I do like this product, but find for myself, I only used it for short times, that is, it is not something that lasts quite long on my eyelids. I think that people who have oilier eyelids, it wears off easily. If I am going out for a short time, it is great as a quick touch-up, but for something longer lasting, I prefer the gel liner.

3.5/5

Value

Quality

Effectiveness

Recommended?
You Betcha!

Anonymous

December 10, 2013

I have this colour in Teddy, which is my go-to brown eyeliner. While it is easy to use, I find it difficult to get a clean finish on the outside of my eye. Great eyeliner, but it is pricey.

I have heard a lot of great reviews on this product, so I thought I would try it out this summer. Unfortunately it was a bust for me. I bought the color Smolder, nice color. I can't use it on my waterline...doesn't last very long, smudges like crazy. On top of my lashes, I have to be careful how far and how thick, it runs up into my eye shadow. Perhaps this type of formulation is not suitable for my skin type? I may try it once again in the fall/winter when it's not so hot...but we will see.

I can give it high marks for the quality of the product though, nice texture, intense pigments for the color and it glides on easily.

Love this eyeliner! This is my first MAC product, i will definitely be checking out other products from this line now! I use this pencil when i want a dramatic eye, it works perfectly and smudges easily without being so creamy that its hard to work with. Excellent on the waterline as well!

I've heard so much about this eyeliner and even seen it on others and it always looked amazing. I got mine in the famous "smolder". I love how easy it glides on and the pigmentation is very BOLD so I don't need to go over more than once. However, I am having mixed emotions on the creamy texture that also makes it very easy to smudge. I think I will be using this eyeliner mostly to wear on my top lids when I want a more dramatic smudged look because when I put this on my water line, it smears like crazy! In all, I love this product! Just wish it had more staying power for the waterline.

These reviews are the subjective opinions of ChickAdvisor members and not of ChickAdvisor Inc.