This restaurant's overall star value is determined by comparing its ratings against
those of other restaurants in the same city.

A teacher might call this grading on a curve. At Seamless, this means that regardless
of their actual tally, restaurants with the highest ratings will have five stars,
those with average ratings will have three, and the not-so-favorite restaurants
will have the least number of stars.

So pay it forward to the Seamless community. Rate and review places you've tried
so we can all find food happiness!

Please check back for future deals.

Reviews for Park Avenue Pizza Cafe

This is my go to pizza place. I have tried many places in the WNY area and Park Ave definitely have the best sauce and pizza. Delivery always fast and consistent.

Written by
Michael L.
on
9/7/2014
|
4 other reviews |
Member since
2011
Michael
ordered from here
within the last month

Food Terrible!! nice delivery man
Never again

Written by
Toine J.
on
9/6/2014
|
Member since
2014
Toine
ordered from here
within the last year

I did not receive one of the items on my order worth $5.00 and they promised to take it off the receipt. The delivery guy said he will tell the management to take it off or he will come back to deliver. Neither happened. The pizza was so-so.

Written by
Richard R.
on
7/8/2014
|
2 other reviews |
Member since
2013
Richard
ordered from here
within the last year

I don't know how this place has such a high rating on yelp. Delivery took over an hour. They actually called to see if I would pick the food up. No. That's why I ordered delivery. The wings had too much breading, which was soggy, and barely any meat. The pizza tasted off. It's hard to describe. There was pizza sauce, cheese, pepperoni, onions, and crust, but the combination of those things did not taste like pizza. First and last time ordering from here.

Written by
Jose A.
on
12/14/2013
|
16 other reviews |
Member since
2009
Jose
ordered from here
over a year ago

Not great. Not terrible. I only had pizza.

Written by
Paul B.
on
8/3/2013
|
7 other reviews |
Member since
2013
Paul
ordered from here
over a year ago

Pizza and wrap were very good, as usual. Delivery was quick and friendly.

Written by
Richard R.
on
7/27/2013
|
Member since
2011
Richard
ordered from here
within the last year

Took over an hour and a half for the delivery driver to show only to have brought someone else's order. They didn't answer the phone when we called back to correct the order and we never got our food! Called all day the next day only to receive attitude and terrible customer service. No offer of trying to make the order right or re-deliver the next day.

Written by
Kadijha B.
on
5/16/2013
|
2 other reviews |
Member since
2012
Kadijha
ordered from here
over a year ago

Everyone got sick. Chicken Francese was way too salty, and that is from people that like salt. Pasta was over cooked. Shrimp Parmigiana? Could not find the shrimp. Cannoli was ok. Woudl not order again.

Written by
Caroline B.
on
4/24/2013
|
1 other review |
Member since
2013
Caroline
ordered from here
over a year ago

Reading the reviews it's apparent that the are very hit or miss! Waited just under 2 hours for my food to show up, and it was over cooked and cold.... Not too thrilled guys! You should know better!

Written by
crumbs k.
on
3/9/2013
|
3 other reviews |
Member since
2012
crumbs
ordered from here
over a year ago

It was nothing outstanding, fast delivery, OK quality. Acceptable, but not sure if I will order again before I try other places.

Written by
Pavel V.
on
1/29/2013
|
Member since
2013
Pavel
ordered from here
over a year ago

This is what we get for trying something new - we waited OVER an hour for the delivery of an ice cold pizza ($18) and Greek salad ($6), which was literally lettuce, tomato, and black olives. In most cases I can understand delivery being a little slow on a weekend (due to volume) but bad food is just down right unacceptable. Lesson learned - stick with what you know!

Written by
Sara D.
on
4/16/2012
|
5 other reviews |
Member since
2011
Sara
ordered from here
over a year ago

I really don't understand the negative reviews. Park Avenue has been my go-to pizza place for a few years now. The pizza is fantastic, and delivery is always quick. Love this place!

Written by
Tim M.
on
1/30/2012
|
1 other review |
Member since
2011
Tim
ordered from here
within the last year

The salad which I ordered without dressing came with dressing on it and the salad was wilted.

Written by
Wendy M.
on
10/27/2011
|
1 other review |
Member since
2006
Wendy
ordered from here
over a year ago

This is for the calamari...the pizza was excellent. The calamari was tasteless and like rubber, very disappointing.

Written by
Dawn A.
on
2/28/2011
|
Member since
2010
Dawn
ordered from here
over a year ago

Overall a good experience, the delivery was fast and the rolls were of an excellent size. I do wish there was a bit more marinara sent out with it, but I'll know to get an extra or two next time. The only thing taking away from the full 5* rating is that I am not a huge fan of the specific sausage they use, but the stromboli was excellent and I'll get a pepperoni roll next time.
Value: 5/5
Speed: 4/5
Flavor: 4/5

Written by
Brian T.
on
9/15/2010
|
11 other reviews |
Member since
2010
Brian
ordered from here
over a year ago