Gigi Hadid and Zayn Malik recently called it quits after dating on and off for over three years. During their time together, they hit many highs, like dressing up as a super sexy Spiderman couple one Halloween, as well as tons of lows, like Zayn going off on more than one Twitter rant about his ex. It’s hard to believe that the power couple is officially over considering their complicated past, and many are still holding out hope that they will reunite. So, to get to the bottom of this tumultuous relationship, I talked with Celebrity Astrologer David Palmer AKA The Leo King who looked at both Gigi and Zayn’s charts to see what went wrong and what the future has in store for these two.

“He’s a Capricorn, and his sensitivities and emotions are out of control,” David says. “He was born with a lot of extreme pressure in his chart.” The Leo King explains that Zayn has this issue where he “takes things so seriously to the point where they’re not even fun anymore.” This could be because his moon is in Virgo, which is making him a “grumpy old man,” according to David. In a similar regard, the Leo King describes Zayn as cold, and lacking compassion, not unlike many mean old men you may have encountered in your life.

“Unfortunately, he was also born with Mars retrograde,” David says. “For a man, that’s very hard. He deals with a lot of masculine insecurities. It’s like he wants to go the opposite direction of where he thinks anybody would want him to go to try to be kind of badass when really it’s like, be you.”

David feels that in a lot of ways Zayn is afraid to show his true self to the public. “It’s almost like he’s putting on a front. He’s afraid to own the more deeper parts of himself and he would rather wear a hard edge right now, which isn’t really working for him.”

The Leo King also speculates that Zayn is struggling with his mental health, which is common when someone is born with Neptune and Uranus conjunct like Zayn. Since Pluto is in the exact position of his sun, it’s currently a very dark time for the singer. “He needs support, but he pushes it away.”

“If you were to pick out on a scale of one to ten of how much extreme stuff is happening to him right now, I would put it on a 9.5,” David says. “What people are seeing out of him right now, it’s just the surface. There is a lot more going on privately.”

WHAT DOES GIGI’S CHART SAY ABOUT HER?

On the other hand, Gigi is the complete opposite of her ex. “She’s a Taurus,” David says. “She’s got her moon in Aquarius, so she’s totally in control and she knows how to disconnect from her emotions in a positive way.”

And while Zayn is currently facing a dark time since Pluto is in the position of his sun, Gigi is actually at a really great moment in her life because Uranus is at the exact position of where her sun was when she was born.

According to David, this revelation is going to manifest itself with Gigi helping others. “Uranus wants freedom interconnected with helping, whether that’s to charities or organizations, or through helping people,” David says. “It’s a great energy because she has the means and she has the way and she can connect with people and that can make things happen right now.”

ARE THEY COMPATIBLE?

Unsurprisingly, as Gigi is hitting this peak in her life while Zayn hits this low, the two are not compatible, according to David.

When they first started dating, based off their charts, Gigi was still trying to figure stuff out. So, when Zayn came around with a “I get what I want” attitude, she was into it. “They both had that similar quality of knowing how to get what they want, but then she realized he’s all over the place,” David says. “He’s kind of an emotional wreck all the time and I think that she outgrew him really quick and realized that she’s an adult and he’s a little kid bashing around all the toys in the room.”

My tweet was not about @GiGiHadid so leave her the fuck alone she is the most amazing woman I’ve ever known

Additionally, David believes that Gigi’s success and confidence could be a trigger for Zayn. “She’s got her stuff way more under control than him,” he says. ” I think that he gets triggered by her because she knows her power and her worth and knows how to actually do something with it.”

A jealous, emotional attitude isn’t good to have when dating a model, and David doesn’t believe that Zayn could deal with it when Gigi would connect with people. “She knows how to move through Hollywood and move through her life without it having to be sexual, but he still can’t handle it. He doesn’t like anything to be any other way than what he wants it to be and for Gigi, who is a double Taurus, that isn’t going to work, because they don’t like to feel owned.”

WILL THEY GET BACK TOGETHER?

So, is there a chance that this tumultuous couple could get back together? David thinks absolutely not. In fact, he believes that Gigi “saved herself from Zayn ruining her life.”

Yes, Gigi’s chart translates to someone who has the ability and desire to help people, but David believes that Gigi isn’t the one who should be helping Zayn. “He’s not in a good place and the last thing she should do is try to go rescue this guy,” the Leo King says. Meanwhile, Gigi is thriving and she would be “doing her own career and life harm to try to go backward and fix Zayn right now. She’s going into a really great direction and she has control over sensitivities and emotions where he does not, but she can’t fix him.”

Even if she could fix him, it might not be worth it. “I think their relationship wasn’t even as good as it looked when it looked good,” says David. So, according to the stars, and the Leo King, the couple just isn’t meant to be.