In Wake Of Boats, A Scarred Seafloor

Concerned that powerboats are tearing up seagrass in Florida Bay, Everglades National Park has proposed a range of possible restrictions on boaters to protect a vast, shallow estuary that supports sea turtles, fish and clouds of wading birds.

The proposals have generated deep concern among South Florida's huge recreational fishing community, where many people worry the most drastic of the alternatives could shut them out of most of the bay and hurt the tourist industry. But park officials say boats have carved at least 325 miles of scars in the bay, with damage accelerating in an era of bigger boats, more powerful engines and tough, stainless-steel propellers that allow boaters to penetrate shallow, difficult-to-navigate areas.

"People have just lost a lot of fear," said David King, the park's Florida Bay District ranger. "They just feel they can power over whatever they come across. Florida Bay has the potential to be one of the phenomenal natural areas of the world. It's not that today. It's been beat up."

In the forest-green carpet of seagrass along the bay bottom, light-green streaks indicate areas where propellers have stripped bare the vegetation that provides most of the bay's energy. Seagrass provides food for fish, manatees and sea turtles and serves as a nursery and hunting grounds for marine creatures.

All the park's proposals include mandatory permits and boater education, but they vary in how much they would restrict powerboats, with the most severe creating huge zones in which they could use only push-poles or low-speed electric motors. The park expects to announce a preferred alternative this fall and implement the plan in 2011.

More than 200 people, mostly boaters and guides, attended a park meeting at the International Game Fish Association in Dania Beach. Some opposed any new restrictions; others agreed there's a problem but urged the park to choose the most surgical alternative that would maintain access to most of the bay. And several speakers said the whole idea of restricted areas, designated trails and no-motor zones would impose an unpleasant bureaucratic grid over a vast wild area.

"It's too much regulation," said Jupiter resident Tracy Bennett, a member of the venerable West Palm Beach Fishing Club. "When you get too regimented - you have to stick to this trail, you can't go here - it just takes the fun out of it."

Bennett, a retired civil engineer who has fished in the park for 35 years, likes to explore remote areas, such as Hell's Bay and Whitewater Bays. He uses aerial photographs to navigate the mangroves, a "real wilderness experience." In an interview, he said he supports the park's Alternative 2, which relies on boater education and would create two small pole-and-troll zones.

Tougher alternatives, he said, would "take out huge areas that boaters have used for a hundred years. The boaters I've talked to don't trust the process. They think the park is taking an extreme position to accommodate the paddlers."

Ted Perron of Coral Springs, organizer of the Palm Beach Water Yaks kayaking club, supports the strictest limits on boats but said he doesn't want them gone from the park.

"It's not to exclude the boaters," he said. "It's to protect the Everglades."

Despite its vast expanse, Florida Bay is extremely shallow, with an average depth of 3 feet. It is not unusual to see a heron or egret standing in water hundreds of yards from land. It can be treacherous for boaters.

Capt. Tad Burke, head of the Florida Keys Fishing Guides Association, said the guides have drawn up an alternative that would emphasize a thorough and mandatory education program before boaters could enter Florida Bay, which he called "one of the most difficult bodies of water to navigate." They strongly oppose the creation of huge pole-and-troll zones, which he said would effectively close off much of the bay.

"We want to protect the environment," he said. "But we also want to protect the economic value of Everglades National Park. How can you close off massive areas of the park?"

But he gave the park's leadership credit for taking the boaters' concerns seriously. "They get it," he said. "They've actually been listening."

Environmental groups generally support the tougher restrictions, arguing that the park's first duty is to protect natural resources.

"No one likes more regulations, but the boating traffic has gone up 2 1/2 times in the last 30 years," said Brian Scherf, of the Florida Biodiversity Project.

"These seagrass areas are so important for juvenile fish habitat, food supply, hunting grounds for other fish. If you don't have healthy seagrass, you won't have great fishing."

David Fleshler can be reached at dfleshler @SunSentinel.com or 954-356-4535.

325 miles

Amount of seagrass scarring in Florida Bay.

Watch more

See a report on the proposed restrictions and more photos at SunSentinel.com/seagrass

INFORMATIONAL BOX:

Have your say

To comment or obtain more information on the plan, go to www.nps.gov/ever and click on "General Management Plan." Comments may also be sent to the National Park Service, Denver Service Center, Everglades Planning Team, P.O. Box 25287, Denver, CO 80225-0287. The deadline for comments is Friday. The park expects to announce a preferred alternative this fall and implement a plan in the summer of 2011.