Wesley Methodist Church (Current)

As the result of the efforts of so many, in October of 1960 a formal ground breaking service for the new Wesley Methodist Church was held on the corner of Florida and Georgia. This was an exciting
time for the five hundred member church. Rev. Lee D. Smith the district Superintendent of the Watertown district was present as well as Rev. Earl Allen (31-38), Douglas Anderson (38-46), Rev Stahmer
( 54-60) and the new pastor at that time Rev. Allen McCaul. After the worship service at the old sanctuary on 10th and Nebraska a car caravan went to the ground breaking ceremony. On Easter day April
2, 1961 the newly built Wesley Methodist Church held its first worship service! Bishop Ralph Alton officiated at the consecration ceremony along with Rev. McCaul.

As was stated in the Wesley Church publication “A Charge to Keep”:

“Today we stand upon a summit from which we look backward with gratitude to the past and forward with high hopes to the future.

In humility we recognize that many who have gone before us have made this day possible through the devotion to the cause of Christ and this church. Each of us, in retrospect, recalls someone whose
rich and living faith has been a bright inspiration to us as we found our way into the life of the church. Beloved among these was the Rev. J.P. Koeller who for over forty years poured into the
church he loved his rare vitality and fervor. To him we dedicate our fellowship hall to be known as Koeller Memorial Hall. His memory bridges the past and future, for this sight were firmly set upon
accomplishment which we celebrate today.”

With the congregation now residing in their new facility, life at Wesley Methodist Church was getting use to the new surroundings. Finally, Wesley Methodist Church had room to grow and expand its
ministries. Between 1960-1967 these was a succession of pastor that served the faith community. Allen McCaul served from 1960-62, Rev. Ray Heilborn 1962-64, and Rev. John Thompson (1964-67). In June
of 1967 Rev. James Vahey was appointed to the church, which brought needed pastoral stability to the Wesley congregation. In 1968, the United Methodist Church was established with the union of the
Methodist Church and the Evangelical United Brethren. It was then that our names officially became Wesley United Methodist Church.

In 1979 Walt Wagner was appointed to Wesley UMC and served until 1983. In June of 1983 Bruce Fenner served as the new pastor and it was under Fenner’s leadership that the groundwork for the
construction of the sanctuary (Phase 2) came to fruition. And under Rev. David Steffenson (1988-92) and the hard work of lay people like Adolph Binder, the dream of a new house of worship finally
became a reality!

This dream for a new sanctuary began on that day when Tenth Street Methodist decided to move to the corner of Florida and Georgia Street. The decision was made at the time to build the education
wing and add the sanctuary soon thereafter. The anticipated short period of time to start the construction on the sanctuary was put off. Unfortunately it was for 30 years. However, during this period
of time, a building fund was established and grew with the support of loyal hopefuls until finally a decision was made to start planning for construction of the long dreamed house of worship.

Several designs for a building were considered and scrutinized by an established building committee until in January of 1990 the congregation of Wesley United Methodist church voted to go ahead
with the plans for our new sanctuary. The official ground breaking was held May 5, 1990 and construction started in mid-July. The period of construction proceeded with very few problems and this
congregation had the thrill of worshipping in their beautiful new sanctuary on February 17, 1991. The sanctuary was consecrated on April 28, 1991.

After the construction of the new sanctuary Norman Bude was appointed as the new pastor to Wesley where he led Wesley through a period of paying off the sanctuary’s mortgage. In 1998 Rev Mark S.
Klaisner was appointed to serve the Wesley faith community. It was just at his arrival that the church celebrated the paying off the sanctuary debt.

Wesley United Methodist Church continues to be a light to the Oshkosh community. For 150 years generation after generation has enriched and empowered the ministry of this congregation. We the
people of Wesley United Methodist Church look forward to embracing our next 150 years of service to Christ! The reality is that there is much yet to be done, and in the spirit of Christ, and genuine
love for each other which His love teaches, we will build a future for Wesley United Methodist Church which will always uphold our proud heritage.