User Reviews

Best Desserts In Town

I had the absolute pleasure of finding Eileen's 35 years ago and I have been coming back ever since.

Eileen's Cheesecake

Posted by sprung on food on 2014-02-06

The Name Says It All: Eileen's Special Cheesecake

Everyone always hears about "real New York cheesecake". So, where are you supposed to find it? Well, you can start atÂ Eileen's Special Cheesecake in NoLIta.

Eileen's Cheesecake

Posted by Ez2bNice on 2011-05-05

Extremely tolerable for a lactose intolerant!

One of favorite places to buy cheesecakes! For my birthday, my friends surprised me with a 6" strawberry cheesecake. I was rather touched by their thoughtfulness because I love, lovee, loveee cheesecakes! I want to commend Eileen for continuing to prod

Eileen's Cheesecake

Posted by Happy Diners on 2010-10-20

Cream Cheese Cakes!!

These fluffy cheese cakes are so good! :) We especially love their pumpkin & mango flavours :D
Service tends to be on the slow side and there's simply too much paraphernalia and articles praising her cheesecakes on the walls... can be tacky.

Eileen's Cheesecake

Posted by A Frequent Diner on 2008-06-30

Glad I'm Not Dieting

Who needs fancy ? - - the best cheesecake, cookies and rugalach in NYC (bar none). I'll put these fine desserts up against any trendy bakery's finest (just wait 'til you tate the difference).

Eileen's Cheesecake

Posted by Anonymous on 2007-10-24

Awesome gem!

A group of friends and I were in the City for a girls getaway when we stumpled upon this wonderful little bakery. By the multiple people streaming in an out we decided that it was a must. And it soooo was. so much that we went again the next night. Th

Eileen's Cheesecake

Posted by eggberry on 2007-10-22

slowly going downhill

i remember this place used to be one of the best places to go in the middle of the night if you wanted a quick snack. but over the past year, its been slowly going downhill. the people behind the register are becoming rude and quality has slowly been goin

Eileen's Cheesecake

Posted by about cheesecake on 2006-02-01

How I feel about this place

First time brought by a friend who claimed this place has very nice cheesecake. I was disappointed. Reasons being that the cheesecake did not taste much cheese. Its softness is praised, I know. But it is a version of slight diluting down than the skill th