Breweries And Bars Should Kill The Shaker Pint…

From Munich to Milwaukee, when you see heads turn over a shapely, elegant glass of hefeweizen, you’ve just witnessed the true beer experience. While taste and smell capture a lot of attention, the sense of sight is too often cast aside as a mere afterthought when it comes to beer. From striking hues to gravity-defying heads, the visual elements of beer bring an immeasurable joy to the drinking experience, too often ignored in the United States.

We’re keen on efficiency here, ruthless in our pursuit of it, often to the detriment of remarking on the value of details encountered along the way. Perhaps nothing in the beer world symbolizes this ethos better than the so-called shaker pint. With its utilitarian design and absence of flair or character, the shaker pint glass screams efficiency. Once derided by Garrett Oliver as a mere “jam jar,” the shaker pint has flourished and become a mainstay in American pubs, not for its ability to improve the products contained within its lackluster glass walls, but because it stacks evenly on bar shelves. Pouring milk and sugary sodas into these beer glasses, as well as the inevitable stacking scuffs, results in instant death to your favorite beer’s head.

So tedious is the shaker pint’s design that breweries have taken to slapping all manners of logos across them. The shaker’s uninspired design, combined with the emblem army, discourage brewers from actively considering how their beers look to the customer. If the ubiquitous, poorly treated glass is designed to kill your beer’s head or obscure its appearance, then why bother spending time ensuring sufficient protein formation necessary to well-sustained foam? If the customer cannot see foam lacing and does not expect much in the looks department, why work for improvements? The shaker pint has bred a culture of a disappointing level of apathetic indifference in American brewers to the cause of good looking pints.

The situation is so advanced that most American drinkers consider a frothy head to be a complaint worthy problem. Bartenders across the country dare to get lambasted by serving their customers with any semblance of foam. And that is somewhat understand, if entirely lamentable. While technically capable of holding sixteen-ounces of liquid, shaker pints in reality are often “cheater pints,” distinguished by their heavy, thick glass bottoms and barely able to handle fourteen-ounces. When advertised as a pint, bars manage to cheat customers an ounce or two at a time, big money over the course of a couple hundred or thousand kegs a year.

In Belgium, beer presentation is nearly considered an art form. Function and form be damned if a Brussels server takes a few extra minutes to find your beer, choose the matching glassware, present the beer to you, and slowly and methodically pout the proper beer, stopping just short of the finish to allow you to decide if and when to pour the last precious few ounces into your glass. Belgian beer glasses either can handle only three-quarters of the bottle’s contents, requiring you to stop short and give it a second pour, or offer several extra inches of room, so that the head has sufficient room to expand. And the Belgians achieve all of this without cheating you out of the advertised amount you ordered. These same bars also manage to carry several dozen, if not hundreds, of individual brands, each with their own specially designed glassware. Storage problems? Never heard of them.

While it would be great if everyday American bars followed the path blazed by the Belgians, we needn’t run before learning to walk. Bars need only select a half-dozen different glass styles, each with the qualities necessary to present their beers in the best lights, and thus encourage sales with the corresponding head-turns, and match the expectations of their customers for honest pints, tulips, and snifters. And breweries should help by discontinuing the production of the shaker pint and redoubling efforts towards promoting pretty pints. Only when these groups get together will the full beer experience be enjoyed in America.

–Article appeared in Issue 30 of BeerAdvocate Magazine…

Please follow and like us:

Post navigation

6 thoughts on “Breweries And Bars Should Kill The Shaker Pint…”

I agree that shakers, as much because of the thick glass as the shape, do not serve the flavor and aroma many beers well. But having once spent an evening tending bar (for a story) I would argue that they are easy to wash and thus more likely to be “beer clean” than other glasses.

Part of the issue here is volume (by this I mean the volume the pub is moving, not whether you are receiving an “honest pint”). Shaker pints hold down costs. So would you pay more, which probably means a quarter because that’s the way bars work, for the proper glass?

Can you talk the woman next to you into doing the same? And the guy next to her?

I like the way shacker glasses keep all those unbalanced US IPAs in their place, letting the malt come through. Plus for a Canadian, they are as exotic as any Belgian glass – many of which shapes do not show off their assigned beer so much as they just differentiate themselves from the next Belgian beer glass. Be proud of your national beery traditions, that’s what I say. And who else has a drinking vessel named after an obscure Protestant denomination?

Alan’s comment is a delightful reminder that, to the visitor, local culture is often beguiling–no matter how much locals hate it.

I’m with Andy on this one, though. Perhaps Alan suggests a solution: the glassware company that can create and popularize a nice-looking, full pint glass (that is to say an, ahem honest pint) of a unique, American design would be doing us a big favor.

Delightful! I knew that wearing my bow tie when I write it would make for magic. So I will return a compliment. Jeff’s point is entirely correct. The US is big enough and gosh darn clever enough to create its own sensible standard glass – without going to the Moulin Rouge lengths of that Sam Adams thing-a-ma-jiggy glass.

I think maybe a compromise is in order. Keep the shaker pint and create special glasses for special beers. I’m of the opinion that the shaker pint glass is a quite good all-around, default beer glass. It works well for most beers. As for it being a head killer, well, I don’t get it. I first read this a week or so ago, then went to a cafe in Belgium. I noticed that not a single beer around me had retained its head as it was drunk, so I’m not so sure the glass is the culprit. I also noticed that the lace left behind was not nearly as nice as what remains on an American pint glass.