Emerson on Fox: Do Trump's Comments Help Recruit Terrorists?

Multimedia for this item

Video Recording

[START TRANSCRIPT]

[Video played of Hillary Clinton in CNN interview]:

Hillary Clinton: When you say we're going to bar all Muslims, you are sending a message to the Muslim world. And you're also sending a message to the terrorists, because we now do have evidence, we have seen how Donald Trump is being used to essentially be a recruiter for more people to join the cause of terrorism.

Morris: Hillary Clinton says there is evidence Donald Trump helps recruit terrorists, but is there really? Let's ask terrorism expert Steve Emerson. Steve nice to see you this morning.

Emerson: Good morning.

Morris: You know former Secretary of State you choose your words carefully. She says we have evidence that this is the case. What do you say?

Emerson: Well let's look at the evidence. It's hard to find actual statistics, but we looked at the frequency of arrests post-Trump's comments and pre-Trump comments--that would be a variable whether they're recruiting more, [as well as] the level of attacks post-Trump versus pre-Trump's comments. OK? Let's look at arrests in the United States pre-Trump's comments versus post-Trump's comments. Last year in the United States there were 71 ISIS arrests. So far this year there have been about 13. That's at a rate about only 20 percent of the rate of last year. Of those 13 this year, only eight were hatched, that is the plot started, after Trump's comments. In those plots none mentioned in the wiretaps or in the admissions submitted to court, none mentioned Donald Trump at all.

Morris: None.

Emerson: None at all.

Morris: So where is she getting this information from?

Emerson: Well I think there was one recording made by one wannabe ISIS member who exploited her comments –

Morris: Right.

Emerson: – and said, 'I'm motivated by Donald Trump,' but no attack, no post-attack recording and claim of credit has ever cited Donald Trump nationally or internationally. And the stats prove that in terms of frequency of attacks and level of recruitment. They've actually gone down following Trump. And you know what's interesting is that the assumption underlying her comments is [that] somehow Muslims around the world are just going to be motivated to carry out fire-breathing attacks just on the basis of offensive rhetoric. Well let's take Americans – are we going to—we Americans--going to suddenly turn into terrorists because of the vast amount of anti-American rhetoric in the Muslim world?

Morris: Right.

Emerson: You know it's very patronizing.

Morris: Donald Trump was on Fox & Friends on Friday. Here's what he had to say about this evidence. Watch.

[Video played of Donald Trump on phone in Fox and Friends interview]:

Donald Trump: We're not going to find the people by just continuing to be so nice and so soft. And I have many Muslim friends and they agree. They have a tremendous problem with the radical Islamic terrorism, tremendous problem. And what she said is so dumb.

Morris: What do you say to that?

Emerson: Look, Mrs. Clinton doesn't mention the term 'Islamic terrorism.' And that's the same problem of and modus operandi of this Administration – they won't mention the term. If you don't mention the term, you don't recognize [the problem] and if you don't want to use the term [Islamic terrorism], you're playing into the hands of Islamic terrorists. Number two, the bottom line actually that motivates Islamic terrorists is the belief that the U.S. is engaged in a war against Islam. And that's a line that's propagated by Islamist groups, quote, 'civil rights' groups, like CAIR Council on American Islamic Relations] and others, that the White House has invited repeatedly into the corridors of 1600 Pennsylvania Avenue and the State Department under Hillary Clinton. So they've legitimized that very message [of the conspiratorial notion that there is a war against Islam].

Morris: She's being slammed for these comments that there's, quote, 'evidence,' and Donald Trump earlier this week was slammed for suggesting right away that it was terrorism responsible for the EgyptAir crash. What evidence did he have? Did he jump the gun on that? Should he have held off?

Emerson: [Laughs.] The media has been going bonkers on the suspicion [that its terrorism] -- and they've quoted U.S. officials, they quoted FBI officials, they quoted transportation officials, they quoted French officials, Egyptian officials have gone on record as saying they believe it's terrorism.

Morris: Right.

Emerson: So look, there's no evidentiary 100 percent guarantee proof that it was terrorism, but it's leading people to believe... suspicions are leading in that direction. Let's go back to Hillary Clinton's comments [about Trump's comments being a recruiting tool for ISIS]. Look, ISIS could give a hoot about what Americans or others say about them. They don't pay attention to that. They carry out... they march to their own drummer.

Morris: Right. Steve Emerson, terrorism expert, we appreciate you joining us this morning.

Reader comments on this item

Relative evils

Submitted by John Coelho, Nov 20, 2016 21:21

The Democrats have wallowed in pc nonsense about Islamism but in every other sense Trump may be spelling the doom of our democracy. The only issue he has any clarity on, Islamism, is not a good reason to support a mendacious corrupt buffoon with fascist tendencies who glories in ignorance.

A consistent liberalism, shorn of cultural relativism and identity politics, would be more than able to deal with the Islamist threat as it dealt with fascism in the forties under Rossevelt.

There is a yin and a yang to countering Islamism. The yin approach draws reasonable Muslims towards us,. The yang approach draws a line against Muslims who don't accept our constitution and try to undermine it.

Would Ayaan Hirsi Ali and Nonie Darwish have left Islam and become prominent critics of it if they had been confronted by nothing but hostility and suspicion when they came to the West?

If the immigration laws are changed so that immigrants are on probation and can be more easily deported if they show signs of extremism, if excessive procreation counts as a mark against them so they can't breed their way into majority status, if we concentrate on religious minorities as candidates for acceptance, if we stop buying Middle Eastern oil and thereby funding terrorism, if we support liberal reformers in the Muslim world and Islamic apostates and reformers at home, we would do much better than supporting this bull in the china shop.

We need a counter narrative and and a counter agenda to Islamists who come here with the idea of out breeding the kaffir, intimidating him and acquiring more and more power. iIt would be the narrative of human dignity, freedom of thought, conscience and expression. The temptations of agency should be used to pull young Muslims away from reactionary theocratic life style. There should be open arms for them

Angry Muslims

Submitted by Jack Rainbow, May 23, 2016 09:38

Angry Muslims practice Terror. They do this because that is the message of the Koran. Even if the West submits, as it is doing, there will be no cessation in compulsive acting out by angry Muslims.

Faux newiless failes again

May 23, 2016 00:07

This clown has missed the point. So much has changed and he states its all about Drumptf. The Foolish red-neck racist who support him are so filled with hatred that they will eat this shut.

Killary is Desperate!

Submitted by Maxine Simon, May 22, 2016 22:39

This woman is Americas Number one Enemy as far as I am Concerned. She will stop at nothing! Blame needs to be put where it belongs. OBAMA, CLINTON'S, ELITES. Sick of these Corrupt Politicians with Power has gone to their head. So willing to Sell out Americans for their Own Greed, Corruption and Life Style! America can see right through her. She has NO SHAME. Thank God for America Donald Trump is a True American, Level Headed and has the interest of the People. He is so correct stating she is Weak and American is in Big Trouble if she is Elected.

Comment on this item

Name: (optional)

Email Address:

Title of Comments:

Comments:

Email me if someone replies to my comment

Note: IPT will moderate reader comments. We reserve the right to edit or remove any comment we determine to be inappropriate. This includes, but is not limited to, comments that include swearing, name calling, or offensive language involving race, religion or ethnicity. All comments must include an email address for verification.