As much as i hate eli I have to put him in the top 5 qbs, and idc wat ppl want to knock against big ben, he doesnt crack under pressure. As for Peyton, nobody in the NFL can read a defense like him, he picks defenses apart and considering he really only has Reggie Wayne and Dallas Clark from his old receiving corp. He makes every1 on the O into stars

^^
ur list is good except for ben
and eli should be 2 or 3
brady isnt as good as he use to be
ben only does good cause his O line gives him soo much time
when theres a good d-fence on him then he wont do shit

Errand boy shouldn't even be on anyone's top 5. That guy flopped. Heck I'll put that grandpa who plays for Viking in the top 5. Eli Manning should be on everybodies list let's see what happens when he no longer exist.

Winning in the clutch is the ultimate test of who is the best. Brees is dope but hasn't proven anything yet. The other guys have won consistently throughout their careers and its too early to say Eli is better than Peyton.

Winning in the clutch is the ultimate test of who is the best. Brees is dope but hasn't proven anything yet. The other guys have won consistently throughout their careers and its too early to say Eli is better than Peyton.

wojo is correct, Peyton has a lot of knowledge about the game and can read and pick defenses in his sleep. That's what makes him so lethal, give him any WR corp in the NFL and he can make them into pro-bowlers easily.