I asked the question on NCIX, but after trying some of the advice I received I came to a realization...
I really have no clue when it comes to more then basic networking. So hopefully someone here will help walk me through it lol.

So this is how I would like to have things set up, I have 2 routers a Dir-655 and some cheap Realtek one. The Dir-655 will have no internet but be connected to my computer and sharing all of my files within its network. The Realtek is connecting to another router as a wireless client to provide me with internet. I have the EVGA P55 FTW with 2 Ethernet ports, one for each router. Currently windows 7 is installed.

I have already set up each one individually and they work great, however connecting both at the same time messes with both. I made sure that both routers were operating on different ip ranges so there was no overlap, still hasnt helped. tried messing around with TCP/IP settings in windows but I didnt stumble on the answer and to be honest I havent worked with these settings before.