Aaron Tveit and Gavin Creel, two of Broadway’s most appealing leading men (who are possibly twins) took bows as two of its most beloved female characters last night in New York City. Tveit, a stage vet who recently won acclaim as Danny Zuko in Fox’s Grease Live!, performed as Rent‘s Maureen in a dazzling duet of “Take Me or Leave Me” with She Loves Me‘s Gavin Creel taking on her girlfriend Joanne. The pair were among the entertainers who took the stage at Miscast, an annual fundraising gala for the off-Broadway MCC Theater, during which actors perform songs from musicals they would never otherwise get to sing.

Watch the two knock it out of the park below and scroll down to watch Creel deliver a sensational “As If We Never Said Goodbye” as Sunset Boulevard‘s Norma Desmond.