According to the executive producer of Teen Wolf, Jeff Davis, “[Sharman] was at a position where he wanted to stretch his creative wings and I said to him, ‘Well, if we can’t convince you to come back, we’ll definitely leave the door open for you.'”

E! News reports Sharman will play Kaleb, a charming witch who is intent on wreaking havoc. If he is your friend, you have nothing to worry about. Otherwise, watch your back!

The Originals‘ season two finale airs Tuesday, May 13 at 8 p.m. on the CW.