mm112: Daily Kos: Evolution is, in fact, a theory, not a fact.

MUDGE’S Musings

Due to the nature of my employment, and the extraordinary nature of my specific role that requires me to venture out of the safe confines of the introverted world of gearhead IT types, and into the dangerous confines of wild-eyed intellectual activity, I meet more than a few scientists. Not daily, or even every week, but several times a month.

It’s quite bracing, actually. I keep myself (comparatively) young by encountering smart people on a regular basis. Quite tonic really.

They wouldn’t have any trouble with this material; do you?

Evolution is, in fact, a theory, not a fact.

Sat Aug 18, 2007 at 10:47:11 AM PDT

I’ve decided to start my diarying with a couple of entries about evolution. I’m working on my PhD in evolutionary biology, and while I can tell most people here understand that there is no logical way to reject evolution, I thought it might be helpful to clarify a few important points about evolution. Those who reject evolution often use the inconsistencies in the understanding of those they argue with to “prove” that evolution does not make sense. So I’d like to see us all on the same page.

For those of you who reject evolution as a matter of faith, it is not my goal to convince you of anything. If you were open to being swayed by facts, reasons or logic, it would, by definition not be faith. If you like, imagine this was written in a fantasy realm in which evolution is real and your genetic code is 95% identical to that of a chimp. I don’t want the comments section to turn into an argument about whether evolution is real or people on the other side are questionable. No one is going to change his mind on the topic.

I found this story at the top of the heap at Daily Kos Saturday; not a lengthy read, but as cogent a discussion of a complex, button-pushing topic as I’ve encountered in some time.

[Per L-HC’s reformed process, please click the link below for the complete article — but then please come on back!]

But he provides some ammunition to those among us who encounter the sincere but scientifically ignorant; hasn’t happened to me lately, but that’s because I don’t usually lead with my liberal chin in the HCA (Heart of Corporate America, not the real name of my real employer).

And, I gained a new perspective reading this article:

The popular view of evolution is a progression from bacteria to squiggly guys to fish to lungfish to amphibians to reptiles to mammals to primates to great apes to Neanderthals to cavemen to us us US, the pinnacle of God’s design! But wait, we are talking about science here, no supernatural explanations need apply. If we overcome our religious biases and our anthropocentrism, it becomes clear that the world’s organisms are not striving to be us. Some populations evolve to be bigger, others to be smaller. Brains get bigger and smaller. Number of limbs increases and decreases. There is no direction to it. Every population just drifts towards whatever happens to encourage survival and reproduction in their peculiar environment at that moment. There is no force driving things towards being human like.

Ow! Now I’m all bruised from being knocked off my pinnacle. But, I’ll heal.

No more than was D.Q., I’m not here to pick a fight (and, as you’ve probably sorted out by now, I don’t have the horsepower to mount much of a defense). But, fearless reader, let me know what you think of this. Kansans need not apply.

Post navigation

6 Responses to mm112: Daily Kos: Evolution is, in fact, a theory, not a fact.

As good old dan says “There is no direction to it. Every population just drifts towards whatever happens to encourage survival.” The late great Kurt Vonnegut once said that he believes the earths “immune system” is on to the human race and is out to get rid of us. That sounds about right to me. If this is the case, then becoming human is not going to “encourage survival.” If I were a lower form of life, I would avoid evolving into the human form and try something different instead. 😉

The scientifically impossible I do right away
The spiritually miraculous takes a bit longer

In this great scheme of things you actually get a B+ for hard work. Where exactly you actually confused me personally was on your particulars. As as the maxim goes, details make or break the argument.. And that could not be more true right here. Having said that, permit me say to you what exactly did give good results. Your authoring is definitely very persuasive which is probably the reason why I am taking the effort in order to comment. I do not really make it a regular habit of doing that. Next, although I can notice a leaps in reasoning you come up with, I am not really convinced of exactly how you seem to connect your points which in turn produce your conclusion. For the moment I shall yield to your position but wish in the future you connect your facts much better.

You make a great point. Got some great information here. I suppose that if more people thought about it that way, theyd have a better time understanding the issue. Your view is definitely something Id like to see more of. appreciate for this site. Its fantastic and so is what youve got to say.