Minutes:
http://www.w3.org/2012/08/30-svg-minutes.html
and as text:
[1]W3C
[1] http://www.w3.org/
- DRAFT -
SVG Working Group Teleconference
30 Aug 2012
[2]Agenda
[2] http://lists.w3.org/Archives/Public/public-svg-wg/2012JulSep/0179.html
See also: [3]IRC log
[3] http://www.w3.org/2012/08/30-svg-irc
Attendees
Present
+1.415.832.aaaa, birtles, nikos, krit, ed, [IPcaller],
heycam, +33.9.80.39.aabb, Rich, cyril_,
+33.9.53.77.aacc, Tav, Doug_Schepers
Regrets
Chair
Cameron
Scribe
nikos
Contents
* [4]Topics
1. [5]CSS4 image type as paint value
2. [6]Filter subregion clipping
3. [7]Behaviour of feOffset dx/dy values with percentages
4. [8]Commas vs spaces in SVG View fragment identifiers
5. [9]maskType, and camel case elements/attributes more
generally
* [10]Summary of Action Items
__________________________________________________________
<trackbot> Date: 30 August 2012
<krit> Zakim: aaaa is me
<scribe> scribenick: nikos
CSS4 image type as paint value
<heycam>
[11]http://www.w3.org/mid/FBBDBDBC-F3CD-404E-AFC1-0369A75DAA89@
adobe.com
[11] http://www.w3.org/mid/FBBDBDBC-F3CD-404E-AFC1-0369A75DAA89@adobe.com
krit: Doesn't matter about the version. I'd just like to use
CSS image
... then we get linear gradient and other gradients
... If we use CSS image as a paint server then it's possible to
use images or filters or anything that is defined by CSS image
birtles: What about making paint servers part of images?
... a lot of CSS specs refer to image values, why not do it the
other way around
... then you could use an SVG gradient in CSS
krit: That is in CSS4 image
<ed> so <rect fill="linear-gradient(bottom, rgb(149,227,138)
47%, rgb(179,255,166) 74%)" .../> for example
krit: we need to figure out how it works because it could lead
to circular dependency
... The element function can reference paint servers from SVG
heycam: Do you want paint server references just inside that
element or do you allow urls?
<krit> [12]http://dev.w3.org/csswg/css3-images/#image-values
[12] http://dev.w3.org/csswg/css3-images/#image-values
krit: I am just asking if we can use the css image type in SVG
fill and stroke properties
... in the beginning I'd be fine with gradient
<heycam> ack
krit: image would be cool but if we just have gradient that
would be good
cyril_: for gradients or patterns you have the gradient limits
that tells you how the gradient space maps to the image space
... how would you do that
krit: you need to define how the bounding box is defined for
svg and it would maybe be object bounding box
cyril_: would the svg objects crop the image or would the image
be entirely contained in the svg object?
krit: you mean referencing an image with a url?
cyril_: any image. css3 image fills an object with an image
... you might end up with an image size different from the svg
object size so you need to crop, or reflect, or something
krit: at the beginning we might just define gradient. its
easier
<krit> [13]http://dev.w3.org/csswg/css3-images/#gradient-type
[13] http://dev.w3.org/csswg/css3-images/#gradient-type
cyril_: Using percentages or integers or fixed values, you can
say the image will take more or less than the bounding box of
the object
... you have to define if you crop, or what you do
krit: I agree with that
... At the beginning I'd be fine to just use gradients as this
isn't a problem for them
... you just need to define a box, and we'd just use the object
bounding box
heycam: I think cyrils concern was that it's not clear whether
gradients cover the entire box or whether you pad or repeat
... I think we need a way to specify whether you repeat in
horizontal or vertical directions
nikos: I think dirk is saying you use the object bounding box
so the dimensions always match up
cyril_: in css gradients I don't think you can specify where
the 2 end points of the vector defining the gradient are -
except for top or bottom
heycam: you can give a length value
cyril_: I'm seeing left, right, top, bottom, thats it
... you can't say I want the points to be 10% inside
... then you don't have to specify pad or repeat
... there is a repeating linear gradient
krit: that's a limitation in css gradients in general, why is
it a problem for svg?
cyril_: I'm just saying it needs to be specified how the object
is filled when the gradient is not big enough
heycam: from what I can see it will always be big enough
... you have stops that go from 0 to 100%
cyril_: Yeh with gradient it seems you will always fill the
object
heycam: With images I think you're right about fitting.
... Are the only types images and gradients?
cyril_: url image_list and gradient
heycam: I'm sure we could define how the image renders without
adding more controls like various background repeat properties
... I don't know how useful it is to solve that here
... maybe in that case you need to use a pattern for example
krit: Can we resolve for linear gradient and solve the other
problems later?
heycam: I'm happy with it
ed: I agree
cyril_: what would be the benefit compared to using svg
gradient?
krit: you can apply a linear gradient to a class of object
... and use the same gradient for html and svg content
cyril_: ok
heycam: it's also an easier way to specify a gradient
Resolution: Paint values will allow gradients from CSS3 image
krit: CSS image 3 is already a REC
<heycam>
[14]http://dev.w3.org/csswg/css3-images/#repeating-gradients
[14] http://dev.w3.org/csswg/css3-images/#repeating-gradients
heycam: I see you can do repeating gradient styles in CSS
cyril_: in any case it's going to fill the whole object
krit: will it be in the SVG2 FPWD or is it for the future?
heycam: I think we've discussed this before in the context of
referencing as many CSS specs as possible
krit: so SVG 2 then
... next draft release
heycam: If you have time
<scribe> ACTION: Dirk to edit SVG 2 draft to add CSS 3
gradients as a paint value [recorded in
[15]http://www.w3.org/2012/08/30-svg-minutes.html#action01]
<trackbot> Created ACTION-3346 - Edit SVG 2 draft to add CSS 3
gradients as a paint value [on Dirk Schulze - due 2012-09-06].
Filter subregion clipping
ed: I sent my comments to the public mailing list
... I think it addressed both discussions
... feOffset and how to define input and output clipping
<ed>
[16]http://lists.w3.org/Archives/Public/www-svg/2012Aug/0143.ht
ml
[16] http://lists.w3.org/Archives/Public/www-svg/2012Aug/0143.html
ed: so in Opera we treat feOffset not exactly as the spec tells
us to, because if you consider the example in the mail,
feOffset itself doesn't specify a primitive subregion - doesn't
have x, y and width. Intuitively for me I wouldn't expect it to
clip, I'd expect it to move the previous primitive
krit: I would agree that we don't need to clip the offset, we
move it around
... Do you clip if you move a primitive to the outside of
filter regions then bring it back in?
heycam: do you clip at each step or just once at the end?
ed: Could you post an example?
<krit> <filter id="feoffset1"
primitiveUnits="objectBoundingBox" x="0%" y="0%"
<krit> width="100%" height="100%">
<krit> <feFlood width="100%" height="100%" flood-color="lime"/>
<krit> <feOffset dx="0.1" dy="0.2"/>
<krit> </filter>
ed: So you move the result out and back again?
... what would you expect in that case?
krit: I think the spec says it's clipped away
... when you move it back you are just moving transparent black
back
ed: I'm not really sure what I'd expect in that case
... I think I might expect to be able to move the result back
... it would be interesting to see what the implementations do
krit: it would be interesting to see what gaussian blur does
ed: I think it would be interesting to have some way of letting
the user agent find out what the filter region is
automatically, but we'd have to be careful not to break content
krit: In this case we definitely should clip, the question is
does opera clip
... Do you clip the input or the output?
... that's a general question
ed: I think we do input clipping
krit: filter effects spec requires input and output clipping,
which is not useful in my eyes
ed: So do we want to control this, or do we require one
particular way?
krit: I think both input and output is not useful
... I don't care if we go with input or output
heycam: what might break if we switched? if we specified just
output
krit: we are really discussion an edge case so I wouldn't
expect much to break
heycam: it only matters to primitives that do things outside
their region
... most filter primitives say their input and output regions
are the same
... is that right?
krit: by default, firefox's subregion depends on the previous
subregion so if you have 2 filters of different size, it is the
union of both
... when you specify x, y, w and h what should be clipped, the
input or the output?
ed: do you have a test case?
krit: I have posted something to the mailing list
ed: I'm looking for something that doesn't use feOffset
krit: it's difficult without feOffset
ed: We treat it differently, we don't take the union of the
inputs, we use the filter region itself if you don't specify
heycam: apart from whether you do clipping on input or output.
Dirk, do you think it makes sense to special case feOffset?
krit: if you don't have input clipping it doesn't matter
... in that case the subregion depends on the clipregion of the
feOffset filter
... I'd have to think about it some more
... right now the specification wants to clip to the region
always
heycam: the spec only says clip the input and output both
... to make feOffset more useful, would we need to change it to
only output or only input? or is that a separate issue
krit: I think it's separate
ed: I think it would be nice to have an analysis of where and
when it's useful to have each clipping method
heycam: I think it would be good too, I find it hard to
visualise why you'd take one or the other
ed: There's one example in the spec but I don't think it uses
feOffset
... There's also the example from the mail and the bug report
... but apart from that I don't think we have many tests for
this
<scribe> ACTION: Dirk to investigate and expand on the proposal
of sub region clipping for Filter Effects [recorded in
[17]http://www.w3.org/2012/08/30-svg-minutes.html#action02]
<trackbot> Created ACTION-3347 - Investigate and expand on the
proposal of sub region clipping for Filter Effects [on Dirk
Schulze - due 2012-09-06].
heycam: what about for the other issue of whether feOffset
behaviour should be special?
krit: I'll look into that as well
ed: They're similar but not quite the same
<krit> nikos: great, thanks. Let us share the examples next
week
<krit> haha
heycam: i imagine you could construct the filter to avoid the
problem - don't shift outside the region
ed: not many people write such advanced filters that they would
run into this issue
heycam: we'll pick up the discussion once dirk has had a look
Behaviour of feOffset dx/dy values with percentages
heycam: does anyone support percentage values for dx and dy?
krit: if you use 50% then it is treated as 50
... on webkit
heycam: we should make percentages work or disallow them
krit: We already support percentage - but indirectly
heycam: why is it that dx and dy unitless values are treated as
unit bounding box values and not ...
... if you have unit less values they are just user units
... there's nothing weird and I'd expect percentages to be
percentages of the viewport
... if you have primitive space = user space on use, dx and dy
should be percentages of the viewport?
krit: if you supported percentages, but we don't
heycam: do we have other primitives that take percentages?
krit: no
heycam: my feeling is that we should make percentages work
krit: and for other cases?
... where percentages could work?
heycam: so the issue with standard deviation is it's a number
not a length right?
<krit>
[18]https://dvcs.w3.org/hg/FXTF/raw-file/tip/filters/index.html
#FilterFunction
[18] https://dvcs.w3.org/hg/FXTF/raw-file/tip/filters/index.html#FilterFunction
heycam: in the corresponding shorthand if we are going to
support lengths, we should take lengths in the element
... I'm thinking whether it would be more consistent in general
to support that, but I'm not sure that it's important
ed: is there any particular examples?
... I'm looking for some kind of testcase to try out
... just wondering if you had one handy
heycam: I think dx and dy look like they go with width and
height, you might expect them to take the same kinds of value
krit: I agree
heycam: I would be happy to say dx and dy take lengths and
percentages and forget about the other things like standard
deviation
ed: I'd like to see an example before we make any changes
<scribe> ACTION: Dirk to provide examples of percentages with
dx and dy in Filter Effects [recorded in
[19]http://www.w3.org/2012/08/30-svg-minutes.html#action03]
<trackbot> Created ACTION-3348 - Provide examples of
percentages with dx and dy in Filter Effects [on Dirk Schulze -
due 2012-09-06].
Commas vs spaces in SVG View fragment identifiers
<krit> [20]http://dev.w3.org/csswg/css4-images/#image-fragments
[20] http://dev.w3.org/csswg/css4-images/#image-fragments
heycam: Robert brought up in the mailing list some text in the
linking chapter that talks about how you must use commas rather
than spaces in the viewbox part of an svg fragment. You can use
%20 to encode spaces but it's easier to use commas.
... there's a similar issue in preserve aspect ratio, because
you can have the slice value after the xMinyMin part
... and that normally takes a space between them
... I think viewbox also would normally take a space, so
there's no issue saying just use a comma
... I think Robert was asking for a clarification on the
grammar
krit: I don't like spaces in iri
... I pasted a link to css image fragments, they comma separate
... I don't have a really strong opinion but I feel its more
natural
heycam: I agree, you don't really want to url encode
ed: I agree with the comma, even though I don't like the svg
view syntax.
krit: the css specifications use uri and svg uses iri
... in theory there's a difference but in practice there's not
... do we have a strong opinion that we should use iri?
heycam: I raised something on the mailing list about the
differences. I didn't get a clear idea in the end whether one
or the other should change or whether we ignore the situation
krit: Filter Effects uses iri and the discussion on exclusions
they want to use parts of svg that use iri
... it would be good to harmonise the specifications
<heycam>
[21]http://lists.w3.org/Archives/Public/www-style/2012May/0772.
html
[21] http://lists.w3.org/Archives/Public/www-style/2012May/0772.html
heycam: here's the mail where I asked how things in brackets
are parsed, because I think the spec doesn't really say.
... I didn't really get a satisfactory answer
ed: The Filter Effects spec uses iri because SVG 1 used iri
heycam: If you look at the data url in the email I linked to
krit: iri just supports more characters right?
heycam: yes, you can use non ascii characters
... for uri you would have to escape them somehow
... the test uses a css background image that has some non
ascii characters
... and that seems to work everywhere so I assume browsers are
interpreting as iri
krit: you tested locally?
heycam: no it's on a server
... if you view my example and 'view source'
krit: it doesn't work in Safari
ed: It doesn't seem to wokr in Opera either
heycam: It may be because I left a bracket out of the example
... I think the issue is that the css spec needs to define how
things inside the url brackets are parsed and interpreted
<heycam>
[22]http://lists.w3.org/Archives/Public/www-style/2012May/0824.
html
[22] http://lists.w3.org/Archives/Public/www-style/2012May/0824.html
<heycam> [23]http://rÃ¤ksmÃ¶rgÃ¥s.josefsson.org/raksmorgas.jpg
[23] http://r/
heycam: That's the test I meant to do... oh wait it doesn't
have the brackets either
... I tried to link to that url in background-image
... I think the css spec needs to say that the things in the
brackets are interpreted as iris or whatever they need to do to
take non ascii characters
krit: Can you bring it up with the css group?
heycam: well I sent the mail, I think if you want to bring it
up you can
... back to the topic. I think the question is whether we allow
commas or spaces
<heycam>
[24]https://svgwg.org/svg2-draft/linking.html#SVGFragmentIdenti
fiers
[24] https://svgwg.org/svg2-draft/linking.html#SVGFragmentIdentifiers
heycam: if you look at the grammar, you can see that the part
of the grammar that refers to preserve aspect ratio, aspect
params is defined in the list beneath and it's not defined
properly
... given that spaces are said to be not allowed, we need to
define it so that spaces are allowed or we can allow a comma
... I don't have a strong preference
ed: i was wondering about another issue, url escaping, firefox
did allow the url escaped spaces to work
... I couldn't find anything in the spec but it would be nice
to have it clarified
heycam: I'm not sure what what level it should do that
... is suspect if we look at the html spec it will define it
... there was meant to be a new url spec, but I don't think it
progressed much
... I think it was going to define this sort of thing
shepazu: is anyone working on it?
heycam: I think so but I don't know
... I suspect that that spec would define how to encode the
fragments and decode them
... that's the level it should be at
... I agree it would be nice to have a link to somewhere that
defines how to parse these fragments
<scribe> ACTION: Cameron to look at the url spec or find out
what we need to reference to make sure url fragments have a
well defined encoding and decoding [recorded in
[25]http://www.w3.org/2012/08/30-svg-minutes.html#action04]
<trackbot> Created ACTION-3349 - Look at the url spec or find
out what we need to reference to make sure url fragments have a
well defined encoding and decoding [on Cameron McCormack - due
2012-09-06].
heycam: Erik or anyone do you have an opinion on what to do
with the preserve aspect ratio part?
... I don't have a strong opinion
ed: this is a special case, I'd prefer if parsing was the same
as the attributes
... might not be possible
heycam: we can make it possible
ed: that would be easier implementation wise
... it's not hard anyway but consistency would be nice
shepazu: consistency means a better experience for everyone
heycam: are there any other examples?
shepazu: any attribute can have keywords
<ed> requiredFeatures is space-separated I think
<ed>
[26]http://www.w3.org/TR/SVG11/struct.html#ConditionalProcessin
gRequiredFeaturesAttribute
[26] http://www.w3.org/TR/SVG11/struct.html#ConditionalProcessingRequiredFeaturesAttribute
heycam: I think you can't just have an arbitrary name in there
or the property would fail to parse
... I was wondering about non property attributes
... I don't know any off the top of my head
... I'm concerned whether we allow commas in preserve aspect
ratio whether that will lead to it happening elsewhere
... there may not be any other cases
shepazu: there's the text, they're not keywords, they're
values. Like x or y for text
heycam: we do allow commas there
shepazu: there was a kerfuffle with stroke dash array because
it wasn't specified
... we fixed that
<shepazu> [27]http://www.w3.org/TR/SVG/attindex.html
[27] http://www.w3.org/TR/SVG/attindex.html
heycam: Unfortunately the type of value isn't in that table
... there's things that take number-space-number and they don't
take commas
shepazu: number-delimited-number should allow anything
... should allow comma or space or a combination rather
... oh transforms!
... you can have a space separated list of values and I don't
think you can use a comma there
heycam: I think you're right
krit: they can be comma or space separated
heycam: they can in the attribute but not in the property
viewbox and zoomAndPan are the only ones I can see
heycam: let me, suggest we allow commas in preserveApsectRatio
<richardschwerdtfe> have to drop
Resolution: preserveAspectRatio will allow commas in the
attribute and that part of the view specification
<scribe> ACTION: Cameron to update preserveApsectRatio in view
specification to allow commas [recorded in
[28]http://www.w3.org/2012/08/30-svg-minutes.html#action05]
<trackbot> Created ACTION-3350 - Update preserveApsectRatio in
view specification to allow commas [on Cameron McCormack - due
2012-09-06].
maskType, and camel case elements/attributes more generally
heycam: We might need to discuss this at the F2F
shepazu: I think that we should not capitalise anything
heycam: I think that's what Simon wanted
... at least on new things
<shepazu> CAPITALIZE NONE OF THE THINGS!
heycam: Maybe allowing lowercase everywhere might be the
cleanest solution
shepazu: I'm struggling to think of a place where
caplitalisation would matter if we had error correction
... is there anywhere where capitalisation would matter?
heycam: it matters from the perspective of making a dom call
... you need to use the correct capitalisation there
... I want to think about this more deeply
... it might tie in with switching modes in the SVG DOM
... like switching to no namespace
... and in that case everything is in lower case, for example.
... I do think it's an issue that we need to resolve.
... or if we keep inventing camel case names we need to make a
concious decision to go that way
... we'll continue the discussion at a later point
Summary of Action Items
[NEW] ACTION: Cameron to look at the url spec or find out what
we need to reference to make sure url fragments have a well
defined encoding and decoding [recorded in
[29]http://www.w3.org/2012/08/30-svg-minutes.html#action04]
[NEW] ACTION: Cameron to update preserveApsectRatio in view
specification to allow commas [recorded in
[30]http://www.w3.org/2012/08/30-svg-minutes.html#action05]
[NEW] ACTION: Dirk to edit SVG 2 draft to add CSS 3 gradients
as a paint value [recorded in
[31]http://www.w3.org/2012/08/30-svg-minutes.html#action01]
[NEW] ACTION: Dirk to investigate and expand on the proposal of
sub region clipping for Filter Effects [recorded in
[32]http://www.w3.org/2012/08/30-svg-minutes.html#action02]
[NEW] ACTION: Dirk to provide examples of percentages with dx
and dy in Filter Effects [recorded in
[33]http://www.w3.org/2012/08/30-svg-minutes.html#action03]
[End of minutes]
__________________________________________________________
Minutes formatted by David Booth's [34]scribe.perl version
1.136 ([35]CVS log)
$Date: 2012/08/30 22:30:55 $
The information contained in this email message and any attachments may be confidential and may also be the subject to legal professional privilege. If you are not the intended recipient, any use, interference with, disclosure or copying of this material is unauthorised and prohibited. If you have received this email in error, please immediately advise the sender by return email and delete the information from your system.