Did Beatles push black music aside?

By Elijah Wald

Updated 2107 GMT (0407 HKT) August 25, 2014

America falls in love with the Beatles15 photos

America falls in love with the Beatles – The Beatles arrived in the United States 50 years ago and embarked on a history-making path of pop culture dominance. Check out coverage of "The Sixties: The British Invasion," a look at how the Fab Four's influence persists. Click through the gallery for more images of the Beatles' first American tour.

Hide Caption

1 of 15

America falls in love with the Beatles15 photos

America falls in love with the Beatles – The Beatles arrive in New York on February 7, 1964. The band from Liverpool, England, already had the No. 1 U.S. single, "I Want to Hold Your Hand," but its U.S. visit confirmed that "Beatlemania" had made its way across the pond.

Hide Caption

2 of 15

America falls in love with the Beatles15 photos

America falls in love with the Beatles – The band waves to cameras at John F. Kennedy International Airport.

Hide Caption

3 of 15

America falls in love with the Beatles15 photos

America falls in love with the Beatles – Beatles fans are restrained by police at the airport.

Hide Caption

4 of 15

America falls in love with the Beatles15 photos

America falls in love with the Beatles – Three of The Beatles -- from left, Ringo Starr, Paul McCartney and John Lennon -- wave from a horse-drawn carriage in New York's Central Park on February 8, 1964. George Harrison was off resting a sore throat.

Hide Caption

5 of 15

America falls in love with the Beatles15 photos

America falls in love with the Beatles – Television host Ed Sullivan, center, stands with The Beatles on February 9, 1964, during a rehearsal for the band's appearance on "The Ed Sullivan Show." The iconic television appearance remains one of the highest-rated nonsports programs of all time. Nielsen estimated that 45% of the country watched the show -- more than 73 million people then.

Hide Caption

6 of 15

America falls in love with the Beatles15 photos

America falls in love with the Beatles – A car belonging to The Beatles is besieged by fans in New York on February 10, 1964.

Hide Caption

7 of 15

America falls in love with the Beatles15 photos

America falls in love with the Beatles – The Beatles have their pictures taken as they sit on a train taking them from New York to Washington on February 11, 1964.

Hide Caption

8 of 15

America falls in love with the Beatles15 photos

America falls in love with the Beatles – The Beatles perform on stage at the Washington Coliseum on February 11, 1964. It was their first U.S. concert.

Hide Caption

9 of 15

America falls in love with the Beatles15 photos

America falls in love with the Beatles – Fans run to catch a glimpse of The Beatles while the band was in New York.

Hide Caption

10 of 15

America falls in love with the Beatles15 photos

America falls in love with the Beatles – Fans cheer for The Beatles and hold signs of encouragement during the band's concert at Carnegie Hall on February 12, 1964, in New York.

Hide Caption

11 of 15

America falls in love with the Beatles15 photos

America falls in love with the Beatles – From left, McCartney, Lennon and Harrison share a microphone as they sing a song at Carnegie Hall.

Hide Caption

12 of 15

America falls in love with the Beatles15 photos

America falls in love with the Beatles – Ecstatic fans await The Beatles outside the Plaza Hotel, where the band was staying in New York during its tour.

Hide Caption

13 of 15

America falls in love with the Beatles15 photos

America falls in love with the Beatles – Lines form down the street from the Deauville Hotel in Miami Beach, Florida, as fans wait to see The Beatles on "The Ed Sullivan Show" on February 16, 1964. It was a week after the band's first appearance on the show.

Hide Caption

14 of 15

America falls in love with the Beatles15 photos

America falls in love with the Beatles – The Beatles enjoy Miami Beach.

Story highlights

He says Beatles created a bridge no one had imagined for youth pop and more adult styles

By 1965, the British Invasion had resegregated the pop and R&B charts, Wald says

The Beatles invented rock music as we know it, and as pretty much everyone has known it since the mid-1960s. But because their success was so revolutionary, it's hard to remember where the music seemed to be headed before they arrived in the United States 50 years ago -- or to imagine what might have happened if they had not.

There are some familiar myths: One is that by 1964 rock 'n' roll had become insipid music dominated by teen idols like Frankie Avalon and Fabian, and the other is that the Beatles introduced white American teenagers to the power of black music. In fact, the rock 'n' roll scene had become increasingly integrated through the early 1960s, to the point that in late 1963 Billboard magazine stopped publishing separate pop and R&B charts because so many of the same records were on both.

The big new sound in rock 'n' roll was Motown, and James Brown was coming up strong, having broken onto the pop charts with his "Live at the Apollo" album.

Elijah Wald

Back then, pop prophets were divided into roughly two camps: Some predicted that African-American artists would increasingly dominate the rock 'n' roll scene, providing a joyously danceable soundtrack to the broader story of a triumphant civil rights movement. Others continued to optimistically predict the demise of rock 'n' roll, pointing to all the young people who were abandoning teen dance music for more mature and intelligent styles like folk and jazz. All agreed that the teens buying rock 'n' roll singles and dancing up a storm to the Supremes were the opposite of the serious folk and jazz fans buying LPs and discussing them endlessly in college dorms.

That divide seemed unbridgeable: People who loved rock 'n' roll thought of it as thrilling, fun, youth music, and expected adults to hate it, while people who appreciated adult styles considered them an antidote to the stupid noise on the radio. The few who imagined rock 'n' roll growing up thought it would take the path of jazz, getting hipper, blacker, and more melodically and harmonically complex. But most people assumed it would remain kid's music and even its most passionate acolytes would grow up to prefer other styles.

No one could have dreamed that rock 'n' roll would be reshaped as a sophisticated British import, or that anyone would want to mingle the already old-fashioned sound of Chuck Berry with baroque string quartets, Indian sitars and avant-garde poetry.

The Beatles were not only unimagined, but unimaginable.

It took the Beatles a couple of years to evolve from peppy rockers to psychedelic culture-trippers, but they transformed Americans' image of rock 'n' roll within hours of stepping off the plane at Kennedy Airport. Previous rockers had been famously inarticulate -- in the movie "Jailhouse Rock," when a group of college professors asked Elvis what he thought of Dave Brubeck, his response was to sullenly slam out of the room, sure that they were laughing at him.

Revoluntionary impact of The Beatles

Just Watched

Working for the Beatles

The Beatles, by contrast, were witty and urbane. When reporters asked them silly questions about their long hair and screaming female fans, they responded with elegant mockery. Their Liverpool accents may have struck Britons as provincial and working class, but to Americans they sounded dazzlingly sophisticated.

The Beatles backed up their exotic charm with brilliant music, but at least for the first couple of years that was somewhat secondary -- witness the success of fellow invaders like Herman's Hermits and the Dave Clarke Five. They had lovely harmonies and interesting melodies, but in retrospect those early records sound no more advanced or earthshaking than what was coming out of Motown, and "Yesterday" sounds positively archaic next to "Papa's Got a Brand New Bag."

The change that redirected the course of American pop was this: By 1965, the year those two records appeared, the British Invasion had resegregated the charts and no one was comparing the Beatles to James Brown. They are remembered as rock 'n' rollers, he is remembered as playing soul and funk. The Brits didn't do that on purpose -- they loved contemporary African-American styles (the Beatles told 16 Magazine that Brown was their favorite singer) -- but they couldn't manage the tricky new rhythms, so they fell back on older varieties of blues and rock 'n' roll.

For dancers, that made their music relatively boring, and after the first wave of Beatlemania the twisting, frugging girls abandoned them for Motown, then moved on to funk and disco.

But their blues-based, guitar-driven sound and increasingly adventurous lyrics created an unexpected bridge to the folk crowd -- they inspired Dylan to go electric, he inspired them to write obscure poetry instead of poppy love lyrics, and rock became music that boys discussed seriously in dorm rooms.

Every revolution has winners and losers. A generation of black musicians remembers the Beatles' arrival as an apocalypse, the moment when rock 'n' roll became white and they were banished to a lower-status ghetto labeled R&B or soul. On the other hand, millions and millions of listeners all around the world remember the Beatles as leveling the divide between high art and street pop, paving the way for 50 years of rock innovation, and making some of the most spectacular music of the 20th century.