Hello! I don’t know if you take requests but I would love to see DreamCatcher’s Siyeon, Yoohyeon and SuA (maybe JiU too) analysed (they all debuted as DreamCatcher this year but debuted as MinX in 2014)
here are some live performances:

What’s your definition of a good vocalist, if I may ask? The people on the “never going to be analyzed list” break the rules we established with 1. rappers, 2. Analyzing more than half of the vocalists in a group and 3. Analyzing ex-members of groups, like Sera. Analyzing V breaks none of these rules, but if we WHOM we analyze is what causes you to doubt our credibility instead of reading the analyses, then it feels like to me that you’re just looking for an excuse to discredit what we do…if that’s so, if you’re not reading the content and not reading the rules but focusing on who’s not analyzed, then I can’t help you there.

Hello! First of all I’d like to thank you for making these posts and videos, there are many times when I see commenting and using musical vocabulary wrong. I really do hope they find your videos/posts. Anyway I’ve always been wondering about seventeen’s Dk and Vromance vocals from a professional standpoint. If it’s ok, can I ask you to analyze one of them? If not, thanks anyway for taking some time out to read this comment 😊

Hi I don’t know if this will qualify since winner lost their main vocalist but there has been a shift on how they tackle their songs. And somehow I notice that Kim jinwoo also have a very interesting husky lower range? not sure but I feel the he can go lower than what seungyoon usually go for. I am curious if he’s a baritone or a tenor? Thanks! https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=gHoEL6VaCcc

Jinwoo does not support and his voice has absolutely no weight. He is most definitely a tenor and that has always been clear. The lowest note in this clip that you sent was G#3, which is really not a low note at all. I’m not sure where you’re hearing the husky lower range, but he’s not really singing low and unfortunately I don’t think we’d analyze his vocal technique. I apologize.

Eunwoo doesn’t really support fully. She’s very tight when she sings, with mostly a high larynx. Her pitch is good, her voice is pretty but her runs can be a bit messy and she lacks consistent support. This is better than I usually hear from her though.

Her placement is in lower inside her mouth, her throat and then in her nose. She doesn’t really lift her soft palate, she doesn’t place the sound forward nor high enough. She doesn’t open up, she doesn’t connect. There’s a lot of raspy scratchiness coming from the lack of connection between her vocal cords. Her tone reminds me of an untrained Baek Yerin. She barely has a mix, she’s mostly going into a very raspy head voice. It’s not the most challenging song when it comes to dynamics because the song doesn’t go anywhere.

It’s funny you mentioned Baek Yerin because she actually covered Bye Bye My Blue. I know the video is short but how did she do ??I hope you don’t mind me posing other videos of but she said that she was preparing to study opera in college which leads me to believe that she already had some sort of vocal training.

hi there! If you have time could you evaluate a bit about the three vocalists from Vietnam in this performance? https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=ADaA2XuJi5c
I know this is meant to be a kpop vocalist blog and I’m sorry for burdening you. If necessary, you might delete this comment. But thank you nonetheless for the hard work!

I’m sorry but I cannot do that. We have a rule in which we do not answer video questions about vocalists we won’t write full analyses for. Which means non-kpop vocalists are always excluded. I do apologize. No need to delete the comment, it can help other people find out that we don’t answer these questions. ^ ^

Well the exercises in vocal tips #8 focus on developing proper vocal cord connection and air management while keeping the vocal cords exercised in a quieter volume. The two note exercise is great for focusing on dynamics and developing support over pushing.

It’s got nothing to do with voice type. Husky is a rough kind of thick and raspy quality. Most people use it loosely and interchangeably with raspy or even throaty. I don’t find that any of these vocalists aside from Junhoe sing in a husky way.

Hello. Kpopvocalanalysis. you did a great job!! thank you very much!!! sorru for my english. i want to ask you about analysis for musical actor of Korea. like Park Eun Tae, Kim Seung Dae, Jeon Don Seok. korean musical is wonderful world and full of good vocalist. so maybe you can anakysis for them?? it will be great i think. thank you

Hello guys your fans missed you a lot you didn’t post anything since February what happened?? I hope you all doing great and having fun. By the way did you listen to the new GG gidle I am super curious about them I am definitely sure that miyeon is weak vocalists to maybe average but how about yuqi the girl with the deep voice if you watched any of gidle MV. I believe yuqi and Minnie are the best vocalists in gidle .thank you so much for taking time to consider my questions. 😘😘😘

hey ahmin, hope you are doing well. I was just wandering if there will be another vocal analysis that will be posted this year? I know you are probably busy living in korea and such so maybe it’s too much of an ask?ㅠㅠ