Walmart’s War Against Unions — and the U.S. Laws That Make It Possible

For several years, Walmart’s annual shareholders meeting has been the staging ground for high-profile protests against the retail giant’s treatment of its employees. As Walmart workers from across the country — many of whom are on strike — once again converge this week on the corporation’s headquarters in Bentonville, Arkansas, one startling fact stands out: none of them, or any of the retail giant’s 1.4 million workers, are represented by a union.

Walmart’s success in keeping its American workforce entirely nonunion is, of course, well documented — so much so that observers of the company’s chronic labor strife almost take it for granted. But even in the context of a long national decline in union membership among American workers, it is staggering that the country’s largest employer, and one of its stingiest, has remained union free.

In a blistering 2007 report that sadly still holds true, Human Rights Watch meticulously analyzed how Walmart has taken advantage of the gaping holes in U.S. labor law to turn back every effort at unionization. For example, because American employers are allowed to actively oppose union organizing campaigns, Walmart “bombards workers with the message that disastrous results will ensue if they organize, while largely denying them access to contrary views.”

Perhaps Walmart’s most powerful tool in resisting unionization efforts is the incredibly weak penalties for employers that violate labor law. There are no punitive awards for labor law infractions, which means that employers — particularly those with the enormous resources that Walmart enjoys — have little economic incentive to obey the law.

Even on the rare occasions when efforts to organize Walmart workers have overcome all these obstacles, the company has still managed to prevail. In 2000, for instance, when butchers at a Texas Walmart voted to join the United Food and Commerical Workers Union, Walmart announced two weeks later that it was closing all 180 of its meat counters. In 2004, the company went so far as to close an entire store after its employees voted to unionize.

It’s not surprising that, given Walmart’s determination to remain nonunion and the complicity of U.S. labor law in supporting this goal, Walmart workers and their supporters have turned to non-traditional alternatives. The caravans transporting striking Walmart employees to Bentonville this week are part of this growing movement, which has succeeded in keeping the company on the defensive about its labor practices. These workers will need every ounce of creative strength they can muster to prevail against a system that is stacked against them, and a corporation that has mastered that system.

Julie Gutman Dickinson is partner in the union-side law firm Bush, Gottlieb, Singer, Lopez, Kohanski, Adelstein & Dickinson. She also serves on the Advisory Board of the Los Angeles Alliance for a New Economy.

READ THIS NEXT:

By clicking and submitting a comment I acknowledge the Capital & Main Privacy Policy and agree to the Capital & Main Terms of Service. I understand that my comments are also being governed by Facebook's Terms of Use and Privacy Policies as applicable, which can be found here.