Console Wars

The 2006 holiday season is finally here: let the gift giving, store camping and mall looting officially begin! As usual, some of the hottest items around this year are the new next-generation gaming consoles: the PlayStation 3, Xbox 360 and Nintendo Wii. With the release of the PlayStation 3 on Nov. 17, people were trampled, shot at, robbed and generally disappointed as they tried to get their hands on limited units of the coveted game console. With less scandal, the Nintendo Wii debuted 2 days later, along with a considerably lower price and many fewer customer grievances. A year ago, the Xbox 360 flew off the shelves, selling 10 million units within 16 months of the release date, according to CNET. Which one of these souped up gaming machines it right for you? SCO gives you a look at the hardware, support and games backing each in your quest for the ultimate holiday gaming machine.

Pros
Released a full year before its competition, the Xbox 360 benefits from a wide selection of solid game titles as well as from a fully developed support network. Perhaps one of the greatest appeals of the Xbox 360 is the fully developed Xbox Live online gaming network, which serves an estimated 4 million customers, offering online cooperative play for popular games like Call of Duty 2 and downloadable retro games. Reverse compatibility is currently available with some Xbox games, including popular favorites like the Halo and the Tom Clancy series, as well as Super Monkey Ball Deluxe.

Cons
Technologically, the Xbox 360 is a full year behind the PlayStation 3, and can't measure up to the technical specs of its rival. Suffering from a lack of new original features, the Xbox 360 simply builds on the original Xbox elements and adds a wider selection of games and online capabilities, as well as occasional fatal error crashes.

Availability and Price
Because of the earlier release date, the Xbox 360 is currently widely available for $300 (base model) and $400 (premium model  same as base, except with 20 GB hard drive and some accessories like chrome finish, Ethernet cable and Xbox Live headset).

Verdict
The Xbox 360 console is a solid gaming system which currently offers a wide array of games and online services, but lacks creativity and original features, as expected of a next generation gaming console.

Services Offered
Sony promises a free online gaming service to come in the near future, as well as the ability to download PlayStation 1 and 2 games online for a fee.
Internet browsing and extensive video, music and picture playback from built-in hard drive.

Pros
In theory the most advanced of the 3 consoles, the PS3's Cell processor offers a unique multi-tasking and simultaneous processing power that gives it a significant graphical edge over its competitors. 7800+ PlayStation and PlayStation 2 titles are compatible with the PS3, and along with newly released titles, give it the widest selection of any of the consoles. The console also features a motion sensing controller similar in concept to that of the Wii's, but doesn't integrate it as fully into any of the currently released titles.

Cons
No current functioning online multiplayer network, a limited array of first release games that fully take advantage of the computing power of the Cell processor and a solid $600 (for the premium model with 60 GB hard drive) price tag knocks the system down a notch.

Availability and Price
Yeah, right. With units selling out moments after stores opened for them and organized mobs roaming the mall looking for more, a buyer's best bet is to either shell out $2,000 on eBay or wait a couple of months for the rage to subside.

Verdict
Though marginally superior technically, the PS3 offers much in the line of the same games as the Xbox and Wii, and its limited availability and hefty price make the PlayStation 3 a difficult buy this holiday season.

Pros
Of the three consoles, the Wii is the only one to offer a truly innovative and new idea, the motion tracking, rumbling Wii-mote controller along with sports games like tennis, bowling and boxing. Slim, small and wireless, the Wii-mote fits snugly in the player's hands and allows him to execute the moves of his favorite games by waving his hands instead of button mashing. Along with a fair selection of games, many classic Nintendo games', such as Zelda, Mario and Starfox, are gearing their next game installments towards working exclusively with the Wii controllers.

Cons
The Wii lacks the raw computing force of the other consoles, the technical components on par with those of the original Xbox. Thus, its graphics tend not to be as good as the competition, and it cannot fully support large HD monitors. Also, there have been several incidents with Wii controllers flying out of overenthusiastic player's hands and damaging televisions, computers, windows and other people (see Wii Have A Problem
for more details).

Availability and Price
Introduced along with the PS3, the Wii has sold 600,000 units in its first week and it remaining a difficult find, priced at a reasonable $250. And of course, there's always the doubled Ebay price.

Verdict
Originality and fun with the new Wii-motes, as well as a better value and larger selection of games (more than 50 planned for several weeks after release time) give the Wii a step up above the competition, though this console is not without its flaws, such as poorer graphics and limited early release games.

So there you have it, gaming fans, the three top items on every fanboy/girl's holiday shopping list. Will you brave the violent mall hordes for a PlayStation 3, settle for a $500 Ebay Wii or mercilessly crush your enemies in an Xbox Live tournament? The choice is up to you.

Discuss this Article

Silver Chips Online invites you to share your thoughts about this article. Please use this forum to further discussion of the story topic and refrain from personal attacks and offensive language. SCO reserves the right to deny any comment. No comments that include hyperlinks will be posted. If you have a question for us, please include your email address or use this form.

You sir are spouting faulty data. 74 billion Vs 48 billion calculations for the GPU. Your flat out full of crap.

I don't know where you are getting your information from but the bottom line is that the GPU can display almost twice as many triangles on the 360. The PS3 has only half of the full memory access as the 360, the General purpose processing is 3 times better on the 360, and the blue ray disk reads much slower than a standard DVD.

Look at the games. pick one game that's on both consoles that looks better on the "super charged" playstation 3 and you will win the gold at the end of the rainbow, oh wait thats what the ps3 cost you in the first place.

Nice article Boris! I like it! The sarcasm is a really good way to boost your holiday spirit when buying consoles!
Xbox 360 so far seems the best, even though they should make an add-on like the PS3 controller with motion senser, that would be so awesome!!!!!
I heard about those stories where TV's break due to the Wii controllers. hahaha, this is what you get when you put physical activity and videos games together, they just don't mix that well!

Blu-ray is pointless (too slow), PS3 costs way too much, and the starting games are kinda boring...
Wii has the the coolest controllers tho, but the 360 is by far the most useful, and has the best games. Halo2, Elder Scrolls 4, Gears of War, Call of Duty 3!?!?! (Which is also for the 360 as well as the PS3)
360 is owning all the other.
If you don't believe me, check out Gears of War, that game looks to awesome!!! I can't wait until they get a PC version cuz i don't have a console, tho some of my friends do.

Sony makes flimsey systems. When i bought my Xbox360 a month or so ago, the store salesman told me that the display PS3 had broken within a day of setting it up and that the 2 ones he had sold had broken. Not much of a suprise there, my PS2 broke within a year of me getting it. Xbox360 is looking to be the best so far.