Is hiding your gender during sex a crime?

The guilty verdict in Gayle Newland's sex deception case may be worrying news for people transitioning to a new gender. Even if they are legally recognised, it could be considered a sexual offence if they fail to declare their gender history to new sexual partners

Gayle Newland, 25, has been convicted of three counts of sexual assault against a woman who had believed she was in a sexual relationship with a man. Newland’s case has thrown up some very thorny questions about gender and sexual consent – and about what, exactly, we are required by law to reveal to our sexual partners.

Newland had established contact with the victim, also a 25-year-old woman, through a Facebook profile set up in the name of a fictitious young man, “Kye Fortune”. She later also used this profile to introduce herself to the victim, and they went on to become close. The two-year relationship that developed between the victim and “Kye” always required the victim wear a blindfold. “Kye’s” justification for this unusual situation was that “he” was self-conscious about his body after suffering an accident.

At trial, Newland maintained that both she and the victim had suffered some confusion about their sexual orientation, and that the sexual activity, which had taken place with Newland using a prosthetic penis, was role-play – something the victim vigorously disputed.

Although these circumstances might sound highly unusual, there have actually been convictions in similar cases before.

Read more

In 2012, Gemma Barker, 19, was convicted of sexual assault after disguising herself as male in order to sexually touch a number of her friends. And in 2013, Justine McNally, 18, also presented herself as male to engage in sexual activity.

Calling herself “Scott” McNally, she built up an online relationship with another young woman over a number of years. When the parties met McNally continued the ruse and penetrated the complainant orally and digitally. She was convicted of six counts of assault by penetration.

These cases raise an interesting question: how, if the victims are “consenting” to sexual activity, can this be a sexual offence?

Baring all

Section 74 of the Sexual Offences Act 2003 provides that a person consents to sex if he or she agrees by choice, and has the freedom and capacity to make that choice. The central issue in these gender deception cases, then, is then whether a free choice has actually been made.

Gayle Newland arrives at Chester Crown Court, where she was found guilty of three counts of sexual assault

As the Court of Appeal found in McNally’s appeal, “deception as to gender can vitiate consent”, as the sexual nature of the acts is different where the complainant is deliberately deceived by a defendant into believing the latter is a male. In that case, the court found that the complainant had chosen to have sexual encounters with a man, and therefore that her freedom to choose whether or not to have a sexual encounter with a woman was removed.

The defining issue seems to be whether the deception has been an “active” one – not a mistake about gender that goes uncorrected, but a purposeful intention to deceive. The evidence given in the Gayle Newland trial did strongly support, and the majority of the jury accepted, that Newland had intended to mislead the victim about her gender in order to engage her in a sexual relationship.

At first blush, this seems perfectly reasonable. We should all have the right to consent to sexual activity with a person who is the gender of our choosing, and the law should uphold this right.

But it gets tricky when we consider the lies that are so often told to attract a partner. People often lie about their marital status, income and age, for instance. These lies don’t make any sexual activity that ensues unlawful.

So the case law singles out gender as a crucial feature on which consent is based – and that could mean trouble for people transitioning into a new gender.

Enforced honesty

Getting legal recognition for a new gender identity takes time: the UK’s Gender Recognition Act 2004 requires an applicant for a gender recognition certificate to have been living in the acquired gender for two years. Nonetheless, once someone who wants to transition is recognised, they are, legally speaking, to be identified by their acquired gender alone.

While those living in an acquired gender role might legally be recognised by it, they might worry that they could be committing a sexual offence if they fail to declare their gender history to new sexual partners.

The case law certainly suggests they could – but there are provisions that mean prosecutions against transgender people in these circumstances would be given careful consideration.

The Crown Prosecution Service policy advises that where there is such a deception that, in addition to the general Public Interest Test, other considerations should be taken into account including the nature of the sexual activity, whether the offending occurred as a result of gender uncertainty and the duration of the relationship between the suspect and complainant.

While this certainly moderates the harshness of the criminal law, it provides cold comfort to those who may be transitioning or experimenting with their gender identity.

Justine McNally had experienced confusion about her gender identity and sexuality, and whether or not Gayle Newland had similar issues, her case proves that as far as the case law goes, gender identity remains a legal and ethical minefield when it comes to sex.

Love and sex news: in pictures

Love and sex news: in pictures

1/30
What makes a perfect penis?

Scientists have now answered one of these great unknowns. According to a new study, “general cosmetic appearance” is the most important penile aspect when it comes to what women value down there. This is swiftly followed by the appearance of pubic hair, penile skin, and girth. Length comes in at number six, with the look of the scrotum trailing closely behind.
The least important facet of the phallus, say the scientists, is the “position and shape of meatus”, the vertical slit at the opening of the urethra.

Getty

2/30
Half of divorcees had doubts on their wedding day

Over half of divorcees considered abandoning their husband or wife-to-be at the altar on their wedding day, a new study has revealed. On top of likely worrying about wedding favours and making sure guests behave on their big day, 49 per cent of divorcees admitted they were unsure before the ceremony that their marriage would last.
Some 15 per cent of divorcees polled said they were so wracked with doubt that they felt physically sick in the run up to their wedding.

Joe Raedle/Getty Images

3/30
Students who marry after studying the same subject

Picking a university subject is already difficult enough for young people. But here’s an extra piece of data to weigh on your decision: you may be picking a life partner as well. Dan Kopf of the blog, Priceonomics, analysed US Census data and found that the percentage of Americans who marry someone within their own major is actually fairly high.
About half of Americans are married, according to the 2012 American Community Survey (part of the Census). And about 28 per cent of married couples over the age of 22 both graduated from college. (The survey didn’t recognise same-sex marriages for the 2012 data, but it will for 2013 onwards, says Kopf).

Sean Gallup/Getty Images

4/30
How much sex we have (and how much we'd like)

As a nation, we don’t have as much sex as we would like, a survey has (somewhat unsurprisingly) confirmed. In a poll of 1523 people by YouGov, 64 per cent of Britons said they would wish to have sex at least a few times a month. The same sample said that only 38 per cent had sex at least a few times a month.
In addition, 10 per cent said they wished to have sex every day, a goal which only 1 per cent admitted reaching.

Rex

5/30
The new female condom

Picture an internal condom. The chances are you’re thinking of something which resembles a carrier bag. However, this could all be about to change with the new VA w.o.w. Condom Feminine. Not only is it a wireless, Bluetooth enabled, vibrating interactive device, which comes available in the shape of a heart, but the manufacturers think you’ll love it more than not using a condom at all.

6/30
The UK's favourite sex position

Casting aside the myth that Brits are a prudish bunch, a new survey has revealed that doggy style is the nation’s favourite sex position. As many as a quarter of UK adults surveyed said doggy style was their favourite way to indulge with a partner.
Missionary, which is sometimes scoffed at the most boring position, was favoured by a fifth of the 1,000 people surveyed by high street sex shop Ann Summers, seeing it come in as third under "woman on top".

Caiaimage/REX

7/30
Who's most likely to cheat?

Men and women who are economically dependent on their spouses are more likely to cheat, a new study has revealed. Researchers have found that men who are solely financially dependent are more like to cheat than women, at 15 per cent and 5 per cent respectively.
Men who are rely on their wives may cheat because they are undergoing a “masculinity threat” by not being the primary breadwinner as is culturally expected, said study author Christin L. Munsch, a UConn assistant professor of sociology.

Eye Candy/REX

8/30
Jailed for loud sex noises

A woman who breached a court order barring her from causing nuisance by making "loud sex noises" was sent to jail. Gemma Wale, of Small Heath, Birmingham, was given a two-week prison sentence after a civil court judge concluded that she had breached the order by "screaming and shouting whilst having sex" at a "level of noise" which annoyed a neighbour.

Rex Features

9/30
Photo of wedding guest proposing to girlfriend in front of bride and groom goes viral

When the staggering amount time, money, and effort that goes into to planning a wedding is considered, it seems pretty obvious that all guests have is to do is turn up with some gifts, and not upstage the couple. But this fact seems to have escaped one man, whose grinning face has gone viral after he decided to propose to his girlfriend in front of the bride and groom’s top table.
The photo, which has been viewed over 1.4 million times on Reddit, shows a boyfriend perched on one knee in front of his crying girlfriend.

Joe Raedle/Getty Images

10/30
Sexual fantasies

The results of a sex survey are busting the myth that Britons are sexually repressed, by revealing how the majority of women have lived out their sexual fantasies. As many as 81 per cent of women and 77 per cent of men have shared and acted out fantasies with a partner – with having sex in public topping the list of turn-ons. The study also laid bare the influence of TV and film on our desires, with three-quarters of couples saying they had inspired them.
Meanwhile, a further three quarters of women and over half of men have played out a fantasy they’d found in a book.

LEO RAMIREZ/AFP/Getty Images

11/30
The world's sexiest nationalities

Irish men are the world’s sexiest, according to a survey of thousands of jet-setting women. In a poll of 66,000 of single American women who use MissTravel.com, as many as 8,000 said that Irish men are the sexiest.
Around half of the females who took said they were turned on by Irish men said their accent influenced their choice, according to the Irish Times.

ANDREW COWIE/AFP/Getty Images

12/30
More sex = happiness?

Couples were asked to double the amount of sex they had each week over a three month period by researchers at the Carnegie Mellon University, who compared them to couples who had their normal amount of sex.
Their findings, published in the Journal of Economic Behavior, went against advice given by the average self-help book – having more sex doesn’t automatically make a person happier.
Instead, couples who were instructed to have more sex reported a decrease in happiness levels.

Mood Board/Rex

13/30
Most sexually satisfied countries

It is often considered the most amorous nation on the planet, but France doesn't even feature in a new list of the most sexually satisfied countries. According to a Durex global survey of 26,000 people, aged 16 and older, across 26 countries, only 44 per cent of people are fully satisfied with their sex lives.
In the wake of these results, AlterNet has compiled a list of the 12 most sexually satisfied countries, with Switzerland, Spain and Italy topping the list.

INDRANIL MUKHERJEE/AFP/Getty Images

14/30
Sex o'clock

They say women are from Venus and men are from Mars – but a new sex survey suggests that members of the opposite sex seem to operate in different time zones too. While women like to get steamy between 11:21pm on average, men are more likely to be turned on at the rather inconvenient time of 7:54am.
These times fall into the broader timeslots of 11pm and 2am for women, and 6am and 9am for men.

PIERRE ANDRIEU/AFP/Getty Images

15/30
More sex = more money

People who have more sex are likely to earn more, new research claims. The research, partly conducted from the responses of 7,500 people, found employees who have sex two or three times a week earn 4.5 per cent more than colleagues who do not.

Rex

16/30
The effects of watching porn

Contrary to suggestion that porn desensitises viewers to sex, a study has found that it doesn't "negatively impact sexual functioning" and in fact boosts couples' sexual attraction to one another. In research published in the Journal of Sexual Medicine, scientists at the University of California tested the effects of visual sexual stimuli on men in relationships, finding that it "is unlikely to negatively impact sexual functioning, given that responses actually were stronger in those who viewed more VSS."

Rex

17/30
'I have herpes'

A woman diagnosed with herpes at the age of 20 has written an emotional essay about living with the common condition to fight the stigma surrounding it. Ella Dawson, now 22, said she had never had unprotected sex and thought she “wasn't the sort of person STDs happened to” when the symptoms first appeared during her time at university in the US. She wrote that the diagnosis initially felt like a “punishment” for her values and relationships and worried her that telling boyfriends would ruin her love life.

Ella Dawson

18/30
More sleep, better sex

A new study could have a simple answer to enhancing your sex life – just get a good night’s sleep (if you are a woman at least). A study conducted by a team at the University of Michigan Sleep and Circadian Research Laboratory found women who get an extra hour of sleep at night reported higher levels of sexual desire and were more likely to have sex with their partners.

Getty Images

19/30
Swipe right

A woman has detailed her experiences of a week of always swiping right on Tinder. By “opening the floodgates,” as Ms Caster describes it, she receives scores of messages from different men – and not all are terrible.

20/30
The most adulterous town in the UK

Ever wondered what the neighbours are up to? Well if you live in Beeston, Nottinghamshire, then the answer is probably... having an affair. The bustling East Midlands town has been granted the dubious honour of being the UK's top spot for infidelity – with a total of 941 affairs reportedly taking place right now.
According to The Official Infidelity Index 2015, which was released this week, 2.54 per cent of the town’s population are currently seeing someone they shouldn't.

REX FEATURES

21/30
Average penis size revealed

Scientists have measured more than 15,000 men’s penises in an effort to find out what size is “normal”. Researchers at King’s College London and a London NHS trust said they hoped the review would help address “the concern that some men have about their penis size” and aid people suffering from anxiety and distress.
They revealed that the average flaccid penis is 3.6ins (9.16cm) long, or 5.2ins (13.24cm) when stretched, and 3.7ins (9.31cm) in circumference.
Erect penises are 5.1ins (13.12cm) long on average and 4.5ins (11.66cm) in girth.

Rex

22/30
One true love

Men fall in love more times in their life than women, according to a new survey. 2,000 adults were asked about relationships, and discovered that more than half of men say they've loved more than one person their lifetime. For women, it's markedly fewer, with only 45 per cent saying they've had multiple loves.

23/30
Dating site for 'beautiful people only'

A self-proclaimed “elite” dating website has removed around 3,000 members because they were "letting themselves go". BeautifulPeople.com describes itself as the “largest internet dating community exclusively for the beautiful” and puts people’s photographs to a members’ vote to decide if they are allowed in.
But administrators have now shown that the rigorous 48-hour selection period is not a permanent pass by taking thousands of profiles down, mainly because of weight gain and “graceless ageing”.

24/30
Sex is a 'miracle cure'

Regular exercise – including sex, walking and dancing – are “miracle cures staring us in the face” and could dramatically cut our risk of cancer, dementia, heart disease and diabetes, leading doctors have said. In a new review of existing evidence which reveals the full extent of benefits that can be accrued from exercise, the Academy of Medical Royal Colleges said the improvement in health and savings to the NHS could be “incalculable”.

Susannah Ireland

25/30
Pornhub searches by age of user

Pornhubs prolific Insights blog fires out many reports of sociological interest, none more so than its latest on age, which lays bare different age groups' sexual proclivities. Looking at the most popular searches among 18-24s, there are several familial terms including 'step mom', 'milf', 'mom' and 'step sister', a trend that seems to die out somewhat in users' 30s. By 65, 'massage' becomes the top term, while 'granny' perhaps unsurprisingly also hits the top ten.

PlaceIt/Just Another IKEA Catalog

26/30
Mature sex

Research into the sexual lives of more than 7,000 men and women between the ages of 50 and 90 in England reveals that half of men and almost a third of women aged 70 and over were still sexually active, with around a third of these sexually active older people having sexual intercourse twice a month or more. Around two-thirds of men and over half of women thought “good sexual relations were essential to the maintenance of a long-term relationship” or “being sexually active was physically and psychologically beneficial to older people”.

Getty Creative

27/30
The secret to an eighty year marriage

Figures from the Office of National Statistics show that 42 per cent of marriages in England and Wales end in divorce, and the average British marriage which ends in divorce lasts 11 years and six months. Helen and Maurice Kaye, now aged 101 and 102, have been married for 80 years, and say the secret is: “I think it’s important to have patience and tolerance. You're two entirely different people who suddenly live together, which can't be easy. But if you love each other, you get over the difficulties.”

28/30
Valentine's Day porn

Pornhub saw a (slight) drop in traffic on Valentine's Day as people focused on pleasuring their partners rather than themselves. Everywhere, it is, except for London. Overall UK traffic dipped 3 per cent across the UK, with Plymouth and Oxford seeing the biggest drops of 11 per cent and 10 per cent respectively.
In fact every major city spent less time watching porn bar London, the Pornhub audience for which grew by 2 per cent.

Getty

29/30
1 in 10 men paying for sex

A tenth of British men have admitted to paying for sex, according to a new study. Professionals aged 25 to 34 who binge drink and take drugs were found to be the most likely to have used the services of prostitutes, based on findings from a study of 6,108 men.
Around 11 per cent of subjects, in the study published in the Sexually Transmitted Infections journal, have ever paid for sex in their lifetime and four per cent admitted to doing so in the last five years.

Getty Images

30/30
Questions that determine if you're in love

The existence of love and its nature is something that has troubled philosophers for centuries, but a pair of scientists believe they have a set of questions that yield "clear empirical evidence" of it, or at least whether your relationship will end in divorce. They are:
'How happy are you in your marriage relative to how happy you would be if you weren't in the marriage?' and 'How do you think your spouse answered that question?'