Same-Sex Marriage vs. Motherhood

The movement demanding legal recognition for same-sex marriage has made a radical and profoundly uncharitable assumption.

It is this: Adult homosexuals need and have a greater right to same-sex marriage than babies have to their mothers.

You cannot simultaneously claim babies have a right to their mothers and two men have a right to marry each other.

Nor, of course, can you simultaneously claim babies have right to their fathers and two women have a right to marry each other.

Notably, advocates of same-sex marriage do not argue that babies have a either a right or a need for a father or a mother. They argue instead that babies neither need nor have a right to either parent.

In the case of Bostic v. Schaeffer, a group of homosexual couples challenged the Virginia state constitutional amendment, approved by 57 percent of the state's voters, that defined marriage as the union of one man and one women and prohibited extending a "legal status" to "unmarried couples" that granted them the "effects of marriage."

The American Psychological Association joined the American Academy of Pediatrics, the American Psychiatric Association, the National Association of Social Workers and the Virginia Psychological Association in filing a brief in this case arguing that same-sex marriage is a wholesome thing.

Crucial to their argument was that children are as well off when raised by same-sex married couples as when they are raised by their fathers and mothers.

"There is no scientific basis for concluding that same-sex couples are any less fit or capable parents than heterosexual couples, or that their children are any less psychologically healthy and well adjusted," the amici told the U.S. Court of Appeals for the Fourth Circuit.

In his opinion in Bostic v. Schaeffer, in which he declared same-sex marriage a constitutionally-protected right, Judge Henry Floyd rejected the argument that Virginia's marriage law safeguarded the interest of children to be raised by a mother and father. Citing the brief submitted by the APA and its allies, Floyd said: "We find the arguments that the opponents [of Virgnia's law] and their amici make on this issue extremely persuasive."

But in arriving at the astounding conclusion that "there is no scientific basis for concluding that same-sex couples are any less fit or capable parents than heterosexual couples," the APA and its allies leapt over the most basic of scientific facts about parenthood. Two people of the same sex cannot create a child. Babies are conceived by mothers and fathers.

Misc.

Mobile

About Townhall.com

Townhall.com is the leading source for conservative news and political commentary and analysis.

Townhall is packed with breaking news headlines, political news, and conservative opinion with Townhall columnists including Ann Coulter, Michelle Malkin, Michael Barone, Star Parker, Dennis Prager, Thomas Sowell, and many more of your favorite conservatives.
Political cartoons full of satire and political humor from editorial cartoonists including Michael Ramirez, Glenn McCoy, and Henry Payne.

Townhall.com also features the latest news videos and pictures on the latest political hot topics including health care reform, the economy, immigration, government tax, President Obama, Sarah Palin, Mitt Romney, Herman Cain, Ron Paul, Iraq, immigration, politics, gay marriage laws, and many more big news issues.