Today's Deals

This restaurant's overall star value is determined by comparing its ratings against
those of other restaurants in the same city.

A teacher might call this grading on a curve. At Seamless, this means that regardless
of their actual tally, restaurants with the highest ratings will have five stars,
those with average ratings will have three, and the not-so-favorite restaurants
will have the least number of stars.

So pay it forward to the Seamless community. Rate and review places you've tried
so we can all find food happiness!

Reviews for Bagel Boss (Murray Hill)

Order comes wrong every time and honey mustard tuna is not as good as any of the other bagel bosses. Bagels themselves are fine if you get the right order!

Written by
Lauren E.
on
11/16/2014
|
3 other reviews |
Member since
2006
Lauren
ordered from here
over a year ago

I love bagel boss, but seriously they have NEVER ONCE gotten my order right. Something is always missing or they send the wrong item. It's beyond ridiculous at this point. It's not that hard to follow what the order says or at the very least double check a bag before you send it out.

Written by
Lara R.
on
8/16/2014
|
3 other reviews |
Member since
2008
Lara
ordered from here
within the last month

The food here is great, but the customer service over time has gotten really bad. The delivery guys refuse to come up to my office for delivery and make me meet them in the lobby. I usually wouldn't mind but the fact that there is a 15% delivery charge, i expect the delivery to be completed. If I had the time to leave my desk I wouldn't pay for delivery. When asking for a toasted bagel it comes burnt and orders have been coming wrong. Bagel Boss needs to go back to the way it was when it first opened at this location and treat its customers right.

Written by
rafi h.
on
7/23/2014
|
Member since
2013
rafi
ordered from here
within the last month

Very quick, attentive service & the delivery person is nice. They listened to the special instructions & filled my order exactly as I wanted. Never disappointed with the quality of the food the last few times ordered. I've had their bagels, egg sandwiches, blintzes & pierogis. The only issue to me is the additional service charge & some of the items are a little expensive. I will order again!

Written by
Mariangela C.
on
7/19/2014
|
1 other review |
Member since
2013
Mariangela
ordered from here
within the last year

Food is good. Bagel with egg and cheese is terrible but cream cheese is fine. Won't order from here anymore with the new fee.

Written by
Taylor C.
on
7/18/2014
|
6 other reviews |
Member since
2013
Taylor
ordered from here
over a year ago

Very very good bagels. I mean come on, it's NYC, there aren't many bad bagel places... Bagel Boss was awesome however. And when I received the delivery, the bagels were STILL HOT which is amazing. Also they very efficiently delivered HOT coffee that didn't spill. I was very impressed. Highly recommend it!!!

Written by
JERRY B.
on
6/30/2014
|
Member since
2013
JERRY
ordered from here
within the last year

Best bagels in NYC. Very Quick delivery. The egg salad and all baked goods are amazing. If you ever want a bagel on the east side this is the place to go.

Written by
Vincent B.
on
6/28/2014
|
Member since
2013
Vincent
ordered from here
within the last year

SIMPLY THE BEST BAGELS IN TOWN - BAGEL BOY
AMAZING TUNA, BREAKFAST SANDWICHES, GREAT CUSTOMER SERVICE - ONLY ORDER FROM HERE!

Written by
Jordan S.
on
6/27/2014
|
1 other review |
Member since
2012
Jordan
ordered from here
within the last year

My order arrived with no bagel and no coffee

Written by
GEORGIANA PAULA A.
on
6/23/2014
|
2 other reviews |
Member since
2014
GEORGIANA PAULA
ordered from here
within the last year

excellent bagels, a huge portion of "schmear" and good and quick delivery service; can't ask for more

Written by
Lawrence M.
on
6/3/2014
|
3 other reviews |
Member since
2011
Lawrence
ordered from here
within the last year

Tuna melt was cold, bagel was cold but cream cheese was very good

Written by
Michael H.
on
6/3/2014
|
5 other reviews |
Member since
2006
Michael
ordered from here
within the last year

very good bagel in midtown

Written by
Ricardo / Reno R.
on
4/30/2014
|
3 other reviews |
Member since
2012
Ricardo / Reno
ordered from here
within the last year

Disappointing. As a regular of the original Bagel Boss, I ordered a chopped salad for the first time from the Murray Hill location. The croutons were soggy and had been incorporated at a proportion far higher than my other add ins. I tasted a cranberry which certainly was not on order, and there was little of my tuna and cheese mix-ins. I understand that these are more expensive, but then don't offer them as all-inclusive and skimp on it. The salad was overly chopped which gave it a soggy texture and made it quite unappetizing. Despite the generous inclusion of sliced avocado at the top, I haven't eaten more than a few bites.

Written by
Rishe G.
on
4/24/2014
|
12 other reviews |
Member since
2012
Rishe
ordered from here
within the last year

Growing up on Long Island living right near the original Bagel Boss, I was so excited to know they are opening up satellite stores in the city. Bagels are huge, filled with different types of cream cheese ( so many options!) and they are super accommodating and friendly staff!

Written by
Elizabeth K.
on
4/1/2014
|
12 other reviews |
Member since
2012
Elizabeth
ordered from here
over a year ago

The order came fast but one of the bagels I ordered was wrong and both were burnt.

Written by
Hayley P.
on
2/23/2014
|
4 other reviews |
Member since
2013
Hayley
ordered from here
over a year ago