Even though the 25-year-old actor behind Jughead Jones admits that his fans have been begging for an on-screen reunion between the two, he doesn’t think it would be appropriate to break the fourth wall. We don’t disagree with him! At least we still have 50% of the dynamic duo.

“I also just don’t think Dylan wants to; to be honest, I wouldn’t want to either. People want to see us on screen together again, and that’s fine. That’s flattering, I guess. But if it’s going to destroy the kind of world that we’ve built [on Riverdale], it’s wildly inappropriate.”

A post shared by Riverdale (@thecwriverdale) on Oct 9, 2017 at 10:06am PDT

The success of “Riverdale” has been a huge milestone for its stars — and for one cast member, it was even their very first role! Do you know the show’s stars kicked off their acting careers? Test your knowledge with this quiz!