"like butterflies with hiccups"

Primary menu

Post navigation

Spending the Twins’ Money… or Not

Terry Ryan has been a busy boy. We may or may not be impressed by what he’s been doing, but nobody can say he took an early holiday break from the office.

The Twins went in to the offseason needing starting pitching. Ryan told anyone who asked that he understood it was his job to improve the rotation. He also has, at various times, mentioned also wanting to add some bullpen pieces and someone to push Trevor Plouffe at third base.

He also consistently claimed that payroll would not significantly inhibit him from turning one of the worst teams in Major League Baseball in to a group that could compete in the AL Central.

Understanding that almost none of us actually believed that last part, I thought now might be a good time to tally up what the Twins’ GM has accomplished so far and how much of the Pohlads’ money he has spent. So, let’s project what the 25-man roster might look like if there are no further additions to the roster. (For the sake of simplifying things, I’ll assume all pre-arbitration eligible players will make $500,000… some will make a few bucks more, some a few less.)

Starting position players:

C Joe Mauer: $23,000,000

1B Justin Morneau: $15,000,000 (inlcudes prorated bonus)

2B Brian Dozier: $500,000

3B Trevor Plouffe: $500,000

SS Jamey Carroll: $3,750,000

LF Josh Willingham: $7,000,000

CF Aaron Hicks: $500,000

RF Chris Parmelee: $500,000

DH Ryan Doumit: $3,500,000

That’s $54,250,000 for the projected starting batting order. Ryan may still try to find a third baseman, but chances are he’ll go dumpster diving even if he does find one, so I think it’s safe to project that whatever four players Manager Ron Gardenhire will have keeping him company on the bench will be making somewhere close to the league minimum, so that’s another $2,000,000 for some combination of Darin Mastroianni, Pedro Florimon, Eduardo Escobar, Oswaldo Arcia, Drew Butera, Chris Herrmann and/or whoever else claims a bench spot in Spring Training. (Butera is arbitration eligible, but it’s unlikely he’ll be awarded much, if any, above $500,000,)

That makes $56,250,000 for 13 non-pitchers. Let’s take a peek in to the bullpen:

Closer Glen Perkins: $2,500,000

Set Up Jared Burton: $2,050,000

LHRP Brian Duensing: $1,300,000 (est. arb award)

RHRP Anthony Swarzak: $500,000

RHRP Alex Burnett: $500,000

RHRP Casey Fien: $500,000

RHRP Josh Roenicke: $500,000

Yes, pretty much everyone below Duensing on the above list is going to have to win a spot in Spring Training, but for financial purposes this projection works. It would seem unlikely that anyone currently with the organization who knocks one of the last four guys out of the bullpen would make much more money. That adds up to a $7,850,000 bullpen.

OK, we’ve put off projecting the starting pitching as long as we can, but let’s uncover our eyes and take a look at the current state of the rotation:

Kevin Correia: $4,500,000

Mike Pelfrey: $4,000,000

Vance Worley: $500,000

Scott Diamond: $500,000

Liam Hendriks: $500,000

Once again, we could discuss the chances of Pelfrey being healthy enough to start the season in the rotation or whether Kyle Gibson will be there to open the season or whether someone like Pedro Hernandez might impress in Spring Training, but the net effect would just be swapping another “minimum wage” earner in to the fifth spot. So that’s an even $10,000,000 for the rotation. Yes, in an era when mediocre starting pitchers are getting seven figure salaries, the Twins look to pay their entire rotation $10 million. And if that doesn’t bother you enough, consider that Kevin Correia will make up 45% of that total.

That all adds up to a current Major League payroll of $74,100,000. Even if we have to add the $5,500,000 the Twins owe Nick Blackburn (yes, the Twins look like they’ll pay Blackburn more money NOT to pitch for them in 2013 than they’ll pay anyone else TO pitch), the total amounts to only $79,600,000… for the entire roster.

Rich Harden signed a minor league contract with the Twins this week and I haven’t read yet whether his deal includes something more than minimum wage pay if he makes the Big League roster out of Spring Training, but it certainly wouldn’t be surprising. That said, I think we will need to see Harden throw hard and stay healthy before we worry too much about what effect he’ll have on the payroll.

Maybe Terry Ryan isn’t finished. One would certainly like to think he’s spending some time with the agents of a couple of the remaining starting pitchers on the market who have demonstrated some level of proficiency of getting batters out over the last year or two, but would you be willing to bet on someone like Shawn Marcum still being added to the roster? Yeah… me either.

The Twins’ Opening Day payrolls during their three seasons at Target Field have been $97,659,167 (2010), $113,237,000 (2011) and $100,435,000 (2012)*, according to Cot’s Baseball Contracts. It’s virtually assured, at this point, that the Opening Day payroll in 2013 will be the lowest since the final year the team spent at the Metrodome when they opened at $65,299,266.

*Charley Waters of the Pioneer Press Tweeted over the weekend that it appeared the Twins Opening Day payroll would be about $83 million, $11 million fewer than in 2012. The only thing I can assume is that Charley is not counting the $3 million owed to Tsuyoshi Nishioka and the portion of Francisco Liriano’s paycheck the team avoided paying by trading him. Perhaps the Twins had insurance that negated Scott Baker’s salary? I don’t know, but even his newspaper’s published estimate of the Twins Opening Day payroll last year was about $100 million. Waters must also be assuming Terry Ryan is going to spend another $5 million somewhere because I can’t come up with anything close to $83 million right now.

What conclusions can we draw from this? Here’s my big take-away: Terry Ryan could have slashed Opening Day payroll by 10% to $90 million and still had over $20 million to spend on starting pitching. Instead he has pried less than $10 million out of the Pohlads’ wallets to fix arguably the most glaring problem of any team in Major League Baseball.

Could this be a glimpse of what Target Field will look like during Twins games in 2013?

Personally, I think cutting payroll even 10% from last season’s level when you’ve got an entire community of frustrated and distrusting fans is just bad business. The Twins brass keep talking about planning to compete in 2013, but talking that way while simultaneously cutting payroll by more than 20% is insulting our intelligence.

I think they’re underestimating the baseball IQ of their fanbase and they will see far more empty seats at Target Field in 2013 than they are expecting. Of course, that’s when we’re likely to learn what “insulting” really is… because that’s when someone in the organization is going to complain publicly about a lack of fan support.

You get the level of fan support you earn. Right now, I don’t think the Twins front office has earned the right to expect a single fan to show up for a game.

4 thoughts on “Spending the Twins’ Money… or Not”

“The only thing I can assume is that Charley is not counting the $3 million owed to Tsuyoshi Nishioka “

They don’t owe Nishioka anything. He nullified the contract to achieve his release.

That said. I really would rather see the Twins at $50 million payroll that makes sense rather than keeping up with an imaginary line in the sand and signing the likes of Correia this season and Capps last season to 3-4 times actual value contracts.

I’d probably add Haren in your list of players and I suspect that he signed a split contract (no details leaked) and would be making at least a couple mil. Haren, Diamond and Pelfrey might not be ready for opening day, so you got to add a couple more 500K to balance the equation. I got this gut feeling that they will sign wife beater Myers to a 2+ year deal with too much money.

I don’t get it. Five of: Gibson, Meyer, May, Hendriks, Worley, Diamond, Wimmers, Hermsen could have been a decent rotation in 2014 and 2015. Now Correia is the 2014 Blackburn and they are getting another one. And more of the kids will be ready in 2015…

The Twins don’t owe Nishioka for this year, but they did for last season. That was what I was referring to… as one possible reason why Waters referred to the Twins opening 2012 with a $94 million payroll, instead of the $100 million they actually owed, in total, on Opening Day.

I disagree wholeheartedly that five of the guys you mentioned would likely be even “decent” as a rotation in 2014-15. I don’t like the Correia signing, but there’s no doubt in my mind they did… and still do… need a real pitcher added to both this season and future rotations. And obviously they can afford it.

I hate to tell you “I told you so.” I knew this was going to happen and the Twins front office should be embarrassed by the outright lies they told season ticket holders back in September. I believe Bill Smith was fired because he wanted to spend more money than the Twins ever imagined. As usual this organization is never about winning but entirely about profit. Jim Pohlad is a real life Ebeneezer Scrooge and folks GM Terry Ryan knows this pitching staff is even worse than last year. I am holding out hope for Brett Myers and Brent Lillabridge. If they signed these two guys it would make me feel a little better about losing 95 games again.