Tuesday, June 25, 2013

Just because
people think you’re a goth band, just because you’ve studied opera, just because
you play synths in minor keys, just because your dance moves make it look like
you’re casting spells—it doesn’t all mean you can’t make a
dance-floor-friendly, upbeat album.

Toronto’s
Austra was perhaps accurately pegged as post-teen-angst pop music for
burgeoning coven leaders. Here, however, after being on the road for two years
straight—including stints opening stadium shows for The Gossip in Europe and
with buzz act The XX—they’re ready to raise the roof and give their fervent
audience the dance party they’ve been waiting for.

Lead singer
Katie Stelmanis is still a drama queen, and her quivering tremolo is far
removed from expectations of disco divas; it remains an acquired taste. But it
sounds considerably warmer here, surrounded by the Lightman twins (who also
perform psychedelic folk music as Tasseomancy); one of whom, Sari, assisted
with all the lyrics. Bassist Dorian Wolf (ex-Spiral Beach) and electronic
percussionist Maya Postepski have also helped bring Stelmanis out of her
solo-composer shell and surrender to the rhythm.

Much of
Olympia owes a debt less to the Nine Inch Nails devotees of the last two
decades than it does ’80s and ’90s house music (the most mainstream incarnation
of which would have been Madonna’s “Express Yourself”); it’s somewhat jarring
to hear flourishes of Latin percussion in the middle of an Austra song, yet it
works—nowhere more so than on “Home,” which opens with clunky quarter-note
piano chords that sound like a lonely schoolgirl clumsily setting her diary to
music. Forty seconds later, the beat kicks in, the piano suddenly perks up, a
bubbly bass arrives, and suddenly we’re in the middle of what could be the
anthem of summer 2013 (or at least Pride festivities—and a Kevin Saunderson
remix helps the case).

Olympia is a
stirring, sexy and soulful record; it’s either the darkest disco album or the
most joyous goth dance party you’ll ever witness. Either way, it’s certainly
transgressive and occasionally transcendent. (June 20)

Download: “Forgive
Me,” “Painful Like,” “Home”

Barenaked
Ladies - Grinning Streak (Warner)

You can’t
keep a good band down. The Barenaked Ladies could easily have packed it in
following the tumultuous departure of co-frontman Steven Page, and listening to
their first post-Page album, 2010’s All in Good Time, it was a fair question as
to whether they should. Three years later, there’s nothing tentative about
Grinning Streak, and the four remaining members haven’t sounded this
re-energized in at least 10 years. Ed Robertson is, after 25 years in front of
a microphone, singing stronger than ever. Jim Creeggan and Tyler Stewart are
particularly punchy as a rhythm section, and Kevin Hearn continues to sprinkle
digital fairy dust with various keyboards, including a jazzy piano solo and an
ambient synth intro on opening track Limits. The production by Gavin Brown
(Billy Talent, Sarah Harmer) and Howie Beck (Jason Collett, Feist) aims for pop
radio saturation on every track, while Robertson’s songs alternate between
Cars-era new wave and countrified dad rock done unusually well. For a band that
many didn’t think would survive their million-selling debut, the third act is
now shaping up remarkably well. (June 6)

Download: “Odds
Are,” “Limits,” “Gonna Walk”

By Divine
Right – Organized Accidents (Hand Drawn Dracula)

By Divine
Right never sold a million records, but one of its former members (Feist) has.
By Divine Right never transformed the city of Toronto, but some of its former
members did (Broken Social Scene). By Divine Right had their brief moment in
the sun in the late ’90s with a video in rotation on MuchMusic and an opening
slot on The Tragically Hip’s national arena tour. Almost 15 years later, Jose
Contreras is on his latest set of bandmates and, for those still paying
attention, is arguably sounding better than ever. “I’m not gonna watch all my
dreams die,” he sings, “when I still got a dream on the inside.”

Lone gone
are their grungy days of the ’90s; BDR in 2013 are a trippy, sparse psychedelic
pop band who turn happy sonic accidents into fully formed pop songs: “stupid
perfection, infinite charm / got no direction, meaning no harm.” Contreras
hasn’t abandoned buoyant rock music (“Mutant Message,” “No One Can Fix Me”),
but even then he leaves lots of spaces in between for guitar textures, soaring
harmonies and tiny keyboards.

Contreras
has earned his due as an elder statesman of Toronto’s music scene, but as this
record shows, not as one who sits around and talks about past glories, but as
one who continues to push himself to create greatness. (June 6)

Download: “Past
the Stars,” “Mutant Message,” “We F’n’R”

Camera
Obscura - Desire Lines (4AD)

The
Pastels – Slow Summits (Domino)

Scotland
isn’t renowned for its cheery weather, but a particularly damp season must have
spawned these two albums by Scottish pop bands: one dating back over 30 years,
the other one of Glasgow’s most celebrated bands of the last decade.

Camera
Obscura perfected Scottish sad-sack songcraft on their first four albums,
particularly 2003’s aptly titled Underachievers Please Try Harder. But Desire
Lines, their first in four years, represents a band out of steam, their already
sleepy sound now nearly somnambulant, with no punchy pop songs to shake up the
pace. Expertly executed, as always, but when you hear Tracyanne Campbell sing
about how she had “a New Year’s resolution to write something of value,” you
wish she’d kept her word.

The Pastels
have been a band since 1981, revolving around the duo of Stephen McRobbie and
Katrina Mitchell, tweaking their brand of twee through the decades and roping
in members of Teenage Fanclub, the Vaselines and other Scots of note. Here,
they travel to Chicago to work with producer John McEntire (Tortoise, Broken
Social Scene), who hooks them up with plenty of twinkling keyboards,
glockenspiels and flutes to decorate their hushed vocals. It sounds lovely,
except grossly ill-suited to the limited vocal skills of the two principals—who
also didn’t seem to get around to writing any songs in the 16 years since their
last album. It’s hard to imagine even avid fans tuning in anymore. (June 13)

Download
Camera Obscura: “New Year’s Resolution,” “Do It Again,” “Fifth in Line to the
Throne”

Download: “Check
My Heart,” “Secret Music,” “Plus You”

Dirty
Beaches – Drifters / Love is the Devil (Zoo)

Alex Zhang
Hungtai doesn’t like to give us easy answers. The Montreal artist behind Dirty
Beaches buries his vocals in rockabilly reverb; his drum machines are dirty and
ragged; his synthesizers are falling apart in the middle of a song; his guitars
are alien instruments. Everything about Dirty Beaches sounds like a cassette
that’s been decaying in a time capsule, perhaps made by someone in the ’70s
trying to anticipate what pop music might be like a few decades further into
the space age. It’s David Lynchian, to be sure—but not the David Lynch of Blue
Velvet and Twin Peaks, but the David Lynch of Lost Highway and Inland Empire,
where the familiar (in this case, shades of Gene Vincent, Suicide and New
Order) quickly becomes f--ked up beyond all recognition in a nightmarish
hallucination.

At least,
that (somewhat) describes Drifters, one of the two halves of this double album.
The companion, Love is the Devil, is an equally strange but considerably more
calming instrumental suite of what sounds like ambient avant-garde jazz
achieved by manipulating tape of scrambled radio signals. It’s not something
you’d likely ever play when it’s not 2 a.m. while driving through the shadier
side of town or through a misty countryside and reminiscing about the late, great CBC show Brave New Waves. But that doesn’t make it any less
fascinating. (June 20)

Download: “Night
Walk,” “Au Revoir Mon Visage,” “ELLI”

Michael
Feuerstack - Tambourine Death Bed (Forward)

Formerly
known as Snailhouse, Michael Feuerstack has spent much of his career as a
sideman—most recently with the Luyas and Bell Orchestre—but his own
discography, including this debut under his own name, is quietly consistent and
captures one of this country’s strongest songwriters. There’s nothing at all
showy about Feuerstack’s vocals, songwriting or guitar playing, which makes it
easy to take for granted—or worse, to ignore. Feuerstack is the kind of artist
that rewards close, intimate listening. Contributions from Arcade Fire’s Jeremy
Gara, Little Scream’s Laurel Sprengelmeyer and Colin Stetson are just as delicate
and subtle as Feuerstack’s own delivery. Lean in, listen closely. (June 6)

“Sadder than
the moon”—it’s not just a chorus sung by Magnetic Fields’ Stephin Merritt on
this new album by one of his many side projects, it also sums up the tone of
the whole project. Merritt doesn’t write the music for Future Bible Heroes; he
writes the lyrics, melodies and sings the occasional song, leaving his
long-time foil Claudia Gonson to tackle most vocals. All other musical duties
are handled by Christopher Ewen, whose CV is considerably smaller than his
collaborators.

Partygoing
is the first Future Bible Heroes album in 11 years—and it’s not worth the wait.
(Though it does mean that the band’s new home at Merge Records is rereleasing
all earlier material.) Ewan’s synth-only arrangements are leaden and far
removed from the playful wit of Merritt’s pen. Not to scapegoat Ewan, but were
Merritt to hand over these melodies and lyrics to just about anyone else, they
would come to life as opposed to withering on the vine the way they do
here—these arrangements are dour even by Merritt’s sad-sack standards. Sadder
than the moon, indeed. (June 6)

Download: “A
New Kind of Town,” “All I Care About is You,” “Digging My Own Grave”

The
Heliocentrics – 13 Degrees of Reality (Now Again)

You think
Tame Impala and Flaming Lips are trippy? They’ve got nothing on this jazz-funk
band from London, the kind of psychedelic band who don’t require drug intake on
the part of the listener, because the music is the most heady intoxicant and
hallucinogen imaginable. The Heliocentrics could be a long-lost 1970
collaboration between Miles Davis and Pink Floyd (the year of both Bitches Brew
and Atom Heart Mother), only this time the drummer is in charge—bandleader
Malcolm Catto— and groove is king.

Since their
2007 debut, the Heliocentrics have been collaborating with Ethiopian jazz
legend Mulatu Astatke, New Orleans-via-Tehran instrumentalist Lloyd Miller, and
abstract hip-hop MCs Doom and Vast Aire. On this long-awaited follow-up, they
embark on a dark and strange journey into spooky, slightly paranoid, and murky
musical waters. Ostensibly just a trio of Catto, bassist Jake Ferguson and
guitarist Ade Owusu—the latter easily conjures the soundscapes Hendrix achieved
at his most ambitious—the Heliocentrics’ sound is sparse yet rich with
mysterious, unidentifiable overtones: is that a Japanese koto or a kalimba run
through a distortion pedal and plenty of reverb? Where are we, anyway? Who
cares?

For all its
disorientation, 13 Degrees of Reality doles out its doses in short bursts: most
songs are less than four minutes, with plenty of interstitial interludes
scattered throughout. This is jazz funk that will frighten your more polite
dinner guests; wait until only the most adventurous and trustworthy lingerers
remain before slapping this on at a party. (June 13)

Download: “Mysterious
Ways,” “Mr. Owusu I Presume?,” “Wrecking Ball”

Jaffa
Road – Where the Light Gets In (Independent)

I’ll
admit that there’s a certain kind of cross-cultural music played by clean-cut
music professors that drives me crazy, music that, however well-intentioned,
tries to be something to everyone and fails at everything except acting as
music stings between traffic reports on CBC Radio One. On the surface, Jaffa
Road is that band. Underneath the depth of this recording, however, they are so
much more.

The
CV: Commanding vocalist Aviva Chernick is schooled in Sephardic Jewish music,
which informs her melodies here, set to backing by a guitarist who plays
Persian stringed instruments (oud and saz) and a sax player schooled in Indian
music, along with well-rounded bassist Chris Gartner (Look People, Loreena
McKennitt) and percussionist Jeff Wilson (Autorickshaw, Maza Meze).

That
they’re all exceptional, virtuosic musicians is a given; it’s their chemistry,
the strength of their grooves, and, most importantly, their
songwriting—haunting, joyous, evocative, melodic—that sets them apart from
dozens of other bands whose collective CD shelves
have more than a few ’90s artifacts from Peter Gabriel’s RealWorld label.

Every
member of Jaffa Road has a dozen projects on the go at any given time; it’s
obvious with every note heard here, however, that Jaffa Road deserves to be
their highest priority. (June 13)

Download:
“On Your Way,” “Ana El Na (Oh Heal Her),” “Rakia”

KJ
– Water (independent)

Alaclair
Ensemble – Les maigres blancs d’Amérique du Noir (Audiogram)

With
the recent release of the long list for Polaris Prize—the critic-voted $30,000
award for best Canadian album, for which I’m on the jury—there’s good reason to
wonder about the visibility of quality hip-hop in Canada: this year, only one made
the list of 40 albums, and that’s the Alaclair Ensemble from Quebec. Like Radio
Radio before them—the franco Acadian hip-hop crew who landed on the Polaris
shortlist a few years ago—Alaclair Ensemble is playful and more musically
astute than their goofy tone might suggest. They owe debts to Dr. Dre’s G-funk,
vintage Euro disco and Outkast, while “Babouine” is a big pop song that sounds
like a Bran Van 3000 and Daft Punk mashup; conversely, “Soucoupe volante” could
be an oddball match between Beastie Boys and Art of Noise. The production is
boffo and bold throughout, and the lyrical flow—regardless of your French
comprehension—is biting. Jokers they may be, but they never miss a beat, and
this is one record that deserves to rise above the pack.

Overlooked
by Polaris was Toronto’s KJ, an artist I’ll admit I’d never heard of until
Water was recommended by a fellow juror. It didn’t make the long list, which is
a real shame: this album is unique not only in Toronto or Canada, but anywhere
else; the only thing close to it today is the psychedelic experimentation of
Shabazz Palaces (formerly of Digable Planets). KJ himself has a skilled
old-school flow not unlike Gang Starr’s Guru, set to future-forward beats ala
Flying Lotus or Boards of Canada. The music is raw, funky, mysterious and
abstract, while KJ himself is crystal clear and engaging throughout. Water is
essential listening; here’s hoping it doesn’t drown in obscurity. (June 27)

Download
KJ: “Bossed Up,” “The Wows,” “Riot”

Download
Alaclair Ensemble: “Pomme,” “Snare Drum,” “Mon cou”

Nathan
Lawr – Chance Encounter (Static Clang)

When
Guelph’s Nathan Lawr reinvented himself as an Afrobeat bandleader in the
Minotaurs, he seemed to be leaving behind the (admittedly modest) career he’d
had as a singer/songwriter, starting with his highly underrated 2003 debut A
Heart Beats a Waltz. He started recording Chance Encounter around the same time
as Minotaurs’ genesis, so it’s here—released mere months after the second
Minotaurs album—that Lawr lets his classic-rock melodies shine, relegating the
rhythm section to a back seat. He’s self-conscious enough to title a song “Nathan
Lawr’s 364th Dream About Bob Dylan,” and the rest of this
EP, warmly captured by producers Andy Magoffin (Great Lake Swimmers) and Dave
MacKinnon (Fembots), could easily have been released in 1975 (think Blood on
the Tracks, Tonight’s the Night). While Minotaurs may be his main focus these
days—and deservedly so—it’s nice to see him in vintage form here. (June 13)

The
grandfather of Canadian hip-hop returned last year with the Black Tuxedo EP, a
show-stopping tour de force that announced his return after over a decade away
from the recording studio. Which is why expectations for this full-length were
high, and why it’s so disappointing that Wes doesn’t live up either his own
legend—or his last EP.

Orchestrated
Noise is far too long and far too crowded: 18 tracks featuring folks as diverse
as Measha Brueggergosman, Chuck D, Classified, Lights, the Trews, Sam Roberts
and Saukrates. Without exception, the non-hip-hop collabs are terrible—not on
principle, as I’m sure there’s a brilliant opera-hip-hop track waiting to be
made, but the duet between Wes and Brueggergosman is downright embarrassing for
both parties.

Instead,
Wes shines when bridging hip-hop generations with Kardinal Offishall or
new-school Toronto heroes Rich Kidd and Adam Bomb. Too much of Orchestrated
Noise is spent pandering to crossover audiences (sometimes it does work, like
the Blue Rodeo-sampling “Reach For the Sky”; mostly, like on “Black Trudeau,”
it’s just weird). By this point, Wes’s historical role as hip-hop’s ambassador
to Canada should give him enough security to, as he would say, stick to his
vision. (June 27)

Among the
dark horses on this year’s just-announced Polaris Prize long list is Peter
Peter, a Quebec City franco purveyor of wispy vocals and soft-rock production,
not unlike a male counterpart to Coeur de Pirate. This, his second album, is
lush and lovely, just as accessible as the likes of Coldplay (without anglos
having to worry about how bad the lyrics might be), but far more Euro and prone
to left turns. With sax solos and some synths that haven’t been updated in 30
years, some of these tracks could be deep cuts on albums by The Box or Corey
Hart. But there’s also enough sonic invention here that means Peter Peter
wouldn’t sound out of place next to, say Sigur Ros (there’s also a slight vocal
resemblance between Peter and Jonsi). With a bit of a Polaris push, Peter Peter
could easily be the franco act to break through to the rest of Canada in 2013. (June 20)

Download: “Réverbere,” “MDMA,”
“Rien ne se perd rien ne se crée”

Rah
Rah – The Poet’s Dead (Hidden Pony)

Rah
Rah may be the pride of Regina, but this album could well be a mix tape of
Canadian alt-rock of the last 10 years. Are you a fan of the Weakerthans,
Sloan, New Pornographers and Arcade Fire? Then this is the band for you, a CBC
Radio 3 dream come true. What Rah Rah has in common with those bands is not
just a penchant for anthemic, occasionally bombastic pop, but the concise
songwriting to back it up. Shared male-female lead vocals and instrument
juggling add to the eclecticism, and the performances are top-notch. Part of that
may be because they feel time is running out, after five years as a band and
writing their third album: “I spent my 20s on rock’n’roll / I’ll spend my 30s
feeling old.” Nothing here sounds like geezers about to give up the game,
however: Rah Rah are inherently celebratory and sound like they’ll be busting
out the confetti cannons—both literally and metaphorically—for a long time yet. (June 6)

Download:
“Art and a Wife,” “Prairie Girl,” “20s”

Sigur Ros –
Kveikur (XL)

For a band
that perfected a formula—post-Pink Floyd ambient stadium rock—then took
themselves for granted then returned with a career-defining live album (Inni)
and a haunting, minimalist masterpiece of a follow-up (Valtari), what could
possibly be next? Sigur Ros has decided to live large.

Their
lurching tempos are still the same, but the volume has increased considerably.
The departure of keyboardist Kjartan Sveinsson means there is no piano to
temper the more volcanic elements of the other three (including Jonsi
Birgisson’s bowed electric guitar), and drummer Orri Pall Dyrason—who was muted
on 2012’s Valtari—sounds itchy to get back to work. There’s nothing
particularly pretty about much of this Sigur Ros album; even the most rousing
songs, "Isjaki" and "Rafstraumur," are filled with strange scraping sounds filling
in the sonic spaces; the latter in particular attempts to tie together nearly
every stage of the band’s career into one pseudo-pop song, albeit a strange
one.

For a band
that could easily be phoning it in at this point, Sigur Ros are still finding
ways to reinvent their wheel. (June 20)

Download: “Isjaki,”
“Stormur,” “Rafstraumur”

Kanye
West – Yeezus (Universal)

It’s
easy to hate Kanye West for being a “jackass” (President Obama’s term), or for
making dense, difficult albums like this one, which is primarily preoccupied
with racial revenge porn. But the problem is not Kanye: it’s that anyone
bothers taking him seriously, when he’s obviously trying to be as ridiculous as
possible. “I’d rather be a dick than a swallower,” he raps, which pretty much
sums up Yeezus (a word that itself sounds more onomatopoeic as an expression of
exasperation than it is sacrilegious).

Lyrically,
Yeezus is unabashedly misogynist, race-baiting and only occasionally clever.
Kanye repeatedly squanders his talents as a wordsmith on unfunny jokes,
non-sequitur outbursts and blowjob reveries that would seem immature even to a
14-year-old boy.

Yet
even the most virulent ’Ye naysayer would have to have zero sense of irony not
to see the self-parody in a track called “I Am a God (featuring God),” with
lines like, “I am a God / Hurry up with my damn massage / in a French-ass
restaurant / Hurry up with my damn croissants!” It’s hilarious, intentionally
or otherwise; it also happens to be the one track here worth listening to more
than once—not a coincidence.

The
nadir, however, has to be his choice to use the heartbreaking lynching lament “Strange
Fruit”—popularized by Billie Holliday, but Kanye samples Nina Simone’s
version—in a humdrum track about a spurned lover. Appropriating one of the most
powerful songs of the 20th century and the civil rights movement is
offensive enough; the fact that he does so in such an atrocious manner of
red-herring contextual confusion, and clipping Simone’s voice into a hiccupping
burst consisting of just the word “breeze,” is even more reprehensible—to say
nothing of the protracted conclusion, in which his AutoTuned warbling duets
with Simone.

Kanye,
who made his name on an innovative yet quickly overly imitated formula,
continues to challenge himself musically. Too bad the rest of his challenges
aren’t nearly as interesting—or remotely enjoyable. (June 27)

Sunday, June 16, 2013

Hilotrons: This fantastic, overlooked album is
far better than its cover image suggests

The Polaris Prize long list was announced last Thursday: right in the middle of a busy Toronto week, including NXNE, Luminato, and a massive police raid peripherally connected to our current mayoral travails. So forgive me if I'm late getting this up. The full long list of 40 albums is here.

Generally speaking, I'm quite happy with the list: almost all the albums I was considering voting for made it on, with a few heartbreaking exceptions. It was a tough year: there were very few albums that stood far and above the pack for me. Instead, there were many completely solid, interesting, challenging and just generally excellent albums released in Canada in the last 12 months. Every year I think I'm about to get jaded, I'm blown away yet again by the staggering amount of great work.

As always, I'm curious how the list breaks down by geography and genre. I'll admit right now that my geographical assessment is contentious: where an artists was born or started their career vs. where they're based now, for example. Either way, once again--as always on Polaris lists--Montreal is the musical capital of Canada.

GEOGRAPHY

Nominees living outside
Canada: 4 (Daphni, Danny Michel, AC Newman, Zaki Ibrahim) CORRECTION: 3, as Michel doesn't live in Belize, as I'd thought, though he does spend a lot of time there

Montreal (including some franco
artists I don't know that I can only assume live there): 13

Alaclair Ensemble – Les maigres blancs d'Amérique du Noir. This
fun franco hip-hop act perhaps shouldn’t have surprised me, seeing how the
somewhat similar Radio Radio snuck into the shortlist several years ago. I
can’t speak to the lyrics, but the flow is fantastic and the production is
stellar.

Zaki Ibrahim – Every Opposite. This totally slipped under the
radar when it came out in 2012; partially because she now lives in South Africa
and the record had zero promo here. I don’t recall reading a single Canadian
interview with her. But some passionate jurors who loved this record (of which
I was one) rallied the troops and drummed up considerable interest in an album
in danger of being completely overlooked.

Kobo Town – Jumbie in the Jukebox. This fantastic modern calypso
album—and how many of those have ever been within spitting distance of
Polaris?—got a lot of last-minute buzz after its release earlier this month.
The production and performances are one thing, but it’s the songs of Drew
Gonsalves that really transcend genre and could catapult them right onto the
shortlist.

OMISSION: Two Hours Traffic - Foolish Blood. These PEI power-poppers shortlisted with their debut many moons ago, but they're the rare pop band who keeps getting better, and this is on par with powerhouses like Spoon and the New Pornographers, with fantastic production by Darryl Neudorf. Sorry to see jurors take them for granted.

OMISSION: Stars: Former shortlisters for In the Bedroom After the War released their best album since then… to crickets. I thought it was a very strong record, and I say that as someone who has never particularly liked this band.

Five things I’d like to have seen
on the list:

Hilotrons – At Least There’s
Commotion: An impeccable, whip-tight new wave rock record with stunning ballads
and electro detours. This, to me, is one of the biggest oversights of Polaris
2013.

Snowblink – Inner Classics:
This record’s subtle charms perhaps made it too easy to overlook; or maybe it
was too Feist-y after that artist’s win last year. But this is a stunning
record that you need to hear. Its long-list exclusion, that if nothing else,
should silence people who think Arts and Crafts is a promotional behemoth
capable of pushing product onto sheep-like critics. In this case, one can only
wish.

Veda Hille – Peter Panties: A
cast recording of a musical based on Peter Pan and co-written by a playwright
with Down syndrome is admittedly a difficult sell. But it’s an amazing—and
concise—rock opera album, and deserves to be heard.

Blue Hawaii - Untogether:
Superior to associated band Braids, just as equally challenging and beautiful
as their friend Grimes, and the rare abstract electronic record with heavy
bass.

The Magic – Ragged Gold: This
amazing band needs a break, badly. Ragged Gold was one of the most underrated
albums of 2012, its take on Hall and Oates-era soul surprisingly convincing and
compelling. Plus, you get to hear Evening Hymns supporting player Sylvie Smith
really shine on supporting vocals.

Five things I’d like to see
off the list:

There are albums on the list
I’m indifferent to but recognize their appeal for fans of that genre and/or the
artist themselves. These, however…

The Besnard Lakes – Until In Excess, Imperceptible UFO. Even most
fans of this band seemed to be disappointed with this record, which is why its
presence here is somewhat shocking (despite the fact their last two albums were
shortlisted). Imperceptible, indeed.

Carly Rae Jepsen: She’s the
Canadian pop success story of the last year, which of course made her a Juno
suction machine and Polaris repellent. She did have some champions in the jury,
however, and the album is far better than one would expect: far better
bubblegum than Bieber, for starters. But I think the Owl City collab
single-handedly sunk any chance she had.

K’naan: The former
shortlister dissed his own follow-up, and nobody else seemed to like it much
better. It’s not that bad, and has some great tracks—but it’s not very good,
either.

Serena Ryder: This young
veteran overcame years of “most promising” status to score one of the year’s
biggest mainstream pop singles and had a solid album to back it up. She’s a
solid artist who deserves everything she attained in the last year, but she
doesn’t make the kind of records Polaris jurors put on in their spare time.

Dirty Beaches: His debut
album came out of nowhere and landed on the long list two years ago, despite
the fact it was incredibly lo-fi, somewhat incomprehensible and owed its
biggest debt to CBGB underdogs Suicide. His 2013 follow-up is much more
accomplished: still murky and mysterious, but far more intriguing and beautiful
(while still occasionally terrifying) and even with some discernible beats.
It’s had glowing reviews here and abroad, but probably was released too close
to the voting deadline, and it’s a record that grows on you.

Bob Wiseman - Giulietta Masina At the Oscars Crying: I wouldn’t have expected Wiseman to get on the list, as his work is easily dismissed as too difficult or political or adventurous or inconsistent or—well, whatever. Fact is, the man is still fascinating, and his latest is his strongest work in, oh, I don’t know, 15 years—certainly it’s his most extroverted and social, employing many of his talented friends.

And ladies and gentlemen, I predict this will be the shortlist announced on July 16: