If this is your first visit, be sure to
check out the FAQ by clicking the
link above. You may have to register
before you can post: click the register link above to proceed. To start viewing messages,
select the forum that you want to visit from the selection below.

How do you rank them? Would you trade up for any of them, even if it meant mortgaging the future?

I’m not settled yet. Some very different guys in skill set, QB type, and leadership and maturity. Allen isat the bottom for me. Rosen I find myself wary of as a leader...I’d rather have small potential maturity issues in a Mayfield than leadership issues in a Rosen. There’s something I really like about Darnold when he’s playing from behind, but not all game in every game. Jackson and Mayfield would be exciting but maybe flash and burn. I don’t think I’ll be able to rank them easily this year and that kind of makes me happy. I won’t freak out as much when we don’t get my favorite.

The fanspeak.com 2018 draft simulator is already open and will be the end of me this off-season.

Just from what he has done the last two years, I have to go with Mayfield. A 70 percent completion percentage is really good. For both years. No matter what division your in. Add in the fact his ypc is over 11, that tells me he is throwing more that bubble screens. Plus he can run a bit. He would be my #1 choice. The rest in any order you want. Not sold on Jackson. Pass on Rosen. Darnold regresses this year. Allen is all hype.

Just from what he has done the last two years, I have to go with Mayfield. A 70 percent completion percentage is really good. For both years. No matter what division your in. Add in the fact his ypc is over 11, that tells me he is throwing more that bubble screens. Plus he can run a bit. He would be my #1 choice. The rest in any order you want. Not sold on Jackson. Pass on Rosen. Darnold regresses this year. Allen is all hype.

Mayfield's on-field record is head and shoulders above most other 3rd and 4th yr prospects expecting to enter the 2018 draft. So, I'm all in w/ a Mayfield selection, unless something drastic happens off-field next winter and spring.