You mentioned you want an HTPC to cut the cable cord, but mention live OTA TV via antenna. Do you have cable now & planning on cutting cable off completely or been running antenna for a while now? I will say the one thing that an HTPC lets you do, is eliminate the cable box, DVR fees from the cable co & the fees from Tivo.

If you're going to use an antenna, I would probably recommend getting a HD Homerun. This box has 2 tuners. If you have cable or planning on getting cable, I would recommend either a Ceton Infinitv4 (has 4 tuners) or HD Homerun prime (has 3 tuners). I believe that HR prime & Infinitv4 do allow for an antenna to be hooked up to it. I believe the cost of the HD Homerun is around $70, while the infinitv4 & Prime is around $200. Regardless of what you decide on, I would probably wait till Black Friday to see if anybody is having a sale. Last year, I got my 1st Infinitv4 for $200, when the regular price at the time, was $300

Also besides what you had mentioned, is there anything else that you do on the computer, that would be cpu intensive? (i.e. play Mindcraft, Battlefield 3, etc)?

If all you do is surf the web & check email, your computer will probably be fast enough, however what kind of video card do you have? You might need to get a better video card. Besides the video, the only other thing that I would probably do is increase the amount of ram to 8 gig.

You mentioned you want to watch shows on 2 TV's. Is the computer near one of the TV's? If it's not, then you would need to get an "extender" for each of the TV's you want to connect. You can either use an XB 360, or at the end of the month, Ceton is releasing the Echo. If you are not planning on upgrading to Windows 8, you could also look at the Linksys extender (which is no longer manufactured), however I have used the Linksys & I didn't much care for it.

choliscott, we are currently using cable. I want rid of it due to cost, we only watch a few channels so it isn't really worth the cost.

The desk top is in the living room, as is the one TV. They are only about ten feet apart. The second TV is a bedroom TV that will not see a great deal of use, it is primarily for if one of us get sick and have to stay in bed. The Grandchildren might use it on occasion as well.

Most of what I watch is on local channels, I would like the ability to record some of the shows as I do not get off the job till 08:00 PM when most shows start.

Upgrading the ram, video card we currently have an on board video card and a large HD is doable. We are not gamers so no extra load on the CPU. Would I need a TV tuner card for the OTA antenna, and how do I get TV and videos to both TV's?

For the TV tuner, I would probably recommend the following: http://www.newegg.com/Product/Produc...82E16815345007 Depending on how soon you are planning on going forward, I would probably look at Slickdeals.net or fatwallet.com to see if there is a sale, as Newegg had this on sale a couple of days ago for either $60 or $65.

This has 2 tuners, so this will allow you to watch 2 live shows at once, or watch 1 live show, while recording another, etc.

I assume you have a desktop computer. Do you know if it has an HDMI video output? If it does, does your TV, have an HDMI input? I'm assuming you have an Plasma or LCD TV. If you have both, then you might be able to get away with using the onboard video of the I3. It would be like having 2 monitors connected to the computer, with the TV being the 2nd monitor (assuming you only have 1 computer monitor). If your computer does not have an HDMI output, then you probably would need to get a video card for the computer. If I remember correctly a 6450 is sufficient is is between $30-$60 at Newegg.

If you wanted to watch tv in the bedroom, you would need to either get an Xbox 360, or a Ceton Echo, when it's released at the end of the month. The 360 does have built in wireless, but if the plan was to record shows in HD, then I would probably run an Ethernet cable to the bedroom. The Echo & 360 act like an "extender", which extends Windows Media Center to other TV's in the home.

You mentioned Large HD. What size HD do you currently have? Depending on if you are planning on recording HD or not, & have many shows you like to watch, I would probably get a 2 TB or 3 TB drive, depending on what the better deal is & what's within the budget.

There will be others that hopefully will respond to give a 2nd opinion

Quote:

Originally Posted by wvmedic

choliscott, we are currently using cable. I want rid of it due to cost, we only watch a few channels so it isn't really worth the cost.

The desk top is in the living room, as is the one TV. They are only about ten feet apart. The second TV is a bedroom TV that will not see a great deal of use, it is primarily for if one of us get sick and have to stay in bed. The Grandchildren might use it on occasion as well.

Most of what I watch is on local channels, I would like the ability to record some of the shows as I do not get off the job till 08:00 PM when most shows start.

Upgrading the ram, video card we currently have an on board video card and a large HD is doable. We are not gamers so no extra load on the CPU. Would I need a TV tuner card for the OTA antenna, and how do I get TV and videos to both TV's?

Can I use my current PC with upgrades, or do I need to build a dedicated HTPC?

Jeff

Both TV's have HDMI, the living room TV is a 42" Sony Bravia it has two HDMI ports and is an old LCD TV. The bedroom TV is a Vizio 32" LED that is new I bought it 11/13/12 it has two HDMI ports, Ethernet and Wi-FI. I might have access to a Xbox 360, but do not know how old it is. Running Ethernet to the bedroom is no problem.

The PC only has a 250 Gig drive at this time, when I built it I had no need for a bigger HD, so I will and another HD.

If you don't mind my asking where did you get the prices from? I have a local computer store that has good pricing, just a little more than say Newegg. I can put my hands on it there also, I don't mind buying online as long as I know the company is reputable.

Win 8 Pro was the same money, wasn't sure about 8 though. Didn't see Media center on win 8, just XBOX something.

I am going to try it this way and see how it goes, any thing else I need to stream recorded TV and movies to the living room TV?

Jeff

MCE is on there and it's free. However, when I tried to set it up, it was no where as easy as XBMC. The layout (default layout without mods or anything) is MUCH easier to use. If you have a large movie/TV database I highly suggest using it instead of MCE.
If you want to use MCE though, I suggest learning how to set up mediabrowser. It's a large upgrade from the normal MCE layout.
To get MCE on Windows 8 there is a free upgrade on the microsoft's website right now. I'd take a look.
As for purchasing a PC, like everyone said newegg and tiger direct. Putting your hands on a CPU box or Mobo box isn't going to change much. It's about the specs and the reviews. That's best found out online.

The only questions I think you need to answer to be helped better is how large is your Movie/TV DB and how large do you intend to grow it by. Then pick a case that fits your needs (shouldn't be too big) and realize that you don't have a CD drive there (although you probably have a bunch lying around and I rarely use mine).

Those prices quoted though seem accurate to me. The 3 TB HD though I've never seen at 90 dollars (never seen available always sold out).

I went with win7 pro, win 8 looked real weird to me and I didn't see WMC on it. I guess like anything else I could have gotten used to it, might change over to it later.

For now I'm going to use the desktop I built today with the Hauppauge card as a DVR for shows I want to watch but will miss otherwise, I have a TB of space for that. I might record a couple movies, but we have Netflix too so we will see. I have never attempted anything like this so it is all new to me. So with the tuner card I have do I just run the coax to the TV to watch my downloaded shows, or do I run an HDMI cable from my video card?

I agree it goes with ease of set up and how much time u wanna spend on it. I think listing features u want Wil help narrow the choice. I used both and wmc just wasn't settling up right for me. I think the plugins are a must so you'll have to purchase them(10 dollars). Also the new Xbmc has live tv so I wouldn't use that as I deciding factor. Tbh, the ease of setup was so fast, I'd say try Xbmc, if you don't like it within an hour of setting it up, learn to set up wmc correctly and do it. It's quite a number more steps but I think the end result on both is pretty similar.

The only thing I'm curious about is the media extender for wmc, I didn't get that to work either and I think that's the shining difference between the two. Perhaps mfusik can elaborate as he knows more about thisthan iIdo . I just started this break on doing as much as possible to organize my media.

Also I just added windows 8. I think it's not bad at all. You barely interact with the weird interface and it's a 5 dollar program to add back the normal start button. I think the faster boot times and responsiveness are worth it. I'll be trying it on my htpc once it's built.