The 1893 sequel to Kidnapped has two titles, David Balfour and, in Britain, Catriona. The latter title alludes to Catriona Drummond, with whom David falls in love while he is helping Alan Breck to escape to the Continent.

Some critics believe that the sequel surpasses Kidnapped by being more historically oriented and "mature."

Also, the love affair adds a dimension not found in the earlier volume.