The author is a Forbes contributor. The opinions expressed are those of the writer.

Loading ...

Loading ...

This story appears in the {{article.article.magazine.pretty_date}} issue of {{article.article.magazine.pubName}}. Subscribe

Within the past 24 hours, user-contributed link aggregator reddit.com compiled a "secret list" of banned domains—including such reputable news sites as The Atlantic, Business Week, PhysOrg and ScienceDaily. But the controversy doesn't end there.

Reddit user and moderator violentacrez brought the issue to light in a post titled, "Reddit is now banning entire high-quality domains, using an unpublished list"

"reddit admins enabled a new feature where links from domains on a secret list cannot be posted, even by moderators, even in their own reddits."

Reddit is a site that claims to be all for online democracy and transparency. This abrupt act of censorship has triggered a response from users—and the upset is gaining momentum by the second. When Alexis Ohanian was fully involved with reddit, he talked about how the users themselves had the right to vote up or down any articles. In the truest sense of democracy, everything was moderated by the community themselves. Deeper than that, each subreddit has its own set of moderators to curate submitted links within their own community. The notion of denying the free press access to a high-volume audience is a relatively new and disturbing development in reddit's previously open culture. The community itself needs to take steps to make sure reddit doesn't turn itself into a tyrant, or a "police state" website.

Some domains are not allowed on any part of reddit because they are spammy, malicious, or involved in cheating shenanigans. Attempting to submit a link to one of these domains will now fail with an informative error message.

We're initially rolling this out for link shorteners which have long been discouraged on reddit as they conceal the true destination of the link.

There is much irony in mainstream news sites being banned by a site that's been such a strong part of the anti-SOPA movement. It's ironic as well to prevent news from being seen as it happens on one of the most-read sites on the internet.

One of the reasons behind the censorship is that it isn't being seen by reddit staff as censorship. The banned domains have been linked to accusations of reddit users "gaming the system," or having financial ties to the promoted links. "Spamming" and "Cheating" were the catchwords for getting these site-wide domain bans in place—but this so-called spam differs vastly from the typical junk you see floating around the "new" section that is downvoted by users, featuring sketchy domain names and topics ranging from cheap prescriptions to racy photos of Bollywood celebrities, etc. Cheating, refers to hammering "fake" upvotes from bots on a network of proxied IP addresses, sometimes allowing the submitted link to reach the front page without the curation of real reddit users.

There is talk within the reddit community of the possibility of "faking" evidence of spam in order to take down, say, Condé Nast's competitor sites.

Erik Martin, aka hueypriest, gives a light confirmation that the bans are only temporary. After reading his comment, I reached out to him to get a better sense of his definition of temporary, and was told that it'll be evaluated on a case-by-case basis.

As a response, I feel the vagueness of the "case by case" response could mean that the best-case scenario for these publications is that their ban is lifted, but the worst-case scenario could mean a permanent ban for those sites found guilty of violating reddit's terms of use.