This is my 2nd pair of the same style. My first pair fit perfectly and lasted more than 3 years. My weight loss combined with them being a little stretched out caused me to order the same style again. Interestingly, they were a little tight, but not unbearable. They are now breaking in nicely (the 1st pair did not need breaking in). I love the soles on these and the are so much more comfortable than flat flip flops.