I reckon Mal's list of records/achievements is superior to Joey's, however Johns is probably the more talented footballer. Personally I think Mal deserves it, and maybe his coaching career success with QLD since he retired will see him get the nod.

Then again, there seems a lot of love around for Johns, so I won't be surprised if it's him.

I reckon Mal's list of records/achievements is superior to Joey's, however Johns is probably the more talented footballer. Personally I think Mal deserves it, and maybe his coaching career success with QLD since he retired will see him get the nod.

Then again, there seems a lot of love around for Johns, so I won't be surprised if it's him.

Click to expand...

Remember C & C, it's purely based on "on field" performances, the judges were told to NOT consider anything off field, which I assume would also mean coaching

As much as it will change the idea of it, I think this is the way to go. There are a lot of people that have done stuff off the field during and after their career ended that need to also be placed in this elite group. However, I also believe that, if you are to take into account what you have done off the field, you need to have been a part of the game for over 10 years since you retired as a footballer, as well as represented the state and your team for a minimal number of games, as well as be a game changer.

You should also have been exemplary, both on the field and off. This includes not being suspended often, or being arrested on in trouble for misbehaving. Joey would not get immortal status after these changes so he'll need to get it this time, or he'll never be given it. Also, Thurston should only get it if he wins the Cowboys a premiership

Hall of fame: for players coaches staff whoever and whatever reasons you can choose to justify it.
Immortals: players only picked from the hall of fame, only those with a good off field record should be considered.