TuleRune's Tiering Thread II Turbo

Comments

It's totally up to you, though I think you should get to everything in the pipeline, personally. That said, whenever you're ready, I'd like to change my requests since I had @Radiohead97 tier the three I requested last June.

I also need to catch up on tier comparisons now that you're alive. Not counting "Slow Ride" due to the different versions, I'm due to make ones for "Super Freak", "Enjoy the Silence" and "That Don't Impress Me Much" between your two threads.

Cool, I'll get too it now that I have an easy work week. In the interim, just gonna bang out the backlog as quickly as I can have the time to put them up. As a reminder, these sets are for what is gonna be "Rock Band 2018". I haven't yet run through my backlog to see what might've been realised, but considering these are all old until further notice, just consider them alternative tiers.

Awesome! I'll go update my Official List of Tier Threads and put you in the active section, then. Guess it'll be left a great mystery where you were the past half-year

Tier comparisons are in the spoiler below for those who care. Spoiler alert - one of them was near-perfect. Feel free to put these (and the ones on the previous page) in the OP if there's room, but no worries if there isn't. If you do end up posting DLC batches with already-released songs, I can make tier comparisons for those too if you'd like!

Even though I bought two of these, I'm going to keep these relatively brief for the sake of catching up:

Guitar is spot-on, bass is one dot off, vocals are two dots off, drums are three dots off.

And my new requests will just be carryover from @Radiohead97's thread since he closed off requests indefinitely. I was in the process of requesting the entirety of Foster the People's Supermodel album, and was getting my 3 least favorites from it out of the way.

Foster the People's Supermodel 03

"The Angelic Welcome of Mr. Jones" (A year after this album, FtP released a "sequel" to this song, "The Unforeseeable Fate of Mr. Jones", that used this interlude in it)"Fire Escape" (This was the first encore when I saw them live, which...didn't really work well, honestly. A lot of people were talking over it.)"Goats in Trees"

Just as a note, there's some faint snare drums throughout "Goats in Trees", and I hear some bass sustains that blend in with the guitar. I don't expect any of these to be particularly fun in a RB context, but y'know, they're part of the album.

Well, you can basically read my post on @FritzyKatz's thread as you guys tiered this nearly exact, with only a one-dot vocal difference, so I'd be repeating myself here for the most part. You got vocals and drums spot-on, and guitar and bass a dot off. Here's the three-way comparison, as well.

Well, I have no idea what that "wtf" was directed at, nor where @TuleRune scurried off to this time, but I'm going to awkwardly shuffle in here to catch up on some tier comparisons one last time until he returns. "Believer" and "Is She Really Going Out with Him?" got released after his return, and I also forgot to compare "Stranglehold" before, so I'm just going to dump those here quickly.

Pretty close to perfect on this one! Vocals and bass are spot-on, while guitar and drums are only a dot off. Having bought this one, I can say I think it probably warrants those 3 dots as drums are the most active instrument in the song.

Okay, so...I know I said that was going to be my last post, but I need to congratulate @TuleRune, because for the first time, he got a tier completely spot-on with Blues Traveler's "Run-Around"! Here's the comparison for reference. I'm honestly amazed - I've only seen this happen maybe once or twice and it's such a rare occurrence. Great job!