So what is everyone's favourite Agalloch album? I would have to saw mine is the cliche choice, The Mantle, as it is an incredibly solid album that molds several genres in a highly successful manner. It is produced more then some other albums in the genre, but the emotions still ring strongly within and the instrumentation is beautiful. In terms of songs, it boasts some of my favourites, especially "In the Shadow of Our Pale Companion", "A Desolation Song", and "The Great Cold Death of the Earth", with "A Desolation Song" being at the moment possibly my overall favourite song.

The other albums are of course great as well. The White is pleasant, serene, calming, Ashes Against the Grain is incredibly solid and utilizes a strong post rock influence, Pale Folklore is raw and yet offers some nice differences, such as the female opera vocals, and Marrow of the Spirit has "To Drown", with it's string based death march towards it's conclusion. Overall, they are an awesome band.

My favourite one is Ashes Against the Grain because to me, it's only a one huge amazing track album. Even if some tracks are better than the others "Falling Snow" ; "Not unlike the waves" (my favourite one) ; "Limbs"... I agree with you for the post rock influence on this record and it's maybe this influence which make of this record my favourite one!

My favourite one is Ashes Against the Grain because to me, it's only a one huge amazing track album. Even if some tracks are better than the others "Falling Snow" ; "Not unlike the waves" (my favourite one) ; "Limbs"... I agree with you for the post rock influence on this record and it's maybe this influence which make of this record my favourite one!

That riff in "Not Unlike The Waves" is incredible, and it has some of the best clean vocal parts that they have ever done.

It's just the most nostalgic one, music-wise it's one of those few albums that really succeeded in combining different genres yet stays under the flag of atmospheric black metal! "The Misshapen Steed" introduced me to a whole world of neoclassic/dark ambient music! Tracks like "She Painted", "As Embers", "Hallways"... are catchy, deep and mesmerizing!

The first demo is awesome (thanks to This Old Cabin), The Mantle is a very solid album, way better than Ashes which is my least favorite (except for tracks like Falling Snow and Not Unlike The Waves), and what can I say about Marrow other than it's awesome, YET the only problem with it is that it needs a special mood (except the most accessible one which is of course, Ghosts Of The Midwinter Fires)

The Mantle is my favorite, but I truly love everything I've heard from them. The Mantle is just special to me. It created such an atmosphere and stirred up emotions like few things have ever been able to do. Also, a lot of the lyrics and feelings match the way I feel. It's almost like it's a musical expression of my thoughts.