Not judging anyone's personal decisions, but let's remember that, like the rest of this site, this board if for Ethical Hacktivism. I don't think anyone would argue with the fact that what they are doing is illegal.

I guess the point of trying to have an 'ethical' hacktivism board is to encourage people to protest and make their voices heard while still remaining legal.

Yeah I probably went a little overboard with the LulzSec posts... . I guess my point was to drive conversation about what we are considering ethical hacktivism. I agree what LulzSec is doing in illegal. But wasn't it also illegal to set up proxy servers that allowed the Egyptian protestors to coordinate using facebook and twitter. They were violating the law of the land to facilitate their right to protest. Do we consider that ethical hacktivism? How do we protest in the digital era? Is there even such a thing as ethical hacktivism if a "hack" is considered an act of war?

don wrote:Not judging anyone's personal decisions, but let's remember that, like the rest of this site, this board if for Ethical Hacktivism. I don't think anyone would argue with the fact that what they are doing is illegal.

I guess the point of trying to have an 'ethical' hacktivism board is to encourage people to protest and make their voices heard while still remaining legal.

Don

I agree with you, posting this info is just the first step into who knows what its eventually going to get to the names of the people that took out Osama. These people feel its important for everyone to have this info, I feel its going to eventually going to get good people killed.

jsm725 wrote:How do we protest in the digital era? Is there even such a thing as ethical hacktivism if a "hack" is considered an act of war?

These are very valid questions. This is the main issue I have when people use a black/white definition when it comes to defining "ethical". I usually find that when people refer to "ethical hacker" they mean "lawful hacker." But not everything that is lawful is going to necessarily be ethical. Case in point being the exact example jsm725 gave: setting up of proxy servers for Egyptian protesters.