Check it out!

Lawyerist

Podcast

Edit This Favorite

Chester County is one of the three
original counties of Pennsylvania, established in 1682. Its Court is
well over three centuries old, as is its Bar.

One needed an attorney in
order to safely navigate the maze of procedures and technicalities, but
attorneys were scarce. They were disliked. In fact, in
1677, attorneys were banned altogether from practicing in the predecessor court
at Upland in what became Chester County upon William Penn’s arrival.

William
Penn was, of course, a Quaker and his faith and prior experiences in England
shaped his approach to litigation. While he did desire to establish
courts of justice in each county, he directed that every court choose
"three peacemakers” to prevent lawsuits. He wrote on August 16,
1683 that they were "to hear and end differences betwixt man and
man.” Thus, Chester County had one of the first alternative dispute
resolution (ARD) procedures in America. The Society of Friends was
not very keen on attorneys either. They used their influence to
prefer laymen over attorneys in the administration of justice in the court, to
be exercised principally in accord with their own consciences, unhampered by
precedent or the technical forms of procedure.

Notwithstanding
this inauspicious start, attorneys did appear in Penn’s new province in Chester
County. The first two were John White and Abraham Mann, in
1683. In 1709, there were but four members of the Bar, which became
a problem for litigant Francis Daniel Pastorious when his adversary retained
all of them. This left him without representation, as he complained
to the court, unless he fetched someone from New York. This he
stated he could not afford to do.

It
would take some years before trained lawyers gained a secure footing in
court. By 1701, however, the court was authorized to issue rules of
practice and procedure, and the technicalities multiplied accordingly.

Many
ancient practices and forms of English law were imported here. There
was the Court of Quarter Sessions, which handled certain criminal cases,
including witchcraft, as well as petitions to open new roads, the Court of Oyer
and Terminer (literally, "to hear and determine”), which handled felonies,
treason and certain appeals, the Court of Common Pleas, for general cases in
law and equity, and the Orphans’ Court with jurisdiction over widows, orphans
and decedents’ estates. The last two are still in operation today.

Old Chester Courthouse, Chester, Pennsylvania

Erected in 1724, this is the
oldest public building in continuous use in the United States. It is a handsome
structure, and a well-preserved example of a colonial period stone
courthouse.

The number of members of
the Bar in Chester County grew during Colonial and Revolutionary times. Many
attorneys rose to distinction. Perhaps the most famous of them all
was Thomas McKean. He was born and raised in New London
Township. He was admitted to the Bar and, in 1777, became a judge in
Chester County. McKean was a Signer of the Declaration of
Independence, and a Framer of the United States Constitution. He was
the Chief Justice of the Pennsylvania Supreme Court for 22 years and, after
that, was elected governor of the Commonwealth.

Thomas McKean, Signer and Framer

James Wilson, of the
Chester County Bar, was one of the first six justices of the United States
Supreme Court appointed in 1789 by George Washington.

In the early days of the
Republic, "the Gentlemen of the Bar”, as they referred to themselves, had
occasion to unite in order to uphold their dignity. For example, in
1797, matters had gotten so out of hand during trials that the group filed a
petition with the Court to express their "extreme inconvenience
Interruption, and disgust” at the habit of spectators to seat themselves at
counsel table. The Court was asked to make it the business of one of
its offices to shoo such strangers away in the name of "decent
deportment.”

In the early 1800's, members of the Bar gathered
together to conduct their business, as they had for the past century, in
taverns and public houses (i.e., "pubs”). Each generation had
its de facto head of the bar. In the 1840’s it was Townsend Haines,
Esquire, who was acclaimed "the ablest”. After him, it was
Isaac Darlington.

Leaders of the Bar, circa 1859

Books were very expensive,
and attorneys needed books; they "read” the law after all. Without access
to them, they could not practice. And so it was that on January 27, 1862,
the Bar’s petition was approved to establish the Chester County Law and
Miscellaneous Library. Its purpose was to hire a librarian and "hold
for safekeeping and reference” not only law books, but also "works of art,
maps … and matters of literary and scientific nature.” An initiation fee
of $5.00 was charged to the members of the Bar, with annual dues
thereafter. Some years later, the income of the Library was substantially
augmented by legislation which directed that certain fines and forfeitures be
paid over to it. The Law and Miscellaneous Library continued active
operations on this basis for the next 118 years, until the law changed again so
as to require the County of Chester to fund the law library.

In the last half of the
nineteenth century the Chester County Bar Committee was formed. It
advocated in a more formal way for the advancement of the profession. It
cultivated collegiality. Under its auspices, the Bar would come together
regularly to conduct memorials to their deceased brethren and to have their
group photograph taken on the steps of the Courthouse.

In those old photographs,
after 1897, a hat with a feather began to appear over a feminine face.
These belonged to the first woman admitted to practice in Chester County,
Isabel Darlington (U. Pa. School of Law, LLB, 1897). One of only a
handful of women attorneys in the entire country, she would practice law for
the next half century.

Isabel Darlingon, Esquire

In 1910, the number of
members of the Bar was just over 50. By 1929, the Bar Committee had given
way to the Chester County Bar Association. This was the name of an
unincorporated association whose president that year was A.M. Holding.

These organizations had
operated so well that there was no real pressure to incorporate. But at the
close of the Second World War, the members of the Bar decided to form a
perpetual corporation under the Pennsylvania Non-Profit Corporation Law.
The Articles of Incorporation of the Chester County Bar Association were signed
April 23, 1945 and filed in 1947. The Chester County Bar Association has
operated in its current form since that time.

During the post-war years,
the population of the County grew at a dramatic rate, and the number of
attorneys in the Association also grew. The Bar Association began to concern
itself with public service as well as the advancement of the profession.
In 1975, the membership of the Bar was 230 lawyers. Membership now stands
at nearly 1,000. The Bar Association publishes the Chester County Law
Reporter, a periodical called New Matter and sponsors Mock Trial and Law Day
Programs. It also maintains a Lawyer Referral and Information Service. As
you can see from the other pages of the website, the Association has dozens of
different committees and sections, along with the Young Lawyers Division, all
of which work together to promote the welfare of the Bench, the Bar and the
public.

The first woman Bar member
to be elected as the first female judge of the County Court after three
centuries was Paula Francisco Ott, Esquire. She was elected in 1991 and
took her seat on the Bench the following year. In 2005, she was chosen to
be the President Judge. She later ran for and won a seat on the Superior
Court of Pennsylvania in 2010.

For further reading:

Chester
County PA Legal Practitioners to 1960, Robert E. Carlson, West
Chester, PA (1988)Side
Lights on the Bench & Bar of Chester County, W.W. MacElree, West
Chester, PA (1918)Chester
County and Its People, W.W. Thompson, Chicago & New York, The
Union History Company (1898)History
of Chester County, Futhey and Cope, Phila., Everts (1881)