X-23 Appreciation Post: My skin has turned to porcelain, to ivory, to steel

NOTICE: ON APRIL 30th 2014 THE CBR FORUMS WERE RESET AND ALL USER ACCOUNTS WERE CLOSED. TO JOIN THE NEW CBR FORUMS ALL PREVIOUS USERS NEED TO RE-REGISTER. All users, both new and returning, are expected to follow the CBR COMMUNITY STANDARDS & RULES.

If this is your first visit, be sure to
check out the FAQ by clicking the
link above. You may have to register
before you can post: click the register link above to proceed. To start viewing messages,
select the forum that you want to visit from the selection below.

Honestly, other than the name I don't know that we'd really notice the difference. Old Man Logan has been treated like he was the one and only Wolverine since Secret Wars.

Goddamit Old Man Logan! - Though I did appreciate the fact that Taylor established and acknowledged a relationship between Laura and OML during Civil War- the fact that they don't really get along shows me that Taylor probably also dislikes that he's been treated as the same character and therefore wanted to show a difference

My Favourite Quotes:

Emma/Kitty:"This children, is Kitty Pryde, who apparently feels the need to make a grand entrance/I'm sorry. I was busy remembering to put on all my clothes/So gushingly glad you could join us"

Emma:"I love what you've done with the place, Kitty. It's like every thirteen year-old girl's dream. Where do you keep the unicorns? And, oh look, a redhead. How novel"

Psylocke:"If you don't get that glass out of my face, I'm going to jam it sideways straight up your bum"

In fact, I'm trying to remember when the last time she got to play a significant role in ANY major event. Everything I can think of since Second Coming she's been shoveled off to tie-ins, or only getting a panel here or there.

As the current Wolverine, and more importantly Logan's DAUGHTER (they both acknowledge it, and there's the paperwork to prove it) if she doesn't have a significant part to play in this it's a complete foul on Marvel's part. Which would be par for the course considering how badly they dropped the ball on her being Wolverine in the first place.

I askes Zub. And shes involved in the events but ther keeping it huss huss for now. But she wont be in madrapoor.

She needs to be front and center in the main event. Laura hasn't gotten to play a significant role in an event since Second Coming.

During AvX she was stuck in the Avengers Academy tie-in. She was virtually sidelined in Trial of Jean Grey so Gamora and Angela could do everything in her skill set. She spent all of Black Vortex either unconscious (ESPECIALLY ridiculous because she was the ONLY character disabled like that. AND SHE WAS THE ONE WITH THE @#$%ING HEALING FACTOR) or trapped in amber. Death of Wolverine she only got to appear in the tie-in books, which weren't particularly important to what else was happening in the Marvel U at the time (and then she got punked by Mystique via massive PiS). During Original Sin she was stuck with the O5 in that shithole Ultimate Universe. I don't think she even appeared in No More Humans (though THAT, at least, makes sense; if there's no humans, Laura couldn't exist because there would be no one to make her). She appeared in precisely ONE panel in the ENTIRE Secret Wars event (and it was a tie-in). She only got a couple wallpaper appearances in Civil War II before her solo's tie-in took her out of the event entirely. Her appearances in IvX were token, and badly-written, besides. And yet AGAIN she only got a single panel during Secret Empire, which makes her "reward" from Kobik for standing up to Stevil almost meaningless (seriously, how much more profound would it have been had she been at the heart of the fighting from the start?).

Still hoping for that Helix Reunion...

Ron White says you can't fix stupid. I beg to differ. Stupid will usually sort itself out, it's just a matter of making sure you're not close enough to become collateral damage.

Honestly, other than the name I don't know that we'd really notice the difference. Old Man Logan has been treated like he was the one and only Wolverine since Secret Wars.

Alternate time line versions of folk who are actually dead being treated like the original folk is......fairly common. Kind of expected even.
Logan struggled with accepting AoA Kurt wasn't OUR Kurt during Liu's Astonishing iirc.
Rachel continually struggled with her "parents" not being the people she knew.
It was a mixed reception when Illyana came back. The "2.0" debate. Lord knows Colossus wasn't letting ANYONE argue the validity of her return. haha.

But anyhow, everyone needs to WAKE UP and realize this guy ISN'T THEIR LOGAN.

She needs to be front and center in the main event. Laura hasn't gotten to play a significant role in an event since Second Coming.

During AvX she was stuck in the Avengers Academy tie-in. She was virtually sidelined in Trial of Jean Grey so Gamora and Angela could do everything in her skill set. She spent all of Black Vortex either unconscious (ESPECIALLY ridiculous because she was the ONLY character disabled like that. AND SHE WAS THE ONE WITH THE @#$%ING HEALING FACTOR) or trapped in amber. Death of Wolverine she only got to appear in the tie-in books, which weren't particularly important to what else was happening in the Marvel U at the time (and then she got punked by Mystique via massive PiS). During Original Sin she was stuck with the O5 in that shithole Ultimate Universe. I don't think she even appeared in No More Humans (though THAT, at least, makes sense; if there's no humans, Laura couldn't exist because there would be no one to make her). She appeared in precisely ONE panel in the ENTIRE Secret Wars event (and it was a tie-in). She only got a couple wallpaper appearances in Civil War II before her solo's tie-in took her out of the event entirely. Her appearances in IvX were token, and badly-written, besides. And yet AGAIN she only got a single panel during Secret Empire, which makes her "reward" from Kobik for standing up to Stevil almost meaningless (seriously, how much more profound would it have been had she been at the heart of the fighting from the start?).

Considering how abysmally bad the Original Sin tie in was for Uncanny, I wouldn't complain about this particular omission. I call it dodging a bullet - that tie in was the absolute worst part of Bendis's Uncanny run, and it isn't even close. I'd even say it's worse than the next 3 low points combined.

Considering how abysmally bad the Original Sin tie in was for Uncanny, I wouldn't complain about this particular omission. I call it dodging a bullet - that tie in was the absolute worst part of Bendis's Uncanny run, and it isn't even close. I'd even say it's worse than the next 3 low points combined.

Honestly, complaining your favorite character isn't featured prominently in any event, is like complaining they were denied the opportunity to swim through %$#@.

Incidentally, Kyle has weighed in on Laura's Wolverine future, and if it was his choice he'd Laura would just go by her name and not use a code name at all. Taylor appears to concur.

You know if Logan takes back his mantle as the one true Wolverine I am all for Laura getting her own with her own supporting but not like how Liu did it and it was so obvious that it was done incase Laura and whatever cast they saddled her could not help her sell well.

I prefer codenames in most instances tbh. I think it's a big part of the superhero identity. Seems silly to have a costume and powers and not have an identity associated with it. X-23 is a regression, but if not Wolverine, then Talon or Ronin work for me. I'm sure there are other options too, but I'm yet to hear any that sound good