@Marekz I would remove onether.com/pool from that list until someone can confirm he has paid out. I and another forum member have reached out to him for a status update, but have not received a response.

However, I have permanently parked my miners on http://ethpool.org since they seem to really have their act together. You can see your account climb the credits list, they have per-worker stats, they reliably payout, and they are also the authors of etherchain.org.

It would be good if you could add things like uncle rates, reported hashrates, and actual hashrates into the list for each pool. Some pools have really high uncle rates which translates into lower profits and fewer blocks.