Selena Gomez had to drink, swear, and wear skimpy swimsuits for her new movie Spring Breakers, but everyone was shocked when a photo surfaced that appears to show Selena kissing another girl. So was it a photo taken from the set of the movie?

According to GossipCop, the photo has been confirmed as a fake by Selena’s rep, but some might have a hard time believing that it’s not the real deal – the brunette girl in the photo bears a striking resemblance to Selena, and the blonde could pass for Vanessa Hudgens, who sported lighter locks while shooting Spring Breakers.

And of course there are probably plenty of fans who think that the photo proves that Selena Gomez is bisexual or something. She already went through a similar “scandal” when photoshopped pictures of her kissing Demi Lovato circulated on the web – a lot fans believed that they were lesbians. Of course, any allegations that she’s a lesbian this time around would be extremely ridiculous since she’s dating Justin Bieber.

So was this latest Selena photo also digitally altered, or is something else going on here? A few sharp commenters on oceanUP.com pointed at that the girls in the photo are actually popular Tumblr users chloerayneee and jaydeygaga. So someone must have seen the photo of them kissing; noticed that one of the girls looks like Selena; and tried to pass it off as her – it was first posted as a reader find on the website Egotastic!. It also certainly helped that the other girl in the photo looks like Vanessa Hudgens.

But if Selena ever wants to try kissing a girl for real, Madonna might take her up on that offer (ew!). Or perhaps she and “I Kissed a Girl” singer Katy Perry would be a better match – they could reenact the smooch between Britney Spears and Madonna at the 2003 MTV VMAs.