Does Niko have the Vercetti Gang with him? Does he have the Cuban gang with him? Does he have the Biker gang with him? Does he have Ken Rosen...ok so Niko wins on that one.

But Niko's outgunned...!

your point being?

i am sorry nicko was in the serbian ARMY he fought in a WAR with REAL guns not a fucking 9mm or a fucking machine pistol, he knows how to handle himself under these situations, plus he can take cover, no one else can a massive advantage when par-taking in a gun fight no?

Tommy can take cover (by cover I mean his crappy crouch).....just really badly and it totally renders him useless when he does. And for the Vercetti gang and all that, think how easy they were to kill.....Niko still has this hands down.

CJ would kick their asses anyways - he has good muscles, can swim (in case thrown at water), he knows some special moves and he can cut others throat with a knife someone from the back, Vic is my second favorite - he was in the army and surely knows a lot of stuff like moves and shooting skills. Niko is third because he is awesome and fought in a war, Tommy is one of the last because he hardly knows any 'special' skills aside from holding a gun and shooting as well as playing 'tough guy'. Claude comes next since he is a mute and wouldn't say a single shit if someone would hold him in the throat. Toni Cipriani lasts least of them since he is just a fatass after LCS and even before he hardly had any skills.

And lmao @ the comments about Tommy having Cubans, Bikers and Vercetti gang behind him - all of them are a group of wimps who couldn't survive a second without the help of Tommy. Ken Rosenberg? You better be kidding me because afterward he had CJ's back, let's just say that.

If the Vercetti Gang actually used those Uzi's and if the Cubans got some Krugers and Uzi's, Tommy's army could kick ass.

Tommy could kick ass.... but only if he had an army behind him. Tommy sucks. Why can't CJ bring in grove street? Why can't Niko bring the Serbian army? Because then Tommy would lose. If it was a straight out bar fight, no armies or crap like that, Tommy would lose.... Horribly.

If the Vercetti Gang actually used those Uzi's and if the Cubans got some Krugers and Uzi's, Tommy's army could kick ass.

Tommy could kick ass.... but only if he had an army behind him. Tommy sucks. Why can't CJ bring in grove street? Why can't Niko bring the Serbian army? Because then Tommy would lose. If it was a straight out bar fight, no armies or crap like that, Tommy would lose.... Horribly.

If that is the case CJ can bring in the Triads (AK's), The Varrios Los Aztecas and Grove Street Families (Desert eagles and MP5). Since when did the Cubans carry Krugers? Only a couple of them in one or two missions. Vic also has the Cubans with him, see?

in which niko wins hands down, he has the countering capabilities that he used on brucie so there!

If the Vercetti Gang actually used those Uzi's and if the Cubans got some Krugers and Uzi's, Tommy's army could kick ass.

Tommy could kick ass.... but only if he had an army behind him. Tommy sucks. Why can't CJ bring in grove street? Why can't Niko bring the Serbian army? Because then Tommy would lose. If it was a straight out bar fight, no armies or crap like that, Tommy would lose.... Horribly.

If that is the case CJ can bring in the Triads (AK's), The Varrios Los Aztecas and Grove Street Families (Desert eagles and MP5). Since when did the Cubans carry Krugers? Only a couple of them in one or two missions. Vic also has the Cubans with him, see?

in which niko wins hands down, he has the countering capabilities that he used on brucie so there!

That cutscene made me laugh, lol.

Do you not read? It's about a fist fight, no armies and shit. And I loled at whoever said that Niko could bring the Serbian army.

in my opinion, even though i love tommy's character i'd have to say Niko would win, tommy doesn't specialize in melee attacks, Carl uses too many guns and even though his kung-fu would beat Claude and Tommy, he would have no chance against Niko, why? Niko specializes in army attacks, stealths, advanced combat, takedowns, and other so called "red-army shit" brucie was talking about.

why are you guys arguing about this? i'd tell you who really knows: it's the God himself, or in this case R*

Niko: okay Brucie, the only way to get your balls back to normal is you stop juicing, or you get implantsBrucie: how many times i have to tell you homie? my balls are golden, okay!

Claude - Doesn't have much of a background with fighting and doesn't seem to be that much of a hard ass, but people do say the quiet ones could fight.

Tommy - He's a hard ass and killed eleven people with his barehands, which leads me to believe that he would be able to take on Claude, CJ and Niko all at once.

CJ - Seems like a pussy when a gun is pulled on him, but since this is a fist fight I think he'd have a pretty good chance, depending on whether or not the player had him train the various fighting styles.

Niko - Yes, he was in a war, but that deals with weapons, not always fist fights. Although, he must have gone through some training, so he could very well be an excellent fighter.

Tommy is the only one out of the bunch that we know could kill a number of people at once in a fight. We have no idea if Claude could fight and CJ and Niko probably just went through training and didn't deal with the real thing like Tommy.

I would assume from just that, that Tommy would win, but if they gang up on Tommy first, then I'd probably say Niko would win, if not him, then CJ and if by some chance Niko and CJ beat the shit out of each other enough, then Claude might be able to step in and finish them off.

Dude. Tommy would use his 80's big ass phone to call in some cuban gangsters, but the cubans were doing coke so they died in a car accident on the way to the fight.
SOOOO, since Claude doesn't talk, he's sneaky and hits Tommy in the face with a baseball bat.

Then, while CJ is busy taking a bite out of his fried chicken Claude takes that moment to bash CJ's face in too, but! Niko takes out his bazooka that he aqquired from war and blows up Claude, to save CJ.
The explosion ends up killing both of then.