8 team, PPR Keeper League Keep 5 I gave this in two trades Pat Maholmes Julian Edleman Jarvis Landry I received AJ Green Robert Woods JuJu Smith-Shuister I'll be starting Wentz as my QB now, Juju and AJ will be starters, Woods will be a bye week filler for now. I'll keep Juju and Green. Thoughts?
... View more

8 team, PPR Keeper League Keep 5 I gave this in two trades Pat Maholmes Julian Edleman Jarvis Landry I received AJ Green Robert Woods JuJu Smith-Shuister I'll be starting Wentz as my QB now, Juju and AJ will be starters, Woods will be a bye week filler for now. I'll keep Juju and Green. Thoughts?
... View more

really hard to say without knowing the league size, rosters, scoring... you know, the basics. With no info I'd say I would go with Barkley/Bell. Lock up those RBs and roll with WRs in the draft.
... View more

@medin066 wrote: Yup that is correct. What's your reasoning for that, if you don't mind me asking? I can get behind not keeping Hopkins because his ADP is 1st round. But you don't think an elite QB (especially one who can add rushing points every week) is a huge value in the 10th round, in leagues that count pass TDs as the same as all TDs? Or McKinnon who could return 2nd round value? Sorry if the tone of my questions sound condescending, definitely not the case! I'm genuinely curious to hear a completely opposite point of view from mine. Its about value... gordon is a 1st round player available at 10. he's your best option in my opinon. watson is a 4-6 round guy in this league. The 6 pptd doens't increase his value any.
... View more

my reading comprehension skills might be a bit lacking... but your options are Watson in the 10th Hopkins in the 1st Gurley in the 3rd McKinnon in the 10th Gordon in the 10th is that right? if so i'd go Gordon/Gurley
... View more

@BJD307wrote: For me, it's Boxberger. He has no real competition for the job. The only threat at this time is injury. After him, I would go with Leone. I do expect him to win out for the closer job long term. I can't see Claudio getting many saves this year. Both Boxberger and Leone are great options in my opinion. Maybe I missed something here... but Archie Bradley is in Ari. He's literally the best P in this group. So Box is in the worst spot since he has the shortest leash. Quit literally the opposite of what you said. And i guess i haven't really seen anything that says that Bradley isn't the closer?
... View more

I like it a good amount. I'm a fan of Mazara, but he may only be what he is now. I think he can creep on the type of season that Marcel Ozuna just had. But it's going to take a while. Worst case, Rodgers probably has a higher ceiling, lower floor. Add in Miller in a HLD, K/9 league and it's more of a steal than anything.
... View more

I'm not a fan. Though, I do like Calhoun. His skill set may lead him into a poor mans Dan Uggla. And Margot is nothing. You can find his stats anywhere, at anytime. Which is why he was ranked outside the top 200. If I'm giving a top 50 player, I want some guaranteed value in return. Again, this might pay off for you. But at this point I'm skeptical.
... View more

@RGBonezwrote: So i have Samardzija on my bench and he is now out for 3 to 4 weeks. I feel that the strength of my remaining pitchers is solid. With a big name like this do you leave him on the bench until he is active or do you dump him? Remainng Pitchers: Scherzer Verlander Roark Happ Jansen Knebel Neris Barraclough Samardzija is not a big name pitcher. He's a poor real life pitcher, and awful roto option. The only reason he gets drafted in H-H leagues is because he can get to 200 Ks. But at the cost of ruinning your other categories. I'd say put him on your DL and then try to trade him. Not smart owner will take anything for him so you might have to find a sucker. if you have no suckers in your league, a simple drop would be best.
... View more

I'm keeping Scherzer 999 times out of 1000. Sano, thought popluar in dynasty rankings, doesn't offer anything special in today's game. Give me Matt Olson and you have the same player. Would you trade Scherzer for Matt Olson and Godley? No. Not trading the top SP unless I'm getting a top 25-50 player in return.
... View more

The runs produced should be similar. Maybe in the 140-150 range. Contreras will have more HR, Posey a better BA. In a redraft, I'm taking Posey all day. Keeper I'd go Contreras. But I'm not expecting him to be anything more than a 25/80 guy.
... View more

@Name1wrote: gordons the best player of that group, take the trade as is @Name1wrote: gordons the best player of that group, take the trade as is based on what? you not doing any research and simply using last year's stat lines?
... View more

What? Maybe I'm missing something? I just recently traded Gordon + for Bogaerts in my dynasty. You're wanting to give Archer, Gennett, AND Boegarts? Bad idea... Even more so in a deep league where depth is so valuable. You're squandering it and not even upgrading.
... View more

@pantherking1983wrote: It really wont matter who you keep at that point with your other 4 keepers. I would try and feel around who you can trade for a SP and keep that player that someone else would trade a big time SP for you to add. What sense does that make? Just because he has 4 other elite keepers means that it doesn't matter who he picks for the 5th? Talk about bad advice... For me it's Bregman and it's not particularly close. In a standard 5x5, I'd keep him. With the added Cats, those are even more to his advantage. Add in age, upside, and position, I think this is an easy solution.
... View more