Nina Dobrev and Ariel Winter added just a hint of edginess to their otherwise very feminine SAG awards looks with smoky gray eyeshadow. The actress's kept the rest of their makeup light and fresh with rosy cheeks and glossy lips.

The Vampire Diaries star wore a bright pink dress and long drop earrings, and her charcoal shadow was just the thing to offset the sweetness of the look. The shadow wasn't night-on-the-town dark, making it perfectly appropriate for the glam red carpet event.

The Modern Family actress wore a creamy peach dress with floral accents, romantic loose waves, and pink lip gloss, so her hint of fierceness came from her silvery gray eye makeup and long, thick lashes. Like Nina, her bottom lash line is left bare, adding to the subtleness of the smoky effect.

These two stars prove that adding just a touch of darkness to a whimsical style is all you need to add layers of dimension to your overall look. Which red carpet beauty's makeup do you like best? Vote!