Re: "Times" reviewer channels Edmund Wilson, is roundly put down...

Nay-saying the Beatles??? Now, *that is* blasphemy. I ll take Galadriel over those wasting-away love sick heroines who die tragically -- if

Message 1 of 4
, Mar 31 9:17 AM

0 Attachment

Nay-saying the Beatles??? Now, *that is* blasphemy. <smile>

I'll take Galadriel over those "wasting-away" love sick heroines who
die tragically -- if operatically -- any old day.

Of course, as warrior-pricess *fans* go, it may be the facat that
Eowyn's creater wasn't obsessed by her tits but by her character that
makes her less appealing to them. <she says sarcastically>. Lezlie

--- In mythsoc@yahoogroups.com, Mike Foster <mafoster@...> wrote:
>
> It's, yawn, the same old Opposing Viewpoints doo-dah that, as a
> recovering newspaper reporter, I am accustomed to. One can always find
> a Nay-sayer whether the topic be the Beatles or Shakespeare. Say,
maybe
> we can find an Oxford don to beat up on Will if we look hard enough.
>
> David Bratman wrote:
>
> >In a word, yes: he only thinks that Gueneveres and Iseults count.
Anyone
> >who could lay out as his ideal women in medieval romance two cases of

Your message has been successfully submitted and would be delivered to recipients shortly.