I curled my lashes before applying this and it totally made my lashes straight all over again. I bought the Le frou frou after reviews on their website but it ended up a big letdown. It was like applying water to my lashes. Did not curl or thicken at all. Even after applying 3 coats of it. Returning it asap!!!

I am pretty hard to impress when it comes to mascaras. I was excited to try this one because the bottle looks amazing, and because I just love trying mascaras anyway. I have short, fragile and thin lashes, so it's hard to find a product that does it for me (and trust me, I have tried a bunch). This mascara gave me a little volume, and a little length and curl at the first application. I put three ...read morecoats in order to get the look that I wanted, which is usually better than average, because with most mascaras I have to put on coat, after coat, after coat. But this one only three. After a few hours of wear, I didn't notice that it had smudges of anything of the sort (as I have pretty oily skin and that's the usual case with me and other mascaras), so I was pretty pleased. Although not a favorite, I would buy again.

Curls and separates my lashes in one coat. I love Pin-Up girl mascara. It provides the best consistency of coverage with a great shaped brush to get my lashes that extra push!
I do note that you need to be cautious when applying since the formula can smudge or clump. Even being that the consistency of the mascara is way better than others I find. I have tried Better than Sex and went back to "fa...read morelsies" b/c of the brush.
I always end up going to this mascara due to the shape of the brush, the formula, and the design is handy. If you want a mascara that does the job and doesn't rob your bank account give this one a try!

...and it's one of my favorite mascaras. It gives a cute look and shapes the eyelashes really nice. Coats well also! I like to use this a base ro give my lashes a nice shape and then when it dries I'll put a thickening/lengthening mascara over top. Doesn't flake off for me which is also a plus!

I bought this mascara because of the inexpensive price tag but I am not really liking it that much. Its not a bad mascara, it doesn't flake or anything but I like really dramaic lashes. This makes your lashes look more natural and doesn't add much fullness. I woud recommend this for someone who doesn't like wearing much makeup or likes a natural looking lash.