Jack Carson — Why Isn’t He Remembered More Often?

He was one of the first of the character actors turned into leading man. He was big. He was brassy. He could sing, dance and act.

Hello, everybody. Joe Morella and Frank Segers, your classic movie guys, here to say that if the guy pictured above reminds you of a velvet-tongued used-car salesman, you have hit upon JackCarson’s professional appeal as an actor.

Who can forget his amiably sleazy businessman turn as “Wally Fay” — his finest role — in the 1945 version of Mildred Pierce.

That classic showcased Carson as a star going toe-to-toe with Joan Crawford. Savor the movie’s early scenes in which Crawford as Mildred plays on the libidinous designs of Carson as Fay to set him up for the murder of of her husband.

A mixture of breezy self-regard, delusion, naivete, gullibility and an almost comic sense of danger, Carson is nothing short of delightful. Then why isn’t he remembered more often as the superb talent that he was? We have some theories.

— For one thing, he didn’t live long. His movie career began as an extra at RKO in 1937 when Carson was in his late Twenties. At the age of 52, some 120 mostly undistinguished movie and tv roles later, the once hard drinking, six-feet-two-inch actor died of stomach cancer.

— Carson did not present himself as strictly a dramatic actor. He was a proud song-and-dance man, who once toured the vaudeville circuit with his first wife, Betty Alice Lindy, a dancer. And much of his best movie work can be found in comedies, a genre that somehow continues to be largely ignored by oh-so-serious critics and scholars.

— Carson would do kooky things from a strictly professional standpoint. He used to disappear from Hollywood for weeks on end, with strict instructions to his wife NOT to disclose his whereabouts. Turns out he was touring incognito as a clown in a traveling circus.

— Of his many movie titles, only a few stand out. There’s Mildred Pierce, of course. He puts in a solid dramatic turn in George Cukor’sA Star Is Born with JudyGarland. Ditto in 1958’s Cat on a Hot Tin Roof with Paul Newman. Then there is FrankCapra’sArsenic and Old Lace with Cary Grant. He also worked with Bob Hope and Bing Crosby.(If you have a favorite Jack Carson movie, we’d love to hear about it.)

— In some respects, Carson is best recalled today for his many tv and radio appearances. His Everybody Loves Jack series on radio was a hit. On the tube, he appeared in a host of specials and series from Bonanza through the U.S. Steel Hour to Walt Disney’s Wonderful World of Color. Stars aren’t suppose to be quite that commercially versatile.

We don’t think Carson has ever received his due from classic movie scholars. No big biographies, no earnest reference write-ups. But we remember and honor his work.

5 Comments

Great talent in a supporting way; I can’t remember the title, but Carson was a vaudeville hoofer/comedian type with Dennis Morgan whose wife/love interest was lovely Joan Leslie. Only her sister, played brilliantly and with bite by Ida Lupino, had other ideas. Carson’s sad ending sticks in my mind as he was very compelling as the broken-hearted sop who couldn’t live without his gal…

One of the “big guys” like Ward Bond & Ralph Bellamy, Jack Carson was such a likeable guy. He brought legitimacy to anything he did. He was a supporting actor early on but whatever part he played you wanted to see more. I remember him first in Destry Rides Again. (You guys are on fire this week!)
Jack was on par with such greats as Eugene Pallette, Ed Brophy, Allen Jenkins & Frank Mchugh… and was a loved co-star by all the major stars.

He’s always worth remembering and worth watching. I was watching his Twilight Zone episode (The Whole Truth) on the set at the local laundromat. The laundromat crowd can be tough – somebody always wants to switch to Springer or some such, but Carson held them spellbound.