Doubts on progress and technology

Mechanical calculators: computing without electricity

Fast and complicated calculations are a product of fossil fuels.

Multiplying and dividing numbers was not always that easy. Before the arrival of cheap electronic pocket calculators and computers in the 1970s, people relied on an array of low-tech means and machines to calculate taxes, profits or the properties of engineering parts.

Being an obsolete technology now, some of these 19th and 20th century calculators are surprisingly sophisticated and fashionable. Moreover, most are powered by a crank, which makes these gadgets "green". Today's pocket calculators are no power hogs, either. The thing is that computers took over most calculating jobs from calculators, and a large supercomputer consumes as much energy as a convoy of trucks.

What do we do with all that calculation power? We build fast cars, giant jumbo jets and worldwide information highways, all of which, in their turn, raise energy consumption. We also construct opaque financial products, rickety electronic voting systems and contradictory global warming scenarios. Mechanical calculators may be an inferior technology, but they had the benefit of keeping things on this planet relatively simple. A brief overview of the most remarkable models.

1. Logarithms (1614-2008)

For most of history, people relied only on their brains when they had to make a calculation. The idea that a machine could count, was unheard of. The abacus, the only instrument which has been available for some thousands of years (and is still being used in some places), is not really a calculation machine but a memory aid, similar to the writing down of a calculation.

The first mechanical calculation machines, developed by Wilhelm Schickhard, Blaise Pascal and Gottfried Wilhelm von Leibniz, were not much of a success since they were not very reliable. But they became the basis for the highly successful mechanical calculators built throughout the 19th and 20 century, when more accurate gears and wheels became available.

2. Mechanical desktop calculators (1820-1970)

Mechanical desktop calculators resemble old typewriters, both in their size, weight and operation. The machines had movable carriages and/or rows of keys. They were an important tool in business and administration for more than 150 years, especially from the 1900s until the beginning of the 1970s.

The first reliable machine was the Arithmometer invented by Charles Xavier de Colmar in 1820. The concept was improved with the impressive pinwheel calculators(picture below right) invented by Baldwin and Odhner (here you find the mechanism and the manual - scroll down the page - of a Pinwheel machine).

The Comptometer, introduced in 1885, was the first mechanical calculator in which numbers were entered (and processed) by pressing keys, which made the operation of the machine easier. Instead of having 10 keys for the numbers from 0 to 9 (like the keyboards we use today), these "adding machines" had columns of 10 keys each, to introduce successively units, tens, hundreds, and so on. The most "powerful" calculators had up to 20 columns in their full keyboards. This is how they worked(picture left: mechanism of a comptometer).

Multiplying and dividing required several operations and could take some time. The keyboard of adding machines was better for fast additions and subtractions, while the carriage of the pinwheels was better for multiplying and dividing. Some machines (like the one pictured above) combined both technologies. Electric (not electronic) driven calculators became common in the 1940s, but hand driven calculators remained popular because they were quieter, smaller, lighter and cheaper.

3. Slide adder pocket calculators (1617-1982)

Napier bones and slide rules, both based on the concept of algorithms logarithms, were invented in the 17th century. They remained the only portable calculation aids until the Arithmographe, invented in 1889 by the Frenchman Troncet. Of this device, which was soon known as a "Troncet", millions were sold. It was on the market until the 1970s. These calculators had very diverse and fashionable designs, not unlike a mobile phone or an mp3-player today. Both cheap and extremely expensive models existed. Some of them were operated with a small metal pen, like a PDA now.

The machines were later known as Addiators, after a brand that was created in Germany in 1920 (and was on the market until 1982). Some marvellous photo collections of Troncets and Addiators can be found here and here. A good description of the workings of the device can be seen in this scanned manual from a very popular device in the US, the Baby Calculator. Contrary to slide rules, these "slide adders" were digital devices, but their mechanism is more related to slide rules and the abacus than to mechanical calculators.

4. Mechanical pocket calculators (1947-1970)

The Curta was the first (and only) portable mechanical calculator. Designed by a prisoner in a concentration camp, it became the most precise portable computer until the arrival of electronic pocket calculators (with 11 to 15 digits it is even more accurate than most simple electronic models today). The Curta was introduced in 1947, the last models were produced in 1970.

The Curta works according to the same principles as the mechanical desktop calculators, but its mechanism is much more compact - the device fits in the palm of your hand.

The only advantages of an electronic calculator over the Curta are portability (an electronic calculator is even smaller) and speed - a not too complicated multiplication or division can take up to a dozen of cranks.

Owners of the device say that turning the crank is a real pleasure due to the excellent gearwork. Later models could also perform squares, cubes, percentages and cosines. About 140,000 Curta's were built. More information on this device can be found here and here. UPDATE: operate a virtual curta online (via).

5. Mechanical supercomputers (1822-2008)

All calculating devices mentioned above were not suited for very complicated calculations, like those needed by science and navigation. Until the 1960s, complicated computations were done with the help of mathematical tables, where one can look up the result for every possible calculation that might be needed (they are still used for some complex calculations, also in computers, where they can increase calculating speed). These columns of numbers - similar to simple multiplication tables - were made by teams of people, called "computers", who were calculating all day (often using the machines mentioned above). Producing those tables was labour-intensive and prone to mistakes.

Babbage never built his machines, except for some parts, but other people did. In 1853, father and son Scheutz from Sweden completed a smaller version of the difference engine and in 1875 Martin Wiberg built a version the size of a sewing machine. A 5 ton replica, based on the original plans of Babbage, will be on display for a year in the American Museum for Computing History, starting this weekend. Another one can be found in the London Science Museum (both museum pages contain pictures of the machines). These are the largest mechanical calculators ever built; the counterparts of the Curta. A good explanation of the importance of Difference Engines can be found in this chapter of "Computing before computers" (heavy download).

The Difference Engine shows both the marvels and the limitations of mechanical calculators. The reliability of a mechanical computer depends on the accuracy of the gears, and the heavier they are, the better. Some people have built Difference Engines with meccano or lego bricks, but those machines deliver less precise results because of the higher flexibility of the lightweight parts. Constructing a mechanical computer with the calculation capacities of a modern computer would create a monstrous machine, larger than our largest buildings, that would have to be cranked several generations long to produce a result.

The Chinese Wheelbarrow

How to downsize a transport network: the Chinese wheelbarrowFor being such a seemingly ordinary vehicle, the wheelbarrow has a surprisingly exciting history. This is especially true in the East, where it became a universal means of transportation for both passengers and goods, even over long distances.

Human Powered Cranes

Wood Gas Vehicles

Firewood in the Fuel Tank: Wood Gas VehiclesWood gas cars are a not-so-elegant but surprisingly efficient and ecological alternative to their petrol (gasoline) cousins, whilst their range is comparable to that of electric cars.

Open Modular Hardware

How to make everything ourselves: open modular hardwareConsumer products based on an open modular system can foster rapid innovation, without the drawback of wasting energy and materials. The parts of an obsolete generation of products can be used to design the next generation, or something completely different.

Power from the Tap

Power from the Tap: Water MotorsJust before the arrival of electricity at the end of the 19th century, miniature water turbines were connected to the tap and could power any machine that is now driven by electricity.