Constructing or rejecting the notion of other in senior university management: the cases of Ireland and Sweden

Abstract:

We focus on gender stereotypes in West European university management by comparing two
countries: Sweden and Ireland. In secular Sweden there are strong policies that are implemented
at all political levels supported by the public discourse; while in Ireland such measures are few
and the equality infrastructures and discourse have been weakened by the state. In Sweden
women have come to dominate the Rector/President/Vice Chancellor positions and each gender
has between 40 and 50 per cent of the other leading positions. In Ireland there are no women in
the top position and their percentage of other leading positions is between 13-25 per cent.
Drawing on interview data from senior ‘manager academics’ (Deem, 2003) in Irish and Swedish
universities this article shows that in Sweden traditional gender stereotypes are not credible
anymore-with senior manager-academics not seeing such stereotypes as mirroring reality. Thus,
even if they acknowledge the existence of stereotypes, they distance themselves from them. In
Ireland traditional stereotypes still have more of a grip on manager-academics. These country
differences are seen in the context of different gender orders in the respective countries. It
seems that more areas are still gendered in Irish society in comparison with Sweden, and the
gender order is stronger and more hierarchical. Thus it appears that by actively recruiting
women in leading positions in a societal context that supports feminist values, traditional stereotypes
may be reduced. On the other hand gendered stereotypes in the absence of such a
context reflect and reinforce patterns that legitimise and valorise men’s and women’s positions
within hierarchical gendered structures.

This item appears in the following Collection(s)

Related items

The reality of discrimination within the university system has been recognised by, for example, the Committee of Vice Chancellors and Principals in the UK (CVCP, 1991), and the President of MIT in the US (MIT, 1999). In a ...

This article describes the formation of a family rights project in
Limerick. It explains how the project came to focus on a rather
narrow legalistic definition of parental rights, typified as a 'male
agenda'. It explores ...

Tourism and other kinds of local development have become important elements, in
generating employment in rural Ireland. Yet, despite a commitment to local participation and to
gender auditing, women are typically ...

In contemporary Irish Society there is considerable uneasiness about both the existence of and threats to the ‘patriarchal dividend’ (O’Connell, 1995a:82). It is suggested that this wider social and cultural context, ...