The Land Bill Row- Both BJP and Farmers to Re-think

The long-standing and tested saying goes as ‘A bend in the storm can help, standing rigid can make the tree collapse’. Devising policies is not an easy task, many a time, in the wake of unforeseen changes in prevailing circumstances, managements do re-think their policies; also make amendments so as not to fall prey to unfavorable conditions. It becomes far more crucial to bend than to fail when your policy is to have a bearing on a vast section of the community, socially as well as economically. The BJP, ruling party in the Lok Sabha, may be heading in the most productive direction that is sure to fetch viable outcomes in terms of foreign investment, employment prospects for Indians and the restoration of Indian manufacturing sector, but if it is clearly visible that one of your endeavors is not able to gather the requisite backing of Indian peasants, shouldn’t the scheme be re-considered; a judicious option is to either get the sanctioning of hostile cluster by infusing confidence in them or to drop the policy for the time-being.

Indian farmers have always remained dejected, overlooked, vulnerable and untouchable for most of the past governments. Private moneylenders, banks, government strategies and the discourteous weather conditions collectively have hit the peasants from every possible corner, and the group, which plays the most key role in our social and financial growth, is left with just diverse options to end life voluntarily. More than 16,000 farmers opt for suicide every year; the figure was 18,241 in 2004 and between 1995 and 2013, almost 3 lakh farmer suicides have been reported. These figures are mentioned in many reports and writings, mutilation of crops due to recent unseasonal rain and hailstorms is also a known fact and the forecast of a bad monsoon in the upcoming days isn’t hidden. The bottom line is that our peasants are in the grip of unendurable conditions, and this may not be the most appropriate time for the BJP to come up with variations that could deprive farmers of their exclusive right to approve/ reject any proposed acquisition bids.

Dear PM, the suggested amendments to the UPA’s The Right to Fair Compensation and Transparency in Land Acquisition, Rehabilitation and Resettlement Act, 2013, which say that the consent of 70 per cent farmers in case of five categories shall be taken off, are in true terms a well-planned measure to kick-start essential reforms in the country and may be termed a long-term win-win situation for the Indian society as whole, but what happened to the CPM led government in the West Bengal post the offense of farmers in Singur and Nandigram are the incidents that cannot be under-valued. While traditional vote-bank of the BJP embraces the middle class and industrialists, in the 2014 polls, the wave of Narendra Modi was equally buoyed by small and marginal peasants, along with the sharecroppers. The lower class, especially from the rural parts, is yet to overcome the episodes of cheap acquisition of farmland backed by political corruption and selling of the same to industries at sky-high rates; they are also yet to overcome the fear of development-induced dislodgment of the impoverished and subsequent injuries.

Politics in India is not the numbers that you present, i.e. the GDP growth rate, interest rates or the fiscal deficit; it is how you are interpreted by the stakeholders, and this is where Indira Gandhi failed owing to the forced mass-sterilization led by her son, Sanjay Gandhi during the emergency, and also the Rajiv Gandhi-led government collapsed on the allegations of Bofors scandal. And the same sentimental up and downs of the voters pave the way for smaller political groups that comprehend the pulse of the public, and the same in turn disturbs the efficiency and effectiveness of the political party ruling at the center. BJP may send party-workers and even its legislators to exchange thoughts directly with the likely-to-be-affected farmers; however, damage to the image of the PM as well the party is underway. The most apt code of conduct for the BJP is to diagnose and have compassion with the pain of farmers, and the same asks for identifying with basic concerns like lack of irrigation facilities and sheer dependence on borrowing from private lenders. Acquisition of land and resulting evolution of rural India can, indeed, follow the corrections to fundamental flaws, but cannot supersede them.

Pro-rich, Pro-industries, Pro-urban and such other tags, accorded to the Modi-led union government by the opposition and even many of the farmers’ associations, are though not be eliminated, but are to be complemented with labels, Pro-poor, Pro-rural and Pro-agriculture. If the administrators are looking for a country with smart cities, digitalized services, smart phone-equipped citizens and a flourishing industrial sector, alike perusal of the concerns of the rural India, home to farmers and employer to more than half of our workforce, is also obligatory. Acquiring land of peasants is more than a transaction and underlying is the uprooting of dwellers from their social tie-ups, controversies in the title of the land, discretion of government officials in determining market rates and most rough, the loss of livelihood. On the contrary are the projects that are awaiting land for their commencement and PM’s dreams for a developed nation, just for all; however the opposition would never consider these while defaming your authentic endeavors.

Elections in key states of Bihar, WB and Tamil Nadu are anytime to ring the bells, which mean that the BJP cannot afford anything like its present portrayal as anti-farmer and anti-poor. Modinomics, the buzz created by economic gurus and even by foreign media, calls for systematic and in-depth analysis of the issues related to Indian agriculture and acquisition of land. It is quite very obvious that lakhs of crores of subsidy flowing to the rural India in the name of fertilizers, food security, and also as compensation for loss of produce and the minimum support price haven’t resulted in any betterment of farmers. The past governments were severely weak in terms of analyzing the rural economy and improving the share of agriculture in GDP. While average holding of farmers has dipped consistently and plentiful land has been acquired in the past at exorbitant rates, neither rural nor the industrial sector has delivered optimistic outcomes.

And for the corporates and governments, the alarm wasn’t felt the way it actually upset the lives of rural inhabitants. The present government is expected to pay heed to the problems of farmers; the way things are turning out with respect to the land acquisition law, I fear that the prediction of above-7 per cent GDP growth or the positive revision in India’s outlook by Moody’s may not be able to add to the number of BJP MPs in the Rajya Sabha, a requisite for the Modi-government to revive Indian economy by way of passing key legislations well within time. UP, Bihar, Rajasthan, Punjab, Maharashtra and Madhya Pradesh, states that backed the NDA colossally in the 2014 general elections, are the ones with substantial farmer population; any mutilation to the coalition’s image in this regard would let opposition parties revive themselves. PM Modi and his astute ministers are to re-assess their stand in light of latest advancements, and if this asks for holding the planned changes to the land bill for the time-being, the party must bend itself, rather than be uprooted.

I cannot conclude without analyzing the impact, actual and not alleged impact, of the land bill proposed by the government on the lives of rural inhabitants. Believe me, the entire opposition is adamant not to let the bill get the nod of the RS only and only for a simple reason that this is their golden moment to provide some oxygen to their fading parties. Buzz is being created that land owners would lose the opportunity to move the court and no complaint could be registered against the official, which are a fabrication of real intentions of the bill. Also, rural inhabitants are to realize that with more than 65 per cent Indians dependent on farming, agriculture is still a liability on Indian economy and it’s high time that alternative livelihood for rural residents is brought to reality, and this isn’t conceivable without electrification, industrial corridors and affordable housing. For the same, the government needs land, and justifiable compensation in return is a win-win condition for land owners. Making farming sustainable and providing alternative occupation to farmers will go hand in hand; hence farmers are to re-think their stand.

The government seeks farmers’ share in upright and effective governance and in revival of the Indian economy that is to benefit all Indians, farmers and opposition are to know their sense of duty, sooner than later.

Post navigation

106 thoughts on “The Land Bill Row- Both BJP and Farmers to Re-think”

Thought provoking article.Why I’ve government opt choosing fertile land for industrialization.How in future growing population will b fed? It’s high time countries of the world should sit and think how to stop further urbanization .

I don’t feel that BJP should change its stand on this issue.
If they will do this, they will be looked upon as non-adamant towards altering the current situation of Indian economy.
They should communicate with farmers broadly.

I have been a close observer of peasants issues and know that farming in India is like doing some work for which you will not get profit but only be burdened with loss and borrowing. MPs and MLAs should concentrate on this.

In the wake of recent turnovers, loss of farmers due to unseasonal rain, it is advisable that PM should stop visiting foreign nations and concentrate on Indian rural society. PM’s first liability is towards India.

Who was governing the country in most of the last 65 years?
Who enacted most of the laws?
Who let farmers suicide a never thought of topic?
Its clear sir, Congress is all responsible for this misery of farmers.

In all this game of politics, the always suppressed farmer community is losing. No government, be it the UPA or NDA or any other party, is co-operative towards farmers because they do not have money to donate to these parties.

I like the valuable information you provide in your articles. I will bookmark your blog and check again here frequently. I am quite certain I will learn lots of new stuff right here! Best of luck for the next!

People in power post independence representing forces led by Congress party were corrupt,divisive and playing vote bank politics.That is what they are again doing.But where are the people with facts and figures to remove the fake smoke created in media world.Government knows its business well.Why not BJP offensive, they all are peacefully listening to the un-parliamentary utterances of Congress,TMC,Lalu,Nitish,Ramgopal,Tyagi etc.Mainly media spreading fake news, why BJP Govt.is unable to book these media people,spreading paid news etc.?Land Bill should be sent to parliamentary select committee for the time being for their suggestions.

Can you send an analysis to the government regarding how farmers are prone to serious misconduct by private lenders who give money at very high interest rates. This is one of the main reasons why our farmers go for suicide. Private money lending should be stopped with immediate effect.

I am very happy to find this web site. I wanted to thank you for your time due to this fantastic read!! I definitely liked every little bit of it and i also have you saved to fav to see new information in your site.

Hello very cool website!! Man .. Excellent .. Amazing .. I will bookmark your website and take the feeds additionally.I am glad to search out numerous useful information here within the publish, we need work out extra techniques in this regard, thank you for sharing. . . . . .

See what you are saying may be right as people in India look at simple things like commodity prices and convenience while judging governments, but think where will land come from if government does not roll out an effective land acquisition law.

A fascinating discussion is worth comment. I do believe that you need to publish more about this subject, it may not be a taboo subject but typically folks don’t discuss these subjects. To the next! Many thanks!!

Just wanted to say how much we appreciate the tremendous amount of hard work and effort you all put in to producing this website. It is a great credit to everyone and I am sure will be a great success.

Hello there! This blog post could not be written much better! Going through this article reminds me of my previous roommate! He constantly kept talking about this. I will send this information to him. Fairly certain he will have a very good read. I appreciate you for sharing!

Thank you for some other magnificent post. Where else could anybody get that kind of information in such a perfect manner of writing? I have a presentation subsequent week, and I am on the look for such information.