Some professors, students and advocates at the state’s flagship university are warning proposed sweeping changes to the state’s higher education system could undermine academic freedom and programs like ethnic studies.

A bill sponsored by state Sen. Gay Kernan, R-Hobbs would scale back the number of required credit hours students take in public university “general education core” classes and establish “meta-majors.”

“Meta-major” classes are defined in the bill as “lower division courses” that are set by the department and include general education courses and prerequisite courses.

At a Senate Education Committee hearing last week, Kernan said her bill’s purpose is to make it easier for students who transfer to different universities to use the credits they’ve already earned from previous courses toward their college degrees.

At last week’s hearing, Damron described meta-majors as a group of courses set under a list of broad subjects that undecided college students can choose from to create a path toward their eventual major.

This would replace the current system of having a college advisor set the course path for each student, according to Diane Torres-Velasquez, an associate professor at the University of New Mexico.

But Torres-Velasquez and others are opposed to the change because of a perceived top-down approach that places business and workplace skills over critical thinking and education.

Subscribe to our mailing list

“Are we trying to educate students or are we trying to get them in and out as fast as we can and into jobs right away?” Myrriah Gomez, also an associate professor at UNM, asked rhetorically in an interview. “It’s another effort to corporatize education, in my opinion.”

Chief among Torres-Velasquez’s concerns are that the reform could “whitewash” courses like Chicano studies by leaving them out of the list of required classes within meta-majors curriculums.

Both professors lament that students and faculty were not properly included in discussions on establishing meta-majors in the state, which have been ongoing for the past few years.

“It would be problematic for administrators to come in and tell us what the meta-majors are because that would affect our academic freedom,” Torres-Velasquez said.

This criticism prompted an emotional defensive from Damron, who explained that she reached out to every group and entity affected by the changes “more than anyone has reached out to them before” for input.

“I’m offended that anything I’ve done has been done differently than that,” Damron said holding back tears.

Damron observed that most of the public comments in opposition to the bill came from people associated with UNM. She blamed the university for that.

“I’m sorry there’s one institution that has communication problems,” she said.

Damron also contended that meta-majors don’t have to leave out ethnic studies courses.

“Meta-major helps group subjects together. Ethnic studies can fall into group,” she said.

Kernan added her daughter graduated from Colorado College with an ethnic studies degree and emphasized that the intent of her bill is to streamline transferring student credits between universities. She and lawmakers from the committee praised Damron for “working diligently.”

“I’m certainly always open to talk to anyone,” Kernan added.

The action leading to this controversy seeded more than a decade ago, when the state Legislature passed a bill designed to ease the burden of transferring college course credits between public universities across the state. The bill was signed into law by Gov. Bill Richardson in 2005 and established August 2017 as the deadline for the new way of transferring college credits.

Originally, the law was only supposed to change the course numbers in lower-division classes “in a way that was common to all universities,” Torres-Velasquez said. But as the deadline approached, “all of a sudden there was not only going to be a change in course numbers, but a change in the general education core.”

Meta-majors exist at universities in some other states.

Palm Beach State College in Lake Worth, Florida, for example, offers meta-majors in broad categories like “science, technology, engineering and mathematics” and “arts, humanities, communication and design”—both of which require students to take some of the same lower-division general requirement courses.

Ultimately, the concerns were not enough to dissuade state senators on the committee from moving the bill unanimously to the next committee.

“This is not rushed,” Sen. Bill Soules, D-Las Cruces, said of the bill just before the committee unanimously approved it. “I’m very supportive of it.”

State Sen. Mimi Stewart, D-Albuquerque, raised concerns about the process.

“It should concern all of us that we have a large number of students who don’t like what we’re doing and are here because of that,” Stewart said. “I think they bring up valid concerns.”

The bill now heads to the Senate Finance Committee.

One legislator, state Rep. Patricia Roybal Caballero, D-Albuquerque, is opposed to the bill, at least for now. At last week’s committee hearing, she said in public comment that “this particular process has not been as inclusive as we have hoped for.”

“Ethnic studies is the core, women’s studies is the core,” Roybal Caballero said. “All of these studies are core to education, however we are not included in the discussion.”

Correction: A previous version of this story reported that Sen. Mimi Stewart voted for the bill. She in fact did not vote on the bill.

Related

Comments

More About

School funding lawsuits are usually long legal slogs, but New Mexico’s timeline could be shortened by years. Late this morning, Democrat Michelle Lujan Grisham was the first candidate for governor to say she would not continue a legal battle over whether the state is meeting its financial obligations to adequately educate children.

MCALLEN — Every afternoon, dozens of immigrant families released by the U.S. government walk three blocks from the Greyhound bus station in this South Texas border city to a migrant shelter run by Catholic Charities. Along with the clothes slung over their shoulders, the migrants sometimes carry government-issued containers — dark-blue receptacles resembling lunch boxes, with plastic handles that shine in the mid-afternoon sun.

An advocate for an animal rights organization says a state representative should step down because he sexually harassed her. The advocate, Laura Bonar, is the Chief program and policy officer for Animal Protection Voters and Animal Protection of New Mexico according to the organization’s website.

State budget troubles are prompting the New Mexico Higher Education Department to make cuts to a program local students use to attend colleges in nearby states for programs not offered at home. New Mexico pays into the Western Interstate Commission on Higher Education (WICHE) Professional Student Exchange Program that allows local students to go to dentistry and veterinary schools outside of the state at a reduced rate.

The Trump administration has quietly taken steps that may inhibit independent oversight of its most high-risk nuclear facilities, including some buildings at Los Alamos National Laboratory, a Department of Energy document shows. An order published on the department’s website in mid-May outlines new limits on the Defense Nuclear Facilities Safety Board — including preventing the board from accessing sensitive information, imposing additional legal hurdles on board staff, and mandating that Energy Department officials speak “with one voice” when communicating with the board.

The president pro tem of the New Mexico Senate on Wednesday called for the resignation of the five regents of New Mexico State University, saying they had arbitrarily stripped powers from Chancellor Garrey Carruthers. The regents voted Monday to prohibit Carruthers from hiring and firing people in executive or coaching positions at the main campus in Las Cruces and on NMSU's branch campuses.

MCALLEN — Every afternoon, dozens of immigrant families released by the U.S. government walk three blocks from the Greyhound bus station in this South Texas border city to a migrant shelter run by Catholic Charities.

LAS CRUCES, N.M. — Groups advocating for the rights of children and families detained at the southern border are using the Freedom of Information Act to find out exactly where the Trump administration plans to build migrant detention centers on two military bases in the Southwest.

Joey Peters has been a journalist for nearly a decade. Most recently, his reporting in New Mexico on closed government policies earned several accolades. Peters has also worked as a reporter in Washington DC and the Twin Cities. Contact him by phone at (505) 226-3197.