1. DE Bruce Smith (1985) - Definitely a tough choice between Smith and O.J. Simpson here. I would say Simpson, but went with Smith based on the Bills Forum all-time polls.

2. N/A - The Bills have never drafted at #2 overall.

3. DT Marcell Dareus (2011) - Ken Rice is the only other option.

4. WR J.D. Hill (1971) - Definitely not Mike Williams.

5. WR Jerry Butler (1979) - Most people don’t know that the Bills drafted Hall of Famer Carl Eller in the 1964 AFL draft. Unfortunately the Vikings drafted him as well and Eller chose the Vikings. Obviously a good choice by the Bills, but I went with a player who actually played for Buffalo.

6. N/A - The Bills have never drafted at #6 overall.

7. TE Paul Seymour (1973) - The only choice for this pick, but helped The Electric Company block for The Juice.

8. LB Shane Conlan (1987) - Who wouldn’t take Conlan over Whitner?

9. DT Jim Dunaway (1963) - I realize C.J. Spiller was also drafted at #9, but seven good games is not yet good enough to overtake Dunaway. Dunaway was first or second team All-AFL for four straight years and was a big part of Buffalo’s AFL Title runs in 1964 and 1965.

28. C Eric Wood (2009) - Much like Carl Eller, the Bills drafted Hall of Famer Paul Warfield in 1964, but the Browns also drafted him and he chose to go to Cleveland. The other choices were not terribly overwhelming (FB Booker Moore and CB Thomas Smith), so I went with the young center.

29. RB Joe Cribbs (1980) - Tough choice between Cribbs and CB Nate Odomes (1987). I went with the more talented Cribbs.