I tried to stay in the flavor of how he would be at the time he was made. so his abilities are very basic. They are both kinda different from normal walkers. I also used everything on the original card to help think of the abilites. I totally understand that the original card had nothing to do with drawing but figured it was a balanced ability that could be good.

-5: Choose a number less than the number of nontoken artifacts you control. Target player gets an emblem with 'Whenever you cast a spell with converted mana cost X, counter that spell,' where X is the chosen number.

5

Supposed to reflect how memnarch turned argentum into mirrodin, he mirrodin-izes your board as you use him. It's cool to think of an alternate story arch where memnarch succeeds in obtaining a spark, setting up an epic duel between him and Karn. We all know karn would just -3 him unless they joined forces somehow.

Last edited by wolfman2nast on Sun Apr 09, 2017 4:29 am; edited 3 times in total

+2 Target player discards a card at random, if it's a creature card exile it instead.
-1 Return target creature card exiled with Gwendlyn Di Corci to the battlefield under your control, it gains haste.
-8 Exile all creature cards from target player's library. You may return one of them to the battlefield under your control each time a creature you control dies.

I love the good old days... I choose Baron Sengir... The only card in MTG history that distributed +2/+2 counters.

Baron Sengir, Homelander
1BBB -- [3 Loyalty]
[+1]: Put a +2/+2 or a -2/-2 counter on target creature. That creature becomes a Vampire in addition to its other creature types.
[+2]: Until the beginning of your next turn, if a Vampire would die, regenerate that creature, then untap it.
[-X]: Create X 1/1 black Vampire creature tokens with Lifelink.
[-7]: If Baron Sengir, Homelander is on the battlefield or in your graveyard, exile it, then return it to the battlefield transformed.
/////////
Baron Sengir, The Final Feast
Legendary Creature - Vampire
Flying, Indestructible, Lifelink, Protection from White and from Vampires
At the beginning of your end step, put a +2/+2 counter on each Vampire on the battlefield and a -2/-2 counter on each non-Vampire on the battlefield.
Pay 5 life: Baron Sengir deals 5 damage to target Planeswalker. If that Planeswalker was White, you gain 5 life.
5/5

Ertai, Wizard Ascendant
2U
Planeswalker - Ertai
+0: Target player reveals the top card of their library. If that card is an instant, you may cast it without paying its mana cost.
+1: Until the beginning of your next turn, whenever an opponent casts a spell, you may remove 2 Loyalty counters from Ertai. If you do, counter that spell.
+2: Search your library for a blue wizard card, put that card into your hand, then shuffle your library.
-7: Create seven 1/1 Blue Wizard creature tokens with "Sacrifice this creature: Counter target non-Wizard spell."
[2]

Thalia, Hate Realized
WWR
If you control a creature with Thalia in its name, Thalia, Hate Realized enters the battlefield with an additional Loyalty counter.
(+1) Up to one target creature gains haste and double strike until end of turn.
(-1) Target opponent can't cast non-creature spells during their next turn.
(-2) Nonbasic lands don't untap during target opponent's next untap step.
(-6) You get an emblem with "Creatures you control gain First Strike, Vigilance, and "Tap this creature: Tap target nonbasic land.""
{2 loyalty}

Emrakul, as Planes Unravel
3<><><>
[+1]: Reveal cards from the top of your library until you reveal two colorless cards. Choose one of the revealed cards, put it into your hand, then put the rest on the bottom of your library in any order.
[+2]: Up to one target colorless creature gains Annihilator 1 until end of turn.
[-3]: Each opponent sacrifices two colored permanents. Add <><> to your mana pool.
[-13]: You control target opponent's next two turns.
[[5]]

Rofellos and Eladamri
GG
At the beginning of your end step, if an Elf creature entered the battlefield this turn, put a loyalty counter on Rofellos and Eladamri.
[0]: Flip a coin. If you win the flip, untap up to one target forest. If you lose the flip, untap up to one target Elf.
[0]: Flip a coin. If you win the flip, add GG to your mana pool. If you lose the flip, you gain two life.
[-5]: Flip a coin. If you win the flip, lands you control become 3/3 green Dryad creatures with trample and forestwalk. If you lose the flip, search your library for up to five Elf creatures with different names, put them onto the battlefield, then shuffle your library.

2

Nerfed the ultimate to prevent getting 3 shaman of the pack for insta win. Shouldnt have an instawin on a 2 mana planeswalker right

Your card was really flavorful, touching on his abilities, and even name. My favorite part of the card was his ult, very old school feeling.

8/10

Wolfman2nast:

Memnarch, awesome theme overall, and flavor, but sadly a bit too overpowered. Would of gotten a better score if he started with even 1 less loyallty, or his ult costed at least 1 more.

7/10

Lord_Cuddles:

Her first ability seems a little too strong, and her second ability is a little random, but I see where you were going with it. Overall really cool, with a super flavorful ultimate.

7/10

Thelemys:

Sadly, her ultimate, and her -2 are totally out there, and her +2 is basically just her ability. Liked your loyalty starting and costs though very balanced for her cost.

3/10

the_hetero:

Super, super flavorful. However, I think he's a bit overpowered, on both sides. and his planeswalker side just feels too busy. Love him turning into a creature cool idea.

7/10

Alysiaa:

Ult is a little too strong, would of been better if it was a cursecatcher effect. The +0 is a really cool ability. The only other part I would change is the +1 to make it not a may ability to remove the counters.

6/10

vagingredien:

Sorry but the first part of the card kind of puts a bad taste in my moth from the beginning since thalia is a legendary creature. It would of been awesome if it was like if you control 2 soldiers or something. For the abilities, you just tried to do too much, it would of been better if you focused on one of the thalia cards rather than both of them.

3/10

epidemiq:

uuuggghhhh. I honestly thought to myself this was gonna be the winner until I read how busted the -3 was. This took off a point or two, the ult is cool, but I think making it cost less and only control one turn would of been better. Otherwise, awesome card.

8/10

Winner: JacobMatthew:

This one is awesome, I love every aspect of the card, I just think this could of been done better with out the flipping a coin. Otherwise every other part of this card is awesome.

All content on this page may not be reproduced without consent of Magic-League Directors.
Magic the Gathering is TM and copyright Wizards of the Coast, Inc, a subsidiary of Hasbro, Inc. All rights reserved.