The “Greenlawns” may now be known as a popular fishing hotspot along the west side of Shelter Island — but in the 1800s, they were the epitome of status.

Named after a pair of side-by-side mansions with identically sized lawns, one parcel that was formerly home to one of the original anchor estates — located at 4 Nostrand Parkway — has sold for $1.65 million in a preservation transaction to the Town of Shelter Island.

And as for the neighboring property, 5 Nostrand Parkway, it is now listed for $9.25 million with Penelope Moore, licensed associate real estate broker with Saunders & Associates Real Estate who was also the listing agent for the recent sale.

“After 117 years of being a part of Shelter Island, the O’Connor family felt that preserving the 7.68 acres one block from the bay at 4 Nostrand Parkway would be a lasting gift to the island by recharging the delicate aquifer that supports many households in the area,” Moore said. “Their estate at 5 Nostand Parkway is nearly a museum piece that offers a step back in time, and an idyllic opportunity for old home aficionados.”

Named “Cherry Tree Farm,” the circa-1890 Victorian has retained many of its original characteristics across its 5,431 square feet, including beadboard walls, iron fireplace fenders, woodwork and vintage Beatrix Potter wallpaper in the nursery.

“So many vintage homes throughout the Hamptons have already been renovated and, in the process, the configuration of the rooms is changed and details stripped or replaced altogether,” Moore said. “The proportion of the rooms throughout the house speaks to the fact that in 1890, this was a special property. There are two sections of the home: the main area, which was built for the owners and guests, and separate living quarters, which were built for staff after the turn of the last century.”

Nearly every room in the six-bedroom home features views of the water, from the entry foyer to the living room — its double doors peek out onto the lawn and the sandy beach — to the attic, which has double-height ceilings.

The two-story staff quarters has a living room with a separate entrance, an eating area, and bonus rooms, “reminiscent, in a way, of ‘Downton Abbey,’ including unpainted wooden walls and hand-blown window glass,” Moore said.

“In a corridor, original steamer trunks with the family name stenciled in still sit,” she continued. “Back in the day, steamboats would drop off passengers around the corner on Bootleggers’ Alley, named after Prohibition-era rum runners, and stewards would come by horse and buggy and pick up the steamer trunks to deliver to summer homes and hotels.”

Two generations of family, including a pair of Shelter Island Yacht Club commodores, have enjoyed the home’s L-Shaped, deepwater dock, which has a protective sea wall and an original cabana, with a grandfathered position next to the staircase on the beach.

“The exceptionally wide dock easily supports a sailboat, and just a short distance off the dock is some excellent fishing,” Moore said. “In those days, people walked to the beach in full clothing, then changed into swimsuits in the cabana. They would never have been seen in bathing suits on the lawn!”

For more information on this property, call 631-749-5801 or email pmoore@saunders.com.

In recent months, a variety of rental scams have targeted people looking for housing on the East End. While many renters were able to avoid the schemes after they wised up to what was happening, others have fallen victim. Scammers, who could be from out of state or even in another country, often use online advertisements that make it difficult for authorities to track them down. While police reports are somewhat frequent, arrests related to such scams are rare. As the public and the police catch on to the latest scams, grifters change their tactics. The best defense for renters ... by Brendan J. OReilly

New York State Assemblyman Fred W. Thiele Jr. of Sag Harbor bucked his caucus last week when he voted against legislation to prevent evictions during the COVID-19 crisis. A member of the Independence Party who caucuses with the Democrats, Mr. Thiele said in a statement Monday that the legislation, which ultimately passed the Assembly, was too broad. “As was the case with the 2019 Housing Act, this legislation fails to make a distinction between primary residences and seasonal rentals,” Mr. Thiele said. “The vagueness in these laws could lead to the possibility that a court will interpret these provisions as ...1 Jun 2020 by Brendan J. OReilly

Governor Andrew Cuomo’s moratorium on evictions during the COVID-19 crisis is overlapping with the first summer rental season that landlords are prohibited from collecting rent for a tenant’s entire stay upfront — though whether landlords really cannot get paid in advance is still a matter of debate. Either way, the convergence of the two issues had raised concerns among landlords and brokers alike that laws and executive orders meant to protect renters who are down on their luck can be abused by squatters who have the ability to pay but choose not to. The worry brought about by the state’s ...26 May 2020 by Brendan J. OReilly

A 1.2-acre Wainscott property with a 7,300-square-foot residence that overlooks Wainscott Pond and has ocean views has sold for $10.5 million, according to The Real Estate Report Inc. Built in 1992, the residence at 60 Beach Lane has eight bedrooms and 7.5 bathrooms. The two above-grade levels have a formal dining room, a library, an open kitchen, a dining room and a den. Both the living room and den have double-height ceilings. The finished basement offers a gym, wine cellar and laundry. Also among the amenities are a heated gunite pool and spa. Michael Schultz had the listing for Corcoran. ...25 May 2020 by Staff Writer

A modern estate in Southampton Village that was completed last year recently sold for $18 million, just $1 million shy of its asking price, according to The Real Estate Report Inc. Three separate structures — a main house, a pool house and a guest house — on 1.9 acres total 9,100 square feet. The main house has five bedrooms and 5.5 bathrooms. A double-height living room with a fireplace, a dining area, an eat-in chef’s kitchen and a den are all light-filled through the wall of glass that overlook the backyard. On the lower level, there’s a bar/lounge area, a ... by Staff Writer

We use cookies to improve your browsing experience and help us improve our websites. We and carefully selected third parties use cookies to show you more relevant ads online. By continuing to use our website, you agree to our use of such cookies.