December 16, 2011 – NYWC: John Silver defeated AR Fox and Dimitrios Papadon in a 3-way match to become #1 contender for the heavyweight title. NYWC heavyweight champion Apollyon defeated John Silver to retain the title.

May 18, 2012 – NYWC: Alex Reynolds and John Silver defeated DJ Phat Pat and Francis Kipland Stevens & Kodama and Obariyon in a 3-way tag team elimination match to become #1 contenders for the tag team titles.

June 9, 2012 – NYWC: John Silver defeated Mark Angelosetti.

June 17, 2012 – No Way Out: Ryback defeated Dan Delaney and Rob Grymes (John Silver) in a handicap match.

October 20, 2012 – NYWC: John Silver and Alex Reynolds defeated DJ Phat Pat and Francis Kipland Stevens & Mikey Whipwreck and Rex Lawless in a 3-way tag team house of madness match to win the tag team titles.

February 23, 2013 – NYWC: John Silver and Alex Reynolds defeated Chuck Taylor and Jigsaw to retain the tag team titles. Bill Carr and Smith James defeated John Silver and Alex Reynolds to win the tag team titles.

July 12, 2014 – CZW: CZW tag team champions JT Dunn and David Starr defeated Alex Reynolds and John Silver, Bill Carr and Dan Barry & Dave and Jake Crist in a 4-way tag team match to retain the titles.

May 22, 2015 – PWG: Alex Reynolds and John Silver defeated Dan Barry and Bill Carr in the 1st round. Alex Reynolds and John Silver defeated Ethan Page and Josh Alexander in the semi-finals, to win the tag team titles. Trevor Lee and Andrew Everett defeated Alex Reynolds and John Silver to win the tournament and tag team titles.

May 6, 2017 – PWM: The Beaver Boys (Alex Reynolds and John Silver) defeated Milk Chocolate (Brandon Watts and Randy Summers) in the 1st round. The Beaver Boys (Alex Reynolds and John Silver) defeated The Twisted Sisters (Holidead and Thunder Rosa) in the semi-finals. The Private Party (Isiah Kassidy and Marq Quen) defeated The Beaver Boys (Alex Reynolds and John Silver) to win the tournament.

August 28, 2017 – Anarchy: Joey Lynch defeated John Silver in the 1st round of the powerbomb.tv independent title tournament.

September 8, 2017 – CAP: The Breakfast Club (CPA and Francis Kipland Stevens) defeated Massage NV (Dorian Graves and VSK) & The Beaver Boys (Alex Reynolds and John Silver) in a 3-way tag team match to win the tag team titles.

September 9, 2017 – CZW: Johnny Silver defeated David Starr.

September 22, 2017 – Limitless: The Thick Boys (Jay Freddie and John Silver) defeated Latin American Exchange (Ortiz and Santana).

February 10, 2018 – CZW: Dan Barry defeated Ace Austin, Alexander James, Alex Reynolds, John Silver and Tyler Murphy in a 6-way match to qualify for the Best Of The Best tournament. John Silver was also in the #1 contenders battle royal for the world heavyweight title won by Maxwell Jacob Friedman.

November 25, 2018 – Beyond Tournament For Tomorrow: The Beaver Boys (Alex Reynolds and John Silver) defeated Mike Verna and Rex Lawless in the quarter-finals. The Beaver Boys (Alex Reynolds and John Silver) defeated The Viking War Party (Alex Herzog and Jake Parnell) in the semi-finals. The Beaver Boys (Alex Reynolds and John Silver) defeated Hot Wheelz (Tracy Williams and Wheeler YUTA) to win the tournament.

January 18, 2019 – EVOLVE 119: The Skulk (Adrian Alanis and Leon Ruff) defeated Lotus (Gavin Quinn and Juntai), Milk Chocolate (Brandon Watts and Randy Summers) & The Beaver Boys (Alex Reynolds and John Silver) in a 4-way tag team match to become #1 contenders for the tag team titles.