Bad dog! When should you shoot a canine?

Bad dog! When should you shoot a canine?

Submitted by:
PoliceOne Senior Editor Doug Wyllie

How many times have you withdrawn your firearm, trained it on a human subject, and pressed the trigger? How many times have you had to withdraw your firearm, train it on some four-legged creature running amok in your jurisdiction, and put the beast down? For many cops, the answer to that first question is either “none” or “one” or some other very low number. For many cops — depending on where you work — the answer to that second question can be considerably higher.

An Iraqi police officer takes aim before shooting a stray dog in the Mansour neighborhood of Baghdad. Obviously, this would not happen in the United States, but sadly, a great many canines are killed each year by officers who simply have not been given the training or understanding they need to avoid disposing of a dog. (AP Photo)

Now, I’m not talking about what my friend and colleague Dick Fairburn calls the “Noah’s Ark Massacre” which took place in Ohio last month — although I have asked him to write a serious column addressing the issue as a result of a humorous conversation we’d had on the subject. Nor am I talking about events like the one in which San Francisco cops ended the Christmas Day 2006 rampage of a 243-pound Siberian tiger named Tatiana, or the one this past weekend in which officers felled two abattoir-bound bovines in the Canadian community of Masson-Angers, or the one reported just today in which an unidentified Douglas County (Calif.) sheriff’s deputy accidentally shot a black bear with a live round rather than a rubber bullet.

Sure, these things happen — and, in fact, clearly happened — but the breed of animal most commonly in an officer’s sights is a canine. Yes, man’s best friend can be a cop’s worst headache.

Late last week I had occasion to connect with a gentleman named Troy Kechely, who has authored a very interesting book entitled Management of Aggressive Canines for Law Enforcement. Having reviewed some of the pages of his work, and discussed some of its concepts with him, I’m eager to share just one of the “tips” I discovered.

Read a dog as you would a human, because that dog is definitely reading you! Understand that dogs are highly communicative, and that they not only communicate through their own body language — through movement and positioning of the head (eyes, mouth, ears), back, legs, and literally all the way to the tail — but they are also very perceptive about the gestural movement and physical stance of humans. Furthermore, says Kechely, a canine’s reading of you incorporates a number of other senses in addition to sight.

That rule of human communication “it’s not what you say, it’s how you say it” applies very well during interaction with a potentially aggressive canine. While it’s estimated that dogs only “understand” a little over a dozen words, they are finely attuned to tone of voice, so the tone with which you speak can have a significant effect on a dog.

“Interestingly, human tones convey many of the same meanings or intent as with dogs,” writes Kechely. “Low tones in the canine world typically denote aggression, correction and dominance behavior, whereas high tones denote play — excited, friendly behavior. But also bear in mind that high tones also denote injured prey and can trigger or amplify prey aggression at the wrong time.”

Finally, we all know that dogs have an incredible sense of smell, and that humans tend to emit a unique odor when experiencing fear... so yeah, they can smell your fear.

Down the road, I’ll share some excellent ideas Kechely has on topics such as:

For the time being, please add your own ideas on this subject in the comments area below. Perhaps together we can amass a catalog of concepts to ensure that the number of dogs put down by police officers is limited to those animals which truly are a threat.

You must enable JavaScript in your browser to view and post comments.

PoliceOne comments can only be accessed by verified law enforcement professionals.
Please sign in or register to view or write your own comments below.