The CDC Can’t Fund Gun Research. What if that Changed?

America doesn't have good data on guns. Blame the Dickey amendment. First introduced in 1996, the legislation didn't ban gun investigations explicitly (it forbade the use of federal dollars in the advocacy or promotion of gun control), but Congress that year also cut the budget for the Centers for Disease Control and Prevention by the exact amount it had previously devoted to firearm research. It's had a chilling effect on the field ever since. (While some states and private foundations are conducting peer reviewed studies on gun violence, the federal government has been AWOL.) That means policymakers in Washington have little information about what causes gun violence, how it can be prevented or reduced, and who is most at risk.

But that could change. The February 14 killings in Parkland, Florida led a bipartisan group of lawmakers to consider repealing the Dickey amendment and resuming government-backed gun-research. Which raises a pressing question: If the CDC were to resume funding studies on the epidemiology of firearm violence, what questions would they want to answer right now?

"We don't know enough about the risk factors, for either the perpetrators or victims of gun violence," says Garen Wintemute, an ER physician and director of the UC Davis Violence Prevention Research Program.

Wintemute says that one of the big predictors of future gun violence is a history of other forms of violence, like domestic abuse. But connecting the dots between prior behavior and future threat is difficult—especially on an individual basis. That said, researchers think that by identifying early signals and studying them more closely, they could help police and social service agents make better decisions about when to intervene.

He also wants to study the psychological impact that high rates of gun violence can have on communities. Does living in place where gunfire or gun violence is common make someone more or less likely to use a gun in the future? Social scientists say they don't know the answer yet.

As for preventing the next mass shooting, experts say they don't know enough about the effectiveness of proposed interventions. Take, for instance, the "gun restraining order" laws recently enacted in California, Oregon and Washington. Such regulations allow family members as well as law enforcement to ask a judge to confiscate guns from people deemed to pose "a serious risk of harm." (In San Diego County, ten gun owners recently received court orders to surrender their weapons under the new law.) It sounds like a good idea in theory, but to expand such laws to other states, or the federal level, policymakers would need to make a case for their effectiveness. And at least for now, the data on whether the laws have a measurable impact on either suicides or murders just doesn't exist.

“There isn’t any information other than anecdotal,” says Shannon Frattaroli, associate professor of health policy at the Johns Hopkins University Center for Gun Policy and Research.

Frattaroli says a key factor, when it comes to studying the effectiveness of firearm policies, is being able to follow weapons. One way to track how violence spreads is by tracing implicated weapons to their source. In big cities plagued by gun violence, these weapons are often bought and sold illegally. "We need to understand where guns are coming from, how they get from the legal market to the hands of people who are prohibited to purchase them," Frattaroli says. "That’s important to know if we want to get a handle on the flow of guns."

Doing so will require a lot more money, time, and resources than researchers currently possess. That’s where the CDC might serve as both a deep-pocketed grant-making agency, as well as a clearinghouse for various databases on gun violence and gun ownership. A boost in funding would also attract more and better scientists to the field, whose numbers have dwindled since the Dickey amendment went into effect. “As I recruit new investigators, it has been a critical question for applicants: 'Will I have a job in a couple years, or will I have to look for a job in another field because there’s no funding,'" Wintemute says.

Social scientist and ER docs like Frattaroli and Wintemute are encouraged by the possibility that Congress might direct the CDC to renew gun research. President Trump’s Secretary of Health and Human Resources, Alex Azar, said the day after the Florida shootings that he backs such efforts. But this shift might take a while. The agency has been without a leader since January, when director Brenda Fitzgerald resigned after news reports that she purchased tobacco stocks after taking office. Any big change in the status quo of the amendment—and more money for gun violence research—will probably have to wait for a change in control of Congress.

Gun Shy

The United States has never funded a research center to study gun violence—so last year, California started one on its own.

BleuPage Pro -> Content FetcherLike a blog in your niche? Want to repost from that blog to your social media networks? Content Fetcher is made exactly for this purpose, just put the FEED URL of your favorite blog and select your social media networks and see the magic unfold.

Video Chief GS AgencyProfit $500 - $1,000 Per Video By Leveraging One of The Largest Library of Pre-Made Videos, Script Templates, VoiceOver Templates And More…Instantly Access Over 1200 High-Converting Templates Spread Across More Than A Dozen Of The Hottest Niches!

Local Animation Studio Promo PackUnlocks your very own instant website to sell your professional animated commercials. Features a working store, customer management system, built in autoresponder, and more. Also includes a special set of 8 additional promotional commercials.

MintsApp 2.0MintsApp is the most innovative software for customer acquisition and engagement in the market

Omega Wealth Club - [Diamond Package]The Omega Wealth Coaching Program - The EXCLUSIVE Coaching and Mentoring Program For Those Who Are Ready To Go From Zero To High 5-figure Income per month within a few months.

Logo Hogg | 1000+ Pro Logo TemplatesLogo Hogg was designed for regular people who want to start making their brands work for them and know that the smart answer is not wasting money on graphic designers, rather getting a complete suite of pro templates that can be edited with the included f

Commission Bullseye SingleCommission Bullseye is a Wordpress plugin that lets you place geo targeted content on your blog. Display Amazon ads for multiple countries, show certain content or ads to targeted locations and more.

SplitEngage SmartAds OfferGet Access to the most Underrated Face Book Marketing Software Available, comes with Ad creation editor, Facebook Ad targeting, and training. Use for ecommerce, ebay, shopify, amazon, affiliate products, and more

NativizeWPThe Fastest, Easiest, And The Most Convenient Way To Create Laser Targeted Content In Your Sidebars And Show It On Related Posts And Pages.

Traffic Trapper PRO VersionGet 10 "Done For You" Templates from two 7-figure copywriters that you can use hand-in-hand with Traffic Trapper.

DesignoPRODesignoPro Lets You Create Unlimited Stunning Designs Using Revolutionary Vector Technology. Extremely simple to use point and click editor. Cloud based software with over 500 templates to start editing from. Never have crappy graphics again with Design