You are here

Chinese Loan To Rebuild Nuku‘alofa Illegal: Committee

Submitted by admin on Mon, 09/03/2012 - 00:00

Some projects funded didn’t meet requirements of loan

By Pesi Fonua

NUKUALOFA, Tonga (Matangi Tonga, Sept. 2, 2012) – A Parliamentary Select Committee that investigated the rebuilding of the Nuku'alofa CBD claims that a $119 million loan to Tonga from the Exim Bank of China was illegal, in a report released on Friday August 31.

The Committee claimed that the loan failed to meet three legal requirements, which are stipulated under Tonga's Public Finance Management Act 2002.

The report of the Select Committee that was tabled into the House on August 28 had been read in Legislature, but has yet to be debated in the Whole House Committee.

The report also claimed that about 58 percent of the $119 million loan was illegally spent and was indifferent to the initial loan agreement that the Tonga parliament agreed to, which was for the reconstruction of buildings that were burnt in the 2006 riots. Among projects the report claimed were illegally funded with the Chinese loan were the $31.9 million Vuna Wharf Project and the $13.7 million Royal Palace Extension Project.

Meanwhile, none of the owners of the five properties that were built with the loan money from China had signed a loan agreement with government of Tonga, according to the report.

Among the recommendations in the report now before parliament, is for government to urgently carry out a structural survey of the multi-storey properties that were built, to ensure that they can withstand an earthquake, and that they match the value of the loan.

Export credit

Copies of the report were distributed to the Tongan media on August 31, by the Chairman of the Parliamentary Select Committee, Lord Fakafanua, and two members of the committee, 'Akilisi Pohiva and Dr Sitiveni Halapua.

Other members of the committee have included the former Speaker of the House, Lord Lasike; the former Deputy Speaker, who is now the Minister of Health, Lord Tu'i'afitu, the government's auditor general, Pohiva Tui'onetoa, and a lawyer, Posesi Bloomfield.

The report stated that the China loan was proposed to the Legislative Assembly by the Minister of Finance in June 2007, and approved by parliament on 2 July 2007 without any supporting documentation, other than a brief covering letter from the Minister of Finance. The letter mentioned that the loan money would be used to rebuild premises that were burnt during the 16 November 2006 riot, and that the loan money would be on-lent by the government to those rebuilding, and for those recipients to repay the loans.

At the time, the then Minister of Finance, Sosiua 'Utoikamanu further elaborated to the House that, "the loan is known as 'Export Credit' – the way the Export Credit works is that the Bank pays a contractor to come and construct the buildings. None of the money is given to the government. The government picks the work that needs to be done and then informs them."

Public Finance

The Select Committee now submitted that the loan was illegal because it failed to meet three legal requirements, which were stipulated under the Public Finance Management Act 2002:

Hand-over ceremony

Shortly before the report of the Select Committee was presented to parliament, the completion of the $119 million project was marked with a hand-over ceremony on August 14, attended by HM Queen Nanasipau'u, the Chinese Ambassador Tonga HE Mr Wang Donghua, the Prime Minister, Lord Tu'ivakano and guests.

The report made four recommendations:

Despite these strong recommendations, when the Select Committee was asked what they thought should be done, Dr Sitiveni Halapua responded "we should learn from all the wrong doings that took place."

This week the House may respond to its Select Committee's recommendations.

Investigation

The parliamentary Select Committee was the third attempt by the Prime Minister Lord Tu'ivakano and his government, since it came into office in December 2010, to investigate and report back to government how the former government of Lord Feleti Sevele and the Nuku'alofa Development Corporation (NDC) had spent the loan that the then Minister of Finance, Hon. Sosiua 'Utoikamanu had signed with the Export-Import (Exim) Bank of China on November 19, 2007.

The first group that was authorized by the Prime Minister on April 29, 2011 to investigate the NDC included Dr Teena Brown Pulu of AUT University New Zealand; Melino Maka of the Pasefika Solution, New Zealand, and 'Ahongalu Fusimalohi of the Prime Minister's Office. The Prime Minister received the report of this group on 10 June 2011and then on 15 June 2011 cancelled the letter of engagement because he said that their report "falls quite outside the scope of the assignment."

On 26 July 2011 approved the establishment of a Parliamentary Special Committee, led by 'Akilisi Pohiva and Dr Sitiveni Halapua to carry out the task that the committee of Dr Teena Brown Pulu, Melino Maka and 'Ahongalu Fusimalohi was supposed to have been doing.

In December 2011 the Special Committee proposed for parliament to turn the Special Committee into a Royal Commission, so that they could have the legal authority to demand the information that they needed. Parliament instead established a Select Committee with the inclusion of the then Speaker, Lord Lasike and the Deputy Speaker, Lord Tu'i'afitu as members.

Pacific Islands Report is a nonprofit news publication of the Pacific Islands Development Program at the East-West Center in Honolulu, Hawai‘i. Offered as a free service to readers, PIR provides an edited digest of news, commentary and analysis from across the Pacific Islands region, Monday - Friday.