Jessie Kowalski of San Antonio lost her chance to re-enter the game, and controversial Texas State University student Aaryn Gries is in danger of being shown the exit door on Thursday's live eviction show.

First, Kowalski and three other evictees were given the opportunity to re-enter the house thanks to a historic “Brother” twist: an obnoxious game of catch, which included steady streams of water sprayed in contestants' faces. Kowalski stumbled, but returned to the jury house, where she'll have a say in who wins the $500,000 on Sept. 18.