Otter, this is the most perfect top five you have ever had. Congratulations! I'm speechless. The imagery is just breathtaking...I just want to roll around in it in hopes that some of the magic and mystery will rub off on me and seep into my pores...

I'll look over the middles and be back later with combos. So excited! ^_^

Super quickly I adore CasimirAntonyHerne. Yes Casimir is my faverit of your boys but that combo makes it amazing! Love!
Also although it not a name I was backing RomulusOdin Valemon is fantastic as well...
Might be back later for a play...

I've got a top five, so now it's that time when I try to put them together into full names. Below I've tried to explain how I feel/see a name, and I've put down a combo or two for each of the names. Further down is a rather long list of possible middle names, and I've put pronunciation next to the Norse/Norwegian and EE names. If you want to help me make combos, that would be fun! Middle name suggestions are always welcome. Thank you so much!

Casimir
Ancient forest at twilight, traveling roads. Men in velvet fur lined capes riding through on beautiful chestnut horses. Mystical and misty, hawks and falcons. The scent of coffee, whiskey, roses and leather. Casimir is nobility and royalty. I think of the Stark boys...

Endymion
Moonlight and starry skies by an ice covered lake. All blue and silver, hoarfrost on the naked trees, the snow beautifully twinkling in the starshine. Endymion's wrapped in woolen throws, reading by lantern light. I hear JustinVernon singing...

Oberon
A woodland clearing, fairy’s dance. Oberon is dancing and flowers, things that glitter and sparkle. The sweet scent of flowers, the music of flutes and bells. Oberon is the original man, he needs to be celebrated with garlands, joy and a lust for life.

OrpheusYoung forest, the kind with the grassy grounds, mountain scenery in the background. The bittersweet romantic, beautiful and young making the loveliest music. There's something ethereal about Orpheus... "Once and for all Orpheus is where there is singing. He comes and goes."Orpheus Brage Lorien

Romulus
Like Casimir, if he'd gone a little crazy and started living in the forest on his own, hunting for food with his bare hands or a rough wooden spear. Romulus is sexy, rugged, yet quiet and intelligent. Tobacco chewing whiskey drinking warrior with a wolf for a pet.

Some great names here! You have such an interesting style, I am so excited.
My top names from your list are Casimir and Endymion. Sophisticated, enchanting but quite familiar. Gorgeous, outstanding choices that will go great with your daughter's name, Aphrodite.
Am I supposed to make some combos? I'd like to try!Casimir Earendil WintersonCasimirWaylandThorCasimirOdinLucius