I think it would be hard to argue against Brady being the Greatest of all time.

Not that hard.

Joe Montana never threw a pick six in a Super Bowl. He never threw any kind of pick in a Super Bowl. He also never lost.

Brady wouldn't have even won this one if the Falcons had shown some clock management. Three runs up the middle and a field goal.

Beyond that, deflated balls, the tuck rule, spygate... Many of his Super Bowl wins have come with strings attached.

Plus, it's a pretty subjective (and hard to define) thing. He doesn't play defense or special teams, and there are 10 other guys out there with him on offense. Way too much is put on the QB.
It was a great comeback, but it was as much a loss by the Falcons as a win by the Patriots.

Joe Montana never threw a pick six in a Super Bowl. He never threw any kind of pick in a Super Bowl. He also never lost.

Brady wouldn't have even won this one if the Falcons had shown some clock management. Three runs up the middle and a field goal.

Beyond that, deflated balls, the tuck rule, spygate... Many of his Super Bowl wins have come with strings attached.

Plus, it's a pretty subjective (and hard to define) thing. He doesn't play defense or special teams, and there are 10 other guys out there with him on offense. Way too much is put on the QB.
It was a great comeback, but it was as much a loss by the Falcons as a win by the Patriots.