Etsy (or any other jeweler) custom ring recommendations???

I’m looking for a really particular type of ring (solitaire 8.5 mm OEC moissy with an eternity band and claw prongs) that i thought would be pretty common but am having a tough time finding. I’m attaching a photo of the overall style I’m going for. I’ve talked to a couple of jewelers on etsy, but so far their recommendations are just a little…off. Either the bands they have are too thin (I think I want about a 1.8 mm band) or the shapes of their existing styles just aren’t quite right.

Has anyone gotten their ring designed by an etsy jeweler (or a jeweler from anywhere else) that you’d recommend? I’d LOVE to see your photos of custom rings!

OR if you have a ring that maches the description above, I’d love to see that, as well And hear where you found it! Thank you! I can’t wait to see your rings and hear your recommendations!!!

I did some reaching out on Etsy before deciding on a local jeweler. From who I can remember contacting:

SamNSue – nonresponsive

Rosado’s Box – extremely rude, although I’m definitely in the minority on this one. Most people have great experiences with her. Also, I didn’t think they were as reasonably priced as others have said.

Masterjeweler (?)- Really kind and lovely but seemed to want to stick with customizing basic designs that he already makes.

Other names/stores that I remember getting thrown around on here are Pompeii3, Studio 1040 (?) and Laurie Sarah

I’ve seen a lot of people reccomend David Klass jewelers for custom work. I can think of several etsy jewelers that do beautiful custom jewelry, but the etsy jewelers that come to mind (like Heart of Water) have more of a track record in unique fluorishes in metalwork moreso than in micro-pave eternity settings.

i have a custom ring from sundarigems on etsy and it is AMAZING – duh, i’m biased but still. my fiancé said working with her was fantastic – she made the custom setting to the dimensions of our chosen diamond, sent CADs to approve the design, sent photos before mailing the ring etc. just went above and beyond and was very well priced.

it’s a beautiful ring and fits perfectly, it is exactly what i wanted, and exactly what he asked for.

also – she works with moissanite, in fact, the original ring from her shop i had based my custom piece on came with a moissanite centre stone.

i will definitely be buying my wedding band through sundarigems as well 🙂

I bought some stacking bands off of there to see how they would look for my e-ring and was really pleased. I like that they are sterling too, so you can wear them as stand ins or RHR or whatever and not worry about getting a green finger!

ETA: To adress your original question, Rosados Box on Etsy is where I bought one of my wedding bands. She’s has a brick and mortar store in Chicago called “Love and Promise Jewelers” and I’ve heard amazing things about her work! She seems very reasonably priced.

Also, my e-ring was done at Schubach’s and they don’t only work with moissy. They work with diamonds too, and everything else in between! Schubachs and David Klass seem like great outlets for custom work.