“I
can’t stand it anymore, being lifted up and then smacked down again, just
when we were all trying so hard to experience hope,” a friend tells me.

She was one of several people I know who
were bystanders to Saturday’s shootings in New Orleans.

Last weekend, revelers filled the streets
for one of our city’s most vital cultural traditions, the second-line -- a
roving street celebration put on by New Orleans community institutions
known as Social Aid and Pleasure Clubs. This second-line was the biggest
anyone I spoke to had seen, put on by 30 different Clubs. Many people came
from out of town just for the day, and during the parade thousands were
chanting, “we’re back, we’re back!”

The day of hope and celebration was
shattered when, towards the end of the route, three people were shot in
three separate incidents on Orleans Avenue between Claiborne and Broad, in
the Treme, a Black neighborhood with a long history and culture of
resistance.

Michelle Longino, one of the event's
organizers, was quoted in the Times-Picayune as saying, “It just
breaks my heart that some people on the outskirts could do such a horrible
thing and have it be associated with the beautiful, glorious, peaceful
thing we were putting together,” adding that the event was organized to
“testify to the importance of the social clubs and the importance of
providing affordable housing and decent schools so people can return.”

The violent end to a hopeful day was
devastating. It was horrifying to see a broad community effort shattered
and to see a return of the violence that has marred our city.

On top of our personal sorrow, there is also
a pressure all of us here in New Orleans feel, this awareness that we are
being judged by the media and by politicians in Baton Rouge and
Washington. The question constantly comes up, are we deserving of
rebuilding? I feel certain no other US city would be facing this
questioning, but we have to constantly prove ourselves as being “worthy”.

All of us were immediately aware that those
who do not want the city rebuilt would use this incident as evidence
against us, just as recent news reports have gloated over the “lack of
crime” that has been brought by the mass displacement of our city’s
population.

Last week, the mayor’s Bring Back New
Orleans commission released its recommendations on rebuilding, which are
filled with the expected double talk and half promises regarding what
neighborhoods can be rebuilt, pegged to vague tests and benchmarks.

But most infuriating, featured in all the
coverage of the report, is the estimate given by the commission,
politicians, developers, and media that only half of the city’s population
is expected to come back to New Orleans in the next several years. The
so-called experts advise us to be “realistic”, and accept that the city
has to have a “smaller footprint” because so many people will not be
returning.

Where do the reduced population statistics
come from? The truth is that the “experts” are manipulating the truth for
their own ends. They are creating a situation where half the city is kept
from returning; then saying that we need to reduce our expectations to
this reality they have created.

This week, 90% of Tulane University students
came back to resume classes in uptown New Orleans. The majority did not
have long-term ties to the city, but they returned because Tulane and the
city wanted them back, and worked to get them back. With housing and
encouragement, the majority of New Orleans would be back today. This is a
completely avoidable displacement, happening in slow motion before our
eyes.

It is also paternalistic, with experts
brought out, one after another, to tell us -- especially poor and Black
New Orleanians -- what is best. You can’t come to this neighborhood yet,
it’s not safe for you. You can’t rebuild, we don’t know if your
neighborhood will be viable. You can’t move back to New Orleans -- we
think you’ll be better off somewhere else, where the welfare is better.

For the city’s poor, more hurdles are being
put up. Some residents who have returned are blocking the installation of
FEMA trailers in their neighborhoods. Hotels are planning evictions of New
Orleanians in preparation for Mardi Gras tourists. The city plans to
demolish homes before people can even come back to see them.

It's perhaps a symbol of Republican
dominance and Democratic cowardice that free-marketers have chosen this
overwhelmingly Democratic city as a front line in their war on government
institutions created for the poor. Charity Hospital is forced to remain
closed. Public housing tenants are pressured to remove their belongings.
The public schools remain mostly closed, while the school system becomes
the landscape for social experimentation by right-wing school privatizers.

Within the first two weeks after New Orleans
was flooded, the right wing think tank The Heritage Foundation released
its plans to capitalize on the disaster. Near the top of the list was
promotion of “school choice” and school vouchers. Pre-Katrina, New Orleans
schools were among the most segregated in the nation, with some of the
nations lowest spending going to public schools, which had a wide array of
problems including collapsing infrastructure and so little money for
elective courses that in some schools JROTC, the military recruiting
program for high schools, was a mandatory class.

The proposed changes do nothing to address
these issues, instead they exacerbate the problem, diverting funds from
the poorest schools, and continuing a system with two tiers of schools,
one for those with the privilege, and one for everyone else. As an added
benefit for privatizers, the teachers union -- previously the largest
union in the city -- faces virtual elimination under this scheme, as staff
is laid off and new schools open with mandates to cut salaries and
eliminate health insurance.

Charity Hospitals, Louisiana’s public health
care system, were setup by Governor Huey Long in the ‘30s. The system was
a shining example of state-provided health care, and Louisiana remains the
only US state with a network of hospitals dedicated to free care for the
poor. Even in recent years, Charity boasted world-class care in some units
-- such as trauma care, and the huge New Orleans Charity Hospital, one of
the two oldest hospitals in North America, served thousands of uninsured
patients every week. People from New Orleans, born in the hospital,
proudly refer to themselves as “Charity babies.”

Doctors at Charity claim the hospital is
clean and safe and ready to re-open, but they have been prevented from
doing so -- instead, there are plans to demolish the massive structure.

Public housing residents face some of the
biggest opposition to their return. As Baton Rouge Congressman Richard
Baker gloated shortly after the hurricane hit, “We finally cleaned up
public housing in New Orleans. We couldn't do it, but God did.”

I spoke with Elizabeth Cook, an activist
with New Orleans Housing Emergency Action Team (NO-HEAT) and C3/Hands Off
Iberville, a local group that combines antiwar and global justice activism
with local issues such as public housing. Cook has spoken with a wide
range of tenants at B.W. Cooper Housing Complex, and has worked with
tenants who are fighting hard for their right to return.

Aside from politicians and developers not
wanting them to return, Cooper residents have also faced opposition from
the management of their complex. A B.W. Cooper management representative
told Cook -- “(residents) gotta change their attitude before we let them
back in.”

As I’ve reported previously, Cooper
residents have also experienced widespread robbery, much of it pointing to
a suspicious level of access. Cook, who has spoken with many residents who
have been robbed, reports, “It seems extremely likely that someone with a
key, someone with access is responsible…HANO was in charge, and they
could’ve provided some kind of security. Any indication that it could’ve
been employees, they needed to do something right away. Even now, this is
still happening -- we’re still getting reports, and HANO has done
nothing.”

At the same time, Cook feels there is also
reason for hope -- some units have been re-opened in the Iberville
projects, and more are scheduled for Lafitte and Cooper. “The pressure on
HANO has been successful. It’s something of a success that they are
reopening (some of the units) at all.” Cook feels she’s seen direct
results from publicity, phone calls and letters.

“They are feeling the public pressure --
it’s affecting them,” she says. “At B.W. there was always a great deal of
community involvement, and they are continuing to fight back,” joined by
advocates and activists. “Word of mouth and the residents are pushing this
movement, and we’re following them. We have to counter the propaganda that
the majority of New Orleans doesn’t want them back.”