Traffic Calming – Saving Lives and Saving Energy

An artist's rendering of what Canal Street in Brattleboro could look like after a major redesign to make it more pedestrian friendly; see below for a current photo.

Brattleboro, Vermont hasn't been a good place to be a pedestrian recently. In the past nine months there have been nine accidents in which pedestrians were hit by vehicles, including two fatalities (one immediate and the other from injuries six weeks later).

While recent events make us focus close to home, pedestrian safety is a widespread problem. Nationwide in 2009, there were 4,092 pedestrians killed by vehicles and 59,000 accidents. Those pedestrian fatalities represented 12% of all traffic deaths. In addition, there were 630 bicyclists killed in collisions with motor vehicles in 2009 and 51,000 injuries.

So, what can we do about it?

Traffic calming. The Institute of Transportation Engineers defines traffic calming as "the combination of mainly physical measures that reduce the negative effects of motor vehicle use, alter driver behavior, and improve conditions for non-motorized street users." There are a lot of effective strategies for slowing down vehicles and creating pedestrian-friendly communities that are not only improve safety but also help us save energy by making getting around without a car more feasible. Here are a few of these strategies:

Install stop signs or traffic lights
This is the old-school solution. Stop signs and traffic lights slow traffic, to be sure, but they also increase fuel use and pollution from idling. There are better strategies that keep traffic moving, while slowing it down and improving safety.

Narrow travel lanes while adding medians and bike lanes
On narrower streets, we drive slower. If pedestrian collisions do occur, at slower speeds the severity of those injuries and the likelihood of death are greatly reduced. Bike lanes should be wide enough for safety (six feet) and clearly separated from the vehicle lane(s) with a different color or even a different texture. In some cities, a brick or brick-like surface is used for the bike lanes so that vehicle drivers are made aware when they cross into bike lane.

Provide plenty of cross-walks
Install clearly identified cross-walks. When it's possible to put in medians, the cross-walks can be designed to cross just one lane of traffic then traverse the median (often at an angle) to reach the other cross-walk. The medians become pedestrian refuges while crossing streets. Curb extensions that narrow the travel lane can shorten the distance of a cross-walk.

Reduce the sight-line for drivers
When we can see a quarter-mile down a straight-away, we tend to step on the gas. Features that reduce that sight-line include planting trees, adding curb extensions or bulbouts, installing mini traffic circles (see below), and adding chicanes to the roadway – a group of three alternating curb-extensions or bulbouts mid-block that result in an S-curve, which slows traffic.

Install speed humps or raised intersectionsSpeed humps aren't conventional speed bumps, but an updated version that are much wider – typically 12 to 22 feet wide with 3-4 inches of vertical deflection. Raised intersections, in which the entire intersection is raised and may have a different surfacing material. Both of these features are designed so that the faster you drive over them, the greater the discomfort — this is different from speed bumps, which at faster speeds may actually become more comfortable because the car's shock absorbers absorb the bump better. Speed humps don't make sense for traveled routes, but they can be appropriate for smaller residential streets and shopping centers. Downsides include slowing emergency responders and, in cold climates, making snow removal more difficult.

Provide on-street parking
On-street parking narrows the travel lane (or creates that illusion) and gives the street a more urban feel. Drivers are more cautious. Curb extensions or bulbouts can define parking areas, and they reduce the sight-line. The safest type of on-street parking is actually back-in diagonal parking. With this approach, the diagonal lines slant away from approaching cars, rather than toward those cars, so drivers have to back into spaces. The parking is a little more difficult than standard diagonal parking, but safety is improved. Loading the trunk is also safer with back-in parking, and when kids get out of cars the open doors blocks their access into the street.

Move sidewalks away from the curb
By moving sidewalks further back from the curb two benefits are realized. First, a buffer strip can be created that can be planted with trees or other landscaping, thus helping to make the streetscape more pedestrian friendly. Second, in a cold climate, snow plowing will not dump snow into the sidewalk, so it's easier to keep sidewalks clear for pedestrians. When the sidewalk is right next to the curb, it's not uncommon for pedestrians to have to walk in the street after a snowstorm – putting themselves at great risk.

Replace stop signs with mini-circles
With mini-circles instead of stop signs, cars don't have to stop and start as often, and drivers tend to accelerate less between those intersections. Vehicles move more efficiently and save gas. Because drivers don't see a long straight-away, but instead see a bit of greenery at every intersection, they drive at a more relaxed pace, but by not having to stop at intersections, they get where they're going just as fast. Seattle has installed more than 1,000 mini traffic circles (typically 15-20 feet in diameter) over the past several decades, and neighborhoods take pride in landscaping their local circles; the city even has competitions for the most attractive circles. A study in Seattle found a remarkable 94% reduction in accidents at intersections with mini traffic circles.

Beautify streetscapes
More attractive streets with trees, benches, public art, and other amenities encourage drivers to slow down. When all you see from the car is asphalt and parking lots, the tendency is to speed up. Beautification may seem like an unnecessary expense for a town or city, but it can pay off with greater pedestrian safety. Beautification programs can be public-private partnerships to get more bang for the buck from tax dollars.

Included in the final report (download here - large file) are inspiring images that show how Canal Street could be dramatically redesigned to slow down traffic, provide for non-motorized ("active") transportation, and improve pedestrian safety. All of these improvements would not only make Brattleboro a nicer place, but also save energy by making it more feasible for residents to leave their cars at home.

The inner ring suburbs in the Twin Cities are much more walkable than the outlying suburbs. The inner ring neighborhood business districts are somewhat intact and you can get the essentials with a short walk. Bus transportation downtown is readily available and homes in these suburbs although not large generally, command a good price per square foot.

The outer ring suburbs are a different story, the auto is king, nothing is handy, hardware stores have disappeared. The "urge to shop" is overwhelming to most, plus you can drive up for coffee and talk on your phone while en route. Pedestrians beware!

2.
Mar 8, 2012 10:52 PM ET

Great synopsis Alex. by James Morgan

I hope Brattleboro is able to implement Dan's recommendations.

3.
Mar 9, 2012 6:24 PM ET

Treelawns by michael maines

In New England the sidewalk is typically right next to, or very close to, the road. If there is a green strip it's called a curb strip and in most cases is a miserable little patch of weeds and doggie doo.

In Cleveland, and possibly other midwestern cities, the strip between the sidewalk and the street is often quite wide and impeccably maintained. The sidewalk can be halfway between the street and the house. They call the strip the "tree lawn." I love the name, and the concept.

Having lived in Seattle for a while I'm not sure how much gas is wasted at the mini-circles, or the right-turn-only rule, and traffic jams are still a problem, but the mini-circles are nice for bikers and pedestrians.

4.
Mar 10, 2012 8:35 AM ET

re by Keith Gustafson

2 fatalities, in a town of 12000, man I don't think the street design is the main culprit.....

About the Authors

Alex Wilson is founder and executive editor of BuildingGreen, LLC in Brattleboro, VT. He is coauthor of the Consumer Guide to Home Energy Savings (9th edition, 2007) and author of Your Green Home (2006). Content from this blog originally appeared in the Brattleboro Reformer and is more relevant to colder climates. An abbreviated index of this blog can be found here.