Pages

Thursday, June 25, 2015

The New York Public Library Wars

What went wrong at one of the world’s eminent research institutions?

Alamy

The
Rose Main Reading Room in the New York Public Library’s main branch, on
Fifth Avenue at 42nd Street. A group of scholars spearheaded a
successful protest to stop radical changes at the library, but now it
looks as if they may have lost anyway.

By Scott Sherman

Scholars who use the New York
Public Library are boiling with frustration. It wasn’t supposed to be
this way. In 2014 the library, under pressure from a coalition that
included four senior scholars, abandoned its controversial Central
Library Plan, which entailed gutting the stacks at the 42nd Street
Library and selling the popular Mid-Manhattan Library across the street.
But the situation hasn’t turned out how many critics had hoped.

Paula Glatzer, an independent Shakespeare scholar, has been engaged
in research at the library since 1963 and has recently used the
collections for her contribution to the new Variorum Shakespeare
editions, published by the Modern Language Association. On January 15 she sent a letter
to Anthony W. Marx, the library’s president: "Sadly, I have had to tell
my Variorum colleagues that the NYPL is over … for now." Many books are
stored off-site, some mislabeled as on-site; others have been lost or
discarded, she wrote. "I requested a series. It couldn’t be found. I
said it was hard to lose 21 volumes. A librarian overheard me and
offered to look. He later emailed. All 21 volumes were indeed missing." Read more...