If this is your first visit, be sure to
check out the FAQ by clicking the
link above. You may have to register
before you can post: click the register link above to proceed. To start viewing messages,
select the forum that you want to visit from the selection below.

View Poll Results: Which ROUGH SKETCH(ES) of the logo do you prefer. You may select more than one.

Voters

62. You may not vote on this poll

Logo 1

58.06%

Logo 2

2032.26%

Logo 3

1625.81%

Logo 4

3048.39%

Logo 5

46.45%

Logo 6

00%

Logo 7

914.52%

Logo 8

1829.03%

Logo 9

46.45%

I, personally, would be willing to submit a logo design to fit a brief.

I lke the colours of 2 more than 1, but2 looks more like a seahorse than a giraffe, so I voted for 1. The giraffe from 1in the colours and patterning of 2 would be my choice. Or possibly 4 in the colours of 2?

I lke the colours of 2 more than 1, but2 looks more like a seahorse than a giraffe, so I voted for 1. The giraffe from 1in the colours and patterning of 2 would be my choice. Or possibly 4 in the colours of 2?

Originally Posted by qaz

I find 2 so much slicker than 4, actually. The colors and the giraffe design are more unique and interesting for me.

The colours are not final. Do I need to mark that out in larger, maybe flashing text in the first post?

I really hope people haven't been chosing on colours. Because few of those up there are finalised in terms of colour choices.

The colours will be worked out once form has been decided. It's very likely, for example, that the grey giraffe, green circle and purple background will be changed. Specifically I was thinking cyan circle, purple giraffe, green giraffe detail and purple or grey for the background.

See my comments above.If you read what I wrote, none of these are final. Colours especially. Textures as well. There is nothing to stop the finalisation of logo 2 turning out to be Rizlar's modification.

I'm starting to worry that people are just voting on what's here, not on what they think they could become if worked on (because all are first-drafts). I probably should have converted them all into black-on-white outlines...

If you read what I wrote, none of these are final. Colours especially. Textures as well. There is nothing to stop the finalisation of logo 2 turning out to be Rizlar's modification.

I was trying to provide my opinion and contribute to the discussion, rather than just casting a vote. I have read all of the original post and I'm aware that these logos are early drafts, which may be worked upon further.

Seeing logo 2 with the modifications made it more appealing to me, and I expressed that opinion. It is not only different in terms of colour and texture, it also has a wider middle circle thanks to a ring in a lighter tone around it.

I won't comment on colours (as I'm colour blind) but if I could I'd vote for #4. I like the simplicity and textures of this one plus the way that the giraffe head echoes the VS logo in it's general shape. Perhaps a combo of 4 & 9 might work, taking the look and feel of 4 and combining it with the slightly more VS logo lookalike nature of 9 (band around the outside rather than solid circle?).

1 & 2 look good but aren't as simple and for me don't have as much impact, plus its not as easy to tell its a giraffe. The rest are too 'generic' without much personality.

Hey, that was very nice! Just polish up the circle at the points where it touches the giraffe, (so that the head is contoured by a pixel or two of white where the two overlap, and this would be awesome!

Inkscape refuses to work on my Windows computer, so I have not been able to do any fancy vector stuff. Instead I've been restricted to GIMP for this mockup. Might be worth firing up the sluggish Linux box for developing that sketch a bit though.

I like the turn in this thread as its much more about suggestion and "i like this in this".

Thanks for all the love of my design! If you want to trawl through the youtube thread, there is a version of 2, with the colourscheme of mine (4) which is what I suggested as a compromise during our discussions.

Im seeing a lot of love for both 2 and 4, which (awesomely) supports my preferences and backs my viewpoint up tremendously.

3 and 8 are getting some love too, but personally I dont like these designs as I think they are too complicated. The colours (or more importantly shades) dont work very well either, so they would need a lot of work.

I love the symmetry of 4, but equally the asymmetry of 2. 2, IMO, is a perfect balance of colours, texture and design. It is clearly a giraffe to me, despite what some people are saying, because of the shape and neck "camo". Im inclined to have more work done on 2, (which is actually what I had decided on personally to use for youtube) and when Rizlar was done with the BG, we were going to work on this.