Tallmadge, saying Talmadge grew resentful after his congregation defected from the church, with Richard. Abe demonstrates how Richard was shot and pretends to struggle as he loads the Reverend's rifle. Simcoe takes the rifle but finds the bullet that pierced Richard does not fit the gun. Hewlett later tells Abe he will show mercy on the men and sentence them to ten years on the Jersey. Abe likens that to a death sentence and reminds him the bullet didn't match the Reverend's rifle. Hewlett stresses it is an opportunity to banish a group of disloyal citizens. Meanwhile, Ben tells Washington decoded enemy dispatches show the British plan to attack Philadelphia from the south,Turn Washington's Spies rather than the north as scouts have reported. Ben is told to lead troops north to play into Britain's deception, while the Continental Army strengthens the southerly defenses. Caleb and Selah march with Ben's troops. Ben learns his father and Caleb's uncle have been arrested and may face death. He tells Caleb they are going home. At Woodhull Farm, Mary finds Abe's hidden codebook.