Hybrid Trail Shoes

May 20, 2006

Q: Hybrid Trail Shoes: I was interested in the Adidas Supernova Trail because your review said it would work well for both on-and-off road, a combination which I often do as the park I run in is only 1/2 mile from my house. However, I'm not sure if this shoe would be right for me. I am an underpronater and a heavier runner at 220 lbs, with high arches. Is this shoe too light for my needs? If so, which trail shoe would you recommend.

Currently I run in the NB 991 (which I stocked up on because I don't like the NB 992 as much) and that seems to work fine. I also have used the Asics Nimbus, but the latest version seems a bit too light for my needs of good cushioning and also good support and durability. I'm not sure which shoe to rotate my 991 with now...maybe the Wave Creation?

Thanks for any insight you can give me.

Scott KabrichSan Antonio TX

A: Scott:

I have found that the best "hybrid" road/trail shoes with ample support and cushioning to meet your needs have come from Saucony, Brooks, and Asics. The Supernova Trail is probably going to be on the more Spartan side, I'm afraid.

In the Saucony line, the Omni 5 would be a solid choice. For Brooks, the ASR and Cascadia would both suit your needs. And for Asics, the GT 2120 Trail would be right.

A Part of Hearst Digital Media
Runner's World participates in various affiliate marketing programs, which means we may get paid commissions on editorially chosen products purchased through our links to retailer sites.