In order to feed a growing global population that’s on track to reach 9 billion people by 2050, some scientists argue that people will have to adopt a predominantly plant-based diet to sustain both the environment and humans’ well-being. As part of FoodNavigator-USA's special edition on plant-based diets, we delve into the sustainability of plant versus animal proteins.

It’s becoming harder to ignore the mounting body of research extolling the health benefits of a vegan or vegetarian diet (lower BMI, increased fiber intake, and lower risk of cardiovascular disease, cancer and diabetes). Not only that, but vegans and vegetarians emit vastly lower levels of greenhouse gases than non-vegetarians (41.7% lower for vegans, 27.8% lower for lacto-ovo vegetarians).

Joan Sabaté, professor in the Department of Nutrition at Loma Linda University, argues that the industrialization of agriculture has resulted in a highly inefficient form of food production.

“In traditional farming methods that used to be in most western countries 200 years ago, in which the farm combines animals with different crops, the manure is used to fertilize the feed, and so on—there was a synergy between the crops and animals,” he said. “Our current system is very different. Nowadays, we have a monoculture in which one farm only produces corn, another soy, another nuts, and so on. The same goes for animal farms. They source corn and soy from thousands of miles away, produce milk or meat and then dispose of the manure. This decoupling of agricultural systems creates big ecological problems and highly inefficient systems.”

Indeed, the energy input versus energy output of meat production versus plant production is notable, as meat production generates comparatively low outputs of nutrients and energy. “Although some animal production involves using land unsuitable for crop production to graze animals, this represents a very small percentage of the market, though it's quite efficient," Dr. Sabaté noted. “A much larger percentage is produced in way I described. This system is inefficient by nature and it is the way it has become in industrial agriculture.”

Sustainability much more complex than carbon footprints

Greg Miller, executive vice president of the National Dairy Council, argued that a sustainable food system can and should include dairy products (they currently account for 2.7% of global GHG emissions, compared to 14.5% for the livestock industry), noting that the concept of sustainability is much broader than environmental impact.

“Many of those making recommendations to change our diets to be more environmentally sound have a narrow view of sustainability,” he told FoodNavigator-USA. “They’re focused on one component, such as GHG emissions or water. The (Food and Agricultural Organization’s) definition of what a sustainable and healthy diet is encompasses water, carbon emissions, biodiversity, affordability, cultural sensitivity—in short, it’s really complex.”

Dr. Miller also pointed out that roughly 75% of what we feed cattle in us is “stuff humans can’t consume. They’re great converters of plant production byproducts and other things we can’t consume into high quality protein.”

People who regularly consume dairy also have a lower risk of type 2 diabetes, better blood pressure and better bone health—all factors that could reduce healthcare costs over time. It’s also a complete source of protein, making it a more efficient way to get all the essential amino acids.

“While it’s possible to eat well and blend different plant protein sources to ensure you’re getting all amnio acids, you’re looking at people having to understand how to achieve a balance over time. The average person would struggle to understand mixing plant proteins to get amino acids they need.”

Make the industry more efficient or change the food produced

When it comes to making global food systems more sustainable, Dr. Sabaté outlines two paths for improvement: “One is to make system more efficient, say through improved technology usual [e.g. rechanneling GHG emissions underground or improving irrigation], but keeping business as usual,” he said. “Another way is to change the food we produce.”

Dr. Miller says the dairy industry has done a great job over the last 50 years of significantly reducing its carbon footprint. “Our industry is probably leading in agriculture in terms of efforts to reduce our carbon footprint. We use less land and produce less GHG. I’m proud because they haven’t stopped. We have set up a sustainability council and are continuing to look at how to improve production across the food chain.”

But Dr. Sabaté challenged the first option with a “bold,” market-driven alternative. “If demand is changed at the hands of consumers, theoretically, production will change,” he said. “If everybody dramatically reduced or stopped buying meat at the supermarket, in less than a year, meat production will decrease dramatically. Of all agricultural GHG emissions, 80% is due to livestock. If overnight this disappeared, we would have an 80% reduction in emissions.”

He admitted that such a dramatic goal is somewhat “utopian,” but he likened it to the trajectory of policy on tobacco over the past 50 years.

“Fifty years ago, more than half of the male US population were smokers, now it’s less than 17%. Fifty years of policies have changed consumption. If we tackle this issue the same way that tobacco was tackled some years ago, maybe the next generation will eat less meat and use less animal products than now.”

Still, as rising GDP in places like China and India has led to an increase in animal protein consumption, such a shift in the eating habits of the middle and upper classes appears to be an even taller order. That’s why it has to begin at home, Dr. Sabaté said.

“Unless we in the United States and Western Europe start making policy for population to reduce meat consumption, the idea that being wealthy and being fashionable is not eating meat but to be plant-based, maybe in 50 years, the upper classes middle in other countries will follow the example.”

But Dr. Miller maintains a more cautionary point of view when it comes to making recommendations about consumption. “We need more science, more information and a more complete picture before we start making policy and recommendations. People want to simplify what’s complicated and move forward.”

In order to feed a growing global population that’s on track to reach 9 billion people by 2050, some scientists argue that people will have to adopt a predominantly plant-based diet to sustain both the environment and humans’ well-being. As part of FoodNavigator-USA's special edition on plant-based diets, we delve into the sustainability of plant versus animal proteins.

3 comments(Comments are now closed)

animals and plants are interdependant

The most effective biodynamic farms use animals to keep their crops healthy and productive. The main problem with meat diet statistics is the epidemiological populations are eating factory farmed meat which is significantly inferior nutritionally than grass fed. Factory farmed meat and dairy have been proven to have more than 60% less Omega 3 than grass fed and organic. There is sufficient open BLM range to reestablish massive bison herds that could be processed with mobile butchering units = sustainable, healthy, humane. Plants alone will simply not provide complete human nutrition.
Historically there has never been a vegan culture documented that was sustainable with respect to human health.

Report abuse

Posted by Marco23 January 2014 | 21h492014-01-23T21:49:50Z

Fuller picture in previous FoodNavigator article

FoodNavigator previously reported on analysis contradicting the estimate that livestock are responsible for only 14.5% of human-induced GHG emissions at http://www.foodnavigator.com/Financial-Industry/FAO-claims-livestock-emissions-could-be-cut-by-a-third -- which is elaborated on at http://www.chompingclimatechange.org/uploads/8/0/6/9/8069267/a_fresh_look_at_livestock_and_ghg_emissions.pdf

Report abuse

Posted by Worldwatcher22 January 2014 | 23h122014-01-22T23:12:55Z

Outdated information

Aloha,
very surprised at Dr. Miller using old outdated information regarding protein combining. As a vegetarian for 42 years, I can tell you that the idea of having to combine plant proteins in the same meal in order to have a so called complete protein has been debunked ages ago. As long as the individual eats various sources of plant protein in the same day, the body will draw from an amino acid pool to create the necessary protein.
www.newjumpwing.com

Related products

Live Supplier Webinar

16-Feb-2015 - What’s hot in snacks? Insects? Posh jerky? Chickpeas? And what’s the difference between a meal and a snack, or are the lines becoming increasingly blurred? What’s a suitable portion-size? And will healthy vending become the norm? To find out, FoodNavigator-USA...

On-Demand Supplier Webinar

06-Feb-2015 - The Coca-Cola Company invested in Chicago-based co-operative Fairlife LLC in December 2012, and since then the company’s star has only risen further. Here, CEO Steve Jones introduces the company and its mission, looking at trends in dairy and the ‘protein...

On-Demand Supplier Webinar

06-Feb-2015 - Stand out in the competitive beverage marketplace and satisfy consumers’ thirst for fun by adding the creamy, smooth mouthfeel and visual appeal of foam and froth. Using naturally sourced foaming agents, you can add superior, long-lasting foams to a variety...

On-Demand Supplier Webinar

06-Feb-2015 - Ingredients such as chia, ancient grains and flaxseed have captured the interest of health-conscious consumers, and more and more beverage companies are taking notice. But where to begin? Long-time beverage ingredient innovator and turnkey formulator Glanbia Nutritionals will offer insights...

On-Demand Supplier Webinar

06-Feb-2015 - We interrupt this webinar to bring you breaking news in functional beverages. Only on AIDP News Channel will you hear from experts in the field of functional beverages. AIDP is known as being an innovator in function and our top...

On-Demand Supplier Webinar

08-Jan-2015 - What are the fastest-growing beverage categories and which consumer trends are successful firms tapping into? ‘Real’ sugar? Fermented beverages? Plant waters? And how are companies such as Keurig changing the beverage landscape? Hear from a beverage entrepreneur, a retailer, a...

On-Demand Supplier Webinar

08-Jan-2015 - Just as with the search for the Fountain of Youth, The Lost Arc or the Meaning of Life; the Holy Grail of functional beverages seems to be an ongoing quest that few of us have been able to conquer, until...

On-Demand Supplier Webinar

08-Jan-2015 - Social media has forever changed the way consumers talk to one another (and the way companies and consumers talk to each other, too). Find out how you can use social media to take your beverage business to the next level.

On-Demand Supplier Webinar

08-Jan-2015 - With annual sales approaching $9B, the US protein beverage market is thriving. The category has quickly become a destination for busy, health conscious, active consumers of all ages. Capturing mainstream consumers can be lucrative for marketers, but one that...

On-Demand Supplier Webinar

08-Jan-2015 - FoodNavigator-USA & BeverageDaily have gathered together CEOs from some of the most innovative beverage companies in the US from Mamma Chia and KeVita to Vertical Water and KonaRed to discuss growth opportunities in the beverage aisle; how difficult it is...

On-Demand Supplier Webinar

29-Oct-2014 - Consumers are snacking more frequently, and the bar category in particular has been consistently growing in terms of dollar and volume sales, making bars an area of great opportunity for manufacturers. For insights and implications on how manufacturers can increase...

Video

02-Dec-2014 - For food manufacturers, Kikkoman Sales USA, Inc. is much more than a soy sauce company. We are a partner in flavor formulation and we have some fresh solutions that will surprise you. Kikkoman provides flavor versatility and a label consumers...

Technical / white paper

02-Mar-2015 - With the uptrend in protein-packed applications and increasing allergen awareness, meat protein can be a desirable alternative to plant- and dairy-based proteins. This white paper compares meat proteins – specifically, concentrated chicken protein – to other common proteins, and outlines...

Event programme

08-Dec-2014 - Leaders in R&D, marketing and business strategy who are passionate about innovation and growth come together at Food Vision in Cannes to debate the sources of sustainable growth and profitability in today's global nutrition, food & drink markets. Food Vision...

Technical / white paper

16-Feb-2015 - Wheat is a well-known and appreciated cereal, rich in nutritious and healthy components. As a source of vegetable proteins, wheat supports a sustainable development process.It is suitable for the formulation of both delicious and convenient foodstuffs, adapted to a modern...