The Deubell family at their home in Maineville. From left, Marcus, 14, Bernadette, 7, Michelle, Rob, Greta, 8, and Anna, 13. The children are home-schooled. Rob runs a website, www.freedom2012.org.

Written by

Tom Miele and Rob Deubell are churchgoing Catholics dedicated to their kids, their communities and the causes that have defined their faith for centuries.

Yet on Election Day, they will agree on almost nothing.

Miele is a self-described progressive from Covedale who says the Republican Party ignores the poor and has been "taken over by wackos." He's donated to President Barack Obama's campaign and intends to vote for him this fall. ...