When will Indian politics wake up to climate change?

Initiatives that do not factor in climate resilience and related gender concerns cannot address development challenges, but the
manner in which state-level climate action plans are being implemented shows these are yet to become electoral planks.
Aditi Kapoor
reports.

The Uttarakhand floods and Cyclone Phailin, which ravaged the coast of Odisha and Andhra Pradesh in 2013, have illustrated how the effects of climate change can
erode development gains, greatly impacting the lives of the poor, especially women.

As able-bodied men move away from unproductive and low-paid agriculture, more women are taking up agricultural labour leading to what is called 'feminisation of
agriculture labour.' A majority (87.3 per cent) of women work in rural areas and female marginal workers outnumber male marginal workers among cultivators,
agricultural labour and household industry.

India is in general election mode in 2014, and 'development' is going to be a key electoral plank. The country has been witnessing declining per capita
availability of foodgrain in the recent past, and climate vagaries are already affecting crop production, milk yields and fish harvests. However, political
parties can no longer promise development without factoring in climate change and addressing related gender concerns. A good place to start doing this would be to
give teeth to the emerging State-level Action Plans on Climate Change (SAPCCs).

Modelled on India's National Action Plan on Climate Change (NAPCC), the state-level action plans are mandated to chart out a climate-resilient development
road-map for each of the states, addressing both emission reduction and adaptation to climate vagaries. Since climate change affects all areas of development .
food production, safety from disasters, education, health, physical infrastructure and energy security . these ambitious plans have involved a huge
inter-departmental exercise, steered by senior-most bureaucrats. The plans reflect the development priorities of the ruling political parties.

The seriousness with which these plans are being drafted and the quality of the end product are both variable. Some states like Madhya Pradesh, Uttarakhand and
Odisha organised several consultations with different stakeholders. Sikkim took the process very seriously, genuinely trying to usher in climate-resilient
development. In Uttar Pradesh, the process has been a slow one and simply getting all the departments interested in the exercise has been a challenge.

Politicians have been almost uninterested in the making of the SAPCCs, though climate change is already leading to developmental losses in
many of the electoral constituencies of the state legislators. The pulling together of the climate plan has essentially been a
bureaucratic exercise.

In West Bengal, a more structured approach was followed, but there was almost no public interaction though the Central guidelines mandate public consultation as
part of the plan formulation process.

Development is central to all climate plans. The plans build on existing policies and programmes, and, in some instance, even add to them. Yet, most of the
proposed actions are business-as-usual development initiatives, not adaptive or climate-resilient. Thus, for instance, 'sustainable agriculture' is heavily biased
towards biotechnology (including genetic engineering) for raising farm productivity and soil carbon content, and concentrates less on promoting low input farming
practices that would help the predominantly small and marginal farmers increase soil fertility and soil moisture in the wake of climate-induced floods or
droughts. Afforestation activities put more emphasis on carbon sequestration than on protection of forest-based livelihoods for 350-400 million people, primarily
tribal and women.

Politicians have been almost uninterested in the making of the SAPCCs, though climate change is already leading to developmental losses in many of the electoral
constituencies of the state legislators. The pulling together of the climate plan has essentially been a bureaucratic exercise, with inputs from climate
scientists and drafting help from bilateral and multilateral agencies.

Several of the plans propose climate cells within departments or an overall climate authority. At this moment, the state climate action plans still fall short of
being able to usher in a more inclusive and resilient growth. What this implies is that 'development' may just be a red herring five years from now.

Growing literature and empirical studies show that women are more vulnerable than men to climate change impact and have different capacities to adapt to these
changes. The authoritative Fourth Assessment Report (2007) of the Inter-governmental Panel on Climate Change (IPCC) states that "the vulnerability of women in
agricultural economies is affected by their relative insecurity of access and rights over resources and sources of wealth such as agricultural land." Women have
lesser education, resources, opportunities and authority to reap the benefits of development. Climate change is only deepening this divide.

Women suffer first and worst but they can also be part of climate solutions.
PIC CREDIT: Subhrajit Dutta Mallick/WFS

The national and state-level climate plans have largely ignored the gender dimension. A few state plans have integrated gender in the later versions of their
drafts. Women suffer first and worst, but they are also part of climate solutions. Strengthening climate plans with gender-based participation, therefore, must
become part of the electoral manifestos in the run up to the 2014 Parliament elections.

Recent events show that the climate for change is here. Witness the 'aam aadmi wave' in recent electoral politics, and the sudden political reverence for an
anti-corruption measure such as the Lokpal legislation. Take the growing societal engagement with issues such as gay rights and violence against women. The
bottoms-up adoption of the digital economy has also been successfully used for many a transformative development initiative. The time is therefore indeed ripe to
move from the obvious to the substantial . address the drivers of change rather than the consequences of change. Based on the state-level climate action plans,
state governments can become the engines of resilient development and far more accountable to its people.

With 50 per cent reservations for women across all Panchayat institutions, it is time to enable women to hold the reins of decision-making for resilient
development on the ground. After all, climate change adaptation is about local resources and local knowledge. Will the deafening silence of political parties on
climate change and inclusive development persist? Or is India finally going to shine?

Aditi Kapoor21 January 2014

Aditi Kapoor is Director, Alternative Futures, a Delhi-based development and communications group. This article has been published in arrangement with the Women's Feature Service.

India Together offers an excellent forum for people from diverse fields of expertise to present their views, share their experiences and raise questions about where our country and society are headed in the future.

Amitabha Basu

Retired Scientist

National Physical

Laboratory

India Together reader

India Together offers an excellent forum for people from diverse fields of expertise to present their views, share their experiences and raise questions about where our country and society are headed in the future.

I urge all democratic-minded individuals to road, contribute to and publicise the e-newsletters from India Together. All power and success to India Together staff for their excellent and vital contribution to our society!