Newsroom

BLOG

Traumatic Shock

byJill Englar

Nothing in my fourteen-year hospice career ever could have prepared me for June 9, 2005, when my mother and my two adult children were flown to Shock Trauma in critical condition following a motor vehicle accident. I was not prepared for the “save life at all cost” philosophy or the total disregard of my mother’s advanced directives. I was not permitted at the bedside or even informed that she was dying.

Locked down on the first floor waiting room, my husband, my brother and I had no access or updates. We knew only from the initial telephone call to my work that a man had run a red light and crashed into my mother’s car. The man had been operating his father’s truck and hauling his sister’s disabled car on a dolly. The accident occurred close to home at approximately two p.m., and I received the telephone call at work by three p.m. An RN named Jim told me only that our son had sustained multiple injuries, including a serious liver laceration, concussion, fractured ribs and a lacerated spleen. He had been unconscious upon impact, but now was awake and unable to remember the accident. I insisted upon speaking to my son, and to his credit, Jim put the phone up to my son’s ear. I tearfully expressed my love and said I was on my way.

Our twenty-one-year-old daughter was “stable” and reportedly undergoing a series of scans. There was absolutely no word about my mother’s status. The nurse had urged us to proceed to the hospital as quickly as possible. I called my husband and only surviving brother with the scant details. After sitting in the waiting room until 5:30 p.m., I could not wait any longer for information, and I told the clerk I was upset. No one had spoken to us since my initial phone contact with Jim. If my son or mother were in critical condition or in danger of dying, then I needed to be at the bedside, even for a moment. Furthermore, I was my mother’s legal health care agent and had her written directive with me.

Eventually, a physician and nurse came down to deliver the news. We were asked to come with them to a small conference room. Since other doctors had been delivering news to different families in the public waiting area, I was sick with fear, and a deep sense of despair swept over me. The death notification they delivered was cold and blunt, without compassion or awareness of the grief process. My mother was dead. Our son remained in critical condition due to his liver laceration and required a groin catheterization to determine the extent of his injury. Our daughter was “stable” and could possibly be discharged home later that night.

No ancillary services were ever offered, and we were too numb with shock and grief to ask. Outside the conference room, a police investigator waited with questions for us. The outburst of emotions from my brother and me ranged from disbelief and anger to almost rage. We were upset and distraught at the medical team for not bringing us up to the floor as soon as possible to be at our dying mother’s bedside. We did not wish to waste time with the police who had failed to run a drug and alcohol test on the driver who killed our mother.

We demanded to see our mother’s body first, and we were told it would be difficult, since there was no privacy—only a large room with curtain dividers. When we insisted, the staff reluctantly conceded. We were instructed not to tell our children that their grandmother had died, since our son was still facing a groin catheterization, so we agreed to abide by their rules. Our grown children were two beds over and lying flat on their backs with neck collars so they were unable to see us enter. A policeman was guarding an injured prisoner in the bed next to my mother. Staff continued to view her scans and discuss her case: “A classic T-bone fracture of the pelvis.” They were literally feet away from where we knelt by her bloodied, lifeless body. We had to close the flimsy curtain around her bed as we struggled to comprehend what had happened.

Our recovery process was significantly impacted by our anger and frustration at the hospital’s medical-model approach. My mother’s intubation tube was never removed, and her toe was tagged in our presence. The message was clear: No mourning allowed. Move on to your children, and ignore any questions about grandma.

No condolences were offered; only a purple folder entitled “Coping with Grief” when our daughter was discharged later that night. Our son was transferred to an upstairs unit, and we were not allowed to spend the night with him.

Shell-shocked and feeling beaten up, we drove home with our daughter and returned the next day to help care for our son. Again, no social worker or chaplain services were offered. Overwhelmed and in tears by later afternoon, I requested a chaplain. He tried to listen and eventually located the shock trauma nurse who had been with the doctor to deliver the news the previous night. In the hallway outside my son’s room, she again coldly reviewed the facts culminating in my mother’s death.

In sum, from my perspective, my mother died without us at her bedside, not knowing if her beloved grandchildren were going to live or that the accident was not her fault. When I kept repeating these concerns, the nurse simply stared at me in icy silence. The complicating factors for me were my hospice background, my mother’s clearly expressed wishes against heroics, and her final hours of struggling all alone.

I understand why shock trauma exists—to save lives whenever possible—but when a person dies, the family needs empathy and understanding, not cold, clinical facts. Furthermore, when it is clear that someone is dying with advanced directives in place, then the medical team should consider honoring those wishes. My mother’s broken body and final hours of pain and suffering could possibly have been eased by having us at her bedside. We were and still are left feeling cheated and robbed of the gift of goodbye. The medical team may regret not saving her life. We regret that they did not honor the living or her wishes to prevent heroics.

Our grief was further compounded by hospital demands to “compose ourselves” and “keep it together” for our grown children. We refused to release my mother’s body until our son’s procedure was over and he was told his grandmother had died. Before our daughter was released from the hospital, she wished to view her grandmother’s body, and while some staff understood her needs, others clearly showed their disdain. I dressed my daughter in surgical scrubs, since they had cut off all her clothing upon arrival at the hospital, and I wheeled her over to my mother’s bedside. She requested privacy to mourn alone, so I pulled the curtain closed and waited nearby.

One resident asked why I would “force” my daughter to view a corpse as opposed to waiting for the funeral. Although dazed and numb, exhausted, saddened and fatigued beyond words, I quietly explained it was our daughter’s request to sit with her grandmother and privately mourn. He shrugged his shoulders and returned to view someone else’s body scans. The police officer guarding the prisoner heard the remark and offered a sympathetic look while shaking his head in apparent disbelief.

Counseling has helped to ease our pain as we begin the process of healing. We will not “get over” what happened to us, but eventually, with caring and compassionate listeners, we will learn to live with our loss.

---------------January 2010

ABOUT THE AUTHOR

Jim Englar is Manager of Support Services at Carroll Hospice in Westminster, Maryland. In addition to her work as a licensed social worker, she oversees the hospice’s volunteer, bereavement and spiritual programs. A dedicated hospice worker since 1991, she has witnessed the growth of the national hospice movement firsthand. Jill is a frequent speaker throughout Carroll County, Maryland, and has also presented for the Hospice Network of Maryland and most recently for the April, 2006, ADEC conference in Tampa, Florida. She has been the recipient of the “Excellence in Direct Service” and “You Make a Difference” awards in Maryland.

Jill received her Masters in Social Work from the University of Maryland in 1975 and has been certified as a grief counselor with ADEC since 1998. Her grief poetry has been published in ADEC’s The Forum and in Bereavement magazine. She and her husband have two adult children and currently reside in Carroll County, Maryland.

Privacy Policy

What Information Do We Collect?
When you visit our website you may provide us with two types of information: personal information you knowingly choose to disclose that is collected on an individual basis and website use information collected on an aggregate basis as you and others browse our website.

Personal Information You Choose to Provide
We may request that you voluntarily supply us with personal information, including your email address, postal address, home or work telephone number and other personal information for such purposes as correspondence, placing an order, requesting an estimate, or participating in online surveys.
If you choose to correspond with us through email, we may retain the content of your email messages together with your email address and our responses. We provide the same protections for these electronic communications that we employ in the maintenance of information received by mail and telephone.

Website Use Information
Similar to other websites, our site may utilize a standard technology called "cookies" (see explanation below, "What Are Cookies?") and web server logs to collect information about how our website is used. Information gathered through cookies and server logs may include the date and time of visits, the pages viewed, time spent at our website, and the sites visited just before and just after ours. This information is collected on an aggregate basis. None of this information is associated with you as an individual.

How Do We Use the Information That You Provide to Us?
Broadly speaking, we use personal information for purposes of administering our business activities, providing service and support and making available other products and services to our customers and prospective customers. Occasionally, we may also use the information we collect to notify you about important changes to our website, new services and special offers we think you will find valuable. The lists used to send you product and service offers are developed and managed under our traditional standards designed to safeguard the security and privacy of all personal information provided by our users. You may at any time to notify us of your desire not to receive these offers.

What Are Cookies?
Cookies are a feature of web browser software that allows web servers to recognize the computer used to access a website. Cookies are small pieces of data that are stored by a user's web browser on the user's hard drive. Cookies can remember what information a user accesses on one web page to simplify subsequent interactions with that website by the same user or to use the information to streamline the user's transactions on related web pages. This makes it easier for a user to move from web page to web page and to complete commercial transactions over the Internet. Cookies should make your online experience easier and more personalized.

How Do We Use Information Collected From Cookies?
We use website browser software tools such as cookies and web server logs to gather information about our website users' browsing activities, in order to constantly improve our website and better serve our users. This information assists us to design and arrange our web pages in the most user-friendly manner and to continually improve our website to better meet the needs of our users and prospective users.
Cookies help us collect important business and technical statistics. The information in the cookies lets us trace the paths followed by users to our website as they move from one page to another. Web server logs allow us to count how many people visit our website and evaluate our website's visitor capacity. We do not use these technologies to capture your individual email address or any personally identifying information about you.

Notice of New Services and Changes
Occasionally, we may use the information we collect to notify you about important changes to our website, new services and special offers we think you will find valuable. As a user of our website, you will be given the opportunity to notify us of your desire not to receive these offers by clicking on a response box when you receive such an offer or by sending us an email request.

How Do We Secure Information Transmissions?
When you send confidential personal information to us on our website, a secure server software which we have licensed encrypts all information you input before it is sent to us. The information is scrambled en route and decoded once it reaches our website.
Other email that you may send to us may not be secure unless we advise you that security measures will be in place prior to your transmitting the information. For that reason, we ask that you do not send confidential information such as Social Security, credit card, or account numbers to us through an unsecured email.

How Do We Protect Your Information?
Information Security -- We utilize encryption/security software to safeguard the confidentiality of personal information we collect from unauthorized access or disclosure and accidental loss, alteration or destruction.
Evaluation of Information Protection Practices -- Periodically, our operations and business practices are reviewed for compliance with organization policies and procedures governing the security, confidentiality and quality of our information.
Employee Access, Training and Expectations -- Our organization values, ethical standards, policies and practices are committed to the protection of user information. In general, our business practices limit employee access to confidential information, and limit the use and disclosure of such information to authorized persons, processes and transactions.

How Can You Access and Correct Your Information?
You may request access to all your personally identifiable information that we collect online and maintain in our database by emailing us using the contact form provided to you within the site structure of our website.

Do We Disclose Information to Outside Parties?
We may provide aggregate information about our customers, sales, website traffic patterns and related website information to our affiliates or reputable third parties, but this information will not include personally identifying data, except as otherwise provided in this privacy policy.

What About Legally Compelled Disclosure of Information?
We may disclose information when legally compelled to do so, in other words, when we, in good faith, believe that the law requires it or for the protection of our legal rights.

Permission to Use of Materials
The right to download and store or output the materials in our website is granted for the user's personal use only, and materials may not be reproduced in any edited form. Any other reproduction, transmission, performance, display or editing of these materials by any means mechanical or electronic without our express written permission is strictly prohibited. Users wishing to obtain permission to reprint or reproduce any materials appearing on this site may contact us directly.

Terms & Conditions

Donation Refund Policy

We are grateful for your donation and support of our organization. If you have made an error in making your donation or change your mind about contributing to our organization please contact us. Refunds are returned using the original method of payment. If you made your donation by credit card, your refund will be credited to that same credit card.

Automated Recurring Donation Cancellation

Ongoing support is important to enabling projects to continue their work, so we encourage donors to continue to contribute to projects over time. But if you must cancel your recurring donation, please notify us.