4. unresolved heart issues. His camp initially said low EF was due to dehydration, but we have not heard anything since. no reports of repeat echo or diagnostic CT, etc.

in anycase, a normal body can maintain homeostasis. dehydrated and thus have decreased extracellular fluid? no problem, body will push intracellular fluid to extracellular, kidneys will increase re-absorption of fluid, veins will vasoconstrict to send more blood back to the heart (veinous system is the storage for extra capacity), heart rate can increase.

Basically your body will do what it needs to so that it can pump enough blood out (i.e. the importance of ejection fraction). A guy who has a low EF at rest is a concern....specially for an athlete.

4. unresolved heart issues. His camp initially said low EF was due to dehydration, but we have not heard anything since. no reports of repeat echo or diagnostic CT, etc.

in anycase, a normal body can maintain homeostasis. dehydrated and thus have decreased extracellular fluid? no problem, body will push intracellular fluid to extracellular, kidneys will increase re-absorption of fluid, veins will vasoconstrict to send more blood back to the heart (veinous system is the storage for extra capacity), heart rate can increase.

Basically your body will do what it needs to so that it can pump enough blood out (i.e. the importance of ejection fraction). A guy who has a low EF at rest is a concern....specially for an athlete.

I disagree with a few of those points.

1. While it is true that 3-4 DEs are usually a little taller 1-4 in taller arm length can easily remedy the lack of height.

2. He can play both and do so very well.

3. While he might not have those quicktwitch moves he can bull rush with the best of them.

4. of course if the heart issue isn't cleared he isn't going in the 1st round.

__________________
Stafford Sig by touchdownrams the rest of the sig by Sig Master Bone Krusher Avy by King of all avys renji

One analyst said he was THE quickest defensive lineman off the ball in the draft.

I'm not sure if you are adding to my point or if you are trying to detract from the idea that he doesn't have those crazy pass rush moves. But fast off the ball has nothing to do with with pass rush moves.

__________________
Stafford Sig by touchdownrams the rest of the sig by Sig Master Bone Krusher Avy by King of all avys renji

I'm not sure if you are adding to my point or if you are trying to detract from the idea that he doesn't have those crazy pass rush moves. But fast off the ball has nothing to do with with pass rush moves.

Well, I think you lost me more that I lost you! Pass rush moves?? No, I am saying he can disrupt, mainly through bull rush.

Star has 33 5/8'' arms. nothing special. He is ideally suited inside, not at end in any defense.

heard that about Glen Dorsey too when he came out. I would like to see some objective assesment of "power" such as vertical/long jump, and quickness such as 3-cone.

Film will show him pushing lineman straight back into the backfield like a blocking sled. And I don't remember hearing anything about an elite first step from Dorsey, which I did hear about Gerald McCoy.

We've already seen the Chiefs make moves that scratch our heads... so arguing about how good or not a player is... that's besides the point. They'll do what they want to do regardless of what anyone else thinks.

So despite his flaws, I think that Star is a very strong possibility. Reid LOVES DTs in Round 1.

All I can tell you is that none of those descriptions say that he is the fastest lineman off the ball and that Dorsey never destroys individual blockers in the manner than Star has. Dorsey is playing out of position in the NFL, he should be in a 4-3 and allow to penetrate. Star and Dorsey are different players altogether so there is little to compare IMO.

All I can tell you is that none of those descriptions say that he is the fastest lineman off the ball

you are moving the goalposts. earlier you said, "don't remember hearing anything about an elite first step from Dorsey."

I think you will be hard pressed to find a scouting report that doesnt say that he is very quick. He was regularly compared to Sapp who was well known for being a quick 3-tech.

Quote:

Originally Posted by Black Bolt

and that Dorsey never destroys individual blockers in the manner than Star has.

Dorsey was pretty much unblockable 1 on 1 in the SEC (i.e. the most competitive division in NCAA div I).

Quote:

Originally Posted by Black Bolt

Dorsey is playing out of position in the NFL, he should be in a 4-3 and allow to penetrate. Star and Dorsey are different players altogether so there is little to compare IMO.

I am not comparing them. You are the one under the impression that Star is BOTH a penetrator (like Sharif floyd) and a powerful 2-gaper. I agree that Dorsey would likely have been better suited in a 4-3. I also think that Star would be better suited as a NT in a 3-4 or a NG in a 4-3.

If the chiefs draft him, than they should expect similar production as a pass rusher as Dorsey and TJackson. They are guys that will do very well agains the run, but limited against the pass.

I think Reid is gonna take Star. They might've showed up at Oregon only to portray the interest in Jordan, hoping that some team who wants him will trade up to get him. But Reid wants to get him some Lotulelei.

you are moving the goalposts. earlier you said, "don't remember hearing anything about an elite first step from Dorsey."

I think you will be hard pressed to find a scouting report that doesnt say that he is very quick. He was regularly compared to Sapp who was well known for being a quick 3-tech.

Dorsey was pretty much unblockable 1 on 1 in the SEC (i.e. the most competitive division in NCAA div I).

I am not comparing them. You are the one under the impression that Star is BOTH a penetrator (like Sharif floyd) and a powerful 2-gaper. I agree that Dorsey would likely have been better suited in a 4-3. I also think that Star would be better suited as a NT in a 3-4 or a NG in a 4-3.

If the chiefs draft him, than they should expect similar production as a pass rusher as Dorsey and TJackson. They are guys that will do very well agains the run, but limited against the pass.

No, I am not under the impression that he is a penetrator "like Floyd." I specifically said he can disrupt with this bull rush. I didn't say he exploits gaps, which is what Floyd does.