On Sunday night, Fergie‘s sultry rendition of the “Star-Spangled Banner” at the NBA All-Star Game got everyone’s attention—but for all the wrong reasons. Online many commenters dubbed the jazzy number “the worst rendition ever” of the national anthem.

And it appears Roseanne Barr, who famously shrieked the national anthem (and who forget the crotch grab?) back in 1990, couldn’t agree more.