The Lying Game Twins: The Cast’s Celebrity Look-Alikes

Credit:
Bill Records/ABC Family / Owen Beiny/WENN

Christian Alexander and Penn Badgley

Christian Alexander’s Lying Game character, Thayer, has a lot in common withGossip Girl’s lonely boy, Dan Humphrey. Both are sensitive, kinda nerdy, and love the Queen Bee, mean-girl type. But Christian has more in common with Penn Badgley, who plays Dan: dark hair, a fondness for tight T-shirts, and pouty lips. Despite the five-year age difference, these two are practically separated at birth.