This is a poll made in response to the James Reimer trade value thread where some internet white knight insisted if we put aside the facts, Reimer had a much better first season (In case you were wondering why this exists).

Based on the facts only it has to be Mason and I'm a Maple Leafs fan saying that.

However what Reimer did in his rookie year was also impressive because he did get 20 wins after playing his 1st NHL game on Janurary 1, 2011 and he at least saved the Maple Leafs from giving the Bruins another 1st round pick in the top 5 of the 2011 Draft.