Tag Archives: access

Question from a provider: VoIP traffic prioritization from essentially our own service?

Moderator: One thing that won’t be allowed is prioritizing your own service
over someone else’s similar service; that’s almost the whole point.
FCC person: This is contemplated in the document. Existing services
wouldn’t have to be reworked rapidly.
Seeking input.
Reasons to be concerned.
Monopoly over last mile has a position to differentially treat such a service.
This is one of the core concerns.

Q: Giving the same priority to somebody else’s similar VoIP service
is essentially creating a trust relationship; how much traffic
will the other service provider send?
Continue reading →

The subtitle is The Regulators Meet the Operators, at NANOG 48, Austin, Texas, 22 Feb 2010.
The ground rules of the panel are that it’s not about politics or policy.
It assumes there will be net neutrality, and it’s about getting
actual network engineers and architects involved in implementing it.
Prior reading: pages 41-51 of the
Notice of Proposed Rulemaking (NPRM).
I’d actually recommend starting at page 37, which is where the NPRM
discusses codifying the existing four Internet principles (see below).

A huge number of comments have been received already, by Jan 15 deadline.
More comments are solicited.
See also openinternet.gov.

The general idea is to take six proposed principles and turn them into
rules that are enforceable and not unreasonable:

Proposed Rules: 6 Principles

Access to Content

Access to Applications and Services

Connect Devices to the Internet

Access to Competition

Nondiscrimination

Transparency

The first four principles have been around for several years.
The last two, nondiscrimination and transparency, are
the same as the ones Scott Bradner’s petition
recommended back in June 2009.
Back then I mentioned as I always do that the FCC could also stop
talking about consumers and talk about participants.
Interestingly, their slide at this talk did not use the word “consumer”,
so maybe they’ve gotten to that point, too.

The FCC is also making a distinction between broadband and Internet.
There are existing rules regarding “managed” vs. “specialized services”
for broadband Internet access, but for net neutrality in general,
maybe different rules are needed.
Continue reading →

In the 1930s Franklin Roosevelt discovered stayed at Warm Springs in south Georgia to treat his polio. He discovered that most of rural America did not have electricity, and thus little light at night, few refrigerators, no eletric irons, and where you could get electricity, it cost much more than he was used to.

It was Roosevelt himself who linked the country’s rural electrification program to his adopted hometown of Warm Springs, Ga. In an
August 11, 1938, speech at Gordon Military College in Barnesville, Roosevelt spoke at the dedication of Lamar Electric Membership Corporation (now Southern Rivers Energy). His comments there immortalized the impact the president’s connection with rural Georgia had in illuminating the nation’s farms and country back roads. “Fourteen years ago, a Democratic Yankee came to a neighboring county in your state in search of a pool of warm water wherein he might swim his way back to health,” Roosevelt said before a crowd of 20,000 that summer day. “The place, Warm Springs, was a rather dilapidated, small summer resort. His new neighbors extended to him the hand of genuine hospitality, welcomed him to their firesides and made him feel so much at home that he built himself a house, bought himself a farm, and has been coming back ever since.”

Truly, Roosevelt endeared himself to Georgians. He continued his speech with the following words, which have been quoted countless times in promoting Warm Springs, the Little White House and Georgia’s EMCs:
“There was only one discordant note in that first stay of mine at Warm Springs: when the first-of-the-month bill came in for electric light for my little cottage, I found that the charge was 18 cents a kilowatt-hour about four times as much as I paid in Hyde Park, New York. That started my long study of proper public utility charges for electric current and the whole subject of getting electricity into farm homes. So, it can be said that a little cottage at Warm Springs, Georgia, was the birthplace of the Rural Electrification Administration.”

The R.E.A. produced more than electricity. “Truly, Roosevelt endeared himself to Georgians”, and to the rest of rural America, making the rest of FDR’s New Deal much easier to sell.
Read
the rest of FDR’s speech: that’s exactly what he’s doing; using the R.E.A. t
o sell the New Deal.

We have a similar situation today with
high speed Internet and rural America.
Republicans controled Congress and the White House for 8 years and the U.S. fell behind.
Democrats want to pass the equivalent of another New Deal.
High speed Internet access everywhere would have the effect the R.E.A. had in the 1930s.

Plus more: the Internet is the printing press, the telephone, the telegraph, the radio, and the TV of the 21st century.
Without it, people can’t even download the PDF of the CWA report that shows how far behind they are, much less YouTube, facebook, blogs, and access to diverse news sources throughout the world, not to mention the text of every bill in Congress and the voting records of every Congress member, as well as who their campaign contributors are. Those of us with Internet access take those things for granted.

Those without still mostly depend on one local newspaper and TV news for their information. Well, that plus chain emails for those who have dialup. With newspapers failing and TV news controled by a handful of companies,
without the Internet there is no free press.
Without a free press there is no democracy.

As FDR said in 1938:

Yes, electricity is a modern necessity of life (and) not a luxury. That necessity ought to be found in every village, in every home and on every farm in every part of the wide United States.

The same is true of high speed Internet access in 2009.

We need high speed Internet access everywhere for economic progress, national competitiveness, and for democracy. And yes, since the Internet is a huge source of recipes, for mom and apple pie! In south Georgia, even for okra fritters!
All the Internet you can eat: how’s that for a slogan?