Quoting my own list here I thought I should add that only Tonari has really grabbed my attention much at all so far. Shinsekai Yori is visually appealing but normally if Crunchyroll is late with their simulcast I will cheat and watch a raw or fansub early and then watch it in beautiful 1080p here to enjoy it properly and give it the views so they get paid but it hasn't got me yet so I am waiting for it to appear here on Tuesday and will watch it when I get a free moment. I know its just been one episode but usually my favorite shows grab me before the first time the opening theme plays, and definitely grab me before the first time the ending theme plays. It isn't logical, it is a feeling immediately of "I must know how this turns out!" I am watching the countdown before the episodes start when I love a show and I buy the light novels and manga when they end because I HAVE TO KNOW WHAT happens but... Even Tonari is not that strong. I am not really dying to find out what happens in any of these yet. Hopefully they'll grow on me...

Further thought I think Zetsuen no Tempest was better than Shinsekai Yori for that reason. There is a bit of a mystery there that I might care to find out about. Might...

everything is the same right now, fall 2012 is a slow start, not necessarily bad. All the plots are the same

boy meets girl

boy saves girl

boy kisses girl

protagonist is being targeted

protagonist goes wtf

The only exception is shin sekai, but this is a different genre entirely so far with only 2 episodes nothing important has been reveal except for the fact that children goes missing if they suck.

So ranking all the plots they are all the same, I'd say to love ru darkness is the lowest of them, cuz that type of anime gets boring and fast, especially when the protagonist is indecisive(some might argue differently but where is he now with his harem?).

so i'd say everything is the same except darkness is the below the rest.

code breaker I read a few chapters and not interested, again it is boy xxxx girl

I thought the First episode of Jojo's was pretty good start. Of everything this season that was the show that had me on pins and needles. It was either going to be fantastic or horrible depending on how well they could capture the feel of the manga.

1.Tonari no Kaibutsu-kun
2. Chuunibyou demo Koi ga Shitai!
3. K (shounen ai-ish xD)
4. Sukitte Ii na yo. (seems like it'll be a nice romance)
5. Psycho-Pass (I thought it was great, very exciting imo. Not for the faint of heart. There won't be any moe in it, as an experiment, to see if it'll do good among todays moe animes)
6. Robotics;Notes (Slow, but I enjoyed it. The end made it really interesting. I'm looking forward to the next ep a lot)
6. Little Busters!
7. Jormungand: Perfect Order (slow but better than the ones under here)
8. Ixion Saga DT
9. Magi (Anime Aladdin. Not ripping on Disney. Aladdin is not Disney's story)
10. Shinsekai Yori (the first ep was interesting)
11. Sakurasou no Pet na Kanojo
12. Girls und Panzer
13. Aikatsu! (Idols. Vocaloid fans might like it. Tokyo Mew Mew fans will definitly like it, it's very sugary cute. I lol'd a lot, but becaus it was weird watching the idols stuff :P)

@Chrome:
If you haven't watched Chaos;Head yet, you should.
It's also an alternative universe to Steins;Gate, but that doesn't mean it was the best of the season it aired in.
It's a good one, but it's not Steins;Gate good.
I'm expecting Robotics;Notes to be Chaos;Head good.