This article was first published in MOTOR magazine's March 2005 issue.

ClubSports have traditionally done well, R8s have done even better and it’s good to see HSV hasn’t forgotten about the original design brief for the ClubSport model. This time, though, it really only scraped into the final six, filling the last space (on raw numbers) and edging out a couple of other worthy contenders.

Throw the judges’ verdicts into the mix, however, and the big Clubbie stepped up a rung to claim fifth spot. And that’s the thing with PCOTY; while bald numbers tell part of the story, there’s always that human element, influenced in this case by the fact that cars like the R8 get the wrinkles out.

To be honest, the last couple of Clubbies have impressed us with their together feel and the fact that they handle pretty sharply for such a big heavy car. This time around the Gen IV mill raises the bar at least another notch or two.

On the track there’s perhaps less difference between Gens III and IV than you might imagine, although there’s no doubt you’re fighting with a bigger stick nowadays. The thing is, because you’re keeping the powerplant revving hard all the time on a racetrack, the Gen III never really fell out of its powerband.

Nope, the big advantage of the Gen IV is most readily seen on the road where the new engine needs none of the wind up the earlier donk required. Similarly, it can be run down to low revs and still yodel when you open her back up.

Which is not to say there’s nothing to be gained by dragging the kind-of-clumsy shifter back to second and getting up it big time, but if you’re feeling lazy then the twist of the new mill is going to really float your boat.

The fact the previous VY model Clubbie and the new VZ are very closely related means they feel otherwise the same. Throw in the fact the all-new VE shell isn’t far away, and you can see why HSV more or less left well enough alone.

But don’t go thinking the VZ feels old fashioned because the basic chassis can still cut it, even if the rear end now has its work cut out getting the torque to the road. Bitches are few and far between, but it remains a shame the R8’s previous excellent front pews have been replaced by chairs with much less side support.

Yes, they’re easier to get in and out of, but they are no longer the best in the biz. Pity.

Slow Tracked

Whither the ClubSport? Off the boil, pace-wise, or is there a deliberate corporate strategy of banging harder in a straight line while feeling nicer mid-corner? At their fastest, the Commodore-based cars leaned heavily on their outside front tyres, squatted notably on the tail and gave superb power down.

But their tyre wear was, um, considerable. This Clubbie isn’t the fastest we’ve ever had at Winton – hell, even the Monaro CV8 of 2003 was quicker – and we reckon we know why. The all-time HSV PCOTY lap record was 2002’s GTS Coupe (1:42.78), with the 2003 GTS posting 1:43.44.

The ClubSport R8 of 2004 ran 1:43.50 and even said Munro ran 1:43.69. When HSV went from Bridgestone S02s to the harder S03s, the cars lost lap speed. They’ve lost more again with the switch to even harder Pirellis. About two seconds a lap, we reckon.