Thanks for the list. I don't know many of the names from Survivior 1-4 as I didn't become a fan until Thailand. And as for the speculation about Elisabeth, isn't she the one that just won the spot on the View?

I think they did a pretty good job selecting the castaways for all stars. I think they could have added a few more and maybe had about 21 castaways with 3 tribes of seven each. Also i noticed no one who was voted out before teh final 10 was given a second chance. That is interesting because a lot of people that were fun to watch were voted out before the final 10(mike, gina, kimmi,ghandia, shawna, michelle, trish, nicole+others)

oh, okay i get what youre saying now! I didnt understand before. I thought you were saying that some of teh all stars contestants had been voted out before teh final 10! I get you now! Yeah, a lot of conflict causing/cool people were out in teh beginning(kimmi, joanna, joel, mitchell, maralyn, lindsey, silas, gina, hunter, and teh ones i have mentioned already)

WHAT? you just said they missed some! I think tehy should have done this: 3 tribes with 8 members each, and extend teh number of days to fit the original voting format(every three days until the final four) and they wouldve had to stay out there longer, which they should because they are all stars!

I agree that they should replace rich with neleh, but i dont think it would be all stars without jerri! shes one of the shows biggest and coolest villains! also i agree elisabeth should be on the show, maybe in place of shii ann.

oh, yeah! forgot about rob m. yeah i would want him out before shii ann. I wanted them on thailand to vote against penny during that tc where they voted out shii ann. they were dumb to keep penny! she turned on all of them, by voting for erin(her best friend) and voting for jake, when those two were the only sook jai members left in the game