I'm in the camp that liked these when they were 100% cotton and thicker.That version was super comfortable. This version just isn't as nice.

Gender:

Male

Height:

5'9"

Fit:

true to size

Size Type:

Regular

Merchant response: Julio, thank you for reviewing the Men's Eddie's Favorite Thermal Crew Shirt. We are sorry to hear that you are not satisfied with the selection of shirt. Your comments will be forwarded to our Product Teams for review and consideration. We hope you will find something in our upcoming selection! If you need any assistance with our 100% Satisfaction Guarantee, please contact our Customer Care Center. We are happy to help!

I now have 4 of these shirts in XLT and love them. Two are older styles from a couple of years ago made in a different country than the current ones. These are just as good as the older ones. In fact, the additional plackets sewn into the sides and over the shoulder of this new design make for an excellent fit. And the seams are sewn flat so you don't feel them, unlike most shirts of this type. These are a little heavier than a well made heavy t-shirt. Perfect for spring and fall. I use these on overseas vacations to layer my clothes for the changing weather throughout the day. You can put a colored t-shirt under them to be warmer; or add a vest over top and still have your arms free. Usually I don't like blends, but the 60/40 blend doesn't affect the soft feel that using some polyester in shirts sometimes does. Plus, I image the polyester helps to retain the shape and reduce the possibility of shrinkage over time. Others have complained about the extra long sleeves. With this I would agree. I have long 37" arms and the sleeves on my XLTs are 38+. It hasn't really bothered me. (EB - Please don't shorten the sleeves too much if redesigned!) Plus, you can roll up the sleeves one fold if desired. One of mine is heather navy. In reality, it looks like dark gray. It was only when I compared it to my heather black shirt, ordered at the same time, that you can tell the difference. That is, the navy is a little bluish in color, but not far off dark gray. Regardless, I am happy because I like dark gray as well. Overall, I have been very happy with Eddie Bauer over the years simply because they offer so many nice styles of shirts in Tall sizes.

You are forcing me to comment on this? Okay: I actually bought two of these at the same time, because the OLD waffle shirts were so great and my old ones are ready to retire. one was back ordered. The one I got looks baggy and shapeless (like think oversized nightshirt). I have the longest arms of anyone I know. And I wear a solid XL Tall. But this year, the shirts are 2 or 3 inches longer than my arms. I can't imagine why. No effort put into this. When I called to cancel the 2nd one on back order, the EB Rep told me I could not cancel that one. It hadn't shipped. She just told me it was policy to not allow people to cancel items on back order. Eventually I was given to another Rep, which I was assured in advance would also NOT let me cancel an item on back order. However, that turned out not to be true and I did get to cancel the second one of these. HONESTLY, What has happened to EB Customer Service?

Gender:

Male

Height:

6'4"

Fit:

very large

Size Type:

Tall

What will you be using this product for?:

Other

Look:

Quality:

Value:

Bottom LineNo, I would not recommend this to a friend

Merchant response: Thank you for your review of the Men's Eddie Bauer Favorite Thermal Crew Shirt. We are sorry to hear that the shirt did not live up to your expectations and the previous shirts you owned. This is definitely not something to expect from one of our items. Your comments have been processed for our Product Teams to review and consider. We hope you will return the shirt under Eddie's 100% Satisfaction Guarantee which states "Every item we sell will give you complete satisfaction or you may return it for a full refund.". If you need assistance with the return please contact our Customer Care Center. We are here to help!

ADVENTURE IN YOUR INBOX

Live Your Adventure. Get Rewarded.

FOLLOW EDDIE BAUER

EDDIE BAUER PRODUCTS ARE GUARANTEED FOR LIFE

As an outdoor guide, Eddie Bauer built products to stand up to the rigors of his adventures. He built them—and guaranteed them— to last. We carry on that legacy. Every product carries a lifetime warranty. If you're ever unhappy with it for any reason, return it for an exchange or refund and we'll help you find what you need to Live Your Adventure.