Chat with us in Facebook Messenger. Find out what's happening in the world as it unfolds.

Photos:San Bernardino shooting

Police officers stand guard as they investigate a suspicious vehicle in Redlands, California, on Wednesday, December 2, after a mass shooting in nearby San Bernardino in which 14 people died and 21 were injured. The shooting took place at the Inland Regional Center, where employees with the county health department were attending a holiday event. The two shooters -- Syed Rizwan Farook and his wife, Tashfeen Malik -- were fatally shot in a gun battle with police hours after the initial incident. Farook worked for the county health department.

Hide Caption

1 of 29

Photos:San Bernardino shooting

A police officer places a marker along East San Bernardino Avenue, near where the shootout occurred.

Hide Caption

2 of 29

Photos:San Bernardino shooting

Law enforcement officers search a residential area for suspects who fled after the shooting.

Hide Caption

3 of 29

Photos:San Bernardino shooting

Police search for the suspects in San Bernardino.

Hide Caption

4 of 29

Photos:San Bernardino shooting

The residential area was not far from where the shooting occurred.

Hide Caption

5 of 29

Photos:San Bernardino shooting

Law enforcement officers search a neighborhood in San Bernardino.

Hide Caption

6 of 29

Photos:San Bernardino shooting

A police officer loads his weapon while pursuing suspects.

Hide Caption

7 of 29

Photos:San Bernardino shooting

A SWAT team mobilizes during the search.

Hide Caption

8 of 29

Photos:San Bernardino shooting

People pray on the San Bernardino Golf Course, across the street from where the shooting took place.

Hide Caption

9 of 29

Photos:San Bernardino shooting

Heavily armed law enforcement officers swarmed the area where the shooting occurred.

Hide Caption

10 of 29

Photos:San Bernardino shooting

People leave a community center after reuniting with friends and family in the aftermath of the shootings.

Hide Caption

11 of 29

Photos:San Bernardino shooting

A woman is comforted near the scene of the shooting.

Hide Caption

12 of 29

Photos:San Bernardino shooting

A police helicopter hovers around the Inland Regional Center.

Hide Caption

13 of 29

Photos:San Bernardino shooting

Luis Gutierrez gets emotional as he talks about his wife who works in the facility and saw a gunman, according to Los Angeles Times photographer Marcus Yam.

Hide Caption

14 of 29

Photos:San Bernardino shooting

Two women speak with a firefighter at a triage area near the scene.

Hide Caption

15 of 29

Photos:San Bernardino shooting

Police stand guard outside of the emergency room at the Loma Linda University Medical Center, where some of the victims were being treated.

Hide Caption

16 of 29

Photos:San Bernardino shooting

Police escort civilians away from the site of the shooting.

Hide Caption

17 of 29

Photos:San Bernardino shooting

People walk away from the scene. It is unclear how many people were at the facility at the time of the shooting.

Hide Caption

18 of 29

Photos:San Bernardino shooting

Police in SWAT gear secure the area.

Hide Caption

19 of 29

Photos:San Bernardino shooting

Two women embrace at a community center where family members were gathering to pick up people from the scene.

Hide Caption

20 of 29

Photos:San Bernardino shooting

People gather at the San Bernardino Golf Course.

Hide Caption

21 of 29

Photos:San Bernardino shooting

People talk to police at the golf course.

Hide Caption

22 of 29

Photos:San Bernardino shooting

A woman is wheeled away on a stretcher.

Hide Caption

23 of 29

Photos:San Bernardino shooting

People are moved away from the area by bus.

Hide Caption

24 of 29

Photos:San Bernardino shooting

Police and fire personnel are seen near the site of the shooting.

Hide Caption

25 of 29

Photos:San Bernardino shooting

A crowd gathers behind the police line.

Hide Caption

26 of 29

Photos:San Bernardino shooting

Ambulances pull out of a staging area near the Inland Regional Center.

Hide Caption

27 of 29

Photos:San Bernardino shooting

A SWAT vehicle carries police officers.

Hide Caption

28 of 29

Photos:San Bernardino shooting

SWAT teams and a bomb squad were working to clear the buildings where the shootings took place.

Hide Caption

29 of 29

Story highlights

John Inazu: The "thoughts and prayers" debate after San Bernardino exposes the real dividing line in American society

Each side can reach across that "transcendence line" and make a difference, he says

John Inazu is associate professor of law at Washington University in St. Louis and the author of "Confident Pluralism: Surviving and Thriving Through Deep Difference" (University of Chicago Press, forthcoming 2016). The opinions expressed in this commentary are his.

(CNN)The war of words over "thoughts and prayers" in response to the San Bernardino massacre is the latest illustration that our culture is fractured not only politically, but also along the transcendence line: The line divides those who believe in a God who intervenes in the world and those who do not.

We see the transcendence line in sharp relief when some people are moved to pray in response to tragedy and others insist that prayer doesn't "work" and isn't "doing" anything. We see it in the puzzled and impatient reactions to the acts of forgiveness extended by the family members of those killed in a church in Charleston, South Carolina. We see it in critiques of Christian missionaries who care for the sick and dying in Ebola-stricken lands.

John D. Inazu

We see the transcendence line play out in other ways. How could those religious believers be so hateful and bigoted in their beliefs? How could those nonbelievers be so selfish and immoral? Our generalities and caricatures fuel our predispositions, and those on the other side of the line increasingly appear to us as less compassionate, less worthy and less human.

America is deeply divided along the transcendence line. Tens of millions of Americans profess belief in a transcendent God. They include Christians, Jews, Muslims and people of many other faiths. Yet these generic labels are also imprecise; many self-identifying Christians and Jews reject the idea that God intervenes in the world in miraculous and supernatural ways.

They may participate in religious practices. They may even pray. But they do not believe that prayer "works." They do not have a category of "forgiveness" that appeals to transcendent justice and mercy.

Read More

They do not anticipate a transcendent world to come. Each of them lives out a kind of faith, but the content and contours of that faith is focused on the present physical world and the people in it.

The transcendence line is not the difference between "belief" and "unbelief." Each of us lives according to strongly held commitments and values-infused beliefs. The liberal atheist who stands up for "equality" and "dignity" relies on foundational and tradition-dependent assumptions in much the same way as the religious conservative who defends "morality" and "truth."

The transcendence line is not a line between good and evil. Some people professing transcendence lay down their lives for their neighbors; others kill their neighbors. Some people who profess nontranscendence are generous and self-giving; others live only for themselves.

The transcendence line matters because it affects how many people orient the most fundamental aspects of their lives. And there is a great deal at stake in our differences over transcendence.

Consider the words of the Apostle Paul: "If only for this life we have hope in Christ, we are of all people most to be pitied." If transcendent hope is misplaced, Paul says, then pity his delusions. Pity his prayers and his acts of forgiveness and his longing for a world transformed by transcendence.

Those who share Paul's transcendent hope might recognize that people of faith have often flourished when others around them reject their beliefs. Rather than bristling at those who mock them, they might see a moment of opportunity for a clearer expression of faith, hope and love. And they might remember that transcendent hope often fuses acts of faith with worldly labors. The Rev. Martin Luther King Jr., Mahatma Gandhi and Mother Teresa prayed and forgave, but they also labored.

In the other direction, those who reject transcendence can choose to extend charity in their bewilderment rather than trivialize acts of prayer and forgiveness. They might resist the urge to assume that those praying and forgiving are not also pursuing other forms of action. And they might hold open the possibility that Paul ought not be pitied after all.

Photos:What's the answer to gun violence?

Photos:What's the answer to gun violence?

Hide Caption

1 of 11

Photos:What's the answer to gun violence?

Hide Caption

2 of 11

Photos:What's the answer to gun violence?

Hide Caption

3 of 11

Photos:What's the answer to gun violence?

Hide Caption

4 of 11

Photos:What's the answer to gun violence?

Hide Caption

5 of 11

Photos:What's the answer to gun violence?

Hide Caption

6 of 11

Photos:What's the answer to gun violence?

Hide Caption

7 of 11

Photos:What's the answer to gun violence?

Hide Caption

8 of 11

Photos:What's the answer to gun violence?

Hide Caption

9 of 11

Photos:What's the answer to gun violence?

Hide Caption

10 of 11

Photos:What's the answer to gun violence?

Hide Caption

11 of 11

Our deep differences are not going away anytime soon. Our own friends, neighbors and colleagues will increasingly fall on both sides of the transcendence line. In light of this reality and other deep differences between us, I have elsewhere argued that we might move toward a "confident pluralism," where we might try to extend tolerance, humility and patience toward those with whom we fundamentally disagree.

That's going to take work. It will require slowing down our social media impulses, drafting and redrafting our written words, and pausing before our spoken words. None of this will be easy. But the coming years will give us plenty of opportunities -- the transcendence line is here to stay.