Right Angle began as a column in the now-defunct Sunday magazine in November 1991. The column allowed me the luxury of presenting an alternative to the prevailing left-liberal consensus in India. It has become the implicit signature tune for all my subsequent writings.

Friday, April 11, 2014

Family for all seasons: - Congress culture is likely to stay the same whatever happens

By Swapan Dasgupta

There are occasions when a seemingly irrelevant
piece of tittle-tattle assumes greater relevance than a thousand words of
weighty commentary. An innocuous piece of news on the first page of last
Wednesday’s Times of India on the selection of the Congress candidate to
contest against Narendra Modi in Varanasi was such an occasion.

The importance lay not so much in the fact that a
local MLA who had unsuccessfully tried his hand in a Lok Sabha election on a
previous occasion had been given the Congress ticket—thereby ending a fortnight
of purposeless speculation over who would be Modi’s principal rival in
Varanasi. For the beat reporter, the significance of Ajay Rai’s nomination was
that he had been personally blessed by the Congress President Sonia Gandhi and
her daughter Priyanka Vadra. Not only that, Priyanka had given Rai her personal
mobile phone number and asked to get in touch directly with her if he needed
help and facilitation. The reporter’s breathless conclusion was that Priyanka
was increasingly calling the shots in the Congress.

Although purists may balk at the prominence given to
this additional evidence that the brother-sister duo was now in control of the
final leg of the Congress campaign, this piece of trivia was not
inconsequential. Ever since opinion polls and anecdotal reports from the
battleground pointed to the Congress performing far worse than even the party
pessimists imagined was possible, Congress loyalists have been praying and
hoping for a “secret weapon” which would improve the final tally that in turn
would ensure that a future BJP-led government would be inherently fragile. In
the past week, ever since Congress General Secretary Janardhan Dwivedi let the
media in one of the party’s greatest secrets—that in 1990 Rajiv Gandhi had
detected Priyanka’s instinctive feel for politics—the demoralised party had
been hoping that Rahul’s leadership would be bolstered by the involvement of
his sister. Indeed, there were Congress supporters who felt that Priyanka would
be declared as the challenger to Modi in Varanasi. Such a symbolic move, they
felt, would electrify Uttar Pradesh and reopen what was increasingly looking
like a one-sided encounter.

The value addition that Priyanka might possibly
bring to the Congress table need not concern us excessively. In a star-obsessed
campaign, the injection of a lady who, it is said in some quarters, has the
mass touch of her illustrious grandmother, would inevitably shift some focus
from an over-exposed Modi and his insolent rival Arvind Kejriwal. In terms of
dividing the media space a little more equitably, Priyanka’s entry into the
2014 campaign would certainly be of short-term benefit to the Congress. In
1998, when Sonia Gandhi made her political debut, she certainly did shift the
spotlight a little away from Atal Behari Vajpayee. Indeed, Congress supporters
were so buoyant that when I mentioned a particular rally where Vajpayee had
drawn big crowds, a Congress groupie asked me incredulously: “Is anyone even
listening to him any longer?”

However, what strikes me about the excitement over
Priyanka is that even as the Congress stares at the possibility of winning less
than 100 Lok Sabha seats, the only magic wand the party can think of is firmly
located within the dynastic mould. Yes, Congress supporters grudgingly concede,
Rahul Gandhi has proved a political disappointment. He may exude sincerity and
even boast of an unwillingness to be derailed by narrow, tactical
considerations but there is no getting away from his inability to connect. In
the past, a presidential style campaign had always suited the Congress against
a fractured opposition. Indeed, even for the 2014 campaign the Congress
publicity campaign had been planned to project Rahul as the great white hope.
Unfortunately for the Congress, the Modi juggernaut proved too formidable for
those who felt that Rahul would encapsulate the necessary measure of change to
offset anti-incumbency. In the direct Modi versus Rahul battle, the man from
Gujarat was miles ahead. Rahul’s famed sincerity and earnestness came to be
equated with naiveté. Rahul was not disliked; he became an object of mockery,
particularly after his disastrous Times
Now interview. With just a month left of the campaign, the only people who
think that a Rahul-led dispensation can govern India with a measure of
enlightenment are the editors of The
Economist.

The widespread acknowledgment of Rahul’s
inadequacies by the Congress hasn’t, however, triggered preparations for an
upheaval in the party in the event of grim news on May 16. Past experience,
especially of the years the party wasn’t in power at the Centre, has convinced
the average Congress supporter that the leadership of the Gandhi family is a
precondition for both survival and growth. There was a time, particularly after
P.V. Narasimha Rao’s term as Prime Minister, when it seemed that the
Nehru-Gandhi dynasty had run out of steam. Sonia Gandhi’s decision to plunge
into politics in 1998 was, for example, greeted with some scepticism and led to
Sharad Pawar’s revolt. But the unexpectedly good performance in 2004 and the
victory in 2009 established Sonia as a leader in her own right and set her up
as the glue that binds the disparate Congress family.

A Congress failure in 2014 isn’t likely to shake
that fundamental assumption and faith in the leadership of the dynasty is
likely to persist. The belief that Rahul isn’t a natural politician isn’t going
to disappear abruptly and neither will the culture of sycophancy. The
indifferent 2014 results are certain to be blamed on the “non-communicative”
Prime Minister Manmohan Singh—Jairam Ramesh has already given an early
indication of the post-mortem findings. On his part, Rahul will be applauded
for selflessly leading a losing battle and persisting with management systems
that should, hopefully, re-energise the party once the country’s honeymoon with
Modi ends. Most important, the addition of Priyanka into the dynastic pantheon
will definitely placate those Congress leaders who have doubts over Rahul’s
ability to engage in combative politics. Far from breeding a sense of disgust
with the party’s inability to look and think beyond the dynasty, the helping
hand Priyanka is likely to give Rahul seems calculated to retain the family’s
stranglehold over the Congress after the likely defeat in 2014.

There are definite indications that the Gandhi
family isn’t working towards a new political culture that will guarantee there
are no glass ceilings in the path of ability and mass appeal. Reports emanating
from the wider durbar of the first family seem to suggest that there is a fear
in 10 Janpath that a Modi-led government will engage in recriminations in
pursuit of its dream of a Congress-free India. Certainly, the businesses of
Robert Vadra are certainly going to be the subject of some investigations.
Whether these fears are real or contrived is not known. What is important is
that the Gandhi court is readying itself for difficult times in the event of a
Modi victory next month. Between 2000 and 2004, the top BJP leadership had
negotiated a non-aggression pact with Sonia. More than an act of magnanimity,
it was based on the belief that Sonia’s leadership would ensure that the
Congress would remain in the Opposition. It was a horrible misreading of her
potential and it is unlikely this error will be repeated by a new BJP
dispensation.

The Congress top rung, it would seem, has psyched
itself into believing that Modi will repay the viciousness that was directed at
him from 2002. This fear may well explain why the Gandhi family will ensure
that its proprietorship of the Congress will not be modified after the
election.

1 comment:

Anonymous
said...

Since last few years Congress keep on defending RG while asked regarding Gandhi Family. But I am amused on clarity of answer or defence.RG is capable and time will prove, that is why he is VPorWithout Gandhi family Congress will get finished and RG's capability is irrelevant for Congress to survive

About Me

The Right is an endangered community in India's English-language media. I happen to be one of the few to have retained a precarious toehold in the mainstream media. I intend this blog as a sounding board of ideas and concerns.
You can read the details of my education, professional experience and political inclinations on Wikipedia (http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Swapan_Dasgupta).
RIGHT ANGLE is an archive of my published articles. USUAL SUSPECTS is my blog.