If we do go with a 4-3 Under style of defense I would be in favor of a rushbacker type to play SAM for us, like Vic Beasley. It would take some creativity on defense though to use him to his max potential and I just don't see us doing that.

I really have no idea what we're going to do or what we're doing. We won't know what's going on until FA is over. Too many holes and too much uncertainty with the FAs and coaches for us to really know or predict anything right now.

All I know is, I would love for us to go after Greg Hardy and/or FA OLmen this year.

I didn't know Anthony Collins was a FA. I would go after him. He's lowkey a very good OT.

Besides Norv/Chud who else would you bring in? I'd love to get Carmichael from New Orleans but that would be a lateral move for him.

I am not sure. I would think the Giants would have a list of assistants that are young and promising. Just like I wasn't sure who Spags was but I liked how he coached every position on defense. I like his aggressive nature and learned under Jim J. So I loved that hire.

That's the ONLY hire I agreed on and supported. I disliked Hufangel hire, Lewis, Sheridan and Fewell.

Thanks Dave! I know we gave him a lot of crap lately but Diehl is a true Giant and he was a major player in our 2 SBs. A pro's pro. He'll be missed.

Yup not his fault Coughlin kept rolling him out there when he was past his prime. Hell of a career for a 5th round pick and an instrumental part of the great and possibly best OL in the NFL those few years.

Besides Norv/Chud who else would you bring in? I'd love to get Carmichael from New Orleans but that would be a lateral move for him.

Mmm, it might not be that lateral of a move. Doesn't Payton call the plays? Everyone knows its pretty much all Payton's system and he's the offensive guru. Carmichael might feel like he needs to be "the guy" as an offensive coordinator to get a head coaching position.