I have to say I'm a bit disappointed with this one. Most of the clips in this video felt like "that fits" rather than really contributing to the humor. Overall the video really just felt lewd for no reason at all since none of the dirty clips really added anything to the humor of the video itself. I really like your humor for the most part, but every time I've seen it fail (at least to amuse me) it has been your use of dirty or sexual video clips.

l33tmeatwad wrote:I have to say I'm a bit disappointed with this one. Most of the clips in this video felt like "that fits" rather than really contributing to the humor. Overall the video really just felt lewd for no reason at all since none of the dirty clips really added anything to the humor of the video itself. I really like your humor for the most part, but every time I've seen it fail (at least to amuse me) it has been your use of dirty or sexual video clips.

I'm not going to say this video is some sort of masterpiece, but something about this just irked me. To be honest, I don't think our senses of humor line up well. Out of politeness I've never said this before, but I haven't found many of your comedies to be all that funny. And I feel I could level those same criticisms back at you. But that's getting rather off topic and all it's going to do is start an argument, so I'm just not going to even bother.

As for the lewdness, it's kind of inherent to the sources. Just for an fyi, this is where the audio originates from (NSFW). Not really any better quality clips of the scene online.

drewaconclusion wrote:I'm not going to say this video is some sort of masterpiece, but something about this just irked me. To be honest, I don't think our senses of humor line up well. Out of politeness I've never said this before, but I haven't found many of your comedies to be all that funny. And I feel I could level those same criticisms back at you. But that's getting rather off topic and all it's going to do is start an argument, so I'm just not going to even bother.

As for the lewdness, it's kind of inherent to the sources. Just for an fyi, this is where the audio originates from (NSFW). Not really any better quality clips of the scene online.

Hmm...perhaps you misunderstand...I get humor is subjective, but my main complaint here is I felt the sources weren't utilized effectively. Seeing the original now it stills stands to me as "those scenes fit" and it really just feels like scene matching the original verbatim instead of being something new. I'm just trying to give some honest critical feedback and tell you what I feel you should work on overall. I was not intending to hurt your feelings or make you feel like I thought all your videos were bad. I actually like a lot of your videos and enjoy most of your comedy videos, including some of your dirty humor (like Kount Krausula).

drewaconclusion wrote:I'm not going to say this video is some sort of masterpiece, but something about this just irked me. To be honest, I don't think our senses of humor line up well. Out of politeness I've never said this before, but I haven't found many of your comedies to be all that funny. And I feel I could level those same criticisms back at you. But that's getting rather off topic and all it's going to do is start an argument, so I'm just not going to even bother.

As for the lewdness, it's kind of inherent to the sources. Just for an fyi, this is where the audio originates from (NSFW). Not really any better quality clips of the scene online.

Hmm...perhaps you misunderstand...I get humor is subjective, but my main complaint here is I felt the sources weren't utilized effectively. Seeing the original now it stills stands to me as "those scenes fit" and it really just feels like scene matching the original verbatim instead of being something new. I'm just trying to give some honest critical feedback and tell you what I feel you should work on overall. I was not intending to hurt your feelings or make you feel like I thought all your videos were bad. I actually like a lot of your videos and enjoy most of your comedy videos, including some of your dirty humor (like Kount Krausula).

You didn't hurt my feelings and I don't mind the negative review (judging by the star scale that seems to be the consensus anyhow). I just had an issue with that particular criticism coming from you. That's all. And in the process, I've probably killed my own thread.

Well, to be fair when I reread my original post I have to say I could have worded it better....and I'm sure you didn't kill the thread, the announcement forum is known for only EPIC videos actually getting a response and everything else just gets ignored ...and hey, your thread is doing better than the thread for mine and Amaterasu's AWA Pro video, lol...

l33tmeatwad wrote:Well, to be fair when I reread my original post I have to say I could have worded it better....and I'm sure you didn't kill the thread, the announcement forum is known for only EPIC videos actually getting a response and everything else just gets ignored ...and hey, your thread is doing better than the thread for mine and Amaterasu's AWA Pro video, lol...

Yeah, I'm not really one to talk about keeping announcement threads alive. I need to get better about that.

l33tmeatwad wrote:I have to say I'm a bit disappointed with this one. Most of the clips in this video felt like "that fits" rather than really contributing to the humor. Overall the video really just felt lewd for no reason at all since none of the dirty clips really added anything to the humor of the video itself. I really like your humor for the most part, but every time I've seen it fail (at least to amuse me) it has been your use of dirty or sexual video clips.

I'm not going to say this video is some sort of masterpiece, but something about this just irked me. To be honest, I don't think our senses of humor line up well. Out of politeness I've never said this before, but I haven't found many of your comedies to be all that funny. And I feel I could level those same criticisms back at you. But that's getting rather off topic and all it's going to do is start an argument, so I'm just not going to even bother.

As for the lewdness, it's kind of inherent to the sources. Just for an fyi, this is where the audio originates from (NSFW). Not really any better quality clips of the scene online.

It's ok man, I've never found ANY of his videos to be any kind of funny, or good for that matter.