Herding is not good, following you around is great. Big difference. When herding, the dog will often crouch, will focus on its target's feet, and will nip at its target if the target doesn't go where it's 'supposed' to go. Herding is a muted remna...

I, too, think that doggie jail is punishment. Even the dog that was "crate trained" thinks so. If the two dogs sleep next to each other then Someone did Something right, so congratulations. I'm curious if you're still getting herded or if that sto...