Schubert composed two movements for the Symphony in B minor (now known as the Unfinished Symphony) in October 1822. It seems that he did not intend for these movements to stand on their own, as he made sketches and scored several measures of a scherzo apparently to continue the work. Unfortunately, no sketches for a finale have ever been found, though there has been some speculation that the Entr’acte in B Minor for Rosamunde composed in the following year was originally intended to be this symphony’s finale. As one might expect, there have also been several misguided attempts to compose a “completion” to this symphony, (not to mention PDQ Bach’s Unbegun Symphony) but nothing could ever be added by another composer that would match the perfection of these two movements that stand well on their own.

Schubert was elected an honorary member of the Styrian Music Society in Graz, and in 1823 he sent these movements to his friend Anselm Hüttenbrunner to give to the Society. Somehow Hüttenbrunner failed to deliver them, and the manuscript remained unknown until it resurfaced in 1865. The work was premiered in Vienna that year and has not left the repertory since.

The Allegro moderato first movement begins with a short brooding theme played by the cellos and basses.

(In my younger days I remembered this theme sung with the words “This is the symphony that Schubert wrote and never finished.”)

This beautiful lyrical melody is abruptly interrupted by forceful tremolos played by the full orchestra, which are followed by fragments of the three themes. This suggests that the development has begun, but then the entire first section is repeated. The development takes the themes apart and introduces interesting harmonic progressions that half a century later could well have come from Wagner. The recapitulation repeats the famous theme and is then followed by the coda, which repeats ideas from the development.

The Andante con moto slow movement begins in E major with the first theme stated by the violins.

The movement ends with a coda that returns softly to the initial violin theme as the movement dies away. We are therefore left with a work that is unfinished but no less a complete masterpiece, leaving the listener with a melancholic wondering of what could possibly have come next had Schubert’s life been extended beyond his early demise. The powerful contrast of Schubert’s towering Ninth Symphony “The Great” seems to leave little doubt that as his own life continued it took him beyond the thoughts of the Eighth Symphony, never to return.

* In 1978 the numbering of Schubert’s symphonies was revised to reflect the chronological order of their composition. The Unfinished Symphony was known before then as No. 8; now it is No. 7. The Great C Major Symphony can be found referred to as No. 7, 8 or 9! It is perhaps better to refer to his symphonies by their nicknames or their Deutsch Catalog number to avoid confusion.

Nice article, brief and comprehensive. But please note that the melody pitch _and_ the key signature in example n. 6 are both wrong. The melody should begin with an E, as originally written for the Clarinet in A, and also the key signature should be just one sharp (so the melody is written in E minor for the Clarinet in A, and sounds in C sharp minor).

Mahler’s Symphony No. 6 is tied with No. 5 for being my favorite Mahler work. So naturally when a friend told me he was going to conduct it I was excited. No. 6 presents two problems that the conductor needs to resolve. One is the ordering of the middle movements. (Andante then Scherzo. End of…

Here are videos of Mark Laycock conducting the Wiener KammerOrchester at the Richardson Auditorium in Alexander Hall which is on the Princeton University campus. This was the Wintermezzo concert in honor of WIlliam Scheide. Schubert Symphony. No. 9 “The Great” in C Major I Movement part 1. (YouTube has a time limit on videos so…

Peter Ilich Tchaikovsky (1840-1893) Born May 7, 1840 in Kamsko-Votkinsk, Russia. Died November 6, 1893 in St. Petersburg, Russia. Symphony No. 6 in B Minor, Op. 74 Pathétique Composed February 16 to August 31, 1893. First Performance: October 28, 1893 in the Hall of Nobles, St. Petersburg with the composer conducting the Russian Musical Society Orchestra.…