The system has one issue, the PSU has a problem that prevents the system from waking from sleep. It starts and runs fine otherwise. I have no interest in ponying up the 300$ for a PSU, as I only use it as a media server and need sleep. Switched to a budget PC with plex.

Is my pricing appropriate? Are there other reliable options to sell aside from eBay (I have no desire to be scammed).

The system has one issue, the PSU has a problem that prevents the system from waking from sleep. It starts and runs fine otherwise. I have no interest in ponying up the 300$ for a PSU, as I only use it as a media server and need sleep. Switched to a budget PC with plex.

Is my pricing appropriate? Are there other reliable options to sell aside from eBay (I have no desire to be scammed).

The bad news is that a fully functional 4,1 only sell around $400 at this moment, and it's virtually identical to the 5,1. That's why it's a bit hard for you to sell at this price. Only the dual CPU 5,1 can ask for higher price. I know your machine already has a very good CPU, but it's value is totally offsetted by the faulty PSU. Non-ECC RAM also lower the value a bit.

For outsider, not many person will buy the 5,1 now. For insider, they know how to get a 4,1 and do the upgrade.

If you are not rush, you may sell it in the following way.

W3680 $150-170
5870 $250-270
Keyboard + mouse $50
And then put a W3520 + any used cheap PC GPU into the machine, then sell it for another $300-350 (price lower than normal due to faulty PSU).

However, if you want to sell everything at once. You may try $500-550.

IMO, the basic price will set at $400 (the market price of the single CPU 4,1 now). Then +150 for the W3680, +50 for keyboard / mouse. RAM, GPU, SSD worth almost nothing due to lots of better upgrade option now. So, it worth $600. However, the faulty PSU will make it worth $50-100 less. That's why I believe 500-550 is a more reasonable price range for this particular machine.

Thanks. I may try that. Does the marketplace have a good reputation for avoiding scams (assuming I don't sell to a MR noobie)?

Click to expand...

You will not find any newbies in the Marketplace. You must have minimum 250 post on MacRumors before you can enter the Marketplace. I have done several deals in the Marketplace with success. Decent people to deal with both buyers and sellers. Good Luck!

You will not find any newbies in the Marketplace. You must have minimum 250 post on MacRumors before you can enter the Marketplace. I have done several deals in the Marketplace with success. Decent people to deal with both buyers and sellers. Good Luck!

Click to expand...

Oh! Such a requirement..... I totaly had no knowledge of it, but its a good concept.

You will not find any newbies in the Marketplace. You must have minimum 250 post on MacRumors before you can enter the Marketplace. I have done several deals in the Marketplace with success. Decent people to deal with both buyers and sellers. Good Luck!

Pretty much when people hear of a faulty part. The value of the computer is trashed.

For the average buyer it is a no go. They don't know how to fix it. So they will have to bring it to Apple and pay whatever Apple will charge to replace it. You will have zero interest from this market.

This leaves your market for technical minded people. When I buy a faulty computer I expect bargain basement which they will expect as well. I have to take the time to fix it and pay for a replacement part. As a techie I'm not going to accept a part that works in some instances. It's a failing part that will need to be replaced. I'll gamble that it is just an OS issue and perform a clean install and PRAM reset. But I know it will likely need to be replaced.

Given that I'd be looking at the street value of the Mac Pro and at least subtract the cost of the PSU. So I'm guessing you won't get much more than $250 to $350 in it's present condition. Maybe you'll get lucky on a sucker that doesn't think things through.

MacRumors attracts a broad audience
of both consumers and professionals interested in
the latest technologies and products. We also boast an active community focused on
purchasing decisions and technical aspects of the iPhone, iPod, iPad, and Mac platforms.