Asia Pacific|Where 518 Inmates Sleep in Space for 170, and Gangs Hold It Together

Image

Detainees in Manila City Jail, where most are still awaiting trial, and may stay for months or even years before that happens.CreditCreditHannah Reyes Morales for The New York Times

Philippines Dispatch

Where 518 Inmates Sleep in Space for 170, and Gangs Hold It Together

Misery and overcrowding are worse than ever in the Philippines’ pretrial jails, with guards so outnumbered that gangs increasingly keep the peace.

Detainees in Manila City Jail, where most are still awaiting trial, and may stay for months or even years before that happens.CreditCreditHannah Reyes Morales for The New York Times

Supported by

By Aurora Almendral

Jan. 7, 2019

MANILA — For some inmates of the Manila City Jail, making the bed means mopping up sludgy puddles, unfolding a square of cardboard on the tile floor and lying down to sleep in a small, windowless bathroom, wedged in among six men and a toilet.

On one recent night at the jail, in Dorm 5, the air was thick and putrid with the sweat of 518 men crowded into a space meant for 170.

The inmates were cupped into each other, limbs draped over a neighbor’s waist or knee, feet tucked against someone else’s head, too tightly packed to toss and turn in the sweltering heat.

If an inmate has money, he can buy a spot in a “kubol,” a small, improvised cubicle shared by two or more men, separated from the crowds with plywood walls and a curtain.

Image

Inmates lining up for food. Gangs are instrumental in ensuring some food supplies.CreditHannah Reyes Morales for The New York Times

Image

Officials searching for contraband during a surprise inspection. One gang was recently found to have more than $13,000 in cash on hand.CreditHannah Reyes Morales for The New York Times

Otherwise, it’s the floor, or perhaps a bathroom, or on a stairway fashioned from two-by-fours; if an inmate falls off one of those steps, he takes everyone below with him.

Few of these inmates have been convicted — most are pretrial detainees — but many will spend months or even years in the jail because the court system is so jammed.

The overcrowding has gone on for so long, and the detainees outnumber the guards by so many, that a tacit agreement between officials and jailhouse gangs has become the rule.

The gangs are technically illegal, but they help keep things from melting down into chaos and often help stretch scarce jail resources to keep inmates fed, officials and inmates said.

Some officials are blunt about how bad things have gotten.

“When you are detained in Philippine jails, you are being tortured,” said Leah Armamento, a member of the Philippine government’s Commission on Human Rights.

Image

Watching television. Most inmates are pretrial detainees. Some will wait months for their cases to be resolved.CreditHannah Reyes Morales for The New York Times

Image

A TV showing a movie that portrays inmates in the Manila City Jail.CreditHannah Reyes Morales for The New York Times

She was referring to a 2015 finding by the United Nations Subcommittee on Prevention of Torture, which called for urgent action to address overcrowding.

The Philippine judicial system is riddled with inefficiencies, and there is a culture of bribery and structural incentives for judges and lawyers to move slowly, despite a constitutional right to a speedy trial, said Raymund Narag, an assistant professor at Southern Illinois University who studies Philippine jails.

One inmate, a boy who left home after his family disowned him for being gay, was arrested in April 2017 on accusations of shouting in public and carrying a concealed knife.

He was 15 years old at the time, he said, but the arresting officers put down a date of birth suggesting he was over 18, and he was taken to Manila City Jail.

Now 16, his case was resolved two months after his arrest, when the prosecutor requested his release after a dental exam proved he was a minor. But the jail has not received a final order for his release from the Social Welfare Department.

Lost amid a culture of institutional indifference, he has been in jail for a year and nine months — far surpassing the sentence he would have received had he actually been convicted, which would have been as little as a $4 fine or 15 days in jail.

Image

Inmates practicing Zumba in the exercise yard.CreditHannah Reyes Morales for The New York Times

Image

A professor who has studied the Philippine prison system said overcrowding has made the jails “much more communal, so the cell becomes a family inside.”CreditHannah Reyes Morales for The New York Times

The boy, whose name is being withheld because he is a minor, said that he wanted to be released, of course, but that he did not know how to make that happen.

“Nobody is helping me,” he said.

Mr. Narag, the professor, spent six years as a pretrial detainee in a Philippine jail himself, before finally being acquitted in 2002. He was a lawyer by training, and climbed the jail gang hierarchy to become a high-ranking “mayor de mayores,” or mayor of mayors.

The slow justice system and the elaborate social world of the jail are related, Mr. Narag explained.

“You stay so long inside the jail you need to develop a coping mechanism to survive,” he said.

Accordingly, he said, compared with places like the United States, the Philippine jails have become “much more communal, so the cell becomes a family inside.”

The gangs are those families, and officials concede that an informal agreement to share governance keeps them from losing control of the jail.

On a recent shift at the Manila City Jail, there was one correctional officer for every 528 inmates. The Philippine government recommends a ratio of one for every seven inmates.

Image

Inmates getting haircuts.CreditHannah Reyes Morales for The New York Times

Image

A mosque in the jail.CreditHannah Reyes Morales for The New York Times

“There’s an equilibrium of peace and order here,” said Capt. Jayrex Bustinera, the spokesman and chief of records for the jail. “Formally, we don’t allow inmates to police other inmates. Informally, we do because of a lack of resources.”

One inmate, Buboy Mendiola, 37, heads up the Sigue Sigue Sputnik gang, and also oversees an informal prison economy, where earnings are pooled to fund the needs of his group — one of the five main gangs that functionally govern the jail from within.

In a recent raid, jail administrators found that the Sputnik gang’s treasury held 720,000 pesos, or about $13,700. Mr. Mendiola bought pigs and hundreds of chickens for the Sputniks’ Christmas feast last month.

And he keeps a fund for medical emergencies and basic needs for the dorm, like soap and toothpaste, he said.

“Boredom lets the devil into your mind,” Mr. Mendiola said. He said he worried that if the men weren’t occupied, they could start causing trouble.

There is fighting, which cannot be avoided living in such close quarters, but it can be somewhat policed, he said.

In the Sputniks, getting into a fistfight will be punished with five lashes, and if someone draws blood, that number jumps to 15 or 20.

Approach another inmate’s visitor without invitation and get 20 lashes. Wink at someone else’s visitor, and it’s 25.

“It’s the kind of thing that starts rumbles,” Mr. Mendiola said.

The beatings are conducted with a lacquered wooden bat, painted with “SPUTNIK No. 1” on one side and “CMDR. BUBOY MENDIOLA” on the other.

After six years at Manila City Jail, Mr. Mendiola’s lawyer recently told him that his time would be ending in a few months and that he would be acquitted of his crime. He is working with a secret council of his deputies to find the next commander.

“Someone godly,” Mr. Mendiola said, “who cares about people, wants to do the right thing and is judicious in his discipline.”

Image

An inmate’s tattoos. “There’s an equilibrium of peace and order here,” the jail’s spokesman said. “Formally, we don’t allow inmates to police other inmates. Informally, we do because of a lack of resources.”CreditHannah Reyes Morales for The New York Times