izithemes said
I agree with you, but what’s the standard?
I have a rejected theme, some (many) people like it and say “awesome”, but the reviewer say “no”, so what’s the important? peoples feeling or reviewers feeling ?

Look at current approvals, that’s the standard. What are they doing better than you? What could you do better to yours?

Scott

On “other marketplace” (I can’t put link here, you can google with my information), my themes sale better than Peerapong’s themes (a popular TF author, sorry if I’m not allowed say this) but on TF, I can not.

And? That means nothing.

Hey, I mean, may be my theme come fit to standard but because I’m newbie here and it’s not aprroved. is it clear?

I think the most important thing to understand in this situation is that it’s not the reviewers responsibility to give us feedback on our designs. Their only job is to approve or deny submissions based on the (very high) marketplace standards. If you do get feedback on your design, which many times you will if you politely ask for them to take some extra time for it, then it’s a bonus. They’re not here to mold us into designers nor are they here to hold our hands during the process of getting an item approved.

Just be honest with yourself, continue to learn, and try not to get too frustrated during the process. Trust me that it’ll make you a better designer which will in turn bring you more sale.

The main issue with the review process is that the submitter is not getting the feedback he need to
start redesigning his work so he can be approved, he’s only getting some standard text, from where
he doesn’t even know where to start. Specially with people like myself, who are more PHP programmers then designers., this is a big issue..

In my opinion, the easiest way TF can overcome this issue is to hire dedicated people, who can
properly review rejected themes/pds’s etc… and give detailed feedback. Of course this service can
be made available to the public for a certain amount of $$$. There can be options, to get your
design reviewed, or your code, etc…

I know I will pay a fee to get a proper detailed feedback and finally get my first theme approved on TF.

kailoon said@mafloral
This look great, I think you can resubmit and state that the design is OK by kailoon. I think we should give this a try.

But I also agree with Sid, I’d recommend you try to refine and double check the details such as spacing, typography and alignment before doing so. Nothing major, just some minor adjustments.

Hey Kailoon

I am actually working on the spacing issues and the typography so maybe later on today i will re-submit the template. As for Scott getting the badge i agree he pointed out some valid mistakes that i made and honestly i loved his feedback. Also i am glad you like the file and as i said i will do all my best to have it finished and uploaded again.

@izithemes
Good start, but I think it lacks of uniqueness. Further, there are many aspects need improvements. The current design, element placements, balance of white space failed express the concept or make it stand out as a premium theme.

kailoon said
@izithemes
Good start, but I think it lacks of uniqueness. Further, there are many aspects need improvements. The current design, element placements, balance of white space failed express the concept or make it stand out as a premium theme.

Thanks Kailoon but I have a question: I continue improve this theme and will be accepted or never (because it lacks of uniqueness, you said) ?

kailoon said
@izithemes
Good start, but I think it lacks of uniqueness. Further, there are many aspects need improvements. The current design, element placements, balance of white space failed express the concept or make it stand out as a premium theme.

Thanks Kailoon but I have a question: I continue improve this theme and will be accepted or never (because it lacks of uniqueness, you said) ?

Post Reply

<strong></strong> to make things bold
<em></em> to emphasize
<ul><li> or <ol><li> to make lists
<h3> or <h4> to make headings
<pre></pre> for code blocks
<code></code> for a few words of code
<a></a> for links
<img> to paste in an image (it'll need to be hosted somewhere else though)
<blockquote></blockquote> to quote somebody