Faults Suggest a High Calling for Delphi Priestesses

By Guy Gugliotta
Washington Post Staff Writer

They warned Oedipus to stay away from his mother, told Orestes to
go ahead and kill his, caused Croesus to lose to the Persians, then
helped Athens defeat them. So what's the story with the priestesses
at Delphi? Did they really channel for Apollo, or were they just high
on something?

Scientists don't know about Apollo, but evidence is growing that
the priestesses, known as pythia, were ripped on hydrocarbon gases,
especially ethylene, a sometime anesthetic which, taken in modest
doses, can induce lively conversation of a somewhat incoherent nature.

This is because the Temple of Apollo at Delphi sits on crisscrossing
geological faults, according to a team of scientists led by archaeologist
John Hale of the University of Louisville and geologist Jelle Zeilinga
de Boer of Wesleyan University in Connecticut.

In re-embracing the ancients' view that intoxicants emanated from
water bubbling from a rock fissure beneath the temple, Hale said,
the team is challenging a century of research that held "that the
priests and oracle were deceiving the public and inventing stories"
to boost the shrine's importance.

Instead, it appears the ancients were right. "I thought that if
there is an active fault, there were most likely gases coming up through
fissures," Zeilinga de Boer said. And if that were true, traces would
show up in the travertine that underpins the temple. Travertine is
a type of limestone.

And so it proved. Reporting recently in the journal Geology, the
team said that tests on the Delphi rock and the waters of a nearby
spring showed the presence of methane and ethane, which can be intoxicating,
as well as ethylene, widely used as an anesthetic in the first half
of the 20th century.

"It was a great gas," said toxicologist Henry Spiller, director
of the Kentucky Regional Poison Center in Louisville and another member
of the Delphi team. "It produces a very rapid onset of effects, and
leaves the heart alone." Unfortunately, "it is also explosive [and]
dangerous for the surgeon," Spiller added, which is why modern medicine
eventually abandoned it.

Ethylene, Spiller explained, produces "stages" of anesthesia. Low
doses induce "disembodied euphoria, with periods of excitation and
amnesia," he said. But at higher doses, "you get delirium, hysteria
and a combative, agitated state," he added. Further along comes unconsciousness
and, if one is not careful, death.

All of this squares nicely with historical accounts. As a high priest
at the temple in the 1st century A.D., the biographer Plutarch noted
that the pythia delivered oracles from a tripod in a small below-ground
chamber bathed in gases carried up by underground springs.

Most of the time, the priestess was conscious, clever and chatty,
but on occasion she flipped out, and things got nasty. The bad trips,
including a death reported by Plutarch, had led past Delphi administrators
to swap out the young maidens they used to put in the seat for more
levelheaded matrons.

Today the temple ruins, on the slopes of Mount Parnassus 100 miles
northwest of Athens, are probably the most visited place in Greece
after the Acropolis, but Hale said archaeological evidence suggests
the ancient Greeks probably regarded Delphi as a holy place from its
founding, about 1400 B.C.

The shrine's heyday began about 800 B.C., Hale said, when Greek
colonists sought Apollo's blessing before they set sail for Italy,
Sicily, Spain, the Black Sea and Africa. The oracle didn't go out
of business until A.D. 393, when the Christian emperor Theodosius
shut it down.

The oracle's warnings and advice figure prominently in Greek mythology.
After the Trojan War, when Orestes asked whether he should seek vengeance
on his mother for murdering his father, Agamemnon, the oracle gave
him the green light.

Told by the oracle that he would murder his father and marry his
mother, Oedipus did everything possible to avoid the inevitable, but
failed.

In actual practice, however, the oracle's chief shortcoming was
the ambiguity of her advice. Croesus, king of Lydia, went to war against
Cyrus of Persia after the oracle told him that "a great nation would
fall" if he crossed the Halys River. Unfortunately, the great nation
turned out to be his own.

And in 480 B.C., after the Athenians rejected the oracle's opening
prediction that the invading Persians would trash them, the priestess
suggested they make use of "a wall of wood." The Athenians correctly
interpreted this to mean ships, and subsequently defeated Xerxes at
sea in the Battle of Salamis.

Delphi's original excavation was performed by French archaeologists,
who at first found no gas emissions beneath the temple. An article
published in English in 1904 suggested the fissure idea was "all a
mistake," Hale said.

"This view defined the debate" for the next 90 years, and was reinforced
by mid- century research suggesting that emissions of intoxicating
gas were impossible without volcanic activity, Hale said.

"But this was archaeologists, mainly," said geologist Luigi Piccardi
of Italy's National Research Council in Florence, whose own research
in Greece reflects many of the U.S. team's conclusions. "The mechanics
of active faulting are something only recently understood."

Geologists have known for years that much of Greece is in one of
the world's most active seismological areas. Delphi sits in the middle
of the east-west "Corinth Rift Zone," which slices the country in
half.

In the mid-1990s, Zeilinga de Boer spotted an active east-west fault
traveling beneath the Delphi temple and challenged Hale, a believer
in the no-emissions theory, to rethink his views.

Together, the pair found a second fault running north and south
beneath the temple, and discovered that the French had indeed found
fissures in the bedrock but had only published their results in the
1920s, long after scientists had lost interest.

"The geology is very young, and you have things happening before
your eyes," Zeilinga de Boer said. Deep in the earth, seismic forces
grind the fault edges together, building tremendous heat that causes
vaporized hydrocarbons to funnel upward, joining groundwater to bubble
up in springs through fissures in the ground.

Spring water near the temple still has plenty of gases in it, Zeilinga
de Boer said. The only reason gas doesn't permeate the temple today
is because modern Delphi is channeling most of the groundwater into
reservoirs: "The gas bubbles off before the water goes to the municipal
system," he said.

"In any field, find the strangest thing and then explore it"
John Archibald Wheeler.