7 comments:

Good cover! A predictable story, but good, solid illustration. This Mister Mystery character -- he's just like the lamest horror comic host going. Is there any horror comic host sillier? I mean, he's supposed to be some top hat magician with a Lone Ranger mask? What is that? How am I supposed to get the chills seeing him show up hosting the story? He's no Mr. K!

This one has got some weird art -- page 3 has confusing paneling and page 5 is only saved by the arrow. This is no crappy artist, it's early Ross Andru, which makes the panel layout a bit more mysterious, but, again, it's early.

GCD says Andru drew most of this comic.

Mister Mystery comics pretty much reads like one of the earlier jump on the bandwagon horror comics that employed writers who weren't yet sure about the genre conventions.

So now we know the truth, Charlton wasn't the first publisher to crank out not so scary grade B horror, they learned from the best (or worst if you prefer.) This was still a decent enough tale, though with a different writer (say, one who worked for Eerie or Creepy) this story could have been memorable nightmare fuel, with the mandatory gore and detached eyeball flying through the air.

Speaking of Charlton, Mister Mystery's habit of actually addressing the villain at least once reminds me of "Winnie the Witch" the hostess GHOST MANOR, and how she was always being insinuated into the story itself, at least visually and sometimes in other ways. (I don't know if Trevor Markwart would find her any scarier than Mister Mystery, but she definitely has other attractions.)

I hate it when revenge stories have the character who's getting the revenge dragging someone else into it - I mean that poor horse! (I don't hate it when the story holds that kind of thing AGAINST the character, but this one doesn't seem to be doing that.)

"...the capital of online comic book horrors... saying "Not the best story THOIA has run" is a bit like saying "one of Beethoven's lesser symphonies!"---Quasar Dragon

"...the object of all horror chicks' wet dreams... a comixkaze of awesome!"---Killer Kittens

"...an online repository of vintage comic fear fare where individual stories from long out-of-print issues are posted in high resolution, page by page. For a fan of EC, Atlas and other Silver Age-era comic companies, it is pure heaven (and hell)..."---Bryan Reesman (Attention Deficit Delirium)