Trouble logging in?If you can't remember your password or are having trouble logging in, you will have to reset your password. If you have trouble resetting your password (for example, if you lost access to the original email address), please do not start posting with a new account, as this is against the forum rules. If you create a temporary account, please contact us right away via Forum Support, and send us any information you can about your original account, such as the account name and any email address that may have been associated with it.

@ctrl-z: True, this episode's animation director seems to be the guy that did Episode 07. Well, at least he didn't use the fish-eye angles this episode . The effects were great though.

I personally loved the fish-eye angles. Even though the director was probably copycatting Shinbo Akayuki. Don't forget despite the craptacular drawings, the actual combat animation was excellent. I sure hope his career flourishes. I am serious as can be.

I love how episode 12 went over all. It's nice to see all of them gang up and beat the final boss. Even through I felt sorry for it having no turn. Hayate's magical girl entrance was cool and dramatic. She had an authority figure feel to her as well.

Unless something really stupid happens in episode 13 this will definitely be one of the best series I've seen. Then again I wanted to watch this series because I loved the original. So go figure. Still out of the new characters I especially love Vita and Hayate. I also like the fact the show didn't wait until the last second to develop the antagonists. Early on they present the Cloud Knights as actually characters. A refreshing change of pace in my view.

Despite how much this series has rocked, I just have a few criticisms, mainly regarding the old characters.

The show is titled Mahou Shoujo Lyrical Nanoha A's, but Nanoha herself did not appear to change or grow over the course of this series. In the first show we got to see her deal with the changes that come about with suddenly gaining magical powers, but in this season she was pretty much a static character. We didn't exactly find out anything new, nor did she grow as a person.
Fate got slightly more attention. We got to see her discomfort around Lindy, and then in episode 11 we learned a whole lot, and she moved on from her past. However, we didn't exactly get to see anything special about her relationship with Nanoha. It just felt like the two were copies of each other, and neither ended up doing anything that was not mirrored by the other.
Arf and Yuuno were almost completely useless, being even more alike in their roles than Nanoha and Fate. Yuuno didn't get to kick ass or do anything special, and Arf got shafted out of her fight scenes with Zafira.
As for Chrono, Lindy, and Amy, no complaints. They didn't gain or lose anymore attention than they got in season 1.

If there is a season 3, then I hope that they focus more on Nanoha. She is the title character, after all.

When did Yuuno ever kick any ass? He binds things. That's what he does. Not counting the very start of episode 1 of season 1 of course. I mean, I like the guy but I'm actually pretty sure Nanoha could do fine in a fight even without him.

That asside, your other complains are fairly valid. It's one of the factors that spawned the "13 or 26 episodes" discussion.

Spoiler for "ep12:

Perhaps it was the support team's innitial casting of "Monster looses one round of combat" that lead to the final boss not getting it's turn. You know, it's like if you successfully put the Troll to sleep in Dragonwarrior 3, his days of evil are over.

Well to be honest one of the hardest things to do with a second season is to give the new characters proper focus without ignoring the old characters completely. Still maybe it would have worked out better as 26 episodes. Heck I can think of quite a few series that should be 26 episodes instead of 13, but that's another story.

How come Hayate doesn't seem to think the Book of Darkness is well, evil? I mean its called Book of Darkness. Sounds kind of evil to me. Or does she just doesn't know the book's name? I think I need to rewatch a few episodes to make sure.

That said, I did notice Nanoha seems a little "out of the loop" with the main focus of the story, which made me a little sad, but given that there are simply so many characters grasping for time, it isn't all that surprising. I'm all for a 3rd season!

I think the focus has been divided pretty well. There are many new characters, and it's obvious the intention is for the viewers to like them. Thus, rightfully, they received a lot of screen time for development. Nanoha didn't grow much, which is true, but basically she's already done her development and stayed true to her character (unlike say Kira in GS and GSD). Yes she is the main character, but so is Usagi Tsukino in Sailormoon and she stopped developing in Season 1 . As for Fate, well, without giving spoilers, I would say she got some nice development. In the end, we got an awesome series (one of my all-time favorite barring something wacky happending in the last episode), and the fans basically love all the characters! Which I would think is truly hard to accomplish.

A 3rd season would be nice. Too many characters? Well, just make it a Mahou Shoujo tourament battle.

I expected they would ATLEAST give Chrono HALF AN EPISODE to look out of Asura's window and make a refelct on his past. And...please, just another FIVE COOL MINUTES for a serious battle between him and the Masked man (which actually...well, you know that) Not to mention how much I wish to know about Yuuno's past, and yes, see him in more action. He did pretty well in EP2, managing to block+dodge all Vita's attacks while maintaining the protection shield for Nanoha and deal with the magic cage. Actually, I was hoping to see his combination spell with Shamal TTwTT
Really, If they would just focus more on Chrono and Yuuno (as well as giving Yuuno more "manly" look), I'm pretty sure this show would easily finds its way in attracting fangirls as well.
(Umm...don't get me wrong. I am not saying they should make it ChronoxYuuno which is just too eerie =w=ili)

How come Hayate doesn't seem to think the Book of Darkness is well, evil? I mean its called Book of Darkness. Sounds kind of evil to me. Or does she just doesn't know the book's name? I think I need to rewatch a few episodes to make sure.

Since everyone here is too obsessed with the raws and inconsiderate of those watching only the fansubs, I guess I'll have to answer -- this is sort of explained in episode 8 (which will be released soon), but she does know the Book's name as of episode 6 which flashbacked to when the guardian knights first appeared before her and stuff. I don't know why she's more freaked out by it, but the knights did promise that they wouldn't do anything bad with it and just live peacefully together with her also as said in episode 6, which is probably why she's not too frightened or scared of what it can do. She knows it can hurt people, but if its not used that way (which she thinks right now), there's not much to worry about.

Since everyone here is too obsessed with the raws and inconsiderate of those watching only the fansubs, I guess I'll have to answer.

I was actually wondering this myself. I've been to a lot of various series boards (don't always post) and there's always been people who watch the raws but for some reason this series seems to have far more people like that. I wonder why that is.

I always try to cover up my spoilers, be vauge with them or outright lie to be misleading, but I greatly apologize if something slipped through.

I was actually wondering this myself. I've been to a lot of various series boards (don't always post) and there's always been people who watch the raws but for some reason this series seems to have far more people like that. I wonder why that is.

I always try to cover up my spoilers, be vauge with them or outright lie to be misleading, but I greatly apologize if something slipped through.

I don't really mind since I also watch it weekly, since well, I translate it, but I feel kind of bad for those who want to talk about it on the thread from just seeing the fansubs, without the raws. Most people use spoiler tags the majority of the time, but sometimes things still slip like the revelation in episode 10 for example.

The "travelling party" is just so huge now it'd never work unless they dropped some of them from the picture for a while. Of course the final ep could change this entirely.

Spoiler for Just in case.:

I'm not sure that they can't just have Hayate and co. live Happily Ever After, while the story focuses on Nanoha and Fate. (Or heck, a spinoff (again) for Mahou Shoujo Lyrical Hayate.)

This would even allow for some great reappearance moments (Nanoha and Fate are fighting some new enemy and losing badly, when suddenly! Out of the sky! The Wolkenritter arrive to save the day! Or something), albeit probably not in episode one like Fate and Yuuno did.

thanks, if anyone wants be my avatar buddy, i have one like mine with Nanoha (but pink) that says little wish.

Also, I have a Christmas set ^^;.

Spoiler:

Well since the Wolkenritter are only doing there stuff for hayte to be save, if hayte comes save, and her life isnt threatened anymore, wouldent the Wolkenritter not need to continue in there mission to fill the book for her? (correct me if i have something wrong) and then disappear for awhile, For those you watched Sailor moon, the outers appeared for one season, and then, for the next season that did not appears, maybe that could be the same for Nanoha, and the focus might go back onto the Fate and Nanoha, and if they get into trouble, and needs some help, out of the blue the Wolkenritters would come and make the scene, and save them, maybe around the end of te 3rd season if there is one, and all of them again help defeat and such who ever is causing the mess...yah. thats all my opnion though haha ^^;

Side note to anyone that wants to help me

I`m been lagging on my site updates, and really do need to get the profiles of all the characters of both seasons written and added, but i really dont have time to write this, to anyone who has seen so fare,all of whats ben released and knows the charscters very well, and wants to write up VERY deatiled descriptions of them please do, i will give you credit, please and thank you.