What exactly do you mean by "if he played a part in the choice" he had sex didn't he? Of course he played a part.

Why don't you believe in sterilization? I don't think you can force sterilization on people regardless of their choices. It goes back to the "choice" thing that i think is so important. I don't think people should have to pay for the procedure, though. think of how many abortions that could be prevented if this procedure were allowed at no cost? Or free birth control for that matter?

So my answer is no. People shouldn't be punished for accidentally becoming pregnant.

This approach is primarily focused on a condition of "punishment" for women. It has nothing to do with the sanctity of life. It has nothing to do with helping women, changing society's views, or helping children. It's even discriminatory towards the female gender.

You don't seem to understand why women get abortions. I would suggest that you do some research into this before advocating a punishment condition. And yes, forced surgery is punishment.

First forced gestation now forced sterilization?? I would question your state of sobriety on this one.. wow.. forced sterilization as a punishment for abortion..
So you want to take away the choice to gestate in the future. So basically because I had an abortion you want to make sure my youngest daughter was never concieved in the first place?
What about women who have had sterlization surgery and get pregnant anyway? Do you want to force them to have another surgery or just remove their uteruses so they don't 'misuse' them in the future..

Pff, I'm done with Guest for now. He believes that consential sex between two loving adults is a mistake, especially if they get pregnant! They got pregnant on purpose didn't you know? Just the SEX was a mistake, the pregnancy isn't!!!

I feel badly for Catholic people. I mean the people that actually believe everything the church tells them, like guest. What a horrible way to go through life.

Humans aren't the only species that have sex purely for pleasure. Many other species of animals have sex purely for pleasure. They have sex when the female is not in heat as well as when she is, for example.

Sex is important for the bonding process, for keeping couples together which is obviously advantageous to their children. Also, there are health benefits to sex, like as a stress reliever, for one.

There are childfree women who will fight their very hardest to get a doctor to sterilize them, backing up their wishes with thorough research, and most of them get laughed right out of the office because 'they'll change their minds' and become baby-rabid (since, you know, doctors know their patients better than the patients know themselves).

I would bet that, if sterilization became a mandatory follow-up to an abortion, unaltered childfree women would get pregnant left and right just to abort and get that tubal/Essure. I would contemplate intentionally getting pregnant just for the sterilization at my age if this was reality. And if BF got snipped too, that just means we'd be able to toss condoms to the wind - no complaints about that.

To be consistent, anyone who had an accidental pregnancy, whether they carried to term or not, could be sterilised. Men especially -- one accidental kid, and that's it, you're done. A little more chlorine in the gene pool, please.

To be consistent, anyone who had an accidental pregnancy, whether they carried to term or not, could be sterilised. Men especially -- one accidental kid, and that's it, you're done. A little more chlorine in the gene pool, please.