Should ISPs be regulated like banks?

Let us, for a moment, draw comparisons between U.S. Internet service providers and U.S. bank lenders. Both data providers and lenders wield great power to influence productivity and economy. Chicago Tribute columnist Phil Rosenthal went so far to suggest that a lack of net-neutrality could make the rich richer and the poor poorer by allowing data providers to squeeze customers, charging variable rates that would inevitably cause poorer customers to suffer. A similar thinking goes that unchecked U.S. bank lenders would tend toward lending discrimination which would deny loans to groups of people based on socioeconomic limitations.

Net-neutrality advocates want the government to enforce fairness in data distribution in a similar manner that the government regulates banks to ensure all classes have access to equal lending practices.

There was a time when no mandate was in place for the government to regulate the banking system, but following early twentieth century financial crises, monetary policy regulation became a priority for U.S. congressman, and the Federal Reserve was created. As part of the Federal Reserve Bank’s core mission, “Our primary objective is to maintain a safe and competitive U.S. and global banking system.” It’s the application of the last two adjectives that could eventually inspire a similar mandate for the U.S. Federal Communication Commission (FCC) to step in and regulate Internet Service Providers (ISPs). Safe and Competitive.

But not yet for the Internet. The U.S. District Court of Appeals for the D.C. Circuit recently tossed out net neutrality in favor of self regulation by data providers, in effect telling the FCC it has limited authority to regulate broadband. Some think that those who believe data should be provided on equal terms without discrimination are missing the point of a free economy. The Wall Street Journal Editorial Board wrote that data caps are “good old-fashioned exercises in price discrimination.”

Just as airlines bring more people into the air by not charging every passenger the same, so broadband operators are adopting convoluted pricing schemes. These aim to segregate customers according to how much bandwidth they are willing to pay for. As happens in the air, the result is an opportunity to create more customers and more traffic. – WSJ.com

Startups and website entrepenuers are among those claiming the new ruling will hurt them most. “Most startup companies cannot afford to pay ISPs for faster broadband or better quality, and therefore the already established companies will have an unfair advantage,” wrote Gabrielle Meyer. Competition is being suppressed.

But safety is not yet a topic mentioned in context to net-neutrality. If there were a catastrophic data disruption among our nation’s ISPs, the FCC would immediately receive that mandate they’re looking for, charged with the unenviable task of ensuring not only the fair distribution of data, but one that provides it equally. Internet Blackout soothsayers will warn that safety of our ISPs should be a concern, and that regulation now could help prevent a major outage that would have devastating impact on economies. But, at least for now, the mandate is on hold.

3 Comments

JJ Beasly

Something else the government doesn’t understand and would just screw up if they got into regulation of ISPs.

Clients served:

Popular Posts

Edward Hadas at Reuters is so sure Bitcoin will collapse that he wrote an early obituary eulogizing the loss of confidence in a baseless cryptocurrency, caused by an illicit and valueless speculation war. Ignoring this death knell includes a long list of Bitcoin investors, each of whom harnesses arbitrage to stabilize the currency. A futures market for Bitcoin already exists and others are on the way. These proponents also point to the world’s first Bitcoin ATM installed in a Vancouver coffee shop in October 2013 and the others springing up since. It would seem the cryptocurrency craze has reinforced usable modularity across the spectrum – from investing to retail banking. The Bitcoin digital currency, which exists as software, is created by solving complex tasks embedded in a program through a process called mining. Once successfully mined, the currencies can be bought and sold via online exchanges. Websites like startbitcoin.com help novices learn to mine Bitcoins, and the underlying open source more

Fresh in the memories of airline travelers are the new fees charged to check luggage through to destinations. First appalled, then angered and finally resolved, travelers watched as American Airlines set the precedent and other airlines jumped on board. A similar trend is emerging among popular social networking websites, specifically, charging for a service we’ve all taken for granted: free messaging to other users. Their representatives claim the new fees provide a means to reduce SPAM and prevent overfull in boxes. While LinkedIn.com has long required annual fees of a minimum $39.95 per year for users to send unrestricted messages to others outside their linked network, a wild rumor serviced in January from the absurdest online tabloid The Weekly World News that Facebook will start charging fees to use the service: According to sources outside the company, Facebook is planning a subscription-based service with monthly fees starting at $0.99 for a basic “friendship” which allows for the posting of text more

Twitter once offered relaxed rules to encourage growth, but their massive expansion has recently led to bandwidth troubles and a paranoia about who Tweets where. Over the summer, new rules took effect not only to keep spammers, scrapers and bots at bay, but to prevent criminal and user bullying activity. An in-Tweet report button and updated Twitter Rules we accept, but their ongoing API Authentication protocol revisions are a pain in the arse. Website managers are in a constant scramble to update failing Twitter feeds. While API authentication effectively bans abusive users, it also aggravates the technology used to integrate Tweets. WordPress aficionado Jonas Kaufmann expressed his frustration: “If you can view the tweets of a person without being logged in on any computer, why should a bot not be able to do the same? I’m one of the first users asking this question and I guarantee you, I will find a solution, post it in the OP and within more

On February 5th Twitter announced that slowing sales and disappointing user growth means they need to reconfigure their design and core functionality. Twitter’s chief executive, Dick Costolo, told disappointed stock holders that twitter is desperately working on making its interface easier for users to use. “We will continue to invest in making Twitter a more visually engaging medium,” he said. “It will be a combination of changes introduced over the year that we believe will begin to change the slope of the growth curve.” But could bad design really explain the nearly 25% erosion in its stock price? Absolutely. Twitter is facing a slowdown in user growth, admitting that only 3.9% quarterly growth is half what previous quarters experienced. The shocking drop in the company’s valuation could point to a hyperinflated stock price, but New York Times writer Vindu Goel offers that the redesigned feature set available on Twitter has become too difficult to use: Twitter has finally acknowledged what more

The desperation can be seen through moderated postings on Apple’s website, posted in their own Apple Support Community. Here, gdgmacguy had some choice words for someone who suggested that Apple is ignoring the issue: Apple does NOT support downgrading the iOS. Why? who knows, But they don’t. Nothing you can do. If you want to jailbreak your phone and downgrade, then fine. But look at all the postings here by people who have attempted to do so and permanently disabled their phones. Jailbreaking voids your warranty with Apple and eliminates your right to any further assistance. Your choice. No one forced you to upgrade in the first place. https://discussions.apple.com/thread/4387499?start=0&tstart=0 But other newsgroups, not moderated by Apple, are giving legacy hardware (i.e., iPhone 4) owners ways to avoid upgrading to new hardware (i.e., iPhone 5) by sharing techniques to combat the bugs Apple engineers are introducing as an incentive for these users to buy new hardware. https://discussions.apple.com/thread/3022587?start=405&tstart=0 For instance, the home more

These free web design optimization tools are available for use and should be used in conjunction with a good Web Design and Marketing Strategy. Website Management Subscription Services sometime offer these as a subscription model because the nature of Search Engine Optimization and the implementation of the technology changes periodically. The ability to have success in searches depends on a great deal of research and time spent creating the content on pages and posts. More than anything else, research and implementation are the two components to finding success when using these free web design optimization tools. It’s worth remembering that many of these resources require a fair bit of experience and technical knowledge, so consider hiring a website manager to help. The Best Free Web Design Optimization Tools WordStream Keyword/phrase Tool: Keyword/Keyphrase Usage WordStream Niche Finder: get keyword suggestions grouped semantically SEO Book Keyword/phrase Suggestion Tool: A useful way of developing new keywords Google Keyword/phrase Tool: Get it from the more

Like it or not, sensationalism is how to write a great headline. As long as you are concise and factual you will not get penalized by Google. The way to a great SEO campaign is to follow this great new headline template policy. You’ll get clicks again and again after and your website manager cred will skyrocket! Template for a good headline … How’d you like to [new great thing] that [creates awesome outcome]? Do you know how [great outcome] with [new remarkable thing]? There’s a way to [great outcome] with this [new great thing]. If you knew about [new great thing] would you be interested? The way to a [great outcome] is to [new great thing]. Write a great headline for links to other blogs Linking to posts on your friend’s blogs or another business website allows you to display their content on your site – and build relevance with Google! Top-10 lists can be quite effective (i.e., North more

New York sent a message to Internet companies when it demanded access to personal information of 225,000 Airbnb user accounts, including bank account numbers and other personal data. The subpoena requires AirBnB to provide immediate access, setting a precedent for ongoing spying to police the website for users who illegally sublet their apartments. According to The Wall Street Journal‘s Allysia Finley, New York Attorney General Eric Schneiderman has severed political ties with Netflix, Facebook, Amazon and Uber by “declaring war on the Internet community.” The legal battle continues as the hostile work environment that is New York City becomes evident. AirBnB faces a daunting battle in the short term, where antiquated laws reflect the reality of their struggle against New York City’s powerful hotel lobby. A New York City man was fined $2,400 for renting his room out by using the website, but the fine was later reversed on a technicality. Many webmasters say the precedent demanding ongoing access to more

In the 1978 ‘Rescue from Gilligan’s Island’, actor Russell Johnson shows the Professor in a reinvention predicament. After returning to work at a university, he discovers all his inventions made (while stranded on the island) had been invented already, among them the Frisbee and skateboard. His frustration makes him want to give up the world he’s come back to. Reinventing the wheel has become a modern epidemic plaguing Internet technologists, and some are even giving up on innovation and settling into parlaying the same flawed technology because of a fear of trademark infringement or, more frightening still, because they think it just can’t be done any better. Blogger Tim Kastelle has written much about what he calls the Innovation Problem (IP), which advocates that we approach innovation through idea management, an effective counter to the pitfalls of commercialization. “In the commercialisation view, the only way to win is to have a great idea, protect the IP from it, and bring more

If websites came in ice cream flavors, many website entrepreneurs would think theirs a variety of Ben & Jerry’s. “Wait until you hear about this cool idea,” they say. “No, this one’s different – there’s something unique in this business recipe!” Never mind they’re probably trying to reinvent the wheel. Listen and nod. Being a website manager invites clients and acquaintances to offer endless ideas on their next great Internet offering. “That’s a great idea!” you say. “Now, Google it and see how many others are doing it already.” Listen and nod. Butter Beendone Before or Strawberry Pipe Dream? The point here is that most websites and ice cream flavors consist of the same basic ingredients. Although Baskin Robins famously claims 31 flavors, most of these flavors start with chocolate, vanilla or some common base, and then get condiments and branding to differentiate them from the others: Banana Nut Fudge Black Walnut Burgundy Cherry Butterscotch Ribbon Cherry Macaroon Chocolate Chocolate Almond more

A young eBay, Inc. led by the young liberal CEO John Donahoe donated loads to the Democratic Party, specifically to Senator Kirsten Gillibrand, Democrat of New York. Now, Gillibrand’s support of the bill known as the Marketplace Fairness Act, legislation that would ultimately allow states to collect sales tax from online merchants, whether they have operations in that state or not, has put John Donahoe in opposition to the Democratic Party. Donahoe is having that predictable “rich man realization” that comes with making millions. eBay’s sudden political shift to the Right is no coincidence considering their CEO saw his compensation nearly doubled to $29.7 million in 2012 while the company grew 2012 first quarter performance with revenue increasing 18%. Nevertheless, it was a surprise to most of the 84 million eBay members to see eBay’s April 24th email in their spamboxes, signed by John Donahoe: SUBJECT: Tell Congress “No!” to new sales taxes and burdens for small online businesses. BODY: more

Website managers are showing their teeth a year after Adobe’s money grab. Despite popular media outlets who endorsed Adobe’s marketing blitz that customers would love it, customers clearly do not. Last year the mammoth software provider declared an end to the install and said they would move to a subscription model whereby users would be required to pay a monthly fee for access to their software. The model is nothing revolutionary, but it does challenge the bank books for struggling website managers and small businesses who will see the cost of running software skyrocket because of the change. For Adobe Dreamweaver a one-time install ($239.88/year) versus the cloud-based annual subscription ($239.88/year) suggests you’ll be paying a lot more for the cloud-based solution over time. Adobe counters that the software includes automatic updates as well as cloud-based services that add significant value to the software. Stephen Shankland wrote last year that “Customer enthusiasm for the Creative Cloud, combined with the awkwardness more