Recording: Reyna shot woman in Collier trailer because she 'disrespected' him

A LaBelle man admitted to a detective that he shot a woman four times in 2014 because she “disrespected” him, according to a recorded interview played during his trial Wednesday.

Aaron Reyna, 27, is accused of fatally shooting Dana Fegueroa, 29, on Oct. 6, 2014, in a trailer in the 500 block of Dorothy Billie Jimmie Way on the Seminole reservation in Collier County.

He faces a second-degree murder charge and two charges of shooting into a dwelling. If convicted, he could face up to life in prison.

Both sides rested Wednesday afternoon and are expected to present their closing arguments Thursday morning before the jury begins its deliberations.

Jurors heard from Collier Sheriff’s Office Detective Brian Clervoix, who was the hostage negotiator who talked to Reyna when he was barricaded in the trailer after the shooting. The detective persuaded Reyna to surrender after a 30-minute talk on the phone.

Hall, one of a group of people in the trailer’s living room the night of the shooting, said Fegueroa cursed at Reyna when she asked Reyna’s girlfriend for a ride and Reyna answered for her, telling Fegueroa not to ask her for anything.

“She told him off,” Hall said, referring to Fegueroa.

Fegueroa then left for her room and Reyna soon followed her, he said.

Hall testified he heard a click, as if a revolver was being cocked back, moments later and then four or five shots.

Panicked, Hall ran out of the home but was soon told by one of the other occupants to come back inside.

When Fegueroa’s boyfriend was told by Reyna to go to the room where Fegueroa had been shot, Hall said he followed him. There, he said, he saw her lifeless body.

“I knew she was dead,” Hall said. “She had too many bullets in her face for her not to be dead.”

Hall said he eventually was able to leave the trailer under the pretense of buying marijuana. Instead, he left to call 911, he said.

Reyna’s girlfriend at the time of the shooting, Mary Ann Garza, also testified Wednesday that she saw Reyna get up off the couch and follow Fegueroa. Then, Garza said, she too heard gunshots.

Garza said she saw Reyna holding a gun shortly after she heard the shots.

After Garza was able to leave the trailer and it had been surrounded by police, she said, Reyna called her on her cellphone.

“He said if anybody went in that he was going to shoot them,” Garza testified.

Earlier Wednesday, a Florida Department of Law Enforcement crime laboratory analyst who examined firearms and ammunition from the scene for latent fingerprints testified she found one of Reyna’s fingerprints on a .45-caliber firearm and one on a magazine for that firearm.

Prosecutors said Reyna used a .38-caliber revolver to shoot Fegueroa and a .45-caliber pistol to fire two shots in his bedroom.