While it’s par for the Twitter course to have a musician tweet at a TV star, this interaction raised eyebrows and angered some fans as showing support for the embattled A & E TV show.

Duck Dynasty has been under fire after Willie Robertson’s father, Phil Robertson, was quoted in the January issue of GQ Magazine linking homosexuality to bestiality and suggesting that blacks were not unhappy in the segregated American South. After the interview was published, Phil stood by his comments, refusing to apologize and was subsequently suspended from the A & E show for nine days.

Reaction to Payne’s tweet was swift. Gay right advocates denounced the singer’s statement on the grounds that the compliment implied support for the Robertson family’s version of family values, as the notoriously rambunctious One Direction fans rushed to Payne’s defense claiming it was all a big misunderstanding. For those who are both supporters of gay rights and fans of the band, the tweet brought up complicated emotions.

Like for real though if that tweet from @Real_Liam_Payne is legit he’s made a huge mistake. You realize how many gay fans 1D has, right?

Payne, however, stood by his tweet, claiming that just because he likes the show, doesn’t mean that he necessarily agrees with all of their personal views:

Being a fan of someones show and the way they still hold a family together doesnt mean i am ok with all they say. — Liam Payne (@Real_Liam_Payne) January 18, 2014

Payne added: “Again i just like the show and i love when families stick together, i havent said i agree with all that theyve ever said.” He noted that, “I just watched a show and I liked it as most people do.” Payne returned to Twitter later to further clarify his comments, vent his frustrations and remind the world that he is just a 20-year old in a boy band:

I can’t do anything without being judged u try that and write about it — Liam Payne (@Real_Liam_Payne) January 19, 2014

What I gotta do to please you bastards I’m a 20 year old just living life as you did when u where twenty but in extraordinary circumstances