Balelo first appeared on the show in August 2011. In an April 2011 interview Balelo gained national headlines after he returned a stolen copy of Action Comics #1, the origin of the "Man of Steel" himself, Superman, to its rightful owner, actor Nicolas Cage.

During his career, Balelo was also known as an energetic auctioneer. During his auctions, he often wore a Superman costume.

Balelo was arrested on Feb. 10 by Simi Valley police for methamphetamine possession and was scheduled to appear in Ventura County Superior Court on Feb.19, county records show.