Companies have wised up to the fact that these days, guys want to look polished and presentable. That's great news. The downside? The market's now flooded with products, and there's simply no way you could try them all. But we can. See how our editors' picks—from cologne to cleanser to hand and eye creams—compare to your own favorites and those of the thousands of readers whose poll responses we've tallied over the past month. Consider it the ultimate consumer report for the well-groomed man.