I know it's an old thread but the best I've found has been Ursa Major face wash http://www.ursamajorvt.com/products/fantastic-face-wash it's not cheap, the 4 oz is about 12 dollars BUT you literally need only the tiniest amount , like the size of a small pea (maybe like a 3mm drop) then you rub your hands together and it foams up, the scent is light and natural and perfect (hints of spearmint and sage. Rinses clean and balances your skin. i was skeptical at first, something i was eyeballing for about a year and finally boght some and I will definitely be buying more. It lives up to the hype. I have oil/dry skin (forehead gets very oily) and other washes have worked well but then a few hours on and my forehead seems almost more oily but with this it's "normal" all day. Amazon sells it too but if you buy direct they send you three free samples, nicely packaged and it's the same price unless you have amazon prime.