Tabard of Conquest

Trying to figure something out regarding this tabard:

- I earned it on my shaman main
- None of my level 85 alts on the same server/faction as my shaman are able to get the tabard from tabard vendors
- Logged on my 85 alliance warrior (who resides on a different server) and was able to get the tabard from the tabard vendor

Almost good of mind to check and see if said warrior has Justicar too, while I'm at it.

Anyone else able to reproduce this? Just wondering which way this tabard is supposed to work. I am thinking it would be character specific, but IIRC, the achievement is account wide (aka Master of IoC can be accumulated across many characters), so wouldn't any and all of my characters (regardless of server/faction) be able to obtain the tabard?

I'm able to go to the Tabard vendor and get the tabard on whichever character I want, whatever server I want. Couldn't seem to loot it on a level 11 Horde on a different server than the one I earned it on.
Earned it at 85 on Alliance, Anachronos-EU.

I'm having no issues looting it on different servers on characters that are below the level required to even enter IoC (75, currently). I'm currently having issues looting it on a different faction, however the character I tried it on might not have qualified for one of possibly several checks. No idea really.

"Reason is not automatic. Those who deny it cannot be conquered by it." - Ayn Rand
"You should never underestimate the predictability of stupidity." - Snatch

Oh, I didn't even realize you could get another tabard if you went to the vendor, I just assumed it was as stingy as all the other PvP achievements...

I got the achievements and tabard on my Alliance paladin years ago, and was able to get it from the vendor on my 90 Alliance monk on the same server just now. Haven't tried with my other characters yet.

I'm wondering now if it may have something to do with the fact the tabards have different item IDs. The achievements themselves are exactly the same, regardless of faction. The tabard rewarded, though, differs for each faction.

FWIW, I never deleted the tabard from my shaman. He's always had it since picking it up out of the mail after completing Master of IoC. Not that I believe that has anything to do with it (I am thinking my first point of pondering is where the issue lies).