Spotlight: Terry's Catering

For Terry’s Catering co-owner Andrea Cockerham, catering is about more than just providing food for an event.

It’s about playing a role in making someone’s special occasion just right, whether it be a wedding or a funeral, a gala or a business meeting.

For more than 30 years, Terry’s Catering — jointly owned by Andrea Cockerham and founders Terry and Lillie Cockerham, her parents-in-law — has been doing just that. A fixture of the local catering scene, Terry’s Catering prides itself on providing excellent food and Andrea Cockerham. exceptional service, all with a family touch.

The business dates back to at least the mid-1980s, when founders Terry and Lillie Cockerham — a musician and seamstress respectively at that time — purchased a building in which they opened a nightclub downstairs and a custom window treatment business upstairs, Andrea Cockerham said. By the early 1990s, the pair had sold the window treatment shop and shifted the focus of the nightclub into catering and hosting events at its banquet hall.

More recently, Terry’s has eliminated its banquet hall and now does a brisk business exclusively as a caterer at off-site events. Indiana University is one particularly big client — “we do a lot on campus for the Kelley School of Business, business meetings and breakfasts and lunches,” Cockerham notes — and they are capable of catering up to three weddings per day during the busy season.

“We pretty much can do anything,” Cockerham said. “Weddings and funerals, we’ll do a lot of memorial services if they want us to come and have some food at their home or a church. We also have bar services.”

The company’s busy season used to be mostly during the popular summer wedding months, but as business has grown over the years Cockerham now finds there are rarely slow periods any more. That means there is always plenty to do for the Cockerhams, who eschew the notion that as owners they should be able to take astep back from the day-to-day operations ons of the business.

On the contrary, Cockerham said, she believes a big factor in Terry’s Catering’s longevity and sterling reputation in the community is the fact that it is not only family owned, but family operated as well. At virtually every event, either Cockerham or one of her in-laws will be on sight making sure everything is running smoothly.

“We don’t sit in the office” and let other people handle everything, she said.

“We are there with them as well and not just sending them out blindly.”

Having a reputation for great food and a seamless setup also helps, she said. Cockerham describes Terry’s Catering as comfort food, tasting like dishes cooked in their own home. Some perennial favorites, she said, are a chicken breast stuffed with homemade spinach artichoke dip and macaroni and cheese; that last one, she said, has made a comeback after years of people avoiding carbs.

That said, Cockerham emphasizes that the company regularly provides a wide variety of cuisine. There’s little, she said, they can’t manage.

“We do a lot of comfort food, but I don’t want to pigeon-hole us,” she said. “When we cater for a program from Korea, we do Korean food. We can do Thai food, we do hors d’oeuvres. We do vegetarian, vegan and gluten free. We try to meet the needs (with options) that everybody would like.”

Customers usually select items from a long menu the business sends to prospective clients, but they are not strict about sticking exclusively to those options. “If they want something that isn’t on our menu, they are more than welcome to tell me and we can customize their menu as well,” she said.

While a typical catering assignment might have Terry’s serving a few hundred people, the company is no stranger to larger assignments. Recently they held an event for 1,400 people, and in the past they’ve served groups of up to 8,000.

Much like with restaurants, Cockerhamsaid, the biggest challenge of operating the business is often staffing. Unlike restaurants, however, serving private parties means the added challenge of not having set schedules for its waitstaff, which can be difficult for working families.

“We try to be creative,” she said of meeting the staffing challenge. “We like to hire IU students because it works around their schedule, or working folks who can work on the weekends in the evening.”

Of course, different individual catering jobs bring different challenges and rewards, Cockerham said. In one memorable case, that meant racing to rescue tables sinking into the ground after portable heaters began to thaw the previously frozen ground at a chilly outdoor event. For another, it might be figuring out how to maneuver equipment up tight stairs in an old building.

But the best part, she said, is knowing that Terry’s Catering has done its part to bring an event off perfectly. e A favorite memory of hers is a special wedding held at the bride’s family home, where the bride’s father had spent a year constructing a pier on which the couple could say their vows above the water. The event was even more touching because the bride’s mother had recently overcome a devastating illness, she said.

“It made us feel like, ‘Wow, we really had a part in making the day special not just for the bride, but for the mom as well because she’d been so ill she wasn’t sure she’d be there,’” remembers Cockerham.

It’s hard to say what the future will bring for Terry’s Catering, Cockerham said, but in the meantime she and her co-owners are focused on continuing to grow the business while maintaining their own high standards.

“We want to continue to make people happy, and to make their events special,” she said simply.