Manning vs. Brady: A Bettor’s Perspective

Manning vs. Brady: A Bettor’s Perspective

When yesterday’s San Diego/Denver game went final on Sunday evening, Roger Goodell and the rest of the folks down at the league office must have been doing cartwheels. Not only did the league have arguably the best budding rivalry in football with the Seahawks hosting the 49ers, but also one of the best individual rivalries in sports with Tom Brady and Peyton Manning meeting for the fifteenth time in their illustrious careers (including three postseason games).

It’s a story we’ve all heard too many times to count: Manning — the can’t miss prospect, former number one draft pick and son of a Mississippi legend. Brady — a sixth round draft pick rushed into action following an injury to the incumbent starter. Combined these two players have thrown for over 110,000 yards while accumulating 22 Pro Bowl appearances, 6 MVP awards (likely 7 after this season), 4 Super Bowl rings, and eventually 2 plaques in Canton.

In fact, not only have Brady and Manning been invaluable to their respective teams, but they’ve also been highly productive for sports bettors. Using the QB filter in our Bet Labs software, we were able to determine that Brady and Manning have actually been the two most profitable signal callers to bet on over the past decade.

Brady has owned the head-to-head matchup with ten wins to Manning’s four; however, the Broncos enter the AFC Championship with the superior record, home-field advantage, and are listed as 4.5-point favorites for this weekend’s showdown. While Brady has owned the individual matchup, the question remains how can sports bettors take advantage of this classic rivalry?

The table below, using line data from Pinnacle and public betting data from our seven contributing sportsbooks, displays the betting trends from Brady and Manning’s 14 previous encounters.

Date

Home Team

Opening Line

Closing Line

Home Betting %

Closing Total

Score

Home Cover?

9/30/2001

Patriots

N/A

Pats -12

N/A

44

44-13 NE

Yes

10/21/2001

Colts

N/A

Pats -10.5

N/A

47

38-17 NE

No

11/30/2003

Colts

Colts -4

Colts -3.5

39%

43.5

38-34 NE

No

1/18/2004*

Patriots

Pats -3.5

Pats -3.5

46%

42

24-14 NE

Yes

9/9/2004

Patriots

Pats -3

Pats -3

51%

45

27-24 NE

Push

1/16/2005*

Patriots

Pats -2

Pick 'Em

38%

52

20-3 NE

Yes

11/7/2005

Patriots

Colts -3

Colts -4

44%

48

40-21 IN

No

11/5/2006

Patriots

Pats -1

Pats -3

41%

48

27-20 IN

No

1/21/2007*

Colts

Colts -3

Colts -3.5

58%

47

38-34 IN

Yes

11/4/2007

Colts

Pats -4

Pats -5.5

38%

56.5

24-20 NE

Yes

11/15/2009

Colts

Colts -3

Colts -1

36%

48

35-34 IN

Push

11/21/2010

Patriots

Pats -3

Pats -4

54%

49.5

31-28 NE

No

10/7/2012

Patriots

Pats -7

Pats -6

56%

50.5

31-21 NE

Yes

11/24/2013

Patriots

Broncos -1

Pats -1

39%

54

34-31 NE

Yes

* Indicates playoff game

Despite the Patriots 10-4 SU (straight up) record against Manning, the team has only posted a 7-5-2 ATS record in those 14 games including a 2-0 mark since Peyton signed with the Broncos. It’s also interesting to note that home-field advantage has been minimized with the home team also posting a 7-5-2 ATS record.

This season, Manning has the advantage over Brady in terms of passing yards (5477 to 4343), touchdowns (55 to 25), completion percentage (68.3 to 60.5) and QBR (82.9 to 61.1). Those advantages are clearly displayed below on our smart chart, which is available to all active members on the “Matchup” page.

The Patriots, who opened as 7-point underdogs at Pinnacle, have been pounded by the public in early betting and have received 76% of spread bets. This influx of public money on New England has helped to quickly move the line to 4.5, but we will continue to monitor this line movement as the week progresses.

Who do you like in this weekend’s AFC Championship game? Which signal caller will have the longer lasting legacy? Make sure to leave your thoughts and opinions in the comment section below.