Movie Jail: This week's defendant is...Eli Roth!

This is Movie Jail, a unique maximum security prison that houses some of the worst writers, directors, actors and producers from Hollywood and beyond. Their crimes? The offenses vary from convict to convict but most of these inmates have contributed negatively to the film world to some capacity* and his or her misdeeds have covered a long enough period of time that the authorities had to intervene. In each column a defendant is put on trial, arguments are made, and then it is up to YOU, the jury, to decide if the person is guilty or not guilty of crimes against cinema. Their lives are in your hands, dude.

The Defendant

The Case

The Prosecution: The Green Inferno, Aftershock, The Man with the Iron Fist, Hostel 2

Ladies and gentlemen of the jury, Eli Roth has been a fixture in the horror genre ever since first making moviegoers squeamish with his darkly funny, but gruesome feature film directorial debut Cabin Fever, which received very solid reviews from critics and grossed over $30 million worldwide against a budget of just $1.5 million. Hostel also scored decent marks and was a success story at the box office, but the prosecution isn't a fan of the "torture porn" flick or its sequel, and in our opinion, he has yet to top his first movie as a director.

It just doesn't seem like Mr. Roth has grown as a filmmaker, although some will probably argue that it's because he has only helmed five movies, including next month's Knock, Knock. But none of his post-Hostel directorial efforts have a fresh rating at Rotten Tomatoes (with his latest, The Green Inferno, currently sitting at 39%), and he also co-wrote the scripts for the lowly reviewed Aftershock and The Man with the Iron Fists.

Mr. Roth may have his fans, but he also has an equal amount of detractors, and while the prosecution will give him credit for not making limp, PG-13 horror movies, we still feel he needs to serve some time behind bars.

The Defense: Hemlock Grove, Hostel, Cabin Fever

Ladies and gentlemen, Mr. Roth has never been a critical darling, however he has developed a loyal following thanks to his blood-drenched movies. Perhaps he's not the future of horror as dubbed by Quentin Tarantino, but he certainly knows the genre, and is still a strong director.

Although my client's big screen efforts have received mixed reviews from "serious" critics, many horror fans love him and his movies, mostly due to the fact that he doesn't shy away from the red stuff. Even though his films may be a little weak story-wise, they do deliver when it comes to blood and guts. He's a very polarizing filmmaker though, and while the defense isn't sure where the hate for him comes from, it appears to have started with the release of Hostel 2. Maybe some people weren't happy that it was just more of the same, but that happens often with horror sequels.

In addition to his feature film credits, Mr. Roth also created that awesome Thanksgiving trailer for Robert Rodriguez and Tarantino's Grindhouse flicks, and besides directing the pilot, he also serves as an executive producer on Netflix's Hemlock Grove. The latter hasn't received fantastic reviews, but it's still an entertaining series. Personally, my client might not be your favorite director, but he definitely doesn't deserve to go to Movie Jail, especially since he's only directed five films.

IN CLOSING...

Do we need to lock up the "Splat Pack" director, or are you a fan of his films? Has he earned a prison sentence with his relatively small amount of movie directing credits, or do you think we need to see more from him before deciding his fate? Is Eli Roth GUILTY or NOT GUILTY?

*The cases for and against a defendant going to Movie Jail by the author are not necessarily his views and opinions but they are some of the beliefs that one would use to effectively make an argument for both sides. Not quite a devil's advocate but you get the point. Anyway, this is all in fun so don't take it too seriously. We have a separate jail for those people called "Troll Tower" and believe me you do NOT want to go there.

WHAT SAY YOU, GUILTY OR NOT?

LAST WEEK'S VERDICT

Since almost all of the jury members said they aren't familiar with many of Michael Polish's films during last week's trial, the court has decided not to imprison the Twin Falls Idaho director. Mr. Polish won't be joining his wife Kate Bosworth in the slammer (except for conjugal visits), but he still needs to be more selective with his movie projects.