He's on 16 votes on AFL Predictor... but I think Grundy might be just by a whisker slighly ahead of Gawn this year, but many votes will be pinched from Grundy by other Pies players, when comparing to Gawn.

I know rucks don't poll that great, but I suspect Tim Kelly our best chance will cop a heavy tag for the rest of season and could potentially drop a bit in polls, but is an extremely good chance.

Premiership Player

If he didn't win the brownlow last year, he will never win it. Especially given the fact we will end up having a considerable difference in win/loss this season which will make polling votes even harder. Not many taking votes off him this year though..

Brownlow Medallist

He's on 16 votes on AFL Predictor... but I think Grundy might be just by a whisker slighly ahead of Gawn this year, but many votes will be pinched from Grundy by other Pies players, when comparing to Gawn.

I know rucks don't poll that great, but I suspect Tim Kelly our best chance will cop a heavy tag for the rest of season and could potentially drop a bit in polls, but is an extremely good chance.

Brownlow Medallist

He's on 16 votes on AFL Predictor... but I think Grundy might be just by a whisker slighly ahead of Gawn this year, but many votes will be pinched from Grundy by other Pies players, when comparing to Gawn.

I know rucks don't poll that great, but I suspect Tim Kelly our best chance will cop a heavy tag for the rest of season and could potentially drop a bit in polls, but is an extremely good chance.

Premiership Player

If he didn't win the brownlow last year, he will never win it. Especially given the fact we will end up having a considerable difference in win/loss this season which will make polling votes even harder. Not many taking votes off him this year though..

That’s why he’s a big chance this year. There’s normally a lag between a player really dominating and polling votes. Once your recognized as a gun you are way more likely to poll well. After the game, when the umps are considering their votes, your first thought would be how did the gun players go? I think the recognized guns have a mortgage on the votes unless someone else plays an absolute blinder.

Premium Platinum

That’s why he’s a big chance this year. There’s normally a lag between a player really dominating and polling votes. Once your recognized as a gun you are way more likely to poll well. After the game, when the umps are considering their votes, your first thought would be how did the gun players go? I think the recognized guns have a mortgage on the votes unless someone else plays an absolute blinder.

Norm Smith Medallist

3 time AA now - fair effort by Max. Who was our last three timer? We have a lot of one season wonders.

Maybe not the right thread but other teams' players make the team when they are ancient - Houli, Pendlebury and Hurn for instance, why do our players suddenly become terrible once they hit their late 20s.

Duel Group 1 winner

3 time AA now - fair effort by Max. Who was our last three timer? We have a lot of one season wonders.

Maybe not the right thread but other teams' players make the team when they are ancient - Houli, Pendlebury and Hurn for instance, why do our players suddenly become terrible once they hit their late 20s.

Premiership Player

No point having a bnf this year quite clearly our best player certainly our most consistent. I had Salem earlier in the year was very consistent but he just fell away badly in the end, gawn however you could rely upon no matter how poorly the team played this year.

Brownlow Medallist

No point having a bnf this year quite clearly our best player certainly our most consistent. I had Salem earlier in the year was very consistent but he just fell away badly in the end, gawn however you could rely upon no matter how poorly the team played this year.