I'm not familiar with the performance of the one you picked, but if you do some googling you should be able to find some comparisons. (You might have to do a lot of googling to get a feel for how it stacks up against the others)

I never owned either of those posted by sswilson but i know that the Big typhoon is overated. It's not that good from what i could see. I have a friend that has one... And i never saw any Xtreme overclock achieved with it. But i did saw some Xtreme overclock with the Scythe Ninja Plus!

My vote goes for a Noctua NH-U12. It was my last air cooler and it replaced my Tuniq Tower. The NH-U12 was able to handle 1.525Vcore 4GHz on a E6400, which is something i can the Tuniq couldn't do with a low speed fan.