Search by Keyword

Paul McCartney greeting a fan, February 10th, 1963

“ANNA (Go To Him)”

(Arthur Alexander)

In The Beatles Anthology television show and videos, McCartney exclaimed that the Beatles thought of themselves as an “R & B combo.”This fact isn’t more noticeable than in this first cover song ever to be heard on American shores.The influence of rhythm and blues artists, such as Arthur Alexander, was immense on The Beatles, especially John Lennon whose lead vocal contributions on this song show that he was well rehearsed in capturing the intensity and warmth of the original recording.In an interview in 1987, McCartney actually goes as far as saying that in the early days, The Beatles “wanted to be like Arthur Alexander.”

On a historic level, we will also focus on the little-known fact that this song, in its’ single form, currently appears to be the rarest of all US Beatles records, reportedly fetching up to $15,000 per copy!

Arthur Alexander

Songwriting History

Arthur Alexander, who hailed from Florence, Alabama, became one of the biggest recording artists in the country-soul genre.His claim to fame on the Billboard Hot 100 was his hit, “You Better Move On”, which peaked at number 24 in April of 1962 (and was covered by The Rolling Stones).During The Beatles search for songs to perform in their “stage act”, they were keen to learn songs that no one else were doing.Hence, many flip sides of songs they admired became part of their live performances at the Cavern Club, in Hamburg and elsewhere.The flip side to “You Better Move On” was “A Shot Of Rhythm And Blues”, which The Beatles performed live on stage as well as on BBC radio.(This is available on their album “Live At The BBC.”)His next single, “Where Have You Been All My Life” failed to make the top 40, but its’ flip side, “Soldier Of Love”, was also performed by The Beatles live as well as on the BBC (also available on “Live At The BBC”).

Arthur Alexanders’ next single, the self-penned “Anna (Go To Him)” (Dot Records #16387), named after Arthur's real-life wife Ann, became a top 10 hit on the Billboard R&B charts (number 68 on the pop chart), and made a big enough impact on The Beatles, especially John Lennon, to suggest the song to be recorded on their first British album, “Please Please Me.”

Alexanders’ R&B chart career continued off-and-on for many years, but without being able to crack the Billboard top 40 again.His closest attempt was in 1975 with a remake of an earlier self-penned song, “Every Day I Have To Cry Some” released on Buddah records, which he never received any money for even though it peaked at number 45.Shortly after this, despite his repeated chart success over the years, Arthur Alexander dropped into obscurity.He had been struggling financially throughout his career and felt it was time to retire from the music business, becoming a bus driver in Cleveland, Ohio for a local social service organization.

After being tracked down by former musician friends he had recorded with in Muscle Shoals, Alabama in the 60’s, he was encouraged to make a comeback.He recorded the album “Lonely Just Like Me” in 1993, but suffered a heart attack in June of that year, three days after his performance in Nashville, Tennessee.

His legacy, although not widely known, is accented by cover versions of his material throughout the years.In 1963, Steve Alaimos’ version of his self-penned song “Every Day I Have To Cry” kept his career going through songwriting royalty payments.And being a singer/songwriter whose material has been covered by such noteworthy artists as The Rolling Stones, The Who, Esther Phillips, Joe Tex, Marshall Crenshaw, Bob Dylan, Pearl Jam, Ry Cooder, and of course The Beatles, definitely adds great credibility to his career.Even though his later career went largely unnoticed by most, respect by those who were acquainted with his work were abundant, as evidenced by John Lennon having several Arthur Alexander singles in his jukebox at the Dakota in New York City, as well as in George Harrison’s jukebox at his “Crackerbox Palace” home.

British "Please Please Me" album

Recording History

This song was also one of the ten songs recorded on that historic day of February 11th, 1963, the day chosen to produce the first Beatles album, “Please Please Me.”The third of three sessions that day (the evening session) was held between 7:30 and 10:45 p.m. at EMI Studio Two.Keep in mind that they had been recording since 10:00 that morning with only two 1½ hour breaks in between.But those weren’t even breaks for The Beatles since they asked to keep practicing while George Martin and his staff took their breaks.

Since just over two hours remained for the days’ session, The Beatles still had half an album to record.So they got to work right away, but unfortunately they were off to an unproductive start.They tried, frustratingly, to record a McCartney/Lennon song entitled “Hold Me Tight”, going through 13 takes of the song, which took up a lot of time.After many false starts, breakdowns, and edit pieces, only two complete versions were performed.It is estimated that a good 30 minutes (probably more) was wasted with this song that never did make it on the album.(It was redone for their next British album “With The Beatles”.)

With that out of the way, and the pressure on, they started work on five cover versions of songs they had been performing on stage.The first one recorded was “Anna (Go To Him), which was probably started around 8:15 p.m.Since they already had the arrangement down, they went through three complete takes of the song, the third one being deemed the best.This was a completely live performance with no overdubs or edits needed.

Both the mono and stereo mixes of the song, as well as the rest of their first album, were created on February 25th, 1965 in the control room of EMI Studio One by George Martin and engineers Norman Smith and A.B. Lincoln.

The Beatles in Borashallen, Boras, Sweden (October 28th, 1963)

Song Structure and Style

The song was written in one of the most established formulas of popular music of its time.It was written in the 'verse/ verse/ bridge/ verse' style (or aaba) which does not have a repeatable chorus.As with the original version of this song, The Beatles opted not to include a solo of any kind, which, after the last verse, allows for an immediate repeating of the bridge and final verse.In this case, it is not the title of the song that is found at the end of each verse, but the subtitle, or hook-line, which was “Go With Him.” (It’s interesting to note that Lennon always sings the subtitle as “go with him” instead of “go to him”, which is the true subtitle on the label of the Arthur Alexander record.Alexander himself sings “go with him” in his recording of the song.)

The song begins with a four bar instrumental introduction highlighted by George Harrison playing the piano riff heard on the original record (played by Floyd Cramer) very convincingly on his electric guitar while Ringo plays a drum rhythm not unlike the one heard two years later on “Ticket To Ride.”Note the squeaky bass drum pedal which can be especially heard during the songs’ introduction, although it can be detected throughout the song.George Martin, when interviewed in 1987 with the album’s first CD release, related that if he would have realized how closely scrutinized this album would have been so many years later, he would have done something about the squeaky drum pedal.

The Beatles give careful detail to the most intricate characteristics of the song, which shows how rehearsed and “fresh in their minds” the song was.Lennon’s vocal style is his precise interpretation of the original, as Arthur Alexander was known as one of his favorite singers.Note the pronunciation of certain words, which turns, for instance, “more” into “mo”, as Lennon continued to be inspired to sing throughout the next couple of years (evidenced in “I Should Have Known Better”, “When I Get Home” and “No Reply”).

Note also the lyrical phrasing of the word “girl” which habitually appears at the end of many lines.Lennon, by inspiration, copies this style in his songwriting as well (evidenced in “Please Please Me” and “Thank You Girl”).As the first verse ends, we hear George and Paul copy the intricately hushed backing vocals, giving more evidence of precise detail.As the climactic bridge begins, the background vocals harmonize, sometimes slightly off key, while Lennon excitingly tackles the emotion of the lyrics that depict supreme self-pity, which reflect his life experience with romance.This he is also inspired to continue in his future songwriting, for instance, in “I’ll Cry Instead” and “I’m A Loser.”He then concludes this emotive bridge with his catch-in-the-throat “oh-oh-oh-oh’s” escalading downward to the last verse, which lyrically finalizes the relationship with the “give back your ring” line and the evidence of conceding to the other guy.The emotional punch of these lyrics, as well as the convincing delivery of The Beatles, brings this R&B standard to an audience who otherwise would have never experienced it.

It’s important to note once again that this was a live recording, just as they had rehearsed, with no edits or overdubs.One can only imagine the impact a performance of this caliber would have on a live audience at the Cavern Club in Liverpool, which would make this band stand head-and-shoulders above the other “beat” group competition floating around the clubs in the early sixties.And since the original was released in September of 1962, not all that much time had transpired to allow them to perfect the song in this way and to make it their own.This shows the dedication The Beatles had when they felt strongly enough about a good song.

The test of a good song is also when you can retain the melody in your memory after its’ being heard.This is the case with “Anna”, as evidenced in the television show “Married…With Children.”A classic episode of this show, “Oldies But Young’uns”, shows character Al Bundy with this song “stuck in his head,” but not being able to remember the words.

American Releases

The first US appearance of the song “Anna” was on the album “Introducing…The Beatles” when it was finally released on January 10th, 1964. The second US appearance was on the Vee Jay EP, “The Beatles – Souvenir of Their Visit To America,” which was released on March 23rd, 1964 in celebration of their first US visit in February. Both of these releases, in their original form, are quite the collectors’ items today.

The second release of "Anna" appeared in the abortive intention of Vee Jay featuring the song as a single. They printed a limited edition of test copies of a disc jockey promotional single pairing "Anna" with “Ask Me Why” (VJDJ #8). Being that Vee Jay records had been primarily a black label, they may have been impressed enough with The Beatles’ rendition of this rhythm and blues classic to feature it as a single. The numbers etched in the trail-off area of the single pre-dates the February release of their single “Twist And Shout,” so we can easily date the printing of these promotional singles in February of 1964. Vee Jay apparently decided to scrap this idea and instead release “Twist And Shout” as a single instead, possibly with the knowledge that this song was to be featured on the February 23rd Ed Sullivan Show.

An interesting note concerning this DJ single is that there are so far only four copies found to be in existence. The highest offer made for any of these copies was $15,000 (which wasn’t accepted). This makes the Vee Jay promotional single of “Anna/Ask Me Why” currently the rarest of all US Beatles records.

The fourth US appearance of the song came with the Vee Jay double-compilation album “The Beatles vs. The Four Seasons”, released on October 1st, 1964, which coupled The Beatles album with “The Golden Hits of the Four Seasons”. The fifth appearance came less than two weeks later with another repackage of the Vee Jay album under the name “Songs, Pictures And Stories Of The Fabulous Beatles”, released on October 12th, 1964. Since Vee Jay records closed their doors in May 1966, legitimate copies of both these albums also bring high price tags for collectors.

The sixth US appearance of the song then takes us to March 22nd, 1965, when Capitol records turned its’ attention to the early Beatles catalog with their release, “The Early Beatles.” Being a part of this collection ensured that “Anna (Go To Him)” would be available to all Beatles fans to this day and beyond. Interestingly, Capitol didn’t utilize the mono mix for the mono version of this disc but instead created their own “type B” mono mix by combining both channels of the stereo mix. Therefore, the superior mono mix created by George Martin on February 25th, 1963 was not available in America for a long time. This album then appeared on an individual CD on January 21st, 2014, this CD containing both the mono and stereo mixes on one disc.

On February 26th, 1987, however, the original British "Please Please Me" album, containing “Anna,” was released on compact disc for the first time. This CD was only available in mono at the time of release and gratefully contained the excellent George Martin mono mix from early 1963. The CD was then re-mastered in stereo and was released on September 9th, 2009, restoring the original stereo mix of the song.

Capitol released the box set “Compact Disc EP Collection” on June 30th, 1992 which contained “Anna” due to its inclusion on the original British EP “Beatles No. 1.”

On April 11th, 2006, the box set “The Capitol Albums, Volume 2” was released which contains all four Beatles albums released in 1965 in both stereo and mono. “The Early Beatles” was therefore contained in this set, including the song “Anna.”

The song was also included in a box set entitled “The Beatles In Mono,” which was released on September 9th, 2009 and contained the entire EMI Beatles catalog in its original mono state.

On November 11th, 2013, the album "On Air - Live At The BBC Volume 2" was released which features an unheard and interesting version of "Anna" as recorded on August 1st, 1963 for the radio program "Pop Go The Beatles." This recording shows how the song became more comfortable for the group as time progressed, John's vocal delivery being near-flawless and Paul's bass work, very clear in this recording, being performed beautifully...not to mention the absence of the squeaky drum pedal!

Also released around this date was a fourteen-track sampler of the above album for promotional purposes, "Anna" being included therein.

The Beatles in Birkenhead, December 15h, 1962

Live Performances

The Beatles discovered "Anna" in December of 1962 while filing through new releases at Brian Epstein's "NEMS" record department. They quickly worked up an arrangement to compensate for the instruments used on the original, the piano parts being played on guitar and the string section of the bridge being replaced by Paul and George singing a sustained "aaah."

The song was not only a favorite of John's but of George's as well, fans sending up requests to the stage that read: "Please sing 'Anna' for George.'" They loved playing the song live and did so exhaustively between December, 1962 and January, 1963, locally and during their final Hamburg trip at the end of 1962. Therefore, they knew the song very well by the time the February recording date at EMI Studios came along.However, the song was performed only sparingly after this time, as it was not included in any of their national British tours of 1963 and thereafter ceased from their set lists. They prefered to perform other tracks from their first album, such as "Misery" and "Baby It's You," as late as June of 1963, as well as the non-recorded track "Some Other Guy."

The song was performed on BBC radio twice, first on the BBC show “Pop Go The Beatles”, which was recorded on June 17th, 1963, but not aired until June 25th.The second BBC appearance, also on the show “Pop Go The Beatles”, was taped on August 1st, 1963 and aired on August 27th. This was the final performance of the song by The Beatles.

Conclusion

The music of Arthur Alexander, it is claimed, shaped the British Invasion of 1964.This is suggested because of his music being covered by The Rolling Stones and The Beatles during the early stages of their careers.Both bands have also acknowledged through the years that the country/R&B style of his music greatly influenced theirs.This is evidenced by the information above which, despite having a particularly heavy cold that day, John Lennon gives the vocal performance of his life.Second only to “Twist And Shout”, which was also recorded that day, this was arguably Lennon’s best vocal performance on the album.

The sheer exuberance of the performance by the band (not just Lennon) shows the great respect they had for the song, which drove them to adapt musically to the original as well as mimic vocally as best as they could.Upon listening, you could tell that they took the task of recording this song very seriously, which was an excellent counterpoint to the previous lighthearted song, “Misery.”“Anna (Go To Him)” by The Beatles, therefore, goes down in recording history as a testament to a great, but highly unnoticed, rhythm and blues singer/songwriter, Arthur Alexander.