By most peoples standards 10/10 would be unattainable for this, not because it's not good but because it isn't an original idea, this has been duplicated thousands of times over. That said, it's a nice attempt.
Here are a few things that might improve it.

-Work on the photo a little more, maybe a little more contrast.

-I don't know alot about polaroid photos but I've never seen ones that look like that, they generally have even white space on all sides except one.

-Try taking it a step farther, doing something to make it your own, original design.

Here is a simple example of something more you could do with this.

Quote:

Originally Posted by Mosh Clockwise

love the idea of using polaroids 8/10

6/10

I understand what you're going for. I think "anarchy" should be a bit more bold, either a stronger typeface or just make it bold. The "order" side is what could be improved the most, I think alot more could me done to relay the idea to the viewer, I would suggest ditching the black square and going with something a little less geometric. I would take a good look at the colors you chose also, they don't really do much for the design. *get rid of those snowflakes*

----------

Here is something I did awhile ago for a event t-shirt.
Annual event for classic cars, used classic pinstripes and vegas style sign and text. The cars where provided by the client as standard non-digital photo's and had to be scanned in and cleaned up. This wasn't quite finished, the client decided they wanted something different.

umm......like 5/10 idk, it might look cool with out the buildings or the random block with stars or the blam text.

Made it from scratch messing with livePaint in illustrator.

__________________
---------------------------
"Originally posted by SmArT-SpOrKs: Jesus Tapdancing christ this thread is a cluster**** on both sides. Its like the civil war, but replace muskets with pool noodles and everyone has a wicked sunburn."ST PHOTOBUCKET_-_ST:GDT 10,000 posts and counting

You gotta be able to persuade your clients to chose different fonts if they're that bad.

2/10

[IMG]http://www.mjmfx.com/clientfiles/paintballsphere/logo.jpg[IMG]

looks great 9/10, only sugestion is to maybe add some more black imaging towards the bottom of the logo, all the black floral brushings on the top kinda throw it out of balance.

Im posting this again because people in here tend to suck at rating the picture above them (ie: not rating it at all).

Background i made, all vector using livepaint

__________________
---------------------------
"Originally posted by SmArT-SpOrKs: Jesus Tapdancing christ this thread is a cluster**** on both sides. Its like the civil war, but replace muskets with pool noodles and everyone has a wicked sunburn."ST PHOTOBUCKET_-_ST:GDT 10,000 posts and counting