Chapter XIVClearing the Coastal Belt and the Ports
September 1944

IN
the early autumn of 1944 several sequences of events important to this history were
proceeding simultaneously in North-West Europe. In the preceding chapter we
abandoned the course of events in the First Canadian Army sector to discuss the higher
direction of the campaign and happenings elsewhere on the front. We must now return to
First Canadian Army and deal with its operations during the month of September. Those
operations themselves were widely dispersed, and it is difficult to describe them even
summarily without occasionally taking some liberties with chronology.

The Advance Beyond the Somme

On 3 September, while the 2nd Canadian Corps was crossing the Somme, the 1st
British Corps was closing in on Le Havre and the Second British Army was speeding
through Brussels on its way to Antwerp, Field-Marshal Montgomery issued another
directive.1
It was brief and general, but it indicated the breadth of the possibilities of the
situation at that moment. His intentions now were, first, "To advance eastwards and
destroy all enemy forces encountered"; and secondly, "To occupy the Ruhr, and get
astride the communications leading from it into Germany and to the sea ports." On 6
September the Second Army was to advance eastwards with its main bodies from the
line Brussels-Antwerp, directed on the Rhine between Wesel and Arnhem. The Ruhr
was to be "by-passed round its northern face, and cut off by a southward thrust through
Hamm". The First U.S. Army, advancing with its two left corps directed successfully
upon the lines Maastricht-Liège, Sittard-Aachen and Cologne-Bonn, would "assist
in cutting off the Ruhr by operations against its south-eastern face, if such action is
desired by Second Army". The Belgian and Dutch contingents, which had been serving
under General Crerar since the moment when the initial advance from the old bridgehead
was undertaken, were now transferred to the Second Army. This was undoubtedly
due to the fact that that army was already operating in Belgium, and would shortly enter
the Netherlands. As for First Canadian Army itself, its tasks

--323--

had already been defined. Now they were summarized in a single somewhat bleak sentence:

Canadian Army will clear the coastal belt, and will then remain in the general area Bruges-Calais
until the maintenance situation allows of its employment further forward.

As we have seen, the Fifteenth Army had had time to occupy the line of the Somme
in the Canadian sector and had destroyed the bridges. However, the rapid advance of the
Second Army on its left imperilled and dismayed the German formation, and it withdrew
from the Somme without offering serious resistance. The necessity of bridging the stream
was the main difficulty encountered by First Canadian Army. Bridging began on the
afternoon of 2 September, the 10th Infantry Brigade crossing the river in the area of Pont
Remy to cover the operation. A "Class 40" bridge (capable of carrying tanks) was
completed here during the morning of the 3rd and by noon the armour of the 4th
Canadian Armoured Division had begun to cross. During the night the Polish Armoured
Division had got part of its infantry across the Somme below Abbeville and repairs were
undertaken to a bridge here to enable tanks to cross.2

The Poles now took the lead of the 2nd Canadian Corps advance and drove
northward without meeting much opposition. By noon of 4 September they were reported
in Hesdin. In accordance with the orders previously issued, the 4th Division concentrated
immediately east of Abbeville to rest and reorganize. The 3rd Canadian Infantry Division
followed the Poles across the Somme and pushed north parallel to the coast. On the
morning of the 4th its 9th Brigade crossed the river Canche near Montreuil and moved on
towards Boulogne.3
Blown bridges on this river and the Authie were making trouble
similar to that met with on the Somme. One of Field-Marshal Montgomery's liaison
officers reported on this day, "The problem facing 2 Cdn Corps at the moment is not
German soldiers but bridging difficulties."

In this phase, indeed, with the Army moving rapidly forward, the Engineers had
constant bridging problems, especially as the First Canadian Army routes crossed the
rivers flowing into the Channel near their mouths, where they were widest. There was a
chronic shortage of bridging equipment during September. Simultaneously the
construction or rehabilitation of airfields in the new areas for the wings of No. 84 Group
was an equally important commitment of the R.C.E. and R.E. units working under the
Army's Chief Engineer (Brigadier Geoffrey Walsh took over this appointment from
Brigadier A. T. MacLean at the beginning of the month). This was likewise a very busy
and exacting period for the Royal Canadian Corps of Signals. By 2 September the Army's
"main signals artery" was complete to Rouen; that day cables were successfully put
across the Seine at Duclair (only to be broken two days later by a ferry dragging its
anchor). On 9 September it was recorded that cable connection had been established with
Headquarters 2nd Corps at Cassel; the Corps now had speech and teleprinter
communication with Army "after being entirely on wireless for
one week".4
Mere distance was a serious problem for commanders and staffs, and particularly for
Army Headquarters. General Crerar in the second week of September

--324--

Sketch 25.--The Coastal Belt4-12 September 1944

--325--

was directing operations from Le Havre in the south to Bruges and Ghent in the north, a
front of nearly 200 miles. Fortunately, his light Auster aircraft gave him the means of
maintaining personal contact with his two corps commanders as well as with Field-Marshal Montgomery.

Early in September we had not yet appreciated that the Germans intended to fight for
the Channel Ports; air reconnaissance had reported the Boulogne, Calais and Dunkirk
areas "deserted",5
and indeed, as we have seen, it was only on 4 September that Hitler
issued his order for defence (above, page 301). On the evening of the 4th General
Simonds sent a directive6
to his divisional commanders emphasizing the objects of
pursuit to the Scheldt and destruction or capture of all enemy south of the river within the
Army boundary. The 2nd Canadian Division when it moved forward was to clear the
coastal strip from Dunkirk to the Dutch frontier. The 3rd Canadian Division, having been
previously directed to push through to the Dunkirk area (above,
page 303), was now
merely ordered to ensure that the 2nd Division's route was clear and thereafter to
reorganize about Calais. But by the night of the 5th-6th the 3rd Division had come up
against the landward defences of Boulogne and established that the enemy was holding
hard there. A momentary intention to contain Boulogne with one brigade while the
balance of the division pushed on to Calais and
Dunkirk7
was quickly abandoned, and
soon after midnight a divisional operation order8
was issued: the 3rd Canadian Infantry
Division was now to "capture Boulogne and destroy its garrison". The 7th Brigade was
pushed on to seize high ground south-west of Calais and cover the flank of the operation.

On 5 September the Polish Armoured Division occupied St. Omer; on the 6th it
crossed the Franco-Belgian frontier and overcame enemy resistance at Ypres and
Passchendaele-names famous in an earlier war; on the 7th it reached Roulers. In the
meantime the refreshed 4th Canadian Armoured Division had resumed the advance early
on the 6th and pushed forward from St. Omer on the Poles' left, directed on Bruges and
Eecloo. Organized in two ad hoc battle groups named after Brigadier Moncel of the 4th
Armoured Brigade and Lt.-Col. J. D. Stewart, who was commanding the 10th Infantry
Brigade in Brigadier Jefferson's absence through illness, the division pushed forward
rapidly. On 8 September it came up against the next German delaying position, the Ghent
Canal, a meandering waterway connecting historic Ghent (which the Second British
Army had reached but not cleared on 5 September) and the beautiful old city
of Bruges.9
The bridges were down, and the enemy intended to make full use of the obstacle to hold
up our advance to the Scheldt.

On the evening of the 8th The Argyll and Sutherland Highlanders of Canada
(Princess Louise's) launched the division's attack across the canal near Moerbrugge, some
three miles south of Bruges. The unit diary remarks drily, "Apparently it was considered
that the crossing would be a routine matter, since no boating material was brought up,
and no serious artillery programme was laid on." The Argylls however found two large
punts and used them for the crossing. Mortar and 88-mm. fire came down, and the
battalion suffered severely.

--326--

Nevertheless, at midnight it was "still clinging, rather precariously" to its narrow
bridgehead on the further side. Fortunately, the Canadian attack had been made at the
junction between the 245th and 711th German Infantry Divisions'
sectors,10
which tended
to delay the enemy's counter-measures. In the early hours of the 9th The Lincoln and
Welland Regiment joined the Argylls in the bridgehead and the two units repulsed
strenuous German efforts to dislodge them. During the day the sappers struggled to build
a bridge; but in the words of the division's General Staff diarist, "For the first time since
we left the Falaise area the enemy was able to put down a truly effective concentration of
fire with the result that the engineers could not get the bridge across in daylight."
However, it was duly completed during the night, and early on 10 September a squadron
of the 29th Armoured Reconnaissance Regiment (The South Alberta Regiment) crossed
to support the infantry. During the day the bridgehead was gradually extended and large
numbers of prisoners were taken; but the ground and the closeness of the country ("much
closer than the map indicates") made progress slow.11

On 9 September, and again on the night of the 10th-11th, the Poles attempted to force
the Ghent Canal on their own front in the area north-west of Aeltre, roughly halfway
between Bruges and Ghent. Steep banks and deep water, combined with unfavourable
conditions for artillery observation, lack of assault craft and heavy German opposition
rendered the efforts fruitless. They were abandoned; and on the 11th, as the result of a
decision by higher authority to regroup (below, page 330), the Poles moved to the Ghent
area to relieve the 7th British Armoured Division.12

In the meantime, the 2nd Canadian Infantry Division, left behind at Dieppe to refit,
had also begun to move forward again on 6 September. After concentrating west of St.
Omer it began its task in the coastal area; since it was now clear that Calais as well as
Boulogne was going to be defended, and the 3rd Division would have its hands full there,
the whole coast from just east of Calais, including Dunkirk, now fell to
the 2nd.13
On 7-8 September Brigadier Megill's 5th Infantry Brigade captured Bourbourg, south-west of
Dunkirk, and was then instructed to contain the Dunkirk garrison, estimated to be some
10,000 strong, which held a wide perimeter of outposts in the villages of
Mardick, Loon-Plage, Spycker, Bergues and Bray Dunes.14

The Calgary Highlanders had begun operations against Loon-Plage--"a very slow,
tedious and costly job"--on 7 September.15
They ran into very heavy opposition and
before long each of their forward companies was reduced to a strength of only 30. Their
diary says on the 8th, "We must give great credit to the artillery and heavy mortars, plus
our own mortars, for the very valuable support they gave us throughout the attack."
Eventually the enemy withdrew and Loon-Plage was occupied on the morning of the 9th.
Simultaneously, The Black Watch (Royal Highland Regiment) of Canada occupied
nearby Coppenaxfort with the help of the 8th Reconnaissance Regiment. The inhabitants'
celebrations were, unfortunately, abruptly terminated by the enemy's
mortars.16
During the following week the 5th Brigade's activities were mainly limited

--327--

to probing the defences of Dunkirk and patrolling. Civilians contributed much useful
information on the enemy's dispositions. The troops remained under fairly severe and
consistent shellfire, some of which was believed to come from heavy guns in Dunkirk.
This static phase soon became trying, and a disgruntled diarist remarked: "We are really
getting fed up with the monotony of this job--a somewhat depressing business." The
brigade learned on 15 September that the entire division would shortly move to the
Antwerp sector. Its last operation before Dunkirk was the capture of Mardick on the
17th.17

In the meantime, east of Dunkirk, in the area of the Franco-Belgian border, the 6th
Brigade, now commanded by Brigadier J. G. Gauvreau, occupied Fumes, Nieuport and
La Panne. The South Saskatchewan Regiment at Nieuport received great assistance from
the Belgian White Brigade, the national resistance movement, which furnished exact
information concerning the enemy's strength, defences and
minefields.18

West of La Panne The Queen's Own Cameron Highlanders of Canada occupied
German coast defences, gaining shelter from the enemy's artillery. On 12 September the
6th Brigade was directed against Bray Dunes and Bray Dunes Plage. During the next two
days the Camerons made several unsuccessful attempts to capture this area. Aided by
Typhoon aircraft and a supplementary operation by the South Saskatchewan, they finally
cleared it on the 15th. Simultaneously, Les Fusiliers Mont-Royal, whose C.O. was now
Lt.-Col. J. M. P. Sauve, took the nearby village of Ghyvelde, where they had been
repulsed in earlier attempts.19
But the enemy showed no sign of relaxing his grip on
Dunkirk, and the place could have been taken only by a major attack with heavy support.

Brigadier Cabeldu's 4th Brigade, initially in reserve, had moved north on 9
September and occupied Ostend.* This not inconsiderable port had not been mentioned
in Hitler's directive of 4 September, and the Germans did not defend it, although the
fortifications, including large concrete gun-positions with excellent fields of fire,
impressed our troops as formidable. However, the harbour installations had been partly
demolished, and the necessity of dealing with mines and sunken ships imposed delay on
the use of the port. From 28 September, pending the opening of Antwerp, stores and bulk
petrol flowed in through Ostend to alleviate the maintenance
problem.20

Just east of Nieuport The Essex Scottish Regiment laid siege on 10 September to a
coastal gun position of great strength. "What had appeared to be sand dunes were
concrete dugouts and emplacements covered with sand. The position commanded all the
surrounding country." But the Essex brought so hot a fire against it--with the help of
mortars and anti-tank and Bofors guns, as well as other supporting artillery--that the
garrison surrendered on the 12th. The Commanding Officer (Lt.-Col. P. W. Bennett)
recorded that 316 prisoners had been taken, at a cost to the Essex of two killed and three
wounded, and that "the booty was absolutely terrific".21

While the Essex were thus engaged, the remaining battalions of the 4th

*The 18th Armoured Car Regiment had been in Ostend the day before.
It had also anticipated the 6th Brigade in Nieuport.

--328--

Brigade moved to the southern outskirts of Bruges to assist the 4th Armoured Division in
that sector. Fortunately, the enemy withdrew without contesting possession of the city,
and on 12 September elements of the 4th Infantry Brigade entered it on the heels of the
18th Armoured Car Regiment (12th Manitoba Dragoons).* The enthusiasm of the
citizens knew no bounds; the diarist of The Royal Hamilton Light Infantry remarked, "the
people on seeing the vehicles became delirious and literally thousands of people swarmed
about and prevented the vehicles from moving for close to an hour". The brigade now
turned south again to attack Bergues, a key feature of Dunkirk's outer defences. But the
area was badly flooded and an attack on the 15th by the R.H.L.I. bogged down. Then,
even as the brigade was preparing to move with the remainder of the 2nd Division to
Antwerp, the enemy withdrew and the 8th Reconnaissance Regiment was able to occupy
Bergues on the morning of 16 September.23

The Need for the Channel Ports

Meanwhile, the changes in strategy described in the last chapter had begun to be
reflected in the orders issued to the First Canadian Army. They appeared first in
decreased emphasis upon the pursuit to the Scheldt and greater emphasis upon the
capture of the Channel Ports. Subsequently the demand for the opening of Antwerp came
to the fore.

We have seen Field-Marshal Montgomery's Chief of Staff, on 6 September, calling
attention to the importance of getting the port of Boulogne (above,
page 310). That
evening the C.-in-C. duly signalled to General Crerar:24

Would be very grateful for your opinion on the likelihood of
early capture of Boulogne. It looks as if
port of Antwerp may be unusable for some time as Germans
are holding islands at mouth of Scheldt.
Immediate opening of some port north of Dieppe essential
for rapid development of my plan and I want
Boulogne badly. What do you think are the chances of getting it soon.

This was delayed in transmission, but Crerar was already working on
the problem25
and as we have seen the 3rd Canadian Division issued orders that same night for operations
against Boulogne.

We have also seen (above,
page 310) that on 9 September Montgomery calculated
that, with the ports of Dieppe, Boulogne, Dunkirk and Calais and some help from Le
Havre, he could go to Berlin; with one good Pas de Calais port plus airlift and extra motor
transport, he could go to "the Münster triangle". At this time he saw the Canadian Army's
tasks as, first priority, capture of Boulogne; second priority, capture of Dunkirk; take over
the Ghent area and clear the enemy pocket north of Ghent; then, as "last priority",
"examine and carry out the reduction of the islands guarding the entrance
to Antwerp".26
On the morning of the 9th General Crerar flew to the Field-Marshal's headquarters for a
conference at which Generals Dempsey and Hodges were also present. Crerar's

*The regiment, normally part of 2nd Canadian Corps Troops,
had one squadron. under the command of the 4th
Division during the pursuit. This hard-driving squadron
reported that, at times, it was up to 40 miles ahead of the
division.22

--329--

diary notes briefly, "Decisions affecting First Cdn Army were reached, i.e., speedy capture
of Channel Ports within First Cdn Army boundary." Later in the day Crerar issued a
directive to his corps commanders.27
This underlined the maintenance difficulties which
were being encountered and which rendered it impossible to press on as quickly and as
powerfully "as the very favourable military situation urgently demands". Crerar proceeded:

It follows that a speedy and victorious conclusion to the war now depends, fundamentally, upon the
capture by First Cdn Army of the Channel ports which have now become so essential, if the
administrative problem is to be solved, i.e. Le Havre, Boulogne, Dunkirk, Calais and generally in
that order of importance.

1 Brit Corps will attack and capture Le Havre on 10/11 Sep--unless unfavourable weather entails
a further delay. On the completion of this important operation 1 Brit Corps will re-organize and reequip
in the vicinity of Le Havre, pending an improvement in the administrative situation which
will permit the movement of this formation to the Eastern sector of First Cdn Army area.

2 Cdn Corps has already been directed to proceed, without delay, to capture Boulogne, Dunkirk and
Calais, preferably in that order, but without prejudice to the earlier and easier capture of anyone of
them. If no weakness in the defences of these ports is discovered, and decisively exploited, in the
course of operational reconnaissance--then a deliberate attack, with full fire support, will require to
be staged, in each case.

In view of the necessity to give first priority to the capture of the Channel ports, mentioned above,
the capture, or destruction, of the enemy remaining North and East of the Ghent-Bruges Canal
becomes secondary in importance. While constant pressure and close contact with the enemy, now
withdrawing North of R Schelde, will be maintained, important forces will not be committed to
offensive action.

During 10 September the 2nd Canadian Corps was to take over Ghent from the 12th British
Corps. Thereafter the inter-Army boundary would be adjusted to give First Canadian Army the
left bank of the Scheldt as far east as the Dutch border where it crossed the river north-west of
Antwerp. The directive ended by stating that the responsibility of No. 84 Group R.A.F. was
now extended to include the Dutch islands of South and North Beveland and Walcheren.
"Every effort is to be made to interfere with, and destroy, the enemy now in process of ferrying
himself across R Schelde to these islands."

The absence from this directive of any direct reference to the opening of Antwerp
suggests that Field-Marshal Montgomery had mentioned it either not at all or merely as
a task of the distant future. This situation, however, was soon to change. At their
conference at Brussels on 10 September Eisenhower seems to have impressed upon
Montgomery his desire for the opening of Antwerp, although he agreed to some delay
for the sake of Operation "MARKET-GARDEN"
(above, page 312). Thereafter Antwerp
assumed a rather higher official priority, at least, in the planning of the 21st Army
Group.28
It is of interest also, and perhaps of some importance, that at this same moment
the Combined Chiefs of Staff, meeting at Quebec, on the motion of Field-Marshal Sir
Alan Brooke urged General Eisenhower to make energetic efforts to open Antwerp.
Eisenhower had reported his immediate plans, which the conference record summarizes
as follows: "The Supreme Commander's first operation will be one to break the Siegfried
line and seize crossings over the Rhine
['MARKET-GARDEN']. In doing this his main effort
will be on the left. He will then prepare logistically and otherwise

--330--

for a deep thrust into Germany." On 12 September the Combined Chiefs agreed
to send Eisenhower a telegram, drafted by Brooke, which concurred in his plans but drew
his attention

"to the advantage of the northern line of approach into Germany, as opposed to the southern, and

"to the necessity for the opening up of the north-west ports, particularly Antwerp and Rotterdam,
before bad weather sets in."29

The changing emphasis was reflected in a signal from Montgomery to Crerar sent
early on 12 September:30

Delighted to hear about good progress at Havre. When you have encircled [sic] concentrate everything
on Boulogne. The early opening of the port of Antwerp is daily becoming of increasing importance and
this cannot repeat cannot take place until Walcheren has been captured and the mouth of the river
opened for navigation. Before you can do this you will obviously have to remove all enemy from the
mainland in that part where they holding up [sic] north east of Bruges. Airborne army considers not
possible use airborne troops in the business. Grateful for your views as to when you think you can tackle
this problem. . . .

The following day, in the same letter which informed Crerar of the
"MARKET-GARDEN" plan
(above, page 312)
Montgomery raised the question of Antwerp in a more urgent form (below, page 336).
The planning of the operations to open Antwerp can best be dealt with
in the next chapter; at this point it is most appropriate to concentrate upon those directed
against the Channel Ports. It should be emphasized, however, that from 12 September
onward the planning for the Scheldt operations, representing a great enlargement of the
tasks of First Canadian Army, complicated its operations. When on 13 September
Montgomery asked Crerar whether he could capture Boulogne, Dunkirk and Calais, and
simultaneously set in motion operations to open the port of Antwerp, he was in fact
setting him, as is now obvious, a task far beyond the limited resources of his Army.

Operation "ASTONIA": The Capture of Le Havre

The first of the Channel Ports to be captured by First Canadian Army was
Le Havre, which was taken by Lieut.-General Sir John Crocker's 1st British Corps
in a neat and expeditious three-day operation in the second week of September.
As has been explained, the capture of Le Havre had been assigned to Crocker
well before the end of August, and his leading troops came up against the city's
outer defences on 2 September. It soon became evident that the place was
garrisoned and that the Germans intended to offer a strong defence; but a heavy scale of
support, by air and sea as well as by land, was clearly required, and obtaining and
coordinating these various resources took time. The assault could not be undertaken for
over a week.

Le Havre had long been a city of much commercial and military significance and
had figured prominently in the old Anglo-French wars. In modem times it had become a
very important mercantile port and just before the Second World

--331--

War it ranked second only to Marseilles among French ports in terms of shipping
handled. In the first week of September 1944 it was already far behind the new
battlefront; nevertheless, if it could be captured quickly without serious damage to the
harbour installations, the pressure on the Allied supply lines would be reduced and the
momentum of the pursuit could be better maintained.

The place had considerable natural strength. It was surrounded by water on three
sides: on the west by the Channel, on the east by the flooded valley of the Lézarde River,
and on the south by the Seine estuary and the Canal de Tancarville. On the land side high
ground at Octeville-sur-Mer overlooked the northern approaches, which were also
protected by minefields and a deep anti-tank ditch. However, although the city was
heavily fortified against naval attack, the landward defences were incomplete. A
defensive line ran west of and roughly parallel to the Lézarde, turning west at
Montivilliers to reach the coast by way of Doudenéville and Octeville; the Germans
considered this latter sector the weakest part of the front. They had large artillery
resources. Apart from the coastal guns, most of which could fire only to seaward, and
which included one 380-mm. (14.8-inch) and two 170-mm. guns in the Grand Clos
battery north of the city, there were 44 medium and field guns and 32 anti-aircraft guns.
The fact that some of these were of French or Czech manufacture complicated the
problem of ammunition supply.31

The fortress of Le Havre had been commanded since mid-August 1944 by Colonel
Eberhard Wildermuth, not a regular soldier but an officer of wide experience. He later
estimated the effective strength of his garrison as about 8000, although the total strength,
as indicated by the number of prisoners finally taken, was well over 11,000. It comprised
a fortress cadre unit (Festungs Stamm Abteilung); some units of the 226th and 245th
Infantry Divisions; a battalion of the 5th Security Regiment; and naval elements. The
defenders were hampered by the presence in the city of some 50,000 French civilians, the
remnant of the peacetime population of over 160,000.32

Before the assault the defences were "softened" by a series of coordinated naval and
air bombardments. The 1st Corps had been authorized to communicate directly with
Bomber Command and the Navy. On 5 September H.M. Monitor Erebus engaged the
defences with her two 15-inch guns, but the Grand Clos battery hit her and forced her to
withdraw. She bombarded again on the 8th but was again hit.33
The R.A.F Bomber
Command also began its attacks on the 5th in daylight, when 348 aircraft dropped 1880
tons on the port area and gun positions. On the night of the 6th-7th there was another
attack in roughly the same strength, and on the 8th a day attack during which 109 aircraft
bombed. A considerable raid attempted the next day was frustrated by the weather. All
told, before the day the ground assault began Bomber Command had put down some
4000 tons of explosive on Le Havre.34

Sir John Crocker decided to launch his Corps against the northern outskirts of Le
Havre immediately after a large-scale attack by Bomber Command, with the 51st
(Highland) Division on the right and the 49th (West Riding) Division on the left. In the
opening phase the 49th Division, with the 34th Tank Brigade

--332--

Sketch 26.--Le Havre: Operation ASTONIA10-12 September 1944

--333--

under command, would seize the northern plateau which lies west of the Lézarde River
and south-west of Montivilliers. The 51st Division, with the 33rd Armoured Brigade,
would then secure a base farther west, on the northern edge of the Forêt de Montgeon,
while the 49th Division pushed on south to capture another plateau looking across the
Lézarde towards Harfleur. In the final stages the 51st would deal with the defences near
Octeville, obtaining control of dominating ground on the northern outskirts, and, together
with the 49th, would crush any remaining resistance in
the city.35
"ASTONIA" was
originally scheduled to begin on 9 September, but weather interference with the bombing
programme necessitated a postponement of 24 hours on
7 September.36

Before the infantry assault the defences, particularly the battery positions, were
heavily shelled. The divisional artilleries of the 1st Corps were supplemented by six
medium and two heavy regiments of the 4th and 9th Army Groups, Royal Artillery. The
artillery programme included counter-flak fire (known as
"APPLE PIE") during our bomber
operations.37

The 10th of September, the Le Havre D Day, began with an attack by 65 aircraft of
Bomber Command on the Grand Clos battery.38
Then Erebus renewed the naval
bombardment in partnership with the battleship Warspite, their targets being "casemated
guns on perimeter defences of Havre". The Grand Clos battery came to life but this time
scored no hits. "Erebus was particularly successful being awarded 30 hits out of about
130 rounds by the spotting aircraft."39Warspite fired 304 rounds and is reported to have
finally silenced Grand Clos. Both ships received the warm thanks of
General Crocker.40

At 4:15 p.m. the main Bomber Command attack began, the first wave of aircraft
dropping its load on the western defence area of Le Havre, the second bombing the
northern belt of defences running west from Montivilliers. Later in the day the southern
plateau was bombed. All told, 932 aircraft took part in this terrifying demonstration of
Allied air power, and 4719 tons of bombs were
dropped.41
Examination later indicated
that the bombing had done considerable damage to batteries with open emplacements,
much less to concrete positions. However, available evidence indicates that the German
garrison (unlike the civilian population, unfortunately) suffered few casualties because of
their deep underground shelters. Indeed, the Fortress Commandant afterwards claimed
that the naval and air bombardment had "only a general destructive effect" and that the
most damaging fire was the counter-battery activity of the
Army artillery.42

At 5:45 p.m., immediately following the cessation of the bombing of the northern
defences, the 49th Division began the ground assault. Preceded by "Flail" tanks of the 22nd
Dragoons, which breached a minefield west of Montivilliers, the 56th Infantry Brigade
captured the northern plateau and secured bridges over the Fontaine River (a tributary of
the Lézarde) during the same night.43
These operations were greatly assisted by other
specialized assault equipment, in particular "Crocodiles",
AVREs and "Kangaroos" from
the 79th British Armoured Division. The "Kangaroos",
first used in Operation "TOTALIZE"
(above, page 210),
were manned at Le Havre by the 1st Canadian Armoured Personnel

--334--

Carrier Squadron.* In the opening phase of "ASTONIA"
they transported British infantry to
the area of their objectives, thereafter assisting the troops in mopping up and exploitation.
The Corps Commander later paid tribute to the "Kangaroos", observing that they "saved
many casualties from small arms and especially enemy harassing
fire".45

At midnight the 51st Division advanced on the 49th's right or western flank and, with
the help of artificial moonlight, began clearing the area north of the Forêt de Montgeon.
The anti-tank ditch hampered progress forward and the evacuation of casualties to the
rear.46
Nevertheless, the 51st made such good progress, reducing strongpoints and
capturing prisoners, that on the morning of the 11th their divisional commander decided
to carry out the third phase of "ASTONIA" at once, by eliminating the German gun areas
west of the Forêt de Montgeon. Meanwhile, the British counter-battery programme had
greatly reduced the number of German field, medium and anti-aircraft guns still capable
of firing.47

Early in the morning of 11 September Bomber Command made its final attack on Le
Havre, 146 aircraft dropping 742 tons of bombs on the western part of the town. In the
course of the day rocket-firing Typhoons made successful attacks on strongpoints in the
south-eastern sector. General Crocker signalled to Air Chief Marshal Harris thanking
Bomber Command for the "absolute accuracy of bombing and timing on every
occasion".48
On this day the 49th Division captured the southern plateau, on the eastern
outskirts of Le Havre, as well as an area east of the Lézarde, near Harfleur. In this latter
sector the 146th Infantry Brigade had to deal with several strongpoints covering the main
road into Le Havre, all well protected by minefields. The infantry suffered severe
casualties from mines when they attacked; later tanks and some "Flails" were brought
forward to assist and the strongpoints were finally subdued on the afternoon of 11
September.49

The stage was now set for the final act. Advancing rapidly through the eastern parts
of the city, the 49th Division reached the vicinity of the old fort of Sanvic (Fort de
Tourneville) by nightfall on the 11th. From the northern outskirts the 51st also forced
their way in, their route blocked in places by debris from the bombing, and by evening
were on the high ground at La H&grave;eve overlooking the Channel. It was evident that the
enemy's resistance was collapsing, for prisoners gave themselves up in large numbers. On
the morning of the 12th Colonel Wildermuth lay wounded in the dugout of his battle
headquarters. The garrison's situation was hopeless. The 49th Division took Fort de
Tourneville. British infantry and armour were closing in, the terrible artillery fire
continued, and there were no German anti-tank guns left. When a squadron of the 7th
Royal Tank Regiment menaced his headquarters just before noon, Wildermuth
surrendered. He afterwards complimented the British troops on their "correct and
gentlemanly behaviour" towards the wounded and prisoners. Throughout the

*This squadron had been organized on 28 August and was
equipped with the "unfrocked Priests" used in the Falaise
operations. In the following October the 1st Canadian
Armoured Personnel Carrier Regiment (two squadrons) was
organized under the command of Lt.Col. G.M. Churchill.
It was equipped with converted Canadian "Ram" tanks
("Kangaroos").44
It operated as a unit of General HobartŐs 79th British Armoured Division.

--335--

remainder of the 12th sporadic fighting continued. The 51st Division captured Fort Ste. Adresse
and cleared the Doudenéville-Octeville area and La Hève
the 49th cleared the docks and the
Schneider works. The last resistance was offered by a small party on one of
the quays.50

Forty-eight hours had sufficed to reduce Le Havre. The number of prisoners was
reported as 11,302;51
while the casualties of the 1st British Corps for the period of the
assault were (according to the best available figures)
only 388.52
Much of the success of
"ASTONIA" was undoubtedly due to the bombardment of the defences by the Royal
Artillery, the Royal Air Force and the Royal Navy. The Germans had offered a
respectable but not a fanatical defence; a British observer wrote,
"Without . . . a halfhearted
garrison and a thorough subjugation of hostile artillery, success would have been
less rapid and much more costly."53

The enemy had carried out systematic demolitions to delay Allied use of the harbour.
The job was in fact so thoroughly done that shipping could not use it until
9 October.54
SHAEF had allotted the port to the maintenance of the American armies, and this the
British did not object to, since it was almost as far behind the front as the Rear
Maintenance Area at Bayeux.55
What Field Marshal Montgomery now wanted was the
Channel Ports, and particularly Boulogne (above, page 329). In his letter of 13 September
to General Crerar,56
he wrote,

things that are now very important are:

Capture of Boulogne and Dunkirk and Calais.

The setting in motion of operations designed to enable us to use the port of Antwerp.

Of these two things, (b) is probably the most important. . . .

The same evening, Montgomery signalled Crerar, "Early use of Antwerp so urgent that I am
prepared to give up operations against Calais and Dunkirk and be content with Boulogne. If we
do this will it enable you to speed up the Antwerp
business?"57
In his directive of 14 September
(above, page 313)
the Field Marshal prescribed the tasks of First Canadian Army as follows:

Complete the capture first of Boulogne, and then of Calais.

Dunkirk will be left to be dealt with later; for the present it will be merely masked.

The whole energies of the Army will be directed towards operations designed to enable full use to
be made of the port of Antwerp. . . .

Leaving the Antwerp operations aside for the moment, we must now deal with the
Canadian operations against the northern Channel Ports.

Operation "WELLHIT": The Capture of Boulogne

General Spry's 3rd Canadian Infantry Division had come up against the
defences of Boulogne on 5 September and that night issued a preliminary order
concerning the capture of the place (above, page 326). But the town was far too
strong to be taken without a deliberate attack and heavy support; and this meant
delay. It is recorded that General Simonds considered "bombers, Priests [armoured
personnel carriers] and medium artillery as vital to plan"; "other

--336--

gadgets" were desirable but not so much so as to necessitate postponing the attack to wait
for them.58
But Bomber Command, the armoured carriers and a great force of artillery*
were all committed to the attack on Le Havre; and Boulogne could not be attacked until
Le Havre fell and these resources were freed. From one fortress to the other was roughly
135 miles by road.

Boulogne was ringed on the landward side by a series of high hills which dominated
all approaches. Mont Lambert on the east, in particular, rose 550 feet; and farther south
the Herquelingue "feature" was almost as high. These and other positions had been
heavily fortified by a resourceful enemy, for Boulogne had been on Hitler's original list
of "fortresses" (above,
page 50).
The garrison was under an able and experienced senior
officer, Lieut.-General Ferdinand Heim, who had served in Poland as Chief of Staff to
General Guderian and had risen to command a corps in Russia. Its strength (estimated by
our local intelligence as between 5500 and 7000)† was actually
about 10,000.59
Its quality
was not especially high, the 2000 infantry consisting of a fortress machine-gun battalion
and two fortress infantry battalions, all made up of low-category men. A good part of the
artillery and engineer personnel of the 64th Infantry Division were
present.60
As at Le
Havre, the enemy was strong in artillery, the guns including coast-defence pieces up to
30.5-cm. (12-inch), of which however many could not fire landward, and at least 22 88mm.
guns, plus about nine 15-cm. howitzers belonging to the 64th Division. Apart from
the dual-purpose 88s there were few
anti-tank guns.61
Under German orders some 8000
civilians left the city between 11 and 13 September--Canadian Civil Affairs officers
making efficient arrangements for transporting, feeding and
housing them.62

The attack on Boulogne, Operation "WELLHIT", was to be executed in four phases.
General Spry intended to launch his main assault from the east against the general area of
Mont Lambert, using the 8th and 9th Infantry Brigade Groups, after a heavy preliminary
bombardment by aircraft and artillery. In the second phase the two brigades would secure
the centre of the built-up area and, it was hoped, seize a crossing over the Liane River
before the bridges could be blown. The third phase would see the capture of outlying
strongpoints at Fort de la Crèche, Outreau and Herquelingue; the fourth, the capture of
Nocquet on the coast and the heights of
St. Etienne.63

The preparations for aerial bombardment reflected the views of the Army
Commander, who on 13 September wrote to Field-Marshal
Montgomery:64

While the rapid fall of Le Havre has favourable potential
influences, it is most important that the effect
so gained should not be more than lost by an unsuccessful
attack on the next objective, Boulogne. I,
therefore, want Simonds to button things up properly,
taking a little more time, if necessary, in order to
ensure a decisive assault.

*Of the three Canadian medium regiments in the theatre,
only one (the 7th) was immediately available to the 3rd
Canadian Infantry Division. The 3rd, which had been refitting
south of the Somme, arrived in the Boulogne area on 8
September. The 4th was supporting the Polish Armoured Division in Belgium.

†These are the figures given in a 3rd Division
intelligence summary dated 13 September. On the same day, however,
General Crerar, writing to Field-Marshal Montgomery,
estimated the garrison more accurately at 10,000.

--337--

The bomber support was in fact the last part of the programme to be settled. A hoped-for
meeting with a representative of the R.A.F. Bomber Command did not materialize on 14
September; H.Q. First Canadian Army complained, "Whole affair now held up awaiting
his arrival."65
But on the 15th General Simonds, his own Chief of Staff and General
Crerar's, and the Senior Air Staff Officer of No. 84 Group, flew to Headquarters Allied
Expeditionary Air Force at Versailles and duly "buttoned up" the question of air support
at both Boulogne and Calais. The first discussions were not particularly satisfactory, it is
true; two air vicemarshals, one of whom was from Bomber Command, were reluctant "to
use more than 300-400 R.A.F. [heavy] Bombers for each port", counting on
supplementing this effort with mediums. But when Air Chief Marshals Tedder, Harris
and Leigh-Mallory arrived "for another meeting" the Corps Commander seized the opportunity
and put his case to them. All three "agreed with little hesitation that if Boulogne
and Calais were to be captured forthwith and air support was necessary, then it should be
given in full measure". The details were worked out
at once.66
Next day General Spry
announced that the "WELLHIT" D Day would be
17 September.67
Thus the assault on
Boulogne went in on the same day as the greater operation at Eindhoven, Nijmegen and Arnhem.

During the final stage of preparation, particularly after the fall of Le Havre, the
tactical air forces were directed against Boulogne. All told, there were 49 attacks, before
the assault, by mediums, fighter-bombers and rocket-firing
Typhoons.68
Their main
targets were battery positions; these were also engaged by the gradually growing force of
artillery deployed around Boulogne, but ammunition shortages
prevented heavy counter-battery fire before the actual day of
the assault.69
Ultimately 328 guns were used against
the fortress: those of five field, seven medium, three heavy and two heavy anti-aircraft
regiments.* The 9th British Army Group Royal Artillery and the divisional artillery of
the 51st (Highland) Division, both of which had hurried up from Le Havre, joined with
the Canadian gunners in this operation. Since this great force of artillery was supporting
the 3rd Canadian Division, the responsibility for coordinating and directing the effort
rested mainly upon the 3rd Division's artillery commander, Brigadier
P. A. S. Todd.70

There was potent artillery help also from across the Channel. The Brigadier Royal
Artillery, First Canadian Army (Brigadier H. O. N. Brownfield) flew to England and
arranged for the mammoth guns on the South Foreland east of Dover to fire on the German
cross-Channel batteries in the Calais-Cape Gris Nez area, to prevent them from interfering
with the attack on Boulogne. Two 14-inch guns ("WINNIE"
and "POOH") manned by the
Royal Marine Siege Regiment, and two 15-inch manned by the 540th Coast Regiment
R.A., came into action, firing with air observation; it may be noted at once that after some
preliminary shooting on the 16th they fired actively and accurately on the 17th. The
German battery positions were hit repeatedly; and one of the 15-inch guns scored a direct

*The 12th Canadian Field and 3rd Canadian Medium Regiments
were supporting the 7th Infantry Brigade in front of
Calais, and did not fire on Boulogne. All three heavy,
five of the medium and one of the H.A.A. regiments were British.

--338--

Reproduced by Army Survey Establishment
Compiled and drawn by Historical Section G.S.
The Capture of Boulogne17-22 September 1944

hit on one of the 16-inchers of the great German Noires Mottes battery near Sangatte, the
range being about 42,000 yards, or over 23 miles. The 15-inch guns fired this day until
their old barrels were so worn that they could no longer reach the French coast. The 14inch
were in action again on 19 and 20 September. Both the army and marine units
cooperated with enthusiasm and shot with a skill that earned the Canadians'
admiration.71

At 8:25 a.m. on 17 September the first aircraft from Bomber Command appeared over
Boulogne. An officer who was watching from high ground south of the city* described
the scene:72

The bombers approached us head on: suddenly huge bursts
of dust and smoke plumed out on the slopes
of Mount Lambert . . . Over the peak of
Mount Lambert appeared a tight concentration of low [artillery]
air bursts, designed to keep the flak crews there
below ground. . . . A later wave of bombers, directed on
the peak of the mount was preceded by a Pathfinder
which dropped a white smoke marker. The arty
seemed also to lay smoke here. A swarm of planes then
materialized out of the sky as before, and once
again huge clouds of smoke blotted out the shape of the hill-top.

In this single attack Bomber Command dropped 3232 tons of bombs on Boulogne. Five
hundred and forty Lancasters, 212 Halifaxes and 40 Mosquitoes took part; in spite of the
artillery fire directed on the flak positions, two aircraft were lost. An R.A.F. group captain was
with Brigadier Rockingham in his tactical headquarters dug in on his brigade's start-line. He was
in radio communication with the master bomber overhead, and was able to pass to him the
brigadier's confirmation that the markers put down by the pathfinder aircraft were on precisely
the right points. This was "close cooperation"
at its best.73

As at Le Havre, the precise results of this bombardment are a matter of discussion.
General Heim claimed that "amongst personnel, casualties were almost negligible" and
that there was little effect on permanent
installations.74
Again British operational
researchers found that only a relatively small proportion of the enemy's guns had actually
been destroyed or damaged. The extensive cratering impeded armoured vehicles
supporting the ground attack.75
There is, however, ample evidence that the bombing
seriously disrupted the defenders' communications and shook their morale. (A German
who had been in an underground bunker during the attacks remarked that it was "like
being in the bottom of a cocktail shaker".)76
The investigators noted that positions within
the limits of the heavy bomber targets were captured much more rapidly than those
outside. Moreover, the bombing certainly gave, as always, a fillip to the spirits of our
own infantry which was no small factor in their success. Headquarters First Canadian
Army, commenting on the researchers' report some months later, remarked, "Despite the
proved lack of material effect of ground or air bombardment on the defences, it is
considered that both the RAF and the artillery bombardment were extremely effective in
neutralizing the enemy defences."77

*The completeness of our command of the air was reflected
in the fact that for this operation a lookout for
"spectators" was arranged on a high hill--as if for an
exercise in England. General Crerar watched the bombing from his
own light aircraft.

--339--

The 8th Infantry Brigade (Brigadier Blackader) attacked on the right, the 9th
(Brigadier Rockingham) on the left. H Hour was 9:55 a.m.--the moment when the last
bomb fell on Target 1. However, it was considered important if possible to capture the
extreme northern end of the German defended area before the main attack went in; for the
strongpoints about La Trésorerie and Wimille appeared to be a menace to it. A coastal
battery on the hill at La Trésorerie mounted three 30.5-cm. (12-inch) guns, and though
these could not fire landward there were other weapons here and the position was
commanding. Accordingly The North Shore (New Brunswick) Regiment was to attack it
at 9:25 a.m. after half an hour's artillery preparation. The evident assumption that thirty
minutes would suffice to clear the area turned out to be too optimistic. The attack was
checked, after making slight progress, in minefields covered by airburst fire from light
artillery. The North Shore in fact did not clear all its objectives until 19 September.
Nevertheless it seems to have kept the Germans busy enough to prevent them from
interfering with the main attack.78

The task of the 8th Brigade's main body was to deal with the enemy's defences
between Mont Lambert and La Trésorerie, in the vicinity of Marlborough and St. Martin
Boulogne. Immediately after the bombing Le Régiment de la Chaudière advanced against
Marlborough. En route they occupied an intact radar station in the hamlet of Rupembert;
and by nightfall they were consolidating in Marlborough. On the Brigade's left (southern)
flank The Queen's Own Rifles of Canada were directed against St. Martin Boulogne. By
11:00 a.m. they had captured the railway station there, and by evening they were close to
the "citadel" of Boulogne. Throughout the brigade area, shellfire and minefields were the
main hindrances to advance.79

While these operations were proceeding on the northern flank, the 9th Brigade
assaulted the Mont Lambert feature, moving forward the moment the Bomber Command
attack had ceased. Tanks of the 10th Armoured Regiment (The Fort Garry Horse) led; the
infantry rode into battle in Kangaroos and half-tracks which were followed by AVREs of
the 87th Assault Squadron R.E. Flails had also been provided to clear paths through
minefields; but when the attack went in the enemy's artillery prevented this relatively
vulnerable equipment from coming into action.80

On the right, along the main road from La Capelle, The Stormont, Dundas and Glengarry
Highlanders led the assault in "galloping Kangaroos under a tremendous barrage of
artillery".81
(The artillery actually fired timed programmes, prolonging the neutralizing effect
of the bombing and enabling the infantry to reach their first objectives with diminished
opposition.)82
When minefields stopped the Kangaroos, the Glengarrians continued on foot;
they took only 45 minutes to capture their first objectives. By this time, however, the German
batteries had recovered sufficiently to bring down hot fire from their commanding positions
on the slopes of Mont Lambert and nearby hills. Although the shelling made movement
almost impossible, men of the 18th Field Company R.C.E. performed an outstanding feat by
clearing a vital route through the mines by hand.83

Meanwhile, The North Nova Scotia Highlanders ran into heavy opposition when they
attacked the main fortifications of the Mont Lambert feature. Both sides

--340--

had appreciated the importance of this dominating ground; General Heim believed that
penetration in that sector "would make defence of the port impossible". He claimed,
however, that his defensive preparations here had not
been completed when "WELLHIT"
began.84
The North Nova Scotias were transported in Kangaroos as far as the minefields;
thereafter their upward progress was delayed by machine gun fire from pillboxes which
had survived the bombing. These were overcome with the help of AVREs and the hard
ascent continued. "Towards night Crocodiles and Flails were able to come up and the
area was steadily cleared."85
By the day's end a great part of Mont Lambert was in our hands.

Arrangements had been made for three armoured assault teams of the 31st British
Tank Brigade (each composed of one troop of Flails, two troops of Crocodiles and one
half troop of AVREs, together with one platoon of Canadian infantry) to drive into
Boulogne, at the end of the first phase, and seize the important bridges over the Liane
River in the heart of the city. The Glengarrians provided the infantry component for two
of the assault teams and these reached the Liane early on the 18th only to find the bridges
blown. The third team, operating with the North Nova Scotias, had a similar
experience.86

Thus, at the end of the first day, a considerable wedge had been driven into the
enemy's fortifications in the Highland Brigade's sector, while in the 8th's good progress
had been made. At the extreme north of the position the North Shore Regiment had a
foothold in the La Trésorerie strongpoint. All along the line, however, the operation had
gone more slowly than the forecast. A paper produced at Headquarters First Canadian
Army on 15 September seems to have assumed that Boulogne would fall in one day; for
it suggested that the same troops that attacked Boulogne on the 17th might be able to
attack Calais on the 19th.87
This, it now appeared, was wildly sanguine.

The 18th, however, saw further solid progress. The North Shore completed the
capture of the gun positions at La Trésorerie;
the Chaudière pushed on to the vicinity of
the Colonne de la Grande Armee (a monument to Napoleon's preparations to invade
England in 1803-5) where there was hard fighting. The Queen's Own advanced through
the northern outskirts of the city. In the 9th Brigade area the North Nova Scotias.
completed the capture of Mont Lambert.88
The Glengarrians, accompanied by AVREs,
reached the so-called citadel in the centre of Boulogne. This was actually the "upper
town", perched on a limestone hill overlooking the port and surrounded by high walls. It
soon succumbed to a combination of modern methods of assault and story-book
stratagem. A civilian showed Major J. G. Stothart, one of the company commanders, a
"secret tunnel" leading to the interior and Stothart soon had a platoon in the passage.

At the same time the Churchills wheeled up, raking the ramparts with Besa [machine-gun] fire, and
prepared to place petards against the portcullis. The gate was effectively blown in. At once a host of
white flags waved from the walls. To add to the confusion Maj Stothart had by now appeared in the
midst of the besieged fort, utterly astonishing its 'defenders'.89

About 200 prisoners were taken, including 16 officers. The Highland Light
Infantry of Canada, coming up from reserve, scrambled across the Liane in the
evening by using the remains of a half-demolished bridge in the middle of the

--341--

city; the 18th Field Company then set to work to improvise repairs to the bridge with
timber, and had it open for light vehicles by 4:30 a.m. on the 19th.90

The capture of the upper town and the crossing of the Liane marked the end of the
second phase of "WELLHIT".
While the 8th Brigade continued its operations to subdue the
German defences north of the port, the 9th turned south to deal with equally stubborn
strongpoints in the Outreau peninsula. On 19 September the H.L.I. pressed forward here
from its Liane bridgehead. The opposition was very heavy: "Murderous fire came from
all directions which was heavier than the battalion has yet experienced." It had 64
casualties and four supporting Flails were knocked out.91
The Glengarrians took up the
struggle in the afternoon with the help of tanks, AVREs and Wasps. They seized the
village of Outreau, after extricating themselves from a minefield, and captured many
prisoners, "including perhaps thirty black Senegalese complete
with fez".92

Between Outreau and the open Channel was a hill, about 250 feet high, capped with a
German battery of six 88-mm. and four 20-mm. guns.* This formidable position, known
in the plan as "BUTTERCUP",
the Glengarrians assaulted on the 19th, aided by heavy
artillery concentrations. "The infantry, following the fire closely, swarmed over the hill
with bayonets and grenades before the last rounds had fallen."
"BUTTERCUP" contributed
another 185 prisoners to the already bulging cages in the
rear areas.94

The North Nova Scotia Highlanders completed the next phase in the Outreau
peninsula with the assistance of the divisional support battalion, The Cameron
Highlanders of Ottawa (M.G.). After containing the enemy on the southern flank during
the initial operations, the Camerons had successfully assaulted the German position on
top of the very high hill at Herquelingue on the night of 18-19 September. However,
when the North Nova Scotias advanced on the 20th they came under fire from the lower
slopes of the feature. About 400 German soldiers had remained hidden in the
underground passages of Herquelingue while the Camerons occupied the casemates on
the summit. Some tank fire from the Fort Garry Horse quelled the opposition and next
day this large force came marching out to surrender (General Spry christened this "the
bargain basement incident"). The North Nova Scotias had continued their advance to
capture the village of St. Etienne, and subsequently turned north along the coast to deal
with the remaining defences at Nocquet, Ningles and Le Portel.95

While the 9th Brigade was completing its tasks in the Outreau peninsula, the 8th was
reducing the last German defences on the northern outskirts of Boulogne. In this area the
focal points of resistance were Wimille, Fort de la Crèche and Wimereux. On 19
September the North Shore moved against Wimille; they met stubborn resistance but
captured the village, together with many prisoners, the following morning. From this time
the momentum of the attack slowed as some of General Heim's best troops fought
tenaciously for their last strongpoints.

Since Fort de la Crèche was strongly held the 8th Brigade screened it with smoke and
attacked the town of Wimereux on the 21st. Lt.-Col. J. E. Anderson

*Examination afterwards established that one of the 88s
and two of the 20s had been destroyed or damaged by the
bombing; one 88 had been put out of action by our
artillery.93

--342--

of the North Shore was reluctant to employ heavy bombardment against a target which he
knew contained many civilians. Accordingly, only one field regiment and some captured
light German guns engaged the defences while the infantry gradually penetrated the
eastern portion of the town. Effective close support was given by a battery of the 3rd
Anti-Tank Regiment R.C.A., which silenced machine-guns in the railway station.
Fortunately, the town's main defences faced seawards and the North Shore were able to
complete the capture of Wimereux on the 22nd, receiving a warm welcome from the
population.96

By this time the formidable Fort de la Crèche had also fallen. This "northern anchor
of the main fortifications"97
was an old French work which the Germans had modernized
and greatly strengthened. When "WELLHIT"
began, its armament included six naval guns
(two 210-mm. and four 105-mm.) * as well as lighter field and flak pieces. The
defenders' morale was noticeably higher than that of the remainder of the garrison. On 21
September patrols of the Queen's Own Rifles and the Chaudière probed the outer works
and obtained valuable information in spite of strong reaction. On the afternoon of the
same day, some 78 medium bombers of No. 2 Group R.A.F. attacked the fort. These
preliminaries proved their worth when the Queen's Own advanced on the following
morning. With the assistance of a captured German gun they quickly subdued the now
disheartened garrison; Fort de la Crèche surrendered at 7:50 a.m. It was reported that
some 500 prisoners were taken in this
stronghold.99

Operation "WELLHIT" ended on the afternoon of 22 September in the Outreau
peninsula. Scout cars with loudspeakers impressed the futility of further resistance on the
garrison at Le Portel. There were two strongpoints here. The northern one fell first; then,
just as the 9th Brigade and a squadron of the 10th Armoured Regiment were about to
assault the southerly position, the enemy hoisted the white flag. General Heim
surrendered to Brigadier Rockingham at 4:30 p.m. and the last fighting ceased after the
German commander sent a cease-fire order to a detachment isolated on the harbour mole,
which had fought a single 88-mm. gun to the bitter end.100

Six days were consumed in the operations against Boulogne at a juncture when time
was very important. Apart from this the results were gratifying.† We took 9517 prisoners,
including 250 wounded.101
Our own losses were calculated as 634 killed, wounded and
missing.102
Those of the six infantry battalions that bore the brunt amounted to 462, the
9th Brigade's (247) being very slightly higher than the 8th's (215). The heaviest loss fell
upon The Highland Light Infantry of Canada (97 casualties, 18 of them fatal) and The
North Nova Scotia Highlanders (96 casualties,
27 fatal).103
The enemy force had been
only a little smaller than that at Le Havre, and the two Canadian brigades engaged against
it had lost more men than the two British divisions that took the larger city (above, page
336). In view of the strength of the ground and the defences, it was fortunate,

*Of these, two 105s were put out of action by bombing and one by
artillery fire.98

†The battle honour "Boulogne 1944" awarded to units
concerned in this operation serves to distinguish it from
"Boulogne 1544", carried by the Corps of Gentlemen-at-Arms,
which was present at Henry VIII's siege.

--343--

as an observer said, that the enemy's will to fight was not stronger. His troops frequently
went on firing until our infantry were close to their pillboxes and gun positions, and then
gave themselves up, in many cases having their kit packed ready
to surrender.104

It was the German artillery that caused most of our losses, and it is evident that the
neutralization of enemy batteries was less effective than at Le Havre. The reason may lie
in part in the smaller effort made by Bomber Command, in the absence of naval
bombardment (the reason for which was presumably the presence of extremely powerful
German coastal batteries in the Pas de Calais), and in the fact that ammunition stringency
prevented a really heavy artillery counter-battery programme being undertaken before the
actual day of the assault (above, page 338). A Canadian artillery commentary on the first
day's fighting attributed the failure to silence some batteries partly to the lightness of the
concentrations used, "seldom more than 2 [guns] to 1", and partly to the exceptionally
strong construction of the enemy gun positions.105
Operational researchers estimated in
one case, that of a battery of six 88-mm. guns at Honriville south of the harbour, that our
artillery put down 5700 rounds on it within a circle 300 yards in diameter, but the battery
nevertheless continued in action and fired some 2000 rounds. The same investigators
found deficiencies in our artillery Intelligence; our hostile battery lists before the
operation contained some dummy positions, on which bombs and shells were wasted,
while some actual batteries were omitted.106
Eight previously unknown batteries were
reported in action on 17 September.107

Boulogne had offered the hope of a considerable improvement in the Allies'
administrative situation. Though not a major harbour, it had a total seaborne cargo
movement, inward and outward, of over 1,000,000 tons in 1937 and was considered "the
first fishing port of France". Unfortunately, however, the harbour installations had been
extensively damaged by the enemy's demolitions and by bombing during the attack or
earlier. Several ships had been sunk across the harbour mouth, most of the cranes had
been destroyed and the locks damaged. Consequently, the port could not be used until 12
October, and there was no immediate alleviation of the Allied
supply problem.108

Operation "UNDERGO": The Capture of Calais

Calais was next. The port was smaller than Boulogne's and therefore less important in
logistical potential. But the opinion of the Naval Liaison Officer at Army Headquarters
(Commander R. M. Prior) was that if Boulogne was to be used with an acceptable degree
of risk "the seven heavy Calais batteries must be captured as well as those at Gris Nez";
Captain A. F. Pugsley, R.N., who now took command of the offshore naval units
operating in the area of First Canadian Army, concurred, and so apparently did Admiral
Ramsay.109
The situation was complicated by the preparations then being made to carry
out First Canadian Army's great task of opening the Scheldt Estuary. On 15 September,

--344--

when giving preliminary consideration to that task,
General Crerar had written to Field-Marshal
Montgomery:110

If, subsequent to the capture of Boulogne, Simonds finds it
possible quickly to exploit that success and
to capture Calais, this will be done by 2 Cdn Corps.
If, on the other hand, the Garrison of Calais shows
indications of resisting anything but a heavy and prepared
assault, then I shall move 1 Brit Corps, less 51
(H) Division to that area and Crocker will relieve Simonds
of the responsibility for the capture of Calais
and the containing of Dunkirk.

It was soon apparent that Calais could not be captured without a deliberate assault.
However, the urgency of the forthcoming Scheldt operations dictated a change in General
Crerar's arrangements; on the 19th the Army Commander directed the 1st Corps to take
over the Antwerp sector while General Simonds prepared to deal with Calais and the
batteries on Cape Gris Nez.111

General Spry's 3rd Canadian Division, already on the ground, naturally received
these latter tasks, and its staff produced their first plan
for the operation ("UNDERGO") the
day before the attack began at Boulogne.112
It was then thought, as we have noted, that
"UNDERGO" might begin as early as
19 September; but the protracted fighting at Boulogne
led to successive postponements, since the special armour, the artillery and even the
infantry needed for Calais were engaged there. Furthermore, there was a possibility that
the naval requirements at Boulogne, already mentioned, might be satisfied if the army
captured the Cape Gris Nez guns and merely contained Calais. As late as 23 September,
the Army Commander believed that a decision to contain might have to be made after the
operation began. The argument in favour of merely masking the place was, of course,
based on the urgent need to expedite the clearing of the
Scheldt Estuary.113

While the remainder of the 3rd Division had been preparing for the siege of.
Boulogne, the 7th Infantry Brigade (Brigadier J. G. Spragge) and the 7th Reconnaissance
Regiment invested Calais and Cape Gris Nez. Initially, the task was boldly performed by
the reconnaissance regiment, which reached the Calais area on 5 September and
proceeded to isolate the fortress, occupying a front of more than 20 miles to
do so.114
On the 10th The Toronto Scottish Regiment (M.G.) of the 2nd Division took over the southeastern
perimeter from Oye to Ardres. Meanwhile, the 7th Brigade, as already described,
occupied high ground about seven miles south-west of Calais on 6 September, cutting off
Boulogne from Calais and threatening the Gris Nez batteries. During the next ten days
these troops gradually advanced their positions and partially cleared
Cape Gris Nez.116

On the night of 16-17 September the 7th Brigade, less one battalion (for the 1st Canadian
Scottish were in divisional reserve for the Boulogne operation) made an attempt to capture the
three heavily fortified batteries on the Cape. The 6th Armoured Regiment, the 12th Field
Regiment R.C.A. and a battery of the 3rd Medium Regiment R.C.A. were in support. The result
was merely to demonstrate that heavier support was necessary to take these positions. The
attack made no impression, and an attempt by The Royal Winnipeg Rifles to bluff the

*This unit came under General Spry's command on 19 September,
returning to the 2nd Division on the 23rd.115

--345--

commander of the Haringzelles battery into surrender by a threat to "blow him off the
face of the earth" made no more. On the 18th the task of containing Cape Gris Nez was
handed over to the 7th Reconnaissance Regiment, while the 7th Brigade prepared for its
share in the attack on Calais.117

The defences of Calais were of some strength but, unlike those of Boulogne, they did
not depend on a fringe of outlying hills. Canals surrounded the landward side of
the city--itself described as "a series of islands culminating in the
CITADEL, the heart of the old
city"118--with
marshy ground and inundated areas forming further barriers to penetration
from the south and east. To one observer the flooded ground looked like
"a vast lake".119
A firm ridge, almost like a causeway, carried the road and railway east to Gravelines; but
this ridge had been fortified and could be easily defended by a resolute enemy.

The city retained much of its old fortifications, including a bastioned wall and a wet
ditch covering most of the built-up area. Here again, however, the modern defences
developed during more than four years of German occupation faced mainly seaward.
According to Lt.-Col. Ludwig Schroeder, commandant of the garrison, no attempt had
been made to deal with the problems of landward defence until about mid-August
1944.120
Calais had only recently been designated by Hitler as the equivalent of one of his
"fortresses" (above,
page 301).
Nevertheless, the enemy's works in the area were
impressive. At and about Noires Mottes, some five miles south-west of Calais, a battery
of three 406-mm. (15.8-inch) guns, a lesser cross-Channel battery and a system of
concrete pillboxes blocked the coastal route to the city. Eastward from Noires Mottes,
along the Belle Vue ridge, machine-gun positions and concrete shelters protected railway
guns. Between these positions and the inundated area south of Calais the Germans had
constructed a formidable strongpoint on higher ground north of Vieux Coquelles. Here a
wide variety of weapons, amply protected by wire and mines, lay astride the main road
from Boulogne to Calais, The eastern and south-eastern approaches were similarly
defended by minefields and infantry positions supported by field, anti-aircraft and antitank
artillery. Finally, in the Les Baraques area on the north-western outskirts of the port,
coastal installations were shielded by still more minefields and an anti-tank ditch
connecting the inundated areas to the sea.121

Our Intelligence originally estimated the strength of the garrison as between 4450 and
5550, later raising the figures to "six to eight thousand". The actual total was evidently
somewhat over 7500.122
These troops were a "mixed bag" of very indifferent quality--Schroeder
described them, somewhat unkindly, as "mere rubbish"--and only 2500 were
available as infantry. Nearly two-thirds of the remainder were needed to man the coastal guns
and port installations. The garrison's morale, following the reduction of Le Havre and Boulogne,
was under standably low. A report based on later interrogation of
prisoners123
noted that

Army personnel were old, ill, and lacked both the will to fight and to resist interrogation; naval
personnel were old and were not adjusted to land warfare; only the air force A.A. gunners showed any
sign of good morale-and were also the only youthful element of the whole garrison.

--346--

Sketch 27.--The Capture of Calais25 September-1 October 1944

--347--

The plan for the capture of Calais followed the familiar pattern of preliminary
bombardment by heavy bombers and artillery, followed by a heavily-supported infantry
assault. At Versailles on 15 September General Simonds had obtained R.A.F. approval
for the use of heavy bombers against Calais as well as Boulogne (above, page 338).
Subsequently, Bomber Command agreed to attack five main areas, including the
Sangatte-Belle Vue ridge positions, the Vieux Coquelles area and coastal fortifications
as well as the north-western defences of the port proper, and
the citadel.124
The artillery
bombardment was to be fired by the same units employed against Boulogne, including
the field regiments of the 51st Division. Detailed preparations were made
for counter-battery and counter-flak programmes in the preliminary phase; these were to be
supplemented, when the ground assault went in, by heavy concentrations on local points
of resistance.125
A feature of the operation was the use of a smoke-screen, 3000 yards
long, to hide a number of artillery units from observation from the German positions on
Cape Gris Nez.126

General Spry planned to attack Calais with the 7th and 8th Infantry Brigades, assisted
by the 2nd Canadian Armoured Brigade. Apart from the artillery, these formations would
be supported by Flails, AVREs and Crocodiles of the 31st British Tank Brigade and
Kangaroos of the 1st Canadian Armoured Personnel Carrier Squadron. The 7th Brigade's
task was to "capture or destroy" the garrisons of Belle Vue, Coquelles and Calais itself,
while the 8th Brigade dealt with the positions at Escalles, near Cape Blanc Nez, and
Noires Mottes.* (Meanwhile, the 9th Brigade would relieve the 7th Reconnaissance
Regiment at Cape Gris Nez and prepare to capture the batteries there.) The infantry attack
would begin when the last bomb fell on the targets nearest our troops. After successive
postponements, D Day was finally set on 24 September as the
following day.127

The air support programme produced one curious incident. Headquarters 2nd Canadian
Corps, "cutting a comer" in a manner which disregarded both Army and R.A.F. "channels",
made a direct request to Bomber Command for a heavy attack on the Escalles area. The
helpful Harris agreed. Army Headquarters, when it heard of the proposal, was alarmed lest
this should vitiate the goodwill which had been carefully built up with the air headquarters
that had been by-passed--particularly H.Q. Allied Expeditionary Air Force and H.Q. 2nd
Tactical Air Force. Accordingly it hastily made a request in proper form, through H.Q. No.
84 Group R.A.F., for the same attack on Escalles that Corps had asked for. A.E.A.F.
nevertheless decided to cancel the attack. They did not succeed in doing so, but in the
attempt (the 2nd T.A.F. later stated) they "made a mistake", with the result that an attack by
mediums of No. 2 Group, planned to go in on Fort de la Crèche at Boulogne on the evening
of 20 September, was cancelled instead. This was done by a direct order to the Group from
A.E.A.F., who thus cut a corner themselves. But the Bomber Command attack on Escalles
was duly made that afternoon; 633 aircraft attacked, 3372 tons were dropped, and

*The 3rd Division's operation order, issued on the evening
of 22 September, assigns only Escalles to the 8th Brigade,
but by the time the Brigade's own order was issued on the
23rd Noires Mottes had been added to its tasks.

--348--

the results were reported on all sides as excellent.128
If this was impropriety, it was at least on a magnificent scale.

Bad weather prevented further attacks until the late afternoon of 24 September, when
188 aircraft of Bomber Command attacked targets in Calais. Unfortunately eight of them
were lost.129
According to the diarist of the 7th Infantry Brigade, this was caused by a
report being received that the attack had been cancelled, which led to no artillery
programme being in readiness to shell the enemy antiaircraft positions.* The entry is
poignant:

We felt very helpless watching this attack--the casualties to aircraft could have been lowered if
someone along the lines somewhere hadn't messed things up. However one has to expect this sort of
thing in war. Patrols were sent out from battalions to try to pick up some of the bomber
crews--those we did find were dead.131

The weather interfered with the main Bomber Command attack beginning at 8:15 a.m. on
the Calais D Day itself. Nearly 900 bombers took to the air, but the majority of sorties
"were abortive"; only 303 aircraft attacked, dropping
1321 tons.132
Headquarters 2nd
Corps signalled Bomber Command, "Bombs which were delivered were well timed and
on targets."133
But as usual many pillboxes and other defences survived the battering from
the air (and the supporting artillery) and caused trouble during the assault. In general, the
results of the preliminary bombardment at Calais were similar to those at Le Havre and
Boulogne: damage was done to the enemy's defences and his morale suffered
appreciably; but there was no overall smothering of resistance, and the attacking troops
had heavy fighting before the port was captured.

At 10:15 a.m. on 25 September, immediately following the aerial bombardment, the
3rd Division's veterans advanced against the western defences
of Calais.134
On the left,
the 8th Brigade assaulted the defences on Cape Blanc Nez and the battery at Noires
Mottes. By the evening of the same day the Chaudière had captured the German garrison
at Blanc Nez, numbering nearly 200. (The regimental history records that most of them
were found dead drunk.)135
Meanwhile, the North Shore attacked "Battery Lindemann",
the Noires Mottes battery. Flails beat lanes through minefields protecting the gun areas,
and tanks of the 10th Armoured Regiment gave covering fire. By the end of the day the
North Shore occupied positions overlooking one of the huge emplacements and, in spite
of continuing fighting, "negotiations" went on throughout the night for the garrison's
surrender. The German commander eventually gave in early on the 26th and at noon the
enemy came filing out of their positions, the North Shore thus adding 285 prisoners to the
brigade's total. This surrender seems to have covered both the Noires Mottes position
with its three great guns, and the lesser coastal battery at Sangatte on the coast
nearby.136

The good progress made by the 8th Brigade in the early stages on the high ground in
the Escalles-Sangatte area greatly assisted the 7th in its attack on the Belle Vue and
Coquelles defences, which this ground commanded. In this sector, the assaulting
battalions reported that the preliminary heavy bombing had missed,

*Other records throw no light on this incident, except that
a situation report sent out by Headquarters 3rd Canadian
Division at 12:45 p.m. states, "Air support for the day
cancelled."130

--349--

or partly missed, their objectives137
(no doubt the reduction of the weight of the attack by
the weather supplies the explanation); but "artillery and light bombers subjected enemy
positions to a terrific bombardment before and when called for during
the attack".138
The infantry were gallantly supported by a squadron of the 6th Armoured Regiment.

The Royal Winnipeg Rifles met stern resistance about Vieux Coquelles; "but after a
bitter close quarter fight the resolute attackers finally drove the enemy from his bombproof
concrete shelters". Pressing forward towards Calais, they encountered troublesome
pockets of resistance, mines and snipers, while the enemy's artillery began to find the
range. Another fierce struggle ensued at the village of Coquelles--"the determined
enemy had to be driven back house by house"--but, with the "always ready and efficient"
support of the artillery, the Winnipegs were able to consolidate on the objective late on
the 25th.139
In the meantime The Regina Rifle Regiment fought its way down the forward
slope of the ridge west of Coquelles with the help of the 6th Armoured Regiment. The
enemy resisted strongly and late in the afternoon Brigadier Spragge ordered the 1st
Battalion, The Canadian Scottish Regiment, to assist the Reginas. The Scottish diarist
recorded that they trod carefully, "as there were many minefields, and a man makes only
one wrong step with them". By the following morning* they were advancing along the
coast road towards Fort Lapin and the north-western outskirts of
Calais.141

The 3rd Division had successfully penetrated the outer western defences. On the
morning of 26 September Bomber Command again attacked, 191 aircraft going for
Calais. The 7th Brigade units clawed their way forward during the day and by the end of
it were within striking distance of the inner line of
fortifications.142
This ran from Fort
Lapin and the strongly-held area of Les Baraques, on the coast, south through Fort
Nieulay to the extensive inundated area guarding the western and south-western
approaches to the city. The defences in the coastal sector were particularly formidable: at
Fort Lapin there was a heavy battery protected by anti-tank ditches and minefields, and
both it and the nearby Bastion 11 were reported to be equipped with flame-throwers. The
8th Brigade, having completed its initial task, prepared to relieve the Camerons on the
east side of the city while the 7th kept up the pressure from the west.

On 27 September the forward troops withdrew slightly, enabling Bomber Command to
deliver another smashing attack; 342 Lancasters dropped
1718 tons.143
Thereafter the 7th
Brigade made steady progress. The Scottish had a hard fight before they subdued Fort
Lapin; but with the help of tanks, Crocodiles and a covering smoke-screen they were able
to capture the fort on the evening of the same day. Assisted by sappers of the 6th Field
Company they immediately pressed forward, seeking crossings over the old water defences
at the western edge of the port. During the night the battalion managed to get "D" Company
and two platoons of "B" across south of Bastion 11. Then the Germans in the bastion and

*As the Canadian Scottish were advancing during the morning
they sent a party to investigate the now quiescent
Noires Mottes battery, and apparently there was a surrender
to them as well as to the North Shore
Regiment.140

--350--

the citadel "opened up in earnest" and "It was suicide to put a head above ground." The
troops across the water could neither be reinforced nor withdrawn; they remained cut off
with no food or ammunition reaching them for
48 hours.144

Inland, on the right flank of the Scottish, the Winnipegs attacked Fort Nieulay, whose
high walls "dominate the flat country to the south, the highway [to Boulogne], and the
approaches to the west".145
Shell-proof pillboxes had been built into the walls of the fort,
which was surrounded by a wide ditch. At first the defences resisted strenuously; but, in
the graphic language of the Winnipegs' account, "the attack was pushed near enough to
the Fort to enable flamethrowers to be used and after warming the enemy up a little the
white flag was seen hoisted and hundreds of Germans poured out through the open doors
with hands up".146
Meanwhile, on the brigade's right (southern) flank, the Reginas were
crossing the flooded area to reach the factories in the southern outskirts
of Calais.147

By 28 September Lt.-Col. Schroeder's situation was desperate. His troops' morale
was low and desertions were numerous. Moreover, he was embarrassed by a large
civilian population (some 20,000) which had refused to leave the city before operations
began. And on the morning of the 28th Bomber Command attacked again, this time with
194 aircraft.148
That afternoon a Civil Affairs officer at Ardres heard that the German
commander was "about ready to consider surrendering". A message was sent to him on
behalf of General Spry offering to meet him at Le Pont sans Pareil, north of Ardres, at 10
a.m. the next morning. The Germans accepted;149
and in the evening the order went out to
the Canadian units, "No further firing except on active
enemy."150
The meeting duly took
place, but Schroeder did not come. His representatives made the surprising suggestion
that Calais be declared an "open city". This Spry quickly refused since, as a 3rd Division
diarist wrote, "the Boche were in the town and defending same". The Germans then asked
for a 48-hour extension of the truce to permit of the evacuation of the civilian population.
Spry granted 24 hours, until noon on 30 September. Later in the day the Senior Civil
Affairs Officer, 2nd Canadian Corps (Colonel J. J. Hurley) attended a conference in
Calais at which Schroeder was present. He gained the impression that the Germans would
surrender "after a sufficient show of resistance has been made to make their surrender
appear an honourable one".151

During the truce period, while the unfortunate people of Calais streamed out of the
city by the eastern roads, to be received and looked after by our Civil Affairs staff,
General Spry issued his orders for the final assault. Two hours after the expiration of the
truce, the Queen's Own Rifles and the Camerons were to make a well-supported
diversionary attack from the east, while the 7th Reconnaissance Regiment maintained
strong fighting patrols on the city's southern perimeter. Then in the second phase the 7th
Brigade would make the main effort from the west, opening the road from Coquelles and
destroying or capturing the garrison.152

But the uneasy interlude had completed the demoralization of the garrison. When
fighting began again at noon on the 30th the German opposition crumbled rapidly.
Anticipating an early surrender, the Canadians cancelled a further visitation

--351--

by heavy bombers; but Typhoons and Spitfires of No. 84 Group were busily
employed and the artillery gave effective support. At one p.m. the Camerons on the
eastern side of the city reported, "Enemy pouring out." Asked whether this was a general
surrender, they replied, "Don't know, but they are sure
coming out."153
In the western
sector the Canadian Scottish now resumed their advance. Aided by Crocodiles they soon
broke into Bastion 11 and the citadel and began clearing the northern section of the city
proper. "Very little active resistance was encountered as the garrison simply waited to be
taken prisoner."154
The situation was much the same elsewhere on the 7th Brigade's front
which, by nightfall, extended deep into the city.

At 7:00 p.m. Schroeder surrendered to the Camerons' commanding officer, Lt.-Col. P. C.
Klaehn. "The ceremony was 'staged' as impressively as possible over a desk in a French
farmhouse."155
Scattered fighting continued through the night, but by nine o'clock on the morning of
1 October all resistance had ceased in Calais.156
The total number of prisoners was about 7500.*
The attackers' losses had been surprisingly light. Overall, they were
"under 300".159
The 7th
Brigade had borne the brunt; its three battalions had had 190 casualties, the heaviest weight
falling on The Royal Winnipeg Rifles (77) and The Regina Rifle Regiment (71). The 8th
Brigade units had only 29 casualties between them.160

The port installations of Calais had been painstakingly demolished by the enemy (air
photographs dated 13 September show dozens of neat craters along the quays) and the
harbour could not be opened until November. It was then used for personnel traffic and as
a train ferry terminal.161

The Cape Gris Nez Batteries

During the period of the truce at Calais, the 9th Brigade carried out a skilful and
inexpensive operation to eliminate the enemy's cross-Channel batteries at Cape Gris Nez. These
guns had interfered with use of the Dover Straits by our shipping and plagued the citizens of
Dover with sporadic bombardment which had latterly grown heavier. But four years had passed
since Mr. Churchill's observation, "We have to fight for the command of the Straits by artillery,
to destroy the enemy's batteries, and to multiply and fortify
our own";162
and the great weapons
were now exposed to attack from their comparatively vulnerable landward side.

The German positions at Cape Gris Nez were manned by the 242nd Naval
Coastal Artillery Battalion. They comprised three main batteries: Battery Todt, at
Haringzelles, with four 380-mm. guns; Battery Grosser Kurfurst, at Floringzelle,
mounting four 280-mm., and Battery Gris Nez, near the western tip of the Cape
itself, with three 170-mm. A fourth, Battery Wissant, at the village of that name, with
four 150-mm. guns, had been overrun earlier by the
7th Brigade.163
Both the Todt
and Grosser Kurfurst guns had ranges of over 25 miles; the latter and Gris Nez could
fire landward.164
These massive installations were well protected against direct
assault by a complex system of minefields, electrified fences, reinforced

*The final total of prisoners from Calais and Cape Gris Nez
together was 9128.157
Those from Cape Gris Nez
numbered "about 1600".158

--352--

bunkers and anti-tank positions supported by numerous machine-guns and field pieces.

The R.A.F. Bomber Command made two heavy attacks on the batteries before the
infantry went in. On 26 September 532 aircraft attacked; this raid and the simultaneous
one on Calais (above, page 350) dropped 3648 tons of bombs between them. On 28
September, the day before the 9th Brigade operation, 302 aircraft dropped 855 tons on the
Gris Nez positions.165
No doubt these attentions contributed materially to the success of
the assault on the 29th.

The operation was mainly the work of two battalions. On the right, The Highland Light
Infantry of Canada advanced against the Grosser Kurfurst and Gris Nez batteries; on the
left, The North Nova Scotia Highlanders took out Battery Todt. The infantry were
supported by "B" Squadron of the 6th Armoured Regiment, together with Flails, Crocodiles
and AVREs of the 79th British Armoured Division. Artillery support was provided by the
14th Field Regiment R.C.A. and mediums of the 9th Army Group,
Royal Artillery.166
The battalions had carefully examined the ground. Lt.-Col. D. F. Forbes of the North Nova
Scotias, an almost legendary commanding officer, had led a reconnaissance whose boldness
can be judged by the story, later apocryphally told, that it culminated in his knocking on the
steel door of one of the casemates and inquiring the strength of the
garrison.167

The supporting artillery opened fire at 6:35 a.m. on the 29th and ten minutes later the
infantry and armour moved forward. Tanks were impeded by minefields and extensive
craters resulting from the bombing;168
but Flails cleared paths through the mines and
AVREs filled anti-tank ditches with fascines. On the northern flank the H.L.I. met little
opposition. "The barrage crept ahead of the troops and was very effective in keeping the
enemy's heads down. As soon as our troops got into the enemy positions the white flags
started popping up and a stream of prisoners of war started to flow back to the PW cage."
By 10:30 a.m. the H.L.I. had captured all four guns of Grosser Kurfurst and, during the
afternoon, they overran Battery Gris Nez.169
The diarist of a squadron of the 141st
Regiment Royal Armoured Corps (The Buffs), which supported the H.L.I. with Crocodiles,
described what he called the "last writhings" of the guns of one battery. "One, the last to
fire, with Canadian Infantry actually on the revolving turret fired one shell wildly out to
sea, another in the direction of Dover and one more inland before sappers could put it out of
action with hand-placed charges." This was presumably the very last shot fired at Dover.

Similar success attended the efforts of the North Nova Scotias against the southern
defences. The Canadians were upon Battery Todt before the defenders realized what had
happened. Afterwards the battalion commander described the technique employed against
one of the formidable gun positions:

An AVRE was brought up near Number 3 gun and commenced to pound its concrete casemate with
petards, while the infantry threw grenades into its open front.
Against the solid walls the petards had
little real effect, but they achieved penetration through the
window slits, and in any event their shattering
detonation produced a notable moral result.

By mid-morning the entire battery was in our hands. The North Nova Scotias completed
their share of the operation, with notable assistance from Flails, when

--353--

they struggled through craters and minefields to the coast and captured the local German
headquarters at Cran-aux-Oeufs.170

The two battalions suffered only 42 casualties between them, including eight killed,
and took some 1600 prisoners.171
That night, for the first time in four years, Dover was
safe from the menace of the enemy's artillery. A flag which had flown over Battery Todt
was sent by General Spry to the Mayor of Dover. Brigadier Rockingham, in the act of
congratulating his men on their victory, was able to point out to sea, where minesweepers
were already at work clearing a channel into Boulogne
harbour.172

Clearing the Flying-Bomb Sites

In clearing the Channel coast in September 1944 the Canadians
eliminated the flying-bomb sites from which the enemy had maintained
for three months a destructive
bombardment of south-eastern England in general and London in particular.

We now know that early in the war German scientists at the Peenemunde Rocket
Research Institute made great progress in developing flying bombs and long-range
rockets. By March 1943 work was proceeding on launching installations along the
Channel coast, and four months later Hitler gave Peenemunde the highest priority in the
German armaments programme with the prophetic remark: "Europe and the whole world
will be too small from now on to contain a war. With such weapons humanity will be
unable to endure it."173
Through the spring of 1944 the Allied air forces poured a great
weight of bombs on the launching sites in a successful effort to delay the enemy's
operations. The missile first used was the V-1 pilotless aircraft or flying bomb.* British
Intelligence had given warning of the new weapon, which had a simple jet propulsion
motor operating on the "impulse duct" principle. It carried one ton of explosive at a speed
of about 400 miles per hour and an altitude of around 3000 feet. It proved to have a very
dangerous blast effect.174

When the German attacks finally began, on the night of 12-13 June, a week after D
Day, the British people met them in a spirit worthy of the community that had stood up to
the earlier blitz; but to London this new menace, coming at a moment of such high hopes,
was a sore trial. The offensive was launched in earnest on the night of 15-16 June. On the
18th the British Government asked General Eisenhower to take "all possible measures to
neutralize the supply and launching sites, subject to no interference with the essential
requirements of the battle in France".175
Heavy bombing of the V-1 bases accordingly
continued through the summer; and skilful coordination of balloons, fighter aircraft and
anti-aircraft guns (the latter now rendered vastly more effective by the use of the
"proximity fuse") took an increasing toll of the missiles, until very few of those launched
were reaching London.176
But the menace could finally be ended only by driving

*Designated V-1 as the first of the Versuchsmuster
(experimental type), later Vergeltungswaffen (revenge weapons).
In English-speaking countries the V-1 was commonly known
as the "doodlebug" or "buzz-bomb", because of the
characteristic sound of its engine.

--354--

the enemy from his positions along the Channel coast. This was one of the objects
mentioned in General Montgomery's directive of 26 August (above,
page 282). Just at
that moment the German flying-bomb units began to withdraw from their firing area
(which lay some miles back from the coast, roughly in a great crescent from south of
Dieppe to south of Dunkirk) as First Canadian Army threatened them. Early on the
morning of 1 September, when General Dempsey's men were across the Somme at
Amiens and General Crerar's, having already overrun the southerly bomb-sites, were
approaching Abbeville, the Germans fired their last bomb from
this area.177
Another phase of London's ordeal was over. However, the last page of the story had not been
written. On 8 September the first V-2 rockets, fired from Holland, fell in the city's
outskirts; and a certain number of flying bombs continued to be launched, from aircraft.*
Fortunately, however, these weapons, though responsible for much death and misery,
killed considerably fewer people than the main flying-bomb campaign.

One other German "secret weapon" had been a failure. At Mimoyecques, near
Marquise, between Boulogne and Calais, a 50-barrelled smoothbore gun installation was
found with which it had been hoped to drop 6-inch shells on London at a rate of, perhaps,
more than one a minute. Very fortunately, however, the projectiles when tested had
proved unstable in flight.179

During their long stay in England the Canadians had formed many ties with the
British people, received much kindness from them, and conceived the warmest regard for
their indomitable courage in peril and cheerfulness in adversity. Thus it gave very special
satisfaction to the men of the Canadian Army that their efforts were responsible for
ending the bombardment of the United Kingdom by long-range artillery and virtually
scotching the flying-bomb menace.

First Canadian Army's siege operations along the Channel coast during September
had been useful as well as arduous. Le Havre, Boulogne, Cape Gris Nez and Calais had
yielded a total of just under 30,000 prisoners, and in addition a
fair number of Germans--we do not know precisely how many--had been killed.
This however was not much more
than an incidental benefit. What the Allies needed was working ports; and though the
ports were now in our hands they were not yet working. On 1 October the only harbours
north of the Seine receiving Allied shipping were Dieppe, its subsidiary Le Tréport, and
Ostend; all of which the Germans had abandoned without a fight. Le Havre, Boulogne
and newly-captured Calais were still unusable; and the sea approaches to Antwerp were
still in German hands.

More than one critic, wise after the event, has suggested that in the actual
circumstances of the time the operations against the Channel Ports were a waste of time
and of resources. And indeed it is easy to see now that those operations

*Air launching had been in progress since July. On 4 September,
evidently in an attempt to conceal and compensate
for the effect of the over-running of the ground sites,
the Armed Forces High Command ordered that the air unit concerned
(No. 3 Group of Kampfgeschwader 3) would "be committed
exclusively against London in greatest possible strength".
Early the next morning 14 flying bombs were plotted in England.
None reached London. There was then a complete lull for
several days.178
This was a weak substitute for the ground-based attack.

--355--

did not yield the dividends that were expected of them. Perhaps the most solid return
from them was the terminals for cross-Channel pipelines (the "PLUTO" scheme).
Gasoline began to be pumped from Dungeness to Boulogne on
26 October;180
but this was too late to help win the war in 1944.*

It would seem that on 4 September, when Antwerp fell to the Second Army, there
were open to the Allied commanders two possible courses either of which, if at once
adopted and ruthlessly persisted in, might possibly have led to the defeat of Germany
before the winter. One was Field-Marshal Montgomery's plan for a concentrated drive
into Germany on a relatively narrow front, supported by all the administrative resources
then available to the Allies. This plan, as we have seen, was certainly risky, and the
administrative calculations on which it was based, involving the use of at least "one good
Pas de Calais port", proved to be optimistic (above,
page 321).

The other possible course was to disregard the Channel Ports, merely masking them
with minimum forces as was finally done at Dunkirk, and to concentrate every available
resource upon opening Antwerp and incidentally destroying the endangered Fifteenth
Army. Could we have struck while the Germans were still off balance, immediately after
4 September, we might have opened the Scheldt much more rapidly and cheaply than we
were able to do in October; and it is possible (though scarcely probable) that we could
have got the great port working in time to support an autumn campaign into Germany.

As it was, not for the only time in this war, and (in the light of the various political
factors involved) perhaps inevitably, we fell between two stools. The Supreme
Commander went a long way in the direction of concentrating resources to support
Montgomery in the north, but never quite the whole hog. And although he was strongly
seized of the vital importance of Antwerp, and put pressure on the commander of the 21st
Army Group in this connection, at a moment when Montgomery had put the Antwerp
matter at the bottom of his agenda (above,
page 310), he compromised to the extent of
allowing the Arnhem operation to be tried first. That operation failed, though only by a
narrow margin; and we had then to undertake the task of clearing the Scheldt Estuary and
opening Antwerp under conditions less favourable than would have obtained a few weeks
earlier. That task we must now describe.

*A longer PLUTO line had been laid earlier from the Isle
of Wight to Cherbourg. Test pumping began on 13 August,
but this line was not a success. The lines to Boulogne,
known as DUMBO, were, on the other hand, extremely successful,
providing, in General Eisenhower's words, "our main
supplies of fuel during the winter and spring campaigns". At the peak
they carried over one million gallons a day. They fed a
pipeline network on the Continent which had originally connected
with the points in Normandy where gasoline was landed
from tankers. By 18 September, it may be noted, the land pipeline
in the British area had reached Rouen.181

20.
W.Ds., H.Q. 4th Inf. Bde., Essex Scottish, and R.H.L.I., 9 Sep 44.
The Administrative History of the Operations
of 21 Army Group on the Continent of Europe, 6 June
1944-8 May 1945 (Germany, Nov. 1945), 40, 71.

114.
W.D., 7th Recce. Regt., 5 Sep 44, and Capt. W.G. Pavey, An Historical
Account of the 7th Canadian Reconnaissance Regiment (17th Duke of York's Royal
Canadian Hussars) in the World War 1939-1945 (Montreal, 1948), 69.

174.
Churchill, Triumph and Tragedy [Toronto] (1953), Book One, Chap. 3.
John Ehrman, Grand Strategy, vol. V
("History of the Second World War, United Kingdom Military Series") (London, 1956),
305-14.
W.F. Craven and J.L. Cate, The Army Air Forces in World War II,
III (Chicago, 1953),
Chap. 4.
Gen. Sir Frederick Pile, Ack-Ack: Britain's Defence against Air Attack during
the Second World War (London, 1949), 326 ff.
H. St. G. Saunders, The Fight is Won ("Royal Air Force 1939-1945",
vol. III) (London, 1954),
Chap. VII.

175.
Basil Collier, The Defence of the United Kingdom
("History of the Second World War, United Kingdom
Military Series") (London, 1957),
372.