Related Products

More people have jobs and yet the use of health care remains stagnant—which should drive nice profits when WellPoint Inc. reports first-quarter earnings on Wednesday. The trends even have some wondering if consumer-driven health plans are finally starting to make a real difference in Americans’ health care spending habits.

The U.S. economy added nearly 2 million jobs over the past 12 months, according to the Bureau of Labor Statistics. That growth in employment helped drive 1.6 million new members into the health plans operated by Minnesota-based UnitedHealth Group over the past year, the industry bellwether reported on Thursday.

Yet levels of spending by its health plan members “remain moderate,” reported UnitedHealth CEO Stephen Helmsley. The percentage of health insurance premiums spent on medical bills ticked down to just 81 percent in the first quarter, the company reported. That helped boost UnitedHealth's profits by 3.1 percent, exceeding analysts' estimates.

Analysts expect WellPoint's profits to dip 3 percent in its first-quarter report, to $2.27 per share, according to a survey by Thomson Reuters. But the UnitedHealth report suggests the expected return of health care consumption is not happening—at least not yet.

"There has been some noise around volume returning, but this report does not point toward a return of utilization," BMO Capital Markets analyst Dave Shove wrote in a note to investors.

Instead, UnitedHealth’s results reinforce the trends seen in 2011. According to market research firm IMS Health, Americans reduced their visits to physicians by nearly 5 percent in 2011 and spent 1 percent less on prescription drugs. Adjusting for inflation, per-capita spending on health care grew just 0.5 percent last year—a far cry from the galloping pace of health care spending over the past 40 years.

That data prompted Drew Altman, CEO of the Kaiser Family Foundation, to speculate that we may be witnessing a new normal in U.S. health care spending.

“We have a new phenomenon to watch with important implications for people and costs,” Altman wrote in an April 16 blog post. He added, “It will take a few more years of monitoring utilization patterns to know if we are seeing a recession-effect or a real change in patterns of use, what may be driving them, and how deep this one-time adjustment in patterns of use may go.”

If the lowered health care spending is more than an after-effect of the recession, Altman thinks the main reason is the increase in high-deductible health plans. He cites Kaiser’s data showing that the share of workers in a plan with a deductible of $1,000 or more grew from 18 percent in 2008 to 31 percent in 2011.

In Indiana, high-deductible and consumer-directed health plans have been embraced even more aggressively than across the country.

Altman notes that the Patient Protection and Affordable Care Act actually will accelerate this growth. The law will pay subsidies to help individuals and small businesses to buy health insurance in exchanges where coverage will be standardized into four categories. But the cheapest of those plans will have family deductibles approaching $8,000, according to Kaiser’s estimates.

Wall's career as a journalist was set in fifth grade, when he took on an afternoon paper route for The Indianapolis News. He admits to being a terrible paperboy because instead of delivering the newspaper right away, he would sit and read it for hours. He may have lost some customers, but he never lost the bug for news. A lifelong resident of central Indiana, Wall grew up in Sheridan—the one spot in Hamilton County untouched by suburbia. After graduating from DePauw University in Greencastle, he joined The Indianapolis Star as a business reporting intern and refused to leave until he had a full-time job. Wall stayed there five years before joining IBJ in February 2007. Wall and his wife now live in Indianapolis with their two sons. When not at the office, the Walls spend time with their extended family and worship at Christ Church Reformed Presbyterian in Brownsburg.

all’s career as a journalist was set in fifth grade, when he took on an afternoon paper route for The Indianapolis News. He admits to being a terrible paperboy because instead of delivering the newspaper right away, he would sit and read it for hours. He may have lost some customers, but he never lost the bug for news. A lifelong resident of central Indiana, Wall grew up in Sheridan—the one spot in Hamilton County untouched by suburbia. After graduating from DePauw University in Greencastle, he joined The Indianapolis Star as a business reporting intern and refused to leave until he had a full-time job. Wall stayed there five years before joining IBJ in February 2007. Wall and his wife now live in Indianapolis with their two sons. When not at the office, the Walls spend time with their extended family and worship at Christ Church Reformed Presbyterian in Brownsburg

Multimedia

Videos

Events

IBJ’s CFO of the Year honorees are impressive financial professionals who steer the fortunes of their companies and organizations. Join IBJ to celebrate them on Dec. 1.

Nominations

Do you know an individual or organization that goes above and beyond to improve health care in the Indianapolis area? Let them know their contributions matter. Nominate them for IBJ’s 2017 Health Care Heroes Awards program. For more information or to submit a nomination, visit www.ibj.com/nominations