Pages

Monday, December 23, 2013

Thomas Edison—Good Guy or Bad Guy?

Thomas Edison was a much more complex person than generally realized. The Wizard of Menlo
Park was a character in the Steve Dancy Tale, The Return. In researching this iconic inventor, I learned that he was single-minded
when he got something stuck in his head. This worked exceptionally well for solving
a puzzle like finding a proper filament for his light bulb, but didn’t work so
well in his personal relationships. His fixated behavior also didn’t enhance
the business side of his groundbreaking discoveries. Edison made enemies. Sometimes, as with J. P. Morgan, he made
enemies out of longtime friends and supporters.

Portraying real persons in fiction can be risky. The author has an
obligation to reflect their character and actions honestly. After all, they are
generally defenseless to an assault by the mighty pen. There is another problem
with historical characters. In fiction,
if you deviate too much from the common image of an historical character, you
can disrupt the flow of the story. As the reporter famously said in The Man Who Shot Liberty Valance, “When the legend becomes fact,
print the legend.”

Kindly Genius?

Or Intense Competitor?

In The Return, I tread
carefully around Edsion’s image as a gentle genius, but I also dropped hints about
his peculiar personal behavior and his ability to be just downright mean. I had
a story to tell, and I included Edison in a Western to show that at the same time people struggled
to settle a raw frontier, other pioneers in New York City were reinventing the
world.

Nonfiction, of course, is completely different. In a history book, it is
important to tell the unvarnished truth about people and events. When I was
approached to assist with Glenn Beck’s new book, Miracles and Massacres, I accepted because Beck insisted that this
book would tell it like it really was. It was a fun experience, and the final
product is unique. It explains underplayed episodes of American history in an
engaging story format.

So, was Thomas Edison a good guy or bad guy? Get the book and decide for
yourself. As Joe Friday used to say, “Just the facts, ma’am, just the facts.”

Note: The Dragnet character Sargent Joe Friday
never said, “Just the facts, ma’am, just the facts,” but as noted earlier, “When
the legend becomes fact, print the legend.”

No comments:

Post a Comment

Home to The Steve Dancy Tales

"The James Best books...are about the best new Western series to come along since Larry McMurtry."—Larry Winget, True West Magazine

"James D. Best is arguably one of the best writers of westerns." —Alan Caruba, Bookviews

"I have to say its one of the best western books I’ve read in a long time. The characters, the plot, everything seem so real. You’ll find yourself lost in the book—the fast pace keeps it interesting." — Maritza Barone, Woman'sDay