the logic is irrefutable new species have new genes/traits if NS does not generate new genes then NS cant generate new species as colin leslie dean says Not irrefutable. Let me see if I can articulate my thinking. The straight beaked booby has an offspring. This offspring has a mutation that causes...

MichaelXY I do not agree with Gamila we see you are now gone quite who do you agree with now-waiting to see where the consensus is first i bet I have gone quiet as I find your assertions to be unfounded and without any data to back them. In fact you have no real argument other than saying Darwin is...

If you and I are the progenitors of two future species a million years from now, my descendants would be the ones to replace the homo sapien species we belong to and your descendants would be the servants to mines provided my descendants didn't exterminate yours on a whim. Well that is just not nic...

gamila, since I'm not familiar with colin dean, may I ask where you think new species come/came from if not by way of NS? I'm not asking to try and start an argument. Just curious. idex i dont know Like me colin leslie dean is not a creationist and does not believes in ID So in essence, you mock al...

Again I fail to see your point. An example: Polydactyly or the six finger person, this is an obvious sign of a mutation, yet the mutated indivdual can still inter-breed with its original species. Mutation does not imply a speciation , only an alteration in the same species. Only after much time and ...

Who ever said the parent had the mutant gene? The offspring could have created the mutant gene which then gets passed on to it's offspring, several generations later the mutation may become dominant, thus altering the phylogeny of the species, but since the species can still mate, they are considere...

I really need to take my own advice. We're done here. it is logically impossible for natural selection to generate new species ie with new traits never seen before in your language if a population has new traits never seen before these traits could not have come from a parent population-as the pare...