Results: Patients with ON had higher median plasma NfHSMI35 values than controls (0.17 versus 0.005 ng/ml; p < 0.05) and higher NOx values (49 versus 35.5μM; p < 0.001). Plasma NfHSMI35 values correlated inversely with visual acuity at presentation (R = −0.67; p = 0.01). NfHSMI35 was higher in patients with poor recovery of visual acuity than in those with good recovery (0.25 ng/ml versus 0.09 ng/ml; p < 0.05). Three of four patients with high NfHSMI35 and high NOx values experienced a poor recovery as opposed to only one of five with high NOx but normal NfHSMI35 values.

Conclusions: NfHSMI35, a surrogate marker for axonal damage, is a prognostic indicator and should be considered in the design of neuroprotective treatment strategies.

The “axonal death cascade”1 has been associated with nitric oxide (NO) mediated damage in vitro.2 However, the relation of axonal degeneration to NO release in vivo is not known. Acute optic neuritis provides a useful model because of the defined onset and the anatomically restricted area of neuronal damage.3,4 Increased concentrations of the NO metabolites (NOx) nitrite (NO2−) and nitrate (NO3−) were found in the cerebrospinal fluid and serum of patients with optic neuritis (ON).5,6 Axonal loss appears to be linked to the acquisition of a permanent deficit.2,7–12 However, the role of inflammation in demyelinating disease is less well defined, and there is accumulating evidence that immune mediated inflammation has neuroprotective properties.1,13

Our study aimed to investigate the relation between the loss and recovery of optic nerve function with surrogate markers of inflammation (citrulline and the NO metabolites NO2− and NO3−)2,14–16 and for axonal injury (neurofilaments17) in patients with acute optic neuritis.

PATIENTS AND METHODS

Patients presenting with symptoms suggestive of acute unilateral ON (n = 18) and age matched healthy controls (n = 14) were investigated in this prospective study (table 1). Inclusion criteria for patients with ON were: progressive loss of vision over a few days, decreased visual acuity (VA; Snellen chart), decreased colour vision (Ishihara colour plates), and relative afferent pupillary defect.3 Because VA was severely affected in most cases, the visual fields were usually assessed by confrontation. Because this is not a quantitative method, this precluded the use of perimetry in the quantitative assessment. Exclusion criteria were: any other macular or retinal pathology, contemporaneous symptoms suggestive of demyelination elsewhere, or lack of spontaneous recovery. Our study was approved by the local ethics committee. Recovery of VA and colour vision was assessed at each visit and once recovery stabilised no further follow up was arranged. The last recorded VA was taken as the final outcome. Brain and optic nerve magnetic resonance imaging (MRI) was performed using a 1.5 Tesla system (Siemens AG, Erlangen, Germany) and consisted of axial T1 and T2 weighted spin echo MRI.3,5 Plasma was taken at the first visit and concentrations of the phosphorylated neurofilament heavy chain (NfHSMI35), NOx, and citrulline were measured as described previously.14,16,17

Data analysis was performed using SAS. Because of non-Gaussian data distribution the medians and interquartile ranges are shown. All correlations were studied using Spearman’s rank correlation coefficient. Differences between groups were compared using the two sided Wilcoxon two sample test. Significances based on small numbers were checked on a categorical level using the two sided Fischer’s exact test. Trend analysis was carried out using the Mantel-Haenzel χ2 test. A 5% level of significance was used throughout.

RESULTS

The diagnosis of ON was confirmed in all 18 patients during follow up. However, in four patients the blood sample was taken over four weeks after onset of symptoms. Therefore, these patients were excluded from our analysis. The remaining 14 patients presented with a median time from onset of two weeks (table 1). At presentation, 10 of 14 of the patients had a VA of less then 0.33 (6/18, 20/60 Snellen equivalent). In total, 13 of 14 patients showed sustained improvement of their VA during follow up. A minor degree of optic atrophy was seen in four of nine patients whose VA recovered to over 0.33 (6/18). Optic nerve atrophy was more severe in those five of the patients who did not recover their VA above 0.33.

Plasma concentrations of NfHSMI35 (fig 1 A) and NOx (fig 1B) were significantly higher in patients with ON than in controls (p < 0.001 and p < 0.01, respectively). No such difference was found for citrulline (table 1). There was a negative correlation between NfHSMI35 and VA at the time of first presentation (R = −0.67; p = 0.01; fig 1C). One outlier with NfHSMI35 values of 0.65 ng/ml was seen. This 48 old male patient presented with a right ON, VA was reduced to hand movement (6/60, 20/200 Snellen equivalent), colour vision to 0/17, and there was a right relative afferent pupillary deficit. This patient had suffered from an episode of myelitis two years previously. In the absence of clinical signs of myelitis, no spinal MRI was performed. After the removal of this patient from our study the correlation between NfHSMI35 and VA remained significant (R = −0.60; p < 0.05), but the slope of the linear regression decreased from −0.22 to −0.145.

No correlation between VA and either NOx or citrulline was found at presentation. There was no correlation between NfHSMI35, NOx, or citrulline and age or time from onset; in addition, there were no sex differences.

Plasma NfHSMI35 concentrations at presentation were significantly higher (mean, 0.25 ng/ml) in the patients with poor recovery of visual function (0.33; 6/18, 20/60 Snellen equivalent) when compared with those whose VA recovered to above 0.33 (mean, 0.09 ng/ml; p⩽0.05). The difference remained significant when comparing proportions of patients with NfHSMI35 values above the cut off value (fig 1A; p = 0.015; two sided Fisher’s exact test). There were no differences in NOx values at presentation between those with good versus poor visual recovery at follow up (54.2 versus 44.6μM; p = 0.1).

The combined association between raised NOx and NfHSMI35 concentrations and recovery of visual function was investigated by comparing proportions of patients with high values (raised above the top value of the control group; NfHSMI35, > 0.17 ng/ml; NOx, > 43.8μM). There was a significant trend for increased proportion of patients experiencing a poor recovery (Mantel-Haenzel χ2 = 4.6; p < 0.05) across the following categories: NfHSMI35 normal and NOx normal (none of three, 0% poor recovery), NfHSMI35 normal and NOx high (one of five, 20% poor recovery), NfHSMI35 high and NOx normal (one of two, 50% poor recovery), NfHSMI35 high and NOx high (three of four, 75% poor recovery).

MRI results were available in 10 of 14 patients; six had an isolated ON lesion (mean NfHSMI35, 0.12 ng/ml; mean NOx, 40.7μM), as opposed to four with disseminated brain lesions (mean NfHSMI35, 0.17 ng/ml; mean NOx, 52.9μM). Although NfHSMI35 and NOx seemed to be marginally higher in patients with disseminated brain lesions this did not reach significance.

DISCUSSION

Ours is the first study to measure biomarkers for axonal injury (NfHSMI35) and inflammation (NOx, citrulline) in the plasma of patients with acute ON. The main findings were that NfHSMI35 concentrations were higher in patients with ON than in controls, they were inversely correlated with VA at presentation, and they were of prognostic relevance. This suggests the presence of axonal damage in the acute phase. The results are in line with clinical, MRI, and electrophysiological evidence of optic nerve fibre loss following a single episode of ON and insidiously in multiple sclerosis (MS).18–20

Recovery of the VA to > 6/18 (20/60) was achieved by fewer patients (36%) than recovery of the VA to > 20/50 (88%) in the optic neuritis treatment trial after five years of follow up.4 Bradley and Whitty (1967) found that recovery of VA to > 20/30 was achieved by 50% of patients after one month and 75% after six months.21 The results of our present study may relate to the small sample size and the relatively short period of follow up (25–189 days).

Recovery of VA in MS related ON has been attributed to resolution of the conduction block caused by acute inflammation.19,20 NO mediated conduction block also seems to be the initial mechanism in in vitro studies.2,22,23 Our present study and one other study5 failed to show a significant relation between serum NOx values and outcome. In addition, NOx and NfHSMI35 did not correlate with MRI parameters, but this could be a result of the small study population. The almost 30–40% higher values, if true, might indicate that demyelinating activity elsewhere is contributing to the worse outcome.

Citrulline is thought to be another marker of NO mediated inflammation, but it did not correlate with NOx and no differences were seen between patients with ON and controls. This finding is in keeping with one study comparing cerebrospinal fluid and serum citrulline concentrations between patients with Lewy body dementia and healthy controls.18 We agree with these authors that citrulline is not a good surrogate marker for NO metabolism because it is also a substrate for enzymes other than inducible nitrogen oxide synthetase.

In MS, it appears that inflammatory markers are predominately related to disease activity and the MRI lesion load but not to outcome.5,24 In addition, epidemiological data suggest that inflammation in MS has only a limited effect on the course of neurodegeneration.25 In placebo controlled trials and clinical experience with ON, anti-inflammatory treatment with steroids does not influence outcome in most cases.3 The destructive and neuroprotective aspects of inflammation have stimulated a controversial discussion.1,5,13,25–27 Therefore, it is interesting that in this small group, four of five of the patients with raised NOx concentrations but normal NfHSMI35 values made a good recovery. This finding highlights the potential for selection bias in treatment trials for neuroprotective drugs by inclusion of those patients with evidence of inflammation only.

Taken together, these findings support the concept that sustained loss of optic nerve function relates to axonal degeneration and that NO might contribute, at least in part, to the “axonal death cascade”.1,2,7–9

Footnotes

Competing interests: none declared

Request Permissions

If you wish to reuse any or all of this article please use the link below which will take you to the Copyright Clearance Center’s RightsLink service. You will be able to get a quick price and instant permission to reuse the content in many different ways.