For the 2012 prom, each of the Prom Committee members were hell-bent on having their idea put forward. This feud was most likely the result of each of the members being from rival social groups in Overland Park. Mackenzie thought it should be a Hawaii themed prom, Shay wanted an "Under the Sea" prom and Judith wanted to go with an "All Dogs Go to Heaven" prom.

The drastically different ideas led to a compromise being made and the final result was an "All Dogs Go to Heaven Under the Sea in Hawaii" themed prom. Mackenzie's boyfriend Steven Carmichael mentioned that it is "quite a unique theme for a high school prom."