MattV wrote:MacGuyvers only as good as the stuff he has around him, he's not much of a fighter unless he's got some gaff tape, pipe cleaners, a metal tube and a packet of baking soda

It is unlikely that Macguyver would end up fighting someone in a completely barren environment.

1) There are few such environments where there is absoloutely nothing.2) Such environments make bad telly, so why would Macguyver go there? He's far more likely to stay around large magnetically-sealed doors, lasers, bits of broken metal, folding chairs, magnafying glasses etc.3) MacGuyver is too clever to get into a situation where he'd have to rely on his fighting alone to keep himself safe.4) MacGuyver isn't a bad fighter, he just doesn't like fighting too much. Prefers to solve his problems with his brain than with his fists.

He'd be a pretty good match for Indiana Jones I believe. But could he stand up to Jack Bauer? For that matter, could anyone?