holster for incase slider? solutions besides innocase?

i'm looking for a holster carry solution for the iPhone 4. i've been considering the innocase but have read very mixed reviews on the case (loose fit, peeling finish, etc) so am hesitant to go for it. is anyone else out there making a plastic holster solution?

has anyone tried the seidio holster with an incase slider? i've done some searching but only find one or two fleeting references to that combination, and not much info.

also considering the innocase rugged because i like the port covers, but again, fit, finish, etc.

I have the incase slider and also the Seidio innocase combo. The incase slider fits in the swivel clip but it's lose and could fall out. The incase slider is just a bit thinner/smaller. It's lose at the top near the clip more than the bottom. If we could get the incase slider case with the seidio cutouts in the combo it would be a killer combo case. The Seidio Innocase is a huge disappointment when comparing it to their older models.

MacRumors attracts a broad audience
of both consumers and professionals interested in
the latest technologies and products. We also boast an active community focused on
purchasing decisions and technical aspects of the iPhone, iPod, iPad, and Mac platforms.