I am so glad that everyone else had better luck than I did. :) I love the PF bronzers and I bought a bronzing kit over the summer which came with two free Shimmer Strip eyeliners; one in black and one in brown. I just thought they were ok. I found them to be difficult to smudge and blend, and found myself tugging at my lids during application. It was a fun product to get for free and try but I wo...read moreuld not purchase. I threw them in spare makeup bags and grab them in a pinch but would not wear as my main eyeliner.— 3 years, 8 months ago

Lately I've been loving the Physicians Formula Shimmer Strips Custom Eye Enhancing Eyeliner Trio so today I wanted to share with you swatches and my quick review. This set retails for $11.99 and it comes with 3 full sized eyeliners, the set I have is in "Nude Eyes" which has 3 neutral liners: Natural (Champagne), Playful (Pewter) and Dramatic (Black).
Physicians Formula claims that this is the p...read moreerfect set of three eyeliners to create a Nude look for any eye color and I agree 100%! Physicians Formula also has a "Smokey Eyes" set and a "Bright Eyes" set as well. I purchased my set from Ulta when they had a major discount so I paid almost half that price, regardless 3 full sized liners for $12 is a major steal!
The liners apply smoothly and without any effort at all, whether you apply it on the lids or waterline, they are amazing and don't tug or hurt at all unlike many other liners out there. They do claim to have a 24 hour wear, I personally have not tested out that theory because that is way too long to wear makeup, but these did last for an average work day of about 9-10 hours...which is pretty amazing! They do take about a minute to set, but soon after they are smudge proof, don't smear, don't cause raccoon eyes, and they appear to be waterproof because they do don't wash off with just water.
Also, don't let the name fool you ("Shimmer") these are not matte, but rather frost, and they don't have any glitter or major shimmer which is a bonus because personally for an everyday look I do not want sparkles on my liner! Overall the Physicians Formula Shimmer Strips Custom Eye Enhancing Eyeliner Trio in Nude Eyes is amazing and I love all three liners that come in the set! I would highly recommend this set to anyone out there who is looking for affordable eyeliners that are long lasting, that apply easily and that are smudge proof!— 3 years, 2 months ago

I love these...The colors are beautifully pigmented. I have black, brown, and blue, and all of them look great. They go on smoothly and its easy to make a perfect line and even to wing it out because there is a sharpener at the end to keep it nice and pointy for a more precise line. It also lasts all day, even through a hot day If I have been sweating, or if my skin is a little oily, this eye ...read moreliner withstands all of that. It doesn't fade or smudge and its still easy to remove. And all this at an affordable price! Three eye liners for only 10 bucks at Walmart! That's great! I Definitely won't stop buying these.
— 4 years, 1 month ago

I bought the trio for brown eyes. I was surprised at how long each one lasts and that they stay put all day even on my oily lids. Plus I love that you get three great liners in one package.
— 6 years, 5 months ago

I used a deep brown one when I didn't have my normal liquid liner and was surprised how well it stayed on. Usually, my pencil liners end up on my upper lids because I have hooded eyes which happen to be oily. Not the case for these guys. Tons of colours, but I wish they were slightly more pigmented for the black that I had the opportunity to swatch. They come with a tiny sharpener at the end, to make the bullet a little pointier if need be, which is a nice add-on.
— 2 years, 5 months ago

I go through A LOT of eyeliner, and I mean it. Drugstore, high end, you name it. If it's in a retractable pencil form, I've tried it. In the end, I go back to this trio set. Always. Forever. I can't even begin to stress how freaking great these are, especially for the price.
The neutral/nude trio is my hands down favorite. I love each and every color but the dark brown is perfect. I wish they sol...read mored it separately.
The best part about these liners? They do not budge, flake, smudge. anything, you name it. I can go through a full day, sweat and all, and my eyeliner will look just a bit faded after a solid 12+hour day. Yet they come right off when I wash my face with cleanser. I can't ask for anything else, really. — 2 years, 11 months ago

This is a product that will take you from the work day to the night life, with only one touch up around dusk! The colors are highly pigmented, and will not run or feather due to heat or length of wear. Generally speaking, I work other colors around or on top of my liner, so I cannot speak for how well this product smudges. However, I will say that one should give it a whirl, and create some magic on their lids!
— 3 years, 1 month ago

I love Physisans Formula. And I was really excited to see these in "muted" tones (aka browns) since I've been going more natural with my make up- way easier to do with a kid around. Well, this product fell kinda flat. While the colors are super rich, creamy, and pigmented, they make my eyes itch! It's enough to be bothersome and I end up rubbing my eyeliner off just to ease the itch. Really surprising, considering nothing in this brand has ever done this before!
— 3 years, 3 months ago

It's an okay eyeliner, but not really intense. The stick keeps breaking off in chunks, so a lot of product is wasted. The colour is nice, but the end is a nub, not a point so its a little limiting,
— 2 years, 9 months ago