I really don't understand the good reviews. This one had poor pigment from the beginning and dried out almost completely after 3 uses.

IDK, maybe I just got a defective tube but I was very unimpressed. My last liquid eyeliner was so pigmented and had so much product that I used it during Halloween to paint a fake Domino mask across my eyes and still had plenty of product left over.

I exclusively wear liquid or gel liner. This is probably the best drug store one out there...ive tried a million of them...colorwise...this is super black. Formulawise this stays put almost all day. Applicatorwise this is harder to use...the wand part is a little loose so its easier to make a mistake. If you know what you're doing its solid but maybe not for a newbie

I hoped for easy application and jet black wings but spent ages on getting a decent flip with this. I regretted buying it as from the first application ...
Pro’s:
- nice and decent case
- last rather ok if you don’t touch it, sweat or walk through humidity
Con’s:
- impossible to draw a sharp wing
- felt tip is wobbly, not firm, not bouncy and not precise
- very hard to apply/correct on top of existing layer, it drags the underlying layer away
- not heavily pigmented and rather dull looking
- I can imagine the felt tip crumbling after a while
- not water- or smudgeproof

I LOVE this eyeliner so much! Not wet, super smooth application, tip pointy enough to do a pointed wing, and just beautiful. Lasts all day, doesn't flake, and doesn't irritate my eyes. I love it because it's the exact dupe of the Lancome artliner precision point but a LOT cheaper. Same formula, same felt tip brush, same packaging, and same results. It also comes off very easily too without a mess. Very clean application and very clean removal. Love love love! Definitely would purchase this again. I've been using it for YEARS. So glad I found it. I hope they never ever discontinue this.

As someone who wears liquid eyeliner everyday, I've tried dozens of brands and the L'Oréal Lineur Intense is by far my favourite. I needed minimal application to get the right look and it would stay in place all day long.

Just like the reviewer before me (feshykins) I too have been using this eyeliner since I was 16 and I'm now 28. This is an excellent liquid eyeliner. It's a very dark black, and the felt tip applicator makes application very easy. It doesn't flake and also doesn't run at the first sign of sweat, and if and when it does finally start to run, it's thin and not very pigmented when it meets water- it won't leave you with big black racoon eyes (the formula that I buy is not waterproof). I do like to try different things out, but that is the one major thing that sent me running back to this from a horrid competing company's liquid eyeliner- it ran very very easily, and then I had a very hard time trying to remove the black half moons underneath each eye. I'm so glad I wasn't out in public when that happened! I really appreciate that I never have to worry about this L'oreal eyeliner moving and making me look terrible. It's been my favorite for over a decade.

I have been using this since i was 16 and im 28 now, i try other liners once in a while to switch it up but always come back to this. It is very easy to use. I have no problem creating a wing, it is the quickest part of my makeup in the morning, very black, i have never had to go over my lines to darken them. Zero cracking or flaking. Even where my lid creases near the edge. The only time i have had issues is when it is starting to drying out then it can be streaky but it will last me a long time before that happens and all i have to do is shake it up a bit to get a dark line again.