Adam LaVorgnaRobbie Palmer

Getty Images

Then: LaVorgna starred as Mary's boyfriend Robbie, whom she met while serving her court-mandated community service. LaVorgna also dated Biel in real life. The couple eventually broke up (both on screen and off) but LaVorgna's character was brought back when Reverend Camden found him homeless and took him under his wing. He then began briefly dating Lucy, who decided having her sister's sloppy seconds was weird.Now: LaVorgna has guest starred on shows like 'Law and Order: Criminal Intent,' 'Cold Case' and 'CSI: Miami.'