Google Farmer Update: Who’s really affected?

In a major update Google changed its algorithm last Thursday to tune down content-farms. Nearly 12% of all search results on google.com were affected. One thing is almost certain: this was an algorithmic update!

Here at Searchmetrics we gather a lot of data from the Web. Over 55 million domains and 25 million keywords are continuously monitored, and all this data is then analyzed on a weekly and monthly basis. Over the last week, we’ve been intensely tracking the recent “Google Farmer Update” and algorithm changes to see what effects it is really having.

Surprise: ehow.com wins

Visibility: The Organic Performance Index (OPI)

As you may know, following the big media buzz around the JCPenney.com story in the New York Times, on 2/24/11 Google made some changes to its search algorithms to try and stem the ever-increasing presence of farmed content on the search engines results pages (SERPs). Being touted as the “Farmer Update”, Google has noted that this change has noticeably impacted 11.8% of their queries.

For purposes of this analysis, we used our own Organic Performance Index (OPI), which is calculated according to a keyword’s search volume, position and the statistical value of traffic distribution.

While speculators are calling this the “anti-Media” update and content heavy websites are quickly trying to pass themselves off as “anti-OnDemand Media sites” one site, eHow, is actually benefiting. Originally being fingered as a site that would be impacted by this update, eHow has actually gained 14% in visibility in the days following the change.

With its nearly 80% increase, the biggest winner in terms of traffic and percentage change is wikihow.com. A remarkable increase considering that in contrast to Wikipedia, wikiwho.com appears to be a classic definition of a content farm. Similarly, Yahoo! Answers experienced an almost 30% increase, in contrast to answers.com and answerbag.com, a site that experienced an almost 60% loss. Statistics such as these are clear indicators that the update must indeed be algorithm-based, fully automated and not carried out manually.

The results displayed are from data that we gathered between the 02/22/2011 and the 03/01/2011.

We analyzed 39 so-called “content farm” domains. We also looked at reputable, content heavy sites such as Facebook and the Huffington Post for comparative purposes. Overall, there was a 57% average drop in our OPI.

Who are the winners if the content farms are the losers?

It’s very hard to categorize the winners and losers. Obviously, it’s similiar to the Mayday update from last year where we saw that the loss of visibility was spread around a large number of different types of domains. Nevertheless, there are winners, notably the news portals like msn.com, mashable.com, zdnet.com and wired.com.

So Far, only US Google.com searches are affected

hubpages.com in co.uk

mahalo.com in co.uk

An analysis of similar domains with a .co.uk extension on google.co.uk index showed that there was an overall slight increase in traffic. Thus, as of yet, the update is only really effective on google.com and still has to swap over to Europe. However, the UK counterparts of domains like hubpages.com or mahalo.com should be prepared to see changes.

Now what to do?

Although eHow.com has always been taken as an example of industrial low-value content, they have actually gained visibility following this update. While the content may be of questionable value, like how to buy a teddy bear, user criteria such as bounce rates, visit duration, and social reach, for example, have obviously been part of the quality guidelines of the update. We also believe that if pages that are genuinely visually attractive to a user, the page will be spared by the Farmer Update. Meaning that ranking is going to come down to how a user values a page, as opposed to just what content is on it.

Was Demand Media really not affected?

answerbag.com

livestrong.com

Some still question whether Demand Media has in fact been affected by the Farmer Update. In looking at popular Demand Media sites livestrong.com and answerbag.com, we think the answer is loud and clear.

Here at Searchmetrics we gather a lot of data from the Web. Over 55 million domains and 25 million keywords are continuously monitored, and all this data is then analyzed on a weekly and monthly basis. Over the last week, we’ve been intensely tracking the recent “Google Farmer Update” and algorithm changes to see what effects it is really having.

Who’s writing this stuff? My name is Marcus Tober and I’m the founder of Searchmetrics. Because we really love to analyze every kind of online data, we can give you more insights than any other company in SEO, SEM and Social Media. It’s not a job, it’s passion. You can find me also on Google+ .Show all articles from Marcus Tober.

Comments (13)

Comments (76)

This is has just made me schocked too, because this “panda’ has made my traffic decreased about 50%. Anyway, how do we detect that the content is really original? If I seen Ezinearticles.com has the very orinigal, but why it decreased until -86% ?

Today, I went to the beach with my kids. I found a sea shell and gave
it to my 4 year old daughter and said “You can hear the ocean if you put this to your ear.” She placed the shell to her ear and screamed. There was a hermit crab inside and it pinched her ear. She never wants to go back! LoL I know this is entirely off topic but I had to tell someone!

Oh my goodness! Amazing article dude! Thanks, However I
am having troubles with your RSS. I don’t
know the reason why I am unable to join it. Is there anybody getting the same RSS
problems? Anybody who knows the solution will you kindly respond?
Thanx!!

[…] and which ones have survived the crosshairs of Google’s latest algorithm change. One such analysis from SearchMetrics confirms much of what’s already been reported, but also adds several new names to the list of […]

[…] Google Farmer Update Google Farmer Update: Who’s really affected? In a major update Google changed its algorithm last Thursday to tune down content-farms. Nearly 12% of all search results on google.com were affected. One thing is almost certain: this was an algorithmic update! searchmetrics.com […]

[…] formula of march are all about numbers, so hunt engine analytics organisation Searchmetrics took a look during some vital websites’ Organic Performance Index, that measures such facilities as a […]

[…] was supposed to help people find “more high-quality sites in search.” But when you look at the top 25 losers, you can’t help but notice Google seems to have devalued user-generated-content (UGC), and some […]

[…] to sites like AssociatedContent.com, FindArticles.com, and EZineArticles.com, according to a post by SearchMetrics.com. It also negatively impacted some perfectly legitimate sites, including Cult […]

[…] a number of keywords that the companies are tracking. SearchMetrics for their part say that “Over 55 million domains and 25 million keywords are continuously monitored“. Sistrix say that their report is “based on a dataset of one million […]

[…] to sites like AssociatedContent.com, FindArticles.com, and EZineArticles.com, according to a post by SearchMetrics.com. It also negatively impacted some perfectly legitimate sites, including Cult […]

[…] to sites like AssociatedContent.com, FindArticles.com, and EZineArticles.com, according to a post by SearchMetrics.com. It also negatively impacted some perfectly legitimate sites, including Cult […]

[…] to sites like AssociatedContent.com, FindArticles.com, and EZineArticles.com, according to a post by SearchMetrics.com. It also negatively impacted some perfectly legitimate sites, including Cult […]

[…] rank higher, sites like eHow took a hit. (For some interesting metrics on that update, check out this article). Will this happen again? Should you be worried? To my knowledge, as long as you’ve been […]

[…] New York Times rank higher, sites like (For some interesting metrics on that update, check out this article). Will this happen again? Should you be worried? To my knowledge, as long as you’ve been […]

[…] For information downgraded Google started a blog that is detected as “content farm” so some sites that are categorized as farm content decreased drastically visitors coming from search engines. Some sites are decreased percentage of visitors are ezineaticles decreased to 86%, HubPages has decreased by 80%. While the site is experiencing an increase in visitors as wikihow.com increased to 79%, answers.yahoo.com 29%, more can be found here Google Farmer Update affected […]

[…] rank higher, sites like eHow took a hit. (For some interesting metrics on that update, check out this article). Will this happen again? Should you be worried? To my knowledge, as long as you’ve been […]

[…] New York Times rank higher, sites like (For some interesting metrics on that update, check out this article). Will this happen again? Should you be worried? To my knowledge, as long as you’ve been […]

[…] US based results. It was covered well here – Danny Sullivan’s take, Aaron Wall’s assessment, SearchMetrics’ analysis, Sistrix’s data-driven post and Seomoz with most of these referring that the Content Scraper […]

[…] US based results. It was covered well here – Danny Sullivan’s take, Aaron Wall’s assessment, SearchMetrics’ analysis, Sistrix’s data-driven post and Seomoz with most of these referring that the Content Scraper […]

[…] though Searchmetrics’s confidence in visitor statistics like bounce rates, saying they “have obviously been part of the quality guidelines of the update” provided an excellent starting point to develop a way to examine. Search Engine Land’s “Why […]

Write a comment

Name (required)

Email (will not be published) (required)

Website

Notify me of followup comments via e-mail. You can also subscribe without commenting.

About Searchmetrics

Searchmetrics is the pioneer and leading global provider of digital marketing software and services. It operates the Searchmetrics Suite, an innovative, interactive online marketing and enterprise level Search Engine Optimization (SEO) platform. In our blog we write about current issues in the areas of online marketing and SEO and show interesting statistics and trends.