Sunday, February 10, 2013

2013 Questions

Camp starts tomorrow, and the question remains...is this the year that Bucs compete? The answer to that question is wrapped up in the answers to these questions:

Can Jason Grilli close? The 36 year old is getting his first crack at finishing games. His eighth inning work has been strong, but will it carry over? Grilled Cheese has 5 career saves, and worked 8-1/3 frames in the ninth last year, so he doesn't have a track record. His eighth and ninth innings metrics were pretty similar in 2012, but whether or not he thrives as the man is yet to be seen. If he falters, Mark Melancon has closing experience, and Buc youngsters Bryan Morris, Vic Black, and Duke Welker have served in the role.

Can anyone lead off? The Bucs are counting on Starling Marte and Travis Snider/Jose Tabata to fill the 1-2 holes in the lineup. In 2012, their OBPs were .324 (Snider), .315 (JT) and .300 (Marte) and they had just 22 stolen sacks among them. The Pirates would like to see better plate discipline and a more threatening presence on the bases (tho Marte is good at swiping sacks, taking 12-of-17 in 2012) to properly set the table this year. There aren't any natural top of the order guys on the roster outside of JT and Marte - Snider is misplaced at the top of the lineup - so there's not much help on the horizon outside of Alex Presley and maybe Felix Pie.

How will the rotation fare? Wandy Rodriguez is the only consistent starter on the staff. We suspect AJ will remain strong, too - the NL Central isn't the AL East, and he seems to thrive in his alpha dog role. After them, Ray Searage has James McDonald, Francisco Liriano and Jonathan Sanchez, all with swing-and-miss stuff but frustratingly up and down, steady but fragile soft tosser Jeff Karstens, the summer return of Charlie Morton and pups lining up on Federal Street as the minor league pipeline is finally reaching Pittsburgh. But it's a tough staff to get a feel for - it's as deep as it has ever been in the Neal Huntington tenure, but with a lot of arms that are higher in potential than in performance.

Will right field sort itself out? The Pirates already have Marte in left, and in his first full season he'll be a work in progress as he plays cat and mouse with MLB pitchers. So they'll need some production from right while he learns the ropes, and it looks now like the Clemente Wall will be defended by JT and Travis Snider. It's possible Tabata will have a bounce back season and Snider will perform like a top pick, but the Bucs are in trouble if they repeat their pedestrian 2012 numbers.

What will be the effects of losing the Astros? Yah, they were everyone's punching bag last year; no one in the division had a losing record against them. But Pittsburgh especially owned them; their 12 wins against Houston was the most by any team. The schedule will smooth things out somewhat, but their loss is likely to cost the Bucs at least a couple or three wins during the campaign.

Will the core regress? Neil Walker has been the poster child for consistency over his brief career; his only question is his balky back. But can Cutch have another MVP-type season, will Pedro improve, hold steady, or slip, and can Garrett Jones continue to be a hammer? Those guys are the heart of the lineup, and the Pirate ability to generate runs lies squarely on their ability to square up baseballs.

Will the bottom of the order remain an abyss? We'd bet on a bounce back by Clint Barmes; he hit .254, which is about his upper limit, over the last four months of the season after a dreadful start. Russell Martin doesn't have a very high bar to hurdle, but his average has dropped every season beginning in 2008, from .280 to .211. He's projected to have a .240 BA and .330 OBP with 15 HR in 2013, and if he does, he'll be an upgrade.

Can the Bucs play six months of baseball? In 2011, a not terribly deep team lost both players and confidence over the last two months, leading to a spectacular nosedive. Last year, the pitching, epitomized by J-Mac, tailed off; the starters couldn't go deep and the bullpen wore down. The Buc deadline moves were made with an eye to the future rather than the day, and Cutch played like a mortal for a spell. In 2013, the team looks deeper, at least in pitching, and should be more mature. They are better built for a longer run. The bigger question is will they be in a race come August?

5 comments:

"Losing" the DisAstros is a major blow to the Pirates, for all the reasons you mentioned, Ron. But I think you put your finger directly on the more important issues for this team heading into 2013. There are a lot of things---to my mind, too many things---that have to break just right in order for this team to make any noise or even to win more than they lose. Most of those issues have to do with hitting, which is the opposite of how things usually go. Most of the time, it's the pitching that you wonder about rather than the hitting. The Pirates seem to have a solid-to-better-than-average, top to bottom pitching staff, and they have some young if still unproven depth. But expecting the likes of Garrett Jones, Travis Snider, Jose Tabata, and especially Neil Walker with his back and Pedro Alvarez with his swiss cheese bat to carry us....I dunno, man.

Agreed, Will, that the attack depends almost entirely on young guys improving. If the past is any kind of teacher, for everyone that does, another will regress. There's still a big talent gap in position players between the upper and lower levels.

I am cautiously optimistic about the pitching. It goes against the flow, but I thin Sanchez may have the best chance of being a bounce back guy, especially if he's slotted at the back end.

There are a lot of ifs, and as you say, things have to break right for the Bucs to make noise this year.

There are too many Ifs for me.Pedro doesn't hit with any consistency and drives in runs in bunches and disappears.Marte and Snyder need to stay healthy and produce for a whole season.AJ started to show signs of wear and tear in second half.JMac doesn't have the stamina to pitch for a whole season.Jeff K is good,when he is sound.Last two seasons problems.I doubt the pen will make up for the loss of the Hammer and Brad.Catching will be better,but they need to do a better job throwing out runners.Pitchers need to hold them on as well.Clint needs to manager better and prepare team for periods of playing without many off days.He failed miserably to do so and our staff went south.Players need to get rest when they have stretches like this.Liriano was a bad sign to a staff that has history of arm problems.I hope Jones can be a reliable bat.Team won't make playoffs or beat out Reds,Cards and Brewers.Reaching 500 is a mirage.I wish we had a different owner and FO>

Anon - the team does have a lot of ifs, and it will take a lot of pieces falling the right way to make them playoff competitive.

The major concern I have now is that the positional talent is all in A ball; I hope that gap between the pitching prospects and the field players doesn't leave too large a gap. That could really limit any future window that may open.

I think that's why the FO has been fast tracking guys; it may pay dividends or may set them back some down the road.

Talk It Up

If you have any thoughts to share or an idea for a future post, we're all ears. Give us a shout atThe Green Weenie. And by all means, let your voice be heard and leave a comment. We enjoy the chatter.

One rule: if you want to leave a relevant link, or a link to your site, that's fine with us; the more the merrier. But if you're trying to sell stuff or are leaving flaming posts, we zap it, no questions asked.