Voting out strong players because they might be mafia is pretty shittie logic.

Unvote Vote Lostfap

Nevermind the fact that when he's town he's capable of single handedly winning the game, I can't take the chance that he could be scum. Does that sound like a valid argument?

Unvote Vote Leeroy

Does it sound like a scum argument though, I'm not overly interested in finding out who's smarter than whom, it's not that hard anyway, it just really is bad regardless of alignment, it's not much different than rush's vote anyway, so w/e.