1417, instead of name-calling and bad mouthing what you call "liberals", had you taken the time to check you would see that the majority siding with this ruling were Republican nominees including Justices Alito, Thomas, Chief Justice Roberts, and Kennedy with the Court's majority being set by Democratic nominee Breyer.

The dissenters were Democratic nominees, Justices Sotomayor, Kagan and Ginsburg joined by Republican nominee Scalia.