After Midnight was performed over 80 times by the Garcia/Saunders band, Legion of Mary and the Jerry Garcia Band between 1972 and 1983.

The song was first recorded by J.J. Cale in 1966 but this version was not fully officially released. The song was next recorded by Eric Clapton for his 1970 solo album. This version was released as a single reaching #18 in the US charts.