Why I’m Not Buying Cheap BHP Billiton Limited

I’ve never quite been able to figure out mining companies. While most companies that suffer a tumble in their share price can be seen as good value and contrarian buys, I have been wary of buying into the recent crash in the share prices of mining companies.
It’s true that mining shares have had an awful 12 months, with commodities such as iron ore and copper crashing in price, and mining shares falling in sync with this.

Keep Reading

Register by giving us your email below to continue reading all of the content on the site. Soon you will also begin to receive our FREE email newsletter, The Motley Fool Collective. It features straightforward advice on what’s really happening with the stock market, direct to your inbox. It’s designed to help you protect and grow your portfolio. (You may unsubscribe any time.)

We will use your email address only to keep you informed about updates to our web site and about other products and services that we think might interest you. The Motley Fool respects your privacy! Please read our Privacy Statement.

I’ve never quite been able to figure out mining companies. While most companies that suffer a tumble in their share price can be seen as good value and contrarian buys, I have been wary of buying into the recent crash in the share prices of mining companies.

It’s true that mining shares have had an awful 12 months, with commodities such as iron ore and copper crashing in price, and mining shares falling in sync with this.

The end of the mining boom

BHP Billiton‘s (LSE: BLT) (NYSE: BBL.US) recent results seem to bear out my scepticism. Its profits are down by 31%, as it suffers the effects of the fall in commodity prices.

Although the P/E ratio of 12 looks cheap, and the dividend yield of 3.8% quite reasonable, my question is: where is the growth? I don’t have a satisfactory answer to that question.

Emerging markets, from India and China to Brazil and Russia, are clearly slowing. And their growth is now rebalancing towards a consumer boom that is gathering pace, and an increased focus on services rather than manufacturing.

While China is still the workshop of the world, more and more it is producing high-value-added products rather than the cheap and cheerful products of yesterday. Much of the infrastructure of China’s cities has already been built. All this points towards a decreasing reliance on metals and minerals.

However, I would temper this scepticism with the fact that other regions of the world, particularly the so-called frontier markets, are still growing apace. Can places such as Africa, Mexico and Vietnam take up the slack from China? Perhaps.

A nuanced picture

So, I don’t foresee a return to the boom years of mining, but I suspect there will be echoes of this original boom. I think that the demand from frontier markets will put some sort of floor under commodity prices, preventing them from crashing inexorably.

Overall, the picture is quite subtle and nuanced. I certainly wouldn’t rule out investing in mining companies.

But, personally, I can find better prospects for growth elsewhere. For me, there is too much uncertainty clouding future earnings. Because of this, although BHP Billiton looks cheap I, for one, will not be buying.

Our growth pick of the year

Although I am not recommending investing in BHP Billiton, there is one company that our resident investing experts feel really could make the difference to your portfolio.

This is a growth share that just seems to keep growing. This is a company that has very successfully blended traditional skills with new technology.

Looking for a low-cost Share Dealing service?

Our preferred partner, interactive investor, offers all the knowledge, tools and information you need to be a confident investor. Whether you’re looking for an everyday trading account, making the most of your ISA allowance or planning for your retirement, they provide great value for money, through simple, fair and clear charges, so it’s easy to work out what it costs to invest.