Price Discrimination: Exercises Part 2

Transcription

1 Price Discrimination: Exercises Part Sotiris Georganas Royal Holloway University of London Problem 1 An economics journal is considering offering a new service which will send articles to readers by . There are two types of potential users, students and professors. Let x denote the number of articles requested by a user. The professors have an inverse demand function p 1 (x) = 1 x and the students have an inverse demand p (x) = 8 x. The marginal cost of sending articles to users is zero. (a) Draw the demand functions. (b) Suppose that the journal can identify the type of use (professor or student). It decides to offer a plan where users can buy a fixed number of articles for a fixed price. What price-quantity combination will the journal offer to each type of user? (c) Now suppose that the journal cannot observe which type any given user is. The journal continues to offer two packages. Suppose that it offers one package which allows up to 8 articles (intended for students) and one package that allows up to 1 articles (intended for professors). What is the highest price that students will be willing to pay for the 8-article package? What is the highest price that the journal can charge for the 1-article package if it offers the 8-article packages at the highest price the students are willing to pay? In this situation, what is the consumer surplus obtained by a professor? (d) Suppose now that the journal decides to restrict the number of articles in the package intended for the students to 6. What is the most the journal could charge for a 6- article package and still get the students to buy it? How much consumer surplus would the professors get from buying this 6-article package? What is now the most the journal could charge for the 1-article package and still get the professors to choose this package? (e) Suppose that there is an equal number of students and professors in the population. Would the journal make larger profits by offering the 8-article or the 6-article package to the students? Solution Problem 1 1

2 (a) Start by drawing the demand curves p 1 (x) = 1 x p x (b) If the journal can identify each user type, then it will first-degree price discriminate. This will involve offering each type of user a package where the quantity is such that the marginal willingness to pay equals the marginal cost. Hence the journal will offer a package that allows up to 1 articles to professors and a package that allows up to 8 articles to students. (In fact, since the marginal cost is zero, the journal could in this case equally well offer unlimited access.) It will charge the professors their entire willingness to pay which is the area under the demand curve from x = up to x = 1. The size of this area is P1 1 1 = = 5 Similarly, it will charge the students their total willingness to pay for 8 articles P = 8 8 = 3 (c) If the journal continues to offer the 8-article package, then the highest willingness to pay for this package by students is still P = 3. In order to work out how much the journal can charge for the 1-article package and still get the professors to choose that package, we first characterize the gross surplus obtained by the professors if they choose the 8-article package. Note that this gross surplus is the area between the two demand curves between x = and x = 8. Formally, this area is 8 ((1 x) (8 x)) dx = 8 dx = 8 dx = 8 = 16

3 Hence, the professors will only choose the 1-article package it it offers a gross surplus of at least 16. We know that the total willingness to pay, by professors, for 1 articles is 5. Hence if the journal charges P 1 = 5 16 = 34 then a professor will obtain the same surplus from buying the 8-article package at the price P = 3 as from buying the 1-article package (d) If the journal restricts the low-quantity package to at most 6 articles, then the most a student would be willing to pay for a package corresponds to the area under the demand curve between x = and x = 6, i.e. P = 6 (8 x) dx = 3 The gross consumer surplus obtained by a professor from buying the low-quantity package corresponds to the area between the two demand curves between x = and x = 6, i.e. 6 ((1 x) (8 x)) dx = 6 dx = 1 The journal can now price the 1-article package at the price that leaves a professor with a gross surplus of 1. Since a professor s total willingness to pay for 1 articles is 5, the journal can now price the 1-article package at P 1 = 38. (e) Suppose now that there is an equal number of students and professors. For simplicity we can think of there being one student and one professor. (If there are N of each, the profits for the N case will just be N times that obtained when N = 1.) Moreover, since marginal costs are zero, we simply need to compare the total revenue in each case. With an 8-article package intended for the students, the student is charged P = 3 while the professor is charged P 1 = 34. Total revenue/profits are then P 1 + P = = 66 When the low quantity package is restricted to 6 articles, the journal charges the student P = 3 and charges the professor P 1 = 38. Total revenue/profits are then P 1 + P = = 68 3

4 which is obviously higher. Note the properties of the solution. The quantity sold to the low-demand group i.e. the students is distorted downwards. Hence for this group there monopoly generates an allocative ineffi ciency. For the professors, there is no allocative ineffi ciency at the optimum the marginal willingness to pay equals the marginal cost. However, the professors obtain some positive consumer surplus. Note also that the price is non-linear in that the price paid per article is 5 by students while it is only 38 by professors. In effect the monopolist is simply offering a non-linear price scheme from which users can self-select a package. The following figure illustrate the two packages and shows how the average price is lower at the 1-article package than at the 6-article package. y x Problem A software company is selling two products: product A (a wordprocessor) and product B (a spreadsheet). The boss of the company is contemplating a marketing strategy that involves bundling the two products together and selling the pair of software products for one price. Suppose that, at present, the company is selling product A at a price of $ and it is selling product B at a price of $5. A survey of 1 people who purchased either of these products last year showed that there were three groups of customers. 1. people bought both.. 4 people bought only product A; they would have been willing to pay up to $1 for product B. 4

5 3. 4 people bought only product B; they would have been willing to pay up to $1 for product A. Assume that new customers have the same characteristics as the surveyed group. Assume also that the marginal cost of producing extra copies of either product is zero; similarly, the marginal cost of creating a bundle is zero. (a) Assume that the company offers the products separately as well as bundled. What is the highest price that the company can set for the bundle and still induce group (the word-processor users) to buy it? What is the highest price that the company can set for the bundle and still induce group 3 (the spreadsheet users) to buy it? (b) What would be the company s profits on a group of 1 users if it priced the bundle at $3? What would be the company s profits on a group of 1 users it priced the bundle at $35? If the company were to offer the bundle, what price should it set? (c) What would profits be without offering a bundle? Should the bundle be offered? (d) Suppose that the company worries about the reliability of the survey. It is clear that there are three groups with the above characteristics. However, the company believes that, out of 1 people, t are of type 1 while (1 t) / are of type and (1 t) / are to type 3. Calculate profits as a function of t assuming that the firm does not bundle. What are profits with the bundle? At what values of t would be be unprofitable to offer the bundle? Solution Problem It is useful to formalize the problem a bit. Let v j i denote the willingness to pay by a consumer in group i = 1,, 3 for product j = A, B. Note first that by buying, the consumers in group 1 reveal they have a willingness to pay for product A that is at least $ and a willingness to pay for product B that is at least $5; hence we know that v1 A and v1 B 5. Consumers in group are willing to pay v A for product A and v B = 1 for product B. Consumers in group 3 are willing to pay v3 B 5 for product B and v3 A = 1 for product A. Let p A = denote the price of product A and let p B = 5 denote the price of product B (bought separately). Let p denote the price of a bundle. (a) Suppose now that the company offers a bundle in addition to selling the products 5

6 separately. By buying only product A, consumers in group obtain a consumer surplus of v A p A = v A. Consumers in this group will prefer to buy the bundle if doing so generates a higher consumer surplus. Hence if v A + v B p v A p A or if p v B + p A = 1 + = 3. The corresponding calculation for group 3 goes as follows. By buying only product B, consumers in group 3 obtain a consumer surplus of v3 B p B = v3 B 5. Consumers in this group will prefer to buy the bundle if doing so generates a higher consumer surplus. Hence if v3 A + v3 B p v3 B p B or if p v A 3 + p B = = 35. (b) Suppose now that the company offers the bundle at the price p = 3. What product will a consumer in each group buy? Consider a consumer in group 1. This consumer will clearly buy the bundle. We know that a consumer in this group is willing to buy each product when not bundled; hence v1 A p A and v1 B p B and the total surplus to a consumer from this group from doing so would then be v1 A + v1 B p A p B By buying the bundle, the consumer can obtain the surplus v1 A + v1 B p > 6

7 which is a larger surplus since p = 3 < p A + p B = 45. Consider a consumer in group. This consumer will also buy the bundle. We know that, ignoring the bundle, this consumer will only buy product A leading to the surplus v A p A. When buying the bundle at the price p = 3 the consumer is exactly as well off since, by construction of the price p, v A + v B p = v A p A. Finally consider a consumer in group 3. This consumer will also buy the bundle. We know that, ignoring the bundle, this consumer will only buy product B leading to the surplus v3 B p B. When buying the bundle at the price p = 3 the consumer is strictly as well off since p = 3 is less 35 that consumers in this group would, at most, be willing to pay for the bundle. Formally v3 A + v3 B p v3 B p B since p v A 3 + p B = 35. Hence all 1 consumers choose to buy the bundle at the price p = 3 leading to the total revenue Π p =3 = 1 3 = 3 Suppose that the price of the bundle was increased to 35. Proceeding as above it is easy to see that consumers in group 1 and 3 would choose to buy the bundle (the latter being indifferent between the bundle and buying only product B); however, since the price p = 35 exceeds what the consumers in group would, at most, be willing to pay consumers in group would choose to buy only product A (at the price p A = ). Hence revenue/profits would be Π p =35 = ( + 4) = 9. 7

9 or, equivalently, as long as t The following figure illustrates revenue/profits as a function of t. The solid line are profits from not bundling. The dashed line are profits from bundling at p = 3. (The dotted line are the profits from bundling at the higher price p = 35 which is hence not optimal for any value of t.) y x 9

Commerce 295 Midterm Answers October 27, 2010 PART I MULTIPLE CHOICE QUESTIONS Each question has one correct response. Please circle the letter in front of the correct response for each question. There

Do not open this exam until told to do so. Department of Economics College of Social and Applied Human Sciences K. Annen, Fall 003 Final (Version): Intermediate Microeconomics (ECON30) Solution Final (Version

Ecn 100 - Intermediate Microeconomic Theory University of California - Davis December 10, 2009 Instructor: John Parman Final Exam You have until 12:30pm to complete this exam. Be certain to put your name,

SCHOOL OF ECONOMICS AND FINANCE THE UNIVERSITY OF HONG KONG ECON60 MICROECONOMICS PROBLEM SET NO.3 COMPETITIVE MARKETS AND MONOPOLY This problem set contains short-answer (true, false, uncertain) problems

ECON 500 Microeconomic Theory Econ 500 - Microeconomic Analysis and Policy Monopoly Monopoly A monopoly is a single firm that serves an entire market and faces the market demand curve for its output. Unlike

Questions of this SAMPLE exam were randomly chosen and may NOT be representative of the difficulty or focus of the actual examination. The professor did NOT review these questions. MULTIPLE CHOICE. Choose

While a competitive firm is a price taker, a monopoly firm is a price maker. A firm is considered a monopoly if... it is the sole seller of its product. its product does not have close substitutes. The

Monopoly Chapter 15 Monopoly While a competitive firm is a price taker, a monopoly firm is a price maker. Monopoly u A firm is considered a monopoly if... it is the sole seller of its product. its product

8.1 Setup Monopoly is a single firm producing a particular commodity. It can affect the market by changing the quantity; via the (inverse) demand function p (q). The tradeoff: either sell a lot cheaply,

ECO 300 Fall 2005 November 10 MONOPOLY PART 1 INTERPRETATION Literally, just one firm in an industry But interpretation depends on how you define industry General idea a group of commodities that are close

WRITTEN PRELIMINARY Ph.D. EXAMINATION Department of Applied Economics University of Minnesota June 16, 2014 MANAGERIAL, FINANCIAL, MARKETING AND PRODUCTION ECONOMICS FIELD Instructions: Write your code

Chapter 3 Basic Monopoly Pricing and Product Strategies Industrial 1 Introduction A monopolist has the power to set prices Consider how the monopolist exercises this power Focus in this section on a single-product

Basics of Economics Alvin Lin Principles of Microeconomics: August 2016 - December 2016 1 Markets and Efficiency How are goods allocated efficiently? How are goods allocated fairly? A normative statement

ECON 115 Industrial Organization 1. Tonight is a calculus review. 2. And a review of basic microeconomics. 3. We will do a couple of problems in class. First hour: Calculus Thinking on the margin. Introducing

Chapter 7 Pricing with Market Power 7.1 Motives and objectives Broadly The model of perfect competition is extreme (and hence wonderfully powerful and simple) because of its assumption that each firm believes

Market structures Why Monopolies Arise Market power Alters the relationship between a firm s costs and the selling price Charges a price that exceeds marginal cost A high price reduces the quantity purchased

Sloan School of Management 15.010/ 15.011 Massachusetts Institute of Technology Economic Analysis for Business Decisions FINAL EXAMINATION (Tuesday, December 18, 2001, 9:00 a.m. to noon) Directions: This

Monopoly Monopoly occurs when there is a single seller of a good or service. Despite this simple definition that is usually given in textbooks, we must criticize it a bit. Monopoly occurs when there is

Instructions: Econ 001: Midterm 2 (Dr. Stein) Answer Key Nov 13, 2007 This is a 60-minute examination. Write all answers in the blue books provided. Show all work. Use diagrams where appropriate and label

In this session we will look at monopolies, where there is only one firm in the market with no close substitutes. For example, Microsoft first designed the operating system Windows. As a result of this

Foundation Course in Managerial Economics- Solution Set- 1 Final Examination Marks- 100 Section I (20 questions; 1 mark each) 1. Which of the following statements is not true? a. Societies face an important

Welfare economics part 2 (producer surplus) Application of welfare economics: The Costs of Taxation & International Trade Dr. Anna Kowalska-Pyzalska Department of Operations Research Presentation is based

Third degree price discrimination Welfare Analysis Third-degree rice discrimination and welfare Does third-degree price discrimination reduce welfare? not the same as being fair relates solely to efficiency

Chapter 28: Monopoly and Monopsony 28.1: Introduction The previous chapter showed that if the government imposes a tax on some good that there is a loss of surplus. We show a similar result in this chapter

Price = The Interaction of Supply and Demand WEDNESDAY, FEBRUARY 17 THURSDAY, FEBRUARY 18 Chapter 4: Section 1 Understanding Demand What Is Demand? Markets are where people come together to buy and sell

Q.1 Distinguish between increase in demand and increase in quantity demanded of a commodity. Q. 2 Given price of a good, how does a consumer decide as to how much of that good to buy? Q. 3 A consumer consumers

Midterm #2 Practice Multiple Choice Questions: Elasticity is a. a measure of how much buyers and sellers respond to changes in market conditions. b. the study of how the allocation of resources affects

1 Economic Efficiency Efficiency is one of the most important concepts in A Level Economics. There are two aspects to economic : allocative and productive. Confusingly, there are many types of. Learn definitions

1. Welfare economics is the study of a. the well-being of less fortunate people. b. welfare programs in the United States. c. the effect of income redistribution on work effort. d. how the allocation of

Imperfect Competition 6.1 There are only two firms producing a particular product. The demand for the product is given by the relation p = 24 Q, where p denotes the price (in dollars per unit) and Q denotes

January 13, 2010 This work is licensed under the Creative Commons Attribution-NonCommercial-ShareAlike 3.0 License. Profit Maximizing Auctions Last time we saw that a profit maximizing seller will choose

Lecture 21 & 22 A new equimarginal condition First Second The efficient allocation of a resource at one point in time, the case of surface water. Third - The MNB to every user should be equal at the efficient

ECON 251 Exam 2 Pink Use the table below to answer the following four questions The table below shows Harry s total utility from consuming beer and wine. The price of beer is $2 per bottle. The price of

Consumer Choice Introduction Managerial Problem Paying employees to relocate: when Google wants to transfer an employee from its Seattle office to its London branch, it has to decide how much compensation

Economics 101 Spring 2015 Answers to Homework #5 Due Thursday, May 7, 2015 Directions: The homework will be collected in a box before the lecture. Please place your name on top of the homework (legibly).

Micro Chapter 6 -price ceiling or price cap: government regulation that makes it illegal to charge a price higher then a specified level -effects of the price cap on the market depend on whether the ceiling

BA 210 Exam 1 Version A Dr. Jon Burke This is a 100-minute exam (1hr. 40 min.). There are 8 questions (12.5 minutes per question). The exam begins exactly at the normal time that class starts. To avoid

Demand, Supply, and Price The amount of a good or service that we demand, the amount of a good or service that suppliers supply, and the price of a good or service all affect one another. Let's examine

Market structure 1: Perfect Competition The perfectly competitive firm is a price taker: it cannot influence the price that is paid for its product. This arises due to consumers indifference between the

McPeak Lecture 10 PAI 723 The competitive model. Marginal willingness to pay (WTP). The maximum amount a consumer will spend for an extra unit of the good. As we derived a demand curve for an individual

ECONOMICS ASSIGNMENT CLASS XII MICRO ECONOMICS UNIT I INTRODUCTION 1. What is the Slope of PPC? What does it show? 2. When can PPC be a straight line? 3. Do all attainable combination of two goods that

Econ 2113: Principles of Microeconomics Spring 2009 ECU Chapter 12 Monopoly Market Power Market power is the ability to influence the market, and in particular the market price, by influencing the total

3 Supply and Demand: CHAPTER Theory Markets and Prices A market is any arrangement that enables buyers and sellers to get information and do business with each other. A competitive market is a market that

ECO 220 Intermediate Microeconomics Professor Mike Rizzo Second COLLECTED Problem Set SOLUTIONS This is an assignment that WILL be collected and graded. Please feel free to talk about the assignment with

Why do monopolies charge different prices to different customers: price discrimination: eg mobile phone tariffs) We have previously seen how a monopolist chooses his profit maximising output - Which is

Microeconomics I. Antonio Zabalza. University of Valencia 1 Lesson 7: Consumer s surplus 7.1 The concept of consumer s surplus The demand curve can also be interpreted as giving information on the maimum

What is price discrimination? Price discrimination or yield management occurs when a firm charges a different price to different groups of consumers for an identical good or service, for reasons not associated

Exam Name MULTIPLE CHOICE. Choose the one alternative that best completes the statement or answers the question. 1) Which of the following statements is correct? A) Consumers have the ability to buy everything

It is most beneficial to you to write this mock midterm UNDER EXAM CONDITIONS. This means: Complete the midterm in 2.5 hours. Work on your own. Keep your notes and textbook closed. Attempt every question.

FIRST MIDTERM EXAMINATION ECON 200 Spring 2007 STUDENT'S NAME: STUDENT'S IDENTIFICATION NUMBER: DAY AND TIME YOUR SECTION MEETS: BEFORE YOU BEGIN PLEASE MAKE SURE THAT YOUR EXAMINATION HAS BEEN DUPLICATED