My Shostakovich (continuing)

So I was listening to Jenny Lin’s recording of Shostakovich piano preludes and fugues, and thinking back to my graduate school days, when Shostakovich was a nonperson among atonal composers.

But, far more, I was hearing how vital the music is. Preludes and fugues seem like archaic forms, and you’d think anyone writing them in 1950, when Shostakovich started his, would have the weight of Bach bearing down on him.

But of course the music doesn’t sound archaic. It’s the usual Shostakovich mix, which — and I just love this about him — includes circus music (think of the finale of the Sixth Symphony), the pop music of his time, musical comedy, and so much more. We see so many serious photos of the man, but I love this one, showing him rocking out at a soccer game.

Which isn’t in the least to minimize how nervous and oppressed he was, how deeply serious the meaning of his music is, or anything else from the profound or even somber side of the artistic stress. But there was more to him than that, and musically he was a complete citizen of his time, as you can hear in his Festive Overture, his “Tea for Two” arrangement, his musical (performed this year in Chicago), his love of jazz, the score for the “Silly Little Mouse” cartoon the Brooklyn Philharmonic played this season, and so much more.

I think, in fact, that Shostakovich was the last composer of this kind, or at least the last famous one, the last who was part of the mainstream of musical life where he lived — of all musical life, not just the classical kind. Maybe Leonard Bernstein came close, in his youth, when he was a nightlife celebrity in New York, writing pure Broadway-style musicals like On the Town. But his classical music lived purely in the classical world, while Shostakovich’s lived more vividly. Think of the audience of Leningrad artists and intellectuals, at the premiere of the Fifth Symphony, knowing that its message was something they had to hear, and that its fate might well be theirs as well.

Or, more peacefully, the premiere of one of the early string quartets, the third or fourth (sorry for my vague memory, and I can’t find the story as I’m writing this). After the premiere, there was a party in a restaurant. The quartet was played again, and, in one of the movements, the audience sang along with a delectable tune.

I don’t think this array of echoes outside the classical world happened with any other classical composer of Shostakovich’s time, or afterward. The reasons for it aren’t complicated, and I think they’re all about the Stalinist repression that Shostakovich suffered from.

First, modernist music wasn’t allowed in Stalin’s world. So the leading composers didn’t split off from the bulk of the audience. Second, pop music couldn’t have the commercial and cultural triumph that it had in the west, so classical music kept much of the cultural force it had had in the past.

And, finally, the arts were politicized, as we know, and so anything an artist did had powerful meaning. And, often, life and death significance. Which is why the premiere of the Fifth Symphony was such a fraught event. What response would Shostakovich have to vicious attacks from those with power to — quite literally — kill him? Would he cave? Would he find a way covertly to resist? What could he get away with? What would he be forced to do? All the artists at the premiere had to asked these questions, because they themselves would feel the force of the answers. Answers which might tell them whether they themselves would live or die.

The sense of all of this, burned into Shostakovich’s work, is one reason that it stays so powerful. We can feel the life force of the world around him flowing through it.

And one more thought. We know now that Shostakovich has depths of irony buried in his work. On the surface he says one thing, in the depths another, and — alongside the surface and the depth — we also hear his sometimes bitter, sometimes ironic, sometimes melancholy, sometimes tragic understanding of himself. Coexisting with his injured sense of fun.

This makes him our contemporary. Our culture, too — and above all our popular culture — is shot through with irony. Irony, for instance, about the modes of presentation we adopt (you can see this in pop bands), authentic, honest, posed, commercial, subverting expectations at the same time that those expectations are fulfilled, and all these things (and more) happening at once. And consciously.

Shostakovich, I think, is the sole voice — the sole great classical composer — with depths of irony like that. And that makes him our contemporary.

Footnote: I had a student from Russia some years ago in my Juilliard course on the future of classical music. She talked once about her love of Shostakovich. When she was growing up, in the old Soviet Union, she’d hear festive march music at Communist celebrations, and hate it for its dishonesty, and because she’d be forced to act as if she liked it. She heard that march music mirrored in Shostakovich’s work, along — no one could convince her otherwise — with a reaction to it just like her own.

Comments

The conscious irony in DSCH’s music is clear and obvious, and we have his own ‘signpost’ in case we’ve somehow missed it – the incongruous quotations in Symph #15. However, it’s a technique which had been embedded in his writing for years.

Look at the scene when the cops turn up at Katerina’s wedding – he lovingly pastiches the musical-emotional vocabulary of “denouement” scenes in Rossini & Bellini.* In a way it’s postmodern – conscious re-use of existing musical building-blocks to achieve a subversive end. Just when it seems that Sergey & Katerina are going to get clean away, in a world based on new values and social norms – the moral cops of Rossini’s time emerge through a time-hole to arrest them for their transgressions.

* I wonder if it prompted Britten’s Bellini spoof in the opera-within-an-opera in MSN? Although it’s a device BB might easily have come up with himself too.

Regarding DSCH’s use of standard, even archaic forms and formats (such as symphonies, string quartets, fugues etc) I’d agree there are clear reasons why he reached out to these forms. Having been carpetted on multiple occasions, very possible over extra-musical elements in his works, it’s entirely credible – to me – to see how he might resolve to work in musical formats where he would be immune to oafish criticism, and answerable only to other musicians for his work. What criticism could a strutting commissar make of a countersubject in a fugue? Only his own peers would have the critical apparatus to go tyre-kicking. And these forms came ready-coated in moral and academic respectability. Sitting in the Great Hall of the Moscow Conservatoire, you see the huge benign portraits of Tchaikovsky, Bach, Handel, Mozart, & Wagner gazing down from the walls. How could it therefore be ‘wrong’ to emulate their work, and the forms in which they wrote it. It was a watertight argument to keep the troglodytes at bay, and largely work without the hand of the censor round your neck the whole time.

And if they came to him for some opening fanfare for a Trade Union Congress, he’d knock something out to keep them happy. It seems very likely, from all the evidence, that Shostakovich did indeed believe in socialism, despite all the knocks he’d taken – in fact his anger with it stemmed from the way its potential had been stolen and abused by individuals.

But where *can* composers work without the meddling of politicians? I saw the UK premiere of DR ATOMIC a couple of years ago, in London. There was a huge 6-page programme note by Adams, in which he outlined the way he’d been forced to rework the libretto material so as to cause less offence to the State Department. The original libretto had gone on to illustrate how Oppenheimer had been persecuted by the Anti-American Activities Committee… plus c’est la meme chose….

Very interesting! I had not heard about the irony in his music before. Thank you!

Greg Sandow

Though I've been known for many years as a critic, most of my work these days involves the future of classical music -- defining classical music's problems, and finding solutions for them. Read More…

About The Blog

For years we've been talking about a classical music crisis. And the crisis is very real -- ticket sales have been falling, funding has been harder to find, and the audience, over many years, has gotten older. Many people don't want to believe these … [Read More...]

Follow this blog

Enter your email address to subscribe to this blog, and receive email notifications of new posts.

Email Address

Archives

@gsandow

Resources

This was the first in what turned out to be a long series of posts, in which I and many readers highlighted people, groups, and institutions making new departures in classical music, doing things in new ways. This wasn't even close to a complete … [Read More...]

“To be a musician in the service of music is not a job; it is a way of life.”
–Isaac Stern, violinist (The Musician’s Way, p. 299)
The music education community is swirling with talk about how best to prepare university-level students for … [Read More...]

Here, as promised, are the key things we need to do, if we're going to give classical music a future. When I wrote this, I was thinking of people who present classical performances. But I think it applies to all of us — for instance, to people who … [Read More...]

[From Greg: A followup to Erica's guest post yesterday, about the performance of Winterreise she did in a small town. Here she tells us what she said before the performance, to introduce the piece to an audience that doesn't know classical music. … [Read More...]

While we're still talking about CD covers, I thought I'd add a few likes of my own. Starting with this one, which I've loved ever since the recording came out on LP in 1962:
Of course it's Siegfried, from the Georg Solti Ring. And there couldn't … [Read More...]

[Lara Downes was the first of our guest bloggers here, and she began with a post about classical CD covers she likes. And about how she came up with the cover for her own latest album. Her list -- along with mine, and others that I hope will come … [Read More...]

I've spent some time compiling a list of videos I think especially stand out from the very bland standard classical music videos (no easy task to find these!).
Most bigger budget classical music videos are basically just documentations of … [Read More...]