Comfort

Condition

Neighborhood

Cleanliness

Service

Comfort

Condition

Neighborhood

Great little hotel w a pool and well kept grounds. Service was great and they had a wine and cheese hour at check in after a day of wine tasting.

Genuine Hotels.com guest review

1 night romance trip in Feb 2015

Jessica

US

MacArthur Place, Sonoma

5.0 / 5

Outstanding

"An Outstanding Stay at MacArthur Place"

Cleanliness

5.0

Service

5.0

Comfort

4.0

Condition

4.0

Neighborhood

5.0

An excellent getaway for the two of us. Great wine and cheese pairings as we checked in, and had a very good continental breakfast... Plenty of great fruits and muffins.

Genuine Hotels.com guest review

1 night romance trip in Feb 2015

William

US

MacArthur Place, Sonoma

4.0 / 5

Excellent

"Great!"

Cleanliness

5.0

Service

5.0

Comfort

5.0

Condition

5.0

Neighborhood

5.0

We stayed for one night and it was great but we were close to the Library and they were serving drinks so it was a little noisy and we could hear the upstairs guests above us almost all night so it was a little loud. Other than the noise it was really great. Beautiful grounds, comfortable room.

Genuine Hotels.com guest review

1 night romance trip in Feb 2015

Natalie

US

MacArthur Place, Sonoma

5.0 / 5

Outstanding

"A must stay!"

Cleanliness

5.0

Service

5.0

Comfort

5.0

Condition

5.0

Neighborhood

5.0

Wonderful!

Genuine Hotels.com guest review

1 night romance trip in Feb 2015

A Traveller

US

MacArthur Place, Sonoma

5.0 / 5

Outstanding

"Beautiful property!"

Cleanliness

5.0

Service

5.0

Comfort

5.0

Condition

5.0

Neighborhood

5.0

The property was beautiful and the rooms were cozy. Perfect for our new year getaway.

Genuine Hotels.com guest review

1 night romance trip in Dec 2014

A Traveller

US

MacArthur Place, Sonoma

5.0 / 5

Outstanding

"Very pleasant and relaxing"

Cleanliness

5.0

Service

5.0

Comfort

5.0

Condition

5.0

Neighborhood

-

All was superb, room, staff, breakfast. We would definatelly come back. Recommended.

Genuine Expedia guest review

Other trip

Dec 25, 2014

Michael

US

MacArthur Place, Sonoma

4.0 / 5

Excellent

"Beautiful grounds"

Cleanliness

4.0

Service

4.0

Comfort

4.0

Condition

4.0

Neighborhood

4.0

A very quick but enjoyable stay. Large and nicely appointed room. Charming location. A long walk (6 blocks?) to the town square but a nice walk. The only issue was the desk clerk not setting up our key cards correctly and I had to walk all the way back there for him to correct. Overall, a very nice spot.

Genuine Hotels.com guest review

1 night romance trip in Dec 2014

Joseph

US

MacArthur Place, Sonoma

4.0 / 5

Excellent

"Overpriced"

Cleanliness

4.0

Service

5.0

Comfort

4.0

Condition

3.0

Neighborhood

-

Staff was courteous and grounds were gorgeous. Expected more amenities for the price tag. Ran out of hot water when showering in the morning. Bathrooms were odd. Some new fixtures, facet oversized for the sink. No door on shower which would have been fine if there was a vent in th room.

Genuine Expedia guest review

Other trip

Oct 28, 2014

jan

US

MacArthur Place, Sonoma

5.0 / 5

Outstanding

"Beautiful Oasis in Wine Countey"

Cleanliness

5.0

Service

5.0

Comfort

5.0

Condition

4.0

Neighborhood

5.0

Our stay was wonderful. The rooms are spacious and cozy with large bathrooms and plenty of counter space. After a day of wine tasting, it was great to relax by the pool. We walked into town for dinner each night and loved the relaxed feeling of Sonoma. Perfect for a relaxing getaway!

Genuine Hotels.com guest review

3 night business trip in Oct 2014

Lynn

US

MacArthur Place, Sonoma

5.0 / 5

Outstanding

Cleanliness

5.0

Service

5.0

Comfort

5.0

Condition

4.0

Neighborhood

-

Second time staying at MacArthur Place. Wonderful staff. Great facilities.

Genuine Expedia guest review

Other trip

Aug 25, 2014

A Traveller

US

MacArthur Place, Sonoma

5.0 / 5

Outstanding

"Over the top Fabulous!"

Cleanliness

5.0

Service

5.0

Comfort

5.0

Condition

5.0

Neighborhood

5.0

MacArthur Place is THE place to stay in the Sonoma/Napa area. Beautiful room, gardens and town, and the service was wonderful. I would live there if I could! Thank you for a sweet memorable stay.

Genuine Hotels.com guest review

2 night romance trip in Aug 2014

Louise

US

MacArthur Place, Sonoma

5.0 / 5

Outstanding

"Fantastic stay"

Cleanliness

5.0

Service

5.0

Comfort

4.0

Condition

4.0

Neighborhood

-

My wife and I had an extraordinary time here. We loved the hotel grounds and enjoyed the daily wine happy hour. The hotel staff was exceptional, and help dus with everything we needed. The location worked for us, it was a few blocks from the plaza; I could see that being a problem for those who do not like to wak, but for us it was great. I would certainly […] stay here again.Read more

Genuine Expedia guest review

Other trip

Aug 20, 2014

sconnieProud

US

MacArthur Place, Sonoma

5.0 / 5

Outstanding

"Perfect place to kick back and relax"

Cleanliness

5.0

Service

5.0

Comfort

5.0

Condition

5.0

Neighborhood

-

Terrific inn with gorgeous rooms and grounds. The inn is close to the town of Sonoma. Overall, a terrific experience and I would highly recommend to all.

Genuine Expedia guest review

Other trip

Jul 10, 2014

Kim

US

MacArthur Place, Sonoma

5.0 / 5

Outstanding

"Lovely and tranquil stay near heart of Sonoma"

Cleanliness

5.0

Service

5.0

Comfort

5.0

Condition

5.0

Neighborhood

-

We usually stay in Yountville but needed a hotel in Sonoma for an evening wedding, so decided to try out MacArthur Place. We were not disappointed! The staff could not have been nicer and more helpful, and the room was spacious and very comfortable. (My husband even wanted to know who made their mattresses!) The grounds are spacious and beautiful--lots […] of places to sit and enjoy the quiet or a good book. We highly recommend it!Read more

Genuine Expedia guest review

Other trip

Jul 7, 2014

A Traveller

US

MacArthur Place, Sonoma

5.0 / 5

Outstanding

"MacArthur Place Country Inn"

Cleanliness

5.0

Service

5.0

Comfort

5.0

Condition

5.0

Neighborhood

5.0

Spectacular Inn~ Highly recommend!

Genuine Hotels.com guest review

1 night romance trip in Jul 2014

Cynthia

US

MacArthur Place, Sonoma

5.0 / 5

Outstanding

"A Hidden Gem"

Cleanliness

5.0

Service

5.0

Comfort

5.0

Condition

5.0

Neighborhood

4.0

MacArthur is just a turn off the main road and when you pull into the property, you think you are in another area completely. The staff is the friendliest you could ever want. They share all of their wine knowledge with you (and coupons for buy one/get one) as well as detailed maps. The continental breakfast and free wifi is also a great plus. Geared […] us to the Farmers Market on Tuesday night ... it was so much more .. music, dancing, camaraderie! Just awesome.Read more

Genuine Hotels.com guest review

2 night trip in Jul 2014

AndorraGirl

US

MacArthur Place, Sonoma

5.0 / 5

Outstanding

"Great place!"

Cleanliness

5.0

Service

5.0

Comfort

4.0

Condition

5.0

Neighborhood

4.0

Great place to stay. Would go back for sure.

Genuine Hotels.com guest review

1 night romance trip in Jun 2014

Toothmechanic

US

MacArthur Place, Sonoma

5.0 / 5

Outstanding

"Great character and very relaxing."

Cleanliness

5.0

Service

5.0

Comfort

5.0

Condition

5.0

Neighborhood

-

We really enjoyed our stay at MacArthur Place. The room was great and very clean. I loved the walkways and all the different vignettes. The staff was so friendly! The food from Saddles was really yummy and it was great having it poolside as well. We rented bikes for the day to go wine tasting. Another thing that we loved was that it was a really nice […] 15 minute walk to the center of town which we did thru the neighborhood and was able to see all the beautiful homes in the area. While I was there I texted some friends saying that they need to stay here when they come to Sonoma! We would definitely stay here again.Read more

Genuine Expedia guest review

Other trip

Jul 1, 2014

Chantal

US

MacArthur Place, Sonoma

4.0 / 5

Excellent

"Very nice hotel, but a little out-dated"

Cleanliness

5.0

Service

4.0

Comfort

5.0

Condition

5.0

Neighborhood

5.0

My husband and I stayed here two weeks ago for one night for our anniversary. The room and the grounds were lovely and very well tended to. We were able to walk to the square for dinner, and it was in a secluded enough location that we didn't need to worry about road noise in our room. The staff was very nice. The only real drawback of the hotel is […] that we found the overall atmosphere to be a bit out dated and "stuffy." Otherwise our stay was very nice.Read more

Genuine Hotels.com guest review

1 night romance trip in Jun 2014

Kristen

US

MacArthur Place, Sonoma

5.0 / 5

Outstanding

"Great place for a romantic over night"

Cleanliness

5.0

Service

5.0

Comfort

5.0

Condition

5.0

Neighborhood

-

The staff here was friendly and helpful. They have a great library of DVDs to check out, for free. The wine during the free happy hour was very good. The only negative was the lack of protein on the buffet table for breakfast. Otherwise, the food was very good!

Genuine Expedia guest review

Other trip

Jun 9, 2014

yum!

US

MacArthur Place, Sonoma

5.0 / 5

Outstanding

"Old style comfortable resort near the Sonoma Plaza"

Cleanliness

5.0

Service

5.0

Comfort

5.0

Condition

5.0

Neighborhood

-

Allowed early check in and was given a room with easy access to the pool. Excellent wine and apps free at happy hour, very nice cont breakfast.

Genuine Expedia guest review

Other trip

Jun 2, 2014

Ed

US

MacArthur Place, Sonoma

5.0 / 5

Outstanding

"Amazing stay"

Cleanliness

5.0

Service

5.0

Comfort

5.0

Condition

5.0

Neighborhood

-

The place was so beautiful. We went to the Sanoma area and had a wonderful weekend. The location was so beautiful and restful. The grounds wre beautifu!! I went for several walks around the property and took countless photos. The outdoor gardens and art were amazing. The room was so cozy and the breakfast was perfect.

Genuine Expedia guest review

Other trip

May 26, 2014

A Traveller

US

MacArthur Place, Sonoma

5.0 / 5

Outstanding

"A perfect homebase for our first visit to Sonoma"

Cleanliness

5.0

Service

5.0

Comfort

5.0

Condition

5.0

Neighborhood

-

We chose Macarthur Place based on other Expedia reviews, but I have to say, the hotel exceeded my expectations in every way. The grounds are every bit as beautiful as they appear in the photographs - actually, I found them more charming in person. We had booked a Standard Queen, but when I called to ask about a possible upgrade to celebrate our recent […] engagement, they not only quietly upgraded us but also had a bottle of bubbly waiting for us upon arrival. From check-in to the wine reception to renting bikes from the concierge to taking a movie out of the library, every person we interacted with was so friendly and helpful - the service here is really top notch.Read more

Genuine Expedia guest review

Other trip

Mar 27, 2014

Lisa

US

MacArthur Place, Sonoma

3.0 / 5

Good

"Not worth for the price"

Cleanliness

3.0

Service

3.0

Comfort

2.0

Condition

2.0

Neighborhood

-

The description of room type was one queen bed, but my room was with two small beds and so noisy.

Genuine Expedia guest review

Other trip

Mar 24, 2014

A Traveller

US

MacArthur Place, Sonoma

4.0 / 5

Excellent

"Nice place, but somewhat overpriced/overhyped"

Cleanliness

4.0

Service

4.0

Comfort

3.0

Condition

4.0

Neighborhood

3.0

Overall a very nice hotel, very clean, and more personable than traditional chain hotels. However overall it was overpriced and overhyped. I don't know how it could have such overall rating. Our room was right next to the road and we had car/truck noise all day and night long. Unfortunately the hotel was fully booked and we could not get another room. […] The staff were super friendly and the garden is definitely very nice. I just expected a bit more out of a hotel with such rating and the per night price.Read more

Genuine Hotels.com guest review

2 night romance trip in Feb 2014

A Traveller

US

MacArthur Place, Sonoma

5.0 / 5

Outstanding

"A beautiful, comfortable, friendly place"

Cleanliness

5.0

Service

5.0

Comfort

5.0

Condition

5.0

Neighborhood

-

We loved our too-short stay at MacArthur Place. It was like staying at a gracious friend's lovely home.

Genuine Expedia guest review

Other trip

Feb 19, 2014

Anne

US

MacArthur Place, Sonoma

5.0 / 5

Outstanding

"best 2nd trip"

Cleanliness

5.0

Service

5.0

Comfort

5.0

Condition

5.0

Neighborhood

-

so good we went back, and would reccoemd to anyone going to visit Sonoma

Genuine Expedia guest review

Other trip

Feb 18, 2014

A Traveller

US

MacArthur Place, Sonoma

5.0 / 5

Outstanding

"Great place to stay"

Cleanliness

5.0

Service

5.0

Comfort

5.0

Condition

4.0

Neighborhood

4.0

This is a great hotel. It has a shabby chic vibe to it when you first drive up to it. The rooms and grounds are clean and well maintained. Excellent customer service and wonderful staff. Great place for a quiet getaway!

Genuine Hotels.com guest review

2 night business trip in Feb 2014

Iliana

US

MacArthur Place, Sonoma

5.0 / 5

Outstanding

"A wine-tasting weekend"

Cleanliness

5.0

Service

5.0

Comfort

5.0

Condition

4.0

Neighborhood

-

Lovely cottage-like rooms around a pool and sculpture garden. Nicely located near but not in the Sonoma Plaza. The rate included an outstanding buffet breakfast in their restaurant, which is also excellent for dinner. The staff was very knowledgeable about Sonoma, Napa, and Russian River wineries, and provided maps, recommendations, and special tasting […] cards for all the properties. We had a very relaxing weekend!Read more

Condition

Neighborhood

Cleanliness

3.0

Service

4.0

Comfort

2.0

Condition

3.0

Neighborhood

-

We had stayed for 2 nights, and they told me they upgraded our room for the price we pay. We were happy first. however when we entered the room outlay was quite odd, and the bed was close to the front door. We liked only the rain shower head they had. They offered free wine tasting in the evening, and they provided very cheap wines. We thought we had […] resort coupon for $100. Originally, the guy at the front desk told me they would honor the coupon at the checkout. Hence to spend the money we had a dinner at the restaurant on the property. It was the worst dinner for the price of $100 for 2. When we finally checked out, they did not want to honor the coupon we had, and they told me that since we booked from Expedia website the coupon was not valid. They cheated literally,
One of the worst experience we had. Never to that place again.Read more

Genuine Expedia guest review

Other trip

Jan 27, 2014

A Traveller

US

MacArthur Place, Sonoma

5.0 / 5

Outstanding

Cleanliness

5.0

Service

5.0

Comfort

5.0

Condition

5.0

Neighborhood

5.0

While keeping a historical feel, this hotel has the comfort and convenience o modern facility. Our rooms were large and comfortable. An added attraction is the breakfast buffet, which was included in the room rate; it was simple, but tasty with the typical offerings. You can walk to the Sonoma town square and other famous wine country towns are within […] a 30 minute drive.Read more

Genuine Hotels.com guest review

1 night trip in Jan 2014

LD

US

MacArthur Place, Sonoma

5.0 / 5

Outstanding

"Great Place"

Cleanliness

5.0

Service

5.0

Comfort

5.0

Condition

5.0

Neighborhood

-

Wonderful Staff, beautiful grounds, terrific room, great location.

Genuine Expedia guest review

Other trip

Jan 15, 2014

A Traveller

US

MacArthur Place, Sonoma

4.0 / 5

Excellent

"Too expensive for what it offered"

Cleanliness

5.0

Service

4.0

Comfort

4.0

Condition

4.0

Neighborhood

3.0

Our stay was for only one night but good. It was too expensive for the overall quality of the hotel. The workout room was small and inadequate. I had a massage at the SPA. Unfortunately it was a typical SPA massage, lots of lotion, nice person, but not much sensitivity- rushed and formulaic. Wine and cheese hour was nothing special. Staff overall were […] great. Might be better in the summer.Read more

Genuine Hotels.com guest review

1 night trip in Jan 2014

John

US

MacArthur Place, Sonoma

5.0 / 5

Outstanding

Cleanliness

4.0

Service

5.0

Comfort

4.0

Condition

4.0

Neighborhood

5.0

great experience and found the Staff Helpful in accomidating the right room for our needs. Appreciated that!

Genuine Hotels.com guest review

1 night trip in Dec 2013

A Traveller

US

MacArthur Place, Sonoma

5.0 / 5

Outstanding

"fantastic hotel!"

Cleanliness

5.0

Service

5.0

Comfort

5.0

Condition

5.0

Neighborhood

5.0

We will absolutely be staying here again!

Genuine Hotels.com guest review

1 night trip in Dec 2013

Dan

US

MacArthur Place, Sonoma

5.0 / 5

Outstanding

"Very nice facilities; nice room and good bkfst."

Cleanliness

5.0

Service

5.0

Comfort

5.0

Condition

5.0

Neighborhood

-

Our first stay in Sonoma. Great find. Staff was exceptional; lots of info about things to do, helpful on all fronts. Hotel is a long block south of the main plaza in Sonoma, so you can easily walk up there to see the town and/or go to dinner, etc. Wine country is all around you...Sonoma wineries, Napa is about 20 mins away. Easy to get around. If we […] go back, we would definitely stay at MacArthur Place. Very enjoyable time.Read more

Genuine Expedia guest review

Other trip

Jan 2, 2014

C & J

US

MacArthur Place, Sonoma

5.0 / 5

Outstanding

Cleanliness

5.0

Service

5.0

Comfort

5.0

Condition

5.0

Neighborhood

5.0

Everything was perfect

Genuine Hotels.com guest review

3 night trip in Dec 2013

A Traveller

US

MacArthur Place, Sonoma

5.0 / 5

Outstanding

"Beautiful Property"

Cleanliness

5.0

Service

5.0

Comfort

5.0

Condition

5.0

Neighborhood

-

From the moment we checked in the staff and property made us feel like we were miles away where we could relax and enjoy. We were a short walk to the Sonoma Square where we went as soon as we dropped our luggage. We returned in time for the wine and appetizer reception, great wines were poured and it was very nice in the Library with the fire place […] warming us up. We enjoyed dinner at Saddles where we also had the complimentary breakfast the following morning. We endeed our quick overnight get away with a trip to the spa, both the facial and massage were just what we needed. We look forward to getting back to MacArthur Place but in the future we will stay for two nights at least.Read more

Genuine Expedia guest review

Other trip

Dec 16, 2013

Cindy

US

MacArthur Place, Sonoma

5.0 / 5

Outstanding

"close to town and main roads to wine country"

Cleanliness

5.0

Service

5.0

Comfort

5.0

Condition

5.0

Neighborhood

4.0

The room was excellent. The bathroom was large and very clean with one of the best showers ive ever had at a hotel. The staff was friendly and very helpful. i would recommend this hotel to anyone and would be certain they would not be disapointed.

Genuine Hotels.com guest review

2 night trip in Dec 2013

J Yasinski

US

MacArthur Place, Sonoma

5.0 / 5

Outstanding

"Beautiful and close to downtown"

Cleanliness

5.0

Service

5.0

Comfort

4.0

Condition

5.0

Neighborhood

-

Great location and very charming grounds. Super helpful staff. Absolute best steak at saddles restaurant ever! Nice spacious rooms. The only negative at all was that the beds were not super comfy. They were ok, but not great.

Genuine Expedia guest review

Other trip

Nov 16, 2013

A Traveller

US

MacArthur Place, Sonoma

4.0 / 5

Excellent

"Second of many stays"

Cleanliness

5.0

Service

5.0

Comfort

4.0

Condition

5.0

Neighborhood

-

This was the second time we stayed at MacArthur Place for a long weekend get-away, and we really love the place. We're already talking about "next time." The campus - there's no better word to describe the facilities - is both large and intimate. Our rooms have been large, clean and charming. The staff are warm, efficient and accommodating. Our only […] complaint would be that the walls and floors are not sound-proof, so we did hear people moving about upstairs and outside, but it was a minor ding on an overall great stay.Read more

Genuine Expedia guest review

Other trip

Nov 12, 2013

Paul

US

MacArthur Place, Sonoma

4.0 / 5

Excellent

Cleanliness

5.0

Service

5.0

Comfort

2.0

Condition

5.0

Neighborhood

5.0

MacArthur Place was a great find in Sonoma. I would highly recommend the hotel to others with the exception of one significant issue-- the guest beds are super firm. I was very uncomfortable on them and even after the hotel placed extra padding on the mattress, it was very difficult to sleep. The hotel staff said they hear guest feedback about the beds […] all the time and that "people either hate them or love them," which makes me wonder why a hotel would ever purchase beds that so often received complaints. Although everything else about the hotel was great, I would likely not stay there again because of the sleepless nights.Read more

Genuine Hotels.com guest review

2 night romance trip in Nov 2013

A Traveller

US

MacArthur Place, Sonoma

4.0 / 5

Excellent

"Quaint neighborhood close to town square"

Cleanliness

4.0

Service

4.0

Comfort

4.0

Condition

4.0

Neighborhood

4.0

Great hotel just a short walk to town. The rooms are nice and the grounds are lovely. The swimming pool has plenty of lounge chairs for relaxing and there is a ping pong table if you want a quick game. The included continental breakfast is abundant, but get there early if you want the famous scones. They were all gone by the time we arrived! Rooms on […] lower level are a little noisy so you may want to ask to be upstairs. Great place to use as a base for local Sonoma wine tasting.Read more

Genuine Hotels.com guest review

1 night romance trip in Oct 2013

A Traveller

US

MacArthur Place, Sonoma

5.0 / 5

Outstanding

"A must stay place, my wife and I loved it."

Cleanliness

5.0

Service

5.0

Comfort

5.0

Condition

5.0

Neighborhood

5.0

Great location, rooms were spotless, landscaping was inviting, Staff was friendly, will go again.

Genuine Hotels.com guest review

3 night trip with friends in Oct 2013

marc

US

MacArthur Place, Sonoma

5.0 / 5

Outstanding

"Lovely grounds, excellent service."

Cleanliness

5.0

Service

5.0

Comfort

5.0

Condition

5.0

Neighborhood

5.0

We loved our stay at MacArthur Place and wish we could have stayed longer. The gardens and sculptures throughout the property, provide a very pastoral surrounding, quietly tucked away in the heart of Sonoma. It was great to be within walking distance of the square. The staff could not have been more accommodating and went out of their way to welcome […] us.Read more

Genuine Hotels.com guest review

2 night trip in Sep 2013

Debbie

US

MacArthur Place, Sonoma

5.0 / 5

Outstanding

"Beautiful place to stay with well-tended gardens"

Cleanliness

5.0

Service

4.0

Comfort

5.0

Condition

5.0

Neighborhood

-

Really enjoyed our stay for 3 nights. Would highly recommend this as a place to stay in Sonoma. Enjoyed the spa, too cool for pool, but a nice size pool. Great continental breakfast included in price.

Genuine Expedia guest review

Other trip

Sep 29, 2013

A Traveller

US

Reviews and ratings contained within this site are the subjective opinions of customers and suppliers; they do not represent or reflect Hotels.com’s position. Neither Hotels.com nor the parties involved in providing review content shall be held liable for any damages of any sort resulting from use of these reviews