There are few movers, just the worst of 2008 and 2009 plus the average 2009 go down one point. 2010 is added but in brackets as the wines are not finished and delivered – those points awarded will be unchanged until this time next year.

Hi Will
I have had a few private notes about poor shape 06s but clearly they have no statistical relevance, so I am simply, applying a time-based rule.

Regarding 2005, I have heard and experienced little in the way of problems so perhaps this vintage is a little more robust? Again my experience is likely to to be irrelevant from a statistical perspective – but in this case I went with gut feeling.
Hope that helps
Bill