"I need my land, not money."

Deprived of their lands, unable to find any kind of
work, the female sharecroppers of Singur are today looking at bleak
days ahead. Government compensation may come, but it may be too little
and a poor substitute for a life-sustaining livelihood.
Aparna Pallavi
has more.

Till about a year back, 50-year-old Shankari Bagal had never known want. She lost her husband many years back, and some four years back her son also died, leaving behind a wife and three small children. But
Shankari and her daughter-in-law had together continued to earn a decent living by cultivating the four bighas (local measure - three bighas is roughly equal to one acre) of rich four-crop land that they were sharecropping. (Landowner allows sharecroppers to cultivate the land in return for a share of the crop produced on the land.)

The roof, as it were, came crashing over Shankari's head when this land acquired by Tata for its now infamous car factory at Singur. "I used to always have heaps of paddy in my
court yard," says Shankari. "We used to take two crops of paddy, apart
from potatoes, vegetables and groundnuts. But now we have to think
twice for every handful of rice we decide to cook."

Sharecropper Shankari Bagal with her family. Pic: Aparna Pallavi.

Women in Singur are no strangers to farming. Especially among
sharecropping families, women and girls regularly participate in
farming activities to save labour costs, and are as skilled in
agricultural work as their male counterparts. "Since the law grants
sharecroppers permanent cultivation rights in West Bengal, and since
the rent for the land is also reasonable  25 per cent of the produce,
it is not uncommon for women to go on cultivating a piece of land
successfully in case of the husband's death, and the family's economic
status does not change very much due to the man's death," says
Anuradha Talwar of the Paschim Banga Khet Majoor Samiti, an
organisation of agricultural labourers.

But for the female sharecroppers of Singur, everything changed after
the now wellknown Tata car project entered the scene. Along with some 12,000 land owners
(numbers estimated by the West Bengal Industrial Development Corporation's status report on
the Singur project), the land
acquisition for the Tata factory has displaced a large
number of unregistered
sharecroppers out of livelihood. Government figures put the total
number sharecroppers on the acquired land at 407, of which
unregistered sharecroppers
are 170. But estimates by organisations
like the Nagrik Mancha and Sanhati Udyog put the numbers
of unregistered sharecroppers at not less than 1,200 families, of which roughly
8 to ten per cent are women-headed households.

In Shankari's village of Dobandi alone, 90 families of unregistered
sharecroppers have lost their livelihoods. Of these, 12 women-headed
households have been the hardest hit, and seven such families in this
village are now on the brink of starvation. One elderly woman, Bimala
Khamaru, has already died of starvation.

"Employment is available anything between five and seven kilometres away. Older women
like me cannot commute so far, and younger married women have children
and homes to take care of."

Dobandi is located adjacent to the land acquired by
the Tatas.
The 90 families in the village are all landless, and had been
sharecropping on land close to the village for generations. All of
this land has now been acquired by Tata, leaving the villagers without
a livelihood. While the men have found casual employment as
agricultural labourers -- of course the wages are very low compared
to what they earned as sharecroppers, the women have all been forced
to remain home.

The reason is simple, says Satyabala Patra, who has
also lost her three bighas of sharecropping land, "Employment is
available anything between five and seven kilometres away. Older women
like me cannot commute so far, and younger married women have children
and homes to take care of." Satyabala's only daughter is now
supporting her mother on a wage of Rs.30 per day, for which she has to
commute 30 kms every day. "How will I ever get my daughter married?"
she asks worriedly.

Durga Bairagi, aged 67, used to actively take part in the farming
activities on her family's five bighas of sharecropping land along
with her two sons and two daughters-in-law until the acquisition for
the Tata project. "Our father-in-law died young, and she farmed the
land and brought up her three children all by herself," says her
daughter-in-law Jayanti. "Up until last year she used to go to the
farm every day and supervise and keep track of every activity." But
after the land was taken away, Durga is a skin-and-bone wreck. "We used to be five workers in our
house," she says in a quavering voice, "but now only my two sons work.
The Rs.80 per day that they earn after commuting 15 kms is not enough
to feed our family of 12."

All these women, whose economic status has undergone such a drastic
change due to the land acquisition, were originally not deemed eligible for
any kind of compensation. As per the West Bengal government's status
report on Singur, sharecroppers have to be paid 25 per cent of the
total compensation for land, including crop compensation. But this
compensation is reserved only for sharecroppers who are registered
with the government. Says Swapan Ganguli of the Singur Krishi Jami
Rakkha Committee, "According to the law sharecroppers in West Bengal
have to be registered with the government. But given the excellent
relations between land-owners and sharecroppers in the Singur area,
many had not bothered to register themselves, and are now left with no
support."

According to Ganguli, no proper survey of sharecroppers in the
area was done before the land acquisition. "While the government's lie
that most of the land was taken by consent was nailed after owners of
367 acres of land filed an affidavit in court stating that their land
was taken without their consent, the bargadars, as sharecroppers are
known in this area, were not consulted at all. Even the numbers of
sharecroppers was heavily downplayed in the status report."

But the government's thinking seems to have evolved. The collector of Hooghli district,
Binod Kumar, now says that the government is offering unregistered bargadars
compensation at par with registered ones. He says that they are now conducting field
inquiries, as there are no records. According to Kumar, around 360-370 unregistered
bargadars have applied for compensation till date and they will be compensated at
par with registered bargadars after the completion of field inquiries to confirm
the authenticity of their claims. He expects the process to be completed in a month.
No special provisions, he said, had been made for female-headed sharecropping
families.

Artabal Das with her daughter. Pic: Aparna Pallavi.

Atrabala Das, another unregistered sharecropper, says that the
economic difference made by the land acquisition is huge. Atrabala's
two bighas of land used to yield 100 sacks (50 quintals) of potatoes
every season, apart from paddy and vegetables. "Today, even a year
after the land was taken, I have some paddy and potatoes left from our
previous crop," says she, "I do not know what I and my daughter will
do after that stock is finished."

Whether or not the unregistered female sharecroppers of Singur will
finally get any kind of compensation will also depend heavily on how the
political situation in the area will turn out. But do they want
compensation in the first place?

Atrabala says that even if they were given compensation, the amounts would
be too meagre. The government rate of compensation for land in Singur, after
several revisions, stands at a little above Rs.8 lakhs per acre at present,
which, according to locals, is substantially below the market price. Atrabala
notes that a sharecropper will be entitled to just 25 per cent of this
amount, which is too low to sustain them for the rest of their life. "I
need my land, not money. It was the land that sustained us. If I had a son,
I could have sent him anywhere to work. We would at least not have starved. But my daughter
is young. How can I send her to work among strangers? How does the
government expect us to survive? Should we all commit suicide?"

Deprived of their lands and livelihood, unable to find any kind of
work, the female sharecroppers of Singur are today looking at bleak
days ahead.

Aparna Pallavi11 July 2007

Aparna Pallavi is a journalist based in Nagpur, and writes on development issues. She is working on 'The Feminine Face of the Vidarbha Agrarian Crisis' under a National Foundation for India fellowship.

Ramakrishna Kandula
Government should never allocated agriculture land for projects/ SEZ's. But only they should allow banjar/ non-agriculture land.
There are more stories like this in across India. We know india is shining with all investments and SEZ's in place, but not at the cost of poor/ middle class people Shankara Bagal.

July 11 2007, 7:11 PM ·
0 ·
0

CAPT.NAVTEJ SINGH
Government should pay at least 3 times the market price for land acquired for commercial projects so that owners do not feel cheated, and there is no bitterness towards the authorities and developers.

November 19 2007, 11:38 AM ·
0 ·
0

India Together offers an excellent forum for people from diverse fields of expertise to present their views, share their experiences and raise questions about where our country and society are headed in the future.

Amitabha Basu

Retired Scientist

National Physical

Laboratory

India Together reader

India Together offers an excellent forum for people from diverse fields of expertise to present their views, share their experiences and raise questions about where our country and society are headed in the future.

I urge all democratic-minded individuals to road, contribute to and publicise the e-newsletters from India Together. All power and success to India Together staff for their excellent and vital contribution to our society!