The Purpose of Market Intervention

Interventions in markets by governments and central banks are routine and
we take them for granted. No one questions them, but they can create dangerous
distortions. Their reason for intervening is to take price determination away
from markets and consumers.

The authorities and big business do not like leaving prices to free markets
because prices are subjective: in other words, prices are decided by the desires
of the consumer and not the cost of production. This is the central plank
in the Austrian School's explanation of economic theory in free markets, and
it therefore follows that what consumers actually want and at what price must
in turn determine prices through the whole supply chain. Keynesians do not
take this view, dismissing the influence of consumers on actual prices as
a short-term effect that does not fundamentally challenge the importance of
costs. They do not like uncertainty over prices, because it invalidates their
economic models.

If you accept the Austrian School's argument, free markets are to be cherished,
and interventions only result in less efficient use of economic resources.
If you go with the Keynesians, you will believe there is room for the market
to fail, arising from aberrations in consumer behaviour. They call it "animal
spirits". They tell us that changes in the allocation of economic resources
by the free market are not always justified, opening the door to market intervention.

There are no prizes for guessing where big business stands in this Keynesian
vs Austrian debate. Given the choice between dancing to the consumer's
tune and looking for government subsidy it always opts for the latter.
It has a vested interest in supporting Keynesian economics.

This is why big business believes in government. Government is a source of
subsidy and protective regulation. Equally, government naively believes that
it must consult big business to form successful industrial and economic policies.
The result of this symbiotic relationship is that government intervenes in
almost everything that has a price both directly and indirectly through the
manipulation of interest rates.

The effect is to downgrade the importance of consumers' wants and needs, which
are most effectively expressed in free markets. The consumer, who is also
a taxpayer, ends up paying the government to rig prices against him. No one,
surely, can argue that this is a satisfactory way of proceeding.

But what about those animal spirits? The answer is simple: prices and products
get out of line with what consumers actually want, almost always as a result
of government interventions. It can be because government has subsidised or
protected the wrong production, or it can be because it has provided easy
money in the past and consumers have become financially over-extended. Today,
both reasons are there in spades.

Understand this, and it becomes obvious that the popular solution advocated
by Keynesians and big business alike, of increasing the pace of intervention,
will not erase those pesky animal spirits. Instead, the cost, borne by the
hapless consumer in his role as taxpayer, actually accelerates, as well as
distorting markets even more.

Market intervention is what has got us here, and more of it is definitely
not the cure.

Alasdair Macleod runs FinanceAndEconomics.org,
a website dedicated to sound money and demystifying finance and economics.
Alasdair has a background as a stockbroker, banker and economist. He is a
Senior Fellow at the GoldMoney
Foundation.

GoldMoney is one of the world's leading providers of physical gold, silver,
platinum and palladium for retail and corporate customers. Customers can trade
and store precious metal online easily and securely, 24 hours a day.

Historically gold has been an excellent way to preserve purchasing power over
long periods of time. For example, today it takes almost the same amount of
gold to buy a barrel of crude oil as it did 60 years ago which is in stark
contrast to the price of oil in terms of national currencies such as the US
dollar.

GoldMoney is regulated by the Jersey Financial Services Commission and complies
with Jersey's anti-money laundering laws and regulations. GoldMoney has established
industry-leading governance policies and procedures to protect customers' assets
with independent audit reporting every 3 months by two leading audit firms.

GoldMoney has its headquarters in Jersey and also has offices in London and
Hong Kong. It offers its customers storage facilities in Canada, Hong Kong,
Singapore, Switzerland and the UK provided by the leading non-bank vault operators
Brink's, Via Mat, Malca-Amit, G4S and Rhenus Logistics.