If this is your first visit, be sure to
check out the FAQ by clicking the
link above. You may have to register
before you can post: click the register link above to proceed. To start viewing messages,
select the forum that you want to visit from the selection below.

Only GK and Full Backs have fixed positions in todays modern football, others are (and rightly so) rotating.
Since none of them is a Maradona, or Platini, or Vafaseya, I say BOTH are needed for rotation and no one a guaranteed spot!

Ehsan Hajsafi because of his versatility and 10 years of experience he has in Team Melli under 3 different eras (Daei, Ghotbi, and Queiroz).

Vahid Amiri is great too don’t get me wrong. He is a mature football player with good awareness, vision, better dribbling technique than Hajsafi. Amiri is a team player. He uses his chances wisely. For example in the away WCQ vs Syria he made a few smart decisions when passing and holding possession to open and confuse the Syrian team.

The point is, they’re both good but they’re also two different type of players. I choose Hajsafi though.

I'm not so sure about that! Haji Safi has always been the victim of our left back problem and never really got to play in his own position (LW/LAM). Once upon a time, he was Iran's best player in his correct position. I remember some years ago, he was PGL's best player all together. Amiri has never had that honor.

Having said that both of them have become much slower now which means versatility plays a more important role so even in that department Haji Safi is ahead.