Depends on where and when in Batman's career they aiming for. But anyone over 40 for a Batman that hasn't met Robin yet doesn't seem right.

I want to see an already established Batman, before any of the "colorful" villains show up. Years of just busting criminals, trying to take down the mob, similar to that portion of Batman Begins. Use a more natural, realistic, believable villain.

In THAT setup, I really like Anson Mount. I think he would be perfect for the role, personally.

I really want to see Long Halloween and Dark Victory adapted. But since the Mob is done and the freaks are out. TLH seems like it would just rehash Batman Begins. So a Dark Victory adaption where an Older 16/17 Robin is introduced would be very welcome by me. Just have Penguin take two-Face's role. And instead of bringing all those "Freaks", just have Penguin hire Black Mask. Keep The Carmine's and Keep Sofia as the Hangman.

I still like the idea of a modified Batman Year Two story which BMOTP is based on.

Batman has been operating in Gotham for a couple of years while taking on the criminal empire run by the mysterious Black Mask. However once the Reaper appears and begins to target mobsters and cops, Detective Yin reluctantly works with Batman to stop this new killer stalking the streets. Her partner Harvey Bullock who sees Batman as a menace , grows weary as his partner is drawn deeper and deeper into Batman's world putting her own life at risk. As the stakes are raised, Batman finds that he needs a way into the mob world in order to stop Black Mask and the Reaper which ultimately results in consulting a criminal Joe Chill, the man who he believes murdered his parents.

I got to be totally honest. Do we NEED a Batman reboot? I mean, it's only been a few months since the Dark Knight rises release? Give Superman his time in the spotlight, wait at least 3 or 5 years, and THEN do a reboot.