American Cultural Imperialism: Fact or Myth?The phenomenon known as globalization has brought sweeping changes to the world. Forces associated with globalization like the spread of capitalism, advancements in communications and information technology, and expansion of the media have contributed to these changes. The main trademark of globalization has been an increasing flow of exchange in trade and culture. With this lowering of barriers, some people have begun to talk of a global culture. Others go even further to fear cultural imperialism from powers dominant in trade products, multinational corporations, and media. More specifically, critics are attacking the American hegemony on culture, with its domination in media and commercial products. However, it is easy to cry wolf in these situations. To determine if American cultural imperialism is occurring, we must examine concepts of cultural imperialism, how it is spread, and cultural imperialist theories in relation to media and commercial products of capitalism, and the counterarguments against those theories. After this careful examination, I will show that the cultural imperialism thesis is severely weakened in the face of human agency and hybridization, and that fears of American hegemony in culture are exaggerated.

Establishing a general concept of cultural imperialism is important. The problem with many cultural imperialism arguments is that often they refer to different meanings. For instance, Petras defines cultural imperialism as "the systematic penetration and domination of the cultural life of the popular classes by the ruling class of the West in order to reorder the values, behavior, institutions, and identity of the oppressed peoples to conform with the interests of the imperial classes" (Petras 139). However, his definition may clash with the concept of cultural imperialism formed by other imperialist theorists. In fact, many will find it difficult to provide substantial evidence of the "systematic penetration" of the dominant class, while others may find the definition too narrow. As Tomlinson points out, achieving a single definition of cultural imperialism is difficult because it would not encompass every sense in which the term is used. Much of the problem of defining cultural imperialism stems from the definitional complexities of the two components of the term, culture and imperialism. Culture and imperialism themselves cannot be reduced to a single meaning. For example, imperialism refers to political and economic systems. Our focus, American imperialism, refers primarily to the economic denomination associated with the global reach of capitalism. Tomlinson claims that it is even harder to tie down culture to a broadly accepted definition because it would likely lead to a level of generality as to make the definition useless. Thus, our goal should not be to find a working definition of cultural imperialism, but to discern how people use the term in contemporary discourses. In a general sense, culture refers to the signifying system of a particular way of life. Thus, for our purposes, cultural imperialism refers to the domination of a foreign culture over a native way of life. We can add that political and economic power is often associated to this spread of cultural imperialism.

Using this general concept of cultural imperialism, we can examine the ways in which cultural imperialism is said to be transmitted. The cultural imperialism thesis claims that "authentic, traditional, and local culture in many parts of the world is being battered out of existence by the indiscriminate dumping of large quantities of slick commercial and media products, mainly from the United States" (Tomlinson 8). The main focus of cultural imperialism debate, especially American imperialism, has been on the use of commercial and media products to spread American culture and values that threaten to "suppress" local cultures. Critics...

YOU MAY ALSO FIND THESE DOCUMENTS HELPFUL

...explores the validity of the CulturalImperialism Theory which says the Western culture has dominated the cultures of developing Nations. It examines to what extent and how the Western world in the real sense has dominated the developing countries. The study further examined the means through which the developing countries are being dominated culturally by the Western culture. The paper further looked at both the negative and the positive effects of...

...The theory of culturalimperialism in media is where one culture controls another, forcing
it's culture to change to the controlling one . This theory is said to have first developed in the
mid-twentieth century, and initially it was a response to the changes society was undergoing after
the development of improved telecommunications. Various terms such as "media imperialism",
"structural imperialism", and...

...MEDIA/CULTURALIMPERIALISM AND NATIONAL IMAGE. THE WAY FORWARD FOR NIGERIA.
INTRODUCTION
Information plays a paramount role in every form and context of relations. The spheres of information range from local, regional, national and international, both as a means of communication between people and as an instrument of understanding and knowledge between nations. The media is often owned by the rich and the capitalists. Thus whoever controls it has a very...

...In the article, In Praise of CulturalImperialism, David Rothkopf illustrates a progressive new world order where information is the new global currency and the United States, "the indispensable nation," is the bank. In his article, Rothkopf contrasts the victimizing tendencies of 'cultural barriers', which are the unmistakably causing ethnic, religious, ideological, tribal or nationalistic conflicts, to the uniting tendencies of western...

...When a sub-ordinate nation is ruled by a more dominant nation, the dominant nation passes on most of its cultural traits, most notably language, onto the sub-ordinate nation through power. This transfer of one culture onto another, is what we call, culturalimperialism. The language that is believed to be the dominant language today is the ‘English’ language, which obviously comes from the western culture. In today’s world you see English spoken...

...﻿ “ To understand cultural globalization, we must define each of the terms culture and globalization. Culture is the characteristic of a group of people recognized by their language, ethnicity, nationalism, religion, behavior and other forms of identity. Globalization is the phenomenon in which several systems across the globe, such as the economy, environment, politics, and culture… become increasingly part of an interdependent whole system. According to Investor Word,...

...CulturalImperialism
CULTURALIMPERIALISM
What is CulturalImperialism?
Culturalimperialism is the practice of promoting, distinguishing, separating, and artificially injecting the culture or language of one nation in another. It is usually the case that the former is a large, economically or militarily powerful nation and the latter is a smaller, less affluent nation. Cultural...

...﻿Assignment One
6. How and why is the argument of culturalimperialism unanswerable?
In order to answer the question of such a complex issue, I wish to delve into the ambivalent relationship between traditionalism and modernisation as more cultures are forced to interact with one another, focusing primarily on the personal level, that of self identity, and the roles particular individuals play when constantly bombarded by modern media from around the world....