A Controversial Diagnosis for Herschel Walker

Among the hundreds of disorders defined by the American Psychiatric Association, dissociative identity disorder, formerly called multiple personality disorder, is one of the more contentious.

Herschel Walker's public announcement brings the disorder back into the public eye. ABC News polled mental health experts to get their reaction.

Can One Be a 'We'?

Controversy exists because it calls into question people's understanding of personality, according to mental health experts. How can someone walk around as a "we" instead of an "I"?

Experts still debate whether the disorder should have ever been included in the Diagnostic and Statistical Manual of Mental Disorders, the psychiatric medical bible. To Dr. Richard Loewenstein, medical director of the Trauma Disorders Program at Sheppard Pratt Health Systems in Baltimore, including the disorder inclusion marked "an important watershed in psychiatric history," but to Dr. Mark Levy, a distinguished life fellow at the American Psychiatric Association and assistant clinical professor psychiatry at the University of California at San Francisco, its inclusion "was a mistake."

nullPlay

null

Dr. John H. Casada, assistant professor of psychiatry at the University of Texas Health Science Center at San Antonio, takes a middle ground, saying "the disorder was appropriately included in the DSM but needs refinement to make the diagnosis more specific."

Most experts ABC News contacted agreed that the disorder exists, and that it probably occurs in about 1 percent of the population. Many expressed concern that DID or multiple personality can be misdiagnosed, however, and a few believe it rarely, if ever, occurs. Here are the different schools of thought on the disorder.

The Skeptics

"It probably isn't real," Levy said. "Dissociation is real. It occurs after trauma in some people and in psychosis, like schizophrenia. However, I've never seen a so-called multiple personality in 35 years of practice."

Casada, of the University of Texas Health Science Center, said, "Such extreme claims demand extraordinary proof. The true believers will be more apt to diagnose the illness and will require less clear symptoms. The skeptics, of which I am admittedly one, will require more evidence and clearer evidence before we diagnose what we believe to be a very rare disorder. I believe that most currently diagnosed DID is caused by clinicians."

Dr. Carole Lieberman, a psychiatrist in Beverly Hills, Calif., suggested that patients might use the disorder to excuse their actions. "Psychiatrists must make the diagnosis of dissociative identity disorder very carefully, because oftentimes patients want to find an excuse for their behavior by attributing it to a 'disorder' rather than their own impulsive mistakes."

The Defenders

"The diagnosis of DID is not controversial," said Dr. J. Douglas Bremner, professor of psychiatry and radiology at Emory University School of Medicine in Atlanta. "It is established in the DSM. Prior media coverage may have confused the issue."

Some clinicians say they have treated many people with DID, including Walker's therapist, Jerry Mungadze, and Sheppard Pratt's Loewenstein.

"I have treated individuals with DID who are psychiatrists, lawyers, corporate executives, politicians and TV news reporters, among others," Loewenstein said. "Because the disorder is subtle, hidden and symptoms are covert, unlike the typical media depiction, co-workers, friends, even family, may be unaware of the person's disorder. When the diagnosis is made, family members typically say, 'now everything makes sense' about what has seemed like a confusing, often contradictory person."

"DID is one of the most controversial and difficult psychiatric conditions to treat," Dr. Ira Brenner, clinical professor of psychiatry at Jefferson Medical College in Philadelphia and author of two books on the subject of dissociation. "The issue of 'false memories' and the possible alibi for those accused of crimes who use a DID diagnosis as a defense in court add to the controversy over the condition."

Dr. Bessel van der Kolk, founder and medical director of the Trauma Center at the Justice Resource Institute in Boston and author of "Psychological Trauma," said the "condition has been very well documented since the 1880s, and we now also have very good neuroimaging pictures that demonstrate how different self-states are reflected in activation in different parts of the brain."

Walker's Impact

Mental health experts also had different views about the impact of Walker's revelation.

"Walker's coming forward is a mixed situation," Loewenstein said. "Public and media fascination with high-profile cases tends to turn off clinicians and others who are unfamiliar with the extensive research on diagnosis and treatment of DID."

In addition, he said, it "contributed to the public and professional confusion that surrounds this disorder."

Casada, at the University of Texas Health Science Center, agreed. "I am concerned that with increased exposure more patients will come to believe that they have DID when they do not and that some practitioners will be encouraged to diagnose DID rather than more common and easily treatable illnesses."

Others believe Walker's announcement will have a positive impact. "Mr. Walker's revelation about his diagnosis is courageous. ... It may empower others to come forth with stories," Brenner, at Jefferson Medical College, said.

Rachel Yehuda, a professor of psychiatry at Mount Sinai School of Medicine in New York, said she hopes the announcement about such a successful athlete "can reduce stigma. It also flies in the face of the stereotype that psychiatric illness happens to the physically weak."