Amy‘s Enchanted co-star James Marsden recently spoke with E! about why a sequal never happened.

“We all hoped it would happen,” James said. “I don’t understand why they never did it. It was a very successful movie…But at some point when the gray hairs start coming, you can’t really play the quintessential animated prince anymore.”

“If it happens, great! If not, what are you going to do?”

WOULD YOU LIKE TO SEE Amy Adams and James Marsden in an Enchanted sequel?