In this fun preview clip, shared by the show on Thursday, Jenner and Baldwin are rocking out in a parking lot to Cyrus’ 2009 hit “Party in the U.S.A.” when the singer herself suddenly appears outside the back window of their SUV, bopping her head to the beat of the song.

In a moment that hilariously and bizarrely seemed to mimic several horror movie tropes, Cyrus pops up next to Baldwin’s window, but disappears just before Jenner looks over, then does the same thing in Jenner’s window, and yet neither of them appear concerned about the pop icon haunting their car like an energetic version of the wet ghost girl from The Ring.

Then, in a moment that would usually be played for screams rather than laughs, Cyrus is inexplicably in the car with them, singing along to her own tune from the back seat as they all rock out together.

The brief teaser doesn’t reveal all the fun (and apparently surreal) moments from Baldwin and Jenner’s Carpool Karaoke adventure, but it’s enough to get us interesting in the madness to come.