I found also this ship's manifest, if it is the right Giuseppa:First Name: GuiseppaLast Name: CarnesiEthnicity: Italy, ItalianLast Place of Residence: PalermoDate of Arrival: Oct 27, 1902Age at Arrival: 17y Gender: F Marital Status: S Ship of Travel: LahnPort of Departure: NaplesManifest Line Number: 0022http://www.ellisisland.org/EIFile/popup ... &line=0022

How did you get Giuseppa birth dateIs this the right Naturalzation record for Gaetano Barcia it has a different birth date for her Might be best to get their marriage record from NY with the parents names Certificate #11391 May 30 1910 Manhattan to get the right birth act Looks like a couple of Carnesi families using the first name Giuseppa I found another in 1887CLICK FOR RECORD KEEP CLICKING TO ENLARGE

The 1885 birth records for the town seem to be missing from the online records. The records jump from the 1884 death records to the 1885 marriage publications, then 1885 acts of marriage, and then 1885 death records. So there is no way to locate the 1885 birth record online to double check the date of birth, unless those records are somewhere out of order.Erudita

Marty,Yes, that is the correct naturalization for Giuseppa. Gaetano is her husband. I had already found that document. I'm thinking the NY marriage license will resolve the issue...Many thanks and much appreciation to all that responded!