The Software Patent debate goes on

It has been more than a week since the Commission text of the Directive on Computer Implemented Inventions was defeated 648 to 14 votes, proving that the Commission’s dodgy strategies have failed. This is already old news in the Blogoshpere, but as I missed the entire round of posts the first time around, but I thought that I would have a second look at what has happened now that the dust is settling and as there has been some time to reflect on what is taking place.

The scrapping of the Commission text is good news, as it was the closest proposal to the American system that we have had so far. It also proves that their tactics to try to circumvent the democratic institutions of the European Union by passing an unpopular directive by stealth have seriously backfired on them. What is bad news is that we now find that the patenting system in Europe is going to have to follow the flawed and often contradictory practices of the last few years. We will have to live with the many broad and obvious patents being awarded in Europe, and this is not a good thing. We do need a directive, but we will not get one in the near future.

I have spoken with a couple of people who are in favour of software patents, and they seem to be happy with the result. This bothers me.

Like this:

4 Comments

David BB
· July 18, 2005 at 6:12 am

You shoudln't be too bothered. Companies like stability and no change means they stick to what they know. They will only vote for change if they think they will benefit from it. Btw, have you seen the film, The Corporation ( http://www.thecorporation.com ) as it is a good overview of the pathology of corporations. We should now be trying to get the requisite directive to support free culture and avoid lock down – but I fear that the companies are lobbying harder now – and not so publicly….

Twitter

Top Posts

RSS

Related Posts

Patent trolls are a blight on the tech industry, extolling licence fees for “inventions” that they never implemented, sitting on broad claims waiting until enough people are deemed to be using the technology and then Read more…

The continuing existence of patent troll is a baffling failure of modern regulation. For those not familiar with this mythical figure, it is the bane of the software industry in the United States. If you Read more…

I finally managed to read the latest (and hopefully last) instalment of the long legal saga that is SAS Institute v World Programming Ltd. This has been an interesting yet long case that made it Read more…