Friday, January 18, 2013

Health Care Rationing Is Nothing New [Excerpt], by Beatrix Hoffman: ...
Opponents of the 2010 Patient Protection and Affordable Care Act warn that the
new health care law will lead to rationing, or limits on medical services. But
many observers point out that health care is already rationed in the United
States. "We've done it for years," said Dr. Arthur Kellermann, professor of
emergency medicine and associate dean for health policy at Emory University
School of Medicine. "In this country, we mainly ration on the ability to pay."
...

Countries with universal health systems ration health care via controlled
distribution, whether through national budgeting, government setting of prices
and provider fees, restrictions on some services, or a combination of methods.
The United States health care system rations primarily by price and insurance
coverage—and ... many other methods as well. Americans have learned to fear
European or Canadian types of rationing, but don't see that the United States
practices both price rationing and other types of rationing in health care.

Rationing in the United States is ... practiced by government agencies, private
health insurance companies, hospitals, and providers, in ways both official and
unofficial, intended and unintended, visible and invisible. The American way of
rationing is a complex, fragmented, and often contradictory blend of policies
and practices, unique to the United States. ... Health care has been rationed by
race, in the case of the Jim Crow health system and other types of racial
discrimination; by region, in the case of the uneven distribution of health
facilities and personnel throughout the country; by employment and occupation,
in the case of the job-based health insurance system; by address, in the case of
residency requirements for various kinds of health care; by type of insurance
coverage, in the case of health insurance that limits benefits and choice of
doctor and hospital; by parental status, in the case of Medicaid (childless
individuals are often excluded); by age, in the case of Medicare and the State
Children's Health Insurance Programs—and the list goes on. These types of health
care organization ... have rarely been called rationing. ...

Comments

You can follow this conversation by subscribing to the comment feed for this post.

'Health Care Rationing Is Nothing New'

On health care rationing in the US:

Health Care Rationing Is Nothing New [Excerpt], by Beatrix Hoffman: ...
Opponents of the 2010 Patient Protection and Affordable Care Act warn that the
new health care law will lead to rationing, or limits on medical services. But
many observers point out that health care is already rationed in the United
States. "We've done it for years," said Dr. Arthur Kellermann, professor of
emergency medicine and associate dean for health policy at Emory University
School of Medicine. "In this country, we mainly ration on the ability to pay."
...

Countries with universal health systems ration health care via controlled
distribution, whether through national budgeting, government setting of prices
and provider fees, restrictions on some services, or a combination of methods.
The United States health care system rations primarily by price and insurance
coverage—and ... many other methods as well. Americans have learned to fear
European or Canadian types of rationing, but don't see that the United States
practices both price rationing and other types of rationing in health care.

Rationing in the United States is ... practiced by government agencies, private
health insurance companies, hospitals, and providers, in ways both official and
unofficial, intended and unintended, visible and invisible. The American way of
rationing is a complex, fragmented, and often contradictory blend of policies
and practices, unique to the United States. ... Health care has been rationed by
race, in the case of the Jim Crow health system and other types of racial
discrimination; by region, in the case of the uneven distribution of health
facilities and personnel throughout the country; by employment and occupation,
in the case of the job-based health insurance system; by address, in the case of
residency requirements for various kinds of health care; by type of insurance
coverage, in the case of health insurance that limits benefits and choice of
doctor and hospital; by parental status, in the case of Medicaid (childless
individuals are often excluded); by age, in the case of Medicare and the State
Children's Health Insurance Programs—and the list goes on. These types of health
care organization ... have rarely been called rationing. ...