"Fight club" is better than "American History X", as a movie. But for Edward Norton, playing Derrek, I think is the best role he has ever had! For Norton, "American History X" is the best movie, in which he has ever played. This movie showed his talent from the best side, a true talent of an ACTOR, a talent of transformation. This film should be his No.1.

Fight club surprised all of us in the plot twist... And was an amazing movie... But American History X is just so good and his performance is better in this! I think this is a better movie and a performance... That's taking nothing away from fight club though

Edward Norton is the best actor I've ever seen he is such an amazing actor and this movie shows how good is really is and primal fear is also great

This is honestly my favorite movie of all time, I've watched it over and over and I could still watch it a hundred more times. Edward stole the show as Aaron/Roy. I've never seen such an amazing portrayal of a character. The fact that he didn't win the oscar for his role is frankly ridiculous.

This should be #1. Norton gives the most amazing performance I have ever seen. Incredible personality transformations. He was a thousand times better than Cuba Gooding Jr. from Jerry Maguire and he should have gotten that Oscar.

Some of the best acting I have ever seen from Edward Norton. Definitely should of won an oscar for this film.