Expiry of emissions pact in 2012 bedevils talks

BONN, Germany — Delegates from 184 nations are exploring “constructive and creative” solutions to make industrial countries continue reducing greenhouse gas emissions after their current commitments end next year, the top U.N. climate official said Monday.

By:
Arthur Max, Associated Press

BONN, Germany — Delegates from 184 nations are exploring “constructive and creative” solutions to make industrial countries continue reducing greenhouse gas emissions after their current commitments end next year, the top U.N. climate official said Monday.

The expiry of the 1997 Kyoto Protocol, which bound nearly 40 countries to specific emission reductions targets, is the backdrop to one of the most divisive issues as nations seek agreement on combating global warming.

Hopes for an overarching climate accord, which fell flat at the Copenhagen climate summit in 2009, remain dim as negotiators in Bonn spend the next two weeks preparing for another major climate conference in Durban, South Africa, starting Nov. 28.

A key obstacle is the fate of the protocol.

Countries generally have fallen into camps of rich and poor on the issue. Developing countries insist the Kyoto obligations be extended and new targets adopted. Industrial countries say they want emerging economies to accept similar commitments.

Three countries that fell under the Kyoto mandate — Japan, Canada and Russia — have said they will not renew their commitments after they expire in 2012. The United States was never part of Kyoto.

But Christiana Figueres, head of the U.N. climate change secretariat, said negotiators appear to be moving outside of the rich-poor boxes.

“Countries are being much more constructive and creative,” she told reporters at the start of a two-week negotiating session attended by 184 nations.

“We don't know yet where it's going to lead, but there is a very healthy atmosphere of really listening to each other,” she said.

Most countries want to find a formula that also embraces the United States, but the U.S. delegation affirmed it would accept treaty commitments only if countries like China and India do.

“The U.S. is committed to a legally binding outcome that would engage all major economies,” said Jonathan Pershing, the chief delegate. “We are not committed to any outcome which would only obligate developed countries ... nor are we committed to an empty agreement merely for the sake of an agreement,” he said.

In a sign of the complexity of the talks, the formal start of the conference was delayed by more than half a day while delegates haggled over the agenda, with several countries insisting on the inclusion of their special interests.

Saudi Arabia, for example, wanted a discussion on the fallout of a climate deal that could be harmful for its economy, and how it could be compensated for the loss of oil revenue.

The U.S. delegation wanted more work done on verifying that countries meet their commitments. That issue, pitting the U.S. against China, nearly caused the collapse of the last year-end conference in Cancun, Mexico, before a skeleton deal was done.

“By Durban we should have guidelines developed for reporting and verification,” Pershing said. He linked progress on “transparency” with finalizing a Green Climate Fund, a $100 billion annual payment to developing countries to help them adapt to climate change and move toward low-carbon economies.

The deal struck in Cancun, he said, was “a balanced package which included financing and transparency.”

Reports of record high greenhouse gas emissions and unprecedented carbon levels in the atmosphere added a sense of urgency as the talks began.

The International Energy Agency said energy-related carbon emissions last year reached record levels — more than 30 gigatons, or 5 percent more than the previous peak in 2008. Experts had predicted the financial crisis that caused a sharp dip in emissions in 2009 would continue in 2010.

The Paris-based agency said the figures were “a serious setback” to hopes of limiting the rise in the Earth's average temperature to 2 degrees Celsius (3.8 F) above preindustrial levels.

Another report by the U.S. government monitoring station in Mauna Loa, Hawaii, recorded carbon levels in May of 395 parts per million, compared with 290 at the beginning of the industrial revolution 150 years ago. Scientists believe atmospheric concentration of carbon is trapping the Earth's heat and causing it to gradually warm.

Also contributing to the apprehension was uncertainty over Japan's future policy, and whether it will adhere to its pledge to reduce emissions by 25 percent after the tsunami-triggered nuclear disaster in March.

Japanese Prime Minister Naoto Kan, speaking in the Diet, or parliament, last week, reaffirmed the pledge. But a Japanese delegate at the Bonn talks said the target was likely to be dropped from a compromise climate bill due to be enacted this month, and would not be binding on the government.

“If we can't have the 25 percent in the Basic Law, then we lose it,” said Yuri Okubo, an activist for the Climate Action Network-Japan.

Japan's 120 million people produce 4 percent of the world's emissions, and it is considered a key player at the climate talks.