I initiated my first trade on PucaTrade on 9/27/15. Since then I have sent 865 cards with a total value of 343,381 PucaPoints and received 220 cards from other members with a total value of 281,623 PucaPoints. It works. It could be better yes. But it's infinitely better than trading IRL at my LGS. They are working on PucaTrade 2.0. Some day it will be complete. Until then I make it work as is.

How is it on other sites like MOTL? What protection is there? (I am familiar with PucaTrade)

MOTL is dead so there is no protection anymore. But it was the same (i presume, since i have not traded on MTGS). You think you get ripped, you post to the bad trades and rippers forum about your experience. They are given time to answer or fix it. Their silence is generally what confirms a rip or they come on there and fix it. People are instructed not to trade with the alleged ripper until things are sorted, and any trade or sale post they make is deleted while they are undergoing the process of clearing their name. And then you're just banned if you don't answer or are found horrible.

How is it on other sites like MOTL? What protection is there? (I am familiar with PucaTrade)

MOTL is dead so there is no protection anymore. But it was the same (i presume, since i have not traded on MTGS). You think you get ripped, you post to the bad trades and rippers forum about your experience. They are given time to answer or fix it. Their silence is generally what confirms a rip or they come on there and fix it. People are instructed not to trade with the alleged ripper until things are sorted, and any trade or sale post they make is deleted while they are undergoing the process of clearing their name. And then you're just banned if you don't answer or are found horrible.

Oh ok. We actually go one step further and ban you from trading for smaller offenses, and for larger things like ripping we fully ban users.

MRHBlue and Celerus, I may give it a look again. I have some trades up on there but have never actually completed a trade; may need some help there. Mind if I send you guys a pm closer to the time when I get it active again? (I'm moving house in a week, so now's not the time )

MRHBlue and Celerus, I may give it a look again. I have some trades up on there but have never actually completed a trade; may need some help there. Mind if I send you guys a pm closer to the time when I get it active again? (I'm moving house in a week, so now's not the time )

PucaTrade has had a number of updates and it feels that more than ever the system caters to those who spend the most money on the site. I have a number of wants on there that I can't move, many of them from Kaladesh where there shouldn't be a problem finding a seller.

If anyone is still on Puca (or were and wonders what's happening to their points), I've been having some success recently by going through the Puca chat channels on Discord and advertising, chatting & begging for trades. It's still nothing like pre-updates and you have to take a little time to get known, but it's better than just letting the points run out.

For those of you who are still active, I'd appreciate any help you can give me to make an Unstable cube, I have about 200 cards listed from the extension across all rarities:https://pucatrade.com/profiles/show/1247