Case Number 00915

GLADIATOR

The Charge

"My name is Maximus Decimus Meridius, Commander of the Armies of the
North, General of the Felix Legions, loyal servant to the true emperor Marcus
Aurelius, father to a murdered son, husband to a murdered wife, and I will have
my vengeance, in this life or the next."

Opening Statement

Director Ridley Scott is the man who brought us such "modern
classics" as Blade Runner and Alien, as well as popular
favorites like Thelma and Louise. He has also ventured into the world of
the historical epic, making the ill-fated 1492: Conquest of Paradise. Now
he returns to that territory, this time taking on the Roman Empire in his latest
blockbuster, Gladiator.

Facts of the Case

Emperor Marcus Aurelius (Richard Harris -- Unforgiven, Camelot,
Mutiny on the Bounty) is nearing the end of his sixteen-year campaign to
subdue the barbarians of Germania. His armies are commanded by the great general
Maximus (Russell Crowe -- L.A. Confidential, Romper Stomper,
The Insider). Maximus is unique in that he is from Spain, one of the
outer provinces of the Roman Empire, and has never even set foot in Rome.
Despite this he has risen to a position of great responsibility, and has gained
the trust of the Emperor himself.

Marcus Aurelius is also reaching the end of his life, and he knows it. He
has decided that his son Commodus (Joaquin Phoenix -- 8MM, Inventing
the Abbots, Parenthood) is too cruel and shallow to be Emperor, and
chooses Maximus as his successor instead. Maximus does not want this position of
power; he just wants to go home to his wife and son, his crops and fields.
However, he reluctantly agrees to do his duty for Rome and his friend and leader
Marcus Aurelius. Upon learning this, Commodus kills his father before anyone
else is aware of his plans. Commodus orders Maximus executed, his family killed,
and his home and possessions destroyed. Maximus escapes, but is gravely wounded
and is soon captured by slave traders and taken to North Africa.

Once in North Africa, Maximus is sold to Proximo (Oliver Reed --
Oliver!, The Three Musketeers, Women in Love). Proximo runs
a stable of gladiators who fight in the provincial arenas. A former champion
gladiator himself, he recognizes the talent in Maximus. When the decadent
Commodus calls for 150 straight days of games to appease the masses and increase
his own popularity, Proximo sees it as his big chance and brings a selection of
his finest to Rome to fight in the Colosseum. Maximus grows in fame and stature
through his success in the games, eventually gaining a following that rivals the
Emperor himself. Soon he is involved in a web of intrigue involving the Senate,
the Emperor's sister, and the very future of Rome itself.

The Evidence

Like the games it portrays, Gladiator is an impressive spectacle in
its own right. Director Scott and his crew spared no expense in bringing the
look and feel of the Roman Empire to life on the big screen. For the most part,
the results are stunning. Battle scenes are violent, chaotic, and thrilling. The
restored vision of ancient Rome is a wonder to behold. Scott's attention to
detail, his use of subtle symbolism, and his construction of scenes all point to
a skilled, effective director.

At the heart of the movie is Russell Crowe's Maximus. Crowe makes Maximus a
believable person. We see several sides of the character, ranging from the brave
and honorable general to the bitter slave to the savage gladiator. We feel his
emotion at the death of his wife and son; we feel his determination and defiance
in the face of the emperor who destroyed his life. However, perhaps the best
moment in Crowe's performance comes early in the film, when Maximus is
discussing his home with Marcus Aurelius. Crowe takes this stoic, heroic
character and fills him with a mix of homesick longing and boyish giddiness when
talking about the place and the family that he loves.

The other truly captivating performance in this movie comes from Richard
Harris as Marcus Aurelius. He captures the emperor as a philosopher, conqueror,
ruler, and sometime tyrant who knows that he is nearing the end of his days and
wants to see that the right thing is done for Rome after his death.

Other solid performances come from Joaquin Phoenix as Commodus; Connie
Nielsen (Mission to Mars, Rushmore, The Devil's Advocate)
as Lucilla, Commodus's sister; and Djimon Honsou (Amistad, Deep
Rising, Stargate) as Juba, a gladiator who befriends Maximus. I would
be remiss if I did not mention that this was Oliver Reed's last film; he died
during the production and his final scenes were completed with the aid of some
CGI wizardry. His Proximo is a wonderful scoundrel with a heart of gold. Also
deserving special mention as always is action film mainstay Sven-Ole Thorsen
(Conan the Barbarian, The Running Man, Kull the Conqueror)
as "the only undefeated gladiator in Roman history." Granted, he
doesn't really do a heck of a lot, but it's always good to see old Sven.

DreamWorks presents us with another excellent DVD presentation.
Gladiator comes to us in its original aspect ratio of 2.35:1. It is an
anamorphic transfer. Overall the picture is excellent, but it is not without
flaws. There are occasional instances of shimmer, usually in shiny objects like
gold ornamentation on uniforms or clothing. Some scenes are quite grainy, and
there are more film nicks and defects than I would have expected from such a
recent movie. Dark and shadowy scenes are a mixed bag; those earlier in the
movie tend to be a bit soft and muddy, while those later on look excellent.
Colors are rich and faithfully rendered, especially the telltale reds and
blacks. Picture clarity is impressive and sharp, with just a few instances of
obvious edge enhancement. Overall this is a very good transfer, but not
perfect.

The audio is presented in DTS 6.1, Dolby Digital 5.1, and Dolby Surround
2.0. The DTS track is so sharp it is almost painful, especially in the opening
battle scene in Germania. The noise of battle totally fills the room, and
directional effects are excellent. Horses thunder through the room. Arrows don't
so much whistle past your head as scream like F-18s. Hans Zimmer's powerful
score surges through it all. This audio presentation is a real treat for the
senses, and I think no one will be disappointed. The Dolby 5.1 track is very
good as well, making great use of the entire sound system, but it suffers by
comparison with the DTS track.

One of the key areas that prompted me to purchase this disc was the
extensive selection of extra content. Due to the inclusion of both a Dolby 5.1
and a DTS soundtrack, this is a two-disc set, with the bulk of the extra
material on disc two. Disc one contains a feature commentary by Director Ridley
Scott, Director of Photography John Mathieson, and Editor Pietro Scalia. In a
nice touch the commentary track has its own index, so that a viewer can search
for a given topic in the commentary and go directly to the appropriate scene.
The commentary by these three is very insightful and explains various choices
that were made during filming, techniques that were used, and the process of
putting it all together. In my opinion a commentary track is always the single
most important extra that a DVD can have, and this one is very good.

The amount of extra content on disc two is impressive, even by DreamWorks
standards. Here is a list of all that is in store:From The Cutting
Room Floor. This features eleven scenes that were cut from the final version
of the film. They average two to three minutes in length, and can be watched
with normal sound or with commentary by Ridley Scott. Some scenes are fully
completed, some are in various stages of completion, but they are all
interesting. Most of it was cut for time purposes, which is a pity because some
of it is really good and should have been in the movie, notably a scene where
Commodus, in a fit of rage, hacks away at a bust of his father with a sword.The Making of Gladiator. This twenty-five minute presentation is quite
interesting. It does include a lot of the standard sound bites from various
people involved, but it also incorporates some very interesting footage,
including split screens showing the use of composite mattes and CGI to rebuild
ancient Rome.Gladiator Games: Roman Blood Sport. This is an
original documentary from the Discovery channel that aired some time shortly
before Gladiator appeared in theaters. It is fifty minutes long and gives
a fascinating account of the historical underpinnings of the movie. It also
draws attention to a lot of parallels between the Roman culture and our own,
some of which I found quite unsettling. The documentary incorporates a lot of
footage from Gladiator, as well as what appears to be Discovery channel
footage that was shot using the Gladiator sets. It also takes a look
behind the scenes of the movie, which was interesting although it repeated a lot
of the information from the "making of" featurette.Hans
Zimmer -- Composing Gladiator. This is a fascinating 21-minute look
at an often-overlooked facet of production: creation of the musical score.My Gladiator Journal. Spencer Treat Clark, the young actor who plays
Commodus's nephew Lucius, kept a detailed journal of his experiences in making
the movie, along with a lot of snapshots. This feature is presented as text
screens with still photos. It is an interesting perspective, but it would take a
very long time to read it all.Storyboards. This could have been an
interesting feature, but is poorly presented on the disc. The storyboards
themselves are presented on the screen too small to make out clearly. There is
no sound or explanation to go with them. There is also an extensive collection
of concept art included in this section.Stills Gallery. This is an
extensive collection of production photographs. Again, it will take you a long
time to get through all of these.Trailers and TV Spots. This
includes the teaser trailer (with Conan music!), the full theatrical
trailer, and a series of four TV commercials for the movie. Also on this page is
an Easter egg -- the trailer for Chicken Run that parodied the
Gladiator trailers.Cast and Crew. This is the usual
DreamWorks excellent job, featuring nine actors and twelve behind-the-scenes
contributors, including the producers, director Scott, Hans Zimmer, and several
others. Each person is given good attention, with a picture and a very extensive
bio included.Production Notes. These are fairly long and
informative. Per usual DreamWorks practice, they are the same as the liner notes
inside the DVD case.

With a list of extra content like that, you can see why DreamWorks needed a
second disc to hold it all. All told there is over four hours of extra content,
and most of it is very worthwhile.

The Rebuttal Witnesses

Gladiator emerged as one of the most successful films of 2000, and
also one of the most over-praised. Many have hailed it as a
"masterpiece," or worse yet as an "instant classic,"
whatever that means. While I enjoyed it, there were a number of flaws, mostly in
the storyline. The most grievous of these flaws is in the ultimate resolution of
the movie. I don't want to give too much away, but the climax just didn't ring
true for me. I would have much preferred to see the plan between Maximus and
Lucilla carried out; regardless of the outcome, it would have seemed more
believable. It also would have been truer to the epic scope that Scott shot for
with this movie and would have brought the Maximus character full circle to his
logical conclusion.

I also found the Commodus character to be a bit more off-putting than was
necessary. Scott states in his commentary track that he wanted to make Commodus
evil but at least somewhat sympathetic or understandable. I tend to think that
Scott and Co. blew their chance to accomplish that when they decided that
Commodus should have...ahem, "unnatural desires" for his sister
Lucilla. Frankly, once that sort of thing is established about a character, the
whole "my father neglected me" angle doesn't really provide the
necessary emotional mileage to make Commodus terribly sympathetic.

There are also some technical problems with the movie. Gladiator
makes extensive use of CGI to recreate the city of Rome. Some of this CGI works
very well and is completely convincing, but some of it is very obviously CGI.
City scenes with ancient buildings and statues look very good, but there are a
couple of fly-over shots of the Colosseum that are really bad. Also, many of the
scenes within the Colosseum itself use smoke and dust to hide the fact that the
special effects aren't quite up to par. Still, recreating the Colosseum and
ancient Rome is not a small accomplishment, and these imperfections are the
price we pay for some otherwise outstanding eye candy.

I have very few criticisms of the DVD package. While the piles and piles of
extra goodies impressed me, I did notice that it was all stuff we had seen
before in one form or another. There is nothing here that really uses the DVD
format to its fullest potential. It would have been interesting to see something
new and innovative, perhaps something interactive or something that used the
"angle" function available on most DVD players. I know this is
nitpicking, but if anyone is to take extra content to the next level, DreamWorks
is a prime candidate.

Closing Statement

While perhaps not the milestone film that many have made it out to be,
Gladiator succeeds as entertainment. It has a bit more brains and a lot
more heart than the average summer blockbuster, and is for the most part a
satisfying way to spend a few hours. I enjoyed it but also found it somewhat
disappointing; with a slightly less clichéd storyline it might have been
truly great. Still, it is a good movie, the DVD presentation is very good, and
it comes with a great collection of extra material. I have no problem
recommending this movie for purchase or rental, whatever you prefer.

The Verdict

The movie and all involved are acquitted. DreamWorks once again is to be
commended for an excellent DVD package.