ipoguy:$TFM When these high PE stocks don't deliver they get crushed. With earnings of less than $1.10, TFM could sell at 25. Then CFO leaves...

Prior to the day's sell-off, shares of Fresh Market were trading at almost 44 times 2013 earnings expectations.

With the day's pullback, the stock's price-to-earnings ratio is still a lofty 35, in line with rival Whole Foods (WFM). But some believe Fresh Market's stock deserves a slightly higher price.

tickertutor: $TFM I think the comparisons to $WFM are grossly exaggerated... $TFM should trade at a multiple putting it in the low 40's imo.

Opinterest: $TFM sell off overdone. See if we get Inverted Mohawk here.

Mahmissa: $WFM has jacked up its bakery prices by nearly 20%. Yet sugar content remained the same.

Some also think investors may be overreacting to the management change, saying the upcoming departure of Klinger, who joined the company in March 2009 and led it through its initial public offering in 2010, shouldn't be a surprise.

abubnic: All of the key execs at $TFM are in their 40's. Not so unusual for CFO to take another (similar) job.

Fresh Market said it will begin to search for a new CFO, but until then, COO Sean Crane will assume the role.

Hibah Yousuf is a reporter at CNNMoney, where she covers stocks, bonds, commodities and currencies trading across the globe, as well as corporate earnings and other markets-related news. Prior to joining the site in 2009, she interned at Money Magazine.