Carrot Cake FAQs

If it’s your first time making this recipe or you have a question then please take a moment to have a read through my carrot cake FAQs for lots of extra tips, suggested ingredient substitutions (if you need to make any) and allergen information.

If there’s something you’d like to know that I’ve not answered here then please let me know in the comments.

How long does this carrot cake last for?

If you store the carrot cake in an airtight container it will be fine to eat for about a week after baking.

If you do make the cake in advance and choose to add little sugar carrots similar to the ones shown I would recommend not adding them until just before serving. This is because the moisture in the buttercream softens the sugar in the mini carrots and they run into the buttercream.

Can it be frozen?

❄️ Suitable for freezing

This carrot cake freezes beautifully, either just the carrot cake sponge or the fully decorated cake.

To freeze the sponges, wrap them in clingfilm or place them in an airtight container to protect them, and freeze. Defrost them thoroughly before decorating.

To freeze the finished cake complete with buttercream, either…

Place the cake in an airtight, freezer-safe container and freeze.

OR

Place the cake on a dish and freeze it uncovered for a couple of hours. Then once the buttercream is firm to the touch, wrap the cake in clingfilm and return it to the freezer. Remove the clingfilm before defrosting the cake (so it doesn’t stick to the buttercream). If you find that the clingfilm has left the buttercream looking a bit messy you can easily neaten it up with a palette knife or the back of a spoon once the cake has defrosted.

Can this cake be made as individual cupcakes?

Do I need to peel the carrots?

I don’t bother peeling mine, I just give them a good wash and then get grating.

Which spices are used in a carrot cake?

My carrot cake is predominantly spiced with cinnamon with a small amount of ground mixed spice (a mixture of cinnamon, coriander seeds, caraway seeds, nutmeg, ginger and cloves) to bring out the flavour.

If you cannot get hold of ground mixed spice (I know it’s not available in all countries) then you could substitute it for more cinnamon.

I prefer nuts to raisins, can I switch them?

I’ve added raisins to my carrot cake as that’s what we like best at home. However, if you prefer your carrot cake to be nuttier, then you can switch the raisins for 100g of chopped nuts. You could also try a mix of the two, or simply leave them out altogether. I’ve tested this cake as a carrot and walnut cake, adding 100g of finely chopped walnuts in place of the raisins and it was delicious 🙂

Why do you soak the raisins in water?

I soak the raisins because it helps them to stay moist and juicy during baking. If you bake with raisins (or other similar dried fruits), you may have noticed that they can end up like little bullets with a bitter taste, especially if they’re on the surface of whatever you’re baking. Soaking them before adding them to the cake mixture prevents this from happening.

Does it have to be water, or can I get creative?

Create away!

You could try tea, or even your favourite tipple. I reckon this would be great with rum or brandy soaked raisins 🙂

What about other flavours?

If you fancy getting even more adventurous with your carrot cake then how about trying one off these recipes…

What is this cake free From? / Who is this cake suitable for?

The ingredients I used to make this recipe are all free from the following allergens. However, please check any labels carefully for allergens you need to avoid as brands can vary, and product recipes can change over time.

Suitable for Vegetarians

Tree Nut-Free

Peanut-Free

Sesame-Free

Soya-Free

Lupin-Free

Can this cake be made gluten-free?

I’ve not tried it, but it should work absolutely fine substituting the self-raising flour for a gluten-free equivalent.

Can you adapt this carrot cake to be vegan?

I haven’t had a chance to test this as a vegan cake yet, if that’s something you’re interested in then let me know in the comments and I’ll add it to my recipe development list.

Drain the raisins and add them and the grated carrot to the cake mixture. Fold them into the other ingredients.

Split the cake mixture between the two pre-prepared tins. Use the back of a spoon or a spatula to spread the mixture evenly in the tins.

Bake for 35-40 minutes until a skewer inserted into the cake comes out clean. Once baked, remove the cakes from the oven and leave them to cool in their tins for 10 minutes, before removing the tins and placing the cakes onto a wire rack to cool completely before decorating.

Make the cream cheese buttercream

Cut the butter (100g) into cubes and beat until soft.

Add the icing sugar (100g) and beat it into the butter until soft and fully combined. I usually add my icing sugar 1 heaped tablespoon at a time to avoid it flying everywhere.

Add the cream cheese and beat it into the other ingredients. I prefer to beat in the cream cheese by hand with a wooden spoon a few tablespoons at a time rather than using an electric mixer as I find it easier to combine it evenly.

Build your cake

Place the bottom layer of your sponge onto your serving dish.

Add half of the cream cheese buttercream and spread it evenly across the cake with a palette knife or the back of a spoon.

Add the second sponge.

Spread the remaining buttercream across the top of the cake, again with a palette knife or the back of a spoon. I've used the tip of my palette knife to make a swirl starting from the outside edge of the cake and working inwards.

Reader Interactions

Comments

You can, but it’ll have a different flavour. If you can find cinnamon then you could do a mix of the two.

Vickysays

June 03, 2020 at 1:55 pm

Made this yesterday for hubby’s birthday. Absolutely delicious. I swapped half the raisins for chopped walnuts and put walnuts on top too. I altered the cream cheese buttercream to 40g butter, and 200g icing sugar. It had a nice thick consistency.

Hey, I’ve made this carrot cake a few times and my family and friends love it! I want to make sugar free for a friend who has quit sugar. What can I use instead or the light brown sugar that will still work? Thank you!

Unfortunately sugar plays a big part not just in the flavour, but also in the way a cake bakes. I’ve done experiments in the past which you can have a look at here. I’d therefore recommend using a cake recipe that’s been specifically designed to be refined sugar-free.

Kimsays

May 23, 2020 at 6:23 pm

Made this cake today. Everything going well until the buttercream. Very runny. Just hoping it will set in the fridge t.

What brand of cream cheese did you use? I find some give a firmer buttercream than others. I always recommend using full-fat Philadelphia, and make sure if there’s any liquid on the top that you don’t add it to the bowl as this will soften the buttercream.

Tracey Hinsleysays

May 23, 2020 at 1:34 pm

Oh my gosh Charlotte! Best carrot cake I have ever made. The tip for soaking raisins made all the difference (soaked mine in half coconut rum and half orange juice!!). First time I have been on you page, looking forward to trying some more of your recipes.

I personally wouldn’t switch brown sugar for demerera. The cake should still work, but demerera has much large crystals so I would expect the final sponge to be a but grainy.

Laurasays

May 21, 2020 at 9:41 am

Thankyou! Just struggling to find any brown sugar in the shops at the minute!

Charlotte Oatessays

May 21, 2020 at 10:19 am

I know the problem. I’m in desperate need of icing sugar and can’t seem to find any anywhere. If you have a food processor, you could give the sugar a blitz in there to create finer granules which would work better.

The sugar carrots are just the little carrot decorations I’ve used on top of the cake. You use normal carrots in the actual cake. You can decorate your cake how you like (so no need for the sugar carrots if you don’t want them), I just wanted to provide instructions to allow you to replicate the cake in the pictures.