Are Singaporeans being crushed by credit card debt?

SINGAPORE – Media OutReach – 7 August 2018 – Singaporeans are big credit card fans — and an improving
economy means consumers are swiping plastic more frequently than ever. But
beneath this exuberance lurks the risk of escalating debt, which can have dire
consequences for individuals and families. Credit card debt here has been
inching up, but how big is the problem and how much of a risk does it pose?
What should borrowers be taking note of when it comes to managing their credit
card debt?

Credit card debt on the rise

Household debt levels in Singapore are largely under control,
thanks in part to borrowing curbs imposed in recent years[1].
Still, a small but growing group of borrowers continue to struggle with
mounting credit card debt.

Credit
card debt made up about 4.3 per cent of all consumer loans in 2016 – roughly on
par with 2015’s 4.2 per cent, according
to data from the Department of Statistics[2]. This
capture ending credit card balances that remain unpaid at the end of the month.

The Monetary Authority of Singapore (MAS) introduced new rules to curb unsecured borrowing in 2013, as part of efforts to put a lid on rising household
debt. Among other safeguards, an industry-wide borrowing limit was introduced
in June 2015. Under this rule, financial institutions are not allowed to extend
further unsecured credit — which includes credit cards – to borrowers whose
debts exceed a prevailing limit. This limit is being phased in over four years
— starting with 24 times a borrower’s monthly income from June 2015, to 18
times from June 2017 and 12 times from June 2019.

These regulations helped lower total debt among Singapore
households. Growth in outstanding credit card balances moderated from a peak of
14 per cent year-on-year in the second quarter of 2012, to an average of 2.6
per cent in the first nine months of 2017, data
from Credit Bureau Singapore (CBS) showed[3].

But households are still holding on to significant credit card debt. Banks wrote off a total of S$128.3 million in bad credit
card debt from January to May this year, according to MAS data. On a per card
basis, bad credit card debts written off reached S$3.34 per card in May 2018 —
a level last seen in 2005. This means borrowers were persistently unable to
repay these loans, forcing banks to write them off.

This comes as the number of credit cards in circulation here has
risen rapidly over the past decade according to MAS data[4]
– from about 6 million in May 2008 to a whopping 9 million as at May 2018, a 50
per cent surge.

The MAS noted in its November 2017
Financial Stability Review[5] that there
are still “a number of borrowers who are increasing their level of indebtedness
above 12 times their monthly income”.

Why is credit card debt climbing?
What are the risks?

Consumers accumulate credit
card debt for a variety of reasons, including spending above their means, bouts
of unemployment and paying for essentials. Credit
cards are an increasingly popular mode of payment, which might be part of the
reason why borrowing is on the rise. Financial institutions offer a wide array
of perks to encourage consumers to spend more on their cards — from cashback
and airline frequent flyer miles to free gifts and sign-up offers. In addition,
it is now easier than ever to make payments with a credit card — the rise of e-wallet apps like Apple Pay,
Android Pay and Samsung Pay, for example, allow users to tap and pay for goods
and services at contactless payment terminals.

The numbers show that people in Singapore are increasingly
reliant on their credit cards. Monthly billings per card hovered between S$300
to S$400 from the mid-1990s to early-2010s, but have started rising above $S400
in recent years[6]. In May
2018, monthly billings per card amounted to about S$555, after reaching S$514
in April and S$537 in March.

Even
as consumers spend more on their credit cards, interest rates are also on the
rise — making it tougher for some to meet their repayment obligations. After
the global financial crisis, major central banks around the world used
ultra-low – even negative – interest rates as a tool to revive economic growth.
Lower interest rates make it cheaper and more appealing for households and
businesses to borrow. Since then, however, the global economy has
recovered and growth has picked up. As a result, policymakers have gradually
started raising rates. The United States Federal Reserve has been leading the
pack of developed market central banks in lifting interest rates from the
ultra-low levels implemented in the wake of the global financial crisis.

Interest
rates in Singapore are highly correlated with global rates – the Fed’s latest
rate hike announcement in June 2018 sent the three-month sibor, or Singapore inter-bank offered rate,
used to price home loans — to its highest level since 2008. Credit card
interest rates are also rising in tandem with these broader increases, making
it more expensive to borrow.

Reducing the cost of credit card
borrowing

Pay credit card bills on time and in full

Credit card users typically fall into two main categories — “transactors” and “revolvers”.
Transactors pay their credit card balances in full every month and avoid paying
interest. Revolvers carry credit card debt from one month to the next, paying
interest on their average daily balance.

Credit
card borrowing is extremely high-stakes – interest rates are astronomical at
over 26 per cent a year. Rollover balances also incur late-payment charges that
are tagged on to the outstanding principal, further magnifying the amount owed.
As a result, credit card debt can snowball very quickly – which means being a
revolver can be very expensive. Clearly, the most
effective way to avoid falling into credit card debt is to pay off balances promptly
and in full.

De-clutter your wallet

There is no magic number for the number of credit cards a
person should have — it depends on spending behaviour, financial goals and
personal money management.

A consumer who pays off balances in full and on time every
month can consider having multiple cards to take full advantage of benefits
such as cashback, frequent flyer miles and discounts. However,
holding more cards also means greater
potential for racking up debt.

Besides limiting your borrowing, having fewer credit cards
also means fewer bills to keep track of each month — which can help you stay on
top of your credit card payments and avoid incurring late fees or interest.

Consider switching to a personal loan

Instead of dealing with sky-high interest rates, consumers can consider using
personal loans to pay off credit card debt. Taking on more debt might sound
counterintuitive, but personal loans can actually help borrowers save money.

Personal loans are “unsecured” loans, which means that unlike secured
loans, they are not backed by collateral — like a house or a car – that lenders
can repossess if borrowers default. This means personal loans have higher
interest rates than secured loans, but they often offer lower interest rates
than credit cards.

Personal loans can be used to consolidate your credit card debt into
one manageable account, as long as you stay within your borrowing limit. This
will help cut back on the number of bills to pay and keep track of every month.
Instead, a personal loan allows borrowers to pay a fixed amount monthly.

There are three main types of personal loans available in Singapore. Personal instalment loans — the
most common type – provide a lump sum of cash upfront, with monthly repayments.
The second type is a credit line, which allows borrowers to draw money
as needed and pay interest only on the amount borrowed. Finally, balance
transfers allow borrowers to consolidate outstanding debt into one account,
with fixed monthly repayment schedule.

One of the newest and most
attractive options on the market is the Standard Chartered
CashOne Personal Loan, which offers guaranteed
flat interest rates as low as 3.88 per cent per annum (EIR: 7.63 per cent
annum) regardless loan amount and tenure. This rate is exclusively available on
personal finance comparison website SingSaver,
for a limited period. Borrowers can borrow up to four times their monthly
salary, capped at S$250,000.

Singaporeans have a total outstanding debt of about S$70.4
billion on credit cards and personal loans, according to 2017 data from the
Department of Statistics Singapore. But if each borrower took time to consider
their personal loan options, Singaporeans could collectively save more than
S$500 million on interest payments every year (assuming S$23.5 billion in
personal loan debt and an interest rate of 3.88 per cent per annum).

While personal loans can be less costly than credit card debt,
however, they still come at a relatively high price. For some borrowers,
personal loans might not be a viable long-term solution — especially if their
debt is the result of overspending or lack of income. Before taking out another
loan, these borrowers should consider identifying and tackling the root cause
of their debt through financial re-evaluation or lifestyle changes. Ultimately,
borrowers need to do their research and make sure personal loans are
financially viable for them.