Related Links

The bright shining faces of 21,151 elementary and K-8 students have been assigned to their places in the Savannah-Chatham public schools and 2,816 who outshine all the others went to the gifted program.

Thirteen percent of the district’s kindergarten through eighth-grade population is considered gifted. Somewhere along the way someone recognized that they had exceptional creativity or outstanding math and reading ability; and their grades and test scores backed it up.

“Gifted used to be the top 1 to 2 percent — the prodigies,” said Gifted Teacher Specialist Debbie Burnette. “But the program has been expanded to include highly talented and motivated kids in many areas. We look at intellectual ability, grades, creativity and motivation. The students in the gifted program may be two or three grade levels ahead or they may be teacher pleasers and creative thinkers.”

Being among the talented few who are labeled gifted is important. Identification begins in kindergarten and some parents are emphatic about getting their child in with the gifted crowd. Those children receive special instruction by specially trained teachers designed to build on their strengths and challenge them to go above and beyond academically. Some gifted middle grades students are all grouped in advanced level math and language arts classes. Some are given more challenging class work and alternative assignments. Being identified as gifted affirms that a student is smart and gives them a reason to feel special and motivated to learn. The elementary schoolchildren who get pulled out of their regular classes for gifted enrichment services are the envy of all those left behind.

“Everybody knows about the gifted class and they all want to be in it,” said gifted Thunderbolt Elementary fifth-grader Patreneii Polite. “They think we get to do better stuff than them.”

At Hesse Elementary about 200 of the 1,000 students enrolled at the school receive gifted services. In Tara Wood’s gifted third grade class they curled up on sleeping bags and blankets, munched cookies and read the books they had written on Georgia’s native animals. Her students come to her on hour every day for advanced lessons. It is a time when they can work in small groups, ask deep questions and research and discuss the answers.

“It helps keep them motivated,” Wood said. “My kids love coming to class and they are usually excited and engaged.”

During their unit on wildlife they researched animal adaptations, habitats and diet and compiled what they found in books. Jenna Afifi was wrapped up in a fuzzy pink blanket thumbing through her book on sea otters, which she had neatly illustrated with crayons.

“They used to be almost extinct,” she said, biting the head off an animal cracker.

But being gifted in Savannah-Chatham public schools doesn’t always mean you get hours of advanced instruction and clever lessons with cookies.

A recent audit of the program revealed that some students aren’t getting their fair share of gifted services. In many instances throughout the district students have not received the proper amount of gifted instruction because gifted teachers were assigned to other duties or children had to skip gifted class as a punishment.

According to the report, auditors visited several schools where gifted lessons were cut short because they conflicted with an assembly or field trip. In many cases the classes are cancelled because the gifted teachers are also assigned test coordinating duties or because the students have to prepare for standardized testing.

Auditors found that some classroom teachers do not know how to modify their lessons to meet the needs of students who may be gifted in one subject area and not another.

But perhaps most alarming is the number of children who have never received services because they have not been identified.

Of the public school system’s 2,816 gifted elementary and K-8 students, 54 percent are white. However, whites make up just 27 percent of the public school population. Black students, who make up 58 percent of the public school population, account for just 31 percent of the gifted program enrollment.

The disparity may stem from the fact that so many of the district’s black students are from disadvantaged backgrounds. Disadvantaged students who are gifted aren’t always easy to identify. Precocious kids from the inner city have been written off as disrespectful instead of identified as intellectual. But more often than not, their potential is overlooked because it is hidden within their standardized test scores.

“Many of our children do exceptionally well in math and reading, but their vocabulary is just not as extensive,” said Thunderbolt Elementary Gifted teacher Jill Lepo-Wieniewitz. “So they’ll score a 90 in comprehension and a 60 in vocabulary and their composite score doesn’t reflect their ability.”

Over the last four years the district has attempted to increase the number of gifted students from disadvantaged schools by using a growth potential delivery model in inner-city schools. Students whose standardized test scores come close to meeting the criteria for gifted services are placed in classes that work to build on their strengths and weaknesses so they can fully qualify. Thunderbolt is one of the three schools growing talented students into the gifted program.

“There are more gifted kids out there who are not identified,” Lepo-Wieniewitz said. “It’s best to catch them when they’re younger, before their creativity is stifled. They get less creative as they get older because someone is always telling them what to do and when to do it and chipping away at their independent thinking skills.”

Fifth-grader Elena Parker has been in the gifted program at Thunderbolt for four years. She and her classmates were looking at slides of cells under microscopes and trying to determine if they were from plants or animals. Elena carefully drew a picture of the bamboo cane cell she was eyeing.

“I’ve never seen bamboo before, except on TV, and on this slide,” she said. “It looks neat.”

Tywan Gilbert was looking at something he had never seen before either — a pond specimen called radiolaria.

“I would say it’s an animal because the cells are circular,” the fifth-grader said.

“I’m a smart guy. I know because I get to come to the gifted class. That’s a good feeling.”

ADVISORY: Users are solely responsible for opinions they post here and for
following agreed-upon rules of civility. Posts and
comments do not reflect the views of this site. Posts and comments are
automatically checked for inappropriate language, but readers might find some
comments offensive or inaccurate. If you believe a comment violates our rules,
click the "Flag as offensive" link below the comment.

Sugar Kitty, I'm not sure I know exactly what your point is. Did it occur to you that the race of the children shown is a reflection of the demographic of that particular school?

The ratio of black vs white students in SCCPS, by school, is available on the State DOE website if you care to look. In addition, the schools report on the DOE site lists exceptional children counts and their scores as well. Again, if you've got something to say, say it, so that maybe us non-gifted readers can understand your point.

Any "gifted" or "advanced" class, as we called them twenty years ago, will contain mostly white students. The situation has nothing to do with extra services or special treatment. It is simply that bright students are allowed to learn at their own pace instead of being held back due to teachers saddled by students with bad behavior. What we should be concerned about is why so many parents send kids to school without ethics or manners. Wasting time and effort dealing with unmanagable children is the main issue in public education and is a true misallocation of public services.

If they are having trouble finding black children to join the gifted program, they could simply find a few who are pleasant, likeable, & trouble free and add them to the group. All children have gifts. Almost all will benefit from the extra attention. Thats why so many from disadvantaged backgrounds fail to shine.

if you have ever been around schools with these programs, you will quickly realize that the kids in them are not truly gifted but rather are the kids that care about and want an education (there are some that are, but very few, 1-2% being correct). 13% is about right. So, in the past it was 13% that DID NOT want an education it is now that amount that want and these classes put them on a path to get a good education. What I pity is the remaining 87% and the quality of the education they get and what they will have for the rest of their life. Teachers in those classes are constrained by the discipline and student issues and can't compare. Also, don't overlook the fact that it is a big $$$$ issue - the more students in "gifted" programs the more money the schools receive. Proof is in the test scores - and SCCPSS schools are NOT getting better.

"children had to skip gifted class as a punishment". Quite possibly the dumbest punishment imaginable. To punish by denying the opportunity to learn is rediculous and examplifies government thinking. Take away sports or PE, but don't take away access to the gifted classes.

"The disparity may stem from the fact that so many of the district’s black students are from disadvantaged backgrounds. Disadvantaged students who are gifted aren’t always easy to identify. Precocious kids from the inner city have been written off as disrespectful instead of identified as intellectual. But more often than not, their potential is overlooked because it is hidden within their standardized test scores."

I would love to see the statistics for Haven Elementary. Anywho, I place the blame on school administrators who are misusing the gifted educators and the time blocks set aside for gifted instruction. Also since when has taking educational opportunity from a student been punishment? That is complete idiocy. It might be time for some parents to step up to the plate as well.

Learning starts at home. Until the day we can plug a line into someone and pour in infor. we can only try to off-set the harm done by no or poor pos. infl. learned at home. Even when we can pour info. into their little skulls, once they return home most of them are going to revert back to using that info. to get over on every one else. THINK about and try to come up with something useful instead of harping on %.