NFL Labor Deal Looks Like Win-Win For Players, Owners

DeMaurice Smith, executive director of the National Football League Players' Association talks with reporters on July 25, 2011 in Washington, DC. The NFL players and owners are set to agree on a labor deal and end the current lockout.DeMaurice Smith (L) executive director of the National Football League Players' Association and NFL Commissioner Roger Goodell (R) address the the media on July 25, 2011 in Washington, DC. The NFL players and owners announced they have reached agreement and ended the lockout. (credit: Rob Carr/Getty Images)

It took a 4½-month lockout to do it, but players came away with better salaries and benefits and safer working conditions. Owners, meanwhile, gain a higher percentage of the more than $9 billion in annual league revenues that figure to rise significantly.

“If you felt this was kind of like a pre-nup, where you needed an out clause, well, for the most part — and some people have different opinions on this — you probably shouldn’t get married then if you’re going into it like that,” said Jets guard Brandon Moore. “Our negotiation committee and (NFLPA head DeMaurice Smith) did a great job in to help us understand that the deal was going to be the best deal. There was no need for an opt-out.”

“The whole deal for everybody is truly an upgrade,” Chicago Bears kicker and player representative Robbie Gould said Monday. “If you look at the whole concept of the deal — for the owners, obviously, they wanted a percentage back. We gave them a percentage back. For the players, workers compensation, the revenue sharing.

The biggest issue involved splitting revenue. In the new 10-year deal, the split is about 53 percent to owners and 47 percent to players. The old collective bargaining agreement was close to a 50-50 arrangement.

“This new agreement is fair for both sides. Neither side got everything they wanted,” San Diego Chargers president Dean Spanos said. “It will give us labor peace for 10 years and helps secure the long-term future of the game. It will allow pro football to be even better, safer and more competitive, and to grow and prosper into the future.”

On the plus side for the players, there’s:

— an increase in salaries and benefits, with the salary cap at $120 million, plus $22 million in benefits, for 2011. Owners must spend 99 percent of the salary cap in 2011-12 in cash;

— minimum salary increases of $50,000 that will increase annually;

— new work rules and shortened offseason workouts, which are expected to result in fewer injuries and perhaps longer careers;

— better health benefits, including more than $1 billion for post-career injuries.

On the owners’ side, there’s:

— more money to invest as gross revenues rise;

— labor peace for 10 years that makes it easier to work out long-term business deals;

— the ability to assist in the development of new stadiums because certain revenue was not included in total football revenues;

— paying less money to untested rookies, specifically high-first round draft picks, although that money will be redirected to veterans.

Each side lost a little, too. The owners did not give the players an opt-out clause NFLPA chief DeMaurice Smith sought, and the players retained a 16-game regular season that Commissioner Roger Goodell wanted increased to 18 games.

“We didn’t get everything that either side wanted … but we did arrive at a deal that we think is fair and balanced,” Smith said.

New England Patriots owner Robert Kraft apologized to fans for taking so long to reach a deal but said “the end result is we’ve been able to have an agreement that I think is going to allow this sport to flourish over the next decade.”

There is still more to be done once the union recertifies and the almost 1,900 players vote to approve the new CBA. When that happens, items such as player discipline, drug testing, disability programs and pensions, have to be negotiated.

Cowboys tight end Jason Witten believes the length of the deal indicates a win-win conclusion to the often contentious negotiations.

“That kind of solidifies that both sides felt good about the deal and that it’s a fair deal,” he said.

NFL fans: was the new CBA worth the months-long lockout? Sound off below…

(TM and Copyright 2011 CBS Radio Inc. and its relevant subsidiaries. CBS RADIO and EYE Logo TM and Copyright 2011 CBS Broadcasting Inc. Used under license. All Rights Reserved. This material may not be published, broadcast, rewritten, or redistributed. The Associated Press contributed to this report.)