I suppose it's because before they invented soft cold packs (which evidently were invented in 1973), it was one of those readily available things that were cold without being freezing (i.e., an actual bag of ice), stayed cold for about 15 minutes at a time, could be molded to fit the over contour of an eye socket on your face, and had a soft surface (no pokey ice corners from a bag of cubed ice).

Why not a bag of frozen peas? My guess there is that the trope pre-dates widespread home storage of frozen vegetables (when people had iceboxes instead of huge refrigerators with dedicated freezer space).

I suppose it's because before they invented soft cold packs (which evidently were invented in 1973), it was one of those readily available things that were cold without being freezing (i.e., an actual bag of ice), stayed cold for about 15 minutes at a time, could be molded to fit the over contour of an eye socket on your face, and had a soft surface (no pokey ice corners from a bag of cubed ice).

Why not a bag of frozen peas? My guess there is that the trope pre-dates widespread home storage of frozen vegetables (when people had iceboxes instead of huge refrigerators with dedicated freezer space).

Yeah, as a kid I remember that frozen vegetables tended to be in cardboard boxes, not in malleable plastic bags. In fact, most people didn't get frozen vegetables at all -- they mainly kept them in cans.

You guys have no idea. When I was a kid, we didn't even have ziplock bags! My mom was the genius of the neighborhood when she started keeping wet, frozen dish towels in the freezer and wrapping them in Saran wrap before she gave thm to the injured child.

You guys have no idea. When I was a kid, we didn't even have ziplock bags! My mom was the genius of the neighborhood when she started keeping wet, frozen dish towels in the freezer and wrapping them in Saran wrap before she gave thm to the injured child.

All of the above are correct but never underestimate the importance of a simple, arresting image in a cartoon. It's easy to draw and it gets the message across. I've never seen anyone do this in real life but the sad face of Fred Flintstone holding a steak over his black eye will live in my mind forever.

All of the above are correct but never underestimate the importance of a simple, arresting image in a cartoon. It's easy to draw and it gets the message across. I've never seen anyone do this in real life but the sad face of Fred Flintstone holding a steak over his black eye will live in my mind forever.

Good call. Will Eisner had a cartooning book that discussed such things. He'd concur.

All of the above are correct but never underestimate the importance of a simple, arresting image in a cartoon. It's easy to draw and it gets the message across. I've never seen anyone do this in real life but the sad face of Fred Flintstone holding a steak over his black eye will live in my mind forever.

It's part of a number of "conventions" not only in cartooning, but in pop culture. Like running a basin of warm watrer when you plan to commit suicide by slashing your wrists. It's pop culture shorthand that conveys the idea.

Tangentially related, but given the question has been answered, wicketkeepers in cricket used to put raw steak inside their gloves as extra padding, which you needed when you could be catching a hard 5oz ball travelling at up to 90mph four hundred times a day. Allegedly, fielding next man out from the keeper on a hot day in Australia was no picnic as the steak would start to smell over a couple of hours.

All of the above are correct but never underestimate the importance of a simple, arresting image in a cartoon. It's easy to draw and it gets the message across. I've never seen anyone do this in real life but the sad face of Fred Flintstone holding a steak over his black eye will live in my mind forever.

Or, where I saw it, it was the sad face of a bad guy who had just been punched out by Obelix.