Michelle Pfeiffer made us do quite the double take when she walked the red carpet at the New York premiere for the HBO original film The Wizard of Lies. In addition to having flawless hair and makeup, Pfeiffer looked exactly like she did the first time she starred opposite Robert De Niro, in Stardust — only that was 10 years ago!

Good genes and careful diet, or just an amazing dermatologist? Whatever her secret, Pfeiffer is far from alone. Hollywood is filled with stars who have found ways to defy age (and gravity) to remain as youthful and vibrant as they were a decade ago.