Litty and Wiggins attempted to talk to Lawrence prior to entering her home, according to a report filed on the incident.

Wiggins and Litty again tried to talk with Lawrence as she stood inside a bedroom. As the officers were speaking with Lawrence, she allegedly attempted to shut the door on the officers.

The officers moved to arrest Lawrence, who resisted, according to the incident report, causing Wiggins and Litty to restrain her prior to handcuffing her.

Lawrence was eventually taken to the Baxter County jail, where she was being held on charges of indecent exposure and resisting arrest. Jail records indicate Lawrence no longer had her wings on when she was booked into the detention center. Lawrence did, however, have one white robe (bathroom style) and a white cross when booked.

Jailers were initially unable to get a mug shot of Lawrence, as she declined to put on any clothing for several hours. Eventually, jailers were able to convince Lawrence to put on clothes and have a booking photograph taken.