According to The Warrington Guardian, Harry Styles bought Taylor Swift 23 cupcakes to commemorate her 23rd birthday, because what 90 lb pop star doesn’t want to eat 23 cupcakes in one sitting?

Matt and wife Kelly, who run the [Custom Cupcake] company together from their Montgomery Close home, said the cakes were a selection of 12 flavours including ones filled with candy floss and a mint liqueur centre.

While it’s possible that Harry showed up to TaySwift’s party bearing enough cupcakes for her 23 guests, that’s not what it says. When you bring your girlfriend birthday cupcakes for real, you bring her just a few in edible flavors like chocolate or strawberry. Much like the Dirty Dancing lift, this seems less like something people who are actually banging would do, and more like something Haylor’s tween fans imagine the perfect boyfriend would do, were they old enough to date.

TL;DR: Fake, fake, fake. Tune in next week, when Harry proposes to Taylor in Paris while riding a horse and wearing a Prince Charming costume.