I'm thinking the way to go is to open the season with Rasmus batting 2nd vs. righties, Melky batting 2nd vs lefties. Put the other in at 6 or 7 (or maybe bench Rasmus vs. really good lefties). I think bottom line you don't know what you're gonna get from either to start the season, but hopefully one of them just takes off.

Reyes

Rasmus

Lawrie

Bautista

Encarnacion

Lind

Melky

JPA

Izturis/Bonifacio

work Gose/Davis into the lineup based on how melky and rasmus start the season.