Giancarlo Frosio, ‘Right to Be Forgotten: Much Ado About Nothing’

Abstract:
In the information society, the role of private sector entities in gathering information for and about users has long been a most critical issue. Therefore, intermediaries have become a main focus of privacy regulations, especially in jurisdictions with a strong tradition of privacy protection such as Europe. In a landmark case, the ECJ ruled that an internet search engine operator is responsible for the processing that it carries out of personal data which appear on web pages published by third parties. The recognition by the European Union of a so called ‘right to be forgotten’ (RTBF) has ignited disgruntled reactions from civil society and legal scholars, especially in the United States. Meanwhile, proposals for the adoption of a similar right have appeared in several jurisdictions, including Brazil, Japan, Korea, and Russia. Supposedly, the right to be forgotten would endanger freedom of expression (FoE) and access to information. Apparently, factoids – defined by the Oxford Dictionary as ‘an item of unreliable information that is reported and repeated so often that it becomes accepted as fact’ – dominated the recent debate surrounding the right to be forgotten. This paper will discuss and debunk these factoids, review data protection legislation in Europe, and explore the legal and policy implications of the newly emerging right to be forgotten. Finally, the idea that extra-territorial application of the RTBF might unleash a kraken that can break down the Internet will be contextualized within the present political scenario. The extra-territorial application of the RTBF follows in the footsteps of a global move towards data protectionism against the de facto market dominance of US Internet conglomerates. Global blocking governed by a nationality principle – as suggested by CNiL and other EU institutions – would put to rest these protectionist concerns.

Frosio, Giancarlo F, Right to Be Forgotten: Much Ado About Nothing (January 31, 2017). 15(2) Colorado Technology Law Journal (2017 Forthcoming); Centre for International Intellectual Property Studies (CEIPI) Research Paper No 2017-03.

Conference on Empirical Legal Studies: University of Oslo, 11-12 June 2020

Due to the spread of COVID-19 and widespread introduction of restrictions on movement and assembly, the programme committee has, with deep regret, decided to postpone the conference in Oslo until 9-10 June 2022 … (more)

The Role of the Law of Unjust Enrichment in Asia: Online Conference, CUHK Graduate Law Center, Central, Hong Kong, 26 June 2020

The law of unjust enrichment is more or less recognized in all modern jurisdictions. The name suggests that nobody should enrich herself at the expense of another party. Details of even very fundamental aspects of the law of unjust enrichment are, however, highly disputed everywhere … (more)

IP Researchers Europe Conference: Geneva, 26-27 June 2020

Because of the COVID-19 health crisis, we have unfortunately decided that the safest course of action is to cancel IPRE 2020, which was planned for June 2020. We will organize the next edition of IPRE in late June 2021 … (more)

The 12th ISHTIP Annual Workshop, scheduled for 13-17 July at Bournemouth University, has been postponed to 2021 due to coronavirus pandemic … (more)

Obligations X: Harvard Law School, 14-17 July 2020

In light of the Covid-19 pandemic, Obligations X, currently scheduled for July 14-17, must be postponed. Our fond hope is that we will be able to hold the conference, more or less with its current line-up of speakers, panels, and papers, in the summer of 2021. However, we cannot yet say for certain whether that timing will work … (more)

If law is centred on human action and practices, key questions concerning rationality and practical reason in law arise. How shall we formulate a sound conception of practical reason for law? What is the correct understanding of the structure of rationality for law and how it differs from the rationality of other human practices? … (more)

SLS Annual Conference: Exeter, 1-4 September 2020

After careful consideration, and in light of the ongoing Coronavirus (COVID-19) pandemic, we have taken the decision to host the 111th Annual Conference of the Society of Legal Scholars virtually … (more)

Small Claims Dispute Resolution for Consumers – A European Approach: Brussels, 10 September 2020

The Università degli Studi di Napoli Federico II and Vrije Universiteit Brussel (VUB) are organising the final conference of the Small Claims Analysis Net (SCAN) project on the theme of Small Claims Dispute Resolution for Consumers (SCDRC 2020) … (more, call for papers)

We are pleased to invite submissions that aim to further comparative insight and learning on the ways in which different legal systems have grappled with particular public law and private law aspects of the pandemic … (more, call for papers)

The Conference on Empirical Legal Studies (CELS) meetings will not be held in 2020 … (more)

The Future of the Commercial Contract in Scholarship and Law Reform: Institute of Advanced Legal Studies, London, 16 October 2020

The 2020 conference explores topics in commercial contract law with a focus on sustainability, not only to combat climate change by contracts to promote the use of green energies but by supporting an ethical approach to supply chains … (more, call for papers)

This conference will bring together academics and legal practitioners to discuss recent developments relating to commercial contracts. Papers will be distributed before the conference, and the discussion started by an expert commentator … (more)

Paradigmatic Shifts in the History of Private Law (25th Ius Commune Workshop): Maastricht University, 26-27 November 2020

The workshops on ‘Comparative Legal History – Ius Commune in the Making’ aim to reveal and understand the nature and effects of various legal formants in the development of law. Indeed, forces of legal formants are too often lost or hidden beneath a superficies of commonalities … (more, call for papers)

Conference on Empirical Legal studies (CELSE): University of Oslo, 9-10 June 2022

The planned CELS-Europe 2022 conference will be held at the University of Oslo. A new call for papers will be announced in June 2021. The papers submitted for CELS-Europe 2020 can be considered afresh but new papers must be submitted if the current paper is published … (more)

Intermediaries play an important role in many aspects of commercial law. Yet there has been little focussed attention upon intermediaries as a crucial category of actors. The aim of this conference is to consider current issues concerning intermediaries from a number of different angles, adopting a range of methodological approaches … (more, call for papers)