Marge had a rabbit just like it when she was younger. Bart found a picture of her and the rabbit and decided to look for one exactly the same to give to her. He does so and Marge loves it.

When Homer was giving Marge his present, a phone call from Paula Paul and a signed Puree-Station 3, he was waiting for the phone call which never came. He found out that this was because the rabbit had chewed through the phone cable and was then chewing on the lamp's cable. Homer got angry at the "monster". Bart then picks it up and starts to talk to it.

Later, which watching the news on the TV, Bart is lying next to the rabbit. Even later, Homer is seen walking both Santa's Little Helper and the rabbit. He then finds out that he is the subject of the graffiti around town, drinks a beer and then goes to find a car to drive, leaving the rabbit and Santa's Little Helper.