Transcription

1 Copyright 2010 The Author(s) SPECIAL SECTION ON ROSA LUXEMBURG S POLITICAL ECONOMY Introduction: Rosa Luxemburg s Political Economy Contributions to Contemporary Political Theory and Practice ELAINE COBURN Co-editor, Socialist Studies / Études socialistes It is fitting that our special issue on Rosa Luxemburg is our most international volume to date, with many contributors sharing migrant histories and working at universities based in Canada, Germany, Spain and the United States. We are fortunate to have several of the foremost Luxemburg scholars today contributing analyses, with each author tackling different aspects of Luxemburg s rich legacy, including theories of capitalist crisis, colonization, feminism, imperialism and war, and doing so from disciplinary roots in economics, English, history, labour studies, philosophy and more. Klaus Dörre draws upon the concept of Landnahme to explore the dialectical relationship between the inside and outside spaces created by capital within the capitalist world system. He argues that the inside is characterized by capitalistic market relationships and normal exploitation within a crisis-ridden system. The outside is simultaneously a realm of superexploitation and non-commodified spaces, including, for example, public health and education services but also traditional, non-market relationships, in agriculture or other domains, that are continually ripe for recommodification. Importantly, the inside and the outside of capitalism are less defined by national boundaries than by the simultaneous coexistence of capitalist and non-capitalist relationships across national borders and the world system. Dörre mobilizes this insight to explain the historic rise of financial capitalism, with an emphasis on the specific case of German coordinated capitalism. In particular, he explores the mechanisms that lead relatively secure workers to eschew strategies based on a unified, class-conscious political force for defensive, corporatist positions that export employment insecurity and precarity to marginalized populations. Dörre concludes by setting out six analytical trajectories that may be particularly useful for contemporary working class struggle, including for a class conscious ecological politics. Peter Hudis analyses as yet unpublished and lesser-known works by Rosa Luxemburg and Karl Marx to explore processes of labour commodification, specifically, the transformation of peasants into free Socialist Studies: the Journal of the Society for Socialist Studies/ Études socialistes: Revue de la Société d'études socialistes ISSN

2 COBURN: Introduction: Rosa Luxemburg s Political Economy workers in the global periphery. Hudis contrasts Engels approach to non- Western societies with Luxemburg s and Marx s independent but parallel analyses, both pointing to contradictory tendencies within non-western communities. They both argue, for example, that Indigenous communities in North America simultaneously contain revolutionary socialist potential rooted in communal forms of living but also incipient hierarchies, including gender inequalities that, within a world capitalist system, portend inegalitarian social relations, including of the capitalist variety. Despite this common ground, however, Hudis argues that Marx had a much more cautious approach than Luxemburg to understanding the likely transformations of such societies. Luxemburg assumes that communal societies will inevitably be absorbed in a unidirectional historical process leading to world capitalism. In contrast, Marx argues that the outcome is uncertain, depending upon socially-conscious action that in the case of Russian communes, for instance, might lead to socialism without capitalism but might equally deteriorate into capitalist private property relations, especially given intervention by the Tsarist state. Hudis concludes that both Marx and Luxemburg have valuable insights into historical transformations across the world system, including underappreciated contributions to the analysis of non-western societies. But, he concludes, Marx is more subtle than Luxemburg and better recognizes that people in the periphery have a vital role to play in their own liberation. In his research note, Paul Le Blanc contrasts Luxemburg s contributions to socialist theories with those of Marx, Bukharin, Lenin and others. He draws particular attention to her analyses of imperialism as a necessary, but contradictory dynamic inherent to the capitalist mode of production. Like no other of her contemporaries, he argues, Luxemburg denounced the full horror of imperialism, the destruction of peoples and cultures, a dynamic inherent to the capitalist system with its tendencies towards limitless capital accumulation. Further, Le Blanc calls attention to the ways that Luxemburg anticipated the current role of international financial organizations like the International Monetary Fund and World Bank, seeing financial loans and large infrastructure projects as simply another face of imperialism, a way of tying new states into a hegemonic system favouring older states, at the expense of displaced, brutalized populations. Le Blanc concludes with Luxemburg s condemnation of capitalism as a system of war and violence, culminating in the devastation of the first World War: mass murder that Luxemburg saw as the final proof of capitalism s incompatibility with humanity. 39

3 40 Ingo Schmidt emphasizes that for Luxemburg, capitalism was always an international system, since the sustained accumulation of capital is only possible by continually incorporating new, non-capitalist economies into the capitalist system. By extending credit to natural economies, for example, demand is stimulated, excess production is absorbed and formerly non-capitalist territories and peoples are thereby incorporated into the capitalist system. States play an important role in this process, waging war to protect the interests of domestic against foreign capital and also to open up non-capitalist societies to capitalist markets. In considering the relevance of this argument for understanding today s crisis, Schmidt puts Luxemburg s work and Marxist criticism of it in historical context, noting how events like the 1930s crisis or internal Communist politics had an impact on how receptive other Marxists were to her ideas. Schmidt then goes on to sketch some ways that Luxemburg s political economy can be used to explain current transformations, notably the rise of neoliberal politics in the 1970s, but also the military aggressiveness of the declining hegemon, the United States. Following Luxemburg, Schmidt wonders if the incorporation of former developing states and the former Soviet Union and China into world capitalism heralds a decisive new moment of crisis in the world capitalist system. He asks: will this moment of crisis see the rise of a new hegemon, intensified imperialist conflict, or renewed working class militancy against the power of capital? Scott briefly sketches the historical context of Luxemburg s life, contrasting the turbulent times in which she lived and to which she contributed with the current moment, when the labour movement, particularly in the United States, is especially weak. Against those who understand Luxemburg as deterministic in her analyses of capitalism, Scott argues that Luxemburg always emphasized the vital role of working class struggle: the choice is between socialism and barbarism, but there is no automatic movement towards the former. Contrasting Luxemburg s views with those of reformist socialist Eduard Bernstein, but also with contemporary critics of Marxism, Scott argues for the ongoing pertinence of Luxemburg s views: on the state, including her understanding of the state s militarism as instrumental to buttressing the power of capital against labour domestically and internationally; on the fundamental incompatibility of capitalism and genuine democracy; and on the possibilities for socialism from below and the potential but also the limits of trade unionism, with its risks of bureaucratization. Scott concludes that Luxemburg s insights are useful in understanding the current economic crisis. Crucially, if the barbarism of contemporary capitalism is to be

4 COBURN: Introduction: Rosa Luxemburg s Political Economy overcome it can only be through revolutionary activity by the masses themselves, not by a vanguard of professional politicians or trade union bureaucrats supposedly acting on their behalf. Trincado argues that Luxemburg s thought is particularly relevant today, helping to explain the current economic crisis and the rise of financial capitalism. In her article, she considers the interweaving of Luxemburg s biography, as a revolutionary woman actively engaged in socialist politics, with her theoretical contributions. Trincado insists that although Luxemburg struggled against sexism and as a result of her disability and was ultimately assassinated, she cannot be considered a victim. Rather, Luxemburg must be appreciated for her active struggle for an open intellectual approach linked to revolutionary politics. This openness led her to question nationalism that did not serve the cause of international socialism, party and trade union politics disconnected from the spontaneous struggle of the masses, and Marxist theories that are not constantly compared against and related to the social experiences of class struggle. In particular, Trincado argues that Luxemburg developed a new concept of alienation, one steeped in her appreciation of art and literature, but also in the simple appreciation of every moment of life. For Luxemburg, Trincado argues, liberation is understood as perpetual movement, a collective participation by the masses in history, based upon a fundamental openness to the possibilities for revolutionary change. As these brief summaries suggest, Luxemburg s work is broad and multifaceted and there is disagreement among progressive scholars about the specific strengths and weaknesses of her theories. For example, there is no consensus about how deterministic or how open her view of history really was, with some authors in this issue lamenting a certain determinism, and others arguing that, on the contrary, she was never deterministic and always committed to the idea of the contingency of working class revolution and socialism. In this debate, Trincado s approach may represent a third way, since she argues that Luxemburg was both strikingly open and critical in her theory and praxis, while nonetheless maintaining that the material that is, social -- context of world capitalism means that working class consciousness is forged in particular and not infinitely malleable ways. Other contributions emphasize Luxemburg s committed internationalism, not least her analytical curiosity about non- Western societies and the ways they are articulated with Western capitalist ones within a world capitalist system, an analytical bent that seems particularly fruitful in the current era of capitalist globalization. Others consider Luxemburg s arguments about the potential for forms of 41

5 worldwide class solidarity today, when capital and capitalism appears particularly strong and working class opposition, fragmented and weak. These kinds of concerns only scratch the surface, contributors maintain, with Luxemburg s concepts potentially illuminating questions around the ecological limits of world capitalism, the articulation of feminism and working class struggles, and many more vital issues. When Ingo Schmidt initially proposed the special volume on Luxemburg s contemporary relevance, another member of the editorial board privately suggested to me that it was doubtful we would have enough interest. The current analyses prove such doubts wrong: not only is Luxemburg s work exciting to progressive scholars in many different disciplines, a hundred years later, but her contributions are critically useful in helping us analyse the evolution of the world capitalist system up to and including the latest crisis today. These articles are just the beginning, a stimulus to further conversation around Luxemburg s life and work. 42 Acknowledgements Special thanks to Ingo Schmidt, a member of the Socialist Studies/Études Socialistes editorial board and a contributor to this issue. Ingo had the original idea for the special section, wrote up the call for papers and sent out the initial invitations, subject to peer review, to contribute.

Market Economy and Socialist Road Duan Zhongqiao The relationship between market economy and socialism has become a point at issue among Marxists in every part of the world after the collapse of the socialist

Rahaf Alwattar Daniela Morales Kiley Smith Madison So To What Extent is The Cold War a Result of Two Conflicting Ideologies? The Cold War was an unceasing state of political and military tensions between

1 di 5 13/07/2007 18.23 Hegemony, subalternity and subjectivity Kylie Smith Many words have been written about the concept of hegemony as Gramsci developed it in the Prison Notebooks, and many of these

Global civil society beyond the good and the bad Håkan Thörn and Heidi Moksnes What is global civil society? And what is the meaning of global civil society? A few years ago, there was a debate on whether

Immanuel Wallerstein This presentation is based on the theory of Immanuel Wallerstein as presented in books listed in the bibliography. A summary of this and other macro-social theories can be found in

Fall 2008 Sociology 101A Michael Burawoy HISTORY OF SOCIAL THEORY A course on the history of social theory can be presented with two different emphases -- as intellectual history or as theoretical tradition.

The Study of Conflict in Political Science and International Relations Stefan Wolff The Study of Conflict in the Social Sciences Conflict as a social phenomenon of competition between actors with incompatible

REVIEW of Marxian Political Economy: Theory, History and Contemporary Relevance by Bob Milward. London: Macmillan. 2000. 219 pages. by Fred Moseley, Mount Holyoke College This book is intended as a textbook

The state of the EU crisis: possible scenarios Johannes Jäger 1 The state of the EU crisis: possible scenarios 1. The crisis at the surface 2. Theoretical perspective: political economy 3. Causes and dynamics

Department Head: Professor John T. Rourke Department Office: Room 137, Monteith Building Undergraduate Catalog 1998-1999 POLITICAL SCIENCE (POLS) For major requirements, see the College of Liberal Arts

International Conference of the Commission on Legal Pluralism in collaboration with the Department of Humanities and Social Sciences, Indian Institute of Technology Bombay Normative Interfaces of Globalization

Challenging Marxism By Sam Wagener The German philosopher Karl Marx provided the world with a new and challenging way to think about social and economic systems. This new social system was called Communism

Standard: History Enlightenment Ideas A. Explain connections between the ideas of the Enlightenment and changes in the relationships between citizens and their governments. 1. Explain how Enlightenment

4 Models of Democracy Part Three: 'What Should Democracy Mean Today?' 4.1 Introduction to Part Three Well, here we are at last! In Parts One and Two of Models of Democracy, David Held looked at nine major

Mirror for Humanity by Kottack Quiz #10 C. Milner-Rose Chapter 10: The World System and Colonialism Multiple Choice Questions 1. What fueled the European Age of Discovery? A. A desire to save the souls

Chapter 2:Sociology s Family Tree: Theories and Theorists 1 What is a Theory? A set of assumptions that attempts to provide a plausible explanation of cause-and-effect (causal) relationships among a group

Capitalist Markets and Crime Gary Potter, PhD. Professor, School of Justice Studies Eastern Kentucky University (Class discussion document) There are many different economic s operating in the world today:

SOCIAL STUDIES TEST for e-lessons day 2 Name Directions: Use your own piece of paper as your answer document. Do not print off the test. You will need to only turn in your answer document. 29. The Cold

Louisiana World History Louisiana History (Core Course: World History) World History 19. Explain the origins, developments, and consequences of the transatlantic slave trade between Africa and the Americas

CHAPTER 11: The Problem of Global Inequality MULTIPLE CHOICE 1. The claim that poverty is unethical is essentially a. Normative c. political b. theoretical d. scientific 2. Self-interest is an important

Globalization and China: Impact on the Economy and People s Quality of Life Tao (Tony) Gao, Ph. D. Zarb School of Business Hofstra University University 1 APEC Economic Leaders' Declaration Shanghai, China;

1 Department: Political Science, Philosophy & Religion. Course No. IU310. Title of Course: Government and Politics of East Asia. I. A. Catalog Description and Credit Hours of the Course: A survey of social,

FROM MARXISM TO POLITICAL PHILOSOPHY: THE DEMAND FOR SOCIAL TRANSFORMATION IN TARRIT FABIEN 1 1. Economic and social transformations that occurred worldwide during the twenty five past years allow us to

Ownership, Property Rights, and Economic Performance: Theory and Practice in the USA and other Countries by David M. Kotz Professor, Department of Economics and Research Associate, Political Economy Research

Executive Report to the CACP Board of Directors from CACP Global 2015 Cyber crime: Police Roles and Responsibilities Within a Collaborative Framework In the fall of 2014, the CACP Board of Directors assigned

A 362352 Contending Theories of International Relations A Comprehensive Survey Fifth Edition James E. Dougherty St. Joseph's University Robert L. Pfaltzgraff, Jr. The Fletcher School of Law and Diplomacy,

150 Years of The Communist Manifesto Page 1 of 5 Page 2 of 5 The Communist Manifesto remains a good introduction in their own words to the ideas of Marx and Engels. Here we summarise its contents and put

As we wind down the year, we are going to be reviewing while also finalizing our preparation for the AP Exam on May 6 th. One of the last skills you will need to have is writing essays from DBQs or Document

ID: International Dialogue, A Multidisciplinary Journal of World Affairs 4 2014 Review Human Rights & Gender Violence: Translating International Law into Local Justice Sally Engle Merry. Chicago: The University

The Right to Work in Dignity: Human Rights and Economic Rights Joyce Apsel Everyone has the right to work, to free choice of employment, to just and favourable conditions of work and to protection against

NOTES O N FORMALIZATION Evolution of informal employment in the Dominican Republic According to official estimates, between 2005 and 2010, informal employment fell from 58,6% to 47,9% as a proportion of

THE DEPARTMENT OF SOCIAL AND BEHAVIORAL SCIENCES POLITICAL SCIENCE PROGRAM HANDBOOK MAY 2015 Political Science Objectives 1. To study the structure and functions of government. 2. To understand political

Fall 2015 Sociology 101 Michael Burawoy HISTORY OF SOCIAL THEORY A course on the history of social theory can be presented with two different emphases -- as intellectual history or as theoretical tradition.

GLOBALIZATION AND THE INVASION OF IRAQ: STATE POWER AND THE LIMITS OF CONSENSUS EGAN, DANIEL 1. One of the major casualties of the U.S. invasion of Iraq has been globalization. By this I do not mean the

The Globalisation of Capital, Crisis and Class Struggle Simon Clarke The relation between capital accumulation, crisis and class struggle has been a central theme of CSE since its foundation, indeed it

Ceremony at the Quirinal Palace on the occasion of the Thirtieth Anniversary Celebration for employees of the Bank of Italy and the Ufficio Italiano dei Cambi Speech by Antonio Fazio Governor of the Bank

THE PARADOX OF ENGLISH LEARNING IN JAPAN: PROBLEMS AND POLICIES BERNARD SAINT-JACQUES ABSTRACT: This paper will examine the various policies of the Japanese Government concerning English teaching and learning

MARXISM AND ENVIRONMENTAL THEORY 1. How to reposition and re-conceptualise Marxism in the age of the crisis of our planetary system? Marxism when theorised in the 19 th century, was conceived as the culmination,

- 1 - This text is about the communist political system, communist, socialist and capitalist political theories and George Orwell s book Animal Farm. There are some words in this text that you won t see

How s Life in the United Kingdom? May 2014 The OECD Better Life Initiative, launched in 2011, focuses on the aspects of life that matter to people and that shape their quality of life. The Initiative comprises

Student Handout #1: A Brief History of Canadian Citizenship Section One: Citizenship The concept of citizenship goes all the way back to ancient Greece. In the Greek city states, citizens were people who

190 P O L I T I C A L S C I E N C E POLITICAL SCIENCE (POSCI) Politics rules over everything you do as a human being and gives you an understanding that enables you to have more control over your own life.

Liberals must embrace power politics to define the 21 st century. - says LI President Van Baalen After the fall of the Berlin wall, the American philosopher Francis Fukuyama concluded that the only remaining

Criticisms of The Neo-Classical Development Model Colin Henning ECON 4999 Spring 2008 At the end of World War II the ideologies of the United States and the Soviet Union were at odds. The two super powers

MC.DEL/8/11 6 December 2011 ENGLISH only STATEMENT OF THE HOLY SEE AT THE EIGTHEENTH MINISTERIAL COUNCIL OF THE ORGANIZATION FOR SECURITY AND COOPERATION IN EUROPE (OSCE) DELIVERED BY HIS EXCELLENCY ARCHBISHOP

HIGH SCHOOL: WORLD HISTORY Standard 1 Historical Thinking Skills Students use information and concepts to solve problems, interpret, analyze, and draw conclusions from historical events. WH.1.1 Produce

The Demise of the Soviet Union and the International Socialist Movement Today David M. Kotz University of Massachusetts Amherst and Shanghai University of Finance and Economics dmkotz@econs.umass.edu April,

I. MAIN ISSUES CHINA S DEVELOPMENT STRATEGY: THE KNOWLEDGE AND INNOVATION PERSPECTIVE Carl Dahlman Jean-Eric Aubert World Bank Institute 2000 EXECUTIVE SUMMARY China has made great progress since it opened

Recommendations of the Board of Trade of Metropolitan Montreal to the Government of Canada for the 2016 federal budget July 2015 1 Preamble The Board of Trade of Metropolitan Montreal (the Board of Trade)

Russian National Security Policy in 2000 Celeste A. January 2000 PONARS Policy Memo 102 Harvard University Although signing a decree granting the new National Security Concept the status of law in January

Cyber Security Ultimately Is Military Security Reporter: ZUO Xiaoyu You Ji Professor of Macau University, School of Social Sciences. Research Area: national security. With deepening development of cyber

Dr. Jürgen Pfister, Chief Economist and Head of Investment Research The Pros and Cons of European Integration: the Pros A German Perspective Global Insight s World Economic Outlook Conference Cambridge,

NORTH NORTH, NORTH SOUTH, AND SOUTH SOUTH RELATIONS L. University of Trier, Germany Keywords: Development, modernization, dependency, polarization, New International Economic Order, Debt Crisis, stuctural

CHINA AND EUROPE, 1500-2000 and BEYOND: What is Modern? Lesson Guide to Web Module Bram Hubbell, the Friends Seminary, Brooklyn, New York. Eight Sections following those of the Web module: I. Introduction

To what extent was Mao Zedong a successful leader, in respect to the implementation of the Long March, his Five Year Plan, the Great Leap Forward, and the Cultural Revolution? Ilyasah Shabazz IB History

Political Science Courses-1 American Politics POL 110/American Government Examines the strengths and weaknesses, problems and promise of representative democracy in the United States. Surveys the relationships

How s Life in Norway? May 2014 The OECD Better Life Initiative, launched in 2011, focuses on the aspects of life that matter to people and that shape their quality of life. The Initiative comprises a set