Who Is The Most Effective Leader Ralph Or Jack

943 words - 4 pages

Dwanasha DecostaMarch 24, 2013LiteratureTopic: Explore Golding's portrayal of Ralph and Jack as leaders bringing out who he think is more effectiveIn the novel "Lord of the Flies" written by "William Goldings" two of the main characters Ralph and Jack are displayed as leaders. Both leaders have different qualities and also different ways in which they take charge over the boys on the island. A leader is someone who has the ability to take charge and control a group. As the novel goes on one of the boys is more effective than the other.One way in which Golding portrays Ralph and Jack as leader is the way the boys handle situations. Ralph is seen as a good leader with his response to the beastie that the littluns have reported seeing. Unlike Jack who completely dismisses the topic, Ralph listens to what they have to say. This shows he cares for the littluns, by trying to comfort them in their time of fear. Ralph has great character. Ralph is stating that there's no beast. While Jack is stating if they see it they'll kill it and do their dance which is ignorant. "…We'll do our, our dance again…" "We'll Kill It …"Another way in which Golding portrays Ralph and Jack as leaders is the way in which the boys rule over their own camp. In the beginning of the novel Ralph knows that to remain civilized the boys needed stability and order. Ralph created rules to achieve order. Ralph being a democrat knows that all boys should be respected even Piggy, so he tried to defend Piggy at times, which shows that Ralph is a fair leader. Ralph also has the sense to keep his focus on getting off the island with the fire which brought them hope. "Make smoke on the top of the mountain" "You hunters you can laugh! But I tell you smoke is more important than the pig ..." As a leader Ralph possesses the quality of responsibility, he creates shelters for the boys to sleep in,Ralph is ensuring that everyone is safe on the island. Ralph shows his courage and determination to be rescued. While Jack who likes things to go his own way is more of a tyrant, he wants the boys to call him chief showing his power, Jack's rule is to listen to him and obey him. "Maurice and Roger put up their hands … Yes chief…" Jack thinks about the entertainment of hunting the pig, which is fun to the boys but won't help them get rescued. Jack who was also persuasive knew what the boys on the island wanted, so he always hunted and had feast to satisfy their hunger. Jack ruled with fear. Unlike...

Find Another Essay On who is the most effective leader ralph or jack

930 words - 4 pages
Who is the Better Leader?
In a group, there are always people who prove to have better leadership skills then others. The strongest of these people can often influence the weaker people into following them. However, the strongest person is not necessarily the best leader as it is proven in William Golding's book, The Lord of the Flies. Although Ralph is the weaker person, he is still able to show a better understanding of people than Jack who

914 words - 4 pages
in time will only leave a priority of hunting, abandoning the chance for rescue. Ralph strongly encourages to Jack that without order there is nothing. After all, Ralph was chosen leader.
Following the important traits of bravery and order, Ralph displays his trait of morality and honesty. Ralph subtly keeps the fairness between all of the boys. Ralph looking for more understanding of Piggy, saw that he was hurt and crushed. He hovered between

749 words - 3 pages
In Lord of the Flies, when a group of young boys are stranded on an island and left their own devices, a leader must be chosen. What separates a good leader is someone who cares for the greater good of the group and their well being rather than just caring about themselves. Some of the boys are better leaders than others and through characterization we see who is most capable of being chief. Ralph is the most qualified leader on the island

2281 words - 9 pages
In William Shakespeare?s Julius Caesar, Brutus and Cassius are very influential characters. Each character makes many mistakes with the assassination plans and the strategies at Philippi. Each man has his reasons for their mistakes, if it is either their idealism, being uncompassionate or not, fully thinking for their actions. Brutus and Cassius are very contrasting people; one man is better suited to be a leader of a battle and an Empire, than

2380 words - 10 pages
. Having an extreme punishment like physical castration will help stop any other offenses from occurring. While giving the offender both a clean slate to work with and a minimized risk of reoffending, physical castration is the most effective punishment over all others and it gives the most peace of mind to victims while being the most cost efficient.
With physical castration, the offender would be able to get a clean slate and be able to integrate

838 words - 4 pages
The word ‘suicide’ is the combination of ‘sui’, which means ‘self’, and ‘caedo’, which means ‘killing’. ) While suicide can be defined differently according to different perspectives, general definition will be the ‘willful behaviors to kill or to harm oneself’ or ‘abandoning oneself and chipping off from belonged society’. Also, according to World Health Organization, WHO, suicide is ‘the act of deliberately killing oneself, understanding the

927 words - 4 pages
If I were to choose one person in my life that had the most influence or impact on who I am today, I would say it was my dad. Ruth E. Renkel once said, “Sometimes the poorest man leaves his children the richest inheritance.” That is evident in the woman I have become from the little girl that my dad raised. With his patient teaching manner and “You can do it!” mentality, my dad is the person who has most inspired me. He was my greatest

622 words - 2 pages
become the richest country. Elizabeth wanted to place more burden on her subjects through new taxes fortunately it was not accepted. Consequently, Elizabeth decided to set up the joint-stock company, which were companies that willing subjects invested in either to their profit or loss. However, through this way the government meaning Elizabeth gained more money. Elizabeth I would find anyway in which she could become richer and be the queen of the richest nation, which would then of course increase her power. In view of how she handled religion, succession, Spain, and finances, Elizabeth I was an authoritarian leader.

927 words - 4 pages
William Golding's Lord of the Flies is a novel about a group of boys who are lost on a deserted island and must do what they can to survive. At the beginning of the novel, two of the boys, Ralph and Jack, become leaders. These differences will form the main conflict in the story. The differences will cause them to hate each other and the anger that results is a recurring part of the plot throughout the novel. These two boys can be compared by

566 words - 2 pages
near the edge of the mountain. During the daytime, everyone put paint on his or her face and they went out hunting for pigs. At night they built a fire and cooked the pig and afterward they dance around the fire. Jack wanted total control so he made all the kids joined his tribe. He got rid of Piggy so that Ralph was alone. Then he made all the kids turned against Ralph by having a search to hunt him down. Ralph was once the original leader, but

753 words - 4 pages
After leaving the island, the adventure truly began for Jack, Roger and Ralph. These three characters never veered off path of their childhood personalities, becoming military leaders, McDonald’s employees, and The Speaker of Parliament. Jack, after graduating high school, joined the British military and became a Naval Commander. Roger, never leaving his sadistic state of mind, never equated too much working the graveyard shift at his local

Similar Essays

1245 words - 5 pages
Wilson during World War 1, who gave a famous speech, known as the Fourteen Points Speech, to approach a peaceful treaty between the Central Powers and the Allies. Jack, on the other hand, is like the leader of the German Army that increased its efforts to conquer Europe as a reaction to Woodrow Wilson’s speech. Jack’s behavior is presented most noticeably following Ralph’s peace-making efforts. “ ’I’m chief!’ Viciously, with full intention, he

962 words - 4 pages
What Makes Jack Welch an Effective Leader?
---ideas from the article “Will Legacy Live On?”
Before I talk about what makes Jack an effective leader, I want to explain briefly why I chose him as my study subject.
Why do I like him?
Jack Welch created a new model for business leaders everywhere. His genius leadership and management techniques are an example to anyone aspiring to a successful career. Why is he so famous?
He became

631 words - 3 pages
create outstanding results. Knowledge and technical skills are basic prerequisites for their success; most importantly, Welch and Goizueta empowered with behavioral and motivational competencies as critical differentiators.Why an effective leader?After all, effective leadership is one of the most elusive keys to organizational success and forming distinctiveness. The article details these findings and offers two vivid examples effective and high

3216 words - 13 pages
Essay - What are the three most difficult challenges that face leader-managers, and how do effective leader-managers meet those three challenges?In the beginning there was the word: leader-managers. I will begin this essay by briefly differentiate between a leader and a manager. A manager has subordinates, meaning he has power over the people under him, while a leader has followers, people who are willing to follow and not obliged to. Huband