Ok, so the first answer on this page helped me greatly when I was trying to figure this problem out myself, although as someone else already stated, if you have a line width greater than 1px you get funny shapes. The fix that someone else suggested almost worked, but I still had some issues when trying to go for a thicker width arrow. After several hours of playing around with it I was able to combine the above solution with some of my own tinkering to come up with the following code that will draw an arrow at whatever thickness you desire without distorting the arrow shape.

function drawArrow(fromx, fromy, tox, toy){
//variables to be used when creating the arrow
var c = document.getElementById("myCanvas");
var ctx = c.getContext("2d");
var headlen = 10;
var angle = Math.atan2(toy-fromy,tox-fromx);
//starting path of the arrow from the start square to the end square and drawing the stroke
ctx.beginPath();
ctx.moveTo(fromx, fromy);
ctx.lineTo(tox, toy);
ctx.strokeStyle = "#cc0000";
ctx.lineWidth = 22;
ctx.stroke();
//starting a new path from the head of the arrow to one of the sides of the point
ctx.beginPath();
ctx.moveTo(tox, toy);
ctx.lineTo(tox-headlen*Math.cos(angle-Math.PI/7),toy-headlen*Math.sin(angle-Math.PI/7));
//path from the side point of the arrow, to the other side point
ctx.lineTo(tox-headlen*Math.cos(angle+Math.PI/7),toy-headlen*Math.sin(angle+Math.PI/7));
//path from the side point back to the tip of the arrow, and then again to the opposite side point
ctx.lineTo(tox, toy);
ctx.lineTo(tox-headlen*Math.cos(angle-Math.PI/7),toy-headlen*Math.sin(angle-Math.PI/7));
//draws the paths created above
ctx.strokeStyle = "#cc0000";
ctx.lineWidth = 22;
ctx.stroke();
ctx.fillStyle = "#cc0000";
ctx.fill();
}

This is now the code that I am using in my program. What I found to be the key with eliminating the distortion issue was continuing the stroke from the tip of the arrow to one side point, to the other side point, back to the tip, and back over to the first side point, then doing a fill. This corrected the shape of the arrow.