Wow. So powerful. This is by far my favorite story that you have written. Very original, and very sad. I applaud you! Keep up the excellent work!

Reviewer: Lily Frost

Date: 2004-06-27

Reviewid: 89091

Chapter: 1

Lovely... perfectly fluffy!

Reviewer: Someone

Date: 2004-06-16

Reviewid: 87419

Chapter: 1

I love this story!!! You have to write more!! :]

Reviewer: Seaspray

Date: 2004-06-15

Reviewid: 87239

Chapter: 1

That was so sweet. I often wondered how Remus must have felt, being told Sirius was the traitor and then knowing that they all suspected him. You dealt with Lupin's pent up anger well, and Sirius' guilt and lingering terror of Azkaban. Excellent writing, keep it up!

Reviewer: Monika

Date: 2004-06-10

Reviewid: 86648

Chapter: 1

Perfect! :DI'd comment on something specific I liked, but the truth is, I loved the whole thing! ^.^

Reviewer: Babe

Date: 2004-06-10

Reviewid: 86625

Chapter: 1

FANTASTIC!!!!

Reviewer: Philippa Sommerville

Date: 2004-06-09

Reviewid: 86590

Chapter: 1

Oh. Oh. Oh. Oh. I loved it.

Reviewer: Greg

Date: 2004-06-09

Reviewid: 86516

Chapter: 1

That was beutifully written. It almost brought tears to my eyes gret job.

Reviewer: Kittenmommy

Date: 2004-06-05

Reviewid: 85992

Chapter: 1

Great missing "scene" - very well written!

Reviewer: Rae

Date: 2004-05-31

Reviewid: 85421

Chapter: 1

Y'see, this is the kind of love I see Lupin and Black sharing. A kind of platonic understanding which binds them oh so closely...

This was beautiful

Reviewer: EvieStark

Date: 2004-05-31

Reviewid: 85393

Chapter: 1

Oh, wonderful! I absolutely adore this fic, it's gorgeously crafted - the interaction between the characters is heart-breaking, but very satisfying all the same. Wonwerful, brilliant job - please keep it up!

Reviewer: Rainydaie

Date: 2004-05-15

Reviewid: 82796

Chapter: 1

Very good. I love your portrayal of what happened with the Marauders, and how you worked Sirius and Remus's relationship. It's very nicely done!!! I really hope you write some more - I'm a new author too, and it's kinda hard to get started, but just keep on going.

Please?

Reviewer: SiriuslyLupin

Date: 2004-05-15

Reviewid: 82753

Chapter: 1

Very heartwarming fic, I love these sorts of stories, and any stories that involve my two favorite characters :) I always thought that Remus would be very forgiving of Sirius, but I like this version, too. You have a wonderful way with words, and their emotions were wonderfully described. Excellent job!

Reviewer: Antonia East

Date: 2004-05-15

Reviewid: 82749

Chapter: 1

Oh how sweet. I did really like this piece, but I can't help thinking of the "Not at all, Padfoot old friend" in PoA. I would have thought that Remus felt guilty for believing that Sirius had been the spy. Nevertheless this was well written and emotive.

Reviewer: Linnet

Date: 2004-05-15

Reviewid: 82714

Chapter: 1

I must admit that I don't think I've read a fic in which Remus reacts like this...it seems very realistic, though, if I think about it.

I love this story! It was very heartwarming. Good job, and I'd love to see more of these from you.

-Linnet

Reviewer: Eirene

Date: 2004-05-15

Reviewid: 82677

Chapter: 1

Aww... that's so sweet. I loved it.

Reviewer: Toby

Date: 2004-05-15

Reviewid: 82637

Chapter: 1

Great job! I'd like to see more of your stories. You've really seemed to capture the characters of Moony and Padfoot and have exhibited some very realistic reactions!

The Sugar Quill was created by Zsenya and Arabella.
For questions, please send us an Owl!