"Bella Notte" from Lady and the Tramp is featured in New York, the twenty-second and final episode of Season Two. It is sung by Artie, Mike, Puck, and Sam, with Puck playing the accordion.

It is played while Finn, who is acting upon his remaining feelings, and Rachel are walking through the streets together at night after their date. When Finn says that they would need some background music, the other four come into view and start singing "Bella Notte." However, when Finn leans in to kiss Rachel, she rejects him, leaving him confused and disappointed.