Restored Mymonero wallet to Monero desktop wallet. Can you restore the Monero Desktop wallet to another Dekstop wallet?

Hey guys,
Awhile ago I restored a Mymonero wallet to the Desktop GUI wallet with the keys. I've recently tried to restore the Desktop GUI wallet (was Mymonero) to a different Desktop GUI wallet using the same keys but the balance shows as zero. Wouldn't it be possible to show the same balance on both of these wallets (two different machines) because they use the same keys?
https://i.redd.it/pc4n08oh9y811.png