In Pictures: Most Overrated Players In Fantasy Baseball

3. Justin Morneau, 1B, Minnesota Twins

Average draft position: 21

Average expert pick: 71

Morneau is a terrific player by all accounts, but he’s not good enough to justify his lofty average draft position. The slugger is getting drafted around pick 21–ahead of fellow first basemen Prince Fielder and Adrian Gonzalez, to name a few. Don’t buy the hype. “Even if he returns to his 2006 MVP level, he doesn’t hit enough home runs or score enough runs to be considered an elite option at first base,” says Swanay.