State tells State Farm to pay up for charges

Last Updated on July 31st, 2017

State Farm Insurance was slapped on Monday with a far-reaching state order that calls on the state’s largest insurer to refund $310 million to its Texas home insurance customers for overcharges dating back to 2003.

Texas Insurance Commissioner Mike Geeslin said that State Farm, which provides coverage to 1.2 million Texans, must pay up after fighting state regulators for several years to avoid the refunds that Geeslin and consumer advocates say are owed.

State Farm officials,Â who have said the company owes nothing, were not immediately available for comment. The company has 10 days to file an appeal, which could delay any refunds until the courts rule.

The refund amounts to 6.2 percent of policyholder premiums for customers insured by State Farm. Lloydsâ€” the company’s home insurance arm – from September 2003 to August 2004. For customers insured from September 2004 to July 2008, the refund amounts to about 3.4 percent of premium for each year they were insured.

“The commissioner found State Farm Lloyds rates were excessive and is ordering State Farm Lloyds to pay refunds,” Geeslin said in a summary of his order released late Monday.

The amount that State Farm was ordered to pay was less than what the state’s public insurance counsel was seeking â€” about $1 billion â€” as Geeslin followed the recommendations of his staff for a lesser amount.

“There is evidence, there is law â€” and between the two, you come up with $310 million,” he said.

Alex Winslow, head of consumer group Texas Watch, called the order an insult to policyholders.

“This is a joke. There is no doubt this refund is a pennies on the dollar settlement,” he said, adding that he wouldn’t be surprised to see the case drag on another six years if State Farm appeals.

The decision is being closely watched in part because insurance could become a pivotal issue in next year governor’s race: U.S. Sen. Kay Bailey Hutchison has indicated she will make insurance rates a major part of her campaign to unseat Gov. Rick Perry.

The rate dispute, dating back to 2003, began when the insurance department ordered State Farm Lloyds and several other insurers to reduce their premiums because they were deemed excessive.

The order stemmed from an insurance reform law passed by the Texas Legislature that year that put home insurance rates under state control after a period of record premium increases.

State Farm, which was told to cut its rates by 12 percent, responded by suing the state.

In the most recent ruling, Geesling was told to convene a hearing on the overcharge allegations and listen to evidence from State Farm, the insurance department and the state’s consumer advocate.

State Farm attorneys had said during hearings this year that a refund totaling hundreds of millions of dollars could be “crippling” for the company.

The attorneys also noted that the insurer is still paying off a $1 billion loan made by its parent company six years ago to stave off bankruptcy.

I endorse this lawyer. Andrew and I have worked together on a couple of clients and I am very impressed with his quality and depth of knowledge. Andrew understands the nuances of different insurance carriers and the way that courts will react to various situations. He is quite experienced and I recommend him highly for any personal injury matters.

Natalie Lynch

3/18/2015

I endorse Andrew Traub because he is a hard-working, diligent, knowledgeable, ethical and creative lawyer. In injury cases, he is definitely someone you would want to have on your side. From a client perspective, he is down-to-earth and easy to talk to, and from the lawyer's perspective, he is tenacious and a strong advocate for his clients.

Jeffrey Barnett

6/21/2013

Andrew is very professional and succeeding in getting a very satisfactory settlement in my very difficult case. He was diligent and maintained a high level of communication throughout the process. I would highly recommend him to anyone who is seeking assistance with a claim that is being denied by the insurance company.

anonymous

5/23/2013

Last year I was driving on interstate 35 up in Oklahoma and was hit by a pickup on the side of the road. I was referred to the Traub Law Firm and they did a great job on this accident case. It was not easy because the accident was out of state and we had to get numerous records from hospitals and other outlets. The law firm did a great job to go the extra mile for me. I would highly recommend The Traub Law Firm for any accident claim you might have. Greg Slater

Greg Slater

8/20/2019

More than just a personal injury lawyer, genuinely cares for his clients!

ERA Product

6/27/2018

If you have been injured in a car accident, get an attorney! I personally recommend Andrew Traub of the Traub Law Office. Here's why; Andrew ended up getting me 7x times the policy payout! A few years ago, I was injured in a car accident, but was unaware just how bad I was injured until about 7 days later. The other drivers insurance gave me an estimate $3,000 lower than my cars worth for starters (I know this because I ended up filing through my personal insurance company). Second, the other drivers insurance canceled my rental insurance the DAY my...read moreIf you have been injured in a car accident, get an attorney! I personally recommend Andrew Traub of the Traub Law Office. Here's why; Andrew ended up getting me 7x times the policy payout! A few years ago, I was injured in a car accident, but was unaware just how bad I was injured until about 7 days later. The other drivers insurance gave me an estimate $3,000 lower than my cars worth for starters (I know this because I ended up filing through my personal insurance company). Second, the other drivers insurance canceled my rental insurance the DAY my car was officially totaled. I was not happy about my dealings with this insurance company and it was apparent these people did not give two you know whats about me, and were trying to save a buck. Fast forward about a month later, I was still injured and not getting better, meanwhile not able to participate in my regular activities like I once did. After speaking with a chiropractor friend, he recommend I hire Andrew Traub for representation, as it appeared a long recovery was ahead. Long story short, I had some sort of spinal hyperextension and hyperflexion "whiplash". This injury is way more than a pain in the neck! I had no idea just how much getting rear ended could affect so many things on my body for so long. Andrew was great, guiding me through the process and handling the details, so that I could recover. After about 2 years of physical therapy and lots of CBD oil (this supplement is great for this injury) Andrew started the process of getting me a settlement. Again, I can not stress enough, don't try and deal with these insurance companies on your own, hire Andrew Traub.read less

Patrick Stanger

3/02/2018

I endorse this lawyer. Andrews is smart, dedicated and thorough with his cases.

Brent Devere

5/14/2013

I was involved in a multiple vehicle crash with complicated injuries, and despite my best efforts could not deal with the insurance companies alone. From the start, Andrew was reassuring, insightful, and determined. Â He gently guided me through the litigation process, and sought out new resources to further my recovery. My case took time to build, and while sometimes I felt unsure Andrew never wavered. Â In the end, the Traub Law Office secured an amazing settlement for me! Â I am so grateful to Andrew, Talia, and Lynne for their kindness and dedication. Now I can move on with my life,...read moreI was involved in a multiple vehicle crash with complicated injuries, and despite my best efforts could not deal with the insurance companies alone. From the start, Andrew was reassuring, insightful, and determined. Â He gently guided me through the litigation process, and sought out new resources to further my recovery. My case took time to build, and while sometimes I felt unsure Andrew never wavered. Â In the end, the Traub Law Office secured an amazing settlement for me! Â I am so grateful to Andrew, Talia, and Lynne for their kindness and dedication. Now I can move on with my life, and heartily refer anyone who needs a true and accomplished lawyer to Andrew Traub!read less

Angela H.

4/27/2015

Andrew Traub and his team were both extremely professional in all their interactions with me and remarkably focused on the best possible outcome for my accident lawsuit. They asked all the right questions and then pursued all the medical paperwork on my behalf, and then negotiated very effectively with the guilty party's insurance agency, obtaining what I know was an excellent settlement on my behalf. I recommend them with no reservations whatsoever. They are terrific.

Andrew Dell'Antonio

8/31/2018

I will be the first to admit that I have not had good relations with lawyers. Very hesitant to hire anyone. Andrew sat and answered ALL my questions and when I c/b he patiently answered them also. He treated me with respect and honesty. Very good man. I still not crazy about lawyers but he will be the one to change my mind. Contact him for legal advise. Best one out there.

Kendra Snead

9/25/2016

Excellent results! You speak with an actual attorney and your phone calls are returned in a timely manner. You will be updated regularly on your case. The staff is very friendly and professional, making the office a very relaxed and comfortable environment when entering, greeted, and meeting with a lawyer.

a google user

9/01/2010

Awesome attorney!!! Andrew has been my attorney since he shortly after he graduated from law school over 20 years ago. I wouldn't use anyone else!

Toby Grace

4/22/2015

I would highly recommend Andrew Traub and his Law Office for a personal injury case. My wife was in a bad accident with a non insured motorist and was suffering with severe pain and trauma. We thought we had no legal recourse Her chiropractic doctor recommended Andy. He was thoughtful, thorough and skillful in handling our case. We were impressed in how he handled negotiations and mediated a settlement. Consider Andy for your legal needs.

Cas Poplawski

1/29/2018

I highly recommend Andrew Traub as the best accident injury lawyer. He is trustworthy, honest. He worked very hard on my case. He made sure a fair distribution was made in the insurance settlement. He kept a professional demeanor, especially since the other party was very difficult to negotiate. Highly recommend Andrew Traub.

Anna Bustamante

8/31/2018

I highly recommend Andrew as the best accident injury lawyer. He is trustworthy, honest. He worked very hard on my case. He made sure a fair distribution was made in the insurance settlement. He kept a professional demeanor, especially since the other party was very difficult to negotiate. Highly recommend Andrew.

Contact

While most of our clients hail from Austin, Round Rock, Cedar Park, Georgetown, and Pflugerville in Travis and Williamson Counties,
we have also worked with clients in Dallas, Houston, and San Antonio. Other clients have come from Lakeway, Jollyville, Anderson Mill, Kyle, and Leander. If your accident was in Texas, we can help you.

The information on this website is for general information purposes only. Nothing on this site
should be taken as legal advice for any individual case or situation. This information is not
intended to create, and receipt or viewing does not constitute, an attorney-client relationship.