Fitness Advice That Doesn't Work

You can't walk into a gym these days without hearing someone spout "surefire" exercise tips. But with all the bad advice floating around, teasing out the effective training tips from the fitness myths can be more difficult than getting through a grueling workout. To help you sort fitness fact from fiction, here is some of the most common fitness advice that doesn't work -- along with expert tips that do.

The reality: "Crunches cause your abdominal muscles to contract, which will increase their strength and endurance, [but] crunches burn very few calories," says Michele Olson, Ph.D., a professor of exercise science at the Human Performance Laboratory at Auburn University at Montgomery in Alabama. You need to burn 3,500 calories to lose just 1 pound of fat, and doing 50 or more crunches won't even come close to burning that much. A better workout tip: "A flat abdominal area with little fat covering the muscles requires a combined effort from an appropriate diet and other calorie-burning workout activities like jogging or spinning classes," Olson says. The takeaway? Combine cardio with ab-strengthening exercises and a healthy diet, and you'll have a flat belly in no time.

The reality: Variety is the mark of a good workout, not hours spent doing the same thing. "Mix it up, even in the same workout," says Michael Maina, Ph.D., an associate professor of health and human performance at Roanoke College in Salem, Va. "Spend five minutes on the treadmill, five minutes on the stair climber, and five minutes on a rowing machine." A varied workout is more motivating, and you'll gain extra benefits by changing up the muscle groups you're working.

The reality: Hot yoga might be all the rage, but that doesn't mean these workouts are high-octane calorie burners. "You will burn the same number of calories doing a series of sun salutations or other yoga moves regardless of the temperature of your environment," Olson says. "Fitness and calorie expenditure come from moving your body weight against gravity. The resistance from gravity does not change the intensity of your workout when temperatures change."

The reality: "Fitness is actually measured in five dimensions: strength, speed, agility, endurance, and flexibility," says certified personal trainer Amanda L. Ebner, MA, MEd, a FitOrbit.com Top 10 Trainer. "If you focus only on the old-fashioned cardio-and-weights duality, you will miss out on some amazing workout alternatives, such as power lifting (strength), high-intensity interval training (speed), team sports (agility), marathon/triathlon training (endurance), and yoga (flexibility)." Among her tips: Try to identify the areas of fitness in which you are weakest and take up a workout activity targeted at building those missing skills.
Flickr photo by sportsandsocial

The reality: "Weight machines are generally designed based on the dimensions of the average-sized male, which can place your knees, back, and shoulders into positions where muscles are not pulling at the proper angle," Olson says. "This can harm your joints." She adds that one advantage of using free weights for the strength-training portion of your workout is that you can lift, press, and curl them with your natural range of motion. Another tip: "Free weights also engage more of your spine-supporting core muscles and help improve balance, preventing common lifestyle muscle pulls, joint strain and falls," she says.

The reality: No reliable fitness tip should advocate true pain as part of workout success. "There is a difference between being a little sore and being injured," Maina says. "You should feel a slight fatigue or mild discomfort following a good workout, but you shouldn't feel so sore that it affects your daily functioning."
Flickr photo by lululemon athletica

The reality: "Stretching cold muscles, tendons and ligaments can actually harm them since they are relatively stiff to begin with," Olson says. "Instead, warm up your muscles at the beginning of a workout by doing dynamic movements, such as walking briskly for five minutes, performing half-squats with just your body weight, and marching with high knees. These activities will increase circulation of oxygen-rich blood to your muscles and literally warm them -- increase their metabolism, which produces heat. Save static stretching for the cooldown part of your workout, when your muscles are very warm and extensible."

The reality: "Muscle length is fixed once we reach our adult height," Olson says. "However, Pilates and dancer-style workouts often emphasize various posture factors, such as keeping your neck long, your upper body lifted, and your spine lengthened." Learning how to hold your body and conditioning the muscles that support a "stand tall" mantra may make you appear slimmer and more elongated. "But these workouts don't actually cause your muscles to grow or increase in true length," Olson says.

The reality: "True, the elliptical machine can minimize some of the jarring impact of running on knees and ankles, but the angle of the incline can also put your hips at risk if you have hip replacements or injuries," Ebner says. "If you have hip issues, walking and cycling are better cardiovascular workout choices." An additional tip for fans of elliptical machines: Because they minimize lower-body impact, they don't build bone density the way running or jogging can, Ebner emphasizes.

The reality: When you're working out hard, you need those carbs to keep you going. "Going low on carbs will rob your muscles and vital body organs such as your heart and kidneys (which are also composed of muscle tissue) from the energy they need to contract and prevent the muscle beds from being broken down, which happens in people who eat low-carb diets," Olson says. She adds that people who exercise regularly need only about 6 to 8 ounces of protein a day, which most adults get without even trying: "If you are an avid exerciser, you can get enough daily protein in just two medium grilled chicken breasts and one glass of low-fat milk."
Flickr photo by Andrea_Nguyen