Has Tom finally found true love after splitting from Katie Holmes in 2012? A revealing new report claims that the actor has been romancing fellow Scientologist Laura Prepon for nearly five months!

Shhh! That’s what the reps for Tom Cruise, 51, and Orange Is the New Black‘s Laura Prepon, 34, have to say about the two celebs dating. But why all the secrecy? Tom is reportedly “smitten” with the That ’70s Show alum, and is “on cloud nine.” Could this be the real deal?

“It’s the buzz on the set of her show [Orange Is the New Black],” the source told the New York Post’s Page Six.

In November of 2013, Tom and Laura were spotted out together in Los Angeles. And not just on one date, but on two dates!

“They spent three hours laughing and joking. It’s clear Tom is smitten and after the date he was on cloud nine,” an eyewitness told Grazia. “They had their second date at the restaurant, too, meeting for Sunday brunch, and then she accompanied him a few days later to a dinner party at John [Travolta]’s home.”

Tom Cruise & Laura Prepon’s Romantic Histories

However, both of the actors’ reps deny that they are dating. In fact, a rep for Tom even told the UK’s Daily Mail that the two had never even met!