4. Only while watching the last few seasons of Buffy, James Marsters.
Again, out of character, he's pretty gross looking, but in character....I'd like him to bite me..

Don't have a number 5, and these are all based on characters. You can tell though, I'm not one that's big on looks. Most guys can turn from "not appealing" to "**** sexy" by just having the right kind of personality, or in this case, acting a certain personality.