A Failed Direct Deal?

PublishedApril 8, 2014 | ByAchim Neumann, President

Quite often our firm is hired to establish a value for a company through an independent accredited fair market valuation, but then we find the company’s owner attempting to sell the company on his own.

“The concept of ’doing a deal‘ directly might be enticing and perceived as a good way to save a broker’s commission,” says Achim Neumann, President A Neumann and Associates, LLC, New Jersey. “However, the truth is that the occurrence of any one of a number of events will most likely wipe out any anticipated savings.”

Specifically, there are numerous factors that jeopardize the efforts of a direct sale.

No Proper Buyer Qualification Process

Most often, when we are requested to advise a seller on a transaction “who currently is talking already to a buyer,” most often we notice that a formal qualification process has not been conducted; in other words, the buyer’s investment/income criteria, management qualifications (from a lender’s point of view), decision timeframe, balance sheet and bank account statements have not been requested. Further, at best, a one-page buyer Non-Disclosure Agreement (NDA) was signed, and not a detailed NDA as utilized by professionals in their day to day dealings with buyers.

Not only is the seller jeopardizing confidentiality through the lack of a proper NDA, he is doing so with a “buyer” who may not even be able to execute a deal, and the buyer will never know this until the deal reaches the closing table.

No Sense of Urgency

Another significant issue is, that if buyers sense they are the “only game in town,” they will typically take their time to wear the seller down on price and other terms. This is characterized by consistent and multiple requests for documents, taking his “sweet time” to decide on every issue, and just simply dragging out each step toward deal closing. The seller’s attempts to “force a decision” by setting a deadline will carry little impact because the buyer knows there is no other seller.

Bottom Fishing

Along the same lines, doing a deal directly will make it more difficult to obtain a full price offer from the buyer – even with a third party accredited valuation report. Buyers will simply disregard the validity of such a report, and the seller is often not sophisticated enough to counter in detail the points that the buyer may bring up with respect to such sophisticated valuation report. The outcome is that the buyer will likely only offer a fraction of the true market value.

Lack of Financing

Every buyer uses bank financing to acquire a company, typically for 50% (or more) of the asking price. We have seen again and again that a buyer relies on our organization to match him with the proper financing sources to obtain such funds, as specific lender risk assessments differ widely between different market segments.

Ironically, the buyer needs to present himself initially to the seller as a very well-funded investor in order to engage with a seller, but will then have to concede at a later stage that he/she does not have the funds for a deal. Consequently, a seller often wastes 2 to 3 months of his/her time until a deal collapses due to insufficient funds. Furthermore, a seller will find himself in a very unfavorable position to request financing details, as the buyer will perceive this as mistrust.

Adversarial Process

By it’s very nature, any type of negotiation is an adversarial process with opposing objectives: the buyer wants to pay as little as possible, while the seller wants to obtain the maximum price. And whereas this might not have any long-term implications in a real estate transaction, it will have a significant impact in the business transfer process. Simply stated, a real estate transaction is the transfer of one asset class with few contingencies. However, the transfer of a business includes many asset classes, and more importantly, it often has often a number of contingencies post transaction (i.e. seller note, consulting agreement, royalties, earn-outs, etc.), for all of which the seller and buyer will depend on each other’s goodwill in the future. Thus, it would not be a smart move to take a too direct an adversarial stance in the negotiation process; however, not doing so will deprive a seller of the maximum benefit. Only the use of a broker – as the middleman – will ensure maximum benefits and facilitate a deal.

Confidentiality Breach

When a seller deals directly with a buyer, then he/she clearly signals that they are ready to sell. The mere public knowledge of such intentions can be bad news for the competitive position of the company; for example, there would be significantly decreased chances for a banquet facility to book weddings, if it is known that the facility is up for sale. Competitors will exploit such uncertainty, no question about it, and competitors nearly always find out about direct negotiations. It is a similar situation when the employees or suppliers become aware that the “business is on the market”. The seller looses leverage with both groups and reduces the goodwill value of the transaction.

Seller Negotiation Position

The moment the seller deals direct, he/she is “on the spot”; in other words, if the buyer puts a proposition forward, the seller has to immediately react to it. With a broker, such reaction does not have to be immediate, and thus, allows for a better negotiation position on each side. For this very reason, we never engage sellers into direct sale price or deal structure negotiations with a buyer. It simply not wise to allow direct contact between two parties who may be negotiating the most significant deal of their life without proper representation.

In sum, the concept of a direct deal might be appealing. However, it only works in very few scenarios. As a matter of fact, most brokers will make adjustments in their commission schedules for existing buyers, and it is always smarter to have a dual process. It’s a win/win: if a potential buyer with whom the seller is currently dealing direct feels “pressured” by the presence of a qualified broker on the sell side and walks, a decision was (finally) obtained – with this buyer having never been a realistic buy side candidate to begin with. If the current buyer at hand will move forward, however, the seller will not only obtain close to full asking price but will do so in a speedy transaction – most often having received benefits that greately exceed any broker’s commission expense paid in the process.

A Neumann & Associates, LLC is a professional merger & acquisition and business brokerage firm with 30 years of experience in New Jersey, New York, Pennsylvania, Delaware and Maryland that assists business owners and buyers with the business transfer process in a completely confidential manner. The company is affiliated with BBN, with 450 offices and access to a national network of qualified buyers and sellers. For more information, please contact A Neumann & Associates at 732-872-6777

DISCLAIMER: You are entering a site that advertises businesses that might or might not be viable businesses. We have NOT reviewed such businesses. Please let us support you in negotiating such an acquisition BEFORE you contact the respective seller or broker on these sites. We can provide advisory services very often without any costs to you.

Please note that this Terms & Conditions of the Company Marketability Assessment & Privacy Policy applies to the A Neumann & Associates LLC (“ANA”) website located at www.neumannassociates.com.

The company is committed to providing its clients with quality service and adheres to the highest ethical practices. The company recognizes the importance of handling your personal information with care, and is dedicated to protecting the privacy of all visitors to the website as well as participants in the company’s email marketing campaigns, subject to the following terms:

Your Consent

By using this Web site, you agree to the terms of this Company Marketability Assessment (“CMA”) and Privacy Policy (“PP”). Whenever you submit information via this site, you consent to the collection, use, and disclosure of that information in accordance with this Privacy Policy.

Gathering and Use Of Information:

ANA collects information voluntarily provided by our clients and potential clients (hereinafter referred to as “you” and “your”) through our website, email marketing campaigns, and any other points of personal data gathering. However, we do not require our users to submit personal information to obtain general access to our website, however, for certain assessments certain data is collected from you. Information that is collected is used to improve our services to you and to better serve your needs by providing ANA with information about your interest in our services. In addition, the information collected helps us evaluate what types of information might be of most interest to you, and will help in establishing certain parameters in selling a company.

Any information or personal data that we collect by way of web site users who send us e-mails, faxes, or fill-in online forms containing personal information is used, solely, for purposes related to the brokerage services we provide to business buyers or sellers. ANA does not sell any information to third parties.

ANA has established appropriate physical, electronic, and procedural safety guidelines to protect the security and confidentiality of your nonpublic personal information. We educate our employees and team members about the terms of this Notice and the importance of customer privacy. We restrict access to nonpublic personal information about you to those employees and others who need to know that information to provide services to you, to maintain your accounts, or conduct our business.

Terms and Conditions of the Company Marketability Assessment

Data collected under the CMA will be used to establish an approximate framework for a company’s marketability within the general economy. The data input is conducted solely by you and thus, we can neither review, if the data is the correct and plausible information, nor do we have an opportunity to audit the information prior to report issuance. As such, the report being issued solely relies on your personal input.

The report shall neither be used as a stand-alone assessment for selling a company, financing or any other purpose, nor can ANA assume any responsibility for the correctness of the inputted information and the subsequent results. The underlying proprietary algorithms in establishing a report are subject to changes over time at the discretion of ANA, reflecting general market conditions. You recognize that the assessment is a subjective assessment based on ANA’s general market observations and that such market assessment can vary in between various firms and its professionals. As such the report in itself is merely an approximation and is of limited use as a stand-alone report but is most useful in conjunction with a detailed formal business valuation. The report will be interpreted and presented to you by an ANA representative.

As such, you and/or any associated party of yours hereby indemnify and hold harmless ANA, its Broker, agents, contractors, representatives and employees from and against any and all claims, liabilities, actions, causes of actions and damages, arising from or relating to any injury or loss arising out of, from, or attributed to the use of the website and the CMA, the report issued and matters subject thereto. In case of litigation due to the CMA, aforesaid indemnification shall provide, without limitation, including but not limited to, reimbursement of all reasonable attorney's fees incurred by ANA in connection with the assessment, in addition to $550/hour fees for any work performed by ANA, its Broker, agents, contractors, representatives and employees in litigation. DO NOT PROCEED IF YOU DO NOT CONSENT TO AFORESAID TERMS.

Categories of Information We Disclose and to Whom

Generally, ANA does not disclose any information about our clients or former clients to any other third party, except as required by law. Should this policy change, we will post an updated policy on our website.

ANA may disclose, however, certain types of information to third party companies that help the company to conduct business and to serve you, such as information we receive from a consumer reporting agency, government agencies and from your agent banks and prime brokers where applicable, and from other sources, such as information concerning credit worthiness and history, and certain information requested pursuant to US Patriot Act anti-money laundering prevention rules and regulations.

Collection of Personal Information in Forms:

Certain pages of ANA’s website contain forms that allow you to request information about our services and solutions. In completing a form, you may be required to provide contact information, such as your name, phone number, email address, company name or financial information. Further, in the course of business we may require nonpublic information from you on various other forms outside of this web site in order to establish credit and to provide you with certain information about businesses we represent.

Please note that any information you submit implies consent for use of the information, and ANA may use the information from these forms to respond to your request and send you the information requested.

Internet users:

ANA records and stores information provided by users when browsing the company’s website, and uses cookie technology to assist in making decisions about changes to the company’s website on an ongoing basis. Cookies help the company to determine, without collecting personal information, which information on the website appeals to our customers by tracking which of our Web pages are visited and what features are most often used.

Specifically, as you navigate through this Web site, certain anonymous information can be passively collected (that is, gathered without your actively providing the information) using various technologies, such as cookies, Internet tags or web beacons, and navigational data collection (log files, server logs, clickstream). Your Internet browser automatically transmits to this site some of this anonymous information, such as the URL of the Web site you just came from and the Internet Protocol (IP) address and the browser version your computer is currently using. This site may also collect anonymous information from your computer through cookies and Internet tags or web beacons. You may set your browser to notify you when a cookie is sent or to refuse cookies altogether, but certain features of this site might not work without cookies.

This Web site may use and combine such passively collected anonymous information to provide better service to site visitors, customize the site based on your preferences, compile and analyze statistics and trends, and otherwise administer and improve the site for your use. Such information is not combined with personally identifiable information collected elsewhere on the site unless you have consented.
The company uses Google Analytics to analyze anonymous visitor data.

Links:

Through this website you may be able to link to other websites which are not under the control of A Neumann & Associates, LLC. We have no control over the nature, content, privacy and availability of those sites. The inclusion of any links does not necessarily imply a recommendation or endorsement of the views expressed therein. We recommend that you check the specific privacy policy of any site before providing any personal information.

Changes to this Privacy Policy:

By using ANA’s website, you consent to the collection and use of this information by ANA. If there are any changes to our privacy policy, we will post the new Privacy Policy on this page.

If, at any time, you wish to unsubscribe to our email notices, you may send a message to info@NeumannAssociates.com with UNSUBSCRIBE in the subject line, or you can use the unsubscribe link on the bottom of any of our business announcements.

A Neumann & Associates, LLC, a New Jersey corporation, is a registered in the state of New Jersey and provides business brokerage services, restructuring, merger & acquisition and divestiture advisory services. The company is located in Atlantic Highlands, and can be contacted at