Crime-Fraud Exception to Attorney-Client Privilege

By on

In In re Campbell, 13 Fla. Law W. Fed. B183 (Bankr. M.D. Fla. 2000), debtor filed an objection to creditor’s motion to compel production of documents filed against debtor’s counsel. Debtor asserted the attorney-client privilege, attorney work product. The Creditor alleged that non-exempt assets were converted to exempt assets with the intent to hinder, delay or defraud creditor and the privilege fails under the crime-fraud exception to the privilege. Id.

The crime-fraud exception is associated with a client who consults a lawyer for advice for a fraudulent undertaking. Id. at 10, SeeIn re Warner, 87 B.R. 199 (Bankr. M.D. Fla. 1988). If advice is obtained with respect to past crimes or misconduct then it is privileged. However, advice sought in contemplation of commission, prior to commission, or during commission of a fraudulent undertaking prior to the commission of a fraudulent event then it is not privileged. Id. at 10.

To invoke the crime-fraud exception to the attorney-client privilege a two part test must be met. First, a party must provide, “prima facie evidence showing that the client was engaged in criminal or fraudulent conduct when he sought the advice of counsel, that he was planning such conduct when he sought the advice of counsel, or that he committed a crime or fraud subsequent to receiving the benefit of counsel’s advice” Campbell, 13 Law. Law W. Fed. B183, 9-10 citing In re Grand Jury Investigation (Schroeder), 842 F.2d 1223, 1226 (11th Cir. 1987). Second, the party must show that the attorney’s advice was obtained in furtherance of the criminal or fraudulent activity or closely related to it. id.

The Court in Campbell, found that the crime-fraud exception to the attorney-client privilege applied. The Creditor did raise sufficient inferences that the transfer may have been fraudulent. The Bankruptcy Court concluded that the Creditor was entitled to certain documents that might be part of a fraudulent plan

A clear goal is necessary to rally public support, to set expectations, and to select the best approaches to achieve the goal. To date, strategic clarity and efficacy have been notably lacking in the administration’s approach to China.

All across the nation, Americans are gearing up for their first vacation of the summer over Memorial Day Weekend. For many Americans, these vacations become cherished memories of setting out on the open road to enjoy time with their loved ones. Unfortunately, some of these trips will end in tragedy.

The SECURE Act would be the first real major retirement legislation since the Pension Protection Act in 2006. While the bill has essentially 29 new provisions, it really falls short on making retirement more "secure" for Americans as basically every major retirement issue is untouched in bill.

One could logically argue that crude oil prices should be heading toward $100 a barrel given the bullish factors in global oil markets. Why prices have stayed low is something of a mystery that cannot be explained by President Trump's Twitter habits alone.

Job growth has been running 80% stronger in low-tax states than in high-tax states since the passage of the Tax Cuts and Jobs Act of 2017 in December 2017. Understanding why holds important lessons for policy, economics, and politics.

In the battle against the damaging effects of concussions, along with the ongoing need for better cushioning for prosthetics, new tools are always welcome. Auxetic foam is one – it expands as it’s stretched and shrinks when compressed, offering much more effective cushioning than regular foams.