The Free Agency stuff is good, but the draft has too many players that are head cases and raw players.

Outside of Ogletree, Fluker, Mathieu, and Hopkins, I don't see any player (other than the Buchanon, a questionable fit, especially as a rookie with no depth behind him) drafted there. RayRay and Klein are borderline Rnd 7/UDFAs. Klein is a great college QB who doesn't have NFL skills. I would honestly stay away from RayRay other than a UDFA flier.

The Positions are fine where you have them drafted, but I would take those 2 players out. Also, if Buchanon is drafted, it would be too much to expect him to start at SLB, even in an elephant position. He was a College DE who played almost exclusively with his hand in the ground. Also, if Kiwi is moving to DE, maybe a cheap veteran LB with starting experience too to be a short-term SLB.

First off, I am definitely not a fan of losing Kenny Phillips. He is a crucial part of this defense, even if he doesn't make many splash plays. I think the two free agent acquisitions would be great fits on the team.

I like Ogletree as a prospect, I just am not sure I would want to take him at #19. If the Giants trade back and then select him, I will be perfectly fine. But I think at 19, Ogletree is a slight reach and there is probably better talent to be drafted. Big fan of Fluker, but I hear many think he won't be able to play tackle effectively in the NFL. I am fine with him as a LG, but it would be nice to be able to fill the RT void with him. NOT a fan of Mathieu in the 3rd round. Too much of a risk to take him in the 3rd. Plus he is going to be limited in the NFL because of his lack of size. Don't know much about Buchanon. Needs to bulk up a little bit to play DE and I doubt he would transition well into a 4-3 linebacker. As a Hurricanes fan, I can say with certainty that I do not want Ray Ray Armstrong on the Giants. He just never showed he could translate into a safety after beginning his career as a WR. It would be a wasted pick, IMO. Don't like taking QBs in the draft, even in the late rounds. Klein doesn't seem like he will translate well into the NFL. Giants would be better off taking another position and hoping to select a gem who may actually see the field. I like the last two picks, as I had the same two selections in my mock.

Overall, not a fan of a rookie backup for Eli. If he were to actually go down, there is no way Coughlin would feel comfortable trotting out Klein. The new improved offensive line would be a huge improvement. I would be ecstatic if the Giants actually signed Loadholt. Perfect fit for the RT void. I would not be comfortable at all with that starting linebacker group. Way too inexperienced to be on the field for almost every defensive play. I don't mind Williams starting, but to start him along with two rookies would be a huge mistake. Linebacker is the largest void on your roster. I think the Giants would need to bring in a FA CB for depth over Mathieu. I think Will Hill would step up as a 3rd safety of starter, and provides good depth. My main problem with your mock offseason is that the Giants would be starting three rookies, which I don't think Coughlin would ever do.

I really really like the draft, having klein replace carr would (should) free up some cap room. And on the off chance that he has to play I really think he would out perform his projections.

I've been high on Ogletree for awhile now. And Buchanan is all I want from a OLB

overall nice job, even though I think we may be getting rid of Webster.

Collin Klein.... DO. NOT. WANT. i do not want that noodle arm anywhere near my team.

besides, Carr made $1M for one of the easiest jobs in the NFL (given Eli's durability *knock on wood*), so why would you replace him with a rookie making $500k? I will take David Carr's "broken" QB play over many backup qbs in the league today, let alone a rookie._________________“I feel sorry for people who don’t drink. They wake up in the morning and that’s the best they’re going to feel all day.”

If Eli goes down, our season is f'ed no matter who starts in place of him. I'd rather have a cheaper, high potential rookie than Carr honestly.

agreed, and that's fine. that's an honest debate. but there is no debating that it should not be Collin Klein _________________“I feel sorry for people who don’t drink. They wake up in the morning and that’s the best they’re going to feel all day.”