Costars say the chemistry was obvious from the start. "I remember being in rehearsal, and the two of them had googly eyes with each other," costar Jake Gyllenhaal said of the couple. "There were sparks immediately," added costar Anne Hathaway. "It was adorable."

The Brooklyn-based duo welcomed their daughter during promotion for the film, with Ledger calling the former Dawson's Creek star the perfect mom.

But the rigorous schedule wasn't easy. "We started promoting the movie about three weeks after [Matilda] was born, which was too soon," she said in a 2006 interview. "I'm just learning lessons now, like learning how to be a working mom."