Way too many categories where I can't decide... but I finished anyway.

Best Story

Best Animation
Best Art Style
Best Setting/World

Best OP
Best ED
Best OST

Best Action
Best Adventure
Best Comedy
Best Drama
Best Fantasy
Best Supernatural
Best Mystery
Best Romance
Best Science Fiction
Best Slice of Life
Best Short Series (2-15 minutes)

Best Male Character
Best Female Character
Best Supporting Character
Best Non-Human Character
Best Antagonist/Villain
Most Adorable/Cutest Character
Best Couple/Ship
Best Character Designs
Best Overall Cast

March Comes in like a Lion 2nd Season
Children of the Whales
Children of the Whales

Ancient Magus' Bride
Black Clover
Children of the Whales

Juuni Taisen
Kino's Journey
Recovery of an MMO Junkie
Welcome to the Ballroom
Ancient Magus' Bride
Land of the Lustrous
Children of the Whales
Just Because
Inuyashiki
March Comes in like a Lion 2nd Season
Love is Like a Cocktail

Best Action
Best Adventure
Best Comedy
Best Drama
Best Fantasy
Best Supernatural
Best Mystery
Best Romance
Best Science Fiction
Best Slice of Life
Best Short Series (2-15 minutes)

Best Male Character
Best Female Character
Best Supporting Character
Best Non-Human Character
Best Antagonist/Villain
Most Adorable/Cutest Character
Best Couple/Ship
Best Character Designs
Best Overall Cast

How about a "Best Setting" category? It could be the city/country/world of a series (such as Hellsalem's Lot in Kekkai Sensen, Hell in Hoozuki no Reitetsu) or a specific building (Kawamoto Household or Shogi Hall in March Comes in Like a Lion, Polar Star Dormitory in Food Wars!, Yokai Apartment in Elegant Yokai Apartment Life, Konohanatei in Konohana Kitan, Stile in Blend-S, etc.). The shows I mentioned have very distinct and memorable locations.

Another possibility is a "Best Group" category. Examples from this season include the Elite Ten in Food Wars!, Black Bulls in Black Cover, Stile waitresses in Blend-S, different unit in The [email protected] Side M, Aquors from Love Live Sunshine, Anime Club in Anime-Gataris, Libra in Kekkai Sensen, Booger Diamonds 48 in Gintama, Matsuno Brothers in Osomatsu-san, etc. After further thought, never mind, this would just a subset of the existing "Best Overall Cast" category.

Best Action
Best Adventure
Best Comedy
Best Drama
Best Fantasy
Best Supernatural
Best Mystery
Best Romance
Best Science Fiction
Best Slice of Life
Best Short Series (2-15 minutes)

Best Male Character
Best Female Character
Best Supporting Character
Best Non-Human Character
Best Antagonist/Villain
Most Adorable/Cutest Character
Best Couple/Ship
Best Character Designs
Best Overall Cast

Blood Blockade Battlefront & Beyond
Land of the Lustrous
Osomatsu-san
March comes in like a lion
Land of the Lustrous
The Ancient Magus' Bride
-
Recovery of an MMO Junkie
Girls' Last Tour
Girls' Last Tour
-

The list is basically done, albeit for any surprise finales. For me this season had a high average, but very few standout shows. In Summer I could have given you an ordered top five within the first few weeks, Fall though was more...difficult. As a result, some of my favourite shows are barely represented. Once again, only full length series I complete are in contention, which means 29 shows this season, 18 of which are represented on the list in some way.

Fall 2017 Anime Awards

Best Story

Best Animation
Best Art Style
Best Setting/World

Best OP
Best ED
Best OST

Best Action
Best Adventure
Best Comedy
Best Drama
Best Fantasy
Best Supernatural
Best Mystery
Best Romance
Best Science Fiction
Best Slice of Life
Best Short Series (2-15 minutes)

Best Male Character
Best Female Character
Best Supporting Character
Best Non-Human Character
Best Antagonist/Villain
Most Adorable/Cutest Character
Best Couple/Ship
Best Character Designs
Best Overall Cast

Blood Blockade Battlefront & Beyond
Magical Circle Guru-Guru
Gintama: Porori-hen
March Comes in like a Lion 2
The Ancient Magus' Bride
Konohana Kitan
Urahara
Just Because
Land of the Lustrous
Girls' Last Tour
Fireball Humorous

Kiriyama Rei - March Comes in like a Lion 2
Komiya Ena - Just Because
Koiwai Homare - Recovery of an MMO Junkie
Phosphophyllite - Land of the Lustrous
Shishigami Hiro - Inuyashiki
Kawamoto Momo - March Comes in like a Lion 2
Komiya Ena x Izumi Eita - Just Because
Land of the Lustrous
Hozuki's Coolheadedness 2

Sakaguchi Daisuke as Leonardo Watch/Shimura Shinpachi
Kurosawa Tomoyo as Phosphophyllite - Land of the Lustrous

King's Game the Animation
Kino's Journey: The Beautiful World
Konohana Kitan
Land of the Lustrous

Best Action
Best Adventure
Best Comedy
Best Drama
Best Fantasy
Best Supernatural
Best Mystery
Best Romance
Best Science Fiction
Best Slice of Life
Best Short Series (2-15 minutes)

Best Male Character
Best Female Character
Best Supporting Character
Best Non-Human Character
Best Antagonist/Villain
Most Adorable/Cutest Character
Best Couple/Ship
Best Character Designs
Best Overall Cast

Best Action
Best Adventure
Best Comedy
Best Drama
Best Fantasy
Best Supernatural
Best Mystery
Best Romance
Best Science Fiction
Best Slice of Life
Best Short Series (2-15 minutes)

Best Male Character
Best Female Character
Best Supporting Character
Best Non-Human Character
Best Antagonist/Villain
Most Adorable/Cutest Character
Best Couple/Ship
Best Character Designs
Best Overall Cast

Juni Taisen: Zodiac Wars
Girls Last Tour
Recovery of an MMO Junkie
The Ancient Magus Bride
The Ancient Magus Bride
The Ancient Magus Bride
Girls Last Tour
Recovery of an MMO Junkie
Girls Last Tour
Girls Last Tour
Love is Like a Cocktail

Best Action
Best Adventure
Best Comedy
Best Drama
Best Fantasy
Best Supernatural
Best Mystery
Best Romance
Best Science Fiction
Best Slice of Life
Best Short Series (2-15 minutes)

Best Male Character
Best Female Character
Best Supporting Character
Best Non-Human Character
Best Antagonist/Villain
Most Adorable/Cutest Character
Best Couple/Ship
Best Character Designs
Best Overall Cast

Best Action
Best Adventure
Best Comedy
Best Drama
Best Fantasy
Best Supernatural
Best Mystery
Best Romance
Best Science Fiction
Best Slice of Life
Best Short Series (2-15 minutes)

Best Male Character
Best Female Character
Best Supporting Character
Best Non-Human Character
Best Antagonist/Villain
Most Adorable/Cutest Character
Best Couple/Ship
Best Character Designs
Best Overall Cast

Blood Blockade Battlefront & Beyond
One Piece
Gintama
March comes in like a Lion
The Ancient Magus Bride
Blood Blockade Battlefront & Beyond
Best Mystery
Recovery of a MMO junkie
Best Science Fiction
Animegataris
Love is like a cocktail

Best Action
Best Adventure
Best Comedy
Best Drama
Best Fantasy
Best Supernatural
Best Mystery
Best Romance
Best Science Fiction
Best Slice of Life
Best Short Series (2-15 minutes)

Best Male Character
Best Female Character
Best Supporting Character
Best Non-Human Character
Best Antagonist/Villain
Most Adorable/Cutest Character
Best Couple/Ship
Best Character Designs
Best Overall Cast