Apple sells the iPhone X refurbished for $600. But is its 2017 flagship still better than its new budget iPhone SE?

When the iPhone X first debuted in 2017, it made headlines for several reasons. It was the first iPhone to have Face ID, the first to have an OLED display and the first to have an on-screen notch. At the time it was a top-of-the-class device. Now, three years later, it’s just as reliable. Though Apple discontinued the iPhone X a mere 10 months after its launch, the company sells refurbished models at a heavy discount: $599 or £599 (64GB) and $699 or £699 (256GB). (Apple does not sell or ship refurbished iPhones to Australia, but that converts to about AU$940 and AU$1,100.)

While this may be a tempting option for those looking for a cheaper iPhone, Apple also introduced a new iPhone SE this year for $399 (£419, AU$749). The iPhone SE’s specs and looks are similar to the iPhone 8, which also came out in 2017, but it has plenty of new advantages of its own that make it a better buy than a refurbished iPhone X from Apple.

Though it doesn’t have a second telephoto lens and its screen isn’t as brilliant as the iPhone X, the smaller iPhone SE still has a few upgrades that make it the better value-buy than a discounted iPhone X. That includes an A13 Bionic processor, dual-SIM capabilities and a handful of camera upgrades. (Neither phone has a headphone jack, BTW.) If you’re looking for an affordable, brand new iPhone with up-to-date support, the iPhone SE should be your go-to. Read our Apple iPhone SE (2020) review.

If you own a working iPhone X, there’s no reason to buy the iPhone SE. But if you’re tempted to buy a refurbished one from Apple at the discounted price, I don’t recommend it unless you just really want that second telephoto camera for some reason. For one thing, it’s likely that software updates from Apple may not be as robust on a three-year-old device than on a new one. Second, if you do want all the aforementioned iPhone SE upgrades or a bigger screen, it’s better to get a new iPhone 11, which costs the same as a refurbished iPhone X. Read our Apple iPhone X review.

Design: iPhone X’s bigger, sharper display

Despite being three years older, the iPhone X still looks modern and its stainless steel design comes off as more premium than the iPhone SE’s aluminum body. Besides its obvious notch, the iPhone X is also bigger, and has a sharper display with a higher resolution and pixel density. It has an OLED screen too, as opposed to the iPhone SE’s LCD display. In general, OLED screens are regarded to have better image quality and color contrast, but they also cost more and may suffer burn-in. The iPhone X’s screen is notably brighter, especially at different viewing angles, and it’s a tad more vibrant. I’ve been using an iPhone X for the past three years and haven’t noticed any burn-in issues.

The iPhone SE is Apple’s only new iPhone that has a physical home button. Some people may prefer that because it’s intuitive to use and you don’t have to use swipe gestures to return to the home screen or call up recent apps like you would on the iPhone X. The home button also houses a fingerprint reader for unlocking the phone and authorizing digital payments through Touch ID. For biometric security, the iPhone X uses Face ID, or facial mapping sensors on the front-facing camera.

The iPhone X also has 3D Touch, an older feature that debuted in 2015 in the iPhone 6S. It allows access to additional menu options and commands whenever you hard-press your finger against the screen. Apple began to phase out the feature in 2018 with the iPhone XR, and it’s now absent from new iPhones. Instead, the company replaced 3D Touch with Haptic Touch. Haptic Touch is on the iPhone SE and does pretty much the same thing, except instead of having to press down harder on the screen, you long-press on the item.

Both devices are rated IP67 for water protection. Both come in black and white but the iPhone SE has a third red variant.

Processor, battery, dual-SIM and memory

The iPhone SE is equipped with Apple’s latest proprietary A13 Bionic chip. The iPhone SE clocked in similar results with the iPhone 11 on the benchmark tests 3DMark and Geekbench 5, which is to say that it also performed comparably to — and at times better than — other top-tier phones such as the Galaxy S20, Pixel 4 and the OnePlus 8 Pro. And the iPhone SE’s result for 3DMark’s Ice Storm Unlimited test was way higher (at 97,415 compared to 62,206) than the iPhone 8, which has the same A11 processor as the iPhone X.

Apple never discloses its iPhones’ battery capacities. The company does list the same 13-hour video playback time on both phones, though, and puts the iPhone X’s audio playback at 60 hours compared to the iPhone SE’s 40 hours. However, when we ran our own battery tests for video playback on Airplane mode, the iPhone SE lasted longer than the iPhone X by nearly 4 hours. (To be more specific, the iPhone SE lasted about 15.5 hours, while the iPhone X lasted 11.45 hours.)

The iPhone SE has options for a nano-SIM and an e-SIM too, meaning you can have two numbers on the same phone. Dual-SIM capabilities is also handy if you travel a lot and need a phone abroad, or you want to consolidate both your personal and business phones. And while both phones have a 64GB and 256GB memory option, the new iPhone SE has a third, 128GB model. That capacity is commonly seen as the “sweet spot” as far as storage goes. That’s because 64GB may not be enough to hold all your photos and 4K videos, but 256GB may be too excessive.