The history of the WNTN Softball All*Stars can be traced to the late 1970's when it was a pick-up team of mostly station employees, playing up to 30 games a season against other local media outlets and area groups and organizations like the Newton Police & Fire Departments.

In 1983, WNTN became a founding member of the Newton Independent Softball League which played at the Fessenden School. After fielding many competitive teams, the All*Stars finally won a championship in 1992, winning all five post-season games. The league disbanded after that season, unable to renew its field rental agreement with Fessenden.

The team went co-ed in 1993 for three seasons in the Needham Industrial Softball League, winning the title in 1994. The following season, WNTN joined the Needham Community Softball League, a men's league playing at Claxton Field. The team continues to be part of that league, having won the 2002 championship 3 games to 1 over Micks.