Looking for a liquid, gel or pencil eyeliner on the cheap? These drugstore brand picks get stellar reviews

Why it's great: Although it's a drugstore brand, readers say this eyeliner stands up to other high-end products. It even stays on when used on the waterline, readers say. "I've tried a lot of eyeliners. The liquid liners are too hard for (clumsy) me and the pencils hurt my lids. This is so easy to put on and very smooth and creamy, so I don't feel as if I'm scraping off my eyelid," says a reader. Reviewers love that these gems are also "so reasonably priced" and come in "many different colors."