SEARCH

This blog is in many ways a response to conversations I have had with many Christians over the last decade and more who are a part of the Pentecostal and charismatic movement [1], as I once was myself. Despite some differences with other Evangelicals it's evident that many Pentecostals nonetheless feel that actually we are all not too far apart in our basic theology, if at all. The idea is not uncommon: ‘when you boil it all down, we all really believe the same thing,’ right? But is it the case?

It’s a good question: What are the differences between charismatic and Pentecostal emphases and those of 'mainline' Evangelicals; and do they matter? And despite whatever distinctive emphases exist, do we actually disagree on any foundational truths?

For if our differing emphases do not prove to matter, and are founded on the same basic core beliefs, perhaps the way forward it to major on our common unity and begin to (or continue to?) work together towards the same ends.

But if our differing emphases really do prove to matter, and are founded on differing core beliefs, then other very important questions must be asked: Where does our disunity come from? What it the Biblical perspective on such disunity within the Church? Can unity be re-established and if so what would need to happen to establish a biblical unity? Can we work together at all towards the same end, and if so how?

In order to answer these questions, this blog attempts to offer a critical analysis of the distinctive emphases of the Pentecostal movement that are seen in charismatic emphases also, from an Evangelical perspective. [2] Pentecostals and charismatics alike have the view that the role of the Holy Spirit has been overlooked and under-emphasised within the Church at large for centuries, and that God has used their movements to bring his presence and work within the Church back into the light, in a way that has been ‘refreshing’, ‘awakening’, ‘renewing’, even 'reforming'.

This new and united focus on the role of the Spirit – his gifts and power - in relatively recent times has proved to be positive in many ways, however it has also generated many new understandings (or doctrines) on the role of the Spirit that are distinct from mainline Evangelicalism. What has been the effect of these new doctrines? The purpose of this blog is to firstly identify and explain these distinct emphases within charismatic circles and the Pentecostal movement, and where they came from. Secondly I attempt to explain where, how and why I think the Scriptures clearly differ with these emphases. Thirdly, I try to outline some of the effects these theological differences have had on the Christianity of Pentecostals and charismatics. Lastly what I want to do is answer some of these 'big picture' questions I've posed above.

My analysis involves obvious emphases that appear on the surface, but also more underlying beliefs evident only on a deeper level. Only after this is established can my basic questions be addressed: are the distinctive emphases of the charismatic and Pentecostal movements significant? When you boil it all down, do we all really believe the same thing?

My prayer for you as the reader is mine for myself also: that God would grant you an understanding of the Scriptures so that you will know Him better, that you would take great care to heed it's warnings and commands not to stray from sound doctrine (2 Timothy 4:3), and that in so doing you would save both yourself and your hearers (1 Timothy 4:16).

--

[1] The Pentecostal movement is so named because it’s most predominant distinctive concerns ‘baptism in the Spirit’, which relates to the Spirit’s coming at Pentecost (Acts 2). The ‘charismatic’ movement was so named because initially its most predominant distinctive was an emphasis on the active operation of the ‘gifts of the Spirit’ within everyday church life (‘charismatic’ literally means ‘gifts’). Though Pentecostalism has a series of churches specifically aligned with it (such as the Assemblies of God in Australia, for example), the charismatic movement is distinguished from Pentecostalism primarily because its influence operates within any Christian denomination.

[2] The majority of distinctives pointed out within the articles of this blog would certainly apply to both Pentecostals and charismatics, though it may well be that in each case Pentecostal beliefs will be better defined, accentuated more and more readily articulated than those of charismatics. Thinking in the charismatic movement is clearly diverse (and more so than within Pentecostalism), and so it is impossible to say what is the view held by everybody. I only attempt to make generalisations of characteristics that appear to be adhered to by the majority, and point out the differences or exceptions where I am aware of them.

Although Talking Pentecostalism is a site predominantly about Pentecostalism, it’s about Christianity more broadly too. The Pentecostal religion will 'reshape Christianity in the twenty-first century’. The Pentecostal or Pentecostalist movement and charismatic movements have become the most vigorous and fastest-growing family of Christians in the world. Unlike traditional Christianity which centers on the events of Easter and the crucifixion of Jesus, Pentecostal beliefs focus on the events surrounding the day of Pentecost and the outpouring of the Holy Spirit that began then. Since 1980 the Pentecost movement has been the largest family of Protestants in the world, not including the charismatic Pentecostals in the traditional mainline churches. Since 1995 the Pentecostals and Charismatics have in global numbers become the second largest family of Christians in the world, after the Roman Catholicism. More recent figures have indicated that today there are well over half a billion Pentecostal and Charismatic believers worldwide. So the size and growth rate alone of the Pentecostal movement means that Pentecostalism will affect everybody in one way or another, whether directly or indirectly. But not only are numbers up, Pentecostal thinking is also increasingly widespread. This is a movement, not primarily interested in record statistics, but seeking a radical transformation of Christian thinking. Today's leading Pentecostals have acknowledged the goal of the Pentecostal movement as a universal transformation of the church, both theologically and practically. It is because the Pentecostal seeks to spread Pentecostalism beliefs that it is having such a dramatic reshaping of Christianity. At the heart of the movement is the story of Pentecost itself, and their story that goes with this of how understanding Pentecost can reshape, and in fact restore, true Christianity to the believer. Pentecostal history begins at the turn of the nineteenth century, however more recently in the 1970s the Neo Pentecostal movement (or New Pentecostalism) spread into mainline church denominations when Pentecostal worship began to have a profound influence on traditional Christian services, inspiring the Pentecostal charismatic movement, now referred to simply as the Charismatics. The history of Pentecostalism is vital in understanding Pentecostal doctrine. What is Pentecost? On the day of Pentecost, Jesus baptized his Church with the Holy Spirit. What is Pentecost about in the New Testament? Talking Pentecostalism answers this question and others like it in detail. What is Pentecostal? Pentecostals believe that recovery of the doctrine and experience of being baptized in the Holy Spirit is comparable to the Reformation's recovery of the doctrine of justification by faith. The Pentecostal movement seeks to restore the experiential dimension of the Spirit's dynamic presence to the believer and collectively to a significant segment of the church. What is Pentecostalism about? Talking Pentecostalism answers this question in more than a little detail, and others like it. Christians need to understand Pentecostalism, not only because of an increasing number of Pentecostal and Charismatic Christians in our midst, but also because the stated goal of the movement is an intentional change to traditional Christian thought. People need to understand Pentecostalism in order to be aware of its affect on their own Christianity, or to their view of Christianity. Coupled with understanding the Scriptures themselves, understanding Pentecostalism is the best way to ensure you are responding rightly to this new influence in Christian history. What is the Holy Spirit? How is the Holy Spirit involved in Christianity? Who is the Holy Spirit? Talking Pentecostalism answers these questions and more. We go into details not only about the Holy Spirit, what is Holy Spirit, who is Holy Spirit, but also how Pentecostalism has understood the answers to these questions and how this differs to traditional teaching on the subject down through history as well as more recent and wider evangelical thought.

Christian discussion on the Pentecostal movement, the history and origin of Pentecostalism, Pentecostal belief, charismatic theology, Pentecostals and the doctrine of the Holy Spirit, the day of Pentecost, baptism in the Spirit, speaking in tongues, gifts of the Spirit, praise and worship, prosperity doctrine, divine healing, guidance, destiny and the voice of the Holy Spirit. An Evangelical critique of Pentecostalism - talkingpentecostalism.blogspot.com by Joe Towns.