Mmf Experts - What Brand Mm Do You Use?

I've used several different brands and find the resulting MMF is different depending on the MM used.

For example, when I use Wal-Mart's store brand I end up with very small clear jelly-like globs that cannot be kneaded away (not the same as the powdered sugar lumps that if left to rest, end up dissolving). When I've used Fireside marshmallows, I end up with more of a paste like consistency regardless of how much PS is used, and it tends to tear. With Kraft, it's more "elasticy" and not so pliable so it seems to want to go back to the shape it was rolled out to instead of conforming to the shape of the cake.

I'm just wondering for those that use MMF primarily or even exclusively, which brand of marshmallows have you found works best for you? Which brand do you have the most luck with?

I don't know if you have the same brands we have here, but I've tried Little Becky's marshmallow, and I didn't like it, it didn't easily absorb the powdered sugar. Then I used Beacon marshmallows, and they worked perfectly. They're fluffy after i microwave them, mix easiyl, and quickly absorb the powdered sugar. What I like the most, is that after I roll it, I can lift it to the cake without distorting. I don't always find it here, so when I found a box of 40 bags yesterday, I didn't hesitate to get it all.

I swear by Kroger brand... they actually come in a 16oz bag which I like because I dont have to measure and every time its perfect. I have tried kraft brand and I dont like the outcome.. too hard to roll out.

>I'm gonna give the No Name brand a try...I'm a Canuck so know exactly which one you are talking about pastryjen! ...>Unfortunately, we don't have Safeway here so won't be able to try those...>Will try Beacon brand if I ever come across it - sounds good to me...>Yeah, Jet puffed doesn't work for me either...

Wal-Mart brand now seems to be hit or miss. I microwave for up to 2 mins in 30 sec intervals until the MMs are all puffed and melty. Made some with Wal-Mart brand just after posting this and it was perfect this time, no blobs...go figure LOL!

I've used several different brands and find the resulting MMF is different depending on the MM used.

For example, when I use Wal-Mart's store brand I end up with very small clear jelly-like globs that cannot be kneaded away (not the same as the powdered sugar lumps that if left to rest, end up dissolving). When I've used Fireside marshmallows, I end up with more of a paste like consistency regardless of how much PS is used, and it tends to tear. With Kraft, it's more "elasticy" and not so pliable so it seems to want to go back to the shape it was rolled out to instead of conforming to the shape of the cake.

I'm just wondering for those that use MMF primarily or even exclusively, which brand of marshmallows have you found works best for you? Which brand do you have the most luck with?

Any insight would be helpful. TIA.

I just used the walmart brand marshmallows for the first time and while kneading it found those little plastic like balls in it too. I kept pulling them out wondering what the heck they were. Now I know it's the marshmallows. I personally prefer the campfire brand, but have used a lot of different brands and besides the walmart brand never had any trouble with my mmf.

I've used several different brands and find the resulting MMF is different depending on the MM used.

For example, when I use Wal-Mart's store brand I end up with very small clear jelly-like globs that cannot be kneaded away (not the same as the powdered sugar lumps that if left to rest, end up dissolving). When I've used Fireside marshmallows, I end up with more of a paste like consistency regardless of how much PS is used, and it tends to tear. With Kraft, it's more "elasticy" and not so pliable so it seems to want to go back to the shape it was rolled out to instead of conforming to the shape of the cake.

I'm just wondering for those that use MMF primarily or even exclusively, which brand of marshmallows have you found works best for you? Which brand do you have the most luck with?

Any insight would be helpful. TIA.

I just used the walmart brand marshmallows for the first time and while kneading it found those little plastic like balls in it too. I kept pulling them out wondering what the heck they were. Now I know it's the marshmallows. I personally prefer the campfire brand, but have used a lot of different brands and besides the walmart brand never had any trouble with my mmf.

Hi,I use the No Name brand too from Superstore. I buy the big yellow bag and get it for $4.98 or $3.98 if on sale for a 1.36 kg bag.

Hello all you fellow canucks!

Wow, I envy you, I buy the Beacon brand for $1.14 for a bag of 130gr!!!!

By the way, I never microvae it for more than 1 minute. I just put the whole bag in a bowl, add a bit of water (without measuring), and microwave around 1 minute, then stir it, and then gradually add powdered sugar while stirring. Then I knead for around 2 minutes and that's it!! So quick.

I've always used Jet Puffed (heard once that you should use a name brand?) and never had any problems. Maybe I'll try a generic brand just to compare and see if I can tell a difference. I always mix mine up in the mixer with the dough hook. Makes it really easy to add color. Dump the melted mm in the bowl, add the color, then the ps. Knead by hand briefly after the ps is mixed in. Done! I grease the bowl and dough hook with Crisco before starting and clean up is much easier!

My batches turn out very well doing what the posters ahead of me have described. However, last week I learned an important lesson: the batch was a mess.....ps wouldn't absorb well and what resulted was very grainy and coarse. Problem (it took me a little while to figure out)---stale marshmallows. Pay attention to how fresh the mms are. Common sense, I know, but something to remember!

Although I usually buy only the amount I need and use them right away, it's still good to know that (so thanks MacsMom & sweetjan) - maybe the store is stocking expired items. I've never checked the expiry date since I assumed they would be fresh if they are being sold but I guess it could happen.