Is Automobile Insurance Admissible at Trial?

Jeremy Thurman on May 2, 2011

The short answer is no. The long answer is much more complicated and scary. Most people believe that you sue and insurance company if someone harms you in an automobile wreck. However, Oklahoma law in particular does not allow you to sue the insurance company and instead only allows a suit to proceed against the tortfeasor (negligent party).

One of the most disconcerting things about litigating an automobile accident case is that a Plaintiff cannot discuss, infer or talk about the fact that the Defendant has automobile insurance. While in theory this may say sound fair, it creates a horrendous problem as defense attorneys often infer that their client will somehow be personally responsible for the verdict. However, Plaintiffs are stuck in that if they mention insurance, the judge will grant a “mistrial” and we will have to try the case over again.

The truth is, cases only go to trial because insurance companies believe they can fool a juror with insurance propaganda regarding frivolous lawsuits and the Plaintiff not being as hurt as he or she claims. Then they want to play on the juror’s sympathies by alleging that the Defendant will somehow be personally responsible for a verdict. That simply is not the truth.

Jeremy Thurman is an attorney at McIntyre Law who focuses primarily on semi-truck accident and catastrophic injury cases. He is known as a meticulous attorney whose work ethic and small town values translate into excellent results for his clients. Read more about Jeremy Thurman.