PROFESSIONAL NEGLIGENCE UPDATE. by John Walmsley

Transcription

1 PROFESSIONAL NEGLIGENCE UPDATE by John Walmsley 1

2 2

3 3

4 1. Negligence: Basics The tort of negligence has three basic requirements which must be proved by the claimant on a balance of probabilities, namely that: The defendant owed the claimant a duty of care not to cause the type of harm suffered. The defendant breached the duty of care owed. The breach caused the harm. This has two elements, both of which must be proved: 4

5 Causation and remoteness factual causation: the claimant must prove that, but for the defendant's negligence, the claimant would not have suffered loss; and legal causation or remoteness: whether the defendant's negligence was the legal cause of the loss. 5

6 2. Duty of care The courts use a number of different tests to establish whether a duty of care is owed in tort by one party to another, for example: The three-fold test established in Caparo Industries Plc V Dickman [1990], which asks whether: the damage which occurred was foreseeable; there is sufficient proximity in the relationship between the parties; and it is fair, just and reasonable in all the circumstances to impose a duty of care. 6

7 3. Assumption of responsibility test What is the test? The assumption of responsibility test asks: Has the professional assumed responsibility towards the claimant? Was there reliance by the claimant? 7

8 A number of cases claiming economic loss have been decided by the House of Lords using the assumption of responsibility principle. The House of Lords' decision in Hedley Byrne & Co Ltd v Heller & Partners Ltd [1963] established that there is a general duty to take care in the making of statements where: 8

9 4. The test in Caparo professional advisers Hedley Byrne is still relied on in many judgments, but the test has since been refined. In Caparo, the question arose whether a firm of accountants owed a duty of care not to cause pure economic loss to existing shareholders and investors who relied on negligently audited accounts. The court held that there must be specificity of both the recipients of the information and the purpose for which the statement was made. It was insufficient to establish a duty of care merely by reliance on the accounts and the foreseeability of loss. 9

10 The test in Caparo is that a duty not to cause pure economic loss may arise where: The advice is required for a purpose (whether particularly specified or generally) that is made known (either actually or inferentially) to the adviser at the time the advice is given. The adviser knows (either actually or inferentially) that the advice will be communicated to the advisee (either specifically or as a member of an ascertainable class) so that it should be used by the advisee for that purpose. It is known (actually or inferentially) that the advice is likely to be acted on by the advisee for that purpose without independent inquiry. It is so acted on by the advisee to his detriment. 10

11 In Caparo, the House of Lords held that the specific purpose of the accounts was to enable the shareholders of the company to exert control over the company. The duty of auditors was owed to the company. The purpose of the audited accounts was not to enable investors to decide whether or not to invest and, therefore, no duty was owed to investors who relied on the accounts for this purpose. The requirement of reliance exists to impose a limitation on the number and classes of potential claimants. But no such limit can apply where the claimants are identifiable and limited in number. 11

12 5. Breach of duty: standard of care Where a duty is owed in contract or tort, the claimant must establish that there has been a breach of that duty. In doing so, the claimant must show that the professional did not comply with the standard owed. The Bolam Test Bolam v Friern Hospital Management Committee [1957] laid down the applicable test for the standard of care for professionals. Although Bolam dealt with medical negligence, the test has been upheld by the House of Lords and is the appropriate test to use in all professional liability cases. 12

13 6. Loss The principle in SAAMCO: loss must be within scope of duty of professional giving inaccurate information In the context of professional negligence and, in particular, the giving of professional advice, a principle has been developed by the House of Lords in South Australia Asset Management v York Montague Ltd [1997] (SAAMCO). The basic measure when assessing losses resulting from negligence is found by comparing what the claimant's position would have been if there had been no breach of duty and the claimant's actual position. Often, without the negligent advice, the claimant would not have entered into the transaction. 13

14 In such a case, a comparison must be made between the position of the claimant if he had not entered the transaction and his actual position to calculate the claimant's loss. In SAAMCO, the House of Lords placed important restrictions on the losses which could be claimed in the context of inaccurate information, holding that only those losses that are attributable to the breach are recoverable. To be so attributable, a loss must come within the scope of the duty owed. The starting point is, therefore, to define the precise scope of the duty. This test is more easily stated than it is to apply in practice. 14

15 In the case of a negligent valuation provided for a lender, the lender has less security than he would have had if the valuation had been accurate. SAAMCO held that only those losses falling within the amount of the overvaluation are attributable to the breach. The amount of the overvaluation, therefore, caps the lender's recoverable damages. 15

16 A crucial distinction must be drawn between the provision of information to enable someone else to decide on a course of action and actually advising someone on what course of action to take. In the latter case, an adviser must take all reasonable care to consider all the potential consequences of that course of action. If he is negligent, he will be responsible for all the foreseeable loss which is a consequence of that course of action being taken. There will be no SAAMCO cap on the damages. 16

17 The distinction may not be easy to make in practice. For example, an accountant may be asked to value shares or to give advice on the merits of purchasing shares. This is a question of defining the scope of the duty owed by the accountant and the answer depends on the precise terms of his instructions. 17

18 The accountant will want to ensure that his retainer does not render him an adviser on the merits. On the other hand, if the client requires the accountant to provide more general advice, the client should ensure that this is expressed in clear terms. The duty owed in a particular case would depend on all the relevant surrounding circumstances. 18

19 7. Recent examples of professional negligence claims (1) Accountants In Arrowhead Capital Finance Ltd (In liquidation) v KPMG LLP [2012], KPMG had provided due diligence services to a company and the claimant, which invested in the company, alleged that KPMG owed it a duty of care. On an application for summary judgment, the court dismissed the claim. It was unfeasible that a business would consider that KPMG had voluntarily assumed such a duty. Further, even if a duty could be established by the threefold test, it would not be fair, just and reasonable to impose a duty of care which could result in unlimited liability. 19

20 (2) Financial advisers In Rubenstein v HSBC Bank Plc [2012], the Court of Appeal considered whether HSBC had mis-sold a life assurance bond to an investor and, if so, whether the loss suffered by the investor was recoverable. The investor lost around 180,000 of his capital following market turmoil in September The Court of Appeal held that HSBC had given negligent advice. The scope of HSBC's duty embraced the regulatory requirements set out in the Financial Services' Association (FSA) Conduct of Business sourcebook. HSBC had breached a number of these requirements. 20

21 Ultimately, the Court of Appeal reversing the first instance decision held that the loss suffered as a consequence of the financial crisis was reasonably foreseeable and, therefore, recoverable in damages. The Court of Appeal stated (Lord Justice Rix): It was the bank s duty to protect Mr Rubenstein from exposure to market forces when he made clear that he wanted an investment which was without any risk (and when the bank told him that his investment was the same as a cash deposit). It is wrong in such a context to say that when the risk from exposure to market forces arises, the bank is free of responsibility because the incidence of market loss was unexpected. 21

22 This presentation contains general advice and comments only and therefore specific legal advice should be taken before reliance is placed upon it in any particular circumstances. 22

BUSINESS LAW GUIDEBOOK SECOND EDITION CHARLES YC CHEW CHAPTER 8: THE LAW OF NEGLIGENCE IN THE BUSINESS WORLD TEST YOUR KNOWLEDGE 1. Outline the elements of the tort of negligence. The elements of the tort

GITC REVIEW VOL.XIII NO.1 ~ DECEMBER 2014 BACK TO BASICS: TAX AND PROFESSIONAL NEGLIGENCE by Michael Thomas It is a sobering thought that those of us who give tax advice are potentially one slip away from

Professional liability of accountants and auditors This factsheet provides guidance on the liability for professional negligence which members may incur because of an act or default by them (or by their

Authorities on SAAMCO and solicitors negligence Nicola Rushton, Alice Nash, Amy Nesbitt & Alicia Tew The purpose of this paper is to provide attendees with a little more detail than can be covered in the

Clinical Negligence by Janet C Kelly Midwifery Lecturer 1 Aim To give an insight into the concept of clinical negligence and its relation to children s nursing 2 Objectives 1. To explain the concept and

Unintentional Torts - Definitions Negligence The failure to exercise the degree of care that a reasonable person would exercise that results in the proximate cause of actual harm to an innocent person.

Provided by the author(s) and University College Dublin Library in accordance with publisher policies. Please cite the published version when available. Title Accountants' liability for negligence Author(s)

BOOM OR BUST? TRENDS IN PROFESSIONAL NEGLIGENCE CLAIMS FROM THE RECENT RECESSION A lecture by Andy Stevenson and Nick Curling, Elborne Mitchell LLP 5 December 2012 These notes are derived from a talk by

Negligent Misstatements 333 Introduction DEVELOPMENTS IN THE LAW RELATING TO NEGLIGENT MISSTATEMENTS: ANY RECOURSE FOR INVESTORS AND CREDITORS? Traditionally, the courts have been reluctant to award damages

University of Oslo University of Oslo Faculty of Law Legal Studies Research Paper Series No. 2015-06 Kern Alexander Tort Liability for Ratings of Structured Securities under English Law Electronic copy

Acknowledgements Table of Cases Table of Legislation ix xix xxix 1. Introduction 1 I. The Disintegration of the Modern Law 1 A. A Very Brief History 1 B. Implications of the Development of the Modern Law:

CAMBRIDGE INTERNATIONAL EXAMINATIONS GCE Advanced Level MARK SCHEME for the October/November 2013 series 9084 LAW 9084/42 Paper 4, maximum raw mark 75 This mark scheme is published as an aid to teachers

Construction Quarterly Review May 2013 John Grimes Partnership Limited v Gubbins [2013] A consulting engineer was held to be liable for losses flowing from the fall in the housing market. The consultant

Presentation to SCSI Claims and Risk Management 13 October 2011 By Tara Cosgrove Beale and Company Solicitors Elements of a Claim Considering any claim the court will consider a number of elements. The

Harris v. Carter, 582 A.2d 222 (Del.Ch.,1990) [ ] The litigation arises from the negotiation and sale by one group of defendants (the Carter group) of a control block of Atlas stock to Frederic Mascolo;

Negligence & Tort Law How to Prove Negligence The plaintiff needs to prove four elements by a preponderance of the evidence Duty Breach of Duty Causation (two parts) Damages Duty Defined: A legal obligation

NEGLIGENT VALUERS LIABILITY FOR MARKET LOSSES IN THE UK AND AUSTRALIA, Professor of Law, Paper presented at the 7TH PACIFIC RIM REAL ESTATE SOCIETY CONFERENCE Department of Law The University of Reading

SAAMCO AND RECOVERABILITY OF LOSSES IN A FALLING MARKET Seminar by Ben Lynch and Christopher Stone, Devereux Chambers 14 October 2010 Introduction 1. This short paper addresses the following: (1) The issue

Unlawful Dividends BRIEFING This briefing note is intended to provide guidance to insolvency practitioners who wish to consider whether to seek repayment on behalf of the company of dividends paid to shareholders.

LIMITATION UPDATE 1. Recently, the Courts have been looking at three areas of limitation law and practice. One is when it is permissible to introduce a new claim in pending proceedings after the limitation

This publication is written as a general guide only. It is not intended to contain definitive legal Broadly speaking professional negligence occurs where a professional such as a solicitor, surveyor, doctor

Bar Vocational Course Legal Research Task Below is an example of a 2,500 word legal research piece which is typical of the task required as part of the Bar Vocational Course. This particular piece is on

UNIT 5 LAW OF TORT Suggested Answers June 2009 Note to Candidates and Tutors: The purpose of the suggested answers is to provide students and tutors with guidance as to the key points students should have

Duty of Care Kung Fu Instructor in Training Program Shaolin Guardian Network Negligence This civil wrong is most importance to all professional groups, as far as being a source of potential legal action.

Negligent Misstatement 0 NEGLIGENT MISSTATEMENT Introduction The majority of professionals are aware that the provision of negligent advice or a negligent misstatement may expose them to liability. However,

Legal Research Record Summary of problem(s) Design and Dress Limited (DDL) has experienced problems due to the alleged harassment of one of their employees, Susie Baker, by another employee, Stephen Harding

Tree roots: causation in natural nuisance cases What is the correct approach to causation in cases concerning natural nuisances where a landowner does nothing at all to abate such a nuisance on his land?

NEGLIGENCE CLAIMS AGAINST PUBLIC BODIES WHERE ARE WE NOW? On 1 April 2004, the House of Lords handed down judgment in Gorringe v Calderdale MBC [2004] 1 WLR 1057. Although on its facts concerned solely

Jeffrey Jupp who practises in commercial litigation and employment law explores the issues that arise when an employee blows the whistle on corporate wrongdoing. THE INTERNAL WHISTLEBLOWER AND CORPORATE

Summary of the law on STRESS AT WORK Stress means different things to different people, but in general terms it s a reaction to excessive pressure or harassment at work. This booklet is solely concerned

STATUTORY AUDIT SERVICES MARKET INVESTIGATION Liability, insurance and settlements Introduction 1. This paper is part of our assessment of barriers to entry or expansion in the market for statutory audits

Professional Indemnity Claims: Avoiding the problems Standard of skill and care against which to measure any breach of duty The Issues of Reliance, Causation and Quantum Standard of Performance Perhaps

TORT LAW CONCEPTS FOR REGULATORS What is a Tort? A legal construct only exists when the law says it exists A private or civil wrong or injury Primary purpose is to compensate person injured by the actions

Chapter 4 Crimes (Review) On a separate sheet of paper, write down the answer to the following Q s; if you do not know the answer, write down the Q. 1. What is a crime? 2. There are elements of a crime.

May 2011 Welcome to the latest bulletin from Bristows' Commercial Disputes team. This bulletin has been prepared by the City & International Disputes group within the team. Should you have any comments

4. WHAT CAN YOU BE LIABLE FOR AND WHY? 4.1 Negligence Liability for negligence is a civil, not a criminal, matter. It is for the victim to prove that the defendant owed them a "duty of care", that that

Michigan Prepared by Cardelli Lanfear P.C. 322 West Lincoln Royal Oak, MI 48067 Tel: 248.850.2179 Fax: 248.544.1191 1. Introduction History of Tort Reform in Michigan Michigan was one of the first states

AIFM DIRECTIVE: ESMA CONSULTATION PAPER On 13th July ESMA published its consultation on the implementation measures for the Alternative Investment Fund Managers Directive (AIFMD). The AIFM Directive aims

Taming the Liability Monster Hershel L. Kreis, Jr. Richard Rubino November 13, 2009 What is so important about understanding Civil Liability for Communications Personnel? Every job has the potential of

Disclaimer In all cases solicitors must ensure that any agreement with a client is made in compliance with their professional duties, the requirements of the SRA and any statutory requirements depending

A brief guide to professional negligence claims Contents Introduction Do I have a claim? Important considerations Pre-action protocol procedure Court proceedings Contact information Introduction Claims

INFORMATION TO CLIENTS OF BLACKWELL GLOBAL INVESTMENTS (CYPRUS) LIMITED IN RELATION TO THE FOR CUSTOMERS OF CYPRIOT INVESTMENT FIRMS (CIFs) 1. BLACKWELL GLOBAL INVESTMENTS (CYPRUS) LIMITED (the Company

UNFAIR DISMISSAL: WHEN WILL THE COURTS ALLOW EXTENDED TIME LIMITS? This article appeared in Employment Law Journal February 2008 Number 87 In the light of a series of recent EAT cases, Marc Jones and Mandeep

This is the author s version of a work that was submitted/accepted for publication in the following source: Stickley, Amanda P. (2012) Long term exposure to asbestos satisfies test for causation. Queensland

Duties & Liabilities of a Director of a Company Incorporated Under the Laws of the Cayman Islands Contents Preface 2 1. Statutory Duties of a Director 3 2. Other Duties of a Director 3 Fiduciary Duties

Causation for nursing Abstract This article considers the application of the tests of factual and legal causation to cases of medical negligence. It is argued that in light of the recent development of

South Australia LAW REFORM (CONTRIBUTORY NEGLIGENCE AND APPORTIONMENT OF LIABILITY) ACT 2001 An Act to reform the law relating to contributory negligence and the apportionment of liability; to amend the

SAFETY REVIEW NOT SPECIFIED IN CONTRACT James C. Kozlowski, J.D., Ph.D. 2008 James C. Kozlowski In contracting for personal services, an architect's duty depends on the particular agreement entered into

RESPONSE BY FORUM OF INSURANCE LAWYERS (FOIL) (SCOTLAND) TO THE SCOTTISH GOVERNMENT CONSULTATION PAPER- Partial Regulatory Impact Assessment on a Proposed Bill to Reverse House of Lords Judgement in Johnston

2013 IL App (1st) 120546-U Third Division March 13, 2013 No. 1-12-0546 NOTICE: This order was filed under Supreme Court Rule 23 and may not be cited as precedent by any party except in the limited circumstances