The Wealth of Children: Reconsidering the Child Labour Debate

Abstract

The past two decades’ re-emergence of child labour has been explained as the outcome of the globalization of the world economy which has made the work of young children available for exploitation on a previously unknown scale. But how this work is exploited and by whom exactly remains a matter of debate. Dominant economic approaches see in local entrepreneurs the main exploiters and place the responsibility with both governments and parents. Parents, being either risk-averse or lacking in altruism, would offer their children as cheap labour power to profit-hungry entrepreneurs. Detailed anthropological studies, far fewer in number, suggest that this view fails to account for the reciprocity that informs long-term intra-familial exchange relationships and the pivotal place of children therein. Both approaches have their merits, but are unsatisfactory.

Cohen, R. (2001) ‘Children’s Contribution to Household Labour in Three Sociocultural Contexts, a Southern Indian Village, a Norwegian Town and a Canadian City’, International Journal of Canadian Studies, XLII (4): 353–67.Google Scholar

De Suremain, C.-E. (2000) ‘Coffee Beans and the Seeds of Labour: Child Labour in Guatemalan Plantations’, in B. Schlemmer (ed.), The Exploited Child, London and New York: ZED, pp. 231–8.Google Scholar

Fallon, P. and Z. Tzannatos (1998) Child Labour, Issues and Directions for the World Bank, Washington DC: The World Bank, Social Protection, Human Development Network.Google Scholar

Haddad, L. and M. Zeller (1996) ‘How Can Safety Nets Do More With Less? General Issues With some Evidence from Southern Africa’, FCND Discussion paper No. 16. Washington: International Food Policy Institute.Google Scholar

Hanson, K. and A. Vandaele (2003) ‘Working Children and International Labour Law: a Critical Analysis’, International Journal of Children’s Rights, 11: 73–146.CrossRefGoogle Scholar

Hashim, Iman, M. (2004) ‘Working with Working Children. Child Labour and the Barriers to Education in Rural Northern Nigeria’, Sussex: DPhil Development Studies, University of Sussex.Google Scholar

Hecht, T. (1998) At Home in the Street, Street Children of Northeast Brazil, Cambridge: Cambridge University Press.CrossRefGoogle Scholar

Invernizzi, A. and B. Milne (2002) ‘Are Children Entitled to Contribute to International Policy Making? A Critical View of Children’s Participation in the International Campaign for the Elimination of Child Labour’, Journal of Children’s Rights, 10 (4): 403–31.CrossRefGoogle Scholar

Nieuwenhuys, O. (2000) ‘The Household Economy and the Commercial Exploitation of Children’s Work, the Case of Kerala’, in B. Schlemmer (ed.), The Exploited Child, London and New York: ZED, pp. 278–91.Google Scholar

Nieuwenhuys, O. (2003) ‘Growing Up between Places of Work and Non-places of Childhood: the Uneasy Relationship’, in K. Fog Olwig and E. Gulløv (eds), Children and Place, London: Routledge, pp. 99–118.Google Scholar

Rose, D. (1993) ‘Local Childcare Strategies in Montréal, Québec: the Mediations of State Policies, Class and Ethnicity in the Life Course of Families with Young Children’, in C. Katz and J. Monk (eds), Full Circles: Geographies of Women over the Life Course, London and New York: Routledge, pp. 188–207.Google Scholar