If this is your first visit, be sure to
check out the FAQ by clicking the
link above. You may have to register
before you can post: click the register link above to proceed. To start viewing messages,
select the forum that you want to visit from the selection below.

I'm not saying that Cilan and Iris are borring and it's not very the point of that topic. But having an episode about learning what Gary became trough time it's like knowing if Brock is actually a Pokémon Doctor.

This is why I could see them making a new Chronicals series to showcase all the old characters

what i meant was a little change would be very much appreciated..despite you guys all liking cilian and iris..i used to like cilian but then he got stale and boring and pretty much forgotten..iris has always been a meh for me sometimes i like her sometimes i dont

Gary would be intersteing becuase he is no longer ash's rival but rather friend and seeing him interact with the trio and ash interacting wtih him would be very nice

I would love to see either Gary or Paul again. I wouldn't automatically dismiss that it's never going to happen, either. They were major rivals; Paul was quite popular during his stint in Sinnoh, and Gary's reappeared in every arc, save Unova. So I see it as a possibility. As for a reason for them to come back... that's the thing about the writers. They can just make up a reason and leave it at that. Arguably all of Gary's appearances didn't really have much of a purpose, except for the reasons the writers set in motion.

I would love to see either Gary or Paul again. I wouldn't automatically dismiss that it's never going to happen, either. They were major rivals; Paul was quite popular during his stint in Sinnoh, and Gary's reappeared in every arc, save Unova. So I see it as a possibility. As for a reason for them to come back... that's the thing about the writers. They can just make up a reason leave it at that. Arguably all of Gary's appearances didn't really have much of a purpose, except for the reasons the writers set in motion.

I think Paul is more likely given the fact that his popularity is still pretty fresh. We've seen Gary make his re-appearance pretty recently, after all.

even if we don't understand each other, that's not a reason to reject each other. There are two sides to any argument. Is there one point of view that has all the answers? Give it some thought.

^ This is the reason why I like arguing. If I come off as standoffish or overly angry in an argument, don't worry. I'm probably having the time of my life. Whether I agree with them or not, the pokemon fandom has a lot of different opinions, and I love how nobody is afraid to share them.

I think Paul is more likely given the fact that his popularity is still pretty fresh. We've seen Gary make his re-appearance pretty recently, after all.

Well, it's actually been three years since Gary last appeared. Two for Paul.

I'm not saying that actually makes one more likely to appear over the other though. In fact, if I were going to argue someone had better chances of appearing, it would probably be Gary if for no other reason than simply he's had a cameo every single series prior to BW. There's also always a chance to run into him when Ash returns to Pallet, too.

The only thing Paul has going for him right now is the fact that he was mutually popular among fans and the writers.

what i meant was a little change would be very much appreciated..despite you guys all liking cilian and iris..i used to like cilian but then he got stale and boring and pretty much forgotten..iris has always been a meh for me sometimes i like her sometimes i dont

Gary would be intersteing becuase he is no longer ash's rival but rather friend and seeing him interact with the trio and ash interacting wtih him would be very nice

I don't like Iris either but to call them stale while Gary's been in the series since Kanto is a little funny don't yah thinkXD I'd find Paul better to return than Gary, I just always loved that rivalry more and he'd knock Ash down a bit for getting in the top 8.

A close family member of mine died today, I put this in my sign as respect for him

Well, it's actually been three years since Gary last appeared. Two for Paul.

I'm not saying that actually makes one more likely to appear over the other though. In fact, if I were going to argue someone had better chances of appearing, it would probably be Gary if for no other reason than simply he's had a cameo every single series prior to BW. There's also always a chance to run into him when Ash returns to Pallet, too.

The only thing Paul has going for him right now is the fact that he was mutually popular among fans and the writers.

I think his popularity could be enough for the writers is the thing. As people stated earlier in the thread, Gary's reintroduction didn't really create hype. Paul appearing again, would create a huge amount of hype. Gary could easily return again, but his role isn't going to be anywhere near as big as it was before.

even if we don't understand each other, that's not a reason to reject each other. There are two sides to any argument. Is there one point of view that has all the answers? Give it some thought.

^ This is the reason why I like arguing. If I come off as standoffish or overly angry in an argument, don't worry. I'm probably having the time of my life. Whether I agree with them or not, the pokemon fandom has a lot of different opinions, and I love how nobody is afraid to share them.

I wouldn't mind him making an appearance, but he really doesn't have a purpose on the show anymore.

On the other hand, I do feel like there are some things Paul could do in a return (not the least of which is wiping the floor with every trainer at the Unova League). Ash needs someone to push him to be better, and I don't think anyone did that better than Paul.

Defeated Super Single Subway Master Ingo - August 19th, 2013

Searching for: Litwick - Near Perfect IVs, Manetric (Shiny) - Good IVs, Switcheroo
Can offer high IV'd Bagons, Digletts, and Darumakas, as well as DWs, Pokerus, and more, PM me if interesting in negotiating.

Gary's appearance in DP was more or less... underwhelming*. Especially for his lack of appearances in all of Hoenn and Kanto BF (up to the last episode). I suppose they wanted to give him a shot; and he didn't receive so much support. But it was still nice of Gary to have his original voice actor throughout the episodes in AG/DP.

I dunno about BW specifically, but at least in the near future? Sure, why not? I mean, he's important to Ash, and so it would make sense for them to meet up, see whatever cool Pokemon Gary's researching, have a battle for good ol' times sake. Now what I'd really love is for Gary to go back to Pokemon training, I mean it seems silly that he'd just decide he didn't want to be the very best after Ash beat him. I think he was stronger as a character with competitive spirit.

I am the current leader of Save Our Voice Actors, a Pokemon fan group supporting the voice actors in the anime dubbed by 4Kids (seasons 1-8). Our goal is to provide The Pokemon Company international with encouraging feedback in support of returning the main cast members. If you're interested, please visit us at facebook.com/saveourvoiceactors

It kinda saddens me to see how so many more people like Paul than Gary. I mean yes I am a Gary fangirl but...Gary is Ashes childhood friend, his "true rival". That's a really big status. Paul is just some random dude that he just became rivals with. How does that make Pauls "better" than Gary. Gary is much more influential on Ash than any other character. He's been the drive for most of his different trips to different regions. He made Ash become stronger. Everyone tends to forget that Paul, in my eyes, was just meant to replace Gary -and they did a cruddy job at it-

I dunno. I guess its just sad to see people say "Gary sucks, Paul is better" when Gary IS Ash's "true rival". You really can't deny that. They may have become friends but they have always been rivals. Ok so your argument is they aren't rivals anymore, but they grew up together. So with "him not being a rival anymore" they still have a huge role in each other that Gary is the person Ash knew for the longest time. Childhood friend is a status Paul will NEVER fill. And I really feel that's why Gary is just, more than Paul will ever equate to. He was a good rival, but he wont have the impact that Gary did. Paul and Ash hardly had the development Ash and Gary did. And even Paul himself. He was a jerk Pokemon trainer that was harsh on his Pokemon. Gary may have been annoying but he wasn't a dink all the time.

I would at least enjoy a cameo. Or something to acknowledged his existence. Hes just kinda gone now, and with how significant of a character he is its almost kinda insulting to him. Dawn got episodes for peets sake. I know a lot of people are going to call me bias because, well, I am. But there's really no reason why he can't have a cameo or like 1 episode where he fights Ash again. As compared to Dawn's what like 9.

I dunno i'm bias and just want Gary back. Its the reason I stopped watching anyways.

This thread is random lol. Why should Gary come back again in Unova. Tbh, all of you Gary fans should've been glad that he actually got an episode during DP. Gary is just a "Tracey" now, researching... researching... researching... and Oak'd. He can come to Unova to help his grandfather's research, but the same reason can be applied to Gen 6, or Gen 7, or Gen 8, or Gen 9... and so on and so forth.

Dawn is special because she's a PokeGirl. Gary isn't a girl, so no 9-episode-arc for him.

I'd rather see Paul help Ash with the transition to Gen 6, since he's more recent. Gary's days for a 9 episode arc are over. The most I see is a small Gen 6 transition, but I personally think Paul should have the merits for that.

EDIT: Also, people are free to choose Paul or Gary over the other, so don't force your bias down their throats. I like Paul.

I wouldn't mind. Personally him and Ash having another battle where Ash wins would be much appreciated.

Proud claimer of Cyndaquil and Ezio Auditore from Assassin's Creed !!
Also proud claimer of Assassin's Creed 2 the game!!
Just became the proud claimer of the Marvel's Agent's of S.H.I.E.L.D. TV show ^_^!!!

The thing is Garys based on an in game NPC. There's always the possibility of him appearing in a future game. If that happens a cameo is quite possible. I doubt he will return in Unova, but after that, its to soon to tell

I thought being on his character of "Blue" in the PWT will give us a hint, but I think I'm wrond on this line. The return of Charizard makes me think that Gary could return, but with the place that N and Charizard are taking actually, if Gary has a cameo, I bet it will be of Ash's return to Kanto, like after Hoenn Kanto Battle Frontier. *sigh*
I don't know how Professor Oak and Gary could make some researches on the new Pokémon if they are actually not in the region. Was it sepcified that Gary won't move of Kanto, or any region else ?

Last edited by The Prince of May; 19th January 2013 at 2:01 PM.

« New beginnings are often disguised as painful endings. » *I will be completely absent from March 22nd to April 5th.

Why would they waste time bringing back a character that flatlined during his last appearances? Look at Charizard for example. Fans have been going crazy since his return confirmation.

I personally have no sentiment to Charizard returning... So I can honestly say that they're wasting time with a character that flatlined during a battle with a Dusclops.. -.-

I liked Gary's role in DP.. He was very much getting on with his travels and studies, whereas we can now see that Ash is just failing along.. Looker's back as well.. He didn't get much more spotlight in DP, yet he's back again..

And you're making it seem as if bringing back Gary for three to four episodes would be a bad thing.. It's not.. Gary brings out the better side of Ash, and the last time I checked, Ash doesn't have any side to him now.. Talk about flatlining..._____________________________________ _____

Originally Posted by DawnBoy

I doubt he, or any of the past characters from the past series will return in Unova now. I'd rather see Paul or Barry over Gary anyways.

Because Barry was just that great of a rival.. Wait what? Oh yeah, people still mistake Barry for being Ash's rival, when he was more inclined to be a rival to Paul in every way, and only opposed Ash as a 'rival' because Ash smacktalked about Paul's treating of Chimchar, and Barry couldn't take it because he thought that Paul was the greatest trainer evah...

Paul I can understand, since he had things he would be doing and it would be cool to see the results of that, but I'd rather see Gary.

Originally Posted by AceDetective

The thing is Garys based on an in game NPC. There's always the possibility of him appearing in a future game. If that happens a cameo is quite possible. I doubt he will return in Unova, but after that, its to soon to tell

He's in the PWT, it's not too far a stretch.

Originally Posted by Ver-mont

Professor Oak can't send Charizard, since it isn't in its Lab, it's in Johto.

But Oak can send Gary to Johto, to fetch Charizard, and then go to Unova.. -.-

Answer to all the bad things in the world: Give up on trying to make everything better. Hence, accepting it for what it is. YOLO! <- Click the link and daw.. -.-