Amerisleep vs. Tuft & Needle Mattress Reviews

Sleeping on a high-quality mattress helps you clock the 7 to 9 hours of shut-eye you need each night. When your bed is interfering with your quality of sleep, you know it’s time for an upgrade. However, choosing the best mattress to enhance your sleep can be tricky in itself. Are you a better fit for a foam bed, or one with springs?

When first starting your search, you’ll see the mattress industry has a vast amount of beds to consider. Beyond reading mattress comparisons and weighing the features of varying beds, it’s pertinent you think about your body type and sleeping style while narrowing down your options, also. Back sleepers, stomach sleepers, and side sleepers all require a different type of support, and what may be comfortable for one sleeper is a nightmare for another.

In this post, we discuss two major mattress brands, Tuft & Needle and Amerisleep, to help you learn more about their options and determine if they sell the right mattress for your needs.

Amerisleep Mattresses

Amerisleep entered the mattress market in 2007. From the beginning, they’ve understood that each sleeper has unique comfort needs. That is reflected in their five luxury models that appeal to sleepers with different sleep styles. Luxury mattresses have high-quality materials in the interior layers. They also have intricate stitching and high-quality fabrics in the covers. Amerisleep uses technologies like Bio-Pur® and HIVE® to increase comfort and breathability.

They don’t stop at mattresses. Amerisleep also sells foundations and adjustable bases along with a line of pillows and bedding. They have their own brick and mortar stores. However, most of their mattresses are ordered online. Amerisleep then delivers beds straight to your doorstep— if you’re looking for the best mattress in a box, Amerisleep should definitely be considered.

Amerisleep models include:

Amerisleep AS1: This two-layer model is also Amerisleep’s most basic design. It’s firm with a support level that targets stomach and back sleepers and those who prefer extra support.

Amerisleep AS2: The AS2 is a medium-firm model and Amerisleep’s best mattress for back pain. It has a slightly softer feel than the AS1, and an Affinity layer with HIVE® technology to provide zoned support for the hips and shoulders.

Amerisleep AS3: Amerisleep’s most popular model, and our pick for one of the best mattresses, balances support with conformability in a medium feel mattress. A thicker top layer than the AS2 appeals to people with a wide range of sleep positions. Like the AS2, it offers zoned comfort at the hips and shoulders.

Amerisleep AS4: This medium-soft mattress comes with a thick top layer that cradles the body. Yet, a thin Affinity layer targets the pressure points at the shoulders and hips for side, back, and combo sleepers.

Amerisleep AS5: The softest and only four-layer Amerisleep model has an extra Active Flex layer. Active Flex improves the responsiveness of the thick foam layers, so you don’t feel stuck in the mattress. The AS5 Amerisleep’s best mattress for heavy sleepers because it includes this extra layer of responsive foam.

Amerisleep’s Materials, Cover, and Construction

The AS1 is the firmest Amerisleep mattress. Its single two-inch comfort layer is made of an advanced open-cell foam called Bio-Pur®. Open-cell foams allow air to move and flow away from the body. Bio-Pur® is five times more breathable than traditional memory foam. Its advanced breathability keeps you cool without weakening the structure of the mattress. A dense Bio-Core® poly-foam support layer keeps the spine aligned.

The AS2 also has a two-inch Bio-Pur® comfort layer. An added three-inch Affinity layer with HIVE® technology (Harnessing Intelligent Ventilation & Energy) conforms to the body and promotes airflow. HIVE® has hexagonal cutouts that create channels for improved breathability. However, the cutouts also provide zoned comfort. The hexagons are closely packed together under the head, back, and feet for added support. At the shoulders and hips, they’re spaced farther apart for better pressure relief.

The popular AS3 is a medium feel mattress with a balance between support and pressure relief. A three-inch Bio-Pur® layer conforms to the body. The Affinity layer enhances breathability and improves pressure relief for all sleep positions. It’s Amerisleep’s best mattress for side sleepers and a good choice for couples where partners differ in size or sleep styles.

If you’re looking for a soft mattress, the AS4 is right up your alley. A thick, four-inch Bio-Pur® comfort layer gives the AS4 a cloud-like feel. Yet, its thin one-inch Affinity layer still provides zoned support. Like the other models, it has the Bio-Core® support layer to keep the spine aligned. This model works well for side and back sleepers as well as those who like to sink into the mattress.

The AS5 is the softest and only four-layer mattress in Amerisleep’s lineup. A four-inch Bio-Pur® layer is supported by a two-inch Active Flex layer. Active Flex improves the reactiveness of the foam. You sink into the mattress but don’t get stuck in its softness. It also has a two-inch Affinity layer for zoned support and a Bio-Core® support layer to keep the spine aligned.

Amerisleep’s Cooling Technology and Temperature Regulation

Amerisleep’s lightweight cover, Bio-Pur®, and HIVE® technology work together to move heat away from the body. Amerisleep mattresses have good support and prevent sinkage so there’s less likelihood of heat build-up. All of their mattresses, even the soft ones, generally have average to above-average breathability.

Amerisleep Mattresses’ Support, Conformity, and Motion Isolation

Amerisleep’s wide range of support and conformability options appeal to an equally wide range of sleepers. Each Amerisleep model offers outstanding conformability and motion isolation.

The AS4 and AS5 have the most conformability for side and combo sleepers who like to sink into the mattress. The AS1 and AS2 have thinner top layers, which still cushion the body but have conformability and support that’s more comfortable for stomach and back sleepers. The AS3 strikes a balance between support and conformability, appealing to many people of all sleep positions.

Amerisleep’s memory foam mattresses have average edge support, so there’s some sinkage if you sit on the edge of the bed to put on your socks and shoes.

Are Amerisleep Mattresses Durable?

High-quality materials, a dense Bio-Core® support layer, and solid manufacturing processes give Amerisleep mattresses impressive durability. Amerisleep has a 20-year warranty that covers indentations over three-quarters of an inch and offers protection for any unexpected defects or breakdown of the foams. These mattresses generally last well beyond the average mattress lifespan of seven to eight years.

Amerisleep’s Trial Period, Warranty, and Return Policies

Amerisleep has a 100-day sleep trial. They recommend sleeping on the mattress for 30 days before returning it. However, the mattress can be returned at any time during the trial period. Amerisleep takes care of all the return packing and shipping, including the cost.

Amerisleep mattresses have a 20-year, prorated warranty that’s broken into two parts. In the first ten years, the company will replace or repair defective workmanship or materials at no cost to the consumer. Indentations over three-quarters of an inch that are not due to an improper foundation are covered under the warranty. There’s a detailed list in the warranty of what counts as a defect, but it does not include tears, stains, or burns.

In the last ten years of the warranty, the replacement is prorated, and the mattress will be replaced at 50 percent of the original purchase price. The mattress must be kept on an appropriate foundation or base as defined in the warranty.

The warranty only applies to the original owner with proof of purchase.

Amerisleep’s Social Responsibility

Amerisleep mattresses are made in the United States. The company uses recyclable packaging and eco-friendly manufacturing processes. When at all possible, they also work with local charities to donate returned mattresses to those in need.

Who Are Amerisleep Mattresses For?

Amerisleep provides mattresses with varying firmnesses, support, and conformability, allowing sleepers to find a model that fits with their sleep style and personal preferences. The AS1 and AS2 have the support for stomach and back sleepers. They’re also ideal for those who need extra support. The AS4 and AS5 are softer for side sleepers and those who like to sink into their mattresses. The AS3 is the comfortable middle that works for people of all sleep positions, including couples who have different sleep positions or preferences.

Tuft & Needle Mattresses

Tuft & Needle entered the market in 2012 with a single model. They merged with Serta Simmons Bedding in 2018 and now offer three models. Tuft & Needle uses unique technology like graphite-infused foam to improve sleeper comfort.

Tuft & Needle operates their own brick and mortar stores, and their mattresses are carried in several retailers nationwide. However, their mattresses can be ordered and delivered bed-in-a-box style to your front door. Mattresses aren’t the only Tuft & Needle product you’ll find in stores and online. They also carry a long line of bedding and sleep-related furniture like an adjustable frame and box foundation. The Tuft & Needle models include:

The Tuft & Needle Original Mattress: This medium-firm, two-layer mattress has a gel and graphite-infused comfort layer and high-density support core.

Tuft & Needle Mint: The Mint has the same gel and graphite-infused foam comfort layer but with extra graphite. It also has an added transition layer to give it extra height, support, and temperature regulation.

The Hybrid: T&N’s newest mattress, The Hybrid, combines their proprietary T&N Adaptive® foam with a pocketed coil system to deliver conforming, but bouncy, support. If you prefer the feel of an innerspring but want the foam layers for added comfort, their hybrid mattresses is likely your best bet.

Tuft & Needle’s Materials, Cover, and Construction

Tuft & Needle’s covers are made of polyester and polyamide. They’re flexible and breathable but not removable. They should be spot-cleaned only.

The Tuft & Needle Original is a two-layer mattress with a three-inch comfort layer. You can’t have a Tuft & Needle mattress review without talking about charcoal. This top layer is made of T&N (Tuft & Needle) Adaptive® foam. That means it’s infused with both gel beads and graphite. The graphite absorbs heat and vents it through the sides of the mattress. The gel acts as a cooling agent. T&N Adaptive® foam has an open-cell structure to let air pass through while still supporting the body. The seven-inch support core is made of high-density poly-foam. This medium-firm mattress appeals to sleepers of many weights and sleep styles.

The Tuft & Needle Mint is a medium-firm mattress with three layers. The three-inch top layer is made of T&N Adaptive® foam, but it has 30 percent more graphite than the Original. This layer also has gel beads to help cushion and cool the body. A two-inch poly-foam transition layer adds extra support and durability. It rests atop a seven-inch high-density poly-foam support core. The added layer gives it qualities the Original lacks such as more support, conformability, and durability.

T&N’s The Hybrid mattress has a plush pillow top and two layers inside; all in all, it has a medium to medium-firm feel. The top layer is graphite and ceramic gel-infused foam designed to cool you down and prevent night sweats. T&N also infuses carbon fiber into this foam to prevent the foam from breaking down or losing its comfort. The second and final layer of The Hybrid is a pocketed coil system in place to provide targeted support and improve the bed’s responsiveness. These coils prevent motion transfer since they’re pocketed, and they also give this bed a bit of edge support, so you won’t have to worry about rolling off the side.

Tuft & Needle’s Cooling Technology and Temperature Regulation

T&N Adaptive® foam is a poly-foam with better breathability than traditional memory foams. The charcoal and gel content help keep air moving. The Mint’s increased charcoal level along with the transition layer boosts its temperature regulation and breathability over the Original. The Original has average temperature regulation while the Mint performs above average.

T&N’s new hybrid mattress is ideal for hot sleepers because it’s more breathable than their other foam beds. The gaps within the coils of this bed’s pocketed coil system boost airflow and prevent heat retention. Plus, the top layer of foam in their hybrid mattress is infused with the same cooling charcoal found in T&N’s other models.

Tuft & Needle’s Support, Conformity, and Motion Isolation

The Original is a medium-firm mattress with good support, especially for light and average-weight side and back sleepers. Poly-foam, like that used in the Original, doesn’t conform as much as a memory foam mattress. For side sleepers, that could mean less pressure relief at the shoulders and hips. On the other hand, stomach sleepers are more likely to keep their spine aligned on its firmer, less conforming surface. It’s more like sleeping on top of rather than in the mattress.

The Mint’s extra transition layer helps it conform to body curves better than the Original. It has good support that works well for side and back sleepers. Stomach sleepers may find their hips sink too much into this model.

The Mint has a reinforced edge for better edge support than your average poly-foam mattress. The Original, however, performs about average for edge support. Both mattresses reduce motion transfer so couples get a quieter night’s rest.

T&N’s hybrid mattress offers great support and conformity due to its use of their proprietary adaptive foams. Plus, because it contains coils, this bed offers better targeted support than their other models. Side, back, and stomach sleepers should all sleep comfortably on The Hybrid, but it may feel too firm for some side sleepers (depending upon personal preference). Despite the hybrid feeling bouncier than T&N’s all-foam models, this bed still isolates motion quite well because they use pocketed coils rather than a connected coil system. These pocketed coils move independently of one another and adjust to your movement to keep you sleeping comfortably and supported.

Are Tuft & Needle Mattresses Durable?

All three of Tuft & Needle’s mattresses are made with quality materials and sound manufacturing processes. Their high-density foams follow the normal wear and tear trends for similar all-foam mattresses. They reinforce their hybrid with carbon fiber foam and steel springs to prevent premature deterioration. They come with a ten-year warranty that covers indentations over three-quarters of an inch. The combination of materials and warranty suggests that their mattresses will last for an average of seven to eight years. We do expect their hybrid to hold up longer and possibly last a whole decade.

Tuft & Needle’s Trial Period, Warranty, and Return Policies

Tuft & Needle has a 100-day trial period. The mattress can be returned for a full refund at no cost to you at any time during that period. Returned mattresses are donated to those in need.

They offer a ten-year limited warranty. The warranty covers any defects in the materials or manufacturing, including cracks in the foam and indentations over three-quarters of an inch. The warranty only applies with proof of purchase by the original owner. Tuft & Needle will repair or replace any defective parts or components.

Normal wear and tear such as tears or stains are not covered under warranty. The warranty also does not apply if the mattress is not kept on the appropriate foundation as outlined by the warranty.

Tuft & Needle’s Social Responsibility

Tuft & Needle partners with schools by offering 25 percent of proceeds for every mattress bought by parents, teachers, families, and friends of a participating school. They also partner with various non-profit organizations to donate returned mattresses to those in need. This company also organizes employee service projects in their local communities.

Who Are Tuft & Needle Mattresses For?

The Tuft & Needle Original mattress is a comfortable, budget-friendly option. It’s a medium-firm mattress that can work for all sleep positions. This model also offers pressure relief without the sleeper sinking into the surface. However, its support better fits light and average-weight sleepers. The Tuft & Needle Mint has more conformability than the Original but may not have enough support for stomach or heavier sleepers. Both mattresses have responsive foams that won’t leave you feeling stuck. T&N’s hybrid model is best suited for particularly hot sleepers who need more breathability from their bed as well as those who prefer a bouncier mattress. It should comfortably support all sleep styles, as well as light and heavyweight sleepers, but may feel firmer to more petite individuals.