who died and made Will judge and juror? he was wrong and is responsible for his own actions.

That is neither here nor there IMO though, one way or the other, Nick was going to find a way to keep him out.

John and Benjy.

well they do fit the died criteria, but EJ was not even the one to kill them.

Not for lack of trying, lol.

I don't agree that it's EJ's "fault" that Will shot him only because I don't think "fault" is the right word. It doesn't particularly matter though. I agree that EJ has a role in the story but I don't agree that he's playing the correct role in the story. And by "the story", I mean every story he is in right now, not just as it applies to Will. But no worries. EJ isn't the only one in the wrong role. As a matter of fact, I don't think there's any character on the show that I think is playing the right role in any story. Blech.