All he said was the box art was uneven, the music was dodgy, and the screenshots we seen in into were already released pix, well watch GTA:SA again all the screenshots in that into was released prior to the game, all this guy has done is give his views on the into, he didn't play the game, so how do you classify that as 'confirmed' I personally think its too good to be fake.

Oh dude I never noticed that the little paper that shows the GTA IV picture on the game box thingy was a little off. Yeah the music and pics seemed a little dumb but nice try! Whoever did this is good with a computer and special effects and stuff...

Anyway to say this is fake might be a little wide of the mark Lets look at this from another angle !! They say its fake because of a dodgy box,a thin manual,odd music and because the intro did not contain cinematic scenes !!

Hold on a minute why is this fake ?? Its on the Xbox We all know the Xbox version is the crap version This looks totaly authentic to me !! Thats the Xbox for you

How is this "confirmed"? It's just some guy with his opinion of why he thinks it's fake. How did this get approved with that title? Unlesss it's confirmed by Rockstar or take2 then it's not confirmed. heyheyhey what is wrong with you approving somthing like this?

Let the company come out and say it is fake..then i will not commet anymore on this matter. said and done..some people here are just saying it is fake cos it is on the 360...dam noobs...dont worry son..you wait will be over..hahaha

wow u guys just cant wait to say stupid ass 360 jokes. I mean so wut if the 360 has a hardware problem the company will fix it for u for free. I mean microsoft is known for software not hardware so honestly i dont know wut the big deal is. I have both systems but i play more games on my 360 cuz they r just better

taht because they fix it for free it makes it ok....wow dumbest thing ive ever heard..ive gone through 2 360s since december im on number three it is true that 360 has the worst hardware no doubt about that hence the reason why im getting this on ps3 and all my other multiplats on ps3 because when my 360 bricks again (oh and im sure it will) i wont have to worry about not being able to play games. besides the 360 only has 1 or 2 good titles this year so sorry man you lose

thing to say, the only reason you are saying that his is will is the fact that its on the 360, but if it were on the ps3, all hell would have broke lose...but here are your flaws:

- the spine is different - the UPC is 1234567890128 - why does he cut scenes off, why not play the whole thing - the game has an autosave feature now, so where is message popping up? - R* confirmed that the intro is way different from any other GTA game - the copyright year on the screen says 2006

these are facts, not opinions...and if you still agree that this is a REAL, then thats you

The intro music was horrible and the lettering on the spine was generic. I think this guy made a video disc mocked up with a printed label made with a PC and simply played it(hence the unusual editing as if to omit anything in the GUI giving it away) Just my opinion.

You don't see him actually putting the disc into the 360, he must put another game in to get the 'reading disc' message. After the reading disc message the video is cut, then comes the fake video, look at how the background changes, the area around the TV, the lighting is totally different.