Eli is right outside the top 5 to me. The best QB is between Rodgers and Brady. I think so far this season Brady has been better but Rodgers was easily better last season. Rodgers has cooled off in the last 5-6 NFL games he has played in.

No he's not. You emphasized right now, in which case Matt Ryan is the best quarterback right now.

I think Eli has like 200 more passing yards 2 or 3 less passing TDs and 2 more intos than Matt Ryan at this point with banged up weapons. Make of that what you will. Both are off to great starts. Hopefully they both keep it going.

I think Eli would put up Brees Rodgers Brady if he was in those insane offenses also.

Say what you want about stats, consistency, etc. whatever. Even though those haven't been problems for eli for a while now. Hands down there is no other QB I would want in a big moment or game. To me that means your the best QB.

Eli Manning has LED the NFL in interceptions twice, thrown away more games than any QB in the league...yet the ring has the fans thinking he is the most clutch QB in the league...smh

THE GIANTS WON A SB...not Eli

Lmao Eli carried the giants last year. We couldn't run, defend the pass or stop the run. Even the special teams was a problems. Those parts of the team didn't step up till the last 6 games.. That's when the team cam full circle and embarrassed the NFC and whooped NE again. CHAMPS.. 2 Super Bowl Mvps...

I think Eli has like 200 more passing yards 2 or 3 less passing TDs and 2 more intos than Matt Ryan at this point with banged up weapons. Make of that what you will. Both are off to great starts. Hopefully they both keep it going.

That's because he threw for 500 yards against the Bucs while throwing 3 picks in the 2nd quarter which got them into a hole.

And 2010, 11 and 12. He led the league in interceptions in 2010 with about a 100, but you think he was awesome and consistent? Last year, he got bailed out by his receivers on a number of plays, but we're not allowed to give credit to anyone but the QB, right? I know the Redskins didn't have trouble beating them last year while Eli was craptacular in those games.

Quote:

Lmao Eli carried the giants last year.

He had 2 pro bowl caliber WRs, a nice #3 WR, 2 DEs that combined for about 25 sacks, and your defense was near the top in getting turnovers. Nobody will doubt that he's really good, but he's just not at the top. It's not like it's a slight on him. I have to agree with pt, he's becoming overrated.