Classic

The competition for this category was fierce. HäagenDazs won us over with its richness, simple ingredients, and the one-two punch of vanilla extract and vanilla bean. It’s a natural with apple pie. ($4.49 for 14 oz.)

Vegan

Organic coconut milk is the first ingredient, but NadaMoo! won’t hit you like a tropical tidal wave. This vegan pick is a creamy blank canvas, ideal for topping a tart pie like cranberry. ($5.99 for 1 pt.)