Not really sure why you would take a spirit trinket anyways since you're trading int for spirit at a 1:1 ratio. If you want more spirit stack spirit gems and make sure its on all your gear. At least with gems you are trading int at a 2:1 ratio and on your gear you are trading other secondary stats for spirit also at a 1:1 ratio. You should be easily able to reach 9500+ spirit without even trying which is plenty. Int trinkets/flask/food ftw.

I am pretty sure it does. However the proc does not profit from mastery

Horridon's does proc from Atonement (and a lot), Megaera's hydra-spawn bag of fail does not appear to. I played around with the inscribed bag of the hydra-spawn on Ji Kun the other night (got it from a bonus roll so figured why not), got 8 total procs on a 9 minute fight. I mostly atonement heal that one, stack spirit shell for quills. I tried forcing procs on the dummy and got nothing after 5 minutes trying. I did however get 125k mana back from horridon's on the same Ji Kun kill. I love that trinket.

Has anyone found out if the Unerring Vision of Lei-Shen works for disc? I know a lot of mages and warlocks would stone me to death but it does look very nice.

I'm very interested in this as well. Having looked at some logs of players with lightning-imbued I seriously doubt it'll be worth using (maaaybe at hc, with the increased proc rate). Otherwise I guess we're stuck with horridons+shado pan/upgraded tier 14 trinkets.

On PTR Unerring Vision was proccing as discipline. It has pretty limited use though as the proc window is so small: refreshing a PoM (on PTR charges still crit after the buff faded) or casting a level 90 talent, although cascade recalculates on each hit so it's not great for that either.

Under normal situations (as in, not changing your casting pattern / having PoM&L90 on cooldown) it wasn't very impressive - the proc rate is simply too low and too random. (Although when I got lucky and it procced a few times in a row or lined up perfectly with PoM/L90 it was pretty amazing.)

I'll likely be using Horridon's + upgraded Qin-xi's until progression is over. As already mentioned, all the T15 raid trinkets with proc healing or shielding effects are terrible. Eventually I may get some heroic DPS trinkets, but that'll probably take a while.

Have you guys considered Cha-Ye's Essence of Brilliance as a throughput trinket for Atonement healing yet? Seems like a solid option if your regen is okay, especially in 10-man if you gear towards crit.

Have you guys considered Cha-Ye's Essence of Brilliance as a throughput trinket for Atonement healing yet? Seems like a solid option if your regen is okay, especially in 10-man if you gear towards crit.

I'll definitely want two "DPS" trinkets for fights where I just don't need as much mana after our casters pick them up

Didn't wanna necro this thread, but didn't see anywhere else we were talking about my question.
I recently got Lightning-Imbued Chalice, and as anyone who has it knows, the proc rate is meh. I run in a 10 man and I still go heavy Atone, even after our nerf. It just works well for our comp.
I was wondering how the RPPM for Cha-Ye's Essence of Brilliance was as Disco Atone healing. I keep reading that it gets a nerf when in a healing spec, but by how much? Honestly if it even had a 10% uptime I think t might be a better choice over Chalice. (was so happy when it dropped just to see its horrid proc rate)

Cha-Ye's Essence of Brilliance is by far the best trinket for discs atm. Uptime is somewhere between 20% and 25% on most fights (30% if you're really lucky). Second best trinket would be Breath of the Hydra, because you can get another 586 crit after a reforge. Don't have that one yet though.

Didn't wanna necro this thread, but didn't see anywhere else we were talking about my question.
I recently got Lightning-Imbued Chalice, and as anyone who has it knows, the proc rate is meh. I run in a 10 man and I still go heavy Atone, even after our nerf. It just works well for our comp.

I'm curious why the proc is Meh? It does something like 3-4% of my healing when I use it (which I admittedly don't always).

I'm willing to sell my soul for Horridon's trinket at this point, too.

Originally Posted by Saeba

Cha-Ye's Essence of Brilliance is by far the best trinket for discs atm. Uptime is somewhere between 20% and 25% on most fights (30% if you're really lucky). Second best trinket would be Breath of the Hydra, because you can get another 586 crit after a reforge. Don't have that one yet though.