Author
Topic: 10 questions [#2690] (Read 4603 times)

I respect your thoughtfulness and have answers to your 10 questions. I am a Christian who tries hard to be one even though I am not perfect and do make mistakes. Here is my attempt to answer your 10 questions, some are correct but some may or may not be. Please bear with me, I tried my imperfect best to answer the questions. Sincerely, Ed

1) I wish God would heal amputees but perhaps the reason he does not is because that would be too obvious a miracle. Obvious miracles could replace faith to the point when there would be no faith. Without faith there is no salvation, this is why you must choose Christianity before you die and see God.

2) Food is provided but much of the time, the country's government steals the food for themselves to eat or sell.

3) This is a tough question but I think that the old testament writers could not fully interpret Gods' inspirational meanings. This is one of the reasons why Jesus came here, to clarify what God The Father meant. This is why you do not read such laws within the new testament.

4) The Bible is scientifically accurate, for example: biblical lists of clean and unclean creatures have a significance often ignored. These lists emphasize a fact not discovered until late in the last century, that animals carry diseases dangerous to man. In fact, the same animals labeled unclean in Scripture still carry parasitic diseases that are still dangerous to human beings today.One of Gods' laws is to circumcise a baby boy when he is exactly 8 days old, doctors now know that a baby's' immune system is very strong on the 8th day. Also, Modern scientific studies have shown that the blood-clotting mechanism in a baby is not fully developed until the eighth day, so it was not wise to do a surgical procedure earlier because of the threat of hemorrhage.The Bible revealed that the earth is round. Job 26:10, Prov 8:27, Isaiah 40:22, Amos 9:6. The people of the fifteenth century feared sailing because they thought they would fall over the edge of the flat earth. Yet the Bible revealed the truth in 1000 B.C. 2500 years before man discovered it for himself!

5) During ancient times, "slaves" were actually paid servants whom were treated well. The Egyptians did not treat their slaves ( servants ) well so God put an end to that.

6) Mankind is responsible for the present schism between God and us, its a wonder that God answers any prayers.

7) Because evidence can replace faith into non-existence, we need faith.

Because about 2,000 years ago, Jesus said: "I will not return until the 2nd coming".

9) Jesus was referring to his body and blood in the spiritual sense.

10) Because many Christians are only lukewarm christians, fervent Christians whom strive hard to obey God will only get a divorce if the spouse had sex with someone else.</HTML>

Logged

[On how kangaroos could have gotten back to Australia after the flood]: Don't kangaroos skip along the surface of the water? --Kenn

So, you do not believe in an all-poweful deity. I find that very interesting. If you decide to join the forum, I'd like to know exactly which things the deity you worship can and cannot do, in your opinion. What are it's weaknesses? Can it see through everything except lead, for example?

I see your point Ed on that amputee thing. You know...it would be a good idea if the church would post a list of the things God won't heal...like amputees. That way people would not be confused and pray for things that are not going to happen.

I respect your thoughtfulness and have answers to your 10 questions. I am a Christian who tries hard to be one even though I am not perfectand do make mistakes. Here is my attempt to answer your 10 questions, some are correct but some may or may not be. Please bear with me, I tried my imperfect best to answer the questions.

What I bolded: is this you, personally belittling yourself, or your religion?

Quote

1) I wish God would heal amputees but perhaps the reason he does not is because that would be too obvious a miracle. Obvious miracles could replace faith to the point when there would be no faith. Without faith there is no salvation, this is why you must choose Christianity before you die and see God.

The Bible says, "If you ask, you will receive." all you have to do is believe, and have faith. Yet, when it never happens for a single amputee, seems to be a lie, more than anything.

Your last line is preaching. Means nothing.

Quote

2) Food is provided but much of the time, the country's government steals the food for themselves to eat or sell.

What are you talking about when you say "government"? How are they "stealing"? In what way? Sounds like you got this from some film, or something.

Quote

3) This is a tough question but I think that the old testament writers could not fully interpret Gods' inspirational meanings. This is one of the reasons why Jesus came here, to clarify what God The Father meant. This is why you do not read such laws within the new testament.

So, they got it wrong in the OT but got it right in the NT? Then why does Jesus say in Matthew that he didn't come to abolish the "old" law or the prophets but to fulfill them[1]? Doesn't put much credence to your answer.

Quote

4) The Bible is scientifically accurate, for example: biblical lists of clean and unclean creatures have a significance often ignored. These lists emphasize a fact not discovered until late in the last century, that animals carry diseases dangerous to man. In fact, the same animals labeled unclean in Scripture still carry parasitic diseases that are still dangerous to human beings today.

Your opinion is not evidence. Evidence is gathered by different sources, non-biased ones, and then relayed as one's evidence that it's true. You gave an opinion. Does not make it true.

Quote

One of Gods' laws is to circumcise a baby boy when he is exactly 8 days old, doctors now know that a baby's' immune system is very strong on the 8th day.

What's the point in circumcising today?

Quote

Also, Modern scientific studies have shown that the blood-clotting mechanism in a baby is not fully developed until the eighth day, so it was not wise to do a surgical procedure earlier because of the threat of hemorrhage.The Bible revealed that the earth is round. Job 26:10, Prov 8:27, Isaiah 40:22, Amos 9:6.

Job 26:10: "He marks out the horizon on the face of the waters for a boundary between light and darkness." -- I don't read where it says it's round? Maybe I am missing something?

Isaiah 40:22: "He sits enthroned upon the circle of the earth, and its people are like grasshoppers." -- One in your favor. Of course this is the NIV, not KJV, so, someone else would have to see if it was reworded. Of course "circle" isn't necessarily the same as "round".

Proverbs 8:27: "I was there when he set the heavens in place, when he marked out the horizon on the face of the deep," -- I don't read where it says it's round?

Amos 9:6: "he who builds his lofty palace in the heavens and sets it's a foundation on the earth, who calls for the waters of the sea and pours them out over the face of the land--the LORD is his name." -- again, I don't read where it says it's round?

Didn't you dismiss the OT as being irrelevant in a previous answer by stating that the writers couldn't interpret "God's Word" correctly, and why the NT was then produced?

Quote

The people of the fifteenth century feared sailing because they thought they would fall over the edge of the flat earth. Yet the Bible revealed the truth in 1000 B.C. 2500 years before man discovered it for himself!

Many of those people were Christian yet didn't remember that from the Bible? Weird.

Quote

5) During ancient times, "slaves" were actually paid servants whom were treated well. The Egyptians did not treat their slaves ( servants ) well so God put an end to that.

Evidence? (The Bible isn't evidence, by the by.)

Quote

6) Mankind is responsible for the present schism between God and us, its a wonder that God answers any prayers.

Evidence?

Quote

7) Because evidence can replace faith into non-existence, we need faith.

Does this actually make sense to you?

Quote

Because about 2,000 years ago, Jesus said: "I will not return until the 2nd coming".

If you say so. I mean, Jesus actually speaks nowhere in the Bible. It's all hearsay.

Quote

9) Jesus was referring to his body and blood in the spiritual sense.

Evidence?

Quote

10) Because many Christians are only lukewarm christians, fervent Christians whom strive hard to obey God will only get a divorce if the spouse had sex with someone else.

I don't really feel like doing a bit-by-bit respond, so I'll just give a couple of replies that applies to most of the points made.

1) For 1, 2, 3, 6, 7, 8, 9, and 10, how is the situtation any different than when there's no god at all? Things like "he can't" or "he won't" means that you're trying to cover for god's inaction. Things like "god won't heal amputees" or "god won't feed starving children" are the sort of respond that we'd expect to hear if god didn't exist.

2) This means that your god is useless. We cannot expect him to help out with much of anything really. Starving children? Fix that ourself. Amputees? Fix that ourself. Prayer is useless and pointless.

Welcome to the forum Ed. Its good to have new faces, particularly ones to disagree with.

I wont go too into all your points as much has been addressed above, but I will say your "scientific" evidence really irritates me. This seems to be a relatively new claim by theists, that the bible is somehow scientifically advanced for its time of writing (it is not). I guess the biggest issue I have with your claim in general is the claim that a circle and a sphere are somehow equivalent. While I am no geometry genius I am pretty sure circles and spheres are just as different as squares are from cubes... in other words completely freaking different.

Logged

"If we look back into history for the character of the present sects in Christianity, we shall find few that have not in their turns been persecutors, and complainers of persecution."

^Actually,it's not new. I've read articles at "Making of America" at Cornell, and Michigan University, dating back to the 18th Century where Christians attempted to use science tovalidate the Bible. They were few and far between but you can find them there, if you look. (Don't forget to put "Making of America" in google first)

-Nam

Logged

Things I've said here:

Quote

I only have a filter for people who do not consistently beg to be belittled, ridiculed, insulted, and demeaned.

Quote

I may believe people, as a whole, should be treated fairly but I also believe those same people are idiots.

During ancient times, "slaves" were actually paid servants whom were treated well. The Egyptians did not treat their slaves ( servants ) well so God put an end to that.

Think what you are saying, man! THIS is what god would put an end to a few thousand years ago? Sit down right now and make a list for yourself of all the things, since, lets say the Irish potato famine, or slavery in the US, up to the treatment of Jews by Hitler, onto the treatment of the refugees in the Sudan, anything in general over history where humans slaughtered humans, and, just the fact that GOD WONT HEAL AMPUTEES! Why wouldn't he put an end to just a few of those things?

He does not exist, Ed! But we do exist! And it is time we move onto what we can do to help ourselves and stop making up our own beliefs to justify all the deities that people refuse to let go!

During ancient times, "slaves" were actually paid servants whom were treated well. The Egyptians did not treat their slaves ( servants ) well so God put an end to that.

Think what you are saying, man! THIS is what god would put an end to a few thousand years ago? Sit down right now and make a list for yourself of all the things, since, lets say the Irish potato famine, or slavery in the US, up to the treatment of Jews by Hitler, onto the treatment of the refugees in the Sudan, anything in general over history where humans slaughtered humans, and, just the fact that GOD WONT HEAL AMPUTEES! Why wouldn't he put an end to just a few of those things?

He does not exist, Ed! But we do exist! And it is time we move onto what we can do to help ourselves and stop making up our own beliefs to justify all the deities that people refuse to let go!

The answer is hidden in many of these responses, which is, If you look at society today, you will see that much of mankind has done the equivalent of saying "F U" to God.

So, you do not believe in an all-poweful deity. I find that very interesting. If you decide to join the forum, I'd like to know exactly which things the deity you worship can and cannot do, in your opinion. What are it's weaknesses? Can it see through everything except lead, for example?

Ed, thanks for joining up. I was hoping I could get an answer to this.

1) I wish God would heal amputees but perhaps the reason he does not is because that would be too obvious a miracle.

What is an “Obvious miracle? One like the loaves and fishes? Why did Jesus do that?

Quote

2) Food is provided but much of the time, the country's government steals the food for themselves to eat or sell.

This is not so.

Quote

This is a tough question but I think that the old testament writers could not fully interpret Gods' inspirational meanings. This is one of the reasons why Jesus came here, to clarify what God The Father meant. This is why you do not read such laws within the new testament.

So, the Old Testament is inaccurate. OK, why did Jesus curse the fig tree that did not bear fruit out of season, and what does this explain?

Quote

4) The Bible is scientifically accurate, for example: biblical lists of clean and unclean creatures have a significance often ignored. These lists emphasize a fact not discovered until late in the last century, that animals carry diseases dangerous to man

This is not correct. And what about cows and sheep that both can carry diseases injurious to mankind?

This is simply wrong. Slaves were not paid, slaves had no freedom, slaves were just the same as Afro-American slaves – just the same. There is a bible verse that says that you can only be charged with murder if you hit a slave and the slave dies within 3 days.

Quote

6) Mankind is responsible for the present schism between God and us, its a wonder that God answers any prayers.

No. God created us, He knew what we were like, and now he blames us!!!

Quote

7) Because evidence can replace faith into non-existence, we need faith.

What’s the difference between ‘faith’ and ‘being gullible’?

Quote

Because about 2,000 years ago, Jesus said: "I will not return until the 2nd coming".

That was supposed to be within the lifetime of those to whom He spoke.

« Last Edit: October 14, 2012, 05:59:50 AM by Graybeard »

Logged

Nobody says “There are many things that we thought were natural processes, but now know that a god did them.”

At this point, your god is going to have to reach out to me because I haven't the slightest inclination to reach towards him. If he exists, he's got a lot of convincing to do. If he exists, he didn't give me the wherewithal to fall for his story. If he exists, he's not very good at it.

If he doesn't exist, that explains everything. Including the artificially low intellect of the true believer, for whom facts are mostly an inconvenience.

Logged

It isn't true that non-existent gods can't do anything. For instance, they were able to make me into an atheist.

Ed, thanks for joining up. I was hoping I could get an answer to this.

I believe in God because consciousness can not come from things such as matter, energy comes from matter so energy probably is not the source either. There is too much precision in life and the universe for it all to be a random creation.

Ed, thanks for joining up. I was hoping I could get an answer to this.

Quote

I believe in God because consciousness can not come from things such as matter, energy comes from matter so energy probably is not the source either. There is too much precision in life and the universe for it all to be a random creation.

Thanks, Ed, but you did not answer my question. Your email answers clearly indicate your belief is in a deity that is not all powerful, and I was wondering which powers you think it lacks.

I was not interested in why you think you believe in a deity. That's a process that's pretty well understood.

During ancient times, "slaves" were actually paid servants whom were treated well. The Egyptians did not treat their slaves ( servants ) well so God put an end to that.

Think what you are saying, man! THIS is what god would put an end to a few thousand years ago? Sit down right now and make a list for yourself of all the things, since, lets say the Irish potato famine, or slavery in the US, up to the treatment of Jews by Hitler, onto the treatment of the refugees in the Sudan, anything in general over history where humans slaughtered humans, and, just the fact that GOD WONT HEAL AMPUTEES! Why wouldn't he put an end to just a few of those things?

He does not exist, Ed! But we do exist! And it is time we move onto what we can do to help ourselves and stop making up our own beliefs to justify all the deities that people refuse to let go!

The answer is hidden in many of these responses, which is, If you look at society today, you will see that much of mankind has done the equivalent of saying "F U" to God. For example: stealing, lying, murdering, raping, adultery, torture, child pornography, bullying, corruption, shall I go on?

I believe in God because consciousness can not come from things such as matter, energy comes from matter so energy probably is not the source either. There is too much precision in life and the universe for it all to be a random creation.

Too much precision? The universe is a horrible place to live. There is no precision in it at all. Eventually we are going to be destroyed by the Andromeda galaxy,[1], that is if the Sun doesn't consume us first, or if we don't get ambushed by astroids, like Apophis[2]. Not to mention on earth we have massive earth quakes, blizzards, tornadoes, hurricanes, etc. Not much precision.

OK, but assuming you are correct, what makes you believe in your god, YHWH? Why not just be a deist? What makes you believe in the god of the bible?

EDIT: Sorry Pony, I missed your post asking the same question in more detail than I asked.

I believe in God because consciousness can not come from things such as matter, energy comes from matter so energy probably is not the source either. There is too much precision in life and the universe for it all to be a random creation.

You said I did not fully answer your question so here is part 2 of my above reason.If consciousness cannot come from matter or energy then it must come from something else, what? I believe that only a greater consciousness (God) can create other conciousness.

..You said I did not fully answer your question so here is part 2 of my above reason.If consciousness cannot come from matter or energy then it must come from something else, what? I believe that only a greater consciousness (God) can create other conciousness.

Do you believe your consciousness and soul reside in your kidneys like Jesus, or do you think it resides in some other body part?

Why is your "consciousness affected by simple chemicals? It's obvious if our thinking is simply the electro-chemical workings of the brain, but if it is god and not our physical brains, then why does LSD change the way you think for a few hours?