Sudeikis appeared on The Late Show With David Letterman on Wednesday and while he said that his time on the show has been "really, really amazing," he added, "I’m definitely done. I’m going to leave. Yeah, I’m not coming back next fall.” Jason noted that he worked as a writer for two years before appearing on camera for eight, and USA Today reports that he was planning to leave in 2012 but producer Lorne Michaels convinced him to stay to play presidential candidate Mitt Romney during the presidential election season.

After the success he's found with movies and TV (we totally forgot he voices a character on The Cleveland Show), it's not surprising that the comedian is making a departure. We're still gonna miss him though!