How popular is Baylie?

Baylie is an uncommon first name for women but a somewhat popular surname for all people (#134037 out of 150436, Top 89%). (2000 U.S. Demographics)

Baylie was first listed in 1995 and reached its top rank of #989 in the U.S. in the year 1997, but is not listed at the moment. (2015 U.S. SSA Records)

Which version is better?

with its source form and related girl names. Bailey(#108 the previous year), Baylee(#406), Bailee(#552), Bayleigh(#1066), Bayley, Baily, Baileigh, Bailie and Baleigh are the prominent variation forms of Baylie listed in the Top 2000. Other forms, like Bayly, are uncommon. Adoption of these forms of Baylie was at its highest in 1998 (average #1168) and is somewhat less today (#1413, 38% less usage). Baylee and Bailee are two of the more contemporarily stylish baby names in this compilation.