Comment by Dusktide

However, since the quest item is zone-specific, it will disappear when you leave the isle.

Comment by firemouth420

There is an under water cave, entrance at 70,77, near where Stinkbraids ship is. There's a bunch in this cave, arranged in the shape of a heart. Also, there are 4 chairs in the center and a blue (Grim) campfire. This is where I got mine.

Comment by derby31

If you find the heart shaped arrangement of these in an underwater cave on the Timeless Isle (entrance below Stinkbraid's unfortunately you can't set up a Romantic Picnic Basket near it because it is indoors.