Main menu

Tag Archives: devolution

Post navigation

Last month saw the Home Office release the latest batch of Crime Statistics for England and Wales.

There were few notable things about the blanket of numbers produced, but something did catch the eye. Burglaries have gone up by 14% since the Conservatives gained power, and violent crime 6%.

There are two respected measurements of crime in the UK. One is by the police, and the other is the British Crime Survey. As the BCS measures unreported crime, it is the more respected of the two, with the police having a reputation for under-recording crime. The police, with their under-representation of crime, recorded a 4% drop in crime levels. The British Crime Survey recorded a 1% rise.

This compares to Labours record in government, which saw a massive 49% drop in violent crime. There are many arguments that Conservatives may give for this. There was a global downward trend in crime, for example. There was also a recession, causing a lot of hardship and poverty. These are both seemingly good points, but can both be thrown into doubt by one simple comparison, and one that David Cameron has used a lot in recent Prime Ministers Questions – that of the comparison between Labour-run Wales and Conservative-run England.

You may have heard Cameron berating Labours record in Wales, claiming that whilst they are cutting the NHS, England’s Conservatives are actually increasing the budget (whilst carefully skating over the fact that the majority of this increase is going to the ‘reorganisation’ to privatise large parts of the NHS, not to patient care. He also ignores the fact a recent poll showed that 86% of Doctors in Wales are glad they aren’t in England). In crime statistics, however, this works against him. You see, in Wales, crime is reported to have dropped by 8%, compared to England’s 4%. Crime is dropping twice as fast in Labour-run Wales than it is in Conservative-run England.

This swiftly disposes of the argument that crime follows a worldwide trend – it’s hard to think of two countries more similar and intertwined than England and Wales.

The argument that the increases in crime are due to the recession, poverty and hardship also fall in the light of this evidence. Wales has a much higher rate of poverty than England. In fact, it was reported by the BBC last year that one in three children in Wales live below the poverty line (although it’s not all bad for Welsh youngsters – they were the most likely to respond that they had ‘lots’ of friends out of the four constituent countries, and of course they’ve got subsidised tuition fees to look forward to, again as a result of their Labour government).

One last alternate argument could be that crime and punishment is not actually a devolved issue. The phrase ‘clutching at straws’ would come to mind, but this claim can be disproved regardless. Numerous studies have shown that it’s not policies on crime and punishment that affect crime the most; it’s the social situation they find themselves in. For example, places in the Middle-East have highly authoritarian and strict laws and punishments, whereas places in Africa experience near lawlessness (the horrific statistic that a girl in South Africa is more likely to be raped than she is to learn to read comes to mind), yet both experience higher crime levels than countries like the UK. These social situations, that affect crime so highly, are devolved to Wales. Things like education and training, economic development and social welfare have been devolved, and they do affect crime statistics.

It therefore stands to reason that Labour policy has been twice as effective as Conservative policy in the reduction of crime – David Cameron can criticise Labours record in Wales all he wants, but he’d do well to take notice. They’re doing something right that he’s getting wrong.

Harry Thompson is a 17 year old Labour party member from Wiltshire, but originally from Wales.

The Labour Assembly Against Austerity saw over 200 party activists come together to discuss the cost of living crisis being caused by coalition austerity and the need for Labour to present an inspiring alternative vision that will win the 2015 election and then go on to change people’s lives for the better. With activists attending […]

This Saturday Labour members will come together at Birkbeck College to discuss how Labour can offer an investment based alternative to the Government’s failed austerity agenda. One of the key debates will be over how to embolden the front-bench to stand up to the coalition’s smears and ensure that future Labour Government invests in a […]

‘No Irish, No Dogs, No Blacks’ read the signs about 40 years ago, unfortunately the recent BBC Inside Out investigation seems to have taken us back in time revealing that such shocking levels of discrimination still exists. The BBC undercover investigation found that estate agents in west London were prepared to discriminate against African Caribbean communities. This should, […]

“When are you bringing back socialism?” “That’s what we are doing, Sir.” It was a throwaway comment in a question and answer session on a Brighton street that has come to dominate the press narrative about Labour’s leader since last week’s conference that has grown increasingly hysterical as the days have gone on. Of course, Ed […]

It was all quite a shock. On Friday, as the government announced that potential shareholders in the privatised Royal Mail were already lined up, campaigners were pre-occupied with the ballot for an anti-sell off postal workers strike. A strike that will now come after the post has been privatised, if the government has its way. […]

‘Recessions hurt, but austerity kills’. This was a title from the Guardian newspaper a few months ago that really carved into my mind. Austerity has equated in a two tier society and class divide has truly impersonated Lazarus and come back from the dead. It is without doubt that austerity is hurting many and even […]

The announcement that Lloyds TSB are back in profit has automatically triggered discussion of the government selling off its 39% share in the bank, back to the private sector. For Labour, it should trigger a discussion on an increasingly interventionist approach to the economy. Britain’s privately-owned banks were bailed out with billions from the taxpayer […]