Stress And Poverty May Explain High Rates Of Dementia In African-Americans

New research finds that African-Americans who grow up in harsh environments and endure stressful experiences are much more likely to develop Alzheimer's or some other form of dementia.

Leland Bobbe
/ Getty Images

Listen

Listening...

/

Originally published on July 16, 2017 8:03 am

Harsh life experiences appear to leave African-Americans vulnerable to Alzheimer's and other forms of dementia, researchers reported Sunday at the Alzheimer's Association International Conference in London.

Several teams presented evidence that poverty, disadvantage and stressful life events are strongly associated with cognitive problems in middle age and dementia later in life among African-Americans.

The findings could help explain why African-Americans are twice as likely as white Americans to develop dementia. And the research suggests genetic factors are not a major contributor.

"The increased risk seems to be a matter of experience rather than ancestry," says Megan Zuelsdorff, a postdoctoral fellow in the Health Disparities Research Scholars Program at the University of Wisconsin-Madison.

Scientists have struggled to understand why African-Americans are so likely to develop dementia. They are more likely to have conditions like high blood pressure and diabetes, which can affect the brain. And previous research has found some evidence that African-Americans are more likely to carry genes that raise the risk.

But more recent studies suggest those explanations are incomplete, says Rachel Whitmer, an epidemiologist with Kaiser Permanente's Division of Research in Northern California.

Whitmer has been involved in several studies that accounted for genetic and disease risks when comparing dementia in white and black Americans. "And we still saw these [racial] differences," she says. "So there is still something there that we are trying to get at."

The research presented at the Alzheimer's conference suggests the missing factors involve adverse life experiences beginning in childhood. These experiences have already been linked to a range of diseases, including heart disease and cancer.

"We're starting to understand how early life stress and early life deprivation can increase your risk of a number of health outcomes in late life," Whitmer says. "And the latest thing is understanding how and why that might affect the brain."

Whitmer was part of a team that presented results of a study of more than 6,000 Kaiser Permanente health plan members, most born in the 1920s.

The team wanted to know whether people who grew up in harsher conditions were more likely to develop dementia. So they looked at people who'd been born in states with high infant mortality rates — an indicator of social problems like poverty and limited access to medical care.

White people's risk of dementia wasn't affected by their place of birth. But black people were 40 percent more likely to develop dementia if they'd been born in a state with high infant mortality.

"These people left the state and subsequently moved to northern California, yet there was still this very robust association between being born in a state with high infant mortality and increased risk of dementia," Whitmer says.

Scientists from the University of Wisconsin presented results of a study of the link between stressful life events and mental function in middle age. They studied more than 1,300 people in their 50s and 60s, including 82 African-Americans.

Stressful experiences included having a parent with a drinking problem, financial insecurity, legal issues, divorce, being fired from a job, and the death of a child.

African-Americans reported 60 percent more of these stressful events than white Americans. But that was only part of the difference, Zuelsdorff says.

"The impact of these stressful events was stronger in African-Americans than it was in non-Hispanic white participants," she says.

The researchers discovered this by administering tests that reveal the brain's speed and flexibility in doing certain tasks. These abilities normally decline with age. So the team looked for evidence that stressful events were accelerating this decline.

And they found that in white participants, each stressful event added about a year and a half to normal brain aging. But in African-Americans, each event aged the brain an extra four years.

The next challenge for researchers is to figure out precisely how adverse life experiences are changing the brain, Zuelsdorff says. That will mean looking at the effects of stress hormones and seeing whether stress leads to inflammation in the brain, something that has been associated with Alzheimer's.

Copyright 2017 NPR. To see more, visit http://www.npr.org/.

LULU GARCIA-NAVARRO, HOST:

Staying with health care, we turn now to a new report on Alzheimer's disease. African-Americans are twice as likely to develop Alzheimer's or some other form of dementia compared to those who are white. NPR's Jon Hamilton reports on new research that's helping to explain the disparity.

JON HAMILTON, BYLINE: Scientists have struggled to understand why African-Americans have such a high risk of dementia. As a group, they are more likely to have conditions like high blood pressure and diabetes, which can affect the brain. And there is some evidence that genetic factors play a role. But Rachel Whitmer of Kaiser Permanente's Division of Research in Northern California says her own research shows that those explanations are incomplete.

RACHEL WHITMER: These risk factors were taken into account, and we still saw these differences. So there is still something there that we are trying to get at.

HAMILTON: So Whitmer and other researchers have been looking at less obvious risk factors like stress and poverty. She says it's already clear that children who grow up in a harsh environment are more likely to have health problems like diabetes and heart disease.

WHITMER: We're starting to sort of understand how early life stress and early life deprivation can increase your risk of a number of health outcomes in later life. And I think the latest thing now is understanding how and why that might affect the brain.

HAMILTON: Whitmer was part of a team that studied more than 6,000 Kaiser Permanente health plan members in their 80s and 90s. The team wanted to know whether people who'd grown up in harsher conditions were more likely to develop dementia, so they looked at people who'd been born in states with high infant mortality rates, an indicator of social problems like poverty. They present their results today at the Alzheimer's Association International Conference in London. The study found that white people's risk of dementia wasn't affected by their place of birth, but Whitmer says black people were 40 percent more likely to develop dementia if they'd been born in a state with high infant mortality.

WHITMER: These people left the state and subsequently moved to Northern California, yet there still was this very robust association between being born in a state with high infant mortality and an increased risk of dementia.

HAMILTON: A separate study looked at the link between stressful life events and mental function in middle age. Megan Zuelsdorff from the University of Wisconsin in Madison says participants answered questions like...

MEGAN ZUELSDORFF: When you were a child, did a parent drink so much that it caused problems? Did your parents divorce? Did you have trouble in school?

HAMILTON: Zuelsdorff says participants also reported stressful experiences they had as adults, things like a serious illness or the death of a child. And African-Americans reported 60 percent more stressful events than white Americans, Zuelsdorff says that was only part of the difference.

ZUELSDORFF: The impact of these stressful events was stronger in African-Americans than it was in non-Hispanic white participants. Each stressful event is more detrimental.

HAMILTON: The researchers tested the brain speed and flexibility, things that normally decline with age. The test showed that in white participants, each stressful event added about a year and a half to normal brain ageing. In African-Americans, each event added about four years. Zuelsdorff says this all may sound discouraging, but it also means there's a possible solution.

ZUELSDORFF: The increased risk seems to be a matter of experience, rather than ancestry. And this is something we can change.

HAMILTON: In other words, by improving the early lives of African-Americans, it may be possible to reduce the risk of dementia later on. Jon Hamilton, NPR News. Transcript provided by NPR, Copyright NPR.

Related Content

We’ll get an idea of how widely shared the economic recovery is on Wednesday of this week, when the U.S. Census Bureau releases its yearly report on income and poverty in the United States. For the first time, the Supplemental Poverty Measure will come out at the same time.

Some encouraging news in the battle against Alzheimer's disease and other forms of dementia: The rate at which older Americans are getting these conditions is declining. That's according to a study published Monday in JAMA Internal Medicine. Researchers say one reason for the improved outlook is an increase in education.

This is the first in a series, Inside Alzheimer's, about the experience of being diagnosed with early-onset Alzheimer's disease.

In 2009, 59-year-old Greg O'Brien was a successful journalist and writer living in Cape Cod. He was healthy and happy — he exercised every day, made a good living, spent time with his three children and wife.