He is remembered for his close relationships with both King Marshall and Pornstache, the latter one being romantic. Sherlock's running gag was wanting to solve new mysteries involving the cast of his original season.

In I CAN NOW CONCLUDE THAT MORKA IS THE MURDERER, Sherlock and King Marshall were both convinced Morka was a murderer, and voted for her to be eliminated.

Sherlock declares he wants to find out why several of the other contestants are so mean to Taco in I Thought Everyone Won The Game!.

Sherlock takes a major step in his relationship with Pornstache in A Sure Sign Of Gay, when he admits his love for Pornstache after the elimination of Red.

Coincidentally, Porn is eliminated next in The Only Game I Played Before This Was Sex, causing Sherlock to breakdown. Initially, according to King Marshall, Sherlock had to pursuade his ally to vote out Tiffany over Pornstache, but it didn't work. With his ally King Marshall trying to calm him down, Sherlock weeps on the ground as Pornstache leaves. He blames Taco.

Now down an ally, Sherlock is Punished by Taco in Is There ANY Surprise?. In an initial 4-4 tie with Twitter, this extra vote ends up eliminating Sherlock.