Canon PIXMA MG5150 inkjet multifunction printer

This mid-range PIXMA multifunction device prints slowly, but it is a cheap way to produce monochrome documents

Expert Rating

3.50/5

Pros

Cheap monochrome printing, costs less than the PIXMA MG5250 but offers similar features

Cons

Slow printing, mediocre document and photo scanning quality

Bottom Line

The Canon PIXMA MG5150 is a mid-range inkjet multifunction printer that is a good choice for anyone looking to print monochrome documents on a low budget. It's not a fast printer and its scan quality is average at best, but if price is a concern the PIXMA MG5150 acquits itself well.

Would you buy this?

Price

Canon's PIXMA MG5150 is a mid-level inkjet multifunction printer that sits below the Canon PIXMA MG5250 in the company's line-up. It is $50 cheaper than the MG5250; the MG5150 has a lower resolution scanner, no Wi-Fi and prints slower than the more expensive multifunction. If you're not worried about these constraints, the Canon PIXMA MG5150 is a good option for printing monochrome and occasional colour documents.

Canon PIXMA MG5150: Design, connectivity and setup

The Canon PIXMA MG5150 mirrors the PIXMA MG5250's design, with a rear-loading 150-sheet tray and a 150-sheet cassette. It has the same clear and bright 2.4in LCD that we liked on its more expensive counterpart, as well as the same basic button layout. It's easy to install the print head and the five ink cartridges, and connecting the printer to your PC or Mac via the USB 2.0 port is easy.

As well as the rear USB 2.0 port the Canon PIXMA MG5150 also has a front host port for PictBridge-enabled camera connection, as well as Bluetooth 2.0 for sending content from a mobile phone.

The main downside of choosing the Canon PIXMA MG5150 over the more expensive PIXMA MG5250 is its lower resolution scanner. You only get a 1200x2400dpi flatbed scanner as opposed to a 4800x2400dpi unit. Scans are acceptable but fine image detail is missing — choose a better scanner if you're intending to digitise old photos or important documents.

Canon PIXMA MG5150: Print quality and speed

The Canon PIXMA MG5150 uses the same print head and technology as the Canon PIXMA MG5250, so its output quality is essentially identical. Monochrome documents in Standard quality are smooth and clear despite being slightly under-saturated. If you want bold, solid text the High quality setting serves perfectly — although printing is slightly slower. Colour documents in Standard quality are equally as good as monochrome prints. We would have preferred slightly more saturation but font edges are smooth and prints are easily legible down to 6pt size.

Like the Canon PIXMA MG5250, the PIXMA MG5150 produces good results when printing high resolution images on photo paper. In High quality mode on Canon's Photo Paper Plus Glossy II stock we found our colour test images to be clear and detailed, with good saturation levels and no visible posterisation. The Canon PIXMA MG5150 also impressed us when it came to producing greyscale images, with only a small amount of banding and graininess visible in images' darker areas.

One area where the Canon PIXMA MG5150 falters is in its print speeds. The PIXMA MG5250 can manage 11 monochrome pages per minute — one sheet per six seconds in our testing — while the PIXMA MG5150 takes around seven seconds on average per monochrome A4 page. This is only slightly slower per sheet, with an overall speed of 9.7 pages per minute. Colour printing is significantly slower, though — the PIXMA MG5250 manages 9.3 pages per minute while the PIXMA MG5150 can only output 6.3.

The five individual ink tanks of the Canon PIXMA MG5150 — PGI-525BK black, CLI-526BK photo black, CLI-526C cyan, CLI-526M magenta and CLI-526Y yellow — cost $119.75 if you're buying at the recommended retail prices. Canon quotes a combined average yield of 496 prints from the colour cartridges, with an ongoing consumable cost of 4.14 cents per A4 colour page. However, it's important to note that because it uses individual colour cartridges you can replace a single empty tank when necessary, instead of replacing a whole tri-colour cartridge (as used on cheaper printers like the Canon PIXMA MP495).

The Canon PIXMA MG5150's black ink tank has a significantly higher yield than the colour cartridges, with a quoted 4335 standard A4 document prints per $23.95 refill. This translates into a very low running cost of 0.55c per A4 sheet.

The power consumption of the Canon PIXMA MG5150 is entirely reasonable. In standby it consumed an average of 1.9 Watts, while maximum power usage of 21W was achieved while photocopying a colour document. You're unlikely to notice the Canon PIXMA MG5150's impact on your power bill. Canon places a heavy emphasis on environmental responsibility for its consumer printer range, with a dedicated section of its Web site educating consumers about PIXMA printers' green credentials.

If you're not concerned about mediocre scan quality or somewhat slow printing, the Canon PIXMA MG5150 is an excellent choice for printing documents and occasional photos on a budget.

I need power and lots of it. As a Front End Web developer anything less just won’t cut it which is why the MSI GT75 is an outstanding laptop for me. It’s a sleek and futuristic looking, high quality, beast that has a touch of sci-fi flare about it.

Reproduction in whole or in part in any form or medium without express written permission of IDG Communications is prohibited. Copyright 2013 IDG Communications.
ABN 14 001 592 650. All rights reserved.