KIRKUS REVIEW

A fishing version of the classic
song “There Was an Old Lady Who Swallowed a Fly” has readers wondering,
“Perhaps she’ll sink.”

Beginning with a skink, the plump
old white woman with the red cheeks and bluish-gray hair, tiny red hat perched
on her round head, proceeds to eat a worm, a bobber, some fishing line, a
fishing pole, a pail, a net, an oar, and a boat. This last makes her float in
fact, though it doesn’t allow her to avoid the fate hinted at in the repetitive
phrasing: one last snack does her in. Aside from the final page and big reveal,
the list of items is repeated on each new spread, allowing for audience
participation, though the rhythm and rhyme sometimes falter: “There was an old
lady who gobbled a bobber. / That bobbled and wobbled and caused her to
slobber.” From the visible linework, Bermejo’s cartoon illustrations appear to
be colored pencil. Starting with spare pictures on white backgrounds, the
artwork gradually becomes more detailed as the story moves closer to the dockside
ending. While she does get a bit red in the face, looks like she might throw
up, and sweats a bit, the old woman never otherwise visibly changes as a result
of the items she eats, making this version a bit less gruesome than others. Children
familiar with sport fishing will wonder how the skink enters the picture; all
the other items she swallows are related to fishing and boating, but the skink
appears to have been chosen just because it sounds funny.

This fisherman’s adaptation doesn’t
add much to the original. (Picture book. 3-6)

Be the first to discover new talent!
Each week, our editors select the one author and one book they believe to be most worthy of your attention and highlight them in our Pro Connect email alert.
Sign up here to receive your FREE alerts.