You are currently viewing the old forums. We have upgraded to a new NFL Forum. This old forum is being left as a read-only archive.
Please update your bookmarks to our new forum at forums.footballsfuture.com.

Wilson had an excellent rookie campaign.
Unfortunately for Wilson, RG3 had a historical one.

RG3 lead Redskins to an NFC East Divisional Title.
Neither Luck nor Wilson did that.
Not to mention the SB Champs being in same Division and Skins went 5-1 VS ALL NFC East opponents. Again...better than Luck & Wilson.

With the exception to Passing TD's, RG3 beat Luck & Wilson in every rushing or passing statistical category.

Not a few...not some...not most
ALL

A 50% at best RG3 marched down the field against that vaunted Seahawk Defense and posted 14 pts in back-to-back drives. He couldn't do anything, after hopping like a pogo stick.

Otherwise, Seattle goes home early.
All people know this...you know this & so do I

Redskins also posted the 4th best scoring Offense in the NFL.
best between Seattle & Indy

Again....no disrespect to Wilson, as he is going to be a very good QB.
Might even have a better Sophomore season if RG3 can't recover 100%.

But this season only
Their rookie years?

Wilson was fantastic
RG3 was historic

I won't even go into the talent difference in Seattle VS Redskins by comparison.
Seattle has a far better team overall and have been competitive in the West for sometime.

Redskins have been the doormat of the NFC East for 13 years. (with the exception to WC playoff seasons in 05' & 07')

So tell me again how Wilson should be rookie of the Year?

I do believe Wilson is #2 behind RG3, though.
Luck shouldn't even be in the top 5 of discussion, imo.

Anyways, good luck this off season.

Congrats to both our clubs for a successful season and bright future.

I love when people talk about what "could've" or "should've" happened. It's almost as pointless as talking about Tim Tebow._________________