“M!Countdown” notified the girls in the sneakiest way of their win (clip below). First, they are told to record the usual introductions for the group and the show. Then they are asked to film the introduction to the winner for this week, unaware that the winner has already been determined (and that it’s them!). It’s kind of adorable how they react to the news; they literally weren’t expecting to win!

Meanwhile, SISTAR was followed by AOA, BIGBANG, Teen Top, MAMAMOO, Baek Ah Yeon, EXO, 2PM, BTS, and SLEEPY to fill out the top 10 this week.