Social Icons

Pages

Friday, June 20, 2014

Moto E review: Where very good meets very cheap

After Motorola released the well-received Moto X into the world last
year, most of us had just one question: What's Google's expensive mobile
division doing next? Then-chief Dennis Woodside was surprisingly
forthcoming for a tech CEO -- he said Motorola wanted to reinvent the
experience of using a low-cost smartphone. When the Moto G appeared
later that year, I thought the company had done what it set out to do.
Oh, how wrong I was. Motorola still hasn't given up on its dream of
putting smartphones within reach of anyone who wants one, and the latest
weapon in the company's arsenal is its cheapest yet.

The Moto E costs a scant $129 here in the States, and Motorola seems
confident that its low-cost formula will do some real good for the
people of the world (not to mention the company's bottom line). Now
we're left with another set of questions: Does the Moto E live up to
Motorola's lofty goals? Can it stand out against a clamoring crowd of
competitors? Are you actually getting what you pay for? Read on for our
take.

Moto E

Moto E

Summary
The Moto E has its shortcomings, but they're largely offset by the
device's affordable price. While the more powerful Moto G is likely the
better bet for most shoppers, those looking to ditch their feature
phones without breaking the bank will find plenty to like here.

Hardware

The Moto E is one of those curious devices that's unassuming and yet
immediately recognizable at the same time. That sounds a tad
paradoxical, but hear me out. Its face is spartan, to put it politely,
and the E's 4.3-inch qHD screen (swathed in Corning's Gorilla Glass 3 no
less) is bounded by some unobtrusive bezels. Your eyes can't help but
be drawn to the two silver strips that run in parallel above and below
the screen, comprising the speakers and microphone. Together, they make
for a very tasteful touch of personality that gives the E a sense of
self without much extra visual noise.

Flipping the Moto E over reveals that the company's design DNA hasn't
been diluted at all. The recessed Motorola logo, the swooping curve
around the 3.5mm headphone jack -- if Superman took hold of a Moto G and
compressed it a bit (you know, without turning it into a diamond or
something), you'd basically have the Moto E. Meanwhile, a 5-megapixel
camera sans flash sits high on the E's rear and selfie fanatics
will be crushed when they discover there's no ego-stroking front camera
here. The E skews toward the chubbier end of the size spectrum
(compared to the lithe Moto X, at least), but its curved rear means
it'll fit quite comfortably in your mitts. During my testing, I actually
found myself cursing at my otherwise trusty iPhone 5s and its prominent
edges. The E is awfully nice to hold, even when compared to premium
gadgets like HTC's One M8.

Moto E

Dimensions

124.8 x 64.8 x 6.2 - 12.3mm (curved)

Weight

5.01 oz. (142g)

Screen size

4.3 inches

Screen resolution

960 x 540 (256 ppi)

Screen type

IPS LCD

Battery

1,980mAh Li-Polymer (non-removable)

Internal storage

4GB

External storage

Up to 32GB

Rear camera

5MP with 4x digital zoom

Front-facing cam

None

Video capture

854 x 480/30 fps (rear)

NFC

No

Radios

Global GSM Model:

GSM/GPRS/EDGE (850/900/1800/1900)

UMTS/HSPA+ up to 21 Mbps (850/900/1900/2100)

North America GSM Model:

GSM/GPRS/EDGE (850/900/1800/1900)

UMTS/HSPA+ up to 21 Mbps (850/1700 [AWS]/1900)

CDMA Model:

CDMA/EVDO Rev A (850/1900)

Bluetooth

v4.0

SoC

Qualcomm Snapdragon 200

CPU

1.2GHz dual-core

GPU

Adreno 302

RAM

1GB

Multimedia

FM radio, Digital TV tuner (Brazil only)

WiFi

Dual-band, 802.11b/g/n

Wireless Charging

No

Operating system

Android 4.4.2 (near stock)

Our review unit pairs a glossy, black plastic face with a curvaceous,
matte rear. Those of you itching for something more chromatically pure
can pick up the white-on-white model, and you can replace those default
backs with more colorful ones for another $15 a pop. Prying off those
back plates reveals... not much, aside from the non-removable 1,980mAh
battery, the SIM slot and the microSD card slot. That expansion slot is
downright crucial, too, since this little guy comes with a paltry 4GB of
internal storage -- easily the surest signifier of the Moto E's
wallet-friendly ambitions. Once you factor in all of the preloaded bits,
you're actually left with just north of 2GB of open space for your apps
and media; suffice to say, a hefty memory card (the E can handle up to
an additional 32GB) should be on your shopping list too. Diving further
still reveals the E's brains: a dual-core Snapdragon 200 clocked at
1.2GHz, paired with 1GB of RAM and a single-core Adreno 302 GPU.

The North American version I've been playing with is slightly boring
compared to some international variations. Models for other markets
include a digital TV tuner or dual SIM slots. The vanilla US model is
pretty sparse in terms of niceties, though it does (like the Moto G)
have a built-in FM tuner for when you need some music that didn't
come from the Google Play Store. There's no LTE to be found here, alas
-- just a GSM radio that plays nice with the 850/900/1800/1900MHz bands,
and UMTS/HSPA+ support for 850/1700 (AWS)/1900MHz frequencies. Really,
though: For $130 off-contract, what did you expect? It's less than half
the price of the Nexus 5 and the Moto X, but as you'll see, cheap
doesn't always equate with crappy.

Display

For a phone of such humble means, the 4.3-inch IPS LCD sitting front
and center still manages to impress... even if it's the
lowest-resolution display I've laid eyes on in a long time. In a bid to
keep costs as low as possible, Motorola ran with a qHD (960 x 540)
screen -- if you're doing the math, that works out to a pixel density of
256 ppi. The number by itself isn't very exciting, but I think we can
agree that the quality of a screen hinges on more than just how many
pixels a manufacturer can squeeze in there.

Sure, you can pick out individual pixels if you peek closely enough.
Taking a step back offers up a different, more positive perspective,
though. The display itself is plenty bright, with crisp whites and
passable blacks (we're not in AMOLED territory, after all), though I
wish it fared better under the blazing sun. Colors are vivid and manage
to pop without dipping into lurid, oversaturated territory. Viewing
angles are similarly solid -- just be warned: Images can take on a
peculiar cast when you peer in from an angle that's oblique enough.
You'll also have a tough time trying to obscure that screen with your
greasy fingers thanks to the anti-smudge coating Motorola has liberally
applied. Is this screen perfect? Hardly, but its strong showing helps
make the entire Moto E package that much more enticing.

Software

Like its brethren before it, the Moto E runs a nearly stock build of
Android 4.4.2 KitKat, which means there isn't anything terribly exciting
to report on the software front. That's just fine by me -- I hate
clunky, overwrought interfaces and "features for the sake of features"
as much as the next elitist nerd. What you're ultimately left with is a
clean-ish slate that stays true to Google's mobile vision, but still
retains a few of Motorola's curious software fingerprints.

Take Motorola Migrate, for instance. It first appeared on the Droid
Ultra, and it still lets phone switchers transfer their existing data
(e.g., contacts, messages) to their new E's once the app has been
installed on the original phone. Assist is still around too, though it
lacks some of the smarts it packed when it first appeared on Moto's most
recent Droids. As always, it can monitor your calendar to deflect
callers at inopportune times, as well as let only VIPs reach you in your
slumber, but there's no way for the E to detect when you're driving and
auto-respond to folks texting you. As it happens, though, Motorola's
newest preloaded app is also its most curious. The new Alert is of two
minds: You can use it to blast your location so a curated list of
friends will know where to meet you, and it packs an emergency
mode that starts reaching out to those contacts (and emergency services)
if you find yourself in trouble. Alert is a surprisingly thoughtful
addition to Motorola's software mix, but with any luck, you'll never
need to touch that emergency feature.

Motorola also promises that it'll get the next big version of Android in a timely fashion, even with a divorce from Google
on the horizon. We'll see just how well Motorola can keep this promise
soon enough -- for now, it's heartening to see a budget smartphone
running the latest and greatest version of Google's mobile OS.

Camera

Smartphone cameras are tricky enough to get right when you're trying
to cobble together a top-tier device, so you've got to have the proper
expectations when you go downmarket. In the case of the Moto E, I
expected very little and I got it. That may sound a bit harsh, but the
Moto G's camera was a pleasant surprise and I was quietly hoping for the
same to happen here. Instead, the 5-megapixel rear shooter consistently
turned in soft shots with colors that seemed muted at best and
downright lifeless at worst. That last issue can be mitigated a touch if
you fire up HDR mode -- it's set to auto by default, so you'll
occasionally find a vibrantly colored photo mixed in with the rest of
the mud. Low-light performance left plenty to be desired too: The E's
camera isn't great at sucking up photons, so there's smudginess and grit
all over the place, a situation that isn't helped by the lack of a rear
flash. Oh, and in case you already forgot, there's no front-facing
camera to be found at all here.

Moto E camera samples

If anything, Motorola's dead-simple shooting interface is the
camera's saving grace. Quick refresher if you haven't used it before:
Snapping a photo requires just a single touch anywhere on the screen,
which means it's nearly impossible to screw up in the heat of the
moment. Sliding my finger up and down the screen to digitally zoom in
and out feels remarkably graceful too, even if digital zoom by nature
makes for lousier shots. You may not absolutely love the shots
you end up with, but I suspect you'll at least enjoy the process of
taking them. My only major niggle is a strictly personal one: Despite
using the E for over a week, I still had trouble remembering that
touching the screen snaps a photo instead of focusing the camera where I
wanted. That's a particular sort of muscle memory that's only really
taken hold after a (shortish) career manhandling high-end phones, so the
Moto E's target audience may not have the same trouble.

Video leaves much to be desired too, which is hardly a shocker. The
Moto E is incapable of shooting HD video -- resolution maxes out at 854 x
480, which is good enough for Instagram, but slightly less so when
trying to capture important moments as they unfold.

Performance and battery life

Ah, now we're getting to the meaty part -- what's the Moto E actually
like to use? Despite a spec sheet that looks like it was pulled from
the headlines two years ago, the E has more than managed to keep up with
my daily grind. I can't in good conscience call the Moto E a speed
demon, but it's still been a worthy companion during my week of testing.

And
what exactly did that week consist of? Plenty of frenzied swiping
between pages of apps and widgets, to start. The whole process was
consistently and pleasantly buttery, with nary a hint of stuttering or
visual slowdown to be seen (though in fairness, KitKat probably deserves
some of the credit for that). Scrolling down long websites was
generally smooth, too... most of the time, anyway. An abundance of
images on a web page (like Engadget!) occasionally threw the E's modest
brains for a bit of a loop. The act of actually firing up apps usually
took a few seconds more than on some premium handsets, but that's just
par for the course considering what we're working with. The games I did
manage to install on the Moto E (I'm looking at you, Minecraft: Pocket Edition)
fared rather nicely considering the dearth of sheer processing power
they had to work with. This is all anecdotal, of course -- here are some
hard numbers, if that's more your speed.

Moto E

Moto G

Moto X

HTC One mini

Quadrant 2.0

5,264

8,723

8,958

5,200

Vellamo 2.0

1,173

1,962

2,427

2,118

AnTuTu 4.0

12,510

17,364

20,292

10,048

SunSpider 1.2 (ms)

1,626.2

1,377

1,023

1,442

GFXBench 2.7 Offscreen (fps)

4.4

16

15

15

CF-Bench

6,483

15,030

14,092

6,542

SunSpider: lower scores are better

The funny (or sad) thing about downloading games for testing was
that, well, it was more troublesome than it should've been. It had
nothing to do with network connectivity (though I only hit down/up data
speeds of 1.82 Mbps and 0.84 Mbps, respectively in San Francisco over
AT&T's HSPA connection). Those headaches were all because of a
dearth of storage space. Like I mentioned before, the E ships with just
4GB of internal storage, and only about half of that is available for
your stuff right out of the gate. It didn't take long to almost
completely fill up that modicum of space with just our usual suite of
test apps and files. And those two-stage game downloads from the Google
Play Store? The ones (like Need For Speed: Most Wanted, for instance) that prompt you to download an installer that then downloads more
stuff once it's in place? Yeah, good luck with that. Picking up a
microSD card is damn near a necessity, and even then, you can't move all
of your apps from their current homes onto an external card. I get that
it's a concession Motorola made to keep the E's price under a certain
threshold, but I can definitely see some cost-conscious consumers ruing
that decision.

On the upside, the Moto E's modest spec sheet means that its 1,980mAh
battery can hang in there longer than you might think. When Motorola
says it's got an "all-day" battery, it actually means it. I spend my
days dealing with a barrage of emails, chatting with colleagues, taking
phone calls and generally running my device into the ground. There
wasn't a time when the E failed to hang in there for a full 12-hour day,
despite my best efforts. Things were a bit more subdued when it came
time for our standard video rundown test (screen brightness set to 50
percent with a 720p video set to loop indefinitely): It stuck around for
5:45 before it needed to be lashed to a wall outlet.

The competition

There's no shortage of cheap hardware out there, and more than a few
competitors may wind up duking it out with Motorola over first-time
smartphone shoppers. Take older, pint-sized versions of high-end phones
like the HTC One mini and the Samsung Galaxy S4 Mini -- both of them
offer more oomph, but even now they'll cost close to twice what the E
does. Speaking of Samsung, you can nab a dual-SIM Galaxy S Duos 2 for
close to the same price as the E-- you can juggle multiple phone numbers
and enjoy a camera with a flash, though TouchWiz could bog things down a bit. There's the LG L40, too, a cheapo device the Korean company showed off at MWC.
It hovers around the same price range as the Moto E, but its screen is
markedly worse and a shortage of RAM doesn't exactly bode well for
performance.

The Nokia X will also give the Moto E a run for its money in certain
locales. It's a curious little thing with its peculiar Finnish pedigree,
offbeat launcher and €89 (about $141) price tag, but a weaker spec
sheet and Nokia's control over its own app store means the experience it
offers is limited in some key ways. Not all of the E's competition
comes from outside Motorola, either. The Moto G packs more power and
performance into a bigger body, and it's still only $50 more than its
little brother. I'd wager that a decent number of shoppers on a budget
will gravitate toward the more impressive G, but the difference in price
could be too much for some to swallow.

Wrap-up

There's no two ways about it -- the Moto E is exciting, if
not in the way most mobile buffs would like. You really shouldn't
underestimate the sort of world-shaking power that can come from making
something that's both very good and very cheap. So what if the
spec sheet is a bit passé? For all its minor shortcomings, the Moto E
still represents a level of power and quality that's become even more
accessible to people the world over, and that's something worth
celebrating. If all you need is a smartphone that can take you to
Facebook, capture fodder for Instagram or fire off missives on Twitter
(or WhatsApp or Weibo), the Moto E will make a worthy sidekick. Not
every important device has to be a flashy flagship.

If Motorola ever manages to offer the $129 Moto E for under $100 (and
I bet it will eventually), we could be looking at a game changer; a
device that could really help bring the next billion people into an age
of connectedness most of us already take for granted. Until then, the
E's value is obscured a touch -- the superior balance of performance and
price means the Moto G will be worth the extra $50 for most people.