I thought the movie was alright but the role really didn't seem to suit Elijah. There wasn't any chemistry at all between Sean (Elijah) and his wife (Rosario Dawson).this could be because they hadn't seen each other in 3 years but there still didn't seem to be anything there. When Rosario Dawson was on the Conon O'Brian show after Elijah, they barely spoke to each other. That same piano tune was used thruout the movie. It got kind of annoying. None of my family liked it. I'mexpecting a lot more from Try 17.

Actually there aren't that many Elijah scenes in the movie. The movie isn't even 1 hour and 40 minutes and Elijah is shown in the first scene for about 2 minutes, not saying anything. Then for about 40 to 50 minutes the characters are saying they hear Sean (Elijah) is back from the dead but they don't show him. It was kind of annoying because his name was mentioned in every scene but we didn't see him. Finally he came into it but Edward Burns kept getting all the screen time. There was enough Elijah at the end but I thought he could have had more to work with. I'd recommend it just for a look though. The role isn't as small as Black and White or anything. Probably the same amount of scenes he had in Deep Impact

i'm sorry to say it but i hate this movie!!!!!!!not offenese to those of u who like it tho, it's just my opinion

i mean, this is just a simple story, why do they made it so long?! it made the whole movie so boring becasue it kept repeating, it spent at least a half hour for the neighborhood dicussed if Sean(elijah) still exist or not...and i hate that edward burns, no one in this movie is acting good, including elijah, he doesn't even know what was he doing in some part....the story, itself just doesn't make sense at all

Doesn't seem like you guys think it's that great of a movie.. i think i'll just rent it. I went to buy the ice storm the other day but i needed to wait for an hour so i could get money from someone then i went back and this chick had bought it 15 mins before i could get back!! i was mad.. oh well i'm sure i can find it somewheres else (there was only 1).. not like anyone cares or anything.. yea neways