Aaron: Right. Detroit doesn’t have any real stars, but I could see them being average or better at every position.

Bryan: Seems to me the Twins and Tigers will be battling for having the third and fourth offenses in the division, but the Twins strength in pitching puts them way ahead.

Cheat: I’d rate the Tigers offense ahead of the Twins, but your point still stands. The difference in pitching is too much to overcome.

Bryan: It seems funny to say that in the AL Central that a good offense and mediocre pitching staff doesn’t have a ton of hope for third. That’s new.

Aaron: Yeah. This Tigers team could have competed for the division title a couple years ago.

Love for Craig Monroe: Greg Eno is a big fan of Craig Monroe and would like to see him inked to a long term contract.

So DD better stop fiddling around and keep Monroe in a Tigers uniform for years to come. He has the strength to muscle the ball over Comerica Park’s distant walls in left and left-center field. He doesn’t drop the ball with his glove, and can throw it with some accuracy and zip. He is also another rarity among Tigers players of late: he is not baseball stupid.

Now I like Greg as a writer, and I like Craig Monroe, but I can’t agree here. Monroe’s production is fairly typical, not extraordinary. He has two more years of arbitration eligibility and there is no need to sign him to a long term deal. I love his work ethic, his attitude, and I have no desire to see him leave. However, he is probably also one of the more replaceable players on the roster.

Former Tigers, current Nationals: Jason Beck writes about the former Tigers who find themselves with the Washington Nationals. The contingent includes Robert Fick, Damian Jackson, Mike DiFelice, Andrew Good, George Lombard and Brandon Harper.

A Rockies fan bashes Detroit: Bad Altitude, a member of the Baseball Toaster family has been preparing Hastily Assembled Previews for various teams. He’s not big on Detroit to say the least:

It’s almost besides the point to try and predict a record or finish for the Tigers in 2006, because for teams with no chance of contending records are looked to for signs of progress. If the Rockies win 75 games this year, that’ll be a nice little accomplishment and pats on the back will be due all ’round. If Detroit wins 75 games in ’06, or 84, or 64, who cares, because it’ll be the exact same story in 2007. And the year after that…and the year after that…. They’re duking it out with Baltimore for the coveted title of Worst Organization in MLB (Kansas City is disqualified as they haven’t been actively trying to field a major league team for some time now). I kind of wish they were in our division.

Now the author qualified it as a hastily assembled preview, and if I tried to put quicly put together several hundred words about a team outside of the Central I would struggle. Still, I’m not impressed with the work here. He criticizes the Tigers for overspending on Rogers (which they probably did), for sticking with the mainstays in the rotation (Bonderman, Robertson, Maroth), and for rushing Verlander and Zumaya. I’m really not sure who he invisions pitching in Detroit. They can’t use their highly touted prospects, they can’t use the average, cheap, homegrown players they have, and they can’t sign free agents.

Dombrowski and the Tigers are certainly open to criticism. The Rogers, Jones, and Ordonez contracts all fall in the category of excessive no matter what your criteria is. However, at least in the case of Rogers and Jones the length of the contracts don’t seem to prohibit anything else (spending, player promotions/development). If you want to call them the worst organization in baseball for the totality of the last 12 years that is fine, and difficult to argue. To base it on the last 2 seasons just doesn’t make sense.

BA’s Top 50 Okay, so you probably didn’t miss this one. In case you hadn’t heard, 3 Tigers made the top 50. Justin Verlander checked in at 8, followed by Cameron Maybin at 31, and Joel Zumaya at 35. I happen to think that Zumaya is probably ranked a little low, but at the same time I don’t know enough about other teams prospects to really complain to much. In any case, 3 players in the Top 50 is probably pretty good for one of the worst organizations in baseball.

5 Comments

// for sticking with the mainstays in the rotation (Bonderman, Robertson, Maroth) //

I think that’s the bit that made the least sense. Maroth improves with each season, Nate kept getting screwed by the worst luck EVER last year – but, yeah, that Bonderman guy, get him off my team. Twenty-two years old with fifteen wins last season. Slacker.

I mean, obviously a non-fan doesn’t know a team like its fans do, and I’ll give him a pass on the thing with Nate’s tragic luck since it’s kind of obscure to an outsider, but it’s not hard to check the numbers with the others and see how much better they’ve both gotten and that there’s no reason to think they won’t continue to improve. If you’re gonna review in any kind of depth a team you don’t know well, do your homework.

Joe

February 26, 2006 at 7:25 am

I saw a quotte from Joel Zumaya today on Detroittigers.com in an interview with him and Justin Verlander. Joel said that he can see the Tigers having starting pitching the way that the As did a few years back. Needless to say I got giddy inside at the thought and it occured to me he could be right. I started to imagine the three of them pitching together, taking the tigers to the playoffs, I even gave the trio a nickname tripple J’s (cause they all have names that start with J). And then I came back to reality and wondered if they actually could be as good as the A’s trio. So I decided to look at the minor league stats and here is what i came up with.

INN K/9 BB/9 ERA WHIP

Hudson

271 9 3.2 3.25 1.15

Zito

170 10.0 4.2 3.18 1.27

Mulder

137 5.7 2.3 4.13 1.57

Bonderman

156.2 9.8 3.4 3.79 1.27

verlander

118.2 10.4 2.0 1.29 0.90

Zumaya

409.2 11.1 4.17 3.25 1.17

Joe

February 26, 2006 at 7:47 am

First of all i noticed that the Tigers stats match up favorably to the A’s. What suprises me How many innings Zumaya has pitched. He and Bonderman are the only two pitchers that did not go to College on this list, but I wonder if he was as highly touted as the rest of the group when he was drafted if he would not have already pitched in the show. Thirdly Verlanders stats look out of this world his controll is outstanding and nobody gets on base against him. Another pitcher who shot through the minors after a distinguished college carreer was Mark Prior. His minor league stats, when you take out his rehab assignments look like this.

Prior

51 13.9 3.18 2.29 1.31

OK so now I feel like i can get giddy, one thing that is impressive is that Prior never pitched in A ball he only pitched AA. And Verlanders bulk of innings came at A ball, However his seven starts and 32 innings at AA allowed only one earned run, in a word outstanding.

Im giddy all over again.

Jeff K

February 27, 2006 at 11:23 am

>>>I even gave the trio a nickname tripple J

Jeff K

February 27, 2006 at 11:25 am

Not sure what I did wrong there, but the rest of the message was supposed to be:

Only Tiger Fan in Mississippi A good read on the Tiger's inability to work any deals during the Winter Meetings.
http://www.freep.com/story/sports/mlb/tigers/2016/12/05/detroit-tigers-winter-meetings/95021824/
I have thought all was

StorminNorman$ http://www.mlbtraderumors.com/2016/12/red-sox-to-acquire-chris-sale.html
DD still making the moves - Sale traded to BOS... the "good news", now DET will only have to

Tony de Florida Agree, without Miggy and JV attendance should go in the tank unless we're getting Trout from the Angels or Jake

Smoking Loon Stormin, in my opinion Detroit is a worse and less interesting team without Verlander and Cabrera, a team without a

StorminNorman$ word on the street is that Tiger fans should get used to mediocrity, unless some of the young players and

Tony de Florida I've been too busy to add my wisdom (please control your laughter) but have been trying to read the blog

StorminNorman$ i could see DD bringing him to BOS to replace Big Sloppy, but i doubt BOS would give up much

Only Tiger Fan in Mississippi V-Mart trade talk:
http://m.tigers.mlb.com/news/article/209950064/tigers-victor-martinez-drawing-interest/
As we know, while the guy can certainly hit a baseball, he isn't the fastest thing around