Post Tagged with: "The Scientist"

As a good chemist I always defend drug companies when I hear people attack their integrity. I can’t help but roll my eyes when I hear the benefits of herbal remedies, and can’t help but wince when I hear people advocate only eating natural non-chemical containing foods. Even I will have to mellow these attitudes after The Scientist uncovered a deal Merck made with Elsevier to publish a fake medical journal for an undisclosed sum of money.

I always feel the readers of Chemistry Blog should draw their own conclusions, so here are the .PDFs for the 1st and 2nd issue of the journal: 1st, 2nd

My findings and take on each issue of the fake journal are summarized below.

Summary from my Perusal of the 1st issue of the Australasian Journal of Bone and Joint Medicine.

Total Quantity

Article Type

# Merck Products

# other Company Products

Conclusion

6

International News

0

0

2

Review Articles

1

1

Aledronate is Good

2

Abstracts

0

0

1

Commentary

0

0

9

Conference Highlights

2

0

Aledronate Effective

2

Case Report

0

0

2

Ads

2

0

Fosamax, Vioxx

Out of 22 articles only 3 show Merck in a good light. The other articles are general information pieces that a doctor might be interested in. Doesn’t really seem too evil, but here are the stats from the next issue.

Summary from my Perusal of the 2nd issue of the Australasian Journal of Bone and Joint Medicine.

Out of 24 articles 15 show Merck in a good light. Two of them show Merck’s drugs work better than competition. Any pretense of legitimacy to any ethical standard is completely lost when 63% of the stories are favorable to Merck. I can understand highlighting articles favorable to your company, but to go through all the hoops to make your own look-a-like peer-review journal seems over the top, ridiculous, and tarnishes science.

Chemistry Twitterverse

Last updated: 0.5 minutes agoRT @biominerals Please RT new TT position in Geochemistry of Near Surface Environments at the University of Minnesota! Excellent departme… →RT @LeiliMortazavi Because of Trump's #travelban, I'm not able to present at SfN @Neurosci2018, which would have been a great stepping sto… →@WorkentinChem Me too. She’s much more adventurous than I ever was (or am now!) →@wfpaxton I do my best proof reading after hitting "submit" →@ihearttheroad Dude, my college did NOT have Bon Appétit-rated fare. →@TomChivers It's almost like the news media chooses to report things that don't happen very often... →RT @gravity_levity 1/ Who wants to hear some scientific intrigue?
A few weeks ago, a group of physical chemists posted a paper online an… →