Menu

Tag Archives: Apache

You’re entitled to your opinion but in open source licensing only the consensus of the community really matters.

In a recent conversation on the Apache Legal mailing list, a participant opined that “any license can be Open Source. OSI doesn’t ‘own’ the term.” He went on to explain “I could clone the Apache License and call it ‘Greg’s License’ and it would be an open source license.” Continue reading →

Facebook’s BSD+Patent license combo fails not because of the license itself but because it ignores the deeper nature of open source.

In July 2017, the Apache Software Foundation effectively banned the license combination Facebook has been applying to all the projects it has been releasing as open source. They are using the 3-clause BSD license (BSD-3), a widely-used OSI-approved non-reciprocal license, combined with a broad, non-reciprocal patent grant but with equally broad termination rules to frustrate aggressors.Continue reading →

Like this:

The Apache Software Foundation has moved the “Facebook BSD+Patent grant” license combination (FB+PL) to its “Category X” licensing list, effectively banning inclusion of any software under FB+PL from Apache projects. That included RocksDB, which has consequently just dropped FB+PL and added the Apache License v2 on Github, and React.JS which does not look like it will resolve the issue so fast.

Update, 22 September: Facebook has announced it will switch React to the MIT license.

Here’s what we know so far (subject to updates, last day’s in green, latest marked 🆕): Continue reading →

Like this:

Even near-perfect governance like Apache’s can get gamed by a determined and well-resourced player. What lessons can we learn from their experience?

I’ve previously written about the fact the Apache Software Foundation offers an exemplar of large-scale open source governance. Even with those supreme qualities, things can still go wrong. Apache offers some of the best protections for open source contributors but its mature rules can be manipulated by skilled politicians and/or determined agendas. What can we learn from their experience? Continue reading →

Like this:

At FOSDEM 2017, Simon gave a well-attended talk explaining many of the things that could go wrong for a company trying to engage a large open source project over legal or governance issues. Based loosely on a mailing list thread at the Apache Software Foundation, the talk highlighted seven things to avoid and gave ideas on how to do so.

Like this:

Starting a large-scale open source project? The Apache Software Foundation is the benchmark against which you will be measured.

We’re now well beyond the point where open source has “won”. We’re seeing the open source idea starting to mature beyond even adolescence into adulthood. As it does so, our understanding and expectations of open source communities need to expand. Continue reading →

Share this:

Like this:

Post navigation

Tip Jars!

We’re an independent team & rely on your support & donations – thanks!

Can We Help?

Meshed Insights can help you with your open source strategy. Contact us for support with community, governance, licensing, branding or any other aspect of your open source strategy. We can also support you on digital rights issues. We offer research reports and white papers for your management and Board from experienced advisors, as well as on-site consulting and longer term engagements such as non-executive directorships.Contact us now.