Banks and Fintech

Graham Seel - BankTech Consulting

A discussion of trends in innovation management within financial institutions, and the key processes, technology and cultural shifts driving innovation.

Should Community Banks and Credit Unions Worry About Blockchain?

09 January 2017 | 6494 views | 0

There is more hype, discussion and disagreement about Blockchain than any other technology impacting financial services today.

There has been a lot written about blockchain (or more generally Digital Ledger Technology). There are some
good tutorials on what it is. The news media seem to always have some new application that is in pilot. All the large banks are in at least a couple of
blockchain consortia.

But should smaller FIs leave all this early activity to the larger banks?

Why should smaller FIs be interested in blockchain?

In the long term, there are likely to be major changes in how banking infrastructure works. This will impact community banks and credit unions. Examples of areas to expect change:

Payments clearing and settlement. The much-hyped
Ripple solution, for example, aims to take correspondent banks out of payments. And some
governments are looking at blockchain-based national and international payment systems.

Core banking vendors will undoubtedly be impacted by blockchain technology. At a minimum they will need to interface with digital ledgers for various interbank transactions, and to support regulatory expectations. They may also have opportunities ultimately
to transform the whole approach to
building a core banking system. These things will, of course, impact their customer banks and CUs.

How should smaller FIs show their interest?

That you should be interested, as a long-term watch item, is a given. But how about getting involved in consortia, experiments, pilots and trials? This author answers with an almost resounding “No!” The only exception is if you have a particular business
problem that is unique to you – a niche business – that would be best solved by digital ledger technology, and could be implemented with appropriate risk. I do not know of any examples, but please let me know if you have one.

Also, do not wait for global rollout of blockchain-based solutions for payments, securities, digital identify, etc. These will take several years, regardless of the amount of hype surrounding bilateral or point solution pilots. You have shorter-term needs
to meet customer expectations, address regulatory issues, and grow your non-interest income. For example, in payments there is nothing urgent about Ripple. Community banks in particular need to focus on offering faster payment mechanism like same-day ACH,
and lower-cost cross-border payment capabilities.

Industry Consortia

There is one interesting nuance on the “do nothing” approach recommended here. There is the potential for industry-driven initiatives in which blockchain can enable the community banking or credit union industries.

A handful of larger Credit Unions and CU Service Organizations, are in process of
forming a consortium called CULedger. This is focused on provision of distributed ledger driven services for credit unions, intended to drive out cost and enable new and improved products. CUNA is also actively participating.
It is too early to say what the priorities will be, but industry-wide action could certainly be beneficial.

Even more recent is the Community Bank Blockchain Alliance. This vendor-led group seems initially to be particularly focused on digital currencies (such as Bitcoin). It isn’t clear that any community banks have yet
signed up. However, sooner or later a community banking focused consortium is to be expected.

The Risks of Not Paying Attention

Some very highly hyped technologies require more attention than others. One fruit of hype is FOMO – Fear Of Missing Out. Blockchain has generated a lot of it. For smaller FIs, FOMO is a distraction and luxury very few can afford.

Nevertheless, there is always risk in completely ignoring new technologies, just as with new market conditions and new customer expectations. It seems like you can’t afford to let it pass you by.

By all means keep your eyes and ears open. It makes sense for someone in the bank to do highly selective reading on blockchain progress. Engage in core vendor discussions. Listen to what is going on in your favorite industry association, including blockchain-specific
industry initiatives.

What Next?

But don’t plan to invest in blockchain technology for at least the next couple of years. If you’re looking for new technologies that are ready for primetime, and will meet existing customer needs, consider:

Video and voice communications to meet the expectations of younger generations of consumers and business owners

Even before you consider these, look at your current technology capabilities. Is your data all over the place? If so, clean it up. What does your website look like? Or your mobile apps? Seek advice on digital marketing and delivery.

Most of all, if you don’t have a business strategy driven technology roadmap, then build one (with outside help if like most banks you need it).