Remember What These Second Chance Castaways Are Originally Known For?

3/21

Jeff Varner (Season 2)

On Survivor: The Australian Outback, Jeff was considered a big threat at the merge, which is why he was targeted and ended up in 10th place.

This castaway wasn't afraid to play dirty, and his most memorable moment was stepping down from Immunity Challenge for peanut butter. That's right—peanut butter, people! Jeff jumped off a pole for that gooey goodness, which is something he still considers his biggest game mistake.