Share

Like many Catholics across the Northeast and Midwest, parishioners in Pittsburgh are adjusting to a difficult new reality.

On April 28 Bishop David A. Zubik announced plans to reduce the diocese’s 188 parishes to 57 by 2023.

The parish closings follow years of falling Mass attendance—the diocese reports it is down by more than 40 percent since 2000—and decreased participation in the sacraments.

The number of priests in the diocese is also expected to fall from 200 today to 112 in 2025.

This situation is not unique to Pittsburgh.

The Archdiocese of Hartford is in the process of merging dozens of parishes and expects its 212 parishes to be consolidated into 85 over the next decade.

Last year, the Archdiocese of Chicago, where an estimated 240 priests will be available to serve as pastors in 2030, launched “Renew My Church,” a major consolidation and renewal initiative for its 351 parishes.

Parish closures and mergers are painful, as anyone knows who has seen the doors close on the church where they were married or were baptized as a child.

Parishioners feel they have lost their spiritual homes.

But too often, coverage of these plans fails to recognize the severe constraints dioceses confront.

Many of these churches were built at a time when seminaries were full or when it made sense to have clusters of ethnic parishes serving waves of new immigrants.

Today, the church does not have the personnel to staff these parishes or the resources to maintain their properties.

According to the Center for Applied Research in the Apostolate at Georgetown University, in 1965 there were 1,289 parishioners per priest; that ratio is now 2,600 to 1; 20 percent of parishes lack a resident pastor, compared with 5 percent 50 years ago. (The priest shortage is playing out rather differently in the South and West, where church construction can hardly keep up with growing Catholic populations.)

There is no way to meet the present challenge without a significant degree of real loss.

But that does not mean these decisions have to be pitched as zero-sum battles. Continue reading

Analysis and Comment

Lieryn Barnett sometimes is so depressed, all she wants to do is sleep, she said. Other times, she’s so full of energy, she’ll be up in the middle of the night, singing or playing guitar. Or her mind will race at the same time her body won’t have the energy to do anything. All are Read more

In his own time people loved being in Jesus’ company, and sometimes spent days on end with him, even going hungry. How they felt about him gives us a window on the kind of Person he was – and a window on how we would have felt if we had been there! That’s why we Read more

Franciscan Clarist Congregation, a 130-year-old indigenous congregation in India, a month ago dismissed Sr. Lucy Kalappura, a member, for violating the vows of poverty and obedience. It gave her 10 days to appeal to the Vatican against the order, which she did. Kalappura says she was being punished for using media outlets to obtain justice Read more

The archbishop of Canterbury, head of the Church of England and the wider Anglican Communion, was an oil executive who helped run a major corporation before he became a parish priest. The latter job was unquestionably the most stressful he ever had, Justin Welby has said. “It was isolated, insatiably demanding, and I was, on Read more

Get CathNews by Email

Search CathNews

Search for:

Comments

Michael EdgarIn New Zealand the government is planning to make the killing of unborn children easier. The local Catholic church hierarchy is guiding us on how to submit a protest voice but nothing has been said about prayer.

KieranWhy stop at Harry Potter?The Lord of the Rings has its magicians and spells. And The Lion, the Witch and the Wardrobe. What about The Never Ending Story with its Nothing as the Death of Imagination. There is a spell in the Harry Potter series that turns one’s greatest fear into something comic....

DavidIt is true that other institutions as well as the Catholic Church failed in their care of minors.
This includes Governance and supervision roles of religious orders who ran many welfare homes like the one I was in.
The churches ecclesiology was viewed in Kingdom terms with Jesus as a King to...

Paul PearceHave you not noticed that for more than a year now, the focus of public derision has been the Catholic Church, and yet my recollection of the Royal Commission points the finger at many institutions who are as deficient as the Church in their handling of abuse.
Where are all the other churches and...