I think that Alison is actually --A, and she set up some of things thats been happening to the girls, like the "good things", (when the girls received the dolls and the information to stop the wedding, and get rid of that girl Aria did not like). But I beileve there is another -A who is the evil one who is actually trying to hurt them and I think Alison was the person who set up Jenna because she killed someone who looks like Ali (Jenna and Garret admitted to killing Alison) and bragged about it, which is probably why --A(Alison) set the house on fire. Also with Duncan I think he flew Alison out of town before anything happened the night she went missing and she's been coming back dressed as another person going around town. Plus i think everyone in the NAT club, Jenna and Melissa is -A. And the newspaper they found is from Alison trying to tell her friends she is alive and where she is. With Maya I would have to say that --A(Alison) tricked her into liking her so Maya would run away and help her, that's why Maya dropped off the bag and left.

10:29 pm March 5, 2012

Princess wrote:

This was an amazing episode! I am dying to know who A is. I really thought Jenna was part of A but after this episode I don't know. I think there is a group of people who are A - most likely the whole NAT club excluding Jason. It would seem Garrett wanted Jenna dead for betraying him and dating Noel now, but why would he be framed with the badge being placed there? Or A placed it there knowing it was Garrett who started the fire.

I definitely do not think Ezra is A.

Possible suspects working together:
- Melissa but she is pregnant
- Mike
- Noel
- Mona
- Garrett
- Ian must have been part of it
- this Duncan character has a lot more to tell us

Alison was receiving texts from A before she died. Interesting theory below that she is still alive and giving clues of where she is now but the body was found, and the producers have said it will not be the same as in the books. I personally prefer that it is not the same as the books.

OMG I can't wait for the finale

10:54 pm March 5, 2012

Layla Alvar wrote:

I think "A" wants us to think Garret tried to kill Jenna. She must be setting him up.

10:56 pm March 5, 2012

Layla Alvar wrote:

Idk, I think "A" wants us to think Garret tried to kill Jenna. She must be setting him up.

You didn't mention the one part of the episode that made me happy (if only for a second). Jason and Aria sitting together for a brief moment at the hospital. I'm happy to see that they are still talking. Sorry but they look really good together. He's got this whole smoldering hot thing going on that Ezra just doesn't have. I'm sooo over Ezra.

8:12 am March 6, 2012

R wrote:

Also....what ever happened to Hanna's first boyfriend...Sean?
I don't think Garret tried to kill Jenna...it was someone else. Melissa is very suspicious but there is no way she could be running around while pregnant. So there is definitley multiple 'A's'. I think it's suspicious that Ezria is always pretty much left alone....which sometimes makes me think that Mike is in on some of it.

Add a Comment

Error message

Name

We welcome thoughtful comments from readers. Please comply with our guidelines. Our blogs do not require the use of your real name.

About Speakeasy

Speakeasy is a blog covering media, entertainment, celebrity and the arts. The publication is produced by Barbara Chai and Jonathan Welsh with contributions from the Wall Street Journal staff and others. Write to us at speakeasy@wsj.com or follow us on Twitter at @WSJSpeakeasy or individually @barbarachai.