I've been pretty happy with Lily's Sugar & Cream, though I haven't tried making a washcloth for my face or anything, just dishcloths. But I'm making a hooded baby towel from CottenTots and it is -very- soft.

IMO Sugar and Cream is too harsh for the face. I made myself a face cloth, but can't use it.

I agree with Jan... I made a dishcloth/washcloth with Lily Sugar and Cream that my dog fell in love with and since it was so harsh I gave it to him. He loves to try and shred it and it's held up REMARKABLY well. LOL

Also, GGH's Bali or Goa are cotton blends...mostly cotton, though, and are nice and soft.

I wonder how a mercerized cotton would work with a face cloth? :thinking: Its always SO soft, but I dont know if the "Mercer" rubs off on your face or if there are weird chemicals involved or anything....