A few months ago, the internet went wild when it discovered the “Wolves” singer had a doppelgänger in 22-year-old Sofia Solares. However, Twitter recently resurfaced another Gomez look-alike from years ago — and there’s an entirely new reason you might recognize her. Back in 2015, Gomez fans confused Doniya Malik — yes, that would be Zayn Malik ‘s older sister — with the singer, which thus began the question: Are Selena and Zayn related?

Of course, time (and logic) uncovered that the two are not, in fact, related at all. But that doesn’t stop Malik and Gomez from sharing some eerily similar characteristics. And according to the resurrected tweet from years ago drawing the original connection — the two women used to look even more identical when they were younger.

Besides the brunette hair and dark, full brows, Malik even shares the same lip shape as Gomez — something the singer’s fans might call her signature. Alas, Gomez recently bleached her hair platinum blond, meaning the 25-year-old looks a little more like a Kardashian than the sibling of a former One Directioner. Yet, we can’t help but wonder: Has Zayn ever noticed this connection between his girlfriend’s sister’s ex-boyfriend’s ex-girlfriend?