"IT'S A GIRL!" Nev captioned the Instagram photo above of the couple at a doctor's visit. "No words can capture the excitement and joy I feel about becoming a father. I am so in love with you @el_peego and thank you for giving me this incredible gift. You inspire and excite me every day."

Fittingly, Max Joseph was quick to offer a sweet message to his brother from another mother:

Congrats, Nev! Better teach your little lady all about Google image search before she starts dating. Be sure to offer your well wishes to Nev and Laura in the comments -- and catch the mid-season finale of Catfish tonight at 9/8c!