Viewpoints, Samantha Sultoon: Pursing the right goals the wrong way in Cuba

Samantha Sultoon

Saturday

May 4, 2019 at 6:03 PM

The Trump administration again turned to its coercive tool of choice, economic sanctions, to ratchet up pressure on the Cuban regime. The actions announced on April 17 were framed as punishment for Havana’s domestic repression and its support of Venezuela’s Nicolas Maduro.

The location and timing of the speech — on the 58th anniversary of the Bay of Pigs invasion — suggest that the Miami announcement was also intended to shore up political support for President Trump among Cuban hardliners angered by the Obama administration’s easing of Cuba sanctions.

Among the disjointed array of policy announcements National Security Adviser John Bolton included in his speech were new restrictions with respect to Cuba travel, remittances and transaction processing; plus the newly authorized ability for Americans whose property in Cuba was confiscated after the 1959 Cuban revolution to bring federal court actions against foreign entities “trafficking” in (i.e. using) those properties.

These changes follow the cancellation of Major League Baseball’s deal to allow Cuban baseball players into the United States absent human smugglers; previously introduced restrictions on transactions with businesses owned by the Cuban military, intelligence or security services; restrictions on educational and individual travel to Cuba; and the significant reduction of staff and services at the U.S. embassy in Havana.

While the Trump administration is right to support freedoms for the Cuban people and the end of Maduro’s rule in Venezuela, these changes are the wrong way to pursue those worthwhile goals.

U.S. administrations over time have tried — and failed — to facilitate change in Cuba through tightening unilateral sanctions. There is no evidence over the half-century embargo that this will be successful. Instead, these changes will suffocate Cuba’s private sector (or cuentapropistas) by denying them a key source of income while simultaneously alienating U.S. allies and partners.

While the devil is in forthcoming regulatory details, Bolton asserted that the U.S. Department of the Treasury will restrict non-family travel to Cuba. If the Trump administration actually wants to support the Cuban people as advocated for in its central policy, it will allow additional areas of authorized travel to remain available, particularly for journalists, humanitarian support and legitimate educational research and travel.

These and other areas of permissible travel have demonstrably benefitted the Cuban private sector, which employs as many as four in 10 working-age Cubans and has already suffered under the 2017 Trump administration restrictions on authorized travel to Cuba.

Exacerbating the economic hardship for the cuentapropistas, and the Cuban people writ large, will be the second announced sanctions change reducing remittances to $1,000 per person, per quarter. The Obama administration had removed the Treasury caps on most remittances, which were estimated in 2018 to reach at least $2 billion per year. Remittances comprise a key source of investment capital for Cuban households and private enterprise. While the drop in remittances will limit opportunities for the Cuban government to benefit from remitted funds from its people, it will certainly hurt the Cuban people more.

Cuba has already weathered decades of unilateral U.S. sanctions. While its economy is certainly in a precarious position due to reduced support from Venezuela, Havana has demonstrated its adaptability to such pressures.

Although the new Trump policies may increase pressure on the Cuban regime, the negative impact on the Cuban people will be far greater. Further, these new policies are certain to generate tensions with U.S. allies and prove a distraction as the U.S. seeks to increase pressure on the Maduro regime, where the chances of success are far greater.

Samantha Sultoon is visiting senior fellow at The Atlantic Council. She wrote this for InsideSources.com.

Never miss a story

Choose the plan that's right for you.
Digital access or digital and print delivery.