Friday, November 18, 2016

Brett's Annotated Bibliography (2)

Share it Please

It has been claimed that Milton based Satan from Paradise Regained off of Shakespeare’s
Iago, from Othello. Although I agree
that these characters are based off of a similar personality type, I believe
that they tempt their victims with different rhetorical strategies: Satan deconstructs
his enemy’s arguments while Iago constructs true temptations to look like
positives. I am hoping to choose two speeches, one from Othello and one from Paradise
Regained, that portray the true characters of Iago and Satan, then pair
that speech with an image or video that portrays their true character. By
looking at these artistic renditions, I will compare and contrast the rhetoric
of each villain and how their arguments develop as their characters develop.

o“In Rossini's musical version of the terrible
scene between Othello and his deceiver, the surprise and anxiety of the former
and the subtle insinuations of the latter finally lead to a burst of fury, in
which the feelings of the enraged dupe and the triumph of the vindictive Iago
are vocally expressed with the full genius of the great composer. In Verdi's
duet describing the same passage, the instrumental accompaniment expresses
perhaps more than the voices the vehemence and passion of the scene, ending
with the almost realistic sound of a fatal stab dealt by a murderous hand.
Evidently Rossini and Verdi alike succeeded through their different styles in
expressing the true meaning of the terrible scene by the attractive medium of
their delightful art.”

oIt has often been noted that Iago's
"motiveless malignancy" in fact comes, in his soliloquies, with a
superfluity of motives, as if he himself has difficulty locating the
source of his depravity. What Shakespeare has done, of course, is to pay
his fellow actor the compliment of trusting him to complete Iago for himself.
He provides the actor with a solid enough starting point: Iago
is consumed by the promotion of Cassio. But thereafter, the play
works overtime not to lock Iago down, and seems to invite the actor to allow
himself to be surprised by what happens to Iago: a man driven by envy and
hatred, who isn't fully in control of what happens next (as none of us
is), to whom the action of the play occurs spontaneously –
as life happens to all of us.

o“In his essay
Michael Shurgot examines the great temptation scene, Act 3 Scene 3,
concentrating on the dangerous section where Iago vividly describes Cassio’s
dream. “The striking theatrical paradox of this scene [is that] the more deeply
felt and convincingly performed the actor’s impersonation of Iago’s sexual
longings, the more incredulous will be Othello’s failure to penetrate Iago’s
mask; and the greater the risk that this segment of [the scene] will dissolve
into a grotesque parody of Othello’s temptation and fall.””

oBases Satan off of Iago because Milton looked up
to Shakespeare in form and mindset.

o“Milton’s first published poem was “On
Shakespeare,” appearing in the Second Folio anonymously. The work, especially
being Milton’s first published work, shows Milton’s reverence and honor for the
greatest poet and playwright of his age” (1).

oIago is disgruntled because he is Othello’s most
trusted confidant and has seen the horrors of war with him.

oSees himself as slighted and therefore plays on
the “sensitive and vulnerable and weak” parts of Othello’s character (4:12).

oIago sees his grievances as legitimate, and uses
“subterfuge” and “insinuation” to fulfill his destructive plans (4:34).

Social:

Homie: Justin

·My husband Justin and I watched an Iago
soliloquy and a Satan soliloquy together, then discussed similarities and
differences between the two. We came to the conclusion that in his “put money
in thy pocket” speech (almost a soliloquy, but very representative of his
rhetoric), Iago uses the temptations characteristic of Satan: riches, sexual
desire, and revenge. Ian McKellen also speaks quietly and quickly, forcing his
audience to listen without interrupting and without major focus. In his
representation of Satan, Ian Richardson is also collected in the beginning—his
argument is headed in a certain direction and he is very eloquent. However, the
further along he gets, he loses clarity. Instead of tempting with “basic”
temptations in order to build his side up, Justin claimed that Satan was
attacking heaven. Rather than constructing the attractiveness of his own side (like
Iago), Satan deconstructed the opposing side.

oCalm and collected at the beginning, knows
exactly where his argument is headed next. Builds steam as he goes on and gets
very angry

o“though few be lost, not all be lost” à
expresses hope in himself and his temptations

oPortrays Christ as the tyrant, “Tyranny of
heaven”

Peer: Chelsea Adams, author of a blog post from Dr. Burton’s
2013 Milton class, now getting a Ph.D. in 20th century African Lit.

oExtremely awesome for sending me an article that
was unfortunately, ultimately unhelpful

o“1.
Look for research on the history of rhetoric for that time period (Meaning both
when Shakespeare would have studied and when Milton would have studied.) I know
that back when, the big controversy with rhetoric was that people would use it
without regard to the morality of whatever it was they were using rhetoric to
argue. As far as I can determine, this was a heated debate clear back in
Ancient Greece. Looking at those "moral arguments" for not teaching
rhetoric to everyone or using rhetoric to argue everything may be the key to
unlocking the crux of your argument.”

Enthusiast: Amanda, author of Shakespeare-Online.

oEmailed, no response yet.

Expert: Robert Means, HBLL librarian over English Language
and Literature

oRobert was helpful in pointing me toward some
helpful research guides that I was unfamiliar with initially, and thus used
incorrectly to search for articles.

o“You’re correct . . . we don’t have a separate
research guide for Milton (only Shakespeare for now). But, never fear, the
Milton stuff IS out there: in the MLA Bibliography, JSTOR, etc., and in
monographs (books) that you can find by searching the HBLL catalog.”