I have this in Moka. It's a super pretty colour but it's hard to apply, very dry and it tugs. I also have the feeling that when I am wearing it that my eyelids are sticking to my upper lid skin. It's really weird. I also find these hard to sharpen as it breaks and the eyeshadow inside seems to be too small for the outer pencil casing. I don't think I'll continue to use this or repurchase.

I have this product in brown and It's great to use as an eye base when you are in a rush. It stays right through my work day (I leave at 7am and don't get home till 6pm or later). Great if you don't want to re-apply makeup throughout the day. I will definitely be buying more of these. A negative is that I hate sharpening products.. I'd rather if it were a twist up product :)

I have tried this only in Moka Mirage but I can tell I am going to love these! Annabelle has yet to disappoint me. These are creamy, luxurious, glide-on chubby pencils, and pretty longwearing, about 7 or 8 hours. They're perfect for an eyeshadow base, a wash of colour for the lid, and they are a great size if you wanted to sweep them in the crease. I use mine for my lower lid; Moka Mirage is a really pretty duotoned silver/beige colour (comes off a champagne taupe) and it looks so gorgeous under there I include it in my look every day! Hoping they will come out with more neutral Smoothies, I can't wait to try more

I love these!! Annabelle has got to be one of my favorite drugstore brands. These smoothie eyeshadow pencils stay put really well, applies great and are quite cute. Decent colors as well but wish they had a white one! Yah will be buying again.

have the geeen one and the bright ocean blue and I love those BUT I hate grapefull! I am done with eyeliners and cream shadows that are purple.I have yet to find one that doesn't go on patchy I had hope since the others were so great that this one would be different but it wasn't.

I really would give these a try super smooth and creamy and crazy pigmrnted.This is a pretty color just because it's patchy requires more work to get it to go on evenly than the other colors.All of the shades that I have that have a real nice shimmer to them.

I would not repurchase the purple but the other two colors I would a million times over

I now have three of these: Moka Mirage, a purple one and a darker chocolaty brown one and I must say, I am very impressed with all three.I've been using the purple one as a wash under my taupey eyeshadows to give them a pop of plum and the dark brown one to give my bronzey smokey eyes a kick.I just purchased Moka Mirage and I think this one is going to be my favorite, it's kind of a taupe/champagne with some lavender in it. LOVE!They last all day, do not crease and are buildable.