Saudi Arabia cracks down on dissent

RIYADH, Saudi Arabia — Mohammad al-Qahtani usually talks to his family at 2 a.m., when his prison cell block in Saudi Arabia is quiet and his wife is making dinner for their five kids in their home in exile in Rochester, New York.

Every night, Qahtani, a human rights activist serving 10 years in prison for “questioning the integrity” of Saudi government officials, sings “Let’s Go Fly a Kite” to his 2-year-old daughter, whom he has not seen since before he was imprisoned in March 2013.

Additional Images

“In this country, if you open your mouth, you end up in prison,” Qahtani, an academic with a PhD in economics from Indiana University, said in a telephone interview from his Riyadh lock-up.

The case of Raif Badawi, a blogger whose criticism of Saudi’s powerful religious leaders led to a sentence of 10 years in prison plus 1,000 lashes in public, has focused harsh international attention in the past week on Saudi Arabia’s human rights record.

But Badawi’s case is simply the most recent example of what rights groups call an intensifying campaign to punish activists, bloggers and anyone else who challenges the country’s political or religious leaders. People have been jailed for tweets, and two women have been held since early December for defying the ban on women driving.

“The government wants to send a message to the people: if you think like them, if you talk like them, you will spend all your life in the jail. They want to make an example of these people,” Samar Badawi, the blogger’s sister, who is also a human rights activist, said in a telephone interview from her home in the Red Sea port city of Jiddah.

Samar Badawi in 2012 received a U.S. State Department “International Women of Courage Award,” which was presented to her in Washington by then-Secretary of State Hillary Rodham Clinton and first lady Michelle Obama.

DANGEROUS SPEECH

She has been especially affected by the government’s imprisonment in the past two years of at least a dozen activists for speech it deems criminal, but which would be considered harmless by Western standards. In addition to her brother, who angered authorities by saying the country’s religious establishment had too much influence, her husband, Waleed Abulkhair, has been in jail since April 2014.

Abulkhair, 35, is a human rights lawyer convicted of “disrespecting the authorities” and “disobeying the ruler” after he criticized the government’s rights record and founded a human rights organization. Abulkhair was originally sentenced to 10 years plus a fine of more than $250,000, but last week a Saudi judge increased the prison term to 15 years when Abulkhair refused to sign an apology and pledge to refrain from further dissent.

Still, she said, the government’s actions have silenced many activists. “People are afraid. Everyone is afraid. They cannot talk, they cannot move, they can’t do anything,” she said.

“I don’t have any choice,” she said when asked why she was willing to speak to a reporter. “I must let all the world know what is going on here in Saudi Arabia. I have to do this for my husband, for my brother and for my daughter; I have to do something. I cannot stop. I must take this risk, and we will hope that they do not do anything to me.”

Saudi Arabia, one of Washington’s closest allies in the Middle East, has long been assailed for its human rights record, which the U.S. State Department says includes the use of torture and arbitrary detention. The country also applies an especially strict form of sharia, which has resulted in the beheadings of at least 10 people so far this year, according to media reports. On Friday in the holy city of Mecca, a Burmese woman convicted of killing her stepdaughter was publicly beheaded with a sword.

U.S. officials have issued statements criticizing the treatment of Badawi, Abulkhair and other dissidents, but Washington is cautious about pressing hard publicly on human rights with Riyadh, a key military ally and economic partner.

Saudi Arabia and three other Muslim countries are currently taking part with the United States in a military campaign against Islamic State fighters, even sending fighter jets to participate in bombing runs. The kingdom is also one of the world’s largest producers of oil and the second-largest source, after Canada, of oil imported into the United States.

But Badawi’s case has set off a wave of international condemnation as the United Nations, the U.S. State Department and human rights groups around the world have decried the lashings. Protesters have picketed Saudi embassies in Washington, Europe and Canada.

A bipartisan group of eight U.S. senators wrote to Saudi King Abdullah on Friday calling for Badawi’s immediate release and calling his flogging “barbaric” and “something no human being should face for expressing peaceful dialogue about religion or politics.”

AN APPEAL TO THE KING

“Flogging is, in my view, at the very least, a form of cruel and inhuman punishment,” U.N. High Commissioner for Human Rights Zeid Raad al-Hussein said in a statement. “I appeal to the King of Saudi Arabia to exercise his power to halt the public flogging by pardoning Mr. Badawi, and to urgently review this type of extraordinarily harsh penalty.”

A Saudi government official, who spoke on the condition of anonymity because of the sensitivity of the subject, said he did not understand why international groups were so focused on flogging, which is standard practice in many Muslim nations.

“Flogging is a punishment approved by the religion of Islam,” he said. “If your court system is based on Islamic sharia law, you will find this sort of punishment. They do it in Iran, they do it in Afghanistan, and nobody complains.”

The official also said that Badawi’s case was serious because “he insulted Islam.”

In a deeply conservative Muslim nation, he said, the government must punish any perceived insults to the religion, because failing to do so would tempt vigilantes to take revenge on the alleged perpetrators.

“The government tries its best,” he said.

Badawi, 31, received the first 50 of his lashes January 9 in a public square outside a Jiddah mosque after Friday prayers, a scene captured in a video posted on YouTube. It showed Badawi standing silently as a police officer struck his back and legs, and when the 10-minute punishment ended, onlookers cheered “Allahu akbar,” or God is great.

Badawi is to receive 50 more lashes each Friday for 19 more weeks, but medical officials on Friday concluded that his wounds had not healed sufficiently, according to Ensaf Haidar, Badawi’s wife, reached by telephone in Montreal, where she now lives with the couple’s three children.

“It’s a horrendous situation that no one should accept,” said Haidar, who moved to Canada 14 months ago because she no longer felt safe in her home country. “I have no loyalty to this government any longer. No one should be loyal to a government that tortures its sons and robs their humanity.”

Said Boumedouha, Amnesty International’s deputy director for the Middle East and North Africa Program, said in a statement: “The notion that Raif Badawi must be allowed to heal so that he can suffer this cruel punishment again and again is macabre and outrageous.”

Amid the outcry, Haidar said Friday that she was told that King Abdullah’s office had taken the unusual step of referring Badawi’s case to the Supreme Court for review.

“The government changed its decision because of pressure from people in the outside world,” Haidar said. “I am hopeful that he and I and our children will all be back together again one day.”

Saudi human rights activists trace the government’s new zeal to prosecute dissenters to the 2011 Arab Spring uprisings, which toppled authoritarian governments in Egypt, Libya, Tunisia and Yemen, and massive anti-government protests across the Arab world.

Saudi officials largely averted protests at home, mainly by spending tens of billions of dollars on housing, jobs and other benefits designed to appease citizens.

Rights activists said the government also started a campaign to silence dissent, especially targeting those who used Twitter and other social media networks that had served as a key organizing tool for anti-government protests in other countries.

“The regime is so scared,” Qahtani said from prison. “In the aftermath of the Arab Spring and the toppling of so many corrupt dictators, they are terrified. They tried to bribe people. They waited until they weathered the storm, and then they went out and rounded up everyone who opposed them and threw them in jail.”

Qahtani said the government was “obsessed by social media.”

“For years they controlled the media – the TV stations and the newspapers,” he said. “Now they are losing control because of social media.”

A NEW TERRORISM LAW

The government last year enacted an anti-terrorism law, which rights groups have denounced as vague and giving the Ministry of Interior broad powers to arrest those who criticize the government. Abulkhair was the first person arrested under the law.

Qahtani, 49, said he has settled into a routine in his prison in Riyadh. In addition to his nightly call to his family, he said, he exercises every morning in his cell and reads newspapers and watches television news to keep up on current events. His wife, Maha, who is studying at the Rochester Institute of Technology, sends him about $300 worth of telephone calling cards each month.

He said he believes that the Saudi political system should be changed to a constitutional monarchy, which he said would provide more accountability to the people.He said the reforms are especially important in light of the rise of the Islamic State and other violent religious groups.

“If we would have political reforms and guarantee free expression, people would not feel the need to resort to violence,” he said. “So many Saudis are engaged with the Islamic State because of the lack of political freedoms in our country. They are frustrated because they cannot express themselves.”

Here at MaineToday Media we value our readers and are committed to growing our community by encouraging you to add to the discussion.

To ensure conscientious dialogue we have implemented a strict no-bullying policy. To participate, you must follow our Terms of Use. Click here to flag and report a comment that violates our terms of use.