I like my big screen S3 but doubt I'd want to go any bigger than 5"...

Whereas me, typing this on a note 2, wants a wider screen than I have now, but I don't want to compromise on power. I do, however think that the 'S pen' is a bit of a gimmick; I don't use it all that often, so I wouldn't be missing that.

I like my big screen S3 but doubt I'd want to go any bigger than 5"...

Whereas me, typing this on a note 2, wants a wider screen than I have now, but I don't want to compromise on power. I do, however think that the 'S pen' is a bit of a gimmick; I don't use it all that often, so I wouldn't be missing that.

I have to admit, I've never really handled anything larger, let alone lived with one so could potentially be converted!

I must admit I have now got use to the size of my galaxy note after a year of ownership. it doesnt look at big to me now. I cant see going much bigger though than what my note is. I have a year left on my contract so I guess I will wait for the S5 or note4

I must admit I have now got use to the size of my galaxy note after a year of ownership. it doesnt look at big to me now. I cant see going much bigger though than what my note is. I have a year left on my contract so I guess I will wait for the S5 or note4
I dont use the stylus either.

How would someone even use a 6.3" or 7" phablet? I have great difficulty imagining my using my Nexus 7 as a phone given it's 3/4 the size of my head. I want some reasonable size, but decent build quality and spec phones back on the market. Bring back 4.3"!

I won't buy a phone larger than 4.5 inches because it is just impractically large. And I have extremely large hands. My current phone is a Lumia 800 at 3.8" and I'm wary about upgrading to the 4.3" 720. What use could such a large phone have?

I fail to understand how this can be marketed as a phone, when in reality it is a tablet with phone functionality.
I already consider the S3 as being too large for a phone, so this just doesn't appeal to me at all.

When I first heard that Asus were bringing out a 7" Phablet I chuckled - then I watched their promo video, and apart from all the usual BS, it did bring to my attention one very important point:

I use the 'smart' functions of my phone (replying to emails, surfing the interwebz, social networking, games etc...) much more than I use it for phonecalls, then of the time I use it for calls - more than 85% of that time I am making calls in-car (via in-car Bluetooth) or at home....I do find the limitations of using the smart functions of the phone is the screen size.

So it brought about the question:

Given that I use the screen more than I use the phone, how bad is holding a 7" phablet to your head?

So to put this to the test - I got the kids kindle fire HD and pretended it was phone and held it to my head - I am 6'2" tall and less than slight in build - sure it looks a bit weird maybe a little unnatural right now, but the unit was solid in my hand and from a functional perspective a phone this size would work...I passed it to my missus to try, at 5'5" tall and slight of build it probably highlights that 7" is about as big as people can manage, still it fitted well in her hands and would still work.

My thoughts are:

As technology develops further and the 'smart' functions integrate more with our lives, the options to have a larger screen becomes more desireable (high speed 4g or increased wifi spots increase this desire especially if video calling becomes a more capable mainstream function than niche) are either manufacturers get innovative with phones that have extendable screens (telescopic? Fold-out?) ..... or we embrace 7" phablets or do we carry/use both tablets and phones?

1) It's not portable enough to be a useful phone for 99% of people.
2) It is exponentially more likely to break if you do carry it around everywhere.

I was one of the early adopters of the "phablet" with a Dell Streak, and whilst it was a fine mobile browsing/gaming device, looked good and made phone calls, it was also impossible not to break on several occasions.

So I did the sensible thing and moved to a smaller smartphone and got a free Nexus 7 into the bargain.

...I use the 'smart' functions of my phone ... much more than I use it for phonecalls, ...

I suspect that is true for a great number of users - perhaps even the majority. Additionally many of those that use them for a lot of calls often use some form of Bluetooth earpiece (or in-car Bluetooth as you mentioned).

I don't own a "smart phone"; I sit in front of a computer most of my work day and have more than one at home as well as a tablet so I haven't felt that I needed one (plus data plans in Canada are stupidly expensive). If / when I buy a "smart phone" it will most likely be a phablet. It's the option that makes the most sense to me.

__________________Regardless of what you believe there is someone at least as smart, or smarter, than you who believes something you think is stupid (and it's not just because you know something they don't).