Reviewer:

Was OK, something just didn't feel/taste right. Followed recipe to the T except sour milk, used 1 cup milk with a TSP of vinegar. Pie tasted floury/dough like, think it was lacking sweetener of some sort. Filling was a bit over sweet.

Reviewer:

I think these are pretty good - really 3 1/2 stars... I think the cookie could use a bit more flavor and I think I would have preferred the filling without the beaten egg whites - anyone know why that's in there? I did use butter (instead of shortening) in the filling just b/c I had already used shortening in the cookie and I just couldn't use that much! Overall good though.

Reviewer:

These whoopies were exactly like they're supposed to be. The only things I did differently was use 1 cup regular milk and 1 tsp. vinegar, because I didn't have sour milk and I used probably less than half the sugar for the frosting. Just my personal preference.

Reviewer:

I used this recipe for the cookie part but not the frosting. It was out of this world. It made so many I spent an hour driving them around my neighborhood giving them to friends. Wow, were they great though. The cookies themselves were totally delish on their own also. I used a filling made with marshmallow fluff and... YUM!

Reviewer:

I have never made whoopie pies before, and have eaten maybe 1 or 2 in my life. I wouldn't consider my myself an expert baker either. I made my first batch exactly like the recipe, using lemon in my milk(sour milk), and beating the eggs to a froth (icing). They turned out perfect & baked exactly in 8 min as instructed. Short of putting a lock on my fridge, my family was begging for more! I thought they were good, but since I was born with an insanely sweet tooth, I felt the cookies could be a bit sweeter so I decided to make a second batch. I added 2c mini chocolate chips to the batter before baking. I also made and used two batches of icing to 1 batch of pies. They were DIVINE and will satisfy any sweet tooth extremist to their hearts content, even without the alterations!!! I'm definitely adding this to my recipe collection! I will be fighting the urge to not dig in to the almost 6 doz pies sitting in my fridge once my kids get in bed tonight! I'm donating to a fundraiser, and a football team. For their sake, I hope I can control myself for the next 18 hrs! I also LOVE that this recipe makes so many at once. I pretty much got 36 out of the batch.