“Sharp-tongued British singer Lilly Allen” certainly thinks so, said Clark Collis in Entertainment Weekly. Over the weekend, Allen said via Twitter that Susan Boyle can sing, but she’s “so overrated.” Allen said Boyle seemed to be a “lovely lady,” but that if talent mattered most, another singer—12-year-old Shaheen Jafargholi—could win.

Susan Boyle still has plenty of people on her side, said Min Lee in the Associated Press via Google. Kelly Clarkson—who won the debut season of American Idol in 2002—says she’s a Boyle fan. And many other show-business powerhouses, including Oprah Winfrey and Demi Moore, have already joined the growing list of Boyle's “celebrity admirers.”