This might be my first vinyl purchase (everglow would be second) because whenever I get around to purchasing a nice sound system and a record player, these would be the first 2 albums I would want to listen to.

Dude, that's a pretty average going price for new vinyl. And when the album is this quality, you really want to miss out because you weren't willing to shell out another five or ten stupid bucks? Years from now, I'll still be spinning this record. Are you going to look back fondly on those few dollars you saved?