If this is your first visit, be sure to
check out the FAQ by clicking the
link above. You may have to register
before you can post: click the register link above to proceed. To start viewing messages,
select the forum that you want to visit from the selection below.

Re: New Manga Section Suggestion thread

i second that with blud on hsdk getting its own subforum. like he said its over 400 chapters and has a decent fanbase going. another reason on how it could pick up its own subforum is with psyren getting cancelled and probably getting taken off that list of shounen forums just like FMA did.

Re: New Manga Section Suggestion thread

I agree with HSDK getting its own subforum. It's popular as it is, and usually a subforum gives more popularity, and with more popularity, there tends to be more people being spoiler providers (which I hear is some kind of requirement).

Re: New Manga Section Suggestion thread

Originally Posted by Zatono

... there tends to be more people being spoiler providers (which I hear is some kind of requirement).

No, it isn't... For the longest time Bakuman didn't have weekly spoilers (or at least not any that came out before scanlations), and Fairy Tail didn't either. Spoilers being provided at most just serve to fuel some discussion, but is not a requirement at all for a series to have its own subforum.

As Nami already said in the OP of this thread,

Quote:

The series must have regular raws and releases and lots of fans support and good discussion going on etc in order to have sub-forum.

Re: New Manga Section Suggestion thread

This is my first suggestion I hope I do this right. I would like to suggest that An no exorcist to be put in for suggestion for it's own sub forum.

List of reasons why
1. Alot of discussions can be brought up from the fans of the series wheather its pertaining to chapters , character discussions , theories , anime releases , chapter reviews , artwork and scans.

2. The manga seems be getting quite popluar on other sites as 2ch recent begun to post spoilers for this on-going series.

Re: New Section Suggestion Thread

While I do enjoy Beelzebub a great deal, I personally don't think it needs a section of its own. The series is more comedic than plot-driven, meaning that most of the time, discussion about new chapters (and episodes) is 75% "haha, xxx part was so funny". There's not much anyone can theorize or debate about for Beelzebub, which I think is key to generating good and long discussion, and which Beelze lacks (by nature of its genre, not the fault of the thread regulars or anything). I'm not ruling out the possibility of it getting a section, but I just don't think its really necessary right now :/

Re: New Section Suggestion Thread

Originally Posted by saladesu

While I do enjoy Beelzebub a great deal, I personally don't think it needs a section of its own. The series is more comedic than plot-driven, meaning that most of the time, discussion about new chapters (and episodes) is 75% "haha, xxx part was so funny". There's not much anyone can theorize or debate about for Beelzebub, which I think is key to generating good and long discussion, and which Beelze lacks (by nature of its genre, not the fault of the thread regulars or anything). I'm not ruling out the possibility of it getting a section, but I just don't think its really necessary right now :/

actually don't say that the plot is preety original and its preety funny there could be lots of joke thread and the manga is more about the story but still comedic :P and btw who decides on making the new sections???

Re: New Section Suggestion Thread

The entire staff generally discusses adding new forum, though the final decision comes from the admin level. Most of the forums added recently have come from suggestions in this thread. HSD Kenichi, the Breaker, and Hunter x Hunter were all suggested by members, not staff.

When deciding what will get a forum certain factors I look for are the number of members who engage in regular discussion, number of repeat visits to a forum, and number of members making multiple posts in a day. The potential to discuss a variety of topics is also important. It usual is only potential, but I do look to see if members make some attempt to discuss topics other than the latest chapters.

At the moment we are not actively looking to add another forum. The Ao no Exorcist forum opened recently, the Breaker and Manhwa forums are only about a month old. While I am not sure Belze is ready for a sub-forum at the moment, things may change when we are ready to add another sub-forum.