It's not like it hasn't happened before - look at Yvonne Ridley (?). Same sort of circumstances - far left reporter, gets kidnapped, when released starts making nutty statements. The real test will be 2-3 months down the line if Carroll decides to convert to Islam like Ridley did....

Posted by: JeremyR at
April 3, 2006 4:18 PM

Carroll's sin, if she committed one, was naivete.
She went about in Iraq too cavalierly, too trusting of the place and its people. She's young. Whatever she said, she said. The tears and spaced out look of the first few videos tell a truer story than her pre-release statements, I think.