If this is your first visit, be sure to
check out the FAQ by clicking the
link above. You will have to register
before you can post: click the register link above to proceed. To start viewing messages,
select the forum that you want to visit from the selection below.

New Player Looking For Advice

Hi everyone,first post here, and I'm fairly new to playing dnd, having played only 3 sessions before.

I'm going to be playing in a new campaign soon, and I was thinking about trying a fighter that dual wields, preferably bastard swords. I know its not the best idea, or optimal or what ever, but I'm also open for suggestions.

I know I need Two Weapon Fighting and ... i think its called Over Sized Two Weapon fighting feats? And the Exotic Weapon feat because you can use a bastard sword in two hands fine without it but only in one with the feat or something...

Anyways, I was hoping you guys could help me out with Class progressions and what feats to take (aside from those 3.)

Re: New Player Looking For Advice

Sure, try it, see if you like it.
The main-hand bastard sword will deal 1d10+Str on a successful hit.
The off-hand bastard sword will deal 1d10+(1/2)*Str on a successful hit.
Exotic Weapon Proficiency (Bastard Sword) removes the -4 for using a weapon you're unfamiliar with.
Two-Weapon Fighting requires Dex 15 and reduces the TWF-ing penalty to melee from -6/-10 to -4/-4
Oversized TWF requires Str 13 and reduces the TWF-ing penalty with Bastard Swords from -4/-4 to -2/-2.

A Human Fighter 1 can get all 3 feats. Otherwise you can have them by level 2.

If you decide you don't like it, or end up dying, then I'd say take the bunch of other suggestions that will certainly be available.

Edit: I missed the last part of that post. Level and feat selection for a fighter like yours are pretty simple on account of how the feats are set up in core. The most basic is Fighter 20, with these feats:
1: Exotic Weapon Proficiency (Bastard Sword), TWF, Oversized TWF
2: Weapon Focus (Bastard Sword)
3: Power Attack
4: Weapon Specialization (Bastard Sword)
6: Cleave, Improved TWF*
8: Greater Weapon Focus
9: Improved Critical (Bastard Sword)
10: Great Cleave
12: Greater Weapon Specialization, Greater TWF**
13+: Any, the campaign probably won't get this high.

If you go Human, you can assign Elite Array as follows:
Str 13, Dex 15, Con 14, Int 12, Wis 10, Cha 8
Then put all level up bonuses into Strength. That will mean at level 1, your attacks look like this (for reference, I included AC and your chance of hitting with a regular, eg. not charging, attack):
Standard Attack: +2 (1d10+1)
Full Attack: +0/+0 (1d10+1, 1d10+0)
Average AC 15, 40% to hit (subtract 10% per attack on a full attack)
Average Full-Attack Damage: 4

Re: New Player Looking For Advice

Considering the cost reward ratio you are likely better off using longsword+shortsword. It is certainly not as flashy, but two extra feats could more than make up the difference in damage potential, and is more accurate as well. Also if you have your heart set on fighting with big swords, just use one. The payoff for doing so VERY good since you get 1.5*str to damage rolls (as opposed to just str) and 2:1 ratio with power attack (ie you get two damage for every point of penalty you take when using power attack, where as one handed weapons only give you 1:1). Generally it's hard to go wrong with 1 greatsword (or bastard sword), though a glaive gives you all the benefits and hits out another square, and a spiked chain is good for everything.

Re: New Player Looking For Advice

Originally Posted by Norwirk

I know I need Two Weapon Fighting and ... i think its called Over Sized Two Weapon fighting feats? And the Exotic Weapon feat because you can use a bastard sword in two hands fine without it but only in one with the feat or something...

Welcome to the Forum! Please be aware, when you ask for build advice around here, it generally goes something like this:

1) You say "Hey, I have this really cool idea, I wanna use X and Y and Z!"
2) Forum says, "OMG that's absolutely horrible, never use X and Y and Z, here's a mathematical formula that proves X, Y and Z will horribly and irrevocably ruin your game and cause cancer in puppies. If you play anything other than <blah> (usually some variation of Wizard 20/Cleric 20/Druid 20) you're doing it wrong, so wrong that we will publicly hunt you down and shame you for it."
3) Stunned anger, usually followed by an agonizing few months as the very slow and painful realization that the forum was probably right sinks in...

Anyway, I absolutely love TWFing with bastard swords, even though I know it's not "Optimized" and it may cause cancer in cute little puppies. Very briefly, there's a few problems with TWF that we need to address before we get down to brass tacks:

1) It's feat-intensive. You only have seven basic feat slots over your 20-level career, and just the basic TWF feats eat up half of those. Ranger helps a bit here, but the biggest worry is to avoid not-so-obvious traps that *seem* like they help TWF but actually make it worse... stuff like Spring Attack or Two-Weapon Defense.

2) It has low damage output, particularly compared to your basic wombat fighter using just a two-handed weapon and Power Attack. We need some bonus damage to keep it somewhat competitive. Ranger Favored Enemy helps a little bit, but not enough. Sneak Attack sometimes works well, but if you have access to Complete Adventurer (that's the one with Oversize TWF, one of my favoritest feats ever even though it's mostly garbage) and Complete Scoundrel, then we can rack up some decent bonus damage from a Skirmish/Swift Hunter build.

3) To make TWF work, you need a reliable way to move + full attack every round, or enough rounds to make it worthwhile. Travel Devotion (from Complete Champion) can help out here, but Person_Man created a nice list of Ways to Get Pounce or Free Movement.

For Favored Enemies, take 1st: Undead, 2nd: Constructs, 3rd: Elementals, and 4th: Oozes or Plants, whichever you prefer. Why? Swift Hunter does something else other than let you stack Scout/Ranger for Skirmish damage, it also allows you to apply skirmish damage to favored enemies that would normally be immune to skirmish. Undead are the most common enemy you'll probably encounter at all possible levels. Constructs are also quite common, and can get extremely nasty at mid/high levels. Elementals aren't quite so common, but continue to get bigger and nastier. Plants tend to be slow and flammable. Oozes are more like traps than creatures, you can usually just walk around them so long as you spot them in time, but unlike vine strike, golem strike, and grave strike, there is no "ooze strike" spell.

ACF = "Alternate Class Feature". This means you swap some of your class abilities (usually not-so-useful ones) for different class abilities (usually much more useful ones). There are several you'll want to consider:

Trap Expert (from Dungeonscape): swap Track for Trap Sense and Disable Device as a class skill. While Track may seem important, more often it's just window dressing thrown in as an afterthought to make the Ranger seem useful: if it's vitally important information, the DM will make sure the players find it regardless of whether or not you make your Track roll. Trap Sense is generally seen as more useful, and you're not quite so fragile as a rogue, so this means you can take over Trapfinding/Disabling duties if the party doesn't have a rogue or the rogue gets squished.

Spiritual Connection (from Complete Champion): Wild Empathy has a chance to improve the attitude of an animal. Spiritual Connection, however, lets you talk to the animal/plant directly, find out key information (who needs Track now? The effin' oak trees saw everything!), ask the animal/plant out to tea, get their opinions on bearded dwarfs, etc. Much more useful.

Distracting Attack (from PHBII): Your animal companion is a bloody smear waiting to happen. It advances so slowly that you'll spend more time and resources in combat just trying to keep it alive than it can give you anything by helping. Distracting Attack renders a foe as "flanked" on a successful hit (even ranged hits). This may not help you directly, but if you have anyone else in the party that relies on Sneak Attack for damage, they will be your BFF.

Skilled City Dweller (from the Cityscape Web Enhancement): This lets you swap Ride as a class skill for Tumble. A couple ranks in Ride and a high Dex will probably be all you ever need (generally a DC 5 to stay in a saddle). A high Tumble check helps you avoid AoOs or move through opponents, which you'll need if you're trying to activate skirmish every round. Get it *really* high, like 40+, and you can take a 10' step instead of a 5' step.

PrCs to Consider:

Highland Stalker (from Complete Adventurer). Dipping in for two levels gives you +1d6 skirmish damage, which is generally faster than waiting four levels for Scout/Ranger to give you the same damage boost. However, you'll need to keep the Track feat to qualify, in which case you can't use the Trap Expert ACF.

Dragon Devotee (from Races of the Dragon). Four levels gives you +2d6 skirmish damage and 1st level Sorcerer spellcasting. Make sure you choose two divination spells (such as true strike and maybe critical strike), and this helps you qualify for...

Unseen Seer (from Complete Mage). Four levels gives you another +2d6 skirmish damage, and you can take the hunter's mercy spell (PHBII) as a sorcerer with a much higher caster level.

You may also want to consider dipping Fighter 2 (for Power Attack and Weapon Focus: Bastard Sword), and then taking a level of Exotic Weapon Master (from Complete Warrior). This lets you take the Exotic Weapon Stunt "Uncanny Blow", which allows you to treat your one-handed bastard swords as two-handed weapons for the purposes of calculating Power Attack damage. This lets you rack up Power Attack multipliers (Valorous weapon enhancement, Leap Attack, etc.) right along with the two-handed wombats.