MOTUC Director's Commentary #7:Dear Legal, it is "Zodac" not "Zodiac". This is not a

If this is your first visit, be sure to
check out the FAQ by clicking the
link above. You may have to register
before you can post: click the register link above to proceed. To start viewing messages,
select the forum that you want to visit from the selection below.

This is how I interpreted it as well. So, I was a bit confused people would find it offensive. If anything, he seemed to be implying that he realized it doesn't work with Eternia. I suppose he might not have known how else to phrase it because, as you say, African American is usually the most accepted term - even when it's perhaps not precisely accurate or preferred by those that it is being used to describe. He could have said "black" or "person of color" or "brown" but all of these can be controversial as well. So maybe he thought this was the safest course of action?

So, how is it proposed that you say it? Black? Doesnt sound right when you have peoples of many different colors, like blue, red, orange, green, purple, etc. Black in this context would be black, like the color of this type, so would we say brown? I dont know. In the cartoon they call themselves humans. Is that an Earth comment? I dont know why people get upset about this, especially since it was evident that it was not Scott's term, but what the creators wanted in the past.

No, dude, he was wrestling with the PC language. We're supposed to say "African-American," but there's no Africa or America on Eternia. Get it? "Africa? America? On Eternia?"

This is not a PC issue. This was the exact statement: "In an effort to diversify the cast, the show’s creators wanted to add an African American (on Eternia?) character." I don't think the issue is about what they called the character. Toy Guru, and the rest of America, understood that Mattel believed they needed a black character to diversify. No one, including myself, has an issue with them or Guru calling that character an African American, because we all understand what Mattel was asking for—a black character. It's not like they were going to put African American in the bio! We would all understand what Mattel meant if they asked for an Asian, Native American, or even an Iceland looking character. It might not sound PC but we'd know what they were talking about—diversity. So the "Really?" remark was supposed to be funny? Or was Toy Guru sincerely confused? I'm pretty sure he was not confused, nor do I believe he was being funny. I think he was being cynical shooting from the hip. Let me ask this question: If we replace African American with "Black" how would that statement read? Now understand there is nothing wrong with either term, but if you replace African American with Black, "(on Eternia?)" looks and sounds off doesn't it? TG is not a racist. I just felt it was unthoughtful, ignorant and unnecessary. Again, this is not a PC issue. I'm thankful for TG. He's done a lot of good work. He's a public figure now and needs to be more responsible with his words. He could have easily left out the "really?" remark and it wouldn't have taken anything away from the read. And I'm sure knowing how someone could have taken it, if he had to do it all over again, he would omit it. Of course Toy Guru could just clarify himself. Hopefully here and not in his next blog.

This is not a PC issue. This was the exact statement: "In an effort to diversify the cast, the show’s creators wanted to add an African American (on Eternia?) character." I don't think the issue is about what they called the character. Toy Guru, and the rest of America, understood that Mattel believed they needed a black character to diversify. No one, including myself, has an issue with them or Guru calling that character an African American, because we all understand what Mattel was asking for—a black character. It's not like they were going to put African American in the bio! We would all understand what Mattel meant if they asked for an Asian, Native American, or even an Iceland looking character. It might not sound PC but we'd know what they were talking about—diversity. So the "Really?" remark was supposed to be funny? Or was Toy Guru sincerely confused? I'm pretty sure he was not confused, nor do I believe he was being funny. I think he was being cynical shooting from the hip. Let me ask this question: If we replace African American with "Black" how would that statement read? Now understand there is nothing wrong with either term, but if you replace African American with Black, "(on Eternia?)" looks and sounds off doesn't it? TG is not a racist. I just felt it was unthoughtful, ignorant and unnecessary. Again, this is not a PC issue. I'm thankful for TG. He's done a lot of good work. He's a public figure now and needs to be more responsible with his words. He could have easily left out the "really?" remark and it wouldn't have taken anything away from the read. And I'm sure knowing how someone could have taken it, if he had to do it all over again, he would omit it. Of course Toy Guru could just clarify himself. Hopefully here and not in his next blog.

Nope... gotta say your off on this.

Not the least of which is because this is an OLD joke. The African American in a world with no Africa or America has been brought up in every thread involving Clamp Champ and Zodak for years now.

He was just drawing attention to the fact that he KNEW there was no Africa or America there when he used the term 'African-American'... Because lets face it, after every other 'black character' thread... it was OBVIOUS that if HE didn't acknowledge it... SOMEONE would have brought it up.

Also on the subject of Clamp Champ... There should be no Shock and Awe that people thought the cast of eternia should be diverse.... Because they made that decision in the 80's!! Eternia is already known for having both Black guys, and even Asian guys (despite no Asia on this world...)

There was nothing there worth getting offended over. Unless you hate the idea of Zodac being redesigned to fit a 'token' slot... THAT could be seen as offensive... but if they really wanted to stick with the 8-12 back characters... I can't really blame them, and Zodac was pretty much a blank slate.

Not the least of which is because this is an OLD joke. The African American in a world with no Africa or America has been brought up in every thread involving Clamp Champ and Zodak for years now.

He was just drawing attention to the fact that he KNEW there was no Africa or America there when he used the term 'African-American'... Because lets face it, after every other 'black character' thread... it was OBVIOUS that if HE didn't acknowledge it... SOMEONE would have brought it up.

Also on the subject of Clamp Champ... There should be no Shock and Awe that people thought the cast of eternia should be diverse.... Because they made that decision in the 80's!! Eternia is already known for having both Black guys, and even Asian guys (despite no Asia on this world...)

There was nothing there worth getting offended over. Unless you hate the idea of Zodac being redesigned to fit a 'token' slot... THAT could be seen as offensive... but if they really wanted to stick with the 8-12 back characters... I can't really blame them, and Zodac was pretty much a blank slate.

Then just say "black" and then there is no issue. Black is PC in the black community. If you say black then you won't have to follow it with the "on Eternia?" remark. And I have to assume that TG knew what they meant when they wanted an "African American". He knew they were requesting someone of a darker complexion. The sentence should have read like this :"In an effort to diversify the cast, the show’s creators wanted to add a black character." Or "In an effort to diversify the cast, the show’s creators wanted to add an African American looking character." My issue is only with the "(On Eternia?)"

Not the least of which is because this is an OLD joke. The African American in a world with no Africa or America has been brought up in every thread involving Clamp Champ and Zodak for years now.

He was just drawing attention to the fact that he KNEW there was no Africa or America there when he used the term 'African-American'... Because lets face it, after every other 'black character' thread... it was OBVIOUS that if HE didn't acknowledge it... SOMEONE would have brought it up.

Also on the subject of Clamp Champ... There should be no Shock and Awe that people thought the cast of eternia should be diverse.... Because they made that decision in the 80's!! Eternia is already known for having both Black guys, and even Asian guys (despite no Asia on this world...)

This is correct, it's been an on going debate on here for years and even talked about on Gooble. No need to make it something it's not.

Then just say "black" and then there is no issue. Black is PC in the black community. If you say black then you won't have to follow it with the "on Eternia?" remark. And I have to assume that TG knew what they meant when they wanted an "African American". He knew they were requesting someone of a darker complexion. The sentence should have read like this :"In an effort to diversify the cast, the show’s creators wanted to add a black character." Or "In an effort to diversify the cast, the show’s creators wanted to add an African American looking character." My issue is only with the "(On Eternia?)"

This is of course the correct way to do it.

Unfortunately... there are a LOT of people who do NOT like the term 'black'.... People find offense at the smallest thing, that sometimes it's like walking through a minefield... Personally... I HATE the term African American.

1) What about black people who are NOT American?

2) I once worked for a guy who's father came over from North Africa... Whitest guy I ever saw.

Therefore as a descriptive term... it sucks. Any time a word does not adequetly convey what you want it to... It's time to find a better one.

But I have seen white guys attacked for using the generic 'Black' term and not 'African American'.... so he was just trying to cover his tracks there. Despite the illogical use of the term.

Exactly! It's like a few people are going out of their way to purposefully find fault with things. I thought that the way he worded it was the best way that he could and still convey what he was trying to convey. I'm all for criticism when it is appropriate, but throw the guy a bone here.

Um, it also feels like someone is going out of their way to purposefully create strife among people who may be offended.

Personally, as I posted above - I understood what he meant, but I also immediately thought of various interpretations that might be made - it's one of those comments that he should have just not made. It may have been the "best" way to make it, but the point would have been made without his side comment, which was rife for people to get PO'd about. It simply shouldn't have been made at all .

African Americans on Eternia? That was an ignorant remark. Are there Europeans on Eternia? We're not talking about cultures or ethnicities. We're talking about complexion. That's all. I'm sure on Eternia there are darker skinned people that aren't from Africa, just like on our planet. In fact, there are orange, green, purple, and you name it, and they're all considered Eternians like we're considered Earthlings. They needed color diversification back then and even today. Someone's skin being darker doesn't change their character in anyway, anymore than you getting a tan would mess with yours. I am sympathetic to the whole nostalgia thing, so I can understand that. I just hate the whole there are no African Americans on Eternia garbage. Just plain ignorant.

Clearly he meant that there is neither an Africa nor an America on Eternia. Only a fool would think he was being racist.

Danielsan

Planet Claire has pink air
All the trees are red
No one ever dies there
No one has a head

Clearly he meant that there is neither an Africa nor an America on Eternia. Only a fool would think he was being racist.

Oh boy. Well I will not resort to name calling. If you had read my other post you would know that I don't think TG is a racist in any way. And I was not offended by his remarks. Just thought that he needed to show more care on a subject that can be lightning rod as you can see by this thread

I did get the joke, but the problem is that this is "the Evil Toyguru" speaking... Everything he says will offend people "just cause he's Mattel"... Personally he should have elaborated on that remark...

(On Eternia? But there is no Africa or America on Eternia...)

to avoid any misunderstanding...

FINALLY!! GLIMMER IS IN MY SHELF!! Crita is coming... Now I NEED SONGSTER! The Awesometastic Bard!