Thanks Gregg.
You interpreted my earlier email better than I did - sorry!
Yes, I think it is only Production 8 that is the offender.
As an encouragement, I think it would then mean that there was more compatibility between N3 and turtle, which is the intention, of course.
Nice to see all this progressing to Recommendation - thanks to the team.
Hugh
On 10 Sep 2012, at 23:44, Gregg Kellogg <gregg@greggkellogg.net> wrote:
> \On Sep 10, 2012, at 9:59 AM, Hugh Glaser <hugh.glaser@seme4.com> wrote:
>
>> Hi,
>> Sandro has asked on the SemWeb list if there are any comments on Turtle syntax.
>> I raised an issue (forwarded below) a few years ago, but it looks to me like the syntax is still the same.
>>
>> I would like the syntax to allow comma and semicolon as a terminator (and thus also to be compatible with N3).
>
> Production 7 does allow a statement to end with a semicolon:
>
> [7] predicateObjectList ::= verb objectList (';' predicateObjectList?)*
>
> However, production 8 does not allow this:
>
> [8] objectList ::= object (',' object)*
>
> It would be fairly easy, and would allow exactly the same form as 7, to just make it objectList ::= object (',' object?)*, or even objectList ::= object (',' objectList?)*. Either of these would create more recursive parser states and are certainly not optimal, but that's not really the standard for publishing normative grammars. I could go either way on making this change.
>
> Gregg
>
>> Hopefully the message is still sufficiently explanatory, but please ask if you need elaboration.
>> Best
>> Hugh
>>
>> On 10 Jan 2008, at 02:25, Tim Berners-Lee <timbl@w3.org> wrote:
>>
>>> Oh, I completely understand why -- that's indeed why N3 has it.
>>> (I have sed files for generating N3 -- very practical. Don't tell anyone.)
>>> Mind you, I have always been generating pred-object pairs,
>>> so I have used the ability to end in a semicolon, not a comma.
>>>
>>> Tim
>>>
>>> PS: IIRC Pascal and Algol has the same problem. See e.g.http://www.lysator.liu.se/c/bwk-on-pascal.html "Pascal, in common with most other Algol-inspired languages, uses the semicolon as a statement separator rather than a terminator". Just because I shave it off doesn't mean it ain't grey ;-) Ee bah gum, when I were a lad, were would be lucky to even *have* semicolons, ... ;-)
>>>
>>> On 2008-01 -09, at 14:33, Hugh Glaser wrote:
>>>
>>>>
>>>> This was going to be a quick confirmation on N3 and turtle syntax for ';'
>>>> and ',', but seems to have got a bit complicated.
>>>>
>>>> I want to write
>>>>
>>>> @prefix owl: <http://www.w3.org/2002/07/owl#> .
>>>> <http://southampton.rkbexplorer.com/id/person-00021>
>>>> owl:sameAs <http://citeseer.rkbexplorer.com/id/resource-CSP109020> ;
>>>> owl:sameAs
>>>> <http://dblp.rkbexplorer.com/id/people-1726e6ee8fb20c8704f47285949b39b3-d101
>>>> 32da488b7179a8b1844f88470032> ;
>>>> .
>>>>
>>>> Similarily:
>>>> @prefix owl: <http://www.w3.org/2002/07/owl#> .
>>>> <http://southampton.rkbexplorer.com/id/person-00021> owl:sameAs
>>>> <http://citeseer.rkbexplorer.com/id/resource-CSP109020> ,
>>>> <http://dblp.rkbexplorer.com/id/people-1726e6ee8fb20c8704f47285949b39b3-d101
>>>> 32da488b7179a8b1844f88470032> ,
>>>> .
>>>>
>>>> That is:
>>>> <#pat> <#age> 24; <#eyecolor> "blue"; .
>>>> and
>>>> <#pat> <#child> [ <#age> 4 ], [ <#age> 3 ], .
>>>>
>>>> Looking at the syntagmata in (1) and (2), my reading is that I can do this
>>>> for ';', although they have different structures:
>>>> N3 seems to do it by the possibility of () for propertylist.
>>>> Turtle seems to have an explicit optional ';' (in rule 7).
>>>>
>>>> On the other hand, for ',':
>>>> N3 seems to do it by the possibility of () for objecttail.
>>>> However, I don't think I can do the same in turtle, as rule 8 in (2) lacks
>>>> the extra (',')?
>>>>
>>>> (I would have downloaded the yacc grammar for N3 and tried it for real, but
>>>> the link on (3) to the yacc grammar gives 404, by the way.)
>>>>
>>>> So the question is: have I got something wrong?
>>>> If not, then to use the second, ',', construct, I need to use N3, not
>>>> turtle.
>>>> So some questions are:
>>>> Is this what is intended, rather than an omission?
>>>> If so, why?
>>>> It seems a bit strange that such simple N3 is not compatible with turtle.
>>>>
>>>> (1) http://www.w3.org/2000/10/swap/grammar/n3.n3
>>>> (2) http://www.dajobe.org/2004/01/turtle/#sec-tutorial
>>>> (3) http://www.w3.org/DesignIssues/Notation3.html
>>>>
>>>> PS
>>>> And if you want to know why, it is because I want to generate a load of
>>>> sameAs triples. It is a common problem for program (and other) generators
>>>> not to want to know you are generating the last item in a list, and simply
>>>> treat the ';' or ',' as terminator, rather than separator. This can be
>>>> achieved by allowing null productions (as N3 above), or an explicit optional
>>>> (as turtle ';'), or by actually making it a terminator, although then you
>>>> tend to end up with ';;;' in the code.
>>>> And you can't put it at the front of each output either, otherwise you need
>>>> to treat the first item in the list specially.
>>>> (For the grey beards among us, this is why generating something like Algol68
>>>> was more of a pain than generating Pascal!)
>>>>
>>>> Best
>>>> Hugh
>>>> --
>>>> Hugh Glaser, Reader
>>>> Dependable Systems & Software Engineering
>>>> School of Electronics and Computer Science,
>>>> University of Southampton,
>>>> Southampton SO17 1BJ
>>>> Work: +44 (0)23 8059 3670, Fax: +44 (0)23 8059 3045
>>>> Mobile: +44 (0)78 9422 3822, Home: +44 (0)23 8061 5652
>>>> http://www.ecs.soton.ac.uk/~hg/
>>>>
>>>>
>>>>
>>>
>>
>> --
>> Hugh Glaser
>> Chief Architect
>> Seme4 Limited
>> 18 Soho Square
>> LONDON
>> W1D 3QL
>> Mobile: +44 7595334155
>> Main: +44 2070601590
>>
>> hugh.glaser@seme4.com
>> www.seme4.com
>>
>> Seme4 - the experts in semantic web and linked data applications
>>
>> Notice of Confidentiality. This e-mail message (including any attached
>> documents) is proprietary and confidential to Seme4 Limited and/or its
>> affiliates and may contain legally privileged information. It is intended
>> for the named recipient(s) only. If you are not the intended recipient,
>> you may not review, retain, copy or distribute this message and we ask you
>> to notify the sender immediately, then delete this message from your
>> system. Thank you for your cooperation.
>>
>>
>
--
Hugh Glaser
Chief Architect
Seme4 Limited
18 Soho Square
LONDON
W1D 3QL
Mobile: +44 7595334155
Main: +44 2070601590
hugh.glaser@seme4.com
www.seme4.com
Seme4 - the experts in semantic web and linked data applications
Notice of Confidentiality. This e-mail message (including any attached
documents) is proprietary and confidential to Seme4 Limited and/or its
affiliates and may contain legally privileged information. It is intended
for the named recipient(s) only. If you are not the intended recipient,
you may not review, retain, copy or distribute this message and we ask you
to notify the sender immediately, then delete this message from your
system. Thank you for your cooperation.