Proof? like Rob Broad? well he had none!, only accusations. I would really like to learn when he received his third or forth?? Rob Broad while drinking and driving wrapped his car around a pole outside of Chatham (actually considered part of Chatham) Killing his girlfriend,, somehow comes out with a third degree??? Dad pay for that too?? where is actual proof of training??

I sent to Rob Broad a Message,, I would personally like to know if he is worthy of his rank? no seems to want to investigate his ability! Why? so this is a copy of the last message I sent him. " SUBJECT TITLE You Decline? "I put a challenge to you because of accusations and wrongful statements you made. I would like to see if you are qualified to wear your Sixth degree Black belt? I can have the use of an MMA cage so neither of us can run away. You still have NOT responded. So if you Decline Post it on Bullshido.net. I would rather have the chance to "Spar" you 70s style" and earlier if you prefer. If not Just Let the administrators know you refuse the challenge, Use any excuse you want, OR take the challenge.

Yes, and JUST LIKE YOU he was taken to task for his crap. Unlike you, he stopped posting when it was shown he might be posting as a grudge.

I would really like to learn when he received his third or forth?? Rob Broad while drinking and driving wrapped his car around a pole outside of Chatham (actually considered part of Chatham) Killing his girlfriend,, somehow comes out with a third degree??? Dad pay for that too?? where is actual proof of training??

See this? It is a claim. Now, get an article, court documents, or verifiable proof for your accusations. This is your last warning.

People snoop into other Instructors arts when some one whines, Do they investigate the person who made the complaint at the same time? If not, WHY?

This is covered by Bullshidoka Arguments #s 2 and 10 (among others).

Argument # 2

Questioning the ability of posters here to make informed judgements.

Counter - Similar to the counter for argument #1. The presence of skilled practioners of a variety of styles is one of Bullshido.net's greatest assests. That said, you don't have to be able to sing to identify someone who can't (American Idol, anyone?).

Argument # 10

Requesting that those who are investigating, provide the same information that is being asked for them.

This tactic is used to "throw the dogs off your scent" so to speak. It makes everyone look at the accuser and not the accused. Nothing wrong with making sure that the person acting as the accuser is not doing so in a malicious way but in an honest attempt to gather important facts but it shouldn't allow the accused a free ride just because the accuser was dishonest in his/her investigative intent.

Counter - If the accused does bring up important information about the accuser then start a new thread about the accuser but keep the original thread on track with regards to the accused. This one may seem similar to one mentioned above about the ability of other posters to judge the one being investigated but it is not. This one is pointed more towards the investigated individual accusing the originator of the investigation of wrongdoing as a means of removing pressure from him/herself.