For their upcoming episode of VH1’s Unplugged series, the band performed a stripped-down version their breakout hit “Stereo Hearts.” With a twist: they replaced The Voice of Maroon 5’s Levine (see what we did there?) with that of former Fall Out Boy Stump, the guy who originally helped put Gym Class in a top-five Chokehold back in 2006. Sneaky move, Heroes.

Don’t believe us? Well, we’ve got an exclusive clip of the performance here. Check it out for yourself in the video below:

That was just one number from the episode’s five-song set; the full show will air this Thursday at 4pm on Unplugged.VH1.com and then again this Saturday at 9pm on Palladia.