A spicy, sexy fragrance. Black Pepper by Molton Brown available at Nieman's.

A retro rad pocket square for wearing his heart in his pocket, instead of on his sleeve. Drake's from Mr. Porter.

Rather than a box of chocolates, how about a bottle of chocolatey booze? Nothing artificial but a product with true indie gourmet bona fides; Kings County Distillery moonshine infused with cocoa hulls from Mast Brothers Chocolate. From Drink Up NY.