ConnectU founders appeal $65 million settlement with Facebook

After reaching a $65 million settlement with Facebook founder Mark Zuckerberg back in 2008, ConnectU founders Tyler and Cameron Winkelvoss are now appealing the settlement.

The twins agreed to a settlement in 2008 that got them $20 million in cash and $45 million in stock, valued at $36 per share. Now, the pair are alleging that they were misled about the real value of Facebook stock in 2008, and have brought the case to the Ninth Circuit Court of Appeals in San Francisco.

A skeptical three judge panel began considering today whether the Winkelvoss twins have a case. They scrutinized the argument put forward by the twins through attorney Jerome Falk. "The (ConnectU) founders are pretty smart people themselves, the twins also have a father from Wharton School who is very bright," Judge John Wallace said.

"If you have all these people to advise you, isn't it difficult to say this is one of those things where you were taken advantage of?"

Wallace was pointing out that the settlement was reached by teams of lawyers and a top mediator. The Winkelvoss brothers had valued the Facebook stock based on a news report that Microsoft had bought a small piece of the social networking site in a deal that valued the stock at around $36, and the company at $15 billion.

Falk argued that Facebook violated US securities laws by not disclosing that it had valued the stock at closer to $9 for stock options issued to employees. "This case is about whether sophisticated parties surrounded by a platoon of world-class lawyers can cancel a deal that is binding," Facebook attorney Joshua Rosenkranz countered.

"No one was misled here," he said. "The ConnectU founders struck a deal that made them very rich and is making them richer by the day. No one made them sign it."

It's like you sold your stuff over eBay and later learned the stuff worth a lot more... Hmmm, you can cry or moan all you want (arguments like "the stuff was sold without permissions etc.") but the truth is, if the "value" was less, you probably laughing like a hyena.

At the end of the day, mark wrote a really good site with his own code and that should be the end of it.

Ok he may have lifted the idea, but this is like coke suing pepsi because they also make a drink that's brown, fizzy and some potential coke customers switched.

Its not like there was copy right on the idea of a social network site, the idea was already there to some respect and has been since the days of the zmodem or there abouts.

As far as I can make out all of their hate for mark grew from the fact he made them look stupid by delivering a better product in less time and made theirs redundant before it got started and has less to do with the money than you may think.

Fair play to mark, i think in the tech world its fantastic to see a role models for the younger generation that's not driven by greed and made it by actually making something better than anyone could.

Instead of creating a world that constantly socially and technologically stunted by people trying to get rich from someone eases success than seek their own.

And people who have an inability to face the fact competition is a great driving force for progress and that you cant win them all.

I'm not sure were facebook will go or what mark may do next, the world is his oyster now and the fact these guys continue on with this would only widen my smile if I were mark :)

Personally he can go into the small list of people I would buy a beer, such a place is reserved for the great woz, captain crunch to name a few and now mark :)

And the The ConnectU founders should be happy with what they have and realise that ultimately all they are doing is making them self's more miserable and bitter.

This message has been edited since its posting. Latest edit was made on 13 Jan 2011 @ 11:45

I personally think that these guys were more upset that they tried to use Mark to perfect an idea that they couldn't and instead of being their flunky he took that concept and created a network that was beyond anyone's expectations.

He is a genius period. Stop trying to piggy back and be greatful that you got a pay day. MOVE ON!!!!!

I personally think that these guys were more upset that they tried to use Mark to perfect an idea that they couldn't and instead of being their flunky he took that concept and created a network that was beyond anyone's expectations.

He is a genius period. Stop trying to piggy back and be greatful that you got a pay day. MOVE ON!!!!!

these guys are 2idiots who couldnt get "the facebook" what it was called...up and running then they get a cash settlement and now they want to renegotiate...typical idiots...yes they had a idea...but they never sat down with mark...he never ever ever worked with them...he did the whole site on his own...99.9% of people WISH they could of done what mark did...its all greed...everybody wants the cash...these 2idiots and thats what they are should be gratefull...they have more cash than most people ever will see in 5lifetimes...grow up you 2idiots...you 2idiots werent as smart as mark...like or hate mark he gets all the credit and deserves all the reward...mark should counter your appeal and try and get his settlement back from you 2idoits...also you 2idiots will be remembered for the rest of your lives for one thing and that being...not being SMART enough TO GET THE WORLDS SOCIALSITE UP AND RUNNING...2IDOITS...

Hey Twinsies - if you were smart and clever enough to come up with such a great idea way back when and feel it did not pan out for ya c'mon - why not just come up with another new idea - - - - what? You can't come up with another new idea on your own? MMMMMMMM - - - wonder why that is . . . . ???????????????

Originally posted by Gnawnivek: It's like you sold your stuff over eBay and later learned the stuff worth a lot more... Hmmm, you can cry or moan all you want (arguments like "the stuff was sold without permissions etc.") but the truth is, if the "value" was less, you probably laughing like a hyena.

Good point!

Judge Wallace summed it up perfectly;
"If you have all these people to advise you, isn't it difficult to say this is one of those things where you were taken advantage of?"

This is what BLACKMAILERS do only the Winkelvoss twins think they can do it in court. These two kids are scary at best and don’t deserve anything.

Quote:Winkelvoss brothers had valued the Facebook stock based on a news report that Microsoft had bought a small piece of the social networking site in a deal that valued the stock at around $36, and the company at $15 billion.

Um...Hello? Anyone home? Idiots... THEY were the ones who said that Facebook is valued such-and-such based on a little report from Microsoft. So in essence THEY are the ones who burned themselves.

Hey Winkelvoss Idiots, it's not Mark's fault that you can't learn to manage $20 million dollars. Maybe you should've used that money to buy some common sense.

Originally posted by Zealousi: Wow talk about greed, you make more money then a entire block of households and the company has expanded over the years and you think you deserve more money because the company has grown even more.

Mark i hope you threw them out on their ass when they told you this, i would of.

Typical American greed, "Sue'em"

These guys are rich kid morons that need to have the shit kicked out of them to get them back on a normal level.

Hey Mark you should sue em for harassment because they have nothing else better to do then leach off facebook lol

THIS IS HOW MARK ZUCKERBERG STOLE FACEBOOK

It all started when DAVID was logged in to the Harvard website, where I was listening in to the conversations of the Harvard students. One of these students was Mark Zuckerberg who was talking about Face Smash and he had just broken up with his girlfriend at the time, so I struck up a conversation with this Mark Zuckerberg. He was talking about creating a dating site. I thought this was a bit odd - a pie in the sky idea since he had just broken up with his girlfriend and he was slagging her off - calling her a bitch and a whore.
dave talked to Mark about the idea, and suggested he call it Face Mash. He was intrigued with my suggestion and thought it was a good idea. Mark wanted to call it Face Smash, because he wanted to smash his ex in the face. I convinced him that Face Mash was a good idea and he agreed, but one week later he changed his mind and wanted to call it Face Smash. When I queried him about this he replied 'f.... off you c...- I'm calling it Face Smash'. Two weeks after this conversation he came up with the name Mashable and when I asked him why he chose the word Mashable instead of Face Mash he said 'f,...off you bastard, Face mash is not your idea'. So I re-posted the conversations we had two weeks earlier and he had to apologize and said he was going with Mashable. I took this as a sign that he wanted to throw me off the scent and take the site for himself. dave found the character of Mark Zuckerberg to be deceptive and dishonest and ended conversing with Mark Zuckerberg because of his dishonesty and lack of integrity

DAVID DUSTIN + CHRIS THE ORIGIN OF FACEBOOK

After this dave started conversing with Dustin and Chris about an idea of mine called Facebook for an online service where students can post pictures and information on themselves and use it as a directory. They were very intrigued by my idea and wanted to know more.
dave told them that in the beginning, it would be an online service just for Harvard students, and then spreading through the other campuses in America, joining them up together. The idea was to make it easy for people to connect with other university students so they could get an idea of what other campuses were like, and even eventually spreading through the general public, giving them an idea of what was on offer at the different campuses.
Dustin and Chris were very intrigued with my idea and said they wanted to be on board. but zuck was there roommate and wonted to be on board zuckerberg was apologetic about face-mash but it was bull shit
dave talked extensively about my ideas of Facebook and went into great detail of how to get it set up and started. They queried about the finance of setting it up and I told them I was in contact with Tony Robbins, who was interested by the idea and we were having discussions regarding his financial backing of the project

THE PLATFORM

So we needed a platform dave made contact with paul ceglia and was in discussion about a platform for my idea the facebook
but zuckerberg made contact to paul ceglia to steal the idea facebook 'paul ceglia had no legal right to sell the the platform to mark zuckerberg but zuckerberg new what he was doing when he sign the contract
(paul ceglia had no legal right to sell the the platform to mark zuckerberg } the contract was to David not zuckerberg

EDUARDO

dave then found another contact at Harvard, called Eduardo Saverin and invited him to join me in developing my idea, and also to find out what was going on between Dustin, Chris and Mark . eduardo offered finance to get facebook up and running but zuckerberg spent the money on him self selfish prick zuck spent eduardo saverin money and spat in his face your best friend .this is the reason how eduardo got a invitation into facebook

THEN david got e-mails from zuckerberg saying he was not interested in the idea facebook david then contacted dustin chris to find out about this email i got from zuckerberg; they went into denial about this. but later on got a email from chris saying they were not interested in the idea facebook

CAMERON AND TAYLOR WINKLEVOSS

So dave found a site at Harvard called Harvard Connect (later, in 2004 changed to Harvard Connect To You) run by Cameron and Taylor Winklevoss, and dave explained everything about Facebook and the dealings with Zuckerberg, Dustin and Chris and how dave believed that Zuckerberg was in the process of stealing david idea, and dave asked if the Winklevosses were interested in running Facebook on the Harvard site

They expressed enthusiasm in the offer and liked the idea of running the site as they liked the concept of Facebook.They told me that they were going to change their site name and redesign it at that time (to Harvard Connect To You The person they called in to help them
redesign their site was Mark Zuckerberg who then stole their platform : I told them that zuckerberg was a crook the winklevoss where to dumb and dupe by zuckerberg And what do the winklevoss remind me off; its two building and the two buildings were the TWIN TOWERS you guys talk about the truth like you own the truth but you do not and never will

the winklevoss contacted summers at UV about zuckerberg but summers new the full story of how zuckerberg stole facebook and it was david idea
david then log a complaint to the FBI about this stolen fake connect 2u account with fake information and about mark zuckerberg

THE WINKLEVOSS BS

it did not take long for david to realize that the winklevoss were not up to do the job when cameron found out that david log a complaint to the fbi on zuckerberg cameron sed that is not the way we do things but tyler wonted to file a lawsuit on zuckerberg but cameron was the dominant personality and the hole idea facebook was on the verge of collapse david then got emails from the winklevoss saying they were now longer interested in the idea facebook( NOT A SURPRISE
DAVID found out later on that the winklevoss contacted WAYNE CHANG and sold 50% of the idea facebook my god how f..ing dumb can you get .all the winklevoss had to do was go hire a team of programmers or learn to program on their own .and the idea facebook was a sound and solid idea and the right skillful execution of the idea was all that was needed this was david skill.

CREATE A FAKE

zuckerberg then went on to create a FAKE CONNECT 2U account filled with FAKE information from the stolen platform he stole from the winklevoss Dave got a email from this FAKE CONNECT 2U account . but dave new it was FAKE it was zuckerberg .
zuckerber wonted more info and idea to steal so dave gave one idea and it was to put a silver layer around the F word on facebook to see if zuckerberg was going to steal this idea and yes he did

SO WHAT DID MARK ZUCKERBERG STEAL BY STEALTH

the idea facebook the name facebook the concept and the execution of facebook
david understands that zuckerberg has a mental personality disorder but this is no excuse for being a asshole and a thief zuckerberg
you see zuck dustin and chris new that facebook was a billion dollar idea but you stole the idea facebook . chris you may have step up about being gay but you need to step up and tell the truth about how zuckerberg stole facebook

MARK ZUCKERBERG GIRLFRIEND

yes zuckerberg got a girlfriend and no he did not get her from GRAIGS-LIST . but he did break up with his girlfriend and look for love on graigs-list or as zuckerberg put it looking for a new bitch .zuck did not realize that you had to pay for the girls on graigs-list .zuck sad what do you mean you have to pay you pay and if you are unlucky you have to pay twice when you have go to the clinic ; zuckerberg saw every thing as a possession some thing to take when he stole the idea facebook and his girlfriend ; zuckerberg social skills are that poor zuck can not pick up sand if he was standing in the middle of a desert and had to go back to his old girlfriend that is all he had ; facemash and facebook was zuckerberg quest to understand woman FAIL

zuckerberg do not use your girlfriend to polish your bull-shit it will not work and never will

THE SOCIAL NETWORK

friend-star it failed end of story : my-space was a good idea but failed to mash the idea with the changing social landscape
sean parker seam to think the only reason we won was because of the gross incompetence of myspace systematically over a period of many years
my god sean parker f..ing grow up you do not have your finger on the pulse of social change that just your but-hole

AARON GREENSPAN

david then went to Aaron Greenspan who was running house systems at Harvard and asked him (under an email non disclosure agreement) to run Facebook on his site which he agreed to do. aaron greenspan used the (info) to extort financal money out of facebook and zuckerberg paid the extortion money and dave call it extortion U see zuckerberg new aaron greenspan new zuck had stolen the idea facebook .I sent all the emails copy to aaron greenspan:{ aaron sold him self off like a hooker standing on a street corner } and what was that quotation aaron that quotation you set me about honour and truth you now the same bullshit the winklevoss are bullshiting on about

DAVID KIRKPATICK

david kirkpatrick was given all the emails and was made fully aware of how zuckerberg stole facebook from david in the beginning i gave kirkpatrick 80% of the emails kirkpatrick then ask if there was more ' yes there is more but ask kirkpatrick that he must reveal the truth the other 20% was email from paul ceglia to me dave made contact with paul ceglia and was in discussion about a platform for my idea the facebook
as for kirkpatrick you are a prick kirkpatrick falls victim to the bane of many business historians infatuation with the subject and the money just a porn-star

BEN MEZRICK AND KIRKPATICK + EDUARDO

ben mezrick was given copes of the emails in and around 2004 dave posted a copy of the emails to ben mezrick and to david kirkpatrick as for kirkpatrick your book is a joke and so are you :
you are just a fence jumper david kirkpatrick and its chris that is the gay one you dick 'you sold yourself out you were given the full story of how zuckerberg stole facebook; and sold out
in a email to eduardo i told him to get a lawyer zuckerberg was going to screw him over and told him to contact ben mezrick
eduardo told me he had a lawyer he can trust but zuckerberg and the lawyer screwed him over; david made contact to ben and ben mezrick got
80% of the emails about how zuck stole facebook and about the winklevoss

PAUL CEGLIA

And what are you going to do zuckerberg when paul ceglia wins you can call the contract a fake a counterfeit ; you cant can you zuckerberg Yes you did sign a contract zuckerberg In a email zuckerberg called paul ceglia a dum sucker in 2003 i david posted a copy on to the internet and the
roomer spread years a go that zuckerberg had sign the contract and yes the abc news room have a copy of the email

ZUCKERBERG OPTIONS

So zuckerberg what are your options zuck i suppose you can tell the truth you see paul cegia had no legal right to sell you the platform
david was in contact to paul cealia about a platform suitable for facebook but you wonted to steal facebook by stealth and you will have to tell
your mother and farther and sisters how you stole the idea facebook

ZUCKERBERG TROJAN HORSE

You can't gift your way out of controversy zucerberg Generosity is not always well-received and what is your true nature bill gates now your true
nature a trojan horse, africa will rise with out your money and the money you gifted zuck is from a stolen idea ;BILL GATES do not bet against
DAVID ON THIS the last time you bet against david you lost REMEMBER and you now the truth about mark zuckerberg

ORRICK

"When plunder becomes a way of life for a group of men living together in society, they create for themselves in the course of time a legal system that authorizes it and a moral code that glorifies it." Sadly, most of the people don't wish to bite the hands that feeds them

The Securities and Exchange Commission says it has set aside about $450 million for payments to outside whistleblowers whose information results in successful ?? ..... SOME THING YOU WONT TO LOOK AT LISA SIMPSON ,, and the best way to rob a bank is to own a bank

Zuckerberg has already, on multiple occasions, demonstrat­ed that he didn't care nothing about the security and privacy and understand even the fundamenta­ls of computer system security ; this is way he stole the idea facebook but not from the winklevoss but did sign a contract to paul ceglia
zuckerberg In a email zuckerberg called paul ceglia a dum sucker in 2003 i david posted a copy on to the internet and the
roomer spread years a go that zuckerberg had sign the contract ; and zuckerberg only sign the contract to steal the idea facebook from david

and it was david who contacted the winklevoss about the idea facebook and paul ceglia is going to get 84% of facebook

The Securities and Exchange Commission says it has set aside about $450 million for payments to outside whistleblowers whose information results in successful : I THINK WIKILEAKS can do with some of this whistle blowers money ; TIME to dropkick GS in the sacK

Tony Merchant may be contacted at 306-359-7777 . Jason Zushman can be contacted at 204-896-7777 .

david made contact to merchant law merchant law contact lisa simmson & mark zuckerberg there are some interesting emails if you contact Tony Merchant you can get the email from him i left instruction to give the emails to every one ask for them this was done years a go

dave posted a copy of the emails to ben mezrick and to david kirkpatrick

Originally posted by Zealousi: Wow talk about greed, you make more money then a entire block of households and the company has expanded over the years and you think you deserve more money because the company has grown even more.

Mark i hope you threw them out on their ass when they told you this, i would of.

Typical American greed, "Sue'em"

These guys are rich kid morons that need to have the shit kicked out of them to get them back on a normal level.

Hey Mark you should sue em for harassment because they have nothing else better to do then leach off facebook lol

THIS IS HOW MARK ZUCKERBERG STOLE FACEBOOK

It all started when DAVID was logged in to the Harvard website, where I was listening in to the conversations of the Harvard students. One of these students was Mark Zuckerberg who was talking about Face Smash and he had just broken up with his girlfriend at the time, so I struck up a conversation with this Mark Zuckerberg. He was talking about creating a dating site. I thought this was a bit odd - a pie in the sky idea since he had just broken up with his girlfriend and he was slagging her off - calling her a bitch and a whore.
dave talked to Mark about the idea, and suggested he call it Face Mash. He was intrigued with my suggestion and thought it was a good idea. Mark wanted to call it Face Smash, because he wanted to smash his ex in the face. I convinced him that Face Mash was a good idea and he agreed, but one week later he changed his mind and wanted to call it Face Smash. When I queried him about this he replied 'f.... off you c...- I'm calling it Face Smash'. Two weeks after this conversation he came up with the name Mashable and when I asked him why he chose the word Mashable instead of Face Mash he said 'f,...off you bastard, Face mash is not your idea'. So I re-posted the conversations we had two weeks earlier and he had to apologize and said he was going with Mashable. I took this as a sign that he wanted to throw me off the scent and take the site for himself. dave found the character of Mark Zuckerberg to be deceptive and dishonest and ended conversing with Mark Zuckerberg because of his dishonesty and lack of integrity

DAVID DUSTIN + CHRIS THE ORIGIN OF FACEBOOK

After this dave started conversing with Dustin and Chris about an idea of mine called Facebook for an online service where students can post pictures and information on themselves and use it as a directory. They were very intrigued by my idea and wanted to know more.
dave told them that in the beginning, it would be an online service just for Harvard students, and then spreading through the other campuses in America, joining them up together. The idea was to make it easy for people to connect with other university students so they could get an idea of what other campuses were like, and even eventually spreading through the general public, giving them an idea of what was on offer at the different campuses.
Dustin and Chris were very intrigued with my idea and said they wanted to be on board. but zuck was there roommate and wonted to be on board zuckerberg was apologetic about face-mash but it was bull shit
dave talked extensively about my ideas of Facebook and went into great detail of how to get it set up and started. They queried about the finance of setting it up and I told them I was in contact with Tony Robbins, who was interested by the idea and we were having discussions regarding his financial backing of the project

THE PLATFORM

So we needed a platform dave made contact with paul ceglia and was in discussion about a platform for my idea the facebook
but zuckerberg made contact to paul ceglia to steal the idea facebook 'paul ceglia had no legal right to sell the the platform to mark zuckerberg but zuckerberg new what he was doing when he sign the contract
(paul ceglia had no legal right to sell the the platform to mark zuckerberg } the contract was to David not zuckerberg

EDUARDO

dave then found another contact at Harvard, called Eduardo Saverin and invited him to join me in developing my idea, and also to find out what was going on between Dustin, Chris and Mark . eduardo offered finance to get facebook up and running but zuckerberg spent the money on him self selfish prick zuck spent eduardo saverin money and spat in his face your best friend .this is the reason how eduardo got a invitation into facebook

THEN david got e-mails from zuckerberg saying he was not interested in the idea facebook david then contacted dustin chris to find out about this email i got from zuckerberg; they went into denial about this. but later on got a email from chris saying they were not interested in the idea facebook

CAMERON AND TAYLOR WINKLEVOSS

So dave found a site at Harvard called Harvard Connect (later, in 2004 changed to Harvard Connect To You) run by Cameron and Taylor Winklevoss, and dave explained everything about Facebook and the dealings with Zuckerberg, Dustin and Chris and how dave believed that Zuckerberg was in the process of stealing david idea, and dave asked if the Winklevosses were interested in running Facebook on the Harvard site

They expressed enthusiasm in the offer and liked the idea of running the site as they liked the concept of Facebook.They told me that they were going to change their site name and redesign it at that time (to Harvard Connect To You The person they called in to help them
redesign their site was Mark Zuckerberg who then stole their platform : I told them that zuckerberg was a crook the winklevoss where to dumb and dupe by zuckerberg And what do the winklevoss remind me off; its two building and the two buildings were the TWIN TOWERS you guys talk about the truth like you own the truth but you do not and never will

the winklevoss contacted summers at UV about zuckerberg but summers new the full story of how zuckerberg stole facebook and it was david idea
david then log a complaint to the FBI about this stolen fake connect 2u account with fake information and about mark zuckerberg

THE WINKLEVOSS BS

it did not take long for david to realize that the winklevoss were not up to do the job when cameron found out that david log a complaint to the fbi on zuckerberg cameron sed that is not the way we do things but tyler wonted to file a lawsuit on zuckerberg but cameron was the dominant personality and the hole idea facebook was on the verge of collapse david then got emails from the winklevoss saying they were now longer interested in the idea facebook( NOT A SURPRISE
DAVID found out later on that the winklevoss contacted WAYNE CHANG and sold 50% of the idea facebook my god how f..ing dumb can you get .all the winklevoss had to do was go hire a team of programmers or learn to program on their own .and the idea facebook was a sound and solid idea and the right skillful execution of the idea was all that was needed this was david skill.

CREATE A FAKE

zuckerberg then went on to create a FAKE CONNECT 2U account filled with FAKE information from the stolen platform he stole from the winklevoss Dave got a email from this FAKE CONNECT 2U account . but dave new it was FAKE it was zuckerberg .
zuckerber wonted more info and idea to steal so dave gave one idea and it was to put a silver layer around the F word on facebook to see if zuckerberg was going to steal this idea and yes he did

SO WHAT DID MARK ZUCKERBERG STEAL BY STEALTH

the idea facebook the name facebook the concept and the execution of facebook
david understands that zuckerberg has a mental personality disorder but this is no excuse for being a asshole and a thief zuckerberg
you see zuck dustin and chris new that facebook was a billion dollar idea but you stole the idea facebook . chris you may have step up about being gay but you need to step up and tell the truth about how zuckerberg stole facebook

MARK ZUCKERBERG GIRLFRIEND

yes zuckerberg got a girlfriend and no he did not get her from GRAIGS-LIST . but he did break up with his girlfriend and look for love on graigs-list or as zuckerberg put it looking for a new bitch .zuck did not realize that you had to pay for the girls on graigs-list .zuck sad what do you mean you have to pay you pay and if you are unlucky you have to pay twice when you have go to the clinic ; zuckerberg saw every thing as a possession some thing to take when he stole the idea facebook and his girlfriend ; zuckerberg social skills are that poor zuck can not pick up sand if he was standing in the middle of a desert and had to go back to his old girlfriend that is all he had ; facemash and facebook was zuckerberg quest to understand woman FAIL

zuckerberg do not use your girlfriend to polish your bull-shit it will not work and never will

THE SOCIAL NETWORK

friend-star it failed end of story : my-space was a good idea but failed to mash the idea with the changing social landscape
sean parker seam to think the only reason we won was because of the gross incompetence of myspace systematically over a period of many years
my god sean parker f..ing grow up you do not have your finger on the pulse of social change that just your but-hole

AARON GREENSPAN

david then went to Aaron Greenspan who was running house systems at Harvard and asked him (under an email non disclosure agreement) to run Facebook on his site which he agreed to do. aaron greenspan used the (info) to extort financal money out of facebook and zuckerberg paid the extortion money and dave call it extortion U see zuckerberg new aaron greenspan new zuck had stolen the idea facebook .I sent all the emails copy to aaron greenspan:{ aaron sold him self off like a hooker standing on a street corner } and what was that quotation aaron that quotation you set me about honour and truth you now the same bullshit the winklevoss are bullshiting on about

DAVID KIRKPATICK

david kirkpatrick was given all the emails and was made fully aware of how zuckerberg stole facebook from david in the beginning i gave kirkpatrick 80% of the emails kirkpatrick then ask if there was more ' yes there is more but ask kirkpatrick that he must reveal the truth the other 20% was email from paul ceglia to me dave made contact with paul ceglia and was in discussion about a platform for my idea the facebook
as for kirkpatrick you are a prick kirkpatrick falls victim to the bane of many business historians infatuation with the subject and the money just a porn-star

BEN MEZRICK AND KIRKPATICK + EDUARDO

ben mezrick was given copes of the emails in and around 2004 dave posted a copy of the emails to ben mezrick and to david kirkpatrick as for kirkpatrick your book is a joke and so are you :
you are just a fence jumper david kirkpatrick and its chris that is the gay one you dick 'you sold yourself out you were given the full story of how zuckerberg stole facebook; and sold out
in a email to eduardo i told him to get a lawyer zuckerberg was going to screw him over and told him to contact ben mezrick
eduardo told me he had a lawyer he can trust but zuckerberg and the lawyer screwed him over; david made contact to ben and ben mezrick got
80% of the emails about how zuck stole facebook and about the winklevoss

PAUL CEGLIA

And what are you going to do zuckerberg when paul ceglia wins you can call the contract a fake a counterfeit ; you cant can you zuckerberg Yes you did sign a contract zuckerberg In a email zuckerberg called paul ceglia a dum sucker in 2003 i david posted a copy on to the internet and the
roomer spread years a go that zuckerberg had sign the contract and yes the abc news room have a copy of the email

ZUCKERBERG OPTIONS

So zuckerberg what are your options zuck i suppose you can tell the truth you see paul cegia had no legal right to sell you the platform
david was in contact to paul cealia about a platform suitable for facebook but you wonted to steal facebook by stealth and you will have to tell
your mother and farther and sisters how you stole the idea facebook

ZUCKERBERG TROJAN HORSE

You can't gift your way out of controversy zucerberg Generosity is not always well-received and what is your true nature bill gates now your true
nature a trojan horse, africa will rise with out your money and the money you gifted zuck is from a stolen idea ;BILL GATES do not bet against
DAVID ON THIS the last time you bet against david you lost REMEMBER and you now the truth about mark zuckerberg

ORRICK

"When plunder becomes a way of life for a group of men living together in society, they create for themselves in the course of time a legal system that authorizes it and a moral code that glorifies it." Sadly, most of the people don't wish to bite the hands that feeds them

The Securities and Exchange Commission says it has set aside about $450 million for payments to outside whistleblowers whose information results in successful ?? ..... SOME THING YOU WONT TO LOOK AT LISA SIMPSON ,, and the best way to rob a bank is to own a bank

Zuckerberg has already, on multiple occasions, demonstrat­ed that he didn't care nothing about the security and privacy and understand even the fundamenta­ls of computer system security ; this is way he stole the idea facebook but not from the winklevoss but did sign a contract to paul ceglia
zuckerberg In a email zuckerberg called paul ceglia a dum sucker in 2003 i david posted a copy on to the internet and the
roomer spread years a go that zuckerberg had sign the contract ; and zuckerberg only sign the contract to steal the idea facebook from david

and it was david who contacted the winklevoss about the idea facebook and paul ceglia is going to get 84% of facebook

The Securities and Exchange Commission says it has set aside about $450 million for payments to outside whistleblowers whose information results in successful : I THINK WIKILEAKS can do with some of this whistle blowers money ; TIME to dropkick GS in the sacK

Tony Merchant may be contacted at 306-359-7777 . Jason Zushman can be contacted at 204-896-7777 .

david made contact to merchant law merchant law contact lisa simmson & mark zuckerberg there are some interesting emails if you contact Tony Merchant you can get the email from him i left instruction to give the emails to every one ask for them this was done years a go

dave posted a copy of the emails to ben mezrick and to david kirkpatrick

Ok probably everyone has been scared off by the $$$ signs involved to post back..

And im not sure if you posted in a moment of anger, if it was, im pretty sure it didnt portray anyone in a good light instead of just illuminating mark.

I also find it pretty sensational to drop in things like the twin towers and refrences to the simpsons as they came across far less as an illustrative aid and more towards something else.

And i dont think telling bill that marks been known to sit on the side line fishing for information from someone else at, as i belive hes been know to go there, ask steve.... but as the saying goes thats business.

I know my opinion has no bearing and will possibly never get read by you, mark or anyone involved....

... But life it to short to waste your lifes arguing, ultimately no one is going to win... You should all think about it.