Search This Blog

Can a Tristan Take a Dramiel?

I get this question a lot in Eve. Someone wants to fly a Rifter, just as an example, so what ships should he attack in confidence? The answer is somewhere between all of them, and none of them.

It could be any ship. From the lowest Frigate to the biggest Battleship, there is no right answer. In fact, it all just kinda depends now don't it?

But let's take a step back and start from the beginning. A Tristan is a T1 Frigate that, when operated in the right hands, can do this to a Dramiel. (Despite the fact that the Dram pilot apparently decided fighting without ammo would be a good idea.) And in the next minute lose a fight to a Kestrel. ( Apologies to my good friend Joffy for using his fights as examples, but they did just happen and I don't think he'll mind.)

On paper, in a perfect world, a Dramiel should beat a Tristan. And the same Tristan should win against a rocket Kestrel. Generally speaking. Most of the time. But sadly, Eve is not a perfect world. And we don't fight on paper. We fight in space with its gazillion layers of complex variables that screw even the best laid plans.

There just ain't no figuring it.

In the absence of a "win" button then, what can the PvPer do? Luckily the answer is rather simple. While it is indeed true that there are no "right" answers, there are actually probabilities of success. Variables influence probability and increasing the variables on your side, weigh the outcome in your favor. Variables increased on the side of your enemy? Decrease your probability.

Let's take the first of those. A straight up Tristan Vs. Dramiel duel? Let's be generous and award the fight a 2-10, or 20%, chance of success on the part of the Tristan. In other words, not bloody likely. A few variables such as age, experience, fit, location and whatnot might increase that probability. The Dramiel was in a Large Plex and the Tristan landed right on top of him. That might, combined with the other variables, increase the odds to maybe 45%. Still not great, but better than 20%. Not loading ammo? Suddenly that increases the odds to 87%. Not much higher because the Dram is dual-prop and had a chance to leave the fight.

Now, the tricky bit. You are not going to be aware of some important variables BEFORE you engage. You can't ring the enemy up and ask questions before the fight. Things don't work like that. So kudos to Joffy for engaging when the best he could've hoped for was maybe a 45% chance of victory, or significantly less if someone had loaded ammo.

And yeah, of course I'm totally making these numbers up. Who knows what the real percentages are? ( Someone might, I mean they are out there to be examined, I'm just not going to do it. Statistical analysis is not my thing, but I would be curious to read such a report. )

The thing is, low percentage/probability fights have the highest reward. You could fly around in a T1 Frigate exploding rookie ships all day, but where would that get you? You'd never have the satisfaction of taking down a Pirate Frig in your Tristan. Or solo'ing a Megathron in a Rifter. Or exploding a Tengu with a Comet.

GIven the right set of circumstances any combat ship in Eve can win versus any other combat ship in Eve. Depending on the variables involved, the odds might not be in your favor, but then again they might. And you just don't know it yet.

That's why the best PvPers don't ask what ships the Rifter can fight. They already know the answer, given the right circumstances, is all of them.

Comments

I know what you mean bro. I wasted an AC Thrasher last night with my rocket kestrel. Wasn't really expecting the win, but was confident I'd have enough time to get out if it didn't go my way. Fortunately for me, he forgot to pack barrage. That capped off a pretty profitable night scoring a nice solo kill, 60k FW LP, and about 12m in drops. Love winning the fights I shouldn't, but you never really know unless you try.

I guess ultimately that is the message I try to preach, try. You can't succeed unless you try, fail, and keep trying. Learn from your mistakes, sure. Try harder, ok. But the heart of it is undocking and making things happen. Only by being in the midst of it can you find the good fights, the solo ratting Megathron with T1 drones.

I tend to engage any and all with some notable exceptions. I really do not want to take the Hookbill of a noted Hookbill pilot on in my Slasher. I will run some other times, if just to set up better for the fight I might get.

Well certainly tactical advantage is one of the many variables, it also happens to be one you can actually control. Dashing headlong into every fight isn't smart either. Doing everything you can to win however? Now that is smart.

What I find important is trying to figure out the other pilot's fit and skill/experience before deciding on the fight. If I know that the pilot is new, I increase my expectations. If I check kill boards and see that they often fly a fit that counters what I am flying, I avoid a fight. Of course this is always the advantage of less expensive ships. I am willing to engage any dramiel with my standard T2 fit tristan, but not with my T2 rigged, deadspace fit long point hanger ornament tristan.

Post a Comment

Popular Posts

FOR IMMEDIATE RELEASE This Saturday, May 23rd, A Band Apart will be hosting their fifth Frigate Free For All (FFA) in Ouelletta, Verge Vendor, from 16:00-20:00 Eve time. 4,000 Frigates will be available for FREE to all participants in the Federal Navy Academy station at Planet V Moon V. “The free Frigates will be fit so that anyone, no matter their skill level or experience, can fly one and enjoy a fun environment of friendly combat,” said Rixx Javix, Executor of A Band Apart alliance and host of the event, “this is still Eve of course, but this is as safe of an environment as we can provide.” The last FFA saw 2,000 players take to space and resulted in over 45,000 explosions over the entire afternoon, “The red dot on the New Eden map was huge!”, Javix said. During the course of the event on Saturday special events will be announced in local, giving pilots a chance to score valuable kills and loot - all provided by pilots in ABA. “We have some special ships our pilots are planning on b…

On Saturday between the hours of 16:00 and 20:00 thousands of ships will be exploded in Ouelletta during the ABA Frigate Free for All. But why should you come to the event? This is your chance! Within the context of Eve the tables are often skewed against you. You know exactly what I am talking about. You're young, you like to focus on mining, industry, staying out of trouble...whatever it is you enjoy doing in Eve. This is your chance to let your hair down and have some pew pew fun. All with a minimum of risk. And while I'd be the last person to tell you it is going to be perfectly safe, within the normal context of Eve, the FFA is at least balanced in your favor. It is as close as you can get to a fair shake in this game. For a few hours you'll be on the field with other players in the same kind of ships, with the same kind of skills, doing the same kind of things. Nothing is "fair" in this universe, but this is as close as it can get for a brief moment in time. A…

On Saturday May 23rd, A Band Apart in association with Streamfleet, will be holding a FFA: Frigate Free For All in Ouelletta. Open to all players young and old, the FFA will feature 4,000 FREE Frigates to be handed out to participants during the four hours of the event, as well as very special event "events" to be announced in the coming weeks. Not to mention prizes!

"The FFA was terrific, This was the best time I ever had in eve." - Saki

These events are huge, you can see the results from our last one in that image above. But it is also the perfect place for any player, no matter what you do in-game or your experience level, to get a taste for PvP in as safe and friendly an environment that you can find in New Eden. The ships are FREE. All the fights will be between Frigates and we'll even have some places for you to get on bigger ship killmails along the way.

More details will be announced as we get closer to the date, but be sure to mark your calendars now …

"This was the best event I have ever participated in after 15 years of playing the game. Thank you Rixx and A Band Apart for all your hard work! o7" - Solidus Zero via Twitter Saturday hundreds and hundreds of Capsuleers grabbed free Frigates and headed into space to find combat, duels, insane battles at the Sun, and do it all over again for four straight hours during our FFA in Ouelletta. Nearly 6,000 ships exploded in glorious balls of fire during the event. All in all A Band Apart handed out over 3,200 fully fit Frigates. You can watch the entire thing over on Streamfleet thanks to Corvus Onzo and Streamfleet, ISD Thalack, CCP Convict, CCP Aurora, and everyone else who helped make the event such a massive success.

This was simply the best FFA of the six I've created and hosted in Eve so far. You never know what might happen, as I kept telling everyone "this is Eve" so anything is possible. But aside from Snuff hot-dropping a Moros, and some Russians causing som…

Our Wednesday fleet this week was yet another Crow based roam down into Pure Blind. Lufax would be FC'ing as usual. But this week had a little extra spice because I had been contacted by Richie Shoemaker (of EON Magazine fame who I've known for over a decade now) who wanted to tag along on our next Null Roam. Perfect. So I decided to make things more interesting and pick up some new Needlejack Filaments.

I was going to do this on Tuesday. But sadly Tuesday was mostly spent without power as our electrical junction box was getting a much need upgrade here at the Pirate Lord Mansion. So Wednesday morning I had to log into my Jita alt and quickly grab some filaments and then safely fly them down thru a War Dec. I admit I was in a hurry. But how complicated could it be? There are only two kinds of Needlejacks - Noise and Signal. Each of which come in 3 different flavors depending on the size of your fleet. And WHOA are they expensive!! So I picked the 3 cheapest ones I could find …