Strain-specific and pooled genome sequences for populations of D. melanogaster from three continents

Featured Referee Report

Our Refereeing is Open & Transparent

Steven Groft, from the Office of Rare Diseases Research, National Institutes of Health

on Ekins et al.'s article about Collaboration for rare disease drug discovery research

This is a very well referenced opinion article on rare diseases and orphan products including historical and current activities that have led to an increased global emphasis on rare diseases research and orphan products development.

The traditional anonymous pre-publication peer-review process can cause long delays before new results become visible. F1000Research uses an author-led process, publishing all scientific research within a few days. Open, invited peer review is conducted after publication, focusing on scientific soundness rather than novelty or impact.

To see a paper in 5 days, in a professional layout, is quite astounding. Two useful referee reports appeared in less than two weeks, supporting the notion that peer review can be done openly.

–
Jurgen Schnermann,
NIDDK/NIH Bethesda, USA

Why fast publication is important

63 sec

Why transparency is essential

62 sec

Transparent Refereeing

Open peer review removes the secrecy and anonymity that can bias the way scientists critique each others’ work. In F1000Research, signed referee reports and author responses are published alongside each article. Authors can publish revised versions of their articles at no extra cost. All articles that pass peer review are indexed in PubMed.

No Editorial Bias

Much valid science remains unpublished, wasting the investment of the researchers’ time and funding, and biasing the scientific record. F1000Research encourages the publication of all findings, including null/negative results, small findings, case reports, data notes and observation articles.

Why all findings should be published

53 sec

Why data should be available

75 sec

Data Included

Access to the data underlying new findings is crucial to enable reanalysis, replication attempts and data reuse. All research articles published by F1000Research are accompanied by the data on which the reported results are based (being sensitive to genuine data protection concerns).