He was a fine actor but you are right eye rolling is about the best way to describe it.

I always remember the story of the cast all going up on stage at the oscars after winning the last award and Sean Astin turns to Stephen Spielberg - Oh Stephen, I hear people talking about doing a sequel of the Gooneys. And Spielberg just stopped him dead by saying - Not now Sean. the man in black fled across the desert and the gunslinger followed