If they added another, I hope there would be an alternate zone as well (such as Hyjal was). It would still be a win-win. Those who enjoyed it would have it and those who didn't would have another option.

If only a minor group liked Vashj'ir, it would be a waste of time and resources to create another underwater zone.

Keyboard turners hates it, and it's possible that they take up 70% of wow's population

So you're implying here that the majority of people who hate underwater zones (Disagree with you) are keyboard turners, which is generally a bad thing. So you're effectively framing it in a way where anyone with an opposing opinion is bad at this game. Nice try, but no, Vashj'ir is horrible zone, it doesn't look bad, but it doesn't feel good. I'm pretty sure an underwater expansion would end in me unsubbing, they're not fun, and an Azshara expansion doesn't sound thematically gripping anyhow.

-Sincerely,
Someone who doesn't Keyboard turn.

- - - Updated - - -

Originally Posted by Hitei

According to current poll standings, it's pretty much even.

if it's something that splits people in half, people that pay for this game by the way, with such strong opinions (people either love it or hate it) for either side, then it's probably not the best business decision to add it.

if it's something that splits people in half, people that pay for this game by the way, with such strong opinions (people either love it or hate it) for either side, then it's probably not the best business decision to add it.

You are not going to find an expansion idea that everyone, or even the vast majority, love.

You tried too hard and now your post is shit. Never try too hard, the gamble isn't worth it. -Boubouille

if it's something that splits people in half, people that pay for this game by the way, with such strong opinions (people either love it or hate it) for either side, then it's probably not the best business decision to add it.

To be fair, we could probably do a poll for every zone in the game and come up with 50/50 love hate.

if it's something that splits people in half, people that pay for this game by the way, with such strong opinions (people either love it or hate it) for either side, then it's probably not the best business decision to add it.

Not that MMOC is statistically-reliable in any sense whatsoever, but I'd say that having 50% of your playerbase excited for a feature is doing extremely well in an MMO.

So you're implying here that the majority of people who hate underwater zones (Disagree with you) are keyboard turners, which is generally a bad thing. So you're effectively framing it in a way where anyone with an opposing opinion is bad at this game. Nice try, but no, Vashj'ir is horrible zone, it doesn't look bad, but it doesn't feel good. I'm pretty sure an underwater expansion would end in me unsubbing, they're not fun, and an Azshara expansion doesn't sound thematically gripping anyhow.

-Sincerely,
Someone who doesn't Keyboard turn.

- - - Updated - - -

if it's something that splits people in half, people that pay for this game by the way, with such strong opinions (people either love it or hate it) for either side, then it's probably not the best business decision to add it.

what load of bs to be honest. no one cares if you are unsubbing.

And ozumat alone makes an underwater expansion super gripping more than anything happened here before. If something wasn't gripping it was pandaland.

To be fair, we could probably do a poll for every zone in the game and come up with 50/50 love hate.

Probably closer to 20% of the zones would be 50/50 love hate. The rest would be, meh, ok, or good. For example, Ashenvale, I don't love it or hate it. It looks nice and is laid out well so, I'll say it's good.

Originally Posted by Lovestar

Not that MMOC is statistically-reliable in any sense whatsoever, but I'd say that having 50% of your playerbase excited for a feature is doing extremely well in an MMO.

It was unique and interesting the first time it was done. But I never really enjoy going back to it and didn't spend any more time there than necessary. I wasn't a big fan of it, but maybe someone else was.

Underwater combat as melee is a horrible experience. No rational person could enjoy playing melee in a zone like Vash'jr.

I enjoyed it, I must be a non-rational person! But seriously, the majority of that zone wasn't hard -- and it was quite easy to understand where you were being hit from. A lot of the NPC's were also conveniently located near the sea floor.

Hearts are man kinds lock. If only everyone's emotions were a skeleton key, this world would be a happier place.

I'd be excited about an Old God-centric underwater zone. I'm indifferent about Naga.

I don't understand what all the hate for underwater zones is coming from. With the buffs you get in Vashj'ir, it's almost exactly like a regular zone that requires lots of flying, like Storm Peaks or something. You just think of it differently.

That being said, maybe, if they do make a new zone like that, they could give you a buff like "metal shoes" that keeps you grounded to the floor and requires you to mount to swim, giving it the cool aesthetic without the annoyance of feeling slowed by the water. Idk.. :x