Car Drivers Issued Warnings, Citations at More than Twice the Rate of CMV Drivers

January 14, 2013

Law enforcement officials who pulled over nearly 35,000 commercial and passenger vehicle drivers during the Commercial Vehicle Safety Alliances Operation Safe Driver 2012 campaign in October found that passenger car drivers continue to speed at alarming rates around commercial vehicles.

Data collected during this years weeklong event indicates that the top three reasons warnings and citations were issued to both commercial and non-commercial vehicle drivers were comparable to last year, however, there was a slight shift in the order of the violations.

This years totals continue to indicate that the number one violation for 2012 is Speeding, number two was Failure to Use a Safety Belt and number three was Failure to Obey a Traffic Control Device while operating their vehicle. In 2011, Failure to Obey a Traffic Control Device ranked second; Failure to Use a Safety Belt was third.

Stephen A. Keppler, CVSAs executive director, said, Its distressing that the number of passenger car drivers who break the law and put their lives and the lives of others in jeopardy while driving around commercial motor vehicles is still so high. The majority of fatal crashes that involve large trucks and passenger cars are precipitated by the car driver.

One of our goals for Operation Safe Driver is to bring awareness to passenger car drivers that they needlessly put themselves and others in danger by failing to recognize that commercial vehicles and cars differ in their handling characteristics, Keppler explained.

From the data collected by 2,918 enforcement personnel at 1,245 locations across the United States and Canada, the majority of warnings and citations were for speeding. Of all of the warnings issued, 70.1% were for speeding.

The breakdown was 19.6% for commercial motor vehicle drivers versus 50.5% for passenger car drivers. Compared to the 2011 data, this represents a slight increase of 2.8% for CMV drivers and a significant increase of 10% for passenger car drivers.

Speeding accounted for 66.2% of all citations, with passenger car drivers issued 51.2% of the total and CMV drivers being issued 15%. This is a 10% increase over last year for passenger car citations.

Warnings for Failure to Use a Safety Belt represented 3.6% of the total number of warnings to CMV drivers and 1.9% of passenger car drivers. In addition, Failure to Use a Safety Belt was the reason 9.9% of citations were issued to CMV drivers and 8.3% were issued to passenger car drivers. These figures represent an increase in the number of recorded citations for both CMV and passenger car drivers over the previous year.

The violation increases for safety belt use in CMV drivers are alarming, particularly since the last several years has seen a steady rise in the number of CMV drivers buckling up.

For Failure to Obey Traffic Control Devices warnings issued, 3.6% were to CMV drivers and 1.9% to passenger car drivers. This translates to increases of 4% for CMVs and 1.5% for car drivers, which is relatively unchanged from the 2011 data. Failure to Obey Traffic Control Devices accounted for 4.7% of citations to CMV drivers and 2.3% of citations to passenger car driver counterparts.

It is vital to educate the public about driving safely around large trucks and buses and that every driver maintains a sharp focus on safety, said FMCSA Administrator Ferro. Always provide plenty of extra space for large trucks and buses to maneuver and to stop. Every driver must do their part so that every individual may reach their destination safely.

Brian Neal, Chairman of the Operation Safe Driver Program, says the data clearly indicates the urgency for greater awareness and adoption of the programs and techniques that are available to educate the public about sharing the road with large trucks.

Two initiatives, such as the Operation Safe Driver Teens and Trucks and Defeating Distracted Driving programs, can be used to continue the safety effort around education and awareness. In addition, partnering with organizations such as the National Organization for Youth Safety will allow the Operation Safe Driver programs to reach critical driving populations as they develop their driving skills and habits.