Re: The better tree?

Originally Posted by SCUBAbe

IMO, if the gold tree was in DCA a lot of people would dislike it. If DCA gets anything it's always met with, "well it could have been better." I'm surprised nobody has used the silliest remaeks yet. Such as, "I would like the DCA tree better if it was standing in the old parking lot.".....LOL

After looking at the photos of the California Adventure tree, I have to agree with you. California Adventure's tree actually looks really nice and very pretty. It may not be as big and tall as Disneyland's, but if they did make it as tall, then it would take away from Disneyland's Christmas Tree tradition. Some of the people who've posted on this thread have come in already disliking the Park itself anyway, so naturally, anything that comes into California Adventure is automatically wrong or dumb, or "blah," as some people say.

Basically, the only thing that's different from the trees, is that Disneyland's has gold ornaments and California Adventure's has multi-colored ornaments. (The size of the trees don't count since it's openly obvious). If it were any other year, Disneyland's would have multi-colored ornaments which would make the trees not so different. You just watch, next year, both trees will have multi-colored ornaments and decorations, but California Adventure's will still be "blah."

Re: The better tree?

There's nothing wrong with comparing the trees. We can discuss which is better. What's wrong with that? This is a discussion board.
I need to see pictures of both before I vote.

These DCA lovers alliance people have a bug up their butt everytime someone makes a comparison with DCA and Disneyland that is why. They always think everyone is bashing DCA when they are just speaking their opinion about the way something looks. Now that I have seen the DCA one decorated I like it. See I am not bias I just call it as I see it.

Re: The better tree?

Originally Posted by SCUBAbe

IMO, if the gold tree was in DCA a lot of people would dislike it. If DCA gets anything it's always met with, "well it could have been better." I'm surprised nobody has used the silliest remaeks yet. Such as, "I would like the DCA tree better if it was standing in the old parking lot.".....LOL

Hey, SOMEBODY gets it.
That was my point.

It's such a polarized issue: Both sides can be blind.
So, IMO, it's just another question to stir up controversy about something that has been hashed and rehashed and will never be settled. It's just stupid to compare the two when many responses won't come without some sort of bias. It's more than "just" a Christmas tree.

And Disney50, no harm meant. Guess I should have put an irony smiley face after my post.

Good morning, son
In twenty years from now
Maybe we'll both sit down and have a few beers
And I can tell you 'bout today
And how I picked you up and everything changed
It was pain
Sunny days and rain
I knew you'd feel the same things...

Re: The better tree?

ok, I looked at both and I will say it again, that big gold tree is boring))))))) I looked at the DCA tree and I thought, yeah!! thats what a tree should look lke!! WOW its awsome!!http://darkbeer.smugmug.com/gallery/959512/23

oh yeah, if I had a choice of having either tree in my yard I would screan DCA tree!!!!!!!!!!

( and I do not have a bug up my BUTT, may something else butt no bug!!

Re: The better tree?

So, if I say I can't stand DCA then the DCA Lovers Alliance is going to be mad at me? Conversely, if I say I love DCA then the DCA Haters Alliance is going to be mad at me?

If this is the way things are going to be here then I say ** ** all the Alliances and the Clubs. Every last one of them. If it's just going to divide people on this board then let's do away with them. Sheez Louise! I used to think the alliance thing was cute, but if it is making things polarized then to heck wit them.

Everyone should be able to speak their minds here. The only group that should take issue with an opinion is a mod and even then it's usually about the way something was said not what is said.