EA Sports released a video compilation on Tuesday the same day the legend Peyton Manning decided to call it a career and retire from the NFL. Never realized until now that he has never been on a Madden cover, not like that’s a good thing anyway.

“The video shows Manning as a pixelated rookie in Madden ’99, tossing touchdowns to old teammates Reggie Wayne, Marvin Harrison, and Dallas Clark, and, of course, capping off his career by winning Super Bowl 50.”