Dam "busters" say Gibe 3 puts thousands at risk

NAIROBI, 7 avril 2010

The Gibe 3 hydro-electric dam being built along Ethiopia’s River Omo will disrupt thousands of livelihoods and threatens to upset the ecology in lower Omo and Lake Turkana, northwestern Kenya, experts and activists warn.

Construction started in 2006 and is due to be completed in 2012.

"Lake Turkana receives [80-90] percent of its water from the River Omo; thus the impacts of the dam on the lake and the people who depend on the lake system for, for example fisheries, protein and livelihoods could be profound if its construction and operation negatively affect flows and seasonal flooding,” said Nick Nuttall, the UN Environment Programme's (UNEP) spokesman.

"Indeed, spawning migrations of fish are synchronized with the seasonal flooding, which occurs from June through September," he added.

An estimated 300,000 people depend on the lake.

According to Terri Hathaway, Africa Campaigner of the NGO International Rivers, an impact assessment of the dam identified another 100,000 people in Ethiopia who are directly engaged in flood recession cultivation, where crops are planted just after the annual river flood. "These crops are more reliable and vital to local food security," she told IRIN.

Another 100,000 people in the Lower Omo Valley depend on these crops and/or grazing lands supported by the flood for livestock, according to anthropologists, she added. "So there are 200,000 people in Ethiopia who depend on the Omo for their food security," she said.

Gibe 3 will have a vast reservoir and regulate the entire river flow, she said.

"By filling the reservoir and destroying the annual flood, the Gibe 3 dam will increase hunger, in turn fuelling greater resource conflicts in an already turbulent region," she warned.

Overall, there is perhaps the need for further and more detailed environmental impact assessments in order for the governments of Ethiopia and Kenya to fully understand the challenges and opportunities for hydro on the River Omo versus other energy-generating options.

"What is highly likely is with reduced resources, the communities will start to migrate a lot more often and increase the likelihood for more conflict. In an area with increased instability, we are looking at serious conflict," Angelei warned.

She noted that the recent disarmament of Kenyan communities in the region would increase their vulnerability against their well-armed neighbours.

The Gibe 3 impact assessment identifies that river flow will be almost completely withheld for at least two years during reservoir filling, but does not address how this will affect Lake Turkana, noted International Rivers' Hathaway.

"[It] suggests that during those two years, impacts to flood recession farmers in Ethiopia should be mitigated by providing food aid, despite vast international efforts to reduce food aid dependency in Ethiopia," she said.

"Since dam construction began, there has been no demonstration of political will to address the needs of communities [which] will be affected by Gibe 3 dam. Communities' rights have already been fundamentally violated," she added. "The Gibe 3 dam does not meet urgent electricity needs of Ethiopia."

However, the Ethiopian Minister for Government Communication Affairs, Shimelis Kemal, told IRIN the Gibe 3 project had come into effect after an extensive experts' survey.

"I know for sure that some highly renowned international experts have publicly assured that the construction of the dam [would] in no way jeopardize the livelihoods of the people living around there and the environment," Shimelis said.

"Some NGOs are trying to rally or get as many signatures as they can to prevent the construction of Gelgel Gibe 3 ... [The] government has repeatedly said the construction of the dam in no way jeopardizes the livelihoods of the people living downstream. It is pro-environmental.

"Various concerned bodies including the Kenyan parliamentarians have endorsed the position of the Ethiopian government and they have openly criticized the position pursued by these NGOs to prevent the construction of Gelgel Gibe 3 hydropower electric dam," he said.

A map showing the current and planned Hydro Dams, along the Omo - Gibe Basin

Responding to concerns that the Ethiopian government had begun advertising indigenous lands along the Omo River for sale, he said: "I don’t have any information if some land has been advertised for agro-business investment in that particular area."

Changing the balance

The organization Survival International recently launched a petition calling on the Ethiopian government to halt the project and urging potential international funders not to support it.

Survival’s director, Stephen Corry, said, "The Gibe 3 dam will be a disaster of cataclysmic proportions for the tribes of the Omo valley. Their land and livelihoods will be destroyed, yet few have any idea what lies ahead."

The African Resources Working Group recently pointed out that Lake Turkana would suffer greatly due to reduced freshwater inflow, which will not only shrink the lake but also change its chemical balance.

The lake is also very shallow given its size; its average depth is just 31m, making it even more sensitive to changes in water flows and to evaporation linked with climate change, said UNEP’s Nuttall.

"Any reduction in water flows could increase the saltiness with impacts on the fish," he warned.

Already, Lake Turkana’s salinity is far higher than any other large lake in Africa as it has shrunk over the past 7,500 years and because it is a closed lake system, he added.

Among the reasons for this is declining rainfall, increased evaporation, the diversion of water upstream and increased siltation due to erosion upstream.

"The rainfall patterns and river flows upon which the operation of the hydro-electric dams are based may no longer hold true 20, 30, 40 years from now," he said.

Hydro-dependent

Gibe 3 is expected to generate 1,800MW of electricity.

If Ethiopia carries out its energy development plans in full, it will be 95 percent dependent on hydro. "The Ethiopian sector of the Rift Valley and the Afar triangle has good potential geothermal resource possibilities. Perhaps these could be explored and harnessed," Nuttall added.

"Overall, there is perhaps the need for further and more detailed environmental impact assessments in order for the governments of Ethiopia and Kenya to fully understand the challenges and opportunities for hydro on the River Omo versus other energy-generating options," said Nuttall.

"The question is whether the new dam, Gibe 3, represents the most prudent and practical option in terms of environmental sustainability."