1) The fact that used weapons of the same rank (S80) did not help much because the difference of P.Atk between Vesper Singer and Vesper Retributer is considerable. (Vesper Retributer > Vesper Singer)

2) I understand by the Spectral Master's preference in the video itself, but knowing that the class already has a specific skill that significantly increases the P.Atk of the pets.

So I'd like it if possible to redo the same test, but with weapons that are different, in the case, but with p.atk almost identical. (In the case here, I see no other option comparing Retributer vs. 2-handed Tauti weapon or 2-handed Frenzied Tauti weapon)And yet with some other Wynn Summoner other than the Spectral Master.If possible, with both scenarios together would be great.

You can clearly see the Vesper Two-Hand Blunt and the Vesper Staff both giving the boost (105% P.Atk) while the other weapons don't. The difference in P.Atk is just causes because the Blunt v Staff have different base P.Atk

Just face it dude; Wynns are dead. NCSoft doesn't care for them any more.

Thank you 4r4m, was all I needed to know.My only concern was regarding the current classification of certain weapons already in progress in Korea.There are a few very badly informed Wynns trading their Retributers for other weapons.In my view, despair.Or rather, they prefer uncertainty than their belief in taking such an attitude.

To be honest, I am also bit lost in the whole weapon classification changes including SoS buff. So far I can understand, is that the weapon of Wynns remains a retributor even with it's re-classification to "cane". The main difference is that use of retri will no longer be benefitial for other classes? SoS should still work normally applying crit dmg to 2h blunts (which restricts its effect other than the Patt increase for retri being classified as "cane").

Simply put, the problem from a Titan's point of view is that the lvl 83 Shillien Templar skill Spirit of Shilen and its description remains the same, while the classification of Retributers has changed. So the one doesn't go together with the other any more.

This means that in order to be able to enjoy the Critical Damage increase bestowed by Spirit of Shilen, Titans must as of next summer use true Blunt Weapons, like for example a Two-Handed Tauti Axe or a heavily overenchanted Vesper Crusher.

Summoners, on the other hand, had their Superior Weapon Mastery changed so that as of next summer they can use either a Two-Handed Blunt Weapon like the Tauti Axe for more P.Atk. of their servitors or a Two-Handed Staff (formerly known as Retributer) for more power of their Marks.

It is possible that there were similar problems with Dual Blunts and Crushers. Since the developers generally don't want 3rd class skills to be used in post-Awakening hunting grounds, any problems with Spirit of Shilen certainly wouldn't have gotten fixed.