5 Stars – BEST EYELINER PENCIL I’VE EVER USED – “Just love this eyeliner pencil. Somehow it sits perfectly in the balance between ‘too soft and smudgy’ and ‘too hard and hurts your lids.’ Also, the color is very nice too, being the perfect shade of deep blue. I’ll never buy another lining pencil at the cosmetics counter.” ~User: VintageRoze from West Texas, Age: 45-54

5 Stars – EXCELLENT SMUDGER – “Love this eyeliner. It smudges nicely and wears all day. Can apply it along the wet-line to make a dramatic smokey eye. Love the little smudging tool at the end of the pencil.” ~User: MargaritaMartiniDiva from Northern California, Age: 35-44