Could Obama Face 2012 Primary Challenge Over Afghanistan?

President Obama's decision to ramp up U.S. troop numbers in Afghanistan by 30,000 while setting a July 2011 goal for draw-down has not been popular. His decisions have especially inflamed the left, with even Congressional Democrats offering
tepid support or outright opposition. Two pundits raise concerns that if the war effort goes poorly, further eroding
support among liberals, Obama could become vulnerable to challenge in the 2012
Democratic primary. It might sound outlandish today, but could it
happen in 2012?

If Obama Fails To WithdrawNate Silver projects an angry liberal base. "If nothing much has changed in Afghanistan and our troops aren't
getting out 20 months hence, we can presumably expect some major
blowback, especially from liberals -- a primary challenge from Obama's
left flank would not be entirely out of the question," he writes. "Politically, this seems very risky."

But If Withdrawal Goes Well The New Yorker's Steve Coll wonders if the July 2011 draw-down date will protect Obama. "Who knows what kind of reëlection campaign President Obama might face
in 2012? If things are truly awful, he might even face a significant
primary challenger. An advantage of marking July 2011 now is that it
provides the President the greatest flexibility of decision-making
about Afghanistan and campaign narrative-writing alike."

Timetable Offers Protection Foreign Policy's Peter Feaver suspects
that Obama's target date of July 2011 is meant to guard against a
primary challenge. "The president talked about timelines, but I do not
think he tied
himself to the mast. He didn't specify a date certain by which time he
would "end" the war; instead, he identified a target for when he would
begin to roll back his surge. That target was far enough into the
future to allow him ample wiggle room yet, conveniently for the 2012
election, early enough to perhaps head of a primary challenge from a
hard-left anti-war candidate."

This article is from the archive of our partner The Wire.

We want to hear what you think about this article. Submit a letter to the editor or write to letters@theatlantic.com.