Does the Bar Exam Make Law School Graduates Better Lawyers?

Every year, thousands of recent law school graduates spend their summer studying crazily for and then taking--perhaps also crazily--the bar exam. A rite of passage for newly minted JDs across the country, the bar exam is the barrier to entry for the legal profession. But why? Does the bar exam test wannabe lawyers on things they will need to know--and use--in their careers? Professors John Yoo of UC Berkeley School of Law and Richard Epstein of NYU School of Lawspoke with Glenn Reynolds of PJTV about the bar exam and its relationship to law school and legal education in "Lowering the Bar: Is Law School Becoming a Fool's Errand?"

The bar exam and law careers

"Surely operates as a barrier to entry, otherwise established lawyers wouldn't care much about it," Says Epstein. "Is it a dumb barrier to entry? Or is it a barrier to entry that bears some relationship to what it is that students ought to know on the bar or when they practice law?" "I don't see really much connection between how you're going to do as a lawyer and whether you pass the bar at all," answers Yoo. "When you have tryouts for a football team and you want to see who might be a good player, you make all the players crawl through the mud, just to see that they have the determination to crawl through the mud, they want to play so bad that they'll do anything. I think the same thing with the bar. People just study for the bar, they pass it. It's really just to show they've got determination and effort just to pass a bar, but doesn't have a lot to do with showing who's going to be a good lawyer."

Critics of the bar exam (including Epstein and Yoo) say that the exam is both too broad and too specific. The exam is administered by individual states, so federal law (the importance of which has increased in recent years) is "just ignored" according to Epstein. At the same time, lawyers today are "extreme specialists" and not the "jack-of-all-trades" they used to be; thus, they do not need to know many of the topics tested on the exam.

The bar exam and law school

Since the bar exam doesn't seem to have much relation to the practice of law, perhaps it does to legal education. Does the bar exam keep law school from becoming too academic? Preserving law school as a vocational school? That would be "too optimistic," says Epstein, though there is more attention paid to the exam at lower ranked schools. "There are, particularly when you go down the hierarchy, immense pressures on the part from students to make sure that they have the set of skills that they think that law firms will want them to have," says Epstein. "At the more advanced law schools—or the higher ranking law schools—we tend not to teach to the bar very much, but tend to do exactly the kind of academic thing you're talking about. So we don't study the re-statement, we study the theory of efficient breach when we're talking about contracts, and rely on the bar review courses to get them through." Yoo agrees. "If it were true that these law schools were grounded in some reality, then why are all these bar prep courses out there, which charge outrageous sums of money to basically cram students full of the information they need to pass the bar in the two weeks or three weeks right before the bar," he explains. "They're the ones that are really preparing students for the bar exam. So I think it's much less so the law schools."

If the bar exam isn't keeping anyone in line--law schools or lawyers--then what purpose does it serve other than to prove you want to be a lawyer bad enough? Perhaps none. But who are we to say that that's not enough? Moreover, given the number of wannabe lawyers out there, a crazy-difficult barrier to entry to the professional that tests how badly they want it isn't necessarily a bad thing.

Comments Policy

Vault.com encourages you to express your opinions and engage in discussions with one another by leaving comments on our site. While we promote an open forum, please follow these guidelines to ensure an enjoyable and welcoming environment for all our readers. Vault.com does not review or moderate all comments but we reserve the right to remove or edit content once posted.

Respect one another. Debates are great, but attacks are not. Please refrain from posting offensive, obscene, threatening or abusive comments. If you personally attack other readers or writers, your comment(s) and responses to those comments may be removed from the discussion. Attacks create a hostile environment that discourages discussion. You are fully responsible for libelous or defamatory comments.

Hate-speech will not be tolerated. Comments containing racism, homophobia, sexism, or any other form of hate-speech have no place on our site.

Keep your language in check. Vulgar posts may offend other readers. Our filters are fairly tolerant, allowing for quite a bit of colorful/questionable language, but too many obscenities may prevent a comment from posting. In addition, in some cases, if a post is still too vulgar, a moderator may later remove or edit it.

Please note that comments may be edited by the moderator for any reason, including but not limited to language.

Stay on topic. Comments should be related to the topic discussed in the associated article or blog post. In order to keep the conversation relevant, off-topic comments may be edited or removed.

Don't impersonate someone else. You may not use a false e-mail address, impersonate any person or entity, or otherwise mislead as to the origin of your comments. If we believe you've impersonated someone else, we reserve the right to remove the comment.

Spam and commercial content will be removed. We do not welcome comments containing copy used for commercial purposes or for soliciting funds. If we see them, we reserve the right to remove them.

Readers may "report" concerns about other reader comments. Please use the "Report Abuse" link to flag inappropriate content. If a reader reports a concern, moderators will try to review that concern as soon as possible. This may take a few days although we hope to review comments more quickly. We do not remove every comment that has been reported and we cannot respond individually to every report.

Stop and think before you comment. We won't remove comments because a reader or writer regrets a post. Please remember that these comments are searchable and a comment history has a long life on the web.

Don't include personal information in your comments. We strongly discourage readers from posting personal information about themselves (ex. address, telephone number, workplace) and reserve the right to remove any comments we find with personal information about other people or that violates a third party's right to privacy.

Complaints about removed comments. We reserve the right to remove comments left to protest a removed comment. Please contact us if you have any complaints about deleted comments.

Repeated abuse of our guidelines may lead to commenting privileges being suspended. If you think you've been banned by mistake, let us know.

For further questions and comments regarding commenting on Vault.com, please contact us.

Get tips on interviewing, networking, resumes, and more directly to your inbox.