It was a reality TV showdown between Love & Hip Hop’s Jessica Dime and Basketball WivesJackie Christie on the latest episode of Hip Hop Squares, but it was an awkward question about Taylor Swift that stole the show. Host DeRay Davis asks Dime, “In the song “Thug Story,” Taylor Swift collaborated with T-Pain to rap about baking cookies and having what in her mouth?”

Of course, this enticed many inappropriate jokes from the cast including a “John Mayer’s guitar” reply from Jessimae Peluso. DC Young Fly was the square chosen to answer the question and surprise, surprise his answer was clutching my pearls worthy. He said, “Balls!” With a shocked look on her face Jessica had to either agree or disagree with DC for a chance to win the money. Can you guess which way she choose? What do you think Swift really had in her mouth? Watch the highlight clip above and see how this wild moment unfolds.