Both women were show-stoppers at the hotdog stand, but there can only be one winner in this American Pie Style Showdown. Who rocked their dress best: Mena or Tara? Cast your vote in the poll and leave a few reviews in the comments.

The gals were joined by their male costars Chris Klein, Sean William Scott, Jason Biggs and Eugene Levy. The latest American Pie installment follows the cast as they return to their hometown for their high school reunion. It’s set to hit theaters in the states on April 6, 2012.

Check out the trailer below to determine if you’ll be catching this movie. (Note: Watch at your own risk. It’s NSFW.)