Well the other two were the Pioneer HDJ500(really comfortable and light) and the Sennheiser HD360 Pro(which maybe rebrads of PX360), and those were even tighter but isolated sound even better than many NC models.

I went to a different BB and was almost sold on the Harman Kardon CL line(they look and kind of feel similar to the P5), but I felt like it would leak sound a bit. There were a few other decent ones too at the same price as the Pionner, but their design are a bit loud.

Well the other two were the Pioneer HDJ500(really comfortable and light) and the Sennheiser HD360 Pro(which maybe rebrads of PX360), and those were even tighter but isolated sound even better than many NC models.

I went to a different BB and was almost sold on the Harman Kardon CL line(they look and kind of feel similar to the P5), but I felt like it would leak sound a bit. There were a few other decent ones too at the same price as the Pionner, but their design are a bit loud.

I got a pair of the AKG 451, which I thought would be different than the 591, but it has a similar darkness to it, but a bit more muffled. The bass level is about the same as the 451, but a bit fatiguing so far. As for comfort, it is about the same but without it being that tight. I am going to let it burn it more, but so far it's more the same as the 591. I think I am coming to realize I need to spend about 200 to get something more to my liking. :/

I am a new here. just wanted to enjoy my music. There is a lot of information here but its very confusing too. I was looking for over the ear closed headphones and did try Shure srh 840 and AT M50 for a few days but did not like those partly because my source is low quality and I have no amp.

After many days of painful reading and re-reading about people's biases and dispositions, I went to Magnolia and tried the handful of headphones there for myself . This Pioneer MJ 591 blew all other away including Sen 558, AT AD 900,B&W P5.and even a pair of Denon d400 there.That was both with their own set up music and with my GS3.

Of course, I am biased too but I would list the things I liked about it

Very crisp clear soound

Amazing bass and mids

lively, fast and fun

Very sensitive and easier to drive with my GS3

I am going to get it now but 299$ is a lot of money for me and I was wondering if someone could direct me to a cheaper deal online.

I also want to protest about the lack of info about this headphone on head-fi except this great thread. This forum might became hype generating media outlet if care is not taken to keep vested interests away.

I also feel that a section be dedicated to a large number of people who just casually use laptops for music and recommend to them good, fun headphones for pre recorded stuff not the studio monitors etc