Nick (played by Jake Johnson) can’t possibly fall for the sot’s time-traveling claims, can he? Maybe it’ll make a difference when the older man – who bears a striking resemblance to the law-school dropout — knows everything that’s going to happen to him in the coming years. (And after Nick’s Season 1 finale freak-out about moving in with Caroline, just the latest event in his sad-sack love life, we’d bet you a beer that his version of events isn’t rosy.) Perhaps the strange encounter will be just the thing to get Nick moving in Jess’ direction…

In addition to playing Justified’s Arlo, Barry’s long list of TV credits includes Cold Case, The Closer and Lost. He also portrayed Capt. Lou Jacobs in the Denzel Washington-Ethan Hawke cop drama Training Day.