These gloves are comfortable and warm; they have made it possible for my 10-year-old daughter to walk to school on all but he coldest days in Chicago. I bought two pairs (my daughter is a champion Glove Misplacer), so I think we will be in good shape for the next couple of years.

My daughter likes these gloves for playing in the snow during recess at school and they keep her plenty warm. But when biking to school she complained of her fingers being too cold, which makes me question the wind proof claim. So now she has to bike to school in her mittens then switch to the gloves for recess.