Get live updates from RTÉ

Davis says no Brexit impact assessments carried out

Updated / Wednesday, 6 Dec 2017 19:04

David Davis confirmed no impact assessments have been carried out by the government

Britain's Brexit minister has been accused of misleading parliament after admitting the government has made no formal assessment of the likely impact of EU withdrawal on different sectors of the UK economy.

Brexit Secretary David Davis told the House of Commons Exiting the EU Committee that the usefulness of an assessment of this kind would be "near zero" because of the scale of change which Brexit is likely to cause.

Leaving the EU will provoke a "paradigm change" in the UK economy on a similar order of magnitude to the financial crash of 2008, making economic forecast models unlikely to be "informative", he told MPs.

Mr Davis was appearing before the committee to defend his failure to deliver the 58 impact assessments demanded by a parliamentary motion last month, handing over instead 850 pages of heavily-edited "sectoral analyses" setting out detail about the current position of different parts of the economy.

He told MPs as early as last December that his department was "in the midst of carrying out about 57 sets of analyses" on different parts of the economy.

And in October, he told the Brexit committee that British Prime Minister Theresa May had read "summary outcomes" of impact assessments, which he said went into "excruciating detail".

However today he told the committee that "no systematic impact assessments" had in fact been carried out.

Pressed by committee chairman Hilary Benn on whether any impact assessment had been conducted of the implications of Brexit for the automotive, aerospace or financial services sectors, Mr Davis said "No" to each before cutting the Labour MP short, saying: "I think the answer will be 'No' to all of them."

Instead, he said, officials will "at some stage" during the forthcoming second phase of Brexit negotiations, dealing with trade, conduct work to quantify the effects of different possible outcomes, such as a free trade agreement with the EU or moving to World Trade Organisation rules.

And he told Mr Benn there was no "formal quantitative" assessment undertaken of the likely impact of leaving the customs union before the Government committed itself to the step.

"There was a judgement made on qualitative things, not a quantitative one," he said.

Mr Benn described the decision not to conduct impact assessment as "rather strange" when ministers were hoping within weeks to enter into a fundamental renegotiation of Britain's trade relations with the rest of Europe.

And he said it was "quite extraordinary" that no assessment was made of the impact of leaving the customs union "given the momentous nature of that decision".

Mr Davis told the committee: "You don't need to do a formal impact assessment to understand that, if there is a regulatory hurdle between your producers and a market, there will be an impact.

"It will have an effect, the assessment of that effect is not as straightforward as people imagine.

"I'm not a fan of economic models because they have all proven wrong. When you have a paradigm change - as happened in 2008 with the financial crisis - all the models were wrong. The Queen famously asked why did we not know.

"Similarly, what we are dealing with here in every outcome - whether it is a free trade agreement, whether it is a WTO outcome or whether it is something between that on the spectrum - it is a paradigm change. We know not the size, but the order of magnitude of the impact."

Mr Davis was last week accused by some MPs of contempt of parliament, after it emerged that the information handed over to the committee by his Department for Exiting the EU had been edited.

But he told the committee he had tried to provide "the closest we could" to what the House of Commons had demanded, subject to his responsibility not to release information which was commercially sensitive or could undermine the UK's negotiating position.

Mr Davis's admission that no sectoral impact assessments have been made provoked outrage among opposition MPs.

RTÉ.ie is the website of Raidió Teilifís Éireann, Ireland's National Public Service Broadcaster.
RTÉ is not responsible for the content of external internet sites. Images courtesy of Inpho.ie and Getty Images