The first duo that went head-to-head was the rabbit and alien, with the former receiving enough votes to progress. Second was the raven and pineapple, and the bird was voted to continue in the competition. Last for the night was the poodle versus the bee, and the buzzing insect was voted to be able to keep their mask on.

During his introduction video, the pineapple (Chong) referred to himself as an “OG” and shared a quote, which was a big clue to him being guessed: “Life is short, man. You gotta seize the day before your dreams go up in smoke.”

After he performed his own rendition of Gloria Gaynor‘s “I Will Survive,” the judges deliberated — and McCarthy, 46, first suspected his identity.

“I’m definitely thinking more stoner, like Willie Nelson. Who else is a stoner? Cheech [Marin], or [Tommy] Chong,” said McCarthy. “But Cheech.”

At the end of the show, the alien, pineapple and poodle were in jeopardy — and it was the tropical fruit that was unmasked.

Tommy Chong

When host Nick Cannon asked for the judges’ final answers on who they thought the singer was, McCarthy hit the nail on the head.

“Well it seems like you obviously like to party, the car said ‘Pipe Dreams’ and the iconic movie Up in Smoke, so definitely Cheech. Or Tommy Chong. But I’m going to go with Cheech,” said McCarthy.