news

A Manly Councillor has been savaged on social media with his comment that people who can’t walk dogs themselves don’t deserve to own one.

And it’s got legs, running on interstate and other online sites, and prompting mocking retorts such as; “You shouldn’t have children if you rely on childcare?”

Liberal Cr Alan Le Surf made the comment during a council debate on new licensing policies for commercial dog walking in Manly.

The discussion was prompted by Good For Manly Cr Candy Bingham’s call for a review of the policy, which banned commercial walkers from LM Graham Reserve, reduced their numbers and limited the number of dogs they could walk each day.

It infuriated dog owners, who said the new policy was unfair and had been introduced without community consultation.

Local vet Dr Beth McDonald said about 50% of households already have a dog, and that number is likely to increase as changes to strata laws make apartment buildings more pet friendly. She said studies have shown that pets are good for their owners’ wellbeing, especially in an ageing population where many people live on their own.

And while most people walk their own animals as much as they can, many need professional walkers to fill in the gaps. And some, such as unwell, or poorly-sighted older people, could never cope on their own. Not enough dog walkers would mean more restless, barking dogs driving the neighbours crazy.

In the end the councillors played ball, with a new park - Manly West in Balgowlah - to be considered as a new fully-fenced site. As well the council will make sure that local dog walkers are favoured over out-of-area businesses when license permits are given out.

“It’s a good outcome,” Cr Bingham said. “I know the dog walkers loved LM Graham Reserve, because it was fully-fenced and very safe for dogs, but it was becoming over-used and there were problems with sports people and lots of dogs sharing the same space.“The reserve is still available for people to walk their own dogs and now we will have an additional fully-fenced area nearby.”

The new policies will be reviewed in September next year.

Image: Dr McDonald with her labrador Ned. She says exercise and socialisation are essential for dogs.

The dog walking policy is completely inadequate forvthe number of dog owners utilizing this service. We need more permits, more walks and less victimization of small business.

Reply

Amanda

24/11/2015 06:36:36 am

Having a dog keeps you fit and happy but sometimes you need a dog walker if you have to go away to visit family or you are sick. Dog walkers offer a vital service and we all need safe enclosed local parks where we can walk them.

Reply

Paula Williscroft

24/11/2015 07:40:41 am

I disagree with the councils view that Graham reserve is over used by dogs, where are the facts? Are numbers being monitored scientifically? The reality is the construction of an unwanted pool on the site had reduced the reserve footprint by at least one third placing the whole reserve under stress from the existing levels of activity. That's the real issue here councillor Bingham. Was this environmental impact assessed as part of the unwanted pool complex tender process? Indeed was there a tender process?.....

Reply

A Roper

24/11/2015 02:29:32 pm

I'll bet this councillor also believes that parents who put their children into child care do not deserve to be parents. Imagine what he thinks of people who hire cleaners and landscapers? Guess they shouldn't have homes and gardens. Stupid comment really and typical council buffoonery.

What we stand for

To make a positive change to the way Council is run:1. A strong independent council2. Open, transparent and accountable administration3. Genuine public consultation on all major issues4. A better vision for Manly5. Addressing popular residents' needs

Subscribe to newsletterIf you want to know what's going on in your community - ideas, issues, discoveries, news and events, then you'll appreciate receiving this monthly newsletter.