How to Present R&D Activities to Non-Technical

Transcription

1 1 How to Present R&D Activities to Non-Technical Audiences Sean McCarthy ( ) Research groups rely on public and private funding to finance their research work. The different people involved in the financing of R&D are the public officials who administer the funding programmes, the technical experts who evaluate the scientific excellence of the research, the business executives who require new technologies and the politicians who prepare economic and social policy. Researchers are under more and more pressure to present their activities to a wide range of audiences. Many books and courses exist on presentation skills. This article concentrates on the skills that are specific to the needs of researchers. The article is based on twenty years of presenting R&D activities at technical conferences, business conferences, contractors meeting and at public events. The article is also based on a training course developed by the author. Problems encountered by researchers presenting their work. The most common presentation problems quoted by researchers include the following: Getting to the point; Having time to prepare the presentation (either due to short notice or trying to be perfect); Tailoring the presentation to the audience; Knowing how much detail is required. Other problems include nervousness and technical problems with equipment (especially the LCD projectors for PowerPoint presentations). Speaking in another language is quoted as a major problem. When researchers present their activities to non-technical audiences the following problems are observed: Researchers use presentations to demonstrate that they know their subject and that they work hard! These two problems consume over 50% of the time in technical presentations. Researchers use public presentations to demonstrate their depth of knowledge in their field and the complexity, intensity and sophistication of their work. If a researcher can avoid the above they can save 50% of the available presentation time. Researchers tell us what they do NOT why they do it! In a presentation the researcher must first educate the audience on why the topic is important. At the beginning of every presentation the researcher must answer the following questions: Why bother with this type of work? Why not purchase the solution on the market? If it is so important, why wait until now (and not 5 years ago)? Is this totally new or are you building on other peoples work? Jargon, buzz words, terminology This problem is common to all professions but science seems to generate acronyms and buzz words at a faster rate. Examples include acronyms such as IPR (Intellectual Property Rights), SME (Small and Medium Sized Enterprises) and WP (work plan). These acronyms should be avoided in presentations. Use the full words rather than the acronyms. Researchers focus on their activities rather than on their results Most organisations and individual describe what they do based on what they produce e.g. Microsoft produce Excel, PowerPoint, etc. Siemens produce computers, controllers etc. Researchers, on the other hand, are often content to describe what they do solely on their activities. Researchers claim that they undertake research on nanotechnology, biotechnology etc. But what do researchers produce? Researchers produce new knowledge, prototypes, documents, software, data, transgenic mice, new materials, etc. In presentations researchers must focus on their activities AND on their results. It is also essential that the results must be expressed in the words of the user. Some examples are shown in the following table.

2 2 Table 1: Examples: Translation of research language into user language Scientific Result User of the Result What the User Calls It Report on the system Design Engineer Design Specification Performance Improvement Production Manager Process Improvement Instrument Data Instrument Designer Calibration Curve Engine Data Engine Designer Performance Data Results of tests Medical Personnel Screening Criteria Data Policy Maker Environmental Indicators CD ROM Trainer Training Material Database Researcher Search Engine New Knowledge Researcher Scientific Publications NB: In a presentaion the researcher would present Column 2 and Column 3 e.g. a design specification for a design engineer or a calibration curve for an instrument designer. How to Prepare a Technical Presentation The following emotional phases are common to all IMPORTANT presentations. Phase 1: Privileged to be asked Phase 2: Realisation of work involved Phase 3: Start planning (Sorry you agreed) Phase 4: Preparation of talk (Really sorry you agreed) Phase 5: Before presentation (Panic!) Phase 6: Presentation (I feel great) Phase 7: Audience applauds (All the effort was worth it) Phase 8: Asked to give another talk (Go to phase 1) The important message here is that presentations have three very distinct phases: (1) The Planning Phase (2) The Preparation Phase (3) The Presentation Phase. The following section summarises what is required in each phase. Sample Presentation A researcher, specialising in nanocomposites, has been asked to make a presentation at a conference organised by the European Plastics Industry Association. The Planning Phase All presentions have a generic format and this is summarised in Figure 1. Figure 1:LAYOUT OF THE PRESENTATION Order of Presenting Title Introduction Background Order of Preparation Details CORE MESSAGE 75% of the preparation 2 1

3 3 The important message here is that 75% of the planning consists of defining the Core Message. This is the most important issue in any presenation. The Core Message will depe nd on the audience. For example if we use the case of the researcher making the nanocomposites presentation the Core Message could vary in the following ways: Table 2: How the Core Message depends on the audience EXAMPLES OF DIFFERENT AUDIENCES Business Enterprises funding the development of a new nanocomposite process. POSSIBLE CORE MESSAGE The system works Funding Agency who is providing funding to the researcher. The work is on schedule Business Enterprises interested in funding a pilot process. We have the technical solution. It is working in the laboratory and we need funding to demonstrate it at a pilot scale. Presentation to a multinational company interested in funding the activities of the researcher. We already work with companies like yours When you identify the Core Message everything else must lead up to this. The best way to test a Core Message is to imagine if someone woke up at the end of the presentation they would have a clear understanding of the presentation. The Core Message should also be structured so that it can be discussed after the presentation. To find the Core Message the presenter must first understand how the presentation will be judged (a) by the audience (b) by the researcher s organisation and (c) by the presenter themselves. In the cases of the researcher preparing the presentation for the Plastics Industry Association the Core Message would be identified in the following way: a) The Plastics Industry will say the presentation was brilliant if: They understand the relevance of nanocomposites to their business. They have facts and figures to compare nanocomposites with their existing products. They receive a roadmap on how to incorporate nanocomposites into their business. They identify funding to support the above. b) The researcher s organisation will say the presentation was brilliant if: The industries were interested in funding R&D activities Meetings were requested to discuss cooperation c) The researcher (the individual) will say the presentation was brilliant if: The researcher is respected by the industry as an expert in the field. Ther researcher is requested to submit proposals for R&D funding

4 4 The Core Message? Nanocomposites market estimated at 10billion by 2010 First markets for nanocomposites:aerospace, automotive, packaging, computers. We are one of the European Leaders in this field. Funding is available in European Union R&D Programmes (CRAFT). (This was actually a real case. The researchers submitted a proposal based on the above and received a score of 5/5 for economic relevance of their prop osal. They also received the full amount of funding they requested. The presentation was later published in the Plastics Industry Yearbook 2000) Preparing the Content Title: This should be based on the Core Message e.g. The Importance of Nanocomposites to the European Plastics Industry over the Next 10 Years. Background: Educate the audience with facts and figures that support the Core Message. For example in the above presentation the following table was presented: Table 3: Improved Performance of Plastics with a 3-5% weight nanocomposite loading. Performance Properties Improvement over existing products Tensile Strength % Flexural Modulus % Thermal Stability 30-80% Gas Permeability Reduction % Heat Release Rate Reduction 60-80% Details of the Presentation: This section should only contain details you need to support the Core Message. In the above example the presenter would demonstrate the samples of products made using nanocomposites, list industries already active in this area (Toyota Central R&D Labs, Inc) and would describe the changes that would have to be made to the industrial processes. The presenter would also provide an overview of the European Union R&D programmes and the programme that would support this type of project.

5 5 WHAT DIFFERENT AUDIENCES LOVE/HATE TO HEAR The following table summarises how different audiences judge presentations. Audience What they like to hear What they hate to hear Business Executives Commercial awareness of their needs Business Arguments Facts and figures relevant to their business Technical competence in the subject Professional image Ability to communicate ideas Lectures Theories Jargon Pet Projects Public Officials (Funding Agency) Relevance to their policies Serious scientists Respect for deadlines/paperwork Real successes Money hunters (with no science) Contractual Problems Problems without solutions Surprises Politicians Issues which support their ideas Image and public relations for themselves Success Stories Slogans e.g. The future is nano Controversial issues Complex issues Other Scientists Latest breakthroughs Sources of information (websites) Relevant conferences/seminars Sources of funding Technical leaders in the field Old stories TIPS DURING PRESENTATIONS Many books have been written on this subject. Here we will simply include the most important points that should be remembered by researchers: 1. When you stand up on the podium everyone is with you! This should help you overcome any nervousness you may have. 2. DO NOT EXPECT A REACTION FROM THE AUDIENCE This is the most important point I have learned over 20 years. If people are genuinely interested in your presentation all their brain cells are used to concentrate on your presentation and very few brain cells are left to control their facial expressions. 3. Speak slowly and clearly. People speaking in their non-native language have a major advantage here they have no option but to speak slowly and clearly. 4. How to deal with interruptions (e.g. your notes falling on the floor) Pause, Correct, Continue. It looks very professional. 5. Adopt a confident poise, have a simple plan for your hands and scan the audience. 6. How to finish You must have your own closing line. For example Thank you for your attention and if you have any questions I would be delighted to answer them. THANK YOU VERY MUCH.

6 6 CONCLUSION When you make a professional presentation the experience can be magic. All the planning, all the preparation and all the practice is worth the effort. Next to science, the ability to communicate your ideas to any audience is the most important skill for a researcher. The important point to remember is that when you are planning the presentation start with the Core Message, then identify the details you need to support the Core Message and finally include background information to educate the audience on issues which will help them understand the Core Message. You make the presentation in the reverse order i.e. background, details and then the Core Message. To perfect your presentation skills you must practice, observe, refine, practice, observe, refine. AUTHOR Dr. Sean McCarthy is Managing Director of Hyperion Ltd. Hyperion specialises in the development of training course for research managers. Full details of their training courses can be found on Hyperion s clients can be seen on

How to Give a Research Seminar When presenting a seminar, the following guidelines may be useful. The main thing to remember when giving a seminar is that you must own the presented material. If you make

Presentation Skills This guide is part of the Applications and Interviews series. For more guides in the series please visit the website below. Careers & Employability Service www.mmu.ac.uk/careers/guides

7 One of the things you will often be asked to do at the university is to give a presentation in class. Many people are terrified of public speaking and would do anything to get out of it. Nevertheless,

How are you going to do it? Drafting a business plan Background A business plan sets out the business case for a particular project, organisation or venture. It states how you will go about running a specific

Equip Financial Medical Coverage For A Secure Future Medical Coverage Guide for help choosing the right Medical Insurance Understanding The Top 3 Questions To Ask Private Health Care Providers To Ensure

Tips and language for telephone interviews What tips could you give someone about each stage of telephone interviews written below? Starting the telephone call Technical problems Taking notes Mentioning

Clinical Trials Clinical Trials This brochure is for people making decisions about cancer treatment. You may be thinking about a clinical trial for you or your child but need to know more before you decide.

Youth Club Young Volunteer Handbook Task Training Presentation and Public Speaking Skills This resource may be used free of charge by local authorities and community groups for the benefit of young people;

the Master Influencer Management Development TOM says Effective influencing is the key skill for succeeding in life and business! 1 day Advanced Business Communication Workshop proudy presented by Seminars

How to Sell Professional Services By Tony Reiss As the markets for professional services became de-regulated and as partnerships competed more aggressively with each other to win new clients, firms started

Risk Analysis toolkit MMU has a corporate Risk Management framework that describes the standard for risk management within the university. However projects are different from business as usual activities,

Steps for Planning and Preparing an Effective Presentation According to speaking consultant Lilyan Wilder (1999), two of the greatest myths about delivering oral presentations are that you re better off

INTERNATIONAL ACADEMY OF EXPERIENTIAL EDUCATION No. 142204-LLP-1-2008-1-LT-GRUNDTVIG-GMP This project has been funded with support from the European Commission. This site reflects the views only of the

How to Make Sure Your Talk Doesn t Suck David Tong This is an annotated version of a talk I gave at a summer school for first year graduate students. Anything sitting in a box, like this, summarizes what

Now available for hire Following the success of the London display 3D: Printing the Future is now available to hire. The Science Museum is offering a Blueprint Pack so that you can be creative, innovative

And Organization Building GOALS By the end of this module, participants should be able to understand: The concept of self-interest and how it is used to recruit and retain volunteers. The Six-Step Process

Guide to marketing www.glasgow.ac.uk/corporatecommunications University of Glasgow Corporate Communications 3 The Square Glasgow G12 8QQ 0141 330 4919 2 Introduction One of the easiest mistakes to make

MICROSOFT DYNAMICS NAV TRAINING Get the best out of Microsoft Dynamics NAV with training from Tisski. Ensure the successful use of your Enterprise Resource Planning solution and exceed your objectives.

Last month s Tip Sheet No. 10 provided information on forming and utilizing a speakers bureau. Now somebody s got to get out there and deliver an insightful, stimulating and captivating speech. Yikes --

White Paper By Bev Meldrum, Pete Read and Colin Harrison Contents 1. Why Measure Social Impact?... 3 1.1 Social Impact tells the story of the change we bring to people s lives... 3 1.2 What does Social

session 5 Evaluation Time One to two hours. Students may need an extra lesson and homework to prepare PowerPoint presentations if doing the two hour evaluation. About this session Students will evaluate

Writing The Business Case for Automated Software Testing and Test Management Tools How to successfully research, plan and present a convincing business case that will justify the budget and resources you

Your guide to Communicating with people with a learning disability About this guide This guide is designed to provide a brief introduction to communication, and the problems faced by someone with a learning

The New Customer Experience Manifesto How to Create a Customer Experience Board How to Create a Customer Experience Board If you agree delivering superior customer experience is vital to your business,

WWW.SOFTDOTNET.COM SOFT DOT NET PROFILE & SERVICES Leading in Web Design & Online Services I- Who We Are? Soft Dot Net is a business solution and leading website design company specialises in web design,

Programmes co-funded by the European Union Joint Communication Training for project partners of the SEE and MED Programmes 2 nd and 3 rd of June 2014 - Bled, Slovenia WELCOME Learning session Story-telling

HOW TO WIN THE BES POSTER PRIZE! Tips, suggestions and worthy advice from Emma Sayer Why bother putting effort into your poster? You have a few days to go before the meeting; you ve been rushing to finish

Reflective Writing Reflective Writing There are a variety of reasons you might need to write reflectively. When you apply for jobs, undertake self-evaluation at work or whilst studying, or when writing

For More Free Marketing Information, Tips & Advice, visit www.lgx.im DISCLAIMER AND/OR LEGAL NOTICES The information presented in this E Book represents the views of the publisher as of the date of publication.

How to write a great CV No matter what the selection process is for the role you are applying for, the first step is making sure you have a great CV! Your CV will be used to assess your suitability for

Learn How to Revise 1 SCHOOL EXAM DATES 2016 END OF YEAR EXAMS FOR YEARS 7-9 BEGIN ON MONDAY 6 TH JUNE THEY WILL TAKE PLACE IN LESSONS DURING THIS WEEK AND IF NECESSARY THE WEEK AFTER. Some subjects are

Stanford s Design Program FAQ s Revised 07. 28. 2014 NOTE: This FAQ s applies to students who have a Bachelor of Science degree in math, science, engineering or some other technical or scientific field

VITAL CHOICES: DRINKING, DRIVING & SEAT BELTS This easy-to-use Leader s Guide is provided to assist in conducting a successful presentation. Featured are: INTRODUCTION: A brief description of the program

PAYMENT PROTECTION INSURANCE RESEARCH ANALYTICAL REPORT NOVEMBER 2015 ABOUT COMRES ComRes provides specialist research and insight into reputation, public policy and communications. It is a founding member

Why Sales Training Doesn t Work...and what to do about it! Selling isn t a great sport in which to come second. In the world of winner takes all, anything that gives you a small increase in performance

Franchise Opportunities Award winning marketing support that delivers business growth Who are Fresh Marketing Solutions? Fresh Marketing Solutions have become a leading marketing consultancy in the East

How to Pass Physics 212 Physics is hard. It requires the development of good problem solving skills. It requires the use of math, which is also often difficult. Its major tenets are sometimes at odds with

Evaluation Support Guide 2.5 Storing Information for Evaluation Evaluation can help you to work out what difference you are making through your services or activities. The changes or differences you hope

THE TOP 5 TIPS FOR BECOMING MORE ASSERTIVE Being Assertive is not just using a certain set of communication skills or behaviours. Assertiveness is, first and foremost an attitude of mind with an accompanying

13. Project Management and the Australian Bureau of Statistics: Doing What Works Dennis Trewin, Australian Statistician, Australian Bureau of Statistics Introduction Project management has to be a core

MARTIN MONTGOMERY Professional Profile METRO REALTY LTD LICENSED REAA 2008 INTRODUCING MARTINMONTGOMERY WHY SHOULD YOU LIST WITH ME? I am a full time Real Estate professional. It is all I do it is my career.

Activity plan guidance Parks for People October 2012 If you require a copy of this guidance in an alternative format (large print, Braille or audio version), or if your first language is not English, we

Why Write the Book, and, Why Release it for Free? by Jeffrey W. Schnick While investigating how best to implement active learning in the classroom, I found that among the various active learning methods

Testimony Before the House Subcommittee on Technology and Innovation Regarding the National Institute of Standards and Technology (NIST) By Mary L. Good Donaghey Professor and Dean, Donaghey College of

WHAT DOES THE PSYCHOLOGICAL THERAPIES HEAT TARGET MEAN TO YOU? NHS Boards are now half way through the first year of implementation of the HEAT target Deliver faster access to mental health services by

Presentation Skills Presentation Skills Preparing and giving presentations Like any academic project, before giving PowerPoint presentation you need to prepare and plan ahead. Identifying the purpose By

Funding and resourcing our work JAMES BANKS, SOCIAL PROFIT SOLUTIONS Five questions we ll cover today 1. Who are we? Are we ready for funding? 2. Why do we need funding? Can we describe what we want to

Communication skills for Internal Auditors Course Outline Day 1 Effective communication the goal of all auditors The importance of effective communication Research results from the IIA Why communication

25 Quick Content Ideas for Social Media & Email Marketing Are you stuck? Not sure what to post or how to start talking to your community? Take a peek at these 25 ideas and put some into action right away.

Draft HPC Standards of Proficiency a personal critique from a humanistic perspective By John Gloster-Smith, MAHPP. Introduction This brief commentary is a response to the Health Professions Council (HPC)

E-learning: revolutionary or evolutionary Initial wild enthusiasm for e-learning has given way to more cautious practice.viki Holton and Andrew Ettinger seek out the reality behind the hyperbole and disappointment.

Business Intelligence for Mid-Size Companies The Case for Better BI and How to Succeed White Paper Introduction Matillion deliver Business Intelligence solutions that are powerful but easy to use. Solutions

Chapter1 13/3/06 8:38 pm Page 1 1 INTRODUCTION 1.1 The Need for Guidance on ERP System Validation There are numerous books that address the topic of computer systems validation in the regulated life sciences

Customer Retention Strategies Quick Tips To Make A Positive Difference Brought to you by and www.learndirect.co.uk/businessinfo/ Improve your workforce with learndirect Business Customer Retention Strategies

How Great Schools Use Design Thinking to Improve Student Agency Laboratory on Design Thinking in Education University of Kentucky dlab.uky.edu 2013 Indiana's Future Conference Indianapolis, IN November