Man number one doesn't need self-defense or survival skills. He could pay someone to hurt man number two if he wanted to. Also, Man number one has gained a position in society that gives him influence, therefore, it would be easier for him to fulfill his desires. Man number two would have a harder time getting what he wants, unless of course he resorts to violence and threats because of his training, but that wouldn't be too smart now would it? So my answer as to who is more satanic: Man number 1.

Another thing: Being over weight doesn't matter at all. If Man number one was a satanist, he would know that he has made the choice to stay overweight, and with his money, he could pay for liposuction if he wanted to.

I would say that none is more Satanic because the question is purely hypothetical. If the question were based in reality then they are both equally as Satanic (providing both these men know what Satanism is which I assume your question aims at, but then I can't be sure of that) If they both are self proclaimed Satanists and know what that means then there is no answer to your question, there is no one 'more' Satanic than anyone else if the parties involved know what it is to be a Satanist and practise it as taught.