In its report, the commission explains that it is the only independent panel that can review confidential children’s case files, and if needed, call investigators to be questioned.

The volunteer members met 21 times to go step-by-step through the decisions made in six child abuse cases, scrutinizing the work of the Department of Children’s Services, police, health care professionals, and others involved in child protection.

Members of the commission review DCS investigative files, police reports, medical and court records, and background checks on those involved in the abuse cases.

“As I understand it, the Second Look Commission is the only entity in Tennessee that has a statutory obligation to review severe child abuse cases where there has been a second or subsequent incident of severe child abuse,” said Craig Hargrow, commission director. “Our commission has, I believe, the most diverse membership and the capability of having people come in to discuss specific issues with specific cases, and as noted by the report, I don’t know that any other commission or agency has prepared the types of reports with the information we have.”

Hargrow, a former DCS attorney and former Montgomery County juvenile court magistrate, is the commission’s only paid member.

“Over the last two years, the SLC has demonstrated the ability, willingness and desire to fulfill its statutory obligation. Even more than simply fulfilling its statutory obligations, the SLC has gone above and beyond its statutory obligations in attempting to not just “get it right,” but to function with excellence,” the report states.

A hearing date about the commission will be schedule when the legislative session begins.

Summerville, who has also served on the Government Operations Committee that will review the Second Look Commission, said options include a renewal, a limited-time renewal, or a cancellation of the commission.

He said the commission is vital and should continue.

“I’m very pleased with this report. It’s hard-hitting and troubling in many aspects. What we’re seeing here is the same old, same old. Not a lot is changing,” he said Thursday. “I cannot disagree with any of the recommendations.”