everyone saying skadaddy is shit and want some jdm or nifty replacement. the real problem is c9 have no support. name 1 good support in NA besides maybe stan and taco (no offense but neither compare to EU supports like karrigan or xyp9x). boston they played well cuz ska played supportive even tho he didnt like it and they played great when ska played good and supported. no good na support that can support consistency like ska did at boston so will never reach that skill level again. no good na supports because na community only wants star players and dont care for someone who can support. tl:dr sorry
/discuss

And they've proven the Major was a complete fluke. They had one great run, then went on to accomplished practically nothing as a team since. RUSH hasn't been doing well as of late, and even tarik has been hit-or-miss. autimatic is the only player to consistently play at a high level.

The had a lot of Top4s before the major actually. It was a fluke in the sense of them being a real contender but not a fluke in terms of being Top5ish. They were doing well for a while before they won the major. Now theyre obviously bad.

They just peaked at the right time. C9 is huge individually, but they have 0 tactics... If they are on point, they will cruise through almost anyone. The problema is, besides the Major, I've never seen them peak all together.

if you want to have the players kicked for wanting to IGL and for being too "free" sure.
NBK is not the right choice for any team, I have disliked him ever since he got rid of Scream and even more when he "kicked" Shoxie.
Mixwell would be a good addition and even though I love Skadaddy and he's my favorite pro player, if he can't step up and so on again they need a new AWPer. He will be a legend though.

NBK studied C9 a lot in demos and found a lot of problems. He can fix those problems by becoming the IGL of C9.
He will become the support to let autimatic tarik RUSH and Skadoodle do the work.
He would be a great addition imo