Though Aguilera is clearly the guest of honor — she’s the Beyoncé to Panettiere’s Channing Tatum, if you will — it looks like Panettiere has things pretty well under control, even without an assist from the song’s original belter. (To be honest, though, I would have also appreciated a visit from Mya. Where did she go?!)

TVLine has confirmed that the segment was taped before Oct. 13, when Panettiere checked into a hospital for treatment of postpartum depression — and thus took a hiatus from her ABC drama.