189426: If a person misses ‘Isha’ prayer, can he pray Taraweeh with the imam, with the intention of praying ‘Isha’?

If a person misses ‘Isha’ prayer, it may be noted in the month of Ramadan in particular – as you are well aware – that there are more than two jamaa‘ahs in the same place and at the same time. This is something that often happens at the time of ‘Isha’ and Taraweeh prayer. For example, when the first jamaa‘ah has finished ‘Isha’ prayer, another jamaa‘ah comes and they say the iqaamah (call immediately preceding the prayer) and they begin to pray ‘Isha’. During this time, the first jamaa‘ah get up and start to pray Taraweeh. Is it permissible to have two jamaa‘ahs at the same time and in the same place? What is your advice – may Allah preserve you and bless your work – to imams and those who come late to ‘Isha’ prayer? Is it permissible for me to pray with the imam having the intention of ‘Isha’ whilst he has the intention of Taraweeh?

Praise be to Allah.

Firstly:

The Muslim
should hasten to do good deeds and compete with others in doing acts of
worship, and this is emphasised even more during the month of Ramadan, in
which the gates of Paradise are opened and the gates of Hell are closed, the
devils are chained up and a caller calls out every night: O seeker of good,
advance; O seeker of evil, go back.

Our advice to
the one who misses some of the prayers without any excuse, or misses them
because of something haraam, such as those who neglect the prayer in order
to watch soap operas, is that they should be keen to offer the prayers with
the Muslims and they should hasten to pray when they hear the adhaan (call
to prayer). Ramadan is a month of worship and multiple reward; we ask Allah
to protect us from the evil of our own selves and to help us to obey and
worship Him, for He is the Most Munificent, Most Generous.

Secondly:

If some people
have missed ‘Isha’ prayer with the regular imam, should they pray ‘Isha’ in
congregation (jamaa‘ah), or should they join the imam in Taraweeh prayer,
with the intention of praying ‘Isha’? That depends on their situation:

If they came
in straight after the prayer, and there is enough time before Taraweeh to
pray ‘Isha’, then in this case it is better for them to pray in jamaa‘ah on
their own, so as to avoid differing with those scholars who do not allow a
person to offer an obligatory prayer behind (an imam) who is offering a
naafil prayer.

But if they
came in whilst Taraweeh prayer was in progress, or the imam started to pray
Taraweeh shortly after ‘Isha’, and there is the fear that if a second
jamaa‘ah prays, the two groups will disturb one another, then in this case
it is better to join the imam in Taraweeh, with the intention of praying
‘Isha’. Then when the imam says the tasleem after two rak‘ahs, they should
stand up and complete the prayer by themselves.

Shaykh Ibn
Baaz (may Allah have mercy on him) was asked: We notice that in some
mosques, those who come after the end of ‘Isha’ prayer and the beginning of
Taraweeh offer a second [‘Isha’] prayer, but by doing so they disturb those
who are praying Taraweeh. Is it better for them to offer the prayer in
jamaa‘ah, or to join the imam in Taraweeh prayer, with the intention of
‘Isha’? Is the ruling different if it is one person or a group that comes
in?

He replied: If
those who come in are two or more, then it is better for them to offer the
prayer on their own – i.e., ‘Isha’ prayer – then to join the people in
Taraweeh. But if they join the imam with the intention of praying ‘Isha’,
then when the imam says the tasleem, each of them gets up and completes the
prayer by himself, there is nothing wrong with that, because it was proven
from Mu‘aadh (may Allah be pleased with him) that he used to pray the
obligatory prayer of ‘Isha’ with the Prophet (blessings and peace of Allah
be upon him), then he would go back to his people and lead them in offering
that prayer; for him it was naafil but for them it was obligatory. But if
only one person comes in, then it is better for him to join the imam with
the intention of ‘Isha’, so that he will attain the virtue of praying in
jamaa‘ah. Then when the imam says the tasleem following two rak‘ahs, he
should complete ‘Isha’ by himself.