A White House proud of being tough is looking for more people to pardon

When Alice Marie Johnson, a 63-year-old grandmother serving life in prison for drug trafficking, was granted clemency by President Trump on June 6, a phone call went out from the White House counsel’s office — the administration wanted more people like her.

On the receiving end was Mark Holden, general counsel and senior vice president at Koch Industries, who has advocated for prison reform. He reached out to Amy Povah, the founder of CAN-DO, a nonprofit organization that advocates for prisoners, and took her names, along with lists from other organizations, to the White House.

Holden met separately with White House counsel Don McGahn and Jared Kushner on June 8. Holden received the impression they will look at additional cases of possible injustice involving convictions for nonviolent crimes.

“Generally, [Trump’s] really interested in the issue, just like he has been with prison reform,” Holden said. “He sees it as a way to deal with injustice and help people improve their lives.”

Trump has said he has “3,000 names” he is considering for clemency. Povah said she’s not sure where the president got that number, but she knows her names have gone straight to McGahn.

Among those names is Tanesha Bannister, who was sentenced to life in prison in 2004 after being convicted of conspiracy to sell crack cocaine. She was resentenced after appealing the decision and received 23 years in 2008.

Since her incarceration, Bannister, 43, has lost her mother, father, brother and sister. If released, she said the first thing she’d do is visit their graves.

“I would tell them how much I love and miss them dearly,” she said, “apologize for not being there, and to let them know the woman I’ve become, and from that day forward I would live my life to make them proud.”

Bannister is a remnant of President Barack Obama’s Clemency Initiative. Under the initiative, which was announced in 2014 by Deputy Attorney General James Cole, clemency applications that met six criteria would be prioritized. Obama wanted to specifically target and commute sentences of nonviolent drug offenders.

Tanesha Bannister was raised in South Carolina and is being held in Texas. (Photo: CAN-DO)

In August 2016, then Deputy Attorney General Sally Yates made a promise: the DOJ would make a recommendation to Obama on every clemency petition from a drug offender.

As a result, the department looked over more than 16,000 requests for clemency. But when Obama left office, there were still over 11,000 pending petitions in the Office of the Pardon Attorney (OPA).

“In the end, the system failed,” Bannister said. “I got looked over and left behind by the Obama administration.”

Out of the Clemency Initiative came Clemency Project 2014, which was made up of nongovernment affiliated lawyers and legal organizations. CP14 vetted thousands of applications and wrote and submitted over 2,600 clemency requests to the OPA.

Bannister had never considered clemency before and wanted to avoid the hurt of being denied. But she was hopeful for clemency when CP14 started. She met all the criteria and was a nonviolent drug offender.

In Obama’s last days in office, the administration released the final list of prisoners who were granted clemency. Bannister’s name was not on it.

“Honestly, I felt like I had been resentenced all over again,” she said. “My days had become long, dark and gloomy.”

The thousands of names still pending in the system when Obama’s tenure ended carried over to the Trump administration. At the time of his inauguration, and for months after, there didn’t seem much likelihood that the new administration, which made a fetish of being “tough” on crime and in general opposed anything done by its predecessor, would have much interest in granting clemency to prisoners.

Mark Osler, a law professor at the University of St. Thomas who runs a commutation clinic, told the Atlantic almost a year after Trump took office that “clemency is going nowhere in the Jeff Sessions DOJ.”

“Some of these people are bad dudes,” he said. “And these are people who are out, they’re walking the streets. Sleep tight, folks.”

And yet now, two years later, the president seems to have taken an interest in criminal justice issues, including prison reform, clemency (a reduction in sentence) and pardons (reversing a conviction).

President Trump speaks during a meeting on prison reform at the White House on Jan. 11. (Photo: Saul Loeb/AFP/Getty Images)

In January, Holden attended a meeting in the White House attended by Trump, Sessions, Kushner and other activists about prison reform and said the president was open to it.

“What really resonated with the president in that meeting was when someone told him that the people who will benefit from prison reform,” he said, “these are the forgotten men and women, the voiceless men and women that you campaigned for and their families and them, are the ones who elected you, and they’re the ones that need help.”

There’s a formal process for getting a clemency petition to the president’s desk. It first must be approved by the Office of the Pardon Attorney, under the guidance of the deputy attorney general. If the request meets their approval, the OPA will provide a recommendation for the president. Afterward, it is sent to the office of the counsel to the president. The president will then either accept or deny it.

But Trump doesn’t seem interested in the formal route. Johnson, who was serving a life sentence for a first-time drug conviction, was granted clemency after Kim Kardashian intervened with Trump on her behalf. Author Dinesh D’Souza was pardoned for election-law violations after Texas Sen. Ted Cruz asked the president to consider it. The late boxer Jack Johnson was given a posthumous pardon for a sexual offense (prosecuted under the racist judicial system of the early 20th century) on the recommendation of actor Sylvester Stallone.

Arizona Sheriff Joe Arpaio, convicted of violating a court order against racial profiling by his office, was pardoned by Trump on his own initiative. Arpaio is now running for the Senate.

Alice Marie Johnson, left, with her daughter Katina Marie Scales on June 7, the day after she was released from prison. (Photo: Adrian Sainz/AP).

Osler said bypassing the process will strain the resources of the White House legal staff. But he called the current clemency system redundant and needlessly bureaucratic.

“The way that you’re supposed to bring something to the president’s attention is to file a petition with the pardon attorney,” he said. “And if everyone’s going to try to jump around that, it’s just going to create a giant jam in a different place.”

But Holden said he’s glad that the White House is bypassing the DOJ, which is staffed by career prosecutors.

“I like that they’re reaching out to advocates and others just beyond the DOJ channels,” he said, “with no disrespect to the Department of Justice in any way, shape or form, I just think it’s good to get information from different groups.”

If the formal process didn’t bring results for those remaining from CP14, the informal process that Trump seems to favor may be to their benefit. LaVonne Roach, 52, is still holding hope that she’ll be next.

“Honestly, he has surprised me,” she said, “and has set off a shock through the prison system, I’m sure.”

LaVonne Roach is being held in California, but will reside in North Carolina when she is released. (Photo: CAN-DO)

Roach, who has been denied clemency at least three times, is serving 30 years for conspiracy to distribute meth. Her release date is six years away.

“I will never forget my past,” she said. “I broke society’s laws and acted immorally, but I will use my mistakes for building blocks to advocate to help make positive changes for my grandchildren, our future generations. I have paid my debt to society.”

Michael Pelletier, 62, was caught transporting marijuana over the Canada border to his home state of Maine. CP14 denied his case, since he had not served 10 years when he submitted his application, a criteria of the initiative. By the time Obama left office, Pelletier had served 10 years.

Michael Pelletier is being held in Indiana. (Photo: CAN-DO)

Maine has since legalized medical marijuana and is expected to have recreational marijuana available in spring 2019. Canada recently took steps to legalize marijuana as well.

Bannister, Pelletier and Roach all said they are optimistic about their chances for clemency under Trump.

“If justice prevailed for those of us who have been buried alive with draconian sentences,” Roach said, “these gates would open and the suffering would be over and tears of joy now would be shed as we reunited with our families. Families would be families again.”