Comment by Boblet

Comment by Tinhay

Currently uncompletable for some people.I am still unable to see a Heart of Magic in the Gift after two kills and so I petitioned a GM who confirmed that this is a known bug. No idea what exactly causes it.

Update: After four Malygos kills without the Heart of Magic dropping I submitted another petition. The GM then asked me for the Raid ID of the kill and I received my Questitem via ingame mail a few minutes later.

Comment by vexis58

Blizzard needs to make up their minds about how they want to spell Judgement/Judgment.

Comment by Fillivan

Now imagine in the next patches they add raids with the other dragon aspects and there are quests added which require everyone's hearts to be brought to Krasus. Then step 2, after turning in all of the hearts, Krasus transforms in to a Demon and says: "Surprise! You are the lamest of your world, not only you killed all of the dragons which were actually protecting you, but you also gave their hearts to the burning legion! is there a limit to how stupid you might become?".

or maybe:

"You just got tricked by the burning legion ^^"

Comment by tethas

in fact Malygos is the Aspect of Magic and Master of the blue Dragonflight

so fighting the Aspects has already begun ... and at some point I would expect us to confront the Black Flight and Neltharion as well ...

Comment by MartinDahl

Is there any prequests for this or how is it working anyway?

Comment by carldudut

atm this quest only allow 1 player to loot it, so if you got like 5 people in quest only 1 people got the quest item =), a lot of people think is bug but is not.

Comment by minttunator

So let me get this straight - if every person in the 10-man group wants to do this quest, the group needs to do 10 runs of Nax and then do 10 runs of Malygos? And 25 times (gonna take about 6 months) for the Heroic version? Am I the only one who thinks this is kinda ridiculous? =/

Comment by Fillivan

You don't expect it? Comment those statements from wowwiki:

"Malygos does not seek out combat; and although he and his dragonflight are still routinely hunted by black dragons, he avoids their kind if at all possible. He protects his lair and himself with illusions and misdirection. Those who discover his home are encouraged to depart through a variety of means; Malygos takes direct action only as a last resort."

"Malygos the Spellweaver is the blue Dragon Aspect, and the master of the blue dragonflight. He is one of the most ancient creatures living on Azeroth, and one of only a handful who were alive at the time the Titans departed. Now that he has regained his sanity, he is once again taking an active role in the protection of the world"

"Malygos lives in a cave within Northrend, and his lair contains many arcane magical artefacts. Malygos and his flight search for any magical source and artifacts and protect them so that mortal races may not endanger the world with their reckless use."

"Malygos is the oldest of the five Aspects, possibly the oldest dragon still living."

"Krasus finally said that Alexstrasza could use her powers over life to grant Malygos a new dragonflight. Seeing an opportunity to avenge the death of his flight, see their resurrection, and redeem himself, Malygos agreed to rejoin the world and confront Deathwing"

Judging by those he is supposed to be a wise creature which tries to protect the mortal races from the burning legion. His only weakness seems to be his brood which he desperately tries to recover.

But suddenly after the WotLK goes out he turn out to be unwise,thick headed, short tempered, stupid and goes totally opposite to his character, and instead of persuading the other dragons to help him limit a little bit the usage of arcane magic in order to protect the world(if you read carefully you will notice that he actually did this by gathering the dangerous artefacts instead of destroying the entire race because of the possibility that they can build more dangerous things.), he decides to throw away the life of his brood, which he loves so much, in a stupid battle with all the other aspects and all the mortal races, he tried to protect so desperately until this very moment...

After reading this are you sure that suddenly the guys from blizz wont decide to sacriface the other dragons in order to make the PvE more attractive? I think that at the moment they added Malygos as a boss they kind of shattered his image >.>. That's why i said that they might decide to do something like this, and ofc they can create another lame excuse, like hmm "Ysera now grows insane because she is affected by the nightmare and starts a war against all that is not green enough to be a part of the green dragonflight" or "Deathwing suddenly appears and reveals that he managed to create an artefact which can control the other dragon aspects and now he resides in <silly raid name> and prepares to destroy all mortal races, by using the power of the enslaved dragon aspects"

Besides... isn't it a little bit strange that someone of the dragon aspects is trying to recover an item that is said to have such incredible power? It seems to me like the Red Dragonflight is up to something...

Comment by ranu

Is the 10 man version of this quest possible to complete in the 25 man instance?

EDIT: Just read the quest text.. "This quest is for the Normal mode, 10-person version of The Eye of Eternity. "

Seems like it's only for 10 man.

Comment by Rougierogue

In regards to the item being unlootable by all players on the quest, here's what a GM told me, and I have verified for real and for certain that it works, 100%:

Normally when a player dies during a boss fight, they need to wait until the boss is dead before releasing their spirit, or else they will not get the quest item, assuming their group downs the boss while spirit is still outside the instance.

The mechanics of this fight, however, don't register Malygos' death until AFTER Alexstrasza does her thing. If you have died during the fight and release immediately after Malygos is dead, you will notget the quest item. Instead, do not release until Alexstrasza has finished her spiel.

The GM handled my issue and got me my quest item since they verified I was there and had the quest yadda, yadda, but I passed the info on to my friends. We had two people purposely die and release at different times. The one who released before Alex came didn't get the item, the one who stayed through Alex before releasing did. This works for both normal and heroic versions.

Comment by BenMS

Nope, they don't need to make up their minds. They just need to spell it right - Judgement. Dropping the E is an Americanisation, just like Honor or Armory dropped the U. It's called English for a reason!

Comment by Rougierogue

Actually, you know what? I've just deleted this reply because I don't care what you basement-dwelling neckbeards think. Try to help - with detailed, verifiable information, even - and I get some %^&* waving response that honestly makes no sense in context of what I said initially, as well as being voted down, to boot.

So do you what you want.

Comment by Ruscher

Is it possible to recive the questitem in heroic? Or is the normal quest only completeble in normal instance?

Comment by Jingoistic

Comment by Zenithan

Comment by hyperbole

Anyone know if the quest is repeatable, meaning can I get another copy of the key and a second necklace?

Comment by MrMagik

I cant seem to accept the quest? its not there anymore, is there a pre-quest or something?

Comment by Deivijs

I'm quite disappointed with the necks. Nothing for spirit-based healers...

Comment by clonjohn55

Is there a quest before this that unlocks this one?

Comment by Ochwat

Did anyone try to get one of the other necks e.g. if you change your spec?

Comment by theboss9990

If you change specs after getting once the necklaces always ask a gm THEY NEVER SAY NO I SWEAR. might take a few hours but you'll get ur neck you just have to be conveincing.

Comment by theboss9990

Once yo get the key for one difficulty of malygos it works on both difficulties.

Comment by Pelmite

For anyone looking for the entrance to the dungeon for this quest, go to 27.95, 28.76 Borean Tundra. You'll find an entrance into the needle looking thing (The Nexus) and you will find three entrances there. The Eye of Eternity Entrance is at the top of the ramps.

Judgment at the Eye of Eternity

Description

Now that you have access to the focusing iris it's time to put that key to use.

As much as I would like to see Malygos brought back into the fold, that's just not going to happen at this point. With everything that's at stake, it is the judgment of the other Dragon Aspects that the Spell-Weaver needs to be put down.

<Krasus says this last with a great deal of trepidation.>

<name>, travel to the Eye of Eternity, confront Malygos and return with the Heart of Magic.

This is a very sad day, not only for dragonkind, but for all of the living creatures of Azeroth. We have lost one of our most thoughtful, intelligent and ancient friends. Magic is now without its guardian.

Let us hope that this was a wise decision in the coming years, <name>. A storm is still brewing on the horizon and now we are without one of our most powerful defenders.