Robinson is an absolutely terrible baseball pick. What the hell were they thinking?

Mays is better, but Ruth would have been better still. 5 years as one the best pitchers in baseball (he led the league in ERA, Shutouts, Games Started, and did not allow a single HR in 1916), then he hits 4 more Home Runs in a single season than any other TEAM'S combined total. Who's done anything like that?

All while spending every single night smoking cigars, drinking bathtub gin, and whoring until dawn. Couldn't have abused his natural gifts more if he tried, and still was that good.

I agree, Karelen number 1. 13 years without a loss. That loss was for the Gold and went to OT. Amazing feat. In fact, if I remember correctly, he didn't even have a point scored on him for those 13 years?

I think solo sports wins mean more because there is nobody else to pick up the slack. Especially something so physical like wrestling. Also, in these sports the medium changes all the time. Each wrestling opponent is different and the ocean changes all the time. I still would vote for Slater but I wouldnt argue against Karelin too much. Both have amazing accomplishments.

While i sort of agree with you, you HAVE to have him on the list of GOATs in the sports world. He has records that will never ever be broken. Dude was the best ever by miles.

I absolutely don't agree with him, obviously. It isn't for greatest raw athleticism. It is for greatest athlete. If you deny hockey is an athletic sport, you are a fool. So obviously an athlete in that sport who is above equal to such an extent should be given respect in this category. If you are talking pure athleticism I doubt Jordan is even top 10 all time NBA. Probably not close. Should Jordan not be recognized? Of course he should.

fitch n prey - How is woods an athlete I know his one of the best golfers ever but athlete I doubt

Dale e jr also, he drives a car

Have you guys tried playing or performing in either sport? Golf is probably one of the hardest sports to be consistently successful in.And driving/racing, you have no idea how hot and sweaty it is in one of those cars. Since everyone knows how to drive, you can imagine its pretty damn difficult to control your car going 160-180mph

And if this was based on international voting, I'd say Pele would win. Being the most dominant at the most international sport would give him recognition. (Although one can argue messi may soon surpass him or already have).But because its a USA/NA poll, the American sports will win

Reply Post

“This is the official website of the Mixed Martial Arts llc. Commercial
reproduction, distribution or transmission of any part or parts of this website
or any information contained therein by any means whatsoever without the prior
written permission is not permitted.”