Book review – The Drowned and the Saved: When War Came to the Hebrides

A truly harrowing account, Wilson’s book sheds light on the untold Hebridean war experience, writes Stacey Wylie. The Drowned and the Saved pays homage to the victims and survivors of two tragic incidents: the sinking of American troop ship Tuscania by a German U-Boat, and the collision of another troop ship with the merchant cruiser Otranto. The combined death count was over 800. Wilson also recognises the traumatic impact on the islanders of Islay who helped rescue survivors, recover victims and bury the dead. Contributing to a new tradition of war accounts, Wilson’s book tells a tale different to the mainstream frontline recollections we are used to and emphasises the war fought at home.

The Drowned and the Saved: When War Came to the Hebrides

Highlights

Despite being a historical, arguably heavy-going book, Wilson’s writing has you hooked. Taking time in the first few chapters to consider the First World War, particularly the naval experience, The Drowned and the Saved is by no means a difficult or intimidating read. Wilson strikes a perfect balance between this knowledge and his main aim of reporting on the horrors that occurred on Islay’s shores. Throughout, Wilson quotes Celtic poetry reminiscent of the heart-rending times of war, making his book emanate with true respect for the Hebridean war devastation.

Audience

The Drowned and the Saved would appeal to anybody. What makes this book so excellent is its balance of information. WWI experts would be adding a niche part of history to their repertoire, but those less familiar with the war are eased into the text by Wilson’s unintimidating contextualisation. As we approach 100 years since the sinking of Tuscania and Otranto, The Drowned and the Saved would make an excellent gift and read for any history, war or Hebrides enthusiast.

Verdict

An easy read that genuinely piques your curiosity, The Drowned and the Saved informs on an important, forgotten part of history. An emotional tale which vitally reminds you of the devastation faced by past generations, Wilson’s book still manages to be an enjoyable, fulfilling read.

The Drowned and the Saved: When War Came to the Hebrides, by Les Wilson, Birlinn, £12.99.

Primary Footer Menu

Secondary Footer Menu

We at Scottish Field endeavour to ensure that all our reports are fair and accurate and comply with the Editors’ Code of Practice set by the
Independent Press Standards Organisation (IPSO). We realise, however, that mistakes
happen from time to time. If you think we have made a significant mistake and you
wish to discuss this with us, please let us know as soon as possible by any of the
three methods: emailing
editor@scottishfield.co.uk;
telephoning the editor on 0131 551 1000; writing to the Editor at
Scottish Field, 496 Ferry Road, Edinburgh, EH5 2DL. We will
attempt to resolve your issue in a timeous, reasonable and amicable manner.
However, if you are unsatisfied with our response, you can contact IPSO, which will
investigate the matter. You can either telephone IPSO on 0300 123 2220 or
email inquiries@ipso.co.uk. IPSO is an
independent body which deals with complaints
from the public about the editorial content of newspapers and magazines.
We will abide by the decision of IPSO.