I has questions.

I am still an admin for some reason. I should have been removed yesterday as yesterday was my date of payment for another month. I realize that it's an actual subscription, but I don't even have a credit card currently on my paypal account, so I definitely could not of had payed for another month.

Ah okay, yeah I'll remove myself. I can't find the page to do so though, I don't have a "more options" below profile.

Give me a sec, let me check it for you to see if paypal has changed their menu set up since I wrote that.

Edit:

Yeah, it's been changed. Follow steps 1 - 4 on the other page then follow these steps here:

Click the "My Money" tab on the left
You should see "My pre-approved payments as the fourth option down now on the right. Click "Update".
On the next page you should see a payment to Plaguefest. If you dont, change the "Filter Status by:" drop down box to say all.
Click on the payment to Plaguefest.
Scroll to the very bottom and click Cancel Subscription.
Confirm Cancelling your Subscription.
You are done.