English-Language Philosophy Journal Paper Submission Policies

TABLE 1-2013
Table 1 has been compiled from the list of English-language philosophy and logic journals listed on Wikipedia at http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Philosophy_journals and http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/List_of_logic_journals , several others not listed there, those advertised on the Philosophy in Europe E-list since 29 July 2008, and selectively from the list at PhilPapers. Journals that have ceased publication, been absorbed into other journals, or that lack an accessible English-language website have not been included. As of 31 December 2013, a total of 604 journals are surveyed. The text of each journal’s paper submission policy statement is quoted and analyzed, and on that basis assigned to one of the categories below. Overlooked additions to the list, as well as updates of policies cited below, would be appreciated. Any revisions or additions received by 15 December 2014 will be posted here in January 2015.

The table indicates that 81.45% of all English-language philosophy journals state no explicit commitment to anonymous author review, i.e. to blind referees. Of course actual practice may diverge from stated policy, unless the entire review procedure from author to referee has been computerized so as to ensure conformity with stated policy.