Try it out. A sociologist friend, Kieran Healy, tipped me off to this. Until there have been about 10,000 comparisons or so, the results probably won't make a lot of sense--so everyone do their part, and cast 50 votes or so! (I've listed 55 law schools for purposes of this survey.)

UPDATE (1/9/11): So with votes on more than 20,000 comparisons, here are the results so far--not utterly crazy (though testimony to the dominance of US News in how even academics think about school quality, with a handful of exceptions):