Suggestion

Yesterday Swordroll asked a great question on Twitter about what would happen if you redeemed the same companion on a pirate who already has one in its crew. [He was suggesting an army of Nausica]

I decided I wanted to try it out. I had one of the Christmas Toads on my low level Bucc and had an extra one in my gift box still. I went to redeem it and the game let me, but alas there was still only one toad in my crew. The other toad that was in my gift box was gone.

My suggestion is to have a warning pop up, or something that doesn't let you redeem it if you already have it on that pirate, because you can lose it with a click of a button for those who don't know.

Yesterday Swordroll asked a great question on Twitter about what would happen if you redeemed the same companion on a pirate who already has one in its crew. [He was suggesting an army of Nausica]

I decided I wanted to try it out. I had one of the Christmas Toads on my low level Bucc and had an extra one in my gift box still. I went to redeem it and the game let me, but alas there was still only one toad in my crew. The other toad that was in my gift box was gone.

My suggestion is to have a warning pop up, or something that doesn't let you redeem it if you already have it on that pirate, because you can lose it with a click of a button for those who don't know.

Happy Sailing!

Excellent suggestion. I am quite sure that if you talk to the powers that be they will return your Toad that is lost in the twinning loop. It is good that you did this and all who read this are now for warned and for armed. Very brave of you. Thank you.

In general, Bundle companions will not act this way (they will give an error message rather than be able to be redeemed) and you should not be able to purchase a companion a second time (or add them to your crew a second time).

We will be fixing a bug with the Mistle Toad that allowed for this to happen, and I've manually returned the deleted Mistle Toad to your gift inventory (for you to redeem on another character on your account)

In general, Bundle companions will not act this way (they will give an error message rather than be able to be redeemed) and you should not be able to purchase a companion a second time (or add them to your crew a second time).

We will be fixing a bug with the Mistle Toad that allowed for this to happen, and I've manually returned the deleted Mistle Toad to your gift inventory (for you to redeem on another character on your account)