Most Helpful Positive Review

This is the #1 grain-free brand for our dog and cats!!

By Thea
on Apr 11, 2019

We had been using Whole Earth Farms grain free cat food for years with great results, so when we adopted our new dog this brand was our first choice. Happy to report that the dog food is excellent too! Our sweet dog Cedar was an underweight, malnourished stray who had trouble eating consistently at theWe had been using Whole Earth Farms grain free cat food for years with great results, so when we adopted our new dog this brand was our first choice. Happy to report that the dog food is excellent too! Our sweet dog Cedar was an underweight, malnourished stray who had trouble eating consistently at the shelter. He quickly took to this food in his new home and is looking better everyday :) Great food at a great price!!… more

Most Helpful Critical Review

I wanted to love this food...

By Brix
on Apr 17, 2019

First time trying this food and wanted to love it. 2nd time feeding it and found cat food in the bag. Pretty concerning since I have a dog with a lot of allergies and I dont know what kind of cat food contaminated the bag.

12 Reviews

Showing 1-10 of 12 Reviews

Sort by:

Filter by:

I wanted to love this food...

By Brix
on Apr 17, 2019

First time trying this food and wanted to love it. 2nd time feeding it and found cat food in the bag. Pretty concerning since I have a dog with a lot of allergies and I dont know what kind of cat food contaminated the bag.

This would be an honest and I think a fair review.

By Murphey
on Jul 22, 2018

I purchased 4 bags of these for my Giant Schnauzer which is somewhat hard to please when its feeding time. Prior to this big order, I kept him on 1 flavor type (salmon) of food so as to avoid setting problems with picky-ness. My dog has always had skin issues ever since I adopted him and I've tried some of the best rated grain free dog foods out there that doesn't leave my bank feeling robbed.
This dog food, among 3 other brands that I've tried gave us the best success in dealing with my dogs skin issues. His dry skin was healed gradually within the first few weeks. On top of that, he no longer smells like a dog and his breath doesn't smell either.
Unfortunately, he isn't particularly too I purchased 4 bags of these for my Giant Schnauzer which is somewhat hard to please when its feeding time. Prior to this big order, I kept him on 1 flavor type (salmon) of food so as to avoid setting problems with picky-ness. My dog has always had skin issues ever since I adopted him and I've tried some of the best rated grain free dog foods out there that doesn't leave my bank feeling robbed.
This dog food, among 3 other brands that I've tried gave us the best success in dealing with my dogs skin issues. His dry skin was healed gradually within the first few weeks. On top of that, he no longer smells like a dog and his breath doesn't smell either.
Unfortunately, he isn't particularly too fond of the food compared to the previous brands and after the 1st 2 bags down, the 3rd and 4th bags went like he's "no longer having it" (we just opened the 4th and last bag couple days back)
Right now we're at a point where he would only eat every other day and even if I mix something up with the dog food, he'll just pick the throw in and completely disregard the kibble.
Currently in a hunt for another problem solver dog food and will likely test out small bags again like I did the first time in as few flavor profiles as possible to see which ones he'll be happy settling with. All in all, this dog food is Good but not for every one.
P.S. it does smell kinda bad comparing to the other brands… more

Texture off

By PHardy
on Oct 17, 2017

have 6 small dogs, 10 to 20 lbs.,....all rescues...very pampered...very much loved...this food is too hard for 4 of smallest ones and they did not eat it, and I could see where the two 20 pounders were having a bit of a hard time as well but did eat it.....gave away

Dogs won't eat it

By Goatgirl
on Nov 9, 2016

Well, no fault of the dog food but my Pyr and Border Collie won't eat it without it being dressed with some sauce or meat! They are terribly picky and I am trying to find a food that they like! They are farm dogs after all!

Quality but not tasty

More hay than anything, it seems

By Liz217
on Nov 1, 2016

I wanted to chose a more affordable grain-free kibble for my allergic dogs. The name of this seemed right, and the ingredients at first sight seemed alright.
I scoop my dogs' poop daily, and am use to seeing tiny little rabbit-like piles of poo. After one day of feeding this, I found 100% round hard balls the size of half an egg, that fell apart like sand when I grabbed them with the scooper.
I added more liquid to the food, thinking it just needed more moisture - but it made no difference.
Dry, sand-like poo indicates to me that there is nothing nutritional in the food.

Dogs would not eat this food

By Tawnyagirl
on Jun 10, 2014

My 3 dogs would not eat this food. When I would place it in the bowls they would smell it and walk away. The first thing I noted about this food was the odor and this obviously was a turn off to my dogs also.