Mohammed Yousuf/Yousuf Youhana

Clearly this bloke has an immense amount of talent, and is scoring an incredible amount of runs at the moment, but how good do you think he could have been, had he made the scores like this through-out his career? On the level or Dravid, Ponting, Inzamam and Hayden etc.

I think he'll be one of the excellent players for our time by the end of his career but I doubt he'll be an all-time great though. Even though we don't have any, batsmen who average above 50 aren't nearly as rare as they used to be.

A True Champion - Bob. Rest in peace. 15/04/06"People today have too big a devil and too small a God"
- Stephen Currie"The Lord is my light and my salvation; whom shall I fear? The Lord is the strength of my life; of whom shall I be afraid?" Psalm 27:1

He will never be considered as a great batsman until he rights his poor record against Australia, Sri Lanka and South Africa who he has failed against so far. Take away the runs he scored against Bangladesh and Zimbabwe and it probably reflects how good he is.

Simply because he hasn't been consistent enough aganst tough opposition on tough wickets, he'll be rated as a great but not an all-time great. No point in assessing how good he would have been if he had scored like this all his career, because he didn't.

He will never be considered as a great batsman until he rights his poor record against Australia, Sri Lanka and South Africa who he has failed against so far. Take away the runs he scored against Bangladesh and Zimbabwe and it probably reflects how good he is.

I often wonder why we don't have same standards for people like Warne and Ponting who have struggled against India as well.

But i do agree with you until he proves himself in bouncy pitches, he won't be considered great.. i doubt he'll be considered a great batsman, a very good batsman but not great,

Very good batsman for mine. If he keeps scoring runs at this rate, I don't know how he can be ignored when it comes time to list some of the "great" batsmen of this era. Will probably be on the fringe of first tier batsmen in this decade by the end of his career.

He's been averaging over 80 since the change of religion...taken his average from ~47 to ~54.

Whoa, thats phenomenal and he's already clocked up 1200 runs this year. If we can grit out some centuries against tough opposition on tough wickets he'll defintely be up there in the Dravid, Kallis range.

Maybe we should make the Indian batting lineup convert religion - aside from Kaif obviously

Whoa, thats phenomenal and he's already clocked up 1200 runs this year. If we can grit out some centuries against tough opposition on tough wickets he'll defintely be up there in the Dravid, Kallis range.

Maybe we should make the Indian batting lineup convert religion - aside from Kaif obviously

Get a Indian bowler to change their religion instead....we already have good enough batsman.