It is certainly true of optical storage and right now blue laser technology.

Self proclaimed experts have been declaring each (BD, HD DVD) is winning and each is losing for months. Others proclaim that it will be DOA.

Let’s put this in perspective:

the orb we live on is about 4.5 billion years old

homosapiens have been wrecking it for about 200,000 years

no new technology has ever been introduced in the PC, CE industry without 2-3 or more views of the right approach

no new technology has ever entered mainstream as fast as we projected (hoped)

Think we’re wrong?

Figure 1

Take a look at figure 1. Things we take for granted today took a lifetime to be accepted.

According to the CEA none of these “gotta have” products are being used by 100% of the folks in the U.S. or anywhere else on the globe for that matter. Their research shows that as of early this year:

TVs had achieve a 95% penetration

VCRs – 87%

Cordless phones – 85%

DVD players – 81%

Cellphones – 78%

Now we’re asking all of these people to:

Upgrade their standard def TVs to HighDef (actually the government is telling them but a lot haven’t gotten the word)

Do away with a perfectly good VCR and get into the 21st century (you couldn’t work it anyway so big deal!!)

Throw out the DVD player they just got used to for even better viewing enjoyment (that sucks you just paid $30 for a new one)

DVD products hit the market in ’96 and the first movies (Twister was the first) were better than videotapes for sure. It was Costner’s Waterworld though that really highlighted the superior quality of DVD.

You could see the ripples in the water. You could see the vibrant flames. You could see the damn movie at every conference, every convention, every show you attended !!!

It was the success story of the industry:

Fastest sales ramp… ever !!!!

Tellywood brought out everything — new, old — to meet the insatiable demand

Prices dropped with a thud!

Serious pirates punched out millions of discs from stuff that was shot in the theater or studio reels

Casual pirates had the code breaker so they could sit in their dorms/bedrooms and use the rip ‘n return services for their libraries

All of this despite the fact that there were different views on the best technology (+/-). It became a moot point when Sony rolled out their multi burner (DVD+/-R/RW) which was later followed by super multi units (addition of DVD-RAM).

Blue laser was in the works even before DVD was introduced. It took more than seven years just to get the cost of the blue laser mechanism down and the performance reliability up before it could be considered anything but a great lab project.

Figure 2

During that time a lot of things changed in the ways we thought about, used, enjoyed our content (Figure 2):

mobile entertainment devices — audio/video

internet-based content — music, video, TV

DCMA, DMA, broken CSS, AACS

Even though we don’t have INet 2 or Net Neutrality, Sand Hill Road VCs are throwing big bucks at any start-up that says we deliver audio, video, content, news…

That’s right.

This is the next big goldmine for the Stanford MBAs.

All of the stars are in perfect alignment.

What? Oh crap !!! Someone forgot to ream out the pipe as much as the video requires (Figure 3).

No big deal. The new/old telcos will build out their pipelines right away. The cable folks will turn over all of their spare capacity. Satellite folks know the air is free. The people with the dark fiber in the ground will turn the lights on.

What do you mean we’ll talk about it???

Did you happen to notice something in Figure 2? Well… look again.

That circle centers on the home — apartment, dorm, trailer, lean-to, tent, whatever.

Not that it matters much in the short term since Toshiba prices are $599 and $700 while Samsung & Sony’s prices barely broke $1,000.

All are in limited availability — as is media — but that isn’t a huge problem in the immediate future. Tellywood is only just beginning to bring out some of their movies and they are surrounding them with some wicked content protection.

At the same time, the flat-panel TV folks have to get LCD and plasma sales moving in Europe and the Americas.

Sales have been slow because of spotty availability of real HighDef signals/shows combined with high cost and a general feeling… “what I’ve got is good enough for the time being.” Price incentives around the first of ’07 will help but retailers have to get their sales people trained in what they are selling. In addition, they need to show standard def and HighDef side by side so ordinary folks can actually see the difference.

Right now, good enough is… good enough.

Once the viewing quality difference is understood, shows are widely available and prices break $1,000; HighDef TV sales will increase.

Then we can really focus on blue laser burner/recorder/player sales.

The silly millimeter difference could be a non-issue for BD and HD DVD by the first of the year.

LG had announced a hybrid player but then said … “sorry bout that.”

However Ricoh could do for blue laser what Sony did for DVD. These guys know advanced optical technology and they have announced the availability of a solution that will read both BD and HD DVD.

They’ve shown the prototypes and will be delivering production samples for evaluation… shortly.

Get enough OEMs to sign on board and watch how quickly the other guys roll super super multi units into their product lines.

Consumers won’t give a rat’s behind about format differences. They’ll buy/rent the movies they want based on… the content!

Figure 4

Burner users will go to the store and buy media based on price… quality… the manufacturer’s reputation for quality.

Sure Sony will still push BD units with their PS3 when it is rolled out this Fall and that will help BD. The system will not only be a wicked game system but also a very inexpensive HighDef video player. Now all Microsoft has to do is get game developers and players enthused about the Xbox and they can offer a similar solution for HD DVD videos.

Oh sure Ballmer has to get Vista out… so what’s the problem?

Figure 5

Blue laser technology will have a slow ramp over the next few years (Figure 5) because a DVD gotta-have rush doesn’t come along that often.

It was a helluva run and it isn’t over. Today’s DVD burners/players/recorders are dirt cheap. Media (single and dual layer) is inexpensive, plentiful and wildly compatible.

Every movie worth a shilling is available on DVD. You can play them now and well into the future — even when the blue whatever units are “reasonable” or you decide to recycle your present system.

Especially when there are so many “enlightened self interest” people involved and so many new ideas are struggling for our attention… and our dollars.

ecoustics is the unbiased resource for the latest technology news, coolest gadgets, and best consumer electronics. Plus get product reviews, roundups and deals from all over the web on everything electronic. Read more →