When news first broke that Menzel would be starring in a made-for-Lifetime remake of Midler’s iconic 1988 film Beaches, the Internet — as it often does — responded with a confusing range of emotions. But one voice, arguably the most important, is rising above the noise to wish Menzel the best on her new project:

Can’t wait to see Idina Menzel as CC in Lifetime’s “Beaches!” DON’TTELL ME THE ENDING!

Now that Midler has given her blessing, are you willing to open your heart to Lifetime’s Beaches remake? And who would you like to see cast in Barbra Hershey’s role opposite Menzel? Drop a comment with your thoughts below.