Reviewer:

I did not enjoy these cookies at all. They were okay, but these cookies were too rich. I tried a few other peanut butter chocolate chip cookies from this site and they weren't that good either. My family and neighbors didn't really enjoy them either. Just a few bites from this cookie made my tastebuds sick. I'm definitely never, ever, going to make another peanut butter chocolate chip cookie again. I'm sticking with normal chocolate chip cookies.

Reviewer:

My husband and I found similar cookies in San Francisco. I really liked them and wanted to duplicate them and although I mixed the soda measurements, they still tasted great, they were just a little flat.

Reviewer:

I didn't like the cookies AT ALL... the texture was more like cake than a cookie - I like cookies crips on the outside and soft on the inside. The flavor wasn't worth writing home over either. It seemed I could almost taste the baking soda or maybe it was the corn starch. Ewwww, nasty!

Reviewer:

I don't know what recipe the bad reviews refer to, although I guess it's possible for anyone to mess up a perfectly good recipe. After all, that's why there are good cooks and bad cooks, eh? This is one of THE BEST peanut butter chocolate chip cookie recipes around, hands down. I add a little extra peanut butter. My oldest son loved them so much, we made them for Santa Claus last Christmas, and this year we will do the same. Thanks, Kathy, for a great submission!

Reviewer:

These are my husbands favorite cookie. I have been making them for a long while and they always come out perfectly. I usually make them with white chocolate chips instead of the chocolate chips because that is what my husband likes. They are thick, soft and peanut buttery delicious! Thanks Kathy!