HollywoodLife.com‘s Editor-in-Chief Bonnie Fuller just doesn’t believe it’s possible for a girl to hook up with a guy without having feelings. Sure, you can have a one-night-stand, but hooking up with your best guy friend repeatedly is just bad news. But our Contributing Editor David Caplan thinks it’s actually totally doable and that everyone should at least try it once!

Check out Friends With Benefits when it hits theaters this weekend and tell us whose side you’re on!