Baton Rouge floods broke a record many thought would never be broken

The flooding in Louisiana is breaking records many never thought could be broken.

"We have crushed the previous records, is probably the best way to put it, " said Louisiana State Climatologist Barry Keim in an interview with CNBC. "The amount of rain is absolutely extraordinary. Nobody expected it. "

In just two days 21.86 inches of rain fell in Livingston, Louisiana, according to National Weather Service gauges. Keim noted that tops the threshold of 20.7 inches for a 1,000-year rainfall event for that period.

But other gauges measured more than 31 inches in Watson, Louisiana. That staggering total left many climate scientists and meteorologists scratching their heads, Keim said.

Several rivers have flooded far beyond record levels set during a severe flood 33 years ago — a flood that was itself so severe, few believed it could be topped.

The Amite River reached such heights in 1983 that levees were later built to the record-breaking levels seen that year, TheAdvocate reported.

But this week's flooding blew past that record by a wide margin of almost 5 feet in the same area, something many hydrologists never thought would happen, said Bob Jacobsen, a Baton Rouge-based engineer who has worked on flood protection with local levee boards.

The Amite River at Denham Springs, near Baton Rouge, reached a 46.2 feet earlier this week, astonishingly higher than the 41.5 feet record seen in 1983.

"It would be like breaking a marathon record by 12 minutes," Jacobsen said. "You can have a record that you can expect to be broken by a little bit, but not by 10 percent."

The aftermath of the flood will leave many scientists wondering whether this is a rare event or a lasting shift.

"Now the next challenge is, how do we regard this kind of event?" Jacobsen said. "Is this a new normal? Or is it really a 1-in-1,000 type event?"

Indeed there is already evidence that a heavy downpours are becoming more severe since the early 1990s, according to the National Climate Assessment. The Northeast and Midwest already have experienced increases in flooding events.

And David Easterling of NOAA's National Centers for Environmental Information told The New York Timesthat increased rainfall flooding and "is consistent with what we expect to see in the future if you look at climate models."

"No single event, or even a year's worth of extreme events, really tells you much about climate change," Keim said. "However it does raise some suspicions as to what is driving this."

It could simply be a very rare occurrence, but if it represents a shift in the overall severity of flooding, it could ripple outward and bear significant implications for the National Flood Insurance Program.

"If somebody comes along and argues strongly that this isn't a 1,000-year event, this is a new normal for a 100 year event, well then the 100-year flood maps have to be totally redrawn," Jacobsen said.

And, he added, if this can happen in Baton Rouge, it can happen anywhere along the Gulf Coast.