Paying by the minute at a coffeehouse

How should a cafe price? After all, most users are actually consuming multiple things at a coffeehouse. Yes, they are getting a jolt of caffeine and maybe a muffin, but they are also consuming a meeting space or a workspace. Indeed, that space may be more important to some customers if getting together with a friend or finding a place with WIFI is more the point of the visit than having a coffee.

Welcome to Tsiferblat in Moscow. It’s one of two in the city, and in English, it would be known as the Clockface Cafe.

When you enter, Polina Poliakova leads you to a cabinet filled with defunct alarm clocks. “When you come to Tsiferblat, first what you should do is take the clock,” she says, explaining what she calls “the ritual.”

So you choose a sturdy Soviet model and Poliakova notes your time of arrival. …

Clockface is the brainchild of Ivan Meetin, a 28-year-old who got started in the business by experimenting with a cafe that ran solely on donations.

Clockface is different, he says. “You don’t have to pay for coffee or tea or cookies,” Meetin says. “You should pay for time, and time costs — I hope — [are] not that expensive.” …

You pay two rubles a minute for the first hour — slightly less than $4 an hour — and then one ruble per minute for the time beyond that. Any time after five hours is free — so you can never spend more than about $12 per person.

Why does this interest me? Because it gets to one of the basic examples I use in my Service Operations class. As I have posted about before, one of the challenges in many service businesses is how you will charge your customers. In many service settings, the cost of providing a service depends on choices customers make after they have contract with the firm. You and I can have the same Internet service provider and pay the same monthly fees. However, if one of us is a serious movie junkie and is streaming videos every night, then the costs we impose on the system differ. A Starbucks is no different. If you get your coffee to go while I camp out to write a blog post, I am using more resources and may, in fact, have paid less than you if I bought a smaller drink.

That’s what makes Tsiferblat so interesting. It basically turns the Starbucks model on its head by, effectively, charging for fat leather chairs instead of coffee. For this to work, it has to be unappealing to wolf down one’s drink and food and go or to pig out on the cafe’s offerings. Said another way, bundling is always going to offer an above average deal to some customers. The novel writer at Starbucks gets a real break relative to renting an office but the to-go customer is overcharged. Those are reversed at Tsiferblat. Simply refusing to offer to go cups might slow down people enough that they at least break even on people who just want coffee and not ambiance and camaraderie. As for those who act like hogs at the trough, there may be a limit to how much coffee one can drink before feeling ill. If not, those that routinely abuse the system can be refused service.

Now is this a better way to price the service? That can’t be universally true. Just think how many commuters and business workers will zip through a well-located cafe on a weekday morning. That’s just a good business and that demand would evaporate if the firm switched to a pay-by-the-minute model. However, when I think of the independent coffeeshops in Evanston with undergraduates camped out for hours, this seems like an opportunity.

Share this post:

Like this:

Related

4 Responses

This reminds me of a concept in Seoul, Korea which is a “Board Game Cafe”. With these you sit down and can borrow from a library of games and are charged by the hour for the use of space and materials. These work in Seoul because of the density, the lack of space for game night in apartments, and the high cost of board games (~$40-$50).

Hello there, I found your site by means of Google whilst looking for a similar topic,
your site came up, it looks great. I’ve bookmarked it in my google bookmarks.
Hello there, just turned into alert to your blog via Google, and found that it is really informative. I’m gonna watch
out for brussels. I’ll appreciate if you happen to continue this in future. Lots of other folks will likely be benefited out of your writing. Cheers!

Hi! I just wanted to ask if you ever have any issues
with hackers? My last blog (wordpress) was hacked and I ended up losing months of hard work due to
no data backup. Do you have any solutions to protect against hackers?