Follow by Email

Thursday, 5 April 2018

Corruption and impunity on trial: Mexican police officers claim torture after being charged in case of missing Italians

On January 31 Raffaele Russo, 60, an Italian national from
Naples, travelled in a rented white Honda CRV 40 kilometers from his four star
hotel in Ciudad Guzmán, to the town Tecalitlán in southeast Jalisco. He left behind his son, Antonio Russo, 25, and
his nephew, Vincenzo Cimmino, 29. Apparently, his plan was to explore
opportunities to sell light machinery.

During the trip Raffaele was in contact with another of his
sons, Francesco, who was in Mexico City. Their last communication was abruptly
cut off at 3 pm on the 31st. Francesco was then unable to reach his
father, and grew concerned. He contacted the car rental agency, which said that
the last GPS reading was from 3.23 PM. Just before this, Rafaelle also sent a
WhatsApp message to family members in Italy saying that police officers were following
him.

The three missing men

Francesco then called his brother and cousin in Ciudad
Guzmán, and asked them to go look for his father. They arrived in Tecalitlán in a rental vehicle similar to Raffaele's around 6 pm on that same night, and asked after him.
At about 7 pm they stopped at a gas station on Highway 110, on the outskirts of
town.

Two municipal police officers on motorcycles approached
them. One of the officers ordered the two Italians to follow him. At this time, Antonio left a voicemail with
his brother in Mexico City:

“Two policemen on motorcycles want to stop us. In fact,
they already have, and one has told us to follow him, while the other patrol is
following behind us.”

Worried after receiving this message, and no longer able to
contact his brother and cousin, Francesco then looked up the phone number for
the municipal police in Tecalitlán, and called them directly from Mexico City.
Only minutes after 7 pm, he had a phone conversation that, according to his
account, went as follows:

“I'm calling to ask if you’ve arrested two Italians who are
looking for someone else,” he said.

To which the woman who answered the phone at the police station responded, “I’m hearing on the radio right now that they’re checking a
vehicle with two foreigners. Call again in a half hour for more information.”

Francesco called back in thirty minutes. This time, the
woman at the police stations denied everything that she had said in the previous
call. Francesco then called the rental agency for a GPS reading on the vehicle
that Antonio and Vincenzo were travelling in. The last reading was two
kilometers ahead of the last point recorded by Raffaele’s vehicle.

That same day, the Jalisco Prosecutor's Office intervened,
and summoned all of the members of the Tecalitlán police force, interrogating
them in the main plaza. They then took some of the officers back to the state
capital, Guadalajara, claiming that is was for training purposes, and that they
were not being detained.

As is often the case in Mexico, officials then began to
dissemble, come up with theories, and cast aspersions on the victims. State
prosecutor Raúl Sánchez Jiménez suggested that the cause of the disappearances
may have had something to do with the machinery business, with Russo “trying to
sell cheap generators and agricultural machinery which they told people was of
good quality.”

Specifically, he accused Russo of unloading generic, knockoff
Chinese generators and soldering equipment while claiming that they came from
global brands such as Bosch and Caterpillar. Sánchez also referenced inconsistencies
in Fernando’s account which, according to the state prosecutor, hindered the
search.

Though such activity by no means warrants murder, Sánchez’s
theory may hold some water: he has indicated that the elder Russo was arrested
three years ago in Campeche for similar activity.

Francesco then returned to Italy, where he made it very
clear that, in his view, it was the municipal police in Tecalitlán who took his
father, brother, and cousin. Further, he complained that the authorities in
Mexico were trying to criminalize his family. The Italian embassy, responding
to pressure back home, got involved and started to lean on the Mexican government
for some kind of action.

Then on Saturday, February 24, Sánchez announced that four Tecalitlán
police officers had been detained, and that these individuals confessed that
they had handed over the Italians to an organized crime group. He also said
that the director of the Municipal Police, Hugo Enrique Martínez Muñiz, as well
as two other members of the force, were being sought.

What happened next would not be earthshattering news in many
countries, but in Mexico it was a small piece of history in the making, because
back in 2008 Mexico announced that it was transitioning its judicial system to
an oral, oppositional format, similar to what’s used in the United States and
the British Commonwealth. The new criminal justice system was supposed to be in
place by its constitutionally imposed deadline on June 16, 2016, but the shift
has been slow and uneven. Where it is in place, it can best be described as an
oral/oppositional system with “Mexican characteristics”.

Nonetheless, on Friday, March 2, in a courtroom in Ciudad
Guzmán designed to accommodate the new process, the judge from the Sixth
District, Damián Campos, listened to testimony from the defense in open court. The
identity of the four defendants was protected, with the surnames redacted. They
were known only as Emilio “N”, Salomón “N”, Fernando “N”, and Lidia “N”.

Remarkable, however, was the fact that the prosecution
publically submitted 43 pieces of evidence to try to establish that the four
participated in the enforced disappearance of the Italians. The prosecution
claims to have received confessions that confirm that around 7 pm on January 31st the third in command of the Tecalitlán police force, Hilario “N”, who is still
at large, received a call on his cell phone. Before he hung up, he allegedly responded to the
unknown caller that: “It checks out and is done.”

Further, while on patrol, Emilio “N” apparently went with his boss and overheard when the commander asked the motorcycle patrol consisting of Salomón “N” and
Fernando “N” to meet on Juárez Street, one block from where Antonio Russo and
Vincenzo Cimmino were fueling their vehicle. He then ordered the patrol to
verify if at the gas station there was a white Honda CRV with two Italians on
board. The two officers went to the gas station, corroborated the information, and
via radio informed their commander, who asked them to take the two Italians to the
exit towards Jilotlán de los Dolores. One of the officers commanded the Italians
to follow him. The commander's truck then followed behind.

When they reached the road to Jilotlán, they stopped and waited for
the arrival of a red Mazda truck. Two men got out, one of whom the prosecution
identifies as "Don Ángel", the alleged leader of the ultra-violent Jalisco New Generation Cartel (CJNG, by its Spanish acronym). The two Italians were
delivered to the cartel leader, who told the police that he would take care of
them along with “the other Italian.”

Back at the police station, Lidia "N" has heard
that her colleagues detained two foreigners. Naturally, when Francesco calls to
ask after them, she says that she will have more information in half-an-hour. However,
Commander Hilario then orders Lidia not to say anything, and upon receiving the
second call from Francesco she denies what she said earlier. At 11 pm of that same
day, Hilario meets with Lidia, Emilio, Salomón and Fernando, and orders them
not to say anything about what happened.

He then gives them each 1,000 pesos (US$55). This has since
resulted in people saying that the Italians were “sold” for a pittance, but
clearly this occurred in the context of a local police force under the command
of a cartel. The money was not a serious consideration – this was never not going to
happen.

Things get interesting when the four police officers are
asked to testify in open court. Remember, this is a new phenomenon in Mexico –
usually a defendant is present only to hear charges, or to be informed of the
status of a case, and never to openly face and respond to allegations.

As often happens in courts the world over, the defendants
changed their story. Emilio, Salomón and Fernando now say they know nothing
about the Italians. Instead, they claim to have been tortured at the Police
Academy in Guadalajara. Rather than receiving “training”, as prosecutor Sánchez
claimed, the defendants say that they were punched in the stomach and
suffocated with plastic bags, forcing them to sign confessions that they never read.
For her part, Lidia says that the police threatened to kill her family.

Jumping on this, the defense requested that the confessions
be thrown out. The judge demurred, indicating that there needs to be an
investigation to determine if the police officers were in fact tortured. After
almost 10 hours in court, the judge determined that the three men should go on trial for the forced disappearance of Antonio and Vincenzo. There can be no
charges in the disappearance of Raffaele, because it is still unknown how he
came to be missing. The three policemen could each be sentenced to 40 years in
prison.

As for Lidia, the judge determined that she wasn’t a party
to the disappearance. However, she did hinder the search by lying, so her
sentence could range from two to nine years in prison.

The trial of the agents will begin sometime after September
1.

A lawyer for the Italian family claims that investigators
have determined that the three men are still alive. "For the Mexican
authorities our co-nationals are alive and the investigative activity is moving
in this direction," said Claudio Falletti. However, in the eyes of many
in Mexico, given what is known of the CJNG’s brutality, and the lack of ransom
demands, it seems likely that the three men are dead.

Jalisco District Attorney Raúl Sánchez is continuing on his
campaign to tie the Russo and Cimmino families to organized crime.On February 20, he announced that he’d
requested a criminal background check on the men from Italian authorities. The
next day, the Mexican press claimed that the Italians worked for a low-level offshoot
of the Magliari, infamous for selling bogus merchandise.

If this were true, it could have exposed them to danger in
an area that is notorious for cartel activity. But this by no means excuses the
apparent collusion between the Tecalitlán police and the CJNG, one of the most
powerful and violent criminal organizations in the world.

In the meantime, the family of the three missing men has
offered an award of two million pesos (US$110,000) for any information that might
lead to their return. They have also taken the case to the Inter-American Commission on Human Rights (IACHR), which has called the situation of the three missing
men serious and urgent, and has requested that Mexico adopt the necessary
measures to protect their rights to life and personal integrity, and to
guarantee an effective search. Sadly, as
with most declarations from human rights organizations, the request is
toothless and will be ignored.

However, the movement on the judicial side – where four
police officers have been charged, and three more remain at large – is more
promising. It has moved quickly, and with transparency – something almost unheard
of in Mexico. It is also demanding a higher level of accountability on the part
of the state.

As it stands, most Mexican judges strongly support the
transition to the oral adversarial system. In fact, this support grew from 76
percent in 2010 to 93 percent in 2016. But Mexico is at a crossroads, because the
public will be deeply frustrated should criminals be set free due to the malfeasance
on the part of the authorities. The idea, of course, is for the police to clean
up their act, but torture, threats, and other abuses are rampant.

This new approach demands a lot of a system that is
inefficient and crippled by endemic corruption. It is no longer good enough for the state to collect evidence, put it in a file, and give it to
a judge. Prosecutors must now present evidence in open court in an oral format,
allowing the defendant to challenge its admissibility. The
state has to reveal the source of its evidence, and Mexican prosecutors must
present it in a way that gives the judge a chance to assess the credibility of
the witness.

Sadly, the temptation to revert to authoritarianism as a
panacea for chaos remains, as is evidenced by the new Law of Internal Security,
which formalizes the power given to the Mexican military as a domestic police
force.

No comments:

Post a Comment

Search This Blog

Podcast: Notes From The Underground

In the podcast Notes From The Underground TE Wilson discusses historical and contemporary attitudes toward crime. Each episode features a one-on-one interview that explores a unique topic. Interviewees include authors, experts, and individuals with personal experiences of crime. These podcasts were originally broadcast through the facilities of Trent Radio in Peterborough, Canada.

Mezcalero, a Detective Sánchez novel

Bicultural and transgender, detective Ernesto Sánchez seeks a missing Canadian woman on Mexico’s Pacific coast. Moving uneasily in a world where benign tourism co-exists with extreme violence, he becomes a pawn in a shadowy power-play between corrupt police and drug cartels. Forced to make hard choices – desperate, wounded, and friendless – Sánchez takes refuge in the lawless mountains of Oaxaca. And discovers his fate.

“Wilson’s Mezcalero is a real-pager turner…While the milieu of Wilson’s novel is reminiscent of the hard-boiled tradition, his creation of P.I. Ernesto Sánchez is original, and helps Wilson push the boundaries with respect to genre. Sánchez is a hard-hitting private eye, but Wilson also depicts him as struggling with many of the issues that transgender individuals typically face; in this manner, Wilson creates both a riveting mystery and timely story about navigating life as a gender nonconforming individual.”

“Mezcalero is a remarkable read, with sustained suspense, surprise explosions of poetry and violence, and some new answers to old questions...Wilson understands something about violence and gender that I have never encountered before: that women’s violence is perhaps the most feared. Sanchez’s womanly violence in his manly body is a mystery revealed, a truth told that we suspected all along. This is a profoundly feminist book. The women in the book are the power brokers, the activators of action; even the most oppressed empleada is a container of her own complete power. Mezcalero is deftly plotted, and deploys an acrobatic narrative that is, frankly, exhilarating. Sanchez has a lot to teach us. Wilson, too.”

Janette Platana, author of A Token of My Affliction (2015 Frank O’Connor International Short Story Prize; 2016 English Language Trilium Book Award finalist).

“T.E. Wilson’s Mezcalerois, as a novel, a tacit consequence of the author’s real-world work as a reporter/journalist in Mexico. His work is rich in essence, and rich in detail, of how widespread organized crime and corruption permeate Mexican society. Highly recommended. This is great, well-grounded fiction.”

Dr. Edgardo Buscaglia, Senior Research Scholar in Law and Economics, Columbia University, and President of the Citizens’ Action Institute (Instituto de Acción Ciudadana).

“T.E. Wilson has crafted a terrific, terrifying and yet sensationally witty portrait of modern Mexico. Detective Sánchez is irresistible. You won’t soon forget his journey through that unpredictable jungle that is Mexico today.”