So Andy, who thrives on awkward moments, wanted to reenact the more awkward moments of the interview, although this time Matt got to play the role of Tom. Before they started, Matt wanted everyone to know that things between him and Tom are all cool now. He said, “Can I say before we do this, I like Tom Cruise. We have a good relationship; we have a good friendship. That was just one little moment.”

The guys went back and forth reading lines from the interview, but Matt strayed from the script a bit. At one point, he said, “You are extraordinarily handsome,” which got a laugh out of Andy. And while the days of Tom Cruise jumping on couches and criticizing Brooke Shields are long gone, we can thank Andy’s Clubhouse Playhouse for this trip down memory lane.