Mobile Payments: The Difference Among the Tech Giants

March 10, 2015

11:00 am

Share

Recently, at the 2015 Mobile World Congress, Google announced that it is currently working on a new system of mobile payments for Android. This confirmation put the company alongside two other technology giants that have already entered the mobile payment market: Apple and Samsung.

Despite their solutions having very similar names, Apple Pay, Samsung Pay, and now Android Pay, there are some important aspects in which they differ. Let's take a closer look at them in order to understand where those differences are, and how they can affect the functioning of the services.

Apple and Samsung have similar approaches

Apple and Samsung are known to have some issues between them, but they seem to share the vision for this market: they both want users to buy products from stores using only a smartphone, without the need to use a credit or debit card.

Apple Pay only works in the most recent iPhone versions, which have the NFC (Near Field Communication) feature. At the moment, over 200,000 merchants support Apple Pay, but not all of them are equipped to handle NFC. However, according to research by Trustev, 80% of iPhone users with access to Apple Pay have never tried it.

Similarly, Samsung Pay only works on newer smartphones as well, specifically in the Samsung Galaxy S6. Nevertheless, phones from the South Korean company will also become compatible with a technology called Magnetic Secure Transmission (MST), which can be applied in about 90% of current sales terminals. This feature can only exist thanks to LoopPay, their latest acquisition.

In terms of security and privacy, both services are still very alike: they depend on the user's fingerprint to authenticate purchases and neither company has permission to access user data, be it what they bought or how much they paid for a product.

Unlike its two competitors, Android Pay is a platform, not a product

Google had its go on mobile payments a while ago with the launch, back in 2011, of Google Wallet. However, and unlike Apple Pay, Samsung Pay, and even Google Wallet, Android Pay is not a product – it is an API layer, which means that it can (and surely will) be used by third-party companies and services to process mobile payments. Google Wallet, for example, will be powered by Android Pay.

Therefore, in a way Google Pay will not be a competitor for Apple and Samsung Pay. And, unlike them, Google's new service will have access to all the transactions made by users, which probably means that Google is planning to take advantage of that information by knowing users' shopping habits and improve the accuracy of ad targeting.

Apple is dealing with another labor violation complaint, as China Labor Watch has released a report noting 18 different violations of Chinese labor laws, including forced overtime, unpaid meetings, and the over-employment of temporary workers.

Apple has officially announced its new lineup of iPhones, including the iPhone 11, the iPhone 11 Pro, and the iPhone 11 Pro Max. Learn more about price, specs, and availability here, as well as whether or not you should buy one for yourself.

The iPhone 11 series launch was the most underwhelming in years. We're inclined to wonder whether there's any point in buying the new iPhones or whether it's worth sticking with your current one, or waiting for 2020. Or whether, whisper it, you might be better of with an Android?