Scoundrel time is back

"Sir, have you no shame?" attorney
Joseph Welch asked Sen. Joseph McCarthy in 1954, when McCarthy was attempting to
smear a young man as a Communist. The same question ought to be asked to those
who are now attempting to tar Larry Pratt, a co-chair of the Pat Buchanan
campaign, as a racist and anti-Semite.

I've known Larry for nearly a decade. There's not a racist or anti-Semitic
molecule in his body.

Speaking to the media on Thursday, Larry pointed out that 20 percent of his
staff is Jewish or African-American, that he attends a church with an
African-American minister, and that he is a longtime member of Jews for the
Preservation of Firearms Ownership and of the Congress on Racial Equality. In
addition, Larry is married to a Panamanian.

Larry Pratt and his group Gun Owners of America have written literally hundreds
of thousands of words on public policy, all of them available to anyone. The
people at the misnamed Center for Public Integrity have not cited a single
sentence written by Larry or GOA that has any hint of racism or anti-Semitism.

Nor does this "Integrity" group point out that GOA has consistently emphasized
the lethal dangers that gun prohibition poses to African-Americans, Jews and
other minorities who, when disarmed, are at the mercy of the majority. Whether
you agree with this argument or not, it is certainly not an argument likely to
be offered by a bigot.

What the center's smear campaign comes down to is this: Larry once attended an
informational meeting about the federal government's killing of Sammy and Vicki
Weaver. Among the other people who attended the meeting were leaders of racist
organizations, and the meeting was organized by a racist.

In other words, Larry must be guilty by association. Even though no one denies
that Pratt told the racists at the meeting that he rejected their views. In
addition, Pratt was reported to have spoken at rallies that were attended by
people in racist groups. What is Pratt supposed to do, post guards at every
speech he makes to keep out anyone who may be a racist? Even by this high
standard, Pratt has done pretty well.

At a "Preparedness Expo," Larry went to the show's promoter and successfully
urged him to order several racist organizations to remove their booths from the
premises. Finally, Gun Owners of America has given money to an attorney to help
with the Branch Davidians' wrongful death suit against the federal government.
The attorney, Kirk Lyons, has (in unrelated cases) represented racists. But then
so has the American Civil Liberties Union, and so have most of the criminal
defense lawyers in this country. Lawyers aren't supposed to judge a client's
entire life; they're supposed to protect the client's legal rights.

Notably, while Pratt has been a strong defender of the right to keep and bear
arms, he has also been a powerful voice against legislation that would infringe
the rights of immigrants.

For example, he has denounced proposals for the use of secret evidence in
deportation proceedings.

Back in 1974, many lifelong Republicans voted Democratic to protest the
Republican party's defense of the criminal regime of Richard Nixon. Perhaps some
New Hampshire voters will cast their ballot for Buchanan as a protest against
the use of character assassination as a political tactic.

Make a donation to support Dave Kopel's work in defense of constitutional
rights and public safety.

Nothing written here is to be construed as
necessarily representing the views of the Independence Institute or as an
attempt to influence any election or legislative action. Please send
comments to Independence Institute, 727 East 16th Ave., Denver, Colorado 80203 Phone 303-279-6536. (email)webmngr @ i2i.org