Mark L. Stout Consulting is an all-purpose transportation consulting firm, specializing in finance, program management, and legislative and DOT policy. Our company has served public agencies and non-profits, big and small, all across the nation. Mark is widely-recognized as an expert whose years of experience can help organizations to break through gridlock and deliver transformative projects and innovative community enhancements.

Mark L. Stout Consulting

Thursday, August 15, 2013

Brasilia or Albany?

OK, of course it’s Albany.Many commentators and critics over the past 40 years have
compared the Empire State Plaza with Brasilia and other “modernist” monumental
government developments – and with many of the same criticisms.

I’m sure nothing significant can be added to the record at
this point, but I have to say that on a recent visit I came away with the
observation that the Plaza (the surface portion – I didn’t go underground)
looks pretty good.The scale is
really decent and the buildings, although too modernist for my taste, have
weathered decently.And of course
the longitudinal vistas – especially toward the Capitol – are beautiful.

My biggest negative takeaway is the lack of pedestrian
activity.A relatively sterile
environment looks even worse with only a few stragglers and workmen
around.(These shots were taken on
a beautiful weekday afternoon.)I
will note that a colleague reported much more activity at lunchtime, with a
small farmers’ market and people moving around.

My advice would be to (1) do something with the rather
scruffy monumental staircase to the state museum (which doesn’t actually offer
an entrance to the museum) and (2) splash some color of some sort on the “Egg,”
which is a theater with no posters, banners, marquees, or other markings.With no trappings of a theater it
rather gives the impression of being an anti-aircraft missile battery.

Albany has a long way to go, but the Empire State Plaza, if
given a thoughtful makeover, could be part of a better future.