It is ironic that the electronic media which played a major role in the movement against a military dictatorship is now being cited as one of the challenges to the fractured democratic transition since 2008. Perhaps it is not by design. It is clear that the electronic media remains a nascent industry and like the rest of the country operates in a largely unregulated environment. Pakistanâ€™s overall governance climate is marked by dynasties, oligarchies and mafias. Why should we expect the media to rise above the larger culture? Nevertheless, given its important role in shaping public opinion and attitudes, the need for media responsibility has increasingly been articulated by a wide range of actors and not just the wounded political players.

The current media freedoms are unprecedented. Gone are the days when holy cows could not be touched and certain subjects were taboos in the public domain. Indeed, the national security paradigm is ascendant and the official history of Pakistan is the major narrative but there are plenty of discordant and critical voices within the industry. However, the imperatives of a rating-advertising driven culture impair the ability to be objective and rational. This is why a highly respected English channel had to switch to Urdu to cater to the cruel corporate dynamics. Concurrently, Pakistan with a largely static readership has witnessed the launch of two major English dailies and a third one is likely to be launched by the end of this year!The outreach of electronic media has also given it a taste of untrammelled power. Musharrafâ€™s downfall and the ability of the TV channels to question the Army during 2007-2008 reshaped its role as a power centre to reckon with. In this tumultuous period, the Judiciary also emerged as a new power centre and there has been a rare synergy between the two institutions in asserting their independence and guarding their turf vis-Ã -vis the Executive and after 2008, the Parliament.

Many analysts have noted that this is not a healthy trend as the two new power centres are unelected and therefore not directly accountable. The Judiciary is insular and can hardly be questioned and media accountability is almost non-existent due to the dysfunctional institutions. Hence the last two years have witnessed chaotic power dynamics which do not bode well for democratic governance. The media houses assume peopleâ€™s representation role and some judges have remarked that they also articulate peopleâ€™s will.As testified by Pakistanâ€™s history, the only workable governance framework is one which is representative. All military led modes of governance have damaged an uneasy federation and caused upheavals. For the media itself, democratic environment is even more important. Its long term growth and survival is contingent on retaining the hard earned freedoms. These days preserving democracy is even more urgent as the rise of sectarian and extremist ideologies reject democracy, constitutionalism and human rights. Therefore, the electronic media is now at the centre of these vital existentialist debates in the country. The record so far has been far from promising. Sections of the media continue to recycle the failed prescriptions of the security establishment.

First, typical to the uninformed opinion industry of the Urdu press, the electronic media has not kept up with the political consensus of fighting extremism and Islamism. Instead, there has been endless glorification of terrorists as mujahids and anti-US fighters. There are channels which take credit for airing the views of the leaders of banned organisations and promoting their disturbing worldviews. It is not uncommon to find a vigorous defence of strategic depth on a daily basis; and celebrations on occupying Kabul next year whether we are able to keep the country at peace or not.

Second, the demonisation of politics and politicians continues unabated. Undue attention is paid to the fake degrees of politicians whilst forgetting that the rules of the game were not set by the political class. Similarly, during the recent floods the politicians (of all hues and shades) were painted as villains as opposed to the Army which was donating its food rations (forgetting that the budgets for the institution were approved by the Parliament).

Thirdly, Pakistanâ€™s ingrained â€˜political instabilityâ€™ is now the ultimate fodder for breaking-news-syndrome. Stories with imminent clash of the institutions are flashed as a matter of routine thereby generating an environment which is deeply hurtful for the economy and the investors. It is now difficult to separate fact from fiction. Whether it is the Government-Judiciary collision or the civil-military divide, the differences are accentuated to an uncontrollable degree fulfilling several prophecies and serving the prophets of doom.

In this context, the recent calls for media accountability at various events in Islamabad, Karachi and Lahore are poignant. More voices in the civil society are backing the demand for media responsibility and objectivity. The government has a rare chance to forge a consensus on restructuring the useless Ministry of Information, reinvigorating PEMRA and strengthening the overall regulatory environment. The media should promptly respond to these calls and protect its credibility. With a failing economy and a fledgling democracy, the road ahead is fraught with uncertainties for the smug media industry.

22 thoughts on “Media: Through the Looking Glass”

I agree with most of the things that you have to say. I still think media’s overall impact would be positive; there is enough diversity that alongside good reporting the mediocre kind will be shown as well. I think you can’t just blame media for threats which current democratic government is facing. If this government knew or even if it tried, it could have used media for its own advantage. In this day and age, if you have a president who is hardly if ever seen in public. It is hard to imagine that sort of government playing media and using it. There is not even an effort; the message is we don’t care bark all that you want to.

I think the glory time of the free media has passed, although it is obviously debatebale if it ever was there in the first place.

The heyday was around the CJs ouster period and its synergy with the black coat movement. The reality is even at that stage it operated under certain parameters, it is largely Islamabad, lhr, khi centric, its sustainablity is open to question and the focus is on talk shows not investigative journalism.

What we have now is increasing self censorship with regard to large parts of state policy e.g., FATA, balochistan etc and more importantly the deep state. The media has bcome increasingly diverse but is not pluralistic, nor multiethnic and as such not reflective of society.

The worst part is the old lifafa journalism is also back but in a new form, side by side is a greater media awareness by the elite, who have become more savvy on media spin control.

Ultimately increased responsibility and accountability will help but what is really needed is a new generation of journalists who can push the envelope, be reflective of all pakistan, re-educate a generation brainwashed by distorted concepts of nationalism & religion and hold the state (as opposed to solely the govt) accountable.

I simply want to say I am just newbie to weblog and really savored this web blog. Most likely I’m likely to bookmark your website . You definitely come with really good posts. Thanks a lot for sharing with us your web site.

Hello There. I found your blog using msn. This is a really well written article. I will be sure to bookmark it and return to read more of your useful info. Thanks for the post. I’ll definitely return.|

Thank you a lot for sharing this with all people you actually understand what you are talking about! Bookmarked. Please additionally visit my website =). We can have a hyperlink trade contract among us|

Can I just say what a comfort to uncover somebody who actually knows what they’re discussing on the internet.
You definitely know how to bring a problem to light and make
it important. More people need to check this out and understand this side of the story.

I was surprised you are not more popular given that you most certainly
have the gift.

Wow that was strange. I just wrote an incredibly long comment but after I clicked submit my comment didn’t appear. Grrrr… well I’m not writing all that over again. Anyways, just wanted to say excellent blog!

Hello there! Quick question that’s completely off topic. Do you know how to make your site mobile friendly? My blog looks weird when viewing from my iphone. I’m trying to find a theme or plugin that might be able to fix this problem. If you have any recommendations, please share. Appreciate it!

It’s a shame you don’t have a donate button! I’d most certainly donate to this brilliant blog! I guess for now i’ll settle for book-marking and adding your RSS feed to my Google account. I look forward to new updates and will share this site with my Facebook group. Talk soon!