Procurement must be more than just cost cutting

Transcription

1 Procurement must be more than just cost cutting In today s challenging environment, aggressive cost control has become a common theme in the pharmaceutical industry. It became fashionable later than in most industries but today it is with us, and it is here to stay: For the traditional pharmacos, the generics are putting a lid on the revenues from older products. For the generic manufacturers, low cost is a way of life. Many social security systems, generating a large part of the revenues of the industry, are facing challenges because there are insufficiently funded and their ageing members have increasing needs. Emerging nations represent a growth opportunity but cannot afford expensive medications Last but not least, Research, from discovery to clinical trials, is increasingly expensive, while the payback period decreases. Often, before cost pressures forced the implementation of a new Procurement organization, the function was mainly structured to administer Purchase Orders and perform basic quotation requests. Then, we implemented the tools and the culture previously found in other industries such as consumer products or assembly. By consolidating volume across plants and harmonizing specifications, Procurement forced suppliers to improve terms. Often, consultants sped up the process and built organizational skills, with double digit initial cost reduction, followed by smaller annual improvements. Negotiation skills were creating value by lowering the cost of the Bill of Material. Although this is far from today s best practices, it marks the realization by upper management that the Procurement function had more to contribute than offering transactional administrative support. Profit margin improved for a few years, fuelling investment in better systems, and attracting a new breed of good managers. They introduced a more strategic vision of the entire supply chain, gained insights on the Total Cost of Ownership (TCO) and redistributed responsibilities to reduce the TCO with cross-functional initiatives. E-Procurement solutions provided an additional transaction cost reduction. The most powerful companies sometimes convinced their suppliers to open their books, discuss their cost structure and offer new ideas to optimize interfaces, setup and management costs. Reaching this level required that firms rethink their organization, their staffing approach. Those changes could only be justified with a long term vision of the Procurement function and its relation with the other functions in the firm. Nimbleness, flexibility, a culture open to change, those were the common traits of the new winners. The changes were therefore of strategic nature, to capture advantages through excellence in execution. Another change occurred. Procurement extended its responsibilities to support maintenance then capital investments. The support functions were also taking the opportunity to leverage Procurement to control better their budget. Today, most pharmaceutical companies have a professional procurement team dedicated to reducing the cost of services, from office supplies to marketing spend such as events and research. But is this new culture of Procurement sufficient? Where will it lead us? Other industries like automotive or electronics have gone this path before us, but relentless cost cutting did not save GM from the brink of bankruptcy, did not prevent Compaq from being acquired by HP, and was not sufficient to satisfy HP s shareholders after the merger. So what is missing? Can Procurement deliver more? How should CEOs view their Procurement, and what should be their objectives?

2 From Tactical Cost Cutting to Strategic Supplier Management The key to investing is not assessing how much an industry is going to affect society, or how much it will grow, but rather determining the competitive advantage of any given company and, above all, the durability of that advantage i. The Pharmaceutical industry today is especially under pressure to increase shareholder value. This must become an objective for all the functions of the firm, including Procurement, which in turn must reassess its role and its culture. But how many Procurement Professionals in our industry have asked themselves What am I doing better than my competitors? To contribute to the success of the firm on par with the other functions, the Procurement team must focus on identifying and capturing strategic advantages, impacting revenues in addition to profit. When Procurement is capable to have that much impact on the future of the Firm, it deserves to be on the CEO and the Shareholder s agenda. The evolution of Procurement is illustrated by the Figure 1. Impact Cost Shareholder Value Opportunistic Value Capture Transient state, unstable Luck driven approach Traditional Purchasing Leverage scale Negotiate Divide and conquer etc. Supplier Management for growth Source of innovation / unique capabilities and raw materials Faster introduction to new markets Exclusive knowledge capture and leverage Supply market reshaping 3 Supply Chain Management Simplify Optimize Total Cost of Ownership Increase transparency, knowledge of supplier markets e-purchasing Tactical Strategic Figure 1 : The evolution of Procurement Scope When Procurement became an agent of change in a cross-functional approach to optimizing the Total Cost of Ownership, its impact was transactional effectiveness (defined as level 2 above). It improved the relation between suppliers and the value chain of the firm, working together to solve problems more efficiently: design, logistics, value engineering, etc. were discussed. But this approach is not intrinsically differentiating because it has been discussed at length and implemented by many enterprises. Nothing in this approach is proprietary, unique, or differentiating. Firms that have not adopted a level 2 in procurement are lagging, but reaching level 2 is not a guarantee of being ahead for a significant time. The complexity of relationships in our industry has increased significantly. Innovative molecules and solutions are not systematically developed in house, and then manufactured in integrated plants starting with basic raw materials. We leverage a network of biotech firms, and academic research institutes for some part of our innovation. We outsource to low cost Far-East facilities the production of bulk chemicals, and to nimble secondary manufacturing specialists the packaging of our products. We rely increasingly on CRO s to support clinical research and farm out data

3 management to India or South Africa. Health Economists and Key other experts provide advice and support to our commercial departments. So in our innovation driven environment, external resources have become increasingly important to value creation. But an innovation that is accessible equally to all players in an industry builds only value to the final users. Therefore, it is important to manage the sources of innovation to build an extended enterprise rather than a loose relationship that will change direction or be broken with the winds of commercial relationships. Today, the Procurement leadership must develop key suppliers to exploit quickly their skills to their advantage rather than for the benefit of the industry. It must contribute to shaping supplier s strategies to speed entry into new markets. To do so, it must dedicate resources to facilitate seamless and exclusive transfer of value from the suppliers development labs to the final consumers and back. That is the reason why Procurement must understand the lifecycle value creation potential of an item, not only as a driver of the Total Cost of Ownership but, more importantly, as a driver of product pricing through the premiums provided by exclusivity, and/or market growth for the company. Those types of initiatives can only succeed if both partners have common goals, and the trust that both will work together rather than exploit a weakness of their associate at the first opportunity. It does not mean that cost cutting strategies are obsolete. They have become necessary rather than sufficient. They will be useful to manage a large portion of the addressable spend, not the entire spend. This strategic sourcing approach, called Collaborative Sourcing, is differentiated from transactional effectiveness. It can deliver superior returns because it aims specifically at creating a gap between the firm and its direct competitors to create sustainable competitive advantages. Another impact is the securization of long-term strategic materials and resources. Transactional effectiveness only aims at improving the operational aspects of the relation, not to build value for the extended enterprise in a competitive environment. Transactional effectiveness is often driven by a buyer at level 2 who imposes its working approach on all its suppliers forced to go along or be replaced by more compliant alternatives. It can also be the result of an industry wide effort, often pushed by solution vendors. Collaborative Sourcing requires a radical change in the culture and the vision of the relation between the buyer and the supplier. Collaborative Sourcing can involve more than two companies, such as a supplier of raw materials, a packaging manufacturer and a final user. Therefore it is clear that Collaborative Sourcing goes beyond the performance of similar activities better than one s rivals. It is a deliberate attempt to reposition the company by using different and distinctive approaches to managing suppliers. Few companies have competed successfully on the basis of their better effectiveness over an extended period. Collaborative Sourcing is the strategic repositioning of the supplier relationship management. Collaborative Sourcing experts define, search, capture, isolate, manage and improve resources internal and external to the firm to deliver strategic advantages by optimizing internal and external working relations. Collaborative Sourcing relies on trust between involved parties. Comprehensive External Resource Management Moreover, leveraging innovation requires the input of many functions in the firm. Therefore a sourcing strategy aimed at value capture relies heavily on collaborations within the firm. Building and managing this collaboration is a complex task that can only be effective if it is properly orchestrated: this is the role of the Sourcing Manager in the Procurement team.

4 So Collaborative Sourcing is not only a change in the relation between the Enterprise and its suppliers. It is also a change in the relation of the Sourcing Managers and the other functions. In the past, Procurement was only involved when the products hit the supply chain, usually at the industrialization phase or later. Unfortunately, this approach presented a few weaknesses: The scientists are often focusing on obtaining products or services to solve a development problem, rather than a supply chain issue. Therefore, they may not take in account all the parameters involved in long term value creation Although some scientists combine brilliant research capabilities with business savvy, many others have less inclination for negotiation, long term cost benefit analysis, or similar skills that a modern Procurement professional must master. Last but not least, good scientists are in short supply, so why ask them to stretch themselves to cover tasks that others can do faster and more naturally. To support Research activities, Procurement must be involved in securing sufficient supply of a hard to find molecule. While the current needs may be for a few hundred grams of laboratory grade product, the long term growth of the company may require a thousand fold increase or more, with radically more complex specifications and service requirements, capable of entering into a GMP production environment, satisfying strict regulatory constrains. Another area for Procurement involvement is the Clinical Research. Here we are not speaking of the mere improvement of contracts with CRO s or academia. Today s Procurement best practices will support a much more strategic and fruitful collaboration through the application of all the tools of the trade: the transparency tools like cost modelling, the specification tools like benchmarking and process reengineering, in addition to the traditional negotiation tools. Procurement must be a natural partner to all the functions in the Enterprise. Nobody but the finance team identifies and secures funding for a new research or a marketing initiative. Human resource professionals manage compensation, and recruitment. The IT department develops and maintain the architecture of systems supporting all other functions. Likewise, if it is an external resource, it must be managed by the specialists in the Procurement Department (Figure 2). To be effective contributors to the strategic issues of the Enterprise, the Procurement leadership must work closely with the other senior executives in charge of key functions. This can be done through an ad-hoc steering committee, usually with the Finance, Production, R&D and HR leaders. Increasingly, the executive in charge of Procurement reports directly to the CEO and sits on the executive leadership council. In this case, this executive is usually a Chief Procurement Officer, a CPO.

5 Resources Capital: CFO Value Creation Framework Capabilities Building R&D Production Commercial Labor: VP HR Information: CIO external: CPO Support Legal Corp Strat Figure 2 : Procurement is the Manager of External Resources The role of the CPO is to optimize all the relations with external suppliers, a much broader role than the traditional cost cutting approach. It complements the transactional activities in the supplier relationship with Sourcing defined as The process of identifying opportunities, evaluating potential sources, negotiating contracts and continuously managing supplier relationships to achieve corporate goals ii. Conclusion In a world class Procurement organization, the potential for creation of shareholder value, not merely the preservation of it, is an intrinsic part of the role of Procurement. The function must be a contributor to strategic differentiation: not only being excellent in executing transactions but also identifying where it can contribute to develop sustainable competitive advantages. Obviously, there will always be a sizeable part of the portfolio that is spent on suppliers that bring no opportunity to differentiate (Figure 3). Those will be managed traditionally to reduce total cost of ownership. Industry-wide solutions, processes to improve transactional efficiency, will be used to stay at the front of the race. And for select relations, collaborative relationships will be developed to build value and support growth.

THE NEXT GENERATION OF HR SHARED SERVICES SUBHEADLINE RUNS HERE AND HERE AND HERE AND HERE SAP Executive Insight It s no secret that implementing HR shared services can help organizations generate significant

Innovation in Indirect Procurement Michel Philippart Professor of Procurement Strategy UCL, ICHEC 1 Definitions Each organization, book, internet site has its definitions. For clarity we use the following

Life Cycle Management in Life Sciences Industry Evolving from siloed to cross-functional management Audit. Tax. Consulting. Corporate Finance. A need for Lifecycle Management Life Sciences companies are

Contracts as a Source of Value IACCM 2009. All rights reserved. Page 1 Executive Summary Sustained investment in contract and commercial management disciplines will occur only when it is possible to demonstrate

Operations Practice Excellence in Supply Chain Management 3 Foreword As the global business landscape continues to evolve, so do its challenges. New competitors are entering the market. Product life cycles

Comprehensive Consulting Solutions, Inc. Bu siness Savvy. IT Smart. What is a Project and when is a Project Manager needed? White Paper Published: March 2001 (with revisions) Explanation of a Project and

Stepping Through the Info Security Program Jennifer Bayuk, CISA, CISM Infosec Program How to: compose an InfoSec Program cement a relationship between InfoSec program and IT Governance design roles and

Drive to the top The journey, lessons, and standards of global business services kpmg.com The new normal for global enterprises is about doing more with less while at the same time driving the top line

IBM Sales and Distribution Chemicals and Petroleum White Paper Tapping the benefits of business analytics and optimization A rich source of intelligence for the chemicals and petroleum industries 2 Tapping

Accenture Technology Consulting Clearing the Path for Business Growth Mega technology waves are impacting and shaping organizations in a profound way When a company s executive management team considers

Digital Customer Experience Digital. Two steps ahead Digital. Two steps ahead Organizations are challenged to deliver a digital promise to their customers. The move to digital is led by customers who are

Accenture Risk Management Industry Report Life Sciences Risk management as a source of competitive advantage and high performance in the life sciences industry Risk management that enables long-term competitive

Small to Midsize Enterprises Profiting from Innovation March 2007 Executive Summary S mall to midsize enterprises (SMEs) are actively pursuing product development improvements to deliver more innovative

IT advisory SERVICES Driving Business Value A closer look at ERP consolidations and upgrades KPMG LLP Meaningful business decisions that help accomplish business goals and growth objectives may call for

HRG Harvard Research Group HRG Insight: Making Successful Sourcing Decisions Harvard Research Group recommends that organizations include sourcing decision-making as part of their ongoing strategic planning.

Manufacturing the way we see it One Manufacturer : Harmonization Strategies for Global Companies How to Align Enterprise Architecture with Corporate Strategy Recently we have seen many global manufacturers

IRMAC SAS INFORMATION MANAGEMENT, TRANSFORMING AN ANALYTICS CULTURE ABOUT THE PRESENTER Marc has been with SAS for 10 years and leads the information management practice for canada. Marc s area of specialty

J. Holincheck Research Note 3 December 2002 Commentary Leveraging HCM Technologies to Control Labor Costs Large human capital management application suite purchases will be few and far between in 2003.

IT Cost Reduction Doing More with Less Anita Ballaney, Vishwanath Shenoy, Michael Gavigan Strategic IT cost reduction - Doing More with Less The current economic climate will force all businesses to thoroughly

January 2012 Change is happening: Is your workforce ready? Many power and utilities companies are not, according to a recent PwC survey At a glance Our utilities-industry survey shows that many companies

See what cloud can do for you. Uncomplicating cloud business Table of contents Introduction 3 Why cloud is relevant for your business? 4 What is changing? 4 Why organizations are moving to cloud 5 What

When it comes to the supply risk, advanced procurement organizations are most in danger because the actions they have taken to generate savings and results have increased their risk as an unintended consequence.

When it comes to supply risk, advanced procurement organizations are most in danger because the actions they have taken to generate savings and results have increased their risk as an unintended consequence.

Consulting Services Portfolio IT SERVICES PROVIDER IT SERVICES PROVIDER Not so long ago, presence at a low cost delivery location was good enough for a company to penetrate and succeed in the IT outsourcing

Top 5 Transformative Analytics Applications in Retail Learn how you can boost your bottom line and acquire engaged, happy customers with actionable insight from the world s most comprehensive analytics

European truck aftersales 2030 Securing the most profitable business Study Munich, December 2015 Management summary Why react? Pressure points within the aftermarket environment for OEMs What to do? OEMs

INDUSTRY OUTLOOK APRIL 2013 Enterprise Performance Management Chief financial officers must address a growing list of modern business imperatives, and EPM can help. Business today is moving at light speed.

MRO Optimization for high performance Accenture Product Lifecycle Optimization About Accenture Product Lifecycle Optimization (APLO) By creating APLO, Accenture has assembled in a dedicated Service Line

Integrated Learning and Performance EXECUTIVE SUMMARY In today s Age of Talent, Enterprise Learning and Talent Management have become key factors in organizations strategic competitiveness. The tight labor

INNOTAS EBOOK The Transformational CIO The Change Agent That Drives Business Strategy Table of Contents Introduction.... 3 Shifting the Focus to Strategic IT Projects.... 4 Adding Value Through IT Operations....

W Finding Efficiency in Clinical Research Time waits for no company. We help biopharmaceutical companies build global competitive advantage in their clinical research operations. Why does this happen in

Global Account Management for Sales Organization in Multinational Companies * Tino Canegrati ** Abstract A Global Company is not just a Multinational Company, but on top it has developed an organizational

IT Governance Regulatory Perspective P.K.Patel AGM, MoF Agenda What is IT Governance? Aspects of IT Governance What banks should consider before implementing these aspects? What banks should do for implementation

The evolution of the IT manager The move to service management Executives are turning more and more to IT to help their business swiftly adapt its processes to accommodate changing market conditions. Within

Why India May Not Be the Outsourcing Destination of Choice Dalip Raheja CEO The Mpower Group, Inc Agenda Why India May Not Be The Outsourcing Destination of Choice A Global Perspective on Global Outsourcing

Rethinking Key Account Management: adapting and refining your Sales organization s response to the new realities Managing the future Most executives recognize that the real assets of a company are embedded

TM How to Go from Good to Great with Pricing Software By Craig C. Zawada, Senior Vice President, Pricing Excellence, PROS INTRODUCTION GROWING COMPLEXITY DEMANDS SOFTWARE SOLUTIONS Over decades of experience

Understanding Media Asset Management A Plain English Guide for Printing Communications Professionals Interest in Media Asset Management is growing dramatically. A growing number of software and service

White Paper December 2012 The Insurance Industry is Ready for Outsourcing Combined market forces in the insurance and annuity industry are driving carriers to outsource their business processing to a risk-sharing

Career Management Making It Work for Employees and Employers Stuck in neutral. That s how many employees around the world would describe their career. In fact, according to the 2014 Global Workforce Study,

Life Science - a sustainable platform for profitable growth 2012 Life Science Information Day Bernd Reckmann Member of the Executive Board and Head of Chemicals Molsheim, France - December 5, 2012 Agenda

What to Look for When Selecting a Master Data Management Solution What to Look for When Selecting a Master Data Management Solution Table of Contents Business Drivers of MDM... 3 Next-Generation MDM...

Numbers behind HR Benchmarking 7 8 Workforce analytics 8 Workforce Analytics For several years, organizations have focused on the tactical information HR needs, and they ve used technology to drive it.