Month: August 2008

I guess it isn’t going to come as much of a surprise to people when I say I’ve been having a hard time finding the time to maintain the extensions I develop. I’ll go over some of the reasons why shortly, but I guess the highlight (or lowlight depending on your point of view) of this post is that I’m no longer going to really put in any effort to keep them updated.

Nightly Tester Tools will probably continue to get the odd update here and there where I find something interesting to add, and Update Channel Selector is due to get an update to make it actually work on most platforms, but otherwise I would not expect to see any further updates for any of my other extensions.

I came to this conclusion last week when doing some updates and I realised that I really wasn’t enjoying it. The things I generally enjoy doing in my spare time are things that are new and interesting. All of my main extensions were born out of finding something cool to do with the platform. Fast ways to perform regular expressions on large html documents, painting thumbnails of webpages (back when it was actually new and exciting), taking enough control of the toolbar customisation service to be able to dynamically add many instances of the same widgets. All of this stuff was interesting enough to make me knock up a quick extension to play with it. When they seemed useful I would go through and try to iron out some of the rough edges to make it something I’d consider release-worthy. Only Tab Sidebar had real effort put into it to try to make it into a real user friendly product.

I’ve also had quite a large change in my life since I last really actively worked on my extensions. Back then I was a small business owner, most of my day to day work was IT support and web development. Getting home and sitting down for a few hours hacking away on extensions worked as quite a diversion, completely taking my mind off the stresses at work. Now I work for Mozilla. Working on extensions is basically no different from what I do during the day. It is no longer a diversion, it is just like work. How many of you like to get home from work, kick back and then go back over more work to relax?

These things, as well as other issues, have left me really uninterested in doing anything except the exciting new stuff. Turning that into a usable tool, fixing bugs, making things work in new releases, all of that is just dull and no longer worth the spare time it loses me.

And that is pretty much that. I’m not totally out of the extensions game, while I might still create a few experimental add-ons in the future, they probably won’t be fully useful, just little things for fun. I’m not really going to be interested in hearing about bugs in my existing stuff or that it hasn’t yet been updated to the latest version of Firefox. I’m not going to do anything about it. Of course all of my add-ons are open source, under the MPL/GPL/LGPL tri-license, and I’d happily talk to anyone thinking of taking over official development of them for the future.

To those of you who have kept using my extensions and let me know how much you liked them I’d like to say thank you, and I’m sorry that there will be nothing more even though I know you were hoping. It’s taken me a while to reach this decision and I’m sure some will feel a little left in the lurch by it, but I can’t keep fooling myself that I’ll find the time to put in the effort you all deserve.

I was very excited to learn at the Firefox Summit that Rob Strong was handing over ownership of the Extension Manager module to me. He did great work making the extension manager what it is today but has lately had to be more focused on Installer and windows integration issues.

Last week I spent a large part of my time trying to get myself up to speed on all the old filed bugs, clearing out things that clearly aren’t going to happen and trying to consolidate others. In particular I made the effort to go over every single unconfirmed bug and either resolve as appropriate or request any additional information from the reporter. It is rather sad that many of these were issues that noone commented in after the initial report or even worse the reporter responded with additional information but people (including me) dropped the ball and nothing further happened.

This big triage has been quite useful. Firstly the number of unconfirmed bugs for the add-ons manager has dropped from the mid 70s to under 30 (I would give you exact figures and pretty graphs but bugzilla’s charting is broken). I expect it to drop even further next week when I resolve the issues where the reporter is no longer responding to bugmail. Secondly it has allowed me to spot a pattern amongst 6 or so filed bugs which strongly suggests a new issue that can break add-on installations. While I have yet to be able to reproduce it in a test environment I certainly have more information to go on than previously.

Finally I have been marking all the trivial little issues that I think we could fix, but are unlikely to be priorities. These are the kinds of things that if you were interested in helping out and getting started in developing for Mozilla you could start out on. Many will end up being a few lines of patch, just need to figure out where to put it and test it.

So if you are interested in tackling any of these please give it a go. You can find me on IRC (for reasons best left alone I appear as Mossop) or by email if you need any guidance on getting started. I’m going to try to keep this list updated as I find new bugs that fit there, I still have yet to go through all of the 263 confirmed bugs, maybe a job for next week.

My head is slightly less fuzzy now and I’m almost back on UK time so I thought it would be a good opportunity to give a quick review of how the Add-ons Manager session I ran at the summit went. I won’t go into too much detail, just a look at the main points of discussion and how I felt the room reacted to the ideas. You can also see the slides I prepared or the notes that Basil kindly took for me without me needing to remember to ask. Most of the session was about things we might want to implement and what problems/benefits we might encounter.

Add-on locale packs

The idea of developing the UI for locale packs specific to extensions received a less enthusiastic response than I had expected. This may have been because there were more add-on developers and less localisers in the room, but the general feeling seemed to be that there was not a large benefit and the potential complications, particularly around updating, could cause some large problems.

Dependency resolution

The current add-on dependency implementation is a very rough start. Being able to automatically find and install dependant add-ons for the user, with clear UI to show what is happening, seemed to be something that didn’t have many downsides. There were also suggestions that AMO could handle dependencies and deliver sets of add-ons as multi-xpi packages, though this could cause issues in upgrades.

Add-on conflicts

The moment I mentioned the suggestion of a system to mark two add-ons as incompatible with each other half the room said they wanted it. It was pointed out that some add-ons were already disabling things they don’t like on install (if you hear of that happening without appropriate warning please let us know). It was also quickly realised that under the author’s control it could just become a means to avoid having to work to fix incompatibilities and to disable the competition. The suggestion of Mozilla maintaining a central list of incompatibilities seemed like a good way to go.

Install without restart

No surprise that this was seen as useful, particularly in non-Firefox applications that don’t have the wonder of session restore. We also started talking about the potential for lower impact extensions that just had a small sandbox to work in with a little piece of UI which could make loading and unloading dynamically far easier.

Install/uninstall hooks

We discussed how the current mechanisms for running setup and cleanup code for extensions were poor, there is no way to deal properly with uninstall in all situations. It was felt that add-ons should be able to provide a full uninstall script that would even run if uninstalled when disabled or in safe mode, but would not run if the add-on had been blocklisted. We also talked a little about sandboxing what this script might be able to access.

Replace RDF

I was surprised that there seemed little to no resistance to the prospect of introducing a new plainer XML form for install.rdf and update.rdf given some of the comments I had when I blogged about it last. We would of course still support the old forms for a time and make converters between the forms available. There didn’t appear to be any benefit in using JSON instead of XML.

Much of the rest of the slides were skimmed over as we had unfortunately run out of time by this point, but thankfully that was most of the more important stuff completed anyway. For the immediate future I think introducing replacements for RDF into Firefox 3.1 is potentially on the cards. None of the other items were ruled out, far from it, though the locale packs seemed less interesting to everyone, and I think there needs to be some very careful thought about the prospect of running an uninstall hook for an add-on in safe mode or when disabled.

It’s 6:30am Sunday UK time (though in my weird method of getting over the jet lag that works out as just after lunchtime) and I’ve just got home to Swansea. As many others are I’ve been thinking back over the great times I’ve had over the past two weeks. Needless to say I got out alive, as I believe everyone did (though apparently some are still stranded in Vancouver), despite Canada’s attempts to break us.

After a short visit with my sister trying to avoid getting licked to death by her new puppy I spent a week in Toronto at the Mozilla offices there. Thanks guys for having me, it was a fun week and I’m sorry I brought the Welsh rain over with me. Although I do have a shared office that I work from for most of the week I forget how good it is to actually be in a place where others are working on the same stuff. Maybe I’ll give in to Beltzner and move out there.

The summit was nothing short of amazing. So much larger than the last one and so much more enjoyable for it. As with all of these events I never got chance to do the things I had planned on and missed meeting many of those I wanted to, but met others I had never known and did more interesting things anyway. Dan and the rest of the organising team should be seriously proud with how the event went and how they coped with the upsets.

I think the Add-ons Management session I ran on Tuesday went pretty well all things considered. I have never really done interactive sessions before and combined with the hangover I was sporting I was a little nervous about it. Thankfully you can always rely on the Mozilla community to be talkative so in the end we actually ran out of time to talk over some of the ideas for the future of the Add-ons manager. Hopefully those there found it useful, I know I will take a lot from being able to get feedback and suggestions on my plans.

I guess the only minor disappointment (which is always the case since it would be impossible to avoid) is that there were many sessions I wanted to attend but conflicted with others. I hope there are some notes around for some of them so I can skim over what I missed.

Somehow I managed to find the journey home easier than normal. I suspect it helps that there were so many of us at the airport and I did the journey in a couple of stages to avoid the drive home immediately after getting off a plane which always turns into a dangerous race between traffic and my body trying to fall asleep.

I forgot how cool it is to drive down the motorways at 4am in the pitch black with nothing but good music and your thoughts to enjoy. Now, if only there were some shops open so I could actually get some lunch and a decent cup of English tea…