Back in 4.3, Kisko put an excellent thread together that ranked expected trinket DPS. It looks like Kisko has retired, and though Anaxie has continued his thread, no one has picked up this one. In an effort to cut down on the number of threads asking what trinkets are BiS as we move from 5.0 to 5.1 and beyond, I'll be working to keep this thread up to date.

Excel tool

Available here. Try it out and, if you're handy with Excel, critique my methodology. Nothing is locked down, so play around.

Stat Weights

I have a set of T14H weights generated in SimulationCraft, using the most up to date profiles available. Everyone should generate their own weights to get the most accurate trinket ranking for their gearset. (Please note that with the nerf to our 4pc T14, these will change slightly....we're just waiting on an updated release to run the numbers again.)

Can you add Eye of Unmaking HC, Creche of the Final Dragon HC and Bone Link Fetish HC? Would like to see how they stack up against Direbrew trinket, which I've been holding off from using because of the loss of static STR

Jade Charioteer Figurine(N) give 3595 haste on proc. Tooltip in game show it.
And before use i have 4238(9.97%), after use i have 7833(18.43%).
Restated please
P.S. I cant post any kind of links or image. View my profile. Links to images there

You should also do another Darkmist Vortex number set with the T14 4-set in mind because every good ret paladin is going to line Avenging Wrath up with Darkmist Vortex if at all possible. Also, Inq takes me like 4 seconds to have active. and I'm pretty sure there is no heroic Jade Charioteer Figurine because I saw people on beta doing 25-man heroics get the normal version off trash.

The 390 ilvl proc pvp trinket averages out to 956 strength by itself because it has the 429 strength main stat on top of the 1452 strength for 20 seconds with a 50 second ICD and assuming 5 seconds to activate, so it should be better than Creche.

Even though AP is our lowest stat, it's only barely behind crit. Since the proc is over 10k AP and has a pretty good uptime, it's looking pretty darn good.

Trinket appears to be about 67.8 seconds ICD with .38 PPM and a 6.28% uptime for a 20 min DPS test.

It's practically impossible to line the trinket up with CD's due to the time difference and it's crit based not hit based, While we do have better crit than cata but it's still lower than most other classes. So if it was hit the trinket would be great but with it being crit not so great.

Trinket appears to be about 67.8 seconds ICD with .38 PPM and a 6.28% uptime for a 20 min DPS test.

It's practically impossible to line the trinket up with CD's due to the time difference and it's crit based not hit based, While we do have better crit than cata but it's still lower than most other classes. So if it was hit the trinket would be great but with it being crit not so great.

Though when it comes to this one and the Carbonic Carbuncle isn't Coren's better ?

Ran 500k iterations in T14H BiS gear to get more exact weights; currently doing the same for Pre-Raid

Updated Coren's to 50s ICD, set it take 10s to proc on average (10% chance on crit), and increased its AP buff (10164 -> 10848). Big decrease in value, but still looking slightly better than Carbuncle.

Rearranging the list to order by Pre-Raid DPS instead of T14H, as that will be the most beneficial for now.

Ran 500k iterations in T14H BiS gear to get more exact weights; currently doing the same for Pre-Raid

Updated Coren's to 50s ICD, set it take 10s to proc on average (10% chance on crit), and increased its AP buff (10164 -> 10848). Big decrease in value, but still looking slightly better than Carbuncle.

Rearranging the list to order by Pre-Raid DPS instead of T14H, as that will be the most beneficial for now.

SC sims the coaster at 10.10% uptime, which is pretty bad. Average interval is 95.8s, which is also horrendous for a 50s ICD. That's reasonable close to your testing for now. Value drops pretty far down if they don't change it to work on hit instead (which is unlikely).

SC sims the coaster at 10.10% uptime, which is pretty bad. Average interval is 95.8s, which is also horrendous for a 50s ICD. That's reasonable close to your testing for now. Value drops pretty far down if they don't change it to work on hit instead (which is unlikely).

Ya I was just curious how close sc was to my testing, thanks for the reply.

Some calculations are really misleading. Did some 2 boss attempts ina new raid, and coren's is really weak. In raid-live proc rate is once per 2-3minutes. Usually went to second phase to see first proc or later.

Only chance to get dps from coren's to match trinket list number, is to use Hor&Dstorm on 3x lvl 60 dummies.

Some calculations are really misleading. Did some 2 boss attempts ina new raid, and coren's is really weak. In raid-live proc rate is once per 2-3minutes. Usually went to second phase to see first proc or later.

Only chance to get dps from coren's to match trinket list number, is to use Hor&Dstorm on 3x lvl 60 dummies.

Yup, CCCC is garbage because it procs on crit only 10% of the time. Even Carbuncle is better.