Antioxidant vitamins may cut mortality risk: EPIC data

Users of antioxidant vitamin supplements may be at reduced risk of cancer mortality, as well as premature death in general, suggests data from the European Prospective Investigation into Cancer and Nutrition.

Antioxidant vitamin supplement use at the start of the study was associated with a 48 percent reduction in the risk of cancer mortality over 11 years of study, according to findings published in the European Journal of Nutrition.

In addition, the risk of all-cause mortality was reduced by 42 percent in people who were supplement users at the start of the study, report scientists from the German Cancer Research Centre and the University of Zurich.

‘Sick-user effect’?

General multivitamin/mineral supplementation, however, was not associated with any impact on mortality risks.

And on the flip side, the EPIC researchers note that people who started taking supplements after the start of the study were at a higher risk of cancer mortality and so-called all-cause mortality, said the researchers.

“The significantly increased risks of cancer and all-cause mortality among baseline non-users who started taking supplements during follow-up may suggest a ‘sick-user effect’, which researchers should be cautious of in future observational studies,” they wrote.

Methodological challenges

Commenting independently on the research, Professor Jeff Blumberg, director of the Antioxidants Research Laboratory at the Jean Mayer USDA Human Nutrition Research Center on Aging at Tufts University, said he agreed that based on a “small number of users of antioxidant vitamin supplements and lack of detailed information on dose, contents, and durations of use,” there appears to be a statistically modest reduction in cancer and all-cause mortality.

“Some other studies are consistent with this finding and others are not. Why? Because the methodological challenge of conducting observational studies on the effect of dietary supplements is great and fraught with serious confounding variables (including the difficulty of accurately assessing the product[s] and their use),” he observed.

Controversial

An attempt to bring together the science was made in 2007, with the publication of a meta-analysis by Goran Bjelakovic et al. and from the Copenhagen Trial Unit at the Copenhagen University Hospital in Denmark in the Journal of the American Medical Association (Vol. 297, pp. 842-857).

The meta-analysis concluded that vitamins A and E, and beta-carotene may increase mortality risk by up to 16 per cent.

On the other hand, vitamin C did not have an effect on mortality and the antioxidant mineral selenium was associated with a nine per cent decrease in all-cause mortality.

Following publication of the Bjelakovic paper, numerous scientists and dietary supplement trade associations questioned the methodology, particularly the exclusion of over 400 clinical trials from the data set because no deaths were reported.

Revisiting old data

Recently, a team of internationally renowned antioxidant scientists, including Prof Blumberg, re-analysed the data used by Bjelakovic et al., and arrived at a different set of conclusions.

This re-analysis, published in Nutrients, found that 36 percent of the trials showed a positive outcome or that the antioxidant supplements were beneficial, 60 percent had a null outcome, while only four percent found negative outcome.

New data

The EPIC scientists based their findings on analysis of intakes of 23,943 people, all free of cancer and heart disease at the start of the study.

After 11 years of data collection, the researchers had documented 1,101 deaths, of which 513 were from cancer and 264 from cardiovascular conditions.

Data analysis showed that users of antioxidant vitamin supplements at the start of the study had a significantly reduced risk of both cancer mortality and all-cause mortality, while people who started taking supplements after the study had started had significantly increased risks.

“Based on limited numbers of users and cases, this study suggests that supplementation of antioxidant vitamins might possibly reduce cancer and all-cause mortality,” they concluded.

Compliance

Prof Blumberg added that an issue he has always found interesting is the definition of ‘regular use’ of a dietary supplement.

“In this study, which is not unlike others, using a supplement as little as 25 percent of the typical indication counts as regular use. In other words, for 5 doses or one week of use per month when the label states ‘take daily’,” he said.

“If this was a study of a drug and adherence was this poor, a null outcome would be dismissed as meaningless due to non-compliance.”

Users of antioxidant vitamin supplements may be at reduced risk of cancer mortality, as well as premature death in general, suggests data from the European Prospective Investigation into Cancer and Nutrition.

2 comments(Comments are now closed)

Be sure of the study

There are many types of supplements on the market,
most are typical of the junk category,such as Centrum,One A Day etc. These are made from lab
equivalents of vitamins ,acetates and such.One good example is artificial E not having the full range of tocotrinols and tocopherols that make it effective .There
are ,however whole food bio active supplements such as
BioSans Innate,which are treated ad food in the body,and not an intrusive chemical .Check out the facts and the difference.
Regards,
William J. Bowers

Report abuse

Posted by William Bowers26 August 2011 | 21h362011-08-26T21:36:45Z

vitamins and cancer

YES before during and after in high strength. 500mg < upwards. all variants and makes, sellected according to individual needs and type of cancer for at least five years or more.

Report abuse

Posted by Harry21 August 2011 | 23h162011-08-21T23:16:00Z

Related products

Live Supplier Webinar

30-Mar-2015 - Insights from the aisles are vital for all product formulators and brand owners, but what are the key issues affecting retailers?
How do retailers communicate with consumers?
How is the rise of the online retailer changing the landscape?
What are the key trends...

Video

10-Feb-2015 - Magnesium is needed for over 360 biochemical functions in the body, from energy production to sleep. But it has little benefit if the body cannot absorb or tolerate it. See what Albion’s scientists discovered when they bound magnesium to amino acids such as glycine,...

Technical / white paper

26-Mar-2015 - PLX® from Monteloeder is a natural plant extract that has been shown in clinical trials to combat the effects of oxidative stress. The benefits it offers are perfect for sportsmen and women, and older consumers looking to maintain an active...

Insight guide

19-Mar-2015 - Astaxanthin is the greatest of all of carotenoids as it’s the only one to easily cross the blood-brain barrier and other bio-membranes which make it more easily absorbed and transported to all tissues and organs in the body.Demand has outpaced...

Technical / white paper

19-Mar-2015 - Picture a Healthy Future! With great success BioPQQ® has helped improve the cognitive function of middle aged and elderly test participants and has potential to improve the quality of life of our aging population. As in many other studies the...

Technical / white paper

04-Mar-2015 - The peel is the most nutritious part of the apple, containing 6x more polyphenols than apple flesh. AppleActiv Dried Apple Peel Powder is manufactured using a unique patented process to preserve its fragile nutrients.A 12-week study of subjects with moderate...

Technical / white paper

01-Mar-2015 - Astaxanthin is absorbed into all cells of the body, and can cross the the blood-brain barrier to protect the nervous system. Astaxanthin's singlet oxygen quenching capacity is 6000 times stronger than Vitamin C and 550 times stronger than Vitamin E.

Technical / white paper

17-Feb-2015 - SOD B® - A concentrate of youthContrary to common perception, our body produces its own antioxidants called primary antioxidants (SOD, CAT, GPx) acting at the source of the oxidative stress reaction. As we age, we produce less primary antioxidants, reducing...

Case study

05-Feb-2015 - One of nature’s most powerful antioxidants supporting joint, cardio, brain, eye health and overall graceful aging, Zanthin® offers one of the most powerful lipophilic antioxidants yet discovered.Now you can target the most important issues for baby boomers with an ingredient...

Application note

02-Feb-2015 - Marinova is an Australian biotechnology company dedicated to the research, development and manufacture of fucoidan extracts - complex sulfated polysaccharides derived from brown seaweed. Fucoidans are safe, natural compounds with wide ranging bioactivities that make them particularly beneficial in dietary...

Clinical study

01-Feb-2015 - Cyactiv™, a brilliant “blue antioxidant” provides a new path to a healthy inflammation response allowing for an active lifestyle and overall wellness. Cyactiv is a natural, GRAS-designated microalgae extract, which is clinically proven to reduce physical discomfort in joints and...

Data sheet

19-Jan-2015 - Oximacro® is a cranberry powder and liquid extract with the highest content of Proanthocyanidins (PACs, 36%) on the market.It is produced by Biosfered S.r.l. – an Academic Spin-Off of the University of Turin, Italy – using its proprietary technology, and its...

Data sheet

02-Mar-2015 - In January, several NGOs, scientists and businesses officially came together to help fund important research projects in Antarctica. Organized under the Antarctic Wildlife Research Fund (AWR), these entities will actively raise money for research into krill, a small crustacean that has...

Research study

22-Jan-2015 - Magnesium is required by over 360 biochemical functions in the body, from energy production to sleep. But, it has little benefit if the body cannot tolerate or absorb it. Learn which forms of magnesium provide the greatest absorption, stability and tolerance. Find out...

Technical / white paper

17-Mar-2015 - Inflammation affects heart health, arthritis and many other health issues – and growing evidence suggests that nutrition is part of the solution. Seize this opportunity with custom nutrient premixes.Any nutrient. Any application. Anywhere in the world.

Technical / white paper

25-Feb-2015 - Beauty from Within is a strong growing category. It has promising future in the US especially if we educate the consumers. This White Paper presents some of the key drivers such as delivery systems but also ingredients with strong science...

Clinical study

10-Feb-2015 - Millions of health conscious consumers are looking for nutritional support to help maintain healthy cholesterol levels. With numerous studies supporting Pantesin’s effectiveness in high-risk subjects, current research shows that it is also effective for low to medium risk individuals. This...

Technical / white paper

10-Mar-2015 - L-Citrulline is an amino acid that plays an important role in nitric oxide metabolism and regulation. L-Citrulline is converted to L-Arginine in the body to support L-Arginine and nitric oxide (NO) levels. Increased production of NO supports vascular dilation and...

Technical / white paper

18-Feb-2015 - Gone are the days when the Brand Owner or Own Label Distributor could abdicate the responsibility for the quality of their products to the Contract Manufacturing Organization. This is exactly why Gemini Pharmaceuticals
developed a Quality Partnership Program. With over...

Technical / white paper

17-Feb-2015 - Capros®, backed by 8 clinical studies and one mechanism of action study, is an excellent product for Heart Health. In addition, it is a super antioxidant with an ORAC value of 47,000 µmoles TE/gram. Capros® has a new patent issued...