The next generation of extremists is being trained in Middle Eastern conflicts, in bigger numbers than before 9/11.
By Anthony Bubalo.

Anthony Bubalo
The new jihadists

These days, the tumult in the Middle East seems to evoke in the West little more than a collective, weary shrug. No one is surprised that the Arab uprisings have failed to transform the region democratically. Nor have the region’s conflicts, and the enormous humanitarian consequences that have resulted from them, provoked much empathy.

But we should care. In fact, we should be worried. For decades, authoritarianism and upheaval have been great incubators of extremism in the Middle East. To understand how serious the current situation is you only need to look back at the conditions in the Middle East in the period leading up to 9/11.

The men that would go on to form al-Qaeda emerged from conflicts between Islamists and authoritarian regimes in the 1980s and 1990s in countries such as Egypt, Algeria and Saudi Arabia. Forced into exile, these extremists fled to other regional conflicts, most notably to Afghanistan, where they found opportunities to enhance their military skills and sharpen their ideology.

These conflict zones eventually became havens from which al-Qaeda’s jihadists plotted a new campaign of violence directed against the West and connected with other like-minded extremists from around the world. It was in Afghanistan in the 1990s, for example, that al-Qaeda built ties with those members of the Indonesian extremist movement Jemaah Islamiyah who would go on to plan the 2002 Bali bombings.

Yet today, the conditions in the Middle East, in terms of the creation of jihadists, are actually much worse than those in the ’80s and ’90s.

In Syria the uprising against President Bashar al-Assad has become a magnet for jihadist groups from around the world. Today there are some 7000 “foreign fighters” in the conflict from more than 50 countries, including 120 to 150 from Australia. By comparison there were never more than 3000 to 4000 foreign fighters in Afghanistan at any one time.

Not all of these foreign fighters, including the Australians among them, are serving with jihadist groups of the al-Qaeda variety. But if even only a small number are fighting alongside the worst extremists it will undo one of the main achievements of the War on Terror era.

In the decade after 9/11, al-Qaeda and its affiliates lost many of their most experienced members who were either captured or killed. Their links with other terrorist groups were also disrupted by the loss of their haven in Afghanistan.

But after three years of conflict in Syria, a new generation of jihadists is gaining military experience, is being trained to make bombs, and is forging personal ties with other jihadists from around the globe.

According to the US director of national intelligence, James Clapper, some groups are setting up training centres in Syria – not for the Syrian conflict, but to train their members for conflicts in their home countries. This echoes what happened in Afghanistan in the 1990s when the country became a training hub for myriad international jihadist groups.

Syria is far from the only problem, however. The fallout from the Arab uprisings has created multiple new conflict zones and semi-governed spaces for jihadists to exploit.

Before 9/11 there was a handful of countries in the wider Middle East where jihadists could operate with relative impunity: Afghanistan, Sudan, parts of Pakistan, Yemen, Algeria and Somalia. Today, most of those countries are still on a list of jihadist havens that has grown to include Syria, Libya, western Iraq, Sinai in Egypt, as well as parts of North and West Africa.

Weapons are also flowing freely across the region, often from looted government armouries. Political unrest has deepened the socioeconomic crisis that in many countries helped cause the uprisings in the first place.

Against this background it is little wonder that many people both inside and outside the Middle East seem to be welcoming the revival of old authoritarian structures. The hope is that a strong hand will bring back stability and contain advances being made by extremist groups under the cover of democracy.

You see this most clearly in Egypt. Last June the military grabbed power in a popular coup after three years of democratic experimentation that led to the Islamist Muslim Brotherhood’s rise to power. The problem is that the military’s move is unlikely to revive the stability most Egyptians crave any time soon.

The military has placed itself on a collision course with the Brotherhood, which it has declared a terrorist group, arresting most of its leadership. The Brotherhood is happy to play the martyr, hoping to win back popular sympathy and to use the instability as leverage with
the military.

The military will ultimately win this confrontation, but at what cost? Younger members of the Brotherhood are already questioning the movement’s hitherto largely non-violent approach to politics. Meanwhile, more extreme jihadist groups are exploiting the confrontational atmosphere that has been created to sow more unrest and gain new recruits.

If you think none of this matters to the West, think again. It is true that this new generation of jihadists is currently focused on events in the Middle East. But we have seen in the recent past how their focus can shift quite quickly from targets in their own countries to targets in the West.

America’s wars in the region during the past decade and a half will linger long in the regional memory. US efforts to stem the flow of jihadists to Syria will bring it into more direct conflict with these groups. The significant number of citizens from Western countries, who will one day return home from these conflicts
with new military skills, gives the situation an added edge.

Three years ago some commentators were rightly heralding al-Qaeda’s struggle for relevance amid the popular uprisings of the Arab world. Today, the regional tumult has created a new pool of jihadists that may end up significantly larger than the one that existed before 9/11. Is it any wonder that al-Qaeda has christened its new English-language magazine Resurgence?

This article was first published in the print edition of The Saturday Paper on
Apr 12, 2014 as "The new jihadists".
Subscribe here.

Anthony Bubalo
is the research director at the Lowy Institute for International Policy.

Karen Middleton
The government ignored security agency advice on amendments to the medivac bill, allowing it to accuse Labor of undermining border security.Pezzullo’s Monday evidence suggests the government was alerted to the repatriation issue well before Labor’s amendments were drafted and it did not act.

Jenny Valentish
Advocates of psychedelic drug research are hoping the psilocybin trial for treating anxiety in the terminally ill, at Melbourne’s St Vincent’s Hospital, is the beginning of a new acceptance for the potential of the field.

Royce Kurmelovs
While the royal commission into aged care has begun by exposing distressing cases of neglect, experts warn that it is the generations currently unaffected – and uninterested – who must become engaged in order for standards to improve.

Katherine Gillespie
Amid the spectacularly divisive response to Kristen Roupenian’s short story about a relationship gone wrong, the author’s conception of “Cat Person” as horror fiction was often overlooked. Here, she talks about reasserting her genre credentials with the release of her debut collection. “The temptation would be to turn the book into 11 stories about dating from the perspective of young women. So I was grateful that editors recognised it was a weird, dark collection of essentially horror stories. They let it be what it was.”

Jennifer Robinson
Despite narrow legal grounds for concealing documents under our freedom of information laws, government agencies routinely refuse to release them. Appeals are long and costly. Final decisions may take years and challenging decisions to refuse access to documents – as in this case – can run to many, many thousands of dollars. The cost is too high for most, and so the information remains hidden and unpublished.

Paul Bongiorno
No longer confident it controls the parliament of Australia, the Morrison government has shut it down for the next six weeks. And no wonder: it is reeling from revelations of cronyism, incompetence and profligate, unaccountable spending. Scott Morrison’s only defence was to accuse Labor of having its head in the “chum bucket”. If he is right, the bucket is his and he will have to do a lot of hard work to expunge the stench before the May election.

Ladislaus Meissner, also known as Joe Meissner, of “Love Boat” notoriety has, after a decent interval, resurfaced. Joe has moved on from his days in the 1980s as secretary of the Enmore branch of the Labor Party and former world karate champion when his putt-putt, the Kanzen, hosted riotous onboard parties, where politicians mingled with even shadier figures. Virginia Perger, a sex worker, said she had slept with the adorable Graham Richardson on board the Kanzen only to withdraw her statement, after much thought.

Perhaps once the Paladin contract story could have toppled a minister. This week, it was almost overshadowed by a parade of other scandals – the 2000 Centrelink robocall deaths; the Helloworld travel scandal; the revelation both Michael Keenan and Michaelia Cash refused to give witness statements to the Australian Federal Police over the Australian Workers’ Union raid tipoffs; the apparent leaking of security advice to The Australian, which was then misrepresented.

As the Federal Court prepares to make a ruling on the AWU raids, and it emerges Michaelia Cash refused to give a statement to the federal police over her office’s involvement, The Saturday Paper reviews the minister’s position to date.

During the ’90s there was barely a glossy magazine that didn’t feature Karl Lagerfeld draped in supermodels. His death this weekoffers a chance to reflect on the fashion powerhouse’s influence on design, style and feminine sophistication.

Peter Hanlon
Trainer Darren Weir’s fall from grace over the possession of electronic shock devices has stunned horse-racing enthusiasts both here and overseas. But could it help efforts to clean up the sport?

Karen Middleton
The government ignored security agency advice on amendments to the medivac bill, allowing it to accuse Labor of undermining border security.Pezzullo’s Monday evidence suggests the government was alerted to the repatriation issue well before Labor’s amendments were drafted and it did not act.

Jenny Valentish
Advocates of psychedelic drug research are hoping the psilocybin trial for treating anxiety in the terminally ill, at Melbourne’s St Vincent’s Hospital, is the beginning of a new acceptance for the potential of the field.

Royce Kurmelovs
While the royal commission into aged care has begun by exposing distressing cases of neglect, experts warn that it is the generations currently unaffected – and uninterested – who must become engaged in order for standards to improve.

Katherine Gillespie
Amid the spectacularly divisive response to Kristen Roupenian’s short story about a relationship gone wrong, the author’s conception of “Cat Person” as horror fiction was often overlooked. Here, she talks about reasserting her genre credentials with the release of her debut collection. “The temptation would be to turn the book into 11 stories about dating from the perspective of young women. So I was grateful that editors recognised it was a weird, dark collection of essentially horror stories. They let it be what it was.”

Jennifer Robinson
Despite narrow legal grounds for concealing documents under our freedom of information laws, government agencies routinely refuse to release them. Appeals are long and costly. Final decisions may take years and challenging decisions to refuse access to documents – as in this case – can run to many, many thousands of dollars. The cost is too high for most, and so the information remains hidden and unpublished.

Paul Bongiorno
No longer confident it controls the parliament of Australia, the Morrison government has shut it down for the next six weeks. And no wonder: it is reeling from revelations of cronyism, incompetence and profligate, unaccountable spending. Scott Morrison’s only defence was to accuse Labor of having its head in the “chum bucket”. If he is right, the bucket is his and he will have to do a lot of hard work to expunge the stench before the May election.

Ladislaus Meissner, also known as Joe Meissner, of “Love Boat” notoriety has, after a decent interval, resurfaced. Joe has moved on from his days in the 1980s as secretary of the Enmore branch of the Labor Party and former world karate champion when his putt-putt, the Kanzen, hosted riotous onboard parties, where politicians mingled with even shadier figures. Virginia Perger, a sex worker, said she had slept with the adorable Graham Richardson on board the Kanzen only to withdraw her statement, after much thought.

Perhaps once the Paladin contract story could have toppled a minister. This week, it was almost overshadowed by a parade of other scandals – the 2000 Centrelink robocall deaths; the Helloworld travel scandal; the revelation both Michael Keenan and Michaelia Cash refused to give witness statements to the Australian Federal Police over the Australian Workers’ Union raid tipoffs; the apparent leaking of security advice to The Australian, which was then misrepresented.

As the Federal Court prepares to make a ruling on the AWU raids, and it emerges Michaelia Cash refused to give a statement to the federal police over her office’s involvement, The Saturday Paper reviews the minister’s position to date.

During the ’90s there was barely a glossy magazine that didn’t feature Karl Lagerfeld draped in supermodels. His death this weekoffers a chance to reflect on the fashion powerhouse’s influence on design, style and feminine sophistication.

Peter Hanlon
Trainer Darren Weir’s fall from grace over the possession of electronic shock devices has stunned horse-racing enthusiasts both here and overseas. But could it help efforts to clean up the sport?