I was thinking about brewing this later this week, but I'm out of tettnang. I could stop by the LHBS and pick some up, but I have quite a bit of crystal and liberty on hand. Would either of those as a substitute? I looked at byo's hop reference chart and neither of them were substitutes, but I figured since there was just a 60 min addition, you wouldn't get too much flavor from the hops.

I was thinking about brewing this later this week, but I'm out of tettnang. I could stop by the LHBS and pick some up, but I have quite a bit of crystal and liberty on hand. Would either of those as a substitute? I looked at byo's hop reference chart and neither of them were substitutes, but I figured since there was just a 60 min addition, you wouldn't get too much flavor from the hops.

I'd lean towards the Liberty. Hops don't play much of a role in this style, except to balance the beer. As long as you maintain a 2.5 to 1 (OG to IBU) ratio and keep this puppy malty (sweet), the hops really don't matter.

brewed this about a month ago, just got around to bottling it, and can't wait to try the result. in typical tranceamerica fashion, I didn't do the exact recipe, but used nugget hops (don't ask...) and nottingham yeast. Yeah, not exactly the same but I'm a dry yeast kind of guy. excited about the results, with the sorta warm seattle summer coming...

brewed this about a month ago, just got around to bottling it, and can't wait to try the result. in typical tranceamerica fashion, I didn't do the exact recipe, but used nugget hops (don't ask...) and nottingham yeast. Yeah, not exactly the same but I'm a dry yeast kind of guy. excited about the results, with the sorta warm seattle summer coming...

I brewed this about 6 weeks ago, fermented 2-3 weeks and kegged one fermenter, the other fermenter is still sitting....tastes realy great...cant wait to see how it will taste in another couple months...i am definately brewing a 15 gallon batch of this next march or early April to have for the warm months of June, July, and August (along with 15 gallons of my orange wheat that my friends seem to never get enough of...im brewing an oatmeal stout tomorrow to have ready by the colder months....and definately 15 gallons of my irish red and maybe a 5 gal batch of an oktoberfest to try it out, even though its pushing it time-wise for it...

__________________
"Because Beer makes you feel how you ought to feel without Beer"

Man, just pulled my first hydro after < 10 days and it's already fantastic!

I ended up doing a split batch (1/2 Kolsch and 1/2 Notty) and fermented between 58-60F. I raised the temp to 65F after 7 days and raised it again today to 70F to finish things up. I still can't get over how clean WLP029 is. When fermented this low, it really is almost lager like w/o the extra trouble. I remember it being somewhat of a bitch to clear, but that's not a huge concern to me when it tastes this freaking good!

The Kolsch batch isn't quite as clear and has a little bit of a bready/yeasty aroma, but overall tastes really clean and is quite tasty. It definitely came out a little more malt forward than the Notty batch.

Surprisingly, I think I actually like the Notty better though. It cleared better, has little/no aroma, and came out a little drier/crisper/cleaner tasting than the Kolsch IMO. I was unhappy w/ the last beer I made w/ Notty, but this is probably the best beer I've made to date. Really, really close to the real thing and slightly better IMHO.

I highly suggest giving Notty a try for anyone not wanting to deal w/ liquid yeast...and if you do, definitely keep the temps really low if possible. I kept mine at 58F and it still fermented out almost completely within 72 hours.

I highly suggest giving Notty a try for anyone not wanting to deal w/ liquid yeast...and if you do, definitely keep the temps really low if possible. I kept mine at 58F and it still fermented out almost completely within 72 hours.

Rodger that. Can't wait to brew it up this weekend. Should I skip 5 gallons and just brew 10?