Featured Post

Sunday, March 10, 2013

Keller of 'NYT' Wrong: Bradley Manning Stated Motivations Early On

UPDATE #2 Audio of Manning's statement in court leaked, and now published.

UPDATE #1 Nathan Fuller of Manning Support Network writes that he emailed Keller and got reply that he believes column is fair and is standing by it. Pressed on this, citing my critique and others, Keller replied in an email: "Sorry, but it really seems to me that some people who have decided
Manning is a hero have assembled a coherent political motivation by
fishing here and there in the Lamo file. Reading the whole transcript, I
found tidbits of political motivation scattered among a host of other
motivations." Note to Bill: I have never written that Manning is a "hero."

Earlier: Last week Bradley Manning in his lengthy statement at his hearing revealed for the first time that he had called the NYT public editor before contacting WikiLeaks--left a message and did not get his call returned. So now Bill Keller, who was the top editor of the paper at that time--and later published hundreds of stories based on Manning material (while also bashing Julian Assange)--takes up the question of what might have happened if the Times had returned the call, in a column.

First of all, I can say with some confidence that The Times would have
done exactly what it did with the archive when it was supplied to us via
WikiLeaks: assigned journalists to search for material of genuine
public interest, taken pains to omit information that might get troops
in the field or innocent informants killed, and published our reports
with a flourish. The documents would have made news — big news.

But somewhat less of it. While in reality The Times and the public
benefited from a collegial partnership with London’s Guardian and other
papers that took part in the WikiLeaks fiesta, I’m pretty sure that if
we had been the sole recipient we would not have shared Manning’s gift
with other news organizations. That is partly for competitive reasons,
but also because sharing a treasury of raw intelligence, especially with
foreign news media, might have increased the legal jeopardy for The
Times and for our source.

There's much to pick through in this column. I love the part where he blames Manning for not getting through to the Times--when it was a Times editor who did not return his call. Then there's the part where he brags about a Times editorial hitting the military for keeping Manning in solitary confinement--months after this became known. But for now I'll focus on one major Keller mistake (nothing new for him). Yes, we've known for a long time now about Manning's social/sexual issues that probably contributed to his decision to leak. But Keller charges that we knew little about Manning's motives in leaking, what evils he saw, because in his chat logs with Lamo, "When asked, he has trouble recalling any specific outrages that needed
exposing. His cause was 'open diplomacy' or — perhaps in jest — 'worldwide anarchy.'”

This is false, as I detailed in my two books on the case. Manning, in fact, told Lamo about U.S. crimes in Iraq and Afghanistan, some that he witnessed himself, others that he observed via that helcopter video, and more. For example:

i think the thing that got me the most... that made me rethink the world more than anything...was watching 15 detainees taken by the Iraqi
Federal Police... for printing "anti-Iraqi literature"... the iraqi
federal police wouldn't cooperate with US forces, so i was instructed to
investigate the matter, find out who the "bad guys" were, and how
significant this was for the FPs... it turned out, they had printed a
scholarly critique against PM Maliki... i had an interpreter read it for
me... and when i found out that it was a benign political critique
titled "Where did the money go?" and following the corruption trail
within the PM's cabinet... i immediately took that information and *ran*
to the officer to explain what was going on... he didn't want to hear
any of it... he told me to shut up and explain how we could assist the
FPs in finding *MORE* detainees...

everything started slipping after that... i saw things differently...I was actively involved in something I was completely against.

This would seem clear enough. But Keller compounds his error by then suggesting that when Manning spelled out the outrages and motives in his recent statement he might have only been "shaped" to the applause of his biggest backers. A sickening claim, and based on the Lamo chat logs, wrong.

More from the Lamo chat log: It virtually opens with Manning saying he had seen evidence of "awful things" such as at Gitmo and Bagram. Then he mentions "criminal political dealings" and cites the "buildup to the Iraq war." He details what he saw on the "Collateral Murder" video and why he wanted it released ("I want people to see the truth"). He wants to get this and much else out (he IDs more) because it might "actually change something." As for the State Dept. cables, he hopes they will spark "worldwide discussion, debates and reforms." Yet Keller claims this was all "vague."

You'd think Bill would be a little more humble this week, as we get ready to mark the start of our tragic adventure in Iraq 10 years ago--an invasion Keller backed as a self-proclaimed "liberal hawk." Also see how Keller tried to explain his support for the war.

Greg Mitchell's book "So Wrong For So Long,"
on media misconduct and the Iraq war, was published today in an updated
edition and for the first time as an e-book, with preface by Bruce
Springsteen.

is author of a dozen books (click on covers at right), including the new "THE TUNNELS: Escapes Under the Berlin Wall and the Historic Films the JFK White House Tried to Kill." He was the longtime editor of Editor & Publisher. Email: epic1934@aol.com. Twitter: @GregMitch

2 comments:

I read the opening paragraphs of BK's editorial this morning and put it down; even as an only casual newsreader, I still felt uncomfortable reading BK's version. I didn't know the details you refer to, or even of the existence of these Lamo comments. I've never gotten over my disillusionment with the NY Times over the Iraq War.

ORDER MY NEW BOOK

Just published in October by Crown. Click on cover (above) to order at nice discount. It's a thrilling history of escape tunnels--under the Berlin Wall--and JFK's attempt to suppress NBC and CBS films about them at the height of the Cold War.. Hailed by The New York Times Book Review, Bill Moyers, and Frederick Forsyth, among others, and feaured by NPR"s Scott Simon. Paul Greengrass attached to direct movie. "A fascinating and complex picture of the interplay between politics and media in the Cold War era.” -- Washington Post. "A gripping, blow-by-blow account."--Publishers Weekly (starred review).

"Atomic Cover-up": Shocking suppression of U.S. film

How U.S. buried for decades the key footage from Hiroshima shot by the U.S. military. Click on cover above for my popular book and e-book.

Hollywood and The Bomb

My book on MGM's 1947 epic on Hiroshima and creating the first bomb--and the White House censorship that wrecked it. E-book just $2.99.

My Book on the Bomb with Robert Jay Lifton

Acclaimed book on nuclear culture, and political and psychological fallout in the USA. Written with Robert Jay Lifton. Click on cover to read more or order.

Award-Winning 'Campaign of the Century''

"Upton Sinclair's Race for Governor of California--and the Birth of Media Politics": Amazingly influential and wild 1934 race with great relevance for today.

New Edition of my book on Bush, and Media, Failures on Iraq

Preface by Bruce Springsteen. "Read this book--twice." -- Bill Moyers

New Edition of Our Beethoven Book!

G.M.'s book w/ Kerry Candaele, a tie-in to our new acclaimed film. E-book and print.

New Edition of my "Tricky Dick and The Pink Lady"

The notorious Nixon-Douglas race in 1950, a New York Times Notable Book, now in new print and e-book versions.

"Vonnegut and Me" E-book

Conversations and close encounters with the novelist. Click cover for more. $2.99.

How the President and the Military Censored MGM's Anti-Nuke Epic!

The truly wild and important story on the unmaking of 'Most Important Movie Ever Made.' Just $3.29. Click cover to order.

My Latest Book: On Hollywood Politics!

Why and when did the movie biz turn "liberal"? The full and fun story, and the left-wing election campaign that sparked it. Click on cover for more. $3.99.

Unique E-Book on the Obama-Romney Race

Probes campaign 2012 and the aftermath--plus 500 clickable links to key stories and videos! Just $2.99. Click on image above to read more or order.

Search This Blog!

New Edition of U.S. vs. Pvt. Manning Book

Updated: The saga of the whistleblowing soldier, written with Kevin Gosztola. Hailed by Glenn Greenwald, Daniel Ellsberg. Click cover for more.

About Me

is author of a dozen books (click on covers at right), including the new "THE TUNNELS: Escapes Under the Berlin Wall and the Historic Films the JFK White House Tried to Kill." He was the longtime editor of Editor & Publisher. Email: epic1934@aol.com. Twitter: @GregMitch