Reviews

Story VS Performance - The 1993 Director’s Cut of Anthology focused primarily on the Beatles story, using performance footage only to enhance the story. The final version would remove much of the story and details to include as much TV and concert footage as possible. At the time this appeared to be the best approach, but in retrospect opinions may change after hearing the uncut interviews; this was after all their one change to tell their story. Collectors have countless sources for the TV and concert footage, but only one option to hear their story as done for the Anthology series, until now that is!

Uncensored Version- comparisons between the two versions of Anthology clearly show heavy editing. An entire sequence regarding Yoko Ono and her effects on the band has been cut-down to almost nothing; only on the 1993 version will you hear unedited and sometimes unflattering comments. Many interviews did not even make it to the Anthology book. One example is George commenting on the positive experiences he had with drugs, including the famous dentist real name! The 1993 director’s cut also includes the original extended sequence on George’s songwriting later trimmed at George’s request. It becomes obvious by program 1 what you are seeing is what the director and production team assembled and presented to the band before they made numerous change request.

Program Beginnings- Each program begins with an unused animated sequence in place of the Help! Introduction.

In My Life Opening Montage- Programs 1-4 use this song montage with the commercial version using it only to start program 1. The early montage contains different shots from the final version including Allen Klein.

Flashback Montage- An early idea was to begin each program (beginning with program 2) with a flashback montage covering important material seen in the previous program, this worked well for the first few programs, but unfortunately took too much time, Beginning with program 4, the flashbacks only went as far back as the previous program

While My Guitar Gently Weeps Montage- Ideas about the montage were changing by program 5, and no song montage was used for this program. For program 6, a different approach/song was used, and for the first time it was flash forward montage, using much footage not seen elsewhere in the program. Programs 7-8 drop the montage idea entirely

Quality Of Archival Footage- At this early stage, Apple had to use what footage it had available with quality varying from poor to ex. Some of early TV appearances and newsreels are obviously taken from VHS screening tapes, and many include time-code. Some scenes contain the text “Temporary Picture” All of the new interviews and Apple owned material, including footage taken directly from the original cut of “The Long And Winding Road” look great and contains no time code. It is quite interesting to see what Apple’s film archives looked like in 1993. In 1995 Anthology producer Chips Chipperfield hinted at what this early version might look like when asked why they could not just use the original 10-hour version for the home video release “We can but that’s off-line. Off-line is a rough cut. It’s cut from whatever archive sources we have so a lot of it is VHS

Unused McCartney Interview- Programs 1&2 include an unused interview with Paul. This was the first interview shot and used before finally being replaced with a re-recorded Paul in black turtleneck With this first interview being re-shot, the stories vary from the final release

Partially Unused Harrison Interview- For most of Programs 1&2, the only Harrison interview used is the control room interview with George sporting a moustache. More than ½ of this interview was later removed and replaced with a re-recorded clean-shaven George. With much of this first interview going unused, the stories vary from the final version

Unused Neil Aspinall Interviews- For most of the first two programs, we see Neil’s first interview sessions wearing no hat, the stories heard vary from the commercial version.

Derek Taylor- Derek has a larger role in the early version of Anthology, and is featured in numerous unseen interviews

Program Endings- An early idea was to end each program with a sequence showing the progression the band was making. Examples would be an overhead view showing the move from Liverpool to London, or the move from London to the US.

Audio Outtakes- It is important to note that the 1993 Anthology uses very little studio outtake recordings. There are no created studio sequences of audio outtakes. We don’t hear any real audio outtakes until the 68 studio sessions, as the audio outtakes were still being examined at this early stage of production and were not made available to the production team just yet. But… we do get to hear the unused “Hums” ending for “A Day In The Life” along with part of take 4!

Early/Abandoned Ideas- The 1993 Anthology uses many ideas later modified or dropped entirely. The recreations of fans rooms differ greatly; TV and tour montages were created then later dropped. An early idea was to show the move from Liverpool to Abbey Road studios, done by filming an entire trip-sequence taking you from Liverpool and ending at George Martin’s door in Abbey Road Studios. Other early ideas put Paul in the film “The Girl Can’t Help It” Various other unused segments appear throughout the entire eight programs

No Closing Credits- At this early stage, none of the eight programs contain closing credits

1993 Ending- At this early stage, the documentary ends with the “Let It Be” sessions and rooftop concert. Program 8 part 1 dates from December 1993. 1994 would alter the Documentary considerably, with the three remaining Beatles reforming to record new music and joint interviews. It was at this point; the 1993 version was heavily re-edited leaving only a hint of what it had originally looked like.

Detailed differences found on Anthology Director’s Cut 1993

1940-1963

George’s take on naming the group ‘I give it 50% Lennon 50% Sutcliffe’

Tribute to Mal Evans includes short “Maxwell’s Silver Hammer”

Different edit of 1960 home recordings, does not have tape spool run out

Greater details on Pete Best and his staying out all night with strippers

Different German tour montage, uses alternate footage and includes “Sheila” in the medley

More details on changing over to suits

No school photo with Paul, George and Neil. A Neil photo is used in place of

Different segment with “Twenty Flight Rock”, Song is longer and Paul is made to look part of the movie

Greater details on George’s black eye

Greater details on “Love Me Do” single

Details on the Harrison/Martin Don’t like your tie story

Different edit of the 8mm van footage

Unused sequence creating the move from Liverpool to the recording studios at Abbey Road

If you do see it.. get it! Its very very good. Amazing.. yes it does has bits from the official release (It is the directors cut... ) but you have to see it.. you will notice the difference (more "honest" interviews, different footage) Plus for that extra 2 dvds (Discs 9 & 10) you get every promo of the Anthology series. Picture Perfect has really done an amazing job!

A jewel in my Beatles' collection. I paid a hefty sum for this (Should I even say?), and it was worth every penny. The listing in the top review is very comprehensive and very helpful. In fact, it led me to buying it, and I thank you for that.

For me, the huge amount of additional interview footage is what makes this so wonderful. It was the aspect that I enjoyed the most from the official DVD release, and there is much more of it here on the Director's Cut. Keep in mind, too, that this set contains SIXTEEN DVD's...not eight.

I just love it. Watching it was druglike. I just couldn't stop and this resulted in some late nights, and days of heavy eyelids afterwards. WELL WORTH IT!

Although it lacks the interviews with the 3 together, most of the single interviews(especially the ones on the later years) have more of a bite than the released version. Thanks to Beatlejuice72 for posting this on You Tube.