1. Angelus
2. Spike
3. Darla
4. Lilah
5. Angel
6. Illyria
7. Cordy
8. Fred
9. Gunn
9,5. Lorne (I'm not cheating! Okay, I am, but I love Lorne so much! I just had to include him!)
10. Doyle (I love Doyle and I know he should be higher, but it's hard to judge a character after just 9 episodes!)