The Budget Shows What We Value

In reading a story today on Tucson.com, I learned about how the Vail Unified School District is thinking about building tiny homes for “cash-strapped teachers.” Although I laud their innovative approach, I can’t help thinking that to some degree, the culpability we all have in creating the need.

The reality is that the starting base salary for a teacher in Vail is about $36,000 in an area where the “household income is $83,000 and the median home sale price is about $260,000.” It also is reality that there is “not a single apartment complex anywhere in the district’s 425-square-mile boundary.”

This situation is not isolated. Vail might be the first district in the country to bring the tiny house concept to fruition, but they aren’t the only ones considering such an option. A charter school in Sedona and school district in Colorado are also looking at it, for example. And, offering housing as part of teacher’s contracts has long been a strategy employed by rural school districts. The Baboquivari Unified School District on the Tohono O’odham Nation has dozens of rental units for teachers and Patagonia Public schools turned an old school building into apartments for teachers.

What I find truly ironic, is that our lawmakers, Governor Ducey included, continually push for a greater percentage of education dollars to be spent in the classrooms, when the inadequate funding they provide for education actually forces energy and funding to be spent outside the classroom – as in creating cheaper housing for teachers ? Truth is, Arizona district schools already have the lowest administrative costs in the U.S. and those costs, are half those of charter schools in our state. That narrative though, doesn’t serve lawmakers’ purposes, so they continue to rail about the inefficiencies of our public district schools, all while doing what they can to try to make it true.

The recently concluded 110th Arizona Town Hall, on “Funding and preK–12 Education”, reported that, “the state needs to fulfill its constitutional mandate by providing adequate funding for state schools.” As the AZ Daily Sun pointed out though, state legislators and the governor “weren’t [even] invited [to the Arizona Town Hall on Education] because they have demonstrated time and again that they are part of the problem, not the solution. They continue to intone their mantra of private school ‘parental choice’ even as teachers are leaving in droves, thousands of classrooms are staffed on a near permanent basis by noncertified substitutes and Arizona remains mired near the bottom of the 50 states in per-pupil spending.”

The old adage “If you don’t have time to do something right the first time, when will you have time to do it over” comes to mind. In fact, the AZ Town Hall reported that, “Arizona’s current education funding system has regressed over the past 40 years into a complicated patchwork of temporary solutions.” That’s certainly how it has appeared to me and I continue to see new workarounds under consideration, such as a “soda tax” to help fund our schools.

How about this? How about we just decide we want our students in fully funded classrooms, housed in safe, adequate, properly maintained facilities? How about we decide we want high-quality, certified teachers and then pay them a living wage? How about we decide the children of Arizona deserve as much opportunity to succeed as any child living anywhere else in our country? And then, how about we put our money where our collective mouths are? Or as former Vice-President Joe Biden put it, “Don’t tell me what you value, show me your budget and I’ll tell you what you value.”

Arizonans have time and again said we want our public schools adequately funded and there are plenty of solutions to do so, many without raising taxes. Yet, those that vote (less than half of those eligible) , continue to vote for lawmakers who are doing everything they can to destroy our system of public education and turn it over to market forces. Until we vote different, we won’t get different. It’s that simple.

5 responses to “The Budget Shows What We Value”

arizonans in phony polls say time and again … but that is not how they vote! when your phony polls (like your phony gun control polls that get democrats who are coned into believing them defeated) align with how arizona voters vote come back to us with your polls.

What? This article isn’t about polls! You can try to change the subject but it doesn’t work. Our schools need more money to pay teachers more so they can pay the higher federal income taxes that the R’s have insisted on—does that work for you?

Community Events

by Tucson Police Department, Tucson Office of Emergency Management & Homeland Security “Have you ever wondered what you would do if you became involved in an active shooter situation? Do you want to learn about simple ways to protect yourself … Continue reading →

THURSDAY, MAY 24 INHERIT THE WIND (1960) Not Rated Starring Spencer Tracy, Fredric March and Gene Kelly. Directed by Stanley Kramer. Based on a real-life case in 1925, two great lawyers argue the case for and against a science teacher … Continue reading →

Hosted by YWCA Arizona – STAT-Stand Together Arizona Training & Advocacy “The STAT team is back from Montgomery, Alabama after attending Equal Justice Initiative’s Peace and Justice Summit, as well as the opening of the Legacy Museum: From Enslavement to … Continue reading →

Hosted by LUCHA – Living United for Change in Arizona and Mi Familia Vota “Join LUCHA and Mi Familia Vota for a Community Conversation on What’s Next for Arizona! Community members are invited to come and share the issues they … Continue reading →

Fightback Against privatization of VA Hospitals Fightback Against Federal Union Busting We Remember in November ! Flip Congress Nov 6th Purpose of Town hall: Education ourselves and take action – fight back Union busting – what does it mean for … Continue reading →