Giants' QB Competition: Setting The Odds On Who Will Be Eli Manning's Backup

If this is your first visit, be sure to
check out the FAQ by clicking the
link above. You may have to register
before you can post: click the register link above to proceed. To start viewing messages,
select the forum that you want to visit from the selection below.

Nassib showed less than nothing last preseason against 2nd string defenses. Just because we drafted him with the 4th pick that we traded up for last yr does not mean that he makes the team this yr. At this point he is not worth a roster spot.

Historically, the Giants keep their draft picks for several years before letting them go. Nassib would really have to stink things up this offseason to lose his roster spot. Most likely he remains with the team.

It would be good if Nassib beat out Freeman, but it's not the end of the world for him if he doesn't either. The longer Nassib has to learn, the better I say. It would be great for them both if they were neck and neck competing hard all season long. That will push Eli too...well it should anyway.

If these guys want to make a difference for this team they should both try to out-work Eli.

Historically, the Giants keep their draft picks for several years before letting them go. Nassib would really have to stink things up this offseason to lose his roster spot. Most likely he remains with the team.

What he did last year was really stink things up. If he doesn't show vast improvement this preseason he is probably gone. Its not like he showed Eli's potential in college.

If you are trying to establish the air apparent then it becomes real important, with two years left on Eli's contract and the Potential that Nassib could be his replacement, while a long shot should be considered and I think giving him a 50-50 chance is prettying reasonable.