SPCNET Idol 2 - Group division

SPCNET Idol 2

After a rather memorable singing competition in May this year, where we discovered the tasty goodness of cheesecake, SPCNET Idol is back for the second season.

I would like to thank spcnet for kindly donating $20 to the winner of SPCNET Idol and for being so supportive of this competition. Despite his plea to remain anonymous, I am sure you will all recognise that netdriftr is again helping me host this competition, just like the days of Actress Battle Royale, only with less bit-… I mean, conflict.

Everyone who entered deserves a round of applause. The entries are amazing!

I am sure most of the contestants would appreciate constructive criticism, but please also recognise that we are mostly amateurs here and for a lot of people, it is their first time recording or mixing. Everyone really entered for fun- and some of them only did so to support me (cough blackmail) - so keep that in mind when you comment on the entries.

The following CRITERIA will be applied for voters:
Join date must be earlier than the 24th of November 2007
Post count must be greater than or equal to 15

All polls will close in 6 days time. Please check the polls for the exact time.

In the group division, there will be only ONE round, due to the difficulty in collaborating. Because there are more than 10 duets, I am going to ask that you vote in your post. Please try and make your vote STAND OUT so that it doesn’t blend into the page of text.

2) This sounds so close to the original performance. Very good. Although the female singer is a three notches higher than the male.

3) Jay Chou song eh? The girl is not bad, has potential, although sounds a bit stiff sometimes. Did you sing with your grandpa here?

4) Another JY song. One sounds not enough energy and the other sounds too high pitch. Very karaoke.

5) Male sounds okay, female has a nice voice and going with the music, she sounds very hauntingly. I'd like to ask her to sing one of the DGSD 2003 sub songs, I think she would sound good with practice. Still needs room for improvement.

6) One of the guys sound very bored or boring. Bad coordination between the two. Quick, I need coffee!

7) Its the deep voice girl again! She sounds very sultry eh sexy in here. Her partner sounds cute, but not a good control of sound and pitch, not really consistent. Overall, not a bad duo. Where have I heard this song before?

8) Bad recording for 1st singer, can barely hear you. The guy that comes after---you need more pep! Excuse me, are you singing to a baby to sleep? Speaking or Singing? Confused.

9) Both girls have nice voices. I like! Very good. Good job girls!

10) ooh! Emli Chow song? Um, clearly, the girl can sing, not sure about her partner here. Bore. The guy needs more feeeeeeeeling and emooootion. Voice is always so monotone-like.

13) She sang Ai Mei on the bg division right? Guy sounds sexy, ah ha...I meant the voice has that soulful sound to it. Girl, a little pitchy at certain notes. Guy, could do some R&B songs next round?The music kind of overshadows them towards the end though.

Its a close tie between 9 and 13, I think I'll go with 9 even though 13 is good too.

Some duets in here meant to be solos because one is better than the other in singing.

7) Its the deep voice girl again! She sounds very sultry eh sexy in here. Her partner sounds cute, but not a good control of sound and pitch, not really consistent. Overall, not a bad duo. Where have I heard this song before?

um actually, there are three singers in this one... i thought the voices are quite different.

loch-lovely...
yi di lei-i really lked he female voice. the male is also good though
you ni zhen hao-beautifully done!!!! great combination
yi yan shun jian- i like the male's calm and relaxing voice. the female sounds good too