Peyton plays in the toughest division.
His team has no defense.
The Broncos offensive line and skill positions have been decimated by injuries.
His team has the best record in football.
He has the most passing yards, touchdowns and fewest interceptions._________________

Uncle Buck wrote:

Viking fans are VERY happy to see the end of the very successful Favre era, and we gleefully usher in the Rodgers era.

Peyton plays in the toughest division.
His team has no defense.
The Broncos offensive line and skill positions have been decimated by injuries.
His team has the best record in football.
He has the most passing yards, touchdowns and fewest interceptions.

I'm assuming this is sarcasm.

The only reason is the return from injury + new team story hype. The media loves the story and has been selling it so hard all season, most people believe it. Personally I'd have him no higher than 4th. I'd put Rodgers, Brady, Peterson, and then Manning/Ryan._________________

Wilfred wrote:

Memory is like the Packers when they are behind by two touchdowns in the 4th quarter... It comes back.

Exactly! I like Brady, Rodgers and Ryan before Peyton. His comeback from injury recognition should have nothing to do with MVP.
He plays in one of the easiest divisions
His team went to playoffs last year so they already had talent
He has a great defense
All the above points would be mute if he had the best QB stats but he doesn't

Peyton plays in the toughest division.
His team has no defense.
The Broncos offensive line and skill positions have been decimated by injuries.
His team has the best record in football.
He has the most passing yards, touchdowns and fewest interceptions.

well this thread just got boring. you couldn't leave one of those bullet points for someone else._________________