I saw the statue and screamed, "ATLANTIS!" And then Sayid kicked a fuss, like, dude, have you never seen any of the kouros statues from Greece? They don't look like real people, either, chill. Though I like your Homer Simpson explanation better.

On the heels of the Atlantis thing, I cannot believe that I did not pick up on Penelope. *headdesk*

Stupidest person on the island is still Sayid, but it's because he somehow did not think that the same smoke that would be visible to his group would also be visible to the Others.