"Go full-on Italian at Salvatore’s, which serves everything from pasta to calzones and—of course—excellent, classic pies. Head to YNot Italian if you’re looking for a gluten-free variety. And at Shorebreak, hand-tossed pies are covered in a sauce derived from a 40-year-old family recipe," the judges wrote.

Among other cities that were recognized were Richmond, New York and Chicago. The No. 1 city for the best pizza? Phoenix.