I have used this product for years. I didn't buy the coordinating brush, but instead bought a brush by Urban Decay which works just as well. I put a droplet of water on the product and then slide my brush through the product to get it on the brush. I then apply it right by the lash line as close as I can get. It instantly makes my lashes look thicker. Once it dries it lasts all day long. I like that with this product you can get such a close thin line. All in all a great product.
— 3 years ago

I love how this eyeshadow/eyeliner looks on. The product is designed to work as an eyeliner on the bottom and top lids and absolutely transforms the face. It makes the eyes absolutely pop and is gorgeous with the flat eyeshadow brush that they sell separate.
— 7 years, 2 months ago

As other reviewers have said, this Eye Pencil is extremely soft. The texture would be better described as an "eye crayon" instead of "eye pencil". The perception of the Eye Pencil will hinge on how durable/smudge-free the Eye Pencil appears to you.
There are few things you can do to make the Eye Pencil more durable:
DO:
-Apply fine, powder foundation on the eyelids before you apply the Eye Penci...read morel. The powder will absorb excess oil and make the Pencil last longer
-Sharpen the Eye Pencil before every use. The Pencil is so soft that it loses its pointy tip, even after a single use. You don't want to apply a thick line with this Pencil, because it unavoidably looks smudgy
DON'T:
-If you use a liquid foundation and find purchasing a powder foundation outrageous, then LEAVE the eyelids foundation-free. Liquid foundation, especially the non oil-free ones make the Pencil smudge almost immediately
-If you live in a hot, humid place, then even with my tips above, the Pencil will smudge. Use this Pencil not in the Summer but in cooler seasons
-If you are into a perfectly smudge-free eye pencils (maybe these kinds that wash out only with a special cleanser), this Pencil is NOT for you. With tips above, you can make the Pencil last longer without too much smudge. By this I mean that you are presentable in front of other people rather than that your eye lines have not changed AT ALL
Overall, the Pencil is one of my favorites, I wear it even to workouts in the gym. Antique Jade (greenish black) complements brown eyes very well.— 1 year, 10 months ago