Post #118: Good For What Ails You

A few weekends back my lady and I jumped in the car after work on Friday and took in Phish’s two night stand in Worcester, MA at the DCU Center. I’ve never seen the band there, but the room goes back a ways in Phish lore and is said to be a space that always brings out the best in the band, high praise indeed for a place that normally houses minor league hockey.

If you’re reading this but you’ve never seen Phish live before, it might be too late to convince you to do so. Maybe you’re an old dog afraid to learn a new trick. Maybe you’re jaded. Maybe you’re short on concert cash. Maybe you live in a place like South Dakota or Alabama where the band just never plays. Maybe you believe the rumors. But I can assure you that seeing Phish live is a concert experience unlike any other. And I’ve seen a few concerts. I’ve often told my father, who I know would never be caught dead at a Phish concert but absolutely loves live music, that if he could ignore the obnoxious fans and their strange hypnotic swaying, he’d genuinely enjoy the music. Be impressed by what the band can do. Phish is one of, if not the greatest improvisational rock band of all time. And I’m including all the other great ones in the mix when I say that. And no, I’m not being hyperbolic. I’ve just listened to a lot of music and thought about it a lot. Phish deserves mention in the pantheon of improvised music, regardless of the esteemed company they’d be asked to keep. As their fan base ages and their relevance wanes (Phish will never enjoy the cultural kitsch of the Dead, alas), I worry that their legacy will be far smaller than it should be. For their music reaches levels of joyful virtuosity that I’m at a loss to find a superior to outside of jazz (whose greatest practitioners I don’t mind saying, are on a whole different level.) A band so great deserves more.

I first saw Phish at Saratoga Performing Arts Center in the summer of 1995, right after I’d graduated from high school. Seven of us piled into a Civic hatchback and drove the two hours each way from Oneonta, New York to SPAC. The band was then so unknown to me that I actually thought they were Rusted Root during most of the first set, having listened to a friend who claimed RR was the opener (not knowing that Phish always tours alone). At one point, I asked “when does Phish start?” only to have my friend say, “this is Phish, asshole.” That show is a fond memory but didn’t necessarily spark my love for the band and its bizarre, addictive music. That happened in college.

My college roommate Mike spun Phish bootlegs from breakfast, lunch, and dinner our freshman year. I hated the music at first and I dreamed of killing first my roommate, and then the members of the band. The music just sounded like a horrible screeching blob to me. Whiny, out of control. Too fast and wild and unpredictable to enjoy. But the more I heard, the more the chaos began to separate, and when it did it broke into melodies and songs and I began to pick out bits of beauty, humor, oddity, even genius. There were musical parts of astounding complexity and cleverness, and some of most supple and lithe guitar playing I’ve ever heard (courtesy of Trey Anastasio). If any song did it that year, it was the version of “Stash” from A Live One, the band’s first official live release. Listen to it. After that I fell for “You Enjoy Myself” and “Reba” and “Gumbo” and other Phish staples. The more I heard, the more I perceived a secret club, one I didn’t necessarily want to be a full time member of, but one I knew I’d enjoy visiting from time to time.

When I met my wife, she just happened to be an on-again, off-again Phish freak, having seen the band thirty times already by that point. We started to see the band together when they were nearby and that was that. I let down my guard, stopped worrying about the drugged out hippies that sprung up like mushrooms and wanted my ticket for free before the show and wanted to sell me grilled cheese after. I mean, who were these people? I’d heard about the Dead’s fans, dedicated masses who traveled from place to place with the band, recording its shows like gospel and trading the tapes, gorging on variations of the same song. But I’d never seen musical love like I saw from Phish’s fans. It was a little weird, but more than anything it was kind of beautiful. It made me jealous. I wanted to love music that much. The band’s unique sensibility and vast and quirky song catalog inspired a level of dedication worth of tunneling into, and which often seemed to result in a sort of insider’s addiction. Loving Phish become a sort of secret knock.

It also became a punch line. Hipsters and doubters have always looked down on Phish, assuming their fans are deluded and their music subpar. But fuck them. I’ll write about them later.

Over the years I’ve been to probably twenty plus Phish shows, no grand number compared to any number of more dedicated or obsessive fans–my friend Leah has seen well over a hundred–though that twenty is still a good five times more than I’ve seen any other band or musician. I’ll keep going until they stop.

When we drove down to Worcester, I hadn’t seen the band in a couple years and though I was tired from a long week teaching, I was buzzing for the buzz. We just made it into the DCU Center before lights out. And out they came.

Honestly, these days, at times it’s hard for me not to feel like the band isn’t treading water a bit. They’re now thirty years into this thing. They’ve broken up officially once, but more like twice, and at times you wonder if the personal chemistry is still there. There were some moments in the first set on Friday night where I could honestly feel them not playing with focus and passion. Like they were watching the clock a bit. Trey was particularly sloppy in that first set, botching lyrics and guitar parts beyond the playful, experimental norm. Mediocre Phish is still far better than the energy and variety you get from nearly any other band, but they set the bar so high, anything less leaves me distracted. And going into set break, that’s how I felt.

And then the second set completely blew my mind. All it takes is one good jam and all is forgiven. And the second set was absolutely dripping with them. I won’t geek out and give you the play by play. It doesn’t feel like the right thing, and it’s hard to do Phish’s music justice with descriptions. Something about their chemistry, when it’s on and they’re flying, defies description or simple understanding.

But try this.

The Greeks hold that perfection is attained not through exact harmony and balance, not through the simple balance of a square, but through the proper combination of contrasts. Through a balance of imperfection. Opposites working together to create a unique understanding, a rare harmony. Phish is sort of like that.

I could keep trying to explain it, but I’m not sure you’d understand.

PS…do yourself a favor and listen to this Tweezer from Tahoe from this summer. But if you do, really listen to it. Give it the time it’s worth. It’ll give right back.

3 responses to “Post #118: Good For What Ails You”

Well written description of something impossible to describe my fellow!

I have had a love/hate relationship w/ phish since 1990. There were those core believers but, I was not one. I was not convinced until the Hampton shows after their first hiatus in 199? They did a Beastie Boys cover, Sabotage, and I was hooked! The molly helped turn the worm….I still get the shiver up my spine when Trey hits a certain note.

My biggest issue with phish was Mike Gordon wearing a black tee shirt w/ the long hair trying to do a Jerry look. That pissed me off and I never got over it until “Sabotage” was covered. I became fully engaged at that point until the disaster at Coventry. I will never forget how we were completely and utterly forgotten, our trauma ignored, after that weekend. What a disaster.

I saw Trey in Richmond the week before they announced their latest reunion, saw the first phish show at Fenway in Boston before the start of the official tour, actually ran into Trey and Page at the Ritz-Carlton in Boston the morning of the show, introduced my wife and I and got our Fenway phish tickets autographed.

We had seen Leonard Cohen at the Wang Theater the night before, phish announced the Boston date after we got our Leonard Cohen tix so phish at Fenway was a bonus show for us.

I wised up and caught the latest Hampton shows via live feed over the internet and watched the show on the widescreen while cranking the show on my Klipsh Heresy speakers. I didn’t miss having draft beer spilled on me by some drunken, tripping, hipster nor did I regret not driving to Hampton even though they were practically giving tickets away. I’ glad the scalpers got burned for once.

I enjoyed the show from my couch and I must say I highly recommend it if you have the sound system to do them justice. I did and my neighbors hate me for it but, it beats the hell out of driving to Hampton and back and paying 8 bucks for a beer.

phish will never be as iconic, or as revered the Grateful Dead nor will Trey ever compare to Jerry. While phish has a certain je ne sais quoi, Trey will always be a spas and will always have that stupid look on his face. I always thought phish was an invention to mock the Grateful Dead. I will always think so and is why they will never be hold the same level reverence by me as I hold in my heart for the Grateful Dead.

Hey! Just wanted to say thanks for reading and for such a thoughtful reply. Great to interact with other fans! My wife and I streamed New Years from the Garden last night and had a blast. The boys still got it!

phish really did kick ass after Trey was tapped by Bobby as heir apparent? Finally……..only took Trey 20 years to get approval.

Chicago changed everything for phish. Trey will never be Jerry, no matter how much he tries not to be, he just ain’t him. Trey is like the anti-Jerry!

They burned it down at MagnaBall!!! f-king A! I watched a few days after on youtube and it blew my mind! I was, like, oh my g-d….Bobby created a monster! The boyz burnt the place down! Nothing left! They even vaporized the ashes like it was 911! More powerful than the WTC coming down! Nothing remained, not even a shadow it was so complete! They utterly bitch slapped the planet. We will see what comes this Spring?

I reread my comment from 2-1/2 years ago…..wow has it been that long?…..and I should add that looking back over all the shows I went to see I really missed the boat when it came to Jerry Garcia Band.

I could have done so much more quality digging on Jerry outside of his activities with the GD. He was always either playing or in the hospital. The guy never rested, really, until he passed away. He lived like 100 lives in that short fifty-odd years.

Happy New Year, 1-1/2 late to you! Hope you are well! I guess you are going to some shows in a few weeks?

Benjamin Roesch

I am a novelist and short story writer living in Burlington, Vermont. My work has appeared in Brilliant Corners, Word Riot, Seven Days, Monkey Bicycle and other fine purveyors of the written word. Mostly, this blog will chronicle my writing life. But I’m restless. And writing can get tiresome to hear about, even if it’s the thing that makes you go boom. So don’t be surprised to find the occasional album or book review, recipe, political musing, notes on a recent home brewing endeavor, writing tutorial, anecdote, or rhetorical question into the ether.
Thanks for coming. Stay a while.