Trump described a payroll tax cut as a must-have for the next coronavirus relief bill during a Fox News virtual town hall on Sunday.

“We’re not doing anything unless we get a payroll tax cut,” he said. “That is so important to the success of our country.”

Reducing payroll taxes is an idea championed by conservatives with connections to the president. They argue that it could be a way to encourage people to work after Congress passed an expansion of unemployment insurance that has resulted in some people receiving more money in unemployment benefits than they would be receiving in wages had they not lost their jobs.

“I do think of all the options that Congress is weighing about more economic support, I would think considering the complete payroll tax holiday for the workers is far more efficient than perhaps another round of economic impact statements,” Brady said.

A spokeswoman for the senator said Tuesday that an employee-side cut would help to make work more attractive for people on the margin and that an employer-side cut could give businesses more liquidity.

Trump had previously expressed interest in a payroll tax cut in March, as businesses and schools started to close because of the outbreak. But lawmakers on both sides of the aisle expressed skepticism, and the administration shifted gears to pushing for sending direct payments to Americans.

The $2.2 trillion CARES Act included a provision that provides one-time direct payments of up to $1,200 per adult and $500 per child and another provision that allows businesses and self-employed individuals to defer payment of employer-side Social Security payroll taxes, as well as the boost to unemployment insurance.

While Trump has renewed his desire for a payroll tax cut, Democrats remain opposed to the idea, arguing that a reduction in payroll taxes wouldn’t help the tens of millions of Americans who are out of work because of the pandemic.

As a way to provide more economic relief to Americans, Democrats have been pushing for additional direct payments, beyond the one-time payments in the CARES Act. Many progressives are interested in people receiving payments on a monthly basis.

Democrats and progressive groups have also defended the expansion of unemployment insurance, arguing that the average jobless benefit before the expansion was only a fraction of pre-unemployment wages and it would be problematic if suddenly tens of millions of people had significantly less money than they had before they lost their jobs due to the pandemic.

“The idea that that in any way is a contributor to the current economic problems is so wrong that I don’t even want to rebut it because rebutting it gives it more credibility than it is due,” said Michael Linden, executive director of The Groundwork Collaborative, a progressive advocacy group.

Some top Republicans have also expressed skepticism about a payroll tax cut, while others have not endorsed the president’s idea.

Tax policy experts said the content of the next coronavirus package will depend on whether the outbreak has subsided and what kind of shape the economy is in when the legislation moves forward. They said a payroll tax cut might make more sense when the economy starts to reopen more fully and people have more of a desire to leave their homes and spend money.

“It would seem more appropriate if we were thinking of reopening the economy soon,” said Kyle Pomerleau, a resident fellow at the right-leaning American Enterprise Institute. If the focus of the next bill remains providing economic relief while people stay at home, a payroll tax cut would be “somewhat inappropriate,” he added.

The timing of a future major coronavirus package is unclear. House Democrats have expressed an interest in moving quickly, while Senate Republicans want to move more slowly to first evaluate which parts of previous bills are working and which aren’t. And Republicans and Democrats have disagreements over key issues such as liability protection and aid to state and local governments.

“My sense is it’s going to take at least the month of May to figure out what the next big bill looks like,” said Rohit Kumar, a former McConnell aide who now works at PwC.

Sponsor

Social Counter

About Us

Newsrust.com is a multi-platform publisher of news and information.

Newsrust.com has earned a reputation as the leading provider of news and information that improves the quality of life of its readers by focusing on health, personal finance, education, sports, travel, news and opinion.

Newsrust.com is not the original publisher of news and information. All the content on this website is being published from syndicated feeds of multiple news publishers. Newsrust.com's aim is to provide its readers a single common platform of news and information from multiple sources.