Ur right melvin best manager A.s have had since La russa but you sent out your rookie closer 3rd day in row when it was abvious he was wild from beiing over used crazy .. Bochy did same with cassilla on sunday dont get this???

It wasn't the third day in a row. Cook had pitched Sunday, Tuesday and Thursday prior to the blown save. That's a very typical schedule for a closer when his team is on a roll. Melvin used him appropriately. Given Cook's stats, his overall performance and frankly, Melvin's very limited options in that situation, Melvin made the right call...he didn't lose the game. Cook just didn't have it that night. I was frustrated by the loss too, but that's baseball.