No offense intended, Hasan (and none taken either, BTW), but you can't just tell me I "must" watch an hour and a half long video. I didn't watch it a month ago and I'm not going to watch it now either.

If there is a particular claim in the video that you want to discuss, then by all means summarize it and I'll explain to you why it's nonsense; but before I invest an hour and a half of my life on a conspiracy theory, I need some indication that the source is credible. There are so many better things I can do with my time.

No offense intended, Hasan (and none taken either, BTW), but you can't just tell me I "must" watch an hour and a half long video. I didn't watch it a month ago and I'm not going to watch it now either.

If there is a particular claim in the video that you want to discuss, then by all means summarize it and I'll explain to you why it's nonsense; but before I invest an hour and a half of my life on a conspiracy theory, I need some indication that the source is credible. There are so many better things I can do with my time.

My apologies to you Ron, may be I was wrong in saying "must". I think the events of 911 impacted lives of almost every living thing on this planet.
There are some valid questions about this event. Just like a man of reason may want to study facts about holocaust. We should be free to ask questions becasue it is also part of freedom.
There are some valid questions. Like many other people I am not satisfied with what I have heard so far.

1- I remember right after the event, there was a news about unusual stock movement taken place few days before 911. We never heard the follow up on that, was that ever investigated?
2- Israeli PM's visit was cancelled a couple of days before this event, why?

These questions like many others I have I don't find answers to that can be satisfying.

Now as far as questions from this video, I will post just two first:

1-Why was the evidence and all the scrap metal shipped to China for recycling, almost immediately. It was a crime scene and according to the rules, all the evidence has to be preserved and presented before a panel of experts. Why in a haste all of those rules were overlooked and bypassed, was there a motive?
2-Tower seven never got hit by a plane, how was it destroyed as if in a "perfect demolition" according to demolition experts.
Let me hear your response before any further questions.

What makes you to say "it's nonsense"?
Hasan

Edited by honeto - 29 September 2012 at 1:51pm

39:64 Proclaim: Is it some one other than God that you order me to worship, O you ignorant ones?"

1-Why was the evidence and all the scrap metal shipped to China for recycling, almost immediately. It was a crime scene and according to the rules, all the evidence has to be preserved and presented before a panel of experts. Why in a haste all of those rules were overlooked and bypassed, was there a motive?

What does "almost immediately" mean? My recollection is that it took months to clean up the site. But of course they got rid of it as soon as they reasonably could. What would you expect them to do? Leave a smouldering, possibly toxic heap of garbage in the middle of Manhattan indefinitely?

2-Tower seven never got hit by a plane, how was it destroyed as if in a "perfect demolition" according to demolition experts.

Good question. Why do you think it got destroyed? Why would anybody stage a fake terrorist attack on the Twin Towers and then plant explosives in Building 7?

Let me hear your response before any further questions.

Okay, but just for the record I'm not going to get caught up in an endless barrage of crackpot theories and accusations. Just give me your best evidence. You can Google the rest yourself.

What makes you to say "it's nonsense"?

Because conspiracy theories like this are always nonsense. It's just not conceivable that such a widespread and intricate government plot could be kept secret in a democratic and open society. Maybe in totalitarian dictatorships (though even that is doubtful), but not here.

like I mentioned the first 1 and 2 were my own thoughts and your replies to them are same to me as mine were to you.
your answers to other questions, the one that this video deals with you fail to address in a manner I was expecting of you.
1- you know when there is a plane crash even if it is in the middle of the ocean on the botoom of the floor specially if terrorism is involved, they assemble every tinny piece they can find, and they put it together in a secure place to figure out what really has happened. They did not do that, why?
At a crime scene, every piece of evidence is important, therefore when a crime happens they secure it and every evidence until crime scene experts and lawyers have cross examined it. Why in such a big case, all of that was bypassed, who ordered such a bypass of laws?
Why the evidence was shipped overseas as it was cleaned off the site and sorted. All metal was shipped to China for melting before even determining by independent experts the reasons for its crumbling.
2- instead of answering this question you are asking me another question.

It is because of this that I asked you to watch this video. This is not a bunch of conspiracy theorists as you label them before listening to them. These are experts in their fields, physicists, scientists, demolition experts of no ordinary type rather cream of the crop. And not just a few, rather a huge number and growing everyday. It now also includes family members of those who died in this disaster, who after listening to these facts were convinced that the truth need to be explored.
Hasan

39:64 Proclaim: Is it some one other than God that you order me to worship, O you ignorant ones?"

1- you know when there is a plane crash even if it is in the middle of the ocean on the botoom of the floor specially if terrorism is involved, they assemble every tinny piece they can find, and they put it together in a secure place to figure out what really has happened. They did not do that, why?

Because despite your attempt to create one, there is no mystery here. Investigators painstakingly reconstruct crashed airplanes in order to determine the cause of the crash. In this case, the cause is blindingly obvious: even you would agree that the planes were deliberately flown into the buildings. There was no design flaw, no stuck valve, no metal fatigue or pilot fatigue. And besides, the planes were totally incinerated, everything including the metal literally melted or burned beyond recognition. There was nothing left to assemble.

2- instead of answering this question you are asking me another question.

Right, because if you find the conventional explanation improbable, then you must have some more probable explanation, eh? But if you want a direct answer to your question: Building 7 was destroyed by fire after large amounts of burning debris fell on it. There was no demolition. Firefighters knew at least half an hour before the building collapsed that it was about to go down, which is why everyone got out in time. No explosives required.

Okay, your turn. Why would anybody stage a fake terrorist attack on the Twin Towers and then plant explosives in Building 7?

It is because of this that I asked you to watch this video. This is not a bunch of conspiracy theorists as you label them before listening to them. These are experts in their fields, physicists, scientists, demolition experts of no ordinary type rather cream of the crop.

Really? Have you checked their credentials? Give my your best example of a "cream of the crop" expert and we'll see.

You cannot post new topics in this forumYou cannot reply to topics in this forumYou cannot delete your posts in this forumYou cannot edit your posts in this forumYou cannot create polls in this forumYou cannot vote in polls in this forum

Disclaimer:
The opinions expressed herein contain positions and viewpoints that are not necessarily those of IslamiCity. This forum is offered to stimulate dialogue and discussion in our continuing mission of being an educational organization.
If there is any issue with any of the postings please email to icforum at islamicity.com or if you are a forum's member you can use the report button.