..because not only are her bottoms lids dusted with white shadow, but the inner rims are also lined with white. And it's hard to tell if she has any white on her top lids at all--if she does, it's pretty close to her lash line.

It's different, but, hey, who can blame her for trying to make her eyes stand out. Just look at her co-stars Ian Somerhalder and Paul Wesley: Have you ever seen two men with more gorgeous peepers? I mean, really.

OK, now you've seen all the evidence. It's time to vote. Is Nina's eye look a Do or a Don't?