What makes a successful book proposal? Publisher lets public weigh in

By By Hector Tobar

Feb 03, 2014 | 8:27 AM

The late Celia Cruz is among the women profiled in a forthcoming book by Florida State professor Delia Poey, "Cuban Women and Salsa." Now you can read Poey's book proposal online. (Celia Cruz Foundation)

If you've ever thought about writing a book, and wondered what a successful proposal looks like, wonder no longer.

In a unique experiment, the publisher Palgrave Macmillan is posting proposals for nonfiction, academic titles, and inviting the public to comment on them. The publisher is also posting chapters from the proposed books -- all of which have been already accepted for publication. The books take on a wide range of topics in the social sciences and humanities, and include titles on "race and the Brazilian body," horror cinema, and the German revolutionary Rosa Luxemburg.

Advertisement

"Forms of open and interactive peer review are now widely used in science publishing, but are still rare in the humanities and the social sciences," Palgrave Macmillan wrote on its website. "This will be the first trial to invite open comment on and review of scholarly book proposals, and the first to investigate how open peer review can contribute to the development of scholarly books at such an early stage in the writing process."

Carrie Calder, Palgrave Macmillan's director of market development, told the British journal the Bookseller that: "We see this experiment as an opportunity to contribute to the emerging debate on opening up the closed peer review system, and increasing transparency in academic publishing."

During the six-week experiment, which launched last week, readers can access the original book proposals, peer review comments and sample chapter. Professor Delia Poey at Florida State University began her proposal for "Cuban Women and Salsa," with a simple declarative sentence: "Although Salsa as a musical phenomenon has garnered academic interest from various disciplines in the last fifteen years, the contributions of female performers has been largely ignored." She proposed to write about the pioneer singers Rita Montaner and Celeste Mendoza, and also about the legendary Celia Cruz.

Chapter Two of Poey's book has a more lyrical tone. "Long before the word Salsa came to refer to music, there was son, and alongside son there was rumba."

Other books in the experiment include titles on digital culture and European asylum seekers.