Crane & Canopy 400 Thread Count Sheets

These cotton sateen sheets impressed us by hardly pilling in our tests. The fabric strength overall was average, and though it fit our sample mattress, it did have some shrinkage after laundering. Consumer testers didn't love the feel of it: some called it "rough" and "just OK," though others referred to it as "crisp." Keep in mind: unlike other online-only sets, its return policy doesn't allow you to try it out first.

How We Tested: We evaluated the durability of each sheet set by testing its fabric strength, tear resistance, pilling resistance, shrinkage after laundering and appearance after laundering. We also examined its wrinkle resistance and fit to mattress when new and after multiple wash cycles. We then had consumer testers blindly rate the fabric for softness and their opinion of the feel.