A massive curtain drops to reveal a stage decked out in Arnold’s Drive-In decorations, including a “Cuomo” pennant and a “Jefferson High School” banner. Rivers Cuomo even dons a cardigan button-up combo that looks almost identical to his original outfit.

Watch the recreation below:

The iconically retro “Buddy Holly” video has amassed over 40 million views on YouTube. Refresh your memory and watch the original video here!