Rants & Reflections

22 Reasons Twitter Makes My Head Explode

I joined Twitter in the summer of 2010, and even though I’m a college-educated, published author, active blogger, Facebooker extraordinaire, and mom of four teens, I’m still thoroughly perplexed about how to use Twitter efficiently and appropriately. You see, I’m an oldest child—a rule-follower by nature—and a little shy to boot. And before I leap onto a new scene, I like tohave a heads-up about the accepted etiquette so I don’t look like a complete horse’s ass (another consequence, no doubt, of being an oldest child). Know if I should be wearing jeans or a cocktail dress. Whether I should bring a hostess gift or make a charitable donation. Which fork to use for the salad.

Sure, I did the easy stuff like choose a handle (@AndreaReiser), set up my bio, uploaded a photo, customized my background, found some interesting people to follow, and even organized everything in a nifty third-party Twitter app. But then I had no clue what to do— and more importantly how to do it “properly.”

So I began reading everything I could about Twitter manners and best practices so I wouldn’t come off as a giant newb. Devoured books that had the words “Twitter” and “dummy,” “moron,” “loser,” “dimwit,” “numbskull” or “dunce” in the title. Googled stacks of articles and blog posts on Twitter etiquette and tips. Paged through countless ebooks claiming to be the “ultimate” guide to Twitter. Sought advice from successful tweeters. Studied actual conversations happening among the folks I followed and their followers.

And after my exhaustive research, I’m more bewildered and disheartened than ever. It seems there are conflicting “rules” about everything. There’s even a conflicting rule about rules themselves: “Twitter is personal and there are no rules,” some swear. But I just googled “Twitter mistakes” and got over 40 million results! “Make sure you follow the rules or you’ll turn people off,” some of these superior folks admonish, as they no doubt roll their eyes while they point and laugh.

See for yourself why the “rules” make my head explode:

1. CREATING A TWITTER ID

Some insist: Make your Twitter ID the same or similar to the name of your site.

Others claim: Your Twitter ID should always be your own name so if you change your focus you don’t need to change your handle.

2. CHOOSING PEOPLE TO FOLLOW

Some insist: Follow whomever you want, based on your interests and social media goals.

Others claim: You should be extremely selective about who you follow, as people will judge you by the quality of your community.

3. HOW MANY PEOPLE TO FOLLOW

Some insist: Follow as many people as you can. It says that you’re trying to learn more, trying to meet more people and that you’re a good listener. And it increases the chances that people will follow you back, thus increasing your follower count.

Others claim: Don’t follow more than 150 people, or you’ll be too overwhelmed to be able to actively engage in meaningful conversations.

And a few advise: You don’t need to follow more than 500 people.

4. FOLLOWING BACK

Some insist: Follow everyone back. By not doing the courtesy follow, it’s like having people approach you at a party and turning your back to them. You look elitist.

Others claim: Following everyone back is unnecessary. Keep your social media world uncluttered by having a follow strategy: selectively follow back people who are interesting to you based on your own criteria.

5. # OF FOLLOWERS

Some insist: Don’t worry about how many followers you have. Twitter is not a numbers game if you use it purposefully.

Others claim: Twitter is definitely a numbers game, and don’t let anyone tell you otherwise. People assess your popularity and desirability by the number of followers you have.

6. WELCOMING NEW FOLLOWERS

Some insist: Use an autoresponder to welcome new followers.

Others claim: It’s insulting to receive impersonal canned messages. Never send automated welcome tweets, as many people will unfollow you immediately.

7. UNFOLLOWING

Some insist: Unfollow people quietly.

Others claim: It’s courteous to direct message people you unfollow to tell them why.

8. GIVING THANKS FOR RETWEETING

Some insist: Thank every person who retweets you.

Others claim: Thanking people for a retweet is a waste of bandwidth. It implies they were doing you a favor by retweeting you, when, in fact, they were doing something nice for their followers. Instead use @reply or DM, or return the favor by praising something they tweeted.

9. WHAT TO TWEET

Some insist: Don’t be scared of tweeting what you did last night, what you ate for breakfast today or how much fun you had walking your dog. You can tweet just like you would update your Facebook status.

Others claim: People don’t care about the mundane details about your life. You’re supposed to be a content curator, adding value by being a resource to your followers. And above all, make sure your tweets are entertaining, informative and rich with panache.

10. TWITTER MANNERS

Some insist: Don’t be afraid to interact. Don’t feel intimidated or worry about “rules.” Just jump in and start having conversations.

Others claim: Twitter has standards for good manners. Make sure you know the proper etiquette and grammar because people will judge you and won’t take you seriously if you don’t follow the rules.

– You should do 5 automated tweets supplemented by 1-3 spontaneous tweets

– 6-8 tweets a day is way too chatty for someone who isn’t a personal friend

– In a “sustainable and consistent” stream

– 7-20 times per day

– A minimum of 3 times a day for a new user

– Don’t tweet just to tweet

– As much as you want! You can’t get too far by being shy.

– 4-8 tweets a day

– No more than once every 2 hours

– 10-20 tweets per day

12. SCHEDULING TWEETS

Some insist: You should absolutely schedule your tweets so they are spread throughout the day and you can ensure they’re posted at peak hours.

Others claim: Twitter isn’t a broadcast tool. It’s a community of humans interested in building relationships and spontaneous communication. Automation doesn’t achieve this honestly; it’s a glorified spamming plan. A lazy short-cut to social media. You need to listen to and engage your followers.

13. JOINING CONVERSATIONS

Some insist: If you can view a Twitter conversation, it’s fair game for you to jump right in. Forget what you know about not butting in to a conversation between complete strangers. On Twitter, it’s not only acceptable, it’s encouraged.

Others claim: It’s rude to interrupt when people are talking. Observe a conversation on Twitter and enter only when it’s appropriate.If you appear too pushy or intrusive, people will be turned off and ignore you.

14. LURKING VS. ENGAGING

Some insist: It’s ok to just be a content consumer by following “A-listers” and not posting tweets yourself.

Others claim: Without engaging often and authentically, you’ve missed the essence of Twitter.

15. HOW OFTEN TO CHECK TWITTER

Some insist: Plan a couple of daily check-in times and respond to what’s happening at those particular times.

Others claim: Twitter is an instantaneous service where conversations fly by throughout the day and you’ll miss out on a lot if you’re not constantly there in real time.

16. HASHTAGS

Some insist: Don’t abuse hashtags. Use them judiciously, generally when you tweet something that you or others might want to track, like an ongoing event or popular topic, or to provide better context to a tweet.

Others claim: You look hip by using creative hashtags with wild abandon, particularly to punctuate your tweets with a bit of irony or humor.

17. TWITTER CLIENTS

Some insist: No need to use anything other than the web version of Twitter.

Others claim: Definitely use a Twitter client. You need to use Tweet Deck; it’s the best. You need to use HootSuite; it’s the best. You need to use Twhirl; it’s the best. You need to use Twitterific; it’s the best. You need to use Nambu; it’s the best. You need to use Tweetie; it’s the best. You need to use Seesmic; it’s the best.

2 Responses to “22 Reasons Twitter Makes My Head Explode”

Man! I can see why you’re head’s spinning on this one. The real question is *why* do you want to use Twitter? Do you want to be a person just hanging out, chatting with her friends? Or do you want to use Twitter as a vehicle to promote your brand?

Your answer here makes it much easier to decide what your “rules” should be. I do both personal tweeting and professional, brand-based tweeting. For my personal stuff, I do whatever I want whenever I want. I talk to my friends. Sometimes, I ignore Twitter for days at a time. Some days, I tweet a dozen times. I only follow people I want to read, and if someone posts too much or gets annoying, I just unfollow…maybe for a while, maybe forever. It’s my personal circle of communications, so I just do what I feel. People who find me interesting follow me, but I don’t feel obligated to follow anyone I don’t really want to read. There’s no award for many followers.

For work, we tweet regularly — try to have one or two a day…but no more than that. In this scenario, one of the best ways to let people know that you’re tweeting, and to encourage them to follow you, is to follow them. Follow people who follow you. It doesn’t matter how many people you follow — you’re never actually going to read the tweets of the strangers you follow (unless they’re talking about you).

Most importantly, scour Twitter for mentions of you or your brand (and your competitors, if appropriate). Don’t autorespond to thank people for following you, but look at their feed and see if there’s something they’ve said within the last couple of days that’s worth/relevant for you to respond to individually. Remember, Twitter is all about authentic conversation. People see right through the autoresponder junk.

As for unfollowing, there’s no need to mention it when you unfollow someone on your personal feed. But if it’s a brand feed, you’re never going to unfollow anyone, so it doesn’t matter. 🙂 And “what to tweet” — if you’re tweeting to your friends, of course tweet about your dinner. If you’re tweeting your brand, well, if you’ve got a lifestyle brand and dining fits with your brand, go for it!

Never bother to thank people for retweeting your tweets. It’s a waste of bandwidth. And always feel free to jump into conversations. Twitter is a *public* conversation — it’s public to *encourage* you to jump in.

No matter what scenario you’re talking about, though, NEVER repeat your own tweets. OMG never. Ever. Nothing will get you dumped from a feed faster than saying the same thing more than once.

In all scenarios:

#12: go with “Others”. It’s a perfect characterization.
#16: go with “Some”.
#17: Always use a client. The web will make you want to stab your eyes out.
#18: Snob my ass. If you want private lists, use private lists. No one cares about your lists.
#20: There is no best time, unless you’re advertising lunch specials.
#21: Share stuff that you think is worth sharing. Don’t share it unless it’s really excellent. Don’t share it if it’s already all over the internet.

Phew! No wonder you feel like a 98 year old today…you stayed up half the night to share your very generous and sensible input with moi! Thank you for such a fabulous explanation. i think my problem lies in the fact that I can’t seem to separated myself from my brand. Both personally and professionally I’m interested in food/dining, moms/parenting, entertainment news, blogging/social media marketing, and of course my personal friends. I feel schizophrenic and overwhelmed when I try to read everything. I’ve set up TweetDeck into lists for each of those interests, so that’s probably a good thing, right? But I can’t seem to find a schedule or rhythm for logging on, reading and responding.

I will have 4 kid-free weeks this summer to get this all figured out. I think I can…I think I can…I think I can!