The phrase “stump for Trump” has acquired a morbid new meaning after a 2011 photo of the candidate’s son holding a dead elephant’s tail was revived in a Photoshop Battle yesterday.

In 2011, Donald Trump, Jr. and his brother Eric reportedly went hunting for a range of big game on a safari trip in Zimbabwe. After TMZ broke the story in March 2012—posting a photo of Trump, Jr. holding the notorious tail—he took to Twitter to defend himself:

Not a pr move I didn't give the pics but I have no shame about them either. I HUNT & EAT game @sharkjumpers: whatever… horrible PR move…

Regardless of whether you support Trump’s hunt or not, redditors are proving that, like elephants, the Internet never forgets—and a five-year-old photo is just as eligible as a more recent snapshot to be the subject of its very own Photoshop Battle.

If you’re not familiar with Photoshop Battles, here’s how they work: A random photo is presented. Anybody in the community can participate. All you need to do is edit the image as you please and submit your work in the comments section.

Reddit user GUANTATDT observed the time-honored Photoshop Battle tradition of the “obligatory face-swap”—which is particularly unsettling for this young Republican and the symbol of his party:

In yet another disturbing addition to the thread, redditor creativecrete reimagined the photo as a Zimbabwean reenactment of The Princess Bride—adding this caption: “You killed my father, prepare to die.”