A new menu and new look at Shelter Island’s updated Bali Hai Restaurant

by
Nicole Sours LarsonSan Diego Community News Group

Sep 05, 2012 | 8914 views | 0 | 9 | |

Andy, Susie, Larry and Tommy Baumann, operate the Bali Hai. Sons Andy, Tommy and Grant (not in photo) have joined parents Larry and Susie as third generation owner/operators of the Bali Hai and Tom Ham’s Lighthouse. Photo by Nicole Sours Larson I The Beacon

If you haven’t visited Shelter Island’s Bali Hai Restaurant for a few years, be prepared for an exciting surprise when you experience its inviting new look and savor its tantalizing new menus. Several recent visits to this old favorite left this “foodie” hungering to return.

Two years ago, the Bali Hai reopened after extensive renovation by local architect Graham Downes, who restored the traditional Polynesian-inspired 1950s structure and beloved tikis while incorporating sleek 21st century design elements that open the interior and bring inside the tropically landscaped grounds.

“The community has great affection for this harbor landmark,” said Downes. “The Bali Hai is like a house you’ve lived in your whole life. Patrons want that hominess and comfortable familiarity. We strived to maintain that pride and history while contemporizing and freshening the environment.”

The renovation included an updated event pavilion, along with a tropically landscaped alcove ideal for weddings and other outdoor events.

“Our menus will now change frequently, depending on what is freshly caught and available from local farms, markets and suppliers,” said Larry Baumann, co-owner with wife Susie, whose father founded the waterfront icon. The Bali Hai opened originally in 1955 as Shelter Island’s first “tiki temple” and was named after the popular song from the musical “South Pacific.”

A new feature is progressive pricing for happy hour, which runs from 3 to