Pumpkin Pie O'Plenty is a co-op job. 1400 Pumpkin have to be grown in 1 day 13 hours hours to earn the bronze medal. If completed in 16 hours, all co-op members will be rewarded with 462 coins, 527 XP, and gold medal reward item: Cafe Statue.

The story reads as follows:

My friends said we'd bake pies for a bake sale in town. Unfortunately we said we'd bake more pumpkin pie than we have ingredients for! We need you to harvest enough pumpkins for us to finish!!