Is this a joke? Roethlisberger at 4? Michael Vick is not top 10, let alone top 5, and neither is Leftwich. Are you serious?

TOM BRADY, Philip Rivers, and Matt Hasselbeck are all superior to Vick and Leftwich. JP Losman and Pennington are also making a case to that claim as well. Carson Palmer is also way too low on your list, he may have had a disappointing season but he is top 5.