JaneOlivia (really like Jane, but recently befriended a couple with a baby named Jane. For some reason, I always think of the other couples' Jane now, and it's not as special to me. Maybe this would go away after birth?)

AnnieRose OR Annabel/nn AnnieKate (We both LOVE the name Annie. Originally, we dismissed it, as I have a cousin named Annie ((I never see her)). Now it's back on the table. I feel like it needs a formal version, and Annabel would give her the option of going by Anna if she wants when older. I like Annalise too, but fear it's too close to big sister's middle name) I meant Rose or Kate as middle names for Annie by the way. I would call her just Annie!

I'm open to suggestions! We may have to take a couple names to the hospital, but that makes me nervous! Thanks for any advice!

Thank you! @fiametta- I love Lucy and Grace, but my husband has vetoed them. Beautiful names on your list!
@judyariel-Thanks! AnnaRose is gorgeous! Is Anna getting really popular? Do you think Annie is an appropriate nn for Anna sometimes. And I love the middle name Rose, but my last name starts with an M. It would spell ARM. Is that a dealbreaker? Also, Alice is another great one from your list. LoveLillian too, but it's already taken in the family. Thanks for your help!