Comments

Tags

This is the third of four short pieces aimed at identifying players to fill four playing roles (identified following a quick survey I did on Twitter):

Centre-back;

Left-back;

Defensive midfield; and

Right wing/forward.

The approach and techniques used are the same as those described in a TTT piece I wrote in March called ‘A Model to Identify Players’. If you haven’t read this piece, you’ll probably need to – just so that you understand the method, its weaknesses and the underlying assumptions. The model used for this piece has been modified slightly and uses newer data – but the basic ‘core’ remains unchanged.

Potential candidates

Typically, I like to provide links to these dashboards so that you can use them interactively. However, because of a connectivity problem, you will need to settle for images (if I solve the problem, I will provide the links in the comments section). The diagram below provides an overview of the talent pool that I have identified, which contains 79 potential candidates. These players are:

Defensive Midfielders

Aged between 19 and 27

Have a ‘Player Score’ exceeding 0.700

Have made an international appearance OR

Play for the equivalent of a Championship club or better

One of the challenges with this piece in particular was to distinguish genuine ‘specialist’ defensive midfielders from more generic ‘midfielders’. The technique I adopted was to compare multiple sources of information so that – hopefully – I was able to identify the ‘dominant’ description of the player’s role. This is perhaps 50% science and 50% art, but it’s the best I can do.

Each of the potential candidates has been reviewed in the context of a theoretical LFC budget for the role. Using an updated turnover number of £200m, and a slightly revised budgeting model, the colour-coding is as follows:

Overspend: more than £9,543,662

High Spend: £6,816,902 to £9,543,662

Sensible Spend: £4,771,831 to £6,816,902

Low Spend: £3,408,451 to £4,771,831

Very Low Spend: less than £3,408,451

The rest of this article is for Subscribers only.

Member-only content - you need to subscribe to read it ! A subscription costs only £3.50 per month.

Praise for Paul Tomkins, The Tomkins Times, its writers, and side projects

Perhaps the most intelligent guide to LFC available on the internet

The Independent on Sunday

“An ingenious and intelligent look beneath the surface to reveal what the headlines too often don’t tell us. Fascinating.”

Jonathan Wilson

“Golddust analysis”

John Sinnott, BBC

“[Football analysis] is best left to the professionals, like the admirable Mr Tomkins.”

Daily Telegraph

"Another triumph of impeccable research, Pay As You Play brings much-needed factual insight to a discussion previously dominated by half-truths"

Oliver Kay, The Times

"Very compelling arguments"

Gabriele Marcotti, BBC Radio Five Live

"Liverpool do happen to be blessed with supporters whose statistical analysis
provides a lucid interpretation of where the club’s strengths and weaknesses lie, accessible through the Tomkins Times website. One such analyst [is] Dan Kennett”