Taking Root

In a rising number of schools, gardens are providing students with
new opportunities for hands-on learning.

Columbia, S.C.

At first, she wasn't sure what to expect. But after six weeks of
toiling and anxiously watching over her 6th grade science project,
Arlene Davis likes the results. In fact, she beams as she talks about
the succulent cucumbers that she helped grow in the garden here at
Summit Parkway Middle School and that were served today in the school
cafeteria. Student-grown zucchini and other squash also shared the
menu.

"Seriously, once you work on it, you cherish the food more," the
bubbly 11-year-old says. "I grew this. My group grew these. And they're
wonderful."

Teachers who have gardened with their classes say that Arlene's
experience is pretty typical for students who take time out to plant
and nurture flowers, vegetables, and fruits. It's just one reason why
gardening is taking root in schools across America as teachers adapt
the activity for science curricula, landscaping projects, fund raising,
or all three.

Thanks to everything from concern over children's diets to marketing
by garden interests to rising environmental awareness, school gardening
is in. And it's gaining popularity in schools even as educators
find themselves pressed to focus classwork on basic academic skills and
raising scores on standardized tests.

"Schools are moving toward outdoor classrooms based around gardens,"
says David Young, the director of youth-garden grants for the National
Gardening Association in Burlington, Vt. "Even if it's just to see the
miracle of something growing."

Tilling soil and planting seeds as a way of cultivating young minds
is hardly new. Long before school property was blanketed in asphalt,
vegetables and flowers often lined campuses. At the turn of the
century, the philosopher and educator John Dewey extolled gardening as
a way to avoid the "evil" of isolated instruction. Gardening, he added,
built understanding of nature and the nation's agrarian legacy, and
roused student curiosity.

During World War II, the government urged schools to plant "victory
gardens" to help meet domestic food demands. By reaching students,
federal officials felt that they could inspire their parents to garden
as well.

Later, however, as the country's school-agepopulation grew and
became more urban, most botanical projects moved inside from school
grounds to classrooms, parsed into individual science lessons. The
shift meant children received less hands-on schooling on the full life
cycle of plants, from seeds, to blooms, to decomposition.

"The trouble is that children don't get exposed to it elsewhere,"
says Mary S. Rivkin, an associate professor of early-childhood
education at the University of Maryland Baltimore County. She has
written extensively on what she sees as the cognitive, emotional, and
physical benefits of getting students out of classrooms and into
natural environments. Rivkin is part of a larger school "greening"
movement that promotes gardens, wetlands, trees, and the preservation
of a school's natural habitat.

Mother Nature, she says, helps introduce flavor, fragance, texture,
and adventure to the curriculum. "When students are involved with all
their senses, that's where learning is really strong."

More schools appear to be coming around to Rivkin's point of
view.

For instance, when it opened and began providing garden-based
curriculum development and teacher training in 1979, the Life Lab
Science Program in Santa Cruz, Calif., served one school. Today, the
non-profit group works with more than 1,000 schools from Alaska to
Maine.

"We have to help teachers see how gardening is an extension of what
they do, and not just something extra," said Lisa Glick, the director
of education and outreach for Life Lab.

In the 1997-98 school year, the National Gardening Association
received more than 2,000 applications for its 300 youth-garden grants.
Each grant through the 16-year-old program is worth $750 in products
and educational materials. "It's become quite competitive," Young
notes.

Some observers predict that expanded access to information,
expertise, and funding will further nurture the trend.

Advocates say getting students outdoors and rooting around in
school gardens can teach them valuable lessons about the
environment, as well as good nutrition.

"Kids are losing the connection with their environment....Parents
hesitate to let their kids run and explore the way they did," says Mary
Ann Patterson, the spokeswoman for the American Horticultural Society.
Based in Alexandria, Va., the group expects 400 educators and youth
leaders to attend its sixth annual children's gardening symposium,
which opens July 30 in Washington. "That's one of the reasons they're
bringing back the school garden."

On top of that, proponents argue that gardening offers a perfect
means of beautifying bland and uninspired school landscapes while also
cultivating learning.

"The exciting part is that you can teach across the curriculum,"
Young says. "From science to math and social studies."

But for all of its potential, some education experts say that
gardening will fall short as an educational tool without careful
planning. And there may be better ways to achieve one's learning
objectives.

"From my point of view, gardening isn't the end, but an occasion for
learning about science, or math, or history," said Andrew Ahlgren, the
associate director of Project 2061, a long-term science education
project run by the American Association for the Advancement of Science
in Washington. "One would want to consider not how interesting it is,
but what is the payoff in terms of general literacy."

For Arlene Marturano, a 6th grade science teacher at the 900-student
Summit Parkway Middle School here in the South Carolina capital,
nutrition is the academic hook for her garden project. Marturano's
spring science classes have finished the year with a six-week segment
on nutrition gardening for each of the past six years. Her students--a
mix of rich and poor, and black and white--begin by studying and
identifying the nutritional value of produce.

From there, they draft plans for their plots and give them catchy
names such as the Garden of Bitter and Sweet and the Garden of
Seedin.

In California, state Superintendent Delaine Eastin wants a garden
in every one of the state's nearly 8,000 K-12 schools by
2000.

Next, using bedding plants donated by local nurseries, the careful
young gardeners plant 8-by-12-foot plots (there are 35 in all) in a
tree-ringed garden at the base of a hill 50 yards from the school.

Working in small teams, the students spend up to three 45-minute
periods each week preparing their soil and planting. The pace slows to
just one 45-minute session a week as they water, weed, and add mulch
and compost, partly composed of food scraps collected for the class by
cafeteria workers.

Marturano relies on strict organization and a firm but gentle
management style to keep classes of up to 30 students on task. During a
recent class, she coaches students to do a better job weeding: "That's
Bermuda grass," she says. "It makes a good golf course, but a lousy
garden."

After six weeks, the students' work is rewarded as brilliant red
strawberries, burly cucumbers, and sturdy squash explode from under
leafy canopies. Once harvested, their trophies are served in the
cafeteria.

As 12-year-old Keith Green tends to his "Grocery Garden," he
concedes: "In the beginning, it wasn't looking so good. The eggplant
died, and so did the watermelon. But the tomato and cucumber came
up."

Marturano has started a statewide network of school gardeners and
already has 300 subscribers to her twice-yearly newsletter. Her next
goal is for her school to grow all of its own produce. It would save
money and, more importantly, encourage better dietary habits, she
says.

"You can't get children to change eating habits in one class," she
reflects. "But gardening is a way to get kids to eat vegetables. I want
them to think of vegetables as a fast food that can be eaten raw."

Across the country in California, state Superintendent of Public
Instruction Delaine Eastin wants a garden in every one of the state's
nearly 8,000 K-12 schools by 2000.

In fact, one of her first acts after being elected to the post in
1994 was to launch her "a garden in every school" initiative. The
program is run by the state department of education's nutrition
education and training program.

A 1996 survey found that 1,000 California schools used gardens for
instructional purposes. That's a far cry from Eastin's goal, but the
numbers are increasing. Earlier this year, the department awarded
$170,000 in gardening grants to 70 school districts, using funds from
the state, and from U.S. Department of Agriculture nutrition-training
grants. Another 350 California schools are expected to be awarded
grants by the fall.

Meanwhile, the state and the University of California, Davis, are
monitoring a model school-garden project at the 800-student St. Helena
Elementary School in the vineyard-rich Napa Valley. The university is
studying whether St. Helena's student gardeners eat more vegetables
than their nongardening peers. "Not many of these studies have been
done," Tamannaie says. "But as interest heats up, more researchers will
ask these questions."

While eager to champion plant projects, garden experts urge
educators to ease into the work.

"Gardens sound like a good idea, but people get in over their heads
and start too quickly," says Young of the National Gardening
Association.

He suggests first assembling a team of interested adults, such as
teachers and community volunteers. The support of school administrators
and maintenance crews, whose members often control water supplies and
tool supplies, is essential, he adds. And local master gardeners are
also often eager volunteers.

Potential vandalism and other security issues also must be
addressed.

Adds Young: "From stolen strawberries to people taking trucks and
doing wheelies right on a field, you name it, it's all happened."

At Mellichamp Elementary School 25 miles south of Columbia in the
rural community of Orangeburg, S.C., teachers, students, and parents
have covered the ground behind their school with a 200-yard swath of
young trees, bushes, and dazzling flowers.

Mellichamp Elementary, where most of the 325 students are black and
from low-income backgrounds, is part of a growing number of schools
with grounds that serve as integrated habitats for gardens, native
plants, and wildlife. In other words, no space is too small for a
milk-jug bird feeder, a rosebush, cornstalks, or anything with green
leaves and roots.

Last month, Mellichamp was selected from a slate of contenders
across South Carolina to win a school environmental award. As part of
the recognition, the school was featured all that month on television
public-service announcements.

Mellichamp's efforts began five years ago with a 5-by-12-foot garden
plot for special education students. After one of the severely disabled
pupils died, the school created a memorial garden around a bench and a
Yoshino cherry tree. School officials then waited and watched to see if
students would respect the new addition to their playground.

While eager to champion plant projects, garden experts urge
educators to ease into the work.

After a year passed with no damage, a few teachers spearheaded a
more ambitious effort to create a lush habitat of dozens of trees and
bushes along the back of the school. Since then, the movement has
spread like kudzu.

"Teachers saw what was going on and put flowers in the school yard.
It's contagious," says Principal Beverly Stroman-Spires. "Kids can see
a change. There's something here now that wasn't here before, and they
had a hand in it. That's meaningful."

A five-member habitat panel oversees the project and is drafting a
garden curriculum aligned with state academic standards. The group also
raises money for the habitat. Lollipops are sold, for example, to pay
for 75 to 100 pounds of birdseed a week.

Not only does Mellichamp's verdant campus teem with butterflies and
birds, but it also lends itself to wide-ranging academic options.
Today, the natural settings provide soothing backdrops for "reading
centers," or clusters of picnic tables for students. In March, 11
volunteers from the federal AmeriCorps national-service organization
built an outdoor classroom and a 100-yard pine-bark walkway through the
magnolia trees, plum trees, and other labeled plants in the school's
main habitat area.

Also this spring, students built a "literature garden" consisting of
eight 4-by-15-foot plots, each one linked to a book they have read. For
example, The Jack and the Beanstalk garden features Jack's
Shack, a 5-foot-tall wooden frame with bean plants growing up its
base.

Nearby, the "ABC Garden" showcases a plant for each letter in the
alphabet, from aster to zinnia.

During a recent schoolwide exhibit in the garden, 9-year-old Thomas
Russell tells two dozen 2nd graders gathered around him about the ABC
Garden, which he helped grow. He sounds as wise as an old farmer.

"Are you ready to learn something important about plants?" the 4th
grader asks with genuine enthusiasm. "If you know the plant, treat it
right, and be nice to it, it will grow."

Thanks to Thomas and others, Mellichamp Elementary School is in
bloom, in more ways than one.

"We see a lot of new pride in teachers," says Melissa Smith, one of
the school's habitat leaders. "It's a big deal to be a teacher at
Mellichamp now."

Notice: We recently upgraded our comments. (Learn more here.) If you are logged in as a subscriber or registered user and already have a Display Name on edweek.org, you can post comments. If you do not already have a Display Name, please create one here.

Ground Rules for Posting
We encourage lively debate, but please be respectful of others. Profanity and personal attacks are prohibited. By commenting, you are agreeing to abide by our user agreement.
All comments are public.