for 3/4 of their life with a single shield slam.

it was fun but also silly, HS mechanic broke keyboards and armour pen was so insanely OP and bugged people were stacking it beyond what blizz thought was capable. I do miss armour pen as a stat though it feels like its something they could bring back to warrior's only in some way as an extra way to scale or an extra mechanic to make us more interesting, tie it to strength or haste or some crap

It was a fun time and probably the pinnacle of my game enjoyment. I loved our nice of splash damage and the utter domination we had in areas likes splashing Anub's adds or handling LK's valks. It was nice to have our niche, warrior dps have fallen through the cracks a little bit since in terms of having an area they undoubtedly excel at over all others.
One thing I don't miss from back then was the stifling mechanic of threat, pulling bosses halfway through raid encounters and needing to plead for salvs was a bit of a pain and made pugging on my warrior virtually impossible.
ARP and no rage restrictions were great things. Deathbringers will was such a fun and distinctive trinket. So many bosses had splash opportunities which seemed to favour us. Great time to be a warrior.

Outside of raids it was a strange time in the game with the gearscore craze at its peak, owning this axe made me instantly a "name" on my realm and always drew comment in random dungeons. It was a strange feeling really, I think the game community has moved on since to not care as much putting somebody with something rare on a pedestal. Everyone used to inspect everyone back then, you mention the name of somebody to a guildee and quite often they'd know them by their gearscore or a notable mount/piece of gear they had. It was a strange time in the game.

I miss fury at the start of wrath. I loved titans grip fury right at the start of naxx. ARP can go F its self as well I am not a huge fan of the new RNG fury build. I was more pleased with Cata's fury build. Id love to have that style back with the new blood surge.

Wrath is where I started playing I loved Ulduar and ICC was okay, but I liked the epic story beind the LK. Not sure if I really was missing warrior. Fury warriors were very easy to play. Only thing you needed was having the gear really. Aside you could weave in Rend for aditional DPS, but it was only a slight increase. ArP did play a big role, it's too bad they removed it.