A blog by Lee Kaplan

Main menu

Monthly Archives: March 2014

Has Texas really sunk that low? Is vaccinating the Lone Star State against the scourge of Sharia law really more important than addressing our education, transportation, and water needs? Apparently so. I didn’t know this until recently, but the Texas Legislature failed to pass a law last session prohibiting the application of Sharia law in this great State. Our current Lieutenant Governor David Dewhurst, trailing in the polls against red-meat conservative state Senator Dan Patrick, felt the need to defend himself in their recent debate face-off for failing to shepherd through the Texas Senate a bill to prohibit the application of Sharia law in the Texas courts. The Lite Guv contended he supported this measure “101 percent” and promised to appoint a new Committee chair next session in order to guarantee that Texans are not threatened with Sharia law anytime soon.

Yes, it’s true—S.B. 1639 was actually sponsored by Sen. John Carona, the chair of the Texas Senate Business and Commerce Committee, but it died in committee. It died because, among other things, some of our legislators woke up long enough to realize that never, ever in Texas’s history had Texas courts deferred to Sharia law, and the need for this extra ounce of prevention seemed remote. Ironically, Sen. Carona’s 100 percent true-to-Texas hostility to Islamic jihadist influence was apparently at least 1 percent short. Carona lost his re-election bid in the Republican primary to an allegedly more-conservative candidate. Now, regardless of whether Dewhurst or Patrick (or, heavens, the Democratic nominee Leticia Van de Putte) wins, the Business and Commerce Committee will have a new chair in the next session.

The wonder is not that there are one-off loonies in Texas who promote such legislation; the wonder is that people who know better are forced to pretend to support looniness or risk losing. Witness Dewhurst, who will probably lose the runoff election anyway. What if he had just said, “This is asinine. We have better things to do than worry about Sharia law suddenly infecting our courts. This is all of a part of my opponent’s general wackiness, including his concern that illegal immigants are introducing leprosy into Texas. We need to focus on keeping the ‘Texas Miracle’ in place – which means meeting our education, water and and transportation needs for the next 10, 20 or 50 years. Anyone who doesn’t focus on the important issues is hurting Texas. Badly.”

I guess I’ll never be hired as a speechwriter, at least not by a Texas Republican. Because I cannot find a single Texas GOP officeholder or candidate who talks that way. That includes Dewhurst, whose nod to education in late January was to opine that, when one takes into account the cost of living, “we are paying our teachers a very fair salary.” Not true. Texas teachers are paid, on average, about 87% of the national average. Even taking into account Texas’ lower overall cost of living, we would have to give every teacher in the state a 10% pay raise just to hit the national average. Even more shocking, and even after the Legislature partially restored funding cuts from two years earlier, a widely-publicized study by the National Education Agency reckons that Texas spends $8998 per student, a 5 percent decrease from per-student funding of $9,462 in 2010-11. Yes, we all know that throwing more money at something doesn’t necessarily solve it. But we’re spending less, not more. And that’s in a state which is flush economically. We are raising a whole generation of children – not just in the Rio Grande Valley, but in the cities and towns throughout the State — who are less literate than their peers in other states. Burger flippers, yes. Rocket scientists, not so much.

The same dearth of leadership is evident with respect to our critical water problems. One statewide officeholder who touched on our water problems in a serious way is retiring from public office. Susan Combs wisely decided that even a West Texas rancher was not conservative enough to win again, but in January she pointed out that Texas is facing a long-term water emergency. (Yes, “emergency” is the word we normally apply to short-term problems, but here, it applies to both.) Too bad the candidates for Governor and Lieutenant Governor haven’t taken note. Abortion is much more important. For example, in an interview on WOAI 1200 a few months ago, our current Attorney General (and still heavy favorite to be our next Governor) Greg Abbott spent more airtime on abortion and voter ID than these important issues. Even though his friendly interviewer tried to ask him about water issues, Abbott’s spiel was focused on pointing out that we shouldn’t use the Rainy Day fund to solve our water problems. OK, then, but what did he propose? Nothing.

Perhaps we’re being unfair, and Attorney General Abbott really is interested in education, transportation and water, but that interview was just too short to get to the important stuff? Nope. Check out http://www.gregabbott.com/issues/, where the candidate for Texas’s highest office lists key issues. None of these three make the top 10. They’re not even listed! What’s the No. 1 issue? You guessed it – ObamaCare. What’s No. 2? – the Second Amendment. You cannot find anything on education, water, or transportation. (I guess we should be grateful that stopping human trafficking made it to tenth place.)

As for Sen. Patrick, who is widely anticipated to beat Dewhurst in the GOP primary runoff for Lieutenant Governor, his contribution on education seems to be an effort to re-work something called CSCOPE. The details of this are fairly arcane, but Sen. Patrick seems to think that CSCOPE was a thinly-veiled effort to indoctrinate children into a left-wing, fifth-column agenda right under the noses of God-fearing Texas parents. OK, once again, we know what he’s against, but what is Sen. Patrick for? When asked by the Collin County Conservative Republicans “what do you want to accomplish?”, this is what he said:

“There are many conservative issues that I will take action on that have not passed in the last decade. I will pass legislation to secure the border, end magnets that draw illegals to cross our border, pass school choice, lower property taxes, repeal or reform the franchise tax, pass campus carry, protect life and marriage, reduce transportation debt, end the diversions from dedicated taxes and fees to other areas of spending, reduce the 21 vote rule to 19 and not appoint half the Democrats to be Chairs of Committees as has been the long practice.”

So the border is No. 1 and No. 2. What refreshing candor. Also, we can at least credit Sen. Patrick for being aware that education and transportation are issues, although it’s hard to tell what he is proposing to improve education, a labor-intensive industry where recruiting and retaining good teachers is critical, and even harder to tell just what more “school choice” will do for students if all the schools are underfunded. It is also hard to tell just how lowering property taxes and reducing transportation debt will do anything about fixing our roads. As for what Sen. Patrick “hopes to accomplish” in dealing with our water crisis, he offers – nothing.

The bottom line is that we Texans are enjoying good times, right here, right now, but if we don’t spend some money while we’re flush on upgrading our education system, providing for our water needs, and building and maintaining roads, that miracle will become a mirage in the rearview mirror. Ronald Reagan (who by today’s standards would be condemned as a backsliding liberal) spent more money on California’s system of higher education than anyone, and California is reaping the benefits even now, all under a Governor once called “Moonbeam.” Laugh all you want about those kooks in Cali, but they are better positioned for the 21st century than we are, by a long shot.

Ronald Reagan and Jerry Brown qualify as hardheaded realists; Greg Abbott and Dan Patrick are hardheaded ideologues. We are about to digest the bitter fruits of their willful ignorance. But at least it won’t be under Sharia law.