Ah, but it actually is. Once Whitelisted, you're whitelisted for good (Less you get banned, which there have only been about 3-5 out of the whole 3 years it's been running, with over 800 people whitelisted) And I donated on PotatoOrgy's stream, so the donation goes towards PotatoOrgy, and you still get access to the server

And the community is pretty epic as well, Just search through PotatoOrgy's server Saturday videos