11/09/16 MLS New England 3 – 1 New York City
07/07/16 MLS New England 0 – 1 New York City
27/03/16 MLS New York City 1 – 1 New England
26/10/15 MLS New York City 1 – 3 New England
19/07/15 MLS New England 1 – 0 New York City

Lima Pertandingan Terakhir New York City :

08/05/17 MLS New York City 3 – 1 Atlanta United
15/05/17 MLS Dallas 1 – 1 New York City
18/05/17 MLS Real Salt Lake 2 – 1 New York City
22/05/17 MLS Orlando City 0 – 3 New York City
29/05/17 MLS Atlanta United 3 – 1 New York City