DesertPenguin wrote:Pens either need a 3rd line RW to make that line harder to play against, or a new RW for Crosby so Dupuis can move down and fill that role. I'm not sure what to do about the 4th line, but that group has not been effective for us. I like Jeffrey as a player, but Vitale is a better fit for the 4th line. Id rather see DJ take Adams' spot than Vitale's.

Why is Dupuis a problem?

He doesn't say Dupuis is a problem. He's saying Dupuis is probably a better option for the 3rd line than anyone out there if we did get someone to plug in with sid and kunitz. Not that we need someone other than Dupuis, but I agree with the premise of the unspoken.

Bingo. I'm perfectly fine with Dupuis playing with Sid. However, if we did get a guy like Iginla as has been speculated, I'd put Dupuis on the 3rd line and instantly upgrade that group. The 3rd line needs a shot in the arm.

i dont think they need a guerin. they have enough vets with rings to fill that role multiple times over. i think they need some discipline on the blueline, and thats about it. someone teach them how to clear the crease please.

Not sure if the Cats would be willing to deal, but a guy I'd love to see on the pens 4th line is Jerred Smithson. He kind of like what I always hoped KV would at the very least develop into...but never did.

I honestly think that they need an upgrade for two bottom six forwards and a defensemen (though Eaton had performed admirably).

You can either shift Kennedy down a line or ship him off as a part of a deal, but that 3rd line is not doing it for me.Get Adams out of the lineup. Glass might not be what people were expecting, but at least he's not 97.

newarenanow wrote:IMO, they need an upgrade in the bottom 6 and/or a more physicsl shutdown Dman.

The first one they should easily upgrade. The second one, it will be tough to find the right balance of someone who you can get for more than a rental with what they will probably have to give up.

If Calgary and San Jose decide to sell at all...

Sarich or Murray. Murray would be better, but he's a pending UFA and would most likely return west. Sarich is older, not nearly as physical as Murray, but no slouch in the crease either. He has one year remaining at a $2,000,000 cap hit.

I'm thinking a lot of the issues are with puck possession. Sustained forecheck and cycling by the bottom six seem to be problematic, so that's where I would look to improve. A good role player with speed who can cycle.

As we all know, you don't give up goals when you play hard in the offensive zone. Sustained pressure leads to PP opportunities and so on.

DesertPenguin wrote:Bingo. I'm perfectly fine with Dupuis playing with Sid. However, if we did get a guy like Iginla as has been speculated, I'd put Dupuis on the 3rd line and instantly upgrade that group. The 3rd line needs a shot in the arm.

I disagree. Even if management did something crazy like trade a meaningful asset for someone like Iginla, Dupuis is not the guy the 3rd line needs. The bottom six need more true grinders with size, some speed, and an edgy game--at the cost of skill.

But the most pressing need imo is a solid defenseman. Someone who plays like Orpik. That's where the best trade asset should go.

Kaizer wrote:i dont think they need a guerin. they have enough vets with rings to fill that role multiple times over. i think they need some discipline on the blueline, and thats about it. someone teach them how to clear the crease please.

They still lose too many individual battles along the boards against tougher teams. This is what Guerin excelled at- especially transitioning out of the zone, taking a hit and getting the puck to Sid at speed. And he was able to do this against anyone. Our current wingers are good, but not in this area per se.

We don't need offence but a bottom 6 defensive forward that can make us tougher, that can play spot duty with Malkin and Neal in the playoffs. Kinda like a Talbot did would help. A stay at home physical guy to match up vs other teams top lines would help.

We are a cup contender we should approach the deadline with that mind set. Sids line is set and playing great. Malkin and Neal with Bennett is getting better. I just worry if we play vs Philly or Boston in the playoffs that you got a good defensive guy with physical play that can play on that line. I know its a tall order and i really can't think of a player who can fit there but i would think Shero can. From what you guys talk about Clowe he might fit this player. He also can play a 3rd line roll better than Kennedy.

I've been clammoring for better wingers for Crosby for 2 years. Dupuis and Kunitz are making me see the light this year. Those two are fine remaining on the first line. We need a defensive d-man, size and defense for 3rd/4th lines.

Defense/2nd line - Smid and Ryan Jones for Harrington, Kennedy, and a pick3rd line- Ott for Niskanen, mid-level prospect/pick4th line - Jerred Smithson/Jack Skille from FL for a late round pick

Pens players going back the other way maybe altered to some degree (not my strong point assessing value), but I those three trades would help a lot. I'd remove Jones from Smid trade for Harrington and mid-pick if there was another option looked at. Smid brings help as defensive d-man, hits, blocks shots, plays PK. Jones is a bit more physical, been injured this year (eye) but has put up decent numbers past two years and has potential. I like Ott for his size and versatility, PK, hits. Smithson is a big guy, kills penalties, hits, and doesn't take a lot of penalties in return (8PIM in 24 games, 6-3 height, 59 hits). Skille is a bit smaller but serves same role (and wife/GF is from Pittsburgh)

I have concerns about Bennett being an every game player in the playoffs this year, which is why I'd like to see them pickup a player like Jones or another scorer for 2nd line, with Bennett and Jeffrey to help if injuries come about.

Calgary, Edmonton, Buffalo, Florida, Columbus, maybe Washington are going to be main sellers this year. Guys like Corey Perry, Daniel Alfredsson, Gonchar, etc, that may be UFA but on good teams, I don't see as being very available, or price may be high.

Kaizer wrote:i dont think they need a guerin. they have enough vets with rings to fill that role multiple times over. i think they need some discipline on the blueline, and thats about it. someone teach them how to clear the crease please.

They still lose too many individual battles along the boards against tougher teams. This is what Guerin excelled at- especially transitioning out of the zone, taking a hit and getting the puck to Sid at speed. And he was able to do this against anyone. Our current wingers are good, but not in this area per se.

Maybe they need more rightys playign rw and lefties playing lw. Though sacrificing uptempo offense is really counter to their current goals.