Posted
by
Soulskillon Sunday May 16, 2010 @09:12AM
from the less-than-handy dept.

hazmat2k writes "Palm's App Catalog appears to have suffered a meltdown of sorts, with users of Palm Pre, Pixi, Pre Plus, and Pixi Plus handsets reporting that after having downloaded a new title — whether paid or free — no aftermarket software would run properly. The issue remained even after fully erasing and restarting the phone; in fact, the apps were still installed even after that process was completed. Core functionality — calls, messaging, and data — were all unaffected. Palm acknowledged the issue on its blog, and later said that it had been fixed."

At least important services were unaffected. My iPhone drops my calls, sometimes won't handle data and when it hangs, no call gets in. If you're buying a phone it's nice that at least the important stuff still works, and that while I'm playing on my device I won't miss critical calls or messages.

But the App Catalog is 100% Palm. AT&T is generally a pretty crappy network even while I was on a "dumb" phone I had dropped calls and missed messages. A lot of the failings of the iPhone (minus of course all the missed features that Jobs said no one wanted and therefore would be terrible to have in a phone like multi-tasking and the like....) can be blamed on AT&T. However, Palm's App Catalog is 100% run by palm, any failing there is purely Palm's fault, the iPhone faults you mentioned could be cau

I don't have problems with dropped calls on my iPhone 3G. Why? Before I purchased it, I made sure that AT&T coverage was excellent in the areas where I use it (and it is). If it wasn't, I'd have an Android phone now. Moral - Don't buy any phone if the coverage where you are mainly going to use it sucks.

You're assuming that I switched to ATT, because of the iPhone. I've service with them for more than 6 years in the same location and multiple devices ( sony, nokia, htc) and never had problems with dropped calls. Even at some places I knew the reception was poor while I was driving the cellphones manages to keep the calls connected. The iPhone tends to give up quite easy and drop the calls at the first opportunity it gets.

There's definitely something to the phone's firmware. The Pre had this issue for a while, that a weakened signal would drop quickly, whereas my previous phone would just go quiet for a second or two. I referred to the Pre's dropped calls as "missing a photon," something my friends picked up when the call unexpectedly ended, as that's about all it seemed to take to drop a call. Since the 1.4 update, it's gotten much better, and even in spotty areas, it at least tries to stay connected for a few seconds be

I could sit my wife's iPhone and my Nokia N97 3 ft apart on our home office desk, and she'd have 1 bar, and I'd have 7 (7 is the new 5, I guess). I'd call both phones from my desk VoIP phone, mine would ring, hers would go to voicemail. Sometimes nothing short of a phone reboot would change that.

My main issue with the iPhone was not dropped calls, it was calls coming in but the front screen not responding to the swipe to answer - it would take a good 5 or 6 swipes until it would answer it. The screen is clean and dirt free, and is responsive at other times in the same area so I do not think its a damaged or dirty screen that is causing the lack of response to input.

At least important services were unaffected. My iPhone drops my calls, sometimes won't handle data and when it hangs, no call gets in. If you're buying a phone it's nice that at least the important stuff still works, and that while I'm playing on my device I won't miss critical calls or messages.

Why is it that tourists like me never ever have problem with their iPhone when they visit the US? I never had any problems with my iPhone when I was down in the states. Is it possible that they apply QOS and give worse service to existing local customers who bitch and moan at the CSRs who cannot fix the problems anyway?

Or here is a thought, check out the service levels of carriers in your area before choosing one. If AT&T is so bad in your area, why didn't you just buy an iPod Touch and go with a simp

They always take their store down when they launch a new product or drastic changes. I was hoping Palm was doing the same.
A minor inconvenience is all it was at best. Oh noes, I can't buy an app for 2-3 hours!!! zOMG call in the military!

It was 'down' for more like 16 hours, depending where you live. Just rolling back the date made everything work fine. It had the appearance of simply being something like an expired certificate. No biggie, but inconvenient if you happened to want a new app this weekend.

This demonstrates how 'fragile' these devices really are (from a software/OS perspective). It's not like a tower that we can pop open, tinker futz and fuss until they're fixed. This also makes it clear that it won't take much to disable the software on a device - and possibly the networking & phone features - if some virus or malformed code makes its way to the device.

I don't believe this is a very accurate description of the problem. Here is the issue in a nutshell: You couldn't install or update apps from the App Catalog. Period. Everything else in the phone was unaffected. The beauty of the webOS ecosystem is that homebrew (encouraged by Palm!) was completely unaffected. You could still go open, tinker, futz and fuss with the phone all you wanted to through things like Preware or webOS Quick Install. Even if HP decided to shutter Palm tomorrow (which isn't goin

It is long overdue that, when you pay a handsome sum for a product that includes a proprietary O/S and the company produces massive crap like this, they should be a) held accountable b) provide full recompense for the incredible amount of lost time that issues like this cause.

I have long advocated that, if you must have patent legislation, there should be a consumer side to it. You can't have it two ways. You can't make money by being proprietary while at the same time not being accountable for your error

You couldn't install any new apps for between 8-16 hours depending on where you live. Besides that minor inconvenience, all previously installed apps worked fine, and the phone worked fine. Incredible amount of lost time? Really?

If you ask me, Palm's WebOS has already screwed the pooch! My palm pre apps do not rotate unless I"m running a browser. if I want to read email sideways, I'm out of luck. If i want to look at any application sideways, none of them rotate. Why would palm come up with a late date new OS and not make that just part of the operating system environment so that all applications rotate? Seems shortsighted..