Which Color Lipstick Do You Like Best on Ashlee Simpson?

On Monday night, Ashlee Simpson wore bright red lipstick to the Vive Le Karaoke Event at rocker boyfriend Pete Wentz's bar. The next night, she showed up to the CosmoGirl Born to Lead Awards in New York City wearing barely-there buff-colored lipstick. If you were Ashlee's friend, which color lipstick would you suggest she wear to her next party?

Wow , she really looks like she's a drug addict. The pale lips are much prettier but I don't like them combined with the weird eye color. The red lips really need to be worn with a flawless face and it doesn't look like she's wearing concealer or foundation here.

I think the nude definitely looks better on her, but I also think the photo of the red is not that great of a shot of her, so it's hard to compare to two. But I like the buff look, she looks more ethereal.

that nude natural makeup is really beautiful on her. and ive never ever liked any of her looks!!
i know what you guys mean about her plastic surgery. and its not just a nose job. she did her jaw, chin, and lips as well.
im not so sure why she changed her entire face, but if she feels better about herself this way, i wont judge her.
but her face did have more character and she was more recognizeable before.

The buff BY FAR! She looks BEAUTIFUL in that second picture! I've never seen such a good picture of her, I normally don't find her to be too pretty -- sorry! But its the truth. That pic is def. an exception though - love it. Whoever did her makeup/hair/outfit should continue to!
xoxo

I love the Nude/Buff/whatever on her but it doesn't hurt that she rocks the smokey eye look with her beautiful peepers.
but yeah, she looks nothing like herself. My teenage neighbor commented she looks like every other generic girl in school. But it's those girls that are IT at their school. Hmmmmm..