Analysis of Politics, Philosophy and Economics from a Marxist Perspective

Friday, 12 May 2017

Lessons of the Local Elections (7) The Real Task Is To Rebuild A Fighting Labour Movement

The Real
Task Is To Rebuild A Fighting Labour Movement

In France, as I wrote recently, socialists could not call for a vote for
Macron. The real task there is to rebuild the labour movement, and
prepare for a fight whoever won the Presidential Election. The day after his election, thousands of workers were on the streets of Paris protesting against his right-wing plans for attacking workers rights and conditions. A
starting point will be to select socialist candidates prepared to
organise such a fight, to stand in the elections to the Assembly, and
local government positions. The same is true in Britain.

From the first day that Corbyn was elected, there has been a
concerted campaign by the old right-wing within the PLP, and council
chambers across the country to undermine him, and remove him,
overriding the massive majority of the party that elected him. They
have been helped in their activity by the Tory media. But, they must
also have been encouraged by the failure of Corbyn and the party
leadership to actively confront them, and instead, at every step, to
accommodate to them. It is a far cry from the ruthless way in which
the right act against the left in the party whenever they have the
opportunity. The right are operating as a party within a party, with their own high profile spokespeople such as McTiernan who lose no opportunity to appear on TV to attack the party during the election campaign. They have their own well funded organs and organisations. If that were the left, as during the 1980's, under Kinnock, that would have got you expelled, and any branches you controlled shut down

When it was first suggested that Corbyn might stand for the
leadership I argued that the danger would be to see things in terms
of some new saviour, rather than what is actually required, which is
to rebuild the labour movement on a solid foundation from the ground
up. In fact, I was pleasantly surprised when Corbyn's nomination
sparked what appeared to be such a renovation, as hundreds of
thousands of new members flooded into the party.

Yet, the evidence, on the ground, is that a large part of this new
membership is largely passive. In some areas, it has resulted in
changes in party control, and indeed, in some of those areas, like
Brighton, and Wallasey, the right-wing have been quick to use the
party machinery to close down CLP's, to reinstate old right-wing
branch officials etc. But, the failure to nominate left delegates to
last year's conference, the fact that the right still have control
over the NEC and so on suggest that this vast new membership is not
being used effectively.

It should have been possible in the year and a half since Corbyn was
elected to have had slates of candidates for all party positions
throughout the country. There should have been pools of candidates
ready to take up positions on Councils, and as PPC's, where the old
right have their power base, and through which they have a channel
directly to the Tory media. It hasn't happened.

The leadership said at the end of last year that they were putting
the party on a General Election footing. In that case, a Manifesto
should have been ready to be printed as soon as May called the
election, and proceedings should have been started in every CLP to
select new candidates more in tune with the current party. Instead,
we were told that there was no time to hold selection meetings and
that sitting MP's would get a free pass. Why, if the party has been
on an election footing for the last six months? And where sitting MP's have stood down, even then we don't get proper shortlisting and selection, but shortlists imposed from the NEC.

And, now we see Labour MP's like John Woodcock come out as soon as
the election is called, and gratuitously shout to the media that he
could not vote for Corbyn to become Prime Minister; we have the Tory
media day after day telling stories of unnamed Labour MP's who are
tramping the streets telling voters that they do no support Corbyn,
but vote for them, because Corbyn will never become Prime Minister;
we have right-wing MP's like Stephen Kinnock using every media
opportunity they have, even when election results are reasonable, claim that the good results are nothing to do with Corbyn, and would
have been better without him. We have former advisors meeting with Theresa May - the channels already having been opened by all those former Labour MP's under Blair who have gone to work for Cameron over the last few years - and talk of setting up a new parliamentary party after the election. And then these people ask why Labour is polling badly!

Is it any surprise that with such a barrage of propaganda, and
fermentation of splits within Labour ranks, by these right-wing
figures, who clearly have no qualms about destroying the party to
further their own narrow interests, that Labour has poor poll
results, or that when interviewed in vox pops voters give negative
assessments of Corbyn. Its rather like a friend of mine many years ago,
who told me about a discussion he had with his mum, who had commented
that the Queen Mother was a lovely woman. “Oh I didn't realise you
knew her that well, or had even met her,” he said. “Well, no, I
haven't she replied.”

The strategy is quite clear. It is to endlessly press home the idea
that Corbyn is useless, and so however, much people actually like
him, or like the policies he proposes, this overriding message will
prevail. So long as our politics is based upon the current
superficial foundations, such strategies have a good chance of
working. But, it can only work in the very short term, as will be
seen with Macron in France.

If Corbyn were replaced tomorrow by say David Miliband, large swathes
of the population would simply yawn. But, even were a Miliband
Labour government to come into office, as with Macron in France, it
would have no solutions. The soundbites would start to grate, very quickly, and as
soon as the next election arrived, it would simply open the door to
reaction of an even worse kind than that currently threatened by Theresa May and her Tory/UKIP government.

About Me

Left school at 16. Became an ASTMS shop steward at 19, and a lifelong trade union activist. Delegate to North Staffs Trades Council 1974-87. Secretary North Staffs Miners Support Committee 1984-5. President North Staffs Trades Council 1985-6 and 1986-7. Delegate to Staffordshire Association of Trades Councils 1985-7. Delegate West Midlands Regional Council of the TUC 1985-7. Secretary Newcastle UNISON 2000-2.
Member of the International Communist League/Workers Socialist League 1974-87.
Went to University as mature student at age of 24. Obtained Joint Honours Degree in Economics and Politics with Philosophy and Statistics, followed by a Post Graduate Certificate in Education.
Labour Party member since 1974. Stoke City Councillor 1983-4, expelled from Labour group 1983, and resigned from Council in 1984 because of refusing to vote for rent and rate rises, and budget cuts. Staffordshire County Councillor 1997-2005.
Assistant Secretary Stoke District Labour Party 1981, and held pretty much every position from Executive member, to Branch Secretary, and Branch Chair.