*Membership spots not really limited!

Zombie Guard

I've read the book, but can't quite muster up feelings to review it. It was pretty well done stuff, but nothing too exciting or game changing. It'd probably get a seven but the review might as well be the word 'competent' in big letters.

Zombie Guard

I've read the book, but can't quite muster up feelings to review it. It was pretty well done stuff, but nothing too exciting or game changing. It'd probably get a seven but the review might as well be the word 'competent' in big letters.

Zombie Guard

Then you review it with those criteria in mind. For me if the book isn't worth buying then I'm not going to give it a high score. Book I like gets a good score, book I don't gets a crap score. This book failed to elicit any real reaction for me, good or bad. It was neither exceptionally good nor bad and when reading it I didn't have anything I felt the need to bring up when talking about it.

Zombie Guard

Then you review it with those criteria in mind. For me if the book isn't worth buying then I'm not going to give it a high score. Book I like gets a good score, book I don't gets a crap score. This book failed to elicit any real reaction for me, good or bad. It was neither exceptionally good nor bad and when reading it I didn't have anything I felt the need to bring up when talking about it.

Staff Writer

Zero wrote:Then you review it with those criteria in mind. For me if the book isn't worth buying then I'm not going to give it a high score. Book I like gets a good score, book I don't gets a crap score. This book failed to elicit any real reaction for me, good or bad. It was neither exceptionally good nor bad and when reading it I didn't have anything I felt the need to bring up when talking about it.

But you haven't even reviewed it! Competence should at least merit a 100 or so words.

Staff Writer

Zero wrote:Then you review it with those criteria in mind. For me if the book isn't worth buying then I'm not going to give it a high score. Book I like gets a good score, book I don't gets a crap score. This book failed to elicit any real reaction for me, good or bad. It was neither exceptionally good nor bad and when reading it I didn't have anything I felt the need to bring up when talking about it.

But you haven't even reviewed it! Competence should at least merit a 100 or so words.

Regular-Sized Poster

Wow, that was really bad. Very by the numbers and overdrawn horribly. I saw the Steve the trained soldier thing before it even happened. I expected better from Bru.

3

doombug wrote:You really are the george carlin of the outhouse. that's fucking hilarious.

doombug wrote:and yeah, Yoni called it.

I feel like a condemned building with a brand new flag pole.- Les Paul

******

by ****** » Fri Sep 24, 2010 10:32 am

Steve Rogers: Super-Soldier #3

I love Ed Brubaker's Cap. I can honestly say that in the last 5+ years there hasn't been a single issue of his run that I haven't enjoyed. The characters, the stories, the tone... it all just clicks perfectly for me. It doesn't really matter what the title of this book is, to me it's a Brubaker Cap comic and just like every other Brubaker Cap comic it thoroughly kicks ass. It's great to be able to read a comic with Steve being Steve, it kind of makes me feel like all is right with the world. It doesn't matter if he's wearing a Cap costume or not.

Dale Eaglesham is a freaking beast. When the day comes that Steve is the lead in the Captain America book again, I hope Eaglesham will be the regular artist. Great storytelling. Beautiful aesthetics.

Story: 9Art: 9Overall: 9

******

I love Ed Brubaker's Cap. I can honestly say that in the last 5+ years there hasn't been a single issue of his run that I haven't enjoyed. The characters, the stories, the tone... it all just clicks perfectly for me. It doesn't really matter what the title of this book is, to me it's a Brubaker Cap comic and just like every other Brubaker Cap comic it thoroughly kicks ass. It's great to be able to read a comic with Steve being Steve, it kind of makes me feel like all is right with the world. It doesn't matter if he's wearing a Cap costume or not.

Dale Eaglesham is a freaking beast. When the day comes that Steve is the lead in the Captain America book again, I hope Eaglesham will be the regular artist. Great storytelling. Beautiful aesthetics.

Story: 9Art: 9Overall: 9

******

by ****** » Fri Sep 24, 2010 11:17 am

Last call for SR:SS reviews! I'll be posting a front page thingy after I get back from lunch. I would do it now, but I'm hungry!

Front page things should be back on a regular schedule next week, my FY10 is officially over and I can go back to being my slack happy self!