Pages

Thursday, October 6, 2016

Marie Antoinette, Phantom Queen Review

[A review copy of this book was provided to me by the publisher]

Marie Antoinette, Phantom Queen is a somber, ghostly tale that
weaves together the tragic end of Marie Antoinette with the life of a
widowed painter in 1930s Paris. The book, written and illustrated by
Rodolphe and Annie Goetzinger, was originally published in French
several years ago; this year, NBM has released an English edition with a
translation by Peter Russella. According to the forward by Rodolphe,
the pair originally intended to adapt the Moberly–Jourdain incident into
comic form, before deciding on an original story.

The story as presented is straightforward, which helps the narrative flow easily from panel to panel. Maud is a recently widowed painter living in Paris in the 1930s, who is attempting to hone her talents as an artist while fending off the advances of her stepson, who is all too keen to get his hands on the vast sums his elderly father left his young wife. While painting at the Petit Trianon, Maud's little dog runs away--only to find himself in a time slip, as he stumbles on a gathering held by Marie Antoinette and her companions, who are being told that a mob is marching on Versailles and they must flee to the palace for safety. Maud, whose visit to the Petit Trianon sparks a previously unawakened connection to the spirit world, finds herself enlisted by the ghost of Marie Antoinette to find her remains and bury them, so that her soul can finally rest at peace.

The few twists in the story aren't exactly unexpected if you are familiar with this type of classic ghost narrative, and the story lacks a real antagonist since the attempts of Maud's sleazy stepson to get her money (through marriage, murder, or commitment to a mental asylum) never pose a serious threat. But a good story doesn't always have to be a complicated or difficult one, and Marie Antoinette, Phantom Queen shines as a simple, somber narrative that plunges readers into a tragic tale and then takes them exactly where they want to go in the end. It's the perfect read for a quiet afternoon or morning, when you can take the time to savor the illustrations and the comic's quieter moments, particularly the last few panels.

The illustrations by Annie Goetzinger for the book have to be singled out: they are truly exquisite, and will stay with you long after you've finished reading. I've found myself flipping through the pages again and again to admire the work, and I always seem to find a new detail to gush over. The depiction of Marie Antoinette's ghost, as well as the nightmares of her final days in captivity, are especially memorable. The soft, dreamy colors are perfectly suited to the ghostly story line, and combined with the artist's great eye for color and mood, they give the comic a dreamlike quality. I would recommend Marie Antoinette, Phantom Queen to anyone with an interest in Marie Antoinette, classic style ghost stories or anyone who is looking for a beautifully illustrated story with an eerie undercurrent of the supernatural.

Visitors to Versailles: From Louis XIV to the French Revolution by Daniëlle O. Kisluk-Grosheide and Bertrand Rondot [April 2018]Enchanted Islands: Picturing the Allure of Conquest in Eighteenth-Century France by Mary D. Sheriff [April 2018]The Little Book of Versailles by Dominique Foufelle [May 2018]

A Genealogy of Terror in Eighteenth-Century France by Ronald Schechter [June 2018]The Culture of French Revolutionary Diplomacy: In the Face of Europe by Linda Frey and Marsha Frey [June 2018]

Robespierre and the Festival of the Supreme Being: The search for a republican morality by Jonathan Smyth [June 2018]Marie Antoinette at Petit Trianon: Heritage Interpretation and Visitor Perceptions by Denise Maior-Barron [July 2018]

The Routledge Companion to the French Revolution in World History edited by Alan Forrest [July 2018]

In the Red and in the Black: Debt, Dishonor, and the Law in France between Revolutions by Erika Vause [October 2018]Versailles by Colin Jones [November 2018]

About Me

I am a history loving writer who enjoys reading and blogging in my spare time. I currently run three blogs: Reading Treasure, a blog dedicated to books and more about Marie Antoinette and 18th century France; Treasure for Your Pleasure, a Tumblr microblog dedicated to Marie Antoinette and her world; and my newest blog, Inviting History, a book blog dedicated to unique and overlooked history books.

Contact

If you need to contact me with any questions or comments or if you'd just like to chat, please feel free to do so at my email: vivelaqueen[@]yahoo.com.

Review Policy

I am more than happy to consider reviewing books that are relevant to any of my blogs and interests. This includes non-fiction books which represent a unique, overlooked or niche point of view as well as fiction or non-fiction about Marie Antoinette, the French Revolution, and 18th century France. If you are interested in having a book reviewed, please contact me at the email above.