My garter (pictured above) was not itchy in the slightest….while we had no garter toss planned – i just wanted to wear one ….. i only wore it until the end of the parent dances……

I chose to buy from etsy in part because I could customize. I sent the seller my thigh measurement and she made the garter to fit. it wasn’t excessively tight but it did feel like the right amount of secure.

Walking to our first look it slipped down my leg and my Maid/Matron of Honor hiked it back up for me….then when i was dancing with my dad it slipped to my ankle … after the dance i took it off for good because it wasn’t fun anymore…..beautiful garter — not sure what would make it more secure. 🙁