I'm a girl, so I can't answer for guys, but I'd say it probably depends on the guy. The best ones are the ones who go for personality anyways, not looks or make-up style. My boyfriend once asked me why I wear such heavy eyeliner... Once we had it confirmed that I wear it because I like it and not because I think I NEED it, he never mentioned it again. He probably wouldn't even remember asking!

As for my own--if not very masculine--opinion, girls should wear what level of makeup they like and they think looks good. The quickest way to acceptance is to be comfortable with yourself!

It kind of depends on your definition of too much. Lipstick is never really over the top. I never really saw the appeal of mascara but it's all right I guess. I never liked eye shadow in general. Personal opinion, but it's just not attractive. In high school there was this girl who practically covered herself in makeup. I don't know if she was trying to look like a ghost or something but her skin looked like it was covered in no-odor baking powder. Personally I don't find that attractive. In fact, that would scare me away. I'd be afraid "if I kissed her on the cheek, would I die or is it non-toxic?"

Don't know...but I get a lot more double takes from guys when I wear my makeup. But I don't put it on two layers thick. So I guess it all depends on what you call lots.
I do hate it when guys and girls wear too much perfume. I always wonder what other stink they are trying to cover up.

i think it's a split,because i see guy's go for superficial stuck up chicks who paint there faces with tons foundation and other crap,but on the other hand some complain they want a natural looking chick...who knows what guys want!...