I voted for bag #2! Regardless if you print your monogram on it or not, people will probably be more likely to use it even when they get back home, rather than a beach bag (Although bag #1 is pretty cute and convienent for the beach)

i could go either way. I think the first ones are really cute. But if your fi doesn't really like them and i'm sure you could do something great to personalize the second bag, that would be great too. so i basically canceled out my vote. sorry!