now THERE is a brilliant idea ! thanks bob. the best part is, anyone can edit the wiki, so you can add threads (even other people's threads) to your heart's content.

There is, of course, already a page devoted to reviews of books on the wiki and has been for a while now. Reviews and recommendations are easily added and there is a category. Links can be used to refer back to the discussions in the forum devoted to recommendations and thus they won't get lost even if they become dormant.