How
eloquent could Anne Elliot have been, – how eloquent, at least, were her wishes
on the side of early warm attachment, and a cheerful confidence in futurity,
against that over-anxious caution which seems to insult exertion and distrust
Providence! –She had been forced into
prudence in her youth, she learned romance as she grew older – the natural
sequel of an unnatural beginning.(30)

This summary of Anne’s life at the beginning of
Persuasion sets her character development apart from other Austen
heroines.At twenty-seven Anne is by
far the eldest heroine and her maturity of vision is reinforced for the reader
by her having almost complete narratorial approval.Because Anne had been “forced” into prudent behaviour when young
but “learned” to value romantic love in her maturity, the progress of her life
runs counter to the typical educational sequence.Yet “Sequel” suggests that another story is to come, another
narrative which will continue the previous sad story of Anne’s life.

I am interested in Jane Austen’s juxtaposition
of prudence with romance and how both aspects are dominant in Persuasion.Because Anne had learned most of her lessons
before the action begins, she can act as tutor to various characters in the
novel, including the hero Wentworth (McMaster 59).This reversal of conventional relationships is one of the “natural
sequels” of Anne’s earlier forced prudence.In order to analyze Anne’s unusual development from prudence to romance,
I will consider her behaviour towards Wentworth in terms of the ideals of
ladylike conduct expressed in the advice manuals popular in Austen’s
period.I will also explain how I read
Anne’s story to be a romance in several senses of the term.

In the 18th century,
advice manuals for women underwent a change from being books of religious
devotion, or handbooks of domestic economy to become practical guides for
conduct, called “Courtesy books” (Blain et al 10).Aimed at the middle ranks of society who were interested in
self-improvement, the books attempted to define the position of women in society.Not books of etiquette, they nevertheless
provided instruction for newcomers into polite society and attempted to teach
good morals as the foundation for correct behaviour: manners were supposed to
be the outward expression of morality (Hemlow 732-33).The books define the feminine in terms of a
domestic world or “province” which is complementary to the economic world of
men (Armstrong 98).They prescribe an
ideal of correct feminine behaviour in terms of a series of abstractions such
as obedience, modesty, chastity, piety, and gentleness (Spencer 16), all the
while calling these ideals natural!Although the writers claim that women are equal companions to men, there
is a repeated emphasis on women’s physical and mental frailty, delicacy, and
softness which suggests otherwise.

Two of the most influential books are Rev.
James Fordyce’s Sermons to Young Women (1765), which Mr. Collins vainly
tries to read to the Bennet girls in Pride and Prejudice (ch. 14), and
Dr. John Gregory’s A Father’s Legacy to his Daughters (1774).Although written from the different vantage
points of preacher and concerned parent, both describe an unforgiving society
which continually judged female behaviour with a worldly eye.Specifically addressing young women about to
“enter” the world, their advice covers the entire range of female
behaviour.Fordyce’s titles are
revealing; they include “On the Importance of the Female Sex, especially the
Younger Part,” “On Female Reserve,” “On Female Virtue,” “Meekness,” and so on;
Gregory’s chapters cover religion, conduct and behaviour, amusements,
friendship, love and marriage.Fordyce
tended toward the pithy maxim such as “Remember how tender a thing woman’s
reputation is; how hard to preserve; and when lost, how impossible to recover”
(16-17), immortalized in Fanny Burney’s Evelina (150).Gregory tended to be more practical and
worldly in his advice, for instance regarding dress he states:

The love of dress is natural
to you, …Good sense will regulate your
expense in it,and good taste will
direct you to dress in such a way as to conceal any blemishes, and set off your
beauties, if you have any, to the greatest advantage.But much delicacy and judgment are required in the application of
this rule.A fine woman shows her
charms to most advantage, when she seems most to conceal them.The finest bosom in nature is not so fine as
what imagination forms.(73)

One strand of the novel in the 18th century,
the didactic novel, paralleled the conduct book: the heroine was often an
“exemplary” character who embodied the qualities specified in the manuals
(Spencer 142).Towards the end of the
18th century, Fanny Burney’s novels were considered “courtesy” or conduct book
novels due to their range of didactic interests (Hemlow 758).By the time Jane Austen was writing, the
feminine ideal had passed into the domain of common sense and was accepted as
“natural” (Armstrong 100).Therefore,
the relation between her novels and the conduct books are complex and on the
level of inference rather than demonstrating a one to one relationship.Austen’s characterizations of her heroines
are often considered to be final variations on conduct book ideals, and I
consider Anne Elliot to represent the most subtle variation.1I will explore how Anne’s behaviour can be
interpreted as Austen’s mature response to the conduct book writers by
providing instances of when Anne applies the rules, stretches the rules, and
even overturns or quietly dissolves them.

Between the beginning and end of Persuasion
Anne changes her mind about her broken engagement with Wentworth.When lonely and miserable, she maintains
that,

under every disadvantage of
disapprobation at home, and every anxiety attending his profession, all their
probable fears, delays and disappointments, she should have yet been a happier
woman in maintaining the engagement, than she had been in the sacrifice of it
….(29)

Yet when safely reunited with Wentworth, Anne tells him that she would
“have suffered more in continuing the engagement than I did even in giving it
up, because I should have suffered in my conscience” (246).These are problematic passages.In the latter instance, however, Anne has
just told Wentworth that she has been trying to judge her earlier actions
“impartially” in terms of right and wrong (246).Her statement suggests an absolute moral code modeled on the
conduct books.Concerning filial duty,
Fordyce stresses that parents know best: “I would begin where your duty in
society begins, by putting you in mind how deeply your parents are interested
in your behaviour” (4); “do nothing to make them unhappy; do all in your power
to give them delight” (5).If a young
woman marries an inappropriate man, Fordyce states that she “disgraces her
education, dishonours her sex, disappoints the hopes she had raised” (6).Moreover, the consequences are never
ceasing: “the reflexion of having acted undutifully … to those that gave you
birth, were alone sufficient to poison the whole pleasure of life” and “the
horror of guilt” will “haunt and distract the mind, more particularly if the
parents were uncommonly worthy” (180).

With strictures such as
these, Anne’s logic becomes more understandable: the very worthy Lady Russell
has been like a mother to Anne, and Anne feels she owes her filial duty.Yet despite her change in attitude, Anne has
remained consistent: she maintains that she was right in her behaviour, that
she does not blame either Lady Russell or herself, but she would not give the
same advice.As Anne wisely observes,
it is only with hindsight that the advice can be seen as mistaken (246).By placing conscience over emotions she is
applying conduct book rules and logic.She even uses conduct book phraseology when she tells Wentworth, “a
strong sense of duty is no bad part of a woman’s portion” (246).

In the last section of the novel, when
Wentworth comes to Bath, Anne stretches the rules concerning proper ladylike
behaviour.2While Anne will
forego an evening with her insufferable cousins the Dalyrymples to visit Mrs.
Smith, when there is a chance that she will see Wentworth at a concert her
transparent change of plans raises Mrs. Smith’s curiosity about an underlying
motive (180).Anne next instigates a
delicate pursuit of Wentworth which bends the conduct book rules.Gregory states, “It is a maxim laid down
among you, and a very prudent one it is, – that love is not to begin on your
part, but is entirely to be the consequences of our attachment to you”
(97).He is adamant about procedure,
whereby men must take the lead; to do otherwise is “to violate the modesty and
delicacy of [the female] sex, and to invert the clearest order of nature”
(108).Yet, when Wentworth enters the
room, Anne takes the initiative:

Anne was the nearest to him,
and making yet a little advance, she instantly spoke.He was preparing only to bow and pass on, but her gentle “How do
you do?” brought him out of the straight line to stand near her, and make
enquiries in return …(181)

During this conversation, Wentworth talks about
the events at Lyme and through his speech and actions Anne learns about his
feelings for Louisa and intimations of his feelings for herself (184).Reinforced with this proof of his love of
her (186), Anne begins to act more assertively.The subsequent scene is comic, for while Mr. Elliot has
“manoeuvred” himself to a seat by her (186), Anne is manoeuvring herself in
order to give Wentworth a spot: “by some other removals, and a little scheming
of her own, Anne was enabled to place herself much nearer the end of the bench
than she had been before, much more within reach of a passer-by” (189).Anne ruefully compares her forward behaviour
with “the inimitable Miss Larolles” in Fanny Burney’s Cecilia, although
Anne succeeds in gaining her gentleman’s attention (189-90).3

Interestingly, the skill
with which Anne interprets Wentworth’s returning interest is prescribed as a
conduct book virtue by Fordyce:

This, I apprehend, does not
require reasoning or accuracy, so much as observation and discernment.Your business is chiefly to read Men, in
order to make yourselves agreeable and useful.It is not the argumentative but the sentimental talents, which give you
that insight and those openings into the human heart, that lead you to your
principal ends as Women.(108)

I will return to Anne’s argumentative skills later, but at present note
how Anne not only possesses this ability for “reading” people, but also that
she employs this ability for her own ends.Austen characterizes Wentworth through a clear code of gesture and
automatic actions.Anne is able to
interpret this nonverbal behaviour (Warhol 6-7), but so is the discerning
reader.Gregory provides a brief
“reader’s” guide for women detailing what a “man of delicacy” acts like, when
under “the effect of honourable passion,” especially when he believes he has
little hope of success (101-05).Gregory observes, “It renders a man not only respectful, but timid to
the highest degree” (101).When talking
with his beloved, “he quietly relapses into seriousness, if not into dullness”
(102); and “Diffidence and embarrassment will always make him appear to
disadvantage in the company of his mistress” (102).

Gregory’s description
accords with much of Wentworth’s behaviour in Bath, with the exception of his
continuing change of colour.Just as
Anne, once her “second spring” of good looks has returned, blushes in
Wentworth’s presence, so does he in hers.Fordyce and Gregory stress how revealing the blush is as a token of
maidenly innocence (Yeazel 65).Fordyce
rhapsodizes, “it is the precious colouring of virtue,” quoting “Clear Chastity
/ with blushes redd’ning as she moves along / disordered at the deep regard she
draws” (33).(Note regarding Anne,
however, that she is not at all put out of countenance when the unknown Mr.
Elliot looks earnestly and admiringly at her! [104].)For his part, Gregory thought so highly of the blush as an emblem
of innocence that he gives it first place in his chapter on conduct and
behaviour (Yeazel 68).Significantly,
he acknowledges that men blush too:

“When a girl ceases to blush,
she has lost the most powerful charm of beauty.That extreme sensibility which it indicates may be a weakness and
incumbrance in our sex, as I have too often felt; but in yours it is peculiarly
engaging.”(44)

Juliet McMaster remarks that due to their
loving knowledge of one another Anne and Wentworth are equally hypersensitive
to one another’s responses and gestures (72-73, Van Sickle Johnson 45).Moreover, by reading each other’s blushes
they achieve a kind of reciprocity.For
example, when Anne first sees Wentworth in Bath, she almost faints.But “when she had scolded back her senses”
she is ready for their meeting, while he is not (Van Sickle Johnson 57):

He
was more obviously struck and confused by the sight of her than she had ever
observed before: he looked quite red.For the first time, since their renewed acquaintance, she felt that she
was betraying the least sensibility of the two.She had the advantage of him, …. (175)

Later, at the concert, their reciprocal responses are described through
Anne’s heightened perceptions:

He stopped.A sudden recollection seemed to occur, and
to give him some taste of that emotion which was reddening Anne’s cheeks and
fixing her eyes on the ground.– After
clearing his throat, however, he proceeded …. (182)

Afterwards, when Anne reflects on Wentworth’s behaviour, her conclusion
that he “must love her” is based on more than his speech about Louisa and Capt.
Benwick:

– sentences begun which he
could not finish – his half-averted eyes, and more than half-expressive glance –
all, all declared that he had a heart returning to her at least;(185)

The conduct book writers
refused to admit passion into an English-woman’s constitution, although they
could not answer for those born in southern countries: “I do not think that your
sex, at least in this part of the world, have much of that sensibility which
disposes to such attachments” (Gregory 96).They insist that “what is commonly called love among you” is “rather
gratitude, and partially to the man who prefers you to the rest of your sex”
(Gregory 96).It is ironic then, that
the code of the blush, so unvaryingly presented as signifying innocence by the
conduct book writers is, in Austen’s rendition, a continuation of Renaissance
love theory which contradicts their arguments! (McMaster, ch. 1).

Austen imbues Wentworth’s character with an
emotionality that softens his vigorous, athletic nature.He is the only Austen hero who “clear[s]” a
hedge at a leap (91), but his sensibility somewhat “feminizes” him.This characterization parallels the waiting
role he is forced to play in Bath, where he assumes the passive position of the
conventional heroine (Poovey 232).Wentworth’s characterization also parallels the reversal of the
traditional mentor-pupil relation whereby he is the one who must be taught
(Butler 275, Kirkham 145).Accordingly,
I interpret Austen’s presentation of Wentworth to anticipate what some feminist
critics call an “androgynous” ideal.4

The greatest instance of Anne’s self-assertion
of her feelings toward Wentworth is the intent behind her debate with Captain
Harville about men’s and women’s love at the (appropriately named) White Hart
Inn.Anne is utilizing the language of
propriety in a contrary fashion to the way it was intended, for she uses a
general statement about women’s constancy in love as a covert announcement of
her abiding love for Wentworth.5As Anne is fully aware, according to the rules of propriety, she does
not know Capt. Harville well enough to engage in an intimate conversation
(Nardin 143).Yet note how she
justifies her conduct and “reads” Capt. Harville’s gesture at the same time:

He looked at her with a smile,
and a little motion of the head, which expressed, “Come to me, I have something
to say;” and the unaffected, easy kindness of manner which denoted the feelings
of an older acquaintance than he really was, strongly enforced the
invitation.She roused herself and went
to him.(231)

Likewise, Harville’s query about woman’s love is not spoken; Anne not
only interprets his gestures but also literally gives voice to his
thoughts.After Harville contrasts his
deceased sister’s steadfastness in love with Benwick’s changeability, Anne
generalizes about woman’s constancy.She is responding to an unexpressed question:

Captain Harville smiled, as
much as to say, “Do you claim that for your sex?”and she answered the question, smiling also, “Yes.We certainly do not forget you so soon as
you forget us.It is, perhaps, our fate
rather than our merit.We cannot help
ourselves.We live at home, quiet,
confined, and our feelings prey upon us.You are forced on exertion.You
have always a profession, pursuits, business of some sort or other, to take you
back into the world immediately, and continual occupation and change soon
weaken impressions.”(232)

Interestingly, Anne’s
description of women’s lot sounds very similar to Fordyce where he argues for
the inferiority of women to men:

Nature appears to have formed
the faculties of your sex, for the most part, with less vigor than those of ours;
observing the same distinction here, as in the more delicate frame of your
bodies …; War, commerce, politics, exercises of strength and dexterity,
abstract philosophy, and abtruser sciences and the like, are most properly the
province of men.(107)

Allison Sulloway considers Anne’s debate with Capt. Harville to
summarize conduct book ideals in an ironic fashion, thereby inverting the
arguments about women’s weak minds, weak bodies and inconsistent nature
(183-85).Other feminist critics align
Anne’s speech with the writings of Mary Wollstonecraft (e.g. Kirkham 147).I agree that Anne’s display of debating
skills dispels any notions of intellectual weakness on her part, while her
description of education as power: “Education has been theirs in so much higher
a degree; the pen has been in their hands,” and her refusal to be hemmed in by
examples of books also sound feminist (234).

Anne’s use of the word
“forced” to describe the typical man’s lot, in other words, Wentworth’s
situation after their break-up, is revealing.It recalls the earlier use of “forced” to describe her assumption of the
prudent role (30).Also, while she is
using the pen as a symbol in her speech, Wentworth in the background has first
dropped his pen in agitation and then hastily resumed writing (233-34).I think Anne’s romantic intentions enable
her to understand the conventional position of both sexes whereby women and men
are “forced” into contrary roles of prudence or exertion.Moreover, through Anne’s speeches Austen
subtly questions the opposition and the compensatory emotional reactions of
women and men (Miller 33-34).As Anne
says, “I believe you equal to every important exertion” as long as “you have an
object.”“All the privilege I claim for
my own sex … is that of loving longest, when existence or when hope is gone”
(235).Anne acknowledges that women
traditionally occupy the weaker position in power relations by adding as an
aside, “it is not a very enviable [privilege], you need not covet it” (235).

The plot of Persuasion is a love-story
or romance in the modern sense.Yet the
narrative suggests another use of the term, current in Jane Austen’s time.In 1785 Clara Reeve published one of the earliest
historical accounts of the novel (Spencer 76).Reeve defines the difference between the romance and novel whereby “The
romance is an heroic fable, which treats of fabulous persons and things.– The Novel is a picture of real life and
manners, and of the times in which it is written” (I, 111).I consider Austen to be playing with the
notion of romance in this sense of her characterization of Anne.

After Anne goes to Lyme,
several characters outside of her male admirers remark on her improved looks,
notably Lady Russell and her father, who wonders if she uses Gowlands lotion
(145)!The scenes are amusing to Anne,
but when Lady Russell compliments her, Anne ruefully “hope[s] that she was to
be blessed with a second spring of youth and beauty” (124).In Bath, the narrator says that Anne had
fared better than her classmate Mrs. Smith by possessing every aspect of beauty
and youth except bloom (153), and other characters of discernment, including
ladies gossiping in stores, stress Anne’s beauty (177-78).The term “glow” now begins to be associated
with Anne as much as with Wentworth.At
the concert, when she senses Wentworth’s returning love, she is radiant: “Her
happiness was from within.Her eyes
were bright, and her cheeks glowed …” (185).In the next chapter, Mrs. Smith notices Anne’s transformed countenance,
correctly “diagnosing” the cause to be the presence of a lover, and causing her
to blush in confusion (194, McMaster 21).In chapter eleven when the lovers are reconciled, the description of
their silent reunion is ambiguous:

Anne could command herself
enough to receive that look and not repulsively.The cheeks which had been pale now glowed, and the movements
which had hesitated were decided.He
walked by her side.(240)

The glow of love belongs to both equally.

Also in Bath, Anne begins
to act more youthfully.She
sentimentalizes suffering when she eulogizes about the uplifting effects of
sickness to poor, ill Mrs. Smith:

“What
instances must pass … of ardent, disinterested, self-denying attachment, of
heroism, fortitude, patience, and resignation – of all the conflicts and all
the sacrifices that ennoble us most.A
sick chamber may often furnish the worth of volumes.”

“Yes,”
said Mrs. Smith doubtingly, “sometimes it may,” … (156)

Anne’s enthusiasm reveals her to be inexperienced, sheltered, and
unrealistic.A little later Anne breaks
her partly formed engagement with her friend because she hopes to see
Wentworth, an instance of girlish enthusiasm (180).Then, after seeing Wentworth and believing he loves her still,
she romanticizes that “Their union … could not divide her more from other men,
than their final separation” (192).Anne is so fulsome that the narrator directs a gently ironic comment
towards her:

Prettier musings of
high-wrought love and eternal constancy, could never have passed along the
streets of Bath, than Anne was sporting from Camden-place to
Westgate-buildings.It was almost
enough to spread purification and perfume all the way.(192)

Yet behind the teasing I detect through the
imagery the figure of Persephone bringing an early spring to the February
streets of Bath.I argue that
ultimately, the tone of Persuasion is not autumnal as has so often been
claimed (e.g. Gard 182), but springlike in its return to the spirit of youthful
love and intensity.When Anne and
Wentworth saunter along the gravel walk in Bath, the narrator says,

There they returned again in
to the past, more exquisitely happy, perhaps, in their re-union, than when it
had been first projected; more tender, more tried, more fixed in a knowledge of
each other’s character, truth, and attachment.(240-41)

I consider Austen, like a fairy godmother, to be imbuing Anne with a
return of youth and beauty.The final
paragraph of Persuasion locates the source of Anne’s now permanent glow
as being her reciprocated love for Wentworth.The narrator compares Anne’s happiness with that of her friend Mrs.
Smith: “[Mrs. Smith’s] spring of felicity was in the glow of her spirits, as
her friend Anne’s was in the warmth of her heart” (252).The penultimate sentence calls Anne’s future
life “sunshine” (252).The imagery of
glow, spring, and sunshine suggests indeed a return to springtime.Anne’s earlier hope about regaining a
“second spring,” a hope that was really a wish, has come true!

In Anne Elliot, Austen
has constructed a complex character who embodies numerous paradoxes.Anne is a mature version of the feminine
ideal which was defined in 18th-century conduct books, yet she breaks these
rules in accordance with her needs.Furthermore, by characterizing Anne’s growth as a movement from prudence
to romance, Austen creates a romance heroine, a romantic figure.Anne, and hence Austen, knew the poetry of
Scott and Byron.Some critics have
suggested that Austen appropriates the language of Romantic poetry to describe
Anne’s and Wentworth’s love for one another.Indeed, Anne comes to identify Wentworth and their love in absolute
terms, calling the contents of his letter, “all which this world could do for
her” (237).I detect in Austen’s
portrayal of the rejuvenated Anne suggestions of fairy tale romance and mythic
renewal.By creating a woman who
combines correct judgment with tenderness, moral superiority with passion, is
Jane Austen not describing a new type of heroine?Anne’s character recalls Wordsworth’s definition of the poet
transposed into a domestic context: is not Anne “endowed with more lively
sensibility, more enthusiasm and tenderness?”; does she not have “a greater
knowledge of human nature, and a more comprehensive soul”?Is not Anne someone who is “pleased with
[her] own passions and volitions, and who rejoices more than other[s] … in the
spirit of life? …” (Wordsworth 737).Jane Eyre – beware!

NOTES

1 See the writings of Poovey, Hunt, Spencer,
Sulloway and Johnson for a discussion of the relation between Austen’s novels
and the didactic novel.

2 Ten Harmsel and Poovey both discuss Anne’s
application and modification of the rules of decorum slightly differently.Ten Harmsel describes Anne as being both
conventional and unconventional at the same time (174).Poovey considers Anne to “struggle” to make
“social conventions accommodate and communicate her feelings” (232).

Miss Larolles, who was the head of the voluble sect in
fashionable society, “talking faster than she thinks,” vainly tried to attract
the attention of Mr. Meadows, the languid head of the Insensiblists, by sitting
on the outside of the benches: “It’s the shockingest thing you can conceive, to
be made sit in the middle of those forms; one might well as be at home, for
nobody can speak to one” (395, note 13).

4 For example, Carol Thurston in The Romance
Revolution (1987) interprets the characterization of heroine and hero in
contemporary (usually erotic) popular romance fiction to explode the old
stereotype of passive woman and masterful hero.Rather, she sees the heroine as no longer competing with other
women for the hero’s attention but focussing on her own challenges (8-9).Their relationship is equal and they have
characteristics usually ascribed to the other.The heroine is socially (and sexually) experienced, confident and
assertive; the hero is sensitive, vulnerable and open (98-99).

5 My Jane Austen Electronic Discussion group has
had some spirited discussions about the scene at the White Hart Inn and Anne’s
debate with Capt. Harville, during the Christmas and over the New Year of 1991
to 1992 and again this May.

WORKS CITED

Armstrong, Nancy and Leonard Tennenhouse,
eds.The Ideology of Conduct: Essays
on Literature and the History of Sexuality.New York: Methuen, 1987.