Joe wrestles with himself over whether or not to talk about one holiday incident where Katie lost or misplaced a certain package. When Gramps sends a text to what he thinks is a customer’s number, he gets a reply he did not expect. The new novel by Robby and Joe’s uncle was a popular Christmas present in 2018. Joe gets a gift bonanza being on his future mother-in-law’s Christmas list. The Die Laughing Production secret Santa gift exchange produced some extraordinary presents, but a portrait painted of Joe and Katie stood-out above all others. Rob still feels self-conscious about his own reaction when receiving gifts. Rob and Joe open gifts from Marcus on the air. Both the cast and the audiences were filled with the Christmas spirit for the final few murder mystery performances of the year and things got wild. Rob is traveling out of the country to perform on New Year’s Eve, and Joe explains why he will never be allowed to do anything like that in the future. There will be no celebrating of the upcoming 400th show because Rob and Joe just don’t think its a big deal. With the benefit of hindsight, some of Rob and Joe’s worst moments from past shows are being reexamined and highlighted on Twitter. Erik gets a sex toy for Christmas.