Author
Topic: Running torsion box through planer (Read 6244 times)

I am doing a floating shelf using a torsion box thing. Bottom skin is flat. Is it a terrible idea to run it through the planer before gluing on the top skin? It is 1/4 inch ply if it makes any difference.

Festool USA does not pre-approve the contents of this website nor endorse the application or use of any Festool product in any way other than in the manner described in the Festool Instruction Manual. To reduce the risk of serious injury and/or damage to your Festool product, always read, understand and follow all warnings and instructions in your Festool product's Instruction Manual. Although Festool strives for accuracy in the website material, the website may contain inaccuracies. Festool makes no representations about the accuracy, reliability, completeness or timeliness of the material on this website or about the results to be obtained from using the website. Festool and its affiliates cannot be responsible for improper postings or your reliance on the website's material. Your use of any material contained on this website is entirely at your own risk. The content contained on this site is provided for informational purposes only and does not constitute professional advice.

The short cross pieces are the only concern. They will likely get knocked over but as long as they end up below the long strips (don't interfere with the bond between long strips and skin) you're okay.

If you want to you can grind the tops of the short strips (right angle grinder) to be sure the cutter head rides above them, or wait and see if you need to do that after.

In the grand scheme of torsion boxes the short strips are only needed to keep the long strips upright. They don't need to be glued to the skin.

"In the grand scheme of torsion boxes the short strips are only needed to keep the long strips upright."

That makes me wonder if I used way too many short pieces. It is very light and very stiff even without the other side skinned, but if I build something larger, like a torsion box miter saw stand or workbench, using thicker materials, I would want to avoid unnecessary weight by having too many short strips.

"In the grand scheme of torsion boxes the short strips are only needed to keep the long strips upright."

That makes me wonder if I used way too many short pieces. It is very light and very stiff even without the other side skinned, but if I build something larger, like a torsion box miter saw stand or workbench, using thicker materials, I would want to avoid unnecessary weight by having too many short strips.

The shorts are only needed to keep the long strips upright, but that is a very important job, especially with relatively wiggly stuff like 1/4" ply. If the long strip gets crooked it's likely to produce high spots that would jeopardize adhesion of the skin.

Check out Sing Panels. They have it down. They use thin vertical grain strips for maximum compression resistance and minimum dead weight with foam blocks to support and regulate the distribution of the strips. I'd like to know how they manufacture the blocks. I guess a hot wire cutter to avoid the foam beads...

Scroll down to the bottom of that page to see a very interesting panel.

FWIW...if this were my project, I'd run it through the planer. The most important part is to just lean on it by a max .005"-.010" per cut, just a whisper of a cut. Less is more in this application. Especially the first cut because that's where you're leveling the surface. Just take it easy, a hair thickness at a time and you'll be ok. The longitudinal strips are fine it's the perpendicular members that may become a problem. Then again, the perpendicular members are not the major structural elements for this shelf, it's the horizontal members that support the skin.

Before I had a big drum sander I would take my stuff to my hardwood supplier that is also a staircase building. He would charge $5 per minute of sanding, that panel would take about 2 minutes. In reality, he never once charged me. Check out whoever builds cabinets in your area and ask what they would charge you - it would probably be free. Slip the guy running the machine $10 and you have a sanding source for life.

It appears the consensus is that a drum sander would be the right tool and that a hand plane would also work, but there is no clear consensus about what would happen on the planer, and no one reported having tried it. At the same time, there was no suggestion that light passes would be dangerous or would damage the planer like trying to run an end grain cutting board through it. In light of the altruistic nature of the FOG forum (and lack of ready access to a drum sander), I feel compelled to try it and report the results. If it explodes, at least we will have a little more information for future use and I won't be set back that much. Will try this tomorrow and report back, hopefully with a video from both sides.

It appears the consensus is that a drum sander would be the right tool and that a hand plane would also work, but there is no clear consensus about what would happen on the planer, and no one reported having tried it. At the same time, there was no suggestion that light passes would be dangerous or would damage the planer like trying to run an end grain cutting board through it. In light of the altruistic nature of the FOG forum (and lack of ready access to a drum sander), I feel compelled to try it and report the results. If it explodes, at least we will have a little more information for future use and I won't be set back that much. Will try this tomorrow and report back, hopefully with a video from both sides.

I hope this works out for you but for your safety I would limit the video to what you can take from the input side and minimize your physical presence on the output side.

I'd consider that a successful result. The only thing I would have done differently would have been to decrease the feed depth, you can hear it in the sound of the planer...back it off by about half and she'd be good to go. This would be really interesting if you installed a Shelix cutter, you'd have even less tear out as it's taking an even smaller instantaneous amount of bite out of the structure.