911 dispatcher sentenced to jail after hanging up on thousands of callers

Cleve R. Wootson Jr., The Washington Post

Published
11:43 am CDT, Thursday, April 19, 2018

Crenshanda Williams of Houston. Williams, A Houston 911 operator accused of hanging up on thousands of emergency calls, was charged Oct. 5, 2016, with two counts of interference with an emergency telephone call.

Crenshanda Williams of Houston. Williams, A Houston 911 operator accused of hanging up on thousands of emergency calls, was charged Oct. 5, 2016, with two counts of interference with an emergency telephone

Crenshanda Williams of Houston. Williams, A Houston 911 operator accused of hanging up on thousands of emergency calls, was charged Oct. 5, 2016, with two counts of interference with an emergency telephone call.

Crenshanda Williams of Houston. Williams, A Houston 911 operator accused of hanging up on thousands of emergency calls, was charged Oct. 5, 2016, with two counts of interference with an emergency telephone

911 dispatcher sentenced to jail after hanging up on thousands of callers

1 / 7

Back to Gallery

It took Hua Li two minutes and three tries to get help from Houston 911 as a convenience store owner lay bleeding to death on the floor of his store after being shot.

Li was about to walk into a Raceway in Houston to buy a lottery ticket in May 2016 but was stopped by another person's warning: Somebody was robbing the store.

Li caught a glimpse of a man holding a gun, court documents say. Then he heard a half a dozen gunshots.

He hopped into his car and sped away, and as he put distance between himself and the crime, he pulled out his phone to dial 911.

The phone line picked up, then immediately disconnected.

Now Playing:

A Clark County 911 dispatcher is out on bond after officers said he pretended to be a cop.

Media: WLKY

Li tried again. Thirty seconds later, his call went through to Crenshanda Williams. "Houston 9-1-1, do you need medical, police or fire?" she asked.

"This is a robbery," Li blurted out.

Li heard a sigh, then nothing. The call had been disconnected again.

On Wednesday, Williams was sentenced to 10 days in jail and 18 months on probation after she was convicted of hanging up on thousands of calls during the 18 months that she worked as a 911 dispatcher for the city of Houston, according to the Houston Chronicle.

When investigators asked why she had hung up on so many people, she told them that sometimes she just didn't feel like talking.

Franklin Bynum, Williams' attorney, told the Houston Chronicle that the case had unearthed systemic problems at the city's emergency center, which had consolidated calls for police, the fire department and paramedics 15 years ago.

Related Stories

He said that one of the problems was that the system drops calls instead of rerouting them if dispatchers aren't ready for them - and that his client was a scapegoat for a broken system.

"She was going through a hard time in her life, and she was a poor-performing worker at the Houston Emergency Center," he said. "But punishing her doesn't do anything to fix the problems that still exist at the emergency center."

Williams' supervisor was put on internal probation for a year, the Chronicle reported, but a jury found Williams criminally responsible for ignoring thousands of calls.

Williams had started working as a dispatcher in July 2014 and had taken thousands of calls, court documents say. But an audit a year and a half after she was hired found that an abnormally large number of her calls had lasted 20 seconds or less, and the city began an investigation.

The disconnected calls include one from March 13, 2016, during which a security guard named Jimmie Moten Jr. dialed 911 from his cellphone to report that two people in trucks were racing on Interstate 45.

"This is Officer Moten. I'm driving on 45 South right now and right now I am at -" he said before he was cut off by Williams.

"Ain't nobody got time for this. For real," she said, then the line went dead.

When investigators pressed Williams about the calls, she admitted she was the call-taker on both, court documents say.

Williams, court documents say, "admitted that she often hangs up on calls that have not been connected because she did not want to talk to anyone at the time."

The consolidated center for 911 calls opened in 2003 and handles millions of calls every year, according to the Chronicle, or 9,000 a day. Two-thirds of those calls aren't true emergencies.

The rest involve people in dire need.

"The citizens of Harris County rely on 911 operators to dispatch help in their time of need," Assistant District Attorney Lauren Reeder told Houston Fox affiliate KRIV. "When a public servant betrays the community's trust and breaks the law, we have a responsibility to hold them criminally accountable."