Part I of this article provided background on the doctrine of rectification and how it is used in the Canadian tax context. This part II will review the facts of Canada (Attorney General) v. Fairmont Hotels Inc. and the decisions made by the lower courts.

Facts – Canada (Attorney General) v. Fairmont Hotels Inc.

In 2002, Fairmont Hotels and its subsidiaries assisted Legacy Hotels REIT in financing the purchase of two hotels in the United States through a reciprocal loan arrangement. Since the financing was to be done in US currency, Fairmont was concerned about tax liability that could arise from changes in the exchange rate. As a result, the transaction was structured to achieve foreign exchange tax neutrality. This was achieved by ensuring that any loss from foreign exchange fluctuations would be offset by a corresponding gain and vice versa. If you are concerned about the tax implications of foreign exchange fluctuations on your business, consider reaching out to one of our top Toronto tax lawyers.

In 2006, Fairmont Hotels was acquired by Kingdom Hotels International and Colony Capital LLC. This acquisition threatened to cause Fairmont Hotels and its subsidiaries involved in the reciprocal loan arrangement to realize a deemed foreign exchange loss without the corresponding gains. That would compromise the ability of the structure to provide foreign exchange tax neutrality. Fairmont responded to this by executing a plan that fixed the problem for Fairmont itself, but deferred solving the problem for its subsidiaries until a later date. If you are involved in the purchase or sale of a business and would like to know more about tax traps and planning opportunities, please contact one of our experienced Toronto tax lawyers.

In 2007, Legacy Hotels REIT decided to sell the hotels and requested on short notice that Fairmont unwind the reciprocal loan agreement. Fairmont proceeded to do this without realizing that since they never fixed the foreign exchange tax neutrality problem for the subsidiaries, they would face adverse tax consequences. The Canada Revenue Agency uncovered this fact as part of the tax audit of Fairmont’s 2007 tax returns. Fairmont then applied to the court to rectify the director’s resolutions they used to unwind the reciprocal loan agreement so as to maintain the foreign exchange tax neutrality the structure was originally designed to ensure.

Judicial History - Canada (Attorney General) v. Fairmont Hotels Inc

The Ontario Superior Court of Justice found in favour of Fairmont Hotels. The Superior Court found that Fairmont a continuing intention to maintain foreign exchange tax neutrality and that Fairmont did not have a specific plan as to how they would achieve that outcome. Relying on Juliar v. Canada (Attorney General), the Superior Court found that it was not necessary for Fairmont to have a specific plan in mind to qualify for rectification. The Superior Court took the position that Fairmont’s continuing intention to maintain foreign exchange tax neutrality meant that their rectification request was not an instance of retroactive tax planning and that denying Fairmont’s application would give the Canada Revenue Agency an unintended gain.

The Ontario Court of Appeal also found in favour of Fairmont Hotels. The Court of Appeal found that the critical component for rectification is the continuing intention to undertake a transaction on a specific tax basis. According to the Court of Appeal, rectification does not require the parties to know the precise mechanics or specific means by which they would achieve their intended tax result so long as the intention to achieve that tax result can be demonstrated.
Please continue to part III of this Toronto tax lawyer tax rectification article which will discuss the Supreme Court of Canada’s decision and its implications for taxpayers.

Disclaimer:

"This article provides information of a general nature only. It is only current at the posting date. It is not updated and it may no longer be current. It does not provide legal advice nor can it or should it be relied upon. All tax situations are specific to their facts and will differ from the situations in the articles. If you have specific legal questions you should consult a lawyer."

Free Income Tax Advice on Phone

We offer a free 10 minute income tax consultation with one of our students. We will identify your tax
problem and advise you if you need assistance from a tax lawyer to solve it and if so we will suggest a
one hour consultation with one of our lawyers, the fees if you wish to consult and a rough estimate of
the legal fees if you choose to retain us.

Schedule a Consultation

Resources

What Our Clients are Saying?

When I received a Notice of Assessment from the Canada Revenue Agency saying I owed an additional $99.769.24 in taxes, I was shocked and I had no idea where to turn. After searching on the internet, I quickly found the top ranked tax law firm of Rotfleisch and Samulovitch P.C. David Rotfleisch, CPA, J.D. listened to me explain my situation, and quickly filed a Notice of Objection on my behalf. They were successful in eliminating the extra amount CRA claimed I owed, and they even got rid of the interest and late filing penalties. My tax liabilities went from $99,769.24 all the way down to $4,040. I love that my case was handled quickly and in a way designed to keep costs low, and I could not be happier to recommend the firm to anyone with tax issues.

I.I., Toronto - Client

David J. Rotfleisch, CPA, JD was my tax and business lawyer in a difficult share sale transaction. He advised me on the income tax and business aspects, handled long and difficult negotiations and successfully closed the share sale. He was very “hands-on” with the deal and was able to resolve matters to my entire satisfaction. I recommend him for any business or tax matters.

Michael Bargman, Toronto, Tel Aviv - Client

David J. Rotfleisch, CPA, JD, represented me in the Tax Court of Canada and in the Federal Court of Appeal . My income tax case went back to the 1980s but was only heard in 2008 and 2009 partially due to the complexity. It involved securities hedging and complex business, complex law and complex accounting issues. I was fortunate to find a lawyer who even understood the business aspect. The organization of David’s firm enabled this successful case to be completed in a cost effective manner, which I doubt the larger law firms could have achieved. I am delighted with his representation and would recommend him without hesitation.

Russ Witt, Toronto - Client

I first met David Rotfleisch when he acted for the vendor of a business I bought, Richards-Wilcox, over 20 years ago. My partner and I were so impressed by him that once the deal was complete we retained him as our tax and business lawyer. He has acted for us on all tax and corporate matters since then, including the sale of our successful garage door business to Raynor in the US and has represented Raynor on the Canadian aspects of various transborder transactions. If you need a tax or business lawyer, David has a broad grasp of tax and business law and is helpful and responsive.

Ray Friesen Raynor Canada, Mississauga - Client

I am a serial entrepreneur, having been involved in different businesses over the years. David J. Rotfleisch has been my tax and business lawyer for over 20 years. He has helped me with complex income tax and GST/HST issues over the years, including tax prosecutions and a subsequent voluntary disclosure that was successfully submitted. I find him to be very experienced and knowledgeable and able to explain complex issues in very clear language. He has a passion for solving business and tax problems, not accepting CRA excesses and attacking CRA's abuses. David's professionalism , attention to detail and unrelenting persuit of justice for the"little guy" has given me comfort while the CRA wolves were pacing at the door.

E.P., Mississauga, Ont - Client

I own Multimedia Lighting & Electric Ltd, an electrical contractor that specializes in large display signs. David Rotfleisch has been my tax and business lawyer and advisor since I started in business more than 15 years ago. He is great at planning to reduce my taxes and keeping me out of any trouble with CRA. His planning and advice is clever and to the point and I rely on him without hesitation.

I first met David Rotfleisch when he acted for the vendor of a business I bought, Richards-Wilcox, over 20 years ago. My partner and I were so impressed by him that once the deal was complete we retained him as our tax and business lawyer. He has acted for us on all tax and corporate matters since then, including the sale of our successful garage door business to Raynor in the US and has represented Raynor on the Canadian aspects of various transborder transactions. If you need a tax or business lawyer, David has a broad grasp of tax and business law and is helpful and responsive.

Ray Friesen Raynor Canada, Mississauga - Client

I own Hometown Electric, an electrical contractor that specializes in large display signs. David Rotfleisch has been my tax and business lawyer and advisor since I started in business more than 15 years ago. He is great at planning to reduce my taxes and keeping me out of any trouble with CRA. His planning and advice is clever and to the point and I rely on him without hesitation.

Doug Hishon, Jr. Hometown Electric, Toronto, Ont - Client

I have used David Rotfleisch as my business and tax lawyer for over 20 years. I own and publish Canadian Homes & Cottages Magazine, and David has been our go to lawyer for over 20 years. He has handled all of my business and personal tax issues as well as my will and estate planning. David and his team are very good at anticipating and handling issues before they develop into problems, and in solving unexpected problems. I would not think of going to any other lawyer.

Dealing with adversarial tax issues is much like a root canal ,a painful but essential process to save the tooth. A skilled and confident Dentist is essential to the exercise.

David Rotfleisch and his staff provided me with a concise and timely roadmap through the Voluntary Disclosure Process. There are many people touting their connections and expertise in the media. David and his staff produce results in an understated and professional manner. Choose your advisor carefully and make it Rotfliesch & Samulovitch.

Dennis, Aurora, Ontario - Client

What Other Professionals are Saying?

I run a professional CPA practice with staff in Toronto, Canada and Texas, USA and have been dealing with David Rotfleisch's tax law firm for over 15 years. David and I have worked on many different CRA and business files over the years, including voluntary disclosures, audits and appeals and the purchase and sale of businesses. He provides practical and timely tax and business advice. I refer all of my clients who need a Canadian business or tax lawyer to David.

I am a chartered professional accountant and a partner with the national accounting firm of Collins Barrow. I have worked with David Rotfleisch on hundreds of client files over the last 15 years. He is my most accessible tax lawyer and the one that I frequently go to, especially since he also has an accounting degree. He understands the accounting side of the issues as well as the tax and business law considerations. He deals with tax problems in a direct and cost effective way. I strongly recommend him to anyone in need of a Canadian tax lawyer.

I am a long time professional bookkeeper.Â From time to time my clients need a Canadian tax or business lawyer for will or tax planning or have problems with CRA and have to file a Notice of Objection or Appeal to Tax Court, or have unfiled income tax returns and have to submit a Voluntary Disclosure.Â I have been working exclusively with David Rotfleisch's tax law firm for over 5 years.Â He and his staff are knowledgeable in tax and corporate matters, responsive,Â effective and provide cost effective tax solutions.Â I continue to refer clients to him and would recommend him to anyone who has need of his services.

Gail Carver, Bookkeeping in the Beach, Toronto, Ontario - Bookkeeper

As a tax CPA/CA I am always working with Canadian income tax lawyers to implement transactions or reorganizations, to provide income tax opinions for private or public deals and to carry out income tax litigation. I have been working with David Rotfleisch and his tax law firm for over 15 years. He has assisted me and my clients on all aspects of tax law. I enjoy working with him, he responds to phone calls and emails as soon as they are sent, he promptly reviews and comments on documents. I have only good things to say about him and do not hesitate to refer him to my clients.

As a Partner at Sloan Partners LLP, Chartered Professional Accountants I am heavily involved in tax planning and tax compliance matters for a diverse client base.
To assist us in providing the best service to our clients, we use lawyers to help formalize and implement income tax planning arrangements. In those cases where
our clients are challenged by CRA, we need a lawyer skilled in tax litigation to defend their positions. My relationship with David J. Rotfleisch goes back almost 20 years.
David has always been available to discuss concepts and issues and to provide invaluable assistance to clients. Although clients always come first, we also enjoy chatting
about photography since we’re both serious about that too.

We are a Toronto tax law firm with a Canada wide full service income tax law practice. We provide comprehensive income tax planning including individual will and estate planning and estate freezes as well as tax representation from the tax audit stage through to full income tax litigation including rectification applications and tax fraud assistance.