A famous private investigator (Mike Starr) sticks his nose into Gibb's (Mark Harmon) case involving the discovery of the body of a Navy officer who vanished in 2002, and whose family is offering a reward for answers regarding his death

A woman (Danica McKellar) claims she witnessed the murder of a sailor in the apartment across from hers, but there's no evidence to prove it happened. Still, McGee (Sean Murray) has a gut instinct that she's telling the truth.

A petty officer (Hilary Salvatore) with psychological problems claims monsters are after her, and Gibbs' (Mark Harmon) gut tells him she's in real trouble, especially when his investigation is stonewalled by the FBI.

The skeletal remains of a woman are found in the storage locker of a soldier who was killed in Iraq and is being recommended for a posthumous Silver Star, but evidence suggests he may be the woman's killer. Directed by James Whitmore Jr.