Refusing to acknowledge the tush squeeze, Tyler said, “Stephen Colbert is a liar!” and added “You don’t have proof,” to which, Colbert explained that the aforementioned grope was, in fact, filmed.

With that settled, the host went through a list of his guest’s accomplishments and when they talked bling, Tyler said his jewelry idol was Elizabeth Taylor. Somehow, the conversation ended up with the host and artists making a date to watch her movies.