If someone only wants the four good ones I'll take the shitty one for a spare.

If anyone is interested in 4, I would entertain this. I will put them on CL if they don't sell here, and it will probably be easier to sell 4 than 5, so I will let you know if I am going to split them up.

Also, it is not that shitty, it is missing some tread, but still perfectly functional. I still kept it on even after the cuts.

Cool, yeah definitely let me know if you split em. At first glance I thought it kinda looked like maybe some of the casing was exposed but upon further review the gouges don't really look too bad. "Extra siping" lol
Also, where are you located?