We were a little hesitant to review Fairway Market after our first visit, simply for that fact that it was such a massive sensory overload, there was absolutely no way we absorbed everything in that first trip. Well, that, and it was so freakin’ busy I’m pretty sure I now know what cattle feel like when being herded through a gate.

That said, we agreed that like many Stamfordites, our first impression really would either make or break Fairway Market as our grocery store of choice. So, for all intents and purposes, we’re just going to ignore that part about the massive crowds since that’s sure to die down in a week or two.

From the moment we walked in we were incredibly impressed by the ginormous fresh area, which you’re forced to walk through first. This unique layout reinforces their whole fresh, healthier positioning by keeping you out of the middle aisles from the start. In the fresh area you can find every fruit or veggie you can imagine, from the average onion to the more exotic cactus pears and persimmons. Then over to their RIDICULOUS artisanal cheese selection (AKA my personal heaven), then to the fresh pastas, sauces, soups, salsas, salads, pickles, olives, hummus… holy crap! And the olive oil and vinegar section? We didn’t even know olive oil was produced in so many regions, but we darn well sampled them all at their sample bar, which led us to buy the most DELICIOUS bottle of syrupy sweet balsamic vinegar (just like it was in Italy) privately labeled for Fairway as super premium. YUM!

To add to the list of highlights was a full deli, meat market, fresh seafood counter, and bakery with fresh baked breads and sweet, sweet homemade goodies! Now, sure, all our area grocery stores have a mix of two to three of these, but NEVER all four done to the extent Fairway Market’s is! Anything you could need from any of these sections is available at your fingertips.

And, if you find yourself buying everything in site because you’re so hungry, you can stop by the intense cafe area for everything from pizza and paninis, to indian and chinese, to burgers, dogs and fries. Of course we had to get a little sometin’ sometin’ to tide us over, so we indulged in the balsamic chicken sandwich with roasted red peppers, olive oil, mozzarella, and broccoli rabe on their amazingly oooey gooey fresh baked bread. DE-LISH!

Once we were done exploring the utopia that is the outer perimeter, we ventured into the inner aisles, for a satisfactory, but less impressive experience with the exception of these highlights:

– COFFEE PARADISE – barrels and barrels of deliciously aromatic coffee beans from all over the world armed with eager employees ready to help you choose, grind, and bag, as well as well-written signs to describe each beans’ characteristics.

– A ton of organic / natural choices in all categories, including personal care and home care.

On the flip side, the layout of the inner aisles was confusing, with awkward placing of organic from traditional groceries, and the same types of food being spread out in two, sometimes three different aisles. Assuming we can get past this strange layout with a view visits, we’re still left challenged with these three pitfalls:

– While all their fresh made and privately labeled food looks phenominal, none of it, not one thing, had the nutritional information on it. For a couple that tries to count calories (emphasis on tries) during the weekdays, this is a huge issue.

– Their selection of pet food and frozen food was very limited, which basically means we need to go to a second grocery store to finish our trip. How much is it to ask to have a ONE-STOP grocery store that has everything you need so you don’t need to waste your weekends grocery store hopping?

– And last, but not least, price. We thought Fairway Market was suppose to be significantly more affordable than Whole Foods, but, sadly it was marginally less expensive. Our bill came to $208, which is about $20 – $25 less than Whole Foods, and about $20 – $35 more than Stop & Shop.

After weighing out the good with the bad, we’re pretty sure Fairway Market makes the cut as our grocery store of choice… mainly because of the fantastic fresh areas and varieties. For this, we’re willing to pay somewhere in between fancy and traditional prices. We’ll be sure to update our blog once we’ve had a few trips under our carts… err, hats.

It’s s very nice store with great selection and things are very fresh. Only problem is THE PRICES! Exorbitant! The same items are priced so much more expensively at Fairway than Stop&Shop or Shoprite. Interesting thing is the location of Fairway is in one of the poorest sections of Stamford. Dont know how they do the business they do.

Prices are definitely expensive, yes… but if we want good quality or something reliable we go there. It evens out with Whole Foods mostly. As for the area, they were really pioneers in reaching into the Harbor Point area. The neighborhood in general still needs progress and work… especially the area closer to the beer garden. But, it’s admirable to go in and take chances like that.

I hate crowds, so I definitely wasn’t sure if I was up to battling through herds of people for gastronomical goodies. Well, that ended soon when I saw how amazing Fairway Market was!

The thing that I was most excited about was checking out all the coffee they had to offer. I was drooling over a special on LX New York months ago in their flyer and was still drooling as I arrived.

I too, was disappointed that some of the awesome prepared food that they had didn’t have any nutritional labels. But, we were told that they would definitely look into it and see if they could get labels up. We were also surprised that there was no recycling bin at the cafe, but a worker actually told us that they were sorting through them in the back and they would be put out soon.

Overall, the variety of food and items at Fairway is truly amazing, truly. I have a feeling that shopping here will really expand our palettes and help us to eat better. I was a bit disappointed that they had such a small selection of pet items, but I have a feeling if I asked for more items, they would bring them in for us. Kristien and I disagree about the price. I think it’s pretty even with Stop & Shop…it’s just that we bought some things we don’t usually buy. That’s my story and I’m stickin’ to it! ;)

[…] winners on here and contact them by e-mail. Then the two lucky winners just need to head down to Fairway Market Stamford’s customer service center and pick up their sauce, pasta, and cookbook. You can […]

[…] disabilities throughout their entire lives. Now, it’s your part to help out! Just shop at Fairway Market Stamford on November 20 from 4-9 PM and 25% of your bill will go directly to Abilis. Just make sure that […]

[…] Stamford’s gonna be BBQ heaven on July 13! And, some local firefighters from Cos Cob, Noroton Heights, Westport, and Belltown are helping to make that happen. Oh yes, it’s time for the third annual Fairway Firefighters Food Face-Off. The fire companies that we just mentioned will do battle over the grill in the hopes of winning a special shopping night at Fairway with 25% of sales going to the charity of the winner’s choice. In addition, the winning firefighters (Cos Cob won last year) will know they rock the grill and will also snag a $500 gift card to Fairway Market. […]

[…] Rare Beer Night, there will be pairings from Laura of Fairfield Cheese Company and charcuterie from Fairway Market, plus a nice dessert to finish things off. Only 40 people can attend, so get your tickets by […]

[…] Fairway Market is helping out families in need after the horrific effects of Hurricane Sandy. By showing “We’re Okay Together,” they are offering a discount to help families recover. When you buy 3 or more pounds of food from their Hot Bar in the month of November, you’ll receive 25% off the cost. If you have no electricity still, are fixing up your house, or are helping others, this is a great opportunity to take advantage of. So, look…it’s not just a Hot Bar. There’s an amazing variety of great food for you to pick from. Plus, when you’ve paid for the food, you can sit down at their cafe and relax, enjoying your food. […]

[…] Fairway Market: Another great place to get high quality meat with great flavors for your bbq. Just be careful because some of their patties are so thick, you’ll need to give them some extra time on the grill or cut them in half. […]