If this is your first visit, be sure to
check out the FAQ by clicking the
link above. You may have to register
before you can post: click the register link above to proceed. To start viewing messages,
select the forum that you want to visit from the selection below.

User Info Menu

Join Date

May 2008

Posts

7,984

Originally Posted by papillon

I'm with you, but I guess what I'm saying is that the symptoms were still there, but the Steelers record was 6-2 prior to Ben's injury, so there wasn't much scrutiny. Once Ben was injured and he returned the losses mounted and the offense came under more scrutiny and the results weren't pretty.

3 of the 6 wins (1st half of season) were to teams whose best record was 6-10 and they lost to two teams whose best record was 6-10. I think the inconsistencies were there all along, but a couple good games against the Giants and Skins may have hid the problems. I don't know for sure, but the past 10 regular season games with Ben at quarterback have been pretty ugly.

Pappy

Good points all. Unfortunately, the reality is there is a plethora of reasons we are in the position we're in. If this were a major business, it would be hard for the newly hired CEO to even know where to start to fix things ...

User Info Menu

Join Date

Mar 2008

Location

Under your bed

Posts

9,072

Originally Posted by SanAntonioSteelerFan

Good points all. Unfortunately, the reality is there is a plethora of reasons we are in the position we're in. If this were a major business, it would be hard for the newly hired CEO to even know where to start to fix things ...

A newly hired CEO would clean house and bring in his guys and gals, hence, remove Haley and promote the quarterbacks coach, he should have a good rapport with Ben.

Pappy

The referee said that you hit Brian Sipe too hard. Did you hit him too hard?
I hit him as hard as I could - Jack Lambert

User Info Menu

Join Date

Mar 2008

Posts

12,202

Originally Posted by papillon

Since Haley arrived to be exact.

I typically would rather give coaches a chance to get things right, but in this case I don't believe Haley has the coaching skill to get this offense right. He's too stubborn and the first three plays of the game and the ridiculous attempt to get different personnel on the field while Ben was trying to run a play to avoid a challenge flag are perfect examples of Haley's ego getting in the way of a franchise quarterback and in all likelihood HOF quarterback.

Haley needs to be removed sooner than later or the Steelers will be fortunate to win a handful of games.

Ben has bailed this team so often in the past that fans expect he can do it under any circumstance and the current circumstance may be more than he can make right.

Pappy

That is actually not true. Ben was on record pace when Haley first arrived, until injury. He hasn't been the same since last years injury is much more accurate.

User Info Menu

Join Date

Mar 2008

Posts

12,202

Originally Posted by SidSmythe

Thank you!! who thinks Tom Brady could be Tom Brady behind this line in this offense??

I do. I have seen Tom Brady play with crap around him, and look like Tom Brady. He makes quicker reads, has a quicker release...and his game is built around setting up the deep ball with ball control passing. Ben is a gun slinger, wants the deep ball at all times, isn't accurate or consistent enough to pull off the O, Haley is trying to implement. That might be an unpopular opinion but Ben isn't playing well and Im not willing to put that all on the OL and WRs. He has been missing many wide open WRs.

User Info Menu

That is actually not true. Ben was on record pace when Haley first arrived, until injury. He hasn't been the same since last years injury is much more accurate.

Shallow statistics IMO, the Steelers beat three teams with records less than or equal to 6-10 and lost to two teams whose records were less than or equal to 6-10. I know you can only play the teams on the schedule, but the statistics were accumulated against teams that didn't have NFL caliber players on the rosters.

He hasn't been the same IMO since Haley joined the team and they got off to a bad start communicating and I have to believe the current train wreck of a game plan isn't making Ben happy. Take a look at the most recent disaster just from a play calling and personnel on the field standpoint, to offer an opinion other than ridiculous is to ignore what you witnessed. The slowest WR running an end around in which the worst blocking TE on the team is supposed to block a DE, 3rd and 8 draw play on the first series (that says, "I give up"), not handing the ball to Jones once in the 2nd half, continuing to run Redman behind blocking designed for a back with vision and cutting ability, the list goes on and on. Besides a lack of talent, there's a lack of coaching taking place.

Pappy

The referee said that you hit Brian Sipe too hard. Did you hit him too hard?
I hit him as hard as I could - Jack Lambert

User Info Menu

That is actually not true. Ben was on record pace when Haley first arrived, until injury. He hasn't been the same since last years injury is much more accurate.

i've heard this argument a million times and it's true, he was... as were most QBs in the league. haley doesn't get credit for changing the passing game and opening it up - the NFL does. They want scoring because it's an exciting game.

i'd be curious, however, to know what the ratio of no huddle drives the team had - after all, they were only 5-3 through that stretch. thinking back on it (and this past game) i suspect Haley is getting credit for Ben calling the plays... seemed to be the only time they moved the ball this past weekend is when haley wasn't allowed to call plays