sounds good, but I'm of the opinion that carlington is more likely to flip Siuan/Not scum, simply because of him having found out that Bessie is a Doctor, and Bessie not being the first scum Night Kill. If something suggests that moody warded Bessie before getting lynched, I'd have similar confidenc...

Mpolo, is there a reason why you aren't explicitly stating that you were recruited into Elaida's faction? Madge's lynch should have prevented Siuan's faction from recruiting the night you claim to have been recruited.

I'm not entirely convinced that SirGabriel is telling the truth for the simple reason that if Sabrar and I are both town, getting the two of us mislynched would result in a scum win, unless something else prevents a night kill, assuming the 3 scum suggested by SirGabriel and speculated by confirmed ...

Just want to confirm I'm reading this correctly before a larger post tonight. Sabrar, are you voting for me obecause you believe me to be Siuan, not a member of the black ajah? I'm a bit confused, where do you get this from? I voted for you because I think that you're lurking scum. I thought I was ...

I would not object to our vig killing SirGabriel to reduce the probability that I have to worry about getting rid of a weak leader in the future. (Of course for purposes of the game, it might be that only the Blacks are unacceptable leaders…) I was under the impression that weak leader meant anyone...

I have some time, so I'll just get out of the way some things I noticed so far in day 3, this will likely be multipke posts just to get each separate thought up sooner. His win condition was to control the leadership of the White Tower or to eliminate all other players (or if nothing could prevent t...

Looks like SirGabriel's claim is going to be important, although I notice conspicuously absent were claims of what he did last night. It has yet to be claimed whether ahippo was recruited last night or was already a follower day 1. I think this is important as Elaida's faction (should it exist) like...

I'm here, just got my laptop back from being repaired, but it came back without the charger, which means I continur to be stuck phone posting until I get it back. Given that I've already shown a power and earlier ajah power speculation, it should come as no surprise that my ajah is grey. As far as w...

Phone post,don't expect too much. ⋅ What scum-hunting strategies have worked for you in the past? ⋅ Do you generally prefer to act based on assumptions then change if your assumptions prove wrong, or wait until you're confident? ⋅ When do you think it's appropriate for ...

I'm glad WoT2 is starting up!! I was beginning to feel guilty for not signing up. It looks like fun, I had fun last game, so I hope you all have fun in my honour!!!! I'm also looking forward to Diablo!! "You have quite a treasure there in that horadric cube" Question - partially for Madge...

Just thought I would read up a bit on what the ajahs are, and while I agree that the threat to the white tower is almost certainly the black ajah, I did notice a couple of interesting things that I may be completely misinterpreting. First and most importantly, it appears that an Amrylin from the Red...

Wheel of Time 2: The White Tower http://forums.xkcd.com/download/file.php?id=51027 Description: Standard Mafia game, set in the Wheel of Time universe, around the time of books 4-5. Mod: jimbobmacdoodle, co-mod: SDK, kalira Speed: 5-7 days, 1 day nights (possibly pseudo-nightless). Day deadlines wi...

GoP tracking rather than watching would also make it possible that adnapemit's claimed 1 shot night action immunity would have let her night kill without being tracked/blocked/etc. even if it required not using her primary powrt as the scum night kill would be a factional and not role based ability....

Secret Santa R. I. P. Me, I'm going to redirect adnapemit to myself tonight to protect confirmed townies bessie and GoP, which should get me killed, putting the final nail in her coffin upon my flip (additionally confirming the 9-3-1-1 set up). If everything goes well, this game should e...

I would like people to know that I plan on targeting whichever of adnapemit/Carlington isn't lynched today, and that so long as no one else targets them(I asked a question that disproved an assumption I had about how my power worked) I will be able to confirm that any kills that happen tonight are n...

I actually know this one from a question I asked in a PM. The way night actions mechanically work is that there is an ordered list which determines when actions occur, simplifying dealing with all the role blocks and redirects. My action must have simply had higher priority.

jimbobmacdoodle wrote:I targeted kalira last night, but unless there's some hidden aspect to my role, I did not kill her. I am also fairly confident that I wasn't redirected, because I believe my action would have had public confirmation (will ask the mods),

Just needed to check some stuff with the mods before posting, but given that Jimbob targeted me last night and was asking everyone to vote, he probably has something to do with me not being allowed to vote today, not as in 0 weight given to the vote, but as in attempting to vote will result in mod k...

@Matt - please post your reads on, as a minimum, emlightened, moody, adnapemit, and GoP, in that order. emlightened- given RR's flip, I would not be surprised if emlightened is also scum, having tried to redirect the wagon twice yesterday, and I'm not sure if I'm willing to believe the claim of dyi...

Looks like Day/Night 1 went rather well. For now I'm inclined to believe the present moody received, mainly because I doubt scum would lie about getting something like that, with one of the 3 players already dead and confirmed town, this early in the game after losing two members day/night 1. As far...

I'm really hoping GoP is not scum, because an early town win seems to be the best chance I have of keeping him alive. Just sent off a PM to ask about how my redirect interacts with other redirects, to try to figure out what happened last night.

Secret Santa Things are going well enough so far, but I need something to happen overnight to keep my maker from getting lynched tomorrow. I probably should go ahead and apologize for keeping dead players from reading spoilers, as I am fairly certain that comes as a result of the role I submitted. I...

Gopher of Pern 2 serious posts, a bit of questioning and responding, seems to be on the low end of expectations of number of scum and abnormal powers in the game, not really sure what people are reading as scummy(on review appears to be caused by failing to withdraw pressure vote after emlightened's...

I'm here, looks like things are happening, I had been trying to figure out a way to ask some mod questions to possibly draw out some new information, like whether any role which would need to be adjusted was adjusted before or after being given an alignment and if a serial killer's kill would be der...

Vote:Carlington For being anti-Christmas and trying to pass this murder off as an accident. As I see it, either someone who knew they were faking Santa's visit wanted Grandma and Granddad dead or someone who didn't know wanted Santa dead. As far as setup goes, I think it is unlikely that there are ...

2016 Secret Santa by Madge http://i.imgur.com/uEed74O.jpg You arrive at your Mum's house in your rusty holden ute to drink some white wine in the sun with the whole family. Lucky, too, because you almost popped a great big boomer with your bull bar when you were chucking a u-ey after stopping by th...

IMHO To put it simply, this comic fails in every important aspect which makes xkcd unique and interesting. It's always struck me as funny how "IMHO" tends to preface a statement that isn't exactly humble in tone, much like "with all due respect" often precedes a statement that c...