New New York Times columnist a bike commuter

I don't like even my own car. For most of my adult life I didn't even own one. I lived in Manhattan and pitied the suburbanites driving to the mall. When I moved to Washington and joined their ranks, I picked a home in smart-growth heaven, near a bike path and a subway station. Most days I skate or bike downtown, filled with righteous Schadenfreude as I roll past drivers stuck in traffic. The rest of the time I usually take the subway, and on the rare day I go by car, I hate the drive.

I think he USED to be a bike commuter, but has more recently become what he calls an "autonomist" - ie a person who believes in the primacy of the auto. My understanding of his entire career is that he was once a decent fellow, but has become an anti-humanist and an extremist libertarian. But I guess we'll see what we get when he actually starts writing!

Righteous Schadenfreude is one of the many pleasures of commuting in DC. It's hard to imagine anyone giving that up. Auto commuter traffic in DC makes me think of a medieval flagellants procession. Whatever his politics, I have no reason to think him masochistic enough to drive.

I think he USED to be a bike commuter, but has more recently become what he calls an "autonomist" - ie a person who believes in the primacy of the auto. My understanding of his entire career is that he was once a decent fellow, but has become an anti-humanist and an extremist libertarian. But I guess we'll see what we get when he actually starts writing!

Reading the rest of his article, its pretty clear the guy is on crack.

His idea that cars create autonomy is a cruel hallucination-- they do the opposite.

All I can say is that I really really hope that virtual workspaces (working virtually from home) becomes a reality before we need friggin' 32 lane highways and computer-controlled cars.

Reading the rest of his article, its pretty clear the guy is on crack.

His idea that cars create autonomy is a cruel hallucination-- they do the opposite.

All I can say is that I really really hope that virtual workspaces (working virtually from home) becomes a reality before we need friggin' 32 lane highways and computer-controlled cars.

He is on crack half the time. During a rush hour in a crowded city, I have to agree that cars don't do much good, everybody is stuck in one place.

But during non rush hours, and in less congested suburban and rural areas, the car is a godsend and definitely creates not only autonomy but vast quantities of wealth as goods, services, and ideas are moved along. If your idea was valid, than the fewer cars an economy had, the more productive their citizens would be.

We need a multi-use transportation network. I think a very good case can be made for better mass transit in many urban areas. But the limitations of mass transit are so manifest that they only succeed when they are massively subsidized and auto use punitively singled out. The end result in such regions--Europe comes to mind--is economic stagnation and high unemployment.

...
But during non rush hours, and in less congested suburban and rural areas, the car is a godsend and definitely creates not only autonomy but vast quantities of wealth as goods, services, and ideas are moved along. If your idea was valid, than the fewer cars an economy had, the more productive their citizens would be.

We need a multi-use transportation network. I think a very good case can be made for better mass transit in many urban areas. But the limitations of mass transit are so manifest that they only succeed when they are massively subsidized and auto use punitively singled out. The end result in such regions--Europe comes to mind--is economic stagnation and high unemployment.

roughstuff

For folks that live and work in low-density rural areas, of course, a car is necessary.

The real problem is when you have massive housing developments built further and further away from cities and industrial centers. More and more people then try to commute absurd distances from all different directions. This creates an insatiable need for more highways.

This is basically a hyper version of what happened in the 50's through the 80's. Except back then, the pattern was that households moved out of the city, had a home constructed and moved into the new home-- a one household at a time steady trickle. Now the pattern is for a developer to buy a trememendous amount of land, build housing for 2000 people in mcmansion and luxury condo form, and then cash in as a flood of buyers come in and become exburbites. These are the people that then complain loudly about 2 hour commutes, too much traffic, and too much stress-- as if more lanes will solve their problems.

For folks that live and work in low-density rural areas, of course, a car is necessary.

The real problem is when you have massive housing developments built further and further away from cities and industrial centers. More and more people then try to commute absurd distances from all different directions. This creates an insatiable need for more highways.

This is basically a hyper version of what happened in the 50's through the 80's. Except back then, the pattern was that households moved out of the city, had a home constructed and moved into the new home-- a one household at a time steady trickle. Now the pattern is for a developer to buy a trememendous amount of land, build housing for 2000 people in mcmansion and luxury condo form, and then cash in as a flood of buyers come in and become exburbites. These are the people that then complain loudly about 2 hour commutes, too much traffic, and too much stress-- as if more lanes will solve their problems.

I live ~7 miles from work, and wish I were closer(10-15 minute commute). I used to live ~13 miles from work and I hated it(20-25 min). Some of my co-workers drive up to 3 hours(one way). Frankly, I'd rather be at home than on the road--what's the point of having time off if you can't enjoy it? Might not be feasible for some people to move closer to their workplace, but I think I'd be getting another job if I had too much travel time.

He is on crack half the time. During a rush hour in a crowded city, I have to agree that cars don't do much good, everybody is stuck in one place.

But during non rush hours, and in less congested suburban and rural areas, the car is a godsend and definitely creates not only autonomy but vast quantities of wealth as goods, services, and ideas are moved along. If your idea was valid, than the fewer cars an economy had, the more productive their citizens would be.

We need a multi-use transportation network. I think a very good case can be made for better mass transit in many urban areas. But the limitations of mass transit are so manifest that they only succeed when they are massively subsidized and auto use punitively singled out. The end result in such regions--Europe comes to mind--is economic stagnation and high unemployment.

roughstuff

Hmm, auto transportaion is much more heavily subsidized that public transit. The problem is they don't call it subsidize. Estimates on the percenatage of true cost paid by the commuter is something like 26% auto and 85% mass transit user.

Hmm, auto transportaion is much more heavily subsidized that public transit. The problem is they don't call it subsidize. Estimates on the percenatage of true cost paid by the commuter is something like 26% auto and 85% mass transit user.

- - Whoa, run that by me again. I have heard about hidden subsidies for auto transportation but I have never seen those figures before. Please tell me your sources of that expose', I want to explore this further.

"The bicycle is the perfect transducer to match man's metabolic energy to the impedance of locomotion. Equipped with this tool, man outstrips the efficiency of not only all machines but all other animals as well."Ivan Illich ('Energy and Equity')1974

There was a newspaper columnist in NYC who used to cover "City Hall". He would ride from the newspaper to city hall on his bike. Rival reporters were still looking for cabs when he arrived and began his interviews.

I was born in Montclair, NJ, about five crow flies miles from NYC. New Jersey gets a bad rap from people entering the state via the NJ Turnpike. The turnpike is not representative of NJ, which is quite beautiful in many areas. Have you heard the lyrics to NJ's official state song:

"When I die, bury me low, where I can hear the petroleum flow. The sweetest sound I ever did know! God bless the bums of New Joisey!" ;-)

"I am a true laborer. I earn that I eat, get that I wear, owe no man hate, envy no man's happiness, glad of other men's good, content with my harm." As You Like It, Act 3, Scene 2. Shakespeare.
"Deep down, I'm pretty superficial." Ava Gardner.