>>12906843I am serious, even if spike dog was dumb as a concept, it worked damnit.

He was back in the S1 mode I liked him for, he often provided commentary on the situation that was in line with what I was thinking and I liked that. And in the crystal empire, at lest he got some nice moments.

>mfw MMC takes place in an alternate universe where Rarity was a weather person, Pinkie a farmer etc. but they were all just really bad at their jobs>mfw Twilight is in the wrong universe>mfw Carpenter/Blacksmith Twilight got transported to the normal universe>mfw something similar happened in the normal universe, and Twilight is now amaster Carpenter/Blacksmith

>>12907272>everyoneYou mean GG hyping it up as some kind of world-building exploration type deal with a variety of personality driven characters instead of the slice of life Wander vs Hater it's going to be?

>>12907358>You mean GG hyping it up as some kind of world-building exploration type deal with a variety of personality driven characters instead of the slice of life Wander vs Hater it's going to be?Anon I thought you were better than this

>>12907438I was going to counter with this pic, but you're right, that's awesome cosplay. Practically flawless, as far as I'm concerned. (as opposed to skeletor over here; RD would have quite a bit more muscle mass on her arms)

>>12907498>If I had to put a pin on it? Personally it’s the whole approach: Weird guy travels to weird places, sees weird things, meets weird people. I mean, look at DiveQuest, or Quorum. It’s the sort of thing I like most.

Nigger, you compared it to questing. Admit that you kind of jumped the gun when you saw the intro and the names working on it.

And it's really not a good sign if I hate the main character more than anything.

Skeletor is best character

Now to be fair it's the first episode. I'll give it 3-4 more episodes. I mean let's be honest the MLP pilots weren't that great...they did a pretty good job introducing the characters and the basics of the world so there's that but over all they were just okay.

Maybe it'll be the same here

But seriously fuck that orange guy. Really

Also holy shit it was more predictable than MLP. That's kinda something.

>>12907529I compared it in specific terms, I never said it was like questingI'll admit that it was only a prediction based on what was known at the time, without anything even having airedBut I do think writing that off is premature too, based on one 10-minute episode about a King of the Hill match for a single location

>>12907502I'm not a shareholder or anything, anonIf MLPG decides it doesn't like WOY that's not really my problem; this is a thread for ponies anywayBesides I like plenty of things that are unpopular

>>12908187Weaver did a whole crap of stuff for 4chan but yeah, the only thing that people know that he made those are from his tumblr or when someone tag his stuff in Derpibooru. Otherwise, its just GG here.

>>12908203Yeah, when his hyperspace hyperwars comic was on reddit, the discussion was largely along the lines of "I have no clue where this stuff comes from but I'll be damned if it isn't great" and lots of people having absolutely no idea where he puts his stuff.

>>12908597He made a pretty good (albeit very obvious) point, not that it will get him anywhere. It's also something that he actually commented on the issue, a bigger wimp like Sethisto would just avoid saying anything at all in fear of losing some precious popularity, regardless of whether or not this ends up making JJ more or less popular, point is it's taking a risk.

>>12906958>>12906925Did everyone forge the part where spike grew super fast once he started collecting items? His growth seems to be tied more to that... he only is baby size since he owns a few items while living at twilights house.

>>12909000I'd have a room with a round table in it, with 8-10 chairs, and each chair (except one) would have a life size, plushie of the mane 6 and two others (maybe Trixie and some other pony). I'd come in there occasionally and sit in the empty chair and talk to them about things.

reminder that every second 10 trillion women get raped, that 33 out of 20 men are violent rapists and that every woman in the world gets raped eleven times a day and that the only way to stop it is to whine about a tumblr ask blog and buy t-shirts

>>12909689Well one the books are complete and utter shit and I enjoyed reading Past fucking Sins moreTwo the entire plot is retarded as fuck. Fuck you if you think it's goodThree That look horrible and doesn't fit rarity at allAnd finally fuck you

>>12910412>>12910389Never mind, actually decided to not be a lazy bitch and find it myself. The two changeling-related ones are actually pretty good, the rest, I dunno. Really, Kaz probably shouldn't have done the "let's do this out of spite" pledge but his looks really damn good.

>>12910041No..not really. She reads technical how to books, mostly on magic or social events. See: Look before you Sleep and Running of the Leaves. She didn't even know about the Crystal Empire, Sombra, the Crystal heart, or Discord. She DID know about Nightmare Moon though, but that's supposedly a legend used to "scare fillies straight" so you can assume lots of ponies know about it, even though it might not be common knowledge. Like fairy tales you might've heard that others haven't.

I'd say she didn't know about the existence of a third alicorn (even though she was babysat by her for how many years?) but Cadence's existence itself throws a wrench in so much previously established canon and fanon it's ridiculous.

>>12910043>historical figureA historical figure is defined as a famous person in history. Literally no one besides Luna knew who she was supposed to be. Twilight only knew who he was because he probably wrote over half of the spells she was studying while under Princess Celestia and thus was an idol to her.

Also, Twilight owns every Daring Do book in the series. She like literature over history, not to say she doesn't like history.

>>12910508Okay let's startShe knew about the NMM story. Even tough it was a old mare's tale she made further research. Why? If it was just an old tale to scare fillies why did she did so much research on it. Next is the history of Ponyville. She knew when it was founded. She knew by what kind of ponies it was founded by Earth Ponies.She also knew about Starswirl but I guess you can ignore that.There's also the legend with the love potion.

The Crystal Empire?Even Celestia barely had any info and knowledge about that? AND SHE LIVED WHEN THE CRYSTAL EMPIRE EXISTED.

And from where are you bringing up the fact that she didn't know about a third Alicorn?