Controversy swirls around purported 'younger' version of Mona Lisa

Different version of classic portrait has prompted questions as two whether Leonardo is the artist

A
painting which is believed to be a younger vision of Leonardo da
Vinci's "Mona Lisa" will be presented in Geneva this week. Some art
historians believe it is the original version of indisputably the
world's most famous painting. Some Leonardo scholars remain skeptical,
and have devoted book-length treatises saying it is the work of another
artist.

Oxford University professor Martin Kemp argued that the Geneva portrait is probably a copy of the Paris version by an unknown painter who simply chose to make the subject younger.

Highlights

LOS ANGELES, CA (Catholic Online) - As the story is told, the one currently recognized as the official Leonardo "Mona Lisa," known as "La Giaconda" or "La Joconde" is a reported portrait of Lisa Gherardini, the wife of early 16th century Italian nobleman Francesco del Giacondo who commissioned a portrait of her. Leonardo never delivered the painting to del Giacondo.

The younger version of the painting shows a woman appearing to be in her early 20s, rather than the early 30s of the Louvre painting in the same pose and with much the same enigmatic smile as the acknowledged masterpiece.

The Swiss-based Mona Lisa Foundation organizing the event says that the painting is an earlier portrayal by the Italian genius of "the lady with the mystic smile.

"We have investigated this painting from every relevant angle and the accumulated information all points to it being an earlier version of the Giaconda in the Louvre," foundation member and art historian Stanley Feldman, told Reuters.

Both Feldman and his brother David have used the most up-to-date critical comparison and scientific examination techniques to support their view that it is, indeed the work of the Master.

A luxuriously illustrated book entitled, "Mona Lisa-Leonardo's Earlier Version," "will permit an unbiased judgment of the claim of this painting to be the earlier portrait, incomplete, of a young Mona Lisa, much younger than that of the Louvre."

Other experts on the "Renaissance Man, who bestrode the European cultural world from the late 15th century until his death at the age of 67 in 1519, remains skeptical.

Oxford University professor Martin Kemp argued that the Geneva portrait is probably a copy of the Paris version by an unknown painter who simply chose to make the subject younger.

"So much is wrong," Kemp says. The world-recognized authority on Leonardo, points to the fact that the foundation's portrait is painted on canvas and not on wood, the artist's preferred medium.

The "younger version" of the painting is by no means new to the art world. Apart from a brief excursion to Japan, it has been in a Swiss vault for many years.

Discovered in 1913 by collector Hugh Blaker in a manor house in the west of England, the painting had hung for a century unnoticed. How it got there is unknown.

Blaker took it to his home in a London suburb, where it was dubbed "the Isleworth Mona Lisa." On his death in 1936, it was bought by American collector Henry Pulitzer, who deposited it in a Swiss bank while writing a book about it, published in 1972.

Pope Francis Prayer Intentions for March 2015
Universal: Scientists: That those involved in scientific research may serve the well-being of the whole human person.
Evangelization: Contribution of women: That the unique contribution of women to the life of the Church may be recognized always.

Comments

Polish
Schoolchildren, attending what they thought was a religious camp
honoring Lent were screaming and in tears when 37-year-old priest Tomas
Wieczorek carried out a mass exorcism. LOS ANGELES, CA (Catholic Online) - The 1,000 young people, from schools in the ... continue reading

Rejecting Pope Francis and consecrating bishops without the approval of the Vatican, the ultra-traditionalist movement "The Resistance" is planning to expand by consecrating again a new generation of bishops. According to one of the French bishops, Jean-Michel Faure, ... continue reading

Excitement
is in the air in Krakow, Poland. The metropolis is readying itself to
host World Youth Day in 2016. As part of the renovations to host the
over two million people who are expected to attend, the city has a new
airport, improved road and rail links, a ... continue reading

The
willful destruction of himself - along with 149 other, innocent human
beings, has the world scrambling for answers. Germanwings co-pilot
Andreas Lubitz, who slammed his plane into mountainside earlier this
week. Killing everyone onboard, remains a ... continue reading

A
terrible tragedy that left 150 people dead may have been the result of a
frightened, insecure man hiding a medical condition. Investigators say
that Germanwings copilot Andreas Lubitz was keeping an unspecified
medical condition secret from others and had a ... continue reading

Investigators have recovered key information from the French Alps wrecked Germanwings Airbus A320's black box and voice recorder. The co-pilot, 28-year-old German, Andreas Lubitz, intentionally locked the captain out of the cockpit and deliberately crashed into a ... continue reading

Nearly
500 British priests have signed a letter urging those attending this
year's family synod to issue a "clear and firm proclamation" upholding
Church teaching on marriage. An extraordinary synod last year provoked
heated debate on the question of whether ... continue reading

150 people were killed in the tragic Germanwings A320 Airbus crash in the snowy French Alps earlier this week. Pope Francis has come forward with some words of comfort for all those involved in the horrific accident. LOS ANGELES, CA (Catholic Online) - Pope Francis ... continue reading

Islamic
State militants returning to the United Kingdom could attack London
Underground trains or football matches with chlorine gas. That is the
frightening estimation from chemical weapons expert Hamish de
Bretton-Gordon, a retired head of chemical and ... continue reading

An airplane carrying 150 people crashed Tuesday in the French Alps. All 144 passengers and six crew members are presumed dead. LOS ANGELES, CA (Catholic Online) A Germanwings Airbus A320 was traveling from Barcelona, Spain to Dusseldorf Germany. During mid ... continue reading