I would like to introduce myself. I'm Holly Creek and have been a Realtor for almost 25 years and I hope very much to be yours. Almost anyone can become a Realtor, but it takes a very special person to be one who is totally sensitive to the needs and desires of a client.

Born and raised in Rochester, Holly has almost 25 successful years in real estate. She is the #1 agent in the Rochester area and the #1 agent at Nothnagle Realtors.

Holly’s exceptional marketing and advertising techniques are second to none. Her combination of knowledge, networking connections and dedication combined with a passionate delivery, create a truly remarkable service for her clients.

Holly is a proven performer and tough negotiator. Her highly competent and professional manner keeps her consistently rated as the #1 agent. Let her continued success be in your future!

We will succeed together. As you have seen, my marketing plan is first and foremost, a plan. I will work to sell your home in a focused, creative and aggressive way. I will stay on the job until the job is done. Your goals direct my efforts. I will communicate with you regularly, so that I know when your thoughts or plans change. I will remain positive. I will remain honest. I will tell you what I am thinking...in a timely way.

Let us begin.

Call me today at (585)400-4000

My Team

My office is state-of-the-art. I have a eight-member expert Sales Team averaging over 15 years experience, pledging you the highest level of service possible. The specialized team will always be available and ready to help you on a moment's notice. You will also have the resources of a full-time Director of Operations, Director of Marketing, a full time Listing Coordinator and a full time Transaction Coordinator. All the details of buying or selling a home will have their full attention.

All information is deemed accurate but not guaranteed. The properties displayed may not be all of the properties available through the Broker Reciprocity Program (IDX Program). Any use of this site other than by potential home buyers or sellers is strictly prohibited. 2017 Elmira-Corning Regional Board of REALTORS®. Listings updated daily.

My Reviews

“Holly and her team did a great job selling our existing home and helping us find our new home. I especially appreciated Holly's individual customer service when we were purchasing our new home (Holly personally came over to our house on a Sunday evening to deliver paperwork). I highly recommend Holly Creek!”
-Jill Schultz

“I have worked with Holly and her team on multiple home sales/purchases and find their knowledge of the Rochester market place to be second to none. If you are buying or selling your home in the area, Holly and her team help you every step of the way to ensure you get the most value in your real estate transactions. Their marketing services make the entire process a great experience.”
-Jeff Nardoci

“Holly and her team did a great job marketing our home and selling it within one week in this challenging real estate market!"
-Shannon O'Grady

“Holly and her team helped me sell my parents home in Sodus Point after my father passed away. We were in a rush to move the property so we could close the Estate and care for my mother. Mind you, this is in the middle of the recession and the lakefront housing market was a disaster at that time. We were in a rush but did not want to give the property away either. Holly and her team aggressively marketed the house, their knowledge of the area and the market conditions led to a successful sale at a fair price. I could not have been happier with the performance and the result. I will use her again when I buy my next house.”
-Steve Glaser

“When I wanted to sell my millon dollar home in a difficult real estate market, I called the best in town. Holly Creek and her team delivered above my expectations. Thanks Holly"
-Cliff Gibson

“Holly and her Team helped our family make the move we dreamed of possible despite a tough local real estate environment. She immediately provided insight and direction and I would certainly recommend her to any serious seller or buyer. Do not put your best investment into the hands of anyone else.”
-Tom Kehoe

“Holly is a consummate real estate professional with unsurpassed knowledge of the Greater Rochester, NY real estate market. Holly is highly responsive and gives you the unvarnished truth - a rare commodity in any field. I would recommend her highly.”
-Michael Crowley

“Holly, and her team of professionals, marketed two entirely different properties for us in the past year with similarly outstanding results. Under her direction, they achieved maximum sales results in a short time. They are detail oriented, very timely in all their actions, communicated faithfully and were imaginative in meeting both buyers and sellers needs. We would easily recommend them to anyone interested in property in the market.”
-Charla/Charlie Henningsen

"Holly listed and sold two of our residences. She knows the opportunities and the challenges in the marketplace ...and was effective at using this knowledge."
-Don and Ann Turrell

“Holly and her staff were thorough, dedicated, diligent, direct, persistent, and disciplined in the approach to selling our house. When it was time to sell again we called Holly....and she didn't let us down..the same attentive approach brought good results again. I recommend her without reservation.”
-Sue Ingalls

Bonita and I would like to THANK YOU VERY MUCH for your assistance in the sale of our property this past August. It was wonderful to work with a true professional in their field that not only understood our requirements for the sale, but actual worked close with the tenants in our building and the perspective buyers. MOST IMPORTANT, you also made sure that Bonita and I were kept informed of the progress of the sale all during this period. Of course we will refer the Holly Creek Team to our friends and acquaintances. " Bonita & Dennis Stanko

Below are some of the properties that successfully sold within the last year (9/26/2016 and 9/26/2017)