Papayans, 27, also was held on a misdemeanor battery charge. Jail records don't show whether either man has an attorney.

The "Dancing With the Stars" contestant has had previous brushes with the law. He was arrest following an incident at a Florida nightclub in 2002 and in 2005 he was arrested and charged with driving under the influence. After attending mandatory alcohol education classes and Alcoholics Anonymous meetings, at the time, Carter told People magazine that he would never "get behind the wheel and drink again," adding that the classes were "so good for me."

Famous Mug Shots: Judge Reinhold

Previous version of this story said Nick Carter was a former member of Backstreet Boys.