'Make a stand for independent, creative film making in a world where the pressures of conformism and commercialism are becoming more powerful every day'
Lindsay Anderson.

Monday, 18 January 2016

Child 44.

A grand cast doesn’t always equate to a grand film and one
such case in point is Daniel Espinosa’s Child 44 (2015). Espinosa you may
remember was the director behind the best of the Easy Money trilogy Snabba
Cash (2010) and two of the stars from the trilogy appear in this latest
movie, Joel Kinnaman plays Vasili Nikitin a middle-ranking officer in the
Ministry of State Security (MGB) and Fares Fares who plays Alexi Andreyev. The
main star and the films narrative backbone is the popular British actor Tom
Hardy who plays Leo Demidov. As a child Demidov was orphaned during the
Holodomor[1] in
the Ukrainian SSR that took place in the 1930’s but manages to escape from the
orphanage and is taken in by some kindly Soviet soldiers eventually becoming a
war hero. After the war Leo Demidov becomes a MGB agent and uncovers a series
of child murders but the MGB leadership refuse to except the death as murders
because Soviet doctrine states that murder only occurs in capitalist country’s
“There can be no murder in paradise” One of the dead children is the son of
Leo’s best friend Alexi Andreyer and even he does not believe that his son has been
murdered! The female lead in our story, which incidentally is based on a novel
of the same name published in 2008, is another favourite of Movie Ramble Noomi
Repace who plays Leo’s wife Raisa. When Raisa is accused of being disloyal to
the state Leo refused to denounce her, both are sent to the town of Volsk and
given demeaning jobs. Both suspect that
Vasili Nikitin is behind their downfall. Other well known and respected actors
the calibre of Gary Oldman, Vincent Cassell, Paddy Considine, Charles dance and
Tara Fitzgerald all have prominent roles in the movie.

Even a cast this good can't rescue this movie.

But as I said at the beginning of this ramble a well known
and respected cast does not always mean that what we are about to see is going
to be something to rejoice over and I must say that this is true in the case of
this movie. On the face of it this should have been an exciting mystery
thriller but I’m afraid it’s completely lacking any real excitement, Its far to
long, the story is made too complicated when there is no need to bogged down with
unnecessary subplots.The heavy
“Russian” accents of the various actors force you to put on the subtitles to
help understand what’s being said. Perhaps someone could explain to me why the
story was not centred on the murder mystery, why the film was not made with
East European actors with undertitles and why everything had to be so dark? The
Ministry of Culture had the good sense to block the screening in Russia, as did
other Eastern Block countries - but it was made available on DVD in these same countries
even Russia has a bargain bin!

[1] A man-made famine in
the Ukrainian Soviet Socialist Republic in 1932 and 1933 that killed
an estimated 2.5–7.5 million Ukrainians, with millions more counted in
demographic estimates. It was part of the wider disaster, the Soviet
famine of 1932–33, which affected the major grain-producing areas of the country.