If this is your first visit, be sure to
check out the FAQ by clicking the
link above. You may have to register
before you can post: click the register link above to proceed. To start viewing messages,
select the forum that you want to visit from the selection below.

I'm not saying there weren't good ideas, because I agree, there were, but when it comes to Transformers in general, I just find it to lose its magic. I liked some of the stuff in the Marvel run, but I don't think IDW has ever come up with a good TF comic and DW only had the first WWI story that was good (except Grimlock being there made no sense), the rest of their stuff was crap. Plus, if I recall, the comic made Galvatron a seperate entity from Megatron, and that was utter nonsense.

Have you checked out IDW's two TF books since Mike "I'm burned out by writing giant robots" Costa left? It's so much better!

Paul dini was the one who was bitter about his work at filmation. (can't say he STILL is but circa BTAS he was definitely bitter about it) Bruce timm seemed more appreciative of his he-man work (he never gushed but I never heard a bitterness)

This is why I can't watch Comic Book Guys on AMC. Or watch any Kevin Smith movies. Or read any of his comics.

Paul Dini is a great writer and certainly did a lot to flesh out the MOTU mythos. But I get the feeling he's let thirty years of bitterness cloud his memories a bit. My reading of the interview went like this:

KS: So, Mattel basically threw toys at you and said "create this universe".
PD: Yeah, they had the name "Eternia" and we (the writers) created everything else. Everything that you love about MOTU came from me and everything you hate resulted from Mattel's vagueness concerning the property.

Don't get me wrong, Dini did as much as anyone else in terms of sculpting the world of MOTU as we know it, but I think he's maybe overestimating his own contributions a wee bit.

This is why I can't watch Comic Book Guys on AMC. Or watch any Kevin Smith movies. Or read any of his comics.

Paul Dini is a great writer and certainly did a lot to flesh out the MOTU mythos. But I get the feeling he's let thirty years of bitterness cloud his memories a bit. My reading of the interview went like this:

KS: So, Mattel basically threw toys at you and said "create this universe".
PD: Yeah, they had the name "Eternia" and we (the writers) created everything else. Everything that you love about MOTU came from me and everything you hate resulted from Mattel's vagueness concerning the property.

Don't get me wrong, Dini did as much as anyone else in terms of sculpting the world of MOTU as we know it, but I think he's maybe overestimating his own contributions a wee bit.

To be fair a lot of the mythos came from the Michael Halperin bible didn't it? that was done for filmation to do a show. I haven't listened to the interview but I know Dini was very bitter for a while. sad because Filmation gave a lot of folks a chance to get their start, i'd be so grateful for a company to do that for me.

The "MOTU Bible" written by Michael Halperin is where most of the built-up lore comes form. Halperin even wrote some of the minicomics himself in the early stage, and they incorporate the elements that have become iconic for the franchise.

The "MOTU Bible" written by Michael Halperin is where most of the built-up lore comes form. Halperin even wrote some of the minicomics himself in the early stage, and they incorporate the elements that have become iconic for the franchise.

Several things were also introduced in the DC Comics (Adam as He-Man's secret ID, his talking cat Cringer, Marlena being from earth). It's quite possible that Halperin was involved at this point or that Mark Ellis, Lou Scheimer, and others were generating ideas, but Paul Kupperberg from DC doesn't recall a series bible. Here's an interview Sallah did with him a couple of years ago...

Regardless, there is no question that much of the post-Glut/Alcala mythos was developed and solidified by Michael Halperin. Still, I suspect others (such as Kupperberg) were tossing in some seminal ideas as well.

Several things were also introduced in the DC Comics (Adam as He-Man's secret ID, his talking cat Cringer, Marlena being from earth). It's quite possible that Halperin was involved at this point or that Mark Ellis, Lou Scheimer, and others were generating ideas, but Paul Kupperberg from DC doesn't recall a series bible. Here's an interview Sallah did with him a couple of years ago...

Regardless, there is no question that much of the post-Glut/Alcala mythos was developed and solidified by Michael Halperin. Still, I suspect others (such as Kupperberg) were tossing in some seminal ideas as well.

Yep, I know the Kupperberg/Glut DC stories well, as I read the original DC minicomic as a kid. What I am wondering is how sure we can be 30 years later that they DIDN'T get any kind of outline of story elements provided to them beforehand. It's hard to remember everything that happened a decade ago, especially in a busy profession such as a comics writer.

Paul Dini Reflects on Filmation on Podcast

Hey guys just wanted to drop in a tidbit here and inform y'all that Paul Dini was just recently on a Kevin smith podacst (Fatman on Batman) where he spoke of his career ladder and Kevin had him speak on his Filmation MOTU experience offering a nice little chunk of history, definitely worth the listen!

here's the link for anyone wanting to listen:**Please do not post direct links to this interview. Lots of vulgarity. It's easy enough to find if you look for Kevin Smith's podcast site.**

I never knew Paul Dini and Bruce Timm were involved with this show before until i did research on the net about 11 years ago and that kicks a$$ you know those two are geniuses for making such shows like Tiny Toons, Animaniacs, Batman TAS, Justice League, Superman TAS and other DC/Warner shows.