Pretty Little Liars’ fourth season’s tenth episode “The Mirror Has Three Faces” reintroduces a sneaky character into the mix and leaves the loyalties of several key characters in question. Beware of spoilers from this point on.

After last week’s shocking almost drowning, Pretty Little Liars opens with the girls sneaking back into school after visiting Jenna (Tammin Sursok) in the hospital. Hanna (Ashley Benson) is determined to find CeCe (Vanessa Ray) while Emily (Shay Mitchell) receives an offer to move into the DiLaurentis home, as her house undergoes construction. Spencer (Troian Bellisario) thinks it would be hard for Emily to room in Ali’s (Sasha Pieterse) old room.

Ezra (Ian Harding) is struggling with doorknobs as he deals with Malcolm’s (Teo Briones) custody issue. Caleb (Tyler Blackburn) uses his hacker skills to track CeCe to Philadelphia. Aria (Lucy Hale) and Jake (Ryan Guzman) share a moment as she promises to be on his match that evening.

Wren (Julian Morris) questions Mona (Janel Parrish) in Radley using sketches to feel out her emotional state. Mona lets Wren know that she feels like she is on the side of the Pretty Little Liars and got rid of Wilden (Bryce Johnson) for them, while Wren believes in her innocence. Mona and Wren used to be friends however Mona no longer trusts him. Wren reveals that Mona is off of her medication. What do you think this means?

Toby (Keegan Allen) returns from his investigatory trip to find sheet music with his name on it from A. Emily freaks out seeing Ali’s room preserved as it was when she died while Spencer tries to comfort him with little success. Mrs. DiLaurentis has a hard time dealing with Ali’s things while Emily’s mom (Nia Peeples) is away for a police disciplinary hearing.

Ashley (Laura Leighton) has a hard time dealing with her house arrest while Hanna tries to sneak into Radley to see Mona, despite Caleb’s protests. Caleb tries to get Hanna to tell her parents and the cops about A before she gets hurt. Do you agree with Caleb?

Hanna asks Wren to get into Radley and inquiries whether or not he knows CeCe. Wren lets on that CeCe attempted to see Mona last night but was turned away. Wren promises to investigate CeCe’s possible appearance but quickly calls his partner in crime to warn them. Do you like Wren’s reappearance?

The sheet music is revealed to be a favorite of Toby’s mother which he confides to Spencer. Toby wants to see Dr. Palmer again and asks Spencer for her support. Looks like Emily will be alone in Ali’s house tonight.

Mrs. DiLaurentis reveals that she is getting divorced while Ezra finds out that Malcolm is not his son. It looks like there are fewer reasons to prevent Ezra and Aria from being together. What do you think about Maggie’s (Larisa Oleynik) lie?

Hanna catches Caleb trying to go into Veronica’s(Lesley Fera) law office in order to protect her. Wren watches the two as they hash it out and then make out. Do you feel for Caleb who feels helpless?

Wren warns Veronica of Mona and states his belief that she still wants to hurt the Pretty Little Liars and their families. What do you think his motives are?

Maggie admits that she did have a doubt about who was Malcolm’s father while Ezra is heartbroken and says that Malcolm is his child in his heart. Aria meets CeCe’s former roommate while Mrs. DiLaurentis states that she thinks she still sees Ali sometimes. Emily reveals that she is a lesbian to Mrs. DiLaurentis who is heartfelt in her acceptance.

CeCe’s former roommate tells Aria that CeCe was kicked out of school due to Alison. Alison apparently threw someone down a flight of stairs and CeCe blamed the other four girls or “she-devils” as well. Do you think CeCe killed Ali and/or is the mastermind behind A?

As Hanna reminisces in Ali’s bedroom, Red Coat sneaks into the house unnoticed. Toby and Spencer’s visit to Dr. Palmer does not go as well as planned due to his poor memory. Veronica breaks into Radley to confront Mona about her statement while Aria ignores a call from Ezra for Jake’s competition.

Spencer plays the sheet music which jogs Dr. Palmer’s memory as he thinks Spencer is Marion and gets scared off at the mention of a blonde girl. He does happen to mention Mrs. DiLaurentis. Could the blonde girl be Ali?

Spencer and Hanna confront Mrs. DiLaurentis about Dr. Palmer who says that he was not hers or Ali’s doctor. In a flashback, she does mention two girls saying, “Is that what the two of you do when you’re not braiding each other’s hair?” Apparently CeCe dressed up as Ali and pretended to be going crazy. Mrs. DiLaurentis outlawed CeCe’s presence from Ali’s life due to the toxicity of the relationship. Mrs. DiLaurentis said that the two of them liked to “wear each other’s personalities.”

Veronica is accused of obstruction of justice in threatening Mona to confess. As a result she has to recuse herself from Ashley’s case. This does not bode well.

Aria and Jake flirt on the stoop of a brownstone after he won his match. Do you like Aria and Jake? Hanna flips out about her mom’s case as Caleb raises after her to drive her again. Wren talks to a mysterious figure over the phone as he hurts Veronica’s reputation and accuses her of tampering.

In the final few minutes, Mrs. DiLaurentis and Emily descend into the basement only to find that someone has been using it as a home and holes in the ceiling to track their movements. Perhaps that explains Red Coat entering the home?

I was really confused by the scene where Emily turns off the lights, turns back around, sees the holes in the ceiling, and then has a really shocked and terrified look on her face. I get that Red Coat was probably living there, but why did Emily look *SO* shocked?

Megan

Right? I was kinda scared during that part! She was probably ‘shocked’ that whoever lived there could hear conversations.

Stella

after doing a bit of Googling- they’re the holes that A drilled into the ceiling in the A-clip at the end of an episode maybe two/three eps ago? They come out under a chair- maybe Mrs D’s armchair?

Megan Slife

Probably because she thought it was just some homeless man/woman that just slept in the basement, she didn’t initially go to “Red Coat was here”.. that would be my guess.

C

She got creeped out because she saw the holes. Obviously whoever’s living in there was trying to listen to the conversations upstairs.

Emily Bryan

Effing Wren! >:( he’s a suspicious creep.
I’m still waiting for Aria to be more involved with the A storyline. She’s the least involved and it’s aggravating. I know some fans believe that she’s A, and for good reason :P hahah! Just miss her being so involved.
I felt so bad for Ezra :( Maggie is a grade A b*tch for doing that. How horrible :(

Hypable encourages the community to use our Comments feature to hold thoughtful, polite, and critical discussions. We do NOT tolerate inappropriate, rude, or downright mean discussion towards the news story's subject matter or towards other Hypable users. We reserve the right to delete or ban comments and users who violate these guidelines.