I would probably take Gio and Freeman. But I think I am lower on Chapman than most and higher on Freeman than most.

Chapman is likely to be really good at some point but it is no guarantee. It doesn't always work for really good relief pitchers transitioning to SP. Plus I feel he will be on an innings limit this year which will limit his value no matter how good he is.

Freeman was dealing with some stuff in the first half of the season. And while you can never take one half, double it and assume that is what he can do, if you did do that it would be a huge season from him. I think he will surprise a lot of people this year.