Apparently T-Swift is a big James Taylor fan. She even goes into detail on how her parents named her after the folk rock singer-songwriter. And since Madison Square Garden is just full of magic (Except for the Knicks in ’95… DUNK it, Ewing!), James Taylor strolled on stage and joined Miss Swift on what looks to be a very comfortable couch.

Watch the Taylor’s perform “Fire and Rain”

Luckily, the tweens in attendance have no idea who James Taylor is, so you can actually hear the performance once their random screams die down.

If you want to watch T-Swift’s story time in addition to the performance of “Fire and Rain” and Swift’s own track “Fifteen,” the video is below.