Attorneys for Chris Kyle’s estate are asking a judge to throw out a defamation verdict and $1.8 million award in the late Navy SEAL-turned-author’s legal battle against Jesse Ventura — or send the matter back for a new trial.

In court filings Thursday, they argued that the former Minnesota governor didn’t meet the high bar of proof for defamation of a public figure. The judge failed to steer the jury away from an erroneous decision, they said, and the award’s dollar amount was pulled from thin air.

The Kyle estate is seeking to reverse a verdict issued in July that found the author defamed Ventura in Kyle’s best-selling autobiography “American Sniper.”

The book claims Kyle punched out a celebrity, dubbed “Scruff Face” but later identified as Ventura, at a Coronado, Calif., bar in 2006 after the man bad-mouthed fallen soldiers at a war hero’s wake.

Ventura said the run-in never happened and sued for defamation. The author was shot to death in 2013 at a Texas gun range. Ventura took the lawsuit to trial against his estate, represented by his widow, Taya Kyle.

The 10 jurors hit an impasse during deliberations and came to a verdict after lawyers from both sides agreed to accept an 8-2 split decision. Neither side knew at the time where the jury stood.

In Thursday’s filings, the Kyle estate argued, as it has before, that the evidence of defamation laid out at trial wasn’t strong enough to support the verdict. As a public figure, Ventura had to prove that Kyle’s story defamed him, that it was false and that Kyle knew as much or had serious doubts about its veracity.

The final component had to be proven by “clear and convincing evidence”; jurors had to find it very likely that Kyle knew the story wasn’t true when he told it.

The testimony laid out in trial fell short of that burden, Kyle’s attorneys argued. Outside of Ventura and Kyle, 11 witnesses said they heard or saw parts of Kyle’s story unfold. Three from Ventura’s side said they were with him and didn’t see a fight.

“The testimony at trial overwhelmingly established that Ventura made offensive, anti-military statements” at the wake, Kyle’s attorneys wrote, including the statement that “SEALs deserve to lose a few” in the war in Iraq.

They also argued that U.S. District Judge Richard H. Kyle, no relation to Chris Kyle, made numerous missteps in instructing the jury, and allowed evidence that tainted the proceedings.

The judge’s instructions failed to properly convey the burden of proof or clear up “obvious juror confusion” about the questions they were weighing, the estate said. Instead, the court filings said, jurors were left to cobble together a verdict that improperly mixed and matched defamatory and irrelevant details of Kyle’s story.

At one point, jurors sent a note to the judge asking what the legal definition of “serious doubt” is. There is none, he told them.

Kyle’s attorneys said that wasn’t right. The U.S. Supreme Court has addressed the topic, calling serious doubt a “high degree” of “awareness of probable falsity,” and the judge could have clarified that. Instead, they argued, he “forced the jury to guess at the meaning of the crucial phrase.”

The jury awarded Ventura $500,000 for defamation and $1.3 million for unjust enrichment. The defamation portion is covered by insurance; the unjust enrichment is not, according to the Kyle estate.

The unjust enrichment award represented a little less than 25 percent of the $6 million Ventura’s attorneys claimed the estate had earned in royalties.

Kyle’s attorneys said Ventura did nothing to prove that the story about him drove 25 percent, or any specific percentage, of the book’s sales. They also said the $6 million figure was wildly inaccurate. The estate earned $2.25 million from royalties through 2013, according to their figures.

Judge Kyle will hear arguments on the filings at an undetermined date.

As you comment, please be respectful of other commenters and other viewpoints. Our goal with article comments is to provide a space for civil, informative and constructive conversations. We reserve the right to remove any comment we deem to be defamatory, rude, insulting to others, hateful, off-topic or reckless to the community. See our full terms of use here.

More in News

A 60-year-old Faribault man was killed Thursday evening when his car collided with a semitrailer in Rice County. The Minnesota State Patrol reported that Randy J. Hansen was driving a 1995 Pontiac Grand Am southbound on Highway 21 and making a left turn to continue eastbound on 21 shortly after 5:30 p.m. when his car collided with a semi going...

Transit for Liveable Communities and St. Paul Smart Trips are merging Jan. 1 to create a new nonprofit organization to promote buses, trains, bikes, car sharing, walking and other alternatives to putting more cars on the road.

DULUTH, Minn. — A Roanoke, Va., multimillionaire who made his fortune in health care and has recently purchased coal mines wants to buy the bankrupt Magnetation LLC operations on Minnesota’s Iron Range and put laid-off employees back to work. That’s the plan of Tom Clarke, owner of ERP Compliant Fuels and now ERP Iron Ore, who has brokered a deal...

Renaldo Terez McDaniel was looking under the hood of his car outside a St. Paul auto-parts store on a summer evening last June when three shots were fired. One hit the 31-year-old McDaniel in the shoulder, another pierced his stomach. The third struck his head.

Delta Air Lines is rolling out new free snacks for customers in the main cabin, including brand-name yogurt bars and pretzels. Some will come in larger portions than before because, Delta has figured out, that’s what customers crave.

MADISON, Wis. — University of Wisconsin System officials Thursday approved raising tuition for out-of-state, graduate and professional school students by hundreds of dollars at more than a half-dozen campuses as they grapple with a Republican-imposed freeze on in-state undergraduate tuition. The plan calls for increases at UW-Eau Clare, UW-Green Bay, UW-La Crosse, UW-Madison, UW-Milwaukee, UW-Stout and all the system’s two-year...