Can we get an all Cheryl and Toni musical episode now? Don’t rule it out!

“We would absolutely do a musical again,” showrunner Roberto Aguirre-Sacasa told Variety recently. “Every high school does a musical every year. So I think it would be finding the right [one].”

He adds, “We got really lucky [with the previous episode] — Carrie felt like it slotted in perfectly and these stories felt like they docked perfectly. The bar is really high but 100% we would do it again. I think everybody had a blast doing it.”