Comparing Twelfth Night And Shes The Man English Literature Essay

She ‘s the Man is a lovely and screaming comedy filmed in the United States. It was directed in 2002 by Andy Fickman and is based on the drama the 12th dark written and composed by William Shakespeare. In the DVD She ‘s the Man the chief character, Viola Hastings, disguises herself as a adult male and takes her brother ‘s topographic point in the male childs ‘ association football squad. Her purposes are to turn out that misss are capable of making what boys do and in a manner she succeeds to make merely that. From Shakespeare ( 8 ) the book twelfth dark is about Viola, subsequently adopts the name Cesario, who find herself in an island shipwrecked and separated from her twin brother Sebastian. The ship captain so clothes her as a male child so that she would alternatively function the Duke. The secret plan is that of a love trigon and many misconceptions.

In the drama, The Twelfth Night and the film She ‘s the One the character of Viola and Cesario played by Imogen Stubbs and Amanda Bynes severally are adult females moving as work forces. They both had their strengths and failings throughout the film and the drama. They portrayed a adult male really efficaciously altering their visual aspects to look like work forces in order to gull other characters. Cesario used a bogus mustache ad facial hair while Viola had burnsides. They had to intensify their voices to sound more of work forces although at some point they erroneously resorted back to their normal voices.

In the scene in The Twelfth Night, where Cesario and Duke Orsino are forcing each other about, the former starts to oink like a miss after losing control on the drop. Although similar things happen in the film on many occasions as good, one incident stands out. When the European wolf spider, Marvolio, Crawls into Viola ‘s room. They characters may be depicted to be similar in many manner but they besides have differences.

In the DVD She ‘s the Man, Bynes uses a sort of slang that is stereotyped and barely in usage presents and might hold been easy to place she was non a adult male. She plays in even less efficaciously when Duke shows up and the two of them are sharing a conversation. She forgets her masculine function and is overcome by her desires for him. In the novel by Shakespeare, it happens to the character Cesario many times but unlike Viola by Bynes, she is better at concealing it.

The film She ‘s the Man shows much of the general thought of the original Shakespearean book, the 12th dark. It besides, illustrates the alteration in feminine functions in the community and society at big, the chief subject of the film being feminism. In Shakespearean epoch and clip, the of import, recognizable and powerful places in the society were taken by work forces and hence Viola in the 12th dark disguises herself as a eunuch in order to acquire near to the Olivia, the countess and the Duke.

Viola in the 12th dark realizes that she has caused Olivia to fall in love with her accidentally. She says she is the adult male as depicted by Shakespeare ( 12 ) . She so observes that by have oning male garb she is a animal that is both male and female and that she is a hapless animal. Similarly, Viola from the DVD She ‘s the Man overhears a conversation Olivia confessing that she has a crush on Sebastian, her male individuality. She is shocked and on looking at herself on the mirror, she smiles absently touching her face and about instantly comes to world with a dork and admirations, “ Oh male child. ” She experiences a minute of crisis merely as Cesario does in the drama.

The film, She ‘s the Man, sticks to the word picture of the drama and by and large follows the narrative construction and merely modernizes the linguistic communication and the scene of the drama into a more familiar conceptual book. However it does non follow the tragic events that are depicted in the drama. It emphasizes on comedy, get the better ofing the dark tones of Shakespeare ‘s book to concentrating on a pleasant heterosexual brotherhood in the concluding scene. Although the girl power message is put across, the film by Fickman nowadayss finally a conservative reading of the drama by Shakespeare by doing Viola encompass the muliebrity traditionally at the terminal.

The film borrows most names of both the characters and the scenes from the original drama. Although the names in the film do non needfully match to the characters in drama, they are used in one manner or another. . Some statements in the book are besides borrowed from the drama for illustration duke says ; “ Some are born great, some achieve illustriousness, and some have illustriousness push upon them ” . ( Shakespeare 37 ) This is a citation in the missive Malvolio read in the drama the 12th dark. The remaking of the original Shakespeare ‘s drama into a film loses most of the tragic impact celebrated in his literature. His chief subjects of love and decease are subsided and it is barely noticeable that the film was adopted from Shakespeare ‘s work. However the secret plan of the drama has by and large been conserved.