Corinne Olympios, one of the few memorable contestants on Season 22 of The Bachelor featuring Nick Viall, has a theory about the next Bachelor contestant Colton Underwood, who claims he’s a virgin.

During an appearance on iHeart Radio’s The Domenick Nati Show on Wednesday, the host asked Olympios, “How do you think Colton will do as the next Bachelor?” Wasting no time, she hit back with, “I don’t know. I just have some insincere feelings I get from him, so, we’ll see how that pans out.” Nati followed up with, “Do you think he’s really a virgin or do you think it’s all an act?” Olympios retorted, “I do think that [his virginity] was a lie. I don’t know why, but I just don’t buy it.”

Olympios went on to say she thinks Blake Horstmann, the unremarkable runner-up from Becca Kufrin’s Bachelorette season—the same one that brought us Colton—should’ve been the next bachelor. Honestly, caring about either guy is about as exciting as watching grass grow, except in the rare exception that Colton shows a modicum of personality.