Chemist1422 wrote:Dash, to be fair, you haven't responded to any of my explanations and are just shading Flake for defending me.

At this point it obvious.Town can see mafia now.You lose. try again next game. ^_^

Flake - Bad Kill, Pushed Chemist awkwardly then calls him Confirms town like ProtoChemist - Bad the entire gameProto - Called Chemist Confirmed Town, Chemist has them as possible scum.

What does "bad kill" mean

How have I been bad the entire game

And with regards to your Proto read, that's solely based on me being mafia, which I'm not.

Flake didn’t kill Town Read.Why were you focused on that exactly?If you haven’t seen yourself this game then your just as bad as Crimson this game.Chemist confirm Proto?Chemist claims his read for Proto means he Mafia.Proto was one that called Chemist locked scum.Chemist defends Proto a Scum Read.Wow Chemist you really ruin the entire mafia this game didn’t you? ^_^

Chemist1422 wrote:Dash, to be fair, you haven't responded to any of my explanations and are just shading Flake for defending me.

At this point it obvious.Town can see mafia now.You lose. try again next game. ^_^

Flake - Bad Kill, Pushed Chemist awkwardly then calls him Confirms town like ProtoChemist - Bad the entire gameProto - Called Chemist Confirmed Town, Chemist has them as possible scum.

What does "bad kill" mean

How have I been bad the entire game

And with regards to your Proto read, that's solely based on me being mafia, which I'm not.

Flake didn’t kill Town Read.Why were you focused on that exactly?If you haven’t seen yourself this game then your just as bad as Crimson this game.Chemist confirm Proto?Chemist claims his read for Proto means he Mafia.Proto was one that called Chemist locked scum.Chemist defends Proto a Scum Read.Wow Chemist you really ruin the entire mafia this game didn’t you? ^_^

Dash2 wrote:No it's literally not. Calling someone scum or dumb is not shade if there's literal evidence backing it up. And don't try to back out of it because I can quote two posts showing how you started trying to call me out on it.

Also your so-called "explanation" is forced as hell

I tried to call you on it because you deserved to be called on it

You never acknowledged my points

Dash2 wrote:

Chemist1422 wrote:

Dash2 wrote:In other words not even a bad person would make that mistake

You clearly underestimate my stupidity then

You're literally making excuses at this point

You're not giving me a window to explain myself with these kinds of posts

I've explained why I did what I did and why it doesn't make me scum and you're dismissing it as an excuse

0verki11 wrote:Sorry about the waitPhone0lx has been killed, he was DoctorEragon1239 has been killed, he was Citizen48 hours glgl.

By the way both of these are shit kill options for scum, so either the Vig was one of them or scum has bad sense of choices

i mean then where did one of the scum kills go, you think someone was attacked & healed?

eragon wouldn't be bad for mafia

phone i do not get at all if mafia killed them

makes sense if sk tried to kill mafia!phone

probs maf killed era and sk killed phone i'm guessing

but yeah both kills were good for my poe so

but maybe that suggests my poe isn't great, idk

discussion here is straight up lamistzero points speculating this without kill credits and with the switches to consider

It's not lamist, it's just me making points from my PoV, is that not acceptable??

And why would I consider switches here, I literally didn't need to at all, first point implies a possibility occurred so switches isn't relevant here, rest of the points are takes regarding kills for which I wouldn't need to mention switches at all

Rickdaily12 wrote:

Flake wrote:

Rickdaily12 wrote:while also pretending to not know that ejj and i are close friends when we openly pair together on threads where i playis actually pissing me off

show me evidence

if you dont know thisyou have zero fucking business meta reading me and speculating what conversations ejj and i shouldnt be havingon this you can straight up piss off

Uh

am I missing something or am i literally being vilified for speculating something that is potentially helpful to the game?

sorry if you're offended by that but i literally don't understand why you would be

I disagree, they could easily be coached to do that, especially if they have a more experienced player in their mafia

It makes them more likely town, but their weird AtE attempt and claim really don't sit right with me

Dash2 wrote:

Flake wrote:

Dash2 wrote:Chemist no town ever acts this way and you know that

If he knew that then why would scum!chemist admit to it

It's literally just WIFOM at this point

The better take is to look at Chemist's demeanour throughout my aggressiveness; do you think that comes from Scum!Chemist? Because I don't

It's literally not even the actual slip I'm talking about, which by the way isn't even a slip to begin with. Your argument is relying on the fact that scum wouldn't admit to a mistake, which is false thinking on your part. Think about how it was brought into the thread and the actual explanation itself. It doesn't make sense at all.

Again, you're not giving me any room to explain myself. You're saying it doesn't make sense, but it has to make sense in some world because that's what happened, and you're not giving me any way to prove it in the world that I am town.

Dash2 wrote:Sigh this is basic logic but I can't believe I have to actually explain this.Spoiler:

Chemist1422 wrote:My metaread on Eragon still stands.

This is the supposed slip, which shouldn't even be a slip knowing this was typed during the night, and Chemist implied he did one final read over it before posting, which brings me to my next point

Chemist1422 wrote:I was actually worried that someone would say I faked it and call me scum for it

This makes no sense from town for 2 reasons

1. If you're actually town why would you intentionally allow yourself to get scumread over a mistake you could have fixed. And no, "scum would have been more careful" is not an excuse, because this legitimately cannot make sense from town perspective.

2. Why would you openly say this as town and not expect some raised eyebrows? Like no this is basic town play 101 to not say anything that could incriminate you. It's hella forced.

Chemist1422 wrote:I literally just copy-pasted what I had typed from when I didn't know Eragon was going to die

This is what us Ace Attorney nerds like to call a contradiction. You literally just said you saw the slip and didn't want to fix it, and now you're saying you just copy and pasted it. No if you really did look over it you would have deleted the Eragon bit after knowing he died.

I'm also gonna close this out with a single question: What kind of town member intentionally tries to slip? There's literally no reason to if you're already town.

1. You misread my intentions then, because I didn't read over it when I posted it2. Because I forgot about it when I had posted it and remembered when Flake mentioned it3. Because if it were to get brought up later, it would be more incriminating so I tried to clear it up now.4. I never said I saw the slip and didn't want to fix it. I said when I typed the post I considered the fact that it would be treated as a slip or fake slip if someone I mentioned were to die, but I didn't think of that when I made the post.5. I didn't intentionally try to slip. I think I've made that clear through my other responses.