On 08/17/2011 09:04 PM, Sylvain Galineau wrote:
>
> [fantasai:]
>> - RESOLVED: Put ltr | rtl keywords back into image(), mark as at-risk.
> ...
>> <fantasai> Florian, prefixes are dropped per feature, not per module.
>
> Don't know how I missed this; the last time I pointed out we agreed we could move
> to CR on a per-feature basis when possible you said we did not in fact agree to that,
> though we discussed it. Can you point to the decision allowing us to do this? If that
> is the case then we never needed to move anything to Level 4 on the grounds of moving
> gradient standardization forward, did we ?
We did not agree to move to CR on a per-feature basis.
We did agree to allow prefix-dropping on a per-feature basis.
Dropping prefixes != moving to CR.
Dropping prefixes requires:
1. The feature is in CR.
2. The implementation is correct *per CR spec*
3. The implementation proves its correctness via tests.
It's possible for #1 to be true for features that don't satisfy all three.
See
http://www.w3.org/TR/CSS/#testing
~fantasai