Good Housekeeping Taste Test: Peanut Butter

Not many can resist this luscious spread: It's found in 90% of American pantries. We tasted 24 versions of this childhood favorite to see which creamy and crunchy varieties came out on top.

Courtesy of the company

7of25

Market Pantry Creamy Peanut Butter

One taster exclaimed, "I am so happy. This is peanut butter!" when tasting Market Pantry Creamy Peanut Butter ($2.69 for 18 oz.). Volunteers approved of this one's smooth texture, which felt lighter and almost fluffy. The classic flavor, deemed more on the salty side than sweet, "tastes like what mom used to buy."

Courtesy of the company

7of25

Market Pantry Creamy Peanut Butter

One taster exclaimed, "I am so happy. This is peanut butter!" when tasting Market Pantry Creamy Peanut Butter ($2.69 for 18 oz.). Volunteers approved of this one's smooth texture, which felt lighter and almost fluffy. The classic flavor, deemed more on the salty side than sweet, "tastes like what mom used to buy."