Like most Stranger Things fans, we spend the majority of our days around conspiracy corkboards of the series’ many mysteries. We may yet have company for Season 2, as comedian Brett Gelman joins the cast to sleuth around Hawkins for a bit.

Per The Hollywood Reporter, the actor-comedian and all-around “that guy” Gelman will take the Season 2 role of Murray Bauman, described as “a disgraced journalist-turned-conspiracy theorist who is investigating a cold case in Hawkins” Plenty of those lying around!