I am brand new to the black powder shooting hobby , I have read a lot of stuff and the more i read the more confused i get :-) What do I need to buy in the way of shooting supplies for my pistol . I have all the hardware but i read about many different patches and caps and such things . Some with grease some without , I read about something called Bore butter?? that you stick in the cylinder after loading is it compulsory ??? The powder goes in then a cap then the ball then the butter ???? , Some say that lard works as well or some such stuff .I just want to do what is right and safe , so any advice will be well received . I buy most of my items online so any suggestions as to where i might get all this stuff would be helpful also :-)
Thanks Guys

Read Gatofeo's sticky at the top of this forum. It will probably answer 90% of your questions.
Then we can help with the remainder. Basically you've mushed together a bunch of either/or's into a mess which is why nits so confusing..

__________________
Allan Quatermain: “Automatic rifles. Who in God's name has automatic rifles”?

Hey Knotty, I'm just across the river from you. Just read the threads and you will learn. The knowledgeable people on here will answer all the questions you have. I got into this about two years ago and the folks on here helped me immensely. I'm totally hooked now, and loving BP shooting. Have fun!

I am brand new to the black powder shooting hobby , I have read a lot of stuff and the more i read the more confused i get :-) What do I need to buy in the way of shooting supplies for my pistol . I have all the hardware but i read about many different patches and caps and such things . Some with grease some without , I read about something called Bore butter?? that you stick in the cylinder after loading is it compulsory ??? The powder goes in then a cap then the ball then the butter ???? , Some say that lard works as well or some such stuff .I just want to do what is right and safe , so any advice will be well received . I buy most of my items online so any suggestions as to where i might get all this stuff would be helpful also :-)
Thanks Guys

To shoot, you will need powder, balls, caps, and, probably, filler and lube.

You will probably want to use 3F powder. Some people have found superior accuracy using 2F, but 3F is commonly used for pistols.

The amount of powder depends on the bullet caliber. Historical 1851 Navies were .36 caliber. Some reproductions are made in .44. I don't know what yours is.

You will probably find that optimal accuracy is delivered at a sub-maximum load. For .36 caliber, some people shoot 12-15 grains. For .44 caliber, some people shoot 18-25 grains.

Most people shoot round balls and the reproduction revolvers are said to have twist rates optimized for them or small conicals. Your balls should be of a size such that when they are rammed into a chamber it shaves off a small ring of lead all the way around the ball. This is critical as it insures a gas-tight fit. Without this, there is an increased chance of a "chain fire" where firing a chamber sets off the chambers next to it.

You should seat the ball only so deep that it is flush with the face of the cylinder. The idea is that by being seated closer to the rifling it will not be moving so fast when it engages the rifling and so less apt to strip lead.

If you are not using a maximum powder load, this may result in an air gap between the powder charge and the ball. This must be filled with some kind of filler or wad. I use cream of wheat.

Many people spread lube over the mouth of the chamber on top of the ball. This lubricates the bullet but also keeps the powder fouling soft making cleanup easier and allowing for more shots to be fired before the gun becomes too fouled to shoot. Many people claim this helps prevent chain fires but I am of the opinion that the majority of this is solved by a proper-fitting bullet. People have lots of recipes or store-bought solutions for this. Plain Crisco works. I use 50/50 beeswax/Crisco.

I suggest heading over to YouTube and searching for "how to load a black powder revolver" and you will no doubt find many videos of people loading and shooting BP revolvers.

You should seat the ball only so deep that it is flush with the face of the cylinder. The idea is that by being seated closer to the rifling it will not be moving so fast when it engages the rifling and so less apt to strip lead.

If you are not using a maximum powder load, this may result in an air gap between the powder charge and the ball. This must be filled with some kind of filler or wad. I use cream of wheat.

To clarify for a new shooter:

There must NEVER be an air gap. If you choose to shoot a load that puts you in conflict with the ball position regarding the chamber face & a ball sitting on a powder charge that allows it to sit deeper ALWAYS pick the option where the ball contacts (& even slightly compresses) the charge. The purpose of the filler mentioned is to fill that potentially dangerous air gap.

__________________
Allan Quatermain: “Automatic rifles. Who in God's name has automatic rifles”?

When I loaded my Remington last weekend (for the first time), I just pressed the ball in as deep as it would go to the limits of the loading lever rotation, my estimate is that the top of the ball was 1/4" below the top of the chamber. I'm not sure if there was an air gap, but I suspect not much, if any, as the lubricated wad under the ball is fairly thick in its own right. I used 1.3cc of powder, about the equivalent of 23 grains of FFFg (except it was Pyrodex P).

I didn't use any additional lube on top of the bullet, my reading and forum feedback indicated it was not necessary as long as the wads were used. Also, the bullet did shave a thin lead ring, which also assured me that I had a tight seal.

I think the whole point of putting lube ahead of the bullet is to prevent chamber flashover. Multiple discharges are not pleasant and potentially dangerous, although I have had it happen a couple of times with no damage to the gun.

This email link is to reach site administrators for assistance, if you cannot access TFL via other means. If you are a TFL member and can access TFL, please do not use this link; instead, use the forums (like Questions, Suggestions, and Tech Support) or PM an appropriate mod or admin.

If you are experiencing difficulties posting in the Buy/Sell/Trade subforums of TFL, please read the "sticky" announcement threads at the top of the applicable subforum. If you still feel you are qualified to post in those subforums, please contact "Shane Tuttle" (the mod for that portion of TFL) via Private Message for assistance.

This email contact address is not an "Ask the Firearms Expert" service. Such emails will be ignored. If you have a firearm related question, please register and post it on the forums.