Author
Topic: Lexar CF cards FAIL - Sandisk? (Read 17209 times)

Is anyone else having massive failures with their Lexar CF cards. I've had a few cards have complete corruptions that lose all data and is not recoverable by any software, tekserve or even Lexars 8-12 week in house recovery. The card only shows 33MB in recovery. They have a great warranty program so everything is replaceable except for the lost work. I've been shooting small jpegs to second card slot, but still not satisfied with that solution.

Is anyone else having this error? Does it happen with Sandisk? Has anyone used the Raw Steel cards?

I think I'm going to switch completely this week. I've been slow to as I know sandisk have a worse warranty program. But if they don't fail then I won't need it.

Anyone else have the 33MB card failure? Could you recover anything? Does this happen with Sandisk?

canon rumors FORUM

No, my Lexar cards are fine. Sandisk is reported on this forum to have some issues.

How many cards failed? You make it sound as though you have a lot of them and they all failed.

Individual cards fail, and, of course, counterfits fail frequently. Even batches of a certain lot can have a die flaw.

Which cards failed,? Is there a serial number laser engraved on the back edge of the card. I'd ask for it, but mine is a very long code and I'd likely make a error copying it. (Its hard to see, because its engraved on black)

I've seen a couple of posts complaining about Lexar cards. I've been considering getting a few of the Pro 1000x cards for the speed. Now I'm hesitant. I've been using Sandisk for many years. I also have one Photofast card. I haven't had any failures with any of them. Where did you purchase your cards? My understanding is that there are a lot of counterfeit cards being sold on Amazon.In what camera body/bodies of yours have the Lexar cards failed?My Sandisk cards have been used in many bodies without a failure:1Dx, 1DIV, 1DsIII, 1DsII, 1DIIn

I've seen a couple of posts complaining about Lexar cards. I've been considering getting a few of the Pro 1000x cards for the speed. Now I'm hesitant. I've been using Sandisk for many years. I also have one Photofast card. I haven't had any failures with any of them. Where did you purchase your cards? My understanding is that there are a lot of counterfeit cards being sold on Amazon.In what camera body/bodies of yours have the Lexar cards failed?My Sandisk cards have been used in many bodies without a failure:1Dx, 1DIV, 1DsIII, 1DsII, 1DIIn

Since Lexar replaced them for him, they are not counterfits, but it is unusual for cards to fail.

How many times had you used the cards before the failure? CF manufacturing defects tend to show up early in the use life of the device. You should test your cards thoroughlybefore you trust them for important work.

I've used both Lexar and Sandisk with pretty much equal success. I had some Sandisk cards fail on me about 10 years ago, but since then, the only other card I've had fail was a Delkin.

I think Lexar and Sandisk haver similarly good products, they both have some who have had problems, but the problem rate is rather low I would think. Those who do have problems are very vocal, of course, and may make it seem that the products are worthless, and that is understandable. If you've had a number of Lexar cards fail on you, then you are not likely to continue to use Lexar and I wouldn't blame you. But you can find this is the case for any card, I'm sure.

If you really want the highest quality card, and are willing to pay for it, you can get the Transend 300x UDMA 16GB, which have a different type of error correction built in:

Be careful, though, not all Transcend cards use this technology, and I don't think the ones that don't have as good a reputation as either Lexar or Sandisk, from what I can tell. The only Transcends I know for sure have this is the one I linked to, and you can tell by the price (almost 3x the price of the regular Transcend cards), it's not cheap technology.

Logged

canon rumors FORUM

It could be the case that you have fake Lexar cards and that's why they are failing. Lexar, Sandisk, Transcend are all really well known firms and I have never heard that their production is failing (massively, as in your case).

Another reason could be that you improperly handle them. In such case Sandisk and others will fail as well.

In my opinion, try to buy original cards and your problems will be solved

I had the same error with a 32GB 400x Lexar. I tried to recovery in Lexar and Sandisk software and both fail. Found online a software called CardRescue that save all files from the card, only 3 losses. Since then i usually test this card in recreational shots, and it never had that error again.