The first four tournaments saw 12 men first compete in elimination style 3-way matches in the first round before then single elimination matches until a winner was determined. During the 2005 tournament, which was held on May 14, 2005, the winner was determined by all single elimination matches but the original tournament structure returned in 2006 but saw the last four men face off in one match to determine the winner.

Final match:Sonjay Dutt defeated Roderick Strong to win CZW’s fourth Best of the Best tournament.

Best of the Best 5

CZW’s fifth Best of the Best tournament took place on May 14, 2005 at the “CZW Arena” (The Arena) in Philadelphia, PA. This was the first Best of the Best tournament to allow heavyweight wrestlers to compete. Also, this Best of the Best tournament did not have the traditional 3-way elimination opening round match. Instead, the final match was a 4-way elimination match.

Final match:Mike Quackenbush defeated B-Boy, Kevin Steen and Super Dragon, to win CZW’s fifth Best of the Best tournament.

Best of the Best 6

CZW’s sixth Best of the Best tournament took place on May 13, 2006 at the “CZW Arena” (The Arena) in Philadelphia, PA. This Best of the Best tournament saw the return of 3-way elimination match for the opening rounds, as well as keeping 4-way elimination match for the final match.

Best of the Best X

Best of the Best X took place on April 9, 2011 at the “Asylum Arena” (The Arena) in Philadelphia, PA. In non-tournament action Danny Havoc def. Jun Kasai in a Ragnarok and Roll Glass Crush Death Match for the UVU Championship, and the Briscoe Brothers and Devon Moore def. Philly's Most Wanted and Robert Anthony with Jon Moxley allowing the Briscoes to retain the tag gold and making Devon Moore the new CZW Champion.

Best of the Best 11

Was held on April 14th, 2012 at the Flyer's Skate Zone in Voorhees, NJ. In non-tournament action Dave Crist defeated Jake Crist for the CZW Wired TV Championship, Matt Tremont defeated Clint Margera in an Ultraviolent Encounter, and Drew Gulak and Danny Havoc signed a contract for a No Ropes Barbwire match that happened May 12th, 2012.