How SPI Made Me More Income Than 3 Bestsellers and 2 Movie Deals

By Pat Flynn on March 28, 2016

Karan Bajaj is a number one bestselling Indian novelist who created his first online course just a few months ago. In this post, he describes how SPI helped him create a profitable course with no email list or prior online business experience in less than a month. A must read for anyone who is on the fence, debating whether online courses are right for them.

I was at the end of my rope.

For eight years, I’d been writing novels on weekends after working all week at my day job. My novels were number one bestsellers in India and optioned into films, one by a Hollywood production house who produced Talladega Nights and Get Shorty. And now, Penguin Random House will be publishing my first international novel, The Yoga of Max’s Discontent, on May 3 in the US. On paper, this writing resume may appear solid, but let’s peek under the hood to see my writing income:

Book

Publisher

Book Advance + Royalty

Film Rights Option Fees

Total

Keep off the Grass

HarperCollins India (2008)

$18,000

$10,000

$28,000

Johnny Gone Down

HarperCollins India (2010)

$12,000

$150,000

$162,000

The Yoga of Max’s Discontent

Random House Worldwide (May 3rd’ 2016)

$82,000

TBD

$82,000

Total

$112,000

$160,000

$272,000

$272,000 over eight years is $2,833/month.

I’ve always supplemented my writing income with a corporate job, but now with one kid and another on the way, I can’t write all weekend as I used to. So I had a deep, sinking feeling that my writing was about to give.

*November 15 to February 15, excluding December 15 to January 15 when I paused given heavy holiday Facebook advertising in other categories.

$8,358 over eight weeks is $4,179/month.

An online course teaching people how to get book deals has earned me 48 percent higher income per month than my book deals. It’s still not enough to quit my day job, but it’s given me hope that in a few years, my daughters will see me at home on a Sunday instead of huddled away, writing in a cafe.

My numbers pale in comparison to the excellent case studies on Pat’s website. However, until October 15, 2015, I knew absolutely nothing about email automation funnels, video courses, or online business models. I didn’t have an opt-in form on my website. I didn’t even have a Mailchimp email list. Yet, within a month, I launched an income generating course.

Do you have a burning passion that consumes your soul but doesn’t pay the bills? Here are some things I’ve learned to transition from offline passion to online business model quickly:

1. Simple Models Work

I zeroed in on the idea of doing the “How to Get a Top 5 Book Deal” course within just three days of hearing about online courses because I kept repeating one question I read in Pat’s excellent blog on knowing your brand.

What disease do I want to cure in the world?

Just this one question helped me articulate exactly what tangible return my course would give. I wanted to cure the belief I’ve heard from aspiring and frustrated writers again and again: to get a top book deal means you need to “know people” or have a big platform. I had neither and got three book deals in five years with Penguin Random House and HarperCollins. So I wanted to share the exact step-by-step writing and querying method that’s worked for me with other aspiring writers.

This funnel is generating a consistent net profit of $6.57 per subscriber for me as shown below:

Cost per acquisition (CPA) of new subscribers defined as money spent in Facebook advertising for every new sign-up on my Mailchimp list: $1.20/subscriber

Conversion Rate defined as percentage of subscribers who buy the course after going through the automation funnel: 4.2%

Average course price: $185

Subscriber revenue: $7.77/subscriber

Net Profit: $6.57/subscriber.

I’m sure webinars, subscription models, etc. will enhance the course. But, if you’re a complete online newbie like me, there’s still hope you can create a profitable online product without drowning in complexity.

2. Pour Your Heart into Every Email in the Funnel.

I was intimidated when I first conceptualized this course. James Patterson was offering a MasterClass on writing for $99. Who was I to teach how to write and pitch a novel when people like James have been writing bestsellers for years? I took James’s course as well as a couple of other successful writers’ courses in one day and realized that my biggest liability was actually an asset. I was a struggling writer who’d been rejected sixty-one times by literary agents. So rather than lecture from a pedestal, I poured my heart out to subscribers about my journey of rejection, dejection, and the eventual success of getting multiple book deals from HarperCollins and Random House.

This is how the third email in my automation series begins:

Subject Line: Top 20 Literary Agent Contacts and Response Times

Dear (First Name),

One of the most heart-wrenching steps in the process of getting a worldwide book deal with Penguin Random House was querying US literary agents. Each day, I would send queries to ten top US literary agents and, initially, it felt like they were going into the ether.

Did they receive the query? Do they like it? How long will it take for them to respond? Should I send them a reminder?

I’d torment myself with these questions and would search for other writers’ experiences on the Internet but most of the responses in Absolute Write and other forums were from unpublished writers. I’d been writing my novel for more than one year at this point, so well-meaning friends and family would suggest I self-publish my novel. Never, I’d say silently to them. Somewhere deep inside me, I knew I could crack the system to get a top five international publishing deal. And eventually I did.

Today, I’ll share a snapshot of my method so you don’t have to go through this dark tunnel of waiting and rejection. Here is the exact query letter and follow-up method I used to get agent responses in record time, eventually landing representation offers from multiple top US literary agents within seven days.

My open rates for these emails are 45 percent and click rates are 18 percent. More importantly, almost a tenth of the people who read these emails replied to me personally, and these are often the ones who convert at the end of the funnel.

3. Create Urgency in an Evergreen Course With Urgent Copy.

I had learned the extreme importance of creating urgency in the sales process from Pat’s conversation with Bryan Harris but I didn’t want to go with a frequent “launch/closing” course model since my real passion is for writing novels and I didn’t want an online business model to distract from that. So I created urgency using these three techniques.

1. I use urgent, emotional copy.

This is how my second sales email in the funnel begins:

Dear (First Name),

You know writing is hard work. But is hard work enough? Between 2012 and 2013, my debut US novel was rejected by sixty-one literary agents until I changed my approach. Within one month, I had multiple representation offers from top agents, and, later, multiple book deals from three of the top five publishing houses. I eventually sold worldwide rights to Penguin Random House’s Riverhead imprint.

Just one decision to change my approach changed my outcome.

Is 2016 going to be the year you make that decision and have the impact you deserve in the world?

The urgency I created is an emotional urgency of time slipping away for people to pursue their dreams versus the closing of the course.

2. I provide limited-time only bonuses.

These bonuses help people feel compelled to buy immediately before the bonuses expire. Right now, for instance, I have these bonuses:

3. I cap enrollment.

I restrict the course to a certain number per month depending on my schedule. This serves the dual purpose of not having to spend time on answering questions about the course during particularly busy times like a book launch while creating further urgency to buy because it’s limited to “20 spots only.”

Are you teaching people something that can change their life by helping them increase their self-confidence, if not their income? Then, a combination of hard-hitting copy with scarcity incentives can force people to not postpone a life-changing decision.

4. Optimize Acquisition Cost With a Bullseye Advertising Model.

I had no mailing list, lead magnets, or opt-in forms before doing the course. The seven hundred people I emailed for my course launch were fans of my novels. I got a few sales from them, but for all intents and purposes, I had to build leads from scratch to sell the course sustainably. Kimra Luna’s interview with Pat Flynn inspired me to test Facebook advertising, and within a few weeks, I cracked the following Facebook advertising model to generate highly qualified leads at $1.20 cost per acquisition (CPA, or cost spent in Facebook advertising for every sign-up on my Mailchimp list).

Only after website visitors have seen my Facebook ads two times, I go after lookalikes of website visitors, a custom audience generated by Facebook with similar interests and profiles as my website visitors. My CPA with this audience is $1.40.

Finally, I spend the least on interest audiences (people interested in various writing and publishing related pages on Facebook). They are our coldest prospects because they don’t know me or match the profile of people who know me. As a result, the CPA is also the highest here at $2.00.

Through this approach of focusing the heaviest on website visitors and lookalike audiences, I grew from zero to 1,800 subscribers in three months while making a net profit of $6.57 per subscriber.

Even more importantly, it has underlined the importance of publishing legendary, original content related to writing and publishing on my website. The more writing-related website visitors I have, the more cost-efficient an advertising pool we create since website visitors and lookalike audiences lie at the center of our advertising strategy.

5. Launch a Minimum Viable Product Quickly, Then Optimize Constantly.

I didn’t have the good fortune of reading Pat’s excellent Will it Fly? when I launched the course, but I validated my idea with the basic research as outlined by Pat here and launched my course in rapid timings as below.

October 22: Discovered Pat and Ramit’s interview

October 22 to October 25: Selected an idea: “How to Get a Top 5 Book Deal”

October 25 to November 14: Planned, wrote, and shot the full video course (three hours, twenty modules) while hiring designers and developers on Upwork in parallel to host the course

November 15: Launched the course

Since then, I’ve constantly optimized the course to reduce costs and improve revenue. For instance, even though my first Facebook advertising campaign was profitable, I tried a new ad with different header copy.

Original Ad:

New Ad:

The new ad lowered CPA by 35 percent with just a change in header copy.

Similarly, in the first month of launch, I had only one course option, the full How to Write and Pitch Your Novel to Get a Top Publishing Deal ($199). I was listening to Pat’s conversation with Nathan Barry to plan my US book launch when he referenced a three-tier pricing structure. That lit a spark so I changed my conversion page to offer three options:

Immediately, we saw a 1.2 percentage points jump in conversion and a 30 percent improvement in revenue per subscriber.

1 OPTION

3 OPTIONS

Conversion Rate

3%

4.2%

Average Price Point

$199

$185

Revenue per Subscriber

$5.97

$7.77

As a result of these tweaks, my month two profitability is 51 percent higher than month one on a per unit basis.

These are things I could’ve never conceptualized in planning. If you’ve proven your basic idea is viable, launching and learning is so much more powerful than thinking of launching. The urgency to learn, measure, and make decisions is highest when you see a live return from your tests.

Resources I Used to Go from Idea to Launch in Three Weeks

Developer & Designer: Used Upwork to find a developer and a designer based on solid past reviews.

Total Cost for full course hosting and opt-in and conversion page designs on my existing WordPress interface: $1,100. You can probably do this yourself but I’m quite technologically challenged (shameful, I know, being an Indian!) so I outsourced everything.

Video Shooting: Freelancer based on personal contacts.

Total cost of full day shoot, including basic editing for three hours of video content: $700.

Video Hosting: Wistia password protected by WishList Member.

Payment Gateway: Stripe.

This was not as effective as I wanted for international payments because they couldn’t show payments in local currency on the purchase page. I would’ve liked to test conversion rate impact if I could show course fees in Rupees in India. I’d definitely go with a different payment gateway next time.

Do You Have a Passion That Doesn’t Pay the Bills?

For almost a decade, I’ve tried to balance my passion for writing fiction with a day job—and didn’t think I could ever break this cycle. SPI showed me that I could in one month with no email list, opt-in forms, or online business experience. Do you have a passion you’re struggling to monetize? Would you consider an online course to teach that passion? Let me know in the comments below. I’ll respond to each one—and give three lucky commenters the very first signed copies of The Yoga of Max’s Discontent, my new novel with Random House to be released worldwide on May 3!

Related Podcasts

What an inspiring story! I always tell people to start with what you know and see how you can reuse that skill instead of learning something brand new. It’s awesome to hear these success stories in action!

Karan Bajaj

Well said,

heyyonikko

This.is.gold.
Thank you for sharing this.Ugh! I can’t wait to get started now!

Karan Bajaj

Good luck!- Karan

Li-ling

Karan, I thoroughly enjoyed reading your post and learning about what it took you to achieve what you have in such a short space of time. Many congratulations on your success. As a writer looking at publishing options, I will certainly be checking out your website and course. Out of curiosity, did you find the course creation process difficult, and would you rather be doing that full time or writing?

Karan Bajaj

Li-I outsourced all the technology so the course creation was actually a ton of fun since it helped me codify exactly what had worked for me and what hadn’t in terms of getting a top publishing deal. Will help me even more for writing my future novels. You’ll like the course as a writer I think!

Erik van Dullemen

Wauw great results and what an inspiring story, Karan! I’m going to use your tips and hopefully it will work for me just like you.

“The urgency I created is an emotional urgency of time slipping away for people to pursue their dreams versus the closing of the course.”

I absolutely love this approach. It always drives me crazy when I see online marketers saying things like “this ebook is only available for X days” or “this course is only available for a limited time”.

It’s a digital product, there’s no scarcity so these approaches always come off as super sleazy to me.

You definitely need urgency in your copy though and the way you’ve put it there is fantastic. You’ve got your urgency but you avoid creating that fake scarcity that always drives me crazy.

Karan Bajaj

Agree, well said Peter. I also find this launch-closing model a tad inauthentic. Let’s see if this keeps working.

Very inspiring story. I am just starting my own online journey and it feels like I’m swimming in the deepend with the sharks. Thanks for posting

Karan Bajaj

Thanks! Does feel like that in the beginning. Cut through the clutter and do it–you learn more by just doing I think.

pooja

Very inspiring story.Get more stories on http:holysongs.in

mounika

wow , nice article ,itsy very inspiring to me ..

E Chronicle

Once upon the time, in a future near or far, not everything is about the monies. It brakes my heart to see shiniest of the minds wasting time to play with the devil in the pocket. Crunching numbers and rounding up support in elaborate schemes is the game of us common people fighting for a glimpse of wealth to feed our vanity. Artist should entertain only the judgment of generations to come.

Karan Bajaj

Personally, I don’t think teaching how to write sacrifices the integrity of writing.

Thank you for providing this excellent case study. When I was younger and I said “I want to be an Author,” everyone always said there was no money in it. It’s so easy to lose hope getting your dream out there because of all the obstacles to success.

As much as I love Pat, sometimes it is easy to forget he now has a team behind him to help him produce the amazing content here on SPI.

What you have done here, Karan, is provide an excellent case study on how these things can be done with little time and resources. Great work!

Karan Bajaj

Rachael, thank you for the kind comments. Agreed, the time the course took has been a fraction of the time it’s taken to write the novels.

Lewi Blake

This is an absolutely amazing case study, one of the best I’ve ever read. Thanks very much, so engaging. I love how you have mentioned the specific posts from the SPI blog that helped you with each step in creating your online course. Thanks again

Another GOLD post from Pat. This post is actually a BENCHMARK, the whole product building and marketing world in a Nutshell = AWE-SUM!

Karrisa

This post really spoke to me! I do indeed have a passion that doesn’t pay the bills, and learning about how you jumped in with no experience, and were so successful is very encouraging to me. I’m on my second day here exploring SPI, and the more I read, the more I think “I could really do this, and be successful!”

Paris Lamont Hamilton

Awesome and inspiring content. Can’t wait to put this into action.

felix lest

Such an informative article! I like reading clever thoughts. What do you think about this https://cpimobi.com/ cpi ad network?

Hi, I can not find your products for sale on your page spi, you have another store page where you can find what you have for sale. A greeting and congratulations.

Jagunmolu Fatai

Awesome!

I love how things are happening here. I am also wondering how people make so much money on affiliate marketing. I tried to set it up myself I just couldn’t make a success of it. Until I get a set up from http://faitheroic.org If anybody have already catch fire but don’t know what to burn you have to visit the website and take action. before you burn out!

Very interesting article. I would like to read more of this information. And the same would like to recommend our service https://playcasinonz.com/betway-casino/ to you. With him you can really make a fortune