Was Harry Truman a Zionist?

In November 1953, after he had left the presidency, Harry Truman traveled to New York to be feted at the Jewish
Theological Seminary. When his old friend Eddie Jacobson introduced him
as “the man who helped create the state of Israel,” Truman responded,
“What do you mean ‘helped to create’? I am Cyrus.” Truman was referring
to the Persian King who overthrew the Babylonians in 593 B.C.E. and
helped the Jews, who had been held captive in Babylon, return to
Jerusalem and rebuild their temple.

In his Memoirs, published in 1956, Truman cast himself as a
consistent proponent of the Jewish state, and some of his noted
biographers have followed suit. In Truman, David McCullough
writes that when Truman recognized the new state of Israel in May 1948,
he had “no regrets” about what “he achieved.” Truman’s reputed devotion
to Israel has become the standard by which subsequent president’s
commitment is measured. In 1982, Richard Nixon described Ronald Reagan
as the “most pro-Israel president since Truman.” A Boston Globe
editorial in 1998 described Bill Clinton as “the most pro-Israel
president since Harry Truman.” In 2009, Charles Krauthammer described
George W. Bush as “the most pro-Israel president since Harry Truman.”
And Vice President Joseph Biden declared in 2012 that “no president
since Harry Truman has done more for Israel’s security than Barack
Obama.”

To be sure, Truman had no regrets about Israel after he
left office. Israeli Prime Minister Ben Gurion recounted how when,
during a meeting in New York in 1961, he praised the former president
for his “constant sympathy with our aims in Israel … tears suddenly
sprang to his eyes.” But in the years leading up to, and in the months
following, American recognition of Israel in May 1948, Truman was filled
with doubt and regret about his role. The rosy portrayal of Truman’s
unquestioning commitment to and constant sympathy with Israel, which is
often linked to a picture of the younger Truman as a Christian Zionist,
is dead wrong....