Shaf was a huge part of the reds almost winning. he outed two greens, almost got us to waste the Seer, and that day phase was referred to for every subsequent vote where we killed blue after blue. if MWB had pulled it off, Shaf should have been given a warz medal for that whole sequence.

Yep, I had to PM shaf after that first day to congratulate him and let him know what a blast that was.I suppose I should have investigated WK first (the quick random, especially when he was the second name on the first random too) made me suspicious of him, but I got so twisted up in the disbelieving Shaf's angel claim that I went after him with blinders on.At one point I was crossing my fingers that a blue would claim the angel just to see Shaf's reaction that night.

CBear3 wrote:Yep, I had to PM shaf after that first day to congratulate him and let him know what a blast that was.I suppose I should have investigated WK first (the quick random, especially when he was the second name on the first random too) made me suspicious of him, but I got so twisted up in the disbelieving Shaf's angel claim that I went after him with blinders on.At one point I was crossing my fingers that a blue would claim the angel just to see Shaf's reaction that night.

Thanks canaan, it was a fun one.

Sorry for not protecting you, we could have saved some headaches if we knew wk wad red that next day.

nah, that's not my line of thinking. When I was angel last game i protected myself one night. Once I revealed my role, I never protected myself again and lived til the end of the game. If you protect other people, you can figure out who's a bad guy and who's a good guy by who the bad guys target, if they target someone you protect. Also, the seer living just 1 more night is better than the angel living til the end of the game.

mac5155 wrote:Also, the seer living just 1 more night is better than the angel living til the end of the game.

that is terrible logic. you want to have a person that is outed and protected from the baddies at the end of the game. without the angel in this game, the baddies would've won, in my opinion. ive modded a lot of games and ive played even more and the angel is a huge help to the village way more than 1 extra night from a seer, especially when the seer hasnt been outed and cant/doesnt want to relay information