New Musical 'Fingers and Toes' at Ivoryton Playhouse

Director Robert Moss talks about the transformation of 42nd Street in New York City that was spurred by his founding of Playwrights Horizons.

Director Robert Moss talks about the transformation of 42nd Street in New York City that was spurred by his founding of Playwrights Horizons.

By FRANK RIZZO, frizzo@courant.comThe Hartford Courant

Robert Moss looks as if he could start another theater company tomorrow.

Trim, charming and full of energy, the fast-talking Moss at 80 still has the skill-set to seize an opportunity, hustle a deal and make things happen just as he did in the 1970s when he founded off-Broadway's Playwrights Horizons. He was also a pivotal figure in the remaking of 42nd Street, turning the seedy strip of porn theaters, hookers and drug addicts into a theater mecca that also transformed a neighborhood and boosted the spirit of a city.

"He was the Neil Armstrong planting his not-for-profit flag on the moon," said the late playwright Wendy Wasserstein in the book "The Ghosts of 42nd Street" that chronicles the history decade-by-decade of that famed thoroughfare through a singular figure.

The Newark-born Moss may be years past founding and heading theaters in New York, such as those he ran in Queens (Queens Theater in the Park), Ithica (Hangar Theater) and Syracuse (Syracuse Stage) but he's still expanding playwrights' horizons — and audiences', too — as a freelance director.

In Connecticut, he's now staging the new three-actor song-and-dance musical, "Fingers and Toes", which begins performances Wednesday at the Ivoryton Playhouse, in the Ivoryton section of Essex.

"Very heady times," he says when asked about the formation of Playwrights Horizons, one of the most influential theaters in the off-Broadway and regional theater movement more than 40 years ago — as well as the transformation of 42nd Street.

Moss began Playwrights Horizons in 1971 when he found free space at the Clark Center for the Performing Arts at the YMCA branch at 51st Street and Eighth Avenue. Three years later, he moved the theater company to then-derelict West 42nd Street at the site of a former house of burlesque.

"Nobody got paid," says Moss, who was notable for passing around a big white bag in the audience asking for donations.

Moss only intended to stay there for a few months but when he discovered that audiences didn't seem phased by the neighborhood's denizens, he secured a long-term lease the day after he opened.

And the day after that? He founded the "42nd Street Gang"corporation with the purpose "to acquire these deteriorating spaces and turn them into working theaters again. I knew there were little theater companies all around town looking for places so maybe they could do what we did which is to transform a space into a theater."

Different Times

Moss saw the potential of the area. "Despite the surroundings we were in the middle of 42nd Street in New York City which is the center of the world."

But an even more significant turn came quickly after was when Moss met millionaire civic activist Fred Papert, who was planning on reviving the street and begin by razing his block.

"I told him I had a better idea and to his eternal credit he bought it," says Moss.

The Gang, along with the new 42nd Street Development Corporation, joined forces and spearheaded the renovation and creation of 42nd Street's Theatre Row.

"He had clout," says Moss, "and could go to the absolute [heights] of power — which I could not do. As the person who helped save Grand Central Station, Fred could go with Mrs. [Jackie Kennedy] Onassis on his arm."

The times were hospitable to artistic visionaries. "[Governor Nelson] Rockefeller just doubled the arts budget from $18 million to $36 million. The city, the state and the federal government all came together on the project and the foundation world — especially the Ford Foundation — was brand new with young people leading them. It wasn't all codified the way it is now. It was like the Wild West where I could call up a [foundation head] and say I need $5,000 today. It was crazy. But all of that money isn't around anymore."

Of that period in theater creation, Moss says "there was a spirit in the land coming out of the '60s where people gave themselves to worthy projects. We were on unemployment half of every year in the beginning and there were plenty of times we ran out of money and we'd have to say, 'OK, no more salaries' and nobody left — nobody. Now if you told someone they wouldn't be paid, they'd be out the door before you could finish the sentence."

During the '70s Moss saw the not-for-profit movement and his own organization mature. "We grew up. At first I was doing 30 plays a year, 15 in full production and 15 workshops but I found the only way to get better was to do less, pay more attention and become more professional," says Moss who began his career as a production stage manager at the APA Repertory Company.

Moss produced new plays by more than 150 American writers, including Wasserstein, James Lapine, Albert Innaurato, William Finn and Ted Tally until 1981 when he says he just felt burned out.

Besides Playwrights Horizons, the multi-tasking Moss simultaneously artistic detector of Queen's Theater in the Park, was also on the boards of theater organizations, and was involved in the National Endowment for the Arts. "I loved doing it but at the same time I was sort of getting tired and it all began to feel like a jail sentence."

When he heard a colleague express similar feelings, he realized that after the birth of the not-for-profit movement that began in the '60s (and included the creation of Hartford Stage, Long Wharf Theatre, Yale Repertory Theatre and the O'Neill Theater Center) it was OK to take a breath.

In 1981, Moss confided to his associate Andre Bishop (now artistic director of Lincoln Center Theater) that he wanted out but couldn't imagine how. "The shy, retiring Andre said, 'Really? I would love to run the place.' Everyone assumed there was a coup and Andre had ousted me but it's not true and we've remained close over the years."

"The minute I walked out the door I tripled my yearly income as a freelance director." But soon he was heading new theaters. But he gave up heading theaters in 2008 to exclusively devote himself to teaching and directing.

Another New Show

Which brings Moss to Ivoryton and a musical that captures the spirit of Moss's early days: That let's-put-on-a-show-with-nothing-but-talent-energy-and-nerve drive.

The show by Logan Medland centers on a fast-talking tap dancer Dustin "Toes" Macgrath and neurotic pianist Tristan "Fingers" St. Claire who have managed to entice a producer to see their new show in two weeks: a boy-meets-girl tap dance entertainment show on the theme of love.

Trouble is, they don't have a show, they don't have a girl and they know nothing about love.

Rick Faugno, who danced in Goodspeed's "Babes in Arms" in 2002 and "The Boyfriend" a few years later, stars as "Toes." His wife Joyce Chittick (Broadway's "Sweet Charity," "The Pajama Hame" and "Anything Goes" plays the female lead and indie musician Aaron Berk play "Fingers."

"I've always been a huge fan of old musicals, particularly of the '30s and '40s," says Medland, "with that fast-talking, quick-witted writing. I thought, wouldn't it be great to write something like that, a show that was driven by the skills of the performers and not just about elaborate sets and special effects."

The show first bowed in 2010 at the New York Musical Theater festival, followed by productions at the Merry Go Round Playhouse in Auburn, N.Y. (where Moss became involved with the project) and Florida. The show now has a producer, he says, who is currently trying to raise money for the next step.

FINGERS AND TOES begins previews on Wednesday, June 4, and opens on Friday, June 6, at the Ivoryton Playhouse, 103 Main St. in the Ivoryton section of Essex. The run continues through June 22. Performances are Wednesdays and Thursdays at 7:30 p.m.; Fridays and Saturdays at 8 p.m. and Wednesday and Sunday matinees at 2 p.m. Tickets are 442; $37 seniors; $20 students; $15 for children. Information: 860-767-7318 and www.ivorytonplayhouse.org.

Sometimes you just want to see a movie away from home but avoid the bigger theaters and venues. And many of these movies you won't find on Netflix or in that Red Box machine in your supermarket anyway. So we've rounded up some other options for you at libraries, museums, in the parks, etc. Most...

In the jazz world, some bandleaders prefer small-group situations. They'll hire players, improvise over a curated collection of standards and originals and attempt to create some sort of chemistry that would compel them to play together again. Maybe they care about large-scale, multi-part structures...