Founded in 1993 by brothers Tom and David Gardner, The Motley Fool helps millions of people attain financial freedom through our website, podcasts, books, newspaper column, radio show, and premium investing services.

Time to Drop Devon

There's no getting past this E&P's blunders.

I don't know what to say. Leading independent Devon Energy's (NYSE:DVN) $7.1 billion writedown of oil and gas properties has simply floored me.

I know that number may not sound like a lot, compared to the $24.2 billion charge at Time Warner, the $37.2 billion writedown of Wachovia's loan book at Wells Fargo(NYSE:WFC), or, closer to home, the $34.1 billion in charges taken by ConocoPhillips(NYSE:COP). I'm still disturbed.

TheWall Street Journal noted that "[m]ost analysts pay little attention to such charges." Well, include me out, as Samuel Goldwyn would say. I'm well aware that this charge doesn't impact Devon's cash flows, which hit a record at $9.6 billion for the year. It still reflects poorly on the firm's reserve booking practices, in my opinion.

One would think this gigantic impairment charge would invite a dose of humility. However, Devon is going ahead with a 2009 capital program that will overshoot cash flow by about $1 billion. Granted, exploration and development spending will drop about 50% from last year, but it's still a fairly aggressive move in this environment.

Even Chesapeake Energy(NYSE:CHK), slighted by certain analysts for spending like a sailor, has been chastened on this front. Then again, Devon has a much better balance sheet, at less than 25% net debt to adjusted capitalization.

Maybe I'm getting all worked up over nothing here, but I find myself in Tudor Pickering's camp. That energy-focused research outfit recommended swapping E&P dollars out of Devon and into Anadarko Petroleum(NYSE:APC) or Noble Energy(NYSE:NBL). Add EOG Resources(NYSE:EOG) -- which just reported it had neither "any significant property impairments or any meaningful price related reserve revisions" -- to that list, and we're right on the same page.