Oh geez. Yeah, there is absolutely no reason he should have even been on the show. Seriously you guys, if it's looks you want then watch Top Model or something. This is for people who sing well, not people who sing okay but are considered "cute" by girls under the age of 19. You're turning what should be a talent competition into a Gum Ball Machine Warehouse. It's ridiculous. And so what if he plays guitar. I play guitar, better than he does from what I've seen, but I'm not on the show. Casey James would wipe the floor with him when it comes to playing guitar, but this is a SINGING competition. Just because we have the technology to make anyone sound good doesn't mean we should ignore the fact that some people aren't very good.

It might have been unfair for Tim to leave this week, but I believe he just left* at the rightest moment! He left with glory. And for all those who hate him and think he's got no talent, well, what can I say, I'm sorry for you! I live in another continent and I follow American Idol every single week, I wish I could vote for Tim. He takes criticism like a man, he doesn't make stupid faces for the camera, he always smiles and never complains. These are the characteristics of a true "Idol". I guess I should thank America for voting him off, becuase they just saved him from the corruption that befalls almost every hollywood celebrity. Now he can have a normal life without the temporary flicker of "fame". I'm so proud of him!GO TIM!

It might have been unfair for Tim to leave this week, but I believe he just leaved at the rightest moment! He left with glory. And for all those who hate him and think he's got no talent, well, what can I say, I'm sorry for you! I live in another continent and I follow American Idol every single week, I wish I could vote for Tim. He takes criticism like a man, he doesn't make stupid faces for the camera, he always smiles and never complains. These are the characteristics of a true "Idol". I guess I should thank America for voting him off, becuase they just saved him from the corruption that befalls almost every hollywood celebrity. Now he can have a normal life without the temporary flicker of "fame". I'm so proud of him!GO TIM!

How could you all hate a person that you do not even know? Imagine if Tim was your brother or friend. Imagine if he was you. He is a good person, and has done nothing bad to deserve all of this hate. The people who vote for Tim have every right to vote for him, just as eveyone else has the right to vote for whomever they want. He is a really great person. I know him personally. He was chosen to be part of American Idol, because he is good. I just can't believe all the hate that you give to this one person. People who make it big without American Idol, who are not necessarily great, don't get hated like this. I wish you could see him as a person. Please don't hate people you don't know. That is the most important thing to learn. Whoever wins American Idol, I'm not going to hate them just because I didn't vote for them, or because I wanted someone else to win. But for you haters, you've gotten your wish. Tim has been voted off Idol, but I know that for all those who admire him, he will return with a great following. It's actually good that he leaves right now, so people won't hate him anymore. Please, I'm begging you, not to hate people. Thank you.

omgg ik well i dont know tim personlly (I WISH I DID) <3 well i really loved him and i voted soooooooo much and he was great and i really think every1 hated him b.c they were jealousss of his looks......tim shoul never be downn well ILOVE TIM<33333333 nd i cried 4 three hours wen he got kicked offff..soo yeahh..i agree with everything u said <333 :) TIM<3

Hold onto your hats, haters! TIM URBAN is going to slide into FIRST PLACE on American Ido this year and I say, RIGHT ON TIM!!! He is super cute and super talented in ways that ya don't see these days. OMG!!! HE is Soooo CUTE!!!!

He sings very good too, and I hope he makes loads of records!!!! GOD BLESS YOU - all you haters - why can't you be LOVERS? Your hatred will boomerang against you and you will eat mud!! HA HA HAA!!!

Those of you who LOVE Tim Urban --- you are going to inherit the Earth, all the good parts only!!!! BIG KARMA's in there for you and TIM URBAN!!!!

I'm really starting to think that The competition is arranged to he win,, i mean is a pity for Lee, Crystal and Siobhan because they are worth if,, but this looks like, he will never go home and, really good people are going out because of him... this suckssss... and i tired to say that he is a talentless person for be a singer ,but now even Simon says that he's good after weeks saying that he practically suckkks.. i'm really disappointed with this season is the worst that i seen,, Lee, Crystal and Siobhan are the only thing worth right there.... is a shame because the show it was really good in every season

Ok, let's get real. Tim doesn't suck. He wouldn't still be on the show if he did. But he just isn't in the same calibre as some of the others. He just have a huge fan base to keep voting him back every week. I'm sure a huge part of it is his looks and age.

Oh my god! Tim Urban sucks so incredibly hard. Talented people are going home while this no talented waste takes up valuable space. Yeah sure he may be a nice guy and good looking but this competition is about SINGING!!!!! And he just flat out sucks. He basically sings the same song every week. He has no range what soever. I get so fricken pissed every week because I think, there is just no fricken way that they can possibly vote to keep this little sh*t here again! And I am dissapointed every time. To all you voters, get your heads out of your butt so you can hear how bad he is!

ok wow...Tim does not suck retards! If he did he wouldn't be there still! No talented person went home yet and if you think that, well then your more retarted then I thought! Don't go flip out over nothing u haters! I love Crystal and know she will win. I'm not a big fan of Lee but I'm sure he will do well! Hopefully my Tim Tim will get high up there! I have heard him when hes not on american with his own original songs and their amazing! So suck it up you tards! Hope American isn't ruined by these STUPID NO TALENT SH*tS!!!!

to you Americans who voted for Tim Urban the asshole, you are a shame to your race!! you are just proving to the world that Americans are shallow and stupid and superficial and vote only for stupid looks and nothing else..YOU STUPID AMERICANS!

Okay, sure, Urban is hot and all, but he has absolutely no vocal talent!!!!! I can't believe poor katie went home over him!!!!! I wish all of these lovesick 12 year olds would stop voting so the competition can just remain about talent!!!!! He knows he has no business in the top 7!!! He knows he should just count it all as luck, and if America gets back to voting for talent, his days should be numbered.

tim is fucking adorable. he isn't the best on the show and i highly doubt he'll win the entire compettition but he DOES have talent, and most likely a lot more than any of u insensitive assholes that keep bashing him. yeah, he's good looking, but u probably keep bringing that up because YOU'RE UGLY AS FUCK.

there are people with better voices than tim on idol, but i'm sure he knows that. he's a really good guitar player though and there are people on the radio right now with worse voices than him. did anyone else notice that adam lambert's performance tonight was very overdramatic and a bit off-key at points? tim isn't an AMAZING vocalist but he's good. he doesn't make my ears bleed. he's genuine. especially his last performance. also, when he sung that song "come on get higher" he could be played on the radio or in coffee shops..i'd pay to go see him AND listen to him. just because he's not the best doesn't mean he's not talented. and who are u to say he doesn't deserve to be there? he works hard and he's under a ton of pressure..i'd like to see one of u up there singing for ur life every week in front of half the world..jesus..

he just simplely sucks... he doesn't have any talent and his voice is horrific like Simon saids and i totally agree with the people who say that he don't deserve the chance to be on idol.. first at all he didn't deserve to go in the first night but just because he don't even deserve to be in the competition the judges was good when they leave him out to the top 24... and finally he really SUCCKKKKKKKKKS !!!!!!!!!!!!!

WHY IN THE WORLD DID TIM URBAN BACAME "GOOD" YOU HEARD SIMON IN THE APOLOGIZE SONG TIM SANG "WE WERE RIGHT TO KEEP YOU OFF THE TOP 24"THEN RANDY SAID TO TIM IN THE UNDER MY THUMB THAT IT WAS COMPLETELY "DULL"AND ALL OF THEM COMPLETELY AGREE THAT HE NEEDS SINGING LESSONS AND HE KEEPS OFF THE GOOD ONES LIKE JOE MUÑOZ, LACY BROWN, ALEX LAMBERT, DIDI BENAMI AND ALMOST MICHAEL LYNCHE!!!!!!!!!!!!!

second of all, he sucks at singing! he really does. Andrew sings better than he does. He really does, and andrew is bad too. I hope Tim and Andrew go home cuz i am sick and tired of people just voting on American Idol for their looks. tim may be handsome or "cute" or "hot" but thats the only reason he's still on the show.

first of all i agree tim does suck.I to am tired of the crap.It is more a popularity contest than a singing contest.JUST LIKE LAST YEAR.Lacy who was the first to go should still be in.Tim should have been the first to go. who are these people voting have they really listened to Tims singing .Good god people get a grip

I just dont get it why this TIM URBAN still in the list. Kinda disappointed with the Vote. There are so many contestant are more qualified then him Tim dont deserve the Vote. >.< This world is not just Beauty or watever, This is American Idol! please vote wisely!

Are u kidding me!!! Tim is the worst singer i ever heard ,, i think me could do it better... i don't understand why..?? people vote for him every week, he's taking the place that someone else could have.. if he through another week more .. this will become in a joke cuz very good people like Didi or Lacey are out and he will stays in.. and for all that crazy girls i just say that this is a singing competition not a beauty certaim but anyway his not even that goodliking WEAK UP!!!

Tim Urban's singing performance simply does not warrant him being in the top 10 of AI. We can thank websites like votefortheworst.com, which are partially responsible for the American viewers having to painfully endure Tim Urban’s poor excuse for his so-called singing ability. Folks let's remember that this is a singing competition, and anyone that thinks Tim Urban has a chance in hell to be the next American Idol clearly must be tone deaf. Unfortunately since he’s made it to the top 10, those of you that opt to see the AI tour will endure Tim's "vocal stylings" or lack thereof beyohd this competition. One can only hope that Tim actually takes some pity on the American public by hiring a vocal coach to improve his singing ability to at least a tolerable level. As it stands, poor Tim doesn’t seem to “get it.” which is probably why he smiles a lot, proving that ignorance truly is bliss.

I'm listing to A I and Tim Urban and the Janis chicka are the two best voices. The judges are wacked. Tim Urban has great potential and if he gets past Hannah Montanan's bogus advice and just performs, he'll do great.

Speaking of hacks...If I hear Randy say "listen up" and "dawg" one more time I'll cash my social security check and buy a stick to beat him.

I like Tim alot but last night's performance of "under my thumb" was just horrible, no two ways about it. I didn't care for the Rolling Stones music but that's besides the point. Tim needs more singing lessons. I think he could be a very good country music singer. Aaron Kelly is my prediction to win this year's Idol.

He's not the best contestant, but he has that star quality. There's potential, he just needs some singing lessons and he'll be ok. I still do wonder how come out of all the people they could've chosen to replace the other guy they chose him? Whatever, It's not like anyone really pays attention to his singing... :)

I like Tim's singing. I think he's making steady and consistent progress. I can see him going into country singing as well.

I think the producers did an injustice to Chris Golightly though. They should have done their pre-acceptance homework thoroughly before Chris was accepted as a contestant. The producers acted hastily and non-professionally to this situation. They should have checked with Dream5 to corroborate Chris' claims. The lack of an apology on the part of American Idol once again shows that this program refuses to accept responsibility for their mistakes and the courtesy to offer an apology to those who are wronged by their decisions. It's these types of situations that continue to reflect poorly on the program and its increasingly negative ratings.

Chris worked hard. He stood before the judges and accepted both their compliments and criticism while he was on the show. His dreams of becoming the next American Idol were shattered because of the incompetence of the producers who did not do their jobs correctly.

tim urban has raw talent and doesnt sound like that teeny bopper shit that everyone else lkes hes got a different sound and thats wat i love about sure hes got great looks but he also has a great voice

The only people who are voting for Tim Urban and his lackluster performances, are little preteens, and tweenies. Girls who cream their pants when they see a pretty boy. It has nothing to do with talent.

This guy should have gone home. He is BY FAR the worst on the show. Out of any eliminations he should have never made it in the top 24... and should have been eliminated in the first round. He has NOTHING going for him and i sure dont think its his looks either.

u have no right to say that about anyone. the only reason ur said those things is probably bcuz ur so upset that u suck and cant sing and are so jelous of him tim urban has raw talent i dont no who u r but im guessing u have no talent, so heres the thing dont go around crushing everyone elses dreams just cuz urs didnt work out