John Ronald Reuel Tolkien
The Homecoming of Beorhtnoth Beorthelm's Son(1966)

Contents

I.
Beorhtnoth’s Death

In August of the year 991, in
the reign of Æthelred II, a battle was fought near Maldon in Essex. On the
one side was the defence-force of Essex, on the other a viking host that
had ravaged Ipswich. The English were commanded by Beorhtnoth son of Beorhthelm,
the duke of Essex, a man renowned in his day: powerful, fearless, proud. He was
now old and hoar, but vigorous and valiant, and his white head towered high
above other men, for he was exceedingly tall(1), The "Danes"-they
were on this occasion probably for the most part Norwegians-were, according to
one version of the Anglo-Saxon Chronicle, led by Anlaf, famous in Norse saga and
history as Olaf Tryggvason, later to become King of Norway.(2) The Northmen had
sailed up the estuary of the Pante, now called the Blackwater, and encamped on
Northey Island. The Northmen and the English were thus separated by an arm of
the river; tilled by the incoming tide, it could only be crossed by a
"bridge" or causeway, difficult to force in the face of a determined
defence.(3) The defence was resolute. But the vikings knew, or so it would seem,
what manner of a man they had to deal with: they asked for leave to cross the
ford, so that a fair fight could be joined. Beorhtnoth accepted the challenge
and allowed them to cross. This act of pride and misplaced chivalry proved
fatal. Beorhtnoth was slain and the English routed; but the duke's
"household", his heorðwerod,
containing the picked knights and officers of his bodyguard, some of them
members of his own family, fought on, until they all fell dead beside their
lord.

A fragment-a large fragment, 325 lines long-of a contemporary
poem has been preserved: it has no end and no beginning, and no title, but is
now generally known as The Battle of Maldon. It tells of the demand of
the vikings for tribute in return for peace; of Beorhtnoth's proud refusal, and
challenge, and the defence of the "bridge"; the cunning request of the
vikings, and the crossing of the causeway; the last fight of Beorhtnoth, the
falling of his golden-hilted sword from his maimed hand, and the hewing of his
body by the heathen men. The end of the fragment, almost half of it, tells of
the last stand of the bodyguard. The names, deeds, and speeches of many of the
English­men are recorded.

The duke Beorhtnoth was a defender of the monks, and a patron of the church,
especially of the abbey of Ely. After the battle the Abbot of Ely obtained his
body and buried it in the abbey. His head had been hacked off and was not
recovered; it was replaced in the tomb by a ball of wax.

According to the late, and largely unhistorical, ac­count in
the twelfth-century Liber Eliensis the Abbot of Ely went himself with
some of his monks to the battlefield. But in the following poem it is supposed
that the abbot and his monks came only as far as Mal-don, and that they there
remained, sending two men, servants of the duke, to the battlefield some
distance away, late in the day after the battle. They took a waggon, and were to
bring back Beorhtnoth's body.

They left the waggon near the end of the causeway and began
to search among the slain: very many had fallen on both sides. Torhthelm
(colloquially Totta) is a youth, son of a minstrel; his head is full of old lays
concerning the heroes of northern antiquity, such as Finn, King of Frisia; Fróda
of the Hathobards; Béowulf; and Hengest and Horsa, traditional leaders of
the English Vikings in the days of Vortigern (called by the English Wyrtgeorn).
Tidwald (in short Tída) was an old ceorl, a farmer who had
seen much fighting in the English defence-levies. Neither of these men were
actually in the battle. After leaving the waggon they became separated in the
gathering dusk. Night falls, dark and clouded. Torhthelm is found alone in a
part of the field where the dead lie thick.

From the old poem are derived the proud words of Offa at a council before the
battle, and the name of the gallant young Aelfwine (scion of an ancient noble
house in Mercia) whose courage was commended by Offa. There also are found the
names of the two Wulfmaers: Wulfmaer, son of Beorhtnoth's sister; and Wulfmaer
the young, son of Wulfstan, who together with Aelfnoth fell grievously hewn
besides Beorhtnoth. Near the end of the surviving fragment an old retainer,
Beorhtwold, as he prepares to die in the last desperate stand, utters the famous
words, a summing up of the heroic code, that are here spoken in a dream by
Torhthelm:

Hige sceal þe heardra, heorte þe cenre,

mod sceal þe mare þe ure maegen lytlað.

"Will shall be the sterner, heart the bolder, spirit the
greater as our strength lessens."

It is here implied, as is indeed probable, that these words were not
"original," but an ancient and honoured expression of heroic will;
Beorhtwold is all the more, not the less, likely for that reason actually to
have used them in his last hour.

The third English voice in the dark, speaking after the Dirige is first
heard, uses rhyme: presaging the fad­ing end of the old heroic alliterative
measure. The old poem is composed in a free form of the alliterative line, the
last surviving fragment of ancient English heroic minstrelsy. In that measure,
little if at all freer (though used for dialogue) than the verse of The
Battle of Maldon, the present modem poem is written.

The rhyming lines are an echo of some verses, preserved in
the Historia Eliensis, referring to King Canute:

Merie sungen ðe muneches binnen Ely,

oa Cnut ching reu ðerby.

'Roweð, cnites, noer the land

and here we ther muneches saeng'.

1. According to one estimate 6 foot 9
inches tall. This estimate was based on the length and size of his bones when
examined, in his tomb at Ely, in a.d. 1769.

2. That Olaf Tryggvason was actually
present at Maldon is now thought to be doubtful. But his name was known to
Englishmen. He had been in Britain before, and was certainly here again in 994.

3. According to the views of E. D. Laborde, now
generally accepted. The causeway or "hard" between Northey and the
mainland is still there.

II. The Homecoming of Beorhtnoth
Beorhthelm's Son

The sound is heard of a man moving uncertainly and breathing noisily in the
darkness. Suddenly a voice speaks, loudly and sharply.

Torhthelm.

Halt! What do you want? Hell take you! Speak!

Tídwald.

Totta! I know you by your teeth rattling.

Tor.

Why, Tída, you! The time seemed long alone among the lost. They
lie so queer. I've watched and waited, till the wind sighing was like
words whispered by waking ghosts that in my ears muttered.

Tíd.

And your eyes fancied barrow-wights and bogies. It's a black darkness
since the moon foundered; but mark my words: not far from here we'll find
the master, by all accounts.

Tídwald lets out a faint beam from a dark-lantern. An
owl hoots. A dark shape flits through the beam of light. Torhthelm starts back
and overturns the lantern, which Tída had set on the ground.

What ails you now?

Tor.

Lord save us! Listen!

Tíd.

My lad, you're crazed. Your fancies and your fears make foes of
nothing. Help me to heave 'em! It's heavy labour to lug them alone: long
ones and short ones, the thick and the thin. Think less, and talk less of
ghosts. Forget your gleeman's stuff! Their ghosts are under ground, or
else God has them; and wolves don't walk as in Woden'sdays, not
here in Essex. If any there be, they'll be two-legged. There, turn him
over! An owl hoots again. It's only an owl.

Tor.

An ill boding. Owls are omens. But I'm not afraid, not of fancied
fears. A fool call me, but more men than I find the mirk gruesome among
the dead unshrouded. It's like the dim
shadow, of heathen hell, in the hopeless kingdom where search is vain. We
might seek for ever and yet miss the master in this mirk, Tída. O
lord beloved, where do you lie tonight, your head so hoar upon a hard
pillow, and your limbs lying in long slumber?

Tidwald lets out again the light of the dark-lantern.

Tíd.

Look here, my lad, where they lie thickest! Here! Lend a hand! This
head we know! Wulfmær it is. I'll wager aught not far did he fall
from friend and master.

Tor.

His sister-son! The songs tell us, ever near shall be at need nephew to
uncle.

Tíd.

Nay, he's not here-or he's hewn outof ken. It was the other I
meant, th' Eastsaxon lad, Wulfstan's youngster. It's a wicked business to
gather them ungrown. A gallant boy, too, and the makings of a man.

Tor.

Have mercy on us! He was younger than I, by a year or more.

Tíd.

Here's Aelfnoth, too, by his arm lying.

Tor.

As he would have wished it. In work or play they were fast fellows, and
faithful to their lord, as close to him as kin.

Tíd.

Curse this lamplight and my eyes' dimness! My oath I'll take they fell
in his defence, and not far away now master lies. Move them gently!

Tor.

Brave lads! But it's bad when bearded men put shield at back and shun
battle, running like roe-deer, while the red
heathen beat down their boys. May the blast of Heaven light on the
dastards that to death left them to England's shame! And here's Ælfwine:
barely bearded, and his battle's over.

Tíd.

That's bad, Totta. He was a brave lordling, and we need his like: a new
weapon of the old metal. As eager as fire, and as staunch as steel.
Stern-tongued at times, and outspoken after Offa's sort.

Tor.

Offa! He's silenced. Not all liked him; many would have muzzled him,
had masterlet hem. "There are cravens at council that crow
proudly with the hearts of hens": so I hear he said at the lord's
meeting. As lays remind us: "What at the mead man vows, when morning
comes let him with deeds answer, or his drink vomit and a sot be
shown." But the songs wither, and the
world worsens. I wish I'd been here, not left with the luggage and lazy
thralls, cooks and sutlers! By the Cross, Tída, I loved him no less
than any lord with him; and a poor freeman may prove in the end more tough
when tested than titled earls who count back their kin to kings ere
Woden.

Tíd.

You can talk, Totta! Your time'll come, and it'll look less easy than
lays make it. Bitter taste has iron, and the bite of swords is cruel and
cold, when you come to it. Then God guard you, if your glees falter! When
your shield is shivered, between shame and death is hard choosing. Help me
with this one! There, heave him over-the hound's carcase, hulking heathen!

Tor.

Hide it, Tída! Put the lantern out!
He's looking at me. I can't abide his eyes, bleak and evil as
Grendel's in the moon.

Tíd.

Ay, he's a grim fellow, but he's dead and done-for. Danes don't trouble
me save with swords and axes. They can smile or glare, once hell has them.
Come, haul the next!

Tor.

Look! Here's a limb! A long yard, and thick as three men's thighs.

Tíd.

I thought as much. Now bow your head, and hold your babble for a moment
Totta! It's the master at last. There is silence for a short while. Well,
here he is-or what Heaven's left us: the longest legs in the land, I
guess.

Tor.

(His voice rises to a chant.) His head was higher than the helm
of kings with heathen crowns, his heart keener and his soul clearer than
swords of heroes polished and proven: than plated gold his worth was
greater. From the world has passed a prince peerless in peace and war,
just in judgment, generous-handed as the golden lords of long ago. He has
gone to God glory seeking, Beorhtnoth beloved.

Tíd.

Brave words my lad! The woven stars have yet worth in them for woeful
hearts. But here's work to do, ere the funeral begins.

Tor.

I've found it, Tída! Here's his
sword lying! I could swear to it by the golden hilts.

Tíd.

I'm glad to hear it, How it was missed is a marvel. He is marred
cruelly. Few tokens else shall we find on him; they've left us little of
the Lord we knew.

Tor.

Ah, woe and worse! The wolvish heathens have hewn off his head, and the
hulk left us mangled with axes. What a murder it is, this bloody fighting!

Tíd.

Aye, that's the battle for you, and no worse today
than wars you sing of, when Fróda fell, and Finn was slain. The
world wept then, as it weeps today: you can hear the tears through the
harp's twanging. Come, bend your back. We mustbear away the
cold leavings. Catch hold of the legs! Now lift-gently! Now lift again! They
shuffle along slowly.

Tor.

Dear still shall be this dead body, though men have marred it. Torhthelm's
voice rises again to a chant. Now mourn for ever Saxon and English,
from the sea's margin to the western forest! The wall is fallen, women are
weeping; the wood is blazing and the fire naming as a far beacon. Build
high the barrow his bones to keep! For here shall be hid both helm and
sword; and to the ground be given golden corslet, and rich raiment and
rings gleaming, wealth unbegrudged for the well-beloved; of the friends of
men first and noblest, to his hearth-comrades help unfailing, to his folk
the fairest father of peoples. Glory loved he; now glory earning his grave
shall be green, while ground or sea, while word or woe in the world
lasteth.

Tíd.

Good words enough, gleeman Totta! You laboured long as you lay, I
guess, in the watches of the night, while the wise slumbered. But I'd
rather have rest, and my rueful thoughts. These are Christian days, though
the cross is heavy; Beorhtnoth we bear not Béowulf
here: no pyres for him, nor piling of mounds; and the gold will be given
to the good abbot. Let the monks mourn him and mass be chanted! With
learned Latin they'll lead him home, if we can bring him back. The body's
weighty!

Tor.

Dead men drag earthward. Now down a spell! My back's broken, and the
breath has left me.

Tíd.

If you spent less in speech, you would speed better. But the cart's not
far, so keep at it! Now start again, and in step with me! A steady pace
does it. Torhthelm halts suddenly. You stumbling dolt, Look where
you're going!

Tor.

For the Lord's pity, halt, Tída,
here! Hark now, and look!

Tíd.

Look where, my lad?

Tor.

To the left yonder. There's a shade creeping, a shadow darker than the
western sky, there walking crouched! Two now together! Troll-shapes, I
guess, or hell-walkers. They've a halting gait, groping groundwards with
grisly arms.

Tíd.

Nameless nightshades-naught else can I see, till they walk nearer.
You're witch-sighted to tell fiends from men in this foul darkness.

Tor.

Then listen, Tída! There are low voices, moans and muttering,
and mumbled laughter. They are moving hither!

Tíd.

Yes, I mark it now, I can hear something.

Tor.

Hide the lantern!

Tíd.

Lay down the body and lie by it! Now stone-silent! There are steps
coming. They crouch on the ground. The sound of stealthy steps grows
louder and nearer. When they are close at hand Tidwald suddenly shouts
out: Hullo there, my lads! You're late comers, if it's fighting you
look for; but I can find you some, if you need it tonight. You'll get
nothing cheaper. There is a noise of scuffling in the dark. Then there
is a shriek. Torhthelm's voice rings out shrill.

Tor.

You snuffling swine, I'll slit you for it! Take your trove then! Ho! Tída
there! I've slain this one. He'll slink no more. If swords he was
seeking, he soon found one, by the biting end.

Tíd.

My bogey-slayer! Bold heart would you borrow with Beorhtnoth's sword?
Nay, wipe it clean! And keep your wits! That blade was made for better
uses. You wanted no weapon: a wallop on the nose, or a boot behind, and
the battle's over with the likes of these. Their life's wretched, but why
kill the creatures, or crow about it? There are dead enough around. Were
he a Dane, mind you, I'd let you boast-and there's lots abroad not far
away, the filthy thieves: I hate 'em, by my heart, heathenor
sprinkled, the Devil's offspring.

Tor.

The Danes, you say! Make haste! Let's go! I'd half forgotten. There may
be more at hand our murder plotting. We'll have the pirate pack come
pouring on us, if they hear us brawling.

Tíd.

My brave swordsman! These weren't Northmen! Why should Northmen come?
They've had their fill of hewing and fighting, and picked their plunder:
the place is bare. They're in Ipswich now with the ale running, or lying
off London in their long vessels, while they drink to Thor and drown their
sorrow of hell's children. These are hungry folk and masterless men,
miserable skulkers. They're corpse-strippers: a cursed game and shame to
think of. What are you shuddering at?

Tor.

Come on now quick! Christ forgive me, and these evil days, when
unregretted lie mouldering, and the manner of wolves the folk follow in
fear and hunger, their dead unpitying to drag and plunder! Look there
yonder! There's a lean shadow, a third of the thieves. Let's thrash the
villain!

Tíd.

Nay, let him alone! Or we'll lose the way. As it is we've wandered, and
I'm bewildered enough. He won't try attacking two men by himself. Lift
your end there! Lift up, I say. Put your foot forward.

Tor.

Can you find it, Tída? I haven't a
notion now in these nightshadows where we left the waggon. I wish we were
back! They shuffle along without speaking for a while. Walk
wary, man! There's water by us; you'll blunder over the brink. Here's the
Blackwater! Another step that way, and in the stream we'd be like fools
floundering-and the flood's running.

Tíd.

We've come to the causeway. The cart's near it, so courage, my boy. If
we can carry him on few steps further, the first stage is, passed. They
move a few paces more. By Edmund's head! though his own's missing, our
Lord's not light. Now lay him down! Here's the waggon waiting. I wish we
could drink his funeral ale without further trouble on the bank right
here. The beer he gave was good and plenty to gladden your heart, both
strong and brown. I'm in a stew of sweat. Let's stay a moment.

Tor.

(After a pause.) It's strange to me how they came across this
causeway here, or forced a passage without fierce battle; but there are
few tokens to tell of fighting. A hill of heathens one would hope to find,
but none lie near.

Tíd.

No more's the pity. Alas, my friend, our lord was at fault, or so in
Maldon this morning men were saying. Too proud, too princely! But his
pride's cheated, and his princedom has passed, so we'll praise his valour.
He let them cross the causeway, so keen was he to give minstrels matter
for mighty songs. Needlessly noble. It should never have been: bidding
bows be still, and the bridge opening, matching more with few in mad
handstrokes! Well, doom he dared, and died for it.

Tor.

So the last is fallen of the line of earls, from Saxon lords
long-descended who sailed the seas, as songs tell us, from Angel in the
East, with eager swords upon war's anvil the Welsh smiting. Realms here
they won and royal kingdoms, and in olden days this isle conquered. And
now from the North need comes again: wild blows the wind of war to
Britain!

Tíd.

And in the neck we catch it, and are nipped as chill as poor men were
then. Let the poets babble, but perish all pirates! When the poor are
robbed and lose the land they loved and toiled on, they must die and dung
it. No dirge for them, and their wives and children work in serfdom.

Tor.

But Æthelred'll prove less easy prey than Wyrtgeom was; and
I'll wager, too, this Anlaf of Norway will never equal Hengest or Horsa!

Tíd.

We'll hope not, lad! Come, lend your hand to the lifting again, then
your task is done. There, turn him round! Hold the shanks now, while I
heave the shoulders. Now, up your end! Up! That's finished. There cover
him with the cloth.

Tor.

It should be clean linen not a dirty blanket.

Tíd.

It must do for now. The monks are waiting in Maldon for us, and the
abbot with them. We're hours behind. Get up now and in. Your eyes can
weep, or your mouth can pray. I'll mind the horses. Gee up, boys, then. (He
cracks a whip.) Gee up, and away.

Tor.

God guide our road to a good ending! There is a pause, in which a
rumbling and a creaking of wheels is heard. How these wheels do whine!
They'll hear the creak for miles away over mire and stone. A longer
pause in which no word is spoken. Where
first do we make for? Have we far to go? The night is passing, and I'm
near finished … Say, Tída, Tída! is your tongue stricken?

Tíd.

I'm tired of talk. My tongue's resting. "Where first" you
say? A fool's question! To Maldon and the monks, and then miles onward to
Ely and the abbey. It'll end sometime; but the roads are bad in these
ruinous days. No rest for you yet! Were you reckoning on bed? The best
you'll get is the bottom of the cart with his body for bolster.

Tor.

You're a brute, Tída.

Tíd.

It's only plain language. If a poet sang you: "I bowed my head on
his breast beloved, and weary of weeping woeful slept I; thus joined we
journeyed, gentle master and faithful servant, over fen and boulder to his
last resting and love's ending", you'd not call it cruel. I have
cares of my own in my heart, Totta, and my head's weary. I am sorry for
you, and for myself also. Sleep, lad, then! Sleep! The slain won't trouble
if your head be heavy, or the wheels grumble He speaks to the horses. Gee
up, my boys! And on you go! There's food ahead and fair stables, for the
monks are kind. Put the miles behind! The creaking and rattling of the
waggon, and the sound of hoofs, continue for some time, during which no
words are spoken. After a while lights glimmer in the distance. Torhthelm
speaks from the waggon, drowsily and half dreaming.

Tor.

There are candles in the dark and cold voices. I hear mass chanted for
master's soul in Ely isle. Thus ages pass, and men after men. Mourning
voices of women weeping. So the world passes; day follows day, and the
dust gathers, his tomb crumbles, as time gnaws it, and his kith and
kindred out of ken dwindle. So men flicker and in the mirk go out. The
world withers and the wind rises; the candles are quenched. Cold falls the
night. The lights disappear as he speaks. Torhthelm's voice becomes
louder, but it is still the voice of one speaking in a dream. It's
dark! It's dark, and doom coming! Is no light left us? A light kindle, and
fan the flame! Lo! Fire now wakens, hearth is burning, house is lighted,
men there gather. Out of the mists they come through darkling doors
whereat doom waiteth. Hark! I hear them in the hall chanting: stern words
they sing with strong voices. (He chants) Heart shall be bolder,
harderbe purpose, more proud the spirit as our power lessens! Mind
shall not falter nor mood waver, though doom shall come and dark conquer. There
is a great bump and jolt of the cart. Hey!
what a bump, Tída! My bones are shaken, and my dream shattered.
It's dark and cold.

Tíd.

Aye, a bump on the bone is bad for dreams, and it's cold waking. But
your words are queer, Torhthelm my lad, with your talk of wind and doom
conquering and a dark ending. It sounded fey and fell-hearted, and
heathenish, too: I don't hold with that. It's night right enough; but
there's no firelight: dark is over all, and dead is master. When morning
comes, it'll be much like others: more labour and loss till the land's
ruined; ever work and war till the world passes. The cart rumbles and
bumps on. Hey! rattle and bump over rut
and boulder! The roads are rough and rest is short for English men in
Æthelred's day. The rumbling of the cart dies away. Thereiscomplete silence for a while. Slowly the sound of voices
chanting begins to be heard. Soon the words, though faint, can be
distinguished. Dirige, Domine, in conspectu tuo viam meam. Introibo in
domum tuam: adorabo ad templum Sanctum tuum in timore tuo.

III.
Ofermod

This piece, somewhat larger than theOld English
fragment that inspired it, was composed primarily as verse, to be condemned or
approved as such(1). But to merit a place in Essays and Studies it must, I
suppose, contain at least by implication criticism of the matter and manner of
the Old English poem (or of its critics).

From that point of view it may be said to be an extended
comment on lines 89, 90 of the original:ða
se eorl ongan for his ofermode alyfan landes to fela laþere ðeode,
"then the earl in his overmastering pride actually yielded ground to the
enemy, as he should not have done". The Battle of Maldon has usually
been regarded rather as an extended comment on, or illus­tration of the words
of the old retainer Beorhtwold, 312, 313, cited above, and used in the present
piece. They are the best-known lines of the poem, possibly of all Old English
verse. Yet except in the excellence of their expression, they seem to me of less
interest than the earlier lines; at any rate the full force of the poem is
missed unless the two passages are considered to­gether.

The words of Beorhtwold have been held to be the finest
expression of the northern heroic spirit, Norse or English; the clearest
statement of the doctrine of uttermost endurance in the service of indomitable
will. The poem as a whole has been called "the only purely heroic poem
extant in Old English". Yet the doctrine appears in this clarity, and
(approximate) purity, precisely because it is put in the mouth of a subordinate,
a man for whom the object of his will was decided by another, who had no
responsibility downwards, only loyalty upwards. Personal pride was therefore in
him at its lowest, and love and loyalty at their highest.

For this "northern heroic spirit" is never quite
pure; it is of gold and an alloy. Unalloyed it would direct a man to endure even
death unflinching, when necessary: that is when death may help the achievement
of some object of will, or when life can only be purchased by denial of what one
stands for. But since such conduct is held admirable, the alloy of personal good
name was never wholly absent. Thus Leofsunu in The Battle of Maldon holds
himself to his loyalty by the fear of reproach if he returns home alive. This
motive may, of course, hardly go beyond "conscience": self-judge­ment
in the light of the opinion of his peers, to which the "hero" himself
wholly assents; he would act the same, if there were no witnesses(2). Yet this
element of pride, in the form of the desire for honour and glory, in life and
after death, tends to grow, to become a chief motive, driving a man beyond the
bleak heroic necessity to excess-to chivalry. "Excess" certainly, even
if it be approved by contemporary opinion, when it not only goes beyond need and
duty, but interferes with it.

Thus Beowulf (according to the motives ascribed to him by the
student of heroic-chivalric character who wrote the poem about him) does more
than he need, eschewing weapons in order to make his struggle with Grendel a
"sporting" fight: which will enhance his personal glory; though it
will put him in unnecessary peril, and weaken his chances of ridding the Danes
of an intolerable affliction. But Beowulf has no duty to the Danes, he is still
a subordinate with no responsibilities downwards; and his glory is also the
honour. of his side, of the Geatas; above all, as he himself says, it will
redound to the credit of the lord of his allegiance, Hygelac. Yet he does not
rid himself of his chivalry, the excess persists, even when he is an old king
upon whom all the hopes of a people rest. He will not deign to lead a force
against the dragon, as wisdom might direct even a hero to do; for, as he
explains in a long "vaunt", his many victories have relieved him of
fear. He will only use a sword on this occasion, since wrestling singlehanded
with a dragon is too hopeless even for the chivalric spirit. But he dis­misses
his twelve companions. He is saved from de­feat, and the essential object,
destruction of the dragon, only achieved by the loyalty of a subordinate.
Beowulf's chivalry would otherwise have ended in his own useless death, with the
dragon still at large. As it is, a subordinate is placed in greater peril than
he need have been, and though he does not pay the penalty of his master's mod
with his own life, the people lose their king disastrously.

In Beowulf we have only a legend of "excess"
in a chief. The case of Beorhtnoth is still more pointed even as a story; but it
is also drawn from real life by a contemporary author. Here we have Hygelac be­having
like young Beowulf: making a "sporting fight" on level terms; but at
other people's expense. In his situation he was not a subordinate, but the
authority to be obeyed on the spot; and he was
responsible for all the men under him, not to throw away their lives except with
one object, the defence of the realm from an implacable foe. He says himself
that it is his pur­pose to defend the realm of Æthelred, the people, and
the land (52-3). It was heroic for him and his men to fight, to
annihilation if necessary, in the attempt to destroy or hold off the invaders.
It was wholly un­fitting that he should treat a desperate battle with this sole
real object as a sporting match, to the ruin of his purpose and duty.

Why did Beorhtnoth do this? Owing to a defect of character,
no doubt; but a character, we may surmise not only formed by nature, but moulded
also by "aristocratic tradition", enshrined in tales and verse of
poets, now lost save for echoes. Beorhtnoth was chivalrous rather than strictly
heroic. Honour was in itself a motive, and he sought it at the risk of placing
his heorðwerod, all the men most
dear to him, in a truly heroic situation, which they could redeem only by death.
Magnificent perhaps, but certainly wrong. Too foolish to be heroic. And the
folly Beorhtnoth at any rate could not wholly redeem by death.

This was recognized by the poet of The Battle Maldon,
though the lines in which his opinion are ex­pressed are little regarded, or
played down. The translation of them given above is (I believe) accurate, in
representing the force and implication of his words, though most will be more
familiar with Ker's: "then the earl of his overboldness granted ground too
much to the hateful people"(3). They are lines in fact of severe
criticism, though not incompatible with loyalty, and even love. Songs of praise
at Beorhtnoth's funeral may well have been made of him, not unlike the lament of
the twelve princes for Beowulf; but they too may have ended on the ominous note
struck by the last word of the greater poem: lofgeornost "most
desirous of glory".

So far as the fragment of his work goes, the poet of Maldon
did not elaborate the point contained in lines 89-90; though if the poem had any
rounded ending and final appraisement (as is likely, for it is certainly not a
work of hot haste), it was probably resumed. Yet if he felt moved to criticize
and express disapproval at all, then his study of the behavior of the heorðwerod,
lacks the sharpness and tragic quality that he intended, if his criticism is not
fully valued. By it the loyalty of the retinue is greatly enhanced. Their part
was to endure and die, and not to question, though a recording poet may fairly
comment that some­one had blundered. In their situation heroism was superb.
Their duty was unimpaired by the error of their master, and (more poignantly)
neither in the hearts of those near to the old man was love lessened. It is the
heroism of obedience and love not of pride or wilfulness that is the most heroic
and the most moving; from Wiglaf under his kinsman's shield, to Beorhtwold at
Maldon, down to Balaclava, even if it is enshrined in verse no better than The
Charge of the Light Brigade.

Beorhtnoth was wrong, and he died for his folly. But it was a
noble error, or the error of a noble. It was not for his heorðwerod
to blame him; probably many would not have felt him blameworthy, being
themselves noble and chivalrous. But poets, as such, are above chivalry, or even
heroism; and if they give any depth to their treatment of such themes, then,
even in spite of themselves, these "moods" and the objects to which
they are directed will be questioned.

We have two poets that study at length the heroic and
chivalrous, with both art and thought, in the older ages: one near the beginning
in Beowulf; one near the end in Sir Gawain. And probably a third,
more near the middle, in Maldon, if we had all his work. It is not
surprising that any consideration of the work of one of these leads to the
others. Sir Gawain, the latest, is the most fully conscious, and is in
plain intention a criticism or valuation of a whole code of sentiment and
conduct, in which heroic courage is only a part, with different loyalties to
serve. Yet it is a poem with many inner likenesses to Beowulf, deeper
than the use of the old "alliterative"(4) metre, which is none the less
significant. Sir Gawain, as the exemplar of chivalry, is of course shown to be
deeply concerned for his own honour, and though the things considered honour­able
may have shifted or been enlarged, loyalty to word and to allegiance, and
unflinching courage re­main. These are tested in adventures no nearer to
ordinary life than Grendel or the dragon; but Gawain's conduct is made more
worthy, and more worth con­sidering, again because he is a subordinate. He is
involved in peril and the certain prospect of death simply by loyalty, and._the
desire to secure the safety _and dignity of his lord, King Arthur. And upon him;
depends in his quest the honour of his lord and of his heorðwerod,
the Round Table. It is no accident that in this poem, as in Maldon and in
Beowulf, we have criticism of the lord, of the owner of the allegiance. ,
The words are striking, though less so than the small part they have played in
criticism of the poem (as also in Maldon). Yet thus spoke the court of
the great King Arthur, when Sir Gawain rode away:

Before God 'tis a shame

that thou, lord, must be lost, who art in life so noble!

To meet his match among men. Marry, 'tis not easy!

To behave with more heed would have behoved one of sense,

and that dear lord duly a duke to have made,

illustrious leader of liegemen in this land as befits him;

and that better would have been than to be butchered to death,

beheaded by an elvish man for an arrogant vaunt.

Who ever heard tell of a king such courses taking,

as knights quibbling at court at their Christmas games!

Beowulf is a rich poem; there are of course many other
sides to the description of the manner of the hero's death; and the
consideration (sketched above) of the changing values of chivalry in youth and
in age and responsibility is only an ingredient. Yet it is plainly there; and
though the author's main imagina­tion was moving in wider ways, criticism of
the lord and owner of the allegiance is touched on.

Thus the lord may indeed receive credit from the deeds of his
knights, but he must not use their loyalty or imperil them simply for that
purpose. It was not Hygelac that sent Beowulf to Denmark through any boast or
rash vow. His words to Beowulf on his re­turn are no doubt an alteration of the
older story (which peeps rather through in the egging of the snotere ceorlas,
202-4); but they are the more sig­nificant for that. We hear, 1992-7, that
Hygelac had tried to restrain Beowulf from a rash adventure. Very properly. But
at the end the situation is reversed. We learn, 3076-83, that Wiglaf and the
Geatas regarded any attack on the dragon as rash, and had tried to restrain the
king from the perilous enterprise, with words very like those used by Hygelac
long before. But the king wished for glory, or for a glorious death, and courted
disaster. There could be no more pungent criticism in a few words of
"chivalry" in one of re­sponsibility than Wiglaf's exclamation: oft
sceall eorl monig anes willan wraec adreogan, "by one man's will many
must woe endure". These words the poet of Maldon might have inscribed at
the head of his work.

1. It was indeed plainly intended as a recitation for
two per­sons, two shapes in "dim shadow", with the help of a few
gleams of light and appropriate noises and a chant at the end. It has, of
course, never been performed.

2. Cf. Sir Gawain and the Green Knight, 2127-31.

3. To fela means in Old English idiom that no
ground at all should have been conceded. And ofermod does not mean
"overboldness", not even if we give full value to the ofer,
remembering how strongly the taste and wisdom of the English (whatever their
actions) rejected "excess". Whita scal geþyldig … ne næfre
gielpes to georn, ær he geare cunne. Bur mod, though it may
contain or imply courage, does not mean "boldness" any more than
Middle English corage. It means "spirit", or when unqualified
"high spirit", of which the most usual manifestation is pride. But in ofer-mod
it is qualified, with disapproval: ofermod is in fact always a word of
condemnation. In verse the noun occurs only twice, once applied to Beorhtnoth,
and once to Lucifer.

4. It is probably the first work to apply the word
"letters" to this metre, which has in fact never regarded them.