NPH and Burtka – who has guested on ‘HIMYM’ multiple times, as Lily’s ex-boyfriend Scooter – have been the subject of surrogate pregnancy rumors before. In fact, just last September Harris dismissed talk that they were planning a family, though he did tell New York Magazine, “We’d make very good parents.”

“We yin and yang very well,” Neil also said of their relationship. “I’m his forever protector, and I’m happiest when he’s happy.”