Hot Topics:

Their View: The Romney myth about helping Detroit

By Froma Harrop / For the Sun-News

Posted:
10/31/2012 01:00:00 AM MDT

Of Mitt Romney's many costume changes, the new Superman outfit portraying him as the would-be savior of the American auto industry wins for most imaginative. Understood: His infamous "Let Detroit Go Bankrupt" op-ed has proven a great inconvenience to winning votes in the industrial Midwest. But continually insisting that one didn't say what one said is severely not honest. Romney is the kind of politician you ask, "Trick or treat?" and he answers "both."

A new Romney campaign ad for Ohio intones, "He has a plan to help the auto industry." A nice sentiment now that the carmakers no longer need saving. His plan in the winter of 2009, when General Motors and Chrysler were clearly going under, was to deny them government aid. (As you may know by now, the ad's riff about Chrysler sending Jeep production to China is untrue.)

Romney was trying to please a Republican fringe that demonizes unionized workers. And he had support from Southern lawmakers figuring that Detroit's collapse would mean less competition for the foreign-owned companies making cars in their region.

President Obama spent those grim days winning government guarantees for automakers over fierce Republican resistance. Consumers were cowering under their beds. It was government help or disaster. Auto industry analysts predicted that even solvent Ford could not have endured the collapsing chain of suppliers that would have undoubtedly followed an unsupported GM bankruptcy.

Advertisement

But Romney lectured the car companies to get private financing at a time when private lending had virtually dried up. Healthy companies couldn't get it.

Interesting that the ad mentions Romney's endorsement by the Detroit News. Everyone should read that editorial. While backing the Republican, it straightforwardly credits Obama for saving the auto industry.

"Don't assume it was a no-brainer for a conservative newspaper to endorse a conservative presidential candidate," the editorial stated in a section subtitled, "Thank Obama for auto rescue."

Romney "was wrong in suggesting the automakers could have found operating capital in the private markets," the Detroit News said. And it dismissed Romney's call for "post bankruptcy" government-backed loans as irrelevant: "What GM and Chrysler needed were bridge loans to get them through the process, and the private credit markets were unwilling to provide them." The editorial went on, "Obama put a rescue team to work, and they were true to the task."

It was rather coy of Romney to offer government assistance "post bankruptcy." That's like letting a house go over Niagara Falls and then offering to insure it if it survived.

Meanwhile, anti-union partisans continue pushing propaganda that the Detroit bailout was a United Auto Workers bailout. The facts: Labor costs at unionized factories were indeed way out of line and had to be brought down. But that was done in the restructuring. Even before, the UAW had accepted cuts for new hires in health care benefits, job security and pensions. The UAW later agreed to slash wages for new workers to half of what they were.

For the first time since Henry Ford raised wages to $5 an hour in 1914, newly hired autoworkers are making less than the average U.S. manufacturing wage. It seems at times that some people won't rest until America's blue-collar workers are turned into serfs.

Obama took an enormous political risk putting so much taxpayer money behind the car companies — though no leader could have responsibly stepped aside at the time. Remember that the Detroit bailout was started under George W. Bush. "I'd do it again," Bush said a few months ago.

When it came to saving the U.S. carmakers, Romney was no Superman. He was a super-panderer willing to sell out America's industrial heartland for a few right-wing votes.

Froma Harrop writes for the Providence (R.I.) Journal and is distributed by Creators Syndicate, Inc.

Billionaires, entertainers and athletes alike announced their intentions to pursue the Los Angeles Clippers with varying degrees of seriousness Wednesday, proving the longtime losers will be quite a prize if the NBA is able to wrest control of the team away from Donald Sterling after his lifetime ban for racist remarks. Full Story

Louie, who (like Louis) is a New York comic and a divorced father of two daughters, knows struggle and angst and cloudy wonderment. He views life through eyes with a stricken look, dwelling in a state of comfortable dread. Full Story