Preemption

Military Action and Moral Justification

Edited by Henry Shue and David Rodin

Research from leading figures in the ethics, history, & politics of war

Lively debate with contending positions vigorously defended

Preemption

Military Action and Moral Justification

Edited by Henry Shue and David Rodin

Description

The dramatic declaration by President George W. Bush that, in light of the attacks on 9/11, the United States would henceforth be engaging in "preemption" against such enemies as terrorists armed with weapons of mass destruction forced a wide-open debate about justifiable uses of military force. Opponents saw the declaration as a direct challenge to the consensus, which has formed since the ratification of the Charter of the United Nations, that armed force may be used only in defense. Supporters responded that in an age of terrorism defense could only mean "preemption." This volume provides the historical, legal, political, and philosophical perspective necessary to intelligent participation in the on-going debate, which is likely to last long beyond the war in Iraq. Thorough defenses and critiques of the Bush doctrine are provided by the most authoritative writers on the subject from both sides of the Atlantic.

Is a nation ever justified in attacking before it has been attacked? If so, under precisely what conditions? Does the possibility of terrorists with weapons of mass destruction force us to change our traditional views about what counts as defense? This book provides the most comprehensive assessment to date of the justifiability of preemptive or preventive military action. Its engaging debate, accompanied by an analytic Introduction, focuses probing criticism against the most persuasive proponents of preemptive attack or preventive war, who then respond to these challenges and modify or extend their justifications.

Authors of recent pivotal analyses, including historian Marc Trachtenberg, international relations professor Neta Crawford, law professor David Luban, and political philosopher Allen Buchanan, are confronted by other authoritative writers on the nature and justification of war more broadly, including historian Hew Strachan, international normative theorist Henry Shue, and philosophers David Rodin, Walter Sinnott-Armstrong, and Suzanne Uniacke. The resulting lively and many-sided exchanges shed historical, legal, political, and philosophical light on a key policy question of our time. Going beyond the simple dichotomies of popular discussion the authors reflect on the nature of all warfare, the arguments for and against it, and the possibilities for the moral to constrain the military and the political in the face of grave threat.

This book is a project of the Oxford Leverhulme Programme on the Changing Character of War.

Preemption

Military Action and Moral Justification

Edited by Henry Shue and David Rodin

Table of Contents

Introduction, Henry Shue and David Rodin1. Preemption and Prevention in Historical Perspective, Hew Strachan2. Preventive War and U.S. Foreign Policy, Marc Trachtenberg3. On Getting One's Retaliation in First, Suzanne Uniacke4. The False Promise of Collective Security Through Preventive War, Neta C. Crawford5. Justifying Preventive War, Allen Buchanan6. The Problem with Prevention, David Rodin7. Preventive War and Human Rights, David Luban8. Preventive War - What Is It Good For?, Walter Sinnott-Armstrong9. What Would A Justified Preventive Military Attack Look Like?, Henry Shue

Preemption

Military Action and Moral Justification

Edited by Henry Shue and David Rodin

Author Information

Henry Shue is Senior Research Fellow at the Centre for International Studies at Oxford University.

David Rodin is a Research Fellow in Philosophy at the Oxford Leverhulme Programme on the Changing Character of War and Senior Research Fellow at the Centre for Applied Philosophy and Public Ethics at the Australian National University.

Contributors:

Henry Shue, Senior Research Fellow, Centre for International Studies, Oxford University David Rodin, Research Fellow in Philosophy, Changing Character of War Programme, Oxford University Hew Strachan, Chichele Professor of the History of War, Oxford University Marc Trachtenberg, Professor of Political Science, University of California at Los Angeles Suzanne Uniacke, Reader in Applied Ethics, University of Hull Neta C. Crawford, Professor of Political Science, Boston University Allen Buchanan, James B. Duke Professor of Philosophy and Public Policy, Duke University David Luban, University Professor, Georgetown University Law Center Walter Sinnott-Armstrong, Professor of Philosophy and Hardy Professor of Legal Studies, Dartmouth College

Preemption

Military Action and Moral Justification

Edited by Henry Shue and David Rodin

Reviews and Awards

"This volume provides essential interdisciplinary consideration of the whole range of questions raised by the novel threats and challenges posed to the international system by nonstate actors bent on mass attacks and/or threatening. Its combination of historical perspective and philosophical theory, and its examination of the international system and of various policy options, makes it a deeply informed contribution to a very important contemporary debate." --Ethics and International Affairs