The forum culminated in a for-and-against debate on the motion ‘Better evidence of the impact of design will drive up demand.’

Design Museum director Deyan Sudjic and architect Michál Cohen, arguing against, faced a losing battle – as a poll taken before the debate showed that 86% of the crowd agreed with the statement, with just 14% against.

Pryce, a former head of the Government’s Economic Service and a long-time servant at the Department for Business, Innovation and Skills, understands the value of speaking Government’s language.

She points out that Government’s power over the design industry is huge. It can support design education, provide tax breaks and support public projects. And crucially, ‘Government will favour proposals which indicate a payoff to the economy’. Particularly in an economic downturn.

Vicky Pryce, ‘Government will favour proposals which indicate a payoff to the economy’

Meanwhile Sands, who points out he ‘works at the coalface, trying to get clients to spend money on design’, was predictably passionate about measuring the impact of design. He does, after all, have to sell it.

Sands says, ‘I spent two days going through two year’s worth of pitches that we had won or lost. I looked at the reasons we had been unsuccessful. For example, if the client had said we were too expensive then we obviously hadn’t adequately communicated the value of what we do.

‘I came up with seven principles of selling design [note: he was understandably unforthcoming on what these are…]. In the last two years I’ve been involved in 20 pitches. We haven’t lost a single one.’

Both Sujic and Cohen (arguing against) put forward the argument that that design’s impact is inherently difficult to measure, with Sudjic also pointing out that ‘lots of companies already know perfectly well that they have to invest in design,’ adding, ‘Government has been saying design is good for you since 1851 [year of the Great Exhibition].’

Jonathan Sands, ‘at the coalface of design’

So, measuring design – beneficial but difficult. But is there more to it? Well yes, first of all why should we measure it at all? As Helen Hamlyn Centre director Jeremy Myerson says, we need to frame the issue. He (jokingly) pointed out that while the Design Business Association is helping consultancies help people sell crisps and beer, designers are working on healing environements to cure people who have had too many crisps and too much beer. What kind of ‘effectiveness’ should we be aiming for?

And should evidence of design’s effectiveness simply be used to drum up demand for it, or should it be used to improve the discipline itself? As Design Council chief design officer Mat Hunter says, ‘Are we selling the value of good design or also identifying the cost of bad design?’

It’s interesting that the motion put forward by the Design Council was ‘better evidence of the impact of design will drive up demand’, rather than, say, ‘design should be subject to evidence-based measurement’. The first is easy to respond to. The second, less so.

Deyan Sudjic, ‘Design is important because it is so hard to pin down.’

There are obviously huge benefits to measuring the impact of design – in selling it to clients and in persuading Government to open its purse-strings. But if we reduce the impact of design purely to statistical analysis, and this is what clients and funders come to expect from it, then isn’t there a danger that we’ll lose the intangible benefits that design can bring?

The beauty of design – when this beauty occurs – isn’t in ticking a series of measurable boxes for a client, but in delivering something completely unexpected, that works perfectly. To use the old cliché, solving a problem that nobody realised existed. As Sudjic pointed out, ‘Design is important because it is so hard to pin down.’

At the end of the debate the opening motion was again voted on – ‘Would better evidence on the impact of design drive up demand? This time 75% agreed, and 25% disagreed.

In the interests of disclosure, Design Week voted in favour of the motion, albeit rather reluctantly. How would you have voted?

Consultancy Aesop has completed some beautiful but harrowing work for charity Unseen, which campaigns against modern day slavery. Aesop worked with illustrators such as Tom Jay and Radio to create what at first appear to be festive paper chains – but on closer inspection, depict individual stories of recent victims of slavery. The paper chains […]

Consultancy Sheridan&Co has designed the branding for fitness studio Opus based in Notting Hill, London. The studio was formerly known as DKPT, so has been renamed and received a new visual look and website. Sheridan&Co also created a new strapline “Fitness to Inspire”. Michael Sheridan, founder at Sheridan&Co, says the rebrand hopes to convey the […]

Jasper Conran has opened a hotel in Marrakech, Morocco, based in a 19th century riad. L’Hôtel Marrakech is comprised of five suites, which surround a courtyard garden and swimming pool. It includes pieces of Moroccan antique furniture, textiles, lighting and art, all taken from Conran’s collection. Conran worked on the restoration of the building with […]

Cardiff-based Bluegg has launched a countrywide awareness campaign in Wales to prevent drivers from driving under the influence of alcohol or drugs over the Christmas period. The campaign was produced in collaboration with the five police forces in Wales, and is designed to tap into people’s emotions by depicting a family dealing with the loss […]

Founder Phoa Kia Boon and creative director Clifford Hiscock have designed The New Black, a coffee shop on Philpot Lane in central London. Design features include stainless steel benches which hide the coffee machines, steel and glass bench seating areas and a “bean counter” near the entrance, where customers are able to smell the individual […]

Fourth year students on the product design engineering programme at the Glasgow School of Art have designed a collection of products in collaboration with the GSA shop. The students were briefed to create designs which would allow them to experiment with materials and manufacturing techniques, while also having commercial appeal. The products, which include a […]

Build has designed the brand identity for the new interior collection by modular furniture and homeware workshop, Plæy. The identity comprises a new modular-inspired logo and icon, which will be applied to all print and digital collateral.

Drinkall Dean has designed the new shop and ticket area for Tower Bridge Exhibition’s Engine Rooms, which house the steam engines, furnaces and accumulators once used to power the raising of Tower Bridge. Design elements include brass shelves inspired by trays in the engine rooms and a series of coloured steel shelves which are used […]