If this is your first visit, be sure to
check out the FAQ by clicking the
link above. You may have to register
before you can post: click the register link above to proceed. To start viewing messages,
select the forum that you want to visit from the selection below.

To me the Yankees going into 2013 with Romine/Cervelli/Stewart as their catchers shows a defeatist mentality.

Not only are they penny pinching, but they also don't care about the overall teams performance.

Cervelli - Yes, he brings energy but he is downright terrible overall.

Romine - I like giving the kids a shot but he's coming off a major back injury.

Stewart - Great defender, solid arm behind the plate, frames balls well but given consistent ABs he won't hit enough.

The Yankees need for another catcher is extremely important.
You need a proven field general leading this team and calling the shots behind home.
AJ Pierzynski, even with his flaws, fills that role for us perfectly given the bad market and poor solutions now.

apparently fans want a change but when change comes they dont like it and want to go back to the old ways of doing things thats lead to NOTHING. so yeah let the yankees spend on brand name over sane direction

allowing romine and cervelli to catch isnt a defeated mentality, thats the stupidest thing ive read and the yankees arent even going to do that I just wish they did, they will say thats their plan but its not. the team needs to transition and have a couple of down years for the sake of the overall health and direction

apparently fans want a change but when change comes they dont like it and want to go back to the old ways of doing things thats lead to NOTHING. so yeah let the yankees spend on brand name over sane direction

allowing romine and cervelli to catch isnt a defeated mentality, thats the stupidest thing ive read and the yankees arent even going to do that I just wish they did, they will say thats their plan but its not. the team needs to transition and have a couple of down years for the sake of the overall health and direction

And your telling me that is not a defeatist mentality?...

The thought of the Yankees having a "couple of down years" makes me upset.
No way should the Yankees be aiming to have multiple bad seasons just to transition. C'mon now. That's giving up.

The mindset should be on winning, every single year. When you have a 189 Million dollar payroll coming off of a 95 win season, the mindset is to win, not to have a bad season or an offseason that leads to multiple bad/losing seasons ahead for the sake of transition. That doesn't work in New York.

They can easily transition into prospects (Romine included) but still bring in improvements from outside the organization to give the Major League team a shot at winning.

A player like Pierzynski is a perfect example and a great bridge to Gary Sanchez.

Austin Romine and Francisco Cervelli are notches below AJ's level at this point. A 1 year / 2 year deal wouldn't hurt.

The thought of the Yankees having a "couple of down years" makes me upset.
No way should the Yankees be aiming to have multiple bad seasons just to transition. C'mon now. That's giving up.

The mindset should be on winning, every single year. When you have a 189 Million dollar payroll coming off of a 95 win season, the mindset is to win, not to have a bad season or an offseason that leads to multiple bad/losing seasons ahead for the sake of transition. That doesn't work in New York.

They can easily transition into prospects (Romine included) but still bring in improvements from outside the organization to give the Major League team a shot at winning.

A player like Pierzynski is a perfect example and a great bridge to Gary Sanchez.

Austin Romine and Francisco Cervelli are notches below AJ's level at this point. A 1 year / 2 year deal wouldn't hurt.

every team aims to win, no team is purposely going to go into a season to lose, but its part of baseball you rise and you fall, for the sake of the team i hope they have some bad stretches, not only for the sake of us getting younger and out of these dumb contracts but for the sake of baseball, I want more diversity to be spread around the league, I wish every fan base can experience what us yankee fans take for granted.

pierzynski isnt a bridge to gary sanchez cause gary sanchez wont be ready in a year, pierzinsky is just a one year patch hole that probably doesnt make a difference to our lineup who has bigger issues than catcher. I rather see what I can get from romine and cervelli and use my limited resources for RF and 3b