Pages

Wednesday, 12 June 2013

Misplaced Medieval Treasures, by H.M. Castor

Bristol's medieval High Cross at Stourhead

Photograph by Chris Downer

[CC-BY-SA-2.0

(http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by-sa/2.0)],

via Wikimedia Commons

Just over a week ago, I went looking for a piece of medieval
Bristol… in Wiltshire. At Stourhead to be precise – that beautifully landscaped
product of an 18th-century banker’s vast wealth, now owned and tended
by the National Trust. There, beside a lake, stands a medieval High Cross that originally
had its home in the centre of Bristol, at the intersection of Corn Street, Wine
Street, Broad Street and High Street.

The cross was built circa 1373 (replacing an older one that
had stood on the same spot), and was constructed to celebrate a charter granted
to the city that year by King Edward III. In gratitude, the citizens included
in the cross’s decorations a statue of Edward III himself, accompanied by the
figures of three of the city’s past royal benefactors: King John, Henry III,
and Edward IV.

These standing figures are replicas - the originals are now in the V&A.

In 1633, the cross gained in height, with a new layer of
niches being added. These niches contained the seated figures of Henry VI,
Elizabeth I, James VI & I, and Charles I.

However, by the 18th century it seems that
crosses such as this were not held in very high regard. High Crosses in
Gloucester and Coventry were destroyed in 1749 and 1771 respectively. By 1733,
Bristol’s High Cross was deemed to be an obstruction to traffic. A 1789 account
(see here)
records that, in addition to this problem, a silversmith who lived beside the
cross offered to swear before the city’s magistrates that “every high wind his
house and life were endangered by the Cross shaking and threatening to fall
(though this was not generally then believed) and so requested its removal.”

I wonder whether the silversmith lived in this
building (below)? Built in 1676, it was known as The Dutch House, and the cross would have
been right outside it.

1931 photograph of The Dutch House by Doris Ogilvie[Public domain]

Whether he was a Dutch House resident or not, the silversmith succeeded in his campaign, and Bristol’s
cross was dismantled and “thrown by in the Guildhall, as a thing of no value”,
as the 1789 account tells us. Sometime before 1750, however, it was rescued by
a group of wealthy citizens and re-erected outside Bristol Cathedral on College
Green.

Bristol's High Cross in its second location on College Green.
Painting by Samuel Scott (circa 1750).[Public domain]

Its new lease of life, however, did not last long. In 1763,
a fresh campaign succeeded in having the cross removed for a second time. The
reason given was that it obstructed gentlemen and ladies from walking eight or
ten abreast, as they evidently liked to do. The plan was to set the cross up
elsewhere in Bristol, but this was never carried out. After five years spent in
pieces in a corner of the cathedral, the cross was bought by the banker Henry
Hoare, owner of Stourhead, who had been informed of its plight by his friend Dr Cutts Barton, the dean of the cathedral.

Sad though it might be that the cross cannot be seen in its
true home today, its perambulations have been its salvation. If you click here you can see what
happened to The Dutch House in 1940 – there is no way the cross would have
survived had it still be standing in this street.

The same is true, incidentally, of another piece of medieval
Bristol that has ended up at Stourhead. This edifice (below), was built circa 1474 to help protect a large spring, known as St Edith's Well, from the unsanitary conditions of the street in which it stood. Since the well stood close to St Peter’s church, this became known as St
Peter’s Cross, and then - after pumping equipment had been installed some time before 1546 - as St Peter's Pump (or, marvellously, 'Saynt Peter's plumpe' or 'Saint Peter's Plompe'). It was rebuilt (or perhaps comprehensively repaired) in 1633, but later - like the High Cross - fell victim to the 18th century's enthusiasm for clearing the way for traffic. When in 1766 Henry Hoare offered to remove it at his own expense, provided that he did not have to pay for the stonework itself, the local trustees in charge of the area jumped at the chance.

(At some point, as can be seen below, the building had lost its upper portion, including the actual cross. Everything above the niches containing the figures that you can see here is an 18th-century addition - as is the grotto-like mound on which it stands.)

If you click here, you can see two pictures of the area
where St Peter's Pump once stood – showing the obliteration achieved by the Bristol Blitz.

So, in these two cases, a banker’s acquistions have
preserved medieval treasures for posterity. And, as you can see from the
photographs, the High Cross has been preserved particularly well, though it has
lost its paint and gilding… except for the odd trace:

And it has gained a strengthening central post, added upon its arrival at
Stourhead.

How elegant and delicate the design must have been without
it!

For a fantastic & fascinating collection of photographs of old Bristol, see here.

H.M. Castor's latest novel VIII - a new take on the life of Henry VIII for teenagers and adults - is published by Templar in the UK, by Penguin in Australia, and will be published by Simon & Schuster in the US in August 2013.H.M. Castor's website is here.

6 comments:

What an interesting post, and what a great photographic resource! I have a soft spot for Hoare too - he built Alfred's tower at Stourhead. At least, i think it was him. I've been meaning to ask you - a while ago you wrote a post about Chatterton's house, opposite St Mary Redcliffe. I drove past there a couple of months ago, and could swear I saw a figure - made out of willow, maybe? - sitting on the roof. I couldn't find any mention of it, but don't think I imagined it! Do you know anything about it?

How interesting! I don't know anything about it, no, but I could try to find out... I will be walking past Chatterton's house tomorrow, so I'll have a look - and take a photo if it's there. Will let you know!

I didn't get to Alfred's Tower on this trip to Stourhead, unfortunately, as it was a couple of miles up the road and I'd already exhausted my family by dragging them to St Peter's Pump (which is a long way from the main garden). But I'd love to see it next time we go, as it looks rather extraordinary.

Fascinating stuff. I was actually in Bristol Museum about a month ago, admiring the old map of the city featured in your post and wondering what on earth the central cross was and why it isn't here anymore. Mystery solved!

Search the History Girls

The History Girls

The History Girls are a group of best-selling, award-winning writers of historical fiction and non-fiction. Some of us write for young adults, some for fully fledged adults, some for younger readers.

Among us, we cover every period from the Stone Age to World War II. Geographically, our novels will take you from Trondheim to Troy, and the Caribbean to the Wild West, via Venice, Victorian England and Ancient Rome.

Individual, entertaining, sometimes provocative: on this daily blog we'll share our thoughts on writing, research, reviews, and all aspects of our work. We love what we do and we want to talk about it. We hope you'll want to join in!

If you want a History Girl to appear at an event or write an article or review, please contact her via her website (links are all goven on the About Us page)

Owing to an overwhelming amount of Spam, we have had to disable Anonymous Comments. Please do comment but you'll have to Follow us first.

Just scroll down in this right-hand column to under Followers and click Join this Site. Thanks.