There’s Something Different About Colton Haynes’ Nipple

Colton Haynes has never been shy about showing off his body: His time on Teen Wolf seemed to be one long excuse to get him topless in the Beacon Hills’ locker room, and his Instagram is like a visual ode to his pecs.

His nipple is pierced! When did this happen? Why did it happen? What possessed him to mar his flawless twunk body, much less his perfect nipples, with a piece of metal? Did he get anything else pierced—perhaps something we can’t see?

Most importantly, do you think he’s hotter with or without the barbell?