The New Waterford Cemetery is located at the intersection of McCloskey Road and Hisey Road in New Waterford, Ohio (Unity Township, Columbiana County). The coordinates are 40° 51' 12.34" N, 80° 36' 49.34" W.

The New Waterford Cemetery is still active. There are many old gravestones, and the majority are in great condition. The oldest gravestones are located closest to McCloskey Road. The township does an excellent job of maintaining the cemetery.