Monday, 10 December 2012

Fruits Of Afforestation

Adivasis in southern Madhya Pradesh see salvation from malnutrition in a drive to plant fruit trees (This article first appeared in the Down To Earth magazine dated December 10, 2012)

On December 8 last year, drumbeats sounded from deep inside the
forests of Umberdoh in Betul, Madhya Pradesh. People had assembled there
from far away villages, many having travelled for nearly 12 hours. The
sun gave way to a full moon, the wintry winds began to blow and people
huddled around a fire while songs of freedom from oppression began to
echo. Rapt attention was paid to details and testimonies were presented
of a new process that promised salvation from chronic malnutrition,
while ensuring a robust livelihood.

A year since, and many more meetings later in other villages in
Betul, the idea of planting fruit tree saplings is slowly taking root
among the Korku and Gond adivasis of southern Madhya Pradesh

Two grassroots organisations, Shramik Adivasi Sangathan (SAS) and
Samajwadi Jan Parishad (SJP), have kick started this afforestation
drive. Aimed at addressing the decreasing forest cover in Madhya
Pradesh—the state accounts for more than one-third of the forestland
diverted from the country since 1981—this process has already found
acceptance among villages in Chincholi and Ghodadongri blocks of Betul.

SAS began the campaign for fruit sapling plantation on July 1, 2011,
when the Hari Jiroti festival to welcome the monsoon and celebrate the
sprouting of new crop was being observed in the region. Faldaar paudhe
lagaayenge, bhukhmari mitaayenge (through fruit sapling plantation, we
will eradicate malnutrition) and Purkhon se naata jodenge, jungle-zameen
nahi chodenge (we'll establish links with our ancestors, we won't leave
our land and forests) were the slogans raised on that day.

People
from near and far off villages assembled at the December 8 meeting.
They paid rapt attention to details and testimonies of how planting
fruit trees promised salvation from chronic malnutrition (Credit:
Priyanka Borpujari)

“We requested for 50,000 fruit tree saplings from the district
authorities, but received none. But that did not deter us,” says Anurag
Modi of SAS, who has been working in the region for almost two decades.
Modi claims that so far, 20,000 saplings of fruits like Indian
gooseberry (amla), jamun, mango, guava and custard apple have been
planted in the forests, close to water bodies.

Study in contrast
Giving back the responsibility of maintaining the forest cover to
adivasis, and thereby ensuring their access to what could possibly
provide them with the nutrition they lack, is in stark contrast with the
Green India Mission-2011 of the Union Ministry of Environment and
Forests (MoEF). The mission's objective is increase of forest cover on
10 million hectares of land by year 2020. The total cost of the mission
has been projected at Rs 46,000 crore over 10 years.

The ministry's projects are all heavy on funds. In fact, Rs 871.25
crore has already been allocated by Madhya Pradesh towards compensatory
afforestation, as on June 30, 2011, according a statement of the
minister of state for environment and forests, Jayanthi Natarajan, made
in the Lok Sabha. Natarajan also stated that 176.54 million trees had
been planted on public and forestland in the state in the past three
years. In a separate correspondence between the office of the principal
chief conservator of forests (development), Madhya Pradesh, and the CEO
of ad-hoc Compensatory Afforestation and Fund Management and Planning
Authority (CAMPA) of MoEF, dated March 18, 2010, an annual plan of
operation for the utilisation of the amount of NPV (net present value)
from the afforestation fund was submitted. In that proposal of a
financial requirement of Rs 17236.29 lakh, a significant amount had been
quoted for the conservation of wildlife and protection of forests,
which includes building patrolling and forest chowkis, purchase of
wireless equipment, utility and range-level patrolling vehicles,
firearms and promotion of energy-saving devices.

“Why do we need such a large budget to protect forests with firearms
and fences, when adivasis have been taking care of forests for
generations?” asks Modi. “The government mostly promotes monoculture,
and it wouldn't be wrong to say that trees it plants would be to ensure
commercial gain in future, like teak or eucalyptus,” he adds.

Modi says that the government is wasting its time in trying to
implement such schemes, which end up being huge scams. “Adivasis have
survived on wild fruits for centuries. They understand best how their
survival revolves around forests, and know how to take care of it,” he
says.

During its campaign, which included a foot march to promote the need
to reclaim government wastelands and a large meeting in December, 2011,
SAS put emphasis on the adivasis' symbiotic relationship with fruit
trees in forests. The announcement pamphlet circulated by SAS and SJP
for the meeting urged people to bring symbols of their gods and
goddesses to the venue in order to honour the deities. The pamphlet
further explained how the British rule in India was responsible for
systematically doing away with fruit trees from the forests and
replacing them with teak plants; this practice continued well after
Independence. “The livelihood from mango, jamun, mahua, cashew,
jackfruit, tamarind on just an acre will ensure that the forest
regenerates. The livelihood thus gained will be more than what could be
derived from agriculture on 10 acres of land. Let's clear off the weeds
of lantana to enrich the wastelands collectively,” says the pamphlet.

A conflict brews
During this meeting, workers of SAS, as well as residents of nearby
Chirapatla village, described the place fruit trees have in the adivasi
ethos of living. Some spoke of the need to protect the river by planting
trees; others explained how saplings could be procured from SAS and
SJP. Modi explained how people in Chunajoori village had developed their
own system to keep a tab on the plantation. First, the people cleared
the weeds. They then planted the saplings, dug a well and even developed
a nursery. This is a significant way to protect those species of fruits
that are disappearing. The people of Chunajoori are also maintaining a
register for the attendance of people planting fruit saplings. Roughly
300 man days from the labour of 100 people have been decided by the
village to be dedicated for this process.

Modi says that this process had begun sporadically in few villages, but the forest department officials destroyed the saplings.
“They also demolished the well that was dug up especially for this
plantation. Finally, another set of saplings were burnt down by the JFM
(Joint Forest Management) Committee of another village at the
department’s instigation. But we are reviving this process slowly,” he
adds.

People in the forest department are sceptical. R B Sinha, who until
recently was the Conservator of Forests, Madhya Pradesh, says that
horticulture is not permitted in forestland. “As per the Forest
Conservation Act of 1980, fruit trees cannot be grown over forest land.”
The adivasis find this response ridiculous. “Fruit trees have always
been growing in forests. We won't be planting any videshi (foreign)
fruit trees here,” says an old man.

“About 30,000 children in Betul district are malnourished. Vision
loss is a prominent condition among the children. Feeding them fruits
from the trees you plant is the best way to provide nutrition to your
children, without any additional cost. This is why the threats to keep
away from forests have not deterred them from deciding their own fate.
They do see hope in these fruit trees,” Modi says.

Priyanka Borpujari is an independent journalist, and is the IWMF
(International Women's Media Foundation) Elizabeth Neuffer Fellow for
2012-2013

I just read your article on AlterNet about your return to India and your response to the current furor over rape cases. Perhaps we should take it as a good thing that more attention is being paid. You describe an incident where no one seemed to think it important that you had been publicly molested; I think it would be less likely now that people are more aware. Hopefully, anyway.

From 2009-2014, I worked as an independent journalist, writing about various conflicts across India. You will find much of my work from that period on this blog. I now continue to write political opinion pieces on this blog.