For those that believe Gilbride is a really good coach please ask yourself 1 question

If this is your first visit, be sure to
check out the FAQ by clicking the
link above. You may have to register
before you can post: click the register link above to proceed. To start viewing messages,
select the forum that you want to visit from the selection below.

6th most points in the league - ouch big time struggle - SO Hilarious that he has a top rated offense -ITS HIS OFFENSE - he installed it - you don't inherit it. He has got it done with different personnel for 9 years. Im not saying he is amazing - but cmon - stats dont lie. and again TC thinks he's pretty good but again you must know better then one of the best coaches in our history - as do most of you on these boards.

I've said this before....when Eli is playing lights-out, Gilbride looks like a ****ing genius.

But in my opinion, having a QB that can hit bombs is more a reflection on the QB than the coordinator.

I'm sure if the Giants had Drew Brees, everyone would be singing Gilbride's praises.

But substitute Christian Ponder for Eli Manning, and it would become apparent just how much of a share of the offensive success belongs with Eli Manning.

There's a reason why the Giants beat the Patriots twice on their final drives.......and that was Eli Manning, not Gilbride.

Gilbride is an NFL-caliber assistant, but that's about the most I'll say about him.

I disagree. His time pasted 10 years ago, sadly, hes been here for Eli's tenure and we cant get rid of him; as it would disrupt Elis progress...YAWN!

It will be a good day when KG is not the OC anymore. If I had his experience, I promise you this team would be unstoppable offensively. His disconnect with player personnel is astounding, in a bad way.

His one out of the ordinary play was actually stolen from me. I'd love to be joking but unfortunately its not a joke. He actually took a play I designed several days earlier and used it on the first play of the drive; although he decided to use bradshaw, who got caught after a huge gain, whereas Wilson woulda took it to the house.Again, lack of confidence and player personnel bit us (somewhat) on that play. Granted we won the game convincingly anyways but still, that wuld have been a nice time to use Wilson; unless he though it would be too obvious....suuuuuuuuuuuure!

It's not all on Gilbride, I never said it was ALL HIS FAULT. Part of it is in fact execution, injuries, etc etc.

The reason I question Gilbride more is because we were I believe 2nd in the league in scoring I believe at one point? Then all of a sudden our offense production to a HUGE drop. So it's either all of our players forgot how to play football, or something in the game plan is not working.

The part of the game plan that wasn't working was the part where the players had to go on the field and make blocks, hit holes, make throws, and get open. That's where we struggled. The players weren't holding up their part of the bargain. Couple that with the defense being a complete ****ing sieve, and we were forced out of whatever gameplan KG may have designed.

The part of the game plan that wasn't working was the part where the players had to go on the field and make blocks, hit holes, make throws, and get open. That's where we struggled. The players weren't holding up their part of the bargain. Couple that with the defense being a complete ****ing sieve, and we were forced out of whatever gameplan KG may have designed.

So what about that second Redskins game? Played pretty well in the first half, then decided to run on a great run defense but not throw on a terrible pass defense.