Africa Great Lakes Democracy Watch

Welcome toAfrica Great Lakes Democracy Watch Blog.Our objective is to promote the institutions of democracy,social justice,Human Rights,Peace, Freedom ofExpression, and Respect to humanity in Rwanda,Uganda,DR Congo, Burundi,Sudan, Tanzania, Kenya,Ethiopia, and Somalia. We strongly believe that Africa will develop if only our presidents stop being rulers of men and become leaders of citizens. We support Breaking the Silence Campaign for DR Congo since we believe the democracy in Rwanda means peace inDRC. Follow this link to learn more about the origin of the war in both Rwanda and DR Congo:http://www.rwandadocumentsproject.net/gsdl/cgi-bin/library

Thursday, June 16, 2011

Rwanda: Why sterilize the poor?

Rwanda’s economy is said to be doing well, so how does population size become a problem that requires dire, questionable voluntary vasectomies of the poor?

by Charles Kambanda, PhD

Poor Rwandans are targeted by the government’s call for voluntary vasectomies of 700,000 men who can’t support their children.
In controversy is the minister of health’s announcement of what the government of Rwanda calls voluntary vasectomies (sterilizing) of 700,000 males between 2011 and 2013. The target group is men who cannot pay bills for their children’s upkeep. The poor who make over 75 percent of Rwanda’s population are only uncertain of when their males will be sterilized. At issue is not whether the country needs sound family planning policy. Whether the political elite will stick to voluntary vasectomies is the main concern. Conceptualizing “voluntary” vasectomies in Rwanda’s contemporary public policy, history gloss and politics is utterly crucial.
The timing of sterilizing 700,000 males raises red flags. In Rwanda’s socio-political environment that swivels on passivity, apathy, suspicion and docile citizenry with militarized “civil society,” securing free will of the men to be sterilized borders on insanity.

Who are the poor?

The deprived are the Twa, a secluded ethnic group. The needy are the Hutu peasants who survived the Congo refugee camps’ massacres. The hard-up in Rwandan society are those few Tutsi survivors of genocide who have not benefited from the genocide survivors’ fund. The underprivileged are the Hutu populace that was uprooted from their land, without compensation, under the habitant and land reform government policy.
The poor are those Tutsi returnees who have no close relations in the Tutsi dominated government. The bitter fact is that poverty in Rwanda runs along the country’s ethnic divides. The poor are mostly victims of the country’s unresolved ethnic and power sharing crisis.
History is seldom a bad teacher. However, people are hardly good students of history. Rwanda’s post-independence history, not different from the country’s pre-independence era, insinuates a constant fight between the Hutu, the majority ethnic group making up about 86 percent of the population, and the Tutsi, the minority ethnic group making up about 14 percent. The Twa hardly make up 1 percent.
Growing or dropping in numbers of either ethnic group is an issue for each ethnic group’s political and physical survival. The Hutu-Tutsi co-existence failed on a win-win modus operandi. The victor seeks to depopulate the loser, or at least to delay the other ethnic group’s violent return to power.
War crimes, crimes against humanity and genocide have long been a “social engineering” and depopulation strategy geared at incapacitating the loser in the country’s power grabbing paradigm. In 1959 it was some Hutu’s turn to “depopulate” the Tutsi.
In the 1980s a Hutu-led government flocked the Tutsi to cannibals and crocodiles in the country’s national park, Akagera. Although scholars disagree on whether the 1994 genocide was committed by only the Hutu against the Tutsi, the scholars appear to concur that genocide was a strategy to “tame” the enemy’s unmanageable and unwanted population.
The brutal massacres of the Hutu refugees in Congo, which the United Nations’ Mapping Report accuses the Tutsi-dominated Rwandan troops of, could also be viewed from this perspective. With growing international enforcement of laws on war crimes, crimes against humanity and genocide, Rwandan society appears vulnerable to apparent legal methods of birth control like “voluntary” vasectomies to achieve the traditional ethnic depopulation conspiracy.
Sociologists, philosophers and psychologists have long discussed whether a poor person can make choices. Do the poor have free will? The Rwandan government does not appear uptight about this paradox. The poor, who cannot nourish their children, are said to be going for “voluntary” vasectomies. This is the proverbial hiding of the head in the sand.

If poverty is a criterion for vasectomies, free will cannot exist

This new policy forcefully encourages human beings to dispel with their primary animal instinct: reproduction. Image sourced at http://www.yorkmedicaltechnologies.co.uk
If the policy be voluntary, the 700,000-man target contradicts what the government of Rwanda calls voluntary vasectomies. Last year, 2010, the vice president of Rwanda’s parliament marketed, in vain, a policy proposal for compulsory sterilization of the “socially retarded” Rwandans. It took excessive efforts by international human rights organizations to thwart the policy proposal. The 2011 “voluntary” vasectomies policy may be a continuum of the 2010 policy proposal. Public policy analysts consent that current latent public policy ideas and motives of any country must be read in light of the similar previous policy. First, the government of Rwanda implemented the habitant and land reform policy. People were supposed to abandon their traditional homestead and go to live in settlement centers – imidugudu. The previous homesteads were meant to be for farming. Initially the government called it a voluntary policy.
Implementation of this policy turned out to be forceful and inhumane. Some government officials snatched victory from the jaws of defeat; they grabbed the land people had abandoned for settlement centers. Second, the government’s policy of what was called voluntary sharing of land between the Hutu owners and the Tutsi returnees ended in the forceful grabbing of land from the Hutu in many regions of the country. Will vasectomies of the unprivileged males be voluntary as the government suggests?
Self-propagation is a basic need and right. However, producing excessive children, as many Rwandans do, is a symptom of insecurity and poverty. There is a general demographic pattern for the well-off to produce between one to three children. The deprived generally produce more than six children. It is no surprise that in a country like Rwanda, where about 75 percent of the population survives on less that $1 a day, the population is increasing by 3 percent per annum. If quantity of the population be the problem, vasectomies are not a durable solution.

The first beneficiary of development is the human person

The quality of a country’s human resources and not the quantity is what matters. Investing in human development is the only sustainable solution. The Rwandan government has sustained one of the most expensive wars in Africa. It is well documented that Rwanda has one of the biggest and most heavily armed militaries in the Great Lakes region of Africa. Rwanda runs the most expensive presidential personal security unit in Africa.
Rwanda’s economy is said to be doing well. Ironically, money is available. How does quantity of the population become a problem that requires dire, questionable voluntary vasectomies?
Human history demonstrates habitual failure by some leaders to reconcile the existence of the poor in an environment that the political leadership project as prosperous. Adolf Hitler exterminated the gypsies alongside the Jews because the gypsies – the poor – would negate the economic prosperity of Germany. This is how seriously the world takes protection of the poor.

Crime against humanity

Rwandan American Law Professor Dr. Charles Kambanda

Denying people the right to self-propagation on the basis of their failure to meet costs for their children ought to be an issue of utmost concern for the international community. Targeting the poor with vasectomies is presumed forceful because the poor always lack free will. Vasectomy in this unique Rwandan context might amount to a crime against humanity. The essence and function of government is redistributing resources and power among the citizens. Vasectomy in a Rwandan context manifests government failure to perform its core functions and responsibilities. The policy mirrors incivility, lack of public conscience and negates the basic ethical tenets.Dr. Charles Kambanda, Dip.Phil., BA, LLB, MA ETPM, MBA, MA HRTs, LLM, PhD, teaches at St. John’s University Law School, LLM Center, New York, and previously lectured at the National University of Rwanda, where, according to the Rwanda News Service, he was known for his “outspoken nature.” This story first appeared on The Proxy Lake: Views and News on the African Great Lakes Region.

27 comments:

Anonymous
said...

It's a shame you don't have a donate button! I'd without a doubt donate to this superb blog! I guess for now i'll settle for book-marking and adding your RSS feed to my Google account. I look forward to new updates and will talk about this website with my Facebook group. Talk soon!

Hello! I just wanted to ask if you ever have any issues with hackers? My last blog (wordpress) was hacked and I ended up losing a few months of hard work due to no back up. Do you have any solutions to protect against hackers?

Thanks for your personal marvelous posting! I actually enjoyed reading it, you can be a great author.I will be sure to bookmark your blog and definitely will come back someday. I want to encourage continue your great work,have a nice day!

Excellent blog! Do you have any tips and hints for aspiring writers?I'm hoping to start my own website soon but I'm a little lost on everything. Would you recommend starting with a free platform like Wordpress or go for a paid option? There are so many choices out there that I'm completely confused .. Any suggestions? Appreciate it!

But they are still organic and realistic precautions are still necessary.After inserting rattan reeds wait 24 hours before turning them to the other side.Let your skin dry and wait at least 5 to 10 minutes before applying the prescribed cream or ointment from your doctor.

Оne can only imagіne what thoughtѕ were goіng thгough Cher''. Onсe it gοes off dоn't think that anyone will to help you, most people just don't do that but the sound оf thе аlaгm goіng off wіll ѕerve a double ρurроse.The loωer aveгage selling priсe ωill be a maϳor contгіbuting factor, although perhaps offset by market share gаins.

First opt; you can consider hormone-replacement therapy (HRT), which is also found effective.Essentially this type of supplement is only based on one or two presenting symptoms,but it also an effective supplement. They can give more appropriate treatment options and medications that can make your heartbeat normal.

Once she had the class put on a play, and she chose me to be the one to place the needle from the record player at a specific place in the MIDDLE of a song. I think she had it out for me from the moment she first saw me, the year my just-built grammar school first opened.Not wearing clothes you bought is a bummer because you have wasted money and wasted space in your closet.

Still, this is the best Sony HD camcorder on the list and should be considered by any amateur videographer.If continuous AF is turned on, the camera focuses after each shot, reducing burst speed to around 1 fps, which is not much of an improvement over the S3 IS or S5 IS. Here is a list of 50 of those things that we can save from becoming trash and indeed recycle and reuse.

Shoes in a mall counters, the press picked up a pair priced at 350 yuan, the design looks like the Leopard MBT Shoes sandals counters when asked about sales,store sales introduction that this section is not the MBT Shoes sandals, leather texture, but the leather products, but the price is right, selling well. Shoe Buy has metallics in flats, sandals, and heels in colors including gold and silver metallic, goldwash, and pewter.It is created with gladiator style, but thin metallic straps.

Upon returning to the home office, he wants the company to start using and supporting Google Docs.Penis symptoms accompanied by sore throat, fever, headache or coughing - sores on the penis or painful urination may seem like no big deal, but when they are accompanied by these symptoms, it can be an indication of an STD such as gonorrhea, herpes, or chlamydia. Safety Louis Delmas, the heavily-favored leader and heart of the defense is also a free agent.

In addition, you might want to consider paying older children a small wage to be your helper for the day. They added something to the overall size and attractiveness of our yard sale, they got a chance to sell their items and we pocketed a reasonable table price or donation for the privilege of joining our sale. Adding special sale days may help sell more books and make more money doing so.

Floral scents consist of a huge diversity of plants such as roses, jasmine, lily of the valley and many, many others.

The shop owner can give you the best advise on how to place the shop owner for maximum effect and what types of shop owner will be the best suited to achieve your desired look. There is a Koshary just beyond the bazaar that has great food for a fraction of the bazaar prices.

If you want to remove their ads and put your own, you must upgrade to a paid e-store. Most sellers ask for a higher price than they actually want and are therefore open to negotiation. These sites offer the chance to come across daily deals in Australia for both one's own family and friends.

And you may wish to emphasize safety to a greater extent instead of styling.1% of the overall population of the United States (National, 2007). Bigger ties should be avoided, as they will make your body look inproportionate by comparison.

He was here to enhance his talent as an opera singer while subsequently having the unique ability to know every aria of the 18thand 19th century by memory. Hence with so many choices available it is important to make the right choice, so that we can feel a lot more comfortable and look very attractive. Women began to wear them in church on Sunday, or to social functions that used to require dresses.

Perhaps, some of your friends are very crazy about shopping online. Hot season is coming ,lots of cheap handbags are on sale.There are varieties associated with online stores that market inexpensive Cheap Handbags.

Τhe independent and aggressive Aries еnergy can feel distinсtly ԁifferеnt frοm the sеntіmentаl and rοmantic vibгatiοn of Venuѕ in Pіsces, to which you have bеcome accustomed in the past few weeks.Τhe Plaіn Dealeг reported Thurѕday that Lebron James, Chris Вosh (formeгly of thе Toronto Raptors), and Dwaуnе Wadе (formerlу of the Mіami Heat) haνe bеen talking about ρlaying for the same squad since 2006.Twο of the majoг plaуers іn thе estаbliѕhment of Tennesseе were Jοhn Sevier and Jοhn Tipton.

choker necklace, although it is not uncommon to find cameos depicting scenes from Greek and Roman mythology. Brocade frontier vest: a men's vest popular in the Wild West that contains a. And tie a wide piece of silk as the belt to hold the gown tight.

I'm truly enjoying the design and layout of your website. It's a very easy on the eyes which makes it much more pleasant for me to come here and visit more often. Did you hire out a developer to create your theme?Exceptional work!