We noticed that you're using an unsupported browser. The TripAdvisor website may not display properly.We support the following browsers:Windows: Internet Explorer, Mozilla Firefox, Google Chrome. Mac: Safari.

My friends and I rented the penthouse on Duval for a Bachelorette party and it was truly amazing! The house was so gorgeous inside that we all felt like we were on an episode of the Real World! We rented both suites which are separated by one dead bolt door in the middle of the units. We had 2 living rooms, 2 kitchens, a back deck, and a balcony overlooking Duval Street, plenty of room for 8 or more.

Only downside was that the place was not easy to find! The parking spot is located down a narrow alley way and the back of the house is a little sketchy to navigate, but once we figured it out we were good to go!

Would definitely recommend and would stay again :)

Travelling group:Friends

Would you recommend this hotel to a friend?
Yes.

Was this review helpful? Yes

This review is the subjective opinion of a TripAdvisor member and not of TripAdvisor LLC

I rented this house located in the PERFECT spot on Duval street for my Bachelorette party. I was plenty of space for all of us and the house was beautiful. Came with everything we would need from a house for 4 days. I rented the entire house so we occupied all 4 bedrooms and surprisingly both kitchens. My friends all loved it and the location couldn't have been better. Short walk to the beach and southern most point, Blue Heaven, Walgreens, liquor store and the bars! I will definitely consider this house (and so will the girls I went with) for our next trip to KW! Pictures on the site are all completely true to how the house looked when we walked in.

How easy was it to book the property?

How helpful were the directions to the property?

How easy was key pickup/access to the property?

Overall condition of the property

Bedding & mattresses

Kitchen & utensils

Bathroom cleanliness

Other facilities & amenities

Service

Liked best:The space!

Liked least:Needs a pool ;)

Travelling group:Friends

Your age range25-34

Would you recommend this hotel to a friend?
Yes.

Recommended for:

Friends getaway

Older travelers

Families with young children

Large groups

People with pets

Was the property as advertised?

Would you recommend the location of this property?

Was it a good value for the price paid?

Did the property offer wi-fi/internet access?

Was your security deposit returned on time?

Was this review helpful? Yes

This review is the subjective opinion of a TripAdvisor member and not of TripAdvisor LLC

We stayed in the rear portion of the rental, called Starlight Seista. It is hard to find reviews of the property. It is very nice. The bad deck is nice to have coffee on in the morning or hang out after a long night downtown. We found the wifi did not work in the home, the ice maker made plenty of ice but would not distribute it, and the biggest problem was in the shower of the second bathroom. There was no hot water. We called the maintenance office, but was given the run around. We made it work for the few days we were here, but any longer would been a problem.

Value

Rooms

Location

Cleanliness

Check-in / front desk

Service

Would I recommend this holiday rental to my best friend?

Was this review helpful? Yes

This review is the subjective opinion of a TripAdvisor member and not of TripAdvisor LLC

Not sure what the other person on here was complaining about... This place was awesome!! It's really an optical illusion because when you first pull up and see the outside your like.. "uh oh". then you open the door and say wow!! The really only complaint i had about the place is parking is VERY limited. I'd high suggest renting some scooter as there is really only room for like one small compact car and that's it. Also the A/C had a hard time keeping up during the day but at night time it would cool this HUGE rental down no problem. We had a great time sitting on the porch that overlooks duval street. especially at night time since it was close to the drag show and we got to see some funny people come and go. We loved this place and would not hesitate to return. If your really picky about some drywall tape or a base board that wasn't painted properly, then I don't think any establishment would make you happy. lol.

How easy was it to book the property?

How helpful were the directions to the property?

How easy was key pickup/access to the property?

Overall condition of the property

Bedding & mattresses

Kitchen & utensils

Bathroom cleanliness

Other facilities & amenities

Service

Liked best:The porch overlooking duval

Liked least:parking SUCKS!!! very narrow alley and no way anything but a compact is parking back there.

Travelling group:Large Group

Your age range35-49

Would you recommend this hotel to a friend?
Yes.

Recommended for:

Friends getaway

Large groups

Was the property as advertised?

Would you recommend the location of this property?

Was it a good value for the price paid?

Was your security deposit returned on time?

Was this review helpful? Yes

This review is the subjective opinion of a TripAdvisor member and not of TripAdvisor LLC

We were in Key West for the first time celebrating my husband’s birthday. I had asked the rental agent for advice, as we had never visited the area; I specifically explained that I was searching for a quality rental and I was assured the penthouse on Duval would fit our needs. The website pictures looked fine, but they did not truly represent the current run down condition of the home. The list of issues is long including dry wall tape coming of under the paint in several areas of the living area wall, stained or torn carpets, stained/dirty living room sofa, broken bathroom mirror, one bedroom’s furniture was badly stained and missing paint (I was embarrassed to have one guest use the room), badly worn painted plywood stairs leading to both upstairs bedrooms, missing door pulls, the dining room table was so wobbly we were afraid to use it, most of the doors to the bedrooms and bathrooms were unpainted folding doors and one of the toilet seats was much small than the toilet, so it was difficult to use. We never used the back porch because the view and smell was of the building next store that had been destroyed by fire back in October; the rental agent failed to mention this and when I asked about it, I was told it had happened recently, which was not true. I did call the rental agent immediately on arrival to express our dismayed with the condition of the home and received a call back the afternoon of the following day from a repairman saying he understood we wanted a mirror replaced! I told him the mirror was the least of the problems, explained our many concerns and asked to speak to someone in charge. I received a call a couple of hours later from someone who identified herself as a manager, she offered to send someone to clean the house, but that was not going to help the overall condition of the rental. We did take pictures if the owner would like to see our concerns. So disappointed in our first and perhaps last trip to Key West!!

How easy was it to book the property?

How helpful were the directions to the property?

How easy was key pickup/access to the property?

Overall condition of the property

Bedding & mattresses

Kitchen & utensils

Bathroom cleanliness

Other facilities & amenities

Service

Liked best:Kitchen

Liked least:Overall run down condition of many areas of the home.

Travelling group:Extended Family

Would you recommend this hotel to a friend?
No.

Did the property offer wi-fi/internet access?

Was this review helpful? Yes

This review is the subjective opinion of a TripAdvisor member and not of TripAdvisor LLC