I understand what you are saying, but please understand this (and why "us skeptics" take issues with ME):

It is ALL based on "He Said/ She Said".

There is absolutely no physical proof at all, or supporting evidence.

That's why ME can not even be a "Theory". It can only be "High Speculation"

In ages past, many things in science that were speculated about and eventually became fact or accepted theory, did so because of supporting physical
or observational evidence and/or proof.

For now ME has none of that. It is completely and totally based on nothing but the faith of those who believe in it.

Maybe down the road some sort of physical proof will present itself that can not be explained in any other way.

Until then however, people who believe in ME should not be appalled at those who do not believe in it. That would be the same thing as being upset at
those who do not believe in the same religion as someone else.

originally posted by: Lysergic
So if ME is real, then that must mean Déjà vu must be the realest experience, riiiiight.???

Déjà vu experiences that are unusually prolonged or frequent, or in association with other symptoms such as hallucinations, may be an indicator
of neurological or psychiatric illness

Imagine a 10 minute long Déjà vu trip.

This ME seems so familiar....

I believe those are different.

You should rely less on your beliefs.

Let's apply occam's razor here. The simplest solution is usually correct. What is more likely, especially in regards to physics? You remembering
something wrong, or you physically shifting to an entirely new dimension of reality.

let me try and use logic here, why are our brains immune from change when everything else changes. if everything changed wouldn't your thoughts as
well? you get some real paradox going on here because obviously people can't change an event after the fact (the fact being the current timeline ie
universe), its either done before or at the time. say it was "luke i am your father" i saw the movie and remember it this way. some other timeliner
has come and changed it to "no luke i am your father" guess what i still would have herd "no luke i am your father" and it would always be that way to
me, remember i never herd that line... everyone who herd it would always hear "no luke i am your father" assuming that was what it was changed to.
when you change something everything is updated immediately to reflect that change.

assuming different universes exist, im from time line A and go back to timeline B. i kill timeline B "me" 10 years before i would have naturally died.
everybody in timeline B would live from that point on in a different world where i died 10 years before, you would never remember me dying when i was
suppose to because it never happened, your world would be updated to reflect that.

lets say timeline A saves Timeline B "me" from dying when i was naturally suppose to die, how would you remember me dying when it never happened, why
wouldn't your mind be updated with the rest of the universe?

the problem with multiverse is that everything is happening and nothing is happening, all this exist and yet nothing exist. in a universe where
nothing exist its proven wrong because in our universe something exist.

originally posted by: jgarc028
the problem with multiverse is that everything is happening and nothing is happening, all this exist and yet nothing exist. in a universe where
nothing exist its proven wrong because in our universe something exist.

No, in all universes something is haoppening. Then something causes them to start overlapping. maybe one, maybe all.

Alright, I may be incorrect but if I understand the gist of this theory, it is that people are shifting from one timeline to another. In one timeline,
life is like a box of chocolates. In another, life was like a box of chocolates. Alright, so suspending my disbelief, we have established at least two
realities.

So if you come from the reality where the line was, "Life was like a box of chocolates" but find yourself in ours, where the line is different,
what the hell happened to the version of you in this reality? Did they shift into the reality you came from (swapping places essentially) or
shift into a third, or fourth reality? Are there only two realities?

As for the multiverse.. more than two realities. So does the shifting compound, ad infinitum? As one person shifts into an alternate reality,
something must have to happen to the "them" of that reality. Presumably that would be a shift of their own. Which would trigger a shift for the "them"
in their new reality.

It gets very confusing thinking about the possible mechanics.

And that's where this whole thing falls apart for me. I have yet to see anyone consider some of the things I've brought up here, and how it would
effect this theory. Another question would be, why is it mostly pop culture stuff? Or things that have alternate explanations, that frankly make way
more sense.

I realize people "know" it was one way or the other. That doesn't mean anything to me... that is entirely subjective. It's akin to how people "know"
their God is real. I cite a multitude of faiths, and not just one. They can't all exist, despite how much one may "know" that theirs does.

In my opinion, the Mandela Effect doesn't stand up to a lick of scrutiny.

That said, I am perfectly willing to reconsider and possibly have my mind changed, if anything substantial could be presented as evidence that
may suggest such a thing is happening.

This content community relies on user-generated content from our member contributors. The opinions of our members are not those of site ownership who maintains strict editorial agnosticism and simply provides a collaborative venue for free expression.