It’s ridiculous to put Tyler Durden at the top, he’s borderline top 25. The Joker despite, I agree, being one of the best villans in cinematic history, has actually become, through all the accolades, overrated. I’ve never seen the Hannibal movies, so I might not be the best person to say he’s up waaay too high. Vader, Solo, Jones are all top 10 locks, though I might put Solo above Vader.

The Dude and Jack Sparrow I’d defend, Depp’s single-handed performance raking in a billion dollars for Disney has to be worth something. It’s cheating to treat all James Bonds as even (same could be said for the Joker and the Terminator). Gollum was fine, but not worth the top twenty. Ellis Redding is a joke this high, as is Ash, Yoda should lose more ground considering the recent movies.

I didn’t look at the whole list but I would put here (just from the top of my head) Daniel Plainview (There Will Be Blood : ranked 29th by Empire), Emmet Ray (Sweet & Lowdown), half the cast from Magnolia, Navin R. Johnson (The Jerk), Jerry Maguire (Jerry Maguire)…

First woman ranked is Mary Poppins at 41st.

How many action stars are on this thing? Do we like any character that isn’t violent?