I would love the Supreme Court to say, "Let's send this back to the states." Rather than having a federal mandate through Roe v. Wade, let the states again consider this issue state by state.

Sen. John McCain made a similar, "let the states decide" argument in 2008. It's an old line from anti-choice politicians.

It's no big deal if the Supreme Court overrules nearly 40 years of jurisprudence that says a woman has a fundamental, constitutional right to choose safe, legal abortion care, these politicians say. The issue would just go to the states.

But what would it mean if states got to consider the issue of a woman's right to choose, "state by state?"

It would mean very bad news for women throughout the nation.

If Roe v. Wade were overturned today, women could lose the right to legal abortion immediately in 17 states.

Fifteen states have near-total bans on abortion already on the books that aren't in effect because they are unconstitutional. Bans in the following states may become enforceable if Roe falls: AL, AZ, AR, CO, DE, LA, MA, MI, MS, NM, OK, UT, VT, WV, and WI.

26 Comments

The direction that the right-wing GOP is taking us scares the hell out of me. Why are they trying to undo the progress women's rights have made in the past 40 years. Women and the men that love them need to speak up at the ballot box in November. Republicans need to be voted out of Congress. Obama must be re-elected. We cannot afford to backtrack.

I am with you Elaine, this scares the hell out of me. The only thing that bothers me more than all of these old men with no MD after thier name trying to come between me and my doctors are the women who actually suppport this crap. I fear that women in my generation have become complascent since all of these rights were fought for and won before our time and we have taken them for granted. I fear that the outcry will not come till they are taken away.

@ imari david - So, let me get this straight: you want to outlaw half of all american's right to choose whether something so utterly personal is correct for them because YOUR family had a bad experience? Are you serious?!

For Nicole and Elaine...
Yes we want Romney elected and for many more reasons than mentioned here. And yes we want Roe overturned because it was bad law and now that the President is turning flips trying to make everyone pay for your abortion, that law is getting worse. If you can afford recreational sex, then you can afford abortion, at least financially. You'll never be able to afford it mentally, emotionally, or spiritually. Here's novel idea...take responsibility for your actions and/or lack of protection.

Nearly overwhelmed by your underwhelming logic. You are reasoning that the President is trying to "make everyone pay for your abortion" - proof, please.

The reason that Roe v. Wade was successfully argued at the Supreme Court is precisely because states had such disparaging laws about abortion - but most were moving towards making abortion legal BECAUSE SO MANY WOMEN WERE DYING.

Mothers, sisters, aunts, daughters.

Take responsibility for your actions? Do you not see that the Republican Congress is trying to limit access to birth control as we write this? What responsibility can a women (and why just the woman?) practice if she isn't even able to use birth control because she can't afford it or doesn't have access to it?

Keep in mind - abortion was not prohibited in the United States until about the turn of the century. From that time until 1973 so many women died that even CLERGY were activists in the movement to get abortion legalized.

Your assertion that if "you can afford recreational sex, then you can afford abortion" not only trivializes the women that would chose to continue with their pregnancies and deliver healthy babies but for tragic and unforeseen complications, it also diminishes the value of the women in YOUR life, because one out of three women in the US have had an abortion, so chances are one of them is related to you.

We're well aware that being anti-choice makes you FEEL GOOD about yourself, morally superior and righteous. You're worshiping at the feet of the idealized fetus - because you have no real connect to those "babies" that you think you're saving.

Remember this always: Abortion is no less prevalent where prohibited, it is merely less safe.

If abortion was made illegal merely to protect the life's of 'unborn children', then why are there half a million children in foster care awaiting adoption? Shouldn't pro lifers be fighting over who gets to adopt these forgotten children?
When folks make the comment to the effect of "women should keep their legs closed" it merely PROVES that they don't give a damn about children, just punishing women for engaging in sex....
Finally just because abortion is illegal, doesn't mean it will cease.... think about that

If Roe V. Wade is overturned, everyone will be forced to kiss their rights to privacy, in addition to the choices they make as they go about their daily lives as humans, goodbye. Not having any level of privacy in one's life is the scariest fear that I have. I do not understand people with "nothing to hide" about thier lives. In fact, I find them downright frightening. I firmly believe it's possible to be honest about yourself and draw a boundary as to what you choose to reveal publicly and what you choose to keep to yourself. Having some forms of privacy in my own personal life keeps me sane. Why are not the privacy advocates more concerned about this matter?

The laws that have passed and are being contemplated regarding contraception and abortion make all women 2nd class citizens.

Why, if I am a 2nd class citizen. should't I only have to pay 1/2 the taxes? Why not start a campaign to have women in states that have passed these laws write the state demanding refunds for overpayment of taxes?

Abortion & birth control are private, personal, MEDICAL decisions. The government has NO right getting involved. Banning abortion in some states would be similar to banning heart surgery, dialysis, chemotherapy, etc & other medical procedures. Sadly, the only way to put end the abortion debate would probably be via a civil war, with one side completely eradicating the other.

Nicole Grove: When my grandfather open heart surgery & MY family had a bad experience with that. I think we should ban it. (JOKE) But seriously.....how about a ban on Viagra? Women could place a pseudo-ban on it but simply refusing to have sex with any man who uses it. Likewise for any MAN who is "pro-life".

"make everyone pay for your abortion" So??? And??? It's a medical procedure, moron. So can I choose not to pay for your antibiotics, heart surgery, eye exams, etc? If you can afford a computer for recreational purposes such as this, you should be able to afford your own medical care. I never quite understand how some people who are so utterly clueless, can function in everyday society.

Chris - perhaps you're unaware of this (maybe because you've never had consensual sex w/o money involved?) but "recreational sex" is 100% free. I really don't know how much you've been paying for sex, but a majority of people normally don't pay for it. So your whole basis of "if you can afford recreational sex, you should be able to afford an abortion" is total nonsense. You're commenting out of pure ignorance, on a subject you obviously know nothing @ all about. There is a name for people who do that. They're usually called "Fools".

Thanks a lot for sharing this with all people you actually recognise
what you are speaking approximately! Bookmarked. Please also consult with my web site
=). We may have a hyperlink alternate arrangement between us

I have got go through some great information the following link. Certainly price book-marking for revisiting. I'm wondering the amount efforts you add to generate this sort of excellent useful internet site.

Do you know how to make your site mobile friendly?
My blog looks weird when browsing from my apple iphone.
I'm trying to find a theme or plugin that might be able to resolve this issue.
If you have any suggestions, please share. Many thanks!

Remarkable challenges below zahnimplantat selters. My business is very happy to professional your own post. Appreciate it exactly what taking a look ahead get in touch with you actually. Might you make sure you lower me a send?

We appreciate you some other beneficial site SABIA. Wherever in addition may perhaps I receive that will variety of information developed in this ideal strategy? I own a assignment that i am only right now jogging upon, and I've been for the be aware of these kinds of info.

For those without a webcam, Huddles provide a more common chat experience.
4) Sitemaps can also organize the structure of your
respective site. This happens because low click through rates can get less traffic and so have lesser probability of getting conversion to sales.

Um, click here this means that you can capitalize on with just a case
of clothes. They are made every year. Never
deal with a few of your items that are reflective and
specifically made for the recommended time, every season. I really like that, it
will always be happy to just click here bung them all into
a scatter ñ go to Page Layout, then print.

They will make a decision on your ability to maintain yourself, how
much confidence and respect you seem to have, and whether or not they even want to deal with you.
Make sure the house is not overwhelmed by
landscaping. Lay a piece of newspaper on the floor, crumple
it up into a ball for thirty seconds, and then repeat with the other hand.