Russian surgeons ready to make face transplants more accessible

The Russian Health Ministry will expand the list of transplantable body parts. This will enable face transplant surgery with the vessels from a deceased person.

Russian surgeons
have stated more than once that they are ready to perform face transplants. In
particular, a group of doctors and scientists from St. Petersburg Medical
University has been developing a technique for this type of operation on
corpses. In 2012 surgeons from the Burn Center of Krasnodar Territory
transplanted skin in a single fragment onto a two-year-old child with a
complete face burn. Before that, similar operations were carried out only by
sewing together separate parts of the face.

Putting the face
transplant "on stream," surgeons say, was impossible because of
current Russian legislation, such as a bill regulating human organs and tissue
transplants that permits only one kind of tissue implantation.

Face transplant
surgeries, however, gives the patient a complete new face from the donor, including
the nose, tongue and ears. Legally, there has been no way to bypass this
juridical case. This is why Russian surgeons have been practicing on silicon
models with exact copies of muscles, nerves and facial surfaces.

Surgeons need new laws

Having raised
the issue of changing the legislation, surgeons say that the process of
collecting facial tissues from the donor and its transplant is in itself a
complicated process. The imperfection of the legislation and the Russian mindset
only makes matters more complex.

According to doctors the challenge of creating
a donor service is immense as few Russian citizens are willing to "give"
their face to another person. A Levada Center survey shows that about 50
percent of Russians are against donating their organs for transplant surgery.

Approximately
1,500 transplant operations are carried out in Russia annually. By comparison
in the U.S. there are roughly 20,000 such surgeries every year with 15 to 20
donors for every one million people in Europe and the U.S. Spain has the
highest percentage with 28 to 35 donors for every million people, whereas in
Russia that figure is only 2.9 for every million people.

"Currently,
doctors can transplant organs if there is no official refusal from the
relatives of the potential face donor or from the donor himself," says
plastic surgeon Georgy Abovyan. "This is the last loophole in the
legislation."

Dmitri Davydov, a
professor, surgeon and the author of several methods of maxillofacial surgery,
believes that the Russian health system is still not ready to put face
transplants "on stream."

"The
problem is much more serious," Davydov remarks. "There are several
parts to it, including the juridical aspect, the agreement period, the
rehabilitation.” He also said that the operation itself depends greatly on the
surgeon and their team.

“Every specialist wants to demonstrate his
professionalism and transplant a face,” he says. “In this sense I understand my
colleagues. But there is also a period of acclimatization, because the donor's
skin has a different genetic code."

In Davydov's
words, after an operation it is important to suppress the patient's immune
system. This involves daily medical treatment, which can cost between 400,000
and 500,000 rubles a month ($10,000-13,000). Davydov thinks that Russia's
healthcare system is currently unable to absorb such costs, since drugs,
patient care and rehabilitation are very expensive.

A constitution for transplant surgery

For some time
Deputy Prime Minister Olga Golodets has focused her attention on the complex
issue of organ transplants. She saw that cancer patients were obliged to travel
abroad for bone marrow transplants because Russia simply does not have enough
donors.

The Health
Ministry has already prepared an aptly named document that has been referred to
as the Transplant Constitution, which seeks to regulate the process of donating
human organs for transplant surgery.

This document should be approved by the
end of 2014 and will likely come into effect on January 1, 2016. The amendments
to the law included in the Constitution will make it easier for Russians to
donate their body parts for transplant surgery.

After the law
comes into effect Russia will have a single database for all types of
transplants. This database will store Russian citizens’ declarations of
intentions, a list of living and deceased donors, the names of recipients and
the index of organs. Children who are at least a year old will be able to
become donors, although this would happen posthumously and only with the
consent of their parents.

"The Duma is
already considering a law from the government regulating transplant surgeries
involving donors' organs and tissues," says Sergei Kalashnikov, the President
of the Duma Health Committee. "The numerous problems facing the country
will be solved in the immediate years after the law takes effect."

The Russian
Health Ministry is also working to make face transplants legal and has issued a
decree that will regulate human tissue and make it easier to transplant a face
with vessels from a deceased person onto a living patient. This will open new
opportunities for face transplant surgery in Russia.