It’s amazingly smudge and oil-proof – it lasted the whole day without giving me racoon eyes. That’s not to say it doesn’t fade – it loses about 20% of its original intensity, but it sort of disintegrates into nothing, so you don’t get black flakes or smudges on your undereye area. Well done Kate! So far, the only eyeliner I’ve tried that does this is the Laneige Natural Eyeliner.

For the upper eye, this is more suitable for those who want a more natural look – the line drawn is really fine and thin.

For the lower eye, this is a perfect undereye eyeliner cos it doesn’t smudge much.