I'll go with Ronnie Brown at this point. I would go with Cadillac but he's had some issues with injuries (although that's in part due to Gruden running him into the ground). Brandon Jacobs isn't in the same class as these guys because he hasn't proven anything as a starter.

Anyway, Jacobs doesn't really deserve to be in the conversation. Not counting o-line's and supporting cast, just pure talent and skill, it goes Ronnie Brown, then Caddy,..........................then Jacobs.

Location: Oh please give me a good reputation. I'm so concerned with what you think about me!

Posts: 2,731

Reputation: 215

I can't wait to see Jacobs as a starter. I still remember his first play as a rookie. Takes the ball off tackle, right side and barrels for about 20 yards.
He's going to be punishing defenses all year. At this point i'd go

Brandon Jacobs will be average at best. Do you know how easy it is to be a back-up? Especially Tiki Barber's back-up? No one game planned for him. Have you ever heard of Troy Hambrick? He was the hear apparent to Emmitt Smith. Having 100 yard and 2 TD games all the time. Talking smack and saying he is better than Emmitt. Then Emmitt leaves, and teams game plan for him, and now lets just say he is out of the league. People are going to suprised by the lack of production from Jacobs.

1) Caddilac
2) Brown
3) Jacobs
Jacobs will be able to prove himself this year and I think he will be great, but hes more one demintional(spelling) whereas Brown and Caddy can do other things. Jacobs wont burn anybody, but Caddy and Brown can and they demonstrate power.