The date went pretty normally… until the end. They went back to his house. Everything was going fine until he pulled out – wait for it – a puppet!

The Actor then ceased talking in his normal voice altogether and used some sort of weird puppet voice to continue the conversation. According to her, “He went from cute to creepy really fast.” When the puppet tried to touch her private parts and proposition her for sex, she bolted.

The first actor I thought of was Jason Segel. He is a huge Muppets fan and has an entire collection of puppets. This is a quote from I’m Not Obsessed: ““My house is packed with puppets. Like, everywhere. Thank God I have a slightly bigger house now, so I have one room that’s sort of dedicated to puppets. But for a long time I lived in a one-bedroom apartment that was just crammed with puppets. It’s why I’m still single.” If you search, you’ll find a ton of links regarding his puppets/muppets and how much he enjoys them (ahem) and “plays” with them (I can’t think of the correct word: play? perform?). I guess it could be fun/ny? Maybe?

Gotta be Jason Segel – tall, best known for HIMYM, but also in plenty of movies, and wrote Forgetting Sarah Marshall, where his character was into puppets. Also, was in The Muppets in 2011, with muppets. The man knows his puppets.

Clues = “normal”, as in the TV show “The New Normal” that was a recent TV series. He’s been in plenty of movies, including National Treasure. Since the word “normal” was used several times, I think that’s the big clue here and the only show that’s been on recently with “normal” in the title is “The New Normal”.

OMG, is this Jason Segal!?! Gross! He’s one of my favorite actors. Knowing this is gonna creep me out whenever I see him. I hope this was just a joke gone bad. Either way, I don’t blame the date for leaving. Puppets shouldn’t be a part of sexy time.

It pains me to suggest this because I am a big fan but…. Taylor Kitsch? He is due in The Normal Heart and he was in FNL which was sort of recent (finished in the last 5 years)…. I’m hoping for Jason Segal, though, because I like him less.

I really don’t understand all the judgment here. Yes, it’s a little weird that this guy likes to use puppets in the sack, but who here doesn’t have a weird sexual fetish? I challenge anyone here to find ONE person who doesn’t have some weird kink. Personally, I think it’s fine if he isn’t hurting anyone (which he isn’t). People need to get over this type of shit. This is why there is sex shaming in our culture. Give the guy a break. If you find it too weird to sleep with him then don’t. But don’t sit here in judgment.