Article Tools

Wouldn’t you love to be “dead broke” the way Hillary Clinton was? With speech and job and book opportunities poised to whisk her to solvency?

Last week, in the ABC News interview that launched her pre-presidential campaign, she lamented how terrible it was to leave the White House in 2001 without a penny in the Clinton family till. Her Oliver Twist remark still bugs me, if only because it was so tone deaf.

At a time when voters are mad at the Washington elite, a paragon of the Washington elite looks pretty stupid when she cries poverty. Because voters might come away thinking, “This woman doesn’t understand our everyday struggles.”

The key moment came when Diane Sawyer asked Hillary about the Clintons’ lucrative speaking fees (Hillary has made $5 million; Bill, $100 million). Hillary replied: “We came out of the White House not only dead broke, but in debt. We had no money when we got there and we struggled to, you know, piece together the resources for mortgages for houses, for Chelsea’s education, you know, it was not easy...We had to make double the money because of obviously taxes, and then pay off the debts, and get us houses and take care of family members.”

OK. For starters, it’s not a good idea to talk about getting “houses,” as in plural. (Even while the Clintons were “dead broke,” they managed to buy a $3 million Washington house and a nearly $2 million Chappaqua, New York house.) Most voters tend to own one or none. I doubt that John McCain did himself any good, back in 2008, when he couldn’t remember how many “houses” he owned.

Secondly, it’s not a good idea to whine about the need “to make double the money because of obviously taxes,” because most voters these days believe that high earners should pay their fair share of taxes. Heck, that’s a Democratic Party principle.

And however “dead broke” Hillary was in 2001, she was uniquely positioned to soar with Bill into the financial stratosphere. She somehow forgot to mention that, in December 2000, she had inked a book advance worth nearly $8 million.

When she’s “dead broke” and struggling to escape debt, she can write best-selling books and deliver lucrative speeches. When the average Joe is “dead broke” and and struggling to escape debt, he takes a second job tending bar or driving a cab — and remains in debt.

Hillary’s remark hasn’t necessarily damaged her prospects because voters don’t necessarily resent candidates for being affluent. FDR was affluent. So was JFK. The money is a problem only when candidates give the impression that they’re out of touch. Mitt Romney hurt himself in ’12 by defending the low taxes he paid on investment income, and by boasting that his wife drives “a couple of Cadillacs.”

Hillary has already tried to make amends — last week, she subsequently said that her original remark could’ve been more “artful,” that she and Bill were “obviously blessed” by their unique status, that “I fully appreciate how hard life is for so many Americans today” — and she may well polish those clarifications in the days ahead. She has also talked about income inequality and the American “dream of “upward mobility.”

But she may still have a problem with the left.

Liberal populists have become steadily more vocal (hello, Elizabeth Warren), more determined to “soak the rich” and assail the special interests. Yet here is Hillary, the presumptive ’16 front-runner, who has long enjoyed close ties to Wall Street, and whose definition of “dead broke” is a tad different from the struggling Democrat’s. Bonding with the left — demonstrating her commitment to the underdog — could be the biggest challenge of her pre-campaign.

We welcome user discussion on our site, under the following guidelines:

To comment you must first create a profile and sign-in with a verified DISQUS account or social network ID. Sign up here.

Comments in violation of the rules will be denied, and repeat violators will be banned. Please help police the community by flagging offensive comments for our moderators to review. By posting a comment, you agree to our full terms and conditions. Click here to read terms and conditions.