Transcription

1 Professor Paust was quoted in the National Law Journal in an article reporting on a seminar at Pace Law School on Friday regarding the legality of the killing of Osama bin Laden. The following article appeared on the website of the National Law Journal of May 6, Was bin Laden raid legal? Probably, according to experts in international law Karen Sloan Was the killing of Osama bin Laden by a team of U.S. Navy SEALs a violation of international law? Probably not. That was the consensus among a panel of human rights and international law experts Friday at Pace Law School although the panelists cautioned that a definitive answer is impossible without knowing exactly what happened inside the compound in Pakistan where the leader of Al Qaeda was killed on Sunday, May 1. "I think it's fair to say we don't know all the facts yet," said Pace law professor Thomas McDonnell during the panel discussion, which was part of a larger conference on teaching international law. Still, the panelists almost universally expressed dismay at the lack of appetite among the American public to discuss whether the mission to take out Bin Laden was legal or moral. Americans are so happy that he is dead that they simply aren't worried about the legality of the operation, said Cindy Buys, a professor at Southern Illinois University School of Law. That's a step backward for international law, said University of Houston Law Center professor Jordan Paust, given that violating those laws could lead to a slippery slope. "It's too easy to have leaders who want to do things that aren't legal," he said. "As lawyers, we must insist that we not allow violations of the law." International law cannot be over looked simply because the nature of Bin Laden's crimes are so heinous, said Pace law professor Alexander Greenawalt. "I have a real problem with the idea that it's OK to kill somebody in order to avoid a politicized trial," he said. "A lot of people have a basic moral intuition that this was OK." The panelists tended to look at the issue from two perspectives: Did the United States violate international law by conducting the operation in Pakistan without the consent of that sovereign nation, and did the United States violate international law by killing an apparently unarmed Bin Laden rather than take him into custody or turn him over to the Pakistani government.

2 Most of the experts agreed that the U.S. military had the right under international law to target a non-head of state in a sovereign country because Bin Laden had attacked the United States. "The de-facto theater of war has expanded, and that's what we look at in international law," Paust said. "Wherever Osama bin Laden was operating, the theater of war was right over his head." Robert Van Lierop, the permanent representative to the United Nations for Vanuatu, said he is inclined to think that United States did have the right to go into Pakistan, given that Bin Laden fits the definition of a "non-state aggressor." "At some point, a sovereign country that is harboring an international war criminal loses somewhat the right to assert sovereignty when an effort is made to bring in that criminal," Van Lierop said. The circumstances of the killing divided the panel somewhat although releasing the footage of the raid or photographs may help clear up some of the lingering questions, several participants said. It's difficult to decipher which laws apply to the raid, given that it was something of a cross between a police enforcement operation and a traditional military operation, said Peggy McGuiness, a professor at St. John's University School of Law. While soldiers are prohibited under international law from shooting those who surrender, it's not at all clear what Bin Laden was doing when the Navy SEALs approached. Not only that, the question of surrender is murkier now, McGuiness said. "How do we know if someone is approaching in order to surrender, or approaching in order to detonate a suicide vest?" she said. If the SEALs were specifically ordered to kill Bin Laden, that could be problematic under international law, Paust said. But those decisions are split-second in close combat, Van Lierop said. "I don't know who could second-guess a split-second decision under those circumstances," he said. "I don't know that there could have been a different outcome." In all reality, U.S. forces could not have left Bin Laden in the hands of the Pakistani government, noting that there was no "chance in the world" that he would be extradited to the United States or granted due process.

3 The fact that the United States chose to send in the SEALs for a targeted strike, rather than blowing up the compound by air, indicates that commanders were taking the law into consideration, several panelists said. "There was an effort to minimize collateral damage, and that is significant on the side of legality," said Laura Dickinson, a professor at the Arizona State University Sandra Day O'Connor College of Law.

4 Professor Paust was quoted in an article in the Journal News about the seminar held at Pace Law School. This article appeared in the Journal News (New York) on May 7, 2011: Bin Laden slaying: Was it legal? Pace hosts international law symposium May. 7, 2011 Written by Rebecca Baker WHITE PLAINS The thrill of finding and killing Osama bin Laden for orchestrating the 9/11 terrorist attacks may have overshadowed a key question: Was it legal? That question was the subject of debate among a group of law professors and international legal experts Friday at Pace University Law School. Pace Law professor Thomas McDonnell organized the event months ago as a symposium to show law students and professors the importance of international law in an increasingly globalized society. But when bin Laden was killed by Navy SEALs on Sunday, the topic became more timely. "There are serious legal questions," he said. "If he could have been captured, should have he been captured?" There were no clear answers. Robert Van Lierop, a former U.N. representative for the South Pacific island nation of Vanuatu, said the U.S. military could never have turned over bin Laden to Pakistani authorities. "There's not a chance in the world he would have been extradited and given due process," he said. Van Lierop said that even though bin Laden was not armed when he was killed, his stated desire to be a martyr, his penchant for suicide bombings and his lack of explicit surrender were solid reasons not to take any chances. "I'm not as troubled by his death," he said. "I don't know who could second-guess a split-second decision. You don't know what's behind the door or who could burst into the room. They did attempt to save human life." Alexander Greenawalt, an international law professor at Pace, questioned if bin Laden was killed to avoid a highly politicized trial.

5 University of Houston Law School Professor Jordan Paust was concerned more with the decision to kill bin Laden. He said the U.S. was likely justified in raiding the compound because he was orchestrating more attacks there, putting "the theater of war right over his head." Cornell Law School Professor Sital Kalantry said the U.S. legal system is not prepared to try terrorists, evidenced by the number of terror suspects who have been held at Guantanamo Bay for nearly a decade. "That is so shameful," she said. "We don't have a semblance of due process even if we had captured him." Others wondered if the United States has clouded the rules of war by killing bin Laden in Pakistan, and if it could set the stage for similar actions in other nations. "I'm a little unhappy with the trail we've gone down," said Peggy McGuiness, a human-rights scholar at St. John's University School of Law. "Here we are, 10 years after 9/11, and there's no consensus as to what these rules should be." As the war on terrorism continues, the panelists said, the United States must show the world that it respects international law. "Maybe we don't care so much about the legality because we're so happy (bin Laden) is dead," said professor Cindy Buys of the Southern Illinois University School of Law. "But, as lawyers, we should insist on the rule of law."

6 Professor Paust was quoted in the Harrison Patch (New York) in an article about the seminar at Pace Law School. The following article appeared on the website of the Harrison Patch (New York) on May 7, 2011 (available online at Was Killing Osama Bin Laden Legal? Top legal scholars discuss fine points of the mission that killed Osama Bin Laden at Pace Law School. By Duncan Raymond While much of the country celebrates the death of Osama Bin Laden, some question the legality of the military mission that killed him. At a discussion at Pace Law School's Justice Institute, legal scholars debated several issues surrounding the al Qaeda leader's death: Was the mission a violation of Pakistan's sovereignty? Does the law of war or law of civil rights apply? Was there an alternative to killing Bin Laden? Friday's discussion, chaired by Pace University School of Law professor Thomas Michael McDonnell with participants from Harvard Law School, Southern Illinois University Law School and St. John's University School of Law, as well as other Pace Law School faculty was part of a larger symposium, Teaching International Law Beyond the Classroom. Facts about the killing have been slow to emerge, and the events that led to Bin Laden's death have changed in the telling. "The facts seem to be evolving," said McDonnell, the author of "The United States, International Law, and the Struggle Against Terrorism." "I think it's fair to say we don't know all the facts yet." Two facts are clear: Bin Laden was killed in a private compound in Pakistan, and the U.S. acted without notifying Pakistan about the military mission. "You can use military force without consent in foreign countries. Osama Bin Laden had command and control with [his] couriers. You can target him legitimately," Jordan Paust, professor of International Law at the University of Houston Law School said.

7 Paust was one of the first to condemn Justice Department attorney's defense of the use of torture methods at Guantanamo Bay, asserting those constitute crimes. However, Paust defended the targeted killings in Pakistan. "Has the war migrated to Pakistan?" Paust said at the debate. "Yes. The de facto theater of war has expanded. Wherever Osama Bin Laden was operating, the theater of war was right over his head." Robert Van Lierop, a former United Nations ambassador, said, "At some point a sovereign state [such as Pakistan] that's harboring an international fugitive loses the right to assert sovereignty." Another issue at play, McDonnell said, is whether Bin Laden should have been captured instead if that was possible. "If the law of war [applies]," he said, "was there military necessity? Was he armed? Was there a fire fight? It's not clear." Van Lierop said if Bin Laden was captured he "could not have been turned over to Pakistani authorities." Raquel Aldana, McGeorge School of Law, said she wasn't sure about the legality of the killing but said Bin Laden was, in a way, "lucky" to have been killed instead of captured. "In some sense we're not prepared to give due process to war criminals. I think about...guantanamo." If the mission was legal under the rules of war, Alexander Greenawalt, also a professor at Pace Law School, said, "I'd have a problem if they killed him [Bin Laden] if he tried to give up."

President Obama Announces Death Of Osama Bin Laden May 1, 2011 East Room Washington, D.C. THE PRESIDENT: Good evening. Tonight, I can report to the American people and to the world that the United States

COMMITTEE AGAINST TORTURE Fifty-third session 3 28 November 2014 CONSIDERATION OF REPORTS SUBMITTED BY STATES PARTIES UNDER ARTICLE 19 OF THE CONVENTION Concluding observations of the Committee against

The New York Times/CBS News Poll July 21-25, 2006 For release in paper of July 27 N= 1,127 All trends are from New York Times/CBS News polls unless otherwise noted. An asterisk indicates registered respondents

TRENCH RAIDER: World War I Wargaming in Ten Minutes by David Raybin 2014 INTRODUCTION Instead of a generic set of WW1 rules I determined to make the rules fit the game scenario rather than the other way

Jawbreaker: The Attack On Bin Laden And Al-Qaeda: A Personal Account By The CIA's Key Field Commander By Gary Berntsen;Ralph Pezzullo If looking for a ebook Jawbreaker: The Attack on Bin Laden and Al-Qaeda:

Verbatim Transcript of Open Session Combatant Status Review Tribunal Hearing for ISN 10014 OPENING REPORTER: We are on the record. Remain seated and come to order. Proceed Recorder. This Tribunal is being

City of Redlands Disaster Council Minutes INTRODUCTIONS: Monday January 26 th, 2015 City Council Chambers 35 Cajon Street Redlands, CA 92373 Meeting called to order at 3:00pm Fay Glass welcomed everyone

Guantanamo Bay Guantanamo Bay is a facility stationed in Cuba that holds persons suspected of terrorism. Its purpose and conditions have been a source of controversy in the United States as well as the

Krav Maga (Krav Maga, Self Defense) By Goerge Silva READ ONLINE Krav Maga is a unique and logical system of self-defense and fighting skills. The most important weapons you'll ever own are your body and

The Writers: Stan Fagerstrom Part One October 25, 2012 By Terry 6 Comments Stan Fagerstrom on the cover of US Bass Magazine, circa 1988. Editor s Note: This series is dedicated to those people who penned

How and why do things change over time? How and why do they stay the same over time? Is change positive or negative? A terrorist attack that took place a short distance from the finish line of the Boston

Practical Advice: Dealing with assault, abuse, and harassment against soccer referees. Presentation written by: Steve Montanino Special Thanks to Curt Hamlin, SRA For the use of some excerpts written by

U5/U6 Player Traits -Physical Easily fatigued but with rapid recovery Body segments grow at different rates Use a movement education approach. Place an emphasis on the fundamental movement skills of: Walking,

N.I.S.L. Player Development Guide Under 8 Under 10 Created by the NISL Technical Committee for the benefit of the NISL Member Clubs I. INTRODUCTION A. Principles of coaching 1. Know who you are coaching

Surviving The Aftermath Of A Self-Defense Shooting THE experts tell you what you need to know Engaging in a self-defense shooting is likely to be the single most traumatic event of your life. Physiologically

How important is it to take a class like this and how important is it to have a gun for protection if you live in the hills? From WA state, future retiree to Panama or Costa Rica. Thank you for an honest

CBS NEWS POLL IRAQ, THE BUSH ADMINISTRATION AND THE PRISONER ABUSE REPORTS May 11, 2004 q1 Do you approve or disapprove of the way George W. Bush is handling his job as President? Apr04d % Approve 44 82

ILLEGAL KILLING OF LARGE CARNIVORES AS DEFIANCE OF AUTHORITIES PERSPECTIVES ON COMBATING ILLEGAL KILLING: THE ROLE OF HUNTERS Senior researcher Mari Pohja-Mykrä Ruralia Institute University of Helsinki

Produced by Washington Media Associates in association with the National Security Archive National Press Contact: National Security Archive Contact: Roslyn Kay Ilyse Veron Roslyn.kay@rcn.com Ilyse.veron@yahoo.com

Frequently Asked Questions Other Bars There is another bar in my area that doesn't have any league play. What can I do to get them involved? Call the League Office and we will either contact the bar ourselves,

How to Break a Terrorist: Insights from a U.S. Military Interrogator in the War on Terror An address given to the Los Angeles World Affairs Council On January 26, 2011 by Matthew Alexander Former United

South Dakota High School Activities Association October 12, 2016 Author: Buck Timmins Unsportsmanlike Conduct Most officials will answer a coach s question if it is asked in a reasonable tone of voice.

A Guide To The Muay Thai Scoring System The basic understanding of scoring at the highest and most professional levels in Muay Thai have often eluded not just fans of the art, but even the practitioners

Texas CHL Test Study Guide The written test is composed of 25 true/false and multiple choice questions. Application A person must be 21 years of age or older to apply for a concealed handgun license. A

School Sports: The Pros and Cons Written by By Raven J. Railey (Special to The Courier-Journal) Do athletics build character? Take up valuable study time? Why are some teams more popular? And what about

LEGAL DEPARTMENT Case 1:17-cv-03391-PAE Document 29 Filed 09/01/17 Page 1 of 6 September 1, 2017 BY ECF The Honorable Paul A. Engelmayer United States District Court Southern District of New York 40 Foley

For release in paper of January 18, 2004 The New York Times/CBS News Poll January 12-15, 2004 N=1,022 All trends are from New York Times/CBS News polls unless otherwise noted. An asterisk indicates registered

Catch Them Being Good: Everything You Need To Know To Successfully Coach Girls By Colleen Hacker, Tony Dicicco If you are looking for the book Catch Them Being Good: Everything You Need to Know to Successfully

Breaking Can a person with a broken arm have another person break for No. The person with the broken arm cannot have someone else break for them. They can, however, give up the break and allow the opponent

Recruiting & Retaining New Club Members by Tim Van Milligan of Apogee Components, Inc. In this article, I'd like to talk about a problem that many rocketry clubs experience; namely attracting and retaining

Major Battles of the Texas Revolution The Battle of Gonzales The Battle of the Alamo The Battle of Goliad The Battle of San Jacinto The Battle of Gonzales October 2, 1835 1st battle between the Texan colonists

NEW FOR 2017-2018 2017-2018 ADI POOL LEAGUE RULES GOOD SPORTSMANSHIP AND COMMON SENSE ARE TO BE USED TO SOLVE ANY PROBLEM NOT COVERED BY THE FOLLOWING RULES. GENERAL: PLAYERS MUST PLAY 3 WEEKS TO BE ELIGIBLE

Introduction Focus Omar Khadr is a member of one of the most notorious families in Canada. His father was an Al Qaeda lieutenant and financier, his brothers were trained at Al Qaeda militia camps in Afghanistan,

Plains Indian Wars Cheyenne & Sioux Notebook Pages "They made us many promises, more than I can remember. But they kept but one--they promised to take our land...and they took it." ~Red Cloud (pictured

Critical Bullet and Melee Hit Chart 2 Expect to be injured in our line of work. Bullet wounds can be most serious, but blade weapons can sometimes be just as deadly. This chart expands upon the previous

Making the Connection Between Gun Violence and Domestic Violence Introduction Intimate partner violence against women is all too common and takes many forms; the most serious being homicide. Domestic violence

I. Settlers Encounter the Plains Indians The government sent agents to negotiate treaties with Plains Indians 4 tribes who lived on the Plains are the. Apache, Comanche, Cheyenne, Arapaho, Pawnee, Sioux

Common Marketing Problems by William Howard Horrocks I thought it might be useful to describe a few marketing problems some of my clients have had, and how we went about solving them. My experience has

DEMOGRAPHICS OF GUANTANAMO BAY PRISON* by Janet Munro-Nelson Posted August 2008; Updated May 2011 I. THE HISTORY OF U.S. CONTROL OF GUANTANAMO BAY, CUBA The United States joined the Cubans in their war

POINTS OF EMPHASIS Faceoff player touching his own or his opponent s crosse with any part of his body Illegal tactics when defending (Cross-check/Hold) Thrusting the crosse, in particular Sideline behavior

U6 Drills At the U6 level, this is the first time for some 4 and 5 year olds to learn to play with each other and follow directions from someone other than a parent. Our goal at this level is to help them

U8 RECREATIONAL COACHING PACKET HOW TO USE THIS PACKET: Hopefully by now you have completed the Nebraska State Soccer Right Start and Online Coaching Modules. If you haven t, you can go through these free

NON-FATAL OFFENCES AGAINST THE PERSON (3) Self-Defence By the end of this unit you should be able to [AO1]: Explain what is meant by self-defence and the difference between public and private defence Understand

Analysis: Al Qaeda's interim emir and Iran By THOMAS JOSCELYN / THE LONG WAR JOURNAL / May 18, 2011 Saif al Adel Saif al Adel has been named the interim emir of al Qaeda in the wake of Osama bin Laden's

SB194 3/13/2017 The Illegal Wildlife Trade According to a 2014 UN report on environmental crime, the illegal wildlife trade of flora and fauna is estimated to be worth as much as 23 billion dollars annually.

TAMPA BAY UNITED ACADEMY PHILOSOPHY & CURRICULUM MISSION The mission of the Tampa Bay United Academy is to provide the best possible coaching and instruction for our young players to ensure proper development

December 5, 2014 An interview with: COACH NICK SABAN THE MODERATOR: We're ready to start with Coach Saban. We'll ask Coach Saban for his general thoughts on the Alabama team coming into the game and then

The International Olympic Committee (IOC) OFFERS THE FOLLOWING VIDEO NEWS RELEASE TO ALL NEWS AGENCIES, BROADCASTERS AND ALL ONLINE PLATFORMS FREE OF CHARGE. Story Headline: DECISION OF THE IOC EXECUTIVE

TRANSITION DEFENSE DRILLS 3 Absolutes for a great transition defense: Communication Hustle Improvisation ( think quick on your feet) As a coach you HATE to see the other team get a long rebound or steal

LEGAL DISCLAIMERS All contents copyright 2017 by Coach Mac. All rights reserved. No part of this document or accompanying files may be reproduced or transmitted in any form, electronic or otherwise, by

Straighten up and y right Understanding formation ying in the B-17 Flying Fortress Flying the B-17 is easy, she is a forgiving aircraft and was designed to be stable. However, ying the B-17 in formation

MISSION The mission of the league is to promote, develop, supervise and voluntarily assist the interest of youths participating in recreational soccer. The primary goal of the league is to provide a safe

ENVIRONMENTALLY FRIENDLY DIVING & SNORKELING Training for Green Fins member staff CONGRATULATIONS! We are now Green Fins members Contents About Green Fins Guidelines to the Code of Conduct Environmentally

#026: START RUNNING OR JOGGING IN ENGLISH Hi, everyone! I'm Georgiana, founder of SpeakEnglishPodcast.com. My mission is to help YOU to speak English fluently and confidently. In today's episode: I'm gonna

How to Understand Stalling It s Simple! Stalling the most interesting call in wrestling. I will tell you that unless you have a thorough knowledge of what stalling really is and how to recognize it, and

2014 ASA Umpire Exam Published and Distributed by the Amateur Softball Association USA Softball The examination consists of a series of questions covering Rules and Mechanics of the 2014 ASA Official Rule

ACES Ball Mastery! Keys to teaching ball mastery components Start slow, let players learn it at their own pace (many repetitions) If they have success ask them to perform at a faster pace After each move