Fox’s Tuesday sitcoms had the last laugh this Tuesday night, while ABC and NBC’s half-hours were feeling mighty low.

The New Girl season finale drew 2.4 million total viewers and a 1.2 rating, adding a few eyeballs plus a tenth in the demo, while The Mindy Project‘s own season ender — which TVLine readers graded a high “A” — did 2.4 mil and a 1.3, up in audience and two tenths in the demo.

NBC |The Voice (10.4 mil/2.4, down three tenths), About a Boy (6.4 mil/1.5, down a tenth) and Growing Up Fisher (5.2 mil/1.2, down two tenths) all hit series lows. Chicago Fire (7 mil/1.9) however ticked up a tenth in the demo to a seven-week high.