you know i really do like the lyrics to this song and i am a kelly clarkson fan, but i just cant imagine this song (or her) being in the movie/soundtrack, i think she is almost too commercial, however if someone else sang this and brought the beat out more it might really fit the movie, but the lyrics are great. i am re-reading NM right now so this song hit hard haha. :) love ya twicrack!

Wow, perfect lyrics, and this was leftover from her "My December" cd, it fits perfectly well with the movie and the mood, like it was written specifically for this scene. Funny how things happen/work out huh?...I agree with Anonymous on top, "Save You" would also be perfect for the scene but from Edward's perspective. You go Kelly!!! Hope you make it in the cd.

I like the song but I don't love it. I loved the songs Kerri suggested. I can see the wolves running through the forest to the Mettalica song and Let it die would be perfect for Jacob when Edward comes back and Bella chooses him.

Shes not good 4 new moon Paramore is more hardcore!!!!!!!!!! THEY HAVE 2 DO ANOTHER1!!!the lyrics 4 KC DO NOT match the new moon story!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!

Yeah, the lyrics work, but the chorus is WAY too repetitious. Like seriously, switch it up a little. It just goes on and on and on, over and over and over. I listened til halfway through the second chorus and then turned it off. Couldn't take it. Kelly Clarkson's alright, but I don't know if she's the right fit for the New Moon soundtrack.

I want WITHIN TEMPTATION on the soundtrack!!! They have SOOOOO many songs that could work - and they have the right sound too. Especially "Memories" for when Edward leaves and "All I Need" for Bella's anxiety about Edward leaving again after they reunite.

Go on youtube and look up these two songs and listen to others as well. They're AMAZING! Kinda along the lines of Paramore, but with a darker, more mature sound. LOVE THEM!

They also have awesome songs that could fit the whole Wolf and Volturi aspects of the book, I just gotta figure out which ones exactly. :D

Ugh!I couldn't listen to the whole thing. The lyrics at the very beginning were okay, but the singing during the chorus was like nails on a chalkboard for me. I liked the less mainstream songs that they had on the Twilight soundtrack. I hope they go that route again.

I liked the song it's fine but I don't think it is "THE" song. I liked the music in Twilight but I really wish that Edward and Balla would have had "Their Song" you know the one that plays during a really romantic part of the movie and whenever you hear it on the radio you get really excited because it makes you remember all the lovey feeling you felt while watching the movie. Sorry, I'm really rambling. Hope this makes sense to someone but it probably wont.

I would like 2 c the group EISLEY on the soundtrack. They r WONDERFUL & have a couple of songs that would go really well with the movie."COMBINATIONS" is a good song 4 when Edward & Bella r n her room & he tells her he will never leave her again & "BLACKENED CROWN" 4 when Bella puts herself n danger.

Check these songs out on myspace music & youtube. I'd love 2 know what people think about these songs.

Kelly Clarkson has a good voice and all. But for one, I don't like the song it really has no memorable melody. Two, I just cannot see it being used for New Moon. NO WAY! Whatever is used for New Moon, it has to be dripping with emotion and kinda dark.

Kelly Clarkson is one of my favorite artists,I know all her songs by heart. This song will work FABULUSLY in New Moon. Another one Kelly's songs that will work is Behind These Hazel Eyes from her ablbum Breakaway.