And this isn’t the first time we’ve seen these two blood-hungry blokes come to blows. Over the summer, Entertainment Weekly‘s Sexiest Beast tournament came down to Rob and Ian, with Ian narrowly clinching the coveted top spot. Will he win our battle, as well? It’s up to you, so start voting!

VOTING IS NOW CLOSED! Thanks for contributing — We’ll reveal the winner Friday, Nov. 25, at noon. We need to give them both some time to recover after their Thanksgiving feasts.