Daly Bread: Giving us a 4 for an A; more trouble in the Judiciary

In parts of the Caribbean, including here in Trinidad and Tobago, fooling someone is referred to as “giving a six for a nine.”

Last week, a High Court Judge was arrested and charged with—as it is popularly known—driving under the influence. After his court appearance, it was reported that the police had erroneously charged the Judge under a section of the motor vehicle legislation referred to as section 70 (4).

Photo: Justice Kevin Ramcharan.

Such a section does not exist and the Judge should have been charged under Section 70A, so the bemused public got a 4 for an A.

The Judge’s lawyers are gung-ho to object to a proposed amendment to the charge. Whatever the Magistrate decides, it is clear that further reputational damage has been done to the already badly wounded Judiciary, All the recent wounds flowing from the current judicial regime, whose Chief is attempting to carry on nonchalantly, no doubt encouraged by shallow statements from the Attorney General to the effect that the threshold for impeachment proceedings has not been reached.

For many months, I took the lead in seeking accountability and consequences for the appointment blunders made by the Judicial and Legal Service Commission—which the Chief Justice heads—as well as for the subsequent serious but largely unanswered questions about the conduct of the Chief Justice. One kernel of the conduct is allegedly approaching State agencies to assist with State-provided housing for dubious friends and acquaintances.

Eventually, when the Law Association took up the matter, I decided that I would not refer to the subject again. The matter proceeded to the courts and the Court of Appeal last month dismissed the Chief Justice’s application for judicial review of the Law Association’s actions.

Photo: President Paula-Mae Weekes (right) addresses Chief Justice Ivor Archie during her inauguration ceremony at NAPA on 19 March 2018.(Copyright Office of the President)

Following the Court of Appeal’s decision, I maintained my silence and I declined all requests for interviews on the current state of play.

However, the Chief Justice proceeded on even more leave, counting his days on duty and off duty in the manner of a poorly motivated clerk fighting to claim Ash Wednesday as a cool down holiday.

Claiming vacation days to replace days attending an Organisation of American States’ conference—hardly an occasion that will improve the poorly regarded administration of justice—after your belly full of holidays already would provoke from the young people the response, “Seriously?”

Do invitations to conferences that come with top management status justify claims for additional holidays, if attendance at these conferences is a personal choice from a menu of travel junkets?

It looks like the bemused public also got a 4 for an A in this long running Chief Justice saga, that is four kinds of leave which are hampering A class leadership of our Judiciary.

To rub salt in the wound, we already have difficulty in putting errant officials in the doghouse, yet we may be property taxed on the empty doghouses—an effective, jokey sound bite from Kamla. The doghouses are mostly empty awaiting the slow grind of the wheels of justice and accountability.

It is useful to note, in the context of another blow to the reputation of the Judiciary, Justice of Appeal Bereaux’s observation that “a judge cannot be expected to be immunised from public scrutiny.”

Both Justice of Appeal Mendonca, who presided. and Justice Bereaux expressed similar opinions regarding allegations of negative conduct of a judge in the public domain.

Justice Mendonca: “Allegations in the public domain impacting negatively on the conduct of a judge particularly when they are unanswered and not refuted are capable of damaging public confidence in the judiciary and undermining the judiciary.”

Justice Bereaux: “These allegations so negatively impact on the office of Chief Justice and by extension the judiciary that they threaten to undermine the administration of justice and the rule of law.”

Given the spin that the Chief Justice is being persecuted, equally useful are the observations of Justice of Appeal Jamadar as to how “difficult it is to sit in judgment of one’s own Chief Justice. It reveals how challenging the work of judging can be.”

The challenges of public commentators are equally formidable. Commentators worth their salt will not be easily run off the field.

Photo: President Anthony Carmona (centre) poses for a photo after appointing High Court judges Kevin Ramcharan (far left), Marcia Ayers-Caesar (second from left) and Avason Quinlal-Williams (far right) in April 2017.Also in the photo is Chief Justice and JLSC chairman Ivor Archie.Ramcharan was charged last week for drunk driving.

About Martin Daly

Martin G Daly SC is a prominent attorney-at-law. He is a former Independent Senator and past president of the Law Association of Trinidad and Tobago.
He is chairman of the Pat Bishop Foundation and a steelpan music enthusiast.

Yea….wrong charge….smh….some senior arrange dat since the charge is written up in the station….yet the remaining public / “poor” man have to pay for all…no one to be held accountable for this willfull/corrupt/ orchestrated blunder…….only in a “shithole” country ….Soo what’s new…….corruption is the order of the day…..one law for the 1% ….whilst the remaining 99% sheep, have to suffer….

Who has eyes, let them see…..The ‘mistake’ in laying the charge was deliberately done to provide a loophole for the judge to wiggle out of…..Ask yourself this….A judge, one of the most prominent office holders of our land is being processed at a police station….How come a young, inexperienced officer is left to write up the charges???….Miss me with that B.S. TTPS …..smh.

You really think Daly is concerned about the case itself? It’s just another tool that he is using while trying to be a “smart man” to go after the CJ.
You don’t think that he knows that the JLSC picks judges and the CJ is only its Chair?
You don’t think that he also knows that after being appointed a Judge, the CJ has very little line authority over the Judges and in true public service fashion, can do very little in terms of enforcing discipline ?
He knows all of that but he also knows that most of the country doesn’t. So, he goes ahead and tries to tie this to the CJ in what he thinks is a very subtle manner. All the while not saying anything further on Ramdeen, Debideen et al, all members of his fraternity.
This batch of professionals make me sick.

People don’t seem to understand that a dui is considered a criminal offense so even if he admits guilt and onĺy gets a fine it comes with a criminal record and instantly impacts his current professional standing

3 weeks agoby wired868Save boi! T&T Maestros goalkeeper Jaydon Thomas keeps out a shot with the help of the bar during RBYL North Zone Under-13 action at the Queen’s Park Savannah on 27 April 2019. Photo: Allan V Crane/CA-Images/RBYL

1 week agoby wired868So close... Crown Trace goalkeeper Michael Frederick (left) uses his right boot to keep out an attempt on goal from San Juan Jabloteh’s Kellon John (centre) during RBYL U-11 action in Macoya on 11 May 2019. Photo: Allan V Crane/CA-Images/Wired868

3 weeks agoby wired868Chip off the old block? Mayo Youths attacker Tyrique Phillip (left) is on the prowl during RBYL South Zone Under-13 action on 7 April 2019. Tyrique is the son of Trinidad and Tobago National Senior Team goalkeeper and 2001 World Youth Cup player, Marvin Phillip. Photo: Allan V Crane/CA-Images/Wired868