Well I recently played another game with him, this time in a Sci-fi/horror homebrew and this is what happens.

The players and 96 other survivors are kidnapped and put into a social expire ment funded by an evil government. The Expirametal works like this: every day the survivors vote for one person to be sacrificed to the computer that runs the facility we are held at.

Time passes, and one of our players is sacrificed to the computer for committing blasphemy against the followers of the computer (some people by this time have been driven insain and worship the computer as of it were a god.) Eventually all that is left is the three surviving players and two NPCs. Seeing the continual sacrifices as pointless one of the players contacts the computer saying.

"Yeah, I know your listening, and we have made our choice. We are not killing anymore people, turn off our air, shut off our water suply, but whatever, we are done with your game."

Almost instantly the computer responds with "congradulations! The Axis Corporation congratulates all of you on your willpower, and selflessness and you may now leave the vault if you wish."

This entire time we could have saved everyone by simply not wanting to kill anyone. The two NPCs ended up committing suicide, and the three surviving players continue on with their life of adventure.

"The minds of gods are not for ponies to know or to judge. Accept that Sheila has a place for all of us in her grand plan, and be happy in the part you have to play."