It would be nice if they recorded commentary but only if it wasn't repetitive and actually made sense and not just random babbling. And if they added Murray Walker as a surprise extra I wouldn't complain although I doubt it will happen.

the commentary sucks!! it sounds so bad i turn it off. come on lets have some feeling lads. the worst thing is that every 2 laps brundle repeats the race order and it never changes because the stupid computer cars never overtake!!

I consider the commentary a major critisism of this game. It's so 1990's, and quite boring and repetetive. Why can't they make it more detailed like they did on the TV. I should expect more from Allen and Brundle. They need to use more power in their commentating just as they would do on TV, instead of random blabbing, like...

OKAY! I'm getting myself confused here. Let's just do an example. There's a battle for the lead between Michael Schumacher and Fernando Alonso at a random track, the commentary SHOULD have been like this. "...and Schumacher is trying to get on the inside of Alonso, but wait, Alonso fights back at it, his defending could help here, but wait! Schumacher is going to continue the fight, they're side by side coming into Turn 1, who's got the moves? Who's on front! Schumacher takes first place from Alonso! FANTASTIC stuff!"

They'll have to look at this because at the moment, no F1 game has had good commentary since Formula One 2003.