Jack Hershey has a laughable 50 line method using stochastics and MACD's, they are not even in the same category of theoretical proof as Bill Schamp is.

The difference between writing a novel about how the market works and not why the market moves the way it does is a lot different than parroting knowledge we already have.

I would understand the skeptic nature of the markets, but Bill's theory Price Physics is the best theory I have ever read about market movement. There isn't any other one, so if you throw in the software to make it work then you'll be getting somewhere.

Bill really should but I'm sure they'll find it too commercial and not at all academic, but that doesn't change how good his theory works. Jack's as far as I'm concerned is confined to autocorrelated 15 minute bars between market hours, and the order of magnitude difference in utility is very obvious from a 9:30 to 4 affair to 24 hour 6 day a week affair.

There is no difference. Jack Hershey doesn't deserve anything for his quaint method, but as far as Bill is concerned he certainly should win a nobel prize for what he's done.