This photo is linked from:

Discussion on SJ9465

Firstly let me confess I have no specialist architectural knowledge, but I would like to suggest that the timber framed building on the Mareknowles site is the older. The framed structure has markings suggesting a build date of 1618, I find it hard to believe it is predated by the stone built structure as suggested by one contributor to this square.

Incidentally a timber framed building presumably of a similar age once stood at Dumkins a mile or so further south down Shell Brook see SJ9464.