Questions and Answers on the Action Plan on
the Protection and Welfare of Animals

What are the objectives of the Action Plan?

The overall aim of the Action Plan is to set out timetabled measures that
will be taken by the Commission to promote animal welfare over the next 5 years.
Taking into account experience already gained in this field, both at EU,
international and national level, and considering discussions held with a wide
spectrum of stakeholders and international organisations, the Commission has set
out the following primary objectives for the Action Plan:

To give a clearer direction to EU animal welfare policies

To continue the promotion of high animal welfare standards

To provide better focus for the allocation of resources

To support future trends in animal welfare research

To continue to seek alternative solutions to animal testing

To ensure a more consistent and coordinated approach to animal welfare
across all EU policy areas

What are the main initiatives to
improve animal welfare foreseen in the Action Plan?

The Action Plan identifies 5 broad areas for action in the field of animal
welfare for the 2006-2010 period:

Upgrading minimum standards for animal protection and welfare

Giving high priority to promoting policy-oriented research and the
application of the “3Rs” principle (replacement, reduction and
refinement of the use of animals in experiments) to animal testing

Introducing standardised animal welfare indicators

Ensuring animal handlers and the general public are more involved and
informed on animal welfare issues

In a
table annexed to the Action Plan, the Commission outlines planned specific
actions to improve the protection and welfare of animals, some of which are
already underway. These include: a proposal to update the current legislation on
the inspection of farms (2006); work to establish a European Centre-Laboratory
for animal welfare and a Community Reference Laboratory for the validation of
alternative testing methods (2006); a revision of the existing rules on animal
welfare at the time of slaughter and killing for disease control purposes
(2007); the possible establishment of a European Quality Standard for products
emanating from high animal welfare standards (2010).

What is proposed with regard to minimum standards for animal
welfare?

Minimum general standards are already set for the protection and welfare of
farm animals at EU level, with specific rules for certain species (see below).
However, the Action Plan proposes that this legislation needs to be updated in
line with latest scientific knowledge, practical experience and progress in
international fora in advancing higher standards. It also suggests that the
minimum standards should be extended to cover species and issues currently not
adequately provided for under EU legislation. The Commission is also currently
preparing a proposal to revise and update the existing legislation on the
protection of animals used for experiments and other scientific purposes.

What is foreseen for research in this area?

The Action Plan clearly states that any measures taken in relation to animal
welfare at EU level must be founded on a solid scientific basis, provided
through research. Moreover, if there is a lack of information needed to develop
appropriate policies, research should be prioritised to address this gap. The
7th EU Research Framework Programme (FP7), currently being finalised
by the Commission and foreseen to run from 2007-2013, integrates animal welfare
into its thematic action on Food, Agriculture and Biotechnology. Further
consideration is given to animals used for research in 4 of the 9 themes:
Health; Food, Agriculture and Biotechnology; Environment; and Nanosciences,
nanotechnology, materials and new production technologies. Animal welfare
related research is also being carried out by the Joint Research Centre, in
particular with regard to the “3Rs”.

What would be the potential role of a new European Centre for the
Protection and Welfare of Animals?

The Action Plan lays down the possibility for a European Centre or Laboratory
for the protection and welfare of animals. This would have an important role in
coordinating and stimulating research in the area of animal welfare, while also
acting as a “centre of excellence” for the collection and exchange
of information and best practice. The Centre could be involved in the setting up
of the new animal welfare indicators and an EU label for animal welfare.

What action is proposed in relation to animal testing?

Around 10 million animals are used annually for research and testing,
including tests on foods and medicines. Certain provision is made for the
protection of experimental animals in EU Directive 86/609/EEC, but updated
scientific information and increasing public concern on this issue have
highlighted the need for stronger action in this area. The Commission is
currently preparing a revision of this Directive to ensure that animals used in
experimentation receive appropriate care and humane treatment. Furthermore in
1999, the EU became party to the Council of Europe Convention on the protection
of vertebrate animals used for experimental and other scientific purposes which
is also preparing recommendations on this issue.

An integral part of the Commission’s approach to the use of animals in
experiments and research is the “3Rs” principle – replacement,
reduction and refinement of animal use. The latest initiative in this area has
been the “3Rs Declaration” agreed by the Commission and industry in
November 2005. This Declaration was the starting point of a European partnership
in which all stakeholders will seek concrete future actions to reduce animal
testing and look for alternatives.

The new Action Plan gives particular focus to the implementation of this
agreement, and a first progress report on the Partnership will be published at
the end of 2006.

Standardised indicators for animal welfare would create a more level playing
field for producers across the EU, and respond to the growing market demand for
evidence of sustainably derived products. At the moment, certain national laws
and voluntary schemes are going beyond the EU minimum standards for animal
welfare, while all EU producers must adhere to standards which may be higher
than those applied in some Third countries. A system of indicators which
acknowledges that these standards have been met or exceeded would encourage
continued improvement of animal welfare conditions and provide consumers with
more information on the added value of animal welfare in the final product.

What would be the added value of an EU animal welfare label?

An EU label for animal welfare would allow for the better promotion of
products which have been produced in line with animal welfare requirements, and
a differentiation between those obtained with basic mandatory animal welfare
standards and those with higher standards. It would also compensate to some
extent for the competitive pressures faced by EU producers in the increasingly
globalised agricultural market, where animal welfare obligations are extremely
divergent.

A clear label identifying the level of welfare applied could prove an
effective marketing tool, and improve the information available to consumers in
the EU and internationally when making purchase choices. A recently published
Eurobarometer survey showed that 74% of consumers believe they can improve
animal welfare through their shopping choices, and over half of all consumers
surveyed stated that they would be willing to pay more for animal
welfare-friendly food products. However, the poll also revealed that consumers
found such products difficult to identify. An EU animal welfare label would help
to address this problem.

What has already been done on animal welfare at EU level?

The first legislation on animal welfare at EU level was adopted in 1974,
dealing with the protection of animals at the time of slaughter (subsequently
updated with Directive 93/119/EEC). Since then a considerable body of EU
legislation related to the treatment of animals has built up. With regard to
farm animals, general minimum standards for their protection have been set out
in Directive 98/58/EC. These rules reflect the “Five Freedoms” i.e.
freedom from hunger and thirst; freedom from discomfort; freedom from pain,
injury and disease; freedom to express normal behaviour; and freedom from fear
and distress.

Additional specific rules are provided for calves, pigs and laying hens, and
in 2005 the Commission adopted a proposal for a Council Directive on the welfare
of broiler chickens. Updated rules on the welfare of animals in transport were
already agreed in November 2004, which clarify responsibility for the protection
of animals throughout the whole transport chain, provide for better standards
for the environment in which animals are transported, and set stricter
conditions when it comes to journeys of more than 8 hours.

What is the Protocol on Protection and Welfare of Animals annexed to the
EU Treaty?

The legally binding Protocol on Protection and Welfare of Animals, annexed to
the EU Treaty, recognises that animals are sentient beings. It states,
therefore, that full regard should be paid to animal welfare concerns when
formulating or implementing policies relating to agriculture, transport,
research and the internal market. This will be done while respecting the
legislative or administrative provisions and customs of Member States relating
in particular to religious rites, cultural traditions and religious heritage

What provision is made for the protection of animals in EU agriculture
policy?

The 2003 reform of the Common Agriculture Policy (CAP) saw a number of
measures introduced to promote the better handling and treatment of animals. The
cross-compliance principle, whereby farmers must meet certain standards in order
to receive CAP payments, covers animal welfare standards, while extra support
will be given to agricultural practices which go beyond required animal welfare
practices under EU Rural Development policies. There are measures to provide
financial assistance to farmers in adapting to meet EU standards on animal
health, while economic support is also given to those who participate in food
quality schemes (including schemes based on high animal welfare). A new proposal
on organic farming sets out that the highest level of animal welfare must be
observed in organic production.

What provision is made for the protection of animals in EU environmental
policy?

Since the 1980s, EU environmental policies have included measures to promote
the improvement of animal welfare. These cover, amongst other things, trapping
standards, trade in wildlife, keeping zoo animals, the import of seal pup skins
and the protection of natural habitats.

Are fish covered by animal welfare legislation?

Information on the sentience of fish has gradually accumulated over recent
years. As a result, the Council of Europe has already drawn up recommendations
on the treatment of farmed fish, while the World Organisation on Animal Health
(OIE) is also preparing welfare guidelines for farmed fish. At EU level, the
Common Fisheries Policy includes a strategy for the sustainable development of
European aquaculture which has highlighted the need to improve the welfare of
farmed fish. In August 2005, the Commission put forward a draft Directive to
improve the health of aquaculture animals.

Will the Commission ban the use of cat and dog fur in the EU?

The Commission is currently looking into ways to ban the trade of cat and dog
fur in the EU, for ethical reasons and in response to considerable public
concerns on this issue. There are many legal issues to address before such a ban
could be put in place, but the Commission is hopeful that a European solution
can be found in the near future.

Who is responsible for checking that animal welfare standards are
met?

National authorities must make sure that rules on animal welfare are
respected by all animal handlers and keepers. The EU Food and Veterinary Office
(FVO) carries out inspections to verify that the EU legislation is properly
implemented and enforced. Under the Action Plan, training for national
authorities responsible for controlling animal welfare standards is foreseen, in
addition to training already undertaken at the national level. Third country
representatives, particularly those from developing countries, will also be
invited to participate in this training.

How has the Commission promoted better animal welfare at the international
level?

The European Commission works closely with international organisations with
the aim of boosting animal protection and welfare worldwide, and supports work
in this regard by the World Organisation for Animal Health (OIE: 167 member
countries) and the Council of Europe (45 member countries). The EU is party to
various Council of Europe Conventions for the protection of animals used for
experimentation, farm animals and the protection of animals during transport and
slaughter. The EU has also started to incorporate animal welfare into
multilateral and bilateral agreements with Third countries (e.g. Chile and
Canada).

What problems are faced at international level in terms of animal
welfare?

There is little international consensus on the importance of animal welfare
and standards applied across the world are greatly divergent. In the globalised
market, competitive distortions can arise from differences in legislation on
animal welfare standards, as it requires more resources to ensure the proper
treatment of animals. In 2002, the EU submitted a Communication to the World
Trade Organization (WTO), stating that in raising animal welfare issues at
international level, the EU was not seeking to create new trade barriers, but to
ensure that trade does not undermine efforts to promote animal welfare or put
the EU at a competitive disadvantage due to its higher demands.

What does the Action Plan foresee for the promotion of better animal
welfare standards internationally?

The Action Plan foresees the continued support of the EU for OIE and Council
of Europe initiatives to raise the standards of animal welfare internationally.
It also proposes closer cooperation between the EU and countries who apply high
animal welfare standards, in order to develop relationships with national
authorities and stakeholders involved and build up a bloc of international
consensus on welfare standards.

Third country representatives can already partake in EU training courses
organised for Member States’ competent authorities on implementing EU
animal welfare rules. The Commission has also taken part in trade related
technical assistance (TRTA) projects with Developing countries, for example
helping their experts to attend meetings on international standard-setting, and
sending EU technical experts to Developing countries.