Soldier in Iraq gets "hate" mail from US school Kids

FACT : Innocent civilians have died at the hands of the US military
FACT : Mosque's have been destroyed by the US military

thanks,
drfunk

Fact, we do not know if the people in civilian clothes were "innocent".
Fact, terrorist were shooting at the troops from within the "holy shrines" so they shot back. BFD, its a pagan religion anyway............

[edit on 22-2-2005 by DrHoracid]

we have killed children, although it was not intentional, how can you possibly say they are not innocent?

It is so nice to see how people with no morals are so eager to use our troops as pawns in a political battle. Both sides should hang their heads in
shame.

Question 1: Do you think it's easy being stationed overseas in a dangerous area watching friends die?

I don't think so.

Question 2: Do soldiers, like this Private, decide foreign policy matters, like where to deploy troops and who to attack?

I don't think so.

Question 3: Is a political message any less of a political message because it has a child's signature on it?

I don't think so.

Here is the issue. No letters of a political sort should be sent to soldiers. This is an outright waste of time, and does nothing but cause strife.
If you don't like this war, voice your opinion to your President and your Legislators. They are the ones who make decisions on where to take
military action, not a PFC in the army. This is misguided poltical action. Except in this case it causes needless hurt.

Troops overseas, be it Afghanistan, Iraq, or whatever, could use a word of support. They could use a "Thanks, get home safe" from people back home.
It's a nice thing to do.

I fail to see why any letter stating someone's views and opinions on the war should be making its way to a soldier. Like they can do anything about
it?

Voice your ire at the people making the decisions.

Send candy and smiles to the troops, they sure as hell need them. "Please stop blowing up mosques" ain't putting anyone in a better mood.

I'm not saying you don't have the right to say "Stop blowing up mosques" if that is what you feel, but why to them? Haven't they got it hard
enough there?

Then again from a nation that took a crap on its soldiers when they came back from Vietnam and threw things at them like it was their fault
personally, am I surprised?

FACT : Innocent civilians have died at the hands of the US military
FACT : Mosque's have been destroyed by the US military

thanks,
drfunk

Fact, we do not know if the people in civilian clothes were "innocent".
Fact, terrorist were shooting at the troops from within the "holy shrines" so they shot back. BFD, its a pagan religion anyway............

[edit on 22-2-2005 by DrHoracid]

we have killed children, although it was not intentional, how can you possibly say they are not innocent?

The children were innocent , yes. The reasons they were in the line of fire is the question. Some "parents" were there against their will some
weren't.

No one is saying the troops dont have it bad over there. I think this is something we can all agree on. Its #ty to be stationed in a strange land
fighting a strange war. Unless you have been there, you have no idea.

You are also correct that when soldiers get mail, it helps if it is uplifiting. However, the whole point of this was not the fact that the soldier is
incapable of changing things. But rather that these 9 kids would like our soldiers to be more careful if possible. We are supposed to be the good
guys. What kind of message are our soldiers sending home when innocent lives are lost? I dont think it is a message of heorism. I am not saying that
these innocent lives are intentionally targeted, but they are still being killed. It is usually an accident or a misidentification, but that still is
no excuse.

These kids are who is going to determine our retirement. I would suggest we pay closer attention to how they feel and what they see, rather than
bashing them for writing what they believe.

Originally posted by DrHoracid
Because of the LIBERAL agenda in the classrooms. Maybe the Viet cong had the right idea about teachers................

What exsactly is "liberal" about it?
Because they dont encourage military service?
They tend to care more about E-D-U-C-A-T-I-O-N! You know the thing that gets you a job outside of the military?

E-D-U-C-A-T-I-O-N is the issue, not "social engineering". Teach the basics not "how" to think and FEEL! Stop this "mother earth" BS. Teach
real history. 2+2 does = 4 not 'whatever". Start giving real grades not "nice try there johnny". Mark up papers with RED ink even.

Doc, I completly agree that there are troubles with the education system. That is why my daughter is home schooled. She doesnt move forward in a
subject untill she has 100% profenciency in the section we are studying.

However, I dont think an agenda is being pushed on our youth in the public school system. It happens in private catholic schools, but the parents pay
to have thier kids brainwashed there.

The very first thing the Viet cong did when they moved into an area is kill all the teachers and replace them with communist indoctrination classes.

Thanks the Kid, forgot.

In my view the liberal in the education system have done the same thing, replaced all the real teachers with "political"
hacks..............."outcome" based education to control the masses. That is why the Libs are fighting home school, and vouchers. They don't want
to lose control of the indoctronation.

In my view the liberal in the education system have done the same thing, replaced all the real teachers with "political"
hacks..............."outcome" based education to control the masses. That is why the Libs are fighting home school, and vouchers. They don't want
to lose control of the indoctronation.

In my view the liberal in the education system have done the same thing, replaced all the real teachers with "political"
hacks..............."outcome" based education to control the masses. That is why the Libs are fighting home school, and vouchers. They don't want
to lose control of the indoctronation.

How do you account for the fact that I home school then

I know its off topic, but I had to ask.

Libertarian...................smart...libertarian in denial.............

Originally posted by DrHoracid
In my view the liberal in the education system have done the same thing, replaced all the real teachers with "political"
hacks..............."outcome" based education to control the masses. That is why the Libs are fighting home school, and vouchers. They don't want
to lose control of the indoctronation.

Fine thats your view and thats what your opinion is, i dont believe it and personally believe its tripe but I respect it.
I think teaching kids to NOT fight and be peaceful is better than teaching them HOW to fight.

It seems pretty clear that the teacher was for the troops here! If the majority was against the troops there may be some basis for the teacher being a
"liberal" but since it's the opposite, obviously the teacher was either as keen to kill Iraqis as Bush or not giving her view at all.

Dr Horacid, so know we've established the Teacher isn't at fault we should be finding out who these kids are and executing them on national TV.

Fact, terrorist were shooting at the troops from within the "holy shrines" so they shot back. BFD, its a pagan religion anyway............

Ignoring the religious rhetoric, why call them terrorists? Both sides are using violence for political gain but one is an occupying force. Osama is a
terrorist, Saddam is a dictator and the Iraqi people fighting the troops are simply trying to protect their way of life.

DrHoracid, are you just confused? Still think that Osama and Saddam are buddies?

Originally posted by DrHoracid
Because of the LIBERAL agenda in the classrooms. Maybe the Viet cong had the right idea about teachers................

What exsactly is "liberal" about it?
Because they dont encourage military service?
They tend to care more about E-D-U-C-A-T-I-O-N! You know the thing that gets you a job outside of the military?

E-D-U-C-A-T-I-O-N is the issue, not "social engineering". Teach the basics not "how" to think and FEEL! Stop this "mother earth" BS. Teach
real history. 2+2 does = 4 not 'whatever". Start giving real grades not "nice try there johnny". Mark up papers with RED ink even.

If every teacher just taught about the box and not how to think outside of it, places like ATS would not exist. This would be just another news
message board where everyone agreed with each other.

Sure, this teacher had an agenda, but I'm sure it wasn't to bash the troops. Like someone stated before, the teacher probably didn't even read the
letters before they were sent out. Could you imagine people's reactions if the teacher had read and screened the letters? People would be screaming
about censorship and stuff like that.

Oh, and last I checked, they still teach 2+2=4, not "whatever". If you truly believe that, maybe you should go back to 6th grade. (I know you were
trying to make a point, but that example was a REALLY idiotic one. Think about it.)

Originally posted by DrHoracid
The very first thing the Viet cong did when they moved into an area is kill all the teachers and replace them with communist indoctrination classes.

Thanks the Kid, forgot.

In my view the liberal in the education system have done the same thing, replaced all the real teachers with "political"
hacks..............."outcome" based education to control the masses. That is why the Libs are fighting home school, and vouchers. They don't want
to lose control of the indoctronation.

Also, I understand it is your opinion, but how exactly did you come to this conclusion? Are you a teacher? Do you know any teachers? Are you
familiar with the public school system's hiring process?

The application does not have any boxes that ask if you are liberal or conservative. This country is in need of teachers so badly, they are willing
to hire just about anybody who fills the educational requirements. They could care less what your political views are (unless you're a nazi or
something to that extreme).

In my opinion, teachers should teach how and what to think and parents should monitor what their children are learning.

The Above Top Secret Web site is a wholly owned social content community of The Above Network, LLC.

This content community relies on user-generated content from our member contributors. The opinions of our members are not those of site ownership who maintains strict editorial agnosticism and simply provides a collaborative venue for free expression.