I'm looking forward to these. It sounds great way to let us make cool themed forces that sit on the fringes of GW fluff. I hope that it makes it's way to WFB too. I'm sure it's easy enough for comp hungry people to stick with your old rules too. The rest of the field not vying for a top 3 spot can still play the game our way after round 1 too.

I hope this comes nowhere near WHFB. You want an army of Skullcrushers? Go ahead. This system is so open for abuse, unless the benefits that you gain for following the force org chart are so astounding that they enable your army to be that Tau player who brings ten riptides to a game.

Keep this away from WHFB, i can only see bad things coming from it, i am fine with a percentage based army list

I think this would be a disaster for WHFB. Every ijit for whom winning is the most important thing would bring the most broken (or at least hardest) units and nothing else, and we would all be forced to do the same thing. Some troop choices would never ever see the light of day again and others would be played all the time. Empire with only Steam Tanks and Demigryphs? And a High Elf army with only White Lions, Allarielle and their dragon banner?

I don't play 40K so the rules there don't bother me, but I do NOT want to see this in WHFB.