I'm cool with most of the updates, notably "soup" being alcohol (skull smash) and everyone getting drunk at Ayla's party (except Robo). I also like that Ayla's caveman speak is toned down, because she is the chief and the most intelligent caveman, but still a caveman speaking in "me Grimlock" fashion.

But things like a medieval character speaking in present day syntax rather than olde English, or Chrono's mom referring to the talking frog as "sir knight" rather than Mister Toad kill the immersion, detract from the storyline and require logical rigmarole to justify. Ayla can speak caveman yet Frog doesn't speak knightly?

I get that some things need to be updated or rethought to reflect the times, but not at the expense of making logical sense. To bring in a characteristic Dincrest food analogy, some old family recipes could use some tweaking to make them better, but other old family recipes are perfect the way they are and should remain unchanged.

You're missing my point entirely. Nerds have a tendency to refuse or hate on change regardless to whatever effect it might have because Nerd culture is incredibly insular and self-gratifying.

As is with the case of the 'Subs versus Dubs' argument. You have one group arguing to 'keep it as it is' and another group trying to 'restore the original cultural purity' regardless of the continuity errors, bad grammar, dated cultural references, the limitations of the original line or the views of the culture of origin. Both groups argue incessantly over the issue while completely oblivious to the advantages of the other option or even the possibility of a third option.

To borrow from recent examples, nobody's gonna argue that Miracle of 34th Street 90's Edition blows chunks (hell, most Christmas movies tend to due to over-commercialization of the season and how utterly white milquetoast the families involved typically are), but Ye Olde Knavelish is also corny as hell (as nobody outside of a Renaissance Fair ever talks like that).

I get your point. You don't need to preach about the insular nature of subcultures, nerd or otherwise. I saw head-up-the-ass levels of insularity big time in the local punk scene, when I used to gig. And I fully admit to my own head-up-the-ass tendencies. We all have those.

I think the closer analogy in the case of Trigger DS is how some of the ways Lucas updated the classic Star Wars movies, while well-intentioned due to technology finally being able to catch up with his creative vision, were not always successful.

I couldn't care less about insignificant trifles like whether Greedo shot first in New Hope; and I liked the additional footage fleshing out Han's backstory with Jabba. But when Luke sees the ghosts of Yodi, Kenobi, and Anakin at the end of Jedi, why is the new ghost of Anakin Hayden Chrstiansen rather than the redeemed Vader that Luke unmasked? Makes no damn sense and would require conspiracy theory logic-leaps to explain how it "should" make sense. It's as if Lucas got stuck inside his own head.

And I mentioned instances where the updated DS localization did things right in Trigger. But I still think they dropped the ball with Frog. Okay, I suppose I can live with him not saying "thou hath," but Chrono's mom not calling him Mr. Toad took away the humor of that scene and felt like a joke that forgot its punchline.

EDIT: ...On that note, I should probably check myself before I need to be committed to the Please Please Please Get a Life Foundation: https://youtu.be/lNJ6dFwh8a4?t=27

EDIT2: Progress report.

Trigger DS: I beat Slash without much drama. However, Flea had me on the ropes quite a bit, so I want to build levels and TP so Robo gets his party-heal technique. This way I have options and flexibility for both offense and healing.

Cross: I went to Blue Dragon island in Home World. I remembered that I fought the dwarf tank but couldn't remember if I fought the dragon too, so I swapped out Razzly and Kid for Leena and Poshul for better element resistance. I dismantled the tank, got Ice Breath from the dragon, and Rosetta gave Razzly a Wisp Cape. Now, I'm in Mt. Pyre in Another World. Tanky Poshul is a great bullet sponge and Leena is no slouch either. Heavier hitter than Kid or Razzly. I might roll with them a bit, for variety.

My biggest issue with Chrono Cross (as mentioned several times in this playlog) was that the recruitment of Starkey was mishandled. And I agree that the regular battle theme, while a nice piece, isn't the best battle theme. I still prefer it to FF6's regular battle theme, though. FF6 was another game where the soundtrack was damn near perfect... except for a bloody awful battle theme.

The regular battle theme is the music you hear the most often in an RPG, so given that I already found FFVI's unpleasant to listen to, compound that with having to hear it over and over again... *shuddercringe*

Now THIS I had no problem listening to every few seconds: (FFV's battle theme, which is hands-down my favorite of the 16-bit FF battle themes.)

As for Chrono Cross, I said it somewhere before in the thread that once I adjusted my mindset to accept the game for what it truly is rather than expect Trigger 2.0 and fit a square peg into a round hole, I grew to really love the game for its ambitious and often unrestrained creativity. The game dared to be different, flew in the face of many conventions, and is the antithesis of Trigger in many regards. But that's what makes it special. Trigger was special because it broke a lot of conventions and Cross did as well.

I linked to the whole "beautiful melancholy" editorial a few times in this thread, as it so eloquently verbalizes my sentiments.

I'd love to see an HD Director's Cut remaster of Chrono Cross. Yeah, I said it 100,000,000 times before and I just said it again. More than almost anything, Chrono Cross and Xenogears would totally benefit from HD Director's Cut remaster treatment.